Origin of temporal compositional trends in monogenetic vent eruptions: Insights from the crystal cargo in the Papoose Canyon sequence, Big Pine Volcanic Field, CA

Abstract Many monogenetic vents display systematic temporal–compositional variations over the course of eruption. Previous studies have proposed that these trends may reflect variable degrees of crustal assimilation, or melting and mixing of heterogeneous mantle source(s). Discrimination between these two endmember hypotheses is critical for understanding the plumbing systems of monogenetic volcanoes, which pose a significant volcanic hazard in many areas. In this study, we examine the Papoose Canyon (PC) monogenetic vent in the Big Pine Volcanic Field (BPVF), which had been well characterized for temporal–compositional variations in erupted basalts. We present new major and trace element and Sr–Nd–Pb-O isotopic data from the PC “crystal cargo” (phenocrysts and xenoliths). Comparison of “crystal cargo” and host basalt provides new constraints on the history of magma storage, fractionation, and crustal contamination that are obscured in the bulk basalts due to pre- and syn-eruptive magma mixing processes. The abundances of phenocrysts and ultramafic xenoliths in the PC sequence decrease up-section. Olivine and clinopyroxene phenocrysts span a wide range of Mg# (77–89). The majority of phenocrysts are more evolved than olivine or clinopyroxene in equilibrium with their host basalts ( Mg# = 68 – 71 , equilibrium Fo ≈ 85 – 89 ). In addition, the ultramafic xenoliths display cumulate textures. Olivine and clinopyroxene from ultramafic xenoliths have Mg# (73–87) similar to the phenocrysts, and lower than typical mantle peridotites. Sr–Nd–Pb isotope compositions of the xenoliths are similar to early PC basalts. Finally, many clinopyroxene phenocrysts and clinopyroxene in xenoliths have trace element abundances in equilibrium with melts that are more enriched than the erupted basalts. These features suggest that the phenocrysts and xenoliths derive from melt that is more fractionated and enriched than erupted PC basalts. Pressure constraints suggest phenocrysts and ultramafic xenoliths crystallized at ∼5–7 kbar, corresponding to mid-crust depths. Correlations between HFSE depletion and Sr–Nd–Pb isotopic compositions, high δ 18 O values in olivines, and radiogenic Os isotopic compositions in whole rocks also suggest incorporation of a crustally contaminated component. We propose that the phenocrysts and ultramafic xenoliths derive from melts that ponded and fractionated and assimilated continental crust, possibly in mid-crustal sills. These melts were drained and mixed with more primitive melts as the eruption began, and the temporal–compositional trends and decreasing crystal phase abundances reflect gradual deflation and exhaustion of these sills as the eruption progressed. The isotopic variations in the PC sequence span much of the compositional range observed in the BPVF. Evidence for variable crustal contamination of PC basalts suggests that much of the isotopic variation observed in the BPVF may also reflect crustal contamination rather than mantle source heterogeneity as previously proposed. In addition, evidence of pre-eruptive magma ponding and fractionation, if applicable to other monogenetic vents, may have significant implications for monitoring and hazard assessment of monogenetic volcano fields.