Spatially heterogeneous trends in nearshore and offshore chlorophyll a concentrations in lakes Michigan and Huron (1998–2013)

Nutrient abatement programmes have been successfully implemented around the globe to reduce nutrient loading into aquatic ecosystems. Concurrently, the worldwide spread of invasive filter feeders, such as dreissenid mussels, may alter nutrient dynamics in invaded systems by sequestering nutrients away from pelagic zones and reducing primary production in offshore areas. Such is the case in the Laurentian Great Lakes of North America, where decades of nutrient abatement and the establishment of dreissenid mussels have seemingly resulted in more oligotrophic conditions and altered spatial patterns of nutrient availability and primary production. Recent studies have focused on whole lake trends in primary production despite spatial differences in tributary inputs, bathymetry, and other environmental conditions that can affect primary production in nearshore areas. Thus, we hypothesised that trends in nearshore chlorophyll concentrations in different areas may diverge in a manner consistent with spatial differences in nutrient input. To evaluate these differences in surface chlorophyll responses, we assessed temporal trends in four different areas of Lake Michigan and three different areas of Lake Huron. We hypothesised that in lakes Huron and Michigan, nearshore zones have experienced slower declines of chlorophyll concentrations relative to offshore zones. To assess this hypothesis, we estimated temporal trends of surface water chlorophyll concentrations (a proxy for primary production) from satellite imagery from 1998 to 2013. We calculated average surface chlorophyll concentrations for 10‐m depth intervals ranging from the shore (0–10 m) to offshore (>90 m) during representative months of May, July, and September. We then analysed these data to determine if long‐term trends in surface chlorophyll varied by season, proximity to the shoreline, and water depth. The rates of annual change in chlorophyll concentrations in nearshore areas were markedly different to offshore trends in both lakes. Chlorophyll concentrations declined overtime in offshore areas, but nearshore chlorophyll concentrations were either stable (in May) or increased (in July and September) throughout the time series. Differences in chlorophyll concentrations among areas were prominent in Lake Michigan. While differences between the northern and southern basin have been previously documented, trends in chlorophyll concentrations also differed between the eastern and western sides of Lake Michigan. Despite similar bathymetry and geographic features to Lake Michigan, regional trends were not observed in Lake Huron. The results of this study are generally consistent with the nearshore shunt hypothesis, which predicts that dreissenid filtering, nutrient re‐suspension, and continued nutrient loading from tributaries can cause an increase in primary production in nearshore areas during periods of offshore oligotrophication. Thus, the localised effects of nutrient abatement programmes in a given lake will be influenced by complex interactions between lake bathymetry and the presence of non‐native filter feeding organisms.