A Review of Research on Subsonic Turbulent Flow Reattachment

Introduction T reattachment of a turbulent shear layer is an important process in a large number of practical engineering configurations, including diffusers, airfoils with separation bubbles, buildings, and combustors. In order to predict these complicated flows, we must understand and be able to predict the behavior of reattaching shear layers. However, our current understanding of the reattachment process is poor, a fact demonstrated by our inability to predict simple reattaching flows over a wide range of parameters. In fact, a complete list of the parameters that affect reattachment has yet to be formulated. Among two-dimensional flows, the backward-facing step is the simplest reattaching flow. The separation line is straight and fixed at the edge of the step, and there is only one separated zone instead of two, as seen in the flow over a fence or obstacle. In addition, the streamlines are nearly parallel to the wall at the separation point, so significant upstream influence occurs only downstream of separation. Although they are not always stated explicitly, these are the reasons why most of the research on reattachment has been done in backward-facing step flows. The backward-facing step is also used as a building block flow for workers developing turbulence models. Therefore, it is important to supply data which can be used to test codes and information that may aid the development of future codes. Bradshaw and Wong reviewed the experimental data for reattaching flows in 1972. Since that time there has been a proliferation of new research in the area, particularly since the advent of the laser anemometer and the pulsed-wire anemometer. This research has been conducted by a number of independent groups, and therefore the net result is somewhat disorganized. Very little systematic study has been done on the effect of the governing parameters on reattachment. In addition, most of the experiments, when viewed separately, have failed to cast any new light on the underlying physics of the reattachment process. The purpose of this paper is twofold. The primary purpose is to review the available data for turbulent flows over backward-facing steps, including some new data of our own and other previously unpublished data. Second, we suggest several areas of research that we feel could lead to improvements in our ability to predict flows with separation bubbles. Several physical mechanisms will be proposed to explain some of the phenomena that have been observed. It is our hope that these suggestions will provoke further thought, comment, and research. The review covers subsonic flows over backward-facing steps in which the Reynolds number is high enough to insure that the separated shear layer is fully turbulent. Important work on laminar and transitional reattaching shear layers has been performed by Goldstein et al. and Armaly et al. but will not be referred to here. Primary emphasis is on planar flows, but some data from axisymmetric flows will be utilized. Double-sided, sudden expansion flows in which the flow is asymmetric are not considered here, because these flows are even more complicated than flows with a single separation bubble. A companion paper examines the uncertainty of the available data in more detail. It also assesses the usefulness of the various data sets as test cases for computational procedures.