Describing Overarching Curricular Goals for Individualized Education

Phenomenon: The phenomenon of individualized education, an essential component of competency-based medical education, addresses individual learner needs while working toward standardized learning outcomes. One challenge with broadly implementing individualized education is the lack of a pragmatic operational definition. To formalize expectations for individualized education, the Accreditation Council of Graduate Medical Education in 2013 began requiring six months of individualized curriculum (IC) during pediatric residency; however, there is not a national standard of formal curricular goals for the IC as an educational entity. Examining and describing the overarching curricular goals of IC could provide a framework for discourse about and further study of individualized education in medicine across disciplines and the continuum of medical education. Thus, we aimed to describe the phenomenon of individualized education through the lens of the goals of the IC in pediatric residency in the United States. Approach: In 2017, a purposeful sample of Pediatric Residency leaders were recruited to represent a diverse sample of program sizes, regions of the country, and importance of the IC to the program leadership. They completed an online survey with open-ended questions describing formal and implicit goals of their program's IC. The authors analyzed responses initially using conventional content analysis, then investigated whether the themes for program goals aligned with any existing educational theory. The concepts and language aligned with the principles of self-determination theory (SDT); therefore, the IC goals were subsequently grouped using the SDT domains of relatedness, autonomy, and competence. A focus group with a subset of survey respondents was conducted for member checking and elaboration of concepts. Findings: Program leaders from a diverse sample of 36 programs participated in the survey and a subset of 11 programs participated in the focus group. The common goals across all programs are listed in parentheses and organized by domains of SDT: 1)Relatedness goals (engage in mentorship, select a career) cultivate resident's professional identity based on their desired future career path; 2)autonomy goals (create a learning plan, practice accountability) help residents plan their path; and fulfillment of their plans lead to 3)competence goals (develop targeted clinical skills and knowledge, ensure comprehensive exposure, address learning gaps), ensuring they have a comprehensive skill set for their chosen identity. Insights: This study provides a framework to describe the phenomenon of individualized education through the lens of IC curricular goals in pediatric residency. The goals for IC that emerged from this study serve as a pragmatic framework for implementation of individualized education. They provide a common language and structure to promote more rigorous and collaborative study of individualized education across programs, disciplines, and settings in medicine. They may function as a roadmap for learners to navigate educational activities and for programs to help shape the experiences of their learners and examine outcomes of individualized education in their programs. The framework can also help individual pediatric residency programs structure improvements to their IC. Disciplines beyond pediatrics may also use this framework to better structure elective experiences to capitalize on the benefits of individual education.