Commentary: Aβ N- Terminal Isoforms: Critical contributors in the course of AD pathophysiology

The assessment of protein or amino acid variations across evolution allows one to glean divergent features of disease-specific pathology. Within the Alzheimer's disease (AD) literature, extensive differences in Abeta processing across cell lines and evolution have clearly been observed. In the recent past, increased levels of amyloid beta Abeta1-42 have been heralded to be what distinguishes whether one is prone to the development of AD [59]. However, observations in naturally occurring, non-transgenic animals which display a great deal of parenchymal Abeta1-42 (Abeta found within extracellular plaque deposits) and a complete lack ofbeta1-40 within these same Abeta1-42 plaques raise the issue of whether Abetax-42 (Abeta that is truncated or modified at the N- terminus), rather than Abeta1-42, is instead the critical mediator of Abeta production and pathogenesis [47,49]. Distinct ratios of Abeta N-terminal variants (i.e. Abeta1-x, Abeta3-x, Abeta11-x, beta17-x) have been assessed in human amyloid plaques [18,21,40,41,42,47,48,49,52]. Moreover, ratios of specific Abeta N-terminal variants separate naturally occurring, non-transgenic animals which develop abundant levels of Abetax-42 and not Abetax-40 from human AD participants who harbor plaques that contain both the Abetax-42 and Abetax-40 variants [49]. Next, Teller and colleagues have demonstrated the presence of N-terminal truncated soluble 3kD (likely Abeta17-x) and 3.7kD peptides (in addition to 4kD Abeta) well before the appearance of amyloid plaques in Down Syndrome brain [51], indicating an early contribution of thebeta N-terminus to the formation of amyloid pathology. Additional critical facts concerning the major contribution of the Abeta N-terminus in AD pathogenesis include observations which support thatbeta generated by rodent neurons is predominantly truncated at Abeta11-x [13], the major form of APP C-terminal fragments in mice lacking functional PS1 is AbetaPP11-98 [9], beta11-x expression is increased as a function of BACE expression [55], and an interrelationship between presenilin-1 mutations and increased levels of N-terminally truncatedbeta [40]. This commentary highlights current understanding and potential biochemical, pathological, and cell biological contributions of Abeta N-terminal variants implicated during the course of AD pathogenesis. Although the amyloid beta protein precursor (AbetaPP) gene and Abeta are highly conserved across mammalian species, there are species-specific differences. For instance, the primate, guinea pig, canine, and polar bear share an identical Abeta sequence to that observed in human brain while the rat displays a distinct amino acid sequence with substitutions at residues 5 (Arg), 10 (Tyr), and 13 (His) [24,37]. All of these mammals generate Abeta1-42 via cleavage by at least two enzymes, beta (beta-) secretase and gamma (gamma-) secretase (Fig. 1). The enzyme that liberates the N- terminus of the Abeta peptide ('beta-secretase') is also termed BACE (beta-site AbetaPP cleaving enzyme) [55]. Cathepsin D, which accumulates within AD neurons [15], also cleaves at the N-terminal side of the first aspartate residue of amyloid beta [2].beta-secretase activity is necessary in order to initiate 4kD beta1-x formation by cleaving AbetaPP at the N-terminus and results in the release of a soluble 100kD AbetaPP N- terminal fragment and a 12kD membrane bound C-terminal fragment (C99/C100) [55]. The carboxyl-terminus of the Abetapeptide is liberated through cleavage by the enzyme termed gamma-secretase. In the past, potential AD therapeutic strategies have mainly been geared towards gamma-secretase inhibition. However, such strategies alone no longer appear sound as it is clear that the AbetaPP C99/C100 fragment itself, which requires beta-, but not gamma-, secretase cleavage for generation and includes the entire Abeta peptide, is neurotoxic when evaluated in cultured cells [12,30,34]. Thus, gamma-secretase inhibition alone would not preclude the generation of the neurotoxic C99/C100 fragment.