Formation of lobate debris aprons on Mars: Assessment of regional ice sheet collapse and debris-cover armoring

Abstract Lobate debris aprons (LDA) are lobate-shaped aprons surrounding scarps and isolated massifs that are concentrated in the vicinity of the northern Dichotomy Boundary on Mars. LDAs have been interpreted as (1) ice-cemented talus aprons undergoing viscous flow, (2) local debris-covered alpine-like glaciers, or (3) remnants of the collapse of a regional retreating ice sheet. We investigate the plausibility that LDAs are remnants of a more extensive regional ice sheet by modeling this process. We find that as a regional ice sheet collapses, the surface drops below cliff and massif bedrock margins, exposing bedrock and regolith, and initiating debris deposition on the surface of a cold-based glacier. Reduced sublimation due to debris-cover armoring of the proto-LDA surface produces a surface slope and consequent ice flow that carries the armoring debris away from the rock outcrops. As collapse and ice retreat continue the debris train eventually reaches the substrate surface at the front of the glacier, leaving the entire LDA armored by debris cover. Using a simplified ice flow model we are able to characterize the temperature and sublimation rate that would be necessary to produce LDAs with a wide range of specified lateral extents and thicknesses. We then apply this method to a database of documented LDA parameters (height, lateral extent) from the Dichotomy Boundary region, and assess the implications for predicted climate conditions during their formation and the range of formation times implied by the model. We find that for the population examined here, typical temperatures are in the range of −85 to −40 °C and typical sublimation rates lie in the range of 6–14 mm/a. Lobate debris apron formation times (from the point of bedrock exposure to complete debris cover) cluster near 400–500 ka. These results show that LDA length and thickness characteristics are consistent with climate conditions and a formation scenario typical of the collapse of a regional retreating ice sheet and exposure of bedrock cliffs. This scenario helps resolve many of the unusual characteristics of lobate debris aprons (LDA) and lineated valley fill (LVF). For example, the distribution of LVF is very consistent with extensive flow of glacial ice from plateau icefields, and the acquisition of a debris cover in the waning stages of retreat of the regional cover as the bedrock scarps are exposed. The typical concentric development of LDA around massifs is much more consistent with ice sheet retreat than insolation-related local accumulation and flow. We thus conclude that the retreating ice-sheet model is robust and should be investigated and tested in more detail. In addition, these results clearly show that the lobate debris aprons in the vicinity of the Dichotomy Boundary could not have attained temperatures near or above the ice melting point and retained their current shape, a finding that supports subzero temperatures for the last several hundred million years, the age of the LDA surfaces. A further implication is that the LDA ice has been preserved for at least several hundred million years, and could potentially contain the record of the climate of Mars, preserved since that time below a sublimation lag deposit.