Massive prey recruitment and the control of rocky subtidal communities on large spatial scales

What drives community change on large spatial scales? An opportunity to address this fundamental question was provided by a massive subtidal recruitment of the mussel, Mytilus edulis, across the southwest Gulf of Maine (GOM), USA, in 1995. Since M. edulis is consumed by many predator species, we hypothesized that the episodic increase in food resources had a bottom-up effect on populations of mussel consumers. The mussel recruitment event was unprecedented in its large spatial extent, high coverage of the sea floor, and depth of penetration into the rocky subtidal zone. During 1995-1997 we tracked mussels and their consumer populations in the area to document what happened. Surveys across a 120-km marine landscape revealed that juvenile mussels covered 33-91% of the bottom (8-12 m depth) at 13 of 17 sites between October 1995 and June 1996. The cover of mussel prey in June 1996 explained significant variation in the density and biomass of mussel predators, the sea stars Asterias spp. and rock crabs Cancer spp., at 16-17 sites 10, 13, and 23 months after mussel recruitment. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that the extensive mussel recruitment had a bottom-up effect on the subtidal food web. Levels of Asterias spp. recruitment, biomass, and density following mussel recruitment were the highest recorded at two monitored sites in 16-18 years. One year after the large pulse of mussel food resources, Asterias spp. recruitment was positively related to the percent cover of mussels, suggesting a feedback between food supply and consumer re- cruitment on a large spatial scale. Crab size-structure data supported the interpretation that recruitment contributed to the high densities of rock crabs recorded in July 1997. We suggest that the bottom-up effects observed in consumer populations were produced by increased growth, elevated reproduction and recruitment, and possibly by immigration. Coupling between bottom-up and top-down control was observed after a lag of 12-14 months post-mussel recruitment when predation by sea stars, rock crabs, and sea urchins eliminated extensive beds of juvenile mussels across the study region. The elimination of Mytilus prey triggered cannibalism in the sea star Asterias vulgaris, which contributed to density-dependent population declines in sea stars between 1996 and 1997. A key as- sumption of a consumer reproduction and recruitment response—that some of the larvae produced by local adult stocks of consumers could be retained in the study region—was tested by investigating the potential larval dispersal of sea stars and crabs in a simulated three-dimensional flow field of the southwest GOM. The simulation supported the as- sumption as 15-75% of particles released below 1-m depth were retained in the region over 2-5 week periods approximating the larval life-span of the consumers. Furthermore, the degree of retention increased dramatically between the surface (1 m) and 15-m depth, implying that the extent of large-scale connectivity by passive larval dispersal is highly dependent on depth. In this study, massive prey recruitment stimulated coupling between bottom-up and top-down forces, resulting in broad-scale changes in local consumer pop- ulations that persisted after the prey-recruitment signal was removed, underscoring the importance of episodic events in marine community dynamics.