THRESHOLD EFFECTS OF LANDSCAPE STRUCTURE ON BIOLOGICAL CONTROL IN AGROECOSYSTEMS

Habitat fragmentation may adversely affect the ability of natural enemies to control pest outbreaks in agricultural landscapes by interfering with their search behavior and ability to aggregate in response to prey. We determined how landscape structure affected the ability of two ladybird beetles (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae) to track aphid populations in experimental landscapes that differed in the abundance and degree of fragmentation of red clover (Trifoliutn pratense). One coccinellid was a native species (Coleomegilla ma- culntn Pallas) and the other (Hartnonia a~ridis Timberlake) was introduced specifically for the biological control of crop pests such as pea aphids (Acyrrlzosiphon pisurn Harris; Homoptera: Aphididae). Landscape structure exhibited a threshold in lacunarity (a measure of interpatch dis- tances) below 20% habitat. at which point clover patches became significantly more isolated. This threshold in landscape structure was mirrored by a similar threshold in the distribution of pea aphid populations. The distribution of the biocontrol agent, H. nxyridis, tracked this threshold in aphid distribution, but the native coccinellid. C. maculata, was unable to do so in fragmented clover landscapes. Although C. maculata was a more active forager within clover cells, overall it was less mobile and moved significantly less among clover cells and between landscapes than H. axyridis, which may have contributed to its inability to track aphid populations in fragmented landscapes. The two coccinellids did not differ in their search success within fragmented landscapes. however. and it was only in clumped land- scapes that H. axyridis maximized search success and foraged within clover cells that had 2.5-3 times more aphids than those in which C. rnnculntn occurred. Thus, the potential of predators to control pest populations in fragmented landscapes may ultimately reflect the extent to which thresholds in landscape structure interfere with the aggregative response of predators. In this system, the aggregative response of cocci- nellids was more closely tied to thresholds in the distribution of clover than aphids. With its greater mobility, H. nxyridis was more effective than the indigenous C. maculata at tracking aphids when they occurred at low patch occupancy (below the threshold in land- scape structure), which is a requisite for successful biocontrol. If native insect predators are generally more sensitive to habitat fragmentation, greater reliance may be placed on the introduction of exotic species for biocontrol, which is not without economic cost and potential ecological impacts to native insect communities. Our study demonstrates that. in addition to economic thresholds. there are also ecological thresholds that must be sur- mounted if biocontrol measures are to be successful. In addition to enhancing vegetational diversity within agroecosystems, conservation biological control should also strive to mit- igate fragmentation effects on natural enemies, especially if thresholds in landscape structure disrupt predator-prey interactions and compromise the efficacy of biocontrol programs.