datamatters24/research-document-archive huggingface dataset:
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R002000960003-2
13 Apri 1
1987
DT
S
MEMORANDUM FOR s
OPS
SUB JEOT s
I.JT I L I TV ASSESSMENT
" p "
OBSERVATIONS::
Utilit y Assessment
"P"
in
its present configuration,
appears
to
be marginally successful
.
Ihe binary parameters
of
the time window appear sufficiently
succinct
to ensure
a normal
rate
of
success,
'•f
1'
cjs’fc
label,
described as
"the
item
of
special
interest"
or
1 h e
i n t e
.1.
J.
:i. g e n c e
q u e ist i on "
,
s eem <3
t o
I ao k
s p ec i f i c i t y
a ri d
fails
to adequately narrow the focus
of
attention
towards the
target
„
The remot f viewers are not particularly enthused about Utility
Assessment
"I-"
as
a viewing
project.
RECOMMENDAT I ONS
::
Mt::«.i.iitain
the same time window,
ie,
remote view
(pred i ct i veil, y
)
on
Ihursday
to obtain results published
on
Monday,,
Mai
l ' ijw the target
label
from
all
data published
on
the front
page
to narrative descriptions and sketches
of
photographs with
captions appearing
on
the front
page
of
the
target,,
Formally retask
remote viewers
(without
explanation,
comments
or
comparison
with previous
levy against
the
target).,
For
ex amp
J. e,
"Utilising
all
your remote viewing skills acquired
to
date,
remote view the tasking outlined
in
the
sealed envelope
and
submit
the results
of
your effort
by COB
of
the Thursday work
d ct y „
77 Ma:i ntai n
a data base for comparison purposes between previous
e f } or t
an d
c u r r e n t
e f
: f or t
„
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R002000960003-2
ri Saenn JESELIDOSRDSEROE Ty inl 14 i t ! { ne: ' i a ‘ } 14 | cal HSE aann aan8 —t—-i- | i t : f : 7 i Cooper coo ee meen Le eee aia ee I, CEOCCere PERE Re Eee Gk ee i Py A SCOT eee PREECE EEE EEC Oe eee ee Coe sesusuueseseseeseuees aaeneR SEE Oe ioe yt Pett ToT Be RESUS RRR REE ede Pe CoC ee reer try rept re Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002000960003-2 i PaO er iz ‘a ey CTCELITTT LL LL a Se et TTT eta Pa Sar : i me preety a PT A COEPTECL ee prt i it | PA ee nae ee 2 Dee et Cale ee | Pitt retary te CTT eet TOT PEE ee CE ete 4 per eye yf || bee Sa REECE eee eB PORTE OO SOE CoLLUL IT eet rot TT rho a Pry rT F : TTT TCL CT SEEEECTCEEEI LCE Ec ; : a ne A OOO OO Sie ad ER oe Preity rye pr Bae PTET Tes 1 _ ro ino 4 eRe rT Trott yt rapa: aC 2e _— ai recy i ; ! Trp ! o+| Mit heen Eee er te teeta ce ey Ean NPS GN um i ae eS eae, Tyr TT Trey ty ae ! a A OO | oem | Prt rer ieee iq@ an ee ee ee BERSeE Rees \ i rrr yy ey rt CCT tS pe rt t ft TTS. : | | rity TTT rrr it PY i] am a ee ee POET ey Py TT aa re YT ae Eaaa _ “TET te be mt (ert Es, * Wan sa HLOL AA WIN! LOL Di X& OL WOH Ids
Approved F, bere ye 8/08 DEP Gare ) f Cp 67 E LEW DO3 27.26 2 — 30 a _ F O// Ce G9 A> / | _ — &f JV AB SF 7 _L - wa JP. On, “3 £3 “y JO Lf  e9 (oy 7 Gg «2 #6 BE, pproved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002000960004-1
oved 12 S CL f —\N od Ole O.2/ o7 pot ior ot pil oot! f16/ 477 OH Ot I. (f/ jolt / elease 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002000960004-1 “0 ) Tig i//
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R002000960004-1
J
//*
StS J
•2 /
//
/^/
Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002000970001-3 PROJECT "PF" PROCEDURES A. Monday (or first day of work week): 1. Post SRV task. * 2. Get sources’ initials. B. Thursday (or day before last day of work week): 1. Reports due in from sources. 2. Extrapolate relevant summary statements from reports. C. Friday (or last day of work week): 1. Summary statements due to operations for record. 2. Place all session results in "P” file. D. Following Monday (or first day of work week): 1. Record "target data” in record book. 2. Check for matches between source data and target data. 3. If a source is successful, provide “feedback” as follows: a. Tell source that he was specifically directed to report on ‘ b. Do not tell source the overall nature of Project *"P” or show him what is being used as "target data.” 4. See A., above. %NOTE: For "target data” date use the following Monday or first day of work week. Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002000970001-3
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R002000970001-3
PROJECT
"P” PROCEDURES
A.
Monday
(or first day of work
week):
1.
Post SRV task.*
2.
Get sources'
initials.
B.
Thursday
(or day before
last day of work
week):
1.
Reports due
in from sources.
2.
Extrapolate relevant summary statements from reports.
C.
Friday
(or
last day of
work
week)
1.
Summary statements
due
to operations
for
record.
2.
Place
all
session results
in
"P”
file.
D.
Following Monday
(or first day of work
week):
1.
Record
"target data”
in record
book.
2.
Check
for matches between source data and target
data.
3.
If
a source
is successful,
provide
"feedback”
as
follows
a.
Tell
source
that he
was specifically directed to
report on
.
b.
Do not
tell
source
the overall
nature of Project
”P”
or show him what
is being used
as
"target data.”
4.
See
A.
,
above.
*N0TE:
For
"target data” date
use
the following Monday or first
day of work week.
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R002000970001-3
Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002001070001-1 Ro) OCT tf —~¢ — (i ALKA PASE, Te Pescesbe LRecee Kacure sup OR VEVT INVS. ( Ne QVE (NW PITA Was Kw fee OF WINAT TARLE7? Wevep pe) (2) PATA FRoWPEP? TS of oSlicee PORE Firs? weee oF DEC, 7666; j?Ro JECT COPE WO RP & LS Soc /ATEV with LAC (TF was PRoVECT SG1A (3) PAY TeouleeD JB Sitwee Sh E4ACRIOPTEO COORPIVATES = le7U00f 3 ( OO8S- Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002001070001-1
Approved ror Release 2000/00/00 r<?tAiRDP96-00789R002301 750001 -3
SC
3 /
g
G-r-> r*?.
G
,
s
<=£-
f a c~
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R002301 750001 -3
Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002001070001-1 Nore, Fie TEAM TE CODE WROD CHANCED Code ued —TseLe MAY Nave Witroor IN FOPAIIV GE — ywRLUEuCeEp ResvctS, PT Uri 2-2 WAS ot POCTE SG1A MAD UO RECATIOMHP wo actuac EVEKT PE SG1A Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002001070001-1
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R002001 070001-1
'rkoT<>c'r
-z.
!j
^V^Atc
£/
^C/Ac
f^AC( L/OY
at
TJ€l>(
//V(js
:
C ^
(P /t/<r
p fA
i^AJ
Au/fiF-i"
£) (c-
iajHa>
Tfy-jL/fey
i^ouc^
?<?.')
W'
1 A
f&o/sPf'P 75
of?
o'C'C/ff^
PoKfuK
Ft
r^> 7
p^c
j
:
*>
/?*0
c f
CcjPPUJO &
p>
<<lS>So<z/A TOP
co/'t~i4
Fa c/ l it y
i^a 9
iT'ctct'
SG1A
~
—
EA^jlb—I^z/aclo
zgz
Ji<£uj pr 5
i
cf?pr&
coowi/v ft ro
/* ?cw/ 3- ^
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R002001 070001-1
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
:: CIA-RDP96-00789R002001 070001-1
Here,
>4^;
Ft CCD
y\
THC
(oOCtXkZb
CttA*/C£l>
fo&Cuxgp
\TltLF
vot^Hoor
\N£bp*tt/1/6^
PT
UAjrtL.
Xil
\\J£LO£lVC&0
BCS(/Of^.
A^O
gcC^T!OpWtP
T&
tVctu-ac
p£
-PC,
SG1A
m
SG1A
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
:: CIA-RDP96-00789R002001 070001-1
€C r
r
5KV
A
AppfoVted Fo r Rel€^&2ff0Q/Q8/08
: g^RI3P9J-00789R002001 080001-0
P«s-T
JU&MdUrs-t*
sivUv-&
.
/Wte.
^
^ O A7r
X
',/
'
V-'/
' /
77y gj/
IMrto
J-ClIa3
Soy/*3%
f?e /<»-
//miT"*MS fSfabkGQ
MMrJt/^
&£iix
'*y
*''J
LJS L/hy l/’Cj
CtS-IVCl/^
*•>
C(T** 5 t^rr-lft
UUtL,»j OX.
X
——
/
#—
•
•
c
^
/
/
/
.
/
~~r
'
!
;
i
.
.....
....
C j^W. A/#-
S
fiesucrs su^Mines*
2o k*o\J 8b
Wfr m\Jm\Al
bfisTB’,
Kb\J gfe
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R002001 080001-0
ZJSDS>a*l5
5nurce
Sconce,
report
gAcjelASW
«=&<*>%
RSACAk/iRAn
i/JeAfc/iJS
Asoiwo 0?A)
Bats
Grinae
cAStrte.x.
Sfec. Setv>irr2.
crcnc«^ei
ov>
UW>
Va. uj****
faxscs St,eef
WffVi
AtOS etvJS»«-
fepoirtr
n£Wcffi«u*rw>v^
fuAAtieter Bsct
ffouietes T*-fcS
To S£c
oe 3
i.iVa')
SAf>»tM Ssac* , Rvstvj;>fcgfHa?Jtt.u«,
&TfcGdW*a£. >J^>«^COfVVch ^frrv^iTww^S,
f^As^iSw-^evC
,
»*» w*4ef
jfejfTSfe, ]«*£?;
usf*
/ .SftU/A&ft
^
(.»/*)
f\
MEer-'MC. {com
\
w& torw)
Op Tv*> S!^f£4?
TIhU,
CtLuJQf*«At eJg€^T
?
m
j
c^g
atv raJ,
,fcu*.y
%dZeJk ,£j»fefii.T
Afinift.
*<u?T
oi 8
oya)
Herr
(Sjck Uzprgf
...
+*'
!
09 9
(N/a1
-r
j/*
cboMi w-Jf f^e&eewe
isewr#t^a&
^
—
T^W*>S&PfFE- C.U**»PCrE, SMAU-
uftvdl^C, peir^fir <fy**<&**ts*r<
S^)
; R&s.c
c«* l^jfcrsTW\iJl i vh? , 4*^
(s0Af4vig^4KVSe
(
Ca>» M**
} t
sk*}£$saA<Rje:ii^
A.*£tXrn.J
!;M« n
62-
,**•»
<j?
5 WilU,+
C**»Ur 'tt*
«
U>Aftr (Utjfce}
usrii|<*.
fincK fe-*x*4'*3
j
eW>4*-S
crt'
ex*+5
s A*,
i
f%ifttJshm
Appi oved For Re lease 2000/1
. a
,
.
p&rh**- Ult
io
gcAf toeek
18/08
: CIA-F DP96-00789 R00200108
t?&#
f!Vj
JfcUAltV
'te^fodAcUcU
\
Ltr\
I
08oboi-(
“TASk ASsISNRD : 3 Guq 84 TASK DVE 4 © Gua 8 NMEAAALA 2 28 (rifte * Mr~ 2 oe 3 loo 3 lect [eure Shape in Backgrand , TOw ¥ orFG Yediwene ociee color, Wan in trent Ons Fwd, Wire pith 6 , Bday ™~ Uke Wekung daum The Nore GPa musyile- Fins , Cmucat (B utlet shoge A Bench F Unes Whe Tage , Marnie prom, Sarish wiory mat Rus: wes, letters , Brown ledmer” pce D a ene arte. cover Sv re " Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA- RP 96-00789R002001080001-0 ~ ; WED Ring wa Ue crvple Sasi, Vat tate 5 | Appraved For Rel
The Battle Over The Future of the Supreme Court ee ka ae
. ‘ a; TASK ASStENED! 10 AVG 37 : Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002001080001- TAaxK Doe 1> Wes? _ | od i . ’ Ay Ge , . MU ees £5 = PA. tad rit 9 Loom QUesT6 sd uititten RRO Page - Sovfos lcaders Olt TT | Leave H |} | i o1 8 Blwe/ Wenre calovs. A “pean ~ | : _ | OA THR, Breecrsung. Corple | ECHADREN (PEOPLE LW Semi - —_o—— P96-00789 ed For Relbase 2000/08/08 : CIA-R
' flor Release 2 Bale ———— ~~ CPYRGHT SSS :
TASK
ASSi6/slE£
RESULTS Ju8ttiTT££>;
wp
ftevtsw
oars’
I
t> 6 C s (0
# TiEc St>
t>gg afe
Approved For Release 2000 /08/08
: CIA-RDP96 -00789R002001 080001-0
TAR&gr
PAm
Soorcc.
SboAOE.
R.£P<0 RT
WWitE. flmjcg
fht\ej % (siMvU
0WA ffertOfe- Ifi/WtMfi
Swi^s
8^fcr
fftoge.
<£tA
Acci.U’O^jS
RS6Sk.j*4S i°Jc_
f» MX Ce*^v.TS
*£>«> b»rr
ftatibwctZ &?tvisr
N««6ASgV^ T^kOflS
^vlf/sr MTFsefcei
{?fk«rr ou+\&-<».r
QeVh^
ap
i va u*ir*Ae<s
S^fi+Z rhnzr
T©
«rr*,$4e4
ctrf
WLJ^
-£*L
3sa,v^
cA
ree&f gc/*
& (ATS -f-M ?LsaK,£
Susytt^ts A-etf«
,<r
ctr»ASfi.;v»s
£>»A.#S£
A/Av^ C*Ac4*
i&rf %
frvuvj
60S
StRUCTwGES
/ MvliTfHVy SiTfe
M<JVV-»s 7 Sirs
Paia. large (jwUsy
MAeLluue. forONe >eefieA,.
t'AFV /a*^0wvD\^4
*K*fKS- pouf -
In
NU<, S&A-SK "
werfl'i
— j
\
6^\
AN ISOLATE® AfteA ,(^3^0
j
A
C-ftATEA-
•
TROcK ATT**
*UM j t>frUSK.iA M6»si wvr*
&*&£&&
Look, uatj
|
o\&
oil
QPe»J Pl^BA
j rAPJtHJULc ST^x)tTvr«r /
Slee^Mo&EfcjL TSSvlAo *P4?nr,pleS,
ClPtNGERoUj /for<rfWl»\<at'lVlS pm^tc.
Pfe»je««i>Avre *teJlii*ne>
tvjT~ a<TT
Kifekl ftPd«M»cU
.
iC&ffeOthrfi
!
i
1AR6£ City CShttUNB} UNjjMff&lC
IF, Rouao
a^,
f>6tf£«T
** Ph^<fAU,
mm
STifctfcMte- (Likin h'AMwUk).
$&f$vnJeii
l(> t.Tfra fTAjJtTVft.es
|
OVj
OPCA 4treCX ^reotiy
&«•%£*.
«
l« irA^^fJws. „
(’ioLo^Te.l
V
ps/ceti/c^
<tvy«
t*\ TV-*.
J0I
ON£ Kw> ClASOJk-L)
IK Small MeenVte { iNrsA\Ji6v»>‘?),
rfS LeccoeJ AfTER. pi/fTin^ -ST^Q^h*^'
i»> PcutLj
, M» Sifovisj e^'hovsJ"
Sfccerr -fft+ftLs^/A 4 CVJTT
-
)
Appi
yio is\Wlc
O^rcLobt'v*
oved For R« lease 2000/1 18/08
: CIA-F.DP96-00789 R00200108 C 001-0
&
Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002001080001-0 TASK ASSIGNED: IF Pon 82 : £0 uG 8} | Tsk Bue £ Z| _ puc- ¥ See ——NEwsweete Couzeer Prchive Jobse Bort Cofee Cudsed7”’ Sovuece hem ran Witt nends ve fy Bxceurentt corvrebiachon 60 3 Couneter , Strembpi feeb y day Lao lates je cect ig Vou Une Fixe. ¢ Rom white lated ol f a\d phon Ol ¥ | unsmewarr x. fcENE | PSs Le ToT & | et Bwenpy Lcene , Seaene sted heard CARS, “Porm, dorkrear lsvanennatae Atume gel wpucing , Yetion’s Dawts + Bol Rassias Chu deca“ or? 0% + { qm» lease 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002001080001-0 Approved For Re —
TASK ASSIGNSD: Zt due Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96- oar inamaianaae -0 TASK DUE . TF Aue es SUEEK CUES F-1[ SEP SF ore SuRTECT & " \eathy yr Hepleums Soveces Dara lO 3 Light Bisé , Yolk, BU, GRsen | Ravn SHAPES , leag ie “Bacew UNES, Carereentist A Posipva  suazecT maybe um MURAD Buss siaees ___| ©/ 1) Ge A dar lace sd, “TPL word PRougeT comes | Awa, @ ery , Babee} Lana | de aresnon, dusty Saniy but, dey i | Ot 7 | OD FASHIONED SCENE Russ | Reo A wRaedT (RIN CATE , | LARGE Buia tag OF Amen wearine A RUC xem, formar Sean as ? ‘ - Domne covpellalim og 4 -<o? “ | as Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002001080001 -0 ——
TASK ASSIGNED 3\ wee Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002001080001-0 TASK DOE 3 3 Bz CovuGe Sueseck: OE Jotinh Lewsl MES His Coes IU-1@ Sep 6p RPE Joted Foul IT == Sovec= “DAra OO 3 Huce BUCK ska TOWERING oOvee Smetler ri ger; core Rolorful shape, Water nly Q TALL RECTANGLES CROWDED TOGETHER , OVERYIng Ideas OF City Any Pdtner” Qe bar rege. PSRs WIth dark bay inl Scentex - Sconnny [ depvlerhin PARTS Ace) Paetrer veguierly, White Woure of Sumber ColummneS Sruduee - (doo Q Prob influcnce, plenct ind Stay —|_ OF 4 SwretT | Lettie Lines ) dade me Cuayen - A Pease dvestehiin Sharts eR Ag / Juerging ~Btg Teas 0% & 1 “ so? ~ Ss ae 7 “a Approved For Re lease 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002001080001-0 ©
TASK ASSGNED ' 8S Ser SF _ TASK DBE 4; 106 Sep 8F __n€ustwee Gover 1 2t- 2s Sep ee Couer Su@sech: Crem, Approved tr'Reipase 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002001080001-0 Sovece “Dara oo 3 Ren Pagooa Ure Chruciive, ow F Pape’ fh cTaanee Ol? Huse in a dyce Suparrted a a Lande Sometnive +t Jd? oTn Hons gry tetra pars, @ wn Soe Cukdeen — Schrott groves OF F Whi Grodine Uk a feune, bs re g ae tee FOU Sing prada, OB ¢ 2 Le ‘. « Yew’ Pa Approved For Rel ease 2000/0 3/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002001080001-0
TASK ASsieseD. 1 ¢ Sa 87> TAS OURS fF Sep 87 Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002001080001-0 COyse Su67BeT 2 Bill Casal} Pesta Tere classy NEwswwtsy Chuse Ze Sep - 2 ot EF Source bara: OO 4 — G ip Wiented uA Slerthng, Arrechon, terton nearst, wears lasses pda clams, stofF | Po ctvte Round crtodlorr aye t with Coop Correlation Ot | A fear try Stand, Mm & a Cael om da POS tae oe. CAO, 4 + + A picture q a Vn , Solus ° “Whack me bry ¥ MAO ny Vebucle ' clark. ate. rtd Mar , a i “g Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : ClA-F}DP96-00784R00200108¢001-9
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R002301750001-3
m
«L
/\pOtO®*%
Vrc^ P'
1*
'
-cFir;\ct,
PLEASE Ml.
UN¥T^% %
I
i
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R002301 750001 -3
Approved For Release 2004/08/16
: CIA-RpP96-0
f07^R0021 00020002-5
SECRET
TORE^i
.Lo
SUBJECT:
Human Use Coordination for Project GRILL FLAME
(U)
f.
(C)
The Army General Counsel maintained that GRILL FLAME activities
involved human use and required Secretariat review and coordination UP Proce-
dure 18, DOD Regulation 5240. 1-R.
The DOD General Counsel initially disagreed.
The issue was decided on 17 Nov
81 with the DOD General Counsel accepting the
Army position.
A detailed review of
this
"human use" question
is
at TAB
E.
g.
(S/N0F0RN)
The future of
the Army program has been complicated by
the elimination
of Army FY
82 GRILL FLAME 0&M funds during
the Congressional
HAC
-
SAC conferees’
hearing.
However,
it appears
that the Army request
for
five permanent GRILL FLAME personnel positions
for FY
82 remained in the pro
gram.
DIA's GRILL FLAME effort
for FY
82 was
fully funded for
$330K.
Army
GRILL FLAME activities
are contained
in our FY
83 program submission and
t
is
will allow us
to fully air the issue with Congress.
In the interim,
INSCOM
.
plans
to keep
the effort alive by internal reprogramming until
a final decision
on future funding can be reached.
h
(U)
The current Army Secretariat authority
to conduct GRILL FLAME
activities UP Procedure
18,
DOD Regulation 5240. 1-R requires renewal in Jan
(TAB
F)
.
Army GRILL FLAME activities will be continued subsequent
to
Jan ~82 pending resolution of
the above described FY
82 funding
issue.
(The
ACS I memo
at TAB A seeks this authority from the Secretary
of
the Army.
w&ne
3.
(u)
RECOMMENDATION :
That ZA sign memorandum at^TAB A.
Approved For Release 2004/08/16
: (m-‘RBPO^-00789F[002l 00020002-5
SECULi FCRFGN hi
hi' S
Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002100030001-5 SECRET - NT-5- 1010-5 SESSA RRA SN DEFENSE INTELLIGENCE AGENCY EVALUATION METHODS (U) INITIAL REPORT DEAE ASARE DAE NMSA AN AA SAA SARIS BAS eae SHEABARRE EASES SSARRAR SEATS AS SERA DEAR LULA ANAS SAA RSSSESSSSSESSSR CANES ASE AA NE AA 13 December, 1990 Leunsnannranany SARS NOFORN SECHET Ruse sas SAAD Ab Asan ANNASSABAADAE RARE ceccaeacaunennecenaeaccecanen Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002100030001-5
Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002100030001-5 — eee EVALUATION METHODS Date of Publication 13 December 1990 This is a Department of Defense Intelligence Document prepared by the Technology Assessment and Support Office, Directorate for Scientific and Technical Intelligence , Defense Intelligence Agency. PREPARED BY Technology Assessment and Support Office (DT-S) NOT RELEASABLE TO FOREIGN NATIONALS Classified by: DIA/DT Declassify: OADR a ne ee Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002100030001-5
Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002100030001-5 mo TABLE OF CONTENTS I. PURPOSE II. BACKGROUND III. SCOPE Iv. OPERATIONAL PROJECT EVALUATION METHODOLOGIES A. SCALE APPROACH B. FUZZY SET APPROACH C. CONCEPT ANALYSIS D. CONTROL GROUPS E. IN-GROUP CONTROLS V. UTILITY EVALUATION CONSIDERATIONS VI. EVALUATION/DATA PROBLEMS VII. PREREQUISITES FOR EVALUATION A. RESEARCH REQUIREMENTS B. PROJECT TYPE C. ROLE OF RECORDS/PROTOCOLS/PROCEDURES BIBLIOGRAPHY FIGURES 1. EVALUATION SCALES 2. DATA CATEGORIES 3. REMOTE VIEWING DATA/TARGET EXAMPLE 4. DATA DEVELOPMENT, EVALUATION AND ASSESSMENT PROCESS se 11 11 12 13 13 13 14 16 10 15 Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002100030001-5
Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002100030001-5 a = EVALUATION METHODS I. (U) PURPOSE: (S) The purpose of this initial report is to provide a summary of methods that have been used for evaluating psychoenergetics (ie., remote viewing) data in both a research and applications-oriented environment. II. (U) BACKGROUND: (U) When modern research into psychoenergetics (ie. Extrasensory Perception) began in the early 1930’s at Duke University, NC., the experiments were designed to accommodate easy to use statistical methods. Consequently, a small number of forced choice targets (e.g., a set of five cards with different symbols) were developed as targets. Results from experiments using such targets could be readily compared with those expected from chance guessing. If results exceeded a preset value (usually one out of twenty) a case for phenomenon existence could be made, especially if the experimental trials were large in number (ie., several thousand). (U) Although these early statistical methods were convenient, they could not be applied to evaluate results from the remote viewing experiments that began in the early 1970’s. Targets in most remote viewing experiments are not limited to a small set of possibilities; most early remote viewing experiments 1 otniingwiaiaiiea Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002100030001-5
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R0028001 40004-3
SOURCE NO:
DATE :
8 Nov 94
SUSPENSE
8 NOV
1500 Hrs
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: ClA-RDP96-00789R0028001 40004-3
- opadind, AFG yh _ Apptoved For Release 2002/11/18 : C1A-RDP96-00789R00#{ooqgdobi-0 , a 25 q t sf a“ po q— this Mon \5 at di, es erdiculds ONd ONHNCS OT WO (ecedkes \ cullen ico-f ned EVIGEN CE \ OR POWER ~SOuURCE Approved For RedaseRUl{G/18 : Zia-ROP SA poFG RoE 0659601 0 >
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R0021 00030001 -5
subjective aspects.
This has not always been accomplished
in
the
past and needs
to
be part
of any future application project
procedure,
whenever possible.
(C)
However,
specific evaluation methods are only meaningful
when the over-all
remote viewing activity
is based on sound
methodological
procedures.
Procedural
aspects can easily be
developed
to ensure
that
the activity
is
in fact consistent with
sound scientific methodology.
Appropriate procedures are
discussed
in companion reports,
and are only briefly addressed
in
this
report.
III.
(U)
SCOPE:
(C)
The following sections provide brief summaries of the
various approaches that have been used by this unit for evaluating
results from operational
or appl ications-oriented projects.
A
follow up report
is planned that will
review
in more detail
the
evaluation methodologies used for research and for appl ications-
oriented projects.
Other relevant issues are also discussed.
IV.
(U)
OPERATIONAL PROJECT EVALUATION METHODOLOGIES:
(S)
There are two main issues
in evaluating remote viewing
data;
(1)
What
is the definition of the target;
(2)
What
is the
definition
of the^ remote viewing response.
Various methods
examined are simply different ways of comparing and evaluating the
target and the response.
Approved For Release 2000/08/08
: CIA-RDP96-00789R0021 00030001 -5
Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002100030001-5 a a Le (April 1989), SECRET-NOFORN. 12. Wanda L. W. Luke et al., "A Prototype Analysis System For Special Remote Viewing Tasks (U)", Final Report--Task 6.0.3 Covering the Period 1 October 1988 to 30 September 1989, Project 1291, SRI International, Menlo Park, CA (October 1989), SECRET-NOFORN-WNINTEL. 13. Beverly S. Humphrey et al., “Remote Viewing Evaluation Techniques (U),”, Final Report—-Objective A, Task 4, Project 1291, ORT International, Menlo Park, CA (December 1986), SECRET-NOFORN-WNINTEL. 14. K. Ramakrishna Rao “The Basic Experiments in Parapsychology," McFarland & Company, Inc., Jefferson, NC, and London (1984), UNCLASSIFIED. 18 onteelinteniteniention Approved For Release 2000/08/08 : CIA-RDP96-00789R002100030001-5