Filtration models, guilds, and biofacies: Crinoid paleoecology of the Stanton Formation (Upper Pennsylvanian), midcontinent, North America

Abstract Filtration models make several predictions concerning the distribution of crinoids among benthic habitats: (1) generally, higher energy shoreward settings should contain crinoid assemblages dominated by taxa with dense mesh filtration fans; (2) generally, lower energy offshore settings should be dominated by crinoids with open mesh filtration fans; (3) diversity should be highest in nearshore settings, which generally contain low energy microhabitats within high energy settings where both dense fan and open fan forms can co-occur, whereas offshore assemblages should be dominated by open fan taxa; thus, open fan forms should be more eurytopic than dense fan forms. Also, previous empirical models for crinoid distribution patterns note that nearshore assemblages are dominated by large forms whereas offshore assemblages are dominated by small forms. Filtration fan morphology and body size interact significantly to determine how and where crinoids feed and thus are used here as criteria for distinguishing late Paleozoic crinoid guilds. The distribution patterns of crinoid taxa and guilds among the benthic paleoenvironments of the Upper Pennsylvanian (Missourian) Stanton Formation were used to test the predictions of the filtration models. The results of quantitative analyses show that large, dense fan crinoids are significantly more abundant in shoreward assemblages than smaller, open fan crinoids, which are more abundant in offshore assemblages; these results are consistent with the aforementioned models. However, diversity patterns are not consistent with the filtration models, indicating that mid-depth and aerobic offshore assemblages are more taxonomically and trophically diverse than nearshore and dysaerobic offshore assemblages, ostensibly due to the overlapping ranges of characteristically nearshore and offshore taxa. Analysis of guild distribution patterns also indicates some contradictions to predicted patterns of stenotopy and eurytopy, indicating additional complexities to late Paleozoic crinoid paleoecology. Five recurrent crinoid assemblages, or biofacies, have been identified from the Stanton Formation of midcontinent North America. The guild structure and diversity of these biofacies are characterized here as: (1) a moderate diversity nearshore biofacies dominated by large calyx, dense fan guilds; (2) a high diversity midshelf biofacies characterized by equitable contributions of many taxa and guilds; (3) a moderate diversity offshore biofacies dominated by non-pinnulate and small calyx, open fan pinnulate guilds; (4) a low diversity offshore dysaerobic biofacies dominated by small calyx pinnulate guilds; (5) a depauperate offshore biofacies dominated by a unique stalkless species, Paragassizocrinus tarri. Except for Biofacies 5, the number of guilds appears to increase offshore; however, the equitability of taxa among and within the guilds generally decreases offshore. This pattern indicates that the heterogeneity of resources, or the recognition by taxa of different classes of resources, as reflected by the variety of functional types, increased from nearshore to offshore, but that the abundance or accessibility of these resources, and/or the relaxation of competition within guilds, increased from offshore to nearshore.