Ecological, genetic, and morphological differences among three Pavona (Cnidaria: Anthozoa) species from the Pacific coast of Panama

Ecological, genetic, and morphological differences among three Panamanian Pacific Pavona species with strongly developed collines (Pavona varians, P. frondifera, and P. chiriquiensis) were examined. Ecological factors included geographical distributions of species, habitat preferences, interspecific interactions, reproductive ecology, and tolerance to bleaching. Genetic differences were based on the electrophoretic analysis of ten allozyme loci. Morphological analyses consisted of tissue coloration, colony morphology, and measurements and counts of ten macro- and micro-skeletal characters. P. varians, present on reefs or in coral communities, is the most widely distributed and shows considerable morphological variation. P. chiriquiensis, a recently described species, encrusts basalt rock and has little morphological variation. P. frondifera is a reef dweller with a compact foliose morphology. Tissue coloration varies from light to dark brown in P. varians, from pink to brown in P. frondifera, and from brick red to brown or silvery in Pavona chiriquiensis. Also, the white to silvery polyp mouths of the latter species are a diagnostic feature that allows an easy identification in the field. Aggressive dominance during short-term interspecific interactions were as follows: Pavona chiriquiensis>P. varians>P. frondifera. P. chiriquiensis and P. varians showed contrasting responses to sea warming during the 1997–1998 El Nino Southern Oscillation. Whereas entire P. chiriquiensis bleached and died within 4 weeks of exposure to 30–31°C, colonies of P. varians did so only on their upper surfaces. The response of P. frondifera to elevated temperatures was not observed because it is mainly present in the Gulf of Panama where coral bleaching was absent in 1997–1998. The genetic data indicated that P. chiriquiensis differed strongly from both P. varians and P. frondifera, with Nei's unbiased genetic distances of 0.434 and 0.379, respectively. A fixed difference between P. varians and P. frondifera, and P. chiriquiensis exists at the triose phosphate isomerase (TPI-2) locus. A nearly fixed difference between P. chiriquiensis and P. frondifera and between P. chiriquiensis and P. varians was found at the hexokinase (HK) locus. P. varians differed slightly from P. frondifera with Nei's unbiased genetic distance of 0.068. No fixed difference was found between P. varians and P. frondifera. There were strong differences between P. chiriquiensis and P. varians in spawning times and gamete characteristics. Spawning in P. varians and P. chiriquiensis is 12 h out of phase. Also, eggs of the former species are white to beige and positively buoyant whereas those of the latter species are dark green and neutrally to negatively buoyant. No reproductive data are yet available for P. frondifera. Calicular diameters are significantly greater in P. chiriquiensis than in the other two species. In contrast, corallum thickness is greater in P. varians and P. frondifera than in P. chiriquiensis. Canonical discriminant function analysis readily separated the three species.