Mobility of nutrients and trace metals during weathering in the late Archean

Abstract The evolution of the geosphere and biosphere depends on the availability of bio-essential nutrients and trace metals. Consequently, the chemical and isotopic variability of trace elements in the sedimentary record have been widely used to infer the existence of early life and fluctuations in the near-surface environment on the early Earth, particularly fluctuations in the redox state of the atmosphere. In this study, we applied late Archean weathering models ( Hao et al., 2017 ), developed to estimate the behavior of major elements and the composition of late Archean world average river water, to explore the behavior of nutrient and trace metals and their potential for riverine transport. We focused on P, Mn, Cr, and Cu during the weathering of olivine basalt. In our standard late Archean weathering model (pCO2,g = 10 − 1.5 bars, pH2,g = 10 − 5.0 bars), crustal apatite was totally dissolved by the acidic rainwater during weathering. Our model quantitatively links the pCO2,g of the atmosphere to phosphate levels transported by rivers. The development of late Archean river water (pH = 6.4) resulted in riverine phosphate of at least 1.7 μmolar, much higher than at the present-day. At the end of the early Proterozoic snowball Earth event when pCO2,g could be 0.01–0.10 bars, river water may have transported up to 70 μmolar phosphate, depending on the availability of apatite, thereby stimulating high levels of oxygenic photosynthesis in the marine environment. Crustal levels of Mn in olivine dissolved completely during weathering, except at large extents of weathering where Mn was stored as a component of a secondary carbonate mineral. The corresponding Mn content of river water, about 1.2 μmolar, is higher than in modern river water. Whiffs of 10 − 5 mole O2 gas or HNO3 kg−1 H2O resulted in the formation of pyrolusite (MnO2) and abundant hematite and simultaneous dramatic decreases in the concentration of Mn(II) in the river water. Chromite dissolution resulted in negligible dissolved Cr in Archean river water. However, amorphous Cr(OH)3 representing easily-weatherable Cr-bearing minerals dissolved totally during the weathering simulations, resulting in concentrations of Cr(III) in the river water of up to 0.14 μmolar, higher than at the present-day. Late Archean weathering of accessory chalcopyrite produced chalcocite and bornite, and extremely low concentrations of Cu ( 10 − 15 molar) because of the low solubilities of the copper sulfides. However, pulses of either O2,g or HNO3 produced native copper, chalcocite, and bornite, much more hematite, and river water containing levels of dissolved Cu comparable to the present-day. Copper mineralogy predicted by weathering models might provide a new correlation with evidence from studies of copper mineral evolution. Overall, our results implied that the redox state of the atmosphere, the pH of surface waters, and the availability of easily-weatherable minerals are all important factors controlling the dissolution of trace elements in river water. Interpretation of the sedimentary signatures of trace elements should consider not only the redox state but also the pH and availability of accessory minerals.