INHIBITION OF NITRIFICATION BY CLIMAX ECOSYSTEMS. II. ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE AND POSSIBLE ROLE OF TANNINS

The same nine plots were used in this study as in our previous study on inhibition of nitrification (Rice and Pancholy, 1972). These consisted of three stands representing two stages of old field succession and the climax in each of three vegetation types in Oklahoma: tall grass prairie, post oak-blackjack oak forest, and oak-pine forest. Soil samples were analyzed three times during the growing season of 1972 for exchangeable ammonium nitrogen, nitrate, and numbers of Nitrosomonas and Nitrobacter. Results were similar to those obtained during the entire year of 1971. The amount of ammonium nitrogen was lowest in the first successional stage, intermediate in the intermediate successional stage, and highest in the climax. The amount of nitrate was highest in the first successional stage, intermediate in the intermediate successional stage, and lowest in the climax. The numbers of nitrifiers were highest in the first successional stage usually and decreased to a very low number in the climax. These data furnish additional evidence that the nitrifiers are inhibited in the climax so that ammonium nitrogen is not oxidized to nitrate as readily in the climax as in the successional stages. This would aid in the conservation of nitrogen and energy in the climax ecosystem. Some inhibition of nitrification occurred in the intermediate stage of succession also. Previous studies of tannins indicated that these are inhibitory to nitrification, so all important plant species in the intermediate successional stage and the climax were analyzed for total tannin content. A method for extracting and quantifying condensed tannins from soils was developed and the amounts of tannins were determined in each 15-cm level down to 60 cm in the same two plots in each vegetation type. Gallic and ellagic acids, which result from the digestion of hydrolyzable tannins in oak species, were also extracted and quantified in the climax oak-pine forest. All the important herbaceous species, including the grasses, were found to have considerable amounts of condensed tannins. The highest amounts of tannins occurred in the oaks and pine, however. Condensed tannins, hydrolyzable tannins, ellagic acid, gallic acid, digallic acid, and commercial tannic acid (hydrolyzable tannin), in very small concentrations, were all found to completely inhibit nitrification by Nitrosomonas in soil suspensions for 3 weeks, the duration of the tests. Slightly larger concentrations were required to inhibit nitrification by Nitrobacter under similar conditions. The concentrations of tannins, gallic acid, and ellagic acid found in the soil of the research plots were several times higher than the minimum concentrations necessary to completely inhibit nitrification. The inhibition of nitrification was always greater in the climax stand than in the intermediate successional stage in each vegetation type, and the concentration of tannins in the top 15 cm of soil was always higher in the climax stand than in the intermediate successional stage. Moreover, the amounts of tannins calculated to be added to each plot each year are much less than the amounts found in the soil, indicating that the tannins accumulate over a period of time. Thus, it appears that the tannins and tannin derivatives may play a continuous and rather prominent role in the inhibition of nitrification by vegetation.