Commentary: exciting new developments in fast neutron cross sections and dosimetry.

The field of fast neutron therapy, and to some extent the practice of radiation protection in the vicinity of medical linear accelerators, requires accurate physical data. The paucity of physical data for neutron cross sections above about 15 MeV in low- Z materials is best exemplified (and somewhat exaggerated!) in the late Herb Attix's standard textbook Introduction to Radiological Physics and Radiation Dosimetry (Attix 1986). On page 464, the contributions to kerma in tissue from neutrons stops abruptly shortly above about 15 MeV. Photon and electron dosimetry has benefited from a well established and highly cohesive relationship between measurement and theory due to the enormous success of quantum electrodynamics. In contrast, measurements in the field of neutron radiotherapy have benefited less from theory because of the complexity of the quantum mechanics of nuclear structure, especially for light elements. This is because the nuclear levels are widely spaced at low excitation energies unlike for heavy elements where the energy level spacing is more dense and statistical assumptions can be applied with success. This means that accurate measurements are crucial for guiding and testing theoretical development. Measurements contributing to the field of fast neutron dosimetry are few and far between. Amazingly, in this issue of Physics in Medicine and Biology there are two such contributions! The paper by Benck, Slypen, Meulders and Corcalciuc (1998) entitled `Experimental double differential cross sections and derived kerma factors for oxygen at incident neutron energies from reaction thresholds to 65 MeV' reports on a set of measurements of the doubly-differential cross sections (energy and angle) for fast neutrons on for 9 energies between 25 and 65 MeV. The reaction channels measured were (n, px), (n, dx), (n, tx) and (n, x). These cross sections were then integrated to produce partial and total kerma factors. There are several features of this paper that are particularly exciting: The quality of the measurements on oxygen appears to have taken a significant leap forward in comparison with the only other experimental studies (Subramanian et al 1983, 1986). In particular, a comprehensive angular range is covered, allowing a more accurate angle-integration of the data, and good statistics are obtained. Much of the cross section experimental data appears to either support or contradict the relatively recent theoretical calculations of Brenner and Prael (1989) and Chadwick and Young (1996). In a few cases the discrepancies between measurement and theory are so large as to motivate more theoretical development in this area. The agreement between the measured kerma factors and theoretical values is excellent. The second paper by Binns, DeLuca Jr, Maughan and Kota (1998) entitled `Direct determination of kerma for a d(48.5)+Be therapy beam' describes a direct measurement of the kerma ratio, , of muscle tissue to A-150 plastic for the fast neutron therapy facility of Harper Hospital in Detroit, Michigan. The measured value of was found to be - a significant departure from that determined using the currently accepted dosimetry protocol (ICRU 1989) (a value of 0.95). This measurement can also be used to test the accuracy of theoretical predictions, since the kerma ratio can be calculated by averaging the theoretical kerma factor ratios over the neutron spectrum at Harper Hospital, which can be estimated from radiation transport simulations of the Be+ d neutron source. Deviations between theory and experiment will stimulate future studies to better understand the cross sections, kerma factors, and neutron spectra. These new measurements described in this issue of Physics in Medicine and Biology raise the standard in fast neutron dosimetry and also make fundamental contributions to the understanding of nuclear structure and reaction mechanisms. It is indeed remarkable and satisfying that the demands of a very practical field like medical physics can issue scientific challenges in even the most basic disciplines, and that the basic sciences rise to the challenge with enthusiasm. References Attix F H 1986 Introduction to Radiological Physics and Radiation Dosimetry (New York: Wiley) Benck S, Slypen I, Meulders J P and Corcalciuc V 1998 Experimental double differential cross sections and derived kerma factors for oxygen at incident neutron energies from reaction thresholds to 65 MeV Phys. Med. Biol. 43 3427-47 Binns P J, DeLuca Jr P M, Maughan R L and Kota C 1998 Direct determination of kerma for a d(48.5)+Be therapy beam Phys. Med. Biol. 43 3449-57 Brenner D J and Prael R R 1989 Calculated differential secondary-particle production cross-sections after nonelastic neutron interactions with carbon and oxygen between 15 and 60 MeV Atomic and Nuclear Data Tables 41 71-99 Chadwick M B and Young P G 1996 Calculation and evaluation of cross sections and kerma factors for neutrons up to 100 MeV on and Nucl. Sci. Eng. 123 1-16 ICRU 1989 Clinical neutron dosimetry part I: determination of absorbed dose in a patient treated by external beams of fast neutrons ICRU Report 45 (Washington, DC: ICRU) Subramanian T S et al 1983 Double differential inclusive hydrogen and helium spectra from neutron-induced reactions on carbon at 27.4, 39.7 and 60.7 MeV Phys. Rev. C 28 521-8 Subramanian T S et al 1986 Double differential inclusive hydrogen and helium spectra from neutron-induced reactions on carbon at 27.4, 39.7 and 60.7 MeV: oxygen and nitrogen Phys. Rev. C 34 1580-7