index title username timestamp decision comment topic policies policy_title policy_index
0 758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Botanophobia User:Jayron32 05:07, 27 October 2006 (UTC) delete If it is a real psychological condition, it would warrant coverage in |medical journals. That people talk about it in blogs or forums does not a notable subject make Deletion of Botanophobia WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1 8723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ari Enkin User:Nixie9 19:09, 18 December 2012 (UTC) delete Fails . Inspirational does not equal notable Deletion of Ari Enkin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2 1224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Young (singer) User:Jersey92 20:27, 5 July 2014 (UTC) delete Promotional article. Not sufficiently notable. At best this is and should still be deleted Deletion of Alex Young (singer) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3 4378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mega Society User:Arthur 17:49, 18 July 2006 (UTC) delete I'm a member of Mensa internation|Mensa, and I haven't heard of it. (By the way, Omni (magazine)|Omni is not a |reliable source of anything.) If the information (presently) in the article can be verified by (burden of proof on the article writers, of course; it's difficult to prove a negative), '''Merge''' to High IQ Society. &mdash Deletion of Mega Society WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4 14021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amir Abdollah Tahmasebi User:Kges1901 11:03, 8 June 2018 (UTC) keep Clearly meets since he is covered by RS decades after his death and the amount of information in the English book linked to by The Might Glen is SIGCOV. Additional English sources https://books.google.com/books?id=FzVANM0p29kC&pg=PA231&dq=Amir+Tahmasebi+abdollah&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjen9aX9cPbAhUGW60KHbQWBdkQ6AEINjAC#v=onepage&q=Amir%20Tahmasebi%20abdollah&f=false and https://books.google.com/books?id=3x5dbJpoBD8C&dq=Amir+Tahmasbi&source=gbs_navlinks_s Deletion of Amir Abdollah Tahmasebi WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5 13381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helicopter Parents User:Daniel 02:39, 6 April 2007 (UTC) delete bordering on '''speedy'''. Essay that could never be made into an article or merged with the existing one even in part. Probably copyvio too. Term has wikt:helicopter parent|already been transwikied when I created the article. Absolutely no reason to have this. I would be invoking at this point if I were an admin Deletion of Helicopter Parents WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
6 104 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hacettepe Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi Kullanıcı:nedim gayet birnedim gâyet bir 15.48, 11 Ocak 2022 (UTC) delete """Kısaca şu hususa dikkatleri celbetmek isterim. Her ne kadar Hacettepe Üniversitesi Türkiye'nin öde gelen kıdemli ve önemli üniversitelerinden biri ise de, madde içeriği maalesef ilkokul seviyesinde. Aslında """"içerik"""" de yok. Emin olun, bu koskoca üniversitenin, koskoca fakültesinin internet sitesine baktığınızda da, aynı sığ, yavan, faydasız ve lüzumsuz ifadelerle yüklü olduğunu görebiliriz. Hacettepe Üniversitesi'nin kıdemi ve önemi, bu ve benzeri maddeleri kendiliğinden KD yapmaz, lakin eğitim düzenimizin ve seviyemizin içler acısı hâlini ortaya koyar. Tıpkı Sakarya Üniversitesi ile ilgili maddeler gibi bu madde de henüz |genel kayda değerlik kıstaslarını karşılayamıyor. Yani; kendisinden bağımsız, önemli, güvenilir, birden çok ikincil kaynaklarca içerik edilmiş veya kapsanmış değil. Silinsin""" Hacettepe Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
7 20574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Neddeaus of Duqesne Island User:Bearcat 00:45, 1 July 2017 (UTC) delete """Well, for what it's worth, this actually ''is'' a real thing — Bearcat the Canuck can slide right past the geoblock, and is currently listening to Colin Mochrie talking about potatoes — but Powerenwiki was right to restub it nonetheless: what it ''is'', is a new ''mockumentary'' web series that's ''pretending'' to be a """"lost documentary film"""" from the 1970s. (And if you don't believe me, consider that it's got Colin Mochrie, who didn't start acting until 1980, and Cara Gee, who wasn't even ''born'' until 1983, in it.) But I can find exactly ''zero'' |reliable source coverage about it besides glancing namechecks of its existence in coverage of the CBC's forthcoming digital OTT service CBCX, and web series are ''not'' granted an automatic presumption of notability per just for existing. So no prejudice against recreation in the future ''if'' the reliable sourcing beefs up and/or it gets a Canadian Screen Award nomination next January for """"Original Digital Program or Series, Fiction"""" — but nothing here as of right now is enough, and even if it does amass a stronger notability claim in the future the article will still have to be written ''honestly''. Next step: running the detector across Ford Francis Mayflower, the purported director of the 1970s documentary film that this never really was. Stay tuned""" Deletion of The Neddeaus of Duqesne Island WP:RS||WP:TVSHOW||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8 4849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Sharmila Banu User:Jersey92 17:49, 20 July 2014 (UTC) delete Easily fails . Also fails and . Delete Deletion of Death of Sharmila Banu WP:NOTABILITY||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
9 7051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Democratic Party presidential primaries, 2016 User:Uzma 15:28, 19 September 2012 (UTC) delete """Speculation by reliable sources can meet Wikipedia:Verifiability since that policy only means that people reading and editing the encyclopedia can check that information, speculation or otherwise, comes from a reliable source. However, the problem at this point in time is noted in : """"some sources may be considered reliable for statements as to their author's opinion, but not for statements asserted as fact without an inline qualifier."""" There may be things to say about this topic with inline qualifiers, but there is not enought encyclipedic things to say about this topic yet""" Deletion of Democratic Party presidential primaries, 2016 WP:RSOPINION Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10 156 [[Herbert Fries]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Nimro NONE delete Der gesamte Artikel ist eine Aneinanderreihung von |TF und mit Ausnahme des Verleigungsdatums zum Ritterkreuz sowie einer Traueranzeige seit Januar 2015!! völlig unbelegt. Weder das Ritterkreuz noch ein Einzeiler im Wehrmachtbericht zu der Person Fries generieren eine Relevanz. Da nicht zu erwarten ist, dass der Artikel mit reputabler Literatur belegt werden kann, bleibt nur eine Löschung von Herbert Fries Wikipedia:Keine Theoriefindung Wikipedia:No original research 65
11 7172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles David Kelley (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 17:10, 20 November 2019 (UTC) delete per , , , and . This is basically a hagiography of a |living person that is written plainly to spread his religious work. Wikipedia is a private, non-sectarian charity, not a Christian version of LinkedIn or Indeed. There's nothing he's done that |even approaches general notability. The award of Order of the Three Stars does not automatically confer notability, and being a republic, an award from Latvia can not be the same as a knighthood. Even if the subject were notable, this is so poorly written and formatted that it would have to be completely re-written to be an encyclopedic article Deletion of Charles David Kelley (2nd nomination) WP:NOTRESUME||WP:SOAP||WP:GNG||WP:TNT||WP:BLP||WP:BARE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12 13404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kiran Jassal User:Northamerica1000 04:18, 1 September 2016 (UTC) merge to Miss Universe Malaysia 2016 as a valid search term, and the subject is mentioned there. Coverage is mostly about her winning the pageant, so is evident Deletion of Kiran Jassal WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13 10238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/QStik Records (2nd nomination) [[User talk:Orderinchaos|Orderinchaos]] 21:10, 26 September 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Lack of independent sources - nearly all sources are primary - which is a problem under . This debate's already been had Deletion of QStik Records (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14 18310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Choosing Death: The Improbable History of Death Metal & Grindcore User:Cunard 04:12, 5 April 2009 (UTC) keep per http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Choosing+Death%22+Mudrian&cf=all this Google News Archive search. The book passes the |general notability guidelines. http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-14718250_ITM Here is a review written by Mike Tribby for the American Library Association. http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-14356353_ITM This article (from Publishers Weekly) is another review of the book. The book has also been http://books.google.com/books?q=%22Choosing%20Death%22%20Mudrian&hl=en&ned=us&um=1&sa=N&tab=np cited by 4 authors Deletion of Choosing Death: The Improbable History of Death Metal & Grindcore WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15 20669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IEEE GIKI Chapter User:Sarahj2107 14:50, 19 June 2013 (UTC) delete fails and . Its just a student branch of a local section of an organisation and is not notable in its own right. Its also poorly sourced and written in a promotional tone Deletion of IEEE GIKI Chapter WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16 18700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hot coil challenge User:Wumbolo 12:04, 21 July 2018 (UTC) delete no Deletion of Hot coil challenge WP:CONTINUEDCOVERAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17 8198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chiu Yang Por Yen Primary School User:Ansh666 01:52, 6 June 2014 (UTC) merge per and, well, how it is right now Deletion of Chiu Yang Por Yen Primary School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18 9098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St Peters, Leicester, Leicestershire User:Nsk92 03:26, 24 May 2008 (UTC) delete In the current state unsalvageable. No sources, filled with |OR and terribly written. Moreover, the subject is very poorly indentified. Are they talking about a city neighborhood? If yes, why is it notable Deletion of St Peters, Leicester, Leicestershire WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19 3788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isra Hirsi User:SoWhy 12:07, 22 January 2020 (UTC) keep WP:NOTINHERITED is in itself not a valid reason for deletion. Failing would be but in this case, the subject seems to have attracted sufficient coverage to pass or at least . Does she receive a lot of coverage mainly because of who her mother is? Most likely. But it's not our job to chastise reliable sources for ''why'' they cover a subject as long as they do cover it substantially. In addition to the coverage already mentioned, there is also https://www.theroot.com/how-ilhan-omars-daughter-isra-hirsi-is-connecting-the-f-1838282035 The Root, https://www.jacobinmag.com/2019/05/youth-climate-strike-isra-hirsi Jacobin, https://www.thewrap.com/16-year-old-climate-and-racial-justice-advocate-isra-hirsi-to-be-honored-as-voice-of-the-future/ The Wrap, https://www.thecut.com/2019/03/ilhan-omars-daughter-is-leading-the-youth-climate-strike.html New York's The Cut and even https://weather.com/en-CA/international/videos/video/meet-isra-hirsi-americas-youth-climate-activist The Weather Channel for example. That appears to be sufficient to meet the bar of both GNG and BASIC. Regards Deletion of Isra Hirsi WP:GNG||WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20 5788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Debra Davenport User:Edwardx 15:01, 1 September 2018 (UTC) delete Fails . Even if notable, this puff piece would be a definite case of Deletion of Debra Davenport WP:GNG||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21 2359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Connections between 24 and La Femme Nikita User:TenPoundHammer 00:58, 17 May 2007 (UTC) delete I agree, this is pure and trivia. It's like the similarities between Abraham Lincoln and John F. Kennedy. (Did you know that their last names both had seven letters? Neither did I Deletion of Connections between 24 and La Femme Nikita WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22 4562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liza Koshy (actress) User:Gongshow 01:49, 15 September 2017 (UTC) keep Subject's roles meet , and sufficient coverage exists (e.g., Variety, Hollywood Reporter, LA Times) to satisfy Deletion of Liza Koshy (actress) WP:ENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
23 5062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lyle Center for Regenerative Studies [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] 22:45, 12 December 2012 (UTC) delete Fails notability Deletion of Lyle Center for Regenerative Studies WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
24 7465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alliv Samson User:Gongshow 05:38, 6 February 2013 (UTC) delete per nom; I'm not finding coverage in reliable sources for this person, either. She does not appear to meet at this time Deletion of Alliv Samson WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
25 9274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BMRB Ltd User:Septrillion 23:22, 6 July 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and . \\\Septrillion Deletion of BMRB Ltd WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
26 3283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GameRatio User:Rankiri 13:55, 1 April 2010 (UTC) delete I couldn't find any coverage either Deletion of GameRatio WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
27 19998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juzaerul Jasmi User:GiantSnowman 13:20, 27 March 2019 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Juzaerul Jasmi WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
28 5821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of 40-plus point games by Michael Jordan User:Darth 15:17, 26 April 2019 (UTC) comment We don't keep articles purely because Deletion of List of 40-plus point games by Michael Jordan WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
29 3729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scavengers (video game) User:Charmanderblue 16:18, 4 May 2020 (UTC) delete Neither the game nor its developer pass notability requirements. Barely any coverage on the internet beyond promotional videos/articles. Clear-cut case of Deletion of Scavengers (video game) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
30 11315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MS Paint Adventures [[User talk:64.5.15.112|talk]]) — [[Special:Contributions/64.5.15.112|64.5.15.112]] ([[User talk:64.5.15.112|talk]]) has made [[Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|few or no other edits]] outside this topic. 22:53, 17 December 2009 (UTC) keep """I'm sorry, but using Google News as a notability criteria? I'm with Oni Lukos here. There is ''no reason'' why a system unlikely to cover items that are not """"newsworthy"""" (i.e. non-political webcomics, etc) should be used to determine """"notability"""". And according to , Google News is not ''specifically'' indicated as a notability criteria. The article may still be non-notable for other reasons, assuming the above mentioned blog sources do not qualify as reliable sources, but I personally am getting a strong anti-MS Paint Adventures vibe from this AfD nomination. --Special:Contributions/64.5.15.112|64.5.15.112""" Deletion of MS Paint Adventures WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
31 20644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blame Game (song) User:Mattg82 00:40, 23 November 2011 (UTC) delete Does not pass Deletion of Blame Game (song) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
32 11064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Foxhall A. Parker Sr. User:Beccaynr 01:15, 23 April 2021 (UTC) keep per , due to the multiple independent and reliable sources now in the article, and #3, he has an entry in the ''Encyclopedia of Virginia Biography Deletion of Foxhall A. Parker Sr. WP:HEY||WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
33 19917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gay and lesbian retirement [[User talk:Benjiboi|Benjiboi]] 22:35, 15 October 2007 (UTC) keep That's 14 refs added so far and no reason to believe that any effort won't quickly produce more. Subject is certainly notable and sources easily found. Article simply needs ''improving through regular editing'' per fD Deletion of Gay and lesbian retirement WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
34 13393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stanley A. Klein User:David 17:53, 23 April 2009 (UTC) keep I'm not seeing the argument for the other criteria of , but (picking out the vision-related papers from Google scholar) he seems to be co-author on six papers with over 100 citations each; that's enough to convince me that he passes criterion #1 Deletion of Stanley A. Klein WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
35 13452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All Tomorrow's Parties (music festival) User:Michig 20:10, 7 September 2010 (UTC) keep Nomination rationale is basically that this is unsourced, which would have taken care of Deletion of All Tomorrow's Parties (music festival) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
36 17977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crossover Comic Archive User:Dragonfiend 04:32, 16 June 2006 (UTC) delete no eliable sources, does not meet Deletion of Crossover Comic Archive WP:R||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Redirect 56
37 2253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melisse User:Shawnpoo 16:51, 8 March 2009 (UTC) delete per #A7|CSD A7 and per Deletion of Melisse WP:CSD||WP:N Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
38 8182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norfolk Island national football team User:SunStar 11:23, 27 October 2006 (UTC) delete WP:HOAX is most probable. I haven't found any evidence from |reliable sources. That's my take on it Deletion of Norfolk Island national football team WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
39 4669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bottle knife User:WilyD 14:15, 30 August 2006 (UTC) delete Neologism that fails ... my Grandmother used to call these something else Deletion of Bottle knife WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
40 18858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heritage (1966 film) User:DARTH 14:05, 20 December 2010 (UTC) delete per nom, fails Deletion of Heritage (1966 film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
41 17062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Hall (animator) User:Tohd8BohaithuGh1 19:15, 24 October 2008 (UTC) delete as an #A1|article with little or no context Deletion of Jeff Hall (animator) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
42 19029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Democratic backsliding User:E 17:05, 10 September 2017 (UTC) delete """I revisited, making time to read more of the books and journal articles. Most of the hits on this term fail to support notability or meet because they merely use two common, English words in their commonly understood sense in the course of discussion the failure or perceived threat of failure of specific democratic institutions due to a variety of proposed causes. Also, the article in ''Democracy Digest'' is a mere report of the Huq & Gisburg article in Vox; even though it is used as though it was a 2nd, independent source to support the POV of this phenomenon taken by this brief page. The only 2 sources we have offering of this term as a term are Bormeo and Huq & Gisburg. (ping me if you find more) That's not a lot on which to base a article. So here is Bormeo (2016) on the history and definition of this term: ''""""The term democratic backsliding is frequently used but rarely analyzed. This explains why a careful recent survey concluded “we know very little” about it. Part of the problem is the term’s extraordinary breadth. At its most basic, it denotes the state-led debilitation or elimination of any of the political institutions that sustain an existing democracy. Since the political institutions that sustain democracy are myriad (including all the institutions that enable people to formulate and signify preferences and then have them weighed by their elected representatives), the term embraces multiple processes. Since the state actors who might initiate backsliding are themselves diverse (ranging from monarchs to presidents to military men), the term embraces multiple agents. Insum, the concept has so many referents that it needs immediate specification to have practical meaning. Like an old steamer trunk, it is opaque and unwieldy but yields much that proves useful when it is unpacked.""""'' Boromeo then goes on to list 6 types of democratic backsliding: classic coups d’état; executive coups; election day vote fraud; promissory coups (essentially, running on a restore-democracy platform;) Executive aggrandizement; and Manipulating elections strategically. This page, unfortunately, is written as though Huq & Gisburg definiton was a consensus view of this topic, when, in fact, it presents a particular concept quite different form that presented by Bormeo. This is problematic, but it could be improved by editing. However, the reason I am arguing for deletion is that there is too little serious analysis of this two-word-phrase as a term of art to pass . ''Democratic backsliding'' is, at present, a simple juxtaposition of common English words used ot describe a range of phenomena. Like republican virtue, or a good mother it fails because and sources do not support the proposition that """"democratic backsliding' is a term of art with a specific meaning or set of meanings like deliberative democracy or democratic socialism""" Deletion of Democratic backsliding WP:NEO||WP:SIGCOV||WP:NEO||WP:NEO||WP:NOTDICTIONARY Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
43 1722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deltopia User:GauchoDude 16:16, 1 February 2017 (UTC) keep Not sure this AfD has been formatted correctly, {{Ping|Quidster4040}} as it's not appearing on the Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2017 February 1|daily log. In any event, if this is a true AfD nomination, I vote for keep. Anyone with a basic knowledge of Google search will turn up result after result of both local and national coverage. In a quick, 2 second search, I found sourcing from http://www.dailymail.co.uk/wires/ap/article-2598223/Huge-California-party-spirals-violent-clash.html Daily Mail UK, http://www.foxnews.com/us/2010/04/07/authorities-plan-sink-santa-barbaras-floatopia.html Fox News, http://cnn.com/2014/04/06/us/california-street-party-melee/ CNN, http://www.ibtimes.com/deltopia-party-devolves-massive-student-riot-santa-barbara-calif-100-arrested-1567979 International Business Times, http://www.complex.com/pop-culture/2014/04/beach-party-riot-deltopia Complex magazine, http://gawker.com/southern-california-beach-party-ended-in-a-giant-street-1559641832 Gawker, http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/fla-officials-vow-floatopia-massive-beach-mess-article-1.2606275 NY Daily News, http://articles.latimes.com/2010/apr/07/local/la-me-floatopia7-2010apr07 Los Angeles Times, http://www.miaminewtimes.com/news/floatopia-trashed-miami-beach-just-like-everywhere-else-it-has-been-held-8396897 Miami New Times, and of course more local flavors such as http://www.independent.com/news/2009/apr/09/isla-vistas-floatopia-fiasco/ Santa Barbara Independent and http://www.keyt.com/news/local-news/isla-vista-beach-closures-announced-for-deltopia-event/65205684 KEYT. Easily passes Deletion of Deltopia WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
44 2123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ninaro User:Kudpung 07:05, 19 July 2014 (UTC) comment Keep. Private, but there are plenty of private establishments providing mainstream education to A-Level. That its web site is on a free web host is not a concern of ours, not should we be overly concerned about the lack of Internet sources for a school in Sri Lanka. The article is informative and not promotional. Spam links can be contained by regular maintenance users. We have a long-standing precedent for keeping secondary schools as reported at Deletion of Ninaro WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
45 2388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Velvet Abstract User:The 16:35, 25 August 2006 (UTC) delete No |notablitiy, and fails Deletion of The Velvet Abstract WP:NN||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
46 16859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twenty20 Stock Photos User:Northamerica1000 17:31, 10 June 2016 (UTC) keep Per a review of |available sources, such as those posted above by {{u|NinjaRobotPirate}}, the company passes . Additional sources are available in searches under the former company name, as denoted below Deletion of Twenty20 Stock Photos WP:NEXIST||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
47 15535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas (Tommy) Tucker User:Toon05 01:38, 31 January 2009 (UTC) delete as unreferenced and seemingly failing . Probably hoax; if this person was actually notable, there'd be an article on him, and some sources to back it up Deletion of Thomas (Tommy) Tucker WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
48 19243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karen Jessica Evans User:SportingFlyer 07:09, 8 June 2018 (UTC) delete I went through the source-bombs. She gets a couple mentions in articles and books here and there, but fails Deletion of Karen Jessica Evans WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
49 18780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyrell McCrea User:SportingFlyer 01:26, 5 December 2019 (UTC) delete fails /. Next to nothing in a search apart from an afl2 game mention Deletion of Tyrell McCrea WP:GNG||WP:GRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
50 20648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Fernanda Londoño [[User talk:Czar|czar]] 19:10, 29 June 2017 (UTC) delete Coverage listed is either Wikipedia:Verifiability#Reliable sources|unreliable, local, or firsthand/primary. Lacks |significant coverage in ''reliable'' sources. Note that the only keep arguments are from SPAs and not based in policy Deletion of Maria Fernanda Londoño WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
51 1610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mahadeva Sambasivan User:Radagast3 23:40, 5 March 2010 (UTC) delete fails due to lack of sources. This person probably '''is''' notable, but the article in its present state is too flawed. There '''was''' a former Vice Principal of that name at Thiruvananthapuram Medical College,http://www.govtmedicalcollegetvm.net/html/Old%20Vice%20Principals.htm and he was a professor there.http://www.thehindu.com/2009/07/02/stories/2009070254710700.htm The bulk of the article is a list of publications, which are not necessarily all by the same person (the 1964 article seems to be by a paediatrician of the same name). I would support a better (properly sourced) article on this person Deletion of Mahadeva Sambasivan WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
52 2178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Williamson's Chapel United Methodist Church User:TimBuck2 16:31, 5 November 2018 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage in independent reliable sources. Fails to meet Deletion of Williamson's Chapel United Methodist Church WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
53 11580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RFX Interactive User:Piotrus 13:16, 8 January 2020 (UTC) delete Nothing here but like content Deletion of RFX Interactive WP:NOTYELLOWPAGES Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
54 19543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Frank Decker User:MER 05:22, 23 December 2006 (UTC) delete WP:AUTO|autobiography of a |non-notable person Deletion of William Frank Decker WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
55 16922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nokia Normandy NONE NONE keep Based on the same reasoning as described by {{u|RaviC}}. Additionally, the above mentioned guideline states this: ''It is appropriate to report discussion and arguments about the prospects for success of future proposals and projects or whether some development will occur, if discussion is properly referenced.'' Obviously, this article contains more than enough good references Deletion of Nokia Normandy WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
56 11286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TBA (Britney Spears album) User:Danski14 22:37, 9 September 2010 (UTC) delete """per . TBA = """"To Be Announced"""". Not even the name is known right now""" Deletion of TBA (Britney Spears album) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
57 12312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The sims 2 store User:MuZemike 18:52, 16 August 2008 (UTC) keep and do a merger proposal per instead Deletion of The sims 2 store WP:MERGE Wikipedia:Merging 54
58 2155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phillip King (tennis) User:Smartyllama 13:10, 25 July 2017 (UTC) comment At the very least, this page should be redirected to Vania King, as with many other non-notable sportspeople related to notable sports people, including Tate Matheny, Tyler Nevin, Ryan Ripken, Mariano Rivera III, Casey Fitzgerald (ice hockey), and Joseph LaMotta, the last two of which were explicitly closed as redirect at AfD. As I said above, I think he's notable, but if consensus is that he's not, the article should at the very least be redirected as an |alternative to deletion. Pinging {{u|Johnpacklambert}} and {{u|Tvx1}}, the only two delete !votes at this point, to see if they would support a redirect instead given this context Deletion of Phillip King (tennis) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
59 21562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zuan Xin User:Vianello 04:42, 11 April 2014 (UTC) delete Article text does not assert any specific claims meeting criteria, nor do sources more than confirm the bare facts given Deletion of Zuan Xin WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
60 2310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JUST EAT India User:Northamerica1000 05:47, 7 December 2013 (UTC) comment Per , perhaps a merge to Just-Eat should occur, rather than blanket deletion of the content Deletion of JUST EAT India WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
61 14194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ybarra Elementary School User:Dennisthe2 02:41, 2 April 2007 (UTC) delete A school is subject to the exact same |notability guidelines as anything else here on WP. Jerry, note that this article has been around for just about three months - it could have been expanded in that time. As an aside, the article is badly written - though, that's not a criteria for deletion unto itself, it's a criteria for cleanup Deletion of Ybarra Elementary School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
62 4466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malice Engineering User:JohnCD 08:38, 16 May 2012 (UTC) delete this term may take off, but it doesn't yet satisfy Deletion of Malice Engineering WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
63 16549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019 Gabriola Island crash User:TheSandDoctor 21:54, 12 December 2019 (UTC) keep Per coffee, I believe this AfD also to be premature. The article has significant coverage from enough |reliable sources to confer |notability. While it ''is'' true that plane crashes are common and do get local coverage, it is not very often that they get coverage from across the nation (Toronto etc) and internationally...on the other side of the continent - some 4900km away - in ''The New York Times'' within 24 hours, nonetheless. The NYT doesn't normally write about small plane crashes in another country. Combine this with the fact that The Canadian Press (Canada's version of the Associated Press) started covering this within 4 hours, it reinforces my initial assessment that the notability requirements were met. I will note, to the benefit of WilliamJE, that ''The New York Times'' had not yet published its article on this at the time of nomination Deletion of 2019 Gabriola Island crash WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
64 351 [[Alternative PHP Cache]] (bleibt) Benutzer:M-J NONE keep Gemäß mediale Beachtung erfolderlich. Diese geht nicht aus dem Artikel hervor, demzufolge Löschung von Alternative PHP Cache Wikipedia:RSW Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
65 20495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lawrence J. Prelli User:Neurolysis 11:10, 26 October 2008 (UTC) keep Meets . &mdash Deletion of Lawrence J. Prelli WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
66 1423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of burn centers in the United States (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 17:02, 18 March 2014 (UTC) keep per doncram. Rather than being |run of the mill common, burn-center hospitals are rare, and mentioned commonly and prominently in the news media, so |significant coverage is readily available. Having a |list here would be helpful for our users to research and navigate, compared to a category Deletion of List of burn centers in the United States (2nd nomination) WP:MILL||WP:SIGCOV||WP:LIST Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
67 21023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Airlines Flight 1572 (2nd nomination) User:Jguy 13:27, 17 June 2013 (UTC) keep I'm not sure why some are thinking this does not pass . ''Significant Coverage''? Check. ''Reliable Sources''? Not in the article, but the NTSB investigation is there, that seems reliable enough for me. Just needs improvement and expansion on what's there. See . ''Sources independant of the subject''? Again I point to the NTSB investigation as a source in this article. Just because there were no major injuries/deaths and no hull loss does not mean this article fails . Do keep in mind that is '''not''' a Wikipedia policy, but merely a guideline for editors as part of the WikiProject for Aviation Deletion of American Airlines Flight 1572 (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:PRESERVE||WP:N||WP:AIRCRASH Wikipedia:Notability 77
68 21935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crap cd User:Yamla 23:36, 7 August 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Crap cd WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
69 880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Newtown Hardware House User:Reywas92 00:46, 10 July 2020 (UTC) merge to Newtown Historic District (Newtown, Pennsylvania). Several buildings there, and some routine local news doesn't give it notability beyond that of the district as a whole Deletion of Newtown Hardware House WP:ITSOLD Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
70 10704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tórshavn derby User:JMHamo 21:45, 14 March 2014 (UTC) delete I can not find wider coverage on this rivalry, so it fails Deletion of Tórshavn derby WP:NRIVALRY Wikipedia:Notability 77
71 6773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rudolf Christmann User:Canadian 17:56, 22 January 2016 (UTC) delete as failing based on a complete lack of non-trivial, reliable, third-party sources. Legacypac's comment above suggests strongly that this inability to find sources is based on their nonexistence, rather than some fault in our searching abilities Deletion of Rudolf Christmann WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
72 6639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Duscher User:Lankiveil 09:53, 1 May 2013 (UTC) delete doesn't seem to meet any of the notability criteria for Aussie Rules players Deletion of Ben Duscher WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
73 84 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neo Financial User:Schazjmd 00:04, 17 April 2020 (UTC) delete All I can find is a flurry of press releases and interviews. Not |notable yet, maybe just Deletion of Neo Financial WP:NCORP||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
74 13131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Everybody Draw Mohammad Day User:Therefore 05:20, 3 May 2010 (UTC) keep given the growing number of reliable sources of high quality, the ongoing improvements to the article and the exponential increase in page views. Given that there is a near zero chance this article will be deleted (now -- possibly may be AFD'd later if it peters out), I'd vote for closing this AFD early per so that we can remove the AFD litter tag in the article Deletion of Everybody Draw Mohammad Day WP:SNOWBALL Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
75 11908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tawhid Afridi User:E 18:02, 14 May 2019 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON for this young actor, Youtuber, who fails Deletion of Tawhid Afridi WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
76 181 [[Roy Robson]] (LAE) Benutzer:Tom_md NONE delete Gelbe-Seiten-Eintrag ohne Relevanz nach #U Löschung von Roy Robson Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
77 6865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How to write a great speech User:Cquan 22:06, 4 June 2007 (UTC) delete per |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information, unsourced, unsalvagably unencyclopedic topic Deletion of How to write a great speech WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
78 6390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jose Maria Tome User:Mdtemp 19:48, 27 January 2014 (UTC) delete He was just released from the UFC, so a third top tier fight isn't likely soon. Fails , but article can be recreated if he gets a third top tier fight Deletion of Jose Maria Tome WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
79 17794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eve Carson User:RevenantPrime 21:12, 10 March 2008 (UTC) comment I would like to point out that I think the massive media attention garnered by this case, and the fact that , we shouldn't be worried about giving a few kilobytes of space here. I don't think this page should be a full fledged biography commemorating her every action, but a simple description of the murder is notable Deletion of Eve Carson WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
80 21067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monkeypig User:Esradekan 01:20, 10 July 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of Monkeypig WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
81 2263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Florida Black Racer User:Carolfrog 00:31, 21 March 2007 (UTC) merge with Coluber constrictor priapus (which is even more stubby than this one) and '''redirect'''. It appears not to be a hoax; however, it needs more sources to comply with . Sources are almost certainly available, and editors should work to find them. This article should not be deleted at this time. If sources are not forthcoming, the deletion issue can be revisited in a few months Deletion of Florida Black Racer WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
82 356 [[Rufnummernmitnahme]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Cae NONE keep Lemma . Der Einleitungsabschnitt kann '''behalten''' werden, im etwas ausschweifenden und -lastigen Teil über Geschichte eventuell '''kürzen Löschung von Rufnummernmitnahme Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
83 282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Binary Report User:Bobet 02:56, 21 December 2005 (UTC) keep based on reading the first paragraph until its very end. Getting mainstream media attention (which google seems to verify and it's mentioned in the Katelyn Faber article here too) qualifies it per Deletion of Binary Report WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
84 16979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Estonia–Tunisia relations (2nd nomination) User:Edison 03:55, 6 June 2009 (UTC) delete per Drawn Some and general failure to satisfy |notability of the particular bilateral relationship Deletion of Estonia–Tunisia relations (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
85 8314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Central Valley Project Water Association User:Bearian 17:10, 18 February 2020 (UTC) delete WP:MILL|run of the mill riparian rights organization. |We are not a web-host to list every real property organization or community association. A one-line selective merger would be the most a reasonable admin could do Deletion of Central Valley Project Water Association WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
86 9490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Snork (musical) User:Slp1 21:33, 16 March 2007 (UTC) delete non- Deletion of Snork (musical) WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
87 12113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Freedows OS (2nd nomination) User:Alan 04:05, 5 January 2013 (UTC) delete per nom and to incrementally reduce the |systemic bias in WP Deletion of Freedows OS (2nd nomination) WP:CSB Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
88 18649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Best of Times (TV pilot) User:Donaldd23 22:15, 1 July 2020 (UTC) comment """Your statement of """"one day of coverage isn't significant"""" is ludicrous. How many Made for TV films have articles and the film was only shown once? Those films usually only have """"one day of coverage"""" too. Should they be eliminated? How about films released direct to video? They are reviewed when released and then never mentioned again, thereby qualifying for your """"one day of coverage"""". Should they be eliminated? No. """"One day of coverage"""" isn't mentioned anywhere. The '''number''' of significant reviews qualifies something for notability...and this TV pilot meets that coverage. This is definitely a prime example of """ Deletion of The Best of Times (TV pilot) WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
89 12653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Homo perfectus User:RGTraynor 20:35, 22 June 2007 (UTC) delete There are only '''five''' unique Google hits for the self-published book from which this fictional race comes. This has got to be in the month's Top Ten for non-notability. Also a hint of , as the external links push the book Deletion of Homo perfectus WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
90 16772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ideological bias on Wikipedia user:MrX 22:46, 27 May 2018 (UTC) delete """The article consists of content that should be covered in existing articles and content that should not be covered anywhere in an encyclopedia. I agree with others that it is a classic , and a bit of a as well. I do appreciate the unintended humor in this gem: {{tq|""""The authors identified party and ideological affiliation using """"userboxes"""" which some Wikipedians place on their user pages.""""}}. If that is an example of what passes as scholarly research these days, then I weep for academia""" Deletion of Ideological bias on Wikipedia WP:POVFORK||WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
91 137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Molly Garnier User:E 21:03, 29 October 2018 (UTC) delete as . the page has very little, although there was an accolade in the 2003 Scotsman article for her work in the art school graduation show. lacks profiles and museum shows. The other thing I am seeing is some praise for her work on group and gallery shows the Eastern Daily Press, Norwich, so it's local Deletion of Molly Garnier WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
92 14486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comanche Stallion (2nd nomination) User:AnmaFinotera 19:28, 1 March 2009 (UTC) delete """per Metropolitan90 fairly exhaustive research and . It seems like this film was never created or even really entered production. It seems like it was nothing more than an unrealized idea. Even the """"official"""" site is sketchy and doesn't look like it is even a legitimate official site, though it is registered to """"7th Voyage Productions"""" whoever they are""" Deletion of Comanche Stallion (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
93 3404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dough Related Productions User:Duffbeerforme 03:40, 10 July 2019 (UTC) delete Non |notable vanity label for non notable artist. lacks coverage in independent reliable sources. Label does not inherit notability from an artist appearing on the ARIA charts (a claim not backed up). Claims multiple other artists with pages but article only lists one, the founder who shall be going to afd. Label is not notable because |other bad articles exist Deletion of Dough Related Productions WP:NCORP||WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
94 9929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sophie Trollope User:Agricola44 21:25, 27 October 2009 (UTC) delete """I'm afraid this is nothing more than a fan-page. Her http://www.wolfpark.org/Sophie/index.html webpage indicates she's properly considered as an activist rather than a behaviour expert / researcher / zoologist, etc. (Her quals are that she's a primary school teacher and evidently completed a 4-day """"wolf behavior course"""" in 1998.) So, I don't think there's much we could even discuss regarding . Indeed, the wide net of GS http://scholar.google.com/scholar?&q=%22Sophie+Trollope%22 turns up not a single hit, http://books.google.com/books?&as_brr=0&as_pub=-icon&q=%22Sophie+Trollope%22 no books, etc. The listed achievements, e.g. """"the first woman from South Africa to visit Wolf Park"""" and the 4-day seminar, lend no significance whatsoever. http://www.iol.co.za/index.php?click_id=139&art_id=vn20040213034907199C455536& One source is listed, a short article in a local paper, but this appears to be a feel-good puff piece. For example, that article paints her as an established researcher, which she clearly is not, with statements like """"Following her second visit to Wolf Park in 2002, Trollope came back more determined to finish her research on wolf-dogs"""". Plain googling doesn't turn up much else besides the epxected facebook/myspace/posting type hits. There simply isn't anything notable to speak of. Respectfully""" Deletion of Sophie Trollope WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
95 13806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rififi (2009 film) User:Mayalld 10:16, 9 August 2008 (UTC) delete per , films which have not yet commenced principal photography should not have articles Deletion of Rififi (2009 film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
96 7006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hal Waller User:Sandstein 14:03, 1 April 2006 (UTC) delete obviously fails the proposed Deletion of Hal Waller WP:PROFTEST Wikipedia:Notability 77
97 15393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kosh Agarwal [[User talk:70.80.234.196|talk]]) 01:43, 4 January 2011 (UTC) delete I count 2 articles with more than 100 cites. Not bad, but if that was sufficient to pass almost all my profs in grad school would deserve their Wiki article.--Special:Contributions/70.80.234.196|70.80.234.196 Deletion of Kosh Agarwal WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
98 19219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Franky Zapata (2nd nomination) User:Puzzledvegetable 21:11, 25 July 2019 (UTC) keep The article can use a few more references, but nominating for deletion is not a replacement for adding a {{more references needed}}. Also conforms to as this person is quite notable Deletion of Franky Zapata (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
99 9337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GetFLV User:DustFormsWords 03:51, 19 November 2009 (UTC) delete Software is not inherently notable, and product listings and capsule reviews don't count towards notability here any more than they do with self-published books and direct-to-DVD movies. Nothing here establishes this software as anything other than |run of the mill or meets the notability guidelines at Deletion of GetFLV WP:MILL||WP:N Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
100 2855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bulgaria–Sudan relations User:WilyD 16:01, 20 April 2009 (UTC) keep easily exceeds the standard set by , and I see no reason this article needs a higher irregular treatment. See http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=NewsLibrary&p_multi=BBAB&d_place=BBAB&p_theme=newslibrary2&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F9782D778E3D9B9&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePMhttp://news.google.com/newspapers?id=uvENAAAAIBAJ&sjid=3XUDAAAAIBAJ&pg=3001,2351934&dq=bulgaria+sudan+relationshttp://select.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=F30812F8395C1A7493C1A91783D85F458785F9http://www.sofiaecho.com/article/diplomatic-dispatches-the-sudanese-ambassador-discusses-relations-between-bulgaria-and-the-largest-country-in-africa/id_7327/catid_30http://www.novinite.com/view_news.php?id=27164http://select.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=F50B16F83F591A728DDDA90B94D8415B818AF1D3http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=NewsLibrary&p_multi=BBAB&d_place=BBAB&p_theme=newslibrary2&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F9782CC2FC9E496&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePMhttp://www.sofiaecho.com/article/economy-briefs/id_10898/catid_23http://select.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=F20E17F8395C1A7493C0A91783D85F458785F9 Deletion of Bulgaria–Sudan relations WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
101 12673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Turbo Sliders User:Videogameplayer99 22:39, 7 November 2018 (UTC) delete article seems to fail Deletion of Turbo Sliders WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
102 17566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vanessa Bluee User:Redrose64 17:40, 9 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Vanessa Bluee WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
103 3319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ilan Manulis User:Pan 18:54, 10 October 2006 (UTC) delete I doubt he passes . Using Google, I can't |verify (though maybe others can) the claim that he's got an asteroid named after him. Wouldn't say he's achieved fame or notoriety even if an asteroid was named after him. Google and Lexis-Nexis suggest he's not the primary subject of multiple non-trivial publications. As for the Israeli Astronomical Association, with http://www.google.com/search?q=%22israeli+astronomical+association%22&hl=en&lr=&start=180&sa=N 178 unique ghits, no results on Lexis-Nexis, and its http://www.astronomy.org.il/nuke2/modules.php?name=News English website being down, I'd say that the association, and especially its past president, is probably not notable. The bottom line, though, is that unless someone can come up with references, the article has to be deleted per Deletion of Ilan Manulis WP:BIO||WP:V||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
104 6722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Human Meta-Human Vampiric Virus (2nd nomination) User:Sgeureka 09:18, 8 April 2012 (UTC) delete to Shadowrun. No outside that fictional universe and nothing to preserve. There are http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special%3AWhatLinksHere&target=Human+Meta-Human+Vampiric+Virus&namespace=0 hardly any articles linking to it to demand preserving a redirect, but a redirect won't really do any harm either. &ndash Deletion of Human Meta-Human Vampiric Virus (2nd nomination) WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
105 16465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taylor Barada User:Jasonakagary88 13:52, 11 August 2019 (UTC) keep Subject does meet point 2. I created the article under not under the intention of 'corporate spam' instead following notability guidelines having made a professional appearance in English football/soccer for the club whose articles I frequently contribute to Deletion of Taylor Barada WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
106 16414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vibrational psychology User:Cremepuff222 19:23, 10 June 2007 (UTC) delete I looked for sources, but couldn't find any. This also suggests that it's |non-notable Deletion of Vibrational psychology WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
107 9763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emma Tillman (2nd nomination) User:RebeccaGreen 10:47, 4 October 2019 (UTC) keep """I have added more sources, so there is now significant coverage from 1990, 1993, 1997, 2006 and 2007. Much of it is in her local paper, the ''Hartford Courant'', with an article in another Connecticut paper, the ''Journal Inquirer''. However, in 2006 there is also a long article in the Salvation Army journal ''Priority!'', and there are long obituaries in the ''New York Times'' (republished internationally) and ''Boston Globe'', with shorter ones in other media. That is certainly enough to meet . While the nominator may think that """"Breathing for a long time is not notable"""", clearly newspapers like the ''New York Times'' and ''Boston Globe'' think that it is notable enough for them to give it significant coverage, and that is what is based on, not how long a subject breathes for""" Deletion of Emma Tillman (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
108 1638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Etienne Mendy User:GiantSnowman 13:12, 8 January 2012 (UTC) keep the quickest of Google searches would have shown that this player meets , as confirmed by http://www.ligue1.com/joueur/mendy-etienne this (among many others). Article needs improving, not deleting Deletion of Etienne Mendy WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
109 10143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raise Your Sword! User:Colapeninsula 14:46, 26 September 2012 (UTC) merge per . No in-depth coverage Deletion of Raise Your Sword! WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
110 4366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Talent Zoo User:Wine 22:04, 27 July 2006 (UTC) keep It looks like this has been cleaned up since the nom, and it |verifiably passes Deletion of Talent Zoo WP:V||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
111 13333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fredrik Svensk User:Walwal20 07:57, 29 August 2020 (UTC) delete Does not pass nor ; maybe a case of . Most of the secondary sources on him come from 'aftonbladet', which I don't see as a reliable independent secondary source. I disagree that #2 applies here, and disagree with the reasons given to invoke it here Deletion of Fredrik Svensk WP:ARTIST||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON||WP:CSK Wikipedia:Notability 77
112 3183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theological hermeneutics User:RJC 03:55, 2 August 2010 (UTC) merge with Qur'anic hermeneutics. As I said under my comment above, I don't think that we can discuss all of the various hermeneutical methods side-by-side without running afoul of or , even if this would be an interesting article. Dab pages are for articles that could in principle have the same name, which is not true of Talmudical, Biblical, and Islamic hermeneutics. Whoever performs the merge should make sure that this article does not redirect toward the new one Deletion of Theological hermeneutics WP:NPOV||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
113 119 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ted Karabük Koleji Öğretmenleri """Kullanıcı:homonihilis'''homonihilis'''""" 22:46, 9 Mayıs 2008 (UTC) delete Şablon Ted Karabük Koleji maddesinde kullanılıyor. Ancak içindeki bağlantıların hiçbiri uzun süredir açılmamış. Zaten açılsa da kriterlerini büyük ihtimalle sağlamayacaklar. İyivikiler Ted Karabük Koleji Öğretmenlerinin silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
114 21865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Walls User:WilliamJE 10:21, 25 October 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Sam Walls WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
115 14240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arpwatch (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep I concur with {{U|Canley}}'s original analysis in Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arpwatch that ''Linux Firewalls, Third Edition'' (Suehring & Ziegler, Novell Press 2006 https://books.google.com/books/about/Linux_Firewalls.html?id=VddQAAAAMAAJ), ''Wireless Hacks'' (Flickenger & Weeks, O'Reilly, 2005 https://books.google.com/books?id=qRFYMgGpWrcC), and ''Real World Linux Security'' (Toxen, Prentice Hall, 2003 https://books.google.com/books?id=_-1jwRwNaEoC) taken together amply demonstrate |notability. A partial list of other books and research papers covering the subject includes: https://books.google.com/books?id=RVQ4GgKeEtgC, https://books.google.com/books?id=2LsBzAtsExUC, https://books.google.com/books?id=L0bHuGieZWkC, https://books.google.com/books?id=VADbJowCwEQC, https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00153558/document, and http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.442.8665&rep=rep1&type=pdf#page=585 (large Deletion of Arpwatch (2nd nomination) WP:NSOFTWARE Wikipedia:Notability 77
116 15132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LRgen User:Jreferee 19:47, 18 July 2007 (UTC) delete After a detailed search, I could not find any and there certainly is not enough available to write a Wikipedia article. Thus, fails Deletion of LRgen WP:RS||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
117 15669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1990s fads and trends in Japan User:Pixelface 18:45, 31 August 2007 (UTC) delete The article lists 5 things and uses other Wikipedia articles for sources, but Wikipedia is not a |reliable source Deletion of 1990s fads and trends in Japan WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
118 15119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Skinner User:GiantSnowman 18:35, 12 September 2013 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Paul Skinner WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
119 8655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mitt Romney Cranbrook incident User:Eustress 23:51, 12 May 2012 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Mitt Romney Cranbrook incident WP:UNDUE||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
120 14503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Let Bartlet Be Bartlet User:Sgeureka 08:50, 9 July 2012 (UTC) merge to season list '''and''' let this be the precedent for the other ''Westwing'' episode articles. The majority violates #PLOT, and the one-sentence real-world information is too embarrasing to count for notability. From sporadic browsing, it seems the vast majority of ''Westwing'' ep articles suffer the same inadequacies. &ndash Deletion of Let Bartlet Be Bartlet WP:NOT||WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
121 17525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brigada NS User:EconomistBR 17:33, 29 October 2008 (UTC) delete Fails usic. The article was created in 2005 and has not sources establishing notability Deletion of Brigada NS WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
122 19331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Violin Diary User:Amwestover 01:32, 9 November 2008 (UTC) delete Doesn't appear to meet any criteria per . It has an ISBN, a few reviews, and that's about it. The book is also self-published via Lulu_(publisher)|Lulu, which is indicative of non-notability unless notability can be attributed from other sources Deletion of The Violin Diary WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
123 889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Misery of Sound User:MuZemike 02:56, 18 October 2008 (UTC) delete and nominate for a |Spammy Award Deletion of Misery of Sound WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
124 13464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ole Söderberg (2nd nomination) User:GiantSnowman 17:45, 8 August 2009 (UTC) delete """player fails and . Note, even if the appearance for BK Häcken is true, it won't affect my vote as at the time, BK Häcken played in the second-division, semi-professional Superettan, and ATHLETE states a player needs to play """"at the fully professional level of a sport"""" in order to be notable. Recreate when/if he becomes notable in the future""" Deletion of Ole Söderberg (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
125 13986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RISE Project User:Ad 04:56, 21 January 2014 (UTC) delete Article and sources fail to establish any notability as per and Deletion of RISE Project WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
126 7921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Story of Negation User:Justinlived 02:16, 20 August 2015 (UTC) delete per being |TOO SOON, as even avant garde films by avant garde filmmakers need some sort of coverage to meet and this one does not have it (yet). If it receives coverage after release and screenings, this article can always be |restored. If its author wishes it reyurned to a draft space at Deletion of A Story of Negation WP:NYF||WP:NF||WP:REFUND Wikipedia:Too soon 40
127 17027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/343743 Kjurkchieva [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 11:30, 4 March 2014 (UTC) merge as suggested. I think everyone would have been comfortable with this being |boldly redirected had the nom been aware of the list linked above Deletion of 343743 Kjurkchieva WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
128 14568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of the X-Men comics User:Lankiveil 13:23, 10 March 2014 (UTC) delete per . A tangled web of original research, probably compiled with the very best of intentions, but not suitable for Wikipedia or compliant with our policies Deletion of History of the X-Men comics WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
129 3107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mijntje Lückerath-Rovers User:onel5969 12:31, 11 July 2018 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet , a single article with 280 cites over more than a decade, with the next highest citation count in the teens, does not appear to meet notability criteria, and nothing else in the article signifies any of the other qualities of NSCHOLAR have been met. And other than mere mentions, not enough in-depth coverage from independent, reliable sources to show they meet Deletion of Mijntje Lückerath-Rovers WP:NSCHOLAR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
130 15799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Bravo (Gary Scott) User:Ideogram 21:43, 19 June 2006 (UTC) delete Fails the notability guidelines. We have verified that this singer was not the lead singer on the hit song associated with the band and he has no other hits Deletion of Greg Bravo (Gary Scott) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
131 14988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silvermist User:Huon 23:11, 17 September 2007 (UTC) delete no |sources, and if Silvermist is indeed supposed to be introduced in a 2009 movie, we're gazing deep into a |crystal ball Deletion of Silvermist WP:RS||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
132 13088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 Summer Olympics national flag bearers User:Lugnuts 18:49, 8 November 2010 (UTC) delete Good-faith article, but fails . No reason not to re-create once names of individuals have been confirmed (IE in 2012 Deletion of 2012 Summer Olympics national flag bearers WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
133 14626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rob Wheway User:AllyD 10:25, 18 March 2017 (UTC) delete Neither a one-year term as president of a small party nor a term as an elected member of a local council is sufficient for criteria 1 or 3. Nor am I seeing the coverage which could meet criterion 2 and while the subject's other activity has had https://www.theguardian.com/society/2006/dec/06/childrensservices.guardiansocietysupplement some coverage I think it falls short of the broader criteria for encyclopaedic notability Deletion of Rob Wheway :WP:POLITICIAN||:WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
134 18732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UEFA Champions League team performances User:Jmorrison230582 18:42, 11 March 2011 (UTC) delete per and redundancy to UEFA coefficient Deletion of UEFA Champions League team performances WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
135 3502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenneth Gordon Neufeld User:Qworty 05:21, 20 May 2008 (UTC) delete Non-notable writer. His book fails Deletion of Kenneth Gordon Neufeld WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
136 4041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Hartl User:Fly 21:47, 28 June 2011 (UTC) delete """minus; The subject does not meet . This article has been written because of http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-13906169 a single page on the BBC news website. He was not the subject of the article, he was simply interviewed for the article. The main notability criteria is that there is """"significant coverage"""" about the subject, which means that sources address the subject directly in detail, and not just interview his once or twice with regard to another issue. OT#NEWS|Wikipedia is not a newspaper. A single mention on a single news webpage does not qualify as significant coverage""" Deletion of Michael Hartl WP:ACADEMIC||WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
137 1826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of item numbers in Indian cinema (2nd nomination) User:power 00:59, 4 December 2017 (UTC) delete """as per nom. A containing blue-linked ''songs'' (not movies) probably can be constructed, and that would be fine to keep. However, there are only about 10 blue-linked songs (including Phir Milenge Chalte Chalte and Kajra Re), but some (Lazy Lamhe) aren't described as """"item numbers"""" on the article page""" Deletion of List of item numbers in Indian cinema (2nd nomination) WP:SAL Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
138 14323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boléro in popular culture User:Mathmo 00:25, 1 August 2007 (UTC) keep nominator did not carefully think out reasons for deletion or present a good case for deletion. Plus it appears to be flirting with breaking due to the sheer nature of AFD's of this nature listed all at once. Just because an article is dealing with popular culture does not mean it has to be deleted. If anything, the opposite is more likely to be true. Due to the nature of popular culture an article to do with it would tend to have more potential references in the popular culture than others would have Deletion of Boléro in popular culture WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
139 20199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/First 100 days of Donald Trump's presidency User:SilkTork 13:57, 30 January 2017 (UTC) keep because it meets our policies and guidelines, does not meet -REASON, is sourced, has precedent, is useful and https://tools.wmflabs.org/pageviews/?project=en.wikipedia.org&platform=all-access&agent=user&range=latest-20&pages=First_100_days_of_Donald_Trump%27s_presidency significantly popular, and at 43 kB is an |appropriate split from the parent article (Presidency of Donald Trump). It's worth noting that Timeline of the presidency of Donald Trump|the timeline article is a different sort of article, which is not comparable. The contents could not be merged back there, nor should the title be redirected there. Merging the contents back into Presidency of Donald Trump would bloat that article unnecessarily, particularly as we go further into the 100 days. It may well be, due to the controversial nature of this presidency, that there comes a need to split the article into 25 day sections. The good thing about our guidelines is that we allow for that per Deletion of First 100 days of Donald Trump's presidency WP:DEL||WP:WHENSPLIT||WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
140 12577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lockwood Analytical Method for Prediction User:Passportguy 18:41, 2 June 2009 (UTC) delete This is either or a copyright infringement of a published text Deletion of Lockwood Analytical Method for Prediction WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
141 5149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monika de Habsburgo-Lorena User:Surtsicna 13:18, 30 May 2020 (UTC) delete I am not able to find any significant coverage of the subject in reliable sources that would satisfy . The notable member of her family appears to be her son. She is only ever mentioned in passing and in genealogy publications but |Wikipedia is not meant for genealogical entries Deletion of Monika de Habsburgo-Lorena WP:BASIC||WP:NOTGENEALOGY Wikipedia:Notability 77
142 9640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Westboro Academy User:RhinosF1 22:29, 14 February 2019 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet |notability + no |refs Deletion of Westboro Academy WP:GNG||WP:CITE Wikipedia:Notability 77
143 4623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Denise McGregor User:Clarityfiend 23:18, 23 March 2016 (UTC) keep Front page news, graphic TV reenactment and interest in the cold case 35 years later satisfy Deletion of Murder of Denise McGregor WP:CRIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
144 5641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernard Lewinsky User:Umbralcorax 01:05, 5 July 2011 (UTC) keep Unless the event in question was his meeting , then doesn't apply. Simply put, the man would be notable even without his relation to Monica Deletion of Bernard Lewinsky WP:ACADEMIC||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
145 8472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dary Al-Ziayaidi User:Sir 14:42, 9 September 2010 (UTC) delete Fails , and without appearances for a fully-pro club, he clearly fails Deletion of Dary Al-Ziayaidi WP:GNG||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
146 13625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Psychic Film Festival User:Cullen328 06:08, 27 August 2011 (UTC) delete This unreferenced article about a non-notable film festival held once 36 years ago is filled with |puffery and pathetic attempts to create |inherited notability by name-dropping Charlie Chaplin, astronaut Edgar Mitchell and descendents of William Randolph Hearst. Rather a sad attempt, really Deletion of International Psychic Film Festival WP:PUFFERY||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Wikipuffery 0
147 20953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Pojman User:MaNeMeBasat 10:01, 29 April 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of James Pojman WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
148 17420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lilias Rider Haggard User:Armbrust 14:50, 1 September 2010 (UTC) delete as article fails |notability criteria for authors and notability is not |inheritable Deletion of Lilias Rider Haggard WP:AUTHOR||WP:INHERIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
149 35 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Space Launcher System User:Sandstein 18:52, 14 October 2018 (UTC) delete Never mind the rocket science minutiae above, an article with zero sources in the actual article even after three weeks of AfD will realistically never get any and therefore needs to go per Deletion of Space Launcher System WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
150 21767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wiki fraud User:JuJube 20:11, 8 March 2007 (UTC) delete author admits to violating Deletion of Wiki fraud WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
151 3362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Book store shoplifting User:North 13:33, 8 August 2015 (UTC) keep Seeing significant |RS coverage, more than sufficient to pass . See https://books.google.com/books?id=EchKhEduEBwC&pg=PT57&lpg=PT57&dq=Book+store+shoplifting&source=bl&ots=wGSCzvO8nX&sig=E-C5TkIbv5xR3af-QMB2M9Ym7f4&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CD4Q6AEwBTgUahUKEwj07IurzJnHAhXJGZIKHf8ADjE#v=onepage&q=Book%20store%20shoplifting&f=falsehttp://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2011/07/05/shoplifting-books-we-ll-miss-what-stealing-books-says-about-us-by-rachel-shteir.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/20/books/review/Rabb-t.html?_r=0 Deletion of Book store shoplifting WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
152 21384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan W. Clarke (2nd nomination) User:Rhadow 14:58, 7 November 2017 (UTC) comment """I cannot believe the amount of discussion here conducted without any facts. The references in the article need to be updated before any discussion of deletion. And where that is concerned, all I hear is wikilawyering: """"As an , he's an trivial scribbler."""" """"As an WP:ACADEMIC, I reject his minor school."""" Guess what, the school changed since the article was written, that's why the links are dead. A small school it may be, but it is a center of death penalty study. Consider instead whether Clarke has made an impact on his field. When he dies, will he get a NYT obit for free? I am guessing he will. Whenever anyone else in his field writes a book about the death penalty, they come to Clarke for a review, It sounds to me like he's the elder statesman""" Deletion of Alan W. Clarke (2nd nomination) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
153 15215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TuxGuitar (2nd nomination) User:Lexandalf 06:14, 16 August 2011 (UTC) delete """On this article's Talk:TuxGuitar#Proposed_Merge|Talk Page I have made an extensive argument that this article does not meet the Wikipedia:Notability|Notability Guidelines of Wikipedia because it fails to cite any Wikipedia:Identifying reliable sources|Reliable Sources. I have provided an Talk:TuxGuitar#Proposed_Merge|analysis of the referneces used for this article and have shown that they all fail to meet reliability standards. I have also addressed suggested new sources and have expressed my feeling that they are not reliable and/or """"trivial mention"""" (see """ Deletion of TuxGuitar (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
154 17530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Group Sports Management User:Piotrus 08:48, 1 May 2021 (UTC) delete Fails , only few mentions in passing, press-releases and their rewrites... , etc Deletion of American Group Sports Management WP:NCORP||WP:CORPSPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
155 8851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Bruggink User:Bearian 21:46, 31 May 2011 (UTC) delete per Bbb23, . I don't see how this person comes anywhere near to meeting and . Passing references in three |unreliable blogs, the only citations, comes nowhere to |significant coverage Deletion of Michael Bruggink WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BLP||WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
156 19430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Planet Slow Mo User:Jmertel23 19:25, 2 April 2019 (UTC) delete """lacks necessary sources to meet and . As for the notability of people involved in the project, I would point to , which states that web content is not considered notable simply because of notable people associated with it. Also - one of the """"notable"""" people wikilinked from this page doesn't even have his own article- the link redirects to another of his shows""" Deletion of Planet Slow Mo WP:GNG||WP:NWEB||WP:INHERITWEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
157 5063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Javier Serafini User:NemesisAT NONE keep Not only per ―like Deletion of Javier Serafini WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
158 16353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simba Sleep User:Devokewater 16:29, 28 October 2020 (UTC) keep with the updated sources, is satisfied Deletion of Simba Sleep WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
159 1760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marlon Licona User:Kosack 17:45, 23 November 2018 (UTC) delete fails having never played in a fully professional league or a senior international fixture and does not have significant independent coverage to meet Deletion of Marlon Licona WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
160 4061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SoftStack Factory User:Graywalls 05:01, 16 November 2019 (UTC) delete local business journals regularly write about new shops in town. That's why they're called.. ahem ''busienss'' journal. A local paper or newsletters don't satisfy |significant coverage criterion of |notability guidelines for organizations and companies Deletion of SoftStack Factory WP:SIGCOV||WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
161 15869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uk airport parking [[User talk:Orderinchaos78|Orderinchaos78]] 04:24, 31 December 2006 (UTC) delete per nom, and - each airport has their own parking (it's not a national authority) so information about parking should be under the page for the individual airport, if at all Deletion of Uk airport parking WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
162 3681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radha Mangeshkar User:Cutest 14:17, 24 August 2015 (UTC) delete Delete as per nomination also it appears to be the case of Deletion of Radha Mangeshkar WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
163 5980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ScienceWorld (2nd nomination) User:Xxanthippe 22:33, 21 June 2017 (UTC) keep Immensely valuable web resource on science, complementary to Wikipedia. Passes Deletion of ScienceWorld (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
164 5 [[Musikverein Steißlingen 1856 e.V.]] (erledigt, gelöscht) Benutzer:Zollwurf NONE delete Selbst wenn keine URV: Klarer Fall für das Vereinsregister, welches WP halt mal nicht ist (siehe |Was Wikipedia nicht ist (Regel 7.2 Löschung von Musikverein Steißlingen 1856 e.V. Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
165 14847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Politicizing Science (book) User:JayJasper 17:09, 31 May 2013 (UTC) delete Google search produces no secondary |RS coverage. Fails & . Not opposed to a redirect as suggested by Tokyogirl79, providing the George C. Marshall Institute article adds a bibliography section which includes this title Deletion of Politicizing Science (book) WP:IRS||WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
166 81 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ill Tone User:onel5969 12:29, 15 January 2016 (UTC) delete Fails , and searches turned up nothing to show they pass Deletion of Ill Tone WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
167 10176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fuse (band) User:MelanieN 05:01, 16 February 2015 (UTC) delete Fails and . References in the article are unconvincing Deletion of Fuse (band) WP:GNG||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
168 19134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Michel User:AllyD 10:53, 10 August 2014 (UTC) delete The French Wikipedia article, created on the same day as the English article, is equally unsourced. I did find one article in Variety (http://www.questia.com/read/1P3-3077136021/toon-boom-on-tap, via Questia, subscription reqd.) that quotes the subject in the context of his employing firm's activity, but that is not enough for |biographical notability Deletion of David Michel :WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
169 13540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Pentagon shooting [[User talk:137.122.49.102|talk]]) 15:27, 17 August 2010 (UTC) delete per and . May deserve a footnote in a relevant Pentagon article, but no more.--Special:Contributions/137.122.49.102|137.122.49.102 Deletion of 2010 Pentagon shooting WP:NOTNEWS||WP:EFFECT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
170 20951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeathBoy User:Andy 17:12, 2 July 2008 (UTC) keep """Meets 4, 5 & 10 of . The artist is certainly ''niche'' (UK Industrial), but we don't limit notability to artists that we listen to personally. They've released albums on an important label within their genre (Wasp Factory Records). They've played the major UK festival for that genre (Whitby Gothic Weekend) and also internationally in Canada. They've also had their work included on a major game soundtrack (Project Gotham Racing). They're also still active today, should anyone care to pitch """"Not doing much recently"""" as a (bogus) reason for non-notability. Additionally they've also had Lee Chaos as a past member, who's ''so'' well-known in the UK Industrial scene that no-one even bothered to create a mere wiki page to describe him (if you cared, you'd already know""" Deletion of DeathBoy WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
171 6082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/18+ (band) User:WordSeventeen 22:58, 4 April 2015 (UTC) keep As per Michig and NorthAmerica1000 meets and has notability Deletion of 18+ (band) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
172 8582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iron Maiden's 15th Studio Album User:Mazca 13:03, 24 June 2008 (UTC) delete the brief mention of what Bruce Dickinson said during the tour at the bottom of the main Iron Maiden article was all that's needed at the moment, I think. There's virtually no verifiable information about what this album will be like, when it's coming out, or indeed whether it's definitely coming out at all. Definite fail, despite the fact that I'm greatly looking forward to it Deletion of Iron Maiden's 15th Studio Album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
173 11576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Paquin User:Arxiloxos 16:52, 21 June 2016 (UTC) delete For the reasons well-stated by the nominator. I agree that winning a state championship (or even several) is not enough to establish notability, and news searches turn up only limited local coverage insufficient to make a case for notability Deletion of Paul Paquin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
174 5385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oracle Advertising and Customer Experience (CX) User:Heartmusic678 15:18, 19 August 2021 (UTC) keep CX passes . It is one of several of Oracle's SaaS enterprising apps, all of which have their own page, as adding their individual info to Oracle would make that page unwieldy. Per , if a company is notable (as is Oracle), information on its products and services should generally be included in the article on the company itself, unless the company article is so large that this would make the article unwieldy. Here are more sources: https://www.forbes.com/sites/patrickmoorhead/2021/05/17/oracle-updates-advertising-and-customer-experience-applications/?sh=2e9c0b5f1bc2, https://www.forbes.com/sites/oracle/2020/11/13/larry-ellison-discusses-the-future-of-office-work-and-integrated-applications/?sh=188c96762483, https://www.forbes.com/sites/moorinsights/2020/09/30/oracle-doubles-down-on-customer-experience-cx-management-with-new-zoom-integration/?sh=773c3e7571c4, https://www.google.com/books/edition/Oracle_CX_Cloud_Suite/gc6PDwAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=Oracle+Advertising+and+Customer+Experience+CX&printsec=frontcover Deletion of Oracle Advertising and Customer Experience (CX) WP:PRODUCT||WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
175 3950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uruguay Football League User:Lil 02:28, 10 January 2011 (UTC) delete this is obviously not an official football league. The article was written (most likely) by one of the four people who started the league of five teams. Either way it doesn't mean Deletion of Uruguay Football League WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
176 7910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trudy Harris User:David 06:26, 27 August 2014 (UTC) keep The many reviews listed by Lesser Cartographies are enough to satisfy , I think Deletion of Trudy Harris WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
177 7289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/77 Diamonds User:Ohnoitsjamie 14:39, 3 October 2016 (UTC) delete """Very little ; most of the articles are related to a publicity stunt the company was involved with. I amended this from a """"delete"""" to a """"weak delete' based on this http://uk.reuters.com/video/2011/09/22/internet-diamond-business-rocks?videoId=221786792 Reuters video, though even the video kind of feels like a press release more than anything else""" Deletion of 77 Diamonds WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
178 7107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dean Monroe User:Bgwhite 19:29, 25 June 2012 (UTC) delete Fails as the Grabby Awards are not a well-known and significant industry award, such as the AVN Award. Unable to find any independent, reliable references that go into any detail Deletion of Dean Monroe WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
179 19809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cassie Jaye User:Bob 19:54, 7 October 2017 (UTC) keep The subject meets point 3 of . I also contend that the article should be kept based on the valid points raised above by Agricola44 and ThinkingTwice Deletion of Cassie Jaye WP:DIRECTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
180 163 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hiçbir Şeyim Yok (Khontkar şarkısı) """Kullanıcı:pragdon'''pragdon'''""" 05.38, 23 Haziran 2020 (UTC) merge Bağımsız güvenilir kaynaklar mevcut. Ancak 'e göre tek başına bir madde oluşturacak boyutta değil. Bilgi kaybı olmaması için Khontkar maddesine aktarılsın Hiçbir Şeyim Yok'un silinmesi (Khontkar şarkısı) siliniyor Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
181 176 [[Thomas Pink]] (LAZ) Benutzer:Ausgangskontrolle 09:45, 27. Jul. 2010 (CEST) keep Textilhersteller, Kaufpreis von 49 Millionen £, weltweite Läden. Ich habe noch ein Bild und Kategorien hinzugefügt. Nach Ausbau durch Ersteller(in) klar . Dem Antragsteller ist ans Herz gelegt, hier besonders Grundsatz 2 und 3 Löschung von Thomas Pink Wikipedia:LR Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
182 11105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samantha Dunn [[User talk:Orderinchaos|Orderinchaos]] 21:15, 22 August 2011 (UTC) delete per nom and Mattinbgn - falls well short of and appears to have been created by a promotional account Deletion of Samantha Dunn WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
183 16831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Newnham User:Joe 19:38, 27 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |musician Deletion of Scott Newnham WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
184 8360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plant cover User:Timneu22 01:22, 25 October 2010 (UTC) comment """Despite the refs being """"improved"""", I find it completely unacceptable that this topic has a Christian Damgaard essay used as a source, since the article was written by Christian Damgaard. We don't put thesis papers or other on here. That information needs to be removed. Huge WP:COI and ADVERT there. &mdash""" Deletion of Plant cover WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
185 14284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natalie Pack User:Tomwsulcer 00:29, 3 September 2016 (UTC) keep as per above keep comments, plus a suggestion, given the nominator's boilerplate machine-gun AfD nominations of all beauty contestants -- nominations which cause the community a lot of work and checking -- and nominator AfDing articles without an ounce of checking |beforehand, that administrators restrict his power to propose AfDs Deletion of Natalie Pack WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
186 19843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St.Augustine's Higher Secondary School Karimkunnam User:Kudpung 16:28, 14 June 2015 (UTC) keep per and '''move to St. Augustine's Higher Secondary School, Karimkunnam Deletion of St.Augustine's Higher Secondary School Karimkunnam WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
187 19190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cryptocurrencies User:Surfer43 02:50, 24 December 2013 (UTC) keep at current state -- per Deletion of List of cryptocurrencies WP:CSC Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
188 8569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Viridiana Salazar User:Govvy 18:02, 25 January 2018 (UTC) delete Fails having not played pro football Deletion of Viridiana Salazar WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
189 13866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Howe User:APerson 15:14, 25 September 2015 (UTC) delete as a non-notable person. I also looked at , which may apply here Deletion of Kim Howe WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
190 9645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terrence M. Andrews User:Marquardtika 14:27, 10 February 2021 (UTC) delete unless is met independent of any failed or expired judicial nominations. And I think I created some of these, but I still think they should be deleted because I have a better understanding of now Deletion of Terrence M. Andrews WP:GNG||WP:JUDGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
191 14809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rosary and scapular User:Willthacheerleader18 21:47, 1 December 2010 (UTC) keep """As stated above, content dispute and are best worked out somewhere else. The same discussion is now occuring on so many pages.. this """"battle"""" Malke is issuing is rediculous""" Deletion of Rosary and scapular WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
192 10502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Svetla Lubova User:Coccyx 16:04, 28 October 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. While I agree that Ginger Jolie is not something we should be using as precedent (per , or in this case does not exist) the argument that this subject has received no substantial coverage from reliable third party sources speaks volumes Deletion of Svetla Lubova WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
193 15910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/El Sueno del Siempre User:Metropolitan90 07:30, 13 May 2008 (UTC) delete per nom, as |unverifiable, |devoid of sources, |unencyclopedic, and |a conflict of interest. I recommend that the creator of this article be warned that he will be blocked if he creates any more articles along these lines Deletion of El Sueno del Siempre WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NOT||WP:COI Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
194 3271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rick L Evans User:RightCowLeftCoast 16:21, 21 January 2013 (UTC) delete No ''significant coverage'' as defined by found in news or book sources, therefore failing that subject cannot pass or . The subject appears to have written three books, however he does not appear to pass Deletion of Rick L Evans WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:BAND||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
195 6546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prevention of Genocide Act of 1988 User:Cdogsimmons 02:38, 8 July 2009 (UTC) keep """The nominator seems to have mistaken Wikipedia's |notability policy with his or her own subjective determination of what is """"notable"""". This article is well sourced by a significant number of 3rd party independent sources. Notability exists""" Deletion of Prevention of Genocide Act of 1988 WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
196 14081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pixel Gun 3D: Battle Royale User:Ferret 11:44, 11 April 2019 (UTC) comment Ping|A loose necktie|Oshawott 12|Mosaicberry|CoolSkittle}} There's some bad procedural-ness going on here. The article has originally been deleted under the name Pixel Gun 3D 3 times as G1, G11, and G11. (I'm not counting a R2 due to a draft move). Smith John created it under a new name, which is probably innocent enough. Moving a separate draft to Pixel Gun 3D ''while an AFD on the topic is already underway'' is probably premature and a bit out of procedure. AFD should be evaluating the topics suitably for an article. Votes for speedy redirect should be clarified as Keeps so its clear you're indicating you believe the topic passes Deletion of Pixel Gun 3D: Battle Royale WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
197 14864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Animal rights and the Holocaust NONE NONE keep Slim and I discussed its creation, even though she and I are (or thought we were!) at opposite sides on this issue. Anyway, this is a typical example of a thoughtless nomination that accuses a spin-off article of being a fork Deletion of Animal rights and the Holocaust WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
198 17892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Wikipedia people User:Northamerica1000 16:05, 9 February 2018 (UTC) keep per relative to :Category:Wikipedia people. That said, this list may be best limited to verified notable subjects, specifically those that have their own article, or as red links with at least two sources that provide significant coverage in reliable sources to demonstrate notability, and to demonstrate that is not a factor if the potential for that exists Deletion of List of Wikipedia people WP:NOTDUP||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
199 13407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tamboti Tent Camp User:TerriersFan 21:30, 13 March 2010 (UTC) merge """to Kruger National Park#Rest camps. I would remind the nominator that requires various steps before nominating pages for deletion, one of which is """"Consider turning the page into a useful redirect or proposing it be merged."""" If, in fact, this was considered and rejected then the reasons should be included in the nomination. The images can be merged into the target. An introductory section can be sourced from material such as http://www.krugerpark.org/Kruger_Park_Camps-travel/tamboti-tented-camp-kruger-park.htmlhttp://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/thestar/access/421605611.html?dids=421605611:421605611&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Jan+24%2C+2002&author=Catherine+George&pub=Toronto+Star&desc=On+the+wild+side+%3B+Established+in+1898%2C+South+Africa%27s+Kruger+National+Park+is+home+to+the+%27Big+Five%27+of+big+game+and+is+one+of+the+world%27s+top+10+game+reserves&pqatl=googlehttp://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/726324/Game-on.htmlhttp://www.african-safari-journals.com/self-guided-kruger.html""" Deletion of Tamboti Tent Camp WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
200 7745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xnee User:Joe 18:46, 8 August 2009 (UTC) delete All that I can find is |trivial mentions Deletion of Xnee WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
201 5916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MacPaw (2nd nomination) [[User talk:94.153.69.197#top|talk]]) 09:25, 14 June 2021 (UTC) keep The article has strong references including Forbes, TechCrunch, Entrepreneur. I think it is in line with . I have found 2 references in books about their products: https://www.google.com.ua/books/edition/Take_Control_of_Managing_Your_Files/6NsPEAAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=macpaw&pg=PA74&printsec=frontcover and https://www.google.com.ua/books/edition/iMac_For_Dummies/a05ZAwAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=macpaw&pg=PT495&printsec=frontcover. Maybe, the article should be edited and rewritten in a more neutral voice without product list. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/94.153.69.197|94.153.69.197 Deletion of MacPaw (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
202 2160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Guildhall at SMU (2nd nomination) User:Hahnchen 21:39, 14 February 2014 (UTC) keep Or merge. Passes now like it did 7 years ago. Sources available - http://www.edge-online.com/features/university-profile-guildhall-smu/http://www.g4tv.com/thefeed/blog/post/715866/g4u-smus-guildhall-video-game-design-program/http://www.1up.com/features/game-design-101?pager.offset=0 Deletion of The Guildhall at SMU (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
203 2266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chancey Illa User:Superastig 16:21, 23 June 2020 (UTC) merge to Anirudh Ravichander: The song was mentioned in a number of articles, but was barely discussed. It is partially discussed https://www.mid-day.com/articles/chennai-turns-377-interesting-facts-about-the-capital-city-of-tamil-nadu/15545150 here, but that's not good enough for the article to pass Deletion of Chancey Illa WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
204 5950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saint David's School (New York City) User:Kudpung 06:26, 29 April 2011 (UTC) keep If I had seen the CSD I would have declined it too as the article certainly makes claims to notability. It has come a very long way since it was created as a tiny stub in 2009 and many editors have contributed to making it a clean school page. The school appears to be far more worthy of mention than a great many primary school articles (although of course, a converse rationale is inadmissible). Most of the referenced sources however, appear to be mainly concerned with alumni and do not support notability for the school as their personal notability cannot be inherited. One of the http://select.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=F50915FA3C5A117A93C5A9178DD85F478585F9 reliable sources that may have more in depth coverage is behind a pay-wall, while the other http://www.nytimes.com/1991/12/24/style/chronicle-404791.html NYT article lends more weight to arguments for notability. My only serious reserve is that it reads a tad promotional, but this can be rectified - I might even have a go at it myself if it is kept. So my overall opinion is 'keep Deletion of Saint David's School (New York City) WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
205 4679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Impeachment of Donald Trump User:Gluons12 19:05, 11 November 2016 (UTC) delete as |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball. Doesn't seem well-sourced enough at this point Deletion of Impeachment of Donald Trump WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
206 17297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ffffpppptthheeewww User:Yanksox 00:08, 28 June 2006 (UTC) delete The title became very funny when I read the article. But it's unverfiable, and not really encylopedic. Should be in Deletion of Ffffpppptthheeewww WP:BJAODN Wikipedia:Silly Things 72
207 6188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burnt-out diabetes mellitus User:Atmoz 16:40, 27 May 2011 (UTC) delete WP:NEO that hasn't been picked up. the hindu article uses the term in passing. the journal article is about the topic, but does not satisfy Deletion of Burnt-out diabetes mellitus WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
208 423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J money beats User:Kf4bdy 20:53, 3 November 2006 (UTC) delete Seems to fail and doesn't seem to be very notable Deletion of J money beats WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
209 16144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor handwriting User:Hog 23:20, 14 April 2020 (UTC) merge to Medical prescription#Legibility per . I think this topic warrants coverage, but not an individual page Deletion of Doctor handwriting WP:PAGEDECIDE Wikipedia:Notability 77
210 12981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pioneer One User:Peridon 13:18, 18 June 2010 (UTC) delete """not being big news may be because it hasn't had enough time to hit BBC, CNN, etc."""" Please see . '''Note to new and anon posters: This is not a vote by numbers.''' You may support the article, but you must give good reasons - good by the standards of Wikipedia policy - for this. Liking it or it having a potential for notability are not good reasons. Yes, we would possibly delete Van Gogh's article unless sufficient notability had been shown - and he had more during his lifetime than is commonly assumed. This is an encyclopaedia, not a TV guide or a news review. """"The implication that this deletion submission was malicious or had ulterior motives wouldn't be unfounded"""" - from what I know of the work here of the nominator, I would say definitely unfounded. The episode is a pilot. Pilots may become notable when the series takes off or for the presence of notable people/production/direction. Is the first thing released on DVD notable enough to have an article purely on that ground? (Substitute CD, VHS, whatever""" Deletion of Pioneer One WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
211 9562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Douglas User:Sir 21:49, 4 June 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not played in a fully pro league, or received significant coverage, meaning this article fails both and Deletion of Steven Douglas WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
212 19748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roach clip (2nd nomination) User:Crisco 07:38, 15 May 2011 (UTC) merge and redirect to Cannabis (drug). It can be recreated if it is expanded from |reliable sources Deletion of Roach clip (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
213 98 [[U-Bahnhof Rosendeller Straße]] (bleibt) NONE NONE keep """Zu allem Überfluss macht sich der Antragssteller nicht einmal die Mühe, eine Begründung gemäß für seinen Löschantrag zu geben (Zitat: ''""""Begründe deinen Antrag präzise und nachvollziehbar, vermeide für Außenstehende unverständliche Begriffe oder verlinke diese zumindest. Bleibe dabei sachlich und vermeide Bemerkungen, die den Seitenautor kränken oder das Thema herabwürdigen...""""'' Meines Erachtens also ein klarer Fall von Wikipedia:Löschantrag entfernen 2.a) bzw. User:Axpde|'''a'''×'''p'''deUser Talk:Axpde|Hallo! 23:27, 2. Nov. 2011 (CET""" Löschung von U-Bahnhof Rosendeller Straße Wikipedia:Löschregeln Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
214 17855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stefan Rapp User:2005 22:55, 21 May 2009 (UTC) delete I added a prod, and no third party sources have been added. He does not meet the Wiki Poker project's criteria for an article, and also fails . He gets no coverage except in passing mention. The article can be recreated if he ever does get significant coverage in third party sources Deletion of Stefan Rapp WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
215 17906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barbara Justice User:Xxanthippe 02:06, 24 May 2016 (UTC) keep Certainly does not pass rof, but may pass as a notable eccentric and contrarian Deletion of Barbara Justice WP:P||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Portal 85
216 18138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transformation of the Roman World User:Elmidae 23:46, 30 August 2020 (UTC) keep """Scholar hits for a combined https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&as_ylo=1997&q=%22European+Science+Foundation%22+%22Transformation+of+the+Roman+World%22&btnG= """"European Science Foundation"""" and """"Transformation of the Roman World"""" are around 400 (and the hits remain good until the end). These are not random phrase hits, they specifically reference the results and impact of the programme. I agree that is satisfied. (The refs provided by Krakkos, above, are surprisingly shite though. What's the point of proffering ''that'' as an argument""" Deletion of Transformation of the Roman World WP:EFFECT Wikipedia:Notability 77
217 11202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anne Lynch (artist) User:Mduvekot 04:06, 9 January 2017 (UTC) comment like I said at rticles for deletion/Brigid Hanrahan and rticles for deletion/Dorothy Berry, I am concerned about the lack of critical reception. Even for artist who technically meet some of the secondary notability criteria of RTIST, for example being represented in a collection, we still need someone else to write something we can base an article on. I would really like to see some in-depth reviews from reliable, independent sources, and artshub is not an independent source Deletion of Anne Lynch (artist) WP:A||WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
218 10914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Dhananjay Diwakar Sagdeo User:Bearian 18:28, 29 January 2021 (UTC) delete """per , , , and . I can't emphasize enough that he got """"India's fourth highest civilian award"""". There's lots of medical and nursing professionals working amongst scheduled tribes in south Asia. There's a whole set of articles; see Nursing in Pakistan and Nursing in India, for example""" Deletion of Dr. Dhananjay Diwakar Sagdeo WP:SNOW||WP:PROF||WP:GNG||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
219 890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Toyota Way User:Elaragirl 14:53, 3 November 2006 (UTC) delete Wow, look. Another NN book with - wait for it - probable copyvios by the bucketload! I don't know any other way to say this but that ''summaries of entire books do not an article make''. Oh, and it doesn't meet , either, in my eyes Deletion of The Toyota Way WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
220 15126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clint Hickman User:MB 22:58, 6 January 2017 (UTC) delete fails . Local politician with only routine local coverage Deletion of Clint Hickman WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
221 14631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Move The Crowd Records User:Dramatic 00:50, 20 August 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Move The Crowd Records WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
222 10241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stop Online Piracy Act [[User talk:Reach Out to the Truth|Reach Out to the Truth]] 19:40, 10 March 2012 (UTC) keep Please read the eletion policy before nominating another article for deletion Deletion of Stop Online Piracy Act WP:D Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
223 6011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christof May User:Haminoon 08:08, 11 May 2015 (UTC) keep Meets several criteria in . Some of his clarinet playing with Abbuehl is stunning Deletion of Christof May WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
224 15243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of traps in the Saw film series (3rd nomination) User:Deon555 22:43, 14 October 2008 (UTC) keep This is a great article. It's already |come back from the dead once, let's save it again. It's a fantastic article, and I've referenced it many a time Deletion of List of traps in the Saw film series (3rd nomination) WP:DRV Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
225 15450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hemant Brijwasi User:Aseleste 05:06, 4 April 2021 (UTC) keep The subject meets .{{Cite web|last=DelhiApril 16|first=India Today Web Desk New|last2=April 16|first2=2018UPDATED:|last3=Ist|first3=2018 13:59|title=From Little Champ to Rising Star: How Hemant Brijwasi won millions of hearts with his breathtaking performances|url=https://www.indiatoday.in/television/reality-tv/story/from-little-champ-to-rising-star-how-hemant-brijwasi-won-millions-of-hearts-with-his-breathtaking-performances-1213157-2018-04-16|access-date=2021-04-04|website=India Today|language=en|no-tracking=yes}}{{Cite news|last=Saifi|first=Javed|date=2018-04-20|title=Straight from the heartland|language=en-IN|work=The Hindu|url=https://www.thehindu.com/entertainment/music/straight-from-the-heartland/article23604762.ece|access-date=2021-04-04|issn=0971-751X}}{{Cite web|date=2016-06-12|title=Singing reality show winner attacked in Vrindavan|url=https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/singing-reality-show-winner-attacked-in-vrindavan/story-xy9Z2rQBFaQalaQSSsRboK.html|access-date=2021-04-04|website=Hindustan Times|language=en}}{{Cite web|last=DelhiApril 15|first=India Today Web Desk New|last2=April 16|first2=2018UPDATED|last3=Ist|first3=2018 10:51|title=Rising Star 2 grand finale: Hemant Brijwasi is the winner of the show|url=https://www.indiatoday.in/television/reality-tv/story/rising-star-2-grand-finale-hemant-brijwasi-is-the-winner-of-the-show-1212944-2018-04-15|access-date=2021-04-04|website=India Today|language=en|no-tracking=yes}}{{Cite web|title='Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Li'l Champs' winner Hemant Brijwasi wins reality show 'Rising Star 2'|url=https://www.newindianexpress.com/entertainment/hindi/2018/apr/16/sa-re-ga-ma-pa-lil-champs-winner-hemant-brijwasi-wins-reality-show-rising-star-2-1802207.html|access-date=2021-04-04|website=The New Indian Express}} Currently elaborating, please wait Deletion of Hemant Brijwasi WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
226 2316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Console wars User:Sergecross73 02:11, 9 July 2013 (UTC) delete completely redundant to the video game generation articles, and manages to be even more based off of Deletion of Console wars WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
227 2029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bays, WV User:Smartyllama 12:34, 6 July 2017 (UTC) keep Passes , plain and simple. It's clear it exists, it's clear it was populated, good enough Deletion of Bays, WV WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
228 21730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiny Toon Adventures: Defenders of the Universe User:Cavarrone 07:21, 16 February 2012 (UTC) keep per provided reliable sources, the nom lacks of Deletion of Tiny Toon Adventures: Defenders of the Universe WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
229 13957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shi'a view of Ali User:Jersey 18:17, 14 May 2006 (UTC) delete all as content/POV forks with aspects of |original research and |ownership of articles Deletion of Shi'a view of Ali WP:OR||WP:OWN Wikipedia:No original research 65
230 7503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D'Antion Christopher McGuire User:DeniedClub 09:29, 19 December 2018 (UTC) delete """His Facebook is gone now as well. Absolutely no notability and fails spectacularly. Was already deleted back on December 25, 2010: """"Speedy deleted per (CSD G11), was blatant advertising, used only to promote someone or something."""" Article does not appear to have evolved any further""" Deletion of D'Antion Christopher McGuire WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
231 2970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hushen Savani User:Piotrus 09:07, 31 March 2015 (UTC) delete The presented sources don't seem sufficient to make him pass Deletion of Hushen Savani WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
232 358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess Olga of Hanover User:TimothyBlue 05:39, 15 August 2020 (UTC) delete This is nothing more than a genealogical record. The topic fails and . There are no reliable sources independent of the subject that cover anything directly and indepth about this individual because they have done absolutely nothing notable. Being related to a public figure is not notable . Wikipedia is of non-notable members in royal families. // Deletion of Princess Olga of Hanover WP:GNG||WP:BASIC||WP:INVALIDBIO||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:NOTGENEALOGY Wikipedia:Notability 77
233 19803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Explorepda NONE NONE delete Probably ? It definitely is! Allow me to present the strong evidence Deletion of Explorepda WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
234 2795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SHARKS! User:PJvanMill 16:41, 24 May 2021 (UTC) keep per the reasoning I gave special:permalink/1024886181#SHARKS!|here; basically, I think it passes the |GNG Deletion of SHARKS! WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
235 2405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/María Sáez de Vernet User:Cwmhiraeth 07:00, 5 August 2018 (UTC) keep Seems to be a significant figure in her own right with her diaries providing historically interesting detail. Appears to meet Deletion of María Sáez de Vernet WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
236 1632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alfred Worthington User:Cunard 06:22, 12 September 2009 (UTC) comment The above links provided by Location have not convinced me of Alfred Worthington's notability per , so I have relisted this AfD to see if anyone can uncover more sources Deletion of Alfred Worthington WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
237 7219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Priya Prakash Varrier User:Sam 12:55, 13 February 2018 (UTC) delete Lovely girl+catchy tune in a movie trailer+press hungry for delivering a quick fix to the masses ≠ notability per ; there simply isn't sig. coverage here. isn't met either Deletion of Priya Prakash Varrier WP:BASIC||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
238 9294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robb Hanrahan User:Kappa 12:29, 3 September 2005 (UTC) keep well-known entertainment figure with an audience far more than 5,000 people, passes Deletion of Robb Hanrahan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
239 4020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cumberland County Schools User:GO 03:08, 1 September 2008 (UTC) keep School district articles are generally always considered notable. If the United States article needed clean up, then would we delete it? The answer is no, and the answer shouldn't be any different here; articles about notable subjects need to be kept and cleaned up. Close this per Deletion of Cumberland County Schools WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
240 2048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/South 40 User:Esradekan 11:57, 29 March 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of South 40 WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
241 17535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Damone Morris User:Rpclod 21:15, 19 July 2014 (UTC) delete This article does not appear to meet Deletion of Damone Morris WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
242 95 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GlanMer Media User:WikiDan61 13:38, 16 August 2012 (UTC) delete per #A7. This is basically a YouTube comedy troupe trying to pass themselves off as a valid film production company Deletion of GlanMer Media WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
243 11050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danny Mann [[User talk:Serial Number 54129|serial]][[Special:contributions/Serial Number 54129|''' #''']] 08:56, 15 May 2020 (UTC) delete unfortunately, the sourcing—extant or |otherwise—does not sufficiently attest to the depth or persistency of coverage needed to meet WP:BLPSOURCE or GNG. The sources presented rely overly on |passing mentions to do so Deletion of Danny Mann WP:BEFORE||WP:MENTION Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
244 7539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/North Dakota State Bison baseball User:Kinston 01:07, 31 August 2007 (UTC) keep """Notable college program. http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&um=1&tab=wn&ie=UTF-8&q=%22North+Dakota+State%22+Bisons+baseball HERE are quite a number of sources that discuss the subject. This more than satisfies as """"Significant coverage"""" and """"Reliable"""" sources""" Deletion of North Dakota State Bison baseball WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
245 3419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Strawberry Machine User:Dylanfromthenorth 04:28, 9 January 2016 (UTC) delete Nowhere near reaching the level of notability required to meet the |general notability guideline, or the |specific guideline for bands Deletion of Strawberry Machine WP:GNG||WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
246 5073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of shopping centres in Australia User:Bidgee 20:50, 30 November 2010 (UTC) keep If we are going to apply , then most lists (such as the list of National Parks, lists of buildings) would be deleted. While I dislike lists common-sense is that the lists are not tourist guides but are lists of notable locations which don't have any street address or phone numbers in the list (e.g. List of shopping centres in Australia) and are far more safer from then List of shopping centres in Australia by size (which most of the Gross Leasable Areas is most likely entered by POV-pushers who think their local shopping centre is bigger then another) which is full of POV and Deletion of List of shopping centres in Australia WP:NOTGUIDE||WP:POV||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
247 20474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Famous Americans User:Belovedfreak 20:43, 22 July 2010 (UTC) delete because Wikipedia is an encyclopaedia, not a teaching aid, not a textbook. (|policy). As User:Are You The Cow Of Pain? says above, choosing which Americans to include (and choosing an arbitrary number of 30-40) amounts to original research. (|policy Deletion of Famous Americans WP:NOT||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
248 710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shraga Hager User:Chabuk 15:31, 9 September 2007 (UTC) delete I'm really quite astonished that there is even a discussion here. The article makes no sourced or verified claim of notability, even if he is the Rebbe of this sect (and I don't doubt that he is) that does not make him independently notable. He objectively fails nearly every qualification of and simply does not meet criteria for inclusion. For goodness sakes, I come closer to notability under WP guidelines then he does Deletion of Shraga Hager WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
249 18598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FLMH User:Punkmorten 20:57, 26 October 2005 (UTC) delete with 80 registered users it does not pass Deletion of FLMH WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
250 10586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amerado (musician) User:Atlantic306 23:58, 14 April 2021 (UTC) keep as passes criteria 8 of (only one criteria needed) as nominated for Ghana's top music awards as confirmed in reliable newspaper sources so deletion is unnecessary in my view Deletion of Amerado (musician) WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
251 8742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taishan Dong (2nd nomination) User:Pharaoh 10:21, 6 March 2015 (UTC) keep Passes . http://www.foxsports.com/boxing/story/fox-sports-1-golden-boy-taishan-dong-perks-of-being-the-great-wall-of-china-022315 this and http://espn.go.com/boxing/story/_/id/12334186/sky-limit-taishan this Deletion of Taishan Dong (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
252 8056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The revolution theory User:Carlosguitar 08:44, 21 September 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of The revolution theory WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
253 18314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2027 Southeast Asian Games User:Serial 13:31, 14 October 2018 (UTC) delete per . And per Lugnuts Deletion of 2027 Southeast Asian Games WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
254 10204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nuked the fridge User:Diego 07:24, 9 July 2008 (UTC) keep """The Newsweek article qualifies as Wikipedia:Notability#General_notability_guideline|Significant coverage, Newsweek is a reliable source. The article in its current form doesn't fall under the guidelines of since it isn't a """"dictionary definition"""" nor an """"usage guide"""", it includes encyclopedic content about the origins, relation to jump the shark, and usage in third party sites""" Deletion of Nuked the fridge WP:NOTDICT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
255 10244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Goaste User:Mr 23:58, 2 September 2006 (UTC) delete Regardless of the reason for the low Alexa rank, it still fails Deletion of Goaste WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
256 11037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jiří Krček User:Mattythewhite 17:54, 19 March 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Jiří Krček WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
257 21616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Link Up (Wiley Single) User:Richhoncho 19:44, 14 December 2011 (UTC) delete Fails , , Deletion of Link Up (Wiley Single) WP:NSONG||WP:GNG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
258 7147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael W. Allen User:Quartermaster 13:43, 6 January 2011 (UTC) delete Reads like a combo ad/resumé/press release. I searched for the subject in the ''Biography and Genealogy Master Index'' (BGMI) and found 6 entries, all exclusively in the Marquis ''Who's Who in America'' for 1994-1997, 2000, and 2001. A problem is that the date of birth is listed as 1948 and the article states DOB for Allen to be 1946. So either there are NO BGMI entries, or there's an error in the article or the source. Even if this IS the 1948 Allen, and this source is considered one of the more authoritative of the ''Who's Who'' products, this is the ONLY source BGMI is citing. The lack of an entry since 2001 is a good indication that the subject stopped purchasing the volume and was dropped by the publisher (I speak from personal experience). Lacking other authoritative third party cites as to notability leads me to conclude this should be deleted Deletion of Michael W. Allen WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
259 9070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Preface (album) User:JohnCD 17:49, 6 August 2008 (UTC) delete """no source, and per : """"''Album articles with little more than a track listing may be more appropriately merged into the artist's main article or discography article''"""" - where it already has a mention""" Deletion of The Preface (album) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
260 20294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebecca Brown (Beckie0) User:danntm 04:57, 3 October 2014 (UTC) delete per #A7 as there is no assertion of notability and no independent sources Deletion of Rebecca Brown (Beckie0) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
261 12018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bilal Al-Balushi User:GiantSnowman 18:50, 9 March 2014 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Bilal Al-Balushi WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
262 10823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Home Alone (The Dumping Ground) User:Davidmichaelscott 01:07, 15 January 2014 (UTC) merge as above. Lack of secondary research indicates a lack of notability as per Deletion of Home Alone (The Dumping Ground) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
263 1838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brad Whitsitt User:Inter 01:47, 27 February 2017 (UTC) comment does the Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup count as a professional competition? If so the subject would pass as per multiple references in the article state that he has appeared in that competition Deletion of Brad Whitsitt WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
264 6841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Uhlmann User:NealeFamily 08:06, 19 May 2012 (UTC) keep Meets because he has represented his country in an officially sanctioned senior international competition Deletion of Greg Uhlmann WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
265 11726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solar Roadways User:Dream 11:24, 24 May 2014 (UTC) keep Wired magazine has an article about it http://www.wired.com/2014/05/solar-road/ as do others. It easily passes . Any problems with the article should be discussed on its talk page and dealt with through normal editing practices Deletion of Solar Roadways WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
266 9707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francis Charles Peecock User:SportingFlyer 04:27, 3 November 2018 (UTC) keep this is an incredibly difficult one because it's historical, and while the sources in the article feel routine from their headlines (I can't access them) I think there's a benefit of the doubt on grounds. doesn't apply since it's too old of an article. He is in the 1885 Ipswich Town photo here: http://www.stowmarketmercury.co.uk/news/ipswich-town-photo-from-1885-recreated-at-ipswich-school-with-help-from-italian-supporters-branch-1-4916797, played against a Canadian team in 1891 http://www.canadiansoccerhistory.com/Canadiantoursabroad/Gt%20Britain%201891.html and is covered non-routinely in at least one book: http://thetwounfortunates.com/book-review-ipswich-town-a-history/. Other period sources may exist on those grounds, especially if you look at the bibliography of the book Deletion of Francis Charles Peecock WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
267 17215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicholas Wald User:Clarityfiend 09:00, 19 February 2013 (UTC) keep """Truly bizarre """"reasoning"""" offered for deletion. Of his co-authored paper, a then-''British Medical Journal'' editor said it was """"possibly 'more than 50 years since we published something as important'"""". http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2011/jan/04/heart-attack-stroke-polypill-trial-begins There's also http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/7452835.stm """"Birth defect test guru knighted"""", an entirely separate basis for notability. UseTheCommandLine needs to read otability (academics""" Deletion of Nicholas Wald WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
268 3006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karen Seal User:Drawn 21:58, 3 May 2009 (UTC) comment The article is basically completely unsourced. It is a very detailed c.v. sort of article and I doubt that much detail could be properly |verified. If the article is kept it needs to be severely cleaned and pruned. I am also concerned about '''Reidthaler's conflict of interest''' in promoting Karen Seal Deletion of Karen Seal WP:VERIFY Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
269 9512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Smoke Dawg User:Bearcat 17:02, 11 July 2018 (UTC) delete Collaborating with more notable musicians is not in and of itself an pass, and the sources being shown to support that are glancing namechecks of his existence in coverage of those other people rather than substantive coverage about him — so they don't establish that he passes in lieu. The ''only'' serious grounds for considering him notable here is the death coverage itself — but if he didn't properly establish any NMUSIC notability in life, then the burst of death coverage just makes him a Deletion of Smoke Dawg WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
270 17771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chihuahua heights User:JJL 00:49, 30 March 2009 (UTC) delete no evidence that it exists no refs., no relevant ghits seen), and no evidence of in any event Deletion of Chihuahua heights WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
271 4438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inspiration developer User:Huon 02:06, 7 May 2015 (UTC) delete a mix of |original research and a non-notable |neologism Deletion of Inspiration developer WP:NOR||WP:NEO Wikipedia:No original research 65
272 19453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Passionato User:Corvus 03:27, 13 September 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Passionato WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
273 7108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DZMD User:Bearcat 17:24, 8 January 2019 (UTC) delete """In order for a radio station to qualify for an article, we require |reliable source coverage to properly |verify that the station actually meets the notability criteria for radio stations (which I already enumerated above in reply to Trackinfo, so I won't repeat here.) It is not enough, however, to simply cite archived copies of the station's own self-promotional materials — we ''have'' seen people try to legitimize hoax articles about radio stations that didn't really exist by ''creating'' fake websites and fake press releases to """"verify"""" that the stations really existed, so that kind of source material does ''not'' clinch a station's notability at all: what we require is ''independent'' sources, such as articles in the local newspaper about the radio station's launch. So no, the new sources Trackinfo has been adding don't cut it""" Deletion of DZMD WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
274 17872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seang Chanthea User:GiantSnowman 13:34, 25 March 2019 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Seang Chanthea WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
275 8138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of molecules discovered in the 21st century User:Ajf773 10:17, 3 April 2018 (UTC) delete List is incomplete and unverified but has all the hallmarks of an indiscriminate list. Fails Deletion of List of molecules discovered in the 21st century WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
276 15492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raheem Sterling (2nd nomination) User:Jmorrison230582 21:54, 19 March 2011 (UTC) delete because most of the coverage centred on something that ''might'' have happened, but in actual fact didn't happen (him playing for the Liverpool first team and thereby setting a new club record). He clearly fails and only arguably passes GNG due to that speculative coverage Deletion of Raheem Sterling (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
277 15296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of football clubs in non-Anglophone countries with English names User:GraniteSand 04:11, 12 November 2014 (UTC) keep A fascinating topic on the legacy of British colonialism and the global dissemination of English language and culture in sports. As far as I can tell the context for the article is established in the first reference and then expounded on in the second. I see no basis for the assertion that the article is based on a foundation of |original research and so can't find a basis in policy for deletion Deletion of List of football clubs in non-Anglophone countries with English names WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
278 7557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Obama-Trump feud User:AusLondonder 16:49, 6 March 2017 (UTC) delete Unenclyopedic and . Fails Deletion of Obama-Trump feud WP:OR||WP:SYNTH||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:No original research 65
279 12053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Australian middleweight boxing champions User:Esquivalience 01:57, 13 June 2016 (UTC) keep Serves a |navigational purpose and the redlinks could simply be removed Deletion of List of Australian middleweight boxing champions WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
280 16249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ovejo, California User:Geschichte 22:12, 3 January 2021 (UTC) delete per problems Deletion of Ovejo, California WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
281 13643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abirami Ramanathan User:VanishingRainbow 14:17, 22 December 2014 (UTC) delete lacks Deletion of Abirami Ramanathan WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
282 17020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Differences between conservative and liberal brain User:Brain 12:00, 14 April 2011 (UTC) keep """See http://news.google.co.uk/news/more?hl=en&biw=1366&bih=627&q=conservative+liberal+brain&um=1&ie=UTF-8&ncl=dB0c4dMH3qUNXhMscLKVgPY_2WHKM&ei=ZdmmTerKNMXjrAf99fDkCQ&sa=X&oi=news_result&ct=more-results&resnum=3&ved=0CD4QqgIwAghttp://news.google.co.uk/news/more?hl=en&biw=1366&bih=627&q=conservative+liberal+brain&um=1&ie=UTF-8&ncl=dHW-N3DSL3kZ6fMyi-tlW2JkiiYGM&ei=ZdmmTerKNMXjrAf99fDkCQ&sa=X&oi=news_result&ct=more-results&resnum=2&ved=0CDEQqgIwAQhttp://news.google.co.uk/news/more?hl=en&biw=1366&bih=627&q=conservative+liberal+brain&um=1&ie=UTF-8&ncl=djxoxfKAp8STvaMZibEv0I0Xy2_gM&ei=ZdmmTerKNMXjrAf99fDkCQ&sa=X&oi=news_result&ct=more-results&resnum=7&ved=0CGcQqgIwBghttp://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&biw=1366&bih=627&q=conservative%20liberal%20brain&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tbo=u&tbs=nws:1&source=og&sa=N&tab=wn The study is covered by major news agencies and maninstream newspapers. And please see these links: 1. study published in Nature Neuroscience by New York University and UCLA scientists in 2007 http://www.latimes.com/news/obituaries/la-sci-politics10sep10,0,2687256.story, 2. online survey by psychologists in 2009 http://www.science20.com/adaptive_complexity/do_you_have_liberal_or_conservative_brain, 3. study in ''New Scientist'' in 2008 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/howie-klein/the-liberal-mind-vs-the-c_b_85898.html So we now have ''multiple'' studies. It is not """"the study"""", it is """"the studies"""". Given the sources, it meets """ Deletion of Differences between conservative and liberal brain WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
283 12618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joey Debus User:WWGB 13:03, 13 November 2013 (UTC) delete Not notable, fails and every other test. Sources are non-specific. Blatant self-promotion Deletion of Joey Debus WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
284 4285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Progressive stack (2nd nomination) User:Rhododendrites 23:54, 11 February 2015 (UTC) keep satisfies . Additional sources provided below --&mdash Deletion of Progressive stack (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
285 15084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohiudeen User:Bsimmons666 02:46, 28 December 2008 (UTC) delete Fails , blatant advertising Deletion of Mohiudeen WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
286 6437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Codikow User:Qworty 11:50, 28 November 2012 (UTC) delete Completely lacking in Deletion of David Codikow WP:42 Wikipedia:The answer to life, the universe, and everything 7
287 2890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Welch (2nd nomination) User:Umbralcorax 22:37, 9 May 2011 (UTC) merge to the appropriate list. Assuming that she doesn't meet the that is. As a former playboy playmate, her name is a plausible search term, and having a redlink for such an obviously plausible search term is unacceptable Deletion of Lisa Welch (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
288 14457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyrees Allen User:Atlantic306 20:06, 19 January 2016 (UTC) keep I agree that he meets because as well as films and tv he has appeared in notable stage productions on Broadway such as Aida and Henry IV Deletion of Tyrees Allen WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
289 7199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Family tree of Confucius in the main line of descent NONE NONE keep This is a terrible article, but it could be turned into a good one. At the moment, it is too focused on genealogical information and undoubtedly fails Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary#Wikipedia is not a genealogical dictionary#|WP:NOT. However, if you read Confucious#Descendants|the relevant section of the Confucius article, you will see multiple RSs making clear that Confucius' family line is notable (not merely that his descendants are notable, but the actual family tree is notable) and discussed in multiple RSs (as per ). I remember seeing coverage of the publication of the last edition of the genealogy on a China Central Television|CCTV national news bulletin. There's also a RS http://www.chinapost.com.tw/commentary/the-china-post/joe-hung/2009/07/27/217923/excess-bureaucratic.htm suggesting that a Republic of China (Taiwan) sinecure follows this family tree. All the information is verifiable (and ''pace'' {{u|Power~enwiki}}, |we don't require sources to be in English Deletion of Family tree of Confucius in the main line of descent WP:GNG||WP:NOENG Wikipedia:Notability 77
290 13897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Harris (North Carolina politician) User:SportingFlyer 20:23, 15 May 2018 (UTC) delete feels to me. There are a couple good articles about him so it's closer to a keep than most of the ones I'd vote for, but all of the articles are either directly related to his candidacy or are not sufficient for notability (the mention in the AP article, for instance.) The problem with political candidates are most articles about them are unless they are elected, and I don't see anything here that's not a run of the mill candidate article Deletion of Mark Harris (North Carolina politician) WP:TOOSOON||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Too soon 40
291 18833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zele Ismail (2nd nomination) User:GiantSnowman 12:08, 18 September 2009 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Zele Ismail (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
292 1278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HP Stream 7 User:SSTflyer 07:37, 8 December 2015 (UTC) keep obviously meets Deletion of HP Stream 7 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
293 20 [[Mo-D]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Dulciamus NONE keep Ziemlich eindeutig... Laut |RK Löschung von Mo-D Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
294 12368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yu Bo User:Hzh 12:51, 8 March 2019 (UTC) keep Sorry for piling in, but using as a rationale for a person suggests that the nominator is not aware of what the criteria for deletion might be. A search reveals plenty of sources on the person, major productions which he was part of and other future releases - http://yule.sohu.com/20160808/n463123665.shtmlhttp://ent.sina.com.cn/v/m/2017-02-08/doc-ifyaexzn9227285.shtmlhttp://ent.sina.com.cn/v/m/2016-01-05/doc-ifxneept3729506.shtmlhttp://ent.sina.com.cn/v/m/2017-10-12/doc-ifymvuys7798487.shtmlhttp://news.ldnews.cn/zhnews/entertion/201812/588587.shtmlhttp://www.sohu.com/a/299755125_412854, etc. Should easily qualify under and Deletion of Yu Bo WP:NCORP||WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
295 13455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of notable people who wore the bowler hat User:Xihr 06:23, 19 November 2008 (UTC) delete This is an |indiscriminate list. It's not that it's not referenced or notable, it's that it's |unencyclopedic Deletion of List of notable people who wore the bowler hat WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
296 5766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Renaissance (demogroup) [[user talk:Kvng|KvnG]] 16:17, 21 September 2014 (UTC) delete Thanks for the useful and civil discussion. Unfortunately, is persuasive here. There is not adequate reliable coverage to write a verifiable article on this topic Deletion of Renaissance (demogroup) WP:WHYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
297 14138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Super Rail Adventures User:Deor 01:49, 22 August 2008 (UTC) delete Fails . Appears to be something that exists only in a kid's mind (or as drawings in a school notebook Deletion of Super Rail Adventures WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
298 1726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SoftwareFreedomKosovo User:Xymmax 03:41, 5 September 2009 (UTC) delete I'm sorry, but I can not see how this even comes close to meeting inclusion criteria. Such coverage as has been mentioned here is pretty clearly the type of routine coverage contemplated by . It isn't notable based on English language sources, and while I normally prefer to err in favor of inclusion in possible language-bias cases, the fact that this was the first year of the conference makes me feel pretty comforatable that Gertrude Stein|there is no there there Deletion of SoftwareFreedomKosovo WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
299 19817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mami Matsui User:Miraclepine 16:46, 26 October 2019 (UTC) delete Just another Gundam seiyuu stub. gave me nothing of sufficient substance. While jawiki gave me two major roles unrelated to Gundam, one does not have a WP article and the other doesn't even list any characters, so that is weak Deletion of Mami Matsui WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
300 10641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julian Morgan User:BlueValour 00:18, 13 November 2006 (UTC) delete any article describing its subject as 'legendary' generally means 'in his own mind'. Fails Deletion of Julian Morgan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
301 20839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Violette Records User:Piotrus 04:52, 3 May 2019 (UTC) delete No indication this company passes Deletion of Violette Records WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
302 17461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Scott Hilk User:A 19:56, 20 March 2009 (UTC) delete per as I could not find any references on Google News, Google Scholar, or Google Books, let alone a regular Google Search. Suspected as well given the difficulty in finding any sources. Sincerely Deletion of James Scott Hilk WP:V||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
303 17626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Longshore Sailing School User:Gtstricky 21:03, 21 February 2008 (UTC) delete http://www.courageoussailing.org/kids/overview.html this teaching program also claims to be the largest. No reliable independent third party references to support |notbility Deletion of Longshore Sailing School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
304 2252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saide Ama User:ShadowHalo 22:42, 6 January 2007 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Saide Ama WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
305 14236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pure Jatomi Fitness User:Northamerica1000 05:55, 30 April 2014 (UTC) keep as meeting per coverage in mainstream (non-niche) publications, such as http://www.thestar.com.my/story.aspx/?file=%2f2012%2f12%2f1%2fbusiness%2f12300180&sec=business ''The Star'' and https://my.news.yahoo.com/art-fitness-160000751.html Yahoo News. It is also likely that additional Polish-language news sources cover this company Deletion of Pure Jatomi Fitness WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
306 7226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuwait Space Rocket User:4meter4 21:38, 1 March 2020 (UTC) keep Just because a news story includes an interview of those involved in a project, doesn't mean that the news story automatically should be treated as a primary source. Media coverage has editorial oversight and investigative research typically before going forward with a story. In this case, I think the criteria for is met Deletion of Kuwait Space Rocket WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
307 11520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cheese dog User:Northamerica1000 00:28, 4 August 2012 (UTC) comment spaced ndash}} Please read . Are you stating that the only reference available on the entire internet is a passing mention? Probably not. This is why exists, to distinguish between topic notability based upon the availability of sources versus the faulty notion of topic notability being based upon sources that may or may not exist in articles Deletion of Cheese dog WP:NRVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
308 8832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stacy Silver User:Malik 01:42, 28 July 2015 (UTC) delete Fails , , and . — Deletion of Stacy Silver WP:PORNBIO||WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
309 16592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dogface (book) User:Sagaciousphil 08:28, 9 May 2015 (UTC) delete """doesn't meet |book notability criteria, which requires at least two non trivial mentions. The Telegraph article linked above is not exactly reviewing the book, IMHO, as it is basically not saying anything more than """"Here's a pretty doggy picture book"""". The author doesn't seem to be |notable either""" Deletion of Dogface (book) WP:NBOOK||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
310 410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neda Agha-Soltan User:Corpx 06:59, 28 June 2009 (UTC) merge per . Most of the people commenting here are not addressing policy, but rather are commenting based on their views towards this person. She did not do anything notable before being killed and it's yet to be known if her death will have any long term notability Deletion of Neda Agha-Soltan WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
311 10028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/South Korea v Germany (2018 FIFA World Cup) User:Joseph2302 21:25, 6 December 2018 (UTC) delete not the most shocking result ever, the Daily Mail is sensationalist rubbish which can't be trusted, and not many other sources to pass Deletion of South Korea v Germany (2018 FIFA World Cup) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
312 12740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darryl Parker User:Hall 19:16, 20 September 2005 (UTC) delete quickly, borderline speedy deletion candidate as per A7 Deletion of Darryl Parker WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
313 10031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quantum aesthetics User:Coredesat 03:28, 30 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails , , and . Essays don't belong on Wikipedia Deletion of Quantum aesthetics WP:NOR||WP:NEO||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
314 16070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Brain Laboratory User:HighKing 13:32, 25 October 2017 (UTC) comment Both the IBL and the Simons Foundation and the Wellcome Trust https://www.internationalbrainlab.com/new-page-2/ released press releases on 19th September 2017 which coincides with the press articles. Clearly this shows that the article are based on information provided by the IBL and therefore fail Deletion of International Brain Laboratory WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
315 409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unofficial Graal Communication Center User:Steel359 23:22, 22 July 2006 (UTC) delete per |NOT a place for forums with only 280 members Deletion of Unofficial Graal Communication Center WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
316 3857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FIFA Street series soundtracks User:Stifle 18:22, 30 September 2007 (UTC) delete per points 1 and 3 Deletion of FIFA Street series soundtracks WP:LC Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
317 7324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laura Peter User:Peridon 19:24, 4 September 2010 (UTC) delete A non-notable candidate - by Wikipedia's standards . I'm sure her party colleagues who are making their first (and possibly last) edits here see her as the bee's knees. Unfortunately, being a candidate does not indicate notability here. (Candidates for President of the USA or Russia would be - but they would have pre-existing notability to get to that candidature.) As to MelanieN, I've always found her a fair editor here from her start - and would point out that she is a member of the Rescue Squadron for saving articles. (I'm not...) More Republicans being deleted? I can't give statistics, but I see quite a lot of AfD stuff - and to me there seem to be more Republican than Democrat candidates appearing and going again. But the Democrats do go too. Unless either is notable, they go. Me? I'm definitely neutral, not being an American (and regarding the political parties where I live with equal distaste). I couldn't care a tinker's damn what party anyone is from. They are either notable or they aren't - and here, please remember that it's our ball and our rules. (And our field too...) I would point out, too, that this is not a vote by numbers like a political election. It's a discussion. Prove that the subject of the article has notability - by our standards - and save the article. Otherwise, don't try to filibuster or swamp us with numbers Deletion of Laura Peter WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
318 326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional nurses User:Northamerica1000 17:24, 26 September 2017 (UTC) keep Qualifies for an article per relative to :Category:Fictional nurses Deletion of List of fictional nurses WP:NOTDUP Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
319 12246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave Canterbury User:Guoguo12 15:17, 14 August 2010 (UTC) delete """as the notability criteria at states that an entertainer is notable if he or she """"has had significant roles in ''multiple'' notable films, television shows, stage performances, or other productions""" Deletion of Dave Canterbury WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
320 6779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minigames of Final Fantasy User:Satellizer 00:40, 31 July 2019 (UTC) merge per , and who knows what else. No valid rationale has been provided on why the ''redirect'' should be deleted (and no, preventing future recreation is not a valid reason when the edit history shows only one attempt of such happening). I'm not one to assume bad faith, but I do consider it to be lying through omission how the nominator failed to acknowledge in his statement tgat the article has been a redirect for ''eight years'', until ''he himself recreated it and nominated it for deletion''(!?). This isn't what AfD is for, and it feels like to me Deletion of Minigames of Final Fantasy WP:CHEAP||WP:DEADHORSE||WP:GAMING Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
321 6694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J.B. Gaynor User:Cobaltbluetony 16:31, 17 April 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. Insufficient refs. avail. to establish |notability. - Deletion of J.B. Gaynor WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
322 9131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fully undetectable User:Reyk 09:24, 5 December 2019 (UTC) delete This doesn't rise much above and as the nom points out, conflates two separate uses of the term. And I'm not sure is an actual article could be written about either of them Deletion of Fully undetectable WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
323 21263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stipula User:AllyD 16:29, 1 March 2019 (UTC) delete Blog entries indicate that the original company encountered financial problems around 6 years ago and was acquired by another firm (Antiche Fabbriche Firenze), but I am not finding reliable sources which could support material on ownership (or whether production continues) or anything beyond listing sites for the past products. Not sufficient for or Deletion of Stipula :WP:NCORP||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
324 5603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timothy Stanley User:David 19:24, 30 June 2009 (UTC) delete Neither the article nor the various Google searches that I tried provide any indication of the academic impact that would lead to a pass of #1, nor that his ideas have become sufficiently widespread in the popular press to pass more generally Deletion of Timothy Stanley WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
325 10408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All About You (film) User:Tokyogirl79 08:46, 27 May 2014 (UTC) keep """or |speedy keep after an expected withdrawal). To {{u|Boleyn}}: With respects, being |neglected is a reason to use some and fix, not delete. See . To {{u|Johnny338}}: Simply lacking citations does not automatically make a sourcable topic """"original research"""". And while yes, the article as first https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=All_About_You_%28film%29&diff=610239292&oldid=610239015 nominated had issues, they were |addresable. A little |research and editing by""" Deletion of All About You (film) WP:SK||WP:NEGLECT||WP:BEFORE||WP:NOTCLEANUP||WP:HANDLE||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
326 9318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UH-60 Black Hawk in popular culture User:Blaxthos 22:31, 19 March 2007 (UTC) delete WP:NOT#DIR|Wikipedia articles are not lists of loosely associated topics also fails and other reasons stated by Deletion of UH-60 Black Hawk in popular culture WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
327 7021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agile CRM User:SamHolt6 01:57, 14 February 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and . Potential sources for this company tend to 1. Only list it as part of a listing of CMR companies (See the article's award section for examples of this) or 2. Are announcements of new services being offered by Agile CRM. Nothing indicates why Agile is particularly notable among other CMR companies, or makes a case for the encyclopedic notability of the company Deletion of Agile CRM WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
328 14108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blaine Cooper User:NewsAndEventsGuy 07:45, 15 January 2016 (UTC) merge So far as I have seen there is no basis for otability|Notability (as Wikipedia uses that word Deletion of Blaine Cooper WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
329 15039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2004 LaSalle County, Illinois earthquake User:De 22:29, 2 March 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of 2004 LaSalle County, Illinois earthquake WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
330 5153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul R. Fleischman User:Bearian 13:35, 8 August 2017 (UTC) delete the award he got was minor, and none of the other information is |verifiable Deletion of Paul R. Fleischman WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
331 4658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/State leaders by year User:Davewild 19:09, 16 July 2007 (UTC) keep This meets (in chronological order and 'lists can be used as a table of contents'), it is part of a wikiproject and has red links showing which years have been done. A disucssion has been ongoing on splitting which I would support as it is overlong but that is not an issue for AFD Deletion of State leaders by year WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
332 15952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Centaurs in popular culture User:Wikisaurus NONE delete A list of random mentions of centaurs. One should not keep such an obvious Deletion of Centaurs in popular culture WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
333 18619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flordemayo User:Gaijin42 13:52, 3 June 2013 (UTC) delete per nom. Deletion of Flordemayo WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
334 3184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Am Also a Human User:Alexandermcnabb 13:45, 18 May 2021 (UTC) delete compelling plot summary apart, this fails . Best Deletion of I Am Also a Human WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
335 10100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Smith (cricketer, born 1988) User:Lugnuts 07:45, 27 October 2015 (UTC) keep Meets . Has played first-class and List A cricket for South Australia cricket team Deletion of James Smith (cricketer, born 1988) WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
336 12339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergey Renev User:Kevin 20:31, 3 December 2020 (UTC) keep """as page creator. Meets , so nominator's """"non-notable individual"""" is his/her opinion, not true according to established policy""" Deletion of Sergey Renev WP:NCYC Wikipedia:Notability 77
337 12240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Javier Flores User:Dissolve 05:26, 10 September 2008 (UTC) delete Lacks #Sources|reliable sources and thus fails to meet , Deletion of Javier Flores WP:V||WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
338 15539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Writing Short Stories User:Truthkeeper88 13:19, 18 January 2011 (UTC) delete per , and '''comment''' - if Kesha495 is writing this for a school assignment, they should explain to the teacher why the article was deleted and perhaps consider working on another short story article Deletion of Writing Short Stories WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
339 7785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Fessler (2nd nomination) User:Ammarpad 11:26, 31 December 2017 (UTC) keep Perhaps you nominate the wrong article not the one you intended. Besides numerous points highlighted above, he also passes #8. He has been editor in chief of peer-reviewed academic journal Evolution and Human Behavior. Thus passing multiple criteria. Though the article is in bad shape, but that is not reason for deletion Deletion of Daniel Fessler (2nd nomination) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
340 3365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave Patten User:Joe 01:59, 3 February 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |musician Deletion of Dave Patten WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
341 19687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allan Fraser (musician) User:Armbrust 18:40, 20 May 2010 (UTC) delete to Fraser & DeBolt as article fails Deletion of Allan Fraser (musician) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
342 6426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spells in Harry Potter (3rd nomination) User:Bfigura 03:38, 21 August 2007 (UTC) keep """and improve. As noted in the first deletion debate, there are secondary sources which can (and should) be cited. But even if there weren't, I think the primary sources would be sufficient. To quote from : """"...there are rare occasions when they may rely on primary sources. An article or section of an article that relies on a primary source should (1) only make descriptive claims, the accuracy of which is easily verifiable by any reasonable, educated person without specialist knowledge, and (2) make no analytic, synthetic, interpretive, explanatory, or evaluative claims. Contributors drawing on primary sources should be careful to comply with both conditions."""" I think this applies""" Deletion of Spells in Harry Potter (3rd nomination) WP:PSTS Wikipedia:No original research 65
343 3632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Live-action wargame [[User talk:64.183.45.226|talk]]) 18:16, 6 April 2017 (UTC) delete or at the very least, '''Redirect''' to LARP. Searches bring up nearly nothing, and the few things that do come up are not from reliable sources. Most of them are nothing but announcements of upcoming events, and many of them seem to be using the term synonymous to regular LARPing. The article was created well over a decade ago, and the fact that no sources have really been created in that time span leads me to believe that this was nothing more than a that never became a thing. Special:Contributions/64.183.45.226|64.183.45.226 Deletion of Live-action wargame WP:NEOLOGISM Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
344 20913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AccessPlace User:Wine 22:16, 27 July 2006 (UTC) delete all articles without independently |verifiable |sources Deletion of AccessPlace WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
345 4208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IDAMS User:Sovereign 12:07, 10 September 2015 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of IDAMS WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
346 21911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/British National Party leadership election, 1999 User:Nizolan 21:53, 30 March 2016 (UTC) keep Regardless of the existence of other articles, and despite the small number of votes in the election, this seems like a notable chapter in the BNP's history with a fair amount of independent scholarly coverage (https://www.google.com/search?tbm=bks&q=Nick+Griffin+tyndall+1999), so passes the . I've fixed the vote counts in the article and added a source. If it's a cut and paste then it should be tagged as a split rather than deleted Deletion of British National Party leadership election, 1999 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
347 10858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ravi's International User:HighKing 16:59, 21 April 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Ravi's International WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
348 112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Earl Blackfoot User:MordeKyle 20:11, 2 February 2017 (UTC) delete This page is a violation of as the subject of the article has not been convicted of this crime. Also a violation of Deletion of Joseph Earl Blackfoot WP:BLPCRIME||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
349 20686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UXO! AN UNPERCEIVED THREAT User:Alexius08 06:17, 18 May 2008 (UTC) delete as #G1|patent nonsense Deletion of UXO! AN UNPERCEIVED THREAT WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
350 8763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Bong-han User:Ceosad 22:26, 3 July 2015 (UTC) keep or '''merge''' with Primo-vascular system, if it is kept or no consensus is reached out there. If we are going to delete this, we would as well need to massacre quite a few half-finished pseudoscience (biography) articles involved with homeopathy or associated nonsense. As long as enough people believe in primo-vascular systems it is good enough to stay in Wikipedia. We are more a Humanism|humanist project than a positivist one, and all (notable) information should be equal. It is probably better to delete the primo-vascular system article and keep this person here, if we are having a single article, just in case this person has done something else during his career. Also, regarding discoveries on human body: There have been a few new tiny parts (re)discovered on humans in the past few years. Like Dua's layer or the rediscovered Vertical occipital fasciculus. Took more than 85 years to find that one again. Those articles are in quite a bad shape too, so some is indeed needed Deletion of Kim Bong-han WP:FIXIT Wikipedia:Be bold 9
351 18824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrian & the Mysterious D User:JoshuaZ 17:49, 25 April 2006 (UTC) delete It isn't clear to me under what guidelines DJ's fall, possibly (which they don't meet) or (which they don't meet). Assuming that DJ's are not treated with either of these guidelines, this pair is just not notable Deletion of Adrian & the Mysterious D WP:BAND||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
352 1774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Messed Up User:Herostratus 14:08, 27 December 2006 (UTC) delete Non-notable webcomic, no third-party citations included or likely available, therefore fails notability and Deletion of Messed Up WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
353 14078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riese the Series User:Accounting4Taste 16:26, 24 September 2009 (UTC) comment The IMDb is not considered a |reliable source for this information. See Wikipedia:Citing IMDb Deletion of Riese the Series WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
354 18524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khayyam Street User:Oakshade 05:58, 7 July 2017 (UTC) keep This does appear to be one of the main thoroughfares in Tehran. Not only is it deemed major enough to have a metro station, Khayam Metro Station, but three stations serve it - Meydan-e Mohammadiyeh Metro Station and Panzdah-e-Khordad Metro Station with the street being the main inner-city route for Tehran Metro Line 1. It's also the location of the Courthouse of Tehran. There is no way such a major street in such a major and historical city isn't notable. Most coverage is likely in Persian which makes it difficult for English speakers. See Deletion of Khayyam Street WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
355 2069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magomed Magomedkerimov User:Newshunter12 09:34, 25 June 2019 (UTC) delete Fails since he has never had a top tier fight. All the sources are coverage and not sustained , so the article also fails Deletion of Magomed Magomedkerimov WP:NMMA||WP:ROUTINE||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
356 9040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caltroit User:Esradekan 21:39, 3 June 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of Caltroit WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
357 4984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rogers Hall User:Mikeman67 16:18, 4 March 2014 (UTC) keep Changing my vote here to keep after Altairisfar pointed out it's on the National Register of Historic Places. Personally I'm not convinced that being listed guarantees notability (the notability requirements for the National Register may be very different than Wikipedia's, so I don't see why we should adopt theirs), but I can see the building had some significant events occurring in the past that sufficiently meet , including the camping of Union and Confederate troops on its grounds {{NRHP url|id=74000415|title Deletion of Rogers Hall WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
358 2154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Great Kathmandu (2nd nomination) User:JasonNox 01:35, 26 August 2006 (UTC) keep I feel it meets the and guidelines. I live in didsbury and know of this establishment. I will see if I can dig up some stuff to add to the page Deletion of The Great Kathmandu (2nd nomination) WP:CORP||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
359 5928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Horwitz (2nd nomination) User:NeoChaosX 09:42, 25 March 2007 (UTC) delete as the person is in no way meeting the notability guideline Deletion of Jim Horwitz (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
360 20077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jagmandar Dass Jain User:Top 00:49, 20 October 2010 (UTC) delete fails , no significant coverage online from eliable sources, evident by article's creator Deletion of Jagmandar Dass Jain WP:BIO||WP:R||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
361 9111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frosmo User:Northamerica1000 09:42, 10 June 2016 (UTC) keep The company meets , albeit on a weak level, having received |significant coverage in two Byline|bylined news articles published by |reliable sources. Source examples are listed below. Also, the article does not have a particularly promotional tone. It does not extol the benefits or greatness of the company, nor does it encourage readers to do business with the company in any manner. The article also includes criticism of some of the company's products, which is certainly not advertising. The article simply provides a neutral overview of this software company Deletion of Frosmo WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
362 6232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JK! Studios User:K 01:46, 3 August 2019 (UTC) delete does not meet / . Sourcing is in passing and / or Deletion of JK! Studios WP:NORG||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:SPIP Wikipedia:Notability 77
363 8896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skulltag User:Daniel 05:59, 27 November 2006 (UTC) delete WP:SOFTWARE and / Deletion of Skulltag WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
364 11763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter Sickert and The Army of Broken Toys User:Dweller 16:10, 25 April 2007 (UTC) delete No current evidence that this band passes Deletion of Walter Sickert and The Army of Broken Toys WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
365 10358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Runes of Mystery User:Alexandra 13:12, 18 January 2021 (UTC) delete """I cannot find any coverage in |reliable sources. The article was claiming that it had seen """"mixed reviews"""" according to Metacritic, but this was a total fabrication - the MC page has zero reviews listed""" Deletion of Runes of Mystery WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
366 18991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Culture of fear User:WookieInHeat 13:30, 23 November 2010 (UTC) comment all the 'keep' comments posted on the 23rd were the result of ing by {{User|Hauskalainen}}, none have addressed the issue of or . in addition, more content and refs were added to the article by the same user, all of it OR Deletion of Culture of fear WP:CANVAS||WP:OR||WP:RS Wikipedia:Canvassing 93
367 13667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FN P90 in popular culture (2nd nomination) User:Yomangani 01:05, 29 September 2006 (UTC) comment suggest a speedy close - nomination seems to be after a disputed merge. AFD is not for content disputes Deletion of FN P90 in popular culture (2nd nomination) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
368 6421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donkovica User:BloodDoll 22:00, 27 July 2014 (UTC) delete clearly not notable per Deletion of Donkovica WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
369 9121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernard Holliday User:Scopecreep 09:00, 3 April 2012 (UTC) merge per Gene93k above. Currently fails , but what's here is worth merging. A big chunk of the article isn't about Holliday, but about election background that he says prompted him to run, and that's all worth merging too Deletion of Bernard Holliday WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
370 2659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled Friday the 13th Sequel User:Wimt 08:55, 20 May 2007 (UTC) delete per all of the above. The article goes against #CRYSTALBALL and lacks any meaningful information, plus the only reference is an equally incomplete IMDB entry Deletion of Untitled Friday the 13th Sequel WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
371 20092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monique Edwards User:I 00:39, 26 September 2013 (UTC) delete per Bearian. No evidence of major acting career, no evidence of ample coverage in |reliable sources Deletion of Monique Edwards WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
372 320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Left Bank Outfall Drain User:Capitals00 12:52, 27 April 2018 (UTC) delete Sources are and circulated across internet through sources that are ultimately related with the primary source. Lack of independent coverage in third party sources Deletion of Left Bank Outfall Drain WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
373 21773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jade Leonard User:Hobbes 02:40, 9 October 2011 (UTC) delete Fails |notability for lack of substantial sources. I looked around, but the two secondary source links in the article, from the Moonee Valley Community News and the Moonee Valley Leader, are as good as it gets. Peeked at her http://www.last.fm/music/Jade+Leonard last.fm page to make sure I wasn't missing a hidden groundswell. A grand total of 22 listeners ever; over the past 6 months, a grand total of 3 song listens Deletion of Jade Leonard WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
374 12525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phantasia (video game) User:Kindzmarauli 15:29, 10 March 2016 (UTC) delete sadly. It sounds like this was important at one time, unfortunately I can't find any sources discussing it and USENET posts don't satisfy the requirements of Deletion of Phantasia (video game) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
375 19730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Japanese American Evacuation of 1942 User:HumbleGod 00:20, 19 July 2006 (UTC) comment are we at the point where we can get a '''speedy delete''' per ? It's pretty clear that this particular article is a POV-fork, and that the real dispute lies with the content in Japanese American internment. Ending this AfD discussion would facilitate the improvement of ''that'' article, which is the outcome everyone's looking for Deletion of Japanese American Evacuation of 1942 WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
376 17477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William J. Ecker User:Necrothesp 14:16, 6 May 2014 (UTC) keep Flag officers are considered notable under Deletion of William J. Ecker WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
377 15299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Meyer (author) User:Stormbay 22:14, 5 June 2013 (UTC) delete I agree with the assessment. I did not find any credible notability references Deletion of Thomas Meyer (author) WP:ARTSPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
378 1456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Patrick Clarke User:Otto4711 14:21, 4 December 2009 (UTC) keep role in Eight is Enough clears the threshold of Deletion of Brian Patrick Clarke WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
379 17311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tour CB16 User:Bec 05:46, 28 December 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Tour CB16 WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
380 8534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of India Hospitals, Ambulance, Blood Banks, Pharmacy and all other Medical Amenities User:Dougofborg 12:04, 15 April 2009 (UTC) delete Not Deletion of List of India Hospitals, Ambulance, Blood Banks, Pharmacy and all other Medical Amenities WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
381 19758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susanna Kantanen User:Jujucabana 14:45, 31 October 2020 (UTC) keep She passes because she won her country's senior national championship Deletion of Susanna Kantanen WP:NSKATE Wikipedia:Notability 77
382 4830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nightmare on Elm Street Companion User:Mitaphane 03:40, 27 September 2006 (UTC) delete per . The website link is already covered on the ''Nightmare...'' article Deletion of Nightmare on Elm Street Companion WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
383 17244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cute Babulja User:CIreland 02:28, 15 May 2007 (UTC) keep Satisfies specifically, ''2. Has had a charted hit on any national music chart Deletion of Cute Babulja WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
384 15080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Egyptian hypothesis User:Tercer 12:45, 24 January 2021 (UTC) delete I'm amazed that there is even a discussion here. This is an obvious and must be deleted. Regardless of the merits of the article, a POVFORK is emphatically not the way to solve a disagreement about content Deletion of Black Egyptian hypothesis WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
385 9911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trains (video game) User:Harlem675 13:44, 18 July 2009 (UTC) delete As far as I can see, It doesnt meet Deletion of Trains (video game) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
386 14042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Dewayne Hughes [[User talk:202.124.88.7|talk]]) 08:17, 17 July 2013 (UTC) delete Clearly fails , with a h-index of 0. His book appears on no searches at all. News coverage is negligible. Fails , and as far as I can tell he fails as well. -- Special:Contributions/202.124.88.7|202.124.88.7 Deletion of Kevin Dewayne Hughes WP:PROF||WP:GNG||WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
387 17486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DisSpam User:Schuym1 00:55, 13 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of DisSpam WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
388 16145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Visevic User:Robwingfield 14:41, 25 May 2007 (UTC) delete as the player has not yet played in a professional league, per . The ''World Club Championship'' is a cup competition, not a professional league Deletion of Daniel Visevic WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
389 16637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Treanor User:Kvng NONE keep Meets as per point 5 (named chair at major institution). tone can be fixed and is not a valid reason for deletion in itself Deletion of Brian Treanor WP:SCHOLAR||WP:NACADEMICS||WP:PROMOTIONAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
390 19763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sparkle (game) User:Anetode 07:09, 17 November 2005 (UTC) delete Original research. Wouldn't this qualify as a candidate for A2 Deletion of Sparkle (game) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
391 13769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nubiles.net User:Exit2DOS2000 02:24, 11 July 2011 (UTC) delete recreation of previously speedied material. The first 3 Cites dont really denote notability, and the second 2 are about the actions of ContentRemove.com and only make passing mention of this website. Sorry, IMO, Nubiles.net just isnt otable yet. Exit2DOS Deletion of Nubiles.net WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
392 4640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allied technology of Command & Conquer User:Pete 19:35, 11 November 2007 (UTC) delete Game cruft. Not a single reference, let alone a reliable secondary source to establish the encyclopedic notability of this topic. must be satisified by an secondary source, this comes no where close. Transwiki it if you like, but this is essentially a fan essay, and just doesn't belong in an encyclopedia, be it paper or not Deletion of Allied technology of Command & Conquer WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
393 20930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of senior career goals scored by Cristiano Ronaldo User:Microwave 00:04, 11 July 2020 (UTC) delete per . This is clearly not what an encyclopedia is for Deletion of List of senior career goals scored by Cristiano Ronaldo WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
394 19249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eagles Nest Outfitters User:Citobun 13:45, 13 October 2016 (UTC) delete run of the mill |article spam for non-notable company Deletion of Eagles Nest Outfitters WP:ARTSPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
395 18 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lin Liangming User:Fenix 12:10, 6 November 2015 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Lin Liangming WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
396 3779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Schirmer User:Mdtemp 16:20, 24 June 2013 (UTC) delete Doesn't quite meet or Deletion of Bob Schirmer WP:MANOTE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
397 9335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Worrell and James Duell User:AmericanAir88 16:22, 3 August 2019 (UTC) delete per . John Pack says it right, violation of the not memorial guidelines Deletion of Larry Worrell and James Duell WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
398 12370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/V-Battalion User:BOZ 19:40, 21 April 2021 (UTC) keep if sources can be found, otherwise '''merge''' to List of Marvel Comics teams and organizations per and Deletion of V-Battalion WP:ATD||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
399 18245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amon Olive Assemon User:Hmlarson 00:01, 11 May 2018 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Amon Olive Assemon WP:SPORTSPERSON Wikipedia:Notability 77
400 10692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tremors 5 User:Erik 19:51, 25 June 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Tremors 5 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
401 3164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maha el-Samnah (2nd nomination) User:E 18:12, 19 July 2017 (UTC) merge and selectively merge to Khadr family. Really, there is very little her to support notability; heavily oversourced; noclear claim to notability. lacking . Many sources merely mention this woman in article about her family, others are from minor, perhaps unreliable sources Deletion of Maha el-Samnah (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
402 21548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NAFA 2017 User:Eggishorn 21:00, 24 February 2017 (UTC) keep Appears to have independent, significant coverage in Deletion of NAFA 2017 WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
403 12160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matti Uaelesi User:Sir 19:38, 18 October 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. He fails , since it does not cover futsal national teams as playing for them does not necessarily generate significant coverage, and since hasn't played in a fully pro league or the 11-a side national team. In the absence of significant coverage also fails Deletion of Matti Uaelesi WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
404 14929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Foreign Body (internet series) User:Alzarian16 19:04, 28 January 2011 (UTC) keep The sources already in the article plus the ones listed by Milowent would appear to just about take this over the boundary required by . Could be merged to an article on the novel at some time in the future, but certainly don't delete Deletion of Foreign Body (internet series) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
405 170 [[GONZoverlag]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Magiers NONE keep Kasten|1=. Die #Verlage sind mit mindestens drei bekannten Autoren erfüllt. Allerdings ist der Artikel noch sehr unenzyklopädisch und werblich. Gruß Löschung von GONZoverlag Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
406 16846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ponte del Paradiso User:Matthiaspaul 16:08, 28 July 2015 (UTC) keep This stub clearly needs expansion and references, but Google turns up with quite a number of hits, there is an article about this bridge in another WP as well as in another wiki about Venice (http://www.venipedia.org/wiki/index.php?title=Ponte_de_l%27Arsenal_o_del_Paradiso). Cavarrone above already came up with a larger treatise on the subject and I'm sure if we dig a little deeper, more sources can be turned up. I see our basic notability criteria for geographic features fulfilled per , therefore I'm confident the article will grow, if given the necessary time to grow Deletion of Ponte del Paradiso WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
407 18360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Losing streak (sport) User:Lankiveil 00:22, 8 July 2008 (UTC) keep at the risk of invoking , I don't see why this article can't be developed into something like Winning streak (sports). Yes, the quality of the article right now is poor, but that's not a good reason to delete Deletion of Losing streak (sport) WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
408 16199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Holly User:Lradrama 13:13, 27 July 2007 (UTC) delete doesn't meet what's required in Deletion of Terry Holly WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
409 9160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Journey to Alpha Centauri (In Real Time) User:Jovanmilic97 22:01, 25 July 2020 (UTC) merge to Only You Can Save Mankind#Ideas and themes as a where it's mentioned. It has no coverage needed for a separate article per , but it can be preserved. I added a source (and probably a bit more reliable than a Pratchet fan book club podcast) at the novel's article that also verifies 3000 years. Nothing to merge here as 1) it's all unsourced and 2) the target article I mentioned has it all Deletion of Journey to Alpha Centauri (In Real Time) WP:ATD||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
410 12005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hiromi Hirata User:Opheicus 02:04, 1 December 2012 (UTC) keep I am the editor of this page and believe that she is notable. First, according to , she would be notable if she has had a release on a national music chart. Refer to her page on Oricon at http://www.oricon.co.jp/prof/artist/248346/ranking/cd_album/ and you will find that her releases have charted at 21st and 23rd. Moreover, she would be considered notable by virtue of , having had significant roles in multiple series such as in Idolmaster, Zoids, and Read or Die Deletion of Hiromi Hirata WP:MUSICBIO||WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
411 13780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Google's hoaxes (2nd nomination) User:Colonel 16:15, 30 June 2011 (UTC) keep The idea that Google could do something like this and escape notice is absurd. When one looks for sources, they are immediately apparent, such as http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=ZfkxoUXqJwUC&pg=PT237 this. seems not to have been followed and so the nomination is therefore frivolous/vexatious Deletion of Google's hoaxes (2nd nomination) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
412 15135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roger Lolly User:Brewcrewer 01:38, 1 August 2008 (UTC) delete Doesn't come close to meeting the notability requirements. Has not received significant coverage (if any coverage) in reliable sources Deletion of Roger Lolly WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
413 12278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of NFL records held by Jerry Rice User:Secret 22:16, 22 January 2009 (UTC) delete """|original research, also rather reduntlant trivia. Yes Rice broke many records, but many of these aren't notable records or records caused by his longitivty. The only records worth mentioning is the career records, and maybe a few of the touchdown records, and that could be fit in the Rice article easily. Some of the records listed for example """"Touchdown receptions made in one state(California, 115) """" are clear made-up and extremely reduntlant |original research, and it seems like it was written just to find a record we can add in these stats. If Rice owns the record for most receptions, and played his entire career in California, isn't that obvious. Many of these """"records"""" has these problems. For many of the people who said that AFD isn't cleanup therefore keep, I looked though this article, and it's unsalvageable, which is a reason for deletion""" Deletion of List of NFL records held by Jerry Rice WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
414 9286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Isle of Mechanical Men User:SingToMePlease 02:39, 4 April 2011 (UTC) keep """per otability (books)#Criteria|otability: Criteria 5. """"The book's author is so historically significant that any of his or her written works may be considered notable. This does not simply mean that the book's author is him/herself notable by Wikipedia's standards; rather, the book's author is of exceptional significance and the author's life and body of work would be a common study subject in literature classes."""" Wikipedia:Notability (books)#Coverage notes|Coverage notes tells us """"Though the concept of """"book"""" is widely defined, this guideline does not yet provide specific notability criteria for the following types of publications: comic books; graphic novels (although it does apply to manga); magazines; etc."""" Additionally, verifiability and reliable sources are required for material that is contentious or likely to be challenged, and quotations. The article on """"Isle"""" is not likely to be challenged, contains no contentious material and no quotations. I prefer the article be kept and given the chance for development. It was created only a week ago""" Deletion of The Isle of Mechanical Men WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
415 17601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Garrett User:Cameron 23:47, 29 May 2009 (UTC) delete Fails no RS of him or his books (and remember the fact that he's written books is not enough, it's that people have written about *him* or the books Deletion of Chris Garrett WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
416 13579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rabid Babies User:Lockley 05:54, 9 February 2006 (UTC) delete per Tito who said it best -- Deletion of Rabid Babies WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
417 501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Birmingham Sailing Club User:Ammodramus 02:46, 27 April 2017 (UTC) delete Google and Google News searches turn up no independent in-depth coverage. Passing mentions, quotes from members, directory entries, and the club's own website, but nothing else. Fairly clear fail Deletion of Birmingham Sailing Club WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
418 52 [[Kosmische Energie]] (erl) Benutzer:NCC1291 NONE delete Der Artikel verstößt sogar gegen . Als Vertreter der Energiewirtschaft muss ich für dieses Geschwurbel natürlich stellen Löschung von Kosmische Energie Wikipedia:AüF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
419 17946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scooter Berry (3rd nomination) User:Cbl62 23:22, 15 April 2011 (UTC) keep College football players who have received significant non-trivial coverage in the mainstream media are eligible for inclusion under . The overwhelming majority of college football players do not meet that standard, and very few defensive players (or linemen of any type) get that kind of media attention. But Berry clearly does. He even meets #College_athletes since he has received coverage in the national media. He was a key defensive player on the 2007 West Virginia Mountaineers football team that beat #3 Oklahoma in the Fiesta Bowl and wound up as the #6 team in the country. I could compile a much longer list, but examples of non-trivial media coverage about Berry include: '''(1)''' http://espn.go.com/blog/bigeast/post/_/id/11785/scooter-berry-looking-to-make-up-for-lost-09 Scooter Berry looking to atone for lost '09, ESPN, 9/2/10, '''(2)''' http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/newsday/access/1187675271.html?dids=1187675271:1187675271&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Dec+31%2C+2006&author=GREGG+SARRA.+STAFF+WRITER&pub=Newsday+(Combined+editions)&desc=Berry+leaves+Gwaltney's+shadow%2C+carves+out+promising+WVU+situation&pqatl=google Berry leaves Gwaltney's shadow, carves out promising WVU situation, Newsday, 12/31/06, '''(3)''' http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/09287/1005244-144.stm West Virginia's Berry slowly recovering, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 10/14/09, '''(4)''' http://www.newsday.com/sports/college/scooter-berry-anchors-defensive-line-at-west-virginia-1.1408680 Scooter Berry anchors defensive line at West Virginia, Newsday, 8/30/09, '''(5)''' http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=4580220 WVU suspends Berry indefinitely, ESPN, 10/20/09, '''(6)''' http://timeswv.com/wvu_sports/x1243790780/Berry-gearing-up-for-comeback-year Berry gearing up for comeback year, Times West Virginian, 8/9/10, '''(7)'''' http://www.dailymail.com/Sports/201008080409 Now or nothing' season for Berry, McClatchy-Tribune Regional News, 8/9/10, '''(8)''' http://vlex.com/vid/berry-ready-emerge-shadow-his-brother-64276241 Berry ready to emerge from shadow of his brother, Charleston Gazette, 8/17/06, '''(9)''' http://timeswv.com/wvu_sports/x1293915449/HERTZEL-COLUMN-Berry-no-stranger-to-Backyard-Brawl Berry no stranger to Backyard Brawl, Times West Virginian, 11/23/10, '''(10)''' http://pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/sports/college/s_696358.html WVU's Berry: 'I'm back', Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, 8/25/10, '''(11)''' http://www.register-herald.com/collegesports/x1316177235/Berry-primed-to-be-D-leader Berry primed to be ‘D’ leader, The Register-Herald, 8/16/10, '''(12)''' http://msn.foxsports.com/collegefootball/story/WVU-FOOTBALLOld-man-of-theDSixyear-vet-Berry-ready-for-one-last-goround-56062980 WVU FOOTBALL Old man of the D Six-year vet Berry ready for one last go-round, Charleston Gazette, 8/9/10, '''(13)''' DT Berry: 'I feel like I'm about 40': Determined to leave his woes behind, McClatchy-Tribune Regional News, 8/8/10, '''(14)''' Ruckus costs Berry, Newsday, 11/13/09, '''(15)''' BERRY'S SLOW RECOVERY HELPS BUILD DEPTH IN LINE, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 10/14/09, '''(15)''' Berry expects to play, McClatchy-Tribune Regional News, 10/7/09, '''(16)''' http://timeswv.com/bob_herzel/x20303756/HERTZEL-COLUMN-Berry-hoping-to-find-field-Saturday Berry hoping to find field Saturday, Times West Virginian, 9/17/09, '''(17)''' http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-20649054.html Berry savors role as leader, Charleston Gazette (and McClatchy-Tribune Regional News), 8/17/09, '''(18)''' Junior tackle Berry putting in his summer work, The Jackson Herald, 6/9/09, '''(19)''' http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-18931035.html Bowl could be reunion for Berry and his mom, Charleston Gazette, 12/19/08, '''(20)''' Berry, half-brother go different directions, Times West Virginian, 11/24/08, '''(21)''' Waiting for WVU offense to become Berry good, too, McClatchy-Tribune Regional News, 10/5/08, '''(22)''' http://timeswv.com/bob_herzel/x681684625/WVU-s-Berry-making-name-for-himself WVU's Berry making name for himself, Times West Virginian, 10/5/08, '''(23)''' http://bdtonline.com/localsports/x519526076/Berry-anxious-to-start-Mountaineer-football-season/print Berry anxious to start Mountaineer football season, McClatchy-Tribune Regional News, 8/28/08, '''(24)''' http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-16731508.html WVU's Scooter Berry doesn't miss offense, Charleston Daily Mail, 6/16/08, '''(25)''' Berry is young leader on D-line, Times West Virginian, 6/12/08, '''(26)''' Berry is 'looking forward to playing a leadership role', The Register-Herald (Beckley, WV), 6/11/08, '''(27)''' http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-15537077.html Berry is accepting leadership role at WVU, Charleston Daily Mail, 3/19/08, '''(28)''' http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-9983034.html Gwaltney's half-brother emerging: Scooter Berry will start on the Mountaineer defensive line Saturday, Charleston Daily Mail, 8/28/07 Deletion of Scooter Berry (3rd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NSPORTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
420 1296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omofo User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable podcast. Reposting it later when it is notable is a good idea. &mdash Deletion of Omofo WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
421 20934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Darker Shades of White User:Esradekan 10:46, 2 June 2009 (UTC) keep """passes #Albums for ''""""significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject""""''. Reviews http://www.jesusfreakhideout.com/cdreviews/TheDarkerShadesofWhite.asp here, http://www.absolutepunk.net/showthread.php?t=962672 here, http://www.sputnikmusic.com/album.php?albumid=35571 here, http://www.indievisionmusic.com/wordpress/2009/03/04/corpus-christi-the-darker-shades-of-white/ here, http://www.thrashmag.com/reviews/content.aspx?id=2519 here, http://www.rockline.it/review3592.html and here""" Deletion of The Darker Shades of White WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
422 15671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Nicholl (footballer) User:Jogurney 19:55, 12 May 2009 (UTC) delete Article has been unreferenced for two years and there is no evidence that it satisfies either or Deletion of David Nicholl (footballer) WP:N||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
423 9920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nelly's sixth studio album User:Doomsdayer520 18:53, 17 April 2010 (UTC) delete I agree with Michig that the album will probably soon be a reality and this article will have to be re-created, but the sources are not reliable and and are relevant guidelines Deletion of Nelly's sixth studio album WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
424 3998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southern Arizona Pride User:Bearian 21:24, 16 December 2013 (UTC) delete but only because it is too new and there are not yet |enough reliable sources with |significant coverage to make a decent |stub. I've done some on-line searches, and have |verified its existence and am satisfied that it is '''not''' fraudulent. I need to emphasize that recognition or non-recognition by the IRS is irrelevant to is veracity; DavidA373's ''ad hominem'' to the contrary borders on the intersection of homophobia and defamation. The I.R.S. allows many different types of non-profits, from 528s to the Elks Lodges, some of which are charities, but most are not. On the other hand, its Wikipedia:Existence ≠ Notability|verifiability doesn't make it notable Deletion of Southern Arizona Pride WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV||WP:STUB||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
425 11980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Continuous Call Team network stations User:Kntrabssi 05:09, 10 April 2007 (UTC) delete per |WWIN Deletion of Continuous Call Team network stations WP:WWIN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
426 462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Barnes User:Xxanthippe 21:42, 28 November 2016 (UTC) delete Early career academic. Only possibility for keep is a technical pass of the #C8 guideline. Probably oo soon as now Deletion of Elizabeth Barnes WP:PROF||WP:T Wikipedia:Notability 77
427 16188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gravewalkaz User:Walton_monarchist89 19:39, 25 February 2007 (UTC) delete even if the band exists, the article admits that they've never been signed by a major record label, and there are no independent sources to demonstrate notability per . In fact, might even be '''speedy delete''' under A7, as I can't see that the article asserts notability at all Deletion of Gravewalkaz WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
428 1720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional beauty queens (2nd nomination) User:Aoba47 23:15, 12 August 2019 (UTC) delete per the nominator's rationale. It fails and , and seems to be rather trivial Deletion of List of fictional beauty queens (2nd nomination) WP:LIST||WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Lists 97
429 5014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Kerruish User:GargAvinash 19:19, 3 February 2020 (UTC) delete Article is wtitten like promotion indicating only awards received . Also poorly sourced Deletion of Sarah Kerruish WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
430 186 [[Andrea Mitchell]] (erledigt) Benutzer:Suit 21:59, 17. Okt. 2006 (CEST) keep gemaess (artikel wurde komplett neu geschrieben Löschung von Andrea Mitchell Wikipedia:ELW Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
431 4112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pitar Ason User:S 04:18, 14 January 2020 (UTC) keep References are added. The film is the first released film of Nipun Akter. The film is also selected for preservation in Bangladesh Film Archive. It passes Deletion of Pitar Ason WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
432 20645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grand Muftiship of Sheikh Abubakr Ahmad User:Akbarali 05:14, 23 January 2020 (UTC) keep I think this nomination is part of a series of bad faith works by a Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations/Padavalamkuttanpilla|group of socks targeting notable articles of ''Islam in India'' like: Zainuddin Makhdoom II|I, Siraj Daily|II and P. K. Parakkadavu|III, and supporting some non notable articles like: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prakash Babu|I, J.K. Ambika|II, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K.P. Sasikala|III, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Outspoken Kerala|IV, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ambika Jk|V, East Coast Vijayan|VI, T. G. Mohandas|VII and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shajan Skariah|VIII. This is not a good faith nomination. The Grand Muftiship of Sheikh Abubakr Ahmad|article is a notable timeline of the major activities of the current Grand Mufti of India and the article is meets the |GNG, significant coverage in independent and reliable sources, as demonstrated by cites in the article. I don't think the article is eligible for merging and there is no reason to delete it Deletion of Grand Muftiship of Sheikh Abubakr Ahmad WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
433 1262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indians in Afghanistan User:Northamerica1000 08:39, 10 January 2012 (UTC) keep The article in its current state is well-sourced, and the topic itself appears notable. and neutral point-of-view concerns expressed in this AfD discussion can be addressed on the article's talk page and through editing, rather than entirely removing the article from Wikipedia Deletion of Indians in Afghanistan WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
434 10292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Margret Kopala User:Z1720 22:53, 29 September 2020 (UTC) delete """Fails and . I searched Canadian newspaper databases and found lots of editorials she has written, but these are not . There were also lots of """"Letters to the Newspaper"""" in response to her writing, but do not fulfil C1 of because they are not her peers. I was unable to find profiles on her life or reviews of her written work from her peers from Google, JSTOR, NYT, ProQuest or Academic OneFile""" Deletion of Margret Kopala WP:GNG||WP:JOURNALIST||WP:RS||WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
435 4188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The longest suicide note in history User:Edison 05:09, 5 March 2010 (UTC) comment """I really do not want to have an article about every epithet uttered by a politician, especially if it extends to Dick Cheney (http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,557670,00.html """"Go fuck yourself!"""") and George W. Bushhttp://www.nytimes.com/2001/02/04/weekinreview/jan-28-feb-3-keeping-an-ear-on-bush.html """"They misunderestimated me."""" These phrases got lots of press coverage, but do not deserve articles any more than the present article.Instead, individual epithets or catchphrases are redirected to an article about the speaker, or about the speech, or to the article which has a collection of such catchphrases, List of political catch phrases. This is Wikipedia, an encyclopedia, |not Bartlett's Familiar Quotations""" Deletion of The longest suicide note in history WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
436 337 [[Kamumbel]] (erledigt/schnellgelöscht) Benutzer:Chrkl NONE delete """Auch wenn der Link jetzt nicht mehr da war und damit das Argument """"Linkcontainer"""" nicht zieht, war ich so |mutig diesen """"Artikel"""" als Geschwurbel mit Begriffsbildung , damit der ein oder andere Leser dieser Diskussion sich den Werbemumpitz ersparen kann""" Löschung von Kamumbel Wikipedia:Sei mutig Wikipedia:Be bold 9
437 6846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackson Rancheria Casino Resort User:NickW557 20:08, 12 June 2015 (UTC) delete presently an |advertisement masquerading as an article. Even if sufficiently cleaned up, I've found no independent reliable sources to establish notability. I see trivial coverage (stories about people winning money, passing mentions in articles about gambling law changes, etc) but nothing in-depth Deletion of Jackson Rancheria Casino Resort WP:ADMASQ Wikipedia:Spam 112
438 18541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bolter User:Radiant 00:48, 29 October 2005 (UTC) merge per (appears to be little info to merge Deletion of Bolter WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
439 8975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jadon Sand User:LACaliNYC 19:23, 16 December 2018 (UTC) delete Obviously fails the and Deletion of Jadon Sand WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
440 16779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laksara Radio User:Dan 07:01, 29 June 2016 (UTC) delete As indicated by the nom, there is no evidence of notability. Subject doesn't comply with or requirements Deletion of Laksara Radio WP:BCAST||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
441 3480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burlington Center Mall User:Dpbsmith 18:35, 8 June 2006 (UTC) delete Generic mall. No published sources for the information in this article are cited, does not currently meet |verifiability policy. Does anyone in this discussion know ''for sure'' whether it is a Sears or a Montgomery Ward's? Are you ''certain'' it is a Chuck E. Cheese and not a Pizza Hut? Has anybody done any fact-checking? Of course not. Why not? Because nobody cares enough about what stores are in this mall to do five minutes' worth of honest research. I could go into that article and make up some plausible-sounding additions off the top of my head of well-known stores that favor mall locations, like Burger King, Radio Shack, and Suncoast Motion Pictures, and nobody would be any the wiser Deletion of Burlington Center Mall WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
442 13733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Briscoe User:Mattythewhite 22:55, 31 July 2017 (UTC) keep Per Struway2's research, subject passes . If we were to delete every football biography that meets but doesn't pass (or at least based on a cursory glance), we'd be retaining very few articles for players who were active pre-war. And all that would do is add to the already staggering level of recentist bias the encyclopedia already suffers from Deletion of James Briscoe WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
443 5853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Protestant Child Abuse User:Gwernol 10:39, 12 June 2008 (UTC) delete """the article is written with a partisan point of view. Given the issues raised above and the lack of any |sources that actually talk about systematic abuse within the """"Protestant Church"""", it would be inherently impossible for this article to ever meet . Indeed there is no single """"Protestant Church"""" as already noted, so this article cannot exist at this title. At least it would have to be retitled something like Evidence of child abuse within some Protestant churches. But given the sources are about child abuse across multiple faiths, why isn't this article Religious child abuse? The agenda here is very clear and is incompatible with the aims and policies of Wikipedia""" Deletion of Protestant Child Abuse WP:V||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
444 15735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bioinformatics and Human Electrophysiology Lab (BiHELab) User:RebeccaGreen 14:57, 30 October 2018 (UTC) delete I don't know if applies to organisations and institutions, but I suspect it is the case with this lab. It may produce notable research, but it is too soon to know - and organising conferences is not particularly notable, though some conferences may be Deletion of Bioinformatics and Human Electrophysiology Lab (BiHELab) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
445 21375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emi coco User:Ryan 19:11, 20 May 2012 (UTC) delete This person may be notable someday but I see no indication of meeting . Mentions in magazines like Vogue aren't through stories but are through spotlights on readers Deletion of Emi coco WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
446 5959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jokin Ezkieta User:GiantSnowman 20:29, 27 April 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Jokin Ezkieta WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
447 13357 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of films that most frequently use the word """"fuck"""" (10th nomination)""" User:Umbralcorax 22:56, 27 February 2011 (UTC) keep """per |section 2 subsection 3 of the speedy keep guidelines. The Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of films that most frequently use the word """"fuck"""" (9th nomination)|previous nomation was made on almost the same same grounds and was soundly rejected""" """Deletion of List of films that most frequently use the word """"fuck"""" (10th nomination)""" WP:SK Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
448 14316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francesco Schettino User:Obsidian 19:22, 20 January 2012 (UTC) merge per , though with no prejudice as to possible future notability.-- Deletion of Francesco Schettino WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
449 17945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cambridge corridor cricket User:Coredesat 22:13, 3 July 2006 (UTC) delete per #G4|CSD-G4 - re-creation of deleted material. Fails Deletion of Cambridge corridor cricket WP:CSD||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
450 5222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenneth Glenn Hinson User:BabbaQ 20:20, 21 April 2012 (UTC) keep per and Deletion of Kenneth Glenn Hinson WP:GNG||WP:CRIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
451 12481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Socionomics (2nd nomination) User:Rgfolsom 21:33, 30 July 2007 (UTC) comment """I’m sorry, but wp:neo says nothing about whether a topic “exists” – what it |does say is, """"''If you have research to support the inclusion of a term in the corpus of knowledge that is Wikipedia, the best approach is to arrange to have your results published in a peer-reviewed journal or reputable news outlet and then document your work in an appropriately non-partisan manner''."""" Our task here is to either acknowledge that the article meets that standard, or explain why we believe it doesn’t""" Deletion of Socionomics (2nd nomination) WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
452 2904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Professor Shekhar Osmania University User:Nipsonanomhmata 10:30, 18 May 2011 (UTC) delete promo of individual. No attempt has been made to show why individual meets or Deletion of Professor Shekhar Osmania University WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
453 21718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Todd McEwen User:Northamerica1000 01:17, 12 October 2018 (UTC) keep Per searches, the subject passes , with his works having received many reviews in independent, reliable sources. Some source examples, which were easily found in basic internet searches, include: https://www.salon.com/2003/09/12/mcewen/, https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/books/reviews/who-sleeps-with-katz-by-todd-mcewen-88993.html, https://www.nytimes.com/1990/12/09/books/mcocalypse-now.html, https://www.scotsman.com/lifestyle/culture/books/book-review-how-not-to-be-an-american-1-3176848, https://www.theguardian.com/books/2013/apr/02/5-simple-machines-mcewen-review, https://www.theguardian.com/books/2003/oct/11/featuresreviews.guardianreview10, https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/todd-mcewen/fishers-hornpipe/, https://www.popmatters.com/who-sleeps-with-katz-2496241072.html, http://articles.latimes.com/1990-10-07/books/bk-2938_1_todd-mcewen, https://www.publishersweekly.com/978-0-8021-1166-1 Deletion of Todd McEwen WP:BEFORE||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
454 3094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Garrison train crash User:Bobrayner 10:21, 21 February 2011 (UTC) keep Passes the |GNG by a comfortable margin Deletion of Garrison train crash WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
455 7518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cat Bongz User:Kinu 07:48, 12 December 2006 (UTC) delete WP:NFT applies, no indication of notability per from Deletion of Cat Bongz WP:NEO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
456 69 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Adem Ersoy """[[User:Styyx|'''~Styyx''']][[User talk:Styyx|''Evet''''?'']]""" 10.40, 25 Ağustos 2021 (UTC) keep """Rektör (olmuş) olması kriterleri karşıladığı anlamına gelir. Diğer konuya özel kriterlerin aksine 'de {{Mesaj alıntısı|""""bu kriterlerin bir veya birkaçının sağlanması da kişinin yer almasını garantilemez""""}} diye bir ifade '''yer almamakta''', sadece kişinin rektör olduğuna dair VP:D|doğrulanabilirlik için güvenilir kaynaklar gerekli (bağımsız olmaları bile gerekmiyor), o da var: https://www.mersinhaber.com/haber-adana-btude-rektor-vekili-olarak-prof-dr-aykut-gul-atandi/355387, https://bahce.bel.tr/b-t-u-rektoru-prof-dr-aykut-gule-ziyaret""" Adem Ersoy'un silinmesi Vikipedi:AKADEMİSYEN Wikipedia:Notability 77
457 361 [[Peter Paul Schütz]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Fido.m NONE keep Dafür spricht nicht nur, aber auch die qualitative und quantitative Resonanz dieses Löschantrags. Der Antragsteller sollte zukünftig den LA sorgfältiger vorbereiten, als Moderator der Diskussion selbst die |Wikiquette beachten, bei anderen Spitzfindigkeiten und persönliche Angriffe abweisen und solche Attacken von der Diskussionsseite entfernen. Also bitte niemand verschrecken, sondern selbst vorbildlich sein, um möglichst viele zu einer fruchtbaren Mitarbeit anzuregen Löschung von Peter Paul Schütz Wikipedia:Wikiquette Wikipedia:Etiquette 91
458 13794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artur Avagyan User:Mentoz86 NONE delete you'll actually has to earn a cap to pass , being included in the squad is not enough. As the player in question hasn't played in a |fully pro league either or received significant coverage in |reliable sources he fails both and . — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Artur Avagyan WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
459 12847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Memorial Oval, Aquinas College User:Gnangarra 14:15, 30 May 2007 (UTC) merge delete, as it appears to be a with the suggestion of merge I have added the history and first class cricket info into the Aquinas college campus section.http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Aquinas_College%2C_Perth&diff=134565990&oldid=133947289 diff Deletion of Memorial Oval, Aquinas College WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
460 6749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prof. Vinod Kumar User:WWGB 11:49, 23 January 2010 (UTC) delete Notability not established, no independent references, fails , contested prod Deletion of Prof. Vinod Kumar WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
461 12133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 in American television User:Postdlf 22:43, 17 October 2011 (UTC) keep """To say this violates is to say that there is nothing verifiably scheduled in American television for the year 2012. Which is so incorrect as to be absurd to assert. First, '''the American TV season lasts from fall of one year to spring of the next.''' So everything that has not yet been canceled that has been picked up for a full season qualifies as verifiably scheduled for 2012. Yes, a show ''could'' get canceled in the meantime, but that would simply be a change in what is verifiably scheduled to occur, that does not mean that nothing is currently verifiably scheduled to occur. Even apart from the extension of the current TV season into next year, there are also many verifiable examples of television series scheduled to return in 2012, or that have been renewed for 2012, had anyone !voting """"delete"""" actually bothered to research it: http://insidetv.ew.com/2011/03/29/amc-greenlights-season-five-of-mad-men-for-2012/ Mad Men, http://hbowatch.com/game-of-thrones-season-2-comes-spring-2012/ Game of Thrones, http://collider.com/the-simpsons-renewed-24th-25th-season/119495/ The Simpsons, http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/02/23/american-dad-renewed-by-fox_n_827186.html American Dad, http://www.seat42f.com/how-i-met-your-mother-renewed-through-2012-2013-season.html How I Met Your Mother... We do not delete what is verifiable just because it isn't verified within the article at present, nor do we delete entire articles just because portions might be flawed. I see this kind of crap in AFD after AFD. Sometimes it's from a good faith misunderstanding of guidelines, as I'm going to attribute to Farine here, but often it strikes me as laziness, a mere in service of . Too many deletion noms and !voters are not following , they are not following , and they are not following . And it all creates wasted effort in these AFDs, time that could be better spent improving articles that are improvable, ''such as this one""" Deletion of 2012 in American television WP:CRYSTALBALL||WP:VAGUEWAVE||WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:BEFORE||WP:PRESERVE||WP:ATD Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
462 11575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Baker (talk radio host) User:Mikehawk10 05:16, 1 July 2021 (UTC) comment Is https://www.chron.com/life/article/Chris-Baker-s-talk-show-canceled-on-KTRH-and-KPRC-1798665.php this https://www.chron.com/life/hoffman/article/Hoffman-Talk-show-host-unveils-documentary-1776991.php the same Chris Baker? There might be a case for if this is the same person Deletion of Chris Baker (talk radio host) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
463 21176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toto (Oz) user:Andrew 12:17, 10 July 2021 (UTC) keep """There's an interesting investigation of the origin of the dog's name https://bleedingcool.com/comics/wizard-of-oz-toto-l-frank-baum/ here. The article doesn't go into this yet and so we see that there's scope for improvement and so our policy applies, """"''If editing can improve the page, this should be done rather than deleting the page""" Deletion of Toto (Oz) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
464 20949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CutThroat User:Lankiveil 05:13, 13 August 2014 (UTC) delete """I don't see that they'd meet any of the notability criteria. This is also sailing perilously close to being CSD A1 at this point, as it's not at all clear from the article that it's a band, at least until you look at the """"sources""" Deletion of CutThroat WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
465 15354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cardiff Crack User:Octoberwoodland 01:22, 2 November 2019 (UTC) delete """Non notable food vendor using Wikipedia for advertising with neologism """"Cardiff Crack"""". Per article should be deleted. I have already removed the same non-notable content placed into the article Tri-tip by apparently the same editor""" Deletion of Cardiff Crack WP:PLUG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
466 5105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Eisenkop (2nd nomination) User:Breadblade 21:04, 31 July 2014 (UTC) keep His article already clearly passes and does not apply, as he has both actively sought out public attention through venues such as https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hw2mHEMUfkI TEDx and has received significant media coverage for multiple independent events. His shadowban has only http://www.dailydot.com/news/unidan-reddit-shadowbanned-crow-ben-eisenkop/ attracted more media coverage, and http://www.reddit.com/r/blog/comments/2c63wg/how_reddit_works/cjccfyt?context=3 hasn't kept him off reddit in the first place. I will echo the sentiment that many of the articles against this article seem to come from the standpoint of Deletion of Ben Eisenkop (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NTEMP||WP:JUSTDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
467 15829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Felix Stewart User:Papaursa 18:32, 4 June 2014 (UTC) delete Fails to meet either or Deletion of Felix Stewart WP:NBOX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
468 20615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neeraj Kumar Singal User:TheBirdsShedTears 09:31, 9 March 2021 (UTC) delete only two RS discuss the subject independently https://inc42.com/buzz/indian-startup-hubs-delhi-ecosystem-builders/, http://bwdisrupt.businessworld.in/article/New-Age-Investors-Are-Bringing-in-Inexpert-Decision-Making-Says-N-K-SINGAL-CEO-SEMCO/03-08-2016-104028/, however they fails to satisfy |one of notability criteria. No awards, no historical contribution, no notable work Deletion of Neeraj Kumar Singal WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
469 369 [[Wolfgang Stahl]] (LAE) Benutzer:Jocian 08:30, 13. Aug. 2013 (CEST) keep wie von Kriddl und Stefan Bellini bereits dargelegt, handelt es sich hier um eine Person, die „wegen ihrer Beteiligung an historischen, politischen oder sonst nachrichtenwürdigen Ereignissen bekannt“ und damit eindeutig relevant ist (siehe #P|WP:RK = Allgemeine Hinweise zur Relevanz von Personen). Der NSU-Prozess gilt als einer der bedeutendsten Prozesse in der Geschichte der Bundesrepublik, und der Rechtsanwalt Wolfgang Stahl gehört mit zu denjenigen Verteidigern, die am meisten im Fokus der Öffentlichkeit stehen. Der Artikel ist in jedem Fall behaltenswert Löschung von Wolfgang Stahl Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
470 10669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pick Up the Phone Booth and Die User:JamesBWatson 15:04, 5 March 2014 (UTC) delete """I don't see it as promotional either, but there is no evidence either in the article or anywhere else that I can see of satisfying Wikipedia's notability guidelines. None of the """"keep"""" reasons advanced by Mewulwe carries any weight under Wikipedia policies & guidelines. For """"it's factual"""" see , for """"does no harm"""" see , and """"it's fairly well known in interactive fiction circles"""", justified by a link to a list in a wiki, comes nowhere near the requirement for substantial coverage in reliable source. ''The editor who uses the pseudonym""" Deletion of Pick Up the Phone Booth and Die WP:ITEXISTS||WP:NOHARM Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
471 5113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of U.S. and Canadian cities by professional sports teams championships User:Deor 01:49, 13 June 2008 (UTC) delete Perhaps not original research; but the nom is correct that this is a fundamentally flawed list of ''cities'' by number of championships, since it apportions championships by ''teams'' rather than by cities (Atlanta, for example, has no NBA championships; the Hawks were in St. Louis when they were champions). I also agree with Shereth (I think) that this list is based on a loose association of topics (though I don't think that is covered in Deletion of List of U.S. and Canadian cities by professional sports teams championships WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
472 5172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cristian Guerrero User:Kinston 00:55, 10 September 2007 (UTC) keep As noted above, this player meets the current standard for athletes in , and it should be noted that he also meets the proposed standards in Wikipedia:Notability (sports) by playing for the AAA Columbus and New Orleans teams. Requests have been made that baseball player AfD's be put on hold until the proposed guidelines are worked out Deletion of Cristian Guerrero WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
473 7394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The 250 User:ObiterDicta 06:37, 6 March 2007 (UTC) delete without |reliable sources, which I have been unable to find Deletion of The 250 WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
474 15223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Süleyman Başak User:Evb 13:21, 9 June 2007 (UTC) delete clearly fails Deletion of Süleyman Başak WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
475 5605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carol Hunt User:Snappy 17:36, 27 October 2015 (UTC) delete """No evidence of |notability. Another election candidate special, standing for election does not make a person notable. If she is a """"famous journalist"""" in Ireland, I must be reading the wrong newspapers/listening to the wrong radio/watching the wrong TV shows as I've never heard of her. If she was really notable, she would have had an article ages ago""" Deletion of Carol Hunt WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
476 246 [[Jens Goldhardt]] (LAE) Benutzer:Papphase 01:32, 3. Aug. 2009 (CEST) keep Genau das habe ich per getan, da der Mann als Kirchenmusikdirektor laut #Musiker_und_Komponisten eindeutig relevant ist und diese Ausneichnung in der LD wie auch im Artikel belegt ist. Diese IP-Arena kann daher als geschlossen betrachtet werden Löschung von Jens Goldhardt Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
477 14667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/From the Notebooks of a Middle School Princess User:StarryGrandma 07:14, 25 November 2015 (UTC) keep another book which easily meets and . In addition to the reviews mentioned by Deletion of From the Notebooks of a Middle School Princess WP:NBOOK||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
478 8970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Succession Wars user:Andrew 10:29, 17 May 2021 (UTC) keep The nomination openly states that it doesn't want to delete the article. Per , AfD is not the right place to request help developing an article. 99% of Wikipedia's articles are |imperfect and AfD is just for those which are hopeless Deletion of The Succession Wars WP:NOTCLEANUP||WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
479 836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Culp User:WilliamJE 12:04, 1 December 2013 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Brian Culp WP:NBASEBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
480 11285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A. J. Howard User:Cbl62 03:34, 29 April 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and , and my searches did not turn significant coverage of the type required by Deletion of A. J. Howard WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:NCOLLATH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
481 18854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lise Watier User:Bearcat 20:47, 4 June 2018 (UTC) keep and flag for improvement. The article definitely needs to be expanded and properly referenced, but even a cursory Google News search reveals that a -passing volume of coverage, about both the company and its namesake founder, very definitely exists to salvage it with. GNG is not purely a question of whether the article is already well-sourced or not — it's a question of the depth and quality of sources that can be ''found'', not just the depth and quality of sources that are already present in the article as written Deletion of Lise Watier WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
482 9816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delta Sigma Rho User:Eggishorn 21:07, 3 September 2017 (UTC) delete All the available appear to refer to the second organization, the merged forensics clubs, rather than this one-campus society. No evidence that this organization has had any impact or recognition beyond the campus, and almost no evidence it has much on its own campus Deletion of Delta Sigma Rho WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
483 86 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ulrich Pleitgen Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 03.27, 23 Eylül 2018 (UTC) keep ping|Chansey}}, Altın Ayı, oyunculara değil filmlere verilen bir ödül öncelikle. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/36th_Berlin_International_Film_Festival İlgili festivalde de bu film ilgili ödülü kazanmış, kendisinin kazandığı bir ödül değil. Ancak görebildiğim kadarıyla kayda değer yapımlarda önemli rolleri var -ki ilgili filmde başrol. Dolayısıyla sayfasındaki oyuncularla ilgili kriterleri karşılamakta Ulrich Pleitgen'in silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
484 8481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Homeless Voice User:Bearian 16:51, 15 November 2016 (UTC) keep per . Closing admin, please consider a redirect to or from the foundation Deletion of The Homeless Voice WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
485 14 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/İzmir Özel Fatih Koleji Kullanıcı:85.108.73.1485.108.73.14 12:47, 19 Mart 2015 (UTC) comment """http://tr.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=İzmir_Özel_Fatih_Koleji&diff=15243276&oldid=15238184 Şu değişiklikteki bilgiye ve |ilgili yönergeye göre, """"okulun, kayda değerlik kıstasları uyarınca uygun bulunmuş Vikipedi maddesi olan birden fazla mezunu"""" vardır. --Özel:Katkılar/85.108.73.14|85.108.73.14""" İzmir Özel Fatih Kolejinin silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
486 19 [[DonnerTV]] (schnellgelöscht) Benutzer:Jogo30 NONE delete """Da der Artikel laut Autor """"komplett"""" ist, muss man die 1-h-Regel auch nicht mehr beachten. Ich kann keinerlei Relevanz gem. erkennen, die auch für reine Internetsender gelten. Daher""" Löschung von DonnerTV Wikipedia:RWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
487 1988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Disney Princess firsts User:NoCOBOL 09:04, 4 January 2019 (UTC) delete The general rule for stand-alone lists is that it is notable if there is significant coverage of the elements of the list as a group. This is not true in this case, where the list has been assembled by cobbling various trivia facts about the characters - which indeed also falls foul of . Finally, while some may find it or, alas, , these are not standards for inclusion on Wikipedia. However, perhaps some of the information would be worthy of transfer to the individual articles Deletion of List of Disney Princess firsts WP:LISTN||WP:TRIVIA||WP:INTERESTING||WP:USEFUL Wikipedia:Notability 77
488 8603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Expert Drones User:onel5969 13:29, 5 November 2015 (UTC) delete despite the numerous SPA !votes, searches do not turn up enough to show it passes (Clarityfriend's point is pretty clear - no pun intended Deletion of Expert Drones WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
489 9169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Labour's Terrorism Laws User:Coredesat 11:29, 27 June 2006 (UTC) delete title fails , article is redundant to article subsection mentioned by Uncle G Deletion of New Labour's Terrorism Laws WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
490 3277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nour Al Zain User:SamHolt6 15:17, 1 September 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Nour Al Zain WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
491 988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of General Hospital User:Jay32183 22:28, 1 July 2007 (UTC) delete Just plot summary here, fails #PLOT Deletion of History of General Hospital WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
492 17228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mockelberg User:Narky 08:00, 29 January 2021 (UTC) delete Neither target mentions the name. I found non- evidence for the name's existence in https://www.myheritage.com/research/category-2000/birth-marriage-death?action=query&formId=bmd&formMode=0&qname=Name+fnmo.2+fnmsvos.1+fnmsmi.1+ln.Mockelberg+lnmo.3+lnmsdm.1+lnmsmf3.1+lnmsrs.1 myheritage.com (a different link from the one in the article). None of the bearers looks in any way notable, and dewiki nowhere mentions the name Deletion of Mockelberg WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
493 12695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bethlehem College, Ashfield User:Silensor 05:20, 31 January 2006 (UTC) keep as per , notable 120+ year old school Deletion of Bethlehem College, Ashfield WP:SCH Wikipedia:Notability 77
494 9436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dennis Brady User:Lugnuts 20:19, 5 February 2021 (UTC) keep """Reading , under Wikipedia:Notability_(people)#Sports_personalities|sports people, he passes the notability (""""...person has actively participated in a major amateur or professional competition.."""") having played in first-class cricket matches. This section links to , which states at the top of the page """"The article should provide reliable sources showing that the subject meets the general notability guideline '''or''' the sport specific criteria set forth below"""", and below there is the critieria for . At worst, per -R, redirect back to the List of Otago representative cricketers""" Deletion of Dennis Brady WP:BIO||WP:NSPORT||WP:NCRIC||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
495 12878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Marois User:AusLondonder 22:47, 15 May 2016 (UTC) delete Almost a case. Absolutely no notability Deletion of Richard Marois WP:SPEEDY Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
496 14198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Great Cello Solos User:Joe 23:56, 3 November 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |music book Deletion of The Great Cello Solos WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
497 16762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St Antony's Church Machad User:Coolabahapple 04:02, 21 August 2019 (UTC) delete does not meet as the sources cited are essentially listings and/or not |useable for notability Deletion of St Antony's Church Machad WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
498 12461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/295th Ordnance Heavy Maintenance Company (FA) User:Nick 08:42, 21 June 2010 (UTC) delete Lacks references to establish notability per and its unlikely that such references exist given that it was an unremarkable support unit and there were hundreds of similar units in the wartime US Army. I'd suggest to the the article creator that they publish this on another website Deletion of 295th Ordnance Heavy Maintenance Company (FA) WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
499 21358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Proper Interval Locality User:Nufy8 16:48, 4 June 2008 (UTC) delete Fails basic |notability guidelines. Scientific hypotheses should be peer-reviewed or have significant media exposure to be considered notable. I see no evidence of either. As it stands now, this is pure |original research Deletion of Proper Interval Locality WP:NOTABILITY||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
500 19353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theatre sub-stubs User:Cfred 05:15, 11 July 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Additionally, Dundee Theatre fails (which is likely most applicable for a movie house Deletion of Theatre sub-stubs WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
501 12805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandor Fekete User:Richard 14:10, 29 November 2011 (UTC) keep """7 references including an entry in Brahms encyclopedia and a two page biography http://www.themeadowsfoundation.org/last-bridgetender.html here. I think you are confusing the snippets used to verify a fact quoted in the citations with the entire reference. states """"If a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to satisfy the inclusion criteria for a stand-alone article or stand-alone list."""" It doesn't say unless that source is the Meadows Foundation""" Deletion of Sandor Fekete WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
502 15115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wiki Syndrome User:Eddie 22:04, 11 June 2006 (UTC) delete puhleeeeze''! This is a perfect example of omplete Bollocks Deletion of Wiki Syndrome WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
503 21052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Business Decision Maker User:MuffledThud 11:44, 27 January 2010 (UTC) delete per , unreferenced. See also nearly-identical article Technology decision maker, created by same editor Deletion of Business Decision Maker WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
504 15828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loose Kaynon User:Bearian 17:54, 18 March 2016 (UTC) delete due to lacking |reliable sources. It's not even clear how this person passes Deletion of Loose Kaynon WP:RS||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
505 19613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Birth Certificate Jeddah User:Doc 00:21, 29 December 2009 (UTC) delete WP:OR|OR |personal |essay Deletion of Birth Certificate Jeddah WP:WEBHOST||WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
506 17079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Shribman User:Magd2884 05:37, 3 January 2021 (UTC) delete Sources are all either not reliable sources or mentions in passing. A google news search shows a couple articles discussing a documentary he made but nothing more; no significant coverage of him personally in and so fails . Something is fishy, however - the page was created by a likely COI single-purpose account Deletion of Matthew Shribman WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
507 20807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bibliography of Jehovah's Witnesses User:RockMagnetist 17:01, 30 January 2013 (UTC) keep now that I have added citations, this list satisfies the |notability criteria for stand-alone lists and |verifiability. The name is a little confusing, though - I wasn't sure if it meant ''by'' or ''about'' the Jehovah's Witnesses. I recommend renaming it to Bibliography of works on the Jehova's Witnesses Deletion of Bibliography of Jehovah's Witnesses WP:LISTN||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
508 21691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Organic Consumers Association User:Viriditas 12:10, 4 August 2013 (UTC) keep """The Organic Consumers Association (OCA) received a six-page profile of its background and history in the ''Journal of Agricultural & Food Information'' in 2008.http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10496500802122811#.Uf4zj9LVC1w The group got its start in 1998 when the USDA tried to implement flawed organic standardshttp://books.google.com/books?id=YtldfGaOJ5IC&lpg=PA269&pg=PA269#v=onepage&q&f=false and they fought back with a """"Save Organic Standards"""" campaign that resulted in the USDA getting more comments than any other topic in history.http://books.google.com/books?id=D00xd8qNUvYC&lpg=PA132&pg=PA132#v=onepage&q&f=false Their notability was established right out of the gate. Then, they achieved international fame in the media when they campaigned against Starbucks in 2001 with a national boycott,http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=nyYfAAAAIBAJ&sjid=D9AEAAAAIBAJ&pg=2436%2C9472769 at which time the ''Wall Street Journal'' and other pro-business sources went after them, giving them even more notable coverage. In 2007, the WSJ called the OCA """"one of the leading opponents of rBGH"""" against its use by Starbucks, highlighting the notability of their campaign. In 2002, South Africa's ''Mail & Guardian'' cited them as representative of the organic lobbyhttp://www.mg.co.za/article/2002-01-01-labelled-organic-foods-branded-as-misleading and the 2007 book ''The Debate over Corporate Social Responsibility'' cited their 2003 campaign as one of the best examples of armchair activism.http://books.google.com/books?id=wrDJpCuodNwC&lpg=PA245&ots=5aZqtOG2Xd&pg=PA245#v=onepage&q&f=false For the last decade, publications like ''USA Today'' and ''The New York Times'' cite the OCA regularly regarding boycotts and lawsuits. The group received an enormous amount of coverage in 2005 when they (along with Bronner's Magic Soap) filed a lawsuit against the USDA over the right to use the organic label,http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/industries/manufacturing/2005-08-24-organic-usat_x.htm and their """"Coming Clean Campaign"""" made it into the history books.http://books.google.com/books?id=Vat73WaVnmoC&lpg=PA84&pg=PA84#v=onepage&q&f=falsehttp://books.google.com/books?id=aaVW5dk8GkMC&lpg=PA135&pg=PA135#v=onepage&q&f=false The debate over the definition of organic food used by the USDA led to a lawsuit by organic farmer Arthur Harvey which resulted in significant coverage of the OCA's role in the debate.http://www.earthisland.org/journal/index.php/eij/article/food_fight/http://books.google.com/books?id=ZhzoTTqwUSoC&lpg=PA246&pg=PA246#v=onepage&q&f=false ''Chemical Week'' cited the OCA as a source on the 1,4-dioxane controversy back in 2008. (March 24, 2008, p. 50) The group has also become one of the largest backers of GMO labeling laws, with ''Biotech Week'' saying in 2012 that """"The Organic Consumers Association (OCA) has been a key funding and organizing driver of the GMO labeling effort"""" for Proposition 37. (September 5, 2012 p. 168) Even their biggest critics recognize this role.http://books.google.com/books?id=Qbn0Scfw1gQC&lpg=PA15&pg=PA15#v=onepage&q&f=false The OCA are also one of the largest critics of GMO foods and Monsanto, and they appear as public interest representatives in the major news media virtually every day. Just last week alone, they were quoted by the ''New York Times'' on the GMO issue, and ''Russia Today'' conducted an entire segment with their spokesperson. Many news media sources also refer to the OCA as an authoritative source on organic products.http://www.nj.com/homegarden/homestories/index.ssf/2008/04/aborga19.html Both the ''Wall Street Journal'' and ''Western Farm Press'' (February 19, 2011) have vilified the organization and its spokespeople, giving them additional notability. Writer Harry Cline of ''Western Farm Press'' dedicated his entire column to attacking the group. ''The Humanist'' listed the OCA as a group whose """"top priorities"""" include """"efforts to push back against corporate rule by denying corporations the same rights as people"""". (February 19, 2011, p. 4) The ''Food Safety'' reference book confirms this claim in a spotlight piece on OCA's national director and the group.http://books.google.com/books?id=D00xd8qNUvYC&lpg=PA132&pg=PA218#v=onepage&q&f=falsehttp://books.google.com/books?id=D00xd8qNUvYC&lpg=PA132&pg=PA132#v=onepage&q&f=false Their fight against child labor was also covered by ''Pediatrics Week''. (December 24, 2011 p. 81) These sources are a very small sample (and only a few campaigns are mentioned here) from an enormous number of sources about this organization, and one look at Google Books and Google Scholar shows that the OCA is cited in virtually every academic journal article and/or book on the subject of organic food certification. Based on this very small sample of sources supporting the article on this group, I am curious how the nominator could argue that it doesn't meet . Perhaps he has not heard of """ Deletion of Organic Consumers Association WP:ORG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
509 10886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1 vs. 100 (disambiguation) User:MrStalker 20:25, 10 February 2011 (UTC) keep what is under discussion here? If the articles topics are so similar, what should be discussed is a |merge. Disambiguation pages is a technicality, a way to provide easy navigation to articles and its right to exist is not dependent of the ''content'' of the articles it links to, just that they exist Deletion of 1 vs. 100 (disambiguation) WP:MERGE Wikipedia:Merging 54
510 7170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pigmanship User:Snowball 03:05, 12 February 2006 (UTC) delete Violates Deletion of Pigmanship WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
511 3087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paganus User:Blackmetalbaz 00:44, 18 August 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Paganus WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
512 18401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kids! User:Schuym1 22:50, 29 August 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Kids! WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
513 13108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indo G User:Pia 16:35, 28 September 2007 (UTC) keep """Notable, as per #Criteria for musicians and ensembles, point 6: """"was once a part of or later joined a band that is otherwise notable"""" (Three 6 Mafia). Has been a musical influence on the Memphis rap scene (active and recording since 1992 + single with Gangsta Boo""" Deletion of Indo G WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
514 13967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Green Park Ltd User:JohnCD 15:36, 21 September 2009 (UTC) delete """I find no indication of notability to the standard of . """"''38th Fastest Growing entrepreneurial business in the UK''"""" and finalist for some awards is not enough. When searching note that there are other companies by the same name, e.g. http://www.alibaba.com/member/cemer.html here. The article was input by {{user1|Green Park Ltd""" Deletion of Green Park Ltd WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
515 474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robb Banks User:Gongshow 00:52, 4 September 2017 (UTC) keep There appear to be multiple examples of non-trivial coverage on this person's music, enough in my view to meet and . I have added references to the article Deletion of Robb Banks WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
516 11000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UK and US counting units User:Kikichugirl 05:39, 26 December 2014 (UTC) delete per arg above and . Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information nor a conversion table website. — Deletion of UK and US counting units WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
517 4315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Langford (computer scientist) User:Eric 17:42, 11 February 2009 (UTC) keep Meets criterion #1 (significant impact in scholarly discipline, broadly construed), as shown by David Eppstein’s search. The Science article alone, with its 2037 Google Scholar citations, makes it very difficult to argue for deletion Deletion of John Langford (computer scientist) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
518 18693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The clearance goal User:GiantSnowman 14:41, 27 September 2010 (UTC) delete fails , , - need I go on Deletion of The clearance goal WP:NOTNEWS||WP:OR||WP:POV Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
519 12697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OpenDrive (platform) User:Ihcoyc 18:45, 20 March 2011 (UTC) delete for mercy's sake, another |run of the mill online backup service Deletion of OpenDrive (platform) WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
520 8558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan McGrotty User:Alvaldi 17:55, 22 May 2021 (UTC) delete fails . I couldn't find anything on him other than a few articles on his legal case. Playing one game or 100 games in a professional league is irrelevant if there is no substantial coverage on the subject Deletion of Jordan McGrotty WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
521 16636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tommy Daugherty [[User talk:2601:188:0:ABE6:B095:6CD9:12FD:9C11|talk]]) 13:57, 5 February 2016 (UTC) delete per above. As a different IP, I've started a thread at the COI noticeboard, and asked that the promotional account be blocked. Also note a variety of sock/meat puppets and s have sprung up. Special:Contributions/2601:188:0:ABE6:B095:6CD9:12FD:9C11|2601:188:0:ABE6:B095:6CD9:12FD:9C11 Deletion of Tommy Daugherty WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
522 5681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Forsyth Experience User:FisherQueen 16:54, 22 May 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find any evidence that this team meets the |notability criteria; a google search revealed no |reliable sources that have discussed it. Creator has declared a |conflict of interest as a member of the team, and as far as I can tell, this is not the University team but an intramural team Deletion of Alex Forsyth Experience WP:N||WP:RS||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
523 15421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Airlines Flight 31 User:Gene93k 11:54, 11 August 2008 (UTC) delete and . Smoke from an oil leak.http://www.khnl.com/Global/story.asp?S=8800489 Precautions taken. Bumps and bruises on evacuation. Unremarkable malfunction with no evidence of lasting impact Deletion of American Airlines Flight 31 WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
524 379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Mauldin User:Moreschi 14:15, 6 April 2007 (UTC) delete per Simoncursitor, to the letter. Checking the web is giving little in the way of stuff that might satisfy and . Seemingly just another businessman with half-decent PR Deletion of John Mauldin WP:ATT||WP:N Wikipedia:Attribution 108
525 20061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adda52rummy User:CNMall41 17:53, 21 August 2017 (UTC) delete Fails . I also just sent Adda52 to AfD as well Deletion of Adda52rummy WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
526 19644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gordos User:MacGyverMagic 11:28, 29 November 2008 (UTC) merge Establishing |notability independent of Zoids is only neccesary for independent article, merging only requires verification it exists Deletion of Gordos WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
527 14458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vicki Nicole User:Matt 04:16, 21 December 2008 (UTC) delete Deosn't meet Deletion of Vicki Nicole WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
528 14165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kate A. Toomey User:E 20:37, 4 August 2016 (UTC) keep as per . position is notable by definition. Nom and SwisterTwister are mistaken Deletion of Kate A. Toomey WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
529 6439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hassan Musa User:Bobrayner 14:22, 28 December 2010 (UTC) keep I think this individual passes by a long way. Cleanup? Meh, it's better than the average new article imho. The refbomb is quite understandable if it's a response to questioned notability, and I don't think a long list of sources does the article any harm Deletion of Hassan Musa WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
530 20221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pete Griffin User:Marjaliisa 23:17, 22 October 2007 (UTC) delete per - Original author is Pgriff1130, so probably he wrote it himself Deletion of Pete Griffin WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
531 1249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Devotion Bidwell User:Gene93k 21:30, 12 August 2008 (UTC) delete per . Straight genealogy associated with a historic place. I might consider merging Bidwell to Rev. Adonijah Bidwell House if could be satisfied Deletion of John Devotion Bidwell WP:NOT||WP:V Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
532 6982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bodekbeska User:Davewild 18:14, 30 October 2007 (UTC) delete wikipedia is for something you make up one day Deletion of Bodekbeska WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
533 4028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cantus Musicus User:Yetisyny 11:25, 3 September 2018 (UTC) delete fails criteria for notability of musical groups Deletion of Cantus Musicus WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
534 4681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How to play deathmetal User:S 23:19, 31 January 2009 (UTC) delete It's (a) a howto, (b) an essay, and (c) |contains serious inaccuracies Deletion of How to play deathmetal WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
535 16505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Talbot User:scope_creep 23:17, 18 May 2021 (UTC) delete Placing third in a reality programme. Geez. Fails Deletion of Sam Talbot WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
536 17740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Werksmans User:AlessandroTiandelli333 09:33, 9 June 2020 (UTC) keep Passes . Arguments that the page should be deleted because it's owned by white people (that's a new one) aren't based on any policy Deletion of Werksmans WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
537 18887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Northwestern Mexico User:Edison 19:39, 13 June 2017 (UTC) delete as |original research which fails |verifiability due to a lack of |reliable sources Deletion of Northwestern Mexico WP:OR||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
538 20882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shabazz Sundiata Sallier User:Bonadea 09:06, 14 November 2016 (UTC) delete apart from being full of irrelevant fluffy and promotional text, there is no claim to notability per or , much less . I have not been able to find any secondary sources. The article has been deleted many times and create protected at Shabazz Sallier, but that was a couple of years ago so no harm in letting this discussion run its course Deletion of Shabazz Sundiata Sallier WP:MUSICBIO||WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
539 2083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pro-Life (politician) User:Hrafn 01:49, 27 January 2008 (UTC) delete """this minor (and to date electorally unsuccessful) politician received ''temporary'' attention due to his bizarre name-changes, but #Notability is not temporary|""""notability is not temporary"""", and he is not otherwise notable per #Politicians""" Deletion of Pro-Life (politician) WP:NOTE||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
540 13155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khaleel Mohammed User:Dennette 01:11, 28 December 2006 (UTC) comment """The second half of the introductory paragraph is copied from the subject's web page at http://www-rohan.sdsu.edu/~khaleel/ ... since there are no references or citations that support '''''any''''' of the criteria in , I don't see how you can say it """"seems to be met here."""" Show me just one link in the article to a |reputable source that satisfies just one of them! The """"assertion"""" that it fails is self-evident and implicit in the '''fact''' that it '''does not satisfy ''any'' of the criteria''' ... and the burden of proof that it satisfies the criteria lies with the supporters, not the detractors ... a personal web page and a bio from the """"Carol Fass Publicity & Public Relations"""" website do not even come close, since both are explicitly forbidden reference sources for notability ... that link for http://www.cias.sdsu.edu/ is useless even as proof that he is """"a core faculty member of SDSU's Center for Islamic and Arabic Studies"""" because his name is not mentioned on the linked page, or any page to which it is linked""" Deletion of Khaleel Mohammed WP:PROF||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
541 18777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rowley Jefferson (2nd nomination) User:Jfgslo 18:08, 10 June 2011 (UTC) merge The fictional character does not meet the |general notability guideline and the content is mostly a |plot-only description of a fictional work, so there is no reason to keep this article around. As most of the content uses primary or unreliable sources, there is no material worth keeping. But, since the fictional character is already covered in List of Diary of a Wimpy Kid characters and since there is no additional description in the article title, which makes it a plausible search term, a redirect is a suitable outcome Deletion of Rowley Jefferson (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
542 16294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Imagine (Madonna song) User:Carlosguitar 00:56, 17 August 2007 (UTC) delete agreed with nominator, fails Deletion of Imagine (Madonna song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
543 11070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marques stevenson User:2008Olympian 19:49, 15 January 2009 (UTC) delete fails both and . Not even close. And Paul disagrees with how is interpreted, but he knows full well that consensus is that football players only meet if they play in a fully professional league. If they do not, they need to meet general requirements Deletion of Marques stevenson WP:ATHLETE||WP:BIO||WP:ATHLETE||WP:ATHLETE||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
544 17123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Han shot first (3rd nomination) User:Colonel 23:32, 4 June 2009 (UTC) keep WP:DISRUPT|Disruptive and |uncivil repeat nomination per Deletion of Han shot first (3rd nomination) WP:CIVIL||WP:DEL Wikipedia:Civility 37
545 201 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Kaymaksız Kullanıcı:ugur basakugur basak 22:07, 3 Haziran 2006 (UTC) delete maddenin şu anki hali standartlarının çok altında, fakat :wikt:|vikisözlüğe eklenebilir Kaymaksız'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Taslak Wikipedia:Stub 114
546 2662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baron, Angelo von Möller User:AllyD 12:10, 24 March 2018 (UTC) delete No |evidence of attained notability provided or found Deletion of Baron, Angelo von Möller :WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
547 8486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Presley User:Inks 07:14, 27 July 2015 (UTC) delete fails ; lacks significant coverage by independent, reliable sources Deletion of James Presley WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
548 13545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethan Sonneborn User:SkyGazer 16:53, 30 August 2018 (UTC) merge Err, this was a tough one. At first I was strongly leaning towards keeping. There is a ton of news coverage all over. However, after thinking about this hard and looking into this situation further, I really do think this is a case of . He's likely going to receive very little or no news coverage in the near future - it's only this particular event that makes them notable. Of course, if more news coverage does appear about him for another event, we could always restore the article and add the new information, as this would likely mean he would now be considered notable. I really do think we should find some way to merge some more of the content into Vermont gubernatorial election, 2018, though. After all, he did receive a ton of news coverage, and because of this, even if he's not notable enough to have a standalone article, it certainly seems like the page should have more information about him than simply Ethan Sonneborn, high school freshman. But then again, I'm not really sure where the best place to incorporate that information would be. I strongly oppose to deleting the redirect - mostly per and just common sense Deletion of Ethan Sonneborn WP:BLP1E||WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
549 7840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baby scoop era User:Cosmo0 22:14, 20 October 2007 (UTC) keep for now. Seems to be fairly well-established for a neologism (at least on the web) and the article doesn't come across as particularly |POV Deletion of Baby scoop era WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
550 3639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Milwaukee Ale House User:Nsk92 04:52, 1 October 2008 (UTC) keep """There is detailed coverage of the pub in several books. For example, this bookhttp://books.google.com/books?id=q4SxHmOVX0YC&pg=PA75&dq=%22Milwaukee+Ale+House%22&ei=Af_iSPaUIpTEzATj7-zbBA&sig=ACfU3U0yEhE0zhpXd9gAGQjsVn-s6HWSQw#PPA75,M1 has a separate chapter about this pub, including its history. Similarly, this bookhttp://books.google.com/books?id=ZCt8wxuXmNAC&pg=PA30&dq=%22Milwaukee+Ale+House%22&ei=Af_iSPaUIpTEzATj7-zbBA&sig=ACfU3U2hs0lkgtW_WNLhQr2ySIAhUziBfg#PPA30,M1 has a section about the pub that starts with """"One of Wisconsin's most acclaimed brew pubs, the Milwaukee Ale House is a hangout for those connected to the microbrewing industry..."""" (a direct assertion of notability here). There is also substantial coverage in local newspaper, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel: 246 hits in googlenewshttp://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&lr=&tab=pn&q=%22Milwaukee+Ale+House%22&ie=UTF-8, much of it specific and detailed, e.g. http://www.jsonline.com/onwisconsin/music/sep05/352585.asphttp://docs.newsbank.com/g/GooglePM/MWSB/lib00253,0EB82AF9500CAAC1.html, etc. Enough here to pass """ Deletion of Milwaukee Ale House WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
551 8052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Borden Grammar School User:Samir_grover 22:52, 1 March 2006 (UTC) keep as it meets criteria Deletion of Borden Grammar School WP:SCH Wikipedia:Notability 77
552 10896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ron Bell (politician) User:Timmeh 20:50, 21 April 2009 (UTC) delete Fails , with a lack of substantial coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Ron Bell (politician) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
553 7568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Senecal (2nd nomination) User:Rusf10 05:42, 5 March 2018 (UTC) delete as , no one has talked about this guy since 2016. Everyone who knows or as ever worked for Donald Trump does not inherit notability from him Deletion of Anthony Senecal (2nd nomination) WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
554 13276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harry Dunn (2nd nomination) User:Hobit 16:35, 24 January 2013 (UTC) keep At least one source one two sources (pasted above and linked above) have significant coverage of this person. We've met the with multiple non-trivial sources. And even if the rest are more run-of-the-mill and less biographical I think we're still above the bar of the GNG Deletion of Harry Dunn (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
555 19282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Taglieri User:LaMona 02:44, 17 March 2016 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet . Sources are indie or funky; most info taken from interviews; no mention of charting; and music published on a very small label (which appears to not be independent of the subject of the article Deletion of John Taglieri WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
556 19304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suite101.com User:ScottW 14:49, 24 November 2006 (UTC) delete I'm the original prodder on this one. There is so many unreliable sources out there for this one that it is tough finding substantial reliable sources on this. The New York Times is obviously a reliable source, but the mentions of the site are, at best, in passing. I see a fair amount of blog entries mentioning some of the problems this organization is having, but if this were a notable site, it seems to me that it would be possible to find references to these issues (or even positive ones) in a site we could reference per . I'm open to being proven wrong here, but so far I'm not seeing how this article could be more than a stub Deletion of Suite101.com WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
557 20595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GSI Outdoors User:CaptainEek 01:07, 4 March 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of GSI Outdoors WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
558 2042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uday Narayan User:Nirmaljoshi 06:01, 9 February 2021 (UTC) delete for now. None of the source quoted in the article is reliable. But when I did searched web, his name appeared multiple times. Probably he may pass if sources are corrected. May be more sources are available in Bhojpuri language Deletion of Uday Narayan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
559 4920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Save Sunset Cliffs User:Joe 02:19, 13 May 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |organization Deletion of Save Sunset Cliffs WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
560 9815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Vincent User:Belovedfreak 11:14, 30 December 2010 (UTC) delete can't see anything in the article that demonstrates that he meets the |notability guidelines. The first few pages of google & gnews archives don't throw up any significant coverage. His IMDb page doesn't seem to show any major roles or awards Deletion of Craig Vincent WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
561 13551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob East User:David 00:40, 20 March 2021 (UTC) delete His works appear to have citation counts in the low single digits, not enough for #C1. Writing multiple books is not enough for ; we need multiple reviews of those books and I found only one review of one book https://www.jstor.org/stable/26621969 Deletion of Bob East WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
562 6983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/City attorney User:Mrschimpf 19:01, 13 April 2021 (UTC) keep You went right to deletion instead of trying to find sources and expanding it. . You have time to delete, you have time to expand Deletion of City attorney WP:SOFIXIT Wikipedia:Be bold 9
563 8256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mehera Irani User:Bearian 15:04, 7 October 2019 (UTC) delete per |lack of significant coverage and |inability to verify. The debate so far has been whether a single book that references the subject is itself notable. |Disciples of |barely notable religious figures are not themselves notable Deletion of Mehera Irani WP:SIGCOV||WP:V||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:BARE Wikipedia:Notability 77
564 3445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mind Riders Tech User:Bonadea 14:56, 30 October 2015 (UTC) delete Fails ; of the five references currently in the article, four are primary sources including press releases and the CEO's own website, and the fifth one looks like a rewrite of a press release so that's essentially primary as well Deletion of Mind Riders Tech WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
565 20022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kadal (1994 film) User:Donaldd23 16:28, 27 December 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Kadal (1994 film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
566 20259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Montenegrin hip hop musicians User:RGTraynor 03:34, 14 March 2008 (UTC) delete """God in Heaven; Montenegro has the population of the city of Boston, about ... how many hip hoppers who could possibly pass could there be? This is eerily similar to the X country at the Xth Winter Olympics articles that had no content beyond """"Mali didn't participate and never has,"""" because some insane inclusionist figured that there had to be an entry for each nation-state in the world""" Deletion of List of Montenegrin hip hop musicians WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
567 12035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GamerGate User:Citation 13:26, 16 September 2014 (UTC) comment There's a clear, although not snowy consensus amongst editors that the article is a clear pass. Arguments for deletion range between arguments based on (not grounds for deletion), merging into Sexual harassment in video gaming, and concerns of vios (most of which have been ironed out from edits made during protection and after). WP:BLP is always a valid concern, but this article surpassed the threshold for ages ago Deletion of GamerGate WP:GNG||WP:LIKELYVIOLATION||WP:GOSSIP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
568 8260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albert McCausland User:Coredesat 02:45, 25 August 2006 (UTC) delete movie key grips and extras don't really cut it under Deletion of Albert McCausland WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
569 9787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naomi Betts User:Peripitus 10:35, 11 March 2007 (UTC) delete many many criminals are arrested and many are shown on news shows. For Naomi there are no recent news articles .. the world has stopped caring and so should we. per as an indicriminate piece of information Deletion of Naomi Betts WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
570 13973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Modified Directory Structure User:Markhobley 09:01, 3 October 2006 (UTC) delete per likely . The page was created by Deletion of Modified Directory Structure WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
571 7559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barry Guerin User:JJL 14:39, 22 October 2008 (UTC) keep """appears to have fought at the professional level http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x6ndbz_barry-guerin-tkod-at-m1-challenge-t_sport which would likely pass , though which leagues are among the """"top"""" in MMA could be debated. Written as a promo and should be edited""" Deletion of Barry Guerin WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
572 4153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sompong Chuenyindee User:Deathlibrarian 01:42, 27 February 2018 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass criteria for |NFOOTY Deletion of Sompong Chuenyindee WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
573 1897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David William Parry (2nd nomination) User:Posen607 05:17, 14 August 2020 (UTC) keep """Firstly, please, note that the individual is not solely a poet. As it is already indicated in the article, he is also a dramaturge (theatre director, producer, actor), essayist and pastor, amongst other things. Therefore, his notability has to be noted in combination with multiple sources over a number of fields as opposed to one . Secondly, references support the content of the article, and demonstrate the individual's international notability (in the UK, Azerbaijan and Central Asia), through interviews with https://www.e-ir.info/2018/12/06/interview-david-parry/ E-International Relations (""""the world's leading open access website for students and scholars of international politics"""") and the https://www.bbc.com/kyrgyz/entertainment/2015/01/150116_iv_devid_parry_literature BBC, or articles about his professional work in The European Azerbaijan Society Magazine (TEAS), OCA Magazine (London), The Astana Times as well as reviews about his books, for example, in the the London Magazine. Obviously, some sources are printed and not available online. Where this is the case, there are specific details about the name, title, journal, year of publication and relevant pages of each source. Lastly, as far as I am aware, speaker candidates for TEDx events undergo rigorous selection processes (according to each individual's significance) before they are chosen as participants. This individual is already listed on the TED Talks website as a speaker in https://www.ted.com/tedx/events/33524 2019 and again in https://www.ted.com/tedx/events/38604 2020. All making me convinced this figure meets notability standards""" Deletion of David William Parry (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
574 3803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baylee Thomas Wylee Littrell User:Oncamera 07:39, 4 April 2007 (UTC) delete as well. Fails . '''Special:Contributions/Oncamera|on Deletion of Baylee Thomas Wylee Littrell WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
575 249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SSPX-affiliated religious orders User:Firefoxman 21:11, 6 March 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of SSPX-affiliated religious orders WP:VERIFY Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
576 4965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Himansh Kohli User:Kinu 06:28, 16 November 2012 (UTC) delete The coverage in is very cursory and not enough to warrant a Deletion of Himansh Kohli WP:RS||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
577 8600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Post Haste: The Letter Carrier Game User:Megaboz 01:26, 4 February 2009 (UTC) delete """If a |reliable source can be found to verify the """"more possibilities than any other game in use"""" claim then it would be notable. The single non-trivial reference isn't enough by itself to establish notability""" Deletion of Post Haste: The Letter Carrier Game WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
578 19689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cole Garner User:TonyBallioni 17:55, 14 April 2009 (UTC) keep At first I was inclined to delete, as most of the results are simply trivial mentions, but Fabrictramp's sources (the Rocky Mountain News) and a Denver Post article on him that I found http://www.denverpost.com/rockies/ci_12074214 establishes notability per and Deletion of Cole Garner WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
579 13204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wendy Hopkins Family Law Practice LLP User:Ihcoyc 15:09, 19 November 2009 (UTC) delete """http://news.google.com/archivesearch?&as_src=-newswire+-wire+-presswire+-PR+-press+-release+-wikipedia&q=%22Wendy+Hopkins+Family+Law+Practice+LLP%22 Google News tells the story by telling no story: it only finds a credit agency's pay per view report, of a kind that can't confer notability. A typical pattern emerges in the article: it spends more space arguing """"notability"""" through media appearances of company personnel or trade awards than it does telling of actual achievements that would confer real notability. There's a reason why |the business notability guideline discounts those things specifically""" Deletion of Wendy Hopkins Family Law Practice LLP WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
580 7643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bikash Khawas User:Atlantic306 21:45, 18 March 2019 (UTC) delete as no additional references have been put forward and I haven't found them so and are not passed at this stage of his career, unfortunately Deletion of Bikash Khawas WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
581 309 [[Rubén Serrano]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Wo st 01/Bewertung 06:40, 6. Jun. 2008 (CEST) delete neutral}}: |Selbstdarstellung ja, Werbung nach Überarbeitung des Artikels nicht mehr gegeben, http://catalogo.bne.es/uhtbin/cgisirsi/LTG3iJuzYl/BNMADRID/114131090/18/X100/XAUTHOR/Serrano,+Rub%C3%A9n Einträge in der Spanischen Nationalbibliothek Löschung von Rubén Serrano Wikipedia:SD Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
582 2023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of video game consoles (eighth generation) (3rd nomination) User:Mattyatty 17:23, 27 March 2007 (UTC) keep Normaly i am opposed to articles like this, but this one seems to be well sourced, with only a few speculative claims (which i plan on removing in a minute). I have had a breif read of and in my eyes, this article doesnt appear to break it. —The preceding Wikipedia:Sign your posts on talk pages|unsigned comment was added by Deletion of History of video game consoles (eighth generation) (3rd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
583 11927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timeline of 1st century B.C.E. Muslim history User:Tijfo098 23:51, 2 April 2011 (UTC) delete as hoax. POV is mildly putting it; it's plain Deletion of Timeline of 1st century B.C.E. Muslim history WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
584 6827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of mechanical keyboards (2nd nomination) User:Dmehus 16:55, 3 December 2019 (UTC) keep Not sure if there is a policy-based argument to this, but Wikipedia has a '''lot''' of |CRUFTy lists; this is a borderline case of those. I've seen a lot CRUFTier lists, some of which have survived AfD Deletion of List of mechanical keyboards (2nd nomination) WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
585 5520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Illinois Policy Institute User:SportingFlyer 12:23, 9 October 2018 (UTC) delete this is really badly source-bombed. It appears to fail - I've only looked at sources which appear to include the organisation in the article title, so I may have missed a few, since a cursory glance of the other sources doesn't suggest anything approaching notability, they're all on other topics or in some cases . I've also looked at the sources above and agree with HighKing. Also fails , and even if we somehow were to keep this, it almost certainly needs Deletion of Illinois Policy Institute WP:NCORP||WP:PRIMARY||WP:PROMO||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Notability 77
586 4043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Need for Speed: Hot Pursuit (series) User:Teancum 16:28, 16 July 2012 (UTC) delete WP:SPINOUT|Unnecessary article spinout. None of the images have rationale for these pages, and references/text are simply borrowed, meaning there's no real substance that doesn't already exist in either the series or individual game articles. It was a |Good faith creation, but is better suited for the http://nfs.wikia.com/wiki/Need_for_Speed_Wiki Need for Speed Wikia. The core series article (Need for Speed (series)) can easily be trimmed for length, too Deletion of Need for Speed: Hot Pursuit (series) WP:GOODFAITH Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
587 18253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Novelist (rapper) NONE NONE keep I created the article as Novelist currently meets the following criteria from Deletion of Novelist (rapper) WP:MUSBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
588 18681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mile High Music User:Lankiveil 05:44, 5 April 2008 (UTC) delete not yet notable per . Article can be recreated if and when they begin to meet those criteria Deletion of Mile High Music WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
589 1 [[Christoph Grube]] (gelöscht) Benutzerin:CaroFraTyskland NONE delete Die akademische Tätigkeit reicht (noch) nicht aus. Da sind unsere |Relevanzkriterien schärfer und die gängige Praxis ist bei Personen mit ähnlicher akademischer Laufbahn eine Löschung. Als Schauspieler ist keine Relevanz dargestellt, bliebe noch das Sprechen von Hörbüchern (dass es sich dabei um eine Person handelt, ist ausreichend belegt). Für Hörspielsprecher gibt es keine Einschlusskriterien, das Sprechen relevanter Autoren macht per se nicht relevant. Insgesamt fehlt es in diesem nicht-akademischen Bereich an der Darstellung der enzyklopädischen Relevanz. Vielleicht ändert sich die Lage ja noch mal und die Relevanz lässt sich in einem der Bereiche darstellen Löschung von Christoph Grube Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
590 8426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dennis Hogan User:Mdtemp 19:00, 12 February 2013 (UTC) delete He fails since he's not even ranked in the top 100 and has fought for no world championships. That's not close to a top 10 ranking and fighting for Queensland state titles is a long way for a major world title bout Deletion of Dennis Hogan WP:NBOX Wikipedia:Notability 77
591 21291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Politics and influences of J.K. Rowling User:Haemo 04:46, 6 June 2007 (UTC) delete appears to be entirely |original research Deletion of Politics and influences of J.K. Rowling WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
592 4417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sutcliffe Jügend User:Samat 00:38, 12 June 2021 (UTC) delete it Fails & , Not enough significant coverege on NO evidence of Notability Deletion of Sutcliffe Jügend WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
593 16272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/René Patrick Burakowski User:Piotrus 17:37, 28 March 2017 (UTC) delete as per nom. It all seems sketchy to me. Looks like something along the lines of to me. Also as Deletion of René Patrick Burakowski WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
594 14950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Action of March 10th, 2011 User:Anotherclown 10:27, 8 June 2011 (UTC) delete """seems to lack """"significant coverage"""" so is likely non-notable under the . Anything that is cited can be merged to Sajjad Afghani, although that article is also in need of some to establish its notability""" Deletion of Action of March 10th, 2011 WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
595 19058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Bad Treasure User:Kzrulzuall 09:13, 18 February 2007 (UTC) delete per . Utter rubbish, television wasn't even invented in the 1800's Deletion of The Bad Treasure WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
596 8252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of dignitaries of mystical organisations User:Walton 17:47, 19 January 2007 (UTC) delete per nom and especially per - I don't see that the internal structures of secret organisations can be verified Deletion of List of dignitaries of mystical organisations WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
597 19305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mani Irani User:GSS 18:10, 13 May 2018 (UTC) delete per . Not seeing any in-depth third-party sourcing sufficient to establish independent notability Deletion of Mani Irani WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
598 12395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Best of Sonic the Hedgehog User:Sephiroth 00:18, 24 April 2008 (UTC) delete appears to be a . Fails and otherwise Deletion of The Best of Sonic the Hedgehog WP:HOAX||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
599 21663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paying the Price: Killing the Children of Iraq User:Coren 00:07, 19 November 2007 (UTC) delete spammy and at least partly copyvio - no |reliable sources, and no real assertion of notability. — Deletion of Paying the Price: Killing the Children of Iraq WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
600 3426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skirt (slang) User:Dcandeto 16:49, 28 February 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Skirt (slang) WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
601 17493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Latarsha Rose User:Clarityfiend 10:06, 30 May 2012 (UTC) comment Seventeen minor credits in TV episodes and shorts don't bolster her notability, and ''Being Mary Jane'' is in pre-production. It's just Deletion of Latarsha Rose WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
602 17789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kristinn Steindórsson User:Argyle 13:57, 16 September 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Kristinn Steindórsson WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
603 14083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CorporateGrapevine User:King 22:05, 25 May 2009 (UTC) delete as original |PRODder Deletion of CorporateGrapevine WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
604 17075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Australian coalition against death penalty User:Zeibura 13:05, 13 July 2007 (UTC) delete This is soapboxing, and vires completely away from the subject. As Propaniac rightly points out, the factual content of this article is all concerned with the death penalty, take all that away and you're left with nothing but the company's mission statement, which is far from neutral and with no assertions to notability. This violates #WEBSPACE and #SOAP Deletion of Australian coalition against death penalty WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
605 11166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Hemingway User:PohranicniStraze 05:36, 14 September 2017 (UTC) delete per nom and A bit iffy. No reliable sources turning up in google, doesn't appear to meet Deletion of Nick Hemingway WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
606 8101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unexplained disappearances User:I 06:12, 22 February 2015 (UTC) delete The topic is notable, but this article is collection of topics, many without sources. It's perhaps best to and start over with a coherent article Deletion of Unexplained disappearances WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:BLOWITUP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
607 20770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Le Brocq User:RFerreira 00:15, 7 October 2007 (UTC) keep per Haiduc. This is a slight, but completely understandable, miseuse of the policy Deletion of David Le Brocq WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
608 16869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Don Martin (public affairs) NONE NONE comment A subject approving or requesting deletion of an article about himself is not reason for a speedy delete, and it is not even reason for deletion, period. Please review , , , and , which states Deletion of Don Martin (public affairs) WP:CSD||WP:BLP||WP:NOTABILITY||WP:AUTOBIOGRAPHY Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
609 10554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Report to the Inspector General into Mobile Telecommunications Licenses in Iraq [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] 04:17, 13 May 2015 (UTC) delete The article is one of the worst examples of non-neutral editing that I've seen and it's rife with BLP violations. As far as I can tell, coverage in reliable sources is sparse, suggesting that the subject doesn't pass . Since there is no NPOV version to revert to, I have nominated the article for #G10| deletion Deletion of Report to the Inspector General into Mobile Telecommunications Licenses in Iraq WP:GNG||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Notability 77
610 4144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The House That Had Enough User:Geoffroi 00:21, 18 June 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of The House That Had Enough WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
611 4673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/University College of Engineering, Kariavattom User:Bearian 19:46, 23 May 2016 (UTC) keep it appears to be a small but real college, which we keep |absent a need to start from scratch. Only problem I see is a possible lack of accreditation Deletion of University College of Engineering, Kariavattom WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
612 11386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Forde User:Jrp 13:38, 23 March 2009 (UTC) keep """this actor doesn't satisfy as he is famous for only one role. However, EastEnders is very notable television show (in Britain) and I find that some of that notability is inherited in this case. (Even though it's a BLP, with all the associated risks.) As an actor in an important and notable ensemble cast, I would say let's keep this for now. Although """"notability isn't temporary"""", if he gets booted from the show and never works again, we shouldn't have an article about him. I could also be convinced if I am told that he has absolutely no speaking role or such a minor role as to be irrelevant. (I have never seen the show, only read about it.) This is a mixed response, but this is a difficult case""" Deletion of James Forde WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
613 19438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Push development User:Topcipher 10:54, 19 April 2017 (UTC) delete an example of |what Wikipedia is not Deletion of Push development WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
614 103 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Meltem TV (3. aday gösterme) """Kullanıcı:melihsenms""" 09.57, 16 Ocak 2020 (UTC) keep Gelişi güzel olarak mı artık içerikler silinmeye aday gösteriliyor? |Şu ölçütlere göre bakarsak, TV kanalı ilk yayın yapan kanallardan biridir ve birçok konuda atıf yapılmıştır. Her madde de kaynaklarla kayda değerliği orta konulmamış diye aday gösterirsek, Vikipedi'nin yarısının silinmesi lazım. Flash TV'yi de aday gösterelim, kaynaklarla durumu belirtilmediği için, popüler olmadığı için Meltem TV (3.gün Gösterme) siliniyor Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
615 5600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jini (IRC client) User:Joe 23:03, 30 September 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of Jini (IRC client) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
616 18386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shapur Mozaffarian User:Joseph2302 01:17, 11 May 2015 (UTC) delete Seems to fail , more importantly the means that even if notable, the article would need to be rewritten from scratch, per Deletion of Shapur Mozaffarian WP:GNG||WP:PROMO||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Notability 77
617 10651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kristi Yamaoka (6th nomination) User:JEdgarFreeman 21:28, 5 September 2008 (UTC) delete """Firstly, I would like to re-iterate Indrian's point that """"We are not here to debate the notability of the accident."""" The fall's notability is, to be frank, irrelevant, as this is an article about Yamaoka, not her accident. This article breaks , , and #NEWS, which state """"If reliable sources only cover the person in the context of a particular event, then a separate biography is unlikely to be warranted"""", """"If reliable sources only cover the person in the context of a particular event, then a separate biography may be unwarranted"""", and """"Unless news coverage of an individual goes beyond the context of a single event, our coverage of that individual should be limited to the article about that event"""" respectively. I have found not found multiple, reliable, independent, and secondary sources that offer non-trivial coverage of Yamaoka outside of the context of the fall. As a result, I do not believe that this article should remain. Frankly, I am surprised that this article was not deleted earlier. To me, this article is a classic violation of the three guidelines I have used in my argument for deletion (Struck out due to my decision to support a re-direct (see below)). Thank you for reading""" Deletion of Kristi Yamaoka (6th nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:BIO1E||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
618 725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ken Fujimoto User:Jeendan 09:58, 16 February 2007 (UTC) delete Nice-looking page but there's nothing here that meets or Deletion of Ken Fujimoto WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
619 16591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Destiny (Marvel Comics personification) User:Path 08:35, 13 September 2019 (UTC) keep Merge to List of Marvel Comics characters: D as per the ''context'' in Deletion of Destiny (Marvel Comics personification) WP:MERGEREASON Wikipedia:Merging 54
620 6192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vikram Kaur Khalsa User:FuFoFuEd 19:51, 20 August 2011 (UTC) delete Most biographical details are from IMDB and similar user-contributed web sites. There's only passing mention of her in reliable sources. Fails Deletion of Vikram Kaur Khalsa WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
621 2502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Western School of Health and Business Careers - Monroeville User:Noroton 04:44, 25 January 2008 (UTC) delete unless someone can demonstrate notability as per or . This is a for-profit company, and while I disagree with the sometimes wild lengths that some editors go to in avoiding mentions of for-profit companies, we do sometimes need to hold them to a strict standard. The reasons for that are (a) they've got a bit less accountability to the public and are therefore more likely to lie in their self-published materials, including their Web site, and (b) I think there's slightly more chance that someone working for the place could present the company in a distorted way. For the good of Wikipedia, we don't want to be an advertising vehicle. I did a cursory look at G-hits and Google Archive hits and didn't find good sources. Also, there's an article for this campus, but not for the school as a whole (the other campus is in Pittsburgh) and it seems to me that a single article encompassing the entire school would be more appropriate. By the way, the dean of education for this school http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/news/cityregion/s_451104.html plead guilty to charges that he lied to the federal government. That doesn't mean the school is lieing all over the place, but it isn't reassuring Deletion of Western School of Health and Business Careers - Monroeville WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
622 2443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Great Jedi Purge (4th nomination) User:Colonel 08:27, 29 September 2013 (UTC) keep The topic is documented in sources such as '' Star Wars: A Movie Embedded In American Culture''; ''Jedi vs. Sith: The Essential Guide to the Force''; ''Star Wars and History''. If the nominator wants the article improved he should go at it per {{tl|sofixit}}. AFDs are not the way because |AFD is not cleanup Deletion of Great Jedi Purge (4th nomination) WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
623 4395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chase McLaughlin User:Eagles247 17:14, 2 October 2019 (UTC) keep when he passes this Sunday as the Chargers' new kicker (signed to the active roster today Deletion of Chase McLaughlin WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
624 18591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miho Tachibana User:Ad 20:46, 16 April 2014 (UTC) delete Subject fails PORNBIO and BASIC. Sources fail per nom Deletion of Miho Tachibana WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
625 2259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2023 NFL Draft User:Ejgreen77 05:46, 27 April 2020 (UTC) merge to National Football League Draft#Future venues. It's a plausible search term, and redirects are , anyways Deletion of 2023 NFL Draft WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
626 21559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The New IP User:Tigraan 09:31, 25 March 2015 (UTC) delete """obvious (''""""...simplify network processes, increase flexibility and control from users, and provide an alternative""" Deletion of The New IP WP:ARTSPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
627 15077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Baker (philosopher) User:Margin1522 02:25, 19 February 2015 (UTC) keep """This is the second nomination. The first one is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Alan_Baker_%28shogi%29 here. I agree about the shogi. About academics, I think that the publications may meet #C1, significant impact. Rather than the number it is the quality of the cites that impresses me. The first one in GS, in Mind (journal)|Mind, has been cited in top-level journals, listed with the http://mind.oxfordjournals.org/content/114/454/223.short the abstract, and it seems to have been significant attention. Likewise for the second one, http://bjps.oxfordjournals.org/content/60/3/611.short here. From his CV, he authored the article """"Simplicity"""" in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. So at least within his field he seems to be well known. – """ Deletion of Alan Baker (philosopher) WP:NACADEMICS Wikipedia:Notability 77
628 650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zum zum zum User:RyRy5 19:09, 20 April 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Zum zum zum WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
629 12442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Goldhead Group User:Citrusbowler 15:42, 16 June 2013 (UTC) delete Fails ; there are no reliable sources Deletion of The Goldhead Group WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
630 8339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Fagan User:Bettia 10:21, 12 June 2009 (UTC) delete He fails as he has yet to make his professional debut, and there's no indication that he has acheived anything of note in any other field. This article can be recreated if and when he makes his debut Deletion of Chris Fagan WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
631 4304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EEE SUST User:Pgallert 21:17, 16 December 2011 (UTC) merge with SUST. If the parent article becomes too long, it would be strategically better to create separate pages for the Schools, and only if those get too long as well should the departments have separate WP pages. Technically (), the EEE department is not separately notable at this time Deletion of EEE SUST WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
632 8880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joelle Behlock User:Montanabw 20:52, 22 July 2017 (UTC) keep """normally I view beauty queen articles with suspicion, but here she has gone on to do a number of different things, and given the difficulty of finding third world sources that compare in quality to those in the first world, I think we DO have enough coverage to be adequate for GNG. Also, to say """"That piece is an interview, so it's not |independent of the subject"""" misreads the guidelines ... who is the interviewer, what media published the interview, etc... that's what matters. This is also an article tht needs a lot of work, but I think it passes muster""" Deletion of Joelle Behlock WP:42||WP:42 Wikipedia:The answer to life, the universe, and everything 7
633 13987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reekrit Serai NONE NONE comment User:Radzee, there is no question that Reekrit has written two books and helped organize the '''first''' edition of this literature festival, but does that make him notable per otability (people)? As with the previous state of the article, you have presented what appears to be an impressive set of links, but the problem is that some are duplicates, a couple are archived versions of these links, several are blogs and/or forums and some are about the literature festival more than they are about him Deletion of Reekrit Serai WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
634 9 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Gökhan Birben """Kullanıcı:pragdon'''pragdon'''""" 09.38, 14 Haziran 2020 (UTC) keep """İlk albümü de Raks Müzik'ten çıkmış. https://www.discogs.com/Gökhan-Birben-Hey-Gidi-Karadeniz/release/10739364 Buradan görülebilir. Böylece kriterlerinden birini karşılıyor. Bunun dışında https://books.google.com.tr/books?id=oc0dDAAAQBAJ&lpg=PP1&ots=NbYdnwxzGZ&dq=""""Gökhan Birben""""&lr&hl=tr&pg=PA233#v=onepage&q=Gökhan Birben&f=false şuradaki kitapta da yayınladığı şarkı ve albümleri inceleniyor. İlk çıktığı zamanlar kayda değerdi şuan durumları nedir bilmiyorum ama https://karnaval.com/muzik/karadeniz-ruhunu-yasatan-en-iyi-9-sanatci-15-486803-haber Karnaval.com'da da bahsi geçiyor""" Gökhan Birben'in silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
635 21583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baruch Halpern User:Siva1979 07:47, 6 September 2007 (UTC) delete Fails . The subject in question has not published any significant and well-known academic work. --|S Deletion of Baruch Halpern WP:PROF||WP:EA Wikipedia:Notability 77
636 14539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mandaara User:The 11:20, 8 August 2018 (UTC) merge """mercifully into """"Bhaagamathie|''Bhaagamathie''"""" since subject lacks |independent notability. A Redirect would be welcome""" Deletion of Mandaara WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
637 4781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Trenches NONE NONE comment Fans or not, as wickethewok says, the article quite clearly fails #Burden_of_evidence and Deletion of The Trenches WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
638 11978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antonio Marion User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:27, 30 December 2012 (UTC) delete as being |TOO SOON for this Broadway producer. I gave the article a major face-lift,http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Antonio_Marion&diff=530417313&oldid=530165209 but his career is far too short,http://www.ibdb.com/person.php?id=492097http://www.playbillvault.com/Person/Detail/122902/Antonio-Marion he has received no coverage, and the purported awards are not verifiable Deletion of Antonio Marion WP:NYA Wikipedia:Too soon 40
639 3928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derrick Van Orden User:SportingFlyer 20:52, 23 April 2020 (UTC) delete non-notable political candidate, not convinced by the argument Deletion of Derrick Van Orden WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
640 13652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WABDL Canadian Deadlift Records User:DoubleBlue 07:47, 23 November 2008 (UTC) delete Even were it to be prettily formatted, there are no including what is noted on the talk page Deletion of WABDL Canadian Deadlift Records WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
641 12882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stereotypes of Arabs and Muslims User:Sijo 13:28, 6 February 2007 (UTC) comment As this is a violation of : ''Synthesis of published material serving to advance a position''. It is possible to make a similar article for every ethnic or religious group because for every group one will find something that will support their position. This article seems to select a few authors and films to make a statement. This càomment may be striked when it can be proven that there exist a substantial academic literature about this subject, rather than selecting a few authors to advance an opinion. Also it seems to be a good idea to differ between Muslims and Arabs, and between American and Western European societies. As many muslims and Arabs live in Western Europe, it is possible that e.g. films show a less stereotypical image, see for instance Gegen die Wand, which can hardly be claimed to be stereotypical Deletion of Stereotypes of Arabs and Muslims WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
642 17638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohit Sukhija User:MezzoMezzo 03:32, 21 April 2013 (UTC) delete This subject, as an amateur actor, seems to fail all three criteria of . Of the given sources, one is a university website's main page, one is a blog, and at least three others which I spot checked don't even mention the subject Deletion of Mohit Sukhija WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
643 329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Beginner's Guide to Snuff User:DBigXray 19:01, 5 July 2018 (UTC) keep Per above, Nom has failed to point out the Policy this article violates. IMHO passes Deletion of A Beginner's Guide to Snuff WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
644 1284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Am a Hotel User:Pastor 23:39, 7 July 2009 (UTC) keep The article meets standards. As an FYI, short films have a long history of artistic and social notability Deletion of I Am a Hotel WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
645 16958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lewis E. Reed [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 03:50, 18 May 2007 (UTC) delete per and . No indication that person has been the subject of coverage by reliable, third-party sources. -- Deletion of Lewis E. Reed WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
646 12825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bonny Lake State Park User:Shawn 03:55, 24 July 2016 (UTC) keep If that's the case, the article should simply be updated to reflect the park's closing. State parks would be notable under , regardless of whether it's a current or former park. Indeed, GEOLAND links to , in cases like of abandoned places -- and that would apply in this case here too Deletion of Bonny Lake State Park WP:GEOLAND||WP:NOTTEMPORARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
647 6010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vinay Deolalikar User:GorillaWarfare 17:36, 9 August 2010 (UTC) delete Goodness, third edit conflict I've run into. Anyway, not |notable enough to meet requirements. Maybe once the proof is substantiated? Additionally, I'd like to point out a few things in response to Aksi's argument. Do you have sources proving notability? Regarding your second point (about the blog posts and tweets) please read . Regarding your third point, please see . Sorry to throw policies at you like this, but the arguments you make above are not strong enough to hold up. The first might be, if you had sources to back it up Deletion of Vinay Deolalikar WP:N||WP:UNRS||WP:POPULARPAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
648 2183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cambridge Satchel Company User:Ihcoyc 14:51, 25 October 2011 (UTC) delete """albeit weakly. It would appear that there are indeed sources talking about the business. There's a human interest story of the week aspect about its foundation, and it would appear that its products have become a passing fad in the world of fashion. I don't see this kind of coverage as making a case that this business has """"|had any significant or demonstrable effects on culture, society, entertainment, athletics, economies, history, literature, science, or education."""" It apparently makes satchels that some folks like. A worthy achievement, but not the sort of thing that equates to the sort of long term significance that endures for centuries and makes the business an encyclopedia subject""" Deletion of Cambridge Satchel Company WP:ORGIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
649 12599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cryonics Society User:Lquilter 13:43, 17 August 2012 (UTC) delete for now) and reference elsewhere - Relatively new organization (2005 or 2006), so length of history (a factor under ) is not particularly notable. Nor does size of membership suggest notability. Its stated scope (the only cryonics society) ''does'' suggest some notability, but in the absence of press or any other significant recognition, we have no way of verifying that claim. At this point it appears to be an organization started by one guy that has done a direct mail campaign to 80,000 to inform them about something about cryonics. Should cryonics ever really take off, then this organization might play a role and demonstrate its own notability. But right now it should be a brief reference in the cryonics article Deletion of Cryonics Society WP:NONPROFIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
650 7166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chiricheppu User:Luna 13:40, 14 August 2006 (UTC) delete I'm still not seeing any demonstrated |notability; there are some claims, but I'm not sure if it's backed up. A scant 65 ghits http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=Chiricheppu&btnG=Google+Search, the top result of which is en.wikipedia, and several of the upper results appear irrelevant to this context; zero hits at gnews http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&q=Chiricheppu&btnG=Google+Search&sa=N&tab=wn. This just doesn't seem to have a very big footprint, to me; sorry folks. This isn't a commentary on the comic, I'm sure it's great and I hope you enjoy it, it's just that we don't really have room to write out an article on every comic ever written -- there has to be a line, somewhere, and I'm not yet convinced that Chiricheppu has passed that line. If you'd like to try and change my mind, it would be wise to link to various websites which will support your points. Thanks for your time, everybody, and have a good one Deletion of Chiricheppu WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
651 450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Société des Amis des Universités de Paris User:Kudpung 07:38, 14 January 2013 (UTC) keep per User:Mcewan, but remove all the unsourced BLP red-listed people per Deletion of Société des Amis des Universités de Paris WP:LISTPEOPLE Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
652 263 [[Foetz]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Stefan64 NONE keep Orte sind per se #St.C3.A4dte.2C_Gemeinden_u..C3.A4.|relevant. Ach ja, und ich habe da schonmal getankt Löschung von Foetz Wikipedia:Relevanz Wikipedia:Notability 77
653 10007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheep Films User:Eddie891 18:22, 16 June 2020 (UTC) delete I found no sources to substantiate |General notability, the website suggests no coverage of that kind exists Deletion of Sheep Films WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
654 6925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Into That Good Night (Roseanne) [[User talk:TenPoundHammer|Otters want attention]]) 19:59, 31 January 2011 (UTC) merge per nom and per , not likely that this is the kind of work that will be repeatedly undone by a rabid fanboy/girl. Ten Pound Hammer, Special:Contributions/TenPoundHammer|his otters and a clue-bat Deletion of Into That Good Night (Roseanne) WP:EPISODE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
655 8346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Masked Mystery Villain User:SailingInABathTub 10:33, 13 April 2021 (UTC) keep the nominator does not propose a valid -REASON. The nominator does not say which notability guideline this article fails to meet Deletion of Masked Mystery Villain WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
656 17133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Newborn Mural User:Sethie 04:12, 8 March 2008 (UTC) keep This is actually not a news article, but an article about an art piece. The piece has appeared in multiple newspapers, hence passes . Stubs are not a reason to delete! (if he merge happens I say we call it a sculpture Deletion of Newborn Mural WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
657 10395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/U.K. Sivagnanam User:Rameshnta909 20:14, 10 December 2016 (UTC) delete Non notable activist. Fails . I couldn't find anything with a coverage of the person Deletion of U.K. Sivagnanam WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
658 17175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marathwada Neta User:Cutest 08:51, 2 August 2015 (UTC) delete This article fails as well as it does not meets Deletion of Marathwada Neta WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
659 17059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Defiore User:SWik78 19:54, 30 May 2008 (UTC) delete Fails , nothing to verify this person's exsitence, let alone |notability Deletion of John Defiore WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
660 127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Windows Police Pro User:RekishiEJ 18:13, 30 October 2009 (UTC) keep """Bleeping Computer has made this an independent article, and the article meets and three core content policies. I've just added a category by using HotCat to make the article more complete. By the way, they're more and more Wikipedians nominate articles for deletion since they regard them """"non-notable"""", but in fact have certain notability""" Deletion of Windows Police Pro WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
661 1609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hana Yori Dango / Meteor Garden (Korean Version) User:AmeIiorate 12:09, 30 May 2008 (UTC) delete Fails , , , , reads like a . Possibly passes CSD#A1. '''~ Ameliorate Deletion of Hana Yori Dango / Meteor Garden (Korean Version) WP:N||WP:OR||WP:WEASEL||WP:FUTURE||WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Notability 77
662 18944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Automaton Biographies User:EEMIV 03:06, 29 December 2009 (UTC) delete looks like #ESSAY. and/or / Deletion of Automaton Biographies WP:NOT||WP:OR||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
663 13377 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""Switchback""""""" User:Asenine 14:52, 12 August 2008 (UTC) delete Fails """Deletion of """"Switchback""""""" WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
664 19890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tui Amar Rani User:AllyD 13:47, 21 April 2017 (UTC) delete An unreleased film and my searches are finding nothing relating to a film of this name. Fails , Deletion of Tui Amar Rani :WP:NFF||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
665 6726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beowulf (Los Angeles band) User:Doc 08:06, 27 January 2008 (UTC) delete doesn't assert |notability, fails Deletion of Beowulf (Los Angeles band) WP:N||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
666 9800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wilshire Regent User:Finngall 20:55, 16 January 2016 (UTC) comment This discussion page was created without the {{tl|afd2}} template and never transcluded to a daily log. Fixed now--I offer no comment on the nomination itself. {{ping|BeenAroundAWhile}} Please fully follow the procedures at for future nominations. Thanks Deletion of Wilshire Regent WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
667 21567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Hughes and Margo Montgomery User:Ambrosiawater 02:36, 21 January 2020 (UTC) keep Meets Deletion of Tom Hughes and Margo Montgomery WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
668 9062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hindu terrorism User:Otolemur 02:35, 25 May 2008 (UTC) delete """Unlike Islamic terrorism and Christian terrorism, the concept of Hindu terrorism does not exists. Some google ghits does not mean there can be any thing like """"Hindu terrorism"""", some people might have used the term """"Hindu terrorism"""", but the concept is not accepted in the academia and nonexistent. Even if an organization attacks other religious groups, kills people, we cannot label the organization """"terrorist"""" unless that particular group is designated as terrorist organization by at least one government. In this article some violent Hindu organizations are presented as terrorist group. But none of these organizations are designated as """"terrorist"""". Hence the article is a """ Deletion of Hindu terrorism WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
669 19278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allan Bligh User:AssociateAffiliate 21:00, 19 January 2021 (UTC) keep Meets , played four List A matches. Nice to see JPL is as tactful as ever Deletion of Allan Bligh WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
670 10316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fresco Norway User:HighKing 18:53, 25 May 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and GNG Deletion of Fresco Norway WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
671 17516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katarína Manová User:Bearian 21:35, 18 November 2014 (UTC) delete I'm sorry, but this model seems very |run of the mill Deletion of Katarína Manová WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
672 17055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tecnoesis [[User talk:2604:2000:8FC0:4:617F:E9A7:AF1C:4546|talk]]) 16:46, 10 December 2019 (UTC) delete alternatively Draft/Userfy pending future notability. Per there needs to be |diverse, |in-depth, and |persistent coverage. I reviewed the google books, news, scholar, and general search results. Even for the last only six pages of websites were listed and almost none of the coverage is independent and so the notability criteria are not met. Merging is sometimes an alternative but there isn't enough independent coverage here to warrant more than a sentence or two on the topic. Would be willing to strike and reconsider if new evidence shows that is met. Special:Contributions/2604:2000:8FC0:4:617F:E9A7:AF1C:4546|2604:2000:8FC0:4:617F:E9A7:AF1C:4546 Deletion of Tecnoesis WP:NEVENT||WP:DIVERSE||WP:INDEPTH||WP:PERSISTENCE||WP:NEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
673 10825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khuila User:Kinu 21:09, 13 January 2011 (UTC) delete at ''best'' this is an article about a neologism with zero to warrant inclusion Deletion of Khuila WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
674 11617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Cost (band) User:Paul 06:40, 8 March 2012 (UTC) keep The cited coverage in SF Weekly, Allmusic and Pitchfork is enough for criterion #1, even if not strongly so Deletion of The Cost (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
675 4520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Gore Effect User:Nsaa 13:32, 13 June 2010 (UTC) keep """Some of the text needs to be rewritten so it's fully supported by the sources given (especially op-eds used should be """"attribute the material in the text to the author""""), but the term has been used significantly by mainstream media, and got in dept coverage as shown above by many other users""" Deletion of The Gore Effect WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
676 21672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pol Goossen User:Alan 04:36, 2 October 2011 (UTC) delete Non-notable actor. Fails Deletion of Pol Goossen WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
677 17501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Olavi Hangula User:Jersey92 00:18, 4 December 2016 (UTC) delete At best this article is . He clearly fails . Either way delete Deletion of Olavi Hangula WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
678 15261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Pyrenees earthquake [[User talk:137.122.49.102|talk]]) 20:17, 18 May 2010 (UTC) delete per . I remember the 1988 Saguenay earthquake, and it actually had a foreshock of the magnitude of the earthquake under AfD. The foreshock doesn't have its own article.--Special:Contributions/137.122.49.102|137.122.49.102 Deletion of 2010 Pyrenees earthquake WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
679 2056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Computer Systems Odessa User:Coredesat 01:09, 15 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Computer Systems Odessa WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
680 10017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arvind Kumar Agrawal User:David 22:28, 23 December 2018 (UTC) comment """In the Indian system, vice chancellor actually is the highest academic position, as chancellor is a more ceremonial role. So vice chancellor of a major Indian university would clearly pass #C6. But Mahatma Gandhi Central University is so new that it might not pass the """"major"""" part of the criterion""" Deletion of Arvind Kumar Agrawal WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
681 600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loreen Hall User:Sro23 19:35, 3 April 2018 (UTC) keep I can't help but sympathize when someone who asks for BLPREQUESTDELETE, and though I don't see anything defamatory or libelous in the article I can understand privacy concerns, but per there's no way the subject ''is not'' notable for Wikipedia Deletion of Loreen Hall WP:NOLYMPICS Wikipedia:Notability 77
682 11130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Egoleech User:Superastig 01:09, 12 June 2020 (UTC) keep I found a few reliable sources which talk about the abum: https://yourlastrites.com/2004/07/14/cock-and-ball-torture-egoleech-review/, http://www.disagreement.net/reviews/cockandballtorture_egoleech.html, https://rockhard.de/reviews/cock-and-ball-torture-egoleech_307179.html, https://metalitalia.com/album/cock-and-ball-torture-egoleech/ and https://wormgearzine.com/2009/01/03/cock-and-ball-torture-egoleech/. With these, the article is good enough to pass . My vote stands. I won't reply any further Deletion of Egoleech WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
683 21515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agon Mucolli User:MKJ6006 10:05, 11 May 2017 (UTC) comment The article may show multiple RSes but fail's and Deletion of Agon Mucolli WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
684 20060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wade Koehl User:Cbl62 01:47, 16 November 2011 (UTC) keep """The article is in pretty poor shape as it stands, and it needs to be improved. But it looks like Koehl has had enough non-trivial coverage in mainstream media sources to pass . Some of it is coverage in his hometown newspaper from Midland, Texas, but there are also two feature stories and a lengthy interview in the ''Houston Chronicle'' (12th List of newspapers in the United States by circulation|largest circulation newspaper in the US), an in-depth feature story from BP Sports, and a CBS Sports story about his being listed on the Butkus Award list. The """"need for speed"""" feature story also has some depth. These article do not constitute routine coverage. Examples of the coverage include: '''(1)''' http://www.chron.com/CDA/archives/archive.mpl/2006_4226394/koehl-s-a-big-hit-off-the-field-too-uh-linebacker.html Koehl's a big hit off the field, too: UH linebacker makes tackles on Saturday, grades every other day, Houston Chronicle, Nov. 2006; '''(2)''' http://www.chron.com/CDA/archives/archive.mpl/2007_4448474/ncaa-football-koehl-covets-roster-spot-on-new-pro.html Koehl covets roster spot on new pro club: Team Texas has tryouts for spring football league, Houston Chronicle, October 2007; '''(3)''' http://www.bpsports.net/bpsports.asp?ID=5575 Koehl: Created to play football, BP Sports, May 2007; '''(4)''' http://www.cstv.com/sports/m-footbl/stories/082004aat.html Koehl Selected To Butkus Award List, CBS Sports, Aug. 2004; '''(5)''' http://blog.chron.com/cougars/2007/03/post-pro-day-with-wade-koehl/ Post-Pro Day with ... Wade Koehl, Houston Chronicle, March 2007; '''(6)''' http://archive.thedailycougar.com/vol71/156/sports/sports2.html Koehl feels need for speed, The Daily Cougar, Aug. 2006; '''(7)''' http://archive.thedailycougar.com/vol72/68/sports/sports2.html Koehl makes the grade: Linebacker voted to C-USA All-Academic team, The Daily Cougar, Nov. 2006; '''(8)''' http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=MRTB&p_theme=mrtb&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=118CBE61F0B80008&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM Koehl watches and waits during this year's NFL draft, Midland Reporter-Telegram, April 2007; '''(9)''' http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=MRTB&p_theme=mrtb&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=118DBC11013EDCE8&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM Koehl agrees to free agent deal with New Orleans Saints, Midland Reporter-Telegram, April 2007; '''(10)''' http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=MRTB&p_theme=mrtb&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=10EB915BC673AC20&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM Koehl honored by Conference USA, Midland Reporter-Telegram, Dec. 2005; '''(11)''' http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=MRTB&p_theme=mrtb&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=10C449A161FF52C8&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM Koehl named to Lombardi watch list, Midland Reporter-Telegram, Aug. 2005; '''(12)''' http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=MRTB&p_theme=mrtb&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0FE2AF96800E4D21&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM MHS' Koehl commits to University of Houston, Midland Reporter-Telegram, Feb 2003; '''(13)''' http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=MRTB&p_theme=mrtb&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=1145F3FDE5CD8E0B&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM An introduction to Cougars football from a Midland native, Midland Reporter-Telegram, Sept. 2006; '''(14)''' http://www.uhcougars.com/sports/m-footbl/spec-rel/112706aaa.html Koehl Unanimous Pick to Conference USA All-Academic Team, Univ.of Houston release, Nov. 2006""" Deletion of Wade Koehl WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
685 4547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skilling v. United States User:RadManCF 23:48, 11 March 2011 (UTC) keep The supreme court is so closely followed by legions of legal publications, so I would argue that its not unreasonable to assume it's decisions are notable per Deletion of Skilling v. United States WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
686 14791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RockIRCd User:Ironholds 18:21, 10 August 2009 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of RockIRCd WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
687 3600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xtube (2nd nomination) [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 02:54, 2 June 2013 (UTC) keep on the basis of my comment above and the sources listed by DGG. If those sources aren't in the article, add them, per Deletion of Xtube (2nd nomination) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
688 2716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eimar O'Duffy User:Ginsengbomb 18:26, 27 August 2013 (UTC) keep Subject appears to have been a fairly prominent author in his time. Article in its current state is very poor, but subject seems very viable for inclusion. http://books.google.com/books?id=I_E2nQEACAAJ&dq=Eimar+O'Duffy&hl=en&sa=X&ei=uu4cUue1EeygsASypID4Bw&ved=0CDEQ6AEwATgK Here is one book devoted entirely to the subject's works, and https://www.google.com/search?q=Eimar+O'Duffy&oq=Eimar+O'Duffy&aqs=chrome..69i57j69i60l2j0l3.203j0&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8#fp=c2773ddb15015db4&q=Eimar+O'Duffy&start=10&tbm=bks this Gbooks search reveals a lot of authors writing ''about'' the subject once you go to Page 2. Everything on Page 1 is the subject's own works. Appears to be fairly heavily-cited on http://scholar.google.com/scholar?start=0&q=Eimar+O%27Duffy&hl=en&as_sdt=0,33 Google Scholar as well. Keep per |the relevant notability guideline Deletion of Eimar O'Duffy WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
689 14113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pasaffe User:Lagrange613 03:19, 1 February 2019 (UTC) delete No significant coverage, no evidence that it passes Deletion of Pasaffe WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
690 2008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christine Fang User:KidAd 02:20, 20 December 2020 (UTC) delete Clear example of . Redirect pertinent content to the pages of politicians she was affiliated with Deletion of Christine Fang WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
691 12890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Expert Drones User:Qwertyus 17:33, 5 November 2015 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Expert Drones WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
692 20339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clyde, Imperial County, California User:Cxbrx 00:27, 14 December 2020 (UTC) delete No http://pbbooks.com/caindex.htm post offices. I checked Frink and Ruthven and found only railroad references. No legal recognition, no nontrivial coverage, so is not met Deletion of Clyde, Imperial County, California WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
693 19992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave Kruger User:Paulmcdonald 21:39, 2 March 2013 (UTC) keep the coverage to me seems to be enough to pass the Deletion of Dave Kruger WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
694 14480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J'ai bu du café dans un café User:INeedSupport 19:17, 29 May 2019 (UTC) delete I couldn't find any sources that talks about the film in detail. Thus, it fails and Deletion of J'ai bu du café dans un café WP:GNG||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
695 1599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lost Angelas User:Epinoia 00:01, 1 May 2019 (UTC) keep or '''Soft delete''' - this is a new film (2019) so it may take some time to build a reputation - I don't think it meets right now, but it could in the future Deletion of Lost Angelas WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
696 10500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flossie Floyd Green Elementary User:Kudpung 12:10, 6 October 2012 (UTC) merge to Allen Independent School District ensuring it is listed there. Per standard practice for nn schools: (#Schools Deletion of Flossie Floyd Green Elementary WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
697 4293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Power ring (DC Comics) User:SudoGhost 05:35, 15 October 2011 (UTC) keep """Many topics are dependent on other topics, this is not a reason for deletion. The first reference above is not a trivial mention, the introduction alone addresses the subject in detail, meaning no original research is needed to extract the content, and is more than a trivial mention. The second reference is the same, it is not the primary topic of the source, but it is much more than a trivial mention. Same with the third reference above. It easily passes ''significant coverage'', as well as the other requirements detailed in . The fourth reference directly discusses the ring in great detail, with it being the primary topic of that section. In no way could that be considered """"|trivial"""". There are multiple reliable, third-party sources, thus the article fulfills the requirements of """ Deletion of Power ring (DC Comics) WP:GNG||WP:TRIVIAL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
698 10055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Wars Theme/Cantina Band User:Gongshow 21:48, 12 July 2014 (UTC) keep """There's an entry on the song in http://www.amazon.com/The-Billboard-Book-Number-Hits/dp/0823076776/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1405199856 this book (p. 474), it's discussed (among other songs) in the ''Billboard'' article http://books.google.com/books?id=DkUEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PT0#v=onepage&q&f=false """"Film Themes Spur Rash of Singles Hits"""", and there's further info on it http://books.google.com/books?ei=66rBU-CCOZHuoATfwYD4AQ&id=ok0UAQAAIAAJ&dq=meco+%22star+wars+theme%22&focus=searchwithinvolume&q=%22star+wars+theme%22 here and http://books.google.com/books?id=N2ExOXxw6cAC&pg=PA442&dq=meco+%22star+wars+theme%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=JajBU8rXCouEogSI8IDIAw&ved=0CEQQ6AEwBg#v=onepage&q=meco%20%22star%20wars%20theme%22&f=false here, for starters. These, along with going platinum and going to number one, shows that enough material exists to meet """ Deletion of Star Wars Theme/Cantina Band WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
699 17246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Divya S. Iyer User:Beccaynr 21:21, 20 March 2021 (UTC) keep """because / appears to be met, e.g. https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Thiruvananthapuram/this-bureaucrat-also-heals/article17413890.ece This bureaucrat also heals (The Hindu, 2017), https://www.thehindu.com/education/imperfections-need-to-be-appreciated/article17663614.ece ‘Imperfections need to be appreciated’ (The Hindu, 2017), https://www.deccanchronicle.com/entertainment/mollywood/281117/from-files-to-films.html Divya S Iyer: From files to films (Deccan Chronicle, 2017), https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/kerala-s-new-power-couple-mla-sabarinadhan-wed-thiruvananthapuram-sub-collector-divya-iyer Kerala’s new power couple: MLA Sabarinadhan to wed Thiruvananthapuram Sub-Collector Divya Iyer (The News Minute, 2017), https://www.deccanchronicle.com/nation/in-other-news/030517/mla-ks-sabarinathan-to-marry-thiruvananthapuram-sub-collector-divya-s-iyer.html MLA KS Sabarinathan to marry Thiruvananthapuram sub-collector Divya S Iyer (Deccan Chronicle, 2017), https://www.thequint.com/news/india/kerala-bureaucrat-marries-politician#read-more Kerala: Bureaucrat Marries Politician, Media Can’t Stop Obsessing (The Quint, 2017, """"The news value of their relationship cannot be denied, considering the near-celebrity status they both hold in their respective professions.""""), https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/t-puram-sub-collector-divya-s-iyer-cancels-land-takeover-tehsildar-triggers-row-78184 T’puram sub-collector Divya S Iyer cancels land takeover by tehsildar, triggers row (The News Minute, 2018), https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/kerala/divya-s-iyer-transferred-to-local-self-govt-dept/article23436218.ece Divya S. Iyer transferred to Local Self-Govt dept (The Hindu, 2018), https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/kerala/2018/apr/05/sub-collector-divya-s-iyer-transferred-to-local-self-government-department-department-1797182.html Sub-Collector Divya S Iyer transferred to Local Self Government Department Department (New Indian Express, 2018), https://www.thequint.com/coronavirus/kerala-mnrega-coronavirus-pandemic-food-kits-cash-work-break-the-chain#read-more Food Kits, #BreakTheChain: How Kerala Made Life Easy During Corona (The Quint, 2020""" Deletion of Divya S. Iyer WP:BASIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
700 7667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruchita User:Gene93k 03:50, 8 September 2017 (UTC) comment An alternative would have been ly moving the page to user space. Otherwise, the page is a speedy deletion candidate (no substantial content/test page Deletion of Ruchita WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
701 21275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Sebamala User:Bearian 18:41, 22 January 2020 (UTC) delete WP:MILL|run of the mill business person and candidate for ''|next year''. This is an SPA's first article in main-space, and appears to be a newbie error. We almost always delete articles about candidates, and |that consensus is not likely to change by 2021 Deletion of Richard Sebamala WP:CRYSTAL||WP:CCC Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
702 13808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/11:11 (Austin Mahone song) User:Merynancy 15:51, 28 April 2012 (UTC) delete it hasn't charted at all, which makes it fail . '''׺°”˜`”°º Deletion of 11:11 (Austin Mahone song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
703 19894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Maloney (doctor) User:CiaranG 23:26, 5 February 2007 (UTC) keep but ruthlessly remove any text not |verifiable from |reliable sources Deletion of Robert Maloney (doctor) WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
704 4885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mandat User:Epinoia 02:10, 18 September 2019 (UTC) delete of the references in the article, none are about the film itself; kinopoisk.ru is just a listing - does not meet , no reviews by at least two nationally known critics, no awards, no significant coverage in multiple reliable secondary sources Deletion of Mandat WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
705 337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Courchaine (ice hockey, born 1989) [[User talk:Ravenswing|''' '' Ravenswing '' ''']] 07:49, 10 April 2016 (UTC) delete """sighs) Yet another """"what was he thinking?"""" creation of a NN substub hockey article, and I'm almost at the point of writing |WP:ITSFROMDOLOVIS into . Somewhat brazenly, he set forth that the """"honour"""" qualifying this mid-minors goalie with no distinction for an article was being on a team that won its league championship. Fails NHOCKEY, no evidence that the subject meets the GNG""" Deletion of Adam Courchaine (ice hockey, born 1989) WP:BULLSHIT||WP:COMMONOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
706 21135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nagaruban Arumugam 2 User:Lear 04:02, 27 January 2010 (UTC) delete Per nominator. I can only agree with the comments already made: this is sad, this man sounds like a fine individual, but is not notable (see ). Deletion of Nagaruban Arumugam 2 WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
707 19929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sa-Deuce User:Mz7 17:03, 24 August 2014 (UTC) keep per #1 (without prejudice against renomination on notability grounds), as the fact that an article is unreferenced is not an argument in itself for deletion. Vejvančický's sources clearly show that references are available to write an article for this subject. The purpose of deletion discussions is to discuss deletion. Deletion discussions are not to be used as a catalyst for cleanup, which is the position appears to be trying to advance Deletion of Sa-Deuce WP:SK||WP:DDC Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
708 3390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdul Latif Khan Tarin User:Anotherclown 08:28, 8 September 2014 (UTC) delete a Google Books search didn't reveal https://www.google.com.au/search?q=Abdul+Latif+Khan+Tarin&btnG=Search+Books&tbm=bks&tbo=1&gws_rd=ssl#tbm=bks&q=Abdul+Khan+Dujaila any significant coverage that I could see. Fails the and is therefore not notable. No doubt a brave soldier but insufficient coverage to justify a stand alone article. If indeed his role in the Battle of Dujaila was important there is no reason it cannot be covered in that article assuming that there are |reliable sources to support the information and it is added in a way that does not constitute |undue weight Deletion of Abdul Latif Khan Tarin WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Notability 77
709 21536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oakview Mall User:Rackabello 03:25, 26 July 2007 (UTC) delete No assertion of Deletion of Oakview Mall WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
710 15068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Víctor Samuel Rivera User:JohnCD 21:37, 4 August 2009 (UTC) delete """the references are all works ''by'' him, I don't see any independent reference ''about'' him, and a http://scholar.google.com/scholar?start=20&q=author:Victor+author:Samuel+author:Rivera&hl=en Scholar search doesn't show him being cited extensively, or indeed at all. I don't think he meets the standard of . For what it's worth, though I don't know how their standards compare with ours, the Spanish-speakers might be better placed to check him out, and his article on :es was http://es.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Especial%3ARegistro&type=delete&user=&page=V%C3%ADctor+Samuel+Rivera&year=&month=-1&hide_patrol_log=1 deleted as """"''without encyclopedic relevance''"""" which I guess is equivalent to our A7""" Deletion of Víctor Samuel Rivera WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
711 18276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Car User:Isotope23 18:35, 21 April 2006 (UTC) delete per if you believe he is a real person... otherwise as just an unimportant series of events Deletion of John Car WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
712 7298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter Bernacca User:Ohconfucius 09:17, 20 June 2007 (UTC) delete """http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Walter+Bernacca%22+-wikipedia&hl=en&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&hs=skG&start=220&sa=N 201 unique Ghits for this """"director/producer"""", almost all of which are for Youtube like sites in the world with free videos hosting. Fails : nothing of substance on this individual otherwise""" Deletion of Walter Bernacca WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
713 465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dawn Of Tomorrow User:Aoba47 14:31, 24 October 2016 (UTC) delete Article fails notability under and Deletion of Dawn Of Tomorrow WP:GNG||WP:MOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
714 8119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Álex Craninx User:Spiderone 15:36, 1 January 2019 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Álex Craninx WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
715 10795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dianne Hiles User:UninvitedCompany 21:13, 20 December 2018 (UTC) delete per . I'm not familiar enough with the context of some of these claims to have a strong opinion Deletion of Dianne Hiles WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
716 14786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kory Mathewson User:Cunard 04:46, 28 April 2009 (UTC) delete None of the references cited in the article are |reliable, third-party sources. http://www.thegatewayonline.ca/articles/arts-entertainment/volume-xcix-number-4/die-nasty-s-soap-a-thon-hawaii-bound This source and http://www.thegatewayonline.ca/articles/news/2009/03/09/president-elect-kory-mathewson-shares-plans-next-year-s-su-exec this source are from the ''The Gateway (newspaper)|The Gateway'', a newspaper at Mathewson's university. These sources are not enough to confer to notability since they are written by students of Mathewson's university, not professional journalists. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/bcacc730-c91f-11dc-9807-000077b07658.html This article from the ''Financial Times'' mentions Mathewson in the first sentence but the rest of the article (save for one sentence) is about other topics. http://www.apegga.org/members/Publications/peggs/Web11-06/student_ua_eng.html This article cannot be used to establish notability because it is written by Kory Mathewson himself, so it is not a third-party source. The http://www.amateurgolf.com/playerview.asp?id=6687 sixth source only lists his name but doesn't mention anything else about him. A http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&q=%22Kory+Mathewson%22&cf=all Google News Archive search returns no related results, as does a http://www.google.com/search?um=1&q=%22Kory%20Mathewson%22&cf=all&sa=N&tab=nw Google search. This is a well-crafted |autobiography (written by {{user|Korymath}}), but unfortunately, there aren't enough sources to establish this individual's notability per . I have no prejudice to re-creation in the future if/when |reliable, third-party sources are available Deletion of Kory Mathewson WP:RS||WP:AUTO||WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
717 7996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeek (2nd nomination) User:Cbs527 03:52, 7 March 2017 (UTC) delete """Promotional. Fails . Article has been """"reference bombed"""" mostly by IP 92.20.196.186 (37 sources are referenced in 6 sentence lede!) which do nothing to establish notability as they are either direct press releases or derived from company press releases or articles where over half the article is quotes from a company executive which are not independent sources per policy and guideline {{cite web|title=Non-independent sources - Press Releases|url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Identifying_and_using_independent_sources#Press_releases}}. requires a topic to meet all 3 requirements of """"significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject"""". Strangely, the article has 22 sources listed and, with the possible exception of the CNN Money article, none seem to meet the """"independent"""" requirement""" Deletion of Zeek (2nd nomination) WP:CORP||WP:PROMOTION||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
718 688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sister Vincenza User:Just 18:58, 31 December 2009 (UTC) keep The article is well referenced – witten in a |NPOV style and informative. Conspiacy??? That I believe, is left to an individual’s own mind-set. As to the article itself, meets all the criteria for inclusion Deletion of Sister Vincenza WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
719 16261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hungary at the 1966 FIFA World Cup User:Kirbanzo 15:48, 20 August 2018 (UTC) delete per nom - this is better off just being part of the main article at most instead of an uneccesary |fork Deletion of Hungary at the 1966 FIFA World Cup WP:FORK Wikipedia:Mirrors and forks 46
720 3841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sophie Gradon User:Thsmi002 13:45, 24 June 2018 (UTC) keep per and ey. I added sources on her career as a marketing manager. She won a wikinotable pageant and had an influential career among the charities in Newcastle. Being a contestant a notable series further adds to notability. Her death was widely reported by notable news sources. All in all, I think notability is now established Deletion of Sophie Gradon WP:CELEBRITY||WP:H Wikipedia:Notability 77
721 7181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DreamSequence User:Joe 00:57, 21 May 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |band Deletion of DreamSequence WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
722 13566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdelhafid Boussouf User:Eqdoktor 17:36, 12 January 2007 (UTC) delete As an airport, it is |not very notable. Google search does not help much, person whom it was named after may have a better claim to notability. Can't find any other external sources that refers to the airport Deletion of Abdelhafid Boussouf WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
723 9379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of current United States governors by age User:TJRC 23:48, 6 November 2009 (UTC) keep This is not a directory, it's a . I think it meets the requirements of PURP. The title is probably a misnomer. It's a sortable list, and can be sorted by state, name (although in the format first-name, last-name, that's not too useful), date of inauguration, age at present or at inauguration, length of service, etc. It probably should be renamed Deletion of List of current United States governors by age WP:LIST||WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Lists 97
724 12750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Into the Cannibal's Pot User:E 23:17, 10 November 2018 (UTC) delete fails , my searches fail to turn up sufficient secondary in; book reviews that exist ate in small circulation and FRINGE publications. Author not notable Deletion of Into the Cannibal's Pot WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
725 16764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iron Grip: The Oppression [[User talk:Czar|czar]] 08:20, 17 May 2016 (UTC) merge to ISOTX (the developer), where the other Iron Grip titles should redirect as well to a section on the series. ''The Oppression'' lacks |significant coverage from |reliable, |independent sources. (|?) It had mostly press releases and passing mentions in a /RS|video game reliable sources https://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=003516479746865699832:leawcwkqifq custom Google search Deletion of Iron Grip: The Oppression WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:42||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
726 13414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sal's Pizza (Dallas) User:Dominus 20:57, 9 February 2012 (UTC) delete Routine local and promotional coverage falls far short of establishing notability per Deletion of Sal's Pizza (Dallas) WP:ROTM Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
727 5848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bobby Friss User:DustFormsWords 00:33, 20 October 2009 (UTC) delete doesn't appear to meet criteria at and in any case recommends the immediate deletion of all unsourced content from the biography of a living person, which here would result in blanking the article Deletion of Bobby Friss WP:NMUSIC||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
728 16789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Open source games User:Rjd0060 21:30, 25 September 2007 (UTC) delete Agree with nom; Article isn't supported by any notable sources. Fails Deletion of Open source games WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
729 20705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Masucci User:Huon 22:52, 20 July 2015 (UTC) comment there is the http://articles.latimes.com/2001/may/26/entertainment/ca-2686 LA Times, and there seem to be some print sources listed in https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Mintlamb/sandbox&diff=prev&oldid=672103369 this edit (though not with enough details to look them up). Masucci might well be notable, but the article would have to be rewritten almost entirely, with no unproblematic version to revert to. may apply Deletion of Alex Masucci WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
730 11774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samy T. User:Omni 12:32, 12 July 2016 (UTC) delete Fails . This is borderline A7-worthy, and merely playing in a high school-level football team doesn't make him notable Deletion of Samy T. WP:NSOCCER Wikipedia:Notability 77
731 10012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Awwad Al-Otaibi User:Scope 14:03, 19 September 2017 (UTC) comment Another football fan. What is the ethics around a football fan or fans voting in a Afd for a football or sports related article in WP? Is it always an automatic keep, all the time? is a lower standard of notability than , and it always has been from the getgo. Fails Deletion of Awwad Al-Otaibi WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
732 11895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enichkin User:Vejvančický 09:01, 11 October 2009 (UTC) delete The main problem here is the notability. In my opinion, Sergey Nazarenko aka Enichkin doesn't meet our |criteria for musicians and ensembles. I can't find anything substantial in reliable third-party sources Deletion of Enichkin WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
733 11999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crud (game) User:Stifle 20:11, 30 April 2008 (UTC) delete unless |citations from |reliable sources are added to comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Crud (game) WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
734 17074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plastic Pollution Coalition User:Lordofthesky 17:01, 1 May 2020 (UTC) keep The article meets and has sufficient references. Promotional content in the first section should be modified Deletion of Plastic Pollution Coalition WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
735 468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hans van de Koot User:Xxanthippe 04:58, 30 October 2010 (UTC) delete GS h index = 6 so not enough for rof#C1 Deletion of Hans van de Koot WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
736 12869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derek and Drew Riker (2nd nomination) User:Tellyaddict 13:51, 19 February 2007 (UTC) delete Non relevant duo, failing Deletion of Derek and Drew Riker (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
737 20979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Green Bunny (2nd nomination) User:TheFarix 23:18, 10 November 2010 (UTC) delete Even for a list, the main topic must demonstrate that it meets the |inclusion guidelines. In this case, the company itself must show that it is |notable. And even then, a list of all of their release will violate Deletion of Green Bunny (2nd nomination) WP:NOTE||WP:ORG||WP:NOTCATALOG Wikipedia:Notability 77
738 19671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WellEz user:czarkoff 17:50, 13 September 2012 (UTC) delete classical spam for a |non-notable company, with all #Common ways of hiding the lack of notability|known techniques to mask the lack of notability employed. — Deletion of WellEz WP:NCORP||WP:NBIZ Wikipedia:Notability 77
739 20764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hany Rambod [[User talk:Lourdes|'''Lourdes''']] 03:29, 6 September 2016 (UTC) delete """The subject is known for creating FST7, a contemporary fitness/muscle building technique. The sources (questionable RS) quoted in the article talk about FST7 and refer to the subject's involvement in its development. The subject Hany Rambod's background is an insignificant mention in any of the sources. In fact, two sources don't even have his name in the complete source. The subject is undoubtedly a multiple time award winner. But on GNG, there is hardly any source to qualify the subject. The closest the subject comes to notability is on |ANYBIO, which notes that a person may be notable if ''""""The person has made a widely recognized contribution that is part of the enduring historical record in his or her specific field""""''. There are two issues here. One, is FST7 a """"widely recognized contribution""""? Second, is there any evidence that this has become part of the """"enduring historical record in the subject's field""""? Unfortunately, the answer to both seems in the negative right now. This might of course change in the future. mentions: ''""""If a deletion discussion of any biographical article (of whether a well known or less known individual) has received few or no comments from any editor besides the nominator, the discussion may be closed at the closer's discretion and best judgment.""""'' The best judgement here seems to delete the article""" Deletion of Hany Rambod WP:ANYBIO||WP:BIODEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
740 4148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary Denniss User:Otr500 11:05, 13 April 2017 (UTC) keep """I am going to look at this from a very narrow point of view, concerning , that include using historical books and considering Wikipedia:Notability (geographic features), Wikipedia:Geographic imbalance, and Wikipedia:Notability (geography), that will add to regional and state prominence, so giving notability to the author. Historical books are important to society, and we can't have a national history without the foundation of local history. 38 books, especially if not self-published, is more than trivial historical prominence, and if we don't consider this important we might as well get rid of all ocal|local places such as lighthouses or town historical interests. Because a reference is not """"listed"""" does not mean it does not exist. Regional coverage is acceptable as notability and one https://books.google.com/books?id=7bmgCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA283&dq=Bob+and+Doris+Bowman&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwipzs71waDTAhVG6YMKHQ_nA2YQ6AEIODAF#v=onepage&q=Bob%20and%20Doris%20Bowman&f=false book on Texas Rangers would be regional as well as state significance. I have found evidence that some of the books are listed at several libraries, not just in one county, so I am inclined to lean towards regional and state notability. The author wrote ''an encyclopedia'' of history that expands coverage to more than just a single town or even county before he died. '''Note''': http://www.ktre.com/story/22843249/angelina-co-historian-and-author-dies-at-77 Angelina Co. historian and author Bob Bowman dies at 77 With such regional and state notability an author with 38 historical books would be notable for Wikipedia inclusion. I do plan to look at the article, as well as sources, for article expansion as well as linking to other relevant articles""" Deletion of Gary Denniss WP:L||WP:policies and guidelines Wikipedia:Lists 97
741 706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harold Garner User:Fuhghettaboutit 21:34, 8 February 2007 (UTC) delete unless |reliable sources are provided substantiating a fact about him which meets . Presently, this is a resume, albeit with some material which if verified and expanded could potentially meet a criterion. A look at Google doesn't help greatly because there are many false positives for identically named individuals. I find violations of distasteful, but once posted, the article has to be considered on the merits Deletion of Harold Garner WP:RS||WP:BIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
742 14187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fish out of water comedy film User:AllGloryToTheHypnotoad 01:03, 1 November 2007 (UTC) delete """as . The ''concept'' of """"fish out of water"""" as comedy would be something you'd write into an article on Theory of Comedy, maybe: but this seems not just an indiscriminate list, but also purely OR""" Deletion of Fish out of water comedy film WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
743 4722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Max Cooper (electronica musician) User:Lawrencekhoo 06:53, 28 December 2012 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Max Cooper (electronica musician) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
744 9407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Free Home Elementary User:John 09:25, 25 March 2020 (UTC) merge to Cherokee County School District (Georgia), per and longstanding practice Deletion of Free Home Elementary WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
745 18811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Elliott (footballer) User:Sir 22:14, 30 September 2010 (UTC) delete fails , and without fully pro appearances, fails as well Deletion of Chris Elliott (footballer) WP:GNG||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
746 21662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maxim Suvorov User:Devonian 11:37, 22 November 2020 (UTC) keep per , people who are included in biographical encyclopaedias are considered notable enough for inclusion in Wikipedia as well. He also passes , with SIGCOV provided in sources https://www.google.com.au/books/edition/Harvard_Slavic_Studies/7jBlILRo220C?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=Maxim+Suvorov&pg=PA34&printsec=frontcover here and https://www.google.com.au/books/edition/Journal_of_Central_European_Affairs/xWcdVxSOJJYC?hl=en&gbpv=1&bsq=Maxim+Suvorov&dq=Maxim+Suvorov&printsec=frontcover here. Also, keep in mind that sources are very likely to exist in languages other than English Deletion of Maxim Suvorov WP:ANYBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
747 19449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bambina (Idoli song) User:Esradekan 03:06, 15 August 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Songs Deletion of Bambina (Idoli song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
748 13716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gallery of coins (4th nomination) User:Cliff 20:51, 24 September 2008 (UTC) delete of these |collections of images; the images themselves (those which are acceptable, as noted above by Serpent's Choice) can be transwikied to the Commons Deletion of Gallery of coins (4th nomination) WP:NOTREPOSITORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
749 8264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patri Friedman User:Trialsanderrors 03:38, 3 July 2006 (UTC) comment Book doesn't seem listed on Amazon, but I still like to see evidence for his notability (please only the type that passes as |reliable source Deletion of Patri Friedman WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
750 20330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abel Joseph User:HisSpaceResearch 09:37, 24 June 2007 (UTC) delete WP:V, Deletion of Abel Joseph WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
751 18119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ATP (programming language) User:Hello71 21:22, 16 October 2012 (UTC) delete I was actually going to A7 this after waiting a few minutes. Never got around to this. Deletion of ATP (programming language) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
752 388 [[Fußball-Weltmeisterschaft 2006/Philatelie]] (bleibt) Benutzer:194.113.59.80 NONE keep Obwohl mit Briefmarken überhaupt nichts am Hut, bin ich für . Allerdings mit einem , da Löschung von Fußball-Weltmeisterschaft 2006/Philatelie Wikipedia:QS Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
753 9701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Etinosa Idemudia User:Celestina007 18:15, 14 June 2020 (UTC) delete I’m not sure I understand how this page has remained on mainspace for this long. Anyway just like the nom, I too can’t see subject of the article satisfying Deletion of Etinosa Idemudia WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
754 670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/3D Issue User:Spleodrach 09:46, 9 June 2021 (UTC) delete per Deletion of 3D Issue WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
755 15166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Surrealist poets user:Andrew 06:05, 12 July 2019 (UTC) keep per - not a valid rationale for deletion. As Deletion of List of Surrealist poets WP:NOTDUP Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
756 2885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monster (book) User:Rtyq2 22:07, 14 December 2008 (UTC) merge to Monster (1999 novel). It seems that's what it redirected to before, until suddenly 2 years later http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Nubile_Servant this editor changes it. Definitely fails (http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_ss_b?url=search-alias%3Dstripbooks&field-keywords=Allan+Hall+-+Monster&x=0&y=0 obviously Deletion of Monster (book) WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
757 98 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hüseyin Alpay Kullanıcı:nedim gayet birnedim gâyet bir 15.57, 20 Aralık 2021 (UTC) delete Maalesef kayda değerliği bağımsız ve önemli ikincil kaynaklar ile desteklenemiyor. Ekşisözlük'teki maddeyi unutmamaya çalıştım, lakin orada yazılanlar, zaten buradan kopyalanmış bilgiler. Ayrıca yerli, yersiz her şey hakkında onlarca, yüzlerce entari girilen Ekşi Sözlük'te dahi Hüseyin Bey hakkında sadece ve sadece bir giriş yapılmış ve o da Vikipedi'den alıntı. Ayrıca, Hüseyin Bey 'e göre uluslararası, ulusal veya il/eyalet düzeyinde bir mevkiye sahip olmuş değil, basında önemli derecede kendisinden bahsedilmiş de değil. Silinsin Hüseyin Alpay'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
758 20088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chhokar User:Coolabahapple 17:04, 15 August 2016 (UTC) comment its funny that the villages that these people live in could probably have articles under but the people as a group may not, could all the Jat people articles be redirected to a 'List of Jat clans' article instead Deletion of Chhokar WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
759 17701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Med Standard User:Tom 09:37, 1 September 2015 (UTC) delete On top of being created by a now blocked sock, references to very dodgy sources, fails Google test. Obviously not notable under Deletion of Med Standard WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
760 396 [[Germanophobie]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:84.163.220.26 NONE delete Der hat schonmal einen /18._Februar_2006#Germanophie|LA überlebt, auch wenn ich das irgendwie nicht verstehen kann Löschung von Germanophobie Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
761 9851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Copyright status of work by U.S. subnational governments User:Dricherby 08:42, 3 July 2013 (UTC) keep State law is outside the scope of Copyright status of work by the U.S. government, so it should not be covered on that page. Federal copyright law only covers the federal government. I see no synthesis in the state law article and, even if there is any, that can be solved by ordinary editing. By , it is acceptable to use primary sources, as long as they are reliably published (which State Codes are) and no original analysis of the primary sources is included in the article. I see no notability issues, so no reason to delete Deletion of Copyright status of work by U.S. subnational governments WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
762 3298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sydney Uni Lions (2nd nomination) User:Hack 01:07, 3 January 2014 (UTC) delete Low level sports club, fails and . There is some coverage in local media but this amounts to |routine coverage (mostly match reports). The level of coverage is such that the article at present is primarily based on |primary sources. I note that there is not an article on the league in which it competes so would suggest merging salvageable content to the Sydney Uni Sport and Fitness and/or Gridiron NSW pages Deletion of Sydney Uni Lions (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:ORG||WP:ROUTINE||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES Wikipedia:Notability 77
763 3967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alison Hartson User:AusLondonder 08:44, 6 November 2017 (UTC) delete Hartson may become notable in the future, but at the moment it unfortunately seems . No significant, in-depth coverage in multiple reliable secondary sources Deletion of Alison Hartson WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
764 20606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Portmann User:Crunch NONE comment Which guideline are you pointing at Deletion of Mark Portmann WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
765 556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Christopher User:Worldbruce 12:41, 28 October 2019 (UTC) comment The interview without independent analysis in self-published zagsblog.com is a poor source for establishing notability, but there is an piece in ''The Atlantic'' that goes beyond coverage.https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/10/can-josh-christopher-fix-what-ails-college-sports/599224 Deletion of Josh Christopher WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
766 6122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christos Papachristopoulos User:Folantin 20:03, 20 October 2007 (UTC) delete Fails notability. Ideas are |cranky |original research. (Delete Insensé too and get rid of similar material which has been added to the Albert Camus article Deletion of Christos Papachristopoulos WP:FRINGE||WP:OR Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
767 4435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Concepcion User:PRehse 13:56, 23 April 2019 (UTC) delete Does not meet either or Deletion of Martin Concepcion WP:NBOX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
768 455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bonifacio Global City station User:Masumrezarock100 06:04, 26 June 2019 (UTC) delete Per nom and it's Deletion of Bonifacio Global City station WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
769 8979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maverick Wild User:Galatz 01:31, 20 August 2018 (UTC) comment Although there are a ton of sources, they all appear to be coverage. There are several however that are from print which I can not verify the quality to see if it could establish notability or not Deletion of Maverick Wild WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
770 16714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whispers of Life User:Koala15 18:04, 6 March 2017 (UTC) delete Non notable film. Fails Deletion of Whispers of Life WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
771 138 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Şili'deki Türkler (2. aday gösterme) Kullanıcı:takabegtakabeg 03:03, 2 Haziran 2010 (UTC) comment Daha önce Ayna'yı izlemiştim. İzledikten sonra hem Ayna programının hem de bu maddede yer alan bilgilerin '''|doğrulanabilir ve VP:TBA|tarafsız olmadığını''' anladım ve KD olmadığına emin oldum. Ayrıca http://www.diyih.gov.tr/articles.php?category_id=224 Çalışma ve Sosyal Güvenlik Bakanlığı Yurtdışı İşçi Hizmetleri Genel Müdürlüğü'nün gösterdiği sayısal bilgi (http://www.diyih.gov.tr/images/articles/editor/2006sayisal.doc) de bile Şiliden hiç bahsedilmemektedir. '''Kısaca KD değildir.''' Yine bilimsel kaynaklar bulunursa (bulabilirsek) Türk asıllı Avrupalılar|Avrupa'da yaşayan Türk vatandaşları maddesinde yer alabilir. Osmanlı döneminde göç etmiş müslümanlar ve çeşitli Millet (Osmanlı Devleti)|millete bağlı tebaası hakkında ise Osmanlı Devleti veya Şili maddesinde kısaca bahsedilebilir. Ayrıca :en:Turks in Chile|İngilizce ''sürümü'' ise son derece güzel değil son derece kötü hazırlanmıştır Şili'deki Türkler (2. aday gösterme) yazısının silinmesi Vikipedi:Doğrulanabilirlik Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
772 10069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raghunath Singh Thakur User:Fayenatic 23:26, 28 October 2015 (UTC) delete """I removed the PROD from this page, thinking that the award tended to indicate notability, and that the claimed work on artemisinin sounded important. Searching for Thakur & artemisinin confirms that he did publish some papers on the subject, but I did not see any that refer to him by name in the text as having made notable advances; they merely cited his research. Although he was head of CIMAP, that does not appear to be a """"major academic institution"""", so his directorship does not establish criterion 6 at """ Deletion of Raghunath Singh Thakur WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
773 13951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Real RocknRolla User:Cliff 23:39, 15 October 2008 (UTC) delete per nom and Erik. |Until shooting starts, info on this project belongs at RocknRolla Deletion of The Real RocknRolla WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
774 14878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sara Pedigo User:Burning 00:22, 27 March 2017 (UTC) delete The article does not meet the ; and it is Deletion of Sara Pedigo WP:GNG||WP:TAINTED Wikipedia:Notability 77
775 544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crowd Linguistics: Rugby User:Dhartung 02:47, 28 April 2007 (UTC) delete WP:NOT#Wikipedia_is_not_an_indiscriminate_collection_of_information|Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information, even when that information is true and attributable to |reliable sources. In the last AFD, I told you ''It wasn't your fault that it was misnamed, it was the fault of the person who made that request. Nevertheless, while we appreciate your efforts to fulfill that request, editors here are arguing that the topic is not needed. In many cases it is permissible to create a stub article for a notable topic that may grow in time, but in this case we probably don't need a local slang directory pertaining to a specific sport.'' Other editors did suggest a rename if the article were kept. The name '''was not a reason for deletion Deletion of Crowd Linguistics: Rugby WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
776 14257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of freeways in Michigan User:Northamerica1000 14:43, 19 April 2014 (UTC) keep """per , """"It is neither improper nor uncommon to simultaneously have a category, a list, and a navigation template which all cover the same topic. These redundant systems of organizing information are considered to be complementary, not inappropriately duplicative. Furthermore, arguing that a category duplicates a list (or vice versa) at a deletion discussion is not a valid reason for deletion and should be avoided"""". This list article is complementary to :Category:Freeways and expressways in Michigan""" Deletion of List of freeways in Michigan WP:NOTDUP Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
777 15949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dashama Konah Gordon User:Simonm223 16:13, 31 August 2018 (UTC) keep There's enough material here at least for a notable stub. A ton of cleanup is required to get rid of all the obvious content, but an article needing serious work is ''not'' grounds for deletion Deletion of Dashama Konah Gordon WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
778 1819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Barack Obama visit to India User:Johnsemlak 12:43, 4 July 2011 (UTC) keep Disclaimer--I'm the author of hte article. As stated in the article's lead, during hte trip Obama addressed a joint session of the Indian Parliament, which I believe is the 4th time that's happened since 2000. He publicly endorsed India to be a permanent member of the UN Security Council. does not apply, as this is not 'routine'. But beyond that, I'll go straight to the meat of the reason--I can'f possibly see how someone could say 2011 royal tour of Canada (currently on it's way to an overwhelming consensus to keep) is worth an article adn this isn't. I'm not normally a fan of this kind of argument; I myself supported the deletion of the Royal tour of Canada but opposed referring to the deletion of Barack Obama's visit to India as an argument. However, I the difference in notability between the two events is very stark in my eyes. Also, in the deletion discussion of the royal tour, several editors expressed support of an article on Obama's visit to India. Thus, I think it's possible that Wikipedia:Consensus can change|consensus has changed Deletion of 2010 Barack Obama visit to India WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
779 2333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parramatta Citadel Band User:VirtualSteve 06:51, 10 October 2008 (UTC) delete Not notable, seems to be edited by a person with a |relationship to the article contents, and has considerable |original research components Deletion of Parramatta Citadel Band WP:COI||WP:OR Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
780 14274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J.D. Lasica User:Hall 22:38, 18 November 2005 (UTC) keep and establish blogger inclusion guidelines at to prevent these type of systematic nominations from happening in the future Deletion of J.D. Lasica WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
781 13952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Mullady User:Twsx 18:33, 13 June 2008 (UTC) delete apparent |autobiography, no references, completely not |notable. Borderline #A1|speedy A1, as i would consider none of those remarks actuall notions of notability. ~ | Deletion of Michael Mullady WP:AUTOBIO||WP:N||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
782 11408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jion de Jordan User:Antandrus 14:40, 24 December 2011 (UTC) delete as hoax, but I'll change this in an eyeblink if someone comes up with ''any'' evidence this person existed, because any documented troubadour is notable. Cmach, ''|start providing your sources'', this is not optional. Thanks Deletion of Jion de Jordan WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
783 2791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Remmy Njoku (2nd nomination) User:onel5969 13:06, 20 January 2016 (UTC) delete I'm going to have to agree on this one. Simply not enough in-depth coverage in independent reliable sources to show they pass , and they clearly don't pass Deletion of Mary Remmy Njoku (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
784 3343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hallel Yaffa Ariel User:Darwinian 02:54, 14 July 2016 (UTC) delete Per , and also Deletion of Hallel Yaffa Ariel WP:BIO1E||WP:EVENT||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
785 2427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dana Terrace User:AleatoryPonderings 16:09, 4 September 2020 (UTC) keep per #3 Deletion of Dana Terrace WP:NARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
786 2475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rush in popular culture 2 User:Deckiller 23:58, 9 February 2007 (UTC) delete mdash; list of trivia trying to show that Rush is common in popular culture. It's plauged by and reliance on ''one fan site'' for reference. The mention that Rush has been influenced in popular culture on the main page is fine, becuase virtually ''all this information comes from that one site, which is already linked to and mentioned in the main article''. Redirect is unnecessary, because nothing is merged and most of the edit history we'd be preserving is edit warring and info thrown out. Besides, to quote the usuals: indiscriminate collection of information, violates the various offshoots of the Manual of Style, which state (on based on a larger consensus than a group of editors on the Rush talkpage), that articles that are lists of trivia or isolated facts are to be avoided. And like I said, they're all from one source, which fails to begin with. Once again, '''Delete'''.&mdash Deletion of Rush in popular culture 2 WP:OR||WP:NOT||WP:AVTRIV||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
787 12829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Privatelektro User:JamesBurns 05:38, 13 February 2009 (UTC) delete self-publishing artists on their own online digital label. Insufficient independent 3rd party sources Deletion of Privatelektro WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
788 9491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Chappelle's Show skits (2nd nomination) User:Stuartyeates 23:55, 22 July 2011 (UTC) delete WP:IINFO, most of the sources seem to be non-independent too Deletion of List of Chappelle's Show skits (2nd nomination) WP:NOTPLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
789 20584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mehta (Uttar Pradesh cricketer) User:Joseph2302 10:55, 6 December 2015 (UTC) keep """Passes , and the only reason given for deletion is """"it's like the other one that got deleted"""", which is bad logic, especially as I believe it was an awful decision to delete""" Deletion of Mehta (Uttar Pradesh cricketer) WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
790 7880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cases of police brutality in the United States user:Andrew 07:45, 15 October 2015 (UTC) keep """There are plenty of sources for the topic with obvious titles such as ''Police Brutality''. These say things like """"''Many criteria have been used by police scholars to delineate various types of police brutality...''"""". The topic clearly passes and, per , we should not delete the list to favour the corresponding category. Lists are better at handling disputed cases because they support citations and notes""" Deletion of List of cases of police brutality in the United States WP:LISTN||WP:CLN Wikipedia:Notability 77
791 8015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmadiyya Jabrayilov User:Mar4d 02:47, 12 November 2015 (UTC) keep """As much appears to have been written about it. Even if it is considered a """"story"""", it definitely is a |notable one, so it should be attributed as such by reliable sources saying that""" Deletion of Ahmadiyya Jabrayilov WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
792 3478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jame Gumb (2nd nomination) [[user talk:sottolacqua|talk]]) 18:26, 13 September 2011 (UTC) comment The length of the article is not a factor used in determining whether this meets . The three references listed aren't applicable to most of the content in the article. Two references relate to which real-life individuals the character is based upon. The other is a parental guide about the film content, which mentions the character briefly, but is more related to the graphic content of the film. Sottolacqua Deletion of Jame Gumb (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
793 17 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/FlashArsivi.Com Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 17:38, 29 Mart 2013 (UTC) delete Ne yeterli kaynak var ne de madde içinde |ilgili KD kriterlerini sağlayacak içerik FlashArsivi.Com'un silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
794 8074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ivan Teodorovich User:Pastor 22:08, 22 February 2009 (UTC) keep The article meets and standards Deletion of Ivan Teodorovich WP:RS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
795 20986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tamaskan Dog (3rd nomination) [[User talk:94.8.142.150|talk]]) 13:51, 17 December 2012 (UTC) comment If an article is written about the Tamaskan Dog Register, which can pass based on the the fact it is a bona-fide registered company with the British Government through Companies house http://wck2.companieshouse.gov.uk//wcframe?name=accessCompanyInfo would the Tamaskan article not therefore pass ? as it pertains to the business associated with the Tamaskan Dog Register ? — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/94.8.142.150|94.8.142.150 Deletion of Tamaskan Dog (3rd nomination) WP:V||WP:INHERIT||WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
796 13911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David M. Dodson User:Bearcat 22:33, 23 February 2018 (UTC) delete People do not get Wikipedia articles just for being as yet unelected candidates in future elections — if you cannot demonstrate and |reliably source that he was ''already'' notable enough for a Wikipedia article for some other reason ''before'' becoming a candidate, then he has to ''win'' the election, not just run in it, to pass . But this shows no evidence of preexisting notability at all: outside of his campaign-related coverage itself, this is referenced ''entirely'' to |blogs and |primary sources and glancing namechecks of his existence in coverage of other things, which are not support for notability at all, and the couple of pieces of campaign-related coverage don't automatically hand him a pass, because ''every'' candidate in ''any'' election could ''always'' show some of that. We are not a free publicity venue for aspiring officeholders to post their campaign brochures — if he wins the election in November, then obviously he'll clear NPOL as an actual elected officeholder, and the article can then be recreated as his basis for notability will have changed. But no, nothing here qualifies him to have an article just for being a ''candidate Deletion of David M. Dodson WP:RS||WP:NPOL||WP:BLOGS||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
797 11094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mehrunisa V Lub U User:Robert 01:22, 4 July 2017 (UTC) comment I mostly agree now. At this point, it needs tagging rather than deleting. As the article now stands, it still doesn't satisfy |film notability, but can be fixed with the addition of Pakistani film reviews Deletion of Mehrunisa V Lub U WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
798 14606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Gannon (footballer) User:Fenix 14:11, 9 August 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Sean Gannon (footballer) WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
799 15212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Betül Tayğar User:Fenix 09:01, 29 August 2017 (UTC) delete Fails No indication of wide |GNG. Article is well referenced, however all sources are essentially databases, stat sites, |brief routine mentions or |Primary sources. Would challenge other editors to provide a single instance of a significant, dedicated article on the player that might be used to support GNG Deletion of Betül Tayğar WP:NHOCKEY||WP:GNG||WP:MILL||WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
800 9574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of books related to Buddhism User:Cyclopia 09:47, 31 October 2013 (UTC) keep to books ''on'' Buddhism and including only notable entries. We |can't become an endless list of buddhism books in the world, but we can list notable books on the topic Deletion of List of books related to Buddhism WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
801 16919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parralox User:JediLofty 12:51, 12 August 2008 (UTC) delete fails . -- JediLofty Deletion of Parralox WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
802 14432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Promode R. Bandyopadhyay User:Xxanthippe 21:33, 2 January 2017 (UTC) keep Passes rof Deletion of Promode R. Bandyopadhyay WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
803 4962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stranger (Kaiju) User:South 01:50, 19 July 2009 (UTC) delete Fails , and Deletion of Stranger (Kaiju) WP:N||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
804 3124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Truck nuts User:Belovedfreak 16:33, 7 September 2007 (UTC) comment possible notability: an article in the Washington Post http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/02/22/AR2007022201426.html here. As the article is now, it's completely non-encyclopaedic and there is a |conflict of interest as the author appears to be, at the very least, the web designer for the product's site. http://www.thenutshop.com Deletion of Truck nuts WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
805 3924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan DeGennaro User:Dirtlawyer1 18:43, 20 June 2013 (UTC) delete """Seriously? The """"head strength and conditioning coach"""" for the Carnegie-Mellon Tartans? Sorry, but this is an extremely weak article topic, and I see no signs of in-depth coverage in multiple, independent, reliable sources to satisfy the general notability guidelines per """ Deletion of Alan DeGennaro WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
806 3989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beaver contest User:Mark 23:28, 21 January 2014 (UTC) delete as . This is a large computer and informatics contest for young folk. http://bebras.org/about/ It's claimed that over 500,000 students participated last year from 27 countries. It's listed as one of the http://www.ocg.at/en/competitions-children-and-young-people top three contests by the OCG, but I don't know if this is enough by itself for notability. For such a large contest, I've been unable to find multiple in-depth independent RS discussing it, but this could just be my incompetence at finding education-related RS. As it stand, this is a case of . If others find good RS, I'm happy to change my recommendation Deletion of Beaver contest WP:TOOSOON||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
807 9660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Garibaldi Annex User:Cullen328 03:03, 6 July 2014 (UTC) merge to Vancouver School Board per long-established practice described at Deletion of Garibaldi Annex WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
808 16082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur Skinny Graham User:Mangojuice 16:12, 4 February 2008 (UTC) keep I managed to dig up his career stats: http://www.baseball-reference.com/g/grahask02.shtml which proves the guy existed and that he played for the Red Sox in the 1930s. Still, we really need more than that for an article. Per , though, he was a real professional athlete, so we should keep the article. That said, if no sources better than the stats page are found in (say) six months, I'd say delete Deletion of Arthur Skinny Graham WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
809 17508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Handbra User:Andrewa 10:52, 25 December 2006 (UTC) keep and revert to a sensible version. Deleting the content while an AfD is in process is IMO |disruption Deletion of Handbra WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
810 3703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lindela Figlan User:TheSandDoctor 00:32, 11 April 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Lindela Figlan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
811 8642 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victoria """"Porkchop"""" Parker""" User:SportingFlyer 04:21, 8 March 2018 (UTC) delete looking at , being a reality television show contestant doesn't get you over the notability line under any of the guidelines """Deletion of Victoria """"Porkchop"""" Parker""" WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
812 4949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kell Hounds (2nd nomination) User:SimpleParadox 18:02, 17 December 2007 (UTC) delete Per otability, this article has none Deletion of Kell Hounds (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
813 252 [[Johannes von Werden]] (LA zurückgezogen) Benutzer:HH58 NONE delete Äbte sind i.a. einem Bischof unterstellt. Personen aus dem Bereich Religion (sofern nicht selig oder heilig gesprochen) sind laut erst vom Bischof aufwärts relevant. Wenn sich also keine anderen relevanzstiftenden Merkmale finden (z.B. Stellung als Fürstabt, bekannter Wissenschaftler u.ä Löschung von Johannes von Werden Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
814 17197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NFS-Ganesha(a Network File System user-level server) User:Whpq 20:06, 30 November 2011 (UTC) comment Significant coverage in independent |reliable sources to establish that it meets Wikipedia's |inclusion criteria Deletion of NFS-Ganesha(a Network File System user-level server) WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
815 133 [[Ulrike Theusner]] (erl.) Benutzer:Wo st 01/Bewertung 18:21, 6. Jul. 2011 (CEST) delete Kasten| Der Artikel hätte in die |Löschprüfung gehört. Selnst wenn man dies außer Acht lässt, dann gelang es dem Ersteller auch im zweiten Versuch nicht, die Relevanz mit WP:Q|Quellen zu belegen Löschung von Ulrike Theusner Wikipedia:LP Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
816 15674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Youth Alive Australia User:Deus 03:59, 3 April 2021 (UTC) comment it's not an album, it's an organisation. And there is a clear merge or redirect available here which must be considered prior to deletion (per ). Please reconsider your !vote Deletion of Youth Alive Australia WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
817 19252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mehtar (word) User:Jason 22:01, 8 July 2012 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Mehtar (word) WP:NOTADICTIONARY Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
818 16390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EliteAnswers.com User:Ihcoyc 14:12, 26 September 2008 (UTC) delete """and '''salt'''. Yet another non-consumer business services business that thinks a Wikipedia article would be |good for business. Execrable prose speaks repeatedly of """"business solutions"""", a strongly |non-neutral term that suggests |conflict of interest""" Deletion of EliteAnswers.com WP:SPAM||WP:NPOV||WP:COI Wikipedia:Spam 112
819 121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valley Entertainment Monthly User:Pdcook 01:48, 19 April 2010 (UTC) delete None of the sources referenced or linked in the article establish any measure of notability. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&safe=off&q=%22Valley+Entertainment+Monthly%22+-wikipedia&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai= Google and http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&safe=off&tbo=p&tbs=nws:1&q=%22Valley+Entertainment+Monthly%22&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai= GNews turn up pretty much nothing. Thus I can find no sources that demonstrate notability per Deletion of Valley Entertainment Monthly WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
820 8209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Internet Relay Chat bots User:Armbrust 02:16, 1 February 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of Internet Relay Chat bots WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
821 8080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corey Mills (2nd nomination) User:Edwardx 23:13, 28 October 2017 (UTC) delete Struggling to find any independent in-depth coverage in reliable sources - lack of . Fails and . Promotional article, created by a , the subject himself Deletion of Corey Mills (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV||WP:BIO||WP:GNG||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Notability 77
822 5834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stacy Layne Matthews User:StraussInTheHouse 16:56, 31 December 2018 (UTC) merge A source analysis which I shall provide below shows she's not really notable |outside the series. Most of the sources cited are |independent. I can't comment on their reliability because I'm unfamiliar with them. The significance of the coverage they give to her is questionable: they heavily ''mention'' her, but it is seemingly always in the context of her being on the RuPaul show, leading me to believe this is a case of |passing notability, and a probably failure of . However, |redirects are cheap, so pointing it to the TV show is probably the best bet Deletion of Stacy Layne Matthews WP:NOPAGE||WP:INDEPENDENT||WP:SUSTAINED||WP:BLP1E||WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Notability 77
823 8324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Iranian football transfers summer 2018 User:Ajf773 23:52, 24 May 2018 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of List of Iranian football transfers summer 2018 WP:LISTN||WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
824 70 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Frankl User:Maclean25 03:55, 7 April 2006 (UTC) delete per , just a lawyer Deletion of David Frankl WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
825 7544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stan Romanek (2nd nomination) User:Silver 02:42, 28 March 2010 (UTC) comment I have tagged this article for |rescue Deletion of Stan Romanek (2nd nomination) WP:ARS Wikipedia:Article Rescue Squadron 98
826 10707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Far Out Recordings User:Vicenarian 15:51, 29 May 2009 (UTC) comment """WP:GHITS|Number of Google hits is a fallacious argument; """"a large number of hits on a search engine is no guarantee that the subject is suitable for inclusion in Wikipedia."""" It is the quality of hits that count. If the subject is indeed notable, then some of these Google hits should be reliable, independent third-party sources that can provide the necessary depth of coverage to prove verifiable notability. So far, I'm not seeing any hits that provide the coverage needed per """ Deletion of Far Out Recordings WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
827 13964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ComicRack User:Smalljim 23:11, 1 January 2008 (UTC) delete """Although arguments such as """"not encyclopedic"""" and """"author appears to be using sock puppets"""" are not appropriate reasons for deletion, I can't find enough independent coverage of this program to convince me that the |general notability guideline is satisfied. Maybe in a few months time, if people start taking notice of it. """ Deletion of ComicRack WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
828 20723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shit on your neighbor User:TenPoundHammer 14:19, 15 July 2008 (UTC) delete per , clearly made up one day Deletion of Shit on your neighbor WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
829 16906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farman Nawaz Khan User:Chrisw80 20:16, 10 March 2016 (UTC) delete per , and per nom. Looking at the other pages linked, one is also at AfD for similar reasons. One has only one source and the other has a good chunk of it copied and pasted from his personal blog and also only one source aside from his personal blog. Personally I think all of these need to be either deleted or have reliable sources added and the improperly sourced content removed. Wikipedia is not a webhost for resumes/profiles Deletion of Farman Nawaz Khan WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
830 17824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neurotronics User:SW3 16:31, 14 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails . Sounds like a article Deletion of Neurotronics WP:GNG||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Notability 77
831 19693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bangladesh–Kenya relations User:Kmzayeem 00:41, 28 July 2019 (UTC) keep passes based on these two sources: https://archive.fo/20140622185259/http://www.thefinancialexpress-bd.com/old/more.php?news_id=142455&date=2012-09-06, https://unb.com.bd/category/Bangladesh/nairobi-keen-to-bolster-ties-with-dhaka-business-team-to-visit-kenya/14148; both are third party reliable sources with indepth coverage discussing bilateral relations between Bangladesh and Kenya. The Kenyan FM has just concluded a visit to Bangladesh this year and signed agreements on education, science and technology as well as on initiating regular foreign office consultations. The national cricket teams of Bangladesh national cricket team|Bangladesh and Kenya national cricket team|Kenya have exchanged several bilateral tours, pointing out the extensive cultural relations between the two countries Deletion of Bangladesh–Kenya relations WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
832 3727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Perfit User:CASSIOPEIA 11:17, 13 May 2019 (UTC) keep As a distinguished professor meets |NACADEMIC#5 and Google scholar citations show over 100K work cited thus passes |NACADEMIC#1 Deletion of Michael Perfit WP:NACADEMIC||WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
833 21841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert D. Cherry user:Hannes 20:36, 8 April 2021 (UTC) keep """has multiple reviews such as """"Social Service Review, Vol. 82, No. 2 (June 2008), pp. 335-338"""", """"Contemporary Sociology, Vol. 19, No. 6 (Nov., 1990), pp. 809-81"""", etc. passes and probably also since these are reviews in academic journals""" Deletion of Robert D. Cherry WP:NAUTHOR||WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
834 642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blackblack User:D 14:57, 11 February 2008 (UTC) keep and place {{Verify}} tag at the top of the page. If no |sources are added within the next few months I suggest re-AFD'ing it Deletion of Blackblack WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
835 19857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Htein Lin (colonel) User:NemesisAT 22:18, 31 July 2021 (UTC) keep Two out of three references present are , establishing notability per GNG Deletion of Htein Lin (colonel) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
836 15666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Tank is Fight! (2nd nomination) User:Angusmclellan 21:07, 10 February 2007 (UTC) delete Without some third-party critical commentary, this is a simple directory entry, which is not stuff. Wikipedia is not books-in-print, and this book is not |notable Deletion of My Tank is Fight! (2nd nomination) WP:NOT||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
837 7485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Santeria (band) User:JohnCD 18:57, 22 January 2009 (UTC) delete not notable per Deletion of Santeria (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
838 3252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pradip Kumar Singh User:Randykitty 18:51, 15 July 2014 (UTC) delete """Yes, Singh has published a few books and some papers, as DGG notes. However, as says, it is not enough to publish, all academics publish. What is needed is evidence that these publications have been noted, which we usually assess by looking at how often an academic's publications have been cited. Usually, this is very difficult to assess for someone with a common name (like """"Singh""""). In this case, too, there seem to be multiple """"PK Singh"""" (one of them a microbiologist), but all of them have been cited so little, that even if we just throw all on one heap and count everything, it just is not enough, not even in a low-citation density field like anthropology. If one clicks the Google Scholar link above (under """"find sources""""), the highest-cited article has 11 hits (and that is one by the microbiologist). The Web of Science (which has a lower coverage in the humanities and social sciences) finds 9 articles, cited a total of 13 times for an h-index of 1 (here, I searched for """"PK Singh""""). If opne searches for """"PK Singh"""" in GS, one finds some very highly-cited papers, but all by other persons (I went through several pages, down to articles cited about 30 times, none of them by the PK Singh under discussion here). In short, I see no evidence of this person having made a measurable impact on his field, as required by #1, nor do I see evidence of him passing any of the other criteria""" Deletion of Pradip Kumar Singh WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
839 3541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Golf Courses in Jacksonville, Florida User:Northamerica1000 02:47, 6 September 2011 (UTC) keep """spaced ndash}}Per Wikipedia:What_Wikipedia_is_not#Wikipedia_is_not_a_directory|Wikipedia is not a directory, the article's inclusion on Wikipedia is appropriate, as the article has an organized focus and is not, per Wikipedia directory guidelines, like """"Lists or repositories of loosely associated topics"""". The article passes all eight points of . Furthermore, the article can also serve to promote the creation of new articles for notable golf courses""" Deletion of List of Golf Courses in Jacksonville, Florida WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
840 12813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elisabeth Waters User:Tacyarg 21:36, 17 May 2020 (UTC) comment looks like applies Deletion of Elisabeth Waters WP:BIODEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
841 950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tommy T. Rapisardi User:Imoeng 02:35, 27 October 2006 (UTC) keep The band name is a red link and no source at all. Seems . But Google search returned results of interviews and reviews. Cheers Deletion of Tommy T. Rapisardi WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
842 15376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abhay Singh (politician) User:Curbon7 00:04, 9 July 2021 (UTC) delete From what I can gather from https://ndtv.in/elections/jharkhand/vidhan-sabha-election-candidates-list-2019/abhay-singh-51048-15 this source, I'm assuming this subject is a failed candidate for office, which means he doesn't pass . Otherwise, agree that he doesn't pass as the sources seem to be either routine election coverage or just election results Deletion of Abhay Singh (politician) WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
843 5258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roomsurge.com User:DoriSmith 00:26, 2 June 2012 (UTC) delete """I don't see a claim to """"importance or significance"""" anywhere in the article—just that they exist. It doesn't appear to meet either otability (organizations and companies) or . Now that I think about it, it ''should'' be up for CSD… I think I'll go do that, in fact""" Deletion of Roomsurge.com WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
844 10460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jocelyne Couture-Nowak (second nomination) User:GarryKosmos 03:19, 3 May 2007 (UTC) keep Satisfies . Her work in Canada makes her notable apart from her death Deletion of Jocelyne Couture-Nowak (second nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
845 1751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Multimedia Esperanto User:Dhartung 13:51, 20 March 2008 (UTC) delete The http://web.archive.org/web/20060211223808/http://www.sensezero.org/ website (no CSS in Wayback, looks awful) doesn't seem to have been online for some time (only archived once). Haindl is certainly verifiable as an academic in the disciplinehttp://www.informatik.uni-trier.de/~ley/db/indices/a-tree/h/Haindl:Philipp.html. But it doesn't have much in the way of independent coverage, so pretty flatly fails / Deletion of Multimedia Esperanto WP:N||WP:SOFTWARE Wikipedia:Notability 77
846 341 [[Helmut Kliem]] (bleibt) Benutzer:TJ.MD 21:26, 22. Aug. 2011 (CEST) keep """1. Relevanz: die Person ist nach #Personen entweder oder die Relevanz ist im Artikel nicht dargestellt (Nein, ein """"Opfer"""" zu sein, reicht nicht - auch, wenn uns die Deutsch-deutsche Teilung näher sein mag, als die NS-Zeit); 2. ist das hier '''kein enzyklopädischer Artikel'''. Es handelt sich bei dem Text im Wesentlichen um eine gekürzte Abschrift aus der angegebenen Quelle, http://www.chronik-der-mauer.de/index.php/de/Start/Detail/id/593920/page/1 Chronik der Mauer, die ich aufmerksam zu studieren bitte. Ich war bei dem, was ich weiter unten noch ausführe, ziemlich erschrocken über das http://www.chronik-der-mauer.de/index.php/de/Start/Index/id/574312 Impressum der Seite. Die Autoren dieser Quelle stützen ihre Angaben auf Originaldokumente aus der DDR und aus Gerichtsurteilen aus der Zeit nach der Wiedervereinigung (was ich beides völlig OK finde), selektieren aber (wonach eigentlich) offenbar missliebiges heraus: In einer ebenda veröffentlichten http://www.chronik-der-mauer.de/index.php/de/Media/TextPopup/id/1444784/oldAction/Detail/oldId/593920/oldModule/Start/page/1 Abschrift ist beispielsweise die Rede davon, dass die Grenzer bepöbelt wurden - das findet sich aber weder im Haupttext der Quelle, noch in unserem Artikel, nicht einmal als Gegendarstellung o.ä.. Abgesehen davon halte ich es für ziemlich gewagt, auf einem Awtowelo#Motorr.C3.A4der|AWO- Gespann jemanden mitzunehmen, um Frau und Kinder(!) abzuholen, sich dabei """"unterhalten"""" haben zu wollen, trotz der offenbar angeregten """"Unterhaltung"""" dabei """"verfahren"""" haben zu wollen, um sich dann """"versehentlich"""" vom Ort des Geschehens zu entfernen. Und dann ist da noch die Behauptung im Artikel, """"''Der Vorfall erfüllte den Tatbestand des Mordes nach dem Strafgesetzbuch der DDR.''"""", dazu schaue dann mal bitte noch auf Schießbefehl und insbesondere auf http://www.verfassungen.de/de/ddr/strafgesetzbuch74.htm StGB der DDR, § 112. Ach ja.. Nachdem lt. Artikel kein Grenzübertritt bzw Grenzverletzung drohte, ist die Kategorisierung als ''Maueropfer'' nicht zwingend angebracht. '''Zusammenfassung''': Da wird kein Schuh draus, auch nicht mit WP:QS, und zwar, weil es einfach nix weiter gibt über diesen Menschen. Es wird immer POV bleiben, rechts- wie linksrum""" Löschung von Helmut Kliem Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
847 42 [[Arbeitskreis gegen Internetsperren und Zensur]] (LAE 1) Benutzer:Wikieditoroftoday 14:25, 24. Okt. 2009 (CEST) keep Bekanntheit erlangte der Arbeitskreis ...'' sagt doch schon alles. Sollte der Verein in ein paar Jahren in die Vergessenheit geraten sein, kann man ihn ja immer noch löschen. Zur Zeit ist er aber definitiv relevant und erfüllt die Relevanzkriterien. Daher Löschung von Arbeitskreis gegen Internetsperren und Zensur Wikipedia:LAE Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
848 3646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Debdas Acharya User:1292simon 12:52, 2 May 2013 (UTC) delete Fails . Even trying to decipher the intended topic of the article was a struggle Deletion of Debdas Acharya WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
849 6862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Absalom User:Malcolmxl5 10:05, 28 February 2008 (UTC) delete Not notable per Deletion of James Absalom WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
850 4958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Batman: Caped Crusader User:Bignole 15:25, 25 January 2009 (UTC) delete per , and possibly Deletion of Batman: Caped Crusader WP:NFF||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Notability 77
851 8755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Graves (American football) User:Paulmcdonald 03:23, 3 October 2012 (UTC) keep """In a matter of seconds, I found some significant coverage through Google News: https://www.google.com/search?q=%22John+Graves+%28American+football%29%22&tbm=nws&tbs=ar:1#hl=en&tbs=ar:1&tbm=nws&sclient=psy-ab&q=%2B%22John+Graves%22+%2Bfootball+%2B%22virginia+tech%22&oq=%2B%22John+Graves%22+%2Bfootball+%2B%22virginia+tech%22&gs_l=serp.3...53781.58478.1.58814.17.17.0.0.0.0.249.1333.16j0j1.17.0...0.0...1c.1.cKZG7Vw5zxE&pbx=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.r_qf.&fp=ea59b38a3ec82222&biw=1024&bih=624 search +""""John Graves"""" +football +""""virginia tech"""" pulls over 180 articles from various nationwide newspapers. While I agree that college football offensive linemen normally do not pass , this is an obvious exception""" Deletion of John Graves (American football) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
852 8793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of musical artists from Japan User:Shirik 01:20, 6 February 2010 (UTC) comment Of course, my argument relies on the need to remove those (very few) red links present in the list. I think musicians should only be listed here if they have an article currently. (The alternative fix is to make stubs for them after verifying they meet or similar Deletion of List of musical artists from Japan WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
853 8451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Federal Agency Short-Term Securities User:Kinu 16:52, 22 July 2006 (UTC) delete blatant ... someone just this crap now. Seriously Deletion of Federal Agency Short-Term Securities WP:SPAM||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Spam 112
854 1896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/QuicksellOnline User:AllyD 08:14, 26 January 2017 (UTC) delete """A article on a yet-to-launch e-commerce site, in which circumstance it is unsurprising that no |evidence of attained encyclopaedic notability (, , ) can be found. It is also worded as an advertisement (''""""Our customer friendly features""""'') which combined with the lack of claim of notability would have made CSD A7+G11 possible, but at this stage maybe it is better to let the AfD take its course""" Deletion of QuicksellOnline :WP:SPA||:WP:RS||:WP:NWEB||:WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
855 9759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dilip De User:Hagennos 04:28, 25 January 2018 (UTC) delete Non notable artist and the coverage does not provide notability under as his main contribution seems to be creating art using a phone Deletion of Dilip De WP:NARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
856 5024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elf Sternberg (2nd nomination) User:Georgewilliamherbert 00:56, 24 September 2007 (UTC) keep Elf's notability in Usenet was unquestioned at the time, and is well documented (in some cases by |reliable sources, in some cases not). There seems to be no genuine disagreement that the sources are accurate - the claim seems to be that not enough of them are reliable by WP standards. If there were serious BLP concerns, one could challenge info on that basis, but this is a deletion debate, in which the notability of the subject and accuracy of the article are the primary concerns. There seems to be no legitimate claim that the article's inaccurate, or that Elf wasn't notable. Asking for more reliable sources when there's a plethora of evidence that he was is a shrubbery. Keep Deletion of Elf Sternberg (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
857 13819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xi Septaton User:Rjd0060 02:59, 1 December 2007 (UTC) delete Per nom (|NN Deletion of Xi Septaton WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
858 9855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derek white and the monophobics User:Superbeecat 17:48, 24 September 2007 (UTC) delete per nom, . —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Derek white and the monophobics WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
859 8158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergio Calderon User:Kraxler 17:00, 30 August 2015 (UTC) delete fails and GNG Deletion of Sergio Calderon WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
860 8496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fallout 4 (2nd nomination) user:Hellknowz 13:10, 10 December 2013 (UTC) delete """and probably salt as redirect) per failing and -- speculation about yet unreleased game. No in-depth sources on the subject exist, because the game is not even announced yet. All the references in the article are ''not'' about F4, but the developer, previous versions, unreliable sources, etc. Nothing is solid, every comment is a """"may be"""", """"probably"""", etc. While I have little doubt the game will be eventually announced and released, it is too early for an article. I don't see anything worth merging (that previous AfD conculded), and a redirect is fine. — """ Deletion of Fallout 4 (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
861 13122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reality Winner User:Geo 04:36, 7 June 2017 (UTC) keep """#Subjects notable only for one event specifically says that BLP1E only applies ''""""If that person otherwise remains, and is likely to remain, a low-profile individual.""""'' Ms Winner is not just a whistleblower, she is the first whistleblower to be captured during the Trump Presidency. So she will be covered in '''''that context''''', over and above her (central) role in her particular leak. The next paragraph of #Subjects notable only for one event offers John Hinckley, Jr. as an example of an individual many people would say is an example of a BLP1E, who nevertheless merits a standalone article... ''""""John Hinckley, Jr., for example, has a separate article because the single event he was associated with, the Reagan assassination attempt, was significanI would urge t and his role was both substantial and well documented.""""'' I suggest Winner has much more in common with Hinkley than with genuine non-notable individuals who found themselves at the centre of a controversy, by accident, and who are only covered as a footnote to that event. ''Atlantic magazine'', for instance, published an article entitled ''https://www.theatlantic.com/news/archive/2017/06/who-is-reality-winner/529266/ Who Is Reality Winner?'' This article is clearly an attempt to cover Winner's life outside the context of her leak. The ''Atlantic'' article isclearly far from the only publication attempting to look into Winner herself, and cover her life, outside of the context of her leak. I would urge nominator to interpret BLP1E in a less extreme manner. Please understand how the wikipedia really works. Topics are '''linked'''. Some topics are '''strongly linked''' to '''multiple topics'''. I suggest the more useful way of interpreting BLP1E is to only apply it to individuals who are really only linked to one topic, the incident where they played a subordinate role. I suggest BLP1E should never be applied to individuals, like Winner, who are strongly linked to multiple other topics""" Deletion of Reality Winner WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
862 5108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bon McDougall User:Ultraexactzz 14:19, 9 January 2008 (UTC) keep as competing in a professional race at the highest level would indicate some notability, per . If the Indy 500 was it, though, then maybe it is a little too soon for an article Deletion of Bon McDougall WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
863 19501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alban Bunjaku (2nd nomination) User:Fenix 11:25, 15 December 2014 (UTC) delete fails , although these matches are sanctioned by FIFA, I do not believe that individuals in the FIFA member team playing receive an official cap, therefore the criteria agreed upon do not seem to be met. I am not convinced there is sufficient, based on one international appearance to satisfy GNG Deletion of Alban Bunjaku (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
864 11572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Podesta Group User:William 14:46, 14 November 2007 (UTC) delete without prejudice. Either copyvio or , per Deletion of Podesta Group WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
865 18839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pop Group J-4 User:MuZemike 21:34, 3 October 2008 (UTC) delete Complete and utter Deletion of Pop Group J-4 WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
866 15915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Gum User:GauchoDude 13:25, 10 January 2017 (UTC) delete Per nom, above rationale, and overarching Deletion of Jeff Gum WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
867 2571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of triathletes User:Bearian 17:06, 26 September 2012 (UTC) keep but please add |some citations, please, for the kittens Deletion of List of triathletes WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
868 16157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carl B. Cook User:Dushan 02:56, 1 February 2019 (UTC) delete possibly a very important person in the church but I can find no good independent sources. fails Deletion of Carl B. Cook WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
869 1124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isaac Richards (footballer) User:GiantSnowman 07:32, 9 April 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Isaac Richards (footballer) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
870 11404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hybrid (StarCraft) User:Axem 20:02, 3 November 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Hybrid (StarCraft) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
871 4895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HomeTips.com User:Themfromspace 05:58, 23 April 2010 (UTC) comment none of the references added discuss the site in significant detail. They are either passing mentions of the site, or not |reliable sources Deletion of HomeTips.com WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
872 13423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 New York plane scare User:JohnCD 12:40, 28 April 2009 (UTC) delete """per #NEWS - this has no """"historical notability""" Deletion of 2009 New York plane scare WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
873 2064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Cunningham User:AlexTiefling 15:56, 7 October 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Craig Cunningham WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
874 17465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Städtholdengrad User:Nsk92 01:42, 15 August 2008 (UTC) delete Fails , not to mention . Possible hoax Deletion of Städtholdengrad WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
875 17921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Costigan User:Zanoni 08:07, 19 March 2011 (UTC) delete fails both and Deletion of Anthony Costigan WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
876 19027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mic Check User:Geniac 14:11, 10 July 2007 (UTC) merge to album. #Songs says a song is ''probably'' notable if it is a released single by a notable artist. It still needs reputable, reliable, third-party sources, of which this article has none Deletion of Mic Check WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
877 3767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional brands in South Park (2nd nomination) User:Paul730 02:45, 30 November 2007 (UTC) delete per EALacey, sgeureka, Erik, and Bignole. Fictional brands have no relevance on Wikipedia under they are independantly notable. |Notability is not inherited - being a part of a larger notable topic does not make something notable. By that logic, we would have a separate articles for every member of a famous person's family, because that person is notable and their family are associated with them. Everything must establish notability of it's own accord... think about it; planet Earth is notable, does that mean we need a separate article for everyone who lives on Earth? I mean, they live on a notable planet, so why not? (Please note sarcasm) Listing every fictional brand on a popular TV show is |indiscriminate information. If something is notable for being on ''South Park'', what's to stop me from making a List of characters in South Park with brown hair? Notability guidelines exist for a reason. This article fails to establish why it deserves a place on Wikipedia. It's fancruft - perfect for South Park wiki but certainly not here Deletion of List of fictional brands in South Park (2nd nomination) WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:IINFO Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
878 19750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Clendening User:Rlendog 19:22, 29 June 2011 (UTC) keep Adequate sourcing to demonstrate . Also was an all-star at the IIHF U18, which may itself be interpreted as meeting criterion 4 Deletion of Adam Clendening WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
879 6847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael A. W. Griffin User:JJL 03:05, 13 January 2008 (UTC) delete insufficient evidence of notability--how senior was he in the NHS? Lacks Deletion of Michael A. W. Griffin WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
880 12769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ITSOKTOCRY User:Lopifalko 18:56, 13 August 2019 (UTC) delete Dreadfully written article full of irrelevant tiny details, the gist of which is: he released some music (first LP released in April this year). Looking through the publishers of the sources I see none that appear reliable. . Delete without prejudice to someone writing a better article on the subject in the future Deletion of ITSOKTOCRY WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
881 20115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zinga (film 2019) User:Sudhakar 22:11, 29 April 2019 (UTC) keep please cheek i am new to wikipedia but i know some rules still learning. i believe this article is notable cheek the ''times of India'' reference Deletion of Zinga (film 2019) WP:UCS "Wikipedia:What ""Ignore all rules"" means" 62
882 12208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thai Airways Flight 679 User:LGA 07:57, 10 September 2013 (UTC) delete fails policy, no demonstrated lasting effect Deletion of Thai Airways Flight 679 WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
883 20320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HP200A User:Colonel 05:09, 10 May 2010 (UTC) keep Yes, the topic is notable. Yes, there are sources. No, the nomination has not followed |our deletion process Deletion of HP200A WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
884 8470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rory Blackwell User:Scjessey 14:09, 6 November 2009 (UTC) keep definitely passes as well; however, more |reliable sources are needed. Subject's concerns valid - recommend that Rory reads for more information Deletion of Rory Blackwell WP:MUSICBIO||WP:RS||WP:BIOSELF Wikipedia:Notability 77
885 14410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dylan Collier User:Mkativerata 19:46, 4 January 2012 (UTC) delete All fail , which is already quite a wide notability guideline Deletion of Dylan Collier WP:RLN Wikipedia:Notability 77
886 4996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Strong (relative detectability) [[User talk:202.124.73.175|talk]]) 03:16, 9 November 2011 (UTC) delete as . Magnitude (astronomy) and Signal strength cover the same topic in far more detail. -- Special:Contributions/202.124.73.175|202.124.73.175 Deletion of Strong (relative detectability) WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
887 10148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wobbly Dog Productions User:Ssilvers 16:29, 24 January 2007 (UTC) delete Small theatre groups are generally not notable according to and , and this one has no particularly notable aspect Deletion of Wobbly Dog Productions WP:MUS||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
888 9484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Change-ad User:Rhododendrites 06:19, 27 January 2015 (UTC) delete Fails . --&mdash Deletion of Change-ad WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
889 20363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peppermint Teaparty User:danntm 01:05, 17 April 2007 (UTC) delete lacks sources to pass Deletion of Peppermint Teaparty WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
890 17360 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter """"Big Walt"""" Anderson""" User:Satori 14:06, 18 July 2006 (UTC) delete Fails and probably """Deletion of Walter """"Big Walt"""" Anderson""" WP:BIO||WP:ADS Wikipedia:Notability 77
891 21164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ESPN College Basketball broadcast teams User:Bagumba 11:37, 19 December 2019 (UTC) delete Fails with insufficient coverage in independent source of the specific team assignments. This is suitable for Fandom (website). I don't recommend a merge; it's verifiable, but the is on proponents to demonstrate that it's encyclopedic and not trivial Deletion of ESPN College Basketball broadcast teams WP:LISTN||WP:ONUS Wikipedia:Notability 77
892 19638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wikispaces User:Terence 06:31, 9 August 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Wikispaces WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
893 7091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hillsong Church Stockholm User:Whpq 12:55, 24 November 2009 (UTC) comment Per , there needs to be significant coverage. The sourcing in the article merely mentions Stockholm as one of the places where the church has expanded. Note also that this same guideline indicates that local chapters of natinal and international organisations are not usually notable indpendently unless significant coverage can be demonstrated beyond that chapters local area. None of the sourcing in the article meets these guidelines, and searching for more sources does not turn up anything that would establish the Stokholm instance of the church as independently notable Deletion of Hillsong Church Stockholm WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
894 10373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 Los Angeles Unified School District closure User:Jax 14:23, 16 December 2015 (UTC) keep """AFAIK, this is the first time in history that a threat like this has shut down an entire school district of over half a million people for an entire day. NYPD is criticizing the LAPD for overreacting, and this |could potentially result in a change in policy. However, if the article cannot be kept, {{ping|Mrfrobinson}}, {{ping|Mlpearc}}, {{ping|Ueutyi}}, {{ping|Ansh666}}, {{ping|Mrschimpf}} and {{ping|Gene93k}} should give a reason why it should not be redirected to """"Los Angeles Unified School District"""" per """ Deletion of 2015 Los Angeles Unified School District closure WP:RAPID||WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Notability 77
895 19645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madison Packer User:Patar 02:51, 28 October 2017 (UTC) keep Fails but passes given in-depth coverage in reliable sources (e.g. http://host.madison.com/sports/college/hockey/badgers-women-s-hockey-madison-packer-displays-uncommon-leadership/article_6027530d-9468-5152-b221-980eebbc4226.html Wisconsin State Journal, https://thehockeywriters.com/madison-packer-the-peoples-choice/ The Hockey Writers, the SB Nation sources, Sporting News link above Deletion of Madison Packer WP:NHOCKEY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
896 13616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Identity and change User:XOR 00:00, 2 June 2018 (UTC) delete as an |essay composed of Deletion of Identity and change WP:ESSAY||WP:OR Wikipedia:Essays 31
897 2551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brad Sugars User:Snigbrook 12:55, 13 June 2009 (UTC) keep ActionCOACH, merge Brad Sugars. The company appears to be notable, Sugars has some notability and possibly enough for , but I don't think a separate article is needed Deletion of Brad Sugars WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
898 6883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Senator P. Eugene Casey Memorial Pool User:Edison 15:35, 13 July 2011 (UTC) delete """Wikipedia is |not a directory of everything that exists. Typical pool, one of three in the town. If, as the article states, the pool """"sees"""" three hundred people a day, its remarkable visual abilities might garner enough coverage to justify an article""" Deletion of Senator P. Eugene Casey Memorial Pool WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
899 12169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Innovation of Sound User:BusterD 16:53, 16 June 2012 (UTC) delete per and . I'm seeing nothing meeting the standard in a reasonable search. If the only applied sources are Facebook refs, it's clearly too soon to consider this subject notable enough for inclusion. Likely promotion Deletion of Innovation of Sound WP:BAND||WP:GNG||WP:IRS Wikipedia:Notability 77
900 14302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mika Narumi User:DAJF 02:40, 20 May 2013 (UTC) delete Looks like a candidate for speedy deletion (#A7|CSD-A7), as the article does not even indicate why the subject might be notable Deletion of Mika Narumi WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
901 8335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stevenage F.C. 3–1 Newcastle United F.C. [[User talk:70.80.234.196|talk]]) 01:17, 13 January 2011 (UTC) delete per . Plus it's a ''score'', not a title. How many games between the two teams have finished with the same scores?--Special:Contributions/70.80.234.196|70.80.234.196 Deletion of Stevenage F.C. 3–1 Newcastle United F.C. WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
902 9024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fariyas Hotel Mumbai User:DARTH 16:42, 2 September 2010 (UTC) delete Non-notable and seems like pure advertising. Also fails , as, like said, seems to be made only to promote and advertise Deletion of Fariyas Hotel Mumbai WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
903 13193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Armando Galarraga's near-perfect game User:Umbralcorax 03:09, 5 June 2010 (UTC) keep for now, with a possible re-examination later. As of right now, I feel it doesn't run afoul of , however I'm willing to concede that its too close to the actual event to be sure my opinion won't change Deletion of Armando Galarraga's near-perfect game WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
904 9120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neighbours 2011 Ratings User:AnemoneProjectors 16:11, 1 March 2011 (UTC) delete I agree that this is an excessive list of statistics, per Deletion of Neighbours 2011 Ratings WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
905 1210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karla Jurvetson User:RebeccaGreen 13:45, 25 November 2018 (UTC) delete """I am finding some coverage of a donation of US$5.4 million she made to Women Vote! in May this year. It was controversial as it was in stock in a Chinese company, see here https://www.recode.net/2018/8/20/17693048/silicon-valley-tech-donors-midterms-2018-democrats-donald-trump-list and here https://www.publicintegrity.org/2018/06/21/21873/democratic-super-pac-hits-jackpot-chinese-company-stock. This is not mentioned in the article. The ''Recode'' article does describe her as a """"little-known doctor from Los Altos"""", but wonders whether this is the start of large political donations. Perhaps """ Deletion of Karla Jurvetson WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
906 11325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Storm Runner User:Rorshacma 15:50, 15 October 2020 (UTC) keep The reviews provided by Coolabahapple above are all rather on the brief side, and in some cases are little more than plot summaries, but altogether I think does push this book into passing . Even if people disagree, though, deletion would still be inappropriate, as a redirect to Rick Riordan Presents, the franchise it belongs to, would be the proper Deletion of The Storm Runner WP:NBOOK||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
907 14845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Last Alliance (single) User:Esradekan 11:59, 18 October 2008 (UTC) comment If it's a merge you're after, why did you bring them to deletion? Why don't you just |be bold and merge them Deletion of Last Alliance (single) WP:BEBOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
908 16551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canlubang User:JC7V7DC5768 17:00, 11 November 2018 (UTC) keep Passes , just because an article needs clean up doesn't mean it should be deleted Deletion of Canlubang WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
909 10489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdulkareem Khadr User:E 18:15, 19 July 2017 (UTC) merge and selective merge to Khadr family. Heavily oversourced article lacking a clear claim to notability. is lacking. Many sources merely mention this woman in article about her family, others are from minor, perhaps unreliable sources. Sourcing of assertion that he was wounded in a firefight is especially dicey Deletion of Abdulkareem Khadr WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
910 316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anand Bhatt (musician) User:Vertium 20:49, 7 September 2012 (UTC) comment As a reminder, these aren't votes. The decision is made by consensus and people can offer as much evidence to support their !vote as they like. The multiple items inserted by 99.99.174.248 (who is strongly encouraged to create an account), should have been encapsulated into one !vote, but just because they entered them as multiple items doesn't give them additional weight in the formation of the consensus. Also, I encourage asking if someone is the subject of or related to the subject of the article instead of accusing them. Please remember that is a fundamental rule here and suspicions don't count - evidence does. I'll do some of my own research and cast a !vote here soon. Thanks Deletion of Anand Bhatt (musician) WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
911 16011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ophiuchus (astrology) User:Nipsonanomhmata 00:55, 13 July 2011 (UTC) keep """The article makes it clear that astrology-wise Ophiuchus was only a suggestion (a proposal). It appears to be fairly well referenced for . It could also be merged in to an article about the man who initially proposed it and if there are good arguments for doing that I'll gladly amend my recommendation to just """"merge""" Deletion of Ophiuchus (astrology) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
912 3296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michel Mimran NONE NONE comment """Hello, Think88. For an article to be eligible for inclusion on the site, Wikipedia needs strong sources noting not just that an artist exists (and has their fans), but that their work is notable and discussed significantly by reliable sources. It's not a place to upload articles about people in the name of """"freedom of speech"""" (|because there are other venues for the promotion of artists). For example, sourcing your artist's work to a catalogue of an exhibition of their work doesn't necessarily tell us ''why'' their work is important in a broader cultural sense. Effectively, all this is is directly promotional of their work. Looking through the sources, they are mostly galleries where the artist exhibits. An artist may have many clients and a studio, but they need to be of wider cultural significance to have a Wikipedia article, and this needs to be demonstrated through the sourcing available ( is a list of specific criteria M. Mimran needs to satisfy before he gets his own article""" Deletion of Michel Mimran WP:NOTWEBHOST||WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
913 33 [[iFixit]] (LAZ) Benutzer:CorrectHorseBatteryStaple NONE keep user:Jbergner: Die Begründung mit der Marktführerschaft ist nicht nötig, da auch #WEB Punkt 1 erfüllt und im Artikel dargestellt ist. Darauf bist du bei deiner Wiedereinsetzung nicht eingegangen, entsprechend setze ich den LA wieder ein Löschung von iFixit Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
914 20797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiffany Houghton User:Bearian 01:18, 2 December 2014 (UTC) keep per due to good work by {{U|Tomwsulcer Deletion of Tiffany Houghton WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
915 21746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Broadband Internet access in the United Kingdom User:Hankwang 11:23, 15 November 2007 (UTC) comment """I realized later that it is part of :Category:Broadband Internet access by country, that has some articles that have a better style, but most of them IMO don't belong on Wikipedia per #DIR: """"Wikipedia articles are not sales catalogs, therefore prices of a product should not be quoted in an article unless the price can be sourced and there is a justified reason for its mention. ... lists of products currently on sale should not quote street prices. In addition, Wikipedia is not a price guide to be used to compare the prices of competing products, ..."""". Most articles in this category are basically market directories with prices. But I guess I won't find support for proposing a category-wide deletion""" Deletion of Broadband Internet access in the United Kingdom WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
916 17732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Clowry User:Papaursa 19:51, 13 October 2018 (UTC) keep Can't find the coverage that convinces me that is met, but considering when he played I'm willing to defer to the fact that he meets Deletion of Matt Clowry WP:GNG||WP:NHOOPS Wikipedia:Notability 77
917 16957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ulrika Ericsson User:Darkwind 08:49, 25 April 2010 (UTC) delete I get far more in the way of results on sources for a tennis player of the same name, even considering that she was in Playboy. Clearly fails Deletion of Ulrika Ericsson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
918 10487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chrissy Murderbot User:Alpha 13:51, 6 April 2011 (UTC) delete Article fails to meet the |notability guidelines for musical performers. Article is also an unreferenced BLP Deletion of Chrissy Murderbot WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
919 13724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Forgiveness (Emily Osment album) User:Hobbes 00:20, 1 October 2011 (UTC) delete Could find few sources, all throwaway mentions or not |RS. Does seem to have a Facebook page, with 16 fans already. I don't think we're looking at a Smile (The Beach Boys album)|Smile-type situation here. Please come back once released and generates some RS notice Deletion of Forgiveness (Emily Osment album) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
920 12458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danielle Solange Curzon User:StAnselm 08:50, 8 January 2012 (UTC) keep I had thought this was borderline until I saw the coverage in the Sun - this is the coverage required of Deletion of Danielle Solange Curzon WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
921 7935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Slaight User:Trillfendi 00:33, 28 February 2021 (UTC) delete as |too soon Deletion of Ali Slaight WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
922 5397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Lee (businessman) User:Sambhil32 19:57, 12 January 2020 (UTC) keep per . Significant coverage in independent reliable sources exist Deletion of Ben Lee (businessman) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
923 6549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Jardine User:TTN 00:02, 8 August 2021 (UTC) delete Topic fails . There are no sources discussing the character Deletion of Michael Jardine WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
924 19273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Galava (video game) user:Hellknowz 23:24, 15 November 2015 (UTC) delete as a non-notable game failing with no reliable, independent, in-depth sources, such as /RS. — Deletion of Galava (video game) WP:GNG||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
925 13499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Security Tool User:OSborn 00:39, 18 September 2010 (UTC) delete to Rogue security software or similar. |Notability issues, primarily |OR/OTHOWTO|HOWTO Deletion of Security Tool WP:N||WP:OR||WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:Notability 77
926 117 [[Benutzer:Liberaler Humanist/Administratorenevaluation]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Schmelzle/Literatur 00:09, 15. Jul. 2013 (CEST) keep da für mich kein Löschgrund ersichtlich. Der Benutzer betreibt eine Seite, auf der er laut Einleitungstext „Adminaktionen bewerten“ will. Bislang findet dies auch statt, Regelverstösse erkenne ich in der aktuellen Version nicht. Gerade Administratoren sind als von gesamten Benutzerschaft gewählte Benutzer mit erweiterten Rechten und Befugnissen in diesem Projekt überdies einem besonderen Interesse ihres Elektorats daran ausgesetzt, dass sie diese Rolle in der von ihnen erwarteten Weise ausfüllen. Dem steht auch nicht entgegen, dass sie in Diskussionen wie Nichtadministratoren auftreten (). // Solange sich der Benutzer an die Richtlinien hält, sehe ich persönlich vor diesem Hintergrund auch keinen Grund und keine Grundlage für administrative Eingriffe. „Prangerseite“ ist jedenfalls keine Löschbegründung – damit unterbindet man jede systematische Befassung mit Benutzerverhalten, und die Tatsache, dass ein Benutzer etwas auch andernorts tun kann, ist ebenfalls keine geeinete Löschbegründung, vgl. WP:Löschregeln. Mir leuchtet nicht wirklich ein, weshalb ein Benutzer auf einer Unterseite xy etwas legitimerweise über Administrator X sagen kann, während dieselbe Aussage im Beisein weiterer (für sich genommen ebenfalls erlaubter) Aussagen über Y und Z die Regelwidrigkeit der zugehörigen Seite begründen soll. — User:Pajz|Pajz (User talk:Pajz|Kontakt Löschung von Benutzer:Liberaler Humanist/Administratorenevaluation Wikipedia:Administratoren Wikipedia:Administrators 89
927 1411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Georgia Ann Laster User:DiamondRemley39 12:00, 3 November 2020 (UTC) keep """as satisfies #1: """"Has been the subject of multiple, non-trivial, published works appearing in sources that are reliable, not self-published, and are independent of the musician or ensemble itself."""" The reviews are plentiful online and not limited to what is in the article at present""" Deletion of Georgia Ann Laster WP:SINGER Wikipedia:Notability 77
928 4261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Down the Block There's a Riot User:Mrschimpf 23:13, 9 November 2010 (UTC) keep Nominator has |ownership issues when it comes to ''Desperate Housewives'' articles and this is an abuse of the AfD process in order to get their way with what they forsee is either an incorrect episode title or an article they didn't get to create. Episode title is http://tvlistings.zap2it.com/tv/desperate-housewives-down-the-block-theres-a-riot/EP006723180157s sourced here Deletion of Down the Block There's a Riot WP:OWN Wikipedia:Ownership of content 86
929 7128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nelson Onit Vazqueztell User:Scientizzle 18:34, 11 September 2006 (UTC) delete a promo for a |non-notable author, whose books were published by a http://www.authorhouse.com/ vanity press and rank ~4 millionth or worse at Amazon.http://www.amazon.com/Truth-Comedy-Poetry-Nelson-Vazqueztell/dp/0759612811/sr=1-3/qid=1157934879/ref=sr_1_3/104-7545054-5734307?ie=UTF8&s=books http://www.amazon.com/V-Files-Truth-Nelson-Onit-Vazqueztell/dp/1403303975/sr=1-2/qid=1157934879/ref=sr_1_2/104-7545054-5734307?ie=UTF8&s=books http://www.amazon.com/Have-You-Heard-One-About/dp/1420815083/sr=1-1/qid=1157934879/ref=sr_1_1/104-7545054-5734307?ie=UTF8&s=books. See also Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vazqueztell Deletion of Nelson Onit Vazqueztell WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
930 17353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Descendants of Queen Victoria and King Christian IX (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 20:25, 2 January 2008 (UTC) keep My instictive reaction was, ''Do we really need this?'' However, I read the article, peeked at the |cites, and read the above discussion. It seems notable to me, and far from OR. Perhaps rename per Noroton Deletion of Descendants of Queen Victoria and King Christian IX (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
931 5949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Centres of influence User:Nosebagbear 08:33, 10 April 2018 (UTC) comment """reply to|Otr500}} regarding What Wikipedia is not#Wikipedia is not a dictionary|""""Wikipedia is not a dictionary"""" - only the first line is sole definition, which is standard form. The second part regards things to bear in mind about usage, and the latter considerations about those being included. Regarding it doesn't seem to violate any of the standard given variations. General Notability (more specifically, lacking it) would seem the primary grounds to reject this, and I feel it avoids that, just. p.s. wasn't sure of correct procedure to provide an AfD response severed from comment with a relist - apologies if incorrect""" Deletion of Centres of influence WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
932 6686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Woodbridge User:Bearian 15:40, 7 October 2019 (UTC) delete the articles referenced seem to be ''|about the YouTubes'' for Coventry, ''|not really about him Deletion of Peter Woodbridge WP:COAT||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
933 15476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Au~eiku User:Edward321 23:32, 26 October 2011 (UTC) delete No independent sources, blatant violation of . Articles created by a SPA with a clear COI. Should have been Speedied Deletion of Au~eiku WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
934 6100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Satsubhra Saha :User:Finemann|Fιnεmαnn]] [[:en 19:37, 26 August 2011 (UTC) delete I wonder why this was not nominated for speedy deletion. The subject appears to have no coverage on reliable Indian media. Fails in all ways. — ''':en Deletion of Satsubhra Saha WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
935 17768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Rand User:Bearian 19:59, 13 May 2015 (UTC) merge per and Deletion of Steven Rand WP:SNOW||WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
936 11665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Feroo [[User talk:72.75.108.10|talk]])}}''' 20:02, 21 December 2008 (UTC) delete No of this individual to even |verify meeting or ... simply ancruft|fancruft that should have been #A7|CSD A7. Happy Editing! — '''{{#if:72.75.108.10|{{User|72.75.108.10}}|Special:Contributions/72.75.108.10|72.75.108.10 Deletion of Feroo WP:RS||WP:V||WP:BIO||WP:MUSIC||WP:F||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
937 6690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hughes & Kettner User:Walter 19:23, 9 January 2021 (UTC) delete I'm not sure about the book entry, but the first review is not from a |reliable sources and the second is a passing mention. If it had been a feature article on the amps or the company, that would have mad a difference in my opinion. My Google search reveals entries from a lot of music stores, fan forums and sales sites (like ebay). https://www.gearnews.com/manufacturer/hughes-kettner/ lists some of the company's recent press releases. If they had listed other sources, that too would have made a difference Deletion of Hughes & Kettner :WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
938 14453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cynthia Crane User:Michig 09:39, 22 October 2017 (UTC) keep Clearly meets and via coverage in ''The New York Times'' (http://www.nytimes.com/1987/12/14/arts/cabaret-cynthia-crane-sings.html, http://www.nytimes.com/1990/02/11/arts/reviews-music-cynthia-crane-cabaret.html), ''New York Daily News'' (http://www.nydailynews.com/news/money/bernard-madoff-victim-singer-cynthia-crane-robbed-steinway-piano-article-1.369621), ''Rapport'' (https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=U00nAQAAIAAJ&q=%22cynthia+crane%22+singer&dq=%22cynthia+crane%22+singer&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjUqZDU9YPXAhVLvRoKHcvJDGo4ChDoAQglMAA), ''Cadence'' (https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=MZbiAAAAMAAJ&q=%22cynthia+crane%22+singer&dq=%22cynthia+crane%22+singer&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiuuK_F9YPXAhXDcBoKHSjYBGwQ6AEINjAE), ''Jazz Times'' (https://jazztimes.com/reviews/albums/cynthia-crane-and-mike-renzi-blue-rendezvous-bittersweet-midnight-blue-songs/), BroadwayWorld (https://www.broadwayworld.com/cabaret/article/Cabaret-Life-NYC-New-York-Cabaret-Legend-Cynthia-Crane-Opens-Pandoras-Box-With-New-Channel-on-Internet-Radio-20141125), and Allmusic (https://www.allmusic.com/artist/cynthia-crane-mn0000123008/biography, https://www.allmusic.com/album/smoky-bar-songs-for-the-no-smoking-section-mw0000177600, https://www.allmusic.com/album/cynthias-in-love-mw0000023100, https://www.allmusic.com/album/the-secret-life-of-a-wasp-mw0000971127 Deletion of Cynthia Crane WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
939 1645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jane Gibian User:CiaranG 23:29, 19 January 2007 (UTC) delete My own brief research didn't turn up anything to indicate that this might satisfy Deletion of Jane Gibian WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
940 508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Posterrorism User:Catgirllover4ever 20:49, 31 March 2020 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Posterrorism WP:A7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
941 20148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aneta Langerová User:Gongshow 20:14, 23 February 2012 (UTC) keep """The references added by User:Vejvančický demonstrate there is significant coverage in multiple reliable sources for this singer; meets . She also quite easily meets the criteria, going by http://allmusic.com/artist/aneta-langerov-p988043/biography this source - she won ''Česko hledá SuperStar'' (the Czech ''Pop Idol''), her first album became """"the country's best-selling album ever"""", another album """"peaked at number two on the Czech charts"""" and she has http://allmusic.com/artist/aneta-langerov-p988043/discography multiple album releases on a major label""" Deletion of Aneta Langerová WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
942 9671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Council of Emergency Medicine Residency Directors User:RP459 23:46, 27 December 2009 (UTC) keep Google search reveals lots of hits with respect to this organization. Current version is likely salvagable and does not have a ''spam'' feel to it. Passes Deletion of Council of Emergency Medicine Residency Directors WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
943 14931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stan Nicholls User:Neurolysis 15:43, 21 February 2009 (UTC) keep Meets as a winner of a notable award, and a nominee for multiple notable awards. &mdash Deletion of Stan Nicholls WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
944 21863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdullah Snobar User:Wikishovel 20:40, 20 October 2016 (UTC) delete per nomination. Fails , and the only coverage I can find of him online is brief mentions in connection with the Ryerson DMZ Deletion of Abdullah Snobar WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
945 20107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Atop the Fourth Wall Episodes User:Starblind 18:38, 22 December 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of Atop the Fourth Wall Episodes WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
946 15631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rajiv V. Joshi User:nonsenseferret 23:47, 18 November 2014 (UTC) keep IEEE Fellow qualifies per criteria Deletion of Rajiv V. Joshi WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
947 7892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Giuseppa Robucci User:CommanderLinx 19:00, 14 July 2019 (UTC) delete or '''Redirect''' to appropriate list per and . Sources are routine birthday articles and don't tell us much more than the usual longevity nothingness of born, got married, had kids, got old, died. Entry on a list is enough Deletion of Maria Giuseppa Robucci WP:NOPAGE||WP:PERMASTUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
948 7240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Can Birsay User:Tarinth 16:20, 27 December 2006 (UTC) comment """Just a comment, I would suggest using gentler language when it comes to AfDs regarding a living person. Saying that they are """"not an important person"""" sounds too personal, and might aggravate a person who might otherwise like to contribute helpful content to Wikipedia. Might I suggest: """"Article does not assert notability per """ Deletion of Can Birsay WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
949 15190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adonnis [[User talk:Ravenswing|''' '' Ravenswing '' ''']] 03:17, 22 July 2013 (UTC) delete Fails every criteria of and . Come back when (and if) this nonentity genuinely achieves something Deletion of Adonnis WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
950 5466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gustavo Picone User:Papaursa 20:11, 18 January 2014 (UTC) delete No top tier fights and no significant coverage, so he doesn't meet or Deletion of Gustavo Picone WP:NMMA||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
951 15125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Kardashian effect User:BenLinus1214 22:29, 29 August 2015 (UTC) merge with Kim Kardashian per . Might be notable for Wiktionary, but some of the material might be nice for the corresponding section on her main page. Johanna (formerly Deletion of Kim Kardashian effect WP:WPINAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
952 7611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seema Sonik Alimchand User:Bejnar 20:32, 18 December 2015 (UTC) delete """clearly if ever. The book was just released, and aside from promotion on its release, there is no coverage. It has not been critically reviewed. The earlier CD compilation did not bring Seema Sonik Alimchand significant coverage. I note that in her past she has also been a """"freelance voice professional"""" and self-published a book """"Catty KT"""", neither of which brought her independent coverage. She fails and does not qualify under . """ Deletion of Seema Sonik Alimchand WP:TOOSOON||WP:BLPNOTE||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Too soon 40
953 11390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SafeLogic User:CNMall41 01:25, 16 January 2018 (UTC) delete To me its more of a notability issue than a spam issue. I would gladly do a quick cleanup of the page, but the problem is there is nothing in-depth that I can use to cite on the page. Basically, needs deleted for failing to meet . I would also advise the creator to either wait for a volunteer editor to create the page once the company is notable, or list it at Wikipedia:WikiProject Requested articles Deletion of SafeLogic WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
954 8221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Astro empires User:Butch 16:16, 29 July 2008 (UTC) keep but needs clean up. The articles supplied and popularity of the game meet . The links provided also meets . I do agree that the article needs to be made more independent and less like an advertisement but we don't shut down notable articles for being in need of some work, we clean them up Deletion of Astro empires WP:NOTE||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
955 1207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Authors with mental illness User:Antivenin 05:41, 28 March 2009 (UTC) comment To be clear, this topic is perfectly notable/relevant per (which is a Wiki policy and not an essay like quoted above). However since this list cites barely any reliable sources, it should be '''deleted'''. I would, of course, prefer to '''keep''' this article with ''reliable sources added Deletion of Authors with mental illness WP:SALAT||WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
956 12374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thamesbeat User:Gwalla 23:36, 13 March 2010 (UTC) delete One band's joke, not a genre. Attempts to include other bands under the umbrella appears to be |original research &mdash Deletion of Thamesbeat WP:original research Wikipedia:No original research 65
957 9776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahwazi Democratic Popular Front User:07fan 19:17, 24 January 2008 (UTC) delete Per User:WebHamster, wikipedia is not the place to promote '''non-notable fringe''' political advocacy groups, please see |soapbox Deletion of Ahwazi Democratic Popular Front WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
958 1203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peru–Ukraine relations User:Edison 15:07, 22 April 2009 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not a collection of articles on miscellaneous juxtapositions of countries, nor a directory of which do or do not exchange diplomats. Fails |notability as well Deletion of Peru–Ukraine relations WP:NOT||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
959 17833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saddleworth Morris Men User:Snottywong 01:26, 6 July 2011 (UTC) delete fails , nothing notable about the group Deletion of Saddleworth Morris Men WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
960 11889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salfia Muslim Institute User:TerriersFan 22:05, 1 July 2011 (UTC) keep the claims in the article are verified by http://www.greaterkashmir.com/news/2008/Mar/13/transworld-muslim-university-by-2010-jamiat-ahle-hadees-55.asp this reliable source from Greater Kashmir. I am in the process of sourcing the article. For background as to why high schools are considered notable see the essay . Indian schools have a poor Internet presence so we should avoid systemic bias by awaiting a search for local sources Deletion of Salfia Muslim Institute WP:NHS Wikipedia:Notability 77
961 11125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Panhumanism User:Rhododendrites 13:14, 21 February 2016 (UTC) keep I'm seeing an awful lot of sources on panhumanism (including book-length). Could you elaborate on why you don't think it meets ? &mdash Deletion of Panhumanism WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
962 9340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lil D Vs. Droppin Sickness User:ArcAngel 21:10, 28 February 2008 (UTC) delete as it fails miserably Deletion of Lil D Vs. Droppin Sickness WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
963 346 [[Lappalie]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Rainer Zenz 19:06, 7. Sep. 2007 (CEST) keep So einen Wörterbucheintrag können wir durchaus verkraften. Das ist übrigens von gedeckt Löschung von Lappalie Wikipedia:Wikipedia ist kein Wörterbuch Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
964 4550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canadian Fraternal Organization - L'Association Fraternelle Canadienne User:Habanero 05:55, 4 May 2008 (UTC) delete Per nomination. It definitely exists, but an occasional press release isn't enough for Deletion of Canadian Fraternal Organization - L'Association Fraternelle Canadienne WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
965 14515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dhruv Vikram. User:Atlantic306 19:24, 22 July 2019 (UTC) delete as with only one film role in an upcoming film, so does not pass at this stage but he may well be notable in the future with other roles, regards Deletion of Dhruv Vikram. WP:TOOSOON||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Too soon 40
966 14492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neighbourhoods of Ciudad del Este User:Ajf773 11:12, 23 June 2018 (UTC) delete per . All entries are redlinks Deletion of Neighbourhoods of Ciudad del Este WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
967 4167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AMX-104 R-Jarja User:Angusmclellan 20:41, 9 January 2007 (UTC) delete per Edison, Proto, Sandstein, Moreschi. , and refer. Apparently the well-intentioned editors who wrote wasted their time. Transwiki if anyone wants it Deletion of AMX-104 R-Jarja WP:V||WP:N||WP:INN||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
968 4809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francisca Susano User:Samsmachado 01:34, 4 December 2020 (UTC) delete """All coverage of Susano centres around her being 199+. IMHO this (not dying/being a supercentenarian) is """"one event"""" and so the article should be deleted per . I would suggest a redirect to Longevity myths, but Susano doesn't yet meet the 130+ requirement to be listed in Modern Extreme Longevity Claims""" Deletion of Francisca Susano WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
969 9730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiffany Adler User:FCYTravis 01:30, 21 April 2007 (UTC) comment I have moved the article to 2007 Pacifica fruit-throwing incident. The article is entirely about the incident in question and we have no |reliable sources which enable us to write anything which provides balance and context to Ms. Adler's biography. Thus, it's not a biography but a report about an incident. So, the article should be given the incident's title Deletion of Tiffany Adler WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
970 10688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oblivion Beckons User:Blaxthos 16:32, 21 October 2007 (UTC) delete fails , no assertion of notability (we don't just assume notability), and we're not a |crystal ball Deletion of Oblivion Beckons WP:MUSIC||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
971 5435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prashanth Chandrasekar User:Kashmorwiki 16:57, 15 April 2021 (UTC) comment u|Nomadicghumakkad}}, thats a good question to ask. While I dont have a clear answer for you, let me tell you one thing. Im also an AFC reviewer. When I have to review some articles where notability can be questioned in future, I only accept those articles which have a greater chance for survival at AFD. I even do a efore from my side to double check whether any other sources are also available. Because I really dont want my genuinity to be questioned by other users. I still wonder why this article was accepted. None of the sources are not giving enough sigcov to the subject from my opinion. Forbes article is actually giving more importance to some other event rather than the subject. Other two are also not enough to establish GNG even if we combine them all. Moreover, this is an article with 5 sentences, which does not give the readers an idea about the subject. Leave the part about notability, but I believe this should have been declined at AFC with atleast giving the reason ''submission provides insufficient context'' Pinging the reviwer {{u|Dial911}} for a clarification from their side. May be Im wrong here. Regards Deletion of Prashanth Chandrasekar WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
972 6640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/T-timeterik User:Hobbes 20:58, 15 October 2011 (UTC) delete Could find no evidence in article or on web search to support or . Nothing in Allmusic or last.fm. Has a http://www.youtube.com/results?search_type=videos&search_query=%22T-timeterik%22&search_sort=video_view_count&suggested_categories=22%2C10 couple of songs, not videos, on youtube, one of which has reached 200 listens. Nowhere near notable Deletion of T-timeterik WP:GNG||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
973 2054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/StrategyWiki User:Charlene 15:46, 6 January 2007 (UTC) delete No assertion of notability. No third-party |reliable sources. Doesn't appear to meet any of the criteria set out in Deletion of StrategyWiki WP:RS||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
974 4972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Bentley User:Rtphokie 17:21, 25 July 2008 (UTC) comment While this is true of licensed radio stations, I'm not aware of any implicit notability for radio personalities. applies and insists on significant coverage in verifiable 3rd party sources. This article contains only references to primary sources. The common name is making searches for news articles a bit challenging, Can someone more familiar with him can find some appropriate references to add to this article Deletion of Jason Bentley WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
975 4296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thefederalist.com User:Horologium 07:39, 28 September 2014 (UTC) keep Once again, we have what can only be described as a partisan witch hunt against another conservative blog. Every single argument that has been used against this blog was addressed at the Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Americablog (2nd nomination)|second deletion discussion for Americablog, which was kept, and the same arguments were used (just two weeks previous to the AFD for Americablog) at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zombietime|the Zombietime AFD, which was deleted. There is a clear double standard on Wikipedia when it comes to blogs, and it's time that the editors here recognize that the problem is getting noticed by more and more sources, and it is going to increase the credibility gap. Don't bother to cite ; I've been here long enough to know the criteria for that argument, and recognize that it only applies when the argument runs against the dominant paradigm here. Before you flame me (and I'm sure that I'll be flamed) please read though those two AFDs and recognize that there is little difference (except for the outcome) between those two discussions, and how closely that they both parallel to this discussion Deletion of Thefederalist.com WP:WAX Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
976 1831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hard Hat Brotherhood User:Krimpet 03:27, 31 January 2007 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Hard Hat Brotherhood WP:ORG||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
977 13002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of anime distributed by Bandai Visual User:Bearian 16:20, 26 January 2021 (UTC) delete per and . A list like this is worse than useless. There's no rhyme nor reason, even if it is chronological. It is a pure mess Deletion of List of anime distributed by Bandai Visual WP:LIST||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Lists 97
978 18925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/As'ad Motawh (Malaysian singer) User:Thine 16:42, 2 November 2018 (UTC) delete """and salt, per above) – Motawh does not meet or . Much of the coverage of Motawh is trivial, such as https://hype.my/2018/159474/ask-the-million-girls-who-follows-me-asad-motawhs-savage-reply-to-hater/ this blog post about his """"savage reply to hater"""" and http://www.astroawani.com/berita-hiburan/tak-rosakkan-lagu-orang-tak-sah-asad-motawh-dikecam-175518 this article littered with YouTube comments. I fail to see the significant coverage in independent RS required to suggest notability""" Deletion of As'ad Motawh (Malaysian singer) WP:MUSICBIO||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
979 16678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ovation Pharmaceuticals User:Pharaoh 13:01, 28 June 2016 (UTC) delete Fails and lacks Deletion of Ovation Pharmaceuticals WP:CORP||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
980 9886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor Who 2009 (fan series) User:Blackmetalbaz 21:17, 31 May 2009 (UTC) delete Certainly get rid of it here on the basis of no legitimate sources to establish notability; no coverage whatsoever making this anything better than |crystal-balling. Ironically, its very presence on Wikipedia may bring it to the attention of the BBC, who will in all likelihood crush it anyway as a breach of copyright Deletion of Doctor Who 2009 (fan series) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
981 5095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Authorities User:Paul 03:09, 2 September 2009 (UTC) delete as |CSD G12 copyright violation of the band's MySpace page description Deletion of The Authorities WP:G12 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
982 2539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Tench User:Isotope23 14:57, 12 July 2006 (UTC) delete per a crystal ball. Recreation if/when this show actaully airs is perfectly acceptible Deletion of David Tench WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
983 20303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siena Root User:Softlavender 09:53, 10 February 2016 (UTC) keep The AllMusic page, the Progarchives, the Magnificent Music together meet notability requirements, and when combined with the articles found on https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Siena+Root%22+-wikipedia&num=50&newwindow=1&biw=1131&bih=856&tbm=nws&source=lnms&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjuoY2W9ezKAhXmxIMKHcbHCAcQ_AUICSgD&dpr=1 GoogleNews, more than meet notability requirements ( and Deletion of Siena Root WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
984 13036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Early anthropocene User:Colonel 11:32, 13 March 2013 (UTC) keep Ruddiman's hypothesis is notable, being covered in sources which have no particular axe to grind such as ''http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=_xl8MCXURoYC&pg=PA241 Functional Biology of Plants''. The issue of forking is irrelevant to the question of deletion because inappropriate forks are addressed by merger, not deletion - see Deletion of Early anthropocene WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
985 14082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cambridge University Punting Society User:BrownHairedGirl 11:56, 16 September 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and . The only external mention I could find was a passing mention in a http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=Ve89AAAAIBAJ&sjid=10gMAAAAIBAJ&pg=4219,3072284&dq=cambridge-university-punting-society&hl=en Glasgow Herlad article Deletion of Cambridge University Punting Society WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
986 10708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Forbes (footballer) User:Jimbo 19:10, 21 May 2008 (UTC) delete easily fails notability at Deletion of Stephen Forbes (footballer) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
987 10088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew nisker User:GeoffreyT2000 23:31, 31 December 2018 (UTC) delete Found no sources that would show that this passes Deletion of Andrew nisker WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
988 16170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mehmet Tevfik Goksu User:Bbb23 12:44, 15 July 2021 (UTC) comment The article was created by a notorious LTA. The account was globally locked on June 21, a few days after this AfD was initiated. If the account had been blocked earlier, the article would have been deleted per . With this AfD leaning toward Keep, that's not really feasible. I realize that stub status doesn't mean an article should be deleted if the subject meets notability guidelines, but it ''is'' a nothing of an article at the moment Deletion of Mehmet Tevfik Goksu WP:G5 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
989 3448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Hamilton (musician) User:AllyD 18:06, 12 April 2012 (UTC) delete I've located and added several references to the article, but don't think there is enough there to meet Deletion of Steve Hamilton (musician) :WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
990 5720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sludgecore User:NASCAR 12:52, 21 October 2007 (UTC) delete Most of the google news hits are trivial mentions in articles. For example, the word itself was used in a CNN movie review, but that was the only use of the word. It did have an article in the Dallas Morning News, but unfortunately you are required to pay $3 to see it and therefore is not allowed to be used as a source. So, it fails usic|the notability guidelines for music through and through Deletion of Sludgecore WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
991 13133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua David Stone User:E 14:19, 22 October 2018 (UTC) delete """a guru of a spiritual movement, it reads like PROMO, although subject is dead. Problem is that his name fails to bring up in searches, and sources on page, dead links aside, are small publicaitons wihtin this spiritual awareness movement. The one apparent exception, a 2004 cite (#3 on page) to the ''Mt. Shasta Daily'', """"Magazine takes over Wesak event for one year,"""" which sounds like an article in a local paper, actually leads to a blank page on a Buddhist website. If anyone can source it, feel free to ping me to reconsider. I can't source it. Fails """ Deletion of Joshua David Stone WP:SIGCOV||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
992 10709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlos Windiz User:Red 12:26, 21 August 2008 (UTC) delete as hoax per #G3 Deletion of Carlos Windiz WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
993 3629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BaseBean User:Quasar 19:17, 10 June 2017 (UTC) delete appears to be a |protologism with very little usage, as seen from https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=basebean&case_insensitive=on&year_start=1800&year_end=2000&corpus=15&smoothing=3&share=&direct_url= Google ngrams. Fails the GNG Deletion of BaseBean WP:NEOLOGISM Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
994 15507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amanda Baker User:Valrith 15:47, 5 November 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Amanda Baker WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
995 17853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suzanne McQueen User:Rms125a 20:39, 6 September 2015 (UTC) delete as insufficiently notable; clear |COI Deletion of Suzanne McQueen WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
996 10589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big bay boom User:Roodog2k 14:42, 12 July 2012 (UTC) comment Personally, I don't agree with a merge/redirect to Garden State Fireworks, but I would agree with a merge/redirect with Big bay boom or '''something''' related to San Diego... assuming it's notable. I have a weird reasoning with this, related to geoscope. This event is really more closely associated with San Diego, and I feel that this information should be preserved vis-a-vis in a San Diego-related article, not the firework company. I don't think this can stand on it's own as an article, but in the spirit of , this information should be kept in an article about San Diego where someone could read about it who would otherwise not know about it Deletion of Big bay boom WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
997 197 [[Heinz Heitzer]] (erl.) Benutzer:Andy king50 NONE delete """Weder """"Historiker"""" noch """"IM"""" ist ein Relevanzmerkmal. Also bitte ein Relevanzmerkmal nach #Personen oder . WP ist u.a. auch kein Pranger für relativ unbedeutende Personen""" Löschung von Heinz Heitzer Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
998 3405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Jeandell User:Horologium 00:36, 9 May 2008 (UTC) delete under G4 and '''Salt''' to prevent recreation. The link above is to his thesis, which is apparently available at the University of Delaware library. This does not establish notability; it only establishes that he wrote a thesis for a Master's Degree. The references in the article include a wedding announcement and a Geocities page. He doesn't begin to approach the qualifications required in Deletion of Jason Jeandell WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
999 17668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lewis Putman User:Hack 20:01, 28 December 2013 (UTC) delete appears to fail as the footballer hasn't been the subject of significant coverage in reliable sources. Some sources do mention the subject but the coverage amounts to routine local coverage. Fails subject-specific notability criteria at as he hasn't played in a fully professional league ( Deletion of Lewis Putman WP:GNG||WP:NSPORTS||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1000 18728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor Who: DWO Whocast User:FOARP 09:53, 16 May 2019 (UTC) keep """or '''Merge to Doctor Who Online''' - It is not fair to accuse the nom of being """"willful"""" (whatever is meant by this - would you prefer them to be """"will-less""""?). However, the fact that we cannot access a source does not mean that it does not substantiate notability. The article includes citations in SciFiNow and SFX (magazine), both of which appear reliable sources for this subject matter. Whilst we cannot examine these over the internet to assess them, we know they exist and, per , the article is probably notable unless there are good reasons to believe otherwise. If good reasons to believe otherwise are produced, I say we merge this with the article discussing the website that produces this podcast""" Deletion of Doctor Who: DWO Whocast WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
1001 1675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stray cow problem in India User:First 19:13, 24 August 2010 (UTC) merge """in spite of author's recent request to close as """"delete"""". The main problem with the article is the horribly POV title (which doesn't meet naming policy for neutrality - ), and the lack of balanced content. An article titled Cows in India or Cattle in India probably merits a WP article. It would cover the overall treatment of cows in India, veneration by some religions and people, laws against killing cows in some regions, and yes, the problem with strays (and also the idea, if sourced, that some people don't see it as a problem), and the situation with non-'cow' cattle""" Deletion of Stray cow problem in India WP:NDESC Wikipedia:Article titles 75
1002 10379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Honour citykhan User:PJM 18:51, 4 January 2006 (UTC) delete per . Even though the claims of notability are vague, they're still claims. Not quite a speedy Deletion of Honour citykhan WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1003 7325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adithya Shivpink User:Sunshine1191 16:35, 20 September 2020 (UTC) delete Not even close to satisfying Deletion of Adithya Shivpink WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1004 9879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Johannes Hans Hess User:Ahecht 20:06, 22 April 2014 (UTC) delete """Being rare, interesting, or a """"big deal"""" isn't the same as being |notable""" Deletion of Johannes Hans Hess WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1005 11073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of companies in the Chicago metropolitan area User:Northamerica1000 03:45, 26 January 2017 (UTC) keep Qualifies for an article per relative to :Category:Companies based in Chicago. Also qualifies as a functional navigational aid per . This latter point is evidenced in part by the https://tools.wmflabs.org/pageviews/?project=en.wikipedia.org&platform=all-access&agent=user&range=latest-30&pages=List_of_companies_in_the_Chicago_metropolitan_area 15,702 page views the article has received in the last thirty days as of this post. Conversely, the :Category:Companies based in Chicago page has only received https://tools.wmflabs.org/pageviews/?project=en.wikipedia.org&platform=all-access&agent=user&range=latest-30&pages=Category:Companies_based_in_Chicago 985 page views in the last thirty days as of this post Deletion of List of companies in the Chicago metropolitan area WP:NOTDUP||WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
1006 9689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frančiška Trobevšek Drobnak User:David 16:24, 19 July 2010 (UTC) delete Vice-dean doesn't rise to #C6, and there's no evidence of academic impact that would pass C1: Google scholar doesn't even find her publications, and although Google books does have some hits for her they're not enough to convince me. I found one hit in Google news, http://www.siol.net/kultura/dogodki/2009/11/knjizni_sejem.aspx this story, but (judging from Google translate) it doesn't seem to have any content about her, it just has a paragraph of her opinions concerning multilingualism. Without evidence for passing and , we should not keep this article Deletion of Frančiška Trobevšek Drobnak WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1007 5152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WHOOP-Szo User:Atlantic306 00:22, 10 July 2020 (UTC) keep as the article subject now clearly passes bith and , imv Deletion of WHOOP-Szo WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1008 14388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Panasonic Lumix DMC-L10 User:Mikeblas 21:46, 21 February 2008 (UTC) comment And, #DIR|Wikipedia is not a directory. If all that can be written is a review, the product is not notable enough to have its own article Deletion of Panasonic Lumix DMC-L10 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1009 4523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Hiller User:Bearian 16:03, 3 December 2019 (UTC) delete while his work is no doubt laudable, he's not notable per (as seen in the table of sources above), nor Deletion of Michael Hiller WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1010 6967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thanks To... User:Marasmusine 10:38, 8 November 2008 (UTC) delete Particular game aspect which has not been the subject of reliable coverage. I have removed the references to self-published sites per eliable sources, interested parties are welcome to check the history to review them Deletion of Thanks To... WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
1011 17900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George C. Wallace White Way User:Bearian 21:18, 22 January 2020 (UTC) delete WP:MILL|four-lane |named roads are not automatically notable. A fictional place could be notable (''e.g.'', Grand Fenwick, see also List of fictional towns and villages), but the vast majority of such places are |not notable. If it's difficult to |verify, then why is it here Deletion of George C. Wallace White Way WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:GNG||WP:V Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1012 2667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fafner in the Azure terminology User:Non 16:04, 6 November 2015 (UTC) delete per the above concerns, author's request Deletion of Fafner in the Azure terminology WP:G7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1013 13415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marriage (Judeo-Christian) User:danntm 21:55, 4 February 2007 (UTC) delete I wish more nominations were as well reasoned as this. Anyway, clear and problems Deletion of Marriage (Judeo-Christian) WP:OWN||WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Ownership of content 86
1014 10300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Almamy Sogoba User:TonyStarks 09:27, 23 May 2012 (UTC) keep """The Malian League might not be pro but AS Real Bamako are a professional team and play in African continental competition regulary. Sogoba is the starting keeper and just recently started in both legs of the 2012 CAF Confederation Cup second round match-up against Wydad Casablanca, another professional team (see http://www.essor.ml/sports/article/coupe-de-la-confederation-le-real-9998 here). As per , he is notable (""""Have played in a competitive fixture between two fully professional clubs in a domestic, Continental or Intercontinental club competition.""""). Also, the fact that he was called up to the 2012 Africa Cup of Nations for a team like Mali should be factored in (meaning he's not some random Malian league player). I'd ask that the people that already voted for deleting the article re-evaluate their position based on this information""" Deletion of Almamy Sogoba WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1015 21408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bones Sanders User:Giants2008 00:17, 15 October 2011 (UTC) delete Fails , and I found nothing suggesting that he meets . There were some game reports and the like mentioning him, but I didn't see any substantial coverage Deletion of Bones Sanders WP:NSPORTS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1016 6643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Huizhou User:SportingFlyer 02:43, 27 March 2018 (UTC) keep """the fact you cite is my single biggest frustration on Wikipedia. NOTTRAVEL means WP is not written like a travel guide, meaning articles shouldn't tell you which restaurants are the """"best"""" or how to get to which tourist attractions. NOTTRAVEL then gets applied in a flagrant and erroneous way to encyclopedic transportation articles, because, god forbid, transport is kind of like travel, is it not? Wikivoyage doesn't want this kind of information, but readers wanting information on the history of bus transport or bus routes in a city would. Furthermore, there's a coordinated effort to get these lists removed from Wikipedia only on grounds, even though there's even a :Category:List of Bus Routes. If this violates , so does List of Bus Routes in London, which has been kept twice. I know I'm slipping into a argument here, but the analogy in this case is actually an accurate one. Cite something like , the fact it's poorly sourced, or the fact there's some timetable info in there that shouldn't be there, but the entire nomination is just one giant , and it's going to get through because there'll be a majority, as always happens""" Deletion of List of bus routes in Huizhou WP:NOTTRAVEL||WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:NOTTRAVEL||WP:OSE||WP:GNG||WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1017 15789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Countess User:BlueValour 02:41, 23 September 2006 (UTC) delete fails due to lack of sourcing Deletion of Robert Countess WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1018 5744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Film Creation Process User:Ignatzmice 14:20, 8 May 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Film Creation Process WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1019 993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Rogues Gallery User:Paddles 15:33, 27 May 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Unverifiable, so smells like a hoax. |WP is not for conspiracy theories you made up one day Deletion of The Rogues Gallery WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1020 442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Great White of Wildwood NJ NONE NONE keep spaced ndash}} Appears to just meet . Source examples include Deletion of The Great White of Wildwood NJ WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1021 3236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wei Hang Flight 252 User:JohnCD 14:18, 14 May 2016 (UTC) delete """This is not a hoax. """"Wei Hang"""" is the Chinese name for """"V Air"""", and I have found http://avherald.com/h?article=497f811c a source for this incident. However, with no fatalities and no damage, it is certainly not |notable enough for an article""" Deletion of Wei Hang Flight 252 WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1022 21026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orissa's Top Private Engineering Colleges User:Beeblebrox 17:23, 16 July 2009 (UTC) delete The title dooms the article, and it's all . Not speedy-able, but obviously not an appropriate approach to what could be a notable subject under a neutral title and with actual sources to verify it Deletion of Orissa's Top Private Engineering Colleges WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1023 18954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giulia Gwinn User:AF4JM 12:26, 5 October 2016 (UTC) keep passes per previous comments Deletion of Giulia Gwinn WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1024 12964 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""Brent Carpenter""""""" User:Barno 03:30, 10 July 2006 (UTC) delete per , self-published author with no indication of book's notability and no other biographical info to suggest author's notability. Wikipedia is not for people with spurious quotation marks around their names. Article is a synopsis of the book rather than attempting to describe the author, and so appears to be promotional in violation of """Deletion of """"Brent Carpenter""""""" WP:BIO||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1025 7804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teaguepocalypse [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 06:14, 18 March 2014 (UTC) delete """no |significant coverage in independent reliable sources. Simple as that. Have a read of some of Wikipedia's inclusion criteria before trying again. And the above is just a spectacular waste of time. None of that is going to """"save"""" your article because none of it is based on policy""" Deletion of Teaguepocalypse WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1026 17503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jin Wang Kim User:Ohnoitsjamie 18:06, 18 February 2011 (UTC) delete Does not meet notability; no significant coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Jin Wang Kim WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1027 279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Scholar Athlete Academy by Ben Summers User:Bagumba 18:30, 28 March 2011 (UTC) delete Article fails to meet primary criteria for notability of companies of significant coverage by independent sources (#Primary_criteria). Article's source consists only of company's own press release with an external link to company's website. Searching the web, I only find the same company press release Deletion of The Scholar Athlete Academy by Ben Summers WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
1028 13605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs played on the Nerve (1995-1998) User:Resolute 04:26, 27 July 2007 (UTC) delete per the bleeding obvious. I might suggest a speedy per just to save everyone the time Deletion of List of songs played on the Nerve (1995-1998) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
1029 4533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BootB User:Lankiveil 12:33, 12 February 2008 (UTC) delete appears to fail Deletion of BootB WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1030 9472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SaveOnMedicals User:Dlohcierekim 20:09, 25 April 2017 (UTC) delete Does not meet Deletion of SaveOnMedicals WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1031 21220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shadow of the Stars User:Stifle 20:50, 15 October 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Shadow of the Stars WP:CBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1032 15051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AirPower User:Nick 21:56, 22 October 2017 (UTC) merge """to Qi (standard) which already mentions AirPower. It is for this proposed variation of the charging standard which """"won't arrive until sometime in 2018."""" Ensure there's also a mention in the Apple Inc products section""" Deletion of AirPower WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1033 18845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St Antony's Church Machad User:Djm 07:27, 17 August 2019 (UTC) delete Merge''': There are likely offline and non-English resources, but in current state a downsized merge to Thekkumkara is probably appropriate. Even then it might initially be a little for that article but long term it might help other parts of that article improve Deletion of St Antony's Church Machad WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1034 7543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sayed Masroor User:MichaelQSchmidt 20:22, 2 January 2013 (UTC) comment The article's current sources all seem to deal more with Masroor's expose of laundering Black money|illicit funds within the Bollywood film industry, than with Masroor himself. If more were forthcoming that dealt with the filmaker's purported-as-award-winning ''Harudh'' (2011), a Hindi film about the Kashmir Conflict, we might be better able to make a sounder determination under Deletion of Sayed Masroor WP:FILMMAKER Wikipedia:Notability 77
1035 18898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andre Nickatina (2nd nomination) User:Fordmadoxfraud 05:24, 31 May 2008 (UTC) keep Sufficient media coverage to satisfy Deletion of Andre Nickatina (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1036 8009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Bailiwick of Portwood, Stockport User:The 15:18, 22 June 2014 (UTC) delete as G3 and tagged as such. Yes there is an area called Portwood but it is clearly not a Bailiwick. Obvious hoax Deletion of The Bailiwick of Portwood, Stockport WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1037 13940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vasilijus Safronovas User:Novickas 15:29, 4 March 2010 (UTC) keep """His major contributions to the encyclopedia show him an authority on Lithuania Minor - thereby fulfilling a condition of - that """"the person has made a widely recognized contribution that is part of the enduring historical record in his or her specific field""" Deletion of Vasilijus Safronovas WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1038 8925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of the Green Goblin User:Shooterwalker 17:33, 27 November 2020 (UTC) delete as a . The sources don't cover this as a separate topic from the main article and this doesn't meet the for a separate article Deletion of Alternative versions of the Green Goblin WP:CONTENTFORK||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Content forking 33
1039 9147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nokia 2110 User:B 16:24, 15 October 2007 (UTC) delete per . Repeating my PROD-2 rationale: Some vague claims towards notability are made, but these go completely unsourced Deletion of Nokia 2110 WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1040 8371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs recorded by Udit Narayan User:Iridescent 12:29, 18 August 2013 (UTC) keep """This AFD is based on a misapprehension, that these are |stand-alone lists (that is, lists without a parent page, such as Deaths in 2011 or List of shipwrecks), where there is indeed a policy that all entries need to be themselves notable (to prevent people flooding lists with cruft). As a list of works is a sub-page to the article on the performers, the applicable policy is , which '''''explicitly''''' states that ''""""The individual items in the list do not have to be sufficiently notable to merit their own separate articles. Complete lists of works, appropriately sourced to reliable scholarship (WP:V), are encouraged""""''. – """ Deletion of List of songs recorded by Udit Narayan WP:SAL||WP:WORKS Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
1041 17809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sumner Atherton User:Alalch 20:41, 10 February 2021 (UTC) delete per Mztourist. A DFC is a DFC in this regard, and it might have the most captivating story behind it, but it's not the highest or second highest decoration. The references in the Career section appear to be somewhere in between trivial non-trivial mentions, but I have a hard time understanding how some of the assertions are supported by the sources. I didn't literally read each one of the 60s newspaper clips, but calling him specifically a ''pioneer'' of aviation looks like Deletion of Sumner Atherton WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
1042 1859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crescent Electric Supply Co. User:Newshunter12 11:47, 8 September 2018 (UTC) delete The article fails due to lacking sufficient reliable sources proving notability. The article seems very promotional in nature and also is serving as a company directory, neither of which is appropriate on Wikipedia Deletion of Crescent Electric Supply Co. WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1043 1431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Friday Alabama mall shooting User:E 12:21, 25 November 2018 (UTC) keep per because, Today's headlines: Washington Post: https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2018/11/24/police-said-they-killed-mall-shooter-now-they-say-they-might-have-shot-wrong-man/?utm_term=.0afebaf619eb ‘They shot the wrong man!’: Police said they killed a mall shooter — then said they made a mistake ; New York Times: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/24/us/alabama-mall-shooting.html Black Man Killed by Officer in Alabama Mall Shooting Was Not the Gunman, Police Now Say. Article needs major overhaul Deletion of Black Friday Alabama mall shooting WP:RAPID Wikipedia:Notability 77
1044 18629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History Book User:Uzma 14:36, 30 August 2012 (UTC) delete per . The numerous stand alone articles appear to have been posted without concern of first sourcing the information to relialbe sources. seems to apply in that element of the compilation need to be significant in their own right to be included in an article. A concise summary is appropriate if it is essential to understanding the compilation or its significance in the industry Deletion of History Book WP:GNG||WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1045 14046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/O Tahiti Nui Freedom User:Oakshade 03:13, 27 March 2016 (UTC) keep per as indicated by the RNZ International coverage already in the article as well as additional coverage by China Central Television, Radio Australia, ''Radio 1 (Tahiti)'', ''La Dépêche de Tahiti'' and ''https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tahiti-Pacifique Tahiti Pacifique''.http://english.cntv.cn/program/cultureexpress/20101125/103843.shtmlhttp://www.radioaustralia.net.au/international/radio/onairhighlights/o-tahiti-nui-freedom-canoe-shanghaiboundhttp://www.ladepeche.pf/La-pirogue-O-Tahiti-Nui-Freedom-immortalisee_a5414.htmlhttp://www.radio1.pf/o-tahiti-nui-freedom-le-voyage-epique-dune-pirogue-entre-tahiti-et-la-chine Deletion of O Tahiti Nui Freedom WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1046 7780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy capper User:Sc 18:41, 23 October 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Andy capper WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1047 8815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/People speculated to have been autistic User:Dpbsmith 14:44, 20 March 2006 (UTC) keep """but remove the large amount of dubious and badly-sourced material in it, and in future apply and punctiliously and ''promptly'' move unsourced items to the Talk page. There's nothing wrong with reporting well-sourced opinions, and there is some point in localizing this material in a single article than rather than having individual discussions biographies. But. This is a page where the |verifiability policy needs to be applied punctiliously. I notice that a number of seemingly sourced items have pretty unsatisfactory sources; for example, Alan Turing is referenced to a page on a ''medium''-credible website—it's about """"sexual health"""" and the source is an RN with an autistic child, who in turn, cites """"Tony Attwood 2000"""" but does not actually give a reference. Attwood in turn is quoted rather vaguely as saying """"Examples of possible 'Asperger's Achievers' are Albert Einstein, Thomas Jefferson, Mozart, Ludwig Wittgenstein, Glenn Gould and Alan Turing ... such illustrious individuals could be valuable heroes to children with Asperger's Syndrome."""" I don't think that's good enough, '''particularly''' since the statement suggests Attwood is motivated by a wish to provide """"heroes"""" to children with Asperger's, rather than a desire for encyclopedic accuracy""" Deletion of People speculated to have been autistic WP:V||WP:CITE||WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1048 9265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zen Do Kai (3rd nomination) User:Mdtemp 21:08, 13 January 2015 (UTC) delete Fails to meet since there's no significant independent coverage of this style. Also doesn't meet Deletion of Zen Do Kai (3rd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1049 4439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Double Digits [[User: RJaguar3|u]] | [[User Talk:RJaguar3|t]]''' 03:04, 13 April 2010 (UTC) delete no indication of existence of any |reliable sources to |verify the article's content, also |notability issues with a single pricing game that hasn't been played in 37 years. '''RJaguar3 | Deletion of Double Digits WP:RS||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1050 16880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Portsmouth humane society User:Joe 17:56, 1 May 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |company Deletion of Portsmouth humane society WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1051 20521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaikh Alauddin Siddiqui User:Eastmain 00:59, 7 November 2009 (UTC) comment Violates , but probably notable. I added this reference from a reliable source about one of his projects: {{cite news|url=http://www.asianimage.co.uk/northwest/4699233.Plans_for_1_500_pupil_Muslim_girls_boarding_school_in_Burnley/|title= Plans for 1,500-pupil Muslim girls boarding school in Burnley|last= Magill |first=Peter|date=23 October 2009|work=Asian Image|accessdate=2009-11-07}} If he is notable (as the founder of a television channel, a university, a medical school and a boarding school), then the article ought to be kept and vigorously rewritten Deletion of Shaikh Alauddin Siddiqui WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1052 21842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nihilist anarchism User:Moreschi 13:17, 14 January 2007 (UTC) delete """Presently, nihilist anarchy is more a collection of scattered individuals than a tendency"""". Well, thanks for telling us. We can't very well have articles about scattered individuals, can we? I might as well start one about my family, at least we aren't scattered. Purest |original research""" Deletion of Nihilist anarchism WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1053 8 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of ethnic minority politicians in the United Kingdom User:Marquis 20:27, 14 June 2015 (UTC) delete per above, a and largely nightmare with no clear criteria in sight. It almost qualifies for speedy deletion under as one of the creations of Deletion of List of ethnic minority politicians in the United Kingdom WP:V||WP:BLP||WP:G5 Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1054 9760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dmytro Baker User:Otr500 02:08, 20 May 2018 (UTC) delete This is a |BLP and a lack of any |''sources'' should immediately qualify for a |speedy deletion. An undersourced BLP would certainly qualify for consideration at AFD. Aside from that we have a transfer from another Wikipedia version, that has drawn an influx of new editors (to this Version), that must not understand the importance of sourcing a BLP when WP:!vote|''!voting'' to keep. It does not matter if we personally know of, or know the subject, we can not have an unsourced BLP on this Wikipedia. I may just be naive but I assumed that any version of Wikipedia would have to comply with the |''five pillars Deletion of Dmytro Baker WP:BLP||WP:RS||WP:FIVE||WP:speedy deletion Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
1055 13008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Jenkin User:Stuartyeates 07:58, 26 September 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Robert Jenkin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1056 12229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dixon Park & Ride User:Coolabahapple 07:00, 6 August 2017 (UTC) delete does not meet , have been unable to find |useable sources, i see that the article on Dixon, California has a sentence under Dixon, California#Transportation|Transportation, thats enough Deletion of Dixon Park & Ride WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1057 11515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maduve Impossible User:Atlantic306 21:07, 22 December 2018 (UTC) delete as a stalled project from 2011, doesn't pass thanks Deletion of Maduve Impossible WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1058 6455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Love Sushi (restaurant) User:Joe 01:32, 15 June 2010 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of I Love Sushi (restaurant) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1059 6989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 SAFF Championship Group A User:Inter 03:23, 4 January 2016 (UTC) keep The consensus of the previous discussion mentioned was to delete because of , not because of . Even though the SAFF is a regional, not continental tournament it is still covered by a variety of websites from a variety of countries, making it seem fairly notable. The articles pertaining to the 2015 edition clearly pass . I'll be adding more text and sources to the other editions to ensure that they meet that qualifying too Deletion of 2015 SAFF Championship Group A WP:NOTSTATSBOOK||WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:NOTSTATSBOOK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1060 13212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Football.co.uk User:Qwghlm 17:19, 26 September 2006 (UTC) delete fails to qualify under any of the criteria laid out in . Alexa ranking of 24,000 http://www.alexa.com/data/details/traffic_details?url=www.football.co.uk suggests not notable enough Deletion of Football.co.uk WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1061 21466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Motorola C139 User:Obina 18:48, 1 October 2007 (UTC) delete Keep''' Without a cell phone guideline, we return to the primary |notability criteria - are there multiple non trivial |reliable sources? In this case trivial is the key word. A million listings for sale are a million trivial sources. What we need are specific articles (not from the manufacturer!) describing the merits of this phone or its cultural impact. We have a few days to find some. Update: my logic stays my conclusion changes with the great sources now added Deletion of Motorola C139 WP:NOTE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1062 20752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Simpson (2nd nomination) User:scope_creep 13:42, 28 March 2019 (UTC) keep Passes and subsequently . A solid keep. I see it has been Afd withdrawn. The consensus is for a keep. I will close this Deletion of Star Simpson (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1063 19900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slashdot trolling phenomena (2nd nomination) User:Sandstein 09:17, 14 October 2006 (UTC) delete per , as variously pointed out above. Also, chronicling the wasting of bandwidth by bored teenagers on the Internet is generally not an encyclopedic endeavour Deletion of Slashdot trolling phenomena (2nd nomination) WP:NOR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
1064 3225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Get Licensed User:HighKing 13:55, 7 June 2018 (UTC) delete Agree with nom, topic fails GNG and Deletion of Get Licensed WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1065 1357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bosniak Canadian User:Laughing 06:02, 11 February 2007 (UTC) delete per nom, and clearly ''' Deletion of Bosniak Canadian WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
1066 7634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bashirat Amoo User:Crystallizedcarbon 17:37, 26 November 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and the references included are just routine coverage, so it also fails Deletion of Bashirat Amoo WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1067 8668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Temasek Primary School User:Narutolovehinata5 09:48, 18 March 2014 (UTC) merge to Education in Singapore or to another relevant article - Per , primary schools, unlike secondary and tertiary schools, aren't inherently notable. If they are confirmed to exist but lack reliable sources, they should be redirected instead to a school district article or to its geographic location's section on education Deletion of Temasek Primary School WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1068 20146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Izak Barnard User:Dane 02:22, 9 August 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Izak Barnard WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1069 14094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roman Ships User:Hobit 12:41, 7 October 2016 (UTC) delete I appreciate the list of sources above, but the only one I think might count as being a reliable source is paste, and that coverage is just too limited. So delete per but please feel free to recreate as more sources become available. I'm a bit surprised you don't have coverage in local papers given the Paste article. Some people count those for less, but a nice in-depth article on the band, even in a local paper, would put me on the keep side Deletion of Roman Ships WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1070 13039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Chung (artist) User:Captain 09:05, 28 November 2019 (UTC) keep """or '''Move to draft''' - I am not sure about it meeting but I think we can keep it for some time by putting """"Template:BLP sources"""" tag, otherwise move it to the draft""" Deletion of Thomas Chung (artist) WP:NARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
1071 7346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saturn and the End of Days User:Jezhotwells 17:07, 28 June 2009 (UTC) delete as per above and Deletion of Saturn and the End of Days WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1072 21823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cojawfee User:68 08:15, 8 July 2006 (UTC) delete Special note of David's mentions of and Deletion of Cojawfee WP:WEB||WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1073 207 [[PetaFuel]] (gelöscht) NONE 11:42, 20. Jun. 2010 (CEST) delete Kasten| #Wirtschaftsunternehmen nicht erreicht, anderes nicht belegt. Löschung von PetaFuel Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
1074 3871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cherie Gil User:Silver 05:06, 28 March 2010 (UTC) comment I have tagged this article for |rescue Deletion of Cherie Gil WP:ARS Wikipedia:Article Rescue Squadron 98
1075 20174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Nelson Mandela User:InedibleHulk 09:35, 8 December 2013 (UTC) delete this, and all similar. Just a quote farm. If readers want to know all the great things he's done, that's what Nelson Mandela is for. There, the facts are presented in a far more |neutral and ''far'' less repetitive way. Any actual events (death, funeral, new memorial buildings named for him, days of mourning) can easily fit there, too Deletion of Death of Nelson Mandela WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1076 10986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The 86 List User:Brewcrewer 20:19, 23 February 2008 (UTC) delete per nom, some local notability doesn't satisfy Deletion of The 86 List WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1077 8468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thefederalist.com User:Bearian 13:55, 29 September 2014 (UTC) delete while the ''Federalist Society'' is notable, |in no way does a website inherit independent notability Deletion of Thefederalist.com WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1078 564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Demartini User:Nonstopdrivel 03:48, 18 June 2007 (UTC) delete This article doesn't pass , much less . It's poorly written and has a distinctly unencyclopedic, whimsical tone. Paul Bragg is himself well known in the health-food industry, but his notability isn't transferable to Mr. Demartini. The latter, I'm guessing, gave a testimonial in one of Mr. Bragg's videos Deletion of John Demartini WP:POV||WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1079 14653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Quraishi User:Wikipedian2 16:24, 15 April 2011 (UTC) delete per of Deletion of Nick Quraishi WP:N||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1080 317 [[Wasser (Begriffsklärung)]] (erledigt, bleibt) Benutzer:Slomox NONE delete Ich habe den Antrag wiederhergestellt. Nichts davon wird wirklich als Wasser bezeichnet. Wasser für Urin ist lediglich eine Umschreibung für das Wort Urin, wenn man das richtige Wort nicht aussprechen will. Bei Lymphe heißt es auch nässende Wunde und wohl eher selten wässernde Wunde. Die anderen Begriffe haben lediglich ''-wasser'' als Wortbestandteil oder gar nichts mit Wasser zu tun (Pärfum, Schnaps: da ist doch gar kein BKL-werter Zusammenhang). Ein perfektes Beispiel einer völlig missverstandenen und zuwiderlaufenden BKL Löschung von Wasser (Begriffsklärung) Wikipedia:Begriffsklärung Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
1081 17082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy User:MelanieN 05:08, 8 January 2015 (UTC) keep """Appears to pass , I was all set to say """"delete"""" because the article contains only one reference, a brief encyclopedia entry. However, a Google News search shows that the organization is very high profile https://www.google.com/search?q=%22People%E2%80%99s+Solidarity+for+Participatory+Democracy%22&rlz=1C5CHFA_enUS568US570&oq=%22People%E2%80%99s+Solidarity+for+Participatory+Democracy%22&aqs=chrome..69i57l2j69i59l4.2782j0j4&sourceid=chrome&es_sm=91&ie=UTF-8#q=%22People%E2%80%99s+Solidarity+for+Participatory+Democracy%22&tbm=nws https://www.google.com/search?q=%22People%E2%80%99s+Solidarity+for+Participatory+Democracy%22&rlz=1C5CHFA_enUS568US570&oq=%22People%E2%80%99s+Solidarity+for+Participatory+Democracy%22&aqs=chrome..69i57l2j69i59l4.2782j0j4&sourceid=chrome&es_sm=91&ie=UTF-8#q=%22People%E2%80%99s+Solidarity+for+Participatory+Democracy%22&tbm=nws&start=10 https://www.google.com/search?q=%22People%E2%80%99s+Solidarity+for+Participatory+Democracy%22&rlz=1C5CHFA_enUS568US570&oq=%22People%E2%80%99s+Solidarity+for+Participatory+Democracy%22&aqs=chrome..69i57l2j69i59l4.2782j0j4&sourceid=chrome&es_sm=91&ie=UTF-8#q=%22People%E2%80%99s+Solidarity+for+Participatory+Democracy%22&tbm=nws&start=20. The article should be expanded to include some of this material""" Deletion of People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1082 18425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Feras Saleh User:Argyle 18:44, 31 October 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Feras Saleh WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1083 9465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drew Roy (2nd nomination) User:Thparkth 02:59, 4 November 2010 (UTC) delete has credits in multiple notable productions, but all for minor roles and so still fails Deletion of Drew Roy (2nd nomination) WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
1084 10594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason W. Fleischer User:David 20:01, 21 May 2011 (UTC) keep per #C1: half a dozen papers with over 100 cites each on Google scholar, including one in ''Nature'' with over 800, are enough to convince me that he's making a serious impact. At nomination time our article was in dire need of improvement; as De728631 states, it was a good candidate for A7 speedy deletion. However, I have made some improvements which I hope bring it up to the level of an acceptable short stub Deletion of Jason W. Fleischer WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1085 12335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pine Lake Middle School User:OSborn 02:01, 26 September 2007 (UTC) comment Still possible issues (is that award so prestiges Deletion of Pine Lake Middle School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1086 21429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bojan Kosednar User:Papaursa 04:33, 6 January 2014 (UTC) delete Unsourced BLP and his one top tier fight is insufficient to meet Deletion of Bojan Kosednar WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
1087 19592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenny Browne User:GiantSnowman 18:39, 5 April 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Kenny Browne WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1088 5786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of volumes in ReViewing Chess (series) User:Sjakkalle 10:07, 18 November 2010 (UTC) delete The content is not an informational encylopedia article, nor does it serve any navigational purpose in binding together articles or serve any developmental purpose as suggested by . I agree with SyG's and Bubba73's comments Deletion of List of volumes in ReViewing Chess (series) WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
1089 21589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phibsboro User:Colonel 00:29, 25 December 2008 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Phibsboro WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
1090 17619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Immerge User:Stifle 14:52, 8 July 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Immerge WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
1091 2625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alberget 4A User:Djsasso 11:59, 23 April 2014 (UTC) merge or delete. I am leaning towards merge but it definitely does not meet the as there is no significant coverage in independent sources so at the very least it should be merged Deletion of Alberget 4A WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1092 4335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of wedding guests of Prince William, Duke of Cambridge, and Catherine Middleton User:Tarc 19:05, 17 May 2011 (UTC) delete Perhaps a bit of commonsense will flourish this time around, and we'll realize that the |Wikipedia is not a publishing arm of the Daily Mail or the Sun. Who attended a wedding is not even the slightest bit noteworthy, it is dumb tabloid obsession with All Things Royal(tm Deletion of List of wedding guests of Prince William, Duke of Cambridge, and Catherine Middleton WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1093 12263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cool Herders User:Atama 17:13, 1 August 2008 (UTC) comment You missed that coverage of the article's subject must be significant to establish notability. A mention on a web site isn't significantly notable. I know why ''you'' think it's notable, but it still doesn't fit any of the criteria Deletion of Cool Herders WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1094 3420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Webber User:SWik78 20:00, 14 July 2008 (UTC) delete The subject of the article fails , the main criteria that would apply to him in terms of notability since he's nothing more than a nominee for the democratic primary for the Missouri House of Representatives. He appears to have quite a bit of independent coverage from |reliable sources but all of those are related to a single event, failing . The subject would merit inclusion into a possible article on the election to the Missouri House of Representatives if, and only if, he's chosen as the democratic nominee. Even then, barring other events that would make him notable, he does not deserve a stand-alone article unless he's elected to serve in the House Deletion of Stephen Webber WP:POLITICIAN||WP:RS||WP:ONEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1095 19359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theodore N. Kaufman User:Loonymonkey 06:50, 20 April 2011 (UTC) merge per and per Deletion of Theodore N. Kaufman WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
1096 17414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Circle Economy User:Cwmhiraeth 12:25, 25 May 2017 (UTC) delete Fails to meet and . I was unable to find significant coverage in reliable secondary sources Deletion of Circle Economy WP:GNG||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1097 9442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J Stalin (2nd nomination) User:Gwernol 10:06, 26 February 2008 (UTC) keep just as it did three days ago, this article has adequate |sources that demonstrate the |notability of the subject Deletion of J Stalin (2nd nomination) WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1098 1747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/StickDeath User:Starblind 15:27, 19 November 2006 (UTC) delete per , and I don't see any reliable sources Deletion of StickDeath WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1099 5217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eva Natus-Šalamounová User:Possibly 18:51, 3 December 2020 (UTC) keep I am seeing many mentions in Czech, and there is the museum collection, so GNG is likely met. Seeing as the nominator does not seem to do and has made two incorrect AfD nominations of notable artists today, I don't put much faith in this nomination Deletion of Eva Natus-Šalamounová WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1100 4708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elctrikchair User:Doc 05:01, 4 July 2009 (UTC) delete WP:NOTMYSPACE|Wikipedia is not MySpace. Band is NN and fails spectacularly. Article reads like a |press release Deletion of Elctrikchair WP:MUSIC||WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1101 9949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eleni Antoniadou (2nd nomination) User:Jobas 13:45, 21 April 2017 (UTC) delete per . It's a borderline case Deletion of Eleni Antoniadou (2nd nomination) WP:NPF Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
1102 21647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jimmy Parker User:Whpq 14:55, 17 September 2017 (UTC) delete No sources in the article and the only articles that identify a Jimmy Parker playing rugby for the Belgium national team are all Wikipedia mirrors. This fails |verifiability in spectacular fashion Deletion of Jimmy Parker WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1103 21076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kami Andrews User:Gene93k 17:57, 28 October 2012 (UTC) delete Award and nominations come up short for . Fails GNG without non-trivial coverage by multiple reliable sources. Only non-trivial GNews hit at ''Wired'' is not completely independent of the subject. Google Book hits are passing mentions Deletion of Kami Andrews WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1104 17303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Occupy Marines (2nd nomination) User:TheRico152 04:30, 13 December 2011 (UTC) keep although i disagree with the occupy movement, it seems to me that this article meets the |GNG standards and should be kept Deletion of Occupy Marines (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1105 15219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of the world User:Spirit 16:01, 1 April 2016 (UTC) delete for failing . Every source available on this subject was created by an individual on the world who was living at some point in history. As no sources independent of this subject can be found, the only proper outcome is deletion Deletion of History of the world WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1106 20482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sparhawk User:Lankiveil 08:04, 10 March 2014 (UTC) comment I've had a look at the sources provided, and except for Bleiler which I don't have easy access to, none of them describe the character of Sparhawk (as opposed to the Elenium trilogy itself) in any great detail. One is also not independent, being the website of Eddings' publisher. I am more convinced now that this does not meet the Deletion of Sparhawk WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1107 6336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judy Wood User:Leuko 16:32, 15 April 2007 (UTC) delete non-notable bio, no Deletion of Judy Wood WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1108 20573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burgess McCranie User:MelanieN 02:14, 2 March 2015 (UTC) delete He is NOT notable per , since he was not mayor of a city of regional prominence; Bossier City isn't even the parish (county) seat. His subsequent offices are also non-notable. And population numbers are irrelevant; despite assertions that 50,000 or 100,000 or whatever population makes a mayor automatically notable, no such number has ever achieved consensus. It doesn't matter if some other mayors of some other cities have articles; is not a valid argument. He also fails for lack of significant coverage Deletion of Burgess McCranie WP:POLITICIAN||WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1109 18724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Đulijano Camaj User:Walls 18:22, 14 June 2013 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Đulijano Camaj WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1110 19192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rion Causey User:Nick 08:07, 5 January 2014 (UTC) delete No clear indications of notability, and applies Deletion of Rion Causey WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
1111 17124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deep Trouble (Goosebumps episode) User:The 11:00, 1 August 2020 (UTC) delete since subject fails Deletion of Deep Trouble (Goosebumps episode) WP:NTV Wikipedia:Notability 77
1112 21800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Bayou, Mississippi User:Idunnox3 23:06, 26 August 2021 (UTC) delete it doesn't meet Deletion of Black Bayou, Mississippi WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
1113 16920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled My Chemical Romance Album User:JohnCD 09:36, 31 May 2009 (UTC) delete """per and . When will they learn that if all you can say is """"''hasent been given much detail''"""", it is too soon for an article""" Deletion of Untitled My Chemical Romance Album WP:NALBUMS||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:Notability 77
1114 18369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nikul Desai User:Adamant1 08:18, 10 August 2020 (UTC) delete the two sources in the article don't seem to work for notability and I couldn't find anything about him when I did a search for his name. So, the article fails both and GNG Deletion of Nikul Desai WP:FILMMAKER Wikipedia:Notability 77
1115 8747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Nine Network slogans User:SharkxFanSJ 01:52, 13 July 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of Nine Network slogans WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1116 21670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SALERO User:Gavin 12:02, 28 August 2007 (UTC) delete as fails notability criteria . Independent evidence of notability to come Deletion of SALERO WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1117 9627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New York International Independent Film and Video Festival User:MichaelQSchmidt 19:53, 7 December 2008 (UTC) keep The NYIIFF has been around for 15 years and has received LOTS of extensive and in-depth coverage in reliable sources that easily exceed / requirements. http://articles.latimes.com/keyword/new-york-international-independent-film-and-video-festival Los Angeles Times, http://www.newyorkcool.com/archives/2007/November/film_Video.htm New York Cool, http://lastheplace.com/2007/09/22/the-new-york-international-independent-film-and-video-festival-returns-to-los-angeles/ LA's the Place, http://www.lasplash.com/publish/Film_106/The_New_York_International_Independent_Film_Video_Festival.php LA Splash, http://www.showbusinessweekly.com/archive/421/Film_NYCInter.shtml Show Business Weekly, http://www.princess.com/news/article.jsp?newsArticleId=na963 Princess.com, http://www.fest21.com/en/node/16646 Fest 21, http://www.nypress.com/article-3630-new-york-international-independent-film-and-video-festival-the-peoples-poetry-gathering-cutthroats-9-play-cbgb-ned-does-soho.html New York Press, etc Deletion of New York International Independent Film and Video Festival WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1118 18864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allison Kilkenny User:Panyd 17:33, 30 October 2010 (UTC) delete No significant coverage of the person appears to exist, in fact nothing seems to exist except for a few articles talking about her boyfriend. Fails and Wikipedia:Notability_(people)#Creative_professionals|this Deletion of Allison Kilkenny WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1119 7850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/T'ien Ti Tao Ch'uan-shu P'ai User:Papaursa 18:12, 11 February 2017 (UTC) delete My search found no significant independent coverage of this style and the article doesn't provide any. Therefore, it appears that is not met. There's also nothing to show it meets any of the notability criteria at Deletion of T'ien Ti Tao Ch'uan-shu P'ai WP:GNG||WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1120 622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Mcleod user:Alf_photoman 20:14, 13 March 2007 (UTC) delete no matter whether hoax or not, fails , and probably Deletion of Paul Mcleod WP:A||WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Attribution 108
1121 18195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mr Fuddlesticks User:Lagrange613 17:22, 27 December 2011 (UTC) delete as not a |notable event. Its geographical scope is limited to Renton, Washington, a town of 90,000. Coverage doesn't seem to have lasted much beyond the initial news cycle. It may be too soon to judge its eventual impact, but for now it's had little. Happy to revisit without prejudice at |deletion review if more comes of this Deletion of Mr Fuddlesticks WP:EVENT||WP:DR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1122 19877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of flags by number of colors (2nd nomination) [[User talk:198.84.253.202|talk]]) 02:42, 15 May 2018 (UTC) delete """since |WP isn't a case study and the information otherwise falls per . Doncram above might think that they are upholding policy by saying everybody is """"not liking it"""", but WP works by consensus, not by moot calls to """"but the other side's arguments aren't right""""... Special:Contributions/198.84.253.202|198.84.253.202""" Deletion of List of flags by number of colors (2nd nomination) WP:NOTCASE||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1123 7632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asher's Energy-Mass Relation [[User: ChromaNebula|ChromaNebula]] [[User talk: ChromaNebula|(talk)]] 15:47, 9 July 2012 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a blog, a webhost, or a publisher of essays and/or original thought (see Deletion of Asher's Energy-Mass Relation WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1124 17478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of gameboy advance colors [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 19:24, 16 March 2009 (UTC) delete lack of |verifiability. I cannot find, even via reliable primary sources like nintendo.com, anything establishing what colors the GBA came in. (Note: I am very well aware that the GBA, in which I went through a couple when I owned one, was sold in many colors, but that has to be ''shown Deletion of List of gameboy advance colors WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1125 19272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coastliner 700 User:Alpha 19:59, 8 February 2012 (UTC) keep Per Alzarian16, the subject has received |significant coverage in |reliable third party sources and meets the |notability guidelines Deletion of Coastliner 700 WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1126 93 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Plotz User:Corpx 09:20, 1 February 2008 (UTC) delete per lack of |significant coverage from |independent sources and I dont think the other stuff is enough for notability Deletion of Richard Plotz WP:NOTE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1127 18721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amir Aldaraji User:GiantSnowman 10:21, 25 November 2019 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Amir Aldaraji WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1128 486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Public Information Research (2nd nomination) User:Hut 10:43, 17 July 2008 (UTC) delete no substantial coverage in third-party reliable sources, as demonstrated above. Fails abd Deletion of Public Information Research (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1129 19852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coromandel Cricket Club User:Spaceman7Spiff 05:56, 12 July 2009 (UTC) keep as a really old and surviving club as noted on an independent |reliable source - http://www.mitchamcouncil.sa.gov.au/webdata/resources/files/9_December_2008_Corporate_and_Community_Services_Committee_Agenda.pdf local govt website. Aussie newspapers don't have online archives from even the 1990s, so it's going to be difficult to get other online sources Deletion of Coromandel Cricket Club WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1130 5071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lijeesh User:Akhiljaxxn 14:34, 30 July 2020 (UTC) delete per nom, subject fails and Deletion of Lijeesh WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1131 6292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Test seat User:Snotbot 19:17, 10 April 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 April 10 Deletion of Test seat WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1132 4666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giant (Clash of Clans) User:Gamingforfun365 06:24, 4 December 2016 (UTC) delete they all fail and otability Deletion of Giant (Clash of Clans) WP:GAMEGUIDE||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1133 15239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tranche (software) User:J 03:01, 31 July 2007 (UTC) keep Well referenced, multiple external links. Though not necessarily |notable, it is |verifiable Deletion of Tranche (software) WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
1134 14543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacob Grady User:Kinu 07:36, 27 August 2010 (UTC) delete does not appear to meet . No , just a couple of bios that indicate he exists, but nothing about why he is notable Deletion of Jacob Grady WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1135 17369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of EINECS substances 200-xxx-x User:Snottywong 23:35, 19 December 2011 (UTC) delete I don't know much about the subject, but it does seem to be |a complete exposition of all possible details. A gargantuan, poorly-formatted, redlink-laden table of every chemical compound known to mankind is not helpful Deletion of List of EINECS substances 200-xxx-x WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1136 19532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transilvane User:Shooterwalker 03:58, 31 August 2020 (UTC) delete as failing to meet the due to a lack of significant coverage Deletion of Transilvane WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1137 7353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seth Goldstein User:Triptothecottage 12:47, 9 July 2017 (UTC) keep Article needs significant trimming to cut out PR, but Wikipedia:AfD is not cleanup|AfD is not cleanup, and the https://www.forbes.com/sites/natalierobehmed/2012/06/20/how-to-be-a-practical-dreamer-lessons-from-turntables-seth-goldstein/2/#6b61259c3230 Forbes and https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB863705277956136000 WSJ articles in particular go a long way to demonstrating the subject meets Deletion of Seth Goldstein WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1138 800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert D. Sundby User:Devonian 12:39, 7 October 2020 (UTC) keep he passes , making the failure of irrelevant Deletion of Robert D. Sundby WP:GNG||WP:JUDGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1139 20841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Love, Hate, and Then There's You User:Esradekan 21:59, 8 October 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per #Albums.2C_singles_and_songs|#Albums & Deletion of Love, Hate, and Then There's You WP:MUSIC||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1140 20318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Old Pueblo Firefighters Association User:Wisdom89 20:06, 17 April 2008 (UTC) keep Well, there is this http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tab=wn&q=%22Old+Pueblo+Firefighters+Association%22 and this http://www.azstarnet.com/sn/printDS/164869. I'm sure that the Arizona Star is a |reliable source Deletion of Old Pueblo Firefighters Association WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1141 11445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melouky User:SamHolt6 20:27, 25 February 2018 (UTC) delete Confectionery supplier that does not meet criteria for notability. Mentions in regional sources are not adequate Deletion of Melouky WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1142 5349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeflateGate User:Epicgenius 18:40, 25 January 2015 (UTC) keep This is covered in numerous reliable sources. While there have been multiple underinflated balls used in football games over the years, this one is quite significantly covered. It may be deleted later if this event has no significant impact in the future, though, per and Deletion of DeflateGate WP:NOTNEWS||WP:EVENT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1143 21805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RAW Pressery User:Fitindia 17:36, 2 June 2018 (UTC) delete fails GNG and Deletion of RAW Pressery WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1144 18614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victoria Beltran User:Animalparty 22:06, 1 February 2017 (UTC) delete not meeting . We don't give encyclopedia articles to extras or actors in non-notable films. Subject's personal life appears to have gained some fleeting news coverage, but focusing on that alone would be a violation Deletion of Victoria Beltran WP:NACTOR||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1145 13569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Clendening User:Lubbad85 15:01, 26 March 2019 (UTC) keep Meets . Subject is notable Deletion of Anna Clendening WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1146 6005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Not The Tommy Boyd Show User:Joe 18:02, 1 May 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |podcast Deletion of Not The Tommy Boyd Show WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1147 16656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Strano User:Joe 14:37, 30 August 2016 (UTC) keep Strano holds a named chair at MIT and therefore should be a snow keep per #C5. The article also lists a number of awards which would probably meet #C2 Deletion of Michael Strano WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1148 718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seafood Network User:RGTraynor 16:53, 20 March 2007 (UTC) delete This near-to-spurious vanity article is about a website that hasn't seemingly been updated in over a year, according to its main page. There are '''zero''' hits on Australian Google for it, if you leave out its own server http://www.google.com.au/search?as_q=&hl=en&num=10&btnG=Google+Search&as_epq=SeaFood+Network&as_oq=&as_eq=&lr=&as_ft=i&as_filetype=&as_qdr=all&as_occt=any&as_dt=i&as_sitesearch=www.sfgaming.my-php.net&as_rights=&safe=images. Fails , NN, and probably as well. Nice try, guys Deletion of Seafood Network WP:ATT||WP:BULLSHIT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
1149 14299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/London Buses route 278 (2nd nomination) User:NemesisAT 19:56, 22 July 2021 (UTC) keep """Between a https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=2fsKBAAAQBAJ&newbks=0&printsec=frontcover&pg=PA278&dq=London+Buses+route+278&hl=en&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=London%20Buses%20route%20278&f=false book source, a https://www.hillingdontimes.co.uk/news/18092680.new-bus-service-links-ruislip-heathrow/ newspaper article dedicated to the route, and https://www.harrowtimes.co.uk/news/18092493.new-bus-services-now-running-harrow-brent/ another newspaper article which discusses the route, I feel has been met for the subject of bus routes in London using number 278. While redirection is a reasonable , I feel this would not improve Wikipedia as List of bus routes in London does not contain any details. This page has ample content, which would be lost were it redirected. This goes against , which states """"as long as any of the facts or ideas added to an article would belong in the """"finished"""" article, they should be retained if they meet the three article content retention policies: Neutral point of view (which does not mean no point of view), Verifiability, and No original research""" Deletion of London Buses route 278 (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:ATD||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1150 9431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Electric Century (2nd nomination) User:Rpclod 03:35, 17 July 2015 (UTC) delete Does not meet criteria. Perhaps |too soon Deletion of Electric Century (2nd nomination) WP:BAND||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
1151 11699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The motivational disorder User:Versus22 00:13, 5 March 2009 (UTC) delete No sources from offical sites, fails , , and possibly Deletion of The motivational disorder WP:N||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1152 9867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicholas Buda User:Vejvančický 07:30, 17 March 2010 (UTC) delete The following links suggest that Nicholas Buda participates in the cultural life of Romanian community in New York: http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:K6QlGXQnz7YJ:www.nymagazin.com/pdf/nr637_Cultural_1.pdf+%22Nicholas+Buda%22+-wikipedia&hl=cs&gl=cz&pid=bl&srcid=ADGEESjKz5avLqUk71_Ds5qwfEfHC_YkUwJ75fUjEyjFhOmULG33AuiR0uczz-IdujPjmGYjGZaNeiIaQlfa1wRLZUrmUZKAgCbf4la05Ra2GhTLgHSYIq8lP8Qw2RMBrC3RZdPJTb19&sig=AHIEtbRIRoCW_QsTDKVqwdpsN-z8SvKy-A Eveniment Literar la New York, http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:g3GWODaQJfYJ:www.nymagazin.com/pdf/nr650_Cultural_Nicholas_Buda.pdf+%22Nicholas+Buda%22+-wikipedia&hl=cs&gl=cz&sig=AHIEtbS3oP_cNnVu7yl-VgZSTaVTrLRN3Q New York Magazin, http://reteaualiterara.ning.com/profiles/profile/show?id=NicholasBuda&fbc_channel=1 reteaua literara. However, the coverage is insufficient to pass the |notability requirements for authors. WorldCat and G-Books has no entries for his works, and I can't find any independent reviews of his work published by reliable websites or journals Deletion of Nicholas Buda WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1153 11678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sun-Kyung Cho [[User talk:Yanksox|Yanksox]] 14:33, 22 April 2007 (UTC) delete Totally unnecessary and most certainly it's mere prescence (unless she does something notable on her own) violates Deletion of Sun-Kyung Cho WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1154 17882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 Nature Air Cessna 208 Caravan crash User:Petebutt 19:09, 4 January 2018 (UTC) delete """Maybe the """"We must have an article for every bump and scratch"""" crowd will finally get the picture! , , """ Deletion of 2017 Nature Air Cessna 208 Caravan crash WP:NOTNEWS||WP:GNG||WP:RUNOFTHEMILL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1155 17786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Wakefield User:Gene93k 15:50, 24 July 2010 (UTC) comment The subject of the article is a U.S. Congressman (who easily passes ). Is this nomination a mistake Deletion of James Wakefield WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1156 20120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Clark (Canadian politician) User:Mccapra 21:36, 15 August 2021 (UTC) keep passes as a member of parliament Deletion of Michael Clark (Canadian politician) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1157 21158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coretrust Capital Partners User:MER 15:59, 9 August 2019 (UTC) delete as likely |paid-for spam. I've blocked the creator for this Deletion of Coretrust Capital Partners WP:UPE Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
1158 19172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Wilkinson User:Blaxthos 12:14, 6 October 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Matt Wilkinson WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1159 10282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yakub Abahanov [[User_talk:Bradv|BradV]] 17:58, 3 April 2008 (UTC) delete Keep. Article needs cleanup, but it is not beyond hope. Flagged for |rescue Deletion of Yakub Abahanov WP:ARS Wikipedia:Article Rescue Squadron 98
1160 7262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Nwokeji User:ChrisTheDude 14:04, 5 June 2008 (UTC) delete fails . Quite a lot of external links but all bar one seem to be non-independent, non-reliable or non-in-depth Deletion of Mark Nwokeji WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1161 7825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ezra A. Bowen User:Interference 06:50, 25 April 2015 (UTC) keep As I mentioned on Bobbertybob's page, it falls under Deletion of Ezra A. Bowen WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1162 2907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fotolia (2nd nomination) User:SamHolt6 15:54, 8 September 2017 (UTC) delete fails and is probably in violation of . Per nom, poorly sourced Deletion of Fotolia (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1163 8081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Gerald Lorge User:IJBall 15:36, 22 July 2015 (UTC) delete Fails #3 Deletion of Robert Gerald Lorge WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1164 20577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samantha Power (actress) User:Minimac 19:27, 24 June 2011 (UTC) delete """This is quite a difficult one to call, because she has made a role in at least one notable production. According to statement 1 in , an actor needs to have """"had significant roles in multiple notable films, television shows, stage performances, or other productions."""" One of the notable productions she took part in was Little Britain where she played as Jane Evans, and yet I took a look at the List of Little Britain characters and that character isn't even listed on there, which in my opinion Jane Evans isn't a very important character, and thus meaning this was only a minor role. There's only one significant role of a character that she played, and that was Debbie Rossi in The Cup (TV series|The Cup, but still, one significant role isn't good enough to pass """ Deletion of Samantha Power (actress) WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1165 38 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/İstanbul Trip """Kullanıcı:lazⓛⓐⓩ""" 13.23, 10 Mayıs 2021 (UTC) delete Ne genel, ne de #Müzisyen ve müzik grubu kriterleri|müzik grupları için kayda değerlik kriterlerini karşılıyor İstanbul Gezisinin silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
1166 77 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Taşkın Tuna """Kullanıcı:can'''can'''""" 15.42, 2 Haziran 2020 (UTC) keep Görebildiğim kadarıyla kriterlerini karşılıyor. Hakkında bağımsız ve güvenilir denebilecek kaynaklar da bulunuyor. --Kullanıcı mesaj:Justinianus|'''justinianus Taşkın Tuna'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
1167 2346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World Patent Marketing User:Smartse 12:37, 24 March 2021 (UTC) keep since no policy based argument is made for deletion. is clearly met per the references I'd included in https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=World_Patent_Marketing&oldid=867771855 this version Deletion of World Patent Marketing WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1168 13754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Malaysia footballers born outside Malaysia User:Lugnuts 06:58, 26 August 2021 (UTC) keep """per #1 of - """"...or fails to advance any argument for deletion""" Deletion of List of Malaysia footballers born outside Malaysia WP:SKCRIT Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
1169 5628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of schools in Jamaica (2nd nomination) User:Ajf773 08:28, 16 October 2017 (UTC) delete per with no prejudice to re-create. The list as it is now is long and indiscriminate (and difficult to read). The article would be better suited to be a list of sub-lists broken down by region Deletion of List of schools in Jamaica (2nd nomination) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
1170 12398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bethel Mission School User:Cutest 16:56, 3 August 2014 (UTC) keep as per . I will be amazed to see a school which is far way from Internet will advertise on Wikipedia Deletion of Bethel Mission School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1171 1107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Berg publishers User:EconomistBR 21:11, 25 May 2008 (UTC) delete 2 days have passed and no independent, reliable sources were found, delete per . If reliable sources confirming notability are found just recreate this article Deletion of Berg publishers WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1172 14578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Children's Philanthropy Center User:Bwilkins 12:36, 7 December 2011 (UTC) delete Might be a great cause, but failes as a project Deletion of Children's Philanthropy Center WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1173 16715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colonization of Pluto User:Dennisthe2 02:37, 10 April 2007 (UTC) delete as and fantastical |crystalballery Deletion of Colonization of Pluto WP:BOLLOCKS||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
1174 16150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of film spoofs in Mad (2nd nomination) User:Mzilikazi1939 18:21, 15 February 2017 (UTC) keep Passes as ably demonstrated by Deletion of List of film spoofs in Mad (2nd nomination) WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1175 2857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Heenan User:GiantSnowman 21:22, 7 October 2009 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Sam Heenan WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1176 17954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laura Murray User:APerson 13:44, 13 April 2015 (UTC) delete Fails both |GNG and the relevant notability guidelines Deletion of Laura Murray WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1177 17211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dramatic Prairie Dog User:Fuhghettaboutit 01:49, 7 July 2007 (UTC) delete """and wait for reliable sources to catch up. I think this may ''become'' notable, i.e. achieve significant coverage in reliable sources, in a few months, similar to craze over the Numa Numa dance/video, but |notability in the future, even if likely, is not notability now. Has a massive web presence: 400,000+ web hits under correct name, and over 2 million under more popular misnomer, """"dramatic chipmunk"""". Alexa rank doesn't tell the story at all because its main agar|agar dishes are youtube and collegehumor, not the eponymous website. I was emailed the link a few days ago and personally find it hysterical—especially the Kill Bill and Darth Vader takeoffs. Some minor news hits for both names http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&safe=off&q=%22Dramatic%20Chipmunk%22&btnG=Search&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&um=1&sa=N&tab=wn but some of them are blogs and none appear to provide significant coverage""" Deletion of Dramatic Prairie Dog WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1178 15058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Shea User:Dolovis 16:34, 10 August 2014 (UTC) keep Nomination fails . This actor meets criteria #1 of (see http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0790260/?ref_=nv_sr_1 IMDB listing for list of numerous acting credits Deletion of Christopher Shea WP:BEFORE||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1179 11342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hindu Taliban User:Wikiality123 10:51, 11 November 2008 (UTC) comment Although I don't see much of original research, wondering if this meets otability|the notability norms Deletion of Hindu Taliban WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1180 7369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jihadi John User:ianmacm 10:15, 24 August 2014 (UTC) comment """They should not made more important than they are, just brutal killers"""" is basically an argument""" Deletion of Jihadi John WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1181 6461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Speed Gamers User:Randomran 18:56, 6 May 2009 (UTC) delete fails . A one line mention in The Escapist isn't enough independent information to |verify a significant part of this article Deletion of The Speed Gamers WP:WEB||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
1182 1813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Illusive Entertainment User:Tarret 23:30, 18 September 2006 (UTC) delete Non-notable and fails Deletion of Illusive Entertainment WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1183 14973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheila (Ugly Betty) User:Snottywong 00:00, 13 July 2010 (UTC) delete No |reliable sources. And good luck changing the behavior of the inclusionists. I Deletion of Sheila (Ugly Betty) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1184 10670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ripple Music User:HighKing 12:49, 19 January 2021 (UTC) comment """The applicable guideline is and not . A lot of the accounts posting to Keep don't appear to understand the criteria for establishing notability for companies or are quoting from other guidelines which have different standards and are not applicable for companies. Here's a summary to help. The criteria for establishing notability for companies/organizations is and applies a stricter interpretation of requirements than for other topics. In short, requires multiple sources (at least two) of |significant coverage with |in-depth information *on the company* and (this bit is important!) containing |""""Independent Content"""". """"Independent content"""", in order to count towards establishing notability, must include ''original and independent opinion, analysis, investigation, and fact checking that are clearly attributable to a source unaffiliated to the subject''. That means, nothing that relies on company information or announcements or interviews, etc. Also nothing where there is """"inherited"""" notability so the inference that they have signed notable acts only points to the notability of the act, not of the company that signed them. None of the references in the article meet the criteria and having searched I am unable to locate any references that meet the criteria. If some of the Keep !voters can produce a couple of good references that they are sure meets and , post them here""" Deletion of Ripple Music WP:NCORP||WP:MUSIC||WP:NCORP||WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:ORGIND||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
1185 6961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Para Todas las Putas Celosas User:B 03:47, 11 July 2008 (UTC) merge per Fabrictramp. Without nontrivial coverage by |reliable sources, the unreleased demo cannot sustain its own Wikipedia article Deletion of Para Todas las Putas Celosas WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1186 13727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Gibbs User:Jeepday 19:02, 23 February 2021 (UTC) keep """I did a google book search on {""""Kevin Gibbs Google Suggest"""" -wikipedia} and found several hits. He looks to meet on just that""" Deletion of Kevin Gibbs WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1187 7251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DaVinci (software) User:Walter 22:58, 24 June 2013 (UTC) delete There do seem to be sources, they just don't appear to be reliable sources: blogs, forums, etc. This may be a case of Deletion of DaVinci (software) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1188 11670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Ogle User:Bearian 21:47, 10 October 2012 (UTC) delete fails not only GNG but Deletion of Thomas Ogle WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
1189 21276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maalan Narayanan User:Brycehughes 11:11, 9 June 2021 (UTC) keep Per . He is (or at least was) the editor of a Puthiya Thalaimurai|major magazine (per the https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/such-tactics-wont-stop-us-says-puthiya-thalaimurai/article6987862.ece second source) and appears to be widely cited (e.g. https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/fighting-a-war-with-his-back-to-the-wall/article20945919.ece, https://www.financialexpress.com/india-news/tamil-nadu-elections-2021-can-mk-stalin-finally-break-away-from-karunanidhis-shadow/2227274/, https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/sasikala-to-be-released-from-jail-on-jan-27-palaniswami-rules-out-her-return-101611074123315.html) by his peers Deletion of Maalan Narayanan WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
1190 14735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fabrice Valcin User:Jogurney 15:24, 16 January 2019 (UTC) delete article about amateur footballer who once scored http://www.leparisien.fr/espace-premium/sports/bobigny-prolonge-le-plaisir-17-11-2014-4297627.php two goals as his club, Bobigny, reached the 8th round of the Coupe de France for the first time. That Le Parisien article might qualify as non-routine coverage, but I don't see anything else that suggests the article could satisfy , e.g.,, he isn't even mentioned in Le Parisien's http://www.leparisien.fr/espace-premium/sports/on-reve-du-psg-et-de-zlatan-08-12-2014-4355843.php report on the club's 8th round win or http://www.leparisien.fr/sports/foot-coupe-de-france-l-aventure-de-bobigny-s-arrete-face-a-evian-03-01-2015-4416839.php report or 0–3 loss in the 1/32-final Deletion of Fabrice Valcin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1191 13467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Revolve (John Newman album) User:Azealia911 18:08, 28 July 2015 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Revolve (John Newman album) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1192 13257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Smith (murderer) [[User talk:Crotalus horridus|*** Crotalus ***]] 21:27, 8 September 2009 (UTC) delete mdash; no evidence of substantial notability that goes beyond . We can't write a comprehensive biography of this person if all we know about him is that he committed a murder while on parole for another criminal offense. Clear case of Deletion of Michael Smith (murderer) WP:NOTNEWS||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1193 6234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhianna Pratchett (2nd nomination) [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 01:58, 6 May 2009 (UTC) keep per the above. Please do your homework |before proposing deletion Deletion of Rhianna Pratchett (2nd nomination) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1194 3153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herbert Harrison Mercer User:MelanieN 21:27, 30 May 2016 (UTC) delete Absolutely nothing is |verified. In particular, the claim that he was involved in the creation of the flag of the Republic of Brazil is contradicted by our article Flag of Brazil Deletion of Herbert Harrison Mercer WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1195 9125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MFC 1 User:CaSJer 16:57, 7 March 2013 (UTC) delete fails since the event isn't held by a top league, doesn't have enough general non-routine coverage to pass Deletion of MFC 1 WP:SPORTSEVENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1196 14387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haredistan User:Metropolitan90 02:38, 7 November 2010 (UTC) delete This term is a |neologism used in a single column by a single author. It's not the name of an actual place or the name of a place that anyone is calling for the creation of Deletion of Haredistan WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
1197 2144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of character actors User:SlamDiego 08:29, 6 September 2008 (UTC) delete A '''''noble''''' thought, but , just as nominator says. If the list is restricted to ''notable'' actors, then a ''Category'' is the correct way of supporting the list Deletion of List of character actors WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
1198 11836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ingrid Detter de Frankopan User:XOR 15:24, 29 May 2019 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Ingrid Detter de Frankopan WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
1199 2074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tough Love: Controversial Methods for the Rehabilitation of Problem Children User:Coredesat 02:24, 3 July 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of Tough Love: Controversial Methods for the Rehabilitation of Problem Children WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1200 16547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American-led intervention in Iraq User:Acetotyce 13:09, 30 September 2014 (UTC) keep This article was proposed to be merged, then CSD'd and now an AFd. {{U|DocumentError}} dragged me to Ani and false accusations of |Canvassing. I made this article to help slim down the parent article which covers both conflicts. Not bypass Full protection Deletion of American-led intervention in Iraq WP:CANVASS Wikipedia:Canvassing 93
1201 12724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Catholic street slang User:Caufman 16:42, 31 October 2005 (UTC) comment I am the one who tagged the article as . Regarding , please see Talk:Catholic street slang for principle author's claims to such; note also that, AFAICT, the alleged source has not yet been properly provided 3 weeks after requesting it; though I have not checked Wikisource, I doubt Deletion of Catholic street slang WP:NOR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
1202 9090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Biochemic tissue salt User:Bearian 20:44, 1 July 2015 (UTC) delete Homeopathy is notable per . This is fringey even for that field of alternative medicine Deletion of Biochemic tissue salt WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
1203 13051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MediaINFO User:Ihcoyc 15:24, 11 March 2011 (UTC) delete """both. MediaINFO says it is ''a web publishing software for digitized content''. In other words, a webpage design or """"content management"""" utility. Geneza is ''a privately held software vendor specialising in software solutions for Libraries and Publishers'', the maker of MediaINFO. I'm afraid you get penalized -50 notability points for """"software solutions"""".The question is whether this particular product has any particular claim to |significant effects on history, culture, and technology; and this article makes no claim for that kind of significance. As such it is |just one of many such packages, with no particular claim to groundbreaking significance.Perceptions of bias are largely in the eyes of the beholder. Now, moronic Facebook games have become cultural touchstones, symbols of the online culture of Facebook, and as such significance is easily shown. When people 100 years from now ask what online life was like in the early 21st century, the topic of Farmville probably will come up. I don't see a US-centric bias in software articles; what I see instead is an ocean of trivial tech-cruft, much of it obvious spam, where every bit player thinks that mention in a Top 100 list or a petty trade award confers historic significance. There also is a large and obvious bias in favor of minor open-source and free software projects. There are altogether too many articles on bit players in crowded software fields. And this software looks very niche, and it does the same thing that many other software packages do""" Deletion of MediaINFO WP:CORP||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1204 3912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steg steganography software User:Ohnoitsjamie 14:49, 20 March 2018 (UTC) delete No evidence that this meet notability guidelines Deletion of Steg steganography software WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1205 4049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bloginity User:Jujutacular 17:15, 20 January 2011 (UTC) delete I have failed to find significant coverage of the company or website from |reliable sources. All of the coverage currently referenced in the article seems to only mention it in passing. It therefore fails the |general notability guidelines Deletion of Bloginity WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1206 10081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kingsbury (band) User:Michig 06:59, 3 October 2015 (UTC) keep Several examples of coverage found. Could do with more. http://articles.orlandosentinel.com/2007-01-19/entertainment/ABBOTT19_1_kingsbury-great-compromise-band Orlando Sentinel, http://articles.orlandosentinel.com/2008-10-24/entertainment/abbott24_1_antolick-band-music-industry Orlando Sentinel, http://www.richmond.com/entertainment/article_6bfc0005-9912-57b4-8938-f9cb07c33704.html Richmond Times-Dispatch, http://www.orlandoweekly.com/orlando/keeping-to-themselves/Content?oid=2257548 Orlando Weekly, http://worcestermag.com/2007/09/20/groupie-09-20-07/4063 Worcester Magazine, plus a couple of others that may not pass : http://thelantern.com/2005/08/kingsbury-darkens-pop-rock/, http://www.lostatsea.net/review.phtml?id=1652023504178e7ceafc8e Deletion of Kingsbury (band) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1207 5891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jaiku.com User:72 03:50, 6 May 2007 (UTC) comment The #Criteria|criteria for notability (web) is very simple ...1. The content itself has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself.No one has provided any ''non-trivial published works'' that satisfy this criteria, and |blogs are not acceptable as reliable sources. &mdash Deletion of Jaiku.com WP:WEB||WP:SPS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1208 3971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SHINE Medical Technologies User:JzG 10:19, 24 July 2015 (UTC) merge per DGG's comment. This is a Deletion of SHINE Medical Technologies WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1209 3620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tomoko Nishimura User:Calathan 04:37, 27 September 2010 (UTC) comment I'm not sure if she technically meets #3 under uthor, but I would think creating a work that has been adapted into a TV series (and a relatively long one, at 70+ episodes and still airing) would be of equivalent notability to what it listed there. Certainly, creating a work that was adapted into a TV series seems more notable to me than creating a work that got a couple reviews in publications Deletion of Tomoko Nishimura WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
1210 20362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Desenrascanço User:Husond 21:29, 21 November 2006 (UTC) delete Although it's a widely known slang word in Portugal, this doesn't merit an article on the English Wikipedia (not even on the Portuguese Wikipedia would this survive). Besides, it's just a blatant |original research, unsourced/unverifiable and complete Deletion of Desenrascanço WP:NOR||WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:No original research 65
1211 20287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salvation, Texas [[User talk:172.131.15.227|talk]]) 13:39, 16 May 2010 (UTC) keep per passing |GNG by having |reliable, independent sources. --Special:Contributions/172.131.15.227|172.131.15.227 Deletion of Salvation, Texas WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1212 6622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaarei Tefillah User:Griswaldo 12:07, 24 June 2011 (UTC) comment """What makes this particular synagogue """"important"""" as Jayjg asserts and why is is the answer to that question not explicated in the entry? makes it clear that the fact that many of the members are notable does not cut it. There is mention of reliable sources above, and indeed they are cited in the entry, but despite several such sources there is next to no information in the entry. It is hard to believe that any of these sources have more than trivial or passing mention of the congregation""" Deletion of Shaarei Tefillah WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1213 2503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aleksandra Dranka User:Dirtlawyer1 20:39, 24 November 2015 (UTC) merge Based on current article, I can see no particular grounds for here. Inclusion in existing list should suffice. Support arguments made by Deletion of Aleksandra Dranka WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1214 11731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B. Rusty Lang User:Gordonofcartoon 14:38, 14 December 2007 (UTC) delete per and . Note the |conflict of interest: the creator is {{userlinks|Dr. B. R. Lang Deletion of B. Rusty Lang WP:SOAP||WP:COATRACK||WP:COI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1215 7605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ginny Aiken User:Thsmi002 04:32, 29 September 2018 (UTC) keep per based on reviews of her works Deletion of Ginny Aiken WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1216 12824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Hamilton College Spectator User:SanAnMan 19:18, 18 April 2016 (UTC) delete and '''Merge''' into Hamilton College (New York), doesn't meet on its own, but useful to the other article Deletion of The Hamilton College Spectator WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1217 2217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albert Crites User:Infrangible 02:20, 30 December 2006 (UTC) delete complete #G1|nonsense Deletion of Albert Crites WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1218 9093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul G. Baker user:Andrew 18:41, 23 January 2021 (UTC) keep """A warship was named after him which is a """"''significant award or honor'' and so passes """ Deletion of Paul G. Baker WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1219 20892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Justin Capră (2nd nomination) User:Раціональне 01:02, 11 February 2015 (UTC) delete per . While a few (credulous) RS seem to exist (the bulk of the references are clones), the article is an irredeemable mass of hoax/fringe nonsense at best and loony old-time communist propaganda at worst. There's no evidence this person made anything Deletion of Justin Capră (2nd nomination) WP:DYNAMITE Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
1220 6933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PNC Australia User:Shirahadasha 01:13, 24 January 2007 (UTC) delete absent sources. Need |sources to meet the requirements of and Deletion of PNC Australia WP:RS||WP:V||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1221 999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anonymous Boy User:Otr500 02:15, 18 November 2020 (UTC) delete """Just not otability (people)|notable. According to present sources, searching, and the two provided above the subject does not pass . If we have to consider a name drop from a picture that includes 98 other people (nytimes) or passing mention, as a """"hint"""" of possible notability, that is stretching things. A good indication of failing notability guidelines would be when a penname is predictably difficult to find in a search. Another indicator would be when information is """"notoriously smallpress and offline"""". I opened a lot of tabs trying to verify the unsourced content of the """"Comics and Artistic Work"""" and the short story """"Green Pubes"""" (presented as being """"the first animated queercore movie""""), other than through IMDb. Print work on pins and tee shirts (artist) did return needed sources. As a |BLP there are some demands that sourcing should be better""" Deletion of Anonymous Boy WP:N||WP:ARTIST||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1222 16368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Jo Buttafuoco (2nd nomination) [[User talk:Usernamekiran|'''(talk)''']] 20:31, 31 August 2017 (UTC) keep """Even though she has been subject of """"passing mention"""" in a lot of sources, in a lot of other sources she has received |significant coverage. Being the gunshot victim, and author excludes her from one event; even if we consider the motivational speaker as non notable/trivial. As another editor stated above, she has been receiving coverage since almost 25 years (for some reason or another). Also, she is attractive, and has a funny last name lol (just kidding). —usernamekiran""" Deletion of Mary Jo Buttafuoco (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
1223 7633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fred Petrovsky User:This NONE delete as |non-notable vanity biography. &mdash Deletion of Fred Petrovsky WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1224 19461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdullah Assem User:LaMona 03:31, 14 December 2014 (UTC) delete It feels generous to give this a . The article was self-created (user:Abdullahasem), and has had formatting but no content added since creation Deletion of Abdullah Assem WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1225 15917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Herzog User:John 20:03, 29 March 2020 (UTC) delete fails , fails GNG (per depth of coverage). No sense in explaining further as Bearcat covered it very well Deletion of Jonathan Herzog WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1226 14406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global Allergy Network User:Drm310 20:26, 12 September 2012 (UTC) delete """fails Wikipedia:Notability (organizations and companies) and Wikipedia:Verifiability. Arguments for keeping are just """"|it contains valuable information"""". Normally I would suggest |userfication but if the editors are in a conflict of interest, then no""" Deletion of Global Allergy Network WP:VALINFO||WP:UFY Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1227 8774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A billion ernies User:Doc 21:46, 7 November 2009 (UTC) delete artist fails . Article never asserts notability for subject and none of the three sources are |reliable ones Deletion of A billion ernies WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1228 12470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Mott User:Malcolmxl5 02:50, 27 April 2008 (UTC) delete All fail thlete Deletion of Sam Mott WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
1229 5270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A State of Mind (band) (2nd nomination) User:David 09:39, 6 October 2016 (UTC) comment fr:A State of Mind (which this appears to be at least partially a translation of) has some RSes. Interviews: http://limonadier.net/interview-a-state-of-mind-the-jade-amulet/http://www.francetvinfo.fr/culture/musique/a-state-of-mind-histoires-de-hip-hop_1704989.html Reviews: http://www.musisphere.com/article-266-ASM-A-State-of-Mind-The-Jade-Amulet.htmlhttp://www.trip-hop.net/album-1930-a-state-of-mind-platypus-funk-laboratoire.html Not quite sure those three alone bring it up to , but it's not implausible Deletion of A State of Mind (band) (2nd nomination) WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1230 54 [[Deutschsprachige SAP Anwendergruppe]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Zipferlak NONE keep Nach ist die Relevanz durch die überregionale Bedeutung sowie die signifikante Mitgliederzahl gegeben, daher:. Löschung von Deutschsprachige SAP Anwendergruppe Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
1231 20187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wedlock (band) User:The 21:17, 12 July 2007 (UTC) delete They appear to fail Deletion of Wedlock (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1232 21582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SU(6) (physics) User:Kj 17:20, 21 October 2020 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of SU(6) (physics) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
1233 17073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dog Fart Neutralizing Thong User:Dragomiloff 04:01, 9 December 2006 (UTC) delete unfortunately this doesn't appear a hoax. It's still and unencyclopedic. Good for a laugh though Deletion of Dog Fart Neutralizing Thong WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
1234 2105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Perunika User:Esradekan 00:03, 18 May 2008 (UTC) delete WP:MUSIC & Deletion of Perunika WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
1235 131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bandung Derby User:Mentoz86 07:55, 16 May 2013 (UTC) delete per . Sports rivalries are not notable unless they pass the Deletion of Bandung Derby WP:NRIVALRY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1236 21087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UngBDSM User:Wildthing61476 18:19, 5 October 2006 (UTC) delete no verifiable sources to prove they meet . (and may I just add BDSM for '''16 year olds''' ewww Deletion of UngBDSM WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1237 5551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Higher-Order Perl User:Northamerica1000 05:06, 3 May 2020 (UTC) keep Per a source review, it has been qualified that this book meets point #1 of Deletion of Higher-Order Perl WP:BOOKCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1238 17514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rutgers Against the War User:MZMcBride 21:57, 24 August 2007 (UTC) delete the article is of a minor organization at Rutgers University that does not meet . Any relevant information from this article can be moved to Campus Antiwar Network (which the group is a member of) and the title itself can be made into a redirect to that article. For full disclosure, I am a Rutgers student but have no affiliation with any campus groups. I just found this article via another site and know from my long-time experience here as an admin that it does not meet our current notability standards. The article was also |speedy deleted by Deletion of Rutgers Against the War WP:N||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Notability 77
1239 13150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs about Melbourne User:YechielMan 18:58, 19 June 2007 (UTC) keep The buck stops here. I consider cities to be sufficiently relevant to escape #INFO, and I can imagine how such lists could be useful for a variety of reading interests. I cannot say likewise for songs about the weather Deletion of List of songs about Melbourne WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1240 20924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jon Girodes User:Jersey92 02:34, 20 August 2014 (UTC) delete Easily fails and . It could be if he were to get elected but Republicans generally don't get elected where he lives Deletion of Jon Girodes WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
1241 104 [[Hellersdorfer Straße]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Steindy NONE delete Ein Artikel, den die WP nicht braucht und der gegen Ziffer 7 verstößt. Es reicht allemal, wenn die wirklich relevanten Straßen dargestellt werden. und etliche andere :Kategorie:Straße in Berlin|davon auch Löschung von Hellersdorfer Straße Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1242 17593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mind Pirate User:Isotope23 15:05, 7 April 2006 (UTC) delete Argh... 'tis a |neologism ya mangy sea-dogs Deletion of Mind Pirate WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
1243 10126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ibrahim Mamman User:Ashleyyoursmile 15:49, 11 February 2021 (UTC) delete per nom. Does not pass and Deletion of Ibrahim Mamman WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1244 18923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EC8OR User:TenPoundHammer 18:03, 26 May 2008 (UTC) keep Meets criterion 5 of by having multiple recordings on evidently notable labels Deletion of EC8OR WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1245 8746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Creators Society User:Etzedek24 21:35, 5 January 2021 (UTC) delete Few, if any independent sources and do not see how it passes Deletion of The Creators Society WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1246 2580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Astrojet User:Stifle 12:46, 3 February 2006 (UTC) delete Bouncing around the eastern seaboard might be construed as meeting the guidelines, but I'll fall back on the fact that it isn't verifiable, for now Deletion of The Astrojet WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1247 19866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Satish Mohan User:Hydronium 10:16, 27 May 2016 (UTC) delete Does not meet or as there's a little regional http://www.buffalonews.com/spotlight/satish-mohan-private-citizen-20131103 news coverage, and the http://www.bizjournals.com/buffalo/news/2012/09/10/developer-amherst-both-win-points-in.html Acquest Wehrle suit does not appear notable. Has some https://scholar.google.com.au/scholar?hl=en&q=%22Satish+Mohan%22+&btnG=&as_sdt=1%2C5&as_sdtp= cited works, but does not appear to meet . There's a https://www.google.com.au/search?q=%22satish+mohan%22+%22billiards%22+ notable billiards player of that name, and if evidence were found that they're one and the same he'd be notable, however I've found nothingone way or the other Deletion of Satish Mohan WP:NPOL||WP:ANYBIO||WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1248 5659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christos Kalousis User:onel5969 03:48, 25 May 2021 (UTC) keep while at the time the nom was made they did not pass , they now do. And while having only played in one game, they most likely will play in more Deletion of Christos Kalousis WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
1249 21398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of news websites in Sudan and South Sudan User:Ajf773 11:25, 13 July 2017 (UTC) delete WP:NOTLINKFARM, Deletion of List of news websites in Sudan and South Sudan WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1250 6291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jen Cass [[User_talk:Bradv|BradV]]'' 14:36, 10 July 2008 (UTC) delete According to the talk page it was written by her publicist. No secondary sources available (fails Deletion of Jen Cass WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1251 16521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moov User:K 05:10, 4 November 2016 (UTC) delete an insignificant tech startup; applies -- the company is not yet notable per available sources Deletion of Moov WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1252 9162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Prodigal Trilogy User:Jclemens 05:21, 2 June 2009 (UTC) keep 1) the Prodigal Trilogy is, upon examination, both a play and a film adaptation of that play; Google shows coverage for both the one-man show and the film/DVD. 2) As such, it meets the GNG, and should be kept even if the awards don't rise to the level envisioned by . I've added a couple of references and some external links Deletion of The Prodigal Trilogy WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1253 14963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Northwest Model United Nations User:NeoChaosX 03:08, 29 June 2007 (UTC) comment See . Just because other Model UNs have an article doesn't mean that this one deserves one. It has to meet the |guidelines for notability, which this group doesn't. And if those model UNs don't meet the notability requirements, those too will eventually be nominated for deletion. But I digress; unless you have |reliable sources that show that this Model UN is notable, you might have a better chance of keeping this article Deletion of Northwest Model United Nations WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS||WP:ORG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1254 18334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elvis Presley's favourite books User:Starblind 21:15, 28 June 2007 (UTC) delete Based on what I know of Elvis, I'd be ''extremely'' surprised if these were really his favourite books. However, that's not why I'm voting to delete. This sort of indiscriminant list is covered by Deletion of Elvis Presley's favourite books WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1255 18265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dumpfile User:SamJohnston 07:10, 2 September 2011 (UTC) merge to core dump with . Removed unreferenced rubbish about simulators Deletion of Dumpfile WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
1256 5844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of wrestlers in WWE video games (2nd nomination) User:The1337gamer 15:33, 2 June 2015 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of List of wrestlers in WWE video games (2nd nomination) WP:LISTN||WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1257 4160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seven Deadly Enemies of Man NONE NONE keep Significant coverage per . The article should be worked on (or discussed in a section at Seven Deadly Sins or somewhere else), per , , and Deletion of Seven Deadly Enemies of Man WP:GNG||WP:ATD||WP:PRESERVE||WP:NOEFFORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1258 20222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alone (Remake) User:Erik 11:02, 10 July 2008 (UTC) delete per ; not verifiable Deletion of Alone (Remake) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1259 17231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arlo Kay Atkin User:Good 04:02, 16 April 2014 (UTC) delete per . I don't think it comes very close to meeting the standard of notability Deletion of Arlo Kay Atkin WP:CRIMINAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1260 3536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pagat.com User:2005 05:17, 12 March 2007 (UTC) keep Plainly meets . The website is the preeminent card games website on the Internet, with literally thousands of non-trivial online references from the International Playing Card Society on down. Please do some research before making afd's... added... and also the random removal of links added by many different editors that clearly meet calls this whole afd into question. Please act responsibly Deletion of Pagat.com WP:WEB||WP:EL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1261 15131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mobifusion User:The 11:19, 20 August 2006 (UTC) delete as . Fails Deletion of Mobifusion WP:VSCA||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1262 19603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Possible consequences of Kosovo independence User:AKMask 21:58, 21 February 2008 (UTC) delete or at least '''Don't rename'''. Delete because its |crystal ballery of the worst sort, but if the content stays, it should stay at the NPOV name of Controversy. Considering the vast majority of the controversy is over whether or not it sets a precedent, naming it the kosovo precedent is, really, just plain silly Deletion of Possible consequences of Kosovo independence WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1263 5324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barona Valley Ranch Resort and Casino User:Adrian 21:17, 16 March 2006 (UTC) delete Not really a speedy candidate. |non-notable corporation Deletion of Barona Valley Ranch Resort and Casino WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1264 2867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willene Johnson User:Pilean 07:14, 23 March 2021 (UTC) keep Meets criteria #6 Deletion of Willene Johnson WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1265 11739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Hindi horror shows User:Colapeninsula 11:40, 20 July 2017 (UTC) keep per as it's already a category, extra information is present, and it's a reasonable topic considering how Hindi media is commonly considered as a distinct group, it's a notable genre, and nobody has proposed merging Deletion of List of Hindi horror shows WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
1266 47 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Steckley User:Prosfilaes 04:49, 20 March 2009 (UTC) keep Per above keeps. Seems like he is the world expert in a small field. Gnews hits like- the http://www.thestar.com/printArticle/288382 Toronto Star article about him cited in the article, book review like http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-30526397_ITM go toward satisfying (answering Deletion of John Steckley WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1267 9965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alistair Macdonald-Radcliff User:AlessandroTiandelli333 13:38, 16 October 2020 (UTC) keep passes and would likely pass if arabic sources were examined Deletion of Alistair Macdonald-Radcliff WP:CLERGY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1268 1432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myspace censorship User:Bushcarrot 02:07, 26 September 2007 (UTC) delete Original research, as well as #SOAPBOX Deletion of Myspace censorship WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1269 5428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellis, Idaho User:Firsfron 20:52, 30 June 2021 (UTC) keep """The USGS lists Ellis as a https://geonames.usgs.gov/apex/f?p=138:3:::NO:3:P3_FID,P3_TITLE:381426,Ellis populated place and my 1960 World Book Encyclopedia lists Ellis as a town with a population of 10, while Davis' Encyclopedia from 1909 gives it a population of 20. is thus satisfied: """"Populated, legally recognized places are typically presumed to be notable, even if their population is very low. Even abandoned places can be notable, because notability encompasses their entire history."""" It does seem as though Ellis is abandoned, but |notability is not temporary. I was able to https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Ellis%2C_Idaho&type=revision&diff=1031293594&oldid=1030974087 expand the article, using serious reference works. It would be quite odd to delete the info here, while reference works like ''World Book'' and ''Davis' Encyclopedia'' have noted the community. What are we doing deleting content other encyclopedias contain""" Deletion of Ellis, Idaho WP:GEOLAND||WP:NOTTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1270 20312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bambang Parmanto User:Tevildo 11:08, 24 June 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails Deletion of Bambang Parmanto WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1271 9470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coast to coast (Canadian mobile network) User:PKT 13:50, 27 May 2011 (UTC) delete """the definition used in the article is , and the terminology """"coast to coast"""" in Canada's cellphone market basically means just what it always means: from St. John's to Vancouver Island""" Deletion of Coast to coast (Canadian mobile network) WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
1272 21245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Milena Leticia Roucka User:The 22:27, 24 August 2007 (UTC) delete fails the notability policy |at this time. '''Special:Contributions/The Hybrid|The Deletion of Milena Leticia Roucka WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1273 8542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martini Talapusi User:TheSandDoctor 05:21, 17 November 2020 (UTC) delete per failure of and Deletion of Martini Talapusi WP:NRU||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
1274 3176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of University of Manitoba alumni User:OlEnglish 18:03, 16 February 2011 (UTC) keep Looks like someone needs to review point #4 in Deletion of List of University of Manitoba alumni WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1275 2061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rose Van Thyn User:Smmurphy 19:17, 17 August 2017 (UTC) keep """passes , , . I don't think non-local coverage is a requirement in . As for N, ICTIM states, """" The historic significance is indicated by persistent coverage of the event in reliable secondary sources that devote significant attention to the individual's role"""", Thyn received persistent coverage from at least three newspapers small Louisiana newspapers (Shreveport Times, Alexandria Town Talk, Monroe News-Star per https://www.newspapers.com/search/#query=%22Rose+Van+Thyn%22). Note that newspapers.com isn't exhaustive of Louisianan newspapers, for instance neither the NO Advocate nor contemporary issues of the NO Times-Picayune are indexed (the two largest papers in NO. As a |creative professional (giving talks on her life), there is not a strong case, but her talk is kept at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum and reviewed in those three papers. As for GNG, independent sources seems sufficient""" Deletion of Rose Van Thyn WP:NPOV||WP:NOR||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:VICTIM||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1276 6084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eddie Christofono [[User talk:Treelo|treelo]] [[Special:Contributions/Treelo|radda]] 13:46, 9 April 2009 (UTC) delete Borderline attack article but even without that it doesn't pass Deletion of Eddie Christofono WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1277 100 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Duygu Özaslan """Kullanıcı:ourlipsareapocalypseourlipsareapocalypse""" 16.39, 16 Temmuz 2020 (UTC) keep """Hakkında bağımsız ve güvenilir tarafından bulgular bulunduğunu düşünüyorum. Son zamanlarda sıkça konuşulan kişiler arasında ve ciddi bir hayran kitlesi olduğunu inkâr edemeyiz. Bu noktada |politikalarımızı esas almalıyız ve """"''Kişinin adının kanıtlanabilir şekilde yaygınca tanınmış olması.''"""" kriterine istinaden kalması doğru olur diye düşünüyorum. Ek olarak, maddenin geliştirilmesi gerekmektedir""" Duygu Özaslan'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
1278 2711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gabe Simon User:Northamerica1000 03:08, 9 March 2017 (UTC) merge to Kopecky (band) per -R; a valid search term. Source searches are providing some coverage, but it doesn't seem there's enough to qualify a standalone article Deletion of Gabe Simon WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1279 443 [[Xenia Tchoumitcheva]] (schnellgelöscht) Benutzer:84.74.5.25 NONE keep Wieso ist das ein grottenschlechter Stub? Bitte mal #Echter Stub zur Kenntnis nehmen. Zweite bei der Miss Schweiz|Miss-Schweiz-Wahl spricht durchaus für Relevanz Löschung von Xenia Tchoumitcheva Wikipedia:Artikel Wikipedia:Artikel 90
1280 10027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fredie Blom User:Jedi 22:50, 5 September 2020 (UTC) keep Topic is notable enough for , I agree with Greenman's arguments Deletion of Fredie Blom WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1281 7237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nature Camp User:Last1in 14:02, 16 March 2010 (UTC) keep per polargeo. It's labeled as a stub and there is enough material around to meet and with a little work. If the page isn't improved in a few months, delete it then. —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Nature Camp WP:V||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1282 2219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of albums containing a hidden track (2nd nomination) User:Verdatum 16:40, 20 August 2008 (UTC) delete I believe a decent article could be created that is a list of notable hidden tracks. This would be albums containing hidden tracks that are reported in reputable independent resources; this would naturally be shorter than a list of notable albums that happen to contain hidden tracks. But, such a list would really require someone actively watching the article to see that the inclusion criteria is strictly enforced. Concievably, the inclusion criteria of this list can be explicitly stated (as per ) to reflect the same thing; in which case, i'm fine with keeping it. I do like the idea of albums with a hidden track existing as a category, if such is not already the case Deletion of List of albums containing a hidden track (2nd nomination) WP:SAL Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
1283 21729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Pinwheel User:IagoQnsi 19:11, 8 April 2016 (UTC) delete per nom. Deletion of The Pinwheel WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1284 13489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wedgie (2nd nomination) User:Fbv65edel 21:22, 3 April 2006 (UTC) keep as per above as well. This is a very famous prank, almost a classic. It doesn't even relate to, on any level, Deletion of Wedgie (2nd nomination) WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
1285 3702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Afro-denial User:Deville 02:53, 1 May 2006 (UTC) delete per others, this is a dicdef at best, more like at worst Deletion of Afro-denial WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1286 4664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jalapa Devi Primary School,Terathum User:Noyster 08:45, 7 April 2015 (UTC) merge to Ishibu per Deletion of Jalapa Devi Primary School,Terathum WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1287 20195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ritwik.P User:HitroMilanese 19:11, 2 April 2015 (UTC) delete Insufficient reliable sources, fails on Deletion of Ritwik.P WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1288 12029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acanac User:Bearcat 20:34, 16 February 2017 (UTC) delete The sources listed above are not ''about'' Acanac, but simply namecheck its existence briefly within coverage of other things. We do not keep articles about companies just because media coverage of other things happens to namecheck the fact that this thing exists — we keep articles about companies only if and when they're ''substantively'' the ''subject'' of enough media coverage to satisfy . And it's also not Wikipedia's role to keep a poorly sourced article just because the subject is a small upstart competitor to more entrenched media conglomerates — we're an encyclopedia, not a free advertising venue. Being a small company is not a barrier to inclusion on Wikipedia, if the article can be sourced ''properly'' — but existing as a small company is not a Wikipedia ''freebie'', if blurbs and listicles are the best we can do for sourcing. And per , if there are other articles on Wikipedia whose claims of notability and evidence of sourceability are as weak as has been shown here, then that constitutes evidence that they should also be deleted rather than evidence that this should be kept Deletion of Acanac WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1289 15896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of crimes committed in the United States by illegal aliens User:MJL 23:57, 4 March 2019 (UTC) delete Irrelevant intersection of two unrelated factors. What's next? List of crimes committed in the Republic of North Macedonia by people wearing silly hats? In all seriousness, this article leads one to simple and speculative concerns. I don't see that as a net plus to the project. – Deletion of List of crimes committed in the United States by illegal aliens WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1290 17607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/First fire women officer in India User:Bmusician 09:47, 22 March 2012 (UTC) delete per #A10|A10 Deletion of First fire women officer in India WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1291 13172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drlibs User:Nevhood 01:05, 20 February 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Drlibs WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
1292 16716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 FIFA World Cup (video game) [[User talk:Muzemike|MuZemike]] 07:51, 1 April 2009 (UTC) delete I trust the above comment that there is even no indication in the development of the game. It's hard to not come off as mean and bite newbies' heads off, especially in cases like this. The |verifiability policy I believe trumps the |behavioral guideline on biting newbies, and it sucks Deletion of 2010 FIFA World Cup (video game) WP:V||WP:BITE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1293 6498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James H. Stuart User:Bearian 14:56, 15 October 2019 (UTC) delete the city of which he was mayor has a population of 127,380, which is |borderline, pardon the pun. There are |insufficient sources Deletion of James H. Stuart WP:BARE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1294 21717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Bouchier User:Gnfnrf 16:28, 15 November 2008 (UTC) delete Does not meet any of the criteria of . Writing a column, even a prominent column, does not make you notable, unless it makes people write about you Deletion of David Bouchier WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1295 7864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anonymous Boy User:10sne1 20:53, 22 November 2020 (UTC) comment I'd like to see a couple stronger sources than the 4 offered in the original article. As it stands now, it leans toward not yet meeting Deletion of Anonymous Boy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1296 3668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uncertainty theory User:Snottywong 00:56, 30 November 2009 (UTC) delete """all or translate them and move them to the Chinese language wiki. The references provided above prove that something called """"Uncertainty Theory"""" (UT) exists, but it is not clear if UT is clearly defined, nor is it clear if this article is about the """"real"""" UT. Since the article claims that UT was invented in 2007, but the references provided date back to the mid-90's, my gut feeling is that this article is not accurately reflecting the sources that were found for it. Just because we can search for """"uncertainty theory"""" and find math articles with """"uncertainty theory"""" in the title doesn't mean that we've found a reference that backs up the material in these articles. I say the articles get deleted, and if someone wants to rewrite the article based on multiple independent |sources, then so be it. At this point, the articles appear to need a nearly complete rewrite, so deletion is probably the best thing we can do for UT""" Deletion of Uncertainty theory WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1297 14775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Internet Security Measures User:OverlordQ 21:51, 2 July 2007 (UTC) delete Author blanked Deletion of Internet Security Measures WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1298 5640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Autariatae User:Bearian 20:33, 27 September 2007 (UTC) keep and clean up, as passing , although I am in no measure an expert on the topic Deletion of Autariatae WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1299 19301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orkhan Mirzaev User:IJA 17:58, 14 January 2015 (UTC) delete Fails as he hasn't played in a |fully professional league and he doesn't have any senior international caps Deletion of Orkhan Mirzaev WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1300 20657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeremy Annear User:The 19:34, 26 March 2018 (UTC) delete for failing , despite commendable efforts by subject to support own notability. Possibly Deletion of Jeremy Annear WP:ARTIST||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
1301 10370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karl Rock User:DerbyCountyinNZ 21:15, 27 March 2021 (UTC) delete Classic as described bu User:NZFC below. The sound of the bottom of the notability barrel being scraped is clear Deletion of Karl Rock WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
1302 1815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Human Instrumentality Project User:Collectonian 01:40, 30 December 2009 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is for the publication of someone's personal opinions and self-research. This is a non-notable fictional concept from the Neon Genesis Evangelion franchise. The one claimed source buried in the article might be usable elsewhere, but there is nothing in this article to salvage for merging or redirecting Deletion of Human Instrumentality Project WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1303 4372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sammy Jayne User:Stifle 18:21, 14 May 2008 (UTC) delete As there are no |reliable sources |cited, I am persuaded that the article does not comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Sammy Jayne WP:RS||WP:CITE||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1304 20798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of automotive flops User:Whispering 19:56, 13 July 2006 (UTC) delete I'm going to be strange here and vote delete I can't see this list ever getting to NPOV or past the stage Deletion of List of automotive flops WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1305 3073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Man-At-Arms User:Zxcvbnm 17:28, 8 October 2020 (UTC) merge """Does not seem to pass . The current title should be redirected to Man-at-arms. """"Duh! He's one of the main characters of X!"""" may work for Wikia, but not Wikipedia""" Deletion of Man-At-Arms WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1306 268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Attack on Kennedy Road [[User talk:192.160.216.52|talk]]) 13:46, 9 April 2018 (UTC) keep Be serious. The sources already in the article are far, far more than sufficient to meet . Nom's theories on why, despite meeting GNG, this subject is not notable, are interesting, but they're not AfD-worthy reasoning. Special:Contributions/192.160.216.52|192.160.216.52 Deletion of Attack on Kennedy Road WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1307 36 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ömer Sevinçgül Kullanıcı:xenverlyxenverly 12.13, 8 Temmuz 2022 (UTC) delete Dosya:OUII Talk icon - Decline.svg|15px|Silinsin|link=Vikipedi:Tartış, oylama yapma kriterlerini karşılamadığını düşünüyorum ve silinmesini öneriyorum. Yazarla ilgili öne sürülen kaynaklar da yine yazarın otobiyografisine atıfta bulunuyor ve yazardan bağımsız incelemeler içermiyor. Bunun yanında yazarın edebiyat dünyasına önemli bir katkısının bulunduğunu da göremedim Ömer Sevinçgül'ün silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
1308 9558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional revolutions and coups [[User talk:122.60.173.107|talk]]) 20:48, 18 November 2020 (UTC) delete This is a collection of fictional events. Also, it is incomplete (Handmaid's Tale|under his eye). Special:Contributions/122.60.173.107|122.60.173.107 Deletion of List of fictional revolutions and coups WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1309 19822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/5grs User:Malinaccier 00:44, 12 December 2008 (UTC) delete The assertion that they are the only band of the genre with a female vocalist is not verifiable, and they otherwise fail Deletion of 5grs WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
1310 20941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Dean Shillingsworth User:Sharkface217 01:51, 17 December 2007 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Death of Dean Shillingsworth WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
1311 5941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J-Office User:Pmedema 01:41, 12 October 2010 (UTC) delete One of the very many Java/office suites that just does not pass Other then it has no notability Deletion of J-Office WP:N||WP:ITEXISTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1312 12219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vidyut Kale User:SerTanmay 17:13, 15 March 2019 (UTC) keep She has been covered by multiple surces, such as New York Times and Times of India. can be worked upon Deletion of Vidyut Kale WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1313 16892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Your Choice Records bands NONE NONE keep The fundamental question is whether this information belongs in Wikipedia. The list seems to be of reasonable length; it's not the can of worms that, say, List of artists on Capital Records would be. Is the list directly |verifiable? No: There is no source that references each of the artists recording on Your Choice. Is it indirectly verifiable? Yes: The notable bands mentioned in the list have albums on Your Choice listed in their respective (discography) articles. (Comment on what Party diktator said: internal links do ''not'' remedy the missing sources issue, though reliable sources cited on the linked pages can carry over Deletion of List of Your Choice Records bands WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1314 15661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Megxit User:Britishfinance 12:40, 12 January 2020 (UTC) comment Spanish Wikipedia has a larger article on https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Megxit Megxit which might be useful for material (not that we need more sources as we are already heavy in the highest quality /Ps, with Megxit in the title and body as Deletion of Megxit WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1315 17642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Waltlou Mobile Home Park User:Phil 19:14, 20 January 2011 (UTC) delete This is a business rather than a distinct populated place, so should be judged by the |standards that we apply to businesses, which I can see no evidence of this article meeting. And, please, don't throw around accusations of prejudice against mobile home dwellers. I live in a bricks-and-mortar house on a street with about three times the number of homes that this park has, and would expect to be held up to ridicule if I was to argue that that street was a suitable subject for an encyclopedia article Deletion of Waltlou Mobile Home Park WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1316 3752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tamil Isai Sangam User:Hongkongresident 13:22, 30 October 2010 (UTC) keep Keep'''. A http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Tamil+Isai+Sangam%22&hl=en&safe=off&rlz=1T4TSNA_enUS385US385&tbs=nws:1,ar:1&ei=tRrMTIH5F4P6lwfI4OzqCA&start=0&sa=N quick News search indicates it does meet criteria, but the article needs to be cleaned up. There's been non-trivial profiles of the organisation on various well-known Indian newspapers, like ''The Hindu'' and ''Indian Express''. And this is without the |non-English results, which there could be a lot of Deletion of Tamil Isai Sangam WP:BAND||WP:NOENG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1317 18071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GE 80-ton switcher user:Andrew 10:06, 30 March 2020 (UTC) keep as the nomination does not give a valid, policy-based -REASON|reason for deletion and so there is no case to answer Deletion of GE 80-ton switcher WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1318 13225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Logiweb User:SquidSK 06:55, 31 December 2009 (UTC) delete Not enough |secondary coverage to be notable. Once it is released, if it has a significant impact on the field, it should receive enough mention by |reliable sources to stand up to the notability tests. Remember, |there is no deadline, and Wikipedia will still be here tomorrow Deletion of Logiweb WP:SECONDARY||WP:RS||WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:No original research 65
1319 19065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Primerica Financial Services User:VoiceOfReason 22:20, 29 August 2006 (UTC) keep I understand your frustration, and a look at the history shows that your concerns aren't unfounded. But the entity itself appears to easily be |notable. There are other ways of dealing with repeated vandalism (which deliberately inserting NPOV material is Deletion of Primerica Financial Services WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1320 225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Fresno Nightcrawlers User:OnionRing 05:04, 26 June 2016 (UTC) delete per nomination, no significant coverage in , GBooks search only turns up Field & Stream articles about fishing in Fresno Deletion of The Fresno Nightcrawlers WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1321 11589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/State terrorism by the United States (sixth nomination) User:Shalom 05:59, 26 June 2007 (UTC) comment """Could we please not have """"keep"""" comments asking that the page not be nominated for deletion in the future? |consensus can change, as the Daniel Brandt and GNAA perennial AFDs have shown. I think this article might become the next perennial AFD, but that's a systemic flaw that really can't be fixed while standing on one foot""" Deletion of State terrorism by the United States (sixth nomination) WP:CCC Wikipedia:Consensus 78
1322 16776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Friend of Mankind User:Aleta 02:26, 20 June 2007 (UTC) delete per . I can't find any reviews of it Deletion of The Friend of Mankind WP:NOTFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
1323 16329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anarcho-capitalism User:Shawn 23:37, 7 January 2016 (UTC) keep regardless of the state of the article -- I really haven't even bothered to check as Afd is -- the Google Scholar results alone above easily establish notability Deletion of Anarcho-capitalism WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1324 5526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Léo Costa (Musician) User:Catfish 08:53, 1 August 2013 (UTC) comment """I am extremely concerned at the level of |bad faith shown by some of our editors relating to this page. We are struggling with new editor retention and one sure fire way to scare them off is to hammer them and their articles with multiple warnings as soon as they put up their first articles. This article has been on Wikipedia for 2 days and has been subjected to two CSD nominations, neither of which were valid (A1, A7), had references removed to restore a BLP-PROD (!) http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=L%C3%A9o_Costa_(Musician)&diff=566336727&oldid=566336668 and has been tagged as a hoax... when it's clear from a simple google search of """"Leo Costa Everlast"""" that he is indeed a professional drummer who has played with Everlast. Looking at the article, it's painfully obvious that it has been written by an inexperienced editor who doesn't know the ins and outs of WP policy. In situations like these, it is usually more appropriate to help to improve the article if possible and to provide mentorship, rather than ganging up on them and smacking them down for daring to write a WP article""" Deletion of Léo Costa (Musician) WP:FAITH Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
1325 7317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of LGBT characters in modern written fiction User:SatyrTN 13:28, 25 September 2007 (UTC) keep """1) Completeness or lack thereof is not a reason to delete a list. 2) """"Link farms"""" are generally collections of |external links, which this is not. 3) Standards for inclusion on the list should definitely be spelled out and adhered to. 4) """"Performing a homosexual act"""" - please read homosexual and learn why that is not what defines someone as LGBT""" Deletion of List of LGBT characters in modern written fiction WP:EL Wikipedia:External links 76
1326 12584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Private equity in China [[User talk:Dank|push to talk]]) 16:51, 13 June 2009 (UTC) comment Since we generally #G11|speedy-delete spam rather than having a 7 day discussion, I'm going to assume from the votes that that's what you guys want, unless you say otherwise within roughly 20 hours. - Dank Deletion of Private equity in China WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1327 4017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martynas Jasiūnas User:Papaursa 00:14, 7 March 2016 (UTC) delete """Does not meet the notability criteria for kickboxers or boxers. His boxing titles are all """"youth"""" or """"junior"""", so they fail to show notability. His success at IFMA events does not show notability because that is an amateur organization and amateur kickboxing is explicitly excluded from showing notability at . Since he is now only 18, it's also not clear whether or not the titles he did win were adult or junior""" Deletion of Martynas Jasiūnas WP:NKICK Wikipedia:Notability 77
1328 12157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/THAC0 User:Percy 13:42, 22 February 2008 (UTC) comment google hits |don't generally establish notability. If any of those hits constitute substantial, independent secondary coverage then please link to them from the article; otherwise, it fails to meet the notability requirements. Regarding the hobby press: can you give any examples of non-TSR/WotC publications dedicating substantial coverage to THAC0 Deletion of THAC0 WP:GHITS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1329 5404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 United States tomato shortage User:Smartse 23:50, 20 October 2010 (UTC) keep there has been significant and lasting coverage to satisfy the and . The article could be renamed tomato shortage and broadened (I've found that there is currently a shortage in http://www.globes.co.il/serveen/globes/docview.asp?did=1000595135&fid=1725 Israel and http://www.freshplaza.com/news_detail.asp?id=69927 Jordan). As a the most popular vegetable (see the WSJ source) a shortage of tomatoes is a relatively big deal Deletion of 2010 United States tomato shortage WP:GNG||WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1330 20307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin D. Skelton User:Edison 01:20, 26 May 2009 (UTC) delete Seems to be a talented working musician and scholar. As such, it would not be surprising to find sufficient evidence to satisfy |notability, but I do not see it so far. Perhaps others more informed about his specialty can search for additional sources and comment. Any reviews Deletion of Kevin D. Skelton WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1331 16822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Messed Up User:Jayden54 20:02, 26 December 2006 (UTC) delete completely non notable, and fails Deletion of Messed Up WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1332 19522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Investigative Project on Terrorism User:A 01:35, 23 September 2014 (UTC) keep A Google news search reveals 166 results.https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws&authuser=0&q=%22Investigative+Project+on+Terrorism%22&oq=%22Investigative+Project+on+Terrorism%22&gs_l=news-cc.3..43j43i53.6316.9371.0.10336.5.3.1.1.0.0.172.479.0j3.3.0...0.0...1ac.1.3E5zlFGiVts and a https://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=010426977372765398405:3xxsh-e1cp8&hl=en Reliable Sources Search Engine yields 100 results (the maximum allowed). Before someone (incorrectly) cites , refers to ''general'' Google searches, not Google ''News'' searches which indexes sites which tend to meet Wikipedia's definition of |reliable sources Deletion of Investigative Project on Terrorism WP:GOOGLEHITS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1333 2870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bellevue Death Squad User:Nicklocarno 22:24, 7 April 2006 (UTC) delete tl|db-band}} candidates, usic violation, as noted by Deletion of Bellevue Death Squad WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
1334 547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saint-Tropez (song) User:Mustapha 09:29, 12 September 2019 (UTC) keep Saw the video and it has up to 1.2M views on YouTube in just 12 hours. The song is by a notable musician Post Malone and shouldn't be deleted. With the views alone and the notability of the artist, it sure passes Deletion of Saint-Tropez (song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1335 4709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Belmont Anti-Tank Ditch User:Nick 12:08, 20 September 2011 (UTC) keep The Lake Macquarie Council website states that this has been heritage listed: http://www.lakemac.com.au/downloads/2009_02_16_stand_pages%2082-118.pdf (see page 33) as well as several other parts of the fortifications built in the area during World War II. Defensive works such as this were highly unusual in Australia during World War II, and I'd be amazed if offline books didn't also discuss this. That said, this is pretty marginal from a perspective, and would be better covered as part of an article on the defences of the Newcastle region rather than a stand-alone Deletion of Belmont Anti-Tank Ditch WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1336 2097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irish E-Sports User:Nifboy 15:59, 12 October 2008 (UTC) delete """WP:Notability has a specialized meaning on Wikipedia. It's not notability in the dictionary sense, but rather something to the effect of """"We don't have decent sources, therefore we can't write a decent (read:erifiability|verifiable) article, therefore we shouldn't bother having an article"""". And that's pretty much the case here""" Deletion of Irish E-Sports WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1337 10005 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""Better Courts for Missouri""""""" User:Grange1272 22:03, 14 March 2008 (UTC) keep I feel the same way about this as Freemarketman. I would also like to go on to say that, to me at least, the page has met the qualifications laid out in """Deletion of """"Better Courts for Missouri""""""" WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1338 2536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Locations in Hogwarts User:Gavin 11:08, 30 October 2007 (UTC) delete as nominated. Lack of |reliable seconary sources suggests these fictional locations have no |notability outside of their fictional setting Deletion of Locations in Hogwarts WP:RS||WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1339 2265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spoorthi User:CookieMonster755 04:29, 6 April 2015 (UTC) merge per {{u|Aircorn}} and Deletion of Spoorthi WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1340 15791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HRM models NONE NONE delete and '''redirect''' to human resource management. More than the title is infelicitous. We |absolutely do not need another vague |spinoff article about an extremely abstract and insubstantial side of business management. This is extremely unspecific Deletion of HRM models WP:B2B||WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Notability 77
1341 14293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Gill (2nd nomination) User:Dylanfromthenorth 22:53, 27 March 2010 (UTC) merge """No notability outside the band yet, but is a very plausible search term and a redirect would satisfy |the guidelines - ''""""Note that members of notable bands are redirected to the band's article, not given individual articles, unless they have demonstrated individual notability for activity independent of the band, such as solo releases""" Deletion of Jonathan Gill (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1342 5453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mecha as Practical War Machines (second nomination) User:Jeepday 03:31, 8 February 2007 (UTC) delete WP:OR and speculation. also fails Deletion of Mecha as Practical War Machines (second nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1343 15589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/María Cristina Rosas User:Agricola44 15:21, 27 January 2010 (UTC) delete GS shows h-index of at most 5, which is way below the typical impact level that we usually consider with respect to . Respectfully Deletion of María Cristina Rosas WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1344 15975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Commercial Capital Training Group (CCTG) User:Rrachet 15:19, 3 July 2017 (UTC) delete as of a non notable organization Deletion of Commercial Capital Training Group (CCTG) WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1345 3036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elijah Lubala User:K 02:21, 20 September 2016 (UTC) delete per ; strictly a vanity page lacking in RS. '''Salt''' is a good suggestion Deletion of Elijah Lubala WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1346 8498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kishore Pratim Biswas User:David 22:21, 27 January 2014 (UTC) delete for lack of evidence of passing (work in permanent collections of major museums, reviews in national newspapers, etc Deletion of Kishore Pratim Biswas WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
1347 1816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad Alipour Rahmati [[User talk:Ravenswing|''' '' Ravenswing '' ''']] 10:11, 10 September 2014 (UTC) keep Another ill-considered nomination from this nom, who's racking up a lot of bad AfDs in recent days -- this is the sixth I've found, so far. Obvious pass on Deletion of Mohammad Alipour Rahmati WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1348 11156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nadeem Askar User:TheBirdsShedTears 09:07, 23 July 2020 (UTC) delete """the subject is covered by the news media, but with """"trival mentions"""". No independent source(s) found. At present, it doesn't pass |general notability guideline""" Deletion of Nadeem Askar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1349 1104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Imma Be User:Abecedare 02:35, 9 January 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Imma Be WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1350 12555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerbilling (2nd nomination) User:RayAYang 23:35, 13 October 2009 (UTC) keep Um. It does appear to have been discussed in detail in multiple publications, thus meeting , and have impact in our culture beyond a dictionary definition. This is perhaps even more disturbing a Keep !vote for me than the time I !voted to keep an article about a hole in the ground Deletion of Gerbilling (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1351 9651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hacker Time User:Dream 22:21, 4 February 2012 (UTC) keep Any show that has millions of viewers is automatically notable by way of common sense. The suggested guidelines are there to help decide what should be here, but they aren't absolute laws. Wikipedia is not a moot court. If a rule gets in the way of improving the Wikipedia, then ignore it. Deletion of Hacker Time WP:BURO||WP:IAR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1352 2713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Animal Crossing residents User:Wikipediatrix 03:24, 27 August 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails Deletion of List of Animal Crossing residents WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1353 11203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lakoda Rayne User:Alpha 04:04, 15 February 2012 (UTC) merge to List of The X Factor finalists (U.S. season 1)#Lakoda Rayne largely per Nate above. The subject lacks a |significant amount of coverage in |reliable third party sources needed to establish the |person's notability. With that said, it is a plausible search term, and it would be best to redirect to the main article at this time Deletion of Lakoda Rayne WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1354 14686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carne Adovada User:SudoGhost 21:24, 9 April 2011 (UTC) delete as per . It iw written more like a cookbook lead paragraph than an encyclopedia entry. What content is there can be merged into an appropriate article Deletion of Carne Adovada WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1355 14984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aural Fixations (compilation) User:Joe 17:02, 6 July 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |compilation album Deletion of Aural Fixations (compilation) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1356 15614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anup Kumar Biswas User:Whpq 14:30, 19 March 2012 (UTC) delete I can find no coverage about this individual in reliable sources. I did turn up stuff about a cellist by the same name though. The claims in the article also fail the fundamental policy of |verifiability; I can find no sourcing to substantiate that he co-founded Evalueserve, nor could I find sources to substantiate the claim of Chairmanship at Hind Heavy & Light Metals (can't even find a trace of the company Deletion of Anup Kumar Biswas WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1357 10827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christy Burke User:BrownHairedGirl 19:42, 24 January 2010 (UTC) keep The nominator is right that being a local councillor does not of itself constitute notability per . However, Burke has been an unusually high-profile councillor, for 25 years, so I'm not surprised to find that he has in fact been the subject of substantial coverage in mainstream media, which has now been added to the article. As such, he meets Deletion of Christy Burke WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1358 12223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ski Centre Savonlinna User:ErikTheBikeMan 21:39, 22 December 2008 (UTC) delete Seems to fail Deletion of Ski Centre Savonlinna WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1359 3471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rory Sweetman User:E 22:32, 17 May 2015 (UTC) keep This minor historian in the very small field (Irish immigrants in New Zealand) fails . But mayjust squeak past when you add the 2 respectful reviews of ''Fair and Just Solution'' to the popular coverage of a controversy surrounding the official history of the boy's school and his very minor presence on the lecture circuit as a speaker on Irish immigrants in New Zealand Deletion of Rory Sweetman WP:PROFESSOR||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1360 5008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Diamond (2nd nomination) User:K 19:03, 14 October 2016 (UTC) delete per ; strictly a vanity page Deletion of Jason Diamond (2nd nomination) WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1361 3617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skeptic's Library [[User talk:101.119.14.99|talk]]) 03:08, 19 November 2013 (UTC) delete per . This seems to be a list of works arbitrarily selected by the article author. While the individual works are notable, this specific list is not. References are cited in the article, but they do not relate to this specific collection of works. -- Special:Contributions/101.119.14.99|101.119.14.99 Deletion of Skeptic's Library WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1362 13367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jung Byung-cheon User:The 16:45, 3 May 2018 (UTC) delete for failing . He's a rookie yet he must get a feature in Wikipedia's main space? Seems unlikely Deletion of Jung Byung-cheon WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
1363 19344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lex Sabre User:יום 20:26, 5 April 2011 (UTC) delete Article does not meet Deletion of Lex Sabre WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1364 7701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GMA News Roundup User:SBKSPP 02:38, 22 May 2021 (UTC) merge to List of programs aired by GMA Network Fails per nom Deletion of GMA News Roundup WP:TVSHOW Wikipedia:Notability 77
1365 11245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Owen Honors User:KVIKountry 00:35, 10 January 2011 (UTC) keep enough coverage to qualify Deletion of Owen Honors WP:MILPEOPLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1366 357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/What. User:SarahStierch 04:15, 12 December 2013 (UTC) delete Appears to be . We could even userfy it until it makes it big Deletion of What. WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1367 9803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ampretur User:Newshunter12 02:30, 20 May 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and was created in 2010 by a , who admitted to being part of this organization. Time to uproot this promotional relic Deletion of Ampretur WP:GNG||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Notability 77
1368 15300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Li Fan (actor) User:Rpclod 11:24, 16 May 2015 (UTC) delete no references at all, let alone any |reliable sources. No indication of notability Deletion of Li Fan (actor) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1369 6698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of Barbara Gordon User:TTN 21:43, 16 November 2020 (UTC) delete The topic fails to establish notability to meet . Per , the main article should summarize excessive in-universe content. There is no justification in splitting this, and I feel a merge is unnecessary Deletion of Alternative versions of Barbara Gordon WP:GNG||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1370 15139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Overclock.net User:Tainter 01:55, 25 January 2007 (UTC) delete I was the one who prod'd it. not notable per and . and please whoever you are sign your posts Deletion of Overclock.net WP:WEB||WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1371 5759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Little Dude User:JeremyMcCracken 19:58, 19 April 2008 (UTC) merge per Fabrictramp for the first; '''speedy close''' for the other two- these need to go to |Redirects for Discussion Deletion of Little Dude WP:RFD Wikipedia:Redirect 56
1372 12050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Air Academy Federal Credit Union User:Till 05:44, 3 February 2012 (UTC) keep passes . See http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&biw=1280&bih=707&tbs=ar%3A1&tbm=nws&q=%22Air+Academy+Federal+Credit+Union%22&oq=%22Air+Academy+Federal+Credit+Union%22&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&gs_sm=e&gs_upl=165660l168260l0l168443l2l2l0l0l0l0l222l222l2-1l1l0 this for coverage in multiple sources Deletion of Air Academy Federal Credit Union WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1373 9401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hidayatullah Kheshgi (2nd nomination) User:Setreis 15:37, 17 March 2021 (UTC) delete Current sources are mostly passing mentions, fails , Deletion of Hidayatullah Kheshgi (2nd nomination) WP:NPOLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1374 5669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dice Creep [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 05:39, 19 December 2006 (UTC) delete per and . -- Deletion of Dice Creep WP:VERIFY||WP:NFT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1375 15577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerald Johanssen User:Jclemens 20:44, 22 December 2012 (UTC) merge to the appropriate character list per Deletion of Gerald Johanssen WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1376 7753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Gudo (2nd nomination) User:CAPTAIN 23:49, 18 July 2017 (UTC) delete He does not seem to meet the notability criteria for ntertainer Deletion of Peter Gudo (2nd nomination) WP:E Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
1377 14367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MatchWare User:Sam 10:17, 1 June 2018 (UTC) delete Some searches including {{mono|site:.dk}} searches did not bring about more sources. Plenty of mention of their different products, but applies, and this still fails GNG/NCORP Deletion of MatchWare WP:INHERITORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1378 16476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finco Services Inc User:HighKing 20:41, 15 June 2021 (UTC) delete """ requires multiple sources (at least two) of deep or significant coverage with |in-depth information *on the company* and (this bit is important!) containing |""""Independent Content"""". """"Independent content"""", in order to count towards establishing notability, must include ''original and independent opinion, analysis, investigation, and fact checking that are clearly attributable to a source unaffiliated to the subject''. That means: nothing that relies entirely on company information or announcements or interviews, etc, there must be independent opinion/analysis etc. None of the references in the article meet the criteria. They are either advertorial """"profile"""" pieces which rely on interviews and information provided by the company or short articles based on an """"announcement"""" by the company - all of the articles I can find are within the company's echo chamber and I have been unable to find any """"Independent Content"""" as per ORGIND. Topic fails """ Deletion of Finco Services Inc WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1379 19566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dark Danny User:Eusebeus 18:49, 24 July 2008 (UTC) delete as nn per Deletion of Dark Danny WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1380 10454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Presley Massara User:Yeti 22:05, 25 April 2019 (UTC) delete per . Only single barely notable role, single GNG hit regarding that role (The West Australian, other hits are local rags or industry publications). No prejudice to recreation if his career should continue to grow into something notable Deletion of Presley Massara WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1381 2941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cinematic immersion User:Frank 02:13, 8 April 2009 (UTC) delete I declined the CSD because it wasn't an obvious candidate, but...while there was some |notability asserted, it isn't actually |supported by |reliable sources Deletion of Cinematic immersion WP:N||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1382 821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zhuyeping User:Trevj 14:18, 12 December 2013 (UTC) merge of Zhuyeping, Sangzhi into Zhuyeping, per Rincewind42 and the fact that the latter was created before the former. Besides this, per , why are we having a deletion discussion where the nomination is to propose a merge outcome Deletion of Zhuyeping WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1383 19820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Engage (organisation) User:E 01:16, 13 February 2019 (UTC) comment Your argument that the publication was short-lived, is not supported by policy. We host articles on many short-lived publicaitons (cf. '47 (magazine), African Observer, Atari Age.) Also, brief sources can be , as I judge the passage that you added to the page in a book by Andrew Pessin to be. and , although the page was poorly (virtually un-)sourced wehn brought to AfD, it is now sourced to and more can be added, including material from the several books mentioned above Deletion of Engage (organisation) WP:SIGCOV||WP:HEYMANN||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
1384 18491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danielle Stella User:Mungo 01:33, 31 July 2019 (UTC) keep I, as the creator of the article feel that she is worthy of being on Wikipedia due to the coverage she has received in multiple notable, reputable channels of media. She is a candidate for an important political position, that of the representation of Minnesota's 5th congressional district, which has been made more so newsworthy by the rise of Ilhan Omar. While I recognize that Stella's public prominence may have flash-in-the-pan qualities, I believe based on her political aspirations and media treatment render her |notable, and that the coverage and public interest in her is likely to continue Deletion of Danielle Stella WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1385 6668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave Ellis (guitarist) User:Schuym1 01:16, 27 January 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Dave Ellis (guitarist) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1386 10662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Alden, Esq User:Bearian 19:11, 11 October 2014 (UTC) delete I see no evidence the subject passes |general notability or my standards for lawyers. I've never heard of this |run of the mill person Deletion of Michael Alden, Esq WP:GNG||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1387 726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Morshu User:WanderingWanda 01:52, 4 February 2021 (UTC) delete Per and #KEEP there is no reason to get rid of a harmless redirect that is potentially useful to readers (for example, one could imagine a reader coming across a reference to Morshu and typing it into the search bar to see what the name is from Deletion of Morshu WP:CHEAP||WP:RFD Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
1388 8172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Basilico's User:Reywas92 15:48, 25 August 2021 (UTC) delete A sputtering of recent news due to the nutty owners' policy, but that doesn't exactly make the restaurant as a dining establishment notable. I would sort of compare this to Shooters Grill (Lauren_Boebert#Small_business_ownership) though she goes beyond the restaurant of course. Generic old routine local reviews fall under and don't establish notability Deletion of Basilico's WP:AUD Wikipedia:Notability 77
1389 10683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southern man User:Schwede66 18:29, 12 July 2017 (UTC) keep """I was inclined to |speedily close the AfD as a procedural keep, but the process does not appear to allow this to happen as the nomination is clearly made in good faith. The reason I was tempted to close this is that the deletion rationale put forward (""""unreferenced 8 years"""") does not meet any of the -REASON|14 reasons for deletion. There's no point editors discussing a rationale that does not allow us to delete the article. May I suggest, {{u|Kintetsubuffalo}}, that you thus withdraw the AfD? Alternatively, please expand on the rationale and put something forward that meets one of the 14 deletion reasons""" Deletion of Southern man WP:SCLOSE||WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
1390 10566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reza Malekzadeh (entrepreneur) User:Anton 06:55, 13 July 2021 (UTC) delete The sources are either directly promotional or are not sufficiently independent to be |reliable Deletion of Reza Malekzadeh (entrepreneur) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1391 20406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HQ Media User:SRX 22:57, 18 August 2008 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of HQ Media WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1392 249 [[Willi Gutmann]] (LAZ) Benutzer:Paulae NONE keep Immerhin: DNB-Eintrag, mehrere Großplastiken im öffentlichen Raum (scheint v.a. in den USA erfolgreich gewesen zu sein), diverse Ausstellungen außerhalb der Schweiz (u.a. Köln 1968, Johnson City USA 1974, Chicago ...), mehrere Publikationen zu Ausstellungen, folgt man Google Books. Alles in Allem eher . Für zeitgenössische Künstler gelten übrigens die , hier haben wir internationale (Einzel-)Ausstellungen und Ausstellungskataloge (einige über Google-Books aufrufbar). Preis der ETH-Zürich ist allerdings gemäß RK nicht relevanzgenerierend Löschung von Willi Gutmann Wikipedia:Richtlinien_Bildende_Kunst Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
1393 21787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Lee (trader) User:KleenupKrew 01:09, 22 April 2008 (UTC) delete per and general non-notability Deletion of David Lee (trader) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
1394 477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SolidCAM User:Lahiru_k 07:50, 26 September 2007 (UTC) keep """Despite the issue this software seems notable to me. I got Results 691 - 698 of about 265,000 for """"SolidCAM """" in google.http://www.google.com/search?q=%22SolidCAM+%22&hl=en&rlz=1B2GGGL_enLK208LK208&start=720&sa=N But obviously this article needs some sources to verify the content""" Deletion of SolidCAM WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
1395 14119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Santiago (2nd nomination) User:Warrah 19:05, 23 October 2009 (UTC) keep Recognition and honors by the Puerto Rican government plus coverage in several major newspapers would confirm requirements. However, I agree with DGG about editing the article into something much shorter Deletion of Tony Santiago (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1396 1054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vermin Supreme User:Qrsdogg 17:20, 7 June 2011 (UTC) keep Clearly a notable performance artist, easily passes otability (people): http://www.boston.com/news/globe/magazine/articles/2004/01/11/merry_prankster/http://swindlemagazine.com/issue18/vermin-supreme/http://www.concordmonitor.com/article/5-questions-for-vermin-supreme?&CSAuthResp=%3Asession%3ACSUserId|CSGroupId%3Aapproved%3ABA4A9537C4BF4594E11F4B09D8217743&CSUserId=94&CSGroupId=1http://www.washingtoncitypaper.com/articles/27812/running-gaghttp://news.google.com/newspapers?id=0qY8AAAAIBAJ&sjid=shQGAAAAIBAJ&pg=2434,2378853&dq=vermin-supreme&hl=enhttp://books.google.com/books?id=LqU8TZMMRQwC&pg=PA129&dq=%22Vermin+Supreme%22&hl=en&ei=NVzuTbyGJafz0gHeya3eAw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=6&ved=0CEAQ6AEwBQ#v=onepage&q=%22Vermin%20Supreme%22&f=false Deletion of Vermin Supreme WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1397 15981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Destiny (Matsuhashi Miki) User:C 05:43, 17 May 2008 (UTC) keep or '''redirect''' to Miki Matsuhashi for being performed multiple times on a famous TV show. It was the theme song for Case Closed (manga)|Detective Conan, one of the most famous anime (based on manga) still running in Japan, for 28 episodes. The single also reached #22 on Oricon, according to some websites, which shouldn't be too hard to check, I think. The first fact was already in article (I've now included the second), and |notability guidelines for music clearly recommend a merge/redirect rather than deletion in this case Deletion of Destiny (Matsuhashi Miki) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
1398 18100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gliese 169 User:David 00:08, 21 August 2013 (UTC) delete or redirect to List of stars in Taurus per . We already have a list of nearby stars and this one isn't near enough to be interesting in that respect Deletion of Gliese 169 WP:NASTRO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1399 16372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AAP 2014 Lok Sabha Candidates User:Redtigerxyz 06:30, 30 March 2014 (UTC) delete Though Wikipedia:Other stuff exists, Wikipedia is a Deletion of AAP 2014 Lok Sabha Candidates WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1400 11435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Kelly (Freeholder) (2nd nomination) User:Alansohn 05:41, 30 April 2007 (UTC) delete per nom; fails for notability of politicians. For my own part, I have been recently canvassed on AfDs where I have !voted against the editor who alerted me. While nom did alert me to this AfD, and is aware I supported deletion of a similar article, I've: (1) participated in hundreds of AfDs and would likely have chimed in on this one anyway, (2) feel this AfD is readily supported on the merits of the nomination, (3) have had Deletion of Joe Kelly (Freeholder) (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1401 2997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dean Cates User:Gongshow 20:53, 30 May 2012 (UTC) delete No significant coverage found, and roles to date do not appear to meet Deletion of Dean Cates WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1402 3825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The White Rose Society (website) user:Krich 02:29, 11 January 2006 (UTC) delete Does not meet the requirements of . Whether people love or hate the content on the site is irrelevant Deletion of The White Rose Society (website) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1403 10159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph C. Stevens Jr. User:Bart133 21:03, 6 September 2008 (UTC) delete per #G7|G7. Tagged as such Deletion of Joseph C. Stevens Jr. WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1404 7658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mobile Legends: Bang Bang User:Videogameplayer99 19:24, 25 February 2019 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Mobile Legends: Bang Bang WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1405 10866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Spagnola User:Colapeninsula 10:23, 15 January 2013 (UTC) keep Not the most important topic, but she's got multiple press reports about the drinking game, not all of which is about the |one event of her being sued over it - some is simply coverage of the music and game. She's notable per (for Power Hour) and Deletion of Ali Spagnola WP:ONEEVENT||WP:CREATIVE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1406 84 [[Bienenhäusle]] (erledigt) Benutzer:Phantomkommando NONE delete Bauwagen mag zwar cool sein, doch es gibt hier #Bauwerke_und_Denkmale|Relevanzkriterien Löschung von Bienenhäusle Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
1407 19193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Srila Bhaktivedanta Narayana Gosvami Maharaja User:Spiderone 17:29, 7 October 2020 (UTC) delete lacks the coverage required in multiple reliable secondary sources to pass ; a lot of the 'keep' votes from SPAs and meat puppets are not addressing Wikipedia policy Deletion of Srila Bhaktivedanta Narayana Gosvami Maharaja WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1408 6091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mustafa Ülgen User:Phil 16:48, 1 June 2009 (UTC) keep """The links above would seem to show that the subject passes . The article can easily fixed by a bit of copyediting and cutting the list of publications to just the most important ones. Conflict of interest is not a reason to delete, but simply for other editors to review content for neutrality - I, for one, have this on my watchlist now so I can help out with this. COI is also much less of a problem when it is disclosed. Dentists might not be as exciting as TV talent show contestants but it is possible to write encyclopedia articles about them. Just a couple of weeks ago I found an article tagged for deletion whose entire prose content was ''""""Sheldon Friel was an Irish dentist""""'' but I think (blowing my own trumpet) that I managed to turn it into a pretty decent start-class article. The only things stopping me from doing the same with this one are physical and linguistic access to sources - I doubt whether any of the sources for this subject would be available in my local library and even if they were I wouldn't be able to read them. The point of the additional notablity criteria such as is that they are strong indicators that reliable sources exist, even if they are not online and in English. We already have enough sources for |verifiability of the main facts in the article""" Deletion of Mustafa Ülgen WP:PROF||WP:PROF||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
1409 162 [[Benzin (Band)]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Tom md 10:32, 22. Jun. 2008 (CEST) delete Dann müsste das ganze wohl in die |Löschprüfung und . Da die Relevanz aber mittlerweile zugenommen hat, bitte in 7 tagen prüfen, ab Artikel gerechtfertigt Löschung von Benzin (Band) Wikipedia:LP Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1410 15044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Climate change denial (3rd nomination) User:23skidoo 13:09, 29 August 2008 (UTC) keep The nomination might have been withdrawn within an hour, but a review of the previous AFD and the one before it clearly shows in favor of keep, so unless the have been substantial changes to the article since the last AFD, I have to vote a procedural keep here as the article has now passed two AFD with snowballing Deletion of Climate change denial (3rd nomination) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
1411 9332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/To Boldly Go User:Eusebeus 11:34, 10 April 2008 (UTC) delete per the above. , , & violations make this anathema to a anything with even vaguely encyclopedic aspirations Deletion of To Boldly Go WP:RS||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1412 380 [[Lann Hornscheidt]] (LAE) Benutzer:Gonzo.Lubitsch NONE keep da Einschlusskritierien nach WP:RK#Autoren eindeutig erfüllt, zudem ordentliche Professorin (siehe #Wissenschaftler Löschung von Lann Hornscheidt Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
1413 5900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Historical deviations in Gladiator (2000 film) User:Erik 16:16, 10 January 2009 (UTC) merge """only'' content backed by |reliable sources that comment on the film through a historical lens to Gladiator (2000 film). Hard to believe that those who are voting """"keep"""" do not see that the article is mostly |synthesis because most of the sources in the article are not even related to the film. It's basically akin to picking up a history textbook and investigating the fallacies of a ''creative work'' on your own, so the claim that the article is """"well-referenced"""" is flawed. For such a high-profile film like this, there will be commentary by historians on the film itself, as evidenced by the smaller number of sources in the current article. There are also similar sources at the film article's historical section... when proper clean-up is done to purge synthesis, all useful information can be kept in that particular historical section. There is ''also'' the concern that this article is a since it focuses on how this film (remember, it is a creative work) does not match up to actual history and does not say what, if anything, Ridley Scott got right about depicting the time period""" Deletion of Historical deviations in Gladiator (2000 film) WP:RS||WP:SYN||WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1414 20295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inertial degravitation User:Gandalf61 15:58, 14 November 2007 (UTC) delete Contains nothing but |patent nonsense Deletion of Inertial degravitation WP:PN Wikipedia:Patent nonsense 105
1415 2642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Daily Dot User:Bearian 18:37, 14 March 2017 (UTC) comment as a |source the subject itself this is unreliable as they come. Whether it's notable is a matter of opinion since |what is significant coverage is subjective here Deletion of The Daily Dot WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1416 17883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colin Timms User:The 03:55, 18 December 2018 (UTC) keep Clear pass of Deletion of Colin Timms WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1417 16154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blood Oath (album) User:Esradekan 04:57, 23 October 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Blood Oath (album) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1418 12598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/About (singer) User:doomsdayer520 13:48, 31 August 2020 (UTC) delete """unless someone can deliver reliable sources that are translated from Korean to English. This guy's manager should advise him to change his stage name because it is hideously unsearchable in any language. Searching for his birth name in English (Jo Tae-kyoung) or stage name in Korean (어바웃) in conjunction with something like """"singer"""" brings up what look like exclusively Korean social media promotions and streaming sites, like those already in the article. I was unable to find an entry on him at Korean Wikipedia, but again I may have been thwarted by his pointless name. Even less comes up in sites that use English. Unless someone proficient in Korean can deliver something useful, I must conclude that this article is just an attempted |promotion for a singer with little media notice""" Deletion of About (singer) WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1419 18240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cecil Foster User:Bearcat 20:25, 13 January 2019 (UTC) delete """As always, the notability test for writers is not just the ability to technically verify that they and their work exist — it requires evidence of ''distinctions'', such as winning a notable literary award and/or receiving enough |reliable source coverage ''about him'' to clear . (And no, having been on the ''judging'' panel of a notable literary award is ''not'' a notability criterion.) But even on a ProQuest search for older media coverage that wouldn't Google, I wasn't able to find anything approaching what needs to be shown — I got a lot of hits where he was the bylined ''author'' of coverage about ''other'' things, which is not the kind of sourcing we're looking for, and virtually none where he was the ''subject'' of coverage written by other ''people'', which is the kind of sourcing that's actually required. Nothing here is """"inherently"""" notable enough to exempt an article about him from having to be referenced much better than this, but I simply can't find the kind of referencing he needs to have""" Deletion of Cecil Foster WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1420 7529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comikey User:Jumpytoo 19:25, 16 July 2021 (UTC) delete None of the sources provided or that I could find are independent enough (not derived from a press release) to meet . I also couldn't find a suitable merge or redirect target. However a category listing the series that they have licenses for may be a partial (ex. :Category:Viz Media manga or :Category:Yen Press titles Deletion of Comikey WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
1421 12807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conrad Abbott User:Bearcat 15:14, 9 February 2020 (UTC) delete """Indeed, I can also find zero sources which attest to anything about this purported executive. Even in the highly unlikely event that he ever did actually hold the claimed role, businesspeople aren't handed an automatic notability freebie in the ''absence'' of any |reliable source coverage about them in real media — this is ''exactly'' why I always harp on the fact that the notability test for people is not the things the article ''says'', but the quality and depth of the ''sourcing'' that can or can't be shown to ''support'' that the things it says are ''true''. But as the response thread on that N-Sider tweet reveals, the ''much'' more likely explanation here is that some random teenage gamergeek named Conrad Abbott decided to try to anoint himself a corporate president on a user-generated discussion forum for shits and giggles — and as noted by the nominator, all of the sources that """"support"""" the claim indeed took ''their'' information ''from us'', and thus aren't legitimate verification that he ever really held the role. A person who had actually been president of the Canadian division of a major multinational corporation would have gotten coverage in at least Canadian newspapers — as witness the fact that in the exact same database, I literally get ''hundreds'' of hits on """"Nintendo Canada"""" which ''do'' name senior executives with that company (such as Ron Bertram and Pierre-Paul Trépanier.) But in the entire past 40 years, the only """"Conrad Abbott"""" who has ever gotten one word of coverage in any Canadian newspaper was a non-notable second-place finisher in a local Kiwanis Music Festival, not a president of Nintendo Canada. Burn it with fire, and brimstone, and maybe even some |salt""" Deletion of Conrad Abbott WP:RS||WP:SALT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1422 8326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gamera 4: Truth User:Haeleth 10:48, 14 November 2006 (UTC) delete Fan films aren't inherently ''non-''notable, but nothing is inherently ''notable'' - everything must claim to be of note if it is to be included in an encyclopedia! But this article doesn't claim notability! More importantly, it doesn't cite any sources! And basically the entire article is a plot summary, which violates the policy! Which is why it should be deleted! &mdash Deletion of Gamera 4: Truth WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1423 18152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mass killings under Communist regimes (3rd nomination) User:LokiiT 00:56, 15 July 2010 (UTC) delete As others have pointed out, it's clearly a POV fork and the article is written almost entirely in . Moreover, the sole purpose of this article is to push a political agenda. I've never seen a more clear example on wikipedia and I'm very surprised that this article has survived for so long Deletion of Mass killings under Communist regimes (3rd nomination) WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
1424 18586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Journalisticity User:Grandmasterka 04:16, 8 June 2006 (UTC) delete Very POV neologism, no sources. Deletion of Journalisticity WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
1425 12861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leon Jordan User:Cullen328 05:32, 18 February 2012 (UTC) keep There is not a shadow of a doubt that this article should be kept. As a three-term member of the Missouri General Assembly , Leon Jordan meets and nothing more needs to be said. In addition, he was the most powerful African-American politician in Missouri when he was assassinated over 40 years ago, and his murder is still unsolved and discussed by reliable sources decades later. It would be a travesty to delete this article which instead should be improved and expanded. His relatively common name just requires slightly better research skills Deletion of Leon Jordan WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1426 6028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francys Johnson User:Splash 17:01, 3 September 2005 (UTC) delete Also, there is no assertion of notability here (stating a profession doesn't count), so this is an '''A7 speedy'''. His page at the Uni http://www.arches.uga.edu/~francys/ is blank, so he almost certainly fails the test and would fail the test if we had one Deletion of Francys Johnson WP:PROF||WP:PRIEST Wikipedia:Notability 77
1427 13435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dominique De Beau User:Pharaoh 04:03, 10 April 2015 (UTC) delete per nom fails and is upcoming but not notable at this point and lacks sources Deletion of Dominique De Beau WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1428 17926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kyan Laslett O'Brien User:RetiredDuke 20:26, 9 June 2019 (UTC) delete No significant coverage in reliable sources to pass , and falls short of the specific guideline (WP:COMPOSER Deletion of Kyan Laslett O'Brien WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1429 17610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grockle User:Pepper 00:17, 16 October 2010 (UTC) delete per . '''''Special:Contributions/Pepper Deletion of Grockle WP:DICTIONARY Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
1430 9283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eurotech Soccer Camp User:Pmedema 19:05, 2 December 2010 (UTC) delete WP:RS|Unsourced article with no claim to |notability Deletion of Eurotech Soccer Camp WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1431 15313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fag Army User:Rhododendrites 14:14, 8 January 2015 (UTC) delete Fag Army selectively to LGBT rights in Sweden (or possibly another similar target) (haven't looked at the other and agree they should not be tied together) - This is a pretty standard delete. Only news coverage for only one event only from the time around the event. is inapplicable: {{tq|There is a possibility that an organization that is generally not notable will have a number of references if they have engaged in illegal acts, or it is alleged that they have engaged in illegal acts. Sources which primarily discuss allegations of unlawfulness shall not be considered when assessing an organization's notability per this guideline. However, keep in mind that the organization may still be notable under separate guidelines (e.g., ).}} ...Going then to (and this same text applies to : {{tq|An event is presumed to be notable if it receives significant, non-routine coverage that persists over a period of time. Coverage should be in multiple reliable sources with national or global scope.}} (i.e. ). --&mdash Deletion of Fag Army WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:CRIME||WP:EVENT||WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1432 14350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Vandersteen User:GPL93 15:04, 10 March 2021 (UTC) delete Fails . Best Deletion of Mike Vandersteen WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1433 14325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of NCAA Men's Division I Elite Eight appearances by coach User:Maduwanwela 15:07, 20 May 2015 (UTC) delete per . Non-notable Deletion of List of NCAA Men's Division I Elite Eight appearances by coach WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1434 9550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ilmi Kitab Khana User:Adamant1 07:43, 28 February 2020 (UTC) delete No reliable sources have been added since like a week ago when the last person claimed the article was taking shape and it obviously without reliable sources being added. The ones currently there are complete garbage Deletion of Ilmi Kitab Khana WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1435 5542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OILiQuidzz User:Stuartyeates 09:32, 7 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of OILiQuidzz WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1436 20909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pokemon chaos black User:Lukeno94 00:30, 19 December 2013 (UTC) delete although it's perhaps the most notable Pokemon hack out there (I have a GBA cart with it on), it still doesn't satisfy notability guidelines. http://www.pokezam.com/games/fake/chaosblack/ is literally the only thing out there that might even come close to a with in-depth coverage, and its reliability is definitely undetermined at best. The article is terribly written to boot Deletion of Pokemon chaos black WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1437 1425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kieran Preston User:GiantSnowman 09:16, 28 May 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Kieran Preston WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1438 1002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC 2 User:Snotbot 09:40, 31 May 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 May 31 Deletion of UFC 2 WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1439 10916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hare and Billet User:Northamerica1000 13:25, 8 February 2014 (UTC) keep Initial source searches are already demonstrating |topic notability. For starters, read links at https://www.google.com/search?tbs=bks:1&q=%22Hare+and+Billet%22 Google Books, and then read news media sources Deletion of Hare and Billet WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1440 6080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle of the Median Border User:Reyk 05:52, 31 August 2008 (UTC) comment this belongs on fD|RfD, not AfD. I'm |putting it there now Deletion of Battle of the Median Border WP:R||WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Redirect 56
1441 18744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Israeli soldiers killed in 2014 Israel–Gaza conflict User:Clarityfiend 21:16, 1 September 2014 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a Deletion of List of Israeli soldiers killed in 2014 Israel–Gaza conflict WP:MEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1442 8553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reiko Nagase User:AggressiveNavel 08:23, 5 October 2015 (UTC) keep """It is the subject of |in-depth (significant) coverage across |reliable, |independent sources. Especially since the subject is only a series/company virtual idol mascot character whose sole spoken-line equivalent is a hidden message in 1 game. Including http://www.1up.com/features/all-about-reiko in 2006. She's also apart from the series from her many guest appearance after her enormous popularity made her a Namco mascot in general. And I don't even know what would make """"out-of-fictional-universe discussion"""" of a voiceless mascot would be if press reports of her huge popularity and the fans' big outrage for briefly removing her are not enough - a Tropes vs Women video about how Reiko makes Russians beat their wives? In fact everything there is """"out-of-fictional-universe discussion"""" as Reiko's role in the fictional universe of Ridge Racer is just being there (there's no plot). She's a virtual equivalent of a celebrity model, with the popularity that no real race queen (here are hundreds of their biographies in Japanese Wikipedia: https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:レースクイーン) has ever even come anywhere close to""" Deletion of Reiko Nagase WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1443 12178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tallest buildings in Columbia, Missouri User:Lightburst 00:09, 12 July 2019 (UTC) keep each individual building on the list can be referenced with a reliable source like: https://www.columbiatribune.com/1b0129be-fa72-52ea-b6eb-ffd3788bffca.html Jesse Hall - ''columbiatribune ref''. The list is relevant, and serves as a starting place for a researcher. As Djflem has stated, the article appears to satisfy Wikipedia:CSC. It seems any list of tall buildings is almost guaranteed to be sent to Afd as of late. I refer to the many tall building articles nominated for Afds: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tallest buildings in Aurora, Colorado|Aurora Colorado, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cities with the most high-rise buildings|Cities with the most high rises, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tallest buildings in Peoria |Peoria Ill Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tallest buildings in Metairie|Metairie, Louisiana, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/North Hudson, New Jersey|North Hudson NJ Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tallest buildings in Tysons, Virginia|Tysons VA. People around the world are fascinated by tall buildings. And as Grey Wanderer has staed: ''Some of the buildings are notable historically exactly because of their height''. Just as a tall person is notable for their Height. Regarding Emporis...it cannot be dismissed entirely. Emporis has its place in research...as a starting place for further research: exactly like Wikipedia and IMDB. An ambitious researcher can improve this article with reliable sources. Additional Note: Emporis does not yet appear on the list Deletion of List of tallest buildings in Columbia, Missouri WP:NEXIST||WP:UGC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1444 20823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Love and Some Swear Words User:Alpha3031 04:01, 5 August 2018 (UTC) keep as being preserved in a national archive meets Deletion of Love and Some Swear Words WP:NFO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1445 20387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samir Masimov (2nd nomination) User:Sir 01:56, 23 May 2014 (UTC) delete per #G4. Nothing has changed in the last four weeks. He's played a few more matches, but since the Azerbaijan Premier League is not confirmed as |fully-pro, this does not confer notability under . The coverage he has received continues only to be routine sports journalism insufficient for Deletion of Samir Masimov (2nd nomination) WP:CSD||WP:FPL||WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1446 15147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Concordia Preparatory School (Utah) User:Arxiloxos 19:31, 11 October 2017 (UTC) keep """and consider renaming as Salt Lake Lutheran High School. I accept, for the purposes of this discussion, that evidence of notability is needed. And this is not as obvious a case as, for example, the recent discussions at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rouse High School and its subsequent Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2017 October 2|deletion review, since this was not a public school, and evidently smaller. But this was also not one of the tiny or nearly unverifiable schools that were the focus of the recent and laboriously argued https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=767023947#RfC_on_secondary_school_notability RfC. Here we have substantial coverage in regional media of the sort that consensus has long accepted as being sufficient to establish that a school passes --especially (though not only) during the decades of its existence as Salt Lake Lutheran. Yes, quite a bit of it is sports, but certainly not just line scores http://archive.sltrib.com/article.php?id=51667472&itype=CMSIDhttps://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-7201829.htmlhttp://archive.sltrib.com/article.php?id=52863742&itype=CMSID. The RfC closure expressly acknowledged that """"schools are special"""", and the discussion makes clear that coverage in local media can still be enough to meet the notability threshhold""" Deletion of Concordia Preparatory School (Utah) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1447 17543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of re-cut trailers User:Pax 18:33, 30 May 2007 (UTC) delete Textbook violation of #LINK. Wikipedia is not an internet directory Deletion of List of re-cut trailers WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1448 16468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Catapultism User:Qrsdogg 16:13, 20 July 2011 (UTC) delete Clearly fails Deletion of Catapultism WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
1449 7221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beefcake (band) User:On 00:19, 19 February 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Beefcake (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1450 278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Yager User:Jakejr 21:23, 23 December 2012 (UTC) delete I don't see how people keep saying he meets when he has one fight for a top tier organization and is currently competing for a minor promotion. As I said at an earlier AfD discussion--exhibition fights don't count, just like the sparring partner of a champion boxer can't claim he fought for that boxer's title Deletion of Jamie Yager WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
1451 5022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Semboga Roy User:onel5969 03:08, 11 August 2021 (UTC) delete Not enough in-depth coverage in-depth coverage to meet Deletion of Semboga Roy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1452 16806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Harrin User:Samsmachado 01:14, 4 December 2020 (UTC) delete There are some hits on Google News, but nothing that seems reliable/neutral/secondary (etc.). In the absence of sources, she doesn't meet /. I don't know what SNGs to even begin to try to fit her under because of the complete lack of information Deletion of Elizabeth Harrin WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1453 9703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthias Schmelz [[User talk:Alphachimp|'''Alphachimp''']] 04:08, 13 November 2006 (UTC) delete Does not meet with current sourcing. The fact that de.wiki does not have an article should be somewhat indicative of his importance Deletion of Matthias Schmelz WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1454 2302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Late july 2009 severe storms User:Rodhullandemu 21:00, 23 May 2010 (UTC) delete poorly-sourced single event with no long-term or widespread effects. Fails as well as Deletion of Late july 2009 severe storms WP:LOCAL||WP:N Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
1455 11590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jay Dave User:Joe 20:57, 31 August 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |chef Deletion of Jay Dave WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1456 14564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brent Watkins [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 02:42, 13 November 2013 (UTC) delete obvious / with dishonest sock-puppetry thrown in for good measure. Want an article about yourself? Take it to . But I don't think the subject meets given the limited geographical scope of the sources in question Deletion of Brent Watkins WP:COI||WP:AUTOBIO||WP:RA||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
1457 6246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti-Americanism in various countries User:LinaMishima 00:46, 10 September 2006 (UTC) delete """We are free to remove unreferenced material from articles without any discussion, ahnks to . Most of the references I noted earlier did not actually support the article itself, and so instead we would be left with ''""""In the Second World War hundreds of thousands of American troops were stationed in Australia, introducing new products and ideas to the isolated British dominion. The relatively more affluent and carefree nature ('Over-sexed, over-paid and over here') of the Americans jarred with the sensibilities of some Australians1. There were some demonstrations marking President Bush's state visit to Britain, although The Guardian2 reported that the vast majority of British people supported the visit.""""'' (external links not copied, but do support). Whilst Anti-American is clearly a real, supported and definable term, this article is actually quite laughably under-referenced. Remove as per the powers of : """"Any edit lacking a source may be removed"""". This is not to say however that I object to the article's concept - just do it right, with references""" Deletion of Anti-Americanism in various countries WP:VERIFY||WP:VERIFY Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1458 7257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jorge B. Vargas Museum and Filipiniana Research Center User:E 19:46, 6 September 2016 (UTC) keep This is an actual museum. has nothing to do with an actual museum housed on the campus of a University. Move to KEEP this on the grounds that the Nom is mistaken Deletion of Jorge B. Vargas Museum and Filipiniana Research Center WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1459 18569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katagory V User:CastAStone 20:10, 28 April 2008 (UTC) delete No ''assertion'' of notability, true. The band has been the subject of tangential mentions in major publications and major mentions in tangential publications. Fail and Deletion of Katagory V WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
1460 8992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hands on Me (Ariana Grande song) User:Sergecross73 19:20, 25 August 2016 (UTC) delete Fails , virtually no content present, and what is there, is the equivent of someone converting an infobox/track list to prose. Better covered in respective album article Deletion of Hands on Me (Ariana Grande song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1461 9850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Academic psychologist User:Hijiri88 14:00, 3 January 2019 (UTC) merge """to Psychologist. Redundant |content fork, since much more information on academic psychologists is already included in the main article, and the distinction """"academic"""" appears to be used primarily to distinguish psychologists from psychiatrists in publications aimed at laymen who hear """"psychologist"""" and the image that jumps to mind is ''Frasier'', but this distinction is one we already make with our separate psychologist and psychiatrist articles. Andrew's claim above and in his https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Academic_psychologist&diff=876610629&oldid=876604150 edit summary to have """"rewritten"""" the page is misleading, as what he really did was blank it and replace it with a single sentence that made it an even more useless content fork than before""" Deletion of Academic psychologist WP:CONTENTFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
1462 15748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quepasa User:Perfecto 23:14, 11 December 2005 (UTC) keep Did the nominator even pause to check if the site meets ? Its Alexa rank is 6,194. As per Grue, show me evidence that this is not notable. -- Deletion of Quepasa WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1463 7548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pickle Barrel User:HighKing 18:23, 26 October 2019 (UTC) delete I am unable to locate any |significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, fails GNG Deletion of Pickle Barrel WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
1464 9361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acuro Organics Limited User:AuthorWiki99 10:46, 5 July 2019 (UTC) delete Not notable enough as an organization Deletion of Acuro Organics Limited WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1465 3664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Age of Chivalry (Mod) User:Sting_au 06:46, 30 December 2007 (UTC) delete blatant advertising. Fails . The whole article reads like an advertisment Deletion of Age of Chivalry (Mod) WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1466 15480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MultiSpace [[User talk:202.124.75.11|talk]]) 21:57, 9 December 2011 (UTC) delete """as non-notable . The term with '''this''' meaning seems to occur only in the original book (there are other unrelated meanings of """"multispace""""). -- Special:Contributions/202.124.75.11|202.124.75.11""" Deletion of MultiSpace WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
1467 14199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Woobie User:Malo 05:22, 27 October 2005 (UTC) delete many google results mostly seem to infer a different meaning. I don't believe this constitues as being wiktionary material. Also a dictionary, much less a non notable slang dictionary Deletion of Woobie WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1468 18449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Operator (2015 film) User:Hitcher 22:39, 20 July 2020 (UTC) keep per ; the film has been mentioned by https://www.refinery29.com/en-us/2015/11/96802/mischa-barton-new-movie-operator Refinery 29, https://deadline.com/2014/08/ving-rhames-operator-threshold-clavius-823149/ Deadline Hollywood and https://patch.com/california/imperialbeach/operator-dials-dvd Patch Deletion of Operator (2015 film) WP:NFSOURCES Wikipedia:Notability 77
1469 2025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew K. Ruotolo (2nd nomination) User:E 19:12, 14 August 2018 (UTC) keep for pretty much the same reasons editors gave for iVoting to KEEP last winter. And because it reliably sourced and passes Deletion of Andrew K. Ruotolo (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1470 14222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Republic of Texas (1861) User:Kinu 05:41, 11 October 2010 (UTC) delete """Based on the research provided herein (as well as my own), there appears to be no source indicating that the term """"Republic of Texas"""" was used again for the entity of Texas between secession from the Union and joining of the Confederacy. As it stands, this article violates """ Deletion of Republic of Texas (1861) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1471 12159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oberlin Academy Preparatory School User:SportingFlyer 05:02, 11 February 2019 (UTC) comment Moseyed here from DRV. Two points. 1) Can one of the keep !voters explain which the best sources for keeping this article are? I leaning merge, but these are difficult sources to sift through. 2) The article has expanded quite a bit since it was nominated per , but I'm distressed this was moved from AfC before it should have been. We should not be accepting or denying articles based on who created the article, but rather on the content of the article Deletion of Oberlin Academy Preparatory School WP:THREE||WP:HEY Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1472 5556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nike Davis User:Doc 16:50, 17 December 2006 (UTC) keep Seems to meet standards for ; notability is claimed and established Deletion of Nike Davis WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1473 2528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Health Shield User:Drchriswilliams 21:09, 1 July 2016 (UTC) delete The article seems entirely promotional. Like the other editors that have commented here, I searched but couldn't find any coverage in reliable sources. Notability has not been established, when judged according to or Deletion of Health Shield WP:COMPANY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1474 11243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baby killer User:Stifle 09:37, 7 March 2011 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Baby killer WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
1475 19287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deniz Akdeniz User:DustFormsWords 06:07, 16 June 2010 (UTC) delete Personal dispute above notwithstanding, I am unable to find significant coverage for this actor sufficient to found a meaningful encyclopedic article. Without such coverage, whether or not he passes , it is not possible to write a verifiable encyclopedic article on the topic. No prejudice against recreation, possibly after ''Tomorrow When The War Began'' is released and more coverage is (presumably) generated Deletion of Deniz Akdeniz WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1476 5184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Straight marriage User:Penelope 03:25, 1 July 2006 (UTC) delete and DO NOT REDIRECT. Redirection would encourage people to do this sort of thing for the sake of Deletion of Straight marriage WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
1477 6738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Composite Number Factoring Theorem User:Nsk92 19:35, 30 November 2010 (UTC) delete pure Deletion of Composite Number Factoring Theorem WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1478 16757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agrarian Bonds in Peru User:Staszek 21:47, 24 February 2016 (UTC) keep AfD . Huge parts of the text are factual. 'Advocacy' may be fixed much more easily than the 'Great Wrong' which look like it was Deletion of Agrarian Bonds in Peru WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1479 13274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/German Inland Waterways Museum User:SW3 22:27, 15 June 2014 (UTC) keep meets /. It's in travel guides like Lonely Planet Deletion of German Inland Waterways Museum WP:NGO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1480 20029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parbhu Dayal Yadav User:Nomadicghumakkad 10:05, 1 July 2021 (UTC) delete The Shilp Guru award might have helped for but it would work only in presence of other sources. Simply receiving the award won't grant an automatic notability Deletion of Parbhu Dayal Yadav WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1481 4027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tsunami solutions User:CNMall41 05:45, 20 April 2019 (UTC) delete Fails . Not to be confused with https://www.courant.com/business/hc-main-street-tsunami-solutions-20160616-story.html this one. There's nothing that comes close to Deletion of Tsunami solutions WP:NCORP||WP:ORGCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1482 15660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Masonda Ketada Olivier User:Srijanx22 10:55, 12 May 2019 (UTC) delete None of the sources including the ones recently provided debunk the rationale that the subject fails and . The votes above largely depend on misrepresentation of Deletion of Murder of Masonda Ketada Olivier WP:NOTNEWS||WP:LASTING||WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1483 11157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Planet Rugby Chat Forum User:Agnte 17:35, 8 December 2005 (UTC) delete article and transfer salvageable content into Planet Rugby. By itself does not meet Deletion of Planet Rugby Chat Forum WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1484 7609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Talend (2nd nomination) User:Huon 22:40, 7 December 2018 (UTC) comment """regarding the presented sources, the WSJ is semi-helpful, Le Monde more so, but the others are interviews with the CEO (not independent coverage of the company), a kind of """"case study"""" that doesn't discuss Talend the company in any detail, and books about their software that mention the company in passing at best. The Forbes piece is not by staff but by a """"contributor"""", effectively a blogger hosted by Forbes but not under Forbes' editorial control; that's not a |reliable source""" Deletion of Talend (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1485 3567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A. A. Khan (academician) User:Phil 17:02, 23 May 2012 (UTC) comment """I contested deletion because I thought that there was an important issue of interpretation here that requires discussion. When criterion 6 refers to a """"major academic institution"""" does it mean a world-renowned research institution, which Ranchi University may not be, or an institution that teaches lots of students, which it certainly is""" Deletion of A. A. Khan (academician) WP:PROD||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
1486 16093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011 Virginia Tech shooting User:LoveUxoxo 23:03, 8 December 2011 (UTC) delete """please see , every other !keep vote is some variation of """"it's in the headlines"""" or """"major news event"""". What presumption of notability do you think applies in this case? Every """"too early to tell if this is notable"""" !keep vote I feel is a """"too early to have this article"""" argument. The onus is on the article to clearly show notability, now. If there was some reasonable chance that this incident would be notable a year from now I'd be open-minded. But there isn't, and no expertise is required in appreciating that - it's the way the news and world is today. I blame Jimbo Wales for lack of sufficient branding of Wikinews, where an article on 2 related deaths by firearm (OMG!) created hours after the event would be less inappropriate""" Deletion of 2011 Virginia Tech shooting WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1487 3511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Regard (DJ) User:The 03:20, 23 December 2019 (UTC) keep """does meet the """"Has had a single or album on any country's national music chart"""" criteria of , specifically for """"Ride It"""" which was number 2 on the https://www.officialcharts.com/chart-news/tones-i-takes-on-regard-for-this-weeks-number-1__27374/ official UK charts. It does appear that Regard might be a """"one-hit wonder"""" as this appears to be the only significant things he's done. But he is covered in multiple |reliable sources, so does meet as well, for example coverage in https://www.bbc.com/news/newsbeat-49856548 BBC, https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-features/jay-sean-ride-it-regard-viral-tiktok-876545/ Rolling Stone, https://celebmix.com/exclusive-interview-dj-regard-discusses-the-success-behind-ride-it/ Celeb Mix. The article is poorly written, but the subject is, I think, notable""" Deletion of Regard (DJ) WP:NMUSIC||WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1488 4251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Debra Dean User:The 20:36, 1 June 2018 (UTC) keep since subject meets , unless my brain cells are playing games again Deletion of Debra Dean WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1489 21702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aimee Ng User:7 12:34, 16 March 2021 (UTC) keep notable enough for reasons cited above. She is a prolific writer and an important scholar. She is a prolific interviewer and appears often in art related productions on YouTube. https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=aimee+ng&qpvt=aimee+ng&FORM=VDRE Amy Ng videos Not the article it was when https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Aimee_Ng&oldid=1007169507 nominated for deletion. And we should all recall that it had been freshly created only a week before. It ought to be given time and space to grow and fluorish. reserve, ot paper Deletion of Aimee Ng WP:HEY||WP:P||WP:N Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
1490 20055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013–14 flu season User:Kingofaces43 21:07, 11 July 2019 (UTC) delete No indication this particular season was outside the norm. This is kind of similar to how heat wave articles have been handled at AfD. The even can be a big deal each year, but not inherently noteworthy because there is an expected baseline every year. Sources need to demonstrate something particularly for that year to even begin discussing notability Deletion of 2013–14 flu season WP:DUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1491 60 [[Gebr. Klöcker]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:S.Didam NONE comment Offensichtlich ist die Firma nach den Kriterien nicht #Wirtschaftsunternehmen|relevant. , um eine historische Relevanz zu belegen Löschung von Gebr. Klöcker Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
1492 5568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Sheldon (writer) User:Chetsford 02:01, 9 February 2020 (UTC) delete insufficient sources demonstrated to pass Deletion of Lee Sheldon (writer) WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1493 12140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christine Kuo [[User talk:147.8.102.172|talk]]) — [[Special:Contributions/147.8.102.172|147.8.102.172]] ([[User talk:147.8.102.172|talk]]) has made [[Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|few or no other edits]] outside this topic. and probably a sock 07:28, 21 February 2012 (UTC) keep Notability is apparent. Don't nominate just because . Special:Contributions/147.8.102.172|147.8.102.172 Deletion of Christine Kuo WP:IDLI Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1494 19966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silence of the Heart User:MichaelQSchmidt 16:36, 3 August 2011 (UTC) keep and close. At the time of nomination, an article from http://www.nytimes.com/1984/10/11/arts/3-tv-films-on-suicide-by-youths.html The New York Times was already IN the article as a source. And in using even minimal , it was easy to find in-depth coverage over several yearshttp://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%27%27Silence+of+the+Heart%22%2C+%22Chad+Lowe%22&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&btnG=Search+Archives in such as http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=_ntAAAAAIBAJ&sjid=XlcMAAAAIBAJ&pg=1098,5951050&dq=silence+of+the+heart+chad+lowe&hl=en The Vindicator http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=xwQsAAAAIBAJ&sjid=S20FAAAAIBAJ&pg=1313,7384524&dq=silence+of+the+heart+chad+lowe&hl=en Kentucky New Era http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=s4wwAAAAIBAJ&sjid=D4wDAAAAIBAJ&pg=2531,1567140&dq=silence+of+the+heart+chad+lowe&hl=en Free Lance-Star http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=6z1WAAAAIBAJ&sjid=--kDAAAAIBAJ&pg=6677,474991&dq=silence+of+the+heart+chad+lowe&hl=en Gainesville Sun http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=H4UiAAAAIBAJ&sjid=36kFAAAAIBAJ&pg=1382,9948612&dq=silence+of+the+heart+chad+lowe&hl=en Sumter Daily http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=pc9PAAAAIBAJ&sjid=-wYEAAAAIBAJ&pg=6492,695091&dq=silence+of+the+heart+chad+lowe&hl=en Ocala Star-Banner http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=SL&p_theme=sl&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0EB327769439B5A2&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM St. Louis Post-Dispatch http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=Ia9RAAAAIBAJ&sjid=9W0DAAAAIBAJ&pg=5468,7090780&dq=silence+of+the+heart+chad+lowe&hl=en Pittsburgh Post-Gazette http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=PI&s_site=philly&p_multi=PI&p_theme=realcities&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0EB2988013C14E3D&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM Philadelphia Inquirer http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/chicagotribune/access/24462864.html?dids=24462864:24462864&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Oct+30%2C+1991&author=Nancy+Randle%2C+a+Los+Angeles+free-lance+writer.&pub=Chicago+Tribune+(pre-1997+Fulltext)&desc=Key+%60Life+Goes+On'+episode+aimed+at+awakening+teens&pqatl=google Chicago Tribune http://www.nytimes.com/1984/10/30/arts/silence-of-the-heart-teen-age-suicide.html New York Times http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=kmcaAAAAIBAJ&sjid=GioEAAAAIBAJ&pg=7205,9239006&dq=silence+of+the+heart+chad+lowe&hl=en Milwaukee Journal and '''many''' more, as well as write-ups in several books.http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rls=com.microsoft%3Aen-US&tbm=bks&q=%27%27Silence+of+the+Heart%22%2C+%2B%22Chad+Lowe%22&btnG=Search&oq=%27%27Silence+of+the+Heart%22%2C+%2B%22Chad+Lowe%22&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&gs_sm=s&gs_upl=0l0l0l3000l0l0l0l0l0l0l0l0ll0l0 Easily found reviews in multiple reliable sources meets , even if the nominator failed to find them in his looking and even if they are all not used to source the article. Deletion is never the answer for notable topics that may only use a minimum of the many sources so readily available. For THAT, we use |regular editing Deletion of Silence of the Heart WP:BEFORE||WP:RS||WP:NF||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1495 9069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of passport offices in India User:Aspirex 22:26, 2 January 2016 (UTC) delete agree with nominator, definitely a violation Deletion of List of passport offices in India WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1496 13318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pradyumana Khokle User:Sodabottle 10:15, 20 January 2010 (UTC) delete """Gscoholar returns two http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&safe=off&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&q=Pradyumana%20W.%20Khokle&aql=&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=ws hits for """"Pradyumana W. Khokle"""". Getcited shows http://www.getcited.org/mbrz/11060041 1 journal article and 2 working papers. He has been covered in the passing in mainstream indian media - http://www.indianexpress.com/news/iima-students-to-study-problems-in-rural-areas-recommend-suggestions/568876/0 indian express, http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/course-for-armed-forces-planned-across-nation/261679/ business standard1, http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/it-firms-bypass-iim-course-for-defence-personnel/331817/ business standard2, http://www.dnaindia.com/academy/report_b-is-for-bihar-school-learning-for-iima-grads_1336508 DNA. I dont think this is enough to meet """ Deletion of Pradyumana Khokle WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1497 5358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Mohammad Pshtdar User:David 17:30, 27 July 2014 (UTC) delete """for lack of evidence of passing . Google scholar does find some of his works under the name """"Poshtdar"""" but not with enough citations to be worth much for notability""" Deletion of Ali Mohammad Pshtdar WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1498 9084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dragan Nikoli%u0107 (war criminal) User:BCoates 13:11, 1 December 2006 (UTC) keep """Labelling someone primarily famous for being convicted of crimes against humanity a """"commander"""" is POV, or at least weasel-wording. We can't drop the disambiguating suffix entirely, and this one fits well enough. doesn't require us to whitewash history, of if it does, it's faulty""" Deletion of Dragan Nikoli%u0107 (war criminal) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
1499 10569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erudition User:XOR 15:40, 28 June 2021 (UTC) delete """per . It ''is'' a little more than a dictionary definition; unfortunately, what it adds to the definition is not encyclopedia material. We get an argument-from-etymology fallacy, a bit of personal opinion, and a paragraph of """"I, too, majored in Western Lit"""". It's all unsourced (tagged as such since 2012!), and if sources for the claims of fact were dug up, it would be . Improving the article to the point where |it would be worth keeping would amount to rewriting it from scratch""" Deletion of Erudition WP:TNT||WP:SYNTH||WP:HEY Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
1500 20875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moses Inwang User:Edison 17:31, 30 December 2015 (UTC) keep """https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Moses+Inwang%22&tbm=nws Search results above indicate that he has lots of coverage in Nigerian publications for his movies, some of which have won awards of one sort or another. That said, I am not familiar with the quality of those publications (are they |reliable and independent?) nor with the prominence of the awards. """"Nollywood"""" gets less coverage in the US media than Hollywood. One of his films wonhttp://pulse.ng/movies/the-last-3-digits-moses-inwangs-movie-to-hit-cinemas-in-november-id4303141.html """"Best International Film"""" at 2 film festivals (in the US and in Europe), but I never heard of the festivals""" Deletion of Moses Inwang WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
1501 16534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Am The Sea User:Fortuna 10:36, 22 January 2017 (UTC) keep the song has clearly entered a lexicography beyond merely that of 'popular' music. And specifically for our purposes, it passes , as it has been the '''subject''' ('non-trivial treatment and excludes mere mention of the song/single, its musician/band or of its publication, price listings and other non-substantive detail treatment') of '''multiple''' ('plenty' suffices here) '''non-trivial''' (philosphical?) sources. And since these sources pass and provide significicant, third party coverage, is passed also. Worth noting in passing that to redirect to ''Quadrophenia'' would endow this song with in that article Deletion of I Am The Sea WP:NSONG||WP:DEPTH||WP:GNG||WP:UNDUEWEIGHT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1502 2336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shifty Eyes User:The 10:45, 2 September 2018 (UTC) delete per nomination, since subject |verifiably fails Deletion of Shifty Eyes WP:V||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1503 14189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tien Shinhan User:Suigetsu 00:41, 8 October 2008 (UTC) merge """Look, the """"notability"""" JJJ thinks he's asserted is a bunch of Google hits to fansites and completely unrelated shit that doesn't do anything for the article. I understand that you're angry that we don't want an article on a character as worthless as Tien, but don't try to worm your way out of things by claiming that it's a capitalist plot and Sephiroth and Collectonian are out to get you. Wikipedia is not the Matrix, and even if it was it wouldn't change the fact that no matter how many """"keep"""" votes you get your friends to post on here, it won't change the fact that the article fails all guidelines and by definition '''must be merged""" Deletion of Tien Shinhan WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1504 20500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noruwa Agho User:Alvaldi 22:56, 5 August 2021 (UTC) keep passes with the sources in the article, such as these from https://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/08/sports/ncaabasketball/08columbia.html The New York Times and https://www.nj.com/college-basketball/2010/01/former_st_joseph_peddie_star_noruwa_agho_leading_nation_in_3-pointers_made_for_columbia.html The Star Ledger Deletion of Noruwa Agho WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1505 445 [[Freundeskreis Polozk]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Gerbil NONE delete Wie vom Antragsteller geäußert, ist keine enzyklopädische Relevanz gemäß #Vereine ersichtlich, d.h. weder wurde eine signifikante Mitgliederzahl behauptet oder belegt, noch ist eine überregionale Bedeutung anzunehmen oder behauptet worden, und eine besondere Tradition ist angesichts der engen Aufgabenstellung trotz der z.T. seit längerem bestehenden Vereine ebenfalls nicht zu erkennen Löschung von Freundeskreis Polozk Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
1506 2172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noémie Lafrance User:Joe 13:24, 8 May 2010 (UTC) keep Passes Deletion of Noémie Lafrance WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1507 20208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur Canham User:Bearian 22:35, 15 June 2010 (UTC) keep per DGG, and as follows. Trade commissioenrs have, |in the past been considered notable as sub-cabinet officials. Ghits are not helpful for a man who flourished 100 years ago. The |references cited are reliable. This is not a BLP, nor a hoax Deletion of Arthur Canham WP:OUTCOMES||WP:RS Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1508 12874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Hunting Party (Judge Dredd story) User:2pou 23:08, 8 October 2020 (UTC) comment """https://dreddreviews.blogspot.com/2012/06/hunting-party.html This review is pretty good, but I'm on the fence. It's self-published, but I'd say its from an expert in the field having published two books. That said it is only one source (if that), so I'm abstaining temporarily, just wanted to throw that out for consideration. It can't sustain an article alone per #5, though. I'll likely recommend a redirect to Judge Dredd: The Mega Collection since it is already listed (iss.64/vol.41), and it doesn't appear """"major"""" enough to merge to the the main """"Major storylines"""" section""" Deletion of The Hunting Party (Judge Dredd story) WP:SELFSOURCE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1509 16472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Obasi Igwe User:CASSIOPEIA 17:53, 8 January 2018 (UTC) delete """fails and weak claims on """"respectable number of publications"""" under #C1 nor achieves any signification impact in the field he practices""" Deletion of Obasi Igwe WP:NACADEMIC||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1510 2906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Actaeon Films User:Tree 09:59, 30 June 2006 (UTC) delete per and . Only 494 Google results http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Actaeon+Films%22 Deletion of Actaeon Films WP:CORP||WP:ADS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1511 3415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Solaris Effect User:Stifle 20:47, 20 September 2008 (UTC) delete The article does not |cite accessible, |reliable sources and as such I am unable to |verify that this term is used Deletion of The Solaris Effect WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1512 20695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013 Perlis FA season User:Cloudz679 11:38, 9 November 2013 (UTC) comment per the rationale above, because it relates to a season in a non-fully professional league. I haven't looked at the other articles you linked but |other stuff exists Deletion of 2013 Perlis FA season WP:OSE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1513 3743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Line-Up Changes on AT&T U-verse from the 2010s User:Wikipedical 06:10, 30 September 2018 (UTC) delete per nom, data table completely violates Deletion of List of Line-Up Changes on AT&T U-verse from the 2010s WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1514 15711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JC I User:Nyttend 14:37, 20 December 2013 (UTC) delete I don't know anything about how to search for reliable sources covering popculture topics, so I also can't agree or disagree with the suggestions of hoaxing. However, the nominator's clearly done the source-searching without finding anything, so I can't imagine how this guy passes our |inclusion standards. Recreate if he gets coverage in places like books or academic journals Deletion of JC I WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1515 6991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glenn E. Ratcliff User:Mus 16:12, 19 March 2007 (UTC) delete as non-notable. Wikipedia is #MEMORIAL|not a memorial Deletion of Glenn E. Ratcliff WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1516 16503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BtVS as pastiche User:Kuru 22:45, 22 July 2006 (UTC) delete looks like just a collection of trivia with a dash of . The bullet points seem to be included in the episode articles as trivia already, so I'm not sure content merging is needed Deletion of BtVS as pastiche WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1517 18735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vicki Taylor User:Joe 22:59, 20 November 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Vicki Taylor WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1518 8034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucy's Retired Surfer's Bar User:Jauerback 14:03, 13 July 2007 (UTC) delete Fails , but certainly meets Deletion of Lucy's Retired Surfer's Bar WP:CORP||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
1519 13060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jocelyne Couture-Nowak (5th nomination) User:Mscuthbert 00:52, 7 December 2007 (UTC) comment """Indeed, though I think in fairness to people who have !voted """"Delete"""" in the other 4 nominations, we should let the process play out for the full five days. It looks like Keep is coming out strongly, but not sure applies to the fifth nomination after four """"no consensus"""" closings""" Deletion of Jocelyne Couture-Nowak (5th nomination) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
1520 15617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael K. Faught User:Agricolae 03:28, 4 May 2011 (UTC) delete It is either blatant self-promotion or blatant . The cites are all to his own cv, or his published papers, which essentially represents the primary record here (hence the OR). There is no evidence that the subject has received any independent coverage Deletion of Michael K. Faught WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1521 15466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle of Wolf 359 (2 nomination) User:Beeblebrox 16:55, 20 July 2009 (UTC) comment That it is an important event within the Star Trek universe or canon or whatever you want to call it is not in doubt. What we are talking about here is independent |notability in ''the real world'' as established, like every other article, by coverage in |reliable sources independent of the subject. So, saying keep because it's important to Star Trek fans is not a valid argument Deletion of Battle of Wolf 359 (2 nomination) WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1522 19545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdul Qodir Jaelani User:Paulmcdonald 02:12, 3 October 2016 (UTC) delete I know nothing of the subject. However, a simple search of online news sources normally considered reliable and independent show that there are none that I can find. For example, top listings in google are the Wikipeida article in question, some youtube videos, pintrest, etc. I cannot find any measure of notability that we use here. I admit that I am not qualified to review the sources in the article so I will |assume good faith with another individual's assessment. If they are found worthy, feel free to strike my position in this AFD. I won't be insulted Deletion of Abdul Qodir Jaelani WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
1523 16852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crew of Breaking Bad User:Sandstein 06:42, 3 August 2011 (UTC) merge selectively to Breaking Bad. The main article can still accommodate it and there's no evidence that the topic of the crew as such meets Deletion of Crew of Breaking Bad WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1524 14675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Internet Explorer 11 User:NinjaRobotPirate 01:21, 22 October 2013 (UTC) merge to Internet Explorer. This article seems to mostly serve as a version history, in opposition to . As a redundant and unnecessary fork, deletion is also acceptable Deletion of Internet Explorer 11 WP:CHANGELOG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1525 8438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Textbookunion.com User:Arbustoo 00:26, 4 April 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails and Deletion of Textbookunion.com WP:WEB||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1526 21387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Last Airbender User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:43, 26 December 2008 (UTC) keep as there seems to be more than http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rls=com.microsoft%3Aen-us%3AIE-SearchBox&rlz=1I7DVXA&q=%22The+Last+Airbender%22&btnG=Search enough significant coverage over the last couple years per the |general notability guidelines to qualify under : http://www.slashfilm.com/2008/04/15/m-night-shyamalans-the-last-airbender-gets-release-date-avatar-dropped-from-title/ Slash Film, http://www.firstshowing.net/2008/12/10/m-night-shyamalan-finally-casts-the-last-airbender/ First Showing, http://www.filmschoolrejects.com/news/m-night-paints-the-last-airbender-white.php Film School Rejects, http://www.mania.com/m-night-shyamalan-to-direct-avatar-last-airbender_article_53268.html Mania.com, http://hollywoodinsider.ew.com/2008/12/shyamalan-casts.html Entertainment Weekly, http://www.variety.com/article/VR1117956950.html?categoryid=13&cs=1 Variety, http://www.allheadlinenews.com/articles/7013358221 All Headline News, http://www.movieweb.com/news/NEkVUppt2hVans Movie Web, http://www.empireonline.com/news/story.asp?NID=22380 Empire Online, http://www.aintitcool.com/node/39400 Ain't It Cool, http://www.collider.com/entertainment/interviews/article.asp/aid/5414/tcid/1 Collider, http://io9.com/5014999/the-last-airbender-will-be-m-night-shyamalans-star-wars io9.com, http://www.mnightfans.com/ M. Night fans, http://www.comingsoon.net/films.php?id=44129 Coming Soon, et al Deletion of The Last Airbender WP:GNG||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1527 18765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rich Christiansen User:Tokyogirl79 06:05, 20 October 2011 (UTC) delete His previous book wasn't notable and despite his next book being published through a more reputable publisher, there is no way of knowing if that book will make him notable. (See ) I think that the article's creator (whomever he may be IRL) jumped the gun because at this time the author is not notable Deletion of Rich Christiansen WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1528 238 [[Undress to the Beat]] (erl. nach Ausbau) Benutzer:Ausgangskontrolle NONE keep Seit Ausbau durch Benutzer:Funkfried333 endgültig . Nach mehrfach ungültiger Löschantrag, aber die Adminschaft schaut bei sowas ja wie gewohnt zu. Hat leider mal wieder den ersten Artikel eines Benutzers erwischt, aber interessiert ja auch keinen. Stattdessen streiten sich hier Benutzer die sowieso überhaupt gar nichts zum Artikel beizutragen haben. So werden hier also Autoren unterstützt und konstruktive Diskussionen geführt. Interessant Löschung von Undress to the Beat Wikipedia:Löschregeln Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1529 15883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Adams II User:Mztourist 07:12, 13 June 2020 (UTC) delete more about his relatives than about him, fails and Deletion of Robert Adams II WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1530 16842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gentle Angels School User:JWilz12345 09:43, 19 April 2021 (UTC) delete per nom. Article history dates its creation https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Gentle_Angels_School&oldid=426500247 in 2011, with an unencyclopedic, narrative, and seemingly promotional tone with the original intent of promoting the school (IMO), thus violated . It was later fixed but still didn't address the issue on lack of references, and at some point it was tagged with Notability template but someone seemed to have removed this tag. Up to now, no references and no sufficient evidence of coverage by independent and reliable sources Deletion of Gentle Angels School WP:PROMOTIONAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1531 2546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moonshine Throwdown User:Ejgreen77 04:45, 24 June 2020 (UTC) delete """Another article about a very recently established CFB """"rivalry"""" game (though there were a couple earlier meetings, the article itself states that ''""""the rivalry was established in 2014""""''), so it's probably in that regard. The only source to call this a rivalry is a non-RS blog site. If this article is kept for some reason, it should definitely be moved to a different title. Fails """ Deletion of Moonshine Throwdown WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1532 10778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Severn Valley (Cthulhu Mythos) User:Jontesta 14:53, 22 August 2020 (UTC) merge """to Lovecraft Country or Ramsey Campbell due to a lack of real world reception. Wikipedia articles are supposed to be rehashes of plot details. Reviewing the sources found at AFD, it's good to verify that this setting is based on Liverpool, but we should have more than a passing mention to establish notability for a full article that's otherwise just a collection of details. Another reasonable target for this information would also be List of films and television shows set or shot in Liverpool if it were renamed """"Fiction set in Liverpool""" Deletion of Severn Valley (Cthulhu Mythos) WP:NOT||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1533 21516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atefeh Farzindar User:Taketa 09:00, 20 August 2014 (UTC) delete per and . The subject has not received a well-known and significant award or honor. No indication for a widely recognized contribution in either academics or business areas. No neutral secundary source is given in the article Deletion of Atefeh Farzindar WP:SCHOLAR||WP:NPERSON Wikipedia:Notability 77
1534 16020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yukio Kawabe User:Jakejr 15:53, 26 December 2012 (UTC) keep His notability is in sumo, not MMA, but the fact is he meets #Sumo. More documentation and text would be nice, but his notability is clear Deletion of Yukio Kawabe WP:NSPORTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1535 532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018–19 The New Saints F.C. season User:The 05:03, 1 December 2018 (UTC) delete per nomination. Subject fails . |Just another item for Wikipedia's rather long and getting longer by the day indiscriminate listings of information Deletion of 2018–19 The New Saints F.C. season WP:NSEASON||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1536 20741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HD 1273 User:Sam 21:00, 24 December 2020 (UTC) delete """Ultimately, we should look for reliable sources (non-catalogs) that mention the object to ascertain whether it merits a Wikipedia page or not. Seeing none, it should be deleted. {{u|ExoEditor}} and {{u|PopePompus}}, see note 1 of : {{tq|These criteria do not supersede WP:NOTABILITY, they merely supplement and clarify it within the context of astronomical objects. If an astronomical object does not meet the general notability guideline, especially if it lacks evidence of significant coverage in independent, reliable sources, then it risks being merged or redirected to an existing article, or deleted altogether.}} We are missing the """"significant"""" part here, hence the article should be deleted""" Deletion of HD 1273 WP:NASTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1537 11935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Passport Software User:Coredesat 04:06, 1 July 2006 (UTC) delete vanity, fails and Deletion of Passport Software WP:ADS||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Spam 112
1538 10412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mansoorah, Lahore User:Smartyllama 20:00, 13 February 2020 (UTC) keep Clearly satisfies . A political party being based there may not grant it notability in and of itself, but it doesn't deny it notability either. It has little to do whatsoever with whether it's notable. Nomination is absurd and bordering on given the subject matter Deletion of Mansoorah, Lahore WP:NPLACE||WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1539 18392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sophia De Muth [[User talk:172.58.110.250|talk]]) 21:00, 14 July 2020 (UTC) keep Meets with new sources. Special:Contributions/172.58.110.250|172.58.110.250 Deletion of Sophia De Muth WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1540 20094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Ryder User:Hobbes 03:43, 21 October 2011 (UTC) delete Subject is an apparently-failed DJ who has moved on to radio sales. Nothing wrong with that, but does not mean subject warrants an encyclopedia entry. References in article are not substantial, secondary sources as to subject's |notability. Web search did not find any, either Deletion of Matt Ryder WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1541 15555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/QuickPar User:JBsupreme NONE keep I've added references to this article. |Notability is not temporary. The nom ''is'' acting in '''bad faith''' in nominating this article and SmartPAR for AfD as he was already aware of a |reliable source that covers this subject. This book is linked in the Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2009 September 22#Parchive|Deletion Review that Deletion of QuickPar WP:NTEMP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1542 4029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Duhart User:Cbl62 16:14, 30 September 2019 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass or . In terms of , the only significant coverage I can find is from the Newport News Daily Press, e.g., https://www.dailypress.com/sports/dp-spt-odu-duhart-20181005-story.html here and https://www.newspapers.com/clip/36540765/duhart/ here. GNG requires that such coverage exists in ''multiple'' independent sources. Accordingly, unless more is uncovered, this one does not make the cut. Will reconsider if significant coverage is found in other sources Deletion of Jonathan Duhart WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:NCOLLATH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1543 2128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adolph Aloys von Braun User:Bearian 19:28, 17 October 2011 (UTC) keep per ; he was equivalent to Secretary of the Cabinet in today's United States Deletion of Adolph Aloys von Braun WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
1544 1287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Newton Crosby User:MaskedSinger 09:37, 5 July 2019 (UTC) delete fails both and . Can't believe it was created almost 15 years ago Deletion of Newton Crosby WP:GNG||WP:UNSOURCED Wikipedia:Notability 77
1545 14832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Razi Vick User:Black 03:02, 14 March 2007 (UTC) delete No evidence provided and/or found that the subject meets . Notability and lack of Google hits are (thankfully) not criteria for speedy deletion. I believe what was intended was: ''delete, speedy close Deletion of Razi Vick WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1546 1240 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of Santa Rosa de Copán, """"Los Llanos""""""" User:Chris 20:39, 30 December 2016 (UTC) delete Fails . This is unreferenced promotional junk. The creator, {{u|Vitrubius32}}, indicates on their user page that they might be the author of same. The version on es-wiki should be deleted, too """Deletion of History of Santa Rosa de Copán, """"Los Llanos""""""" WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
1547 11318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fifth Harmony (3rd Nomination) User:Boleyn 19:18, 3 May 2013 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Fifth Harmony (3rd Nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1548 1910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/For This Cause (band) User:Lankiveil 12:04, 9 August 2012 (UTC) delete the usual garage band stuff, but nothing that indicates that the band meets or is close to meeting any of the criteria Deletion of For This Cause (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1549 11089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Waltair Main Road User:K 00:32, 8 February 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet & significant RS coverage not found. The article exists to advertise the stores that are located there -- that's not what the encyclopedia is for Deletion of Waltair Main Road WP:GEOROAD Wikipedia:Notability 77
1550 20744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toples User:Whpq 16:17, 27 May 2011 (UTC) comment The one source already in the article is from Gazeta Wyborcza, which is a major Polish Daily. I've named a second source above. There appeared to be more coverage but it's very tough going when relying om machine translation. Based on the two sources, and what appears to be more available in Google News, it would seem that the is satisified. For sure the article needs significant work, but I will leave that to an editor that has some Polish language skills Deletion of Toples WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1551 20117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PatientOS User:Whpq 22:43, 30 January 2012 (UTC) comment """I will point out that is an essay and not an official guideline or policy. I'll also go into a mini-rant on the use of the word """"notability"""" on Wikipedia. It is perhaps an unfortunate choice of word to use as it taken in a pejorative sense when subjects are declared """"non-notable"""". I deliberately used the term """"inclusion guidelines"""" in my rationale for deletion. We are judging whether it a subject meets inclusion criteria in this discussion. The applicable guideline is , the general notability guideline in the absence of any other topic specific guidelines (and as I pointed out, is not an official guideline). I'll accept an argument that PatientOS has recognized merit in its field, but that needs to backed up with significant coverage in independent reliable sources. None of the sources offered so far represents such significant coverage in independent reliable sources""" Deletion of PatientOS WP:NSOFT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1552 373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dakota Valley Elementary School User:VanTucky 04:07, 9 August 2007 (UTC) comment Notability is not established through the opinions of students, it is established through |reliable, published sources. We do not automatically assume a subject is notable without independent sources and work from there, despite what some think of schools. Of course feel free to search for independent verification of some possible notability, but we judge articles ''as they stand'', not by guessing or assumptions Deletion of Dakota Valley Elementary School WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1553 13019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kathy Simms User:Jclemens 00:40, 7 March 2012 (UTC) merge to a list of office characters. Per , deletion isn't even really a viable outcome: either we merge it (primary sourcing only...) or we keep it as a separate entry (Sufficient RS exist Deletion of Kathy Simms WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1554 680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Metropolitan Community Church of New York (2nd nomination) User:Snotbot 02:18, 19 February 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 February 19 Deletion of Metropolitan Community Church of New York (2nd nomination) WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1555 6818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhlenberg Park, Pennsylvania User:Lightburst 15:36, 29 March 2020 (UTC) delete Not a populated place per . Fails Deletion of Muhlenberg Park, Pennsylvania WP:GEOLAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1556 4784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James M. Nolan User:David 19:29, 24 July 2011 (UTC) delete A college with eight core faculty is not a major institution and does not pass #C6, and the article offers no other indication of notability Deletion of James M. Nolan WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1557 20985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Belarus–Iran relations User:Edison 21:50, 24 April 2009 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not a directory or a collection of miscellaneous information Deletion of Belarus–Iran relations WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1558 18775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dutch Australian User:SatuSuro 14:21, 10 June 2007 (UTC) keep per Mattinbgn's comment above - notability is a non issue if you read my comments above - to ponder otherwsise is contravening there are hundreds of refs in the book that I have cited above Deletion of Dutch Australian WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
1559 6389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hero Alom User:Worldbruce 19:51, 16 December 2016 (UTC) keep The deletion discussion is poorly framed. With the exception of biographybd.com (which has been removed), the original sources were reliable, albeit not all that deep. To those original sources, {{U|Wikishovel}} has added four more solid Bengali-language sources. I don't like the topic, don't relish guarding it against vandals, and won't shed any tears if it's deleted, but I don't see how anyone can seriously argue that it still doesn't meet Deletion of Hero Alom WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1560 4423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Portable Nintendo System (2009) User:MuZemike 08:24, 29 August 2008 (UTC) delete with the user refusing to indicate any sources whatsoever, it gives me reason to believe that this is complete Deletion of Portable Nintendo System (2009) WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
1561 245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Crabnet User:Brewcrewer 03:05, 4 December 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of The Crabnet WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1562 15566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inheritance Abuse User:Jersyko 02:05, 12 January 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Never heard of the term, though I suppose the phenomenon it purports to describe has some relation to reality. If |reliable sources are provided, I will reevaluate, of course, but I suspect there is unsalvageable original research here Deletion of Inheritance Abuse WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1563 76 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Report of Van Fleet Mission to Far East User:Icewhiz 07:58, 29 November 2017 (UTC) delete While passing , this doesn't pass or . I don't think anything here needs to be merged with James Van Fleet Deletion of Report of Van Fleet Mission to Far East WP:V||WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1564 9035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thatgamecompany User:MLauba 22:23, 25 February 2009 (UTC) keep Nom confuses Notability with importance and only offers an irrelevant |JNN argument Deletion of Thatgamecompany WP:JNN Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1565 3074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of gimmicks in television shows User:Acalamari 20:46, 17 April 2007 (UTC) delete per violations Deletion of List of gimmicks in television shows WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1566 602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agonist (Christian) User:Squeamish 20:39, 16 October 2012 (UTC) delete """There are some uses of the phrase """"Christian agonist"""" in reliable sources, often in reference to Milton. On the other hand, that's not what this article is about. What this article ''is'' about is a |fringe |synthesis of religious topics. Some of this material is derived from http://www.christian-agonist.com www.christian-agonist.com (and, indeed, that appears as an external link). This article doesn't link to http://agon.us agon.us, but some of the contributor's other work clearly derives from it. Someone with some familiarity with the broader Christian topics may need to review the contributions of {{user|All Worlds}}; there is related material at Agon, Cafeteria Christianity, Saulieu and probably more that seems dubious at best, and I have substantial concerns about much of Sacred cockfight. I don't see anything in a reliable source to support any of this""" Deletion of Agonist (Christian) WP:FRINGE||WP:SYN Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
1567 858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Journal (episode) User:Thinker78 06:47, 3 December 2017 (UTC) keep """I spent a couple hours dwelling on the merits of keeping or deleting this article, so I will say it is a gray and complicated area, and my position is far from perfect. Per , I think that the topic has received somewhat significant coverage in, arguably, reliable sourceshttps://moviepilot.com/p/imporant-moments-from-hey-arnold-the-jungle-movie-trailer/4384158https://www.hit.com.au/scoopla/tv/hey-arnold-fans-have-finally-had-all-their-questions-answered-in-new-movie?station=adelaidehttps://www.bustle.com/p/recap-how-hey-arnold-ended-before-the-jungle-movie-solves-the-shows-greatest-mystery-5533960 that seem to be independent of the subject; for this reason, the topic is presumed to be '''suitable for a stand-alone article'''. The topic in those sources is addressed directly and somewhat in detail. In addition, I think that the coverage doesn't seem to be a trivial mention. has several criteria, which seems to be too long to be listed here, but I think that a standalone article helps understand more the topic than a constrained table entry, as """"List of Hey Arnold! episodes"""" is. states, """"Sometimes, when an article gets too long..., an unduly large section of the article is made into its own highly detailed subarticle... This is completely normal Wikipedia procedure."""" I think adding more information to this topic's entry in """"List of Hey Arnold! episodes"""" would be making the entry too long compared to the other entries and so, inappropriate. Therefore this would support a standalone article of the topic at hand""" Deletion of The Journal (episode) WP:GNG||WP:PAGEDECIDE||WP:SPINOFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1568 6489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Podcast Awards User:AP1787 04:49, 2 September 2009 (UTC) keep """I respectfully disagree, I believe this article, while lacking a terrible amount of coverage in the more traditional new sources, still satisfies the """"significant coverage"""" aspect of . There are several sources that do cover the event when it appears, and while I personally can't imagine it being a terribly enthralling or prestigious honor, 350,000 votes is hard to ignore, and I think that combined with the limited yet acceptably significant coverage make it notable enough to be included in Wikipedia""" Deletion of Podcast Awards WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1569 13421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason DeRulo (album) User:MuffledThud 23:57, 2 November 2009 (UTC) merge I've added one supporting ref from Reuters, so not such a blatant violation of which allows for notable works to be described before their release. See also :Category:2010 albums Deletion of Jason DeRulo (album) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1570 8675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tina Cheri User:Goldsztajn 23:02, 19 February 2020 (UTC) delete Fails - no detectable fan base, no significant roles, no unique contributions Deletion of Tina Cheri WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1571 3612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of stone churches User:Chris 20:23, 29 January 2012 (UTC) delete far too broad in its scope, fails , etc. This belongs as a category instead Deletion of List of stone churches WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1572 667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adana derby User:Inter 12:47, 21 March 2016 (UTC) keep not the best article, but I took a quick look through it and it seems well sourced and satisfies Deletion of Adana derby WP:NRIVALRY Wikipedia:Notability 77
1573 417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VIPJourneys User:AllyD 08:22, 29 January 2018 (UTC) delete An article which makes no claim of encyclopaedic notability, with advertorial, passing mention and routine announcement sources. No |evidence of |notability Deletion of VIPJourneys :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1574 19905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Joseph Dandurand [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 02:24, 15 July 2013 (UTC) delete """per |G4, |G5 or |G11 (take your pick) then '''|salt''' every single possible variation of this spammer's name and edit-filter/blacklist his website. This sh*t again?!? Obvious recreation of self-promotional spam deleted about 10 times under various names, created each time by the accounts of a prolific sock-puppeteer whose latest account (that created this article) started editing only 4 days after his last batch of sock-puppets got indeffed in January. Managed only 6 edits 5 edits not related to the subject before the promo-spam started again and ''every'' edit since has been about the subject and his """"work"""". Give me a break""" Deletion of Jeff Joseph Dandurand WP:G4||WP:G5||WP:G11||WP:SALT Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1575 8397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Coates (longevity claimant) (2nd nomination) User:Newshunter12 16:03, 16 July 2019 (UTC) delete This article fails , , and . The experts say he was a fraud and there was very little reporting on him or anything to say about him in a wiki article except brief information on record possibilities if his already disproven age claim was true and how his claim was debunked Deletion of William Coates (longevity claimant) (2nd nomination) WP:BIO1E||WP:NOPAGE||WP:SUSTAINED Wikipedia:Notability 77
1576 10902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/University of Virginia Cancer Center User:Unscintillating 15:56, 17 December 2017 (UTC) keep """nbsp; While it would be nice to have employment and budget figures, I don't see that the article is unduly promotional. The talk page has no report of attempts to resolve concerns. The nominator added a """"Merge"""" tag to the article in November, which proves that WP:ATD were known at the time of the nomination, and that as per eletion policy, the talk page is the place to resolve concerns. """ Deletion of University of Virginia Cancer Center WP:D Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
1577 21910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roger Federer in 2011 User:Jenks24 03:32, 9 June 2011 (UTC) keep It's common practice to split large articles into smaller ones and simply summarise the child articles in the parent one. If all this info was to be merged into the the Roger Federer article, it would be in violation of and would probably have to lose it's GA status. Merging these articles would be a net negative for the encyclopedia Deletion of Roger Federer in 2011 WP:LENGTH Wikipedia:Article size 51
1578 6926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anderson de Carvalho Barbosa User:PamD 06:57, 17 April 2009 (UTC) keep he meets the notability criterion, per , as I said when de-prodding it. I don't like the rule either, but it has been decided that people who play for fully professional teams are notable. If you don't like it, try to get the notability rules changed. Trying to delete this article seems to be Deletion of Anderson de Carvalho Barbosa WP:ATHLETE||WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1579 6706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dynamic errors of numerical methods of ODE discretization User:Mark 20:07, 25 June 2016 (UTC) delete I was unable to find any mention of ''dynamical characteristic'' in this ODE context independent of the preprint, this Wikipedia article, or derivatives of the WP article. Without independent reliable sourcing, the topic fails notability per and the complete lack of independent sourcing means there is nothing verifiable to merge or to redirect Deletion of Dynamic errors of numerical methods of ODE discretization WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1580 21486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Texas Tech University Libraries User:Yngvadottir 02:12, 18 July 2014 (UTC) delete """under : a statement on the talkpage says: """"We are experimenting with article geotagging for use in an Augmented Reality environment. The content was written by Texas Tech University Libraries Communications and Marketing division. The current content is to serve as a placeholder for revised content while we attempt to implement the geotagging technologies""" Deletion of Texas Tech University Libraries WP:NOTWEBHOST Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1581 7129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dean L. Lourensz (2nd nomination) User:Sir 13:29, 31 July 2017 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Dean L. Lourensz (2nd nomination) WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1582 19541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyler Faith User:Stifle 19:39, 18 August 2008 (UTC) delete doesn't appear to meet Deletion of Tyler Faith WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1583 15082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warren Ashcroft User:Dhartung 19:15, 15 August 2007 (UTC) delete fails . The only source I found was http://thewhir.com/marketwatch/che120604.cfm this which isn't much (and a press release summary to boot). Red Fox itself (a software and services company that is sorta known) could be notable, but it's not even clear from sources what Ashcroft's role is. Owner? Founder? Employee No. 1 Deletion of Warren Ashcroft WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1584 11077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RGC-83 GM Cannon II User:Moreschi 22:32, 12 January 2007 (UTC) comment any other reason other than ? Because I have cited policy, you have not. IMO closing admins should ignore these ILIKEIT votes Deletion of RGC-83 GM Cannon II WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1585 17735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mucoid plaque (3rd nomination) User:S 19:33, 24 January 2009 (UTC) keep From reading the above, the result will be keep or no consensus, and there's no point dragging this out. Cf ; consensus can change but it clearly hasn't Deletion of Mucoid plaque (3rd nomination) WP:KEEPLISTINGTILITGETSDELETED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1586 12768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Game (game) (2 nomination) User:JoshuaZ 15:07, 20 March 2006 (UTC) comment """Actually, per comments below the game is notable, since everyone seems agree that it exists as a known phenomenon. So the above go to verifiability, and as others observed on gets that also from googling the phrase """"I just lost the game""" Deletion of The Game (game) (2 nomination) WP:UCS "Wikipedia:What ""Ignore all rules"" means" 62
1587 17125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Submission Hold User:Alexandermcnabb 08:49, 25 April 2021 (UTC) delete Fails . Best Deletion of Submission Hold WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1588 16362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Sandwich: Great Eats from All 50 States User:Fosse8 17:00, 20 February 2015 (UTC) delete this is a strange one! As Borock says, it actually does meet the criteria for establishing notability for a published work, but there's no actual assertion of notability in the article - indeed, there's pretty much no article, just some links to types of sandwiches. There's a mention of it being a tie-in for a TV show, and between that and the Houston Chronicle piece there might be enough there to expand this to a stub, but as things stand, there's no reason to keep it Deletion of American Sandwich: Great Eats from All 50 States WP:NBOOKS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1589 19002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susie Frazier Mueller User:Silver 01:15, 21 March 2010 (UTC) comment I have listed the article for Wikipedia:Article Rescue Squadron|rescue. I have also added a number of notable external links that now need to be worked into the article. There were many more besides just these on Google. She appears to be rather notable, per Deletion of Susie Frazier Mueller WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
1590 11608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pokemon vs Digimon User:Pmedema 16:39, 30 March 2008 (UTC) delete Patent nonsense and tagged as such. Fails , , , ... take your pick Deletion of Pokemon vs Digimon WP:N||WP:V||WP:OR||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1591 15484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank Hogan [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 04:40, 28 November 2006 (UTC) keep Subject meets the notability requirements of . Article provides reliable, third-party sources as required by . -- Deletion of Frank Hogan WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
1592 15002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Classixx User:Starblind 23:13, 4 May 2010 (UTC) delete after having looked at the http://www.discogs.com/artist/Classixx Discogs entry, I don't see anything that passes or even comes close. Their own releases appear to be MP3-only, and they may or may not have done remixes for somewhat notable artists, but those claims are sourced only to the myspace page and said remixes may be unofficial and/or unreleased Deletion of Classixx WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1593 844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of surnames in Ukraine User:Postdlf 20:40, 1 August 2020 (UTC) keep as index of articles per and per as complement to :Category:Ukrainian-language surnames, which includes 421 surname articles Deletion of List of surnames in Ukraine WP:LISTPURP||WP:CLN Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
1594 2030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Best Practices, LLC User:Bonadea 09:08, 10 July 2015 (UTC) delete fails . Several trivial mentions, some of which are in independent sources, but no significant coverage. The only source that might possibly qualify as non-trivial is the inc.com case study from 2001, but I don't think that cuts it on its own. The company's website has been repeatedly spammed to various Wikipedia articles for the last couple of years, so it does seem as if they have tried to use Wikipedia as an advertising platform Deletion of Best Practices, LLC WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
1595 13444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Undermountain User:A 22:13, 10 February 2009 (UTC) keep maybe even per at this point, as it concerns the titular location in multiple works and is at worst redirectable, but at best serves as a navigational means to other articles. It meets our verifiability guidelines by being covered in multiple reliable published sources and is notable by any reasonable standard as a titular location in part of a mainstream and popular franchise familiar to millions around the world. And in event, we don't delete based on or . Sincerely Deletion of Undermountain WP:SNOW||WP:JNN||WP:PERNOM Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
1596 10699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amir Higher User:Arthistorian1977 13:18, 11 June 2017 (UTC) delete He has some followers on Youtube and 1.2 mil views, but almost nothing in search shows independant sources and reviews of his music. Looks like a rising kid. Deletion of Amir Higher WP:TOOEARLY Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1597 10409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coronation Street sets User:Toughpigs 19:43, 28 December 2019 (UTC) keep From the references, it looks like the history and evolution of the sets are of particular interest. There are three books referenced (''Coronation Street; A fully illustrated record'', ''Coronation Street: The Inside Story'' and ''40 Years of Coronation Street'') with multiple page numbers, indicating that the sets are discussed in detail and not simply mentioned. News articles from the Guardian and BBC News indicate public interest from reliable sources. The four examples given on -- plot summary, song lyrics, list of statistics and log of software updates -- bear no similarity to this fairly in-depth article with connection to real-world events Deletion of Coronation Street sets WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1598 1056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Satux User:Wikieditor06 17:52, 14 August 2008 (UTC) delete Lack of |notability and seems like pam|advertising to me Deletion of Satux WP:NOTE||WP:S Wikipedia:Notability 77
1599 10835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Broughton Anglican College User:TerriersFan 14:57, 26 June 2010 (UTC) keep contains a high school with independent coverage. Sources available to meet Deletion of Broughton Anglican College WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1600 11177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Blackouts (1979 band) User:Foetusized 02:50, 20 August 2009 (UTC) keep Notable per #6 if nothing else, as Bill Rieflin and Paul Barker went on to successful careers in music and have articles. If the stub needs fleshing out, I can work on that Deletion of The Blackouts (1979 band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1601 4085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of English Word Suggestions User:Doc 19:57, 10 May 2008 (UTC) delete Per TenPoundHammer and . Wikipedia is not the place for you to list your personal snigets, #WEBSPACE|Wikipedia is not your webspace and is not a dictionary Deletion of List of English Word Suggestions WP:NFT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
1602 20641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julia Pomeroy User:Porqin 11:59, 10 August 2006 (UTC) keep This author appears to meet per her book ''The Dark End of Town Deletion of Julia Pomeroy WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1603 7758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flemingsberg Church User:Largoplazo 11:30, 16 May 2020 (UTC) delete """A Google search for {{google|""""flemingsberg church""""}} turns up no coverage in |independent, |reliable sources. Even in Swedish, searching through all results for {{google|""""flemingbergs kyrka""""}}, I came across only two sourceshttps://sverigesradio.se/sida/artikel.aspx?programid=103&artikel=7413996https://www.stockholmdirekt.se/nyheter/i-flemingsberg-gar-muslimer-till-kyrkan-alla-har-ju-samma-gud/repqio!fXB2Xf9kQ@d95o47SYdZg/ that could be seen as contributing to . That, in my opinion, doesn't suffice""" Deletion of Flemingsberg Church WP:IS||WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1604 17878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glitch City User:Randomran 16:41, 2 June 2008 (UTC) merge Jeremy McCracken pulled out some sources that DO establish notability, so this is a topic that should be in wikipedia. But there doesn't appear to be much to say about this topic that doesn't violate and . I would recommend drastically trimming this article, summarizing it, and merging it into a relevant pokemon game article Deletion of Glitch City WP:GAMETRIVIA||WP:GAMEGUIDE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
1605 4810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seven Silver Fish User:Coredesat 02:32, 25 August 2006 (UTC) delete vanity for a |non-notable band Deletion of Seven Silver Fish WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
1606 16403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Internet slang phrases User:Black 03:50, 17 March 2007 (UTC) keep If Wiktionary can use this list, good for them. However, this list aids in navigation and is, moreover, referenced, NPOV, NOR, etc. is inapplicable as this list is a supplement to Internet slang and a navigation aid Deletion of List of Internet slang phrases WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
1607 3443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Euthanasia Coaster User:Reference 10:18, 24 April 2011 (UTC) keep Enough coverage to pass Deletion of Euthanasia Coaster WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1608 2519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Multitorrent User:Gary 07:10, 8 March 2008 (UTC) delete This is completely non-notable, per . Cannot find any notable mention of the website anywhere besides the fact that torrent sites typically result in a lot of search results Deletion of Multitorrent WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1609 11471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PWR Heavyweight Championship User:LM2000 12:23, 17 November 2018 (UTC) delete I understand the difficulty in writing articles about older subjects where most of the sources are no longer extant but we really need to get some before articles are created. Consider taking this through the draft process to flesh things out before creating them here. Consult and in the future. Also, please read /RS, , and in particular. Cagematch and other databases can be used in some circumstances but don't demonstrate notability. |Verification generally requires more than just talking to someone involved with the subject. I'm willing to change my !vote but it would take solid sourcing Deletion of PWR Heavyweight Championship WP:GNG||WP:COI||WP:PW||WP:RS||WP:V||WP:YOUTUBE||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
1610 4749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madhubanti Bagchi User:Bejnar 05:29, 6 July 2017 (UTC) delete this fails |NARTIST and well as |GNG Deletion of Madhubanti Bagchi WP:NARTIST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1611 18726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ala Avia User:Kosm1fent 19:24, 17 October 2012 (UTC) delete hasn't actually played for his country's national team. Fails and . &ndash Deletion of Ala Avia WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1612 399 [[Dekanat Ostalb]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Ehrhardt NONE delete Unter Relevanzgesichtspunkten klar für behalten. Die /21. Oktober 2007#Stadtdekanat Mannheim (bleibt)|Diskussion ist auch absolut nicht neu. Allerdings ist der Artikel wirklich schlecht. Sollte er sich nicht verbessern, dann bleibt nur Löschung von Dekanat Ostalb Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1613 2428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prof Irfan Shahid User:Pharaoh 10:47, 2 April 2015 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Prof Irfan Shahid WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1614 11985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maintenance-free operating period User:Mark 12:22, 21 October 2018 (UTC) keep per and lots of sources out there. XOR'easter added a couple of sources to make this short stub well-referenced. A style search quickly yields many GScholar and GBooks sources discussing the concept. Hence keep. --{{u| Deletion of Maintenance-free operating period WP:HEY||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
1615 361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vicca (2nd nomination) User:Gene93k 12:26, 29 July 2015 (UTC) delete """The """"Best Solo Sex Scene"""" award win is scene-related and does not count for passing . Being a Penthouse Pet does not establish notability either. Lacks significant reliable source coverage to pass . Brief mentions in ''Adult Video News'' are not enough""" Deletion of Vicca (2nd nomination) WP:PORNBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1616 20532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sharon D. Allen (OARDEC) User:Yachtsman1 18:52, 1 December 2010 (UTC) delete per nomination, fails - fails , io and Deletion of Sharon D. Allen (OARDEC) WP:GNG||WP:B||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1617 15527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Masha Archer User:Johnbod 13:15, 13 December 2007 (UTC) delete as NN; Saks PR will achieve many mentions in local papers; this does not meet the requirements of Deletion of Masha Archer WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1618 7093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pyrrho (RDBMS) User:RoySmith 21:23, 3 July 2018 (UTC) delete The only source that looks solid is the textbook, https://books.google.com/books/about/Database_Systems.html?id=odtKPgAACAAJ Database Systems: A Practical Approach to Design, Implementation, and Management. I was thinking that could qualify as, ''It is the subject of instruction at ... universities or post-graduate programs'', stated in . It turns out, however, that the authors of that textbook are both faculty at University of Paisley, which is now called University of the West of Scotland, which is where Pyrrho comes from. So, that's not an independent source. My own searching failed to come up with any good sources either Deletion of Pyrrho (RDBMS) WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1619 14652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denial of lesbianism User:Grrrlriot 00:35, 8 July 2008 (UTC) delete The article's references doesn't discuss the issue in any detail, except provide examples of people that are lesbian. There's no evidence that the concept meets . It seems that this article is gossip about people denying their sexuality Deletion of Denial of lesbianism WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1620 1294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Man, Myth & Magic (role-playing game) User:Coolabahapple 14:38, 14 August 2018 (UTC) keep meets , reviews in the gaming magazines listed above are sufficient Deletion of Man, Myth & Magic (role-playing game) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1621 9463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Schaefer Ambulance Service (3rd nomination) User:Alzarian16 17:33, 11 November 2011 (UTC) merge seems like a sensible compromise here, since we can't verify that the possible sources are enough to meet but the search term seems reasonable Deletion of Schaefer Ambulance Service (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1622 12530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kurt Mertins User:Edison 23:22, 21 June 2007 (UTC) keep """The comparison to Blake Beavan is invalid, because he had not even signed a contract, much less played. This article's subject played for 2 years as a professional baseball player. Minor leagues players are still fully professional players, so if he has played in the minors he satisfies """"Competitors who have played in a fully professional league."""" Minor league says """"Minor leagues are professional sports leagues which are not regarded as the premier leagues in those sports."""" I expect they still compare favorable in salary and in press coverage to pro leagues in other sports in some smaller countries. If you want to amend , then go there and edit it; otherwise follow it and keep articles about athletes who have played in the minor leagues""" Deletion of Kurt Mertins WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1623 18106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebecca Anibueze User:Mr 01:23, 23 December 2008 (UTC) delete the only secondary source I've found is a brief article in the University of Arizona school newspaper. Doesn't meet Deletion of Rebecca Anibueze WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1624 18582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julie Goiorani User:AGK 22:12, 10 December 2018 (UTC) delete From what I see, no secondary sources have provided coverage of the subject's career. While we know from primary sources that the subject indeed participated in some significant competitions, they have not played internationally and are not ''likely to have received significant coverage'' (). Indeed we know the subject has received no such coverage. I cannot see how this subject currently warrants inclusion of a biography Deletion of Julie Goiorani WP:SPORTSPERSON Wikipedia:Notability 77
1625 3823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jai McDowall User:Spyka 16:23, 5 June 2011 (UTC) merge For now per . If he becomes hugely famous and releases music down the line and gains notability away from the show then sure. Right now however, remembering , he's known for only being on BGT. Aside: Anyone else suspicious of these multiple 92.22.x IPs who've only ever edited Jai's page Deletion of Jai McDowall WP:1E||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1626 16938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melvine Malard User:ArsenalFan700 03:54, 1 October 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and . I have seen articles dedicated to young 12 year old Indian players before for doing well in local Indian leagues. Does it mean they pass ? Two articles doesn't make one notable or pass GNG in my opinion Deletion of Melvine Malard WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1627 1744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isa Bagci User:GiantSnowman 22:32, 25 May 2009 (UTC) delete per nom; fails Deletion of Isa Bagci WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1628 18621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/4-Ethylamphetamine User:Bearian 13:29, 30 July 2019 (UTC) delete per , subject to |re-creation if and when it becomes notable Deletion of 4-Ethylamphetamine WP:SNOW||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
1629 13698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerald Milton User:Rms125a 02:58, 19 October 2014 (UTC) delete fails and , as has been noted Deletion of Gerald Milton WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
1630 15554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Love & Peace (group) User:Lankiveil 12:37, 3 April 2009 (UTC) delete would not appear to meet the notability criteria Deletion of Love & Peace (group) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1631 20449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC 5 User:Snotbot 10:12, 31 May 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 May 31 Deletion of UFC 5 WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1632 20998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hollywood Blood User:JediLofty 14:24, 25 April 2008 (UTC) delete What the...? Surely this is a ? -- JediLofty Deletion of Hollywood Blood WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
1633 13117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suresh krishnan User:GargAvinash 04:51, 4 February 2020 (UTC) delete Not a notable director as per Deletion of Suresh krishnan WP:DIRECTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1634 7198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeffrey Bushell User:BaronVonYiffington 01:29, 11 March 2010 (UTC) keep a http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0124244/ quick http://www.mooviees.com/291699-Jeffrey-Bushell/celebrity google http://www.film.com/celebrities/jeff-bushell/14748380 search http://uk-tv-guide.com/celebrity/Jeffrey+Bushell/226406/ brings up lots of pages about the things he has written. The big thing keeping me from voting delete is that he has won two notable awards, which makes him notable under . ''However'', these two awards are unsourced, and I cannot find anything that shows ''he'' won the award, only that The Bernie Mac Show won the awards. I think this article just needs proper sourcing, not deleting Deletion of Jeffrey Bushell WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1635 8283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lester E. Taylor III User:Ajraddatz 03:19, 28 December 2017 (UTC) delete fails , and I can't find any other sources on a cursory search Deletion of Lester E. Taylor III WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1636 14514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Moline User:Pascal 23:33, 26 June 2006 (UTC) delete Even a redirect is a bit of importance that this guy does not really deserve. See guidelines and the 100 years test Deletion of Matt Moline WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1637 19716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Wolter User:Xxanthippe 00:18, 6 February 2014 (UTC) delete """GS search for """"S F Wolter"""" shows negligible cites. Fails rof""" Deletion of Scott Wolter WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
1638 13811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Hasselvander User:Rasadam 20:44, 3 July 2008 (UTC) delete my vote is not on the basis of the article's poor quality. The subject fails to meet notability requirements of . His former band appears to have some sort notability, Pentagram (band) but the artist fails to meet individual notability. ''Being in a notbale band is not a criteria for article creation, as per notability guidelines''. I can only find two mentions in reliable media http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9407E1DA1E3EF934A25750C0A96F958260&sec=&spon=&pagewanted=2 http://www.mywire.com/pubs/Muze/2007/02/01/630114?extID=10051 which only mention his name within the context of the band. I have struggled to find notability in many of his other bands. As such, I believe the article should be deleted Deletion of Joe Hasselvander WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1639 15140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of richest actors [[User talk:Martin451|Martin'''451''']] 23:56, 3 January 2015 (UTC) comment to base it on a single source may be a . However there are richer actors than those in this list. Bill Gates#Appearance in ads|Bill Gates worth billions. Elizabeth II#Diamond Jubilee and beyond|Elizabeth II has a personal wealth of $450M and runs crown estates worth billions. Richard Branson#Television.2C film and print|Richard Branson worth $5billion Deletion of List of richest actors WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
1640 11029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Goon shower User:Tony 21:59, 14 November 2007 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not for things made up at four in the morning in the frat house under the influence of far too much alcohol and other intoxicants Deletion of Goon shower WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
1641 5528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qamar Shaheen Babur User:JFHJr 00:13, 14 December 2011 (UTC) delete As far as I can tell, this subject doesn't pass requirements of substantial coverage in reliable sources. Also as far as I can tell, this subject isn't the same person who worked for a competitor and received marginally more coverage as a victim of torture. At least I can't find any overt connection. Finally, assuming it is the same person, I'm not sure the incident is sufficient to support a stand-alone (see ). If someone can provide citations indicating the contrary, I'll be glad to change my !vote Deletion of Qamar Shaheen Babur WP:BASIC||WP:BLP1E||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
1642 3339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Crossed (2nd nomination) User:Papaursa 23:46, 13 June 2016 (UTC) delete He wasn't notable earlier this year and nothing has really changed. He obviously doesn't meet . I don't think that appearing in a local ad with Mike Tyson is sufficient to show notability via . I agree with the comment about Deletion of Sam Crossed (2nd nomination) WP:NBOX||WP:GNG||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
1643 14607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Geurtjens (2nd nomination) User:Sarahj2107 09:32, 7 January 2016 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet . There is some significant coverage in http://www.coventrytelegraph.net/sport/rugby/coventry-bears-prop-james-geurtjens-10219628 this source but everything else I can find is just a passing mention so not enough to pass either. The article in its current form is different enough from the previous one that it probably shouldn't be speedy deleted as #G4 Deletion of James Geurtjens (2nd nomination) WP:RLN||WP:GNG||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Notability 77
1644 15050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dawn of Rage User:MER 10:38, 3 December 2006 (UTC) delete as |unsourced and unverifiable |crystal balling Deletion of Dawn of Rage WP:V||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1645 6727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michelle Obama transgender conspiracy theory User:XOR 16:36, 17 February 2021 (UTC) delete per — it's documentable, but there isn't enough to indicate it's sufficiently noteworthy to warrant a stand-alone article. We're not here to make a page for each thing that drops out of Alex Jones' mouth. The topic could potentially get a sentence or two in another article, but I'm doubtful we'd need a redirect from here to there Deletion of Michelle Obama transgender conspiracy theory WP:NFRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
1646 10760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shiron.net User:Gidonb 15:58, 29 November 2009 (UTC) comment Looking a at the greater Wikipedia picture, coverage of the Middle East suffers from a huge bias in the direction of conflict and violence. While these are part of life in the Middle East and should never be hidden, people also live in the Middle East, listen to music, read books, follow their idols, attend events, take joy in their families, in culture, and sports, to name just a few. It would be sad if our article about this website that easily meets and is used by so many people every day, without any connection to the conflicts and violence, gets deleted. It would only increase our bias Deletion of Shiron.net WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1647 15054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jon Olick User:Scope 19:32, 9 November 2006 (UTC) delete Its a puff piece. Fails all of Deletion of Jon Olick WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1648 4492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erich Sbraccia User:Newshunter12 02:29, 26 June 2019 (UTC) delete Fails due to a lack of sustained . Has lots of sources, but they are in nature Deletion of Erich Sbraccia WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1649 10115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skye englert User:NawlinWiki 12:11, 5 March 2010 (UTC) delete no indication of notability per , no sources cited Deletion of Skye englert WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1650 12693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Duke Mason (4th nomination) NONE NONE delete There are no particularly strong claims of notability here, nor is there the depth of |reliable source coverage about him needed to clear for any of it. Apart from one ''blurb'' in the annual ''Out100'', this is otherwise based entirely on blogs, primary sources, glancing namechecks of his existence in articles that aren't ''about'' him, and Q&A interviews in which he's speaking about ''himself'' — none of which are sources that can assist in building notability Deletion of James Duke Mason (4th nomination) WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1651 2208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FreeHeadset.org (2nd nomination) User:OliverKianzo 10:09, 1 February 2019 (UTC) delete Promotional article Deletion of FreeHeadset.org (2nd nomination) WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1652 16665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/N. Jehangir User:Robert 04:18, 29 June 2020 (UTC) delete Not every businessman is notable. Does not satisfy |general notability Deletion of N. Jehangir WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1653 18284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oblon, Spivak, McClelland, Maier & Neustadt, P.C. User:Ryanaxp 20:55, 2 January 2007 (UTC) keep disclosure: original author). I updated the article to reference some additional rankings and a law.com article featuring non-trivial information regarding the law firm, and added a few more factoids regarding the firm's date of founding and relocation to Alexandria. It would seem that in view of these, Oblon Spivak meets the criteria of #Criteria for companies and corporations, because the relevant rankings are compiled by independent entities and the law.com article is written by a sizeable and independent journalistic webzine Deletion of Oblon, Spivak, McClelland, Maier & Neustadt, P.C. WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1654 17214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roller Hockey International User:Djsasso 18:21, 23 January 2017 (UTC) keep This was the major league of roller hockey. It had a national prime time spot in the US. There are hundreds if not thousands of sources that can be easily found for this. The nom has been on a crusade to delete all inline hockey articles. At this point I am seriously considering this to be at a disruptive editing situation. Did you even remotely try to fulfill when nominating Deletion of Roller Hockey International WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1655 20251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Code Lyoko 2 User:jonny 15:57, 2 March 2008 (UTC) delete I couldn't find any |reliable sources confirming any information about this game. While any potential sequel would be notable, it doesn't seem that there is any |verifiable information available Deletion of Code Lyoko 2 WP:SOURCES||WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1656 9577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Best city User:Chiswick 18:18, 25 September 2012 (UTC) delete """only source is a master's thesis, so POV issue (lack of balance) looms large, and notability certainly isn't established. Whether 'Best xxx' can be an encyclopedic topic is a matter for debate; certainly """"Best..."""" invites POV writing, but if a range of sources is available it might be possible to write neutrally about it. Whether this article is a suitable place to begin for that project is doubtful: it sets out a particular bunch of criteria, which other sources probably wouldn't agree with, so comparison would involve starting again - i.e. """ Deletion of Best city WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
1657 18093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riaz Afridi User:BlackJack 15:11, 25 July 2014 (UTC) keep """The man has played Test cricket, never mind first-class cricket, and therefore meets requirements of with something to spare. If you feel the article needs more citations, then tag it as such with """"refimprove""" Deletion of Riaz Afridi WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1658 20774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ow Yeong Wai Kit User:Otr500 00:17, 23 January 2018 (UTC) delete """There is just not enough to advance |notability. The subject co-edits books, one compilation ''Love at the Gallery'', has 13 poems with the subject and his co-editor submitting one poem each. He co-edited ''From Walden to Woodlands'' along with """"Muzakkir Samat"""". The article credits the subject simply as the editor. Nothing even approaching notability for a stand-alone article. As a Secondary School teacher he is one of multiple thousands the world over. He apparently invented a learning game but that has not gained notability""" Deletion of Ow Yeong Wai Kit Wikipedia:Notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
1659 8981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krishnadas Babaji User:Rsbj66 19:16, 23 January 2007 (UTC) delete as the only source cited is original research, therefore, failes . Also as it was stated, the subject was a recluse and probably known by only the people within the Vaishnavism group that the user joined in India. As he is the author of the only source and a member of the religious party, inclusion of this article on Wikipedia may be considerd . BTW, the user Deletion of Krishnadas Babaji WP:V||WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1660 3563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susan Addison User:Lonehexagon 02:31, 31 May 2018 (UTC) keep """I incorporated the references given abovehttps://www.allmusic.com/artist/susan-addison-mn0001320806https://www.discogs.com/artist/1073043-Susan-Addisonhttps://www.theguardian.com/music/tomserviceblog/2009/nov/20/elgar-trombonehttp://news.bbc.co.uk/local/berkshire/hi/front_page/newsid_8534000/8534682.stm as well as one more from the Independent.https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/classical/news/great-composer-shame-he-couldnt-play-1824125.html I think she passes for significant discussion in secondary sources that are independent of the subject. She is known for her research in historical trombones (as indicated by the discussion in the articles above about her research work with Edward Elgar's trombone) and was awarded an Hon.RAM from the Royal Academy of Music in 2002, which may not quite satisfy but I think it does add a little bit to her notability. I also added several references to verify each piece of information in the article. However, the most strong reason I believe the article passes the notability test is due to because the subject """"is a musician who has been a reasonably prominent member of two or more independently notable ensembles."""" She was a founding member and principle trombone player for the Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment, and a founding member and 25-year player of His Majestys Sagbutts & Cornetts""" Deletion of Susan Addison WP:GNG||WP:NACADEMIC||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1661 2814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of victims of the Virginia Tech massacre User:Ohconfucius 01:53, 21 April 2007 (UTC) merge Especially after 911, emotions are running high on any wanton act perpetrated on Americans. Whilst I would not expect to see lists of victims for each and every massacre, independent of scale, I believe that this list in this case fits the mood, notable as the event, but could exist within context of the article, worked in to either in Virginia Tech massacre or Virginia Tech massacre timeline. This is a list of 30-odd names, already part of Virginia_Tech_massacre#Victims|Virginia Tech massacre. A separate article would constitute a |memorial, and would be an invitation for people to start expanding the article beyond notable biographical details and into the trivial existence of individuals who would not have merited a listing if they had not been in the wrong place at the wrong time. Have a look at List of victims of the Virginia Tech massacre|the article again: with all the flags and descriptions of the courses the victims were on, it bears an increasing resemblance to memorials we are well accustomed to seeing Deletion of List of victims of the Virginia Tech massacre WP:MEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1662 8026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dumb Drum Records User:Bearcat 23:14, 20 February 2018 (UTC) delete """Generally speaking, it's no longer possible to verify an album's ''Chart Attack'' placement, as the actual chart histories didn't survive the Channel Zero switchover — it's weirdly still possible sometimes to find individual radio stations' ''tracking'' submissions ''to'' the charts, and occasionally it's possible to source the fact to another newspaper or magazine mentioning it, but the actual fully tabulated national charts are gone gonzo gone. But even if we could verify the chart placement, it's actually a non-IFPI-certified that ''doesn't'' count toward getting an album or an artist over NMUSIC's charting criterion — where verifiable, it can be mentioned as a supplementary fact in an article that's already cleared our notability standards on other facts and other sources for them, but it's not an article-clinching notability claim in and of itself. And there just aren't any |reliable sources being cited here at all — I was able on a ProQuest search to find a glancing namecheck of the label's and album's existence in a """"concert listings"""" blurb for two non-notable bands who happen to have been ''on'' the compilation, but that's not enough""" Deletion of Dumb Drum Records WP:BADCHART||WP:RS Wikipedia:Record charts 13
1663 4565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AFA (file format) User:Emily 18:29, 25 April 2010 (UTC) delete """Astrotite and AFA (file format): utterly fails . I'm the one who put the speedy tag on Astrotite originally: it was a website and company with no substantial claim of notability. It was blatant utobiography in my opinion, and its only major claim was that it existed and it was the only software that could use the AFA format, which of course is circular reasoning and not a claim to notability. The rest of it was talky-talk about the software's creator, Vicente Sanchez-Alarcos Blanco, who openly uses the username """"Matabyte"""" in places other than Wikipedia""" Deletion of AFA (file format) WP:GNG||WP:A Wikipedia:Notability 77
1664 10149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prenatal and perinatal psychology User:CoffeeWithMarkets 01:24, 28 May 2016 (UTC) merge It's agreed that this article here is a jumbled mess of a few nuggets of good research mixed in with lots of pretentious nonsense that has nothing to do with real science. The title itself is a reflection of a fringe theory and not what's actually used in real academic study, so the problems go to the core. Rather than keep rehashing the debate on whether to just |TNT this pile of garbage or keep it despite all the problems, I've tried to cut the Gordian Knot by creating this: ''Fetal psychology''. I now boldly propose that we shift the few positive contents of this article over to that one, which has the title actually used scientifically Deletion of Prenatal and perinatal psychology WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
1665 16191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natureceuticals User:JohnCD 11:31, 7 October 2008 (UTC) delete unsourced (refs don't mention the word), and fails #Articles on neologisms Deletion of Natureceuticals WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
1666 4276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Newgen Software (2nd nomination) User:HighKing 12:09, 23 March 2021 (UTC) delete """The criteria for establishing notability for companies/organizations as per is for multiple sources (at least two) of deep or significant coverage with |in-depth information *on the company* and (this bit is important!) containing |""""Independent Content"""". """"Independent content"""", in order to count towards establishing notability, must include ''original and independent opinion, analysis, investigation, and fact checking that are clearly attributable to a source unaffiliated to the subject''. None of the references in the article meet the criteria, most are bog standard PR or articles based entirely on announcements. Having searched I am unable to locate any references that meet the criteria. Topic fails """ Deletion of Newgen Software (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1667 4332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soldier Front User:Black 18:44, 19 February 2007 (UTC) keep The article has been significantly improved (including sources) since the AfD was placed (see http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Soldier_Front&oldid=107955391). Also, I don't find it very appropriate to nominate a |speedy-able article for deletion '''7 minutes''' after its creation. I appreciate the work new-page watchers do, but non-speedyable articles can be added to one's Watchlist or bookmarked Deletion of Soldier Front WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1668 8463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spectrasexuality User:IslaySolomon 15:46, 22 October 2006 (UTC) delete The only google hits http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Spectrasexuality%22&btnG=Google+Search are for this article. At best this is a #Wikipedia_is_not_a_dictionary|dictionary definition for a |neologism Deletion of Spectrasexuality WP:NOT||WP:NEO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1669 15744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Infamous people associated with Harvard User:Thivierr 07:13, 18 May 2006 (UTC) delete """per : """"''Administrators encountering articles that are unsourced and negative in tone, where there is no NPOV version to revert to, may delete the article without discussion""" Deletion of Infamous people associated with Harvard WP:LIVING Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
1670 10721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1919 Market Street User:Mkdw 22:06, 15 March 2015 (UTC) delete an article about a 29 story apartment building in Philly. No assertion of notability, no sigcov, and possibly even coming into play since it's about a building not fully built yet Deletion of 1919 Market Street WP:FUTURE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1671 8229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/European Beer Star user:Andrew 12:05, 1 July 2020 (UTC) keep It's been running for 16 years now and seems to be reasonably substantial. There's coverage to be found such as https://www.brusselstimes.com/all-news/art-culture/78675/belgian-beers-take-home-seven-gold-medals-at-european-beer-star-awards/ this. The worst case would be to consolidate into a page such as list of food and drink awards#Beer_awards per -M Deletion of European Beer Star WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1672 97 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Şablon:Kullanıcı Erdoğan """Kullanıcı:thecatcherintheryethecatcherintherye""" 19:52, 28 Nisan 2017 (UTC) comment Çok tartışmalı bir konu. Öncelikle, Şablon:Kullanıcı HDP, Şablon: Kullanıcı CHP, Şablon: Kullanıcı MHP, Şablon:Kullanıcı TKP varken, Google üzerinden https://www.google.com.tr/search?num=100&rlz=1C1NHXL_trTR713TR713&q=Şablon:Kullanıcı+akp&oq=Şablon:Kullanıcı+akp&gs_l=serp.3...8745.11689.0.11964.4.4.0.0.0.0.173.585.0j4.4.0....0...1c.1.64.serp..0.0.0.s6Hbuohehe4 Şablon:Kullanıcı AKP aratması sonucunda, sayfa önizlemesinde görünmesine rağmen Şablon:Kullanıcı AKP'nin ve/veya Şablon:Kullanıcı AkParti'nin neden silindiğini merak ettim (''Ş1 Ş2'' olarak belirtilmiş). Neden bir kişi Vikipedi'de belirli bir partiye oy attığını ve atacağını belirtir? Bu, Gizli oy|Gizli oy açık sayım ilkesine aykırı değil mi? Kışkırtıcılık değil mi? 'ya aykırı değil mi? Açıkçası, bütün siyasi parti şablonlarının silinmesi gerektiğini düşünüyorum. Yok, silinmeyeceklerse, bırakalım, bu da kalsın. Hatta Şablon:Kullanıcı AKP ve Şablon:Kullanıcı AkParti de geri gelsin Şablon:Kullanıcı Erdoğan silme Vikipedi:TBA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1673 8109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Forgotten (band) User:Epeefleche 00:19, 28 October 2009 (UTC) keep """Meets Criterion 1 of in that it """"Has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent from the musician or ensemble itself and reliable."""" (excluding """"Works comprising merely trivial coverage, such as articles that simply report performance dates, release information or track listings, or the publications of contact and booking details in directories""" Deletion of The Forgotten (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
1674 796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diminished Fifth Records User:Moonriddengirl 15:22, 3 November 2007 (UTC) delete """Reviews of their products will not necessarily satisfy , in my opinion. Unless the company has significant secondary coverage itself, I think should govern here, and that policy states that a """"more important indie label"""" is one which has """"a history of more than a few years and a roster of performers, many of which are notable"""". This does not yet seem to qualify""" Deletion of Diminished Fifth Records WP:CORP||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1675 3203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russell (locomotive) User:Gwernol 02:30, 16 January 2008 (UTC) keep I've added three references to |published sources discussing ''Russell'', and I have a slew more which I will add. The three references should be enough on their own, I know of at least half a dozen more. This is an easily verifiable subject. The article would bear some improvements though Deletion of Russell (locomotive) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1676 18173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Captain Macdougall User:JulesH 13:53, 18 March 2007 (UTC) comment I've removed content that refers to real people due to concerns Deletion of Captain Macdougall WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
1677 7519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HQ9+ (2nd nomination) User:Mitaphane 03:50, 31 January 2007 (UTC) delete per #IINFO. Essentially this is an article about a joke created about Cliff Biffle (since there is no use for this programming language). Unless there is assertion of the significance of this joke, I say delete Deletion of HQ9+ (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1678 9559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Savona, California User:Hog NONE delete Using JSTOR, Google scholar, GEOREF, I found the same mottly collection of passing references and surnames. None of them qualifies this entity (nonentity ?) for notabilty under or . I did add a possible bus stop to Deletion of Savona, California WP:GEOLAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1679 117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohsen Bouterfif User:Hammersoft 20:20, 19 January 2011 (UTC) delete Do we really need an article for every supposed copycat of Mohamed Bouazizi? Do self immolations get a free pass from concerns? This article, in its current form, contains exactly ONE sentence about this person. The rest of it refers to Bouazizi, the path of the Tunisian president and family, and other copycat incidents. There's nothing to work with here Deletion of Mohsen Bouterfif WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
1680 6789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Redoku [[User talk:Lambiam|Lambiam]] 23:05, 14 March 2010 (UTC) delete do not redirect. A redirect is only appropriate if the target article mentions '''Redoku''' (see #PLA), which, however, it shouldn't as this is totally nonnotable. Deletion of Redoku WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
1681 61 [[Mental Defect]] (erl.) Benutzer:Steindy NONE delete Einspruch zum SLA ist nicht nur nicht gerechtfertigt, sondern sagt eigentlich alles über das Ziel des Eintrags aus. Gerne doch beschleunigt Absatz 3 und 6 sprechen eine deutliche Sprache. Zudem sehe ich im Bild eine URV, da es wohl nicht möglich ist, dass der Einsteller das Bild, auf dem er selbst abgebildet ist, in dieser Form selbst fotografiert hat; selbst mit Stativ und Selbstauslöser nicht. Neuerlicher SLA gestellt Löschung von Mental Defect Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1682 11611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A future loss User:It 04:04, 31 August 2005 (UTC) delete They do not meet 's criteria. Plus, this is just glaring vanity Deletion of A future loss WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1683 20213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maryanne Connelly User:Richard 04:18, 17 December 2017 (UTC) keep the referencing is solid per as both a mayor and senate candidate, endorsements from the New York Times, and a NOW award. The references makes the person notable, not the title, or the population of the town, which is what is actually stated in WP:POLITICIAN. The dirty tricks and negative campaign on both sides made it into reference books Deletion of Maryanne Connelly WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1684 4323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhamad Naji Subhi Al Juhani (2nd nomination) NONE NONE delete Plain and simple - doesn't meet the notability standards of . For a person to be notable s/he must recieve significant coverage in independant and/or secondary sources. This person hasn't recieved coverage in independant and/or secondary coverage. ''A fortiori'', he hasn't recieved significant coverage Deletion of Muhamad Naji Subhi Al Juhani (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1685 4612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Nova User:Rockstar915 06:17, 20 April 2007 (UTC) comment The spelling of the name is no big deal, as a simple page move can change that. If an external reference can prove that she's won the Venus Award, then she's possibly notable, and probably fulfills , and the article should be kept. I'll go ahead and give it a shot and try to find some info on her. If I or the rest of the participating Wiki community can't find anything in five days, then we should delete Deletion of Anna Nova WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1686 2911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randy Leach User:DonCalo 11:46, 1 July 2012 (UTC) delete Does not meet and Deletion of Randy Leach WP:CRIME||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1687 3922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fuck on the Beach User:ErikTheBikeMan 22:03, 3 October 2008 (UTC) delete I'm not sure how this could possibly meet Deletion of Fuck on the Beach WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1688 16723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Lawrence (attorney) User:Stormtracker94 17:17, 21 December 2007 (UTC) delete Nn lawyer, fails Deletion of Richard Lawrence (attorney) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1689 4554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eternal Blaze User:Gongshow 06:09, 14 February 2012 (UTC) comment """Peaking at #2 in Japan leads me to think the song is, as suggests, """"probably notable"""". This http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2008-10-08/nana-mizuki-trickster-cd-single-reaches-no.2 source, which according to Wikipedia:WikiProject Anime and manga/Online reliable sources#Situational may be considered reliable, notes that """"Mizuki's 2005 'Eternal Blaze' CD single for the ''Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha A's'' opening theme song was the first single by a voice actress to reach #2 on the weekly chart."""" I'm curious if siginificant coverage exists in non-English sources""" Deletion of Eternal Blaze WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1690 16490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Lee (bassist) User:Cullen328 04:08, 13 September 2013 (UTC) delete He fails as he has never been a member of notable bands, never had a hit record, never participated in a national tour, nor fulfilled any of the other criteria. He's just a regional semi-pro musician Deletion of Paul Lee (bassist) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1691 2298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cezar Dior [[User talk:Becky Sayles|''' B E C K Y S A Y L E S ''']] 01:59, 5 January 2015 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Cezar Dior WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1692 11557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haris Khan User:FreeRangeFrog 02:47, 8 February 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails anyway, and belonging to a Microsoft program is not itself a claim to notability Deletion of Haris Khan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1693 10664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giorgos Nikoltsis User:GiantSnowman 00:38, 18 January 2011 (UTC) delete fails both and Deletion of Giorgos Nikoltsis WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1694 574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wendy Barrie-Wilson User:MurderByDeadcopy 21:54, 25 January 2016 (UTC) keep passes . Article needs a rewrite though Deletion of Wendy Barrie-Wilson WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
1695 19277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henryk Rolirad User:Dream 10:03, 30 December 2020 (UTC) keep Righteous Among the Nations is a notable award/recognition. Can anyone search for his name in Polish news sources? For what he did I think he deserves an article on Wikipedia. A founding principle of Wikipedia is to Deletion of Henryk Rolirad WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
1696 15032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alesha Oreskovich User:Carrite 13:41, 4 May 2011 (UTC) keep """The use of automated tools for mass deletions should not be allowed against large blocks of articles which have already been patrolled at New Pages. It is, simply put, a violation of — due diligence is not being done when these tools are being used in this way. """"Shoot them all and let the saps at AfD sort them out,"""" is apparently the line of thinking. While I am personally sympathetic to the idea of a very high bar for so-called """"Porn Bios,"""" this blasting of 100 articles at the rate of 1 per minute, judging from the time logs, is not conducive to the spirit or practice of AfD. It is putting DON'T LIKE IT ahead of the established article deletion process and is disrespectful both to the work of article creators and those of us who volunteer our time at AfD. We have seen similar automated mass annihilation efforts recently against modern Trotskyist political organizations and against fraternities and sororities. The net result of these efforts was a lot of lost time by article creators and AfD participants and a lot of lost information from those articles annihilated as part of these campaigns. Meanwhile, the backlog of crap at New Pages festers. Something needs to be done about this problem. Mine is not a unique view — see Wikipedia:ANI#Massive_number_of_Playboy-related_AFD_nominations_by_a_single_user at ANI. We need to keep them all as a matter of principle and ban the future use of automated tools in this way. ''This argument will be copied-and-pasted in the debate sections for all automated AfDs of this campaign""" Deletion of Alesha Oreskovich WP:BEFORE||WP:I Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1697 10267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicole Jolicoeur [[User talk:192.160.216.52|talk]]) 14:26, 3 December 2018 (UTC) keep Meets 4(c). For instance, https://www.jstor.org/stable/44030030 here's an article from Mosaic focusing on her work. https://tessera.journals.yorku.ca/index.php/tessera/article/download/24929/23122 This article from Tessera discusses her work in some depth, and so on. Obviously the present sad state of the article is only an argument for cleanup through ordinary editing. It's unrelated to notability. Special:Contributions/192.160.216.52|192.160.216.52 Deletion of Nicole Jolicoeur WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
1698 11554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acrojet User:Gary 19:56, 24 April 2008 (UTC) keep meets , has Deletion of Acrojet WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1699 8892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bulgaria–Indonesia relations User:BlueSquadronRaven 20:53, 7 May 2009 (UTC) delete """Article is not """"generally notable"""". Fails , , , OTDIR and probably a few other acronyms""" Deletion of Bulgaria–Indonesia relations WP:N||WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1700 17232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abu Muhammad Ordoni User:Siva1979 12:46, 7 August 2007 (UTC) keep A quick http://www.google.com.sg/search?as_q=&hl=en&num=100&btnG=Google+Search&as_epq=Abu+Muhammad+Ordoni&as_oq=&as_eq=wikipedia&lr=&as_ft=i&as_filetype=&as_qdr=all&as_occt=any&as_dt=i&as_sitesearch=&as_rights=&safe=image google search shows up quite a number of |reliable hits for this author. The information on this subject is also easily being |verified as well. --|S Deletion of Abu Muhammad Ordoni WP:RS||WP:V||WP:EA Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1701 14219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shéhérazade (Frederica von Stade recording) User:Niggle1892 16:07, 22 September 2019 (UTC) keep per . The article's COPYVIO issues have now been addressed - brief quotes from reviews will be added in due course. For further coverage of the album, see ''Newsweek'', Vol. 97, 1981, p. 112; ''Saturday Review'', Vol. 8, Issues 7-12, p. 90; Alan Blyth's ''Song on Record'', 1986, p. 111; and ''The complete Penguin stereo record and cassette guide'', 1984, p. 861 Deletion of Shéhérazade (Frederica von Stade recording) WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
1702 156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fallout 3 walkthrough User:Haipa 01:22, 3 April 2009 (UTC) delete per MLauba and Deletion of Fallout 3 walkthrough WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
1703 2774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Biden assault allegation User:Miniapolis 00:13, 16 April 2020 (UTC) delete this |POVFORK per nom, |NOTNEWS and |WEIGHT Deletion of Joe Biden assault allegation WP:POVFORK||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:WEIGHT Wikipedia:Content forking 33
1704 1555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marius Ceteraş User:Peter NONE delete FIDE Master (two levels below Grandmaster (chess)) and no national championships, is insufficient for notability. The article was created by a single edit user - {{Userlinks|Nemo76}} - with lots of detail, so I strongly suspect the article only exists due to editor with issues. His strongest claim to notability would be as a chess author, but it looks to me like the publications are mostly pretty minor ones Deletion of Marius Ceteraş WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
1705 7497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Express Raja User:MichaelQSchmidt 06:41, 30 September 2015 (UTC) keep There were |enough available sources speaking toward the film's MOS:FILM#production|production that I decided to re-visit the one-line stub which https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Express_Raja&diff=prev&oldid=682898615 '''was''' nominated to make some https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Express_Raja&type=revision&diff=683426339&oldid=682898615 '''sourced''' improvements to bring it to short '''start class'''. More can be done, certainly... and I think in a week or two it meeting | (paragraph 3) will be far more obvious. Thanks Deletion of Express Raja WP:NRVE||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1706 4267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carol Hiller User:Alias 20:27, 6 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Carol Hiller WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1707 20960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martial Law: 9/11 Rise of the Police State User:IworkforNASA 19:40, 7 September 2006 (UTC) delete per |wikipedia is NOT a sopabox Deletion of Martial Law: 9/11 Rise of the Police State WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1708 13454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brad Stone (porn star) User:FingersOnRoids 01:58, 19 February 2009 (UTC) delete Does not pass Deletion of Brad Stone (porn star) WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1709 19429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michelle Vogel User:Bearian 18:28, 8 February 2021 (UTC) delete WP:AGF|even if we assume everything is true, she fails , period. We need significant coverage in independent and reliable sources about a living person Deletion of Michelle Vogel WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
1710 5200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of windmills in Guernsey User:Mjroots 17:58, 8 March 2021 (UTC) keep It's a sub-list of the List of windmills, per . Of the mills in the Bailiwick of Guernsey, Vale Mill and Sark Windmill may just be notable enough to sustain articles, but it would be hard work getting either above start class. The subject is notable enough to sustain a list, per Deletion of List of windmills in Guernsey WP:LSC||WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
1711 16274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Racial views of Winston Churchill User:YorkshireLad 12:13, 3 June 2020 (UTC) keep per {{u|Buidhe}} and per {{u|Toughpigs}}' reply above. Seems there's no dispute as to notability at this point, and the issues identified by the nom can, if necessary, be fixed by editing the article. If reliable sources exist disputing the claim that Churchill was racist and are not already included, then they can—and should—be added Deletion of Racial views of Winston Churchill WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1712 7668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Branch Insurance User:InsuranceLovers 20:46, 1 January 2021 (UTC) keep I know that as the article's author, I have a vested interest in the article not being deleted, and it's probably also clear that I support it being kept. But I would like to at least contribute my view on this: Insurance is not a topic that garners tremendous coverage in mainstream press, in part because it's viewed by many (though not me!) as mundane and boring. I do not believe that means it is a not a notable or important topic. I believe that if the community rigidly and without judgment applies the same standards to companies of all industries, that will lead to undercoverage of some important topics (including insurance). Imagine there are two companies: Company A, an insurance company, and Company B, a car company. Those companies, with the same level of innovation, market share, and impact on their communities, will see dramatically different coverage in the mainstream press. By strict standards of , Company A might not pass review, while Company B might. This is simply to say that there are underlying reasons, unrelated to true notability, why some companies in some industries get substantially more coverage, earlier in their existence, than companies in other industries. In the case of Branch and other companies in the insurance space, it takes far more than 'notability' to garner coverage in non-trade or national publications -- it takes something closer to being one of the the absolute largest behemoths in the industry. I don't take the purpose of the notability guidelines to be to sort out all corporations in an industry other than those with the absolute greatest prominence and/or those that are the handful of largest ones in the nation. Strictly and rigidly applying to insurance companies would have that effect. I also disagree with the judgment that the article is overly promotional or promotional at all, but I don't take that to be the central challenge to the approval of the article, so I won't address that directly or thoroughly. If you believe I should, I can do that Deletion of Branch Insurance WP:NCORP||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1713 3451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Ricca [[User talk:2001:8003:5999:6D00:8826:7EAA:B135:5C72|talk]]) 07:18, 20 August 2019 (UTC) delete Fails . Non notable local wrestler. Hammonton News is a local suburban newspaper with limited circulation http://www.thedailyjournalsolutions.com/solutions/products-and-services/print-products/the-atlantic-county-weeklies/ see here for proof that it's local which does nothing for notability. Agree with nom about promotional article. Special:Contributions/2001:8003:5999:6D00:8826:7EAA:B135:5C72|2001:8003:5999:6D00:8826:7EAA:B135:5C72 Deletion of Tony Ricca WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1714 7742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PinkPT 2 User:SusanLarson 19:02, 15 January 2006 (UTC) delete Notability 206 sites link to this one. Alexa traffic rank 74,597 so also doesn't meet Deletion of PinkPT 2 WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1715 16025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohanalakshmi User:Jupitus 02:42, 22 June 2021 (UTC) delete Non notable businesswoman. Only passing mentions or puff pieces provided as references and nothing better found in a . Most of the references are about her company which I believe would not pass if it had an article, so I don't believe she merits any automatic inherited notability as well Deletion of Mohanalakshmi WP:BEFORE||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1716 13291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Live from SoHo (The Decemberists) User:TheJazzDalek 00:33, 8 April 2009 (UTC) delete Non-notable, non-charting EP with little or no media coverage of substance. Fails Deletion of Live from SoHo (The Decemberists) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1717 16574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Livejournal's Next Top Model [[User_talk:Shell_Kinney|babelfish]] 00:02, 4 September 2006 (UTC) delete as completely failing . Shell Deletion of Livejournal's Next Top Model WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1718 6875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lector Latinus User:Wcquidditch 01:51, 30 March 2006 (UTC) delete per nom, and if it was created by the author of the software, it's likely |original research Deletion of Lector Latinus WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1719 3597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaheen Peerbhai User:GPL93 23:08, 21 March 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and . Best Deletion of Shaheen Peerbhai WP:GNG||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1720 10905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron and Bryce Dessner (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 17:23, 23 September 2016 (UTC) merge """to the band per Johnpacklambert. We definitely don't need standalone s of them as individuals, a separate article about them as a duo ''and'' an article about the band that they're notable for being in. It is a remotely plausible search term in its own right, as they ''have'' done a couple of compilation album tracks under this name rather than as the band per se, but it doesn't need a standalone article of its own as a separate topic from the other ''three'' related articles that already exist. Question, though: if this is a """"2nd nomination"""", then where's the first""" Deletion of Aaron and Bryce Dessner (2nd nomination) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
1721 248 [[Terminal Tower]] (LA zurückgezogen) Benutzer:Havelbaude NONE keep Hm. Wird 2008 zweithöchstes Bauwerk in Linz. mMn damit knapp #Bauwerke_und_Denkmale erreicht. Insofern Löschung von Terminal Tower Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
1722 10066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of 2012 Romanian legislative election Chamber of Deputies candidates User:1292simon 01:53, 15 December 2012 (UTC) delete As per rticles_for_deletion/List_of_2012_Romanian_legislative_election_Senate_candidates Deletion of List of 2012 Romanian legislative election Chamber of Deputies candidates WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
1723 10389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph and Imhotep User:Drnhawkins 17:56, 28 April 2009 (UTC) delete this material has not been included on other articles for precisely the same reason that this one should be deleted - because it is original research. I certainly understand the editor's confusion, as he has provided sources. But the reliance entirely on primary sources, combined with conjecture, is exactly how |synthesis is produced, and it should be published by a reliable publisher before arriving on WP. I hope that Deletion of Joseph and Imhotep WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
1724 20074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Morris the Cat User:Bearian 16:24, 10 December 2019 (UTC) keep Famous mascot. Deletion of Morris the Cat WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1725 14812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dogface (book) User:Coolabahapple 12:19, 10 May 2015 (UTC) delete does not meet , search yields seller sites, some blog sites, all trivial mentions Deletion of Dogface (book) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1726 16899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gable Carr [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 00:50, 26 September 2006 (UTC) delete """Does not yet meet the notability requirements of . No sources of any kind in the article, much less credible, third-party ones as required by . I found http://www.google.com/search?as_q=&num=50&hl=en&rls=GGLH%2CGGLH%3A1969-53%2CGGLH%3Aen&btnG=Google+Search&as_epq=Gable+Carr&as_oq=&as_eq=&lr=&as_ft=i&as_filetype=&as_qdr=all&as_nlo=&as_nhi=&as_occt=any&as_dt=i&as_sitesearch=&as_rights=&safe=images around 40 unique G-Hits, most of them just credit listings for ''Dorm Daze 2'', in which she had a bit part. One might actually expect many more GHits on an actress in a movie that has a tag line of ''""""College Sophmores. Salty Sea Men''."""" Ugh""" Deletion of Gable Carr WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
1727 10332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/India Today's top 10 colleges of India User:Jacqui 05:51, 8 November 2005 (UTC) keep We have American lists that are similar. This helps Deletion of India Today's top 10 colleges of India WP:CSB Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
1728 10917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Feathercoin (4th nomination) User:Balkywrest 00:25, 15 November 2018 (UTC) delete does not pass the |general notability guideline Deletion of Feathercoin (4th nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1729 11898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Board of Secondary Education,Madhya Bharat,Gwalior User:Bharathiya 19:19, 25 January 2013 (UTC) delete Pure advertisement of a non notable and fake institution offering secondary and senior secondary courses without any authority in India. Fails , , and . For speedy deletion Deletion of Board of Secondary Education,Madhya Bharat,Gwalior WP:GNG||WP:BASIC||WP:GOOGLE||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1730 10733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solstice at Panipat, 14 January 1761 User:Animeshkulkarni 08:10, 1 August 2012 (UTC) keep The book has received fair coverage in media. Three independent newspapers writing about it, reviewing it or interviewing author about the book, is sufficient for . Every book does not have to be ''Devdas'' or ''A Brief History of Time''. And as to some editor's views that the book is rubbish and non-credible and what not, let third-party sources call it so. You don't get to decide that Deletion of Solstice at Panipat, 14 January 1761 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1731 11398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clarks Beach User:MakeSense64 15:59, 6 December 2011 (UTC) comment I get 111 hits on gnews search for it. So, it probably satisfies because its existence can be verified through reliable sources Deletion of Clarks Beach WP:NPLACE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1732 16140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helen LaKelly Hunt User:Knox490 05:34, 2 March 2018 (UTC) keep Definitely meets on the basis of her much discussed published work. As noted by Coolabahapple, there are notable reviews/discussions of her book ''Making Marriage Simple'': https://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/03/21/making-marriage-simple_n_2917305.html Huff Post, http://www.oprah.com/relationships/how-positivity-can-save-your-marriage-imago-relationship-therapy Oprah.Com, https://health.usnews.com/health-news/health-wellness/articles/2013/02/14/how-to-claim-the-love-of-your-life US News, https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/life-style/relationships/love-sex/4-things-that-can-stop-a-divorce/articleshow/47107718.cms Times of India. She has a track record of producing work that is noted by prominent sources Deletion of Helen LaKelly Hunt WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1733 16769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gilles Domoraud User:Phil 20:59, 9 December 2008 (UTC) keep Has played in two fully professional leagues (the Greek top division and the second division in France), so passes Deletion of Gilles Domoraud WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1734 2006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karlie's Kookies User:The 13:18, 13 September 2018 (UTC) merge whatever can be salvaged, certainly selecting only from what's |sourced, into Milk Bar (bakery). No independent notability: strictly |brand love Deletion of Karlie's Kookies WP:V||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1735 5700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pip Skid User:Gongshow 20:59, 14 May 2010 (UTC) keep """As Chubbles noted, |notability is not temporary, so significant coverage for a """"flash in the pan"""" still qualifies as significant coverage. Here is an additional source, a http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/6541-funny-farm/ Pitchfork review from 2004""" Deletion of Pip Skid WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1736 233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Commune (documentary) User:Ichibani 02:42, 18 June 2007 (UTC) merge """to Black Bear Ranch. The article does not effectively assert notability except in the statement """"It's among the first of a group of films that reexamine and contest the negation of the ethos of the 1960's and 1970's"""". The Wikipedia:Notability (films)|proposed policy for film notability suggests notability is met if """"The film is widely distributed and has received full length reviews by two or more nationally known critics"""". Although two full length reviews seem to be available http://www.tvguide.com/movies/commune/review/282751http://movies2.nytimes.com/2006/11/03/movies/03comm.html, the film is not yet widely distributed. #CBALL|Wikipedia is not a crystal ball, so a merge with no prejudice against recreation if/when more reliable sources are available is indicated. ''Ichibani""" Deletion of Commune (documentary) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1737 10151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prabir Purkayastha User:Qworty 05:51, 30 March 2013 (UTC) delete No to establish notability Deletion of Prabir Purkayastha WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1738 12280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ColorfulTabs user:varun21 17:30, 19 June 2009 (UTC) keep d/l stats cited are significant. Inclusion in a significant number of independently published must-have lists seem to speak to . Note, though that Deletion of ColorfulTabs WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1739 18194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ubercart User:Ducknish 02:33, 1 May 2012 (UTC) delete No reasonable unaffiliated sources on the subject, no evidence that it meets Deletion of Ubercart WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1740 20340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ni-Oh (2nd nomination) User:Sergecross73 00:10, 21 October 2012 (UTC) keep There's enough coverage in |third party reliable sources to meet the , and enough content to establish a pretty good Dev section. It's been officially announced, has a name, and in the alpha stages; I see no valid reason to apply CRYSTAL here Deletion of Ni-Oh (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1741 488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cathy Day User:Alpha 16:08, 3 February 2012 (UTC) delete The subject lacks |significant coverage in |reliable third party sources, and appears to fail the |notability guidelines for biographies Deletion of Cathy Day WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1742 21308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Janata enterprises User:Ihcoyc 21:36, 11 July 2010 (UTC) delete """This is ''a Consumer Electronic Showroom and retailer chain of showroom carrying fine Furnitures, T.V, LCD, Refrigerators, Computers, Laptops and all major Consumer electronic goods. (from 1981 to till date). '' This is obvious advertising; and this one is probably |not the first such business, and as such this one has no """"Notability in Wikipedia|long term historical"""" |significance""" Deletion of Janata enterprises WP:MILL||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
1743 2398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Are You Ready (Hannah Montana song) User:onel5969 00:42, 29 December 2020 (UTC) merge to the album, ''Hannah Montana Forever''. SPA apparently disingenuously simply slapped some chart information on the article which is unsupported by citations, or by searches. Another song by this artist did chart at #66 on ''US Billboard Hot 100'', but that was ''Gonna Get This'', the week of 11/6/2010, see https://www.billboard.com/charts/hot-100/2010-11-06?rank=66 here. The other 2 are not major charts, so would not count towards . So it doesn't meet that SNG or Deletion of Are You Ready (Hannah Montana song) WP:NSONG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1744 19602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Theodoridis User:WFCforLife 22:55, 16 September 2010 (UTC) delete It's unclear whether he even passes , which is pretty lenient for Greek footballers. As far as I can tell, he fails and , and given that he now plys his trade for a club that don't even have a wikipedia article, his notability is unlikely to change in the near future Deletion of Thomas Theodoridis WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
1745 5798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 Agdam skirmish User:Nick 07:20, 30 January 2009 (UTC) delete Per #NEWS. I just checked, and this is different enough from the previous article (which was recreated after deletion) to not fit into a speedy deletion category Deletion of 2009 Agdam skirmish WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1746 12797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manish Pitambare User:De728631 19:00, 10 August 2009 (UTC) delete per nomination. An early promotion to Major might be notable but would still fail Deletion of Manish Pitambare WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1747 5813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of characters in The Simpsons by MBTI type (2nd nomination) User:RHaworth 18:20, 25 February 2008 (UTC) delete The first AfD was quite clear that this is pure |OR Deletion of List of characters in The Simpsons by MBTI type (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1748 2565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anupap Buachand User:Orangemike 17:57, 12 September 2014 (UTC) delete without prejudice - no assertion of notability, no evidence of notability, in fact no |reliable sources whatsoever on a BLP Deletion of Anupap Buachand :WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1749 17210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cheryl B. Schrader User:Xxanthippe 22:43, 15 May 2016 (UTC) keep Passes #C6 Deletion of Cheryl B. Schrader WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1750 21159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enamel signs in argentine User:Clarityfiend 04:34, 3 July 2012 (UTC) delete Most of it isn't even about enamel signs, but about posters. The little that is is and/or unreferenced. Nothing worth merging to Enamel sign Deletion of Enamel signs in argentine WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1751 15717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kishan bagh User:SwisterTwister 05:21, 16 July 2015 (UTC) delete This is a case of and would be need to be rewritten with a new start; my searches found nothing to suggest good improvement such as https://www.google.com/search?q=Kishan+bagh+Hyderabad&btnG=Search+Books&tbm=bks&tbo=1#q=Kishan+bagh+Hyderabad&tbm=nws this Deletion of Kishan bagh WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
1752 13462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oobliette Sparks [[User talk:Jезка|talk]]) 11:25, 21 July 2008 (UTC) delete Fails ; non-notable person. She is only known for being in the band Tsunami Bomb, which itself is a somewhat unremarkable band. Special:Contributions/Jезка|''Jезка Deletion of Oobliette Sparks WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1753 19563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gopesh sarath User:Jimfbleak 12:56, 27 June 2018 (UTC) delete this elf-written vanity page as Deletion of Gopesh sarath WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1754 11873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of streets and roads celebrated in music User:sumnjim 17:34, 21 June 2007 (UTC) delete I agree with the nominator that this suffers from and issues. What kind of encyclopedic value does this add, anyways Deletion of List of streets and roads celebrated in music WP:POV||WP:OR Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1755 16875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Garmina Paygar-Flangiah User:GiantSnowman 09:06, 7 October 2019 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Garmina Paygar-Flangiah WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1756 1342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cibao Airport Flight Schedule (2nd nomination) User:Cremepuff222 00:56, 19 June 2007 (UTC) delete Already deleted before. Recreation of material violating . it already Deletion of Cibao Airport Flight Schedule (2nd nomination) WP:NOT||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1757 10507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brooke Saward User:Eggishorn 18:34, 27 February 2017 (UTC) keep Has sources in independent, and there is significant coverage of her apparent in further searches. Passes Deletion of Brooke Saward WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1758 16610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MyAnimeList (2nd nomination) User:Ursasapien 06:47, 27 March 2008 (UTC) keep Notable, sourced, certainly should have an encyclopedia entry. The article is well written and the nearly immediate renomination for deletion smacks of and trying to keep nominating until editors get the result they want Deletion of MyAnimeList (2nd nomination) WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1759 460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sonatype Nexus User:AllyD 06:59, 27 July 2017 (UTC) delete Searches are turning up routine coverage (announcements, etc.). There are a few how-to postings at Medium but I am not seeing the substantial coverage needed for or Deletion of Sonatype Nexus :WP:NSOFT||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1760 9209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Sabga User:The 09:52, 19 January 2019 (UTC) delete since subject fails Deletion of Alex Sabga WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1761 10458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris M. Gent User:ZimZalaBim 03:40, 4 August 2007 (UTC) delete even after I removed the copyright-infringing material, article fails Deletion of Chris M. Gent WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1762 541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LOL (Internet slang) User:Onorem 12:29, 16 January 2007 (UTC) keep First of all, the article has citations. Secondly, #I don't like it|I don't like it isn't a very good argument for deletion Deletion of LOL (Internet slang) WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1763 10083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herschel Lovett Bridge User:Lightburst 15:18, 29 August 2020 (UTC) keep Per Nondescript bridges are not usually the subject of dedications. This one was https://newspaperarchive.com/thomasville-times-enterprise-mar-16-1953-p-5/ dedicated in 1953. The bridge is featured prominently in a book about the county. https://www.google.com/books/edition/Laurens_County/nZTdnpAiS5EC?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=%22Herschel+Lovett+Bridge%22+-wikipedia&pg=PA120&printsec=frontcover 1 Deletion of Herschel Lovett Bridge WP:GEOFEAT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1764 7076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rachel Held Evans User:Goodvac 06:41, 23 November 2011 (UTC) keep """Evans meets both the |GNG and (3c), as evidenced by these exquisite sources—http://www.webcitation.org/63P3w7mOa """"A year of living biblically"""" from ''Toronto Star'', http://www.npr.org/2011/09/25/140761994/biblical-womanhood-a-year-of-living-by-the-book """"'Biblical Womanhood': A Year Of Living By The Book"""" from ''All Things Considered'', http://www.journalgazette.net/article/20111006/FEAT04/310069990/1011/FEAT """"Exploring Bible's roles for women"""" from ''The Journal Gazette'', http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/the-womens-blog-with-jane-martinson/2011/oct/06/woman-year-living-biblically """"One woman's year of living biblically"""" from ''The Guardian'', http://www.slate.com/articles/double_x/doublex/2011/09/a_year_of_biblical_womanhood.html """"A Year of Biblical Womanhood"""" from ''Slate (magazine)|Slate'', and http://www.webcitation.org/63P4Y1kSC """"How to be a woman: playing it by The Book"""" from ''The Times|The Times of London""" Deletion of Rachel Held Evans WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1765 19313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/André Anderson User:Ejgreen77 00:25, 18 August 2016 (UTC) keep per Smartyllama as a pass Deletion of André Anderson WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
1766 2477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Davis (footballer) User:GiantSnowman 17:19, 18 April 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Ben Davis (footballer) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1767 18054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Backyard cricket User:BU 11:07, 3 July 2015 (UTC) comment Note that the nominator withdrew his nomination above. This now likely meets |speedy keep criteria 1 Deletion of Backyard cricket WP:SK Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
1768 11746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Elevator Men User:Joe 21:39, 19 December 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |band Deletion of The Elevator Men WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1769 4094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Britt Marie Hermes User:Fieari 02:13, 15 June 2016 (UTC) keep """I honestly don't see it as promotional, or at least not """"too"""" promotional. Most of it seems simply stating what she is known for. If any rewriting is necessary, it would be very minor tweaking into more encyclopedic voice, not wholesale gutting of the article. Notability seems to be established, and besides, I am philosophically opposed to anyway""" Deletion of Britt Marie Hermes WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
1770 4159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayor of Englewood, New Jersey [[User talk:Lambiam|Lambiam]] 17:27, 20 October 2011 (UTC) keep We have articles Mayor of Ashland, Kentucky, Mayor of Boonton, New Jersey, Mayor of Charlotte, North Carolina, ... . I know |OTHERSTUFFEXISTS is not supposed to be an argument, but there is nothing making the office of Mayor of Englewood, New Jersey, any less notable than these other mayorships. So should all these articles be deleted? If you look at the Mayors of Englewood we have articles on, you'll see that their main claim to fame is ... having been the Mayor of Englewood! I'd say, if holding an office makes one notable, then the office is notable. Deletion of Mayor of Englewood, New Jersey WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1771 13029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cruateese Classic User:Ihcoyc 14:28, 19 October 2009 (UTC) delete Not sure that this qualifies for speedy deletion as an '''''obvious''''' hoax. There is no blatant falsehood or contradiction here; the dreary regimen prescribed may well work, and the references do support the article's trivial assertion that cottage cheese is rich in protein. But it remains a |non-notable neologism, and |you could have thought of it yourself Deletion of Cruateese Classic WP:NEO||WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
1772 8683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katy Allen User:Narthring 05:06, 5 November 2009 (UTC) delete per ; none of its criterion are satisfied. A single non-leading role in a television series is not notable Deletion of Katy Allen WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1773 18460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ravens Bluff User:Jclemens 05:24, 10 July 2017 (UTC) merge per BOZ and -M. I'll note that K.e.coffman's opinion is ''not'' policy based, in that primary sources are perfectly acceptable to verify uncontroversial content; they just don't count towards notability Deletion of Ravens Bluff WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1774 3126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Fischetti User:Less 12:26, 15 April 2021 (UTC) delete my has shown no coverage about the subject. Fails and Deletion of Mike Fischetti WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1775 9295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sharon Presley User:Binksternet 02:09, 23 December 2013 (UTC) comment The strong presence of Presley in the Klatch and the Heider books gets us into field position for . Presley being cited by Kelly, Taylor, Welsh and others puts the ball into the end zone Deletion of Sharon Presley WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1776 13144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019–20 Gheorghe Hagi Football Academy teams season User:Number 11:15, 18 June 2020 (UTC) delete Clear failure Deletion of 2019–20 Gheorghe Hagi Football Academy teams season WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1777 15569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jaybleeng User:NatGertler 20:46, 8 February 2015 (UTC) delete under . This is so heavily an ad that it would take monumental scraping, and I see no sign that we would find anything under there. Boasted Post-Dispatch coverage is a press release on their website Deletion of Jaybleeng WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1778 15853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erogrendel (novel) User:Jergling 17:05, 16 November 2016 (UTC) delete WP:INHERIT - Father's fame does not make him notable. - Summary-only description of a piece of media Deletion of Erogrendel (novel) WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1779 11723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dezmond Meeks User:MacGyverMagic 07:50, 9 April 2009 (UTC) delete """On further inspection: According to http://dev.realitytvmagazine.com/blog/2005/02/01/dezmond-meeks-former-american-idol-reject/ this page he was rejected in an earlier audition and made it past that round in American Idol (season 4). Still, he hasn't made the semi-finals or finals according to our own article, so he didn't """"place in a major music competition"""" nor does he meet other music inclusion criteria. The sources are insufficiently reliable to meet """ Deletion of Dezmond Meeks WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1780 530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Biblical counseling NONE NONE keep It's all very well saying the argument is worthless, but there are numerous books and theses ''about'' the subject. Here are a few Deletion of Biblical counseling WP:GOOGLEHITS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1781 12304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K. Sivarajan User:Walwal20 13:07, 2 October 2020 (UTC) delete """per might apply here. There is not enough information in the article that allows me to pinpoint who this """"K. Sivarajan"""" is and what he has done. Surprisingly there are many """"K. Sivarajan"""" out there, for many different flavors of this """"K"""", and I'm not willing to put more effort in trying to find which one we are talking about, and which works actually belong to the subject of this article https://www.kopykitab.com/Educational-Technology-by-Dr-K-Sivarajan https://www.flipkart.com/educational-psychology/p/itm75a23b6c9542f https://career.webindia123.com/career/institutes/details_colleges_Institutes.asp?group=49&parent=yes&inst_no=24805. This difficulty also indicates lack of notability, so if speedy is contested, I'm still voting '''delete''' for not meeting or """ Deletion of K. Sivarajan WP:A1||WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1782 16203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of international cricket centuries by Michael Hussey User:Davidstewartharvey 09:06, 22 January 2021 (UTC) merge No need for separate article, does not count as centuries are a small and rather exclusive part of a cricketers career. If it was his whole international career details I would have said delete, but it's not so its def a merge Deletion of List of international cricket centuries by Michael Hussey WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1783 16481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of maps in Battlefield 2 (2nd nomination) User:Charlesknight 12:28, 14 December 2006 (UTC) delete per , - as it currently stands the tone of this article is all wrong and if even it was re-written from scratch, I don't see any real world or cultural impact that requires more than 3 or 4 lines on the main article Deletion of List of maps in Battlefield 2 (2nd nomination) WP:V||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1784 13651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wang Zuanxu User:Whaterss 00:48, 21 March 2015 (UTC) keep Per Deletion of Wang Zuanxu WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
1785 140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of box office records set by Avengers: Infinity War User:Tutelary 04:20, 27 June 2018 (UTC) keep There List_of_box_office_records_set_by_Star_Wars:_The_Force_Awakens|have List_of_box_office_records_set_by_Deadpool|been List_of_box_office_records_set_by_Avatar|other Wikipedia articles for separating and elaborating on more records than is exhaustively possible on the main movie article. I will not solely rely on those articles as |other stuff exists, but to demonstrate that this is not a new phenomenon. Particularly after Avengers: Infinity War kept breaking records, https://screenrant.com/avengers-infinity-war-records/ the https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/heat-vision/avengers-infinity-war-box-office-a-rundown-records-broken-1106802 news https://www.forbes.com/sites/scottmendelson/2018/04/30/avengers-infinity-war-the-box-office-records-it-broke-in-its-641m-debut/#64f0fd4a2ff1 media https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/comic-riffs/wp/2018/05/07/avengers-infinity-war-just-topped-1-billion-in-record-time-whats-next/?utm_term=.98093000e62b certainly http://comicbook.com/marvel/2018/04/29/avengers-infinity-war-records/ took https://filmschoolrejects.com/avengers-infinity-war-box-office-records/ notice https://deadline.com/2018/04/avengers-infinity-war-weekend-box-office-opening-records-1202378032/ and https://www.gamespot.com/articles/avengers-infinity-war-busts-more-records-on-way-to/1100-6458662/ continued http://collider.com/avengers-infinity-war-box-office/ writing https://www.wsj.com/articles/avengers-infinity-war-sets-box-office-records-1525025846 articles https://www.rollingstone.com/movies/news/avengers-infinity-war-breaks-the-force-awakens-record-w519665 on https://www.forbes.com/sites/scottmendelson/2018/05/28/infinity-war-tops-last-jedi-and-avengers-at-u-s-box-office/#1f185bc52630 the https://variety.com/2018/film/news/avengers-infinity-war-box-office-1-billion-1202798746/ subject. Not every movie that is released has this type of coverage in numerous |reliable sources relating to the records that it has broken for its Box Office Debut. I argue that due to this consistent media coverage and the |general notability independent of the movie warrants this separate article. It is not in violation of as it was not intended for promotion, but to provide an encyclopedic explanation of the various box office records that Infinity War has broken. Nearly all of the records have solid sourcing behind them, are not published with Marvel's PR team, and instead written by volunteer editors seeking to |contribute to the encyclopedia. That is pretty much the opposite of . This type of article cannot be simply merged with the parent movie article as it has broken more records than is feasible to include in the parent article, and if forced to merge, would |tip the balance for content already on the movie article. I recommend that this article be kept for those reasons Deletion of List of box office records set by Avengers: Infinity War WP:OSE||WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:PROMO||WP:HERE||WP:PROMO||WP:DUE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1786 19012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lorenzo Andrenacci User:Sir 17:07, 21 July 2013 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Lorenzo Andrenacci WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1787 11542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional television shows (2nd nomination) User:Reyk 01:48, 29 July 2008 (UTC) delete Unscourced, |indiscriminate, non-encyclopedic listcruft. Last year's AFD got it badly wrong Deletion of List of fictional television shows (2nd nomination) WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1788 3975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JayJay Oakey User:Papaursa 19:51, 25 October 2015 (UTC) delete """Fails to meet because of a lack of significant independent coverage. He's not even mentioned in several of the references, notability is not gained through your boxing trainer, and there's no evidence he achieved notability as a boxer () or weightlifter (). Being selected for the """"regional pre-selection trials"""" for the 2012 Olympics does not show notability""" Deletion of JayJay Oakey WP:GNG||WP:NBOX||WP:NSPORTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1789 16382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Family Guy in Star Wars User:NiciVampireHeart 07:55, 23 March 2008 (UTC) delete hoax or . Take your pick Deletion of Family Guy in Star Wars WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1790 7982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evoke engine User:Hersfold 02:01, 18 February 2008 (UTC) delete as a violation Deletion of Evoke engine WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1791 15292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harrison J. Fuller User:Theroadislong 12:19, 6 November 2018 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Harrison J. Fuller WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1792 7447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daredevil (Marvel Comics series) User:BOZ 11:33, 28 June 2016 (UTC) keep I agree that there is some redundancy remaining from the Daredevil (Marvel Comics) article, but I also believe that these are two valid topics on their own and meet the |notability guidelines. I will try to find some time today or tomorrow to rectify this Deletion of Daredevil (Marvel Comics series) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1793 2609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Proctor User:David 21:09, 29 March 2008 (UTC) delete Still looks like an A7 speedy to me, but let's finish the AfD so that we can salt and/or use #G4 in future Deletion of Bob Proctor WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1794 686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Last Piece Theory User:Bearian 18:16, 28 June 2007 (UTC) delete per nom, or Urban legend Deletion of Last Piece Theory WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1795 6244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1975 Australian network television schedule (weekday) User:JohnCD 15:22, 23 November 2009 (UTC) delete per . Pretty colours, though Deletion of 1975 Australian network television schedule (weekday) WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1796 5080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of computer pranks User:Stephen 06:38, 6 August 2006 (UTC) delete contents seems entirely - the judgement about what should be included is not backed by published sources Deletion of List of computer pranks WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1797 15642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerardus Everardus Tros User:Bearcat 20:10, 8 April 2019 (UTC) delete """Just to be clear, our inclusion criteria for philosophers have very little to do with whether their philosophy is """"serious"""" or """"woo"""" — metaphysical writers can still receive |reliable source coverage that analyzes their importance (e.g. Helena Blavatsky), and non-metaphysical philosophers can still fail to receive that. What's determinative here is not so much his subject area, as his complete lack of any sources he didn't write and publish himself""" Deletion of Gerardus Everardus Tros WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1798 344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Contender (stock character) User:Snow 02:03, 19 December 2017 (UTC) delete Whoever authored this article may find their approach welcome at TV tropes, but under this project's guidelines, this is blatant riginal research that hasn't even so much as been masked by a single reference. This is certainly an archetype we can all recognize, but we don't create articles based solely on our own observations of narrative trends. Again, there's a voluminous and very interesting project devoted to exactly this purpose, but Wikipedia is not it Deletion of Contender (stock character) WP:O Wikipedia:Orphan 47
1799 6848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Catterall User:Martinp23 23:17, 7 January 2007 (UTC) delete I am another English editor who |would not know him from a hole in the ground. Also, his show (Whatever) seems not to be notable enough to have an article (and, the comment of mine applies to the show to, but I trust Guy's judgement that it was crap). Also, doesn't seem to meet |notability criteria - not every TV presented has/needs/deserves an article Deletion of David Catterall WP:HOLE||WP:HOLE||WP:NN Wikipedia:I wouldn't know him from a hole in the ground 12
1800 21279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laurence Kaptain User:Romanempire 09:03, 13 June 2008 (UTC) comment I would agree if weren't the only issue. I think the debate is shaping up to being a question of whether the article satisfies , and, in the larger picture, what criteria need to be met for concert musicians in general Deletion of Laurence Kaptain WP:COI||WP:N Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
1801 16902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Yiakoulis User:Joe 23:05, 18 May 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |musician Deletion of Maria Yiakoulis WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1802 59 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional astronauts User:TenPoundHammer 16:09, 29 July 2007 (UTC) delete per #IINFO and #DIR. Who ''cares'' about fictional astronauts Deletion of List of fictional astronauts WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1803 19985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patxi's Chicago Pizza User:OlYeller21 22:24, 21 December 2010 (UTC) keep In my opinion, it satisfies 's significant coverage from reliable and independent sources with the 4 provided references (there are 6 total right now but two are from the official website of the subject Deletion of Patxi's Chicago Pizza WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1804 2476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Pokémon references or spoofs (2nd AfD Nomination) User:Zappernapper 16:05, 19 February 2007 (UTC) keep """While i agree with Krimpet's arguement that this is one of those lists that makes people want to crusade against ''all'' pop culture lists, both RobJ1981 and Jerichi need to remember that just calling something |cruft is not an argument in itself and should be avoided at AFDs. First, the keep: Any subject that has become so well known that it is criticized, parodied, and referenced in a wide variety of media outlets deserves a section that appropriately details some of the more high-profile or notable cases (e.g. given ''South Park's'' ratings, the """"Chinpokomon"""" episode would be high-profile). I could make a |point and go over to Wikipedia in popular culture and delete the two rather lengthy lists found there. While there may be consensus for deleting the Wikipedia in popular culture#Miscellaneous|Miscellaneous section, I doubt I would get away with rming the first one which are """"Landmark references."""" I'm not trying to make a """"two wrongs make a right"""" arguement, i just want to show how editors tend to say, """"Well it's Pokemon, and so if it's not highly important or ref-bloated we should get rid of it."""" The result is """"cruft, cruft, cruft."""" How to improve: If you take a close look at Otto4711's arguements you can see that this list ''could'' be improved if anyone wanted to take the time to provide the importance of said pop culture references - the Wikpedia related article justifies many of it's inclusions because they are the first examples within a specific media (of course 3 of them could be rm for not fulfilling this criterion), this list could follow suit with many of the entries""" Deletion of List of Pokémon references or spoofs (2nd AfD Nomination) WP:CRUFT||WP:POINT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
1805 6458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs about rain (2nd nomination) User:Ajf773 10:18, 11 June 2021 (UTC) delete Too broad of a list criteria. Deletion of List of songs about rain (2nd nomination) WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1806 1118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hyperlexicon User:StraussInTheHouse 03:55, 21 February 2019 (UTC) delete per {{noping|Squeamish Ossifrage}}. Plus per Deletion of Hyperlexicon WP:NOTNEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
1807 20600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ed Butcher [[User talk:2over0|2/0]] ([[Special:Contributions/2over0|cont.]]) 08:13, 23 February 2010 (UTC) delete Lacks in depth coverage in independent sources, misses Deletion of Ed Butcher WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1808 16102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Double price discrimination User:Rcurtis5 14:00, 8 July 2009 (UTC) delete This article seems to be a term. The references included in the page never mention this term or anything related to it. A search of Google, Google Books and Google Scholar revealed nothing to indicate this term has ever been used in any type of economic sense Deletion of Double price discrimination WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
1809 10016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vincent Therraisnathan User:Amatulic 23:55, 15 July 2014 (UTC) delete in accordance with #G11. I may have missed something looking through the 50 references, but as far as I can tell, all of them are self-published, trivial mentions, youtube links, download links, directory listings, and other non-references that provide absolutely zero |significant coverage of the subject. The article appears to exist purely for publicity purposes in violation of Deletion of Vincent Therraisnathan WP:CSD||WP:SIGCOV||WP:NOTPROMOTION Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1810 20593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shankudeb Panda User:Lefcentreright 16:07, 27 February 2020 (UTC) delete Fails as Panda has only held non-notable party positions and not public offices as required Deletion of Shankudeb Panda WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1811 6205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss World 2010 User:Matt 07:43, 15 December 2008 (UTC) keep """Per , Miss World 2010 is notable and and verifiable. """"All articles about anticipated events must be verifiable, and the subject matter must be of sufficiently wide interest that it would merit an article if the event had already occurred""" Deletion of Miss World 2010 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1812 5709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Army of One (2020 film) User:ReaderofthePack 07:07, 17 November 2020 (UTC) delete as there's not enough coverage to show that this meets . No objection to its restoration when/if it gets more coverage upon its release date Deletion of Army of One (2020 film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
1813 14234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeremy Taylor (writer) User:DGG 16:53, 31 May 2011 (UTC) keep but consider merging some of the related content, certainly the article for his book Discover Trinidad and Tobago, which does not warrant separate coverage, and probably also the article for the publisher he runs, Media and Editorial Projects Limited, and perhaps also Caribbean Beat the magazine he publishes, and even Caribbean Review of Books, which he also publishes--though that is the one of them all which most deserves a separate article. I must admit I felt a little more positive about this before discovering separate articles on each of them, a classical alled Garden. This is one of those cases where there might well be distinct sources for notability , but they are not in any practical way accessible to us because of regional bias. It's not just getting access to print: Some regions and languages have neither print nor online adequate periodical or newspaper indexes, or even book union catalogs. And in the US there are inadequate collections for some areas in even the major libraries. And some aspects of life of great human cultural and economic significance do not publish anything that resembles what we think of as reliable sources; some still rely entirely upon oral or manuscript traditions. The only approach to this that is productive for us in the short run is to relax our standards for what we do accept, in consideration of what can be expected to be found. In the long one, we can hope that the spreat of the multilingual Wikipedia projects will encourage the development of the necessary resources. I have sometime criticized some WMF initiatives, but their efforts to increase participation for the global south, and for development in these regions of the necessary basic information resources, do information from the things and people important to them can get the recognition they deserve in the general world community Deletion of Jeremy Taylor (writer) WP:W Help:Watchlist 110
1814 18899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RTMOS (Real-Time Multiprogramming Operating System) User:Mark 21:53, 25 August 2013 (UTC) keep per AND Deletion of RTMOS (Real-Time Multiprogramming Operating System) WP:RECENT Wikipedia:Recentism 10
1815 15105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs in Wii Music User:Dissident93 21:26, 22 October 2018 (UTC) merge consensus was to allow these sort of track listings on music games ''if'' they can be sourced. If they can't however, they it should be deleted per Deletion of List of songs in Wii Music WP:GAMECRUFT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
1816 18964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neeraj Chawla User:FisherQueen 00:52, 16 February 2009 (UTC) delete This appears to be an autobiography, and his professional resume doesn't seem to inherently meet the |notability criteria. Google led me to his profiles on what appears to be every professional networking site in the world; possibly he has mistaken Wikipedia for one of those Deletion of Neeraj Chawla WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1817 11735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zorek Richards User:Qworty 00:09, 31 December 2010 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet , , or . His nearest brush with fame appears to be the time a U.S. Senator delivered a personal put-down that attested to the subject's non-notability Deletion of Zorek Richards WP:AUTHOR||WP:BK||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1818 1158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mountain Astrologer User:Jovanmilic97 10:34, 14 November 2018 (UTC) delete This magazine fails . Literally nothing of the references (which are: a references without a link, second one is the closest to attribute to something but seems like a passing mention, primary stuff and the reference that has nothing to do with the subject) in the article is significant coverage of the subject to account to which counts towards . I was not able to find anything in secondary sources. Regarding as to what Atlantic306 has said, to pass you need to have ''significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject.'' Not notable Deletion of The Mountain Astrologer WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1819 3701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jovan Nikolic User:Ohconfucius 07:34, 30 May 2013 (UTC) delete I found nothing on the dude whatsoever; furthermore, the article fails to assert the notability of this great soldier, so I guess I will conclude that this was a stb at creating a #MEMORIAL|memorial Deletion of Jovan Nikolic WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1820 1168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cytext ; Cytexting User:Doc 14:41, 2 August 2008 (UTC) delete WP:VSCA|Vanispamcruftisement. Also fails Deletion of Cytext ; Cytexting WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
1821 18981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Tide (album) (2nd nomination) User:Joaquin008 21:33, 4 March 2011 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Black Tide (album) (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1822 17340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of published lists User:Starblind 04:09, 26 February 2010 (UTC) delete the very definition of listcruft, appears to have been created as a joke arising from a feud on an AFD (Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/100 Worst Britons|specifically, this one). See also Deletion of List of published lists WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
1823 17383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siding (disambiguation) User:Shhhnotsoloud 08:34, 27 August 2020 (UTC) delete At the time of this comment, this disambiguation page is not required (). Partial title matches are easily found using Search Deletion of Siding (disambiguation) WP:ONEOTHER Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
1824 345 [[GuttenPlag Wiki]] (erl., wird behalten) Benutzer:Okin NONE keep Ganz klar : Neben der inzwischen deutlichst gegebenen Relevanz als Website (auch als Beispiel für die gesellschaftliche, politische und wissenschaftliche Bedeutung von Web 2.0 bzw. Social Media) ist mittlerweile auch eine ausreichende Zeit- und wissenschaftsgeschichtliche Bedeutung erkennbar. Braucht eigentlich nicht weiter diskutiert zu werden: Erneuter |LAE Löschung von GuttenPlag Wiki Wikipedia:LAE Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
1825 524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rajkumar Kanagasingam User:Ccscott 08:25, 18 March 2007 (UTC) keep As decided by the community less than three months ago, this subject is notable as he is discussed in multiple, non-trivial and independent published references (see Rajkumar Kanagasingam|here and Talk:Rajkumar Kanagasingam#References(off-line columns)|here) thus meeting the primary notability criteron of . I do not understand what has changed to necessitate another AfD so soon after the last one resulted in a Keep consensus Deletion of Rajkumar Kanagasingam WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1826 9954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebbeca User:Stifle 21:26, 6 May 2008 (UTC) delete The lack of |citations from |reliable sources indicates to me that the article fails to comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Rebbeca WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1827 6132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bold (film) [[user talk:TheMagnificentist|Magnificentist]] 09:21, 7 August 2017 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails . — '''The Deletion of Bold (film) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1828 19403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nofel Izz User:Mar4d 11:41, 19 March 2012 (UTC) keep Good coverage of sources proving |notability of the subject Deletion of Nofel Izz WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1829 19083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brock Turner User:LM2000 23:22, 6 June 2016 (UTC) keep This is an instance where the crime, and reaction to it, are more notable than the perpetrator. The case passes but is relevant here Deletion of Brock Turner WP:GNG||WP:CRIMINAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1830 20225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of television series notable for positive reception User:Lugnuts 09:44, 19 February 2012 (UTC) delete per |WP:ABORTION Deletion of List of television series notable for positive reception WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1831 17385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Controversy surrounding Liberty User:NJ 03:44, 8 June 2012 (UTC) merge with Liberty University. As an independent article, it is a |point of view fork Deletion of Controversy surrounding Liberty WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
1832 7155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ah Kong User:Baileypalblue 19:57, 27 January 2009 (UTC) keep """Ah Kong"""" is certainly a generic phrase, but it was also the name of a powerful Chinese drug-smuggling Triad in the 1980s. A http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&q=%22Ah%20Kong%22%20gang&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=wp google book search turns up four valid hits, and there's a few more |RS out there; I'll try to add a couple of refs to the article""" Deletion of Ah Kong WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1833 16710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Queer coding User:Qwaiiplayer 21:22, 17 July 2021 (UTC) keep the subject meets per significant independent coverage in a basic search (e.g. https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_A_Z_of_Gender_and_Sexuality/44F2DwAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=%22Queer+coding%22+-wikipedia&pg=PA212&printsec=frontcover https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_Intersectionality_of_Critical_Animal/NsUpDwAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=%22Queer+coding%22+-wikipedia&pg=PA120&printsec=frontcover https://dialogues.rutgers.edu/images/Journals_PDF/2017-18-dialogues-web_e6db3.pdf#page=164 https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.13110/marvelstales.29.1.0110). This article needs to be improved and better sources need to be added, but AFD is . An article on a notable topic should not be deleted just because the article is poorly written Deletion of Queer coding WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE||WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1834 15502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stochastic terrorism NONE NONE keep """accidentally repeated by a reliable source"""" is the most contrived reason I've ever heard in a deletion discussion. The |general notability guidelines only require coverage in |reliable sources. You don't get to decide whether that's intentional or accidental because that would be |editorializing and beyond the scope of Wikipedia. Similarly, with neologisms, one doesn't just use that word for any new term, but rather those that aren't used by reliable sources. This article contains usage of the term by ''Rolling Stone'', ''Raw Story'', ''Vox (website)|Vox'', and ''Salon''; all reliable sources. Not sure why people are getting hung up over academic usage when the article makes clear that that's just the origin of the term and that it has been used by journalists. The proof of that is right in the references section""" Deletion of Stochastic terrorism WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:EDITORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1835 7461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bindhu Pamarthi User:Otr500 02:09, 28 October 2016 (UTC) delete """A Google search only brings up Miss District of Columbia. The ''degree of significance'' is not enough to provide |notability for a Wikipedia:Notability (people)|BLP article, evidenced by ''""""significant coverage in reliable secondary sources that are independent of the subject.""""'' (), in more than a |single event (WP:BIO1E). If kept this ultimately means the article would be relegated to a Wikipedia:Permastub|permanent stub Wikipedia:Avoiding_harm#Pseudo-biographies|pseudo-biography""" Deletion of Bindhu Pamarthi WP:NOTABLE||WP:GNG||WP:SINGLEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
1836 15712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2022 in Canada User:Hog 21:43, 3 February 2020 (UTC) delete per . Couple years in the future is still too far out, we don't know much set in stone for then right now Deletion of 2022 in Canada WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1837 7238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guleria User:Oliver 15:42, 12 November 2006 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Guleria WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1838 2721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DJ Kelblizz [[User talk:Begoon|Begoon]] 04:53, 14 June 2019 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails Deletion of DJ Kelblizz WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1839 6029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of female supervillains (3rd nomination) User:ChrisGualtieri 01:55, 16 August 2014 (UTC) keep As doesn't seem to have been done and limited improvements to improve this over a category hasn't happened yet. I'll do some work, but as a matter of reference, most of these villains already contain numerous links to their criteria and portrayal in media. I'll keep to the easier lists which are ever present to start with. clearly applies and we should aim for a little more than a mere list Deletion of List of female supervillains (3rd nomination) WP:BEFORE||WP:NOTDUP Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
1840 284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New York Mets minor league players User:Ejgreen77 03:20, 6 November 2014 (UTC) keep on a y nomination Deletion of New York Mets minor league players WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
1841 14827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nigel Malone User:400spartans 02:52, 30 December 2019 (UTC) delete """fails , only points for seem to be his first team all-big 12 selection in 2011, and I'd consider that to be too weak. Media coverage is limited to """"gopowercat.com""" Deletion of Nigel Malone WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
1842 20066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrenalin Rush User:Ericorbit 13:09, 23 August 2010 (UTC) delete ridiculous, , , etc etc etc Deletion of Adrenalin Rush WP:CRYSTAL||WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1843 16753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Egan User:Malcolmxl5 08:15, 31 July 2008 (UTC) delete Not notable as evidenced by the lack of |reliable sources. I can find none in google newshttp://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Paul+Egan%22+Classic+source:%22-newswire%22+source:%22-wire%22+source:%22-presswire%22+source:%22-PR%22+source:%22-press%22+source:%22-release%22&sa=N&start=10 so fails to be |verifiable also Deletion of Paul Egan WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1844 17934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Collins McSparran User:Nosebagbear 22:40, 28 January 2019 (UTC) delete while it's a historical example, the individual does not appear to meet . No stand out redirect target Deletion of John Collins McSparran WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1845 7866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Complete Idiot's Guide... books User:NMChico24 05:15, 29 July 2006 (UTC) delete Perhaps a footnote in the The Complete Idiot's Guide to... article might be appropriate, but even that could get |listcrufty. On their own, they don't belong here Deletion of The Complete Idiot's Guide... books WP:LC Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
1846 7174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/L'CHAIM Vodka User:Ynhockey 06:41, 17 May 2012 (UTC) keep article passes because there are enough third party sources that cover it in a non-trivial manner Deletion of L'CHAIM Vodka WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1847 21147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Internal Affairs (band) User:Deranged 08:44, 22 May 2007 (UTC) keep It seems to satisfy (criteria 4 and 6, for example). That of course doesn't make the countless articles on inconsequential bands anything more than clutter, but that's a topic for Wikipedia Talk:Notability (music Deletion of Internal Affairs (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1848 10557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Woody Allen sexual assault allegations [[User talk:24.151.116.12|talk]]) 17:54, 16 January 2018 (UTC) keep as a proper from the biographical article. The RS coverage of these issues has been voluminous and . Including this much information at Woody Allen would be . Note that if this is kept, the summary at Woody_Allen#Sexual-assault_allegations should be trimmed per . Special:Contributions/24.151.116.12|24.151.116.12 Deletion of Woody Allen sexual assault allegations WP:SPINOUT||WP:SUSTAINED||WP:UNDUE||WP:SUMMARY Wikipedia:Article size 51
1849 18022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrianus Johannes Lemmens User:Richard 12:57, 5 April 2013 (UTC) delete Everything the nominator said is true. Non-notable individual and strong issues throughout. Requesting an admin close this per Deletion of Adrianus Johannes Lemmens WP:COI||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
1850 6715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BDD Clan User:Adrian 01:40, 3 March 2006 (UTC) delete as |non-notable online gaming group. Long |non-notable articles are still |non-notable Deletion of BDD Clan WP:N||WP:N||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1851 17467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crosspointe church User:SkierRMH 08:49, 16 December 2006 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Crosspointe church WP:CORP||WP:CHURCH Wikipedia:Notability 77
1852 20691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TechExcel (2nd nomination) User:Ammarpad 11:57, 28 October 2017 (UTC) delete no , recreation shows adamancy to promote this non notable company. Clear violation of Deletion of TechExcel (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1853 7286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Oregon wineries and vineyards User:Tedder 23:45, 27 July 2010 (UTC) comment """Just a comment, as I'm unsure my final feelings. For one, an article shouldn't be deleted because it simply needs cleanup. e.g., not everything on the list needs to be notable to make it a notable list. (somewhat addressed at ). For instance, an article about """"parks in oregon"""" would stay even if some of the parks would never have their own article. The links can be cleaned up simply by wrapping them in reftags""" Deletion of List of Oregon wineries and vineyards WP:STAND Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
1854 11406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Your Vegas User:MonkBirdDuke 21:29, 30 October 2006 (UTC) delete I think most people are voting keep just because there is a picture of the band on there...the article still doesn't assert any claims of notability and doesn't meet Deletion of Your Vegas WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1855 4297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jake Goodman (footballer) User:Nfitz 04:33, 12 January 2014 (UTC) keep meets as has played on fully professional team. The requirement is a fully professional team, not a fully professional league - Conference National is a mostly-professional league Deletion of Jake Goodman (footballer) WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1856 10266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jan Sobczyński User:Icewhiz 12:58, 22 November 2018 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass for his WWII service. Seems to have been created (un-sourced) around the time of his death by a SPA (which per the permissions on the file uploads in commons seems possibly connected to the subject). I don't see the here to meet GNG (or NARTIST Deletion of Jan Sobczyński WP:SOLDIER||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
1857 2540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monstercat 003 – Momentum User:UserDude 07:42, 24 March 2020 (UTC) delete per nom. Could not find any sources supporting Deletion of Monstercat 003 – Momentum WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1858 6372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Dathan Holbert User:Location 02:41, 28 October 2010 (UTC) keep The subject was recently featured on http://www.blueridgenow.com/article/20101025/NEWS/101029950/1042?Title=Watch-8216-Dateline-NBC-segment-on-William-Holbert-here Dateline NBC and his received coverage from http://www.amw.com/fugitives/case.cfm?id=37959 America's Most Wanted, http://www.cbsnews.com/8300-504083_162-504083.html?keyword=william+dathan+holbert CBS, http://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory?id=11284975 ABC and http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/08/02/william-dathan-holbert-ja_n_667430.html Huffington Post, as well as various national and international sources. Meets and due to significant coverage in independent reliable sources. I am OK with a rename if that helps to satisfy concerns, however, I'm not sure how that is done for serial killers Deletion of William Dathan Holbert WP:GNG||WP:BIO||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
1859 3634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elaine Mardis User:Xxanthippe 02:35, 24 July 2010 (UTC) delete on grounds of copyright infringement despite subject passing rof cites in spades. One of several articles on the The Genome Center written by the communications coordinator. Such practices are apt to end in tears Deletion of Elaine Mardis WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
1860 1424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Racial Boundaries User:Mandsford 17:08, 25 November 2008 (UTC) delete """Though it may not be """"original research"""", it's certainly """"original synthesis"""", and it's unavoidably someone's point of view . The central thesis of what looks like someone's college essay is """"Racial boundaries are widely used in the United States to keep certain races from achieving their full potential through political policies, social policies and family wealth."""" The two sections are, in reality, two book reports, with """"Wealth as a Racial Boundary"""" being drawn from a book by Thomas Shapiro, and """"Mass Imprisonment as a Racial Boundary"""" coming from a book by Bruce Western. My suggestion is that the author should merge this to the article Thomas Shapiro and to consider creating an article about {Bruce Western""" Deletion of Racial Boundaries WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1861 15063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dana Chapman User:Meters 04:56, 28 March 2018 (UTC) delete No evidence of passing . Amusingly, one could read the dates associated with two of her three listed credits as suggesting that she was acting before she was born (rather than listing the dates those shows started Deletion of Dana Chapman WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1862 17143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heir to the Ottoman dynasty User:Anythingyouwant 18:13, 10 April 2011 (UTC) delete The editor who wrote this put a lot of time and effort into assembling this interesting information. So, it is sad that Wikipedia policies require deletion, but hopefully that editor will understand policies better in the future. Reliable sources are needed, as defined by , especially where living people are involved. Some of the living people at issue here are minors. In Turkey, or some parts of Turkey (or among Armenians) there may be very strong feelings against the old royal family, and so publicizing these names could cause harm. At the very least, we would need reliable sources that have balanced these concerns and decided to publish Deletion of Heir to the Ottoman dynasty WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1863 8334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anusha Gunasekera User:Bearcat 16:57, 1 May 2018 (UTC) delete """The article does not claim that he's ever held any office that constitutes an automatic pass as an """"inherently"""" notable role — that attaches to state and national ''legislatures'', not municipal councils — but the article is not referenced anywhere near well enough to get him over in lieu. Further, it's written far too much like a campaign brochure, but even an NPOL-passing national legislator still doesn't get to have their article written in that kind of tone""" Deletion of Anusha Gunasekera WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1864 7106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kowloon Development Company User:WikiAviator 14:35, 21 February 2020 (UTC) comment U|199.66.69.88}} @{{U|GSS}} I've found credible sources by prominent newspapers in Chinese that have whole articles about the projects of Kowloon Development Company. Sources: https://hk.appledaily.com/finance/20200214/GY2GQHL6F55FDLXS5JQTTOJIJA/https://www2.hkej.com/instantnews/market/article/2249749https://news.mingpao.com/pns/%E7%B6%93%E6%BF%9F/article/20191017/s00004/1571249451561/%E4%B9%9D%E5%BB%BA%E6%A8%93%E7%9B%A4%E6%93%AC%E5%8F%96%E6%B6%88%E3%80%8C%E5%91%BC%E5%90%B8plan%E3%80%8Dhttps://www.finet.hk/newscenter/news_content/5d4fac8ebde0b3270a21d42ahttps://ps.hket.com/article/2495476https://hk.appledaily.com/finance/20191016/A6QQHBMLQ5RR7MQBJMP2WC5V3Y/. They are all reliable sources that can verify notability of the company. Therefore the article complies with and Deletion of Kowloon Development Company WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
1865 3483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanya Kroytor User:Lacypaperclip 08:26, 23 November 2017 (UTC) keep There is an alternate spelling of this violinists last name Kroytnor. Kroitor If you search for the name Sanya Kroitor, there is a multitude of articles with significant coverage. I added these ones to the article tonight. {{cite web | title=Саня Кройтор: «Хайфа - уникальный город и уникальная публика!» Интервью после концерта. | website=Татьяна Климович | url=http://klim-reporter.com/sanya-kroytor-hayfa-unikalnyiy-gorod-i-unikalnaya-publika-intervyu-posle-kontserta.html | language=ru | access-date=23 November 2017}}{{cite web | last=Radio | first=Jazz | title=Sanya Kroitor, Didier Lockwood et Laetitia Himo en concert à Bastia ! | website=Jazz Radio | date=15 November 2016 | url=http://www.jazzradio.fr/news/soiree/32122/sanya-kroitor-didier-lockwood-et-laetitia-himo-en-concert--bastia | language=fr | access-date=23 November 2017}}{{cite web | last=Cashman | first=Greer Fay | title=Of synagogues and the communities they serve | website=The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com | date=9 July 2014 | url=http://www.jpost.com/Features/Magazine-Features/Of-synagogues-and-the-communities-they-serve-362027 | access-date=23 November 2017}} There are plrnty more. This article passes and should be kept. It needs to be expanded not deleted Deletion of Sanya Kroytor WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1866 2363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jumbo Lake User:Reywas92 07:38, 8 September 2019 (UTC) delete I don't really care if it stays as a redirect or not, but it's blatantly obvious that this fails , with no sources of any substance describing the lake itself, only a database entry with its name and coordinates. Precisely zero of the information previously making up the article was about the Lake, rather the general geography of that region of Quebec, making this a textbook example of a , exaggerating content and references on tangential information that do not actually support the notability of the subject – or even provide any information about it, unlike the countless Billy Hathorn biographies Deletion of Jumbo Lake WP:GEOLAND||WP:REFBOMB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1867 10086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David W. Virtue User:Polarbear97 16:52, 5 January 2008 (UTC) delete this article is non notable, and should not have an article of it's own. Does not meet criteria Deletion of David W. Virtue WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1868 15078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Campbell (journalist) User:Mtking 08:44, 10 December 2011 (UTC) delete Clearly the guy exits, clearly he writes newspaper articles, but I am not seeing any significant coverage about him, so he fails etc Deletion of James Campbell (journalist) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1869 16115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/False Sexuality User:TonyBallioni 23:05, 29 June 2017 (UTC) delete I had originally PRODed this before Robert sent it to AfD. I'll go with my reasoning there: this is pure original research which is excluded by Deletion of False Sexuality WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1870 18469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cash accumulation equation User:Deacon 02:09, 9 March 2020 (UTC) comment I tagged this for |speedy deletion under . &ndash Deletion of Cash accumulation equation WP:CSD||WP:G12 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1871 10922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Temple Emanuel (St. Louis, Missouri) User:Orlady 13:47, 26 June 2011 (UTC) merge """the architecture-related parts of the article to William Bernoudy, delete the rest. The architecture of the synagogue building seems to be notable, so it could be effectively covered in the article about architect Bernoudy. Otherwise, I don't see evidence of notability for the synagogue. I've looked at all of the """"sources"""" cited in the article and I find that many of them are merely directories of synagogues -- listing in a lot of directories does not make this synagogue notable. Other than the architecture, the only possible claims of notability here are (1) the sourced indication that the temple conducts most of its services on Sunday morning, which turns out not to be true -- the website shows services on Friday evenings and religious education programs on Sundays, and (2) providing a venue for an interesting photo exhibition (that's more about the photography than it is about the synagogue -- |notability is not inherited). Most of the article is trivia that should be expunged""" Deletion of Temple Emanuel (St. Louis, Missouri) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1872 16291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fenda Audio India User:Philg88 11:08, 21 June 2015 (UTC) delete Per nom. Heavily |promotional and sourced largely through press release reprints, which aren't |reliable sources Deletion of Fenda Audio India WP:PROMO||WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1873 124 [[Mofatuning]] (bleibt) Benutzer:PeeCee NONE delete In dieser Form eher ein HowTo, als ein Artikel. Und daher, nach Löschung von Mofatuning Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1874 1458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susan Berkley User:Artene50 10:06, 4 June 2008 (UTC) delete ASAP The nasty tone of this article has been removed:http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Susan_Berkley&diff=216954450&oldid=216944662 here but I hardly think this article's creator Lexlex has Susan Berkley's best intentions at heart in making this article. This appears to be a '''character assassination''' Also much of the info is from her web site which cannot be considered a Deletion of Susan Berkley WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1875 9394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zhenteng Li [[User: Allen3|Allen3]]'' [[User talk:Allen3|talk]] 13:27, 19 March 2006 (UTC) delete as per unless |reliable sources are |provided to verify the article's claims Deletion of Zhenteng Li WP:V||WP:RS||WP:CITE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1876 18674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pomoeroticism User:LonelyBeacon 03:13, 14 July 2008 (UTC) delete fails , though I suspect that the day may come when this gets more written up in journals and becomes notable. Though that day is not today Deletion of Pomoeroticism WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1877 17594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laura Valdivia User:E 21:41, 26 June 2019 (UTC) delete WP:MILL staff writer, fails as a staff writer, not lead author, and fails Deletion of Laura Valdivia WP:CREATIVE||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
1878 5373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anime Warriors! User:Kinu 04:21, 2 August 2006 (UTC) delete blatantly non-notable fan fiction, fails , for its website, for any of its claims of importance Deletion of Anime Warriors! WP:FICT||WP:WEB||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1879 6904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kabza User:Donaldd23 16:19, 27 December 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Kabza WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
1880 14656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plastic Paddy User:Angusmclellan 22:17, 10 January 2007 (UTC) delete a dicdef appears to be more suited to Wiktionary than Wikipedia. . Lo and behold! it's already there at :wikt:Plastic Paddy. I too have seen the term in s.c.i, but what does that prove? If someone can suggest how this can be expanded beyond a simple definition, I'll change my opinion, but so far I haven't seen anything like that. What NPOV has to do with the matter escapes me Deletion of Plastic Paddy WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
1881 10527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AlwaysHD User:SyndicaterUI78 01:38, 13 May 2019 (UTC) delete Fails to meet , has poor sources, and it fails Deletion of AlwaysHD WP:GNG||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1882 3145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lozar User:Cunard 23:13, 7 July 2009 (UTC) delete per the http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&q=Lozar+Veles&cf=all lack of |reliable sources Deletion of Lozar WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1883 6120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennxpenn User:Youtuberinformation 04:55, 24 November 2012 (UTC) keep Per #2. YouTube 'personalities' that have millions of views and thousands of subscribers should be notable, as another user said. I think she has enough followers to be considered notable Deletion of Jennxpenn WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
1884 10737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeest User:Stifle 15:43, 26 April 2006 (UTC) delete but watch out for Deletion of Zeest WP:CSB Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
1885 15687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arif Saeed User:Riteboke 16:22, 13 April 2021 (UTC) keep meets Deletion of Arif Saeed WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1886 14617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frozen plasticity User:Ihcoyc 14:28, 24 June 2009 (UTC) comment At present, I cannot begin to judge the suitability of the subject, but I would observe that the citations make it appear to be |one man's theory. I'd flag this for expert attention and ask for help at ikiProject Biology|the biology project. The title does appear to be less than satisfactory, given that the hypothesis is not well known, and I also expected this to be about plastic materials Deletion of Frozen plasticity WP:OR||WP:W Wikipedia:No original research 65
1887 16223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Barratt (British author) User:Wisdom89 03:42, 29 March 2008 (UTC) keep Well, no news http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&um=1&tab=wn&q=%22Mark+Barratt%22+author&btnG=Search+News. However, there is http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/search-handle-url?%5Fencoding=UTF8&search-type=ss&index=books&field-author=Mark%20Barratt at amazon which indicates multiple books. I think this might marginally meet Deletion of Mark Barratt (British author) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1888 9981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohisen Al-Jamaan User:Yanksox 04:58, 6 July 2006 (UTC) delete per nom, a hoax is not a speedy per Deletion of Mohisen Al-Jamaan WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1889 13277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandra Sully (songwriter) User:Roodog2k 12:54, 4 June 2012 (UTC) comment A criterion of is a songwriting credit from a notable song. She has this, and there are notable sources that say this, whether its a directory is irrelevant Deletion of Sandra Sully (songwriter) WP:COMPOSER Wikipedia:Notability 77
1890 5338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indiana State Police Pension Trust v. Chrysler User:South 22:16, 27 June 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Indiana State Police Pension Trust v. Chrysler WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1891 18520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United States presidential candidate girls, 2008 User:Hrafn 07:56, 21 April 2011 (UTC) delete to United States presidential election, 2008. A fairly ephemeral gimmick, apparently lacking anything non-routine, any or any analysis of its wider implications Deletion of United States presidential candidate girls, 2008 WP:CONTINUEDCOVERAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1892 18690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caroline Howarth User:Crusio 07:03, 30 September 2008 (UTC) delete I agree with Nsk92 that she is't there yet, but especially the two editorial board memberships indicate that some people think she's somebody important in her field, or becoming important. Still, WP |is not a crystal ball Deletion of Caroline Howarth WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1893 21793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris krause User:Kinu 08:55, 6 March 2006 (UTC) delete does not meet Deletion of Chris krause WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1894 1590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The The's User:Capitalistroadster 01:32, 28 October 2005 (UTC) delete """as per and . A Google search for """"The The's"""" Kamloop didn't get any Google results showing verifiability problems see http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=lang_en&c2coff=1&q=%22The+The%27s%22+Kamloop&btnG=Search. There is no allmusic.com page. No evidence of albums released, tours performed or any other indicators showing notability as per """ Deletion of The The's WP:V||WP:music Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1895 9060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Taarak Mehta Ka Ooltah Chashmah characters (2nd nomination) User:Ravensfire 16:12, 29 August 2019 (UTC) delete """The sourcing is, frankly, abysmal, but I've come to expect that for most Indian TV show articles. MOS:TVCAST mentions list articles and explicitly notes """"Remember to follow the notability guidelines when creating a cast list: not every fictional character ever created deserves to be listed and even fewer will deserve an individual article."""" This article doesn't appear to have any concern for that need. I think the subject itself is notable, but the current state is just so bad, may be the only option here. Some guidance to the recent main editor of the article about MOS:TVCAST around the notability requirements and ordering could help""" Deletion of List of Taarak Mehta Ka Ooltah Chashmah characters (2nd nomination) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
1896 9297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D'X-Man... User:Jo7hs2 14:36, 10 May 2009 (UTC) delete First, everybody needs to remember Wikipedia:There is no deadline. That said, there is very little coverage in sourceshttp://www.gmanews.tv/story/92186/P1M-reward-offered-for-information-on-TV-hosts-killershttp://telebisyon.net/D-X-Man/http://www.untvweb.com/programs.html, and nothing that I feel satisfies . I must recommend deletion Deletion of D'X-Man... WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1897 15991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beni Mihai User:GPL93 20:46, 19 November 2019 (UTC) delete Very clear violation and failure. Best Deletion of Beni Mihai WP:NOTPROMO||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1898 20248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Happn User:Lemongirl942 08:06, 18 October 2016 (UTC) delete Per This is nothing but . This is an app which received spiked coverage for a while. There is enormous promo pressure here with the creator using sockpuppets to spam the article. Notability is not the only reason for deletion - borderline notability combined with the intention to use Wikipedia for promotion is a good enough reason as well. Volunteer resources are finite and these articles with borderline notability but promo pressure suck up enormous volunteer efforts. We should not encourage this kind of editing as it ultimately increases the on Wikipedia Deletion of Happn WP:DEL14||WP:CORPSPAM||WP:BOGOF||WP:SYSTEMICBIAS Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1899 5467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MidPhase User:Abecedare 21:32, 9 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails . No secondary sources included in article or availble on google search Deletion of MidPhase WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1900 1870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Five.Bolt.Main User:Stifle 00:06, 12 April 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Five.Bolt.Main WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1901 16044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Popular Yaoi Pairings User:Seraphimblade 10:36, 28 January 2007 (UTC) delete """and add |original research to the above list-who decides what constitutes """"popular""" Deletion of Popular Yaoi Pairings WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1902 6564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Gash User:Jimbo 07:39, 15 August 2008 (UTC) comment none of those on Google news meet . Anyway, there seems to be no more than any other non-notable player in the same league e.g. http://news.google.ca/news?hl=en&tab=wn&ned=ca&nolr=1&q=%22john+akinde%22 John Akinde, http://news.google.ca/news?hl=en&tab=wn&ned=ca&nolr=1&q=%22adam+bartlett%22 Adam Bartlett, http://news.google.ca/news?hl=en&tab=wn&ned=ca&nolr=1&q=%22matt+tubbs%22 Matt Tubbs or http://news.google.ca/news?hl=en&tab=wn&ned=ca&nolr=1&q=%22darren+stride%22 Darren Stride Deletion of Michael Gash WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1903 11333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jane Walker (journalist) User:WWGB 11:53, 2 September 2011 (UTC) delete Meets none of the criteria at , the relevant requirement for notable journalists Deletion of Jane Walker (journalist) WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1904 3661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Jara User:Sir 13:33, 30 September 2017 (UTC) keep Having played in the Peruvian top flight, he meets Deletion of Daniel Jara WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1905 8217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sudden Jihad Syndrome User:EliminatorJR 13:31, 25 February 2007 (UTC) delete just as it was last time. Vague sourcing, mostly and some of it's plain guesswork (for instance Gamil al-Batouti's motives can only be guessed at), not to mention being borderline racist Deletion of Sudden Jihad Syndrome WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1906 374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United Airlines Flight 1175 User:AyaanLamar 18:58, 14 February 2018 (UTC) keep The article clearly satisfies . It states that 'if a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to be suitable for a stand-alone article or list', this itself is a reason to keep the page. Moreover, the given sources have exclusive articles on the incident which clearly states that it is a popular aviation accident and is investigates by FAA and NTSB Deletion of United Airlines Flight 1175 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1907 7990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cine Report User:Khadeerali 17:02, 20 June 2015 (UTC) keep Article depicts a site which is reliable for use as per our guidelines, but reliability does not automatically bestow notability. The site has been latched on to ''passing mentions'' in tons of reputed websites which have also used their reports directly or indirectly, but notability demands that significant coverage and some material ''about the site'' in third-party sources is necessary. I doubt if these are competent enough to contain the article and on par with . From what I can comprehend, this is a case of where the article just seems on border between notability and non-notability, making its contingency inconceivable beyond . But again, what is competent and what is not is again subjective. If more sources could be found, the article's stance would escalate, but until then, it remains as a mere paradigm of bare notability Deletion of Cine Report WP:WEB||WP:BARE||WP:TWOPRONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
1908 6682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Autosomal chromosome epigenetic silencing to cure Down syndrome User:Agyle 19:52, 17 May 2014 (UTC) delete """The current article lacks secondary sources to support the material that are recommended by ; this is synthesis of several primary sources, with heavy reliance on a single http://www.uff.br/neurociencias/images/artigos_selecao/Luiz_Leao_2014.pdf August 2013 study in ''Nature''. It's a very important, groundbreaking study, but is preliminary, foundational research that probes what it refers to as """"the major first step towards potential development of 'chromosome therapy'"""". Merging elsewhere is inappropriate; medical topics are treated differently than other subjects on Wikipedia, and coverage of proposed medical cures should generally be referenced with secondary sources, not individual studies (primary sources). Rationale and details for the different treatment are discussed in and its Talk page archives. If secondary sources can be found with substantial information on this approach, it may warrant an article, but I didn't find any; the ''Nature'' article is recent, and while it has been widely cited in medical literature, it does not seem to have been cited in any reviews yet. (Note: I'm a layperson with no medical expertise; weigh my opinion accordingly""" Deletion of Autosomal chromosome epigenetic silencing to cure Down syndrome WP:MEDRS||WP:MEDRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1909 3598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Najarian User:Willsome429 16:17, 15 January 2020 (UTC) keep meets number 1 as he has played multiple National Football League games as evidenced by https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/N/NajaPe20.htm Deletion of Peter Najarian WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
1910 3459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Christmas special (Doctor Who) User:TreasuryTag 14:41, 13 July 2010 (UTC) keep """ is completely irrelevant, as it merely notes that, """"Wikipedia is not a collection of unverifiable speculation."""" This article contains no unverifiable speculation: it is all referenced. Indeed, point 1 of precisely covers such a situation. (Would you also nominate 2012 Summer Olympics for deletion on the basis that it's not happened yet""" Deletion of 2010 Christmas special (Doctor Who) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1911 19776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Louie McCroskey User:Ihcoyc 13:57, 12 June 2007 (UTC) keep """As a former member of the Syracuse University Syracuse Orange|Orangemen, and a current player for Marist College, this person has """"played or competed at the highest level in amateur sports,"""" and as such meets |the notability guidelines for people""" Deletion of Louie McCroskey WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1912 4752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zulfiqar Ahmad Naqshbandi User:AaqibAnjum 14:20, 25 August 2020 (UTC) keep a clear pass of per https://www.worldcat.org/identities/lccn-no2002108108/ his books, and a leading Sufi shaykh of Naqshbandi oder. Copy edited, expanded the article with some references Deletion of Zulfiqar Ahmad Naqshbandi WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1913 1429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jenny Wüstenberg User:David 04:44, 24 May 2019 (UTC) delete I found and added to the article three reviews and two award shortlists for her book. If there were another book with a similar reception I'd switch to keep. But it's one book, not enough by itself for , and the other material doesn't appear to rise to the level of notability Deletion of Jenny Wüstenberg WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1914 3636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacques Marnier Companie User:Deor 12:31, 25 July 2010 (UTC) delete Fails . MSGJ, the book that you cited in the article (and that 4meter4 linked to above) is a scrape of Wikipedia articles (see Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Unreferenced articles#Books LLC), and after typing this comment, I'll be off to remove it. I can find no reliable sources that establish this person's existence Deletion of Jacques Marnier Companie WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1915 13994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fatal dog attacks in the United States User:Guerillero 15:11, 14 September 2020 (UTC) delete based off of non-RSes and / Deletion of List of fatal dog attacks in the United States WP:NOTMEMORIAL||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1916 9614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Coughlan User:Ramaksoud2000 03:58, 14 November 2013 (UTC) keep Meets . Has substantial coverage in multiple sources. It doesn't matter how small the position, if it meets , it's enough Deletion of Jim Coughlan WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1917 1191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Cambridge Student (2nd nomination) user:Andrew 11:34, 2 November 2020 (UTC) keep This is the newspaper of the Cambridge Students' Union and so the worst case would be merger into that page. Per , deletion is not appropriate Deletion of The Cambridge Student (2nd nomination) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1918 17851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Daniel Cooper User:Ke5crz 22:50, 7 June 2011 (UTC) delete per section 2.9 it reads like a newspaper obituaries and i'm not sure it could be presented in another light Deletion of Death of Daniel Cooper WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1919 13677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trevor Grundy User:Bearian 20:50, 22 December 2020 (UTC) delete WP:SIGCOV beats out Deletion of Trevor Grundy WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
1920 21954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charlie Austin User:Malcolmxl5 14:26, 31 August 2009 (UTC) delete Does not meet thlete. The player needs to have played in a fully professional league to warrrant an article in the encyclopedia, which in England means the Premier League or the Football League. The Wessex League Premier Division where Poole Town F.C. plays is a long way below that level Deletion of Charlie Austin WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
1921 6515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MVPMods User:Krawhitham 19:42, 6 July 2006 (UTC) keep Alexa scores and Ghits are not listed in , The site has been mentioned in a few computer games magazines including Computer Games magazine June 2005 on pg 77 Deletion of MVPMods WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1922 1165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cardiak (3rd nomination) User:Alansohn 14:56, 31 January 2017 (UTC) keep The article continues to meet , and with appropriate reliable and verifiable sources Deletion of Cardiak (3rd nomination) WP:BIO||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:REFERENCE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1923 7754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Little (engineer) User:StAnselm 02:23, 16 May 2018 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Patrick Little (engineer) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
1924 13239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hammad Safi (2nd nomination) User:Bonadea 13:25, 20 September 2018 (UTC) delete I was working on an AfD nomination for this article when I noticed another one had already been created, so I'll add my rationale here: A biography about a child; there are a few sources but I do not believe that he meets yet. Of the three sources, two are based on the same text (not sure if it is a press release, but they cite the same people using the exact same phrasing), and the third is a very brief interview of the subject. That does not amount to |significant coverage. He is not a university lecturer, as claimed in some earlier versions of the article; the University of Spoken English and Computer Science is a language school which uses Safi quite prominently in their advertising (it seems that he he is part of the staff for their programme for children) but it's not an institution of tertiary education Deletion of Hammad Safi (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
1925 20489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bloobis User:Black 20:17, 4 March 2007 (UTC) delete as suspected . If confirmed, then delete per Deletion of Bloobis WP:HOAX||WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
1926 19580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finbar Madden User:Demiurge 10:31, 15 December 2005 (UTC) delete appears to be a associated with Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Fullerton Deletion of Finbar Madden WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
1927 242 [[Die Urlaubstester]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Pöt NONE delete """Millionärs-show als VErgleich? Oh, wann lernen wir das endlich mal mit dem ? Im Übrigen: natärlich sind die WP:RK keine Ausschlußkriterien. Aber wenn schon die Einschlußkriterien nach WP:RK nicht geschafft werden, solle man andere Gründe für """"behalten"""" vorbringen können. So natürlich nur . Und nimm endlich am Mentorenprogramm teil, HErr Schwarz""" Löschung von Die Urlaubstester Wikipedia:BNS Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
1928 4886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of archive repair programs User:Ajf773 18:41, 17 May 2018 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Comparison of archive repair programs WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1929 12979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Cipriano User:Turnstep 22:09, 5 January 2006 (UTC) delete """per and because WP is not a crystal ball (see end of article's sole paragraph). If the artist ever gets the fame and/or sales they """"deserve"""", they can start a new article then""" Deletion of Joseph Cipriano WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1930 5908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sadia Khan (model) User:NickW557 06:19, 10 February 2016 (UTC) delete seems to be a failure. I can find primary sources, non-reliable blogs & fan sites, but no significant coverage in sources that would help establish notability Deletion of Sadia Khan (model) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1931 164 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/İstanbul isminin kökeni """Kullanıcı:vito genovese'''vito genovese'''""" 13:56, 12 Ekim 2006 (UTC) delete """Maddeye """"Çalışma var"""" şablonu konmamış ve 14 Eylül'den 8 Ekim'e kadar geçen 24 gün boyunca dokunan olmamış. Bu durumda rahatlıkla #Maddeler|Madde 8 kapsamında silinebilir. Zaten en.wiki'den alındığı için, üzerinde çalışılmak istendiğinde rahatlıkla tekrar eklenebir ve şu ana kadar çevrilmiş olan 7-8 cümlenin de çevirisi kolaylıkla tekrarlanabilir. Kullanıcı maddeyi kendi kullanıcı sayfası altında geliştirebilir alternatif bir çözüm olarak. Maddenin taraflılığına değinmiyorum bile""" İstanbul adının kökeninin silinmesi Vikipedi:HS Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1932 20915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Associated Students of the University of Missouri User:TerriersFan 22:41, 16 March 2008 (UTC) delete student bodies have to meet . This requires significant secondary sources. This page hasn't them and thus clearly fails notability standards Deletion of Associated Students of the University of Missouri WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1933 8259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quotations on Islam User:Colapeninsula 13:23, 13 June 2017 (UTC) delete As mentioned, it does not meet , which specifically says Wikipedia is not for lists of quotes. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, that is, a collection of articles providing facts on different topics; it is not a collection of primary sources or other people's quotations. An encyclopedia is not a dictionary of quotations. Arguing over the closeness of the association is irrelevant, but it could be pointed out that the quotations are from a wide range of people, countries, historical periods, and attitudes, and while an individual person or closely-connected group's religious beliefs may be notable, the topic of what everybody ever says about Islam is far more loosely connected than that Deletion of Quotations on Islam WP:NOTQUOTE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1934 8697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Integrated pornography User:Orangemike 13:58, 14 April 2008 (UTC) delete non-notable (possibly spurious) neologism with no |verifiability; apparently WP:OR Deletion of Integrated pornography :WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1935 4938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wusion User:Armbrust 20:12, 18 September 2010 (UTC) delete as |Wikipedia is not a dictionary Deletion of Wusion WP:NOTDIC Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
1936 471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Singaporean general election, 2016 User:Eduemoni 21:55, 1 February 2013 (UTC) merge or '''Redirect''' - /, this article is going to be plundered by what if arguments Deletion of Singaporean general election, 2016 WP:CRYSTAL||WP:FUTURE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1937 16783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Team Nexus User:Rockpocket 07:10, 15 September 2006 (UTC) delete Appears to fail pretty convincingly Deletion of Team Nexus WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
1938 13096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mercantila User:Deli 18:31, 16 October 2006 (UTC) delete Doesn't appear to meet either or Deletion of Mercantila WP:WEB||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1939 4231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008-09 Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey season User:Paulmcdonald 18:26, 1 November 2008 (UTC) keep aside from which this article obviously meets by being the highest level of the amateur sport, there is enough significant coverage to warrant an article on its own outside of . Notable. Verifiable. Worthwhile Deletion of 2008-09 Bowling Green Falcons men's ice hockey season WP:ATHLETE||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1940 1996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Watch the Throne (2nd nomination) User:Hongkongresident 00:06, 21 November 2010 (UTC) merge into Kanye West. |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball. The article will merit its own article when it's released Deletion of Watch the Throne (2nd nomination) WP:BALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1941 19284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marlboro School User:Suriel1981 04:16, 12 January 2008 (UTC) delete IMHO fails , and ; our three core content policies Deletion of Marlboro School WP:NPOV||WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1942 2817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Baptist churches in Leicester User:Jerodlycett 19:44, 18 January 2020 (UTC) delete """per ''Notability of lists (whether titled as """"List of Xs"""" or """"Xs"""") is based on the group.'' and this group is not notable""" Deletion of List of Baptist churches in Leicester WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1943 11279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Armenia: The Secrets of a Christian Terrorist State User:Ihcoyc 16:45, 24 January 2007 (UTC) delete http://www.amazon.com/Armenia-Samuel-Weems/dp/0971921237 Amazon.com suggests that this book, which they have as out of print, was printed by a vanity publisher, http://www.stjohnspress.net/ St. John's Press. This article seems devoted entirely to attacking the credibility of this vanity publication. This could possibly be '''speedily deleted''' as an attack page. ( G10 Deletion of Armenia: The Secrets of a Christian Terrorist State WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
1944 15785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Promo (Flight Only) User:Aspects 03:55, 21 May 2011 (UTC) delete Album fails and . The sources consist of an editor remembering a quote of someone's opinion in an eBay auction that is no longer searchable, a dead link and the rest are about the songs and not the album itself Deletion of Promo (Flight Only) WP:NALBUM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1945 10335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joel jeffs User:AllyD 06:25, 4 September 2013 (UTC) delete possibly CSD G11/A7. The article text was originally submitted at AfC by one editing account (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia_talk:Articles_for_creation/Joel_Jeffs&oldid=479907183, rightly declined with a detailed rationale, and has now been copied to article space by another editing account. The article is riddled with claims and statements that need references, but even if they were, when it comes down to it there is nothing here that indicates encyclopaedic notability Deletion of Joel jeffs :WP:SPA||:WP:SPA||:WP:BLP Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
1946 19918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/North Louisiana History User:Dennis 00:50, 11 April 2011 (UTC) comment """Loose affiliations does not |reliable sources make. """"Notability"""" is not a factor of how you or I define it, it is how it is outlined in otability. Who it is written by is not the issue or a criteria for Wikipedia (""""The Encyclopedia that anyone can edit""""). The issue is singularly whether or not the subject matter of the article can objectively meet the criteria for inclusion. I understand that this article was created by you, and you feel an affinity for it, but that alone doesn't make it notable""" Deletion of North Louisiana History WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1947 20880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atma Global NONE NONE keep I think company pass ; (''Examples of substantial coverage: A scholarly article, a book passage, or ongoing media coverage focusing on a product or organization Deletion of Atma Global WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1948 17826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buurtpoes Bledder User:Lee 17:19, 24 January 2020 (UTC) delete """I had a look through what sourcing was on the article, and it just and just doesn't quite meet in my eyes. There's no article on James Bowen (author)|Bob the streetcat, just a redirect (and the article on the movie), which is probably the most famous cat I can think of (there are some items on :Category:individual cats though, which should probably be looked through. There are articles in three other languages for this item, but I don't think it meets the English wikipedia definition of notability. There's clearly some press, but it borders on (whilst not technically being an """"event"""", it was .) I did a search, but I couldn't find much through wikidata or google, but if there were some offline sources or additional foriegn language sources I could be persuaded to change to keep. Best Wishes""" Deletion of Buurtpoes Bledder WP:GNG||WP:1E||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1949 13687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lars Olav Karlsen User:Fenix 15:48, 17 January 2018 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG. Probably a BLPProd in its current state with IMDB being the only source Deletion of Lars Olav Karlsen WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1950 8098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicholas Harisis User:Kugao 18:25, 15 January 2011 (UTC) delete Does not pass erifiability Deletion of Nicholas Harisis WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1951 14258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phillip Palethorpe User:BlueValour 20:37, 18 January 2008 (UTC) delete if he gets on the pitch for Chester, even as a sub, he gets a page. Until then he fails Deletion of Phillip Palethorpe WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1952 8629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WKID 96.7 FM User:I 19:05, 8 September 2013 (UTC) keep I read nothing in that says that Part 15 stations are always non-notable, only that they are less likely to be so. I agree with Bearcat's assessment of the current article, but I was able to dig up a number of sources that do provide some content on the radio station's history. The Tampa Bay Times article (maybe not the same one the was a deadlink on the article) is http://www.tampabay.com/news/humaninterest/young-largo-broadcasters-are-riding-radio-airwaves/510706 here, and provides pretty decent coverage on the station's history and impact even as far away as Germany, which would be appropriate to include in this article. http://digitaljournal.com/article/220101 This article from Digital Journal is a bit more anecdotal, but does provide useful info about its budget and call-in policy. http://www.longisland.com/articles/06-09-11/local-kids-launch-radio-station.html?print=1&page=1 This press release from another station in Long Island is obviously less reliable, but it does state that they reached out to WKID for advice about how to get started on their own station run by kids Deletion of WKID 96.7 FM WP:NMEDIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
1953 17902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joint Baltic American National Committee User:Redditaddict69 06:19, 2 August 2018 (UTC) delete per all reasons listed above AND they aren't an official government organization and few have heard of it, so fails Deletion of Joint Baltic American National Committee WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
1954 8681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaviri Mainthan User:SpacemanSpiff 06:21, 9 February 2010 (UTC) delete I found one http://books.dinamalar.com/BookView.aspx?id=207 piece in ''Dinamalar'', but even that appears to be a reformatted press release, mostly because it's supposed to be a sequel to Kalki Krishnamurthy's ''Ponniyin Selvan''. Doesn't pass at present. &mdash Deletion of Kaviri Mainthan WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
1955 17149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SeaQuest DSV 4600 User:Fogeltje 19:48, 15 January 2008 (UTC) keep No need for AfD, suggestion to merge relevant into the main article has already been made which should sufficiently deal with the matter. Seems to me that nominator is |trying to prove a point Deletion of SeaQuest DSV 4600 WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
1956 11366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bøfsandwich User:Northamerica1000 11:07, 18 January 2014 (UTC) keep meets . Source examples include: http://www.mx.dk/nyheder/danmark/story/19011642, http://stiften.dk/aarhus/boefsandwich-havnens-perle-slaaet-paa-maalstregen, http://www.nordjyske.dk/nyheder/aalborg-kan-det-med-sovs/1acc612b-1109-4758-81af-d0a85206660e/112/1513 Deletion of Bøfsandwich WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1957 15328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jyoti Prakash Dutta (writer) User:Md 23:46, 25 February 2016 (UTC) keep Jyoti Prakash Dutta or J. P. Dutta is an Indian film producer. This Jyoti Prakash Dutta (writer) is a Bangladeshi short-story writer. He was awarded the most prestiguous Ekushey Padak (highest honor for any Bangladeshi writer) by the Government of Bangladesh. Garnering an Ekushey Padak clearly makes the subject notable per Deletion of Jyoti Prakash Dutta (writer) WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1958 11516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Palestinian immigration (Israel) User:Malik 14:05, 6 February 2013 (UTC) keep as Arxiloxos wrote, a name dispute is not a #REASON|valid reason for deleting an article. — Deletion of Palestinian immigration (Israel) WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
1959 17248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Powell User:Dustimagic 22:16, 8 February 2006 (UTC) delete as it is nn/vanity, Deletion of Brian Powell WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1960 16863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Snitker User:RayAYang 21:42, 13 April 2010 (UTC) merge per Mkativerata. The coverage appears to be entirely in the context of his candidacy, thus being a fail of Deletion of Alexander Snitker WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
1961 9937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omer Dekel User:onel5969 20:33, 25 February 2017 (UTC) delete While he may be an expert, he doesn't pass WP's notability criteria. There's not enough in-depth coverage to pass , and his anemic citation counts (high of 22), doesn't help him pass Deletion of Omer Dekel WP:GNG||WP:SCHOLAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
1962 4288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013 Maria Sharapova tennis season User:Cbl62 16:56, 22 August 2014 (UTC) comment """This one is not an easy call for me. A couple preliminary points. First, there is room for reasonable debate over which individual tennis seasons merit stand-alone articles, but I think that broader debate is best held elsewhere. Second, the article in its current format is in the nature of a statistical compilation; that's a reason to improve (to make the article more like 2013 Serena Williams tennis season) but not necessarily reason to delete. What matters for AfD purposes is not the current state of the article, but whether Sharapova's 2013 season has received significant coverage satisfying . By Sharapova's recent standards, her 2013 season was an """"off"""" year, but still decent. She did not win any majors, but she did win the BNP Paribas and Porsche tournaments, played in the finals at the French Open, and was ranked No. 3 in the world when her season ended prematurely due to injury. Coverage of her 2013 season includes '''(1)''' http://au.ibtimes.com/articles/527537/20131205/maria-sharapova.htm#.U_dtqvldVyU this article from the ''International Business Times'' specifically focused on Sharapova's 2013 tennis season. A google search for Sharapova and """"2013 season"""" turns up 41,000 hits, including '''(2)''' http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/16/sports/tennis/sharapova-is-back-in-the-game-and-as-driven-as-ever.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0 this from ''The New York Times'' focusing largely on her 2013 season, '''(3)''' http://www.si.com/tennis/beyond-baseline/2013/10/07/maria-sharapova-withdraws-from-wta-championships-shoulder-injury this from ''Sports Illustrated'', '''(4)''' http://www.upi.com/Sports_News/2013/10/07/Shoulder-injury-ends-Sharapovas-season/UPI-79501381162127/ this this from the UPI, '''(5)''' http://www.tennischannel.com/news/NewsDetails.aspx?newsid=12269 this from Tennis Channel, and '''(6)''' http://www.tennisnow.com/News/2013-in-Review-Maria-Sharapova.aspx this from TennisNow focusing on S's 2013 tennis season. I am still on the fence on """"keep"""" vs. """"delete"""" but thought I'd offer some of my preliminary thoughts""" Deletion of 2013 Maria Sharapova tennis season WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1963 15253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antagonist (band) (2nd nomination) User:Esradekan 23:19, 1 December 2008 (UTC) keep passes #C4 for the gigs in the States. While the Amplifier.co.nz & Muzic.net may be reliable sources, they are far from third party, since the bands themselves edit those profiles. Also support starting a new article under Antagonist A.D., and revert the history back to the American based Antagonist band Deletion of Antagonist (band) (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1964 1421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Haiti earthquake conspiracy theories [[User talk:70.29.210.242|talk]]) 08:03, 28 January 2010 (UTC) comment does it meet ? Special:Contributions/70.29.210.242|70.29.210.242 Deletion of 2010 Haiti earthquake conspiracy theories WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
1965 9423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Brandman User:Bearcat 17:56, 10 September 2018 (UTC) delete Anaheim is ''not'' a large enough city to hand all of its city councillors an automatic presumption of notability under #2 — that privilege accrues only to internationally prominent global city|global cities like New York City or Chicago or Toronto or Los Angeles, not to every city that exists. But the sourcing here — which consists mainly of |primary sources and a community hyperlocal rather than any strong evidence of -worthy media coverage beyond his hometown alone — is nowhere near solid enough to deem him a special case over and above most other not inherently notable city councillors in non-global cities Deletion of Jordan Brandman WP:NPOL||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1966 7587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Focus concerts User:Otr500 03:13, 23 December 2017 (UTC) delete Use 5 pounds of salt. The article uses |primary sources which counts as zero towards WP:notability|notability Deletion of List of Focus concerts WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
1967 21095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Kicklighter User:BlueValour 19:07, 22 April 2008 (UTC) delete plainly a talented and up and coming individual. However, he has yet to achieve anything notable and fails to meet Deletion of James Kicklighter WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1968 11 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Kürdistan İslam Partisi """Kullanıcı:seyitaseyit""" 00:39, 10 Kasım 2016 (UTC) keep Ahmet Turhan'a katılarak, kayda değer. E4024, ansiklopedi kurallarını burada da ihlal etmemeniz gerektiğini bilmem hatırlatmam gerekir mi? ?|Burası herkesin görüşlerini istediği gibi söyleyeceği bir forum değil Kürdistan İslam Partisi'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:Vikipedi ne değildir Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1969 9219 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jose Maria Casas """"two-""""""" User:Bschott 23:33, 19 December 2006 (UTC) delete Not only does it fail but it reads like a personal resume """Deletion of Jose Maria Casas """"two-""""""" WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1970 13241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atlantic-North Sea Continental Divide User:onel5969 17:45, 20 March 2021 (UTC) delete definitely , and there are articles which are clearly synth, but have some semblance of passing GNG, but this isn't even one of those. That being said, I found the concept interesting Deletion of Atlantic-North Sea Continental Divide WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
1971 10258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wooboo User:Mangoe 15:50, 24 September 2012 (UTC) delete as |something mixed up one day Deletion of Wooboo WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
1972 6269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Titania McGrath User:Atlantic306 21:00, 19 February 2019 (UTC) delete as but the Evening Standard is definitely a reliable source, its in tabloid format (as The Guardian is now) but the content is not tabloid content, its the leading evening newspaper in the UK and well respected Deletion of Titania McGrath WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
1973 19293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fundamental Payroll Certification User:Ihcoyc 14:59, 7 October 2008 (UTC) delete per nomination. |Wikipedia is not a repository for press releases, nor a place for |free advertising Deletion of Fundamental Payroll Certification WP:NOT||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1974 10022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenneth Gardner User:Padenton 16:51, 4 May 2015 (UTC) merge """Keep I admit I only went off nom earlier since its author requested deletion and no other real edits. Nah {{u|CookieMonster755}}, it's completely fine. Keep per #3 """"The person has created, or played a major role in co-creating, a significant or well-known work"""" and #4 """"The person's work (or works) either (a) has become a significant monument"""". One of two designers for the rebuilt Twin Towers....major role {{ok}}, significant or well-known work {{ok}}. #4, not entirely certain on the definition of 'monument' here, but sounds like {{ok}} to me. ― """ Deletion of Kenneth Gardner WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1975 20139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Schneider (writer) User:Charlene 02:38, 10 March 2007 (UTC) keep He passes by being the main subject of articles by three reliable sources Deletion of Dan Schneider (writer) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
1976 6151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pegasus Intellectual Capital Solutions User:APerson241 19:34, 25 June 2013 (UTC) delete Only two references; no evidence of at all Deletion of Pegasus Intellectual Capital Solutions WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
1977 1147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kathleen McGarry User:Capitalistroadster 02:12, 26 August 2006 (UTC) delete She was impressive on the Einstein Factor but winning an episode of it is not sufficient to meet . As I recall, the episode last week didn't mention her age. No need for redirect to Einstein factor as there doesn't seem to have been any coverage of her Deletion of Kathleen McGarry WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
1978 17911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faqeer Muhammad Soomro User:Bearian 16:29, 22 May 2017 (UTC) delete per . We can't locate even a single source Deletion of Faqeer Muhammad Soomro WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
1979 18472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Epygi User:Artene50 07:57, 16 June 2008 (UTC) comment I agree with Bjweeks. This company fails . Karl, I would suggest that you should have left the company's obvious spamming on the article's talkpage instead of removing it http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Epygi&diff=219471862&oldid=202369809 here. It is indeed sneaky and brazen to post advertising on any article's talkpage on Wikipedia...and contacting an employee of this company only alerts them that their spamming is effective. is not acceptable under any guise Deletion of Epygi WP:N||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
1980 6583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Infinite Computer Solutions (2nd nomination) NONE NONE delete per with content such as Deletion of Infinite Computer Solutions (2nd nomination) WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1981 17497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Justin Hazell User:Bettia 10:04, 16 July 2010 (UTC) delete WP:ATHLETE requires that a sportsman competes at a fully professional level - making just one solitary substitute appearance in a cup match against a semi-pro team doesn't satisfy that in my opinion, and I can't find anything that would suggest he would pass |general notability guidelines at the moment Deletion of Justin Hazell WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1982 8374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plain hair User:Stifle 11:30, 5 May 2008 (UTC) delete due to lack of |citations from |reliable sources which causes the article to fail to comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Plain hair WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
1983 19443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aqeel Abbas Jafri User:Imadkasir 18:31, 19 April 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. The long list of books is the give-away in my mind of it being a CV. Running out of for creator Deletion of Aqeel Abbas Jafri WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
1984 8936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Living Prime Ministers of Australia User:TheGracefulSlick 20:14, 3 December 2018 (UTC) delete Looks like a lot of |original research went into this article. I cannot find sources, however, that validate it as a noteworthy topic requiring an article. How is GNG met, as it is argued, if the article is unsourced and no reliable sources have been offered Deletion of Living Prime Ministers of Australia WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
1985 130 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ozan Huyukpinar Kullanıcı:WoozeTRkatkılar 18.57, 17 Mart 2022 (UTC) comment internette kişi üzerine araştırma yaptığımda bir kaç tane siteye denk geldim. açısından değerlendirmeyi tek başıma yapmak yerine topluluğa sunmak daha uygun olur diye silinmeye aday gösterdim Ozan Hüyükpınar'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
1986 12649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conflict Computer Limited User:Onebravemonkey 12:48, 28 September 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Shades of Deletion of Conflict Computer Limited WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
1987 56 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Kamil Tolon """Kullanıcı:thecatcherintheryethecatcherintherye""" 20.56, 31 Ocak 2020 (UTC) comment seslen|İnkanyezi}} SAS oy kullanma değil görüş bildirme yeridir. Bu nedenle silinsin diye belirttiğiniz görüşünüzün gerekçesi nedir? sayfasında hangi eksiği gördüğünüz için bu görüşü belirttiğinizi söylerseniz madde üzerinde gerekli düzenlemeyi yapayım Kamil Tolon'un silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
1988 4963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aso Mohammed Ibrahim User:FreeRangeFrog 05:21, 30 January 2013 (UTC) delete Classic Deletion of Aso Mohammed Ibrahim WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
1989 14418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David macarthur User:Valenciano 21:23, 11 June 2012 (UTC) delete fails due to lack of coverage in reliable sources Deletion of David macarthur WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
1990 9210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hickey-Voodoo Glow Skulls User:Coredesat 05:14, 8 July 2006 (UTC) delete nonsense, fails Deletion of Hickey-Voodoo Glow Skulls WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
1991 21505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grace Igboamalu User:Number 12:40, 2 December 2020 (UTC) delete per failure Deletion of Grace Igboamalu WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
1992 10717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christos Trikalinos (2nd nomination) User:Xxanthippe 05:41, 19 March 2011 (UTC) delete Only minimal on GS. Not enough for rof Deletion of Christos Trikalinos (2nd nomination) WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
1993 2444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PRA Health Sciences User:timtempleton 19:04, 3 April 2018 (UTC) keep public, $2B company, with >15,000 employees. I added a few sources. Passes Deletion of PRA Health Sciences WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
1994 11097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Felicia Tang (3rd nomination) User:BabbaQ 18:46, 25 December 2015 (UTC) keep firstly because of the previous AfD, |notability is not temporary. plenty of reliable sources and high profile case. Clearly keep article. Also per WP:GNG. Just because she made her career within the porn industry doesnt make her notability less notable than an actress within mainstream film Deletion of Felicia Tang (3rd nomination) WP:NOTTEMPORARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
1995 6124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicole Rubio User:The 15:50, 27 December 2018 (UTC) delete """on account of subject failing both and . More explicitly, as to the former criterion, there is no significant, |source-based |evidence out there that she is {{tq|regarded as an important figure, widely cited by peers or successors, known for originating a significant new concept, theory, or technique}}. She """"directed episodes"""" of ''Grey's Anatomy''; she has ''not'' {{tq|created nor played a major role in co-creating}} this admittedly {{tq|well-known work}}. And as to the latter criterion, she has not had {{tq|significant roles in multiple notable films, television shows, stage performances, or other productions}}, nor does she have any kind of {{tq|a large fan base or a significant """"cult"""" following}}. We may be fans of her work but Wikipedia is neither a |film journal nor some |indiscriminate listing of information""" Deletion of Nicole Rubio WP:CREATIVE||WP:NACTOR||WP:RS||WP:V||WP:NOTJOURNAL||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:Notability 77
1996 6110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Duncan MacLeod Timeline:1592-1691 User:NinjaRobotPirate 08:20, 5 January 2016 (UTC) delete This belongs on Wikia. Per , plot-only summaries of works do not belong on Wikipedia. This is also redundant to the episode plot summaries Deletion of Duncan MacLeod Timeline:1592-1691 WP:NOTPLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1997 9798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plot of Les Misérables User:Deckiller 22:10, 6 July 2007 (UTC) keep mdash;please find real-world information to complement the plot summary. For an encyclopedia, this is the only way to justify having a subarticle for the plot (as mentioned in ). If you can show that there are plenty of sources out there covering stuff like analysis, real world legacy, and critical response '''in enough portions to justify a whole subarticle on the plot''', then a keep may be appropriate. But in reality, this stuff (including the real-world context) is more suited for the main article, but there are always ways to toy with organization. &mdash Deletion of Plot of Les Misérables WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
1998 15065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ogar Siamupangila User:Florentyna 18:55, 1 August 2017 (UTC) keep Notable badminton player, meets GNG per Deletion of Ogar Siamupangila WP:NBADMINTON Wikipedia:Notability 77
1999 17529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TCM Automobiles User:Pharaoh 21:25, 30 September 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of TCM Automobiles WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2000 18328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asian Football Hall of Fame User:SportingFlyer 23:28, 24 April 2020 (UTC) keep per the sources found by Pahlevun, easily passes Deletion of Asian Football Hall of Fame WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2001 4851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/0 A.D. (game) User:Marasmusine 13:14, 3 September 2009 (UTC) merge """the only -qualifying coverage (and only independent source) presented is the GameDev interview linked to under ELs. As always, I prefer multiple sources. If this is the only such coverage, then the game can perhaps be mentioned in our """"List Of"""" articles instead, with no predjudice against restoring the article if more coverage is achieved at a later date""" Deletion of 0 A.D. (game) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2002 7280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sutherland Hall User:CaliforniaAliBaba 09:12, 25 June 2007 (UTC) comment You as the article creator should check whether the topic has |multiple instances of non-trivial coverage in |reliable sources ''before'' starting the article, not afterwards. If you can't find any, then the topic is probably not appropriate for Wikipedia:Wikipedia is an encyclopedia|inclusion in an encyclopedia Deletion of Sutherland Hall WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2003 11235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How Best to Avoid Dying User:Yakushima 16:09, 1 February 2011 (UTC) delete Seems to fail , let's leave it at that Deletion of How Best to Avoid Dying WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2004 18479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tummy Trouble User:Charlene 11:10, 2 November 2006 (UTC) keep """This passes . It was released theatrically as a """"double bill"""" with ''Honey, I Shrunk the Kids'' per IMDB, and per disney.com was shown in every North American theatre that ''Honey'' was originally shown in. That means at the very least that it was released nationwide in two countries and was shown in 1,371 theatres, which is more than the one country and 200 theatres required by """ Deletion of Tummy Trouble WP:NOTFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
2005 10188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mighty Ducks 4 User:Thesquire 06:25, 14 January 2006 (UTC) delete WP:NOT a pair of crystal Deletion of The Mighty Ducks 4 WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
2006 17004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shadow Lords Tribebook User:Chetsford 16:14, 4 February 2020 (UTC) delete insufficient RS to demonstrate ; insufficient RS to allowing sourcing in a merge Deletion of Shadow Lords Tribebook WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
2007 16211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Travel Radar User:Heartmusic678 13:33, 2 September 2021 (UTC) delete Travel Radar'' only has mentions outside of 2 primary sources. Taken as a collective, the sources fail Deletion of Travel Radar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2008 7418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miniature whipperman User:Dbromage 04:15, 28 August 2007 (UTC) delete """Fails and . The infobox itself says """"Not recognized by any major kennel club""" Deletion of Miniature whipperman WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
2009 3793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pelinpala User:Zeibura 19:09, 22 June 2007 (UTC) delete borderlining on A7. No assertions of why he meets ; if the record labels on which his albums are released are notable, then he does meet the guidelines, but said labels aren't named. Furthermore this is full of unverifiable information Deletion of Pelinpala WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
2010 2733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ecosse Heretic Titanium User:Chromancer 17:57, 23 May 2011 (UTC) delete I just want to go ahead and point out here that even the source cited in the article ''does not'' claim that it's the world's most expensive motorcycle, only that it was the most expensive ''new'' bike ''coming out recently''. i have to admit I'm a little amused that a one-sentence article is getting an AFD longer than it is. Nevertheless, this fails on every criteria: the secondary source is a trivial mention that does not in and of itself constitute notability. I could sell my kitchen table for two hundred thousand dollars and it'd likely make it the most expensive kitchen table put on the market recently, but I doubt I or my table get an article for it. — Deletion of Ecosse Heretic Titanium WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2011 11495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Kripsy User:Mentoz86 12:32, 26 April 2013 (UTC) delete fails as a footballer, fails as a musician, and fails the |general notability guideline Deletion of John Kripsy WP:NFOOTY||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2012 10673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/McAuley High School (Cincinnati, Ohio) User:Seinfreak37 15:37, 23 February 2007 (UTC) keep """School's recognition in 1999-2000 by the Blue Ribbon Schools Program, accompanied by and sources constitute an explicit claim of notability. This award clearly satisfies Criteria 2 of , which states '''""""The school has gained national recognition for its curriculum or program of instruction, or for its success at the national level in extracurricular activities such as art or athletics.""""'''. Statements of the ilk of """"No notability asserted whatsoever, and it doesn't seem likely that any can be found"""" are decidedly biased and unhelpful, and are demonstrative of a failure to perform even the most basic research before participating in an AfD. Rather than targeting the articles created by this individual as one set deserving knee-jerk deletion, it would be helpful for our nominator""" Deletion of McAuley High School (Cincinnati, Ohio) WP:RS||WP:V||WP:SCHOOL Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2013 4363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United Kingdom 2030 FIFA World Cup bid User:Number 11:03, 20 June 2018 (UTC) delete per Deletion of United Kingdom 2030 FIFA World Cup bid WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
2014 20587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Genocide of Azerbaijani people in Iran User:The 00:48, 10 October 2011 (UTC) delete unconfirmable sources that, judging by URLs, don't appear to be . Smells of and Deletion of Genocide of Azerbaijani people in Iran WP:RS||WP:POV||WP:RIGHTGREATWRONGS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2015 19564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Understanding Integrative Intelligence User:Squeamish 21:31, 31 May 2017 (UTC) delete """Frankly, stridently self-promotional article copy. I don't believe there are any independent reviews of this work, and suspect that even the """"academic"""" reviews quoted in the article are solicited, rather than stemming from an actual review in the conventional sense. Additionally, this is ''essentially'' a self-published work. The publisher, Praan Uitgeverij (Praan Group), http://praan.nl/our-team/ conveniently comprises the author list. I don't think this is in G11 territory, but its nowhere close to meeting """ Deletion of Understanding Integrative Intelligence WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2016 16235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Truman Show delusion User:Eggishorn 18:08, 21 June 2017 (UTC) keep I'm at a loss how an article with cites to ''New York Times'', ''Newsweek'', and the ''British Journal of Psychiatry'', all of which significantly cover the topic, could ever not pass , whether the DSM recognizes it or not Deletion of The Truman Show delusion WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2017 7654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of albums awarded Best New Music by Pitchfork Media (2nd nomination) User:Dan56 04:00, 23 February 2016 (UTC) delete as the nominator, per and lack of significant third-party coverage Deletion of List of albums awarded Best New Music by Pitchfork Media (2nd nomination) WP:NOTINHERIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2018 6864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aasan R. Rajendran User:Sandals1 15:31, 22 October 2018 (UTC) delete Definitely fails . The GNG is a closer call, but I don't think the sources are quite good enough. Thanks to WBG for his efforts Deletion of Aasan R. Rajendran WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2019 15498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pentax MV 1 User:Cunard 07:38, 28 November 2010 (UTC) merge I, like Axl, have been unable to find significant coverage in reliable sources to allow Pentax MV 1 to pass Wikipedia:Notability. However, because the article is sourced, albeit with tangential mentions, some information can be moved to Pentax cameras per Deletion of Pentax MV 1 WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
2020 15852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lebanon at the 2013 Asian Youth Games User:Malcolmxl5 11:41, 3 June 2016 (UTC) merge to the main games article. This could have been done |boldly without bringing this and others here Deletion of Lebanon at the 2013 Asian Youth Games WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
2021 12728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bret Weinstein User:AusLondonder 14:51, 3 September 2017 (UTC) delete Per . Weinstein is known exclusively in connection with a news story and is otherwise a low-profile individual Deletion of Bret Weinstein WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2022 8521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Minotaur references in popular culture User:Carlossuarez46 04:34, 25 July 2007 (UTC) delete """half credit for honesty in being a reference list, but there are apparently no es that this """"pop culture"""" phenomenon is notable""" Deletion of List of Minotaur references in popular culture WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2023 1 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ceyhan Belediye Başkanları listesi Kullanıcı:Noumenon''katkılar'' 10:59, 20 Haziran 2007 (UTC) delete Kayda değerlik hususunda bir netliğe ulaşabilmemiz için yönergeleri kullanırken elimizde olan ipuçlarını da iyice değerlendirmemeliyiz. İlk ve önemli ipucu bu maddedeki hiçbir şahsın ''Ceyhan Belediye Başkanı'' olduğu için bir madde sahibi olamayacağı gerçeği. Bu kayda değer değil. Niçin değil? Zira Ceyhan Belediye Başkanı olmak kayda değer olmak anlamına gelmiyor. Buradan hareketle kayda değer olmayan bir makam için oluşturduğumuz liste de kayda değer değildir. Seçilmiş olmak başlı başına bir kayda değerlik sunmuyorsa bize, niçin seçilmişlerin listesi kayda değer olsun? Olay oradaki her şahsın kayda değer olup olmayışıyla da bitmiyor. Şans eseri bu listede gerçekten kayda değer olan büyük başarılara imza atmış bilim adamları da olabilirdi. Hatta listenin çoğunluğu öyle olsaydı bile, bu Ceyhan Belediye Başkanları listesini meşru kılmazdı zira listenin dayandığı makamın kendisi kayda değer değil. Altını çizmem gerekir ki burada kastım ''Ceyhan kayda değer değildir'' benzeri bir şey değil; ''Ceyhan Belediye Başkanı olarak seçilmek'' kayda değer '''değil''' diyorum ve eğer kayda değer değilse bu makam ne salt bu makama eriştiği için bir kişinin maddesi olabilir ne de makama gelmiş geçmiş kişilerin. Seçilmiş kişilerin salt seçilmiş olduklarından kayda değer olmadıklarını da ana sayfasını okuyan herkes (daha kişiler için özel yönergeyi okumadan) fark edebilir. Ayrıca not düşmekte yarar görüyorum: evet Vikipedi bir basılmış, cilt cilt kitaplardan oluşmamaktadır ama sonuçta bir ansiklopedidir ve ''diğer ansiklopedilerde'' bir şeyin yer almıyor oluşu bizim için ''önem taşır'' - bu kayda değerliliği de doğrulanabilirliği de tanımlamakta kullanılan önemli bir noktadır Ceyhan Belediye Başkanları listesinin silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
2024 3011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Levon Smith User:Fenix 11:50, 9 October 2014 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Levon Smith WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2025 18431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Czech Wikipedia User:W 17:32, 23 September 2006 (UTC) delete """no evidence of meeting , e.g. """"The content itself has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself""" Deletion of Czech Wikipedia WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2026 6064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wayne'M User:The 23:04, 21 January 2010 (UTC) delete as a non-notable musician; article will need to be rewritten even if kept due to a significant |neutral point of view violation. &mdash Deletion of Wayne'M WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
2027 2053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Crilly User:ImmortalWizard 18:01, 24 March 2019 (UTC) delete Fails . '''THE NEW Deletion of Martin Crilly WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2028 1200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philipp Fankhauser User:AddWittyNameHere 21:27, 30 August 2016 (UTC) keep very much satisfies #2 (single or album on any country's national chart). ''Love Man Riding'' peaked at #7 on the Swiss Album Chart http://www.swisscharts.com/album/Philipp-Fankhauser/Love-Man-Riding-87007 (official Swiss Charts site), ''Watching From The Safe Side'' peaked at #19 http://www.swisscharts.com/album/Philipp-Fankhauser/Watching-From-The-Safe-Side-32836 (same site), ''Try My Love'' at #3 http://www.swisscharts.com/album/Philipp-Fankhauser/Try-My-Love-146533 (same site), ''Home'' at #2 http://www.swisscharts.com/album/Philipp-Fankhauser/Home-252731 (here), ''Philipp Fankhauser Plays Montreux Jazz Festival'' at #7 http://www.swisscharts.com/album/Philipp-Fankhauser/Philipp-Fankhauser-Plays-Montreux-Jazz-Festival-214035 (still the same charts) and ''Philipp Fankhauser & Margie Evans - Unplugged - Live At Mühle Hunziken'' at #4 http://www.swisscharts.com/album/Philipp-Fankhauser-&-Margie-Evans/Unplugged-Live-At-Muehle-Hunziken-293446 (same Deletion of Philipp Fankhauser WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2029 379 [[Berlin Rangers]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Si! SWamP/Umpf#I M WHAT YOU SAY 19:07, 6. Okt. 2013 (CEST) delete Kein relevanter Verein, da bislang nicht erfolgreich genug in seiner Sportart. Verschieben ins Vereinswiki und hier . Tipp: Vor dem Erstellen eines Artikel die genannten seiten sowie und WP:WWNI zu Rate ziehen. Es empfiehlt sich ja auch, die Baseball-Regeln zu kennen, wenn man bei den Berlin Rangers mitspielen möchte Löschung von Berlin Rangers Wikipedia:WSIGA Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
2030 5293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Izvjestaj User:Kevin1243 02:54, 15 May 2006 (UTC) delete as |unverified and highly |POV Deletion of Izvjestaj WP:V||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2031 18391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Owl Ventures User:Spiderone 19:36, 2 March 2021 (UTC) delete spam article pushed into main space by socks. As per nominator's thorough analysis, the sourcing is not of the standard required for Deletion of Owl Ventures WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2032 18318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All Aboard! 20th Century American Trains User:MacGyverMagic 09:59, 25 February 2009 (UTC) keep for meeting . If possible I'd prefer merging this stubby thing in some larger list or article, but I'm not well-versed enough in stamps to find such a target Deletion of All Aboard! 20th Century American Trains WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2033 1977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gintor User:Nscheffey 14:11, 27 June 2006 (UTC) delete Actually, this article '''is''' about Gintor.com, so Gintor.com has to be notable enough to be |verifiable. The only claim to notability I see here, the file format, links to a page with exactly no information about said format. Maybe this could be mentioned in some article about warez or warez groups but there's nothing here to show it merits its own article Deletion of Gintor WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2034 3979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyril Ogston User:Bearcat 07:59, 26 November 2020 (UTC) delete Founding a small settlement isn't a notability freebie in the absence of a -worthy volume of |reliable source coverage ''about'' him Deletion of Cyril Ogston WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2035 1660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emil Nielsen User:Crystallizedcarbon 18:17, 21 January 2015 (UTC) delete per nom, could not find with in depth coverage to establish |notability Deletion of Emil Nielsen WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2036 16243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Machree User:Gonzonoir 10:23, 18 February 2010 (UTC) delete The news piece linked from our article appears to be literally the http://news.google.co.uk/archivesearch?q=%22machree%22+baum&btnG=Search+Archives&hl=en&ned=uk&scoring=a only coverage of the band known to Google News (based on a search for the name of the band and its lead performer). Nothing relevant in GBooks or GScholar, so I've seen no evidence the band meets |notability requirements Deletion of Machree WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2037 21649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Smartron User:HighKing 17:31, 19 June 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and GNG Deletion of Smartron WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
2038 16124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Masonic architects User:BrownHairedGirl 19:35, 24 October 2006 (UTC) delete per nominator and Deletion of Masonic architects WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2039 15701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ravi Prasad User:Isotope23 17:05, 17 March 2006 (UTC) delete per nom... redirect to non-article that may or may not meet doesn't seem like the right solution Deletion of Ravi Prasad WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2040 11110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arnold and the Brady bunch User:segv11 20:57, 12 January 2006 (UTC) delete as spam, hoax, POV, NN movie, and |complete bollocks. Nonsense too, but not patent enough for speedy Deletion of Arnold and the Brady bunch WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
2041 21596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mistress Absolute User:Edgarde 23:31, 23 December 2009 (UTC) comment While I nominated this article, I am now neutral on retaining it. Wikipedia may not need an entry on Mistress Absolute, but with the http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Mistress_Absolute&oldid=331571207 ad drivel http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Mistress_Absolute&diff=333226234&oldid=332141777 purged, this article no longer agonizes me to the degree where deletion seems imperative. I would suggest one of Absolute's fans on WP take the opportunity to |userfy this article upon deletion Deletion of Mistress Absolute WP:USERFY Wikipedia:Userfication 87
2042 12954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Island Cricket (2nd nomination) User:Atlantic306 17:34, 5 January 2018 (UTC) keep article references 8 and 9 are reliable sources coverage in Asian Tribune and Ceylon News Today for a close pass of . Cricket Archive was a controversial close and could easily have been no consensus with more editors wanting to keep it rather than delete and is a candidate for a deletion review Deletion of Island Cricket (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2043 9088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liga Bet User:Fenix 15:21, 4 August 2014 (UTC) keep Clear pass, all teams are eligible for the national cup Deletion of Liga Bet WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2044 885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geoff Clayton (geologist) User:Dougweller 09:31, 12 July 2010 (UTC) delete """I agree that there was no prediction, but an analysis that if x, then y, and that his analysis was the response to an approach from the newspaper - the article is clear on this, saying Clayton """" was asked by Seattle Weekly to evaluate the potential impact of a lahar on Seattle. """" I see no evidence that 's criteria are met here""" Deletion of Geoff Clayton (geologist) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2045 8700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Zaitchik User:Inner 21:38, 5 December 2006 (UTC) delete Seems like there are very few sources of info which can be used for this. must be a consideration Deletion of Alexander Zaitchik WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2046 938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farshid rostami User:PRehse 13:39, 4 November 2016 (UTC) delete Non-notable boxer - does not meet Deletion of Farshid rostami WP:NBOX Wikipedia:Notability 77
2047 4735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guitar Hero 6 User:Joe 19:19, 9 November 2009 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Guitar Hero 6 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2048 2229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of TEDMED speakers User:Snow 02:38, 26 June 2012 (UTC) delete The list itself does not meet notability standards (even if TEDMED itself does), is in conflict with hat_Wikipedia_is_not#Wikipedia_is_not_a_directory|hat Wikipedia is not on several levels, is promotional, and isn't even verified at present Deletion of List of TEDMED speakers WP:W Help:Watchlist 110
2049 8053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Inder User:Blueboy96 05:01, 22 July 2007 (UTC) delete Doesn't even come close to passing Deletion of Paul Inder WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2050 10385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Captain Trips User:Matt 15:21, 3 January 2008 (UTC) keep it's a plot device used in at least three of King's works and wouldn't be adequately covered in any one of the individual articles. There may be issues with some minor , but that's fixable Deletion of Captain Trips WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2051 15275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dicko Kasongo User:Dlohcierekim 18:40, 1 May 2017 (UTC) delete not significant coaverage for . Doses not meet . Wikipedia is not social media, and one should not use it in lieu of facebook or linkedin Deletion of Dicko Kasongo WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2052 21120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syed Muhammad Kafeel Bukhari User:Smsarmad 12:57, 13 September 2012 (UTC) delete appears to be non-notable per . As mentioned above, this subject finds only passing mention in a few news items Deletion of Syed Muhammad Kafeel Bukhari WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2053 11124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zion Square assault User:TheGracefulSlick 16:49, 11 January 2019 (UTC) keep I will |AGF here. The incident forced Israeli society to consider their issues of racism and lack of tolerance https://www.cnn.com/2012/08/30/world/meast/israel-arab-racism-concerns/index.html?no-st=9999999999; I see that as having |significance. News cverage existed for a year, maybe more, and I will review some of the hits I am seeing in academic journals Deletion of Zion Square assault WP:AGF||WP:LASTING Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
2054 8297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hayat Al-Fahad User:Dom 19:18, 10 July 2020 (UTC) delete this non-notable actor, per Deletion of Hayat Al-Fahad WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2055 19788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oscar Jose Gutierrez User:GPL93 02:03, 19 January 2019 (UTC) delete doesn't mean or , playing for a long time does not ensure notability. Best Deletion of Oscar Jose Gutierrez WP:NTENNIS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2056 16725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phase Shift (video game) User:Sergecross73 14:50, 18 June 2012 (UTC) delete No coverage in |reliable, third party sources. Fails the . Judging by the article creator's edit history and the connection Teancum made, it looks like there's a |conflict of interest here as well Deletion of Phase Shift (video game) WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:COI Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2057 17869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of excommunicable offences in the Catholic Church User:Ritchie333 12:54, 28 November 2016 (UTC) keep the article needs work to explain the context behind the rules, but |that can be solved by normal editing Deletion of List of excommunicable offences in the Catholic Church WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2058 8423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Upper Penninsula (U.P.) Arctic Blast User:The 18:11, 26 January 2007 (UTC) delete per nom, it shows no assertion of and can't be verified because there are zero sources Deletion of Upper Penninsula (U.P.) Arctic Blast WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2059 9043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zach Varga (2nd nomination) User:TimBuck2 15:02, 17 May 2019 (UTC) delete As noted by others, this player does not appear to meet notability criteria establish at Deletion of Zach Varga (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
2060 18562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zuggtmoy (2nd nomination) User:Zxcvbnm 08:01, 28 October 2019 (UTC) delete Per nom. Notability is . The sources in the last AfD were not about the character, but the game they appear in Deletion of Zuggtmoy (2nd nomination) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2061 5039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1MDB Airlines User:Oripaypaykim 12:05, 17 December 2015 (UTC) delete it appears was able to no official announcement are notable but Deletion of 1MDB Airlines WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2062 15294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Dougherty User:TenPoundHammer 21:03, 11 July 2008 (UTC) delete No reliable sources to be seen, no real assertation of notability per Deletion of Mark Dougherty WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2063 8197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katie Fitzgerald (2nd nomination) [[User talk:Ravenswing|''' '' Ravenswing '' ''']] 17:40, 23 September 2018 (UTC) delete """Subject fails to meet NHOCKEY, and no evidence she meets the GNG beyond scanty references in routine sports coverage (and damn little enough of that) explicitly debarred by from supporting notability. Almost all sources in the article primary ones. I'd be very interested in what notability criterion the deprodder thinks """"playing in a national league"""" satisfies""" Deletion of Katie Fitzgerald (2nd nomination) WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2064 430 [[Evangelisch-Freikirchliche_Gemeinde_Kiel-Pries_(Friedrichsort)]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Irmgard NONE delete Wäre auch mit angegebenen Fakten kaum relevant gemäss #Religiöse Gruppen Löschung von Evangelisch-Freikirchliche_Gemeinde_Kiel-Pries_(Friedrichsort) Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
2065 2368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Am The Sea User:Ritchie333 15:20, 19 January 2017 (UTC) merge """to Quadrophenia per , and for homework consider having a similar debate about """"Speak to Me""" Deletion of I Am The Sea WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2066 19795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shahkur Ullah Durrani User:Fiachra10003 02:40, 27 February 2015 (UTC) keep You need to google under S.U. Durrani to track him down properly. A lot of Indians and Pakistanis follow the convention of using first names very rarely in public. I've found this http://www.dawn.com/news/876265/from-subaltern-to-sbp-governor-durrani and this http://www.thenews.com.pk/TodaysPrintDetail.aspx?ID=209702&Cat=7&dt=11/26/2009 and, more entertainingly this http://www.ebay.com/itm/Pakistan-Bangladesh-5-Rupee-P15-Sign-S-U-Durrani-Puruple-Ultra-RARE-/321652348135, which together seem to meet the requirements of . There's also https://www.wikileaks.org/plusd/cables/1973ISLAMA07854_b.html: if Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto thought him notable enough to put under house arrest, that's good enough for me! Incidentally, it's worth reading the article about his daughter Tehmina Durrani. The father seems a dull dog, but worthy. The daughter's article is not well written but she was clearly a lot more fun Deletion of Shahkur Ullah Durrani WP:SECONDARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
2067 21694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mumtaz Qadri User:pepperbeast 21:36, 10 April 2018 (UTC) comment quoting A person who is known only in connection with a criminal event or trial '''should not normally be the subject of a separate Wikipedia article if there is an existing article that could incorporate the available encyclopedic material relating to that person''' emphasis mine. This shouldn't be a separate article, and if there's anything useful that isn't covered in Salmaan Taseer, it should be merged into that article Deletion of Mumtaz Qadri WP:PERP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2068 3177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nostradamus (album) User:RC 03:36, 13 March 2008 (UTC) delete per . '''''Special:Contributions/RC-0722|K Deletion of Nostradamus (album) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2069 17744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spike and Suzy: The Texas Rangers User:Big 18:33, 20 February 2009 (UTC) delete """No IMDb entry for any of """"''Bob & Bobette''"""", """"''Spike and Suzy''"""" nor """"''Luke & Lucie''"""". The http://www.spikeandsuzy-themovie.com/ official website listed in the article contains nothing but the disclaimer """"Coming soon !"""". Extensive Google searches for any of the above search terms come up with no reliable hits that could verify that principal photography has started on this film. Per : """"Films that have not been confirmed by reliable sources to have commenced principal photography should not have their own articles""" Deletion of Spike and Suzy: The Texas Rangers WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2070 14930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The musical parody User:WilliamH 11:19, 24 July 2008 (UTC) delete """Google is not a lynchpin to go by, but when a search of """"The musical parody"""" with its supposed writer, """"Daniel Solorzano"""" reveals only one hit: the Wikipedia article, it is highly likely that this is essentially wholly unverifiable material, either made up by the and/or in support of the previously put-forward Myspace. Either way, not notable""" Deletion of The musical parody WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
2071 3591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/King's Lynn in popular culture User:Themfromspace 23:43, 16 June 2009 (UTC) delete in its current form. The subject lacks notability and the content consists of nothing but |trivial details Deletion of King's Lynn in popular culture WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
2072 13657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Meiklejohn User:Location 14:37, 21 August 2012 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Ben Meiklejohn WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2073 197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vytool User:FisherQueen 23:13, 19 March 2011 (UTC) delete I wasn't able to find any |reliable independent sources writing about this in any significant way Deletion of Vytool WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2074 2550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Campaign Against Antisemitism User:AusLondonder 07:57, 13 November 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and . Has not received significant, in-depth coverage in multiple independent reliable sources Deletion of Campaign Against Antisemitism WP:ORGCRITE||WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
2075 12662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Catalan supremacism User:Calthinus 02:23, 29 October 2017 (UTC) delete """It's a POVFORK and various nationalisms have espoused racialist notions in the past, there is no need to single Catalan nationalism out as the only one with its own page. If the page somehow escapes deletion, the section about """"influence on the 21st century movement"""" (i.e. a -y pasting together of whatever quotes someone could find to try to smear a secessionist movement as based on racism) must go. Cheers""" Deletion of Catalan supremacism WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
2076 16116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicole Asgar User:Aoziwe 21:28, 26 October 2017 (UTC) delete Apart from plenty of social media and routine industry related promo type material cannot find any sufficient useful I|RS to demonstrate to support GNG Deletion of Nicole Asgar WP:RS||WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2077 21424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/+Greythorne the Technomancer (+gthorne) User:Sandstein 20:46, 21 April 2015 (UTC) delete per , . Reams of internet cruft cited as sources, but nothing recognizable as a reliable source Deletion of +Greythorne the Technomancer (+gthorne) WP:BLP||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2078 10047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle of the Birds User:78 14:53, 18 September 2013 (UTC) delete as . Although the term is often used when the mentioned teams play each other or are otherwise compared (see http://espn.go.com/sportsnation/post/_/id/9279456/lcs-round, http://espn.go.com/sportsnation/post/_/id/9232494/which-team-mlb-best-uniforms, http://www.vancouversun.com/sports/baseball/Blue+Jays+dumped+Orioles+battle+birds+Baltimore/8654789/story.html) but there is no longstanding, notable rivalry as claimed by the article. The term has also been used to describe games in Australian rules football (http://www.theroar.com.au/2013/09/01/crows-big-winners-in-battle-of-the-birds/) and rugby (http://www.nswrl.com.au/default.aspx?s=article-display&id=84660&title=chan-prepared-for-bitter-battle-of-the-birds Deletion of Battle of the Birds WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
2079 14402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maharashtra Students Welfare Association User:Robert 00:13, 10 November 2020 (UTC) delete and '''|Salt''' - The history shows that the draft was submitted 6 times, and declined 5 times and then rejected, by 4 reviewers, before being moved into article space anyway. I concur with the reviewers who declined and rejected it, and think that the move to article spae was |tendentious Deletion of Maharashtra Students Welfare Association WP:SALT||WP:TE Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
2080 7066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of unusual deaths (5th nomination) User:Iselilja 09:57, 16 June 2013 (UTC) delete """Agree with nom. and first commenter. The inclusion criteria """"unusual deaths"""" cannot be defined in any reasonable way; as such the list can only be upheld by consistent violation of . It does not surprise me that such a list gets many clicks as people are naturally drawn to the peculiar, sensational and bizarre; list is still not appropriate for an encyclopedia. Regards""" Deletion of List of unusual deaths (5th nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2081 4265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mr. Monk Gets Lotto Fever User:Sgeureka 08:33, 12 August 2010 (UTC) merge No evidence of otability, violates OT#PLOT. &ndash Deletion of Mr. Monk Gets Lotto Fever WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2082 11724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meaninglessness User:Fuhghettaboutit 21:15, 10 March 2007 (UTC) delete """Appears to be |original research and the parts of the article that are """"sourced"""" are to the author's own work in violation of (the website source is a press which bears the same name as the article's creator). Furthermore, the publisher isn't even a publish on demand vanity press, but the author's own press which publishes only his material ( http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/gamahucher_press_catalogue.htm Gamuhucher press catalogue). Thus, no independent |attribution""" Deletion of Meaninglessness WP:NOR||WP:COI||WP:ATT Wikipedia:No original research 65
2083 14540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marianna Karakeyan User:Hunterm267 17:33, 9 July 2018 (UTC) merge with redirect to Nemra (band)|band's article, per nom, {{u|Jmertel23}}, and primarily due to quoted above Deletion of Marianna Karakeyan WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2084 5679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How a good person can really win User:Coolabahapple 07:44, 1 May 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet or , have been unable to find any |useable reviews Deletion of How a good person can really win WP:NBOOK||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2085 5236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Grisanti User:Jbhunley 13:25, 2 June 2016 (UTC) delete Not enough coverage in |independent, |reliable sources to |verify or |sustian article. Fails |Wikipedia's General Notability Guidelines and . His emplyment bio does nothing to demonstrate notability Deletion of Anthony Grisanti WP:IS||WP:RS||WP:V||WP:NRV||WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2086 1273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of clubs and societies of the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology User:Ajf773 21:18, 8 January 2017 (UTC) delete per . Wikipedia is not a university enrolment guide nor a directory of social clubs, none of which are notable Deletion of List of clubs and societies of the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2087 14538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C. V. Krishna Reddy User:Kj 18:35, 15 March 2021 (UTC) delete Insufficient citation record, and I don't think 'Director of Nalla Narasimha Reddy Group of Institutions' is sufficient to pass Deletion of C. V. Krishna Reddy WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2088 6923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carol's daughter User:Metropolitan90 03:51, 11 December 2006 (UTC) keep and '''move''' to Carol's Daughter for proper capitalization. http://money.cnn.com/2005/05/18/news/newsmakers/cosmetics/ CNN confirms that celebrities are among the investors in this company. This brand appears to qualify under Deletion of Carol's daughter WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2089 20143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chikara Season 11 User:Whitescorp34 00:57, 10 February 2014 (UTC) keep This article has more than enough |reliable references that are independent of CHIKARA Season 11 and that discuss it in a significant manner. and it has verifiable material. That is what it needs in order to warrant its own article and it has them Deletion of Chikara Season 11 WP:42 Wikipedia:The answer to life, the universe, and everything 7
2090 16355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sachin Gole User:AfPEN 09:19, 28 March 2019 (UTC) delete Does not meet basic and has no reliable sources Deletion of Sachin Gole WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2091 7947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thirty Pieces of Silver User:Doomsdayer520 18:47, 19 March 2010 (UTC) delete notwithstanding the procedural stuff above, once someone is able to see the article and do their own research, this band does not meet the notability requirements under . Note that the web search can be made easier if you search for the band's name in addition to one or more members, such as Dale Baty. Nonetheless, they have not achieved any significant coverage in reliable sources; just message board postings, social networking sites (within Christian music) and the like Deletion of Thirty Pieces of Silver WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
2092 2149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Femina Look of the Year User:Northamerica1000 14:59, 21 June 2016 (UTC) merge to Femina (India), which hosted the event. This is a functional -M that will improve the merge target article Deletion of Femina Look of the Year WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
2093 9273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Montana Fishburne [[User talk:24.222.124.252|talk]]) 04:37, 22 August 2010 (UTC) keep I believe this satisfies the |general notability guideline. Special:Contributions/24.222.124.252|24.222.124.252 Deletion of Montana Fishburne WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2094 2769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diego Deiros User:David 20:25, 24 August 2016 (UTC) delete per unless evidence can be found showing something other than measuring the height of that one peak that he has gained attention for Deletion of Diego Deiros WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
2095 4264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled Project (film) User:Lugnuts 12:40, 28 February 2014 (UTC) delete Fails (maybe the title is ''Untitled Project''!) and is unref'd too Deletion of Untitled Project (film) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2096 10457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prinye Jaja User:Mredidiongekong 10:55, 10 June 2018 (UTC) delete Per norm. She fails and . Merging with Jaja of Opobo is not advised, apart from mention from https://www.bellanaija.com/2016/05/prinye-jaja-kuvie-announced-as-first-acts-in-mc-galaxys-new-international-record-label-mcg-empire/|this about being related to Jaja of Okpobo there's nothing or any source from GBOOKS dating back to time of Jaja that can also support that, usually in cases like this i use GBOOKS and there should be a few mentions but nothing of such in this case Deletion of Prinye Jaja WP:NARTIST||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2097 139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hall Lyons [[User talk:180.172.239.231|talk]]) 06:41, 23 August 2014 (UTC) comment """The problem of the sources listed in the article should be explained, as you say ''""""nothing in this article supports notability.""""'' Otherwise the volume of the sources would get him past whatever he has actually done. Disclosure: I have no idea of the reliability of the sources.--Special:Contributions/180.172.239.231|180.172.239.231""" Deletion of Hall Lyons WP:BIO||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2098 4730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manon von Gerkan User:Mkativerata 02:22, 16 March 2010 (UTC) delete Sources are nowhere near sufficient to meet the dual test of ''reliability'' and ''significant coverage''. What has been presented so far?http://www.fashionmodeldirectory.com/models/Manon_von+Gerkan/ This is a PR profile - who knows who puts the information on there; http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/swimsuit/collection/models/manon_von_gerkan.html this has no meaning; http://www.perfectpeople.net/biography/119/manon-von-gerkan.htm this has no content; and it is well established that IMDB is not reliable. We cannot have a reliable article about this subject because there is no coverage in reliable sources. An encyclopaedia is only as good as its sources. That's why ''reliability'' must be given its proper weight in . Still awaiting any genuine coverage of the subject in reliable secondary sources Deletion of Manon von Gerkan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2099 12277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Angels- Baptism of Blood User:Justa 12:33, 15 December 2009 (UTC) delete """Fails clearly on four of the five main points, and on the fifth the three links Schmidt provided don't quite make the grade IMO. If there was a category under speedy for films under """"articles fails to indicate it's importance"""" I'd be using it with this""" Deletion of American Angels- Baptism of Blood WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2100 10377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GAT-X252 Forbidden Gundam User:Philosophus 11:32, 27 April 2006 (UTC) delete and '''Transwiki''', per Mango. None of these appear to be verifiable (), and there are no sources listed. However, the nomination was done poorly. All of these should have been listed on one AfD Deletion of GAT-X252 Forbidden Gundam WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2101 14324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Hidan of Maukbeiangjow User:Guest9999 19:45, 29 August 2009 (UTC) delete """considering there appears to be a complete lack of any kind of critical commentary of the subject I think it lacks ''significant coverage'' by |reliable sources. The |notability guideline for films specifically mentions that films are subject to the |general notability guideline ''""""A topic is presumed to be notable if it has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject.""""''. Accepted sources for establishing notability are listed as ''""""published works such as books, television documentaries, full-length featured newspaper articles from large circulation newspapers, full-length magazine reviews""""''. Sources specifically excluded are ''""""Media reprints of press releases, trailers, and advertising for the film""""'' and ''""""Trivial coverage, such as newspaper listings of screening times and venues, """"capsule reviews,"""" plot summaries without critical commentary, or listings in comprehensive film guides such as """"Leonard Maltin's Movie Guide,"""" """"Time Out Film Guide,"""" or the Internet Movie Database""""''. All the coverage presented (and I can't find any more) would appear to fall into the later category. Entries in directories or databases should not confer |notability, the Yellow Pages is a |notable directory but not every business in it is notable. As a side note whilst there may be some overlap the criteria for inclusion on IMDb are different from those on Wikipedia (see http://www.imdb.com/help/show_leaf?titleeligibility), for example ''""""is listed in the catalog of an established video retailer (e.g., Amazon.com)""""'' and ''""""has been downloaded in 'large' numbers from some website(s)""""'' probably wouldn't cut it here without independent coverage""" Deletion of The Hidan of Maukbeiangjow WP:RS||WP:NF||WP:NN||WP:NN||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2102 5116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Addis Sheraton Shopping Center User:Technical 15:50, 5 September 2013 (UTC) delete as this does in fact fail Deletion of Addis Sheraton Shopping Center WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2103 21929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Luscher User:Mwelch 02:19, 13 March 2007 (UTC) keep Seems to be mildly notable in that he worked on the soundtrack to a film (''Abby Singer'') that seems to be at least somewhat notable (imdb entry, apparently has made several film festivals, and includes appearances by numerous big-names in film) and also on the music for a notable video game (''Amped'' — Xbox release that was apparently successful enough to spawn two sequels). That seems to meet the notability requirement of , if just barely Deletion of Paul Luscher WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2104 16193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nurzaidi Bunari User:NZ 11:18, 2 January 2018 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Nurzaidi Bunari WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2105 8236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Peoples User:Norespectasip 06:28, 20 September 2011 (UTC) merge to Average Joe (TV series). Fails |general notability guideline, only known in relation to TV series Deletion of Jason Peoples WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2106 1770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RailsBricks User:Lesser 19:26, 23 August 2014 (UTC) delete mdash;The rubygems site does not contribute to notability, nor does the single sentence + link at rubynews. That leaves us with one podcast, and railsbricks was only one topic among six discussed. There's just not enough out there in the way of to warrant an article. If uptake continues and coverage starts to accrue, the article can be recreated Deletion of RailsBricks WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2107 15987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Latency User:Bearcat 20:37, 4 June 2018 (UTC) delete """The only potential claim to passing here is the chart positions attained by the single """"Tonight, I Love You"""", but those completely fail to |verify in a ''Billboard'' search. And ''Billboard'' is the ''only'' acceptable or notability-conferring chart provider for Canada's """"Hot 100"""" or """"Hot AC"""" charts in the 21st-century, because both ''RPM'' and ''The Record'' were long gone by 2009 — so if they don't verify in ''Billboard'' then there's no other acceptable chart to """"rectify"""" them to. And since bands and musicians quite routinely try to curveball their way around our notability standards by claiming to have had bigger chart hits than they ever really did, it's not the ''claim'' of a chart position that gets a band into Wikipedia but the ability to verify that the claimed chart position is actually ''true''. And this is not referenced to |reliable sources that get the band past NMUSIC #1, either — it's referenced entirely to |primary sources, with ''zero'' evidence of media coverage about them being shown at all, and nothing here is """"inherently"""" notable enough to exempt them from having to be referenced much better than this""" Deletion of The Latency WP:NMUSIC||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES Wikipedia:Notability 77
2108 11084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Labyrinth City User:Guy 03:21, 27 December 2012 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability, all sources are self published -- see Deletion of Labyrinth City WP:SPS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2109 17799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stoneriver User:Stifle 09:39, 3 June 2010 (UTC) delete No significant coverage (per VernoWhitney's analysis) and fails Deletion of Stoneriver WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2110 1330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dexter's Laboratory: The Musical Time Machine User:SBKSPP 03:31, 15 May 2021 (UTC) merge to Dexter's Laboratory#Music releases Fails per nom Deletion of Dexter's Laboratory: The Musical Time Machine WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
2111 60 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Deniz Baykal NONE NONE comment """VP:SAM sayfasından alıntı yapalım. '''Ayrıca, """"tarafsız olmama"""" () gerekçesi de sıklıkla kullanılır, fakat bu durumdaki çoğu maddenin kurtarılabilmesi olasıdır. Dolayısıyla bu gerekçe, silme için çok kuvvetli bir dayanak değildir.''' Görüldüğü üzere size göre taraflı olması maddenin silinmesini gerektirmez.Maddeye taraflı şablonu ekleyerek sebeplerinizi tartışma sayfasında belirtebilirsiniz""" Deniz Baykal'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Tarafsız bakış açısı Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
2112 14498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neil Korotash User:Rpclod 11:43, 16 May 2015 (UTC) delete article does not demonstrate that criteria are met Deletion of Neil Korotash WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2113 8606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Briar Rose (band) User:Jack 22:05, 31 August 2008 (UTC) keep Satisfies and Deletion of Briar Rose (band) WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
2114 11929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Postmarks User:Jersey92 01:09, 4 July 2014 (UTC) keep But the article needs to be edited. There are sufficient results from Google searches to pass Deletion of The Postmarks WP:RS||WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2115 9824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dmitry and Natalia Baksheevy User:Wm335td 22:37, 5 December 2019 (UTC) keep Meets GNG per the which NEXISTS. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2017/09/26/russian-cannibal-couple-may-have-drugged-killed-and-eaten-as-many-as-30-people-police-say/ The Washington Post Deletion of Dmitry and Natalia Baksheevy WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2116 6780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Pale (band) User:SunStar 23:55, 24 March 2007 (UTC) keep The band meet |the criteria for recording artists on Wikipedia. However, a rewrite may well be needed Deletion of The Pale (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2117 9382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charley Koontz User:Justlettersandnumbers 21:21, 2 April 2018 (UTC) delete """If his most notable rôle is not even mentioned in our article on ''Community (TV series)|Community'' then it is minor indeed, and surely not a """"significant role"""" as required for ; his other parts appear to be even more trivial. If someone adds a good number solid reliable sources with in-depth coverage of numerous '''significant''' parts as required by our notability guideline, then please ping me""" Deletion of Charley Koontz WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2118 9997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jen friel User:Chzz 21:35, 5 July 2010 (UTC) delete per the above; same reasoning; lack of coverage in Deletion of Jen friel WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2119 9338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grand Staircase of the Titanic User:Dhartung 04:17, 2 July 2007 (UTC) delete the staircase is not ''independently'' notable, as fine a staircase as it may have been. For an historical artifact or architectural structure, these are extremely weak sources, and two really border on in that the importance is asserted by our article and not our source. I could see an extensive and sourced article on ''all'' the ship's notable architecture, but the importance of the staircase is as the nominator states a construct of the James Cameron film ''Titanic Deletion of Grand Staircase of the Titanic WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
2120 16277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burst Oral Care User:HighKing 21:05, 4 January 2021 (UTC) delete """This is spam. The content appears to have been taken from the company's PR material (I mean, 25,000 """"ambassadors"""", c'mon!). Cunard has found some mentioned of the company but even by his own admission there is next to nothing written about *the company* and instead there appears to be coverage of the products (and even that coverage is PR-driven for the most part). The criteria for establishing notability for companies/organizations as per is for multiple sources (at least two) of |significant coverage with |in-depth information *on the company* and (this bit is important!) containing |""""Independent Content"""". """"Independent content"""", in order to count towards establishing notability, must include ''original and independent opinion, analysis, investigation, and fact checking that are clearly attributable to a source unaffiliated to the subject''. None of the references in the article meet the criteria and having searched I am unable to locate any references that meet the criteria. Topic fails GNG/""" Deletion of Burst Oral Care WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2121 17321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Sidoni (2nd nomination) User:Newshunter12 04:01, 17 June 2019 (UTC) delete This article fails and because its subject has received nether sustained nor had important roles in any major productions. There is also no evidence that he is any more notable now then when this article was deleted before in 2010 Deletion of David Sidoni (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
2122 144 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Selin Ciğerci Kullanıcı:seksen iki yüz kırk beşseksen iki yüz kırk beş / ggt 11.30, 17 Eylül 2020 (UTC) keep """Maddede hâlihazırda olan 1 ve 3 numaralı kaynaklar bağımsız statüde (Ayşe Arman'ın röportajı da kayda değerlik açısından """"dış dünyanın verdiği önem"""" teşkil ediyor). Onun dışında Google Haberler'de kendisiyle ilgili bağımsız kaynaklar bulmak mümkün, örneğin: http://cnnturk.com/magazin/selin-cigerci-4-1-milyon-tllik-takilariyla-dikkat-cekti?page=2 https://www.milliyet.com.tr/selin-cigerci-nin-baba-itirafi-neden-hafife-alinmamali--molatik-14564/ https://www.haber46.com.tr/magazin/selin-cigerci-kahramanmarasa-gelmesin-kampanyasi-h365001.html https://www.milliyet.com.tr/selin-cigerci-12-bin-takipcili-fake-hesabim-var--molatik-14760/. kriterlerini sağlamasının gerekli olmadığını, genel kayda değerlik kriterine uygunluğun mutlaka kontrol edilmesi gerektiğini not düşeyim""" Selin Ciğerci'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
2123 1094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uppercut (band) User:Shauri 15:02, 24 September 2005 (UTC) delete doesn't meet Deletion of Uppercut (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2124 20215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Montgomery User:Actingadam 16:49, 12 June 2006 (UTC) delete i read the and i get it go ahead and delete it Deletion of Adam Montgomery WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2125 20865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Lawler User:Jayden54 18:02, 24 December 2006 (UTC) delete non notable per , and . The band has more than two albums, but their label isn't notable which means their albums don't qualify for . Jim Lawler doesn't pass in any way Deletion of Jim Lawler WP:BIO||WP:MUSIC||WP:CORP||WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2126 2620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fabian Benko User:Sir 16:01, 14 February 2016 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Fabian Benko WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2127 174 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Cemre Baysel (2. aday gösterme) Kullanıcı:seksen iki yüz kırk beşseksen iki yüz kırk beş / ggt 23.29, 13 Temmuz 2021 (UTC) comment """Diğer arkadaşlara ping atılmış ancak Victor bana katıldığını söylemekle yetinmiş, dolayısıyla cevap vereyim. Hâlbuki """"garantiler"""" mantığıyla hareket etmediğimizi çok açık bir şekilde ifade ediyoruz . Yukarıda belirttiğim üzere genel kayda değerlik kriterine düşülen şerh çok açık, çoklu bağımsız kaynaklar aranmasına ''alternatif olarak'' başka testler kullanılabiliyor; bağımsız kaynak olmaması, kayda değer olmadığı anlamına gelmiyor. Bu özel kriterlerdeki muğlak ifadeler çok yanlış yorumlanıyor (gerçi 'deki gibi çok net şekilde """"kayda değerdir"""" dediğinde bile """"boşverin siz onu"""" denilebiliyor ya), hani sanki o cümle """"bu yönerge kendi kendini imha edecektir, aslında böyle bir yönerge yok, okumayın gitsin"""" anlamına geliyormuş gibi bahsediliyor; hâlbuki hatırlatmak gerekirse ondan önceki ifade """"Aşağıdaki kriterleri sağlayan bir kişinin genel olarak kayda değer olduğu kabul edilir."""" diyor. Bu 0 garantiler anlamına gelmiyor, ancak garantilemediğini ispat etmek için gerçekten istisnai bir durumun varlığını ispat etmeyi zorunlu kılıyor. Bu istisnai durum için kullanacağımız eşik elbette tartışma konusu olabilir. Benim anlayışıma göre """"Bağımsız kaynak bulamadık"""" kesinlikle yeterli bir gerekçe değil, zira bu zaten özel kriterin doğası gereği olabileceği öngörülen bir durum, genel kayda değerlik yönergesi de açıkça bu duruma izin vermiş. Vikipedi tarihi boyunca da sayısız emsalimiz var bu şekilde, ansızın özel kriterlerde muğlaklık sağlayan bir cümlenin """"keşfedilmesiyle"""" bunun değişmesini doğru bulmuyorum ve bugüne dek alınmış emsal kararların keyfî olarak addetmekten çekinmeyeceğim bir yorumlamayla iptal edilmesini, ansiklopediyi ileriye taşıyacak bir adım olarak görmüyorum. Böyle bir adım en fazla buradaki editörlerimizin (tipik olarak Türkiye'de yaşayan, erkek, kentli, belirli bir yaş ortalamasına sahip kimseler) ilgi alanlarının dışında kalan maddeleri daha kolay silmemize yol açacak ve sistemik yanlılık açısından kendi kalemize gol olarak dönecektir. Benim için bu istisnai durum başka herhangi bir gerekçe olabilir, atıyorum söz konusu dizinin kayda değerliği yalnızca yan karakterlerin oynadığı bir sahnenin tartışma yaratması sonucu olmuştur, bu nedenle başrollere kayda değerlik sağlaması doğru değildir, vesaire""" Cemre Baysel (2. günü gösterme) yazısının silinmesi Vikipedi:AKADEMİSYEN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2128 10509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruno Julliard User:Sharkface217 08:37, 31 December 2006 (UTC) keep This needs to be rewritten due to , but it should be kept Deletion of Bruno Julliard WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
2129 2993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesus (archangel) User:Hut 20:26, 5 May 2017 (UTC) delete per . Richard Carrier is one of the best known proponents of the Christ myth theory, the view that Jesus did not exist. AFAICT this article represents part of his views on the subject, as a possible explanation of where the idea of Jesus came from if Jesus was not a real historical person. The Christ myth theory is a fringe theory and has very, very little support in mainstream academic scholarship on the subject, so our policies and guidelines concerning fringe theories apply. Fringe theories (or aspects of them) only deserve independent articles they have ''been referenced extensively, and in a serious and reliable manner, by major publications that are independent of their promulgators and popularizers'' (). That is certainly going to require more sources than just Richard Carrier. Furthermore, per the article would have to make it clear that it is discussing a fringe theory with little mainstream acceptance, which this one doesn't Deletion of Jesus (archangel) WP:NFRINGE||WP:NFRINGE||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
2130 11012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuala Lumpurian User:William 00:40, 13 September 2006 (UTC) merge unless possibility for moving the page beyond a |dictionary definition is shown Deletion of Kuala Lumpurian WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
2131 16459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adolf Fruchthändler User:P 18:38, 22 March 2015 (UTC) delete Approximately eleven million people were killed in the Holocaust. While their fates all were tragical, most of them are not notable enough to be included in Wikipedia with separate biographies. Fruchthändler appears to fail both and Deletion of Adolf Fruchthändler WP:VICTIM||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2132 11395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Roenfeld User:E 23:35, 20 January 2018 (UTC) delete Fails , . Author of local history books that fail to support notability; Arcadia Press is a vanity publisher of paperbacks tomes of local history lite filled with nostalgic photos of a particular town or neighborhood. They do sell to a local market, and can be charming, but they do not confer notability on an author Deletion of Ryan Roenfeld WP:AUTHOR||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2133 20576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Damon Weaver User:JayJasper 19:28, 1 September 2009 (UTC) delete """per nom. Although I've edited this article, it is now obvious that this a case of |recentism. Delete w/o prejudice against re-creation in the event that he becomes notable beyond his recent """"15 mins. of fame""" Deletion of Damon Weaver WP:RECENTISM Wikipedia:Recentism 10
2134 2364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ICracked User:K 04:06, 30 October 2016 (UTC) delete per ; a vanity page that is being used for promotion. Sources do not meet but simply illustrate that the company exists Deletion of ICracked WP:PROMO||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2135 13970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D100 Radio (New York City) User:NZ 08:18, 3 July 2017 (UTC) delete As already mentioned Fails and . Did a search for them and isn’t a lot of articles on them Deletion of D100 Radio (New York City) WP:GNG||WP:NMEDIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
2136 19366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CureROM User:Masterpiece2000 02:58, 16 June 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of CureROM WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2137 19630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evil Star (album) User:J04n 10:29, 1 April 2013 (UTC) merge to Wolf (band), really nothing to merge. The album does not approach or Deletion of Evil Star (album) WP:GNG||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2138 19554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Real Time Developer Studio User:Sam 18:24, 21 March 2014 (UTC) comment An {{diff|Real Time Developer Studio|596709470|596665653|AfD nomination}} is not y Deletion of Real Time Developer Studio WP:BITE Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
2139 13436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Website scale User:VivioFateFan 05:48, 14 January 2008 (UTC) delete Most of the article seems to be unsourced |original research Deletion of Website scale WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2140 11459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Leventhal User:Msnicki 23:17, 4 June 2012 (UTC) delete Lacks reliable independent secondary sources to establish notability as required by or . Clearly an utobiography Deletion of Mike Leventhal WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO||WP:A Wikipedia:Notability 77
2141 20918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyclingteam Jo Piels User:Lugnuts 10:04, 7 December 2014 (UTC) keep One ref does not equate to non-notable. Suggest the nominator withdraws this and reads Deletion of Cyclingteam Jo Piels WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
2142 1305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2021 NHL Outdoor Games NONE NONE keep There is significant coverage in multiple, reliable independent sources so is clearly met. And these sources are major outlets: in addition to ESPN and USA Today other sources to cover this are Sportsnet https://www.sportsnet.ca/nhl/article/nhl-planning-two-outdoor-games-lake-tahoe-2021-season/, Bleacher Report https://bleacherreport.com/articles/2924959-nhl-reportedly-planning-2-outdoor-games-at-lake-tahoe-during-2021-season, and The Athletic https://theathletic.com/2296327/2021/01/01/all-the-details-of-nhls-outdoor-games-at-lake-tahoe/; plus the local Reno Gazette-Journal https://www.rgj.com/story/sports/2021/01/01/nhl-lake-tahoe-outdoor-game-edgewood-tahoe-resort-avalanche-golden-knights-flyers-bruins-schedule/4108388001/. All these are independent articles, not just the same Associated Press blurb Deletion of 2021 NHL Outdoor Games WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2143 19690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emma Vigeland (3rd nomination) User:TheBattleAngel 15:56, 9 April 2021 (UTC) delete I would agree that she fails and Deletion of Emma Vigeland (3rd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NJOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
2144 3144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krayola (Timesplitters) User:Yom 05:57, 11 July 2006 (UTC) delete forgot I had that game. Fails , however. &mdash Deletion of Krayola (Timesplitters) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2145 16834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eotis (endoftermitis) [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] 02:47, 28 June 2017 (UTC) delete Non-notable neologism. Fails and Deletion of Eotis (endoftermitis) WP:GNG||WP:NOTURBANDICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2146 13490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lois de Menil User:Agricola44 15:47, 21 April 2015 (UTC) delete """I did not wade through the sock-wall-of-text above, but simply took a quick look at the article and sources. Article has plenty of and lots of entries in the biblio that are not . I thought maybe the Vanity Fair (magazine)|Vanity Fair piece would lend some weight, but it is basically about the family with a focus on a few members – Lois is only mentioned, somewhat trivially, a few times. From what I take of the article, it is clear that she is not notable ''per se''. may be a relevant guideline (since she has a PhD and is associated with a research institution) and her book """"Who speaks for Europe"""" is held in ~500 institutions, but we normally set the bar for c1 in this guideline to having at least 2 such """"well-held"""" (noted) publications. Perhaps simply """ Deletion of Lois de Menil WP:OR||WP:RS||WP:PROF||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:No original research 65
2147 9426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OGame (3rd nomination) User:S 21:24, 24 January 2009 (UTC) keep There's a |reliable source and it's failed two AfD's previously Deletion of OGame (3rd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2148 10095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/15 Khordad (Paramont) Intersection User:Imzadi1979 00:01, 1 January 2012 (UTC) delete can be covered in the articles about the demonstrations, but otherwise fails on its own. Remember, notability can't be inherited Deletion of 15 Khordad (Paramont) Intersection WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2149 20025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erand Hoxha (2nd nomination) User:GiantSnowman 12:13, 25 June 2009 (UTC) delete per nom; fails Deletion of Erand Hoxha (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2150 21953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fernando Saraceni User:SL93 23:15, 16 June 2013 (UTC) keep Per . Competed in a professional league Deletion of Fernando Saraceni WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2151 1975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deuce untitled album User:Purplebackpack89 23:55, 18 April 2011 (UTC) delete Duh-duh-duh, (duh-duh), duh-duh-duh, |Can't touch this Deletion of Deuce untitled album WP:HAMMERTIME Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
2152 691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Li Jian (singer) User:Hisashiyarouin 04:45, 2 April 2015 (UTC) keep Satisifies at least #9, most recently with second place in I Am a Singer (Chinese TV series) season 3, and a handful of other awards dating back to 2006. Do see :zh:李健 (歌手) and search by the Chinese name for expansion, where you should find at least the sort of http://xw.qq.com/ent/20150330055822 interview with a Chinese newspaper. '''野狼院ひさし Deletion of Li Jian (singer) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2153 3824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nickels User:Kinu 06:33, 22 February 2006 (UTC) delete as |made up in school one day goodness Deletion of Nickels WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
2154 223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Z LaLa (2nd nomination) User:doomsdayer520 15:39, 2 February 2021 (UTC) delete """This is a close call because she has a charting single (https://www.billboard.com/music/z-lala) and some media notoriety in """"worst dressed"""" lists. She has some listings for modeling work, and gets noticed occasionally for her gimmick of singing in lots of different languages. Those are minor achievements that the article desperately over-interprets with terms like """"controversial"""" and """"pushing the boundaries"""", or implying that she is a social justice champion because she has LGBT fans. She is present in the media but not quite comprehensively enough for the requirements at and """ Deletion of Z LaLa (2nd nomination) WP:NSINGER||WP:NMODEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2155 9317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simone de Gale User:JudgePure 18:19, 5 February 2017 (UTC) keep """meets significant coverage in reliable and independent sources have been listed on the page. Checked , no listing of Wikipedia on website: """"http://simonedegale.com/awards/ Awards and Accreditations"""". Expanded on """"Early Life"""" and """"Style"""". — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of Simone de Gale WP:GNG||WP:NOTADVERTISING Wikipedia:Notability 77
2156 14615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billy Lockwood User:Nishkid64 21:52, 1 September 2006 (UTC) delete He fails and has only acted in 3 movies, of which have mostly been minor roles Deletion of Billy Lockwood WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2157 10165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/We Are North Melbourne User:Dave 01:45, 23 April 2009 (UTC) comment """Are you sure applies to this case? According to these guidelines apply to """"topics"""", whereas WANM is a legal entity in it's own right. In this case I think Wikipedia:ORG would apply""" Deletion of We Are North Melbourne WP:N||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2158 3628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haakon Faste User:Randykitty 15:32, 3 November 2013 (UTC) delete Way |too soon. Doesn't even come close to meeting Deletion of Haakon Faste WP:TOOSOON||WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Too soon 40
2159 19087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Formula One driver numbers (3rd nomination) User:Tvx1 11:09, 28 October 2017 (UTC) delete I have nominated this myself before and still have the opinion that this should deleted. This is . It's trivial information with little encyclopedic value in a stand-alone list. Everything we need to tell our readers about F1 drivers' numbers is already presented in the season articles. While numbers are assigned for a considerable time, they are not permanent. In a couple of years all numbers will have been used by multiple drivers. Making this list more and more pointless. If a particular driver has a particularly notable reason for picking a particular number that can be explained in their biography Deletion of List of Formula One driver numbers (3rd nomination) WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
2160 19162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radhi Rudy Bin Dadu User:Uncle 05:13, 18 May 2017 (UTC) delete No indication of notability per , with no significant coverage online in . Evident onflict of interest by article creator, who has so far created only articles on films connected with director Mohd. Hafiz Mat Ishak Deletion of Radhi Rudy Bin Dadu WP:NFILM||WP:RS||WP:C Wikipedia:Notability 77
2161 3555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Culp [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 19:55, 26 November 2013 (UTC) delete Doesn't seem to meet either or . Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Brian Culp WP:NBASEBALL||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2162 17296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Project Unreality [[User talk:Crotalus horridus|*** Crotalus ***]] 21:14, 30 September 2009 (UTC) delete I don't see any evidence of coverage in |reliable, third-party sources, so I think this article fails the |verifiability requirements. Google Books shows a handful of hits: some of them are not talking about the emulator, but a derisive nickname for N64 project delays; one is a printed Wikipedia mirror; and one does mention the emulator, but it is simply part of a list with no details whatsoever. Google Scholar shows nothing of value. A regular Web search turns up lots of hits, but nothing that I would classify as a reliable third-party source in this context. Zophar's Domain might be an acceptable source under some circumstances (it is one of the oldest and best-known emulation sites), but all it contains is a couple of sentences. There really isn't sufficient material to pass the |general notability guideline or have an article that meets Wikipedia policy Deletion of Project Unreality WP:RS||WP:V||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2163 4792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of 2015 MLB games on ESPN User:Bearcat 20:37, 8 January 2016 (UTC) delete It's a longstanding principle that |Wikipedia is not TV Guide; maintaining lists of every individual baseball game that aired on one particular television network definitely falls afoul of that Deletion of List of 2015 MLB games on ESPN WP:NOTTVGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2164 6254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Assumption Thonburi School Stadium User:Fenix 08:46, 5 September 2016 (UTC) delete not seeing anything here that would meet let alone GNG Deletion of Assumption Thonburi School Stadium WP:GEOFEAT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2165 998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Rabilizirov User:Sławomir 11:08, 1 August 2013 (UTC) delete Based on http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=R+Rabilizirov&btnG=&hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C39 this Google scholar search, the subject has an h-index of 6 (but that could be artificially low due to different romanizations of the name). I don't think being a fellow of the Russian Academy of Sciences in itself is enough to confer a pass under , but I could easily see how it could (but then I would expect that there would be other evidence of notability, such as high GS cites Deletion of Robert Rabilizirov WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2166 8452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles de la Croix User:GRBerry 00:26, 1 July 2009 (UTC) keep Inclusion in a paper encyclopedia is in and of itself sufficient evidence of notability. No further investigation needs to be done to reach a keep conclusion. The article would be better off if one or more editors did the historical research to cite sources other than that encyclopedia, however I'm sure they will have it done by the |deadline Deletion of Charles de la Croix WP:TIND Wikipedia:There is no deadline 35
2167 18934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Balbir Singh Jakhar User:Pharaoh 07:08, 6 August 2019 (UTC) delete fails not elected Deletion of Balbir Singh Jakhar WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2168 18436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cultural Developments under the Delhi Sultanate User:Secret 04:54, 17 January 2012 (UTC) delete Appears to be full of |OR. The Islamic cultural developments in India were not restricted to the Sultanate alone. Not much significance with regard to the Sultanate either Deletion of Cultural Developments under the Delhi Sultanate WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2169 2743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alli L!ve User:Armbrust 13:25, 4 November 2010 (UTC) delete per the lack of significant coverage in |reliable sources Deletion of Alli L!ve WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2170 4796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/R. C. Unnithan User:S 16:26, 24 February 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of R. C. Unnithan WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2171 887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Anne Feeney User:Mcmatter 14:56, 15 July 2019 (UTC) delete Despite the single word nomination without any rationale for deletion. This person does not seem to meet the |inclusion threshold. I have found no further sourcing to support anything over the current sources in the article which are a primary source and a business listing about the charity, not the subject at hand. I don't believe even her position is even notable enough to make a mention in the International Peace Institute article Deletion of Mary Anne Feeney WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2172 89 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ali Biçim (4. aday gösterme) Kullanıcı:ravagesravages 10.37, 31 Mart 2020 (UTC) comment Açıklamaya çalıştığım gibi, bu tip kişiler hakkında haber bulmak artık kolay denebilir. Önemli olan, bu kişilerin özel kayda değerlik kriterlerin sağlayıp sağlamadığı. Mesela bu kişi için 'deki '''eğlence sanatçılarını''' kıstas alıyoruz. Oradaki kriterlerden herhangi birini sağladığı kanaatinde değilim. Yer aldığı projelerden, Okan Bayülgen ile çalıştıkları hariç herhangi birinin Vikipedi maddesi dahi yok. Bu projelerin kayda değerliği de tartışmalı, belki de değiller. Mesela Babam Sınıfta Kaldı dizisi, kayda değerlik gerekçesiyle silinmiş. Bir kez daha vurgulamak istiyorum, son dönemlerde güvenilir kabul edilen kaynaklarda bir sürü kişinin haberi çıkıyor. Fakat sadece bunlara dayanarak kayda değerlik değerlendirmesi yapmak bence eksik olur. Eğer özel kayda değerlik kriterleri bulunan bir madde hakkında tartışıyorsak, o özel kriterleri de değerlendirmeye katmalıyız. Bu nedenle, kişi hakkında güvenilir kaynakların varlığını kabul ediyor, fakat VP:KİŞİ kriterlerini karşılamadığı gerekçesiyle '''silinmesi''' yönündeki görüşümde şu an için ısrar ediyorum Ali Biçim (4. aday gösterme) yazısının silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
2173 14841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Peale Bishop User:David 04:38, 1 February 2011 (UTC) delete No evidence of passing and two local obituaries (one not available online) are adequate enough to reliably source the article but aren't enough to convince me of a pass of Deletion of Jonathan Peale Bishop WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2174 4845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roark's Formulas for Stress and Strain - Seventh Edition User:Wizard191 13:54, 28 December 2009 (UTC) keep Thanks for posting this over on the Engineering Wikiproject. This book is definitely notable per #Criteria point 4. However, I'm at a loss for finding any online references to support this at the moment. I can tell you that I learned about it in college and that it is held in high regards among mechanical engineers and professors Deletion of Roark's Formulas for Stress and Strain - Seventh Edition WP:NB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2175 1251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mr. Key User:Pharaoh 04:17, 28 September 2014 (UTC) delete Clearly fails both and Deletion of Mr. Key WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
2176 13492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali S. Asani User:Kim 08:53, 18 June 2007 (UTC) delete The award cannot be verified from the Harvard Foundation's own website (because of the poor quality of the site, rather than because the claim is bogus, I would guess!) No other external sources. Has written some articles found on Google Scholar, but then so have I and I don't have a Wikipedia article! Fails unless some better external sources can be found Deletion of Ali S. Asani WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2177 17656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elliptical poetry User:Evb 18:08, 20 July 2007 (UTC) delete per . Also contains . Should be ''speedy delete'', as author/nominator requests deletion. {{tl|db-author Deletion of Elliptical poetry WP:NEO||WP:OR Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
2178 12663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bai Chali Sasariye User:MichaelQSchmidt 03:02, 11 July 2009 (UTC) keep as article has enough sourcing to show it as the most successful Rajasthan film in the period from 1990 through 2005. Considering the area is not known for their film industry, I am encouraged to remember and that it does not matter to wikipedia that it might not made splash headlines in the New York Times. Anybody have a copy of the 1988 Rajasthani Gazette, or whatever non-English sources covered their most successful film in 15 years? And has anyone checked the various spelling permutations that occur with translation to English? The article may never be more than a stub, but it's an acceptable and encyclopedic stub Deletion of Bai Chali Sasariye WP:CSB Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
2179 355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Haiti earthquake conspiracy theories User:Pontificalibus 09:46, 28 January 2010 (UTC) delete """It seems there is nothing notable here that can't be adequately covered in other articles. The HAARP claim doesn't have reliable sources, the """"concerns over military occuption"""" claim is not really a conspiracy theory and the rest doesn't meet and so certainly shouldn't be given |undue weight by having it's own article""" Deletion of 2010 Haiti earthquake conspiracy theories WP:FRINGE||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
2180 20351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerald Vernon-Jackson User:Bschott 15:14, 14 August 2006 (UTC) delete According to point number two in : ''Political figures holding international, national or statewide/provincewide office or members of a national, state or provincial legislature.'' This is a city council member/leader. As a political figure, they do not hold a statewide/provincewide office Deletion of Gerald Vernon-Jackson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2181 21804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bottle toss User:ThePaintedOne 18:35, 3 February 2011 (UTC) delete Textbook example of Deletion of Bottle toss WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
2182 16440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Morgan W. Walker Jr. User:WilliamJE 19:32, 18 March 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Morgan W. Walker Jr. WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2183 9013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/3ware (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 09:04, 16 April 2016 (UTC) merge to Applied Micro Circuits Corporation (AMCC), which presently only has a very short mention. Sources exist, but many of them cover the topic relative to AMCC's developments of the product. Source examples include https://books.google.com/books?id=3jcEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA33&dq=%223ware%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwje6avY5ZLMAhUT-2MKHe5JBnsQ6AEIIzAB#v=onepage&q=%223ware%22&f=false, https://books.google.com/books?id=QwIAAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA48&dq=%223ware%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwje6avY5ZLMAhUT-2MKHe5JBnsQ6AEIKzAD#v=onepage&q=%223ware%22&f=false, http://www.macworld.com/article/1141789/lsi.html, http://www.macobserver.com/tmo/review/The_3ware_Sidecar_SATA_II_Hardware_Desktop_RAID. This will improve the merge target article per Deletion of 3ware (2nd nomination) WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
2184 513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward Dick User:WFCforLife 00:06, 24 July 2010 (UTC) merge I don't see this AfD as down to notability. In my opinion, Phil and Theleftorium have established beyond any doubt that this man is notable. But the decision on whether or not an individual should have a stand alone article should always boil down to whether or not it adds encyclopaedic value, |regardless of established conventions. If this is a reasonable summary of his life, and there are similar articles on similar people from the same company, coverage on both the company and the individual would be best served with a higher-quality, concentrated article, rather than having to click on multiple links for little snippets of the picture. For clarity, this content definitely warrants coverage on wikipedia. But as the article stands, a merge of some description seems a logical step Deletion of Edward Dick WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
2185 21682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GeckoOS Backup Loader Game Compatibility List User:Jons63 00:55, 29 September 2008 (UTC) delete No |reliable sources, only source is a blog. The ''GeckoOS Backup Loader'' doesn't have an article and there are no reliable sources to support an article. So if the program is not notable is the games it works with notable Deletion of GeckoOS Backup Loader Game Compatibility List WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2186 18687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Genome Project User:Bearian 21:07, 11 January 2010 (UTC) delete without prejudice. Too new; fails , , EO, , etc Deletion of International Genome Project WP:N||WP:CORP||WP:NEO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2187 8025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Adams (judge) User:Gene93k 16:16, 8 November 2011 (UTC) delete as . Lacks ongoing RS coverage. Does not pass WP:POLITICIAN as a county judge Deletion of William Adams (judge) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2188 15420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terrible one User:Atrian 12:07, 10 January 2006 (UTC) delete as per Werdna648 doesn't meet notability criteria under Deletion of Terrible one WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2189 21442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bird Neighbors [[User talk:202.124.72.86|talk]]) 08:39, 28 May 2012 (UTC) keep as a notable 19th century American nature classic. There are many, many sources, apart from those in the article. Clear failure of . -- Special:Contributions/202.124.72.86|202.124.72.86 Deletion of Bird Neighbors WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
2190 11271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brad Vigon User:Papaursa 21:17, 7 August 2017 (UTC) delete There's a lack of coverage to meet , which is what he'd need to meet to be a notable coach. His playing career lacks the accomplishments to meet any of the criteria at Deletion of Brad Vigon WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
2191 11023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chakzam User:Lightburst 02:59, 22 January 2020 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Chakzam WP:D Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
2192 5114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diana Pharaoh Francis User:Xxanthippe 22:57, 4 June 2016 (UTC) delete for reative at present. We need multiple independent in-depth reviews to establish notability Deletion of Diana Pharaoh Francis WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
2193 13916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qantas Flight 30 User:Samkass 02:56, 27 July 2008 (UTC) keep Going purely by the guidelines, this accident seems to fall into , which defines what deserves its own article, moreso than , which defines what information should be included on an airlines' page. Thus, the event seems to definitely belong in its own page, and may or may not be appropriate for the Quantas page depending on what comes out of the investigation. In any case, a gaping hole of any size forming spontaneously in the external fuselage of an aircraft seems like an event noteworthy of inclusion even if it becomes a somewhat obscure article (only of interest to researchers) in time. And if it's really as mundane as some posit, it can be deleted later, but at this point I'm convinced it's noteworthy Deletion of Qantas Flight 30 WP:NOTE||WP:AIRLINES Wikipedia:Notability 77
2194 5025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Audra Paquette User:Lemongirl942 03:09, 17 October 2016 (UTC) delete per . We seriously don't have enough sources to write an article. The information is already covered in the respective articles Deletion of Audra Paquette WP:WHYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2195 592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dennis Guma User:GiantSnowman 09:54, 8 September 2011 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Dennis Guma WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2196 4421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Melrose Place (2009 TV series) characters User:Jclemens 02:57, 19 July 2010 (UTC) keep """as PROD decliner. If you look at the List of Melrose Place characters, two things are obvious: 1) this content is primarily unique, and 2) this article is a |summary style breakout of that parent character list. It might be reasonable to merge this content back into the parent article, since """"list of X characters"""" articles seem to generally ignore , just like it might be reasonable to trim the content... but both are editorial decisions and don't need AfD""" Deletion of List of Melrose Place (2009 TV series) characters WP:SS||WP:LENGTH Wikipedia:Summary style 34
2197 18654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wakefield High School (Wakefield, Massachusetts) User:TerriersFan 01:17, 22 June 2007 (UTC) keep contains encyclopaedic content and has the multiple sources to meet Deletion of Wakefield High School (Wakefield, Massachusetts) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2198 13034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hot much User:Stuartyeates 20:56, 23 September 2009 (UTC) delete Apparently fails , and only serious and prolonged work by a linguist could potentially bring it to that standard Deletion of Hot much WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2199 15867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clackamas Town Center Shooting [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 01:05, 12 December 2012 (UTC) delete for now) - we simply don't know what the longer-term might be. Until we can substantiate any effect with |verification from |reliable sources we are just bouncing between and . The result is an article which might very well have been created , but until we know, we just don't know. Let's get rid of it for now but if a longer-term effect can be substantiated then there's nothing wrong with re-creating in in the future Deletion of Clackamas Town Center Shooting WP:EFFECT||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
2200 11990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eduardo Russi Assumpção User:Adamtt9 12:15, 19 April 2017 (UTC) keep meets as he appeared in 3 ATP World Tour level matches. Unsourced but sources can easily be found. Just because he hasn't won, doesn't mean he doesn't fit the notability guideline. If you feel it is too weak, you can start a discussion for stricter guidelines. But as of now, he meets the criteria Deletion of Eduardo Russi Assumpção WP:NTENNIS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2201 21152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Novotel Nathan Road Kowloon Hong Kong User:LibStar 12:29, 27 April 2010 (UTC) delete the keep votes are very weak as they provide zero evidence of significant third party coverage as required for Deletion of Novotel Nathan Road Kowloon Hong Kong WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2202 11762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russiasm User:DonaldDuck 08:15, 12 March 2014 (UTC) delete per Wikipedia:Attack page and Deletion of Russiasm WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
2203 9846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zoran Boškovski User:Future 08:01, 3 August 2009 (UTC) keep now that it's been expanded with sources, it meets with flying colours Deletion of Zoran Boškovski WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2204 20090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sponge Bob errors User:Doc 16:47, 21 August 2009 (UTC) delete """WP:TRIVIA|trivia |cruft. And that's not even going into the |original research and the erm...""""nodisabol"""" spelling errors""" Deletion of Sponge Bob errors WP:CRUFT||WP:OR Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
2205 3104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyber Troopers Virtual On Force User:Captainktainer 16:50, 25 July 2006 (UTC) comment Anything not supported by references is either |original research, a copyright violation, or a hoax, and should either be referenced or deleted by Wikipedia guidelines. The policy on reliable sources and verifiability is ironclad; we can't keep an article if it isn't sourced Deletion of Cyber Troopers Virtual On Force WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2206 126 [[Summery Mind]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Bunnyfrosch NONE keep glücklicherweise legen nicht irgendwelche löschaffinen benutzer fest, welche label hier als ''renomiert'' gelten, vor allem wenn das label 2000 verschiedene tonträger vertreibt. die band ist seit 2008 etabliert 2 LPs und 4 EPs, damit sind die rk (#Musiker punkt 3) übererfüllt. zudem schreiben wir hier nicht das musikmultilexikon, wer das lesen oder haben will kann bei sony und konsorten blättern. schnell Löschung von Summery Mind Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
2207 941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Esquimaux User:WebHamster 19:16, 4 September 2007 (UTC) delete Don't seem to meet in spite of the pregnant breathy vocals. Two EPs and an online album do not an article make (regardless of FTP transfer rates Deletion of Esquimaux WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
2208 4381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarathi International User:Nileena 11:01, 18 January 2007 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of Sarathi International WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2209 2410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dylan Ace User:AllGloryToTheHypnotoad 01:24, 6 August 2007 (UTC) delete per and lack of . Also, it's blatant ; is there a speedy criterion for deleting spam Deletion of Dylan Ace WP:LIVING||WP:RS||WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2210 15184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grant Kay User:Stevietheman 18:06, 10 September 2014 (UTC) comment """I find to be too restrictive in that Triple-A (baseball)|AAA minor league teams operate in major cities and they are considered direct Major League prep factories. That said, this individual plays for a """"Short-Season A"""" team, so he even fails my standard for ''presumed'' baseball notability""" Deletion of Grant Kay WP:NBASEBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2211 14382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Candice Cassidy User:Stifle 08:19, 28 April 2010 (UTC) delete Standard case Deletion of Candice Cassidy WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
2212 8777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khaled Ghassan Youssef [[User talk:70.21.16.94|talk]]) 23:28, 5 November 2010 (UTC) comment Note that the subject, {{User|Khaledyousef}}, has been adding links to their to other articles … I have reverted them and warned them that continued disruptive edits could lead to their being |blocked from editing here. — Special:Contributions/70.21.16.94|70.21.16.94 Deletion of Khaled Ghassan Youssef WP:AUTO||WP:BLOCK Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
2213 12125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soft sell User:Becksguy 18:23, 10 September 2010 (UTC) keep per arguments and P&G noted by Uncle G, and the other keep arguments. Meets and . I would have contested the PROD also, as it isn't a dicdef, but the AfD nomination rationale of SYNTH and OR is not supported by the references Deletion of Soft sell WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2214 2864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pulsatile flow generator User:Mangoe 14:55, 30 August 2017 (UTC) delete per As the nom says, this is a general class of devices (the feds say so), and what we have here is an article hawking one particular design. I'm not even sure the thing is notable on its own, but at any rate the current article is hopelessly promotional Deletion of Pulsatile flow generator WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
2215 20919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Big Fish Games User:Craw 10:15, 4 September 2007 (UTC) keep as it seems to satisfy notability of . If desired, '''Merge''' relevant content to Big Fish Games and '''Redirect''' there Deletion of My Big Fish Games WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2216 916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wendi Knight User:Tarc 22:02, 10 August 2015 (UTC) delete Scene awards to not qualify for , no coverage in independent re;liable sources otherwise Deletion of Wendi Knight WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2217 17239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cruel Sky (novel) User:Spirit 20:24, 12 September 2015 (UTC) comment After further research, I found , a policy which states that “Names not originally in a Latin alphabet, such as Greek, Chinese, or Russian names, must be transliterated” and Wikipedia:Naming conventions (use English)# No established usage in English-language sources, a guideline which notes that its possible for notable subjects to have failed to receive attention in the English speaking world and to not have English names. This should solve any disputes over title and original research. I’ll also admit that I may have previously attempted to force some policies and guidelines that didn’t really fit. However, we now have a title (or an ability to get one) in line with policy for an article with sources whose reliability no one has objected to, and that a keep is the outcome most in-line with Wikipedia policy. Unless anyone has any objections to the above comment, I’ll be withdrawing myself from this AfD in the hopes that cooler heads will step in Deletion of Cruel Sky (novel) WP:TRANSLITERATE Wikipedia:Article titles 75
2218 4993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arctic Monkeys' third studio album User:Stifle 19:12, 13 May 2008 (UTC) delete all X's #th album/single/EP articles. If they don't have an announced name they are an inherent violation of Deletion of Arctic Monkeys' third studio album WP:CBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2219 16183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Factor X (Film) User:Dalejenkins 19:30, 6 August 2008 (UTC) keep Pleanty of reliable sources - http://www.totalfilm.com/movie_news/eric_bana_and_terrence_howard_have_factor_xhttp://www.movieweb.com/news/35/15335.phphttp://www.cinematical.com/2008/06/03/eric-bana-in-talks-for-judd-apatow-adam-sandler-dramedy/. Not a violation of Deletion of Factor X (Film) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2220 6112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Massacre User:Robofish 01:46, 21 February 2011 (UTC) keep at the moment, yes, this article is a bit of a . However, it does have ''some'' information besides the definition, and the fact that books have been written on the subject suggests that it could be expanded into a longer article. (Compare, e.g., Mass suicide.) But I'm sympathetic to those who say such an article would probably end up duplicating Mass murder and List of events named massacres, and if this article can't be expanded it should be merged into one or both of those Deletion of Massacre WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
2221 17146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wanneroo Kartway User:Exit2DOS2000 09:29, 8 October 2010 (UTC) delete untill a |RS can Cite that the Australian National Kart Championships were there. I cannot http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Australian+National+Kart+Championships%22&sa=N&hl=en&tab=nw#q=%22Australian+National+Kart+Championships%22+Wanneroo&hl=en&prmd=iv&ei=TOKuTJ-_GdHPngf_ru2oBg&start=0&sa=N&fp=6248f386b3c06fd8 find it . http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Australian+National+Kart+Championships%22&sa=N&hl=en&tab=nw#sclient=psy&hl=en&q=%22Australian+National+Kart+Championship%22+wanneroo&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=%22Australian+National+Kart+Championship%22+wanneroo&gs_rfai=&pbx=1&fp=6248f386b3c06fd8 Dropping a S makes me think that WP is the only place it says it.Exit2DOS Deletion of Wanneroo Kartway WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2222 1298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Voice (recording artist) [[User talk:68.183.55.64|talk]]) 01:03, 1 January 2009 (UTC) delete subject doesn't come close to meeting requirements of ; blatant advertisement that appears to have been written by the subject or someone associated with her. -- Special:Contributions/68.183.55.64|68.183.55.64 Deletion of Voice (recording artist) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2223 1647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Info Mesa User:Be 04:33, 17 April 2015 (UTC) delete """two unconvincing references in obscure journals for """"many survived""""/""""many died"""" |weasels, two self-published, only one good reference. &ndash""" Deletion of Info Mesa WP:WEASEL Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
2224 10597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noel Agwuocha Chukwukadibia User:Necrothesp 11:34, 11 November 2020 (UTC) keep Appears to meet as a member of a sub-national legislature Deletion of Noel Agwuocha Chukwukadibia WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2225 2611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SoundCloud rap User:Krishna 12:56, 12 October 2017 (UTC) keep The coverage is quite good, passes . Regards Deletion of SoundCloud rap WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2226 10442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anta Plumbing User:Kansiime 17:42, 11 January 2016 (UTC) keep There are no major issues to do with notability of the company. Some improvements or more sources pointing to the problems discussed above in the article itself if such problems exist would be helpful in imrpoving the article. Coverage by third party sites like http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/leah-morrigan/lead-exposure-health-risks_b_5512146.html this and http://www.bbb.org/kitchener/business-reviews/plumbers/anta-plumbing-and-drainage-in-etobicoke-on-1158285 this meet the principle Deletion of Anta Plumbing WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2227 16063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael H Royal User:Otr500 10:02, 19 April 2018 (UTC) delete And Deletion of Michael H Royal WP:BLPREQUESTDELETE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2228 11790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alberta Freedom Party User:Power 00:12, 14 July 2017 (UTC) delete per / Deletion of Alberta Freedom Party WP:TOOSOON||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Too soon 40
2229 14724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people who have been pied (3rd nomination) [[User talk:Treelo|treelo]] [[Special:Contributions/Treelo|radda]] 14:49, 3 October 2008 (UTC) delete """Pieing good. Who gets pied, couldn't give a damn. Fails on the whole """"#INFO|no collection of random garbage which are vaguely related guideline we have""" Deletion of List of people who have been pied (3rd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2230 12306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tunbridge Wells Grammar School for Boys User:Radiopathy 22:46, 2 March 2009 (UTC) keep as discussed above, passes ; continue cleanup Deletion of Tunbridge Wells Grammar School for Boys WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2231 20572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Doe User:Shoessss 21:18, 15 December 2008 (UTC) keep Able to find this http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Confetti%22+-+%22Andrew+Doe%22&sa=N&start=10 with a quick Google News search. Not sure if the piece should be about Andrew Doe |Confetti or Andrew Doe. Likewise, a general Google search showed these results http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&fkt=&fsdt=3372&q=%22Confetti%22+-+%22Andrew+Doe%22&btnG=Google+Search&aq=f&oq=&aqi=Overall, believe he or his company meet the |notability guidelines. Hope this helps Deletion of Andrew Doe Wikipedia:Notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
2232 11304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Symply Tacha User:DESiegel 20:04, 3 December 2019 (UTC) comment I have checked the deleted version as it was just before deletion. It uses the exact same cited sources in the exact same order. I don't think it is byte-for-byte identical, but there is not significant difference between them that i notived. If the first had been deleted by AfD, the second would be a valid G4 speedy in my view. I choose to |assume good faith that this was not a knowing attempt to circumvent the deletion process, but it might as well have been. Predictably, it didn't work . {{U|AndrewNatty}}, the creator of the version now in mainspace, made the overwhelming majority of the edits to the deleted version, and tagged it for deletion under G7, user request. But really, this version should be kept or deleted on its own merits, without regard to the actions of th4e creator or other editors Deletion of Symply Tacha WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
2233 21862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Galaxy Sessions User:DustFormsWords 03:16, 31 May 2010 (UTC) delete Demo or not, it fails the |general notability guidelines, as the article provides no evidence of significant coverage in reliable independent sources, and my good faith searches have failed to uncover any Deletion of Galaxy Sessions WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2234 18023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hallway Tray Sliding User:Sandstein 05:13, 5 April 2006 (UTC) delete textbook Deletion of Hallway Tray Sliding WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
2235 12571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Catterick User:Fenix 09:41, 13 November 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Ryan Catterick WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2236 19005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tux, of Math Command User:Marasmusine 08:08, 30 January 2010 (UTC) keep or '''merge''' to a broader article. Few of the references added qualify as reliable sources; I hope that the contributing editors can review . Of the usable sources, only one represents ''significant'' coverage (Linux Journal) - we would normally ask for more for a standalone article Deletion of Tux, of Math Command WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2237 5845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/They Are Billions User:Zxcvbnm 02:21, 20 December 2017 (UTC) delete As per nom. Popularity =/= notability Deletion of They Are Billions WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
2238 9066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nehemia Bill Solossa User:SatuSuro 09:24, 22 November 2010 (UTC) comment this is one of a large number of BLP and club articles created by the editor - the only constant thread is referring to liga indonesia website as the main source - in most cases articles created by this ed stop at that, and to check for have been in the main non-existent. The expanding out an article to actually show ''aspiration'' rather than participation is quite unusual. The editor has never been seen to use talk, or respond to any queries also. Although there have been other deletions, there seems no sign of response - and at time a very poor grasp of english.(http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=West_Java_provincial_under-23_football_team&action=historysubmit&diff=396695535&oldid=396695497) and possibly not a clear grasp of and . The problem is that if this is a successful deletion - ''there is potentially the problem with all the others'' - maybe someone with a good grasp of specific footy and athletes notability could cast an eye over (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Iha9c) to check that others may have also slipped through Deletion of Nehemia Bill Solossa WP:RS||WP:V||WP:NFOOTY||WP:ATH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2239 13518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iyaaz Jaadulla Naseem User:Iyaaz 11:41, 23 January 2006 (UTC) delete as |vanity Deletion of Iyaaz Jaadulla Naseem WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
2240 5754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paper Blindness User:Deor 14:56, 25 June 2009 (UTC) delete Fails for want of |reliable sources Deletion of Paper Blindness WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2241 20188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Millers User:RadioKirk 18:00, 26 September 2006 (UTC) keep Article needs considerable improvements (at least some of which I've http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Tinlinkin&diff=prev&oldid=77895641 agreed to undertake in the coming days) but, by my standards, is sufficiently—if barely—met within to fail . RadioKirk Deletion of The Millers WP:N||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Notability 77
2242 11149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Age-oriented pornography (2 nomination) User:Jack 05:01, 28 September 2010 (UTC) delete Reads like an essay and has no sources. Fails , , OR Deletion of Age-oriented pornography (2 nomination) WP:N||WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2243 18720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riverside Park Speedway User:Pharmboy 01:17, 28 October 2008 (UTC) keep """The track exists, you can http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O3UatOq1ET8 watch the video on unreliable sources (youtube), gets 8k hits, and likely there was plenty written about it in newspapers. The problem is that if we can't find it in 5 minutes on the web, we assume it isn't notable (I do the same, we all do). The policy on notability says the subject matter must be """"verifiable"""". Not """"verified"""". I would bet my lunch money it can be verified, using newspapers in New England from the 50s. Those are not online. It was a NASCAR track, I am pretty sure it got press, and my confidence that reliable source exist (which is what the policy requires) but will take a while to locate (which is ok, read ). Common sense says it has to be notable, even though I have never heard of it before, so I have to vote keep. In short, show me one NOT notable track running NASCAR, and I might change my mind""" Deletion of Riverside Park Speedway WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:There is no deadline 35
2244 9679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abneet Bharti (2nd nomination) User:GiantSnowman 11:37, 6 December 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Abneet Bharti (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2245 9615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unit 4 Agresso User:Sleepyhead81 09:39, 10 July 2006 (UTC) keep Agresso is a large and well-known company - refer to orp. The article needs extensive cleanup though as it currently reads as an advertisement Deletion of Unit 4 Agresso WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
2246 20684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tmbax User:Forest90 13:56, 3 June 2019 (UTC) delete the article because it's not notable itself and also clearly does not meet or , as your description say Deletion of Tmbax WP:GNG||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2247 20978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Live at La Cigale User:Gongshow 20:30, 15 August 2011 (UTC) delete I'm not finding any coverage for this release, at least not in English sources; does not appear to meet unless there's something significant and reliable http://www.google.com/search?aq=f&hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws&btnmeta_news_search=1&q=placebo+%22live+at+la+cigale%22#q=placebo+%22live+at+la+cigale%22&hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws&source=lnt&tbs=ar:1&sa=X&ei=toJJTp0FpOGIAo6ggP4G&ved=0CA8QpwUoBQ&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.&fp=59cc0868fe6a1b43&biw=1229&bih=519 here, for example Deletion of Live at La Cigale WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2248 6824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Batman's career timeline User:Frank 11:58, 9 September 2008 (UTC) delete """because although it's well-researched, it's... | original research. The sources are the comics themselves; this is not reporting on anything verifiable. It is drawing its own conclusions and reporting plot directly from the source. I'm going with """"weak"""" because I hate to toss away someone's work so cavalierly...but it is not in line with policy""" Deletion of Batman's career timeline WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2249 12100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lancaster Opera Company [[User talk:Ravenswing|''' '' Ravenswing '' ''' ]] 13:36, 26 July 2020 (UTC) delete """Fails the GNG, WP:ORG. No coverage beyond local small-town weekly papers, and thus fails . In examining the three links posted above, the first is a casual mention, the second is a piece in the aforementioned small town weekly, and the third is a namedrop consisting of """"Berks Opera Company presents this heartwarming story for children of all ages in collaboration with OperaLancaster""" Deletion of Lancaster Opera Company WP:AUD Wikipedia:Notability 77
2250 18379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Osman Uyanık User:Argyle 07:57, 1 September 2010 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Osman Uyanık WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2251 12492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heavy Snowfall of Late 2010 in the United Kingdom User:Bearian 21:56, 2 December 2010 (UTC) keep major weather events |generally are kept. Still ongoing, people may yet die because of it Deletion of Heavy Snowfall of Late 2010 in the United Kingdom WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
2252 19053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammed Farhan User:onel5969 02:20, 24 September 2015 (UTC) delete searches did not reveal anything to show they meet or Deletion of Mohammed Farhan WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2253 18278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Escape Together World Tour User:Esradekan 23:37, 4 April 2009 (UTC) delete a non-notable tour that fails to satisfy the |general notability guideline with significant coverage in |reliable, third-party, sources Deletion of Escape Together World Tour WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2254 12139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Davis (county clerk) User:Nomader 00:22, 3 September 2015 (UTC) keep """I understand the nominator's concerns about , but I think it's pretty obvious that Kim Davis herself is now getting coverage that's beyond the scope of rule 3, which says """"If the event is not significant or the individual's role was either not substantial or not well documented."""" It's pretty obvious that her role is significant and well documented. The Guardian has written an article about her history leading up to becoming a clerk (http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/sep/02/kentucky-clerk-kim-davis-divorced-three-times) and there's been coverage comparing this to the schoolhouse stand. I think that's well beyond the requirements to keep""" Deletion of Kim Davis (county clerk) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2255 8576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicole Kortlüke [[User talk:2001:4DD1:E5CF:0:804C:3C25:C6AE:301B|talk]]) 14:49, 6 December 2019 (UTC) keep """Unfortunately, I am not so familiar with the rules of English Wikipedia. However, I have expanded the article. I hope I could show evidence for the relevance of this in Germany known film editor. I refer in particular to point 3 here: """"The person has created or played a major role in co-creating a significant or well-known work or collective body of work."""" --Special:Contributions/2001:4DD1:E5CF:0:804C:3C25:C6AE:301B|2001:4DD1:E5CF:0:804C:3C25:C6AE:301B""" Deletion of Nicole Kortlüke WP: FILMMAKER Wikipedia:Notability 77
2256 51 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Philippine network television schedule (2nd nomination) User:Howard_the_Duck 13:13, 11 April 2013 (UTC) delete """I'm not sure about the legitimacy of TV schedules here in general (see also Lists of United States network television schedules and Lists of Canadian network television schedules for more examples) but this one definitely fails . Not only is it unreferenced, being """"effective from 6 December 2010"""" means it only runs for less than 4 weeks in 2010""" Deletion of 2010 Philippine network television schedule (2nd nomination) WP:NOTTVGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2257 12764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hugh Atkin User:MichaelQSchmidt 01:10, 3 March 2009 (UTC) keep and tag for expansion per the additional available sources, as being more than one-event and no need by some (no offense) to treat Australia as if it were a |backwater, as http://news.google.com/archivesearch?ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Hugh+Atkin%22&um=1 coverage by their press about one of their citizens for an initial and sunseqhent actions as good enough Deletion of Hugh Atkin WP:CSB Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
2258 15185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ShopInterest User:LM2000 06:04, 14 January 2014 (UTC) delete I don't see this passing Deletion of ShopInterest WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2259 19333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Homo Spaciens User:Catfish 16:37, 23 November 2010 (UTC) delete WP:OR Deletion of Homo Spaciens WP:MADEUP||WP:NOTESSAY||WP:BALL Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
2260 6252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Flynn (British Army soldier) User:RetroCraft314 22:44, 4 June 2018 (UTC) delete per nom. There are no |independent, |reliable sources that I could find. The sources used in the article are all either |primary sources that simply acknowledge his existence, by no means |significant coverage. Clear fail of . < Deletion of William Flynn (British Army soldier) WP:IS||WP:RS||WP:PRIMARY||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2261 16671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NBA MVP 2005 User:Coredesat 22:47, 23 June 2006 (UTC) merge anything useful into Steve Nash, '''delete''' the rest. Fails Deletion of NBA MVP 2005 WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2262 3921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virgil W. Magee (second nomination) User:Carlosguitar 02:12, 28 September 2007 (UTC) delete non-|notable person Deletion of Virgil W. Magee (second nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2263 21770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/X.X.X. Live NONE NONE keep Meets . Source examples include, but are not limited to those listed below Deletion of X.X.X. Live WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2264 8660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcus Foligno NONE NONE keep This article started as a redirect before it was expanded into an article, and it should revert back to a redirect if he is not yet notable, however Marcus Foligno passes as demonstrated by the significant and non-routine coverage he has received in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, including Deletion of Marcus Foligno WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2265 218 [[78plus]] (LAE) 193.81.222.36|193.81.222.36 14:02, 25. Jul. 2015 (CEST) keep Die |Relevanzkriterien sagen eindeutig das ein Album auf einem relevantem Label ausreicht - dies ist hier gegeben. Weiteres gibt es einen Eintrag auf allmusic.com es fehlt nur an Hintergrundinformationen zur Band. Theoriefindung ist es auf keinen Fall da unter den Weblinks im Artikel alle Informationen zu finden sind. Löschung von 78plus Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2266 267 [[Albert-Anker-Loge Aarberg]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers NONE delete Kasten|1= gemäß Diskussion. Keine ausreichende Relevanz nach #Vereine, Verbände und Bürgerinitiativen dargestellt. Keine Literaturtreffer, Google-Treffer sehr durchschaubar, letztlich reine Binnensicht statt dargestellte öffentliche Wahrnehmung. Gruß Löschung von Albert-Anker-Loge Aarberg Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2267 19407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Capricorn (manga) User:Quasirandom 19:16, 3 June 2008 (UTC) keep Although not documented as such, it has been the concensus in the past of WikiProject Anime and Manga that, given the status of OVAs in Japan, an anime adaptation is equivalent to a theatrical or television release for the purposes of C5. Between that and the NYT notice provided above, this two convince me this is indeed a notable manga per our guidelines Deletion of Capricorn (manga) WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2268 11659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Truth About Muhammad: Founder of the World's Most Intolerant Religion User:Tarinth 19:38, 9 January 2007 (UTC) keep the author is already a NY Times Bestseller, any new books he writes are going to be notable by extension. (Compare to which states that all the alumbs of a notable band are considered notable...I don't see the difference here Deletion of The Truth About Muhammad: Founder of the World's Most Intolerant Religion WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
2269 3441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dynamic counterbary [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 21:18, 12 September 2006 (UTC) delete per . Article is completely unsourced Deletion of Dynamic counterbary WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2270 9502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rabia Salihu Sa'id User:Grand 08:45, 17 December 2016 (UTC) keep """I agree she may only be """"an average academic"""" based on her publications, but she obviously meets and based on sources (BBC, NPR, Nature, Elsevier). Also, the article has been substantially improved since it the AFD nomination, making the case for keeping it even stronger""" Deletion of Rabia Salihu Sa'id WP:GNG||WP:PEOPLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2271 16068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mag Wheels (film) User:Atlantic306 00:13, 21 March 2017 (UTC) keep as allmovie and AFI sources allow a pass of Deletion of Mag Wheels (film) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2272 15121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria (Counting Crows) User:Newslinger 19:10, 29 July 2018 (UTC) delete Not notable. Doesn't meet . Insufficient coverage from reliable sources. The HuffPost article is the closest one approaching significant coverage, but I can't find any others that give more than passing mentions. — Deletion of Maria (Counting Crows) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2273 17400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor Steel (2nd nomination) User:Histrion 12:52, 9 September 2009 (UTC) keep """arguably meets criteria 1, 7, and 10 (in part due to the ''Dr Horrible'' tussle). I do think the """"Media Attention"""" section of the article needs some serious clean-up, as right now it seems to exist purely as a defensive act against those who insist on the artist's non-notability, but that's a side issue""" Deletion of Doctor Steel (2nd nomination) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
2274 20559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loci Controls User:Chrislk02 18:55, 22 May 2015 (UTC) keep """As the author of most of the content in the article) I found a request at the teahouse after speedy deleting it . I looked into it and definitely consider popular science to be a , so I undeleted, did some research, found some citations. A google search found several other that I added in. The 25% part was meant to be part of an """"assertion of notability"""", and not promotional""" Deletion of Loci Controls WP:A7||WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
2275 13109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pleasuredisc Records User:Dennisthe2 05:15, 14 June 2012 (UTC) delete on account of . They appear to be a new label just what I'm seeing. A bit spammy in my opinion, and I'd be inclined for db-corp Deletion of Pleasuredisc Records WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
2276 3467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of Rogue User:Whiteguru 06:25, 20 September 2020 (UTC) merge to Rogue (comics)|Rogue per writing about Fiction. Should have been summmarized Deletion of Alternative versions of Rogue WP:WAF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
2277 4928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Let's Go Sailing (band) User:Shell_Kinney 03:12, 22 October 2008 (UTC) keep Needs better sourcing, but both the Grey's Anatomy mention and the backup on a national tour mentions seem to indicate they pass Deletion of Let's Go Sailing (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2278 6520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Kassel User:Cunard 22:44, 1 December 2009 (UTC) keep """The sources provided by Nfitz establish that Matt Kassel passes / . Kessel fails but this does not matter when he passes . As {{user|Davewild}} http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia%3AArticles_for_deletion%2FBob_Poe&action=historysubmit&diff=328242624&oldid=328237546 wrote at another AfD, """"The general notability guideline supersedes any subject specific guidelines."""" Wikipedia:Notability (people) (which encompasses ) says that """"A person is presumed notable if he or she has been the subject of published secondary source material which is reliable, intellectually independent, and independent of the subject."""" Kassel has clearly received this coverage.See http://soccernet.espn.go.com/columns/story?id=530064&root=mls&cc=5901 this article from ESPN (titled ''Youth product Kassel looks to have bright prospects''; this article is over 10 paragraphs long), http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/08/28/AR2008082803311.html this article from the ''Washington Post'' (titled ''Recruit Kassel Joins the Terps, At Least for Now''; this article is also over 10 paragraphs long), and http://74.125.155.132/search?q=cache:vQ849W0uu-QJ:www.nypost.com/p/blogs/soccerblog/item_6CWKcBlWbPWYKpa2OcjLbO+%22Matt+Kassel%22+source:%22-newswire%22+source:%22-wire%22+source:%22-presswire%22+source:%22-PR%22+source:%22-press%22+source:%22-release%22+source:%22-wikipedia%22&cd=10&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us this article from the ''New York Post'' (titled ''RBNY's Matt Kassel staying at Maryland''; this article is six paragraphs long). Notability is fully established due to the extent of coverage""" Deletion of Matt Kassel WP:GNG||WP:BIO||WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2279 21901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WE Youth Political organization User:Osli73 16:26, 13 December 2007 (UTC) delete non-notable with , and violations Deletion of WE Youth Political organization WP:SOAP||WP:POV||:WP:OWN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2280 7586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Obopay User:MelanieN 15:51, 25 March 2013 (UTC) delete and '''Salt'''. Completely agree with nominator's analysis of the sources in the article. On a search of Google News, I found one article of significant coverage at http://www.businessweek.com/stories/2009-12-07/obopay-turns-mobile-phones-into-banksbusinessweek-business-news-stock-market-and-financial-advice Business Week. Other items that look at first glance like significant coverage turned out to be press releases, such as http://www.reuters.com/article/2009/10/28/idUS94108+28-Oct-2009+PRN20091028 this one published by (and disavowed by) Reuters. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws&q=obopay&oq=obopay&gs_l=news-cc.3..43j43i53.2627.3347.0.5322.6.2.0.0.0.0.837.837.6-1.1.0...0.0...1ac.1.y8NLZQe7OMo#q=obopay&hl=en&gl=us&tbs=ar:1&tbm=nws&ei=m3BQUeuXEcnU2AWBz4CQCw&start=0&sa=N&bav=on.2,or.r_qf.&bvm=bv.44158598,d.b2I&fp=6cf242f5e722bf22&biw=1148&bih=670 Google News Archive turns up a few passing mentions in Reliable Sources like http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-03-18/orascom-s-burundi-unit-to-start-mobile-banking-to-add-customers.html Bloomberg. Bottom line, a single article in Business Week plus some passing mentions and press releases do not amount to significant coverage in multiple independent reliable sources, and this subject does not pass Deletion of Obopay WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2281 10878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Second Chinatown (disambiguation) User:Whpq 14:52, 19 June 2013 (UTC) keep """as an """"|ignore all rules"""" disambiguation page. Although none of the linked articles have the name """"Second Chinatown"""" to disambiguate, there entries are all secondary Chinatowns. This page serves as a navigation aid for readers who may be looking for an article on the second Chinatown in some city but do not know the name. As such Wikipedia is improved by providing this navigation aid""" Deletion of Second Chinatown (disambiguation) WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
2282 9952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Waka Laka User:Esradekan 14:47, 17 June 2008 (UTC) merge non-notable song, merge to Jenny Rom per Deletion of Waka Laka WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2283 14072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Studypool User:OnionRing 19:21, 14 June 2016 (UTC) delete """the two TechCrunch articles don't seem like press releases, and there's a tiny paragraph about them in the Chicago Tribune, but that's not really """"significant coverage from multiple reliable, secondary sources"""", so it looks like this doesn't quite make yet""" Deletion of Studypool WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2284 12870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bader tv User:Dewritech 09:01, 5 June 2012 (UTC) delete spam, mainly composed by one |SPA, GNews: zero Deletion of Bader tv WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
2285 11093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aamer Bhatti (cricketer, born 1972) User:Lugnuts 13:56, 18 January 2021 (UTC) keep meets . Ten days ago Deletion of Aamer Bhatti (cricketer, born 1972) WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2286 11750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Physioalphabet User:Red 13:40, 12 July 2019 (UTC) delete While a PAGEDECIDE application and the creation of a permanent stub is an option, if we don't have sources to establish notability now, when would we? This was done in 1994; it's not something that's currently ongoing. As it stands, we don't have it now, and I'm not finding any reliable secondary sources in a search Deletion of Physioalphabet WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
2287 21788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Political kidnapping User:Bearian 15:44, 13 October 2020 (UTC) keep per . While it can be vastly improved, it's a decent start, and has been in the news lately Deletion of Political kidnapping WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2288 1365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hattie B's Hot Chicken User:Otr500 10:45, 9 December 2017 (UTC) delete """I saw the listing here and clicked on the article before reading these comments. I was surely going to !vote """"keep"""" because it is referenced with """"Time"""", """"Sports Illustrated"""", """"USA Today"""", """"Washington Post"""", ''and'' """"National Geographic"""" among others, so that is a wrap right? I came back here, read the """"keep"""" !vote comment of """"Northamerica1000"""", with all the reasoning why the article should remain, and it was still a wrap. '''Then''', I read the comments of SwisterTwister, and reread the article. '''OMG! It is the best advertising article Wikipedia could present'''. Just read (or reread) the fantastic |advertising """"Reception"""" section. I want some of that chicken. Take a look at the guideline concerning Wikipedia:Spam|spam, the lack of Wikipedia:Neutral point of view|neutrality, and the rationale (such as great national advertising) for any """"keep"""" !votes are buried beneath several WP:policies and guidelines|policies and guidelines that mandate deletion. This article is so good I still think I would like to try the chicken, but that is probably a red flag also""" Deletion of Hattie B's Hot Chicken WP:NOTADVERTISING Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2289 14355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Piers Robinson User:Ed6767 14:36, 27 May 2020 (UTC) keep per all above. Maybe AfD is , but probably too early to call Deletion of Piers Robinson WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
2290 7599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cliffhanger endings (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 07:20, 17 August 2012 (UTC) delete because this list fails , and has an inclusion criteria that is too broad Deletion of List of cliffhanger endings (2nd nomination) WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2291 9067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of instrumental songs User:Themfromspace 01:37, 5 December 2009 (UTC) delete too vague of a criteria for inclusion () makes any attempt at a list to be laughably incomplete. I'd say this is too wide for a category even Deletion of List of instrumental songs WP:SALAT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
2292 20731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Burns User:Sportzeditz 14:36, 6 September 2020 (UTC) keep Passes , see sources above Deletion of Jordan Burns WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2293 16572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TaskY User:Awesome 20:35, 24 March 2021 (UTC) comment Tagged for speedying by Deletion of TaskY WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
2294 20499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mithra Siriwardena (2nd nomination) User:Dan 05:18, 11 December 2017 (UTC) comment In relation to U|Otr500's comments above - #1 - Obit and #2 - Obit are exactly the same, the first is the HighBeam link to the Daily News obit, which simply confirms that he played schoolboy cricket, joined the police force, was a DIG, retired and died. #3 - Obit is an obituary prepared by a schoolboy friend and close friend of the family and therefore fails . Conclude with Otr500's comments about the current references, as above Deletion of Mithra Siriwardena (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2295 14404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Louis Torres [[User talk:PeaceNT|''P''ea]][[Special:Contributions/PeaceNT|ceNT]] 17:13, 2 March 2007 (UTC) delete per above, obviously fails and Deletion of Louis Torres WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2296 13974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of CEP vendors User:Bardcom 01:29, 29 January 2008 (UTC) delete """List is valid. It does not violate #INTERNET as it is not acting as an internet guide for a website. It is a valid list of vendors of CEP technology. It is in line with existing lists, for example List of IT Service Management vendors and List of ERP vendors as pointed out earlier - for more lists, check out the ''':Category:Lists_of_companies_by_industry''' for example. It does not violate#REPOSITORY as it is a separate article, just like the other """"list of"""" pages. It also helps to keep the encyclopedic nature and tone of the original CEP article""" Deletion of List of CEP vendors WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2297 17252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Force lightning User:Eusebeus NONE delete per the various arguments above. |Not-notable, OT, etc.... — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Force lightning WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2298 21705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2001 White House shooting User:Carrite 01:12, 3 June 2014 (UTC) delete I find SoE's argument above to be compelling Deletion of 2001 White House shooting WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2299 13991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernard Morris User:BQZip01 23:32, 18 November 2008 (UTC) keep """ok a bit of overkill there, but you get the point). This particular person explicitly meets the criteria in which state """"Competitors who have competed at the highest level in amateur sports."""" The quarterback for a team is inherently the highest position for an athlete on a football team""" Deletion of Bernard Morris WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2300 8857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Full Armor of God Broadcast User:Dougweller 12:37, 17 May 2009 (UTC) delete """I see no evidence that it meets ''Wikipedia's'' notability criteria which I agree are those at . I see a lot of misunderstanding of our criteria (or just plain ignoring our criteria) from people who want """"to continue having this website up as a way to share info about the show, and to share our ministry work"""" and to give """"the devil a black eye on Wikipedia"""" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Limetom#Full_Armor_of_God_Broadcast_2 which also shows a basic misunderstanding of what Wikipedia is. The fact that it reads almost purely like an advertising page and that at least some editor's see it as a website for the program reflects its lack of notability with no significant coverage by reliable third party sources""" Deletion of Full Armor of God Broadcast WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2301 11288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Westgate Resorts User:Nishkid64 18:31, 17 September 2006 (UTC) keep 7,000 employees and you say it's not-notable? It's a worldwide company. It definitely passes . The company's website has an Alexa web traffic ranking of 158,306, which does seem like a respectable ranking for a company website Deletion of Westgate Resorts WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2302 17130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Persons related to Qur'anic verses User:Schizombie 00:49, 17 March 2006 (UTC) delete and merge content—if properly verified—either to Qur'an or to the articles for the Suras in which the people are mentioned. is a must. Relative importance of being mentioned in the Qur'an might also be addressed Deletion of Persons related to Qur'anic verses WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2303 3606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Relationship between Tyranny and Arms Control User:Finngall 20:23, 23 August 2016 (UTC) delete """I could see that this was shaping up to be a massive wall of |original research, but in the interest of |assuming good faith I tried moving it to draft space where the author could work on it at their leisure. But given that the author is persisting in working in mainspace (apparently because ), I have to evaluate the article as it is, and at best it is simply not ready for prime time. And while I tend (sometimes to a fault) to stick with assessing the ''current'' state of an article as opposed to what ''will'' be there or what ''could'' be there, it doesn't look promising for all the reasons given by the """"delete"""" !voters above""" Deletion of The Relationship between Tyranny and Arms Control WP:OR||WP:AGF||WP:ITSIMPORTANT Wikipedia:No original research 65
2304 7117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twisted Ear User:Flakeloaf 15:13, 18 January 2007 (UTC) delete Much of the content serves asserts the entry's notability without describe the article's subject; without those paragraphs this would almost certainly be a successful |prod candidate. If this AfD nomination is to fail, someone will need to add some information that explicitly describes the subject and implies notability instead of the other way around. Additionally, Guy's concern appears to be well-founded Deletion of Twisted Ear WP:PROD||WP:COI Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
2305 15168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nada Herman-Witkamp User:Netherzone 01:29, 23 February 2021 (UTC) delete I'm not finding any indication that this is a notable artist whose credentials match our criteria for nor . Written in a non-encyclopedic promtional tone which does not help Deletion of Nada Herman-Witkamp WP:NARTIST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2306 16912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Food Matters (2nd nomination) User:onel5969 13:01, 8 January 2016 (UTC) keep With the sources provided by Northamerica1000 and duffbeerforme, passes Deletion of Food Matters (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2307 11786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ProStudioApp User:Aleksa 15:57, 21 November 2013 (UTC) delete not notable, no |reliable sources, pure promotion Deletion of ProStudioApp WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2308 16695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GAR meme User:danntm 22:24, 3 March 2007 (UTC) delete as a |neologism without any |attribution to support it's importance Deletion of GAR meme WP:NEO||WP:ATT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
2309 13822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evan Davis (actor) User:Scjessey 12:06, 20 August 2008 (UTC) delete per |lack of notability and the fact that it is essentially an |autobiography co-written with |meat puppets. There are serious |conflicts of interest in this and related articles Deletion of Evan Davis (actor) WP:NN||WP:AUTOBIO||WP:MEAT||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
2310 3350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ocean's Thirteen User:155 02:42, 19 January 2007 (UTC) keep Completion or not it has obvious notibility and is well known. Also don't fail . Also it is rather standard that famous sequals to almost any series get accepted because they are inheretly notable (look at Harry Potter books and movies for example, sometimes started years before release Deletion of Ocean's Thirteen WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
2311 6736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nebraska in the Elite Eight User:Isotope23 18:15, 14 March 2006 (UTC) delete per as crystalballism... almost makes you want to go Speedy Deletion of Nebraska in the Elite Eight WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2312 7207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of notable Star Wars substances User:Erik 15:20, 15 September 2015 (UTC) delete per since there do not seem to be reliable sources listing items under this specific topic. I could see certain substances from this fictional universe being mentioned in broader-scope list articles if sources do exist, but this particular scope does not appear justified Deletion of List of notable Star Wars substances WP:NOTESAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2313 2126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/And that's a good thing User:HelenDegenerate 00:08, 30 July 2021 (UTC) delete I concur with the nominator-- none of the sources cited actually discussed the phrase, all they did was use the phrase. Fails Deletion of And that's a good thing WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2314 8750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Fighter (film) User:Steve 19:28, 2 July 2008 (UTC) delete fails |notability as there is no indication this will even be made Deletion of The Fighter (film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2315 11355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samidh mukerjee User:Sparklism 11:00, 2 February 2015 (UTC) keep per the coverage detailed above, which meets and Deletion of Samidh mukerjee WP:N||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2316 3353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fractyl User:Shooterwalker 16:33, 21 September 2010 (UTC) delete lack of sources to . Needs third-party sources, not primary sources and unreliable sources Deletion of Fractyl WP:verify notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
2317 9935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christina Linhardt User:Wm335td 22:14, 2 January 2020 (UTC) keep WP:NORUSH and NEXIST (reliable sources exist even if not in the article) https://skopemag.com/2008/04/14/christina-linhardt-voodoo-princess-takes-us-on-a-journey Here is one that a loose necktie found. Subject of a https://music.usc.edu/christina-linhardts-documentary-gets-picked-up-by-amazon/ documentary. Deletion of Christina Linhardt WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
2318 5597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wellesley College Senate bus User:The 21:07, 4 September 2013 (UTC) keep Notability may be tenuous, but it's there and it |isn't temporary Deletion of Wellesley College Senate bus WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2319 15509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naved Ahmed (Lahore cricketer) User:DevaCat1 17:31, 26 February 2021 (UTC) keep the article clearly needs improvement, and to take out all of the Cricket Archive links. However, the article also clearly passes by virtue of Naved having played in three List A matches. As usual for cricketers, is not the relevant standard Deletion of Naved Ahmed (Lahore cricketer) WP:CRIN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2320 21265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/We Made It User:Reyk 21:51, 13 December 2008 (UTC) delete this article has no sources and there is no evidence of real-world impact (insert joke about crash landings here). That's probably why the article contains nothing but |plot summary written in an |in-universe style Deletion of We Made It WP:PLOT||WP:INUNIVERSE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2321 621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MediaMan (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep Due to the following reviews, I believe it passes and Deletion of MediaMan (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NWEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2322 2811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marion Lee Kempner User:The 20:23, 29 December 2017 (UTC) delete Does not meet either or ; notability is |not inherited from the fact a segment of an anthology mentioned his writing home. A man who served his country and sadly did not come home, but |Wikipedia is not a memorial Deletion of Marion Lee Kempner WP:GNG||WP:SOLDIER||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2323 3396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Integral yoga User:ජපස 11:22, 10 June 2021 (UTC) keep and perhaps promote to a main article to grow past the current domination of Integral theory (Ken Wilber) which is, for example, to what integral philosophy redirects. I have become convinced looking at the various sources which discuss Sri Aurobindo that integral yoga and Sri Aurobindo's philosophy are actually ''more'' influential in New Age circles than Ken Wilber's work. See California Institute of Integral Studies for an example of a thriving New Age community built around this tradition. Yes, it is ... but it appears to me to be . I don't think this is a situation here, to be honest Deletion of Integral yoga WP:FRINGE||WP:NFRINGE||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
2324 3863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meggan Scavio User:scope_creep 12:12, 21 August 2021 (UTC) keep More than enough to satisfy and clearly notable enough for Deletion of Meggan Scavio WP:SIGCOV||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2325 16566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haluskein User:A1octopus 11:18, 16 April 2007 (UTC) delete and then hopefully it won't come back again. Article fails and Deletion of Haluskein WP:M||WP:V Wikipedia:Mediation 96
2326 8509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phillip Reilly User:Angelo 08:43, 9 September 2008 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of Phillip Reilly WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2327 8281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nikki Jayne User:Ifnord 17:50, 30 July 2018 (UTC) delete per nom, not meeting Deletion of Nikki Jayne WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2328 19601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chief Surgeon Who? User:Ikip 15:35, 15 May 2009 (UTC) keep there is no this should have been discussed on List_of_M*A*S*H_episodes_(Season_1) first. There is little basis to have this article to be removed from wikipedia, has failed to become a guideline three times, and is currently under an intense edit war Deletion of Chief Surgeon Who? WP:DEADLINE||WP:FICT||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:There is no deadline 35
2329 5676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mounao Thoibi User:onel5969 12:57, 8 December 2015 (UTC) delete was waiting to see if there was any improvement. I can't find anything to help, and in its current state doesn't pass Deletion of Mounao Thoibi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2330 1953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad Bahareth (2nd nomination) User:Crh23 08:08, 22 April 2016 (UTC) delete can't find anything to assert |notability, nor anything to pass . Since most of the search hits are about his books, I'll mention that he doesn't appear meet AUTHOR either. — Deletion of Mohammad Bahareth (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:ANYBIO||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2331 20701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Along for the Ride (tour) User:K 01:30, 3 February 2018 (UTC) merge to Dream_Theater#Tours; not independently notable. Lacks for a stand-alone article Deletion of Along for the Ride (tour) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
2332 466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Hernandez (intern) User:Fetchcomms 20:11, 16 January 2011 (UTC) delete Most obvious case of I have seen in 2011 Deletion of Daniel Hernandez (intern) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2333 16409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Urban bible [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 06:11, 3 February 2009 (UTC) delete You've heard of |spam, right? now this is the deletion of spam!'' Thou shalt not spam the hallowed pages of Wikipedia Deletion of Urban bible WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
2334 18756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Motley's Crew (August 28, 1997) User:GentlemanGhost 01:25, 15 March 2013 (UTC) delete Uh, wow. I know that Wikipedia is |not paper, but come on! Decidedly non-notable and lacking in |secondary sources Deletion of Motley's Crew (August 28, 1997) WP:NOTPAPER||WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2335 16972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HMS Richmond helicopter crash User:Stalwart111 07:49, 3 September 2014 (UTC) delete """as the spokesperson said - ''""""as far as we are aware, there is no issue of safety with the Lynx or indication about defects which could be proven in other aircraft""""''. No impact on the industry or even that line of aircraft in the context of that service. Tragic, but it fails """ Deletion of HMS Richmond helicopter crash WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2336 4455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mule (slang) User:BillC 00:27, 2 May 2006 (UTC) comment """It's not even in Urban Dictionary. You can add it there if you like, though you should understand that that action would make no difference to this debate, as Wikipedia does not recognise Urban Dictionary as a |reliable source. If you want to save this entry, what is required is some well-sourced usages: is a syndicated columist using it in a respected newspaper, for example? If, as someone on this page has claimed, it is a word or sign that """"only hundreds know"""", forget it, it's neither |notable, OT|encyclopaedic nor |reliably sourced""" Deletion of Mule (slang) WP:RS||WP:N||WP:NOT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2337 15317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TweetBot User:Monty845 01:15, 22 May 2012 (UTC) keep With the added references the subject appears to pass . Advertising concerns, to the extent they have not already been addressed can be handle through normal editing Deletion of TweetBot WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2338 1280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All Caps (band) User:A 19:49, 10 April 2011 (UTC) comment """It would seem that the most common rationale for keeping the All Caps article from the """"Do Not Delete"""" !voters is that they are extensively covered by media outside the """"mainstream"""". While this may or may not be true, the advantage that mainstream media has over, say, blogs or YouTube is that it is generally more reliable and trustworthy, due to its rigorous fact-checking and editorial oversight. We need to use only reliable, third-party sources on Wikipedia to make sure that what we are publishing is verifiably accurate. Anybody can edit, for example, Last.fm and alter it to say whatever they want it to, hence why we can't use http://www.last.fm/music/All+Caps to determine notability. Also, having over 26,000 YouTube subscribers doesn't in and of itself make a band notable, per . It should perhaps also be noted that a large number of the """"Do Not Delete"""" !voters have made few or no contributions outside this AfD""" Deletion of All Caps (band) WP:BIGNUMBER Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2339 1759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juli Briskman User:TJRC 00:17, 7 November 2019 (UTC) delete Non-notable, not even for the one event. Do not redirect to NANA Development Corporation; the comment in that article is . I'd remove it, but not while this is under discussion. See also Wikipedia:Redirects for discussion/Log/2017 November 29#Juli Briskman|this RFD from 2017 Deletion of Juli Briskman WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
2340 20039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yamate Gakusha User:ToThAc 20:54, 24 September 2017 (UTC) delete Absolutely no references, and nothing to prove that it isn't a |hoax. (I'm, of course, not saying that it IS a hoax, just that it seems likely Deletion of Yamate Gakusha WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
2341 14126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Intelligent Investor (Company) User:Inother 19:33, 31 March 2015 (UTC) delete Does not meet the |general notability guideline Deletion of Intelligent Investor (Company) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2342 14904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timeline of the 2014 Crimean crisis User:Spirit 06:24, 5 March 2014 (UTC) keep The article is on an ongoing event, so its obviously going to read a bit like a news report. This is an issue that can | be fixed through editing Deletion of Timeline of the 2014 Crimean crisis WP:AFDNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2343 1752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Kolb User:Thryduulf 22:56, 9 October 2006 (UTC) delete """no evidence presented why he is more notable than any other college football player. The article effectively even says """"we wont know how good he is until this game in the future"""", which is crystal ballism (|Wikipedia is not a crystal ball""" Deletion of Kevin Kolb WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2344 2910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tishting User:Blue520 15:24, 5 May 2006 (UTC) delete seems to be a neologism , also unverifiable Deletion of Tishting WP:NEO||WP:V Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
2345 8050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Edge 101 User:Metropolitan90 03:17, 1 July 2006 (UTC) delete per nomination. I can find no evidence that this Internet radio station satisfies criteria Deletion of The Edge 101 WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2346 8265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zuma: Tales of a Sexual Gladiator User:MichaelQSchmidt 23:32, 29 September 2015 (UTC) delete for failing . Ignoring the |content, I gave the article https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Zuma%3A_Tales_of_a_Sexual_Gladiator&type=revision&diff=683385582&oldid=682627683 a facelift but was unable to find enough coverage in reliable sources to meet inclusion criteria. ''IF'' an acceptable article is written on the rather unique PornoMation series, this can be spoken of therein Deletion of Zuma: Tales of a Sexual Gladiator WP:NF||WP:NOTCENSORED Wikipedia:Notability 77
2347 20184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greater Quad Cities User:Snotbot 02:46, 4 April 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 April 4 Deletion of Greater Quad Cities WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
2348 21741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jill Mortimer User:Ser 00:35, 31 March 2021 (UTC) delete Fails as only coverage is informing us she's standing, not notable outside being a candidate Deletion of Jill Mortimer WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2349 4452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darwin kummins User:Arendedwinter 09:03, 24 October 2007 (UTC) delete Per above and also author admitted it's |made-up Deletion of Darwin kummins WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
2350 15306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benoit family tragedy User:Resolute 22:44, 8 July 2007 (UTC) merge there is no reason why this information cannot remain at Chris Benoit. Brutal case of |recentism and an unnecessary article Deletion of Benoit family tragedy WP:RECENT Wikipedia:Recentism 10
2351 6837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World of Warcraft Professions User:MLauba 13:42, 13 March 2009 (UTC) delete WP:NOTGUIDE and , content is already present and maintained at http://www.wowwiki.com/Profession wowiki, and last, per Deletion of World of Warcraft Professions WP:TRIVIA||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
2352 12008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ringleader Man User:BlueSquadronRaven 21:45, 20 May 2009 (UTC) delete There is simply nothing to these articles, or these songs, apparently. No sourcing, no chart positions, no nothing. Fails and Deletion of Ringleader Man WP:N||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2353 12348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Semyon Hitler User:Septrillion 23:10, 6 July 2018 (UTC) delete Fails . Fails . \\\Septrillion Deletion of Semyon Hitler WP:GNG||WP:NSOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
2354 16883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harriet Sylvia Ann Howland Green Wilks User:Richard 06:07, 9 June 2008 (UTC) comment If your going to say an article fails , please make an effort to cite a line of , so we all can know what your thinking. You can't tell someone its in the Bible without citing a chapter and verse Deletion of Harriet Sylvia Ann Howland Green Wilks WP:BIO||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2355 4587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Blake Ames User:Kudpung 21:32, 5 October 2010 (UTC) delete as per nominator. Fails all policies at , , , and Deletion of Andrew Blake Ames WP:ANYBIO||WP:BASIC||WP:ENT||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
2356 18215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neo Pastafarian Church of Costa Rica User:Coolabahapple 01:09, 13 February 2019 (UTC) delete does not meet , sources in the article are not , gsearch brings up nothing, also, checking SpanishWP brings up no article on this (see https://es.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?search=Pastafaria&title=Especial%3ABuscar&go=Ir here Deletion of Neo Pastafarian Church of Costa Rica WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2357 749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Project Reality (Mod) User:Wickethewok 17:55, 29 September 2006 (UTC) delete Fails , . No multiple reliable sources = no article. Fyi, many mods ''have'' been deleted in the past Deletion of Project Reality (Mod) WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2358 12889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SafeCharge User:Drewmutt 23:22, 30 January 2018 (UTC) delete All points point towards Zero. This is actually a rampant and horrible example of failing -- as Deletion of SafeCharge WP:ACTUALCOI||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
2359 11951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Óscar Zepeda User:GiantSnowman 13:12, 19 October 2014 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Óscar Zepeda WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2360 13481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aeonico [[User talk:Devokewater|water]] 22:34, 23 March 2021 (UTC) delete Per nom, maybe. . --Devokewater|Devoke Deletion of Aeonico WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
2361 7860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gram Panchayat Building, Sattari User:PohranicniStraze 07:02, 21 December 2018 (UTC) delete Just an |ordinary building with no special claim to notability Deletion of Gram Panchayat Building, Sattari WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
2362 20718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stacee Myers (2nd nomination) User:reddogsix 16:54, 15 May 2017 (UTC) delete Fails to provide basis for . Created numerous times - a salting candidate Deletion of Stacee Myers (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2363 10920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madrasa Misbah al-Uloom User:PohranicniStraze 04:22, 10 November 2018 (UTC) delete Fails ; not seeing any significant reliable source coverage to establish notability Deletion of Madrasa Misbah al-Uloom WP:NSCHOOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2364 16631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melody Johnson User:Papaursa 19:03, 28 October 2018 (UTC) delete There is insufficient coverage to show that is met and she also appears to fail . She's not listed at the WNBA website's list of historical players http://www.wnba.com/players/archive/ so apparently she never actually played in the WNBA, despite the article's implication that she did Deletion of Melody Johnson WP:GNG||WP:NHOOPS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2365 8384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Justine Hardy User:Hmlarson 19:28, 22 December 2016 (UTC) keep Article could use improved referencing per , not deletion. Clearly meets notability guidelines as outlined by {{u|Megalibrarygirl}} and {{u|Oakshade Deletion of Justine Hardy WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
2366 1933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of works of fiction set in 2029 User:Coolabahapple 07:29, 13 January 2017 (UTC) comment """we already have these cats ie. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:2029_in_fiction Category:2029 in fiction, do we need list articles that are essentially duplicates? do these meet ?, where are these """"discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources""" Deletion of List of works of fiction set in 2029 WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2367 723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prerna Kohli NONE NONE comment This source assessment table reviews sources that make a assessment of her as an expert, including articles from mainstream news sources listed on her website, as noted above, and others found during an online search Deletion of Prerna Kohli WP:SECONDARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
2368 5003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Angry Video Game Nerd episodes User:Postdlf 18:24, 5 January 2019 (UTC) keep per above, I see no argument presented that would justify overturning the past consensus on this page that it is an appropriate , and no argument at all that is rooted in a demonstrated understanding of the subject (as would be necessary to have a meaningful discussion of the merits of splitting). The episodes are reliable sources for their own content so I don't see an inherent issue with sourcing either. And as the series as a whole is indisputably notable, and the episodes comprise the series, this would then also pass . There is no need for the episodes to be independently notable such that they would merit their own articles. The whole motivation for the nomination seems to be a new editor complaining about what they think was inconsistent treatment of other content, i.e. Deletion of List of Angry Video Game Nerd episodes WP:SPLIT||WP:LISTN||WP:WAX Wikipedia:Splitting 57
2369 16139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mwetoolkit User:Piotrus 14:02, 8 January 2015 (UTC) delete The sources presented here seem to fail policy; they don't seem to be peer reviewed; the websites seem to be just generic paper repositories (see http://www.aclweb.org/anthology/). In other words, just hosts for self-published content. And is not a valid argument Deletion of Mwetoolkit WP:RS||WP:ITSUSEFUL Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2370 17909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Nakamichi User:MusikAnimal 19:21, 23 January 2014 (UTC) delete Not finding anything through web searches, nor a qualifying criterion. &mdash Deletion of Lisa Nakamichi WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2371 5811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Regional News Group User:SBKSPP 03:16, 15 May 2021 (UTC) delete """Fails per nom. Does not comply with since this is an """"umbrella"""" of programs formerly of ABS-CBN Regional""" Deletion of Regional News Group WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2372 19886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hawks PDX User:Thsmi002 19:08, 25 March 2019 (UTC) keep per on as shown in the review of the sources above Deletion of Hawks PDX WP:AUD||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2373 10040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011 First Flight High School protests and walkouts (2nd nomination) User:MorbidEntree 03:47, 9 September 2016 (UTC) delete but this really should have been a CSD per |A7 using {{tl|Db-event Deletion of 2011 First Flight High School protests and walkouts (2nd nomination) WP:A7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
2374 4318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of Deadpool User:Adamant1 07:04, 19 September 2020 (UTC) delete I looked through a lot of the sources provided by both Andrew and Darkknight2149. I just don't find any of them compelling for notability them though nice 99% (or all) of them are just top lists that very briefly mention the alternative versions. So, I don't think they or the subject passes the in-depth coverage clause to the notability guidelines. I'd be willing to change my opinion if there was a serious article about the alternatives though. It's highly possible one of the sources was, but that I just missed it. Although, it would take more then one to pass Deletion of Alternative versions of Deadpool WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2375 20596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marco Polo Adriano-Garcia User:Raykyogrou0 13:05, 6 October 2015 (UTC) delete """This person doesn't exactly pass . Is winning an award from the Philippine film academy supposed to satisfy """"Has made unique, prolific or innovative contributions to a field of entertainment""""? If we were to create a Wikipedia page for everyone who won an """"award"""", we would have countless stubs about non-notable people""" Deletion of Marco Polo Adriano-Garcia WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2376 2775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rudston Preparatory School User:Deor NONE merge to List of schools in Rotherham#Independent schools per The Whispering Wind and Deletion of Rudston Preparatory School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
2377 4983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Difference between Delhi and New Delhi User:Shawn 18:13, 30 October 2017 (UTC) delete """per nom. The ead to New Delhi states clearly enough: """"Although colloquially Delhi and New Delhi are used interchangeably to refer to the National Capital Territory of Delhi, these are two distinct entities, with New Delhi forming a small part of Delhi."""" If the article creator thinks some valid point has been omitted in these articles, he should attempt to add there, provided it is not original research or a personal essay""" Deletion of Difference between Delhi and New Delhi WP:L Wikipedia:Lists 97
2378 3739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wrexham & Shropshire Route User:Tivedshambo 19:51, 23 June 2008 (UTC) delete unsourced speculation/|OR about the route a train company takes. — Deletion of Wrexham & Shropshire Route WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2379 2594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kit and Kay Boodle User:Alphachimp 00:54, 11 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails per yet another hilarious nom Deletion of Kit and Kay Boodle WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2380 7027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Metropolitan bias User:CFCF 22:01, 27 May 2018 (UTC) merge to urban bias — These seem to be the same, and some of the sources to this article in fact user the other term. That said there are considerable amounts of in the current article, and that should of course not be merged into the other article Deletion of Metropolitan bias WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2381 2549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Bascombe (2nd nomination) User:GiantSnowman 10:17, 21 April 2013 (UTC) keep the previous nomination was withdrawn (by me!) not because he met , but because he met and consensus was clearly in agreement Deletion of Chris Bascombe (2nd nomination) WP:NAUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2382 17070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kumin Sommers LLP User:THF 15:19, 18 March 2009 (UTC) comment NB that http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Matthew+Kumin%22+attorney&btnG=Search+Archives&ned=us&hl=en Matthew Kumin and http://news.google.com/archivesearch?pz=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Stephen+Sommers%22+attorney Stephen Sommers are each arguably notable, though I would personally have a higher encyclopedic standard for notability under . (Some of the Sommers hits in that google link are for the director, not the attorney.) While notability is generally , I would argue that a recently-created two-person law firm consisting of two notable attorneys would be notable even if the firm itself has not generated coverage Deletion of Kumin Sommers LLP WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2383 2211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of most-liked YouTube videos User:Paintspot 18:42, 11 February 2019 (UTC) keep per above. Per . Has enough secondary source coverage Deletion of List of most-liked YouTube videos WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2384 9781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roger Stritmatter User:Quidlibet 21:46, 28 September 2015 (UTC) keep As discussed by Shapiro and Matus, Dr. Stritmatter is perhaps the most notable apologist for the Oxford-as-Shakespeare theory. He fails , but easily passes . If his page is rewritten to reflect that status, it should be kept Deletion of Roger Stritmatter WP:SCHOLAR||WP:FRINGEBLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2385 612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Kinetic (comics) User:Darkknight2149 02:08, 14 October 2020 (UTC) comment While the |poor writing is certainly a problem, I'm not seeing a |criteria for deletion cited here. Did the article fail a source check (otability)? Is the implication that the subject of the article is a fan theory or hoax Deletion of The Kinetic (comics) WP:INUNIVERSE||WP:DELREASON||WP:N Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
2386 12909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evan Talianko User:MichaelQSchmidt 08:54, 28 May 2016 (UTC) delete this sourced BLP simply for failing and ... and NOT for it |being unimproved or forgotten Deletion of Evan Talianko WP:BIO||WP:BASIC||WP:NEGLECT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2387 20144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wenche Kjølås User:Geschichte 07:49, 24 June 2014 (UTC) keep meets (as the article shows) and is one of the most influential women in business in Norway. Important director job and numerous board memberships in major corporations, chair of major transport company Deletion of Wenche Kjølås WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2388 8579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Old Colours User:Sparklism 11:49, 22 November 2013 (UTC) delete I cannot find any evidence that this band meets the guidelines for inclusion at or the Deletion of Old Colours WP:BAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2389 3694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scotty McCoy User:Jack 21:42, 29 October 2017 (UTC) delete Insufficient coverage to meet or . Does not otherwise meet . |PROMO ahoy Deletion of Scotty McCoy WP:NAUTHOR||WP:BASIC||WP:GNG||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2390 8121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shabbir Ahmad Rao User:Alexandermcnabb 08:54, 27 May 2021 (UTC) delete Sorry to hear of the manner of his passing, but he fails . Best Deletion of Shabbir Ahmad Rao WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2391 16344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melissa Baker User:Hako9 04:52, 5 September 2020 (UTC) delete No evidence of |enduring notability here. Needs to have significant coverage unrelated to her single association with SI Deletion of Melissa Baker WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2392 11528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plains of the Paynims User:A 20:34, 30 January 2009 (UTC) keep as and are not valid reasons for deletion. Topic can be verified in a http://books.google.com/books?id=FMd62e8Z-kwC&q=%22Plains+of+the+Paynims%22&dq=%22Plains+of+the+Paynims%22&ei=_GODSfLPLoPmzATXrqjADw&pgis=1 published book. Merge discussions can take place elsewhere, but clearly no valid reason for redlinking and deleting edit history. Sincerely Deletion of Plains of the Paynims WP:JNN||WP:ITSCRUFT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2393 17166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carla Walker-Miller User:Beccaynr 22:43, 24 March 2021 (UTC) keep per / as noted above, and other coverage that includes: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/linda-apsey-president-ceo-itc-100000677.html Linda Apsey, President and CEO, ITC Holdings Corp. and Carla Walker-Miller, Founder and CEO, Walker-Miller Energy Services, join The Henry Ford Board of Trustees (YahooFinance, 2020), https://finance.yahoo.com/news/asahi-pompey-on-disparities-for-black-business-owners-173203847.html How the 'pandemic within the pandemic' creates disparities for Black businesses (YahooFinance, 2020), https://www.mlive.com/news/detroit/2014/09/warren_buffett_to_detroit_smal.html Warren Buffett to Detroit small businesses: 'You're in the right city' (MLive, 2019), https://www.msnbc.com/morning-joe/watch/small-business-owners-take-next-step-330774083993 Small business owners take next step (MSNBC, 2014), https://www.huffpost.com/entry/michael-bloomberg-detroit-new-york-1970s_n_5843690 Michael Bloomberg: Detroit Is Just Like 1970s New York, And That’s A Good Thing (HuffPost, 2014), https://www.fastcompany.com/3007840/how-young-community-entrepreneurs-rebuilding-detroit How A Young Community Of Entrepreneurs Is Rebuilding Detroit (Fast Company, 2013 Deletion of Carla Walker-Miller WP:BASIC||WP:GNG||WP:SUSTAINED Wikipedia:Notability 77
2394 11339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cause célèbre (disambiguation) User:Lukeno94 21:46, 13 February 2014 (UTC) keep I'm not aware of any issue with including partial matches in the count. ''may'' be valid for DAB pages Deletion of Cause célèbre (disambiguation) WP:ITSUSEFUL Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2395 12792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Fountain User:Themfromspace 03:39, 28 February 2009 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Richard Fountain WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
2396 2037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southern Region of the Black Law Students Association (SRBLSA) User:Jamesontai 18:00, 13 April 2008 (UTC) delete This organization fails in additional to 's notes on student organizations that span only one university Deletion of Southern Region of the Black Law Students Association (SRBLSA) WP:ORG||WP:UNIGUIDE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2397 14259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan McGivern User:Mkdw 22:23, 2 February 2013 (UTC) delete Subject has 1 Bellator MMA fight but remains 2 fights shy from a |top-tier organization needed to meet Deletion of Ryan McGivern WP:MMATIER||WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
2398 1945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gwendolyn Masin User:doomsdayer520 14:28, 23 February 2021 (UTC) keep She has some notice in the classical music community, which can support a basic stub article here. However, the article absolutely needs to be cut down to notable and verifiable facts, while removing obvious |CV-like minutiae. That is a cleanup job and not a reason to delete Deletion of Gwendolyn Masin WP:NOTRESUME Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2399 18184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alma L. Lee User:North 21:37, 2 August 2015 (UTC) delete Finding no indication of |significant coverage in any independent reliable sources Deletion of Alma L. Lee WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2400 9285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Ko/ User:PacknCanes 23:11, 11 October 2005 (UTC) delete per A1 and A7. If it fits two CSDs, why not speedy Deletion of Daniel Ko/ WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
2401 20923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francesca Catalano User:DannyS712 08:16, 8 January 2019 (UTC) delete not notable, fails Deletion of Francesca Catalano WP:NACTRESS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2402 6540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Revolution 9 User:Radiopathy 01:22, 5 May 2010 (UTC) keep per - see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds. Disruptive nom Deletion of Revolution 9 WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
2403 12656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gudang Padimas S2 User:AllyD 09:33, 10 September 2017 (UTC) delete A article describing a business. If this had been written in English rather than Indonesian, I suspect it would have gone straight to CSD A7. No claim or evidence of encyclopaedic notability. Fails , Deletion of Gudang Padimas S2 :WP:SPA||:WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
2404 4228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Maguire (American football) User:Cbl62 10:22, 30 July 2017 (UTC) keep Maguire was a starting quarterback for Florida State Seminoles football|Florida State, one of the most elite football teams in the county, in 2015. Passes . Even aside from extensive local coverage in the ''Tallahassee Democrat'' (e.g., http://www.tallahassee.com/story/sports/college/fsu/football/2016/08/14/fsu-qb-sean-maguire-past-few-days-have-been-pretty-devastating/88719118/ here), he also received significant coverage in other multiple reliable sources, including national media outlets like ESPN.com (http://www.espn.com/blog/acc/post/_/id/96545/sean-maguire-deserved-spotlight-on-florida-states-senior-night here), ''USA Today'' (https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/2016/06/22/fsu-player-profile-sean-maguire/86259084/ here, http://ftw.usatoday.com/2014/09/meet-sean-maguire-florida-state-jameis-winston-suspended here), NBC Sports (http://collegefootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2015/04/11/sean-maguire-is-fsus-qb-to-beat-but-he-is-not-unbeatable/ here), CBS Sports (https://www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/maguire-looks-to-defy-odds-earn-nfl-opportunity/ here and https://www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/what-do-we-know-about-florida-state-qb-sean-maguire/ here) and ''Sports Illustrated'' (https://www.si.com/college-football/2014/09/22/florida-state-sean-maguire-jameis-winston here), as well as major metropolitan newspapers like the ''Orlando Sentinel'' (http://www.orlandosentinel.com/sports/florida-state-seminoles/os-fsu-sean-maguire-football-1119-20151118-story.html here) and the ''Miami Herald'' (http://www.miamiherald.com/sports/college/acc/florida-state-university/article30804939.html here Deletion of Sean Maguire (American football) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2405 3533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Olson User:Cbl62 05:05, 4 September 2012 (UTC) keep College football players who receive significant non-trivial coverage in mainstream media sources pass . If they receive such coverage in national media outlets, they also pass . Although either one suffices, Olson appears to have received enough coverage to pass both standards. He also played at the highest level of the college sports as the starting quarterback at UCLA and was named the AT&T All-America Player of the Week for the opening week of the 2007 season. http://www.uclabruins.com/sports/m-footbl/spec-rel/090207aae.html Examples of coverage include: (1) http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1113980/index.htm Sports Illustrated feature on Olson, (2) http://www.thefreelibrary.com/WUNDERKIND+THOUSAND+OAKS+QUARTERBACK+BEN+OLSON+HAS+INGREDIENTS+OF...-a083400140 Los Angeles Daily News feature on Olson, (3) http://www.ocregister.com/sports/benolson-48074-rickneuheisel-uclabruins.html Orange County Register feature on Olson, (4) http://www.deseretnews.com/article/600155699/Ex-next-great-BYU-QB-loving-life-at-UCLA.html?pg=all Deseret News, (5) http://www.deseretnews.com/article/695207282/Just-another-game-BYU-Bruins-QB-Ben-Olson-vow-to-keep-Saturdays-game-in-perspective.html?pg=all Deseret News, (6) http://www.aolnews.com/2008/08/10/ucla-qb-ben-olsons-foot-hates-football/ AOL News, (7) http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=2556846 ESPN, http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=3055138 ESPN, (8) http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=2618840 ESPN, (9) http://www.cbssports.com/collegefootball/story/10927102/2 CBS Sports, (10) http://nbcsports.msnbc.com/id/26128220/ MSNBC, (11) http://articles.latimes.com/2005/aug/28/sports/sp-uclarep28 Los Angeles Times, (12) http://articles.latimes.com/2004/dec/30/sports/sp-olson30 Los Angeles Times, (13) http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/latimes/access/730497571.html?dids=730497571:730497571&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Nov+05%2C+2004&author=Lonnie+White&pub=Los+Angeles+Times&desc=Ben+Olson+May+Return+to+Southland%3B+Quarterback+from+Thousand+Oaks+who+left+BYU+to+go+on+a+two-year+Mormon+mission+will+attend+UCLA+game+Saturday.+USC+is+also+on+his+list.&pqatl=google Los Angeles Times, (14) http://articles.latimes.com/2008/aug/11/sports/sp-ucla11 Los Angeles Times, (15) http://the.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/2008/Nov/19/br/hawaii81119005.html Honolulu Advertiser, (16) http://seattletimes.com/html/collegesports/2008109565_grid13.html Seattle Times, (17) http://www.usatoday.com/sports/college/football/pac10/2008-04-25-ucla-qb-injuries_N.htm USA Today, (18) http://ucla.scout.com/2/332986.html Bruin Report Online Deletion of Ben Olson WP:GNG||WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
2406 5495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Powerpac International User:HighKing 15:40, 13 May 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and GNG Deletion of Powerpac International WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
2407 8809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amit Bhadana User:Ammarpad 08:48, 7 October 2018 (UTC) delete Have been watching this article for sometime but fail to understand how it's encyclopedic. Lacks SIGCOV from reliable sources and fails GNG completely. Entirely promotional stuff built upon total unreliable sources such as https://socialblade.com/youtube/top/500/mostsubscribed this fan's blog and back reference to Youtube and his own self promotion blog. For those saying move to draft, it was once moved but immediately moved back to mainspace as is to be expected from generally non notable promotional stuffs. So moving it is worthless. If it's notable, just shows us multiple independent |RS discussing him directly and in detail. If no such sources exist then it's meaningless moving it to draft Deletion of Amit Bhadana WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2408 3477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Green Andy User:DarkAudit 17:09, 11 May 2007 (UTC) delete fails on numerous levels. No verifiable, reliable, independent sources whatsoever. MySpace and fan sites do not count Deletion of Green Andy WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2409 14992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of U.S. state license plates User:Ektar 17:13, 17 June 2006 (UTC) keep """I think the """"#Wikipedia_is_not_a_mirror_or_a_repository_of_links.2C_images.2C_or_media_files|Wiki is not a repository for images"""" argument is being misused here. There are a lot of """"repositories for images"""" on Wikipedia (like Flags of the U.S. states, Seals of the U.S. states, etc.) and these lists are certainly encyclopedic. Also, the #Wikipedia_is_not_a_mirror_or_a_repository_of_links.2C_images.2C_or_media_files|IS NOT policy states that wiki is not a """"Collections of photographs or media files with no text to go with the articles."""" (emphasis added) This article has as much text as the flag and seal articles (in fact it has more than the seal article). Sure, I would like to have each license explained (and I'll probably add that when I have time) but not having a thorough explanation is not a valid reason to delete. Now, the matter of copyright is an ENTIRELY different discussion and it should be handled elsewhere and on a per image basis""" Deletion of List of U.S. state license plates WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2410 16356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Semi Ajayi User:GiantSnowman 17:34, 31 March 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Semi Ajayi WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2411 6271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pantaloons Fashion & Retail User:Harshil169 14:35, 22 August 2019 (UTC) keep This article passes but should be improved Deletion of Pantaloons Fashion & Retail WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2412 19222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luno (company) User:David 05:42, 27 July 2020 (UTC) delete two passing plausible RSes, seems a bit thin for , and the article would be about three sentences Deletion of Luno (company) WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2413 15346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PVS-Studio User:Dialectric 01:16, 4 February 2015 (UTC) delete Software article of unclear notability, lacking independent coverage in reliable sources. As above, the article has a number of references, but they do not meet the threshold of significant independent coverage for a range of reasons. The Dr. Dobb's article was written by a PVS-Studio developer. and is not independent. sourceforge.net/ is edited by community members and has no editorial oversight or policy, thus not RS. The other coverage is all incidental mentions or blogs/non- sites Deletion of PVS-Studio WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2414 6427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Terry Lydell Bowser, Sr. User:Themfromspace 00:50, 6 February 2010 (UTC) delete """as paid-editing originating from http://www.elance.com/jobs/create_wikipeida_article_personal_profile/web_content_content_writing/18397629?catId=1020 this posting on elance dot com. The posting is from the name """"bowser52000"""" and reads """"I need someone to create a Wikipedia article about myself. I will provide you with all the descriptions and etc and you have to make sure the description is formatted in a way that it can get past the """"autobiography"""" filter in Wikipedia. I have a book that need to be described in the article in a neutral way so that it won't seem like you are advertising for me. The goal of this is for me to have my own Wikipedia page with details about myself, career, book, goals and etc."""" I've had this link on my paid editing watchlist for some time now""" Deletion of Dr. Terry Lydell Bowser, Sr. WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
2415 2062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of simulation typefaces (2nd nomination) User:Alpha3031 05:58, 19 March 2019 (UTC) merge to List of typefaces#Simulation/Mimicry fonts and Simulation typeface to Typeface#Ethnic typefaces (merging some things if necessary). I don't really think there's enough coverage of simulation typefaces for a full standalone article, but it's already covered at those two articles, meaning there is an appropriate redirect target where it can be covered according to .{{pb}}{{pb}}(if there is enough content for a standalone article, I'd suggest a '''move''' to simulation typeface as suggested by {{noping|Nabla}} and '''reverse merge''' Typeface#Ethnic typefaces Deletion of List of simulation typefaces (2nd nomination) WP:DUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
2416 16292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sohaib Athar User:Joe 02:10, 3 May 2011 (UTC) merge after merging anything relevant to the Death article, as per Deletion of Sohaib Athar WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2417 2915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C.B. Robinson Bridge User:Cewbot 00:03, 22 October 2020 (UTC) comment While this discussion appears to have |no quorum, it is '''NOT eligible for |soft deletion''' because it has been Special:Diff/983564417|previously PROD'd (via summary Deletion of C.B. Robinson Bridge WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
2418 6302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tabitha King User:Ren99 11:17, 11 August 2012 (UTC) delete Fails clearly. Also, suggesting , , or learly notable are not valid arguments for retention. The author must have made significant, notable, personal contributions to the field. Mrs. King is pretty much except for the association with her husband's fame Deletion of Tabitha King WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:ILIKEIT||WP:PLEASEDONT||WP:C||WP:NN Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2419 10942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Usenet personalities (2nd nomination) User:Amatulic 00:41, 1 May 2009 (UTC) keep The article accomplishes what it says: describe individuals that gained notoriety on usenet. I find this to be a useful compilation, myself. I agree with responses above that this deletion proposal results from a case of , which is not a reason to delete. The article meets criteria for inclusion, and it should be improved to correct deficiencies. Deletion is not the answer to such deficiencies Deletion of List of Usenet personalities (2nd nomination) WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2420 3376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UCLA Girl User:Chrishmt0423 01:24, 27 March 2011 (UTC) delete clearly fails Deletion of UCLA Girl WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2421 13240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Penny User:CAWylie 03:06, 8 January 2012 (UTC) delete Who? and Deletion of Alex Penny WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2422 15035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kathy Fagan User:Bearian 23:03, 8 December 2020 (UTC) keep per , great work by {{U|David Eppstein Deletion of Kathy Fagan WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
2423 949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silver Bullet Media User:onel5969 21:14, 2 November 2015 (UTC) delete Searches on the engines returned a single trivial mention (on Scholar, of all places). Fails and Deletion of Silver Bullet Media WP:NCORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2424 7064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National Wind User:Hro 15:08, 17 June 2008 (UTC) comment Smerdis seems to have it right. Some of the links to National Wind's own website are to reprints of local press articles, so are much more useful than they look at first sight, though I can't find a mention of National Wind in the Twin Cities Business reprint (help me.) While its model of community co-ownership is unusual (unique?), I would like to see it ''do'' something that gets it into the national press (not just trade press), but with 33 employees doing project management and property development, that may not be soon. When it does, someone will be justified in creating a Wikipedia article. There is no guideline to prevent me from saying ''keep'' per , but I think AfD precedent does. See Wikipedia talk:Notability (organizations and companies)#Local notability for more Deletion of National Wind WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2425 18896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur Charles Rothery Nutt User:Srich32977 04:51, 7 September 2014 (UTC) keep If anything this article has . The article is being added to the WikiProject Military history, which is quite active. Also, a note on their talk page as to this AFD will be posted. So I think project members will come on in to assist with developing the article. (The fact that an article on miniature ranges has not been developed is not determinative as to Nutt's notability. We are building, so the miniature range is an idea for another, worthwhile article Deletion of Arthur Charles Rothery Nutt WP:POTENTIAL Wikipedia:Potential, not just current state 11
2426 13550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BOiFINDER User:ConMan 10:21, 27 September 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and as a Google search shows no non-trivial results that might make it satisfy . This isn't about whether or not the site exists, and it's not about being anti-gay, it's about notability and not using Wikipedia to promote a website Deletion of BOiFINDER WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2427 20260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Universe reality User:Wazronk 21:47, 26 February 2008 (UTC) keep """but as """"Cosmology (The Urantia Book)"""", and use it as the main article for that topic according to (there already is a decent but cumbersome subsection """"Cosmology"""" in The Urantia Book article, which could actually stand to have content shifted to a side article like this one). The book doesn't use the phrase """"universe reality"""" as a specially defined term and """"cosmology"""" could be taken as a synonym as far as I can tell. There is independent third-party assessment that this aspect of the book is notable. The harshest published criticism to date was Martin Gardner's ''Urantia: The Great Cult Mystery'', but his summary conclusion on this aspect of the book was that """"The UB's cosmology outrivals in fantasy the cosmology of any science fiction work known to me"""". Brad Gooch in his book echoed this view and added in the context of discussing the cosmology that """"No one can read through the UB, or even just parts of it, without wondering how such an incredibly detailed mix of science, ethics, politics, and polytheology ever got set down in one monstrous blue-covered volume."""" That being said it's clear the article is in rough shape and needs a lot of work. I've been on the fence about whether it's a suitable topic for a wikipedia article and haven't contributed to it before, but in the sense of it becoming a explanation of the TUB's cosmology (eg, like Mormon cosmology, Hindu cosmology, etc... heck, there's even a Raëlian cosmology article on WP), I think that it is a defensible sub-topic to keep and improve. If there is agreement by the end of the Afd that it is worth keeping, I'll assist with clean up""" Deletion of Universe reality WP:SS||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Summary style 34
2428 475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Space (NewsRadio episode) User:Ckatz 01:28, 30 November 2007 (UTC) comment """Three of the four """"delete"""" supporters have used as their rationale for opposing the article. It should be noted that specifically states ''""""Avoid listing episodes for AfD unless they are completely unverifiable and original research.""""'' As this article is neither """"unverifiable"""" or """"original research"""", the only option would be a redirect - ''not'' deletion""" Deletion of Space (NewsRadio episode) WP:EPISODE||WP:EPISODE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
2429 18037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zarabanda (band) User:Phoe 19:11, 9 July 2009 (UTC) delete per the mentioned and. Note that all locatable eliable sources refer obviously to two other bands with the same name (http://www.zarabandamusic.com/home.html and http://www.orchestrazarabanda.com/band.html Deletion of Zarabanda (band) WP:B||WP:R Wikipedia:Bots 21
2430 12931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RAVPower User:Graywalls 20:24, 15 December 2019 (UTC) delete """There is no indication of notability. I've reviewed the edit history and it was created by a single purpose account; and I also see an edit by a user name containing """"Rav"""" and based on my experience, this was likely created for purpose""" Deletion of RAVPower WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2431 11842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FxPro User:Nagle 17:57, 23 June 2017 (UTC) delete The only in-depth coverage in a reliable source is one Daily Telegraph article http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/banksandfinance/12155078/FXPro-holds-off-flotation-plan-on-market-chaos.html, and it's about FxPro deciding not to try an IPO Deletion of FxPro WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2432 18220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laura Les (2nd nomination) User:Dylpicklee 00:22, 6 June 2021 (UTC) keep Clearly meets the . Alongside this she is as mentioned been an integral part of pioneering an emerging sub genre Deletion of Laura Les (2nd nomination) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2433 5279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henrik Breimyr User:Hobbes 17:53, 16 December 2011 (UTC) delete """Fails and . Ghits are stray mentions in football-centric news reports, primary, social media, a bit in football blogs. Only 18 and seems to have some promise, so I could see him achieving ''actual'' notability in future (and not just a technical """"meets NFOOTY"""" characterization). But not there yet""" Deletion of Henrik Breimyr WP:NFOOTY||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2434 2019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of the best-selling boy bands in Asia [[User talk:Starcheerspeaksnewslostwars|Talk to me]] 05:36, 8 September 2015 (UTC) delete The sources used do not have subentries for boy bands or girl groups or other type of genre, just a combined synthesis of sourced information, which makes this . --Starcheerspeaksnewslostwars Deletion of List of the best-selling boy bands in Asia WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2435 7265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Varonis User:Msnicki 02:02, 4 July 2012 (UTC) delete """Lacks reliable independent secondary sources to establish notability as required by and . Sources offered are trivial, irrelevant to notability (e.g., patents), unreliable blogs or random industry """"awards"""". Googling turned up nothing better. Wikipedia is not for """ Deletion of Varonis WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
2436 17750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rekha Rana User:Atlantic306 18:01, 12 March 2018 (UTC) keep has three promnent leading roles in films as confirmed by tne article's sources so passes Deletion of Rekha Rana WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2437 10129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Stalins's religious views User:Cavarrone 16:46, 29 May 2015 (UTC) keep obviously a notable topic, is not a valid reason to delete it. I also support a move as suggested above Deletion of Joseph Stalins's religious views WP:UGLY Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2438 11941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plush Movies User:ShadowUltra 21:23, 28 October 2007 (UTC) delete due to non-notability. Seems to be edited exclusively by single-purpose accounts. being used repeatedly by the article editors isn't helping Deletion of Plush Movies WP:ABOUTEVERYTHING Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2439 11169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamnet Shakespeare NONE NONE comment """I'm surprised by the element of certainty in some of the !voting here. On the one hand, """"notability is not inherited"""" is |part of an essay on arguments to avoid in deletion discussions. What it really means is """"notability is not ''automatically'' inherited"""" and hence is a weak argument ''on its own''. Wikipedia at least tolerates many articles on family members who wouldn't be notable were it not for the family connection. The Shakespeare family has a Template:Relatebardtree|whole tree containing over 10 people whose lives are known and researched primarily because of the link with WS himself. Of course """"other stuff exists"""" is not an argument on its own either""" Deletion of Hamnet Shakespeare WP:INHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2440 10929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mastermind (Sparta) [[User talk:86.146.241.58|talk]]) 16:55, 21 January 2009 (UTC) comment I'm not a puppet. Whatever happened to ssume good faith, huh? This encyclopedia has gone way down! Special:Contributions/86.146.241.58|86.146.241.58 Deletion of Mastermind (Sparta) WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
2441 15586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Austin Osueke User:TheFarix 14:18, 21 September 2006 (UTC) delete with the addition that Eigomanga should also be deleted. Nither these articles make any assertions of notability and both articles appear to be vanity pages or possible advertisement. I highly doubt that this article will pass or that Eigomanga could pass . Also neither articles offers any kind of citations for the information contained within, leading to the posibilities that both articles are |original research. And finally, there have been several anonymous IPs removing the AfD notice from this article and removing the {{tl|citations missing}} tag from Eigomanga article Deletion of Austin Osueke WP:BIO||WP:CORP||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2442 14553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Primary Route Destinations in Wiltshire User:Kappa 05:14, 10 September 2005 (UTC) keep per which explicitly permits this kind of list Deletion of List of Primary Route Destinations in Wiltshire WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2443 16768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Horace A. Bass Jr. User:Mztourist 03:37, 24 January 2021 (UTC) merge """to USS Horace A. Bass (APD-124). Fails (Ensign awarded a Navy Cross. Having a ship named after him during WWII is not a """"significant award or honor"""") and . No SIGCOV in multiple RS so not notable""" Deletion of Horace A. Bass Jr. WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2444 8005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ololade Adesola User:Versace1608 14:01, 3 May 2020 (UTC) delete The subject fails and . She is the founder of a non-notable company. A Google search of her did not bring up significant coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Ololade Adesola WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2445 3794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neldë User:Disavian 08:38, 19 December 2007 (UTC) delete I'm having trouble finding any sources for any of this, so IMO it pretty clearly fails and Deletion of Neldë WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
2446 3846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patchy the Pirate User:Antepenultimate 01:44, 30 January 2007 (UTC) keep barring that: Try to '''Merge''' with SpongeBob SquarePants or List of SpongeBob SquarePants characters - except both of those articles seem to be approaching the limits of . Article definately needs cleanup in any sense. If lack of sources is the real problem, then it should be tagged as unsourced Deletion of Patchy the Pirate WP:SIZE Wikipedia:Article size 51
2447 1350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people with coronavirus disease 2019 User:DigitalPanda 08:25, 16 March 2020 (UTC) keep the delete !votes are misunderstanding or misrepresenting the policies they keep quoting. I call on getting a consensus Deletion of List of people with coronavirus disease 2019 WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
2448 7569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Survival food User:Where 04:25, 27 June 2006 (UTC) merge and '''delete''' without merging, as per above due to |original research aspects of page Deletion of Survival food WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2449 20457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/3E Accounting User:HighKing 15:24, 6 January 2018 (UTC) delete No indications of notability, fails GNG. References rely on interviews and quotations from company sources or materials provided by the company, fails and/or Deletion of 3E Accounting WP:ORGIND||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
2450 15850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Gwyn User:Colapeninsula 11:18, 31 July 2012 (UTC) keep """He's also got coverage in Publishers Weeklyhttp://www.publishersweekly.com/978-0-393-06723-1, Library Journalhttp://www.libraryjournal.com/article/CA6650972.html and Creative Loafinghttp://clclt.com/charlotte/book-signing-author-aaron-gwyn/Content?oid=2152501http://clclt.com/charlotte/digging-into-aaron-gwyns-the-world-beneath/Content?oid=2153014http://clclt.com/theclog/archives/2009/07/21/five-novels-to-read-while-thinking-about-faith and some briefer mentions praising his workhttp://www.smokymountainnews.com/news/item/1497-southern-stories-don%E2%80%99t-disappointhttp://latimesblogs.latimes.com/jacketcopy/2009/05/jg-ballard-in-the-new-yorker-and-more-short-stories.htmlhttp://www.dallasnews.com/entertainment/books/20111223-book-review-west-of-98-and-best-of-the-west-2011.ecehttp://thecelebritycafe.com/reviews/2012/06/review-you-and-me-and-devil-makes-three-esquires-fiction-men-volume-onehttp://www.sfgate.com/default/article/3-Bay-Area-writers-are-finalists-for-Young-Lions-2641818.php. is full of vague terms about """"significance"""" and """"widespread coverage"""" that you can argue about forever, but he clearly passes """ Deletion of Aaron Gwyn WP:WRITER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2451 21266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs with fruit in the title User:Dhartung 19:18, 7 May 2007 (UTC) delete this list is B-A-N-A-N-A-S. Per nom, there are song topics which are not just |interesting but notable (e.g. topics of discussion), this is not one of them Deletion of List of songs with fruit in the title WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2452 17742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Strauss (artist) User:PlusPlusDave 23:13, 11 April 2011 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Mark Strauss (artist) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2453 19455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of buildings with the most floors by country User:LaundryPizza03 21:48, 16 June 2021 (UTC) delete per |A10 Deletion of List of buildings with the most floors by country WP:A10 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
2454 5893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aristean calendar User:Assize 04:21, 22 August 2007 (UTC) delete This is original research . The secondary sources only demonstrate that the person who invented this concept has had trouble getting somebody to take his concept seriously. His concept has only been mentioned in passing and nobody has conducted an indepth review of the concept, rather than the novelty of it. This is one instead for WikiNews Deletion of Aristean calendar WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2455 18564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vin Abrenica User:Seav 10:57, 26 September 2015 (UTC) keep This actor is currently in a leading role in a primetime soap opera on a major TV network. He has also had other acting roles in previous drama series. Seems to pass Deletion of Vin Abrenica WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2456 18787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandisk Sansa e260 User:MER 02:43, 3 February 2007 (UTC) delete fails , redundant Deletion of Sandisk Sansa e260 WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2457 13048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward Jarvis (author) User:E 14:00, 10 July 2019 (UTC) delete Fails , fails . Much/most of the sourcing is PRIMARY. The claims to notability are co-founding a Catholic Worker's house, sourced to Catholic Worker. Writing 2 books, but no book reviews are given. If, someone manages to find INDEPENDENT reviews of the books in publications, please ping me to revisit. I am always willing to change an iVote when shown solid sources. This, however, appears to be PROMO for a non-notable author Deletion of Edward Jarvis (author) WP:SIGCOV||WP:AUTHOR||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2458 12108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/President's House Association User:Unscintillating 01:35, 24 June 2012 (UTC) delete to Georgetown College. This topic is already covered in the encyclopedia, so a straight deletion is not policy-based. The article has a problem in that it is mostly duplicated at http://www.wix.com/pha-64/presidentshouseassociation this site. One of the two is not properly attributed, see opyright problems#Handling previously published text on Wikipedia. One way to resolve this problem is to delete the edit history on Wikipedia. I am assuming here that the topic will fail wp:notability if the research is done, but I've not done so myself. Deletion of President's House Association WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
2459 8527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Finnegan (journalist) User:Thompson 10:48, 26 July 2011 (UTC) delete unless references are added. I would have added PROD|BLP PROD Deletion of Michael Finnegan (journalist) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2460 1535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Aaron User:Dolovis 03:29, 29 April 2014 (UTC) comment Criteria #10 of NMUSIC states “''Has performed music for a work of media that is notable''”, which is certainly true for this musician who has performed music on many notable albums including Blondie's ''The Hunter (Blondie album)|The Hunter,'' David Bowie's ''Let's Dance (David Bowie album)|Let's Dance'', and Amy Winehouse's ''Frank (Amy Winehouse album)|Frank'' (to name just three of the many notable albums listed in the article). The body of work performed by Robert Aaron over his lengthy musical career is certainly significant, notable, and verifiable by http://www.allmusic.com/artist/robert-aaron-mn0000827693/credits Allmusic.com and the CD lining notes for each album listed in the article. He demonstrably meets Criteria #10, and if news of his arrest (which was added to the article ''after'' its creation) is a violation of then that sentence within the article should properly be removed (as it now has been Deletion of Robert Aaron WP:CRIMINAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2461 19 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Bahaeddin Sağlam Kullanıcı:ddenkel'''ddenkel''' 15:43, 27 Temmuz 2007 (UTC) delete Ansiklopedik olup olmaması bir yana; madde bu siteden http://www.insanyayinlari.com.tr/authors.aspx?ID=47 kopyalanmış. Telif ihlali G9.--User:renegade|'''renegade'''User_Talk:renegade|''msj Bahaeddin Sağlam'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:HS Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
2462 7148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Lounge Kittens User:Cari 09:49, 15 June 2015 (GMT) keep Based on my input above, this article meets the requirements for and, therefore, should be kept Deletion of The Lounge Kittens WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2463 389 [[Online-Publishing.net_Verlag]] (Gelöscht) Benutzer:Kriddl NONE delete Ich schaue mir so die speziellen Relevanzkriterien für Verlage (#Verlage) und die etwas allgemeineren für Unternehmen (#Wirtschaftsunternehmen) an und frage mich, was davon erfüllt sein soll. Ansonsten, nachdem ich den Artikel gelesen habe, habe ich irgendwie dieselben Assoziationen wie Löschung von Online-Publishing.net_Verlag Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2464 152 [[Benjamin Tewaag]] (LAE) Benutzer:Tom_md NONE keep Aufnahmeleiter von ''Das geheime Leben der Spielerfrauen'' sollte reichen. Zudem mehrfache mediale Präsens - dieser LA und das ständige Wiedereinsetzen durch einen Einzelnen ist schon fast ein - Fall Löschung von Benjamin Tewaag Wikipedia:BNS Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
2465 442 [[Piccolo Puppenspiele]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Kriddl NONE keep """Laut den #Schauspieler, Film-Stab, Moderatoren|Schauspieler und Schauspielschaffenden-Relevanzkriterien sollen diejenigen relevant sein, """"''in wesentlicher Rolle (Regisseur, Schauspieler, Drehbuchautor, Produzent etc.) an einem kommerziellen Theaterstück oder Musical mitwirkten''"""". Inhaltlich handelt es sich um einen Artikel über Gerd J. Pohl. Wir sollten daher diese Kriterien anwenden. Er ist laut Artikel Alleinbetreiber der auch kommerziell gedachten Bühne. Es werden mehrere TV-Auftritte genannt. Selbst wenn sich die doch relativ lange Liste der Zeitungsbeiträge auf den Rheinländischen Raum beschränkt, deutet auch diese auf Relevanz. Mein Vorschlag und auf Gerd J. Pohl verschieben, Einleitung etc. entsprechend umstricken. Das redirect stehen lassen, damit auch bei der Suche nach den Puppenspielen der Leser fündig wird""" Löschung von Piccolo Puppenspiele Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2466 14235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marinello Schools of Beauty (2nd nomination) User:Jim 12:37, 21 February 2015 (UTC) delete As already noted. Subject doesn't pass our notability threshold as I couldn't find any in-depth coverage in reliable third party sources. Fails Deletion of Marinello Schools of Beauty (2nd nomination) WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2467 108 [[Deutsche Stämme]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Heinrich L. NONE keep """Einfach zu löschen hieße, diesen historisch relevanten Begriff in den Verdacht zu bringen, ein Wiedergänger zu sein, sobald er wieder aufgegriffen wird. Es sollte klargestellt werden, was die (überwiegend demokratisch gesonnenen) Verfasser gemeint haben und auch, was die Nazis dann daraus gemacht haben. Der Begriff kommt m.W. implizit sogar noch in der (Nachkriegs-)Hymne Niedersachsens vor. Danach sollen die Niedersachsen """"von Widukinds Stamm"""" sein, und das ist wohl auch in dem historisierenden Sinne gemeint, der bereits 1919 den Geist der Verwender dieses Begriffs bestimmt hat. Was die """"Vereinnahmung"""" Österreichs und der Schweiz betrifft, war dieses über Jahrzehnte Gegenstand der Deutsche Frage|Deutschen Frage, zumindest zwischen 1848 und 1871. Muß daher (ohne Rechtfertigungsversuch für den inzwischen überholten Gedanken) in angemessener Form mit dort hinein. Sofern machbar: und '''|Neutralitäts-Baustein'''. Denn der Sachverhalt wird wohl nicht in 7 Tagen auszuleuchten sein""" Löschung von Deutsche Stämme Wikipedia:Neutralität Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
2468 7525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs that debuted at number ninety-five on the Billboard Hot 100 in 2020 User:doomsdayer520 14:44, 20 October 2020 (UTC) delete This was probably created by a chart watcher who likes trivia and number patterns, and that's okay for geek purposes but it does not belong on Wikipedia per . In an early version of the article, the creator speculated that an unusually high number of songs debuted at #95 in 2020 alone, which may have kicked off a conspiracy theory among chart nerds, but it could just be a wild coincidence Deletion of List of songs that debuted at number ninety-five on the Billboard Hot 100 in 2020 WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2469 4836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Hidden Curriculum User:Ad 16:16, 23 October 2016 (UTC) delete per . It's an unencyclopedic combination of WP:NOTESSAY and WP:PLOT, full of what smells like WP:OR. Its referencing is simply unacceptable. I have added multiple CN tags. While I concede the subject may be notable, this article is a disaster on wheels. Blow it up and start over Deletion of The Hidden Curriculum WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
2470 10092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canada at the 2017 World Games User:Lugnuts 08:23, 2 December 2015 (UTC) keep """per - """"1.Individual scheduled or expected future events should be included only if the event is notable and almost certain to take place""" Deletion of Canada at the 2017 World Games WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2471 16533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Staton User:Otolemur 04:43, 23 May 2008 (UTC) delete Fails / Deletion of Ali Staton WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2472 11764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sir Elwoodin hiljaiset värit User:Richard3120 20:41, 12 August 2019 (UTC) keep lots of charting records in Finland, both singles and albums https://finnishcharts.com/showitem.asp?interpret=Sir+Elwoodin+Hiljaiset+V%E4rit&titel=Pahaa+verta&cat=s, two gold discs https://www.ifpi.fi/tutkimukset-ja-tilastot/kulta-ja-platinalevyt/?q=Sir+Elwoodin+hiljaiset+v%C3%A4rit... clearly a popular group in Finland and easily passes Deletion of Sir Elwoodin hiljaiset värit WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
2473 8781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orland Park Crossing User:Reddragon7 10:37, 8 January 2019 (UTC) delete lacks in sources and doesn't meet Deletion of Orland Park Crossing WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2474 17350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jentri Anders User:AllyD 06:31, 19 May 2013 (UTC) delete I have added a couple of sources to the article. However the passing mention of her interview in a film in the Washington Post plus the brief discussion of her book in one other book do not seem sufficient for criteria such as Deletion of Jentri Anders :WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2475 676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dick Lane (Cutler Heights, Bradford) User:Ohconfucius 03:53, 21 June 2007 (UTC) delete WP:HOLE|undistinguished road in an industrial estate. #DIRECTORY|Wikipedia is not a directory Deletion of Dick Lane (Cutler Heights, Bradford) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2476 12413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jocelyne Couture-Nowak User:JoshuaZ 18:37, 21 April 2007 (UTC) delete Youngamerican makes a good argument although the way he says it sounds almost like a deliberate caricature, but the basic idea holds true. BanyanTree, Rbelln, Nyttend and María also make good points. It appears that even the people advocating keeping acknowledge at this point that the article does not meet . The argument must therefore be made under . However, longstanding precedent is that in general victims of tragedies whose lives are reported in detail merely due to their being victims of horrific events does not count for purposes of . See as well as many precedents set by among other things, the myriad of Sept 11 AfDs and many articles about individuals who have died in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Cases like Sarah Payne are different because her death led directly to knew laws and regulations named after her. I strongly doubt that there will be any Couture-Nowak law made after this. This woman died tragically, and maybe even would have become a notable academic in her field if she had survived. However, she does not at present meet standard inclusion criteria Deletion of Jocelyne Couture-Nowak WP:PROF||WP:BIO||WP:BIO||WP:MEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2477 20507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel O'Brien (comedian) User:Dream 10:44, 5 December 2012 (UTC) keep """Ample coverage of him at Forbes http://www.forbes.com/sites/ryanholiday/2012/04/16/exclusive-how-comedian-daniel-obrien-turned-one-joke-into-a-major-book-deal/. He clearly passes #1 and #2, as his episodes and other work are seen by millions. Also #4 since his work has """"won significant critical attention""" Deletion of Daniel O'Brien (comedian) WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2478 11503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicole Pullar User:GiantSnowman 12:52, 15 January 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Nicole Pullar WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2479 15688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/White thunder User:IslaySolomon 06:45, 12 November 2006 (UTC) delete WP:V|Unverified |original research. Almost certainly |made up in school one day. The band's been around since 1988, but the average age of its members is 16... interesting. The single worst attempt at |sock puppetry ever (above), hasn't really helped Deletion of White thunder WP:OR||WP:NFT||WP:SOCK Wikipedia:No original research 65
2480 21355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cockring User:Mhking 16:39, 18 March 2007 (UTC) delete violates Deletion of Cockring WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
2481 18202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark C. Urban User:David 05:44, 5 August 2016 (UTC) keep u|Nicholasarisco}} has already demonstrated a pass of but he also passes #C1 with many highly-cited publicatlons (e.g. 9 with over 100 citations each in Google scholar Deletion of Mark C. Urban WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2482 3792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/10th Anniversary User:Armbrust 13:14, 16 September 2010 (UTC) delete """as article fails |notability criteria for books. The """"Women's Murder Club series"""" should be created first, it it meets notability criteria""" Deletion of 10th Anniversary WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2483 9598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Story of the Setting Sun and The Moon User:4meter4 18:42, 3 October 2019 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of A Story of the Setting Sun and The Moon WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2484 7523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hal Rockland User:Bmclaughlin9 02:32, 27 January 2010 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Hal Rockland WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2485 14725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emotes User:Patar 04:21, 19 April 2021 (UTC) merge to emote as {{t|R from plural}}. Current article fails and Deletion of Emotes WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2486 11910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ghulam Haider Blogger User:Drchriswilliams 20:09, 20 December 2015 (UTC) delete The article appears promotional. no reliable sources. The article fails to establish notability of this living person, who on current evidence does not meet , or Deletion of Ghulam Haider Blogger WP:ANYBIO||WP:CREATIVE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2487 3265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amaury Guichon User:Atlantic306 17:01, 18 May 2017 (UTC) delete this autobiography is also a case of Deletion of Amaury Guichon WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2488 14753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 SOCATA TBM crash User:BilCat 07:40, 7 September 2014 (UTC) keep For now, at least. It meets in having significant media coverage in reliable sources, and is likely to be continuing coverage as there are many unanswered questions about the circumstances of crash, especially the apparently-denied request to descend to a lower altitude. If it should prove to be non-notable once the investigation has finished, unlikely though that seems at this time, then it can be merged to the aircraft article Deletion of 2014 SOCATA TBM crash WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2489 11090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Ekber Çiçek User:Animalparty 05:11, 6 May 2015 (UTC) keep """http://www.jstor.org/stable/834293?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents This JSTOR article, while not thorough, devotes about a page in total to Çiçek (also spelled Çiçik- other variants may exist and yield more sources), calling Çiçek a master virtuoso of the Bağlama and """"Of these other virtuosos, Cicek was one of the first to engage in compositional activity while experimenting with new approaches to the refashioning of indigenous repertory"""" thus it is very likely other sources exist in folk music encyclopedias, scholarly or popular books. By no means do sources need to be online, free, or |even English""" Deletion of Ali Ekber Çiçek WP:NONENG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2490 3034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sri Chandrasekharendra Saraswati VII User:Abecedare 22:16, 23 February 2010 (UTC) merge """The subject is possibly notable, but I could not locate any reliable sources online. At present we can only write a 1 line sourced stub (""""... was a Shankaracharya at the Kanchi Math from 1897-94""""), based on the http://www.kamakoti.org/peeth/origin.html Kanchi Math website, which has glaring |redflag issues (see""" Deletion of Sri Chandrasekharendra Saraswati VII WP:REDFLAG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2491 3311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yitong Law Firm User:Dream 23:35, 20 November 2011 (UTC) keep Significant coverage in reliable sources has been found. Nominator should follow and take a moment to check the Google news archive search before nominating this. Ample results, Northamerica1000 already mentioning some good ones Deletion of Yitong Law Firm WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
2492 18052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Six Families of Berlin User:Orangemike 15:36, 9 July 2010 (UTC) delete obvious racist engaged in |bogus original research and fraudulent synthesis Deletion of Six Families of Berlin :WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2493 8511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ivan Antonov (Professional Gamer) User:Cjmclark 06:26, 25 October 2011 (UTC) delete """7 of the 9 sources on the page discuss """"player transactions,"""" for lack of a better term, and cannot be used to establish notability. The other 2 sources consist of the results of a gamer forum fan poll (also not useful for notability) and of a tournament in which his ''team'' placed...his name isn't even mentioned. At best this could be userified to one of the supporters until such time as firm notability standards for """"e-sports"""" are established (if consensus deems such standards are necessary beyond ), or it could go to at that time. On a side note, I don't think that some of the folks here appreciate that it is far more common to use GNG to rescue an article from AfD for ''not'' meeting the SNG than it is the other way around. And that neither guideline guarantees notability""" Deletion of Ivan Antonov (Professional Gamer) WP:GNG||WP:DRV Wikipedia:Notability 77
2494 20496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zolzaya Munkhtseren User:GretLomborg 05:24, 17 July 2017 (UTC) delete autobiography & subject doesn't meet Deletion of Zolzaya Munkhtseren WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2495 11482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcus Stanley (musician) User:Huesofcolor 09:01, 1 August 2015 (UTC) keep Passes and Deletion of Marcus Stanley (musician) WP:GNG||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2496 11594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lauren Prott User:GiantSnowman 07:47, 31 May 2019 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Lauren Prott WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2497 9458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Promotional mix User:Hisashiyarouin 01:12, 29 August 2014 (UTC) keep following good fix by Tom. is not needed now (could need more expanding though Deletion of Promotional mix WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
2498 690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Korn's ninth studio album (2nd nomination) User:Doc 13:24, 5 September 2008 (UTC) delete Hey, McWomble stole my |crystal |hammer bit! (not like I mind). Anyway, remember, this is a band who Untitled Korn album|simply didn't title their eighth record, so I wouldn't be surprised if the title isn't announced for a long time, so that part of isn't applicable. But there's no tracklisting and they're not even in the studio yet, so it still gets bonked on the head with a crystal hammer (The Wizard of Evergreen Terrace|patent pending Deletion of Korn's ninth studio album (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2499 16050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al karims User:Terenceong1992 16:38, 27 January 2006 (UTC) delete non-notable, anyway |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball Deletion of Al karims WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2500 13876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coulrophilia (2nd nomination) User:Rameshnta909 18:19, 9 December 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Coulrophilia (2nd nomination) WP:NAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
2501 1379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yellow cab User:Dhartung 09:11, 16 May 2007 (UTC) keep Yellow cab (stereotype). Excellent by CaliforniaAliBaba aka cab. http://www.mssv.net/wiki.cgi?Eponysterical Eponysterical Deletion of Yellow cab WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
2502 18105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mira Gonzalez (2nd nomination) User:Omni 02:17, 12 October 2016 (UTC) keep as subject quite clearly meets . Multiple independent reliable sources such as https://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2015/sep/03/mira-gonzalez-poems-digital-era-lily-allen, http://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry-news/people/article/68064-four-questions-for-poet-mira-gonzalez.html and http://theeconomymagazine.com/I-Will-Never-Be-Beautiful-Enough-to-Make-Us-Beautiful-Together-Mira. I would suggest a close Deletion of Mira Gonzalez (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Notability 77
2503 21934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aakash Pandey User:Abecedare 14:52, 15 May 2015 (UTC) delete Subject has played minor and supporting roles in various films and TV shows, but fails and . Mentioned only in passing in cited media articles (which themselves are mostly second-tier sources), eg http://www.tellychakkar.com/tv/tv-news/its-bday-time-parmeet-sethi-dayanand-shetty-hrishikesh-pandey-and-akash-pandey, http://www.metromasti.com/page/biography/53633 and I couldn't locate anything more comprehensive Deletion of Aakash Pandey WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2504 6405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stars Align (R3hab and Jolin Tsai song) User:Cunard 15:00, 7 July 2021 (UTC) keep Article needs a little expansion. Other than that, it's good enough to pass , especially with reliable sources indicated by Deletion of Stars Align (R3hab and Jolin Tsai song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2505 13316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Music to Raise the Dead (2nd nomination) User:The 02:54, 28 October 2011 (UTC) keep and speedy close - immediately re-opening the AfD after the last one closed smells of yness Deletion of Music to Raise the Dead (2nd nomination) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
2506 15384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RScript User:Dlohcierekim 05:25, 2 September 2008 (UTC) delete """As it was just released yesterday, it hardly has had time to become notable. I found no |reliable, |verifable sources. The thing http://www.freewebs.com/rscript/ is hosted on freewebs, and has had no hits on it's forum. This gives the appearance of a start-up from yesterday. No hits for """"Rabbid Script"""". Many for RScript, but there are many other uses. Charlie Parker, the musician gets many G-hits. Only 3 for Charlie Parker + Rscript. Google news has seven archives, unrelated. It seems to me that this is promotional in nature based on talk page content @ Talk:RScript and general lack of any info anywhere else, and brand newness of subject.Cheers""" Deletion of RScript WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2507 16370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John McSoriley User:Colapeninsula 14:03, 13 November 2013 (UTC) delete Lack of third-party coverage, fails . Not notable as a writer or public official Deletion of John McSoriley WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2508 9915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phillip Reilly User:Nfitz 03:47, 6 September 2008 (UTC) keep We've established previously that articles can exist for players in the top league of football in Ireland. Most recently in Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neil Gallagher (footballer) which I note was closed as a keep no less than 36 minutes before this AfD was started. As that AfD was started by the same person as this one, this is clearly a nomination Deletion of Phillip Reilly WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
2509 14017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of apologetic works User:A1octopus 12:55, 23 April 2007 (UTC) delete Wikipedia:Listcruft|Listcruft article that could never be completed nor could entry criteria ever be agreed upon. #IINFO|Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of List of apologetic works WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2510 8318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonezetta User:DarthVader 10:08, 12 May 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Jonezetta WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2511 2020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rock paper User:The 23:06, 13 September 2008 (UTC) delete as joke article, per Deletion of Rock paper WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
2512 12511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caritamo Foundation User:Shoy 19:03, 1 August 2016 (UTC) delete Fails . This may be a situation if the foundation was just created Deletion of Caritamo Foundation WP:NCORP||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
2513 14798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The New York Times and the Holocaust User:Loonymonkey 02:19, 15 January 2010 (UTC) delete """As currently written, it's just an essay (and not a very good one at that). It's plagued with and problems (as well as clear ax-to-grind issues) but it's difficult to imagine how this could be corrected through editing. If it were boiled down to the notable and the reliably sourced, it would just be a stub of an article, a paragraph or two in length. Really, the entire article seems to be a summary of a single source, the book by Leff (which also accounts for almost all of the cites in the article). The claims and opinions of that author are repeated as fact, producing ridiculously non-NPOV language like """"...Sulzeberger’s firmly held personal beliefs that it was wrong to ever treat Jews as a people"""" or """"The paper of record deliberately hid the Holocaust from the American people."""" Since this article exists to simply repeat the thesis of a single book (with a little original research thrown in as well) it's not possible for mere editing to make it compliant with Wikipedia policies""" Deletion of The New York Times and the Holocaust WP:OR||WP:SYNTH||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
2514 17428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carmella Bing (3rd nomination) User:Meters 18:24, 7 September 2016 (UTC) delete A Wikipedia article must be based on significant coverage in multiple, independent, reliable secondary sources, per . This article, on the other hand, is based primarily on IAFD, which, for the reasons stated by Deletion of Carmella Bing (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2515 1109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lin Liangming User:GiantSnowman 09:32, 7 November 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Lin Liangming WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2516 11246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asif Ali Malik (2nd nomination) User:TonyBallioni 21:31, 15 December 2013 (UTC) keep per Necrothesp. He meets by having been an elected member of the Punjab assembly Deletion of Asif Ali Malik (2nd nomination) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2517 7250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raphaël Fortin User:Bearcat 20:08, 24 September 2020 (UTC) delete without prejudice against creation of a redirect to the party afterward. There was once a time when we just routinely handed leaders of minor unrepresented political parties an automatic notability freebie for being political party leaders, regardless of their sourceability or lack thereof, but that's been deprecated for quite a while now. The test that such a leader has to pass today require much more |reliable source coverage ''about'' his work ''in'' the leadership than this is showing, and just being able to offer one or two sources demonstrating the technical fact that he was selected as leader is not enough all by itself Deletion of Raphaël Fortin WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2518 2705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1x1 music User:Esradekan 04:09, 27 November 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability per Deletion of 1x1 music WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2519 18445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Travis Boyd (ice hockey) User:Ejgreen77 05:50, 27 March 2017 (UTC) keep Meets and , per Rlendog's sources & research Deletion of Travis Boyd (ice hockey) WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2520 10562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Armenian terrorism User:The 12:15, 29 December 2009 (UTC) delete per nominator, and also per , Deletion of Armenian terrorism WP:SYN||WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:No original research 65
2521 5472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cory Davenport User:Pharmboy 19:26, 18 October 2008 (UTC) delete """as G11. To quote the article: """"''Cory Davenport (1968-) is one of the most creative botanical designers of the recent decades''"""", and it gets worse. Barfing on |peacock feathers""" Deletion of Cory Davenport WP:peacock Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
2522 8805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Industrial plastic pipe systems User:Flyguy649 06:11, 8 August 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Since the article was created by a sock of a banned user, it may be speediable under #G5 Deletion of Industrial plastic pipe systems WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
2523 21010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The hit squad User:Juliancolton NONE delete As non-notable and per Deletion of The hit squad WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2524 17590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shehab Khan NONE NONE delete This might be , but applies. I could find mentions but nothing that meets SIGCOV addressing the subject directly and indepth Deletion of Shehab Khan WP:TOOSOON||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Too soon 40
2525 7388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jane Bom-Bane User:Stuartyeates 23:24, 20 July 2012 (UTC) delete as failing and Deletion of Jane Bom-Bane WP:MUSICBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2526 10793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Pork User:Ice 04:39, 9 August 2008 (UTC) delete due to lack of |reliable sources Deletion of The Pork WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2527 5425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Human photosynthesis User:McGeddon 11:32, 3 October 2015 (UTC) delete """as human ; the only sources that deal with the subject directly are papers from the Human Photosynthesis Study Center (whose website will sell you a box of """"QIAPI 1"""" photosynthesis pills for $55), the other two refer to related melanin processes without going so far as calling it """"photosynthesis"""". The rest seems ; concluding that a long-distance swimmer was possibly photosynthesing because they had a suntan is ridiculous. There may be an article to be written about fringe theories of human photosynthesis, but not with any of this content""" Deletion of Human photosynthesis WP:SYN||WP:PRIMARY||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2528 2655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Time Superlation Theory User:DV8 19:46, 30 April 2006 (UTC) delete as vio Deletion of The Time Superlation Theory WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2529 7899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hold Tight (Justin Bieber song) User:Status 00:28, 13 December 2013 (UTC) keep There are http://www.complexmag.ca/music/2013/10/justin-bieber-hold-tight plenty of http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1715875/justin-bieber-hold-tight-music-mondays.jhtml reliable http://www.billboard.com/articles/columns/pop-shop/5763139/justin-biebers-stuck-in-love-on-hold-tight-track-listen sources http://ca.eonline.com/news/472495/justin-bieber-releases-sexy-new-song-hold-tight-listen-now covering http://www.rap-up.com/2013/10/20/new-music-justin-bieber-hold-tight/ the song. On top of that, it charted on several national charts. That's more than enough for the song to pass . — Deletion of Hold Tight (Justin Bieber song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2530 11220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Progressive Foundation User:CAPTAIN 19:01, 21 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Progressive Foundation WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2531 6526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ultima Dragons User:TJ 21:35, 21 September 2006 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Ultima Dragons WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2532 795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chuck Finley (Burn Notice) User:Jfgslo 15:20, 18 June 2011 (UTC) delete The fictional character as an individual subject does not meet the |general notability guideline and the article is mostly a |plot-only description of a fictional work that does not provide reception or significance for the fictional character. Per sgeureka's argument and to generate consensus, a merge to Sam Axe is an acceptable outcome Deletion of Chuck Finley (Burn Notice) WP:GNG||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2533 5591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evidence regarding Bigfoot User:TexasAndroid 15:59, 29 October 2009 (UTC) keep Proper split performed per and . Problems with the POV of the sub-article are reasons to fix the sub-article, not to delete it or shoe-horn it back into the main article Deletion of Evidence regarding Bigfoot WP:SIZE||WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Article size 51
2534 5817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Bishop User:Artw 00:30, 8 April 2017 (UTC) keep Needs expansion and additional references but I would argue that as an editor of 2000ad and the Judge Dredd Megazine for a good portion of the 90s and in the process of that bringing a good deal of new talent into the comics industry, as well as being the instigator for the creation of several well known comics characters, he meets the 1st and 3rd critera of Deletion of David Bishop WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2535 18580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dean Hohl User:Gaarmyvet 21:26, 7 September 2017 (UTC) delete Leading Concepts, Inc. has no coverage outside of self-generated promotional/contacts forums; thus, no Deletion of Dean Hohl WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
2536 3235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vernon Hargreaves III User:X96lee15 17:32, 19 March 2014 (UTC) keep I'm usually all about voting delete on run-of-the-mill BCS players, but it appears this one is notable (best HS cornerback, first-team SEC as frosh) per Deletion of Vernon Hargreaves III WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2537 4969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamilton Island Triathlon User:LibStar 13:33, 28 November 2010 (UTC) delete WP:NSPORT#Individual_games_or_series|WP:NSPORT and . a relatively small event that does not warrant a WP article Deletion of Hamilton Island Triathlon WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2538 13460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Outline of natural language processing User:The 09:19, 19 April 2019 (UTC) delete This is not a subject that has been independently the object (no pun intended) of outside sources. The subject is concocted (not necessarily baselessly, from a scientific point of view) and then supported by related (reliable) sources that refer, though, to the ''elements'' of this research and not on the research ''subject'' per se. It appears this is yet another of those theses that could possibly be useful in a scientific context but has no place in Wikipedia; this project is neither |a forum or a journal for scientific research and publications, nor |an unruly listing of information Deletion of Outline of natural language processing WP:NOTJOURNAL||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2539 13192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gurinder Singh Mann User:XOR 22:50, 8 April 2018 (UTC) keep Passes #C5 for having held a named chair, and passes as well Deletion of Gurinder Singh Mann WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2540 13388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Policijska stanica User:SkierRMH 20:09, 28 June 2007 (UTC) delete I asked the creator to reference several of these on 13 June, with no reply or action. There are no IMDB /AMG listings or any other good references for any of the above. Violates w/ notability concerns Deletion of Policijska stanica WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2541 5661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kern, Alaska User:Necrothesp 15:36, 24 May 2019 (UTC) keep Seems to have existed and notable per Deletion of Kern, Alaska WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
2542 16994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Surprice Cars User:Piotrus 02:23, 17 September 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Surprice Cars WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2543 10514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yun Chol (weightlifter) User:Insertcleverphrasehere 00:48, 3 February 2020 (UTC) merge """to Weightlifting at the 1992 Summer Olympics – Men's 90 kg. The deletion rationale is actually reasonable. I hate all of these """"Keep per NOLY"""" arguments. It is a ''terrible'' precedent that has been set at AfD. If it can't meet the GNG it shouldn't be an article; this applies to all sportsperson articles. NOLY and other things at the sports SNG don't create notability. I believe that sources probably exist, but are not searchable in English on the internet. How good they are is another thing entirely. While geopolitical issues interfere with being able to do a search properly, I don't believe that we should have BLP articles for subjects that can't be sourced reliably""" Deletion of Yun Chol (weightlifter) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
2544 4567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vanguard (band) User:DarjeelingTea 21:17, 15 February 2017 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Vanguard (band) WP:NMUSICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2545 12463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maf, Shamkir User:Cunard 08:21, 30 October 2009 (UTC) comment Relisted for the final time to generate discussion about whether the existence of Maf, Shamkir can be |verified Deletion of Maf, Shamkir WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2546 15382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandra Fluke User:Bbb23 22:34, 3 March 2012 (UTC) delete Per classic Deletion of Sandra Fluke WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2547 10888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Yang (entrepreneur) User:Bearian 17:02, 10 September 2020 (UTC) delete per nom, , , and . Totally lacking in any sources to build a . We are not a resume service, and everybody in 2020 knows that Deletion of David Yang (entrepreneur) WP:MILL||WP:GNG||WP:NOTRESUME||WP:SIGCOV||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
2548 4316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Current characters of The Young and the Restless User:Rjd0060 04:57, 18 November 2007 (UTC) delete Per the nom. Completely a character |plot. Unnecessary; any importance of these characters should be (...probably already is) mentioned in one of the other articles for the show Deletion of Current characters of The Young and the Restless WP:PLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2549 5196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fully sick User:Insanephantom 12:26, 9 January 2007 (UTC) delete per some above comments as |neologism. Or maybe put in Wiktionary Deletion of Fully sick WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
2550 17358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UD Alzira User:Fenix 09:34, 26 October 2015 (UTC) keep meets Deletion of UD Alzira WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2551 15580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Tolbert User:TBC 05:41, 17 February 2007 (UTC) delete I couldn't find any |verification of his alleged contract with Comedy Central; Google shows few, if any, relevant resultshttp://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Scott+Tolbert%22+comedian&btnG=Google+Search Deletion of Scott Tolbert WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2552 19660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ek-sen-trik-kuh Discordia User:Wickethewok 05:12, 18 May 2006 (UTC) comment Indeed, Hetar. In fact, according to , '''We may not use primary sources whose information has not been made available by a reliable publisher'''. All of the sources cited most certainly fall under this category Deletion of Ek-sen-trik-kuh Discordia WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2553 19946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stop Dead User:STATicVerseatide 05:13, 7 July 2013 (UTC) delete Pretty clearly fails Deletion of Stop Dead WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
2554 2264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Olly Groome User:Peripitus 13:35, 2 June 2006 (UTC) delete as nn bio- fails and is not funny enough for BJAODN Deletion of Olly Groome WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
2555 12243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Northanger Horrid Novels User:NewYorkActuary 20:22, 23 April 2016 (UTC) merge as noted above. This seems a clear-cut example of Deletion of Northanger Horrid Novels WP:NOPAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2556 3214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ho Chiu Yeng User:Eggishorn 14:54, 20 December 2017 (UTC) delete The article re-creator has asked for my opinion via my talk page but did not ask for a specific opinion, making this borderline canvassing. Given the abundance of bad faith editing connected with this topic, they clearly hoped I would !vote for keep. They are going to be disappointed. I see nothing in the article or the sources provided here (including what Google Translate can help me make of the Chinese ones) that substantiates qualification. The significant sources are not independent and the independent sources are not significantly about the article subject. The latter category is mostly about other subjects to which this subject is connected through family ties Deletion of Ho Chiu Yeng WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2557 21871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/28 Months Later [[User talk:Snigbrook|Snigbrook]] 14:30, 30 January 2009 (UTC) merge to 28 Weeks Later#Sequel, where it is mentioned. Too soon for a separate article, as there is a lack of significant coverage (), and not enough confirmed information (, Deletion of 28 Months Later WP:N||WP:V||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2558 7656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farzad Esmaili User:K 21:44, 21 November 2016 (UTC) delete """or '''redirect''' to Islamic Republic of Iran Air Defense Force (as that's what """"Air Defense Base"""" is piped to) per ; despite a technical pass of (which is an essay, BTW, not an SNG), this subject does not qualify for a stand-alone article just yet. No sources have been presented at this AfD that cover the subject directly and in detail. applies -- he may be more notable in the future, if he does something notable and gets the requisite coverage. Not just yet""" Deletion of Farzad Esmaili WP:WHYN||WP:SOLDIER||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
2559 8938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vampire: Undeath v.1 User:DESiegel 15:59, 21 June 2007 (UTC) delete as per my nom unless there are citations of independent |reliable sources added to the article that establish notability (which i doubt Deletion of Vampire: Undeath v.1 WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2560 19050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ramachandra Mohapatra User:Icewhiz 08:32, 4 February 2019 (UTC) delete Content fails . I'm not certain the gbooks hits by Bridger are on the same individual, and even if they are - it doesn't seem he passes GNG Deletion of Ramachandra Mohapatra WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2561 4659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Lucas (21st Century Ohio politician) User:JohnCD 12:05, 4 February 2009 (UTC) delete it only made the papers because he was a candidate: per that doesn't give him notability, and no other notability is suggested Deletion of Robert Lucas (21st Century Ohio politician) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2562 10279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Mackin User:Tokyogirl79 04:01, 11 June 2014 (UTC) comment I've cleaned out the worst of the sourcing, as much of it was such as the guy's own website and a routine notification of an event. I also removed duplicates of the same source, as the same interview was posted in several different newspapers. For the original editor and anyone coming in, a news story is considered to be one source, regardless of where it is posted or re-posted Deletion of Joseph Mackin WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
2563 1700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samsung HL-R5688W User:SL93 00:53, 29 June 2017 (UTC) delete Clearly non-notable product. Fails Deletion of Samsung HL-R5688W WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2564 13709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shriya Jha User:Sodabottle 16:47, 22 August 2011 (UTC) keep """She was in two Telugu films in 2007 (mainstream ones with wide releases etc). And those are lead roles not minor ones. I think she just makes our criteria. (""""significant roles in multiple films""" Deletion of Shriya Jha WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2565 18076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trevor Grant (programmer) User:Nsk92 11:37, 24 February 2021 (UTC) delete """Can't find any publications by this subject (even though he is characterized as an """"author"""" in the article) or any independent sources covering him. Does not appear to pass or any other notability guidelines""" Deletion of Trevor Grant (programmer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2566 12424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Appleyard (2nd nomination) User:Z1720 00:17, 17 October 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and The sources in the article are either unreliable, mentions in passing, broken (and unobtainable from the Way Back Machine) or promotional in nature. The ESPN interview could be used to show notability, and I found a short profile of him from the Toronto Star on Jan. 1, 2003 in a ProQuest database but I can't find the article on TS's website (ProQuest's links reveal the library's location and I don't want to out myself). However, these two sources are not enough significant coverage to determine notability. I searched Google, JSTOR, NYT and Gale for but did not find usable sources there Deletion of Mark Appleyard (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2567 9735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beer Auction Game User:Mark 20:01, 23 March 2014 (UTC) delete While the Beer distribution game is a well-known game exercise illustrating problems in supply chain prediction, this game appears not to have yet gained notability. I could find no independent reliable sources. At best, Deletion of Beer Auction Game WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
2568 2990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Speak Love Life Lessons (album) User:Gongshow 05:57, 4 June 2013 (UTC) delete per #A9|A9; the artist's page Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexis Houston (2nd nomination)|has been deleted Deletion of Speak Love Life Lessons (album) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
2569 12343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ghostbusters III User:Jersey 00:41, 19 May 2006 (UTC) delete per a crystal ball. No release date, simply rumors and speculation Deletion of Ghostbusters III WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2570 1430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Postmodernism and Me User:Scientizzle 21:14, 18 May 2006 (UTC) delete non-notable. , clearly Deletion of Postmodernism and Me WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
2571 8060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Che’Nelle User:Terence 14:36, 31 May 2006 (UTC) keep meets Deletion of Che’Nelle WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2572 6396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyrell Fortune User:PRehse 19:01, 1 January 2018 (UTC) delete As per nominator. Does not meet Deletion of Tyrell Fortune WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
2573 17312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Direct Guide to Green Dragons in Chaos Tunnels User:Haipa 14:54, 25 June 2009 (UTC) delete as clear |game guide content Deletion of Direct Guide to Green Dragons in Chaos Tunnels WP:GAMEGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2574 20191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Deans User:Papaursa 20:46, 7 August 2017 (UTC) delete Fails both and . Has never competed at the highest level Deletion of Steven Deans WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
2575 16833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Permanent North American Gaeltacht [[User talk:Angr|Angr]] 18:42, 1 August 2007 (UTC) delete """apparent hoax, or at best so very much still """"in planning"""" as to be deletable per """ Deletion of Permanent North American Gaeltacht WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2576 7034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yusuf Gobir NONE NONE keep """Most senior civil servant in the Ministry of Defence during the Biafran crisis; eminently notable. Entries in biographical encyclopedia, meets c.3.{{cite book |last1=Uwechue |first1=Raph |last2=Limited |first2=Africa Books |title=Makers of Modern Africa |date=1991 |publisher=Africa Journal Limited |location=248 |url=https://www.google.com/books/edition/Makers_of_Modern_Africa/YkEOAQAAMAAJ |language=en}}{{cite book |last1=Adeogun |first1=Segun |title=Who is who in Kwara State? |date=1991 |publisher=Segun Adeogun |pages=100-101 |url=https://www.google.com/books/edition/Who_is_who_in_Kwara_State/WX4XAQAAIAAJ |language=en}} Frequent mentions across numerous texts which discuss Nigeria in the 1960s and 1970s. """"...Yusuf Gobir, and Edwin Ogbu, all of whom were highly regarded, and all of whom contributed immensely to preserving Nigeria's unity.""""{{cite book |last1=Ihonde |first1=Moses O. |title=First Call: An Account of the Gowon Years |date=2004 |publisher=Diamond Publications Limited |isbn=978-978-2938-25-1 |page=153 |url=https://www.google.com/books/edition/First_Call/i44PAQAAMAAJ |language=en""" Deletion of Yusuf Gobir WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2577 4199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/R G C Levens User:Bwithh 05:59, 15 December 2006 (UTC) delete Failure of and failure to assert substantive encyclopedic notability (even stubs should do this). The only insubstantive attempt made is the claim that he ''edited'' a classroom version of a speech or speeches by Cicero. A search of the http://library.ox.ac.uk Oxford library catalog turns up only the two books mentioned in the article plus a brief Greek translation of a Shakespeare scene he did as a student to win a student prize. Google Books (Oxford University Library is one of the 9 library partners of this project) returns 37 hits but no books by him. Of the 37 hits (some of them are inaccessible), I can only find one which is more than a passing mention or footnotehttp://books.google.com/books?q=%22r+g+c+levens%22&lr=&sa=N&start=0 (no hits for his full name Deletion of R G C Levens WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2578 4056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grey Party User:Bearian 01:58, 20 February 2009 (UTC) delete per all of the above and Deletion of Grey Party WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
2579 19949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pierre Kiandjan User:Lightburst 02:21, 18 October 2019 (UTC) keep passes our notability guide. An artist is known for their work. Check out the s https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Kiandjan on the article for our subject on the French WIKI. Perhaps an ambitious editor could add some of these sources here Deletion of Pierre Kiandjan WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2580 12853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nepal Tribune Media (2nd nomination) User:Orville1974 08:21, 4 June 2019 (UTC) delete Huh? The company is registered? I think it works that way in most countries for ''any'' company. Fails . Wikipedia is not Deletion of Nepal Tribune Media (2nd nomination) WP:NCORP||WP:YELLOWPAGES Wikipedia:Notability 77
2581 6929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shawn Carter (actor) User:Nocrowx 22:02, 2 October 2009 (UTC) keep I created this article because I think that he '''does have multiple significant roles as required by ''', which are available to view on IMDB, which the article links to. Other editors may wish to add more references or expand the article, but at the moment this is still a good stub, to make people aware of him, and it justifies Wikipedia inclusion. —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Shawn Carter (actor) WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2582 18826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pornopedia User:JohnWBarber 15:09, 19 October 2009 (UTC) delete Not seeing reliable sources in searching Google, Google News, Google Books, Google Scholar. Fails , Deletion of Pornopedia WP:WEB||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2583 9195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trajectory Hermeneutics User:Pete 20:51, 6 October 2007 (UTC) delete """http://books.google.com/books?id=pbwVnPnJy-QC&pg=PA65&lpg=PA65&dq=trajectory+hermeneutic&source=web&ots=JtNJBRX1j1&sig=J2NVp_cO8SXBrWd3b_-RVYlbolg this is the closest I can find to an , a book by the author (Grudem) of the review that is the only reference currently listed in the article. That reference exists to support elaboration upon the statement that """"One proponent of trajectory hermeneutics is William J. Webb"""", but it seems that Webb uses the term """"redemptive-movement hermeneutics"""" while Grudem calls it """"trajectory hermeneutics"""". In any case, while I don't think this is , I do think it fails and therefore . I'm willing to change my opinion if is supplied to show otherwise""" Deletion of Trajectory Hermeneutics WP:OR||WP:FRINGE||WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
2584 12636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Austin Highsmith User:Gongshow 00:50, 4 March 2014 (UTC) delete subject's roles to date do not appear to satisfy , and I'm not finding significant coverage to meet Deletion of Austin Highsmith WP:ENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2585 7189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Futurekids User:Sharkface217 03:09, 21 March 2008 (UTC) keep Appears to have established Deletion of Futurekids WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
2586 3776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Banks (journalist) User:Wikicology 18:09, 15 July 2015 (UTC) delete Sadly no evidence of |notability Deletion of Michael Banks (journalist) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2587 21008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kobi Karp Architecture & Interior Design User:Edwardx 00:20, 15 June 2018 (UTC) delete No in-depth independent coverage found. Fails Deletion of Kobi Karp Architecture & Interior Design WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2588 7365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joel (The Last of Us) User:Serial 15:02, 3 June 2020 (UTC) merge the game may well be {{tq|widely regarded as among the greatest of all time}}, but notability is |not inherited, and this particular character has received insufficient coverage in independent, third-party reliable sources to justify an independent article. {{u|Czar}}'s reasoning, as well as the analysis from {{u|Rhain}}, is wholly convincing Deletion of Joel (The Last of Us) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2589 9182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whorecore User:RP459 16:43, 6 March 2010 (UTC) delete non-notable band and albums are self release and fail Deletion of Whorecore WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
2590 4306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Young American Virtuosi User:Cocytus 03:05, 16 December 2009 (UTC) delete nothing I can find that makes them pass . Thus, does not merit inclusion Deletion of Young American Virtuosi WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
2591 2202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tammy Jennings User:Dweller 12:20, 18 January 2010 (UTC) comment I'm puzzled. If the world was so convinced she'll be notable in a few weeks' time, why isn't she whizzing past the normal criteria now Deletion of Tammy Jennings WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2592 18577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Engelbert Sonneborn User:SoWhy 08:02, 21 August 2017 (UTC) merge to German presidential election, 2017. With all due respect to my fellow Germans over at de-wiki, whose strict inclusion standards I often criticized, this is not really someone who is actually notable |outside this one event. He is mentioned in the election's article though, so redirecting makes more sense than deleting. Regards Deletion of Engelbert Sonneborn WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2593 11270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Spasyk User:Coredesat 10:08, 25 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails , |Wikipedia is not a free webhost Deletion of George Spasyk WP:BIO||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2594 2501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lela London User:StephenBuxton 00:05, 31 October 2010 (UTC) delete Cannot find anything beyond the one event. http://www.graziadaily.co.uk/fashion/archive/2010/10/26/harry-potter-bride-marries-in-knock-off-alexander-mcqueen.htm Grazia has picked up the story, by repeating her findings, but other than that I can't see anything to warrant an article about Ms London. If there are some reliable sources found about this event (other than those that just repeat her blog), then by all means it should be added to the film article (as per ).''(edit - just realised that I didn't add my sig. Whoops Deletion of Lela London WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2595 19812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/To Be Announced (Album) User:Enigmaman 06:20, 18 August 2008 (UTC) delete I agree with rspeer, and if nothing else, applies Deletion of To Be Announced (Album) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2596 19198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eon8 (2nd nomination) User:_ChadyWady 02:00, 2 July 2006 (UTC) delete due to Deletion of Eon8 (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2597 9727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthias Kuhle User:Eric 20:35, 30 March 2009 (UTC) delete The subject’s contributions are indeed in a variety of related topics, and suggest some measure of notability, but I could not find enough to clearly establish notability under . Does not seem to pass either. Citation impact, while not negligible, http://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_sauthors=%22Matthias+Kuhle%22 seems to be relatively low. Most widely held book in libraries, currently in less than 80 libraries worldwide according to http://www.worldcat.org WorldCat. News coverage exists, but is http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Matthias+Kuhle%22 not particularly impressive. As noted by Crusio before, the English WP is the main/global WP, so notability should be verifiable through international sources Deletion of Matthias Kuhle WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2598 14823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Classroom expectations and procedures User:Metropolitan90 01:25, 1 October 2005 (UTC) delete per all previous noms. #Wikipedia_is_not_an_instruction_manual|Wikipedia is not an instruction manual Deletion of Classroom expectations and procedures WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2599 5145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PJ Liguori User:Atlantic306 01:41, 31 March 2016 (UTC) keep in view of the reliable sources above, particularly the Deadline Hollywood article, passes Deletion of PJ Liguori WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2600 11915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Today in Focus [[User talk:Czar|czar]] 16:48, 16 November 2019 (UTC) merge a mention per nom, whose rationale is sound. Once the primary sources are removed, this podcast is not |independently notable Deletion of Today in Focus WP:42 Wikipedia:The answer to life, the universe, and everything 7
2601 4508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aliza Shvarts User:TJRC 19:25, 18 April 2008 (UTC) delete per . Let's not confuse newsworthiness, which is fleeting, with notability, which is not Deletion of Aliza Shvarts WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2602 13882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Florinel Enache User:Dricherby 09:48, 8 June 2013 (UTC) keep Doesn't meet but the coverage described above seems to go beyond so I think this meets Deletion of Florinel Enache WP:SOLDIER||WP:ROUTINE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2603 16838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vinay Deolalikar User:FD 09:02, 17 August 2010 (UTC) delete Not |notable, 15 minutes of fame does not merit his inclusion on Wikipedia Deletion of Vinay Deolalikar WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2604 16381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neo-Buddhists User:Anirvan 23:39, 5 August 2006 (UTC) delete """to Indian Buddhist Movement (neo-Buddhism is another term for contemporary Buddhism in India). This is an |original research Wikipedia:Attack page|attack page |POV fork. The article discusses Biblical concepts of race, the role of the caste system in Indian Islam, the proposition that """"Hindu"""" means """"Indian"""" -- everything ''besides'' an encyclopedic discussion of contemporary Indian Buddhists""" Deletion of Neo-Buddhists WP:OR||WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:No original research 65
2605 10574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dynix (software) User:Northamerica1000 16:38, 28 May 2012 (UTC) keep """The topic appears to at least meet , per http://www.libraryjournal.com/lj/ljinprintcurrentissue/871774-403/automation_system_marketplace_2004_migration.html.csp, http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=bkRhRA6h8J4C&lpg=PA437&dq=Dynix%20library&pg=PA437#v=onepage&q=Dynix%20library&f=false. Per section of Wikipedia's Deletion policy, """"If the page can be improved, this should be solved through regular editing, rather than deletion""" Deletion of Dynix (software) WP:GNG||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
2606 11289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prinzzess User:Epbr123 08:54, 21 October 2008 (UTC) keep Passes and hasn't asked for her article to be deleted Deletion of Prinzzess WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2607 472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wu-Invasion Mixtape Series: World Edition Volume 1 User:Richard3120 16:51, 18 July 2018 (UTC) delete fails . And there won't be any independent sources for this, because the albums are only available through Wu Tang's website, AND the contributing artists pay to have their tracks included on the Wu Invasion albums. In short, it's a money-making exercise with the Wu Tang Clan's names on it for publicity purposes Deletion of Wu-Invasion Mixtape Series: World Edition Volume 1 WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
2608 1971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesus Taught Me User:Sxeptomaniac 18:34, 22 September 2009 (UTC) keep I was primarily concerned about the significant issues when I nominated it the first time. I'm still not really sure it's a worthwhile article, but I'll lean a little towards keep for this nomination and see if it can improve with a little more time Deletion of Jesus Taught Me WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2609 4151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bust of Bernardo O'Higgins (Houston) User:Another_Believer NONE merge as previously suggested, doesn't merit own article per . There is not much in the Houston Chronicle archives in the stories referenced by Deletion of Bust of Bernardo O'Higgins (Houston) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2610 4189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rachel Uchitel User:Rdm2376 21:52, 6 December 2009 (UTC) delete or redirect per . Were it not for the Woods connection, what is left would be a clear case of non-notability. A couple of mentions over several years does not add up to anything approaching notability Deletion of Rachel Uchitel WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2611 20937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Burns (businessman) User:Bearian 01:37, 18 September 2019 (UTC) delete per , . The page is filled with trivia, such as his house was listed for sale. His name is Mr. Burns, but not ''that'' Mr. Burns. Really Deletion of Donald Burns (businessman) WP:GNG||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2612 790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Damien Sojoyner User:XOR 21:52, 24 June 2018 (UTC) comment """I turned up three academic reviews of his book https://doi.org/10.1111/aeq.12204https://doi.org/10.1111/amet.12579https://doi.org/10.1353/anq.2018.0020. That's a step on the way to passing , but he only has the one book http://faculty.sites.uci.edu/sojoyner/publications/. """"Multiple reviews of multiple books each"""" seems to be the bar to clear in practice with that criterion. At the moment, I'm inclined to say that this article is just |too soon""" Deletion of Damien Sojoyner WP:AUTHOR||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
2613 21252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abington stanley User:SkierRMH 01:43, 30 December 2006 (UTC) delete """even as a non-sports fan, I can figure out that """"Mens Sunday league"""" players aren't quite meeting the /sports criteria""" Deletion of Abington stanley WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2614 1978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syntasoft User:AllyD 07:04, 16 May 2018 (UTC) delete Nothing better than Wikipedia mirrors and a download site found in searches. No claim or |evidence of notability. Fails Deletion of Syntasoft :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2615 20028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Netspend User:Quarl 09:25, 30 December 2005 (UTC) delete as |non-notable corporation. &mdash Deletion of Netspend WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2616 17063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tsunami (Manic Street Preachers song) User:Kokoro20 05:39, 4 February 2015 (UTC) keep I've found two in-depth sources on the song through a Google search, one by http://www.nme.com/reviews/4527 NME and one by http://www.theguardian.com/music/musicblog/2014/dec/10/manic-street-preachers-10-of-the-best The Guardian. I think these are enough to pass or Deletion of Tsunami (Manic Street Preachers song) WP:GNG||WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2617 13644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mysterious Girlfriend X User:AnmaFinotera 20:40, 22 June 2010 (UTC) delete """Has no significant coverage in any reliable, third-party sources, and the """"popularity"""" on an illegal site that is blacklisted and against |policy to link too is less than insignificant. How long it has run is irrelevant as is its age. As it is, it fails and and the only verifiable thing about it is title, author, plot, and publication dates, i.e. all stuff from the primary source. No objection to a redirect from the title to the author being created after deletion""" Deletion of Mysterious Girlfriend X WP:COPYRIGHT||WP:BK||WP:N Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
2618 13785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Auseklis (newspaper) User:Premeditated 11:12, 23 February 2019 (UTC) delete fails / due to lack of sources. &spades Deletion of Auseklis (newspaper) WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2619 8978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fieldwork (novel) User:Arxiloxos 16:53, 3 June 2012 (UTC) keep The nominator should have followed , and it is especially hard to understand xis failure to do so given that I pointed out the existence of sources when I removed his proposed deletion. This book has received serious reviews in numerous sources, a number of which are already cited at the author article. Some examples quickly found by a basic Google searchhttp://www.google.com/search?q=%22Fieldwork%22+berlinski&hl=en&safe=off&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&tbm=nws&prmd=imvns&source=lnt&tbs=ar:1&sa=X&ei=9JLLT9zON-be2AWejNTZCw&ved=0CCcQpwUoBQ&biw=1280&bih=644: ''Los Angeles Times''http://articles.latimes.com/2007/feb/07/entertainment/et-rutten7, ''The Believer''http://www.believermag.com/issues/200703/?read=review_berlinski, ''Entertainment Weekly'' review http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20015923,00.html and Stephen King's column about what he saw as the book's mis-marketing http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20034042,00.html, ''Deseret News''http://www.deseretnews.com/article/660196255/Fieldwork-is-a-clever-voyage.html, ''The Independent''http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/books/reviews/fieldwork-by-mischa-berlinski-956424.html, ''Christian Science Monitor''http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/0309/p13s02-bogn.html. Search also shows that it showed up on a number of best-of-the-year lists Deletion of Fieldwork (novel) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
2620 17054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of unreleased Lady Gaga songs (2nd nomination) User:Till 01:46, 22 July 2012 (UTC) delete this may qualify under CSD:G4 as page that was deleted per a deletion discussion. Even if it doesn't, this list still fails as pointed out in the previous AfD Deletion of List of unreleased Lady Gaga songs (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2621 17597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bupenda User:Lankiveil 11:46, 24 April 2008 (UTC) delete would not appear to meet notability criteria Deletion of Bupenda WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2622 111 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Bilge Parlak Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 13:17, 9 Mayıs 2015 (UTC) keep Kayda değer yapımlarda önemli rolleri var, bu |kayda değer olması için yeterli. ''Bizimkiler''{{'}}in 14 sezonunda yer almış bir kere Bilge Parlak'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
2623 13604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Time-challenged User:NuclearWarfare 13:11, 6 August 2013 (UTC) delete ndash; this may be a noteworthy topic, but as it stands it fails enough to a point where I can't tell if it is salvageable or not Deletion of Time-challenged WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2624 18208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunset Island User:Arxiloxos 07:12, 15 February 2013 (UTC) comment Not so sure about this. It's a real, named island, and as such maybe ought to be kept under . Some facts about the island's history as farmland for the keepers of the nearby Colchester Reef Light are mentioned in the article about the lighthouse and are verified in ''New England Lighthouses: A Virtual Guide''http://www.newenglandlighthouses.net/colchester-reef-light-history.htmlhttp://www.lighthouse.cc/colchester/history.html; I'm not certain about the RS status of that source, but it does seem to be cited in a lot of our lighthouse articles Deletion of Sunset Island WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2625 3638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/InterfaithFamily User:Bakazaka 01:23, 6 September 2018 (UTC) delete as unambiguous Deletion of InterfaithFamily WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2626 4615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acton Fall Fair User:Bearcat 19:37, 20 June 2018 (UTC) delete There's only one non-|primary source here to even ''begin'' establishing notability, and it just links to a general content directory for the defunct local community weekly while providing ''no'' title or date information to help us figure out ''where'' in its 100+-year haystack the content actually being cited might be found. This is ''exactly'' why I keep getting on people's necks about the need to provide ''complete'' citation details and not just blank URLs or links to generic content directories. Something like this would have to clear on the basis of coverage that expanded ''beyond'' just the local weekly newspaper, but there's no evidence of that being shown at all. It can absolutely be briefly mentioned in the town's article, but the sourcing here doesn't earn it a standalone article of its own independently of that Deletion of Acton Fall Fair WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
2627 13197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pumppuamo User:Saalstin 12:25, 3 July 2009 (UTC) delete fails . http://www.google.fi/search?hl=fi&q=Pumppuamo+Valtimo&btnG=Hae&meta=cr%3DcountryFI Finnish google search and http://www.google.fi/search?hl=fi&q=Pumppuamo+Valtimo&btnG=Hae&meta=lr%3Dlang_fi Finnish language google search both go only to that map and english wiki articles+derivatives. Might exist, but with a complete and total lack of |sources there's currently no way to know. Can be recreated if such sources are found Deletion of Pumppuamo WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2628 4114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Logiks (framework) user:czarkoff 11:41, 25 May 2014 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Logiks (framework) WP:B2B Wikipedia:Notability 77
2629 7893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earp: Saints For Sinners User:Pharaoh 11:55, 23 September 2014 (UTC) delete as per MichaelQSchmidt and fails Deletion of Earp: Saints For Sinners WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2630 213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Gay Scanlon User:Kirbanzo 20:32, 7 September 2018 (UTC) keep would close as non-admin but we need more !votes first. She's definitely notable though Deletion of Mary Gay Scanlon WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
2631 96 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Perez User:Fenix 10:47, 8 February 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Joshua Perez WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2632 11881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arklow vs. MacLean User:Bearian 23:34, 22 October 2007 (UTC) delete WP:N|Nnon-notable case, possible |copyright violation, and |soapbox Deletion of Arklow vs. MacLean WP:COPY||WP:SOAP Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
2633 19168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sargeant Roger Hunkins User:Royalbroil 04:13, 21 March 2014 (UTC) delete local politician who doesn't meet . Looks like his family was more notable than he was Deletion of Sargeant Roger Hunkins WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2634 15859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fourth North American blizzard of 2010 User:Ser 21:04, 25 December 2010 (UTC) comment as it stands ''right now'', delete per . However, the storm is forecast for tomorrow (actually, it's supposed to begin in the DC area White Christmas|tonight, according to the latest models), so there may be some merit to it by Monday Deletion of Fourth North American blizzard of 2010 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2635 2449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prequalified User:JChap2007 20:40, 20 August 2006 (UTC) delete Opinion dressed up as a dicdef. No |reliable sources are provided. Articles need to contain information; if you want to do an article that contains/is about ranting, go Dennis Miller|here Deletion of Prequalified WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2636 1208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bundaberg Christian College User:Lankiveil 04:03, 23 March 2014 (UTC) keep I don't agree at all with the reasoning that high schools should always be kept by virtue of being high schools. It will usually be the case that high schools will have the necessary secondary coverage to meet the , but not always, and the sources should be found first. With that said, this school's policy of being one of the last schools in Queensland where beating children was acceptable seems to have gotten it the required coverage, so the article should be kept Deletion of Bundaberg Christian College WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2637 10433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lauren Lee Mitchell User:Davey2010 01:23, 25 February 2016 (UTC) keep as meets and , https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Wikicology&diff=706176911&oldid=706176622 This isn't a hottie !vote or anything Deletion of Lauren Lee Mitchell WP:NBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2638 12752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kalisha Buckhanon User:Wisdom89 06:36, 12 March 2008 (UTC) keep Absolutely fulfills and given the content in the article Deletion of Kalisha Buckhanon WP:BIO||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2639 80 [[Olivier Würgler]] (SLA) Benutzer:Miraki NONE delete Der Einspruch des Artikelerstellers Brodkey65 gegen den SLA mit dem Wortlaut ''Ein Journalist, der als Hauptreferenzquelle 6x in unserem Ganser-Artikel zitiert wird, kann nicht per se irrelevant sein''. zeigt meines Erachtens, dass der Artikel als |BNS-Aktion erstellt wurde. Sie dient dem Zweck zu beweisen, dass ein enzyklopädisch irrelevanter Journalist bei dem Wikipedia-Artikel zu Ganser als Beleg herangezogen worden sei. Dabei interessiert es Brodkey nicht, dass die seriöse Wochenzeitung mit ihrer Redaktion den Beleg darstellt und nicht der von ihr eingesetzte Autor. Da dieser weder die Relevanzkriterien für Journalisten erfüllt noch sonst enzyklopädische Relevanz stiftende Merkmale (etwa entsprechende Veröffentlichungen, Preise o.a.) zu erkennen sind, ist er Artikel zu löschen. Mit dem Beleg bei einem Wikipedia-Artikel hat das in der Sache nichts zu tun und Brodkey, der zu Recht Wert auf seine Fähigkeit zu intelligentem Tun legt, weiß natürlich, dass mit reputablen Zeitungen (Vollredaktion) belegte Wikipedia-Artikel keine enzyklopädische Relevanz für den jeweiligen Autor des Zeitungsartikels begründen Löschung von Olivier Würgler Wikipedia:BNS Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
2640 10971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Castle Cover User:Ihcoyc 15:41, 16 May 2011 (UTC) delete Article is about an insurance agent or reseller. |Advertising: ''...named as the fastest growing UK home insurer in 2007. The company is continuing to grow and develop... able to work with its select panel of insurers to offer competitive prices.... committed to recruiting within the local area....'' No showing of |significant effects on history, technology, or culture, without which no business is an encyclopedia subject Deletion of Castle Cover WP:SPAM||WP:ORGIN Wikipedia:Spam 112
2641 4021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Gloucestershire User:Imzadi1979 01:04, 25 March 2013 (UTC) delete fails and . Lists like these should be transwikied to Wikivoyage rather than left on Wikipedia Deletion of List of bus routes in Gloucestershire WP:GNG||WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2642 18111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Semi Ajayi User:Nfitz 23:35, 31 March 2015 (UTC) keep Meets with detailed profile in national paper http://www.walesonline.co.uk/incoming/who-semi-ajayi-19-things-8919754 Deletion of Semi Ajayi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2643 18 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Arslan Kaya Kullanıcı:yasingyasing 14:37, 8 Mayıs 2013 (UTC) comment Ben KD olduğunu düşünüyorum. Hakkında haber olmayabilir. Ama maddesine baktığımızda birden fazla ve alternatifli kriterler getirildiği görülmektedir. Meslek gruplarına göre farklı hususlar vurgulanmış. Bilim adamları da yaratıcı meslekler kategorisinde sayılmış ve KD kriteri olarak inter alia meslektaşları arasında önemli bir kişi sayılmak ve sıkça atıf almak, iyi bilinen bir eseri yaratmış olmak sayılmış. Maddeye konu olan akademisyen yazar alanında yazılan kitaplarda, tezlerde ve makalelerde sıklıkla atıf almaktadır. Bunun için kaynak olarak Ulusal tez merkezinde https://tez.yok.gov.tr/UlusalTezMerkezi/tarama.jsp yazarı tarafından içeriği görmeye izin verilmiş tezleri gösterebilirim. Ayrıca yazarın -maddeye de ekledim- doçentlik tezinde getirdiği madde önerisi kabul edilerek yeni Ticaret Kanununda yer almıştır. Bir hukukçu akademisyen için bu çok önemlidir. Takdir edersiniz ki bir hukukçunun ortaya koyabileceği eserler kitapları ve başarabilirse yani fikirleri kabul görürse bunların yasalaşmasıdır - yeni bir madde olarak veya mevcut kanun da eleştirdiği hususlar değiştirilerek kabul edilmesidir-. Bu bakımında alanında tanınan ve ortaya koyduğu çalışmalar takdir edilen bu akademisyenin KD olduğunu düşünüyorum Arslan Kaya'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
2644 6576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Aciar User:Tommy1933 03:19, 27 January 2015 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Alan Aciar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2645 5164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Duchamp (clothing) User:Northamerica1000 09:59, 22 October 2013 (UTC) keep Meets . Source examples include: http://www.scotsman.com/lifestyle/fashion/fashion-the-scottish-force-behind-duchamp-1-3105691, http://www.gq-magazine.co.uk/style/articles/2013-01/07/duchamp-london-collections-men, http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-20216775.html Deletion of Duchamp (clothing) WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
2646 2326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riz Mokal User:Can 21:10, 14 May 2020 (UTC) delete Per . {{Template:replyto|replyto| Deletion of Riz Mokal WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2647 6026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Beatles (terrorist cell) User:Carlossuarez46 19:56, 15 September 2014 (UTC) keep notable, easily passes , esp. since Jihadi John's inclusion Deletion of The Beatles (terrorist cell) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2648 14968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George F. Putnam User:David 05:00, 13 December 2019 (UTC) delete He wasn't retired; he died over 30 years ago. The fact that this omission went unnoticed for so long may say something about his notability. I found an obituary and ten reviews of his one book, but I think multiple books are needed for and that the book itself (despite its ten reviews) is too obscure for it to make sense to make an article about the book and redirect this article to it. His publications, citation record, and other accomplishments do not appear to pass , either Deletion of George F. Putnam WP:AUTHOR||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2649 9604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Climb It, Tarzan! User:Gongshow 07:13, 3 November 2012 (UTC) delete I'm unable to find evidence that this meets or Deletion of Climb It, Tarzan! WP:GNG||WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2650 5860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seven Oaks (magazine) User:Icalanise 02:25, 30 January 2011 (UTC) delete non-notable, no sources in article meeting Deletion of Seven Oaks (magazine) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2651 4104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angel Pantoja Medina (Standing Wake) User:Gene93k 02:44, 2 November 2008 (UTC) delete per #NEWS. This is a BIO1E with a single burst of news coverage at the event. Unusual but not notable Deletion of Angel Pantoja Medina (Standing Wake) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2652 12218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prab Rai User:SJP 23:07, 27 June 2008 (UTC) delete """Yes, this clearly doesn't meet |the notability criteria for athletes, which should be used as a rule of thumb, but that isn't the biggest issue. The biggest issue for me is that it fails . I don't see this article ever not failing either. I searched this players name in google, and went over the first 450 results. One was for ESPN, and it had just about no information on him, and the other was http://www.usatoday.com/sports/hockey/nhl/canucks/notes.htm this. The US Today article isn't much better either. Also, he doesn't meet my standards as well;-) You can't gather basic information about him(Birth, place of birth,etc) from reliable sources, and nothing really """"sets him apart"""" from the average hockey player in the minor leagues that I can find""" Deletion of Prab Rai WP:ATHLETE||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
2653 1640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John G. Jensen User:RayAYang 05:23, 12 September 2010 (UTC) comment The university webpage linked from the article serves to confirm his existence and his profession. An article in the Macon Telegraph http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=MT&s_site=macon&p_multi=MT&p_theme=realcities&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0EB76E14EDA0E7E6&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM confirms that he was commissioned by the town of Richmond Hill to build a statue of Henry Ford. Here's a profile in a local newspaper of his work http://savannahnow.com/louise-shannon-martin/2008-01-09/local-artist-creates-whimsical-other-pieces-life. If this were all I could find, I would not say that is met. But this is what I could find in 10-15 minutes of online searching. I suspect a more interested researcher might find more, leaving this article marginal as far as notability goes. That said, this is no slam dunk Deletion of John G. Jensen WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2654 4843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blogburst User:Uncle 20:36, 2 December 2006 (UTC) delete unless a |reliable (non-blog Deletion of Blogburst WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2655 13207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019–20 Gimnàstic de Tarragona season User:HawkAussie 23:32, 14 October 2019 (UTC) comment reply|Ludost Mlačani}} The difference between the third tier of English football and the third tier of Spanish football is that the third tier of English football is professional so the resources to create that specific article is available. Compared that to the Spanish 3rd tier which is only semi-professional and their is limited amount of resources that isn't Deletion of 2019–20 Gimnàstic de Tarragona season WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
2656 18400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Context-aware network User:Kvng 14:47, 16 June 2019 (UTC) delete The current text is not referenced or focused enough to be of value to readers or for other editors to build from. We could if there were a single referenced statement Deletion of Context-aware network WP:STUBIFY Wikipedia:Stub 114
2657 9 [[Karl-Heinz Bührer]] (erl. bleibt) Benutzer:Mo4jolo/Bewertung NONE keep Klar relevant. . Vor dem Antragsstellen bitte lesen. LA ungültig Löschung von Karl-Heinz Bührer Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2658 10465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jerry Kwan User:DarkAudit 01:46, 17 July 2006 (UTC) delete per . Having a buddy write your article for you is as vain as if you did it yourself Deletion of Jerry Kwan WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
2659 11912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mates rates User:Andrensath 05:43, 18 July 2010 (UTC) merge to WWGB's suggested location. Per , it's out of place in Wikipedia Deletion of Mates rates WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
2660 3585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Complete Discocrappy User:Neranei 19:19, 23 August 2007 (UTC) delete """The article is somewhat POV """"making it hard to get through the entire album in one sustained listening session"""", and, according to the article, wasn't charted. According to , if the band that made the album is notable, the album may be notable, but Charles Bronson is borderline, seeing as their article is going through an AfD as well""" Deletion of Complete Discocrappy WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2661 9933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lukas Gage User:Edwardx 10:59, 30 March 2018 (UTC) keep Article has had some promotional editing, but I have added enough for it to easily pass Deletion of Lukas Gage WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2662 3985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SolidFire (2nd nomination) User:Mark 21:29, 16 November 2016 (UTC) keep There exists some reliable sources in the article and Northamerica1000 has pointed out multiple reliable sources with content that is clearly more than just regurgitated primary sources. With multiple RS, the topic has been shown to be notable per . Any promotional or non-neutrality issues can be better solved through editing, not deletion. Hence, keep Deletion of SolidFire (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2663 9980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Wang (cadet) User:Edison 16:55, 21 February 2018 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a proper site for a memorial. Does not satisfy Deletion of Peter Wang (cadet) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2664 12754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur Nixon User:Isotope23 16:37, 29 June 2006 (UTC) delete does not meet criteria and I personally don't accept the notion of conferred notability. A mention could be added to Richard Nixon Deletion of Arthur Nixon WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2665 21242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ћ User:Hogweard 19:50, 16 July 2013 (UTC) delete """It is a |mere news story. I have added anything relevant to English articles#Abbreviations for """"the"""" and """"that""" Deletion of Ћ WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2666 21545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Driveme.in user:czarkoff 21:18, 2 June 2014 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Driveme.in WP:GNG||WP:IMPACT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2667 6190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One Night Out User:DBigXray 22:14, 13 May 2018 (UTC) delete The film is yet to be launched and the production house is not notable delete per Deletion of One Night Out WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2668 1034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Target intercom incident User:Ansh666 23:35, 21 December 2015 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Target intercom incident WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2669 16084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack McCauley User:Scope 11:00, 8 September 2016 (UTC) keep """He certainly didn't invent the scroll wheel, that was these boys Scroll wheel#history|Scroll Wheel, but he could have """"invented"""" the physical and software implementation for it while at Microsoft, or or it could have been Logitech that did it. I don't clearly remember when they came in or who did, but certainly he was not the first. As the designer of the Guitar Hero guitar components along with all the light guns and controllers he's built for the industry possibly. """ Deletion of Jack McCauley WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2670 1687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National Express Coach route 040 User:United 04:46, 29 July 2014 (UTC) delete Non-notable bus routes that carry ordinary people and travel the same roads everyday. Fails N, GNG, and maybe a loose interpretation of , as this is a routine event Deletion of National Express Coach route 040 WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2671 16021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rana Gujral User:Bearcat 18:58, 12 July 2019 (UTC) delete """Nothing stated in the article is """"inherently"""" notable enough to guarantee him a Wikipedia article just because he exists, but the referencing is almost entirely to |primary sources and listicles, not real media coverage that is substantively about him. For example, a person is not notable as a contributor to publications just because you reference the fact to his own writing ''for'' those publications — the notability test is not the ability to verify that he's been the ''author'' of media coverage of other ''things'', it's the ability to verify that he's been the ''subject'' of media coverage authored by other ''people''. Similarly, video clips of him speaking are not support for notability either — again, the notability test is not the ability to show sources in which he's ''doing'' the speaking, but the ability to show sources in which he's the ''subject'' that ''other'' people are speaking ''about""" Deletion of Rana Gujral WP:PRIMARYSOURCES Wikipedia:No original research 65
2672 11544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BLACKOUT (improv group) User:Darkwind 09:06, 25 April 2010 (UTC) delete """Does ''not'' pass #2 - 4000 listeners out of a metro area of almost 10 million people is not a """"large fan base or significant cult following"""". Additionally, all of the sources on the article are upcoming performance announcements or schedules. No significant coverage in any independent source has been provided to meet """ Deletion of BLACKOUT (improv group) WP:ENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2673 3188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of current Indian Super League players User:Ajf773 02:59, 23 December 2016 (UTC) delete as and . Possibly mirrored from another source Deletion of List of current Indian Super League players WP:LISTCRUFT||WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
2674 7567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PROUD Principle User:MelanieN 23:21, 14 February 2015 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is for promoting a non-notable book you wrote yourself. In a quick Google search just now, the ONLY reference I found to this principle was the Wikipedia article. As Noah pointed out, the author did a nice job of name-dropping in the article (Maya Angelou was only one of several), but it does not add to the concept's notability Deletion of PROUD Principle WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2675 814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fire Emblem (anime) User:Quasirandom 03:59, 12 May 2008 (UTC) merge """per the apparent intent of the nominator, with a reminder that this is """"articles for deletion"""" not """"articles for |merging""" Deletion of Fire Emblem (anime) WP:MERGE Wikipedia:Merging 54
2676 16886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indonesia–Serbia relations User:Edison 19:19, 1 May 2009 (UTC) delete Fails and OT|not a directory. Foreign relations of the 203 sovereign countries are best discussed in the article about the country, or a standalone article if a major country, rather than in 20,000 such binary stubs. A link to the country's foreign ministry website will provide more up-to-date info than a robostub created and neglected Deletion of Indonesia–Serbia relations WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2677 9894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Race baiting User:Kinu 17:20, 2 September 2010 (UTC) comment I'm amending my justification as the examples and non-sources appear to have been removed. Nonetheless, the only content of this article now is an unsourced definition which may still fall under |synthesis and, at best, . The term is of encyclopedic value, I'm fairly certain, for ''an'' article; however, right now ''this'' article basically states ''race baiting is insert unsourced/possibly OR definition here, and Glenn Beck uses the term''. In other words, what's present is not an encyclopedic article about the topic of race baiting at the moment. ''Keep and improve'' could be a possible course of action, but given the lack of anything sourced in this article, might apply here unless an editor can, at the very least, amend and source the definition soon Deletion of Race baiting WP:SYN||WP:DICDEF||WP:TNT Wikipedia:No original research 65
2678 9818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erika Grey User:Slakr 07:28, 24 March 2017 (UTC) delete """mdash; fails . Coverage in sources is mostly either trivial, incidental, or one-event. Body of work is https://www.amazon.com/s?ie=UTF8&page=1&rh=n%3A283155%2Cp_27%3APedante%20Press obviously self-published and not critically cited. Similarly fails due to lack of extensive, significant coverage. Pretty much at best, as far as attempting to establish expertise, we would have http://www.coasttocoastam.com/guest/grey-erika/85170, which is solely due to a single appearance (Coast to Coast AM, a show that basically also gives random appearances to the Ancient Aliens/tinfoil-hat/pseudoscience crowd) and is probably de facto a self-published media-release biography. She's admittedly covered in exactly 3 news articles (http://www.rightwingwatch.org/post/donald-trump-is-probably-one-of-the-biggest-things-to-happen-to-end-times-bible-prophecy/ http://www.newyorker.com/culture/on-and-off-the-avenue/the-literal-stink-of-the-trump-apocalypse and http://www.christianpost.com/news/is-donald-trump-the-last-trump-before-jesus-christs-return-173779/) that all popped up at the same time (inauguration), which even more seems to reflect the coverage as, at best, (i.e., """"you'll never guess what ''some'' people are saying about Trump""" Deletion of Erika Grey WP:AUTHOR||WP:GNG||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
2679 5400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burying the lead User:Shreevatsa 14:26, 26 March 2009 (UTC) delete """per . I would say """"merge into News style"""", but there isn't anything worth merging""" Deletion of Burying the lead WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
2680 4655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New York City housing crisis User:BenKuykendall 04:23, 11 December 2018 (UTC) comment """I think this is more of a |neutrality issue than a notability one. However many facts and figures about housing in NY we have, regardless of the sources, we as Wikipedia editors cannot conclude there is a """"crisis"""". Instead, we need to present the arguments and conclusions of experts. The San Francisco housing shortage article is a very good example of what to do: the first paragraph includes the sentence {{tq|Late San Francisco mayor Ed Lee has called the shortage a """"housing crisis"""",4 and news reports have said that addressing the shortage is the mayor's """"top priority"""".5}} Properly sources attributions like this are essential to maintaining neutrality in this article""" Deletion of New York City housing crisis WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
2681 2189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mosaic notation program (2nd nomination) User:Dreamyshade 04:30, 30 July 2017 (UTC) keep This is an abandoned product but it looks like it was notable in its day. In addition to the sources that the article currently has, I found https://www.jstor.org/stable/3680582?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents this review in an academic journal from 1993 and a https://www.copyright.gov/1201/2006/comments/robinson.pdf comment about the program for the DMCA anti-circumvention exemption process in 2006 (see Digital Millennium Copyright Act#Anti-circumvention exemptions. This tells me that this is a sufficiently important and well-documented part of music notation software history that we should keep the article. The article should probably be renamed to '''Composer's Mosaic''' to fit better Deletion of Mosaic notation program (2nd nomination) WP:CRITERIA Wikipedia:Article titles 75
2682 11756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Umbrella Foundation [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']][[User talk:(aeropagitica)|''' (talk) ''']] 06:58, 13 May 2006 (UTC) delete as non-notable organisation/website & refer respectively. The website is a beta template with no content as of the time of writing Deletion of Umbrella Foundation WP:CORP||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2683 4036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evolutionary theory of the self User:Bearian 20:56, 25 November 2019 (UTC) delete per , hat tip to {{U|Headbomb}}. This is a sloppy mix of |original research and an op-ed. I'm |sure the creator and editors who wrote this meant well, but this is not even wrong Deletion of Evolutionary theory of the self WP:TNT||WP:OR||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
2684 4678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Bogtrotter User:Stifle 19:38, 7 September 2008 (UTC) delete I still don't think this meets the requirements. Merging fine too Deletion of Bruce Bogtrotter WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2685 21754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Out from Under (Song) User:Rlendog 19:25, 20 August 2009 (UTC) comment Why do you say this particular song is not notable when it charted on a national chart per Deletion of Out from Under (Song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2686 16066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nightstick (film) [[User talk:NukeThePukes|Allons!]] 22:33, 7 July 2016 (UTC) delete """MarnetteD should take a look at before making recommendations about guidelines to others. The only part of that guideline referencing cast states """"The film features significant involvement (i.e., one of the most important roles in the making of the film) by a notable person and '''is a major part of his/her career'''."""" An ephemeral and award- and significant coverage-free TV movie doesn't cut it. ''' ''Nha Trang""" Deletion of Nightstick (film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2687 3663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shimmy (song) (2nd nomination) User:Esradekan 12:55, 30 April 2009 (UTC) delete as a non-plausible search term, fails notability per #Songs. No awards, no chart, no covers, no . As pointed out, nothing to warrant a stand alone article that already isn't in Toxicity (album Deletion of Shimmy (song) (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2688 21724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fair Online Network User:Mr 21:54, 15 November 2008 (UTC) delete I'm surprised the A7/G11 speedy tags were declined, certainly doesn't meet the |notability requirements, borderline spam Deletion of Fair Online Network WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2689 17170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Stagecoach Manchester bus routes User:Imzadi1979 00:50, 25 March 2013 (UTC) delete fails and . Lists like these should be transwikied to Wikivoyage rather than left on Wikipedia Deletion of List of Stagecoach Manchester bus routes WP:GNG||WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2690 20212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sinclair Method User:Literaturegeek 01:13, 21 March 2010 (UTC) comment Hmmm, you have put a doubt in my mind now. Maybe I was applying and too strongly and jumped the gun? Perhaps it is notable enough to keep as an article after all. I shall wait for other wikipedians to weigh in. Why not vote keep as you think it should be kept Silver Deletion of Sinclair Method WP:MEDRS||WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2691 6324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlos Moreno (fighter) User:LlamaAl 23:40, 23 March 2013 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Carlos Moreno (fighter) WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
2692 1311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher C. Harmon User:Sonofstar 16:42, 17 April 2021 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Christopher C. Harmon WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2693 7378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Janko Prunk User:Bad 01:56, 14 February 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Janko Prunk WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2694 4442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Winter (Starbucks) User:FreeRangeFrog 04:33, 28 December 2012 (UTC) delete The notability guidelines are intended to serve as a guideline to establish whether or not an article about a subject merits inclusion in the encyclopedia. They're not a web coverage counter. This to me is trivial and pointless, and can easily be construed as failing Deletion of Winter (Starbucks) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2695 12406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rujjana Utaiwan User:Littleb2009 19:28, 15 June 2021 (UTC) delete completely unsourced, should have been |BLPPROD-ed long ago, but since it's been brought here, no need to PROD it Deletion of Rujjana Utaiwan WP:BLPPROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion of biographies of living people 66
2696 12846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Polish invasion of Czech Republic User:Volunteer 04:05, 16 June 2020 (UTC) delete come on. , especially not sensationalist, inane news. Just because there’s a newspaper story about something doesn’t mean we need to have an article about. This is ridiculous Deletion of Polish invasion of Czech Republic WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2697 5127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyberathlete Amateur League (2nd nomination) User:Randomran 19:31, 28 September 2008 (UTC) delete no reliable third-party sources to support this article, thus failing and . Only sources are either self-published unreliable sources, or official material that has been reprinted such as press releases Deletion of Cyberathlete Amateur League (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
2698 7331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samantha Henderson User:Quasirandom 03:25, 24 September 2009 (UTC) comment """Being an """"up and coming author"""" is the sort of argument that is designed to to cut off at the pass -- she needs to have arrived to be |notable. Whether she has, is what we're here to debate""" Deletion of Samantha Henderson WP:CRYSTAL||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2699 14907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David A. Cherry User:Arthur 22:51, 22 June 2010 (UTC) keep Being artist guest of honor at a Worldcon seems adequate notability, limited to at most one person per year since there have ''been'' Worldcons, making the count approximately 70. Being nominated for the Hugo Award 8 ''11'' times seems also to be adequate evidence of notability, per #1. (Sources for facts in the article would be helpful, however Deletion of David A. Cherry WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2700 11409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vecteezy User:The 22:26, 2 May 2018 (UTC) delete per nomination. |They may resurface Deletion of Vecteezy WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
2701 13451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Lopez: Let's Get Loud User:Till 05:09, 3 July 2012 (UTC) keep as per the numerous sources provided above, this topic meets Deletion of Jennifer Lopez: Let's Get Loud WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2702 12748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Illustrations of Japan User:Chiswick 14:32, 18 January 2016 (UTC) keep meets and which is shown by citations above, thanks to Deletion of Illustrations of Japan WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2703 13324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pipi (footballer) User:SunDawn 03:11, 4 May 2021 (UTC) keep Clearly passed . Numerous sources, all signifying his notability as future prospects for Real Madrid. The coverage from Guardian also further adds to his notability. His international play for Japan U-15 didn't establish notability, but coupled with others he is surely notable Deletion of Pipi (footballer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2704 6717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hotmobile User:AllyD 07:31, 19 May 2013 (UTC) delete The provided references are evidence of existence, but not notability and I have found no |reliable 3rd party sources to meet . The second half of the article is essentially a prospectus for what the company intends/hopes for the future ( nos. 3 and 5 Deletion of Hotmobile :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2705 8779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diane Farrell User:Coredesat 04:43, 1 July 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Diane Farrell WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2706 12215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian Swann User:DustFormsWords 05:50, 9 November 2009 (UTC) delete """The article makes a backhanded claim (""""acted extensively in the theatre"""") against criterion 3 (""""Has made ... prolific contributions to a field of entertainment"""") but that claim is not supported by IMDB (which admittedly doesn't list theatre roles) or Google (which shows several reviews of his performance in """"Outside Edge"""" but no other theatre credits I can find). As such, unless further sources emerge, he doesn't pass or and is therefore not notable""" Deletion of Ian Swann WP:ENT||WP:N||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2707 18855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twist my ballbag one more time User:Daniel5127 22:09, 23 December 2006 (UTC) delete Fails usic Deletion of Twist my ballbag one more time WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
2708 8316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norval Marley User:Bearian 21:46, 17 October 2007 (UTC) merge with Bob Marley as the content is useful, but the subject is plainly not notable for his own article per the requriements of Deletion of Norval Marley WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2709 1584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giant (Clash of Clans) User:Odie5533 06:39, 4 December 2016 (UTC) delete all per Reliable secondary sources with significant coverage for each of these do not exist Deletion of Giant (Clash of Clans) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2710 15446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global Youth Model United Nations User:PohranicniStraze 18:56, 20 December 2018 (UTC) delete Fails ; no |reliable source coverage that I can tell Deletion of Global Youth Model United Nations WP:ORG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2711 5372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vecino (disambiguation) User:Jovanmilic97 17:13, 5 October 2019 (UTC) keep """It has 4 entries now that were found in less than 5 minutes of a search. A valid by the surname. We can even add Vecinos entries (since """"vecino"""" means a neighbor, and """"vecinos"""" means neighbors) like Vecinos (which possibly needs to move to Vecinos (Mexican TV series) in my opinion), Vecinos (Colombian TV series), Vecinos, Salamanca, and Ramón Vecinos""" Deletion of Vecino (disambiguation) WP:DAB Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
2712 5716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erdős–Bacon–Sabbath number User:David 20:08, 6 April 2017 (UTC) delete I removed two sources (the ''Telegraph'' and ''Nature'') which appeared to be used to support the notability of this concept, but actually don't mention it. With them gone, the only sources that actually cover the EBS number are the first three, all web sites of dubious reliability and independence. The remaining sources are all either about collaboration distances considered more generally, or are used to support |original research about the numbers of individual people. I supported keeping the article on Erdős–Bacon number because it was covered in-depth in undisputably reliable sources, despite its unimportance, but for this one I just don't see it Deletion of Erdős–Bacon–Sabbath number WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2713 3853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Memorial High School Memories (Hedwig Village, Texas) User:Metropolitan90 05:01, 25 April 2006 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a high school yearbook. Please review if you still think this is an appropriate article Deletion of Memorial High School Memories (Hedwig Village, Texas) WP:VANITY Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
2714 4978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darrin Doyle User:David 21:44, 17 April 2017 (UTC) delete I found some blog reviews of his books but nothing major and reliable enough for Deletion of Darrin Doyle WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2715 18114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/First Day [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']] 21:25, 24 January 2006 (UTC) delete tl|hoax}} Schoolgirl fantasy, non-notable band as per usic - albums/singles chart positions; notable members Deletion of First Day WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
2716 4684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anderson de Carvalho Barbosa User:Camw 03:08, 18 April 2009 (UTC) keep Passes thlete. The article needs significant improvement (some references at the very least) but it isn't subject to deletion for notability Deletion of Anderson de Carvalho Barbosa WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
2717 3973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leonor Espinoza User:Green 05:22, 6 November 2013 (UTC) keep """per . The guidelines do not require sources to be in English. Newspapers in Colombia are acceptable, she is obviously more notable in Colombia where she lives and works than, say, the United States of America (to pick a country at random). Sources include: http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.cromos.com.co/especial-mujeres-inspiradoras/articulo-148456-leonor-espinosa-la-colombiana-mas-sazon&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522Leonor%2BEspinosa%2522%2Bsite:.co%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26hs%3DGWH%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26biw%3D1139%26bih%3D762,http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.jetset.com.co/edicion-impresa/temas-revista-jetset/articulo/leonor-espinosa-ferran-adria-colombiana/85271&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522Leonor%2BEspinosa%2522%2Bsite:.co%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26hs%3DGWH%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26biw%3D1139%26bih%3D762 (""""renowned chef""""), http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.elheraldo.co/tendencias/la-chef-leonor-espinosa-ahora-en-senal-colombia-130286&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522Leonor%2BEspinosa%2522%2Bsite:.co%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26hs%3DGWH%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26biw%3D1139%26bih%3D762,http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.fucsia.co/edicion-impresa/articulo/la-costena-cachaco/3961&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522Leonor%2BEspinosa%2522%2Bsite:.co%26start%3D10%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26sa%3DN%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26biw%3D1139%26bih%3D762(""""one of the most recognized chefs Colombia""""), http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.culturaemedellin.gov.co/sites/CulturaE/rutae2011/Paginas/leonor_espinosa.aspx&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522Leonor%2BEspinosa%2522%2Bsite:.co%26start%3D10%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26sa%3DN%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26biw%3D1139%26bih%3D762 (""""Conde Naste says one of 82 best restaurants in the world""""), http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.revistalabarra.com.co/news/2175/2179/Avesco-y-Leonor-Espinosa-se-unen-para-resaltar-sabores-colombianos.htm&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522Leonor%2BEspinosa%2522%2Bsite:.co%26start%3D10%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26sa%3DN%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26biw%3D1139%26bih%3D762,http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.las2orillas.co/la-cocinera-persiguen-los-chefs/&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522Leonor%2BEspinosa%2522%2Bsite:.co%26start%3D20%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26sa%3DN%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26biw%3D1139%26bih%3D762,http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://italia.embajada.gov.co/newsroom/news/2013-10-31/2102&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522Leonor%2BEspinosa%2522%2Bsite:.co%26start%3D20%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26sa%3DN%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26biw%3D1139%26bih%3D762(""""Two of Colombia's most recognized chefs, Leonor Espinosa and Carlos Yanguas"""")(government website),http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.eluniversal.com.co/suplementos/viernes/al-rescate-de-los-sabores&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522Leonor%2BEspinosa%2522%2Bsite:.co%26start%3D30%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26sa%3DN%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26biw%3D1139%26bih%3D762,http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://static.elespectador.co/impreso/unchatcon/imagen-243173-leonor-espinosa&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522Leonor%2BEspinosa%2522%2Bsite:.co%26start%3D30%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26sa%3DN%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26biw%3D1139%26bih%3D762""" Deletion of Leonor Espinoza WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2718 21378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/So i herd u like mudkips User:Kotepho 11:55, 9 April 2006 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not really the place for this. Sadly, people will come here looking for it. While it isn't unverifiable or |original research it is still fails . I prefer Gardevoir anyways Deletion of So i herd u like mudkips WP:NOR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
2719 12988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reptilianized Lion User:Rosiestep 23:57, 4 May 2008 (UTC) delete """Instead of writing an article about the pictured mythological lion-dragon, or """"leogryph"""", (the term currently Redirects to Chinthe), common in various forms, and depicted in various ways (architecture, heraldry, parades) by many Asian and European cultures, the article creator chose a hoax term that fails #When adding material that is challenged or likely to be challenged""" Deletion of Reptilianized Lion WP:CS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2720 21042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yankee Doodle Doctor User:Ikip 15:47, 15 May 2009 (UTC) keep per Richard, there is no as per and merging should have been discussed on List of M*A*S*H episodes (Season 1)before an AFD Deletion of Yankee Doodle Doctor WP:DEADLINE||WP:BEFORE||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:There is no deadline 35
2721 14363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cave Clan (2nd nomination) User:Stifle 11:39, 8 April 2008 (UTC) delete seems to have very little notability outside its immediate area. See Deletion of Cave Clan (2nd nomination) WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2722 1270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dread Central (2nd nomination) User:Wafulz 20:01, 16 July 2007 (UTC) delete """The sources provided do not """"feature"""" Dread Central- they quote one sentence from it. Doesn't seem to meet |notability guidelines for web content, and doesn't have any |independent non-trivial reliable sources""" Deletion of Dread Central (2nd nomination) WP:WEB||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2723 19236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sweat365 User:Gongshow 16:17, 9 August 2012 (UTC) delete I found a couple passing mentions and press releases, but no other significant coverage beyond the Seattle P-I profile. Subject does not appear to meet or Deletion of Sweat365 WP:GNG||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2724 21525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Gertler User:Rpclod 01:51, 6 May 2015 (UTC) delete appears to try to | inherit notability from an alleged client Deletion of Andrew Gertler WP:NOTINHERIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2725 11521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buru (legendary creature) User:Tessaracter 06:03, 18 December 2019 (UTC) keep per above. The article had some sources but in the previous versions.https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Buru_(legendary_creature)&oldid=860241093 Subject meets Deletion of Buru (legendary creature) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2726 19047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parental Rights Amendment to the United States Constitution (2nd nomination) User:Philosopher 22:19, 25 August 2011 (UTC) comment """It is fairly well-known, in part because it's been proposed by Michael Farris and in part because of the recent large number of co-sponsors it has had, though it has yet to come close to the necessary number for ratification (110 is the highest House co-sponsors I found in my search). I'd be interested if anyone with a current database account could do a search to see what sort of coverage it's gotten in legal or educational journals. I do know there are at least two interesting """"secondary sources"""" on this - the state legislatures of http://www.myfloridahouse.gov/Sections/Bills/billsdetail.aspx?BillId=45417& Florida and http://www.parentalrights.org/index.asp?Type=B_BASIC&SEC={9954D286-24C5-4A07-902F-1AC34DEDB241} Louisiana, which each urged Congressional passage of the amendment. Ultimately, however, I don't know if the amendment deserves an article here or not. The parental rights ''movement'' is unquestionably notable and some of this article's contents should at least be '''copied/merged''' into parents' rights movement and the amendment certainly deserves mention in US ratification of the Convention on the Rights of the Child. But I don't know how widely it's been discussed by experts, covered in the press, or otherwise fulfilled """ Deletion of Parental Rights Amendment to the United States Constitution (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2727 17317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/25 to Life (Eminem song) User:Armbrust 10:29, 7 July 2010 (UTC) delete to Recovery (Eminem album) per , no individual notability Deletion of 25 to Life (Eminem song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2728 11380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Film Investors Netherlands User:AllyD 14:55, 10 October 2018 (UTC) delete """I did find some initial coverage concerning this scheme: a discussion of its potential http://www.filmkrant.nl/av/org/filmkran/archief/fk189/filmfina.html """"Film Krant"""", May 1998 and EU Commission approval for this state support later the same year (added as a reference in the article). It appears to have been a limited-funding, limited-term initiative, but my searches are not finding any substantial evaluation or coverage beyond that initial start-up coverage. Fails """ Deletion of Film Investors Netherlands :WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2729 5596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Woodson Farmstead User:TheCatalyst31 11:29, 14 November 2013 (UTC) keep For a property to be listed on the National Register, a nomination form must be submitted explaining the historical significance of the property, complete with a bibliography. The federal government must then approve the nomination and designate the property as historically significant, using a higher standard than Wikipedia's standard for notability. If a property is significant enough to pass the standards of the National Register, it is certainly significant enough to pass the . (In the case of this article, see page 9 of reference 2 for an assertion of the significance of the property Deletion of Woodson Farmstead WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2730 16628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Waldo Mootzka User:Netherzone 21:30, 16 November 2020 (UTC) keep Clearly meets notability requirements per by way of museum collections mentioned above by {{u|ThatMontrealIP}} and {{u|onel5969 Deletion of Waldo Mootzka WP:NARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
2731 11119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uma Kumaran (2nd nomination) User:Rms125a 17:15, 26 April 2015 (UTC) delete non-notable solely for being a losing candidate under |POLITICIAN if there is no other reason for claim to |notability Deletion of Uma Kumaran (2nd nomination) WP:POLITICIAN||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2732 20277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jerry White (Navigators) User:Septrillion 20:34, 6 July 2018 (UTC) keep Passes . \\\Septrillion Deletion of Jerry White (Navigators) WP:NSOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
2733 20167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lori Klausutis (third nomination) User:Armedblowfish 23:07, 14 October 2006 (UTC) delete per . Also note that the husband of the subject of this article requested it's deletion. See Talk:Lori_Klausutis#Why_write_this_article, https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/w/index.php?title=Talk%3ALori_Klausutis&diff=48642114&oldid=46213502 diff Deletion of Lori Klausutis (third nomination) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2734 11704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jay Spearing (2nd nomination) User:Heshs 16:41, 18 February 2008 (UTC) delete per nom, fails Deletion of Jay Spearing (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2735 4530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lowly Palace User:Atsme 00:32, 3 February 2018 (UTC) delete independent producer on YouTube, fails Deletion of Lowly Palace WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2736 19077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Quest of the Sparrows User:Stuartyeates 01:59, 9 October 2011 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of The Quest of the Sparrows WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2737 20760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dwight Frazier User:PRehse 10:06, 30 August 2015 (UTC) delete The article is heavy with trivia of a minor nature and who he had associations with ( Deletion of Dwight Frazier WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2738 13439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Texas Chainsaw Massacre User:Quiddity 18:32, 14 May 2009 (UTC) keep because this is what disambiguation pages are ''for''. This should be a discussion about : The 2006 movie is getting just as many hits as the 2003 movie (according to http://stats.grok.se ), and the 2nd 3rd and 4th movies are close behind. As a reader, I'd rather initially go to a short disambig page, than a long page for the wrong movie (irregardless which of the 6 I'm actually looking for Deletion of The Texas Chainsaw Massacre WP:PRIMARYTOPIC Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
2739 15310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ivy Bean User:TexasDex 05:07, 29 July 2010 (UTC) keep """I will be the first to acknowledge that it's a silly thing to be notable for, but I don't think this is a case of . BLP1E says """"in the context of a single event"""". From reading it very carefully, I think the fundamental point of BLP1E is that a single high-profile event doesn't automatically confer notability on every person who is named in relation to that event. People who only played a small role in it, and didn't get coverage that singles them out as an individual beyond that ''event'', aren't worthy of biographical articles, (for example, Tourist guy vs. Peter Guzli) and generally we couldn't write a biographical article on them anyway given that lack of coverage. BLP1E ''doesn't'' cover people who are famous for a single achievement or distinction, if (as in this case) the achievement and coverage focuses on them as a person. I'm seeing substantial amounts of coverage about Ivy's personal life, such as this http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1298301/Worlds-oldest-Twitter-user-Ivy-Bean-dies-aged-104.html Daily Mail article. Given that and the above articles, I think this has the potential to be a great article""" Deletion of Ivy Bean WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2740 18906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheba Mason User:Niteshift36 00:57, 24 June 2009 (UTC) delete """Non-notable. Fails . I did find a mention of her in a weekly newspaper here: http://www.observer.com/2009/o2/jackie-mason-s-scion-seeks-spotlight-and-what-punim, but I have trouble calling that significant coverage. Looking at her ticket prices, she's not exactly in the big leagues. Seems more an attempt to cash in on Dad's fame. Also suggest for the author who submitted a ''5 word'' (two of which are her name), unsourced BLP """"article""" Deletion of Sheba Mason WP:CREATIVE||WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2741 13485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paola Zizzi User:Nsk92 21:03, 19 June 2010 (UTC) delete Citability in GScholar and WebOfScience is fairly small, nothing else in the record to indicate passing Deletion of Paola Zizzi WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2742 7176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russian names in space User:Less 11:29, 8 May 2020 (UTC) keep The article clearly passes and so there's no reason for deletion. The naming seems a bit odd to me, but it's not a reason for deletion Deletion of Russian names in space WP:GNG||WP:LIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
2743 10493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KazAirJet User:YSSYguy 06:54, 22 November 2012 (UTC) delete being unsourced can be fixed, if the sources are out there, but a lack of significant coverage is the kiss-of-death per . I note that this is not an airline as such, but an air charter company operating business jets and helicopters Deletion of KazAirJet WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2744 3815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Interactive Storytelling Game User:Markkbilbo 19:26, 18 January 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Interactive Storytelling Game WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2745 1586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delaware County Intermediate Unit User:Srikeit 14:47, 22 May 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Delaware County Intermediate Unit WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2746 9 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/619 Wrestling Move User:Safiel 22:21, 1 September 2011 (UTC) delete Fails otability Deletion of 619 Wrestling Move WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2747 6167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blair Martin User:Assize 13:25, 13 June 2007 (UTC) delete No secondary sources cited, therefore not notable Deletion of Blair Martin WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2748 158 [[Dominik Oberhofer]] (gelöscht) 91.115.51.125|91.115.51.125]] 12:07, 1. Feb. 2018 (CET NONE keep """Gemäß als """"Vorsitzender auf oberster subnationaler Ebene einer in der Volksvertretung vertretenen Partei"""" zweifelsfrei relevant." Löschung von Dominik Oberhofer Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2749 12586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of salaries of central bank governors User:Ajf773 21:21, 27 August 2020 (UTC) delete per and that the editor has only bothered to fill in eight countries' data Deletion of List of salaries of central bank governors WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2750 13010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Combatant (computer game) User:Capitalistroadster 18:54, 11 November 2005 (UTC) delete according to |verifiability concerns and Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not. We are not a crystal ball and we do not have any verifiable information as to whether this game will be successful. Until we do, we cannot have an article. Best wishes on its success Deletion of Combatant (computer game) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2751 12579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Border Downs Tintinara Crows User:Auroranorth 02:24, 3 November 2007 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Border Downs Tintinara Crows WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2752 1209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flavius Chişu User:Argyle 13:39, 11 October 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Flavius Chişu WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2753 14814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of consumer brain–computer interfaces User:Eggishorn 18:30, 28 December 2016 (UTC) delete falls somewhere between #OR and CATALOG. Either way, there's no reason to keep or merge Deletion of Comparison of consumer brain–computer interfaces WP:NOT||WP:NOTCATALOG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2754 18041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Critical response to She Has a Name [[User talk:NE Ent|NE Ent]] 11:21, 21 January 2015 (UTC) delete Not encyclopedic, reads like something a PR department would release. Well sourced Deletion of Critical response to She Has a Name WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
2755 16095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pottsylvania User:Squidfryerchef 13:48, 12 December 2007 (UTC) keep """In-universe"""" is a guideline on how to and how not to phrase fiction articles, it is not a reason for deletion. The show was 40 years ago, I'm sure if someone starts digging through periodicals they could find dozens of references. See also """ Deletion of Pottsylvania WP:RECENTISM Wikipedia:Recentism 10
2756 402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benwood Junction, West Virginia User:MrsSnoozyTurtle 03:04, 22 May 2021 (UTC) delete Does not meet Deletion of Benwood Junction, West Virginia WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
2757 1310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Sharpe (WCSC-TV) User:Baileypalblue 06:07, 18 February 2009 (UTC) keep award-winning, widely-respected news anchor meets the requirements of . I have added |reliable sources to the article to satisfy #General notability guideline|the general notability guideline Deletion of Bill Sharpe (WCSC-TV) WP:BIO||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2758 10705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canadian Memorial Church & Centre for Peace User:Agent 08:57, 5 August 2006 (UTC) comment Just as you Wikipedia:Guide_to_deletion#Please_do_not_take_it_personally|ought not take it personally if an article you've worked on is nominated, there is |no need to put down the work of other contributors in order to defend your own. If you have problems with those other articles, nominate them for deletion. As for ''this'' article, Wikipedia is |not a directory nor a local interest guide. It matters not if someone is American or Canadian or Greek or Chilean - they are entitled to question the notability of the subject matter of an article. If it matters, I'm Canadian, I'm from Vancouver, and I've seen the Centre countless times. I can tell you, this place does not meet whatever standards of notability might apply. I'm not saying the place is unimportant, but it's no more significant than any other parish church in Vancouver Deletion of Canadian Memorial Church & Centre for Peace WP:CIVIL||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Civility 37
2759 20560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pritzker Military Presents User:Normal 23:49, 20 August 2020 (UTC) comment """That quote starts with the word '''""""Generally""""''' which you have omitted from your rendition, {{noping|Pigsonthewing}}, meaning that isn't an open and shut case. The policy also includes {{tq|""""the presence or absence of reliable sources is more definitive than the geographic range of the program's audience alone""""}}, to which I point out (again) the glaring omission from the article of ANY citation except for those from its own website and IMDb content (mindful that IMDb content can be user-generated). In other words, your argument on the face does NOT solve the notability issue. Nor does it address the nature of the article, especially since it is supported by the museum's own WikiProject. What other organization in the world has its own WikiProject""" Deletion of Pritzker Military Presents WP:PROMOTIONAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2760 10319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter E. Massey User:StAnselm 20:58, 27 October 2015 (UTC) keep passes #6 as President of Morehouse College Deletion of Walter E. Massey WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2761 15307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Time Adaptive Self-Organizing Map User:Joe 22:02, 6 June 2010 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Time Adaptive Self-Organizing Map WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2762 10263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Northeastern Quartersphere User:Metropolitan90 04:17, 25 January 2012 (UTC) delete """as |original research. For comparison, the term """"Northern Hemisphere"""" gets over 2 million hits on Google Books, and the term """"Eastern Hemisphere"""" gets over 300,000 hits on Google Books. But the term """"Northeastern Quartersphere"""" gets a grand total of zero hits on Google Books (or Google News or Google Scholar""" Deletion of Northeastern Quartersphere WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2763 6555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ESurveysPro User:Czarkoff 01:46, 24 February 2012 (UTC) delete """per {{section link|WP:CSD|A7}}: this """"application"""" is a survey ''website'', and I see |no substantial difference from the rest of them. The references are specifically interesting, though. May be it's time to blacklist {{URL|http://about.com""" Deletion of ESurveysPro WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
2764 19833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanjeev Kamboj User:Ira 01:38, 24 October 2017 (UTC) delete He is not notable by any standard, including and Deletion of Sanjeev Kamboj WP:BIO||WP:NLAWYER Wikipedia:Notability 77
2765 1385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aris Poulianos User:Adambiswanger1 17:37, 6 October 2006 (UTC) comment I can easily see why one would want for this to be deleted, but also I am remidned that Greek Anthropology is not likely to summon up many Google hits or many sources outside of a specialized library. This does not mean he is not notable, though. As Fut. Perf noted, it would be difficult to verify much of this information, but I'm not sure if that is reason enough for deletion. It seems to be more of our own insufficiency rather than his. The |professor test comes to mind here. This guy is an academian, and if he stood in a lecture hall and spoke for 1 hour per week, he would otherwise prove to be more notable than the average professor Deletion of Aris Poulianos WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2766 20805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of films featuring pugs User:Mangoe 20:31, 1 December 2009 (UTC) delete Pugs? How about dalmatian (dog)|dalmatians? Or golden retrievers? Or Siamese cats? How about car models, or brands of beer, or musical instruments? This is just unmitigated trivia: at its finest Deletion of List of films featuring pugs WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
2767 16942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ray Turney User:Epinoia 01:16, 21 September 2019 (UTC) delete that has to be one of strangest ''Career'' sections I have ever read - but that's not the reason for deletion - does not meet ; has not been the subject of significant coverage in multiple reliable secondary sources Deletion of Ray Turney WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2768 8379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dark Star (radio personality) User:Elonka 06:45, 21 November 2006 (UTC) delete """I did a Google search too, but couldn't find anything that looked like a substantial press mention. A merge might work, too, and I might change my mind to """"keep"""" if bonafide |reliable source references can be produced, but even then I'd want to see a substantial rewrite to get rid of the self-promotional and """"silly"""" language, like, """"In his own opinion and agreed to by many regular listeners, Dark Star stole every moment he's been on the radio."""" In his own opinion, indeed""" Deletion of Dark Star (radio personality) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2769 20808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lindsey Stagg User:Jayron32 05:58, 19 August 2010 (UTC) delete non-notable actress, lacks independent sources as required by and Deletion of Lindsey Stagg WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2770 6966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nissanka Senadhipathi User:Dan 00:39, 7 June 2020 (UTC) delete the references do not support the requirements of Deletion of Nissanka Senadhipathi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2771 1532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harvey Weinstein sexual misconduct allegations User:Muboshgu 05:02, 14 October 2017 (UTC) keep This clearly meets . – Deletion of Harvey Weinstein sexual misconduct allegations WP:NEVENTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2772 14463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Covfefe User:Orthogonal1 11:53, 4 June 2017 (UTC) keep Clearly meets . To those who say that this is only temporary, you cannot know this, and in any event are likely incorrect in your assumption. We don't have to wait several months before documenting clearly notable current events, and this is no exception Deletion of Covfefe WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2773 9399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/40 Pra (song) User:RadioFan 16:04, 21 February 2010 (UTC) delete no indication that this song meets , lacks coverage in 3rd party sources Deletion of 40 Pra (song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2774 20548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Powerglove (2nd nomination) User:Cazbahrocker 07:20, 11 June 2009 (UTC) delete This article was changed to redirect twice now, both times having the article reconstructed. I'm not seeing anything in the article that has changed since the original AfD that established notability as all references are self-published . The article should be deleted, but the term refers to an unrelated Article, so the redirect should be added after. Presuming that notability can been established and the page is kept, a {{tl|oldafdfull}} should be added to the talk page so we don't have to go through this again. Finally, if the redirect is restored, is there a way to place a link to the AfDs to discourage future creation/deletion cycles Deletion of Powerglove (2nd nomination) WP:SPS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2775 10400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Rainford User:GretLomborg 01:54, 28 July 2017 (UTC) keep Clear violation of created by a . The subject also fails to meet the and , the only coverage I can find of him is shallow. His name is hard to Google, but it seems Passgo was the most notable thing he did. His article will always live on on youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJr9H0pjW7Y Deletion of John Rainford WP:NOTPROMOTION||WP:SPA||WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2776 333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Island View Residential Treatment Center User:Septrillion 20:24, 7 July 2018 (UTC) keep passes . \\\Septrillion Deletion of Island View Residential Treatment Center WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2777 20220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Bahar User:Lankiveil 04:12, 22 September 2008 (UTC) delete I was unable to find anything on this person either, other than self-published material and the usual directory entry style things. Would not appear to meet the notability guidelines Deletion of David Bahar WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2778 7412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denise Nicoletti User:Russ 12:32, 1 December 2019 (UTC) delete She died rather young in a car accident in 2002 (added to article). Her publication record (especially with the outreach programs) looks like it was on track to notability, but it was in 2002, and I sadly don't see the situation changing now Deletion of Denise Nicoletti WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
2779 10716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Mitzewich User:Cullen328 21:23, 27 February 2011 (UTC) comment What matters is not our own personal opinions about systemic bias and virtual chefs, but rather what the |reliable sources say about Mitzewich. This sort of in-depth coverage is what notability is all about: http://www.mercurynews.com/food-wine/ci_17319582?source=rss&nclick_check=1 YouTube foodie John Mitzewich embraces Valentine's Day, San Jose Mercury News, February 9, 2011 This is the newspaper of record for the Silicon Valley. Bottom line - he's notable Deletion of John Mitzewich WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2780 5901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syed Mohammad Husaini User:Sleddog116 14:49, 12 February 2020 (UTC) delete The article doesn't establish any independent notability of the subject beyond grandiose adjectives. The only reference links to a blank web hosting page, and I'm struggling to find any other sources on this topic. So it meets neither nor Deletion of Syed Mohammad Husaini WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
2781 8653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yuliyan Chapaev User:GiantSnowman 16:40, 29 April 2014 (UTC) delete fail and Deletion of Yuliyan Chapaev WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2782 20613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angela Beyince User:Hateless 17:10, 18 October 2006 (UTC) keep subject passes . Commenting on her sexuality is inappropriate Deletion of Angela Beyince WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2783 17720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of syndicated columnists User:Alf 23:43, 25 October 2011 (UTC) comment """mdash;could nominator maybe point to a policy that suggests deletion? seems to be a policy that suggests that a reason other than """"would be better to have the topic as a category"""" would be good to have.&mdash""" Deletion of List of syndicated columnists WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
2784 10298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dhoom 3 (2nd nomination) User:DustFormsWords 07:10, 25 February 2010 (UTC) keep Not in production but still plenty of notability; a thing doesn't have to yeti|exist to be notable. http://www.indianexpress.com/news/srk-to-play-baddie-in-dhoom-3/468081/ Indian Express reports negotiations here, http://entertainment.oneindia.in/bollywood/news/2009/shahrukh-dhoom-3-250509.html One India has the same story here, http://ibnlive.in.com/news/srk-not-in-dhoom-3-yash-raj-films/93681-8.html IBN Live has Yash Raj denying them here, http://movies.indiatimes.com/news-gossip/gossip/Neil-Nitin-Mukesh-in-Dhoom-3/articleshow/5606717.cms India Times has more recent news here, and that's just English language sources. Passes requirement of significant coverage in independent reliable sources, despite not being in production yet. Another example of a film that would have merited an article despite being nowhere near production would have been the Watchmen film at any point during its 10-year-long development hell Deletion of Dhoom 3 (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2785 11770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wordeep User:Spicy 09:38, 25 August 2020 (UTC) delete sources are junk blogs and press releases, fails . https://www.jpost.com/Jpost-Tech/Business-and-Innovation/Can-Wordeeps-AI-Make-Non-natives-Speak-Like-Native-English-Speakers-602492 This article is in the ''Jerusalem Post'', but it's clearly a blatant advertisement. Googling the author's name reveals that he's a digital marketer and SEO guy Deletion of Wordeep WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2786 6845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alix Lynx User:Cullen328 18:55, 7 April 2018 (UTC) delete Fails the overly lenient guideline. Writing a self-promotional autobiographical article does not make a person notable Deletion of Alix Lynx WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2787 19531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben LeCompte User:Paulmcdonald 14:19, 15 October 2016 (UTC) keep I'm more inclined to make an exception for this player: two-time all-American for Division I-FCS, and punters are far more likely to move from FCS to NFL. I found http://www.wday.com/sports/football/4033189-former-ndsu-punter-ben-lecompte-signs-chicago-bears this article and video in the news that points toward notability. Others include http://football.dailyherald.com/article/20160107/sports/160109272/ Chicago Daily Herald and http://www.brainerddispatch.com/sports/college/3904865-college-football-haeg-repeat-first-team-stats-fcs-all-american Brainered Dispatch. These point to passing based on coverage and college career Deletion of Ben LeCompte WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2788 13206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Metaplacebo User:Medicellis 03:00, 13 July 2008 (UTC) delete """Besides being COI, it also fails to meet , as seen on the talk page, were a search finds no articles or secondary cites of this so called """"new"""" term""" Deletion of Metaplacebo WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2789 17386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of male film actors (L-Z) User:MichaelQSchmidt 15:57, 6 September 2008 (UTC) delete """While one can appreciate the time and dedication it took to compile this partial list, as they have also created List of female film actors, with sublists List of American actresses, List of Chinese actresses , List of Japanese actresses , List of Indian actresses , List of Philippine actresses , List of Iranian actresses , List of Italian actresses , List of Thai actresses , as well as 2 others now at AfD... List of male television actors, and List of female television actors... I have to agree """"what's the point"""". All |LISTCRUFT. Perhaaps they should all be combined into one larger AFD""" Deletion of List of male film actors (L-Z) WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
2790 12885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris E. Janicek User:Mccapra 05:32, 15 June 2021 (UTC) delete does not pass and not otherwise notable Deletion of Chris E. Janicek WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2791 3292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katrina Campins User:Satori 13:29, 17 August 2006 (UTC) delete per and '''Redirect''' to The Apprentice 1 Deletion of Katrina Campins WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2792 2815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ski-Whoop User:Headwes 04:46, 16 January 2008 (UTC) delete This does not meet notability requirements Deletion of Ski-Whoop WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
2793 15330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Regan Booty User:Kosack 06:17, 11 July 2017 (UTC) delete fails having never played in a fully professional league and does not have enough significant coverage to pass Deletion of Regan Booty WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2794 20502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Therion demo albums User:DustFormsWords 03:55, 24 March 2010 (UTC) keep """Perfectly reasonable discography / chronology. Meets the stand-alone list criteria at , has clearly defined inclusion criteria, is closely related to an article on a notable topic (Therion), and can reasonably be considered to aid in an detailed understanding of that topic. Please note that this is not an ''article on a particular demo'' but rather a ''list of demos'' and therefore the presumption against demos at is not invoked. It does need a rename, though, to """"List of Therion demo albums""" Deletion of Therion demo albums WP:SALAT||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
2795 21591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Music Central User:Mhking 15:56, 23 March 2007 (UTC) delete violates Deletion of Christian Music Central WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
2796 21256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rescue Chocolate User:Dom 07:32, 28 August 2020 (UTC) delete per nomination. I can't find anything online to demonstrate notability. Fails Deletion of Rescue Chocolate WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
2797 16118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nexsan User:AllyD 08:55, 3 February 2017 (UTC) delete Until a few weeks ago, a redirect to the article on the parent :Imation could have been suggested as an outcome, but the recently completed sale (https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-40416868.html{{Highbeam}}) makes that inappropriate. I have added several news items from points in the convoluting history but the question remains whether there is enough for encyclopaedic notability? Aside from these takeover/sale items, I am seeing only routine product announcements: not sufficient for or broader Deletion of Nexsan :WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2798 17191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Torn (online game) User:TheSandDoctor 04:17, 16 March 2018 (UTC) delete per the above. It does not meet Deletion of Torn (online game) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2799 2758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion//r/The Donald User:That NONE keep """and I'm leaning towards ''speedy''. Just because topics involved with this forum are elsewhere does not preclude this article existing. I'm unconcerned about this """"opening the door"""". If the sources establish notability, that's enough. Per {{tq|The content itself has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself}}. A brief examination of the sources used in this article shows this sub-reddit meets that criteria""" Deletion of /r/The Donald WP:WEBCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2800 20072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Louise Cliffe User:Doomsdayer520 03:32, 28 January 2010 (UTC) delete """Except for http://www.imdb.com/name/nm3114981/ IMDB most of the sources to be found are self-promotional or comments on her modeling shots. My vote is """"weak"""" because like the nominator I see the notability as questionable. She has been in a possibly notable film, and the fact that her non-acting (i.e. modeling) has gained fans and notice in places like http://www.askmen.com/galleries/louise-cliffe/picture-1.html AskMen indicates that she ''might'' be close to meeting #2 of . But I don't think she's quite notable yet""" Deletion of Louise Cliffe WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
2801 3827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tradepedia User:David 13:26, 19 September 2016 (UTC) delete no references, a basic shows mostly press releases Deletion of Tradepedia WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
2802 1474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billy Oman User:Guliolopez 23:54, 24 May 2008 (UTC) delete """Fails - no sources, supporting citations or other references offered or available. For reasons of VER alone, should be removed. Also fails - the """"highest level in amateur sports"""" in this context is a place with the national team. Transport F.C. are hardly top-flight. Even Bohs at the time were also a struggling team. If Oman helped Bohs to any major silverware I could see a case, but Bohs didn't win a single piece of silverware in those 2 years (or in fact for about 10 years either side of Oman's tenure""" Deletion of Billy Oman WP:VER||WP:NN Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2803 20306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aubrey K. Miller (2nd nomination) User:NatGertler 19:36, 27 May 2019 (UTC) delete per nom; Deletion of Aubrey K. Miller (2nd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
2804 4910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Zupicich User:AuthorAuthor 08:00, 30 August 2018 (UTC) keep Per and asic, well worded by Deletion of Joseph Zupicich WP:BIO||WP:B Wikipedia:Notability 77
2805 2891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Tea Party politicians User:Colapeninsula 16:09, 17 May 2012 (UTC) comment The only valid criteria I can think of is to restrict it to people who self-identify as Tea Party members/supporters (although people may change their minds, which will give problems). There's a lot of non-notable people there; says lists should be lists of links to articles, not just lists of people who wouldn't merit WP articles on their own Deletion of List of Tea Party politicians WP:L Wikipedia:Lists 97
2806 21423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ikes Fire User:Reywas92 23:43, 10 December 2019 (UTC) delete Content is merely procedural news of the extent burned and fails , , and . Our ATD is that these can be discussed at 2015 California wildfires, 2018 Oregon wildfires, etc. The Notes column of the tables in these can certainly handle the small amount of content here Deletion of Ikes Fire WP:LASTING||WP:GEOSCOPE||WP:CONTINUEDCOVERAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2807 12188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Ayoub User:TenOfAllTrades 13:14, 7 August 2007 (UTC) comment """Ayoub DM"""" draws only six hits on PubMed; one is a recent letter to ''Am J Epidemiol'', one is is 1983 ''Science'' paper, there are three radiology-related papers over the intervening twenty years, plus one letter to the editor of ''Am J Surg''. Four actual publications over twenty-four years – even including one in ''Science'' – is a very weak publication record. It sure looks like this guy is being used as yet another |coatrack to push a particular anti-vaccination position—for some reason this article has a """"Quotes"""" section, and there seems to be an effort to remove criticismhttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=David_Ayoub&diff=110237160&oldid=110095147 from the article""" Deletion of David Ayoub WP:COAT Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
2808 3312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Leonard (Vivation) User:Pharaoh 01:23, 30 August 2014 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Jim Leonard (Vivation) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2809 14742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Bacon User:Athomeinkobe 11:14, 4 February 2016 (UTC) keep As per above, he meets / otability (sports), and I can see no justifiable reason to otherwise remove the article Deletion of Chris Bacon WP:NOLYMPICS||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2810 4981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Travis Clark User:Jasynnash2 12:35, 15 September 2008 (UTC) merge per Deletion of Travis Clark WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2811 8701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teal Swan User:Kraxler 17:15, 16 August 2015 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a to describe one's problems. It's also not a place to te one's business or views. There's no claim of notability in the article, and even ed with questionable refs, it fails Deletion of Teal Swan WP:SOAPBOX||WP:PROMO||WP:BOMBARD||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2812 12065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hell or High Water (2017 film) (2nd nomination) User:Versace1608 16:02, 6 May 2020 (UTC) delete https://guardian.ng/saturday-magazine/at-hell-or-high-water-premiere/ ''The Guardian Life'' and https://nostringsng.com/hell-or-high-water-goes-online/ NoStrings are two websites that have published press release articles about the film. Pulse Nigeria wrote https://www.pulse.ng/entertainment/movies/hell-or-high-water-short-film-explores-reality-of-sexuality-amidst-spirituality/3fj5g7k a solid review of the film but this isn't enough to satisfy criterion 1 of Deletion of Hell or High Water (2017 film) (2nd nomination) WP:NFO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2813 10660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Television series considered the greatest ever (2nd nomination) User:Bob 18:59, 26 October 2007 (UTC) comment I agree it could potentially be interesting, but as I see it, most of the inclusions appear to suggest that longevity is a measure of 'greatness', which, as you say, is |original research Deletion of Television series considered the greatest ever (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2814 17198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Makoto Shinryu User:Papaursa 19:32, 25 September 2020 (UTC) delete He has no top tier MMA fights. A championship in a lower tier counts nothing towards WP MMA notability. My search found no significant independent coverage, just lots of routine sports reporting and listings in fight cards and databases. Right now it appears to be for him Deletion of Makoto Shinryu WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
2815 20269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maksim Agapov User:Ejgreen77 01:21, 28 February 2017 (UTC) keep as he appears to meet the requirements Deletion of Maksim Agapov WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2816 13353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larah Claire Sabroso User:RightCowLeftCoast 04:21, 11 June 2013 (UTC) merge to ''May Isang Pangarap'', although I have found some brief mentions of the subject of this article from reliable sources in the Philippines none of those RSs appear to give the subject |in-depth |significant coverage for the subject to be considered notable as defined by ; now it be argued that she has a significant role in one television program in the Philippines, but I am unsure if she has had multiple significant roles as required to be notable as defined by . Therefore, it is my present opinion that it is |too soon for the subject to have a stand alone biography article. Therefore, as the individual has only had a major role in one program ''May Isang Pangarap'', I am presently supporting a redirect. If the subject of this AfD has a significant role in another television series, the article can be resurrected from the redirect Deletion of Larah Claire Sabroso WP:INDEPTH||WP:SIGCOV||WP:ANYBIO||WP:NACTOR||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
2817 7075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BlackDown User:Gongshow 00:59, 25 January 2012 (UTC) delete per ; agree with the above users that this term does not appear to be notable Deletion of BlackDown WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
2818 5842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Machete (film) (2nd nomination) User:PC78 17:58, 16 February 2009 (UTC) delete or '''merge''' (don't mind which) per my nomination first time around. Whether this meets the GNG or not is besides the point; per the basic principles of , a few comments in the media about a film which may or may not go into production is not something tangible enough to warrant it's own article. If it is to be covered on Wikipedia at all, this material belongs elsewhere, such as at Robert Rodriguez Deletion of Machete (film) (2nd nomination) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2819 12522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesse Bushyhead User:Blathnaid 20:29, 18 February 2008 (UTC) keep Meets the Wikipedia:BIO#Basic_criteria|basic criteria of , as he has been talked about in http://books.google.ie/books?q=%22jesse+bushyhead%22&ie=UTF-8&oe=utf-8&rls=org.mozilla:en-GB:official&client=firefox-a&um=1&sa=N&tab=wp multiple reliable sources, eg http://digital.library.okstate.edu/chronicles/v014/v014p349.html (halfway down the page) http://books.google.ie/books?id=Vjwly0QyeU4C&pg=PA115&dq=%22jesse+bushyhead%22&lr=&sig=OgX6Fgks5PCxH8ZWeqWLBUKZvvY and http://books.google.ie/books?id=HL482H3SjesC&pg=PA108&dq=%22jesse+bushyhead%22&sig=YpQjjJBMR5gn8Sfm9UeEjIHvgY4#PPA108,M1. His grave is http://www.ocgi.okstate.edu/shpo/shpopic.asp?id=04001334 includedin the National Register of Historic Places, which also gives him notability Deletion of Jesse Bushyhead WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2820 14846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rohanpreet Singh User:Ad 20:11, 29 October 2020 (UTC) keep WP:GNG doesn't care whether the reasons for coverage are completely superficial. Friendly puff pieces in RS/IS are still coverage in RS/IS. in /WP:IS means GNG met Deletion of Rohanpreet Singh WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2821 13699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Bundy Jr User:Starblind 04:39, 9 November 2010 (UTC) delete per , . Doesn't inherit notability for appearing on non-notable shows either Deletion of Larry Bundy Jr WP:N||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
2822 17505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fabrice Elysée Kouadio Kouakou NONE NONE comment Does not meet yet, (will soon), but clearly meets as there are many sources that can't be dismissed as Deletion of Fabrice Elysée Kouadio Kouakou WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2823 6771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Arrowsmith User:Kuyabribri 15:22, 3 February 2010 (UTC) keep Meets as he has competed at the Olympic Games. &mdash Deletion of Chris Arrowsmith WP:ATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
2824 224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anne K. Block User:Ubelowme 02:24, 31 August 2012 (UTC) delete Neither version, the attack page or the whitewash, seem to contain sufficient |notability to meet the , mostly because the subject's notoriety is in an extremely limited geographic area. Deletion will solve the serious BLP and COI concerns Deletion of Anne K. Block WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2825 9370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adimulapu Suresh User:Gene93k 14:32, 10 March 2016 (UTC) keep Verifiable MLA. State legislators pass Deletion of Adimulapu Suresh WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2826 21595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fatima Rainey User:Yuckfoo 01:17, 28 September 2006 (UTC) keep please per meets music guideline since signed with warner japan Deletion of Fatima Rainey WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
2827 1501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dick Nasty User:Johnuniq 05:23, 11 April 2010 (UTC) delete """per as stated by nom. Further, """"moderately well known for briefly appearing..."""" does not compensate""" Deletion of Dick Nasty WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2828 10548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dustin Kahia User:Chosenone 04:40, 1 February 2015 (UTC) delete I didn't find any reliable sources to meet . Most of the sources seemed to be written by a user. But If better sources are added bringing awareness it could be a keep Deletion of Dustin Kahia WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
2829 16984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Johnstown Redevelopment Authority User:NJ 04:56, 19 May 2012 (UTC) merge Fails to meet notability requirements, but its content seems informative, so merge into Johnstown, Pennsylvania article Deletion of Johnstown Redevelopment Authority WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2830 3037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Normal Bob Smith (2nd nomination) User:Cbrown1023 20:01, 22 November 2006 (UTC) delete The fact that it was recreated without a is enough for me. But it also seems to be a little on the unnotable side... (the bunch of SPAs don't help either Deletion of Normal Bob Smith (2nd nomination) WP:DRV Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
2831 17072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thirlmere Primary School User:JamieS93 02:57, 31 March 2008 (UTC) delete Nothing indicates the school's notability; the article itself doesn't really even have much #A1|context to be able to identify that Deletion of Thirlmere Primary School WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
2832 18299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nabi Hasan User:DrStrauss 17:54, 2 October 2017 (UTC) delete """of the 10 sources the article cites, every single one of them has """"profile"""" in its description. The article is nothing more than a résumé so fails """ Deletion of Nabi Hasan WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2833 9130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nasir Mahmood Khosa User:Snowycats 16:25, 15 July 2018 (UTC) keep passes basic and can move further Deletion of Nasir Mahmood Khosa WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2834 850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thirteen of Everything User:ArcAngel 16:52, 24 May 2011 (UTC) delete """fails . It's interesting to note that the article states their debut album received """"wide acclaim"""", yet never charted according to Billboard""" Deletion of Thirteen of Everything WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2835 12114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amsterdam Magazine (3rd nomination) User:Uzma 23:22, 23 September 2012 (UTC) delete """fails . I found some bylines with """"Amsterdam Magazine"""" in them.http://www.google.com/#hl=en&sclient=psy-ab&q=%22Arun+Sood+writes+for+Amsterdam+Magazine+%22&oq=%22Arun+Sood+writes+for+Amsterdam+Magazine+%22&gs_l=serp.3...12828.13563.0.13750.3.3.0.0.0.0.156.375.1j2.3.0.les%3B..0.0...1c.1j2.asSXM5IkA-E&pbx=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.&fp=1868d924740104b&biw=1280&bih=856 The Guardian mentioned Amsterdam Magazine in a news article,http://www.guardian.co.uk/travel/blog/2012/feb/29/guardian-travel-network-city-bloggers The Guardian February 29, 2012 probably as a favor to Amsterdam Magazine writer and The Guardian contributor Arun Sood in an effort to get some additional readers to the Amsterdam Magazine's final issue. That's about all the reliable source info, which doesn't add up to enough coverage to meet """ Deletion of Amsterdam Magazine (3rd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2836 10368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 May Day protests User:Bri 22:31, 2 May 2017 (UTC) keep ec}} Once again a vexatious, knee-jerk delete nomination to go along with progressive-related Northwest and national themes immediately nominated for deletion like rticles for deletion/Marissa Johnson, rticles for deletion/Women's March on Seattle, and rticles for deletion/Scientists' March on Washington. Agree with AB's comment above, this should stop Deletion of 2017 May Day protests WP:A||WP:A||WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
2837 13234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haukur Halldórsson User:B 04:15, 15 December 2006 (UTC) keep international exhibitions are sufficient for . To disregard this is to add to Wikipedia:Systemic bias|systemic bias Deletion of Haukur Halldórsson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2838 17207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Other Side (album) User:Cocytus 04:35, 4 January 2010 (UTC) delete does not appear as if there is any significant coverage to satisfy Deletion of Other Side (album) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2839 16747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mall goth User:Alphachimp 01:21, 11 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Mall goth WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2840 13321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Federation of the European Sporting Goods Industry User:HighKing 19:00, 16 December 2019 (UTC) delete I am unable to locate any |significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, fails GNG/ Deletion of Federation of the European Sporting Goods Industry WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2841 16681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mac renshaw [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']] 16:03, 4 March 2006 (UTC) delete Unverifiable biography & warns against stacking the vote Deletion of Mac renshaw WP:SOCK Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
2842 6483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ActivMedia Robotics (2nd nomination) User:Cewbot 00:02, 12 December 2020 (UTC) comment While this discussion appears to have |no quorum, it is '''NOT eligible for |soft deletion''' because it was Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ActivMedia Robotics|previously discussed at AfD and the result was Keep Deletion of ActivMedia Robotics (2nd nomination) WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
2843 331 [[Wildwäxl]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers NONE delete Kasten|. Die Erklärungen sind zwar sympathisch offen, aber sie zeigen eben genau nicht die überregionale Bekanntheit, die für einen Wikipedia-Eintrag erwartet würde, und die sich in allgemein verfügbare Veröffentlichungen bei einem bekannten Label oder überregionaler Wahrnehmung in den Medien zeigen müsste. Die #Pop|Relevanzkriterien werden jedenfalls anscheinend nicht erfüllt. Auch das Fehlen von WP:Belege|Belegen aus Sekundärquellen (Medien, Fachzeitschriften) macht den Artikel ungeeignet für die Wikipedia. Für eine Selbstdarstellung der Bandgeschichte wäre evtl. das http://musik.wikia.com/wiki/Musik_Wiki Musik-Wiki (keine Relevanzkriterien für Artikel) besser geeignet. Gruß Löschung von Wildwäxl Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2844 2969 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""Zitterbewegung and Cold Fusion""""""" User:Hut 18:37, 8 November 2007 (UTC) delete original research, little notability. Seems to be created to promote this theory, in violation of and . An http://en.wikinews.org/wiki/%22zitterbewegung_and_cold_fusion%22 extremely similar article has also appeared on Wikinews, despite the fact it is obviously not a news story. See also Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quantum Ring Theory """Deletion of """"Zitterbewegung and Cold Fusion""""""" WP:COI||WP:SOAP Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
2845 910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sab Kichu Bhene Pare (2nd nomination) User:NahalAhmed 19:39, 6 January 2020 (UTC) keep Since that is bengali novel written by Bangladeshi writer Humayun Azad. it is a Bangladeshi article, it is basically found in Bengali Wikipedia. Please search on google :bn:সব_কিছু_ভেঙে_পড়ে and review sources via transliteration. https://www.rokomari.com/book/2707/sob-kisu-venge-pore 1 https://bn.bdebooks.com/books/%E0%A6%B8%E0%A6%AC-%E0%A6%95%E0%A6%BF%E0%A6%9B%E0%A7%81-%E0%A6%AD%E0%A7%87%E0%A6%99%E0%A7%87-%E0%A6%AA%E0%A7%9C%E0%A7%87/ 2 and probably those source can be passed to Deletion of Sab Kichu Bhene Pare (2nd nomination) WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2846 21753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liu Chang (actor) User:Jumpytoo 05:34, 29 October 2020 (UTC) keep A quick look at sources at https://baike.baidu.com/item/%E5%88%98%E7%95%85/12638043 Baidu Baike's version of the article show enough (there are probably better choices, but examples http://js.ifeng.com/yc/news/detail_2015_11/16/4560026_2.shtml http://ent.sina.com.cn/m/c/2015-11-13/doc-ifxksqis4802768.shtml Deletion of Liu Chang (actor) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
2847 17640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amalgam Digital User:Nomader 02:53, 26 May 2008 (UTC) delete edit conflict): Written as an advertisement, violates and as well as as brought up by the nominator Deletion of Amalgam Digital WP:SOAP||WP:NPOV||WP:CORP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2848 11267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KEWS User:B 04:23, 12 September 2009 (UTC) delete completely lacking in coverage in |reliable sources (per Wikipedia definition) independent of the station and its owner (please read ). I must point out that Wikipedia is not on a crusade to delete this article because it's a pirate radio station but because of complete lack of coverage (other U.S. pirate radio stations have had their articles here because of coverage in local print and television coverage; some European pirate stations have had worldwide press coverage). Should this article survive the AfD, it's in serious need of cleanup Deletion of KEWS WP:RS||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2849 12297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omniverse User:Mrt3366 15:46, 4 December 2012 (UTC) keep This article is one of the most |poorly written articles I have recently come across. This article fails to meet multiple guidelines and the standard expected. Some sections even need to be re-written. That being said, deleting is not the solution. I agree with {{UT|Thesteve}}. The problems listed here are Wikipedia:FIXTHEPROBLEM|surmountable and the content is not entirely irretrievable ergo they cannot serve as grounds for deletion. But I might be wrong anyway Deletion of Omniverse WP:RUBBISH Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2850 12234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B2B CFO User:HighKing 20:07, 13 August 2021 (UTC) delete """The criteria for establishing notability for companies/organizations as per is for multiple sources (at least two) of deep or significant coverage with |in-depth information *on the company* and (this bit is important!) containing |""""Independent Content"""". """"Independent content"""", in order to count towards establishing notability, must include ''original and independent opinion, analysis, investigation, and fact checking that are clearly attributable to a source unaffiliated to the subject''. None of the references in the article meet the criteria and having searched I am unable to locate any references that meet the criteria. Topic fails """ Deletion of B2B CFO WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2851 6459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Peto User:Colapeninsula 09:03, 10 April 2012 (UTC) keep Full professor at one of the world's leading universities, University of Oxford, seems to meet . However there is almost no information about him online Deletion of Tim Peto WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2852 3438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Notre Dame of Greater Manila User:Peter303x 07:59, 22 June 2021 (UTC) delete Fails . Not enough citations Deletion of Notre Dame of Greater Manila WP:NSCHOOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2853 14397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derek Alfonso User:Paul 03:32, 1 April 2010 (UTC) delete I was also not able to find any reliable sources that would support notability, neither in Google News archives http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Derek+Alfonso%22+%22power+of+information%22&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&btnG=Search+Archives nor elsewhere Deletion of Derek Alfonso WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2854 10547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Assiut University alumni User:Rhododendrites 14:40, 21 April 2018 (UTC) comment Seems like a pretty standard sort of list, and |lists don't duplicate categories, but with such a short list it probably makes most sense to merge it into the university article. Not !voting at this time because I haven't checked that there are actually sources in the linked articles showing those people are alumni, and also because I'm not sure about the sock puppetry issue (which would be a reason for speedy, no?). I see a suspected sock tag, but no SPI, no block, etc. -- on what basis are you saying it's a sock puppet? &mdash Deletion of List of Assiut University alumni WP:NOTDUP Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
2855 9889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Masse User:SkierRMH 20:40, 16 January 2007 (UTC) delete Clearly , reads like a 'letter to the editor Deletion of Jamie Masse WP:OR||WP:SOAPBOX Wikipedia:No original research 65
2856 6732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Campitelli User:RMHED 12:42, 26 August 2006 (UTC) keep Seems to meet notability, as a musician (Yes drummers do count), he even has his own http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1687218/ IMDB page Deletion of Jeff Campitelli WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2857 1206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tomono clan User:Cliff12345 18:36, 7 May 2013 (UTC) comment I have added as much information and as many sources as I could find for the article on the internet; I also agree with Michitaro's suggestion regarding checking published sources. I'll leave it to others to decide whether to remove the page or not. On second thoughts, given the lack of consensus on whether to delete the page (it's also been |relisted), I may have to put in my own opinion at some point Deletion of Tomono clan WP:RELIST Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
2858 10365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/High School Musical 4: The College Years User:Matthewedwards 22:53, 14 August 2008 (UTC) delete per , , Deletion of High School Musical 4: The College Years WP:V||WP:NN||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2859 1360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aisha Chaudhary User:Atlantic306 20:07, 5 July 2020 (UTC) keep as meets as explained above and as confirmed in multiple reliable sources already in the article such as Indian Express, India Today and others so deletion is unnecessary in my view Deletion of Aisha Chaudhary WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2860 4695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cornelia Chase Brant User:Enos733 20:27, 10 July 2021 (UTC) keep Easily passes Deletion of Cornelia Chase Brant WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2861 53 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TWA media (non-commercial) User:AmericanAir88 13:30, 26 July 2019 (UTC) delete No convincing sources to pass . Not a deletion comment, but this non-notable article can also be confused with Trans-World Airlines (TWA Deletion of TWA media (non-commercial) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2862 16151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lexington Partners NONE NONE delete per my nom. Article fails , and . Article was created by an account. Part of a larger spam campaign that seeded WP with spam articles Deletion of Lexington Partners WP:NOTABILITY||WP:CORP||WP:SPAM||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Notability 77
2863 17655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/South Dakota Gold User:Rpclod 03:13, 16 May 2015 (UTC) delete no references at all, let alone any | reliable sources. Article does not support notability criteria Deletion of South Dakota Gold WP:RS||WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2864 6074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Financier User:Bearian 13:58, 9 August 2017 (UTC) keep per due to good work by {{U|BD2412 Deletion of Financier WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
2865 10404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flying chess User:Frayae 14:41, 27 August 2018 (UTC) comment Wikipedia is not a general encyclopedia, at least according to the Wikipedia:Five pillars|five pillars. Meanwhile I see no reason why two reliable sources is not enough for an article. Particularly where both are in-depth and one is an encyclopedia. There are sufficient sources to meet . That other discussion is not comparable because that was an instance of an article cited to a single source, which obviously fails . &mdash Deletion of Flying chess WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2866 20601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parwiz border point User:فرهنگ2016 14:53, 4 August 2019 (UTC) keep per https://tools.wmflabs.org/geohack/geohack.php?language=en¶ms=34.554321_N_45.589503_E_&pagename=%DA%AF%D8%B0%D8%B1%DA%AF%D8%A7%D9%87_%D9%85%D8%B1%D8%B2%DB%8C_%D9%BE%D8%B1%D9%88%DB%8C%D8%B2%D8%AE%D8%A7%D9%86https://en.irna.ir/news/83036544/Iran-s-Parviz-Khan-Border-Crossing-strategically-important-forhttps://en.isna.ir/news/96101206221/Iran-reopens-Parviz-Khan-Tamarchin-borders-with-Iraqi-Kurdistanhttps://en.isna.ir/news/96072413471/Iran-closes-Parviz-Khan-Border-Terminal-in-Kermanshah-Provincehttps://en.mehrnews.com/news/128672/Iran-shuts-Parviz-Khan-border-with-Kurdistan-regionhttps://www.iraq-businessnews.com/2018/01/02/border-crossings-with-iraqi-kurdistan-reopen/http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/arbil-offers-joint-administration-of-borders-with-baghdad-as-iran-re-opens-borders-125117https://www.en.eghtesadonline.com/Section-economy-4/12460-iran-exports-more-than-one-billion-dollars-goods-to-iraqhttps://www.magiran.com/article/3640521https://www.dailystar.com.lb/News/Middle-East/2018/Jan-02/432120-iran-reopens-border-crossings-with-iraqi-kurdistan.ashxhttps://www.magiran.com/article/3064258https://www.magiran.com/article/1497100https://www.magiran.com/article/3541637https://www.magiran.com/article/1031577 Deletion of Parwiz border point WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
2867 8183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reel cinerose User:MichaelQSchmidt 03:23, 16 May 2015 (UTC) delete While this little company exists, simply producing films and having no coverage is a failure of Deletion of Reel cinerose WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2868 13030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuchar Von Dieu User:DarkAudit 18:39, 13 May 2007 (UTC) delete seems slightly hoaxy to me. Search for UMPC TV on Google only returns Ultra Mobile PC hits. nothing about any TV network anywhere in the world. All we're left with is a bunch of YouTube videos. Not enough per Deletion of Kuchar Von Dieu WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2869 14818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John D. Freyer User:Wifione 19:55, 24 December 2014 (UTC) keep """u|Northamerica1000}}, {{u|LaMona}}, as per , notability is likely to be present if ''""""the person has created... a well-known work...that has been the subject of ...multiple independent periodical articles or reviews.""""'' In the case of authors, considering their writing of one book as a BLP1E event is not standard practice. If an author's book has attracted multiple independent book reviews, then it is likely that the author is notable. In this case, Freyer's book ''All My Life For Sale'' has attracted book reviews in http://www.newsweek.com/books-different-kind-selling-out-140985 Newsweek, http://www.theguardian.com/books/2002/dec/08/art Guardian, http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:S_QYwKLEGdcJ:www2.citypaper.com/printReview.asp%3Frid%3D5090+&cd=2&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=in CityPaper, http://www.portlandmercury.com/portland/all-my-life-for-sale/Content?oid=27953 Portland Mercury, http://www.seattlepi.com/ae/books/article/In-All-My-Life-for-Sale-a-man-learns-it-s-not-1101216.php Seattle PI, apart from others. This is enough to qualify Freyer's notability on |AUTHOR""" Deletion of John D. Freyer WP:AUTHOR||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2870 8952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Packaged cake User:Kinu 07:36, 13 February 2006 (UTC) delete as , which I'd bet my package that this is Deletion of Packaged cake WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
2871 18572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/China Quality Certification Center User:Metal 13:58, 12 August 2014 (UTC) delete the CCC mark is totally important and this is the organization that processes it. There's already a good China Compulsory Certificate|CCC article and it already mentions the CQC. Coverage of the CQC is almost entirely about CCC as one would expect and |Notability is not inherited. I would support expanding somewhat the coverage of the CQC in the CCC article to the extent that independent sources can verify such an expansion. If you look at independent coverage and ask if they are talking about CCC or the organization that processes it, then you can see that it's hard to get this past Deletion of China Quality Certification Center WP:INHERITORG||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2872 15779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmet Orun User:David 20:34, 14 March 2016 (UTC) delete Google scholar citation record too slim for #C1 and no other indication of notability Deletion of Ahmet Orun WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2873 5414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fatima de Madrid User:Amatulic 20:17, 5 October 2011 (UTC) comment """It occurs to me that sources are likely to be non-electronic and non-English. Possibly Spanish or Arabic. Also, it isn't exactly true that |significant coverage of the subject is the only criterion that matters for notability. From Wikipedia:Notability (people), a scholar can be notable without her biography being the subject of secondary sources. She would be notable if she has made a widely recognized contribution to astronomy, or originated a significant new concept or discovery. Note that the concept or discovery is the notable thing that receives coverage, not necessarily the person; this is a possible exception to . Simply """"being an 11th century female Muslim astronomer"""" isn't really a good claim, although Wikipedia:Notability (academics) suggests that she'd be notable if sources make note of the rarity of female astronomers in her time — and it would be surprising if no source made note of this fact. Whether such sources exist is another matter. Anyone know how to spell her name in Arabic""" Deletion of Fatima de Madrid WP:SIGCOV||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
2874 10186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Intellectuals and Society User:RadioFan 20:32, 6 July 2011 (UTC) keep Meets with at least 2 in depth critical reviews of the book avialble (Washington Times and National Review Online). It would be nice to have a review from the other end of the political spectrum to help ensure a nuetral article can be written however Deletion of Intellectuals and Society WP:NBOOKS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2875 19036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Seibert User:NawlinWiki 11:54, 21 March 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Alex Seibert WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2876 10262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blob 'n' Slob User:Cirt 17:29, 13 December 2007 (UTC) delete per above, unsourced/, no notability established Deletion of Blob 'n' Slob WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2877 3667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susan M. Dray User:Deadwikipedian 23:25, 1 April 2018 (UTC) comment """The article seems blatantly advertorial, with peacock words like """"...an ''experienced'' American HCI..."""". If kept, it would need to be rewritten to be encyclopedic and comply with """ Deletion of Susan M. Dray WP:BLPSTYLE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2878 19913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Secret Life of Walter Mitty (2009 film) User:Dhartung 23:36, 25 December 2007 (UTC) delete and restore former naming as above. There is nothing, nada, zilch in Google News Archive since Myers was attached to the project in May, which is exactly where it was when previous stars were attached. Could be in D-Hell forever. Fails , , etc. #DIR|We are not a directory of films in development Deletion of The Secret Life of Walter Mitty (2009 film) WP:CRYSTAL||WP:FUTFILM||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2879 15154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chessgames.com User:MaxBrowne 10:04, 8 April 2015 (UTC) keep """It's a well established site going back to 2001, and is one of the most popular chess-related sites on the internet, despite its well publicized shortcomings. I think significant ''negative'' coverage in reliable sources counts towards establish notability too. (I'll fix the link to Olimpiu Urcan's chesscafe article to point to the wayback machine.) How to determine what is a """"reliable source"""" with regard to chess? The fact is most mainstream news sources rarely cover chess, and when they do they often get the details wrong (e.g. not knowing the difference between a """"game"""" and a """"match""""). Taylor Kingston's chesscafe.com, Edward Winter's chesshistory.com and Mark Crowther's theweekinchess.com are among the more reliable sources for chess information. Lubomir Kavalek's column in the Huffington Post is good, Leonard Barden's column in the Guardian is good... but the chess community will always be somewhat incestuous and self-referential. I really think wikipedia needs to re-examine its notability policy; just because a web site doesn't have an article written about it in the New York Times doesn't mean it's not notable. The current policy makes it too easy for people with an agenda to get articles about websites they don't like deleted; this has happened in the past with other chess-related websites""" Deletion of Chessgames.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2880 19479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Baker (actor) User:Xender 19:47, 24 May 2016 (UTC) keep """per ntertainer. The guideline recommends that actors who have had """"''significant roles in multiple notable television shows...''"""" may be kept. Bob has appeared in 8 episodes of Valentine (the TV series) and 13 episodes of Grey's Anatomy. There is a significant probability of sources being available. One should add and develop this article rather than delete""" Deletion of Robert Baker (actor) WP:E Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
2881 857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isaaq genocide User:Ms 00:00, 18 May 2017 (UTC) keep """The delete request has offered no persuasive community-agreed reason to delete this article. None of the criteria 1-13 of -REASON apply in this case. WP:PROPAGANDA is alleged, which qualifies as criteria 14, but the topic has been covered in WP:RS published by reputable sources such as Oxford University Press, Cambridge University Press, Cornell University Press, University of Pennsylvania Press, Springer, etc and an article attempting to summarize these views is neither WP:WWIN nor the intent of that guideline. See further discussions and quotes from WP:RS on the :Talk:Isaaq genocide page. All this means the topic meets the """"verifiability, reliable sources and notability"""" criteria. The article's NPOV and title issues need to be discussed on the article's talk page per (see the January discussion""" Deletion of Isaaq genocide WP:DEL||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
2882 14897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Standard assumptions in astrodynamics User:FellGleaming 05:35, 14 April 2010 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a teaching or |how to guide; this is essentially a thumb guide to solving astrodynamical problems Deletion of Standard assumptions in astrodynamics WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2883 3355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glenn Hagele User:Bearian 00:44, 22 December 2007 (UTC) delete While there are lots of ''quotes'', there is not much ''about'' the subject. He is |not notable beyond the average board-certified physician and |adjunct college teacher. I don't see how ''deletion'' of a bio can be libel; in fact, the ''contra'' is true Deletion of Glenn Hagele WP:N||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2884 10212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rosie Winter – Winter in June User:BethNaught 08:52, 22 November 2014 (UTC) delete Not notable. Barely any Google or Google news hits, certainly no reliable sources to be readily found. Also the article contains undue biographical information about the author. I believe it fails Deletion of Rosie Winter – Winter in June WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2885 8120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Arbuthnot (politician) User:BrownHairedGirl 18:51, 5 June 2007 (UTC) keep because notability asserted per as a member of a national Parliament. Needs more sources, though, so I have tagged it with {{tl|moresources Deletion of Alexander Arbuthnot (politician) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2886 16541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The WBC User:MER 06:10, 2 January 2007 (UTC) delete no evidence from |reliable sources that has been met Deletion of The WBC WP:RS||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2887 21769 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""C"""" Is for (Please Insert Sophomoric Genitalia Reference HERE)""" User:Bfigura 17:03, 14 October 2009 (UTC) delete as |Wikipedia isn't a crystal ball: there's no references that discuss the subject, hence no need for an article """Deletion of """"C"""" Is for (Please Insert Sophomoric Genitalia Reference HERE)""" WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2888 2119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greeks in Cuba User:Edison 03:07, 4 May 2009 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not a directory listing articles with every bilateral combination of persons from country X who live in country Y. A few incidentals in newspapers does not establish that such article are encyclopedic, and the references do not satisfy Deletion of Greeks in Cuba WP:NOT||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2889 2776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanchari Mondal User:Atlantic306 14:44, 22 February 2019 (UTC) keep as passes with multiple roles in notable productions and now has reliable sources references added to the article so it does need to be deleted in my view, thanks Deletion of Sanchari Mondal WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2890 20008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tupple [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']] 18:45, 14 February 2006 (UTC) delete Non-notable 'sport', violation Deletion of Tupple WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2891 8399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nekojiru User:NewYorkActuary 21:51, 8 February 2016 (UTC) merge to Cat Soup. I'm seeing this as a situation for which applies. AngusWoof's argument convinces me that a merge and redirect is the right approach here Deletion of Nekojiru WP:NOPAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2892 5764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The ringworm children affair User:Davidruben 14:06, 22 October 2007 (UTC) merge """whilst I can't comment on specifics in Israel, the use of radiation therapy in otherwise potentially severe and difficult to treat scalp ringworm infection (in the days before griseofulvin) was not limited to Israel, but was also standard practice in the UK in the 1930's & 1940's, so the suggestion within the article (by its sole discussion on Israel experience) of it being a sinister experiment seems just a wild conspiracy theory (notwithstanding whether or not there was sterotyping of one group of Jews against another). I still occassionally come across elderly UK patients who were so treated and have had multiple recurrent localised skin tumors since. See {{PMID|17467352}} for a paper published this year about experiences of one hospital in London. A quick search on PubMed shows also recent papers of {{PMID|17209506}} from Tunisia, {{PMID|16896588}} from Germany, {{PMID|15565500}} Italy etc etc. The example in Israel is therefore not unique, and I know of no sinsiter conspiracy theory for radiotherapy's use elsewhere to treat this condition. Therefore if it was routine and """"the modern thing to do"""" in 1940's Britain, the sole dicussion of the use in Israel seems focus, for what should be just a sub-section in an article with more global perspective (eg Radiotherapy for scalp ringworm). Use of a journalistic headline title for a discussion solely about a non-English speaking country seems inappropriate here in English wikipedia, where our primary readers are those from English-speaking countries (Australia, Canada, Ireland, N.Z., S.Africa, UK, US etc""" Deletion of The ringworm children affair WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
2893 12361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twist ending in anime User:Ned 06:44, 1 February 2007 (UTC) delete possibly Deletion of Twist ending in anime WP:SNOWBALL Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
2894 15303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mana World User:Sephiroth 01:19, 15 July 2008 (UTC) delete no notability asserted through coverage by |reliable sources independent of the topic. An AfD of a recently created article is a pretty bad decision, but this game is clearly not notable Deletion of The Mana World WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2895 4101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Lindquist (2nd nomination) User:Utopes 00:26, 27 October 2019 (UTC) delete per . The subject of the article, being a relatively unknown non-public figure, requests its deletion, so this request should be fulfilled Deletion of Mark Lindquist (2nd nomination) WP:BLPREQUESTDELETE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2896 20256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Antin User:CaroleHenson 16:43, 16 December 2016 (UTC) comment I agree that right now it sounds very promotional - and it's also possibly |original research. It's unfortunate that it's only source is IMdB. I am going to work on it and see what I can dig up, starting with the sources provide above. As it is right now, I am not prepared to vote to keep it Deletion of Jonathan Antin WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2897 2455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bad Karma (EP) User:Articuno 12:38, 22 April 2021 (UTC) keep Current status meets as per above Deletion of Bad Karma (EP) WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
2898 10516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ninth Letter User:Chondrite 23:16, 7 December 2006 (UTC) keep and cleanup. Article asserts notability that should be easy to verify. The article definitely needs cleanup though. Wikpedia does not need to discuss every issue of this periodical, an external link to the publication site should suffice. Editors should see , and seek examples of |good or |featured articles in category:American Magazines Deletion of Ninth Letter WP:STYLE||WP:WIAGA||WP:WIAFA Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
2899 5147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Atheist Experience (2nd nomination) [[User talk:202.124.72.77|talk]]) 00:47, 2 June 2012 (UTC) delete The only about the show I can find is the local coverage in the ''Austin American-Statesman'' and ''The Austin Chronicle'' noted above, which isn't enough for . -- Special:Contributions/202.124.72.77|202.124.72.77 Deletion of The Atheist Experience (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2900 21465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beep!!/Sunshine Sunshine User:Ryulong 08:38, 1 February 2011 (UTC) keep Prosperosity is incorrect that the article does not pass notability. I have provided 7 independent sources which mention the release (outside of those verifying that it exists) and discuss the notability of the two songs within Japan. It seems that there is a fatal flaw in that it explicitly forbids articles on verifiable future releases of singles (which are more like EPs in the Japanese music industry Deletion of Beep!!/Sunshine Sunshine WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2901 10269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Twisted Outlook User:Trebor 01:18, 16 February 2007 (UTC) delete unless non-trivial sources are produced to establish |notability (although the relatively low traffic levels makes that seem unlikely). Probable conflict of interest as the article is written very much like an advert Deletion of A Twisted Outlook WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2902 16117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unitas Communications User:Northamerica1000 03:04, 30 December 2011 (UTC) delete spaced ndash}}Only found directory listings and this mention: http://www.asiansinmedia.org/2009/03/13/cineforum-event-looks-to-raise-muslim-women-profile/. Topic isn't passing at this time Deletion of Unitas Communications WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2903 8395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albert Lee Ferris [[User talk:2607:FE50:0:8202:6080:6D42:4BBA:8D41|talk]]) 01:18, 24 January 2014 (UTC) delete Does not pass notability standards, fails the and , no sources and everything appears to be original research. Special:Contributions/2607:FE50:0:8202:6080:6D42:4BBA:8D41|2607:FE50:0:8202:6080:6D42:4BBA:8D41 Deletion of Albert Lee Ferris WP:GNG||WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
2904 14267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CMiC User:Ihcoyc 16:21, 13 December 2011 (UTC) delete WP:CSD#G11|Unambiguous advertisement for |another |back office software business. Google News suggests a possibly notable CMIC, but that apparently is a medical concern and this is something else entirely Deletion of CMiC WP:MILL||WP:B2B Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
2905 8638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess Katarina of Yugoslavia User:TJMSmith 00:44, 11 September 2020 (UTC) keep per based on the available sources. I trimmed some fluff and added a few sources Deletion of Princess Katarina of Yugoslavia WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
2906 1246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Modulus Global User:CNMall41 03:16, 9 October 2015 (UTC) delete There are a ton of press releases but nothing I see in depth. In fact, there is very little coverage at all. Fails Deletion of Modulus Global WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2907 18116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oliver Wyman Group User:Shalom 00:09, 14 October 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Predictably, the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Acrylucs contrib log of the original author demonstrates a clear |conflict of interest Deletion of Oliver Wyman Group WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
2908 4422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eastern Hungarian Kingdom User:Wizardman 17:24, 14 January 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Eastern Hungarian Kingdom WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2909 13434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ugo Wallet User:Bejnar 22:47, 20 June 2017 (UTC) delete fails . Not much here to merge. Better off improving those other articles ''de novo Deletion of Ugo Wallet WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2910 21671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Super temperate [[User: King jakob c|King]] [[User talk: King jakob c|Jakob]] [[Special:Contributions/King jakob c|C]] 23:54, 25 January 2013 (UTC) delete Unreferenced |wordcruft Deletion of Super temperate WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
2911 3301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Msafiri Zawose User:Northamerica1000 01:23, 27 October 2015 (UTC) keep Meets as per http://www.tampabay.com/news/humaninterest/tanzanian-musician-brings-african-culture-to-kids-of-belleair/1242402, http://www.msn.com/en-za/travel/news/musical-instruments-made-for-the-sound-of-tanzania/vp-BBiJdhw, http://allafrica.com/stories/201503031508.html, http://www.thecitizen.co.tz/magazine/success/Keeping-our-traditional-music-alive/-/1843788/1864880/-/v2kdn6z/-/index.html Deletion of Msafiri Zawose WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2912 3368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indie911 User:Tainter 18:55, 29 January 2007 (UTC) delete fails as well as sounding a lot like a spamvertisment Deletion of Indie911 WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2913 1085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rude Awakening (band) User:Kudpung 20:27, 5 October 2010 (UTC) delete Fails . See A7: ''...an article about a band that does not credibly indicate the importance or significance of the subject Deletion of Rude Awakening (band) WP:BAND||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Notability 77
2914 13000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leo (astrology) eminent personalities User:Jmertel23 17:41, 30 November 2019 (UTC) delete as per and Deletion of Leo (astrology) eminent personalities WP:NOTESAL||WP:IINFO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2915 5832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Coke, 8th Earl of Leicester User:Rpclod 14:12, 3 February 2018 (UTC) delete references are insufficient to support notability. Peers are not inherently notable Deletion of Thomas Coke, 8th Earl of Leicester WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2916 2196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baman Piderman User:MelanieN 01:02, 26 September 2010 (UTC) delete Fails by a mile, no coverage ABOUT this web cartoon found anywhere Deletion of Baman Piderman WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2917 3476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blake Murray User:Papaursa 21:24, 7 August 2017 (UTC) delete Right now he doesn't appear to meet either or . At best this is Deletion of Blake Murray WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
2918 14747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helen Baker User:Nsk92 06:41, 21 December 2008 (UTC) delete As noted above, the book does not appear notable (no published reviews, few library holdings and nothing in googlescholar or googlebooks) and there is nothing else in the record to indicate notability of the subject either under or Deletion of Helen Baker WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2919 4256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darth Epsis User:Patar 03:32, 16 February 2009 (UTC) delete It seems to be a |hoax, and there's no mention on Wookiepedia Deletion of Darth Epsis WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
2920 15637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heckler & Koch HK WSG2000 User:ArcAngel 04:20, 3 March 2008 (UTC) delete Due to it being cancelled, that would mean it fails Deletion of Heckler & Koch HK WSG2000 WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2921 9582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamoru Yusuf User:Bearian 00:10, 8 October 2019 (UTC) delete WP:MILL|run of the mill business person; article is |poorly referenced with |shallow references Deletion of Kamoru Yusuf WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2922 4574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Massive Audio User:Sir 09:46, 27 June 2006 (UTC) keep looks like this passes Deletion of Massive Audio WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2923 1711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pollution Check Bangladesh User:Mangoe 16:24, 5 September 2012 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Pollution Check Bangladesh WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2924 59 [[SV Altendorf]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Threedots NONE delete auch so ein Text der nach garnicht erst diskutiert werden sollte: Löschung von SV Altendorf Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2925 12328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malamanteau NONE NONE keep because it meets Deletion of Malamanteau WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2926 14085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mors Syphilitica User:B 08:17, 21 June 2007 (UTC) comment The |Google test is not a valid argument in this context, and neither is the allmusic entry, nor . The possible claim to notability they might have is #6 in : If Lisa Hammer and/or Doc Hammer are notable independent of the band, then the band would be notable as well (although one might to consider a merger Deletion of Mors Syphilitica WP:GHITS||WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2927 16722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Political gaffes User:Worm 13:50, 29 May 2012 (UTC) keep as an article about what a political gaffe is, it's after effects and so on (would need to be renamed to Political gaffe). There appears to be more than enough sources for the term. The article as it is should probably be moved to List of political gaffes, and there's a bit of a difficulty ensuring that the gaffes are notable enough to be mentioned and don't contravene , but it's certainly possible Deletion of Political gaffes WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
2928 18325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Admittedly Incomplete Demos User:SBKSPP 02:12, 7 August 2021 (UTC) merge to Tally Hall#Discography. Fails per nom Deletion of Admittedly Incomplete Demos WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
2929 7663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/European Parliament election, 2019 (United Kingdom) User:RetroCraft314 22:26, 4 June 2018 (UTC) delete per nom. states that the event must be {{tq|almost certain to take place}}, and Brexit casts a substantive doubt. < Deletion of European Parliament election, 2019 (United Kingdom) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2930 6370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jia Sharma User:Skr15081997 15:16, 8 August 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and . The subject doesn't appears to be a notable model or actress Deletion of Jia Sharma WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2931 11113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard King High School User:TerriersFan 10:48, 4 October 2008 (UTC) keep plenty of sources available to meet . We don't delete because of length; we tag and expand Deletion of Richard King High School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2932 18680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VConnect User:Jamie NONE keep """Are you familiar with wikipedia's |GNG criteria at all? This article obviously doesn't fail |notability (web) criteria. All the references cited are from credible and popular dailies. plus The social media accounts of the subject all have what can be considered as a """"cult following"""". Google search didn't give any significant result? are you sure you used the same google search I just used? — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of VConnect WP:GNG||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2933 18073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allied Solutions India Pvt. Ltd. User:K 06:19, 10 August 2016 (UTC) delete for the bad taste shown in adding so many red links (even in Categories) :-). But seriously, this is nothing but a and I cannot find anything substantial on this company Deletion of Allied Solutions India Pvt. Ltd. WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2934 16 [[Wikipedia:Wer zuerst kommt, mahlt zuerst]] (erl., zurück im BNR) Benutzer:Defchris NONE delete Ich dachte, dass das Lemma irgendwas von wegen Autorenrechte darlegt, ist aber nichts als ein Witz, denn schließlich kommt es ja von einem Benutzer, von dem man weiß, dass er sich etliche |unlustigen Scherze erlaubt. , am besten derart, dass es nicht einmal die Admins wiederherstellen können. Das zeigt IMO auch, warum Fossa nichts im Schiedsgericht verloren hat Löschung von Wikipedia:Wer zuerst kommt, mahlt zuerst Wikipedia:BNS Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
2935 8320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of film sequels considered better than the original User:Eivind 06:54, 26 June 2006 (UTC) delete POV and unencyclopedic listcruft, and imdb.com is not a |reliable source. --Wikipedia:Esperanza|E Deletion of List of film sequels considered better than the original WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2936 7524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Royal Air Force Mountaineering Association User:The 19:39, 25 June 2016 (UTC) delete """until actual ''evidence'' is produced to support that this is a """"notable organisation"""" per """ Deletion of Royal Air Force Mountaineering Association WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2937 21077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eon8 (2nd nomination) User:Trialsanderrors 06:55, 2 July 2006 (UTC) delete WP:AUTO|AUTO|VANI|HOAX|CRUFT Deletion of Eon8 (2nd nomination) WP:VAIN||WP:HOAX||WP:NN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
2938 292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BSA Twin Tower User:Mendaliv 07:43, 24 June 2008 (UTC) merge to St. Francis Square; there is |notability in |reliable sources under that name (via Google News Deletion of BSA Twin Tower WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
2939 9573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kreynet User:Satori 15:40, 6 September 2006 (UTC) delete Article does not provide any reputable published sources as required by , and I was unable to locate any Deletion of Kreynet WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
2940 18018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Need a Man (Foxy Brown song) User:doomsdayer520 00:52, 16 November 2020 (UTC) merge """to Ill Na Na 2: The Fever. The single seems to have been released, but it achieved no media notice or significant sales while trying to promote an album that was never released. Now the song is only visible in the |typical streaming and lyrics sites. But since it was a retail item it is a possible search term, so redirect to its so-called """"album"""" as is usual policy""" Deletion of I Need a Man (Foxy Brown song) WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
2941 8328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vector Sigma User:Altered 23:24, 14 December 2012 (UTC) delete long and almost entirely unreferenced article loaded with POV analysis about a fictional universe with no assertion of otability. In short, it's a perfect article for the Transformers Wiki, but not an appropriate article for Wikipedia Deletion of Vector Sigma WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2942 18327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gandhi's racism User:Alex 14:26, 27 March 2007 (UTC) delete per issues (big) and Deletion of Gandhi's racism WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
2943 4314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geomajas User:LiberalFascist 21:14, 6 February 2010 (UTC) delete There is no online coverage of this besides press releases and blogs. The links provided in the article are all to the company's website, or to press releases (with advert-like company profile at the bottom) requires multiple reliable secondary sources, of which none are available that I can find Deletion of Geomajas WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2944 17037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deontay Burnett User:Ejgreen77 01:42, 20 September 2017 (UTC) keep Meets , per WikiOriginal-9's sources and research Deletion of Deontay Burnett WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2945 10780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew C. Levy User:K 03:12, 23 March 2019 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Matthew C. Levy WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2946 8797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amy Buckman User:Coredesat 22:29, 22 July 2006 (UTC) delete per #A7|CSD-A7, no assertion of notability Deletion of Amy Buckman WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
2947 1478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riograndense Republic User:Toon05 17:24, 15 July 2008 (UTC) comment I have to point out that the first three sources clearly fail - and can't |verify existence or anything else due to this. The third, a report on the secessionist feeling in southern Brazil only mentions the Riograndense Republic in passing, and does nothing to establish the existence of such a state, just that some organisations in the south exist who want secession Deletion of Riograndense Republic WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
2948 1794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alek Skarlatos User:Coolabahapple 16:36, 11 September 2015 (UTC) comment """probably nothing useful:)), funny when afds become longer then the article concerned, """"The lowest grade, which these gentlemen were awarded, is very common and cannot possibly be said to confer inherent notability"""" - very common??, I don't have one, does anyone else involved in this discussion?, according to the wikiarticle Legion of Honour, as of 2010 there has only been about 100,000 issued, if we can have thousands of articles about academy award winners and sports people (""""competed at the modern Olympic Games"""" is notable - 1000s compete at each Olympics eg. over 10,000 at 2012 Summer Olympics|London) why can't recipients of this honor (and obes, mbes as well:)) have an article (and no, I am not volunteering to do them:))? Also, is the comment relevant as this person is receiving the award as a civilian? If this article is redirected, won't there arise balance/undue weight issues in the main article? """"it's only a WP:BLP1E situation"""" which states """"We should generally avoid having an article on a person when each of three conditions is met"""" (my emphasis) can someone please show where this is the case here as I have not been convinced by the 'deleters""" Deletion of Alek Skarlatos WP:NOLYMPICS||WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
2949 19883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrian Talbott User:E 19:28, 20 December 2017 (UTC) delete """as Nom says, a couple of news stores state that Talbott withdrew for """"personal reasons"""" and that the search for a director has been renewed. I am not seeing enough notability here to keep. He's young, probably """ Deletion of Adrian Talbott WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
2950 2560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lil Lody User:Magnolia677 01:53, 25 December 2016 (UTC) delete Fails , , and . I found a few interviews like http://www.memphisflyer.com/CallingtheBluff/archives/2015/03/26/throwback-thursday-lil-lody-talks-sisters-death-being-sued-by-juicy-j-and-project-pat this, but no secondary sources needed to establish notability Deletion of Lil Lody WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2951 21532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Westin Causarina Las Vegas Hotel, Casino & Spa User:Vegaswikian 03:16, 25 November 2008 (UTC) keep Notability is established given that when it was nominated, there was at least one news source used. Yes, the article does need work. But that work is adding references which should be addressed by a cleanup tag and not bring it here for deletion. Also otability (buildings) does not apply since notability is as a casino and not a building Deletion of Westin Causarina Las Vegas Hotel, Casino & Spa WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2952 15201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faithful Word Baptist Church [[User talk:202.124.72.156|talk]]) 01:43, 26 August 2012 (UTC) delete """The content of the article seems to primarily be non-notable things backed up by news stories (see #NEWS). I read """"It was reported that some of the previous sermons were against policies of the presidency of Barack Obama."""" Really? That's unusual in the US? The main claim to notability seems to be the SPLC listing but, given the length of that list, I'm not sure that's enough. A year from now, will anyone really care about Faithful Word Baptist Church? -- Special:Contributions/202.124.72.156|202.124.72.156""" Deletion of Faithful Word Baptist Church WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2953 5150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Heartfield user:Hannes 16:14, 12 August 2021 (UTC) keep with a number of reviews including https://www.jstor.org/stable/41999451 https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2979/victorianstudies.56.3.522 https://www.jstor.org/stable/24047001 and the ones found by {{ping|Elemimele}} he passes . {{ping|Maud.Clowd}} Generally academic reviews are counted towards notability per . I would fail to see how reviews in academic journals are less important than other reviews, I would rather suggest that they are held to a higher standard and assess scholarly contribution. In general as long as the venue in which the review appears is reliable, we can use it -- there are many niche genres outside academia where authors become notable by being reviewed in a specialized journal (eg science fiction etc). Given that multiple books of his have multiple reviews, this also means doesnt apply here but this shows a consistent streak of recognized scholarship Deletion of James Heartfield WP:NAUTHOR||WP:NAUTHOR||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
2954 8408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mediabids User:Riana_dzasta 02:51, 22 June 2006 (UTC) delete non-notable, read Deletion of Mediabids WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
2955 17494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thunderbird Releasing User:AllyD 09:31, 12 March 2021 (UTC) comment An article with a history of editing by connected contributor accounts and IPs. The given references are routine and inadequate for . The company appears to have been involved in distributing a number of notable films, but notability is . There is some coverage such as https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=DUsKEAAAQBAJ&newbks=1&newbks_redir=0&lpg=PT255&pg=PT255#v=onepage this, which, though it may be more about Eve Gabereau than the company, might provide the |basis for an article, though I am unconvinced that is sufficient for Deletion of Thunderbird Releasing :WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:NOTINHERITED||:WP:V||:WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2956 15000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Rombola User:Mendaliv 11:09, 2 October 2008 (UTC) comment While I hate to pry, would you mind elaborating on your rationale? The article still doesn't seem to have the sort of coverage necessary to pass or . &mdash Deletion of Christopher Rombola WP:ATHLETE||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2957 9795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Go (verb) (2nd nomination) User:Quiddity 18:09, 24 June 2013 (UTC) keep please closely read (and wikt:WT:NOT) before nomming based on that policy Deletion of Go (verb) (2nd nomination) WP:NOTDIC Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
2958 9845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ogelle Africa User:Levivich 18:22, 8 October 2020 (UTC) keep meets with The Guardian (Nigeria) https://guardian.ng/art/for-african-culture-ogelle-goes-live/ Apr 21, 2019 and Vanguard (Nigeria) https://www.vanguardngr.com/2020/07/trinidad-and-tobago-envoy-commends-ogelle-platform/ Jul 11, 2020 (reporting on a commendation from the High Commissioner of Trinidad and Tobago), both of which have bylines are published by reputable national media outlets. Both The Guardian https://guardian.ng/features/ogelle-unifying-africas-content-distribution/ and Vanguard https://www.vanguardngr.com/2020/03/digital-platforms-like-ogelle-will-create-jobs-for-african-youths-obasanjo/ https://www.vanguardngr.com/2020/09/ogelle-targets-to-become-highest-aggregator-of-african-content-oparaugo/ have published other stories about Ogelle. Additionally, we have The Nation (Nigeria) https://thenationonlineng.net/ogelle-africas-first-user-generated-content-platform-berths-in-nigeria/ Apr 21, 2019 and Peace FM (Ghana) https://www.peacefmonline.com/pages/showbiz/news/201905/383317.php May 27, 2019, which are not bylined but appear to be reliable sources nonetheless. I'm not familiar with the reliability of Techpoint.africa https://techpoint.africa/2019/10/22/african-startup-is-aggregating-african-content/, but it's bylined also. There is multinational significant coverage by reliable national media outlets Deletion of Ogelle Africa WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2959 2684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Osama bin Laden conspiracy theories User:Abductive 09:11, 3 May 2011 (UTC) delete """none of these """"theories"""" have any traction. By """"traction"""", I mean serious analysis and coverage in reliable secondary sources. Page consists of , and ing/editorializing""" Deletion of Death of Osama bin Laden conspiracy theories WP:SYNTHESIS||WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:No original research 65
2960 20328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blue Blooded Allstars User:Capitalistroadster 03:43, 4 August 2006 (UTC) delete A search of an Australia/New Zealand database comes up with 0 mentions of this hip hop crew. They don't appear to meet at this stage Deletion of Blue Blooded Allstars WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
2961 2482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Letele User:Mdtemp 15:32, 21 October 2015 (UTC) delete Only routine sports coverage and fails to meet Deletion of David Letele WP:NBOX Wikipedia:Notability 77
2962 3143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kurt Holobaugh (2nd nomination) User:Papaursa 02:41, 19 November 2015 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet and the coverage consists on routine reporting of results so is not met Deletion of Kurt Holobaugh (2nd nomination) WP:NMMA||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2963 3763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hayfield Homes User:HighKing 11:32, 13 August 2018 (UTC) delete I agree with the above analysis, references fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic fails GNG and Deletion of Hayfield Homes WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2964 3881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pop Star (film) User:HTGS 22:41, 20 June 2021 (UTC) delete The film, so far as I have been able to tell, does not pass . I also have concerns about a string of single-purpose accounts covering the actress Robin Bain, and her work, namely this film and the films: Girl Lost, wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hollywood Sex Wars|Hollywood Sex Wars (deleted), wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eat Cake|Eat Cake (deleted) and wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wishful Thinking (2004 film)|Wishful Thinking (deleted). — Deletion of Pop Star (film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
2965 7411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Visitors (American punk band) User:Operator873 03:56, 29 November 2017 (UTC) delete Fails . Sources provided in article are either primary or mention the band incidentally Deletion of The Visitors (American punk band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
2966 13624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peace Treaty with North Korea User:Goodtiming8871 07:40, 7 September 2017 (UTC) comment Please note that is no longer valid, and explain the cases of as speculation it is necessary to know for the contributors of this article. To generate a more thorough discussion and clearer consensus, Can we please extend this AfD discussion for another seven day as some of the contributors of this article were not able to express their opinion Deletion of Peace Treaty with North Korea WP:RECENT||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Recentism 10
2967 20940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solé Bicycle Co. User:Northamerica1000 10:25, 6 November 2015 (UTC) keep """Passes . Sources include: {{cite web|url=http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/03/23/us-column-cohen-sole-idUSTRE72M7CZ20110323|title=Quest for cheaper bikes turns into niche business|work=Reuters}}, {{cite web|url=http://college.usatoday.com/2014/03/25/college-students-find-success-in-self-made-businesses/|title=College students find success in self-made businesses|work=USA Today}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.inc.com/coolest-college-start-ups-2011/sole-bicycles.html|title=America's Coolest College Start-Ups of 2011|work=Inc.com}}, https://smallbusiness.yahoo.com/advisor/sol%C3%A9-bicycles--turning-a-passion-into-a-million-dollar-business-210907380.html """"Solé Bicycles: turning a passion into a million-dollar business"""". ''Yahoo Small Business''., {{cite web|url=http://www.gq.com/story/sole-windward-city-cruiser-bicycle|title=Meet the Bicycle That's Mastered Casual Style|author=|work=GQ magazine}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.bizjournals.com/seattle/print-edition/2011/09/02/behind-the-scenes-with-patti-payne.html|title=Behind the Scenes with Patti Payne|date=2 September 2011|work=Puget Sound Business Journal}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.businessinsider.sg/bike-sales-are-going-crazy-and-these-startups-are-cashing-in-2015-7/|title=Bike sales are going crazy, and these startups are cashing in|work=Business Insider""" Deletion of Solé Bicycle Co. WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
2968 7553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexis Gharibian User:Sir 13:48, 7 September 2017 (UTC) delete While an appearance for the Armenian national team would of course satisfy , this claim appears to be inaccurate. The article also fails Deletion of Alexis Gharibian WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2969 4291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rajesh P Barnwal User:David 04:11, 4 April 2020 (UTC) delete """Citations far below the level needed for #C1 in a high-citation field. I don't know what """"listed guide for the fellow"""" means but I'm pretty sure it doesn't satisfy #C3. ACM Senior Member also definitely doesn't count for notability (it is two levels below the level of membership that does, fellow). And I don't see anything else that could even be plausible as an argument for notability""" Deletion of Rajesh P Barnwal WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
2970 85 [[Waldkrankenhaus St. Marien]] (bleibt) Benutzer:UlrichAAB NONE keep Nach der obigen Diskussion ist für mich klar dass #Krankenhäuser erfüllt sind. => (WP:LAE|LAE1 Löschung von Waldkrankenhaus St. Marien Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
2971 12380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enterprise Risk Management Academy User:K 19:56, 18 September 2016 (UTC) delete per ; strictly an avertorial. '''Salt''' too as it's unlikely to become notable in the future Deletion of Enterprise Risk Management Academy WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2972 9923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon Lee Gallery User:HighKing 14:30, 30 April 2018 (UTC) delete Clearly none of the Keep !voters above have read the guidelines. This is a run-of-the-mill business with no indications of notability. Most of the coverage is based on announcements and/or interviews, none are intellectually independent and all fail . Other coverage provides information on exhibits but noting about the business of the gallery and fails . Topic fails GNG and Deletion of Simon Lee Gallery WP:ORGIND||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
2973 8023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Hullah User:Luna 06:54, 30 May 2008 (UTC) delete There might be something out there to suggest the guy passes , but as of yet I haven't found anything. Of the books mentioned, I can only find a library catalog entry for one of them, and that includes a note that only 250 copies were printed. Wishing him the best of luck, in his career, but not sure if we can authoritatively cover the subject with so little information available/verifiable. &ndash Deletion of Paul Hullah WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
2974 11489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edvard Hovhannisyan User:GiantSnowman 08:56, 19 November 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Edvard Hovhannisyan WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
2975 12581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diuretic and Anti-inflammatory Pill User:Bearian 18:11, 26 May 2011 (UTC) delete as spam per and Deletion of Diuretic and Anti-inflammatory Pill WP:SPAM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Spam 112
2976 17359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pilot Breakdown User:Esradekan 21:00, 18 February 2009 (UTC) delete as a Deletion of Pilot Breakdown WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
2977 6730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Abbey (novel) User:Epinoia 02:22, 17 August 2019 (UTC) delete orphan article on non-notable book - does not meet the criteria of - no ''major'' reviews or ''significant'' awards - the article links are to a database, the publisher's website and a blog (Cititor SF) - no notable references - this is just a promotional article - therefore, delete Deletion of The Abbey (novel) WP:BOOKCRIT||WP:NOTPROMOTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
2978 3537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ananda yoga User:MuZemike 01:26, 18 December 2008 (UTC) comment I understand, from the reasons above for keeping, that the subject is likely notable. However, articles written as clear advertisement or copyright violations are reasons for deletion (see the |deletion policy). The article requires a complete rewrite to remove said offending material. It is also against official policy to engage in copyright infringement, which is what has happened above. With all that said, I stand by G11, and I will also flag the article for potential copyvio Deletion of Ananda yoga WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
2979 16581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hong's paradox User:S 15:27, 8 March 2009 (UTC) delete this unreferenced and unreferenceable |original research per and Deletion of Hong's paradox WP:NOR||WP:BURDEN||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:No original research 65
2980 7661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Redundant topologies User:W 23:36, 3 December 2013 (UTC) delete """First I thought it might be a for something called VLAN Transport Protocol, since that is given as the """"fix"""" for the """"solution"""" (although as usual, nothing at all to do with solutions!). But it appears that the original article properly wikilinked to spanning tree protocol, which is where this article could be merged if it had any useful sourced content. But https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Redundant_topologies&diff=prev&oldid=564630689 this edit by an unregistered user in July 2013 broke that link anyway""" Deletion of Redundant topologies WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
2981 5725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Johns User:Ravenswing 04:17, 26 August 2010 (UTC) delete Meets neither the GNG nor Deletion of Stephen Johns WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
2982 287 [[Dadda-Multiplizierer]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Yen Zotto 18:15, 5. Aug. 2013 (CEST) keep da Löschgründe entweder inzwischen entfallen (Quellen, Beschreibung) oder ungültig sind. Wer ein paar einfache Formeln als ''Sonderzeichensalat ohne erkennbaren Sinn'' auffasst, sollte vielleicht besser keinen Mathematik-Artikel beurteilen. Der Artikel ist inzwischen gut und verständlich, auch für |Omas, sofern diese wirklich an der Sache interessiert sind. Die anderen sollen einfach Häkeln|was anderes lesen Löschung von Dadda-Multiplizierer Wikipedia:Oma Wikipedia:Allgemeinverständlichkeit 79
2983 5248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One Bull user:Andrew 18:23, 24 September 2020 (UTC) keep It seems easy to find more coverage of this notable warrior. See ''https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=xj9oFICvaRYC&pg=PA38 Hokahey! A Good Day to Die!'', for example. Applicable policies include ; ; and Deletion of One Bull WP:ATD||WP:NEXIST||WP:NOTPAPER||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
2984 21946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LINUX PAWUPA User:Piotrus 05:51, 5 December 2016 (UTC) delete Fork/how-to guide, so . Fails Deletion of LINUX PAWUPA WP:NOT||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2985 18731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Cook (songwriter) User:MacGyverMagic 09:21, 5 February 2009 (UTC) comment Song-writers tend to get little praise for their work unless they are the ones to sing it as well. Still, a songwriter would meet if they wrote a notable song. Rather than featuring on the negative aspects of the current articles, someone with access should check if he wrote any Deletion of Steve Cook (songwriter) WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2986 6323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UTEX Industries (2nd nomination) User:DGG 09:49, 15 June 2017 (UTC) keep just what I hoped for. An excellent example of .Companies can be notable because of widely reported financial problems, not just sucesses. People who commented earlier might want to look again: {{Replyto|Exemplo347|Lankiveil|K.e.coffman| Onel5969|HighKing |E.M.Gregory Deletion of UTEX Industries (2nd nomination) WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
2987 10089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cynthia A. Young User:David 23:06, 6 May 2019 (UTC) keep I've made some cleanups to the article including updating her affiliation. I found five reviews of her one book; the number of reviews is ok but one book only is a little light with respect to and a little problematic with respect to . And no matter how well cited it is, one publication is probably not enough for #C1. And her rank and administrative position are not enough. So I think the best case is through , but it's a weak one Deletion of Cynthia A. Young WP:AUTHOR||WP:BIO1E||WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2988 10539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Duttons User:Warrush NONE keep They have a show on national television dedicated to them, They meet . Atleast keep until America's Got Talent is over, and If nothing else comes out and noone expands the article, delete it Deletion of The Duttons WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
2989 13199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donalism User:Bearian 00:28, 13 November 2007 (UTC) delete as a hoax, although |it is funny Deletion of Donalism WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2990 19988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glow Artisan User:HalfShadow 22:32, 25 September 2010 (UTC) delete Not unambiguously spam, but contravenes and is not notable. I've restored the AfD notice that Deletion of Glow Artisan WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
2991 19594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/London Buses route 278 User:NemesisAT 15:02, 6 July 2021 (UTC) keep this was tagged with {{T|notability}} only minutes before the deletion nomination. What was the purpose of that? This is a well-written article with lots of info and ten sources. How does removing this information |improve Wikipedia Deletion of London Buses route 278 WP:IGNOREALLRULES Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
2992 16373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tamding Tsering User:Abecedare 05:07, 15 January 2009 (UTC) delete There is nothing available to establish Wp:N|notability of the individual players, either as |athletes or as icons in the Tibetan political struggle. We do not have a ''single'' source that discusses the biography of any of these players - only online sites listing them as members of the Tibet national team. As has been noted multiple times in the above discussion the Tibet national football team is clearly notable enough to merit a wikipedia article, but its member are not (at least yet Deletion of Tamding Tsering WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
2993 16932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disappearance of Sunil Tripathi User:Cymru 02:34, 28 April 2013 (UTC) comment merge and delete isn't really a valid option, due to Wikipedia's copyright policies. (See -M and erge and delete for more information. Merging and ''redirecting'', however, is an option. — Preceding ''signed'' comment added by Deletion of Disappearance of Sunil Tripathi WP:ATD||WP:M Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
2994 4632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bush family conspiracy theory User:Jdcooper 13:36, 7 May 2006 (UTC) keep As long as sources can be provided for examples of when these conspiracy theories have been alleged (to avoid ) and the article is slightly rewritten to '''emphasise''' that they are conspiracy theories, I see no problem with a verified list of things people have alleged. Maybe '''rename''' to List of Bush family conspiracy theories Deletion of Bush family conspiracy theory WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
2995 7515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Area 404 User:Spiderone 11:32, 10 December 2020 (UTC) delete blog entries and social media posts do not amount to passing Deletion of Area 404 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
2996 2754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farm to Market Road 1417 User:Dravecky 05:43, 27 October 2015 (UTC) keep per as a notable state-maintained highway. Perhaps in the future a case could be made for merging it to List of Farm to Market Roads in North Texas but as that article isn't even a complete shell yet merger now would be inappropriate Deletion of Farm to Market Road 1417 WP:ROADOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
2997 10466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angelica Hamilton User:SoWhy 16:01, 26 September 2017 (UTC) keep """While the arguments are weak, the nominator and other delete !voter overlook that notability is not necessarily something that comes from a person's own actions. Their traits or illnesses can equally be a reason to assume notability, just as long as {{xt|""""|they have received significant coverage in multiple published secondary sources that are reliable, intellectually independent of each other, and independent of the subject""""}}. This is the case here. ''Why'' they covered her is not really important. Regards""" Deletion of Angelica Hamilton WP:OSE||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
2998 13542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PeopleinMovement User:Quarl NONE delete """as |non-notable, OR|original research. I think """"this site"""" refers to the MSN website. &mdash""" Deletion of PeopleinMovement WP:N||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
2999 20840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kira Takenouchi User:Twsx 09:53, 14 June 2008 (UTC) delete per #A1. ~ | Deletion of Kira Takenouchi WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
3000 15251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brawl hall User:Dustimagic 03:27, 14 February 2006 (UTC) delete as nn, fails Deletion of Brawl hall WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3001 2446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rajesh Bhatt User:Utcursch 01:53, 2 March 2016 (UTC) delete Unable to find any non-trivial coverage in |third-party reliable sources. Most of the sources cited in the article are spam-ish blogs. Among the rest, a couple make a passing mention of the subject. http://www.rediff.com/movies/report/cannes/20040427.htm does't even mention him Deletion of Rajesh Bhatt WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3002 6500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brenden Foster (2nd nomination) User:Jo7hs2 21:48, 9 February 2009 (UTC) keep I'm iffy on this one. The death of this individual, or the fundraiser, or the illness, or several other portions of this story (Seahawks paying for funeral, etc...) could be considered distinct events, so I'm not 100% sure that should apply. However, I'm not convinced the article should be about the individual rather than the response to the individual, so my support for keeping the article is merely support for the status quo Deletion of Brenden Foster (2nd nomination) WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3003 8495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/For the Sins... User:Flaming 16:16, 30 August 2009 (UTC) delete Stop— |HAMMER TIME! Deletion of For the Sins... WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
3004 13397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flowsense User:Whpq 16:07, 17 April 2007 (UTC) delete as Deletion of Flowsense WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3005 19471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Q. Schmidt (2nd nomination) User:Prosfilaes 19:40, 15 October 2008 (UTC) delete looking at the sources, I don't see one half-decent source about this guy. Nothing has changed since the last AfD. One or two of the links are dead, and maybe they had more, but most of the references to this article are listing of this person in cast lists. Two of them are about him, and give birth date, real name and height, and frankly I doubt they're independent, and don't for one second consider them reliable sources. We don't even really have to consider otability, IMO; the article fails hands down Deletion of Michael Q. Schmidt (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
3006 6629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Moore (author) User:Eggishorn 02:39, 27 February 2017 (UTC) delete At best but more likely self-promotion Deletion of Mark Moore (author) WP:TOOSOON||WP:COI Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3007 8085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SUN OF A STARVE User:JohnCD 18:05, 17 May 2012 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON - may meet in due course, doesn't yet Deletion of SUN OF A STARVE WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
3008 7588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slave auction (BDSM) User:Jeepday 00:48, 31 July 2008 (UTC) delete per fist sentence of ''The threshold for inclusion in Wikipedia is verifiability, not truth—that is, whether readers are able to check that material added to Wikipedia already has been published by a reliable source, not whether we think it is true'', unless references provided,per , this article is in :Category:Articles lacking sources from July 2006, there are no articles on Wikipedia that have been tagged for lack of references longer then this article Deletion of Slave auction (BDSM) WP:V||WP:PROVEIT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3009 2585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Truthiness (3rd nomination) User:Part 23:24, 16 April 2007 (UTC) keep I'll that Deletion of Truthiness (3rd nomination) WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
3010 15404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Molecular Operating Environment User:Dialectric 03:34, 21 July 2016 (UTC) delete Software article of unclear notability, lacking independent references. A search turned up no significant coverage. Article was created by an Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|SPA as possibly promotional. Also possible copyvio as noted above Deletion of Molecular Operating Environment WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3011 3027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Voodoo Gods User:GreenRunner0 17:49, 2 September 2010 (UTC) keep """per Ensemble Criteria #6: ''""""Is an ensemble which contains two or more independently notable musicians, or is a musician who has been a member of two or more independently notable ensembles""" Deletion of Voodoo Gods WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
3012 20014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pennridge–Quakertown Thanksgiving Day Football Classic User:SportingFlyer 14:53, 25 November 2020 (UTC) delete I can't see the additional sources such as mccall.com and theintell.com since they're geo-blocked so can't vote a strong delete (though theintell.com is clearly local, and mccall.com appears to be a women's clothing website?), but I am concerned the vast, vast, vast majority of sources are local, and I can't find anything about the game that's not in the prep sports section of local papers, with the exception of the game's listing in a Wapost listicle. I would assume a notable youth sports rivalry would have been written about or covered in non-local sources, since I think the vast majority of high schools have one of these rivalry games, and I find myself agreeing with the nom here. is designed for athletes, but youth sports reporting is so common I think it should apply to general discussion as well, and this article fails both of those tests at the moment Deletion of Pennridge–Quakertown Thanksgiving Day Football Classic WP:NHSPHSATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
3013 13534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Troll (Warcraft) User:Kesh 21:27, 14 October 2007 (UTC) delete An extensive article already exists at http://www.wowwiki.com/Troll WoW Wiki, so there's no need to transwiki this anywhere. Pure in-universe article, fails Deletion of Troll (Warcraft) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3014 4420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaun Xavier NONE NONE delete Fails . Google search did not yield any positive results and IMDb page http://www.imdb.com/name/nm4915448/bio?ref_=nm_ov_bio_sm does not credit any movies Deletion of Shaun Xavier WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3015 6692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Jenni-Lyn Watson User:Meco 09:36, 29 November 2010 (UTC) keep As the subject may relate to missing white woman syndrome and possibly for that reason has received national media coverage, that should suffice to satisfy our |general notability requirements. I agree that the article may resemble an obituary as the level of detailing of the victim's life does appear exaggerated given the relevant focus at what would constitute notability for it as a Wikipedia article. However, that is not an argument for deletion. I also believe that NOTNEWS should ''probably'' not come to use here, but I'm a bit unsure. __ Deletion of Death of Jenni-Lyn Watson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3016 1564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ki Chung Kim User:Papaursa 13:19, 19 July 2020 (UTC) delete There is a total lack of any significant independent coverage of him. Passing mentions and school websites do not constitute the coverage necessary to meet . Ranks and halls of fame have never been considered sufficient evidence to show notability in martial arts. I couldn't find any reliable sources that show he meets any of the notability criteria for martial artists Deletion of Ki Chung Kim WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3017 5922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John M. Anastasatos User:Chalk19 NONE comment The user above has https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Contributions/GogouAnastasia&offset=&limit=500&target=GogouAnastasia contributions only on John M. Anastasatos. Maybe there is a with her subject Deletion of John M. Anastasatos WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
3018 16865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Terror Conspiracy User:Morton 19:54, 11 October 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Violates and Wikipedia:Vanispamcruftisement -- I hate when people use Wikipedia to try to create notability Deletion of The Terror Conspiracy WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
3019 21012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zaw Myint Oo User:Bearian 00:58, 26 April 2020 (UTC) delete per , , and . I'm afraid this inexperienced musical artist has paid a lot of money to get this crappy page - he was ripped off Deletion of Zaw Myint Oo WP:SPAM||WP:TNT||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Spam 112
3020 9999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ambarish Mitra User:Kraxler 14:22, 4 August 2015 (UTC) keep Seems to get some attention in the media, two of the refs in the article (Sunday Times and Evening Standard) look good. There's also http://www.dnaindia.com/lifestyle/report-reality-bytes-2110281 ''Ambarish Mitra: From runaway teen to tech genius and entrepreneur'' (DNA India), http://www.fastcompany.com/3049055/most-creative-people/a-year-in-a-delhi-slum ''A Year In A Delhi Slum'' (Fast Company), http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/d1507b96-1b24-11e5-8201-cbdb03d71480.html#axzz3hr7NUERK ''European tech: In Silicon Valley’s shadow'' (Financial Times), http://webrazzi.com/2014/11/28/blippar-istanbul-ofisi-ambarish-mitra/ a Turkish source, http://businesstoday.intoday.in/story/what-kind-of-start-up-would-refuse-to-sell-for-usd-1.7-billion-just-blipp-it/1/219875.html ''What kind of start-up would refuse to sell for $1.7 billion? Just Blipp it'' (in Business Today (business magazine)|''Business Today''), passes Deletion of Ambarish Mitra WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3021 4892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chaos Theory of Literature User:Coredesat 03:03, 5 July 2006 (UTC) delete per |Wikipedia is not a publisher of original thought Deletion of Chaos Theory of Literature WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3022 12817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rachel Aldana User:Atama 16:00, 21 March 2008 (UTC) delete """The one real notability claim that Rachel has is her Guinness World Record claim. That on its own could satisfy if verified, however the only news source I can find is The People. According to all mainstream news sources are """"welcomed"""", but it further goes on to state, """"When adding contentious biographical material about living persons that relies upon news organizations, only material from high-quality news organizations should be used."""" As this is a article and this claim of """"largest breasts"""" is disputed, The People fails since it's a tabloid paper with a dubious reputation. Tossing out the big boob record claim we don't have enough in this article to satisfy """ Deletion of Rachel Aldana WP:N||WP:RS||WP:BLP||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3023 1439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lizette Parker User:Seraphim 21:56, 16 December 2017 (UTC) keep per above comments. does not say that the coverage for local politicians needs to be international or national, just significant. is a criteria for , not . There will of course be very notable political figures who don't receive national coverage Deletion of Lizette Parker WP:NPOL||WP:AUD||WP:NORG||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3024 7895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doug Hirschhorn User:Cameron11598 03:29, 4 November 2016 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a billboard, also fails Deletion of Doug Hirschhorn WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3025 5488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aedin Adams User:Clarityfiend 23:09, 19 December 2013 (UTC) delete Two extra roles in films that haven't even been released yet and zero media notice? |WP:WAAAAAAAAAY TOOSOON Deletion of Aedin Adams WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3026 18376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Student activism at the University of Virginia User:Creffett 01:15, 1 April 2020 (UTC) delete """I've been watching this article for a while, it came up in NPP and I just couldn't figure out what to do with it (so I left it where it was and hoped someone else would figure it out!). I'm still not absolutely certain. On the one hand, it's clear that there is a lot of student activism at UVa, and there probably are sources out there about the topic at a broad level. On the other, the article is a blend of and and almost entirely based on primary sources. Based on the number of very new editors involved and their edit summaries, I think this was a class project, and I think everyone wanted to add their student organization's history of protesting, which we see get out of hand in several sections (see, for example, the """"Black Students for Freedom"""" and """"Union of University Students"""" sections, which (respectively) list the organization's founding principles and their org structure). Bottom line, the article in its current state does not establish notability of the topic and I doubt there is any amount of editing that could save it. If high-quality scholarly or news coverage is found (and I think it's at least possible that such coverage exists), I would support TNT + rewrite in place of deletion""" Deletion of Student activism at the University of Virginia WP:SYNTH||WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:No original research 65
3027 2953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuki Grewal User:Aseleste 03:57, 25 March 2021 (UTC) delete The subject does not meet any criteria of . Applying the less strict where is not always required compared to , the subject is still not notable. Two of three sources provided in the article are too trivial; the remaining one is not wp:independent being an interview without original content. Doing wp:before |searches yield very low quality results that are either not relevant, not wp:reliable, or not wp:independent. For valid sources, the ''combined'' coverage as required by is not significant enough to warrant an article Deletion of Kuki Grewal WP:NACTOR||WP:BASIC||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG||WP:SET||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3028 6268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Karani User:R96Skinner 17:28, 15 June 2019 (UTC) keep Current footballer who passes . Plays for Swope Park Rangers in the USL Championship, which is listed at Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues. No doubt the article needs improving, though Deletion of Sean Karani WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
3029 7454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cordectomy User:Earthdirt 02:21, 1 January 2008 (UTC) keep Keep as per and above comments Deletion of Cordectomy WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
3030 19870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National Brick Wall Day User:Tckma 14:29, 27 August 2009 (UTC) delete Blatant and obvious hoax, per #G3|CSD G3 Deletion of National Brick Wall Day WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
3031 19104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elon University School of Law User:TreasuryTag 20:06, 14 June 2011 (UTC) keep because the nominator seems to be asking for editorial advice rather than deletion. Failing that, '''keep''' since there is plenty of |significant coverage shown and any issues with tone can be dealt with |in the normal way Deletion of Elon University School of Law WP:SIGCOV||WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3032 17270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D.C. United – Philadelphia Union rivalry User:Ravenswing 16:50, 9 January 2011 (UTC) delete Merging or redirecting presumes there are actually any |reliable sources discussing this alleged rivalry in significant detail. I very much doubt there are Deletion of D.C. United – Philadelphia Union rivalry WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3033 8133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heather Jacks User:Qrsdogg 16:40, 20 July 2011 (UTC) delete Seems like a nice lady, but it appears that she fails Deletion of Heather Jacks WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3034 1236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mr. Billion User:Joe 23:02, 24 October 2009 (UTC) delete All that I can find for significant coverage is http://www.variety.com/review/VE1117793271.html?categoryid=31&cs=1 this. Fails Deletion of Mr. Billion WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3035 7415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Morton Brilliant (2nd nomination) User:THF 02:50, 2 February 2009 (UTC) comment """That footnote is the very epitome of |Wikipuffery. There are literally dozens of political operatives of both parties who would be """"notable"""" by that standard. Taylor Griffin is a redlink, and he actually ''is'' nationally known. To repeat: a glancing mention in a Athens Banner-Herald|32,000-circulation newspaper opinion column about a different subject does not create notability. The standard is ''significant independent coverage""" Deletion of Morton Brilliant (2nd nomination) WP:PUFF Wikipedia:Wikipuffery 0
3036 8951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 Moscow–Constantinople schism User:Aoidh 12:37, 17 August 2021 (UTC) keep Per Veverve. Plenty of sources in the article to support the content, which easily meets Deletion of 2018 Moscow–Constantinople schism WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3037 13301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Milan Amatya User:Lonehexagon 21:29, 28 February 2018 (UTC) keep A quick Google search shows she's an extremely popular singer and performer in Nepal. I added several citations to her article. She has been covered regularly in the media for almost a decade, easily passing . Additionally, she passes (via sections 1, 4, 9, 10, 11, and 12 Deletion of Milan Amatya WP:GNG||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3038 6365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 in film (2nd nomination) User:Closeapple 02:53, 16 July 2013 (UTC) delete """to something else: Perfect example of Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law. The so-called sources for the items show just how lacking in any this subject (film releases years in advance) are. The direct references are to blog-like news sites that list things like """"Source: Sony / Columbia Pictures"""" with no links for proof. Even if there was a direct studio source: Hollywood claims for things 5 years in advance are possibly even less reliable than educated guesses by media critics; they're """"leaked"""" to manipulate someone else in the industry — maybe mass media, maybe just some individuals — with no relation to whether it will actually happen. Even if the proposals are verified to be """"official"""" somehow, it will end up being the Ship of Theseus by the time 2018 rolls around. The chances of any article made in 2013 having any relation to film reality in 2018 is about zero, and |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball, and article space is not the place for rough drafts of an article that can't be reliable yet""" Deletion of 2018 in film (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3039 15136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David LaBrava User:Cunard 06:59, 8 December 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. Non-notable actor. A http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tab=wn&q=%22David+LaBrava%22 Google News Archive search returns no results. The sources added by Seren are not |reliable sources. An http://www.imdb.com/name/nm3157157/ IMDb link and a http://www.ftwthemovie.com/ link to the homepage of a movie this individual had a role hardly shows notability. In fact, the IMDb link shows he's fairly new to the acting business. He's only been in 2 episodes of ''Sons of Anarchy'' and probably played only a minor role. Ryan's comments are completely wrong. There are plenty of biographies of non-notable living people in :CAT:CSD and the majority gets deleted. This individual may someday be notable but that's |crystal balling Deletion of David LaBrava WP:RS||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3040 17335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susan King (TV presenter) User:JulieSpaulding 15:07, 26 January 2010 (UTC) delete WP:ENTERTAINER says that an entertainer is notable if they have ''had significant roles in multiple notable films, television shows, stage performances, or other productions''. I would say that 'Horses Galore' is a somewhat notable television show (a http://www.google.ca/search?&q=horses+galore+tv+show Google search brings up http://ftvdb.bfi.org.uk/sift/series/35246http://ftvdb.bfi.org.uk/sift/title/147300http://www.alibris.co.uk/search/books/qwork/2991993/used/Horses%20galore - the third being a shopping site for a book about the TV series), but Country Search is not (a Google search brings up nothing at all - I tried multiple queries, but nothing can verify that the show even existed except http://ftvdb.bfi.org.uk/sift/title/720181, which didn't even come up in the Google search - it is a reference in the article). In addition, I can't find anything on Susan King in reliable independent sources, so the article fails the |general notability guideline Deletion of Susan King (TV presenter) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3041 2133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bias in Mental Testing User:Cullen328 04:48, 16 February 2014 (UTC) keep """The book is certainly both notable and controversial. It meets as it """"has been the subject of multiple, non-trivial published works appearing in sources that are independent of the book itself"""", namely, hundreds of reviews. Though the original author has since been blocked, several other editors have contributed to the article. Any shortcomings in the current version of the article should be addressed by normal editing""" Deletion of Bias in Mental Testing WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
3042 15529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Altasciences User:HighKing 13:58, 13 March 2018 (UTC) delete Run-of-the-mill company with no apparent claims to notability. Wikipedia is not a platform for advertising or promotion and is not a yellow pages or directory, references fail the criteria for establishing notability and fails and/or , topic fails GNG and Deletion of Altasciences WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3043 323 [[Kurt J. Heinz]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Wikiwal NONE delete """Nun ist Herr Heinz zweifellos Chefredakteur. Deswegen macht es Sinn, sich mit den Relevanzkriterien, die die Wikipedia für Websites aufgestellt hat, zu beschäftigen. Es kann ja sein, dass medrum.de im Sinne der Wikipedia eine relevante Website ist, und Heinz als Chefredakteur dieser Seite deswegen einen eigenen Artikel verdient. Diese Kriterien finden sich hier: . Von der dort verlangten """"Berichterstattung über die Seite in eigenen Artikeln/Sendungen in überregionalen Printmedien, Hörfunk und Fernsehen, sowie in Online-Magazinen, solange es sich um relevante Magazine im Sinne der hier beschriebenen Kriterien handelt und die Beschreibung über eine Kurzmeldung hinausgeht"""" ist Medrum.de allerdings in meinen Augen noch ebenso weit entfernt wie von einer ausführlichen Zitation in wissenschaftlichen Publikationen oder dem Gewinn eines relevanten Preises einer unabhängigen Organisation. Daher: , und sollte ein eigenes Lemma für medrum.de geschaffen werden, wird man sich auch dort mit einer Löschdiskussion herumschlagen müssen." Löschung von Kurt J. Heinz Wikipedia:Richtlinien Websites Wikipedia:Notability 77
3044 20884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Latin Food Fest User:Jim 22:19, 30 June 2014 (UTC) delete I think is the best way here (If significant third party reliable sources can be found Deletion of Latin Food Fest WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
3045 17249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BCODE User:Ginsengbomb 04:58, 24 June 2013 (UTC) delete """The newly-added reference does not devote significant attention to BCODE, and I cannot find any reliable third-party coverage significantly devoted to this topic. There are a huge number of systems that support sending a """"unique identifier"""" to a mobile phone via SMS for validating a ticket/voucher/etc. This article about one such branded system is a subtle bit of , methinks""" Deletion of BCODE WP:ADVERTISING Wikipedia:Advertising 107
3046 9218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mount Kosh-Kaya User:Coolabahapple 07:58, 4 December 2019 (UTC) keep """meets , a number of sources are available online showing its importance in the field of astronomy ie. https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2011KPCB...27..317R/abstract """"Some characteristics of astronomical climate on Mount Koshka, Simeiz"""" (sub needed) (assuming koshka is the same mountain""" Deletion of Mount Kosh-Kaya WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3047 14243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparision of online remittance services in United Kingdom for sending money to India User:Bearian 22:58, 19 February 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Comparision of online remittance services in United Kingdom for sending money to India WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
3048 5074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bangladesh Tribune User:Worldbruce 19:20, 22 April 2019 (UTC) delete Ephemeral news portals come and go all the time in Bangladesh. The ''Bangladesh Tribune'' website went belly up in 2015. The first cited source is dead, and from the construction of the url, appears to be bogus. The other source is about another company. The ''Bangladesh Tribune'' isn't mentioned in the ''Encyclopedia of International Media and Communications'', the ABYZ ''Bangladesh Newspapers and News Media Guide'', or ''Willings Press Guide''. Searches of the usual Google types find no cases of a reliable source citing ''Bangladesh Tribune'', and zero independent coverage. Fails Deletion of Bangladesh Tribune WP:NMEDIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
3049 13205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lexington-class fleet carrier User:Edison 01:40, 18 December 2007 (UTC) delete per nomination, and for failure to show notability per and for failure to satisfy . Per the article talk page, much of the detail comes from fans and thus appears to fail as well. (edited Deletion of Lexington-class fleet carrier WP:N||WP:FICTION||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
3050 20602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The most beautiful Arab cities User:NawlinWiki 18:07, 23 April 2007 (UTC) delete subjective and unsourced/unsourceable, violates Deletion of The most beautiful Arab cities WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
3051 17188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randi Brooks User:LACaliNYC 21:10, 28 October 2018 (UTC) delete Definitely fails the and Deletion of Randi Brooks WP:GNG||WP:NACTRESS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3052 12761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Travel For Care User:Joe 21:43, 7 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |company Deletion of Travel For Care WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3053 19659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernard Morris (2nd nomination) User:NawlinWiki 15:57, 11 November 2009 (UTC) delete never played in pros, fails Deletion of Bernard Morris (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3054 11046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benjamin Bradley User:Hall 21:16, 3 February 2006 (UTC) keep notable enough as per for living people Deletion of Benjamin Bradley WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3055 18676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dasha Nekrasova (2nd nomination) User:My 19:49, 28 February 2020 (UTC) keep """I agree with people who voted """"keep"""" during the first AfD, less than two months ago. She got non-trivial coverage in a large number of independent third-party sources (currently cited on the page, I removed only one of them after checking). For example, The Cut (https://www.thecut.com/2019/02/red-scare-podcast-hosts-walk-first-fashion-show.html and https://www.thecut.com/2018/10/profile-red-scare-podcast.html), https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/red-scare-the-politically-incorrect-podcast-thats-wooing-liberal-millennials-lmtqzw25r The Times, https://www.teenvogue.com/story/sailor-socialism-dasha-nekrasova-viral-infowars-interview Teen Vogue and https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/xw7ezn/the-chill-woman-who-pwned-infowars-discusses-life-after-going-softly-viral Vice. The coverage is not just about the Infowars interview, so does not apply. Therefore, I think she easily passes """ Deletion of Dasha Nekrasova (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3056 12550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ushin Language Institute User:Kudpung 13:12, 31 December 2014 (UTC) delete per nominator. Fairly typical language cram school. After reading through the article and knowing our guidelines I cannot see how this article even remotely meets or , besides which, being basically a promo for a run-of-the-mill commercial language school it's probably a |G11 CSD candidate for advertising or using Wikipedia as a listing site. It's certainly neither a mainstream high school or degree awarding institution that might, under certain conditions being met, accord it some notability. Riding on the back of unsourced informal university recognition does not in any way assert notability here Deletion of Ushin Language Institute WP:GNG||WP:ORG||WP:G11 Wikipedia:Notability 77
3057 19682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank Rouas User:HighKing 14:20, 1 June 2018 (UTC) delete Not even close to meeting the requirements of . Wikipedia is not a platform for promotion nor a substitute for a CV or personal website Deletion of Frank Rouas WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3058 10915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eugene Kobylinsky User:Necrothesp 08:40, 14 June 2013 (UTC) keep Clearly existed (as a brief search will determine) and played a significant role in a major event in world history. Just because an article is unreferenced does not mean it is |original research, as a quick glance at that policy will reveal Deletion of Eugene Kobylinsky WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3059 7844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angus MacLane User:MichaelQSchmidt 09:28, 11 July 2014 (UTC) keep Meets and . While not over-sourced, this article IS sourced and, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Angus_MacLane&diff=616601730&oldid=616534717 now sourced within its current content, it seems this individual has won two Annie Awards.http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0533691/awards?ref_=nm_awd That would seem to be something significant that could have been found through a |little research. Notability is met Deletion of Angus MacLane WP:ANYBIO||WP:NRVE||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3060 12355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aima Rosmy Sebastian (2nd nomination) [[User talk:103.61.208.98|talk]]) 15:21, 25 August 2016 (UTC) delete All sources cited are interdependent related to one film (more like a promo), fails to satisfy and fairly this gives enough sanctions for delete, re-listing's by related editors from previous discussion seems to be Wikipedia:Relisting can be abusive.Special:Contributions/103.61.208.98|103.61.208.98 Deletion of Aima Rosmy Sebastian (2nd nomination) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3061 3978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2028 Summer Olympics User:JulesH 12:03, 8 July 2007 (UTC) keep """ doesn't apply to verifiable speculation that has been discussed in reliable sources. In fact, quoting from : """"... and 2036 Summer Olympics are not considered appropriate article topics because nothing can be said about them that is verifiable and not original research."""" This is a well-sourced article that is verifiable and does not contain original research""" Deletion of 2028 Summer Olympics WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3062 7351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dawn Fantasia User:Skirts89 16:39, 27 April 2019 (UTC) delete Fails NPOL as well as . Totally non-notable subject Deletion of Dawn Fantasia WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3063 19315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NOA (rapper) User:Nick 09:45, 11 October 2013 (UTC) delete No evidence that Mr Aligiannis meets or passes Deletion of NOA (rapper) WP:BIO||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3064 7003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Joe Campbell User:MPFitz1968 17:26, 14 December 2018 (UTC) keep per {{u|Rmhermen}}'s comment. Campbell's eight seasons as part of the main cast on ''According to Jim'' is very impressive. What bothers me is the guideline, which expects multiple major (significant) roles, but he has many guest or recurring roles across a number of TV series in the years since ''According to Jim''. All that appears to sum up notability on NACTOR grounds (especially with all the seasons he was on ''According to Jim''), even if it may not technically meet point #1 in the guideline Deletion of Larry Joe Campbell WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3065 2458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clara Lin User:Sam 18:19, 31 January 2017 (UTC) delete zh:林彦伊 never existed, and that may be an indication that she's not notable although |it isn't necessarily. I did some searching on '''{{mono|林彦伊}}''' but from the little I can understand of the Google translation, there's not much coverage found. From all I can tell, she fails /, the prize she won does not make her likely notable per , and the article should be deleted per . I am very willing to change my position, if someone fluent in Chinese can find a handful of good sources Deletion of Clara Lin WP:OTHERLANGS||WP:GNG||WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO||WP:DEL8 Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3066 16433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Givensix User:LibStar 08:21, 17 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails due to nothing in gnews Deletion of Givensix WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3067 11909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JLS (Album) User:Joe 00:12, 1 August 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of JLS (Album) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3068 10803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caitlin Crosby User:Cindamuse 23:22, 24 April 2011 (UTC) comment Please note that recommendations after April 22 have been made based on a vandalized version of the article, since restored. That said, while the mtv.com content is not independent of the subject and is a duplicate of the allmusic.com reference, it it my opinion that sufficient sourcing has been found to support notability according to the |general notability guidelines Deletion of Caitlin Crosby WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3069 12810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RAS syndrome User:TenPoundHammer 17:21, 18 July 2008 (UTC) comment I think that the New Scientist articles aren't very substantial in their coverage, so I'm still not convinced that this meets Deletion of RAS syndrome WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3070 12399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cashmere Agency User:MacGyverMagic 13:51, 29 March 2009 (UTC) keep It obviously needs some editing to get rid of less than stellar language, but so far everyone has ignored the references. One is a passing mention to establish a fact, one is not dependent. The rest appears to be fully reliable and meeting . Also, articles shouldn't be deleted based on who created them. They should be judged on their own merit or lack thereof Deletion of Cashmere Agency WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3071 11848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arun Benny User:CAPTAIN 19:31, 8 March 2017 (UTC) delete He does not seem to meet the notability criteria for ntertainer Deletion of Arun Benny WP:E Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
3072 3279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/February 2021 Joe Biden speech to joint session of Congress User:Arccosecant 21:01, 9 February 2021 (UTC) delete per and lack of reliable sources other than the AP calendar entry, which states that the date is unconfirmed Deletion of February 2021 Joe Biden speech to joint session of Congress WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3073 9757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EC8OR User:Guest9999 21:52, 26 May 2008 (UTC) keep there seem to be sufficient |reliable sources on which to base an article. For example http://www.popmatters.com/pm/music/reviews/17144/ec8or-one/ this profile from PopMatters.com, http://www.nme.com/reviews/ec8or/3088 these http://www.nme.com/reviews/ec8or/489 two from NME, http://www.nowtoronto.com/issues/2001-05-10/music_feature7.html this article in Now (magazine)|Now, also mentions in other sources such as http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1449099/20010924/story.jhtml MTV and http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9A00E5DF1F30F931A35752C0A961958260&sec=&spon=&pagewanted=3 the New Yorkhttp://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9502EEDD173FF930A35753C1A960958260 Times Deletion of EC8OR WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3074 19267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rollonfriday User:ais523 NONE keep After all that {{Template:unsigned2|unsigned2}} tagging, it's time to vote. This seems to satisfy the notability criteria guideline 1: The content itself has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself (see the references added to the article), it's inherently verifiable, and there don't seem to be any other deletion-worthy problems. (It needs cleanup, but that isn't a reason for deletion Deletion of Rollonfriday WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3075 17773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Project 26 [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']] 22:42, 22 January 2006 (UTC) delete tl|db-band}} as per violation of usic - albums & singles chart positions or notable members Deletion of Project 26 WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
3076 21134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MS-14 Gelgoog User:TheFarix 13:25, 19 October 2008 (UTC) merge to List of Mobile Suit Gundam mobile units. Does not meet |notability criteria to have its own article, but can be covered in a list of mobile suits from the series Deletion of MS-14 Gelgoog WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3077 9171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poldberg [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 15:38, 15 November 2006 (UTC) delete """per , which states ''""""If an article topic has no reliable, third-party sources, Wikipedia should not have an article on it.""""'' We shouldn't be keeping articles because there are """"probably"""" sources somewhere that no one has found yet. Better to not have an article on a topic than to have one that contains possibly inaccurate info that has not yet been properly verified. Once someone ''does'' find good sources, the article can be recreated at that time. -- """ Deletion of Poldberg WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3078 13416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian extremism User:JASpencer 14:01, 30 December 2006 (UTC) keep This seems a problem with and and should go through the text before relisting Deletion of Christian extremism WP:V||WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3079 10685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acoustic Graffiti NONE 20:51, 8 July 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find any sources that show notability. Fails Deletion of Acoustic Graffiti WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3080 18135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gynophagia User:Kim 23:48, 1 January 2011 (UTC) delete I was going to speedy this one straight away but sadly a Google search confirms this is not a hoax. However the article is completely insufficient and the topic is well covered at Vorarephilia already. Can we pile on and this quickly Deletion of Gynophagia WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
3081 10861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuliza Technologies User:Glrx 18:45, 1 November 2016 (UTC) delete """I'll stand by my AfC decline.https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Kuliza_Technologies&diff=501952824&oldid=501807218 Being among a crop of fast growing companies does not show notability. There are many ways to measure growth: revenue, capitalization, employees, .... The measure can be absolute or relative. Landing a $100,000 contract might increase revenue by 2000 percent. Even the Deloitte article implies the company is """"small"""" (but pages are offline now). Also, restricting the sample to a small subset (particular technology in India) does not suggest significant impact on the community. Choose the measure that makes you look good. BusinessLine article says there were 371 startups; article is also an interview with the CEO rather than an independent analysis. Flinging buzzwords like """"social networking"""" and """"mobile platforms"""" does not make a company notable; the first paragraph is meaningless. teaches that capitalizing a company or having employees does not make the company notable. The second paragraph does not show . The only stated claim in the article is it is a fast growing software development/business consulting firm (with only 70 employees, how big can it be?). There is absolutely nothing about what the company has done for its clients let alone something that would cause the public to take notice""" Deletion of Kuliza Technologies WP:CORP||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3082 11109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Advances in Group Theory and Applications User:David 22:04, 5 September 2015 (UTC) delete This appears to be a legitimate new journal and not one of the many Predatory open access publishing|predatory journals that have been popping up like mushrooms. In particular it claims not to charge authors for publishing, always a good sign. But it's |too soon to tell whether it will become notable Deletion of Advances in Group Theory and Applications WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3083 19653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sagarmatha Secondary Boarding School User:Mccapra 04:23, 31 July 2019 (UTC) delete Does not pass Deletion of Sagarmatha Secondary Boarding School WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3084 12457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Post-presidency of Bill Clinton User:Praemonitus 03:04, 27 March 2013 (UTC) comment Isn't that the point of Deletion of Post-presidency of Bill Clinton WP:SUBARTICLE Wikipedia:Article size 51
3085 922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Animal treatment in rodeo [[User_talk:Neon white|talk]] 11:19, 21 March 2009 (UTC) keep First issues are not a reason for deletion. The article is clearly not a coatrack, it sticks the subject and nothing else. Therefore the reasons for nomination appear unsound. --neon white Deletion of Animal treatment in rodeo WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
3086 21832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TUGS characters accents User:Bryson109 21:30, 14 April 2007 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of TUGS characters accents WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3087 14942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sorcery 101 User:Whispering 13:13, 14 August 2006 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Sorcery 101 WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3088 2930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adytum (band) User:Titoxd 00:57, 3 May 2006 (UTC) delete fails , Deletion of Adytum (band) WP:BAND||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3089 7452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Space stations and habitats in fiction User:LaundryPizza03 23:31, 5 August 2021 (UTC) delete As it stands, everything here is and — per precedent at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Far future in fiction and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earth in science fiction (2nd nomination), which voted to rewrite from scratch. From the length of the ''The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction'' entry above, I'd suggest that the topic will need a new article at this location and not a mere section in Space station Deletion of Space stations and habitats in fiction WP:OR||WP:IINFO Wikipedia:No original research 65
3090 21678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yale International Relations Association [[User talk:Czar|czar]] 03:38, 22 September 2017 (UTC) merge to parent Yale_University#Student_organizations (where it is mentioned by name but unsourced) as -R. No showing of |significant coverage in multiple |reliable, |independent sources (|?), or put another way, there isn't enough secondary source content to do justice to the topic Deletion of Yale International Relations Association WP:ATD||WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:42 Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3091 6081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K. Johnston User:onel5969 14:02, 18 May 2016 (UTC) delete I'm not finding enough in-depth coverage from independent, reliable sources to show they pass , and as pointed out by {{u|David Eppstein}}, they don't pass Deletion of K. Johnston WP:GNG||WP:SCHOLAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3092 18604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ROTH Capital Partners User:Septrillion 08:09, 6 July 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and . \\\Septrillion Deletion of ROTH Capital Partners WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
3093 10380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Digiclone User:Tbo_157 19:36, 30 October 2007 (UTC) delete Fails . Doesn't seem to be well known Deletion of Digiclone WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3094 20368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Open Road (Short Film) User:Esradekan 12:10, 29 July 2008 (UTC) delete currently fails notability per , and even if it comes out I can't see it passing either Deletion of Open Road (Short Film) WP:NFF||WP:MOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3095 12637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norwegian-Azerbaijanis Youth Organization (NAYO) User:LibStar 08:17, 31 May 2009 (UTC) comment """you say """"The reason why this organization is not in google news or spread in secondary sources is due to the reason it is quite new and was registered recently."""" you've actually give an excellent reason why this article fails , and . the links you provide only prove the organisation's existence. just because it exists doesn't mean it automatically gets a wikipedia article""" Deletion of Norwegian-Azerbaijanis Youth Organization (NAYO) WP:N||WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3096 19747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 AFF U-15 Women's Championship User:GauchoDude 17:20, 6 January 2017 (UTC) delete Per nom and above rationale. Fails Deletion of 2017 AFF U-15 Women's Championship WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3097 9590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/India's Coal Story User:Gråbergs 09:45, 23 January 2020 (UTC) comment I'm adding these to the argument for : https://www.telegraphindia.com/opinion/objects-in-focus/cid/1455480 The Telegraph (Kolkata) and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rcCl-SfzOqs DD News Deletion of India's Coal Story WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3098 13857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oleksiy Shevchuk User:Timtempleton 19:54, 14 October 2020 (UTC) delete this is a bit tricky because I don't speak Ukrainian and can't do a thorough , but based on what's there now, there isn't a single piece of biographical coverage in the media. All his biographical info comes from professional directory or licensing listings, which can be self-submitted. His cases with his firm got coverage, and his shows have YouTube links (but oddly not media coverage), but I'd like to see a single profile of him in any media source. Otherwise this is a delete Deletion of Oleksiy Shevchuk WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3099 5444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harry Potter music (2nd nomination) User:Le 16:57, 7 August 2008 (UTC) keep due to clear and overwhelming consensus in previous AfD and because is never a valid argument for deletion. Also, we don't merge and delete per the Wikipedia:Merge and delete|GFDL. --Happy editing! Sincerely Deletion of Harry Potter music (2nd nomination) WP:ITSCRUFT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3100 5588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Price (businessman) User:AllyD 08:20, 31 January 2018 (UTC) delete """To be """"the first male managing director of Topshop for eighteen years"""" is not inherently notable. A Sunday Times magazine feature on the subject's home furnishings may be a closer call, but neither that nor http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/news/article-4890866/Is-Paul-Price-right-man-Topshop-top.html a """"This is Money"""" piece on his appointment is, I think, sufficient to demonstrate |encyclopaedic notability""" Deletion of Paul Price (businessman) :WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3101 2613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tobi Bakre (2nd nomination) User:Versace1608 13:51, 3 May 2020 (UTC) keep The subject passes and the first criterion of . He played a major role in ''Sugar Rush (2019 film)|Sugar Rush'', a film currently occupying the fourth spot on the list of the highest grossing Nigerian films of all time. He also had a major role in Kunle Afolayan's ''Mokalik'', a notable film that has been critically reviewed by https://www.premiumtimesng.com/entertainment/nollywood/365003-movie-review-kunle-afolayans-mokalik-thrives-on-memory-not-viewer-satisfaction.html ''Premium Times'', https://tns.ng/review-kunle-afolayan-mokalik/ TNS, https://ynaija.com/film-review-kunle-afolayans-mokalik-isnt-quite-a-return-to-form/ ''YNaija'', https://www.nollywoodreinvented.com/2019/09/mokalik.html Nollywood Reinvented, https://thelagosreview.ng/welcome-to-mokalik-where-little-things-count-temitayo-olofinlua/ The Lagos Review, and https://medium.com/@jobaoje/why-kunle-afolayans-mokalik-might-not-blow-your-mind-65a2e86bd0db Medium. Other reliable coverage of the film can be seen https://variety.com/2019/film/news/nigeria-kunle-afolayan-african-audiences-shouldnt-be-second-class-durban-film-festival-2019-1203274861/ here, https://www.pulse.ng/entertainment/movies/mokalik-5-things-you-should-know-about-kunle-afolayans-new-movie/qgtxk79 here and https://www.pulse.ng/bi/lifestyle/kunle-afolayans-movie-mokalik-is-the-latest-nigerian-movie-to-be-acquired-by-netflix/1pebj2d here Deletion of Tobi Bakre (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3102 17309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malaclemys terrapin maximus User:Deor 21:15, 7 August 2011 (UTC) delete I'm unable to find any |reliable sources discussing this supposed subspecies Deletion of Malaclemys terrapin maximus WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3103 2021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Democrat Party (phrase) User:Cazort 22:16, 5 March 2009 (UTC) keep This article is very well-sourced and I'm a bit surprised to see such an extensive and well-sourced article proposed for deletion. Some of the sources are written specifically about this topic (as in written about the phrase/term itself). That certainly meets the otability criteria Deletion of Democrat Party (phrase) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3104 10732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barbecue (G.I. Joe) [[User talk:70.80.234.196|talk]]) 22:15, 21 February 2010 (UTC) merge to G.I. Joe: A Real American Hero - per /. Alternatively, '''merge all''' into a single list article.--Special:Contributions/70.80.234.196|70.80.234.196 Deletion of Barbecue (G.I. Joe) WP:FICT||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3105 21093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Koziol User:Cunard 01:00, 15 November 2009 (UTC) delete per the lack of |reliable sources. A http://news.google.com/archivesearch?&as_src=-newswire+-wire+-presswire+-PR+-press+-release+-wikipedia&q=%22Scott+Koziol%22 Google News Archive search does not return relevant results.Per Wikipedia:Verifiability and Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons, a biography of a living person sourced to only unreliable sources should be deleted Deletion of Scott Koziol WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3106 6174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OCAU User:Stifle 22:37, 21 May 2006 (UTC) keep per Deletion of OCAU WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3107 2599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Billboard Hot 100 number-two singles of 2015 User:Clean 00:50, 13 June 2015 (UTC) delete Clealy fails and . That's what this article is Deletion of List of Billboard Hot 100 number-two singles of 2015 WP:LISTN||WP:IINFO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3108 3762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gianluigi Donnarumma User:Sir 17:22, 31 August 2015 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Gianluigi Donnarumma WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3109 4711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of unlawfully killed transgender people User:Location 13:07, 30 September 2015 (UTC) delete per , specifically . Unfortunately, hate crimes are relatively common and our goal should not be to catalog them. I agree with those that believe the topic should be addressed in Wikipedia and it is. Notable examples that meet (i.e. pass ) can be discussed in Violence against LGBT people or in appropriate sub-articles (e.g. History of violence against LGBT people in the United States Deletion of List of unlawfully killed transgender people WP:WWIN||WP:NOTDIRECTORY||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:EVENT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3110 19725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sound object User:Qwaiiplayer 18:18, 12 July 2021 (UTC) keep per . The topic seems notable as it has several hits on https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22Sound+object%22 Scholar (e.g. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00754179508254905https://psycnet.apa.org/buy/2012-10031-001https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/cogs.12734) and there isn't any reason under -REASON I see to delete the article Deletion of Sound object WP:NOTCLEANUP||WP:DEL Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3111 18435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jean-Christophe, Prince Napoléon User:Ritchie333 17:44, 7 January 2013 (UTC) merge The existence of being the pretender to the throne of France is a notable fact, but that's it, which makes it a . Just not sure what to direct to, maybe Pretender#French_pretenders, or maybe we need an English equivalent of http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pr%C3%A9tendants_au_tr%C3%B4ne_de_France_depuis_1815#H.C3.A9ritiers_de_la_Couronne_Imp.C3.A9riale_de_France Liste des prétendants au trône de France depuis 1792 on the French Wikipedia Deletion of Jean-Christophe, Prince Napoléon WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
3112 12239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sherika L. Hawkins User:Taewangkorea 18:20, 12 October 2019 (UTC) delete per . We should not write articles for people with the thought that they have committed a crime. If the subject receives more coverage in the future (either related to this or another) I am sure can apply Deletion of Sherika L. Hawkins WP:BLP||WP:REFUND Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3113 21529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julian Owusu-Bekoe User:Nfitz 03:38, 17 July 2009 (UTC) keep References in article meet and Deletion of Julian Owusu-Bekoe WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3114 582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paula Fatic User:pd_THOR 17:46, 7 August 2006 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Paula Fatic WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3115 25 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Haskoç Adam """Kullanıcı:ovalthunder9ovathunder9""" 17.54, 2 Nisan 2021 (UTC) delete Bağımsız ve güvenilir hiçbir kaynak bulamadım karşıladığını düşünmüyorum Haskoç Adam'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
3116 19126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ambir Hamsa User:Ohconfucius 05:25, 21 August 2006 (UTC) delete """Regrettable incident which brings the US armed forces into disrepute, but does not qualify for inclusion per , which clearly states """"Multiple similar stories describing a single day's news event only count as one coverage"""". Also the subject is a 14 year old Iraqi girl who would be otherwise not notable, so the article will probably remain a stub forever. However, the subject of American war crimes perpetrated in Iraq could warrant an article, as there have been a few of these""" Deletion of Ambir Hamsa WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3117 395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/British Basketball Association User:BDD 19:56, 26 March 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of British Basketball Association WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3118 8798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Gilb User:Xxanthippe 02:34, 29 July 2014 (UTC) keep GS h-index of 15 not normally enough to pass rof#C1 in this highly cited but one publication with > 1000 cites plus contributions to industry take this BLP over the line. Why did nom not find these facts Deletion of Tom Gilb WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
3119 10879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hameed Razi User:Pharaoh 23:14, 26 September 2014 (UTC) delete Per nom and fails Deletion of Hameed Razi WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3120 7377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Border Town User:Joe 02:34, 23 December 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |film Deletion of Border Town WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3121 10132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amy Reid User:Valrith 21:44, 5 February 2007 (UTC) delete Fails all notability criteria, and has no |verifiability via |secondary sources Deletion of Amy Reid WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3122 6561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kampas Records User:Esradekan 00:50, 20 July 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability per . Not sure their distribution arm, Firebox Records, passes either Deletion of Kampas Records WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3123 7841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian John Converse User:Mh29255 01:32, 27 December 2007 (UTC) delete per |Recreation of deleted material Deletion of Brian John Converse WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3124 16935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cryptocurrencies user:Hellknowz 14:17, 4 January 2014 (UTC) delete Redirect). The list of ''notable'' currencies can be (and already is) included in digital currency and cryptocurrency. This list is an unnecessary that in reality only serves to host non-notable currencies and ends up being promotional. There are not enough items to warrant a split at this point. Trimming the list off non-notable entries just leaves the same content as already in parent articles. I don't believe simply being a member of the group (#3) is a valid criteria for this list, as the list is ultimately indiscriminate. There are sources like http://www.forbes.com/sites/reuvencohen/2013/11/27/the-top-30-crypto-currency-market-capitalizations-in-one-place/, but they are similarly endless lists arranged by criteria that is not relevant to GNG. When individual currencies become notable, we can include then, not before. When the list becomes too large for the main article(s), we can split it. — Deletion of List of cryptocurrencies WP:SPLIT||WP:CSC Wikipedia:Splitting 57
3125 5212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mystic Travelogues User:Tokyogirl79 10:20, 16 January 2013 (UTC) delete I remember endorsing the PROD, not realizing that it was a second attempt at PRODing the same article. I did a quick search to see if any new sources had been put out since I endorsed the PROD and sure enough, there aren't any that would show it passes . This just isn't notable at this point in time Deletion of The Mystic Travelogues WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
3126 17598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hand Held Computer User:John 15:04, 29 December 2015 (UTC) merge the relevant information across both 2010 United States Census and Harris Corporation, then redirect this title to Mobile device ensuring {{tl|rcats}} {{tl|R from alternative name}} and {{tl|R from other capitalization}} are displayed on the redirected page. The information in this article is |verifiable in |reliable secondary sources and though it is not sufficiently |notable for a stand alone article, it is necessary information that should be included in existing Wikipedia articles where its best fit is found. In my opinion, it becomes disproportionate and ndue|undue if all of this article's information is merged into any single article. I disagree with the assessment that conflicted interests are apparent within the article. The closeness with the subject the article's creator self-declared above appears to have been well managed when based solely on a reading of this article Deletion of Hand Held Computer WP:V||WP:R||WP:N||WP:U Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3127 3017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adele Croucamp User:Tamsier NONE delete WP:A7 - Deletion of Adele Croucamp WP:AUTOBIO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
3128 7272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Desiertos User:Leebo 20:43, 25 March 2007 (UTC) keep as the album of a |notable group, regardless of its own status Deletion of Desiertos WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3129 21924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/La Teresita User:Northamerica1000 19:51, 20 March 2014 (UTC) keep meets per book and news sources Deletion of La Teresita WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3130 2153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/QuantAlea (2nd nomination) User:AllyD 11:51, 13 February 2017 (UTC) delete I am seeing |nothing to indicate that this company is of |encyclopaedic notability Deletion of QuantAlea (2nd nomination) :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3131 13660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derek Frazier (2nd nomination) User:Mikeman67 21:22, 3 March 2014 (UTC) delete Previously deleted following AfD debate. Still fails , or (wherever it should belong Deletion of Derek Frazier (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:ENT||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3132 4727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Walkes User:Richwales 01:06, 21 August 2011 (UTC) delete per . No evidence of ''notability'' (see to understand what this means on Wikipedia) via any ''independent'' reliable sources discussing the subject or his writings (please carefully read to understand what this means). I did a Google search but found only stuff from Masonic sources and/or the Phylaxis Society, and sites selling Walkes' books. If anyone is aware of sources which would suffice to establish Wikipedia notability, please add them ASAP Deletion of Joseph Walkes WP:PEOPLE||WP:PEOPLE||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3133 20037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bern's Steak House User:Coredesat 04:18, 10 July 2006 (UTC) keep if notability can be |verified with |reliable sources Deletion of Bern's Steak House WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3134 18371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neo-Capitalism User:MichaelQSchmidt 19:15, 19 February 2009 (UTC) keep Tag for sources and send to leanup. If http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&rls=com.microsoft:en-US&q=%22Neo-Capitalism%22&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=wp google books and http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&rls=com.microsoft:en-US&q=%22Neo-Capitalism%22&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=ps google scholar are any indication, this could become a terrific addition that improves wiki. Definitely needs attention from experts in the field Deletion of Neo-Capitalism WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
3135 17693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Australian Justice Party User:Bearian 21:23, 18 April 2017 (UTC) delete Not even wrong|Where do I even begin? , , , and are good places to start, I guess Deletion of Australian Justice Party WP:TNT||WP:TOOSOON||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
3136 21440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sayonara (Red velvet song) User:Dom 11:35, 17 September 2020 (UTC) merge per : no evidence of notability per Deletion of Sayonara (Red velvet song) WP:CHEAP||WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
3137 6953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of painters by name User:Northamerica1000 18:10, 4 February 2016 (UTC) keep These articles fully qualify per relative to :Category:Painters and subcategories therein. They are also functional navigational aids per . The lists are not indiscriminate because virtually all of the links are blue-linked to valid Wikipedia articles. The few that are redlinked can be verified with sources. Also, the lists are quite easily maintainable, as evidenced by their neat and organized state at this time. See regarding articles that are not being continuously worked on Deletion of List of painters by name WP:NOTDUP||WP:LISTPURP||WP:NOEFFORT Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
3138 15117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robot2 User:RichardOSmith 19:51, 27 May 2011 (UTC) delete """This one's a no brainer: states """"films that have not been confirmed by reliable sources to have commenced principal photography should not have their own articles"""" and the article and refs state that work on the script has not even started""" Deletion of Robot2 WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3139 10250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Menstelia User:Hello32020 02:44, 9 April 2007 (UTC) delete Violates |POV policy Deletion of Menstelia WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
3140 17910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richest cities in the world User:Eusebeus 08:33, 3 July 2007 (UTC) delete A list that, absent a specific, credible source can make no claims to encyclopedic verifiability or accuracy. Ad that is the issue. As it is, the list is a reprint of the PWC report, which itself is fairly arbitrary, and so this amounts to a reprint of someone else's OR, which risks CV issues among other things. If this is exapnded beyond the PWC report, then it becomes a hopeless muddle of competing metrics and statistics and descends into a morass of unverifiability. That's not on. If you want to find out who PWC thinks are the richest cities in the world, go to them directly. For an article on Wikipedia, we need |multiple, independent sources that can be |verified. That is not the case here Deletion of Richest cities in the world WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
3141 21285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flyff (3rd nomination) [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 22:23, 20 September 2009 (UTC) keep and '''cleanup''' – there's awards there and some coverage by multiple reliable sources, asserting notability. However, I have to agree that the vast majority of the ''content'' in the page is not appropriate for an encyclopedia (i.e. |game guide material and overdetailed minutiae) and can probably be removed. Hopefully, someone can step up—preferably someone good enough to be able to write in a more professional and formal manner than what I see right now—and take charge of this article (hence, the ''cleanup'' part Deletion of Flyff (3rd nomination) WP:GAMEGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3142 20194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sands Fish User:Russ 10:53, 23 May 2021 (UTC) comment Is there any indication of ? (As participants here know, this would generally require multiple reviews of multiple works or similar.) I agree that there's no indication of or GNG notability Deletion of Sands Fish WP:NARTIST||WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3143 17003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shahzad Ali Najmi User:Anupmehra 23:35, 23 July 2014 (UTC) delete Subject lacks significant coverage in multiple secondary, independent and reliable sources, therefore it does not merit a Wikipedia article. It fails |Wikipedia general notability guideline and |Wikipedia notability guideline for people. I see, tons of SPAs here, not sure if there have been a SPI regarding this Deletion of Shahzad Ali Najmi WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3144 16943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Calvin Hill User:Dead 08:55, 12 January 2017 (UTC) delete Indeed, his most notable activity was apparently being a soldier, but he does not seem to meet or WP:ANYBIO by any means. He never did anything remotely notable by our standards. I also have my doubts whether the sole source is an RS, it seems to be some self published family history which has probably a short blurb about him. There is nothing else on him online, and I also doubt that there is anything else about him offline too. I think it is safe to say that this article can be deleted per the aforementioned guidelines and WP:GNG due a lack of notability and RS Deletion of John Calvin Hill WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
3145 1366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Food Network Humor User:RL0919 18:50, 19 December 2009 (UTC) delete No sign of any coverage by reliable sources, pretty much just obvious Deletion of Food Network Humor WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
3146 11129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shelley Batts User:Ohconfucius 21:51, 7 August 2008 (UTC) delete If the blog is itself notable, it may warrant an article. However, we delete references from blogs, and people |known only for writing blogs. What's more, this article seems to be no longer sourced, although the source appears to have been an expired or deleted blog, so fails Deletion of Shelley Batts WP:BLP1E||WP:RS Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3147 13052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Project Alexander (manga) User:Quasirandom 15:25, 1 August 2009 (UTC) delete unpublished, unfinished, self-published doujinshi with no third-party coverage (reliable or otherwise) anticipating its release = fails by a mile. ( is the relevant notability guideline if you're generous and call an OEL manga an actual manga and not a graphic novel Deletion of Project Alexander (manga) WP:BK||WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
3148 13271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jubilee USA Network User:Eggishorn 04:55, 17 January 2014 (UTC) keep and re-write. Organization clearly passes , with coverage in http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2014/01/13/18749131.php Bay Area Indy Media, http://www.ipsnews.net/2013/11/u-s-a-favourite-roost-of-vulture-funds/#13899343723261&action=collapse_widget&id=2866525 Inter Press Service, and http://www.dailycal.org/2013/12/05/jubilee-usa-reception-sparks-moves-toward-debt-solutions/ the Daily Californian Deletion of Jubilee USA Network WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3149 4156 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicholas """"DeCoY"""" Case""" User:Carlosguitar 04:04, 4 August 2007 (UTC) delete fails """Deletion of Nicholas """"DeCoY"""" Case""" WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3150 6348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dryve User:Monicasdude 14:43, 28 March 2006 (UTC) keep as above, apparently satisfied Deletion of Dryve WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3151 4102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mo Moulton User:Espresso 16:41, 10 January 2021 (UTC) keep Generally in practice requires at minimum two books which each receive at least one or two reviews, preferably from different sources. This is easily met here. I don't think the subject yet meets ; the academic book with CUP has healthy citations in Google Scholar (32) but there's nothing else yet. The creator of this and other articles is a relatively new editor who is picking, on the whole, notable topics but not always succeeding in demonstrating their significance in the way the 'pedia expects. It would be more positive to attempt to help out, rather than attempt to delete Deletion of Mo Moulton WP:AUTHOR||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3152 875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Siegel User:Tree 05:17, 30 June 2006 (UTC) delete per . Not a lot of relevant Google results http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22David+Siegel%22+spokesman Deletion of David Siegel WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3153 17049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Political prisoners in Venezuela User:Cathar11 00:31, 18 January 2010 (UTC) delete I cosider this article a of the Human rights in Venezuela article Deletion of Political prisoners in Venezuela WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
3154 1316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Hopp User:Qrsdogg 17:28, 31 May 2011 (UTC) delete A couple trivial mentions, but doesn't seem to meet Deletion of Jeff Hopp WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3155 14561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rock with RONY User:Epinoia 17:15, 10 September 2019 (UTC) delete no significant coverage in reliable secondary sources as per Deletion of Rock with RONY WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3156 9271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2003 Route 60 Hamas ambush User:onel5969 16:27, 7 September 2015 (UTC) keep clearly passes . I may not personally think that this one particular attack is notable, but the guidelines are pretty clear. Sources are widespread and in-depth Deletion of 2003 Route 60 Hamas ambush WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3157 16652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plav-Gusinje massacres (1912-13) (2nd nomination) User:Khirurg 22:15, 22 May 2020 (UTC) delete """per lack of coverage in reliable sources. As Amanuensis Balkanicus explains very clearly, there is simply no mention of this rather large massacre in reliable sources. As far as I can see, we have activist schoolteachers, collections of primary documents, and an obscure symposium in Albania in 1993. Yet, had such a large massacre taken place, one would expect '''at least one''' modern scholar to have documented it. The Balkans are a heavily studied area; there are dozens of scholars who focus on Balkan history and politics. Surely one of them would have verified the existence of this massacre and put his name to that? Maleschreiber has had plenty of time to find reliable sources that document this purported massacre, but has failed to do so, likely because such sources do not exist (certainly not through lack of effort or motivation). The only reliable sources (BI and Pacariz) speak of commemorations by activists, but do not document the existence of the massacre itself. They are misused. I also find arguments of the type """"there is no coverage because this was a small massacre"""" to be absolutely ridiculous and contrived. 2,000 killed is not a small number, it is a HUGE number (comparable to the 8,000 killed in Srebrenica). To suggest that this was a minor event and that does not apply is highly intellectually dishonest""" Deletion of Plav-Gusinje massacres (1912-13) (2nd nomination) WP:EXTRAORDINARY Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3158 11198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Trek versus Star Wars (4th nomination) User:Phirazo NONE comment """The Salon article is an editorial and is already mentioned in the article, along with a heaping helping of |original research about fan reaction to the article. The Tribune and the Inquirer articles are the same article, which is mostly interviews with fans. I'm still looking around for the full text of the L.A. Daily News articles, but the blurb in the link screams """"news of the weird"""". I don't see how an article can be built from these sources. As for trimming OR, if you remove the OR from this article, there won't be anything left""" Deletion of Star Trek versus Star Wars (4th nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3159 2218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Wallington User:E 12:01, 8 January 2019 (UTC) delete """claims are highly exaggerated. For example, """"starred"""" in a BBC series, but the series was a home gardening show where the show visits a different home gardener every week, and one week they came to his garden. None of the several similar claims in article are claims to anything recognized here as notability. and there is no of him""" Deletion of Jack Wallington WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
3160 9220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Dungeons & Dragons dwarf deities User:SportingFlyer 11:55, 27 January 2020 (UTC) delete clearly fails and . None of the sources are independent Deletion of List of Dungeons & Dragons dwarf deities WP:LISTN||WP:GAMEGUIDE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3161 8801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul LaVinn User:Paulmcdonald 15:47, 19 November 2008 (UTC) comment """I suppose that information is """"look-up-able"""" but how would any argument about size/etc not violate as an """"argument to avoid in deletion discussions""" Deletion of Paul LaVinn WP:NOTBIGENOUGH Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3162 21553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silion User:Clarityfiend 11:21, 16 February 2015 (UTC) keep per . It's an officially recognized, populated barangay, as demonstrated by the '''very first reference''' in the article (http://www.nscb.gov.ph/activestats/psgc/municipality.asp?muncode=072209000®code=07&provcode=22 the Philippine Statistics Authority) and by various other authoritative sources, e.g. http://www.socmon.org/upload/documents/CentralPhilippines_SocMonReport2007.pdf Deletion of Silion WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
3163 5451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kasia Al Thani (2nd nomination) User:Hongkongresident 07:32, 22 October 2010 (UTC) merge to Abdelaziz bin Khalifa Al Thani, due to #Family. There are a few sources specificially about her and a defunct business she started, but not enough to merit a separate article Deletion of Kasia Al Thani (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3164 10807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Relationship between rugby league and rugby union User:Jnestorius 22:09, 8 September 2016 (UTC) merge """somewhere. Possibly Comparison of rugby league and rugby union or History of rugby league. Despite the claim that """"The topic ... seems to be covered very well at History_of_rugby_league"""" I did not see any of the Relationship between rugby league and rugby union#21st century information in that article. It would be to suggest the four instances are part of a pattern of union trying to stamp on league, but that's not a cause for deleting all the information""" Deletion of Relationship between rugby league and rugby union WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
3165 1125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michel van Rijt User:Mdtemp 20:01, 18 November 2014 (UTC) keep Medals at four world championships (even if only 2 are sourced) is enough to meet . I think the whole section on training can go unless someone can add some sources Deletion of Michel van Rijt WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3166 16684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WebAPP User:Flakeloaf 22:08, 18 January 2007 (UTC) delete Fails , Deletion of WebAPP WP:WEB||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3167 12540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mombathi (film) User:Spiderone 09:27, 11 March 2017 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Mombathi (film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
3168 3528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maf, Shamkir User:Cunard 22:22, 22 October 2009 (UTC) comment """I've relisted this debate because none of the participants voting """"keep"""" have |verified that Maf, Shamkir exists and should be redirected to Şəmkir""" Deletion of Maf, Shamkir WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3169 6406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dynamic painting User:MER 10:21, 31 January 2007 (UTC) delete per above. Maybe too Deletion of Dynamic painting WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
3170 700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/也是醉了 User:Hisashiyarouin 13:33, 9 November 2014 (UTC) delete """per . This article is about a Chinese internet slang and nothing else. Cnilep might find use for its literal meaning (""""I am also drunk"""", which is easily commonplace) but no notability would be established for that case. Also Baidu Baike is not RS anyway""" Deletion of 也是醉了 WP:NOTDICT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3171 5415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James K Baker User:David 20:53, 1 July 2010 (UTC) keep Google scholar http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=author:j-baker+-author:jm-baker+-author:ja-baker+speech+-tinnitis+-sleep+-telomere&btnG=Search&as_sdt=2001&as_ylo=&as_vis=0 shows heavy citation counts (over 350) both for his Dragon system and for his paper on trainable grammars. The search results are messy but his h-index appears to be around 15 or 16. It's enough to convince me of a pass of #C1 and also enough to convince me that he's known for more than just one thing Deletion of James K Baker WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3172 4075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of breweries in Massachusetts User:Ellin 16:45, 21 January 2014 (UTC) keep These lists are valid for navigation. It is not hard to add links to them. It probably takes less time to go web hunting and add links than it does to set up deletion nominations for twelve lists. I updated parts of several of these lists including List of breweries in California. It was not hard and I learned that beer brewing is one of the largest non-durable industries in the U.S. and growing at a rate of up to 20% per year. Therefore I think the entire topic is relevant. I have worked on many lists in Wiki before and never encountered this sort of situation because does not demand citations on each line and states that a list may contain non-notable entries Deletion of List of breweries in Massachusetts WP:CSC Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
3173 3575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/London Buses route 603 User:Colonel 09:29, 14 February 2009 (UTC) keep The article has been merged which is a sensible alternative to deletion per Deletion of London Buses route 603 WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3174 14533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Purple economy User:scope_creep 12:09, 4 September 2021 (UTC) delete It is TNT case. Looking all the socks that have been blocked, they have completed by far the majority of work, apart from that IP address editor in the last few days. On top of that I can't find any academic sources confirm it is a genuine concept. I lack confidence in saying it is notable from that aspect. Certainly there is many sites that seem to have latched onto it. But certainly, if notable, then it needs a COI free new article and it is clear case for ''' Deletion of Purple economy WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
3175 1937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellen Johnson User:MCB 22:53, 22 January 2006 (UTC) keep bad faith nom, . After 10 or more of these it is time to block nominator for disruption of Wikipedia Deletion of Ellen Johnson WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
3176 15665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Furious Four [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']][[User talk:(aeropagitica)|''' (talk) ''']] 22:01, 23 June 2006 (UTC) delete as a non-notable band according to usic. Tagged as such Deletion of The Furious Four WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
3177 19710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ace Online NONE NONE keep lack of coverage by reliable secondary sources does not mean the article fails to meet . That's just one indicator of notability. The game is apparently known by several names: Ace Online, Space Cowboy, Space Cowboy Online, SCO, AirRivals, Flysis. I do see an interview with the producer of the game Jason Parkhttp://www.mpogd.com/news/?ID=2299, another interview with Jason Park at Joystiqhttp://www.joystiq.com/2006/05/01/interview-with-space-cowboy-online-producer-jason-park/, a profile on GameSpothttp://www.gamespot.com/pc/rpg/spacecowboy/, a profile on GameSpot Koreahttp://www.gamespot.co.kr/pc/gamespace/0,39051125,39095143p-10000011c-01r,00.htm, a mention in ''The Register''http://www.theregister.co.uk/2007/09/25/cable_wireless_gne_deal/, something about security technology for the game at Gamasutrahttp://www.gamasutra.com/php-bin/news_index.php?story=10084, a mention in ''Next Generation''http://www.next-gen.biz/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=8004&Itemid=2 Deletion of Ace Online WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3178 8966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Octavia Airlines User:The 17:36, 11 February 2013 (UTC) delete The suggestion that there is 'no impact left = non-notable' forgets that |notability is not temporary. However this appears to have never been notable in the first place; the presumption that scheduled airline = notability does not apply here as it was a charter outfit Deletion of Octavia Airlines WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3179 12674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bowral High School User:PCHS 13:01, 14 July 2018 (UTC) keep per , tag with {{tl|unreferenced}}, and work on improving it. It does indeed meet per DuckDuckGo Deletion of Bowral High School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES||WP:V Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3180 19639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Charmed Magical Spells User:Barno 23:04, 22 June 2006 (UTC) delete per the arguments made by Coredesat, Mgm, and Danny L. A short description of the series' spells in general would be an appropriate addition to the Charmed article, but these transcriptions should not be merged there, per Deletion of List of Charmed Magical Spells WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3181 16653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UK MMA Awards User:Astudent0 17:22, 12 March 2012 (UTC) delete """per . There is still no significant independent coverage. The only sources are the site that created the awards and the sites from some of the winners saying """"we won this award."""" — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of UK MMA Awards WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3182 5017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cargurus User:Arichnad 19:36, 8 August 2006 (UTC) comment Don't confuse |prod and |speedy. They are different. '''~a Deletion of Cargurus WP:PROD||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
3183 17949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of UK top 10 albums in 2018 User:Hzh 23:01, 29 March 2018 (UTC) comment I find it puzzling, what exactly is the rationale for a list of top 5 (rather than top 3, 12, 20, or whatever number)? If it is something randomly chosen by the editor rather than something that has any significance, then I would vote for delete, but I would like to hear an explanation first. Note that per {{tquote|One accepted reason why a list topic is considered notable is if it has been discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources}}, are there sources for a top 5 UK list Deletion of List of UK top 10 albums in 2018 WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
3184 18567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional turtles User:Atmoz 16:48, 24 March 2009 (UTC) keep """http://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Aen.wikipedia.org+%22list+of+fictional%22 Other stuff exists. This is the sort of information that you would not expect to find in a #PAPER|paper encyclopedia. However, the fact that so many of these """"List of fictional ____"""" articles exist is proof that at least one person found them potentially useful, and are not cruft. These lists are not in any way an indiscriminate collection of information; its a list of fictional turtles. The topic of the article is precisely defined. I fail to see how DIR applies; this isn't a directory or anything close to what that policy describes as a directory. These lists are easily verifiable, and each entry should be of a notable subject making the list notable. Several of these lists have come to AfD before, with the result being keep or no consensus (I could not find any that resulted in delete, but that doesn't mean there haven't been any) Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/List_of_fictional_dogs|AfD/List of fictional dogs, Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/List_of_fictional_cats|AfD/List of fictional cats, Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/List_of_fictional_monkeys_and_List_of_fictional_apes|AfD/List of fictional apes, and Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/List_of_Fictional_Pandas|AfD/List of fictional pandas""" Deletion of List of fictional turtles WP:NOT||WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3185 20098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of CHL playoffs series User:PKT 16:40, 11 May 2020 (UTC) delete as . This list is an odd way to look at playoff histories, and it appears to be an idea that the original editor embarked upon without realizing what a big job it would become. As a fan of the Windsor Spitfires, I ''might'' be interested in seeing this sort of detail on the team's article, but not in a pan-CHL list of all teams like this Deletion of List of CHL playoffs series WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
3186 4827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julius Lindgren User:GiantSnowman 12:54, 15 January 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Julius Lindgren WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3187 19574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ary Pratama User:Assyrtiko 08:32, 2 August 2021 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails and NFOOTBALL (per concensus Deletion of Ary Pratama WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3188 2976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pixilang User:Twsx 12:06, 16 October 2007 (UTC) delete per nom, Deletion of Pixilang WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3189 7315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/¥Π¥ NONE NONE keep This would be my first submission, so you'll forgive me if I'm a little confused. But according to a band qualifies for Wikipedia if it meets any critereon from the list, including Deletion of ¥Π¥ WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3190 10233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Hunkins User:Clarityfiend 01:21, 7 March 2015 (UTC) delete per . Like Moses Chamberlain below, to whom he is related, being an officer in the American Revolution (and never being taken prisoner) is insufficient. Ancestry.com is thataway Deletion of Robert Hunkins WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
3191 20529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Freakalicious User:Lightdarkness 15:22, 8 April 2006 (UTC) delete Neologism, |Wikipedia is not Urban Dictionary Deletion of Freakalicious WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3192 20547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 Tinsukia killings User:Harshil169 07:16, 16 July 2019 (UTC) delete It's just a single event, not massacre or genocide that it require any wikipedia page. It doesn't meet any otability criteria and doesn't increase the encyclopedic knowledge of the readers Deletion of 2018 Tinsukia killings WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3193 18498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pottsylvania User:LaMenta3 20:42, 12 December 2007 (UTC) keep """This is one of those cases where I feel that is somewhat appropriate. Gtstricky and Shoehorn make fairly cogent arguments that (intentionally or unintentionally) support this. The article has a couple of references which seem to confirm the external notability, even if the coverage in those sources isn't """"highly significant"""" in Wikipedia terms. The existing sources for these notability assertions and the assertions themselves hint at a strong potential for coverage in academic works, particularly those examining Cold War media. A cursory internet search doesn't turn up much in this regard, but at the same time, it doesn't turn up much of any source material published before 2000. It is likely that any significant source material is not well-archived online at this point, given the non-recentness of the information. I support the decision to place a tag for citation improvement on the article, as has already been done, but those participating in AfDs need to remember that |there is no deadline on Wikipedia, and that AfD is NOT the place to get articles improved""" Deletion of Pottsylvania WP:IAR||WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
3194 9199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Extreme Circus User:Dennis 14:46, 16 April 2011 (UTC) comment I expected to do some searching and quickly conclude delete, but it wasn't so easy. It is a harder term to search because the phrase 'extreme circus' is used incidently in a lot of articles. A little more work gave me http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=mNokAAAAIBAJ&sjid=KRIGAAAAIBAJ&pg=1794,1990788 and others. The term is used extensively in news reports to describe a type of circus, so it appears to be a very valid and accepted term (whodathough). The question remains, however, if it is more than a , as I didn't find a lot on the concept of 'extreme circus', just a lot of valid usage and a couple of circuses that use that as part of their name (there is much I didn't search, so it may still exist). The current article, however, is wrong and the term wouldn't be credited in 2010, as it was in use before that. In it's current form, there really isn't anything of value (no sourcing, inaccurate info), so transwiki to wiktionary isn't really a choice. This might be a good candidate for a rescue, as the subject matter *might* be notable on its own, but would require a complete rewrite. Withholding !vote for now Deletion of Extreme Circus WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3195 9212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Australian Enemy (film) User:Ultraexactzz 15:10, 22 February 2010 (UTC) delete until additional sources become available to establish notability/existance. At best, applies, and the article is premature. No objection to userfication Deletion of Australian Enemy (film) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3196 21144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MySupermarket (3rd nomination) NONE NONE comment """on deletionist stretching of the locality criterion from (a section of ): most if not all of the media publishing the sources I considered above—including the majority that I disqualified on various grounds other than , as well as the four I accepted as legitimate—would in my judgment qualify as at least regional, not local. doesn't really define where """"local"""" ends and """"regional"""" begins, nor does the article section Newspaper#Local or regional to which it links. But as I understand those terms, the reach of television stations affiliated with major networks in the USA or the UK, in particular (even those with """"local"""" in their URLs, as in """"abclocal"""") is such that all of them would qualify as regional; this is especially clear for those that serve major metropolitan areas. Similarly, a major USA metropolitan newspaper like the ''The Philadelphia Inquirer|Philadelphia Inquirer'' or the ''The Boston Globe|Boston Globe'' would be regional, not local (and the ''The New York Times|New York Times'' and the ''The Wall Street Journal|Wall Street Journal'' would be national or even international""" Deletion of MySupermarket (3rd nomination) WP:AUD||WP:CORP||WP:AUD||WP:AUD Wikipedia:Notability 77
3197 5272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keyontyli Goffney (2nd nomination) User:Silver 21:49, 7 April 2010 (UTC) keep """I believe that he would meet 3 in , """"''starred in an iconic, groundbreaking or blockbuster feature''"""", since that's what it seems the video he and his brother starred in was. He would also meet 4, really, regardless of it being because of a single event""" Deletion of Keyontyli Goffney (2nd nomination) WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3198 13395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evelyn Keppel User:Clean 00:45, 13 June 2015 (UTC) keep Explicitly passes as the league she played in is listed there Deletion of Evelyn Keppel WP:NBASE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3199 16895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neil Hurst User:Kinu 05:52, 6 June 2008 (UTC) delete no indicating notability per , just a few mentions in some local/minor reviews of the shows he's been in, no substantial content about the individual himself Deletion of Neil Hurst WP:RS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3200 9355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DarkThrone (video game) User:Marasmusine 12:10, 30 November 2008 (UTC) delete under criteria #A7|A7 - web content with no indication of importance Deletion of DarkThrone (video game) WP:SPEEDY Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
3201 15416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Le Brocq User:1of3 15:28, 6 October 2007 (UTC) delete with extreme prejudice, as nom Deletion of David Le Brocq WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3202 15371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danny Anthrop User:James 17:33, 23 May 2019 (UTC) delete ping|Paulmcdonald}} Unfortunately I had no luck myself. I did a search online and couldn’t find any really good sources that would indicate notability, this person doesn’t pass or Deletion of Danny Anthrop WP:GNG||WP:GRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
3203 5888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Casus Belli (Jericho episode) User:Gtstricky 15:32, 30 November 2007 (UTC) delete changed from keep) per Deletion of Casus Belli (Jericho episode) WP:EPISODE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
3204 18828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/T.J. Hoban User:Colapeninsula 11:42, 18 February 2014 (UTC) delete No major roles in film or TV (occasional appearances or guest roles only, often with minimal speaking). Sources don't quite establish notability per : it's mainly directories, casting sites, etc Deletion of T.J. Hoban WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3205 17808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harriet Barber User:Vejvančický 18:47, 25 March 2010 (UTC) delete It seems there's very little information outside of blogs, social sites and self-published profiles. I found http://www.dorsetecho.co.uk/news/4477924.Artist_who_fought_breast_cancer_is_up_for_award/ an article published by a local newspaper Dorset Echo, and http://www.plushart.co.uk/previous/page3/page3.html a short mention at the website of a local gallery ''art@plush''. No independent and substantial reviews of her work, published by |reliable |third-party sources. In my opinion, the subject fails |notability criteria for artists and the |general notability guideline Deletion of Harriet Barber WP:RELIABLE||WP:3PARTY||WP:ARTIST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3206 15513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pro-war Left User:Pak21 11:27, 18 October 2007 (UTC) comment """I'm more than familiar with political debate in the UK; such |personal attacks won't help your case. I still hold that while this term is used by various bits of the media, there isn't actually a grouping of people here. How exactly would I know if someone is a member of this group? To go from the article, """"the Euston Manifesto is the closest the PWL has come to a statement of its principles."""" but also that """"the manifesto is ambivalent about supporting the invasion of Iraq"""", which seems to be rather contradictory. As to why a random magazine can define the term but Wikipedia can't, that's the difference between a comment magazine and an encyclopedia""" Deletion of Pro-war Left WP:NPA Wikipedia:No personal attacks 58
3207 5483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kings of Chaos (game) User:Kyaa 14:20, 26 January 2009 (UTC) keep per the spirit of . There appears to have been some reporting on this, but at this time it is rather weak and sporadic. There is no deadline though and this may be a notable game, but the article requires work Deletion of Kings of Chaos (game) WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
3208 2593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nat Gertler (2nd nomination) User:GentlemanGhost 11:52, 15 March 2014 (UTC) keep Again.) Bad faith nomination by a now-blocked sockpuppet. (Again.) But ignoring the problems with the nominator, Tomwsulcer has stated above how this article meets the notability requirement. If you want want to do away with making nominees notable, then you'll need to change . And this is not the place to do that Deletion of Nat Gertler (2nd nomination) WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3209 12422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan DeBono (politician) User:CASSIOPEIA 15:05, 23 July 2019 (UTC) delete Being in SEAL Team and non-elected candidate in politics, fails , and Deletion of Dan DeBono (politician) WP:NPOL||WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3210 15993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thu Riya [[User talk:65.18.124.241|talk]]) 13:39, 3 January 2019 (UTC) keep I did some clean up/improvement and Re-write anual of Style. He is a notable actor in Myanmar who has played lead and major featured roles in several Burmese films, and big screen movies easily passing . http://www.popularmyanmar.com/2017/04/24/%E1%80%B1%E1%80%85%E1%80%BA%E1%80%B8%E1%80%80%E1%80%BC%E1%80%80%E1%80%B9%E1%80%A1%E1%80%9B-%E1%80%81%E1%80%BA%E1%80%B3%E1%80%B6%E1%82%95%E1%82%90%E1%80%AF%E1%80%AD%E1%80%80%E1%80%B9%E1%80%80%E1%80%B0/ This press from local newspaper ''The Popular Journal'' gives further background.Special:Contributions/65.18.124.241|SuMyat Deletion of Thu Riya WP:M||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Mediation 96
3211 16383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leslie Jamison User:RightCowLeftCoast 02:00, 8 March 2011 (UTC) delete After reading the book might meet the first cirteria, however, the author definitely does not meet . If there is sufficient information from secondary or tertiary |reliable sources about the author to support her passing an article can always be |spunout Deletion of Leslie Jamison WP:NBOOK||WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:BIO||WP:SPINOUT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3212 17517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of American Catholics User:Praemonitus 02:02, 7 May 2013 (UTC) keep """The original deletion criteria was invalid, per . Per : """"Cross-categories like these are not considered sufficient basis to create an article, unless the intersection of those categories is in some way a culturally significant phenomenon"""". Catholicism in America is culturally significant, so does not apply. Hence, keep""" Deletion of List of American Catholics WP:OTHERSTUFF||WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3213 5519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Playlist Tv NONE NONE delete """Delete as hoax. Article has been copied and tweaked from VH1 India (where Viacom and Zee-Turner ''did'' cooperate ref the The Financial Express (India)|Financial Express source and http://www.televisionpost.com/television/vh1s-10-year-journey-in-india/). No indications of """"Playlist"""" or """"Play List"""" in an Indian tv channel context""" Deletion of Playlist Tv WP:G3 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
3214 19432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raj Gill User:ChunnuBhai 14:38, 16 September 2016 (UTC) delete Fails . Apart from a few press releases in Punjabi newspapers, that too giving out official party line, no coverage of the person herself Deletion of Raj Gill WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3215 5225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Barnes (Left Behind) User:Bearian 14:51, 9 September 2014 (UTC) merge as suggested, and per |the usual procedure when the notability of a fictional character is not clear Deletion of Bruce Barnes (Left Behind) WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3216 1155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diversity (Black Lives Matter Guiding Principle) User:EdChem 08:10, 26 April 2017 (UTC) delete The Black Lives Matter article has a simple list of the principles and could be augmented with reliably-sourced text on their meaning. With sufficient sources, it could become necessary to create a more specific article such as Guiding principles of the Black Lives Matter movement which could explore different perspectives from inside and outside the movement in line with usual considerations for due weight, reliability of sources, NPOV, etc, and to have a simple summary in the parent article. Unfortunately, the essays here are not the basis for such an article as the task set was inherently non-neutral. I feel sad for the student editors {{u|Burgesspfc}} and {{u|AngelicBeaver}} because they are stuck trying to explore meaning of principles from the movement's perspective (the task set) and when policy requires neutral coverage of perspectives in accord with their weight in sources. Some of the sources used would be useful for an article but the content is not. Essays for tertiary education often require synthesis of information, advocacy / arguing for a perspective, and original ideas and thought, and all of these are inconsistent with encyclopaedic writing. These essays are not the basis for acceptable articles, a |blank page would be an easier starting point. If the students want to persist, there is a notable topic here and there are editors who would help, but given this is an assignment and the semester is nearly over, I will not be surprised if this does not occur. It is a shame when instructor-set work on Wikipedia is incompatible with Wikipedia policy, as seems to be the case here, and the Education Program is already planning to look at this case and the Environmental Justice case over summer – so hopefully we will not see cases like this arise again Deletion of Diversity (Black Lives Matter Guiding Principle) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
3217 352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Economy Car Rentals User:AllyD 06:23, 24 May 2013 (UTC) delete This would be a suitable article for a business directory, but this is an encyclopaedia. Lack of |reliable 3rd party sources to demonstrate compliance with the criteria Deletion of Economy Car Rentals :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3218 8972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Visa requirements for Zimbabwean citizens User:Ansh666 18:38, 17 June 2013 (UTC) delete per nom ( Deletion of Visa requirements for Zimbabwean citizens WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3219 19914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Desperately Seeking Santa User:Donaldd23 10:44, 11 June 2021 (UTC) comment Two sources are all that is needed per , which doesn't have different rules for TV films. Also, the parent's guide (Common Sense Media) is listed as a Wikipedia Reliable Source, see Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Perennial_sources and their content is acceptable as a review Deletion of Desperately Seeking Santa WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
3220 10303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Culture (US band) User:Reconsider 11:58, 11 July 2010 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Culture (US band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3221 14035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rory McArdle User:Barno 19:32, 23 September 2005 (UTC) delete """but willing to be persuaded otherwise. How notable is under-19 """"international"""" football? Covered in major media like the FIFA World Cup, or ignored like an international spelling bee? After verifiability is satisfied, this will be at the edge of importance for living athletes. No indication that he would meet the criterion for non-living people after he dies. """"Any professional sportsman will be kept"""" is not policy and is not a standard practice here; it's just an opinion which some voters use as personal voting policy""" Deletion of Rory McArdle WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3222 9115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saringkarn Promsupa User:Fenix 09:02, 24 July 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Saringkarn Promsupa WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3223 21518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solar Electric Power Company User:Atmoz 16:02, 13 October 2010 (UTC) keep the number of , or lack thereof, does not make or break a subjects notability for inclusion in Wikipedia. Sources currently provided in the article are reliable, third-party publications about the company that demonstrate its notability Deletion of Solar Electric Power Company WP:GHITS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3224 9464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Meadows (California) User:Kungming2 00:48, 15 November 2006 (UTC) delete Doesn't seem to meet , and there's no verification of his claims to fame other than his own websites Deletion of Mark Meadows (California) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3225 778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Red gummy User:Nizolan 00:18, 21 March 2016 (UTC) delete """I assume https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/76454848/ this has something to do with it (though I can't find a corresponding """"Five Nights at Gummy Bears""""), so it's either a reference to a non-notable browser game or just . Plausibly the page could also be redirected to gummy bear, but it'd be a redirect of dubious usefulness. {{ec""" Deletion of Red gummy WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
3226 6666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luke Remington User:WWGB 02:31, 15 April 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Luke Remington WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3227 19385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SwaroopMM NONE NONE delete Fails . Wikipedia is not a place for |promotion Deletion of SwaroopMM WP:RS||WP:NOTPROMO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3228 19631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VC C23 Company User:Ammarpad 15:01, 29 October 2017 (UTC) delete fails and fails . Created seven years ago and still remain without even single unreliable source Deletion of VC C23 Company WP:MILUNIT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3229 2192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mail Bastard User:Zupreme 02:27, 2 August 2006 (UTC) delete fails , no , likely campaign by Deletion of Mail Bastard WP:WEB||WP:V||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
3230 10195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HypeVercab User:Andante1980 06:54, 31 August 2007 (UTC) delete I tagged this one for speedy once before, it was deleted right after that. No new information has come up. All external links are either promotional, blogs from the articles author or other quite likely NN references. Currently doesn't fall in line with , also fails as should be evident from the authors username and the blogs links referenced in the article Deletion of HypeVercab WP:MUSIC||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
3231 314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of lowest scoring games in the NFL User:Cbl62 02:59, 14 February 2020 (UTC) delete per . The list also appears to have been copied from http://mcubed.net/nfl/pttotlgm.shtml this site and be a possible Deletion of List of lowest scoring games in the NFL WP:LISTN||WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3232 6707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard M. Levitan User:David 05:48, 1 May 2020 (UTC) keep The citation record shows him to be a leading expert on emergency airway management, long before the coronavirus made this specialization extremely relevant. I think he passes #C1 Deletion of Richard M. Levitan WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3233 17755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ionuţ Caragea User:Tyrenon 14:31, 29 May 2009 (UTC) comment Why was this relisted? We've got one editor putting up a huge fight to defend an article that he wrote...and frankly making a mess of things in the process. I, for one, do not intend to change my vote; I honestly suspect a |conflict of interest here considering the amount of energy being put into the article and to the fight here by the author Deletion of Ionuţ Caragea WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
3234 2272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eaglexpress User:Northamerica1000 13:51, 28 September 2012 (UTC) keep The topic passes . Source examples include: http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2012/1/16/business/20120116160349&sec=business%3Cbr%20/%3E, http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2012/1/28/business/10554381&sec=business, http://www.thesundaily.my/news/279762, http://www.thesundaily.my/news/268198 Deletion of Eaglexpress WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3235 3753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JahSun User:Begoon 00:37, 6 February 2012 (UTC) delete Unless reliable sources establishing |notability are provided Deletion of JahSun WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3236 21908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TalkSwitch NONE NONE comment Fair enough, however I would state this article never met and likely should have been a candidate for in 2010 under section G11 when the article was not edited for {{tl|db-spam}}. Perhaps it would be better to relist for deletion under {{tl|db-g11}} however either way the article in my view is (a) unwanted by it's new publicly traded owners, (b) was never complete or acceptable and is in reality using Wikipedia as and should be deleted Deletion of TalkSwitch WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:SPEEDY||WP:SOAP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3237 915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexei Borodin User:Errabee 12:28, 16 November 2006 (UTC) keep Borodin is invited to speak at symposia all over the world, see http://www.math.ethz.ch/u/felder/Research/RandomMatrices, http://www.math.duke.edu/conferences/dmj04/, http://math.arizona.edu/~mcl/ISRMA.html and http://maths.leeds.ac.uk/~vadim/LMS_course.htm. Also look at the number of invited talks in his http://www.claymath.org/fas/research_fellows/Borodin/CV.pdf CV. I think this identifies Borodin as qualifying for criterion 2 Deletion of Alexei Borodin WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3238 9925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mundo Arts User:CNMall41 21:03, 24 January 2018 (UTC) delete Cannot locate anything to satisfy Deletion of Mundo Arts WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
3239 5240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Molecular economics User:Dpbsmith 13:35, 2 December 2005 (UTC) delete as |unverifiable unless far better evidence is provided prior to close of discussion. At the very least, we need an ISBN is given for the |single cited source and easily verifiable evidence that the book exists. Google books shows http://books.google.com/books?q=Subjectivist+Labornomics&btnG=Search+Books&hl=en no hits on Subjectivist Labornomics and no hits on http://books.google.com/books?q=%22Arthur+W.+Baron%22&btnG=Search+Books&hl=en Arthur W. Baron. If this were an important theory and book, it is almost certain that a 1999 book itself or references to it would show up in Google Books. The http://www.upne.com/bip_index_0002.html University Press of New England's complete author/title index shows a book by Mary Baron entitled ''Wheat among Bones'' and one by Barron, Jonathan N on Jewish American Poetry but nothing resembling the cited book. Looks, sounds, feels, tastes and smells like a transparent hoax; the onus is on the contributor to show othersize Deletion of Molecular economics WP:V||WP:CITE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3240 19963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pollo Tropical User:Glane23 18:00, 31 October 2017 (UTC) keep There are enough reliable sources for this regional chain of 140 restaurants, operating since 1988, to establish notability under both and . I have added some book sources and copyedited to prune out much of the puffery. More needs to be done, to be sure, but this article which has been with us in various forms since 2006, is worth saving Deletion of Pollo Tropical WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3241 8420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cherona User:Atlantic306 21:02, 7 November 2020 (UTC) keep as this reliable source https://www.allmusic.com/artist/cherona-mn0002013775/biography here shows that they have had an album chart in the top twenty of Germany's national chart, the top ten of Austria's national chart and the top thirty of Switzerland's national chart, so passing criteria 2. They have also released two albulms on major labels - Sony, and Columbia which meets another criteria of which strongly indicates they would have received significant reliable sources coverage particularly in German, imv Deletion of Cherona WP:NMUSIC||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3242 5109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Paulin User:Cameron11598 03:42, 4 November 2016 (UTC) delete Fails , and ACTOR Deletion of Scott Paulin WP:N||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3243 14440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shmuel Yerushalmi User:Gidonb 01:55, 19 February 2007 (UTC) delete Shmuel Yerushalmi publishes his poetry and essays in an open web forum and participates also in real life political activities. He is not notable by the Wikipedian standards set in and . But, as DGG correctly points out above, this may of course change in the future Deletion of Shmuel Yerushalmi WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3244 17083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hayden Keeling User:Seraphimblade 03:58, 10 December 2006 (UTC) delete as failing Deletion of Hayden Keeling WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3245 11525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aurum sulphuricum User:JJJ999 03:44, 26 September 2007 (UTC) delete Clearly fails , especially the ''reliable'' part. Of the impressive list of three references, two are repeats of each other and that reference is unintelligible. About a fourth of the article consists of a quote from the third reference, which makes nearly unintelligible claims. If there has been prior discussion of this article, I can't find it. The speedy delete was quickly converted within minutes to a prod by the same editor that added the speedy tag. The prod was removed by Deletion of Aurum sulphuricum WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3246 14922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siamak Taghaddos (2nd nomination) User:Bmbaker88 02:27, 19 October 2019 (UTC) keep I've identified three major sources that discuss Siamak Taghaddos, including CBS News https://www.cbsnews.com/news/how-to-rebrand-your-company-using-chocolate-covered-grasshoppers-homeland-security-and-guy-kawasaki/, USA Today https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2015/04/20/ozy-launching-business-on-former-employers-dime/26068295/, and Inc. (magazine)|Inc. https://www.inc.com/30under30/2011/index.html (see Deletion of Siamak Taghaddos (2nd nomination) WP:THREE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3247 6477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pour over User:Wmahan 02:42, 31 May 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Pour over WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3248 2407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gershon Wiesenfeld User:David 16:45, 21 January 2011 (UTC) comment """Your argument 1 is patently false. There is neither an implied requirement nor a presumption that someone be an expert on an article to edit. In fact this is stated right on the Wikipedia:Introduction|WP Intro Page, in , etc. In essence, nobody any particular article. Arguments 2, 3, and 5 build further upon the concept you are trying to push, attempt to discredit people who would apply WP policies, and basically plead the """"just give it more time"""" position. Argument 4 tries to shift the burden away from those who wrote the article from the responsibility of documenting it and to instead cast any skeptics as mean-spirited editors who don't care. I'll not have it and here's why. Invariably, these articles have no because there ''is'' no out there to be had. To """"just give it more time"""" is to stall. Take the Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tzvi Berkowitz|Berkowitz article again as an example. It ''still'' has no reliable sources that demonstrate notability, despite the fact that I raised this issue last May and even took it to AfD! This is predictably when the special pleading|pleading starts regarding how regular policies shouldn't apply in this case. The AfD archive is ''full'' of instances like this. I'm afraid what this boils down to is no , no article. I think again that our dear colleague""" Deletion of Gershon Wiesenfeld WP:BOLD||WP:OWNS||WP:OWNERSHIP||WP:RS||WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Be bold 9
3249 3049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/March 0 User:Timtrent 23:24, 28 December 2009 (UTC) delete I don't see that being mentioned in a spreadsheet program has any encyclopaedic merit in terms of Deletion of March 0 WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3250 1710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/InfoTrac User:MichaelQSchmidt 08:50, 15 May 2016 (UTC) keep per an errant deletion rational that does not argue non-notability, but simply complains that a |sourced article is unsourced. Addition sources are spoken of in detail on the Talk:InfoTrac|article's talk page and a little is encouraged before judgments Deletion of InfoTrac WP:UGLY||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3251 15308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/L'Atelier aux Couleurs User:RightCowLeftCoast 07:24, 25 August 2012 (UTC) delete Fails ''significant coverage'' as required by Deletion of L'Atelier aux Couleurs WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3252 12716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sino Japanese Wars and Conflicts User:Yunshui 13:47, 17 September 2011 (UTC) delete The article's in a horrible state, but that's not in itself a reason for deletion. I'd argue that the topic is definitely notable. However, virtually all the potential content could find an equally good home at Sino-Japanese relations, which already has sections on all major conflicts between the two nations. Hence, no need for this possibly |coat-rack article Deletion of Sino Japanese Wars and Conflicts WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
3253 9110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert H. Bolton User:GPL93 15:56, 21 February 2020 (UTC) delete Like most Hathorn articles, the sourcing does not suggest that he is |anything more than a local businessman active in his community. I don't really think any of the Bolton family members he created articles on pass notability standards. Best Deletion of Robert H. Bolton WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
3254 12 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ahmet Demir (bürokrat) Kullanıcı:nanahuatlnanahuatl 21.18, 28 Ocak 2020 (UTC) keep """Denizli valiliği de yapmış, sayfasındaki kriterlere göre kayda değer. İsim benzerliği olabilir diye gazete arşivlerini de karıştırdım, """"eski Denizli valisi EGM oldu"""" haberine denk gelince aynı kişi olduklarını anlayarak maddeye kaynaklı bir şekilde ekleme yaptım""" Ahmet Demir (bürokrat) silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
3255 14155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dear Jayne (3rd nomination) User:Chubbles 00:30, 16 September 2012 (UTC) keep This seems to be a rehash of the 2nd nomination, also by Lil-Unique1. The band's charting single qualifies it according to bullet 2, which hurdles the notability requirement, regardless of Deletion of Dear Jayne (3rd nomination) WP:MUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3256 2102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Fisherman's Granddaughter User:Whiteguru 11:59, 19 September 2020 (UTC) keep as per above, it is important to have some examples of silent films. Historicity and the research given here satisfies Deletion of The Fisherman's Granddaughter WP:NFSOURCES Wikipedia:Notability 77
3257 12629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert James Ley User:Useight 08:28, 17 July 2007 (UTC) delete as hoax, nonsense, fails , and Deletion of Robert James Ley WP:NOTE||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3258 112 [[Steckstuhl]] war [[Afrikanischer Stuhl]] (BNR) Benutzer:Phi NONE delete Solange der Artikel keinen einzigen Beleg für die dort aufgestellten Angaben enthält, darf gemäß #Grundsätze jeder einzelne Satz jederzeit entfernt werden. Soll ich mal? Daher bitte zeitnah nachbelegen, oder eben Löschung von Afrikanischer Stuhl Wikipedia:Q Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3259 20230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Alhaje User:BigHaz 10:26, 4 February 2018 (UTC) delete """While Alhaje has a significant role in """"Here Come the Habibs"""", his other roles don't appear to get over the line of """"significance"""" per NACTOR's criteria (I agree with Kb.au's assessment that GNG isn't met either). """"Rake"""" is indeed a notable series, but the role he's played seems not to be listed on the ABC's own website for the show or even on IMDB (which customarily lists everyone whose name can be verified, regardless of role). His other recurring roles may eventually lead to fame, but |they haven't yet. Instagram followers in and of themselves don't amount to a claim to notability, and neither does """"attending red carpets"""" in an industry where most people would happily attend the opening of the proverbial envelope (a """"reputation for bringing the fun to the carpet"""" ''may'' count for something if there's the relevant level of coverage for that, but I'm not seeing it). Even his appearance on the Today Show here in Australia means less than you might think, given that the commercial networks use those breakfast programs as an opportunity for cross-promotion""" Deletion of Sam Alhaje WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3260 545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hantamaru Ririku User:ColourBurst 14:22, 28 August 2006 (UTC) delete fan fan anity fan. Oh yeah, extremely overpowered as well Deletion of Hantamaru Ririku WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3261 16519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael's Music Service User:Kinu 15:28, 1 August 2006 (UTC) delete the use of first person pronouns leads me to believe it's for a company that fails anyway Deletion of Michael's Music Service WP:SPAM||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Spam 112
3262 77 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Great Southern Wood User:AllyD 05:47, 8 September 2020 (UTC) delete I added a short Birmingham Business Journal notice as a reference but I don't see that or anything else found in searches as sufficient to demonstrate |notability here Deletion of Great Southern Wood :WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3263 8591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darrell Scott (American football) User:Oren0 11:18, 14 December 2008 (UTC) keep Regardless of , how can you deny that the 12 sources in the article are more than enough to meet Deletion of Darrell Scott (American football) WP:ATHLETE||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3264 14908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/With a Bullet User:doomsdayer520 17:47, 16 August 2021 (UTC) merge to Harry Nilsson#1980–1992: Winding down. The nominator and I have both done some work on this article because the primary editor was unfamiliar with the templates and other matters. I was indifferent to notability at the time, but upon further reflection I don't think the song and its story have made it into the |significant and reliable media as required for a stand-alone WP article. While the song was Nilsson's statement on the murder of his longtime friend John Lennon, and it is fairly legendary in the fan community, the rest of world (especially reliable music journalists) just hasn't really noticed. The episode can be mentioned briefly at Nilsson's article, and already is Deletion of With a Bullet WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
3265 5512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myra Nicholson User:Newshunter12 23:42, 18 November 2018 (UTC) delete """This article fails and because there is only sparse local coverage of her that fails to demonstrate notability and there is no notability guideline that the """"oldest X"""" is notable. The content of the article is routine trivia fancruft. She lived. She avoided the Reaper longer then most. She died. Pure . Her age, life dates, and nationality are already recorded on the List of supercentenarians by continent, where they are easier to view, so this permanent is not needed""" Deletion of Myra Nicholson WP:GNG||WP:BIO1E||WP:ROUTINE||WP:NOPAGE||WP:PERMASTUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3266 4652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indefinite logarithm User:D 00:51, 26 July 2012 (UTC) delete """For above reasons. Moreover the notion intends to formalize the notion of """"logarithm up to a multiplicative constant"""" but fails to give a workable definition. Thus, this is not only but also """ Deletion of Indefinite logarithm WP:OR||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:No original research 65
3267 19821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josef Allerberger User:Hydronium 07:19, 28 March 2016 (UTC) keep though a slightly uncomfortable one: He's the second-most successful (recorded) German sniper of WW2 (behind Matthäus Hetzenauer) with 257 confirmed kills, and according to John Plaster in ''https://books.google.com.au/books?id=qIHKAwAAQBAJ History of Sniping and Sharpshooting'', has the only first-person account of a WWII German sniper. The original German language version was apparently significantly longer (and used pseudonym Franz Karner). Interviewed in 1967 in Austrian military journal :de:Truppendienst_(Zeitschrift)|Truppendienst per https://books.google.com.au/books?id=8g_PBQAAQBAJ&pg=PT87 this - (?partially?) http://forum.axishistory.com/viewtopic.php?t=10324 transcribed here. Referenced in multiple books, eg https://books.google.com.au/books?id=4LZGCgAAQBAJ&pg=PT114 Shooter's Bible Guide to Tactical Firearms, https://books.google.com.au/books?id=8g_PBQAAQBAJ Sniper in Action, https://books.google.com.au/books?id=-mkh931pIugC Out of Nowhere: A History of the Military Sniper. The discomfort arises from so much of the sourcing ultimately coming back to Wacker, which is rather , and it being unlikely that there are many better, more-reliable sources Deletion of Josef Allerberger WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
3268 20249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danny Ward (footballer, born 1993) (2nd nomination) User:IJA 20:40, 17 February 2015 (UTC) delete Fails as he hasn't played in a Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|Fully Professional League and doesn't have any international caps Deletion of Danny Ward (footballer, born 1993) (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3269 11314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harold Reeves User:Annette46 16:39, 11 January 2010 (UTC) delete Doesn't cross the notability bar, nothing in the article itself to establish enduring notability. a memorial website Deletion of Harold Reeves WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3270 16055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ewa Sonnet [[User_talk:Kwh|KWH]]'' 03:44, 28 February 2006 (UTC) keep """she has a http://www.abum.com/show/12085/sexy_ewa_sonnet_music_video.html music video. It is hard for USians/UKians to judge some criteria at but per http://jop.pl/ewa-sonnet.html this page she has been interviewed on """"best known and most popular :pl:Kuba Wojewodzki|Kuba Wojewodzki Show. It's gonna be seen by over 4 million people o next sunday at 10:25 pm of Polish time at the biggest Warsaw private TV station"""" which would seem to come close to """"Has been the subject of a half hour or hour broadcast on a national radio TV? network""" Deletion of Ewa Sonnet WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3271 18300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neko Atsume User:Hisashiyarouin 10:56, 4 July 2015 (UTC) keep but strong before anything for the horrid machine-translation-like prose. The app attracted some attention from Japanese press as a fad sort of like Flappy Bird did. '''野狼院ひさし Deletion of Neko Atsume WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
3272 17993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lenin's Tomb (blog) User:Jayden54 16:31, 26 December 2006 (UTC) delete completely fails . It doesn't even have its own domain, and uses blogspot Deletion of Lenin's Tomb (blog) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3273 899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RaShawn McAllister User:Gene93k 10:37, 17 July 2008 (UTC) delete Fails per nom. RS coverage is of a routine nature (game coverage and team roster changes Deletion of RaShawn McAllister WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3274 15761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eon8 (2nd nomination) User:Tromboneguy0186 01:32, 2 July 2006 (UTC) delete Part of me thinks the phenomenon makes it notable, but the other part of me has read Deletion of Eon8 (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3275 13532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indonesia at the 2020 Summer Olympics User:Ajf773 05:20, 2 September 2018 (UTC) merge to 2020 Summer Olympics. but will eventually become an article Deletion of Indonesia at the 2020 Summer Olympics WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3276 15327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NK Trogir 1912 User:Sir 16:49, 28 February 2013 (UTC) delete This club clearly fails the |general notability guideline. No prejudice to redirecting to HNK Trogir if a connection between the two clubs can be reliably sourced. However, at present, there is no indication beyond the text of the article that such a connection exists Deletion of NK Trogir 1912 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3277 1508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chanel Santini User:Levivich 04:05, 5 June 2019 (UTC) delete per , because the article subject doesn't meet . The NYTimes piece is significant coverage of the website, not of Santini. The Houston local news piece – it's terrible what happened to her – but it's not significant coverage of her as an entertainer. It's a story about her being a victim of harassment and discrimination; it only briefly mentions what she does for a living. I'm not seeing anything in the article or finding anything online that approachers significant coverage to meet BASIC. Xbiz is a major adult industry award but so what? Awards don't establish notability for entertainers Deletion of Chanel Santini WP:NOTADIRECTORY||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3278 8692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/High Rock User:Falcon9x5 17:42, 5 December 2007 (UTC) delete per , , etc Deletion of High Rock WP:N||WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3279 16094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dalan Edwin Decker User:Starblind 19:13, 5 November 2007 (UTC) delete """per """"Writer"""" with an upcoming vanity-press book""" Deletion of Dalan Edwin Decker WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3280 21038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven John Glass user:Bakerstmd 17:42, 12 February 2015 (UTC) delete Agree, doesn't meet as the only refs are the website for the pharma company he runs and a press release from that company Deletion of Steven John Glass WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3281 10488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stereotype inevitability User:Grrrlriot 02:57, 21 July 2008 (UTC) delete This article is definitely , , and . Mandsford is right and I think it is Deletion of Stereotype inevitability WP:OR||WP:SOAP||WP:ESSAY||WP:COPYVIO||WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:No original research 65
3282 2690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anything but Khamosh User:Kudpung 06:30, 26 October 2016 (UTC) delete and redirect to author page (whoever that is). Clearly fails Deletion of Anything but Khamosh WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
3283 16004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Selfo User:Lifebaka 02:58, 11 January 2008 (UTC) delete My http://www.google.com/search?source=ig&hl=en&rlz=&q=Selfo+game&btnG=Google+Search Gsearch didn't hit anything remotely related to a game named Selfo, so it appears to fail and therefore also . No idea if it's a hoax Deletion of Selfo WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3284 120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seven Kingdoms (band) User:JohnCD 23:00, 10 March 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. - fails Deletion of Seven Kingdoms (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
3285 18872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jane P. Gray User:Bearcat 18:12, 14 April 2019 (UTC) delete A pass requires a ''state-level'' judgeship, not a district court at the county level, so there's no automatic free pass of our notability standards for judges in the absence of enough |reliable source coverage to get her over in lieu Deletion of Jane P. Gray WP:JUDGE||WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3286 14875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Kamin User:Cullen328 05:15, 11 May 2011 (UTC) keep """There are a lot of people named """"Ben Kamin"""" but simply adding the word """"rabbi"""" to the Google News Archive search disambiguates and weeds out the false positives. The result is extensive coverage of ''this'' Ben Kamin in |reliable sources, including an Ann Landers column just as the article asserts and the nominator was unable to find""" Deletion of Ben Kamin WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3287 12161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eddie Rosenstein User:LACaliNYC 22:40, 10 June 2018 (UTC) delete Obviously, fails the and Deletion of Eddie Rosenstein WP:GNG||WP:FILMMAKER Wikipedia:Notability 77
3288 19358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jean moukarzel User:Whiteguru 13:19, 8 May 2011 (UTC) delete Absolutely no references, even changing the search terms to'' Maronite Lebanese Catholic Youth'','' Maronite Youth in Lebanon'', all sorts of combinations of this. I had considered if the article was a possible contender for , but it will really need to start from scratch again Deletion of Jean moukarzel WP:USERFY Wikipedia:Userfication 87
3289 11043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bedo Brwynllys User:RebeccaGreen 13:28, 31 August 2019 (UTC) keep """He meets #3 """"The person has an entry in the Dictionary of National Biography or similar publication""" Deletion of Bedo Brwynllys WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3290 4303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twisted Attitude (truck) User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable. Wow, I didn't realize we had :Category:Monster trucks|so much about monster trucks. I guess it's a fan area like any other. &mdash Deletion of Twisted Attitude (truck) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3291 10094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seth Mullin User:Atlantic306 17:26, 28 March 2018 (UTC) delete both as its for the band as they haven't released an album yet so its definitely too early for the band members to have standalone articles Deletion of Seth Mullin WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3292 10511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeNique Ford User:Cbl62 19:05, 19 September 2014 (UTC) delete Not finding sufficient coverage in independent, reliable sources to satisfy GNG. Also, playing on a practice squad in the Arena Football League doesn't satisfy the standards of Deletion of DeNique Ford WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
3293 2645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/What is Knowledge Management User:VasileGaburici 20:44, 8 November 2008 (UTC) delete and salt. Clearly a being recreated, and the title looks intended for google bombing Deletion of What is Knowledge Management WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
3294 19618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bank Transfer Day User:Tkynerd 21:39, 21 October 2011 (UTC) keep per Fayerman. At this point I believe notability is established, and the article clearly does not violate Deletion of Bank Transfer Day WP:SOAPBOX Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3295 14197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Arsenal red cards under Arsène Wenger User:Bejnar 03:38, 21 September 2015 (UTC) delete it is not being recommened for deletion for lack of references, it is being deleted for Deletion of List of Arsenal red cards under Arsène Wenger WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3296 7239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Albania national football team World Cup and European Championship squads User:FkpCascais 01:41, 2 December 2016 (UTC) delete besides everythiing already said, the list title and way article is created sugest more squads will be added to the list in future, which will happend only if Albania qualifies again, however clearly forbids this kind of predictions Deletion of List of Albania national football team World Cup and European Championship squads WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3297 14947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B.G. Knocc Out (2nd nomination) User:Walter 21:56, 13 November 2018 (UTC) keep Did nominator do or just check the current state of the article? A quick set of Google-assisted searches reveals https://hiphopdx.com/news/id.16485/title.b-g-knocc-out-alleges-eazy-e-was-murdered-recalls-showdown-with-nate-dogghttps://www.ballerstatus.com/2015/09/22/b-g-knocc-out-recalls-nearly-fighting-suge-knight-with-eazy-e/https://www.ballerstatus.com/2015/10/27/b-g-knocc-out-recalls-golf-course-brawl-with-nate-dogg/http://www.vh1.com/news/210531/bg-knocc-out-suge-knight-eazye-vladtv-interview/https://www.bet.com/news/music/2011/08/18/eazy-e-associate-claims-he-was-murdered.html and a bit at https://www.billboard.com/music/bg-knocc-out-dresta and https://www.allmusic.com/artist/bg-knocc-out-dresta-mn0000762960. Yes, there's a bit of , but there's enough to think that the article can be expanded Deletion of B.G. Knocc Out (2nd nomination) :WP:BEFORE||:WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3298 5383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven M. Greer User:SheffieldSteel 21:24, 2 June 2008 (UTC) delete I'm tempted to suggest BLP1E applies, but the subject might not agree with me, so I'll stick with the basics. This person is not |notable enough for an encyclopaedic article to be written, in that multiple non-trivial mentions in independent |reliable sources have not been provided to satisfy our |verifiability policy. The sources that are present are mainly self-published and/or faith-based (to whatever extent). The archived OMNI piece is the best source provided, but even that provides essentially no biographical information. There really is very little salvageable material in the article as written Deletion of Steven M. Greer WP:N||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
3299 6710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walker Films - ASL User:Czar 14:23, 17 May 2014 (UTC) delete A7. Article does not credibly indicate the significance of the company. Additionally, it doesn't pass the |GNG by a search engine test (no reliable, secondary coverage) and was written by a username with an apparent Wikipedia:Conflict of interest|COI. czar Deletion of Walker Films - ASL WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3300 12973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adams Crossroads, Delaware User:Edison 23:40, 19 August 2013 (UTC) delete """Saying """"Wikipedia is a gazetteer"""" does not magically make every barren place where roads intersect a """"community"""" or an """"inhabited place"""" which needs to have an entry in encyclopedias. Having some anonymous person create a GNIS entry based on unknown references or standards does not confer some inherent notability on a mere intersection of latitude and longitude. Fails """ Deletion of Adams Crossroads, Delaware WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3301 13592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Blue Ruin User:Pharaoh 15:42, 15 October 2014 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of The Blue Ruin WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
3302 3384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicoye Banks User:Glenfarclas 19:23, 13 December 2009 (UTC) delete """Most of the information I can find is obvious PR puff, e.g. claiming he """"co-starred"""" in things where he had a minor role. And IMDb doesn't show that he was ever in One Life to Live. Also, he tweets in block capitals; that's never a plus. Seriously though, he may make it big in the future, but so far he hasn't had the """"significant roles"""" or """"large fan base"""" we're |looking for""" Deletion of Nicoye Banks WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3303 5072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Adams (judge) NONE NONE delete """The nomination states the reason is . It is not optional. None of the keep votes address the fact that Adams is known for one event (and the """"If the event is significant..."""" test hasn't been even discussed above by keep voters). I'll add some text from BL1PE here to guide editors who want to argue that it does not apply to William Adams""" Deletion of William Adams (judge) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3304 8840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mathew Craig User:Joe 23:30, 27 September 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |person Deletion of Mathew Craig WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3305 3210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TorrentUs User:onel5969 02:22, 3 November 2015 (UTC) delete as per nom and above editors. Searches did not turn up anything to show the article passes Deletion of TorrentUs WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3306 2060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hermione Corfield User:Bearian 00:45, 24 March 2015 (UTC) delete or ''userfy'' per Deletion of Hermione Corfield WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3307 8058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WazirX User:The9Man 13:10, 17 August 2021 (UTC) comment There is not even a single sentence in the article which is not referenced with . Regarding , read , especially the last paragraph. Even if it lacks that needs editing not deletion. This company is in the news recently for both good and negative reasons. Anybody can add more information if they wish. I expected issues when created this article because it was deleted earlier, but I chose to be . Since this nomination is based on 'assuming bad faith' and not on notability, I don't have anything else to add. Leaving to others Deletion of WazirX WP:RS||WP:NPOV||WP:POVDELETION||WP:NPOV||WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3308 17677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nighthawks in popular culture (2nd nomination) User:Bulldog123 02:07, 8 July 2007 (UTC) comment """In my experience, users who remind others to be civil are the worst violators of Wikipedia policy."""" Kind of have to agree with Jay there. Those are usually back-handed |personal attacks in disguise anyway. Anyone who makes """"Please read _____"""" suggestions usually fits the bill too""" Deletion of Nighthawks in popular culture (2nd nomination) WP:NPA Wikipedia:No personal attacks 58
3309 7919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susanne Winter User:Armbrust 14:37, 5 September 2010 (UTC) delete as she is |only notable for one event Deletion of Susanne Winter WP:ONEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3310 20618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Wretched User:Caknuck 05:30, 8 November 2006 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of The Wretched WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3311 14601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Race and intelligence (4th nomination) User:Schazjmd 17:47, 6 February 2020 (UTC) delete """After reading all of the comments and comparing this article to History of the race and intelligence controversy, there is clearly excessive overlap between the two articles () and I agree that the """"history"""" article provides better coverage of the subject""" Deletion of Race and intelligence (4th nomination) WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
3312 5569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luke (2009 film) User:Joe 21:32, 3 December 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |film Deletion of Luke (2009 film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3313 1546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Essex bus route 804 (2nd nomination) User:Colonel 09:39, 14 February 2009 (UTC) keep Inherently notable. Better alternatives to deletion need consideration per , e.g. merger to List of bus routes in Essex Deletion of Essex bus route 804 (2nd nomination) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3314 416 [[Liste der bekannten Sozialen Netzwerke]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:AT NONE delete Eine Liste ohne Definition und Grenzen, siehe (u.a. keine Datenbank). In dieser Form Löschung von Liste der bekannten Sozialen Netzwerke Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3315 12802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marupaka User:Belovedfreak 18:32, 22 April 2008 (UTC) delete doesn't pass |notability guidelines Deletion of Marupaka WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3316 3276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of sex symbols (4th nomination) User:Postdlf 21:56, 22 June 2020 (UTC) keep per Cunard. The sources available and cited in the article show how well many entries can not only be verified but contextualized in cultural history. The nominator and deletion !votes too easily disregard that and are either coming from (as with the nominator's quite obvious contempt) or (as with Staszek Lem's slippery slope fear that this would somehow explode to include the entire porn industry Deletion of List of sex symbols (4th nomination) WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:SUSCEPTIBLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3317 7126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bang Bang Bang (Selena Gomez & The Scene song) User:SummerPhD 14:09, 11 June 2011 (UTC) comment """Hair"""" Hair_(Lady_Gaga_song)#Chart_performance|has charted. """"Bang Bang Bang"""" http://www.billboard.com/#/artist/Selena+Gomez+%26+The+Scene/chart-history/1011432?f=379&g=Singles has not charted """"on ''Billboard''"""", as far as I can see (iTunes charts are |not meaningful). If it has charted, please add it to the article""" Deletion of Bang Bang Bang (Selena Gomez & The Scene song) WP:BADCHARTS Wikipedia:Record charts 13
3318 10520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Marshner User:Jovanmilic97 16:01, 18 May 2019 (UTC) merge """to Connaught Marshner as a where he is mentioned (and can be expanded to reflect on his work) per which is a policy. Seems that his book Cultural Conservatism: A New National Agenda could be notable per because it was reviewed in notable publications. But that does not make him notable because |notability is not inherited, and he would be only known for |one event (co-creating one notable book). argument can be made, but I don't see that the book itself is mentioned widely as """"significant"""" (and cannot be verified as such per another policy at even if arguments stands) or that it recieved awards and """"won significant critical attention"""". If an article about the book was made, I would propose redirecting to that article, but since it was not, this will suffice""" Deletion of William Marshner WP:ATD||WP:PRESERVE||WP:NBOOK||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:BLP1E||WP:AUTHOR||WP:V||WP:OFFLINE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3319 10216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Great Game User:Majoreditor 17:49, 12 November 2007 (UTC) delete This is a poorly-written article with POV issues and potential violations of . It may be possible to salvage with either a re-write or a combination re-write and re-list as New Great Game (book Deletion of New Great Game WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
3320 15847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William M. Johnson User:AustralianRupert 05:37, 15 August 2009 (UTC) delete Based on precedent. Clearly a career soldier deserving respect, however, the last time a Command Sgt Major article was up for deletion, the concensus was to delete (even though I voted keep that time). This individual has basically the same awards and very similar service history, and even less sourcing than the other article (other one had a couple of mentions from books about the Vietnam War). Indeed we consistently hold that recipients of the Silver Star are not notable based on that fact alone, and that award is higher than the Bronze Star that this subject has received. While I feel that the notability guidelines seem a bit inconsistent across Wikipedia as a whole (e.g. from what I can see reading other AFD debates, certain types of 'actors' for want of a better term seem to be notable just for receiving awards for taking their clothes off and doing other things...the bar, however, seems a lot higher for a military person), I feel that it is important to be consistent. Also, independent sourcing is not there, so it does not meet requirements for Deletion of William M. Johnson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3321 21473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonah Manzano User:CruzRamiss2002 15:28, 26 February 2021 (UTC) delete per nom, did not meet both and otherwise not notable Deletion of Jonah Manzano WP:MUSICBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3322 8139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/411 SOLUTIONS International User:Starblind 20:24, 1 October 2010 (UTC) delete """borderline speedy. Fails badly. The """"IBM business partner"""" program that Allison is so proud of isn't anything special, the exact requirements for it are found http://www-2000.ibm.com/partnerworld/pwhome.nsf/weblook/pub_mem_level_point_na.html here""" Deletion of 411 SOLUTIONS International WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3323 8479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Jeff Dunham puppets User:Sgeureka 09:08, 15 December 2008 (UTC) merge """to Jeff Dunham per and no independent notability. 3,793 + 5,220 bytes is way below the recommended """"May need to be divided"""" 30 KB level. &ndash""" Deletion of List of Jeff Dunham puppets WP:SIZE Wikipedia:Article size 51
3324 7817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earliest documented people User:JFlav 02:51, 19 February 2008 (UTC) delete """I don't agree with the nom's reasoning; even if a candidate for inclusion on the list is disputed, all that is needed is a reputable source and a discussion in the article of controversy. That in itself doesn't mean the article should be deleted. However, as of now it doesn't seem any sources do exist to provide the information this article seeks to provide: namely who are the """"earliest documented people."""" As such, any attempt to synthesize existing articles would seem to break """ Deletion of Earliest documented people WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3325 840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelly Rowland's third studio album User:Esradekan 02:34, 30 July 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability per , #Albums & Deletion of Kelly Rowland's third studio album WP:HAMMER||WP:MUSIC||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
3326 18102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Votes for deletion (2nd nomination) User:Cyde 01:13, 22 July 2006 (UTC) delete any way you look at it these are going to be either |self-references or cross-namespace redirects, neither of which are acceptable Deletion of Votes for deletion (2nd nomination) WP:ASR Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
3327 20685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rezarta Smaja User:Spiderone 13:07, 20 February 2021 (UTC) keep passes due to being runner-up at Kënga Magjike Deletion of Rezarta Smaja WP:NMUSICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
3328 11008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derrick E Grayson User:C 16:55, 27 May 2013 (UTC) delete due to failure to provide multiple |reliable sources that show Grayson is notable beyond his intent to run for Senate. The general rule is that running for office does not make one inherently notable: the subject should either be notable before the run for office, or they should receive so much coverage that they meet as a result of the coverage of their run. There is only one secondary source, a ''Creative Loafing'' article, that mentions Grayson's Senate run. There are no secondary sources that demonstrate his notability outside of his candidacy. (The ''Washington Post'' article cited does not mention Grayson at all; it mentions attacks on another politician but makes no mention of Grayson's role in that Deletion of Derrick E Grayson WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3329 3 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Bu Dinciler O Müslümanlara Benzemiyor Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 18.41, 21 Kasım 2018 (UTC) merge Kitap, yazarının sahibi olduğu Oda TV'de sık sık bahsedilmiş; ancak gerekçede de dendiği gibi |bağımsız bir kaynak değil. Yazarının maddesine aktarılabilir Bu Dinciler O Müslümanlara Benzemiyor'un silinmesi Vikipedi:Bağımsız kaynaklar Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3330 21022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Huggle [[User talk:Sir Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington|'''Nearly Headless Nick''']] 10:53, 7 January 2007 (UTC) delete fails , a dictionary, |unsourced, |original research, |no independent and reliable sources. Burn it. &mdash Deletion of Huggle WP:NEO||WP:NOT||WP:V||WP:NOR||WP:RS Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3331 19841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faith and Friends Radio User:Bearcat 21:37, 7 December 2016 (UTC) delete While an internet radio station can qualify for a Wikipedia article ''if'' it can be sourced over , it does ''not'' get an automatic presumption of notability under just for existing. But there's no RS coverage shown here at all, and none out there with which this can be salvaged Deletion of Faith and Friends Radio WP:GNG||WP:NMEDIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
3332 8754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yassin Fortune User:Hmlarson 02:40, 7 July 2016 (UTC) keep """included citations and a google news search indicate the article meets and , which trumps the """"sport-specific notability guideline""" Deletion of Yassin Fortune WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3333 6035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SableVM User:1292simon 01:49, 15 December 2012 (UTC) keep Topic is notable, but article desperately needs a rewrite so that non-geeks can understand it and to wind back the Deletion of SableVM WP:PEACOCK Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
3334 18178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Essex bus route H1 User:Dfadden 12:31, 7 January 2015 (UTC) keep I was leaning towards delete as I can't see anything particularly notable about this now cancelled route - it is certainly verifiable, but that alone does not make it notable. However, I stopped short of arguing for deletion, as regional and metropolitan rail and light rail routes are almost always notable, therefore why not major bus routes? My only concern is with , as there are literally thousands of bus routes in cities all over the world. The article really should be improved to demonstrate why this one was significant, as opposed to say the ACTION No. 56 bus that stops outside my house linking Canberra City with Belconnen via Gungahlin (a catchment area of close to 200,000 which I would not expect to withstand a deletion debate if I was to create an article Deletion of Essex bus route H1 WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3335 21188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Dunn (California) User:JimMillerJr 17:11, 4 December 2010 (UTC) keep a former member of a state legislature. And the nom should read instead of using language that seems to demand that other people do the work Deletion of Joe Dunn (California) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3336 8847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leigh Holbrook User:Peter 16:59, 7 December 2020 (UTC) keep It's better to have a complete set of articles here for than maintain a complete set on another site and a separate incomplete set here. Subject-specific guidelines are more important than as a reason to delete an article, there's no reason to say they shouldn't be as a reason to keep an article Deletion of Leigh Holbrook WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3337 11971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Societism User:M3taphysical 02:18, 12 October 2010 (UTC) delete """This article has some serious |OR issues. Whoever wrote this article clearly sought to """"make up"""" his own definition of the term. All sorts of information were simply gathered and pieced together in order to give an appearance of legitimacy to the author's agenda; yet anyone vaguely familiar with philosophy and logic will notice that it is full of ''Non sequitur (logic)|non sequitur'' fallacies""" Deletion of Societism WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3338 4004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FL-802nd AFJROTC User:Kinu 02:18, 1 May 2007 (UTC) delete per , individual JROTC units are, unless otherwise sourceable, non-notable outside of the scope of the parent organization and/or the school at which they are based. I believe there's precedent here, so if anyone can find some of the other AfDs for these, that would help Deletion of FL-802nd AFJROTC WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3339 15865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harald Baldr User:Þjarkur 09:38, 24 April 2020 (UTC) delete """he does have a little bit of coverage in independant sources for a viral video (""""You won't believe why this man paid $400 for a haircut in India"""") and a couple of mentions in Italian sources for video on tourist scams in Italy https://www.quinewsfirenze.it/i-peggiori-truffatori-a-firenze-esplode-il-caso.htm, but it's not quite sufficient yet for """ Deletion of Harald Baldr WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3340 3076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of short place names User:Fram 08:34, 12 January 2010 (UTC) delete Where are the sources about these short place names? The one Colonel Warden supplies certainly doesn't pass any interpretation of . The fact that some sources consider very short place names (or very long ones) as unusual is already mentioned in Place names considered unusual, where more info can be included. But this is insufficient to have a separate list for subjects which share only a minor, inconsequential characteristic (the length of the placename has no relation to the actual village, apart from those one or two extremely long ones luring tourists by that ''amusing'' characteristic Deletion of List of short place names WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3341 20628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional spoiled brats (2nd nomination) User:Deor 16:29, 2 March 2008 (UTC) delete as irredeemable and POV. Personally, I think there's a difference between a plain brat and a spoiled brat, but whoever's been contributing to this article clearly doesn't. Some of the entries would be extremely difficult to justify as brats at all, by any definition Deletion of List of fictional spoiled brats (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3342 20503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bitglass User:K 02:28, 15 January 2017 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Bitglass WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3343 17120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Association (ecology) User:Stuartyeates 22:24, 28 September 2012 (UTC) delete as per and friends Deletion of Association (ecology) WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3344 20678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucía Parker User:STATicVapor 04:50, 12 February 2014 (UTC) delete Subject fails Deletion of Lucía Parker WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3345 3757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laura-Ioana Andrei User:Tvx1 21:21, 31 July 2017 (UTC) delete The tennis project is extremely inclusive, so if a subject does not meet that ||project's notability guideline nor Wikipedia's GNG, it's crystal that we should not have an article on that subject. Also, doesn't this fall under Deletion of Laura-Ioana Andrei WP:NTENNIS||WP:G4 Wikipedia:Notability 77
3346 19213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenn Bivins User:EWikist 21:05, 25 April 2012 (UTC) delete """I could not find any independent sources regarding this guy or anything he's published that would qualify him as """"notable."""" I'd say to delete this unless his book becomes more well-known (at which point he'd have at least one criterion from """ Deletion of Kenn Bivins WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3347 4763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clacket Lane User:Tony 20:29, 30 April 2007 (UTC) delete the record label has three bands, of which these guys are referred to as the 'big project'; with no albums out, and minimal outside references, they just don't meet at this time Deletion of Clacket Lane WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3348 479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charlie Moone User:South 02:52, 13 November 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Charlie Moone WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3349 5814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charlie Cole User:Bart133 23:34, 5 September 2008 (UTC) delete I can't find any |reliable sources that demonstrate |notability of this article Deletion of Charlie Cole WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3350 1649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Bachour User:Msnicki 02:18, 14 July 2014 (UTC) delete """His company was """"sold to an unnamed tech giant for an undisclosed amount"""" and there's """"speculation"""" it was Apple? This is what Wikipedia has become? Surely not! Completely lacking reliable independent secondary sources as required by . Googling turned up absolutely nothing. Stick a fork in it. This one is done""" Deletion of Eric Bachour WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3351 16558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lead Creek Derby(Band) User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable band. 26 unomitted Google hits. Tagged as {{tl|nn-band}}. &mdash Deletion of Lead Creek Derby(Band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3352 4812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa McGregor User:Jersey92 04:41, 22 July 2014 (UTC) delete I do not see how this subject passes Deletion of Lisa McGregor WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
3353 13779 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""Liebowitz Day""""""" User:JohnCD 21:02, 16 January 2009 (UTC) delete local interest only, not |notable """Deletion of """"Liebowitz Day""""""" WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3354 14684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Pierce NONE NONE keep per commenters above, the subject meets our notes. http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Yamaguchi%E5%85%88%E7%94%9F&action=edit§ion=new Yamaguchi先生 06:09, 9 November 2006 Deletion of Jason Pierce WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3355 12919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yeh Shuhua User:Abdotorg 14:15, 31 May 2021 (UTC) merge Redirect to to (G)I-dle until the individual meets , appearing on ISAC and in a music video is not notable Deletion of Yeh Shuhua WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3356 11204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ozzfest forums User:Alias 01:25, 1 August 2006 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is a tertiary source and this provides no secondary sources to |verify any notability — which it lacks Deletion of Ozzfest forums WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3357 15395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qaiser Iqbal User:Störm 11:22, 4 April 2021 (UTC) keep He has played in 14 qualifying matches, well over the 1 match threshold for , including scoring three first-class half centuries, which are exactly what is likely to lead to meaningful coverage for . Although I'm grateful for Deletion of Qaiser Iqbal WP:NCRIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3358 319 [[Overclockers.at]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:XPac 22:50, 28. Mär. 2007 (CEST) comment zur Klärung der Relevanz. Ich bitte darum, Einträge durch die vier Tilden (~) zu unterschreiben, das macht die Zuordnung/Unterscheidung einfacher. Außerdem sei gesagt, dass die Mitarbeit an der WP immer gerne gesehen ist, solange sie sich an die vereinbarten Richtlinien und Normen hält. Dazu zählen auch die |Relevanzkriterien. Wenn diese Richtlinien nicht beachtet werden, dann sind solche Artikel der Wikipedia eher eine Last als eine Förderung Löschung von Overclockers.at Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
3359 3616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shrikrishna Upadhyay [[User talk:24.151.10.165|talk]]) 19:03, 14 August 2014 (UTC) comment """I should have caught this earlier, but we really should be searching for him without the honorific, thus, """"Krishna Upadhyay"""". Immediate hits such as http://books.google.com/books?id=6vaHAwAAQBAJ&pg=PA166&dq=%22Krishna+Upadhyay%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=EQbtU-zSPIbfsAT5w4DADw&ved=0CCwQ6AEwAw#v=onepage&q=%22Krishna%20Upadhyay%22&f=false, http://www.nepalnews.com/contents/2011/englishweekly/spotlight/aug/aug19/focus.php and http://books.google.com/books?id=5JiOAAAAMAAJ&q=%22Krishna+Upadhyay%22&dq=%22Krishna+Upadhyay%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=EQbtU-zSPIbfsAT5w4DADw&ved=0CDwQ6AEwBg. My opinion is that he now passes as well as . Special:Contributions/24.151.10.165|24.151.10.165""" Deletion of Shrikrishna Upadhyay WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3360 7891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barony of Caux User:Metropolitan90 05:26, 1 October 2017 (UTC) delete """Being a micronation is usually an indication of non-notability. This article does not establish that this micronation has received """"significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject"""" to qualify as notable per the . (I don't consider two pages in a Lonely Planet book about micronations to meet that criterion, and the """"barony""""'s own web site certainly isn't independent; no other sources have been provided""" Deletion of Barony of Caux WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3361 4661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acres of Dead Space Cadets User:Richwales 21:08, 27 July 2011 (UTC) delete Only one source (and of uncertain quality); album evidently didn't make any national charts or honours; thus fails Deletion of Acres of Dead Space Cadets WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3362 12736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susam Pal User:MER 09:25, 31 December 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Susam Pal WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3363 20261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of characters in The Nightmare Before Christmas User:Sephiroth 03:38, 12 November 2008 (UTC) delete no need for a character list on a single film. Violates and #PLOT, as the characters can be adequately covered in the film article, and this list is excessive and unnecessary Deletion of List of characters in The Nightmare Before Christmas WP:WEIGHT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
3364 1717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CK Morgan User:Lankiveil 11:39, 12 January 2014 (UTC) delete I don't see any evidence at all that this person meets any of the notability criteria Deletion of CK Morgan WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3365 15280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aidan Bissett User:Argyle 05:15, 19 March 2011 (UTC) delete Non-notable footballer who fails and doesn't appear to have done anything of note to pass Deletion of Aidan Bissett WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3366 19037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ginger Jolie User:Captain 00:31, 18 October 2008 (UTC) keep Seems notable and I don't think that inconvenience is a reason to invoke Deletion of Ginger Jolie WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3367 18565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roy Moore sexual misconduct allegations User:Rusf10 15:34, 11 January 2018 (UTC) keep since this was covered extensively for an entire month, I think it goes beyond . There is just too much content to merge into the Roy Moore article Deletion of Roy Moore sexual misconduct allegations WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3368 18039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sajid Yahiya User:JackTracker 21:12, 19 May 2016 (UTC) keep The article is notable as of , you can read more about him at http://archives.deccanchronicle.com/130927/entertainment-mollywood/article/enthralled-cinema, and on http://www.filmibeat.com/malayalam/news/2016/interesting-facts-about-idi-220895.html it states 'He has acted in nearly 18 movies which include films like Bangalore days, Pakida etc', and on http://www.nowrunning.com/pranav-mohanlal-to-lead-in-inspector-dawood-ibrahim/106847/story.htm it clearly states Sajid Yahiya has done noted roles in 'Bangalore Days' and 'Pakida'. Also via WP:INADFD you can find lot of links stating the directional debut and about his movies Deletion of Sajid Yahiya WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3369 20 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/İzmir Özel Fatih Koleji Kullanıcı:hakan sungurhakan sungur 19:05, 26 Mayıs 2015 (UTC) keep Kullanıcı:kibele'nin bahsettiği gibi yönergesine göre kayda değer İzmir Özel Fatih Kolejinin silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
3370 13924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Hoelgaard User:Michig 13:24, 16 December 2012 (UTC) comment There is some coverage around (http://www.procycling.no/article3486227.ecehttp://sport.aftenposten.no/sport/sykkel/article260924.ecehttp://www.nettavisen.no/procycling/article2933442.ecehttp://www.rogalandsavis.no/sport/article2787232.ecehttp://www.sykling.no/nyheter/Sider/course%20de%20la%20paix%20etapp%203aogb2010.aspxhttp://www.nettavisen.no/procycling/article2928622.ece), arguably enough to pass , although I'm not familiar with the sources Deletion of Daniel Hoelgaard WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3371 16545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayapa User:MA 11:05, 14 May 2019 (UTC) keep Satisfied Deletion of Mayapa WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
3372 7086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AdultMerchantPay User:Littleteddy 10:02, 10 March 2008 (UTC) delete and merge all content into Emerchantpay. Seems to not be too notable, with hardly any |reliable, independent sources except for one trivial mention Deletion of AdultMerchantPay WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3373 10619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamiecg74 NONE NONE comment The problem is that not all references that people get in newspapers is equal. The eBay sale may have received national coverage, but it doesn't necessarily qualify you for |notability. People generally don't come notable (according to the Wikipedia definition) after just one mention in a newspaper; it requires multiple, independent |reliable sources Deletion of Jamiecg74 WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3374 11992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Equal Parenting Alliance User:Olaf 10:25, 11 May 2008 (UTC) delete per Asenine as it makes no reference to independent sources per Deletion of Equal Parenting Alliance WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3375 11292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charlie Rich, Jr. User:Duffbeerforme 05:04, 28 September 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and for lack of significant coverage, also ''per Deletion of Charlie Rich, Jr. :WP:NOTEBLP||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3376 15540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raffles Resort Canouan Island User:Sjakkalle 13:22, 8 April 2008 (UTC) delete Article boarders on being an advert, and all references point back to the resort's website. Hotels in general are a subject where I am fairly ambivalent to notability, and in cases like that I consider the article quality and motive. I cannot see that it really passes the main guideline, but if it does I am not opposed to recreation of a better version Deletion of Raffles Resort Canouan Island WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3377 13601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Socionomics (2nd nomination) User:TedFrank 12:01, 30 July 2007 (UTC) delete """per #G4; in the alternative '''delete''' or '''merge''' with Robert Prechter. (""""An editor's personal observations and research (e.g. finding blogs and books that use the term) are insufficient to support use of (or articles on) neologisms because this is analysis and synthesis of primary source material""""), (""""publication by itself is not a sufficient (and sometimes not necessary) standard for encyclopedic notability.""""), and, most critically : """"If a viewpoint is held by an extremely small (or vastly limited) minority, it does not belong in Wikipedia (except perhaps in some ancillary article) regardless of whether it is true or not; and regardless of whether you can prove it or not."""" Severe problems, too. As the Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Socionomics|first AFD nomination documented assiduously, the """"third party, independent, reliable sources"""" are largely imaginary or neither third-party nor independent, and, in any event, too rare to qualify as |notable. , too. Per , there already exists an ancillary article, Robert Prechter: every single one of the supposed reliable sources mentioned that I've checked so far was really about or by Prechter (or not about socionomics at all). And I'd like to see some administrative investigation: why was the same editor with a severe COI who disruptively and decisively lost an AFD after being found to have faked evidence allowed to recreate the same article without Wikipedia:Deletion review|going through the administrative processes for reversing a decision or notifying the people who voted for its deletion""" Deletion of Socionomics (2nd nomination) WP:CSD||WP:NEO||WP:SCI||WP:WEIGHT||WP:COI||WP:N||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:WEIGHT Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
3378 5769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Good Old Days (Leroy Shield song) User:Squeamish 14:49, 23 May 2018 (UTC) keep No valid deletion criteria offered; potential mergers are an editorial matter, not a topic for AFD. ''That'' said, I also would oppose a merger here. ''Our Gang'' is a large article with a lot to cover, and there's no reason why accessory topics like this can't or shouldn't be |spun out. Additionally, while it doesn't even get a redlink, there's an argument to be made that Kaltenmeyer's Kindergarten is sufficiently notable for an article (our coverage of radio programs is maybe worse than our coverage of silent-era films!); in any case, this song was not exclusively associated with the ''Our Gang'' property. Is the article a stub? Yes, but ''stub'' doesn't always mean ''bad Deletion of Good Old Days (Leroy Shield song) WP:SPINOUT Wikipedia:Article size 51
3379 20848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eleventeen (band) User:Esradekan 08:37, 11 November 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of Eleventeen (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3380 14715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Town Pants User:Starblind 23:06, 11 June 2013 (UTC) delete non-notable, per . However, I disagree with the above: I'd say if the band still isn't notable after 17 years(!) it almost certainly isn't gonna be Deletion of The Town Pants WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
3381 4598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judicial murder User:Evb 19:00, 14 September 2007 (UTC) delete per nom, and . Also, violates . (maybe not Deletion of Judicial murder WP:OR||WP:SYNTH||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
3382 11918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Things in my pocket User:Walter 05:02, 15 May 2020 (UTC) delete Poor name choice makes it difficult to find RSes that discuss the band. The sources in the article are essentially (press releases, etc.) and the ones that aren't, are associated (festivals, concerts). Fails both and with making to district finals of small competitions the closest they get to the latter Deletion of Things in my pocket :WP:PRIMARY||:WP:GNG||:WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:No original research 65
3383 12052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tower Mall User:Lightburst 14:38, 8 September 2020 (UTC) keep """a 53 acre footprint shopping mall that is listed in the Directory of Major Malls. Notability is not temporary, and the mall remains notable even though it has been demolished. Passes ..."""" historic, social, economic, or architectural importance""" Deletion of Tower Mall WP:NBUILD Wikipedia:Notability 77
3384 17548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Selective file dumper User:Eggishorn 22:12, 20 December 2017 (UTC) delete Likely self-promotion (article creator {{u|Nannibas}} is very close to the name of one of the authors, Nanni Bassetti) and no evidence of qualifying for or Deletion of Selective file dumper WP:GNG||WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3385 19380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victoria Taylor (2nd nomination) User:Gamaliel 13:38, 14 July 2015 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Victoria Taylor (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3386 8656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tahir Jarwali User:David 23:07, 8 April 2011 (UTC) delete in the absence of third-party |reliable sources that would show a pass of Deletion of Tahir Jarwali WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3387 17238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edmund Ward Poor (2nd nomination) User:B 03:52, 14 February 2009 (UTC) merge as his chief claim to fame was to be one of five founders of Grumman. His work in local government doesn't add much toward satisfying , and I don't see anything else aside from his premature death (but thousands drown at a young age every year). This almost reads as a eulogy. If more can be added about his career, it might be enough to make the bar for a standalone article, but for now, a mention in the Grumman article should be sufficient Deletion of Edmund Ward Poor (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3388 21294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Pet Collective User:Whpq 16:21, 27 May 2013 (UTC) delete There is no significant coverage in independent reliable sources to establish notability. is an option if the article creator needs more time to work on the article Deletion of The Pet Collective WP:USERFICATION Wikipedia:Userfication 87
3389 10315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twisted voices of reason User:PJM 02:45, 21 November 2005 (UTC) delete Clearly doesn't meet Deletion of Twisted voices of reason WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3390 123 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Mete Gündoğan Kullanıcı:78.190.114.11278.190.114.112 15:22, 7 Mart 2015 (UTC) comment internette cok yuksek taninirligi ve populerligi olan, ayrica cok faydali calismalar yapmis bir profesorun vikipedide sayfasi olmali bence Özel:Katkılar/78.190.114.112|78.190.114.112 (geçersiz Mete Gündoğan'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:OY Wikipedia:Administrators 89
3391 4771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drop Goblin User:TheTic123 19:53, 4 June 2013 (UTC) keep As far as literal and needed criteria to be eligible for Wiki, though not a large amount, he does, in fact meet the music artist notability criteria '''Criteria for musicians and ensembles - #5: Has released two or more albums on a major record label or on one of the more important indie labels)''' along with releasing and working with other notable and page approved artists on noted various indie labels and retail store releases connected with Reid Speed and Nick Pittsinger as well as Excision (musician)|Excision. He is also linked to other notable artist's pages, as well as worked with the very notable band Alestorm more than once. And that's just by looking on the artist page. I have also seen an article on him on FEARnet, the biggest horror/dark themed music site on the planet. To be honest administrators, I have seen other pages with far less that have lasted for years on Wiki. I would like to see his page remain and grow. Hopefully my input helps Deletion of Drop Goblin WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3392 15706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Planned Parenthood 2015 undercover videos controversy User:Gobonobo 00:28, 9 August 2015 (UTC) keep This is an acceptable content fork with enough detail that shoehorning it into the Planned Parenthood article would be as the coverage there is already borderline excessive. This topic should still be covered briefly at Planned Parenthood. Care should be taken to ensure that both articles conform with the rules on neutrality and weight Deletion of Planned Parenthood 2015 undercover videos controversy WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
3393 13236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neudesic (2nd nomination) User:Pmedema 17:16, 20 May 2016 (UTC) delete Article is promotional. It fails |notability and |reliable source guidelines Deletion of Neudesic (2nd nomination) WP:NCORP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3394 17589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/667 Dark Avenue Forum User:Joy 15:31, 2 April 2006 (UTC) delete I don't believe this meets the criteria. Google shows http://www.google.com/search?as_lq=http%3A%2F%2Fasoue.proboards11.com%2F&btnG=Search only 3 pages that link there, Alexa shows a 421,199 rank. It does have about 5000 registered members, but the site doesn't seem to be having much impact beyond those Deletion of 667 Dark Avenue Forum WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3395 12019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MAKO Model User:I42 18:47, 13 July 2010 (UTC) delete """Due to an edit conflict I also nominated this for deletion with the rationale: """"Article about a business model placed by the creator of the model and with no references or indication of notability. PROD legitimately contested by the author; speedy tag also removed but the criterion did not apply; possibly speedy deletable as db-spam, though. Fails , and """ Deletion of MAKO Model WP:V||WP:N||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3396 6648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clarence Hugo Linder User:David 16:19, 22 October 2013 (UTC) keep One doesn't have to hold an academic position to be notable via . This particular criterion (#3) is one of the easiest parts of to justify by other Wikipedia policie, as these memberships and fellowships are explicit recognition of his accomplishments by third parties. That is to say, these people noted him, therefore he is obviously notable Deletion of Clarence Hugo Linder WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3397 4518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Restaurant.com User:Terence 03:03, 2 September 2006 (UTC) delete needs reliable sources, does not meet criteria, advertsising Deletion of Restaurant.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3398 961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Runes of Mystery User:Shooterwalker 15:07, 24 January 2021 (UTC) delete no independent reliable sources from what I can tell. Does not meet the Deletion of Runes of Mystery WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3399 12843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nonukah User:Yoninah 23:08, 6 October 2012 (UTC) delete per . The references are all non-functioning links Deletion of Nonukah WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
3400 7733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Belen Shapur User:Superm401 19:53, 30 June 2009 (UTC) merge to Mark_Sanford#Extramarital_affair. If that section becomes too large, an article can be broken off (e.g. Mark Sanford extramarital affair). But means there should not be an article on just Chapur Deletion of Maria Belen Shapur WP:1EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3401 3473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Pirillo (2nd nomination) User:Cirt 16:46, 15 November 2010 (UTC) keep Satisfies . I am seeing quite a bit of coverage from multiple different |reliable secondary sources independent of the subject Deletion of Chris Pirillo (2nd nomination) WP:NOTE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3402 13992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sun Plaza Park User:MB 02:45, 18 May 2018 (UTC) delete Searching finds little coverage beyond routine mentions in guidebooks. Nothing indicates this is more than a local city park Deletion of Sun Plaza Park WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
3403 8307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yuva Sena User:HitroMilanese 18:33, 7 August 2016 (UTC) keep """I can find numerous references in reliable sources such as http://www.news18.com/newstopics/yuva-sena.html, http://indianexpress.com/tag/yuva-sena/, http://www.outlookindia.com/newswire/story/thane-aditya-kicks-off-yuva-sena-membership-drive/717751, http://www.business-standard.com/article/pti-stories/yuva-sena-stands-for-a-movement-says-aaditya-115101700632_1.html, http://indiatoday.intoday.in/video/yuva-sena-sweeps-mumbai-university-polls/1/174348.html. Searching for """"Yuva Sena"""" at https://www.google.co.in/ Indian version of google emits 300 thousands results. Seems to pass easily""" Deletion of Yuva Sena WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3404 19995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1+1 (song) User:Gongshow 21:03, 1 June 2011 (UTC) comment """Per : """"Notability aside"""" (the song meets ), """"a separate article on a song is only appropriate when there is enough verifiable material to warrant a reasonably detailed article; articles unlikely ever to grow beyond stubs should be merged to articles about an artist or album."""" This suggests a """"reasonably detailed"""" song article is one that goes beyond a stub - a standard which appears to have already been met""" Deletion of 1+1 (song) WP:NSONGS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3405 90 [[Obi-Cup]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Matthiasb 17:29, 8. Jul. 2007 (CEST) delete Findet zum ersten Mal statt, WP:WWNI, Punkt 8 (Veranstaltungskalender). mMn meilenweit unterlaufen Löschung von Obi-Cup Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
3406 145 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Kime Ne (Khontkar şarkısı) """Kullanıcı:pragdon'''pragdon'''""" 05.36, 23 Haziran 2020 (UTC) merge Bağımsız güvenilir kaynaklar mevcut. Ancak 'e göre tek başına bir madde oluşturacak boyutta değil. Bilgi kaybı olmaması için Khontkar maddesine aktarılsın Kime Ne (Khontkar şarkısı) siliniyor Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
3407 13573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 Interstate 75 rock-throwing deaths User:Pontificalibus 20:32, 30 January 2019 (UTC) delete The title is , implying there is a connection between the two events where there is none. The topic also isnt notable enough for this to be a list article Deletion of 2017 Interstate 75 rock-throwing deaths WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
3408 17273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avni Sali User:David 21:16, 2 February 2016 (UTC) delete His citation numbers in Google scholar are not high enough to convince me of a pass of #C1 and I am also not convinced that the awards are significant Deletion of Avni Sali WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3409 9375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Lost Choices User:Donaldd23 15:33, 30 August 2020 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of The Lost Choices WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
3410 19229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Two Twenty Two User:Eauhomme 06:03, 29 May 2009 (UTC) delete per . I am a licensed drug counselor and this one is news to me. A Co-codaprin|222 is a Canadian aspirin-caffeine-codeine tablet Deletion of Two Twenty Two WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
3411 10798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Pokémon (1-20) (2nd nomination) User:Dennisthe2 17:38, 21 May 2007 (UTC) keep Another user had complained about the split of the larger article in to these articles during the first AfD back in April (which is, evidently, a merge in progress at this time). My opinion hasn't changed - the attempt to delete these reeks of a to me, since consensus on the Pokemon project page seems to have stated that this should be done Deletion of List of Pokémon (1-20) (2nd nomination) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
3412 16918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glenroy Football Club User:Murtoa 23:27, 29 September 2008 (UTC) delete Non-notable amateur club with no claims to notability. Retaining because other clubs have articles sounds like . Unless they have other grounds for notability (and it's hard to imagine at this playing level), they could rate a mention as part of the league article but otherwise deleted Deletion of Glenroy Football Club WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3413 1364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of selfie-related injuries and deaths User:Savonneux 04:07, 19 August 2015 (UTC) keep or merge. It looks as though some people need to read again ''Questionable sources are those with a poor reputation for checking the facts, or with no editorial oversight.''. Searching this brings up a huge article in the Christian Science Monitor (has nothing to do with Christian or Science before the uninformed lose their shit) http://www.csmonitor.com/Technology/2015/0726/Enough-with-the-bison-selfies-at-Yellowstone-says-National-Park-Service, covering most of the incidents listed. Coverage on a government website of one incident http://www.nps.gov/yell/learn/news/15047.htm. NBC news one incident http://www.9news.com/story/news/weird/2014/08/10/couple-falls-to-their-deaths-while-taking-selfie/13873801. Among others. Not to mention general coverage of the topic in the CS Monitor http://www.csmonitor.com/Technology/2015/0707/How-to-prevent-death-by-selfie-a-guide-from-Russian-government, the Russian Ministry of Internal Affairs https://mvd.ru/safety_selfie. And so on and so on Deletion of List of selfie-related injuries and deaths WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3414 9766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IQcuties User:Coredesat 04:14, 30 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of IQcuties WP:WEB||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
3415 1225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Last Days of Blink-182 User:Nouse4aname 13:59, 3 December 2008 (UTC) delete Fails . Doesn't seem to exist. Should be a speedy, but not sure if any are relevant Deletion of Last Days of Blink-182 WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3416 17488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Sherwin User:Roxy 20:39, 21 October 2017 (UTC) delete Non notable fails GNG. Article obviously written by wikimates after his death - in spades. Would have nommed it myself had I known it existed Deletion of Chris Sherwin WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3417 11696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Baker (basketball) User:Rikster2 21:42, 3 December 2015 (UTC) comment """the Mexican league in no way is a """"similar league"""" to the Italian, Spanish and Australian pro leagues (which are the non-NBA legacy men's leagues named in the guideline). That league does not garner the consistent independent coverage to assert it meets . That said, the subject may very well meet , I will research and !vote accordingly after I get a chance to do so""" Deletion of Jordan Baker (basketball) WP:NBASKETBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3418 3958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Darren Scale user:Alf_photoman 22:07, 12 March 2007 (UTC) delete failing for lack of sources and , not verifiable Deletion of The Darren Scale WP:A||WP:V Wikipedia:Attribution 108
3419 11818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ralph Clayton User:DavidWS 14:48, 28 November 2008 (UTC) delete fail . That isn't the highest or second-highest level of football Deletion of Ralph Clayton WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3420 5770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mimeo.com Inc. User:OSborn 05:18, 23 February 2012 (UTC) delete that quote above is from the article talk) I have read through the refs and am somewhat unimpressed. While a few do appear to be reliable coverage that could establish notability, the vast majority are PR. The article was clearly created for |advertising purposes and reads as advertising copy Deletion of Mimeo.com Inc. WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
3421 4881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeWitt Clinton High School User:Quarl NONE keep per . No need to nominate high schools, especially ones of this size. &mdash Deletion of DeWitt Clinton High School WP:SCH Wikipedia:Notability 77
3422 10427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Harchick (2nd nomination) User:Ammarpad 10:25, 24 November 2017 (UTC) delete Because this person doesn't meet and lacks significant coverage to meet . In addition to being largely referenced to |unreliable sources, more than half (14/27) are |YouTube sources. None of the remaining sources discuss him in detail apart from ''profile'' in upwork.com which is of course a commercial platform upwork|for connecting clients who pay '' —'' Deletion of Jonathan Harchick (2nd nomination) WP:CREATIVE||WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:SOCIALMEDIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
3423 12066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chuck Whittall User:David 18:55, 6 May 2019 (UTC) delete I don't think counts here (there's certainly not enough of a demonstrable legacy for prong 2 to demonstrate an 'enduring' record) and I don't think GNG gets covered either with regards to significant non-local coverage (the Fox article Dream linked isn't really about the subject or even the development so much as the archeological site discovered by the aforementioned.) Feels like a case. Barkeep's suggestion is an interesting one but I haven't looked into the reliability of the company as separate Deletion of Chuck Whittall WP:ANYBIO||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
3424 12048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/7 Seconds of Love (2nd nomination) User:TruthbringerToronto 01:13, 30 November 2006 (UTC) keep I added references, including one from http://www.nme.com If the band has toured nationally within the United Kingdopm, it passes on that basis Deletion of 7 Seconds of Love (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3425 19105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moni Bhattacharjee User:Faizanalivarya 22:14, 8 January 2012 (UTC) keep I do respect your comments regarding Moni Bhattacharjee however in bulk reviewing you didn't check it properly in Moni Bhattacharjee article has citations are satisfying the |secondary sources policy in Wikipedia, look you are agreed on the point that his one movie is very notable and its logical thing that if his movies are notable so does he, its not only one movie he has more than 6 biggest movies as he is director of nineties and he was very well known and notable personality of his time as he was in nineties therefore its hard to find information on internet however I am working on it as soon as I find I will upload it therefore deleting of article is not a good solution therefore it ought to |improve rather deleting Deletion of Moni Bhattacharjee WP:RS||WP:EDIT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3426 17344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A.C. Milan squad User:Angelo 22:32, 30 May 2007 (UTC) delete per #INFO - unnecessary collection of information Deletion of A.C. Milan squad WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3427 12232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Truck (game) User:CindyLooWho 01:17, 23 August 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Certainly fails Deletion of Big Truck (game) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3428 5064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GScentral User:Parasytic 23:35, 5 February 2007 (UTC) delete Does not appear to hold any encyclopedic value as described in Deletion of GScentral WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3429 11226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brosix Instant Messenger User:StraussInTheHouse 14:29, 7 February 2019 (UTC) delete per {{u|Praxidicae}}. No need to keep going through AFDs on it, |Wikipedia is not for promotion Deletion of Brosix Instant Messenger WP:NOTSOAPBOX Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3430 2139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Rosatti (2nd nomination) User:Nomoskedasticity 16:44, 2 January 2010 (UTC) keep with restoration of the crime family association passages. That issue was supported by perfectly respectable sources (newspapers in Philadelphia and Palm Beach, in addition to the ''Village Voice''). This AfD has been mounted with a false premise; Rosatti meets and it is disingenuous to delete the portions of the article that establish notability and then to claim that he is not notable Deletion of John Rosatti (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3431 178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jón Pauli Olsen User:TheSpecialUser 07:17, 26 May 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Jón Pauli Olsen WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3432 4450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Chiminski User:Doggy54321 21:59, 19 February 2021 (UTC) delete all those sources are about the company, not the person. Deletion of John Chiminski WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
3433 4833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Bryant (Motivational Speaker) User:Bearian 21:11, 18 November 2016 (UTC) delete per and . This guy appears to be |just another cheerleading speaker. Yes, he spoke in Singapore, a tiny nation that I spent five days in and saw almost all there is to see (I loved the popiah, for what it's worth). I remind the gentle reader that we are a private American charity, |not a free web host for jet-setting business people out to make a profit Deletion of Andrew Bryant (Motivational Speaker) WP:OUTCOMES||WP:GNG||WP:MILL||WP:NOTWEBHOST Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3434 0 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ahmet Ataç (2. aday gösterme) Kullanıcı:nedim gayet birnedim gâyet bir 10.31, 20 Nisan 2022 (UTC) keep Belediye başkanları |Vikipedi:Kayda değerlik (Kişiler)in siyasetçiler başlığında açık ve seçik bir şekilde ele alınmamışsa da, güzel yurdumuzda çoğu belediye başkanı, çoğu milletvekilinden daha etkili, yetkili ve kamuoyu nezdinde daha tanınmıştır. Dolayısıyla belediye başkanları kendiliğinden kayda değer olmasalar da, çoğu durumlarda kayda değerlikleri ispat edilebilir. Bu minvalde, Ahmet Ataç'ın da kayda değer bir belediye başkanı olduğu kanaatindeyim. Madde içeriğini düzenledim ve hakkında bağımsız kaynaklar ekledim. Arz ederim Ahmet Ataç (2. aday gösterme) yazısının silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
3435 21728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soccer Administrators Day User:Nsk92 22:34, 9 May 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. No independent reliable sources to indicate notability. Fails Deletion of Soccer Administrators Day WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3436 19727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss Earth 2001 User:Alansohn 16:39, 14 December 2015 (UTC) keep WP:Fancruft is a piss-poor excuse for deletion; It's a mere essay that basically ads up to a in slightly different words. These articles cover notable events, with ample coverage from reliable and verifiable sources around the Earth about the events Deletion of Miss Earth 2001 WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3437 1725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hippo.com.au User:Lankiveil 12:04, 21 January 2008 (UTC) delete fails . It may also be necessary to salt, based on what the nominator has said Deletion of Hippo.com.au WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3438 8354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amy Shira Teitel User:Davey2010 00:03, 1 December 2016 (UTC) comment I originally closed as Speedy Keep due to the noms rationale (I believed it was more or less ) however I was asked by an admin to reopen so am reopening and relisting, Thanks Deletion of Amy Shira Teitel WP:ITSNOTNOTABLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3439 20897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chaitanya Gavali User:Papaursa 15:23, 18 September 2018 (UTC) delete He definitely doesn't meet . He also lacks the accomplishments in BJJ to meet . I don't believe is currently met since the bulk of the coverage is routine sports reporting or is focused on where he trains. If additional significant independent coverage of him in reliable sources can be shown, I will reconsider my vote Deletion of Chaitanya Gavali WP:NMMA||WP:MANOTE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3440 19968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marion Cohen (second nomination) User:Btball 19:38, 26 August 2006 (UTC) comment I think the current version now does meet based on TruthbringerToronto's updates. (Thanks Truthbringer Deletion of Marion Cohen (second nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3441 164 [[TARGET 3001!]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Geraldstiehler NONE comment Efficiency: Das soll dann wohl belegen, dass hier eine gewisse Relevanz vorliegt. Mag sein. Dennoch entsprichst der Artikel nach dem aktuellen Stand nicht den Kriterien für eine Enzyklopädie. Siehe . Was macht diese Software relevant? Bitte Löschung von TARGET 3001! Wikipedia:Wie schreibe ich einen guten Artikel Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
3442 14414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faith Cook User:Hongkongresident 05:49, 19 November 2010 (UTC) delete The quantity of books a person writes is not relevant. All of the books are obscure as the author; there's little coverage out there of the author or her books, neither meet the guidelines. A person could churn out a hundred books and still not be notable by Wikipedia standards; productivity does not reflect notability Deletion of Faith Cook WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
3443 1267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Misty Woods User:Pontificalibus 14:57, 6 September 2017 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet , and nor would the Ju Ju Babies Deletion of Misty Woods WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3444 7886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grace Period (Unix) User:Otolemur 09:44, 30 September 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Grace Period (Unix) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3445 6936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Australian Labor Students User:GarrieIrons 23:52, 19 June 2007 (UTC) delete unless |verification is provided in full Deletion of Australian Labor Students WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3446 14506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dalia Harir User:Thunderwing 15:49, 21 April 2007 (UTC) delete I disagree that she meets the critera of - she is only in the news as part of the murder- and is not notable in herself Deletion of Dalia Harir WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3447 9032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melouky User:David 23:25, 20 February 2018 (UTC) delete Article is promotional and appears to be written by a member of the same family who own the company and is already involved in other controversial contributions on numerous business articles. Further, it fails |reliable sources and |Wikipedia's General Notability Guidelines. This is advertising pure and simple and should be subject to speedy deletion Deletion of Melouky WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3448 149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Argentina–Singapore relations User:Piotrus 17:34, 2 February 2009 (UTC) keep or '''Merge''' to respective countries pages on foreign relations. I would like to see proof that those relations are non-notable, with in mind: even if nobody outside Argentina and Singapore cares about their foreign relations, they may be notable in light of works in language of those countries. Have respective deletion projects been notified? I don't see such notifications Deletion of Argentina–Singapore relations WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
3449 20634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B-52 Stratofortress trivia User:Tdmg 00:40, 6 July 2007 (UTC) delete """by #INFO. Subject alone is not notable. Keeping it because the main article is too long is not a legit reason. Calling it something other than """"trivia"""" is just covering up what it really is. Sure, some of it could be formed into a """"in Pop Culture"""" article, but a lot of it would need to be cut. """"Achievements and Milestones"""" would just be a euphemism for """"trivia"""". The information might be interesting, I'm not a nut about planes and it is still interesting, but that does not make any of it notable or worthy of an article. If any of these factoids were important to the B52 then it would be incorporated into the main article""" Deletion of B-52 Stratofortress trivia WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3450 9175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Wong (artist) User:Freshacconci 18:34, 18 February 2015 (UTC) keep Speedy keep'''. Easily meets -- Governor General's Award, in MoMA and National Gallery of Canada. All of this can be verified. Article should have been tagged for references and edited for wording, if it was inappropriate Deletion of Paul Wong (artist) WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
3451 20709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patton Creek Shopping Center User:GRBerry 16:10, 4 November 2006 (UTC) delete """The """"ACIA - ConcreteWorks"""" link has the look and feel of a press release, especially based on the last paragraph. The Chamber of Commerce page is a little better, but doesn't leave me believing that this business meets """ Deletion of Patton Creek Shopping Center WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3452 9352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philippine House of Representatives elections in Caraga, 2010 User:JulieSpaulding 15:16, 8 January 2010 (UTC) merge into a 'Caraga' page or possibly a '2010 Philippines election results' page. Individual pages would just amount to mere statistics, and |Wikipedia is not a mere collection of statistics Deletion of Philippine House of Representatives elections in Caraga, 2010 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3453 7889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Rodney Galloway User:Lipsticked 23:52, 9 June 2007 (UTC) delete """per ; searching for William Rodney Galloway returns pretty much only Google Groups hits. The article also seems to violate regarding the """"Marquis Who’s Who"""" directory""" Deletion of William Rodney Galloway WP:NOTE||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
3454 11691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Half-cut User:Paolo 14:48, 17 December 2005 (UTC) delete article does not even contain claims of meeting Deletion of Half-cut WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3455 4463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JG (rapper) User:Eggishorn 18:24, 9 April 2020 (UTC) delete the usual mix of fails Deletion of JG (rapper) WP:NARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
3456 11874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Scriven (2nd nomination) User:Struway2 07:05, 7 June 2009 (UTC) delete Fails as never having played at a fully-professional level. In my opinion, fails , per the sentence quoted by the nominator. cheers Deletion of Kevin Scriven (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3457 21070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simplicity PHP framework (2nd nomination) User:Joe 18:48, 5 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of Simplicity PHP framework (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3458 3946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Beatty (author) User:Colapeninsula 08:54, 18 May 2015 (UTC) delete """There are very short reviews in Publishers Weeklyhttp://www.digitalpw.com/digitalpw/20150216?pg=68#pg68 and Library Journalhttp://reviews.libraryjournal.com/2015/05/media/audio-in-advance/kids-previews/chris-colfer-james-patterson-grimes-on-tubman-and-anthony-audio-in-advance-july-2015-middle-grade/ and some on blogs/social media, but not enough to meet . Can't find much about his other ventures either. Not notable. (I don't think the qualification """"author"""" is anything other than a likely indication of where his notability might lie""" Deletion of Robert Beatty (author) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3459 20498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DJ Green Lantern Presents Fort Minor: We Major User:JamesBurns 07:50, 16 March 2009 (UTC) delete Insufficient independent 3rd party coverage Deletion of DJ Green Lantern Presents Fort Minor: We Major WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3460 2058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chanchal Kumar Sharma User:David 05:28, 23 June 2012 (UTC) delete The citation record doesn't support a pass of #C1, and I'm not convinced of any other criterion. Most of the sources in the article are primary; there are a few reliable newspaper stories but they all mention him only trivially, so the evidence for is also lacking Deletion of Chanchal Kumar Sharma WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3461 20653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Papillon Soo Soo User:Jessamyn 01:24, 31 March 2019 (UTC) keep Would normally be but I think her other major acting role makes this meet notability in Deletion of Papillon Soo Soo WP:BLP1E||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3462 19021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of literary works with eponymous heroines User:Pascal 00:08, 15 January 2007 (UTC) keep The debate is whether or not we consider this to be an indiscriminate collection of information. Although the list could use a bit of cleanup, the info in there is easily verifiable so is really the sole thing to worry about. While I personally see no great value in such a list, it could be kept on the grounds that Wikipedia is not paper Deletion of List of literary works with eponymous heroines WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3463 5446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M4 (Star Trek) User:Carlossuarez46 21:38, 9 May 2007 (UTC) delete per nom & per , if it belongs in the Requiem... put it there Deletion of M4 (Star Trek) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3464 218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darren Whittingham User:John 00:01, 19 February 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Darren Whittingham WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3465 11123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crossed storylines User:Are 21:12, 17 August 2010 (UTC) delete WP:NOT#PLOT|Wikipedia is not a collection of plot summaries. If there are Batman storylines which are nothing but plot summaries they should also be deleted. Their |existence doesn't warrant the existence of this article Deletion of Crossed storylines WP:WAX Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3466 6995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skeet (slang) User:IslaySolomon 05:54, 4 November 2006 (UTC) delete Largely |unverified |original research. Not that that matters since |wikipedia is not an (urban) dictionary Deletion of Skeet (slang) WP:V||WP:OR||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3467 12212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas McElwain (3rd nomination) User:Qwfp 08:09, 18 March 2011 (UTC) delete """Apparent claim to notability in article is that """"He is well-known for his conversion from Christianity to Shi'a Islam."""" However, http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Thomas+McElwain%22+islam+OR+muslim+source%3A%22-newswire%22+source%3A%22-wire%22+source%3A%22-presswire%22+source%3A%22-PR%22+source%3A%22-release%22+source%3A%22-wikipedia%22&btnG=Search+Archives&scoring=a Google News Archive search for Thomas McElwain Islam OR muslim gives only http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=A7ljAAAAIBAJ&sjid=eyUMAAAAIBAJ&pg=2939,29784799&dq=thomas-mcelwain+islam+%7C+muslim&hl=en one hit, and even that isn't ''significant'' coverage. I found no reviews of his book """"Islam in the Bible"""" on either GNews Archive or GScholar, so he doesn't appear to meet . I'm no expert on our ing policy but note that this article hasn't been ''repeatedly'' recreated following deletion as the ''first'' deletion discussion resulted in 'Keep""" Deletion of Thomas McElwain (3rd nomination) WP:AUTHOR||WP:salt Wikipedia:Notability 77
3468 6679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeFilm User:Vejvančický 15:38, 19 October 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. I can't find any sources confirming that the band 'DeFilm' meets |our notability criteria Deletion of DeFilm WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
3469 5682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Mary's Cathedral, Pazhanji User:Carlossuarez46 18:41, 7 August 2018 (UTC) merge with Pazhanji - the village in which the church is located. My thoughts: and don't apply. This is a building, not a village or mountain or lake. I find it difficult to find any unaffiliated reliable sources containing coverage of this church. Even the diocese has no article Kunnamkulam diocese. However, the self-published material can support the inclusion of the information/text in another article, which I merit should should be the village in which this church is located. We have many articles on populated places that have sections on a particular (but not notable in the WP sense) building. Why not this as well Deletion of St. Mary's Cathedral, Pazhanji WP:GEOLAND||WP:GEOFEAT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3470 19309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delone Catholic High School User:TerriersFan 18:12, 4 July 2007 (UTC) keep notability comes from multiple reliable sources per and this article has plenty of them together with notable achievements Deletion of Delone Catholic High School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3471 7955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019 Dallas Courthouse shooting User:Lightburst 20:06, 3 July 2019 (UTC) keep once notable always notable meets . Good references suggest Deletion of 2019 Dallas Courthouse shooting WP:GNG||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Notability 77
3472 13418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sauda Nabawesi User:Cewbot 00:02, 14 April 2021 (UTC) comment While this discussion appears to have |no quorum, it is '''NOT eligible for |soft deletion''' because it has been Special:Diff/1015044479|previously PROD'd (via summary Deletion of Sauda Nabawesi WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
3473 18876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Never Be Alone (series) [[User talk:TenPoundHammer|What did I screw up now?]]) 04:22, 25 May 2021 (UTC) delete """possible as I don't see any references to this show that don't just trace back to Wikipedia, just false positives that use the phrase """"never be alone"""" in other contexts. '''Ten Pound Hammer""" Deletion of Never Be Alone (series) WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
3474 20687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gateway Technolabs User:Dark 11:10, 29 July 2006 (UTC) delete per , , and . And per the pleas of the advertiser to leave his ad up on Wikipedia Deletion of Gateway Technolabs WP:VAIN||WP:CORP||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
3475 15957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Recaptive User:FreeRangeFrog 22:32, 27 November 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and of course it's basically a promotional article with external links for an entity that fails . Nuke it Deletion of Recaptive WP:PRODUCT||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3476 1516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 Romanian protests User:E 19:39, 12 November 2015 (UTC) keep Major deal political moment within national politics; adequately sourced to pass Deletion of 2015 Romanian protests WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3477 1354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pwn (2nd nomination) User:MLauba 08:44, 20 May 2009 (UTC) merge No |reliable sources in sufficient non-trivial quantity to attest to anything more than the fact that it exists, doesn't warrant a standalone article. Leet already covers the neologism, add a transwiki link to Wiktionary and we're done Deletion of Pwn (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3478 8727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Street League User:Snotbot 19:20, 25 March 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 March 25 Deletion of The Street League WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3479 9973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jai Reason User:Angelo 07:19, 6 July 2009 (UTC) delete fails (Conference is not fully pro) - recreate if and when he plays in a fully-pro league Deletion of Jai Reason WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3480 20359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Austin-East Magnet High School shooting User:Nsk92 04:37, 20 April 2021 (UTC) comment """For those arguing for merge or delete, I'd like you to take another look at what happened in this case so far and how it is actually being covered by . A black teenager was killed at school during an armed confrontation with the police. The original police account of the shooting turned out to be crucially incorrect. There is a bodycam video that the DA is refusing the release, despite a mounting community pressure to do so and a court suit by the city itself seeking to release the video. There have been escalating local racial justice protests over the shooting. The dead student's family hired ''the'' highest profile lawyer for these types of cases, Ben Crump, to represent them. The national media continues to cover the case in-depth. Just from earlier today we have APhttps://apnews.com/article/us-news-shootings-knoxville-tennessee-2f17b23ab01abc982cc937c73cb33ea3, Newsweekhttps://www.newsweek.com/regina-perkins-mother-anthony-thompson-jrs-girlfriend-regrets-calling-police-who-shot-1584700, Huffington Posthttps://www.huffpost.com/entry/anthony-thompson-knoxville-school-shooting_n_607da110e4b001abc4dfa439, and even international media https://newsdome.co.za/a-tennessee-teen-was-killed-by-police-inside-his-school-heres-what-we-know/. Today's NYT storyhttps://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/19/us/minnesota-school-walkout-chauvin-trial.html says that the Anthony Thompson case was mentioned at the Minnesota racial justice protest on Monday. Plus the local media in Knoxville continues to give the case high profile coverage. Calling this case """"minor"""" completely disregards how the have been covering it. The racial justice aspect of this case makes it different from many other school shootings and makes it highly improbable that in today's U.S. political, societal and media climate the story will quietly disappear""" Deletion of Austin-East Magnet High School shooting WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3481 130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greatest Hits 2 (album title TBA) User:Cliff 19:47, 31 July 2010 (UTC) delete per above: |title and track listing are unknown. This should be included in the artist's article until those are confirmed Deletion of Greatest Hits 2 (album title TBA) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3482 20511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mount Kosh-Kaya User:Coolabahapple 06:39, 4 December 2019 (UTC) comment """before other editors pile on the """"plenty of sources, why didnt the nom look for them"""" route just noting that although their 1st edits were in July 2019, the nominator hasnt done many until October so are quite new ie. |dont bite new editors""" Deletion of Mount Kosh-Kaya WP:BITE Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
3483 16733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erika Lauren Wasilewski User:TonyTheTiger 14:18, 28 September 2012 (UTC) keep Notability is permanent. If we shifted time back to when she was on TRW, we would have said that there are sources that provide us with a basic biographical sketch and that she passes Deletion of Erika Lauren Wasilewski WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3484 17654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Garou Tribes (Werewolf: The Apocalypse) [[User talk:70.80.234.196|talk]]) 00:01, 27 January 2011 (UTC) delete I understand the concept of a spinoff but most of this is pointless . It could possibly be trimmed but the users who care about such articles usually aren't the type to trim. Since sources are not particularly significant, independent or reliable, I think it's best left to the http://whitewolf.wikia.com/wiki/Werewolf:_The_Apocalypse White Wolf Wiki.--Special:Contributions/70.80.234.196|70.80.234.196 Deletion of Garou Tribes (Werewolf: The Apocalypse) WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
3485 6964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Necla Güngör User:MarkH21 10:03, 17 December 2019 (UTC) delete Fails for not having managed a full senior international and for not managing in a fully professional league (|list of known such leagues). http://hurriyet.com.tr/kadin-teknik-direktorun-idolu-fatih-terim-25100391 This Hurriyet article would count towards , but I don’t see another independent reliable source with significant coverage on her Deletion of Necla Güngör WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3486 16087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor Blight User:Colonel 18:12, 30 October 2007 (UTC) keep Voiced by Meg Ryan and with respectable references like http://www.nytimes.com/2006/04/22/arts/22ted.html NYT and http://cla.calpoly.edu/~jrubba/495/papersS98/paper1.html Cal Poly - seems good enough to me. |I hate fiction is insufficient reason to delete Deletion of Doctor Blight WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3487 8238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The House of Fine Art User:Justlettersandnumbers 17:01, 10 September 2018 (UTC) comment """u|James500}}, {{u|Sam Sailor}}, I wonder if you are aware that leads to the same paragraph as ? The first sentence there is """"{{teal|If a topic has received '''significant coverage''' in '''|reliable sources''' that are '''ndependent sources|independent of the subject''', it is '''presumed''' to be suitable for a stand-alone article or list}}"""". So perhaps, instead of merely stating """"meets/satisfies GNG"""", you could provide evidence of where you found that significant coverage, why you think the detailed analysis of the sources provided here by {{u|NitinMlk}} is incorrect, and how you think that the sources you've found might satisfy ? Thanks""" Deletion of The House of Fine Art WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:I||WP:NCORP||WP:reliable sources Wikipedia:Notability 77
3488 5617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Still Play User:Zingarese 02:36, 1 November 2019 (UTC) keep i feel there is enough coverage about this piece in reliable sources to pass the . Thanks {{u|Jg2904}} for your cleanup efforts Deletion of I Still Play WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3489 15106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Misinformation related to the COVID-19 pandemic by the United States User:Novem_Linguae 01:52, 25 January 2021 (UTC) keep This isn't a POVFORK. It's a . The original article is Misinformation related to the COVID-19 pandemic by governments, and that in turn was CFORKed from Misinformation related to the COVID-19 pandemic. The original Misinformation related to the COVID-19 pandemic was massive, and these CFORKs were necessary to keep the article to a manageable size Deletion of Misinformation related to the COVID-19 pandemic by the United States WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
3490 6036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/12. Hitoe User:ShadowHalo 05:22, 25 January 2007 (UTC) delete Appears to fail Deletion of 12. Hitoe WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
3491 2810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lynno Lovert User:Versace1608 15:05, 15 April 2020 (UTC) delete The subject fails and . The movies he's starred in do not appear to be notable. The awards he is a recipient of are not notable Deletion of Lynno Lovert WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3492 10510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pholde User:Stifle 09:47, 9 September 2008 (UTC) delete due to lack of references. If the list of album releases was verified, it would suffice to pass Deletion of Pholde WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3493 2225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Social network aggregation User:Colonel 11:27, 10 April 2008 (UTC) keep """It is obviously not a neologism as these are all long-standing words and their meaning seems clear enough. Per : """"''use a title that is a descriptive phrase in plain English, even if this makes for a somewhat long or awkward title.''"""" And there seems to be enough discussion of the topic http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&ned=us&q=%22social+network%22+aggregation&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&start=10 out there to support an article""" Deletion of Social network aggregation WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3494 3314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Powerhouse Films User:Ciccio 09:50, 16 January 2018 (UTC) keep It passes Deletion of Powerhouse Films WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3495 13037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EasyMandarin User:Zanhe 06:32, 19 September 2018 (UTC) delete fails . The article largely relies on reviews from Time Out Shanghai and The Beijinger. However, reviews in local newspapers do not constitute in-depth coverage. Many restaurants and other businesses are reviewed in major newspapers (just read the local sections of the New York Times or Washington Post), but that does not make them notable Deletion of EasyMandarin WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3496 2813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrián Ochoa User:RightCowLeftCoast 05:20, 16 October 2014 (UTC) delete insufficient non-primary or secondary sources that provide the subject |significant coverage that suggest the subject meets . Alternatively, the article can be changed to a '''redirect''' to the article about General authority, such as this article List of general authorities of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, however until the subject can meet from non-secondary and non-primary sources, I believe this article falls under |too soon, and I wouldn't be opposed to the the creators |incubating the article until the time arises when there are sufficient tertiary sources to show independent notability Deletion of Adrián Ochoa WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON||WP:INCUBATE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3497 1527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denise Lutgens User:Pburka 15:55, 18 September 2010 (UTC) delete Not notable. Winner of several non-notable piano competitions, but no news coverage. Article was created by a , possible Deletion of Denise Lutgens WP:SPA||WP:COI Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
3498 18688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Henley (Birmingham mayor) User:SportingFlyer 02:29, 3 October 2018 (UTC) comment are we sure there's not a couple other sources that would get him past ? Birmingham's large enough that I would expect he would be covered somewhere Deletion of Robert Henley (Birmingham mayor) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3499 13783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 Major League Baseball All-Star Game User:Dru 09:26, 18 April 2011 (UTC) comment With a brief nod to , the 2011, 2012, and 2013 articles do exist; planning for major sporting events has notability and coverage in various independendent third-party reliable sources long before they occur, with the 2028 Summer Olympics being the furthest sourced example ready at hand. If there was a 2014 article, it was not deleted through an AfD, and creation and sourcing are likely only a matter of an interested editor's priorities. MLB.com isn't independendent, but it is certainly reliable about venue coverage Deletion of 2015 Major League Baseball All-Star Game WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3500 378 [[CBIRC]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Jpp NONE keep Wurde schon mal gestellt mit gleicher Begründung und damals vom Antragsteller zurückgezogen (/21. Juli 2005#CBIRC (erl., LA zurücckgezogen)). Als Wiedergänger Löschung von CBIRC Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3501 9462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shiamara Almeida User:onel5969 01:11, 6 March 2017 (UTC) delete Does not pass , and only a youth career does not pass Deletion of Shiamara Almeida WP:GNG||WP:NATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3502 643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barbara Sobel User:Joe 21:47, 11 June 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |person Deletion of Barbara Sobel WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3503 10033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wicked (2011 film) User:Cliff 23:12, 14 October 2009 (UTC) delete per above: |no verification that principal photography has started Deletion of Wicked (2011 film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3504 12103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carbery GAA User:Guliolopez 01:50, 2 November 2016 (UTC) comment """Per {{u|The Banner}}, I can't figure out what this article is about. If this article is about a club (which has won championships in football and hurling), then the subject is possibly notable under . If this article is about some kind of (seemingly nebulous) """"all stars"""" team of players representing a division, then it may or may not meet NN criteria. Unless someone can improve the article to the extent that a reader might understand what it's about, one wonders what notability criteria to even apply. (If it's a club, we might apply the |notability guidelines for sports clubs. If it's a league/division, we might apply the |notability guidelines which covers sports leagues""" Deletion of Carbery GAA WP:CLUB||WP:CLUB||WP:NSPORTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3505 20084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quarantine The Challenges During Quarantine and How to Keep Our Sanity User:Spiderone 06:58, 6 August 2021 (UTC) delete clearly fails ; it's listed on Amazon (Amazon will sell anything) but there's no whatsoever. Almost definitely created to promote the book Deletion of Quarantine The Challenges During Quarantine and How to Keep Our Sanity WP:NBOOK||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3506 5209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victor Osimhen User:GiantSnowman 07:18, 20 June 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Victor Osimhen WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3507 2418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Liepa User:TenPoundHammer 21:35, 23 May 2009 (UTC) merge to Pringles per and . Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Special:Contributions/TenPoundHammer|Many otters • :User talk:TenPoundHammer|One bat Deletion of Alexander Liepa WP:RS||WP:PUTEFFORT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3508 10456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Religious identity User:JChap2007 23:57, 8 February 2007 (UTC) delete Purely |original research. Not a single sentence is anything that we can use to build an article Deletion of Religious identity WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3509 20776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dragon (2017 film) User:Winged 13:46, 11 April 2017 (UTC) delete Fails .The article creator has an habit of creating all these articles on future films--(prob. to feature as an article creator after years when the film has released or it has indeed become notable get converted to an article) and then !votes for an redirect at AfD.Put an end to this Deletion of Dragon (2017 film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3510 16724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Vevo Certified music videos [[User talk:Starcheerspeaksnewslostwars|Talk to me]] 22:29, 30 January 2014 (UTC) delete I created the article following the outcome of a Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2013_September_13#Category:Vevo_Certified_songs|CFD for Category:Vevo Certified songs. There is a mention of the certification within the Vevo article. I agree that the list is merely ancruft with no real legitimate sourcing of artists/videos that receive this certification. --Starcheerspeaksnewslostwars Deletion of List of Vevo Certified music videos WP:F Wikipedia:Non-free content 99
3511 13718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Generalized additive model for location, scale, and shape User:Qwfp 18:59, 23 May 2010 (UTC) keep """Google Scholar says the 2005 paper in JRSSB has been cited 119 times, and gives http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=%22Generalized+additive+model+for+location%2C+scale%2C+and+shape%22+OR+GAMLSS 175 hits for ''""""Generalized additive model for location, scale, and shape"""" OR GAMLSS'' so this is clearly notable and clearly not . Article has now been edited to remove any resemblance to an or WP:essay""" Deletion of Generalized additive model for location, scale, and shape WP:original research||WP:advert Wikipedia:No original research 65
3512 4283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trof User:Champion 03:39, 22 July 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet Deletion of Trof WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3513 2693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tamar El Or User:Roscelese 20:14, 24 May 2012 (UTC) keep Holding a named chair at a major university is a technical pass, but besides that, her books have been reviewed in a http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/2074267 number http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/4131655 of http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/40316750 journals Deletion of Tamar El Or WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3514 17192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delaware Route 17 User:Imzadi1979 15:20, 5 August 2012 (UTC) keep """per and per . The latter states that """"Wikipedia is an encyclopedia. It incorporates elements of general and specialized encyclopedias, almanacs, and ''gazetteers''."""" Our article on gazetteers states that one """"is a geographical dictionary or directory, ... used in conjunction with a map or a full atlas. It typically contains information concerning ... ''roads''."""" Further down, the article states, """"gazetteer editors gather facts and other information from ''official government reports''"""". (emphasis mine in all quotations.) If we're to """"incorporate elements of gazetteers"""" and they detail information about roads from official government sources, then this article is perfectly acceptable on policy grounds. (otability is only a guideline, not a policy let alone a pillar""" Deletion of Delaware Route 17 WP:ROADOUTCOMES||WP:5P||WP:N Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3515 21563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fabio di Celmo [[User talk:151.52.254.197|talk]]) 07:46, 22 July 2020 (UTC) merge to 1997 Cuba hotel bombings. He received some coverage (as it generally happens in these tragic events), but it is not enough for a separate article per and . --Special:Contributions/151.52.254.197|151.52.254.197 Deletion of Fabio di Celmo WP:VICTIM||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
3516 13004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eiffel Tower in popular culture (2nd nomination) User:Claritas 21:48, 2 September 2010 (UTC) delete per and , with no prejudice against the creation of an encyclopaedic article on the Cultural impact of the Eiffel tower, which is a notable topic. x in popular culture articles are innately unencyclopaedic Deletion of Eiffel Tower in popular culture (2nd nomination) WP:IINFO||WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3517 451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zarb-e-Sukhan NONE NONE delete This self-published poetry book doesn't come close to meeting any of the three |thresh-hold criteria for book notability Deletion of Zarb-e-Sukhan WP:BKTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3518 5295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trí Phải User:Aymatth2 16:43, 4 June 2020 (UTC) keep Check w:vi:Trí Phải. This is a significant settlement with a population of 12,970 as of 2005. Passes Deletion of Trí Phải WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3519 6659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unitarian Universalists for Jewish Awareness User:Thewinchester 06:50, 1 June 2007 (UTC) delete Delete as , just another *cruft article about a non-notable organisation that does not meet the relevant policy Deletion of Unitarian Universalists for Jewish Awareness WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
3520 6742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GLJ User:Serpent 04:07, 6 May 2007 (UTC) delete I consider it likely that this is, instead, a |hoax. Jan Mohammad is a linguist ... at the University of Arizona. I find no evidence suggesting he published ''Urdu and Cute Idioms'' or anything similar. This seems to be an inside joke of some sort by a couple of Lahore University of Management Sciences|LUMS students Deletion of GLJ WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
3521 18750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K. Michelle User:TheSpecialUser 00:31, 24 August 2012 (UTC) keep meets and per hammer Deletion of K. Michelle WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3522 15812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evan Mendel (Mendell) User:HisSpaceResearch 17:36, 1 February 2008 (UTC) delete could easily be an A7 CSD nn bio. Fails and totally Deletion of Evan Mendel (Mendell) WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3523 392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Love twins User:Rebecca1990 00:37, 29 April 2013 (UTC) keep """Passes , which states """"has made unique contributions to a specific pornographic genre, such as beginning a trend in pornography"""", in this case, twin porn""" Deletion of Love twins WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3524 21468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Senpuu User:Bendono 03:56, 16 January 2010 (UTC) delete per . Also, please do not transwiki because it is already there: wiktionary:旋風#Etymology 4|旋風 Deletion of Senpuu WP:NOTDICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3525 4888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Official Album Summer Olympics Games Rio 2016 User:McGeddon 17:06, 27 June 2016 (UTC) delete """as at best. I get precisely three Google results for ''""""Si Te Vas"""" """"Time Works Wonders"""" """"Olympics""""'', none confirming the existence of an Olympic album opening with those two tracks""" Deletion of Official Album Summer Olympics Games Rio 2016 WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3526 10474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dear Pricey User:GrammarFascist 12:35, 27 October 2015 (UTC) comment I am deferring advocating to either Keep or Delete the article at this point in the discussion.) In general, of course, if an article has been speedily deleted and the creator (or another editor) believes the deletion to have been in error, the proper course is to request a |deletion review, not simply recreate the article, especially not without addressing any of the issues raised when the original article was tagged for deletion. And when an article was previously deleted due to a valid issue, and the same article is recreated without addressing the issue(s) raised, such an article will generally be deleted again after discussion reaches a onsensus|consensus to do so. But the article is now here on Wikipedia (again), and so there is an opportunity for {{U|AlexWit}} to provide |reliable sources to establish Dear Pricey's |notability. Indeed, I see that in fact AlexWit has already begun attempting to provide such sources — though I have not yet examined the sources to determine whether any of them are actually reliable sources by Wikipedia's definition. I will wait and see how the article develops Deletion of Dear Pricey WP:DRV||WP:C||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3527 10570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Biden assault allegation User:SharabSalam 08:40, 15 April 2020 (UTC) keep passes , the controversy has been there since the 1990s. I don't see any reason to remove it. This is now a legal issue and there is a police complaint against Joe Biden Deletion of Joe Biden assault allegation WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3528 20315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Knockout Kings (band) User:FreeRangeFrog 22:08, 19 February 2009 (UTC) delete Non-notable regional band claiming notability by way of the non-notable indie record company. Fails Deletion of Knockout Kings (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
3529 6165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sieve of Zakiya User:CRGreathouse 15:15, 11 December 2011 (UTC) delete we already have an article on the Wheel factorization|wheel sieve. Further, the name is a |neologism and as such not appropriate for Wikipedia. The sieve is inefficient compared to modern sieve implementations; compare it to, e.g., http://sites.google.com/site/bbuhrow/ yafu. And has already been brought up: there has not been any coverage of this topic independent from its source. So for those three reasons it's pretty clear that it needs to go. Oh, and I suppose may apply as well, but that's borderline since it's pretty much just a bog-standard SoE with a wheel Deletion of Sieve of Zakiya WP:NEO||WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3530 18747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Max Burkhart User:Dom 13:09, 9 December 2017 (UTC) delete per nom. Agreed, a tragic story, but sadly the only news hits relate to Burkhart's death, so this fails and Deletion of Max Burkhart WP:ONEEVENT||WP:NOTAMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3531 9198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hitball User:RGTraynor 16:58, 19 March 2007 (UTC) delete fails , . I can't see grounds for a speedy, but this is just another insignificant local game Deletion of Hitball WP:ATT||WP:NFT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
3532 1814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wilmington Montessori School User:Corvus 02:27, 3 February 2008 (UTC) delete """Does not meet as it does not appear to have """"received significant coverage in reliable secondary sources that are independent of the subject"""" - none are cited in the article and a Google search http://www.google.com.au/search?hl=en&q=Wilmington+Montessori+School&btnG=Search&meta= provides no references. The only claim to notability is that one of its teachers was awarded a prestigious award, but this has no bearing as |notability is not inherited - the teacher probably isn't notable enough for an article, so why would this somehow make the school notable? As a side note, I don't see anything which suggests that""" Deletion of Wilmington Montessori School WP:N||WP:ITSA Wikipedia:Notability 77
3533 4957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Pownall User:Gongshow 07:23, 30 April 2014 (UTC) keep Coverage includes http://www.allmusic.com/artist/alan-pownall-mn0002432482/biographyhttp://www.allmusic.com/album/true-love-stories-mw0002021791http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/reviews/alan-pownall-borderline-london-1958574.htmlhttp://www.musicomh.com/reviews/albums/alan-pownall-true-love-storieshttp://www.theguardian.com/music/2010/jul/08/alan-pownall-true-love-stories-cd-review. I've added these sources to the article; subject meets and Deletion of Alan Pownall WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3534 10980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phil Jones (footballer) User:GiantSnowman 17:01, 31 August 2009 (UTC) delete non-notable player who fails and Deletion of Phil Jones (footballer) WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3535 13023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ARHAX.studio User:RadioFan 02:07, 1 May 2011 (UTC) delete does not meet , lacks coverage in 3rd party sources Deletion of ARHAX.studio WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3536 15736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sighetu Marmației explosions User:Joe 17:15, 23 March 2012 (UTC) delete No sign of rising to , in particular it seems rather unlikely this event will meet nor does it appear to meet Deletion of Sighetu Marmației explosions WP:EVENT||WP:EFFECT||WP:GEOSCOPE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3537 11728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aspects of Mars NONE NONE comment Proper |process was followed for nominating multiple articles. This AfD is improper Deletion of Aspects of Mars WP:BUNDLE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3538 15231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammed Al-Moeini User:Struway2 09:10, 25 June 2016 (UTC) keep Subject does indeed pass by having played for several teams in the fully professional UAE Arabian Gulf League, as confirmed by the http://uk.soccerway.com/players/mohammed-al-moeini/153803/ Soccerway external link already present in the article. cheers Deletion of Mohammed Al-Moeini WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
3539 12423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fly Hornbill User:Steve 06:09, 22 July 2017 (UTC) delete no indication of notability because there is virtually no coverage in independent reliable sources. There is only one acceptable independent source that covers this: https://www.telegraphindia.com/1161001/jsp/northeast/story_111235.jsp. But this is not enough to demonstrate notability. Agree with nom fails GNG and NCORP. This is probably |wp:too soon, having only been established in 2016 as a small airline (read source Deletion of Fly Hornbill WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3540 27 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marysburgh vortex User:LuckyLouie 12:02, 3 September 2014 (UTC) comment Seems to be a legitimate legend with at least a couple of |objective sources showing some notability. I've removed all the cruft propagated by UFO/paranormal/sensational books/websites and original research (i.e. a detailed list of ships, the sinkings of many of them dubiously attributed to the so-called vortex) and stripped it down to a viable stub Deletion of Marysburgh vortex WP:FRIND Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
3541 14547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Normanton Telecoms User:SW3 15:58, 31 December 2016 (UTC) delete Fails and . There are no articles in reliable sources that focus on this company, just listed in a directories. Wikipedia is not a free publicity site Deletion of Normanton Telecoms WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3542 1211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Adams (organist) User:Atlantic306 01:18, 17 March 2021 (UTC) keep as per the coverage identified in this discussion by Gerda that shows enough coverage for imv Deletion of Thomas Adams (organist) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3543 5223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maya Hills User:MichaelQSchmidt 21:23, 30 December 2010 (UTC) delete per . Only entered her career field recently, and while receiving award nominations, they are both in a single year Deletion of Maya Hills WP:TOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3544 5060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammed Dawood Yaseen User:Fenix 17:15, 6 November 2017 (UTC) keep per |good work by Deletion of Mohammed Dawood Yaseen WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
3545 13756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slumbie User:Kinu 04:34, 28 August 2006 (UTC) delete per , fails , Urban Dictionary Deletion of Slumbie WP:NEO||WP:V||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3546 17274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diane Schuler User:Location 10:55, 11 September 2009 (UTC) keep The subject meets Deletion of Diane Schuler WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3547 6418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of international cricket five-wicket hauls by Rangana Herath User:Ajf773 08:33, 28 January 2021 (UTC) delete """per /. {{tq|""""To provide encyclopedic value, data should be put in context with explanations referenced to independent sources.""""}} This article is just a list of scores from ESPNCricinfo and has no independent sources covering these individual achievements as a set. Agree with nom that there should be no precedent to include these on players' articles""" Deletion of List of international cricket five-wicket hauls by Rangana Herath WP:NOTSTATS||WP:RAWDATA Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3548 13390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Krae User:Kinu 08:28, 28 April 2020 (UTC) delete Not enough third-party RS coverage to justify a BLP. Fails . (Also, why was this relisted prior to the 7-day mark and with a seemingly apparent consensus Deletion of David Krae WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3549 1493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glen Swan User:Guest9999 00:24, 18 November 2008 (UTC) delete I can't find any |reliable sources on which a |verifiable article could be based. I'd imagine that - given his profession - any sources that did exist would be readily available on-line Deletion of Glen Swan WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3550 10631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Star Circle Quest Alumni User:Lenticel 01:04, 1 February 2007 (UTC) delete per |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information. Even if it has references it does not mean that it could stand as an article Deletion of List of Star Circle Quest Alumni WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3551 7761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dua Sanamain Quraish User:Bearian 15:47, 28 May 2014 (UTC) delete if not even one source gives |more than passing mentions, this is |not notable Deletion of Dua Sanamain Quraish WP:SIGCOV||WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
3552 20053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bright green (second nomination) User:GRBerry 15:24, 16 October 2006 (UTC) keep the article on the color. If the environmentalism stuff comes back it should be on a different page, as the color article is worth having. We can then have an AFD discussion about the environmentalism content, but my current thinking is that it fails due to lack of |independent reliable sources ''about'' the term Deletion of Bright green (second nomination) WP:NEO||WP:INDY Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3553 10930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brent Woods, Indiana User:RL0919 13:59, 1 June 2019 (UTC) delete """The interpretation that a subdivision inside an incorporated community is a """"legally recognized place"""" because it can be found on a sufficiently detailed map or in a geographical database is unsupportable and would render the guideline virtually useless. The only sources cited in the article or in this discussion are of this type. By the explicit wording of the guideline, subdivisions """"could be considered notable on a case-by-case basis, given non-trivial coverage in multiple, independent reliable sources"""". No such coverage has been shown or even claimed""" Deletion of Brent Woods, Indiana WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3554 12183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010s in urban music User:Gosox5555 03:06, 6 January 2010 (UTC) delete per failure of Deletion of 2010s in urban music WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3555 15919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of television comedies without laugh tracks User:Koffieyahoo 04:20, 10 August 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of television comedies without laugh tracks WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3556 4347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Konwarpurar Konwar User:Rameshnta909 18:21, 16 December 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Konwarpurar Konwar WP:MOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3557 13606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Strikeforce Challengers: Gurgel vs. Evangelista User:Dream 04:41, 21 September 2011 (UTC) keep """If you find an article that doesn't have reliable sources in it already, then just search for the names of those participating plus Strikeforce. Example: """"Strikeforce"""" """"Gurgel"""" """"Evangelista"""" shows some results to look through. http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Strikeforce+Challengers:+Gurgel+vs.+Evangelista%22&tbm=nws&tbs=ar:1#sclient=psy-ab&hl=en&safe=off&tbs=ar:1&tbm=nws&source=hp&q=%22Strikeforce%22+Gurgel%22+%22Evangelista%22&pbx=1&oq=%22Strikeforce%22+Gurgel%22+%22Evangelista%22&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&gs_sm=e&gs_upl=39931l44027l2l44236l6l6l0l0l0l1l194l940l1.5l6l0&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.&fp=8e5afc580abd7b17&biw=1024&bih=617 Always follow and don't just nominate something because you don't like it""" Deletion of Strikeforce Challengers: Gurgel vs. Evangelista WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3558 9906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ran Neu-Ner User:Kvng 15:04, 27 October 2020 (UTC) merge to The Creative Counsel as Deletion of Ran Neu-Ner WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3559 5407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeitgeist: Moving Forward User:MichaelQSchmidt 08:57, 7 March 2011 (UTC) keep per having |sourcable independent |notability meeting . We do not need to agree to the subject matter, as |our inclusion threshold is verifiability, not truth... and independent notability is independent notability. Or will the next such AFD suggest that ''Rocky 2'', ''Rocky 3'', ''Rocky 4'' etal should all be merged and redirected to ''Rocky 1 Deletion of Zeitgeist: Moving Forward WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:NF||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3560 5 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Engin Çakar Kullanıcı:nanahuatlnanahuatl 20.45, 11 Temmuz 2021 (UTC) delete Kayda değer olduğunu ispat edebilecek bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynaklar yok. Zaten maddenin hemen hemen tamamı |özgün araştırma şeklinde, kaynaklardan çıkarım yapma şeklinde Engin Çakar'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:ÖA Wikipedia:No original research 65
3561 3953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Savior (Rise Against song) User:ZooFari 02:41, 18 June 2009 (UTC) delete too soon. Sources lack per Deletion of Savior (Rise Against song) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3562 18224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kellie Pickler (album) User:Cliff 01:28, 19 August 2008 (UTC) delete unless the title, track list and release date can be |verified by |reliable sources Deletion of Kellie Pickler (album) WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3563 18984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hungry For Music NONE 02:48, 9 September 2011 (UTC) comment So, is anyone going to actually ''add'' this NPR citation to the article? :-) If not, then I say '''Delete''' for lacking sufficient to satisfy , or even . Happy Editing! — '''{{User|68.239.69.231 Deletion of Hungry For Music WP:RS||WP:NONPROFIT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3564 15107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernstein Medical User:Drchriswilliams 21:37, 29 December 2016 (UTC) delete Reads like an advert. Of the 16 references listed, not one actually has any |depth of coverage of the clinic. While some mention Bernstein, many don't make any mention of his clinic: 1) a feature on hair loss, clinic gets passing mention 2) a quarterback consults Bernstein, clinic has passing mention 3) dead link 4) passing mention for Bernstein, clnic not actually mentioned by name 5) is a press release 6) Bernstein mentioned, clinic not 7) Bernstein quoted quite a bit, but no mention of the clinic itself 8) interview with Bernstein, briefest mention of the location of his clinic 9) lots of people and their workplaces mentioned, including Bernstein and his clinic 10) No mention of Bernstein or his clinic 11) Bernstein is mentioned, clinic is not 12-16) links are not given but text suggests they aren't providing coverage of the clinic itself Deletion of Bernstein Medical :WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
3565 13054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evoke engine User:Pgagnon999 14:11, 19 February 2008 (UTC) comment """Why should it be given time to grow? It is currently not notable. Based on the remarks by the editor of this article, I also have concerns about onflict of interest; this article may be promoting a product created by that user; if so, regardless if profit is gained from the product or not, it may still be pam as it seems to exist for the sake of promoting something. Note that editor indicates that the """"sourcecode is ''going'' to be released into the public Domain. . ."""" which indicates that it is indeed rystal""" Deletion of Evoke engine WP:C||WP:S||WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
3566 5065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dragonfly CMS User:SMcCandlish 21:26, 3 August 2007 (UTC) keep Is under active development by at least two editors, and tagged as such. Does not raise issues at all, any more than any other article on a piece of software. issues likely to be rectified by on-going editing, and that will satisfy . If the editors working on it stop working on it after AfD, AfD it again, noting that promise to fix the article was not met Deletion of Dragonfly CMS WP:SPAM||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Spam 112
3567 15726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abul Kalam Azad (doctor) (2nd nomination) User:Xxanthippe 23:02, 17 June 2014 (UTC) delete No pass of rof Deletion of Abul Kalam Azad (doctor) (2nd nomination) WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
3568 21459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diecast Car Collectors Zone User:Epinoia 01:25, 18 August 2019 (UTC) delete """no references other than the group's website and a domain registration lookup (!) - does not meet which requires that online content """"has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works"""" - fails , and other notability criteria; therefore, delete""" Deletion of Diecast Car Collectors Zone WP:WEBCRIT||WP:GNG||WP:ORGCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3569 17267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SKILLS IN THE GLOBAL ECONOMY: UK MANUFACTURING'S IMAGE AS A CAREER User:Isotope23 17:53, 18 October 2005 (UTC) delete essay appears to violate Deletion of SKILLS IN THE GLOBAL ECONOMY: UK MANUFACTURING'S IMAGE AS A CAREER WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3570 14627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Washington Heights, Manhattan in popular culture User:Rorshacma 16:31, 19 June 2021 (UTC) delete """As mentioned already above, there do not appear any sources that discuss these entries as a group or set, or the concept of """"Washington Heights in Popular Culture"""" as a whole, thus failing that portion of . The actual entries are almost entire just pure trivia along the lines of """"a scene of this show was filmed here"""" or """"it was mentioned once in the lyrics of a song"""", many of which are not referenced to reliable, secondary sources. The few reliable sources included do confirm that yes, a few of these entries definitely were set in the neighborhood, but none of them actually establish why the overarching concept of the topic of this list is notable, or why it would pass either the or """ Deletion of Washington Heights, Manhattan in popular culture WP:LISTN||WP:GNG||WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
3571 20398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013–14 Chester F.C. season User:Fenix 16:01, 18 August 2015 (UTC) delete WP:NSEASONS is quite clear that season articles for clubs are usually only suitable for clubs in top professional leagues. Long standing consensus has been that for the english league system, the fourth tier is the cut off point for this. Ignoring the obvious issues and the failure to adhere to NSEASONS requirement that articles such as this consist mainly of sourced prose, contrary to comments above, none of the articles are well sourced. Not only do almost all the sources provided reference |routine transfers and loan movements rather than any discussion of the season itself, the vast majority of these are from primary sources (often Chester's own website). I am simply not seeing significant, reliable, non-routine coverage of this season in the club's life Deletion of 2013–14 Chester F.C. season WP:NOTSTATS||WP:MILL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3572 15320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Finance Companies in Jaipur User:Fedderlloyds 18:05, 15 October 2020 (UTC) delete Absolutely right, this violates . Should be deleted Deletion of List of Finance Companies in Jaipur WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3573 864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled debut album by Jason Castro User:A 12:27, 7 July 2009 (UTC) delete without prejudice to remaking the article when more information is available. Also consider the |TenPoundHammer principle -- the album doesn't even have a confirmed name or release date Deletion of Untitled debut album by Jason Castro WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
3574 15095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baggio Husidić (2nd nomination) User:Angelo 08:21, 1 May 2009 (UTC) delete per nom, fails Deletion of Baggio Husidić (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3575 13160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlos Soler Barragán User:Kosack 15:13, 3 September 2016 (UTC) delete Fails , having never played in a fully professional league, and does not have enough significant coverage to pass Deletion of Carlos Soler Barragán WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3576 19991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fuckexercise User:Gongshow 19:47, 28 December 2009 (UTC) delete I'm not finding any in-depth coverage; does not appear to meet Deletion of Fuckexercise WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3577 21224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UIC MSA User:Metropolitan90 04:51, 14 April 2010 (UTC) delete Student organizations that exist at only a single school are generally non-notable per , and no independent sources have been provided to establish notability Deletion of UIC MSA WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3578 4338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timeline of fictional future events User:Ian 23:48, 3 January 2010 (UTC) keep Actually Johnbod has made most of the points I intended to. I will just add that simply doesn’t apply, and that the fact that it is entertaining makes it not in the least unencyclopaedic Deletion of Timeline of fictional future events WP:NOTCRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3579 16961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of anagrams User:The 16:18, 26 August 2006 (UTC) delete fails as an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of List of anagrams WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3580 14008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brescia Furniture Fire User:Hut 19:39, 29 July 2009 (UTC) delete I can find quite a few news stories covering it but this is a pretty clear case of #NEWS as this event has virtually no long-term significance Deletion of Brescia Furniture Fire WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3581 16554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norb Vonnegut User:Arxiloxos 04:52, 29 July 2010 (UTC) keep Passes , coverage in multiple reliable sources. Links in the article need some cleaning up (some of them are dead links right now) but the coverage is pretty clearly there Deletion of Norb Vonnegut WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3582 2931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vix from VixPix User:Brewcrewer 01:54, 13 December 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Vix from VixPix WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3583 1415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nirvana Chaudhary User:Brianhe 17:35, 4 October 2015 (UTC) delete agree, obviously non-notable per . I was going to try to rescue any material that could be copied to Binod Chaudhary but couldn't really find anything to keep Deletion of Nirvana Chaudhary WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3584 12961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SAP Smart Forms User:Serial 15:37, 29 August 2019 (UTC) merge per -R|policy: since it has been |verified to exist it is clearly a reasonable search term Deletion of SAP Smart Forms WP:ATD||WP:V Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3585 7849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Cobra characters User:Postdlf 18:14, 24 March 2011 (UTC) keep """per Fortdj33. 1) it's under construction pursuant to a WikiProject discussion, and 2) character lists of this sort are part of standard coverage for media franchises, particularly since they help get rid of character articles that don't merit being stand-alone (think of it as a compromise position, if you will). """"Fictional cruft"""" is not helpful and smacks of """ Deletion of List of Cobra characters WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3586 17407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of countries by formation dates User:Mais 17:33, 17 March 2008 (UTC) delete as one massive big POV-magnet. The entire concept of the article is a breach of and . The History is littered with , and travesties. If someone can provide me with a list of respectable external refs which prove that this is a valid encyclopaedic topic then it would be some progress, because despite many such appeals not one valid ref has ever been provided Deletion of List of countries by formation dates WP:OR||WP:VERIFY||WP:SYNTH||WP:UNDUEWEIGHT||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:No original research 65
3587 8828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Taylor (second baseman) User:Spanneraol 12:32, 13 April 2017 (UTC) delete College baseball all-americans were intentionally admitted from because of their lack of general coverage. Weak professional career.. lack of sourcing that would rise to GNG Deletion of Terry Taylor (second baseman) WP:NSPORTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3588 1608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Linear Programming Language User:Ihcoyc 15:14, 13 November 2009 (UTC) delete """non-consumer software with no showing of |historical or technical importance, also promotional and non-neutral in tone: ''LPL is a powerful modeling language and a full-fetched mathematical modeling system with a point-and-click interface.'' """"Full-fetched""" Deletion of Linear Programming Language WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
3589 9250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 Notre Dame attack User:Inter 19:14, 6 June 2017 (UTC) merge per above and . Also as per Ansh666 points out these types of routines are becoming more and more routine Deletion of 2017 Notre Dame attack WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3590 7776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Action of 11 November 2008 User:BlueVine 02:18, 15 November 2008 (UTC) comment """If I may ask, why do you think the encounter is minor, when it has been stated that the battle is """"believed to be the first time recently that British naval service personnel have been involved in a confrontation that resulted in deaths"""", and """"the first time the Royal Navy had been engaged in a fatal shoot-out on the high seas in living memory""""? As for no lasting notability, according to , notability is not temporary. Thank you in advance if you respond to my query""" Deletion of Action of 11 November 2008 WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3591 4609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Website Magazine User:L337 00:35, 22 November 2007 (UTC) delete per #General criteria|CSD G4: recreation of deleted material. After two speedies this ''still'' hasn't been fixed. Looks unlikely it will at this rate Deletion of Website Magazine WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
3592 9360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shelly Boston User:Bearian 02:14, 9 April 2020 (UTC) keep per after good work by {{U|DaHuzyBru Deletion of Shelly Boston WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
3593 2171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Notable names in anime User:Jay32183 18:36, 31 August 2007 (UTC) delete The list has a subjectively defined scope, therefore, it can't pass . The intention of the list seems to be subjective so the scope cannot be redefined to be acceptable Deletion of Notable names in anime WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3594 15960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sectarian violence among Muslims User:Roscelese 03:14, 1 February 2012 (UTC) delete It's obviously a topic, but Herostratus is right that it would need to be written using scholarly sources, not news sources. Until it's written with appropriate sources, it's unsuitable for mainspace (and there's nothing there worth keeping right now - ), but since the topic is notable, I see no reason not to let the creator have it and keep working on it Deletion of Sectarian violence among Muslims WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
3595 14850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexandros Grigoropoulos User:WWGB 12:18, 10 December 2008 (UTC) delete Notability limited to Deletion of Alexandros Grigoropoulos WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3596 19834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Somewhere in America (album) User:MSJapan 20:30, 12 August 2015 (UTC) comment """WP:NBAND|Band and |album notability criteria are distinct. The soundtrack and single aren't on and aren't relevant to this album. The chart position of the single is not relevant to this album. A playlist from a show, or a half-hour snippet doesn't indicate """"rotation"""". Rotation means it's replayed, and there's no indication of that. The Dayton article is a few questions in a local paper, and it only mentions """"Head Over Heels"""" briefly, which isn't this album. Therefore, none of your sources establish notability for this album""" Deletion of Somewhere in America (album) WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
3597 18986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yogesh Shouche User:David 20:02, 27 January 2018 (UTC) keep per #C1 Deletion of Yogesh Shouche WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3598 1615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xheni Çuni User:Arthistorian1977 15:35, 22 December 2016 (UTC) delete Obviously fails both and Deletion of Xheni Çuni WP:CREATIVE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3599 4806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delone Catholic High School User:Zivko85 07:10, 1 July 2007 (UTC) delete per , OT#IINFO. I am broadly in support of VanTucky's and OIC's comments here Deletion of Delone Catholic High School WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3600 20830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bishop Elijah J. Rasheed User:E 22:27, 10 July 2016 (UTC) delete """because 1.) his bishopric is Presiding Youth Bishop, but because position is not listed among the bishoprics on the Church of God in Christ, it may not be notable. 2.) He is the """"youth pastor,"""" not the Pastor of Showers of Blessings Church Of God In Christ in Sacramento, California http://www.showersofblessingscogic.org/pastor.html. 3.) Sacramento's Showers of Blessings Church Of God In Christ lacks a WP page, and does not show up well in a google news search https://www.google.com/#q=%22Showers+of+Blessings+Church+Of+God+In+Christ%22+++Sacramento&tbm=nws 4.) """"Elijah J. Rasheed"""" gets no hits on a google news search https://www.google.com/#q=%22Elijah+J.+Rasheed%22&tbm=nws, """"Elijah Rasheed"""" gets none; and the sole hit on """"Bishop Rasheed"""" https://www.google.com/#q=%22Bishop+Rasheed%22&tbm=nws is for someone else. May be a simple matter of ; youth pastors are often quite young""" Deletion of Bishop Elijah J. Rasheed WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3601 14550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vietnamese in Brunei User:The_Determinator 04:31, 4 December 2012 (UTC) delete per above and '''The Determinator Deletion of Vietnamese in Brunei WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
3602 9717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ava Addams User:Rebecca1990 10:03, 10 December 2013 (UTC) keep """Passes both and . The AVN Award|AVN and XBIZ Awards are both well-known and significant awards and PORNBIO only excludes scene-related and ensemble categories. Consensus hasn't determined that MILF performer awards aren't notable, in fact, I think #2 of PORNBIO reinforces this categories importance. #2 of PORNBIO states """"has made unique contributions to a specific pornographic genre"""", in this case, MILF pornography. The AVN and XBIZ MILF categories have no more than 15 nominees each year, and it's usually the same performers over and over again. Out of perhaps hundreds or even thousands of older female performers in the entire industry active in the MILF genre, being one of the 15 each year to be nominated is evidence that this performer has made unique contributions to this specific pornographic genre, especially if they are nominated more than once and by different ceremonies. And also, let me remind you all that PORNBIO isn't defunct and while it may be tagged as disputed, Wikipedia talk:Notability (people)#PORNBIO again|this discussion has been inactive for two months. PORNBIO is a valid guideline and Ava Addams passes it""" Deletion of Ava Addams WP:PORNBIO||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3603 10541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mathew L. Golsteyn User:JzG 13:13, 3 January 2019 (UTC) delete this , but a smerge/redirect may be appropriate if the news incident re pardons continues Deletion of Mathew L. Golsteyn WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3604 8904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ikenna Aniekwe User:December200 13:27, 17 May 2020 (UTC) delete """Lack of reliable primary sources to show that the subject passes the criteria from. The reference """"nollywoodforever.com"""" is not a reliable source on Wikipedia""" Deletion of Ikenna Aniekwe WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3605 19874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrzej Tkacz (actor) User:Piotrus 03:35, 27 January 2021 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON at best, failure of Deletion of Andrzej Tkacz (actor) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3606 407 [[A pandabear nightmare]] (schnellgelöscht) Benutzer:Zaphiro 02:45, 10. Jul. 2010 (CEST) delete Nette Werbung Laudatio (ohne Belege), aber Amazon und Co schweigen sich aus, als klarer Bandspam, eher , vgl Löschung von A pandabear nightmare Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
3607 2035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wink (game) User:The 00:16, 29 October 2011 (UTC) delete WP:ITEXISTS, but |WP:ITFAILSTHEGNG Deletion of Wink (game) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3608 81 [[Alternative für Deutschland]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Fröhlicher Türke NONE delete der artikelteil http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_f%C3%BCr_Deutschland#Parteiprogramm Parteiprogramm besteht ausschließlich aus fast wörtlicher wiedergabe https://www.alternativefuer.de/programm.html dieser spannenden quelle. bis hin zur anordnung im artikel. abgesehen vom verdacht auf |urheberrechtsverletzung verkommt der artikel zu einem werbepamphlet für die splittergruppe. auch eine art de.wiki zu nutzen. mein hinweis darauf wurde übrigens diskret aus dem http://de.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Alternative_f%C3%BCr_Deutschland&diff=next&oldid=115441898 löschantrag entsorgt Löschung von Alternative für Deutschland Wikipedia:Urheberrechte beachten Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
3609 21517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1895 Larink User:Praemonitus 19:04, 11 May 2015 (UTC) merge per : concur with above Deletion of 1895 Larink WP:DWMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3610 7716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Mahnken User:RGTraynor 16:20, 9 May 2008 (UTC) comment """At what point does the """"significant """"cult"""" following"""" element of kick in""" Deletion of Larry Mahnken WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3611 8853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LUEshi (7th nomination) User:Quirex 03:04, 10 December 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and . (Has anyone looked for sources Deletion of LUEshi (7th nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3612 3945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Londonistan (term) User:JamesBurns 00:48, 19 January 2009 (UTC) keep Article is reasonably well written. Precedent already set with Helengrad (vote was to keep), and I must admit I never heard of Helengrad until I read this AfD. The term Londonistan has already been used in a published title by author Melanie Phillips. PS. The argument that because some people find the term offensive therefore it must be deleted, is not a valid reason for deletion, see Deletion of Londonistan (term) WP:NOTCENSORED Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3613 3917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crocker Highlands Elementary School User:TerriersFan 18:13, 29 February 2008 (UTC) keep first of all the nomination lacks any grounds on which to base deletion. Also, in addition to the source above, there are enough sources available to meet . Following the paralysis of a student caught up in a shooting the school has had significant media coverage, for instance http://www.ktvu.com/news/15059075/detail.html here. Also there has been coverage of a book that the students published, for example http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P1-3985697.html here. Further, the school was a pilot for a new staff selection process http://moreresults.factiva.com/results/index/index.aspx?ref=CCT0000020070105e31500049 here and the school has been the focus of efforts to encourage parents to keep their children within the public school system http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=CC&s_site=contracostatimes&p_multi=CC&p_theme=realcities&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=1064A15232F45AC9&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM here Deletion of Crocker Highlands Elementary School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3614 15757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David After Dentist (2nd nomination) User:Rhododendrites 02:26, 1 May 2015 (UTC) keep Easily passes . &mdash Deletion of David After Dentist (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3615 11165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Summers (2nd nomination) User:Tarc 03:45, 28 March 2015 (UTC) delete """Notability and """"groundbreaking"""" have to be proven, not cited to one's memory of flipping through a review in a porn magazine 20 years ago. So we're left with the usual non-notable porn industry links, non-notable films, and so on. failure""" Deletion of Jamie Summers (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3616 1787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New York Marriott Marquis User:Oakshade 14:13, 7 July 2007 (UTC) keep """Per above. Very notable location, size and hotel company. NYT refs alone above to boot. The nom's """"A big concrete slab of a hotel"""" is a very obvious example of """ Deletion of New York Marriott Marquis WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3617 18645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gregory Boyle (psychologist) User:David 00:07, 30 June 2015 (UTC) keep I'm less impressed by the h-index, and more by the fact that he has five publications with over 100 citations each in his Google Scholar profile https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=utmzar4AAAAJ, but regardless I agree that he passes #C1 Deletion of Gregory Boyle (psychologist) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3618 3754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Backstreet Boys' eighth studio album User:Lawrencekhoo 04:17, 31 December 2012 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Backstreet Boys' eighth studio album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3619 15988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siobhan Thompson User:LACaliNYC 22:07, 9 December 2018 (UTC) delete Obviously fails the and . This is case of Deletion of Siobhan Thompson WP:GNG||WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
3620 21775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Refind Technologies User:CNMall41 18:33, 22 February 2017 (UTC) delete Fails . There are a few references out there, but nothing I could find that was in-depth to establish notability Deletion of Refind Technologies WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3621 18017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/3D's User:Ultraexactzz 13:21, 31 January 2008 (UTC) comment While I believe that this topic could indeed be notable (with a renamed article), none of the sources I see here can be |verified to use the term as discussed in the article. The PDF source (from JR EAST Technical Review) doesn't use the term at all, so far as I can see, and I can't evaluate the other sources. Further, the reference to Television shows that document jobs of this nature (Dirty jobs, et al) might be synthesis or , as it's unsupported by sources and seems to describe what the production of a particular series might ''imply''. I'm neutral about deletion, but there are some significant issues to resolve if the article is indeed to be kept Deletion of 3D's WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3622 8838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southern Stars User:Phil 19:45, 30 September 2011 (UTC) comment """This does not fail (or pass) , because there is no criterion there by which to judge clubs outside England and Australia, just a note that """"it is necessary to take an individual view about each country in terms of its own grassroots structure""" Deletion of Southern Stars WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
3623 14813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bradley Tomlinson User:GiantSnowman 19:05, 16 May 2013 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Bradley Tomlinson WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3624 7649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Babieca.com User:Snottywong 00:09, 25 February 2011 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails Deletion of Babieca.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3625 7845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/L'aeiou a.k.a. The Vowels User:Revolving 14:59, 12 January 2008 (UTC) delete No significant independent coverage, so not |verifiable Deletion of L'aeiou a.k.a. The Vowels WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3626 18605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manuel Gonzalez Hernandez User:Captain 22:38, 28 October 2008 (UTC) keep I agree with everyone else. He passes Deletion of Manuel Gonzalez Hernandez WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3627 21039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madan Gowri (2nd nomination) User:Suneye1 13:17, 11 July 2021 (UTC) keep the subject is mostly a youtuber with 5 million subscribers known widely in one state of Tamil Nadu, India and there is a lot of news sources in Tamil language about him. He is certainly notable from the Tamil sources. I could find three sources with in English.{{Cite web|date=2020-06-26|title=Beauty of the internet is that we can break pre-conceived notions: Madan Gowri|url=https://www.hindustantimes.com/more-lifestyle/beauty-of-the-internet-is-that-we-can-break-pre-conceived-notions-madan-gowri/story-xPNlmPUxTlAb0rgf9ROxbM.html|access-date=2021-07-11|website=Hindustan Times|language=en}}{{Cite web|date=2019-01-19|title=From science to history, how YouTuber Madan Gowri’s Tamil explainers became a hit|url=https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/science-history-how-youtuber-madan-gowri-s-tamil-explainers-became-hit-95309|access-date=2021-07-11|website=The News Minute|language=en}}{{Cite web|date=2020-06-06|title=Need more regional content online, says YouTuber Madan|url=https://www.deccanherald.com/metrolife/metrolife-lifestyle/need-more-regional-content-online-says-youtuber-madan-846456.html|access-date=2021-07-11|website=Deccan Herald|language=en Deletion of Madan Gowri (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
3628 11303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roman Weaver User:Dlohcierekim 00:47, 31 May 2008 (UTC) delete """On close reading, not sure there's a assertion of notability in the article. Once again, there is a problem of verifiability even for that which is asserted. There is no significant media coverage that I can find. Unable to locate |reliable sources supporting a claim of |notability on reviewing http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Roman+Weaver%22&start=90&sa=N about 90 Unique Google hits. I did find information about Roman weavers, that is weavers in Ancient Rome, who were apparently a highly skilled lot. Search for the full """"Roman Jason Cory Weaver"""" came up empty. There was a http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Roman+Jason+Weaver+%22 handful of hits for """"Roman Jason Weaver"""" that did not look like they fit the bill. They did not seem concerned with the content of this article. A search through Allmusic did not support notability. He is not mentioned on the Allmusic page about """"Fusebox"""". I found a """"Jason Weaver on IMDB, but I think it is someone else. Cheers""" Deletion of Roman Weaver WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3629 7802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wolf (Wolf album) User:Michig 21:41, 25 March 2013 (UTC) comment How did you determine that it fails and ? First place I looked was Allmusic, where I found http://www.allmusic.com/album/wolf-mw0000331554 this review. For a band and album called 'Wolf', Googling is going to be difficult Deletion of Wolf (Wolf album) WP:GNG||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3630 21336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angular Material User:Epinoia 00:18, 28 August 2019 (UTC) merge """to Angular (web framework) where it is mentioned as a component of that framework 5 times - the five books referenced in the Angular Material article are all about using Angular (web framework) and using Angular Material as part of Angular projects, so it is not notable outside of that context - If the article can only be understood by experienced writers and IT experts, then it falls under """"Wikipedia is not a manual, guidebook, textbook, or scientific journal"""" . |Writing better articles says that articles should be """"accessible and understandable for as many readers as possible"""" and """"Aim for a balance between comprehensibility and detail so that readers can gain information from the article"""" and should """"make sense if the reader gets to it as a random page"""" and """"if we cannot explain to readers why something is important, then it is not important"""" - I can't see any way that this is important as a stand-alone article, therefore, redirect to main article""" Deletion of Angular Material WP:NOTMANUAL||WP:WBA Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3631 20590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank (language game) User:JohnCD 20:50, 4 December 2007 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not for things made up one day Deletion of Frank (language game) WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
3632 21846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeremy Corbyn leadership campaign, 2015 User:My 13:22, 30 August 2015 (UTC) merge to Labour Party (UK) leadership election, 2015 and '''merge''' content of use into Jeremy Corbyn. While Corbyn has more popularity, it does give undue weight to one candidate. The article also feels a little |crystal-ball like Deletion of Jeremy Corbyn leadership campaign, 2015 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3633 13694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christine Smith (activist) User:Bearian 18:02, 12 December 2007 (UTC) delete as one of many wannabees. No for ? Deleteography Deletion of Christine Smith (activist) WP:RS||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3634 5411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Curtis Brown User:GoldenAgeFan1 12:32, 9 April 2020 (UTC) keep The subject's 56-episode stint in ''Search for Tomorrow'', his recurring roles in various TV series and his film appearances are sufficient for the purposes of . The sources that Deletion of Robert Curtis Brown WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3635 1864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jane McIvor User:Kagundu 07:34, 16 February 2016 (UTC) delete could not find any significant coverage from third party sources to pass . Also the cases mentioned do not meet threshold for general notability to be included on Wikipedia Deletion of Jane McIvor WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3636 17845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diego Prado Jaramillo User:Whiteguru 12:20, 5 May 2011 (UTC) delete The information here is likely as it appears in a number of other sources in search results. It is unclear which competition this University now competes in as the team has merged with Brixton Topcats. Does not satisfy so delete is somewhat inevitable Deletion of Diego Prado Jaramillo WP:COPYVIO||WP:NSPORTS Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
3637 356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Secular Homeschooling User:WikiDan61 22:02, 6 July 2015 (UTC) comment It's not clear that there is a lot of validly sourced material to merge. I'm not entirely sure the article wasn't created merely as a |coatrack for the links to the secular homeschooling website that its primary source Deletion of Secular Homeschooling WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
3638 241 [[Schlitzenhausen]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Crito NONE delete Wieviele Kleinstgemeinden gibts eigentlich? Verkraftet die Wikipedia überhaupt technisch so viele Artikel? Wollt ihr die Wikipedia zu Tode schreiben?. Spaß beiseite: #St.C3.A4dte.2C_Gemeinden_u..C3.A4.|Relevanz ist zwar laut WP-Kriterien gegeben, aber Artikel ist einfach nicht ausbaufähig, daher (meine rein subjektive Meinung Löschung von Schlitzenhausen Wikipedia:Relevanz Wikipedia:Notability 77
3639 14621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Subornation of false muster User:JFHJr 02:21, 9 October 2012 (UTC) delete http://web.archive.org/web/20060721005125/http://www.pensacolanewsjournal.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20060718/NEWS01/607180319/1006 This kind of thing doesn't establish it's even an actual term. I agree coverage is insufficient to indicate the concept meets . If it were an actual term, Wiktionary might be a better place. But it's not Deletion of Subornation of false muster WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3640 2357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magic: The Gathering deck types (4rd nomination) User:Hornpipe2 20:07, 11 August 2017 (UTC) delete """Basically . The article is not necessary """"bad"""" and the editors have clearly gone to great lengths to source info and make it seem as notable and legit as possible - but at the end of the day, the subject itself is just Too Niche to warrant its own space. No amount of citations from WotC and Star City Games is going to help with that aspect. See also Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/List_of_Yu-Gi-Oh!_Deck_Formats_and_Strategies""" Deletion of Magic: The Gathering deck types (4rd nomination) WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3641 219 [[KESO]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Tom_md NONE delete Relevanz nach #U o.ä. im Artikel nicht nachgewiesen Löschung von KESO Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
3642 13477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Free Range Studios User:My 07:55, 11 September 2006 (UTC) keep per VegaDark. Marginal on the usual criteria but the company's projects appear exceptional Deletion of Free Range Studios WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3643 12552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Casio Exilim EX-S600 User:Kinu 17:03, 17 September 2006 (UTC) delete if there is any useful content (i.e., that does not read like a product review), then it should be merged into Casio Exilim and the page should be redirected there. Information on the various models of this line of camera may be useful for comparison purposes in that main article, but as it stands, a page on each individual model seems unencyclopedic, and seems to provide a magnet for addition of |POV content that would turn Wikipedia into epinions.com Deletion of Casio Exilim EX-S600 WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
3644 6891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vortexis User:onel5969 12:27, 31 March 2016 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability. Searches did not turn up anywhere near enough in-depth coverage to pass . Most mentions were not to this subject, but different uses of the term Deletion of Vortexis WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3645 11716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islamic Perspective on Human Rights User:XavierItzm 11:17, 4 April 2018 (UTC) delete Essay based on primary sources. For the article to even exist, essentially it would have to be deleted and re-built using Deletion of Islamic Perspective on Human Rights WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3646 3736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad-Hashem Mohaymeni User:Phil 18:26, 22 September 2010 (UTC) keep If the source confirms that the subject is a provincial governor then he clearly passes . Would we even consider deleting an article about the governor of a US state Deletion of Mohammad-Hashem Mohaymeni WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
3647 8717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Law & Order plot inspirations User:Pax 09:58, 16 May 2007 (UTC) delete """There seem to be no sources where the writers explicitly say that """"episode X was based on case Y"""", so the article fails . Since that connection constitutes the very essence of the article it follows that the article should be deleted""" Deletion of List of Law & Order plot inspirations WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3648 20443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Strabane Square User:Evb 16:08, 27 November 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. shopping complex, without or an assertion of Deletion of Strabane Square WP:NN||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3649 1887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of stalked celebrities User:Moreschi 22:11, 16 February 2007 (UTC) delete per nom and everyone else. #INFO|Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of List of stalked celebrities WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3650 6909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tau (mathematics) User:Andy 20:24, 2 July 2011 (UTC) keep This has been around for ten years now, and has recently been covered by New Scientist and BBC Radio 4 (and that's just in the UK). Those alone are enough to demonstraate - end of story. We don't need articles for ''both'' Michael Hartl and Tau, but we should cover this issue, under at least one of those name, with a redirect from the other. Mathematicians who think it's a nonsense are simply irrelevant - the point is that the campaign exists and is notable, not whether it's right or wrong. As a physicist more than a mathematician, it also make a lot of sense from my viewpoint Deletion of Tau (mathematics) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3651 4519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AGM-30 engine User:Ahunt 16:26, 12 August 2013 (UTC) delete seems to be non-notable, all refs are from the manufacturer and promotional in origin and thus the article does not make Deletion of AGM-30 engine WP:SPS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3652 15274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hildebrandt Intermediate School User:XDanielx 07:41, 3 August 2007 (UTC) keep as a somewhat useful article, at least potentially if not currently. It might not have the name recognition of Chuck Norris, but if I were considering sending my kids there I'd appreciate an informative description of the place. Remember and Deletion of Hildebrandt Intermediate School WP:SENSE||WP:IGNORE "Wikipedia:What ""Ignore all rules"" means" 62
3653 16322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Planet-4D User:Mark 18:54, 15 January 2014 (UTC) delete The Arxiv paper mentioned above was by Amiot, a collaborator of Baroin, so independence is questionable. I was unable to find independent sources discussing this topic and so it seems to fail general notability guidelines per . I agree that this may be a case of for RS to develop Deletion of Planet-4D WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
3654 5320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camp Deer Run User:RebeccaGreen 09:05, 27 August 2019 (UTC) comment I have found some coverage about camps called Deer Run in Newspapers.com, but it will take time to work out where the camps are located (Texas, Pennsylvania, New Hampshire, New York ...), and how much coverage relates to these particular camps (why two in one article?). Per , the state of sourcing within an article is not a reason to delete, and the nominator does not indicate that they have done a thorough , particularly in historical sources Deletion of Camp Deer Run WP:NEXIST||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3655 3192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Alexander (1982- ) User:Dhartung 10:30, 27 July 2007 (UTC) delete fails . Insufficient attribution of notability to independent third parties Deletion of James Alexander (1982- ) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3656 3308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Hall Effect User:Edison 02:29, 10 November 2009 (UTC) delete Fails and is an annoying ripoff of Hall Effect. Should have (Band) as part of article name. By the way: If an electric current were passed through this band in the presence of a perpendicular magnetic field (not that I am suggesting for a moment that should be done) would a voltage appear across the band in the transverse direction? I think not Deletion of The Hall Effect WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3657 20961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nevermas User:Mallocks 16:52, 7 October 2005 (UTC) delete """will debut"""", no albums, no tours, no label, fails """ Deletion of Nevermas WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3658 6158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yehoshua Rubin User:J04n 12:50, 25 June 2011 (UTC) delete unable to find significant coverage in |reliable sources independent of the subject of this unsourced |BLP Deletion of Yehoshua Rubin WP:RS||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3659 18459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adejinle User:Davidpdx 10:54, 1 January 2007 (UTC) delete NN, fails Deletion of Adejinle WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3660 17085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GHMC Corporator User:Jeffrd10 19:08, 21 January 2014 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of GHMC Corporator WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3661 21388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bye Bye Birdie Live! User:Aoba47 18:37, 28 February 2017 (UTC) merge to Bye Bye Birdie#Bye Bye Birdie Live!|Bye Bye Birdie § Bye Bye Birdie Live! as per -M. This can be recreated in the future if/when this occurs, but right now I agree with the nominator and the above commentators Deletion of Bye Bye Birdie Live! WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3662 15721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zed (comics) User:TTN 22:10, 29 September 2020 (UTC) delete Fails , neither source in the article currently providing sufficient coverage Deletion of Zed (comics) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3663 15431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PGC Studios User:MichaelQSchmidt 05:54, 23 April 2016 (UTC) delete per being failing and being (at kindest) |TOO SOON. While nice that this young filmmaker created a production company, he and it have not yet gained the requisite coverage in reliable sources. And while conceivable that some of his/its short films ''might'' have notability, that has yet to be determined. Worse here is the |COI of author {{u|ChloeHendrickson}} who is likely promoting the company http://www.imdb.com/name/nm7357896/?ref_=fn_al_nm_1n because '''she''' has involvement in some of its films. She really needs to visit and Deletion of PGC Studios WP:ORG||WP:NYA||WP:COI||WP:PRIMER||WP:NAU Wikipedia:Notability 77
3664 12638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Aliffi User:ArsenalFan700 21:40, 9 August 2013 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Daniel Aliffi WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3665 103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Walsh (designer) User:APerson 17:09, 6 March 2015 (UTC) keep Just from a Google search I found five sources (although two, the designboom and yatzer ones, might not be exactly |independent sources): the ''http://www.independent.ie/life/home-garden/the-wood-magician-furniture-designer-joseph-walsh-30666713.html Irish Independent'', ''http://www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/homes-and-property/the-specialist-joseph-walsh-furniture-designer-1.1931809 The Irish Times'', http://yatzer.com/magnus-celestii-joseph-walsh yatzer, http://www.designboom.com/design/joseph-walsh-studio-magnus-celestii-07-04-2014/ designboom, and http://www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/homes-and-property/cool-crafts-in-cork-joseph-walsh-and-the-art-of-making-1.2092380 another ''Irish Times'' article Deletion of Joseph Walsh (designer) WP:IS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3666 19887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ratana Burapharat User:Coredesat 04:14, 9 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Ratana Burapharat WP:NOR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
3667 7695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of insurgent fatality reports in Iraq User:PeterSymonds 09:07, 5 September 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of insurgent fatality reports in Iraq WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
3668 11106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Thomson affair User:Trevj 08:58, 21 June 2012 (UTC) keep per , . A merge to Craig Thomson (politician) would give the subject |undue weight there. The main article has a readable prose size of just 3174 bytes, and the article under discussion here 5710, so extensive paring down would be needed for a viable merge to take place Deletion of Craig Thomson affair WP:EVENT||WP:NOTCENSORED||WP:undue weight Wikipedia:Notability 77
3669 13369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sudanese goat marriage incident (2nd nomination) User:LonelyBeacon 05:16, 23 July 2008 (UTC) delete per and per #NEWS. I can find more coverage for my high school football team Deletion of Sudanese goat marriage incident (2nd nomination) WP:NOTMEMORIAL||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3670 0 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Celebrity news User:ST47 15:50, 20 August 2006 (UTC) delete as per a dictionary Deletion of Celebrity news WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3671 18126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Curtis Allen User:Fenix 11:24, 16 August 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Curtis Allen WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3672 12654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ActiveMedia User:TerriersFan 04:09, 24 December 2007 (UTC) delete Potentially notable. However, they haven't actually won any awards and there are no reliable sources attesting to the notability of their products. It also fails with no critical reviews - what are the problems (all such products have them)? There is also a clear . If this is truly notable an independent person will come along and write a less promotional piece Deletion of ActiveMedia WP:NPOV||WP:COI Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
3673 10294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paris Conservatory Flute Concours User:Bibliopole5795 03:07, 9 March 2021 (UTC) merge Although there is some good content here, it doesn't meet to be stand-alone. Agree with nom that it could be merged/redirected with Conservatoire de Paris, probably in its history section Deletion of Paris Conservatory Flute Concours WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3674 18214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1000 NICKS User:TCN7JM 04:04, 17 August 2013 (UTC) delete This band does not pass any of the criteria listed in . It doesn't even seem to pass the GNG Deletion of 1000 NICKS WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3675 820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mama Ngina User:The 12:40, 23 July 2006 (UTC) delete per , and . Can't see any reason why she is 'celebrated Deletion of Mama Ngina WP:NN||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3676 65 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magic in Once Upon a Time User:Mangoe 17:55, 5 March 2018 (UTC) delete this painfully y Deletion of Magic in Once Upon a Time WP:FANCRUFT||WP:ESSAY Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
3677 10390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Audra (band) User:doomsdayer520 01:01, 13 April 2020 (UTC) keep This a case of as the article needs to be improved with better sources, and this does not mean that the band is non-notable. As said above, each of their albums got pretty robust reviews from AllMusic. Their name makes a basic search for sources difficult, but search for the name in conjunction with an album title and some more {partially) reliable sources come up, such as https://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/music/audra-the-lunchbox-september-27-11362798, http://stereoembersmagazine.com/the-right-spark-at-the-right-time-audras-dear-tired-friends Deletion of Audra (band) WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
3678 16361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Retribution Engine User:Pmedema 03:53, 23 February 2017 (UTC) delete While looking for |sources I didn't find any that could pass. The personal reviews that I was seeing were even saying that there have been no significant creations on this gaming engine. Fails . My search got better results with looking up Retribution gaming (or game) engine Deletion of Retribution Engine WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3679 15531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam B. Taylor User:Celarnor 20:32, 17 May 2008 (UTC) delete First source is a trivial mention, second source contains a few trivial mentions (if there were more of these, it would probably be different, though still borderline), and the rest are just tables of data. Nothing to suggest he passes |BIO or even |general notability Deletion of Sam B. Taylor WP:BIO||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3680 16516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Somphone Sichaleune User:Traveling 04:47, 20 October 2014 (UTC) delete """Per guideline , """"ambassadorships are not considered international offices."""" The criterion for inclusion then falls back to having significant coverage. So far, no one has managed to find it. I have failed as well. It's certainly possibly it exists in another language, but we need actual evidence""" Deletion of Somphone Sichaleune WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
3681 1184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Footvolley User:RHaworth 17:07, 11 August 2008 (UTC) merge to footvolley. This article is a simple |fork. &mdash Deletion of American Footvolley WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
3682 11058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Audrey Tomason User:Off2riorob 18:36, 10 May 2011 (UTC) delete no objection to a redirect to the The Situation Room (photograph) article - no objection to recreation at a time when or if there are more than a to report Deletion of Audrey Tomason WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3683 444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poverty in Tanzania (2nd nomination) User:Neutrality 13:54, 12 September 2016 (UTC) delete It is possible that someday a well-sourced article can be written on this notable topic, but right now the piece of an un-salvageable disjointed personal essay. applies here. Alternatively, we could '''redirect''' to Economy of Tanzania Deletion of Poverty in Tanzania (2nd nomination) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
3684 14700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Veda Scott (2nd nomination) User:Dirtlawyer1 17:05, 23 July 2014 (UTC) comment """Ping|Starship.paint}} As I am sure you know, Google hits are meaningless for purposes of determining notability per and . Have you reviewed these sources in any depth? I've just waded through several dozen, and I am not impressed. Most, if not all, of these sources appear to be fansites, blogs or industry promotional sites, and the """"Veda Scott"""" mentions seem to be coverage or trivial one-sentence mentions. Lots of video clips, too. Can you pull five or six sources out of the 300+ which are (a) reliable sources per , (b) independent sources, i.e., not industry promotions, and (c) include significant, non-trivial coverage of Veda Scott individually? Oh, and don't forget: multiple stories/articles from the same website, newspaper or other publication count as a single source, and we need multiple sources to establish notability""" Deletion of Veda Scott (2nd nomination) WP:ENT||WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3685 5322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warx2 (2nd nomination) User:Auric 22:40, 8 March 2014 (UTC) delete Not because it it isn't notable, simply because it's |too soon. Hasn't been released yet and hasn't been reviewed Deletion of Warx2 (2nd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3686 3893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional books from non-print media User:Clarityfiend 19:34, 5 February 2020 (UTC) delete per flurries. I've also nominated its periodical counterpart Deletion of List of fictional books from non-print media WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
3687 13629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Anderson (mathematician) User:McGeddon 00:26, 8 December 2006 (UTC) delete one Slashdotted item of minor local news coverage isn't enough for . He has his own web site to explain his identity Deletion of James Anderson (mathematician) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3688 6357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/War criminals in Canada User:Bwilkins 12:24, 19 May 2012 (UTC) comment I also have issues with the articles neutrality and there are comments on the talkpage of the article in this regards - a template I added has been removed without addressing the content issues by the above user - http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=War_criminals_in_Canada&diff=493316837&oldid=493289388 diff - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Bwilkins#War_criminals_in_Canada This discussion about the article on Deletion of War criminals in Canada WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
3689 13426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rubik's Cube in popular culture user:Andrew 18:47, 1 May 2021 (UTC) keep """It's easy to find more sources such as ''https://www.theneweuropean.co.uk/brexit-news/roger-domeneghetti-on-the-rubik-s-cube-chronicles-92576 this'' and so it passes and , """"''If editing can improve the page, this should be done rather than deleting the page""" Deletion of Rubik's Cube in popular culture WP:LISTN||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
3690 12523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaosarah Adeyi User:Bearcat 01:25, 8 June 2021 (UTC) delete Being an unelected political advisor is not an automatic notability freebie under , but the sourcing is not solid enough to get her over for it Deletion of Kaosarah Adeyi WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3691 3494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ghost Train (2011 film) User:Hobbes 03:27, 15 October 2011 (UTC) delete Nothing about the company or participants in this project suggests that it would ever become notable, even if it ever does get filmed. Fails big-time--zero worthwhile Ghits. WP is not a and Deletion of Ghost Train (2011 film) WP:GNG||WP:CRYSTALBALL||WP:NOTPROMOTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
3692 3113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Level Up! Games User:Cabe6403 12:02, 22 October 2012 (UTC) keep """Per Turlo. Although some portions of the text appear to be marketing Hyperbole, e.g. """"With nearly eight years and a pioneer in the market, The Level Up! Games Brazil (sometimes abbreviated as LUG! Brazil) has..."""". I'd like to see these parts rewritten or removed to bring it back to """ Deletion of Level Up! Games WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
3693 8207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Live Steam & Outdoor Railroading (magazine) User:Arxiloxos 06:13, 13 July 2012 (UTC) keep """per 's provision for significant """"niche"""" publications. GNews and GBooks do produce some decent hits using the search string , at least enough to persuade me that this is worth keeping""" Deletion of Live Steam & Outdoor Railroading (magazine) WP:NME Wikipedia:Notability 77
3694 16911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Colors (band) User:J04n 21:25, 29 October 2009 (UTC) delete """Does not meet , article states they are an """"influential rock and roll band"""" but can find no to support or even hint at this. Their releases were not on a major indie label, no evidence of a national tour""" Deletion of The Colors (band) WP:BAND||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3695 14041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LUCY Gateway User:Jasynnash2 10:38, 22 May 2008 (UTC) delete as well referenced spam article, the subject of which fails , |notability, and |verifiable Deletion of LUCY Gateway WP:CORP||WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
3696 17756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Morgana Davies User:Armbrust 12:18, 19 August 2010 (UTC) merge The article is a |BLP Deletion of Morgana Davies WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3697 21636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Mulshine [[User talk:Crotalus horridus|*** Crotalus ***]] 21:39, 7 January 2011 (UTC) delete on the basis that there don't appear to be any reliable, third-party sources of which Mr. Mulshine is the primary subject. Thus the article fails our |verifiability policy and our |inclusion guidelines for biographies Deletion of Paul Mulshine WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3698 15953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hank Green NONE 05:16, 4 August 2007 (UTC) delete """he IS notable per . Under """"Entertainers"""": Has a large fan base or a significant """"cult"""" following. BenL""" Deletion of Hank Green WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3699 15053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Work Management User:Ihcoyc 14:41, 19 May 2010 (UTC) delete Work Management is a strategy for planning and getting work done through people. The management of work is distributed through most people involved (not just managers).... Key components to be managed are:* People - doing the work and affected by the work (stakeholders),* Tasks – what needs to be achieved,* Actions – the work to complete tasks, and* Management processes –processes that make work flowWork management coordinates the dynamic relationships between the key components, so work gets done. Work management uses a distributed management paradigm and technology, rather than traditional manager centric approaches....''If somebody I managed started to |write like this, they'd be cleaning out their desk Deletion of Work Management WP:CB Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
3700 14200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Wang Yue User:Jizhu2011 21:06, 22 October 2011 (UTC) keep """According to , """"if a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to satisfy the inclusion criteria for a stand-alone article or stand-alone list"""". I think coverage in New York Times http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/19/world/asia/toddlers-accident-sets-off-soul-searching-in-china.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=Wang%20Yue&st=cse, Washington Post http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia-pacific/toddler-in-china-hit-by-2-cars-then-ignored-dies/2011/10/21/gIQAmamL2L_story.html, CNN and multiple world wide media in multiple languages completely satisfies the requirement for notability. Plus, not to be disrepectful, Phan Thi Kim Phuc http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phan_Thi_Kim_Phuc is most notable for her appearance in Nick Ut's photograph. Hazel Massery http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hazel_Massery is most notable for her shouting at Elizabeth Eckford. They enjoy their own page in wikipedia mostly because of one famous photo. I would argue this video is no less famous than these photos, as it has been viewed tens of millions time over the globe. Plus, this page is not about a person, but an event, as pointed out by numerous people ahead of me. If this article is deleted, then the other pages should be marked for deletion as well. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of Death of Wang Yue WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3701 7993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DYNU-TV User:VMS 08:19, 10 November 2015 (UTC) merge per if it is a relay as stated here, otherwise if it does original programming, then '''Keep Deletion of DYNU-TV WP:BCAST Wikipedia:Notability 77
3702 8982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Adventures of Dr. McNinja (fourth nomination) User:Dragonfiend 18:04, 10 June 2006 (UTC) comment This is not the second deletion nomination for this topic; it is the fifth. It has been AFDed and deleted three times, and deleted through once Deletion of The Adventures of Dr. McNinja (fourth nomination) WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
3703 7169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Russell (disc jockey) User:Rameshnta909 17:50, 16 December 2016 (UTC) keep Notable in his field. I think it passes Deletion of Tom Russell (disc jockey) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3704 4464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Preetha P V User:onel5969 16:00, 19 September 2015 (UTC) delete as per nom and above editors. Nothing in the search engines to show this person meets either or Deletion of Preetha P V WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3705 5262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brady R. Allred User:Edtropolis 18:06, 13 June 2007 (UTC) keep Meets criteria of . Needs improvement, though. User got bad nom faith Deletion of Brady R. Allred WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3706 5059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suman Sahai User:RayAYang 18:57, 29 April 2013 (UTC) keep People who pass the GNG because of plagiarism or other scientific misconduct are still notable, even if they otherwise would not have been. The article in this case is from a RS, and discusses the subject's misconduct in depth and at length, as well as the significance of the plagiarism in the context of her relatively prominent role otherwise. Subject may well have passed without this controversy, this simply guarantees it Deletion of Suman Sahai WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3707 152 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/17-18 Ocak 2016 Şırnak saldırıları """Kullanıcı:maurice flesiermaurice flesier""" 10.57, 21 Mayıs 2019 (UTC) keep """Bir konu kendisinden bağımsız, önemli, güvenilir, birden çok ikincil kaynaklarca içerik edilmiş veya kapsanmışsa kayda değerdir."""" 'nin bu tek kriteri bile kalması için kâfi. Kaldı ki o yukarıda aktarılması tavsiye edilen, örgüt propagandasının çok mükemmel bir biçimde işlendiği kokuşmuş maddeye aktarılacağı fikri nasıl oluştu? Bir saldırı maddesi olarak doğrudan parçası olan PKK saldırıları (2015-günümüz) maddesi de bir seçenek. Veya Hendek operasyonları'da aynı şekilde. Dediğim gibi aktarılması için politikalar açısından ikna edici bir gerekçe göremiyorum""" 17-18 Ocak 2016 Şırnak saldırılarının silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
3708 5852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Small business idea User:Ohconfucius 03:01, 18 January 2007 (UTC) delete per #REPOSITORY and |#HOWTO Deletion of Small business idea WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3709 15244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Metapedia User:ObiterDicta 23:17, 17 July 2007 (UTC) delete """Does not appear to have been covered in independent,|reliable sources. I don't suppose by """"pro-European"""" they mean that they support the Reform Treaty""" Deletion of Metapedia WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3710 4872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled Jennifer Lopez Greatest Hits (2009) User:Pharmboy 00:21, 30 October 2008 (UTC) delete with a |crystal hammer Deletion of Untitled Jennifer Lopez Greatest Hits (2009) WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
3711 2465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Dunlop (politician) User:The 09:22, 30 June 2018 (UTC) delete per nomination. Subject could, of course, have been independably notable himself, but all we have in |sources is that he's the chair of a party that won 0.3% of the vote in the 2017 general election. I wonder who the table is Deletion of Alan Dunlop (politician) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3712 2627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ace Combat X Super Aircraft User:Kunzite 00:54, 23 December 2006 (UTC) merge """to Ace Combat X Super Aircraft per for now. (If the entire series or articles on fictional airplanes was put up for deletion, I'd vote '''transwiki/delete''' because of the previously mentioned precendent. One by one AFDs often lead to confusing and uneven enforcement of policy.) The target article is very light on substance. (It has one large table a few paragraphs of text.) X-02 Wyvern, ADF-01 Falken, and XFA-27 should be summarized on the page. Fenrir (Ace Combat) should be merged to the page. All of them need to have the game guide elements removed. (i.e. """"Unlocking""" Deletion of Ace Combat X Super Aircraft WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
3713 186 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Dilek İmamoğlu Kullanıcı:seksen iki yüz kırk beşseksen iki yüz kırk beş / ggt 02.22, 28 Ocak 2020 (UTC) keep öznel gerekçelerle değil, kriterleri ile değerlendirilmeli. Google Haberler'de adı aratıldığında çıkan ilk 10 sayfada kendisini eşinden bağımsız ele alan çok sayıda kaynak var, örnek olarak https://t24.com.tr/haber/sabah-yazari-uluc-tan-dilek-imamoglu-na-aldirmayin-aynen-devam,846467 ve https://t24.com.tr/haber/semiha-yildirim-dilek-imamoglu-na-cok-tesekkur-ederim,8255169, bunlar yeterli Dilek İmamoğlu'nun silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
3714 6105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Self creation cosmology User:Crum375 11:34, 25 June 2006 (UTC) comment """to Garthbarber: You seem to have a misunderstanding about WP inclusion criteria. You say we should """"wait until the result of the Gravity Probe B geodetic precession is published (April 2007) until deciding"""". This is totally immaterial. Nowhere in WP policies are we to judge technical merit or base inclusion directly on results of experiments. Your 3rd party reference does seem OK, and seems to establish both notability and secondary sourcing. My main concern is with the fact that by you presenting the work here essentially exclusively, it constitutes |original work, and to some extent |vanity, which are frowned upon, though are not absolute barriers to acceptability. |Neutrality also becomes an issue, in principle, when the inventor is the sole author of the article. It would have been so much better from WP's perspective if a colleague could have presented the work, with you providing critique and correcting errors""" Deletion of Self creation cosmology WP:OR||WP:VAIN||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
3715 3379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hillary O'Connor Mueri User:Bearcat 13:46, 16 November 2019 (UTC) delete """without prejudice against recreation in November 2020 if she wins the election. Candidates are not entitled to have Wikipedia articles just for being candidates, but have to win the seat and thereby hold the office to pass NPOL — but merely being ''one of'' the first members of an underrepresented group to do a not inherently notable thing is not a notability freebie that would give her the """"preexisting notability for other reasons"""" key: if she can't be shown to have received a -passing volume of reliable source coverage in that context at the time it was happening, then being able to source the fact to mentions of it as career background in coverage of her campaign announcement does not get her over the bar. And no, the fact that a couple of pieces of local coverage of her campaign announcement exist is not in and of itself a free pass over GNG either, because a couple of pieces of local coverage of campaign announcements ''always'' exist for ''every'' candidate in ''every'' election ''everywhere''. So to earn an article ''before'' winning the election, she would have to be sourced a hell of a lot better than this ''regardless'' of whether you're aiming for """"campaign coverage = GNG"""" or """"she was already notable enough for an article before she was even a candidate""" Deletion of Hillary O'Connor Mueri WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3716 219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Odell Louis Dubree [[User talk:208.176.248.6|talk]]) Robert 13:50, 13 October 2009 (UTC) keep Does meet ; according to the Any Biography section in a person can be consider notable if that person has received a notable award or honor. I can think of no higher award than the Purple Heart. Furthermore, I am shocked that under it talks about being notable if you are a pornographic actor or a criminal but says nothing about veterans and especially those who received Purple Hearts. There is a difference between being notable and being famous. I think the should definitely be used for notability and not be confused with infamy. A Purple Heart recipient is definitely notable. They might not be famous to most people alive today, but they were famous in the small towns across America that they returned to after the War. I think more people would be interested in researching Purple Heart recipients and how they were wounded in battle rather than Porn Stars and their performances. There were approximately 200,000 http://www.purplehearts.net/id6.html Purple Hearts awarded during WWII compared to the 13,104,355 http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_many_Americans_fought_in_World_War_2 total number of soldiers that fought in WWII. With those numbers I would consider the Purple Heart medal very hard to obtain. I would like to make a larger plea to the Wikipedians out there to make Purple Heart recipients just as notable as porn stars and criminals. Special:Contributions/208.176.248.6|208.176.248.6 Deletion of Odell Louis Dubree WP:BIO||WP:BIO||WP:BIO||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3717 14669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OfficeMA Timesheet User:Dialectric 02:43, 3 August 2015 (UTC) delete Software article of unclear notability, lacking independent RS references. Only ref provided is a single-author blog, and a search turned up no significant coverage Deletion of OfficeMA Timesheet WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3718 3212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soc.history.what-if (2nd nomination) User:Action 20:20, 4 July 2007 (UTC) delete while generally well-written, the group seems to have no particular |encyclopedic merit, and the vast majority of content of the article belongs elsewhere - perhaps on a S.H.W-I FAQ site, or textfiles.org Deletion of Soc.history.what-if (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3719 4869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United Kingdom general election debates, 2009-2010 User:DustFormsWords 04:40, 29 September 2009 (UTC) delete per . It's very difficult for a future event that may or may not take place to be notable; this article is premature and can be recreated (at the earliest) when the possibility of their future existence has some real and notable effect on the socio-political landscape Deletion of United Kingdom general election debates, 2009-2010 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3720 136 [[Flonix]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:acE 10:47, 27. Okt. 2006 (CEST) delete Relevanz nach #Wirtschaftsunternehmen auch nicht erkennbar. . Löschung von Flonix Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
3721 21686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2006 rugby union handbag controversy User:Mattinbgn 20:46, 13 February 2011 (UTC) delete """per #NEWS What next, an article about the time the Wallabies ignored the Haka? The underarm bowling incident had huge repercussions including a change in the laws of the game. The 20th anniversary of the underarm earlier this month saw feature articles in all Australian dailies. By contrast, """"Handbag-gate"""" has already been forgotten on this side of the ditch. IMO, the whole thing was a beat up to begin with""" Deletion of 2006 rugby union handbag controversy WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3722 10665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Night Guard User:Fortuna 10:52, 10 July 2017 (UTC) delete per nom & . &mdash Deletion of Night Guard WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3723 10337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coordinated management of meaning User:Mark 23:11, 7 March 2016 (UTC) keep This is a real theory of communication in sociolinguistics, created in the 1980s, and the article and a style search turn up lots of reliable sources; about 1600 hits in GScholar and over 5,000 hits in GBooks. As a theory of communication, it is in the social constructionism school of thought. While not as well known as say symbolic interactionism, it turns up in courses and textbooks. The article itself has some promotional sections, particularly Coordinated management of meaning#Theory developers, as well as some essay-like prose, but cleaning these up is a matter of editing, not whole article deletion. A notable topic and an article with problems suggests keeping the article Deletion of Coordinated management of meaning WP:BEFORE||WP:SURMOUNTABLE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3724 16524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/After Happy Ever (Radio Show) (2nd nomination) User:LuckyLouie 22:33, 11 March 2009 (UTC) delete Nonexistent to build an article from. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/After_Happy_Ever_(Radio_Show) Others of its ilk should be zapped as well Deletion of After Happy Ever (Radio Show) (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3725 14292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013 Toronto Lynx season User:GiantSnowman 15:46, 6 October 2014 (UTC) delete fail and Deletion of 2013 Toronto Lynx season WP:GNG||WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3726 170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FS (logic) User:Gregbard 23:00, 28 July 2007 (UTC) comment All the reasons for deleting FS are all about the person who created the page, not the content. You guys have your corner wrapped up, I guess you don't have to work or play nice with anyone if you don't want to. As long as we can all see how it is (and everybody can), history will be the judge. I think making my point, and explaining it repeatedly with every bit of evidence that you guys do not understand the meaning of it, is probably what led to my frustration. I hope you guys are proud of your accomplishment. It isn't helping the quality of wikipedia AT ALL, just your egos. A vote like this brings into sharp relief Deletion of FS (logic) WP:FAIL Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3727 15819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaura (2nd nomination) User:JamesBurns 01:48, 20 March 2009 (UTC) delete insufficient independent 3rd party coverage Deletion of Kaura (2nd nomination) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
3728 342 [[:Kategorie:Mann]] (erledigt, da ungültiger Wiederholungsantrag) Benutzer:DieAlraune NONE keep wurde bereits /6._Dezember_2004|hier ausreichend diskutiert Löschung von :Kategorie:Mann Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3729 14981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katrina del Mar User:Gobonobo 00:34, 20 July 2014 (UTC) keep There's plenty of significant coverage of Katrina del Mar to be found. Articles about her in reliable sources such as http://photographmag.com/newsandreviews/view/154 Photograph magazine, http://museemagazine.com/culture/art-out/katrina-del-mar-summer-sang-in-me-at-strange-loop-gallery/ Musee magazine, http://www.papermag.com/2010/07/gorgeous_girl_gangs_invade_ind.php Papermag, http://posturemag.com/online/2014/03/22/katrina-del-mars-summer-sang-in-me-blends-romanticism-and-toughness/ Posture Mag, and http://www.huffingtonpost.com/phillip-m-miner/katrina-del-mar_b_4175826.html HuffPo demonstrate that the subject meets Deletion of Katrina del Mar WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3730 5541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mei Shigenobu NONE NONE comment Social activist? Author? Can you proove the otability of such achievements? Is she Deletion of Mei Shigenobu WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3731 2576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Varieties of capitalism User:Adambiswanger1 20:41, 24 July 2006 (UTC) delete I'm afraid it falls under the realm of |Original research. Thanks for your contributions, though Deletion of Varieties of capitalism WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3732 7863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oren Kessler User:Ohnoitsjamie 04:15, 15 August 2016 (UTC) delete None of the sources are ''about'' the subject, they simply verify that he's been published, which is not itself enough to meet notability criteria Deletion of Oren Kessler WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3733 18607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Am I Right User:Stifle 19:15, 29 November 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Am I Right WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3734 4392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Texas Junior College Student Government Association User:Orangemike 19:57, 13 March 2008 (UTC) delete non-notable; fails Deletion of Texas Junior College Student Government Association :WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3735 11834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lil Dicky User:SL93 03:05, 15 June 2013 (UTC) delete Nowhere near passing Deletion of Lil Dicky WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3736 13826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Paly Voice User:Silensor 16:49, 13 June 2006 (UTC) keep sufficiently notable as per guidelines Deletion of The Paly Voice WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3737 1848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Musical 2016 User:teb728 08:38, 7 November 2016 (UTC) delete per |A11 (by nominator). The musical is clearly madeup by the author. The song and character pages for the musical were all speedily deleted per A11 Deletion of My Musical 2016 WP:A11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
3738 6745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bond 24 User:Betty 12:59, 1 August 2013 (UTC) merge """to James Bond in film#Bond 24 and future. It clearly fails since filming has not begun, and at the moment it is just a series of announcements by Eon Productions. Point #5 of states """"'''''Wikipedia is not a collection of product announcements and rumors''' ... short articles that consist only of product announcement information are not appropriate. Until such time that more encyclopedic knowledge about the product can be verified, product announcements should be merged to a larger topic''"""". Until we can offer encyclopedic coverage of the production i.e. write about things that have happened as opposed to things that will happen the content should be merged into the series article, and the page redirected to the appropriate section of that article""" Deletion of Bond 24 WP:NFF||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3739 20656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gayle Laakmann McDowell User:JohnBlackburne 14:12, 1 September 2012 (UTC) delete """per nom. On """"Her notability stems from her books""""; yes, per even if her books were notable it would not make her notable, though the article contains no evidence that she or the books are notable by the standards of Wikipedia""" Deletion of Gayle Laakmann McDowell WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3740 19663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angus MacLane User:Taylor 15:31, 11 July 2014 (UTC) keep Don't think he meets the GNG, but he meets Deletion of Angus MacLane WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3741 21568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bodel (Mossad) User:The 07:03, 28 January 2021 (UTC) comment tq|If that article is deleted this should go}} . No comment on the article (and I was pinged here, apparently everyone who ever made the smallest edit on the aritcle is being pinged? Please be careful of Deletion of Bodel (Mossad) WP:OTHERSTUFF||WP:CANVASS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3742 2034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sounds for Energy-efficient Buildings User:JayJasper 18:43, 28 December 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. Lacks significant coverage in reliable independent sources. Fails & Deletion of Sounds for Energy-efficient Buildings WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3743 20833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Everybody Introduce Prophet Mohammed Day User:Meco 06:50, 20 May 2010 (UTC) delete This is clearly |original research and no coverage in reliable sources has been produced to document notability. __ Deletion of Everybody Introduce Prophet Mohammed Day WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3744 5305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Homeland Security Digital Library User:AusLondonder 23:01, 10 November 2015 (UTC) delete No indication of meeting Deletion of Homeland Security Digital Library WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3745 19524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammed Shakir User:Jimbo 18:32, 2 September 2009 (UTC) delete fourth tier in England is full-pro, as per Bettia's source the Iraqi league isn't. The inclusion criteria for sportspeople is they must have played in at a fully-professional level, not a top league of a country. There's also no independent media sources about the subject of this article, failing Deletion of Mohammed Shakir WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3746 16121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GoWrite App User:Walter 22:01, 23 June 2013 (UTC) delete Clearly does not meet any notability criteria. It was just released this month so it may just be a case of Deletion of GoWrite App WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3747 18753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angelo Valentino User:Xymmax 15:35, 29 November 2007 (UTC) delete You want obscurity, you've got it. Fails Deletion of Angelo Valentino WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3748 9427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of DirecTV channels (2nd nomination) User:Krushia 01:27, 14 October 2012 (UTC) delete Article is a |directory, and has no use otherwise due to lack of |historical perspective Deletion of List of DirecTV channels (2nd nomination) WP:NOTDIRECTORY||WP:RECENTISM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3749 21191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy cultural references (2nd nomination) User:Spellcast 17:11, 24 July 2007 (UTC) delete Judging by the archives of previous debates at Wikipedia:WikiProject Deletion sorting/Popular culture, it seems that most articles were either deleted, merged, or redirected. was made for a reason. So delete this along with all the other trivia pages in :Category:In popular culture (as of typing, there are still 120 trivia articles). Also, anyone thought of doing a single mass afd of that category? I don't think it will work because some editors may prefer some articles, but not others. I suppose they have a better chance of being deleted on a case by case basis Deletion of The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy cultural references (2nd nomination) WP:ATRIV Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
3750 9774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Linda Lam User:I42 19:02, 16 April 2009 (UTC) delete Does not meet Deletion of Linda Lam WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3751 4230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susan Lindauer (2nd nomination) NONE NONE delete per . In the first five (5) pages of google results, I found only the following references from reliable sources. All were about her arrest and trial Deletion of Susan Lindauer (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3752 11745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenny Plotnik User:Bfigura 21:33, 4 September 2007 (UTC) delete per . While the station may have won some awards, that doesn't make him notable Deletion of Kenny Plotnik WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3753 8298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iblees Ki Majlis-e-Shura User:Mar4d 04:19, 5 September 2012 (UTC) keep Very obviously satisfies notability as per the depth of results shown here https://www.google.com/search?q=Iblees+Ki+Majlis-e-Shura&btnG=Search+Books&tbm=bks&tbo=1. Keep per Deletion of Iblees Ki Majlis-e-Shura WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3754 15193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamad Jaman User:GiantSnowman 10:29, 15 December 2011 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Hamad Jaman WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3755 13659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Menua Hovhannisyan User:Necrothesp 11:44, 10 June 2021 (UTC) comment """It certainly appears to meet #1. However, I'm not convinced that the highest award of a small, self-proclaimed state of 150,000 people that has already awarded 24 of its """"highest awards"""" in the thirty years of its existence (compared with, say, a major nation like the UK, which has awarded only 15 Victoria Crosses in 75 years!) can be considered to meet the criteria""" Deletion of Menua Hovhannisyan WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3756 6488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parakeet (programming language) User:AllyD 07:49, 21 February 2014 (UTC) delete No |evidence provided or found that this attained any notability Deletion of Parakeet (programming language) :WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3757 6465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clocks (band) User:Eludium 18:17, 11 January 2007 (UTC) delete without prejudice to re-creation in a month or two. I would be minded to call to keep if there were |reliable sources for some of the claims made. Anyone can put their gigs on a website; a review in a publication such as the NME or a local newspaper (and Birmingham101.com is not a newspaper) would be far more persuasive. Similarly for entry on the Xfm playlist (which may or may not pass muster as ''rotation'' on a ''national'' station per - this is arguably spot plays on a London station.) Complete the tour, get a couple of published reviews, release a major-label single, and come back Deletion of Clocks (band) WP:RS||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3758 20133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Niccolò Casini (2nd nomination) User:Number 16:04, 6 September 2007 (UTC) delete Has not played in a fully-professional league ( Deletion of Niccolò Casini (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3759 10463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Schlossberg (4th nomination) User:Slakr 03:49, 16 May 2014 (UTC) keep mdash; I had !voted delete on one of the prior ones because I was skeptical about whether realistically applied, especially given that meeting or meeting notability in the realm of politicians wasn't evident, and most of the sources, like the nom mentions, had issues issues with whether the subject's actually the subject of the coverage versus just incidental to wider story / ing. The http://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/jfk-grandson-jack-schlossberg-joins-caroline-kennedy-official-tour-article-1.1791779 NYDN article mentioned above, as well as http://www.people.com/article/kennedy-grandson-meets-president-bush-granddaughter this one (recent, clearly-the-subject-of-the-coverage) helps counter those concerns, as celebrity-style coverage, which seems to be increasingly dominant, would also place him in . It's still not clear'n'obvious, but so long as the article's actually improved with the newer sources and whatnot, it would seem much more reasonably so to me Deletion of John Schlossberg (4th nomination) WP:GNG||WP:BIO||WP:INHERIT||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3760 585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/February 15, 2003 anti-war protest User:Fuhghettaboutit 05:02, 30 April 2006 (UTC) keep """I too think this is a violation of , as the stated argument for nomination is so specious. By the way, listing elbow licking, which is stated by Guiness to be a myth, """"so stop telling us about it"""", is really not a very effective way of attacking Guiness' certification that the protest ''was indeed a world record breaker''. You grok""" Deletion of February 15, 2003 anti-war protest WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
3761 6790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AdChoices User:Michig 06:03, 6 August 2015 (UTC) keep Another one where doesn't seem to have been followed. Plenty of coverage exists Deletion of AdChoices WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3762 14501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Internet identity in research and education User:Rusf10 03:31, 16 May 2018 (UTC) delete reading this, my first though was, this is an essay. so applies here Deletion of Internet identity in research and education WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3763 11017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fighter McWarrior User:Adashiel 11:15, 15 May 2006 (UTC) comment I am not entirely opposed to two separate 8-Bit Theater characters articles — one for the light warriors and the other for minor characters — but I'd prefer it if the contributors of the Characters article instead exercise some discipline. Contrary to what you may think, an exhaustive article covering fine details is ''not'' ideal. Unless you're already a fan, just reading an article like that is a real slog, let alone trying to keep it proofread, verifiable, and appropriate in tone. If an article can ''only'' be managed by dedicated fans, it is not useful. For once, notability is not a concern, but there certainly is an issue about respecting , , and Deletion of Fighter McWarrior WP:V||WP:NOR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3764 8622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Market share of leading PC vendors [[User talk:137.122.49.102|talk]]) 20:07, 18 May 2010 (UTC) delete per #STATS. The statistics may not be ''too'' sprawling but the layout is terrible, making it hard to follow, and there is insufficient text to explain everything. Of course, cleanup is not delete but I'm not convinced a cleanup is warranted over a delete in this case. Also, it is based on essentially a single source.--Special:Contributions/137.122.49.102|137.122.49.102 Deletion of Market share of leading PC vendors WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3765 17915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nirnroot User:RMHED 19:00, 27 November 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Nirnroot WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
3766 20761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Man-eating elephant User:Mike 19:21, 30 January 2013 (UTC) delete """Only a handful of major media outlets appear to have covered this incident; it took several Google searches with different keywords to locate just three stories (http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2002-06-25/kolkata/27302011_1_elephant-forest-officials-shot, http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/2062876.stm, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-25633862_ITM). Nothing indicates that this particular elephant attack had a lasting impact or received persistent coverage (fails , and ). Other elephant attacks in India have claimed even more lives (e.g. http://www.nbcnews.com/id/16248233/ns/world_news-south_and_central_asia/t/serial-killer-elephant-shot-dead-india/) so it's not even notable as the worst attack of its kind. It may be appropriate to include a sentence or two about this incident in Elephant#Attacks, but some of the article's details appear to be incorrect. For example, (1) elephants are herbivores and cannot be """"man-eating"""" and (2) the news sources say 13 victims, not 17""" Deletion of Man-eating elephant WP:GEOSCOPE||WP:INDEPTH||WP:PERSISTENCE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3767 18603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HBS Towers (2nd nomination) User:Orientls 03:01, 18 June 2020 (UTC) delete At least per Deletion of HBS Towers (2nd nomination) WP:NOTCRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3768 1872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greater Western Norway Region User:Arsenikk 11:31, 15 May 2009 (UTC) delete as Deletion of Greater Western Norway Region WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3769 18468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spykee Head Dude (video game) User:Littleteddy 08:49, 14 March 2008 (UTC) delete Definitely not wiki-worthy as it fails almost every policy I can think of... , Deletion of Spykee Head Dude (video game) WP:WWIN||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3770 9408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Fisher (Businessman) User:Jersey92 18:55, 19 May 2014 (UTC) delete As the article is written, he does not seem to meet or other notability requirements Deletion of Mark Fisher (Businessman) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
3771 4871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Valley Shockwave User:Bagumba 16:36, 5 November 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and doesnt meet Deletion of Big Valley Shockwave WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3772 19239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people who have turned on the Oxford Street Christmas lights User:Mike 02:22, 6 December 2010 (UTC) keep Clearly notable event and the list meets all requirements of and . Those that argue ''Indiscriminate'' apparently don't understand what that really means. Nothing indiscriminate about the inclusion criteria for this list Deletion of List of people who have turned on the Oxford Street Christmas lights WP:LIST||WP:SAL Wikipedia:Lists 97
3773 16731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Starmind Innovation User:Ihcoyc 15:32, 3 February 2010 (UTC) delete """likely '''speedy delete''' candidate as #G11|unambiguous advertising: ''has received world-wide acclaim from both business and academic institutions... The business model has received several awards for its ingenuity. Open innovation websites are becoming increasingly popular for companies looking to out-source problem solving and find creative approaches to the business problems they face...'' Note also that the """"references"""" provided all point to their own blog""" Deletion of Starmind Innovation WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
3774 7323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Cavallo User:Yellow 09:29, 31 October 2016 (UTC) delete fails and . — Deletion of Joshua Cavallo WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3775 17496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 conspiracy theories User:Supernerd11 02:56, 28 March 2014 (UTC) keep """Whether the theories are plausible or not is moot. What matters is that they're reliably sourced (Chicago Sun-Times? Wall Street Journal? CNN? Sounds good to me) and that they're notable enough to be encyclopedic (which the references usually do, as in this case). It's tempting to go into the whole |""""Elvis lives! 9/11 was an inside job! Insert other conspiracy theory here!"""", but let's ignore that for now. says """"Wikipedia summarizes significant opinions, with representation in proportion to their prominence"""" for it's very first sentence! Judging by the previously listed sources, I think these count as """"significant opinions"""", even if they do seem a little harebrained. The lede for also seems to back this up. Sorry if I seem to be spamming guidelines, but for something like this, it seems necessary""" Deletion of Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 conspiracy theories WP:OSE||WP:FRINGE||WP:CONTROVERSIALFACT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3776 8846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucky (Radiohead song) User:Dylanfromthenorth 21:45, 7 June 2010 (UTC) merge It has tenuous claims to notability due to it being covered by 3 notable acts. However, due to a lack of coverage of this song it should be redirected to its parent album as per the guidelines at . If the redirect needs protecting then protect it Deletion of Lucky (Radiohead song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3777 9079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Oprah Effect User:Factlibrary1 05:02, 15 November 2019 (UTC) delete per . Phrase is not widely known and failed to gain traction beyond her very own circle Deletion of The Oprah Effect WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3778 14822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sysmind User:AllyD 19:14, 10 December 2014 (UTC) delete An article created and tended by a sequence of accounts. Multiple searches (Highbeam, Questia, Google) fail to turn up |evidence of |notability Deletion of Sysmind :WP:SPA||:WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
3779 1008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of HD DVD releases (2nd nomination) User:DannyS712 03:57, 29 December 2018 (UTC) delete clear violation of , not encyclopediac content Deletion of List of HD DVD releases (2nd nomination) WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3780 13637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kittie May Ellis (second nomination) User:Agent 22:52, 20 July 2006 (UTC) delete """per nom (and nearly a speedy as an attempt to re-create a deleted article). I recall that past commentors had some serious concerns about |verification. I also think it may be difficult to verify some of the claims in the article. One such claim is that Ellis is """"one of"""" or """"the only"""" narrative, first-person sources of information for the Pacific Northwest. For example, one would have to comb the Hudson Bay Co. archives, various university libraries, and state and provincial archives to ensure that there are no such other first person accounts of life in what is now Washington and B.C. for this time period. I am also a bit concerned because the creator of this article verges on |incivility (as can be seen in this discussion) and acts in a manner that is |overly possessive. That, however, is not a reason for deletion, it's just a concern about the constant appearance and disappearance of this article. The creator of the article is not helping his cause by such behaviour""" Deletion of Kittie May Ellis (second nomination) WP:V||WP:CIVIL||WP:OWN Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3781 12408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abigail Keam (2nd nomination) User:CAPTAIN 20:10, 15 March 2017 (UTC) delete doesn't meet Deletion of Abigail Keam (2nd nomination) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3782 8943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Limeroad.com NONE NONE keep Sadly the company does find mention in the newspapers such as The Economic Times, Mint (newspaper) and Hindustan Times which makes it notable according to Deletion of Limeroad.com WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3783 206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soccer Brain User:Doc 03:21, 14 July 2008 (UTC) delete WP:NEO|Neologism created by NN coach. Article is a mix of dicdef and |personal essay Deletion of Soccer Brain WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3784 13812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Concerto Signage User:Bejnar 20:46, 4 October 2015 (UTC) delete """non-notable software, fails to have significant coverage in reliable independent sources. Fails . Most sources are either """"forums"""" or the copany's. Others do not rise to the level of sigfificance. See also the informative essay Wikipedia:Notability (software). IP editor Special:Contributions/69.204.153.39|69.204.153.39 is incorrect, it is not guidelines for non-inclusion, it is guidelines for inclusion, and this topic does not meet those guidelines""" Deletion of Concerto Signage WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3785 4870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global Media Journal User:Headbomb 15:30, 18 May 2018 (UTC) delete AFAICT, utter fail of . {{MIAR|1550-7521}} says its indexed in a few places, but I'm not sure any of those are selective. {{ping|DGG}} would know Deletion of Global Media Journal WP:NJOURNALS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3786 14372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oak Bay Police Department User:Ohconfucius 05:14, 11 June 2008 (UTC) delete or redirect to British Columbia Provincial Police. The BCPP is notable, but one department of it, without any special achievements and without |sources which attest to its |notability? There is nothing in the article, or in the defenses above, which suggests that it is passes Deletion of Oak Bay Police Department WP:RS||WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3787 21096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernhard Steffen (computer scientist) User:Randykitty 17:08, 27 January 2014 (UTC) keep His Google Scholar profile (linked under EL in the article) shows several articles cited hundreds of times each, a total of almost 9000 citations, and an h-index of 47. Easy pass of #1 Deletion of Bernhard Steffen (computer scientist) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3788 6185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Tiger Woods' alleged affairs User:Blueboar 15:06, 13 December 2009 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of List of Tiger Woods' alleged affairs WP:BLP||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3789 14405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crossfire (computer game) User:Brighterorange 22:06, 22 February 2007 (UTC) keep of the sources above, the only one that appears to be an independent is the linux journal article, but it's not very substantial. Is there anything better? — Deletion of Crossfire (computer game) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3790 12021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timothie Fielder User:Senator2029 20:03, 14 June 2012 (UTC) delete Unable to find sources to meet requirements of Deletion of Timothie Fielder WP:NRVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3791 6304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pamela Sossi (2nd nomination) User:Bkissin 14:28, 19 October 2020 (UTC) delete Does not meet Deletion of Pamela Sossi (2nd nomination) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3792 13645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/23 Skidoo (magazine issue) User:Uzma 22:33, 26 August 2012 (UTC) delete The 23 Skidoo (magazine issue) topic lacks significant coverage in Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable sources that are Wikipedia:Independent sources|independent of the 23 Skidoo (magazine issue) subject for a stand-alone article as required per |Wikipedia notability Deletion of 23 Skidoo (magazine issue) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3793 8856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CMS Station Brokerage User:Orangemike 12:15, 26 June 2014 (UTC) delete Non-notable local company; the original author and s.p.a. fails to understand the concept of |notability as used here Deletion of CMS Station Brokerage :WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3794 14826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Welfare Party of India User:Djm 08:44, 22 January 2020 (UTC) keep While party is small and fringe they have achieved and over a period of 8 years Deletion of Welfare Party of India WP:SUSTAINED||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
3795 1078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scottsdale National Golf Club User:Northamerica1000 07:28, 2 January 2018 (UTC) merge to Scottsdale, Arizona#Golf as a functional -M. The suggested merge target presently lacks a mention of this golf club Deletion of Scottsdale National Golf Club WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3796 942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Labrador Mall (2nd nomination) User:RoySmith 13:16, 11 June 2014 (UTC) delete Fails . All of the references are either self-published, or, in the case of the ''The Aurora'' article, inconsequential (as per NOT ABOUT PARKING LOT TRAFFIC PATTERNS). List of tenant stores and vacant areas are inherently ephemeral, and thus non-notable Deletion of Labrador Mall (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:IS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3797 9833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Warner (artist) User:Alex 20:44, 27 November 2019 (UTC) delete Subject does not meet , or Deletion of Bob Warner (artist) WP:GNG||WP:ARTIST||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
3798 11791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Docker's Guild (2nd nomination) User:Oshwah 08:39, 6 March 2016 (UTC) delete Per . Doesn't appear to meet the requirements to satisfy NMUSIC Deletion of Docker's Guild (2nd nomination) WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3799 15009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wilma Echandy User:Mabalu 10:04, 22 October 2014 (UTC) delete """Point blank fails general notability. Almost completely non-encyclopaedic and uncited content - including stuff about her father's troubles with the law, which I have removed as a violation of and almost seems like a personal attack - """"look her daddy was in trouble with the law!"""" - which has NO bearing on her as a person""" Deletion of Wilma Echandy WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3800 11563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tear gas manufacturers User:Seraphim 04:02, 24 June 2017 (UTC) keep """What does this have to do with point 1 of . As for point 5 - there are plenty of notable companies that produce tear gas, in fact most of the companies that produce tear gas seem to be notable. There is more then enough in published books (mostly books) to preclude deletion through AfD. There is TransTechnology, which has been covered in many books; Condor, who has been the subject of numerous articles in mainstream publications, including WSJ; Combined Systems, Inc - one of the companies mentioned in the article - has been discussed in published books; Federal Laboratories .... None of the reasons given above have even a remote connection to our policies on deletion. """"Tear gas is not a difficult chemical?"""" """"Non-complete subjective list?"""" What could possibly be subjective about whether a company produces tear gas - they either do, or they don't. I don't see a single policy reason that would justify deleting this article""" Deletion of List of tear gas manufacturers WP:DOAL Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
3801 1090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Creating Opportunities in Vietnam User:RadioFan 20:25, 18 March 2010 (UTC) delete just doesn't have the coverage to meet Deletion of Creating Opportunities in Vietnam WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3802 17905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Israeli occupation of the West Bank User:Johnuniq 08:49, 7 February 2019 (UTC) keep """Many reliable sources in the article (and weekly news feeds) treat """"Israeli occupation of the West Bank"""" as a topic so is satisfied with coverage. OTESSAY refers to """"{{tq|essays that state your particular feelings about a topic (rather than the opinions of experts)}}"""" but the many reliable sources in the article ''are'' the opinions of experts. Any unsourced personal feelings should be removed without trying to use an Wikipedia:Deletion is not cleanup|AfD for cleanup. Those advocating TNT/userfy/draftify have not given a policy-based reason""" Deletion of Israeli occupation of the West Bank WP:N||WP:SUSTAINED||WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:Notability 77
3803 107 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Jalpi Türk Tili Kullanıcı:i̇ncelemeelemanii.e. 17:09, 7 Mart 2012 (UTC) comment Aslında KD olmadığı konusunda haklısınız. Ancak yaptığım minik araştırmada ; yaklaşık olarak http://www.dilforum.com/forum/yapay-diller-forumu/82796-yapay-turk-dili.html 2010 yılından bu yana geliştirilmeye çalışılan yapay bir Türk dili olduğunu anladım. Meraklısı epey çok gibi gözüküyor. Yani en azından çeşitli yerlere ekleyenlerin kullanıcı adları birbirini tutmuyor. Bu doğrultuda, bir miktar daha geliştirildiği takdirde kalmasını düşünebilirim. Ancak hali hazırda bu hali ile kalması tuhaf gibi gözükse de, kalabilir diye düşünüyorum. Zaten wikt:Jalpi Türk Tili|Vikisözlük'te ve b:Jalpi Türk Tili|Vikikitap'ta b:Jalpi Türk Tili/Dilbilgisi|bile kendine yer bulmuş. Fakat ingilizce http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Jalpi_Türk_Tili Wikisözlük'te silinmiş :). Ayrıca projenin http://gaspirali.com/ Gaspirali projesi olduğunu da, http://jalpiturktili.com/ buradan anlıyoruz. Yapılan çalışma küçük gibi gözüküyor. Gördüğüm kadarıyla pek çok forum sitesine konu olmuş. Fakat sağlam kaynak olarak gösterebileceğimiz bir kaynak yok. Tabi ben hem bunları yazıyorum, hem araştırıyorum bu arada. Bu nedenle sözümün başlangıcı ile geldiğim bu noktaya kadar araştırmalara devam ettim ve ediyorum :). Bir diğer kaynak http://www.turkbirlik.gen.tr/lang-tr/medeniyet/elifba/1570-jalpi-tuerk-tili-alfabesi.html bu sitede ve 2007 yılına işaret ediyor. Bu dili ekleyenlerin durmayacağının bir göstergesi de wikt:bir#Jalpi_T.C3.BCrk_Tili|burada ve Yapay dil|burada. Fakat sanırım sonuçta Turancı tabir edilen görüşteki kişilerin böyle bir dil oluşturma çabası var http://forum.hunturk.net/index.php?PHPSESSID=b11179d7f96fdea8de523269af7eae01&topic=2477.msg15988#msg15988 1 http://forum.hunturk.net/turk-dunyasinda-ortak-dilin-olusturulmasi-ortak-turkce-8217nin-temel-ilkeleri-2477-s15.html 2. Şahsi fikrim biraz katılıyorum, biraz katılmıyorum. Azerbaycan Türkçe'sine yakın olduğunu düşünenler http://turkcesivarken.com/yazismalik/index.php?topic=7414.msg27163;topicseen var ki, buna bende katılıyorum. Türk yapay dili için model olabileceğini düşünenler http://wowturkey.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=27887&start=130 var. Yani velhasıl, var ve var. Ama tekrar belirteceğim gibi |KD için yeterli mi değil mi? Bilemiyorum Jalpi Türk Tili'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
3804 21321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dina Rae (singer) User:STATicVapor 05:59, 4 September 2014 (UTC) delete The subject does not meet at all. Her only claim of significance is through her association with Eminem and their early collaborations. It was already deleted at Wikipedia: Articles for deletion/Dina Rae and the subject has done nothing of significance since then at all. There is no independent coverage in reliable sources that would indicate any notability. Not to mention the https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Dina_Rae_(singer)&diff=621084170&oldid=621083569 creator/top contributor is a personal friend of the subject. Thank you {{u|Fevrret}} for nominating this, I was going to wait for the RM to close so there would be no technical issues, but this discussion might just need to be moved once the article is. I firmly believed this should have been G4ed, but a regular user that had no access to the deleted version at all declined it Deletion of Dina Rae (singer) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3805 4340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticism of Judaism (2nd nomination) User:Basket 18:51, 9 May 2010 (UTC) delete This article is a perfect example of , and . I strongly urge it's deletion, even considering a speedy deletion Deletion of Criticism of Judaism (2nd nomination) WP:SYNTH||WP:COAT||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3806 13319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hem Chandra Chowdhury User:Ipsign 14:30, 9 May 2020 (UTC) keep per , agree with Deletion of Hem Chandra Chowdhury WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3807 8623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Chestney (2nd nomination) User:Toddst1 02:08, 29 June 2017 (UTC) delete She's probably as notable for being a http://www.wtae.com/article/murrysville-police-investigating-reports-of-suspicious-man-seen-near-royal-highlands-park/7480010 trivial crime victim or https://books.google.com/books?id=QmQjMhTIsp8C NN psychic as anything else (which is not much). Note that this article has been repeatedly hammered by editors trying to promote the subject as well as the CREATE festival, and has been recreated after the previous AFD result of DELETE Deletion of Kim Chestney (2nd nomination) WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
3808 17090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark I. Sutherland User:Colapeninsula 11:36, 29 October 2013 (UTC) delete I found a bit of independent coveragehttp://www.stltoday.com/entertainment/books-and-literature/penned-in-st-louis-mark-i-sutherland/article_6d3cf292-963c-5845-84d2-fad3fb43738a.htmlhttp://harvestmagazine.net/?p=523 but it's not enough for or . All his books are self-published and he's a very run-of-the-mill journalist/columnist. Not notable Deletion of Mark I. Sutherland WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3809 9827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Portrait of a Call Girl User:Cindamuse 17:39, 18 April 2012 (UTC) keep Article clearly meets |general and Wikipedia:Notability (films)#Other evidence of notability|topical notability guidelines for films. Couldn't find any indication of COI, lack of neutrality, or supporting information or clarification on talk page about concerns. That said, a conflict of interest (even if identified) is not a valid criteria for deletion. Best regards Deletion of Portrait of a Call Girl WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3810 3186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nostradamus ni Kiite Miro♪ User:SeizureDog 13:44, 2 December 2006 (UTC) keep Are you people even actually looking at the article? The game has both an official website ''and'' has been the cover story for a magazine, I haven't speculated about this game at all and made no original research. |Crystal balling refers to making articles on games without official annoucements that they will be released, such as a ''Metroid Prime 5''. ''Metroid Prime 3'' however, is annouced and in development as is ''Nostradamus ni Kiite Miro♪''. Furthermore, it is being produced by one of the most respectable publishers of visual novels, and is a notable game in Japan (as evident of it having an article on the Japanese Wikipedia). And I don't see how it falls under at all Deletion of Nostradamus ni Kiite Miro♪ WP:CRYSTAL||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3811 4858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exit Day of the Withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union User:Eeveeman 19:17, 27 December 2019 (UTC) delete Don't think any of the information in the article is unique, it's all contained in other articles such as Brexit where the section specifically on Brexit#Exit day|Exit Day is artificially small as to presumably justify the external article. Merge back to there. As currently (perhaps applies) a bell-ringing and presumed busy news day isn't notable enough for its own article Deletion of Exit Day of the Withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
3812 14975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Jackson's finances User:Blanchardb 17:49, 26 December 2007 (UTC) delete or '''Merge'''. As a separate article, it fails . --Blanchardb Deletion of Michael Jackson's finances WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3813 21433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OsmoEngine user:Hellknowz 23:12, 15 November 2015 (UTC) delete """as ; an otherwise non-notable fake """"game engine"""" failing with no independent, reliable, in-depth sources. — """ Deletion of OsmoEngine WP:HOAX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
3814 16416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Davenport – V. Williams rivalry User:Hrafn 14:45, 14 December 2010 (UTC) delete """simply an (unsourced) tabulation of sports results (#STATS, #NEWS, or simply generally ), lacking any source information interpreting or evaluating this """"rivalry""" Deletion of Davenport – V. Williams rivalry WP:NOT||WP:NOT||WP:IINFO||WP:SECONDARY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3815 4351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whiteness theory user:Andrew 10:43, 25 January 2019 (UTC) keep See the ''https://books.google.co.uk/books?hl=en&lr=&id=S8Kf0N0XALIC&oi=fnd&pg=PG1007#v=onepage&q&f=false Encyclopedia of Communication Theory''. Per , we should improve the page, not delete it Deletion of Whiteness theory WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
3816 171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My mhealth User:Skirts89 20:29, 11 January 2019 (UTC) comment As the nominator, I stand by my initial thought process - this fails and Deletion of My mhealth WP:GNG||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3817 5593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aziz Shavershian (2nd nomination) User:A412 22:29, 25 March 2012 (UTC) keep This again? Subject clearly passes |GNG Deletion of Aziz Shavershian (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3818 17889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melanie Faye User:Wee 14:04, 4 August 2018 (UTC) delete After checking for further sources on this person I can't find anything that would meet the requirements of . Its worth noting that this article was mentioned Wikipedia:WikiProject Women in Red/Article alerts|here at , which may explain why some are so keen to keep it Deletion of Melanie Faye WP:GNG||WP:WPWIR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3819 21455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Misogyny in horror films User:MarnetteD 17:34, 9 August 2018 (UTC) keep As Lugnuts states an article needing work (and there are millions of those here at the 'pedia) is not a reason for deletion. and are guidelines to consider brfore nominations like this Deletion of Misogyny in horror films WP:BEFORE||WP:SOFIXIT Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3820 20522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chuff Chuff User:Darkwind 12:20, 12 September 2007 (UTC) delete as a non-notable event. Couldn't find any |sources to establish notability Deletion of Chuff Chuff WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3821 15379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Talbot User:Alexandermcnabb 12:46, 18 May 2021 (UTC) delete fails . Best Deletion of Sam Talbot WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3822 6031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Reynolds (American musician) User:Richard3120 15:32, 15 January 2021 (UTC) delete fails and . The nominator is correct, the subject is unrelated to John Reynolds (musician), the former husband and musical collaborator of Sinéad O'Connor, whose name comes up more frequently in searches. This John Reynolds doesn't seem to have any notability apart from being the producer of Graham Clarke, but notability is not inherited by association Deletion of John Reynolds (American musician) WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3823 5743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/3Sigma User:TParis00ap 00:26, 24 June 2010 (UTC) delete I searched not only this company but it's parent company as well and I could not find any notable/reliable sources. Anything I could find on this company seems to be advertisement. The author points to an advertisement video and the company's own website as reliable sources. The poor sourcing aside, I can't see anything notable or unique about this company that would warrent an article either to suggest there could be a source out there. I agree with nom, fails .--v/r Deletion of 3Sigma WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3824 1515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tuhina Das User:Celestina007 18:10, 21 July 2021 (UTC) comment Above is an evaluation of the “sources”, provided above and the “piece” they optimized, all have been evaluated and still fall below the threshold of , is not satisfied at all or in any manner as the article’s subject is yet to feature in significant multiple roles and have not won a prestigious award reserved for actors Deletion of Tuhina Das WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3825 6250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/There's No One As Irish As Barack O'Bama [[User talk:Skomorokh|the skomorokh]] 10:30, 10 November 2008 (UTC) keep per . These sort of nominations are quite unnecessary; tagging the article with {{tl|note}} would have resulted in a much quicker and less drama-inducing resolution Deletion of There's No One As Irish As Barack O'Bama WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3826 5328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riky Ash User:Colapeninsula 10:02, 26 May 2015 (UTC) delete Lacking sufficient sources: it's all Lincolnshire/Nottinghamshire local press except from the Business Matters interview, which doesn't count as a reliable source (because it's an interview). Purely local press isn't normally considered sufficient for notability. Doesn't meet , or Deletion of Riky Ash WP:NSPORT||WP:NACTOR||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3827 10161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nadine Baggott (2nd nomination) User:Davidstewartharvey 15:05, 29 January 2021 (UTC) comment Difficult one. Existing article is backed by promo refs and listings. She is often quoted by publications{{citation|url=https://www.ft.com/content/8eae54fa-c677-11e8-86e6-19f5b7134d1c|title=FT}} {{citation|url=https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/nadine-baggotts-expert-guide-to-dyeing-grey-hair-rw93ptcgj|title=The Times}}{{citation|url=https://www.harpersbazaar.com/uk/beauty/a31224013/nadine-baggott-interview/|title=harpers}} and Superdrug have signed her up for a range of products.{{citation|url=https://www.retailtimes.co.uk/superdrug-announces-first-beauty-box-launch-curated-by-guru-nadine-baggott/|title=Retail Times} Could argue point 2, or asic if rewritten and referenced better Deletion of Nadine Baggott (2nd nomination) WP:ENT||WP:B Wikipedia:Notability 77
3828 6596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Li Ruigang User:AllyD 15:05, 14 December 2020 (UTC) keep """An article on a businessperson with a history of building multiple notable companies and interests (''""""Li, an English-speaking media mogul dubbed the Rupert Murdoch of the East""""'' https://www.theguardian.com/football/2015/dec/02/china-manchester-city-world-cup The Guardian, 2015) as well as of political appointment to a Shanghai position described as ''""""roughly on par with the director of the Chief Executive’s Office in Hong Kong""""'' (https://www.ejinsight.com/eji/article/id/1572404/20170526-li-ruigang-china-s-rupert-murdoch-comes-to-hong-kong Hong Kong Economic Journal, 2017). I think the available |references, as well as the rather basic Britannica entry, are sufficient for and criterion 3""" Deletion of Li Ruigang :WP:RS||:WP:BASIC||:WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3829 16936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LeShaun (2nd nomination) User:Active 03:49, 23 December 2010 (UTC) delete """the """"sources"""" cited in the last AFD fail in not providing any significant coverage other than a vague implication that a rapper by that name exists. If a year since the last Afd and 4 years since the creation is not sufficient for the supporters of the article to provide valid sourcing, ODEADLINE|even though there is no deadline, how long are we supposed to wait with an unsourced ??? Special:Contributions/Active_Banana|''Active""" Deletion of LeShaun (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:NODEADLINE||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3830 13202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/La Plaza Mall User:TJ 02:18, 14 September 2006 (UTC) delete Seems to be just another mall, also fails Deletion of La Plaza Mall WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3831 13789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CampusTours User:VoiceOfReason 05:18, 25 August 2006 (UTC) comment my inclination is '''delete''', else I wouldn't have nominated it, but I agree with the above that this company might just barely reach the threshhold of notability. (Although it might not; again, the links that the author provided to establish notability are highly questionable.) The problem is that the article does ''not'' deserve to survive in its present form, and I think it's likely that the author (whose only contribs are to this article) is affiliated with the subject and may be unable to provide an appropriately |neutral point of view. And I don't know if there's anybody else who's informed enough to write a good, neutral article. Again, the company, if notable, is just barely so. If this whole virtual-tour thing catches on, the company will probably grow in importance and in notability, and at that time unbiased people will be familiar enough with it to write an appropriate article. Until then, however, I continue to believe that the appropriate action here is to '''delete Deletion of CampusTours WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
3832 7887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fuzors User:Colonel 10:11, 12 August 2011 (UTC) keep It is easy to find detailed sourcing for this topic such as ''The Transformers Beast Wars Sourcebook'', ''Dictionary of toys and games in American popular culture'' and ''Television cartoon shows: an illustrated encyclopedia''. The nominator is clearly failing to follow our |deletion guidelines. All of these Transformers topics have an obvious parent topic to which they could be merged as a reasonable alternative to deletion and so none of them should be brought here Deletion of Fuzors WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3833 15487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle of Bulford User:Qworty 09:13, 17 May 2011 (UTC) delete If no sources can be found for this event, it may be an instance of Deletion of Battle of Bulford WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
3834 6930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Over the Edge (book) User:Haukurth 14:37, 26 September 2019 (UTC) keep Reviewed by https://www.publishersweekly.com/0-375-50609-8 Publishers Weekly, https://search.proquest.com/docview/235505521/fulltext/AC3E5FBAFB2E4949PQ Booklist and https://search.proquest.com/docview/409347379/fulltext/AC3E5FBAFB2E4949PQ/ The Washington Post. This is enough for us to have an article, only requires two reviews Deletion of Over the Edge (book) WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
3835 4841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SEEDS User:K 23:05, 20 June 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet and significant RS coverage not found. The sources offered above are very minor passing mentions Deletion of SEEDS WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3836 9371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rob Rudko User:Vrac 23:45, 22 January 2015 (UTC) delete can't find significant coverage in . Fails Deletion of Rob Rudko WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3837 10247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EyeSore Angels User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable-music. No AMG entry. &mdash Deletion of EyeSore Angels WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3838 14838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phillip Torres User:Accounting4Taste 05:37, 15 October 2007 (UTC) delete """This may be an extremely literate hoax (the meaning of the meaning of meaning?). Google Scholar gives zero hits for this name, either as Philip or Phillip, and Harvard.edu doesn't return anything for either name, let alone as a distinguished scholar. Google and Google News return zero relevant hits for the name, with or without """"the meaning of meaning"""". I can't accept that this meets erifiable unless I've really been misled, which is possible. If there was a citation for this """"influential paper"""", I might be more convinced""" Deletion of Phillip Torres WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3839 9864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vernon Heywood User:David 05:17, 29 April 2008 (UTC) keep I added an award that he won recently, filling out another entry of in case we needed more Deletion of Vernon Heywood WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3840 7316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isokoboy User:Bakazaka 20:31, 17 May 2019 (UTC) delete as unambiguous constructed from unreliable sources and . This is fundamentally unencyclopedic in tone and content, and it falls under multiple criteria for what Wikipedia is not, by policy Deletion of Isokoboy WP:PROMO||WP:GOSSIP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3841 13148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Redwood Middle School (Saratoga, California) User:Ansh666 06:36, 19 August 2013 (UTC) comment """The Redwood Marching Band and Color Guard was selected to represent the state of California in the 56th Presidential Inaugural Parade of President Barack Obama in Washington, D.C. on January 20, 2009."""" This is probably this school's """"claim to fame"""" - if there are enough sources out there, it could be a keep. I'm about to sleep now, but if someone could check it out. Otherwise, it's a typical '''merge/redirect''' to Saratoga Union School District""" Deletion of Redwood Middle School (Saratoga, California) WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3842 19113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susana Reche User:Dacium 23:03, 22 January 2007 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Susana Reche WP:BIO||WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3843 3378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathan MacDonald (2nd nomination) User:Ron 00:05, 20 June 2010 (UTC) merge The article is a |BLP Deletion of Nathan MacDonald (2nd nomination) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3844 17758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Huemer (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep meets ; here's sample reviews Deletion of Michael Huemer (2nd nomination) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3845 13772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Medical Board of California User:Northamerica1000 02:22, 28 November 2015 (UTC) keep Sources and source searches demonstrate the the topic meets Deletion of Medical Board of California WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3846 761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plot devices in Agatha Christie's novels User:Jerry 04:52, 20 February 2008 (UTC) keep I agree with everything above, and come to the conclusion that the chalkboard does not need to be completely erased in order to write on it. Just address the concerns at and close this AfD for now. It can always get renommed later if the desired improvements do not occur Deletion of Plot devices in Agatha Christie's novels WP:EDIT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
3847 9596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vadaine Oliver User:Peterkingiron 11:27, 27 May 2013 (UTC) comment I think we need a clearer statement in on the application of the criteria in UK: which leagues provide notability for players and which for clubs. This may mean that we get fewer Football AFDs Deletion of Vadaine Oliver WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
3848 6377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yvonne Brown User:Tomwsulcer 22:26, 20 September 2014 (UTC) keep True, she was (died in 2012) mayor of a small town, but her story is interesting, moving from religious outreach to politics, and she is notable for being the first African-American woman mayor of any town in the USA, and she was a notable figure in the Republican convention because of her unique qualifications (ie, African-American, female, mayor who was ''Republican''). http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=3878566 She was interviewed on NPR by Tavis Smiley, and she got http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/05/20/AR2006052000523_pf.html coverage in a national newspaper -- the Washington Post -- here, and http://www.wapt.com/news/central-mississippi/Former-Tchula-Mayor-Brown-dies/11795938 coverage here and http://www.jacksonfreepress.com/news/2006/sep/16/mayor-yvonne-brown-guided-by-faith-driven-to-serve/ depth coverage here, http://msbusiness.com/blog/2006/04/24/tchula-mayor-wants-to-serve-second-congressional-district/ in-depth look into how she came to politics, http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/661777/posts in-depth treatment here, story that she http://www.wtok.com/news/headlines/626762.html won an impressive $5 million grant from Washington. Also http://books.google.com/books?id=steLXpuOONEC&pg=RA9-PA1671&lpg=RA9-PA1671&dq=%22Yvonne+Brown%22+Tchula&source=bl&ots=QLifkGdewb&sig=l_kdN54s3G0bb1MI3mrDZa-CjE4&hl=en&sa=X&ei=7_EdVOvxO8uMyATg6YDwDg&ved=0CCQQ6AEwATgU#v=onepage&q=%22Yvonne%20Brown%22%20Tchula&f=false she was included in the book 4,000 Ground-Breaking and Pioneering Historical Events. Numerous in-depth reliable independent sources means she passes the Deletion of Yvonne Brown WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3849 19892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thyrsus (Mage: the Awakening) User:Percy 09:10, 28 December 2007 (UTC) delete no independent coverage, fails Deletion of Thyrsus (Mage: the Awakening) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3850 1003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patricia Yunghanns User:SamHolt6 14:57, 14 December 2020 (UTC) delete subject fails to meet criteria. All of the sources cited in the article appear to be written by the subject or based upon information written by the subject (). Even the local news outlet sources are re-published content from unreliable sources like ABNewswire. In addition, there is no third-party coverage cited that could be used to assert the subject meets the criteria laid down by Deletion of Patricia Yunghanns WP:NAUTHOR||WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
3851 11190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michele O'Shea User:Agricola44 16:49, 11 November 2010 (UTC) delete I think any disinterested ed will come to the same conclusion after reviewing the article history. The subject is basically a student who is a country mile from fulfilling any of the broad collection of possible notability criteria we have here. The original article was a CV, filled mostly with . The current version is a gutted shell. This is an uncontroversial delete. Thanks Deletion of Michele O'Shea WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3852 10387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mr. Hero User:Wickethewok 14:15, 25 August 2006 (UTC) comment There are ''many'' around here in Cleveland. I think the guideline to be investigated is . It seems like it is probably notable, but some reliable sources would be nice. As it is, the article is pretty not good Deletion of Mr. Hero WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3853 18781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of counterintuitive truths User:LaundryPizza03 04:47, 13 May 2021 (UTC) delete Everything here is based on the personal opinion of creator {{user|Seckends}}, and nothing is based on a reliable source asserting that a proposition is counterintuitive to most people. And most of the examples were removed for being too obscure to possibly encounter most people's intuitions, or seeming as if the creator finds it hard to grasp many ideas. |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information. I could go on and on about everything wrong here, but the others have already summed it up Deletion of List of counterintuitive truths WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3854 3345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Libyan Premier League 2009-10 Fixtures & Results User:COMPFUNK2 22:18, 12 September 2009 (UTC) delete per . It also looks like the creator added a few tables but didn't put anything in them Deletion of Libyan Premier League 2009-10 Fixtures & Results WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3855 9223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of The Blacklist characters User:Gonnym 16:35, 24 January 2020 (UTC) keep list of subjects of a notable topic don't need to be notable by themselves as says {{tq|The notability guidelines do not apply to contents of articles or lists}}. If this were in the parent category you'd have no valid argument. The only reason this is in a different article is because of . Some editors, including some here, keep thinking that a) all entries in a list need to be notable, which is the exact opposite of what are guidelines actually say and b) that these need to be notable as a group, which is also incorrect, see my first point Deletion of List of The Blacklist characters WP:NLISTITEM||WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3856 13715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Cosgriff User:Cullen328 04:46, 11 May 2011 (UTC) delete I was unable to find any |reliable sources that discuss this person in depth Deletion of Charles Cosgriff WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3857 19257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Goal setting User:Colonel 10:38, 31 May 2010 (UTC) keep Great notability as there are http://books.google.com/books?as_brr=0&q=intitle:%22Goal+setting%22&btnG=Search+Books hundreds of books devoted to this topic. The rest is a matter of article improvement in accordance with our |editing policy. The current draft actually provides inline citations and its critics don't seem to have read closely enough to observe this or follow them up. Their opinion is therefore worthless Deletion of Goal setting WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
3858 18511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of boats in Arthur Ransome books [[User talk:TenPoundHammer|What did I screw up now?]]) 03:27, 5 November 2019 (UTC) delete """trivia, unsourced, no out of universe notability. Also {{ping|Dabbler}} might want to check because """"|I like it"""" is not a reason to keep. '''Ten Pound Hammer""" Deletion of List of boats in Arthur Ransome books WP:ATA||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
3859 6297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glen Maxey User:Capitalistroadster 21:29, 19 March 2006 (UTC) keep Under , being a current or former state politician qualifies you. It doesn't matter whether you are straight, gay, bi, lesbian or asexual Deletion of Glen Maxey WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3860 18344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liongrass Editions User:Lopifalko 17:59, 29 July 2020 (UTC) delete Has no sources and cannot find any to satisfy or Deletion of Liongrass Editions WP:GNG||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3861 2608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Laing [[User talk:146.198.67.160|talk]]) 10:36, 2 August 2019 (UTC) keep per / . Just needs work. Special:Contributions/146.198.67.160|Boleyn Deletion of Jamie Laing WP:BASIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3862 15180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007 Painesville, Ohio train derailment User:Dew 02:43, 10 January 2011 (UTC) keep per . This crash has had lasting effects, as can be shown by sourced information on lawsuits Deletion of 2007 Painesville, Ohio train derailment WP:EFFECT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3863 13280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BDJS Fernando User:Undead 15:13, 4 August 2011 (UTC) delete Not enough coverage in third party sources. Fails Deletion of BDJS Fernando WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3864 18006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gabriel Williams User:Sjones23 17:02, 1 May 2009 (UTC) delete Seriously fails , and OT#NEWS Deletion of Gabriel Williams WP:N||WP:BLP1E||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3865 18718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Scarlatoiu (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 21:23, 22 September 2016 (UTC) delete A person does not get over Wikipedia's inclusion and notability rules by giving soundbite in articles about other things, nor even by giving a ''lot'' of soundbite in a ''lot'' of articles about a ''lot'' of other things — a person gets over Wikipedia's inclusion and notability rules by being the ''subject'' of enough media coverage to satisfy . But little to no sourcing which satisfies that latter standard has been shown here; it's all glancing namechecks of his existence as the giver of soundbite in articles whose ''subjects'' are ''other'' things, and that's not how a person clears the bar. His name can be ''mentioned'' in the article on the organization he's affiliated with, sure — but ''none'' of this satisfies GNG to the degree needed to earn ''standalone'' BLP ''separate'' from being mentioned in the organization's article Deletion of Greg Scarlatoiu (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3866 271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aircrafts currently in production User:PennySpender1983 02:46, 21 September 2010 (UTC) delete per the policy that |wikipedia is not a directory of everything that exists or has existed. This data is better suited split and placed into the articles about each company. It is more likely to be maintained there Deletion of Aircrafts currently in production WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3867 10693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arno Maasdorp User:Quale 21:30, 17 September 2005 (UTC) delete No indication that this artist meets Deletion of Arno Maasdorp WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3868 9091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kincardine Beach Pavilion User:Dolphin51 22:45, 30 August 2011 (UTC) delete Non-notable building. Fails Deletion of Kincardine Beach Pavilion WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
3869 18416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barnraisers User:Madchester NONE delete fails requirements. Wiki is not a platform to promote an upcoming band either Deletion of Barnraisers WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
3870 3399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Rice User:Paste 15:35, 26 February 2011 (UTC) merge I would agree that a redirect is the correct route for this article, a tragic and untimely death but Deletion of Jordan Rice WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3871 15515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2006 Doodhipora killing User:Bharatiya29 18:12, 7 July 2018 (UTC) delete As per Deletion of 2006 Doodhipora killing WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3872 4205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellwood Walter (businessman) User:Lightburst 22:12, 20 July 2020 (UTC) keep I am adding newspaper articles to the article, there are many I added a Wisconsin newspaper (1862), and his obituary from the Philadelphia Inquirer (1877). Notable businessman who passes I will continue Deletion of Ellwood Walter (businessman) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3873 11031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moyara Ruehsen User:Hmlarson 00:42, 26 September 2016 (UTC) comment I've added a number of references that reinforce Criterion #7, including LA Times, Boston Globe, and others Deletion of Moyara Ruehsen WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
3874 347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Christian Bollywood actresses User:Cavarrone 09:47, 5 August 2016 (UTC) delete same as List of Muslim Bollywood actresses, pure , no indication that religion influences acting skills Deletion of List of Christian Bollywood actresses WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
3875 15780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Roseview Group User:Crunch 00:59, 22 January 2006 (UTC) comment In order for your company to fit the criteria for inclusion, it should fit these |Guidelines. Most companies do fit these guidelines and therefore most companies are not included in the Wikipedia encyclopedia Deletion of The Roseview Group WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3876 5345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Goodrich Club User:RoySmith 13:13, 19 September 2019 (UTC) delete Fails , badly. Clubcruft Deletion of The Goodrich Club WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3877 19926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tomáš Marcinek User:Papaursa 22:57, 6 June 2019 (UTC) delete Fails to meet and my search for coverage didn't find that is met Deletion of Tomáš Marcinek WP:NHOCKEY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3878 11692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noppol Sankapong User:WikiVirusC 17:07, 19 February 2018 (UTC) comment Article was created in 2009 when the player was with Nakhon Pathom FC while the team was in the fully professional Thai Premier League. We will need a source to show a match played, but this isn't as blatant violation of as it looks. Its just a poorly sourced article that if we can find some Thailand league match data, we would be able to properly source. The issue is sources will be from 9 years ago, and nearly all of them will be in Thai Deletion of Noppol Sankapong WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
3879 8462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beast (B2ST) User:MS 22:02, 31 October 2009 (UTC) keep Keep'''- The group seems to pass criteria #1. The page just needs to be cleat up Deletion of Beast (B2ST) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3880 19970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mushtaq Ahmed (cricketer, born 1997) User:Megtetg34 23:43, 22 March 2021 (UTC) delete Subject does not have enough coverage, or independent sources to pass . It's not borderline from where I'm sitting as it is the bare minimum requirement for inclusion. Page should be deleted Deletion of Mushtaq Ahmed (cricketer, born 1997) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3881 19336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pawan Tiwari User:Atlantic306 05:57, 5 November 2016 (UTC) comment the number of reliable sources outlined above mean is passed, the article can be improved rather than deleted Deletion of Pawan Tiwari WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3882 7937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kristin Leachman User:AllyD 07:40, 17 December 2015 (UTC) comment I have flagged this CSD G12 as the article text is copied from the subject's own site (with its claims also referenced to that source Deletion of Kristin Leachman :WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
3883 744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Guzman User:Johnuniq 02:21, 10 April 2017 (UTC) delete No evidence that is satisfied. The references I checked had only superficial mentions Deletion of Elizabeth Guzman WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3884 4935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hyperlay User:Serial 15:55, 8 April 2019 (UTC) delete per |policy Deletion of Hyperlay WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3885 18853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WooPlus User:Cabayi 16:58, 20 February 2019 (UTC) delete spam by an who gamed & ran away. Should have gone A7/G11 Deletion of WooPlus WP:SPA||WP:ACPERM Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
3886 2255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pat Phelan User:Number 22:47, 12 March 2008 (UTC) delete Fails #Athletes. The article can easily be restored if he ever plays professionally Deletion of Pat Phelan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3887 4785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boxxy User:Chasingsol 06:25, 27 January 2009 (UTC) delete The sole (dubious) |reliable source is a blog for the online version of a respected newspaper, the other mentions of this meme are from lesser known 'fan sites' and similar. Does not appear to meet . The subject of the article is a short-lived meme that has little relevance beyond those who frequent 4chan and has received no major news coverage Deletion of Boxxy WP:RS||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3888 4999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clayton McKinney User:TreyGeek 16:06, 29 May 2010 (UTC) delete fails and - as per Deletion of Clayton McKinney WP:N||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3889 16999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony D'Algy User:Lugnuts 17:34, 13 April 2020 (UTC) keep Passes - this guy appeared in 60+ films across three decades. The main issue is that span was from the mid 1920s, and he's Portuguese. However, |within a few seconds I found some sources straight away, and have included them in the article. Sadly, I don't speak Portuguese, but I'm betting there's a ton more in his native language Deletion of Tony D'Algy WP:NACTOR||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3890 20231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of politicians convicted of crimes User:Ifnord 16:15, 19 July 2020 (UTC) delete per . Such a large list, it really will neither ever be complete nor focused enough to be useful. You might as well have a list of politicians who wore ties. A more focused list, capital crimes or a specific category of crime, may be useful; this list is not that Deletion of List of politicians convicted of crimes WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3891 100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/State Crimes Against Democracy User:E 01:38, 23 May 2016 (UTC) delete """as mere promotion of an neologism that has not caught on. By his own account, Lance deHaven-Smith coined the term in his 2006 article """"State Crimes Against Democracy."""" (DeHaven-Smith, Lance. """"When Political Crimes Are Inside Jobs: Detecting State Crimes against Democracy."""" Administrative Theory & Praxis 28, no. 3 (2006): 330-55. http://www.jstor.org/stable/25610803.) His coinage has had a decade to catch on, and it has gotten little traction despite the fact that the conspiracy theories deHaven-Smith peddles are very popular. Check out deHaven-Smith's website http://dehaven-smith.com/faq/default.html ''""""What are some examples of SCADs in recent U.S. history? : the assassinations of John Kennedy, Robert Kennedy, and Martin Luther King; the attempted assassinations of George Wallace and Ronald Reagan; the election breakdowns in 2000 and 2004; the numerous defense failures on 9-11-2001; the anthrax mailings in October 2001""""'' There's more, but you get the drift. 9/11 conspiracy theory. JFK assassination conspiracy theory. Anthrax mailing conspiracy theory. Good grief. Original deHaven-Smits 2006 article defines a SCAD as :""""concerted actions or inactions by public officials that are intended to weaken or subvert popular control of their government."""" Note also that this page was started by an SPA in 2014, and has seen little in the way of expansion or incoming links in the years since. This seems to parallel the lack of resonance in the world at large, at least in my searches. The hits on the term in a books google search are a mix of conspiracy theory books, books about conspiracy theories, and a book by deHaven-Smith. If DeHaven-Smith's original article, or his book ''Conspiracy Theory in America'' were a Wikipedia article, we would delete it as mere , he piles one example after another with little to connect them, an dvirtually nothing in the way of evidence that these events were in fact conspiracies. ''Conspiracy Theory In America'' did garner a positive review on the website: Citizens for Truth About the Kennedy Assassination'' http://www.ctka.net/reviews/cta.html, but was ignored by the political press and scholarly world. Delete as per """ Deletion of State Crimes Against Democracy WP:COATRACK||WP:BROCHURE Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
3892 6607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad Umar (Lahore cricketer) User:SportingFlyer 18:18, 3 March 2021 (UTC) delete only source is Cricket Archive. As it stands, fails Deletion of Mohammad Umar (Lahore cricketer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3893 603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grace Kingston McLeod User:Eusebeus 18:44, 28 March 2008 (UTC) delete per . No assertion of real-world significance Deletion of Grace Kingston McLeod WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3894 21178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of international goals scored by Milan Baroš User:TompaDompa 01:42, 19 December 2020 (UTC) delete outright, do not merge. The parent article already contains a brief summary of this information, and that is (more than) enough. This list is and should never have been created in the first place; the list of goals belongs not in an encyclopaedia, but on a fansite or similar. This applies to ''all'' these lists, including |featured ones such as List of international goals scored by Abby Wambach and List of international goals scored by Cristiano Ronaldo. We also should not have List of 100 meter dashes by Usain Bolt or List of pole vaults by Sergey Bubka. Editors need to learn to summarize this information instead of exhaustively enumerating each example. To put it another way, we should strive to write Climate of London, not List of rainy days in London Deletion of List of international goals scored by Milan Baroš WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:FL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3895 14548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pornography-induced erectile dysfunction User:Lesion 02:57, 28 July 2013 (UTC) delete """if this is being presented as a medical condition, then there need to be MEDRS compliant sources. People reporting something on an internet forum does not make it a real medical condition, it's just more people stating boring opinions on the internet (**hypocrisy alert**). The blog and the Dr Oz show are definitely not suitable sources, I can't assess the book, but it's using terms like """"sexual brain maps"""" I wonder how mainstream it is... per above comment from a reliable editor, a search for sources on PubMed, google scholar did not find anything on this supposed condition. Redirect is only appropriate if a MEDRS source can be found to support some of this content ... unless ... there is potential mention of this based upon these same sources in """"society and culture"""" sections of erectile dysfunction and/or pornography. I generally think that generally rather than applies to the history and society and culture sections of medical pages. This would be the appropriate way to document a """"meme"""" and present it as it is rather than presenting it as a medical condition when it is not. I would alter the wording of such content to reflect the lack of medical sources, but this might be hard to do without breaching """ Deletion of Pornography-induced erectile dysfunction WP:RS||WP:MEDRS||WP:OR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3896 20301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Americans in the Venona papers (2nd nomination) User:Spinningspark 22:19, 26 May 2012 (UTC) delete List is sourced to a single author who has associated Soviet codenames with real people. Any verifiable information can be added to the Venona project article. The rest are non-notable specualtion. Some of these people may still be alive so the page also has potential |BLP issues, the page title implies they were named in the Venona decrypts whereas the codenames are associated with real life names by synthesis and accusation Deletion of List of Americans in the Venona papers (2nd nomination) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3897 16142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul and Carol Mott User:Schuym1 23:05, 22 January 2009 (UTC) delete The only reliable source with significant coverage that I can find is http://www.horse-canada.com/articles/HCcarolmott07.03.htm this. Fails Deletion of Paul and Carol Mott WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3898 3205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tariq Mahmud Naim User:Kmzayeem 16:30, 25 September 2020 (UTC) delete fails . No significant coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Tariq Mahmud Naim WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3899 20056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Tedesco User:JoannaSerah 19:02, 10 February 2013 (UTC) delete Yes, it seems like electioneering and hasn't held statewide office or anything higher than school board, but has generated some recognition. And Wake County is one of the largest counties in NC, so it isn't just like any other school board out there. I would say delete completely because he does fail to me too, but then my AfD of Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Keadle|Scott Keadle wound up as no consensus. Seems similar Deletion of John Tedesco WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
3900 2047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DIIA User:Mduvekot 22:59, 6 April 2016 (UTC) delete per high probability (96.1%) that article is a copyvio according to http://tools.wmflabs.org/copyvios/?lang=en&project=wikipedia&title=&oldid=287186664&action=search&use_engine=1&use_links=1&turnitin=0 Earwig's Copyvio Detector Deletion of DIIA WP:G12 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
3901 7584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Accompany User:Pharaoh 00:24, 21 September 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Accompany WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
3902 2423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Ling (footballer) User:Hmlarson 01:42, 29 April 2017 (UTC) comment Here are some references to improve the article to meet (which trumps ) found from a Google News search. In my opinion, it should be improved, not deleted per . http://www.barkinganddagenhampost.co.uk/sport/football/dagenham-and-redbridge/dagenham-redbridge-boss-john-still-happy-to-bring-in-sam-ling-after-debut-in-win-over-dover-athletic-1-4695651 1, http://www.barkinganddagenhampost.co.uk/sport/football/dagenham-and-redbridge/dagenham-redbridge-defender-sam-ling-says-rehabiilitation-work-has-been-better-with-so-many-players-out-injured-1-4830527 2, http://www.barkinganddagenhampost.co.uk/sport/football/dagenham-and-redbridge/dagenham-redbridge-defender-sam-ling-says-there-is-no-added-pressure-on-squad-just-because-they-are-top-ahead-of-trip-to-bromley-1-4708016 3, http://www.barkinganddagenhampost.co.uk/sport/football/dagenham-and-redbridge/dagenham-redbridge-defender-sam-ling-admits-red-card-for-scott-doe-was-a-game-changer-1-4829720 4 Looks like there's also some potential hits on BBC - probably worth a bit more time adding sufficient references {{ping|DM Trix Deletion of Sam Ling (footballer) WP:GNG||WP:FOOTY||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
3903 20558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/67 (sex position) User:JJL 03:54, 10 December 2007 (UTC) delete """per . Just a variant of the """"68"""" joke (George Carlin""" Deletion of 67 (sex position) WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3904 16612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of novels, the action of which takes place within 24 hours User:Gavin 11:09, 27 April 2010 (UTC) delete as the creation entirely novel list topic contravene the prohibition on #OR|original research as illustrated by . As far as I can see, this list, or anything like it, has not be been published anywhere except within Wikipedia, so there is no evidence that it is verifiable, let alone notable. To demonstrate that this topic was not created based on editor's own idea, a verifiable definition is needed to provide external validation that this list complies with |content policy Deletion of List of novels, the action of which takes place within 24 hours WP:NOT||WP:MADEUP||WP:CONPOL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3905 29 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Peşeng Kullanıcı:takabegtakabeg 08:14, 4 Şubat 2010 (UTC) comment Bildiğiniz gibi eninde sonunda bu madde başından sonuna kadar |özgün araştırmadır. İsterseniz bunu silelim bilimsel kaynakları bulursanız yeniden açabilirsiniz. Ne dersiniz Peşeng'in silinmesi Vikipedi:Özgün araştırmalara yer vermemek Wikipedia:No original research 65
3906 1905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naoki Sano User:Nikki311 04:46, 16 February 2010 (UTC) keep passes as a professional wrestler, as previously mentioned. In addition, he passes it as a mixed martial artist, as he was a part of the Pride Fighting Championships, one of the top MMA companies Deletion of Naoki Sano WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3907 13784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Athletesareanimals User:Xyzzyplugh 20:46, 5 August 2006 (UTC) delete No alexa ranking, its discussion forums have 8 registered members, fails and any other measure of notability Deletion of Athletesareanimals WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
3908 7058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/100% Hits: The Best of 2006 (2nd nomination) User:Doctorhawkes 06:12, 19 July 2015 (UTC) keep Meets if it was certified platinum Deletion of 100% Hits: The Best of 2006 (2nd nomination) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3909 2375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Digital Nitrate Prize User:Blue520 06:50, 18 April 2006 (UTC) delete """seems to have problems with & may fall under - crystal ball as the article notes """"A group is forming to determine the rules of the competition and to raise money for the prize""" Deletion of Digital Nitrate Prize WP:V||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
3910 12390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earth in science fiction (2nd nomination) User:Piotrus 04:57, 13 July 2021 (UTC) keep the current version, which is effectively the version, as 99% of old OR content is gone, and the new version is now properly referenced. I think we can use the two sources found and de stub it too, maybe DYK it Deletion of Earth in science fiction (2nd nomination) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
3911 1463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Threesomething User:onel5969 15:52, 6 October 2018 (UTC) delete searches did not turn up enough in-depth coverage to pass , and certainly doesn't meet Deletion of Threesomething WP:GNG||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
3912 8460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salvador Ruiz User:Argyle 19:04, 30 November 2011 (UTC) delete Fail and Deletion of Salvador Ruiz WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3913 14949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Universal intelligence User:WoKrKmFK3lwz8BKvaB94 11:55, 7 December 2016 (UTC) delete We need some here. Blow it up and start over with the AI term which is more usual. The innate intelligence ideas need to be described at the other article Deletion of Universal intelligence WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
3914 4390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theatre, Club and Arena Tour User:Escape_Orbit 16:30, 30 November 2016 (UTC) delete Fails . Possibly may yet pass it at some point, but not yet Deletion of Theatre, Club and Arena Tour WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3915 9002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fabrice Elysée Kouadio Kouakou User:Crystallizedcarbon 18:35, 14 January 2015 (UTC) comment I feel like George Armstrong Custer|Custer at his Battle of the Little Bighorn|Last Stand ;) , When I first read this AfD I was going to vote '''Delete''', but after doing some efore my only choice was to vote '''Keep'''. I have just improved the article and I must insist that the article clearly meets . There are at least 3 sources that objectively meet the first 4 requirements cited in the policy. The only subjective point is the fifth, that significant coverage in reliable sources creates an assumption, not a guarantee, that a subject should be included. But the article does not violate WP:what Wikipedia is not and his achievements for 2012 and 2014 are indeed notable so there is no reason to justify deletion. In addition, it is confirmed by USM Alger that he has been transferred, and according to the subject he will probably play his first game before the end of this month, meeting also Deletion of Fabrice Elysée Kouadio Kouakou WP:B||WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Bots 21
3916 9726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cartwright band User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable musical group. &mdash Deletion of Cartwright band WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3917 6990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kassy Dillon User:SportingFlyer 16:11, 29 November 2020 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass per the above votes Deletion of Kassy Dillon WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3918 5128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Regions of sydney User:WWGB 12:12, 20 July 2008 (UTC) delete """Unreferenced, """"blue ribbon suburbs"""" appears to be """ Deletion of Regions of sydney WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3919 19176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gritter (software) NONE NONE delete """The article is about a plugin for jQuery which advises that JQuery#jQuery_plug-ins|""""There are thousands of jQuery plug-ins available on the Web"""". This is one of those thousands and is not |notable""" Deletion of Gritter (software) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3920 12480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nipissing University Student Union User:TerriersFan 22:41, 16 March 2008 (UTC) delete student bodies have to meet . This requires significant secondary sources. This page hasn't them and thus clearly fails notability standards Deletion of Nipissing University Student Union WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3921 13781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Culture of Akron, Ohio User:JonRidinger 07:12, 13 December 2009 (UTC) comment """This doesn't need expanded it needs completely rewritten. One of the biggest reasons the Akron, Ohio article is so long is because it too contains an enormous amount of |fancruft and other """"interesting"""" but largely irrelevant triva. And this article has had several tags on it for months with little or no action""" Deletion of Culture of Akron, Ohio WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
3922 10196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rosemount Middle School User:TerriersFan 20:10, 11 October 2008 (UTC) keep as a Blue Ribbon School with plenty of sources to meet Deletion of Rosemount Middle School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3923 5583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tatiana Iuel User:Metropolitan90 05:29, 1 November 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Being in the line of succession to the British throne is not inherently a claim of notability, particularly when there are over 900 people ahead of the person (as there are for Tatiana), the person is only 5 years old, and no sources are provided to indicate any media coverage of her life. People much higher in the British line of succession have been deleted per ; see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marina Ogilvy, Zenouska Mowatt, and Christian Mowatt for a group of people in the top 40 of the succession line whose articles were deleted Deletion of Tatiana Iuel WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3924 1174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alec Powers (3rd nomination) User:Thryduulf 23:51, 13 February 2010 (UTC) keep The sources in the article show that he passes Deletion of Alec Powers (3rd nomination) WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3925 11232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tariq Amadi User:BenTels 17:34, 9 September 2012 (UTC) delete Does not seem to meet from easily accessible h-index calculations. But he has a lot of older papers, so I'm open to contrary arguments from domain experts Deletion of Tariq Amadi WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3926 15196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ricardo Duchesne User:DÜNGÁNÈ 17:34, 25 August 2011 (UTC) delete """First of all, Mr. Duchesne is just one of hundreds of unimportant professors who have so far, not been noted by any major scholars. Secondly, the way the article was written was in a manner designed to promote Mr. Duchesne's views, I have removed violations of from the article, and the creator of the article, User:Gun Powder Ma has been inserting Duchesne's work onto multiple other articles and calling it """"influential"""", which may be seen as an attempt at puffery. See""" Deletion of Ricardo Duchesne WP:PEACOCK Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
3927 3523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wipe Your Eyes (2nd nomination) User:onel5969 23:59, 7 January 2021 (UTC) merge all, none meet Deletion of Wipe Your Eyes (2nd nomination) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3928 21254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Beitler User:Becky 14:46, 31 December 2014 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Michael Beitler WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3929 20005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Cantoni User:Sir 04:25, 19 March 2014 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of David Cantoni WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3930 3474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Online Film Critics' Poll User:Erik 18:43, 4 January 2013 (UTC) delete """per not meeting Wikipedia:Notability (organizations and companies)|the notability guidelines for organizations. Anna made me realize that this topic can be seen as an organization, and I had not considered the guidelines specific to organizations. in particular was my earlier concern; even with reliable sources, the content amounts to routine announcements. In addition, upon reviewing ''Yes! Weekly'', I just noticed that the writer said the following: """"Founded in 2007, this marked the third edition of the IOFCP — and the first in which ''I was honored to participate''"""" (italics mine). I think this disqualifies it as an independent source even as it provides a bit more history than the rest of the sources""" Deletion of International Online Film Critics' Poll WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
3931 10201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Knut Anders Opstad User:AllyD 06:58, 2 September 2014 (UTC) delete The version prior to https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Knut_Anders_Opstad&diff=prev&oldid=414049632 this IP edit did have references. They are deadlinks but a search on the subject's name at http://www.dn.no/ Dagens Næringsliv does turn up several 2007-8 articles. However, this appears to fall under and there is no evidence of lasting biographical notability Deletion of Knut Anders Opstad :WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3932 14100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Walker (footballer born 1992) User:Bettia 14:12, 9 July 2009 (UTC) delete for now due to failure to meet and lack of sources establishing general notability. This article can easily be recreated if and when he makes his professional debut Deletion of Paul Walker (footballer born 1992) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3933 2231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World's Finest Shows User:ERcheck 15:49, 19 February 2006 (UTC) delete Advertisement for company that does not meet . &mdash Deletion of World's Finest Shows WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3934 12069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Passive drinking User:Cyclopia 13:22, 14 October 2010 (UTC) keep WP:GNG. The term has real-world substantial coverage: see some of the http://books.google.com/books?as_brr=0&as_pub=-icon&q=%22Passive+drinking%22 Google books results for example. The article has problems but that is |not a reason to delete, and at least two references are germane. I would be happy with a suitable merge target but found none Deletion of Passive drinking WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3935 18221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellen Bork User:ExRat 12:36, 29 January 2021 (UTC) keep and '''Comment'''. Did you do a proper this AfD? I just Googled her and pulled up a multitude of articles she penned for ''https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/author/ellen-bork The Washington Examiner'', ''https://www.usnews.com/topics/author/ellen-bork U.S. News & World Report'' and several articles from ''The Wall Street Journal'', such as https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702303661904576453672924851518 this. There's also a list of articles she authored or co-authored for various publications at https://muckrack.com/ellen-bork/articles Muck Rack. There's also coverage of her at https://militarist-monitor.org/profile/ellen-bork/#_edn5 Militarist Monitor which includes links to articles published by ''The New York Times'', ''The Weekly Standard'', ''Financial Times'', ''The Washington Post'', ''Humanitarian Affairs Review'', and ''Forward''. Seems notable enough to me to keep, with her prominent roles with Project for the New American Century and as an Asia specialist for the Senate Committee on Foreign Relations Deletion of Ellen Bork WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3936 17970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apparel 2000 User:Mcmatter 22:38, 2 August 2021 (UTC) delete I can't find anything to support this company meeting the requirements of or to the lesser effect . The 2 sources I found were just simple mentions they worked with some groups to make patches https://www.miningjournal.net/news/front-page-news/2020/04/living-green-re-embroider-recycle-repeat-nmus-dining-services-repurposes-old-uniforms/ and https://www.seacoastonline.com/news/20180913/east-kingston-keeps-memory-alive-of-fallen-officer Deletion of Apparel 2000 WP:NCORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3937 10182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Cartwright (Pennsylvania politician) User:Northamerica1000 21:52, 9 June 2012 (UTC) keep spaced ndash}} Upon reviewing the links above provided by User:Gobonobo, this person certainly passes and with ease Deletion of Matt Cartwright (Pennsylvania politician) WP:BASIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3938 15937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thinsulate User:Newslinger 12:42, 14 September 2018 (UTC) keep Meets with HighBeam Research references cited in the article. — Deletion of Thinsulate WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3939 143 [[Marko_Wolfram]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:DasBee NONE delete Lt. Löschung von Marko_Wolfram Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
3940 15162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plane Ride from Hell User:JamesBWatson 10:57, 10 May 2013 (UTC) comment """Contrary to what the creator of the latest version of the article says, it is not true that """"the first AfD centred around the basis that it was a rumour, didn't sound real, and was generally an urban myth"""". The nominator referred to it as a """"rumored"""" event, and said that he or she wasn't sure if it happened, but subsequent discussion accepted that it happened, and centred on the issue of notability. In fact, notability was the central issue in both the previous AfD discussions. The present article does have better sources than the previous versions, which is why I am not speedily deleting it as a repost of a previously AfD-deleted article (Speedy deletion criterion #G4|G4). Whether those sources are good enough to establish notability must be the issue here. At present, there are three references. (1) A YouTube video of one of the people in the incident talking about it. Never mind the issues with YouTube about copyright etc, this is not independent coverage. (2) A Bleacher Report page. Wikipedia:WikiProject Professional wrestling/Style guide includes the Bleacher Report in a list headed """"Unreliable sources - Avoid using these websites as sources"""". (3) A blog-like page on a web site called """"PWInsider"""". I don't know much about PWInsider, but it seems that this page does not do much to establish notability. Since the other two sources are close to worthless as far as establishing notability is concerned, I have to be inclined towards '''delete""" Deletion of Plane Ride from Hell WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
3941 9331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlo Diego D'Andrea User:SamHolt6 23:41, 21 June 2018 (UTC) delete WP:MILL|run of the mill lawyer and businessman. Subject fails , for while they are named in several sources, these sources by and large do not concern D'Andrea; rather, they focus on entities that D'Andrea is affiliated with, which is an issue given that subjects do not inherit notability () from other, more notable topics. Thus these mentions should not be construed as conferring undue notability on D'Andrea, and I would wager they constitute mentions in passing or trivial mentions. It should also be noted that Wikipedia does not hold businessmen or lawyers to be innately notable, and that chambers of commerce (several of which D'Andrea is a member of) often name members based on financial contributions. Finally, nothing indicates why the subject is individually notable when compared to other corporate lawyers or why anything about D'Andrea has any longterm encyclopedic notability Deletion of Carlo Diego D'Andrea WP:GNG||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
3942 3267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/What Up User:Esradekan 03:19, 6 July 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per #Songs & Deletion of What Up WP:MUSIC||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3943 8166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicolette Rankin User:timtempleton 19:20, 3 May 2018 (UTC) merge to Open English. I noticed the Open English article was deleted twice, for promo and copyvio reasons, but I'll take a shot at recreating it as a stub with some of the info in here. If I can find enough, then this problem is solved. Give me an hour. In this case, most of the sourcing on her is the Harvard Business Review coverage, which is nice but really more about the company. And I'm not really sure that being featured in HBR puts a business over the top for notability - it just means they had a notable problem that can be a teaching moment for students. I don't see enough other coverage about her - just the company. So fails Deletion of Nicolette Rankin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3944 10765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chicken Kiev Parmigiana (Karma) User:Arxiloxos 07:13, 23 November 2010 (UTC) delete based on the article (and the dearth of any outside sources for this invented recipe in a Google search) this appears to be, literally, Deletion of Chicken Kiev Parmigiana (Karma) WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
3945 15345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Echidnas (Sonic the Hedgehog) User:Randomran 15:20, 3 July 2008 (UTC) delete as this article does not meet the |general notability guideline of coverage in multiple secondary sources that are independent of the subject. As per , every article must assert its own notability Deletion of Echidnas (Sonic the Hedgehog) WP:GNG||WP:AVOIDSPLIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3946 21471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/L'Afrique en morceaux User:Shawn 22:31, 10 March 2012 (UTC) keep within minutes, I was able add two : an interview with the director about the project by ARTE France, and a feature story by the Afrik.com news site. The nominator has complained that the mass creation of these articles is disruptive; I would argue that a mass deletion with little effort to find reliable sources would be more of a problem. (If this string of nominations continues, and ''if'' it can be shown that the nominator is failing to make a good faith effort to find reliable sources in a number of these cases, then I'd say the nominator is in violation of . But those are IFs, I'm not saying that's the case now Deletion of L'Afrique en morceaux WP:RS||WP:POINT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3947 6491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kathy Chitty (2nd nomination) User:AJHingston 21:11, 18 June 2011 (UTC) delete Though I understand the reasons for retention set out in the earlier AfD debate, I am persuaded by Herostratus. Yes, she was an important part of Paul Simon's life for a period, but notability is not inherited. She is referred to, obliquely, in some of his songs. People have referred to her in biographies of Paul Simon, but she was not part of the making of his music so far as I can tell. There is no indication of what has happened in the rest of her life, so probably . Not independently notable, part of the Paul Simon story, and she should not have her own biography in Wikipedia Deletion of Kathy Chitty (2nd nomination) WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3948 6571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Homafaran allegiance User:Otr500 09:20, 2 February 2018 (UTC) delete """per nom, , and Wikipedia:Notability (events), that community consensus has determined does matter. There are ''multiple millions'' of """"historic photographs"""" around the world but we don't push them to be more significant than the event a photograph was taken at or of, just to create a Wikipedia gallery of historic pictures. http://www.magiran.com/npview.asp?ID=2239316 This source from the article states """"...Imam Khomeini during his visit to Alawi School on February 19"""" and the photograph was contested as propaganda. Since it was so secretive we have to place in the article ''""""Army public relations denied the photo but '''Ruhollah Khomeini confirmed its authenticity'''.""""''. The world of Wikipedia does not revolve around that Ruhollah Khomeini alone can certify that the picture was not a group of """"cadets"""" being photographed as propaganda. This is the reason for requiring multiple |reliable sources""" Deletion of Homafaran allegiance WP:NOTGALLERY||WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3949 682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indhuja Ravichandran User:Nosebagbear 13:44, 16 June 2019 (UTC) keep she satisfies criterion 1. The requirement is ''significant'', not leading coverage. She's been the 3rd or 4th actor/actress in multiple films Deletion of Indhuja Ravichandran WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
3950 11044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Matlock User:Imzadi1979 01:03, 25 March 2013 (UTC) delete fails and . Lists like these should be transwikied to Wikivoyage rather than left on Wikipedia Deletion of List of bus routes in Matlock WP:GNG||WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3951 5031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J.D. Durkin User:Bearian 00:36, 16 June 2017 (UTC) delete per , , and . Nobody has stepped forward after many days to rescue this mess. He hosts a cable show on an obscure channel. So did my oldest brother. So what Deletion of J.D. Durkin WP:SNOW||WP:TNT||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
3952 17787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DARE Championship User:Astudent0 18:01, 29 August 2011 (UTC) delete Non notable events by a non-notable organization that fails Deletion of DARE Championship WP:MMANOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
3953 8036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Newsmart User:Dialectric 16:47, 15 March 2016 (UTC) delete Software article of unclear notability, lacking independent references. The only ref provided is written by a company employee, and a search turned up no significant, independent coverage. Article creator and major contributor are Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|SPA accounts, one with a name similar to a company employee, so possibly promotional Deletion of Newsmart WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3954 9544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DreamHost (2nd nomination) User:HelloAnnyong 14:21, 29 June 2009 (UTC) keep DreamHost definitely satisfies ; plenty of sources to go around. Whether or not the article in its current incarnation is a different story, but there certainly is potential here. &mdash Deletion of DreamHost (2nd nomination) WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
3955 10378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional weasels User:TreasuryTag 09:38, 8 July 2010 (UTC) delete per {{user|Tavix}} – there is no established notability for the ''topic'', rendering the page an indiscriminate collection of information (so Deletion of List of fictional weasels WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
3956 8850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siae Microelettronica User:Waggie 19:36, 3 January 2017 (UTC) comment To the nom ({{u|Vale93b}}, please note that per and - in a deletion discussion, the purpose of writing an article doesn't factor in to a deletion discussion, nor does the quality of the article's ''assertion'' of notability. It strictly comes down to whether the subject is actually notable or not. Would you please be willing to clarify your nomination under those understandings? A Google News search reveals a few reliable sources discussing the article subject. Digging through the mountain of press releases wasn't easy, but some reliable, comprehensive, coverage does exist: http://www.mbnews.it/2014/04/vimercate-alcatel-no-ai-contratti-di-solidarieta-dal-7-maggio-inizia-la-cassa/, http://www.rcrwireless.com/20160113/analyst-angle/nokia-purcase-alcatel-lucent-61-reverse-split-tag9, http://www.lightwaveonline.com/articles/2014/12/alcatel-lucent-transfers-optics-r-d-to-italys-sm-optics.html. I'm not taking a stance one way or the other regarding deletion, I just wanted to introduce more facts and point out the AfD guidelines Deletion of Siae Microelettronica WP:AFD||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3957 3818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Digital community art User:Stuartyeates 05:36, 16 November 2011 (UTC) delete as a with no significant coverage Deletion of Digital community art WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3958 21302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Runeterra User:Red 22:08, 10 July 2020 (UTC) merge to Legends of Runeterra as a valid |alternative to deletion. Clearly not an independently notable fictional setting, but as Masem pointed out, surely a valid search term for the main game, which includes this word in the title Deletion of Runeterra WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
3959 19491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vincenzo Cox User:Spiderone 12:35, 13 August 2009 (UTC) delete appears to be non-notable as he hasn't received any news coverage therefore failing Deletion of Vincenzo Cox WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
3960 14213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LRG clothing User:Wikipediatrix 05:09, 4 August 2007 (UTC) comment That they did some design work for T-Mobile is encouraging, but still not sure that satisfies Deletion of LRG clothing WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3961 9473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nadeea User:Dissolve 08:50, 28 February 2009 (UTC) delete Fails the notability standards set at Deletion of Nadeea WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3962 13156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flo Jalin User:FiggyBee 06:49, 18 December 2006 (UTC) delete doesn't meet Deletion of Flo Jalin WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3963 11948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diseconomies of scale User:Colonel 12:04, 28 November 2013 (UTC) keep This is a standard topic covered in economics textbooks. If the nominator doesn't like the current draft, he may improve it himself per our |editing policy. |AFD is not cleanup Deletion of Diseconomies of scale WP:IMPERFECT||WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
3964 13504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernard London User:Atlantic306 22:10, 1 July 2016 (UTC) keep as improved references detailed above have improved the article so that is passed, and he nas had significant impact on economic discussion Deletion of Bernard London WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3965 14554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Dilts (2nd nomination) User:APerson 14:16, 14 January 2015 (UTC) delete per nom. Very promotional; fails Deletion of Robert Dilts (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
3966 20885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elena Shportun User:Pohta 12:11, 8 February 2010 (UTC) keep I guess. She won the World Amateur Championships twice, so that might qualify her by . I'm not into bodybuilding, so I don't know if that's a well known competition or not, but http://english.pravda.ru/society/stories/30-09-2006/84775-Russian_bodybuilder-0 coverage is easy to find Deletion of Elena Shportun WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3967 8194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darren Heitner User:Bearian 22:38, 15 October 2007 (UTC) delete Sports agent with 2 clients, blogger about sports, screams NN. No cites screams . Ironically, his relative Ken Heinter of Avaya is much more notable Deletion of Darren Heitner WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
3968 8632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008 United States presidential election controversies and attacks User:Horologium 13:58, 25 April 2008 (UTC) delete as per nom. Articles such as this are simply laundry lists of grievances against the candidates, stripping them of context and presenting an |undue weight concern. All of the issues addressed in this article are already extensively linked at the candidates' biography articles and (where they are currently relevant) their campaign articles. We don't need another fork that serves only to foment MOAR DRAMAH Deletion of 2008 United States presidential election controversies and attacks WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
3969 16861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solution Inn User:davidwr 21:02, 11 October 2015 (UTC) delete Nothing in the article suggests it meets or any other applicable notability guidelines. Relatively few companies that are less than 7 years old and which have less than 100 employeeshttps://www.crunchbase.com/organization/solutioninn meet Wikipedia's criteria for inclusion Deletion of Solution Inn WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3970 11191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eugene Goodman (police officer) User:Mztourist 04:06, 15 January 2021 (UTC) delete fails and , complete , WP is Deletion of Eugene Goodman (police officer) WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG||WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3971 286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vague relationship User:Nwlaw63 23:54, 2 February 2011 (UTC) delete If this is an encyclopedia article then I'm a lamppost. It's an essay with no sources - at its most trivial Deletion of Vague relationship WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
3972 10313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Wilson (actor) NONE NONE keep I think the subject can make a case for : he had starring roles in ''Time Trap (film)'', ''Church Ball'' and ''Druid Peak'' (though the latter two films are less notable), and supporting roles in ''Bottle Rocket (film)'', ''Fever Pitch (2005 film)'', ''Idiocracy (film)'', ''Calvin Marshall'', ''Whip It (film)'' and ''The Big Year''. He also co-directed ''The Wendell Baker Story'' with brother Luke. In terms of , however, many of the articles I've found mention or discuss the subject with respect to his brothers Deletion of Andrew Wilson (actor) WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3973 19014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blend corp User:Alphachimp 03:25, 7 August 2006 (UTC) delete Actually, I get even fewer, http://www.google.com/search?as_q=%22Blend%20corp%22&num=50&hl=en&lr=lang_en&as_ft=i&as_qdr=all&as_occt=any&as_dt=i 136 ghits. It's not notable and it fails , , and Deletion of Blend corp WP:CORP||WP:ORG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
3974 20250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blocking of Wikipedia in mainland China User:Ravenswing 19:16, 29 June 2007 (UTC) merge """While I agree that isn't a valid ground here - like it or not, Wikipedia looms largely in the news, and if you want an example as to why, Google """"Chris Benoit"""" right now - there probably isn't enough material to sustain an independent article""" Deletion of Blocking of Wikipedia in mainland China WP:ASR Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
3975 2746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ikonick User:HighKing 14:21, 3 February 2019 (UTC) delete Not a single reference meets the criteria for establishing notability. The references are entirely promotional, the article provides no indications of why this company is notable. References fails and/or . Article fails , and GNG Deletion of Ikonick WP:ORGIND||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:SPIP||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3976 14915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Five Star Urgent Care User:I 07:38, 11 November 2014 (UTC) keep meets Deletion of Five Star Urgent Care WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3977 3836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Biffole User:Meshach 05:02, 14 October 2007 (UTC) delete per . Not encyclopedic Deletion of Biffole WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
3978 3943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billard (slang) User:Armbrust 15:45, 2 May 2010 (UTC) delete as article fails Deletion of Billard (slang) WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3979 250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Red this ever user:DakotaKahn 07:12, 24 March 2006 (UTC) delete This is reposted content 3 times speedy deleted. Does not meet Deletion of Red this ever WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
3980 12790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erika Schwartz (2nd nomination) User:Techwikiwitty 14:39, 3 December 2016 (UTC) delete Does not meet . Notability is established from in-depth coverage from reliable, independent sources, which this page lacks. The sources do not show recognition from the medical community, but rather the press as a result of promotional activity (around her book releases Deletion of Erika Schwartz (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3981 6642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Air Force (game) User:Solarra 08:03, 5 June 2014 (UTC) delete As much as I tried to find sources for this, the only things I can find are user-generated board game clubs and other similar sites. Going through 15 pages of Google, Bing, and Yahoo search results I couldn't find anything relevant to point out the notability of this board game. As such the article clearly falls under and fails Deletion of Air Force (game) WP:OR||WP:N Wikipedia:No original research 65
3982 184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Holmes (football player) NONE NONE comment VegaDark says that the standard is unreasonable, DarkAudit says that has not been met. Can you get together on this one, or do you want to maintain opposing points Deletion of John Holmes (football player) WP:ATHLETE||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
3983 20742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Payability User:HighKing 20:58, 12 April 2021 (UTC) delete Good work by Megtetg34 on analyzing the references. Topic fails Deletion of Payability WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3984 15367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quality villas User:APerson 17:22, 8 July 2015 (UTC) delete Couldn't find any sources providing much significant coverage. Fails Deletion of Quality villas WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3985 1105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chemistry Set Records User:Wwwwolf 21:37, 17 May 2006 (UTC) delete """per head-spinning-inducing screeds. Anons, please note that ranting about unrelated articles isn't going to help the case of ''this'' article. Also, """"Someone doing something first"""" isn't notable per se, unless the action really is world-changing (think of then-famous and now-famous bands getting leverage from Napster - while this is just some company hopping on the bandwagon a lot later). In this case, Weed may be notable, but there's no evidence about the company's notability (unless some is provided); as such, it may warrant a small mention in the Weed article. But unless this company is notable in its own merits, it doesn't need an article of its own - so please, read carefully and explain a contrary point. (And what does http://www.dict.org/bin/Dict?Form=Dict2&Database=*&Query=arist rising up have to do with P2P music distribution, anyway? Sorry, not intended as a lame spelling flame or anything - I was just so colossally disappointed when I thought I might learn some new musical term that I ''had'' to complain. Sorry""" Deletion of Chemistry Set Records WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3986 6096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fantasy bond User:XOR 23:36, 14 August 2021 (UTC) delete Such sources that do exist fail the |relevant standard Deletion of Fantasy bond WP:MEDRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
3987 21392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Donnelly (Scottish footballer) User:GiantSnowman 19:13, 19 September 2013 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Paul Donnelly (Scottish footballer) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
3988 10048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of ships attacked by Somali pirates in 2013 User:Hisashiyarouin 14:39, 25 January 2015 (UTC) merge These lists would warrant a if it is very large, say like List of ships attacked by Somali pirates in 2008|the 2008 list (78 kB) and List of ships attacked by Somali pirates in 2009|the 2009 list (82 kB). The 2013 list seems to have been created just in for the pattern of the split lists, and looks severely unfinished in its current state. If that's the only two attacks in the year, it would be better to incubate back at the main article and only split again if necessary Deletion of List of ships attacked by Somali pirates in 2013 WP:SIZESPLIT Wikipedia:Splitting 57
3989 17629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohkam NGO User:SamHolt6 03:57, 17 September 2017 (UTC) delete Fails due to a severe lack of coverage Deletion of Mohkam NGO WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
3990 14873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andre Holmes User:Cbl62 20:02, 3 November 2011 (UTC) keep """I was initially inclined to vote """"delete"""" on this one. After all, Holmes played for Hillsdale College, which is a Division II program. But as I started digging, I found enough to satisfy me that he passes with the amount of non-trivial coverage he has received in the mainstream media. The feature stories in ESPN.com and ''Chicago Sun-Times'' tipped the scales in favor of a """"keep."""" Holmes also set the all-time record for receiving yardage in Hillsdale College history and played in the Texas vs. The Nation All-Star Game. Examples of the non-trivial coverage includes: '''(1)''' """"http://espn.go.com/blog/chicago/colleges/post/_/id/2837/ex-conant-star-primed-for-nfl-chance Ex-Conant star primed for NFL chance, April 28, 2011, ESPN.com; '''(2)''' """"http://www.suntimes.com/sports/football/5040297-419/ex-depaul-star-kevin-holmes-excited-about-sons-nfl-draft-chances.html Ex-DePaul star Kevin Holmes excited about son's NFL draft chances,"""" ''Chicago Sun-Times'', April 26, 2011; '''(3)''' http://www.onenewspage.com/n/Lifestyle/74mqm1kfx/Hillsdale-star-Andre-Holmes-seeks-spot-with.htm Hillsdale star Andre Holmes seeks a spot with Vikings,"""" The Detroit News, July 28, 2011; '''(4)''' """"Good to be home, Holmes sets record as Chargers win,"""" The Hillsdale Daily News, November 8, 2010 (reporting that Holmes had set the all-time record at Hillsdale for receiving yardage), '''(5)''' """"Quality compadres: Juniors Weatherhead and Holmes are a big part of Chargers' success,"""" The Hillsdale Daily News, November 6, 2009, '''(6)''' """"Holmes headed to All-Star game, WR accepts bid to Texas vs. The Nation game,"""" The Hillsdale Daily News, December 9, 2010, '''(7)''' """"Two Chargers earn All-American, Holmes, Weatherhead garner honors,"""" The Hillsdale Daily News, June 9, 2010, '''(8)''' """"http://www.hillsdalecollegian.com/nfl-teams-look-for-holmes-in-late-rounds-1.2211490#.TrLvzkOa9tk NFL teams look for Holmes in late rounds"""", The Collegian, April 28, 2011; '''(9)''' """"http://www.mlive.com/sports/jackson/index.ssf/2010/12/hillsdale_college_wide_receive.html Hillsdale College wide receiver Andre Holmes to take part in Texas vs. The Nation All-Star Game,"""" The Jackson Citizen Patriot, December 9, 2010; '''(10)''' """"http://news.breakingdetroitnews.com/tweets/68320575344488448 Hillsdale WR Andre Holmes not worried by NFL lockout limbo,"""" Detroit Free Press, May 14, 2011, '''(11)''' """"http://cowboysblog.dallasnews.com/archives/2011/04/cowboys-woo-draft-worth-visito.html Draft prospect Andre Holmes impressed with Cowboys visit,"""" Dallas Morning News Blog, April 21, 2011""" Deletion of Andre Holmes WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3991 18536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Piper Stoeckel User:HighKing 17:19, 1 January 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Piper Stoeckel WP:ANYBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3992 15441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Haley User:Wm335td 21:35, 24 January 2020 (UTC) delete Not enough about him to show notability for or GNG Deletion of Robert Haley WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
3993 15286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mansour Barnaoui User:Papaursa 17:09, 17 November 2013 (UTC) delete Fails with no top tier fights and with no significant independent coverage. Winning a second tier title does not show notability Deletion of Mansour Barnaoui WP:NMMA||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
3994 17860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Curb stomping User:Wenli 04:37, 14 December 2007 (UTC) delete as original research and violation of . — Deletion of Curb stomping WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3995 3458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michel Boulos User:MarnetteD 21:18, 5 August 2020 (UTC) keep per . Try and remember that there have been times when all Olympic athletes were semi-professional athletes - or even full amateurs Deletion of Michel Boulos WP:NOLYMPICS Wikipedia:Notability 77
3996 19909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dead-eye syndrome User:Sr13 03:09, 9 April 2007 (UTC) delete as non-notable |neologism Deletion of Dead-eye syndrome WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
3997 20470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthropologie User:Isotope23 17:48, 18 July 2006 (UTC) merge to parent company Urban Outfitters article. Anthropologie doesn't meet , but UO does Deletion of Anthropologie WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
3998 1636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pauline Campbell User:Willsome429 15:35, 28 November 2018 (UTC) delete a search shows no significant coverage Deletion of Pauline Campbell WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
3999 2044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Totally Insured User:AllyD 16:19, 1 June 2020 (UTC) delete There is little aside from the coverage of the launch and pricing of the firm's policy aimed at people with HIV, and an in-role quotation from the company spokesman about cover for people living with cancer https://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/personalfinance/insurance/2948555/Insurers-deny-cover-to-cancer-sufferers.html. The firm co-launched a TIG Impaired line with MorganAsh in 2009 https://www.morganash.com/about/news/totally-insured-group-and-morganash-co-launches-impaired-risk-service but the regulator's listing page indicates that the firm ceased to be authorised around a year later https://register.fca.org.uk/ShPo_FirmDetailsPage?id=001b000000MfSkFAAV. I am not seeing the |coverage about the company needed for |notability Deletion of Totally Insured :WP:RS||:WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4000 8988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mystic Bourbon Liqueur (2nd nomination) User:MelanieN 00:56, 4 October 2014 (UTC) delete Sorry, this liqueur does not yet meet Wikipedia's |notability requirement - also known as . The requirement is that the subject must have received |significant coverage from multiple independent reliable sources. Each of those terms has a specific definition here, and the bottom line is that we can't have an article about this liqueur until mainstream sources like major regional newspapers (not foodie blogs) begin writing about it. It's no wonder that hasn't happened yet; the brand has only been marketed for a few months and only in a few states. Someday this product may achieve the recognition needed for inclusion in an international encyclopedia - but it isn't there yet. (No offense to the liqueur, it sounds delicious Deletion of Mystic Bourbon Liqueur (2nd nomination) :WP:N||:WP:GNG||WP:42 Wikipedia:Notability 77
4001 11513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeremy Gelbwaks User:MichaelQSchmidt NONE keep per and . Very smart parents to take their child out of acting before he went the way of some others with whom he worked (not mentioning names, but two were his co-stars). Interesting too, that decades after his last appearance in front of a camera, he received TWO TV Land Awards nominations... one in 2003 and the other in 2006, and is STILL being written of in multiple reliable sources long after his series ended (though still seen in syndication). My thought here is that is the consideration over , and we do have considerations of his exceeding the needs of as well http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Jeremy+Gelbwaks%22&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&btnG=Search+Archives... |even if he is never heard from again. ''People'' http://www.people.com/people/archive/article/0,,20106624,00.html ''CNN'' http://money.cnn.com/2011/08/04/news/companies/david_cassidy_partridge_family_lawsuit/ and some 119 others,http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Jeremy+Gelbwaks%22&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&btnG=Search+Archives as well as numerous books.http://www.google.com/search?q=Jeremy-Gelbwaks&btnG=Search&rls=com.microsoft%3Aen-US&oe=utf8&um=1&tbo=u&tbm=bks&source=og&sa=N&hl=en&tab=wp&oq=Jeremy-Gelbwaks&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&gs_sm=s&gs_upl=217625l220656l0l222219l4l4l0l0l0l0l594l1406l2-3.5-1l4l0 We don't toss the notable simply because their time of peak notability has passed Deletion of Jeremy Gelbwaks WP:NTEMP||WP:ANYBIO||WP:ANYBIO||WP:ENT||WP:GNG||WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4002 13740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adolf Sturmthal User:David 19:08, 22 September 2019 (UTC) keep Added six books with many reviews. Pass of . In addition the named professorship is a pass of and an obituary in the NYT is usually a clear sign of notability Deletion of Adolf Sturmthal WP:AUTHOR||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
4003 1030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ugur G. Abdulla User:Qwfp 20:48, 10 July 2011 (UTC) delete A few invited lectures and an associate editorship is still some way from meeting . Also current article is a resumé and (with the exception of the first line) would require a total rewrite Deletion of Ugur G. Abdulla WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4004 12851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Om Prakash Bhatt (producer) User:Bearian 20:29, 9 December 2020 (UTC) delete per and . No significant coverage. We almost always delete articles here about film producers Deletion of Om Prakash Bhatt (producer) WP:SIGCOV||WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Notability 77
4005 1420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Games Finder User:Aoziwe 04:27, 5 March 2020 (UTC) delete Having perused the requirements of , the site surely fails. I agree that there are no IRS; and none are likely to be found. I had hoped I could add some IRS in an attempt to save the page but like Deletion of Games Finder WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4006 1077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Antelmi User:GiantSnowman 20:12, 7 July 2014 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Patrick Antelmi WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4007 8061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martha Layne Collins High School User:Themfromspace 23:58, 5 March 2010 (UTC) comment No opinion on the merits of this particular article, but I'd like to echo the statements made by TJ Spyke and Click23 on the importance of and to dispel the idea that all high schools are inherently notable Deletion of Martha Layne Collins High School WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4008 2251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abaana User:A 17:07, 6 September 2016 (UTC) delete No hits on Google News that appear related to the charity. Doesn't pass the bar of Deletion of Abaana WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4009 6521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swecon User:Dravecky 11:06, 5 April 2011 (UTC) keep """as nominator is mass-nominating a long list of science fiction conventions with the same cookie-cutter rationale, not grounded in facts or policy, without regard to content or sourcing (plus List of science fiction conventions), apparently as a result of Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MystiCon|this discussion. |Notability is ''not'' a competition to """"stand out from all the others""" Deletion of Swecon WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4010 685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oversimplified User:Robert 02:57, 6 May 2020 (UTC) delete This is written in the present tense and so is a |biography of a living person and is unreferenced. Notability is only an issue if a reference is added while the AFD is running Deletion of Oversimplified WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4011 12411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Houston–SMU football rivalry User:Kirbanzo 16:39, 2 November 2018 (UTC) delete likely Deletion of Houston–SMU football rivalry WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
4012 10680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angus Tók Hnífinn User:Fabrictramp 00:36, 4 January 2008 (UTC) delete Album is not yet released, and no claim of meeting otability or in article Deletion of Angus Tók Hnífinn WP:N||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4013 20240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ayodhya City F.C. User:Govvy 11:01, 17 October 2018 (UTC) delete per nom, failing Deletion of Ayodhya City F.C. WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4014 10531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barrel Mountain Brewing User:Reywas92 21:21, 15 February 2019 (UTC) delete No assertion of notability, fails Deletion of Barrel Mountain Brewing WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4015 13886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sisira Jayasuriya User:Jenks24 09:02, 1 October 2010 (UTC) keep """as he does pass and I would ask Xxan to remember , before accusing someone of """"ethnic bias""" Deletion of Sisira Jayasuriya WP:PROF||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Notability 77
4016 20075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/It's Happy Bunny User:Blcfilm 21:51, 7 October 2007 (UTC) keep It's certainly a well-known product, but barely passes . A quick google search found some legitimate articles including some stuff on a project between Happy Bunny and Partnership for a Drug-free America. Needs a lot of work to meet standards, but I suspect it could become a acceptable article Deletion of It's Happy Bunny WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4017 19930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gorby no Pipeline Daisakusen User:Czar 16:14, 22 October 2012 (UTC) delete Fails |GNG without /RS. Its jawiki page is completely unsourced. Show me any signs of non-inherited notability (especially old magazines and foreign language reviews that I can't access) and I'll reconsider Deletion of Gorby no Pipeline Daisakusen WP:GNG||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4018 1642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mathias Harter User:Bearcat 18:01, 6 October 2016 (UTC) delete """A ''well-sourced'' and ''substantive'' article about a mayor could potentially be kept regardless of the city's size, but does ''not'' confer an automatic ''presumption'' of notability on all mayors. A city would have to be ''twice'' the size of La Crosse before his mere existence as a mayor was a compelling enough claim of notability in and of itself to get the """"keep and flag for refimprove"""" treatment rather than the """"delete"""" treatment""" Deletion of Mathias Harter WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4019 1948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/From Me Flows What You Call Time User:Gidonb 20:21, 27 December 2017 (UTC) merge if any) for that article. Rationale: As a standalone I disagree that there is justification for this article. Reasons were mentioned by others above and for me these trump the . It may still be a legitimate spinout of Future Library project given sufficient importance and substance of that article. It is unclear to me at this stage that Future Library project is terribly important and irrelevant whether this is the case (hence will not check) since Future Library is short and underdeveloped. Hence we should add a line or more and some sources from From Me Flows What You Call Time into Future Library project and redirect Deletion of From Me Flows What You Call Time WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4020 9729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hero Certified Burgers (2nd nomination) User:Lukeno94 10:21, 1 March 2014 (UTC) keep In addition to the multiple in the article, I've found http://www.businessreviewcanada.ca/reports/hero-certified-burgers this from Canada Business Review, and there are certainly far more offline pieces as well. The article is also not really that much of an advert, in the grand scheme of things Deletion of Hero Certified Burgers (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4021 14027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Writing Short Stories User:Jenks24 16:31, 16 January 2011 (UTC) delete Agree with nom. Wikipedia is |not an instruction manual Deletion of Writing Short Stories WP:NOTMANUAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4022 13503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Weavers' cottage (Kleinschwarzenbach, Zum Weberhaus 10) User:Levivich 21:48, 10 August 2020 (UTC) keep weakly, based on: paywalled article about the Kleinschwarzenbach weaver's house being filmed for a documentary https://www.frankenpost.de/region/muenchberg/Mystisches-aus-Kleinschwarzenbach-im-TV;art2441,6495037 (here's a press release about the same thing http://www.kula-hof.com/Media/Default/Fotos/Frankenpost_27_12_2018.pdf), and combining these two articles https://www.blickpunkt-verlag.de/bpws/nachrichten/landkreis_hof/art278486,4415420 https://www.blickpunkt-verlag.de/bpws/nachrichten/landkreis_hof/art278486,5616154 from the same publisher, each of which have some information (but not a lot) about this particular weaver's cottage. There's also a little blurb in what appears to be local coverage https://ol.wittich.de/titel/2191/ausgabe/4/2019/artikel/00000000000012548359-OL-2191-2019-9-4-0. The about us page for the cottage doesn't contribute to notability but can be used as an source https://weberhaus.ks-bach.de/. There's just barely enough here to write a policy-compliant article Deletion of Weavers' cottage (Kleinschwarzenbach, Zum Weberhaus 10) WP:ABOUTSELF Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4023 10755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mandarin as a Heritage Language in Toronto User:Blythwood 19:05, 16 August 2016 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Mandarin as a Heritage Language in Toronto WP:ESSAY Wikipedia:Essays 31
4024 1022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cornwall Centre (Regina, Saskatchewan) User:Philg88 05:08, 7 June 2014 (UTC) delete """per |Wikipedia is not a directory. |Non-notable mall with only passing mentions on Google and some local references. Single """"reference"""" in the article is a disallowed Wikipedia internal link""" Deletion of Cornwall Centre (Regina, Saskatchewan) WP:NOTDIR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4025 6301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AC Ventures User:Devokewater 09:49, 27 September 2020 (UTC) delete per nom, fails , the articles creator was blocked for advertising Deletion of AC Ventures WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
4026 4608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haas family User:Bearian 22:04, 20 November 2019 (UTC) delete as and of IG Farben Deletion of Haas family WP:OR||WP:FORK Wikipedia:No original research 65
4027 19350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I'm Just a Woman User:Hog 17:15, 25 June 2020 (UTC) merge to Goodbye to the Island#Track listing. Fails the notability criteria for songs. Coverage in the article that is about the song is very limited - it was released as a single, had cover art, and failed to chart. A search brings up discogs (unreliable) and a variety of unreliable lyrics sites. No evidence this song has gained coverage apart from the album, so redirect to the album's page Deletion of I'm Just a Woman WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4028 48 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Burak Oyunda (3. aday gösterme) Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 16.45, 25 Ağustos 2018 (UTC) delete """ping|thecatcherintherye}} ve {{ping|TmY e12}}, Vikipedi'nin |kayda değerlik yönergeleri dışında her kullanıcı her şekilde """"kendince"""" bir gerekçe sunarsa hiçbir tartışmayı sonlandıramayız, müthiş bir kaos olur. """"Milyonlarca kişinin takip etmesi"""" de malumunuz bir Vikipedi kriteri değil. Başka bir adaylıkta """"kitabı çok okunmuş"""" denir, öbüründe """"çok izleniyor"""" denir, berisinde """"çok iyi top oynuyor"""" bile denebilir; bunların tamamı Vikipedi yönergeleriyle bağdaşmayan kişisel görüşlerdir. Vikipedi yönergeleri çerçevesinde inceleme yapılması için """"konunun, kendisinden bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynaklar tarafından işlenmiş olması"""" gerekmektedir. An itibarıyla maddede 10 adet kaynak var. Bunların 4'ü ya şahsın sitesi ya kendi YouTube kanalı zaten, """"bağımsız"""" olmayan kaynaklar (siz kendi resmî sitenizi kaynak göstererek kendi maddenizi açabilir misiniz?). """"O oynuyur..."""" şeklindeki ''Milliyet'' haberi de tamamıyla röportaj, kendi söylemleri yani ve bağımsız olmayan bir kaynak yine. İki de liste var, bunlarda da diğer kanallar gibi adı anılıyor sadece. Geriye elimide kalıyor üç kaynak: """"Hem başarılı..."""", Haberler.com kaynağı ve """"Dijital çağın..."""" kaynağı. Bunların üçü de kullanılabilecek kaynaklar, ne kendisinin söylemleri ne kendisiyle bağlantılı kaynaklar. Her ne kadar bunlardan ikisi aynı konuya dair olsa da bunu atlıyorum şimdilik. Üç bağımsız kaynak, kayda değerliğin ispatı için yeterli değil kesinlikle. Önceki tartışmalarda yorumum nasıl oldu bakmadım, şu anki hâline göre değerlendirmem bu şekilde. Ha birkaç bağımsız kaynakla madde geliştirilirse kayda değerliği ispat edilebilirse bu görüşüm de elbette ki değişecektir""" Burak Oyunda (3. aday gösterme) yazısının silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
4029 7631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James D. Montgomery User:Isotope23 18:53, 26 April 2006 (UTC) delete """per . Subject does not meet the professor test in my opinion as exceeding the """"average professor"""" with 15 articles, 5 working papers and 6 reviews http://www.ssc.wisc.edu/~jmontgom/vita.pdf""" Deletion of James D. Montgomery WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4030 694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billy Rosewood User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:18, 13 July 2009 (UTC) keep """as it does not matter that it is a character from a notable film as long as the article subject receives coverage in relable sources that meets .... and """"Billy Rosewood"""" seems to get the coverage. The character was specifically covered and in depth by http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,964514,00.html Time Magazine in 1987, and again by http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1101870601-146766,00.html Time Magazine in 2001. And there is significant coverage of the character in relation to the actor: http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,302383_2,00.html Entertainment Weekly, http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=CSTB&p_theme=cstb&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0EB36DBF223D9D03&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM. Chicago Sun-Times... and http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Billy+Rosewood%22&btnG=Search&hl=en&ned=us&um=1&scoring=a many others. This is a case where there is enough to support an article about the character, per the precedents set by Hawkeye Pierce, Hot Lips Houlihan, Archie Bunker, Al Bundy, et al""" Deletion of Billy Rosewood WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4031 15230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Photo Incentive User:Bearian 17:44, 15 December 2008 (UTC) merge with, or move, to Tim Pool per Deletion of Photo Incentive WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4032 8612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crimson Viper NONE NONE keep I disagree with the nominator's subjective assertion that there are no substantive mentions of the character in reliable sources. The issue to consider is whether the subject has garnered enough significant coverage to warrant a standalone article. In this instance, given the article's state of sourcing, a merge proposal would be more appropriate then a proposal for outright deletion if there is concern about whether the topic warrants a standalone article. It's a borderline for me, but per , a few sources I have found which is not used in the article. Coverage range from substantial to incidental Deletion of Crimson Viper WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
4033 17086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K244CA User:Edison 03:54, 8 November 2007 (UTC) delete Translators are not in themselves notable. Fails to satisfy Deletion of K244CA WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4034 5251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of women linguists User:Cnilep 06:03, 27 December 2016 (UTC) keep the topic is inherently notable. There are major problems with the current state of the article, including a lack of clear inclusion criteria, insufficient lead section, and some questionable inclusions. These seem , though. It's true that clean up will require time and effort, but it's equally true that rebuilding after deletion, presumably with some of the same content there now, will require time and effort, plus entail loss of edit history. (And if more evidence is needed that women linguists is a notable topic, see http://www.linguisticsociety.org/about/who-we-are/committees/status-women-linguistics Committee on the Status of Women in Linguistics and links therein Deletion of List of women linguists WP:SURMOUNTABLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4035 20058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NEWFood User:Ihcoyc 14:26, 13 May 2009 (UTC) delete unverifiable |original research, as is the claim of a food shortage so severe that people will be reduced to eating processed sewage Deletion of NEWFood WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4036 13885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TheGamer User:HighKing 14:09, 9 August 2019 (UTC) delete Does not appear to meet the requirements for notability, I am unable to locate any references that meet the criteria. Topic fails GNG and Deletion of TheGamer WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4037 21836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Velma Kelly Online User:Sandstein 21:15, 20 September 2006 (UTC) delete has no reliable sources for its claims to notability as required by . Being defunct is not, by and of itself, a reason for deletion for the subject of an encyclopedia, though: we have many articles on dead people Deletion of Velma Kelly Online WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4038 17398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Early User:Papa 13:32, 9 July 2008 (UTC) delete No evidence that this is notable. There's a huge |conflict of interest going on, at the very least Deletion of David Early WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
4039 183 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ahmet Madaralı (2. aday gösterme) Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 10:38, 13 Haziran 2015 (UTC) keep dönemin pek az güreşçisinden biri, bütün kaynaklarda adı geçiyor. bu açıdan da |'Amatör spor dallarında en üst seviyede oynamış veya yarışmış sporcular' kriterine uygun. --Kullanıcı mesaj:Kibele|'''kibele Ahmet Madaralı (2. aday gösterme) yazısının silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
4040 10242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mud Connector User:Soetermans 13:06, 22 February 2016 (UTC) delete Fails , only mentioned in passing. Not notable for its own article Deletion of The Mud Connector WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4041 9548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle of Mars User:Reyk 05:34, 3 March 2009 (UTC) delete Excessive and crufty #PLOT|plot summary sourced entirely from |primary sources. Spectacularly fails our requirements for |reliable sources and |notability Deletion of Battle of Mars WP:NOT||WP:PSTS||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4042 8927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1985–86 Washington Capitals season User:Djsasso 04:20, 13 June 2009 (UTC) keep As Resolute mentioned notability of season articles for major league teams has long been established. As well this is very much a case of Deletion of 1985–86 Washington Capitals season WP:SOFIXIT Wikipedia:Be bold 9
4043 6403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Visible penis line User:Jsfouche 03:08, 11 June 2011 (UTC) delete agree that this is really more like a dictionary entry. Does not meet |significant coverage Deletion of Visible penis line WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
4044 7718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annual Digital Archive User:Armbrust 19:56, 26 October 2010 (UTC) delete No coverage in |reliable sources Deletion of Annual Digital Archive WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4045 11562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Favelle Favco Group NONE NONE keep Seems to meet |GNG. Also found Deletion of Favelle Favco Group WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4046 8380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Davor Čaurević User:Mattythewhite 08:37, 2 July 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Davor Čaurević WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4047 19497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vivek Venugopal User:Rabbabodrool 18:11, 30 December 2010 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails Deletion of Vivek Venugopal WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4048 6963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zambranaing User:Chris857 18:00, 23 August 2013 (UTC) delete at least Alex Zambrana seems to exist http://www.usacycling.org/results/?compid=39384. Its creation date of today, its strong US-centrism, purported origin on Facebook, all point to . By the way, if that photo is by Zambrana, are we sure of its copyright status? Also, if it came from Facebook, there should be a link to where the image came from Deletion of Zambranaing WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
4049 3838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss Hartigan User:Schuym1 00:03, 15 September 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Miss Hartigan WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4050 18274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I'm on Fire (mixtape) User:Versace1608 22:00, 16 October 2017 (UTC) delete The mixtape definitely fails when looked at in detail. A Google search doesn't show the mixtape being discussed in detail. Of all the sources cited in the article and in this AFD, the https://web.archive.org/web/20130807052647/http://www.nigeriansounds.com/archives/35060 Nigerian Sounds source is the only source that dicusses the album. Using the charting argument to justify a delete is invalid here since Nigeria doesn't have a national music chart system. The music scene in Nigeria and majority of Africa isn't well structured. If the mixtape was critically reviewed by Pulse Nigeria or ''Nigeria Entertainment Today'', I would easily vote keep. The mixtape may not be popular across Nigeria, but it is definitely popular in PH. 50,000+ downloads certainly proves this. The Nigerian Sounds source alone is not enough for stand-alone inclusion Deletion of I'm on Fire (mixtape) WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
4051 1084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geographical distribution of English speakers user:Andrew 09:43, 12 June 2019 (UTC) merge per and Deletion of Geographical distribution of English speakers WP:REDUNDANTFORK||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Content forking 33
4052 521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clara Chu User:Silver 19:32, 7 April 2010 (UTC) comment I have tagged this article for |rescue Deletion of Clara Chu WP:ARS Wikipedia:Article Rescue Squadron 98
4053 7965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Der Bunker (2015) User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:21, 8 July 2015 (UTC) keep """per topic meeting . Very poor accompanied with a nomination statement easily disproved. Heck, even when first https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Der_Bunker&type=revision&diff=670260145&oldid=670260091 nominated included https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Der_Bunker&type=revision&diff=670260145&oldid=670260091#References sourcing showed a meeting inclusion criteria. """"A few decent reviews"""" is exactly what meets criteria. Sorry {{u|Primefac|nominator}}, but in acknowledging they existed just where was your head at? Go re-read #General principles, please. And {{u|Tokyogirl79}}, thank you for your work |improving an improvable topic""" Deletion of Der Bunker (2015) WP:NF||WP:BEFORE||WP:NF||WP:IMPROVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4054 19081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hawaa (2019 film) User:Spiderone 19:13, 19 September 2020 (UTC) delete due to concerns around and Deletion of Hawaa (2019 film) WP:GNG||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
4055 12995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rob McDowall (3rd nomination) User:Coderzombie 22:24, 19 June 2016 (UTC) delete Per {{u|Jbhunley}}. No coverage with |reliable sources Deletion of Rob McDowall (3rd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4056 17302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St Nicholas Pre-School Playgroup User:Stormie 23:35, 28 October 2005 (UTC) delete non-notable, an indiscriminate collection of information, or a business directory Deletion of St Nicholas Pre-School Playgroup WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4057 9057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NHL players A User:Ccwaters 17:51, 7 June 2006 (UTC) keep """WP:HOCKEY was mentioned in every article's talk page. Thanks for inquiring there prior to nominating. And thanks for |assuming good faith, and realizing that the hockeydb.com links were added by a third party not as a """"googlebombing"""" but because said site is widely regarded as the de facto resource for professional hockey statistics""" Deletion of NHL players A WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
4058 18653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Danny McKay Project User:MichaelQSchmidt 03:36, 30 June 2009 (UTC) delete and allow return when article can meet Deletion of The Danny McKay Project WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4059 17769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/U.N. Force User:Stuartyeates 09:21, 29 April 2012 (UTC) delete as failing Deletion of U.N. Force WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4060 13314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zhan Qixiong User:FunnyPika 23:05, 28 May 2013 (UTC) merge to 2010 Senkaku boat collision incident. I agree with the case but I think the captain would still be a viable redirect to the event. The rest of the information is already covered in the aformentioned article, although it could do with a few more mainland Chinese sources Deletion of Zhan Qixiong WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4061 18588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D-Day: Normandy User:Brewcrewer 23:00, 23 February 2008 (UTC) delete One newpaper article doesn't reach the ''signifact coverage'' standard that requires Deletion of D-Day: Normandy WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4062 9126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heidenreich (band) User:Zeibura 22:34, 27 June 2007 (UTC) keep """weak as the article will need to be rewritten. Caknuck's links have provided some room for expansion, and as far as 's definition of """"one of the more important independant record labels"""" goes, it seems Napalm Records does qualify, as they've been running 15 years and have a roster of notable bands, perhaps only notable within the black metal scene, but using that as a reason to delete would be """ Deletion of Heidenreich (band) WP:MUSIC||WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4063 76 [[ConVista]] (GeLöscht) Benutzer:Fano NONE comment Hinweis: Wurde 2010 als ConVista Consulting gelöscht: /29._November_2010#ConVista_Consulting_.28gel.C3.B6scht.29 Kopie kann unter anderem bei http://unternehmen.wikia.com/wiki/ConVista_Consulting eingesehen werden. Trotzdem würde ich vorschlagen zu warten, 2010 ist ja eine weile her und 17 Geschäftsstellen ist jetzt auch nicht unendlich weit von den 20 geforderten weg dass man das unbedingt schnell löschen müsste Löschung von ConVista Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4064 6068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agility Association of Canada User:Justlettersandnumbers 11:16, 30 December 2020 (UTC) delete no independent sources in the page, no sign of any in-depth coverage via Gbooks, Scholar or JSTOR, does not begin to satisfy Deletion of Agility Association of Canada WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4065 19187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quayeyeware User:Scapler 23:48, 27 February 2010 (UTC) delete I was unable to find any sources which would establish the notability of this company per . Cheers Deletion of Quayeyeware WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4066 9179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giuseppe Provenzano (Italian politician born, 1946) User:David 08:10, 14 January 2021 (UTC) keep President of Sicily is enough for and from the Italian Wikipedia version I found the following source https://www.ars.sicilia.it/deputati/provenzano-giuseppe which I think is enough to verify that claim and survive BLPPROD. I'll add it to the article. If kept, it should be moved to a title with a more-grammatical disambiguator Deletion of Giuseppe Provenzano (Italian politician born, 1946) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4067 18206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FedEx Express Flight 647 User:DustFormsWords 05:53, 9 December 2010 (UTC) delete Biography of a plane notable for only one event. requires the event to be the subject of ongoing and sustained coverage demonstrating its historic notability, for it to have impact on a wide demographic or geographic swathe, or be the catalyst or result of another notable event. It does not meet these criteria Deletion of FedEx Express Flight 647 WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4068 12080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Lucas User:GiantSnowman 09:46, 19 August 2019 (UTC) keep meets ; needs improving, not deleting Deletion of Chris Lucas WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4069 13583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wincanton Primary School User:TerriersFan 18:43, 8 December 2008 (UTC) keep article has independent, verifiable coverage that meets Deletion of Wincanton Primary School WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4070 16428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sepehr Salehi User:doomsdayer520 18:44, 19 March 2020 (UTC) delete """I agree with the nominator. All sources on this """"media personality"""" are unreliable blogs, |typical industry listings, and self-created press releases. This Wikipedia article is just part of the self-promotional effort and was probably created by a user with a conflict of interest. Until this person's media career takes off for real, Wikipedia is |not a promotional service. When searching, note that there are other people of the same name with LinkedIn accounts and the like""" Deletion of Sepehr Salehi WP:MILL||WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
4071 21330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of minor characters in Tokyo Mew Mew (2nd nomination) User:G 05:54, 12 March 2008 (UTC) delete Fails |notability requirements: except for the Kanji links, and the mere mention of the names in the only source, ''none'' of the information has any Wikipedia:Verifiability#Sources|independent, Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable sources whatsoever. The other information is #PLOT|plot information only, which can be deleted. The information may be transwiki'd at a later stage if needed — editors wishing to perform this may refer to Wikipedia:Deletion review#Temporary review if this article is deleted Deletion of List of minor characters in Tokyo Mew Mew (2nd nomination) WP:FICT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4072 1254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bombhunters User:MichaelQSchmidt 19:25, 2 August 2009 (UTC) comment I have just completed a first round of cleanup and sourcing. Article meets the Deletion of Bombhunters WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4073 20785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexandra Jacovidou [[User talk:Jennavecia|Lara]] 17:50, 4 October 2009 (UTC) delete I think this is the first time I've seen a nom longer than the article, haha. She doesn't satisfy Deletion of Alexandra Jacovidou WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
4074 354 [[Türk Demir Döküm]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Mo4jolo 18:07, 22. Okt. 2006 (CEST) keep Bitte vor dem stellen von LAs die lesen. Artikel muss natürlich überarbeitet werden Löschung von Türk Demir Döküm Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4075 9075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Sponer User:Themfromspace 02:13, 17 February 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails . Also note the apparent |COI Deletion of Anna Sponer WP:N||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
4076 18985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ken Coomer User:Septrillion 05:23, 9 May 2018 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Ken Coomer WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4077 16017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dharmendra banshal User:Worldbruce 16:08, 26 October 2016 (UTC) delete Searches of the usual Google types, HighBeam, and EBSCO found zero reliable sources, so does not meet or Deletion of Dharmendra banshal WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4078 14006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Gelato Fiasco User:JoshuaZ 03:32, 6 October 2009 (UTC) delete Per DGG the sourcing isn't great. I'm not sure it actually fails Deletion of The Gelato Fiasco WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4079 15659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/He Saifei User:Pengyanan 19:02, 1 January 2010 (UTC) keep Her roles in ''Raise the Red Lantern'' and ''Temptress Moon'' are ''not'' minor. has be established Deletion of He Saifei WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4080 4712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of New Gods User:Piotrus 09:13, 19 November 2020 (UTC) delete I thought about redirecting this to New Gods but why bother? The title is unlikely to be search for, and this seems to fail / otherwise. Nothing to merge, as this is almost totally unreferenced, too Deletion of List of New Gods WP:GNG||WP:NLIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
4081 1204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eck Louvell User:Ged 16:01, 24 August 2008 (UTC) delete I don't think it's a hoax, but I can't find any ghit that isn't WP, one of the 'sources' provided doesn't actually refer to the phrase, and the other doesn't meet the criteria Deletion of Eck Louvell WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4082 1390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Cohen User:MER 07:07, 18 December 2006 (UTC) delete unreferenced |autobiography of a |non-notable person Deletion of Ryan Cohen WP:AUTO||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
4083 6108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of political parties in North Korea User:Kvng 14:55, 29 September 2010 (UTC) keep Merge destination identified. See #4 Deletion of List of political parties in North Korea WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4084 2024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammed Kamin User:RightCowLeftCoast 04:53, 12 August 2012 (UTC) merge to Afghan detainees at Guantanamo Bay. No significant coverage of the individual, from what I have searched in possible |reliable sources appear to be found for the subject to pass . There are multiple mentions of the subject in relation to the subject's detention, and the ongoing interaction of the subject with the judicial process at Guantanamo Naval Base however the coverage has been more about those two events than the subject of the biography article; therefore, it is my opinion that the subject does not pass or . That being said the subject is a member of a notable group, and therefore a redirect can be made to said notable group Deletion of Mohammed Kamin WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO||WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4085 16738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/French Quarter, Philadelphia User:OcarinaOfTime 07:01, 30 July 2017 (UTC) delete no references I can find to the area since the late '90s Deletion of French Quarter, Philadelphia WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4086 2873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Foxit User:OlYeller21 05:12, 7 January 2014 (UTC) keep """Satisfies with these articles that represent significant coverage from independent and seemingly reliable sources (if someone wants to call them not-reliable, they'll need to back that up): http://www.neowin.net/news/foxit-reader-6121224http://www.techcentral.ie/foxit-reader-portable-6-1-2/http://soft.zol.com.cn/409/4099993.htmlhttp://news.sina.com.tw/article/20131227/11454422.html. """"No indication of notability"""" isn't a reason for deletion at which has been clearly explained at rguments to avoid in deletion discussions. Simply doing a https://www.google.com/search?q=Foxit&safe=off&espv=210&es_sm=93&source=lnms&tbm=nws&sa=X&ei=FYvLUtiVDaKc2QXY7ID4Cw&ved=0CA0Q_AUoAA&biw=1920&bih=964 Google News search for Foxit produced all of these articles. Maybe these references can be disputed when it comes to establishing notability but did any delete !votes even check before !voting? These were as easy to find as it comes. If you found no references, it helps the discussion to show what searches you did that resulted in no references. Otherwise, your !vote is baseless and not very useful""" Deletion of Foxit WP:GNG||WP:AFD||WP:A Wikipedia:Notability 77
4087 9404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Franck Traore User:Cbl62 01:40, 11 August 2014 (UTC) delete Does not pass as he never played at pro level. Does not pass as he was a reserve player for a second (or third?) tier Manhattan Jaspers basketball team and did not receive significant, non-trivial coverage as a player. Also just not finding the coverage to pass -- the only items that might even count in such an analysis are http://www.nbaplayoffs.com/africa/development_camp__burkina_fas_2012_06_14.html this (press release from the NBA that mentions him in passing) and http://philadelphia.cbslocal.com/2012/09/27/all-eyes-on-archbishop-carroll-6-10-transfer-ernest-aflakpui/ this (story about an African high school player discovered by Traore in Burkina Faso). I am assuming that http://www.primarypost.com/pilots/A4876623/Guesbeogo-Franck-Traore this is a different Franck Traore Deletion of Franck Traore WP:NBASKETBALL||WP:NCOLLATH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4088 10015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of politicians in Poland User:Ajf773 03:16, 19 September 2019 (UTC) delete Unreferenced, outdated original research and most probably fails . A redirect to :Lists of Polish politicians as well would be a good idea Deletion of List of politicians in Poland WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
4089 9716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Don't Go Near the Water (Beach Boys song) User:Colonel 16:10, 29 May 2009 (UTC) keep Not seeing any evidence of any |due diligence. Nomination asserts that redirection would be contested but this does not seem to have tried nor does the matter seem to have been discussed on the article's talk page Deletion of Don't Go Near the Water (Beach Boys song) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4090 4502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eugene Stepanenko User:Ejgreen77 05:24, 1 March 2017 (UTC) keep Appears to meet based on My very best wishes's sources Deletion of Eugene Stepanenko WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4091 1253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eddie Anaclet User:Number 16:58, 13 October 2007 (UTC) delete Has not played in a fully-professional league ( Deletion of Eddie Anaclet WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4092 14759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JamesRedfern User:Capitalistroadster 01:56, 4 November 2005 (UTC) delete This is a classic candidate for an |A7 Speedy Delete. Could possibly be a redirect to early 1970's Australian singer Jamie Redfern except for the lack of punctuation Deletion of JamesRedfern WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
4093 3199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jegulja User:Kraxler 00:06, 16 September 2015 (UTC) delete non-notable band, no chart positions, no coverage, the sources are blogs, trivial mentions and primary pieces, fails all criteria of Deletion of Jegulja WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4094 12273 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""One Shot 2 Shot""""""" User:Artene50 04:30, 19 June 2008 (UTC) delete Fails """Deletion of """"One Shot 2 Shot""""""" WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4095 6162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LAX (group) (2nd nomination) [[User_talk:Dlohcierekim| '''Cheers, :) Dlohcierekim''' ]] 02:16, 30 September 2007 (UTC) delete Being profiled by allmusic does not indicate notability. Nothing at the allmusic page suggests meeting . Being part of a notable label does not convey notability Deletion of LAX (group) (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4096 14800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Girls Islamic Organisation of India (2nd nomination) User:Tayi 17:52, 11 February 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and per , relevant information should be added to Students Islamic Organisation of India Deletion of Girls Islamic Organisation of India (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:BRANCH Wikipedia:Notability 77
4097 21232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti-Turkism in Armenia User:Zoozaz1 23:34, 26 December 2020 (UTC) delete as per . I think that this topic does merit an article, but as of now this is a laundry list of occurrences that do not help in the slightest in explaining the phenomenon in Armenia. A list of random atrocities committed by Armenians contributes almost nothing to actually learning about the topic itself; a good, neutral, article on this topic would be great, but as of now it is just an Wikipedia:INDISCRIMINATE|indiscriminate list that helps no one at all in understanding the topic Deletion of Anti-Turkism in Armenia WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
4098 5365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billy Quinncroft User:Simione001 23:53, 7 July 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Billy Quinncroft WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4099 10818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ella Russell User:RebeccaGreen 07:24, 23 October 2019 (UTC) keep In fairness to the nominator, I have substantially rewritten this article and added sources - at the time of nomination, there were only 3 sources relevant to the subject (and one about mayors of her town a hundred years later). The point is, though, that they - many on a subscription site, but some freely accessible. The 3 relevant sources that were already in the article are all from the 2000s, which surely suggests that someone who is noted for her actions of 100 previously is actually notable Deletion of Ella Russell WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
4100 11610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Colbert Busch User:Muboshgu 19:36, 11 May 2013 (UTC) keep Absolutely understand the argument of BLP1E, but she's gotten coverage that doesn't relate to the election, so I don't think the policy applies.http://www.abcnews4.com/story/14433292/elizabeth-colbert-busch-honored I had initially thought of nominating this article for deletion on the argument of , but now I believe the coverage of her from this high profile race has exceeded any NOTINHERITED or concerns, as she meets , which supersedes those other guidelines. Reliable sources do mention her as the sister of Stephen Colbert, but as a throwaway line in many cases, suggesting that it's not the reason the articles are written. There are plenty of sources about her that don't mention Stephen at all.http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-fix/wp/2013/05/08/did-nancy-pelosi-cost-elizabeth-colbert-busch-a-victory/http://www.slate.com/blogs/weigel/2013/05/05/elizabeth_colbert_busch_v_s_the_cardboard_nancy_pelosi_cut_out.html– Deletion of Elizabeth Colbert Busch WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4101 154 [[Kai Schürholt]] (zurückgezogen) Benutzer:AF666 21:56, 26. Aug. 2007 (CEST) delete wenn Urkundenfälschung - also hier konkret: unerlaubte Tragen eines Doktortitels - künftig ausreicht, um die zu erfüllen, dann würde Schürholt wahrscheinlich vielen als Vorbild dienen, um so an einen eigenen Wikipedia-Artikel zu kommen Löschung von Kai Schürholt Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4102 20975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Proud User:Rugbyfan22 09:21, 13 April 2021 (UTC) merge 3 LA cricket board matches, but I'm not seeing anything other than a couple of match reports, certainly nothing significant. Redirect a suitable , but this one should probably have been BOLDly redirected Deletion of John Proud WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
4103 15954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southgate Shopping Centre (Australia) User:Deus 09:17, 27 March 2021 (UTC) comment can anyone explain why a merge to Sylvania, New South Wales is not inappropriate (and required to be assessed before deletion as per Deletion of Southgate Shopping Centre (Australia) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
4104 2238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Elvir User:Nfitz 22:51, 12 October 2014 (UTC) keep meets and not surprisingly given 70+ appearances for such an internationally well-known team. Examples are http://www.latribuna.hn/2013/10/02/omar-elvir-por-rendimiento-vidakovic-tambien-deberia-estar-aqui/, http://www.elheraldo.hn/zonadeportiva/589846-215/el-invicto-nos-da-fuerza-afirma-omar-elvir, http://www.elheraldo.hn/zonadeportiva/704124-215/omar-elvir-a%C3%BAn-no-es-la-mejor-versi%C3%B3n, http://www.tiempo.hn/cronometro/liga-nacional/item/977-omar-elvir-%E2%80%9Cno-seremos-trampol%C3%ADn-del-marathon%E2%80%9D, and http://www.diez.hn/futboldeprimera/754308-99/omar-elvir-no-s%C3%A9-si-es-que-somos-de-mentalidad-mediocre Deletion of Omar Elvir WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4105 8048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013 Udon Thani F.C. season User:Walter 14:38, 11 February 2015 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of 2013 Udon Thani F.C. season :WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4106 19637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lipid therapy User:XOR 17:24, 6 November 2019 (UTC) delete """Either a hoax or, potentially, a quack """"treatment"""" that isn't |notorious enough to be wiki-notable as such""" Deletion of Lipid therapy WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
4107 17618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Selin Hasbal User:Ortizesp 13:00, 23 May 2021 (UTC) delete Fails . If Deletion of Selin Hasbal WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4108 19664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minnesota State Highway 127 User:Inkpaduta 00:58, 9 February 2007 (UTC) comment """It is not disruptive to nominate an article for deletion when it does not satisfy the general criterion even if several editors say """"ILIKEIT."""" There is no policy or guideline which says that all numbered roads in the world are inherently notable. Please do no make unsupported accusations of disruptive editing, as that is incivil. AFD is the appropriate forum for deciding which articles should be kept, not """"dispute resolution""" Deletion of Minnesota State Highway 127 WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4109 17839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Small Mining Encyclopedia User:Green 17:17, 2 October 2013 (UTC) delete per . 45+ Google hits, most of it sourced to Wikipedia Deletion of Small Mining Encyclopedia WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4110 19620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aldera.net User:MelanieN 15:17, 7 November 2010 (UTC) delete Fails . No significant coverage found about the website - just passing news coverage due to legal action taken against the site by Lucasfilms Deletion of Aldera.net WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4111 20278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leftosphere User:JohnCD 22:39, 23 January 2009 (UTC) delete or transwiki to Wiktionary. Even if expanded to be more than a dicdef, I think it fails #Articles on neologisms Deletion of Leftosphere WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
4112 282 [[SAM (Buch von Luisa Stülke)]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Jürgen Oetting NONE delete Enzyklopädische Relevanz im Sinne der Wikipedia nicht gegeben, siehe #Bücher Löschung von SAM (Buch von Luisa Stülke) Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
4113 349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/6Q0B44E User:Gwernol 01:48, 9 September 2006 (UTC) keep WP:V|Verifiable with coverage in a major British newspaper that gives a reasonable claim of |notability. Being on the Internet is not a goods measure of significance, IMHO Deletion of 6Q0B44E WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4114 7675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alon Badat User:Sir 19:53, 29 March 2011 (UTC) delete The CSL is not fully pro, meaning he fails , and there is not enough significant coverage for him to meet Deletion of Alon Badat WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4115 4535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Get Out (song) User:Boffob 16:56, 3 December 2008 (UTC) delete no indication it passes , though nothing prevents you from |boldly redirecting Deletion of Get Out (song) WP:NSONGS||WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Notability 77
4116 6140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robin Bladimir (2nd nomination) User:AllyD 15:16, 26 July 2015 (UTC) delete Highbeam and Questia searches return nothing, Google returns nothing substantial, including the already-cited references from a site which invites user-submitted content. No |evidence of |notability Deletion of Robin Bladimir (2nd nomination) :WP:RS||:WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4117 11035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fuel cell sports car User:DARTH 15:11, 25 October 2010 (UTC) delete Per nom, speculation. Deletion of Fuel cell sports car WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4118 12195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaun Rashid User:scope_creep 21:44, 25 April 2021 (UTC) delete Tenious at best. Fails Deletion of Shaun Rashid WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4119 6356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paper Rival User:Michig 20:18, 5 May 2011 (UTC) keep Using popular search engine Google found these: http://www.allmusic.com/artist/paper-rival-p918816/biography Allmusic bio, http://phillyist.com/2008/08/19/phillyist_interviews_brent_coleman.php Phillyist, The Tennessean: http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/tennessean/access/1700989031.html?FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Jul+04%2C+2008&author=DAVE+PAULSON&pub=The+Tennessean&desc=Local+band+Paper+Rival+leaves+town+to+cut+its+teeth&pqatl=google, http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/tennessean/access/1719472791.html?FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Nov+29%2C+2007&author=DAVE+PAULSON&pub=The+Tennessean&desc=PAPER+RIVAL&pqatl=google, http://www.nashvillescene.com/nashville/the-spin/Content?oid=1197064 Nashville Scene, http://nashvillecitypaper.com/content/lifestyles/4-days-city-39 The City Paper, http://www.boston.com/ae/music/articles/2008/08/19/paper_rival/ Boston Globe, http://www.popmatters.com/pm/review/paper-rival-paper-rival-ep/ PopMatters. Enough there to satisfy and criterion 1 of Deletion of Paper Rival WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4120 5808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DC3 (album) User:Theseeker4 14:27, 25 November 2008 (UTC) delete Not-yet-released album that has received no mainstream coverage by a non-notable performer. Fails all aspects of and as does the individual who made the album. Delete Deletion of DC3 (album) WP:MUSIC||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4121 12729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agoda.com User:Clpo13 06:24, 5 October 2015 (UTC) keep The secondary sources provided appear to be |reliable and |independent enough to satisfy the criteria at . It's currently neutrally worded enough, as well. I would be wary of possible edits by boonchong_chua, but that shouldn't reflect on the article itself Deletion of Agoda.com WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:NCOMPANY||WP:COI Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4122 1108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allosexual User:Zumoarirodoka 14:20, 25 April 2015 (UTC) delete The topic is clearly non-otable. I noticed it with https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Asexuality&diff=659110861&oldid=659108965 this edit at the Asexuality article (followup edit https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Asexuality&diff=659111324&oldid=659110861 here), and I noted that it would be deleted. And even if it were otable, we certainly don't need some tub about this topic; it would be similar to the Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agender case Deletion of Allosexual WP:N||WP:S Wikipedia:Notability 77
4123 12137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Leo User:CooperDB 20:23, 18 October 2009 (UTC) delete References seem just a little less than what the require Deletion of Josh Leo WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4124 11676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shoepedia User:Can 08:53, 15 December 2005 (UTC) delete does not foot the bill of Deletion of Shoepedia WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4125 14824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luke Garbutt User:Malcolmxl5 23:49, 23 July 2009 (UTC) delete Does not meet inclusion requirements of thlete or Deletion of Luke Garbutt WP:A||WP:N Wikipedia:Attribution 108
4126 18311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Mikusheva User:Snow 23:58, 1 August 2017 (UTC) keep """It's certainly a """"by the skin of the teeth"""" call, but EAWH is correct; the academics guideline is explicit that even that one high profile award is sufficient to establish notability. The Elaine Bennett Research Prize is not the absolute highest of profile awards, but probably sufficient to the """"highly prestigious bar"""". There's the additional h-index evidence suppline by Xxanthippe as well, but as makes clear, that is the weakest possible evidence for just one prong the notability analysis and is to be treated with skepticism. Still, looking at the entire package of this Harvard-trained MIT faculty member with significant publications in major journals of her field, I have to say she just barely gets through by the smallest possible margin""" Deletion of Anna Mikusheva WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4127 17533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shadley User:Davidpdx 13:15, 27 December 2006 (UTC) delete I agree |this is original researchand fails Deletion of Shadley WP:OR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
4128 15503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emma Vigeland (2nd nomination) User:Missvain 00:21, 23 January 2020 (UTC) delete Appears to be for Ms. Vigeland. Happy to make it a '''soft delete''' in case things change Deletion of Emma Vigeland (2nd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4129 18204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vietnam War film User:MichaelQSchmidt 03:38, 15 March 2009 (UTC) keep as the stub has tremendous potential to grow. DGG has it 100% correct per . No need to merge. Allow it to grow and be pleasently surprised at the results Deletion of Vietnam War film WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4130 16253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antony Rea User:Sepulwiki 26:56, 6 January 2013 (UTC) keep passes and Deletion of Antony Rea WP:GNG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
4131 6383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solo (Australian soft drink) User:The 06:34, 26 February 2012 (UTC) keep """The current Schweppes Australia article is insufficient and overly concentrates () on the two brands, rather than on the company and it's whole history - and the fact that it doesn't mention Schweppervescence or lemonade or mixers means that it needs a lot of work. Whilst this may sound like a argument, but Solo is a long standing iconic soft drink brand in Australia, but suffers from using a """"normal word"""" so Google searches are difficult to focus on the actual brand, not just the word solo""" Deletion of Solo (Australian soft drink) WP:UNDUE||WP:THEREMUSTBESOURCES Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
4132 244 [[Eva Korsmeier]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Robertsan 07:14, 1. Jul. 2009 (CEST) delete """brodkey: Bitte lies Dir einmal die Relevanzkriterien durch. Ich versuche nur objektiv, diese zu prüfen. Beim Ilhami Sevim ließ ich mich durch Gräf ja auch überzeugen. Mich stört eben, dass man unter """"lange Nacht der Museen"""" eine Museumsausstellung vorgaukeln will, die sich dann als kommerzielle Galerie herausstellt. Wenn die Relevanz korrekt belegt wird, soll die Künstelrin bleiben, wenn nicht, dann nicht. Bis jetzt ist die Relevanz noch nicht belegt. Deshalb nach wie vor . Gruß""" Löschung von Eva Korsmeier Wikipedia:RBK Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
4133 10501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American comic book industry timeline User:Shooterwalker 22:21, 12 September 2011 (UTC) delete as a redundant with American_comic_book#History, but riddled with |original research and |undue weight as described by the nominator. Already covered with better referencing and context. (Note: nominator is unfamiliar with AFD processes, but is navigating the bureaucracy in good faith by moving from PROD to AFD. Give him a break Deletion of American comic book industry timeline WP:CONTENTFORK||WP:OR||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Content forking 33
4134 9977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Will Davidson User:Williambellwisdo 20:25, 22 May 2017 (UTC) keep """article is sourced. Source shows 40+ appearances for Manchester United. A quick check of one of his match dates in the newspapers of the time https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DAdMohwWsAAnTBh.jpg show him in the planned line-up (this is the September 9, 1893) edition of the ''Manchester Courier and Lancashire General Advertiser'' on page 11 under Football - Fixtures For To-Day. The simplest of Google searches with just his team name and surname yields 124,000 hits, with some legitimate ones right on the first page such as http://www.11v11.com/matches/crewe-alexandra-v-newton-heath-01-december-1894-91019/ one, https://books.google.ca/books?id=YWaoAwAAQBAJ&pg=PT11&lpg=PT11&dq=%22newton+heath%22+davidson&source=bl&ots=uVgODuYdHr&sig=KKyG7Jo5My3L6booliL4_BmKRZk&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjZ0_iFp4TUAhVFhywKHf3HCfUQ6AEIUzAI#v=onepage&q=%22newton%20heath%22%20davidson&f=false two, and http://www.11v11.com/matches/newton-heath-v-woolwich-arsenal-13-october-1894-90978/ three as examples. And even if one was unaware that arguably the most famous football team in the world didn't used to have a different name, a click on """"what links here"""" would have made that clear. Clicking on the Russian version of this article, which is very well referenced (:ru:Дэвидсон, Уилл) would have found a good list of references which are primarily in English! This is a massive fail of , and I don't understand""" Deletion of Will Davidson WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4135 15598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019 Bagram Airfield attack User:Coolabahapple 14:26, 21 December 2019 (UTC) comment i note that a number of editors here talk of not knowing whether this attack will have lasting effects/conseguences, i am reminded of Deletion of 2019 Bagram Airfield attack WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4136 1392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caffers User:Lee 20:41, 10 May 2006 (UTC) delete """From the line """"I believe i now meet the criteria!"""" as well as the """"dead, famous, etc, etc"""" remark, it appears the author needed to prove they are notable for some reason or another to someone who said they'd accept """"having an article on Wikipedia"""" as acceptable proof of notability. Still violates , among others""" Deletion of Caffers WP:VANITY Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
4137 274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lukewarmer User:Sailsbystars 16:57, 19 March 2014 (UTC) delete this for the same reasons I gave for deleting Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of scientists opposing the mainstream scientific assessment of global warming (6th nomination). It has too many possible definitions. Add in eologism and that weighs even more heavily towards deletion Deletion of Lukewarmer WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4138 5463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tie Break (jazz ensemble) User:Alzarian16 12:00, 1 June 2010 (UTC) keep The coverage found appears to be just enough for the group to meet Deletion of Tie Break (jazz ensemble) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4139 8761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Slater User:Harry4000 00:37, 12 August 2010 (UTC) keep """This is NOT a subject of which reads: """"If reliable sources cover the person only in the context of a single event, AND if that person otherwise remains, or is likely to remain, a low-profile individual"""".. Slater is NOT likely to remain a low-profile individual. He is likely to have a reality show, a book deal, and much more because his name and story has become a valuable brand that captures audience attention, and that's what drives continuing media""" Deletion of Steven Slater WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4140 16985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of roundabouts in Pennsylvania User:Colapeninsula 11:42, 14 February 2013 (UTC) delete Fails and and there's a lack of reliable sources: we need sources providing detailed coverage, as well as showing why this is a notable topic in general. Wikipedia:NGEO says major roads are usually notable, but regional/local roads may not be, and doesn't mention smaller road features. Unless someone wants to write a history of roundabouts in PA, with appropriate sources, delete Deletion of List of roundabouts in Pennsylvania WP:NOTDIRECTORY||WP:L Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4141 17692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Butler (British politician) User:Cullen328 03:38, 30 October 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Richard Butler (British politician) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
4142 12132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shannon McGregor User:Yosemiter 15:48, 10 June 2017 (UTC) delete Appears to fail GNG per only sources. Players time in the third tier worlds and in a league with no pre-established notability criteria means GNG is the only guideline that needs to met (as always Deletion of Shannon McGregor WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4143 15285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jaibriol III User:Savidan 17:40, 20 July 2009 (UTC) delete no evidence of notability outside the series; thus fails #PLOT and Deletion of Jaibriol III WP:NOT||WP:WAF Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4144 13284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Bosworth User:Metropolitan90 08:13, 3 November 2007 (UTC) delete Unverifiable article with no sources and serious problems Deletion of Andrew Bosworth WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4145 9217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giovanni Sacheli User:Hammersoft 20:07, 2 August 2017 (UTC) delete Not notable under , or . Ok, he exists. Ok, he's attended some conferences and spoken at a few conferences. Ok, he has a blog. None of this makes him notable by our standards, nor do their appear to be any reliable secondary sources attesting to his notability. Even https://www.advancedseotool.it/relatori/giovanni-sacheli this conference, which should be singing his praises as being a leading expert or some such in his field, has nothing to say that approaches our standards for notability. Given such rapid recreation after Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giovanni sacheli|being deleted, a |salting might be appropriate Deletion of Giovanni Sacheli WP:GNG||WP:NBIO||WP:NPROF||WP:SALT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4146 17536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The 9/11 REcommission Report User:Leuko 19:48, 28 March 2007 (UTC) delete no for or Deletion of The 9/11 REcommission Report WP:RS||WP:N||WP:A Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4147 770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agnivesh Jyotiraditya User:CaroleHenson 00:42, 9 April 2017 (UTC) delete """but open to being swayed if there's proof of award significance, bestseller, other key evidence of notability) - There are a few sources, but not enough to be considered """"significant"""" and a news show that back up the points in the article, but the """"best selling"""" part is hard to substantiate. I'm not finding what organization may have considered him a best-seller - and I cannot find an authority/identity record for him, except perhaps https://viaf.org/processed/DNB%7C109977747X this """"sparse"""" VIAF record under Monu. I don't find an authority/identity under his birth name. I am not finding information that the awards are particularly notable, except perhaps """"Kamala Surayya Award"""" which is listed as an award under List of Malayalam literary awards, but I cannot find an independent source saying he won that award. Although he sounds to be quite a talented boy, I am not finding enough to establish notability at this time. This is possibly a case of """ Deletion of Agnivesh Jyotiraditya WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4148 2226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of systems biology research groups User:Kingofaces43 20:38, 11 April 2016 (UTC) delete As others above have mentioned, is pretty clear on this. Seems to be a place for using a category if someone really wanted to organize these rather than creating an article Deletion of List of systems biology research groups WP:NOTADIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4149 8440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of X-Play characters (2nd nomination) User:Rorshacma 22:01, 31 October 2019 (UTC) delete """There is really no sourced information here, thus negating the need to merge anywhere. Likewise, I was unable to find any sources that would indicate that this vast collection of minor """"characters"""" is at all notable. This is just an list of overly detailed cruft. Most, if not all, of these entries are completely non-notable """"once, Adam dressed up as *insert random character*"""" style entries that have no encyclopedic value""" Deletion of List of X-Play characters (2nd nomination) WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4150 18207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Monroe Middle School NONE 03:15, 2 April 2007 (UTC) merge to respective school district (or locality) per and school guidelines. http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Yamaguchi%E5%85%88%E7%94%9F&action=edit§ion=new Yamaguchi先生 Deletion of James Monroe Middle School WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
4151 10725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qantas Flights 7 and 8 User:ToThAc 13:47, 10 October 2019 (UTC) keep per {{u|AmericanAir88}} and definitely per . The subject was definitely significant in the past, and just because it no longer holds a record doesn't automatically detract its notability Deletion of Qantas Flights 7 and 8 WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4152 19775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/24 The Galaxy war User:MichaelQSchmidt 08:38, 18 January 2017 (UTC) delete per being (at kindest) |TOO SOON. Announced that filmmakers wish to release in eleven months, we do not even have a confirmation of filming. If or when the topic ever meets the article can always be |resurrected Deletion of 24 The Galaxy war WP:NYF||WP:NF||WP:REFUND Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4153 16951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scientific Software Database User:Joe 20:03, 24 July 2009 (UTC) delete I didn't find any sources for this. Fails Deletion of Scientific Software Database WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4154 16478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Androphilia and gynephilia User:Jokestress 05:41, 26 July 2011 (UTC) comment """Two of the better secondary sources listed in the article as it stands are the analysis in the """"Surrogate phonology and transsexual faggotry"""" piece by Bruce Bagemihl, and the chapter in ''Brain Storm'' by Dr. Jordan-Young, which includes graphs, extensive analysis, and debunking of a lot of the """"brain sex"""" stuff put out by psychologists. The discussion of androphilia/gynephilia vs. homosexual/heterosexual starts at page 158, but the closing admin can http://books.google.com/books?id=iAxfiKRXYfgC&pg=PA160#v=onepage&q&f=false read some of it here. As far as the bloviation and statistical nonsense above, ''gynephilia'' appears 16,800 times, 2,600 of which are connected with ''androphilia'', or about 15% of the time. ''Gynecophilia'' appears with ''androphilia'' about 47% of the time. I see this attempt at suppressing this debate now has multiple fronts, including a Wikipedia:Biographies_of_living_persons/Noticeboard#BLP_errors_in_mentions_of_James_Cantor_.28me.29.|trumped-up BLP claim that removed a reliable source containing contextualization of the term as part of Blanchard's transsexualism typology (a link now removed completely from the article in a knee-jerk response), a y content fork of this article at androphilia, and other disruptions. I hope the closing admin sees through all this, looks at the Jordan-Young link above, and closes this inappropriate AfD after it has been up for the full amount of time required""" Deletion of Androphilia and gynephilia WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
4155 9525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MMP (Oregon street gang) User:Ammodramus 18:46, 19 September 2012 (UTC) delete Google and Google News Archives searches for (mmp salem gang) fail to turn up anything relevant beside this article and the two sources cited therein. Subject treated very briefly in sources cited; no evidence of significant coverage. No evidence of coverage outside of Salem area. Delete per failure to satisfy and Deletion of MMP (Oregon street gang) WP:GNG||WP:GEOSCOPE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4156 5979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Independent National Socialism User:Toon05 16:42, 6 July 2008 (UTC) delete non-notable, non-|verifiable due to no |reliable sources - a forum posting is actually used as a cite. Looks to be promoting this organisation Deletion of Independent National Socialism WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4157 5438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adminsoft Accounts User:Whpq NONE delete There is no significant coverage in |reliable sources to meet Wikipedia's |inclusion criteria. The sourcing in the article do not represent reliable sources and the closest thing I could find was this http://www.thehindu.com/business/companies/article1536533.ece passing mention in The Hindu Deletion of Adminsoft Accounts WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4158 2402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leviak B. Kelly User:MelanieN 19:29, 7 June 2015 (UTC) delete """Fails / There are literally NO independent reliable sources about this person or his book. The references at the article are an interview by """"The Pew"""", which doesn't seem to exist except for that one youtube interview; Createspace, a self-publisher; and Religion the Ultimate STD, the author's or book's own web page. The Keep arguments from the SPAs are unconvincing and not policy based""" Deletion of Leviak B. Kelly WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4159 4719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nate Garner User:Northamerica1000 02:34, 16 June 2016 (UTC) keep Presumed notable per . E.g. http://www.sun-sentinel.com/sports/miami-dolphins/sfl-dolphins-release-veteran-offensive-lineman-nate-garner-20150302-story.html, http://sports.yahoo.com/news/odrick-garner-show-versatility-dolphins-002021658--nfl.html, http://www.sportsnet.ca/football/nfl/offensive-lineman-garner-re-signs-with-dolphins/, etc Deletion of Nate Garner WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
4160 8932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Estádio Municipal 22 de Junho User:ManicSpider 05:23, 19 December 2013 (UTC) comment On the reference that has now been added, I would like to point out that it does not meet or Deletion of Estádio Municipal 22 de Junho WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4161 2331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CookiePie User:Sebastianwain NONE comment What? Are you saying that the amount of time I spend on Wikipedia is administrative privilege? And one of the other things Wikipedia is clear about is |assume good faith. Besides, the articles haven't actually been removed yet, this is the process to see whether they will get removed. This is what happened: after I read Deletion of CookiePie WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
4162 12448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nehemia Bill Solossa User:Carioca 21:29, 23 November 2010 (UTC) delete as he fails both and Deletion of Nehemia Bill Solossa WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4163 17920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bert Lucas (footballer, born 1921) User:Smartyllama 15:10, 15 November 2016 (UTC) keep Meets and invalid rationale for deletion. Let's close this now Deletion of Bert Lucas (footballer, born 1921) WP:NAFL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4164 8442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mumtaz Qadri User:Saqib 09:12, 12 April 2018 (UTC) keep with regret but some obvious reasons. Per , {{blue|If the event is highly significant, and the individual's role within it is a large one, a separate article is generally appropriate.}}. Generally, I'm not in favor of keeping bios about low level terrorists but the unfortunate assassination of Salman Taseer attracted wide media attention and is of significant historical importance. This terrorist is subject of massive media attention, and therefore clearly meets the notability criteria, unfortunately. The actions of this terrorist have turned the spotlight onto the issue of blasphemy law in Pakistan and lead to significant debate on the issue Deletion of Mumtaz Qadri WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
4165 2674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. User:VMS 01:53, 20 June 2014 (UTC) keep per above comments and Deletion of Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. WP:LISTED Wikipedia:Notability 77
4166 18366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Graffiti (album) User:SRX 22:15, 11 August 2008 (UTC) delete per , can be recreated when meets Deletion of Graffiti (album) WP:CBALL||WP:NM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4167 14771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Visiondirect.co.uk User:LaMona 18:17, 24 August 2014 (UTC) delete obvious Deletion of Visiondirect.co.uk WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4168 15415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamed Minhaj User:Kinu 22:15, 9 October 2009 (UTC) comment Note that notability is established through ''significant coverage'' in ''reliable sources''. The sources you provide are a start, but without actually seeing the sources, a) they cannot be |verified, and b) merely being mentioned in a newspaper, especially on a local scale, is not an indicator of actual notability per versus local importance. Also note that the ''Kabul Weekly'' IS online (http://www.kw.af/; the author linked to it himself in the article); however, there seems to be no mention of this subject found in the archives Deletion of Hamed Minhaj WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4169 20851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adelaider User:Alphax 15:09, 20 December 2005 (UTC) delete doesn't satisfy . Plus, I'm from Adelaide and I've never heard of it Deletion of Adelaider WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4170 17567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frogs in popular culture (2nd nomination) User:Quasirandom 19:42, 19 December 2007 (UTC) keep and execute Zagalejo's suggestion. Lots of dross in this ore, but with the refining fire of |sources, this is at least a nugget, if not a full bar, of a cool, interesting, and useful article. I note, btw, that is an argument to leap over. Ribbit Deletion of Frogs in popular culture (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:NOEFFORT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4171 212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sugunthan User:Dflaw4 13:49, 5 February 2020 (UTC) delete """A weak case might be made for , but all the sources I could find are passing mentions in International Business Times of India, which is generally considered unreliable, or in Silverscreen and """"IndiaBlitz"""", which I'm not familiar with. If anyone can find better sources or argue why the existing sources pass , I'll certainly consider updating my vote""" Deletion of Sugunthan WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4172 7608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RevLeft User:Esquivalience 02:53, 5 May 2015 (UTC) delete fails - HighBeam and Google News found zero results, books most likely have no mention Deletion of RevLeft WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4173 19789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dusan Zarubica User:Aleksa 08:22, 21 November 2013 (UTC) delete fails GNG searching the web I couldn't find anything that had 'Dusan Zarubica' as a main topic of material, fails as insignificant political figure, and also obvious conflict of interest as it's possibly an autobiography, Deletion of Dusan Zarubica WP:POLITICIAN||WP:SELFPROMOTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
4174 35 [[Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Sportengagement von Red Bull]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Steindy 14:19, 19. Jun. 2009 (CEST) keep Socrates, hast Du eine ''Begründung'' für Deine These, dass die Vereine ''nicht'' von Red Bull geführt werden? Wenn nicht, dann ist Dein Löschantrag, wie Du so schön schreibst, „mehr als verzichtbar“ und gemäß Fall 1 zu entsorgen Löschung von Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Sportengagement von Red Bull Wikipedia:LAE Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
4175 4321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chandler Hoffman User:GiantSnowman 09:17, 5 January 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Chandler Hoffman WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4176 11145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people in Playboy by Birthdate User:Kwsn 16:05, 18 June 2007 (UTC) delete pointless list and violates Deletion of List of people in Playboy by Birthdate WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4177 10469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slayy Point User:Alexandermcnabb 13:28, 31 May 2021 (UTC) delete The more 'improvements' have been made to the page, the more I have become convinced of its lack of fundamental notability. Being the source of a 'meme' that trended for two days is not the stuff of . Best Deletion of Slayy Point WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4178 15621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oil Disposition, Reuse and Recycling NONE NONE keep Firstly, '''the article has been renamed to Oil recycling'''. This topic obviously passes . I've done some work to improve the article. Here are some sources that qualify this topic's |notability for inclusion in Wikipedia Deletion of Oil Disposition, Reuse and Recycling WP:GNG||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4179 19010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Every Heart Broken User:Bill NONE delete No reliable sources. |Crystal Ballerisationism Deletion of Every Heart Broken WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4180 15765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shazza McKenzie (2nd nomination) User:Aoziwe 12:52, 14 September 2018 (UTC) delete I was about to ''pile on'' here, having had a quick look around and not finding anything to support GNG sufficiently well. Not sure why, but I had a second look and very quickly found https://www.smh.com.au/lifestyle/showcase-chantelle-allison-20161103-gsgu7r.htmlhttps://www.smh.com.au/lifestyle/showcase-chantelle-allison-20161103-gsgu7r.html this from 2016 and https://hercanberra.com.au/cpactive/what-it-really-takes-to-be-a-pro-wrestler/ this from 2018. Both of these are outside wrestling and importantly the 2016 one from the SMH would be considered as about as best reliable secondary source as one can get. Not sure though that two such articles is sufficient though Deletion of Shazza McKenzie (2nd nomination) WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
4181 13275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/אלין User:Doc 18:59, 11 January 2009 (UTC) delete A |dicdef and nothing more Deletion of אלין WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
4182 6809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Woolfson User:AllyD 07:01, 23 April 2020 (UTC) delete Searches find mentions relative to the firms involving the subject (e.g.https://www.lawfuel.com/blog/steptoe-johnson-llp-announced-today-that-steptoe-will-acquire-the/) plus occasional commentary items by the subject https://www.internationallawoffice.com/Newsletters/Insurance/European-Union/Oppenheimer-Wolff-Donnelly/Agreement-on-Modernization-of-Motor-Insurance-Directives-is-Welcomed, but I am not finding the |specific coverage needed to establish |notability Deletion of Philip Woolfson :WP:RS||:WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4183 6200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yasmin Lucas User:Griseum 06:41, 27 February 2010 (UTC) delete as |not notable. Perhaps on the cusp of notability, but what 'net presence this person has (in English and Portuguese) seems like self-promotion Deletion of Yasmin Lucas WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4184 43 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Watson (politician) User:117Avenue 03:44, 26 April 2012 (UTC) delete unreferenced, Deletion of Ryan Watson (politician) WP:BLPPROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion of biographies of living people 66
4185 9843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One/Off Printmakers User:Netherzone 20:31, 23 June 2020 (UTC) delete Notability is not inherited from artists who have worked there or their affiliations. The sourcing amounts to listings and press releases. Fails Deletion of One/Off Printmakers WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4186 12627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Crecente (2nd nomination) User:hmwith 09:19, 29 May 2007 (UTC) delete per . Not every writer deserves an encyclopedia article Deletion of Brian Crecente (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4187 2028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leotask User:Mcmatter 17:41, 8 January 2015 (UTC) delete There is not even a claim to significance for this software, this articles fails both and and there seems to be zero |relibale sources Deletion of Leotask WP:GNG||WP:NSOFT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4188 15653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of The Fairly OddParents characters User:Torc2 01:08, 8 January 2008 (UTC) keep This is just part of the main The Fairly OddParents article parsed out due to restrictions. It is not a separate article; it just exists on a separate page. It should not be assessed for notability in complete isolation from The Fairly OddParents, but should be viewed as part of that article Deletion of List of The Fairly OddParents characters WP:SIZE Wikipedia:Article size 51
4189 13500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International reactions to the 2011 Norway attacks User:Silver 22:41, 23 July 2011 (UTC) keep They do not fall under NOTNEWS, they fall under , as they are too long to include in the main article. Thus, they were split onto their own page. This is a common practice and responses from various world government is encyclopedia and important in a number of ways (International climes, relationships between countries, reactions to reasons behind event, terrorism in this case Deletion of International reactions to the 2011 Norway attacks WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Splitting 57
4190 15094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pranshu Chatur Lal User:GermanKity 09:35, 18 June 2021 (UTC) delete As per nom. fails Deletion of Pranshu Chatur Lal WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4191 14215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Brigden User:Bearian 17:28, 12 August 2019 (UTC) delete per above. Being the CCO, board secretary, etc., |by itself is not notable. He has to have done something Deletion of John Brigden WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4192 19211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/India Luxury Style Week User:Wikimandia 11:00, 11 June 2015 (UTC) keep article is a mess and unclear but the sources are there; the men's edition of fashion week was in April and the women's is in August. does not apply. Even though it's promotional, judging by the large number of articles and photo galleries from the April event, it meets GNG Deletion of India Luxury Style Week WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4193 9214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vladan Mijatovic User:Bearian 21:52, 27 July 2016 (UTC) delete despite a chance to |save this, there has been no edits for ten days. I'm not convinced by the |poor sourcing Deletion of Vladan Mijatovic WP:HEY||WP:RS Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
4194 9499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Afunika User:Superastig 06:09, 28 May 2020 (UTC) keep I only found sources about him in Zambia Daily Mail: http://www.daily-mail.co.zm/afunika-release-new-album/, http://www.daily-mail.co.zm/no-album-this-year-for-afunika/, http://www.daily-mail.co.zm/legend-king-meet/, http://www.daily-mail.co.zm/afunika-eye-eagle/ and http://www.daily-mail.co.zm/afunika-launches-isumbu/. With these reliable sources, I believe the article is good enough to pass . My vote stands Deletion of Afunika WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4195 18766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Game Factory Interactive user:Hellknowz 13:23, 6 December 2012 (UTC) keep Game Factory Interactive and GFI Russia. http://www.fcenter.ru/online.shtml?articles/software/interview/17277 Here and http://gamestar.ru/article/1278.html here are interviews with GFI and http://web.archive.org/web/20101121081546/http://crpg.ru/sections.php?op=viewarticle&artid=2053 here with MiST. http://games.cnews.ru/articles/3/641_1.html Here and http://www.fcenter.ru/forprint.shtml?online/articles/software/interview/21602 here are a dev inteviews on Warfare with mentions of company. http://news.softpedia.com/news/GFI-and-Russobit-M-Merge-Looking-for-New-Market-Segments-86097.shtml Here's a news article. http://www.myrtana.ru/g3/interviews/237-interview27 Here is another interview, but I doubt it's a reliable source. I'm sure I could dig out more, but I think that's enough for at this time. '''Keep''' Paradise Cracked and Alfa: Antiterror as having suitable /RS. (P.S. Looking at searches above other games like Warfare (2008) are also most likely GNG notable) — Deletion of Game Factory Interactive WP:GNG||WP:GNG||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4196 7717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Angeli User:Niteshift36 11:18, 21 June 2009 (UTC) delete """per nom. is an essay, you are correct. An essay that """"''may be consulted for assistance during an AfD discussion''"""". And sure, people could be notable without passing those criteria. Maybe they wrote a best selling book before they took up the sport. That would make them notable without passing """ Deletion of Jordan Angeli WP:FOOTYN||WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
4197 1058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SpinnWebe User:Rodii 13:10, 23 February 2006 (UTC) comment """I won't keep commenting here, but I do want to note a few things: (a) I can't speak for anyone else I resent the implication that I'm here because Schumin """"recruited"""" me. I have zero interest or involvement in SpinnWebe; I read AfD and comment where I have something to contribute—I didn't see Schumin's note until after I commented here. But informing people who have spoken up in a debate that it's continuing in another forum |could be seen as a courtesy instead of a conspiracy. (b) Wikipedians have a right to comment, even if they have some involvement in the issue being discussed. Please note that the alleged meatpuppets actually made arguments and didn't just do the usual newbie """"'''Dont Delete our Board you fuckers!'''"""" kind of nonsense we often see on AfD. (c) The Mirsky nom is a separate issue, but """"kids these days"""" sounds funny rather than snide to me. Maybe you have to be old to get it. (d) Most importantly, if you read the page JerseyDevil so triumphantly adduces, instead of just his cherrypicked examples, in my opinion you'll see Spinn working fairly respectfully ''within'' the Wikipedia process to get his page reinstated. To hold up that page as some kind of evidence of bad faith is just not appropriate""" Deletion of SpinnWebe WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
4198 4044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathan Sykes (singer) User:Armbrust 20:37, 18 September 2010 (UTC) delete per , no notability outside the band and it is a unlikely search term Deletion of Nathan Sykes (singer) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4199 14452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Cheetah Girls 3 (second nomination) User:Wafulz 18:06, 25 August 2006 (UTC) delete No IMDb entry yet, still being written, entirely speculative, fails Deletion of The Cheetah Girls 3 (second nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4200 3882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Deacove User:Bearcat 20:16, 10 December 2018 (UTC) delete """The references are all either |primary source directory entries or unreliable sources, not |reliable source coverage in real media, but nothing stated in the article body is """"inherently"""" notable enough to exempt him from having to have much better referencing than this""" Deletion of Jim Deacove WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
4201 15518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lyndon Burgess User:Number 10:00, 31 May 2019 (UTC) keep Six international appearances means he meets Deletion of Lyndon Burgess WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4202 1968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Depression and natural therapies User:VigilancePrime 04:28, 5 January 2008 (UTC) delete """and if necessary relocate good information. Much of the article should be in individual pages, such as Acupuncture, Amino Acids, Coffee, Inositol, and Reiki. This is a clear POV fork and I feel it was written for a particular |POV as well, evidenced by subtle POV statements such as """"drug companies have responded with a ''vast arsenal'' of antidepressant medications"""" and """"they nevertheless may have a contribution to make""" Deletion of Depression and natural therapies WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
4203 18226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Yovchev User:Necrothesp 16:09, 18 February 2015 (UTC) delete NCO awarded what appears to be his country's second highest medal for gallantry, so fails . No other reason for notability Deletion of Ali Yovchev WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
4204 4994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caribbean Bird Vendor User:Coolabahapple 08:05, 2 May 2020 (UTC) comment """this appears to be an important example of wilson's art, in addition to being chosen by ''Emerging Infectious Diseases (journal)|Emerging Infectious Diseases'' for one of their Journal covers (as brought out by {{u|ThatMontrealIP}} above) with a small but |non trivial discussion/analysis of it, it was also chosen by the curator to be the cover illustration for the exhibition catalogue of ''https://www.worldcat.org/title/art-of-ellis-wilson/oclc/900344960?referer=di&ht=edition The Art of Ellis Wilson'', with the Biography#Ellis Wilson|referenced mention of it in the artist's article (4th paragraph), its almost, but not quite there, in terms of wikinotablenes for a standalone, but a '''redirect/merge''' to a """"Works"""" section in Ellis Wilson may be appropriate""" Deletion of Caribbean Bird Vendor WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
4205 18169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Hickmott User:Mdtemp 08:32, 31 March 2016 (UTC) delete Lacks the coverage needed for and the accomplishments for Deletion of Jordan Hickmott WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4206 19008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leslie Johnson (publisher) [[User talk:Czar|czar]] 03:06, 16 December 2019 (UTC) delete Lacks |significant coverage and the related magazine is not a suitable redirect target, since it will likely be deleted or redirected soon Deletion of Leslie Johnson (publisher) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
4207 204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donnie Darko: The Director's Cut NONE NONE keep Donnie Darko: The Director's Cut'' had its own international release, its own budget, its own theatrical release poster, its own screening at an international film festival. It has its own pages on https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/donnie_darko_the_directors_cut/ Rotten Tomatoes, http://www.metacritic.com/movie/donnie-darko-the-directors-cut Metacritic and http://www.boxofficemojo.com/movies/?id=donniedarko04.htm Box Office Mojo, and two different home media releases (10 years apart). Its production and release were reported on by the likes of http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/life/movies/news/2005-02-14-dvd-donnie-darko_x.htm USA Today, https://www.theguardian.com/film/2004/jul/30/2 The Guardian, https://web.archive.org/web/20040806162303/http://www.indiewire.com/movies/movies_040722darko.html Indiewire, http://www.alternet.org/story/19627/the_resurrection_of_%27donnie_darko%27 AlterNet, and http://www.seattlepi.com/ae/movies/article/Donnie-Darko-gets-a-second-shot-in-theaters-1146161.php various http://www.sfgate.com/movies/article/Teen-sinister-rabbit-get-second-chance-2696394.php other http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A17348-2004Aug19.html sources. Reviews at the time came from https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=SbAEim_dVQkC Roger Ebert, http://www.bbc.co.uk/films/2004/08/24/donnie_darko_directors_cut_2004_review.shtml the BBC, https://web.archive.org/web/20040807060457/http://www.villagevoice.com/issues/0429/lim2.php The Village Voice, plus others. In all of these sources, it's the director's cut that's the primary subject, ''not'' the original film. This all suggests to me that the director's cut is notable (independent of the original film), meets , and that therefore this article should be kept Deletion of Donnie Darko: The Director's Cut WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4208 5186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guardians of Ga'Hoole Book 11: To Be a King User:Reyk 02:16, 8 July 2010 (UTC) delete I agree that this fails in general and in particular Deletion of Guardians of Ga'Hoole Book 11: To Be a King WP:GNG||WP:NB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4209 9699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kwik Way (band) User:Nlfestival 19:01, 26 October 2013 (UTC) delete looked everywhere, Does not meet guidelines Deletion of Kwik Way (band) WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4210 17664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beth Gerstein User:Realkyhick 06:45, 4 January 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Blatant Deletion of Beth Gerstein WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
4211 4302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Awake (Hillsong album) User:Canyouhearmenow 02:03, 2 July 2014 (UTC) delete This album in no way meets the requirements. Billboard nor Cashbox have record of this title. Even though a few mention of it exist, I do not feel it meets the criteria to remain viable on Wikipedia Deletion of Awake (Hillsong album) :WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4212 18021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harun hilton User:KurtRaschke 19:45, 24 May 2008 (UTC) delete per above; fails and Deletion of Harun hilton WP:V||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4213 9200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eclipsia User:Dawn 20:37, 21 January 2009 (UTC) delete Not notable per . Has a few http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rls=com.microsoft:en-ca&q=eclipsia+robert+francis&start=20&sa=N google hits, but only because it has been submitted to free classified sites and self-publishing outfits like LuLu.com. I think this is a textbook example of Wikipedia:Vanispamcruftisement|vanispamcruftisement Deletion of Eclipsia WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4214 2078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boar (Thomas Harris) User:Dhartung 20:54, 13 January 2007 (UTC) merge with Hannibal (novel) per Deletion of Boar (Thomas Harris) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4215 6503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monit User:Joe 00:07, 29 September 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of Monit WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4216 10926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/César Luis González User:Mztourist 03:07, 21 January 2021 (UTC) delete fails and , first X nationality to do/receive/die during Y is not notable. We don't have pages for the first person of every nationality, US state or territory to do something, so no reason why an exception should be made for Puerto Rico Deletion of César Luis González WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4217 18030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marie Gannon User:Bearcat 13:36, 24 May 2019 (UTC) delete Officeholders at the county level can sometimes still clear #2 if there's enough sourcing to write a genuinely substantive article about their political importance — but they are not automatically entitled to have articles just because their existence as county councillors can be single-sourced to a |primary source list of the councillors. The lowest level of political office that ''entitles'' a person to have an article is the ''state'' legislature — people at the local level of office require notability claims that go significantly ''beyond'' just the fact that they exist, such as the ability to write and source a genuinely substantive and detailed article Deletion of Marie Gannon WP:NPOL||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES Wikipedia:Notability 77
4218 14567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cary S. Cox User:Danre98 15:09, 14 July 2020 (UTC) delete Patents by themselves are not notable. There is no coverage on this guy from independent, reliable sources per . In addition, the inventions themselves probably aren't notable either Deletion of Cary S. Cox WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4219 6580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chulbul Pandey User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:12, 3 May 2014 (UTC) keep this '''BRAND NEW''' article and encourage the |'''new article''' be improved, per , , ... and and the |numerous available sources discussing and analyzing the chracter. A five minute |search quickly found such as http://ibnlive.in.com/news/dabangg-2-15-reasons-to-cheer-chulbul-pandey-once-more/311514-8-66.html ''IBN'' http://archive.indianexpress.com/news/chulbul-pandey-poised-to-overtake-tiger/1050460/ ''Indian Express'' http://www.bollywoodlife.com/tag/chulbul-pandey/ ''Bollywood Life'' http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-national/tp-newdelhi/dabangg-chulbul-pandey-is-back-with-a-bang/article4230705.ece ''The HIndu'' http://www.firstpost.com/bollywood/movie-review-dabangg-2-should-have-been-titled-chulbul-pandey-565949.html ''First Post'' http://zeenews.india.com/entertainment/bollywood/dabangg-2-review-make-way-for-chulbul-pandey-reloaded_124844.html ''Zee News'' http://www.ndtv.com/video/player/news/when-chulbul-pandey-met-inspector-vijay/282581 ''NDTV'' (1) http://www.ndtv.com/video/player/saturday-night-fever/salman-khan-at-his-wittiest-best/262454 ''NDTV'' (2) http://www.ndtv.com/video/player/no-biz-like-showbiz/how-the-dabangg-phenomenon-is-taking-the-country-by-storm/259162 ''NDTV'' (3) (and more) showing the character is spoken of quite a bit... and there are real-world considerations. The character is considered an inspiration by other actorshttp://archives.deccanchronicle.com/121219/lifestyle-fashion/article/chulbul-pandey-inspires-soha see ''Deccan Chronicle'' is to become a video game character http://www.newswala.com/Entertainment-News/Dabanggs-Chulbul-Pandey-will-now-become-a-Game-Character-25519.html see ''News Vala'' is being emulated in other films and by other actors http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/hindi/bollywood/news-interviews/Bollywood-snippets-Amyra-to-do-a-chulbul-pandey/articleshow/34532456.cms see ''Times of India''http://www.dnaindia.com/entertainment/report-rani-mukherji-to-do-a-chulbul-pandey-1925487 ''DNA''http://www.apunkachoice.com/content/article/sid100017448-rani_mukerji_to_do_a_chulbul_pandey_in_mardaani/ & ''ApunkaChoice'', and even has https://www.facebook.com/chulbulpandeyfanclub a cult/fan following. I was prepared to opine a delete.... until my searches revealed how often this character is spoken of and analyzed directly and in detail in multiple reliable sources. If he were a real person, |notability would not be in doubt. The topic needs expansion and |use of available sources... IE: editorial attention, not deletion Deletion of Chulbul Pandey WP:SOFIXIT||WP:WIP||WP:IMPERFECT||WP:SOFIXIT||WP:NFICT||WP:NRVE||WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG||WP:NRVE Wikipedia:Be bold 9
4220 8976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M. S. Ramaiah User:David 23:16, 11 April 2016 (UTC) delete per . This has clearly not been written on the basis of what reliable sources say about the subject and would need a complete rewrite to become compliant with our sourcing and verifiability policies Deletion of M. S. Ramaiah WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
4221 14371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Mobility Agenda User:Kinu 20:45, 28 October 2019 (UTC) delete This reads more like an essay than an encyclopedia article. It is entirely possible that the topic itself is worthy of inclusion, and while the term appears to be used, I cannot tell from a cursory search how much this differs from, say, sustainable transport. Given the tone and next-to-nil sourcing, I cannot tell how much of the content is useful or relevant, which seems to make this a situation even if an article about it should exist Deletion of New Mobility Agenda WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
4222 15835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rockdetector User:Lykantrop 09:37, 26 October 2008 (UTC) keep Rockdetector is the world's biggest rock database. You can see some sources about it http://www.roadrunnerrecords.com/blabbermouth.net/news.aspx?mode=Article&newsitemID=61217 here and http://www.roadrunnerrecords.com/blabbermouth.net/news.aspx?mode=Article&newsitemID=33768 here or http://metal-rules.com/interviews/Rockdetector.htm the introduction of this. Some of those sources are from Blabbermouth, which is a website hosted by the record label Roadrunner Records. Rockdetector does not fail Deletion of Rockdetector WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4223 15826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amphenol ICC User:Abequinn14 01:05, 18 September 2017 (UTC) delete A sock puppet investigation says that this article may be made by the same company. So it is , and of course, the reasons above Deletion of Amphenol ICC WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4224 13919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mechanicsburg High School Marching Band User:Barkeep49 03:31, 20 December 2019 (UTC) delete If someone wants to merge some of the content go ahead but even with the low cost of redirects, I don't think, following a successful merge, that this redirect satisfies policy and as such I don't think it's an appropriate . Best Deletion of Mechanicsburg High School Marching Band WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
4225 9393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Legalise Cannabis Queensland User:Frickeg 07:34, 4 October 2020 (UTC) keep The general (admittedly informal) rule has been to have separate articles for parties that are registered ''and'' run endorsed candidates in federal or state elections. We have made rare exceptions for the truly obscure, but this is clearly not one of them. Canley's point above easily refutes any concerns and there is adequate (though not extensive) sourcing, with more inevitable over the next few weeks Deletion of Legalise Cannabis Queensland WP:NOTPROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4226 9241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Superior Glove User:StraussInTheHouse 11:18, 12 March 2019 (UTC) delete the company has received coverage in secondary sources, however, much of that is in local papers about their commendable yet not notable philanthropy. Better sourcing is needed to demonstrate the company has received the |depth of coverage required for corporations to be considered |notable. Here is an analysis of the sources. See my comment below for a source assessment Deletion of Superior Glove WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4227 7777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monday Night Football all-time team standings (2nd nomination) User:Clarityfiend 11:53, 29 December 2016 (UTC) delete """I found one non-Wikipedia hit for """"Monday Night Football all-time results"""". That's http://www.espn.com/abcsports/mnf/s/alltimehistory.html here by ESPN, and all that is is a list you can click on to see various games by year. It also ends at 2002, so apparently they've lost even that minimal interest. So it fails , unless someone can produce more reliable sources. It's a stat right up there with best results after bye weeks""" Deletion of Monday Night Football all-time team standings (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4228 214 [[Wikipedia:Strukturoffensive]] + [[Wikipedia:Strukturoffensive/ToDo]] (erledigt, bleibt) Benutzer:217.247.66.62 NONE delete wurde das von offizieller Seite ins Leben gerufen? Ist das /Qualitätsoffensive_-_Strukturoffensive???|Meinungsbild zu diesem Thema schon beendet und wurde da für die Einführung der Strukturoffensive gestimmt? Entspricht die Umsetzung und vor allem die Struktur, die diese Strukturoffensive schaffen will überhaupt erwünscht? Und vor allem: Ist schon irgendwas im Rahmen dieser Aktion passiert oder ist das bloß eine Seite mit ein paar Benutzernamen die sowieso nicht besucht und deren Ziel absolut verfehlt wird Löschung von Wikipedia:Strukturoffensive/ToDo Wikipedia:Meinungsbilder Wikipedia:Meinungsbilder 80
4229 14924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nabil Abou-Harb User:ThaddeusB 23:15, 22 July 2009 (UTC) keep """the sources provided by MichaelQSchmidt and the subject passes the |GNG. Failing |CREATIVE is not an automatic fail, as clearly stated in otability (people). It is rare, but sometimes movie makers can be notable for less than to default """"2 notable movies""" Deletion of Nabil Abou-Harb WP:GNG||WP:CREATIVE||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4230 5666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laura Critchley User:Trident13 01:37, 23 January 2008 (UTC) keep passes as there are sufficent . Rgds Deletion of Laura Critchley WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4231 2668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quantum-Touch (3rd nomination) User:MastCell 21:28, 17 March 2008 (UTC) delete """Fails all forms of |notablity, including and , due to a lack of non-trivial coverage in independent reliable secondary sources. The BBC reference is the definition of """"trivial"""" coverage, and the remainder of the sources are questionably reliable (e.g. promotional DVD's) and directly affiliated with the subject (hence not independent). At the very least, this should be redirected to energy therapy, though I think deletion would be more appropriate. Note that I noticed this AfD on the |fringe theories noticeboard, so take that for what you will""" Deletion of Quantum-Touch (3rd nomination) WP:N||WP:FRINGE||WP:ORG||WP:FTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
4232 15831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ayitham User:MichaelQSchmidt 17:06, 31 January 2016 (UTC) merge per to Venu Nagavally, the one place where readers may at least learn of the film's director even if this pre-internet film lacks English sourcing Deletion of Ayitham WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
4233 20452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avengers (film) User:Archrogue 19:35, 21 February 2021 (UTC) merge as this has already been covered in a main article plus a few more. Clear Deletion of Avengers (film) WP:CONTENTFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
4234 6974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Airlines Flight 31 (2nd nomination) User:Ahunt 13:12, 23 May 2017 (UTC) delete AS per , total non incident. The only reason it even made the news is the total over-reaction by authorities Deletion of American Airlines Flight 31 (2nd nomination) WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4235 20487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexei Eryomin User:David 08:13, 5 March 2021 (UTC) delete Citation counts are too weak to support a pass of #C1, and we have no other case for notability. In addition, as his work seems to be at least somewhat fringe in nature, and demand adequate mainstream coverage of it to provide a properly neutral description of his contributions, and we don't have those Deletion of Alexei Eryomin WP:PROF||WP:NPOV||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4236 7853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Parente (2nd nomination) User:Hellno2 04:11, 9 July 2009 (UTC) keep very well |covered and |sourced. OTNEWS does not state that a news event cannot ever be notable, particular a very unusual type of event. While it says that ''routine'' coverage or events reported in tabloids only are not notable, this is anything but routine. There is also no guideline on Wikipedia that an event has to have daily coverage forever in order to be notable, or to continue to have occasional coverage every so often in order for the notability to remain Deletion of William Parente (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:RS||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4237 3019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transmetals User:Satellizer 22:39, 10 May 2016 (UTC) merge the nominator's rationale is perfectly valid. No evidence of ''independent'' notability, thus failing not only but also Deletion of Transmetals WP:GNG||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
4238 3196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darker Prisons User:Jclemens 17:19, 16 September 2008 (UTC) delete fails rather badly Deletion of Darker Prisons WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4239 20314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Findaway (Silverchair song) User:Azealia911 19:09, 3 April 2016 (UTC) merge to ''Frogstomp'', fails Deletion of Findaway (Silverchair song) :WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4240 5218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shwe Eain Min User:Devonian 12:29, 17 January 2021 (UTC) delete total failure of , the only sources I could find that even mentioned her were social media and a couple of directory listings Deletion of Shwe Eain Min WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4241 8242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ocrana (band) User:Peripitus 11:39, 2 August 2006 (UTC) delete fails with no music releases, major concerts, news articles etc Deletion of Ocrana (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4242 5040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shepherd's Hill Academy User:Bearian 21:36, 9 January 2020 (UTC) keep Based on media coverage, it appears |to skim by because I found |at least two reliable sources with technically significant coverage. It has Deletion of Shepherd's Hill Academy WP:BARE||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
4243 239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Jo Cox User:Richhoncho 09:49, 17 June 2016 (UTC) merge This is a discussion regarding article namespace, not notability. Nobody is suggesting that the event should not be recorded in WP (a little trimming of the unnecessary will happen in due course, we are not expecting some international figure to say it's a good job she's dead, are we?) If later the murder becomes notable for some reason (i.e. subsequent events outside the scope of the individual), or because of , then it can be split out again. Let's be honest, anybody who wants to read about the murder will also want/need details of poor Jo too, there is no logic to separation Deletion of Murder of Jo Cox WP:SIZE Wikipedia:Article size 51
4244 12427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Datatune User:Dialectric 08:37, 21 March 2013 (UTC) delete non-notable software article with no RS references - blogs in general are not reliable sources - the sources here are blogs with a clear connection to the developer; article was created by an Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|SPA as possibly promotional. An article about discontinued or non-commercial software or organizations can still be promotional, see Deletion of Datatune WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4245 8694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blinkbox User:LinguistAtLarge 15:18, 20 December 2008 (UTC) keep There are easily a http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&ned=us&q=blinkbox&ie=UTF-8 half dozen articles in gNews to support claims to notability under criteria 1 of . Of course, they need to be added to the article. Deletion of Blinkbox WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4246 15366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Douglas Blakely User:SportsOlympic 15:54, 18 January 2021 (UTC) keep Meets . Nominator didn't do a WP:BEFORE to show the opposite. The nominator nominated (automatically) a large amount of cricketeers. It would have been better to made a bunch of them in one nomination Deletion of Douglas Blakely WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4247 13075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Eric Duncan (2nd nomination) User:Squeamish 16:48, 3 September 2015 (UTC) merge """to Ebola virus cases in the United States. doesn't strictly apply (and I'm not willing to stretch the """"recently deceased"""" clause to cover this article), but the ''principle'' behind the policy is still apt: individuals who are merely a small part of a larger story with no further biographical context are better treated in the context of that story. I find the Keep !vote above disturbingly incompatible with """ Deletion of Thomas Eric Duncan (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4248 3187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kresten Bjerg User:Theroadislong 23:48, 27 November 2015 (UTC) delete Clearly fails and doesn't appear to meet any of the 9 Specific criteria notes at otability (academics Deletion of Kresten Bjerg WP:GNG||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4249 17603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monique Alexander (2nd nomination) User:Rebecca1990 17:41, 20 April 2015 (UTC) keep Passes . Has received coverage both within the industry (http://www.avn.com/search/search.pl?criteria=monique+alexander&asArticleSubmit=Search<ypenames=1 & http://www.xbiz.com/search/?news=1&articles=1&st=1&sa=1&sb=1&t=exact&q=monique+alexander&x=0&y=0) and outside of it (http://www.complex.com/pop-culture/the-top-100-hottest-porn-stars/monique-alexander & http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/eb5667ca-91ac-11dd-b5cd-0000779fd18c.html#axzz3Xs6xLnjC Deletion of Monique Alexander (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4250 20735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Achieving sex integration User:Ihcoyc 16:47, 7 June 2011 (UTC) delete WP:OR|original research with neutrality and |stylistic issues. ''Moving the minority sex or completely excluded sex into a social endeavor, activity, or society may succeed in achieving sex integration. In a workplace environment promoting investment in sex-neutral skills is a mechanism that may produce sex integration. Attributing relative meaning to gender or sex may transcend a belief in the reality of gender or sex so as to reduce sex segregation and dominance by exclusively males or females.''If you can explain in English what that last sentence means, you are cleverer than me Deletion of Achieving sex integration WP:UPE Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
4251 8928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of scientists opposing the mainstream scientific assessment of global warming (3rd nomination) User:Hobit 18:03, 26 October 2009 (UTC) keep Not a BLP problem, useful and encyclopedic. I see no OR problem. The synth problem is pretty much the same problem we have with most lists and categories--what to include and not is rarely published elsewhere. So a list of Jewish Inventors (for example) can require some editorial thought, but not so far as to be a violation of Deletion of List of scientists opposing the mainstream scientific assessment of global warming (3rd nomination) WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
4252 18895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SemEval User:Atmoz 00:01, 9 November 2010 (UTC) keep per https://doi.org/10.1007%2Fs10579-009-9091-2 this article and several of the references therein. Therefore, passes Deletion of SemEval WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4253 101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moglix (2nd nomination) User:CNMall41 20:07, 5 July 2017 (UTC) keep Responding to a ping based on commenting at first AfD. My !vote remains the same here. There is in-depth coverage that meets such as https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/280920 this one in Entrepreneur (written by staff writer) and the ones analyzied by {{u|Cunard}} above Deletion of Moglix (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
4254 3572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Ward User:GiantSnowman 20:20, 26 November 2020 (UTC) keep meets and there is sourcing out there, see e.g. https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/news/scott-ward-mark-hunter-luton-life-after-ecstasy-agony-sport-a8577951.html this from the Independent as well as https://www.cityam.com/former-footballer-scott-ward-launches-new-scheme-ey-support/ this and https://www.standard.co.uk/sport/olympic-rowing-champion-mark-hunter-and-exfootballer-scott-ward-helping-stars-prepare-for-life-after-a4095716.html?fallback=true this, all just from a very quick Google search Deletion of Scott Ward WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4255 11685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ira Trivedi User:Marquardtika 01:00, 29 July 2019 (UTC) keep meets . That the article needs (or needed) substantial work doesn't mean the subject doesn't meet our notability standards Deletion of Ira Trivedi WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
4256 5436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary Wales (actor) User:Jersey92 17:15, 3 July 2014 (UTC) delete Fails . Maybe . Either way, delete for now Deletion of Gary Wales (actor) WP:ENT||WP:NYA Wikipedia:Notability 77
4257 3673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Confucius Peace Prize User:Bxj 21:35, 9 December 2010 (UTC) keep it's not speculative, it's real and it has happened. Just because it's pathetic doesn't mean it's not noteworthy. Appears to have sister articles in several other languages Deletion of Confucius Peace Prize WP:BALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4258 9870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brooklyn 11223 User:Toughpigs 21:30, 10 May 2020 (UTC) keep """per , which says, """"Generally, an individual radio or television program is likely to be notable if it airs on a network of radio or television stations (either national or regional in scope), or on a cable television channel with a broad regional or national audience."""" The ''New York Times'' review and WNYC article provided by Davey2010 support the claim for notability""" Deletion of Brooklyn 11223 WP:NTV Wikipedia:Notability 77
4259 17981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aapu User:JohnCD 16:02, 16 March 2009 (UTC) delete WP:NEO, Deletion of Aapu WP:NAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
4260 9455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Christian Church (2nd nomination) User:Coolabahapple 13:54, 24 January 2019 (UTC) delete with a '''Redirect''' to Kip McKean#International Christian Church, not enough |useable sources for a standalone but may be a wikireader searchterm Deletion of International Christian Church (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4261 8510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Politics of Gatineau Park User:M 23:00, 18 November 2009 (UTC) delete """and merge a few sentences in summary to Gatineau Park as discussed above. The article has been written by an editor with an admitted , and has resulted in a POV attacking the NCC. Even though considerable effort has been made to keep this article NPOV, the article is still solely based on GPPC/NWPL arguments which are not notable. Perhaps one or two items should be mentionned at Gatineau Park, but the controversy of the park and NCC is not notable enough to warrant its own Wikipedia page. For comparison, Ottawa editors could consider the controversy over Lansdowne Live!, which has been a major source of debate in the city for over the past year, including many front-page news reports, yet does not have its own article (Lansdowne Live! redirects to Lansdowne Park). Even though a handful of news articles have mentionned """"politics of Gatineau Park"""" issues (and mentionned GPPC/NWPL in passing), they are not notable enough to have their own article""" Deletion of Politics of Gatineau Park WP:COI||WP:SOAPBOX Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
4262 16136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Althea Hill User:Ritchie333 11:05, 19 February 2015 (UTC) keep A book search reveals many sources including https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=m-sfdSUseN8C&pg=PA387&dq=%22Sarah+Althea+Hill%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=oMDlVIvkH4rbsAS954DABQ&ved=0CCwQuwUwAQ#v=onepage&q=%22Sarah%20Althea%20Hill%22&f=false this, https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=7FYA-x6w4DYC&pg=PA148&dq=%22Sarah+Althea+Hill%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=oMDlVIvkH4rbsAS954DABQ&ved=0CDkQuwUwAw#v=onepage&q=%22Sarah%20Althea%20Hill%22&f=false this, https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=QehPhNwc_FkC&pg=PA222&dq=%22Sarah+Althea+Hill%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=oMDlVIvkH4rbsAS954DABQ&ved=0CD4QuwUwBA#v=onepage&q=%22Sarah%20Althea%20Hill%22&f=false this, https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=9XaU8GY32hUC&pg=PA175&dq=%22Sarah+Althea+Hill%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=oMDlVIvkH4rbsAS954DABQ&ved=0CFgQuwUwCQ#v=onepage&q=%22Sarah%20Althea%20Hill%22&f=false this and https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=ZYQvAQAAQBAJ&pg=PA13&dq=%22Sarah+Althea+Hill%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=18DlVPSDJtXasASKi4HYAQ&ved=0CCIQuwUwADgK#v=onepage&q=%22Sarah%20Althea%20Hill%22&f=false this. While I realise |other stuff exists, I don't see much difference regarding the notability claim to, say, Christine Keeler and I don't think we can do anything about for someone who died in 1937 Deletion of Sarah Althea Hill WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4263 20010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Outernet (megatrend) User:Cullen328 00:19, 21 March 2011 (UTC) delete """The word pops up in a variety of ways, but I found no coverage of this specific """"megatrend"""" concept in any |reliable, independent sources""" Deletion of Outernet (megatrend) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4264 3377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joselu (footballer, born 1987) User:BrazilianDude70 22:53, 9 June 2021 (UTC) comment u|Mattythewhite}} tried to add a PROD to the article back in 2014, but @{{u|In ictu oculi}} removed the PROD stating that he passed Deletion of Joselu (footballer, born 1987) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4265 2509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bay Valley Foods User:Youngamerican 01:30, 20 August 2007 (UTC) delete per general guidelines of Deletion of Bay Valley Foods WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4266 2261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/People Can Change User:Fireplace 12:50, 27 September 2007 (UTC) delete as and failing . No evidence of substantial coverage from reliable sources that are independent of the subject. The only reliable source that discusses this group online support group is a newspaper article that mentions them in only two paragraphs Deletion of People Can Change WP:SPAM||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Spam 112
4267 2588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cary Towne Center User:Crzrussian 04:03, 9 July 2006 (UTC) delete despite and in spite of and to spite prior precedent. All individual retail outlets are NN unless they either occupy notable/historic structures (e.g. The Passage) or are of '''monumental''' significance (e.g. same or Mall of America). Otherwise, they are to be listed in the articles of the corporations operating them, if such corporations meet etc Deletion of Cary Towne Center WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4268 7542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hulk vs. Thing User:Emperor 15:05, 8 March 2010 (UTC) delete """if this stays as a list of the battles between Hulk and Thing as that is and . If it is refocused to deal with the storyline """"The Hulk vs The Thing"""" in ''Fantastic Four'' #25-26 then I might reconsider - it is that storyline that has received the most attention, but even then 7th greatest Hulk battle and 13th greatest comic battles suggests there are plenty more out there that have received much more critical plaudits and so do we have an article on all of them too? Where do we draw the line? The idea that this might become a precedent for dozens of more similar articles gives me The Fear. This kind of thing is better off on a fan site but I don't see it as being encyclopaedic - perhaps it is better to transwiki this to the Comics and Marvel Comics wikia pages. That said I am open to a more focused, better sourced article because even if I think this kind of article is A Bad Idea it is possible there are exceptions as long as it is focused on the storyline (and is better sourced and possibly award winning, not cropping up part way down a couple of lists""" Deletion of Hulk vs. Thing WP:OR||WP:SYNTHESIS Wikipedia:No original research 65
4269 5181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benjamin Hoskins Paddock User:Kintetsubuffalo 10:07, 3 October 2017 (UTC) keep if we're going to have weepers about anyone executed in the United States, as is the rage now, then FBI most wanted listers are more clearly notable and meet and Deletion of Benjamin Hoskins Paddock WP:CRIMINAL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4270 3413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Interhall Council User:BQZip01 00:55, 25 February 2008 (UTC) keep per , but needs more sources. Just because it needs sources though, doesn't mean it should be deleted Deletion of Interhall Council WP:SUMMARY Wikipedia:Summary style 34
4271 14582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gog.com User:We66er 01:03, 16 September 2008 (UTC) comment Add about three to demonstrate notablity Deletion of Gog.com WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4272 12338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Best Picture milestones User:Egsan 08:19, 14 December 2017 (UTC) delete Interesting, but also and probably original research Deletion of List of Best Picture milestones WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4273 11751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emilie Taman User:onel5969 13:35, 7 October 2015 (UTC) delete as per nom. Doesn't pass either or Deletion of Emilie Taman WP:GNG||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4274 2600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New World Thorndon User:The 11:58, 11 September 2006 (UTC) delete as |non notable Deletion of New World Thorndon WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
4275 15113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trax House Party User:Nsk92 17:06, 21 July 2010 (UTC) delete in the absence of evidence of significant coverage by independent sources. Fails and Deletion of Trax House Party WP:ORG||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4276 18297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/India under-19 cricket team in England in 2017 User:BlackJack 11:45, 13 September 2017 (UTC) delete per nom as the matches are not first-class and, therefore, the tour fails Deletion of India under-19 cricket team in England in 2017 WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
4277 18873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Castlebawn (Newtownards) User:Guliolopez 20:24, 10 January 2021 (UTC) delete """per nom, , and . This seems to be a run-of-the-mill shopping centre. Containing Tesco and Matalan outlets. And not much else. Maybe a Burger King. But so what. The available coverage speaks to a broader development which was never progressed. And so this article stands only as an example of why we have guidelines. Mine is a very firm """"delete"""" recommendation""" Deletion of Castlebawn (Newtownards) WP:NBUILDING||WP:NBUSINESS||WP:GNG||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4278 14330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manna (drone delivery company) User:Bearian 02:05, 12 January 2020 (UTC) delete a start-up whose |only notability is connection to a new invention. FWIW, my father's parents were born in Ireland and Wales, respectively Deletion of Manna (drone delivery company) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4279 19076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timeline relating to allegations of Israeli Apartheid User:Jayjg 21:27, 8 June 2007 (UTC) delete """POV fork, inherently OR. No """"Timelines of Israeli apartheid"""" exist in the |verifiable, non-|original research real world, only in that rarefied Wikipedia world where the usual suspects POV-push, and their abettors and co-dependents whine on Talk: pages and AfD discussions""" Deletion of Timeline relating to allegations of Israeli Apartheid WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4280 2763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryce Hall (internet personality) User:Mrschimpf 22:03, 28 October 2020 (UTC) delete Outside the bottom section where his parties/power being turned out can be sourced, the rest of the article is pretty much standard 'People article/sources say' or 'get 500 words around a social media post' questionable. I've contributed a few things to this article (including removing more questionable love life gossip), but I don't feel this subject meets myself Deletion of Bryce Hall (internet personality) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4281 17952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luao Luka User:Sir 00:26, 13 March 2013 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not played in a fully pro league or for a senior national team, and has not received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Luao Luka WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4282 17024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laura Chandler Rockefeller User:Jcbarr 20:13, 30 January 2006 (UTC) delete """not many 6 year olds can meet and nothing here indicates Laura does (yet). On same """"family tree does not equal notability"""" criteria, shouldn't John D. Rockefeller V be deleted as well""" Deletion of Laura Chandler Rockefeller WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4283 4693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Rock Shooter [[User talk:159.182.1.4|talk]]) 12:14, 5 October 2009 (UTC) comment It does seem like there's SOMETHING here though. There are figurines being made, people in Japan cosplaying the character, there's apparently a CD somebody put out... an anime series probably falls under , but perhaps further research is in order? Special:Contributions/159.182.1.4|159.182.1.4 Deletion of Black Rock Shooter WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4284 16987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin McKeever (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 16:09, 28 October 2017 (UTC) delete A person has to ''win'' an election, not just run in it, to pass — but this offers little to no evidence that he had preexisting notability for any other reason, which is the only other way for a non-winning candidate to get an article on here Deletion of Kevin McKeever (2nd nomination) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4285 20746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hash Code cracker User:Tigraan 13:54, 4 July 2016 (UTC) delete the best I found was http://thehackernews.com/2011/10/hash-code-cracker-v-12-released.html that. It fails by a landslide Deletion of Hash Code cracker WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4286 5731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss Supranational 2017 User:Bonutra NONE keep This is one of the notable major beauty contests of the year. It has reliable and diverse sources meet . This is evidenced in part by the https://pageviews.toolforge.org/?project=en.wikipedia.org&platform=all-access&agent=user&redirects=0&start=2021-05-19&end=2021-06-08&pages=Miss_Supranational_2021|Miss_Earth_2021|Miss_International_2021|Miss_Earth_2020 12,435 page views in the last 20 days, much higher than the two of big 4, Miss International 2021 and the two most recent editions of Miss Earth, Miss Earth 2020|2020 and Miss Earth 2021|2021 Deletion of Miss Supranational 2017 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4287 19115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/43,112,609 (number) User:Eumat114 03:20, 6 June 2020 (UTC) merge The notability of this number very much rests on it being a Mersenne prime index. Nearly all of the properties listed are somewhat linked to its corresponding prime. If anything, this page should be moved to a page like 2^43112609 - 1. The sources provided are all centered around the Mersenne number instead of 43,112,609 itself, and based on , the number that should be included is 2^43,112,609-1 Deletion of 43,112,609 (number) WP:INHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4288 7192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ricky Allman (3rd nomination) User:David 18:02, 28 January 2021 (UTC) delete Looking through his CV doesn't find anything that might pass (like national-level awards or an above-full-professor title) nor anything that might pass (like being included in the permanent collections of multiple notable museums). And the analysis above shows that -style notability for obtaining publicity rather than for accomplishments is also missing Deletion of Ricky Allman (3rd nomination) WP:PROF||WP:CREATIVE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4289 16989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhawn Joseph User:Stuartyeates 08:03, 26 September 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Rhawn Joseph WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4290 21768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scampers [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']][[User talk:(aeropagitica)|''' (talk) ''']] 17:50, 8 April 2006 (UTC) delete Flash animators, non-notable company, refers Deletion of Scampers WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4291 20033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry George (entrepreneur) User:JeremyMcCracken 13:14, 1 April 2008 (UTC) delete Yet another , based on the other contributions of the creator. No reliable sources, though notability could be considered marginal considering the state of Mr Gay UK and Bent (magazine), where he is mentioned, and where the account in question has also edited. It doesn't seem like enough to warrant trying to clean up this article, however Deletion of Terry George (entrepreneur) WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
4292 92 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slow living User:Esquivalience 01:45, 27 February 2016 (UTC) comment I have |stubified the article Deletion of Slow living WP:STUBIFY Wikipedia:Stub 114
4293 64 [[Perik]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers NONE delete Kasten|1=. Ich halte das Thema nicht für grundsätzlich irrelevant. Nur war der Artikel halt letztlich bloß eine Wiedergabe der Binnensicht und kein enzyklopädischer Artikel, der auf |belegten Sekundärquellen aufbaut. In dieser Form leider für eine Enzyklopädie ungeeignet. Gruß Löschung von Perik Wikipedia:Belege Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4294 20390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thesaurus Software Ltd user:czarkoff 12:29, 4 August 2012 (UTC) delete or should I say ''kill it with fire''? |Unambiguously non-notable |B2B |company. — Deletion of Thesaurus Software Ltd WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:B2B||WP:NBIZ Wikipedia:Notability 77
4295 6410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of IT Companies in Tamil Nadu User:Stifle 19:41, 29 December 2008 (UTC) delete per items 1-5 Deletion of List of IT Companies in Tamil Nadu WP:LC Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
4296 17156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MYNAH Technologies User:Czarkoff 03:52, 18 February 2012 (UTC) delete a |division of North American distributor of another company's |simulation software for the process automation industry. Hope at least ''they'' know the meaning of this phrase. &mdash Deletion of MYNAH Technologies WP:CORP||WP:B2B Wikipedia:Notability 77
4297 4795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asif Group of Companies User:HighKing 12:25, 16 August 2017 (UTC) delete I agree, fails and no secondary sources can be found Deletion of Asif Group of Companies WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4298 3457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bad pie User:HisSpaceResearch 12:12, 28 January 2008 (UTC) delete per , , , . This should be easy Deletion of Bad pie WP:V||WP:NEO||WP:WINAD||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4299 7089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artard User:Flakeloaf 18:28, 18 January 2007 (UTC) delete per . At best it's cruft Deletion of Artard WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
4300 7167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jay Jason User:Bearian 18:02, 16 January 2012 (UTC) keep per despite the obvious and admitted issue Deletion of Jay Jason WP:GNG||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
4301 16670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bangsai F.C. User:Fenix 08:27, 31 August 2017 (UTC) delete fails , has not participated in a national competition. No indication of wider GNG Deletion of Bangsai F.C. WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
4302 398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gordon Adomdza User:The 12:56, 7 March 2019 (UTC) delete this |unsourced, |promotional text about a non-|Wikinotable businessman Deletion of Gordon Adomdza WP:PRIMARY||WP:PROMO||WP:NPERSON Wikipedia:No original research 65
4303 19779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ESwiki User:Joe 21:39, 14 December 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |website Deletion of ESwiki WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4304 98 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tsolak MLKE-Galstyan User:Netherzone 16:49, 6 May 2020 (UTC) delete I could not find enough to establish notability as per guidelines , or Deletion of Tsolak MLKE-Galstyan WP:ARTIST||WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4305 3902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lilia Mai (2nd nomination) User:Eggishorn 01:47, 8 May 2018 (UTC) delete The links that can be considered significant coverage in the article are all press releases or otherwise non-independent coverage. No evidence in article or in searches that this singer qualifies under or Deletion of Lilia Mai (2nd nomination) WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4306 10065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Misty Plowright (2nd nomination) User:Arthistorian1977 13:24, 29 November 2016 (UTC) keep since passing , does not apply here Deletion of Misty Plowright (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
4307 13238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bayard Bridge User:Icewedge 07:16, 22 November 2008 (UTC) delete its just a bridge, small span and likely very low cost. No reliable sources, does not meet the criteria at Deletion of Bayard Bridge WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4308 7383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pungle User:SL93 20:46, 17 April 2012 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Pungle WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4309 7506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lyrics007 User:Spiderone 18:43, 21 February 2021 (UTC) delete fails as this website does not appear to have received significant coverage from multiple reliable sources under either of its names Deletion of Lyrics007 WP:WEBCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4310 16913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/25dates.com User:Terence 14:49, 6 January 2007 (UTC) delete advertisement, fails Deletion of 25dates.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4311 13168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maurice Jay User:MichaelQSchmidt 06:49, 22 October 2010 (UTC) keep per subject meeting notability for various projects through . As the article now belongs to Wikipedia, concerns with COI are best addressed in this case by author being cautioned and article being sent to cleanup Deletion of Maurice Jay WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4312 75 [[LANE]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:KaiMartin NONE comment """Das Problem besteht darin, dass die QS eine erhebliche inhaltliche Verbesserung wie sie hier erforderlich wäre, um zu einem akzeptablen Artikel zu gelangen, #Aufgaben|nicht leisten kann. Im aktuellen Zustand ist der Artikel nicht nur für die Oma unverständlich. Er erklärt schlicht das Lemma nicht. Es wird lediglich mit wenig aussagekräftigen, dafür POV-getränkten Formulierungen das Anwendungsfeld umrissen (""""die heute zunehmend Einzug ins LAN findet"""", """"erfordert vollkommen neue Netzwerkfunktionalitäten""""). Quellen sind in keiner Form vorhanden. Frist, um beides zu ändern""" Löschung von LANE Wikipedia:QS Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
4313 3134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Georgia car insurance requirements User:Kinu 01:24, 11 August 2012 (UTC) delete contravenes , no evidence that this is encyclopedic material Deletion of Georgia car insurance requirements WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4314 11702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magdalen Berns User:Accesscrawl 13:14, 30 September 2019 (UTC) keep Coverage exists for more than one event and it appears significant. Weeks ago the article might have been deleted per , though not anymore Deletion of Magdalen Berns WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4315 13296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Squares User:Royboycrashfan 05:05, 5 April 2006 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of The Squares WP:MUSIC||WP:VANITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4316 1607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K. Prasad Babu User:Anir1uph 11:53, 3 June 2014 (UTC) keep WP:ANYBIO and/or would apply as the article's subject was awarded Ashok Chakra, India's highest peace time gallantry award. Also may not apply as the subject is not a living person, hence the article is not a Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons|BLP. Apart from that, I do not see any paucity of sources as the person received enough coverage in regional and national publications, but all of these may not be in English (which is never an issue Deletion of K. Prasad Babu WP:MILPEOPLE||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
4317 9792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcus Fenix User:Comandante42 19:26, 9 May 2008 (UTC) merge per above; also, the article is mainly |gamecruft, and much of the content merely reiterates the plot of Gears of War Deletion of Marcus Fenix WP:GAMECRUFT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
4318 518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Venda Wikipedia User:Northamerica1000 07:27, 21 April 2017 (UTC) merge to List of Wikipedias as a valid search term (-R). Source searches are not providing any significant coverage in RS; fails Deletion of Venda Wikipedia WP:ATD||WP:N Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
4319 12624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Klarna User:BabbaQ 14:57, 8 April 2016 (UTC) keep The topic passes . Swedens best known e-commerce company Deletion of Klarna WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
4320 19912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bees Bagla User:Spiderone 08:58, 30 November 2020 (UTC) keep passes as per the two editors above; the OR should be removed after this AfD concludes but let's Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater|not throw the baby out with the bathwater Deletion of Bees Bagla WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4321 18104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Louis Robinson (rugby league) User:J 18:39, 12 December 2014 (UTC) delete Fails . Sources provided consist of either trivial mentions of the player or |routine coverage Deletion of Louis Robinson (rugby league) WP:RLN||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4322 7760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Čair User:ThePlatypusofDoom 14:27, 26 April 2016 (UTC) keep """on the basis that """"Too short to be included"""" is not a valid reason. See """ Deletion of Ali Čair WP:AFDISNTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4323 11377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ogre (2017 video game) User:Jovanmilic97 12:12, 10 March 2020 (UTC) merge to Ogre (game)#Video games section that is currently empty and should cover both this and Ogre (video game) as two of the video game adaptations. Besides the Digitally Downloaded review mentioned, I found a interview on Pocket Gamer https://www.pocketgamer.com/articles/075353/we-talk-with-steve-jackson-and-auroch-digital-about-the-upcoming-adaptation-of-classic-board-game-ogre/, an article on Rock Paper Shotgun that is weak coverage wise and doesn't go indepth about the game itself despite the text size https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2017/10/06/steve-jackson-ogre-game-released/ (plus only written by a contributor), and some development bits on GamesRadar+ https://www.gamesradar.com/when-star-wars-was-new-making-ogre-steve-jacksons-40-year-old-board-game-for-pc/ with Kickstarter/release announcements. All in all, it doesn't pass . Per , a section that covers this and the 1986 game (no opinion on whether that too should be merged for now), is enough to details of what seems to be a low buzz release Deletion of Ogre (2017 video game) WP:PRIMARY||WP:ROUTINE||WP:GNG||WP:ATD||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:No original research 65
4324 16872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arun (actor) User:Cewbot 00:03, 17 November 2020 (UTC) comment This nomination has had limited participation and falls within the standards set for |lack of quorum. There are no previous AfD discussions, undeletions, or current redirects and no previous PRODs have been located. This nomination may be '''eligible for |soft deletion''' at the end of its 7-day listing Deletion of Arun (actor) WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
4325 20492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucas Joseph User:SeannyFunco 19:59, 14 March 2006 (UTC) delete non-notable, fails , a promotional tool Deletion of Lucas Joseph WP:MUSIC||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4326 15241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gold gate casino User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable. &mdash Deletion of Gold gate casino WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4327 8196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uwe jarling User:Mousey NONE comment """Somewhat, it seems. 18,000 Google hits (with """"""""), and most of them are of artist galleries, shows, awards, ect. A couple are MySpace-y sites, so those wouldn't fall under |the notability standards""" Deletion of Uwe jarling WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4328 17030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Rizzono User:MPJ 18:20, 6 May 2007 (UTC) keep Fullfills in addition to and just to cover all the bases, in it's current form it's actually a good Wikipedia entry Deletion of Steve Rizzono WP:N||WP:BLP||WP:A Wikipedia:Notability 77
4329 20068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bony (2020 film) User:Clovermoss 01:38, 25 December 2019 (UTC) keep The Times of India source linked to by {{u|Czar}} shows that principal photography has commenced so it meets Deletion of Bony (2020 film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
4330 10208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hue-man Cao User:Adamant1 18:53, 3 November 2020 (UTC) delete She seems to fail both the notability guidelines for football players and like GiantSnowman say's, more importantly she fails Deletion of Hue-man Cao WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4331 2479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of common phrases in various languages (second nomination) User:Ohconfucius 02:48, 1 September 2006 (UTC) delete """It is a scope problem and has to go. """"Wikipedia articles are not... a usage guide or slang and idiom guide"""". Whilst I find it potentially useful, this article is very clearly outside the scope of wiki per . I am very tickled by the inclusion of Scottish, which I think is omplete bollocks|complete bollocks, as it is the transliteration of what a particular regional Scottish accent. Wiki is also an indiscriminate collection of information. Aside from the main recognised languages, dialects and regional accents abound. Editors have obvious difficulty drawing the line at pidgin english, or pidgin French. We have included the main Chinese dialects, but there are tens of others. Now what about Brummie, Scouse or Geordie accents, for example""" Deletion of List of common phrases in various languages (second nomination) WP:NOT||WP:C||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4332 17326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sir William Arbuthnot, 2nd Baronet User:Vintagekits 20:34, 27 April 2007 (UTC) comment """I have been a bit OTT so far in this AfD with regards my challenging of editors to explain their """"keep"""" !votes - yes this is a discussion and I am gully entitled to do this however I feel I may have gone to far but this was only in the interests of having a proper debate and not allowing some editors to rely on on and rather to base their !votes on wikipolcy. Over the past number of months a number of editors have been abusing the AfD process, canvassing and vote stacking - they have all appeared here again. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Robert_Murray_Arbuthnot This is a prime example of what I am talking about and I have added fuller details on the talk page of this AfD. Again sorry for going OTT here but if you had you put up with months of systematic abuse you might know how I feel. I am going to take a break from this page now an lie down - aaaaaah! regards""" Deletion of Sir William Arbuthnot, 2nd Baronet WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4333 2944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Babylon 5: The Passing of the Techno-Mages – Casting Shadows User:Joe 05:28, 6 July 2014 (UTC) delete I did the usual range of searches, and don't see the sourcing we'd need to meet Deletion of Babylon 5: The Passing of the Techno-Mages – Casting Shadows WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4334 10284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayou Trikerioti User:MichaelQSchmidt 03:13, 31 May 2010 (UTC) comment While the lack of available English coverage for this individual's career in film and theater apparently fails , if a Greek-reading Wikipedian cares to start digging through these 7,000 results,http://www.google.com/search?q=%22%CE%9C%CE%B1%CE%B3%CE%B9%CE%BF%CF%8D+%CE%A4%CF%81%CE%B9%CE%BA%CE%B5%CF%81%CE%B9%CF%8E%CF%84%CE%B7%22&sourceid=ie7&rls=com.microsoft:en-US&ie=utf8&oe=utf8 I'd like to learn if there is a notabiity in Greece that is not being revealed in my English-laguage searches. And to the nom: your friend's adventures aside, costume designers can indeed be notable.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marilyn_Vance Deletion of Mayou Trikerioti WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4335 14911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chen Bing User:Takeaway 00:24, 9 October 2014 (UTC) delete Until this singer has a significant hit in music charts, she fails Deletion of Chen Bing WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
4336 10941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hadelin de Ponteves User:Iqra 17:58, 17 November 2020 (UTC) keep Clearly passes the as sources provide significant coverage in reliable sources. The references in no way look like Press release articles to me and address the person directly and in detail Deletion of Hadelin de Ponteves WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4337 14469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of downloadable songs for Rocksmith User:Ferret 22:48, 30 June 2017 (UTC) keep This is essentially valid PAGESIZE content fork for a list/table split from the main article(s) due to size. In addition, even as a standalone list, it should pass , as reliable sources regularly have covered the DLC releases of the game: https://www.engadget.com/2013/11/27/radiohead-dlc-creeps-onto-rocksmith-2014s-setlist/https://www.gamespot.com/articles/rocksmith-2014-adds-smashing-pumpkins-dlc/1100-6415857/http://www.vg247.com/2013/08/12/rocksmith-2014-edition-can-import-past-tracks-and-dlc-uses-same-cable/https://www.engadget.com/2013/11/17/alice-in-chains-dlc-strums-along-with-rocksmith-2014/https://www.engadget.com/2014/04/17/the-latest-rocksmith-2014-dlc-is-garbage-in-a-good-way/https://www.engadget.com/2014/04/17/the-latest-rocksmith-2014-dlc-is-garbage-in-a-good-way/https://www.destructoid.com/muse-dlc-comes-to-rocksmith-2014-267904.phtmlhttps://www.destructoid.com/iron-maiden-gallops-onto-rocksmith-2014-as-dlc-264953.phtmlhttps://www.engadget.com/2014/01/22/say-it-aint-so-rocksmith-2014-adds-weezer-dlc/https://www.polygon.com/2013/11/26/5149430/rocksmith-2014-dlc-adds-five-radiohead-songshttp://www.shacknews.com/article/84594/cake-delivers-a-rockin-five-pack-to-rocksmiths-dlchttp://www.shacknews.com/article/86114/rocksmith-2014-gets-sublime-dlc-packhttps://www.polygon.com/2013/11/13/5100258/rocksmith-2014-alice-in-chains-dlc-launches-for-select-platformshttps://www.engadget.com/2014/02/05/rocksmith-is-losing-its-religion-gaining-rem-dlc/http://www.digitalspy.com/gaming/news/a437969/rocksmith-alternate-rock-dlc-pack-is-out-now/. This was just 3 pages into over 100,000 results in /RS's reliable source custom search. This article is watched over by several established editors, as far as the COI/N post goes (As are most of the articles noted there Deletion of List of downloadable songs for Rocksmith WP:LISTN||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4338 3408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC 158 User:TreyGeek 13:54, 21 December 2012 (UTC) comment The keep arguments have failed to address issues with this article, particularly in light of other recent AfDs in which future UFC events were deleted. Also the article currently fails due to its lack of well-sourced prose; it has practically no prose. I would advice those wishing to keep the article would do better to write actual prose discussing the background of the event thus far as it would bolster any notability arguments they are attempting to make Deletion of UFC 158 WP:SPORTSEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4339 2529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LAGbook User:GabrielF 19:59, 1 July 2013 (UTC) delete this article has a long history of problems. Lagbook was deleted twice in February 2012 as unambiguous advertising. The article was recreated as LAGbook and had significant issues with sourcing. Particularly troubling was the company's tendency to make claims that were reprinted in the Nigerian media but were either grossly inflated or taken out of context or untrue. My favorite examples: the company claimed to have partnered with Dropbox when, if you read what they were claiming to have done carefully, it sounded like they had just plunked down $100 on Dropbox for Teams and called that a partnership. Similarly, the article claimed that Lagbook had been covered by TechCrunch, but when you read the TechCrunch article it was about a completely different company, GROUPS.PS, which makes a white-label social networking service and only briefly mentioned Lagbook as one of the users of that service. There were other s, at the time I first CSD'd Lagbook, the company's logo was identical to Facebook's except that it was green instead of blue and used a lowercase l instead of a lowercase f. So I was not at all surprised when the creators of Lagbook put the website for sale and then the purchaser of Lagbook came forward and said that the founders were making false claims about the business and hijacking the purchaser's social media accounts. You can read the details at Talk:LAGbook. The sources that we have are primarily Nigerian media (The Vanguard and the National Mirror). Given that these sources have printed inaccurate claims from the Lagbook founders without doing any kind of independent research, I think they need to be discounted as unreliable. What that leaves us with is a website that sold for $10,000https://flippa.com/2867569-pr-4-social-network-with-750k-registered-members-124k-uniques-mo-making-693-mo, ranked around 18,000 on Alexa at its best and is now defunct. I don't see any notability here but I am worried that the founders are using Wikipedia as a vehicle for dishonest self-promotion Deletion of LAGbook WP:REDFLAG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4340 21629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tolka Rovers F.C. User:RadioFan 12:04, 16 October 2009 (UTC) comment that is an essay, has it reached consensus yet? I see lots of discussion on it but the tag on it indicates that it's not moved beyond an essay state. If so, should link to it as another source for sporting notability guidelines Deletion of Tolka Rovers F.C. WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4341 7676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fag bangle User:Huon 22:05, 15 September 2007 (UTC) delete """the reasons are probably best explained by contrasting it to fag hag: That article has multiple sources ''discussing'' the term, at least some of which seem to be published in scientific journals, while this has Urban Dictionary and a few passing mentions in the press. There seem to be no further sources available; Google gives rather few hits, most of them forums, none (that I looked at) reliable sources. Google Scholar and Google Books both came up empty. For comparison, """"fag hag"""" gets 138 and 600 hits, respectively. It's clearly a |neologism that hasn't found wide use""" Deletion of Fag bangle WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
4342 8620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Vault User:Cwmhiraeth 12:32, 24 January 2017 (UTC) delete as a company that fails Deletion of Star Vault WP:NCOMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4343 3142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Georgia United States Senate election, 2010 User:Otto4711 13:27, 28 October 2007 (UTC) delete until such time as there is maybe a declared candidate. At the very least the list of potential candidates needs to be deleted as Deletion of Georgia United States Senate election, 2010 WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4344 19805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Business gold coast User:Ravenswing 16:37, 28 July 2008 (UTC) delete as . I'm surprised it wasn't speedied Deletion of Business gold coast WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
4345 1417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adana-Mersin metropolitan area User:onel5969 02:00, 31 December 2020 (UTC) delete nothing to indicate this article is about a place that meets Deletion of Adana-Mersin metropolitan area WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4346 11212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K2GXT User:Nsk92 13:32, 15 July 2008 (UTC) delete A non-notable student club with no coverage by independent reliable sources. Fails and Deletion of K2GXT WP:ORG||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4347 9638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Besuds User:Ansh666 17:14, 16 June 2013 (UTC) merge to Behsud (Hazara tribe). Unsourced, at best Deletion of Besuds WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4348 21295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poetic Flow User:Causesobad 15:32, 15 February 2007 (UTC) delete fails , Deletion of Poetic Flow WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4349 17322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elftor User:Reyk 01:35, 28 May 2006 (UTC) delete yet more pointless webcomic-cruft. Doesn't meet Deletion of Elftor WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4350 19393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vlad Dragomir User:Fenix 07:23, 30 June 2015 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG. The move to Arsenal is not notable in itself, he has merely joined the academy along with a host of other non-notable prospects Deletion of Vlad Dragomir WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4351 20082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pamela Wilson User:E 17:42, 14 May 2019 (UTC) delete """this """"Expert, Advocate and Speaker"""" as mere PROMO for a self-promoting owner of a home care agency. she wrote a How-to book about homecare, which sank with hardly a ripple. Fails """ Deletion of Pamela Wilson WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
4352 6855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Badro User:TravisTX 20:04, 10 January 2008 (UTC) delete per #G3 - this is pure vandalism. Examples: he was educated at the ”school for armchair testing” and he holds a record in long-distance napping. See Deletion of James Badro WP:CSD||WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
4353 19384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mireia Castane User:Jreferee 06:52, 2 September 2007 (UTC) delete There is not enought |reliable source material independent of Mireia Castane to write a Wikipedia article on Castane Deletion of Mireia Castane WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4354 16297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nature of life User:Stalwart111 05:02, 20 August 2014 (UTC) delete per . Pretty simple really Deletion of Nature of life WP:ESSAY Wikipedia:Essays 31
4355 15427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ATCO Field User:Levivich 19:37, 15 May 2019 (UTC) merge """to Spruce Meadows per . """"ATCO Field"""" is a useful search term, but the content should be a section of Spruce Meadows rather than a stand-alone article, per the merge arguments above and the sources (which focus more on """"Spruce Meadows"""" and the """"Cavalry FC"""" than on """"ATCO Field""" Deletion of ATCO Field WP:PAGEDECIDE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4356 859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Later-no-harm criterion User:Ihcoyc 15:09, 8 March 2007 (UTC) keep """These appear to be articles that have to do with the mathematics of voting, which is the subject of a good deal of interest. I'd be inclined to refer this matter to an expert on these topics; there may be a better name for this, and it lacks context and is not clearly written. I am not convinced yet that these articles are |original research and they pass my own """"smell"""" test""" Deletion of Later-no-harm criterion WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4357 19016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellipsis Entertainment User:HighKing 13:30, 31 January 2018 (UTC) delete No indications of notability, topic fails GNG and , no references available that meet the criteria for establishing notability Deletion of Ellipsis Entertainment WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4358 11432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zack Niizato User:Michitaro 12:59, 5 October 2015 (UTC) delete """I cannot find anything on him in Japanese. Part of the problem is that I'm not sure of the kanji for his name, but 新里栄作 is the most likely and I cannot find anything with that. I tried other variations with no success. So the only thing left is to see if there is anything significant in Spanish, which seems to be the language he has mostly been working in. But I can't seem to find any RS there as well, though I will defer to someone who can. Otherwise, the roles he has played (""""Japanese student"""") aren't likely enough to clear """ Deletion of Zack Niizato WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
4359 17784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dead Swans User:Doomgaze 22:58, 12 April 2011 (UTC) comment I've also found live reviews in ''Rock Sound'' issues June 2008 and February 2010, album reviews March 2008, April 2008 and September 2009 and a 4 paragraph feature March 2008, in addition to the full page interview I mentioned above (and I actually cannot be bothered to find any more). So yeah, guidelines easily passed Deletion of Dead Swans WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4360 21854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Felicity Barrington User:Dhartung 23:44, 28 June 2007 (UTC) delete """In December 2007...."""" I've never seen a bio violate before. Or shall we wait until then in case it's verifiable""" Deletion of Felicity Barrington WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4361 15911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/West Huaxia Road (Shanghai Metro) User:Pzoxicuvybtnrm 23:26, 8 April 2011 (UTC) keep Metro stations are notable per and . There is a large precedent on this, as many other such articles exist. — Deletion of West Huaxia Road (Shanghai Metro) WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4362 14089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Gregory Barbarigo School (2nd nomination) User:Kudpung 09:43, 6 September 2015 (UTC) merge of course as per age-old practice and precedent as documented at and probably nearly 1,000 AfD closures Deletion of St. Gregory Barbarigo School (2nd nomination) WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
4363 19553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black & White Publishing User:AllyD 14:31, 11 February 2021 (UTC) keep The references added by {{u|Mutt Lunker}} since this AfD began indicate a breadth of attention for the activities of this publisher and their main imprint, which I think is enough for Deletion of Black & White Publishing :WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4364 5543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willow Ridge User:Black 07:17, 25 February 2007 (UTC) delete """per . A gang with 32,000 members and no sources (all ghits for '+""""Willow Ridge"""" +gang -Wikipedia' seem to be about places called Willow Ridge)? Also, they killed 79 people with only 72 bullets (was there a shortage of ammunition)? Can snipers even achieve this""" Deletion of Willow Ridge WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
4365 17791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Facts about foxgloves User:LinaMishima 13:41, 21 August 2006 (UTC) delete I normally merge such things, but no references for style comments means can't keep Deletion of Facts about foxgloves WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4366 534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AAPLAC User:MER 05:33, 6 January 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of AAPLAC WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4367 4123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chailie Ho User:CaliforniaAliBaba 01:13, 7 August 2010 (UTC) delete per the lack of significant coverage in |reliable sources. I have reviewed Deletion of Chailie Ho WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4368 1276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rod of Seven Parts (2nd nomination) User:Lankiveil 13:18, 24 December 2007 (UTC) delete it's bad form to renom so quickly, but while we're here I think that it's worth pointing out that this particular artefact does not appear to have any notability outside of the D&D universe. Wikipedia is a roleplaying source book Deletion of Rod of Seven Parts (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4369 14482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiago Ghidotti User:DoubleGrazing 08:33, 18 December 2020 (UTC) delete Pure vanity piece about a non-notable individual, fails with flying colours, despite the valiant refbombing efforts Deletion of Tiago Ghidotti WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4370 3697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teenager Liebe User:Tokyogirl79 13:56, 27 January 2012 (UTC) merge The big problem here is that there's a language barrier as well as a time period one. Music reviews from the 80s aren't typically uploaded to the internet and since there's a language barrier, searching for sources isn't proving particularly fruitful for me. I'm seeing tons of fan pages and other non-usable sources, but nothing that would get this song to pass . I do think that a redirect would be worthwhile, though. I'd say that it should go to the EP it was released on, but I don't see any sources on the album and I'm a little afraid of it getting deleted itself. If anyone with better German skills than I possess can find sources, I'm open to changing my vote Deletion of Teenager Liebe WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4371 37 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Hill Bill Show User:Ydam 11:01, 13 June 2006 (UTC) delete per failure of , even then notability would be questionable Deletion of The Hill Bill Show WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4372 7054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rabble User:UkPaolo 23:32, 7 March 2006 (UTC) keep seems to meet with some press coverage. Large userbase too. Potential bad faith nomination Deletion of Rabble WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4373 14331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Mashamaite [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 13:34, 19 February 2014 (UTC) delete Fails . Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Daniel Mashamaite WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
4374 911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kessler-Standard User:FreplySpang 18:59, 15 May 2006 (UTC) delete WP:NOR|original research. Subjects must be |verifiable by |reliable sources. When people outside this local group write articles about this standard, we'll have an article about it. Wikipedia isn't the place to promote new ways of doing things Deletion of Kessler-Standard WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4375 8001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Progressoft User:GRBerry 02:51, 19 May 2006 (UTC) comment an important part of the claim to fame that is found in the reference was omitted in the redraft. This is only the first such software developed by a Jordanian company, not the first such software. The article does satisfy point 1 Deletion of Progressoft WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4376 1393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sciona Browne User:Tavix 19:58, 1 November 2008 (UTC) delete as non-notable Survivor contestant. Aside from the winners and two-time players, it is generally been a consensus to delete articles of survivor contestants that are not notable for anything else outside the show because of Deletion of Sciona Browne WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
4377 21622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anime Depression User:Knowledgekid87 04:01, 19 February 2011 (UTC) delete This made me LOL, Anime depression, really? Where was I when this all went down? Anyways delete per Farix Galore Deletion of Anime Depression WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4378 177 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Lingorya Kullanıcı:85.107.117.17285.107.117.172 15:25, 28 Nisan 2015 (UTC) comment Topluluk yönerge teklifine ilgi gösterirse, bunun gibi kayda değer olmayan oyunlar hızlıca değerlendirilebilir. --Özel:Katkılar/85.107.117.172|85.107.117.172 Lingorya'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
4379 20966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Will Brooks (actor) (2nd nomination) User:Craftyminion 03:40, 20 July 2009 (UTC) delete G4. Should speedy be declined then '''delete''' as non-notable and failing Deletion of Will Brooks (actor) (2nd nomination) WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4380 15148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Schedule chicken User:Tavix 21:28, 28 November 2008 (UTC) delete per . Poorly written as well Deletion of Schedule chicken WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
4381 2678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Umar Saif User:ALM 20:20, 27 January 2007 (UTC) delete It fails . Nothing special about this person and have not achieved anything. Doing Phd at young age is not significant and neither is doing post doc from MIT Deletion of Umar Saif WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4382 9741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gamera vs Garasharp User:Iowateen 08:44, 15 July 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Gamera vs Garasharp WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4383 4467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Ouellette User:Ctjf83 15:32, 25 March 2011 (UTC) delete non-notable, fails Deletion of Greg Ouellette WP:NTENNIS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4384 14237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fer Sure (2nd nomination) User:Joe 18:03, 15 November 2015 (UTC) delete I found Arizona press of dubious independence, but not enough to meet Deletion of Fer Sure (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4385 2597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/University Mall (Little Rock, Arkansas) User:JoshuaZ 06:06, 9 November 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. There is nothing notable about this mall. I'm not even sure it meets |verifiability even before we get to notability Deletion of University Mall (Little Rock, Arkansas) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4386 18072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Harrington (2nd nomination) User:4meter4 17:40, 29 September 2019 (UTC) keep per Andrew D. I see no new argument, and consensus at the last AFD that the article meets the criteria at both and is still accurate Deletion of Steve Harrington (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4387 14304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Music Remains the Same: A Tribute to Led Zeppelin User:Colapeninsula 11:39, 24 January 2013 (UTC) keep Meets with significant coverage in reliable sources per above links Deletion of The Music Remains the Same: A Tribute to Led Zeppelin WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4388 18563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andreas Teuber (Second Nomination) User:Richardcavell 00:16, 16 March 2007 (UTC) comment I Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andreas Teuber|speedy deleted the first article that was written under this name because the text of the article was originally published under a copyright message on a University's website. It was also written by the subject of the article. A new article now exists on the same topic, written by a different author. The present problem for this AfD, on the new article, is notability under . If the nominator' attempt to withdraw is valid, then I nominate this new article myself ''pro forma'' in order to allow the AfD to run its course on notability concerns. I reserve my judgment on it Deletion of Andreas Teuber (Second Nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4389 33 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Sobel User:AllyD 06:12, 23 September 2014 (UTC) delete Fails as a local councillor and candidate. The individual points in what amounts to a CV are not in themselves sufficient for biographical notability, nor is the local media coverage; fails Deletion of Alex Sobel :WP:POLITICIAN||:WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4390 3260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Ozanne User:Crusio 20:34, 8 February 2009 (UTC) delete For someone who did his PhD 20 years ago, his scientific production and citation counts are very low. Does not meet Deletion of Adam Ozanne WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4391 277 [[Flexsys]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Tom_md NONE delete Nun, der erste Fehler ist, dass Du den Artikel einfach kommentarlos wiedereingestellt hast, obwohl er schon mal als Werbeeintrag gelöscht wurde. Der zweite Fehler ist, dasd Du für Unternehmen nicht gelesen hast und somit keine Aussagen zur Relevanz machst und der dritte Fehler ist, dass Du hier mit dem Finger auf Andere zeigtst. Alles in allem Löschung von Flexsys Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4392 215 [[Orth (Band)]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Wangen NONE delete Erfüllt die nicht, zudem Text voller POV, dafür ohne harte Fakten Löschung von Orth (Band) Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4393 21584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D Michelle Gent User:Tokyogirl79 18:42, 25 February 2012 (UTC) delete Gent does not pass the guidelines for either or . I went through the sources on the articles and the ones that I left are trivial at most and do not show how Gent is any more notable than any other locally elected politician. As far as writing goes, there's nothing out there to show that Gent has any notability Deletion of D Michelle Gent WP:AUTHOR||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
4394 1241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hosted Network User:Trysha 18:36, 17 December 2014 (UTC) delete A non-notable company that fails . Seems like an advertisement. Nothing in the media seems to have ever referenced this company other than their own press releases Deletion of Hosted Network WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4395 5133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Occupation symbols User:Colonel 11:53, 26 December 2009 (UTC) keep The matter is highly notable and I had no difficulty finding a recent news source which comments extensively upon this topic following the recent passage of another law about this matter in Poland. The claims of synthesis seem weak and have not been raised as an issue at the article's talk page. Failure to resolve such issues at the article before bringing the matter here is contrary to our |deletion policy Deletion of Occupation symbols WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4396 8228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drop the T User:Spinningspark 08:24, 22 May 2019 (UTC) comment """I !voted """"keep"""" above, but would also support a merge that d the existing material""" Deletion of Drop the T WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
4397 16000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Persecution of Serbs and other non-Albanians in Kosovo User:Howicus 16:39, 20 February 2013 (UTC) delete Yes, there are many references in this article that are from reliable sources. However, these sources are used to make a non- list that also fails . Given the immense amount of contention between some of the pro-Albanian and pro-Serbian editors here, including socking, accusations of socking, personal attacks, and miscellaneous uncivility, I doubt that this article could ''ever'' be neutral Deletion of Persecution of Serbs and other non-Albanians in Kosovo WP:NPOV||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
4398 4386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amel bouchoucha User:JohnCD 16:48, 8 August 2010 (UTC) delete not enough to meet or Deletion of Amel bouchoucha WP:MUSICBIO||WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
4399 11259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dispute about Jesus' execution method User:History2007 22:54, 28 February 2012 (UTC) comment Based on the user talk page link provided by AuthorityTam above, this seems like a clear case of '''| 2.d''': i.e. ''nominations that are clearly an attempt to end an editing dispute through deletion'', given that the nominator stated that he would prefer deletion over article improvement via consensus Deletion of Dispute about Jesus' execution method WP:SK Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
4400 634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gigablast (2nd nomination) User:Unforgettableid 18:27, 2 September 2013 (UTC) delete This article was copied into mainspace by Wiki12rt, a |single-purpose account (SPA) almost surely affiliated with Gigablast. The |COI SPA has violated Wikipedia community norms both while putting the article into mainspace and afterwards. The article needs work, in Macrakis's user space, before we can even consider whether or not it is acceptable in mainspace. For now, it reads like a press release and seems more like one-sided journalism than balanced journalism. Please delete per |CSD G11 for now. If Wiki12rt leaves Wikipedia, never to return, then perhaps we can work further on the article in userspace then discuss whether it's acceptable in mainspace or not. Cheers, &mdash Deletion of Gigablast (2nd nomination) WP:SPA||WP:COI||WP:G11 Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
4401 9233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oceania (Smashing Pumpkins album) User:Darwin 19:48, 28 April 2011 (UTC) keep The album has been announced and has been reported by authentic sources. Although a tracklisting has yet to be announced, this page doesn't violate any other of |TenPoundHammer's Laws. It has a title, a release date and is not referenced from information off rumors posted to message boards, blogs or MySpace. The information has been reported from a reputable source, i.e. ''Rolling Stone'' magazine, with which the reference is currently included in the article Deletion of Oceania (Smashing Pumpkins album) WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
4402 2598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HandWiki User:David 05:39, 7 September 2020 (UTC) delete """no evidence of passing . The only independent sources I could find for anything by this name were for a small, defunct and unrelated 2012 """"handwiki"""" project of the American Society for Surgery of the Hand. Becoming big by making a copy of Wikipedia is not cause for notability; it just means you're a scraper""" Deletion of HandWiki WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4403 16517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aileen G. Baron User:Aeternitas827 08:03, 13 December 2007 (UTC) delete this one will likely need extensive research before it can become an article, and as it's written we probably have issues with (not NPOV Deletion of Aileen G. Baron WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4404 12892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WECAN at West Virginia University User:Marcusmax 02:32, 16 September 2009 (UTC) delete Its nice don't get me wrong, well written, factual etc. but it is also an essay and wikipedia is |not a place to write personal essays Deletion of WECAN at West Virginia University WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4405 188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Top Hat Willy (2nd nomination) user:Hellknowz 10:00, 3 May 2019 (UTC) delete as a non-notable video game failing with no reliable independent in-depth sources, such as /RS. — Deletion of Top Hat Willy (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4406 16056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dogs (Call of Duty) User:Spongefrog 21:56, 19 December 2009 (UTC) delete """Complete violation and . I think you may even have gotten away with a PROD there. Features of video games don't get their own articles, unless they're particularly notable for some reason (actually, the only one I can think of is Hot Coffee minigame controversy, but I don't know if this counts). Considering it exists in several games, a redirect would be tricky, so I'd suggest adding in a sentence or two about it into the related article (if it doesn't already exist). The Call of Duty (series) article doesn't have a """"Common gameplay elements"""" section or anything, it's really just an overview of the games released. Even if there was, I think it'd be to minor a feature. Sorry for the length of this !vote""" Deletion of Dogs (Call of Duty) WP:GAMEGUIDE||WP:GAMETRIVIA Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4407 20305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raccoon City User:Doctorfluffy 18:03, 5 January 2008 (UTC) delete Just a reorganized #PLOT summary and a list of elements of that plot. No real-world context or analysis. Doubtful there is any relevant information to be merged that isn't already included elsewhere in the series' articles Deletion of Raccoon City WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4408 5948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Kirksey User:Sticky 01:28, 22 October 2008 (UTC) delete no notability, probably written by someone with a in my humble opinion Deletion of Lee Kirksey WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
4409 4718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Michael Afable User:onel5969 12:28, 1 November 2015 (UTC) keep He's had significant roles in at least 3 films (''Akeelah and the Bee'', ''To Save a Life'', and ''Hardflip''), to of which are notable by wiki standards, and the third might be. In addition he had a featured, although smaller, role in another notable film, ''Boogie Town''. ''One Warm Night'' was a webseries in which he had the leading role. I didn't do a search for , but to me, he barely squeaks by with this resume as meeting Deletion of Sean Michael Afable WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
4410 5762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FACES User:Joe 15:46, 26 December 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of FACES WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4411 7547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Lords (demogroup) User:Liftarn NONE keep as we have a newspaper article especially noting their sound-chip skills and at least two of their productions was published as covermount of the ''Outlet'' magazine. They thus fulfil Deletion of The Lords (demogroup) WP:NONPROFIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4412 9396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marguerite Humeau User:Arthistorian1977 12:20, 7 July 2016 (UTC) keep With the list of exhibitions and sources, she is definitely passes Deletion of Marguerite Humeau WP:ARTISTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4413 2096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Jensen (musician) (2nd nomination) User:Nnadigoodluck 20:50, 18 October 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Adam Jensen (musician) (2nd nomination) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4414 15922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chicago (Sufjan Stevens song) User:Rlendog 19:36, 11 March 2010 (UTC) merge to Illinois (album). No independent notability, but per , no reason to delete rather than redirect Deletion of Chicago (Sufjan Stevens song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4415 14431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Momma's House 3 User:JuJube 22:40, 25 October 2007 (UTC) delete per and my deep depression in the fact that there was a Big Momma's House ''2 Deletion of Big Momma's House 3 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4416 15664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1692 Subbotina User:Astrocog 14:19, 1 April 2015 (UTC) merge these all fall within the context of Wikipedia:Notability_(astronomical_objects)#Dealing_with_minor_planets|NASTRO's section on dealing with minor planets. Why this particular set for AfD? I don't know. I think some at WP:Astro have argued for keeping dedicated articles for the asteroids with numbers up to 5000 or 10,000 or something, and I'm ok with that as a matter of practice. However, since someone has brought it up here, let's go with the policy. was initiated, originally, in response to an unusual amount of article creation for high-numbered asteroids. In the case of this set, redirecting does no harm, and if/when any particular rocks among them are studied beyond basic parameters, then an individual article can be made. Cheers Deletion of 1692 Subbotina WP:NASTRO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4417 21343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scala, Inc User:Euryalus 10:22, 12 August 2008 (UTC) keep company has been the subject of some limited coverage in reliable secondary sources. The depth of coverage is a bit thin but on balance it appears enough to narrowly meet the criteria of the |notability guideline for companies Deletion of Scala, Inc WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4418 232 [[Deutscher Preis für Nature Writing]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Muns NONE keep Lt. #Literaturpreise|WP:RK sind Literaturpreise relevant, die von staatlichen Institutionen oder von Verlagen nicht für eigene Bücher vergeben werden. Das ist hier gegebene. Bei Literaturpreisen wird Löschung von Deutscher Preis für Nature Writing Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
4419 1812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annie jr User:SlamDiego 13:02, 11 August 2009 (UTC) delete I see no evidence of sufficient |“notability” for a separate article. Possibly Annie (musical)|the article on the original musical should make some reference to this adaptation Deletion of Annie jr WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4420 15405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/South Tibet User:Peterkingiron 21:15, 31 March 2007 (UTC) keep Having looked at various articles, I am convinced that this article merits inclusion. The problem is that it needs some one who can provide a to it and Arunachal Pradesh making clear what the current ''de facto'' position is, based on the ceasefire line after the Indo-Chinese War. The maps provided do not make this clear to me. The arguments about the adoption of Christianity whether freely chosen (my guess) or forcably (as some apparently allege), which appear in the Arunachal Pradesh talk page clearly show that the whole issue is one on which there are some very strong feelings Deletion of South Tibet WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
4421 14307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David C. Teague (2nd nomination) User:Quantpole 10:29, 17 June 2010 (UTC) delete """Does not appear to have had significant roles, which is why there isn't significant coverage in reliable sources. I thought the credits as a director might be good, except that IMDB lists most of these as """"uncredited"""" or """"unknown episodes"""" (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0172052/fullcredits#cast, http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0117947/fullcredits#cast etc). Maybe they were significant roles, maybe they weren't, but without |verifiable information we cannot know. By all means put it in incubation to see if better sources are available, but it shouldn't be brought back to mainspace unless those sources are found""" Deletion of David C. Teague (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4422 21821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of gangs in the Saints Row series User:Claritas 15:26, 18 June 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of gangs in the Saints Row series WP:GAMEGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4423 16425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quicksort implementations User:Allan 18:09, 15 February 2006 (UTC) delete or '''move to WikiBooks''' — #Wikipedia is not a mirror or a repository of links, images, or media files|Wikipedia is not a code repository Deletion of Quicksort implementations WP:WWIN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4424 8646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coffee consumption in Uruguay User:Shawn 18:18, 15 November 2016 (UTC) delete """the mere consumption of coffee on a by-country basis has no encyclopedic value from what I can see. (Actually, I see does ''not'' cover this, as the info here ''is'' properly presented -- but it's still unencyclopedic imo. Wikipedia is a gazetteer of certain things, such as all species or named places, but the logical extension of this for a multitude of """"Fooian food consumption in Fooian country"""" articles is clearly not a good idea""" Deletion of Coffee consumption in Uruguay WP:NOTSTATSBOOK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4425 12259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shehzad Ghias Shaikh User:Wiki 19:20, 5 March 2017 (UTC) delete I can see that this person is a comedian who tells jokes and that some of them have landed him temporary media attention. However, there is ''no evidence in this article so far'' which would make him appear notable enough to have a Wikipedia article. Furthermore, the article does not pass and . Wikipedia:Signatures Deletion of Shehzad Ghias Shaikh WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4426 220 [[Wikipedia:ELKE]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Manuel Heinemann NONE keep """Auch beim vorhergehenden ELKE - Löschantrag vermeinte sich der Antragersteller am Pranger: /13. August 2008#Wikipedia:ELKE (erledigt, LA entfernt). Er wurde auf die Möglichkeit der Entfernung der ihn betreffenden Einträge hingewiesen. Davon machte er Gebrauch und alles war gut. Das seit dem keine (?) Einträge gelöscht wurden, zeigt das die Bmeisten ''ELKE-Träger'' sich nicht ehrverletzend gedümitgt sehen. ELKE hat den positiven Effekt der Selbstreinigung und -kritik. Empfindliche Gemüter können """"ihre Punkte"""" gerne löschen lassen." Löschung von Wikipedia:ELKE Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4427 13302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Linton Robinson User:Starblind 02:17, 27 February 2010 (UTC) delete per , , and , with a nod toward as well. And yes, Dustry, that is how it works: if something cannot be sourced to reliable sources, it cannot be in Wikipedia. This applies to every type of article, but |biographies of living people are especially important to source correctly Deletion of Linton Robinson WP:BIO||WP:N||WP:V||WP:COI||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4428 16047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Webcomic List User:Dpbsmith 20:17, 14 August 2006 (UTC) delete per nom, unless someone adds some good source citations to |reliable sources that testify to the importance of this site. (Presently, the only sources cited are the site itself!). '''Who,''' exactly, says that this site is important Deletion of The Webcomic List WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4429 4295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DbXpert for Oracle User:Shruti14 18:58, 16 August 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of DbXpert for Oracle WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4430 14056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Davin Wood User:MichaelQSchmidt 05:57, 15 June 2010 (UTC) merge """Interesting case... a composer that does not cut albums, but instead composes music for numerous notable comedy series. It would then seem he does meet #10: """"''Has performed music for a work of media that is notable, e.g. a theme for a network television show''"""". For instances such as his, guideline recommends a redirect and """"mention"""". So how about to either cult favorites ''Tim and Eric Awesome Show, Great Job!'' or ''Tom Goes to the Mayor''? And yes, while I have myself worked on both series, I do not personally know Davin""" Deletion of Davin Wood WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4431 8909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dreamers of the Ghetto User:Hydronium 20:36, 20 February 2016 (UTC) merge to Enemy/Lover. While NMUSIC#1 and #11 are possible, none of the other criteria are met and there's barely any coverage of the ''band''. This is reflected in the second paragraph of the ''History'' section, which shows notability of the ''album'', and which would help fill out Enemy/Lover nicely. No objection to a reasonable non-|COATRACK quantity of the first paragraph of the ''History'' section being incorporated into that article for context/background Deletion of Dreamers of the Ghetto WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
4432 16982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Duf Sundheim User:Piotrus 10:41, 22 March 2019 (UTC) delete Failed candidate, party position is not auto-notable, local coverage. at best Deletion of Duf Sundheim WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4433 11914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virginia towing laws User:Stifle 14:53, 19 April 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Virginia towing laws WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
4434 11194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michele Besso User:Agent 19:57, 27 September 2006 (UTC) delete Does not really meet and is no more than notability-by-association. The article really does not impart that this person was any more important to Einstein than anyone else. At most, this person might merit mention in the article on Einstein Deletion of Michele Besso WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4435 11324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ousmane Sidibé (footballer, born 1990) User:Harambe 13:34, 16 October 2018 (UTC) delete Never played a professional game and no sign of extraordinary circumstances to pass . Amazed this has been live for six years. Additionally, though we shouldn't comment on content but notability, this is also clearly written in pidgin or machine-translated Spanish Deletion of Ousmane Sidibé (footballer, born 1990) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4436 10142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/667 Dark Avenue Forum User:Gwernol 16:38, 2 April 2006 (UTC) delete non-notable, doesn't meet Deletion of 667 Dark Avenue Forum WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4437 12142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denny Sheehan (2nd nomination) User:Tokyogirl79 17:36, 14 February 2012 (UTC) delete The second source (Writers Magazine) is good, but the first source is more concerned with apartments and using Sheehan's search as an example than it is about Sheehan as a writer. This is not the type of coverage that is needed to pass or even . Generally speaking, when you have to use Amazon as a source that means that there's not much notability there Deletion of Denny Sheehan (2nd nomination) WP:AUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4438 11567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lahna Turner User:Dflaw4 03:21, 29 April 2020 (UTC) keep There is a fair amount of coverage of the subject, which I am poring over now, and the subject also won an award—though I'm not sure whether it is considered notable for the purposes of Deletion of Lahna Turner WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4439 380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gell-Mann amnesia effect User:Lightburst 02:37, 10 August 2019 (UTC) merge into Michael_Crichton#Other_speeches deletion is a disservice to our readers, Deletion of Gell-Mann amnesia effect WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
4440 9145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The rape of Savannah Dietrich User:Dream 13:03, 7 January 2013 (UTC) keep Something like this got ample coverage in different nations. Its a notable event. Passes just fine Deletion of The rape of Savannah Dietrich WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4441 21581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack D. Schwager User:Spyder212 19:56, 20 April 2019 (UTC) keep Seems to meet notability criteria as an author as per . Multiple books published with positive reviews. Seems quite known in his field of writing Deletion of Jack D. Schwager WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
4442 12639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruby Yadav (2nd nomination) User:GPL93 00:56, 2 March 2020 (UTC) delete fails , and . Best Deletion of Ruby Yadav (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NMODEL||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4443 3481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boys Suck User:Sting_au 01:38, 18 December 2007 (UTC) delete nn fails Deletion of Boys Suck WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4444 11804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anže Šenk User:EllsworthSchmittendorf 14:40, 5 May 2016 (UTC) delete seems to fail . Never had a podium place Deletion of Anže Šenk WP:SPORTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4445 18625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Student Bar User:DaveG12345 17:56, 6 July 2006 (UTC) delete """per nom. Alexa in the 1.7m area, fails even if its KentUnixa ranking is 3. WP is not here to """"publicise"""" anything""" Deletion of The Student Bar WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4446 7459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Legend of the green dragon User:Snotbot 06:10, 13 June 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 June 13 Deletion of Legend of the green dragon WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4447 1486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 United Arab Emirates Under-19 Tri-Nation tournament User:Worldbruce 00:34, 27 May 2017 (UTC) keep Nomination fails . The 2015 India Under-19 Tri-Nation has significant coverage in more than just ESPNcricinfo, for example: http://indianexpress.com/article/sports/cricket/india-announce-u-19-squad-for-tri-series/, http://www.thedailystar.net/sports/cricket/youths-leave-india-174205, http://www.theindependentbd.com/printversion/details/23533, http://indianexpress.com/article/sports/cricket/before-u-19-tri-series-a-masterclass/, http://www.news18.com/cricketnext/news/under-19-india-cricketers-gear-up-for-tri-series-1166394.html, http://indianexpress.com/article/sports/cricket/u-19-tri-series-india-remain-unbeaten-seal-final-berth/, http://zeenews.india.com/sports/cricket/under-19-triseries-indian-colts-trounce-afghans-by-104-runs-to-finish-on-top_1827341.html, http://indianexpress.com/article/sports/cricket/u-19-tri-series-rishabh-pant-sizzles-with-ton-india-unbeaten/, http://www.thedailystar.net/sports/cricket/bangladesh-youths-thrashed-final-179971, http://www.daily-sun.com/magazine/details/96197/Bangladesh-Under19-Cricket-team-finished-2nd-in-the-trination-Youth-ODI-/2015-12-04. These six newspapers include Bangladesh's largest English-language newspaper and two major Indian news services (IANS and PTI). Considering this, 2015 India Under-19 Tri-Nation tournament plainly meets . Without searching in as much detail, the same appears to be true for the other two - reliable news organizations in the competing countries covered the event in sufficient detail for us to be able to write a complete encyclopedia article Deletion of 2016 United Arab Emirates Under-19 Tri-Nation tournament WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4448 1314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sharon D. Allen (author) User:DARTH 17:42, 30 November 2010 (UTC) delete fails and , non-notable Deletion of Sharon D. Allen (author) WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4449 18238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Landon Ross User:Bearian 02:29, 23 March 2020 (UTC) delete per . There's not even a real allegation of notability. There's |nothing he's done that has been notable. There's |no reliable sources Deletion of Landon Ross WP:SNOW||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
4450 19421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lipstick on a pig User:Cirt 11:12, 11 September 2008 (UTC) keep Agree with {{user|Hemlock Martinis}} and {{user|23skidoo}}, there are literally hundreds of / secondary sources to utilize that were published years ago about this subject matter from which to draw upon for this article in order to provide historical context Deletion of Lipstick on a pig WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4451 14184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denver Randleman User:K 20:35, 12 August 2017 (UTC) delete does not meet & significant RS coverage not found Deletion of Denver Randleman WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
4452 687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyrus Ahanchian User:Schazjmd 21:53, 17 August 2021 (UTC) delete """although the article title could be redirected to :Ahanchian v Xenox Pictures Inc., et al). I cannot find any significant coverage of the individual to support or notability, and none of the reliable sources currently in the article support notability of Ahanchian. The impact of the legal case doesn't extend notability to the person (). Adding to my statement, since has rightfully been mentioned and I didn't address it initially: the films that Ahanchian's been associated with don't meet """"significant or well-known work or collective body of work"""". No awards; none of the work has """"been the primary subject of an independent and notable work... or of multiple independent periodical articles or reviews"""". Ahanchian is not """"regarded as an important figure or is widely cited by peers or successors"""", he is not """"known for originating a significant new concept, theory, or technique"""". Does not meet """ Deletion of Cyrus Ahanchian WP:GNG||WP:BASIC||WP:BLP1E||WP:FILMMAKER||WP:FILMMAKER Wikipedia:Notability 77
4453 2339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Religious communism User:Omni 10:27, 4 July 2016 (UTC) keep Obviously hasn't been followed here. Yes, the article is in a very poor shape, but it undoubtedly meets . Just take a look at a https://www.google.com/search?tbm=bks&q=Religious_communism Google Books search Deletion of Religious communism WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4454 3435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lists of Irish-Americans (2nd nomination) User:Nihonjoe 03:48, 13 September 2007 (UTC) keep I agree with ExRat and Badagnani. In addition, this mass nomination is too |POINTY Deletion of Lists of Irish-Americans (2nd nomination) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
4455 19546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Embark Trucks User:Jonnyvsrobots 18:14, 3 November 2017 (UTC) keep Please review additional edits made to address and based on recent media coverage. Thanks Deletion of Embark Trucks WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
4456 7154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erik Wikholm User:Joe 01:57, 6 December 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |person Deletion of Erik Wikholm WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4457 17283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of deaths in The Bill User:Stifle 14:16, 21 August 2008 (UTC) delete per items 1-3 and 8 of Deletion of List of deaths in The Bill WP:LC Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
4458 15541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malamanteau User:BigDom 07:30, 11 September 2012 (UTC) delete """Having looked through the sources provided, many of them are |unreliable or simply do not even mention """"malamanteau"""" (no, someone writing it in the comments section doesn't count). The only ref that comes close to being usable is the ''Boston Globe'' article, but that alone is not enough to pass GNG. I will AGF that the author did not intentionally mislead us into assuming notability by using an unreliable blog from ''The Economist'' but not mentioning that fact that it is a blog in the reference. Also, this article is full of false attribution; not one of the sources provided in the Sarah Palin paragraph actually says that """"refudiate"""" is a """"malamanteau"""" (not that they would be reliable sources anyway) and there are other examples throughout""" Deletion of Malamanteau WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4459 21324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leonard Eisen User:Accounting4Taste 19:28, 3 October 2007 (UTC) comment """Thanks for pointing that out, and I'm surprised not to have found them -- they must not be indexed on Google very well. Possibly it was the hyphen. Anyway, a """"chain"""" with only two stores isn't really notable IMHO. By the way, we assume |good faith when referring to the work of other editors on Wikipedia, and rarely, if ever, suggest that they are """"lieing""" Deletion of Leonard Eisen WP:GF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
4460 16611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Incredible Things (fragrance) User:Hobit 08:59, 5 April 2016 (UTC) keep easily meets . Are people even doing web searches before !voting to delete? https://www.google.com/search?q=Incredible+Things+(Fragrance)&oq=Incredible+Things+(Fragrance)&aqs=chrome..69i57.431j0j4&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8#tbm=nws&q=%22Incredible+Things%22+(Fragrance). We've got Glamour, MTV, Daily Mail, Hollywood Life and more Deletion of Incredible Things (fragrance) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4461 4360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reenie Mansata User:Jamez42 00:54, 30 June 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and notability guidelines Deletion of Reenie Mansata WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4462 5312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Westbeach User:MilborneOne 21:16, 14 March 2020 (UTC) keep """per , which says, """"Generally, an individual radio or television program is likely to be notable if it airs on a network of radio or television stations (either national or regional in scope)."""" This was a BBC1 show. Also — the article has been improved by""" Deletion of Westbeach WP:NTV||WP:HEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4463 798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Narayana Nethralaya User:Indon 08:00, 12 May 2007 (UTC) delete Should be for blatant advertising. &mdash Deletion of Narayana Nethralaya WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
4464 8780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cleveland East Side Writers User:Haeleth 15:50, 19 July 2006 (UTC) delete I fear. My primary concern is |verifiability -- the only references I can find on the web are Wikipedia mirrors and a brief one-sentence mention on Erin O'Brien's personal homepage, which is in the form of a link to Wikipedia. Regardless of the notability concern, keeping this would require someone to locate and cite some reliable sources that could be used to verify the article's claims.With regard to notability, I strongly disagree with Scorpiondollprincess's claim that the group derives automatic notability from the notability of its members. I do not dispute that at least some of its members are notable, but the article does not claim that membership of the group has verifiably contributed to their success, nor that it forms a defined literary circle with an identifiable style or influence, and I'm not sure what other grounds there could be for claiming that it is of any significance whatsoever to non-members.Let me reiterate, however, that notability concerns are secondary; if no sources can be found to verify the article, notability becomes moot. &mdash Deletion of Cleveland East Side Writers WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4465 18994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deveo User:MaxSem 09:56, 11 July 2016 (UTC) delete still precisely zero references to establish compliance Deletion of Deveo WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4466 5441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 in Ghana User:Ultraexactzz 14:40, 13 March 2013 (UTC) delete as per nom. Few indeed are the events that we know with certainty will happen that far in advance. If we get one of those, sure - but anything else is just Deletion of 2016 in Ghana WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4467 4071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Ribacoff User:JPxG 05:12, 27 September 2020 (UTC) delete Holy moley -- of the nine references cited by this article, three are direct links to YouTube videos, one is a direct link to a Hulu video, one is a transcript of a talk show... the reference from the bar association is just an invitation to a golf event, one isn't in English, and the Connecticut Mag reference literally mentions him once in passing. The only remotely acceptable reference is the ABC News one, which quotes him on a few things, but none of the stuff in this article. I can't even fathom how an article could be written from just this source, let alone an article that would pass Deletion of Daniel Ribacoff WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4468 166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dale Ogden User:CactusWriter 00:36, 9 October 2010 (UTC) keep Meets notability guidelines for ( is unnecessary). As one of only six candidates listed on the current ballot for Governor of California, he is going to qualify for some notability.http://yourcallradio.blogspot.com/2010/09/how-are-you-planning-to-cast-your-vote.html This hour-long interview on the NPR radio station KALW-FM adds to significant coverage. And there seems to be plenty of mentions on political discussion websites -- enough to ''presume'' more reliable sources. There currently is enough for the tiny bit of information that exists in the article. IMO, with only one month left before the election, this seems poor timing for a notability debate on this guy Deletion of Dale Ogden WP:GNG||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
4469 10057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/August 2019 Philadelphia shooting User:TJRC 18:31, 20 August 2019 (UTC) merge to Philadelphia_Police_Department#Notable_events. This is not a mass shooting like the Gilroy Garlic Festival shooting, the 2019 El Paso shooting or the 2019 Dayton shooting. It's a police operation that went bad when the suspect began shooting. I don't think this operation passes the ; it's more in in the nature of |news than encyclopedia material. It's certainly pertinent to the merge target, and should be discussed there Deletion of August 2019 Philadelphia shooting WP:10YEARTEST||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Recentism 10
4470 11431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeopardy! set evolution (2nd nomination) User:Boffob 15:15, 4 November 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Jeopardy! set evolution (2nd nomination) WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4471 1213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunil Sharma (2rd nomination) User:RayAYang 12:08, 11 March 2013 (UTC) delete per nom, arguably A7, since Chancellor is a purely ceremonial position per Chancellor (education), not qualifying for C6 - and there is some question about whether such a recently founded school, with a small student body, qualifies as a major academic institution in any sense. Searching for secondary sources via Gnews proved rather fruitless, but turned up lots of people with the same name, including a scholar at BU who may actually be notable, so fails anyhow Deletion of Sunil Sharma (2rd nomination) WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4472 11138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/R. Chandrasekaran User:Narky 22:04, 10 April 2017 (UTC) delete None of the sources is . I can see no notability at all. His claim to fame is that he's ''Vice Chairman'' of a company??? Gimme a break, this is nowhere near passing or Deletion of R. Chandrasekaran WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4473 21140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Computation and Neural Systems User:W 19:48, 26 August 2011 (UTC) delete """or '''Merge''' if it were better sourced, probably Artificial intelligence or Artificial neural network. There is also Bio-inspired computing but it also not well cited. Also of course California Institute of Technology which mentions it (without a link) as just one in a list of undergraduate programs. Note it is not a single """"class"""" (which is how """"course"""" is often meant) but an academic program. But still, would need to show general notability to remain stand-alone, with an independent source saying something about it, more than it existing. No citations at all, just link to its own web site and others inline. Would also observe the Special:Contributions/Perona|user Perona seems a |single purpose account. Only edits related to this article are seen in the history. One was adding a link to the graduate program section of Caltech's article. But that was reverted without comment, perhaps because it was sourced to the 2011 registrar newsletter which nowhere I could find mentions this program. The article states (without citation) that """"Pietro Perona"""" is an """"executive officer"""" of the program. Actually from its web page, it might be more involved in Computational neuroscience? I am not an expert in any of these fields""" Deletion of Computation and Neural Systems WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
4474 7470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mister Supranational India User:Fitindia 16:32, 27 October 2017 (UTC) delete Does not have any encyclopedic value. The pageant itself has been around only a few years and is Deletion of Mister Supranational India WP:LASTING||WP:TOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
4475 2121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michelangelo Albertazzi User:Luxic 09:52, 15 May 2010 (UTC) delete obviously fails , even though I must admit he's way more notable than several players that do meet the criteria (but this is not the matter at issue, so Deletion of Michelangelo Albertazzi WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4476 8597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pucci Dellanno User:Esradekan 23:46, 27 January 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per . Searching pulls up no |reliable, third-party, sources. Ghits only show online stores, myspace and facebook sites. The only reference to releases on Polydor, Atlantic or Network records is this wikipedia particle. Willing to change me vote if someone can find some thing that would pass any of the 12 criteria Deletion of Pucci Dellanno WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4477 1786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rodney Morison (2nd nomination) User:Atmoz 18:53, 19 May 2011 (UTC) delete unreferenced bio. obits in general don't satisfy . no other sources found. but no objection to recreation if someone finds a reliable source. fails Deletion of Rodney Morison (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4478 2767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mac OS 11 (2nd nomination) User:Baseball 02:36, 14 December 2011 (UTC) delete Per #G4 Deletion of Mac OS 11 (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
4479 4457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grand Belial's Key User:AmitDeshwar 01:00, 26 September 2006 (UTC) keep per Prolog and others above. Seems clearly to pass Deletion of Grand Belial's Key WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4480 769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cody Chupp User:Deadman137 19:16, 15 August 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and falls well short of Deletion of Cody Chupp WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4481 8075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paola Sebastiani User:Eric 02:57, 2 February 2009 (UTC) keep Arguably meets criterion #1 (significant impact in scholarly discipline, broadly construed). Google Scholar http://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_sauthors=Paola+Sebastiani citations, although not exceptional, seem to indicate notability Deletion of Paola Sebastiani WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
4482 3607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quad 5 Trio User:Aleron235 03:54, 28 November 2005 (UTC) keep A band that has been around for 5 years and continues to thrive is notable in itself. They claim to have 4 releases, and are currently working on a new one. is not policy and should not be treated as such. However, the article does need heavy cleanup to remove what seems to be mostly self-promotion. I'll volunteer to do this Deletion of Quad 5 Trio WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4483 5799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giblets F.C User:Peridon 20:58, 10 February 2011 (UTC) delete """and per nom. If you read the policies, you might see reasons. No-one is """"entitled"""" to a page. """"The non- notability issue is rendered pointless with the external link to the league website. It has many teams in many leagues."""" That merely proves existence. Please read and . If you really want to save the article, take notice of what we are saying. We are regular editors here - why would we bother using our time trying to delete something worthwhile? We try to help people with articles - when they are willing to be helped, as you seem not to be. Wikipedia is free - you didn't pay to come in. It is collaborative - this is a part of a collaborative process. Your article wasn't deleted at first sight by a supporter of Vale Madrid, or even by someone like us who had never heard of either you or them before. It's being discussed. But Wikipedia is not anarchy. It has rules. It's not free webspace - if you want that, you can get it at AboutUs or LinkedIn""" Deletion of Giblets F.C WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4484 4202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Envy Theory User:Nuujinn 21:26, 15 June 2010 (UTC) delete but let's not |bite the user Deletion of Envy Theory WP:BITE Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
4485 20394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ikos Resorts User:Meatsgains 03:24, 24 September 2016 (UTC) keep Might be but is https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Ikos+Resorts%22&tbm=nws covered in reliable sources Deletion of Ikos Resorts WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4486 21015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Garay Asadov User:CCamp2013 03:46, 17 June 2016 (UTC) keep per and give the new editor time to mold the article with references Deletion of Garay Asadov WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
4487 11890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wesley Gibson User:ilikepie2221 01:05, 3 July 2008 (UTC) delete per . ''...Significant coverage is more than trivial but may be less than exclusive.'' LESS than exclusive. The only source is the subject's comic book. ''...Availability of secondary sources covering the subject...'' There are no secondary sources. 3.1 million hits on Google may be appealing for keep supporters, but they're all MySpace/Blog/Job-finding websites Deletion of Wesley Gibson WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4488 876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul H. Carr (2nd nomination) User:onel5969 16:36, 30 January 2021 (UTC) merge to USS Carr (FFG-52). Lack of in-depth coverage causes him to fail , and he definitely doesn't meet . Contrary to the assertions by some, having a ship named after you is not part of any SN guideline, and not cause for automatic notability. I would say merge, but the pertinent data is already in the ship's article Deletion of Paul H. Carr (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NSOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
4489 14574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Winx club season 5 User:Stuartyeates 07:32, 6 November 2011 (UTC) delete as per rystal Deletion of Winx club season 5 WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
4490 9004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sri lanka see more do more User:Drat8sub 03:06, 4 June 2020 (UTC) delete fails notability, does not meet ...aligning with Deletion of Sri lanka see more do more WP:BKCRIT||WP:BOOKSTORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4491 6242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Sullivan (footballer) User:Angelo 08:29, 26 June 2008 (UTC) delete """not really a notable subject. Saying he is """"expected to play"""" is crystal-balling, saying he is notable merely because he sat on a bench is a violation of and does not confer notability in my own views. Recreate it only if/when he actually plays""" Deletion of John Sullivan (footballer) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4492 4557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/N&k Technology [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 21:44, 6 February 2008 (UTC) delete as insufficiently notable per Deletion of N&k Technology WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4493 12068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Central Modern School User:TerriersFan 15:14, 12 July 2012 (UTC) keep We keep high schools for the very good reason that experience shows that, with enough research, sources can invariably be found that meet . Google is a very poor tool for finding sources on Indian schools because, unlike US schools, they don't dump everything on the Internet. Indeed, very few have much of an Internet presence at all. We must avoid systemic bias and allow time for local sources to be researched since no evidence has been adduced that this school cannot meet notability requirements Deletion of The Central Modern School WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4494 13059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Vault (wiki) User:Chaos5023 05:13, 5 July 2011 (UTC) keep and '''trout''' nominator. Cited sources clearly exceed and Deletion of The Vault (wiki) WP:GNG||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4495 13106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Evans (football goalkeeper) User:Richard 13:17, 20 January 2008 (UTC) delete as per usual concerns about footballers who have only played non-league in England. The bit about Chasetown being the lowest ranked side to ever compete in the 3rd Round is open to interpretation as well Deletion of Lee Evans (football goalkeeper) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4496 2826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Breakup Song User:Barkeep 14:23, 22 November 2010 (UTC) merge In addition to |general notability, fails SONG. Merge to album ''The Art of Losing Deletion of The Breakup Song WP:N||WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4497 2789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chakreshwar Bhattacharyya User:RebeccaGreen 16:30, 14 December 2018 (UTC) keep I am unable to find any significant sources in English. I can verify that he was associated with the Assamese literary journal ''Jayanti'', and I also discovered that he translated books from Hindi and Marathi into Assamese. Given that he was active in India from 1943-1969, it's possible that any sources that exist are not findable online, whatever language they are in. He may have received enough coverage or critical attention to be considered notable, but online sources do not provide any evidence beyond the basic facts of his work with the journal and translations. However, as this article was only created one week ago, and nominated for deletion on the same day (what happened to and ATD?) I would suggest keeping the article, tagging it with eg 'expert needed', adding it to relevant projects, and reviewing it after some time Deletion of Chakreshwar Bhattacharyya WP:BITE Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
4498 13508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cronin Economics User:הסרפד 00:58, 29 November 2012 (UTC) delete """terrible article, but it doesn't merit a speedy delete. An article that {{tq|""""serves no purpose other than to promote its creator's POV""""}} has another name on Wikipedia: """ Deletion of Cronin Economics WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
4499 18028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nitin Kumar Gupta User:Stuartyeates 06:07, 11 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Nitin Kumar Gupta WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4500 20569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of statistically superlative countries User:Reyk 03:52, 25 November 2010 (UTC) delete """this article is a textbook violation of . There is no possibility that any meaningful comparison can be drawn between such wildly random properties like """"Best performance at Paddle Tennis World Championship"""", """"Largest sisal producer"""", """"Most frigates in operation"""" and """"Highest number of World Heritage Sites"""". This entire list is meaningless, incoherent , and deciding which of the millions and billions of possible statistics to list is unavoidably |original research""" Deletion of List of statistically superlative countries WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:TRIVIA||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4501 20207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of Australian and New Zealand governments User:Lamberhurst 07:33, 12 October 2009 (UTC) delete There should be no place in Wikipedia for what are essentially unreferenced POV essays with large helpings of |original research. Comparison of United States and United Kingdom governments is riddled with so many inaccuracies and hackneyed stereotypes it is difficult to know where to begin. These three articles are an embarrassment to Wikipedia Deletion of Comparison of Australian and New Zealand governments WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4502 12483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uncle Gamer Radio User:FangzofBlood 22:20, 26 December 2007 (UTC) delete for reasons of nominator, but everyone please refrain from Deletion of Uncle Gamer Radio WP:GHITS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4503 4470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cruise118 User:HighKing 14:42, 22 May 2020 (UTC) delete Unless the various awards push this company into notability, it hasn't met the requirements based on references. I am unable to locate any |significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, references to date fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic therefore fails GNG/ Deletion of Cruise118 WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4504 12425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blood Red Renaissance User:Niteshift36 13:13, 9 July 2009 (UTC) delete Appears to fail Deletion of Blood Red Renaissance WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4505 7145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jon and Tracy Morter User:Pawnkingthree 03:31, 21 December 2009 (UTC) delete Seems a textbook case of . They are not notable outside of the Facebook campaign, which can be adequately covered in the Killing in the Name article Deletion of Jon and Tracy Morter WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4506 11282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Schultz (2nd nomination) User:RHaworth 02:03, 18 March 2009 (UTC) delete I am not greatly impressed by the references. I would prefer to see the articles deleted until a |non-SPA writes about them. &mdash Deletion of Larry Schultz (2nd nomination) WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
4507 715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Intentional Names of Pokémon [[User Talk:JzG|Just zis Guy you know?]] 13:19, 25 April 2006 (UTC) delete per and concerns above Deletion of Intentional Names of Pokémon WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4508 6369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How to Host a Murder User:LjL 12:50, 18 October 2015 (UTC) comment may we have a Template:Copypaste on the article with the source of the seemingly copied text? If obvious copypaste, that content should probably be removed ''before'' the article even meets its fate (assuming it does), per Deletion of How to Host a Murder WP:DCV Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
4509 18000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skin (Rihanna song) User:Bearian 21:23, 27 October 2011 (UTC) comment """I was asked to add another comment, but I don't have anything to add, except """"per """ Deletion of Skin (Rihanna song) WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
4510 19223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paula Huston User:Coolabahapple 15:27, 21 November 2015 (UTC) keep """meets , here is a review from the LA Times http://articles.latimes.com/2012/feb/02/entertainment/la-et-book-simplify-the-soul-20120202 for ''Simplifying the Soul'' - """"it's encouraging reading for people struggling with big challenges or the smaller daily distractions that upset our peace of mind."""" and heres a review of ''A Land Without Sin'' from the Chicago Center for Literature and Photography Weekender magazine http://www.cclapcenter.com/2014/02/book_review_a_land_without_sin.html - """"What Paula Huston gives the reader is a mature and cynical adventure novel."""". oh and good old Buffalo library shows reviews from Booklist and Publishers Weekly for ''Signatures of grace''http://www.buffalolib.org/vufind/Record/1055810/Reviews, ''The holy way''http://www.buffalolib.org/vufind/Record/1247478/Reviews#tabnav, ''Daughters of song''http://www.buffalolib.org/vufind/Record/852582/Reviews#tabnav, and ''A land without sin''http://www.buffalolib.org/vufind/Record/1988212/Reviews#tabnav""" Deletion of Paula Huston WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4511 10470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cornelius Law College User:Bearian 19:17, 19 December 2019 (UTC) merge to University of the Punjab, its parent institution. It's too new to have any notable alumni, nor more than a few even admitted to the bar, but a redirect for now is |cheap and easy Deletion of Cornelius Law College WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
4512 6979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Library event planning User:TimothyBlue 00:33, 26 August 2020 (UTC) delete A combo of and // Deletion of Library event planning WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
4513 11207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/School Girl (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 02:21, 26 April 2010 (UTC) keep """per meeting . Anyone care to visit a mainstream review? For a porn film THAT's a rarity. Here it is as reviewed by ''Time Magazine's'' Richard Corlisshttp://www.time.com/time/columnist/corliss/article/0,9565,1043267-5,00.html and amazingly is listed as one of ''Time's'' """"ALL-TIME 100 best films"""". http://www.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,1953094_1953151_1954816,00.html Go figure""" Deletion of School Girl (film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
4514 8715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Secure-webconferencing User:WilyD 12:56, 21 July 2006 (UTC) delete per crazy hard failure of , , , and so forth Deletion of Secure-webconferencing WP:SPAM||WP:VAIN||WP:NOT||WP:OR Wikipedia:Spam 112
4515 309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elene Church User:Wm335td 19:59, 2 January 2020 (UTC) delete fails . if kept it needs Deletion of Elene Church WP:GNG||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4516 13623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SureID NONE NONE delete as with a good dose of , due to excessive intricate detail. Wikipedia is not an office directory and not a for a corp web site; sample content Deletion of SureID WP:PROMO||WP:TNT||WP:WEBHOST Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4517 2832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Promode channel User:Bobet 22:04, 11 December 2005 (UTC) delete 200 edits and no encyclopedic content, please read and note that wikipedia isn't a free webhost or an indiscriminate collection of information. If there's something that makes the channel notable in a wider context than beyond it's own community, please list it on the article Deletion of Promode channel WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4518 4900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Birkensnake User:HeartSWild 07:40, 24 August 2010 (UTC) comment I've never posted my opinion on here, but what the heck. The whole crux of this debate comes down to the sources of this entry being blogs, thus making them unreliable sources, thus making this entry not notable. This not correct. According to , blogs ''can be'' considered reliable sources if they meet certain wickets. ''NOTE: I don't see any blogs currently being used as sources for this entry''. But since it seems to be such an issue of contention if you would like to use a blog as a source, it would be best to put the link on the talk page and discuss why it would or why it wouldn't be a reliable source. Some blogs are, some blogs aren't. I hope that helps Deletion of Birkensnake WP:IRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4519 13152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Hacksmith User:Samsmachado 20:41, 5 December 2020 (UTC) keep CBC article https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/kitchener-waterloo/the-hacksmith-youtube-kitchener-avengers-end-game-1.5107790, Men's Health article https://www.menshealth.com/entertainment/a34335375/star-wars-lightsaber-real-hacksmith-how-to-build/, and NY Post https://nypost.com/2020/10/13/youtuber-creates-real-life-star-wars-lightsaber-that-slices-steel/ would be my top three sources cited in the article to contribute to /. They all seem to be reliable indpendant sources. If that wasn't enough, 8mil. subscribers in a secondary source https://torontolife.com/city/life/internet-famous-how-james-hobson-a-k-a-the-hacksmith-brings-in-500000-a-year-building-superhero-props-on-youtube/ clearly indicates meeting crit. 2 Deletion of The Hacksmith WP:GNG||WP:BASIC||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4520 5292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sloppy seconds (sexual practice) User:Malik 19:13, 27 March 2016 (UTC) keep """Satisfies . Also not a neologism, unless it's still considered """"relatively new"""" after https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=sloppy+seconds&case_insensitive=on&year_start=1950&year_end=2000 50 years of documented usage in print. — """ Deletion of Sloppy seconds (sexual practice) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4521 9291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kent Holtorf User:Chzz 02:10, 29 November 2011 (UTC) keep WP:GNG, , Deletion of Kent Holtorf WP:BIO||WP:HEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4522 14435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Claremont-Mudd-Scripps Stags User:Finngall 02:31, 1 June 2017 (UTC) comment This page was created without the {{tl|afd2}} template and never transcluded to a daily log. Fixed now. Should properly be '''procedurally closed''', as no rationale has been given for deletion, but could possibly be linked to the related AfD at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Claremont-Mudd-Scripps Stags and Athenas, for which the early !votes have been for deletion. Nominator also created a similarly malformed nomination at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Claremont-Mudd-Scripps Athenas. {{ping|Spatms}} For future nominations, please fully follow the procedures at Deletion of Claremont-Mudd-Scripps Stags WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4523 348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert D. Parks User:Dsreyn 12:52, 6 July 2006 (UTC) delete None of that seems to satisfy . Holding professor positions at different universities is hardly notable, and the center at Florida Atlantic (essentially an extension of his school board position http://www.coe.fau.edu/tlc/content/about-index.htm) doesn't appear to make him worthy of an entry either. If he has additional academic notability, it needs to be added to the article Deletion of Robert D. Parks WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4524 3782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tommy T. Rapisardi [[User talk:Yanksox|Yanksox]] 02:29, 27 October 2006 (UTC) delete Does assert some important stuff, but simply doesn't appear to meet Deletion of Tommy T. Rapisardi WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4525 11636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nikolaos Okekuoyen (2nd nomination) user:Chalk19 20:18, 11 December 2020 (UTC) delete He fails the criteria for basketball players. Doesn't meet the general guideliness for notability, either. There were some more or less favourable reports on him recently in the Greek spots media based mainly on the Nigerian ancestry he shares with his pal Giannis Antetokounmpo|Giannis. For the time being . ǁǁǁ ǁ Deletion of Nikolaos Okekuoyen (2nd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4526 7428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CandN User:JamesBurns 01:49, 27 January 2009 (UTC) delete insufficient independent 3rd party notability Deletion of CandN WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4527 16 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cody Lane (2nd nomination) User:PMDrive1061 16:14, 21 May 2011 (UTC) delete I recreated the article |assuming good faith from an established user. No need to release the hounds Deletion of Cody Lane (2nd nomination) WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
4528 15397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Euclid St. Paul's Neighborhood User:Estemi 08:00, 19 March 2008 (UTC) delete No reliable sources independent of the subject. and Deletion of Euclid St. Paul's Neighborhood WP:RELY||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4529 5175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mathew Knowles User:Fæ 10:39, 6 July 2012 (UTC) keep sufficient for the otability#General notability guideline|General notability guideline Deletion of Mathew Knowles WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4530 49 [[Aare Linth]] (erl.) NONE NONE delete keine dargestellte Relevanz gem. #Schienenverkehr, wo es heisst ''Zuglinien und einzelne Züge/Zugpaare sind nur in herausragenden Einzelfällen relevant''. ※ 10:25, 12. Dez. 2020 (CET Löschung von Aare Linth Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
4531 11363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myron Boadu User:Inter 22:57, 20 June 2017 (UTC) delete at the age of 16 definitely , article can always be recreated if and when subject meets & Deletion of Myron Boadu WP:TOOSOON||WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4532 18583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/San Luis Shrine Desecration (Mormons) User:Cullen328 02:51, 26 December 2011 (UTC) delete Let me count the ways. The last bigoted remark takes the cake. This is an article about a regrettable but minor and non-notable act of religious vandalism. The article pushes a anti-Mormon |point of view hostile to Mormonism and is written by a |single purpose account who displays no fewer that four anti-Mormon user boxes hostile to Mormonism on his user page. The article is illustrated with images that are almost certainly |copyright violations. This new editor has been dedicated in the past few days to working on articles pertaining to Mormonism. His request that only one Mormon be allowed to express an opinion in this AfD debate is totally out of line. Any editor of any faith or none is welcome to participate here. I am not a Mormon, don't care for Mormonism, and don't usually get involved with topics related to Mormonism. But this article and this editor's behavior are both way over the line Deletion of San Luis Shrine Desecration (Mormons) WP:POV||WP:SPA||WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
4533 16839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harvard Bonin user:czar 05:13, 25 September 2015 (UTC) delete Article topic lacks |significant coverage from |reliable, |independent sources. (|?) Run-of-the-mill spokesperson coverage in a /RS|video game reliable sources https://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=003516479746865699832:leawcwkqifq custom Google search. There are no worthwhile redirect targets. If someone finds more (non-English and offline) sources, please {{tl|ping}} me. – Deletion of Harvard Bonin WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:42||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4534 16312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammad Rafiq (retired army) User:Kingsif 16:43, 13 August 2019 (UTC) comment """Those with votes to delete or merge base this on policy, whereas those with votes to keep base this on the media referring to him as a """"hero"""", which they argue denotes importance enough for an article. I'd also like to quote from : """"A person who is known only in connection with a criminal event or trial should not normally be the subject of a separate Wikipedia article ''if there is an existing article that could incorporate the available encyclopedic material relating to that person''."""" and : """"Even when an event is notable, individuals involved in it may not be. Unless news coverage of an individual goes beyond the context of a single event, our coverage of that individual should be limited to the article about that event, in proportion to their importance to the overall topic""" Deletion of Muhammad Rafiq (retired army) WP:CRIME||WP:NOTWHOSWHO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4535 3637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Illinois Arborist Association User:DasallmächtigeJ 18:31, 17 January 2010 (UTC) delete by . I'm averse to even call this an article Deletion of Illinois Arborist Association WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4536 10326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess Kaguya (ship) User:T 03:35, 4 July 2008 (UTC) delete until construction actually begins, I'm afraid this fails per Deletion of Princess Kaguya (ship) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4537 9831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Todd J. Rathner User:DickClarkMises 13:16, 28 June 2016 (UTC) keep He has been covered by major news agency like ''The New York Times'', ''NPR'', ''Los Angeles Times'', ''Houston Chronicles'', ''Bloomberg'' etc. He seems to pass the notability test per . Apart from links mentioned above by Deletion of Todd J. Rathner WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4538 9489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skycandle User:The 11:22, 21 April 2018 (UTC) delete per nomination. Fails and , and like nominator I can only find passing mentions about them online. At present their site, hosted on :Shopify, is unavailable, and they also appear to have misconfigured their SSL. Best of luck with that launch, guys Deletion of Skycandle WP:NCORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4539 4585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Playstation Portable 2 User:Twirligig 01:57, 24 January 2009 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Playstation Portable 2 WP:HOAX||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
4540 15358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Communication Risks and Best Practice in Global Software Development User:Bearian 20:22, 25 July 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. Also, some sections stink of |having been plagiarized directly from editor's notes of the book itself Deletion of Communication Risks and Best Practice in Global Software Development WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
4541 17169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie A. Thomas (Anthropologist) User:Hzh 13:23, 13 June 2018 (UTC) delete Appears to have zero notability as an academic to satisfy any of the criteria per . It seems that a book by the person in question may be released later, and if there are enough significant reviews, it may justify an article about the author per , but before that, there is nothing to warrant an article Deletion of Jamie A. Thomas (Anthropologist) WP:NACADEMIC||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
4542 9896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annette Daniels NONE NONE comment guidelines are decidely skewed towards popular music. I'm no authority on opera, but how many artists outside of The Three Tenors actually could meet if you discount longer term stints they may do with a local opera company? It always seemed to me that most opera performers are like orchestral conductors: they work in a particular city for a while before moving on and taking an engagement elsewhere. Maybe I'm wrong about this... like I said I'm no authority on opera... but it would seem that perhaps a slightly different set of criteria should apply to opera performers Deletion of Annette Daniels WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4543 1356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pursed lip breathing User:Edison 15:55, 7 September 2011 (UTC) keep """http://www.normalbreathing.com/d/pursed-lip-breathing.php This reference, cited above, includes a listing of many articles published in major medical journals which are about this therapeutic breathing technique, so it satisfies . http://books.google.com/books?id=Km5x3lEVOCUC&pg=PA260&dq=%22pursed+lip+breathing%22&hl=en&ei=N5RnTsmsIMXz0gHw0Z3LCw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=2&ved=0CDwQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=%22pursed%20lip%20breathing%22&f=false This book actually discusses """"pursed lip breathing"""" as an example of finding reliable sources in medical journals, and says the author found such sources. Here are others of the Google Books hits, which have with significant coverage: http://books.google.com/books?id=rTexGiX5bqoC&pg=PA277&dq=%22pursed+lip+breathing%22&hl=en&ei=lpVnTqCCDNS_gQfb4JS3DA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CDYQ6AEwADgU#v=onepage&q=%22pursed%20lip%20breathing%22&f=false, http://books.google.com/books?id=oMzhfkVZBDYC&pg=PA37&dq=%22pursed+lip+breathing%22&hl=en&ei=zpVnTtuGIcLngQeBouXtDA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=7&ved=0CFcQ6AEwBjge#v=onepage&q=%22pursed%20lip%20breathing%22&f=false, http://books.google.com/books?id=VE8UJZrp6NIC&pg=PA143&dq=%22pursed+lip+breathing%22&hl=en&ei=JZVnToneIojEgAfyzInRDA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CDgQ6AEwADgK#v=onepage&q=%22pursed%20lip%20breathing%22&f=false, http://books.google.com/books?id=HY9PiQL3kQMC&pg=PA504&dq=%22pursed+lip+breathing%22&hl=en&ei=JZVnToneIojEgAfyzInRDA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=4&ved=0CEoQ6AEwAzgK#v=onepage&q=%22pursed%20lip%20breathing%22&f=false, http://books.google.com/books?id=dQ2zJxdXpWkC&pg=PA170&dq=%22pursed+lip+breathing%22&hl=en&ei=JZVnToneIojEgAfyzInRDA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=7&ved=0CF0Q6AEwBjgK#v=onepage&q=%22pursed%20lip%20breathing%22&f=false, http://books.google.com/books?id=M4HwH5IxfToC&pg=PA464&dq=%22pursed+lip+breathing%22&hl=en&ei=N5RnTsmsIMXz0gHw0Z3LCw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=3&ved=0CEEQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=%22pursed%20lip%20breathing%22&f=false, http://books.google.com/books?id=p-hrqLpelEgC&pg=PA206&dq=%22pursed+lip+breathing%22&hl=en&ei=N5RnTsmsIMXz0gHw0Z3LCw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=4&ved=0CEYQ6AEwAw#v=onepage&q=%22pursed%20lip%20breathing%22&f=false, http://books.google.com/books?id=A--epDTB2hMC&pg=PA6&dq=%22pursed+lip+breathing%22&hl=en&ei=N5RnTsmsIMXz0gHw0Z3LCw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=5&ved=0CE0Q6AEwBA#v=onepage&q=%22pursed%20lip%20breathing%22&f=false, http://books.google.com/books?id=gRwhZN4B4i4C&pg=PA2486&dq=%22pursed+lip+breathing%22&hl=en&ei=N5RnTsmsIMXz0gHw0Z3LCw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=6&ved=0CFMQ6AEwBQ#v=onepage&q=%22pursed%20lip%20breathing%22&f=false, http://books.google.com/books?id=NWjb332kyMUC&pg=PA203&dq=%22pursed+lip+breathing%22&hl=en&ei=N5RnTsmsIMXz0gHw0Z3LCw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=9&ved=0CGQQ6AEwCA#v=onepage&q=%22pursed%20lip%20breathing%22&f=false. Google Scholar has 1300 hits: http://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_q=&num=10&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=%22pursed+lip+breathing%22&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=&as_publication=&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_sdt=1.&as_sdtp=on&as_sdtf=&as_sdts=14&hl=en""" Deletion of Pursed lip breathing WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4544 6975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Frantzis User:Jeff5102 10:12, 3 June 2013 (UTC) comment I made some minor improvements to the article. I do not know if it is enough to save the article; I’ll leave it to the administrators if it meets . But if it does, the article at least looks better than it did before. Regards Deletion of George Frantzis WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4545 12899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oswald Leroy User:David 06:32, 2 June 2014 (UTC) keep The case for #C1 looks weak to nonexistent from the citation record, but the honorary doctorate and the foreign medal of the French Acoustical Society together add up to international recognition that has a high enough profile to pass #C2 for me Deletion of Oswald Leroy WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
4546 12541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Burge User:RadioFan 12:08, 11 August 2009 (UTC) delete unreferenced, fails . notability of the club itself is questionable as well Deletion of Sam Burge WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4547 18539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vice president I'd love to fuck (VPILF) User:MuZemike 20:37, 28 December 2008 (UTC) delete per lack of reliable sources establishing notability for this |neologism as well as |common sense Deletion of Vice president I'd love to fuck (VPILF) WP:NEO||WP:COMMON Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
4548 7836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leading ladies (game) (2nd nomination) User:Kirbanzo 22:36, 10 February 2019 (UTC) delete fails . No notable Ghits either Deletion of Leading ladies (game) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4549 2903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Center for CosMedic Rejuvenation and Wellness User:SM247 01:29, 13 June 2006 (UTC) delete unless it is of particular historical or other significance, it doesn't merit its own page. I would also recommend to the nominator a similar page, Paradise Day Spa and Bath House, which is essentially an ad despite its opening by the Mayor and assertions of historical importance. The problem is that there is simply nothing notable about this particular center which would merit inclusion in an encyclopaedia - see and if you are not quite familiar with policies. Maybe it will be significant one day, or maybe it is and needs to be rewritten to assert what it is that makes it so. But for now, it doesn't belong here Deletion of The Center for CosMedic Rejuvenation and Wellness WP:NOT||WP:CORP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4550 6514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Vasco Era [[User talk:Moondyne|''Moondyne'']] 10:54, 10 May 2007 (UTC) keep Seems to pass . &mdash Deletion of The Vasco Era WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4551 19174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Mexico School of Natural Therapeutics User:MrBill3 08:37, 19 August 2014 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of New Mexico School of Natural Therapeutics WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4552 4481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ESOM School of Music User:AllyD 19:06, 6 December 2016 (UTC) delete Originally a , article, which has been through various transformations without ever establishing |reliable 3rd party references, which my searches have also failed to locate. Nor am I seeing any real claim of notability for this tuition centre, even in https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=ESOM_School_of_Music&oldid=753351101 the strongly promotional version which was recently edited-down in place of G11 deletion. Fails , Deletion of ESOM School of Music :WP:SPA||:WP:COI||:WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
4553 21074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tani Cinco User:Karst 16:39, 8 July 2016 (UTC) delete as it stands. Move to user space so that the author can continue work on it and especially sources. If there are further sources it would pass Deletion of Tani Cinco WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4554 6094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Wild Wild Westmar Show User:Deor 18:21, 11 October 2007 (UTC) comment """The article was created (by you) in April of this year, so it's hardly been """"up for nearly a year"""". I'd also suggest that you peruse """ Deletion of The Wild Wild Westmar Show WP:NPA Wikipedia:No personal attacks 58
4555 2689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011 MLS Reserve Division User:Bzweebl 16:55, 20 February 2012 (UTC) merge to MLS Reserve Division. Although there are reliable sources on the topics, they are generally not focused on events during the season but rather on the existence on the league itself, so the notability is directed on the league. Arsenalkid700's argument is merely Deletion of 2011 MLS Reserve Division WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4556 10261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pro-Islamic bias on Wikipedia User:HyperGaruda 20:17, 24 April 2017 (UTC) delete WP:KILLITWITHFIRE and ! Hmmm, I see that the former link leads to , but please only blow it up and do not start over Deletion of Pro-Islamic bias on Wikipedia WP:SNOW||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
4557 5321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Overworld User:EyeSerene 16:41, 27 July 2007 (UTC) delete per , , and Propaniac Deletion of Overworld WP:NEO||WP:ATT||WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
4558 17829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/5 steps to effectively tap online Medical Transcription projects [[User:.snoopy.|.snoopy.]] [[User talk:.snoopy.|]] 12:21, 29 March 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of 5 steps to effectively tap online Medical Transcription projects WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4559 16321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saturday Night Alive User:Squirepants101 17:18, 28 January 2007 (UTC) delete as an unsourced |neologism Deletion of Saturday Night Alive WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
4560 6701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paddles (cat) User:Arthistorian1977 14:19, 9 November 2017 (UTC) keep Quite enough coverage before the death. Passes Deletion of Paddles (cat) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4561 13114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave Black (politician) User:Kraxler 01:28, 5 September 2015 (UTC) delete """smalltown mayor, fails , coverage in a metro paper which covers his hometown remains local, and is not """"significant"""" as required by GNG""" Deletion of Dave Black (politician) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4562 13279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/University of Florida Student Government User:Jamesontai 21:27, 12 April 2008 (UTC) merge """back into the UF article. This stub fails , , G, and also has a direct copy of the UFSG mission statement pasted from the SG website without quotations or proper citations and is screaming """"COPYRIGHT VIOLATION""" Deletion of University of Florida Student Government WP:OR||WP:RS||WP:ORG Wikipedia:No original research 65
4563 9019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Azad Jammu and Kashmir Council User:Savonneux 07:23, 10 August 2016 (UTC) delete I think this is already covered and better written at History_of_Azad_Kashmir. So and Deletion of Azad Jammu and Kashmir Council WP:POVFORK||WP:A10 Wikipedia:Content forking 33
4564 5981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rahul Parmar User:Atlantic306 16:31, 21 April 2018 (UTC) delete apart from the probable coi, he only seems to have a finished film credit as an assistant director so this article is as he needs to be the main director on notable released films Deletion of Rahul Parmar WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4565 20694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CoTherix User:Bearian 01:51, 18 February 2020 (UTC) merge per |unanimous vote Deletion of CoTherix WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
4566 16527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kalendar Koffee House Company User:Bridesmill 14:52, 31 March 2006 (UTC) delete WP:VANITY, , , NN Deletion of Kalendar Koffee House Company WP:CORP||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
4567 5701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sigma Omega Nu User:RightCowLeftCoast 18:19, 6 July 2012 (UTC) merge although the subject does not appear to pass or with all these AfDs for minority sorority/fraternity organizations it appears to me that perhaps an List article should be created for List of ethnic minority fraternaties and sororities in the United States, and all such organizations that fail independent can have verified content moved to such a list. If any of those organizations later are found to pass or , they can be |spunout Deletion of Sigma Omega Nu WP:GNG||WP:ORG||WP:ORG||WP:ORG||WP:GNG||WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4568 110 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Üç Kulhü bir Elham Kullanıcı:superyetkinsuperyetkin 20:41, 14 Ocak 2015 (UTC) comment silinsin}} Hiçbir anlam ifade etmeyen bir cümle.Kulhü nedir yahu? Kuran-ı Kerimde geçen surenin adı ihlas suresidir. Ne Mutlu Türküm Diyene! bkz. Oylamanın başlangıç tarihi itibariyle kullanıcı 150 değişikliğe sahip değil Üç Kulhü bir Elham'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:OY Wikipedia:Administrators 89
4569 2730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of rebels user:Alf_photoman 23:29, 8 March 2007 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of List of rebels WP:NPOV||WP:LIST Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
4570 15217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harbhajan Singh (military officer) User:Kvng 16:20, 28 June 2020 (UTC) keep The subject played a historically significant role in the Nathu La and Cho La clashes. He is, for example, a significant character in a Paltan (film)|movie on this topic. Most recent Maha Vir Chakra recipients have articles. Be careful of Deletion of Harbhajan Singh (military officer) WP:RECENTISM Wikipedia:Recentism 10
4571 397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Viscera Trail User:TheJazzDalek 12:22, 13 March 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find anything that would satisfy Deletion of Viscera Trail WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4572 3088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heathville Road User:Davidpdx 01:03, 2 January 2007 (UTC) delete No assertion of noteablity, fails Deletion of Heathville Road WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4573 18595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Western acceptance of Iranian uranium enrichment User:Cowlibob 11:22, 22 August 2015 (UTC) delete """per . Clear POV fork created after article creator couldn't get their way as of yet at the parent article which they have taken to mean that the """"truth"""" is being hidden. The clearly non neutral point of view title and content of the new article indicates article creator has tried to prove a . Content disputes should be resolved at the page they occur on, not by creating new pages to fit your viewpoint. Encourage article creator to discuss the inclusion of their points over at the parent article. Also please read: Wikipedia:Advocacy""" Deletion of Western acceptance of Iranian uranium enrichment WP:SOAP||WP:POINT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4574 9830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vladine Biosse User:Ad 01:41, 4 March 2014 (UTC) delete A Google did indeed turn up tons of hits. But they were pretty much all promotional or affiliated sites such as boxing news with short blurbs about scheduled fights. None really meet and nothing here rings the notability bell Deletion of Vladine Biosse WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4575 11019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JT Southern User:Claritas 10:03, 8 May 2010 (UTC) delete as a violation of Deletion of JT Southern WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4576 4683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Take Control (Dangerous Muse album) User:Lightburst 01:22, 15 November 2019 (UTC) delete I think this is Deletion of Take Control (Dangerous Muse album) WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4577 19463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diego Benzi User:Argyle 21:53, 28 March 2011 (UTC) delete Has not played in a fully professional league, failing , and has not received any significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject to pass Deletion of Diego Benzi WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4578 5960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liverpool F.C. 4–0 FC Barcelona User:Crowsus 20:21, 29 August 2020 (UTC) merge as it falls on the upper end of and , definitely a dramatic event and significant in the Euro histories of Liverpool and Barça, much of the content could be moved to their Euro articles if it hasn't already. But the result itself didn't break any records so I'm not really convinced of its long-term notability in terms of the scoreline itself, as the years pass it will likely be remembered that Liverpool got a big comeback, Barcelona had a defensive collapse (becoming their trademark) and Origi scored that mad goal from a corner, and that will be/already is recorded in various articles in some way Deletion of Liverpool F.C. 4–0 FC Barcelona WP:MILL||WP:RECENTISM Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
4579 11091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Square root of 5 User:Bearian 03:24, 12 August 2007 (UTC) keep per discussion above. Inherently notable, per malcomx15, and relevant to all sorts of things -- math education, number theory, the Golden mean, architecture and engineering. Now it is |snowing, folks Deletion of Square root of 5 WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
4580 704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radiohalo User:Happyme22 17:32, 18 May 2008 (UTC) delete Citations are badly needed and is an issue Deletion of Radiohalo WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4581 1542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VAPH User:Ilyushka88 09:22, 19 July 2016 (UTC) delete """per notability. Google search for ''""""VAPH""""'' gives results of some belgian company. Results for ''""""VAPH Shoes""""'' seem to be mostly retailers. Also, . Removing self promotion from the article would not leave with much content""" Deletion of VAPH WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4582 10225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orion 17 User:Artw 23:11, 13 July 2009 (UTC) keep I don't see grounds here Deletion of Orion 17 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4583 10355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devlin Waugh User:Gleeanon409 10:37, 28 November 2019 (UTC) comment Isn’t this a part of the Waugh universe? If so the reasonably developed content should be considered for merge efore deletion Deletion of Devlin Waugh WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
4584 14748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Army Public School and College (Pakistan) User:Darkness 17:03, 13 January 2012 (UTC) keep Roscelese says keep due to , this is an essay. However this essay in a nutshell says, ''High schools/secondary schools are generally considered to be notable, but they '''must be able to meet the relevant guidelines for notability''''' This school does not. Kudpung says keep as ''produced some highly notable alumni'' Notability is not inherited Deletion of Army Public School and College (Pakistan) WP:NHS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4585 6601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darkstar One User:Barno 01:26, 15 September 2005 (UTC) delete """promo for future product which has no ''current'' encyclopedic significance and no indication (verifiable or otherwise) that it ever will have encyclopedic significance, even if it meets the stated goals. One more space-sim game will not be sufficiently noteworthy unless it gets literally millions of users or generates some controversy widespread enough to get covered in major mainstream media or a bestselling book or something. (No, a few bits in the morass of gamer sites isn't enough by itself.) a gamer's guide. And I'll vote """"delete"""" on X3: Reunion if nominated, too, unless verifiable evidence of impact (not just """"a new game engine"""") is provided""" Deletion of Darkstar One WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4586 12677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dimitri Ehrlich User:Bearian 19:50, 27 July 2016 (UTC) delete he has a couple of credits listed at one reliable source, but requires |significant coverage in multiple sources. Maybe ''userfy'' if somebody is willing to work on this Deletion of Dimitri Ehrlich WP:BLP||WP:SIOGCOV Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4587 18289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/L. Dinaparna User:BlackJack 09:31, 1 October 2017 (UTC) keep per the above. Meets . If he did not, then would ensure deletion Deletion of L. Dinaparna WP:CRIN||WP:CRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4588 9988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sniper Elite (series) User:Zxcvbnm 21:14, 10 October 2017 (UTC) merge Per series page guidelines and , the current Sniper Elite should be moved to Sniper Elite: Berlin 1945 Deletion of Sniper Elite (series) WP:NATURAL Wikipedia:Article titles 75
4589 5647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beaner (2nd nomination) User:Yukichigai 23:43, 26 March 2007 (UTC) comment """Yes, that's right, call me stupid. Excellent way to hammer your point home. Now, ignorance of aside, let's address the issue of """"adding more dictionary article content"""": the article contains a brief, expandable summary of the term's history and subjective impact. All these bits of information are outside the scope of a dictionary definition; a dicdef would be limited to the meaning and useage of the word. -- |Y'''|""" Deletion of Beaner (2nd nomination) WP:CIVIL||WP:IKNOWBEST Wikipedia:Civility 37
4590 2865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 County Down helicopter crash User:Chris 20:20, 24 October 2010 (UTC) comment The level of notability used for air accidents seems to be a bit random. All of these have third-party media coverage, but I can't see a clear pattern for that does and doesn't fail . I don't want to go down the route of , but would it beneficial to have a proper discussion of how much coverage we expect for an air accident to be considered notable Deletion of 2010 County Down helicopter crash WP:NOTNEWS||WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4591 8255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wendy Valdez User:Niteshift36 00:47, 14 July 2011 (UTC) delete Just being a contestant on BB doesn't do it, nor does a list of guest appearences and minors roles. Fails Deletion of Wendy Valdez WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4592 17820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryona (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 17:13, 4 June 2010 (UTC) merge to sadism per Deletion of Ryona (2nd nomination) WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
4593 19217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Colegrove User:DARTH 13:03, 25 October 2010 (UTC) delete This looks like a failure at , non-notable Deletion of Daniel Colegrove WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4594 16357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avon Inflatables User:Piotrus 08:29, 15 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails as written, entry Deletion of Avon Inflatables WP:NCOMPANY||WP:YELLOWPAGES Wikipedia:Notability 77
4595 16350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Risque Disque User:Bearcat 05:49, 14 July 2017 (UTC) delete This was created (by me) at a different time in the evolution of Wikipedia's notability standards: all a record label had to do to be considered notable at the time was to have notable artists releasing music on it, and the sourcing didn't actually have to clear increasingly tough later standards like — it was enough to simply be able to verify that the claim to having had notable artists on it was true. But those aren't the standards that pertain today, and under contemporary standards I just can't find the sourcing needed to get it back up to snuff: all I get on a ProQuest search is glancing namechecks of its existence in coverage of either Blue Rodeo or Crash Vegas, not coverage ''about'' the label Deletion of Risque Disque WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
4596 7119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Hidden Jungle User:MarnetteD 21:56, 10 December 2015 (UTC) delete another fail from the SPAs Deletion of The Hidden Jungle WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4597 788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Introduction to the Monty Hall Problem User:Jasynnash2 11:51, 4 September 2008 (UTC) delete unneeded article. I'm sure good intentions abound but, this article is simply not needed and isn't a valid reason to keep the article Deletion of Introduction to the Monty Hall Problem WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4598 8854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caimeiju [[User talk:Lourdes|'''Lourdes''']] 05:22, 5 February 2017 (UTC) delete u|Exemplo347}} :D Fails ORG and |WEB Deletion of Caimeiju WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4599 19013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ken Davis User:AusLondonder 00:44, 26 January 2017 (UTC) delete """The fact the best claim to fame this guy has (per the lede) is that """"He is a long-term ally of controversial Republican National Committeeman Bob Asher, a mainstay in statewide and Montgomery County Republican politics"""" is evidence of his non-notability. springs to mind""" Deletion of Ken Davis WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4600 18860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wenyi Wang User:Horrorshowj 13:56, 10 September 2007 (UTC) keep 13 references meeting over more than a year period meets Cat 1 of . Has coverage for both the heckling incident and organ harvesting accusations. OP's disdain for article's subject appears to be primary reason for nomination Deletion of Wenyi Wang WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4601 5718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zach Light User:Poison 14:45, 6 January 2013 (UTC) keep Yes, this article meets Deletion of Zach Light WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
4602 15894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haunter User:Kung 01:29, 4 September 2021 (UTC) keep I'm going to go against the grain here, but I feel that even with small mentions regardless if they're lists or not if there's enough people giving reactions especially given how large Pokemon's cast is, that shows a sign of notability. The article does need improvement and '''better''' resources and statements to emphasize notability, but I disagree that it fails outright Deletion of Haunter WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4603 7253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bertram K. and Nina Fletcher Little User:JayJay 19:51, 10 July 2014 (UTC) keep Did you even bother to do a simple Google search. I can find plenty of sources that can satisfy , http://www.nytimes.com/1993/08/08/arts/a-family-totally-at-home-with-folk-art.html NY Times, http://articles.baltimoresun.com/1994-04-03/features/1994093193_1_folk-art-maryland-historical-society-museum-of-art Baltimore Sun, http://www.bostonglobe.com/lifestyle/travel/2013/09/07/trail-folk-art-essex-legendary-collectors-set-standard-for-ideal-antiques/cbd6Y0WmMt6IUy0ALbzhIM/story.html Boston Globe, http://www.seacoastonline.com/articles/20070708-ENTERTAIN-707080313 SeaCoastonline, http://articles.mcall.com/1997-08-01/features/3161477_1_folk-art-american-folk-art-folk-paintings The Morning Call, http://harvardmagazine.com/2001/07/protecting-special-place.html Havard Magazine. There are many other websites and books that are devoted and mention their collections of folk art over a period of 50 sum years. Also is a separate article on the historic museum they owned and still exists called Cogswell's Grant. and other collections are also featured in many other museums like Baltimore Museum of art Deletion of Bertram K. and Nina Fletcher Little WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4604 10310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Rage of Caliban User:Otto4711 22:23, 24 February 2007 (UTC) delete copy and paste from http://www.mala.bc.ca/~Johnstoi/essays/caliban.htm here which acknowledges that it's an essay, which runs afoul of #OR (whether it's user Franz-kafka's original thought or someone else's Deletion of The Rage of Caliban WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4605 9688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of MSX compatible computers User:LjL 02:36, 17 November 2015 (UTC) keep """antiquated"""" doesn't factor into the equation, as |notability is not temporary, and the MSX standard is certainly notable. A list where most of the items fail notability criteria (and as such don't have articles) is okay per """ Deletion of List of MSX compatible computers WP:NTEMP||WP:CSC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4606 21747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of computer and video games not released in the USA User:Kzrulzuall 10:03, 24 March 2007 (UTC) delete unmaintainable. Delete per Deletion of List of computer and video games not released in the USA WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4607 12762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luis Suárez racial abuse incident User:Aircorn 08:08, 12 January 2018 (UTC) comment I really really dislike this article and would love nothing more than for it to be deleted. It is a NPOV and BLP nightmare. However it clearly passes . Maybe it would be better off redirected to his main article, but it is probably alright in its present form. I just noticed Luis Suárez controversies which is ten times worse and should be deleted as a fork if nothing else. I see it was kept as ''no consenus'' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luis Suárez controversies three years ago. I think I will nominate it now Deletion of Luis Suárez racial abuse incident WP:GNG||WP:POV Wikipedia:Notability 77
4608 17051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glossopdale Bus Company User:Ritchie333 14:39, 30 January 2012 (UTC) keep Sorry, but I'm not sure you've |assumed good faith here. I think this was written by a newcomer to Wikipedia who has knowledge on this subject, probably from actual sources rather than first hand knowledge as such, but is unfamiliar with the correct procedure to cite reliable sources. I can see a http://companycheck.co.uk/company/02815080 Company Check reference and a http://www.speedwellbus.com/about/ page about the company, though the latter would be a primary source. Certainly a bus company running on regular and recognised routes in the UK for many years ought to qualify as notable - there must be other sources out there Deletion of Glossopdale Bus Company WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
4609 1167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Pathfinder books User:Mark 20:24, 8 November 2017 (UTC) merge to Pathfinder Roleplaying Game. This list-based article graduated from AfC into mainspace. This is obviously not indiscriminate, as there are clear inclusion criteria. Excessive detail is not a policy-based reason for deletion. Unencyclopedic is a vague term that is often a synonym for . (DGG, I know you can craft a better AfD rationale than this.) Anyway, it's good that the lists have some references, albeit they are mostly primary refs. I wasn't able to find in-depth independent sources discussing these books as a set. It likely fails notability criteria like . But given than the game is largely based on these books, it makes perfect sense to merge this content into the main Pathfinder article. Excessive information and catalogue-like info, such as the Code and Link columns, can be trimmed as a matter of routine editing. Per , a merge of content is preferred over deletion when there is verifiable material Deletion of List of Pathfinder books WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:GNG||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4610 9951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhamad Naji Subhi Al Juhani (3rd nomination) User:Metropolitan90 17:01, 9 February 2011 (UTC) delete Unless one buys into the idea that everyone who was detained at Guantanamo is automatically notable just because of that, I don't even see a claim to notability here. This individual was released from Guantanamo and repatriated to Saudi Arabia over 4 years ago, so if he wanted to tell his story to the media since then, he could have done so. But either (1) he didn't want to tell his story to the media, or (2) the media weren't interested in it, or (3) he did tell his story to the media but such reports have not been found and used as sources in this article. In any event, though, what is in this article now does not appear to justify a |biography of a living person Deletion of Muhamad Naji Subhi Al Juhani (3rd nomination) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4611 18552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manmohan Vaidya User:Bearcat 18:33, 8 April 2017 (UTC) delete A political party's campaign chair could qualify for a Wikipedia article on grounds if he could be |reliably sourced to a ''significant'' degree of media coverage — but he's not automatically entitled to one just because he exists, and ''one'' news article is not enough sourcing to get him over the bar Deletion of Manmohan Vaidya WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4612 16966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Res Ipsa (Philadelphia restaurant) User:Sdkb 03:36, 25 March 2021 (UTC) keep The nominator cites but seems to be operating by a standard ''far'' stricter than what that guideline dictates. Several of the reviews and other pieces of coverage are clearly not routine. {{u| Deletion of Res Ipsa (Philadelphia restaurant) WP:PRODUCTREV Wikipedia:Notability 77
4613 9667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyber Evolution User:Shadowjams 03:05, 25 May 2009 (UTC) comment I would remind users unfamiliar with wikipedia policies to 1) Be civil to other users and they will be likely to listen to you, and 2) wikipedia has specific criteria for inclusion at . No one doubts the site exists, just question its notability Deletion of Cyber Evolution WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4614 6912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inna Muddanu Mahalingeshwara User:Monty845 05:13, 27 August 2011 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability. While I would like to see some applied, the article creator is already making each new article with a different variation of the name, I doubt create protecting will be effective. It may just require application of CSD G4 to any future recreations Deletion of Inna Muddanu Mahalingeshwara WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
4615 21673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sobia Tahir User:David 06:33, 12 August 2017 (UTC) delete Listing in a directory is not enough for and we also don't have evidence of passing any criterion Deletion of Sobia Tahir WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
4616 1345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Private Jet Group User:Ahunt 18:10, 1 October 2010 (UTC) delete Clearly a CorpSpam article, the refs cited are just directory listings and do not establish notability to the degree required by Deletion of Private Jet Group WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4617 2321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019 California stabbing rampage user:Shrike 20:28, 9 August 2019 (UTC) keep Per also meets I added BBC source there are also Guardian https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/aug/08/california-stabbing-rampage-garden-grove Deletion of 2019 California stabbing rampage WP:RAPID||WP:DIVERSE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4618 19924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/$30 Film School User:Armbrust 15:14, 17 August 2010 (UTC) delete as article fails |notability criteria for books Deletion of $30 Film School WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4619 11433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fabian Benko (2nd nomination) User:Jimbo 16:37, 26 August 2016 (UTC) keep passes with enough media coverage Deletion of Fabian Benko (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4620 4865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greenwich Printmakers User:ThePointblank 07:36, 3 November 2008 (UTC) delete as per . Non-notable, is not covered by reliable secondary sources Deletion of Greenwich Printmakers WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4621 179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of films with surprise ending/plot twist User:Perfecto 14:56, 20 March 2006 (UTC) keep """The """"/plot twist"""" might be the problem. """"Surprise ending"""" is quite clear and definite - it will not be """"infinitely expandable"""". If you want a reliable source, well IMDB lists 34 of them.http://www.imdb.com/keyword/surprise-ending/ So it passes """ Deletion of List of films with surprise ending/plot twist WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
4622 18077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AFK Smetanova Lhota User:Cloudz679 05:30, 14 February 2015 (UTC) delete no evidence of |significant coverage, no evidence of playing in the Czech Cup|national cup, insufficient to warrant a Wikipedia article Deletion of AFK Smetanova Lhota WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
4623 20412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ghar Ka Chiraag (1967 film) User:Gab4gab 13:22, 28 May 2017 (UTC) comment It would lead to a better consensus discussion if editors would point to specific sources that satisfy specific notability criteria. Simply arguing without addressing the specifics of opposing points of view isn't a helpful a dialog Deletion of Ghar Ka Chiraag (1967 film) WP:LOTSOFSOURCES Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4624 19792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1972 Yi Xing User:Padenton 22:01, 17 May 2015 (UTC) merge per () No significant coverage found on this object itself. Everything on google scholar is a paper listing several asteroids (explicitly mentioned in NASTCRIT #3 as not meeting notability) or too little coverage to provide significant commentary on the object. There's a paper on it and another minor planet, but it does not appear to be significant coverage. ― Deletion of 1972 Yi Xing WP:NASTRO||WP:NASTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4625 1600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heidtman Steel User:Eggishorn 02:04, 28 December 2016 (UTC) delete advertising and web site copy by SPA that is apparently connected. No coverage that is not Deletion of Heidtman Steel WP:RS||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4626 6959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Climate change denial (3rd nomination) User:Brougham96 15:58, 29 August 2008 (UTC) comment I'm unclear on where in it says as long as you refence biased sources, a biased article is okay. Not to say every single source is biased, but quite a few of them are Deletion of Climate change denial (3rd nomination) WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
4627 3669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel O'Reilly (soccer player) User:GiantSnowman 16:58, 23 June 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Daniel O'Reilly (soccer player) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4628 5508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Gentile User:Johnuniq 08:12, 27 June 2009 (UTC) delete Article is just a promotion. No mentions the subject; fails Deletion of Richard Gentile WP:RS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4629 7796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2042 FIFA World Cup User:Tillerh11 19:31, 4 July 2018 (UTC) delete per all of the above as Deletion of 2042 FIFA World Cup WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4630 14995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Agnes Sina-Inakoju User:Mangoe 20:33, 26 January 2018 (UTC) delete per : coverage of a murder in London by British newspapers is expected and routine Deletion of Murder of Agnes Sina-Inakoju WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4631 14811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boris Pribich (2nd nomination) User:Stifle 19:06, 9 April 2008 (UTC) delete don't see how this meets Deletion of Boris Pribich (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4632 10342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti-globalization filmography User:Ajf773 00:57, 27 September 2020 (UTC) delete Subjective criteria for a list therefore is Deletion of Anti-globalization filmography WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4633 10600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Object-oriented software engineering User:StraussInTheHouse 12:17, 24 November 2020 (UTC) delete this is a |puff piece about Jacobson's approach. The article attempts to |inherit notability from the broad concept of object-oriented programming which has a similar title. It's basically |coatracking off another article and has demonstrated no |significant coverage in independent, reliable sources to suggest |notability. |Searches for such coverage turn up very little when restricted to Jacobson's approach. It perhaps merits a line in the aforementioned similarly titled article Deletion of Object-oriented software engineering WP:ADVERT||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:COATRACK||WP:42||WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Advertising 107
4634 11710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yarin Hassan User:TheSpecialUser 07:28, 22 June 2012 (UTC) delete It fails and Deletion of Yarin Hassan WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4635 14659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heralds of Unicron User:Steve 19:36, 1 September 2010 (UTC) delete An encyclopedia needs to be for facts (even when the article is about a fictional universe), not fans' opinions. riginal research Deletion of Heralds of Unicron WP:O Wikipedia:Orphan 47
4636 4100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Gasiorek User:Coredesat 19:44, 28 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Joe Gasiorek WP:BIO||WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
4637 16891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Trek: Enterprise alleged continuity problems (third nomination) User:Mangojuice 04:13, 16 June 2006 (UTC) delete transwiki if anyone cares to, natch): don't be fooled; though there are 5 references, they don't back up conclusions of discontinuity, just basic facts about the Star Trek universe. This is |original research; it's a new analysis of published work (namely the show), unless the ''conclusions'' the article tries to reach can be backed up Deletion of Star Trek: Enterprise alleged continuity problems (third nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4638 21205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/András Csonka User:GiantSnowman 15:56, 29 May 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of András Csonka WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4639 1133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prince Philippos of Greece User:Willthacheerleader18 14:16, 18 July 2021 (UTC) keep Prince Philippos of Greece and Denmark'', in accordance with the naming of articles of other members of the former Greek royal family. Appears to have enough coverage to pass , and all his other siblings have their own articles. Not to mention there are already articles for him on https://da.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prins_Philippos_af_Gr%C3%A6kenland/ Danish Wikipedia, https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ph%C3%ADlippos_de_Gr%C3%A8ce_(1986)\ French Wikipedia, https://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Filipe_da_Gr%C3%A9cia_e_Dinamarca_(1986)/ Portuguese Wikipedia, https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Felipe_de_Grecia/ Spanish Wikipedia, https://ca.wikipedia.org/wiki/Felip_de_Gr%C3%A8cia/ Catalan Wikipedia, https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philippos_van_Griekenland_en_Denemarken\ Dutch Wikipedia, https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%A4%D0%B8%D0%BB%D0%B8%D0%BF%D0%BF,_%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%B8%D0%BD%D1%86_%D0%93%D1%80%D0%B5%D1%86%D0%B8%D0%B8_%D0%B8_%D0%94%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%B8\ Russian Wikipedia, https://no.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philippos_av_Hellas_og_Danmark/ Norwegian Wikipedia, https://th.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E0%B9%80%E0%B8%88%E0%B9%89%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%8A%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%A2%E0%B8%9F%E0%B8%B4%E0%B8%A5%E0%B8%B4%E0%B8%9B%E0%B8%9B%E0%B8%AD%E0%B8%AA%E0%B9%81%E0%B8%AB%E0%B9%88%E0%B8%87%E0%B8%81%E0%B8%A3%E0%B8%B5%E0%B8%8B%E0%B9%81%E0%B8%A5%E0%B8%B0%E0%B9%80%E0%B8%94%E0%B8%99%E0%B8%A1%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%A3%E0%B9%8C%E0%B8%81\ Thai Wikipedia, https://uk.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%A4%D1%96%D0%BB%D1%96%D0%BF%D0%BF,_%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%B8%D0%BD%D1%86_%D0%93%D1%80%D0%B5%D1%86%D1%96%D1%97_%D1%82%D0%B0_%D0%94%D0%B0%D0%BD%D1%96%D1%97/ Ukrainian Wikipedia, https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E3%83%95%E3%82%A3%E3%83%AA%E3%83%83%E3%83%9D%E3%82%B9%E3%83%BB%E3%83%86%E3%82%A3%E3%82%B9%E3%83%BB%E3%82%A8%E3%83%A9%E3%82%B6%E3%82%B9_(1986-)/ Japanese Wikipedia, https://et.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phil%C3%ADppos_(Kreeka_ja_Taani_prints)/ Estonian Wikipedia, and https://mk.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%A4%D0%B8%D0%BB%D0%B8%D0%BF_(%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%B8%D0%BD%D1%86_%D0%BD%D0%B0_%D0%93%D1%80%D1%86%D0%B8%D1%98%D0%B0)/ Macedonian Wikipedia Deletion of Prince Philippos of Greece WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4640 900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derrick Noble User:Mdtemp 20:48, 5 February 2013 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet . Much of the article deals with people he's associated with, but that's Deletion of Derrick Noble WP:NMMA||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
4641 403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pasupati Group (2nd nomination) User:onel5969 12:28, 27 December 2020 (UTC) delete nothing has changed in the two days since the last discussion was closed, not enough in-depth coverage to pass either or . Just like the discussion of Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pasupati Agrovet Deletion of Pasupati Group (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
4642 9917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Selçuk özdemir User:David 04:44, 26 February 2009 (UTC) delete No evidence of passing . According to http://w3.gazi.edu.tr/~sozdemir/index_eng.htm his web page he's an assistant professor with a recent (2005) Ph.D.; although it's possible for someone at that level to already be notable for their academic achievements, it's unusual, and I don't see any signs of it in this case Deletion of Selçuk özdemir WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
4643 3813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Kleine User:Kugao 19:54, 15 January 2011 (UTC) keep I also agree that Major League Scouts should be considered notable, and the references in the article appear to demonstrate that he passes Deletion of Matt Kleine WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4644 9895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Complete list of candidates for the United States presidential election, 2016 User:Supernerd11 14:12, 17 February 2014 (UTC) delete per and . There's also no references saying anything about it, and if there were, it still wouldn't be good enough for an article Deletion of Complete list of candidates for the United States presidential election, 2016 WP:TOOSOON||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4645 18789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Talk.bizarre User:DarkAudit 13:13, 19 July 2008 (UTC) delete By standards, this is no more notable than your average web-based forum that has by and large replaced USENET. Google hits are nearly all for sites that archive USENET postings, just as some sites mirror Wikipedia. Google Groups is merely Google's own newsfeed. The hits in Google News' archive are either false positives, or cites as background for a wider article. Such a mention is not considered valid as a show of notability Deletion of Talk.bizarre WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4646 6600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anime Punch! User:AnmaFinotera 18:20, 12 June 2008 (UTC) delete unnotable organization. A single mention of one of its events in a magazine does not make it a |notable organization Deletion of Anime Punch! WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4647 11346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sakari Momoi (2nd nomination) User:Legacypac 06:51, 3 December 2018 (UTC) delete its a 1Event case - he was ''reported'' as the world's oldest man, but no one really knows because there is no central tracting of this. Beyond the repeated report we have nothing substantive. applies. His name belongs on the lists Deletion of Sakari Momoi (2nd nomination) WP:NOPAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4648 18771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ferid Celosmanovic User:Mkativerata 05:26, 14 April 2010 (UTC) delete Fails , and Deletion of Ferid Celosmanovic WP:ATH||WP:BIO||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
4649 1353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kudai's third studio album User:PC78 17:51, 7 February 2008 (UTC) delete per . The single reference is very weak, and this information is already covered in the band's article Deletion of Kudai's third studio album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4650 19221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derek Chauvin NONE NONE comment I don't really have a preference whether the biography of Chauvin is on a stand-alone page, or merged into another page. However, the policy and the guideline suggest having a separate article (not a redirect), whereas suggests a redirect, and suggests doing whichever is better for the reader's understanding Deletion of Derek Chauvin WP:BLP1E||WP:BIO1E||WP:CRIME||WP:PAGEDECIDE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4651 19460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nazam Shirazi User:Rugbyfan22 12:37, 29 April 2021 (UTC) merge Fails as ICC Trophy appearances weren't in a final. In terms of GNG I'm not seeing anything really that would constitute significant coverage, unless source 1 in the article is so, but then it would still only be one source as the others aren't significant coverage (one isn't even about him). Redirect a suitable and nominator may want to consider using this for some of the others in the previous bundle Deletion of Nazam Shirazi WP:CRIN||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
4652 15860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VPIN User:Mark 22:49, 2 September 2014 (UTC) keep """First of all, thanks goes to the nom for bringing this to AfD. Not enough people patrol PRODs for lack of action to be a reliable guide of article deficiency and this one certainly has enough sources to be a controversial deletion. A GScholar search for """"volume synchronized probability of informed trading"""" nets 67 results, including a few secondary sources, such as http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2173126812000344 From PIN to VPIN: An introduction to order flow toxicity and ''Bethel, E., David Leinweber, Oliver Rübel, and Kesheng Wu. """"Federal market information technology in the post flash crash era: roles for supercomputing."""" In Proceedings of the fourth workshop on High performance computational finance, pp. 23-30. ACM, 2011,'' in addition to the secondary sources in the article, e.g, WSJ. There seems to be enough content in reliables source to pass notability per and on which to build an article. The article itself is well-structured, but tagged with neutrality concerns. Fixing neutrality concerns is a matter of simple editing and not deletion; it is a problem. A notable topic and surmountable article problems suggests keeping the article""" Deletion of VPIN WP:GNG||WP:SURMOUNTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4653 842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nikulchev Evgeny User:Joe 23:35, 30 August 2016 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability. I'm not sure there's even a claim of notability; as the IP above pointed out, pro/vice-rector isn't a very prestigious or highly-ranked position. He's an academic, so could apply, but he has only a https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=9oTrPIIAAAAJ&hl=en&oi=ao string of poorly-cited papers, many in predatory vanity journals, and I couldn't find any indication that he meets any of the other criteria Deletion of Nikulchev Evgeny WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
4654 99 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Rivers and Beacon-Hills of Gondor User:Piotrus 04:44, 20 April 2020 (UTC) delete Most of Tolkien works have been studied to death, but right now I am also not seeing enough to make this essay notable. No, not everything penned by a notable author is notable, requires 2+ reviews, or other indications of impact, and this is not shown currently (Tolkien Encyclopedia discusses it in a single paragraph: https://books.google.co.kr/books?id=by0dzzQ6m8sC&pg=PA159&dq=%22The+Rivers+and+Beacon-Hills+of+Gondor%22+-wikipedia&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwioifH9mPboAhXFw4sBHf_MDGMQ6AEINjAC#v=onepage&q=%22The%20Rivers%20and%20Beacon-Hills%20of%20Gondor%22%20-wikipedia&f=false; I don't think that qualifies as in-depth treatment). The source cited by Hog Farm (https://www.elvish.org/Tengwestie/articles/Hostetter/sindll.phtml) would pass in-depth, but how reliable is https://www.elvish.org/Tengwestie/ Tengwestië The online journal of the Elvish Linguistic Fellowship? See also https://www.elvish.org//Elvish Linguistic Fellowship. I am afraid this may be not scholarly but just scholarly-like fan analysis. PS. Still, all things considered, I am leaning towards that source being in-depth and reliable. If anyone can show another source of similar or higher quality that is in-depth I'd be willing to change my vote to keep. But right now I am not seeing it, and one passable source is not enough in light of our policies Deletion of The Rivers and Beacon-Hills of Gondor WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4655 21179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs about California User:Hrafn 11:13, 7 May 2012 (UTC) delete """or replace with an EL to a search for the word """"California"""" in a lyrics databasejoke) -- blatantly and of no encyclopaedic use or value. Arbitrary intersection of the categories :Category:California and :Category:Songs, even if cleaned up. What next? A List of songs about the color black (blue, red, London, Berlin, Kintyre""" Deletion of List of songs about California WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4656 11295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Kahn User:DarkAudit 22:27, 8 December 2009 (UTC) comment """Baseball Reference does not list him as ever making it above the AA level, much less the majors. Just being on the 40-man roster is not really sufficient. Using another editor's opinion that the subject was notable as rationale for keeping is not enough. There has to be more concrete proof than """"that guy said he was notable"""". The """"National Team"""" you mention is not the true national team, but a team of college players tapped to play a series against Japanese college players. That is not a high enough amateur representation per . The Pitcher of the Year award is for the conference, not a national award. I'm dubious that it is a high enough award""" Deletion of Stephen Kahn WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4657 9005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cambrelo User:Coredesat 10:08, 25 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Cambrelo WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
4658 7621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Arnoux User:Neiltonks 19:57, 20 December 2019 (UTC) delete per Apart from basic biographical details, most of the article concerns allegations which are as yet unproven Deletion of Eric Arnoux WP:BLPCRIME Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4659 21148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gunay Aliyeva User:Dexxtrall 21:38, 17 May 2021 (UTC) delete Sources don't appear to add up to a person that would pass Deletion of Gunay Aliyeva WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4660 20275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bridgewater Bank User:scope_creep 21:32, 12 October 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Bridgewater Bank WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4661 12301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Onuh Justus Izuchukwu User:David 22:02, 25 June 2018 (UTC) delete After https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Onuh_Justus_Izuchukwu&type=revision&diff=847512678&oldid=847287704 removing sources that do not mention the subject there is nothing left. The linked Google Scholar profile is larded with publications not by the subject, so clearly unreliable, but even if it were reliable it wouldn't demonstrate a pass of . We also don't have a pass of any other notability guideline. And the editing history of the two copies of this article appear to both be heavily promotional and in violation of our policies on use of multiple accounts Deletion of Onuh Justus Izuchukwu WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
4662 1229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of entomology journals User:Andyjsmith 22:56, 1 July 2007 (UTC) comment This is well covered at . The essential question for any encyclopedia article is what useful information it conveys. This article lists the names of many journals but gives ''no information whatsoever'' about them, not even how to find them. Does this article actually tell anyone anything useful? If the name of one of these journals was replaced with The Beano would it alter the information content of the article? Compare with List of scientific journals in chemistry which has a ''ranked'' list of external links together with references to analyses of citations Deletion of List of entomology journals WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4663 3659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Scarlet Letter SparkTune User:Armbrust 19:27, 21 October 2010 (UTC) delete It is a non-notable |song without |reliable sources Deletion of The Scarlet Letter SparkTune WP:NSONGS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4664 3802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hi5teria User:HyperGaruda 04:54, 30 November 2016 (UTC) keep It looks like someone improved the previously sketchy sourcing. While I still have my doubts about the blog post in ''Viva'', the coverage in ''Republika'' and ''Tempo'' seems to satisfy Deletion of Hi5teria WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4665 13149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennings International School User:Jovanmilic97 19:49, 16 February 2019 (UTC) delete as it fails . There is no more presumed notability for secondary schools as it was discussed on RfC, so it is bound by significant coverage in reliable secondary sources and that is not present here. The references in the article are: primary, a listing, passing mention, passing mention, with my search consisting of listings of the school. It exists, but that is not enough. Even the Keep voter himself admits there isn't indepth coverage. Enough said Deletion of Jennings International School WP:NSCHOOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4666 19474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Ortag User:Dane2007 06:53, 4 September 2016 (UTC) delete Fails as well as Deletion of Christian Ortag WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4667 11387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Netherlands Institute of International Relations Clingendael User:Arch 04:52, 14 January 2019 (UTC) keep Coverage such as https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2018/04/19/de-wereld-woedt-ook-clingendael-moet-vechten-a1600032 this and https://www.ad.nl/den-haag/nieuwe-directeur-voor-instituut-clingendael~a2f464da/ this leads me to believe the organization easily meets . Other governments have touted visits indicating its international importance (GO).https://www.president-ksgov.net/en/news/president-thaci-traveled-to-the-hague-delivers-a-lecture-at-the-clingendael-institutehttps://valtioneuvosto.fi/en/article/-/asset_publisher/minister-lehtomaki-at-the-clingendael-institute-of-the-netherlands Perhaps people would have more luck finding substantial coverage by searching for ''Instituut Clingendael'' in Dutch Deletion of Netherlands Institute of International Relations Clingendael WP:N||WP:NGO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4668 7245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anne Hendershott User:David 23:26, 24 August 2019 (UTC) keep Multiple published book reviews (several already in the article at the time of nomination) give her a pass of . The nomination statement is vacuous and provides no evidence that the nominator has attempted to check the notability of the subject Deletion of Anne Hendershott WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
4669 21552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kunlé Adeyemi User:Stuartyeates 07:43, 9 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Kunlé Adeyemi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4670 1447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/InterQuest Group User:EuroCarGT 01:27, 3 October 2013 (UTC) delete Sources are not reliable and requires additional primary, secondary and teritary sources. Most of the sources are to there website. The article tone sounds like a company portfolio and many not meet Deletion of InterQuest Group WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4671 14025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moneygall Aerodrome User:Guliolopez 11:48, 18 March 2019 (UTC) delete per nom. And the additional input which {{u|Mccapra}} provides. Whether or not the subject here still exists seems pretty clear. It does not. (A small grass strip does appear http://map.geohive.ie/mapviewer.html?webmap=7458e029654049e0b712a301de16d981 aerial imagery from 2005 but is entirely ploughed through (and a house built) http://map.geohive.ie/mapviewer.html?webmap=d9fac0641545474194abedd1e2b177e6 by 2011-2013.) Whether or not the subject here ever met guidelines or the advice proposed under is less clear. That said, personally I'm not seeing it. As far as I can see, this was a small private landing strip that wasn't subject to coverage beyond a few directory-style listings. I can't see how it meets the inclusion criteria Deletion of Moneygall Aerodrome WP:GNG||WP:NAIRPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4672 584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black by Popular Demand User:Esradekan 08:26, 12 July 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per #Albums Deletion of Black by Popular Demand WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4673 5138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heavy metal fashion User:Wisdom89 23:06, 10 March 2008 (UTC) keep Requires citations, but is definitely culturally relevant. Also, is not a reason to delete. It's a reason to improve Deletion of Heavy metal fashion WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
4674 7725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hit Back User:Collectonian 23:34, 12 March 2010 (UTC) delete Unnotable film with no significant coverage in reliable, third-party sources. Being listed in diretory sites like IMDB and Allmovie does not confer notability, and IMDB is user-edited. Film fails and Deletion of Hit Back WP:NF||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4675 14263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MTV's Oddities User:Badger 11:52, 19 October 2011 (UTC) keep """This wasn't a """"show"""", rather it was a """"slot"""" (similar to Nick at Nite, Nicktoons, or Adult Swim - for some reason Viacom does this a lot), so it's unsurprising there are no DVDs of it (there aren't any DVDs of """"Prime Time"""", either). All of the shows featured in this slot have had DVD releases (http://www.amazon.com/Maxx-Complete-Michael-Haley/dp/B002WJHDJI/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1319024194&sr=8-1 The Maxx, http://www.amazon.com/The-Head-Complete-Series/dp/B002WJHDIO/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1319024215&sr=8-1 The Head). The article is in absolutely ''wretched'', piss-poor shape (owing in no small part to someone copy-pasting text from other articles in violation of the GFDL - http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=MTV%27s_Oddities&action=historysubmit&diff=448536434&oldid=444844463 after I removed this text, the article became the stubbiest of stubs), but it seems to meet (""""Generally, an individual radio or television program is likely to be notable if it airs on . . . a cable television network with a national audience""""). A '''merge''' isn't a particularly good solution here, as this particular slot was rather short-lived and obscure in the grand scheme of things and would be somewhat on the main MTV article (it'd be like having a """"Chevy Chase Show"""" section on FOX). I could understand a """"delete with no prejudice towards recreation"""", but - based on my reading of - this does seem to pass """ Deletion of MTV's Oddities WP:TVSERIES||WP:UNDUE||WP:TVSERIES||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4676 14062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/York School (Toronto) User:Noroton 02:47, 16 July 2007 (UTC) keep """Plenty of sources have been added since the original nomination, although editors who voted at the beginning don't seem to have kept up with the changes. As states: """" The number and nature of reliable sources needed varies depending on the depth of coverage and quality of the sources. Multiple sources are generally preferred."""" The Blue Book entry is longer than many newspaper articles and appears independent. That combined with the several other sources of lesser quality is more than enough to satisfy Wikipedia notability""" Deletion of York School (Toronto) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4677 15414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jerry Jones Jr. User:Paulmcdonald 13:32, 27 November 2019 (UTC) keep I'm finding sources all over the place supporting passage of . Certainly the article content needs to be brought up to that same level, but the subject matter itself clearly passes notability threshold. Although the article is stubby, that is fixable. Let's not |confuse stub status with non-notability. In my view, this is a case where editing is the answer, not deletion Deletion of Jerry Jones Jr. WP:GNG||WP:CONFUSESTUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4678 10816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jada Facer User:Bondegezou 15:57, 21 June 2019 (UTC) keep 10 episodes of Melissa & Joey might be considered to meet . As per Uncle G, the first citation is good. The last has merit too. I'd say this sneaks in as a pass Deletion of Jada Facer WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
4679 5048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Panos Armenakas (2nd nomination) User:GiantSnowman 08:58, 10 May 2015 (UTC) delete clearly fails , the question is whether or not he meets - this is a close one, but I'd be inclined to say the coverage is not significant enough / slightly too to satisfy GNG Deletion of Panos Armenakas (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4680 3938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hair by Mr. Bean of London User:Sam 22:24, 12 February 2017 (UTC) keep """per the |notability guideline for TV-series and per long established precedent in : """"Television series broadcast nationally by a major network or produced by a major studio are usually kept as they are considered notable."""" I think it is fair to say that ''Mr. Bean'' has been widely broadcasted and rebroadcasted ''internationally'' for the past 25+ years, according to http://www.firstpost.com/entertainment/mr-bean-rides-again-rowan-atkinson-celebrates-25th-anniversary-of-show-at-buckingham-palace-2423830.html the video here in """"190 territores around the world"""". We have the parent article at ''Mr. Bean'' (not nominated for deletion), we have the episode list at List of Mr. Bean episodes|List of ''Mr. Bean'' episodes (not nominated for deletion), and then we have 15 individual episode articles (all are up for |unbundled deletion). This structure is the accepted standard per Wikipedia:Manual of Style/Television and is fine per with a {{tl|Main}} in Mr. Bean|''Mr. Bean''#Episodes per . Lack of {{tq|information on the episode's production}} is not a -REASON|policy based reason for deletion, it is not even an article requirement, see . A few words {{tq|on its reception when broadcast}} would certainly be nice, but is not mandatory, see , and again, its absence is not a policy based reason for deletion, it's a argument. I agree with nom that most of these 15 articles are poorly sourced, but it is a argument to be avoided, as -T (policy) specifically suggests tagging for such problems, and because |notability is based on the existence of suitable sources, not on the state of sourcing in an article. And finally there is the question: why take these article to AfD in the first place instead of considering -M (policy) into List of Mr. Bean episodes|List of ''Mr. Bean'' episodes or a -R solution (policy)? If the titles did not exist and were requested at /R, I would not hesitate with responding to the request by creating them as |categorized {{tlx|R to TV episode list entry}} redirects""" Deletion of Hair by Mr. Bean of London WP:TVSERIES||WP:BCASTOUTCOMES||WP:BUNDLE||WP:SPINOFF||WP:SS||WP:DEL||WP:TVPRODUCTION||WP:TVRECEPTION||WP:NOTBUILT||WP:UNRS||WP:ATD||WP:NEXIST||WP:ATD||WP:ATD||WP:AFC||WP:RCAT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4681 4630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Last Tormentor User:Colapeninsula 09:01, 28 September 2012 (UTC) merge or '''redirect''' to Gorgoroth per . Not a notable recording Deletion of The Last Tormentor WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4682 7314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Association of Geomagnetism and Aeronomy User:RockMagnetist 21:46, 8 July 2016 (UTC) keep easily satisfies |GNG. There are three reliable, independent sources that discuss it at length and are already cited for much of the material in this article: Lastovicka (2009); Thébault et al. (2015); Gubbins and Herrero-Bervera (2007). The 2008 tags should have been removed long ago Deletion of International Association of Geomagnetism and Aeronomy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4683 2181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tatyana Arntgolts User:SwisterTwister 02:09, 18 December 2012 (UTC) keep per meeting ,http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1708631/filmotype and . As offered by Deletion of Tatyana Arntgolts WP:ENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4684 3888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nancy Vandal User:Petaholmes 00:38, 19 January 2006 (UTC) keep well known Australian band, with several albums, meets Deletion of Nancy Vandal WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4685 14003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Japan Airlines Flight 472 (1972) (2nd nomination) User:WilliamJE 16:07, 9 January 2012 (UTC) comment Write off doesn't mean a incident automatically qualifies for an article. Here's Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philippine Airlines Flight 421|an example of a incident where the article was merged into the incidents section of the aircraft involved. A writeoff must still meet Deletion of Japan Airlines Flight 472 (1972) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4686 8480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Academy of Learning College (2nd nomination) User:Bejnar 20:46, 22 June 2020 (UTC) delete """as Wikipedia:College and university article guideline#Notability makes clear, an institution of higher learning must still pass the |general notability guideline. It is also appropriate to consider the guidelines at . """"Academy of Learning College"""" has since been renamed """"Academy of Learning Career College"""" and known as AOLCC. The first source is a press release from AOLCC, and thus is neither independent nor |reliable. The second is a reworking of a press release from Launchlife, the parent company for AOLCC, and thus is neither independent nor |reliable. The second source also only mentions AOLCC in passing as an asset of Launchlife. LaunchLife International Inc. is the Franchising|franchisor for Academy of Learning Career College, Pitman Training, and School Is Easy Tutoring. So AOLCC is not so much a set of campuses, as a set of franchisee locations. For what it is worth AOLCC is '''not''' https://www.bbb.org/ca/on/richmond-hill/profile/continuing-education/academy-of-learning-0107-1073051 Better Business Bureau accredited. As ZoomInfo (a blacklisted site) indicates at """"LaunchLife International Inc. - Overview, News & Competitors"""" there is nothing there. An extensive Google search found nothing but related websites, directory information, and blog and facebook entries. The one exception was the mention in ''South Africa Law Reports'' where a franchisee was estimating how much it would cost to set up an Academy of Learning college. There is no basis for notability""" Deletion of Academy of Learning College (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:ORG||WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4687 19719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Howard (academic) User:LargelyRecyclable 03:49, 16 December 2017 (UTC) keep He objectively meets Criteria #8 and arguably meets # 3 of cademic. I don't understand the assertions to the contrary and, therefore, I see nothing that meets the criteria for deletion Deletion of Bob Howard (academic) WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
4688 980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Sanford User:Bagumba 08:01, 17 August 2011 (UTC) delete Fails , having never played at highest level. NSPORTS does not automatically assume notability by merely being on the active roster. This is a un-of-the-mill player who does not deserve a standalone article. He also fails with lack of non-OUTINE|routine coverage in multiple independent reliable sources. would suggest not to speculate on future notability based on whether the undrafted player ever plays in the NFL Deletion of Brian Sanford WP:NSPORTS||WP:R||WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4689 2629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greek Catholic Church, Şimleu Silvaniei User:Xanchester 20:11, 24 October 2012 (UTC) delete Church was recently built and it's |too soon for it to be either culturally or historically significant. There are no reliable secondary sources demonstrating its notability, and a search for http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Greek+Catholic+Church%22+%22Simleu+Silvaniei%22&btnG=Search&hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws news articles doesn't bring up anything. The subject does not meet the |general notability guidelines Deletion of Greek Catholic Church, Şimleu Silvaniei WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4690 20907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Heraldry Society User:Piotrus 13:28, 18 May 2016 (UTC) delete Not seeing anything but passing mentions in Google Books. As the article doesn't show any references suggesting any coverage of the topic, I say delete per failure of and Deletion of American Heraldry Society WP:NORG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
4691 6660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Schmitz User:Nsk92 17:42, 15 August 2008 (UTC) delete A retired semi-professional athlete, does not pass Deletion of Brian Schmitz WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4692 16672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Catalyst (single) User:JamesBurns 01:14, 6 January 2009 (UTC) delete non-notable song Deletion of Catalyst (single) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4693 14002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lakewood Football (2nd nomination) User:WilliamJE 13:32, 24 October 2019 (UTC) delete Not notable sports team. also applies Deletion of Lakewood Football (2nd nomination) WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4694 4937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of psychedelic rock songs User:Otto4711 00:52, 11 February 2007 (UTC) delete as indiscriminate subjective list, rife with and issues Deletion of List of psychedelic rock songs WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4695 7141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Chaney (Australian businessman) User:Capitalistroadster 01:32, 4 March 2007 (UTC) keep and '''cleanup'''. On the board of two of the top 10 Australian companies and the director of another notable Australian company Wesfarmers see http://www.seven.com.au/sundaysunrise/finance_041107_chaney. While the article needs a cleanup, Chaney definitely meets Deletion of Michael Chaney (Australian businessman) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4696 11687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Her Majesty's Wizard User:Orangemike 21:29, 16 July 2010 (UTC) merge into a single article on the series. Not Stasheff's most commerically successful work, but certainly a lot more notable than much of what passes for notability among books here (I know, almost an argument). The series is discussed, for example, in Buker's ''The science fiction and fantasy readers' advisory: the librarian's guide to cyborgs, aliens, and sorcerers'' and one or more of the books were reviewed in various fantasy-friendly publications Deletion of Her Majesty's Wizard :WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4697 14888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shorthand-Aided Rapid Keyboarding User:Zordrac 19:48, 29 November 2005 (UTC) merge with ShapeWriter (or whatever name it goes with) and also page in case someone gets here by accident. Quite valid to list it as it seems to be topical enough to pass and Deletion of Shorthand-Aided Rapid Keyboarding WP:WEB||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
4698 4861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Todd Friel User:Springnuts 22:33, 15 December 2008 (UTC) delete """Extraordinary. I am certain I have heard of him, yet I am in a different continent and we do not move in the same circles. So I find the lack of reliable, independent and substantial sources very odd, but compelling from a Wiki-notability point of view. Comes closest, maybe, to being a |creative professional ... or to being an |entertainer - he may have a """"large fan base or a significant 'cult' following"""" ... but I come back to the lack of reliable, substantial, independent sources. My heart wants to |make an exception here but my wiki-head says he is better deleted for now and re-created when he is (in the Wiki sense) notable""" Deletion of Todd Friel WP:CREATIVE||WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:IAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
4699 447 [[Gwen Raverat]] (erl.) Benutzer:Wo st 01 NONE delete """Enkelin von""""'' begründet alleine noch keine |Relevanz. Kennt jemand das Buch, so dass Relevanz ggf. belegt wird""" Löschung von Gwen Raverat Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4700 21626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akiko Hatsu User:Xymmax 13:34, 18 September 2008 (UTC) keep based on the subject's role in orginating the concept of yaoi, and the volume of her work. Assuming the link I cited above in reply to Nsk92 is accurate, I feel her role is sufficient to meet Deletion of Akiko Hatsu WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4701 19203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Idea economy User:Vcessayist 00:30, 7 October 2012 (UTC) delete """per . Articles of this type can probably be developed with a few spotty sources that mention """"ideas"""" and """"economics"""", but we're trying to write articles about established knowledge, not summaries of opinion pieces and how some hot jargon is used and misused. Go ahead and redirect this to an article about economics if someone finds a suitable target""" Deletion of Idea economy WP:NEOLOGISM Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
4702 3175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tango en Tres User:Gm545 12:10, 2 January 2014 (UTC) delete Completely unsourced and even if it wasn't, there's nothing sufficient enough to make it past Deletion of Tango en Tres WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4703 16717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonnie West User:N2e 21:33, 16 January 2011 (UTC) delete notability not demonstrated in a |reliable secondary source. He was a college student who played ball Deletion of Jonnie West WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4704 7252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avaya FAST Stacking User:P199 13:59, 8 September 2011 (UTC) delete Agree with North8000. It's just product info that doesn't belong on WP ( Deletion of Avaya FAST Stacking WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4705 19196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Things (film) User:Newshunter12 05:29, 18 June 2019 (UTC) delete Per the nom. This whole article needs and can come back if someone finds actually significant and reliable sources for it. It's a complete mess on every level at the moment. The COI issue also means this article should be vigorously uprooted so as not to reward corruption on Wikipedia Deletion of Things (film) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
4706 1517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gregory P. Leichner User:Coredesat 04:10, 30 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Gregory P. Leichner WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
4707 13915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susannah Fullerton User:GretLomborg 05:56, 17 July 2017 (UTC) delete """per nom and Duffbeerforme. Article mainly written by a whose userpage (https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Libbycat50&oldid=692938439) has a link to some kind of online marketing/SEO website misleadingly labeled """"Independent web developer,"""" which is not adequate disclosure for me. Per , this article should be ed to discourage such behavior. I don't think any volunteer editors should waste their time earning the paid editor her fee""" Deletion of Susannah Fullerton WP:SPA||WP:COI||WP:NOTPROMOTION||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
4708 21062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chelsea Tavares User:Ron 02:19, 10 December 2010 (UTC) delete I think she barely passed but this is a |BLP and the sourcing isn't there and I'm not finding anything significant at google news. Having a recurring role in 2 TV shows you would think there would be a little more buzz about her Deletion of Chelsea Tavares WP:NACTOR||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4709 17788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frederick Goold User:James500 19:56, 31 December 2019 (UTC) keep Satisfies and criteria 3 of WP:ANYBIO Deletion of Frederick Goold WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4710 8435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skyquake (Transformers) User:Piotrus 14:02, 9 December 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Skyquake (Transformers) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4711 18903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twodeadsluts Onegoodfuck User:Proto 14:15, 31 March 2006 (UTC) delete fails to achieve the level of notability required by Deletion of Twodeadsluts Onegoodfuck WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4712 13900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert A. Rees User:Stalwart111 04:42, 22 December 2014 (UTC) keep the article is full of nonsense like his entire teaching history and stuff like his future publications. It reads like a (bloated) LinkedIn profile. That said, it would seem his actual publications make him notable enough for inclusion. It needs cleaning up and cutting back but deletion isn't the solution, I don't think. But I'm happy to discuss that in greater detail Deletion of Robert A. Rees WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4713 1481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Wright (2nd nomination) User:Hello32020 21:37, 30 November 2006 (UTC) delete per #Articles|CSD A7 and #General_criteria|G4 criteria Deletion of Sean Wright (2nd nomination) WP:CSD||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
4714 18670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Imperial election of 1376 User:Kusma 10:28, 22 November 2017 (UTC) keep discuss on the talk page. Both the previous structure (all in one page) and the current structure (lots of pages) are possible models for the organisation of this content. At the very least, the page titles need to exist as redirects (perfectly valid link targets). The idea that there could be a problem with or is fairly laughable Deletion of Imperial election of 1376 WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4715 14426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fifth International User:Tomwsulcer 14:52, 10 July 2014 (UTC) keep but agree with many of the problematic issues with the article raised above. I think the lede paragraph should state quite clearly that it is an amorphous hypothetical concept, used in different ways and times by different people, meaning different things, as well as trying to circumscribe the commonalities (eg, pro-workers, socialist, international movement). Agree with {{U|Gzuufy}} that it is allowable per , in that while the 5th Intl may not exist as an actual organization, it exists as a concept of one, and the concept as such is real and has a meaning. Another problem touched on above is that there could be POV issues, in the sense that merely having an article on an organization which does not exist, can have an advocacy-effect, in the sense that Wikipedia may be seen as advocating for the creation of this organization merely by having an article on it. So care must be used in the article, but I do not see that as grounds for deletion Deletion of Fifth International WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4716 3584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quran code (4th nomination) User:Chalst 13:07, 15 July 2021 (UTC) keep it's an unconvincing write-up of a dubious concept and most of the sources that exist for it highlight the topsy-turvy lingo we have where calls them ''reliable'', however, the concept is sufficiently visible, the sourcing goes beyond what is appropriate for a section of the Rashad Khalifa article and the Martin Gardner articles show that it is possible to write both well and objectively about the topic and the text analysis article I gave is also usable. I'd nominate {{u|Trijnstel}} for except this is her first AfD nom in 8 years: even with a no consensus result at AfD, one should normally wait at least six weeks before nominating unless there is an exceptional rationale: so soon after a keep close with no new information, the right thing to do is to challenge the close on . I found {{u|Barkeep49}}'s close uncharacteristically weak: {{u| Eggishorn}} made a strong OR case that was not refuted, and the nom {{u|Hemiauchenia}}'s case that the sourcing was too weak to justify recreation was not really disputed; ''no consensus'' or relisting would have been better options. &mdash Deletion of Quran code (4th nomination) WP:V||WP:TROUT||WP:TNT||WP:DRV Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4717 10289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kigo (Kim Possible) User:TheBlueFlamingo 23:21, 1 January 2007 (UTC) delete per iction, and above Deletion of Kigo (Kim Possible) WP:F Wikipedia:Non-free content 99
4718 20159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sadaf abdul jabbar User:AllyD 20:18, 27 July 2013 (UTC) delete """possibly speedy A7. Having a job in the media (or a """"carrer"""" as this article would have it), is not of encyclopaedic notability. No |evidence that the subject meets the biographical notability criteria""" Deletion of Sadaf abdul jabbar :WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4719 2334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryanair Flight 4102 (2nd nomination) User:Mjroots 17:06, 7 October 2020 (UTC) keep An aircraft that is almost new was written off. Such a course of action is not taken lightly. This is not your |run of the mill birdstrike. Lack of fatalities ≠ lack of notability Deletion of Ryanair Flight 4102 (2nd nomination) WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
4720 5615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 FIFA World Cup Third Place Play-Off User:X96lee15 11:41, 11 July 2014 (UTC) delete As of now, the article is merely receiving coverage. Does not meet Deletion of 2014 FIFA World Cup Third Place Play-Off WP:ROUTINE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4721 1935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Martian canals User:Britishfinance 20:22, 21 February 2019 (UTC) keep The topic of Martian canals is notable (they have an WP article). I have added links to articles in Nature and Scientific American about them. Obviously the theory turned out to be bogus but that does not diminish from the considerable time and investigation by leading academics (plus wider public) in this issue (there are loads of references to this topic on any google search). My issue however is where this exact list came from? I have added external links to PDF copies of Lovell's book and the relevant Chapter IV on the Canals. However, I am not sure how this list compares (it is not a direct extraction). I guess we still have a potential issue (but not a notability issue), but given that the lists/diagrams exist, it it solvable task, and clearly someone went to great trouble to complete this list many years ago implying that it is probably right. However, all of this should no prevent the article from being kept Deletion of List of Martian canals WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4722 10288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blood libel (U.S. political term) [[User talk:94.9.9.162|talk]]) 23:50, 12 January 2011 (UTC) delete Its an attempt to separate Palin's use of an anti-semitic term from Sarah Palin. It isn't a US political term, its a bad choice of words. Put the fact she decided to go on the defensive with anti-semitic words on a day of mourning on her article, not a new one. . Special:Contributions/94.9.9.162|94.9.9.162 Deletion of Blood libel (U.S. political term) WP:NOTNEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
4723 12315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TalkFree User:onel5969 03:26, 29 December 2020 (UTC) delete meets neither or Deletion of TalkFree WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
4724 16770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moving the Earth User:I 19:21, 13 March 2017 (UTC) keep References are good enough for Deletion of Moving the Earth WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4725 1471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vandita Dhariyal User:Accesscrawl 03:06, 4 November 2018 (UTC) keep Passes and . Sources mentioned in RS are reliable Deletion of Vandita Dhariyal WP:GNG||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4726 303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atheist Universe User:Horselover 20:08, 29 October 2009 (UTC) delete Fails to meet Deletion of Atheist Universe WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4727 9225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wipipedia (2 nomination) User:Kinu 18:55, 23 December 2006 (UTC) comment """Many articles are listed, relisted, and listed again at AfD; most of these are good-faith attempts to benefit the project, and this appears to be one of those cases. To say that ''it was kept once already, so it should be kept again'' is circular logic: if indeed the article should be kept this time as well, there should be valid arguments to that point, rather than the simple fact that it did survive a previous attempt for ''x'' reason. Establishing a consensus, and reaffirming that consensus, hardly constitutes double jeopardy; the quality of the article can change over time, facts about the subject of the article can change over time, and so on, and comparing the article then to the article now may ultimately be comparing apples and oranges, rather than (to continue the example) """"trying the same article twice"""". Regardless, bear in mind that double jeopardy or anything to that effect is not a policy, nor is it a guideline. Notability, however, is a guideline, and regardless of the outcome of the first AfD and/or the reason the original administrator closed it as a keep, the article should be able to (but as far as I can see, does not) stand on its own merits... and I will repeat myself: those recommending to keep are advised to find |reliable sources indicating if and how the notability guidelines are met""" Deletion of Wipipedia (2 nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4728 21379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dow-Key Microwave User:OnePt618 04:17, 6 February 2020 (UTC) delete Zero references, doesn't seem to pass .-- φ Deletion of Dow-Key Microwave WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4729 12207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finny Samuel User:Starblind 14:19, 6 March 2014 (UTC) delete appears to be . No evidence this is a popular or well-known drink Deletion of Finny Samuel WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
4730 6251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ajeesh Dasan User:Bearian 13:10, 2 August 2019 (UTC) delete WP:MILL|run of the mill songwriter and poet. Getting a song into a film |does not automatically make you notable Deletion of Ajeesh Dasan WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4731 1580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/18+ (band) User:Northamerica1000 16:04, 4 April 2015 (UTC) keep Meets . E.g. http://www.laweekly.com/music/is-18-an-art-project-or-a-band-maybe-both-5334797, http://www.clashmusic.com/features/next-wave-623-18, http://www.theguardian.com/music/2014/nov/09/18-plus-trust-review-r-and-b-duo-inscrutable, http://www.irishtimes.com/culture/music/18-trust-1.2067241 Deletion of 18+ (band) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4732 6216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pauli Antoine User:Green 20:32, 17 October 2013 (UTC) delete The ''Female Network'' sources count as a single source for notability purposes. The remaining sources are trivial mentions or primary sources. Does not pass Deletion of Pauli Antoine WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4733 18521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charlton Davies User:Jimbo 08:21, 1 September 2008 (UTC) delete as the original PRODer. Clearly fails notability at , recreate if and when he makes an appearance in a fully-professional league or competition Deletion of Charlton Davies WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4734 2414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Troubled identity User:Fbifriday 06:29, 29 November 2009 (UTC) delete Most sources appear to be myspace, facebook, or self-generated sources. Fails Deletion of Troubled identity WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4735 1907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cristofer Duarte User:Editorofthewiki 01:05, 30 July 2008 (UTC) delete This practically reads as spam. Fails and . --I'm an '''''Special:Contributions/Editorofthewiki|Editor Deletion of Cristofer Duarte WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4736 3904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shadowban User:Seed 06:34, 7 June 2007 (UTC) delete per above and nom. A little context for those uninvolved with the issue: Fark.com redesigned their website in late April of this year without consulting with their userbase or even prior announcement, which was a bit unusual. There was some uproar among its users, many claimed they had canceled their paid subscriptions and some users started a spin-off site. Almost since back then, members of that site have tried to get that site's domainname into the main Fark article which has lead to an extended edit war (please check http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Fark.com&action=history the article's history), full page protection, semi-protection less than 24 hours after it was unprotected and an extended discussion on the Talk:Fark.com|Fark.com talk page. Yesterday, there was even a thread on their site specifically announcing that the article was good to be edited by unregistered users again.This article is another, albeit somewhat clever, attempt at getting the domain name into the article. I strongly assume that this not so much out of a genuine desire to write an article about 'Shadowbanning' but the result of the realization that adding the domainname to the article by itself, as part of major sites like reddit and digg, as part of that article's 'Filters' section (all of which can be easily verified by checking the history) and now as a separate 'criticism' section will quickly result in a revert. Fact is, It's still a non-notable website and the article still lacks reliable sources for a very simple reason: there are none. The screen shots are and this has been explained in detail by multiple users, myself included, again and again. (FD: I wasn't involved in the edit war in any way, shape or form but I am keeping an eye on the article since I requested its unprotection after about a month of full protection.) This attempt at self-promotion has taken up way too much time already that could have been spent doing something productive. Hence, my !vote Deletion of Shadowban WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4737 14182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cloudreach User:Anupmehra 23:49, 2 February 2015 (UTC) delete There are few independent coverage but they mostly are short/passing mentions and do not help subject to reach the standard Deletion of Cloudreach WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
4738 2190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BS.Player (2nd nomination) User:Bejnar 22:13, 7 August 2014 (UTC) delete for lack of ''significant'' coverage in independent eliable sources|reliable sources. Fails Deletion of BS.Player (2nd nomination) WP:R||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Redirect 56
4739 18894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angel Eyes (porn star) User:SunStar 12:05, 2 February 2007 (UTC) delete This article has nothing in it that asserts the notability of the subject, and nothing of note that would satisfy |Wikipedia's policy on articles relating to pornographic actors. Of course, if it later transpires that something happens that ''does'' make the subject notable enough for encyclopedic inclusion, then people can always ask for a |deletion review Deletion of Angel Eyes (porn star) WP:PORNBIO||WP:DRV Wikipedia:Notability 77
4740 19582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rich Perez (2nd nomination) User:K 04:15, 11 August 2016 (UTC) delete non notable per and better sources do not appear to exist Deletion of Rich Perez (2nd nomination) WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4741 5260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Titus (2nd nomination) User:Robofish 12:27, 21 February 2010 (UTC) delete I'm inclined to agree that this is virtually a case of . Technically it isn't, as the news stories cover more than a single event, but I'm not convinced there's real longterm notability here: this is just a case of a man who was convicted of rape and then had his conviction overturned, with no indication of what makes it particularly important. The strongest claim to being article-worthy is that the coverage of the story won the Pulitzer prize; but so have many other news stories, and does that make them all notable? I don't think so (if anything, it's a claim to the notability of the person who wrote the article instead Deletion of Steve Titus (2nd nomination) WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4742 11213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sonic The Hedgehog Online User:Hit 11:37, 7 August 2006 (UTC) delete Doesn't seem particularly notable, even among mods, and it's pretty |crystal ball-ish as well. No disrespect intended toward your work, and no bias against re-creation if it's ultimately released and covered in mainstream media Deletion of Sonic The Hedgehog Online WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4743 16348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Slipstream User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable musical group. &mdash Deletion of The Slipstream WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4744 10671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Football at the 2014 Asian Games User:Mentoz86 21:39, 7 August 2012 (UTC) delete per the Deletion of Football at the 2014 Asian Games WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4745 10399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rehmat Aziz Chitrali User:Yoninah 08:43, 28 July 2011 (UTC) delete Subject fails , , and Deletion of Rehmat Aziz Chitrali WP:BIO||WP:SOAP||WP:SECONDARY||WP:INDY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4746 7772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerrard crime family User:Bill 00:52, 11 May 2006 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of Gerrard crime family WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4747 12076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pure play (2nd nomination) User:Vassyana 22:06, 3 February 2007 (UTC) comment """Please |assume good faith. I did research the matter. There are an abundance of definitions that are more or less the same for """"pure play"""". However, outside of a few debates/essays about whether a diverse or focused approach is better this subject doesn't have much meat. Subjects of this type, which are basically definitions, |do not belong in Wikipedia. It's just a jargon phrase with limited scope. I also do not find the """"pure play method"""" notable as it is nothing differant than what is done with other businesses. (That is, analysis is based on the type and market of the business.) Of course, this is just my opinion based on my research. If you have contrary sources and information please use that knowledge to |improve the article""" Deletion of Pure play (2nd nomination) WP:AGF||WP:WINAD||WP:BB Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
4748 19026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seattle National Hockey League team User:Ansh666 03:58, 2 July 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Seattle National Hockey League team WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
4749 19782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raw and Uncutt User:Masterpiece2000 03:34, 10 June 2008 (UTC) delete No reliable sources, fails Deletion of Raw and Uncutt WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4750 9695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sly Forum User:Xyzzyplugh 18:55, 2 August 2006 (UTC) delete doesn't meet . Note that while the article claims this forum has 2 million members, it has no alexa ranking. Furthermore, using the highly sophisticated detective work of going to the forum here http://www.slyforum.us/forum/index.php, I noticed it only has 17 registered users Deletion of Sly Forum WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4751 20925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2nd Regiment New York Volunteer Cavalry User:Phil 17:16, 12 July 2019 (UTC) keep On reading through the article I can't see anything that doesn't belong in an encyclopedia article. Of course it should have a lead section and internal links and otherwise have stylistic changes made to it, but I really can't see any reason why those improvements can't be made without deleting this, and why the current article doesn't serve readers better than nothing, which is what we would have if this was deleted. suggests that we usually have articles about regiments Deletion of 2nd Regiment New York Volunteer Cavalry WP:MILUNIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4752 5229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monastery of St. Michael, Zadar User:Bluerasberry 16:30, 26 December 2015 (UTC) comment Strange - I would have expected to apply, but for some reason, the rules say that untranslated content in English Wikipedia is deleted if the content exists on another Wikipedia, but kept if it does not exist in another version and needs translation. I would have expected CSD in both cases and not sure how this policy works. I would favor deleting this content because English Wikipedia is for English language and this content seems out of scope to me Deletion of Monastery of St. Michael, Zadar WP:CSD||WP:A2 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
4753 2937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heartlight (song) User:Richhoncho 13:26, 28 June 2009 (UTC) keep per . Whereas I have great sympathy for deleting articles with poor/no references or mostly trivia it's not the WP way Deletion of Heartlight (song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4754 11469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aga Syed Haider Rizvi User:Pharaoh 17:46, 17 January 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Aga Syed Haider Rizvi WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4755 203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/November 9th, 2010 Southern California Missile Launch User:Bahamut0013 15:52, 10 November 2010 (UTC) delete per nomination. Totally speculative and falls under . I'm not even convinced there was an incident beyond some confused citizens that saw a contrail, which conspiracy theorists picked up and ran as a missile Deletion of November 9th, 2010 Southern California Missile Launch WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4756 20696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taylor Hickson User:Piotrus 03:43, 10 November 2016 (UTC) comment I'd say that being one of the main actors (leading characters) in a mainstream TV series (Aftermath (2016 TV series)) makes them close to passing the above criteria, but the problem is the multiple requirement. The two other main roles she had are in movies that have not been deemed notable yet, at least in so far as nobody bothered to create Wikipedia articles on them. If someone thinks one of those two movies is notable, she would probably classify, and I'd change my vote to weak keep (ping me if you make an argument for movie notability and I'll reconsider my vote). PS. If the creator bothers to participate in the discussion (sadly, unlikely as this seems like write-and-run case), we could also consider usefying it, given that it is a likely case of ; she'll probably be notable in a year or two when she gets another important role Deletion of Taylor Hickson WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4757 13282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of artists with the most number ones on the Billboard Mainstream Top 40 chart User:Mz7 22:56, 4 January 2018 (UTC) merge I definitely think this isn't necessary. It is sufficiently covered at Mainstream Top 40#Artists with the most number-one singles, and the information in prose can be found at the artists' respective discography articles. I agree that this falls under , as these are statistics that don't have that much attention in reliable sources, and aren't even for the flagship ''Billboard'' chart (the Hot 100). As the nominator pointed out, a {{noredirect|Artists with the most number-ones on the U.S. Billboard Hot 100|similar article}} for the Hot 100 was redirected Deletion of List of artists with the most number ones on the Billboard Mainstream Top 40 chart WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4758 20539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jupiter Station User:pd_THOR 18:51, 5 January 2008 (UTC) delete as lacking any evidencing of |notability from |reliable sources Deletion of Jupiter Station WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4759 7092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lorna Bourg User:AllyD 08:18, 21 May 2021 (UTC) comment """As well as the couple of sources that I added to the article, there is https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=hYj9I3zuZ_QC&lpg=PA152&pg=PA151 this introduction to a personal narrative by the subject in ''""""Women Pioneers of the Louisiana Environmental Movement""""''. I'd prefer to find more, but without wanting to fall back on inherited notability, a :MacArthur Fellows Program|MacArthur Fellowship (almost all of whom are blue-linked) could be regarded as indicative of meeting criterion 1""" Deletion of Lorna Bourg :WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4760 9328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phone Call to Putin (2nd nomination) User:Ezhiki NONE delete """or merge to wherever). The article establishes notability of the term based on its being mentioned in passing in relation to one and only one case. If the keep proponents are so convinced that this term is beyond being a """"non-notable neologism"""", why in the world have such a hard time providing references which tie the term to something other than Mikheyev's case? The term is """"widely known"""" in Russia and is mentioned by numerous independent sources? Give me two (2!) such sources, and as long as they are |reliable and don't reference back to Mikheyev's case like every single other source mentioned here, I'll change my vote to """"keep"""" (""""strong keep"""" if you give me three). Thank you""" Deletion of Phone Call to Putin (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4761 1834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill 165 User:Bearcat 22:06, 16 December 2016 (UTC) delete """Every piece of legislation that exists in every jurisdiction that passes legislation is not automatically a suitable article topic; |reliable sourcing must be present to ''show'' that the topic is noteworthy. Creator also needs to be aware that pieces of legislation are titled with their ''short form name'', not their bill number — every single state or province in North America will have its own completely different """"Bill 165"""" within the life of its current legislature, another completely different """"Bill 165"""" several years ago during the life of its ''previous'' legislature, and then another completely different """"Bill 165"""" a few years into the future after the next election resets the bill numbering ''again""" Deletion of Bill 165 WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4762 10731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barry Johnston (footballer) User:Rlendog 14:57, 9 October 2009 (UTC) keep """The highest level of soccer in Ireland may not technically meet the """"fully professional"""" criteria of , but I think Ireland is a lot closer to such criteria than it is to the leagues in """"Monserrat, Vatican City, Somalia or Guam"""", and is close enough to warrant inclusion""" Deletion of Barry Johnston (footballer) WP:ATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
4763 19310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bridgehead, California User:TimothyBlue 13:16, 2 August 2020 (UTC) delete The article does not meet , . // Deletion of Bridgehead, California WP:GNG||WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4764 17922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Runescape Quests User:QuagmireDog 23:14, 18 September 2006 (UTC) delete as per an indiscriminate collection of information. The processes required to complete individual quests are neither notable nor offer a real insight into RS. An outline of all quests is already available on the RS knowledgebase (official page) and quest walkthroughs are already on several fansites. There are more than one hundred quests on RS, trying to list each, some or even a handful (the criteria for inclusion would be another hurdle) is a lost cause, replicating what's out there and boring readers rigid. The RS wiki would benefit from this sort of information, I'd suggest contributors interested in listing this kind of material would do well to pay the place a visit and have a look around Deletion of Runescape Quests WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4765 15738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nimrod (programming language) (2nd nomination) User:Psychonaut 11:49, 25 August 2013 (UTC) delete Did my own search for |reliable sources; came up empty Deletion of Nimrod (programming language) (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4766 19400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gibsonten User:Armbrust 18:14, 19 February 2010 (UTC) delete per nominator and Deletion of Gibsonten WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4767 1312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Safoora Zargar User:Sturdyankit 12:05, 21 May 2020 (UTC) delete most of content isn't cited with reliable source, a very few sources are cited with indepent or reliable websites, I think the subject isn't notable enough (yet) to be here as per ; many part of this article have no any refrance seems editor's interest e.g the first para. of controversy section where the editor mentioned porn actress, her allegations and all that, also for her husband a very few result are showing and however it is clear, the subject covered a few media coverage on internet but not notable (yet), Thanks Deletion of Safoora Zargar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4768 9165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Dead Fathers Club User:Alan 23:35, 12 April 2012 (UTC) delete per Deletion of The Dead Fathers Club WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4769 17132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Voice of Evil User:Gtstricky 15:58, 13 June 2008 (UTC) delete as a fan created episode that is not |notable. True episodes are listed on List of Doctor Who serials It is also a copy violation and has been taged for speedy (G12 Deletion of The Voice of Evil WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4770 6097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Views of the French military User:Synchronicity 10:26, 24 August 2006 (UTC) delete mainly |original research, heavy issues too. I agree with Deletion of Views of the French military WP:OR||WP:POV Wikipedia:No original research 65
4771 13776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tandoor Chef User:Glane23 22:15, 31 July 2012 (UTC) delete The only news hits for this brand which are not marketing or pr pieces are passing mentions at best. The same appears when searching for book references. Fails otability|notability Deletion of Tandoor Chef WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4772 17620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Backyard Football League User:Jayden54 20:47, 7 December 2006 (UTC) delete per and it doesn't contain any references Deletion of Backyard Football League WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
4773 13908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barack Obama and the Enemies Within User:I9Q79oL78KiL0QTFHgyc 16:13, 4 January 2016 (UTC) delete I am mystified that people would claim that there are sources which allow this subject to pass . There are not. Glenn Beck and the John Birch Society are not the kinds of serious, reliable, |independent sources we require when establishing notability for books. The lack of circulation, mainstream reviews, or even notice in the normal world is just the nail in the coffin Deletion of Barack Obama and the Enemies Within WP:BK||WP:FRIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4774 7150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of foreign consulates in Oklahoma City User:Orangemike 01:00, 29 October 2007 (UTC) delete whole list) as violation of #DIR, despite a plea of Deletion of List of foreign consulates in Oklahoma City WP:NOT||:WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4775 4016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daran Norris User:MichaelQSchmidt 09:07, 17 December 2010 (UTC) keep """Never a good idea to send to AFD simply due to or to force by others. Nominator made an unfortunate mis-statement when saying """"all voice acting credits are one-or-two-shot characters or additional voices"""". This is patently incorrect, and this individual meets through easily |verifiable http://books.google.com/books?as_brr=0&as_pub=-icon&q=%22Daran+Norris%22http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Daran+Norris%22&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&btnG=Search+Archives and quite lengthy careerhttp://www.imdb.com/name/nm0358460/filmoyear with numerous significant roles roles in multiple notable productions stretching from at least 1977 through 2010""" Deletion of Daran Norris WP:NOEFFORT||WP:CLEANUP||WP:ENT||WP:V Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4776 9466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Desa (band) User:Hydronium 06:39, 13 April 2020 (UTC) merge I'm not seeing coverage apart from the two AllMusic reviewshttps://www.allmusic.com/album/year-in-a-red-room-mw0000693298https://www.allmusic.com/album/arriving-alive-mw0000771050. Punknews does have a review, but that seems to be that reviewer's only reviewhttps://www.allmusic.com/album/arriving-alive-mw0000771050https://www.google.com/search?q=%22lesspunkthanyou%22+review, and even if that were counted it's not reaching NBAND or GNG. The band is, however, a subsequent project of the members of Link 80, so #6 does not be apply, but it would be reasonable to expand slightly on Desa (separate sub-section?) there using the three Allmusic refs and limited bits of passing coverage. That said, there may well be offline music magazine coverage due to the era Deletion of Desa (band) WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4777 8305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unconscious - The Real Life User:Ukexpat 17:24, 1 November 2010 (UTC) delete clearly and/or . It has to go Deletion of Unconscious - The Real Life WP:OR||WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
4778 21389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Biallas User:Mukkakukaku 23:30, 7 February 2011 (UTC) delete """The author appears to be a |single purpose account whose only articles appear to be this one and the two articles about the """"virtual worlds"""" the subject in question created; this makes me wonder if this doesn't fail the various promotional/self-promo restrictions here (, , ). Also the sources consist of pretty much promotional material and press releases. A google search reveals that for the most part the only results are the aforementioned promotional material, profiles on various social networking websites, celebrity/gossip sites about one opening gala in which he was involved, and unrelated persons. Only about 20 websites actually about him, the rest are unrelated. I'm pretty sure it fails the ''significant coverage'', ''reliable'', and '''''secondary''' source'' requirements of the """ Deletion of Martin Biallas WP:SPA||WP:SPIP||WP:COI||WP:AUTO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
4779 20416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dominique Strauss-Kahn sexual assault case User:Dragons 20:51, 20 May 2011 (UTC) keep """This event forced the head of the IMF is forced to resign. http://www.voanews.com/english/news/economy-and-business/Embattled-IMF-Chief-Resigns-122218109.html. Before his arrest he was considered the front-runner to challenge Sarkozy for the 2012 French Presidency http://news.xinhuanet.com/english2010/indepth/2011-05/19/c_13882950.htm, and this event left the French Socialist party in disarray http://www.france24.com/en/20110517-strauss-kahn-affair-throws-socialists-disarray-presidential-election-2012-france. It has been covered in roughly 24000 news outlets http://news.google.com/news/search?q=dominique+strauss-kahn. Yes it is news, and yes it is recent, and that makes for some difficulty in writing about it; however, I really fail to see how anyone could conclude that this fails the |general notability guidelines (""""has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject""""?) or that the event won't be of lasting significance, whatever the actual outcome of the case""" Deletion of Dominique Strauss-Kahn sexual assault case WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4780 3174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teairra Mari's Forthcoming Studio Album User:Kanonkas 12:07, 3 August 2008 (UTC) delete The article fails and Deletion of Teairra Mari's Forthcoming Studio Album WP:CRYSTAL||WP:NOR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4781 10622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roman Retzbach User:AllyD 10:38, 1 July 2020 (UTC) delete I am concerned that this article appears to have been created at the behest of a World Future Society to place biographies of their principal members here, also at the extent of collusive involvement of the subject in the placing of this article (as evidenced in the text on the subject's website, giving permission to a specific editor here to use the copyright material, which is far from a CC-by-SA license) and in the use of processes here (RfC, Dispute Resolution) to attempt to defeat this ongoing AfD, also consuming yet more volunteer effort. The present article is effectively a CV with list of publications which does not in itself confer notability, a notability which I am not seeing demonstrated in |sources. All of these factors would lead me to propose its deletion. However, if there is a growing consensus for this to be returned to draft, then I think it should be the former attributed version currently at :User:YvesMe/Roman_Retzbach rather than the mainspace instance, and it should immediately be shorn of the content replicated from https://futures-studies.com/roman-retzbach-founder/ the subject's website, before further development towards any future second pass through AfC. I am also concerned that despite all that has been said, I am still not seeing a |clear disclosure declaration of the involvement of the editor who put this in mainspace and those in the World Future Society Deletion of Roman Retzbach :WP:RS||:WP:COPYVIO||:WP:DISCLOSE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4782 408 [[Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Kader der Sportfreunde Lotte]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Steak 09:08, 27. Jun. 2012 (CEST) delete Eine Navigationsleiste muss gleichranringe Elemente aufführen, siehe . Wenn einige relevant sind und andere nicht, sind sie nicht gleichrangig Löschung von Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Kader der Sportfreunde Lotte Wikipedia:TR Wikipedia:Themenring 103
4783 19565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CLC bio User:Ihcoyc 15:12, 19 January 2007 (UTC) delete Nothing here suggests that the guideline is met, or that this business's offerings would be of wide interest to any other than a small market of specialists Deletion of CLC bio WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4784 2361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bifrost (band) User:JamesBurns 09:06, 7 March 2009 (UTC) delete no significant independent 3rd party coverage Deletion of Bifrost (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4785 10577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wray Query User:Bagumba 17:51, 8 November 2011 (UTC) delete Fails with no significant coverage in multiple independent sources. I only see trivial mentions, nd the article is currently only sourced with references to a stats site. If the article is worth salvaging, it would have saved the community's time if Alex had assumed good faith and http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wray_Query&diff=456539452&oldid=456436990 better explained his de-PROD Deletion of Wray Query WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4786 19184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CJ Environmental User:Ravenswing 06:16, 29 December 2010 (UTC) delete """I agree that the Inc. """"profile"""" is, in fact, a bare-bones mention in a rolling list, and not remotely the feature article AkankshaG and Sandfernandocourt imply that it is. The other two cites Akanksha raises are likewise passing mentions; this particular company is neither the subject of, nor discussed in the """"significant detail"""" the GNG requires, in either. The other cites in the article, which look superficially good, are either likewise passing mentions or fail to be |reliable sources. That being said, would Sanfernandocourt care to explain what makes this a bad faith nomination? Anything beyond that he disagrees with it, or the implication that someone who describes himself as a """"deletionist"""" must by definition have malicious intent? I am sure, for example, that he would not care himself to be characterized as having made a """"bad faith keep"""" simply because he erroneously conflates a mention on Inc.'s website into a feature article in the magazine""" Deletion of CJ Environmental WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4787 2278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wooster School [[User talk:Benjiboi|Benjiboi]] 18:38, 23 October 2007 (UTC) keep Article seems written and reffed to an acceptable level. If any major flaws exist they should be addressed with regular editing per fD Deletion of Wooster School WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
4788 3809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al Gore III (4th nomination) User:Bluedustmite 15:03, 22 September 2006 (UTC) delete per . I would also support a '''redirect''' to Al Gore, since everything noteable about Gore III is already mentioned in that article Deletion of Al Gore III (4th nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4789 3910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/411mania (2nd nomination) User:Carlossuarez46 21:08, 28 September 2007 (UTC) delete fails the passing mentions in mainstream media come nowhere near that threshold, which we have for a reason Deletion of 411mania (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4790 13146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Belle Knox (2nd nomination) User:Lagrange613 03:19, 1 October 2014 (UTC) keep In March she was known only for her outing. That got some extra coverage because of her Duke affiliation, but it was |routine nonetheless. Novelty is not notability. We were right to exercise caution in the early days, especially while it remained to be seen how she would handle her newfound notoriety. Since then, she's apparently chosen to embrace it and had some success building on it. She's notable now, even if the coverage of her outpaces her actual notability. Of course, sensation will continue to swirl around her, and we'll have to use judgment about what goes in the article. But the article should stay Deletion of Belle Knox (2nd nomination) WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4791 19297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Afroludi User:Pinktoebeans 20:47, 30 January 2021 (UTC) delete per (blatant misinformation/hoax Deletion of Afroludi WP:G3 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
4792 8618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sri Shivamurthy Murugharajendra Sharanaru User:Stifle 18:44, 17 September 2008 (UTC) delete The lack of |citations from |reliable sources in this article leads me to conclude that the article is not in compliance with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Sri Shivamurthy Murugharajendra Sharanaru WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4793 17754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zoltan David User:Modern 17:41, 20 November 2012 (UTC) comment Based on the comments and actions below, I Deletion of Zoltan David WP:WITHDRAWN Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
4794 3972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dog camp (2nd nomination) user:Andrew 14:57, 24 August 2020 (UTC) keep """This is obviously a cross between a dog park and kennel and so there are obvious |alternatives to deletion. It is not difficult to find more coverage such as ''https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=RJQXBgAAQBAJ&pg=PA109 Dogs in the Leisure Experience''. And I'm especially liking that they """"''typically screen potential canine guests for aggressive tendencies as they do not want to risk fights''"""" – Wikipedia should try this. See also """ Deletion of Dog camp (2nd nomination) WP:ATD||WP:BITE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
4795 4876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs about killers (2nd nomination) User:MrFizyx 21:21, 2 August 2007 (UTC) merge """relevant content to murder ballad. Since murder ballads are basically songs about killers and/or their victims. And this list has some details and worthy examples not present there. Both the list and the article are short enough that this could be done if editors feel that the stand-alone list is a violation of #DIR or whatever else. Frankly I find the policy arguments on both sides of this debate to be fairly week. I added the """"further reading"""" section during the last debate in hopes that someone might put a little more meat in there. It appears that kept the mob at bay for about two weeks. Very discouraging""" Deletion of List of songs about killers (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4796 5494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fred De Luca User:Doc 21:00, 29 May 2008 (UTC) keep Bad faith nom. Person meets as he founded one of Subway (restaurant)|the most successful resturant chains in the United States. Nom is trying to |make a point. Possibly someone connected to a competitor, like Shawn in Montreal mentioned Deletion of Fred De Luca WP:BIO||WP:POINT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4797 8652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zhao Jing (volleyball) User:Bennv3771 05:04, 2 September 2018 (UTC) comment This is what a https://www.google.com/search?q=赵静女排&ei=k2yLW4rbC5uo9QPg5pjgBw&start=0&sa=N&biw=1280&bih=584 google search in Chinese sources yields on Zhao Jing (volleyball). Haven't had the time to look through the search results to see if she meets myself, but maybe this will help anyone who is interested Deletion of Zhao Jing (volleyball) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4798 16247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Gadnis User:Crystallina 03:14, 23 November 2006 (UTC) delete as failing . Professor test doesn't even apply here Deletion of Adam Gadnis WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4799 1193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George B. Schwartzman User:Enos733 02:24, 7 March 2014 (UTC) merge to 2003 California Recall. This is the usual outcome for losing candidates for a state/provencial-wide executive race per Deletion of George B. Schwartzman WP:POLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
4800 4081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 Joy Flight crash User:Ram 16:00, 20 April 2016 (UTC) delete There are a ton of news references that covered these events, including national coverage (), but that's just not enough Deletion of 2009 Joy Flight crash WP:GEOSCOPE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4801 10900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parlour talk User:Dpbsmith 00:41, 31 December 2005 (UTC) delete """no sources given. Do ''not'' transwiki, '''unless''' good verifiable sources are provided prior to expiration of AfD. As |the policy says, """"The burden of evidence lies with the editor who has made the edit. Editors should therefore provide references. Any edit lacking a source may be removed."""" In this case, that would be the entire article. (Also, Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up in school one day""" Deletion of Parlour talk WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4802 17660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Navea Training Center User:RightCowLeftCoast 12:44, 3 March 2011 (UTC) merge Any useful, |cited information from |reliable sources can be merged intot he article Hīt forming its own section within the article. If the section expands sufficiently with more referenced content then it can always be |split and the article in question can be recreated Deletion of Navea Training Center WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:SPINOUT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4803 21740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natami User:Tarc 13:16, 14 June 2011 (UTC) delete Unremarkable, non-notable hobby project, supported only by a primary source and a user forum. Standard Deletion of Natami WP:NOTADVERTISING Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4804 20211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Little Guilin User:Ad 22:30, 15 April 2014 (UTC) keep per |Speedy Keep - Applicability section 1 Nom has made no argument for deletion. This is not a merge forum. Suggest tagging the article for proposed merger Deletion of Little Guilin WP:SK Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
4805 13053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kunt and the Gang (band) (2nd nomination) User:Eddie 23:23, 4 June 2009 (UTC) delete No matter how it's sliced, diced or knuted I'm just not seeing compliance with Deletion of Kunt and the Gang (band) (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4806 750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/5-1-0 User:Narutolovehinata5 NONE delete Patent nonsense. Recommend #G1|CSD G1 Deletion of 5-1-0 WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
4807 3719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Lee Adams User:Epinoia 21:49, 21 August 2019 (UTC) delete nothing notable here - popularity does not establish notability - no substantial coverage in the references per , many refs are to his own articles and social media: in order to lack of notability - therefore, delete Deletion of William Lee Adams WP:BASIC||WP:REFBOMBING||WP:MASK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4808 10784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manipulating the microflora of the gut NONE NONE delete the current article is an essay full of , but one should consider potential, not just current state. However, none of the impressive-looking sources deal with ''manipulation'' of the microflora, they are just studies on its ''effects''. The article goes far into territory by suggesting to intentionally alter it Deletion of Manipulating the microflora of the gut WP:SYNTH||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4809 2317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Armenian Americans User:Badagnani 01:21, 13 September 2007 (UTC) keep """Important aid for researchers. We only include notable individuals in these lists and they are well sourced. As with previous ethnic group nominations, this nomination, apparently done along with dozens if not hundreds of others all in a single day, is disruptive, , and does not enhance our encyclopedia. Editor apparently presumes that all Americans ''should'' simply be """"American,"""" and their national origin should be ignored. This attempt to inject political POV into the Wiki should be eschewed in the strongest terms. '''Improve, don't delete""" Deletion of List of Armenian Americans WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
4810 321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kutty Shranku User:Appoose81 11:25, 26 February 2008 (UTC) delete per . I (page creator) acknowledge that the article violates these policy and support the removal of the page Deletion of Kutty Shranku WP:CRYSTAL||WP:NFF Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4811 1473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virago 2 User:Quarl NONE delete as |unverifiable and/or |original research. &mdash Deletion of Virago 2 WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4812 18942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Park Lane (mall) User:Paul 20:05, 17 August 2014 (UTC) keep probably enough to meet with the sources I have added. There are entire articles about the development in the Canadian Press/''Toronto Star'' and in ''The Chronicle Herald'', as well as at least a few sentences of coverage in several other publications (the ''Canadian Journal of Urban Research'', ''Atlantic Business'', and the ''Financial Post Deletion of Park Lane (mall) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4813 12476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethnocide of Uyghurs User:MarkH21 05:50, 1 February 2020 (UTC) comment One major issue is that the article doesn’t discuss the labeling of these events as {{tq|ethnocide}} anywhere, except the very first sentence. In some sense, the article is an editor |synthesis of describing all of these separate aspects collectively as ethnocide in the rest of the article. A lot of the content either duplicates content in other articles (e.g. Xinjiang conflict, Xinjiang re-education camps, Strike Hard Campaign Against Violent Terrorism) or is better suited to be in those articles Deletion of Ethnocide of Uyghurs WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
4814 10994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heehler, C. Thomas User:DrunkenSmurf 15:38, 22 August 2006 (UTC) delete no articles can be found to establish that this person meets Deletion of Heehler, C. Thomas WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4815 11353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Phoebe User:Peripitus 07:58, 3 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails in having not signed to a label, no charting releases and no news mentions Deletion of Anna Phoebe WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4816 21904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brothers in Arms (Young Jeezy & Akon album) User:Moonriddengirl 12:42, 27 October 2007 (UTC) delete unless |reliable sourcing can be produced. I tried to find some myself but found only speculation at questionable or unacceptable spots Deletion of Brothers in Arms (Young Jeezy & Akon album) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4817 20059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Blank Page Dream User:Mets501 22:43, 9 May 2006 (UTC) delete fails &mdash Deletion of A Blank Page Dream WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4818 8625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Toronto District School Board elementary schools NONE NONE keep """The nomination's opinion that """"this article is not ready for mainspace"""" is fundamentally contrary to our |editing policy which states that{{quote|Perfection is not required: Wikipedia is a work in progress. Collaborative editing means that incomplete or poorly written first drafts can evolve over time into excellent articles. Even poor articles, if they can be improved, are welcome. For instance, one person may start an article with an overview of a subject or a few random facts. Another may help standardize the article's formatting, or have additional facts and figures or a graphic to add. Yet another may bring better balance to the views represented in the article, and perform fact-checking and sourcing to existing content. At any point during this process, the article may become disorganized or contain substandard writing""" Deletion of List of Toronto District School Board elementary schools WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
4819 6603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Begbie User:GiantSnowman 13:55, 13 December 2010 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Jim Begbie WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4820 14167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leadership Initiatives User:MER 08:33, 5 March 2007 (UTC) delete Leadership Initiatives is a multi-source copyvio from http://www.leadershipinitiatives.org/, http://www.leadershipinitiatives.org/namibia/, http://www.leadershipinitiatives.org/nigeria/ and http://www.leadershipinitiatives.org/philippines/ (the history section is probably copied as well). Marshall Bailly fails and , with http://www.google.com.au/search?hl=en&q=%22Marshall+Bailly%22+-wikipedia&btnG=Search&meta= 35 non-wiki ghits Deletion of Leadership Initiatives WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
4821 15943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Huntingtown, Maryland's Snowstorms 2002-? User:Metropolitan90 05:13, 28 March 2007 (UTC) delete as |unsourced and |indiscriminate information Deletion of Huntingtown, Maryland's Snowstorms 2002-? WP:RS||WP:IINFO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4822 12486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmed Ziauddin (2nd nomination) User:RayAYang 01:35, 13 April 2013 (UTC) delete per . This guy appears to be insignificant aside from being at the epicenter of one news event Deletion of Ahmed Ziauddin (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4823 17186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pippin Parker User:FoxyGrampa75 14:00, 28 August 2019 (UTC) comment Now let's see. Dean of a subschool of a university? 6 says such notability is only exceptional, of which this one is not. Founding member of a Naked Angels (theater company)|theater company that made a deal with a Big 4 network like Fox? No independent notability is derivable from that alone. Creator of a short play that was adapted to NPR and writer of The Tick (1994 TV series)|a Saturday morning TV show? Combined together with the theater company foundership, I'd says she may barely satisfy , on the condition that these claims are reliably sourced Deletion of Pippin Parker WP:NACADEMIC||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
4824 10773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC 37 User:Snotbot 10:31, 31 May 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 May 31 Deletion of UFC 37 WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4825 1029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Smith (Leadership Consultant) User:Bearian 20:54, 14 April 2011 (UTC) delete per - ''nothing'' on Google news, scholar, or books. It's funny, because Google seems not to index his books several ways. So I tried a http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Thomas%20Smith%22%20%2B%20%22Leadership%20Consultant%22%20source%3A%22-newswire%22%20source%3A%22-wire%22%20source%3A%22-presswire%22%20source%3A%22-PR%22%20source%3A%22-release%22%20source%3A%22-wikipedia%22&hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=sw#sclient=psy&hl=en&source=hp&q=%22Thomas+Smith%22+%2B+%22Leadership+Consultant%22+-wikipedia&aq=&aqi=&aql=&oq=&pbx=1&fp=d20dc6883e250f01 narrow net and a http://www.google.com/#sclient=psy&hl=en&site=&source=hp&q=%22Thomas+Smith%22+%2B+%22Leadership+Consultant%22+-wikipedia&aq=&aqi=&aql=&oq=&pbx=1&fp=d20dc6883e250f01 wider net, but I could not find much else either Deletion of Thomas Smith (Leadership Consultant) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4826 17631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Girl in the Mirror (2nd nomination) User:UninvitedCompany 21:10, 26 June 2009 (UTC) delete Per ; individual songs are notable only in exceptional cases Deletion of Girl in the Mirror (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4827 403 [[Billiard]] (LAE) Benutzer:Nothere 13:53, 5. Apr. 2012 (CEST) keep Übliche Falschschreibung, : http://www.google.de/search?q=%22Billard%22+-wikipedia&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:de:official&client=firefox-a#q=%22Billard%22+-wikipedia&hl=de&client=firefox-a&hs=HLm&rls=org.mozilla:de:official&tbs=lr:lang_1de&prmd=imvns&source=lnt&lr=lang_de&sa=X&ei=54Z9T82aO-eL4gSu3sG1DA&ved=0CCwQpwUoAQ&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.,cf.osb&fp=ae3d0a2a11f59d7e&biw=1280&bih=614 Billard vs. http://www.google.de/search?q=%22Billiard%22+-wikipedia&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:de:official&client=firefox-a#q=%22Billiard%22+-wikipedia&hl=de&client=firefox-a&hs=Ny6&rls=org.mozilla:de:official&prmd=imvnsa&source=lnt&tbs=lr:lang_1de&lr=lang_de&sa=X&ei=XoZ9T6SwHYrN4QTdkNTQDA&ved=0CCAQpwUoAQ&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.,cf.osb&fp=ae3d0a2a11f59d7e&biw=1280&bih=614 Billiard liegt etwa bei dem von geforderten Verhältnis von 1:9. Die trotzdem erfolgreiche Suche ist kein Kriterium Löschung von Billiard Wikipedia:FS Wikipedia:Redirect 56
4828 21493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Volha Satsiuk User:Niteshift36 14:33, 7 July 2009 (UTC) delete """Moorvis claims there is notability and I'll AGF, but I don't see it. Yes, I know that non-English sources are valid, but the whole """"search in Finnish/Russian/Czech/whatever"""" idea always annoys me. This is the English WP, not the Russian one. I can't a source that I can't read. So while notability may be there, if it the notable coverage is in a language I can't read, I can't verify it, so it fails for me""" Deletion of Volha Satsiuk WP:V||WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4829 18844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alyas Pogi: Ang Pagbabalik User:MichaelQSchmidt 02:37, 17 May 2015 (UTC) keep """and allow this |brand new article to be expanded over time and through attention of Philippines editors. Yes, sourcing Philippines films is often difficult... and specially when the topic is pre-internet. But this receiving FAMAS Award recognition allows a reasonable supposition that it did receive press coverage 26 years ago. As """"some"""" sources ARE available, there is no need to toss it because the nominated version did not use them""" Deletion of Alyas Pogi: Ang Pagbabalik WP:BITE Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
4830 19405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of poorly performing college football coaches User:Boing 17:01, 16 June 2010 (UTC) delete Blaming it all on the head coach is (even if it might be accurate Deletion of List of poorly performing college football coaches WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
4831 4852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grexy User:MichaelQSchmidt 18:48, 4 October 2008 (UTC) delete as . I can sure Grok that Deletion of Grexy WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
4832 5285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WZMT - Minecraft Radio User:Davey2010 22:46, 12 July 2014 (UTC) delete per nom, Found no evidence of any |notability Deletion of WZMT - Minecraft Radio WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4833 15775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Countess (shortbread) User:Glane23 20:50, 27 January 2017 (UTC) delete Fails . I too found no sources whatsoever in multiple searches. |Notability requires the existence of suitable sources Deletion of Countess (shortbread) WP:GNG||WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
4834 16663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Algol (Phantasy Star) User:Someone 23:19, 16 December 2009 (UTC) merge per Nifboy, has been dealt with appropriately considering it's way outside of Deletion of Algol (Phantasy Star) WP:VGSCOPE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
4835 9497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omniscopic User:Siva1979 06:16, 31 August 2007 (UTC) delete A quick http://www.google.com.sg/search?as_q=&hl=en&num=100&btnG=Google+Search&as_epq=Omniscopic&as_oq=&as_eq=wikipedia&lr=&as_ft=i&as_filetype=&as_qdr=all&as_occt=any&as_dt=i&as_sitesearch=&as_rights=&safe=image google search shows up no |reliable hits for this article. It is also difficult to |verify the contents of this article as well. --|S Deletion of Omniscopic WP:RS||WP:V||WP:EA Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4836 9742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shekinah Christian Training Center User:Cordless 21:17, 15 January 2018 (UTC) delete as failing . There simply isn't the secondary coverage necessary for writing an article here Deletion of Shekinah Christian Training Center WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4837 270 [[Käthe-Kollwitz-Gymnasium Dortmund]] (gelöscht) 217.251.123.70|217.251.123.70]] 19:05, 26. Okt. 2008 (CET) P. s.: Weißbier, deinen Namen kannst du ja ganz nach Geschmack schreiben, aber schreibe bitte nicht immer wieder ''blos''. Es schmerzt regelrecht. Und warum hältst du dich nicht an die Löschregeln und sprichst den (angemeldeten) Autor an, ehe du einen Löschantrag stellst NONE keep denn der Artikel entspricht . Dass ein Kollwitz-Familienmitglied an der Namensgebung teilnahm, ist eine Besonderheit. Die Schule wurde noch nach WW II als Mädchengymnasium gegründet. Einen Löschgrund kann ich nicht sehen. Löschung von Käthe-Kollwitz-Gymnasium Dortmund Wikipedia:Artikel über Schulen Wikipedia:Artikel über Schulen 4
4838 8497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of strongmen User:Colonel 12:38, 19 March 2013 (UTC) keep The topic is notable per . See http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=0ighAQAAIAAJ Strong Man, for example Deletion of List of strongmen WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
4839 21739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Windows 8 (2nd nomination) User:Trevor 10:07, 7 June 2009 (UTC) delete As per Nom, . Or create more articles for 'Windows 9, 10, 11, 12 Deletion of Windows 8 (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4840 1739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gilli Sørensen User:Lukeno94 21:33, 25 March 2013 (UTC) comment we need a Danish-speaking editor whom can establish whether this guy meets or not. English searches turn up nothing, and although he has clearly been on the books at Aberdeen FChttp://www.afc.co.uk/articles/20100510/team-of-youngsters_2212158_2048217, he never played for them at a senior level, and hasn't received much coverage away from primary sources and routine things (including name dropping Deletion of Gilli Sørensen WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4841 3332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Halil Kayıkçı User:Meatsgains 21:40, 27 July 2016 (UTC) delete I was tempted to take this page to AFD after the subject's DOB was brought to BLPN, where it was first brought to my attention. Seems to be a case of Deletion of Halil Kayıkçı WP:1EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4842 16113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Werster user:Hellknowz 13:54, 29 January 2014 (UTC) delete """as non-notable person not passing with multiple reliable independent in-depth sources. The key point is """"in-depth"""" rather than passing mentions in other content. Although I am familiar with their work and the importance in the niche field of video game speedrunning, there is no GNG-worthy coverage that I can find. — """ Deletion of Werster WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4843 3356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MIPSel User:Mark 23:11, 22 April 2013 (UTC) merge to MIPS architecture. One can verify that the term MIPSel exists, but there are few sources beyond a definition. While there are not enough in-depth reliable sources to support saving this article, it is a term that users could search on. So following , I suggest converting this to a redirect to MIPS architecture and adding the definition to the section MIPS architecture#CPU family where the bi-endian nature of the processor family is mentioned Deletion of MIPSel WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
4844 4692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Lowe (2nd nomination) User:Abductive 01:34, 24 November 2010 (UTC) delete Fails and as sacrificial lamb candidate, fails Deletion of Ben Lowe (2nd nomination) WP:AUTHOR||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
4845 14084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WWE Smackdown! Board (IGN) User:Metropolitan90 06:01, 9 August 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of WWE Smackdown! Board (IGN) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4846 52 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of open source computer hardware suppliers User:Kvng 12:55, 16 May 2012 (UTC) keep no specific or compelling reason given for deletion. I don't see a point in that clearly applies to this Deletion of List of open source computer hardware suppliers WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4847 179 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Sorgu Kullanıcı:dr. coaldr. coal 19.12, 17 Haziran 2020 (UTC) delete """Maddeye bakınca {{seslen|Justinianus}} ile aynı fikirdeydim fakat bilgileri doğrulayabileceğim bir kaynağa erişemedim. Gerçek ismi de dahil birkaç kombinasyon ile arama yaptım ancak """"Sorgu"""" olarak adının geçtiği 1-2 kaynak haricinde kendisi hakkında bilgi veren bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynak göremedim. Madde içeriğinde verilen bilgiye göre KD olmalı fakat |doğrulanabilir olmayınca bir anlamı yok... Eğer bu konuda kaynağa rastlayan olursa ve seslenebilirse gerçekten çok sevinirim""" Sorgu'nun silinmesi Vikipedi:D Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4848 19661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vivek Jain User:RationalPuff 23:28, 16 January 2021 (UTC) delete Terribly fails . Wikipedia is not LinkedIn Deletion of Vivek Jain WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4849 7857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natasha Owens User:Walter 14:35, 10 January 2017 (UTC) keep I was asked to review the AfD by Karst. I see reviews in reliable sources so for me it meets . The sources are niche to the Christian Music genre, but they are listed at :Wikipedia:WikiProject Christian music/Sources Deletion of Natasha Owens :WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4850 111 [[Kaffee Partner Ost-Automaten]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Andy king50 NONE delete Relevanznachweis nach #Wirtschaftsunternehmen umgehend nachholen, sonst Löschung von Kaffee Partner Ost-Automaten Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4851 18067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergio Vargas Gonzalez User:Nika2020 16:37, 30 May 2020 (UTC) delete By definition fails Deletion of Sergio Vargas Gonzalez WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4852 10668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conor Lamb User:power 03:42, 23 December 2017 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet . The only claim of notability is as a candidate in a special election (assistant US attorneys generally aren't notable), and it's not a particularly high-profile special election Deletion of Conor Lamb WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
4853 17715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Philip Gale User:Cirt 16:11, 10 January 2011 (UTC) keep satisfies , with secondary source coverage from multiple sources Deletion of Death of Philip Gale WP:NOTE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4854 1148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Louis Wiltshire User:WikiDan61 11:53, 26 March 2013 (UTC) comment """Mentioned at ..."""" is hardly the criteria we use for """ Deletion of Louis Wiltshire WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4855 21033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Visual modularity User:Peripitus 23:51, 29 January 2007 (UTC) keep pending a better deletion reason - I'm not sure what policy this is supposed to be against. The article is clearly an academic article and so does read like most other articles, however it's replete with references, does not seem to be |original research. May be a limited point of view but it's beyond my technical knowledge to determine Deletion of Visual modularity WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4856 12594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darkside Bowls User:Starblind 18:37, 17 November 2010 (UTC) delete since this is the only mention of this on Google, it's pretty obviously a case of Deletion of Darkside Bowls WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
4857 3649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nanoprobe (Star Trek) (2nd nomination) User:Pixelface 09:49, 27 October 2008 (UTC) keep """the article doesn't have to be brought """"in line"""" with and since those are not policies. Nanoprobes are a notable :Category:Star Trek devices|''Star Trek'' device. This article survived AFD two months ago, and another nomination for deletion so soon after is uncalled for""" Deletion of Nanoprobe (Star Trek) (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4858 12227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hugh Loxdale User:Spicy 18:26, 14 July 2020 (UTC) keep President of the Royal Entomological Society satisfies #C6, and NACADEMIC explicitly supersedes GNG. That said, the article is indeed promotional with evidence of obvious COI editing. I recommend passing this on to to deal with the COI and promo issues Deletion of Hugh Loxdale WP:NACADEMIC||WP:COIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
4859 12681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Synaptogenomics User:Madeleine_Price_Ball 22:08, 5 June 2008 (UTC) delete """per : This is a """"protologism""""; it is not widely used and the page appears to have been created to promote usage of a term. If the term catches on such that there is a field of research to describe here then a page would be justified, but otherwise not notable and ikipedia is not a dictionary""" Deletion of Synaptogenomics WP:NEO||WP:W Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
4860 7734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brad Baker User:Hit 20:43, 23 December 2009 (UTC) keep In addition to the claims to fame listed above, he was on teams' 40-man rosters not once but twice. There are some sources from a past notability debate regarding Baker at Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Baseball/Notability#Case_study:_Brad_Baker, certainly enough to satisfy Deletion of Brad Baker WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4861 21521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delboy (musician) User:Cunard 06:43, 7 May 2009 (UTC) delete """this |autobiography. This articles asserts no notability and the references provided are either non-neutral sources or sources that don't even mention this person. A http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Derek+Wilson%22+band&btnG=Search&um=1&ned=us&hl=en Google News Archive search for sources returns unrelated results. The closest result is http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-63236923.html this article about about a musician called """"Derek Wilson"""" (which is the real name of Delboy (musician)). However, this news article is about a musician from Virginia Tech, not Australia""" Deletion of Delboy (musician) WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
4862 7873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tallest buildings in 2020 User:Eauhomme 01:45, 20 July 2009 (UTC) delete per . Life happens, which is why we need to stick with the facts and what has already happened. Speculation has its place, but that place isn't here Deletion of List of tallest buildings in 2020 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4863 10581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MapleStory User:Echuck215 22:23, 21 December 2006 (UTC) comment """The states: """"The obligation to provide a reliable source lies with the editors wishing to include the material, not on those seeking to remove it."""" This seems relevant to the discussion""" Deletion of MapleStory WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
4864 11389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roland W. Schmitt User:Espresso 13:39, 3 February 2008 (UTC) keep Eleven honorary degrees, several prizes, former president of a university, & former chair of the National Science Foundation. Clearly meets Deletion of Roland W. Schmitt WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
4865 12054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sowon (singer) User:Xxanthippe 22:52, 24 July 2017 (UTC) delete Inadequate sources. , the 1E being membership of the band. If there is still interest in the subject in ten years time then BLP can be resurrected. Presence on other Wikipedias is irrelevant Deletion of Sowon (singer) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4866 7538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suicidal angels User:LoveUxoxo 21:30, 8 December 2011 (UTC) delete without prejudice to recreation by another editor without if notability can be shown. There is nothing to save here, and the encyclopedia is definitely worse for having it included in its current state Deletion of Suicidal angels WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
4867 10741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Varney User:Victuallers 23:28, 23 November 2008 (UTC) delete fails under and short of refs etc that might convince Deletion of James Varney WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4868 19099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Good Evening With User:McGeddon 09:47, 24 February 2017 (UTC) delete per , article offers no secondary sources and I can't find any online. (Or speedy as if the sockpuppetry is confirmed Deletion of A Good Evening With WP:NWEB||WP:G5 Wikipedia:Notability 77
4869 21892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hidayatullah Kheshgi (2nd nomination) User:CaptainNathonson 22:21, 19 March 2021 (UTC) keep Clearly unfounded biased views by the same user who nominated the Article previously. Sources are reliable as they have been disseminated by a diverse range of news agencies operating in the same environment of the subject. Article meets and as notability is corroborated by the subject's political position. Former Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf, who is the former Chief Executive of the State and political party's founder has attested several times that the notable subject is the party's (APML) incumbent chairman. Other references regarding the subject's activities with regard to business {for e.g. PIA Board Membership) and politics further deduces the notability of the subject Deletion of Hidayatullah Kheshgi (2nd nomination) WP:NPOLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4870 9968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Swanner User:DHeyward 16:21, 20 February 2015 (UTC) delete It's a G10 speedy delete intended only to disparage a living person by association. The talk page is a BLP violation. Length of time is not a G10 requirement. Fails . , and Deletion of Mark Swanner WP:BLP1E||WP:BLPCRIME||WP:BLPNAME||WP:PSEUDO Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
4871 18914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The World Only Spins Forward: The Ascent of Angels in America User:Roscelese 19:10, 6 March 2018 (UTC) keep Passes Deletion of The World Only Spins Forward: The Ascent of Angels in America WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4872 1671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Lebanese Army Martyrs during Nahr el Bared Operation User:JulesH 22:13, 5 December 2008 (UTC) comment I have retitled the page to List of Lebanese Army soldiers killed during Nahr el Bared Operation to avoid violation Deletion of List of Lebanese Army Martyrs during Nahr el Bared Operation WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
4873 11442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Archenland (2nd nomination) User:Shooterwalker 20:20, 28 July 2020 (UTC) delete due to a lack of reliable third party sources with real world context. There's no way for this article to meet the and #PLOT and there's already sufficient detail about Narnia in other articles, particularly the article about Narnia as a world. I would consent to a '''merge''' if that's where the consensus is going, though I don't see much material that would need to be expanded Deletion of Archenland (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4874 18499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Claire Potter User:David 18:21, 16 October 2014 (UTC) delete for lack of evidence of passing any of the criteria. She's a recently promoted full professor at a good school, though, so most likely the people who promoted her know more than we see here. The complete lack of references is also a problem, but a fixable one Deletion of Claire Potter WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
4875 3529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Dating Guy (2nd nomination) User:Till 14:32, 26 January 2013 (UTC) delete The analysis of the sources shows that this topic doesn't have enough significant coverage and fails Deletion of The Dating Guy (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4876 11118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Society for social studies User:Defender 17:32, 7 February 2010 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Society for social studies WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4877 20426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Claudia Bermúdez User:Bearcat 18:50, 16 April 2017 (UTC) delete Unelected candidates for political office do not get Wikipedia articles just for being candidates per se — if she doesn't have a strong and |properly sourced claim of notability for some other reason independent of her candidacy, then she has to ''win'' the election, not just run in it, to be deemed notable because of the election itself. But this makes no credible claim of preexisting notability, and is referenced ''nowhere'' close to well enough to claim that she passes in lieu — and notability is not inherited, so she's not special just because of who her father happens to be, either Deletion of Claudia Bermúdez WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4878 15861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francesca Hilton User:Flyguy649 18:23, 27 February 2007 (UTC) delete """She's apparently an actress, but her roles aren't in """"well-known films"""". Her name is known, but only for it being """"Hilton"""". She seems to be best known for the lawsuit following her father's death and when she was sued by her mother. These fail to establish notability per """ Deletion of Francesca Hilton WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4879 1898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corporate Representatives for Ethical Wikipedia Engagement User:SMcCandlish 17:49, 12 March 2012 (UTC) merge """per GabrielF or '''delete''' otherwise or '''move to projectspace''' I don't care which: There's no question that the debate is at least marginally notable, but this particular quasi-organization isn't. It's no surprise that PR professionals, whose job it is to cultivate relationships with journalists, can drum up a """"maybe just enough"""" level of press coverage almost entirely in PR publications that happens to mention the Facebook group, but I think we all know here that the coverage is of the """"PR industry vs. Wikipedia"""" issue, not {{em|inherently of the Facebook group}}, which is mentioned incidentally. If tomorrow the group switched sites and became a YahooGroup called PRWiki or laugh! moved to Wikia and was a wiki there called WikiComms, the next article on the topic would mention the new location and name and not ever bother mentioning the then-defunct Facebook group. The name and location of the group is entirely tangential to the real issue, which is Wikipedia policy clashing with real-world commercial interests. There's no issue here. Keeping an article on the Facebook group itself on GNG grounds would border on |wikilawyering, honoring the wording rather than the spirit of notability policy, because no one actually |GAFs about the group itself, but rather about the issue they're raising, and we all know that the higher-powered members of CREWE can manufacture press coverage with trivial ease. Our system is wide open to here""" Deletion of Corporate Representatives for Ethical Wikipedia Engagement WP:COATRACK||WP:LAWYER||WP:DGAF||WP:GAMING Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
4880 7682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warganism User:JamesBurns 00:37, 30 January 2009 (UTC) delete insufficient 3rd party notability Deletion of Warganism WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4881 1715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Connan Mockasin User:Sparklism 10:56, 1 October 2012 (UTC) keep """Subject has """"been the subject of multiple, non-trivial, published works appearing in sources that are reliable, not self-published, and are independent from the musician or ensemble itself"""", so meets #1. In addition to the sources already contained in the article, there are many sources available online. Examples of this are an http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/15716-forever-dolphin-love/ album review from Pitchfork Media and http://drownedinsound.com/releases/15407/reviews/4139980 another from Drowned in Sound""" Deletion of Connan Mockasin WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4882 2354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brad Gotshall I User:141 22:13, 21 September 2006 (UTC) delete at least until Destish Media becomes notable, or is does his company fail Deletion of Brad Gotshall I WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
4883 12815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maadi British International School User:Edison 18:21, 27 December 2011 (UTC) delete since it does not appear to satisfy and per #Schools Deletion of Maadi British International School WP:ORG||WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Notability 77
4884 20988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ZipBooks User:Nihonjoe 20:39, 24 November 2017 (UTC) keep """As I showed on Talk:ZipBooks, the article very clearly meets and , so there is no valid reason for deletion. The article was completely rewritten by me before it was moved, so the """"damning critique"""" is irrelevant. I agree with {{u|Anachronist}} regarding the need to perhaps make the article about the software or the company instead of both. Right now, they are really pretty much the same thing as they only have this one software as far as I can tell""" Deletion of ZipBooks WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
4885 8004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pankration (Holiday) User:Kinu 04:35, 10 November 2009 (UTC) delete no indicating notability, ultimately violates Deletion of Pankration (Holiday) WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4886 19717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drago Boskovic User:Gonzonoir 10:15, 5 March 2010 (UTC) comment football-talents is a user-editable site and I do not think it can possibly meet |reliable source standards Deletion of Drago Boskovic WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4887 2871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Abel User:E 12:55, 25 November 2018 (UTC) delete """as PROMO for a non-notable """"content strategist, conference organizer and author"""" who has published two books with XML Press. He appears to be successful in business https://www.cmswire.com/content-marketing/ubm-acquires-content-marketing-institute-for-176m/. Fails , """ Deletion of Scott Abel WP:ANYBIO||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
4888 5712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yorkshire Bleeps and Bass User:Chzz 04:32, 25 August 2009 (UTC) delete per nom - and I looked around quite a bit; everything that I did found seems to come from WP. Hence, does not meet through lack of coverage Deletion of Yorkshire Bleeps and Bass WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4889 905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Our Lady of Ransom School User:JaconaFrere 19:26, 7 July 2014 (UTC) merge to locality article Rayleigh, Essex per Deletion of Our Lady of Ransom School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
4890 14294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Is Genesis History? User:E 12:23, 6 September 2017 (UTC) comment """That this is '''NOT''' an article about a """"fringe theory"""". It is an article about a POV documentary film about a theory and should be judged according to the rules of , just like any other POV documentary. '''Note''' in particular that the specialists interviewed in documentaries on political or controversial subjects frequently share a worldview and a political POV with the filmmakers, and that section states: ''""""The source needs to be independent of the topic, meaning that the author and the publisher are not directly associated with the topic. Authors should not include members of the production, and publishers should not include the studio or companies working with it on the production and release. The kinds of sources that are considered independent are those that have covered topics unrelated to the one at hand, such as periodicals""" Deletion of Is Genesis History? WP:NFILM||WP:NFILM||WP:NFSOURCES Wikipedia:Notability 77
4891 21913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canadian National Federation User:Power 10:59, 23 June 2009 (UTC) delete Obscure organization, a search reveals complete absence of , even the external link to the organization in the article is dead Deletion of Canadian National Federation WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4892 11411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SwiftCoin User:Vinodbasker 04:31, 28 October 2018 (UTC) delete All the references point towards Cryptocurrencies, swiftcoin is just a mention with no reliable independant source so fails NOTABILITY.But cryptocurrencies usage in money transaction is on the rise- so will suggest , because this topic may become relevant in future Deletion of SwiftCoin WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4893 9668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yashar Abuzerov User:Mattythewhite 20:05, 3 December 2009 (UTC) delete per and . Could it also be a possible hoax? A Google search brings very little up Deletion of Yashar Abuzerov WP:BIO||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4894 6843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Overloved User:Bearian 23:28, 3 November 2010 (UTC) keep lots of songs are stubs, and |stubs are perfectly valid. This has been covered by two artists in different styles, so a single article would help research the title Deletion of Overloved WP:STUB Wikipedia:Stub 114
4895 3930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asia Commons User:Paul 17:17, 19 September 2020 (UTC) delete This was originally about a conference held in 2006, which doesn't seem to go past . The Special:Diff/60008359|later edit which attempted to introduce coverage of this as a concept seems to be largely unrelated OR Deletion of Asia Commons WP:NEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4896 20673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camila Janniger User:Ejanniger 07:07, 6 November 2006 (UTC) comment It appears to be a |conflict of interest: Author is Deletion of Camila Janniger WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
4897 5366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amanda Hatcher User:Bearian 21:06, 19 July 2011 (UTC) delete per - I made several searches, and found that she has http://www.kdge.com/new2/artists/i/330338?psid=455422 a single song on a single station's radio rotation. She has a http://names.whitepages.com/amanda/hatcher common name, so one must husk the chaff from the wheat online. She's |up and coming, but she hasn't made it yet Deletion of Amanda Hatcher WP:CRYSTAL||WP:UPANDCOMING Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4898 11083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathanael Greene Historical Foundation User:Whpq 20:58, 28 April 2009 (UTC) delete """as spam. Note that the article's author has expressed a desire to donate the material from the orgnsiations website to Wikipedia, but without allowing change. """"Copyright © 2009 Nathanael Greene Historical Foundation (NatGreene) - All Rights Reserved unless expressly stated, Everyone is permitted to copy and distribute verbatim copies of this license document, but changing it is not allowed."""" from http://www.natgreene.org/about/overview/. This is a clear indication that the goal is purely promotional in nature with an advancement of the organisations viewpoint without possibly of changing the text to suit a |neutral point of view""" Deletion of Nathanael Greene Historical Foundation WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
4899 145 [[Status 2]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers NONE delete Kasten|1= gemäß Diskussion. Keine Relevanz nach #Pop dargestellt, ebenso keine überregionale Wahrnehmung in den Medien. Dazu war der Artikel eine reine Selbstdarstellung, die von keinerlei Sekundärbelegen gestützt wird. Ich verstehe eigentlich nicht, warum man bei sowas erst einmal eine Freigabe einholen muss. Gruß Löschung von Status 2 Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4900 17316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rustic (Game) User:Anarchyte 10:45, 24 August 2015 (UTC) delete it seems as though this might be |too soon for an article Deletion of Rustic (Game) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4901 16179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gavin Barwell [[User talk:(aeropagitica)|(aeropagitica)]] 22:09, 3 January 2007 (UTC) delete as per unless |reliable sources can be provided for proof of notability Deletion of Gavin Barwell :WP:BIO||:WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4902 3424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kitrina Podilata User:Spada2 17:36, 7 July 2010 (UTC) delete has some Google hits but the article is unsourced and doesnt meet usic Deletion of Kitrina Podilata WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
4903 11866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Davor Zupičić User:GermanJoe 02:56, 24 April 2015 (UTC) delete per request and . Has only a few passing mentions via Google and could be easily re-created later, when notability increases Deletion of Davor Zupičić WP:BIODELETE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
4904 13138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/San Luis Shrine Desecration (Mormons) User:72Dino 01:18, 26 December 2011 (UTC) delete Minor event with no significant coverage, fails Deletion of San Luis Shrine Desecration (Mormons) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4905 15413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colbert it User:Le 20:53, 23 March 2008 (UTC) keep as a notable indiom, but just improve citations and wording. Consistent with a http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_ss_gw/002-3793058-0309647?url=search-alias%3Daps&field-keywords=idioms+encyclopedia specialized encyclopedia on idioms. Also, keep per the style http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Verdatum&diff=176061328&oldid=169950712 non-argument. Happy Easter Deletion of Colbert it WP:ITSCRUFT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4906 6090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone NONE NONE delete """In my opinion, the original rationale for deletion given by the user who proposed AFD is correct—this is a) a relatively clear case of given that the zone in question formed merely 2 days ago, b) likely to ultimately become a case of given that it is one of several previous """"declared"""" communities that have spontaneously formed and eventually disappeared in the course of various past Seattle protests, and c) so far has not merited any mainstream media coverage aside from assorted local coverage and minor, intentionally incendiary articles from Fox News, RT, Sputnik and similar outlets (eliability). There were similar cases of moderately-sized """"declared"""" zones that appeared momentarily in residential areas during the 1999_Seattle_WTO_protests, but none of these have ultimately existed long enough or been impactful enough to merit full articles""" Deletion of Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone WP:TOOSOON||WP:NOTABILITY||WP:R Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4907 8333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Va Bene (L'Algérino song) User:Superastig 02:23, 15 April 2020 (UTC) keep """The song is a Top 30 hit in Belgium and France. It's certified """"Diamond"""" in France. The YouTube link shuld be placed somewhere instead of considering it as a reference. I even found a few sources about the song: https://www.musicinafrica.net/magazine/african-musicians-who-impressed-2018-part-3, https://www.laprovence.com/article/sorties-loisirs/4966268/lalgerino-va-bene.html, https://www.funx.nl/news/music/36884-l-algerino-releast-va-bene-van-de-taxi-5-soundtrack and https://www.booska-p.com/new-l-algerino-annonce-l-ete-avec-va-bene-videoclip-n88080.html. These sources are reliable enough for the article to pass . My vote stands""" Deletion of Va Bene (L'Algérino song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4908 18261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jenni Potts User:Starblind 15:30, 21 February 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Jenni Potts WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4909 4551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Products Manufactured in Australia and New Zealand User:Bejnar 04:29, 26 February 2010 (UTC) delete """This article is primarily |original research as is shown, by among other things by the section /* Search engines */. In the attempt to ''puff'' ANZAC production, the author makes transition errors between sources and text, such as converting """"Tasmania is the world's biggest producer of legal raw opiates."""" to """"Tasmania produces 40% of the worlds opiates."""" which is a very different thing. Another example, the author coverts """"Australia has two ageing petrochemical complexes."""" to """"Australia has a substantial chemical industry, including the manufacture of many petrochemicals."""" Real content might be worth saving, this article doesn't have real content, just puffery""" Deletion of Products Manufactured in Australia and New Zealand WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4910 20047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gzim Selmani User:Oknazevad 11:28, 14 June 2016 (UTC) keep """Not meeting is insufficient reason to delete, as he nit just an MMA fighter. Specific notability guidelines are always secondary to the GNG, which, as the anon notes, he passes. Also, while NXT is, in part, developmental for the main WWE roster, they do sell out 20,000 seat arenas for NXT shows. Not exactly """"just a training program""" Deletion of Gzim Selmani WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
4911 15120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Ochoa User:IJBall 05:08, 13 January 2016 (UTC) keep just one significant role, and it was as a supporting player, on ''Pair of Kings''. Probably enough for now (it's probably just ''under'' qualifying vis a vis , but I'm usually willing to overlook that for a main role on a single longish-running TV series). But I'd be willing to revisit this one in 5 years if nothing else of significance happens in the meantime, and reconsider then Deletion of Ryan Ochoa WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
4912 14479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nelson De La Nuez User:Beyond 23:17, 10 July 2017 (UTC) delete """I worked on this article some, but after looking in sources that would very likely have '''''some''''' coverage (or at least a mention) of this self-proclaimed """"King of Pop Art"""" (such as the ''NY Times'' or the ''LA Times''), I've reached the conclusion (or at least the extremely strong suspicion) that this person's """"fame"""" is almost entirely built on self-promotion. I suggested in the AN/I discussion that someone bring it to AfD, because that can sometimes be a catalyst for finding reliable sources, and if that's the case, I'll reconsider my !vote, but as things stand at the moment, this just doesn't add up. I'm not sure it's a , but he sure as heck doesn't appear to be notable in our terms""" Deletion of Nelson De La Nuez WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
4913 5715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pocketbook (song) User:RadioFan 20:36, 17 August 2009 (UTC) keep I did not check the reviews but there seems to be acknowledgement that there are several reviews. If that is the case, the song meets |the general notability requirements and so the specific music criteria that Deletion of Pocketbook (song) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4914 2052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asami Sato (2nd nomination) User:Tutelary 03:55, 3 January 2015 (UTC) delete or '''Redirect'''. This article should not have been created, and qualifies under speedy deletion criterion . The character is not notable outside of Legend of Korra and as a result does not stand to have a standalone article. Whatever content that is mergable should be merged to respectable articles Deletion of Asami Sato (2nd nomination) WP:G4 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
4915 6199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Chandler User:Lulu 17:20, 7 September 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Philip Chandler WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
4916 661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timeline of Valve Corporation User:Sunmist3 10:33, 13 August 2016 (UTC) delete or redirect. Article is a , and doesn't provide any additional information compared to Valve Corporation. While displaying the events in chronological order is useful, a seperate article isn't need to do so Deletion of Timeline of Valve Corporation WP:REDUNDANTFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
4917 12475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caffeinated Concert Tickets (3rd nomination) User:MB 00:45, 24 November 2016 (UTC) delete as nominator): A summary of an un-notable episode of a cartoon show. Was Redirected per 2012 AFD nomination and recreated in 2015, after which it was nominated for AFD again and that time closed as No Consensus due to lack of participation. Another episode was recently deleted for the same reason (not notable), see rticles for deletion/The Unicorns Have Got to Go. This episode is similarly un-notable Deletion of Caffeinated Concert Tickets (3rd nomination) WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
4918 7913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of military disasters (4th nomination) User:Georgethedragonslayer 02:12, 18 May 2021 (UTC) delete """It is mainly and the actual """"military disaster"""" would not require a list""" Deletion of List of military disasters (4th nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
4919 8571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian Sklar User:Cunard 09:43, 2 November 2008 (UTC) delete fails . A http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tab=wn&q=%22Ian+Sklar%22 Google News archive search returns few results related to this individual. The article says he is related to many notable musical relative, such as Walter Hautzig, but Wikipedia:Inherited|notability is not inherited. He has released albums but they have not won any notable awards or charted. Article asserts no notability at all and might be an '''A7''' candidate Deletion of Ian Sklar WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4920 4918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tellows User:JamesBaldwinWiki 09:17, 7 September 2018 (UTC) keep The article has notable and significant sources. I've erased some sources that are too unreliable such as blogs, press releases, or untrustworthy sites and added more reliable sources such as BBC spain, Bild, Genbeta. The sources are now trusted websites which meet the criteria of . As mentioned in the product review section in some sources are mainly product reviews which are allowed, as the reviews are objective with comparison of the product/application with other brands Deletion of Tellows WP:ORGDEPTH||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4921 413 [[Vorlage:Kategoriegraph]] (Bleibt vorerst) Benutzer:Xorx/Bewertung 15:41, 8. Jul. 2007 (CEST) keep Erstmal : Ich habe die Vorlage damals nach Diskussion mit dem Autor des CatGraph-Tools erstellt. Sehen wir es mal als Testballon, der dazu dient zu prüfen, ob so ein Werkzeug die Arbeit hier unterstützt. Das scheint sich nun abzuzeichnen. Von daher halte ich den Vorschlag das über zum Standardwerkzeug zu machen für sehr vernünftig. Bis dahin würde ich es aber in der Vorlagenform erhalten Löschung von Vorlage:Kategoriegraph Wikipedia:KAT Wikipedia:Kategorien 63
4922 17306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nikalas Catlow NONE NONE delete I have found the following pages that contain biographical information about Catlow (in addition to the self-authored bio): http://www.book-by-its-cover.com/author/nikalascatlow, http://www.perseusbooksgroup.com/RunningPress/author_detail.jsp?id=1000031440. Neither of these pages contain anything more than the most cursory coverage of the man himself, and we are still left in a position where the only source containing any sort of |significant coverage about the author is one he has written himself. Not only is the |reliability of this source questionable because it is self-published, but because it is self-published ''it is not sufficient to establish |notability under the |general notability guideline.''. Furthermore, I would point out the 4 indicators of notability for creative professionals at Deletion of Nikalas Catlow WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS||WP:N||WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
4923 20617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disk knight User:Schuym1 00:13, 13 December 2008 (UTC) delete Doesn't show notability per Deletion of Disk knight WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4924 19981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deck of 52 User:Teancum 11:40, 11 May 2010 (UTC) delete """Normally I don't use this, but """"''per everyone else''"""". Everything that needs to be said has been. Its and fails . If the subject had any significant coverage (which it doesn't) I'd be more lenient, but even then it would need a 100% total rewrite""" Deletion of Deck of 52 WP:GAMETRIVIA||WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
4925 18831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of English words of Japanese origin User:Colonel 08:11, 3 May 2008 (UTC) delete per |Wikipedia is not a dictionary since this is nothing but a list of dictionary definitions. The many references to dictionaries above prove the point. If we were to compile other similar lists, such as List of words of Greek origin, then we would have the entire English language which, being a mongrel language, is composed of nothing but loan words Deletion of List of English words of Japanese origin WP:DICT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
4926 11277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sofya Polyakov User:Hmlarson 07:49, 4 April 2018 (UTC) delete unless citations can be added to the article to re-inforce with no prejudice towards recreation and expansion at a later date given adequate referencing Deletion of Sofya Polyakov WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4927 16266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amber Rose (porn star) (2nd nomination) User:Oakshade 02:20, 11 March 2007 (UTC) keep Well, she has a nich in the porn genre. I don't care for it, but is not a reason to delete this and I don't want to blow hot air Deletion of Amber Rose (porn star) (2nd nomination) WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4928 16300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of countries by population in 2050 User:Metropolitan90 18:18, 5 June 2011 (UTC) delete because |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball, and because this isn't actually a list of countries by population in 2050 anyway Deletion of List of countries by population in 2050 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4929 15571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Boathouse Putney User:Novem 11:42, 14 April 2021 (UTC) delete Sources in the article and sources from my Google searches do not pass . I found various problems with potential sources including primary, self-published, and lack of significant coverage Deletion of The Boathouse Putney WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4930 2122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Jimenez User:Abishe 19:24, 5 June 2020 (UTC) keep the subject definitely meets and he was notable even prior to his arrest Deletion of Omar Jimenez WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4931 5237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Arthur (musician) User:W 02:20, 29 August 2006 (UTC) keep he's listed on AMG and they've reviewed his album on Bardic http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sql=10:s963tr3tkl5x. His 2000 album was on The Orchard (music label) apparently. would seem to meet based on that. Also, Google search suggests there's some reliable sources with information on him, so article could be expanded Deletion of Ben Arthur (musician) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4932 6867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Probabilistic solution discovery algorithm User:Bearian 21:25, 9 March 2015 (UTC) delete this seems to be original research, |which we do not publish, by a single primary author, for whom RESUME|we are not a free resume host Deletion of Probabilistic solution discovery algorithm WP:NOT||WP:NOTRESUME Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4933 12449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/200 Greatest Israelis User:Ratibgreat 16:35, 25 September 2011 (UTC) delete """Let's see what the poll was about from the sources quoted in the article: http://www.businessinsider.com/could-obama-be-ready-to-jumpstart-the-peace-process-2011-8 """"Newspaper tabloid poll"""", http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/biography/Arison_Shari.html """"a poll by the Israeli news website Ynet"""" and http://www.salem-news.com/articles/september082011/israel-dogs-ua.php """"a poll by the Israeli news website Ynet"""" (using English sources only). Absolutely ludicrous methodology that's ''unrepresentative'' of the population (for one thing, this was an ''online poll''). Moreover, every tabloid has an online poll everyday. Nothing here shows how this poll is unique - refer to """ Deletion of 200 Greatest Israelis WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
4934 18769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conspiracy journalism (2nd nomination) User:Uzma 11:16, 20 December 2010 (UTC) delete """I participated in the MfD and was invited to add my thoughts in this AfD#2. """"Conspiracy Journalism"""" is Wikipedia:Wikipedia_is_not_a_dictionary#Neologisms|neologisms and there is not enough reliable source material to satisfy . The article violates wp:OR|No original research in that the article combines material from multiple web sources to reach the conclusion that Conspiracy Journalism represents a genre of journalism when the sources do not state that. The article lead states, """"Conspiracy Journalism represents a genre of journalism that has elements of advocacy journalism, yellow journalism and investigative journalism."""" Books Ngram Viewer shows that, unlike advocacy journalism, yellow journalism, and investigative journalism mentioned in the conspiracy journalism article, http://ngrams.googlelabs.com/graph?content=advocacy+journalism%2C+yellow+journalism%2C+investigative+journalism%2C+conspiracy+journalism&year_start=1960&year_end=2008&corpus=0&smoothing=3 the phrase 'conspiracy journalism' has had no noticeable usage through 2008. Moreover, there is no sense from the sources in the article that they are each talking about the same idea when they mention the phrase """"Conspiracy Journalism"""". Conspiracy journalism is fast becoming the Grigori_Rasputin#Murder|Rasputin of Wikipedia. Since its March 20, 2010 deletion, the material has been moved in the past nine months from article space-->AfD--> DRV-->Article Incubator-->MfD-->User space-->article space. No significant new information has come to light since March 20, 2010 to overcome the reasons for deletion at AfD#1. As noted in the collapsed template above, the November 28, 2010 Article Incubation assessment established that the deleted article had not proven useful to write a new article at Article Incubator. Delete and remove from Wikipedia""" Deletion of Conspiracy journalism (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4935 17813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional Australian politicians (2nd nomination) User:Darkknight2149 02:26, 21 January 2021 (UTC) merge """The first AfD was from 2007 and the reasons cited in the """"Keep"""" votes seemed very superficial without a lot of elaboration. Per {{u|Rorshacma}}, if no one is able to demonstrate that there is enough coverage of the topic to satisfy , then I don't see how it can remain a standalone article. However, I will concede that the scope of List of fictional politicians seems a bit too broad and abstract, and articles like that tend to become sponges""" Deletion of List of fictional Australian politicians (2nd nomination) WP:LISTN||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
4936 15925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aziz Deen-Conteh (2nd nomination) User:Fenix 08:10, 3 October 2013 (UTC) delete per nom, but do not agree with salting. He is at a club in an FPL, so seems more a case of than a player who could never probably have a WP article particularly given his age Deletion of Aziz Deen-Conteh (2nd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
4937 12166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charley Marcuse User:Lankiveil 13:34, 31 May 2014 (UTC) keep for someone that sells hot dogs and now is a mustard salesman, he seems to have gotten a surprising amount of coverage, as outlined above. Meets the quite easily Deletion of Charley Marcuse WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4938 11004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of character actors User:Stifle 16:18, 7 September 2008 (UTC) delete per items 3, 4, 7, and 9 at Deletion of List of character actors WP:LC Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
4939 19414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SD International Public School User:Chiro725 14:52, 6 April 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of SD International Public School WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4940 6782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danny Welbeck User:RMHED 02:34, 31 January 2008 (UTC) keep currently just scrapes through #Athletes, though quite likely to gain greater notability in the near future Deletion of Danny Welbeck WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4941 4866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bong cooler User:DMacks 20:26, 22 November 2009 (UTC) merge to Evaporative cooler#Evaporative cooler designs if can be found about it. OTOH, this seems like a niche-application device, so maybe better to put it in Computer cooling .A lack of sources is a good reason to delete because is a core policy, as well as being evidence for the guideline. It indeed does look interesting, but that's not the criterion for inclusion. Someone quick get us ''some'' sources so we can decide if it's got enough to merit inclusion in those articles or if I should change my !vote to delete as a piece of FT lore Deletion of Bong cooler WP:RS||WP:V||WP:N||WP:V||WP:NFT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4942 11853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Bolt User:ZimZalaBim 03:49, 12 September 2008 (UTC) delete even if referenced, isn't |notable Deletion of Donald Bolt WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4943 16668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Davide Giannoni User:Ymblanter 09:48, 1 December 2013 (UTC) keep I was about to close this as delete, but wanted to check whether the athlete indeed fails (SPORTS does not say anything about Xtreme sports, from what I can see, and applies). I searched in Italian and was able to found a couple of things where he is described in some detail: http://www.bladeinitaly.it/2013/06/25/itw-davide-giannoni-di-ritorno-da-shangai/ Italian rollerblading magazine, http://www.romagnagazzette.com/2012/01/02/il-sammarinese-davide-giannoni-al-5%C2%B0-posto-nel-campionato-europeo-di-mosca/ Romagna Gazzette - the provincial newspaper, not just Rimini, and a couple of local Rimini articles were reprinted by national media, such as http://www.sportit24.com/notizie/davide-giannoni-all-international-roller-cup-di-modena here Deletion of Davide Giannoni WP:N||WP:NSPORTS||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4944 306 [[Chris Wickenden]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers NONE delete """Kasten|1=. Ich sehe keine Relevanz nach #Wissenschaftler und auch keine nach WP:RBK: Wenn explizit eine Professur an einer staatlichen Hochschule gefordert ist, ist eine Lehrgangsleitung an einer privaten Hochschule eben nicht dasselbe. Sicher fallen """"andewandte Künste"""" ein wenig durch das Raster, aber es müsste dann halt eine größere Wahrnehmung in entsprechenden Medien/Fachpublikationen vorhanden sein, die trotzdem beweist, dass eine besondere Position innerhalb des Fachs vorhanden ist. Das ist für mich auch nicht ohne Weiteres aufzufinden und war im Artikel nicht dargestellt. Damit einfach noch zu früh für wirkliche zeitüberdauernde enyzklopädische Bedeutung. Gruß""" Löschung von Chris Wickenden Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
4945 14964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chronic hero syndrome User:NinjaRobotPirate 01:38, 5 June 2016 (UTC) delete Very few Google hits, which are mostly just stuff like TV Tropes. I don't see any coverage in reliable sources, especially the kind that we'd need to satisfy as an actual psychological condition. This could have been imported from TV Tropes by someone who doesn't understand the GNG Deletion of Chronic hero syndrome WP:MEDRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4946 17554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soramimi User:Whpq 18:00, 9 December 2008 (UTC) keep sources may be difficult to deal with as they are likely to be in Japanese. But being popular enough to generate a recurring segment in a comedy show is evidence that the subject is likely notable and kept per Deletion of Soramimi WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
4947 17 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skinner Creek User:Clarityfiend 20:13, 8 January 2020 (UTC) delete """or possibly '''redirect''' to List of rivers of Missouri and add it there as a tributary of Big Creek (assuming the map Google brings up is accurate). Per , no """" notable, provided information beyond statistics and coordinates"""" is available, so no standalone article is warranted""" Deletion of Skinner Creek WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4948 18764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sokrat Hovhannisyan User:Jkudlick 02:15, 1 October 2015 (UTC) delete Presently fails as he has not yet appeared on the pitch for FC Shirak. Fails due to lack of non-routine coverage. — Deletion of Sokrat Hovhannisyan WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4949 6083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of San Francisco Ballet 2012 repertory User:Daniel 23:29, 27 January 2012 (UTC) delete this is clearly a case of . This information might be hard to find elsewhere, but that is not a reason to insist on it being hosted here Deletion of List of San Francisco Ballet 2012 repertory WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4950 2925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kyle Reed User:Bagumba 09:19, 19 July 2011 (UTC) delete """Does not meet for college athletes, and never played at highest level professionally. Source from The Daily Californian is a school newspaper and not an |independent source as required by . says """"Multiple publications from the same author or organization are usually regarded as a single source for the purposes of establishing notability"""", but the sources are from MediaNews Group which syndicate each others articles (San Jose Mercury News, Oakland Tribune, Las Cruces Sun-News). A lot of the sources listed were available subscription only, so cited results from does not weed out articles that might be coverage even though the limited headline and excerpt seems promising. I personally can't verify it. This player generated some news because he decided to transfer schools within the Bay Area and happens to be a quarterback who played against Nebraska, so """"keep"""" proponents can have a field day citing sources from the state of Nebraska. But WP is . I'm at a loss as to what would ever be """"interesting or notable"""" in even the most polished |lead section for this article. Perhaps someone can provide some talking points to change my mind on why this person should not be considered un-of-the-mill and is deserving of an article""" Deletion of Kyle Reed WP:NSPORT||WP:IS||WP:GNG||WP:GOOGLEHITS||WP:ROUTINE||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:LEAD||WP:R Wikipedia:Notability 77
4951 14957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The End of the World (animation) User:Leebo 18:56, 26 March 2007 (UTC) delete The |notability is not established by |reliable, third party sources. It would also appear to include |original research Deletion of The End of the World (animation) WP:WEB||WP:RS||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
4952 1941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Zalewski User:Rlendog 22:29, 6 March 2017 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet and not finding significant coverage Deletion of Richard Zalewski WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
4953 9694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Jarman User:Walter 14:44, 8 May 2017 (UTC) delete I found a few sources, but not enough to convince me that the subject meets . http://www.sgnscoops.com/woodsmen-quartet-welcome-tony-jarman/ https://southerngospeljournal.com/archives/10087 http://singingnews.com/news/11591844/ A mention at http://www.sgnscoops.com/quite-a-legacy-a-look-at-legacy-five Deletion of Tony Jarman :WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4954 4556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gemma Quinnell User:Wjemather 11:52, 22 February 2021 (UTC) delete per . No to suggest this is a notable person Deletion of Gemma Quinnell WP:NOTRESUME||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4955 14513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Boylan User:Peter 00:04, 29 January 2009 (UTC) comment or to put it another way, he's a case of , with that event already covered at Frome by-election, 2009 Deletion of Terry Boylan WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4956 278 [[Getränkemarken der Coca-Cola Company]] verschoben nach [[Liste der Getränkemarken der Coca-Cola Company im deutschsprachigen Raum]] (LAE) Benutzer:Chaddy NONE keep """Veraltet"""" ist kein Löschgrund und """"sinnlos"""" wurde bereits im /23. Oktober 2017#Getränkemarken der Coca-Cola Company (bleibt)|letzten LA als Grund gebracht. Da keine neuen zulässigen Argumente genannt wurden ist der LA ungültig""" Löschung von Liste der Getränkemarken der Coca-Cola Company im deutschsprachigen Raum Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4957 1882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crazy Planets User:Reyk 05:14, 21 November 2009 (UTC) delete Facebook has zillions of games and applications. Most of them, such as this one, are not notable. The standard for inclusion at Wikipedia is substantial coverage in reliable sources, no matter how many people |like it Deletion of Crazy Planets WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4958 13294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yousha Liu User:Alex 09:55, 23 March 2020 (UTC) delete Article does not pass , looks promotional Deletion of Yousha Liu WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4959 4926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Controversies of the Polish-Soviet War User:Martintg 09:36, 5 August 2007 (UTC) keep per Sander. Seems this AfD is a case of Deletion of Controversies of the Polish-Soviet War WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4960 10536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Home alone 5 User:TenPoundHammer 23:17, 25 November 2007 (UTC) delete """Lucifer McAllister""""? Sounds like a hoax to me. Either way, it's definitely seeing as nothing's been confirmed yet. (And furthermore, you'd think they'd know better, seeing as the last ''Home Alone'' movie was a flop""" Deletion of Home alone 5 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4961 7712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tuareg Geeks User:Gongshow 18:27, 24 December 2009 (UTC) delete I'm unable to find any in-depth coverage; does not appear to meet Deletion of Tuareg Geeks WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4962 8180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Oulds User:Bearcat 15:53, 13 August 2018 (UTC) delete """Nothing stated in the article hands him an automatic """"inherently notable"""" freebie just because he exists, but the sourcing isn't cutting it in terms of getting him over : it's far too dependent on |primary sources rather than |reliable ones — a person is not notable as a company director just because the fact can technically be referenced to the company's own |self-published website about itself, and neither is he notable as a writer just because the fact that he wrote a book can be metareferenced to itself — but the few sources which are actually reliable ones just make him a rather than a |ten-year test passing topic of enduring permanent notability""" Deletion of Robert Oulds WP:GNG||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:RS||WP:SELFPUB||WP:BLP1E||WP:10YT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4963 12993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rules According to Ral: Chaos Wars User:BOZ 16:55, 22 January 2020 (UTC) keep based on available sources, or '''merge''' to Ral Partha Enterprises per and Deletion of Rules According to Ral: Chaos Wars WP:PRESERVE||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
4964 18556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RDX (Band) User:Dlohcierekim 08:24, 11 June 2017 (UTC) delete does not meet GNG. sourcing in article insufficient in depth. Clash is not sufficient in depth. Just saw reviews that are Deletion of RDX (Band) WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
4965 16814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/First Bush transfer of power User:Corpx 02:45, 24 July 2007 (UTC) delete This is absolutely no historic notability for this even - #NEWS Deletion of First Bush transfer of power WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4966 20252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of individuals with obsessive compulsive Disorder (OCD) User:Bearian 19:34, 22 May 2013 (UTC) delete as a |train wreck Deletion of List of individuals with obsessive compulsive Disorder (OCD) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
4967 18669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helgason Asgeir User:Thatcher131 12:26, 16 March 2006 (UTC) delete Does not appear to be more noteworthy than than the average university professor (see ). Wikipedia is not PubMed. Additional evidence of notariety outside PubMed might change my mind, such as if he has been quoted (more than once) in newspaper stories as an expert about his field. Institutions are often anxious to promote their research for fundraising purposes or to raise their standing in terms of recruiting students and faculty, and issue press releases that may or may not be picked up by the local press. I searched the website of the Karolinska Institutet (English version) and did not find any press releases about his work. Note that if the article is kept it needs to be moved to Asgeir Helgason. Backwards talking wikipedia is not. Also may be a violation of anity. Note that the article has 3 editors whose only edits have been to this article, its 3 redirect pages, or adding links to articles in his field of research Deletion of Helgason Asgeir WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
4968 20795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atheist Community of Austin User:Starblind 14:30, 8 October 2008 (UTC) delete per the nom and Schmidt. Doesn't pass , no notability at all, poorly sourced Deletion of Atheist Community of Austin WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
4969 18686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor Who Club of Australia User:Graymornings 19:31, 19 January 2009 (UTC) comment I found a couple of news mentions for the club with a http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tab=wn&q=%22doctor+who+club+of+australia%22 Google News search—also, a few for the http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&tab=wn&ned=us&q=%22whovention%22&ie=UTF-8 Whovention. Don't know whether this is enough to pass —I'm inclined to think it isn't, since they've been around since the 1970s—but it might help Deletion of Doctor Who Club of Australia WP:CLUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4970 9610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Carlin co-founder Funny Garbage, Red Hot User:THF 17:21, 22 November 2010 (UTC) delete """Just on the borderline for . I wouldn't cry hard if it were merge/redirected to Red Hot Organization; I don't see much useful in the way of secondary sources independent of his role at RHO. Being """"quoted"""" in my mind is insufficient to qualify under ; articles need to be ''about'' you, rather than simply mentioning you, and searches for Carlin that mention biographical details like his law firm turn up empty. If kept article needs a renaming and a rewriting""" Deletion of John Carlin co-founder Funny Garbage, Red Hot WP:AUTHOR||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4971 860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artie Diamond User:Chaser 17:59, 7 November 2009 (UTC) keep """I can't find very much, but I think it is enough. There are at least a few articles with a couple of hundred words a-piece, the first two hits in http://query.nytimes.com/search/query?frow=0&n=10&srcht=a&query=%22Artie+Diamond%22&srchst=p&submit.x=22&submit.y=10&submit=sub&hdlquery=&bylquery=&daterange=period&mon1=01&day1=01&year1=1981&mon2=11&day2=07&year2=2009 Gnews archives. If you keep going there are articles of a few dozen words, so those may be """"trivial mentions"""" for the purposes of . However, the two longer NYT pieces with the Inside Sports piece is enough to establish notability""" Deletion of Artie Diamond WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
4972 17700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank Ronzio User:CASSIOPEIA 04:16, 6 February 2019 (UTC) delete A found subject fails GNG and Deletion of Frank Ronzio WP:BEFORE||WP:ACTOR Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
4973 12404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Icoy de Guzman User:RightCowLeftCoast 20:28, 4 May 2013 (UTC) delete Subject has received some coverage, arguably |significant, in non-primary |reliable sources; however, the coverage is primarily regarding the subject's candidacy for a future election. Therefore, it can be argued that the subject is only notable for one event, and thus falls under . Furthermore, the subject clearly fails , for being a candidate for an election does not automatically denote notability. Therefore failing POLITICIAN and not being notable for realms outside of politics, I believe that the subject of this AfD is |not yet notable to warrant a standalone BLP article Deletion of Icoy de Guzman WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS||WP:BLP1E||WP:POLITICIAN||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
4974 5015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IndianCashback.com User:Norvoid 11:37, 20 November 2015 (UTC) delete no indication of notability per , and no mention on secondary, , just lots of self-promotion on social media etc Deletion of IndianCashback.com WP:WEB||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
4975 8543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ambassador Downs Mobile Home Park User:onel5969 21:04, 14 August 2016 (UTC) keep """Per : """"Populated, legally recognized places are typically presumed to be notable, even if their population is very low."""" By definition, the USGS designation is legal recognition of the place. And the USGS listing gives the location the definition of a """"populated place"""". There is nothing, as the nominator claims, in Geoland which says that a populated place which meets the main requirement of Geoland must also show independent notability if it is located within a city/town""" Deletion of Ambassador Downs Mobile Home Park WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
4976 9029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Arsenal F.C. Supporters User:segv11 23:13, 22 December 2005 (UTC) delete as |really bad listctuft Deletion of List of Arsenal F.C. Supporters WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
4977 305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional kangaroos and wallabies User:Hans 20:14, 8 October 2010 (UTC) keep per Deletion of List of fictional kangaroos and wallabies WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
4978 16251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 Australian counter-terrorism raids User:XavierItzm 11:52, 6 September 2017 (UTC) keep Case is already included in books,https://books.google.it/books?id=svh4CAAAQBAJ&pg=PT63&lpg=PT63&dq=Omarjan+Azari&source=bl&ots=yNREGfqvgm&sig=2fDYHVH3c9ytVgTTZGE4HyHnrDU&hl=en&sa=X&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=Omarjan%20Azari&f=false. The case got widespread national media coverage in 2014, 2015, 2016, and 2017 (see article for refs for e.a. year). The main suspect is to be tried by the Supreme Court; the Supreme Court case starts November 2017. Meets Deletion of 2014 Australian counter-terrorism raids WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
4979 15291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edwina (M*A*S*H) User:Collectonian 04:34, 15 May 2009 (UTC) delete Unnotable episode of the series with nothing but a short plot summary which is already covered in season list and this is an unlikely search term. Fails and . Per Wp:MOS-TV, numerous other episode AfDs, and general consensus regarding individual episode articles, doesn't belong here. M*A*S*H wikia for transwiking Deletion of Edwina (M*A*S*H) WP:N||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Notability 77
4980 10785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lotus (rock band) NONE NONE keep From the Page Deletion of Lotus (rock band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
4981 4361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kinder's User:JFHJr 19:15, 29 September 2012 (UTC) delete Fails due to lack of |reliable sources that give any measure of in coverage. The multiple mentions show the company exists and has changed hands, but little more Deletion of Kinder's WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
4982 14059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Economic history of the Christians [[User talk:75.57.242.120|talk]]) 01:32, 5 April 2011 (UTC) delete clever retort to Jews and money but y to put it in article space. Would have deserved a smile if released in user space instead (especially on April 1) and linked in appropriate project-space venues. As things are, to the author. Special:Contributions/75.57.242.120|75.57.242.120 Deletion of Economic history of the Christians WP:POINT||WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
4983 17917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Intensional statement User:PWilkinson 12:41, 28 February 2014 (UTC) keep By 2004 Wikipedia standards, the article actually handles a notable, if an obscure and conceptually rather difficult, topic fairly well - even the lack of references was acceptable by the standards of that time, provided the article was fairly non-controversial. The problem is that the nature of the topic and the small number of inward links has resulted in the article not getting any substantial attention since then, and it has not been updated in line with our current checklist of standards. Even the article as it stands is almost certainly sourceable, though possibly with some difficulty - it corresponds closely, right down to the specific examples, with what I remember being taught about the topic as a philosophy student in about 1977, and while I rather wonder whether the article creator was using lecture notes of a similar vintage, the same material will have been somewhere in the background reading lists for that part of the course. If I can easily find some relevant sources in my remaining philosophy books, I will add them to the article, but even if I can't, they should still be available in a sufficiently good university library. Of course, the ones I remember will be fairly old (though I would point out |notability is not temporary) - but the standard GBooks search comes up with quite a number of more recent reliable sources for a more up to date article, particularly if the search is expanded to the effectively synonymous ''intensional sentence'' and ''intensional proposition Deletion of Intensional statement WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
4984 4618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandeep Unnikrishnan User:LeaveSleaves 20:15, 28 November 2008 (UTC) merge to List of victims of the November 2008 Mumbai attacks. Even though under #NEWS and this person may not qualify for an article, I think that in present situation a redirect would be helpful. Particularly since he was among the security forces and slightly more notable than other victims. ''Special:Contributions/LeaveSleaves|Leave Deletion of Sandeep Unnikrishnan WP:NOT||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4985 6123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FOB Productions User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable. &mdash Deletion of FOB Productions WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
4986 181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Left-Wing Fascism in India User:Soman 11:58, 20 February 2009 (UTC) comment oh the irony. I had posted a message (a generic template for CSD:G10) at {{user|Michonuri}}'s talk page. Now {{user|Minten}} uses the wording 'on my talk page', thereby admitting to |sock-puppetry. My personal guess is that not only Minten and Michonuri, but also {{user|Gabriel N}} are one and the same person Deletion of Left-Wing Fascism in India WP:SOCK Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
4987 14116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philippine Showbiz Clans User:Hiwilms 05:40, 21 March 2019 (UTC) delete WP:LC does not fall in any CSD but falls under Deletion of Philippine Showbiz Clans WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4988 10472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diary of an Unborn Child NONE NONE delete Sorry, but it still does not meet , or .- none of the sources are at all in depth, and quite a few are not RS Deletion of Diary of an Unborn Child WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
4989 82 [[Werner Ratering]] (nach Überarbeitung erledigt) Benutzer:Kriddl NONE keep Die #Bildende Künstler|Künstlerrelevanzkriterien sehen Relevanz bei mindestens zwei Ausstellungen in anerkannten Museen vor, der hier hat im Kunstpavillion der Stadt Soest (ist unter Museen in Nordrhein-Westfalen#S|Museen in Nordrhein-Westfalen aufgeführt) und dem Dominikanerkirche Osnabrück (vgl. Liste der Museen in Niedersachsen#O|Liste der Museen in Niedersachsen) Einzelausstellungen, damit relevant genug für Wikipedia. Geht nebenbei aus dem Artikel hervor Löschung von Werner Ratering Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
4990 2898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mariana Huerta User:Noq 16:35, 20 December 2016 (UTC) delete """I originally proded it with the foloowing rationale: No indication of meeting |notability guidelines. IMDb shows as appearing in 3 shorts - 2 of which have not been released. The """"nomination"""" for best actress is from a non notable festival that issues monthly lists of winners and is for something that does not even make IMDb""" Deletion of Mariana Huerta WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
4991 6287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RomleyOmley.tk User:DarkAudit 14:36, 14 July 2006 (UTC) delete as failing . Wikipedia is not free ad space. Authors only edits are to this article Deletion of RomleyOmley.tk WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
4992 11026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Money in the Bank (2011) User:Crisco 07:15, 4 June 2011 (UTC) merge I think Chzz is in the right here; it is a future event that doesn't pass just yet. Don't delete the history; we will probably recreate this article after the event happens (or as it is happening). As for the reverter, I'm thinking |fish Deletion of Money in the Bank (2011) WP:GNG||WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Notability 77
4993 20494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Free (hip hop musician) User:Coredesat 01:37, 25 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails |CSD:A7 Deletion of Scott Free (hip hop musician) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
4994 14991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Croxton User:Undead 07:20, 14 December 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and . The band redirects to an index Deletion of Matthew Croxton WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
4995 8869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PlanetFurry User:Alan 22:02, 4 April 2006 (UTC) delete The article makes no assertion of notability and doesn't appear to meet Deletion of PlanetFurry WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
4996 1238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of video game emulators User:Rhododendrites 18:58, 27 September 2018 (UTC) keep Nothing resembling a valid reason for deletion given. Just like the list of guitarists or list of social networking websites do not list every person who plays guitar or every social networking website that exists, so this is a directory of every emulator that exists or otherwise an Emulator Wikia. That you don't like it is not a good reason for deletion. &mdash Deletion of List of video game emulators WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4997 12923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Rudy User:Moreschi 14:58, 16 March 2007 (UTC) delete unsourced, is policy, probably hoax based on Tikiwont's findings above Deletion of James Rudy WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
4998 137 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Petros Fyssoun Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 08:06, 16 Aralık 2016 (UTC) keep """Yunanlılar için önemini bilemem, burası için pek yok"""" gibi bakış açısını yakıştıramadım size. sayfasının okunmasını şiddetle tavsiye ederim. Türkçe içerik sunuyoruz diye Türkiye'ye göre önemli maddeleri açacak değiliz. Şahıs, kayda değer yapımlarda başrol oynadığından kayda değer kriterlerimize göre""" Petros Fyssoun'un silinmesi Vikipedi:MİLLİ Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
4999 9858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rohan Rangarajan User:BlackJack 11:19, 9 March 2017 (UTC) delete per nom. This is Deletion of Rohan Rangarajan WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
5000 5882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Halis Aydemir User:Phil 16:33, 27 July 2011 (UTC) delete It would be unusual for anyone to have achieved the standards of so early in an academic career (PhD in 2004 and associate professorship since 2009) and there's nothing in the article or that I can find elsewhere to indicate that Halis Aydemir is an exception to that general trend. Turkish uses the Roman alphabet, so searching for the subject's name as written in the article would find Turkish as well as English sources if they existed. There's no need to understand a language to see that Google Books only finds books ''by'' the subject (two of the three being self-published via Lulu.com) and Wikipedia mirrors, that Google Scholar finds no citations to those books, and that Google News, which has wide coverage of the Turkish media, finds nothing Deletion of Halis Aydemir WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5001 11943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ramfire User:Kinu 06:54, 1 March 2006 (UTC) delete The term RAMfire was coined by http://dreamstar.aerocore.net Corey Edwards in February 2006.'' was made for this one Deletion of Ramfire WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
5002 16192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary Pease User:SummerPhD 13:34, 29 May 2009 (UTC) comment He does ''not'' meet any of the criteria under , all of the roles listed are clearly minor. In any case, that would only have established a ''presumption'' of notability. To actually be notable, we would need substantial coverage in independent reliable sources. IMDb is not a reliable source, so we have no coverage whatsoever in reliable sources Deletion of Gary Pease WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5003 12336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pepe Salcedo User:CactusWriter 21:43, 19 July 2017 (UTC) delete fails and . No evidence of significant coverage in independent reliable sources. No evidence of notability in sport, such as world record holders Deletion of Pepe Salcedo WP:ATHLETE||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5004 5675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ESPN College Basketball broadcast teams User:Lightburst 00:40, 5 January 2020 (UTC) keep Per useful for navigation and information. RS exists Deletion of ESPN College Basketball broadcast teams WP:NLIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
5005 6184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S. Perera (Old Cambrians cricketer) (2nd nomination) User:Reyk 09:44, 19 December 2015 (UTC) comment that this article's defenders are |canvassing for keep votes: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Jhall1&diff=prev&oldid=695837770 Deletion of S. Perera (Old Cambrians cricketer) (2nd nomination) WP:CANVASS Wikipedia:Canvassing 93
5006 8902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jane Parker-Smith User:SportsOlympic 11:18, 29 June 2020 (UTC) keep """Previously deleted article"""" not a reason, as it wad deleted due to copyright issues. We can say she meets under point 7 (''Has become one of the most prominent representatives of a notable style or the most prominent of the local scene of a city.'') and 12 (''Has been a featured subject of a substantial broadcast segment across a national radio or television network""" Deletion of Jane Parker-Smith WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5007 10218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barbara Baker User:Meatsgains 18:07, 17 September 2016 (UTC) delete Subject lacks notability. Most of the page's current references are local news outlets and the personal life section, as DGG noted, is and Deletion of Barbara Baker WP:UNDUE||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
5008 12715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Parker (doctor) User:Dennisthe2 00:16, 3 October 2009 (UTC) delete no notability as per Deletion of Jim Parker (doctor) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
5009 3128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vanessa McIntosh User:WarthogDemon 00:53, 13 July 2007 (UTC) comment That's not a legit arguement, see Deletion of Vanessa McIntosh WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5010 1472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neon Synthesis User:doomsdayer520 15:12, 6 March 2021 (UTC) delete It turns out that they have a media mention in a reliable source, Blabbermouth: https://www.blabbermouth.net/news/neon-synthesis-completes-work-on-debut-album/. Unfortunately a basic album announcement is not particularly |significant. Otherwise I can only find them at the |usual retail and streaming services. This WP article is old but the edit history shows that it started as a pretty obvious attempt at |promotion, by themselves or a fan back in 2007, with very little of substance added since Deletion of Neon Synthesis WP:SIGCOV||WP:MILL||WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
5011 13317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammad Sex Simulator 2015 User:Edison 00:34, 12 February 2015 (UTC) delete Does not satisfy with the 3 instances of coverage noted. Wikipedia is OT|a listing of every offensive creation that gets discussed by 3 writers Deletion of Muhammad Sex Simulator 2015 WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5012 14852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Brammer User:Mkdw 05:01, 9 February 2013 (UTC) delete With only two UFC fights, he remains one shy of a top-tier fight to meet . As he was cut from UFC, there is no indication he will have another top-tier fight anytime soon. No outside to warrant a standalone article outside Deletion of Joe Brammer WP:NMMA||WP:SIGCOV||WP:ROUTINE||WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
5013 6307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brad M. Barber User:Blaxthos 11:34, 15 September 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Brad M. Barber WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5014 4339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abeiku Adams User:Kosack 08:28, 11 February 2017 (UTC) delete his three appearances for RoPS came when they were in the second tier in Finland, which is not fully professional, so he fails and he does not have enough significant coverage to pass Deletion of Abeiku Adams WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5015 4921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark oddo User:Sethacus 20:40, 22 October 2007 (UTC) delete """per . Doesn't appear notable, even with his life of """"fanthorpey"""" (philanthropy""" Deletion of Mark oddo WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5016 11769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cedric Xulu User:Pharaoh 11:59, 6 May 2020 (UTC) keep per above passes Deletion of Cedric Xulu WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5017 19355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Changxing railway station User:Bearian 15:07, 15 October 2020 (UTC) keep """per {{U|Mackensen}} et al. exists to establish basic ground rules for large, high-speed train stations, as this is: """"Existing heavy rail stations on a main system (i.e. not a heritage railway) are generally kept at AfD."""" This is about as |unchanging a consensus as I've seen; it's not a """"soft consensus"""". Deleting this because """"all Chinese media are |unreliable"""" is classic systematic bias and is thus untenable. If this were something controversial (say, prisoners in Tibet or a terrorist attack, Mandate of Heaven|heaven forbid), I'd understand, or if {{U|Jimbo}} declared trains stations to be |run of the mill, but |the coverage is substantial and uncontroversial as it gets""" Deletion of Changxing railway station WP:RAILOUTCOMES||WP:CCC||WP:RS||WP:MILL||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5018 9158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anila Ali User:K 03:37, 20 October 2016 (UTC) delete """per ; the article has no less than eight (8) photos with various dignitaries, such as """"Anila Ali with President Clinton and Lieutenant Governor Gavin Newsom"""" etc. Only a person close to the subject would have stuffed the article with so much puffery. Wikipedia is a platform for self-promotion. Even if the subject were notable (of which I'm not convinced), TNT would have applied as the article would need to be completely rewritten. If a volunteer editor comes along and wants to create an NPOV article, all the power to the. But there's not need to keep promotionalism in the article history""" Deletion of Anila Ali WP:PROMO||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5019 21810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monday Morning (newsletter) (2nd nomination) User:JGHowes 13:57, 21 December 2020 (UTC) keep Not to make an justification, but simply to provide context, we generally cover college newspapers, provided that they meet GNG (see :Category:Student newspapers). While the vast majority of references cited in this article are self-pub or otherwise not reliable sources, the ''Hindu'' and especially the ''New Indian Express'' articles certainly do meet SIGCOV Deletion of Monday Morning (newsletter) (2nd nomination) WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5020 5930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Paya (2nd nomination) User:Colapeninsula 11:19, 15 March 2012 (UTC) comment Per : http://www.westminster.ac.uk/about-us/directory/paya,-ali this indicates he doesn't hold a high enough position (just assistant/visiting professor); Google Scholar shows minimal cites. I can't read Persian, but the English-language sources are lacking Deletion of Ali Paya (2nd nomination) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5021 14429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Lawrence (ice hockey) User:Technical 00:33, 5 September 2013 (UTC) keep """as states """"''Played one or more games in an existing or defunct top professional league such as ...''"""". There is no mention there of a requirement for it to be worldwide nor is there a requirement for the league to be specifically listed whereas it say """"such as"""". That being said, this individual does meet this requirement as Eredivisie itself means """"premier league"""" and being the only league in the Netherlands, is the top league (as well as the bottom""" Deletion of Jim Lawrence (ice hockey) WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5022 10761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Funga User:Royboycrashfan 03:11, 26 February 2006 (UTC) delete """per nom. (this page explains the """"things made up in school one day"""" guideline, not WP:NOT""" Deletion of Funga WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
5023 19694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sinu User:Hetar 22:41, 18 April 2006 (UTC) delete Their website has an Alexa ranking of 6,365,009. The article doesn't even make an assertion of notability, and I can find no evidence that it meets Deletion of Sinu WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5024 21462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ginger Jolie User:Pharmboy 02:12, 16 October 2008 (UTC) comment According to lp#Deletion|BLP, the AFD '''is''' the place to discuss it. We do handle biographies of living people very carefully so we don't harm anyone with inaccuracies, but this article seems to be well within policy. iographies_of_living_persons/Help has info for people who want to have their own article deleted, although I am not sure it will help much. I have to admit that I am against with the idea of deleting an article ONLY because the person it covers wants it deleted, purely on principal. While I try to empathise, Wikipedia's role is document facts that can be verified only, not to decide who it helps or hurts. I am sure that MANY non-living persons would also like to have their articles deleted Deletion of Ginger Jolie WP:B||WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
5025 5309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kalitta Charters Flight 720 User:Devokewater 20:09, 18 March 2021 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Kalitta Charters Flight 720 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5026 4498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Alvarez User:Dennisthe2 22:47, 13 December 2010 (UTC) delete Not only do we have a |conflict of interest, but I refer to - he hasn't made the pro leagues at this point Deletion of Christopher Alvarez WP:COI||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
5027 16689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danilo Kocevski User:Gidonb 09:25, 26 July 2017 (UTC) keep extensively published Macedonian author with news coverage, and also some scholarly publications. Meets . Should not have been listed for deletion Deletion of Danilo Kocevski WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5028 13151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J. Bryan Scott User:MER 05:38, 14 April 2007 (UTC) delete this patent |vanispamcruftisement Deletion of J. Bryan Scott WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
5029 7687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marquez North User:Cbl62 01:25, 2 July 2019 (UTC) delete The Wiki article states that he was the No. 1 prospect in North Carolina out of high school, but he never fulfilled expectations. No conference honors or even team honors. Does not pass or . Also not finding significant coverage in multiple reliable sources as needed to pass under Deletion of Marquez North WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:NCOLLATH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5030 16293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phone Car User:Coren 01:00, 19 July 2007 (UTC) delete completely |non-notable; and, as a self-proclaimed publicity stunt, speedy-worthy as spam. — Deletion of Phone Car WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5031 17276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Air Cadets 276 (Chelmsford) Sqn NONE NONE merge per ; individual unit does not meet , , & ; as a branch of a notable organization a redirect to the parent organization is the common result. {{quote|Aim for one good article, not multiple permanent stubs: Individual chapters, divisions, departments, and other sub-units of notable organizations are only rarely notable enough to warrant a separate article. Information on chapters and affiliates should normally be merged into the article about the parent organization. See Wikipedia:Merging Deletion of Air Cadets 276 (Chelmsford) Sqn WP:BRANCH||WP:ORG||WP:MILUNIT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5032 2464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr.Mohammad Reza Marvi Mohajer User:Edison 20:52, 6 June 2010 (UTC) delete I formatted the article a bit to make more easily readable. It is a nice resume, but so far does not quite appear to satisfy Deletion of Dr.Mohammad Reza Marvi Mohajer WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5033 4702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canon EOS R2 User:4meter4 00:42, 4 March 2020 (UTC) delete per nom. A clear case of Deletion of Canon EOS R2 WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
5034 8581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prashast Singh's Vishwavijay User:Ultraexactzz 17:14, 9 February 2016 (UTC) delete """on the merits. The numerous database links show that the film exists and was released - which is good as far as it goes. But there is only one news link about the film, and it has only a passing mention about this film being released (and, indeed, is mostly about other films). To be considered notable, the film must be noted - and, so far, it has not been. The |usual caveats apply, of course - if the film enters a wider release and sees some success, and (most importantly) that success is reported upon, then an article might be appropriate. And if that turns out to be the case, go over to and show them that coverage. They'll undelete before you can say """"Vishwavijay"""". Until then, however, it's too soon""" Deletion of Prashast Singh's Vishwavijay WP:USUAL||WP:REFUND Wikipedia:Usual caveats 41
5035 7337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irish slave trade User:EricSpokane 15:19, 20 July 2015 (UTC) delete """as theory. I recently read the Jordan and Walsh book which is actually a good account by two journalists of just how bad indentured servitude could be, but even the authors admit that they are deviating from the use of """"slavery"""" by mainstream historians. In the introduction, they note that """"It invites uproar to describe as slaves any of these hapless whites ..."""" (p. 14) but then goes on to note: """"Of course, black slavery had hideous aspects that whites did not experience ...."""" (p. 15) This attempt to redefine """"slavery"""" to include indentured servitude and to contrast this with a new """"black slavery"""" that had even more """"hideous aspects"""" is not a usage that mainstream historians have adopted""" Deletion of Irish slave trade WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
5036 16956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Turner (academic) User:The 00:42, 24 November 2013 (UTC) delete doesn't yet meet nor is there the necessary reliable source coverage to meet Deletion of Stephen Turner (academic) WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5037 3492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chloe Lynn User:Gene93k 00:00, 17 April 2015 (UTC) delete Unremarkable porn star. No claim of passing with no awards or RS-acknowledged contributions to porn. Fails without reliable source coverage. I couldn't even find coverage in the porn trade press Deletion of Chloe Lynn WP:PORNBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5038 11463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergio Jurado User:Crusio 10:01, 14 June 2011 (UTC) delete Self promotion (and badly written at that), doesn't meet or Deletion of Sergio Jurado WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5039 19838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harry F. Bauer User:TimothyBlue 05:48, 25 January 2021 (UTC) merge """very selectively) to USS Harry F. Bauer per above. Doesn't pass for a stand alone article, but the content will improve the target article, be less fragmented, and give the content more readership. Per , ''""""Editors may use their discretion to merge or group two or more related topics into a single article.""""'' // """ Deletion of Harry F. Bauer WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5040 5546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Aronsky User:David 19:11, 26 March 2015 (UTC) delete No evidence of passing nor any other notability criterion Deletion of Michael Aronsky WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5041 18965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BigBookshelf.com User:Kalathalan 20:12, 5 August 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of BigBookshelf.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
5042 2242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JAG (franchise) User:Stuartyeates 09:03, 14 November 2011 (UTC) delete as . Links between the series can be discussed in the series themselves Deletion of JAG (franchise) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5043 8293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henry West (director) User:Edwardx 21:52, 19 August 2021 (UTC) delete Not enough in the article or elsewhere online to pass or Deletion of Henry West (director) WP:GNG||WP:NDIRECTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5044 208 [[Judith Grassinger]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:M-J NONE keep weg damit. Hinweis an Judith: Löschung von Judith Grassinger Wikipedia:SD Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
5045 4373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aanchal Bhatia User:K 01:43, 27 June 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet / . Promotional Deletion of Aanchal Bhatia WP:ANYBIO||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5046 5243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grand ole party User:Erechtheus 15:18, 25 August 2007 (UTC) keep http://www.pluginmusic.com/news/archive.php?id=2012 This article appears to establish that they are about to embark on a national tour. I think that's good enough for notability under even if the standard is ''technically'' that they have already been on the tour. It makes no sense to delete now and then have notability cemented a few weeks from now when they make their first move from west coast to east coast on the tour Deletion of Grand ole party WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5047 12436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Windows User:Power 16:54, 19 August 2017 (UTC) delete and bordering on Deletion of Mark Windows WP:G10 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5048 18948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fever (Little Nell song) User:Esradekan 22:40, 14 March 2009 (UTC) delete as a non-plausible search term, fails notability per #Songs. Nothing to merge as there are no reliable, third-party, sources. There's already a mention of the Nell Campbell|Little Nell cover version in the Fever (1956 song)|parent article. Merging the content of this article and not the 100 or so others that have covered it would unduly favour this artist and violate Deletion of Fever (Little Nell song) WP:MUSIC||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
5049 18088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evan Batten User:Aleksa 00:02, 3 December 2013 (UTC) delete no specific claims of notability, pretty promotional; also these are no sources, so fails erifiability I couldn't find anything that includes Evan Batten as a main topic of a publication, that makes the article fail GNG too Deletion of Evan Batten WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5050 5742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Crabtree (2nd nomination) User:Hatchens 13:07, 17 April 2021 (UTC) comment """Let's ignore the -thing for a moment. Getting a coverage at Financial Times- """"2018 Business Book of the Year Award"""" is highly absurd because he had been a https://www.jamescrabtree.com/bio/ former bureau chief of the same newspaper. Ok let's ignore the FT Awards... except his book and interviews... there is no such information exist about him as a """"person"""". This clearly shows that the entity lacks independent significant coverage... It's not what he said or wrote. It's about who he is. If not AfD, the page should/must be draftified. This opinion should be considered as an extended part of my nomination statement""" Deletion of James Crabtree (2nd nomination) WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
5051 5346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sultan ul Faqr Publications User:JugniSQ 08:42, 10 August 2015 (UTC) keep The article should not be deleted. I have done some research on it and found that this publication does meet https://www.google.com/search?q=books%20on%20faqr&rct=j. It is not only about the publication, it is also about the work that the publication is doing. The books it publishes are popular and notable …People turn to Wikipedia to learn about the credentials of a particular topic and this is what Wikipedia users want. The primary purpose of an encyclopedia is to provide information and providing sources is secondary. To say that the article of a particular publication should be removed because it not notable is ticking off the fact that users are only going to learn about the publication from Wikipedia itself and this in itself a necessary criteria for the article to keep. The contributions made by this publication with reference to Islam/Sufism cannot be disregarded. It would not be wrong to call them unique or prolific in the field of Sufism. Give me one good reason for deleting this article based on publication and not any other article on publication from the List of Urdu language book publishing companies. Be fair and offer justice here on Wikipedia. All the web sources cited talk about Sultan ul Faqr Publications. Despite the references, the publication house is clearly known for its books all over the web as well as nationally in Pakistan. The article does not violate any Wikipedia rule. In fact, Wikipedia itself encourages publishing material relevant to the notability focusing on high-quality secondary or external sources which in this case have been cited as Britannica, Marymartin, ISSUE, etc Deletion of Sultan ul Faqr Publications WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5052 16358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tarik Ramić User:Dougal18 09:56, 27 July 2021 (UTC) comment Cup matches between two FPL clubs give a pass of Deletion of Tarik Ramić WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5053 9869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional mustelids User:AadaamS 18:46, 14 July 2015 (UTC) merge """this is not a suitable topic for a list according to . It should instead be made a section of the Mustelidae article like """"Mustelidae/In popular culture"""" or similar. Not one single source of this article verifies the notability of """"badgers & otters in fiction"""" ''as a group""" Deletion of List of fictional mustelids WP:SALAT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
5054 2834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Einstein–Cartan–Evans theory User:Arxiloxos 23:45, 10 May 2013 (UTC) keep per Mathsci, and because |notability is not temporary Deletion of Einstein–Cartan–Evans theory WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5055 12778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AJ Raval User:Superastig 10:00, 19 August 2021 (UTC) keep Sources in the article seem reliable. Sources 1, 2 and 5 talk about her. Sources 5 to 7 talks about her role in certain movies. I also found some reliable sources about her and her career: https://www.philstar.com/the-freeman/cebu-entertainment/2021/06/07/2103630/sexy-actress-aj-raval-really-wants-be-action-star-dad-jeric, https://www.philstar.com/entertainment/2021/08/01/2116619/aj-raval-confident-bare-her-talent, https://news.abs-cbn.com/entertainment/01/19/21/jeric-ravals-daughter-aj-joins-ang-probinsyano, https://entertainment.inquirer.net/418910/the-daughter-also-rises-aj-raval-forges-her-own-path, https://tribune.net.ph/index.php/2021/08/01/aj-raval-a-hot-prize-in-taya/, https://cnnphilippines.com/videos/2021/4/23/Diego-Loyzaga--AJ-Raval-team-up-for-movie--Death-of-a-Girlfriend-.html and https://www.pep.ph/pepalerts/pep-troika/159849/aj-raval-nerisa-a4118-20210801. That said, the article is good enough to pass Deletion of AJ Raval WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5056 11180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rita Vorperian User:DavidTTTaylor 13:57, 18 March 2013 (UTC) delete Per nom. Notability not established yet or Deletion of Rita Vorperian WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5057 6464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wikijumping User:KleenupKrew 10:32, 25 April 2008 (UTC) delete Patent Deletion of Wikijumping WP:NONSENSE Wikipedia:Patent nonsense 105
5058 5443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shailesh Gupta User:Pharaoh 15:22, 30 July 2016 (UTC) delete per Bearian, Fails Deletion of Shailesh Gupta WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5059 19470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Palak Sharma User:Tayi 08:20, 4 February 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Palak Sharma WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5060 10623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dracut Police Department User:Elgatodegato 19:06, 8 May 2015 (UTC) delete to town article; fails . No references on the article at all and I couldn't find any either to support keeping it Deletion of Dracut Police Department WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5061 6872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Last Human [[User talk:122.60.173.107|talk]]) 07:54, 16 November 2020 (UTC) delete Non-notable fiction book. The article is written like a book review and needs a . Special:Contributions/122.60.173.107|122.60.173.107 Deletion of The Last Human WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
5062 805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of British Jewish entertainers User:Colonel 08:43, 12 December 2010 (UTC) keep The nomination's assertion that British Jews are an arbitrary and non-notable selection of people is absurdly counterfactual. One can immediately find sources such as ''http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=SMOQkrUtqkwC The Jews of Britain'' which prove the falsity of this assertion. The nomination makes no policy-based argument and seems directly contrary to core policies such as and Deletion of List of British Jewish entertainers WP:NPOV||WP:IMPROVE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
5063 6602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Obama Eats Dogs User:Kelly 21:35, 23 April 2012 (UTC) comment the article has been Talk:Obama Eats Dogs (internet meme)#Undiscussed move|twice moved to Obama Eats Dogs (internet meme) by {{user|Youreallycan}}. Probably a vio of but not worth a separate discussion, as the content looks likely to be merged elsewhere anyhow Deletion of Obama Eats Dogs WP:PRECISION Wikipedia:Article titles 75
5064 154 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Banu Taviloğlu """Kullanıcı:hakanistakan""" 08:43, 4 Aralık 2015 (UTC) comment Kanal 7 bin en aşina sunucularından kaynak TV kanalının kendisidir bilinen bir ekran yüzü...{{imzasız|88.253.170.61}} nedeniyle yoruma çevirildi. '''H Banu Taviloğlu'nun silinmesi Vikipedi:OY Wikipedia:Administrators 89
5065 2434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesse Hirsh (2nd nomination) User:Ad 05:21, 21 January 2014 (UTC) keep A quick Google turned up several stories about, and interviews with this guy in publications in the first couple pages of hits. He seems to have sufficient coverage to meet Deletion of Jesse Hirsh (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5066 16635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ESTfield User:Piotrus 04:41, 4 March 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of ESTfield WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5067 17994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Z. Williamson (2nd nomination) User:Jmaynard 20:01, 21 July 2019 (UTC) comment By its own terms, not meeting is not sufficient grounds to claim non-notability Deletion of Michael Z. Williamson (2nd nomination) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5068 1758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohini Bhairav User:onel5969 21:00, 16 December 2020 (UTC) delete certainly doesn't pass Deletion of Mohini Bhairav WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5069 1053 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""C"""" is For (Please Insert Sophomoric Genitalia Reference Here)""" User:Tathar 08:35, 25 April 2011 (UTC) keep """I came to this AfD expecting something much different, but after seeing the article I decided to take a look for myself. A quick overview of the cited sources leads me to believe that the article meets """"significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject"""" as in and . The IGN article in particular needs to be cited more than it is based on the depth of the coverage. The Blabbermouth articles are also somewhat useful as source material. However, source #3 seems to lack any instance of """"Puscifer"""" and is an opinion article, which is generally not suitable as a source on WP. Also, I'm afraid that source #7 is a poor source as well. Not only is Twitter generally a poor source (with some exceptions), the link is prone to link rot as it doesn't link to the specific tweet's permalink. I also wonder why source #9 is used. As far as I can tell, it appears to be an ecommerce site selling the album, which I must recommend against using whenever possible. Is there perhaps a better source for that? Perhaps someone can clean up the page to meet album article guidelines""" """Deletion of """"C"""" is For (Please Insert Sophomoric Genitalia Reference Here)""" WP:NALBUM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5070 18974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunil Giri (2nd nomination) User:Ceosad 19:54, 12 April 2017 (UTC) delete per nom. Would probably have qualified for '''Speedy Deletion''' per Deletion of Sunil Giri (2nd nomination) WP:G4 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5071 15028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gilo Muirragui User:Stalwart111 11:12, 22 October 2014 (UTC) delete with no prejudice against recreation if historical, off-line coverage (sufficient to pass ) comes to light Deletion of Gilo Muirragui WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5072 16804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Berwick User:Bfigura 00:01, 20 November 2007 (UTC) delete As purely |original research. As the author of the page http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk%3AChristopher_Berwick&diff=171140225&oldid=171138140 admits on the article's talk page, there are no sources for the claims made (due to sources being destroyed/lost/etc). While the author might have good intentions here, Wikipedia isn't a place for original genealogical research Deletion of Christopher Berwick WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5073 5171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dance of Death (novel) User:Kafziel 00:15, 22 October 2010 (UTC) keep Does appear to meet based on the reviews added by Edgepedia. I could see it being merged along with all the others into a larger article about the Pendergast series. (I'd be happy to put that together, if that's the consensus.) But I do think it is fine as a separate article as well Deletion of Dance of Death (novel) WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
5074 18209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mina sundwall User:AKS 04:57, 19 October 2015 (UTC) delete Fails and also a case of Deletion of Mina sundwall WP:ENT||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
5075 18246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Broda Otto Barnes User:A 23:22, 2 May 2009 (UTC) keep as significant variety of sources presented above and incorporated into the article demonstrate that the article's subject is |verifiable; the shear number of sources and their nature as discussed above by DGG and Richard Arthur Norton further suggests that the subject is sufficiently |notable for inclusion in a paperless encyclopedia. Sincerely Deletion of Broda Otto Barnes WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5076 18002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Versobank SA User:Lemongirl942 06:09, 26 September 2016 (UTC) delete The references I see unfortunately have to be discounted per . Beyond that, I don't see any other references to satisfy Deletion of Versobank SA WP:ILLCON||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
5077 19746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lim Jae-Suk User:IronKnuckle 19:28, 29 March 2013 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Lim Jae-Suk WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
5078 13901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Space Opera in Latter-day Saints theology User:Cjewell 07:53, 18 April 2007 (UTC) delete This is obviously |something made up in school one day or something of the like... &mdash Deletion of Space Opera in Latter-day Saints theology WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
5079 17553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EffiaSoft User:Dialectric 02:03, 25 March 2015 (UTC) delete software company article of unclear notability, lacking significant coverage in multiple sources. Most refs are incidental mentions, or not , with the only exception being the siliconIndia link Deletion of EffiaSoft WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5080 237 [[Greymold]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:NoCultureIcons NONE delete Ja, haben leider die für österreichische Bands üblichen Probleme mit den #Bands|Relevanzkriterien Löschung von Greymold Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
5081 9731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 Thai FA Cup User:BDD 16:30, 9 May 2012 (UTC) keep """per Colapeninsula and Sir Sputnik. From , """"It must be possible to attribute all information in Wikipedia to reliable, published sources that are appropriate for the content in question. However, in practice it is only necessary to provide inline citations for quotations and for any information that has been challenged or that is likely to be challenged."""" Unless anyone thinks a particularly creative vandal has written a bizarro version of the Thai FA Cup, perhaps where his team wins, there's no great rush to find sources. And as Keresaspa pointed out, there is now a source cited which does verify all these results. (And I changed the template at the top from {{unreferenced}} to {{one source}} accordingly""" Deletion of 2012 Thai FA Cup WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5082 18709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Discrimination in education User:Nwlaw63 13:04, 20 July 2015 (UTC) delete Highly problematic article. Being used to push a POV, it's basically a ssay. There's also the issue of links to many non-existent articles. The article would have to be rewritten from scratch Deletion of Discrimination in education WP:E Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
5083 6572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SoMedia User:HighKing 20:47, 26 May 2021 (UTC) delete """The criteria for establishing notability for companies/organizations as per is for multiple sources (at least two) of deep or significant coverage with |in-depth information *on the company* and (this bit is important!) containing |""""Independent Content"""". """"Independent content"""", in order to count towards establishing notability, must include ''original and independent opinion, analysis, investigation, and fact checking that are clearly attributable to a source unaffiliated to the subject''. None of the references in the article meet the criteria and having searched I am unable to locate any references that meet the criteria. Topic fails """ Deletion of SoMedia WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5084 8156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karam 2017 ( film) User:GeoffreyT2000 17:18, 9 August 2017 (UTC) delete Fails . Coverage in ''independent'' reliable sources not found Deletion of Karam 2017 ( film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
5085 14645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Garett Whiteley [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 18:43, 17 October 2013 (UTC) delete One top tier fight (a loss) doesn't meet and he lacks the significant coverage required to meet . Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Garett Whiteley WP:NMMA||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5086 1534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Dunford User:Schwede66 05:15, 14 March 2017 (UTC) delete as I can't see how this meets . Whilst there are some foreign language source, and I don't speak those languages, they appear to be |routine coverages rather than in-depth reporting. Just wondering why we haven't heard from the article's creator, {{u|CeeGee}}, as yet? They are a senior editor, and have been active since the AfD was posted Deletion of Brian Dunford WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5087 18303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mad Hatter Studios User:TheGoofyGolfer 21:35, 11 February 2014 (UTC) comment AFAIK legal notices in Billboard Magazine wouldn't make it notable nor would it help to meet the . There needs to be more concrete references that shows they have done something significant and worthy of inclusion in Wikipedia Deletion of Mad Hatter Studios WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5088 2463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clifford Brown (scrutineer) User:Cbs527 21:33, 30 November 2016 (UTC) delete Seems to fail otability. Has not has received significant coverage in reliable sources. Subject is already mentioned in Eurovision Song Contest article Deletion of Clifford Brown (scrutineer) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5089 12897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wipeout teams User:Ningauble 01:27, 1 September 2008 (UTC) delete Fairly clear violation of Deletion of Wipeout teams WP:VGSCOPE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
5090 12143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orgrim Doomhammer User:Ridernyc 22:56, 1 November 2007 (UTC) delete violates lot and , while the game Warcraft is notable. The fiction and characters within it are not Deletion of Orgrim Doomhammer WP:P||WP:OR Wikipedia:Portal 85
5091 18999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aids on a Plane User:The 22:24, 19 June 2007 (UTC) delete I have to agree smells like a hoax, and if not fails Deletion of Aids on a Plane WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5092 21637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wilayat Nineveh (ISIL) [[User talk:TheRedPenOfDoom|TRPoD aka The Red Pen of Doom]] 01:32, 12 December 2014 (UTC) delete a blog post as an effectively self published book. fails no significant third party coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Wilayat Nineveh (ISIL) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5093 17801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kristy Holtfreter User:XOR 23:06, 31 October 2020 (UTC) keep if the identity of the requester can be verified, otherwise '''snow keep'''. With lots of papers with 100+ citations, small author list, first author, etc; the case for C1 is solid. That's supported by the chief-editorship of a new-ish journal. There is no question that this would be a keep in the absence of a request from the subject. As Deletion of Kristy Holtfreter WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5094 20388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Hyatt User:HistoricalAccountings 12:49, 13 January 2021 (UTC) keep also as per . Added a Google Scholar Profile to his page if that helps. More links will need to be added. Will have a look Deletion of Robert Hyatt WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5095 3444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Claudia Alvarez (politician) User:Kudpung 01:46, 21 September 2019 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Claudia Alvarez (politician) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
5096 20136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Railpage Australia (9th nomination) User:Mackensen 12:48, 20 July 2016 (UTC) comment TL;DR version of nomination: this is, at most, the third actual nomination and the first in nine years. The site fails Deletion of Railpage Australia (9th nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
5097 1126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Armenia–France relations User:Meowy 16:29, 18 February 2012 (UTC) keep """the article as it is now is bit of a disaster area, but the subject itself is entirely valid and notable. The subject is NOT restricted to international relations between two states, as a perusal of the various other Wikipedia """"county xxxx-country yyyy relations"""" articles will show. Ash's argument for deletion is not valid. If it is admitted that the subject IS notable enough to have a Wikipedia article then the current content of the article is unimportant as far as deletion arguments go. See: otability#Notability_guidelines_do_not_limit_content_within_an_article """"Notability is a property of a subject and not of a Wikipedia article. If the subject has not been covered outside of Wikipedia, no amount of improvements to the Wikipedia content will suddenly make the subject notable. Conversely, if the source material exists, even very poor writing and referencing within a Wikipedia article will not decrease the subject's notability""" Deletion of Armenia–France relations WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5098 3810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shag Harbour UFO incident User:Erebus 16:15, 6 March 2014 (UTC) keep Although the article's sourcing may need a little work in it's current state, more sources can be found. The article has been covered in The Chronicle Herald in http://www3.ns.sympatico.ca/dledger/the%20herald%20headline682.gif 1967 and more recently http://thechronicleherald.ca/novascotia/1146689-witness-shares-memories-as-shag-harbour-ufo-festival-set-to-begin in 2013 A quick google search comes up with other sources: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/n-s-town-marks-45-years-since-possible-ufo-sighting-1.1168468 1, http://www.huffingtonpost.com/alexandra-holzer/ufo-dances-with-airplane-_b_1213784.html 2 http://metronews.ca/news/166662/diver-finds-depressions-on-seabed-at-alleged-nova-scotia-ufo-site/ 3. The Canadian government/millitary has some reports available in their archives, there is an annual http://www.thecoastguard.ca/Living/2013-08-06/article-3340089/UFO-incident-festival-set-for-Shag-Harbour/1 festival celebrating the incident and it has been the subject of a documentary and multiple books. Admittedly, all together it isn't ''that'' much, but considering it happened in 1967 I feel it's enough coverage to make it pass Deletion of Shag Harbour UFO incident WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5099 13080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Students for Impeachment [[User Talk:JzG|Just zis Guy you know?]] 13:07, 6 June 2006 (UTC) delete a student group which wants to expand: fine and dandy, but the way to achieve that. Sole reference is their blog. Zero evidence of significance Deletion of Students for Impeachment WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5100 19189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Bable's List of wrestlers User:Fuhghettaboutit 22:36, 22 July 2006 (UTC) delete """both. Not being a wrestling fan, I wondered just who exactly Jeff Bable was. Having found no google results, I can only surmise it is the name of the articles' author. The criterion for inclusion, then, appears to be """"whim of the author,"""" and I can think of no basis for a list more |indiscriminate than that""" Deletion of Jeff Bable's List of wrestlers WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5101 9912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islamic Research Foundation (2nd nomination) User:Dougweller 21:04, 7 September 2014 (UTC) comment Please read then and make sure the article meets those requirements Deletion of Islamic Research Foundation (2nd nomination) WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5102 3372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of votes for Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act User:Krimpet 00:42, 22 April 2007 (UTC) delete Congress's website already lists every vote by every Congressman on their website (http://clerk.house.gov/evs/2003/roll242.xml here's the House's for this bill). |Wikipedia is not the place for this information Deletion of List of votes for Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5103 13647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SydLexia.com User:HackJandy 07:29, 28 November 2005 (UTC) delete nothing about this would hold for the criteria in my opinion Deletion of SydLexia.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
5104 11816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Connan (2nd nomination) User:Erik 17:40, 20 August 2015 (UTC) comment """Considering the person's main occupation as singer, the notability guideline can also be applied here, and Connan does not appear to meet any of this criteria. In addition, says, """"Articles may still not be created for such people if they fall under exclusionary criteria,"""" referencing . From this, #4 (self-promotion) can apply, especially considering that both editors !voting to keep have only edited articles related to Connan and nowhere else""" Deletion of Tom Connan (2nd nomination) WP:MUSICBIO||WP:BASIC||WP:NOT||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5105 14585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Liddicoat User:GiantSnowman 18:43, 8 February 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Sean Liddicoat WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5106 11327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leigh Bennie User:onel5969 15:30, 7 September 2015 (UTC) delete per nom and FoCuS. Fails Deletion of Leigh Bennie WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5107 19330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Robertson (Canadian politician) User:Winhunter 02:47, 25 August 2006 (UTC) delete for failing for being merely an candidate as the highest archevement. If new (previously unknown) information about this person surfaces then I will be happy to reconsider Deletion of David Robertson (Canadian politician) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5108 2874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heritage Guitars User:Nick 17:22, 7 January 2007 (UTC) comment """I think you're setting the bar pretty high for notability. otability states that """"a topic is notable if it has been the subject of multiple, non-trivial, reliable published works, whose sources are independent of the subject itself."""" The two books now cited provide such coverage of the company. That the books are not ''entirely'' dedicated to covering the company does not make the coverage trivial. The coverage is more than a mention--the Bacon book provides several historical details about the company's founding, while the Freeth & Alexander book dedicates a two-page spread to the company. I don't see how it is a mark against notability that the company is mentioned in books about guitars. What better place to find information about a guitar-making company than in a book about guitars? I am certain that coverage of the company can be found in well-established music or guitar magazines, but do not have access to such. I have made a request of WikiProject Guitarists to find such coverage. In the meantime, I think that the two book sources provide sufficient reason to keep the article""" Deletion of Heritage Guitars WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5109 8192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philosophy of conspiracy theories User:LuckyLouie 22:25, 31 October 2019 (UTC) delete Our conspiracy theory article contains a plethora of philosophical opinions reflecting mainstream discourse on the subject. This article focuses primary weight on opinions that suggest some (unspecified) conspiracy theories shouldn't be dismissed because some are likely true. At best, it's a , and at worst, a Deletion of Philosophy of conspiracy theories WP:POVFORK||WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
5110 7791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Time-challenged User:Ansh666 18:42, 7 August 2013 (UTC) merge to Time management - at current, this article is -filled and so nonsensical I can't figure out what it's actually about; my preferred redirect target is what I'd think of. Other possible redirect and merge targets mentioned above Deletion of Time-challenged WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5111 504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jungjangbi Plaza User:MER 08:05, 30 November 2006 (UTC) delete no assertion of meeting Deletion of Jungjangbi Plaza WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5112 12147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alfa Sa'adu User:Erc 15:51, 21 April 2020 (UTC) delete as coverage is outine, and therefore subject of the article is not notable and does not have independent sources Deletion of Alfa Sa'adu WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
5113 12443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stanley Page User:HawkAussie 03:43, 9 December 2019 (UTC) delete I have looked through the Gale Primary Sources website and put his name between 1933-1938 to see if I get any results. The result was 30 stories about a Stanley Page. How many of those were about the football player, Stanley Page? Zero as there are mentions of an Stanley Page playing bowls in Dover but not football as most of the other references had Stanley and Page seperate. So the player fails Deletion of Stanley Page WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5114 14415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiffany Patterson (choreographer) User:Sionk 16:49, 13 October 2013 (UTC) delete for the reasons outlined by the nominator. There is very little at all about her online. The Washington Post quote is a brief eating advice tip by Patterson, so is not substantially about her and not counting towards her |notability. Appearing near a famous person doesn't count towards notability either Deletion of Tiffany Patterson (choreographer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5115 4620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bunny nick User:Quarl NONE delete sloppy |hoax. &mdash Deletion of Bunny nick WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
5116 5846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Metal Reviews User:Wafulz 16:49, 10 September 2006 (UTC) delete The website does not meet criteria set out in - the article itself mentions that the site is small, and it is written from a personal perspective. Anyway, http://www.alexa.com/search?q=www.metalreviews.com%2F Alexa ranking of about 750k, no awards, no news mentions, http://www.google.ca/search?q=link:http://www.metalreviews.com/&hl=en&lr=&safe=off&start=30&sa=N 33 links from other sites (mostly blogs and the like Deletion of Metal Reviews WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
5117 13697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BesMella User:Royboycrashfan 07:31, 7 March 2006 (UTC) delete per , , and Deletion of BesMella WP:NEO||WP:CRUFT||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
5118 2639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Streetz User:On 19:20, 29 March 2008 (UTC) delete Fails criteria Deletion of Streetz WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5119 310 [[Lingener Bahnhof]] (bleibt) Benutzer:DscheJ-Ouh NONE keep Auf Google Earth erkenne ich mindestens ''fünf'' Gleise, daher definitiv ''Bahnhof''. Der Text sollte daraufhin korrigiert werden, dass es sich hierbei um nur ein ''Bahnsteiggleis'' handelt. Zumal aber der Artikel seit LA-Stellung erweitert wurde, bin auch ich für , allerdings unter dem den |Namenskonventionen entsprechenden (oben vorgeschlagenen) Lemma Löschung von Lingener Bahnhof Wikipedia:Namenskonventionen Wikipedia:Article titles 75
5120 17527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Changement Intégrité pour notre Québec User:Bearcat 16:33, 11 July 2018 (UTC) keep Referencing improvement is certainly still needed here, but there are already enough |reliable sources present to cover off the basic notability question. The notability test for a political party is not having actually won seats in a legislature, but is passed by any party — major or minor doesn't matter — that is ''registered'' with the appropriate electoral registrar and referenceable to ''something'' other than ''purely'' |primary sources Deletion of Changement Intégrité pour notre Québec WP:RS||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5121 17378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohamad Barakat (2nd nomination) User:Iridescent 14:55, 4 September 2019 (UTC) delete obviously, and a trout to the nominator for restoring a blatantly policy-violating article—regardless of whether it's courtesy-blanked or not—purely for the sake of a pointless piece of process-for-the-sake-of-process. Per https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk%3AIridescent&type=revision&diff=913803907&oldid=913803259 my previous comment {{tq|every single version is either blatant advertising, a laundry-list of insults and violations, or a meaningless microstub … Nobody has a problem with someone writing a {{em|compliant}} biography of this guy, but none of the people arguing over this appear to have the slightest interest in doing so.}}; if someone {{em|does}} want to write a BLP-compliant biography I have no issue with that being kept, but it's abundantly clear that neither of the two people who say they think the initial deletion was inappropriate have any intention of doing so. ‑ Deletion of Mohamad Barakat (2nd nomination) WP:BLPCRIME Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
5122 1924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/12 Barz of Christmas User:Sparklism 13:42, 8 November 2012 (UTC) delete Zero Gnews hits, and most other hits just point to promotion of this non-notable event. Fails Deletion of 12 Barz of Christmas WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5123 15884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edilberto de Oliveira [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 16:13, 10 March 2014 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet or .Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Edilberto de Oliveira WP:GNG||WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
5124 10769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/No User:Bearian 19:36, 5 November 2007 (UTC) keep per and almost everyone above Deletion of No WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5125 956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mezzo Secolo Di Ritornelli User:S 21:26, 23 June 2020 (UTC) delete per nominator. Doesn't appear to meet any of the notability criteria in Deletion of Mezzo Secolo Di Ritornelli WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
5126 12733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Wolven User:Marc 06:12, 30 September 2009 (UTC) delete I first went though all of the references included with the article. None were |reliable-sources and all were trivial coverage (one short paragraph or less) of his stories. There was zero coverage of the subject (Nick Wolven). I then checked Cengage, Google Scholar, Books, and News and came up with zero hits across the board. He does not pass anything in either or and I don't see a case for . One good feature is that it's a nicely done article in terms of references Deletion of Nick Wolven WP:RS||WP:N||WP:PEOPLE||WP:IGNORE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5127 8086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phan Văn Long User:SuperJew 12:12, 14 September 2014 (UTC) delete """hasn't played in pro league, no significant coverage, failing and . Morever, the """"article"""" is a stub of one single sentence, and the infobox doesn't even have caps and goals in the SHB Da Nang F.C.|non-pro team he did play in or his national (u20) caps and goals""" Deletion of Phan Văn Long WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5128 19264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liam Gallagher's debut studio album User:Sergecross73 12:31, 21 September 2016 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Liam Gallagher's debut studio album WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
5129 8237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jannike Kruse Jåtog User:MichaelQSchmidt 08:45, 6 June 2012 (UTC) keep per meeting ,http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1097997/filmotype and apparently .https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Jannike+Kruse+J%C3%A5tog%22&tbm=nws&tbs=ar:1 Enlist assistance from Norse-reading Wikipedians in translating sources and improving the article, as notable to Norway is perfectly fine for en.Wikipedia Deletion of Jannike Kruse Jåtog WP:ENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5130 4637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/E-Hobby User:Nosebagbear 21:04, 9 October 2018 (UTC) delete couldn't find any refs that satisfied both Sig Cov, independent and so notability demonstrated. The three lines there are some blend of and advertorial Deletion of E-Hobby WP:ROUTINE||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5131 1930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Blue Wing Airlines Antonov An-28 crash User:Shadowjams 09:01, 25 August 2010 (UTC) delete I don't see sufficient notability outside of routine news reports. Tragedy, but not notable in the sense Deletion of 2010 Blue Wing Airlines Antonov An-28 crash WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5132 11939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nanci Filipelli User:Ubelowme 15:55, 13 July 2012 (UTC) delete I could not find any |reliable sources, as per the nominator's efforts, to confirm any of the assertions that would confirm |notability for the subject; no arm's-length third-party sources of expert opinion that document her expertise as compared to other models Deletion of Nanci Filipelli WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5133 18979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Brother Cicero User:MichaelQSchmidt 21:03, 19 August 2008 (UTC) comment Toward that end, I have just cleaned up the My Brother Cicero|article per Wikipedia:WikiProject Films/Style guidelines and moved the above links over to its External Links section. Will see about further citing to affirm Deletion of My Brother Cicero WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5134 17375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craftsuprint User:TBrandley 06:04, 17 November 2012 (UTC) delete fails ; non-notable topic Deletion of Craftsuprint WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5135 21193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exocet (band) User:Bmicomp 20:07, 15 September 2005 (UTC) delete Band articles don't have to ''assert'' any of the guidelines... but this band is not notable enough to merit inclusion anyway Deletion of Exocet (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5136 21830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ana Lobo User:Frankie 20:42, 11 July 2011 (UTC) comment """Funny, I had just finished searching for rticles for deletion/Maru Guerrero|a similar AfD when I came across this one. Here are some links that I could find about Ana Lobo, although I'm not sure if they could be used as reliable sources for verifiability http://shinchanland.com.ar/doblaje http://www.animexis.com/inuyasha/htm/doblaje.php. There is also this, http://perso.wanadoo.es/doblajesp2/doblaje.html, which is a very comprehensive website with information on voice actors for a large number of shows, but it is maintained by a single person. I can't put a link to the search results because freefind is blacklisted, but you can get them by searching for """"Ana Lobo"""" on the left frame. Regarding notability, it is rare for voice actors in Mexico to receive any mainstream coverage, even for those actors that are fairly known by the general public, so my opinion is that in these cases it is best to go for #1. With Maru Guerrero I think that the roles she has played are important enough so to satisfy the criteria, but in this case I'm not familiar with the programs, so I can't say how significant the characters are""" Deletion of Ana Lobo WP:A||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Attribution 108
5137 8937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeadZones.com User:Muhandes 07:44, 17 May 2011 (UTC) delete No significant coverage as required by Deletion of DeadZones.com WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5138 2116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russia investigation origins conspiracy theory User:Jdcomix 22:18, 21 October 2019 (UTC) comment I just noticed that the article was renamed to Russia investigation origins counter-narrative. However, one of the new sources for the new name is completely unrelated to the article subject, although the CNN video is pretty solid. If the issues that I mentioned above are addressed and there are more sources that are as solid as this one, yet the article is still deleted, I'm completely in favor of |blowing it up and starting from scratch to make the article more concise Deletion of Russia investigation origins conspiracy theory WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
5139 21235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coincidences and synchronicities related to September 11, 2001 attacks User:Ikkyu2 17:17, 16 February 2006 (UTC) delete per author's explanation above. You violated Deletion of Coincidences and synchronicities related to September 11, 2001 attacks WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5140 16186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pill Hill, California User:Dhartung 21:01, 9 November 2007 (UTC) delete I'm all for keeping |verifiable settlements of any size, but this one fails the most basic of basic tests Deletion of Pill Hill, California WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5141 15221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arian Romal User:PureRED 18:58, 19 May 2015 (UTC) delete Fails . No significant results found after a fairly exhaustive search engine hunt Deletion of Arian Romal WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5142 18420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gravity Separator User:Mayalld 22:40, 5 January 2009 (UTC) delete non-notable invention that has never gone into comercial production. A patent doesn't confer notability on a product that |may never be produced Deletion of Gravity Separator WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5143 18383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Serato User:Isingness 22:18, 14 November 2018 (UTC) keep In-depth coverage in DJ Magazine, New Zealand Herald, Billboard, and others; discussed in several trade published books; more than passes Deletion of Serato WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5144 14358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Desire Climax User:Dinoguy1000 18:04, 3 April 2009 (UTC) comment Based on that, I |went ahead and moved the article to Yokujō Climax - if that was inappropriate in light of its being at AFD at the moment (even though it's looking now like it'll be kept), feel free to rv me Deletion of Desire Climax WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
5145 15336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamey Rodemeyer [[User: Phoenix B 1of3|Phoenix B 1of3]] [[User talk: Phoenix B 1of3|(talk)]] 02:59, 18 October 2011 (UTC) keep The article fully meets , This case has also generated very much media attention, the victim is now well know and talked about in the media and general public, supplying many opportunities for additional citations and expansion Deletion of Jamey Rodemeyer WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5146 18462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Total Body Lift [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 17:40, 10 February 2009 (UTC) delete not quite sure if the user (my guess is that the creator is an M.D.) is blatantly trying to promote this technique, is engaging in |original research, or is just rolling a bunch of other |stuff into a |personal essay. In either case, this is clearly against |what Wikipedia is not Deletion of Total Body Lift WP:OR||WP:SYNTH||WP:ESSAY||WP:NOT Wikipedia:No original research 65
5147 1169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Oaks Mall, Florida User:TenPoundHammer 17:20, 18 June 2007 (UTC) keep seems notable enough at nearly 900,000 square feet, also has several |reliable sources. I'll be |bold and move this to The Oaks Mall (Florida), though. Move made to The Oaks Mall (Florida Deletion of The Oaks Mall, Florida WP:RS||WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5148 490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Legend of Zelda (Wii) (2nd nomination) User:Isotope23 17:04, 5 June 2006 (UTC) delete per nomination and a crystal ball clause. Existence is not verifiable. Also, it appears from the nom that a similar article was deleted last year? If this is the case and this is close enough to be a recreation, someone should consider a speedy delete under #G4 Deletion of The Legend of Zelda (Wii) (2nd nomination) WP:NOT||WP:CSD Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5149 18815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Binaca Geetmala records User:Ajf773 03:45, 4 January 2018 (UTC) delete per as two out of three sources are links to blogs/self published sources. Also and Deletion of List of Binaca Geetmala records WP:NOR||WP:NOTSTATS||WP:NOTINDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:No original research 65
5150 11605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Jeremy Lespi User:Pmedema 17:00, 3 January 2008 (UTC) delete It appears that this is an admiration article. Possible condolences to Mazielouisemontgomery because Robert Jeremy Lespi died December 28, 2007 after a lingering fight with multiple health problems. Unfortunately, none of the poems appear to have been published and does not meet . His funeral is today at Bolton Letlow Chapel with burial to follow in Columbiana City Cemetery http://obits.al.com/birmingham/DeathNotices.asp?Page=Notice&PersonID=100508011 Deletion of Robert Jeremy Lespi WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5151 5746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rod Maxson User:Imzadi1979 03:07, 8 February 2018 (UTC) delete per nom. The article doesn't meet either Deletion of Rod Maxson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5152 10441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lake Bodom (2016 film) User:Blythwood 02:47, 21 September 2016 (UTC) delete films self-released on YouTube don't satisfy unless they've been independently profiled by reliable sources. This article is at best Deletion of Lake Bodom (2016 film) WP:MOVIE||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
5153 16830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katy Perry (album) User:Gongshow 16:32, 9 August 2010 (UTC) comment There is some additional info on the project in a http://www.billboard.com/bbcom/feature/katy-perry-single-lady-1003940623.story#/bbcom/feature/katy-perry-single-lady-1003940623.story ''Billboard'' article. Neither that nor the ''Blender'' write-up mention the album would have been named ''Katy Perry'', so if this page is kept, the article title should be changed unless another |reliable source is presented. I'm skeptical of the SuperiorPics link meeting , and even it refers to the album as ''(A) Katy Perry Deletion of Katy Perry (album) WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5154 1574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunshine tax User:SudoGhost 18:15, 13 April 2011 (UTC) delete Although I won't argue that it isn't a real thing, it doesn't seem to be |notable Deletion of Sunshine tax WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5155 8332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muslim Educational Trust (2nd nomination) User:Smmurphy 16:12, 15 June 2017 (UTC) keep """MET is central in debates in England over education of young Muslims, especially through the activity of Hewitt and Sarwar and particularly in the 1970s-1990s. I've added some material about this. The Trust is almost always discussed in news articles as the organization which an individual represents, with the individual receiving more in depth discussion, but the consistency and import of the organization's role leads me to believe they are notable. In particular, notes that coverage is significant if it """"addresses the topic directly and in detail, so that no original research is needed to extract the content."""" This is clearly the case, even if no indepth article about the organization is cited""" Deletion of Muslim Educational Trust (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5156 20130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IMPACT-Charlottesville User:C 03:45, 1 March 2008 (UTC) delete No assertion of |notability made in the article—at least, nothing that would mean any notability beyond the local level Deletion of IMPACT-Charlottesville WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5157 1733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ger Hanley (footballer) User:GiantSnowman 14:22, 29 November 2010 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Ger Hanley (footballer) WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5158 7222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sex Bunny User:Coredesat 18:01, 1 August 2006 (UTC) delete per #A7|CSD-A7 and . I wouldn't mind redirecting, though, if this is a plausible search term. I'm not really sure it is Deletion of Sex Bunny WP:CSD||WP:FICT Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5159 22 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Dora Özsoy """Kullanıcı:victor trevorvictor trevor""" 19.56, 28 Mayıs 2021 (UTC) keep """Pek çok bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynak bulunuyor: https://www.haberler.com/stratera-games-cikartacagi-oyunlari-duyurdu-13957478-haberi/ """"Stratera Games"""" adlı oluşumu kurmuş, https://www.haber.com/khontkarin-lol-ve-valorant-dandik-paylasimina-okkali-cevap-540194/ """"Tartışma"""" başlığına eklenecek bir kaynak, https://www.webtekno.com/khontkar-lol-valorant-espor-sunucusu-cevap-h107900.html bir önceki kaynağa kıyasla daha derinlemesine işlenmiş bir kaynak, https://www.fanatik.com.tr/dora-ozsoy-facebook-gaminge-veda-etti-2162102 """"Facebook Gaming""""ten ayrılması haber olarak yapılmış, https://www.sozcu.com.tr/hayatim/kultur-sanat-haberleri/iyi-oyunun-fragmani-yayinlandi/ """"İyi Oyun"""" filminin oyuncu kadrosunda yer almış, https://www.haberler.com/espor-sunucusu-dora-ozsoy-geriye-donuk-vergi-13939408-haberi/ vergi konusunda sorun yaşamış, https://www.hurriyet.com.tr/kelebek/hurriyet-pazar/madde-madde-20-yas-alti-gencleri-anlama-kilavuzu-hazir-eve-kapanmislarken-onlari-biraz-daha-yakindan-tanimak-ister-misiniz-41492254 14-16 yaş aralığının izlediği kişiler arasında gösterilmiş, https://www.sporx.com/bau-esportsun-da-yer-aldigi-uluslararasi-universite-kupasi-basliyor-SXHBQ792428SXQ bir turnuva sunmuş. VP:D|Doğrulanabilirlik açısından sorun yok. #Kişiler için kayda değerlik kriterleri|Kriterlerimizin 1, 2 ve 4. maddelerini karşılıyor""" Dora Özsoy'un silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
5160 18211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Juggernaut Bitch (again) User:Pathoschild 05:32, 28 April 2006 (UTC) delete being a somewhat popular amateur animation does not make it |notable. The fact that it is on Google Video is meaningless, since they accept nearly anything that is legal and appropriate; see the https://upload.video.google.com/?hl=en Google Video upload page. // |admin Deletion of The Juggernaut Bitch (again) WP:N||WP:ADMIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
5161 11439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Badboy Lifestyle 2 User:Walton 17:32, 4 February 2007 (UTC) delete """per . Article seems to be just a list of someone's ideas about seduction. (Were it not for the sources, I would have had difficulty believing that this was even a real industry. """"Seduction guru""" Deletion of Badboy Lifestyle 2 WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5162 1223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in the West Midlands county User:Imzadi1979 00:13, 25 February 2013 (UTC) delete fails and . Lists like these should be transwikied to Wikivoyage rather than left on Wikipedia Deletion of List of bus routes in the West Midlands county WP:GNG||WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5163 12033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WoWWiki (third nomination) User:NeoChaosX 19:15, 27 October 2006 (UTC) delete This site does not meet the guidelines of notability for |web content. Like a Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FFXIclopedia (third nomination)|similar article on an MMORPG wiki, this site deserves to be an external link on the article of the game it's about, at best Deletion of WoWWiki (third nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
5164 9089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Roman cognomina user:Andrew 16:00, 3 September 2018 (UTC) keep Easily passes as there are extensive scholarly studies and analyses such as ''A Study of the Cognomina of Soldiers in the Roman Legions'' or ''A classification of the cognomina appearing in the Corpus inscriptionum latinarum''. Some of these are still well-known such as ''Caesar'' or ''Cicero'' and, while there's a long tail of lesser-known names, our policies , and indicate that we should keep this Deletion of List of Roman cognomina WP:LISTN||WP:ATD||WP:NOTPAPER||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5165 404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of jägerbomb variations User:Bigger 22:59, 16 September 2010 (UTC) delete I'm tempted to make up a new version and call it the Bigger Bomb, for my 3 milliseconds of fame. Any verifiable variations can be added to the jagerbomb article, at the moment this is just a load of , some of which repeats. Oh, and no hint of otability Deletion of List of jägerbomb variations WP:OR||WP:N Wikipedia:No original research 65
5166 4412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minami Minegishi User:Michitaro 23:23, 10 November 2012 (UTC) keep I have expanded the article by adding three more Japanese references from different sources, all national sports newspapers: Sponichi, Nikkan Sports, and Sports Hochi. All have her name in the article title and all are focused on her various activities. With the other English references I added, I believe this is sufficient to pass Deletion of Minami Minegishi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5167 10405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ALD518 User:Fvasconcellos 14:56, 21 November 2009 (UTC) comment I will not comment on the merits of keeping the article as I have a strongly inclusionist viewpoint when it comes to the notability of drugs and chemical compounds, but I will offer some suggestions. Belinostat is a good example of WhatamIdoing's suggestion in practice: information is presented as a subsection in the article on the manufacturer. When I come across a drug that seems to have notability potential (in the real world, not in the WP sense) and meets , I keep an outline of the article Deletion of ALD518 WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5168 21933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orange Avenue (band) User:Shawnpoo 16:19, 8 March 2009 (UTC) delete per , I live relatively close to Orlando FL (supposedly where they are) and have never heard a word about them let alone know them Deletion of Orange Avenue (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
5169 20377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark McGowan (performance artist) (2nd nomination) User:Possibly 10:22, 8 July 2021 (UTC) keep This is a really bad nomination. There are multiple good in-depth sources ((BBC, Guardian etc) in the article that indicate that the nom clearly did not do Deletion of Mark McGowan (performance artist) (2nd nomination) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
5170 1510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ann Cookson User:P199 17:15, 28 September 2011 (UTC) delete fails . Vanity article Deletion of Ann Cookson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5171 7156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary Michael Green User:Dekisugi 09:18, 20 December 2007 (UTC) delete Although it is the first edit of the nominator, but I agree with him/her. Unless there is an |independent third-party reliable sources given (per ), I opt to delete this article Deletion of Gary Michael Green WP:RS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5172 6931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lesser or Greater Extinctions User:NickCT 13:25, 18 April 2014 (UTC) delete Looks like a pretty clear example of |promotion to me Deletion of Lesser or Greater Extinctions WP:NOTPROMOTION Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5173 2174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Team Cherry (developer) User:Zxcvbnm 10:43, 4 March 2020 (UTC) delete Non-notable except in relation to Hollow Knight. Possibly , but either way this should not be an article yet per Deletion of Team Cherry (developer) WP:TOOSOON||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Too soon 40
5174 1918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Land of Hero User:Czar 03:04, 5 November 2012 (UTC) delete Zilch towards |GNG. Game's kind of new, so watch this http://www.metacritic.com/game/ios/land-of-hero/critic-reviews Metacritic page for potential reviews. I'll obviously reconsider if there are reliable non-English sources. I couldn't find any Deletion of Land of Hero WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5175 1232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sweere-arse (2nd nomination) User:Jbhunley 20:18, 7 September 2015 (UTC) delete per . No evidence this term was widely used or has any particular significance. Fails Deletion of Sweere-arse (2nd nomination) WP:NOTDICTIONARY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5176 17325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eurofins Scientific User:Uzma 12:37, 25 October 2012 (UTC) comment I'm finding 6,000+ news articles with 1,500 having Eurofins Scientific in the title alone. However, as I scroll through them, I'm seeing press release after press release. There also are many that have Eurofins Scientific among a string of names and many that merely report on the stock status. I'm not going to look through them all. Between that much press coverage, 10K employees, $1B revenues, there probably is enough independent reliable source information for a stand alone article. I think it would be hard to wade through all the non independent/non reliable sources to find sources to properly cite the article and achieve a thorough and representative survey of the relevant literature Deletion of Eurofins Scientific WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5177 3644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Color or Country (second nomination) User:Mangojuice 14:41, 8 April 2006 (UTC) delete """I actually think the article (well, the top section, anyway) is adequately sourced. The last paragraph is false, by the way: this game was not introduced for the ''first time'' at Mathcamp 2002, I have firsthand knowledge.. and the business about """"Functor or category"""" is a mathcamp in-joke. This game is simply not notable enough... it's basically a case of """ Deletion of Color or Country (second nomination) WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
5178 9658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heather Tallchief User:JBsupreme 07:02, 4 March 2010 (UTC) delete I have no idea what Robert K is talking about (see above) but this article is a at best, BLPzeroE at worst Deletion of Heather Tallchief WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
5179 10416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kristijan Jajalo User:GiantSnowman 14:54, 13 June 2013 (UTC) delete fails (as has not received significant coverage) and also fails (as he has not actually ''played'' in a |fully-professional league Deletion of Kristijan Jajalo WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5180 12943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheenlac Paints User:Hagennos 05:33, 9 February 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Sheenlac Paints WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
5181 300 [[:Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Burgen und Schlösser im Landkreis Neustadt an der Waldnaab]] (erl.) NONE 13:25, 3. Apr. 2020 (CEST) delete Themenring, da unbekannte Grundgesamtheit. Weitere Argumente analog zu dieser /5. April 2016|Rax'schen Löschbegründung Löschung von :Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Burgen und Schlösser im Landkreis Neustadt an der Waldnaab Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
5182 21032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WellChild User:Olly150 12:14, 17 February 2016 (UTC) keep The charity and it's award ceremony has received national press coverage in a range of newspapers and television outlets, has royal patronage, and is known and operates nationally. Therefore, complies with . I would disagree that the article is clearly promotional - though admittedly could probably do with a clean up and better sources, at most Deletion of WellChild WP:NONPROFIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5183 17506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gracie Harrison User:Brewcrewer 00:42, 22 February 2008 (UTC) delete per nom, no major roles, fails Deletion of Gracie Harrison WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5184 8448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Treworgey tree fayre User:Edison 19:50, 17 October 2010 (UTC) delete Fails , , Deletion of Treworgey tree fayre WP:N||WP:ORG||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5185 16135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Goldman User:E 23:17, 20 January 2018 (UTC) delete as mere PROMO lacking Deletion of Jordan Goldman WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
5186 14698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Political Crossdressing User:IslaySolomon 07:44, 4 November 2006 (UTC) delete Death by abbreviations: for a that was probably per http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=%22Political+Crossdressing%22&hl=en&lr=&start=30&sa=N GHITS Deletion of Political Crossdressing WP:V||WP:DICDEF||WP:NOTE||WP:NEO||WP:NFT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5187 353 [[Die Kleptomanin]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Presse03 12:51, 4. Sep. 2008 (CEST) delete Und wenn es hundert mal ein gültiger Stub ist, die sind lt. unerwünscht: ''Bei der Einzeldarstellung literarischer Werke sind Kurzartikel („Stubs“) ausdrücklich nicht erwünscht, da eine Kurzdarstellung im Artikel zum Autor erfolgen kann.'' Wenn nach 7 Tagen die Mindestanforderung nicht erfüllt ist Löschung von Die Kleptomanin Wikipedia:Richtlinien Literarische Werke Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
5188 18711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of chess openings named after animals User:Abductive 05:12, 26 October 2009 (UTC) delete as |indiscriminate and unsupported by |reliable sources. These chess openings are not grouped by tactic or strategy or anything else relating to the playing of chess, unlike List of chess openings. Furthermore, some the actual names are in question, due to the self-published nature of the source (Schiller Deletion of List of chess openings named after animals WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5189 6143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Building Services Architect User:Dylanfromthenorth 06:43, 7 October 2010 (UTC) delete As per nom, basically an unreferenced dicdef, reads very much like |original research on an unnotable topic Deletion of Building Services Architect WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5190 19201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Cadwallader User:Number 16:30, 5 May 2008 (UTC) delete Fails #Athletes Deletion of Mark Cadwallader WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5191 7911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warsaw Pact rail User:Kierzek 19:33, 14 November 2017 (UTC) delete Not showing notability for a stand alone article and has and issues Deletion of Warsaw Pact rail WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5192 2719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yuta (musician) User:Bearian 19:38, 5 August 2020 (UTC) delete I don't see how a |backup singer/dancer is |notable. Userfying this mess will only encourage |re-submission too soon Deletion of Yuta (musician) WP:MILL||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
5193 19033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parental acceptance-rejection theory NONE 02:14, 12 November 2011 (UTC) delete """Lacks sufficient to meet … 12 of the 15 references are from Rohner, the creator of the theory (hardly """"independent""""), and 11 are just different pages in the same work. Happy Editing! — '''{{User|72.75.52.11""" Deletion of Parental acceptance-rejection theory WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5194 5800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jentique Furniture Ltd User:AllyD 21:42, 2 November 2019 (UTC) delete """The company's lifespan preceded digital media, but even allowing for that, something more is needed for than occasional passing mentions. A merge with the :Metamec article might be an option, as they appear to have been part of the same group, but that would again need some of the solid sourcing which is wanting. Add to that the catalogue-ish tone of much of the current article (''""""there exists a small but devoted band of Jentique ash furniture collectors""""'', ''""""an affordable collectors' item prized for being attractive, well-made pieces""""'', etc.) and I am not seeing that this article can be sustained here""" Deletion of Jentique Furniture Ltd :WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5195 10687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zia Mian [[User talk:A Den Jentyl Ettien Avel Dysklyver|''Dysklyver'']] 11:24, 22 October 2017 (UTC) keep What I find even more puzzling is why no one has noticed he easily meets . In my opinion this easily meets , like most the people here I agree the majority of the sources are namechecking, however several are clearly not, and these substantial sources are easily sufficient to pass GNG. He features on several lists of the most important Asian scientists, so I have no issue with the relevance of the subject Deletion of Zia Mian WP:NAUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5196 8330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ricardo Farcaș User:Spiderone 13:47, 10 April 2021 (UTC) delete I don't think that the coverage is that significant. If we analyse the sources in the article, firstly, we have https://www.digisport.ro/fotbal/fotbal-international/un-roman-pe-urmele-lui-chivu-mitea-si-ogararu-capitanul-nationalei-u17-a-romaniei-a-semnat-cu-ajax-236630 a routine transfer announcement; no depth at all; simply mentions that he is U17 captain and has signed for Ajax. The https://www.digisport.ro/fotbal/fotbal-international/ricardo-farcas-primul-roman-din-academia-ajax-ma-bucur-ca-am-contribuit-la-aducerea-lui-315110 next article simply states that he is the first Romanian in the Ajax academy and has a brief quote from him. I don't believe that being the first person of x nationality to play for the academy of y is a claim to notability. The https://www.digisport.ro/fotbal/serie-a/surpriza-mare-inca-un-roman-va-evolua-in-serie-a-in-sezonul-urmator-689711 third and last source is essentially a routine announcement of being added to the senior squad for Spal. The article states that he is a central defender and that he played 28 matches and scored 5 goals with the youth team last season. No other info or depth. My own brief searches did not come up with anything better. GSP articles are nothing better than a https://www.gsp.ro/international/stranieri/ricardo-farcas-inca-un-fotbalist-roman-in-serie-a-572418.html brief announcement that he made his debut in a friendly match and a https://www.gsp.ro/international/stranieri/ajax-vrea-sa-cucereasca-fotbalul-european-cu-un-roman-ma-bucur-ca-am-contribuit-la-aducerea-lui-urmeaza-alte-sosiri-din-romania-509724.html passing mention. https://www.sport.ro/stranieri/pustii-minune-vlad-dragomir-si-ricardo-farcas-au-un-weekend-perfect-dragomir-a-jucat-atat-pentru-arsenal.html Sport.ro labels him as a wonderkid but the article itself is barely more than a passing match report mention. My delete is 'weak' because there is plenty of coverage in reliable sources but I still lean towards 'delete' because I honestly don't think that any of it meets , if we apply it properly Deletion of Ricardo Farcaș WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
5197 11189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Las Araucarias NONE NONE keep Playa Hermosa, Pichilemu: Meets Deletion of Las Araucarias WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5198 16138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Franciscan Missionaries of Divine Compassion User:Joe 22:25, 31 January 2010 (UTC) delete All that I can find in Google is the official site, Wordpress, Facebook, and American Anglican which isn't independent of the subject. I found zero sources in Google News and Google Books. Fails Deletion of Franciscan Missionaries of Divine Compassion WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5199 10953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yxngxr1 User:Jdcomix 21:44, 21 October 2019 (UTC) delete Clearly fails Deletion of Yxngxr1 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5200 10059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Hansen User:Joe 23:13, 8 May 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |musician Deletion of Larry Hansen WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5201 16026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buddha is not an Avtar of vishnu User:Cool 11:43, 19 May 2007 (UTC) delete Per nom, , no sources, and . Also, don't merge the content either. It's likely to never be verified, and the page is opinional anyways Deletion of Buddha is not an Avtar of vishnu WP:OR||WP:SOAP Wikipedia:No original research 65
5202 20334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kippax Centre User:Jeepday 11:45, 9 February 2021 (UTC) comment there is nothing in -M that says anything MUST be merged. If you want to try and add it to the article you are welcome to, but trying to get an AFD ruling that it must be merged is without grounds Deletion of Kippax Centre WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5203 2876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Koohiar Peik User:Jmertel23 20:26, 19 November 2018 (UTC) delete pure |self-promotion that has no in-depth or |reliable sources. Simply fails notability guidelines Deletion of Koohiar Peik WP:SPIP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5204 4458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beyoncé's untitled third studio album User:Jasynnash2 11:20, 11 September 2008 (UTC) delete title or not it isn't notable, hasn't come out (and may not ever come out despite what is currently said). Clearly fails . Billboard reference means including it in the artist's article is reasonable but, on its own really doesn't support a separate article Deletion of Beyoncé's untitled third studio album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5205 18181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camp Courage User:Taewangkorea 09:03, 30 August 2019 (UTC) keep It appears that the camp meets as there is significant coverage for the topic, although the article needs some work Deletion of Camp Courage WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5206 14391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter sendzik User:Roswell 03:53, 22 March 2007 (UTC) delete as it does not assert notablity per Deletion of Walter sendzik WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5207 17780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Medievia (2nd nomination) User:Spy 13:49, 27 December 2019 (UTC) delete No significant coverage from reliable sources and therefore fails . Most coverage in reliable sources are just trival mentions Deletion of Medievia (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5208 15634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arrogant (2 Pistols album) User:Joe 15:52, 26 September 2009 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Arrogant (2 Pistols album) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5209 17588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haven Arts User:NinjaRobotPirate 13:40, 20 January 2016 (UTC) comment I found some trivial mentions, such as http://www.nytimes.com/2006/07/30/nyregion/thecity/30sobr.html?pagewanted=all and http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/08/travel/08weekend.html?_r=0 in ''The New York Times'' and http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748704099704576289213167219704 in ''The Wall Street Journal''. However, I'm not sure there's enough coverage to satisfy . Maybe this could be merged somewhere, but I'm not sure where. Perhaps somewhere in Culture of New York City or Mott Haven, Bronx? if nobody can suggest a good merge target, then I guess I'll probably go ahead and vote to delete Deletion of Haven Arts WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5210 16532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Wilken User:Stifle 00:32, 4 January 2006 (UTC) delete per . Many people have had work published in journals. Books are required Deletion of Patrick Wilken WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5211 5288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Foreman III User:Niteshift36 12:18, 14 June 2009 (UTC) comment """It says """"pro"""". Was this sanctioned by any of the recognized boxing federations? If so, he'd qualify under . If not, then I'd say non-notable""" Deletion of George Foreman III WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5212 5840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moxie 88 User:Gongshow 08:05, 28 October 2017 (UTC) delete I'm not finding coverage to satisfy or Deletion of Moxie 88 WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5213 11595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deaths of Christopher Stewart and Deanna Rivers User:Darth 15:05, 29 October 2019 (UTC) delete Sad, yes, but otherwise does not meet the requirements for Deletion of Deaths of Christopher Stewart and Deanna Rivers WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5214 21020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kate Chappell User:NahalAhmed 21:32, 24 December 2019 (UTC) merge to Tom's of Maine. I don't get significant coverage, Fails Deletion of Kate Chappell WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
5215 2076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amber Walter User:Tomwsulcer 23:01, 20 November 2014 (UTC) delete My sweeps turn up nada, US news, international, entertainment-related, subject doesn't meet the Deletion of Amber Walter WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5216 492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenta Furube [[User_talk:ClubOranje|T]] 10:28, 2 June 2009 (UTC) delete per nom, fails in never having made the field, non notable per . --ClubOranje Deletion of Kenta Furube WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5217 3323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Autumn's Concerto (South Korean TV series) User:Michaela 03:06, 4 October 2014 (UTC) delete No refs to support that this is actually real, fail . Could even be a hoax or a wish of an overzealous fan Deletion of Autumn's Concerto (South Korean TV series) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5218 10565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cage (enclosure) (2nd nomination) User:Widefox 16:34, 1 October 2017 (UTC) keep SNOW) Does anyone seriously think sources can't be found? Not a dict def, similar non-dictdef articles on things are Box etc. Nom overlooks it being a at the which solves issues with it, and with the in the dab. Dabconcepts shouldn't be deleted just because they're difficult (per guideline) or not done yet Deletion of Cage (enclosure) (2nd nomination) WP:DABCONCEPT||WP:PRIMARYTOPIC||WP:PTM Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
5219 20272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 Santa Ana, California mayoral election User:Reywas92 22:10, 14 November 2019 (UTC) delete Just because an election happened doesn't mean there automatically needs to be an article for it. Please do not continue to mass-create articles for positions that don't necessary pass . This merely says the one-line results three times (in the prose, infobox, and election box); where is the content and the substantive sources? The official results do not count just for being from both the city and county. A possibility is List of Santa Ana, California mayoral elections, which could also be combined with a List of mayors of Santa Ana, California, but individual content-free articles are not necessary Deletion of 2018 Santa Ana, California mayoral election WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5220 11903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yevgen Zadorin User:Velella 11:21, 4 May 2019 (UTC) delete """as per nomination. The use of the adjective """"exceptional"""" is usually a robust indicator that the subject is not exceptional. Publishing 40 papers is hardly a claim to notability , even I can better that. Fails . ''''' """ Deletion of Yevgen Zadorin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5221 20987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bilingual name User:Ingratis 17:36, 27 March 2021 (UTC) delete nom has it completely right with RESEARCH|original research Deletion of Bilingual name WP:ORIGINAL Wikipedia:No original research 65
5222 13804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Baldermann User:AssegaiAli 14:00, 30 June 2009 (UTC) delete No there is no indication of notability - the article seems to have been produced based purely on the understanding that being mayor is sufficient. It isn't. Fails Deletion of Tim Baldermann WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5223 11942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anjali yadav dancer User:Anupmehra 13:57, 13 November 2016 (UTC) delete I'm not able to find any sources. Even the one cited in the article doesn't mention subject. As of now, fails and Deletion of Anjali yadav dancer WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5224 12704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cal Marshall User:Cwmhiraeth 10:49, 13 May 2018 (UTC) delete per nom. Does not meet Deletion of Cal Marshall WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5225 18332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natalie Paige Bentley User:Sue 20:36, 26 November 2012 (UTC) delete Puff piece, fails Deletion of Natalie Paige Bentley WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5226 3465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of landmarks in Las Vegas User:Bearian 03:46, 3 December 2009 (UTC) keep """I can't see what guideline or policy this violates. It seems to pass . Virtually all of the """"landmarks"""" are notable by themselves, so a list of such would also be notable. Cut out the cruft (NN sites) and |fix the citations. Am I missing something""" Deletion of List of landmarks in Las Vegas WP:LIST||WP:RS Wikipedia:Lists 97
5227 2101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamia Fatimatuzzahra Napa User:Cordless 07:08, 1 September 2016 (UTC) delete a search doesn't reveal anything other than a Facebook page, so fails Deletion of Jamia Fatimatuzzahra Napa WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5228 12016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nu metal User:AmeIiorate 04:05, 31 August 2008 (UTC) keep """appears to be notable' http://www.google.co.nz/search?q=%22Nu%20Metal%22%20+Music """"Nu Metal"""" +Music returns 2,890,000 |GHITS. Also, there are multiple categories for :Category:Nu metal musical groups present on Wikipedia (created as far back as 2005), so I doubt this is a word that someone recently. '''~ AmeIiorate""" Deletion of Nu metal WP:GHITS||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5229 8835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Revation Communicator User:Sam 16:18, 16 January 2017 (UTC) delete """In the sources provide I mostly see trivial mention of Revation Systems and little about their product. Searching for '''{{mono|""""Revation Communicator""""}}''' I find no in-depth sources that could make this pass """ Deletion of Revation Communicator WP:NPRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5230 12517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Easter Sunrise Diamond User:DroEsperanto 04:04, 2 September 2009 (UTC) delete Sources are mediocre at best, no indication of notability. Also '''delete''' Glenn Worthington as it should have already been deleted as per '''rticles for deletion/Shirley Strawn|previously established consensus'''. &mdash Deletion of Easter Sunrise Diamond WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
5231 5055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Floast User:Danny 01:02, 10 September 2006 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not for stupid in-jokes Deletion of Floast WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5232 17363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Megan Elizabeth User:Hullaballoo 22:55, 22 April 2009 (UTC) delete Fails ntertainer and GNG, PORNBIO isn't really relevant Deletion of Megan Elizabeth WP:E Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
5233 16697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hutchinson Middle School User:Kudpung 20:42, 22 November 2014 (UTC) merge to Norwalk-La Mirada Unified School District per standard procedure as documented at as per Deletion of Hutchinson Middle School :WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5234 20425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ann Barker (Civil Servant) User:FreeRangeFrog 21:50, 4 February 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Ann Barker (Civil Servant) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5235 5732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/University Alliance in Talent Education Development User:Cewbot 00:02, 27 May 2020 (UTC) comment This nomination has had limited participation and falls within the standards set for |lack of quorum. There are no previous AfD discussions, undeletions, or current redirects and no previous PRODs have been located. This nomination may be '''eligible for |soft deletion''' at the end of its 7-day listing Deletion of University Alliance in Talent Education Development WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
5236 21664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ekti Tarar Khonje User:Atlantic306 20:58, 28 April 2018 (UTC) keep as the reliable sources including rs reviews identified above passes criteria 1 of , only one criteria is needed. The nominator is also allowed to add the references to the article Deletion of Ekti Tarar Khonje WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
5237 11002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Old School Death Metal User:Jayron32 06:25, 15 February 2008 (UTC) delete as |unverifiable and |original research Deletion of Old School Death Metal WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5238 1010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ozlabs User:Chondrite 23:37, 13 December 2006 (UTC) delete unsourced/OR article, subject does not appear to meet otability Deletion of Ozlabs WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5239 14058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ghazi Abdul Qayyum User:Scorpiondollprincess 18:17, 27 July 2006 (UTC) keep as I think this squeaks by under and has plenty of |verifiable |sources. My only objections are to the . I'd like to see a big cleanup of this article. This is poorly written encycylopedia material, as is. ''If'' a major cleanup can be undertaken, then I say keep Deletion of Ghazi Abdul Qayyum WP:BIO||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
5240 9006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bristol Indymedia User:Simon 16:39, 5 February 2009 (UTC) delete """I am not sure if this scrapes across the |notability threshold or not, but if it ''does'', the article is going to need to be rewritten from the ground up based on reliable sources. The writing is highly unencyclopædic to the point of implicating and (e.g. """"Opinions vary on their success; for example, previous versions of this Wikipedia entry contained a vitriolic rant which, while ill-suited to Wikipedia's NPOV neutral tone, is indicative of the strong feelings that Indymedia can sometimes evoke""""). At any rate, I'm not convinced as to notability beyond the server seizure (see ), of which there is some limited coverage by other indymedia outfits, and nearby news outlets (Wikipedia:EVENT#Local events seems to cover that). If this local indymedia outfit is notable independent of arguably notable events, why Bristol Indymedia but not Scotland Indymedia or Portland Indymedia? (But see .) Virtually every line of the article is cited based on work published by the subject of the article, and the sole independent source - a link to BBC news - turns out to be dead. and require more of an article than this. All in all, while I could be pushed back into the keep camp, on evidence currently available, I lean towards deleting. That position is bolstered by my suspicion that even if the subject is notable, Brian Eno was on to something: sometimes the fastest way to get something to where it needs to be is to delete it and start afresh, rather than getting bogged down trying to patch up a defective version. - Simon Dodd""" Deletion of Bristol Indymedia WP:ORG||WP:OR||WP:NPOV||WP:EVENT||WP:WAX||WP:BURDEN||WP:RELIABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5241 16019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Problem-reaction-solution [[User talk:RasputinAXP| RasputinAXP ]] [[Special:Contributions/RasputinAXP|c]] 23:59, 1 August 2006 (UTC) delete Total and complete lack of |verifiability from |reliable sources. This ''consept'' is |bollocks, pure and simple Deletion of Problem-reaction-solution WP:V||WP:RS||WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5242 10330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beautiful Nitemare User:Esradekan 09:16, 14 July 2008 (UTC) merge both back to Beyonce Knowles. Fails to establish notability as per #Songs Deletion of Beautiful Nitemare WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5243 17936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ACTRAN User:Fred 17:00, 19 March 2009 (UTC) keep this article contains information useful to understand what is Actran, as other articles like Ansys, Comsol, OpenFOAM and hundreds of others. The specificity of this (commercial) product is explained, and this information is useful to anyone interested in simulations, eg to decide whether it is scientifically appropriate to tackle a specific problem. Wikipedia is the best place to put this type of information because it is the only way to have at last an objective statement on how exactly this product should be defined, thanks to the feedback of the community (which is allowed to edit if anything is wrong, not?). It is by no means in contradictions with the rules listed in |their own web site, to quote MuZemike: a wiki page must live and evolve through the community whereas commercial communication is fed only by the vendor Deletion of ACTRAN WP:NOTWEBHOST Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5244 13538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Touhid Talukder User:Bearian 15:48, 29 January 2021 (UTC) delete per and . Producers, especially co-producers as with this subejct, are rarely notable Deletion of Touhid Talukder WP:MILL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
5245 136 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ajdar (2. aday gösterme) """Kullanıcı:bora006'''bora006'''""" 12:37, 10 Mayıs 2008 (UTC) keep Kendisini her ne kadar sevmesem de; Madde 10-Müzisyenin veya grubun ulusal bir televizyon veya radyo yayınında en az yarım saat işlenmiş olması,ve Vikipedi:Kayda değerlik (kişi) Kişinin adının kanıtlanabilir şekilde yaygınca tanınmış olması,maddelerine göre kalsın oyu kullanmak zorundayım.--Resim:Torchlight help icon.svg|22px Ajdar (2. aday gösterme) yazısının silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
5246 19641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fernando Pérez (software developer) User:StarryGrandma 00:14, 9 August 2015 (UTC) keep """Using Google Books with """"IPython Perez"""" turns up multiple book citations including https://books.google.com/books?id=Y7RCCgjmowcC&pg=PA22 a sidebar about Pérez. There is also http://www.nature.com/news/interactive-notebooks-sharing-the-code-1.16261 a nice article in Nature about IPython notebook and Pérez's work in developing it. Meets #7, substantial impact outside academia in their field""" Deletion of Fernando Pérez (software developer) WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5247 21774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Ireland (Columbine) [[User talk:74.88.115.8|talk]]) 18:58, 17 July 2013 (UTC) delete """clearly a person and the supposed """"book"""" he wrote doesn't seem notable either since there is no coverage of it other than this http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/otl/news/story?id=4069745 ESPN post. In fact, he seems that he never published this """"book"""" and only wrote it for ESPN to commemorate the 10th anniversary of the shooting, which does not indicate notability at all. Special:Contributions/74.88.115.8|74.88.115.8""" Deletion of Patrick Ireland (Columbine) WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5248 10871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Outline of Louisiana history User:Highfields 20:46, 19 October 2009 (UTC) merge This has been discussed at depth for the last few weeks, if outlines are to be deleted, we need a central discussion/RfC, not AfD. As for the , the issue is countered Wikipedia:Why do we have outlines in addition to...?|here. On the other hand, I feel that state history outlines may be a bit too much to keep (). If that is the case then maybe these should be merged with Outline of Louisiana etc Deletion of Outline of Louisiana history WP:FORK||WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Mirrors and forks 46
5249 589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I'm Only A Woman User:Sgeureka 14:10, 13 May 2008 (UTC) delete If the author didn't write this story himself (), it is a copyright violation (). &ndash Deletion of I'm Only A Woman WP:MADEUP||WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
5250 13127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gints Freimanis User:Sir 13:58, 20 February 2010 (UTC) keep per Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rihards Gorkšs|previous AfD. The consensus was then that he met , because of significant coverage in major Irish newspapers as in http://www.herald.ie/sport/soccer/pats-snap-up-latvian-star-1650028.html here amd http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/2009/20090304-it.xml?style=article_legacy_url§ion=sport&fn=1224242233818 here (the latter requires a subscription to the Irish Times to be viewed). I see no reason to overule the previously established consensus Deletion of Gints Freimanis WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5251 13223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry J. Powell User:Gene93k 21:50, 20 May 2015 (UTC) delete as a ONEEVENT biography that also fails . No trace of ongoing RS coverage for this person before or after the 2007 event. Impersonating a war hero is not that unusual a crime Deletion of Terry J. Powell WP:PERP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5252 18162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J. E. Sherrill User:DarkAudit 19:25, 28 January 2008 (UTC) delete Fails for public officials. No significant non-local coverage to warrant inclusion Deletion of J. E. Sherrill WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5253 14076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paheena User:Deletapedia 18:34, 19 September 2014 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass and Deletion of Paheena WP:NOTE||WP:CS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5254 8532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VA Sound User:Fortuna 11:18, 22 August 2017 (UTC) delete per nom and . &mdash Deletion of VA Sound WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5255 7968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/North County Community Church User:GRBerry 03:01, 13 September 2006 (UTC) delete as it contains neither an assertion of notability nor citations to |reliable sources to support any such claim Deletion of North County Community Church WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5256 13124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Viktor Lövgren User:Atlantic306 17:57, 3 July 2018 (UTC) delete as does not pass and autobios are discouraged Deletion of Viktor Lövgren WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5257 3556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vicariously User:First 05:40, 11 September 2010 (UTC) delete """Does not come close to meeting , because it hasn't """"received significant coverage in Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable sources that are Wikipedia:Independent sources|independent of the subject""" Deletion of Vicariously WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5258 984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transparent Records User:Excelse 09:57, 27 October 2017 (UTC) delete not very notable. Yes they have a number of clients but is still missing Deletion of Transparent Records WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
5259 11329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tadasana User:Transcendence 22:49, 10 May 2013 (UTC) keep Looks like it passes Deletion of Tadasana WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5260 14777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All the plants User:TompaDompa 11:29, 18 July 2021 (UTC) delete """This is rather a bizarre article. The scope is unclear, but seems to duplicate those mentioned in the nomination. The title is definitely non-standard (and as mentioned above, not useful as a redirect). The content is a strange mix of very broad information ({{tq|Plants are mainly multicellular organisms, predominantly photosynthetic eukaryotes of the kingdom plantae.}}), very specific information ({{tq|Ground cinnamon is composed of around 11% water, 81% carbohydrates including 53% dietary fiber, 4% protein and 1% fat.}} and {{tq|World production of raspberries in 2018 was 870,209 tonnes, led by Russia with 19% of the world total.}}), and instructions ({{tq|Put a seed, bulb or plant in the ground so that it can grow.}}), as well as some stuff that is related to a different sense of """"plant"""" ({{tq|A place where an industrial or manufacturing process takes place.}}) or is pretty much incomprehensible ({{tq|Vegetable in a market in the philines.}}). The layout with bulleted lists and one sentence per bullet point is rather odd. All in all, it looks like something written for personal use, not for an encyclopedia. Consequently, #14 ({{tq|Any other content Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not|not suitable for an encyclopedia}}) applies, specifically """ Deletion of All the plants WP:DELREASON||WP:NOTHOST Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5261 11466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buffyverse chronology (2nd nomination) User:DHowell 08:12, 27 July 2007 (UTC) keep """This is article is neither |original research nor a |plot summary. It is a list of episodes (note that episode titles are real-world information, not in-universe information) with short plot descriptions, ordered by their occurrence in the fictional universe's timeline. It is well-referenced and verifiable, and is an encylcopedic treatment of one aspect of an academic field of study (see Buffy studies). The original research policy does not prohibit all synthesis of published material (if it did, just about every Wikipedia article would be in violation). It prohibits """"''#Synthesis of published material serving to advance a position|synthesis of published material serving to advance a position''"""". Exactly what position is being advanced by ordering the episodes in-universe chronological order? To say that policy prohibits this chronology would be like saying that policy prohibits one from listing the Star Wars movies in order I,II,III,IV,V,VI; that to avoid """"in-universe perspective"""" we may only list them in order IV,V,VI,I,II,III. If rules as written do indeed prohibit this highly encyclopedic article, then |ignore the rules and fix the broken policy""" Deletion of Buffyverse chronology (2nd nomination) WP:OR||WP:PLOT||WP:OR||WP:IAR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5262 15523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lo Salt User:Colonel 16:36, 4 December 2008 (UTC) keep A brand named product that captures 84% of a country’s market share, as shown here by reliable - independent sources http://www.just-food.com/article.aspx?ID=73856 http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22LoSalt%22+Brand&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8 is pretty notable to me and falls within our otability|notability guidelines. Likewise, as Deletion of Lo Salt WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5263 12383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Ching User:Sparklism 10:17, 13 August 2013 (UTC) delete I cannot find any evidence that this guy meets the guidelines for inclusion set out at or Deletion of Joshua Ching WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5264 5706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reach Every Dolla User:DMacks 23:00, 10 June 2008 (UTC) delete non-notable band and album/single/etc. Fails many ways Deletion of Reach Every Dolla WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5265 15114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nasal breathing User:Colonel 17:32, 4 January 2012 (UTC) keep The topic is notable and so should be developed further per our |editing policy Deletion of Nasal breathing WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
5266 13768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/First Person Plural: My Life As A Multiple User:Medicellis 01:44, 22 July 2008 (UTC) keep after rework and '''Agree''' with redirecting the author to the book as the book as much more than the author Deletion of First Person Plural: My Life As A Multiple WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5267 6754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lists of Stargate topics User:Neon 20:21, 27 April 2008 (UTC) keep per . Lists and categories complement each other. They aren't exclusive and should not be nominated for deletion because of overlap. --neonwhite Deletion of Lists of Stargate topics WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
5268 10988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward Sidney Hyman User:PropelAssisting 09:28, 30 September 2020 (UTC) delete or '''redirect''' if a suitable target can be found. While it is possible that the subject is very marginally notable, the current article vastly overstates what he is done, and is undersourced and/or primary-sourced. applies. I don't strenuously object refunding to user space of the originator, but I tend to think that there is so little that is usable there right now that it would be better to just start over Deletion of Edward Sidney Hyman WP:TNT||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
5269 15873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murmur Creative User:MER 04:17, 7 September 2015 (UTC) delete Promotional article about a |non-notable company. Creator has an undisclosed conflict of interest regarding this subject Deletion of Murmur Creative WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5270 1079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phyllis Bolds User:Thincat 20:58, 9 April 2019 (UTC) keep """My start on WP predates the notability guidelines and I remember them being proposed and developed. It is therefore natural for me not to see as rules that are to be obeyed but as suggested criteria to be mulled over. The guidelines are intended to serve a purpose – to try and be reasonably sure articles meet our content policies as explained at otability#Why we have these requirements. It looks to me that this article does indeed meet these policies pretty well. If applying the criteria strictly line-by-line leads to a """"fail"""" (I don't know whether or not it does) then, in my view, the guidelines are not giving good advice in this case""" Deletion of Phyllis Bolds WP:GNG||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5271 19402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orange Book liberalism User:The 02:40, 29 January 2012 (UTC) merge """There is an ''Orange Book'' and the liberals who support it are occassionally refereed to as """"''Orange Book'' Liberals"""". In order to justify an article we need a source that says it is a commonly used term with a clear definition. Until then it is just |original research""" Deletion of Orange Book liberalism WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5272 8342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sadguru Appaiah Swami User:DaGizza 00:19, 8 August 2008 (UTC) delete Per and Deletion of Sadguru Appaiah Swami WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5273 198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Waterdeep User:Daranios 15:43, 1 December 2020 (UTC) keep or '''merge''': In a first search I did not see large-scale discussion, but a number of shorter bits about Waterdeep in secondary sources, both present in and as yet absent from the article. I would like to search more, but that takes time, especially given the number of deletion discussions going on at the moment. Taking these sources together, especially when considering that Undermountain redirects here, and therefore any discussion of Untermountain in secondary sources directly pertains to the notability of this article, I think the article can be kept. If all that together is not seen as enough, the present information should still be |preserved, both by merging (I guess to Faerûn), and by keeping the history available for future use and improvement Deletion of Waterdeep WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
5274 95 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Bilal Yiğit Koçak Kullanıcı:güherçilegüherçile 07.40, 30 Haziran 2021 (UTC) delete """Röportajlar yerine göre KD'lik ispatlayabilir, ama bu kişi için ben de yeterli bulmuyorum. O gibi sayfaların çoğunu Mart civarından beri bir anonim kullanıcı oluşturuyor. Kendisiyle epey uzun tartışmalarımız oldu ile ilgili ama çok da amacına ulaşmadı. Hala ilk bakışta 30 kaynak var görünen ama bunların neredeyse tamamı """"kimdir"""", """"biyografi.x"""", şu plajda görüntülendi şununla evlendi minvalinde aynı magazin haberlerinden 3'er 5'er tane eklenmiş, KD'likle ilgisi olmayan onlarca bağlantıdan oluşan birçok sayfa var. Bu kişilerin bir kısmı KD bir kısmı değil. O kullanıcı fazla ısrarcı olduğu için silmeye dair müdahale etmek istemedim ama zamanı olanlar""" Bilal Yiğit Koçak'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:GÜVEN Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5275 428 [[Zahra Kameli]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Laibwächter 13:55, 15. Jun. 2010 (CEST) delete """Extremer Verstoß gegen . Hier geht die Wahrung des Persönlichkeitsrechts vor dem abgeklungenen Medieninteresse. Der letzte Satz zeugt von der Verjährung des Medieninteresses. Die meisten """"Quellen"""" werden in der Zwischenzeit kaum aufzufinden sein, wenn sie nicht gar spätesten durch die geführenfinanzierte Löschung von bestehenden Inhalten bereits verschütt gegangen sind. Ergo""" Löschung von Zahra Kameli Wikipedia:BIO Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
5276 11248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tristan Thomas (marketer) User:Beemer69 19:11, 7 January 2020 (UTC) delete """Clear fail of . Name search alone turned up Tristan Thompson. Adding """"Forbes"""" and """"marketing"""" to distinguish subject resulted in zilch""" Deletion of Tristan Thomas (marketer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5277 20300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Airus User:Closenplay 00:13, 4 June 2007 (UTC) delete """Absolutely non-notable. See how many ghits you get when searching """"Airus + Garbrecht"""" (the singer's last name). Totally fails + , and it's , too""" Deletion of Airus WP:BAND||WP:V||WP:AB Wikipedia:Notability 77
5278 665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joanna Masingila User:Xxanthippe 01:32, 4 March 2012 (UTC) comment GS shows 392 cites with an h-index of 10. Could be a weak keep on rof#1 in a low cited field Deletion of Joanna Masingila WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
5279 10111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lists of people User:Buidhe 08:02, 9 January 2019 (UTC) delete per . In its current form there is no encyclopedic value and no navigational utility Deletion of Lists of people WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
5280 5306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IPod touch Fans User:Ohnoitsjamie 02:21, 2 October 2008 (UTC) comment Can someone show me the two non-trivial coverages in reliable sources? I have yet to hear any keep criteria based on our notability policy Deletion of IPod touch Fans WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
5281 2063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicola Tappenden (2nd nomination) [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']] 16:01, 27 February 2006 (UTC) delete Just as non-notable the second time around. No evidence of notability supplied to change previous vote, refers Deletion of Nicola Tappenden (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5282 7008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julian Dobrowolski User:Charlene 21:58, 13 June 2007 (UTC) delete I'm finding nothing on a Julian Dobrowolski on Google outside of a 20-year-old Warhammer player and a middle-aged murder victim. Does not appear to pass ; article is also not attributed Deletion of Julian Dobrowolski WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5283 1576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/X-Terminator User:Footlessmouse 22:34, 12 October 2020 (UTC) delete fails . There is no significant coverage in reliable sources. There is nothing to merge, and a redirect is unnecessary Deletion of X-Terminator WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5284 9825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Complicated Wire User:That NONE delete as |non-notable band. &mdash Deletion of Complicated Wire WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5285 10919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shanzay Hayat User:Sulfurboy 04:10, 24 April 2020 (UTC) delete Lots of coverage that basically is routine pagent winner stuff that doesn't demonstrate notability. There is some of the subject, but all of it surrounds a nude photoshoot they did. As such, it would be considered and Deletion of Shanzay Hayat WP:SIGCOV||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
5286 7885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of NBC slogans (2nd nomination) User:Armbrust 00:51, 12 July 2010 (UTC) delete as |Wikipedia is not a directory Deletion of List of NBC slogans (2nd nomination) WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5287 18947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NATO supply Line User:Anotherclown 22:00, 3 December 2011 (UTC) keep per TopGun and Nick-D. Article appears to have signficant coverage in reliable sources and as such is likely notable under . (As a starting point only please see the hundreds of news articles available through Google dating over a period of several years which discuss the topic and the numerous issues which have affected it and ongoing campaign in Afghanistan, not to mention Pakistan and US relations). While I agree with the nominator that the article is in terrible shape and that it would be no great loss if what we currently have was deleted, I would be surprised if this article cannot be developed with the material available (should editors with suitable knowledge be willing to work on it). It should probably be renamed too Deletion of NATO supply Line WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5288 9808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hair in food User:Indon 10:43, 22 July 2007 (UTC) delete patent nonsense. I can search any term in google, so can I write article based on that facts? Nope, it fails . &mdash Deletion of Hair in food WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5289 272 [[Freie Weinbauern Südtirol]] (LA zurückgezogen) Benutzer:Sicherlich 15:51, 4. Jul. 2007 (CEST) delete hmm es ist ein Verein (lt. impressum''Nicht anerkannter Verein'') : aus #Vereine: ''überregionale Bedeutung'' - kann ich nicht erkennen. ''besondere mediale Aufmerksamkeit'' - nicht erkennbar, ''besondere Tradition'' - 1999 gegründet, daher wohl nicht, ''signifikante Mitgliederzahl'' - 80 Mitglieder - sehe auch sonst keinen hinweis auf eine andersartige Relevanz, daher Löschung von Freie Weinbauern Südtirol Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
5290 10615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Catanzariti User:WWGB 11:28, 15 November 2008 (UTC) delete Political staffer, non-notable under and every other test Deletion of Peter Catanzariti WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
5291 4067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Paul McQueen and Craig Dean User:Flyer22 13:32, 2 August 2009 (UTC) keep Notability is clearly established within the article; the nominator even points this out. The article is not excessive plot summary, is not fanboy-ism, , or . Nor is most of this stuff in either of their individual articles. Their individual articles are what are mostly plot Deletion of John Paul McQueen and Craig Dean WP:FANCRUFT||WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
5292 20217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christ: the dark years User:Bearian 18:51, 2 September 2009 (UTC) delete a http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&as_q=diederich&as_epq=Christ+the+dark+years+&as_oq=&as_eq=wiki+blog+amazon+lulu&num=10&lr=lang_en&as_filetype=&ft=i&as_sitesearch=&as_qdr=all&as_rights=&as_occt=any&cr=&as_nlo=&as_nhi=&safe=images specified Google search reveals only five commercial sites on Ghits, and broader searches reveal lots of blogs and online stores. Zero |reliable sources and no reviews to prove this book is notable Deletion of Christ: the dark years WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5293 20995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thumbelina: A Magical Story User:Quasirandom 21:04, 19 December 2008 (UTC) keep """Per #Entertainment, """"Television series broadcast nationally by a major network or produced by a major studio are notable,"""" which this was""" Deletion of Thumbelina: A Magical Story WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5294 18699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lil Ru User:J04n 13:17, 21 November 2009 (UTC) keep the album has charted. The reference that was found by Samir has been added, Lil Ru passes per criterion 2 Deletion of Lil Ru WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5295 20445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nina Power User:Ultraexactzz 14:06, 7 February 2012 (UTC) delete Agricola44 has it, I think. With all due respect to the subject notability is borderline at best - and her request tips the scales toward deletion, as per doing no harm. That said, as per , if the subject becomes more notable down the line - a high-profile publication or some other project that gets widespread coverage, for example - an article might be warranted. The more notable the subject is, generally the more likely it is that their article would be kept, all requests from the subject notwithstanding - and the subject should be aware of that possibility. The only way to ensure that no article will ever be written about you would be to go do something obscure. High-profile scholarship is not that Deletion of Nina Power WP:USUAL Wikipedia:Usual caveats 41
5296 2765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global Urban History User:Joe 14:46, 1 September 2016 (UTC) delete as a non-notable Deletion of Global Urban History WP:NEOLOGISM Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
5297 3524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Dench User:Exok 10:44, 12 January 2012 (UTC) keep Number and variety of sources indicate notability per Deletion of Peter Dench WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5298 6903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blackened death metal User:Paul 03:20, 10 July 2008 (UTC) comment """A small number of reliable-source articles using the term http://news.google.ca/archivesearch?hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tab=wn&q=%22Blackened+death+metal%22 turn up on Google News archives. The ''New York Times'', in reference to Behemoth (band)|Behemoth says """"http://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/30/arts/music/30choi.html?_r=1&pagewanted=2&sq=rihanna&st=nyt&scp=45&oref=slogin ...this pushed Behemoth across the fine line that separates black metal from its slightly more mainstream cousin, death metal. Some old fans weren’t amused, but they have been replaced — and then some — by new ones, some of whom like to split the difference by using a hybrid term, blackened death metal."""" I'm not convinced that there is enough here to establish notability for an article about this genre""" Deletion of Blackened death metal WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5299 17245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Prize Fighter User:Firestorm 21:45, 18 February 2009 (UTC) delete per and also a suspected Deletion of The Prize Fighter WP:MUSIC||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Notability 77
5300 47 [[Internationales Seminar für Analytische Psychologie in Zürich]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Tom_md NONE delete Lesetipp: : es steht Dir frei, auf das andere Institut einen (gut begründeten LA) zu stellen. Hier tut das abrer nichts zur Sache. Hier interssieren nur Argumente in eigener Sache. So ist dieser Werbeflyer zu Löschung von Internationales Seminar für Analytische Psychologie in Zürich Wikipedia:BNS Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
5301 15709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raymond A. Watson (2nd nomination) User:Unscintillating 18:02, 3 October 2011 (UTC) keep """nbsp; I decided to examine the assertion that the topic does not meet , and conclude that this assertion is incorrect. Point 2 of states, """"Major local political figures who have received significant press coverage."""" """ Deletion of Raymond A. Watson (2nd nomination) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
5302 7268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Q42 (Wikidata item) User:KingSkyLord 16:12, 30 April 2020 (UTC) delete This is just ridiculous and Y Deletion of Q42 (Wikidata item) WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
5303 17604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mrs. Universe User:Northamerica1000 08:28, 3 January 2016 (UTC) keep """The topic meets and . Source examples include, but are not limited to: {{cite web|url=http://www.thesundaily.my/news/819728|title=Malaysia to host Mrs Universe|publisher=}}, {{cite web|url=http://balticreports.com/2010/08/30/mrs-universe-sued-by-miss-universe/|title=Mrs. Universe sued by Miss Universe - balticreports.com|publisher=}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.cp24.com/entertainment-news/miss-universe-threatens-legal-action-against-contest-with-similar-name-won-by-canadian-1.2554493|title=Miss Universe threatens legal action against contest with similar name won by Canadian|work=}}, {{cite web|url=http://eng.belta.by/society/view/mrs-universe-2015-kicks-off-in-minsk-84327-2015|title=Mrs Universe 2015 kicks off in Minsk|publisher=}}, {{cite web|url=http://lifestyle.iafrica.com/herlife/features/1004557.html|title=iafrica.com Scott wins first place at Mrs Universe|work=}}, {{cite web|url=http://en.ctv.by/en/1440582959-contenders-for-mrs-universe-2015-title-to-be-shown-belaz|title=Contenders for Mrs Universe 2015 title to be shown BelAZ|work=Belarus News}}, https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-428999209.html """"Winning Big on the International Stage""" Deletion of Mrs. Universe WP:ORGDEPTH||WP:EVENTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5304 17828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Boatman User:Sliggy 10:53, 22 March 2006 (UTC) keep of marginal notability. I added a badly needed |source to the article. In my opinion voting To my mind, opining keep for an article that lacks any verifiable sources is not good practice Deletion of Peter Boatman WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5305 15297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lugansk parliamentary republic User:Spirit 18:46, 14 April 2014 (UTC) delete Enough is enough. We do not need an article about every single Ukrainian building that gets occupied by protestors for a couple of days. Calling these occupations legitimate countries is a gross misrepresentation of the word. Likewise, the entire focus of the article is on a country a group is planning on forming, which is a violation of both rystal and Deletion of Lugansk parliamentary republic WP:C||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
5306 16147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Initiative (Buffy the Vampire Slayer organization) User:Piotrus 02:08, 5 December 2019 (UTC) delete """Thanks for AfDing this, the prod was removed by an anon with no rationale. The PROD rationale was """" No evidence this fictional organization passes /""" Deletion of The Initiative (Buffy the Vampire Slayer organization) WP:GNG||WP:NFICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
5307 18715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Caged (band) User:Dennis 12:55, 17 April 2011 (UTC) delete Falls short of , one mention in a RS isn't strong enough Deletion of The Caged (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5308 6371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ran (Bob and George) User:Haeleth 17:41, 9 December 2006 (UTC) delete per Kunzite (and ). &mdash Deletion of Ran (Bob and George) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5309 1842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prince of Persia 4 User:Jauerback 15:31, 26 October 2007 (UTC) delete it's not even announced. Until then, this article is pure Deletion of Prince of Persia 4 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5310 10694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ebiquity User:Snottywong 20:04, 13 December 2010 (UTC) keep Appears to have enough coverage to satisfy . I've taken the liberty of deleting some of the more |spammy parts of the article Deletion of Ebiquity WP:GNG||WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5311 19537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kalomira Sarantis user:Radman1 07:31, 7 September 2005 (UTC) keep Notable as per . &mdash Deletion of Kalomira Sarantis WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5312 1442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Dubeau User:Eastmain 16:53, 26 July 2018 (UTC) keep The analogy seems to make sense Deletion of Dan Dubeau WP:MILPERSON Wikipedia:Notability 77
5313 2652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tulio Febres Cordero [[User talk:86.17.222.157|talk]]) 22:47, 7 December 2016 (UTC) keep per https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Tulio_Febres_Cordero&diff=753557429&oldid=753511069 the edit summary that I gave when contesting deletion. Special:Contributions/86.17.222.157|86.17.222.157 Deletion of Tulio Febres Cordero WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
5314 4216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seripa (Dragon Ball Z) User:Quasirandom 14:34, 9 May 2008 (UTC) merge to List of Saiyans in Dragon Ball, where she is already listed, per the suggestion of and the growing concensus that lists are the best way to handle fictional elements of subjects that grow too large for our britches, er, size constraints Deletion of Seripa (Dragon Ball Z) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5315 12085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willie Levesque User:Secret 17:46, 13 August 2013 (UTC) delete WP:GNG trumps Deletion of Willie Levesque WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5316 11894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wisetrack User:Northamerica1000 08:56, 7 January 2012 (UTC) keep spaced ndash}}The nomination doesn't contain a valid rationale for deletion, per criterion listed at -REASON. AfD is not cleanup Deletion of Wisetrack WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5317 10223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Haslam (football coach) User:RGTraynor 18:07, 10 October 2008 (UTC) comment """Without indulging in an equally rambling counter essay, (1) In terms of college football, the near-unanimous consensus is that """"highest level of amateur sports"""" applies exclusively to Division I NCAA football, the only demurrers being the aforementioned three or four editors at the CFB Wikiproject. NAIA is three rungs ''below'' that; (2) Mr. McDonald's sole rationale for Keep on a number of AfDs were """"Per CFB:COACH,"""" and when challenged, attempted at first to defend it on the grounds of claiming to have achieved a broad consensus for it; (3) requires that """"""""Significant coverage"""" means that sources address the subject directly in detail ..."""" I doubt many (beyond CFB, of course) would agree that a college with 683 undergrads is a """"major"""" anything, or that being the founding coach in a NAIA program that size is a """"widely recognized contribution;"""" (4) That Mr. McDonald feels that """"a game can be considered the athletic equivalent to an academic published paper"""" I don't argue, but I'd wager he'd be met at best with derision if he took that premise to the academic community, most of whom don't publish a dozen academic papers a season; and (5) Mr. McDonald has not hesitated to claim other specific AfDs as consensus, and I'm surprised to hear him now discount the notion""" Deletion of Kevin Haslam (football coach) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5318 6888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenny Browne User:Fenix 09:09, 5 April 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Kenny Browne WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5319 653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asghar Bukhari User:Kigelim 17:55, 14 June 2015 (UTC) keep defiantly . I would say meybe merge but since there is a lot of contraversy, dumping it on the org article seems counter productive. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Asghar Bukhari WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5320 9568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doortechnik User:AllyD 08:47, 10 January 2020 (UTC) delete A listing-type article by a which has lingered for over 12 years without improvement or claim to notability. Searches are finding nothing better than routine listings. Fails Deletion of Doortechnik :WP:SPA||:WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
5321 19718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Adriano User:Erpert 08:47, 5 August 2013 (UTC) keep Three non-scene-related award noms in different years (Director of the Year in 2011, Best Director in 2012 and Male Performer of the Year in 2013) more than satisfy point #1 of . (The article creator might want to read if s/he wants to write more articles in the future, but as Guy1890 pointed out, AfD is not cleanup.) '''Erpert Deletion of Mike Adriano WP:PORNBIO||WP:BETTER Wikipedia:Notability 77
5322 12388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Murray (field hockey) User:Guliolopez 00:30, 3 January 2018 (UTC) comment """I had advocated a 'delete' in Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Murray (field hockey player)|the previous AfD. Mainly on grounds. While I am perhaps not swayed to recommend a firm 'keep', I do not feel I can agree with the """"not a single sentence since"""" statement in the nom. As, in the months since (Apr 2017 to Jan 2018), there does seem to have been https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Sean+Murray%22+hockey&biw=1366&bih=662&source=lnt&tbs=cdr%3A1%2Ccd_min%3A4%2F1%2F2017%2Ccd_max%3A&tbm=nws an increase in https://www.rte.ie/sport/hockey/2017/0820/898709-murray-magic-earns-ireland-impressive-draw-with-germany/ some types of coverage. While it may still be slightly TOOSOON, I am shifted to a more neutral stance based on the activity in the intervening months. If the community feels that the article is to be kept, then the scope and references will need to be firmed-up (to avoid a loosely sourced article becoming a magnet for more https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Sean_Murray_%28field_hockey%29&type=revision&diff=817649554&oldid=800489557 loosely framed nonsense""" Deletion of Sean Murray (field hockey) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
5323 20038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Polar Cities User:Debate 13:33, 31 May 2008 (UTC) delete The originator of the concept, Danny Bloom, has been spamming a huge range of newspaper comment pages, which complicates a search on the theory (at least he's using his own name). The most credible coverage I can find is a New York Times http://dotearth.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/03/30/polar-cities-a-haven-in-warming-world/index.html?ex=1364616000&en=56d90cd09c02e619&ei=5088&partner=rssnyt&emc=rss article, although there ''is'' a serious buzz in some of the more credible parts of the blogosphere. Still, until it gets some non-trivial coverage outside of this one-man campaign I don't think it meets Deletion of Polar Cities WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5324 6169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Declan Davis User:Calor 14:41, 23 August 2008 (UTC) delete Seems to fail all the points made at . Delete as nn Deletion of Declan Davis WP:TEACH Wikipedia:Notability 77
5325 20461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Bowmans User:Pontificalibus 16:32, 13 October 2009 (UTC) delete Seems to meet only #12 of , but I can find no reliable sources for their tour of Europe. In any case this |autobiography would require a massive rewrite to remove |peacock terms and make it WP|NPOV. Delete unless further sources can be found to show how it meets , for example, evidence in reliable sources of major competition wins etc Deletion of The Bowmans WP:BAND||WP:AUTO||WP:PEACOCK||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5326 920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Team Solomid User:Sergecross73 19:21, 9 March 2012 (UTC) delete Lack of |reliable, third party sources. They're pretty much all fansites or forum posts. Fails to meet the Deletion of Team Solomid WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5327 13216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shiba Maggon User:Hmlarson 20:54, 17 April 2018 (UTC) keep per . Article could use improved referencing, cleanup and expansion per Deletion of Shiba Maggon WP:GNG||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
5328 20822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global Mobility Solutions User:Crp2010 00:02, 29 September 2015 (UTC) comment forgot does not fail bc multiple srcs (read the section) cited including two large scale studies Deletion of Global Mobility Solutions WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
5329 11962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of female justice ministers User:L3X1 02:06, 7 October 2017 (UTC) keep as Montana said, Demographic-occupation lists are legitimate. Also, {{tq|ther stuff exists is not a valid argument.}} should keep in mind that OSE is an ''essay'' not a writ of policy to be enforced. I think the second sentence of the the essay explains it Deletion of List of female justice ministers WP:O Wikipedia:Orphan 47
5330 20749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Side Salad Records User:Dmehus 23:44, 8 November 2019 (UTC) delete """per nom and above. Just did regular Google search, but looked through '''all''', non-duplicative results. Nothing which even meets let alone second stage test. Fails both counts. Note that Google news search results will be time-consuming to wade through—lots of results for """"side salads"""" or a """"salad on the side"""", etc""" Deletion of Side Salad Records WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
5331 3326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herbert Schildt User:Colonel 04:49, 26 April 2010 (UTC) delete """Only has low-grade self-published sources - publisher's puffs and poison pen pieces - which are insufficient for a contentious, derogatory BLP. It is our |policy that """"''Contentious material about living persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced—whether the material is negative, positive, neutral, or just questionable—should be removed immediately""" Deletion of Herbert Schildt WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
5332 21957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Surrealist Women User:E 17:24, 12 July 2019 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Surrealist Women WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
5333 15489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cory Martin User:Freshacconci 19:17, 18 November 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails Deletion of Cory Martin WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5334 15155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Elias User:Papaursa 23:51, 26 June 2019 (UTC) delete I'm not seeing the significant independent coverage required to meet Deletion of Steve Elias WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5335 13859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sankalp Semiconductor User:Coolabahapple 13:59, 4 November 2016 (UTC) delete as Deletion of Sankalp Semiconductor WP:NOTPROMOTION Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5336 6724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of media portrayals of bisexuality User:Zxcvbnm 23:32, 12 February 2021 (UTC) delete """Per . At this point it's the same as listing """"media portrayals of coffee shops"""", in other words it appears too often for a list to be necessary. It's also far too much of a magnet for original research as opposed to actual confirmed bisexual characters""" Deletion of List of media portrayals of bisexuality WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5337 16870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melissa Lauren User:FuriouslySerene 20:02, 25 January 2016 (UTC) delete """Being referred to in a city newspaper as 'the most anticipated adult film of 2006' in no way establishes that the film was """"an iconic, groundbreaking or blockbuster feature,"""" which is clearly a very high standard. The low quality citations provided also do not do enough to meet this standard. Since she doesn't meet the GNG or , I don't see how this could meet the notability guidelines""" Deletion of Melissa Lauren WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5338 4484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 New York City attempted bombing User:TheGracefulSlick 06:56, 12 December 2017 (UTC) keep Actually, this was just a bad nomination and I am not even going to entertain it. Per which seems to be a popular response. Revisit this in a few months I suppose Deletion of 2017 New York City attempted bombing WP:RAPID Wikipedia:Notability 77
5339 13006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Harrison (Californian politician) User:RightCowLeftCoast 04:53, 16 October 2014 (UTC) delete or '''redirect''' to Fremont, California#List of mayors. Although the city has an estimated population of 220k, the subject https://www.google.com/search?as_eq=wikipedia&q=%22Bill+Harrison+%28Californian+politician%29%22&num=50#q=%22Bill+Harrison%22+Fremont+-wikipedia themselves doesn't appear to pass , as few if any non-primary reliable sources give the subject |significant coverage for the subject to be considered independently notable outside of their position in office. Presently the argument for keep appears to center around , that as the subject is the chief executive of a size-able city, that the subject should be considered automatically notable. At the same time, the subject does not hold an elected office of a statewide or national level, and I believe POLOUTCOMES for mayors and city councilmembers makes a presumption that if a city is significant enough, that its chief executive and city councilmembers should be sufficiently notable enough to warrant significant coverage from non-primary sources and thus pass GNG. That being said, I do not see that |yet being created for this subject. Therefore, if there was an embedded list of mayors of Fremont, California, I can easily see this article become a redirect to that list, however at this time I do not see sufficient reliable sources to indicate independent notability for a standalone article at this time. This may change, and when those sources are found this article can be recreated, but not until that time that those sources can be found Deletion of Bill Harrison (Californian politician) WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:POLOUTCOMES||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
5340 20538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leo Ford User:Delicious 18:15, 6 December 2009 (UTC) comment """The search results provided by Benjiboi appear to be, for the most part, passing references. Leo Ford does not appear to meet the guideline. Four references have been added to the article to support a claim that is inaccurate (see '''""""Hand in Glove"""" single cover model not Leo Ford''' discussion on Talk:Leo Ford|talk page""" Deletion of Leo Ford WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5341 19347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lil Henchmen(2nd nomination) User:JohnCD 16:14, 13 April 2009 (UTC) delete """the article is all about his musical ambitions and shows no notability at all; the references are about an incident where he was allegedly assaulted; one of them says """"''none of this has been confirmed by anyone involved''"""" and the other is a year-old report that his mother has filed a civil suit about it. Fails and #NEWS""" Deletion of Lil Henchmen(2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5342 17714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grace O'Malley (film) User:Steve 13:38, 6 March 2008 (UTC) delete The |notability guidelines for future films stipulate that a stand-alone article for a film should not be created until a project enters production. This is for very good, practical reasons. Many factors such as budget issues, scripting issues, and casting issues can interfere with a project well ahead of its intended filming date. This film is merely in development; in accordance with the guideline, the article can be recreated when principal photography is confirmed to have begun Deletion of Grace O'Malley (film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5343 7903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Markoff(2nd nomination) User:Backslash 01:08, 7 July 2009 (UTC) merge I really do doubt whether this bloke will have lasting notability, and the attention afforded to him by the blood-thirsty media outlets was as a result of a fairly standard crime of murder. The media hysteria due to the Craigslist post qualifies him for a mention ''somewhere'', but given the acronyms , and , merging seems like the sensible solution. I would also like to point out that just because you saw him on the news when it happens does note make the AfD about him a 'joke'. Also, charged with more than one crime doesn't make him exempt from . The policy covers people who are only ''notable'' for one event, and his standard robbery charges are not anything that would've resulted in a Wikipedia page. He got attention for the murder, his article was written due to the attention of the murder, not the binding and robbery of the robbery of an escort Deletion of Philip Markoff(2nd nomination) WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BLP1E||WP:BLP||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5344 13976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dust ClothingCO User:Royboycrashfan 06:20, 30 March 2006 (UTC) delete per , , and Deletion of Dust ClothingCO WP:CORP||WP:SPAM||WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Notability 77
5345 9077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teenage Dog Orgy User:Dlohcierekim 00:23, 30 May 2008 (UTC) delete """Not sure this even asserts notability. There are many Google hits for """"Teenage Dog Orgy,"""" yes. Many are for Keyword strings including those words but having nothing to do with the subject. Notability/verifiability is not based on Google count for a string of text. The essential test would be for national tours, records/CD's on a suitable label, scoring well on the charts. I have not located any Google hits that support meeting . I find nothing at Allmusic. Cheers""" Deletion of Teenage Dog Orgy WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
5346 9087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Macaroni soup User:Sticky 23:13, 5 August 2008 (UTC) keep erm, has anyone checked for sources? http://news.google.co.uk/archivesearch?q=%22macaroni+soup%22&btnG=Search&hl=en&um=1 284 google news hits, http://books.google.co.uk/books?q=%22macaroni%20soup%22&hl=en&um=1&sa=N&tab=np 634 on google books, http://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?q=%22macaroni%20soup%22&hl=en&um=1&sa=N&tab=ps 73 on google scholar. We have a lot of stub articles about foods, that doesn't make it , foods are encyclopedic if they've been mentioned in multiple reliable sources Deletion of Macaroni soup WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5347 16587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fernando Obama User:GiantSnowman 17:05, 15 February 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Fernando Obama WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5348 9898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of successful products that spun off of failed commercial products User:Tyrenius 05:55, 10 May 2006 (UTC) comment I think this is an interesting and valid idea that could provide an article. As I understand it |NOR applies to content of articles, not ideas for articles in themselves, and presumably there is a lot of existing information that details connections such as the ones listed. The title could do with being more succinct Deletion of List of successful products that spun off of failed commercial products WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5349 14483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roddy Patterson User:Nfitz 21:26, 11 August 2012 (UTC) keep why are we here? Easily meets and Deletion of Roddy Patterson WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5350 5086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jocelyne Couture-Nowak (5th nomination) User:Gorgan 14:05, 6 December 2007 (UTC) comment Jocelyne Couture-Nowak is a person who came to fame by being shot in the Virginia Tech massacre. At first, this sounds like a clear-cut case of |BIO1E. Unfortunately the waters are muddied by the fact that after death, several media outlets decided to turn her into a hero by publishing stories about her life. Technically, these news stories assert notability according to the |general notability criteria. Some would argue that this is sufficient for inclusion of the article. Others would argue that common sense needs to be applied, and that since this person's only actual claim-to-fame is the Virginia Tech massacre, |BIO1E still applies. &mdash Deletion of Jocelyne Couture-Nowak (5th nomination) WP:BIO1E||WP:N||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
5351 2285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Those Aren't Muskets! User:MelanieN 03:54, 24 February 2013 (UTC) delete I was able to read the article you found, RCLC, and it is indeed a full-length article about this troupe, amounting to significant coverage from an independent reliable source. I used it to add information to the article. Unfortunately I couldn't find any other significant independent coverage, and one such reference is not enough. Maybe a case of . Perhaps the article could be wikified to the author, for expansion if their notability grows Deletion of Those Aren't Muskets! WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
5352 19210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CocoIce User:Oluwa2Chainz 21:36, 7 June 2017 (UTC) delete subject fails Deletion of CocoIce WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5353 7338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DAP Technologies User:Karnesky 04:54, 18 February 2006 (UTC) merge to Roper Industries. This is a subsidary that doesn't alone meet , but is notable in the context of the parent company Deletion of DAP Technologies WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5354 3284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Afelee Valoa User:Klant01 12:21, 17 October 2012 (UTC) keep Article satisfies to . (3. Have played FIFA recognised senior international football or football at the Olympic games.) He participated at the Oceanian Futsal Championship, a football tournament recognised by the FIFA. The winner of this tournament participates at the FIFA Futsal World Cup. Tuvalu is part of the OFC, the football association from Oceania and therefore recognised by FIFA. Article is already a half year on wikipedia if it will not be to the criteria satisfy Article already rather removes Deletion of Afelee Valoa WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
5355 9547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wonmyung Elementary School User:Kudpung 07:19, 13 June 2015 (UTC) comment Notability criteria are guidelines and as such it is pefectly acceptable to interpret them with common sense. However, 'redirect' is an official alternative to deletion that is anchored in ''policy''. Being non-toxic, school articles fall squarely in that area of policy and 'redirect' for non notable mainstream schools has been fully established by consencus through precedent as evidenced by hundreds, if not thousands, of redirected school articles. The oppose votes here, especially those from {{U|Hithladaeus}}, {{U|Joseph2302}}, {{U|Bilorv}} and {{U|Heyyouoverthere}} may be simply due to the fact that they are not aware of the standard practice that is documented at Deletion of Wonmyung Elementary School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5356 3010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Racial Contract User:Mangoe 14:45, 23 October 2017 (UTC) keep though bordering on . It's hard to tell in what we have which parts are Mills's ideas being recounted without citations, and which parts are the musings of the editor. That said, GScholar shows plenty of refs to this book and its ideas Deletion of The Racial Contract WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
5357 8137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hillbrook Anglican School User:Pan 13:28, 11 December 2006 (UTC) comment Hold on there guys. The nominator doesn't really raise a valid reason to delete, but if the school's website is the only non-trivial source that we could use to write a good article on this school, then that ''would'' be a |valid reason to delete. If no other sources on this school can be found, the article should be deleted per Deletion of Hillbrook Anglican School WP:N||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5358 8605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcus Thers Sørensen User:IJA 15:47, 12 November 2014 (UTC) delete He hasn't played in a Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|Fully professional league and he doesn't have any senior international caps either therefore he fails Deletion of Marcus Thers Sørensen WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5359 124 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Anarşist Komünist İnisiyatif """Kullanıcı:dbl2010özgür""" 19:44, 27 Mayıs 2006 (UTC) delete Bknz. Anarşist Komünist İnisiyatifin silinmesi Vikipedi:Vikipedi ne değildir Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5360 9612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 Big Sky Conference Men's Basketball Tournament User:RadioKAOS 23:58, 19 November 2016 (UTC) delete """It is so ridiculous to repeatedly come across articles about events which haven't happened and are therefore completely lacking in substance. |Indiscriminately slapping together content with happenstance sources is one thing. Pushing what's supposed to be an encyclopedia further in the direction of yet another current events site and/or news site is another. Acting as if there's no obligation to create articles about past events where notability and reliable sourcing is well established only makes things worse. What part of """"|Wikipedia is not a newspaper"""" requires further debate""" Deletion of 2017 Big Sky Conference Men's Basketball Tournament WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5361 4516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Command & Conquer: Renegade references User:NASCAR 00:45, 6 October 2007 (UTC) delete per nom - Great example of |original research Deletion of List of Command & Conquer: Renegade references WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5362 16735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Darnell (musician) User:Gab4gab 14:30, 3 April 2017 (UTC) delete Current sources give no indication of notability. Searching found nothing helpful. No significant coverage found in independent reliable sources. I'll reconsider if better sources are found. Fails general & Deletion of John Darnell (musician) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5363 14098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of provinces and states in North America User:Black 00:51, 18 January 2010 (UTC) delete """as a poorly-defined list that is inferior to lists contained in the articles Provinces and territories of Canada, Political divisions of Mexico, and U.S. state. The list identifies its scope as including ''provinces'' and ''states'', yet it includes the three territories of Canada, the Mexico City#Federal District|Distrito Federal, and the District of Columbia. The """"|useful"""" argument is simply not convincing since anyone with the ability to find this list could just as easily search for and find the others""" Deletion of List of provinces and states in North America WP:USEFUL Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5364 20226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Totara LMS User:FuFoFuEd 11:04, 15 June 2011 (UTC) delete Seems to lack independent coverage required by and . Article created by a Deletion of Totara LMS WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Notability 77
5365 18820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swish (Internet slang) User:Mike 01:51, 3 September 2006 (UTC) delete violates Deletion of Swish (Internet slang) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5366 13514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Javad Mirzaev (2nd nomination) User:GiantSnowman 21:09, 14 January 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Javad Mirzaev (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5367 74 [[TSG Öhringen]] (erl.) Benutzer:Wo st 01 NONE delete """die in Artikel enthaltenen Informationen begründen nach #Vereine keinerlei Relevanz. Die sportlichen Erfolge sind nicht ausreichend. Das Argument """"''Kennt jemand, der relevant ist''"""" mag nicht zu überzeugen. Das Training der australischen Fußball-Nationalmannschaft vor und während der WM 2006 macht den Verein nicht relevant. Sonst dürfte jeder Acker, auf dem der FC Bayern München schon mal trainiert hat, mit einem Artikel bedacht werden. Zudem ist nicht klar, ob der Verein überhaupt Eigentümer des Stadions ist. Wenn - rein hypothetisch - die """"Taubenzüchter"""" Eigentümer wären, müssten an sonsten über diese der Artikel geschrieben werden""" Löschung von TSG Öhringen Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
5368 11071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ezra Wiener User:MarcoTolo 03:39, 26 July 2007 (UTC) delete per , . Any reason this wasn't prod'ed as a CSD A7 in the first place Deletion of Ezra Wiener WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5369 6527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicky Clee User:GiantSnowman 23:30, 26 May 2010 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Nicky Clee WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5370 438 [[VDU]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Besserwisserhochdrei NONE delete Wenn jemand eine Begründung dafür haben will, der möge nochmal nachfragen. Vorerst verkneife ich mir die aber, weil ich sonst vielleicht wieder #LK-Disk von heute|gemobbt werde Löschung von VDU Wikipedia:Vandalensperrung Wikipedia:Vandalism 29
5371 1321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thon (river) User:Carlossuarez46 05:15, 21 June 2013 (UTC) keep per ; nominator failed Deletion of Thon (river) WP:GEOLAND||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5372 14251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nada Herman-Witkamp User:Curiocurio 21:02, 23 February 2021 (UTC) delete agree with what's already been said. Doesn't pass Deletion of Nada Herman-Witkamp WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5373 21549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sound-O-Mat (label) User:Esradekan 02:49, 10 August 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per . Searching finds no significant coverage in |reliable, third-party, sources Deletion of Sound-O-Mat (label) WP:CORP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5374 787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UZURV User:Scope 12:50, 24 March 2018 (UTC) comment It would for sure fails the new standard Deletion of UZURV WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5375 19848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Era Tak User:Spiderone 17:22, 5 August 2020 (UTC) delete clear failure of Deletion of Era Tak WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5376 18090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Box Springs, California User:BlackcurrantTea 05:52, 16 January 2021 (UTC) keep The article's been improved significantly since it was nominated. (In other words, per , a shortcut I tend to forget the meaning of within minutes of clicking on it Deletion of Box Springs, California :WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
5377 19651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of Deadpool User:Zxcvbnm 22:43, 9 September 2020 (UTC) delete Per TTN. ing with countless clickbait articles is not enough to turn trivial mentions into significant discussion of Deadpool's alternate versions. It's hard to imagine a circumstance in which alternate versions of a character merit an entirely separate article and cannot be mentioned in the article of that character Deletion of Alternative versions of Deadpool WP:REFBOMB Wikipedia:Citation overkill 60
5378 13928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sidney Sanabria User:Sander 06:22, 12 April 2016 (UTC) keep Meets (Competed at Worlds) I Expanded the article Deletion of Sidney Sanabria WP:NSPORTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5379 11223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Strike off Fighting Championships User:Narutolovehinata5 00:17, 11 September 2015 (UTC) comment It appears that the article has already been speedily deleted multiple times. Should this AfD be closed as delete, I recommend that the title be |salted Deletion of Strike off Fighting Championships WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
5380 13620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert G. Abboud User:SportingFlyer 23:59, 21 June 2020 (UTC) delete The sourcing of the article is pretty terrible. He fails for being a small suburban mayor and an unelected candidate for higher office and appears to fail as well Deletion of Robert G. Abboud WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5381 4180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of diplomatic missions in Hanoi User:Aaronw 22:27, 8 August 2008 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is a yellow pages or directory Deletion of List of diplomatic missions in Hanoi WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5382 21091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Safiya Nygaard (2nd nomination) User:Robert 16:28, 28 December 2017 (UTC) comment It looks like |G4 to me, but I tried to tag it and the nomination was removed Deletion of Safiya Nygaard (2nd nomination) WP:G4 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5383 17739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miriam Schmierer User:Newshunter12 01:18, 20 November 2018 (UTC) delete """This article blatantly fails , , and . There is no policy that the """"oldest x"""" is notable and this article is packed with longevity fancruft like administrative changes in her lifetime and all her various moves. Furthermore, she does not inherit per the notability of Australia's shift from colony to country just because she was a citizen of both entities. And as the article itself says, """"Her life was very ordinary until she reached the age of 110."""" Enough said. She belongs on a list, nothing more""" Deletion of Miriam Schmierer WP:GNG||WP:BIO1E||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:NOPAGE||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
5384 945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Masoud Minaei User:Papaursa 19:36, 23 April 2017 (UTC) delete He doesn't meet the notability criteria for kickboxers and some routine sports reporting isn't sufficient to meet Deletion of Masoud Minaei WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5385 18883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helen Berggruen (artist) User:AllyD 22:56, 23 May 2011 (UTC) delete The main reference is to an article largely relating to her art collector father. Although the external link gives a reasonably long exhibition list, neither there or in Google Book search is there clear evidence of |notability in her own right Deletion of Helen Berggruen (artist) :WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
5386 19109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Railroad nicknames User:Reywas92 21:50, 2 June 2019 (UTC) delete per and ; in particular, this is a near-perfect example of {{tq|'''simple listings''' without context information}} that do not pertain to a clear, specific topic. As there are potentially thousands of railroads that could be considered, and numerous names can be proposed for each, there is no way to determine what qualifies for such a list regardless of the availability of sources. Furthermore, some sources used in the article are also indiscriminate and unreliable (per Deletion of Railroad nicknames WP:NOTDIR||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5387 3108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanaz Alasti User:Green 08:49, 9 December 2012 (UTC) delete The subject doesn't appear to pass any criteria listed in or (or ). That leaves us with and the only independent reliable sources are the ones immediately above posted by IP 72.86.39.103 (New Yorker and Examiner mainly). My issue here is this is an academic and an author, yet can't meet those notability guidelines. We are trying to squeak an academic author under the GNG wire with a few sources that in total are not terribly strong. I couldn't even tell you why they are notable other than being from Iran and having a PhD (the book itself doesn't have multiple ''independent'' reviews per ). Others above have said she is notable for her views on the Death Penalty, or her controversial views (unstated what), but none of the provided sources really get into that, so it can't be verified. She seems to be a ''visible'' professional, and may be notable for Wikipedia someday, but doesn't seem to be there today, based on the available sources Deletion of Sanaz Alasti WP:AUTHOR||WP:ACADEMIC||WP:ANYBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5388 1791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Hippocratic Registry User:Power 12:21, 18 February 2009 (UTC) comment The real issue here, is that some doctors don't like the doctors' general Charter, but wish to revert to the original Hippocratic Oath, which inter alia, does not allow assisted suicide or abortion. These are the life and death issues (literally) at stake here. The article is not specific and blunt enough on this, I suspect due to issues. Bottom line is though, that the topic is important, existential, relevant - in short, encyclopaedic - and so is articles on national organizations of physicians that trumphet pro/con such principles . Keep or delete votes here, will mostly be based on a perception if guidelines are some sort of policy, of if they merely are ''guidelines'', that need not rigorously be complied with Deletion of American Hippocratic Registry WP:COI||WP:N Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
5389 15938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Between the Devil and the Sea User:Gongshow 01:36, 3 June 2011 (UTC) keep Between the Allmusic write-up and these reviews http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/10660-between-the-devil-and-the-sea-ep/http://www.qromag.com/reviews/album_reviews/oh_no!_oh_my!_:_between_the_devil_and_the_sea_ep/, there appears to be enough significant coverage for this EP to pass Deletion of Between the Devil and the Sea WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5390 2068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Margot Rose User:MichaelQSchmidt 10:44, 15 February 2010 (UTC) keep per 30-year career in film and television adequately meeting http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0741558/filmoyear. Yes, the article could use cleanup, expansion and further sourcing, but surmountable issues are no reason to delete Deletion of Margot Rose WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5391 11007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Concurrency (road) User:Hmich176 10:26, 30 January 2014 (UTC) keep """per Imzadi1979. Appropriate source material exists. The article is not """"|original research plain and simple""" Deletion of Concurrency (road) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5392 4057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gch government colleges hostel User:Schuym1 23:33, 6 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Gch government colleges hostel WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5393 11551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kent RO Systems User:Atlantic306 15:15, 13 July 2017 (UTC) keep as it is a public company with a 40% market share, has some reliable sources in the article but adding more would help with Deletion of Kent RO Systems WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5394 1650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of commercial failures in computer and video gaming User:Koffieyahoo 00:57, 10 August 2006 (UTC) delete """as """"commercial failure"""" has written |original research all over it""" Deletion of List of commercial failures in computer and video gaming WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5395 12244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/You didn't build that User:Cyclopia 16:34, 13 November 2012 (UTC) comment """to answer them in one place) I'd like to notice that the !votes above by M0rphzone, AgnosticAphid, KillerChihuahua and Holyfield1998 are not based in any real policy or guideline, despite their linking of and the like. NOTNEWS makes sense in the context of very routine news coverage, but the fallout of this remark went well beyond that. http://www.salon.com/2012/11/12/obamas_2012_tax_mandate/singleton/ It is still being cited. It Also, arguments like """"not encyclopedic"""" are known to be |fallacious""" Deletion of You didn't build that WP:NOTNEWS||WP:UNENCYC Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5396 13350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George McConnell Davison User:Bearian 21:53, 11 July 2013 (UTC) delete Touting someone as local is essentially stating that someone fails . He may be an entreprenuer, and creative, and a genius, and a really nice guy, but I can't see how he's anything more than a |run of the mill businessman Deletion of George McConnell Davison WP:GNG||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5397 9228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Burke (American football) User:Paulmcdonald 06:18, 12 January 2013 (UTC) delete does not appear to pass or any other notability measure I can find. Would change my position if information surfaces Deletion of Paul Burke (American football) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5398 668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Morgane Polanski User:TJRC 01:55, 29 February 2020 (UTC) keep I'm seeing coverage in https://www.wmagazine.com/story/morgane-polanski-marc-jacobs-spring-2016/ W Magazine, https://www.harpersbazaar.com/culture/features/a10229/morgane-polanski-0415/ Harpers Bazaar (blog, but one meeting ) and the UK https://www.telegraph.co.uk/women/life/morgane-polanski-i-would-never-change-my-fathers-name/ Telegraph. It is admittedly challenging to use a search engine to find material about her that is not primarily about her fugitive father, but it does seem to be out there if one takes the time to sift Deletion of Morgane Polanski WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5399 10894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Schafer House User:Dlabtot 21:17, 23 September 2007 (UTC) delete does not meet otability|notability criteria. Also, the article also fails to assert that the subject of the article is important or significant Deletion of Schafer House WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5400 4126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy Reyes User:Fenix 08:48, 13 October 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Andy Reyes WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5401 3775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oldest Language User:Isotope23 20:07, 21 February 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Oldest Language WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5402 3507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marline Barberena User:Otr500 13:30, 17 September 2016 (UTC) merge """Come on people. She is not """"independently"""" Wikipedia:Notability|notable and everyone on this page knows this or will directly. She won one title and that is why we have policy about this. It is not just about the fact that there are """"sources"""". The only way we can justify keeping a one time national winner of one event is to |ignore all the rules. The purpose of that """"rule"""" is so there are not undue restrictions, that hamper improvements to Wikipedia, and not to allow articles that will very likely forever be a stub biography article, about a person that won one title. This does not improve Wikipedia. '''Note''': If we do consider """"source"""" There are three references listed. #1)- Please look at first one used in the article. I used a translator but the title appears to be ''Miss Nicaragua statement'' and concerns """"Miss Nastassja Bolivar"""" and mentions """"Mrs. Olga Isabel Cifuentes"""" and """"Miss Nicaragua 2014"""", with nothing I could find about the subject. #2)- The second reference is a primary source of """"Beauty Pageant News"""", and #3)- The third is a Spanish Wikipedia entry that is not a reference. This means there is one primary source related to the one event. This discussion is WP:!VOTE|not a vote count but closure is to be based on the merits of the discussion, reasoning, and olicies and guidelines. In light of this evidence this is clearly a redirect unless someone can offer more substantial reasoning""" Deletion of Marline Barberena WP:IGNORE||WP:P Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
5403 13574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barbara Vernon User:Meerkate 03:10, 3 December 2008 (UTC) keep """I don't believe that Google News is now the hurdle that people have to overcome to be included in WP. It is but one indicator of notability. The question is does it fail ? While Omarcheesboro asserts it, this editor provides no evidence of this. Vernon is clearly notable enough to be on ABC PM, Australia's most respected current affairs program. They don't interview just anyone. She is obviously at the forefront of the maternity debate in Australia as evidenced by her being appointed to the Health Minister Nicola Roxon's high level Ministerial advisory group. Surely if someone is after information about Vernon because of her appointment, WP is a good place to come. I would have also thought that Vernon meets the requirement of: """"has made a widely recognized contribution that is part of the enduring historical record in his or her specific field."""" Even if it is such a narrow field as birth politics and midwifery. She was apparently the lead author of the """"National Maternity Action Plan"""" which has now led to the Australian Government to do the National Maternity Services Review. I will attempt to find other references over the next week""" Deletion of Barbara Vernon WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5404 9072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Northern Independence Party (2nd nomination) User:4meter4 15:23, 26 March 2021 (UTC) keep With coverage in ''The Independent'', a major paper with international readership, and several regional papers, the organization would appear to meet the notability requirements at and . While canvasing is concerning, equally concerning is the willingness of the nominator and those crying deletion to ignore a clear policy based rationale for keeping the article. With sources at this level, there is no policy based rationale for deletion Deletion of Northern Independence Party (2nd nomination) WP:ORG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
5405 17337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of most-printed books User:Uzma 06:27, 14 July 2012 (UTC) keep per and Colonel Warden above. The list may be a valuable information source. Also, they give out the Bible free so this seems like a good list to complement, rather than contradict, the book profits list mentioned in the nom. Disputes over which reliable sources to use can be worked out on the article talk page. The two lists have started to diverge becuse they are two different lists Deletion of List of most-printed books WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
5406 593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dark Iris User:Pdcook 16:54, 7 May 2010 (UTC) delete I don't see how this band passes . Internet searches seem to bring up mostly social networking sites, but certainly no coverage in RS Deletion of Dark Iris WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
5407 10656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iván Hernández Carrillo User:Edison 03:11, 3 November 2009 (UTC) delete per . Political prisoners are not inherently notable Deletion of Iván Hernández Carrillo WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
5408 7610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meena Wong User:Tchaliburton 20:38, 22 September 2014 (UTC) keep She has significant coverage which makes her notable per . These are just a handful of the recent pieces covering her: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/meena-wong-says-vancouver-needs-absentee-homeowners-fee-1.2774178 1, http://www.scmp.com/news/world/article/1587719/meena-wong-launches-bid-become-vancouvers-first-chinese-mayor?page=all 2, http://rabble.ca/blogs/bloggers/michael-stewart/2014/09/meena-wong-offers-strong-alternative-to-vancouvers-blancmange 3, http://www.straight.com/news/721956/tim-louis-suggests-cope-mayoral-hopeful-meena-wong-could-boost-voter-turnout 4, http://metronews.ca/news/vancouver/1148648/cope-nominates-meena-wong-as-vancouver-mayoral-candidate/ 5, http://metronews.ca/news/vancouver/1148648/cope-nominates-meena-wong-as-vancouver-mayoral-candidate/ 6. Her likelihood of winning has nothing to do with . The coverage she has received makes her notable per se Deletion of Meena Wong WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5409 20383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dorothy Wang User:Piotrus 02:31, 15 November 2016 (UTC) merge Fails (requirement of multiple roles). There is the expected celebrity coverage, which does amount to multiple sources, however. I'd suggest merging with the main show's article, or with a List of Rich Kids of Beverly Hills participants or such, since it can be argued she falls into - she is known for that single minor celebrity role, and that's a bit too little for stand-alone article Deletion of Dorothy Wang WP:NACTOR||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5410 4724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Professional wrestling attacks User:Yukichigai 22:31, 18 January 2007 (UTC) keep """The nominator is blissfully ignoring the section of on primary sources, specifically for works of |fiction. (Or works of kayfabe if you prefer) All of these articles meet at levels anywhere from """"just barely"""" to """"with flying colors"""", as each can be cited to various primary sources, e.g. the specific wrestling event(s) in which the move appeared. Some could use more overt citations, but remember that """"inline"""" citations (e.g. """"used by wrestler X in WrestlingEvent Y on wrestler Z"""") qualify. Also take a look at Y:V%26A#Verifiability: Citing the Primary Source|my repeatedly used arguments on citing fiction from the primary source. As to , I agree that ''some'' articles contain ''some'' OR content, but this is neither a majority of the articles nor a majority of their content. This at most warrants a cleanup. Finally, we come to : every one of these moves is or has been a """"signature"""" move by more than one major, mainstream wrestler. Notability is therefore asserted by the repeated use of the move by prominent figures in wrestling media. -- |Y'''|""" Deletion of Professional wrestling attacks WP:RS||WP:FICT||WP:V||WP:OR||WP:N||WP:IKNOWBEST Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5411 6111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wintermoon User:W 05:26, 15 November 2005 (UTC) delete not a notable band anyway (fails usic for example), as far as I can tell Deletion of Wintermoon WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
5412 5865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stone Court User:Chris 11:47, 12 December 2009 (UTC) delete or '''Merge'''. Clear Deletion of Stone Court WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5413 7679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gigi Mon Mathew User:KleenupKrew 10:17, 26 April 2008 (UTC) delete winning a contest, lottery, etc. does not establish notability. Deletion of Gigi Mon Mathew WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
5414 12548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Carter (judge) User:Northamerica1000 22:01, 17 December 2016 (UTC) keep Per a review of sources presently in the article, the subject meets Deletion of Mary Carter (judge) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5415 3913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/6yd User:Kuru 22:56, 21 May 2006 (UTC) delete not really close to , one year old front for google ads. Alexa in the 4m+ range and almost zero external references. Why was this de-prodded Deletion of 6yd WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
5416 17034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/People Staring at Computers User:TheSandDoctor 06:56, 7 July 2017 (UTC) delete """with references currently there, it does not pass |GNG. Only """"interesting"""" reference is the BBC article and within that article, the art project is not even the main focus in any notable way (per the above""" Deletion of People Staring at Computers WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5417 10648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Azhar Sulfikar User:onel5969 03:30, 17 September 2015 (UTC) delete fails ... searches turned little other than a YouTube hit Deletion of Azhar Sulfikar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5418 12414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KMLE Medical Dictionary User:Vegaswikian 00:17, 24 April 2008 (UTC) delete Does not meet , , or . Probably could be a speedy as spam Deletion of KMLE Medical Dictionary WP:N||WP:WEB||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5419 17354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/USS Kentucky (BB-66) User:The 23:57, 26 July 2012 (UTC) keep """Both of these ships had their keels laid and were partially completed before cancellation. In cases such as the {{sclass|Montana|battleship}}s, where none of the ships which had names assigned to them were ever laid down, merging and redirecting the individual ships to the class article makes sense. In cases where construction was actually done, however, the ships should retain individual articles. Also, the """"shifting notability standards"""" argument here is a bit of a red herring; while the standards considered for the notability of ships that don't otherwise meet the GNG might be stricter, still applies otherwise, and the subjects of both of these articles clearly meet the GNG""" Deletion of USS Kentucky (BB-66) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5420 20510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tallest buildings in Lucknow User:Northamerica1000 19:07, 25 August 2012 (UTC) keep per . Topic notability is based upon the availability of sources, and not whether or not sources are present in articles. There's also significant precedent for these types of articles on Wikipedia. For starters, see http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?search=list+of+tallest+building&title=Special%3ASearch&fulltext=1 this search Deletion of List of tallest buildings in Lucknow WP:NRVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5421 2698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cort Stevens User:Joe 00:36, 5 December 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |pornographic actor Deletion of Cort Stevens WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5422 1742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David E. Stern User:Bhaktivinode 12:47, 28 March 2008 (UTC) comment The article has been updated to include 2 additional references that are |reliable sources, per discussion above. Thanks Deletion of David E. Stern WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5423 10052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlson Gymnasium User:JTSchreiber 00:56, 3 January 2011 (UTC) delete per reasons given by Snottywong. I don't think it would be good to merge this content, because that would give this building |undue weight within the CU Boulder article. I don't think that the Carlson Gymnasium has the significance of the other buildings currently listed. If the Carlson Gymnasium were added, wouldn't most academic buildings need to be added for balance? Wouldn't that give undue weight to the campus section of the CU Boulder article Deletion of Carlson Gymnasium WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
5424 17298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kativasthi User:MelanieN 19:21, 20 July 2014 (UTC) delete per . The article is unreferenced and consists of a single sentence. Could be redirected to :Ayurveda but is not currently mentioned at that article. I would not recommend transwiki to Wiktionary because the definition is unsupported and the spelling is in doubt Deletion of Kativasthi :WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
5425 8306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Warlock (film) User:Shearonink 02:11, 29 December 2011 (UTC) delete Fulfills none of the parameters at otability (films). Also please see Wikipedia talk:Articles for creation/The Warlock (Film) created by same user, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Fisaa7 Fisaa7 within minutes after creating this article Deletion of The Warlock (film) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5426 10839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mick McCleery User:LACaliNYC 21:18, 3 February 2019 (UTC) delete Clearly fails the and Deletion of Mick McCleery WP:GNG||WP:FILMMAKER Wikipedia:Notability 77
5427 4879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judaism and bus stops User:Jbtscott 14:08, 6 October 2010 (UTC) delete total |synthesis Deletion of Judaism and bus stops WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
5428 13613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/See What a Fool I've Been User:Richard3120 03:14, 15 February 2021 (UTC) merge probably to Seven Seas of Rhye, but ''Queen II'' is also an acceptable possibility. Fails : unremarkable single B-side, eventually added as a bonus track to a CD reissue almost two decades after its original appearance. As with other articles recently websites by a now blocked sock, this is mostly sourced to fan sites and other non-RS sites Deletion of See What a Fool I've Been WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5429 1247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Chernyakhovsky User:Guillaume2303 09:03, 12 April 2012 (UTC) delete Not an A7 (given the asteroid), but otherwise way too soon. Misses and by a mile Deletion of Alexander Chernyakhovsky WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5430 4128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gersi Xhuti User:Sir 01:27, 2 January 2011 (UTC) delete He's quite clearly not-notable. The Canadian Soccer League is not fully pro, and he has not received sufficient coverage to meet Deletion of Gersi Xhuti WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5431 4108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kleargear (2nd nomination) User:TJRC 00:23, 8 July 2014 (UTC) keep and '''rename'''. The company is not notable, but the case is. It's had substantial coverage beyond the threshold in http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-12-18/a-company-is-sued-over-its-no-bad-reviews-clause Business week, http://techcrunch.com/2013/11/18/kleargear-goes-into-social-media-lockdown-after-it-charges-customers-for-posting-bad-reviews/ Techdirt, and non-local news providers (for example, http://www.khou.com/news/KlearGear-fines-Texas-couple-35K-for-posting-negative-review-232421601.html Houston and http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2013/12/18/retailer-that-fined-couple-3500-for-negative-review-hit-with-lawsuit US News and World Report), as well as the source cited by SBaker43, above. Move to :Palmer v. Kleargear.com to make the article name conform to the topic and content Deletion of Kleargear (2nd nomination) WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5432 16586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/To Market, to Market (M*A*S*H) User:Collectonian 04:42, 15 May 2009 (UTC) delete Unnotable episode of the series with nothing but a very brief episode summary that seems an appropriate length. Fails and . Per Wp:MOS-TV, numerous other episode AfDs, and general consensus regarding individual episode articles. Unlikely search term, so redirect unnecessary Deletion of To Market, to Market (M*A*S*H) WP:N||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5433 21640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WhatIsJoppa.com User:75 NONE keep """The podcast was a top 5 or so on iTunes at one point, a google search for """"what is joppa"""" actually returns 5,300 not 37 hits (are you blind?), and articles about the group have been published or are scheduled to be published as cited by Quolnok. The spirit and criteria of is satisfied in my eyes.; lets focus on real violators. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of WhatIsJoppa.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
5434 4582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Azeem Ward User:Kinu 20:23, 15 May 2015 (UTC) delete Not enough sourcing to meet or to justify the existence of a . As stated by multiple commenters above, and 1E are appropriate essays here. also applies as well; notability is not temporary, and there is no evidence that this is anything but random news Deletion of Azeem Ward WP:ANYBIO||WP:BLP||WP:15MOF||WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5435 10873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diary of a Bad Man (2nd nomination) User:Frankie 17:40, 26 October 2012 (UTC) merge to Humza Arshad. I took part of Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2011 August 4|the first DRV, and while participation was low the outcome was to allow recreation of Humza Arshad, which appears to have been recreated and subsequently deleted a few times since. I cannot comment on the content of those versions regarding A3, but deletion per G4 was not warranted anymore, and A7 seems kind of moot considering the amount of community discussion available. The links I had found are dead now (I could try looking for them again, but IIRC they were an interview by BBC Asia and a couple of local articles), but http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-14222093 this one works, and adding the http://www.guardian.co.uk/culture/shortcuts/2012/jun/10/diary-of-a-badman two http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/06/27/humza-arshad-the-badman-of-youtube_n_1597536.html sources from the second DRV I still think that is sufficiently met Deletion of Diary of a Bad Man (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5436 290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jill-Lyn Euto NONE NONE delete per and Deletion of Jill-Lyn Euto WP:NOTMEMORIAL||WP:VICTIM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5437 18424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticisms of medicine (2nd nomination) User:RexxS 20:00, 27 May 2018 (UTC) delete The article is simply an essay promoting a fringe POV, fleshed out with disparate sources. Any particular source or sentence could be justified as criticism of a relevant aspect of medicine, but no reliable source has proposed the same thesis as this article. The way it is assembled is tantamount to Deletion of Criticisms of medicine (2nd nomination) WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
5438 3096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony J. Hilder (2nd nomination) User:RebeccaGreen 02:29, 3 February 2019 (UTC) keep I have not looked at the article or most of the content above, but from the sources given by 3 editors immediately above, it appears that there is significant and sustained coverage in independent, reliable sources, so he meets . It seems that part of the coverage is for his music industry work, and part for his conspiracy views, but it's not necessary for him to meet specific notability criteria when there is sufficient overall for him to meet . If the article needs improving, that is another issue (and, from the comments made above, seems to be controversial in itself Deletion of Anthony J. Hilder (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5439 12086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cary Barlowe (2nd nomination) User:Jorgath 17:29, 10 May 2012 (UTC) merge to American Honey (although I'm open to other merge-target suggestions). All of his claims to be notable in his own right seem to go against . My !vote is weak, though - if someone finds sources that suggest more notability, I'm open to change Deletion of Cary Barlowe (2nd nomination) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5440 9184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eila Kaarresalo-Kasari User:Carlossuarez46 21:38, 26 January 2009 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Eila Kaarresalo-Kasari WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
5441 8212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The stunners User:TenPoundHammer 23:29, 9 September 2008 (UTC) delete Utterly fails . May not meet A7 given the marginal notability of each individual member Deletion of The stunners WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5442 21764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Open Rails User:WikiDan61 14:16, 14 July 2010 (UTC) comment The references added are to forums, not to |reliable sources Deletion of Open Rails WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5443 6259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Human Factors Lab User:Yilloslime 18:28, 10 February 2010 (UTC) delete """Fails . Their releases are not on """"one of the more important indie labels"""", and no other criteria are fulfilled""" Deletion of Human Factors Lab WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5444 7063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amsterdam Magazine (2nd nomination) User:The 00:58, 16 August 2012 (UTC) comment The infusion of SPAs into this issue, attacking Guillaume, |smells |funny. It's not the Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jarred Land|first time Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bambi Magazine|that's happened, too Deletion of Amsterdam Magazine (2nd nomination) WP:MEAT||WP:SOCK Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
5445 21941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gwenyth Hood User:Jeepday 15:07, 27 January 2007 (UTC) delete """Google = Results 21 - 24 of about 31 for """"Gwenyth E. Hood"""". The search results support the two short sentences about the author. The rest of the article is about one of the books. I believe it fails Signed""" Deletion of Gwenyth Hood WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5446 3455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeremy Bieber User:DJAMP4444 18:59, 15 June 2014 (UTC) delete may I ask why this article was not proposed for deletion in accordance with PROD Deletion of Jeremy Bieber WP: BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
5447 17213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Barker User:Aaron 16:30, 18 October 2006 (UTC) delete per all above, and because article violates both and http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Lisa_Barker&action=history Deletion of Lisa Barker WP:VAIN||WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
5448 2884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liu Zhe User:Thomas 18:25, 14 November 2017 (UTC) comment """It's interesting to see that everyone who has !voted """"keep"""" here seems to feel that an '''essay''' on ''WikiProject:Military History'' (claiming that it says that all one to four star generals/admirals, past ''and'' present, around the world, no matter what their job is, are notable enough to have a stand-alone article) carries more weight than a Wikipedia guideline (; since the subject fails , unless someone proficient in Chinese can come up with something better than the pressreleases in the article...). Especially since the essay in question is on a project about military ''history'', refers to people in the past tense (was awarded, held a rank, served as, etc), and makes no mention whatsoever about it also applying to modern day military """"civil servants"""", i.e. one star generals/admirals who have held no higher offices and have no meritorius service in wars to list in their CVs. - '''Tom''' | """ Deletion of Liu Zhe WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5449 21569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Thomas (basketball) User:Bagumba 23:20, 11 June 2012 (UTC) delete Fails with no significant coverage in multiple independent sources Deletion of Ben Thomas (basketball) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5450 6748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benson (comic strip) User:Politepunk 14:27, 6 May 2006 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not for advertising one's website Deletion of Benson (comic strip) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5451 4767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bobby Tamkin User:Harlowraman 23:32, 8 August 2007 (UTC) delete does not seem to meet and Deletion of Bobby Tamkin WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
5452 21490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucid dreaming in popular culture User:Haemo 04:04, 15 July 2007 (UTC) delete """hey, it's another honest one; """"This is a list of cultural references made about the phenomenon Lucid dreaming."""" In other words, an |indiscriminate collection of |trivia""" Deletion of Lucid dreaming in popular culture WP:IINFO||WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5453 16051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slavior User:Schuym1 01:49, 13 November 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Slavior WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5454 4536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Planetary Bill of Rights Project User:Alba 13:15, 24 March 2006 (UTC) delete nn . This guy ''does'' know about the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, doesn't he Deletion of The Planetary Bill of Rights Project WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5455 15177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conor Benn User:Naue7 00:09, 12 September 2016 (UTC) keep as meets as mentioned above. More than one of the above sources mentions he has a major endorsement deal with Reebok and is also a brand ambassador for them Deletion of Conor Benn WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5456 19922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanner Park User:FloridaArmy 02:29, 3 February 2018 (UTC) keep abundant coverage in reliable independent sources. Nom is reminded to please follow Deletion of Tanner Park WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
5457 16207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mubarak Al Bloushi User:GiantSnowman 09:03, 12 August 2009 (UTC) delete fails as he has only played in a semi-professional league; also fails Deletion of Mubarak Al Bloushi WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5458 19560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dhruba Joetirmoya Gope User:Coolabahapple 02:10, 4 April 2020 (UTC) comment """this afd looks like it may be heading for a """"delete"""" but i note that Gope has received the Bangladesh Police#Organisation|Bangladesh Police Medal (Service) which could go towards as only https://tbsnews.net/bangladesh/police-awards-2020-number-medallists-decreases-one-third 30 (""""Police awards 2020: The number of medallists decreases to one-third"""") to https://risingbd.com/english/349-cops-get-awards-for-best-service/59361 100 (""""349 cops get awards for best service"""") are issued each year? other editors' thoughts please""" Deletion of Dhruba Joetirmoya Gope WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5459 9105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guitar in popular culture User:Blueboy96 13:08, 13 July 2007 (UTC) delete Pity there isn't a speedy for this. Nah, I take that back--a guitar in a movie is so duh-huh that you might--and let me emphasize, MIGHT--nuke this as a G1 or G3. In any case, I think it's |snowing outside Deletion of Guitar in popular culture WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
5460 17676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sebastian Sidi User:Brewcrewer 07:55, 23 February 2008 (UTC) delete No reliable sources for the article that in any case doesn't satisfy Deletion of Sebastian Sidi WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5461 4441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bridget Murphy Kennedy User:Armbrust 18:09, 26 September 2010 (UTC) delete per |A7, there is no indication of notability. Being a relative of notable persons does not make her notable per Deletion of Bridget Murphy Kennedy WP:A7||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5462 12771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Art (Law & Order: Criminal Intent) User:Claritas 16:45, 30 June 2010 (UTC) delete fails and . No significant coverage, and we can't just ''presume'' that significant coverage exists. If any editor wants to work on it, we could send it over to the article incubator or userfy it Deletion of Art (Law & Order: Criminal Intent) WP:GNG||WP:NRVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5463 21551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Kratman User:Girth 12:39, 22 July 2019 (UTC) comment Whatever it is, this isn't a speedy keep, regardless of who started the AfD. The article is indeed poorly sourced, and it's not immediately clear that the author meets or . I'm on mobile so haven't done a proper search for better sources, but this discussion needs to run its course Deletion of Tom Kratman WP:GNG||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5464 14040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/River Coruisk User:Arxiloxos 01:14, 15 April 2013 (UTC) keep per above and per , but the references I saw all refer to this as River Scavaig; should the article be moved/renamed Deletion of River Coruisk WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5465 198 [[Szenesprache]] (erledigt, weitergeleitet) Benutzer:Wiska Bodo NONE keep Satzbau vereinfacht, Liste nach Heroin verschoben und bei der Gelegenheit dort etwas sauberer gelgliedert. Der Artikel ist nicht der Brüller, aber nichts das unsere mit Bezug auf Wikipedia:Was_Wikipedia_nicht_ist ausschließt Löschung von Szenesprache Wikipedia:Löschregeln Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5466 15281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Onward Oregon User:E 09:36, 17 October 2017 (UTC) delete Took a swing at sourcing it; struck out. Page created in 2008, but has had no content added since; rarely visited. If anyone finds , feel free to ping me Deletion of Onward Oregon WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
5467 5674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chandrin Fernando User:Pharaoh 14:58, 6 October 2017 (UTC) delete per nom fails and Deletion of Chandrin Fernando WP:NBUSINESSPEOPLE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5468 16692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Efrat Shvily User:Mduvekot 12:14, 12 July 2016 (UTC) comment Works in the permanent collection of several museum is not the only criterion in . The Venice Biennale is a very significant temporary exhibition, and participation would be covered by 4b Deletion of Efrat Shvily WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
5469 8679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 Russian military intervention in Ukraine User:My 17:23, 11 August 2014 (UTC) comment Deletion of this page https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Russian_invasion_of_Crimea was discussed before and decided to keep. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:2014_Russian_military_intervention_in_Ukraine&diff=620666989&oldid=620244257 This is also anvass|a matter of concern Deletion of 2014 Russian military intervention in Ukraine WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
5470 12816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cablinasian User:Corpx 18:23, 16 July 2007 (UTC) delete per or a redirect would work Deletion of Cablinasian WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
5471 9357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Akoh User:MurderByDeadcopy 20:19, 18 December 2015 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Jeff Akoh WP:WINNEROUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5472 19711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cameron Lindsay User:Mattythewhite 20:18, 8 May 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Cameron Lindsay WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5473 11718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Northeast Regional Library User:Stormtracker94 22:02, 20 December 2007 (UTC) delete Nn library, fails Deletion of Northeast Regional Library WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5474 537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National team appearances in the UEFA Women's Championship User:Fenix 09:33, 16 February 2013 (UTC) delete as clear |Stat Attack. Besides, isn't all this information available in other articles and has just been combined here in a series of tables, the selection of whch seems to be entirely arbitrary and therefore unencyclopaedic Deletion of National team appearances in the UEFA Women's Championship WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5475 21247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kresten Bjerg User:Jbhunley 22:49, 28 November 2015 (UTC) delete Not enough coverage in |independent, |reliable sources to |verify or |sustian article. Fails |Wikipedia's General Notability Guidelines, and . References are to material written by him not about him. His work does not seem to be considered significant by his peers, GScholar reports citation rates in the single and low double digits for his works in a field where much higher citation rates are the norm for significant works. There may be press on him in Danish but a quick search on google.dk did not turn up anything I could identify using machine translation Deletion of Kresten Bjerg WP:IS||WP:RS||WP:V||WP:NRV||WP:GNG||WP:BASIC||WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5476 4053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mobility Network Laboratory User:Reaper 20:04, 18 January 2011 (UTC) delete Fails the |general notability guideline Deletion of Mobility Network Laboratory WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5477 6563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suzy Kassem (2nd nomination) User:Meters 21:55, 23 February 2016 (UTC) delete Fails , and does not meet notability standards as an author, filmmaker or any of the other creative professionals. Article creator now indef'ed Deletion of Suzy Kassem (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5478 16262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DPG Unit User:Addhoc 18:14, 22 January 2007 (UTC) delete would even support a speedy. Completely fails and Deletion of DPG Unit WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
5479 12978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islamophobia Watch User:Itaqallah 22:52, 4 January 2008 (UTC) comment there appears to be at least two reliable sources discussing the website to a significant extent. I'm sure that suffices the criteria mentioned in Deletion of Islamophobia Watch WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
5480 124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Media Effects on Social Behavior User:Stuartyeates 09:14, 14 November 2011 (UTC) delete as Deletion of Media Effects on Social Behavior WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5481 3215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mitchell Bailey User:Bearian 00:48, 1 October 2017 (UTC) delete based on the analysis by nom and the well-respected Canadian {{U|Bearcat}}. This article is barely more than |spam Deletion of Mitchell Bailey WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
5482 13982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/San Antonio mayoral election, 2019 User:Robert 00:45, 24 November 2018 (UTC) keep with a backup option to '''Draftify''' if not retained. As noted above, this is an event that is almost certain to occur, and published pre-discussion is not |crystal-balling. The election is only six months away. It is more immediate than published pre-discussion of November 2019 and November 2020 elections Deletion of San Antonio mayoral election, 2019 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5483 5690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adventure World Warsaw User:Northamerica1000 11:49, 12 April 2013 (UTC) keep Meets Wikipedia's threshold of |notability. Source examples: http://www.wbj.pl/article-55409-poland-set-for-8364400-million-theme-park.html, http://www.deluxe.hu/elmenypark-vidampark-lengyelorszag/20110722, http://www.pb.pl/2460534,18143,rozrywkowy-raj-wyrosnie-w-grodzisku Deletion of Adventure World Warsaw WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5484 16486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Treggings User:FOARP 18:30, 1 December 2019 (UTC) keep Per , This subject is annoying but notable, see the following refs: https://nypost.com/2018/05/22/grown-ass-women-have-no-business-wearing-treggings/ 1 https://www.elle.de/treggings-shoppen 2 https://www.stilo.es/moda/trend-alert-treggings 3 Deletion of Treggings WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
5485 2673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergio Sartorelli User:Colonel 13:33, 31 December 2009 (UTC) keep The nomination fails as there are clearly other sources for this notable designer. I have performed some cleanup on the article and added another source Deletion of Sergio Sartorelli WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
5486 14380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Macaroni soup User:PeterSymonds 09:23, 6 August 2008 (UTC) keep The |reliable sources provided, a source from 1819 and a page in the New York Times, is a testament to the subject's notability. Passes and Deletion of Macaroni soup WP:RS||WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5487 6164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laurel Schwulst User:Lcoombs 02:44, 16 September 2020 (UTC) keep Schwulst's meets reative. Per item 1, Schwulst is widely regarded as a leader in the field. See Schwulst's citation in a design lecture by industry professional Andy Pressman at Design Portland. https://designportland.org/stories/2016/what-do-we-lose-when-its-easy-to-use What do we Lose when it's easy to Use Deletion of Laurel Schwulst WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
5488 21875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Curse of Vanilla Ice User:Paulmcdonald 00:57, 18 March 2014 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of The Curse of Vanilla Ice WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5489 11075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tong Zhe User:Xinbenlv 00:19, 20 June 2018 (UTC) keep I did some Google search and it appears to me an obvious keep. Meets , has significant coverage by national-level media XinhuaNet and iFeng(凤凰 Deletion of Tong Zhe WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5490 200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Digital Gangster EP User:Stifle 23:53, 11 October 2008 (UTC) delete uncited and fails Deletion of The Digital Gangster EP WP:CBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5491 7078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cinsay Inc. User:Bearian 15:45, 23 September 2016 (UTC) delete Very |run of the mill |company lacking widespread coverage. The lede is so poorly written that I'm not even sure what this company ''does Deletion of Cinsay Inc. WP:MILL||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
5492 1877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Battlefield 1942 mods [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']][[User talk:(aeropagitica)|''' (talk) ''']] 06:30, 13 May 2006 (UTC) delete WP:CRUFT|Listcruft and #Wikipedia_is_not_a_mirror_or_a_repository_of_links.2C_images.2C_or_media_files|a collection of external links, neither of which is encyclopædic. Better off on a games website Deletion of List of Battlefield 1942 mods WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5493 8428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ralph Watkins User:MurderByDeadcopy 06:16, 19 December 2015 (UTC) keep passes . Has major journal reviews. Also, see Michael Scott Cuthbert for more info Deletion of Ralph Watkins WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5494 14493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/June 2017 Champs-Élysées car ramming attack (2nd nomination) User:XavierItzm 19:24, 2 September 2017 (UTC) keep """Not true that the article had a """"3 day coverage cycle"""". For example, Le Parisien dedicated an article to it on 13 July.{{cite news|title=Daech claims missed attacks from Paris and Brussels in June|url=http://www.leparisien.fr/faits-divers/daech-revendique-les-attaques-ratees-de-paris-et-bruxelles-en-juin-13-07-2017-7132920.php|accessdate=2 September 2017|work=Le Parisien|date=13 July 2017|language=French}} El Pais published an in-depth reportage on 18 August that vehicular attacks are increasing in Europe because the Islamic State has been encouraging its followers to execute this tactic for three years, and included this particular attack as an instance of the success IS is having with it.https://politica.elpais.com/politica/2017/08/17/actualidad/1502988327_789176.html. With regard to the argument that mentions of this attack during coverage of more recent attacks is """"no further coverage,"""" remember that each time the refer to this incident, it proves the significance of the Champs-Élysées attack. Finally, if anyone does not like literally a couple of sentences on the background section because of differences of opinion with regard to their relevance to the attack itself, I should point out that the correct way of addressing any such issues is to edit the 11,187 byte article, not to nuke the article from orbit. We are trying to improve the Wikipedia, not to obliterate it, and there has to be a reason why the article had ca. 4,400 page views in August""" Deletion of June 2017 Champs-Élysées car ramming attack (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5495 12464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tulsa Town Hall User:Stuartyeates 07:30, 6 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Tulsa Town Hall WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5496 15646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Banks User:Dan 00:57, 5 November 2008 (UTC) keep satisfies and is verifiably notable Deletion of Alan Banks WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5497 4884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anuja Trehan Kapur User:Harshil169 03:56, 31 July 2019 (UTC) delete Non notable fails . Most of the sources fails Deletion of Anuja Trehan Kapur WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5498 10788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transfer of mitochondrial and chloroplast DNA to the nucleus User:Softlavender 02:37, 15 September 2017 (UTC) delete as nonsensical and hypothetical personal Deletion of Transfer of mitochondrial and chloroplast DNA to the nucleus WP:ESSAY Wikipedia:Essays 31
5499 308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Desktop Cyber User:Bwilkins 11:38, 13 August 2011 (UTC) delete I've written a lot of print articles on IT topics, but cannot find anything that remotely considers this to be |notable. Maybe someday, but not now. This is exactly the argument about COI - we *know* that it's important/notable to the product owner, that does not make it notable for an encylopedia Deletion of Desktop Cyber WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5500 11623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magtheridon User:Edward321 03:59, 10 November 2007 (UTC) keep Nominator appears to have a serious agenda since they talk of nominating over 100 articles for deletion, which will overwhelm the system. Reasons given by nominator |unsourced, |original research, and |fancruft are grounds for improvement, not deletion, and by nominator's own admission may not be relevant to this article. Nominator claims |unnotable and yet provides no indication of what notability criteria they think this article fails. Most importantly claim by nominator that topic is non-notable because non-fans would not read it shows a lack of understanding of notability. I am not a fan of hip-hop or opera - but the 'fact' that only fans would read those articles does not mean those articles are non-notable Deletion of Magtheridon WP:SOURCE||WP:OR||WP:CRUFT||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5501 10606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Woman city User:Nanowolf 06:47, 15 May 2009 (UTC) delete """as per nom. Gets a """"strong delete"""" from me due to |self-promotion, as it seems to contain |blatant plagiarism from http://www.womancitymovie.com/ the movie's own website. This movie may become notable in the future, but it certainly is not now""" Deletion of Woman city WP:PROMOTION||WP:PLAG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5502 12330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mount Airy High School User:Dhrm77 23:03, 27 September 2016 (UTC) keep I have no problem with keeping the page as per , as long as it can be improved Deletion of Mount Airy High School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5503 20097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Perfect Aces: Heads Up Poker User:The1337gamer 16:20, 25 August 2015 (UTC) delete Fails . Cannot find significant coverage from reliable sources Deletion of Perfect Aces: Heads Up Poker WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5504 9129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs about suicide User:Tim 05:46, 5 June 2007 (UTC) keep """If it is not clear-cut like """"Don't Fear the Reaper"""" then it is put in the section List of songs about suicide#Misinterpreted where it says """"Songs either misinterpreted as songs about suicide, or where a reference to suicide cannot be ruled out."""" It seems to me to fit the criteria for inclusion at #Criteria for inclusion in lists and #Purpose of lists""" Deletion of List of songs about suicide WP:LIST||WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
5505 19802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SALT (quartet) User:Adavidb 14:26, 19 December 2009 (UTC) comment """Within the |musician notability criteria, the subject of this article satisfies criterion 9, having """"won ... a major music competition"""", and in so doing became the most prominent representative of womens barbershop singing (satisfying criterion 7""" Deletion of SALT (quartet) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5506 19530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lauren Clinton User:Atlantic306 19:33, 5 February 2018 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON a good start but not enough notable roles for and lack of coverage for Deletion of Lauren Clinton WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5507 8434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1998 Ryukyu Islands earthquake User:Cyclopia 23:55, 21 June 2010 (UTC) keep """The article contains two distinct (albeit small) RS about the subject and as such it passes . That no damages or injuries occurred is irrelevant, as it is the fact that it is a frequent event -notable does NOT mean """"unique"""". The problem of the title can be dealt with editing, and as such is |not a reason to delete, per deletion policy. That said, the article would be probably best merged in some list of minor earthquakes""" Deletion of 1998 Ryukyu Islands earthquake WP:GNG||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
5508 19591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Press Club Vode User:Bearian 18:41, 21 February 2019 (UTC) delete per nom. I am confused why anyone would consider a small club, which had a single annual event, at what was then a small college, to be |notable Deletion of Press Club Vode WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5509 15214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SATUMA Mukhbar User:The 20:48, 21 November 2017 (UTC) delete """In general, it's |long-standing consensus that aircraft that have flown are included in Wikipedia. However, in this case, even leaving aside the thorny issue of where the line is with UAVs vis-a-vis manned aircraft when it comes to that, it doesn't appear to be |verifiable that this UAV has flown, as opposed to being an entry with a pretty picture in a manufacturer's catalogue. If anybody can find """"yes, it flew"""" evidence, ping me and I'll happily change my !vote, but until then""" Deletion of SATUMA Mukhbar WP:CONSENSUS||WP:V Wikipedia:Consensus 78
5510 12376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/True Independence II User:Aspects 03:30, 29 July 2010 (UTC) delete Unsourced non-notable album fails Deletion of True Independence II WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5511 13962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaun Weatherhead User:Spiderone 13:02, 5 December 2020 (UTC) keep does pass the SNG () as York was a Football League club at that time. It would have been more appropriate to nominate on the grounds of failing although he may well pass that too Deletion of Shaun Weatherhead WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5512 6513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ADO Group User:Amortias 21:59, 30 May 2014 (UTC) delete No evidence of |notability that meets criteria for inclusion Deletion of ADO Group WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5513 12248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Block of Cheese Day (2nd nomination) NONE 05:54, 18 March 2008 (UTC) keep as it is interesting to know if it is real, and it is interesting to know what the historical basis is. There are |reliable sources. And if an entire category exists for :Category:Fictional holidays, then this is the type of content that is appropriate for Wikipedia. Wikipedia is |not paper and as such can include more obscure topics. This has already survived AFD once. — Reinyday Deletion of Big Block of Cheese Day (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5514 20721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Safala User:Czar 02:21, 29 May 2014 (UTC) delete I could find nothing on this character in relation to ''Teamo Successfullo'' when I searched. Unless someone can dig up some print or non-English sources out of my reach (ping me if so), the article topic lacks |significant coverage from |reliable, |independent sources. (|?) It didn't pass a Wikipedia:Search engine test|search engine test or have meaningful hits in a /RS|video game reliable sources search (not a single hit for the game name). File:Eye close font awesome.svg|14px|link=user:czar/watching|I am no longer watching this page—whisperback if you'd like a response czar Deletion of Safala WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:42||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5515 20400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kangen Band User:Corpx 15:37, 21 July 2007 (UTC) delete per - This band fails all of them Deletion of Kangen Band WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5516 3948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New R. S. J. Public School Senior Secondary User:The 22:34, 8 January 2014 (UTC) keep large secondary school that, when local research is carried out, will probably be able to be brought into compliance with . There is never much on the Internet about Indian schools, unlike say US schools, so we should avoid systemic bias and await hard copy searches Deletion of New R. S. J. Public School Senior Secondary WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5517 1143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simply FOBulous User:CaliforniaAliBaba 09:06, 30 July 2007 (UTC) keep WP:N|Full-length articles in |reliable sources, listed below Deletion of Simply FOBulous WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5518 17046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Double Double Pizza User:Keeper76 18:58, 27 September 2007 (UTC) delete I suppose the health violations here would make it |NPOV? Just kidding. Too bad this is taking double double the efforts to get rid of an obviously unfixable, unsourceable stub. I have a favorite pizza place too. It's double double good. It's not in Wikipedia Deletion of Double Double Pizza WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
5519 10020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UW Phases User:Shawn 23:58, 30 April 2010 (UTC) delete per nom. Despite all the outlandish wiki-lawyering (Shakespeare was right) and SPA claims, there are no independent indicating real world notability. Even their photo's a joke. begone Deletion of UW Phases WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5520 1050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conquistador (band) (2nd nomination) User:onel5969 13:38, 2 March 2016 (UTC) delete Can't find enough in-depth coverage to show they pass . Would not oppose it being moved to draft, if there is interest to improve the sourcing and content Deletion of Conquistador (band) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5521 20689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ayogu Kingsley User:Ukpong1 22:46, 1 March 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and . As stated by Kudpung, all the sources listed doesn't mention him and the only place his name appears is a passing mention on This Day saying he won some cash Deletion of Ayogu Kingsley WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5522 2282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dream (YouTuber) (2nd nomination) [[User talk:98.35.13.170|talk]]) 23:33, 26 December 2020 (UTC) keep per Nsk92 and their additional sources, which show that Dream has gained significant coverage and passes – and not only since the cheating incident. Special:Contributions/98.35.13.170|98.35.13.170 Deletion of Dream (YouTuber) (2nd nomination) WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5523 6700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiffany Limos User:Longhair 07:39, 14 April 2007 (UTC) keep meets . Notable film actor Deletion of Tiffany Limos WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5524 15387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annie Cruz User:Dustimagic 21:21, 18 February 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Annie Cruz WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5525 13332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dmitry Geller User:New NONE keep """decent coverage in sources, for example http://calvertjournal.com/articles/show/544/yekaterinburg-animation-captures-imagination-with-hand-darwn-techniques this article and this http://www.zippyframes.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=1285:hiroshima-animation-festival-2012-winners&catid=23&Itemid=31 film festival win where won the grand prize at the Hiroshima film festival: """"The Grand Prize of the festival was given to Dmitry Geller for his I Saw Mice Burying a Cat (Russia-China 2011), a bittersweet story of the eternal struggle between cats and mice."""" Many other non-trivial respectful mentions on film festival web sites, https://www.animationfestival.ca/index.php?option=com_oiaf&task=showevent&i=1092 such as this one On the Ottawa international Animnation Festival site (a highly respected animation fest), where they say """"Declaration of Love is by one Russia’s most interesting directors, Dmitry Geller..."""". Such mentions are enough to meet .— Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of Dmitry Geller WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5526 15976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hawthorne Plaza Shopping Center User:TimothyBlue 03:47, 29 August 2020 (UTC) comment """The above are all routine news coverage that '''any''' mall would receive; it does not demonstrate notability. says that ''""""""""Buildings, including private residences and commercial developments, may be notable as a result of their '''historic, social, economic, or architectural importance''', but they require significant coverage by reliable, third-party sources to establish notability."""" Nothing above touches on historic, social, or architectural importance (and significant coverage means addressing the subject directly and in depth). Economic significance is refuted by the fact that it is a dead mall. If someone disagrees, please state which sources show historic, social, economic, or architectural '''importance'''. // """ Deletion of Hawthorne Plaza Shopping Center WP:NBUILD Wikipedia:Notability 77
5527 20030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Best Movies of all Times [[User:(aeropagitica)|(aeropagitica)]] [[Image:Flag_of_England.svg|25px|UK]] 21:02, 10 January 2006 (UTC) delete Article totally subjective - If people want the opinions of many movie-goers then they can go to http://www.imdb.com http://www.imdb.com for such a list. -- Deletion of Best Movies of all Times WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
5528 9056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Hill (goalkeeper) User:CAPTAIN 23:43, 13 February 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Josh Hill (goalkeeper) WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5529 297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Epik (domain registrar) User:Dibbydib 01:25, 21 April 2020 (UTC) keep does seem factually based, also (easily) passes . Also passes as article is not solely based on a controversy or local incident. OP's Special:Contributions/NameShiba|contributions also seem a little suspicious, I might add — from the account creation (17 April) to now, |almost all of them seem to revolve around Epik? Call me a conspiracy theorist but I think something fishy's going on Deletion of Epik (domain registrar) WP:GNG||WP:CORP||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Notability 77
5530 340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David A. Bray User:Hasteur 13:05, 29 December 2015 (UTC) delete """I concur that the argument for notability is on that margin edge of being notable and a courteous collapsing is reasonable. I would note (particularly in the direction of the subject of the article) that it would take a few controversial or very popular opinions to push over into definite notability and inclusion, and therefore wish to indicate that the |""""Recreation of a page that was deleted per a deletion discussion"""" should not be used short of a exact copy of the text going forward. I'd rather have the debate full out every time as the standards could raise or lower and the BLP's own actions could raise or lower their notability""" Deletion of David A. Bray WP:G4 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5531 6315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magomed Saadulaev User:IronKnuckle 00:44, 12 March 2013 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Magomed Saadulaev WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
5532 2582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Operation Market Sweep User:LightandDark2000 21:58, 24 May 2018 (UTC) keep Obviously notable. The nominator also appears to be a |single-purpose account Deletion of Operation Market Sweep WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
5533 14386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lars Mullback User:Inother 17:23, 6 May 2015 (UTC) delete Does not meet Deletion of Lars Mullback WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5534 15725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess Protection Program (3rd nomination) [[User Talk:Bongomatic|Bongo]][[Special:Contributions/Bongomatic|matic]] 06:50, 2 February 2009 (UTC) keep There is sufficient information to |verify the existence of this movie. Given its cast, it is virtually certain to obtain uncontested |notability soon after release (and the arguments that it already has such status—while weak—seem persuasive to many here. Given the high likelihood of recreation, seems pointless to delete it now. If by some chance it is never widely reviewed or fails to get any additional coverage, bring it back to AfD Deletion of Princess Protection Program (3rd nomination) WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5535 9733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/F-16 flight simulator User:Marasmusine 15:59, 16 December 2008 (UTC) delete """I think there ''is'' scope for a article about F-16 flight simulators (and video games - why, we could start with """"F-16 Fighting Falcon"""" 1989, CodeMasters !), but this has inherent and problems""" Deletion of F-16 flight simulator WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5536 18232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quisk NONE NONE delete no indications of notability or significance; an unremarkable private tech company. & apply. Wikipedia is not a catalog for unremarkable minor companies. The copy includes Deletion of Quisk WP:TOOSOON||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Too soon 40
5537 96 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/İhsan Şurdum """Kullanıcı:cekli829cekli""" 17:13, 7 Aralık 2013 (UTC) comment """Konuyla ilgili internetde küçük bir araştırma yaptım ve en az 2 İhsan Şurdum buldum. İkisi de Çerkes asıllıhttp://arsiv.zaman.com.tr/1998/02/23/guncel/dunya/3.html. Biri bu: """"Ürdün Hava Kuvvetleri Komutanı Orgeneral İhsan Şurdum...""""https://kafkas.org.tr/ajans/2002/aralik/17.12.2002_editorun_notu_said_bino.htm. Diğeri ise şuan SAS'da olan İhsan Şurdum. İlk önce söyleyelim ki, o, Çerkes, Kaberdey kökenlidirhttp://www.cerkes.gen.tr/cerkes-ressamlar-ihsan-surdum/. Sanırım en ünlü http://arsiv.ntvmsnbc.com/news/214372.asp profesyonel Çerkes ressamlarından biridir. 1976 yılı devlet sergisinde Başarı Ödülü kazanmış, 1998'de UPSD Onur Ödülü almıştırhttp://www.upsd.org.tr/psd_kurucu_uyeler.htm. Çeşitli kaynaklardan gördüğüm kadarıyla bu |kişi meslektaşları veya ardından gelenlerce önemli bir kişilik sayılmakta veya ona sıkça atıfta bulunulmakta ve s""" İhsan Şurdum'un silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
5538 1992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neha Thirani Bagri User:onel5969 13:05, 19 January 2016 (UTC) delete searches did not turn up enough in-depth coverage to show that this person passes Deletion of Neha Thirani Bagri WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5539 15465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heim theory (4th nomination) User:Cyclopia 08:47, 15 July 2013 (UTC) keep """Here we go again. Notable per : see for a quick example https://www.google.com/search?q=heim+theory&btnG=Cerca+nei+libri&tbm=bks&tbo=1&hl=it#hl=it&safe=off&tbo=d&tbm=bks&sclient=psy-ab&q=%22heim+theory%22+physics&oq=%22heim+theory%22+physics&gs_l=serp.3...9912.10869.1.10971.8.8.0.0.0.0.151.788.4j3.7.0.pchatac..0.0...1.1.7RotZA5uLpE&pbx=1&fp=1&bpcl=39967673&biw=1535&bih=787&bav=on.2,or.r_cp.r_qf.&cad=b&sei=R7bjUdm0DIXd4QTMnID4BQ coverage in books. That said, the nomination rationale is invalid. Is it crackpottery? Sure thing. Is """"crackpottery"""" a deletion rationale? Not at all. Notable crackpot theories are still notable. By having this article, Wikipedia does not """"promote"""" anything, we just describe a wacky theory that exists. NPOV/UNDUE problems can be solved by editing, so they're not a reason to delete, per |deletion policy""" Deletion of Heim theory (4th nomination) WP:GNG||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
5540 16129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sun Way Flight 4412 User:C628 22:33, 28 November 2010 (UTC) keep a large plane crash, with worldwide coverage of the incident, is not routine news coverage and does not fall under Deletion of Sun Way Flight 4412 WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5541 8973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/San Diego Barracudas User:Djsasso 18:42, 23 January 2017 (UTC) keep Professional major league team that was playing at the height of roller hockey popularity when it was on prime time ESPN. is about players, not leagues or teams. Also stop misinforming everyone that these articles were all created by one user as it was not Deletion of San Diego Barracudas WP:SPORTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5542 8669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Backyard Wrestling 2K8 User:Sloane 04:26, 10 March 2009 (UTC) delete Fails inclusion criteria as per . No reliable sources Deletion of Backyard Wrestling 2K8 WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5543 6626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alishka Varde User:NahalAhmed 08:02, 25 November 2019 (UTC) delete She has acted in two films, and neither was in the lead role, Fail Deletion of Alishka Varde WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5544 12253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of hospitals in Cameroon User:RJHall 01:55, 26 November 2011 (UTC) keep Valid list per . Regards Deletion of List of hospitals in Cameroon WP:SALAT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
5545 18857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan River (director) User:Dravecky 14:42, 29 August 2010 (UTC) delete the Jordan River article as while notability is asserted it is not proven through reference to reliable third-party sources. Existing references include press releases hosted on wordpress blogs which do not meet . The ''Sacred Code'' article was already moved to the Article Incubator earlier today after its own AfD then improperly recreated by one of the handful of single-purpose accounts that have sprung up to edit (often, improperly) these two articles. It has been taken to its own 2nd AfD where speedy deletion is likely Deletion of Jordan River (director) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5546 7131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sokratis Tsoukalas User:GiantSnowman 16:14, 8 July 2011 (UTC) delete """fails both (due to lack of """"significant coverage"""") and (as hasn't played in a |fully-professional league""" Deletion of Sokratis Tsoukalas WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5547 6126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B. Scott User:Accounting4Taste 23:57, 23 January 2008 (UTC) comment I was sufficiently stung by the above suggestion that I went back and tried to look at the article from scratch, identifying the claims for |notability and holding them up against the relevant policy statements. I still don't see a reason to change my !vote for deletion, although I admit there is more there than I saw by only tracing a representative sample of the links. This individual may have notability when his career approaches the level of Perez Hilton, whom I believe has achieved notability by being the subject of references/quotes/allusions in other media; right now, it's self-publication -- at a very high level of self-publication, but self-publication nevertheless -- and my understanding of self–publication in any medium is that it does not confer notability. If someone has policy to cite, I'd be pleased to hear it; I think this might be a case where policy doesn't entirely cover the situation, because this type of potential notability is so new and unusual, but I just cannot see how true notablity attaches to this type of self-promotional activity. I'm also concerned that Wikipedia might be being used as an advertising vehicle in this type of situation Deletion of B. Scott WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5548 13752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abraham Jennison User:Jenks24 08:36, 1 October 2010 (UTC) keep per the arguments of Hesperian. Also clearly passes all of the basic criteria of and I'm failing to see why this is even being discussed, to be honest Deletion of Abraham Jennison WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5549 14436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Louise-Marie von Eppinghoven User:Reywas92 04:52, 31 January 2020 (UTC) delete """Notability is not , even for royalty, which she apparently is not. No evidence for claim she """"appears"""" to be a princess...that title is not automatically applied to children of children with mistresses... No . Fr and Nl-wikis have just passing mention in her father's articles""" Deletion of Louise-Marie von Eppinghoven WP:INHERITED||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5550 15072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timo Somers User:84user 16:55, 1 July 2012 (UTC) merge to Vengeance (band) and/or Delain, using a few cites that might support a sentence or two there, for example: http://womenofmetal.net/news/61-news/119-delain-singer-says-new-album-goes-in-a-lot-of-directions and http://jasonbeckerfest.com/news/files/Timo-Somers-Delain.html, http://www.ed.nl/regio/helmondstad/article5843588.ece and http://www.burnyourears.de/reviews/interview/2945-vengeance-interview-mit-saenger-leon-goewie (German interview that mentions Timo and his father briefly). Otherwise I don't think there's enough independent sourcing to justify a bio, and what's there now is wholly unsourced and a concern Deletion of Timo Somers WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
5551 18165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Connor and Garret Sullivan User:J947 01:01, 27 December 2019 (UTC) delete as I can't find anything that indicates a |GNG pass. '''Happy Festivities Deletion of Connor and Garret Sullivan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5552 15876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunset Brawlers User:Eggishorn 04:52, 7 January 2017 (UTC) delete NO significant mentions in , only download/Youtube/free play sites, etc Deletion of Sunset Brawlers WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5553 1701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ukrainian Revolution of 1918 User:Ev 08:08, 3 May 2008 (UTC) delete """per nomination as a Wikipedia:Content forking|content fork of """"Makhnovism"""" (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Ukrainian_Revolution_of_1918&diff=209863365&oldid=209087941 compare the differences between the two entries) and then keep any ensuing redirect fully protected or simply |prevent re-creation""" Deletion of Ukrainian Revolution of 1918 WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
5554 19768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Traedonya [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 08:00, 24 June 2013 (UTC) delete having done my own search I could find virtually nothing. Facebook, YouTube, Twitter, sure, but nothing by way of |significant coverage in multiple reliable sources. Happy to consider anything anyone can find, but I can't support keeping this at the moment Deletion of Traedonya WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5555 3106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John McGuirk (2nd nomination) User:Setreis 16:48, 17 March 2021 (UTC) keep Current coverages passes Deletion of John McGuirk (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5556 2441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/P. Paul Minieri User:David 20:30, 15 July 2013 (UTC) keep I think the Ritter reaction and the tetracycline synthesis patent issue are together enough to pass #C1 and avoid falling into . But, an encyclopedia article here can only contain material coming from reliable sources, and I completely agree with the nominator's demolition of the sources as nominated. I am unable to find sources for most of the personal detail in the article as nominated, but have stubbed it back to a short article that reports only on the two things I can source: the Ritter reaction and tetracycline. It may be necessary to keep this article as a perma-stub, but I think it's ok in that state. However, I would prefer deletion over reversion to its expanded and badly sourced version Deletion of P. Paul Minieri WP:PROF||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
5557 4268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darknet Horror User:Boffob 14:34, 10 December 2008 (UTC) delete per , Deletion of Darknet Horror WP:MADEUP||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
5558 11862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Win Wenger User:David 16:34, 16 August 2009 (UTC) delete Does not pass and does not have sufficient third-party non-academic citations to pass more generally Deletion of Win Wenger WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5559 2617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Shale [[User talk:90.195.111.82|talk]]) 09:27, 27 June 2011 (UTC) keep because if it's deleted from Wikipedia it'll cause conspiracy theories as there were over David Kelly. Important because of his comments to a national party newspaper about Conservative Party membership shortly before he died and close links to Prime Minister. Chair of a local Conservative association is not a politician so doesn't apply, just an office-holder within a political party. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/90.195.111.82|90.195.111.82 Deletion of Christopher Shale WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
5560 8894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gina DeVettori User:Joe 16:44, 20 January 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |actress Deletion of Gina DeVettori WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5561 13922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/José Antonio de Magalhães Lins User:Victor 19:13, 8 July 2016 (UTC) delete Most of the article is |an attempt to make him notable simply because of his family, and it doesn't do anything other than showing that he is a business man being a businessman. One of the sources merely mentions him. A Google search didn't return anything relevant (just more mentions). I plan to request the deletion of the Portuguese article as well Deletion of José Antonio de Magalhães Lins WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5562 17665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryuji Utomo User:GiantSnowman 18:35, 12 April 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Ryuji Utomo WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5563 7647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amrita Kak User:Lonehexagon 03:35, 7 March 2018 (UTC) comment """Added additional sources to the article. Passes She """"has been the subject of multiple, non-trivial, published works appearing in sources that are reliable, not self-published, and are independent of the musician."""" She """"has performed music for a work of media that is notable, e.g., a theme for a network television show, performance in a television show or notable film, inclusion on a notable compilation album"""" as she's written music for several notable Bollywood films. She """"has been placed in rotation nationally by a major radio or music television network"""" and although India doesn't have official music charts, in many profiles on her, her music is referred to as a """"chart buster,"""" """"climbing the charts,"""" or something along those lines, which indicates they were widely popular in the country. For example, this article in the India Times says """"Amrita Kak, who has chartbusters like 'Just Chill' and 'Character Dheela' to her credit""""https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/hindi/music/music-reviews/Dangerous-Ishq-Music-Review/articleshow/12838126.cms or """"Kak's heart pumping numbers 'Character Dheela Hai' and 'Dhinka Chika' in the recent Salman starrer 'Ready' became a rage in the country"""" http://archive.indianexpress.com/news/i-am-too-shy-to-perform-on-stage-amrita-kak/810953/ or """"Her latest number, 'Character dheela' from the upcoming Salman Khan-Asin starrer Ready, has been steadily climbing the charts. And the same was the fate of almost all of of Amrita Kak’s previous numbers."""" http://www.dnaindia.com/entertainment/report-singer-amrita-kak-is-just-chilling-at-the-moment-1539223 or """"Amrita, who gave Bollywood hits like 'Just Chill-Chill' from the movie 'Maine Pyar Kyun Kiya' and 'Character Dheela' from the movie 'Ready'"""" https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/hindi/music/news/Amrita-Kak-Jhunjhunwala-singer-Just-Chill-Chill-Maine-Pyar-Kyun-Kiya-Nusrat-Fateh-Ali-Khan/articleshow/24604442.cms Nearly every bio on her that discusses her music says something along those lines, indicating her music is extremely popular and well-known in the country""" Deletion of Amrita Kak WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5564 13392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Rohde Scudday User:Faustus37 06:20, 1 November 2012 (UTC) delete No here. Nothing published with Samuel French, Inc.. Can't justify it Deletion of Mary Rohde Scudday WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5565 13090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elliottism User:BrokenBeta 17:25, 19 September 2006 (UTC) comment Wikipedia can't hold all information ever found. You need to assert |notability if you want the article to be kept Deletion of Elliottism WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5566 5505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timothy Machin (2nd nomination) User:Wjemather 12:17, 28 March 2021 (UTC) merge to List of Bedfordshire County Cricket Club List A players. Reasonably long minor counties career including one List A match, but none of it equates to playing at the highest domestic level. No |significant coverage found, with mentions being almost exclusively scorecard data, so fails Deletion of Timothy Machin (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5567 14941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CIMR User:Ww2censor 09:54, 4 March 2018 (UTC) delete I can't find any independent either for this unsourced page. There are some mentions of a preaching programme but that's not enough to establish notability Deletion of CIMR WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5568 12456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Kollwitz User:Caknuck 03:59, 18 October 2006 (UTC) delete """If he's not notable enough to be a """"Featured Artist"""" on stick.com, then probably doesn't pass """ Deletion of Michael Kollwitz WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
5569 15547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Horace Kenton Wright User:Tevildo 22:47, 10 April 2009 (UTC) comment """The volume of coverage isn't as important as its content. The criterion requires him to be """"regarded as an important figure"""". Do the sources describe him as important? Yes. I suppose one could argue that the sources aren't |reliable, but an official government website probably is""" Deletion of Horace Kenton Wright WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5570 18384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Intention Records User:Aarktica 16:28, 19 August 2007 (UTC) delete Multiple claims lacking sources (per ) and notability of subject questioned per Deletion of Intention Records WP:V||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5571 15657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Falconer User:Bearcat 22:44, 7 August 2019 (UTC) delete """Carrollton is certainly a large enough city that a |well-sourced and substantive article about a mayor could be kept, but it is not so large that the """"need"""" to have articles about its mayors would justify their being sourced like ''this'': six of the seven footnotes are |primary sources that do not constitute support for notability at all, and the only one that's a reliable media source is simply |routine reportage of the municipal election results. The notability test for a mayor is the ability to write and source a substantive article about his political ''career'', not the ability to provide the names of his wife and kids""" Deletion of Kevin Falconer WP:RS||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5572 10075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caerlon User:MuZemike 19:26, 26 July 2008 (UTC) delete Seems to be written like a ; also no references cited to verify the article's notability Deletion of Caerlon WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
5573 10672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boiler plant boys higher secondary school User:Clarityfiend 21:03, 13 October 2015 (UTC) keep per , existing references and its appearance on this Tamil Nadu school listing.http://www.agaram.tn.gov.in/dsepinfosys/sa_new_desig2.asp?qceo_cd1=15&qdesig_cd1=220&qdesig_nm1=Vocational%20Teachers Deletion of Boiler plant boys higher secondary school WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5574 18919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wilderness Updates - Runescape User:Jonathan 16:07, 29 December 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Wilderness Updates - Runescape WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5575 16504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cincopa User:LoudHowie 21:58, 26 November 2009 (UTC) delete """It could be the best and the most downloaded on Wordpress, but that does not make it notable let alone warrant an entry in an encyclopedia. """"A big player in the wordpress blog world"""" yet I fail to find significant, independant notable coverage. The discussions created by the accounts just shows their disrespect for Wikipedia as they blatantly try to use their fan/user base to justify keeping this article. I vote delete""" Deletion of Cincopa WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
5576 1347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony (editor) User:Oroso 23:27, 23 August 2008 (UTC) delete WP:CSD A7. The article does not indicate why its subject is important or significant. If it doesn't meet that, regular delete for failing to prove it meets Deletion of Anthony (editor) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5577 17648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wavedash Games User:Sergecross73 16:20, 9 August 2017 (UTC) comment It's a pretty poorly written article, but https://www.redbull.com/us-en/wavedash-games-and-the-rise-of-the-platform-fighter Redbull Games and http://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2017-05-03-wavedash-games-secures-USD6m-in-series-a-funding Games Industry Biz both have pretty in-depth articles about the company, (And have a |consensus for being reliable per /S) so I'm not so sure I agree with the vague assertion that it fails the Deletion of Wavedash Games WP:CONSENSUS||WP:VG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Consensus 78
5578 10691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/High-risk heterosexual User:Gosox5555 12:35, 13 August 2009 (UTC) delete as a neologism and per #DICT Deletion of High-risk heterosexual WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5579 19767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenneth Reid User:NASCAR 01:16, 7 October 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. The article also says that he is a Leesburg, Virginia town council member. Per , just being a member of a town council does not make you notable Deletion of Kenneth Reid WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5580 14283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guy Savoie (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 22:46, 10 February 2017 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Guy Savoie (2nd nomination) WP:POLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5581 7795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshuah Michael user:BlindEagle 16:49, 5 October 2007 (UTC) delete per #A7|CSD A7 Deletion of Joshuah Michael WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5582 7936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liam Patton User:Number 10:47, 12 July 2009 (UTC) delete per failure Deletion of Liam Patton WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5583 17864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muntadar al-Zaidi [[User talk:67.150.245.46|talk]]) 13:45, 15 December 2008 (UTC) comment """Al-Zaidi's TV station is calling for his release. The way in which he should be treated by the authorities in Iraq is already a matter of controversy there. Thousands of al-Sadr supporters have demonstrated for his release. We may have to be patient for editors with the right language skills to add relevant material from Arabic-language sources on this. At that point, it is clear there will be too much material to reasonably fit in the article on George W. Bush. Therefore the choice will be between an article on al-Zaidi, or an article on ''the event itself'', which clearly meets notability criteria, if there are objections to an article on him. It is inappropriate to ask that the al-Zaidi article be merged into the Bush one when it has the potential to grow, but may simply not have had time yet. Let me add that a number of people are misinterpreting the intent of the """"one event"""" guideline. It does not support a merger in any way. It is intended to prevent the creation of biographies of people associated with a single, notable event, when there are numerous people associated with that event (such as all candidates, including minor ones, in an election). In this case, al-Zaidi is more or less synonymous with the event, in which he was one of the two main protagonists. The """"one event"""" rule is not an excuse to avoid evaluating the notability of the event itself. By any reasonable measure, this event was notable. Otherwise, newspapers wouldn't have thought it important to report it, practically unanimously. (See the general notability guideline .) That leaves the choice of creating an article for the event or one for al-Zaidi. Special:Contributions/67.150.245.46|67.150.245.46""" Deletion of Muntadar al-Zaidi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5584 17810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nimal Yatiwella User:Dan 23:44, 13 April 2020 (UTC) delete fails / . The RS provided don’t even mention the individual. The other references such as YouTube and Wikipedia are not acceptable sources Deletion of Nimal Yatiwella WP: ANYBIO||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5585 15834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Merryman User:NDSteve10 08:14, 5 November 2010 (UTC) delete Agree with above, should have been a Deletion of Peter Merryman WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
5586 9691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles E. Swanson User:David 03:25, 10 June 2007 (UTC) delete Shows no signs of passing : not the subject of a bio or of multiple press pieces, and I don't think the encyclopedia itself counts as his personal contribution Deletion of Charles E. Swanson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5587 9871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saji Paravoor User:RebeccaGreen 02:59, 13 January 2019 (UTC) merge both ''N.R. Sanjeev'' and ''Saji Paravoor'' to Janakan. The film is notable, but he does not appear to have enough coverage to meet , and does not meet Deletion of Saji Paravoor WP:BASIC||WP:DIRECTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5588 11550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Holland Township Ballpark User:Secret 17:10, 11 March 2014 (UTC) delete No evidence of meeting Deletion of Holland Township Ballpark WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5589 17723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Happy (video gamer) User:Sergecross73 20:49, 4 July 2016 (UTC) delete As the nomination alludes to, the sourcing |is a bit misleading, with most sources not looking to be an , or barely mention the subject himself at all - passing mentions Deletion of Happy (video gamer) WP:BOMBARD||WP:RS Wikipedia:Citation overkill 60
5590 7390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dimensional Insight User:Oakshade 00:56, 1 December 2006 (UTC) keep Outside sources provide and Deletion of Dimensional Insight WP:V||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5591 19888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slutty and Sluttier User:Erpert 11:38, 21 February 2013 (UTC) keep The article could definitely use some better sources, but the two AVN wins for Best Gonzo Series should be enough for it to pass . '''Erpert Deletion of Slutty and Sluttier WP:NFILMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5592 18412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Layfield & Barrett User:OnionRing 22:04, 16 June 2016 (UTC) comment they are currently involved in an interesting legal dispute over anonymity of online commenters on :Glassdoor, which is getting some coverage online, mostly from law blogs but also from a few : http://www.inc.com/suzanne-lucas/the-worst-possible-response-to-a-bad-glassdoor-review.html, http://www.abajournal.com/news/article/upset_by_people_who_spit_their_venom_on_glassdoor_name_partner_seeks_identi/, https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160518/05383434471/law-firm-subpoenas-glassdoor-negative-anonymous-reviews-supercharges-streisand-effect-with-response.shtml, http://www.humanresourcesonline.net/can-employers-sue-online-commenters-negative-comments/, http://www.globallegalpost.com/global-view/law-firm-files-lawsuit-over-anonymous-online-trashing-30579733/, http://abovethelaw.com/2016/05/working-here-is-psychological-torture-law-firm-sues-over-anonymous-comments/, http://www.advocatie.nl/working-there-psychological-torture-kantoor-geweer-tegen-anonieme-aantijgingen. I also notice that this was already mentioned at Anonymous post#Effects on users. I'm leaning toward keep and improve at this point, but would be interested to hear other editors' opinions first Deletion of Layfield & Barrett WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5593 1669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dean Howes [[User talk:Bullzeye|Complaint Dept.]]/[[Special:Contributions/Bullzeye|Contribs)]] 23:41, 26 July 2007 (UTC) delete """Merely throwing down """"related"""" links and calling them references doesn't make the subject meet . Bullzeye""" Deletion of Dean Howes WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5594 827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julian R. Decker User:Coreykai 00:26, 13 December 2020 (UTC) delete Does not have multiple, if any roles in any major productions, has average to small fan base, and has not made any significant impacts on the entertainment community, therefore failing all three points in Deletion of Julian R. Decker WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5595 8737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taeveen [[User talk:24.151.10.165|talk]]) 19:17, 4 March 2015 (UTC) delete Fails unless this is a nonstandard transliteration from the local language. Special:Contributions/24.151.10.165|24.151.10.165 Deletion of Taeveen WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5596 4182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Mamatas [[User talk:12.71.54.226|talk]]) — [[Special:Contributions/12.74.54.226|12.74.54.226]] ([[User talk:12.74.54.226|talk]]) has made [[Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|few or no other edits]] outside this topic. 19:59, 3 May 2011 (UTC) comment Meeting one or more criterion does not guarantee inclusion, but it's rather silly to first argue that the awards are regional, and then when that is refuted argue that mere nominations don't count, and when that is refuted change your argument a third time without changing your opinion. Clearly, the reasons you put up for deletion originally simply aren't true-the awards are not regional, the publications are notable, and there are reliable third-party notes, including NPR. (It's also worth noting that the NPR material does not show Mamatas in a good light, which suggests that COI isn't a major issue with this entry either.) —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/12.71.54.226|12.71.54.226 Deletion of Nick Mamatas WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5597 14248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Catherine Lynch User:Icewhiz 10:24, 11 March 2018 (UTC) delete Possibly even CSD A7. Article is sourced entirely to ''Swansea's 'Bad Girls': Crime and Prostitution 1870s–1914''https://www.amazon.com/Swanseas-Bad-Girls-Prostitution-1870s-1914/dp/0957597428 by ''Elizabeth Belcham'' and to (what are probably her sources) local news reports and court proceedings. The Belcham book does not seem RSey, and regardless, this individual clearly fails even it was - very local coverage and one book (which is not available online, but from the citations in the article - from 8 pages in said book Deletion of Catherine Lynch WP:PERP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5598 5502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maximillian Bryant User:Lightdarkness 05:07, 22 February 2006 (UTC) delete NN-bio? Fails Deletion of Maximillian Bryant WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5599 4127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of motorcycle clubs (2nd nomination) User:Gene93k 10:34, 7 April 2008 (UTC) keep per . It appears to be an ordered developmental list that complements the category. A category cannot show red-links for missing encyclopedic entries, an important function. Notability of red-linked clubs should be better sourced, but the main problems with the list were fixed in the first AfD Deletion of List of motorcycle clubs (2nd nomination) WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
5600 15076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madrassah Tahfeezul Quran User:Bearian 21:23, 14 December 2020 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Madrassah Tahfeezul Quran WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5601 12472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Falcon Lake Incident User:Brewcrewer 18:41, 10 January 2009 (UTC) delete per . Has not received significant coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Falcon Lake Incident WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5602 14510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geek Hardcore User:HisSpaceResearch 13:52, 29 December 2007 (UTC) delete as OR, neologism, fails Deletion of Geek Hardcore WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5603 5241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tirukkural translations into Meitei User:Kautilya3 06:54, 9 June 2021 (UTC) delete or '''Merge''' to Central Institute of Classical Tamil. Wikipedia is Deletion of Tirukkural translations into Meitei WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5604 2676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inflation tax User:Mark 01:06, 10 March 2016 (UTC) comment """Doing a simple style search, I found the University of Chicago press book https://books.google.com/books?id=yvBS2KnhWSUC&dq=%22Inflation+tax%22+-wikipedia&source=gbs_navlinks_s Inflation, Tax Rules, and Capital Formation and an ECB working paper https://www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/scpwps/ecbwp038.pdf?a1cb4280848b9c3557120a146468f3ab THE OPTIMAL INFLATION TAX WHEN TAXES ARE COSTLY TO COLLECT as sources that discuss the inflation tax. Both have a nice overview of the the history of the concept in economics and show that """"inflation tax"""" seems to be a real concept used in the economics literature at least since the 1980s""" Deletion of Inflation tax WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
5605 4119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/South Asian Friends User:ARUNEEK 11:20, 5 December 2016 (UTC) delete Fails .No notable sources to demonstarte for it's keep Deletion of South Asian Friends WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5606 8092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jubin Jacob User:DESiegel 16:06, 29 September 2005 (UTC) delete under A7 and so tagged. If for some reason not speedy deleted, '''delete''' as non-notable Deletion of Jubin Jacob WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5607 17441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Reporter (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 05:10, 12 January 2011 (UTC) delete per #Films|. While happy to congratulate these high school filmmakers for their creative efforts, high school films by student filmmakers rarely achieve the coverage required to meet |inclusion criteria Deletion of The Reporter (film) WP:TOOSOON||WP:NF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
5608 8773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad Yaghoobi user:Alf_photoman 23:06, 3 March 2007 (UTC) delete unless sourced and referenced i.a.w. or by end of this AfD. Due to the total lack of secondary sources this article fails Deletion of Mohammad Yaghoobi WP:BIO||WP:PROF||WP:ATT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5609 3800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Smith (ice hockey) [[User talk:Ravenswing|''' '' Ravenswing '' ''']] 09:01, 3 January 2016 (UTC) delete Whether the EIHL is a fully professional league (something currently under debate at the WikiProject) is irrelevant. At the most generous, he's played a relatively small number of games without achieving particular distinction, and would fail the most generous conceivable criterion of . No evidence the player meets the GNG beyond routine match coverage explicitly debarred by Deletion of Sam Smith (ice hockey) WP:NHOCKEY||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5610 15195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of wind turbines in Thuringia User:Pburka 16:08, 25 November 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of wind turbines in Thuringia WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5611 21240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kovas Boguta User:Anas 08:48, 1 February 2007 (UTC) delete found nothing to assert his notability. Fails Deletion of Kovas Boguta WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5612 6934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marchesi di San Vincenzo Ferreri User:Ravenswing 01:10, 27 May 2008 (UTC) delete """As has been cropping up in the other related AfDs over the last few days, the '''only''' source we can actually see for any of these articles and any of these claims is the creator's own website. The creator claims (unpublished) documents in government archives in Europe and his own """"unpublished research notes"""" for sources, as well as presenting much of the articles (much of which is cut and pasted from his other articles) in Italian and French. Fails , , and """ Deletion of Marchesi di San Vincenzo Ferreri WP:V||WP:N||WP:OR||WP:SYN Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5613 14688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/U2's 16th Album User:MrFizyx 16:38, 18 June 2007 (UTC) keep sourced (though not all likely to pass . More info is likely to emerge. U2 are kinda notable and all Deletion of U2's 16th Album WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5614 4591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lesmahagow High School User:Adamant1 19:49, 26 December 2020 (UTC) delete reading through all the discussion and looking over the sourcing it appears that this school lacks the multiple in-depth reliable independent sources it needs to pass and . As they all seem to either trivial or connected to the school somehow. Which doesn't cut it for the standards of notability. That said if someone is able to provide |three good, independent, in-depth, reliable sources I will be more then willing to change my vote Deletion of Lesmahagow High School WP:GNG||WP:NORG||WP:THREE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5615 15134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelly Lane Middle School User:Edison 16:49, 8 May 2012 (UTC) comment """Why must all the school redirects come through AFD, when the nominator typically desires the article be replaced by a redirect to the locality or school district, rather than actual deletion? Perhaps a middle school or elementary school could be listed at Wikipedia:Articles for creation/Redirects, if an editor does not wish to be bold and go ahead and make the redirect, although that page does not have discussions; it is just a page where individual editors make the decisions. Such requests might be rejected there as not being called for in any notability guideline or policy. A solution to this would be to add language to recommending a redirect for the typical elementary or middle school which lacks refs to demonstrate notability, to bring into accord with the essay as reflecting the consensus of the community. There was a discussion at Wikipedia talk:Notability (organizations and companies) Dec 2011-Feb 2012 which discussed this issue(starting with the question of """"Blue Ribbon Schools"""") without actually resulting in any change to the language of the guideline""" Deletion of Kelly Lane Middle School WP:ORG||WP:ORG||WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Notability 77
5616 18389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minnie Hollow Wood user:Andrew 19:01, 25 September 2020 (UTC) keep """Passes – """"''The person has received a well-known and significant award ''"""", i.e. the right to wear a warbonnet – an exceptional honour for a woman of her tribe. See https://www.pbs.org/wned/warrior-tradition/watch/minnies-war-bonnet/ PBS for a retelling of her heroism""" Deletion of Minnie Hollow Wood WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5617 6178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stream Companies User:Ihcoyc 15:57, 10 November 2010 (UTC) delete """Yet another ad agency turning to Wikipedia for free publicity. If being """"one of the largest full service advertising agencies in the Philadelphia region"""" is its only claim to fame, I'd say that fails #A7|minimal significance; and in any case this does nothing but |promote the business""" Deletion of Stream Companies WP:CSD||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5618 145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Željko Loparić User:Xxanthippe 02:25, 24 July 2016 (UTC) keep Passes rof#C1 in the low-cited field of philosophy Deletion of Željko Loparić WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
5619 12003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional raccoons User:TenPoundHammer 21:08, 20 March 2008 (UTC) keep per , maybe snowball it. Surely this is verifiable Deletion of List of fictional raccoons WP:LISTS Wikipedia:Lists 97
5620 12928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jolyon Dixon User:Yamsahh 16:34, 5 August 2011 (UTC) keep The earliest version of the article had no independent refs proving Now, the inserted refs support it Deletion of Jolyon Dixon WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5621 19681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jody Hoskins (2nd nomination) User:Dream 18:09, 12 December 2008 (UTC) keep """There is a rule for this, in and by that rule, the article is fine. It reads in part: """"'''Has been featured multiple times in notable mainstream media'''."""" Well, Playboy counts as a notable mainstream media doesn't it""" Deletion of Jody Hoskins (2nd nomination) WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5622 9385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Gade User:Sjakkalle 16:37, 24 October 2020 (UTC) keep I am inclined to agree with the notion that major party candidates for US Senate races should have articles in general. While the policy does not directly apply, I do believe that deleting the non-incumbent major party candidate runs while giving full coverage with a biography of the incumbent runs against the spirit of that policy. When Wikipedia covers elections, there should be fair representation to both sides of the election. The caveat is that coverage is contingent on the core and policies being met, and there needs to be enough sourcing () for a full article. In this case, there is a wide amount of media articles, so I don't see that as an issue here Deletion of Daniel Gade WP:NPOV||WP:V||WP:NOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
5623 16750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1890 Konoshenkova User:Padenton 21:53, 17 May 2015 (UTC) merge per () No significant coverage found on this object itself. Everything on google scholar is a paper listing several asteroids (explicitly mentioned in NASTCRIT #3 as not meeting notability) or otherwise failing to provide significant commentary on the object. ― Deletion of 1890 Konoshenkova WP:NASTRO||WP:NASTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5624 8431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward S. May User:LutherBlissetts 20:30, 1 May 2012 (GMT) keep """Article is currently being expanded to included information in keeping with . May is a """"central organiser""""http://www.scribd.com/doc/90039108/Learning-to-Love-the-Jews-T-Archer#page=3 of the anti-Islam Counterjihad movement""" Deletion of Edward S. May WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5625 13627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Maurice Davis User:Paulmcdonald 11:14, 15 May 2013 (UTC) delete if it isn't self-promotion, it certainly is Deletion of Aaron Maurice Davis WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
5626 9244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Proffitt's House User:Arthur 18:36, 19 June 2006 (UTC) delete """if at all possible. , created by a """"user"""" who has done nothing else but edit this, and has a relevant name. &mdash""" Deletion of Proffitt's House WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
5627 14297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stevan de Geijter User:Mentoz86 21:36, 30 October 2012 (UTC) delete fails both and Deletion of Stevan de Geijter WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5628 6854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hotrod (actor) User:Malik 02:35, 24 July 2015 (UTC) delete Fails , , and . — Deletion of Hotrod (actor) WP:PORNBIO||WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5629 4704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susan Berkley User:Mattinbgn 22:58, 3 June 2008 (UTC) delete Arguably breaches in that the article seems to accuse her of misrepresenting herself. On top of this she is marginally notable at best Deletion of Susan Berkley WP:ATTACK Wikipedia:Attack page 100
5630 12770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Export Development Bank of Iran User:David 10:49, 21 September 2016 (UTC) comment It's a statutory body, so is not the right measure. That said, we do need good sourcing, else a decent redirect target Deletion of Export Development Bank of Iran WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5631 21393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maggie Bill User:Ad 01:55, 4 March 2014 (UTC) delete per nom. Most of the sources do indeed fail RS. The article fails to make any claims that satisfy . Although clearly a talented athlete, there is nothing here that rings the notability bell for our purposes Deletion of Maggie Bill WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
5632 15245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur Rubin (6th nomination) User:Xxanthippe 01:59, 11 March 2018 (UTC) delete Now that the citation record has been established, it is clear that it is not enough to pass rof#C1. There is one highly cited paper (~ 900 cites) written with a distinguished mathematician and another coauthor. The few other papers published have had coauthors and few citations, so there is little evidence of independent achievement. The student awards do not satisfy rof#C2. The consensus here, which I agree with, is that rof is not passed. Neither is olitician. One case for keep that is at least coherent has been made by Eppstein, who argues that although the student awards do not qualify for rof, they pass when suppoprted by the media references. Other editors have agued that the references do not give the substantial coverage required by . I agree, and agree that there is no pass of either Deletion of Arthur Rubin (6th nomination) WP:P||WP:P||WP:P||WP:P||WP:P||WP:GNG||WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Portal 85
5633 14768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pria Viswalingam User:Canley 05:03, 8 February 2021 (UTC) keep """as article creator): I started this article in 2006 as an admittedly poorly-referenced microstub, I see it has now gotten a little out of control, with dozens of additions by anonymous IPs and single-purpose accounts over 15 years, which given the effusive wording some are probably connected contributors. I don't think there are any notability issues – Viswalingam is a well-regarded and prolific filmmaker and former television presenter on a national network. There is significant coverage of some of his work, particularly of the documentary series ''Decadence (TV series)|Decadence''. I'm a little hesitant to throw in here, as clearly the article has been tagged as unreferenced for far too long, but surely """"wrong capitalization"""" is ''easily'' surmountable/fixable and a pointless argument for deletion. I will, however, undertake to prune down the article, make sure it's all referenced, and keep a closer eye on it in future""" Deletion of Pria Viswalingam WP:AFDISNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5634 9221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/9fans User:Dhartung 05:57, 11 March 2007 (UTC) delete NN mailing list about a little-known (outside certain circles) operating system. No sources, fails Deletion of 9fans WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
5635 3769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giapo User:Acroterion 17:59, 9 December 2009 (UTC) delete I see no coverage outside of Auckland, and precious little there, at least as references. For this company to meet it should at least have broad notability in New Zealand at large, with coverage in other media in other NZ cities. Coverage in social media is interesting, but so far I see nothing beyond up-to-date marketing practice, of which an article on Wikipedia would be a part Deletion of Giapo WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5636 8870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sipho Tshabalala User:Kraxler 01:53, 12 August 2015 (UTC) delete unsourced, and fails Deletion of Sipho Tshabalala WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5637 15334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008-09 Stonehill Skyhawks men's basketball team User:DoubleBlue 02:57, 27 March 2009 (UTC) merge to Stonehill College. There's |no need to go through AfD for an article like this. There is a possibility that an article on the Skyhawks basketball team will be notable enough that an article can be written about it and also quite likely that someone will seek information on the Stonehill Skyhawks men's basketball team, so why not direct them to the college Deletion of 2008-09 Stonehill Skyhawks men's basketball team WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
5638 19761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suri Cruise (2nd nomination) User:hmwith 21:07, 2 March 2012 (UTC) comment """After giving this much thought, I can't reach a decision. She meets the additional criteria in . See (""""received a well-known and significant award or honor"""") and (""""large fan base or a significant 'cult' following""""). However, proof of secondary sources here would cement change my !vote to keep""" Deletion of Suri Cruise (2nd nomination) WP:BIO||WP:ANYBIO||WP:NMODEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5639 21710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Ball (fighter) User:Mkdw 04:23, 12 January 2013 (UTC) delete Another fighter article being cleaned up after was passed Deletion of Jason Ball (fighter) WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
5640 6355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Combined Community Codec Pack User:TheFarix 21:22, 13 September 2006 (UTC) keep Quite notable, recommend by many fansub groups and AnimeSuki. Doesn't appear to violate , , or . The only real problem I see is that it is base entirely on primary sources and needs secondary sources to balance it. It could also include information on its affects on the fansubbing community and what criticism it has received, if any. But those alone aren't enough to delete this article Deletion of Combined Community Codec Pack WP:V||WP:NOR||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5641 19049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blundon Corner, Virginia User:Pontificalibus 10:42, 10 March 2021 (UTC) merge to Arcadia (house), Virginia. The Arcadia house seems to meet and , so we can make this article about the house in order to preserve the edit history Deletion of Blundon Corner, Virginia WP:GNG||WP:BUILD Wikipedia:Notability 77
5642 13340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barack Obama speech at Tucson memorial User:Truthsort 06:26, 22 January 2011 (UTC) merge I do not understand why some users argue that because Republicans applauded the speech that it means keeping it. I highly doubt you are going to see any mainstream figures of the rival political party criticized a speech that honored shooting victims. Again, an approval rating bounce should be no surprise give the circumstances, but we should not assume that is permanent. They could go up or down again three months from now based on his performance. It is too early to determine how significant this is. You can add as much |wikipuffery as you want in the article, but this should not have an article on it Deletion of Barack Obama speech at Tucson memorial WP:PUFFERY Wikipedia:Wikipuffery 0
5643 1694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian D. Evans (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 01:16, 6 December 2016 (UTC) delete and |protect against continued creation. This is a |run of the mill business person, and obviously |has been an advertisement created at least twice by an SPA. We are not a |resume builder or LinkedIn. We are |not a web host. We are a private charity that builds an encyclopedia. My name is Brian, and I have over 1,157 friends on Facebook and 259 followers on Twitter - big whoop Deletion of Brian D. Evans (2nd nomination) WP:SALT||WP:MILL||WP:ADVERT||WP:NOTRESUME||WP:NOTWEBHOST Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
5644 19856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/You Know Me movement User:Wumbolo 14:01, 24 May 2019 (UTC) keep The movement has lengthy coverage and establishes . See https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/tasneemnashrulla/stop-the-abortion-bans-protests https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/busy-philipps-aclu-team-ad-campaign-fight-abortion-ban-1213081 https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/15/style/busy-philipps-abortion-youknowme.html, and it also has tons of local coverage Deletion of You Know Me movement WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5645 4356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enomalism User:Red 11:45, 31 August 2008 (UTC) delete as '''G11'', confilct of intrest (pointed out in the nom), and non-notable. Basiclly, |spam Deletion of Enomalism WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
5646 5388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/N-iX User:WikiDan61 16:34, 14 July 2016 (UTC) delete as |spam. Self-promotional and non-|notable Deletion of N-iX WP:SPAM||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Spam 112
5647 11184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Heaton NONE 23:03, 15 October 2010 (UTC) delete Pure |vanispamcruftisement created by a with issues. Happy Editing! — '''{{User|71.166.157.40 Deletion of Terry Heaton WP:VSCA||WP:SPA||WP:COI Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
5648 12756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jan-Dirk Nijkamp User:Papaursa 04:36, 24 December 2019 (UTC) keep While the article's coverage is not overly impressive, I suspect that there's more out there if one has access to Dutch newspaper archives. Meanwhile, I'll defer to Deletion of Jan-Dirk Nijkamp WP:NOLYMPICS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5649 17094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ideomanifestationalism [[User talk:Ultimus|'''UlTiMuS''']] 06:59, 6 November 2006 (UTC) delete There are no for this, and there probably never will be. I don't think there can be any serious debate about that Deletion of Ideomanifestationalism WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5650 332 [[Otto Hahn Gymnasium Nagold]] (bleibt) Benutzer:RöntgenTechniker NONE keep Fehlende Relevanz nach #Schulen ist kein gültiger Löschgrund Löschung von Otto Hahn Gymnasium Nagold Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
5651 12117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Woodside Community Church (Baptist) User:Bearian 19:59, 13 November 2020 (UTC) delete per above, especially {{U|Hog_Farm}}, , and Deletion of Woodside Community Church (Baptist) WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
5652 19101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guillermo López Langarica User:Phil 21:56, 21 October 2008 (UTC) delete per #NEWS and , which doesn't only apply to living people Deletion of Guillermo López Langarica WP:NOT||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5653 7038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Companions of the Hall (2nd nomination) User:Jclemens 08:45, 11 September 2016 (UTC) keep This is a |summary style parent of multiple notable fictional characters, which span many books and game components. This specific collection of characters is mentioned by this name in reviews http://www.geeksofdoom.com/2015/09/15/book-review-dungeons-dragons-abyss, http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/132423-1st-Chapter-of-New-R-A-Salvatore-Book-Released-for-Free, http://www.christiantoday.com/article/neverwinter.ps4.release.date.news.ported.game.launches.this.summer.with.newest.dlc/87572.htm; interviews https://digitalburg.com/?p=10289, http://diehardgamefan.com/2011/10/13/interview-with-peter-lee-of-wizards-of-the-coast-about-the-legend-of-drizzt-board-game/; and are one of the topics covered in an RPG-focused dissertation, http://fantasyliterature.pbworks.com/w/file/fetch/99772099/looting%20the%20dungeon%20-%20canavan.pdf Deletion of Companions of the Hall (2nd nomination) WP:SS Wikipedia:Summary style 34
5654 18069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radio Today (Australian & New Zealand website) User:Uzma 13:59, 30 August 2012 (UTC) delete I didn't find any news coverage of the website. The website itself does not maintain an In-the-News page of news coverage about itself. No newspaper covered the website's formation, launching of 20 February 2012, or it's growth since 20 February 2012. There are many hits for Radio Today (usually as in adio today (e.g.http://www.google.com/#hl=en&output=search&sclient=psy-ab&q=%22(ESPN2)+RADIO+TODAY+%22&oq=%22(ESPN2)+RADIO+TODAY+%22&gs_l=hp.3...1013.1676.0.1885.3.3.0.0.0.0.178.362.1j2.3.0.les%3B..0.0...1c.2U1yaM3uqXs&pbx=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.&fp=7e9041a74f73c7f&biw=1920&bih=911)). Does not meet . Also falls into : 4. Internet guides. Wikipedia articles should not exist only to describe the nature, appearance or services a website offers Deletion of Radio Today (Australian & New Zealand website) WP:GNG||WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5655 19215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/War theory User:Cosmo0 20:46, 13 October 2007 (UTC) delete per any of the above (//). Reads like a school essay, not an encyclopedia article Deletion of War theory WP:ESSAY||WP:SOAP||WP:OR Wikipedia:Essays 31
5656 12290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emily Dunn (footballer) User:Inter 01:51, 28 June 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Emily Dunn (footballer) WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5657 4942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tobi Kukoyi User:Harsh 04:51, 8 July 2020 (UTC) comment yo|ContentBI}} Please read and understand . It doesn't matter if you are paid to write an article or not, if you have a COI you should not edit an article. Plain and simple. Your ranting is not helping your case. I do not know what sources are considered reliable in Nigeria, but please keep your argument succinct. Give links to the articles you think satisfy and leave it at that. Do not engage in arguments. Make your case and move on Deletion of Tobi Kukoyi WP:COIEDIT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
5658 9349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beth HaMedrosh Hagodol-Beth Joseph User:IZAK 03:49, 13 July 2014 (UTC) keep because the article has more than sufficient & that make it . Thank you Deletion of Beth HaMedrosh Hagodol-Beth Joseph WP:V||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5659 13247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Feras Moussa User:Abu 23:09, 10 August 2006 (UTC) delete Fails . Matches anity Deletion of Feras Moussa WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
5660 9487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Jewish American cartoonists User:Plot 19:27, 28 November 2010 (UTC) delete At point in time, not adequately sourced (fails ). Would be more viable if there were an independent article on the topic Deletion of List of Jewish American cartoonists WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5661 10256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kris Clack User:Davidpdx 19:21, 14 July 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and fails Deletion of Kris Clack WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5662 3630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry (Fawlty Towers) User:Bob 13:58, 18 May 2011 (UTC) delete """with a standard of someone actually coming up with sources instead of just asserting them). I've made an effort to look for sources but I haven't been able to find anything. I'm not hopeful either, since whilst I'm a fairly big fan of Fawlty Towers, I had to look up who he was and I'm fairly sure he only had 20 or 30 lines in the entire run. I'm not expecting more than a footnote in """"Cockneys in 1970s British Television""" Deletion of Terry (Fawlty Towers) WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
5663 3849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evandro Rachoni De Lima User:Yellow 10:58, 28 September 2016 (UTC) keep passes per multiple reliable and in-depth sources found by Fenix down Deletion of Evandro Rachoni De Lima WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5664 16057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Of Evans User:Bearian 02:38, 1 October 2017 (UTC) delete per and . There is not even a single |reliable source that proves any fact in this article Deletion of William Of Evans WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5665 9039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comité international pour la protection des droits de l'homme User:Comte0 19:30, 18 August 2020 (UTC) delete only 23 results on a google search, which does not meet the significant coverage requirement of . Regards Deletion of Comité international pour la protection des droits de l'homme WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5666 40 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Türkiye'nin en zengin 100 ailesi listesi """Kullanıcı:sputnik1907sputnik""" 00:01, 6 Mart 2016 (UTC) keep Gerek yerli, gerekse yabancı onlarca kaynak var. Türkçe veya İngilizce basit google aramalarında bile ve VP:GÜVEN politikalarına uygun kaynaklar bulunabiliyor. Maddenin KD'lik konusunda bir sorunu olduğunu düşüünmüyorum. Lakin çok iyi elden geçirilmesi gerekiyor. Saygılar Türkiye'nin en zengin 100 ailesi listesinin silinmesi Vikipedi:D Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5667 273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stanlie James User:K 03:27, 12 December 2017 (UTC) keep as . The three books listed are widely held, with the top books in 700+ libraries: https://www.worldcat.org/identities/lccn-no92011969/ Worldcat Identities. The article is sufficiently well sourced at the moment and establishes stand-alone notability Deletion of Stanlie James WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5668 6746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julianne Wurm User:Rsrikanth05 08:02, 24 July 2012 (UTC) delete Fails . No sign of notability. Just because she is the founder of TEDxEast, doesn't mean it needs to be kept Deletion of Julianne Wurm WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5669 3903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hairline Illusions User:Inthepubliceye 15:56, 15 April 2013 (UTC) delete lacking in information and sources. Hint of in the style of the writing Deletion of Hairline Illusions WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5670 8659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Winston Edmondson (2nd nomination) User:Stuartyeates 10:17, 7 September 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Winston Edmondson (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5671 17005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soul Reaper (Bleach) User:Sephiroth 18:23, 15 July 2008 (UTC) delete all quite blatantly fail , #PLOT (and I'm sorry, Ynhockey, there's really no way I could possibly improve them that would allow them to pass NOTE). If possible, a Universe of Bleach article might be an appropriate merge target, but only after the material is heavily reduced Deletion of Soul Reaper (Bleach) WP:NOTE||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5672 3468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/China Garden Restaurants User:RichardOSmith 20:28, 5 February 2012 (UTC) delete http://www.google.co.uk/#sclient=psy-ab&hl=en&source=hp&q=how+many+chinese+restaurants+in+us&pbx=1&oq=how+many+chinese+res&aq=2&aqi=g4&aql=&gs_sm=c&gs_upl=2846l7961l0l9750l22l16l1l5l5l0l157l1474l10.6l22l0&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.,cf.osb&fp=531836a7026a05cc&biw=1415&bih=702 Aparrently there are about 40,000 Chinese Restaurants in the US alone. Whatever the actual number, I can belive this is a good one to visit, but I'm not seeing any reason for considering this one to be especially |notable Deletion of China Garden Restaurants WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5673 10388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sasha Compère User:The 10:46, 22 March 2019 (UTC) delete since subject fails Deletion of Sasha Compère WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5674 1399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elisabeth DeMarse User:Cerebellum 14:28, 4 December 2011 (UTC) keep She seems to have had enough reliable, third-party coverage to pass . Most of the results of https://www.google.com/#q=%22Elisabeth+DeMarse%22&hl=en&safe=off&tbs=ar:1&tbm=nws&prmd=imvnso&ei=oIHbTs6JC-L10gGm0uSEDg&start=0&sa=N&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.,cf.osb&fp=5a8580cc4be5acb6&biw=1366&bih=631 this google news search are paywalled, but here are few that are not: http://www.bizjournals.com/sacramento/news/2011/01/10/insweb-adds-board-member.html, a brief article about her, http://www.nytimes.com/2000/05/03/business/executive-changes-064491.html, which contains a paragraph about her, and http://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20060410005246/en/Austin-Ventures-Announces-Partnership-Elisabeth-DeMarse-Pursue, a fairly extensive profile of her. She was president and CEO of Bankrate and CreditCard.com, and also held senior positions at Bloomberg L.P., Citibank, and Hoover's, has been on the board of directors of several enterprises, and seems to have started her own company (DeMarseco) also, which is partnered with Austin Ventures Deletion of Elisabeth DeMarse WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5675 21688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tzvi Berkowitz User:Nmagedman 08:42, 14 May 2010 (UTC) keep Rav Berkowitz non-notable?! Is this a joke? Within the Chareidi religious community he is a very big name. Given the conversation that I'm seeing here, I'm really having a hard time adhering to . This is a spurious AFD Deletion of Tzvi Berkowitz WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
5676 13167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atlantic International University User:Miniapolis 23:38, 9 October 2015 (UTC) delete Unaccredited (one of the definitions of a Diploma mills in the United States|diploma mill) um, school does not meet , despite legal threats and SPAs Deletion of Atlantic International University WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5677 14855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ShamanDhia User:Mr 17:02, 15 March 2008 (UTC) delete Vanity/ CV page, fails , , , etc.... I would list for speedy if not for the references and how detailed it is Deletion of ShamanDhia WP:BIO||WP:COI||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5678 2838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antoniev Caves- Sacred place User:Oakshade 05:58, 26 September 2012 (UTC) keep """The writing might be """"silly"""", but it does appear to pass as there is significant coverage, in non-Ukrainian languages even. http://books.google.com/books?id=fgUV3ml_hsUC&pg=PT95&lpg=PT95&dq=%22%D0%90%D0%BD%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BD%D1%96%D1%94%D0%B2%D1%96+%D0%BF%D0%B5%D1%87%D0%B5%D1%80%D0%B8%22&source=bl&ots=u0fTtlM7qa&sig=DIfDgJSLDBE_VFZcoDjPVyFHpVA&hl=en&sa=X&ei=2pZiUPrsBMzSigK14oDwDQ&ved=0CEEQ6AEwAw#v=onepage&q=%22%D0%90%D0%BD%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BD%D1%96%D1%94%D0%B2%D1%96%20%D0%BF%D0%B5%D1%87%D0%B5%D1%80%D0%B8%22&f=false The http://uk.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%90%D0%BD%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BD%D1%96%D1%94%D0%B2%D1%96_%D0%BF%D0%B5%D1%87%D0%B5%D1%80%D0%B8_%28%D0%A7%D0%B5%D1%80%D0%BD%D1%96%D0%B3%D1%96%D0%B2%29 Ukrainian WP page appears to be much better written. (See g-translation http://translate.google.com/translate?sl=uk&tl=en&js=n&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&layout=2&eotf=1&u=http%3A%2F%2Fuk.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2F%25D0%2590%25D0%25BD%25D1%2582%25D0%25BE%25D0%25BD%25D1%2596%25D1%2594%25D0%25B2%25D1%2596_%25D0%25BF%25D0%25B5%25D1%2587%25D0%25B5%25D1%2580%25D0%25B8_%2528%25D0%25A7%25D0%25B5%25D1%2580%25D0%25BD%25D1%2596%25D0%25B3%25D1%2596%25D0%25B2%2529&act=url here""" Deletion of Antoniev Caves- Sacred place WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5679 4631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BaoFeng UV-5R User:Mark 21:34, 26 October 2019 (UTC) keep The ARRL, FCC and Hackaday sources are independent RS and there seems enough depth for and a modest article. --{{u| Deletion of BaoFeng UV-5R WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5680 21541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naum Koen User:Lapablo 20:37, 19 May 2019 (UTC) delete They're a few articles on the subject but its just not enough for . Defintely Deletion of Naum Koen WP:SIGCOV||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
5681 19231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Revelation Space races User:Piotrus 03:58, 16 June 2020 (UTC) delete Pure that belongs on Wikia, not here (fails Deletion of List of Revelation Space races WP:FANCRUFT||WP:NFICTION Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
5682 19220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Subramaniam Mohanadas User:Pharaoh 18:23, 23 September 2014 (UTC) keep As per DGG and Necrothesp. Clearly meets . The subject was the List of University of Jaffna people|Vice-Chancellor of the University of Jaffna.His appointment and qualification are controversial but the notability is unquestionable Deletion of Subramaniam Mohanadas WP:NACADEMICS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5683 4797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aum (unit) [[User talk:24.151.10.165|talk]]) 18:03, 8 January 2015 (UTC) keep Sarpler. An historical measure for wool. See, e.g., https://books.google.com/books?id=7S78AQAAQBAJ&pg=PA59&dq=Sarpler+wool&hl=en&sa=X&ei=WsSuVMGPEPTfsASVlIGIDA&ved=0CCgQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=Sarpler%20wool&f=false and https://books.google.com/books?id=TMEFFT-28CYC&pg=PA140&dq=Sarpler+wool&hl=en&sa=X&ei=WsSuVMGPEPTfsASVlIGIDA&ved=0CB0Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=Sarpler%20wool&f=false. Recommend '''Keep all''' per with no prejudice to renominating individual articles for deletion. Special:Contributions/24.151.10.165|24.151.10.165 Deletion of Aum (unit) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
5684 1046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jase Harper User:Lankiveil 22:05, 13 May 2010 (UTC) delete """going to go with """"not notable"""" at this time. I thought that the Ledger Awards might get him over the line, but I can't find any reliable reference to him winning them, and the award's page (ledgerawards.org) seems to be down. There's nothing else in the rest of the article as far as I can see which would have Harper meeting , but I'd be happy to be contradicted on that""" Deletion of Jase Harper WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5685 11206 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""Captivating"""" Corey Mason""" User:Whpq 12:07, 5 March 2011 (UTC) comment These types of wrestlers are covered by and not """Deletion of """"Captivating"""" Corey Mason""" WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5686 10357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Institute of Global Concern (2nd nomination) User:The 14:51, 7 August 2018 (UTC) merge as the subject's independent-notability claims are |unfounded Deletion of Institute of Global Concern (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5687 182 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/2005 Şemdinli Olayları """Kullanıcı:alibaz'''alibaz'''""" 15:55, 4 Şubat 2007 (UTC) delete Genelde ve bir çok yerde Vikipedi:Doğrulanabilirlik ilkelerinde ihlal.kaynaksız iddialar mevcut, ayrıca belirtilen kaynaklar sözkonusu olayın kapsamı bakımından güvenilirlikten uzak.Madde başlığıyla uygunsuz icerik olarak.Olayı değil Büyükanıt'ın nasıl aklandığını anlatıyor daha çok.madde genelkurmay'ın görüşlerine göre yazılmış.Başlık, '''Genel kurmaya göre 2005 Şemdimli Olayları''' şeklinde değiştirilmeyecekse silinsin 2005 Şemdinli Olaylarının silinmesi Vikipedi:Tarafsız bakış açısı Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
5688 16254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Advanced tic tac toe User:Deltahedron 06:18, 25 July 2014 (UTC) merge in the absence of further independent |reliable sources to establish |notability Deletion of Advanced tic tac toe WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5689 10123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Davidson L Haworth User:RightCowLeftCoast 01:58, 13 February 2012 (UTC) delete fails & Deletion of Davidson L Haworth WP:AUTHOR||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5690 1451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The LiveWire (2nd nomination) User:Twsx 11:58, 2 December 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of The LiveWire (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5691 1318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manipur State Constitution Act 1947 User:ChunnuBhai 10:41, 25 November 2020 (UTC) delete I dont see this article being more than few lines ever. Earlier the article was a copy paste of website e-pao.net and was trimmed down to avoid . The author has a history of copy pasting material from the same website into different articles. possible with Independent Manipur movement and SPA for the same Deletion of Manipur State Constitution Act 1947 WP:COPYVIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
5692 16471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ClickTime.com User:Gongshow 09:33, 13 September 2017 (UTC) delete I'm not coming up with any in-depth coverage in independent sources, either. This does not appear to meet or Deletion of ClickTime.com WP:GNG||WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5693 2262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The adventures of Clive and Banana boy User:Sergecross73 18:11, 17 July 2012 (UTC) delete Appears to be a |hoax Deletion of The adventures of Clive and Banana boy WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
5694 4217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malcolm Hall (fashion designer) User:Chiswick NONE keep the http://collections.vam.ac.uk/item/O163738/theatre-costume/ '''Victoria & Albert Museum''' link in the article decisively proves Notability - the museum, which is Britain's primary museum of fashion and design, only collects what it believes best represents the finest and most notable designers of each generation. Malcolm Hall has created not just the costume shown at the V&A for Jimmy Page of Led Zeppelin, but for many other rock stars and celebrities including royalty - Princess Diana. But I agree that some of the article's other references could have been better chosen - remember it was written by a newbie ewbie|Don't Bite The Newbies. I thought the article so obviously noteworthy even as newbie-drafted that I didn't bother looking for more sources... maybe I have to do that now Deletion of Malcolm Hall (fashion designer) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5695 19605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billy Jack Haskins User:Jreferee 01:29, 25 April 2007 (UTC) keep """There is enough material to write an |attributable article on the topic. Thus, the topic does meet Wikipedia |notability guidelines and can meet Wikipedia Wikipedia:List_of_policies#Content_and_Style|article policy standards. """"Who can forget the Billy Jack Haskins game at Commonwealth Stadium in 1995 when the Wildcats jumped out to a huge first-half lead only to watch the Vols storm back and pin a 34-31 loss on UK""" Deletion of Billy Jack Haskins WP:RS||WP:A||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5696 15916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Ku Klux Klan In Prophecy User:Skywriter 22:38, 7 January 2010 (UTC) merge There are way too many articles on this topic http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Pillar_of_Fire_Church and some are way overblown. The basis of this article is an early 20th century newsletter distributed by the Pillar of Fire Church, which is both an article and a category :Category:Pillar_of_Fire_Church on Wikipedia with many subtopics. The newsletter became this book and other of the books that have their own separate articles at Wikipedia. I am sure the enthusiasts who are placing these articles have good intentions but they seem to be stepping over the ot line into advocacy Deletion of The Ku Klux Klan In Prophecy WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5697 8449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cindu Chandrasekharan User:Armbrust 13:09, 13 September 2010 (UTC) delete as article fails |notability criteria for entertainers Deletion of Cindu Chandrasekharan WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
5698 12051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fouad Riaz Bajwa User:Marwatt 17:38, 12 November 2006 (UTC) delete I feel soory for Mr. Bajwa but the article has to go as per Deletion of Fouad Riaz Bajwa WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5699 14792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gloria Idahota Williams User:Bearian 20:09, 28 July 2014 (UTC) delete """There are very few Ghits about this person, other than social media. I can't |verify many of her roles. """"Award winning"""" generally means an Oscar, Tony, Obie, or similar major acting award, which she hasn't gotten""" Deletion of Gloria Idahota Williams WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5700 8032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hubert Invents the Wheel User:MarkZusab NONE keep per meeting criteria #1 through the reviews listed in my comment above Deletion of Hubert Invents the Wheel WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
5701 730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Climb Media User:K 04:10, 6 December 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet ; significant RS coverage not found. Insufficiently notable for a redirect even, and the article history is 100% spam & not worth preserving Deletion of Climb Media WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5702 7639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ava's Demon User:Sandstein 20:01, 8 July 2013 (UTC) keep """as creator, else userfy. Per , """"the number and nature of reliable sources needed varies depending on the depth of coverage and quality of the sources. Multiple sources are generally expected."""" In this case, I submit that the http://io9.com/in-a-spacefaring-future-a-girl-must-join-with-a-demon-483126533 one existing reliable source narrowly suffices to write a reasonably comprehensive and verifiable stub article, which is the point of the notability guideline""" Deletion of Ava's Demon WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5703 1571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of stations that air Casey Kasem's American Top 40: The 80's [[User talk:137.122.49.102|talk]]) 15:02, 20 April 2010 (UTC) delete per --Special:Contributions/137.122.49.102|137.122.49.102 Deletion of List of stations that air Casey Kasem's American Top 40: The 80's WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5704 5954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mobiscope User:MuZemike 18:18, 24 December 2008 (UTC) delete Notable or not, this is |blatant advertisement Deletion of Mobiscope WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
5705 18132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avidian User:Avb 20:04, 18 January 2006 (UTC) keep Lack of information is a reason to improve and expand. As to the two delete votes: If benefiting from having a WP article is a reason to delete, all articles on specific medication|drugs have to go just for starters. So far I've seen only one reason to delete - the company or its products may not be notable. Lacking useful policies and guidelines (or am I the only one thinking that declares all companies notable that have ever advertized in a paper?) it is my personal opinion that this company is notable because it is growing exponentially in a niche within an extremely competitive market (which I happen to know to some extent - the market, not Avidian or its products Deletion of Avidian WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5706 12791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erik Arvinder (2nd nomination) User:Dream 00:55, 5 November 2019 (UTC) keep You nominated this before already, it got relisted twice, and closed on 4 July 2019. Now you are trying again? Anyway, the Google news search results are mostly not in English. The Quietus is a reliable source and comments on him and his work at https://thequietus.com/articles/15672-roll-the-dice-until-silence-review. A musician is known for their work, and that many famous people wouldn't work with him for notable albums unless he was quite skilled. His work is part of something notable, so that makes him notable under the subject specific guidelines for musicians. Deletion of Erik Arvinder (2nd nomination) WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5707 2764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlos Corberán User:SportingFlyer 21:22, 25 August 2019 (UTC) keep Easily passes both and Deletion of Carlos Corberán WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5708 163 [[Willibald Caspari]] (gelöscht) NONE NONE delete Kasten|1= Die Tätigkeit als Pfarrer allein begründet keine Relevanz, im Gegenteil setzt #Persönlichkeiten im Themengebiet Religionen die Relevanzschwelle deutlich höher (nämlich beim Bischof) an. Eine Tätigkeit als Theologe (z.B. Veröffentlichungen) ist nicht belegt. Die Unterschrift bei der FC ist aufgrund der gemachten Einwände nicht relevanzstiftend. Die allgemeinen Relevanzkriterien für Verstorbene geben auch nichts her (also weder irgendein Lexikoneintrag noch eine Straßenbenennung wie in der verglichend zitierten LD Flebbe). Dass jede überhaupt irgendwo in der historischen Literatur erwähnte Person relevant sei, ist m.W. derzeit kein Konsens hier Löschung von Willibald Caspari Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
5709 13326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Triune Kingdom of Croatia, Slavonia, and Dalmatia NONE NONE comment """Oh, boy, somebody forgotten . To all users (and the closing Admin): sources denoting the usage of the term """"Triune Kingdom of Croatia, Slavonia, and Dalmatia"""" are valid as any other source for any other subject. If such name is used in literature, then we can safely assume that it meant something, and that meaning should be described in appropriate article. Or authors of following books had no clue, and proposer of deletion knows better and we all should listen to him and forget what is written in our books""" Deletion of Triune Kingdom of Croatia, Slavonia, and Dalmatia WP:CIVIL Wikipedia:Civility 37
5710 14015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prince Nicolas, Duke of Ångermanland User:Bearian 02:00, 7 August 2020 (UTC) delete or if necessary '''merge'''. This child is |barely notable. We |usually delete when we are unsure about child actors and crime victims. See also Deletion of Prince Nicolas, Duke of Ångermanland WP:BARE||WP:OUTCOMES||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
5711 20553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Freedom of Life User:MichaelQSchmidt 21:12, 6 August 2010 (UTC) delete I do not doubt the film screened... but after that it seems to have disappeared... and no reliable sources speak about it.http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Freedom+of+Life%22,+%22Sharat+Chandra%22&hl=en&prmd=o&ei=IXpcTI_nBpPGsAPO9bDvDw&start=30&sa=N. Fails and Deletion of Freedom of Life WP:GNG||WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5712 9216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alonzo Holt User:Gongshow 19:29, 4 March 2014 (UTC) merge """to Wrecking Ball (Miley Cyrus song)#Cover versions, which already contains: """"Canadian singer-songwriter Alonzo Holt released his own rendition of the track in October, which featured vocals from Arthur; it peaked at number 97 on the UK Singles Chart and number 71 on the Irish Singles Chart."""" As there is no other claim to notability, duplicating this info in a standalone Holt article seems rather unnecessary. Readers searching for this person are no doubt looking for info on his """"Wrecking Ball"""" cover, so a redirect to that section seems appropriate until (if) he achieves fame in some other way. As for meeting #2 of , the guideline also states that """"meeting any of these criteria does not mean that an article ''must'' be kept"""", and given the tiny amount of info on this person, I feel a redirect is the better way to go for the aforementioned reasons""" Deletion of Alonzo Holt WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5713 8072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miquel Antoine User:Redoryxx 18:47, 10 March 2021 (UTC) keep It looks like she satisfies Criteria 1 at based on citation counts at https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C47&q=Miquel+D.+Antoine&btnG= Google Scholar, but might be borderline. Leaning towards keep to bridge the Gender bias on Wikipedia|gender bias gap Deletion of Miquel Antoine WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5714 11776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clive Nolan User:Fetchcomms 17:30, 16 December 2010 (UTC) keep to whichever band article he is most known for. There is http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Clive+Nolan%22&sa=N&tbs=nws:1,ar:1 some coverage (mainly non-English) out there, and he seems to pass , but the large amounts of unsourced content taken from a website is concerning Deletion of Clive Nolan WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5715 2132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nelabhotla Venkateswarlu (3rd nomination) User:Bearian 13:02, 12 January 2021 (UTC) delete per , , , and . There is no way to fix this hot mess of an over-the-topic puff piece of a resume, for what is a run of the mill person. It seems they are involved in self-marketing, which is not really a substantive business. |Closing admin should consider salting it Deletion of Nelabhotla Venkateswarlu (3rd nomination) WP:TNT||WP:GNG||WP:MILL||WP:NOTRESUME||WP:SALT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
5716 21396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pyxis Corporation User:K 02:25, 16 June 2018 (UTC) merge to Cardinal_Health#Acquisitions; not independently notable. Sourcing does not meet ; just a business directory listing Deletion of Pyxis Corporation WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
5717 4682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anuwat Nuchit User:WikiVirusC 19:29, 21 February 2018 (UTC) keep Passes , as shown by the match summary report provided above from a competitive game in a Deletion of Anuwat Nuchit WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5718 3338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Demographic surveillance system User:Mark 22:50, 29 September 2017 (UTC) keep I have rewritten and expanded the article to include several paragraphs backed by 10 reliable sources, all secondary for the basic facts they support. DSS are an important part of public health monitoring in developing countries. The multiple RS in the article, including two books, show notability per Deletion of Demographic surveillance system WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5719 10184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rachael Faye Hill User:Fbifriday 07:53, 6 July 2010 (UTC) keep The one event is notable, and the media coverage appears relatively significant for inclusion. It's also hard to create an article for the event. Age related accomplishments are regularly included, as in the case of David Dicks, or Jessica Watson, even though they are all known for only one event. (And to those who are going to bring it up, I know, I know, .) I think that the event is notable, and the media coverage is significant enough to warrant, inclusion, however, I don't know if the wording of even allows for inclusion, that's why I'm saying weak keep. If it does, then keep Deletion of Rachael Faye Hill WP:WAX||WP:1E Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5720 11505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gridiron West User:Paulmcdonald 02:32, 30 November 2015 (UTC) delete fails and any other measure I can find. No independent sources. Would change my position of they are found Deletion of Gridiron West WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5721 16995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Christmas Detour User:Some 18:27, 21 December 2020 (UTC) delete per nom and as it fails Deletion of A Christmas Detour WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5722 12012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National Western Complex shooting User:NewYorkActuary 21:40, 8 February 2016 (UTC) delete """That's the question, isn't it? Whose """"magic ball"""" do we trust here -- the one that says the event will have lasting effects or the one that says it won't? My own magic ball says that this debate will get re-listed. If something noteworthy turns up by then, I'll be happy to reconsider my recommendation. But for now, . (By the way, Adog104, rating the article as C-class seems overly generous. But maybe that will be moot in a few days""" Deletion of National Western Complex shooting WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5723 4396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enjoy The Zoo User:J04n 01:26, 11 November 2009 (UTC) delete Can find no coverage from a , WBUZ (FM) is a local Nashville (actually LaVergne) station, it can be heard over the internet nationwide but so can just about any station. Can find nothing else that would support Deletion of Enjoy The Zoo WP:RS||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5724 8884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Estoclet User:Delta13C 08:38, 16 May 2016 (UTC) keep Meets as he is currently playing for a professional team in the highest level league in Italy Deletion of Adam Estoclet WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5725 3573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disneyland Dubai User:Unscented 16:52, 4 August 2009 (UTC) delete http://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=navclient-ff&ie=UTF-8&rlz=1B2GGFB_enCA225#rlz=1B2GGFB_enCA225&hl=en&q=%22disneyland+dubai%22&btnG=Google+Search&aq=f&oq=%22disneyland+dubai%22&aqi=&fp=-Pw1cEIpNGU Google and http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&ie=UTF-8&q=%22disneyland%20dubai%22&rlz=1B2GGFB_enCA225&sa=N&tab=wn&um=1 Google News do not reveal any |reliable sources for the article, and |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball. However, as the article concerns a theme park to be built in the United Arab Emirates, it's possible that there are sources in Arabic that aren't showing up from an English Google search Deletion of Disneyland Dubai WP:CRYSTAL||WP:reliable sources Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5726 7309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dahlia Kurtz User:Pharaoh 14:38, 12 September 2017 (UTC) delete Fails upcoming not notable at this point Deletion of Dahlia Kurtz WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5727 7635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sensis User:Joseph2302 10:48, 10 June 2015 (UTC) keep As stated on Talk:Sensis, there is no evidence that you are the primary topic that people search for when looking for Sensis- all 3 are valid search criteria. Therefore under no circumstances should this legitimate disambiguation page be deleted and replaced by an article for your company, per Deletion of Sensis WP:DISAMBIGUATION Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
5728 16679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of KaBlam! episodes User:23skidoo 22:55, 7 June 2008 (UTC) keep and expand. Since individual episode articles are frowned upon now, according to consensus, episode list articles are the preferred alternative. This is a series broadcast nationally on a major network; I see no reason why it doesn't warrant an episode list article. only applies to brand new original thought; it does not apply to lists of existing television episodes Deletion of List of KaBlam! episodes WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5729 3658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hard White (Nicki Minaj song) User:IndianBio 13:52, 2 November 2018 (UTC) delete In no way this passes for Deletion of Hard White (Nicki Minaj song) WP:GNG||WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5730 5489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Church of Israel User:Snotbot 02:07, 21 February 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 February 21 Deletion of Church of Israel WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
5731 5392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Chacon (2nd nomination) User:SheffieldSteel 20:45, 10 April 2008 (UTC) delete If Chacon has not been the subject of non-trivial coverage by independent |reliable sources, then there is no proof of |notability - and no way we can write an encyclopaedic article about him Deletion of Christopher Chacon (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5732 12603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allen Epley User:RP459 15:49, 20 February 2010 (UTC) delete Fails & no 3rd party coverage found of this individual. Disagree with proposed alternative merge into Shiner or other bands Deletion of Allen Epley WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5733 1625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chaos Prevails User:Esradekan 13:54, 15 April 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of Chaos Prevails WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5734 8327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional penguins User:Calathan 17:17, 18 June 2010 (UTC) comment I don't see how this list fails or . Whether something is a fictional penguin is easily determinable, and the number of notable fictional penguins would certainly be finite and of a manageable size for a list. Furthermore, being a fictional penguin links all of the listed characters in an obvious way, making the list well defined. The arguements for deletion seem to be based primarily on the poor quality of the current article, specifically that it currently includes a large number of non-notable entries. However, the solution to that issue is to remove the non-notable entries, not to delete the entire list Deletion of List of fictional penguins WP:IINFO||WP:SALAT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5735 20968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ventus (producer) User:Richard3120 11:22, 23 May 2018 (UTC) delete fails and , absolutely no notability beyond his own social media Deletion of Ventus (producer) WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5736 21931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caroline Jaden Stussi User:MichaelQSchmidt 00:34, 22 December 2012 (UTC) keep Yup, article is written in promotional tone, but deletion policy suggests that we |address tone and sourcing through regular editing when possible, |rather than delete. Like many actors, she has had many crappy and minor roles, but her recurring character of Scorpio in 7 episodes of ''12 Corazones'', as Janelle Ferrett in 21 episodes of ''Hallo Hollywood'', and as herself in 9 episodes of ''Descontrol'' meet the instructions of . We do not judge by the least of roles, but by overall career Deletion of Caroline Jaden Stussi WP:ATD||WP:PRESERVE||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5737 12799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EarthKry User:Oshwah 04:38, 30 April 2019 (UTC) delete Taking a look at the sources provided, nearly all of them consist of simple album reviews, general information, or trivial coverage about tour dates and live performances - nothing about the band itself or any significant impact that they (or any of their music) has had on culture, society, music, or history that's notable. I also couldn't locate any sources in my search that are reliable, provide primary coverage about the band's impact and notability, nor validate that any of their music has hit any national top records, charts, lists, etc or that they're recognized or received any awards from any major label, publisher, notable organization, or competition. This article subject fails as well as Deletion of EarthKry WP:NBAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5738 4917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Your Woman Sleep With Others User:doomsdayer520 16:42, 8 June 2020 (UTC) keep """Note that the process requires some tolerance of other languages. There is plenty of evidence in sources that are reliable, both in Taiwan and internationally, that this band has gained notice in their country, at a level that satisfies the """"coverage"""" requirements at """ Deletion of Your Woman Sleep With Others WP:BEFORE||WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
5739 16565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Safe hands User:TenPoundHammer 05:44, 25 March 2008 (UTC) delete The sources added don't seem to meet |the criteria for reliable sources; MySpace is ''definitely'' not reliable. Otherwise, this band seems to fail WP:MUSIC entirely Deletion of Safe hands WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5740 12199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/East Coast Heat F.C. User:Fenix 14:03, 29 January 2014 (UTC) keep per GS, team is playing in top level league in its country, so passes . Concede there are potential GNG issues here though, but want to see the article expanded if possible, as per current consensus at on clubs Deletion of East Coast Heat F.C. WP:FOOTYN||WP:FOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5741 2216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lupe Fiasco's Food & Liquor II: The Great American Rap Album (3rd nomination) User:Jorgath 19:28, 17 April 2012 (UTC) merge to Lupe Fiasco, '''without prejudice''' to recreation when the album is released. Until then, it's a violation of , even though it's clearly going to be notable. Twitter is not a reliable source Deletion of Lupe Fiasco's Food & Liquor II: The Great American Rap Album (3rd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5742 8429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Microsoft Store retail locations User:Clarityfiend 02:13, 28 March 2018 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is Deletion of List of Microsoft Store retail locations WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5743 10782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emediate User:Cabrils 04:42, 23 April 2019 (UTC) delete """Not notable. No references in a ProQuest search were found. Also worth noting that page was created by the account """"Andersschaffner"""" which strongly appears to be whose purpose was to create this page""" Deletion of Emediate WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
5744 19170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MVB Records User:Lesliechin1 08:34, 25 May 2021 (UTC) delete No significant news coverage. Does not meet Deletion of MVB Records WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5745 5576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal User:Dragonfiend 17:57, 11 February 2006 (UTC) delete Does not meet Deletion of Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
5746 4611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ImpressCMS User:LinguistAtLarge 21:47, 23 January 2009 (UTC) keep This piece of software has |verifiable |notability, as I demonstrated by adding half a dozen |reliable sources to the article. It has also won an award. If more sources are wanted, they can easily be had. Deletion of ImpressCMS WP:V||WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5747 9682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sophia Stewart User:Dennisthe2 01:02, 20 November 2009 (UTC) delete Going per Blinking Spirit's argument above. Article is a major case of - it's not about Sophia, it's about the circumstances around her lawsuits Deletion of Sophia Stewart WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
5748 307 [[Vorlage:CE]] (erl. bleibt) Benutzer:Hoch auf einem Baum NONE keep diese regel auf ist mir schon lange ein dorn im auge, weil oft gerade die besten links darunter fallen - zum glück wird sie bereits weitgehend ignoriert. sie sollte allein schon aus dem grund entfernt werden, dass sich die herren aus dem extrem rechten politischen spektrum, denen die links auf das lexikon des Informationsdienst gegen Rechtsextremismus in artikeln über gewisse personen stets ein dorn im auge sind (Diskussion:Armin Mohler|beispiel), darauf berufen könnten. grüße Löschung von Vorlage:CE Wikipedia:Verlinken Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
5749 7266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raymond Leslie Morris User:Location 06:00, 10 September 2009 (UTC) comment Regarding the concerns regarding , the article has virtually been rewritten since it was listed for Afd: http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Raymond_Leslie_Morris&oldid=311592094 Deletion of Raymond Leslie Morris WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5750 20526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stillblade User:Lightdarkness 06:48, 26 January 2006 (UTC) delete as recreated article per See http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special%3ALog&type=delete&user=&page=Stillblade Block Log: Stillblade Deletion of Stillblade WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5751 12465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fernando Obama User:Fenix 15:38, 16 February 2018 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Fernando Obama WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5752 20545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buhawian User:Happyme22 23:34, 18 May 2008 (UTC) delete per , as it appears to be an essay on a relatively unknown topic Deletion of Buhawian WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5753 3569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zack Vank User:wknight94 12:06, 21 February 2007 (UTC) delete I've also added a |prod tag to Dooney which was created by the same author (who will be indefblocked unless one of these three articles proves to have some validity Deletion of Zack Vank WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
5754 3601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sex swing User:Flyer22 04:48, 10 September 2016 (UTC) comment Wikipedia articles are supposed to be based on their coverage in eliable sources. Do see otability. The above keep arguments are weak Deletion of Sex swing WP:R||WP:N Wikipedia:Redirect 56
5755 13128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cary Herrman User:Doc 14:55, 20 June 2008 (UTC) delete Non-notable person who fails and a possible (but probable) Deletion of Cary Herrman WP:BIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
5756 14590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/L/L Research User:Verbal 10:19, 25 August 2009 (UTC) delete Currently fails and , with no claiming or asserting notability, and no RS showing significant coverage Deletion of L/L Research WP:GNG||WP:ORG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5757 109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Types of torture used in the Japanese occupation of Singapore User:Arskwad 18:32, 24 May 2010 (UTC) delete this is what might call an unencyclopedic cross-categorization... like fast food chains in 1950s England, or new york senators named dave... yeah you could source it... but it's better off covered as part of a bigger article... maybe Japanese war crimes or Japanese occupation of Singapore Deletion of Types of torture used in the Japanese occupation of Singapore WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5758 10348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tin Pei Ling User:Hans 20:44, 2 May 2011 (UTC) keep as she passes . I note that there are broken links in the references section. In particular the link in the last footnote http://www.temasekreview.com/2011/04/05/wrong-to-let-tin-pei-ling-sneak-into-parliament/ does not work for me (server not found), although I can see the content of the page in the Google cache. I also note for editors from Singapore that offline sources and non-English sources are OK both as references in the article and for making it even clearer that she passes Deletion of Tin Pei Ling WP:BASIC||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5759 11444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nash Paints User:Anachronist 06:57, 14 June 2018 (UTC) comment When I first saw this article, it was completely unsourced. Since then, sources have been added. The question is, are the sources sufficient to meet Deletion of Nash Paints WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5760 17681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Midnight Insanity User:Otto4711 18:18, 16 October 2007 (UTC) delete simple guest shots on TV series are not sufficient to get an individual past and ought not to be enough for a performance troupe. The single newspaper story linked in the article does not IMHO establish the notability of the group. I've searched previously to try to source this article and was never able to find anything. Worth at best a name-check in the article about the film's cult following Deletion of Midnight Insanity WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5761 9680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qorikuxaar User:PWilkinson 21:58, 8 April 2018 (UTC) comment Just to point out that Cebuano Wikipedia seems (to someone who had never knowingly met the language before) to have :ceb:Qori Kuxaar|a better (and more accurate) article on this topic than we do here - written by Lsjbot|a bot. The sources given are all English-language ones, which I think I would trust for verifiability if notability was otherwise established. However, what I can't tell for certain is whether the Cebuano article gives anything beyond statistical-level data - if it does, then would be established, but I suspect that it does not Deletion of Qorikuxaar WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5762 8598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Phillips (soccer) User:Sir 23:53, 1 February 2015 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and . I have no objection to moving it to draft, but clearly this does not belong in the article namespace yet Deletion of Josh Phillips (soccer) WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5763 13021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Otto Middleton user:ErrantX 08:32, 5 May 2011 (UTC) delete """the whole article is full of """"alleged"""" and """"claimed"""", that's a terrible start to begin with. Also; does not really pass the , is trivial un-encyclopaedic rubbish. At most worth a line or two in Kate's article""" Deletion of Otto Middleton WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5764 14522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Concurrent average memory access time User:Esquivalience 23:08, 8 August 2015 (UTC) delete except for a ''very short'' mention in the Average memory access time article for |weight, as a non-notable concept Deletion of Concurrent average memory access time WP:DUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
5765 13501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Envy (pornstar) User:TheBilly 10:30, 3 January 2008 (UTC) delete per #A7|CSD A7. Just another porn actor that fails —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Envy (pornstar) WP:CSD||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5766 7426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Aquanettas User:Eddie 16:45, 23 September 2008 (UTC) keep They may have been minor league but they seem to meet . Wikipedia has many articles on bands of a similar ilk Deletion of The Aquanettas WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5767 19253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Butthugger User:Dbtfz 00:39, 9 April 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of Butthugger WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
5768 13744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Floyd User:Tedder 07:57, 15 May 2010 (UTC) keep Appears to (barely) meet Deletion of Chris Floyd WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5769 4394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jens Erik Gould User:Jmertel23 18:49, 11 December 2018 (UTC) delete I can't find any independent, reliable sources with significant coverage. Therefore, the subject fails ; he is simply not notable enough to warrant an article Deletion of Jens Erik Gould WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5770 3395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elastic men/women fetish User:GIen 01:06, 9 August 2006 (UTC) delete Until such time as is met I would assume this is a hoax Deletion of Elastic men/women fetish WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5771 13363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WWE: Uncaged VIII User:Sergecross73 12:34, 20 May 2019 (UTC) delete per failing the . Its probably too late to bundle them in now, but a bunch of these WWE music albums could probably be bundled together in a future AFD too Deletion of WWE: Uncaged VIII WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5772 4992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Professional Practices for Business Continuity Management User:ZI 16:29, 19 July 2018 (UTC) delete Does not meet . Warm Regards Deletion of The Professional Practices for Business Continuity Management WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5773 17492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myles Cochrane [[User_talk:Bradv|Brad]] 23:05, 18 April 2010 (UTC) delete Almost none of the material in the article can be sourced to |reliable secondary sources. None of the sources listed in the article establish the notability of the subject Deletion of Myles Cochrane WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5774 16959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seaholme railway station, Melbourne User:Jakew 19:09, 21 May 2008 (UTC) keep I don't subscribe to the concept of inherent notability. However, although the usual Books, Scholar, and News searches were somewhat disappointing, this station does seem to have attracted some independent attention in reliable web sources, as evidenced by many of the results in http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&as_qdr=all&q=seaholme+railway+station+Melbourne+filetype%3Apdf&btnG=Search&meta= this PDF search. Hence, I think it just scrapes past , and there is evidence of potential to satisfy Deletion of Seaholme railway station, Melbourne WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
5775 1289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Sean User:AmaryllisGardener 16:51, 28 November 2014 (UTC) keep Seems to pass Deletion of Christopher Sean WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5776 4489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ramona Jennex [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 19:15, 17 May 2009 (UTC) delete per |promotion lack of notability, and an unsourced BLP Deletion of Ramona Jennex WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
5777 12191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Gaston User:Icewhiz 13:00, 10 April 2019 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass on NFOOTY, and while there is some coverage it does not rise, in my opinion, to SIGCOV. Quite possibly a case of Deletion of Tom Gaston WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
5778 1103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deadly Impact User:Taylor 19:06, 21 August 2014 (UTC) keep Three reviews by reliable publications exist. DVD Verdict: http://www.dvdverdict.com/reviews/deadlyimpact.php Two DVD Talks: http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/43895/deadly-impact-unrated/ http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/42226/deadly-impact/. There is also a brief review http://www.northjersey.com/arts-and-entertainment/new-on-dvd-this-week-1.953887 here. According to IMDb the Mansfield News Journal also reviewed it, but their link is dead and I can't find any archives. In any case, this movie seems to pass Deletion of Deadly Impact WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
5779 14018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Madin User:ANode 06:32, 6 November 2018 (UTC) delete Zero independant coverage online, fails Deletion of Chris Madin WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5780 3270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blake Palmer User:The 19:16, 25 December 2019 (UTC) delete since subject fails and Deletion of Blake Palmer WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5781 13968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shamsurrahman (Afghan cricketer) User:Pharaoh 10:32, 19 August 2016 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Shamsurrahman (Afghan cricketer) WP:NCRIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5782 550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jane Speed User:Qworty 06:02, 31 October 2012 (UTC) delete """for failing and . I wish we could delete it for its lousy writing style: """"It was in the late fall of 1948 that she consulted with her long-beloved husband and took the momentous decision to pluck her eyebrows fortnightly."""" If there's such a thing as a writing gene, he sure didn't inherit it from his pretty mom, rest her soul""" Deletion of Jane Speed WP:AUTHOR||WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
5783 15774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Habibullah Mir User:TimothyBlue 01:17, 6 November 2020 (UTC) delete Tragic, but this is that fails , and . I don't believe it would have much chance if rewritten as a event. // Deletion of Habibullah Mir WP:1E||WP:LASTING||WP:GNG||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
5784 14751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Centres of influence User:Otr500 03:06, 9 April 2018 (UTC) delete What Wikipedia is not#Wikipedia is not a dictionary|Wikipedia is not a dictionary or |an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of Centres of influence WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5785 7878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tristan Zand User:Whisperjanes 21:54, 14 July 2020 (UTC) delete From what I can tell through a Google search, doesn't meet . This is also possibly a |promotional or |COI article, since the page creator has a long history of creating/editing Dualphotography, a term that was coined by, and has only been mentioned in sources written by, Tristan Zand Deletion of Tristan Zand WP:GNG||WP:PROMO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
5786 15771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shahra Razavi NONE NONE keep """per above points and in line with fulfilling through Criteria 7. Edited that Ravazi was an invited contributor to a Japan's journal on National Institute of Population and Social Security Research|welfare policies discussion; Ravazi's analysis as UNRISD officerIn the ''Special issue: International comparison of care'', http://www.ipss.go.jp/syoushika/bunken/data/pdf/19249304.pdf accessed 23 February 2020, pdf {{issn|1344-3062}} {{in lang|ja}}. on care giving sectors among six Asian countries binds topics by Japanese researchershttps://www.worldcat.org/search?q=kw%3A2010-Spr.+ti%3A%E6%B5%B7%E5%A4%96%E7%A4%BE%E4%BC%9A%E4%BF%9D%E9%9A%9C%E7%A0%94%E7%A9%B6&qt=lang_switch&fq=yr%3A2010&se=as&sd=asc&lang=en Contribution by Japanese researchers around Ravazi's article, {{issn|1344-3062}} {{in lang|ja}}., evoking a long term discussion.Emiko Ochiai; Leo Aoi Hosoya. """"https://www.worldcat.org/title/transformation-of-the-intimate-and-the-public-in-asian-modernity/oclc/984803155?referer=di&ht=edition Transformation of the intimate and the public in Asian modernity"""", translated from Japanese; {{oclc|984803155""" Deletion of Shahra Razavi WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5787 16698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andreas Hoffman User:Papaursa 19:13, 16 November 2014 (UTC) delete I don't see evidence that he meets either or Deletion of Andreas Hoffman WP:GNG||WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5788 18050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lida Hensley User:Hobbes 02:18, 26 May 2012 (UTC) merge to Universal Life Church. The article itself has one dead link to a primary source. What I found searching Google News, Books, and generally were primary sources, this article, its mirrors, and trivial mentions. Her presidency of this California-based organization lasted from 1999-2006, a fairly media-saturated time and place. If the ULC is so exceedingly notable that one could fairly assume its former president notable, then it should be easy to find substantial, independent, |reliable sources. Instead, not a single one has even been offered for debate. Fails Deletion of Lida Hensley WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5789 13183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eunice Sanborn (2nd nomination) user:Ricky81682 10:52, 11 November 2015 (UTC) keep She was thought to be world's oldest person is itself have |notability. revocation of the record will not be a lose of notability. user:Ricky81682 is issued deletion discussions of a large amount, but some of them is indisputably abnormal Deletion of Eunice Sanborn (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5790 16075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seth Mandel User:E 08:09, 11 October 2018 (UTC) keep """Mandel has had more than enough coverage to pass notability. Mandel's job changes, marriage, and more to the point, his writing gets covered in articles like: ''The Hill,'' https://thehill.com/homenews/media/401542-cnns-stelter-new-york-posts-mandel-clash-over-de-blasio CNN’s Stelter, New York Post’s Mandel clash over de Blasio; Vox https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/10/4/17936664/brett-kavanaugh-republicans-never-trump-sham """"Mandel, in his Atlantic piece, argued that"""", and many similar. '''Notable journalist, conservative pundit, and editor.''' and '''Note''' that the question at AfD is not what's already on the page, but what coverage exists. Nom's assertion that so page is inadequate is not an argument """ Deletion of Seth Mandel WP:DELETIONISNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5791 9919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How to vote in Broward County User:MuZemike 00:14, 4 December 2008 (UTC) delete edit conflict) #HOWTO|Wikipedia is not a how-to. The instructor of this class should know better than have his/her students write their papers and place them here. Wikipedia does approve of school projects, but I am thinking this is clearly not one of them Deletion of How to vote in Broward County WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5792 1617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J. P. Calderon User:Black 21:15, 24 February 2007 (UTC) keep Yes, consensus can change, but not this fast. I won't say that the nomination is as the nom may not have checked the talk page Deletion of J. P. Calderon WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
5793 1499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dwayne Boyd User:CaroleHenson 01:07, 5 December 2016 (UTC) delete I really want to vote weak keep. I see https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Dwayne+Boyd%22+actor&rlz=1C5CHFA_enUS690US690&oq=%22Dwayne+Boyd%22&aqs=chrome.0.69i59j69i57j0l4.4492j0j4&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8#q=%22Dwayne+Boyd%22+actor&tbm=nws some news articles and information about his acting school and related events back to 2010, but I agree that it seems . I'm not finding quite enough at this time Deletion of Dwayne Boyd WP:TOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
5794 18627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael C. Seto User:James 15:30, 19 August 2012 (UTC) keep the article appears to be well-referenced, and the subject should pass under category 7 (influence outside academia) on the basis of noted testimony before US committees and commissions. The argument that the author is an seems to be somewhat spurious Deletion of Michael C. Seto WP:ACADEMIC||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Notability 77
5795 158 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Emin Atlı """Kullanıcı:vito genovese'''vito genovese'''""" 05:10, 12 Ekim 2009 (UTC) delete M6'dan direkt silinebilir. kriterlerini karşılamıyor Emin Atlı'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
5796 15482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess Loko User:doomsdayer520 15:08, 14 June 2020 (UTC) delete I am sorry to hear of her recent untimely death, but this article runs afoul of . There are some fairly reliable news sources announcing her death, but otherwise the nominator is correct about her lack of notability as a musician. For her actual music, only the routine streaming and social media listings can be found Deletion of Princess Loko WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5797 1409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aero Charter User:Hydronium 04:00, 9 March 2016 (UTC) delete """There's a number of GHits under """"Аеро Чартер"""" or """"Аеро-Чартер"""", though they appear mundane and mostly of questionable reliability. The Ukranian Wikipedia https://uk.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%92%D1%96%D0%BA%D1%96%D0%BF%D0%B5%D0%B4%D1%96%D1%8F:%D0%92%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B0%D0%BB%D0%B5%D0%BD%D1%96_%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B0%D1%82%D1%82%D1%96-%D0%B0%D1%80%D1%85%D1%96%D0%B27#.D0.90.D0.B5.D1.80.D0.BE-.D0.A7.D0.B0.D1.80.D1.82.D0.B5.D1.80_5.E2.80.943 voted to delete its article. ikiProject Aviation/Notability points at otability %28Transportation%29#Airlines, and that just lists |discussion in multiple, reliable sources. Even if common practice happens to be to retain airlines with scheduled flights, I'm not convinced that it's warranted here with cargo rather than passenger flights, and the contents of the article appears at risk of being and becoming inaccurate given the lack of RS and that it appears to be a snapshot of a particular time. Did the airline always operate with the listed destinations and aircraft? Does the airline still exist, and if not List of defunct airlines of Ukraine|when did it cease operations""" Deletion of Aero Charter WP:W||WP:N||WP:GNG Help:Watchlist 110
5798 116 [[800xA]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Holmium 09:37, 2. Okt. 2015 (CEST) keep Kasten|1= per Rechtsbeugung. Der Artikel ist nach wie vor nicht behaltbar, denn es fehlt an Sekundärquellen, welche die allgemeine Bekanntheit und Bedeutung des Produktes spiegeln. ist jedem Artikelautor nahezulegen. Ich entscheide dennoch aus purem Mitleid auf Behalten, denn es wäre schade um die vertane Zeit und der Artikel lässt sich meines Erachtens per http://www.technica-online.ch/artikel/800xa-abb-erhaelt-energietechnik-auftrag-ueber-73-millionen-us-dollar-in-der-schweiz-abb-darf-das/ und http://www.chemietechnik.de/texte/anzeigen/120988/Automatisieren/PLS-Steuerungen-Regler/ABB-stellt-neue-Version-seines-Prozessleitsystems-vor/ABB-Prozessleitsystem-800xA-Industrie-40+ABB-Automation-GmbH mit ausreichenden Einzelnachweisen/Belegen versehen. Noch besser wäre ein Review von PLSen in einer Fachzeitschrift, falls sich der findet? {{Ping|ColaNeune}} du bist zu dieser Nacharbeit aufgerufen. Falls keine Reaktion erfolgt, bitte mich anpingen, notfalls mach ich das selbst - dann müsst ihr alle euch aber schämen Löschung von 800xA Wikipedia:Belege Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5799 10050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Høgni Reistrup User:Hansi667 10:21, 18 January 2016 (UTC) keep The subject is extensively covered by |reliable sources, and thus it should stay per . I can find hundreds of articles on him on Faroese media (http://www.in.fo/search-results-solr/?q=H%C3%B8gni+Reistrup&id=49&L=0&search.x=0&search.y=0 in.fo, http://portal.fo/?search_for=H%C3%B8gni+Reistrup portal.fo). Apart from this, I can also find media coverage coming from Denmark (http://gaffa.dk/nyhed/40792?ref=camefromrelatedleft gaffa.dk), Germany (http://www.spiegel.de/unispiegel/jobundberuf/faeroeer-inseln-warum-viele-studenten-in-die-heimat-zurueckkehren-a-998620.html Der Spiegel, and http://www.deutschlandfunk.de/musiker-hoegni-reistrup-die-anziehungskraft-der-heimat.807.de.html?dram:article_id=303313 Deutschlandfunk), and Iceland (http://www.visir.is/hogni-spilar-a-islandi/article/2012703019995 visir.is). is covered by the amount of sources on the subject, and is totally irrelevant since the subject meets beyond question, and by the fact that he is not notable as an academic. I think the AfD should be withrdawn, but at the same time more reliable sources should be added in the article Deletion of Høgni Reistrup WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5800 11742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Biotech industry in Boston User:Jamez42 16:12, 12 January 2018 (UTC) comment """The article could be renamed as a list if it meets the notability criteria. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Biotech_industry_in_Boston&type=revision&diff=819894879&oldid=819877070 While the last editions were a significant contribution for the content, per I wish to give Biotechnology industry in China and Biotechnology in India as examples, as they include more comprehensive information regarding the industry as a whole. One of my concerns is also that an article only about Boston is too obscure, so I also encourage simply creating """"Biotechnology industry in the United States""" Deletion of Biotech industry in Boston WP:OSE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5801 9586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trento-Bondone Hill Climb User:Lukeno94 22:17, 16 December 2013 (UTC) keep It's a hillclimb track used in an FIA sanctioned continental event. Evidence is really not hard to find;. Given that this is fairly high up on a generic Google search, I'm questioning whether was really adhered to; given that the first route, and the route that turns up the most sources, which is to simply Google it, was clearly not followed Deletion of Trento-Bondone Hill Climb WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
5802 15034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edenton Bell Battery User:AustralianRupert 03:42, 7 July 2009 (UTC) keep there now appears to be quite a few sources about this military unit following rescue work mentioned above. I believe that the article probably meets |notability guidelines and can be expanded/improved by interested editors Deletion of Edenton Bell Battery WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5803 7726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pull a Family Guy [[User talk:Erpert|(let's talk about it)]] 07:37, 9 July 2010 (UTC) delete I have to agree with Carrite and urge everyone to |get out their shovels. '''Erpert Deletion of Pull a Family Guy WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
5804 18512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gin (drinking game rules) User:FrankTobia 22:24, 1 May 2008 (UTC) delete as . Notability is suspect. Looking for |reliable sourcing for such a topic is completely non-trivial, and from my preliminary search I doubt they exist Deletion of Gin (drinking game rules) WP:OR||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
5805 12473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Forever (website) User:K 04:12, 26 September 2016 (UTC) comment Pittsburgh Post-Gazette'', the ''Detroit Free Press'', and the ''Pittsburgh Tribune-Review'' are all regional press, not meeting requirement. This is insufficient for notability Deletion of Forever (website) WP:AUD Wikipedia:Notability 77
5806 5256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cubicle 7 User:Scarpy 19:29, 21 August 2018 (UTC) delete not a gamer here, but to my eyes this looks non-notable and the discussion regarding the 20 page chapter is not particularly relevant here as there is so much in this article. If a comprehensive article could be written using multiple reliable independent sources with in depth coverage, would reverse me decision Deletion of Cubicle 7 WP:SPS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5807 12402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Obscurity (recording) User:Jayron32 14:41, 13 June 2009 (UTC) delete Pink Floyd is a notable band, and all of its officially sanctioned albums are usually notable as well. However, everytime some fan sneaks a tape recorder into a concert and then has a few hundred albums pressed of that recording does not make THAT a notable album. There are occasional bootlegs which will meet the and criteria, but those are rare and are recordings which are historically significant. This is just another bootleg of a Pink Floyd concert, of which there are likely hundreds, and this one shows no evidence that it is particularly notable Deletion of Obscurity (recording) WP:N||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5808 1871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albania–Australia relations User:timtempleton 19:27, 10 July 2017 (UTC) delete seems very thin, and reminds me of the discussion for Bahamian British, also under deletion review. There would be over 37,000 articles if we tried to pair every country up, and without significant evidence that relations are covered with any regularity in the press, this fails . Also should look at this one. Albania–Australia bilateral treaties Deletion of Albania–Australia relations WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5809 11902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All Spectre Appearances User:JIP 06:52, 25 November 2012 (UTC) delete a textbook example of |Wikipedia is not a directory. This is just a list for the sake of being a list Deletion of All Spectre Appearances WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5810 17376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hicham Oudghiri User:Ahg0606 20:21, 25 July 2018 (UTC) keep This entry cites two New York Times articles about this personhttps://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/23/technology/data-mining-start-up-enigma-to-expand-commercial-business.htmlhttps://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/16/technology/a-harvest-of-company-details-all-in-one-basket.html, who is the co-founder and CEO of a Enigma (company)|100+ person tech company, as well as a U.S. Patent held by the subject for his inventionhttps://patents.google.com/patent/US20140222826A1/en and articles from other credible media outlets including Fast Companyhttps://www.fastcompany.com/90130247/public-data-is-more-important-than-ever-and-now-its-easier-to-find, TechCrunchhttps://techcrunch.com/2013/05/01/and-the-winner-of-techcrunch-disrupt-ny-2013-is-enigma/, PCMaghttps://www.pcmag.com/article/357903/how-to-apply-big-data-to-the-real-world and others. I believe this suffices to meet . As far as the creator (me) having few edits outside of this topic, while it is true that I am relatively new to Wikipedia, I do not believe that should factor into the credibility of this article, for which I have attempted to provide ample sourcing and maintain a neutral tone for all claims. If there are things that can be done to make this article better, I would love input, rather than simply deleting it! Thank you Deletion of Hicham Oudghiri WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5811 13588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Papillon Soo Soo User:Wee 10:11, 26 March 2019 (UTC) keep A close call but just scrapes into . Role in a Bond film is notable, significant cult following for the FMJ role. Article needs expanding though Deletion of Papillon Soo Soo WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5812 986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camp Bow Wow User:HighKing 18:57, 30 June 2020 (UTC) delete I am unable to locate any |significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, references to date fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic therefore fails GNG/ Deletion of Camp Bow Wow WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5813 21 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kinsey Wolanski User:Ceethekreator 23:28, 2 June 2019 (UTC) delete fails . Simply running across a field doesn't establish notability Deletion of Kinsey Wolanski WP:NMODEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5814 13007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glasshouse (novel) User:23skidoo 00:03, 9 February 2007 (UTC) keep A Google search reveals tons of references to this book being available and discussed, plus it's a followup to a book for which an article exists -- but individual novels are also notable. Needs expansion, but that's what is for. I'm also adding it to the NovelsWikiProject which will result in users adding infobox, etc. in due course. (Never mind, someone already has Deletion of Glasshouse (novel) WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
5815 6408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamiah Islamiah Talimuddin Dabhel User:davidwr 22:09, 29 August 2015 (UTC) comment """pending evidence from independent, reliable sources that this school meets either , , , or any other relevant notability guideline. Being """"100 years old with 1000 students"""" is highly suggestive that such sources exist, but not conclusive enough for a """"free pass"""" on finding them""" Deletion of Jamiah Islamiah Talimuddin Dabhel WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES||WP:CORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5816 11263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/And you are lynching Negroes User:Krimpet 01:29, 9 April 2007 (UTC) keep the article's a bit of a mess but it does appear to be a historically important expression. There's already one |source; more could certainly be found Deletion of And you are lynching Negroes WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
5817 8926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myron Belkind User:Ruhri_Jörg 13:22, 20 August 2019 (UTC) delete """though as creator of the page I'm a bit biased, I've checked sources etc. again and agree with all above (except that it isn't corporate spam ;)). At the time I was still new (as I still feel compared to most of you) to Wiki and felt like the award, his presidency at the National_Press_Club_(United_States)|National Press Club and other positions might be enough to meet |general notability. Hurts me to see a """"deletion"""" in my account history, but that's life I guess :D Thank you all for weighing in""" Deletion of Myron Belkind WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5818 11397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amish boy in africa User:Doc 20:29, 19 July 2008 (UTC) delete per possible |made up |hoax, largely because of the lack of http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Amish+Boy+In+Africa%22&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a ghits outside of Wikipedia Deletion of Amish boy in africa WP:CRYSTAL||WP:NFT||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5819 1483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HiveOnDemand User:Ihcoyc 16:47, 7 January 2010 (UTC) delete also #G11|unambiguous advertising: ''provides a quick, easy way for individuals and small to medium sized businesses to build, edit and manage dynamic treemaps without the need for specialized IT infrastructure and personnel Deletion of HiveOnDemand WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5820 13640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Professor Joe Carrington User:Ultraexactzz 02:30, 12 October 2007 (UTC) delete My Google search matches yours - there isn't any data to suggest that this professor is in any way notable. If, for some reason, Prof. Carrington becomes notable, or receives coverage in the press for some notable act or event, then an article might be appropriate. I presume that the professor is alive, bringing into play as well Deletion of Professor Joe Carrington WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
5821 4517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/British Rail Class 37, 37427 User:MickMacNee 16:43, 26 April 2008 (UTC) delete """While trying to find some notability, I came across this statement from the author """"She is one of the most popular 37/4 ever built, due to her reliability."""". I'm pretty certain this falls well below the standards for wikipedia. A good read is the authors fotopic site, http://37427.fotopic.net/, the section on the left """"Why are you obsessed with 37427 when you've never seen her?"""". I'm not entirely sure what thrash and clag is, but it sounds exciting""" Deletion of British Rail Class 37, 37427 Wikipedia:Notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
5822 15996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ChessBase India User:Usedtobecool 17:52, 19 May 2020 (UTC) merge to ChessBase. Merge, if there's anything to merge. The work will remain safe in history to be picked up again, after the organisation gets some Deletion of ChessBase India WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
5823 13359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hydrogel agriculture User:Bearian 22:55, 7 February 2017 (UTC) keep because of the |significant improvements to the article. Wow, kudos to {{U|Chiswick Chap Deletion of Hydrogel agriculture WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
5824 2703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hypnose (cigarette) User:Cocytus 22:18, 6 January 2010 (UTC) delete does not appear to satisfy in order to merit inclusion Deletion of Hypnose (cigarette) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5825 253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Power (actor) User:Iowateen 02:12, 5 May 2009 (UTC) delete Non-notable |actor Deletion of Sean Power (actor) WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
5826 60 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/(I Do Not) Hook Up User:Esradekan 01:05, 23 January 2009 (UTC) delete as a non-plausible search term, fails notability per #Songs Deletion of (I Do Not) Hook Up WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5827 10771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Engrish (2nd nomination) User:HMSSolent 12:25, 20 May 2013 (UTC) keep under and , clearly well-referenced and is notable enough to warrant an article in its own right Deletion of Engrish (2nd nomination) WP:CENSORED||WP:POINT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5828 18179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boris Willis User:Top 09:48, 7 November 2010 (UTC) keep substantial coverage online in GNEWS archives per on his performances and choreography from the Wash Post, Wash Times, Miami Herald, JFK Center website, etc., though most of the GNEWS archive hits are unfortunately behind paywalls Deletion of Boris Willis WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5829 12520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tommy Lynn Calhoun User:DoubleGrazing 05:58, 29 April 2021 (UTC) delete as nommed. Had she not been tackled (how did she arrange that, I wonder?) and got some BLP1E coverage, there'd be nothing; now there's very close to nothing. Fails by a country mile Deletion of Tommy Lynn Calhoun WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5830 13622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephanie Braganza User:E 12:26, 2 May 2017 (UTC) delete possibly it's just . Local papers do count towards notability, they just don't count very much. I'm just not seeing enough coverage in major media, or enough significant achievement (prizes) to pass Deletion of Stephanie Braganza WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
5831 13079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sgha User:Kinu 01:12, 14 August 2006 (UTC) delete non-notable local amateur league. Fails , probably , , and ANITY as well Deletion of Sgha WP:ORG||WP:V||WP:OR||WP:VANITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5832 15074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Legend of Zelda Fan Community User:TheJC 17:18, 28 June 2006 (UTC) delete """per above. Article fails on the three main content policies: |No Original Research, |Neutral Point of View representing views fairly and without bias, and |Articles should contain only material that has been published by reputable sources. |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information, |Wikipedia is not a mirror or a repository of links, images, or media files, most of the links on the page fit |Occasionally acceptable links — although fails because of the number of external links: """"Fan sites: On articles about topics with many fansites, including a link to one major fansite is appropriate, marking the link as such. In extreme cases, a link to a web directory of fansites can replace this link."""" — and the article also appears to fail |Criteria for web content""" Deletion of Legend of Zelda Fan Community WP:NOR||WP:NPOV||WP:VERIFY||WP:NOT||WP:NOT||WP:EL||WP:WEB Wikipedia:No original research 65
5833 4203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Living Death (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:25, 12 September 2009 (UTC) keep per improvements made since the AfD began. And per request input from Korean Wikipedians in searching through the 3 million google hits http://www.google.com/search?q=%EB%B6%88%EC%8B%A0%EC%A7%80%EC%98%A5&rls=com.microsoft:en-us:IE-SearchBox&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&sourceid=ie7&rlz=1I7DVXA, the 1100 news hits http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%EB%B6%88%EC%8B%A0%EC%A7%80%EC%98%A5&cf=all, and the 98 book hits http://books.google.com/books?q=%EB%B6%88%EC%8B%A0%EC%A7%80%EC%98%A5&rls=com.microsoft:en-us:IE-SearchBox&oe=UTF-8&sourceid=ie7&rlz=1I7DVXA&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&hl=en&tab=wp. And before anybody squawks about my just providing g-hits... I do not myself read Korean, but a film that set box office records in South Korea is notable enough foir me, and common sense would seem to indicate that even if a small percentage of those g-hits is about this film, that small percenntage would be plenty Deletion of Living Death (film) WP:CSB Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
5834 11701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juliet Langton's Speech User:Dougweller 18:33, 1 June 2008 (UTC) delete as vandalism, Deletion of Juliet Langton's Speech WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5835 16704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billy Tsovolos User:GiantSnowman 14:22, 23 November 2010 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Billy Tsovolos WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5836 7111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pat Simonds User:Narthring 16:05, 18 October 2010 (UTC) delete I didn't locate sources that would pass . If some were brought forward I would change my !vote Deletion of Pat Simonds WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5837 13123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Chariot of Wisdom and Love User:Javit 20:49, 7 June 2007 (UTC) merge with Hacker per otability Deletion of The Chariot of Wisdom and Love WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5838 5873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Piers Lauder User:Tyrenius 14:23, 17 September 2007 (UTC) merge Individual notability has not been established per adequate verifiable sources per Deletion of Piers Lauder WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5839 6490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Societal attitudes towards homosexuality User:Last_Malthusian 11:49, 15 February 2006 (UTC) keep per others, increasingly looks like a nomination Deletion of Societal attitudes towards homosexuality WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
5840 8519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Preksha Mehta User:onel5969 15:24, 22 September 2020 (UTC) delete does not meet either or Deletion of Preksha Mehta WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5841 14494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Sestero User:Oakshade 03:06, 24 August 2010 (UTC) keep """Easily passes . Very substantial coverage. http://www.pasadenaweekly.com/cms/story/detail/the_room_to_improve/7658/http://www.avclub.com/chicago/articles/the-rooms-greg-sestero-best-friend-extraordinaire,30724/http://popwatch.ew.com/2010/07/30/greg-sestero-the-room-5-second-film/. Besides being one of the stars of ''The Room (movie)|The Room'', was one of the stars of ''White Liar'' which won the Academy of Country Music|Academy of Country Music Award for Best Video. Just because sources are """"in reference"""" to a certain piece, doesn't mean they don't satisfy """ Deletion of Greg Sestero WP:GNG||WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5842 5545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gey-freezing State Reserve [[User_talk:Rudget|Rudget]] [[Special:Contributions/Rudget|Contributions]] 19:01, 12 December 2007 (UTC) delete as hoax, can find no |reliable sourcing. &mdash Deletion of Gey-freezing State Reserve WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5843 9414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sovereignty of God in Christianity User:Fayenatic 09:37, 16 January 2020 (UTC) keep per the arguments above; just tag it with multiple issues for improvement and list it at ikiProject Christianity as needing work Deletion of Sovereignty of God in Christianity WP:W Help:Watchlist 110
5844 5664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adesh Tyagi User:Septrillion 08:09, 6 July 2018 (UTC) delete Fails \\\Septrillion Deletion of Adesh Tyagi WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5845 1477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vytaute Andrijauskaite User:Joe 15:53, 29 November 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |actress Deletion of Vytaute Andrijauskaite WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5846 13861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Senecal (2nd nomination) User:Scjessey 17:57, 6 March 2018 (UTC) keep Satisfies the |general notability guidelines by virtue of press coverage, and once a person is notable they do not lose that notability with time. While it is true his notability was attained through another person, that disqualifier is negated by the fact that sources exist that are chiefly about Senecal (rather than his famous employer Deletion of Anthony Senecal (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5847 1544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eöl User:Devonian 06:15, 2 March 2020 (UTC) merge to Thingol, where he is mentioned. There is only one secondary source given, John D. Rateliff's history of the hobbit, I cannot tell if it gives more than a passing mention of this character but one source is not enough to pass in any case Deletion of Eöl WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5848 20719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cop on the edge User:Tychocat 09:37, 7 July 2006 (UTC) delete per . As it stands right now, it's OR. A nice term paper for a film class, but not WP Deletion of Cop on the edge WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5849 6851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of nicknames used in cricket (2nd nomination) user:Andrew 17:50, 9 December 2015 (UTC) keep Clearly passes , e.g. ''https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=6Vu9cih3u1kC&pg=PT211 Cricketing Nicknames Deletion of List of nicknames used in cricket (2nd nomination) WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
5850 7018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Rae (2nd nomination) User:RGTraynor 13:53, 3 April 2008 (UTC) keep It's hard to deny that he passes going away Deletion of Jason Rae (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5851 18014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2021 African Minifootball Cup User:Joseph2302 07:33, 8 August 2021 (UTC) merge to African Minifootball Cup#Results as a valid . Doesn't pass . There's also an article for the 2018 tournament, which is also questionable at best Deletion of 2021 African Minifootball Cup WP:ATD||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5852 429 [[:Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Fastnachtstage]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:O0TsRVi7 NONE delete Diese Navigationsleiste ist ein unerwünschter |Themenring. Schon der Titel der Navigationsleiste („Tag mit Karnevals-/Fastnachtsbezug“) formuliert, dass es eher unklar ist, was denn überhaupt hier reingehören soll. Willkürlich sind nur die für den rheinischen Karneval und die schwäbisch-allemanische Fastnacht Tage aufgeführt, andere Traditionen (z.B. der bayerisch-österreiche Fasching) fehlen. Das ist problematisch, da die Übergänge zwischen den einzelnen Traditionen fließend sind. Zudem ist diese Navigationsleiste noch nicht einmal für die Fastnacht vollständig, denn unter Schwäbisch-alemannische Fastnacht#Ablauf der Fastnacht sind noch einige andere Termine aufgeführt. Alles in allem handelt ich es meiner Meinung nach hier um ein Lehrbeispiel für einen Themenring (weder klar abgrenzbar, noch die Möglichkeit vorhanden, vollständig zu sein). Daher beantrage ich, diese Navigationsleiste zu Löschung von :Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Fastnachtstage Wikipedia:Themenring Wikipedia:Themenring 103
5853 12415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Schlogger User:The 14:32, 13 August 2006 (UTC) delete Fails as |non notable. Also seems to violate Deletion of Schlogger WP:WEB||WP:NN||WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
5854 4196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Little House with an Orange Roof User:Collectonian 06:32, 22 September 2009 (UTC) delete fails and . Just not notable Deletion of Little House with an Orange Roof WP:BK||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5855 18995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muriel K. Rand User:John 04:07, 30 September 2019 (UTC) delete the lack of reliable sources is more concerning as this is a |BLP. &ndash Deletion of Muriel K. Rand WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
5856 7047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Dao User:WaltCip 13:10, 12 April 2017 (UTC) delete per aforementioned . You cannot measure the significance of this event on two days of reactions. No one's going to be writing about this in history books Deletion of David Dao WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
5857 21646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Heaven User:K 23:42, 1 September 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet ; significant RS coverage not found Deletion of Chris Heaven WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5858 21890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gabrielle Bennett User:Ramaksoud2000 04:00, 5 May 2013 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Gabrielle Bennett WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5859 3749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Wetzel NONE 21:10, 21 November 2006 (UTC) delete Clearly fails under --Orange Mike Deletion of Joshua Wetzel WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5860 1613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brain Injury Law Center User:Rhododendrites 16:42, 25 October 2014 (UTC) delete not seeing sufficient reliable secondary sources. Fails . --&mdash Deletion of Brain Injury Law Center WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
5861 130 [[Der Engel des Schicksals]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Abundant NONE delete Irrelevant, zumal das Buch in einem Zuschussverlag erscheinen wird (vgl. dazu für Schriftsteller). , gerne auch schnell Löschung von Der Engel des Schicksals Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
5862 12356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elliot Elam User:Johnbod 22:46, 25 February 2008 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet the criteria Deletion of Elliot Elam WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5863 7441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gangnam Style in popular culture User:CallawayRox 21:14, 4 December 2012 (UTC) keep AFD is , there was just a Talk:Gangnam_Style_in_popular_culture#Is_this_article_necessary.3F|failed merge proposal Deletion of Gangnam Style in popular culture WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5864 8188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Human photosynthesis User:I9Q79oL78KiL0QTFHgyc 16:23, 4 October 2015 (UTC) delete Very nearly a |hoax article Deletion of Human photosynthesis WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
5865 7105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Next Bracknell parliamentary election User:Peterkingiron 22:23, 18 October 2009 (UTC) merge back to Bracknell (UK Parliament constituency). We deal with future elections in an election box. Any commentary on its significnace is likely to be . WE do not need 649 of this kind of article (one per constituency) but that would be the logical conclusion of keeping it. Furthermore, the article (or rather most of the 649) would probably need deletion when the election is over Deletion of Next Bracknell parliamentary election WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5866 12028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Simoné User:onel5969 04:31, 5 September 2017 (UTC) delete could not find enough in-depth coverage to show that he passes Deletion of David Simoné WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5867 9068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fiona Hamilton-Fairley User:E 22:11, 6 August 2019 (UTC) delete per . The fact that in over a decade no pages link to this one - except her cooking school - speaks volumes. That said, I do see a few old articles in a news archive: (Kids' recipe for healthy eating: MOST PARENTS AGREE, COOKING IS A VITAL SKILL CHILDREN NEED TO LEARN. KIDS' COOKERY EXPERT FIONA HAMILTON-FAIRLEY OFFERS lisa salmon TIPS ON GETTING LITTLE ONES BUSY IN THE KITCHEN, Salmon, Lisa. Liverpool Echo; Liverpool (UK) Liverpool (UK)26 Oct 2016: 8. ), (We can all go to work on an egg A pioneering cookery school is teaching as much about life skills as how to rustle up a shepherd's pie, says Kevin Gould. Meanwhile, family food guru Annabel Karmel has advice on how to get your children eating more healthily, Gould, Kevin. The Daily Telegraph; London (UK) London (UK)31 Aug 2002: 12.). If someone wants to attempt to make this into an acceptable article, I suggest that they make it a single article on school and its founder/director. If you make the attempt, feel free to ping me to reconsider. However, even though I am seeing a few sources, I am very skeptical that there is enough her to pass Deletion of Fiona Hamilton-Fairley WP:NOTPROMO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5868 12445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Austin–Bergstrom International Airport runway incident User:Ahunt 20:24, 25 December 2020 (UTC) delete """This is a somewhat usual incident, but the article never got beyond . The general and aviation media all reported on it when it happened, but never did any follow up and, as far as I can tell no one has published any findings on the investigation that was done by local authorities. I did some extensive digging on the incident and discovered that the person killed was a local resident of the city and had https://www.austinintoxicated.com/atx-neighborhood-watch/2019/07/24/public-intoxication-junin-ko/ a prior arrest for """"public intoxication"""" on 24 July 2019, only nine months prior. There probably is a more extensive story here about what happened and why, but the media seems to have dropped it and not investigated to any degree at all, leaving us with no refs to build an article on. More could be added from the ref I cited above and others like that (of which there are several), but it would end up impaled upon . Sadly, the way it stands the story is just a news oddity - one death for no discernible reason and with no context, so I don't see any point in keeping it as it is. Because the incident is not known in the press as the """"Austin–Bergstrom International Airport runway incident"""" and the article name is not even close to reasonable search term for this subject, I see no point in a redirect""" Deletion of Austin–Bergstrom International Airport runway incident WP:NOTNEWSPAPER||WP:SYNTHESIS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5869 10579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Decleated User:Husond 04:34, 24 November 2006 (UTC) delete Obscure |neologism. Blogs don't serve as reliable sources, so neither should they serve to assert notability to neologisms Deletion of Decleated WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
5870 8915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timmie Jean Lindsey User:Struthious_Bandersnatch 17:00, 24 May 2012 (UTC) keep Satisfies with substantial international coverage: a half-dozen solid Google Books hits and dozens of Google News hits with a significant percentage of those being in reliable sources as Arxiloxos observes. (And actually, in the narrow category of tabloidy topics of prurient interest like breast augmentation I think the ''Daily Mail'' sort of qualifies as a reliable source http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-484674/I-worlds-breast-job--endured-years-misery-says-Texan-great-grandmother.html in this case. Caution preceding link contains Not safe for work|NSFW material.) doesn't override because this isn't a newsy burst of coverage, this is sustained broad-spectrum interest half a century after the event Deletion of Timmie Jean Lindsey WP:BASIC||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
5871 5906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Springfield Raceway User:Ravenswing 15:16, 14 October 2010 (UTC) delete Would you like to cite any policy grounds upon which to advocate keeping the article? As far as I can see, |launching a personal attack on the nom is not generally considered a valid one. That aside, there are ''zero'' sources and ''zero'' hits on G-News to anything beyond race results in the local newspaper Deletion of Springfield Raceway WP:NPA Wikipedia:No personal attacks 58
5872 16508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cadèmia Siciliana User:Dapal 23:51, 4 January 2018 (UTC) keep I fail to see how the referenced interviews are Wikipedia:Interviews#Independent_or_not|not independent, given it's not proven that the interviewees and the interviewers are linked. I consider all the references given as third-party. I do agree it's a small and relatively new organization, but it passes . We should also consider that its field of action is superspecialized: we can't expect massive international coverage, given that Sicilian language|Sicilian is a minority language. This should also lower the quantity of citations needed for being considered having |significant coverage. I also just found one more reference to the organization, related to CLDR, which I'm going to add to the article Deletion of Cadèmia Siciliana WP:RECENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Recentism 10
5873 3001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacklyn Lick User:Sammy1339 13:07, 27 August 2015 (UTC) keep based on #3. She has appeared in the notable mainstream films Orgazmo, The Big Lebowski, Bikini Planet (film), and Homo Erectus (film Deletion of Jacklyn Lick WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5874 20175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Georgia Glastris User:Hmlarson 01:25, 13 October 2017 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Georgia Glastris WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5875 15718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcus Bachmann User:And 00:55, 25 July 2011 (UTC) delete """As per the Wikipedia policy of . The information box on the article clearly states that Mr. Bachmann is '''Known for: husband of Michele Bachmann''' - his """"fame"""" for running some fringe/freakish therapy center would never be notable on its own terms if he was not married to a leading American politician. I like what Tarc says: """"This is an encyclopedia, not a vacuum cleaner."""" This dust bunny of an article can be thrown out without disrupting the character of the web site""" Deletion of Marcus Bachmann WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5876 8125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NYMZ User:NewYorkActuary 20:28, 2 October 2015 (UTC) delete I'm not seeing how the subject meets any of the notability criteria under or Deletion of NYMZ WP:BASIC||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5877 12542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radhe Krishan User:Extraordinary 15:54, 16 March 2021 (UTC) delete no sign of meeting or the GNG. There's no presumption of notability for former assistant professors, and his citation count is very low. My searches find no substantial independent coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Radhe Krishan WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5878 11266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The X-15s User:Happyme22 02:27, 3 July 2008 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of The X-15s WP:MUSIC||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5879 7472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luchima User:J 01:08, 5 September 2007 (UTC) delete It's right there in the article: '''Legend'''! and therefore, possible |hoax. If not, this princess is certainly |not notable Deletion of Luchima WP:HOAX||WP:N Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
5880 2851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siopepa Tailolo User:Kosm1fent 19:32, 17 October 2012 (UTC) delete hasn't actually played for his country's national team. Fails and . &ndash Deletion of Siopepa Tailolo WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5881 16702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mmg records Inc User:Andrew 04:41, 4 August 2007 (UTC) delete WP:CORP. Notability is not established by multiple, nontrivial sources. In fact, no sources are cited. The article does not read like an encyclopedia entry, but instead like a marketing piece or advertisement. Complicating matters is where the sole author is an employee for the label Deletion of Mmg records Inc WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
5882 8485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pornography in the Russian Federation User:BobLaRouche 23:57, 11 April 2017 (UTC) delete as Deletion of Pornography in the Russian Federation WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5883 8866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aspect Consulting (2nd nomination) User:Cabayi 22:39, 12 February 2018 (UTC) delete even if one were inclined to try and untangle all the mind games and contradictory edits of the author and their sock puppets at its core the topic remains a PR setup claiming some ed notability from its dodgy clients Deletion of Aspect Consulting (2nd nomination) WP:INHERIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5884 8488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of residents and natives of Ithaca, New York User:Torc2 22:00, 10 January 2008 (UTC) keep Per , category is irrelevant and should not be used as a reason to delete. This is just a sub-article of Ithaca, New York broken out due to and style restraints Deletion of List of residents and natives of Ithaca, New York WP:CLS||WP:SIZE Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
5885 17050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of minor characters in Xena: Warrior Princess User:Edison 17:41, 12 March 2008 (UTC) keep """Weak because I am not able to see that each of these characters is in fact discussed in the book about the series which Le Grand Roi des Citrouilles pointed out, """"Xena Warrior Princess: Complete Illustrated Companion"""" by K. Stoddard Hayes. In its 240 pages such a book probably discusses major and many minor characters, so it is a secondary published source for those minor characters it in fact discusses. This supplements the actual episodes which are primary sources and less convincing. A list is far, far preferable to having a stub article about each minor character, and merging the list into the main Xena article would probably tend to make it too long. The requirement for substantial coverage in multiple reliable and independent sources does not prevent less notable things or characters being included in articles, as long as the articles themselves are about notable things""" Deletion of List of minor characters in Xena: Warrior Princess WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5886 9802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Rastner User:Northamerica1000 22:28, 7 June 2016 (UTC) keep Presumed notable per Deletion of Patrick Rastner WP:NOLYMPICS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5887 12950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Hughes (footballer, born 1865) User:GiantSnowman 21:40, 9 February 2020 (UTC) keep meets . It is not standard to merge player articles into club/season articles. According to https://www.lfchistory.net/Players/Player/Profile/679 this Hughes played League football for Bootle as well Deletion of William Hughes (footballer, born 1865) WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5888 17661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/South Indian Food in New Zealand User:Adabow 20:05, 23 December 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of South Indian Food in New Zealand WP:A10 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5889 19507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Navin Khambhala User:Joshualouie711 01:03, 18 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails , , and Deletion of Navin Khambhala WP:GNG||WP:PERSON||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5890 9366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shelter Now User:Ejgreen77 01:53, 10 January 2019 (UTC) keep Appears to meet , per Rajulbat's sources Deletion of Shelter Now WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5891 20235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sudden Rockers User:Metropolitan90 04:51, 21 September 2005 (UTC) delete A look at the band's official site shows no evidence that they meet any of the criteria Deletion of Sudden Rockers WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5892 12428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ernest Yélémou user:Bobby122 21:59, 25 January 2012 (UTC) delete Fails per as he has not made his debut Deletion of Ernest Yélémou WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5893 1949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Brand Vision User:CNMall41 23:43, 16 March 2016 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of New Brand Vision WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5894 13103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Airlines Flight 550 User:Adog104 22:33, 6 October 2015 (UTC) keep I know, I know the creator of the page wants to defend his article he wrote. No, that's not why I'm here. The page was created on a current aviation event which is important to know, the incident had wide media coverage (even outside the US), and this doesn't happen a lot. I understand this isn't a newspaper, however it is a notable event that happened. We ''could'' also transfer this article to the WikiNews (since looking into this more and since I'm new I just learned a thing and two). - -TRANS Deletion of American Airlines Flight 550 WP:AFD||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
5895 6942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Territorial Army units (2012) User:Otr500 20:21, 5 December 2020 (UTC) delete """per Nom and the the flawed rationale of {{u|Concertmusic}} (the size of the article has nothing to do with notability) and {{u|Andrew Davidson}} (A |primary source does not advance notability and : {{tq|However, once an article's notability has been challenged, merely asserting that unspecified sources exist is seldom persuasive, especially if time passes and actual proof does not surface.}}) This is a 2013 list article. I was wondering exactly what {{u|Brigade Piron}} stated: """"why 2012 is particularly justifiable compared with, say, 2011 or 2013"""". With the direction keep !votes are leaning we could have a very large (makes it obviously notable) article on any subject where a primary source is shown. That is not according to our accepted community practices on sourcing such as |{{tq|All material in Wikipedia mainspace, including everything in articles, '''lists''' and captions, must be verifiable.}} That does not necessarily mean """"presented on the article"""" but along with , since notability is questioned, then proof should be presented. Lacking this is evidence of a lack of notability. The criteria of Wikipedia:LISTN clearly states """"independent reliable sources, per the above guidelines"""". Since primary sources do not advance notability there is a very fundamental issue with claims the article satisfies WP:LISTN. Since none of the """"keep !votes"""" are advocating to keep because of invoking (so we can't discuss that) then the policies and guidelines are applicable to list articles, as a group, and with only primary sourcing it fails that. I am still trying to determine the encyclopedic value of such a list. (#5) gives disadvantages of having such a list {{tq|...entries that cannot be reliably sourced and do not meet the requirements for inclusion in the encyclopaedia.}}, and sourcing that advances notability is the main issue""" Deletion of List of Territorial Army units (2012) WP:NEXIST||WP:V||WP:BURDEN||WP:IAR||WP:CLN||WP:primary source Wikipedia:Notability 77
5896 10617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dafydd Morris Jones User:Qwghlm 17:22, 15 February 2007 (UTC) delete when you strip out the speculation there is nothing to suggest either has any assertion to notability under Deletion of Dafydd Morris Jones WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5897 5694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amar Prem User:Bonadea 19:12, 4 May 2013 (UTC) keep clearly meets , and the nomination does not mention any actual reason for deletion Deletion of Amar Prem WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5898 4697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdelrahman H. Elsayed User:Nsk92 11:04, 19 October 2020 (UTC) delete per nom. All the awards listed in the article are indeed student and trainee level awards and don't contribute to academic notability under . https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=FqL387UAAAAJ&hl=en&oi=ao GoogleScholar gives him h-index of just 2, with his GScholar profile still listing him as a PhD candidate. Probably a fresh PhD Deletion of Abdelrahman H. Elsayed WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5899 5575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathan Charnock User:GiantSnowman 16:56, 10 September 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Nathan Charnock WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5900 9967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/G. N. Patil User:Shirik 17:21, 14 January 2010 (UTC) comment Would you please elaborate on why you consider this politician to be notable? Please see Deletion of G. N. Patil WP:JNN Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5901 6146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theodore Cohen (chemist) User:Russ 08:05, 4 March 2021 (UTC) keep I see several quite highly cited papers, in what I understand to be a medium citation field. I think it's a pass of C1. Sure, he's well-known partly because of the length of his career (but you could say the same for Johnny Carson). Pitt held a small event for him on the occasion of his retirement, and there's a little more about him in coverage of the event in the chemistry department newsletter https://www.chem.pitt.edu/sites/default/files/200705031331340.NL_draft2.pdf. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Theodore Cohen (chemist) WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5902 18296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nikki Feroni User:TruthbringerToronto 21:52, 13 August 2006 (UTC) keep She seems notable, and should probably be reworked so that it doesn't exclude artists of considerable potential like this one Deletion of Nikki Feroni WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5903 9251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Screenshot/fodder User:Anomie 13:16, 9 June 2017 (UTC) delete Find a solution to phab:T162454 that doesn't require dumping garbage in enwiki's mainspace. I've just suggested two such potential solutions on that task. I find arguments proposed above unconvincing Deletion of Screenshot/fodder WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5904 6179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Borrell Associates NONE 16:28, 15 October 2010 (UTC) delete Pure weapons-grade |vanispamcruftisement … article lacks sufficient |attribution for |verifiability of the notability criteria … most of the links provided are from the subject's own website. Happy Editing! — '''{{User|71.166.157.40 Deletion of Borrell Associates WP:VSCA||WP:CORP||WP:SPS||WP:attribution||WP:verifiability Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
5905 13345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Feudalist Party User:MelanieN 22:22, 25 November 2011 (UTC) delete I'm sure the kids have enjoyed their fifteen minutes of Wikipedia fame, but come on! This is an absolutely classic example of |something made up one day and it has no place in Wikipedia. That's what Facebook is for, and these kids know it: in fact they are canvassing for |meatpuppets on their http://www.facebook.com/pages/The-Feudalist-Party/274850625886110 Facebook page Deletion of The Feudalist Party WP:MADEUP||WP:MEATPUPPET Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
5906 17822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marie-Thérèse Bardet (2nd nomination) User:SportingFlyer 13:32, 21 October 2018 (UTC) delete Fails per nominator Deletion of Marie-Thérèse Bardet (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5907 9714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fucktard User:Jd027 22:56, 9 February 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Fucktard WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
5908 4873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clearview Horizon User:Spinningspark 16:23, 31 May 2019 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Clearview Horizon WP:NORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5909 13631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Last Straw Family Restaurant and Ice Cream Parlour User:Kinu 06:20, 22 May 2008 (UTC) delete no evidence of notability, no Deletion of The Last Straw Family Restaurant and Ice Cream Parlour WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5910 10175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Baby Sister User:Stuartyeates 03:55, 8 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of The Baby Sister WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5911 2665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Identified User:Hello 13:48, 12 April 2008 (UTC) delete No |reliable sources. Fails #Albums and Deletion of Identified WP:RS||WP:MUSIC||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5912 2293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Modissa User:Piotrus 04:02, 20 November 2020 (UTC) delete No evidence the company passes Deletion of Modissa WP:NCOMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
5913 16686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Max Lipset User:GiantSnowman 12:25, 5 April 2012 (UTC) delete fails and . 90 minutes in a cup match against an ameteur team does not instill confidence in notability Deletion of Max Lipset WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5914 5221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iman Farzin User:John 13:10, 1 November 2020 (UTC) keep Although no significant English sources, the fa references show . Whilst the article needs some work, that shouldn't be a consideration for deletion. Agree with {{u|Mjroots}}, what happens on fa-wiki should not spill over here Deletion of Iman Farzin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5915 13478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SitNGo Wizard User:Themfromspace 01:46, 19 January 2010 (UTC) delete Sorry but this is promotional editing and should not be encouraged on Wikipedia, as per AND . A truly notable organization shouldn't have to entice editors to write a Wikipedia article on their product. I also think Tony should refrain from creating similar COI articles in the future Deletion of SitNGo Wizard WP:NOT||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5916 12866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/José Carlos Castillo User:Sir 21:32, 30 August 2012 (UTC) keep As a Guatemalan international, he clearly passes Deletion of José Carlos Castillo WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5917 15906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Urban dog User:Forest90 08:21, 1 July 2019 (UTC) delete the Article because it's not meet Deletion of Urban dog WP:NOTDICTIONARY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5918 21606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mongolia at the 2013 Asian Youth Games User:Malcolmxl5 11:32, 3 June 2016 (UTC) merge to the main games article. This could have been done |boldly without bringing this and others here Deletion of Mongolia at the 2013 Asian Youth Games WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
5919 20253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buddhu Bhutum User:Bejnar 07:33, 12 December 2016 (UTC) delete """for lack of significant coverage, fails and . So far it just looks like hype and celebrity following. As the guideline says """"Additionally, films that have already begun shooting, but have not yet been publicly released (theatres or video), should generally not have their own articles unless the production itself is notable per the notability guideline."""" After it comes out if it has popular or criticl acclaim it might achieve notability, but not now. See YET (films""" Deletion of Buddhu Bhutum WP:GNG||WP:NFILM||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5920 11418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southern mafia User:Arkyan 05:09, 19 March 2007 (UTC) delete Even if the sources weren't a little on the wonky side this wouldn't be much more than a dicdef as it stands. This article suffers the same problem as a related article recently deleted in that the 'sources' are largely just instances of the phrase being used and do little if anything to establish the meaning of the term or convey any information about it. It does little more than establish the existence of the term - the point of is not to simply find quotes but to tell us something, which this doesn't Deletion of Southern mafia WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
5921 21514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EP128Emu User:Joe 01:17, 29 January 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of EP128Emu WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5922 11334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Etimani Maio User:Kosm1fent 19:25, 17 October 2012 (UTC) delete hasn't actually played for his country's national team. Fails and . &ndash Deletion of Etimani Maio WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5923 1964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Running on Empty (comic) User:Mr 21:01, 6 April 2007 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Running on Empty (comic) WP:N||WP:ATT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5924 2986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ClimateTalk User:Click23 17:20, 24 June 2009 (UTC) delete """Does not pass , it has not """"received significant coverage in reliable secondary sources""" Deletion of ClimateTalk WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5925 7694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kirk Aanes User:Dennisthe2 23:11, 28 September 2009 (UTC) delete Of two of the links, somebody's resume says that the worked on the play by Mr. Aanes, and somebody else mentioned someone else who worked the play by Mr. Aanes. As he is not the subject of these (beyond that he's cited as the author of said play), these can't work. The others are NY Times links for searches (which don't mean much), and then his iMDB listing - which is not a |reliable source. Beyond that, there's nothing for this guy Deletion of Kirk Aanes WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5926 15862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Prouty User:Cullen328 23:52, 15 March 2013 (UTC) merge at this time to Mitt_Romney_presidential_campaign,_2012#Video_of_private_fundraiser, and later, I hope to Mitt Romney 47% video as I believe the video is of enormous historical importance. I will try to explain to Jehochman how the three criteria in apply in this case. 1. The sources cover Prouty only in the context of this one event. A rescue is wonderful but not otherwise notable. 2. Prouty is a low-profile individual who remained anonymous for six months and has repeatedly stated in recent days that he does not seek fame for himself. 3. Prouty's role was nowhere near as substantial as John Hinckley's in the Reagan assassination attempt. We have no articles about the videographers or photographers who documented that notable event. Hinckley caused that event himself by wounding four people including a U.S. president and severely disabling one of those, Jim Brady. Mitt Romney was the primary actor in this 2012 event, and if Romney had given his standard stump speech, Prouty would be unknown. Prouty was the messenger, not the historical actor, who was Romney. Prouty deserves a redirect, and some basic biographical information in whatever article describes the video and its political impact in greatest depth, but there is no need for a stand-alone article about him at this time Deletion of Scott Prouty WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
5927 3510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Majority Plus User:NinjaRobotPirate 01:51, 9 July 2016 (UTC) delete It's difficult to determine whether older topics were never notable or if they just faded into obscurity. In the case of bands, there's usually some kind of evidence in digitized sources and retrospectives. I see a trivial mention in https://books.google.com/books?id=yCRlCwAAQBAJ&lpg=PT233&ots=yZ5lW21365&dq=%22Majority%20Plus%22%20merseybeat&pg=PT233#v=onepage&q=%22Majority%20Plus%22%20merseybeat&f=false this book, and there are a few Merseybeat fan sites that mention the band, such as http://www.liverpoolbeat.com/rocknroll/majority-plus/ this one. It would be nice if we could keep this article, as the creator apparently made it as a tribute to his grandfather, but there doesn't seem to be significant coverage in |reliable sources. If someone can locate offline coverage, such as in contemporary newspapers, the article can be recreated Deletion of Majority Plus WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5928 2129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victor Carlström User:Eggishorn NONE delete Completely self-promotional sources. Not one single source presented comes even within shouting distance of being a . Given the re-creation, the extreme tenor of the claims, and the disruption in this AfD, I also suggest '''Salting Deletion of Victor Carlström WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5929 15030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Potato filling User:Northamerica1000 20:49, 27 January 2016 (UTC) keep """A historical topic that comfortably passes . Source examples include, but are not limited to: {{cite web|url=http://www2.readingeagle.com/article.aspx?id=171291|title=How did potato filling become a local holiday tradition?|publisher=''Reading Eagle'' |no-tracking=yes }}, {{cite web|url=http://articles.mcall.com/2011-11-22/entertainment/mc-potato-filling-1123-20111122_1_baked-potatoes-thanksgiving-dinner-bland-dishes|title=Potato filling: Potato filling stars at Pennsylvania Dutch Thanksgivings|work=The Morning Call}}, http://www.seattletimes.com/life/food-drink/recipes-amish-potato-filling/ """"Recipes: Amish Potato Filling"""". ''The Seattle Times''., https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1928&dat=19771121&id=ULwgAAAAIBAJ&sjid=rWkFAAAAIBAJ&pg=4435,3471919&hl=en """"Hearty Potato Stuffing Tradition among Pennsylvania Dutch"""". ''The Lewiston Daily Sun''., {{cite web|url=http://lancasteronline.com/features/food/top-chef-visits-lancaster-county-adds-gluten-free-potato-filling/article_ddf2179e-848b-11e5-bfc6-0b2339d0dee6.html|title=Top chef visits Lancaster County, adds gluten-free potato filling to latest cookbook|author=|date=|work=LNP Media Group|LNP}}, {{cite book|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=jSnzCQAAQBAJ&pg=PA156|title=Gluten-Free Girl American Classics Reinvented|publisher=|page=156}}, {{cite book|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=i4POAAAAMAAJ&q=%22Potato+filling%22|title=Good Home Cooking Across the U. S. A.|publisher=|page=84}} {{paywall}}. Since the dish is centuries-old, additional offline sources are very likely available""" Deletion of Potato filling WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5930 18997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shafiqah Shasha (2nd nomination) [[User talk:IgnorantArmies|IgnorantArmies]] [[User talk:IgnorantArmies|(talk)]]''' 11:39, 15 January 2017 (UTC) delete fails the . I couldn't even find an independent source confirming her existence, let alone significant coverage. The only source listed is ''Lucknow - A Veritable Goldmine'', a book about Lucknow, New South Wales|a town that doesn't even have its own Wikipedia article. There is nothing about her life that suggests more/better sources are likely to be found Deletion of Shafiqah Shasha (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5931 17140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryan Smith User:Bearian 17:45, 3 May 2010 (UTC) delete BIO1E is being |strictly applied by consensus nowadays; see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Ely Deletion of Bryan Smith WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
5932 4647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hans Hagen User:Timneu22 13:56, 3 May 2010 (UTC) delete """No reliable web notability, and a """"strong keep"""" from the subject's friend is or . This article is rubbish and should be removed. &mdash""" Deletion of Hans Hagen WP:POV||WP:OR Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
5933 15630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Association of Sporting Events for Rabbits User:Jéské 07:06, 20 May 2009 (UTC) delete Zero sources what-so-ever and smells like |vanispamcruftisement Deletion of American Association of Sporting Events for Rabbits WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
5934 127 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Stokholm Kürt Enstitüsü Kullanıcı:hedda gablerhedda gableя 09:47, 27 Eylül 2009 (UTC) delete """Sizin gibi deneyimli bir kullanıcıdan """"kaynak gösterilmeyle mi kayda değerlik kazanılıyor?"""" cümlesini duymak cidden üzücü. Neden kayda değer olmasın sorusu yerine |bu sayfadaki kriterlere uygunluğunu, uygun kaynaklarla ortaya koymanız Vikipedi açısında daha faydalı ve VP:TBA|tarafsız olmaz mı? Son sorunuzun cevabı da evet kayda değerliği belirsiz maddeler SAM adayı olarak gösterilebilirler ve bundan doğal bir şey olamaz. --Kullanıcı mesaj:Eldarion|Eldarion""" Stokholm Kürt Enstitüsünün silinmesi Vikipedi:ÖRGÜT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5935 15629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gilas Pilipinas program User:Bagumba 09:49, 8 October 2019 (UTC) delete per . No constructive reason to have stats re-combined from Philippines men's national basketball team, Philippines men's national under-19 basketball team, Philippines men's national under-17 basketball team, Philippines men's national 3x3 team, Philippines women's national basketball team. General information should go in Samahang Basketbol ng Pilipinas; nothing to preserve from here Deletion of Gilas Pilipinas program WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5936 9569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Darwin User:ConcernedVancouverite 20:42, 30 May 2011 (UTC) keep I fully agree that notability is not inherited. But in this case it appears Chris Darwin has leveraged his ancestry and gone out to establish a name for himself with significant coverage in reliable sources such as: http://www.smh.com.au/environment/a-natural-selection-regret-turns-to-blooming-marvel-for-darwin-20090829-f3em.html http://www.news.com.au/evolutionist-charles-darwins-grandson-says-its-okay-to-teach-children-creationism/story-e6frep2f-1225887513882?from=public_rss http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2003/04/22/1050777257295.html http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/4082078.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/4607037.stm. I think this is enough to pass - but I also agree that the article is very poorly written and needs substantial trimming to focus it down to what is cited from reliable sources and is actually notable Deletion of Chris Darwin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5937 19137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Justin Bronson User:Hobbes 13:08, 19 January 2012 (UTC) delete """Once lost an undercard match at some MMA fight. """"Was hired to appear in a remake of Death Wish. After many months of scheduling conflict, the project was scrapped."""" """"A few notable appearances as an extra on Law and Order."""" This brief article is practically an AfD nomination for itself. Fails , fails , fails """ Deletion of Justin Bronson WP:NACTOR||WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5938 13344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/8 Bucks Experiment (band) User:Precious 19:50, 27 December 2007 (UTC) delete All albums self-released; fails . No references—also fails Deletion of 8 Bucks Experiment (band) WP:MUSIC||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
5939 11410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alessandro Nori User:Northamerica1000 02:38, 25 May 2016 (UTC) delete FWIW, http://www.lawndalenews.com/2016/04/italian-actor-to-captivate-audiences-nationwide/ here's one source that provides significant coverage about the subject, found using the Google News link atop. However, not finding much else; does not meet Deletion of Alessandro Nori WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5940 6229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elliot Benjamin User:SkierRMH 04:18, 19 December 2006 (UTC) delete per , can't find links referring to citations Deletion of Elliot Benjamin WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5941 20948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Psychedelipunk User:EurekaLott 15:26, 23 December 2005 (UTC) delete Unencyclopedic. |NN, |UV Deletion of Psychedelipunk WP:NN||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
5942 20440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slut Night (2nd nomination) User:Ironholds 22:51, 9 September 2009 (UTC) delete Horribly badly sourced - six of the refs go to the same website, hardly useful for establishing notability, one goes to ''geocities'' and the remainder don't add up to Deletion of Slut Night (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5943 7409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ramakrishnan (actor) User:VocalIndia 07:16, 13 September 2020 (UTC) keep for this one, I did delete vote on your deletion requests for many actors who fails , but this one is meets Deletion of Ramakrishnan (actor) WP:NACTOR||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5944 496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robbie Sigurðsson NONE NONE keep subject passes . Sources in other languages are sufficient to demonstrate notability Deletion of Robbie Sigurðsson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5945 149 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ayşegül Coşkun Kullanıcı:4nn1l24nn1l2 04.05, 15 Şubat 2022 (UTC) keep There are abundant sources in both Turkish and Persian (Farsi). Please also note that she is an actress too, as she has played the character Nazan in '':en:Motreb|Motreb'', the :en:List of highest-grossing Iranian films|highest grossing Iranian movie ever. Thus, this person passes :en:WP:GNG|WP:GNG. When GNG is passed, you really don't need to look at the secondary auxiliary criteria such as . The English Wikipedia community decided unanimously to keep the article: :en:Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ayşegül Coşkun. I can provide further Turkish and Persian sources if need be. See also Tartışma:Ayşegül Coşkun#Kayda değerlik. Thanks Ayşegül Coşkun'un silinmesi Vikipedi:MÜZİK Wikipedia:Notability 77
5946 8493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baneforlaget User:HighKing 19:59, 12 August 2018 (UTC) delete and merge. Topic fails GNG and Deletion of Baneforlaget WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
5947 1196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cindy Cohen User:Atama 18:30, 25 June 2009 (UTC) delete I have checked out the references on the page and while the number of references seem impressive at first glance, the references themselves don't meet . The only possible exception is the Columbus Dispatch, but that alone is not enough. Her only legitimate shaky claim to notability is as a contestant on a reality show, but unless more coverage can be found for that, she clearly fails Deletion of Cindy Cohen WP:RS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5948 9672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diablo 3 (2nd nomination) User:Rushyo 21:13, 24 June 2008 (UTC) delete per . Even if Blizzard do announce it, they're only going to announce it is going to exist. They're not going to give enough reliable information to justify a full article Deletion of Diablo 3 (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5949 11675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kermit Roosevelt III User:Eric 14:31, 13 April 2014 (UTC) keep Meets criterion #1 (significant impact in scholarly discipline, broadly construed). Has at least one book, ''The myth of judicial activism'', currently in more than 1,000 major libraries worldwide according to http://www.worldcat.org WorldCat. Has an h-index of 12 based on GS, with one pub. with more than 100 citations to it Deletion of Kermit Roosevelt III WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5950 5757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qantas Flight 32 User:Memset 21:25, 4 November 2010 (UTC) keep """due to extensive coverage in reliable sources. Citing by itself is not a reason for deletion, it needs to be proven that the event will have no lasting notability. """"Too recent"""" is not an argument (there is no such thing as """"recentism""""), and is not a guideline. It is to early to tell if the event has lasting notability or not, therefore the article should not be irreversibly deleted but kept for now""" Deletion of Qantas Flight 32 WP:NOTNEWS||WP:AIRCRASH Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5951 17044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlos Castillo (Colombian footballer) User:Govvy 10:47, 13 May 2018 (UTC) keep The Colombian top flight league is on our pro list and R96Skinner pointed you to Soccerway, so clearly passes The nominator pointed to a google search, but did he really do his homework?! The article could do with a bit of work on it know Deletion of Carlos Castillo (Colombian footballer) WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5952 772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krown Hospital User:Fortuna 18:57, 3 May 2017 (UTC) delete per nom: only a spilt bedpan away from being , and that's on top of the only |reliable sources being https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=Krown+Hospital&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&gws_rd=cr&ei=UScKWZCVJoSPgAac-JeIAw#tbm=nws&q=%22Krown+Hospital%22 ...none, the nomination is a good one. &mdash Deletion of Krown Hospital WP:G11||WP:RS Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
5953 5139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John James (American politician) User:Bearcat 02:37, 5 April 2018 (UTC) delete People do not get Wikipedia articles just for being candidates in elections they haven't won yet — if you cannot demonstrate and |reliably source that he was ''already'' notable enough for an article for some other reason ''before'' becoming a candidate, then he has to ''win'' the election, not just run in it, to become notable as a politician. As usual, no prejudice against recreation in November if he wins the seat — but nothing stated or sourced here has demonstrated that he's already eligible to have an article today Deletion of John James (American politician) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5954 7514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lynette Long User:K 21:40, 24 October 2016 (UTC) keep """notable as with wide library holdings: http://www.worldcat.org/identities/lccn-n78019757/ link and as for the """"latchkey kids"""" work. Plenty of sources are available""" Deletion of Lynette Long WP:AUTHOR||WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5955 16126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary Schwartz (actor) User:Stuartyeates 08:41, 4 November 2012 (UTC) delete as failing and lcaking indpeth coverage Deletion of Gary Schwartz (actor) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
5956 15912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Gannon Award (2nd nomination) User:Gap9551 23:09, 27 January 2016 (UTC) delete Despite |notability not being temporary, I don't think the award was ever notable. The second (dead) source can be found http://www.oxfordmartin.ox.ac.uk/news/bostrom-gannon-award here now, but it's a primary source as it is published by the institution of a recipient. There are some trivial mentions of the award, but all in the Nick Bostrom context. Bottom line, there are no independent reliable sources about the award itself, and as such it is not notable per . The award does not need to be the primary topic, but the mentions are clearly not significant enough even for that standard. There is no detailed information at all in RS, and there would be insufficient material to write a useful article without the award's background, founders, their motivations, the full list of recipients, etc. I can't see any article to redirect this to either Deletion of The Gannon Award (2nd nomination) WP:NOTTEMPORARY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5957 18444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaner G Yo User:Joe 01:17, 23 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |rapper Deletion of Shaner G Yo WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
5958 4714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pratisaad - The Response User:Atlantic306 21:28, 30 October 2018 (UTC) delete all three as there are hoax concerns that are proven and in any case they do not pass and , thanks Deletion of Pratisaad - The Response WP:GNG||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
5959 18156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gumday User:Captain 12:33, 7 May 2013 (UTC) delete per eb, no assertion of notability and no significant coverage online from eliable sources. Could have been speedy deleted per #A7. Evident onflict of interest by article's creator, following quick web search for creator's account name and website name Deletion of Gumday WP:W||WP:R||WP:CSD||WP:C Help:Watchlist 110
5960 3588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of population milestones by country User:Nwlaw63 16:55, 3 January 2016 (UTC) delete The article topic itself (and how the whole article is structured) is a hopeless case of Deletion of List of population milestones by country WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
5961 21738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pleasant Ridge Chili User:Bearian 18:17, 24 August 2007 (UTC) keep """as this is the most notable """"cook"""", of the defining cuisine, of a large and notable city, in the English-speaking world. Although |I can't stomach the stuff, this place makes """"the best"""" dish according to the locals. It's well-sourced, too""" Deletion of Pleasant Ridge Chili WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
5962 2041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exa Web Solutions User:Xanchester 08:54, 25 October 2012 (UTC) delete No significant coverage by |reliable secondary sources outside of press releases. The subject fails to meet the |general notability guideline and the |notability guideline for organisations Deletion of Exa Web Solutions WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5963 3868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artificial controversy (2 nomination) User:Robofish 21:26, 28 February 2010 (UTC) keep The article needs improvement (to say more about the subject, rather than just a list of examples), and I understand the concerns, but I think it's also clear that this is a real and widely-used concept which is deserving of an article. It should also perhaps be moved to Manufactured controversy, as that seems to be the more popular term Deletion of Artificial controversy (2 nomination) WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
5964 3593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PAR Technology User:HighKing 19:59, 9 January 2018 (UTC) delete No indications of notability, references fail the criteria for establishing notability,in particular they are not *intellectually* independent and fail . References that rely on company announcements fail Deletion of PAR Technology WP:NCORP||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
5965 12703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Feazell (2nd nomination) User:Papaursa 23:02, 6 May 2019 (UTC) delete I said at the first AfD discussion that he didn't meet or . A month later nothing has changed Deletion of David Feazell (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5966 10147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim So-hye User:Bagas 16:34, 1 December 2016 (UTC) delete She has less solo work and zero notable activities/ events outside of her group. We do not predict the future fame of people on this site. It's currently . Her information in this article is already sufficiently summarized in her section on the group's article Deletion of Kim So-hye WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
5967 16176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Obadiah Newcomb Bush (2nd nomination) User:Americasroof 14:55, 26 February 2008 (UTC) keep This is a toughie. However says A''' person is presumed to be notable if he or she has received significant coverage in reliable secondary sources that are independent of the subject'''. I see 3,470 google links. I know there's the debate over whether Google links are adequate but it does show there is interest and articles about him. Cited as a source on an article '''Rochester Democrat and Chronicle.com, President's family has deep roots here, by Lara Becker Liu, February 21, 2005'''. Thus, he meets the standard there are significant third party articles about him. The article clearly establishes the Bush trait of taking risks sometimes at the expense of his own family. Wikipedia is not a geneology but common sense should dictate a different standard for tracing the history of heads of state Deletion of Obadiah Newcomb Bush (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5968 11249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alyssa Bustamante User:Xymmax 16:39, 3 January 2010 (UTC) delete This currently is a case. I currently do not favor a Killing of Elizabeth Olten article at the momment as the event is too fresh, and any coverage would be likely to violate . However, I do recognize that there has been more than the usual level of media attention, and if continues and results in sufficent sourcing, an article about the incident could be appropriate Deletion of Alyssa Bustamante WP:BIO1E||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5969 17107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Wachter User:Actaudio 07:51, 15 February 2019 (UTC) delete """Does not meet notability requirements. While his award wins are respectful, none are major music competitions. They are youth awards and #4 of says recognition must be for """"major music competition not established expressly for newcomers""" Deletion of Adam Wachter WP:COMPOSER||WP:COMPOSER Wikipedia:Notability 77
5970 2303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bomma Borusa User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:27, 26 December 2008 (UTC) comment I just completed some cleanup and sourcing per film MOS. However, I will not judge this 37-year-old film by an http://www.dinakaran.com/cinema/english/cinebio/23-06-99/balacha2.htm award-winning K. Balachander as non-notable simply because I cannot read Telugu and am unable to discern the content of the non-English sources. That it was made by a man who has won numerous awards, and has numerous Telugu notables in it would seem to indicate in |assuming good faith that the sources are out there... just not in English. Cultural bias is a tough trap to fall into... so I won't Deletion of Bomma Borusa WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
5971 10338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Luther Schofill, Jr. User:David 04:25, 23 June 2010 (UTC) delete I'm not seeing adequate evidence that his filmmaking is enough for , and while the Guggenheim is a worthy accomplishment I'm pretty sure it's less of an indication of notability and more something one gives academics to encourage them to be productive Deletion of John Luther Schofill, Jr. WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5972 18045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sierra Vista Mall (2nd nomination) User:1 18:52, 7 October 2007 (UTC) delete per . BASE10 Deletion of Sierra Vista Mall (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
5973 1683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon Lyons User:GiantSnowman 14:23, 30 March 2009 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Simon Lyons WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
5974 9709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Wood (Christian apologist) User:Vyselink 04:04, 24 January 2011 (UTC) keep This page is filled with sources that do not even come close to meeting the requirements of Wikipedia's (and yes, Someone65, I am aware that you have seen that about a billion times, but that's because it's valid). The reason I say keep ''for now'' is that '''if''' Someone65 can find some reliable, ''third party sources'', this gentleman (who I have heard of, even seen one of his debates) would warrant inclusion on Wikipedia, IMO Deletion of David Wood (Christian apologist) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
5975 15335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Chee Pei Kun User:A 11:23, 5 October 2017 (UTC) delete Using as our standard, this article fails. Even if we take the whole thing at face value, none of the awards or contests won by the subject appear to be notable enough for their own articles Deletion of Jason Chee Pei Kun WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5976 21889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MurmurHash (2nd nomination) User:sligocki 15:42, 15 November 2009 (UTC) keep Unless there's some sort of conflict of interest, I don't see why we need to delete. ikipedia is not paper. It would be nice if the article could be expanded a bit. — Deletion of MurmurHash (2nd nomination) WP:W Help:Watchlist 110
5977 8824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bloody Hands User:MichaelQSchmidt 10:15, 27 October 2015 (UTC) delete or '''userfy''' until more sourcing becomes available. While it IS sourcable as filming, the topic lacks enough coverage in reliable sources to at this time meet | (paragraph 3)... while this may change, for now it is simply |TOO SOON Deletion of Bloody Hands WP:NFF||WP:NYF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5978 12619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Ewin User:Poison 14:49, 6 January 2013 (UTC) delete Fails and seems to fail Deletion of Matt Ewin WP:NMMA||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5979 9670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moquette User:Colonel 13:55, 14 February 2008 (UTC) keep http://books.google.com/books?q=moquette+carpet+-patent&btnG=Search+Books Obviously notable. A case of |So fix it Deletion of Moquette WP:SOFIXIT Wikipedia:Be bold 9
5980 14298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Hall (British Army soldier) User:Clarityfiend 22:30, 20 July 2020 (UTC) delete per nom and also Deletion of James Hall (British Army soldier) WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5981 20296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virginia gubernatorial election, 2013 User:Cocytus 04:00, 4 January 2010 (UTC) delete I agree with Blodance: if it's ''cited'' speculation about an event that's likely to occur, then it's typically borderline acceptable, even with considerations. However, in this case there doesn't seem to be enough to substantiate that route at present Deletion of Virginia gubernatorial election, 2013 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5982 9243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zomk User:Fuhghettaboutit 13:58, 29 August 2006 (UTC) delete Even if it's not made up, it appears to be a |neologism and Wikipedia: What Wikipedia is not#Wikipedia is not a dictionary|Wikipedia is not a dictionary of slang Deletion of Zomk WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
5983 5566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Magennis User:Nfitz 18:22, 8 July 2008 (UTC) keep fails but meets with Belfast Telegraph coverage. I'd hardly call it a local paper, it can be found (not easily mind you) on the newstand in Canada, with the London papers, unlike what we normally call local papers Deletion of Josh Magennis WP:ATHLETE||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5984 9692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Machowicz User:RightCowLeftCoast 03:06, 10 March 2012 (UTC) keep subject passed & Deletion of Richard Machowicz WP:NACTOR||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5985 13169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julie Elston User:David 23:28, 1 June 2016 (UTC) keep Google scholar lists https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=CJaufrsAAAAJ five papers with over 100 citations, and an h-index of nearly 20. It's not enough even to put her in to the top 25% of economists in her state https://ideas.repec.org/top/top.usa-or.html, let alone the top 10% of the US or world https://ideas.repec.org/top/top.usa.html https://ideas.repec.org/top/top.person.all.html but I think it may be enough for #C1 Deletion of Julie Elston WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
5986 6451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/T. P. Sasikumar User:Pharaoh 09:42, 8 February 2012 (UTC) delete Fails , and Deletion of T. P. Sasikumar WP:N||WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
5987 11561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 presidential election User:Redfarmer 12:37, 13 January 2008 (UTC) delete I don't even know that you could call this --it's not predicting anything other than that electoral votes will still be the same in 2012. This is a placeholder article it seems and we don't really need a placeholder for four years Deletion of 2012 presidential election WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
5988 11311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Belegarth User:Dacium 04:31, 3 April 2007 (UTC) delete Fails . No |sources outside of itself Deletion of Belegarth WP:N||WP:ORG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
5989 11228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Back from Ashes User:Andy 22:55, 7 April 2012 (UTC) comment Whatever the outcome of this still-open AfD, equests for comment/TenPoundHammer has ''already'' decided to blank and redirect the album articles for The Suffering Within, 261 (album), Back from Ashes (EP) & Broken (Back from Ashes album). This is a pattern of disruptive behaviour that TenPoundHammer has recently taken to, probably following the criticism of his excessive deletions. Whilst not quite as bad as his blanking of Viz (comic) characters (50+ articles blanked in under half an hour), this is particularly egregious behaviour when it's done around an article that's already at AfD Deletion of Back from Ashes WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
5990 14816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Have It All (Jesse McCartney album) User:OlYeller21 22:30, 27 June 2012 (UTC) delete Album fails . From what I can find (as others have), the album was announced but never released. I won't echo what others have said but can add by saying that a https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ie=UTF-8&ion=1#q=%22Have+It+All%22+%22Jesse+McCartney%22&hl=en&prmd=imvnso&source=lnms&tbm=nws&sa=X&ei=1IfrT46iKYX02QWcybSdAQ&ved=0CDQQ_AUoBA&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.r_qf.,cf.osb&fp=3e4d9bc2e6aefbac&biw=1658&bih=687&ion=1 Google News search produces no significant, independent, and reliable coverage and https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ie=UTF-8&ion=1#q=%22Have+It+All%22+%22Jesse+McCartney%22&hl=en&tbm=nws&prmd=imvnso&source=lnt&tbs=ar:1&sa=X&ei=3YfrT-nONI2LrQHT5IXHBw&ved=0CCQQpwUoBQ&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.r_qf.,cf.osb&fp=3e4d9bc2e6aefbac&ion=1&biw=1658&bih=687 Google News archive search produces no new coverage besides what's already in the article or regurgitation of apparently false non-independent information. In other words, even though the sources that published the information may be reliable, the information they were covering was not. At most, that should be covered but not in its own article and since the rumors are already covered in the Jesse McCartney article, the article should be deleted Deletion of Have It All (Jesse McCartney album) WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
5991 4954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khanbehbin User:Shaundakulbara 06:29, 25 January 2007 (UTC) delete This article provides no |verifiable sources to establish |notability. Its also an un-Wikified mess that shows no respect for thousands of editors who are trying to make Wikipedia not suck Deletion of Khanbehbin WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
5992 13084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riley Evans User:Epbr123 14:11, 15 December 2008 (UTC) keep Passes Deletion of Riley Evans WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
5993 12310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karikku User:Robert 20:20, 4 April 2019 (UTC) comment Does the author of either this article or the draft have an affiliation or |connection with the group? If so, read |the conflict of interest policy and make the required declaration Deletion of Karikku WP:COI||WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
5994 18665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelli Smith (2nd nomination) User:Seasider91 13:46, 14 May 2016 (UTC) comment The policy concerns the notability of association football players regardless of age, race or gender, when creating an article on Wikipedia the guidelines for notability have to be met otherwise any Tom, Dick or Harry could have a Wikipedia article made about them and that would take up a lot of space Deletion of Kelli Smith (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
5995 14 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cole Pemberton User:Giants27 18:37, 15 August 2011 (UTC) delete Fails , , and Deletion of Cole Pemberton WP:ATH||WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
5996 13085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Righeira (Righeira album) User:Synthwave 14:42, 31 March 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Righeira (Righeira album) WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
5997 2014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dark Princess User:Poeloq 00:32, 15 January 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability guidelines at usic Deletion of Dark Princess WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
5998 14702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Semantic annotation User:Eggishorn 15:29, 28 December 2016 (UTC) delete minor stub with no indication of independent notability. Little more than Deletion of Semantic annotation WP:DICTDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
5999 20905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Chae-yeon (singer) User:HueMan1 16:05, 17 August 2021 (UTC) merge to Iz*One as an Deletion of Lee Chae-yeon (singer) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
6000 12922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bresketball User:Hobbes 01:35, 28 September 2011 (UTC) delete As a |neologism, or, if you want to bend over backwards to be generous, on the grounds that |WP is not a dictionary.--amongst the small number of cruddy, juvenile Google hits, there is an Urban Dictionary entry, for what that's worth Deletion of Bresketball WP:NEO||WP:NOTDIC Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
6001 19298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haldane Rodger Cram User:Piotrus 10:02, 3 November 2014 (UTC) delete """Seems a violation of and . A passing mention in an academic journal is not sufficient to establish notability. And that's assuming this is not a hoax, as I cannot find the reference (""""A changing of the guard: regional planning in Ottawa, 1944-1974"""") mentioned anywhere on the web outside of this very article""" Deletion of Haldane Rodger Cram WP:GNG||WP:MEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6002 18480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reaper bot User:Cunard 06:25, 20 July 2010 (UTC) delete per the lack of |reliable sources. I concur with Arbitrarily0 that there's nothing verifiable to merge Deletion of Reaper bot WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6003 49 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlos Valdes (actor) (2nd nomination) User:Victor 04:19, 6 January 2015 (UTC) keep There are some minor sources that we could add (http://www.accesshollywood.com/carlos-valdes-flash-characters-bubbly-personalities-affect-arrow_article_101396 this, http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/ustv/s246/the-flash/news/a616356/the-flashs-carlos-valdes-on-becoming-hero-vibe-its-up-in-the-air.html#~p0ySHYzm3iF47G this and http://www.thewrap.com/cw-flash-pilot-adds-broadway-actor-carlos-valdes-casting/ this, for example), but I guess this article is unlikely to grow beyond a stub in the near future, and the fact that we only find Flash-related sources could possibly make him a case of Deletion of Carlos Valdes (actor) (2nd nomination) WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6004 21784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Belvidere Cemetery User:Alansohn 05:29, 5 September 2007 (UTC) keep to Belvidere, New Jersey (as has already been done). In addition to satisfying the Wikipedia:Cemeteries guidelines, the article provides a complete set of reliable and verifiable sources for all of the notables listed, making it the largest such cemetery in a county of several hundred residents. The nominator's insistence that only cemeteries such as Arlington National Cemetery is ludicrous on its face. The nominator acknowledges that the material is encylopedic, and seems to be trying to make a disruptive and destructive here (as described on his talk page) by pushing to delete this and other articles, while refusing to consider the suggestion made to merge Deletion of Belvidere Cemetery WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
6005 14143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WebTrain User:Matilda 00:02, 19 June 2008 (UTC) comment I have no difficulty with userfying the article '''again''' while it is developed. The reason there is a time limit being suggested is that the content breaches which is policy and that applies to user pages too. As per discussions at Wikipedia:Conflict of interest/Noticeboard#User Gary WebTrain one month seems reasonable Deletion of WebTrain WP:NOTADVERTISING Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6006 9461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katya Cengel User:Samsmachado 23:42, 2 October 2020 (UTC) keep Easily meets criteria 3 of as proven by AleatoryPonderings. As demonstrated by '''W''''''42''' and my GoogleNews search, there is also sufficient coverage of Cengel to meet Deletion of Katya Cengel WP:NAUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6007 14600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008 attack at Beijing Drum Tower during Olympics User:Davumaya 03:42, 31 October 2008 (UTC) delete """Fails #NEWS """"News coverage can be useful source material for encyclopedic topics, but '''not all events warrant an encyclopedia article of their own.'''"""" As for claims of censorship, see Concerns and controversies over the 2008 Summer Olympics. Again this article does not bear additional weight beyond that main article""" Deletion of 2008 attack at Beijing Drum Tower during Olympics WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6008 6751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Carlos Castañeda Elementary School User:TerriersFan 23:38, 7 February 2008 (UTC) merge into McAllen Independent School District per and accepted practice Deletion of Dr. Carlos Castañeda Elementary School WP:SCL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6009 17145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Feminist Hulk User:Winner 19:49, 5 May 2015 (UTC) keep The subject has been the subject of significant coverage by several major news organisations including NPR, the Huffington Post, and boston.com's Boston Globe ideas section. I'll be honest here, either but that is not a reason for deletion and it clearly passes Deletion of Feminist Hulk WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6010 6098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/University of Alabama in Huntsville varsity tennis team Playboy controversy User:Pedro 21:30, 24 May 2010 (UTC) delete Let alone the poor sourcing and likely concerns, the claimed |notability of this event to demand coverage by an |encyclopedia is highly dubious Deletion of University of Alabama in Huntsville varsity tennis team Playboy controversy WP:BLP||WP:N||WP:ENC Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6011 14712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pakistan Union Norway User:GretLomborg 13:24, 22 June 2017 (UTC) delete as per nom. It lacks sources to establish notability under and I cannot find any for it Deletion of Pakistan Union Norway WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6012 5561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeviceAtlas User:JJMC89 05:39, 14 September 2016 (UTC) delete The sources cited and others I could find are press releases/announcements, routine coverage, unreliable, and/or don't cover DeviceAtlas in-depth. is not satisfied. —&thinsp Deletion of DeviceAtlas WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
6013 4140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AIS Time User:Cnilep 13:33, 27 August 2009 (UTC) delete """as an unsourced |neologism. Furthermore the page currently consists of a |definition and a de-facto """"opular culture|In popular culture"""" section (the description of the television episode), neither of which is appropriate as the sole content of an article. (I suppose one could argue that the combination of the two is sufficient; I disagree.) Note, too, that the references suggested by MichaelQSchmidt are uses of the term ''ass-in-seat'', not uses or descriptions of ''AIS time""" Deletion of AIS Time WP:NEO||WP:DICDEF||WP:P Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
6014 21506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eliot Prince User:Drmies 16:51, 4 March 2009 (UTC) delete as a : there is no such player on the Chelsea F.C. roster. Some kid dreamed this up, but it's vandalism: he or she should do well to pay more attention in English class as well Deletion of Eliot Prince WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
6015 9633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BPM Energy User:Guliolopez 16:52, 8 May 2017 (UTC) delete or '''merge/redirect'''. Per nom. And Deletion of BPM Energy WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6016 1035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rachel Roxxx (2nd nomination) User:Smith 19:10, 5 December 2010 (UTC) delete im not going to go in the validity of having a biography on a glorifeid prostitute on wikiepdia. while there asre some porners like Jenna Jameson that have legitimate mainstream coverage in the mainstream media, there are also hunrdedds of porn stars whose names arent really known or covered outside of porn industry blogs and random little dinky ratholes on the Net. one criteria that we need to remember is and . especially the later, its difficult to find verifiable sources on these porn people because half the time the article writers dont even bother to find their real names or to figure out what fake name theyre using to whore. this isnt necessarily a disaster except that they rarely bother to find sources that cover this that would meet ANY standard of notability currently upeld by Wikipedia. articles like pople on Rahcel Roxx are only marginally more notable than your average garage band and posting articles on every hooker in California isnt going to fly unless you can find sources to verify some of these comments, which also dangerously push up on without |reliable sources. to reiterate, this article should be ''deleted'' and ONLY rercreated once verifiable, s are detected Deletion of Rachel Roxxx (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:V||WP:BLP||WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6017 247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devamrita Swami (2nd nomination) User:L3X1 19:25, 30 November 2017 (UTC) delete Some mentions, but fails |NMonk Deletion of Devamrita Swami (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6018 17227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randford University User:Thunderwing 12:10, 15 April 2007 (UTC) delete not notable- fails Deletion of Randford University WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6019 10504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Weapons of Eve Online User:Sandstein 21:44, 2 November 2006 (UTC) delete Zero external sources merits automatic deletion per . Also, is the policy that a game guide really so hard to understand Deletion of Weapons of Eve Online WP:NOR||WP:NOT Wikipedia:No original research 65
6020 18517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/West Virginia Route 817 User:Scott5114 19:59, 12 November 2008 (UTC) keep clearly meets , as the ''Charleston Daily Mail'' did a story about it (which is used as a reference), and as a primary state highway, would be considered notable enough for an article anyway per /NT. (This highway was until recently a segment of U.S. 35, which is enough historic significance for USRD.) Minor highways lists have become somewhat deprecated in USRD; we should see about revising that guideline to reflect this practice Deletion of West Virginia Route 817 WP:N||WP:USRD Wikipedia:Notability 77
6021 8858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Attenborough user:Andrew 15:28, 25 August 2014 (UTC) keep The sources demonstrate notability per . It's not our role to question the reasons why the sources cover the subject in such detail Deletion of John Attenborough WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6022 21848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Candice LeRae User:Ichibani 22:47, 3 May 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails as there is only one reference, and that reference is discussing an event in which she participated, not LeRae herself Deletion of Candice LeRae WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6023 16316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I'm Always Right User:Jakew 21:41, 29 August 2007 (UTC) delete as non-notable advertisement. It is also impossible to make it conform to without third-party sources Deletion of I'm Always Right WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
6024 19107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ronen Segev User:DeLarge 18:09, 23 January 2007 (UTC) keep I'm leaning towards ''strong keep'', actually. There may in the past have been content added which stepped on the toes of , but looking at the article at this minute, all that's there is a brief bio which indisputably asserts his ote|notability through http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=940DE1D71339F934A3575AC0A9679C8B63 this cited source. There's no need to get so antsy about deletion when all we have to do is splice out the stuff about his arrest Deletion of Ronen Segev WP:BLP||WP:N Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6025 13098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buffalo hunting (disambiguation) User:Jujutacular 17:18, 1 February 2010 (UTC) delete per nom. says that we only need disambiguation pages if multiple articles exist. Seeing as they are redlinks, this is not needed. The page can be recreated if the other articles are created Deletion of Buffalo hunting (disambiguation) WP:DISAM Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
6026 5371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dom Dwyer User:Mattythewhite 17:16, 25 March 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Dom Dwyer WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6027 18252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyler Matakevich User:Paulmcdonald 16:57, 26 November 2013 (UTC) delete coverage that I can find appears to be local and on his high school playing career, and high school players are rarely notable. I see no exception here. He could achieve notability through from his college play, but I don't see that as achieved just yet. I recommend that the article creator |try another wiki for now and when he's ready, we will be too Deletion of Tyler Matakevich WP:GNG||WP:TRYANOTHER Wikipedia:Notability 77
6028 13735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sinbad Rock User:Bearian 00:23, 8 July 2021 (UTC) delete per . Where is the signficiant coverage? Most importantly, this completely lacks any secondary sources Deletion of Sinbad Rock WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
6029 12203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myron Boadu User:Kosack 06:29, 18 June 2017 (UTC) delete fails having never played in a fully professional league and does not have enough significant coverage to pass Deletion of Myron Boadu WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6030 6433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vanessa LEE-AHMAT User:Pilean 16:19, 31 January 2021 (UTC) keep She passes as per honoured by Parliament of Australia and as per faculty of medicine and health at University of Sydney Deletion of Vanessa LEE-AHMAT WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6031 10432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silicone Sex World User:K 04:59, 16 August 2018 (UTC) delete fails & . Coverage offered above is PR-driven and publicity seeking Deletion of Silicone Sex World WP:NCORP||WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
6032 1803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jenn Dolari (2nd nomination) User:Bucketsofg 19:21, 20 January 2007 (UTC) delete as failing unless we have multiple independent sources Deletion of Jenn Dolari (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6033 1820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Levi Johnston User:S 00:39, 10 May 2009 (UTC) delete This unremarkable individual has received a certain amount of attention from the more immature and gossipy rags as a result of his tenuous connection with Sarah Palin, and thus his existence and status are |verifiable from |reliable sources. Therefore his name is a plausible search term, and should not be a redlink. However, he is not |notable enough for his own article because |notability is not inherited. Thus, a redirect is the only option consistent with policy and guidelines.The reason I think the article's previous content and history should be deleted is because it is not encyclopaedic in nature and is in conflict with the guidelines and policies I cited a moment ago Deletion of Levi Johnston WP:V||WP:RS||WP:N||WP:INHERITED Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6034 18492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Morgan User:Dhartung 06:53, 23 May 2007 (UTC) delete """fails . Has not """"competed at the highest level"""", and being diabetic is ... not uncommon, unfortunately. It's certainly no bar to athletic competition""" Deletion of Alan Morgan WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6035 20122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Björn Thorsell User:Ejgreen77 12:13, 28 February 2018 (UTC) keep Right now, he doesn't meet , however, it appears that there's a decent argument that the omission of the league he played in at the time he was playing in is from /LA is the result of a simple oversight. A wider discussion is probably needed here Deletion of Björn Thorsell WP:NHOCKEY||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
6036 1343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Power (actor) User:MichaelQSchmidt 19:07, 9 May 2009 (UTC) comment """The basice citeria for begins """"''A person is presumed to be notable if he or she has been the subject of published secondary source material which is reliable, intellectually independent, and independent of the subject. If the depth of coverage is not substantial, then multiple independent sources may be needed to prove notability; trivial coverage of a subject by secondary sources may not be sufficient to establish notability. Primary sources may be used to support content in an article, but they do not contribute toward proving the notability of a subject.''"""". Simple and difficuly to misunderstand. The next section """"additional criteria"""" list some additional standards, of which is one, but specifically states among its cautionary caveats: """"''Failure to meet these criteria is not conclusive proof that a subject should not be included''"""" and """"''Should a person fail to meet these additional criteria, '''they may still be notable''' under Wikipedia:Notability.''"""" Continuing on past these preliminary instructions in order to then find some way to exclude a notable person is not what guideine expects or desires. This individual's notability has been asserted, properly established, and properly sourced through and . Thank you""" Deletion of Sean Power (actor) WP:PEOPLE||WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6037 8882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Ferrante User:Yvarta 14:22, 13 August 2016 (UTC) merge to Michael Franzese per RegistryKey and , which argues against a separate page for people only known for being involved in a crime Deletion of William Ferrante WP:PERP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6038 11193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IndiaLaw LLP. User:Spiderone 15:14, 28 December 2018 (UTC) delete clear failure Deletion of IndiaLaw LLP. WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6039 21877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2006–07 Stevenage Borough F.C. season User:Number 08:46, 26 August 2016 (UTC) delete Clear consensus that these fail and we need to have a cut-off somewhere Deletion of 2006–07 Stevenage Borough F.C. season WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6040 3909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brain Occupation in Traditional Chinese Medicine [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 03:47, 17 December 2012 (UTC) delete the sources provided aren't about Chinese medicine at all. This looks to be an essay based on some tenuously referenced (, basically) ideas and concepts Deletion of Brain Occupation in Traditional Chinese Medicine WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
6041 699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Velubha Vaghela User:AllyD 07:48, 5 January 2016 (UTC) delete An elected position in a village of under 6000 population does not meet criteria 2 or 3. In addition, the given reference just mentions the village in a list, and not the person, so is providing no verification, leaving this article an |unsourced BLP Deletion of Velubha Vaghela :WP:POLITICIAN||:WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6042 21791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zou Yitian User:Ultraexactzz 19:27, 24 October 2011 (UTC) delete If there were coverage of this individual in his own right, then maybe a case could be made for notability. But I'm not seeing that here, nor can I find it elsewhere. applies, however, if the subject becomes more obviously notable down the line Deletion of Zou Yitian WP:USUAL Wikipedia:Usual caveats 41
6043 20999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdulmajeed Al Abbas User:Spiderone 09:18, 4 May 2021 (UTC) delete this is, at best, a massive . His only game for Al-Nassr was against a 3rd tier side so does not pass . No significant coverage cited and searching his name in Arabic comes up with nothing outside a squad list mention, Kooora, Soccerway and his clubs' own websites. The draft can be retained if people wish for it to be but this doesn't meet our agreed minimum inclusion criteria and I see no reason for us to ignore notability guidelines in this case Deletion of Abdulmajeed Al Abbas WP:TOOSOON||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Too soon 40
6044 3391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Over Ashes User:fvw 17:21, 14 December 2008 (UTC) delete some notability perhaps, for very small values of some, but nothing approaching Deletion of Over Ashes WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6045 20283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/9/12 Candidate User:S 21:02, 30 June 2009 (UTC) delete it now, and add it back |when it becomes |notable Deletion of 9/12 Candidate WP:AGF||WP:N Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
6046 6172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swedish Judicial Authority v. Julian Assange user:victor 20:25, 8 March 2011 (UTC) keep per wikipedia:summary style|wikipedia:summary style (WP:SS), according to which sections may be spun off to own article per to avoid . See Silvio Berlusconi underage prostitution charges and Roman Polanski sexual abuse case for analogy. Special:Contributions/Victor_falk|''walk Deletion of Swedish Judicial Authority v. Julian Assange WP:CFORK||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Content forking 33
6047 7386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Boys (South African gang) User:Oldlaptop321 15:36, 27 April 2009 (UTC) delete Not a single source, fails , , and laughingly unnotable Deletion of The Boys (South African gang) WP:ONEEVENT||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6048 16718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bismarck Model user:Andrew 13:39, 9 August 2020 (UTC) keep The topic seems quite notable. See the scholar links above and Deletion of Bismarck Model WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
6049 14622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reuben Doctora Jr. User:Narutolovehinata5 01:03, 9 March 2013 (UTC) delete Unfortunately, the United Football League (Philippines)|UFL isn't a fully-professional league yet (it's only semi-professional, although its fanbase is growing), and as such, he fails Deletion of Reuben Doctora Jr. WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6050 5861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Super Junior's Untitled fifth studio album User:Michaela 11:27, 19 July 2011 (UTC) delete """Wikipedia is not a collection of product announcements"""" per . The article is a collection of claims by various individuals that they are working on the album, with no official details eg name of album, lead tracks, release date, track listing etc. So """"it's not going to hurt you to wait"""", as so neatly summarized, then at least the article can be named properly rather than the generic """"fifth studio album""" Deletion of Super Junior's Untitled fifth studio album WP:FUTURE||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6051 14175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minor technology in Sonic the Hedgehog User:Tgies 07:02, 6 June 2008 (UTC) delete No future for this. an indiscriminate collection of information etc Deletion of Minor technology in Sonic the Hedgehog WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6052 14990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon Gudge User:Bdb484 18:56, 18 May 2009 (UTC) delete Nothing to verify notability. As a note, the one source cited http://nobudgetfilms.net/?p=269 seems to fall under , as users upload their own films and descriptions. He sounds like he may be interesting, but let's let someone independent decide that Deletion of Simon Gudge WP:SPS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6053 14595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eugene Plotkin User:Edison 03:27, 27 February 2012 (UTC) keep Notable crime. Sourcing satisfies . (And who doesn't love a story wherein a retired seamstress in Croatia making $270 a month, makes millions in insider trading, via her young relative in the US Deletion of Eugene Plotkin WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6054 18434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rendavathu Padam User:Johannes003 17:28, 12 December 2011 (UTC) keep What's wrong with the article? It has several |reliable, |third party sources, principal photography has commenced, no Wikipedia:POV|POV... What else Deletion of Rendavathu Padam WP:RS||WP:THIRDPARTY Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6055 15150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of shaggy dog stories User:Budgiekiller 18:32, 7 January 2007 (UTC) delete it's what Wikipedia is |not about. Pretty much |schoolyard behaviour Deletion of List of shaggy dog stories WP:NOT||WP:NFT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6056 19128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of legislators who support SOPA or PIPA User:George2001hi 16:54, 23 January 2012 (UTC) keep for the |international reaction to this bill, this list is useful Deletion of List of legislators who support SOPA or PIPA WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6057 2562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelechi Onyenachi User:Paulmcdonald 02:54, 16 December 2013 (UTC) delete clearly a promotional piece. Stats aren't even all that impressive for a high school player at his peer level. I would support a on this one per G-11 and possibly A-7 Deletion of Kelechi Onyenachi WP:SPEEDY Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
6058 11713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SLAM Magazine's Top 50 Players of All-Time (NBA) User:Metropolitan90 01:37, 3 July 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. No |independent reliable sources have been provided that discuss this list Deletion of SLAM Magazine's Top 50 Players of All-Time (NBA) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6059 1844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry David Evans User:Papaursa 16:01, 23 February 2019 (UTC) delete There are over 3000 active IMs, which is why I suspect the Chess project didn't say it was enough to show notability. He lacks the significant independent coverage to meet Deletion of Larry David Evans WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6060 15199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yeh Dil Kisko Doon User:Donaldd23 19:37, 10 September 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Yeh Dil Kisko Doon WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
6061 20243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simonball User:Docether 20:22, 29 June 2006 (UTC) delete """I'm tempted to say that Wikipedia is |not for things made up in (Cottenham) one day, but let it pass, let it pass. Regardless of how fun this game might be, """"fun"""" is not the measure by which AfDs are resolved ... and, as this article does not present erifiability|verifiable evidence of its subject's otability|notability, it should be deleted. Best""" Deletion of Simonball WP:NOT||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6062 13472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susan Fuhrman User:David 03:29, 9 October 2009 (UTC) keep I consider the #6 argument to be completely convincing, but she's also been named one of New York's 100 most influential women in a magazine article (now included), so I think there's a clear pass of more generally Deletion of Susan Fuhrman WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6063 15551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Royal Order of the Golden Fire Dog User:Bearian 20:25, 12 November 2020 (UTC) delete WP:RS is required to pass . Wikipedia has never published |original research like this, and in 2020, everybody knpws that Deletion of Royal Order of the Golden Fire Dog WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6064 13195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hurricane Danielle (2004) (2nd nomination) NONE NONE merge to 2004 Atlantic hurricane season - There's no evidence of notability (and, by the way, LASTING literally gives non-destructive storms as their example of ''not'' having lasting notability:{{quote|Events that have a noted and sourced permanent effect of historical significance are likely to be notable. This includes, for example, natural disasters that result in widespread destruction, since they lead to rebuilding, population shifts, and possible impact on elections. For example, Hurricane Katrina or the 2004 Indian Ocean earthquake are notable by these standards. '''A minor earthquake or storm with little or no impact on human populations is probably not notable Deletion of Hurricane Danielle (2004) (2nd nomination) WP:LASTING Wikipedia:Notability 77
6065 1304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Ng NONE NONE comment I find it a bit humorous the way some WP-folk deal with other editors they use , , , , , , digging through a users contributions like an overly zealous proctologist and many others in their arsenal of weapons to submit their opponents to their will (much the same way I would a challenger in the ring). I say don’t be a ... I admit I have many flaws, I am a ass sometimes, as well I’m a prankster. I really don’t know my ass from a hole in the ground here in wickipedia (there is a hell of a learning curve; and I’m not getting payed as some people on this site). So If I hurt someone feelings by my word choices let me say I’m from the bottom of my heart (with sugar on top). Now can we act like grown men with a set of brass balls and not panzy-metrosexul ? Because I really don’t give a Deletion of John Ng WP:AFD||WP:COI||WP:NPOV||WP:VAND||WP:OR||WP:BIO||WP:SORRY||WP:MASTODONS||WP:FUCK||WP:dick Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6066 13742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Beams [[User talk:Orderinchaos|Orderinchaos]] 05:46, 4 August 2010 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Nick Beams WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
6067 7149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CTL Global Solutions User:Melcous 01:43, 18 June 2016 (UTC) delete the references given are either associated with the company or for awards that are not notable. Doesn't meet primary criteria of Deletion of CTL Global Solutions WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6068 13201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Adding Machine: Collected Essays User:Stifle 10:32, 1 May 2010 (UTC) delete unless references added. As ever, the |burden of proof is on those seeking to include content to provide proper sourcing Deletion of The Adding Machine: Collected Essays WP:BURDEN Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6069 4802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shihab S. Asfour User:David 00:00, 8 July 2016 (UTC) delete This is essentially just a cv, and neither his Google scholar citation counts nor his administrative position are enough to convince me of a pass of Deletion of Shihab S. Asfour WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6070 18336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southern Ontario Model United Nations Association User:Bearcat 16:58, 11 May 2020 (UTC) delete """Organizations are not automatically entitled to have Wikipedia articles just because they exist — they need to show sufficient |reliable source coverage in real media to clear . But this features literally no non-|primary sources at all — a press release on the self-published website of a directly affiliated school is not notability-assisting media coverage at all, yet that's the ''only'' source here that the organization didn't produce ''itself'' — and claims nothing about the organization that would be """"inherently"""" notable enough to exempt it from having to show significantly better sources than this""" Deletion of Southern Ontario Model United Nations Association WP:RS||WP:ORGDEPTH||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6071 209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carmen Perez User:Porqin 04:24, 1 May 2008 (UTC) delete The article claims to be written by the subject herself. Fails Deletion of Carmen Perez WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
6072 20439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs involving computer and video games [[User_talk:Dlohcierekim| :) Dlohcierekim]] 18:10, 16 May 2006 (UTC) keep Wikipeida is |not a ''paper'' encyclopedia Deletion of List of songs involving computer and video games WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6073 13521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sy Rogers User:JGabbard 14:56, 5 March 2019 (UTC) keep Passes not only because of multiple secondary sources, but also a documentary about his life. Rogers is a pioneer figure who gained notoriety in the realm at least five to 10 years before associated figures arose such as John Paulk, Anne Paulk, Andrew Comiskey, John Smid, Alan Chambers (activist)|Alan Chambers, Wayne Besen and Joe Dallas, most of whose articles have far less support than this one now has. Relatively speaking, it would make no sense to keep theirs but not his, because Rogers' notability surpasses theirs and they would all likely say the same. All of them early on would have drawn some inspiration from Rogers Deletion of Sy Rogers WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6074 8826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of artists influenced by Christina Aguilera User:doomsdayer520 14:07, 13 April 2021 (UTC) delete Not an informative list article per and . Anyone who says they were influenced by Xtina can have that fact stated at their own article, if it is backed up by reliable sources Deletion of List of artists influenced by Christina Aguilera WP:LISTCRUFT||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
6075 16579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warner Avenue User:Imzadi1979 23:02, 10 September 2019 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Warner Avenue WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6076 9364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Levi Simoes User:Barno 21:10, 22 February 2006 (UTC) delete http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=%22Levi+Simoes%22&btnG=Search Google search shows low- and mid-level racing, with nothing to indicate he would pass Deletion of Levi Simoes WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6077 10422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PSA Athletics User:Nuttah68 20:03, 11 January 2007 (UTC) delete as . Wikipedia is not the place for an article on inter school sports results, let alone articles on individual events Deletion of PSA Athletics WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6078 15372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Citizens' Coalition User:Sjö 05:56, 27 September 2017 (UTC) delete not enough significant coverage in independent WP:RS. Of the nine sources in the article four are from the party itself, one (Wilderäng) is a blog, two are links to official records that verify that the party exist and only two are from a news source. There are some more mentions in WP:RS that are not as of now included as sources, but not enough to reach notability. FWIW, the article about the party has been deleted as non-notable on the Swedish Wikipedia, citing that they haven't gained sufficiently significant attention by the world at large and over a period of time, and that no representative for the party has been elected in a public election . (I know that the last criterion isn't included in , but I think that it's relevant to the discussion about notability Deletion of Citizens' Coalition WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6079 5286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darius Mosun User:CiaranG 08:12, 31 January 2007 (UTC) delete there seems to me to be a clear issue with the article which is evident both from the promotional tone, and the author's linkspamming activities, though in fairness I must point out that the author has strongly denied any problems with or . The sources provided on the article page do not establish notability per . The additional sources discussed on the talk page might well satisfy for the company in question, but not for the individual. If the article were to stay, it would need a complete re-write from reliable sources, if available, since currently it reads like an advert Deletion of Darius Mosun WP:COI||WP:AUTO||WP:COI||WP:BIO||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
6080 178 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/OtonomA """Kullanıcı:dbl2010özgür""" 19:44, 27 Mayıs 2006 (UTC) delete Bknz. OtonomA'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:Vikipedi ne değildir Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6081 557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SmartRecruiters User:K 05:03, 3 May 2018 (UTC) delete None of the sources meet . For example, Forbes is forbes.com/site which is a user submitted area, not editorial content; possibly a promo placement. Techcrunch is way too indiscriminate to count towards notability in tech. The rest of the sources are likewise non-independent / Deletion of SmartRecruiters WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:SPIP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6082 14009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lewis P. Fisher User:Rollidan 21:39, 23 September 2019 (UTC) delete Per arguments above as well. The standards, such as and are set up, and if sources cannot be shown to exist, the subject does not pass notability Deletion of Lewis P. Fisher WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6083 7558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Brother 2009 (UK) User:Malkinann 20:03, 8 September 2008 (UTC) comment why should it be deleted because it's unlikely to be expanded significantly until January or possibly the airing? The examples at WP:CRYSTAL (the Olympics and the election) are unlikely to be significantly expanded until when the event is over. The article on this show is a stub, but it's a reliably sourced stub with potential to expand in the (relatively) near future. In it says that articles should be assessed based on their potential - as the show has been confirmed to be in the works, I believe it has potential Deletion of Big Brother 2009 (UK) WP:NOEFFORT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6084 269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Praise and veneration of Muhammad User:FreeatlastChitchat 05:53, 27 December 2015 (UTC) keep """A very hilarious reason for deleting has been provided which should be included in and reasons for not nominating an article. I literally looked twice to make sure I was reading it right. The thing that is so wrong with this article is that it """"Looks like a overtly positive article"""", yes gentlemen, we should delete an article about veneration because it discusses veneration. and Even if the article is titled """"Praise and veneration of XXXXXXX"""" it should '''not''' include positive views? Can someone just shoot me already. Another concern seems to be that the article has and issues,,,,,,,,,,,and should therefore be '''DELETED''' instead of being improved. I hang my head in shame at this view and would like to say that articles with these issues are to be improved instead of deleted. The topic """"Praise and veneration of Muhammad"""" is encyclopedic in nature and has quite a lot of encyclopedic value and therefore it makes sense. Can the article be improved? YES. Should the article be just wiped off the face of wiki just because there is room for improvement there? '''NO''', and I do hope we do not set a precedent here. Appears to be a classic case of from the nom as he thinks that only topics critical of the subject are allowed""" Deletion of Praise and veneration of Muhammad WP:BULLSHIT||WP:PRIMARY||WP:QUOTE||WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
6085 14186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rationale for the War on Terrorism User:Rankiri 11:50, 23 March 2010 (UTC) delete Unintentional . Compare with War on Terror#US objectives Deletion of Rationale for the War on Terrorism WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
6086 19920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ann Marie Curling User:Coredesat 06:08, 2 July 2006 (UTC) delete per Pascal.Tesson. |Wikipedia is not a promotional tool. This AFD may need to be monitored for vandalism, if negative comments on this person are being removed from the talk page Deletion of Ann Marie Curling WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6087 16823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Good Blades User:ShadowHalo 05:27, 25 January 2007 (UTC) delete Non-notable with insufficient |reliable sources Deletion of Good Blades WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6088 18935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Wermerskirchen User:Kirbanzo 18:23, 7 May 2019 (UTC) delete I originally BLP-prodded it because I missed some cited sources, but yeah, it fails . It's pretty much attempting to claim notability from |one event. Kirbanzo Deletion of Brian Wermerskirchen WP:NBIO||WP:1EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6089 15872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swine (song) User:IndianBio 05:07, 7 April 2014 (UTC) keep The article passes now and can be kept as a standalone article. Thanks to {{ping|Another Believer}} for making this happen Deletion of Swine (song) WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
6090 9784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marita Black User:Atlantic306 00:20, 30 April 2021 (UTC) delete as there is a lack of substantial coverage in multiple reliable sources so that asic is not passed at this time. Also only one prominent role so does not meet the criteria of in my view Deletion of Marita Black WP:B||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Bots 21
6091 439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of famous failures in science and engineering User:Andrewh 21:07, 30 June 2006 (UTC) keep while I voted delete for List of famous successes in science and engineering, I will give weak support for keeping this article. It's not essential to Wikipedia, and may have some problems |POV-wise, but it's always interesting to find out about the scientific or engineering projects that generally ''weren't'' so successful (it's not so interesting reading about successes, as most people, for obvious reasons, know about them anyway). Given a cleanup, this article will be much more worthy of inclusion in Wikipedia Deletion of List of famous failures in science and engineering WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
6092 2807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ayman Ahmed El-Difrawi User:Sc 04:02, 29 September 2007 (UTC) delete Fails for notability Deletion of Ayman Ahmed El-Difrawi WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6093 16765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Lehr [[User talk:99.73.74.57|talk]]) NONE keep Legitimate claims with real sources. The page DOES meet the requirements of (See Awards) 4:58, 7 July 2012 (UTC) — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/99.73.74.57|99.73.74.57 Deletion of David Lehr WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6094 127 [[Thomas Mann und das Judentum]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Mautpreller 10:31, 7. Sep. 2012 (CEST) keep Übrigens gibt es einen alten, ebenfalls sehr bedenklichen Präzedenzfall: Brecht und der 17. Juni 1953 wurde vor knapp vier Jahren /14. Oktober 2008#Brecht und der 17. Juni 1953 (gelöscht)|gelöscht und auch in der Wikipedia:Löschprüfung/Archiv/2008/Woche 43#Brecht und der 17. Juni 1953|Löschprüfung nicht wiederhergestellt. Der Löschung von Thomas Mann und das Judentum Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6095 8690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Northkeep User:Folken 11:01, 6 September 2013 (UTC) merge into List of Forgotten Realms cities (if there is appropriate content), otherwise '''Delete'''. The absence of significant coverage from reliable independent secondary sources does not establish notability for the topic, which means there cannot be a stand-alone article, per Deletion of Northkeep WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6096 7290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyloon User:Ohconfucius 03:27, 13 October 2006 (UTC) delete non notable |neologism and non notable |company/trademark. Although the company claims (xinhua article) that the search engine is the first ever capable of simultaneous multi-lingual searches, it's still a startup which has not yet established itself Deletion of Tyloon WP:NEO||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
6097 11326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashwin Gupta User:Stuartyeates 04:11, 12 August 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Ashwin Gupta WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6098 8130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National Rebirth Alliance User:Cewbot 00:02, 2 February 2021 (UTC) comment This nomination has had limited participation and falls within the standards set for |lack of quorum. There are no previous AfD discussions, undeletions, or current redirects and no previous PRODs have been located. This nomination may be '''eligible for |soft deletion''' at the end of its 7-day listing Deletion of National Rebirth Alliance WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
6099 21813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Langford User:Espresso 01:43, 5 February 2021 (UTC) comment It was not deleted after a deletion discussion. Recreating after a proposed deletion is no different from contesting the prod. Not opposed to deletion, but imo it's not eligible for speedy deletion under , or . As the declining admin I'd also note that, in addition to the playing claim, there's a claim to coach British Basketball to be considered (which I didn't mention in the edit summary but did consider in the decline Deletion of Andrew Langford WP:G4||WP:G11||WP:A7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
6100 17925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Young Dizzy User:E 01:12, 21 February 2017 (UTC) delete """as Nom says,no found. I tried, and every hit I got was a false positive on some phrase like """" Neil Young, Dizzy Gillespie, Theloneous Monk..."""" or """"the young Dizzy Gillespie..."""". Clever name for a young performer. Wish him well and hope it's just """ Deletion of Young Dizzy WP:RS||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6101 5081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alpha Theta Sigma User:Terrillja 18:11, 29 December 2008 (UTC) delete nothing to show why this is notable, and the creator identifies himself by name on his userpage, then names himself as one of the founders of the fraternity. and . The fact this article has been speedy deleted and recreated six times in the last yearhttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&page=Alpha_Theta_Sigma implies that consensus is that this group is not notable Deletion of Alpha Theta Sigma WP:COI||WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
6102 21 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Kuzgun Nogay Kullanıcı:seksen iki yüz kırk beşseksen iki yüz kırk beş / ggt 15.33, 27 Şubat 2022 (UTC) delete Gerek Kuzgun Nogay, gerekse Nogay Kesim ismiyle detaylı aramalar yaptım. Almış olduğu ödüller olsa da bunlar 'yi karşılamaya yetecek önemde ödüller değil gibi gözüküyor. Kendisini veya eserlerini konu alan bağımsız kaynaklar tespit etmem de mümkün olmadı Kuzgun Nogay'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
6103 8657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Thom User:Spaceman7Spiff 21:50, 3 June 2009 (UTC) delete NN, fails , an award by a boutique magazine in a large field doesn't qualify Deletion of Jeff Thom WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6104 8175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spice Girls Live In London User:Milk 22:08, 27 February 2008 (UTC) delete This is a future album, so it fail Deletion of Spice Girls Live In London WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6105 15490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Subhash Ware User:Redtigerxyz 16:10, 17 March 2014 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Subhash Ware WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
6106 3197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Not for Sale (organization) User:Rhododendrites 15:10, 25 November 2015 (UTC) keep Passes . http://www.huffingtonpost.com/michelle-s-melendez/not-for-sale-nonprofit_b_1917561.html Huffington Post, http://www.usnews.com/news/blogs/washington-whispers/2012/10/09/meet-the-nonprofit-helping-the-white-house-stop-human-trafficking U.S. News & World Report, http://www.latimes.com/sports/dodgers/dodgersnow/la-sp-dn-dodgers-adrian-gonzalez-joins-effort-to-combat-human-trafficking-20150612-story.html LA Times, http://www.forbes.com/sites/kareanderson/2014/02/21/how-exactly-can-we-accomplish-greater-things-together/ Forbes, http://oaklandlocal.com/2014/11/the-new-social-network-local-organizations-diminishing-modern-slavery/ Oakland Local, http://mashable.com/2012/07/10/not-for-sale-modern-slavery/ Mashable, http://www.huffingtonpost.com/mark-wexler/a-new-way-to-fight-modern_b_7912230.html Huffington Post again, http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304071004579407452025492322 Wall Street Journal on their coworking space, http://www.theguardian.com/social-enterprise-network/2014/jan/14/modern-slavery-social-enterprise-solution The Guardian... &mdash Deletion of Not for Sale (organization) WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6107 20438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Walker (Battle of Britain pilot) User:Gaia 09:53, 29 October 2012 (UTC) keep """As above, following his death, a large number of detailed obituaries have been written about him and significant sections of news broadcasts/bulletins were devoted to him. While he may not satisfy (which is skewed towards senior officers or decorated individuals) his death """"received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject"""" thereby satisfying """ Deletion of William Walker (Battle of Britain pilot) WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6108 7288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saxony Lutheran High School User:Ansh666 22:46, 1 September 2013 (UTC) keep """I ''am'' going to cite the longstanding consensus and precedent at : """"Most independently accredited degree-awarding institutions and high schools are being kept except when zero independent sources can be found to prove that the institution actually exists."""" Google news search (above) may only link to a regional newspaper, but that's enough""" Deletion of Saxony Lutheran High School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
6109 87 [[COVID-19-Pandemie im Landkreis Tirschenreuth]] (LAZ) Benutzer:Yardsrules 11:07, 7. Apr. 2020 (CEST) keep Gründe siehe oben und /2. April_2020#COVID-19-Pandemie im Kreis Heinsberg|LD vom 2.4. zu Heinsberg. Zitat von Hannes 24 auf LD vom 2.4. zu Heinsberg: ''Eigentlich wurde alles schon mal geschrieben. Warten wir auf die Entscheidung eines admin Löschung von COVID-19-Pandemie im Landkreis Tirschenreuth Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6110 21407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eduardo (rapper) User:Loriendrew 18:09, 11 April 2015 (UTC) delete redirect to band. Would also need to delete A Fantástica Fábrica de Cadáver via , as well as that book that was redirected to the person Deletion of Eduardo (rapper) WP:A9 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
6111 12623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethnic stereotypes in popular culture User:Plm209 13:39, 3 July 2007 (UTC) delete Upon first reading the article, it seems as though it is legit but when looking at it from the point of view of it is definately more of an essay as outlined in #3 under #PUBLISHER Deletion of Ethnic stereotypes in popular culture WP:OR||WP:NOT Wikipedia:No original research 65
6112 7261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AmIRC User:Joe 23:33, 29 January 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of AmIRC WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6113 20026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J.Deepa jayakumar User:Fitindia 20:38, 11 February 2017 (UTC) comment She is the niece of a former Chief minister of Tamil Nadu Ms.Jayalalitha and that alone does not make her notable but she does have coverage in the media here http://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/jayalalithaa-lookalike-deepa-sasikala-look-to-keep-amma-s-legacy-alive/story-kdn0y9Knjl1tdfgAw7PzOO.html http://www.ndtv.com/tamil-nadu-news/jayalalithaas-niece-deepa-jayakumar-her-lookalike-set-for-political-debut-1649587 http://www.financialexpress.com/india-news/revolt-within-aiadmk-jayalalithaas-niece-deepa-jayakumar-says-she-has-already-entered-politics/510876/ http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chennai/i-am-not-afraid-of-sasikala-jayalalithaas-niece-deepa-says/articleshow/57019659.cms http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/Jayalalithaas-niece-Deepa-Jayakumar-to-enter-politics/article17049523.ece http://www.news18.com/news/politics/jayalalithaas-niece-deepa-to-announce-her-political-roadmap-on-feb-24-1336944.html.This might be a case of for a .My two cents says it looks like a '''delete''' but I have a feeling this article will be back due to the recent political turmoil in the Indian state of Tamil Nadu regarding the political legacy of Ms.Jayalalitha Deletion of J.Deepa jayakumar WP:TOOSOON||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Too soon 40
6114 9501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syed Ahmed (2nd nomination) User:N4 03:00, 7 February 2014 (UTC) merge """The subject is largely notable for his appearance on the reality TV show and so is only notable for one event as per , however, the subject has remained active since then. His career after his TV appearances are verifiable in multiple, independent, reliable secondary sources so he at the very least fulfills . They should not be included in his """"mini-bio"""" at the suggested merge page""" Deletion of Syed Ahmed (2nd nomination) WP:1E||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6115 1526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radio Wey User:Bearcat 19:25, 4 February 2018 (UTC) delete """without prejudice against recreation in the future if somebody can source it better than this. Under , the only notability claim that a radio station actually has to make to be keepable is that it exists as a properly licensed radio station that originates at least some of its own programming — it doesn't need to make any claim that would make it a special """"more notable than other radio stations"""" case, as our goal for radio stations is to be as complete as feasibly possible a reference for ''all'' of them. But """"as feasibly possible"""" is the operative part of that equation, because NMEDIA doesn't extend radio stations an ''exemption'' from having to be |reliably sourced — they still have to be the ''subject'' of at least ''some'' coverage in ''media'' other than their own |self-published content about themselves — but there's virtually no evidence of that being shown here, as the referencing is virtually entirely to |primary sources that can't support notability. So no, it doesn't need a stronger notability ''claim'' than is already present here, but it ''does'' need stronger ''referencing'' to ''support'' it than this""" Deletion of Radio Wey WP:NMEDIA||WP:RS||WP:SELFPUB||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES Wikipedia:Notability 77
6116 15568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Olufela Olomola (2nd nomination) [[User talk:86.17.222.157|talk]]) 23:27, 22 November 2016 (UTC) keep because no reason for deletion has been stated. If the nominator wants to improve the article with content from a draft then that can be done without deleting what we have already. It doesn't matter one jot who gets the credit for creating an article about a particular subject. The nomination obviously has everything to do with , despite the claim to the otherwise of the nominator. Special:Contributions/86.17.222.157|86.17.222.157 Deletion of Olufela Olomola (2nd nomination) WP:OWNERSHIP Wikipedia:Ownership of content 86
6117 21808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Automatic Backup Copy User:Xanchester 02:19, 24 October 2012 (UTC) delete No significant coverage by |reliable secondary sources. A http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Automatic+Backup+Copy%22&hl=en&tbm=nws&source=lnt&tbs=ar:1&sa=X&ei=UE-HUOTPFsji0gHZ8oGgAw&ved=0CBcQpwUoBQ search for news articles doesn't bring up anything. Most of the citations listed on the page are not considered reliable (like download sites for freeware). The subject does not meet the |general notability guideline Deletion of Automatic Backup Copy WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6118 15979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donna Eden 2 User:ScienceApologist 13:24, 24 October 2008 (UTC) delete """As currently written and from what I can glean from possible sources, this article is of a marginal figure whose notice is derived primarily through self-promotion rather than third-party recognition. What outside source has indicated that she is an expert in this so-called """"energy medicine"""" field? I cannot find any. Sure, there are """"gnews"""" hits, but they all look to me to be either from unreliable primary sources meant to |unduly promote energy medicine or the mention is so off-handed as to be useless in establishing notability. I point out that this particular person seems to fail miserably. So delete""" Deletion of Donna Eden 2 WP:ADVERT||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Advertising 107
6119 5174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scary Movie 5 (2nd nomination) [[User talk:Erpert|(let's talk about it)]] 07:18, 17 November 2010 (UTC) delete There ''is'' an http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0795461/ IMDb entry but it doesn't even have so much of a cast listing; thus, it's |too soon for this article. '''Erpert Deletion of Scary Movie 5 (2nd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
6120 5911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kill the Silence technique (disambiguation) User:Joe 18:44, 26 October 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Kill the Silence technique (disambiguation) WP:DAB Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
6121 17216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lagro High School [[User talk:125.212.123.127|talk]]) 07:18, 10 March 2013 (UTC) keep Although it may be non-notable (I believe this school is notable), school articles are exempt from #A7|speedy deletion criterion A7. It was not a recreation of the deleted page, since the deleted page is a redirect to a non-existent page, Lagro Subdivision.Special:Contributions/125.212.123.127|125.212.123.127 Deletion of Lagro High School WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
6122 16296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lobster spartan User:Dirtlawyer1 16:03, 15 March 2013 (UTC) delete """This is one of those Wikipedia eccentricities that draws a chuckle: an Indonesian flag (American) football team called """"Lobster spartan?"""" Perhaps the team name translates better in Indonesian. Of course, the team is not a professional or even semi-professional team, and the article fails to establish the subject's notability per the general notability guidelines. The only sources for the article appear to be the team's weblog, Facebook page and Twitter account; none of the three constitutes an independent, reliable source per for the purpose of establishing the team's notability per or """ Deletion of Lobster spartan WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6123 12789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Windforce User:Stifle 16:15, 16 May 2006 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Windforce WP:NFT||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
6124 15608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helen Cozza User:Tyrenius 17:15, 29 July 2010 (UTC) delete The Wikipedia requirement for articles is stated at , namely coverage in multiple sources that meet . Only two sources have been provided to date. There are only 87 Google hitshttp://www.google.co.uk/search?num=100&hl=en&safe=off&client=firefox-a&hs=TfC&rls=org.mozilla%3Aen-US%3Aofficial&q=%22Helen+Cozza%22+&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai= with nothing of sufficient substance Deletion of Helen Cozza WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6125 1851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Perry (baseball) User:BRMo 04:40, 19 April 2009 (UTC) delete """Statistics or brief mentions in articles about minor league teams do not constitute """"significant coverage in reliable sources,"""" as required by """ Deletion of Robert Perry (baseball) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6126 8292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Amoo User:Cbl62 22:56, 31 January 2012 (UTC) delete While he could qualify under if there was substantial non-trivial coverage of his college football career, my searches don't show any such coverage. Can't find even one article with non-trivial coverage of Amoo (after searching Google news archive and NewsLibrary.com). College football linemen typically don't get a lot of non-trivial coverage. If someone can locate non-trivial coverage of Amoo, I'm willing to reconsider Deletion of Anthony Amoo WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6127 16244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Back to the Future timeline User:Isotope23 17:42, 1 December 2006 (UTC) delete as |original research but it ''is'' rather cool. The article has been around for a while though and it is almost a shame to see it go. I'd say transwiki this somewhere if I could think of a good target Deletion of Back to the Future timeline WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
6128 11036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al Rosas User:TheFeds 23:06, 28 September 2009 (UTC) keep on the basis of coverage in Florida Trend (June 1, 2008), Boston Globe (November 2, 2008) and Ocala Star-Banner (October 8, 2007). Those articles, taken together, are definitely sufficient for |notability Deletion of Al Rosas WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6129 62 [[Figuren aus dem Marvel-Universum]] (bleibt) Benutzer:LaWa NONE keep hast du dir mal durchgelesen? Da steht drinne das Sammelartikel besser und sinnvoller sind als einzelne. Also anstatt gerade die zu löschen sollte man sich lieber der ganzen Miniartikel über Nebenfiguren entledigen. Löschung von Figuren aus dem Marvel-Universum Wikipedia:Wikipedia ist kein Fanzine Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
6130 3690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Mathieson User:Gnangarra 12:35, 28 June 2010 (UTC) delete """not notable as per the recent Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mimi Macpherson|Mimi MacPherson decision, to quote Jimbo ''Our guideline is clear that """"Being related to a notable person in itself confers no degree of notability upon that person. """" (See #Family""" Deletion of Tim Mathieson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6131 2180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hyper Optical pointer extension User:Glrx 03:52, 29 April 2012 (UTC) delete TivaSerano explains at Talk:Hyper Optical pointer extension that the state change is the addition of 3 references. Those references are Sabri's patent, a related patent certificate, and an acceptance notification for a yet-unpublished paper. These documents neither independent nor secondary sources. Even if the unpublished acceptance notice is taken as a good source, there are not multiple reliable sources here. The long list of references at the end of the article are not about HOPE; they are about techniques that HOPE (and other systems) use. The article does not meet Deletion of Hyper Optical pointer extension WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6132 2165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of guests on Red Eye w/ Greg Gutfeld (2nd nomination) User:Shawn 15:32, 23 November 2015 (UTC) delete one of several talk show guest lists we've seen at Afd lately. The consensus seems to be that these are all rather trivial and do not rise to the level of meeting and I do think that is the case here Deletion of List of guests on Red Eye w/ Greg Gutfeld (2nd nomination) WP:NLIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
6133 11195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Q&A About the Assassination of President John F. Kennedy User:Lukep913 16:47, 26 November 2011 (UTC) delete No verifiability or any sources on the claims outlined in the article. It looks likes also Deletion of Q&A About the Assassination of President John F. Kennedy WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
6134 5257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jakiw Palij (2nd nomination) User:Ukexpat 15:37, 10 January 2011 (UTC) delete per nomination, appears to be a clear Deletion of Jakiw Palij (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6135 2574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Widdershins, LLC User:AllyD 13:05, 10 March 2018 (UTC) delete It is surprising, given the discussions on the article Talk page, that it did not arrive at AfD before this. It appears to be a run-of-the-mill events business; I am seeing nothing to demonstrate notability, nor is that inherited from recent social media posts concerning a person associated with the company Deletion of Widdershins, LLC :WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
6136 1040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The New Century Family Money Book User:Aleksa 08:07, 23 November 2013 (UTC) keep sources have been provided. Notability established per and GNG Deletion of The New Century Family Money Book WP:BKCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6137 207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henry Chidozie User:Sir 03:50, 6 March 2011 (UTC) delete per nom. Nigerian football is not fully pro so he fails , and there isnufficient coverage to merit keeping this article under Deletion of Henry Chidozie WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6138 5319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Kinkaid School Archives User:Edison 02:43, 6 May 2012 (UTC) merge """It is just a kindergarten through 12th grade school. """"Other stuff exists"""" is not a viable argument for keeping this article, but rather a suggestion that an AFD for Phillips Exeter Academy Library|Phillips Exeter Academy Libraries is needed. The argument also conflates a modest 160 thousand volume school library (at Exeter) with the mere archives of a lesser-known school, Kincaid. Fails """ Deletion of The Kinkaid School Archives WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6139 21489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karlie Redd User:TheGracefulSlick 02:04, 7 December 2018 (UTC) merge to Love and Hip Hop. Gossip stories cannot substitute for reliable, secondary coverage, especially when evaluating |GNG. I believe the amount of guess work on her life may also be a |BLP concern Deletion of Karlie Redd WP:GNG||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6140 18121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LAX (group) User:Ronbo76 14:08, 26 January 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Fail most of ; does not merit inclusion at this time Deletion of LAX (group) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
6141 19228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mongolian passport [[User talk:Happenstance|''what a crazy random happenstance'']] 08:37, 26 January 2010 (UTC) keep This is a y nomination of a user involved at the Talk:Passport dispute. Those articles have always been one-line stubs, with or without the visa-free sections. Now that they're gone, maybe some effort will actually go into improving documentation of the passport itself, rather than documenting unrelated visa policy of foreign nations Deletion of Mongolian passport WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
6142 4688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zecherism User:Nerdluck34 00:22, 24 September 2008 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not for |religious cults made up whilst bored in school one day. Absolute rubbish Deletion of Zecherism WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
6143 17545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sex and the City 2 (film) User:ArcAngel 18:07, 15 February 2009 (UTC) delete per nom and per Deletion of Sex and the City 2 (film) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6144 12863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Happy Ratio User:Shoy 15:05, 21 July 2017 (UTC) delete Lack of Deletion of Happy Ratio WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6145 12972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flowering Rose of Glastonbury User:Mo 21:06, 11 August 2010 (UTC) merge per Deletion of Flowering Rose of Glastonbury WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6146 20878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wonderland Resort User:Lulu 23:08, 9 July 2008 (UTC) delete Almost squeezes by , but not quite Deletion of Wonderland Resort WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6147 13120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Arnold (2nd nomination) User:Wine 08:11, 3 February 2010 (UTC) delete """Definitely not notable as an illustrator; and as for the murder, a relatively minor which doesn't appear to have gotten coverage outside of Massachusetts. The previous AfD likely suffered from |recentism, as the case was ongoing at the time. The nom from the old AfD says it all: """"Had he not discovered the body of Christa Worthington, he would have been forever obscure""" Deletion of Tim Arnold (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:RECENT Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6148 123 [[Gefahrerhöhung]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Aschmidt NONE keep Was dort steht, mag richtig sein, es ist aber völlig WP:BLG|unbelegt und müßte ausgebaut werden. Allein das macht es noch nicht zu einem |Artikel. Da die QS das heutzutage nicht mehr so ohne weiteres leistet, stellt sich die Frage, ob man den Text dort so stehen lassen sollte oder ob es besser wäre, ihn zu löschen? Ich würde ihn eher wollen, weil es darin um einen Grundbegriff des Privatversicherungsrechts geht, von dem man einfach erwartet, daß er in einer Enzyklopädie erläutert wird, und sei es noch so knapp. Das kann zum Anfang auch mal kurz in dieser Form geschehen. Auch m.E. ist es ein WP:STUB|gültiger Stub, denn die Zusammenfassung der gesetzlichen Vorschriften ist eine eigenständige Leistung, die denjenigen, der nach dem Begriff sucht, schon weiterbringen kann. Der Rest wäre Aufgabe der weiteren Artikelarbeit Löschung von Gefahrerhöhung Wikipedia:Artikel Wikipedia:Artikel 90
6149 13814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tami Lane User:Metropolitan90 17:54, 24 December 2006 (UTC) keep """Winning an Oscar ought to qualify her under the provision for """"other professionals whose work is widely recognized (for better or worse) and who are likely to become a part of the enduring historical record of that field""" Deletion of Tami Lane WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6150 5733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Royal Confraternity of Sao Teotonio (2nd nomination) User:Orangemike 19:46, 2 April 2009 (UTC) delete """Non-notable ersatz """"order"""" (and I must join the chorus shouting, |Notability is not contagious (i.e., you can't make yourself notable by selling or giving something to somebody notable""" Deletion of Royal Confraternity of Sao Teotonio (2nd nomination) :WP:NOTCONTAGIOUS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6151 9429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry's Old Geezers/Gals User:The 15:02, 31 January 2007 (UTC) delete per nom, anything relevant already exists in the Wogan article; this article is heaped in and possible Deletion of Terry's Old Geezers/Gals WP:OR||WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:No original research 65
6152 17181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Zande User:Wildthing61476 17:10, 19 October 2006 (UTC) delete College radio DJ, but does not seem to meet Deletion of Mike Zande WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6153 12419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Westwood High School (Michigan) User:Jerry 18:59, 20 December 2008 (UTC) keep and troutslap nominator. , #PAPER, Wikipedia:Notability (high schools). Adequate sources for notability and encyclopedic content were easy to find Deletion of Westwood High School (Michigan) WP:NODEADLINE||WP:NOT Wikipedia:There is no deadline 35
6154 13888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cheryl Charming User:E 01:32, 28 March 2018 (UTC) delete the strongest source I can find is New Orleans Magazine : http://www.myneworleans.com/New-Orleans-Magazine/December-2014/Mixologist-of-the-Year/ Mixologist of the Year. Despite PROMO efforts by her friends, fans, or self, subject fails Deletion of Cheryl Charming WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
6155 2369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Gow User:Strothra 01:33, 23 June 2006 (UTC) delete as per and Hillman as well as and Deletion of James Gow WP:BIO||WP:CITE||WP:VERIFY Wikipedia:Notability 77
6156 19341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artur Kołosowski User:Wikipedysta 21:52, 4 December 2014 (UTC) keep See #3. See also the article in polish Wikipedia Deletion of Artur Kołosowski WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
6157 1811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KO·MO·RE·BI User:Kunzite 02:52, 21 August 2006 (UTC) keep Release info exists on site; artist is notable per But, let's get rid of the ALL CAPS NAMES Deletion of KO·MO·RE·BI WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
6158 18784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ricky Powell User:Enigmaman 20:38, 16 March 2009 (UTC) delete The new claims still do not make him notable per and Deletion of Ricky Powell WP:CREATIVE||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6159 14043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mmmmilk User:YSSYguy 08:05, 16 November 2012 (UTC) delete per , which could have been written specifically for this. Orbell's soft drinks were widely available where I grew up, but at the end of the day - so what Deletion of Mmmmilk WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
6160 11553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Tournier User:Sanketio31 09:37, 23 April 2021 (UTC) delete As per nom fails , nothing significant notable here Deletion of Mark Tournier WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6161 11577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Haque User:Bearian 17:10, 8 October 2013 (UTC) comment WP:OUTCOMES|we have been all over the map on requests to delete BLPs of otherwise |marginally notable adults (''cf.'' similarly-situated children, who we usually delete). Can we have some more input on this one? I am leaning towards '''delete''', based on the fact that his restaurant is really notable, while the chef is not always in the limelight Deletion of Nick Haque WP:BARE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6162 1234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Navy Field (2nd nomination) User:Sloane 01:49, 31 March 2011 (UTC) comment """Let's look at the ''three'' sources again. http://mmohut.com/review/navy-field is a review from a site pretty much run by two brothers http://mmohut.com/about, so it fails (""""Base articles on reliable, third-party, published sources with a reputation for fact-checking and accuracy. Sources should directly support the material presented in an article and should be appropriate to the claims made. The appropriateness of any source depends on the context. In general, the best sources have a professional structure in place for checking or analyzing facts, legal issues, evidence, and arguments; as a rule of thumb, the greater the degree of scrutiny given to these issues, the more reliable the source."""") http://www.mmortsgamers.com/reviews/mmo-rts/navyfield-us.html offers a TWO sentence review, and is a site run by probably one person, again failing . http://www.subsim.com/ssr/navy_field/review_navy_field_subs.php seems to be the only site that perhaps has some editorial oversight. But it's still a weak source. This article clearly doesn't meet """ Deletion of Navy Field (2nd nomination) WP:V||WP:V||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6163 20049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tarique Kalam User:Rugbyfan22 20:06, 26 February 2021 (UTC) keep Has played 9 FC matches, passing him for Deletion of Tarique Kalam WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6164 17196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Western Investor User:Resolute 15:24, 6 May 2007 (UTC) delete I am sure that you meant criteria #2 rather than #3, as I can find no indication this band has been awarded a gold record. The problem here is that CBC Radio 3 is a satellite radio station, not a national network. Even though it has the CBC brand on it, I do not believe that makes it any more special than any other satellite station. As such, I do not belive it passes Criteria #2 or #11 for . Further, there are a complete lack of independent sources for this band. The only two links I can find are their myspace page, and their page on CBC Radio 3's website - which is rather obviously also updated by the band itself Deletion of The Western Investor WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6165 12 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mirkan Aydın User:The 21:40, 1 January 2009 (UTC) delete Not indicate inportance of significanse. Also completly fails Deletion of Mirkan Aydın WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6166 21895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward Keonjian User:Salih 15:50, 24 August 2009 (UTC) keep passes criterion #3 Deletion of Edward Keonjian WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6167 18203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Dungeons & Dragons deities User:BOZ 15:44, 5 May 2020 (UTC) keep """since there are to retain, per and . There are in fact several non-primary sources cited (as opposed to """"entirely""""), namely Dicing with Dragons, Heroic Worlds, and https://books.google.de/books?id=t3X18dopUoMC&pg=PA275#v=onepage&q&f=false Religions in Play""" Deletion of List of Dungeons & Dragons deities WP:RS||WP:PRESERVE||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6168 14882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The 6th of August at the 2008 Summer Olympics [[User talk:Moondyne|Moondyne]] 23:39, 31 July 2008 (UTC) delete WP is |not an events directory Deletion of The 6th of August at the 2008 Summer Olympics WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6169 9797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oz Bengur User:JimMillerJr 19:40, 11 January 2011 (UTC) keep per points 9 and 10. I have added easily found sources to the article dating back as far as his service as an aide to the Governor of Maine in 1979. The subject has had political and business coverage outside of his recent campaigns, and passes the GNG Deletion of Oz Bengur WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6170 16141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MovieCodec Forums User:Kraftlos 09:11, 13 June 2009 (UTC) delete """does not meet . The """"I am lonely thread"""" is probably notable, but that doesn't make the site notable""" Deletion of MovieCodec Forums WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
6171 3133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali in the Jungle User:Anarchia 11:43, 15 August 2007 (UTC) delete As the proposer argues, this song fails . It is a recently released song played by one group. There is nothing notable about it Deletion of Ali in the Jungle WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6172 12958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colonization of Trans-Neptunian Objects User:Iridescent 18:51, 29 August 2007 (UTC) keep """This is a technical article, not """"will there be a Spiderman 4"""" speculation""" Deletion of Colonization of Trans-Neptunian Objects WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6173 9711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angela Campanella User:Geoffroi 17:03, 7 June 2019 (UTC) delete per Johnpacklambert and Atlantic306 - fails Deletion of Angela Campanella WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
6174 14913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wisely (company) User:Rapanuiislander 16:00, 15 January 2021 (UTC) keep Added an additional citation that meets . There should now be enough sources to reach Deletion of Wisely (company) WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
6175 3735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/QED International User:MartinDK 09:26, 2 December 2006 (UTC) comment You may want to read G4, G11 and again Deletion of QED International WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
6176 39 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vacilando (2nd nomination) User:JohnCD 15:01, 5 October 2008 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not a dictionary, still less a Spanish dictionary Deletion of Vacilando (2nd nomination) WP:NAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
6177 3101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fucking shit User:Hillabear10 17:04, 23 August 2012 (UTC) delete As per Deletion of Fucking shit WP:NOTDIC Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
6178 1243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007–08 Commonwealth Bank Series statistics User:BlackJack 10:20, 7 October 2017 (UTC) delete per Ian. . No point in merging with tournament article as that would breach NOTSTATS then Deletion of 2007–08 Commonwealth Bank Series statistics WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6179 12875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 North Carolina train crash User:Edison 15:38, 17 November 2015 (UTC) delete Garden variety plain vanilla news story. Delete per Deletion of 2015 North Carolina train crash WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6180 20509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Curse of Morrissey User:Isotope23 16:02, 22 November 2006 (UTC) delete per failure of |verification by |reliable sources Deletion of Curse of Morrissey WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6181 3806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Hoffman (businessman) User:Bearian 17:56, 31 October 2007 (UTC) delete per Burtntsauce. Sorry, DGG, but there's a blatant BLP violation here, with lots of claims and |zero sources for any of them. Not my field, so I can't rescue this one Deletion of Steve Hoffman (businessman) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6182 410 [[Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Burgen, Schlösser und Festungen in Estland]] (gelöscht) NONE 15:21, 24. Sep. 2013 (CEST) delete Themenring. Vollständigkeit kann mit einer Navigationsleiste nicht abgedeckt werden. Löschung gem. /17. April 2012#Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Burgen, Festungen und Schlösser in der Steiermark (gelöscht). Nach :et:Eesti linnuste loend und :en:List of castles in Estonia dürfte die Liste noch wesentlich länger sein. —|| Löschung von Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Burgen, Schlösser und Festungen in Estland Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6183 1614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Voice chasing User:UnitedStatesian 14:11, 2 December 2008 (UTC) delete No sources; violates the core |Verifiability policy Deletion of Voice chasing WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6184 3993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pile-on User:Tarret 14:44, 24 December 2006 (UTC) delete as according to Deletion of Pile-on WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
6185 20302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/16 August 2008 lunar eclipse User:Gandalf61 19:49, 24 February 2008 (UTC) comment """And indeed #TEMP|""""Notability is not temporary"""" and the linked essay Wikipedia:Notability does not degrade over time, if you read then carefully, actually say that Wikipedia content does not ''need'' to have long-term importance. Once notability is established by sufficient short-term coverage in reliable sources then a subject ''remains'' notable even if it never gets another mention outside of Wikipedia""" Deletion of 16 August 2008 lunar eclipse WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6186 2383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Callan User:Ohconfucius 08:19, 20 March 2007 (UTC) delete """schoolboy and """"writer of local acclaim"""". Nothing but LOCAL media coverage and LOCAL student awards, thus fails to pass """ Deletion of Jonathan Callan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6187 8505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/London Mail Processing Plant User:Dhartung 20:28, 10 July 2007 (UTC) delete OT|Wikipedia is not an employee-of-the-month award and there isn't any |notability here no matter how dedicated the staff may be. If there is a desire for an ego-boost there are many other free webhosts that are not encyclopedias Deletion of London Mail Processing Plant WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6188 262 [[Peter Seelig]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:PanchoS 19:22, 29. Aug. 2013 (CEST) keep Stimmt: Relevanz ist nicht dargestellt. Ausstellungen in der Bank Austria, bei der Akzenta Graz und der Kunstmesse Salzburg sowie in der Londoner Gagliardi Gallery sind jetzt auch nicht gar nichts, wenngleich nicht relevant nach . Auch die Tatsache, dass er diese Ausstellungsreihe in einem Wiener Café kuratiert (wenn das belegt werden kann), deutet zumindest auf eine gewisse Relevanz hin.Klar relevanzbegründend ist aber seine Teilnahme an der Biennale :en:Chianciano International Award for Digital Art and Photography (http://www.museodarte.org/?q=catalogue2010 Katalog) im :en:Chianciano Museum of Art. Damit wäre das Inklusivkriterium ''Teilnahme an einer Gruppenausstellung in einem überregional bedeutenden öffentlichen Museum, einer nichtkommerziellen Biennale, einer internationalen Gruppenausstellung oder einer Ausstellung einer Künstlergruppe.''Überregional bedeutsam: wohl eher nein, trotz NY Times-Bericht; aber nichtkommerzielle Biennale: ja; und internationale Gruppenausstellung: auch ja.Diese Relevanz muss aber auch dargestellt werden. Wenn das geschieht, dann halte ich ein für vertretbar, wenn nicht gar zwingend nach WP:RKBK Löschung von Peter Seelig Wikipedia:RKBK Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
6189 1300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pippa Middleton User:Cindamuse 20:36, 18 February 2011 (UTC) delete Notability is not established independent of her sister, Kate Middleton. References provided tend to focus on Kate, while offering peripheral mentions of the subject of this article. If the subject was not related to the future wife of Prince William, the subject of this article would not merit coverage. See Deletion of Pippa Middleton WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6190 7809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Final fantasy 8 guardian forces User:Dennisthe2 16:03, 4 October 2009 (UTC) delete We are |not a game guide Deletion of Final fantasy 8 guardian forces WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6191 18946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/African Origins Project User:Mercurywoodrose 16:05, 17 October 2009 (UTC) delete per nom and as rystal ball Deletion of African Origins Project WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
6192 11151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terrell Whitehead User:Cbl62 19:24, 20 November 2020 (UTC) keep """Appears to pass as a three-time Division I FCS All-American. See '''(1)''' https://www.pilotonline.com/sports/article_f5443da5-386b-5c78-98a7-21955970c32f.html Virginian-Pilot, '''(2)''' https://www.pilotonline.com/sports/college/article_5c4d4744-d706-587a-9290-e0c84a2cbe2e.html?outputType=amp here, and https://meacswacsports.blogspot.com/2010/05/2010-udfa-profile-terrell-whitehead-s.html MEAC. He was also selected as the Mid-Eastern Athletic Conference|MEAC Defensive Player of the Year two years in a row. See '''(3) ''' https://www.espn.com/college-football/news/story?id=4685989 ESPN. He has received additional significant coverage which includes: '''(4)''' https://www.pilotonline.com/757teamz/article_02a6a709-58e3-558e-b13a-b8a2b65f69d5.html Ex-NSU, NFL player Whitehead now a Salem assistant, The Virginian-Pilot, 11/7/14; ''' (5)''' https://www.pilotonline.com/sports/college/article_d1611390-25e4-548d-8d8a-90ccf3bc0400.html NSU's Whitehead Tabbed as Top Defensive Player, The Virginian-Pilot, 8/1/09; '''(6)''' https://www.pilotonline.com/sports/article_bba02092-f699-5723-9f12-f8c0df426440.html Whitehead added to watch list for Buchanan award, The Virginian-Pilot, 8/5/09; '''(7)''' https://www.pilotonline.com/sports/college/article_c8a56396-41dd-5d82-a558-c42c6af863f1.html Looking back, NSU was a good move for Whitehead, The Virginian-Pilot, 9/20/08; '''(8)''' https://www.pilotonline.com/sports/columns/article_28a3ab98-f956-5a07-aab7-0129c7be71f7.html """"Former Spartan preparing for unclear NFL future, The Viginian-Pilot, 11/20/20; '''(9)''' https://www.pilotonline.com/sports/college/article_18f49ddc-aeac-5968-b9d5-742c06998677.html NSU's Whitehead named as a preseason All-American, The Virginian-Pilot, 5/20/09; '''(10)''' NSU's Whitehead an All-American 2nd year in row, Virginian-Pilot, 1/7/09""" Deletion of Terrell Whitehead WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
6193 5082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Miller (writer) NONE NONE delete She doesn't meet or Deletion of Mary Miller (writer) WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
6194 16808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/March 7 Apple Media Event [[User talk:AniMate|AniMate]] 02:16, 5 March 2012 (UTC) delete or '''merge''' This is a press conference. By their very nature press conferences get media coverage, that doesn't make them notable. For instance, every single time Jay Carney, the White House Press Secretary, gives a briefing it is extensively covered in multiple sources. Each and every briefing therefore passes . Should we have an article on every one of those briefings? Of course not. Nor should we have separate articles on every single new product launch. Yes its Apple and super exciting, but the significance isn't the event itself, but the product being launched. Let's use common sense Deletion of March 7 Apple Media Event WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6195 17708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Shaving User:Jclemens 20:04, 31 August 2010 (UTC) merge While Snottywong is technically correct, I note that the bluelinked articles at List of Aqua Teen Hunger Force episodes have shorter and more perfunctory plot summaries, suggesting that these may originally have been breakouts. Thus, I prefer a merge with no prejudice against creating full breakout articles for episodes sourced appropriately. Oh, and I was PROD decliner on many (all?) of these Deletion of The Shaving WP:SS Wikipedia:Summary style 34
6196 2135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soup all'Imperatrice User:Velella 20:51, 15 May 2021 (UTC) delete despite the slight confusion over sources, there is no evidence here, or in searches or in a reasonably extensive library of recipe books that I have available that this was anything other than one author's personal recipe. There is nothing to indicate any notability or indeed, any significance. Just another recipe. Fails . ''''' Deletion of Soup all'Imperatrice WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6197 1067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick McClean User:GiantSnowman 18:40, 5 April 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Patrick McClean WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6198 17205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bo Kaspers Orkester User:Punkmorten 07:36, 30 April 2007 (UTC) keep won a national music award and released at least one album on Sony Records. So meets Deletion of Bo Kaspers Orkester WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6199 16929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SCSI Express User:Legis 08:34, 12 December 2011 (UTC) delete per . Not convinced it will be sufficiently notable if/when launched, but we can cross that bridge later Deletion of SCSI Express WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6200 10854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Strehl (2nd nomination) User:Lightburst 19:46, 7 December 2019 (UTC) keep passes #1 Deletion of Alexander Strehl (2nd nomination) WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6201 15399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess from the Moon User:Cavarrone 16:36, 9 October 2013 (UTC) keep and '''trout the nominator''' for starting a half dozen of silly and pointy AfDs about obviously notable films not daring to do a minimal . With respect, please don't waste our time anymore Deletion of Princess from the Moon WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6202 2071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phil good User:Charlene 19:41, 17 July 2007 (UTC) delete No references, unattributed and (after Google searches) likely unattributable. At best, both expressions fail and Deletion of Phil good WP:NEO||WP:ATT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
6203 18515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gothic War (Warhammer 40,000) User:WilyD 14:15, 10 August 2006 (UTC) delete fails and I'm pretty suspicious it violates - if citations are added, I'll reconsider Deletion of Gothic War (Warhammer 40,000) WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6204 14484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Wall (basketball) User:Phil 21:53, 22 May 2009 (UTC) comment It's very interesting to compare this AfD with Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samuel Galindo|this one. As policy and guidelines are supposed to reflect practice I propose that we should say in that North American sports are subject to completely different standards from those in the rest of the world Deletion of John Wall (basketball) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6205 3025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theertha Artists Collective User:NawlinWiki 18:11, 13 September 2015 (UTC) delete unless someone can provide sources that meet Deletion of Theertha Artists Collective WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6206 19381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Kelly (Entrepreneur) user:DMySon 06:38, 8 July 2020 (UTC) delete I also tagged for speedy but creator claims for notability. Advertisement & Non-notable business person. fails Deletion of Peter Kelly (Entrepreneur) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6207 16048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of minor Star Wars Sith characters (2nd nomination) User:Collectonian 21:05, 2 December 2007 (UTC) delete all. Minor characters are not notable enough for mention anywhere but in the plot summaries (and then only if they do something of significance to the plot). All of these minor character lists fail and are excessive fancruft. Belongs on a Star Wars wiki or on a fan site, but not in an encyclopedia Deletion of List of minor Star Wars Sith characters (2nd nomination) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6208 19692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Araxi Hubbard Dutton Palmer User:Nsk92 16:12, 13 May 2008 (UTC) delete Agree with the nomination: the subject clearly fails . No independent sources covering the subject listed in the article and nothing else that I could find on the web. GoogleBooks returns a single hit, to her bookhttp://books.google.com/books?hl=en&q=%22Araxi%20Hubbard%20Dutton%20Palmer%22&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=wp. Nothing in GoogleNewshttp://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tab=pn&q=%22Araxi+Hubbard+Dutton+Palmer%22 or GoogleScholarhttp://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&q=%22Araxi%20Hubbard%20Dutton%20Palmer%22&sa=N&tab=ns. Even a plain Google search return only 74 hits http://www.google.com/search?tab=sw&sa=N&hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&q=%22Araxi+Hubbard+Dutton+Palmer%22&sa=N. It is borderline possible that the book itself is notable per and maybe a separate article about the book might stand on its own. But even that appears unlikely as I did not see any independent reviews of the book by . As for the present article, clearly fails and should be deleted Deletion of Araxi Hubbard Dutton Palmer WP:BIO||WP:BK||WP:RS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6209 12702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Popular Alliance (UK) User:Carrite 04:00, 7 December 2014 (UTC) keep this and all similar political party articles on the basis of (Use Common Sense to Improve the Encyclopedia). This is the sort of material that SHOULD be in a comprehensive encyclopedia Deletion of Popular Alliance (UK) WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
6210 12389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/R. Diwakaran User:TimothyBlue 17:09, 13 August 2020 (UTC) delete """The article does not meet , or . From : ''""""For people, the person who is the topic of a biographical article should be """"worthy of notice"""" or """"note""""—that is, """"remarkable"""" or """"significant, interesting, or unusual enough to deserve attention or to be recorded""""""""''. Some coverage exists. Might just be . // """ Deletion of R. Diwakaran WP:GNG||WP:CREATIVE||WP:BASIC||WP:NPEOPLE||WP:ROUTINE||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
6211 9541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emelio Bruno User:Krishna 02:00, 25 September 2016 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet the basic notability guidelines, . Regards Deletion of Emelio Bruno WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6212 19897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shirtlifter User:Edison 01:45, 12 March 2010 (UTC) delete Per JamesBWatson for failure to satisfy or any subsidiary guideline Deletion of Shirtlifter WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6213 2055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hijire Anze User:JamesBurns 06:27, 16 February 2009 (UTC) delete insufficient 3rd party sources Deletion of Hijire Anze WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6214 8517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mengullo, Randy User:Mmaasia 03:03, 3 February 2009 (UTC) keep WP:RS|Reliable sources about his coaching career can be |verified, pass . Notable and respected coach/teacher in the Philippines with online citations and references are credible with lead photo http://www.sunstar.com.ph/static/bac/2006/05/16/index.html front pageexposure in local newspaper and contributed article in http://showbizandstyle.inquirer.net/sim/sim/view/20081214-177923/Life-Lessons-from-Karate national newspaper/magazine.&mdash Deletion of Mengullo, Randy WP:V||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6215 1738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wiggleball [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 00:55, 10 February 2009 (UTC) delete per lack of |verifiability as well as |crystalballery. We do not create Wikipedia articles to boost popularity of someone or something—that is called |spamming, which is not allowed. As also noted in Talk:Wiggleball, |Wikipedia is not your own web host to act as a repository and promotion vehicle of this |madeup sport. Perhaps if the sport garners significant coverage via |reliable secondary sources, then it may be suitable for inclusion in the future, but not now Deletion of Wiggleball WP:V||WP:CBALL||WP:SPAM||WP:NOTWEBHOST||WP:MADEUP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6216 18694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyrus Toulabi User:Edison 18:37, 13 October 2009 (UTC) delete A high school student puts video programs on at the high school and on Youtube. Some of his work received a high school recognition at a national level, and was given some degree of newspaper coverage. This does not appear to satisfy . A National Merit Scholar, winners of youth talent competitions or national youth chess tournaments and many high school athletes get this much recognition and are not considered notable for it Deletion of Cyrus Toulabi WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6217 9878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dmitri Novgorodsky User:Metropolitan90 16:22, 13 September 2007 (UTC) keep It appears that the subject should be evaluated for notability as a musician (see ) rather than as a professor. I would recommend that the article be revised to focus on his performance and recording history, rather than his academic achievements. Being the first person of a particular nationality to earn a degree in a particular instrument at a particular university should not be the focus of his article, since there are so many possible combinations of nationalities, instruments, and universities Deletion of Dmitri Novgorodsky WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6218 11803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Demongelic User:Tokyogirl79 03:35, 2 May 2015 (UTC) delete While the book exists (), there hasn't been any coverage of the book other than a couple of local newspaper articles. It's far from the amount of in-depth coverage that Wikipedia would require to pass notability guidelines. As far as appearances at events go, that in and of itself won't count towards notability unless there was coverage of the event and/or the book (or author) received an award at these events that would be considered a major enough award to give either partial or total notability. It doesn't help that the CPE is just a local comic book convention. However even if it was a major convention it still wouldn't give notability. Coverage of the event would be what would give notability, but I don't see where there has been any coverage of the book or its author beyond the sourcing currently in the article. I don't mean to sound harsh, just that there isn't anything that would give notability per Wikipedia's guidelines for books, which are pretty strict Deletion of Demongelic WP:ITEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6219 7934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Melungeons User:Schizombie 16:19, 11 December 2009 (UTC) delete """However, I'd recommend prosifying and posting to Talk:Melungeon and giving them the opportunity to source and merge as prose (not a list) into that article. Source for Lisa Alther is right in her article. Source for Lincoln is in his mother's Nancy Todd. notes such things as """"If the page can be improved, this should be solved through regular editing"""" and """"Consider turning the page into a useful redirect or proposing it be merged"""" and """"When nominating due to sourcing or notability concerns, try to confirm that such sources don't exist."""" This shouldn't've had to come to AfD""" Deletion of List of Melungeons WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6220 7449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrik Twardzik User:Sir 17:07, 23 December 2012 (UTC) delete He has not received significant coverage or played in a fully pro league, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Patrik Twardzik WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6221 8518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ternevig (bus stop) User:Ad 23:02, 18 November 2014 (UTC) delete all per every comment above. In addition these articles appear to fail the often overlooked requirement |that stub articles should have some reasonable hope of expansion into encyclopedic articles. I can't see that here Deletion of Ternevig (bus stop) WP:STUB Wikipedia:Stub 114
6222 14066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mojo Motors, Inc. NONE NONE keep spaced ndash}} The topic passes Deletion of Mojo Motors, Inc. WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6223 1960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Advanced Science and Technology Education Center User:Adamant1 23:13, 12 February 2021 (UTC) delete """I did a search for ASTEC Charter School and the only thing that came up were two results in Google News. Both of which are extremely trivial. One is about them breaking ground on a new building is about them receiving a """"STEM Gift."""" Whatever that is. Neither pass . The next article down is about rodent droppings in a Chinese restaurant. Which clearly isn't relevant and things don't get any better from there. 12 results or so down is a local article about something throwing a plastic cow off the schools roof as a prank. At least that one is about the school, sorta. Although, it's still not helpful. So, although there are technically """"results"""" if you use ASTEC Charter School as the search term, they clearly aren't relevant, useful, or help establish notability""" Deletion of Advanced Science and Technology Education Center WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6224 5226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burn This City User:Adolphus79 18:17, 5 October 2009 (UTC) comment """I'm sorry, you're right, the """"physical version"""" has not been released yet... """"future"""" has been removed from my rational... as far as your comments on the band's notability, I share your thoughts... I prodded all their singles and demo albums because there was no signs of them passing /, but two of the album articles claim they have made it onto some national chart, which passes ... each of the member's articles have also been removed because they did not pass ... The band's article, and 2 of the albums are about all I can find that even come close to passing notability concerns, but I have not done any heavy research to confirm the claims of the articles... If you do decide to do said research and take the band (or the 2 albums that claim to have charted) itself to AfD, please leave me a note... The creator/primary editor of a lot of these articles ({{User|Simonpettersen}}) has a pretty long history of creating articles for non-notable bands and their albums, and uploading images without any licensing information... As much as I hate to do it, I had to pretty much go back through his entire contribution history and tag most of it for deletion after I came across Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanity Shed|this... I am still |AGF'ng this user, and am trying to help him better understand policy (zero replies to anything written on his talk page), but for now am keeping a close eye on his contributions""" Deletion of Burn This City WP:NALBUMS||WP:NSONGS||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6225 9602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Air West Flight 612 User:RFerreira 05:13, 8 May 2007 (UTC) keep despite the personal held by nominator, the topic is worthy of note for our encyclopedia Deletion of Air West Flight 612 WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
6226 315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr Morton's - the medical helpline User:Daicaregos 08:36, 19 August 2016 (UTC) keep The article subject satisfies i.e. ''the organization is notable enough to justify a separate article on the verifiable evidence that the organization or product has attracted the notice of reliable sources unrelated to the organization or product.'' Further, per , ''Significant coverage is more than a trivial mention, but it does not need to be the main topic of the source material.'' Disclosure: article creator Deletion of Dr Morton's - the medical helpline WP:ORGIN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6227 1849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Surojit Sen User:onel5969 22:56, 14 April 2017 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass , and nowhere near enough in-depth coverage to show they meet Deletion of Surojit Sen WP:NAUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6228 7 [[Liste der Künstler, die Platz 1 der deutschen Singlecharts erreichten]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Steak 08:48, 15. Jul. 2012 (CEST) delete Erfüllt nicht die Kriterien unter , also Löschung von Liste der Künstler, die Platz 1 der deutschen Singlecharts erreichten Wikipedia:Listen Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
6229 2650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gripen vs Rafale vs Typhoon User:Kyteto NONE delete This article is a one-editor opinion piece that makes quite a few subjective conclusions in its body. While I hope not to be drawn into a point-counterpoint on those subjective issues, I wish to state that I do not see this article as meeting , as well as . — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Gripen vs Rafale vs Typhoon WP:NPOV||WP:OR Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
6230 4146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asian pride (3rd nomination) User:RightCowLeftCoast 01:07, 18 December 2012 (UTC) keep """the primary purpose of an AfD is to see whether the subject is notable. If we do a google search we can find more than https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Asian+Pride%22&aq=f&oq=%22Asian+Pride%22&aqs=chrome.0.57j0l3j62l2.2874&sugexp=chrome,mod=10&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8#hl=en&safe=off&tbo=d&sclient=psy-ab&q=%22Asian+Pride%22+-wikipedia&oq=%22Asian+Pride%22+-wikipedia&gs_l=serp.3...375906.378247.0.378349.11.11.0.0.0.0.219.1039.10j0j1.11.0.les%3B..0.0...1c.1.h3GrX9Xi3tw&pbx=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.&bvm=bv.1355534169,d.cGE&fp=4923ca7c4da5ccfb&bpcl=40096503&biw=912&bih=387 700k google hits, as well as over https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Asian+Pride%22&aq=f&oq=%22Asian+Pride%22&aqs=chrome.0.59j61j5j0j61l2.2717&sugexp=chrome,mod=10&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8#q=%22Asian+Pride%22&hl=en&safe=off&tbo=d&source=lnms&tbm=bks&sa=X&ei=nrrPULrINIjoigKivoHQCQ&ved=0CA8Q_AUoAA&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.&bvm=bv.1355534169,d.cGE&fp=27b39e0b5279bf6c&bpcl=40096503&biw=915&bih=674 1k mentions in books. Now to meet ''significant coverage'' per we can see the subject is covered under the chapter """"Got Rice?"""" in the book http://books.google.com/books?id=-0sEJ_0vV1QC&dq=%22Asian+Pride%22&source=gbs_navlinks_s Encyclopedia of Asian American Folklore and Folklife, Volume 1, the term is used to counter Asian American#Stereotypes|Asian American stereotypes in Greg Pak's http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6G4Q6VPbPsc ''Asian Pride Porn''http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0291025/ , as well as discussed elsewhere (http://books.google.com/books?id=dVUvp-XcLB8C&lpg=PA182&dq=%22Asian%20Pride%22&pg=PA181#v=onepage&q=%22Asian%20Pride%22&f=false 1, http://books.google.com/books?id=4hqpJEJp7cUC&lpg=PA54&dq=%22Asian%20Pride%22&pg=PA54#v=onepage&q=%22Asian%20Pride%22&f=false 2, http://books.google.com/books?id=lSltA45YAkQC&lpg=PA103&dq=%22Asian%20Pride%22&pg=PA103#v=onepage&q=%22Asian%20Pride%22&f=false 3). Moreover, it is also used outside of the United States, with usage in http://books.google.com/books?id=tujY4nUQdtkC&lpg=PA119&dq=%22Asian%20Pride%22&pg=PA115#v=onepage&q=%22Asian%20Pride%22&f=false Australia. Granted the article is in VAST need of improvement. However, that does not mean that it is not notable, and thus should be deleted. Rather it means, it should be tagged, and improved""" Deletion of Asian pride (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6231 14130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeVry DuPage User:N 05:47, 13 February 2007 (UTC) delete This is unverifiable and unsourced (sources do not meet |reliable source criteria). It is also not notable Deletion of DeVry DuPage WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6232 14131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madeline Cripe User:Qworty 20:48, 15 September 2012 (UTC) delete per and . The credits for movies and TV shows can go on for many minutes these days, listing all sorts of non-notable people who were somehow involved in production. But the notability standards around here are a much higher bar. It's an ugly squib of an article, unsure even of the gender of its subject Deletion of Madeline Cripe WP:CREATIVE||WP:NOTADIRECTORY Wikipedia:Notability 77
6233 21867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sore Thumbs User:GassyGuy 15:49, 6 January 2007 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Sore Thumbs WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
6234 5097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rewakening User:Hobbes 02:36, 27 December 2011 (UTC) delete Can't find anything substantial from an source. A bit of blog/'zine notice. It does appear to be a real album from a real band, just not sufficiently up the notability scale. If better sourcing can be found, happy to look again Deletion of Rewakening WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6235 1324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Brown (motorist) User:Richard 02:36, 5 July 2016 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Joshua Brown (motorist) WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
6236 3724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Florence Nibart-Devouard (second nomination) User:GRBerry 04:25, 18 December 2006 (UTC) comment Wikipedia is not a crystal ball. I suspect notability to standards will become clear before the next year is out, but it will also be easy enough to recreate the article at that time. With neither the ability to read French nor the willingess to pay for archived New York Times articles, I have no opinion on whether has been met yet Deletion of Florence Nibart-Devouard (second nomination) WP:BIO||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6237 18575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Modica User:Kicking222 16:12, 14 December 2006 (UTC) delete """Only claims of notability are winning non-notable local awards. I couldn't even figure out what the """"Bunny Award"""" is. Only http://www.google.com/search?q=%22jason+modica%22&num=30&hl=en&lr=&safe=off&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&hs=Uos&start=30&sa=N 41 unique Google hits, and many of those relate to a baseball player. Fails """ Deletion of Jason Modica WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6238 2888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Gamble (socialite) User:MER 15:26, 27 July 2019 (UTC) delete as a opyright violations#Addressing contributors|presumptive copyright violation; the author was blocked for an extensive history of copyright infringement Deletion of Patrick Gamble (socialite) WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
6239 8016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Book store shoplifting (2nd nomination) User:E 15:27, 16 July 2019 (UTC) keep oddball topic, but the sourcing on the page establishes that it ''is'' a coherent topic, and it passes Deletion of Book store shoplifting (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6240 10828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeremy Annear User:Sionk 12:25, 11 March 2018 (UTC) delete for the arguments presented by the nominator. Clearly Annear is an active artist but, according to his own website, has only had one solo exhibition. Probably a successful artist, but not meeting Deletion of Jeremy Annear WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
6241 4927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conservative Underground (2nd nomination) User:Jersey 00:06, 19 April 2006 (UTC) delete alexa rank isn't that bad but it isn't comparable to some of the top political forums that have established non-Afdable articles here. The forum also fails (unless one of the three notability critera per web can be met then I'll stick with delete vote but it notability can be established I'll change my vote Deletion of Conservative Underground (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
6242 470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hideyuki Akaza User:David 03:39, 29 November 2013 (UTC) keep per #C1 Deletion of Hideyuki Akaza WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6243 5252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gravity Hurts (song) User:RichardOSmith 20:18, 27 February 2015 (UTC) keep per use of the title song by Lego (#5 Deletion of Gravity Hurts (song) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6244 8501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seán Ó Conghaile NONE NONE delete fails and Deletion of Seán Ó Conghaile WP:NAUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6245 6993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donetsk People's Republic NONE NONE keep """I can't believe this has been nominated for deletion. Seems to be a case of a . As another used said above 'I fail to see how this isn't notable. If a group of a protestors broke into the Nebraska State House, kicked everyone else out of it, and declared the """"Nebraska People's Republic"""", would that not be notable? Just because it's in Ukraine, and a lot of stuff is happening in Ukraine, doesn't mean that this is not notable. Question: What does this hurt? I fail to see how Wikipedia is a lesser place with this article. I also fail to see how it's a better place without this article""" Deletion of Donetsk People's Republic WP:WORLDVIEW Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
6246 12145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sell the lexus, burn the olive tree User:Nenyedi 03:08, 16 August 2007 (UTC) delete fails , and Deletion of Sell the lexus, burn the olive tree WP:N||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6247 197 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Mef Okulları Kullanıcı:murateromuratero 05:32, 3 Mayıs 2016 (UTC) delete Madde, içeriğindeki mevcut verilere göre |KD kriterlerini karşılamamakta Mef Okullarının silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
6248 12043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reylynn Caster (2nd nomination) User:Beccaynr 16:18, 17 April 2021 (UTC) keep based on the in-depth feature articles that were in the article, and the sources, including reviews, that have since been added, per , she {{tq|has had significant roles in multiple notable ... television shows Deletion of Reylynn Caster (2nd nomination) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
6249 17504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deaths of Lawrence and Glenna Shapiro User:Wdchk 16:14, 30 March 2014 (UTC) delete """I'm sorry, but this is a local story with insufficient evidence of national or international coverage (). The article itself rather confirms this by stating """"The Shapiros' homicide was a shock to the Phoenix metropolitan community ..."""". The claim of """"widespread attention in the national press"""" does not hold up: references to ''cbsnews.com'' and ''foxnews.com'' are simply repackaged local and agency reports. – """ Deletion of Deaths of Lawrence and Glenna Shapiro WP:GEOSCOPE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6250 6502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Damon A Williams User:RayAYang 18:57, 13 May 2013 (UTC) delete per nom. Unremarkable university administrator, fails . does not apply, as administrators are not academic researchers in the sense of the guideline Deletion of Damon A Williams WP:BIO||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6251 3713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chowtime Na! User:CruzRamiss2002 12:13, 11 August 2021 (UTC) merge to List of programs previously broadcast by Intercontinental Broadcasting Corporation. Not notable enough and insuffcient sources to create a separate article, completely fails and Deletion of Chowtime Na! WP:GNG||WP:TVSHOW Wikipedia:Notability 77
6252 57 [[Kulanu]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Prügelprinz NONE keep """Was ist ''""""Partei ohne Sitze und damit auch ohne Relevanz""""'' bitte für eine löschtrollige Begründung? Seit wann sind Parteien erst relevant, wenn sie Sitze errungen haben? Laut spricht für ''""""die Aufnahme eines Artikels über eine politische Partei … die Teilnahme mit Parteilisten oder mit Wahlkreis-Direktkandidaten an einer Parlamentswahl auf … nationaler … Ebene …. Erstmals antretende Parteien können mit der erfolgten Zulassung durch die zuständige Wahlbehörde aufgenommen werden.""""'' Wie viele Sitze haben denn z.B. die Partei Bibeltreuer Christen, die Sarazzistische Partei – für Volksentscheide|Sarazzistische Partei oder die Anarchistische Pogo-Partei Deutschlands? Im Gegensatz zu diesen Außenseitern ist Kulanu eine Partei des Mainstreams, die von einem prominenten ehemaligen Minister und Likud-Abgeordneten gegründet wurde (Mosche Kachlon) und auf deren Liste zahlreiche bekannte Personen kandidieren (u.a. der Militär Joaw Galant, der Historiker und ehemalige Botschafter in den USA :en:Michael Oren|Michael Oren, die stellvertretende Bürgermeisterin :en:Rachel Azaria|Rachel Azaria und der ehemalige Kadima-Vorsitzende :en:Akram Hasson|Akram Hasson.) Den :en:Opinion polling for the Israeli legislative election, 2015|Umfragen zufolge kann die Partei mit 7-10 Sitzen rechnen""" Löschung von Kulanu Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
6253 16941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Selman Munson & Lerner User:Dlohcierekim 17:55, 23 October 2017 (UTC) delete does not meet or other relevant criteria. See above rationales. Perhaps the creator/company in question mistook us for LinkedIn Deletion of Selman Munson & Lerner WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6254 18375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nela Arias-Misson User:Edwardx 19:14, 7 March 2017 (UTC) keep WP:BEFORE applies here. Passes and . The El Pais article alone is enough Deletion of Nela Arias-Misson WP:ARTIST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6255 17779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Casey Calvert (actress) [[User talk:Erpert|blah, blah, blah...]] 00:03, 16 February 2019 (UTC) keep What part of does she fail, exactly? (SN: {{u|Guilherme Burn}}, while I agree that the article should be kept, her Instagram account isn't a good source; better sources include: https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/the-only-worker-prop-60-h_us_12111522 https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/pity-porn-the-unlikelihoo_us_7530586 https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/why-i-dont-want-condoms-a-porn-performers-perspective_us_5425635 https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/porn-stars-r-stupid_us_5188166 https://www.xbiz.com/news/198712/gamelink-taps-casey-calvert-as-bdsm-fetish-expert) '''Erpert Deletion of Casey Calvert (actress) WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6256 9133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taxon expedition User:Ventric 23:15, 7 December 2017 (UTC) delete This article falls under , but could be re-created at another time using more sourced material Deletion of Taxon expedition WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
6257 13690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Graphical interface of future operating system User:Fabrictramp 01:17, 18 January 2010 (UTC) delete """as per the reasoning in my prod tag: """"A speculative unsourced essay on what the editor would like to see in future computers. Fails """ Deletion of Graphical interface of future operating system WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6258 5249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Lindberg User:Northamerica1000 01:36, 4 August 2014 (UTC) delete Source searches are not demonstrating notability for the subject; does not appear to meet for a Wikipedia article Deletion of Greg Lindberg WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6259 8663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noppol Sankapong User:GiantSnowman 17:54, 18 February 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Noppol Sankapong WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6260 13691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Two Blue Lines User:Aquila92 08:31, 23 June 2010 (UTC) delete Fails . I am not opposed to moving the article to Deletion of Two Blue Lines WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6261 16400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Media whore2 User:Coroebus 14:59, 2 June 2006 (UTC) delete unless anyone can be arsed to make a sensible entry about the concept (personal favourite example would be Kevin Warwick, but that'd just be pushing my Deletion of Media whore2 WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
6262 11062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Anix User:Capitalistroadster 06:21, 4 December 2005 (UTC) delete According to Allmusic.com, it only has one album to its credit see http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&token=ADFEAEE4781ED947A57520EFB71670E1FA5CDE2DFE62D9BA5007656392940454880C71ED59E695CCB3E571AB7BAFFF2BE85B05D2CCE452FDCC1740&searchlink=ANIX&uid=MIW040512040116&samples=1&sql=11:qy09kextfq7n~T2 credited to Anix records. 222 Google hits appears to indicate a lack of notability as per see http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22The+Anix%22&btnG=Google+Search Deletion of The Anix WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6263 21511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lenovo K3 Note NONE NONE merge to Lenovo smartphones. There are sources, but per , we should not keep product-stubs when a merge is suitable ({{tq|Avoid creating multiple stubs about each individual product Deletion of Lenovo K3 Note WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6264 7513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dorothy Cheney (scientist) User:Jmertel23 20:44, 13 May 2018 (UTC) keep as per #C3 Deletion of Dorothy Cheney (scientist) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6265 9296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reactions to the 2008 Sichuan earthquake User:Matthiasb 18:24, 16 May 2008 (UTC) delete the contents is in no way from encyclopaedical value. That the Pope prayed and Dubya sent his condolences is an act of courtesy but no information at all. See als on this. Did I say delete Deletion of Reactions to the 2008 Sichuan earthquake WP:RECENTISM Wikipedia:Recentism 10
6266 5302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pridgen cipher User:Armbrust 00:54, 17 May 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Pridgen cipher WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
6267 12608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erlang (programming language) User:Jfire 06:55, 4 February 2009 (UTC) keep Highly notable programming language. Nominator appears to be a Deletion of Erlang (programming language) WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
6268 21300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mary Janes User:HumbleGod NONE delete per above. If not deemed appropriate, then at least '''delete''' per not being met. (There's a different group called Mary Janes on allmusic, and the previous version of the article didn't make any real claim of notability Deletion of The Mary Janes WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6269 6384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ShadowFall User:Seb 08:02, 3 January 2010 (UTC) delete per nom... and most likely spam. And . And whatnot. Should've been speedied Deletion of ShadowFall WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6270 21847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kyle Keyes User:Bagumba 00:12, 5 February 2013 (UTC) delete Fails . The only significant source I found was not independent—he is the CEO of the company. The rest is just trivial mention in game coverage Deletion of Kyle Keyes WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6271 14161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fabia Orestilla User:Krishna 03:28, 14 May 2018 (UTC) delete per nom and . Regards Deletion of Fabia Orestilla WP:INHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6272 18338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oulton Park Folland Gnat crash User:Kolbasz 17:20, 23 August 2015 (UTC) delete Can't find more than routine news coverage, and it doesn't seem likely this crash will have any |lasting effects. Not notable enough for a standalone article Deletion of Oulton Park Folland Gnat crash WP:LASTING Wikipedia:Notability 77
6273 5763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Om Thanvi User:Shivkarandholiya12 13:22, 29 December 2018 (UTC) keep I am the one who created the article and see failure of . Subject meets per significant coverage by The Sunday Guardianhttps://www.sundayguardianlive.com/culture/modern-master-whose-passing-marks-end-era-indian-art, Aaj Takhttps://aajtak.intoday.in/story/bihari-puraskar-for-writer-journalist-om-thanvi-1-807852.html and other sources.https://www.bhadas4media.com/om-thanvi-patrika-group Deletion of Om Thanvi WP:BEFORE||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6274 15625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Margaret Ayers User:JeremyMcClean 18:12, 18 August 2010 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Margaret Ayers WP:HOAX||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
6275 4309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiffany Page User:AllyD 16:50, 11 September 2011 (UTC) comment The damage done to the article isn't really a justification for deletion. As to whether she meets the |Notability criteria, #1 might be argued by the UK press attention (http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2009/oct/22/new-band-tiffany-page Guardian 2009 article, http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/music/rockandpopfeatures/7544761/New-faces-Tiffany-Page.html Daily Telegraph 2010, http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-1255613/The-Next-Big-Thing-Tiffany-Page.html Daily Mail 2010) but it feels more like comment on PR push than solid critical attention. So more would be needed Deletion of Tiffany Page :WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6276 8643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Nelson (professor) User:Bearian 20:00, 10 March 2015 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Philip Nelson (professor) WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
6277 6612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helen Gibbins User:Whpq 18:39, 9 July 2010 (UTC) delete for failing |verifiability. The claims, if true, may be notable, but there is no corroboration for any of this in reliable sources Deletion of Helen Gibbins WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6278 8823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chicken Lady (2nd nomination) User:Piotrus 03:50, 13 November 2019 (UTC) delete to The_Kids_in_the_Hall#Recurring_sketches_and_characters. Nothing here suggests this passes / for a stand-alone article Deletion of Chicken Lady (2nd nomination) WP:NFICTION||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6279 19529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess Friederike of Hanover User:Kusma 14:47, 28 November 2013 (UTC) delete unless sources can be found that say anything nontrivial about her (hint: not just about who her parents and grandparents are). I don't see how she passes Deletion of Princess Friederike of Hanover WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6280 5602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/What'sBest! Excel Spreadsheet Solver User:Leebo86 04:50, 14 February 2007 (UTC) delete as |blatant advertising. The only reason the tag is off is because the author has repeatedly removed it. The author was warned once, but that was it Deletion of What'sBest! Excel Spreadsheet Solver WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
6281 15272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erin Bethea Catt User:HisSpaceResearch 11:50, 3 December 2007 (UTC) delete per #CRYSTAL, no prejudice against recreation obviously Deletion of Erin Bethea Catt WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6282 6999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MuleSoft (2nd nomination) User:Patar 02:26, 11 October 2016 (UTC) keep Since 2012, it's reached a valuation of $1.5 billion and is considered a Unicorn (finance)|unicorn startup, and is apparently about to IPO. Sources now seem enough to meet and include ''TechCrunch'' https://techcrunch.com/2016/09/17/what-do-you-call-a-tech-unicorn-that-goes-public/, ''Fortune'', http://fortune.com/2015/05/19/mulesoft-unicorn-club/, ''The Wall Street Journal'', http://blogs.wsj.com/cio/2016/06/07/mulesoft-founder-ross-mason-says-cios-top-priority-is-accelerating-change/, ''CNBC'' http://www.cnbc.com/2016/10/07/why-you-shouldnt-expect-many-more-billion-dollar-tech-ipos-anytime-soon.html, and a reputable ''Forbes'' contributor, http://www.forbes.com/sites/stuartanderson/2016/06/04/ross-mason-immigrant-founder-of-1-5-billion-mulesoft-on-job-market-and-managing-a-global-company/#5daba4326148 among others Deletion of MuleSoft (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
6283 14525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buddhist-Christian parallels [[User_talk:Dlohcierekim|'''Cheers, :) Dlohcierekim''']] 01:39, 25 October 2006 (UTC) keep """When I saw the title, I thought, """"oh, boy-- another |OR mess"""". When I saw the article, I thought, """"wow- people have worked hard on this."""" It looks like a well-written article""" Deletion of Buddhist-Christian parallels WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
6284 7017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cristian Fleming User:Whpq 21:33, 18 December 2007 (UTC) delete despite the numerous references in the article, I see one that would be considered a |reliable source Deletion of Cristian Fleming WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6285 3414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gia na xereis alaniari [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] 15:14, 21 July 2017 (UTC) delete The articles fail , , and (in some cases) . Perhaps some of them could be combined into a list article if sources are available to show notability Deletion of Gia na xereis alaniari WP:GNG||WP:NSONG||WP:RS||WP:OR||WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
6286 4478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chuck Taylor (wrestler) User:Darrenhusted 23:49, 30 June 2007 (UTC) comment One last time, and s l o w l y for you. You...are...filibustering. Edit the article, stop pumping up this debate. The problem is that you feel you |own this article and don't want it deleted, but spamming AfDs and filibustering '''does not''' help the article Deletion of Chuck Taylor (wrestler) WP:OWN Wikipedia:Ownership of content 86
6287 4008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rajan Kannattu User:Bearcat 18:08, 22 June 2015 (UTC) delete In its current form, this is a completely |unsourced article about a person whose only substantive claim of notability is as the leader of a ''splinter'' faction within a political party, with ''no'' evidence that he's actually held a notable office to satisfy , and ''no'' real substance to indicate why leading a splinter faction within a political party would get him over either Deletion of Rajan Kannattu WP:RS||WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6288 18176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs with personal names: A User:Hirohisat 05:29, 27 June 2007 (UTC) delete per #DIR Deletion of List of songs with personal names: A WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6289 15908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oakland Colegio Campestre User:Extraordinary 20:56, 30 June 2021 (UTC) merge to List of schools in Bogotá. The article needn't meet : as makes clear, meeting the |GNG is just fine. In this case, however, that's a distinction without a difference since there are zero reliable sources at all. My searches aren't finding anything either, so I'll conclude it isn't notable. But redirecting the page to the list of schools in Bogotá, where it's already mentioned, seems to be a reasonable |alternative to deletion, if only per Deletion of Oakland Colegio Campestre WP:NORG||WP:NSCHOOL||WP:GNG||WP:ATD||WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6290 11287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Cohler User:Qworty 05:12, 3 June 2008 (UTC) delete He's worked for a lot of well-known companies, but he himself has not achieved notability per Deletion of Matt Cohler WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6291 7778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1980–81 United States network television schedule (Saturday morning) User:FOARP 20:01, 4 December 2018 (UTC) delete fails . is not a good argument for keeping - lots of things are useful, not all of them are suitable for inclusion on Wiki Deletion of 1980–81 United States network television schedule (Saturday morning) WP:NOT||WP:USEFUL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6292 12230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xavi Simons User:Inter 23:26, 16 January 2019 (UTC) delete fails and , at the age of 15 this article is obviously way Deletion of Xavi Simons WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
6293 8707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ICall (2nd nomination) User:Kinu 23:23, 29 January 2020 (UTC) delete Very little coverage. does not appear to be met Deletion of ICall (2nd nomination) WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6294 5601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Our Fragile Intellect (2nd nomination) User:Tryptofish 15:54, 4 January 2015 (UTC) merge """to Gerald Crabtree. I came here from the ping to editors who commented in the previous AfD. Looking at the page as it has come to be now, the """"reception"""" section is entirely about negative receptions in the scientific community, and the """"cultural trope"""" section is basically about this work echoing cultural ideas that preceded it, rather than exerting influence of its own. I agree with Qwertyus that this AfD should evaluate the page as a news event more than as a scientific concept. I do think the topic is interesting and encyclopedic in the context of Crabtree's work, and it seems to me that the biographical page is currently incomplete without it, so a merge would improve that biographical page. But I think that points against keeping this standalone page""" Deletion of Our Fragile Intellect (2nd nomination) WP:CONTINUEDCOVERAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6295 721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael White & The White User:Wildthing61476 17:11, 27 July 2006 (UTC) comment For now, but I have to ask, does a tribute band also have to meet the requirements of Deletion of Michael White & The White WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
6296 17052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comics and Sequential Art User:PWilkinson 21:26, 22 June 2014 (UTC) comment The present article is fairly ghastly, but I am left wondering about the quality of the nominator's . The book was apparently not aimed at the academic market, but a GScholar search on the book's author shows over 600 citations of the book, and apparently an additional 400 of a Portuguese translation - I find the book's notability effectively undeniable. Though if the article is not improved during the course of this AfD, I would have no objection to stubbing the article back to its first and third paragraphs and the infobox (and not very much to redirecting it to the author) pending re-expansion into a properly sourced article concentrating on its influence Deletion of Comics and Sequential Art WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6297 1320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Medvertex User:HighKing 18:22, 16 June 2018 (UTC) delete Fails GNG and . I rolled back the blanking of the article Deletion of Medvertex WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6298 19489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russia investigation origins conspiracy theory User:Darknipples 22:21, 21 October 2019 (UTC) delete """see other editors comments above) Wiki is not a mouthpiece or spin-zone for """"alternative narratives"""" or conspiracy theories. You can't just put a bunch of citations together and invent a subject - see """ Deletion of Russia investigation origins conspiracy theory WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
6299 9552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soltan Hajibeyov User:Nsk92 03:24, 10 January 2010 (UTC) keep People's Artist of the USSR is a very significant honor, basically the highest artistic honorary title that was available in USSR. Also, the Russian Wikipedia article mentions that he received the Stalin Prize of second degree in 1952. Passes on those grounds Deletion of Soltan Hajibeyov WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6300 12531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murray Tregonning User:Dawn 13:49, 4 May 2012 (UTC) delete I agree with the nominator that notability per can't be established - my searches yielded only trivial and/or non-independent sources. Cheers Deletion of Murray Tregonning WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6301 8094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sending Orbs User:onel5969 03:05, 11 February 2016 (UTC) delete searches don't show enough to pass , and doesn't meet either or Deletion of Sending Orbs WP:GNG||WP:CORP||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6302 15200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World s Most Hated User:Edtropolis 16:37, 18 June 2007 (UTC) delete This article is nonsense, in fact a |snowball Deletion of World s Most Hated WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
6303 9821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muslim Musa User:Johnlp 11:07, 25 November 2015 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Muslim Musa WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
6304 21397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Colonel (Monty Python) User:Arxiloxos 17:01, 28 May 2014 (UTC) keep subject to probable '''merge'''. The Colonel is a iconic Python character, and certainly sources exist that discuss the character in those terms. I've added a few.http://books.google.com/books?id=eQ23S8m0-p0C&lpg=PA151&dq=colonel%20%22monty%20python%22%20stop&pg=PA151#v=onepage&q=colonel&f=falsehttp://books.google.com/books?id=gSFYYKbtDCsC&lpg=PA120&dq=colonel%20%22monty%20python%22%20stops%20the%20sketch&pg=PA120#v=onepage&q=colonel%20&f=falsehttp://books.google.com/books?id=RS0FAgAAQBAJ&lpg=PA88&dq=colonel%20%22monty%20python%22%20%22saturday%20night%20live%22&pg=PA88#v=onepage&q=colonel%20%22monty%20python%22%20%22saturday%20night%20live%22&f=false Having said that, I think merge/redirect is fine, unless and until there's too much material to fit in the list. I can't agree that the redirect should to be deleted: this item is already listed on The Colonel|the appropriate disambiguation page, and per I don't think there's any need to get rid of it Deletion of The Colonel (Monty Python) WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
6305 16690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Domestic Football League User:Steve 17:13, 6 July 2008 (UTC) delete The article appears to be something |made up, and I can't find any sources to suggest otherwise Deletion of Domestic Football League WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
6306 20860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Northwest Royale User:Vectro 23:33, 17 October 2006 (UTC) delete even if it satisfies (it doesn't appear to), it has serious problems with , , and Deletion of Northwest Royale WP:MUSIC||WP:NPOV||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
6307 6913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BluesAirmen Guitars and Music User:Edgar181 15:07, 12 March 2006 (UTC) delete as non-notable per Deletion of BluesAirmen Guitars and Music WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6308 8248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helfensteller, Hirsch & Watson User:Sphilbrick 15:26, 18 December 2011 (UTC) comment I don't see the as working in this case. It is clear in the literal cases, that Person X being notable does not make the children of person X notable. Person X was notable for certain things, which usually have nothing to do with their children, parents, siblings, or casual friends. The situation is different with a notable building. It is often (but not invariably) notable because it is architecturally interesting. The architect or firm is the proximate cause of that notability, not merely related in some irrelevant fashion. Would we declare that David (Michelangelo)|David is notable, but Michelangelo not? Would we declare that The Starry Night is notable, but argue that Vincent van Gogh is not? I'm not arguing for an automatic, inflexible rule, but a general presumption seems warranted. On the merits, I support Orlady's suggestion to userfy Deletion of Helfensteller, Hirsch & Watson WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6309 4058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akil Kumarasamy User:Pburka 19:53, 30 May 2021 (UTC) keep Award winning Deletion of Akil Kumarasamy WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
6310 18849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pietro Balbo User:Cewbot 00:03, 14 September 2020 (UTC) comment This nomination has had limited participation and falls within the standards set for |lack of quorum. There are no previous AfD discussions, undeletions, or current redirects and no previous PRODs have been located. This nomination may be '''eligible for |soft deletion''' at the end of its 7-day listing Deletion of Pietro Balbo WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
6311 14262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs from Burnout Revenge and Burnout Legends User:ToonLucas22 16:10, 19 September 2015 (UTC) delete per and possibly Deletion of List of songs from Burnout Revenge and Burnout Legends WP:VGSCOPE||WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
6312 9143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drago Montalban User:Ubelowme 23:16, 12 August 2012 (UTC) delete My search for references for this person found nothing and the article doesn't really say anything about him anyway, it's all about this mysterious story that doesn't seem to exist either. If this isn't a |hoax it's a good imitation Deletion of Drago Montalban WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
6313 20837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Milad Seif User:Cerebellum 16:41, 22 January 2017 (UTC) delete I could not find |reliable sources for this article Deletion of Milad Seif WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6314 10374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dreams of a Playa User:Phantomsteve 20:11, 31 July 2009 (UTC) comment """The question isn't whether the article is harming Wikipedia - the question is whether it is |notable. Perhaps in the future, this will become a world-wide highly regarded, important piece of work, but at the moment it is not notable, and by that criteria, an article about it does not belong on Wikipedia. ''Thoughtless users on wikipedia'' are not trying to stop the blossoming minds of anyone - however, we have criteria for inclusion on wikipedia which do not include ''""""Allowing blossoming minds to have a forum""""'' - there are more appropriate places for this, such as blogs and the like. While the book is unpublished, and obviously has not received reviews and commentary from eliable|reliable sources, it remains unnotable from the point of view of wikipedia's criteria - this is not to belittle the work of the young adults working on it, this is just the policy followed here. My suggestion is to keep working on it, get it published, get into the NY Times (or London Times, or other world-reknown paper or website) best seller list - then no one will say it is not notable... '''but it is not notable yet'''. Thank you""" Deletion of Dreams of a Playa WP:NOTABLE||WP:R Wikipedia:Notability 77
6315 10349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1349 Woking Squadron User:Deor 21:17, 8 April 2008 (UTC) delete """per : """"Individual chapters of national and international organizations are usually not notable enough to warrant a separate article unless sufficient notability is established through reliable sources."""" Not seeing sources that establish individual notability of this squadron""" Deletion of 1349 Woking Squadron WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6316 12459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bibliography of Oakland, California User:Rusf10 01:36, 30 December 2017 (UTC) delete Falls under Wikipedia:INDISCRIMINATE. Its also worth noting that most (but not all) of the books are not notable enough themselves to have an article and neither are the authors of the books. And an even stronger argument to delete is this list fails . Without any sources, how do we know what these books are about? Looks like somebody did original research Deletion of Bibliography of Oakland, California WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6317 13045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HandWiki User:Expertwikiguy 00:59, 8 September 2020 (UTC) delete No significant news coverage and does not meet Deletion of HandWiki WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6318 15536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Longest streets in London User:ciphergoth 13:19, 19 February 2006 (UTC) delete clear violation of . &mdash Deletion of Longest streets in London WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
6319 3935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Losasso User:Boffob 15:52, 15 December 2008 (UTC) delete having an IMDB page is not sufficient to establish notability. Given the lack of roles in other productions and the lack of sources in general, it is highly doubtful that this person passes the |notability guidelines Deletion of Peter Losasso WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6320 904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/YouTubeMobile User:YechielMan 18:56, 19 June 2007 (UTC) delete per nom and probable ; the author has no other edits Deletion of YouTubeMobile WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
6321 15385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Airlines Flight 1561 [[User talk:Ravendrop|Ravendrop]] 06:06, 15 February 2012 (UTC) merge to List of aircraft hijackings At this moment it fails ersistence. The majority of the text can be trimmed as it is simple narration, which, while sourced, really isn't that notable. Only the few main points need to stay Deletion of American Airlines Flight 1561 WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
6322 5992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xindi (Star Trek) (2nd nomination) User:Dennisthe2 07:18, 24 December 2019 (UTC) keep I'm a bit on the fence here, but the Xindi had a fair presence in Enterprise. At the risk of invoking , there is precedent for including the races of the Trek universe (see Klingon, for instance) - but I know that this alone is not justification. Seems well cited, at the worst Deletion of Xindi (Star Trek) (2nd nomination) WP:WAX Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6323 19003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mikhnovskyy Serhiy User:Armbrust 14:05, 24 August 2010 (UTC) delete as article fails |notability criteria for artists. The awards he received (according to article), are not significant Deletion of Mikhnovskyy Serhiy WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
6324 6770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Occupational hazards with fire debris cleanup User:John 23:10, 2 April 2020 (UTC) delete The problem here is . Looking a bit deeper, I see that Deletion of Occupational hazards with fire debris cleanup WP:NOTADVICE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6325 21872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Casey Bender User:Bagumba 22:30, 18 August 2011 (UTC) delete Fails , having never played at highest level. This is a un-of-the-mill offensive lineman who does not deserve a standalone article. He also fails with lack of non-OUTINE|routine coverage in multiple |independent reliable sources. would suggest not to speculate on future notability based on whether the undrafted player ever plays in the NFL Deletion of Casey Bender WP:NSPORTS||WP:R||WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE||WP:INDEPENDENT||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6326 3832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Perry D Cox User:Arxiloxos 01:04, 26 August 2010 (UTC) comment """There is a lot of cruft that needs to be cleaned from this article, but it does make some significant assertions of notability--for example the coverage of his work in ''Us Weekly|Us'' and ''Forbes''. There is a significant coterie of influential, notable Beatles experts who are primarily self-published (''see, for example'', Allan Kozin, http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9C0DE5DC1E31F935A15751C1A9609C8B63 """"A Book Publisher, Beatlemaniacs? Why Don't You Do It on Your Own?"""", ''New York Times'', December 26, 2006). However, Cox isn't mentioned in that ''NYT'' article and I am not sure that the 2 older articles mentioned above are enough to get him over the hump, -wise. Some additional reviews or coverage of him or his work in mainstream media might do it, though, if such could be found""" Deletion of Perry D Cox WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6327 15149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ted Reilly User:AnemoneProjectors 08:15, 17 May 2016 (UTC) delete I think it's probably still , he technically fails and most sources discuss his ''EastEnders'' character rather than the actor himself - I can't find any exceptions, even the interview he did in a recent ''Gay Times'' is purely discussing his ''EastEnders'' role Deletion of Ted Reilly WP:TOOSOON||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Too soon 40
6328 19318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of politicians in India charged with corruption User:Uzma 02:58, 31 August 2012 (UTC) delete Clearly falls under . The list creates a single collective of these polticians and that single collective is relatively unknown, even if the individuals in the list are not. The article not only is suggesting that the persons in the list has committed a crime, the article list heaps guilt by assiciation. The list still suggests acquitted Prakash Singh Badal committed a crime by his being on the list and being assiciated with other people on the Wikipedia list. Delete Deletion of List of politicians in India charged with corruption WP:BLPCRIME Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6329 8276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blak Jak (2nd nomination) User:Atlantic306 15:01, 22 February 2019 (UTC) keep as clearly passes with coverage in multiple reliable sources such as Billboard, LaTimes and Allmusic which is certainly a reliable source as continually agreed by the WikiProject Albums and WikiProject Music as its bios and reviews are by a professional staff with music knowledge, the above commenter seems to want to disrepute every possible source in contradiction to accepted consensus Deletion of Blak Jak (2nd nomination) WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6330 10698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Rossiter User:Sir 05:46, 10 January 2014 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Jordan Rossiter WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6331 19132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammed Sagar Ali User:Number 16:56, 19 December 2020 (UTC) delete per failure Deletion of Muhammed Sagar Ali WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
6332 19861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Shall Dance User:SPACKlick 13:43, 25 July 2014 (UTC) delete without predjudice to recreation as per Deletion of I Shall Dance WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6333 4384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chase Koch User:Ddcm8991 19:51, 12 April 2016 (UTC) delete per . Subjects fails notability guidelines per and Deletion of Chase Koch WP:BLP1E||WP:BIO||WP:42 Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6334 13310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nova in trouble User:Capitalistroadster 00:09, 15 February 2006 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not a blog. Article appears to be a blog-type entry on a dispute between two Irish radio stations Deletion of Nova in trouble WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6335 6948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martyn Carruthers [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']] 21:14, 14 February 2006 (UTC) delete Non-notable biography, refers Deletion of Martyn Carruthers WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6336 3990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ignacio Govere Colliport (iBoy) User:Doc 16:01, 9 March 2008 (UTC) delete Absolutely no sources check out on him. No charts list him, nothing found on everyhit.com, All Music Guide or anywhere. In fact the only ghits for the artist is to http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Ignacio+Govere+Colliport%22&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a Wikipedia and mirror sites. If he hit #1 on the UK Singles Charts, I would've at least gotten something. And the fact the album went Gold in America? I've got nothing on that either. This is a |hoax Deletion of Ignacio Govere Colliport (iBoy) WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
6337 20104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yuji Rokutan User:Alexf 12:45, 23 December 2008 (UTC) delete The few ghits available show he has not yet played a pro game in first league. Fails Deletion of Yuji Rokutan WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6338 17579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MAIBTYBILP User:Coredesat 03:09, 6 August 2006 (UTC) delete as a |non-notable neologism Deletion of MAIBTYBILP WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
6339 11275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greenbrier Addition, West Virginia User:Lightburst 02:18, 20 March 2020 (UTC) delete fails #2 Deletion of Greenbrier Addition, West Virginia WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
6340 5183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agent 3S3: Passport to Hell User:Cavarrone 12:23, 16 January 2012 (UTC) keep The film has a strong and not-trivial coverage in http://www.google.it/search?tbm=bks&tbo=1&hl=it&q=%22Agente+3S3%3A+Passaporto+per+l%27inferno%22&btnG=Cerca+nei+libri#q=%22Agente+3S3:+Passaporto+per+l%27inferno%22&hl=it&safe=off&tbo=1&tbm=bks&ei=9RQUT9i-Gojk4QTP5qHrAw&start=0&sa=N&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.,cf.osb&fp=78622060eb4a341b&biw=939&bih=358 Google Books, including books like ''L'Avventurosa storia del cinema italiano raccontata dai suoi protagonisti, 1960-1969'', ''007 All'Italiana'', ''Mondo exotica: sounds, visions, obsessions of the cocktail generation'', ''Dizionario dei film italiani stracult'', ''Spionaggio, avventura, eroi moderni''. The nom lacks of Deletion of Agent 3S3: Passport to Hell WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6341 14485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Songs that start with telephone sounds User:Ezeu 20:26, 20 September 2006 (UTC) delete Listcruft. an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of Songs that start with telephone sounds WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6342 20200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nexus War User:Peephole 17:15, 27 July 2006 (UTC) comment """From : """"the burden of evidence lies with the editors who have made an edit or wish an edit to remain."""" My point of view isn't that a browser-based game isn't notable, it is that this particular browser-based game isn't notable. And indeed notability is a point of view, that's why we need reliable, verifable and independent sources and that's also why there are guidelines for notability like and the proposed """ Deletion of Nexus War WP:V||WP:WEB||WP:SOFTWARE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6343 3208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/InTouch Messenger User:Dialectric 05:22, 29 May 2015 (UTC) delete software article of unclear notability, lacking significant coverage. Refs provided are download links and an incidental mention, and a search failed to turn up any further RS coverage Deletion of InTouch Messenger WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6344 20471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon Grindrod User:SalmanZ 15:40, 20 October 2019 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Simon Grindrod WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6345 1879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ra mes ses User:Caknuck 05:29, 7 August 2007 (UTC) delete """Only one source is cited, and it's an atlas. Phrases like '''""""If Ancient Egypt isn't something you have studied intensively...""""''' advertise |OR with giant, blinking neon signs and an eight page insert in the Sunday paper""" Deletion of Ra mes ses WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
6346 16761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Logan Williams (2nd nomination) User:Otr500 10:32, 7 April 2020 (UTC) delete """Per , , , as well as . There is no doubt that notability was lacking and the recent event (death is an event) in |news reports provides """"imbalance"""" that does not advance notability. All this does is fuel |speculation as to what really happened to the young actor, that -N|didn't really have enough notability until a flurry of news events because of the death, is catapulted as becoming more important. Yes Wikipedia is dynamic, but these types of situations is why we have policies and guidelines directing us not to fall into the drama of being steered to becoming a newspaper, or falling for wanting to create a future """"Death of"""" article as 8 out of 14 (57%) of the sources are about the """"death of..."""". When considering the trading card and Joey awards (not notable) are added it is something like 86% of the sources do not advance notability but just providing |ref bombing""" Deletion of Logan Williams (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTMEMORIAL||WP:RECENT||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BREAKING||WP:NOTSPECULATION||WP:SEMI||WP:REFBOMB Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6347 19154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michelle Jenneke User:IShadowed 02:52, 27 July 2012 (UTC) keep """Passes with flying colors ''and then some''. Ridiculous AfD. (Just a note -- being attractive and garnering news coverage because of it ''is'' a reason for inclusion. If it wasn't, we wouldn't ever have articles on models or pornstars because, as the nom says, they """"contain very little coverage of name as a person"""". Oh please""" Deletion of Michelle Jenneke WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6348 14398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Onion Games User:Spiderone 18:10, 15 January 2021 (UTC) delete per failure; may well be notable in the future so possibly at best; not every indie game developer is notable enough for an article Deletion of Onion Games WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
6349 13129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/People Can Change User:Joshuajohanson 20:54, 3 October 2007 (UTC) comment Wow, I was gone for awhile, and I was surprised how much changed. For some reason, the source from the Christian Newswire and the 2003 NARTH Conference on Homosexuality: Current Trends in Research and Therapy were removed, the first one with reason of being self-published, though the Christian Newswire is clearly independent. Also the authorship of the Marketwire report was changed to People Can Change. It seems like someone is trying to sway votes by removing third party sources and falsifying other information. To me, that represents a new low in the discussion. I have also since added an interview with Warren Olney on KCRW's show To the Point and a New York Times article (pay special attention to the second audio clip included with the story). With substantial coverage by the New York Times, KCRW, Marketwire, Deseret News, NARTH and the Christian Newswire, I think this passes Deletion of People Can Change WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6350 12431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beedi Naataka User:KylieTastic 20:08, 1 March 2017 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON doesn't pass Deletion of Beedi Naataka WP:MOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6351 17487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corpsefucking Art User:Mr 18:21, 6 April 2008 (UTC) delete does not make a valid assertion of notability, nothing even remotely satisfying Deletion of Corpsefucking Art WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6352 9325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naomi Kritzer User:Movingboxes 10:49, 30 August 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Naomi Kritzer WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6353 16307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darren Grimes User:Bearian 18:34, 12 November 2019 (UTC) delete WP:SNOW|clearly this is a |run of the mill, |young, |non-notable political activist. The |coverage on him is shallow and unreliable. |That other articles should also be deleted or that |the issues he espouses are important do not matter. |We are not a British web-host, we are an American charity subject to New York laws about charities Deletion of Darren Grimes WP:MILL||WP:UPANDCOMING||WP:POLOUTCOMES||WP:SIGCOV||WP:OTHERSTUFF||WP:SOAP||WP:NOTWEBHOST Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
6354 11811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erin Brown User:Metropolitan90 06:23, 23 December 2007 (UTC) keep per . A few of her movies are staples on late-night cable television, and she plays the lead role in those movies Deletion of Erin Brown WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6355 5308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Douglas tait User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:00, 10 June 2010 (UTC) keep While failing , and while he has had small roles in his early career as has any actor, it is my determination that in his total careerhttp://www.imdb.com/name/nm1408752/maindetails he meets . His SAG Awards nomination is a nice extra.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Douglas_Tait#Awards_.26_nominations Deletion of Douglas tait WP:GNG||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6356 14171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Like What I Like User:TenPoundHammer 19:13, 2 May 2008 (UTC) keep These appear to be major-label releases by a very notable band, and per , albums by a notable band are ''almost always'' worthy of their own pages as well. Just because the pages are sub-stub-class doesn't mean that they're not notable subjects. I'm sure there are some sources somewhere to expand on each of these articles Deletion of I Like What I Like WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6357 265 [[Wikipedia:Konfliktmeldung]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Superbass NONE keep Ich weiß definitiv nicht, ob wir so was brauchen. Aber die Initiatoren der Seite haben zuvor öffentlich und unübersehbar um Meinungen gebeten und einen überschaubaren Test-Zeitraum angegeben, nach dem die Seite natürlich gelöscht wird, falls ein angekündigtes Meinungsbild ihre Notwendigkeit nicht bestätigt. Da wirkt es schon ganz besonders destruktiv, diese gute Absicht zu ignorieren und ihnen per Löschantrag einen unnötigen Knüppel zwischen die Beine zu werfen. Eine Löschung würde das Prinzip torpedieren, auf dessen Basis sich die meisten anderen Institutionen die wir heute hier nutzen entwickelt haben, einschließlich dieser Seite hier, die ebenfalls ohne vorheriges Meinungsbild eingeführt wurde und auf die auch sonst alle negativen Attribute zutreffen, die genannt wurden. Also bis September und Tee trinken Löschung von Wikipedia:Konfliktmeldung Wikipedia:SM Wikipedia:Be bold 9
6358 7115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amit Majmudar User:Coolabahapple 14:37, 1 April 2016 (UTC) comment """here are some more reviews further showing that is also met: ''The Abundance'' - """"The narrative is slow, but sumptuous with recipes and reflection. Mr Majmudar, who is also a poet, imbues his prose with phrases and metaphors that linger with the warmth of spices."""" - ''The Economist'' http://www.economist.com/news/books-and-arts/21581968-cooking-grants-feelings-continuity-new-novel-about-immigrant, indeed based on the reviews (by Booklist, The Plain Dealer|Cleveland Plain Dealer, Good Housekeeping, Kirkus Reviews and Publishers Weekly) listed at amazon here http://www.amazon.com/The-Abundance-Novel-Amit-Majmudar/dp/1250045096 a separate book article could be created, ''Partitions'' - """"Majmudar writes with the incisive prose of a poet and the unflinching eye of a scientist"""" and """"The book’s flaw — if it’s a flaw — is that we’re so close to our subjects at every moment that we lose sight of the river they’re swept away by"""" - ''Hyphen magazine'' http://hyphenmagazine.com/magazine/issue-24-survival-winter-2011/book-review-partitions-amit-majmudar, and some more by (oh, oh{{=)}}) those trade magazines kirkus """"In his magnificent first novel"""" and """"Written with piercing beauty, alive with moral passion and sorrowful insight—a rueful masterpiece."""" - https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/amit-majmudar/partitions/; and pw """"Poet Majmudar's unconvincing debut novel"""" - and """"Tedious though not clumsy, ... but even the dark ending can't shake the notion that the whole endeavor feels like a semisanitized and oversensationalized theme park ride."""" - http://www.publishersweekly.com/978-0-8050-9395-7, and pw reviewing ''Dothead: Poems'', """"Aided by his unforgiving eye and a seemingly effortless ability to electrify his images, he composes a portrait of humankind that exposes its overreliance on the persuasive strength of fear."""" and """"But throughout Majmudar keeps focused on one task: exposing what he views as the hollow American claims to being a “melting pot,” as only those who appease the fickle identity of an American are guaranteed their own freedom."""" - http://www.publishersweekly.com/978-1-101-94707-4""" Deletion of Amit Majmudar WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6359 7224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chess tactics User:Iain99 22:29, 15 July 2007 (UTC) keep Extremely encyclopaedic subject, hundreds of books written about it, I'd be shocked if even a paper encyclopaedia didn't have at least a basic overview of the rules and strategies of chess. If implies that it shouldn't be here then I think this is a clear case where we should |Ignore All Rules. It's not some here today, gone tomorrow video game - it's chess Deletion of Chess tactics WP:NOT||WP:IAR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6360 16600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laura Coryton [[User talk:Czar|czar]] 05:07, 11 December 2016 (UTC) merge """to tampon tax#United Kingdom. Many of the above responses do not appear to reflect on the content of the sources or make policy-backed arguments. I merged the refs I could and ended up writing the separate tampon tax article while responding to this. Coryton is an activist in a larger campaign—the sources cover her as such and thus so should we. I read through the sources and, as usual, the tell is to find the central idea of each source: (primarily) the tampon tax in the UK, (secondarily) activism against the tax, and (tertiarily) Coryton's personal activism. So the vast majority of the news pertaining to Coryton is really about the tax, of which she is a part. We have no biographical sources from Wikipedia:Verifiability#Reliable sources|reliable, secondary sourcing—her background, her life, her other activism—it's all in the context of this one element. We handle these situations with Wikipedia:Summary style|summary style: cover the topic in an existing article and if the section grows to become |undue weight and the sources warrant more expansion, split it out into its own article. I'd additionally argue that a whole lot of context is lost by discussing her campaign without any of the background on what the tampon tax activism was like in the UK outside of her petition and participation. Tampon#tax (and Peterkingiron above) make it sound as if this is all her campaign, and some sources do too, but the vast majority of the sourcing credits her mainly for the popular, online petition and """"stop taxing periods, period"""" campaign. I looked and have yet to find any more depth of her campaigning. Until there is sufficient source content for a full treatment of the topic, Coryton is best covered in context at tampon tax#United Kingdom.File:Eye close font awesome.svg|14px|link=user:czar/watching|I am no longer watching this pageping if you'd like a response """ Deletion of Laura Coryton WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
6361 11253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nestor (film) User:NewYorkActuary 23:52, 2 March 2016 (UTC) delete Agree with nominator -- none of the criteria under are met here Deletion of Nestor (film) WP:NOTFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
6362 580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reuben Haines III User:Coolabahapple 16:14, 22 July 2016 (UTC) delete does not meet , sources found just have trivial mentions, subject is already covered at Wyck House Deletion of Reuben Haines III WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6363 15349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhythmicru User:K 06:39, 5 October 2016 (UTC) delete """per ; strictly a vanity page with puffed-up language such as """"They were known{{by whom}} for their guerilla marketing,1 live shows,2 and passion (!) for supporting the hip hop community.3. Nothing to salvage here""" Deletion of Rhythmicru WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6364 18628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ficticious Nigeria User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable reference to fictional work. ''Ficticious Nigeria is a fake uncharted island in the Atlantic Ocean''. &mdash Deletion of Ficticious Nigeria WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6365 3346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alfa Nero User:Mjroots 06:39, 9 March 2012 (UTC) keep per Bushranger. Needing expansion/improvement is not a reason to delete an article. appears to have been satisfied Deletion of Alfa Nero WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6366 11413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shards of Ice (2nd nomination) User:Pharaoh 09:51, 20 August 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Shards of Ice (2nd nomination) WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
6367 148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virgin Mobile Australia User:NahalAhmed 18:32, 27 December 2019 (UTC) merge Virgin Mobile Australia to Virgin Mobile. it's Doesn't meet Deletion of Virgin Mobile Australia WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6368 18370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of EINECS substances 200-xxx-x User:Toddst1 21:37, 20 December 2011 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of EINECS substances 200-xxx-x WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6369 15181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/State Sponsors of Terrorism User:Finnusertop 14:05, 12 January 2018 (UTC) keep per . The nomination is completely off the mark. These topics are related but not redundant. Both pass GNG with flying colors. – Deletion of State Sponsors of Terrorism WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
6370 15863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criminal procedure in California user:Andrew 20:49, 12 May 2018 (UTC) keep Per , only quotations and controversial material requires citations. The topic is clearly not original because there are entire books written about it; a selection follows. Please see , , , Deletion of Criminal procedure in California WP:V||WP:BEFORE||WP:BITE||WP:ATD||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6371 9229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sex Party (British Columbia) User:Whpq 18:54, 20 December 2006 (UTC) keep this is a registered political party, and the article itself is sourced meeting and Deletion of Sex Party (British Columbia) WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6372 21441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Evans (actor) User:Rutebega 23:26, 25 July 2019 (UTC) delete I have to concur with Clarityfiend here; a list of films on TV Guide is not good coverage, and it doesn't even come close to satisfying GNG. This is a BLP with no sources for even basic biographical info, and has been since 2012. I've searched for web, news, and book sources that could be used for this article, and turned up nothing. I'm astonished to have to point this out, but the GNG requires {{xt|''significant coverage''}} in ''reliable sources'', {{xt|traditionally ''more than one''}}, which are ''independent of the subject'', and only then is the subject presumed notable. |Significant coverage can be a slippery concept, but the guideline expressly stipulates that {{xt|''no original research is required to extract the content''}}. In this article, nearly the entire lead sentence is |original research. While TV Guide is a reliable source, it only gives Evans a |routine filmography, not significant coverage, and is unsuitable for establishing notability, especially on its own. If anyone is able to turn up coverage of Evans in other reliable sources, those can then be evaluated, but with this AFD being in its third week, I won't hold my breath. The mere supposition that more sources could exist is not enough to keep Deletion of Charles Evans (actor) WP:SIGCOV||WP:OR||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6373 2296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oobliette Sparks User:Doctorfluffy 23:18, 21 July 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Oobliette Sparks WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6374 15959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hampus Lönn User:GiantSnowman 10:52, 17 January 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Hampus Lönn WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6375 6584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xiaomi M365 User:Dmehus 23:29, 13 October 2019 (UTC) delete A scooter, or an electric scooter? I'd tend to think this is the way to go. It's also a ermastub|permastub. Of course, without prejudice to someone re-creating it, but at this point, it's just blatant SEO pumping Deletion of Xiaomi M365 WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
6376 21540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/London (heavy metal band) User:doomsdayer520 18:51, 12 November 2018 (UTC) keep I have great respect for the nominator, but his rationale in the nomination and previous comments shows undue dismissal of the and standards. The current article is indeed a sloppy unverified mess and it even has some internal contradictions. But those are reasons to improve, not delete. London is well-known in the metal world, because even though they accomplished little under their own name, they were an early stop for several musicians who became more famous in other bands later. They have attracted plenty of mainstream coverage ''for that reason'', as a ''historical item'', and that bestows notability just as much as number of albums and the other things being argued above. Michig has delivered plenty of reliable and significant sources to indicate the band's historical importance. Here are some more: https://www.axs.com/interview-the-reinvention-of-cinderella-drummer-fred-coury-from-rock-s-119472, http://ultimateclassicrock.com/wasp-songs/, https://www.laweekly.com/music/londons-calling-nadir-dpriest-looks-back-on-a-career-of-highs-and-lows-9920393, https://waaf.radio.com/blogs/anthony-capobianco/37-years-ago-nikki-sixx-started-motley-cr%C3%BCe, https://www.ultimate-guitar.com/news/general_music_news/nikki_sixx_i_left_the_band_i_started_with_my_best_friend_to_start_motley_crue.html. They were also profiled quite prominently in the film The Decline of Western Civilization Part II: The Metal Years, as can be verified in many reliable sources that discuss the film or several of the sources about the band that have already been linked by Michig and myself Deletion of London (heavy metal band) WP:NEXIST||WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6377 929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Barnaby Greenwald User:Jacona 19:12, 12 April 2019 (UTC) comment This is not just internet-age google hit count we're talking about. This is genuine coverage in Newspapers in New Jersey and elsewhere. In addition to all the New Jersey Coverage, there are over 700 newspapers.com articles in the Philadelphia Inquirer alone, and more in other Philly publications. I'm not going to try to list them, but that level of coverage doesnt apply to your average freeholder. Since Philly might be considered local, there are also articles from NY papers, including for instance The New York Daily News including the February 26, 1979 issue. There's coverage in The Morning News from Wilmington, Delaware - 3 articles dated September 1, 1977 September 23, 1977, January 12, 1995. Much of the NY and Delaware coverage discusses the mayor and two events/issues: a workfare proposal and a police force sickout. With these, this article meets |the general notability guideline Deletion of Maria Barnaby Greenwald WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6378 8506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Allure User:Cunard 07:31, 17 November 2009 (UTC) delete per the http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22This+Allure%22+California+source%3A%22-newswire%22+source%3A%22-wire%22+source%3A%22-presswire%22+source%3A%22-PR%22+source%3A%22-press%22+source%3A%22-release%22+source%3A%22-wikipedia%22&btnG=Search+Archives&scoring=a lack of significant coverage in |reliable sources. A browse through the http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22This+Allure%22+California+band&aq=f&oq=&aqi= results on Google return no indication that this band passes Deletion of This Allure WP:RS||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6379 966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yorkie poos User:TenPoundHammer 18:15, 29 August 2007 (UTC) delete to poodle hybrids, per nom, for lack of |reliable sources Deletion of Yorkie poos WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6380 5084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Body 1 User:Dalbury 04:29, 3 December 2005 (UTC) delete advertising and fails Deletion of Body 1 WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6381 16661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wretched (metal band) User:Lugnuts 18:39, 23 November 2017 (UTC) keep per #5 - has released two albums on Victory Records Deletion of Wretched (metal band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
6382 18192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BoardGameGeek User:Keeper 23:00, 2 January 2007 (UTC) keep website meets and is not that different from the one on h2g2 Deletion of BoardGameGeek WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
6383 19853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Hudson Automotive Group User:Steve 19:55, 28 July 2021 (UTC) delete As explained above, this topic should satisfy WP:NCORP - and CORPDEPTH in particular and - it does not. The sources added here by Lesliechin1 do not satisfy notability criteria. The first two are routine information as delineated by COREDEPTH https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability_(organizations_and_companies)#Examples_of_trivial_coverage here. The third source appears to be about the owner of the company. |Notability is not inherited and coverage must be about the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability_(organizations_and_companies)#Significant_coverage_of_the_company_itself company itself. I'm not sure the fourth source is actually in-depth coverage of the organization. It gives a brief overview of the company and that is about it. I think User:Lesliechin1 should probably stop advising other editors about their ivote Deletion of Jim Hudson Automotive Group WP:INHERITORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6384 4060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stéphanie Allard-Gomez User:Rpclod 05:30, 19 July 2014 (UTC) delete Does not appear to meet Deletion of Stéphanie Allard-Gomez WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6385 8289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of golf courses in the United Kingdom User:Ajf773 09:16, 9 January 2021 (UTC) keep Per keep only the notable courses, remove all others (redlinks Deletion of List of golf courses in the United Kingdom WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6386 13695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MobiAccess User:Millermk90 20:26, 3 December 2011 (UTC) delete I can see how a developement environment that allows cross platorm applications ''could'' be significant, but it is definitely , or possibly it will just never pass . — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of MobiAccess WP:TOSOON||WP:N Wikipedia:Too soon 40
6387 13348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agnes Callard User:Russ 16:04, 4 October 2020 (UTC) keep While citations look light for C1, the Guggenheim Fellowship is a pass of C2. The Lebowitz prize helps support, and her book has several reviews towards (helpfully linked from her https://philosophy.uchicago.edu/faculty/a-callard web page). Altogether, looks like a solid notability case Deletion of Agnes Callard WP:NPROF||WP:NPROF||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
6388 4275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen M.D. Chang User:Wikipedical 20:09, 13 October 2012 (UTC) delete """Fails to meet with no |reliable sources. Should not vote 'keep' while """"guessing"""" that more sources are available""" Deletion of Stephen M.D. Chang WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6389 21520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Till Tantau User:Pgallert 15:14, 4 May 2010 (UTC) comment OK, here we have the aticle creator of PGF/TikZ, claiming the software is notable but the creator is not. It seems that also in the case of Beamer (LaTeX), the software is notable but the creator is not. And further, we have a misunderstanding of (The nutshell, item 2), three of the German university system (they do not have a position of assistant professor, all professors have a lifetime position, profs at a university, as opposed to a ''Fachhochschule'' automatically have the right to conduct examinations, including for PhD), and a blanket accusation that the Fakultätentag Informatik lacks perspective when using Tantau as a face to promote IT. Anything else Deletion of Till Tantau WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6390 15475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WOLFPAC User:ReyBrujo 21:33, 5 May 2006 (UTC) merge to Daddy Long Legs. states that ''Contains at least one member who was once a part of or later joined a band that is otherwise notable; '''note that it is often most appropriate to use redirects in place of articles on side projects, early bands and such Deletion of WOLFPAC WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6391 9288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Singil Station User:Mangoe 23:31, 26 December 2006 (UTC) keep per . Discussion of inherent station inslusion is at Deletion of Singil Station WP:AFDP Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
6392 1651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dataway User:Adrian 21:01, 16 March 2006 (UTC) delete as |non-notable corporation, and I've never heard anyone else in this field mention them Deletion of Dataway WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6393 15129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daigo Umehara (3rd nomination) User:Kusunose 08:56, 8 February 2007 (UTC) keep According http://members2.jcom.home.ne.jp/monmon999/etc.html this page, Japanese arcade game magazines have several articles about him and interviews with him. According to http://www.tanomi.com/insanity/sf.html this, a booklet and DVD package about Street Fighter II competition features a 'special interview' with him. I think he meets Deletion of Daigo Umehara (3rd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6394 73 [[Judith Burmeister]] (erledigt) Benutzer:89.59.129.229 NONE delete """im Bewusstsein, dass der LA eigentlich ungültig ist, aber es gibt ja auch . - Mich hat die Diskografie im Artikel gerade irritiert, da ist ja auch ein Album gelistet, und ich habe deshalb mal kurz auf ihre HP geklickt. Die Seite http://www.judith-burmeister.de/musik/ """"Musik"""" zeigt die Irrelvanz überdeutlich. Und, um Himmels Willen, wir können doch nicht jedes Sternchen, das mal im Fernsehen Dieter Bohlen angelächelt hat, als dauerhaft relevant einstufen""" Löschung von Judith Burmeister Wikipedia:Ignoriere alle Regeln Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
6395 20984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mobpon User:Ihcoyc 14:23, 23 June 2008 (UTC) delete No notability is shown for this web based business. |Wikipedia is not in the business of offering |free advertising to non-notable businesses, even if it would stimulate the economy if we did. That has to be one of the more clever and original arguments to keep a spammy article I've seen in some time, though Deletion of Mobpon WP:NOT||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6396 5220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abraham Lubelski (3rd nomination) User:KidAd 22:25, 17 May 2020 (UTC) delete per nom. The article is blatant , and was partially written by Lubelski himself Deletion of Abraham Lubelski (3rd nomination) WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6397 18134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mukesh Hariawala User:Tryptofish 20:36, 18 August 2017 (UTC) delete Please, no wall-of-text reply. (And I'm not going to read most of the wall-of-text above.) The page, as is, is a mess and comes across as . I've looked at the sources that come up via the source links at the top of the AfD, and pretty much everything that comes up is relatively local coverage from India. Also, the awards are given by organizations in India. To whatever degree applies here, the subject fails that, so we are in territory, and I do not think that I'm seeing the more-than-local coverage that it requires. I'm going to leave a note at , because COI issues should be addressed there more so than here Deletion of Mukesh Hariawala WP:PROMO||WP:ACADEMIC||WP:GNG||WP:COIN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6398 20821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terror Drome User:BOZ 22:54, 6 June 2020 (UTC) merge to Cobra (G.I. Joe)#Bases per and Deletion of Terror Drome WP:PRESERVE||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
6399 14613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ely (band) User:Hello32020 20:38, 14 September 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Ely (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
6400 18951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oh Snap! User:Robman94 19:40, 29 March 2011 (UTC) keep This band has been a featured artist on two separate radio stations (CBC Radio 3 and http://www.thezone.fm/ The Zone), they have had articles written about them in 4 separate publications (including the Calgary Sun, http://www.martlet.ca/ The Martlet, http://www.bclocalnews.com/vancouver_island_south/victorianews/ Victoria News and Examiner.com) and one of their tunes was used for a RadioShack commercial. That's enough to satisfy Deletion of Oh Snap! WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6401 7664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ergonomically Designed Facilities User:Suriel1981 23:36, 31 March 2007 (UTC) delete Looks rather like as well Deletion of Ergonomically Designed Facilities WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
6402 102 [[Regionalgeschichtliche Datenbank Mittleres Saaletal]] (SLA) Benutzer:JARU/Bewertung 21:19, 9. Jul. 2011 (CEST) delete Full ACK. Habe wegen Fall 2 in Verbindung mit Fall 8 Löschung von Regionalgeschichtliche Datenbank Mittleres Saaletal Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6403 21866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shircago User:WilyD 13:39, 13 July 2006 (UTC) delete for failing and as apparent vanity Deletion of Shircago WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6404 614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Janne Wallenius User:Joe 06:01, 14 January 2017 (UTC) keep Many well-cited papers, a Scopus h-index of 21 and lots of GBooks hits suggest the subject passes #C1, although physics is a high-citation field and he doesn't appear to hit any of the other criteria. Similarly he seems to be mentioned a lot in the news, particularly in relation to his start up, which may scrape past /. Not super convincing in isolation but I think taken together these demonstrate notability. The issue of promotional content has evidently already been fixed. – Deletion of Janne Wallenius WP:PROF||WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6405 3223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Himo User:Elmssuper 06:26, 4 December 2020 (UTC) delete Doesn’t come close to meeting , let alone Deletion of Himo WP:NCORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6406 6868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fatsuit User:Andy 10:02, 24 September 2008 (UTC) keep It's hardly commonplace, but that's why we need an encyclopedia to explain it to us. Shallow Hal alone should be adequate justification for notability and . Expansion please though, especially some photographs Deletion of Fatsuit WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6407 12097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Georges Groulx User:Cindlevet 17:18, 2 March 2016 (UTC) keep it needs some work, but the actor meets }. No need to delete this atlall Deletion of Georges Groulx WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
6408 2223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paper Garden Records User:NinjaRobotPirate 05:40, 13 April 2016 (UTC) delete I found http://clatl.com/cribnotes/archives/2015/08/25/brooklyns-paper-garden-records-brings-music-to-ponce-city-market this article in ''Creative Loafing (Atlanta)|Creative Loafing'', but it's more about an event than the record label. There were also a few more trivial mentions scattered about, such as http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/11/technology/turntablefm-lets-users-play-dj-to-virtual-crowds.html?_r=0 this article in ''The New York Times''. However, it's still a bit |too soon for an article, as these are not in-depth coverage of the record label. I guess sending it to draft space would be OK, too Deletion of Paper Garden Records WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
6409 7407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jerry Donald User:Krishna 04:31, 16 May 2018 (UTC) delete """Local politician with no """"significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject of the article"""". Apart from the official government listing there isn't much coverage to establish notability. Fails and of course, . Regards""" Deletion of Jerry Donald WP:GNG||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
6410 13360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sadiel Rojas User:Dirtlawyer1 16:19, 25 February 2013 (UTC) keep """per Jrcla's comments above. No presumption of notability per either or , but subject appears to have received sufficient in-depth coverage of his NAIA POY award in multiple, independent, reliable sources to satisfy the general notability guidelines per . Article should be edited to give proper weight to the reasons for his notability; three or four added sentences could make this a respectable """"start"""" class article""" Deletion of Sadiel Rojas WP:NCOLLATH||WP:NBASKETBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6411 7882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elicia Maine User:A 13:29, 7 March 2021 (UTC) keep She meets criterion 5. She won 2 awards, TD Canada Trust Distinguished Teaching Award and B.C.'s Most Influential Women 2018: Stem Stars Deletion of Elicia Maine WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6412 1926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Logitech MX revolution User:Djbrianuk 23:17, 28 March 2007 (UTC) comment No, that's not Wikipedia policy - anyone can remove a prod from an article for any reason bar blatant vandalism. Please see Deletion of Logitech MX revolution WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
6413 12698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harcharan Singh Manget User:Hatchens 16:10, 31 May 2020 (UTC) keep Borderline qualified Deletion of Harcharan Singh Manget WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
6414 17583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zul Fahmi Awang User:L293D 02:21, 4 April 2018 (UTC) delete article is not bad, but he technically fails Deletion of Zul Fahmi Awang WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
6415 5041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paisa paisa User:MichaelQSchmidt 19:12, 30 July 2012 (UTC) merge """per to De Dana Dan#Theme song, where this (now-sourced) song is spoken of in context to that film. One addresses the existance of earlier versions of this song by tightening one's search paramaters to https://www.google.com/search?as_eq=wikipedia&q=%22Paisa+paisa%22&num=50#q=%22Paisa+paisa%22+,+%22De+Dana+Dan%22&hl=en&tbm=nws&prmd=imvns&source=lnt&tbs=ar:1&sa=X&ei=p8YWUPDnGMPIqgH5r4CIDQ&ved=0CCUQpwUoBQ&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.r_qf.&fp=d8e6d11dd8fbde3d&biw=1024&bih=616 """"Paisa paisa"""" , """"De Dana Dan"""" to then find sources which speak toward this particular version being covered in news media in relationship to ''De Dana Dan'', being released before the film, and being considered a chart hit. I gave the article an |overhaul to address earlier issues of its format and lacking use of available sources,http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Paisa_paisa&diff=504975556&oldid=503267590 and pre-emptively included pertinant information at its target,http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=De_Dana_Dan&diff=504977779&oldid=504604852 before coming to this discussion""" Deletion of Paisa paisa WP:MUSIC||WP:HANDLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6416 202 [[Monoton Music]] (erl., gelöscht) Benutzer:Frank11NR 17:59, 25. Mär. 2007 (CEST) delete """Der Grund für den Einspruch war die - durchaus verständliche - """"Wikipedia- Laienbegründung"""", Relevanz sei subjektiv. Da sie das zumindest in einem gewissen Maße hier nicht ist (falls der Autor nochmal vorbeischaut: Bitte lesen), halte ich den Artikel bei dieser geringen Verbreitung des Begriffs immer noch für zweifelsfrei irrelevant und somit . Der zweite Einspruchsgrund (""""Geschmack ist auch subjektiv"""") erledigt sich von selbst, der SLA-Steller hat zwar aus seinem Missfallen keinen Hehl gemacht, die Begründung zielte aber auf Irrelevanz. Grüße""" Löschung von Monoton Music Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
6417 879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nom Anor User:Doctorfluffy 04:34, 9 May 2008 (UTC) delete The article consists entirely of plot summary without real-world context or analysis, which violates #PLOT. It also currently lists no sources, and Google turned up only unreliable fansites/forums and unrelated hits (seems to be a popular username for people to use in online communities), which indicates that significant coverage from reliable secondary sources does not exist and that notability criteria cannot be met Deletion of Nom Anor WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6418 846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jaxon Rose Moore User:GeoffreyT2000 00:31, 20 November 2018 (UTC) delete Being 7 years old, she is too young to have an article on Wikipedia per . Also fails the GNG Deletion of Jaxon Rose Moore WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
6419 8977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eva Sayer User:Nenyedi 14:10, 17 August 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Eva Sayer WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6420 833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GamesRadar User:Ansh666 07:15, 28 July 2014 (UTC) keep searches on Books and Scholar show that GamesRadar is used commonly as a source itself in VG-related media (and is indeed considered a Wikipedia:WikiProject Video games/Sources#General|reliable source in Wikipedia itself), and as such meets . See Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kotaku for a similar case Deletion of GamesRadar WP:NMEDIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
6421 747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hitmixes (2nd nomination) User:L 22:05, 2 January 2011 (UTC) delete Agreed with Xwomanizerx. No promotion, only remixes of previously heard songs, article is a stub and does not seem to pass , simply charting in one country isnt significant coverage Deletion of Hitmixes (2nd nomination) WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
6422 13364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Hammond User:Lankiveil 12:02, 4 September 2008 (UTC) keep due to coverage in reliable third-party sources. Meets . Article seems more or less neutral, so no pressing COI concerns as far as I can tell Deletion of Kevin Hammond WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6423 13830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Structure of the Belgian Armed Forces in 1989 User:TimothyBlue 04:30, 13 December 2020 (UTC) keep """Article meets for keeping a list. 1989 is a major milestone year in the Cold War. Per CLN ''""""Deleting these rudimentary lists is a waste of these building blocks""""'' // """ Deletion of Structure of the Belgian Armed Forces in 1989 WP:CLN||WP:AOAL Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
6424 8487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of ACM-W Celebrations User:RoySmith 21:50, 13 June 2019 (UTC) merge I also came here from the DRV. This appears to fail because the group of listed items hasn't, ''been discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources''. If it has, and I've just not looked in the right place, please correct me per . Some of the top material in this article could well be merged back into the parent, but not the entire list, per Deletion of List of ACM-W Celebrations WP:LISTN||WP:THREE||WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:Notability 77
6425 13255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Law of One (The Ra Material) User:LuckyLouie 03:43, 19 November 2015 (UTC) delete It appears this obscure book article has lingered on WP for quite some time as a semi-stub on the basis of references that are passing mentions of the book rather than works specifically about the book, or sources that are sufficiently comprehensive but hopelessly entrenched within the fringe bubble. It's time to trim it back to an entry at List of modern channelled texts until such time as reliable sources arise that discuss the book in an in-depth and serious manner Deletion of The Law of One (The Ra Material) WP:FRIND Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
6426 6335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corizon User:Polargeo 20:20, 23 June 2009 (UTC) delete as spam per G11 Deletion of Corizon WP:SD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
6427 2457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Dale (New York politician) User:Lightburst 21:46, 12 August 2019 (UTC) keep non notable politician who fails NPOL yet passes . Subject became notable by being disbarred in 2005 for malfeasance, and a felony arrest and conviction 2012 for practicing as a disbarred lawyer, and denial of appeal in 2016. I added several sources including New York State Court of appeals and Buffalo news Deletion of David Dale (New York politician) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6428 20963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicole Wallace User:Shooterwalker 16:26, 17 July 2010 (UTC) merge per Claritas. No independent coverage that would . Merging in information can be left to editorial process Deletion of Nicole Wallace WP:verify notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
6429 1153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Typhoon Pepeng (disambiguation) User:BD2412 13:07, 21 May 2014 (UTC) delete per . A disambiguation page is merely a navigational device, one that is not needed where this navigation can be provided in a hatnote Deletion of Typhoon Pepeng (disambiguation) WP:TWODABS Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
6430 3821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Tsarion (2nd nomination) User:Qworty 04:46, 20 May 2008 (UTC) delete """Self-published """"author"""" without much going for him. Most of the sources are blogs and such, and the few legitimate sources, unfortunately, are not ''about'' him. So WP notability standards are not being met here""" Deletion of Michael Tsarion (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6431 11549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marif Piraev User:Papaursa 02:34, 19 November 2015 (UTC) delete I can't find (and the article doesn't have) significant sources to show he meets GNG. He doesn't meet since he has no top tier fights and there's no sources to support any claims he's a notable martial artist (see ). The most I could find was a results article showing he won his division at the Moscow city sambo championships and qualified to compete at the national championships. I don't believe that's enough to claim he's a notable martial artist Deletion of Marif Piraev WP:NMMA||WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6432 2849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Business planning User:Hetar 07:08, 16 April 2006 (UTC) delete seems like |OR. If the Method Engineering team wants to publish their work online, perhaps they should look into Wikibooks or Wikiversity Deletion of Business planning WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
6433 15246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clan (Warriors) User:Seraphimblade 06:50, 20 October 2007 (UTC) delete or transwiki to a fan wiki, if they even want it. Incoherency can be solved by editing, but a lack of out-of-universe |reliable source material cannot, and I see no indication that substantial amounts of such source material exist Deletion of Clan (Warriors) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6434 18651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slut-shaming User:Kaldari 21:34, 29 November 2012 (UTC) merge or '''Keep'''). Passes as there are several books and journal articles that discuss the concept of slut-shaming (rather than just using the term).http://books.google.com/books?id=r0ODZH9h-mgC&pg=PA186&dq=%22slut+shaming%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=TNO3UOHMEMjAiwK_4IGgCg&ved=0CDYQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=%22slut%20shaming%22&f=falsehttp://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09540253.2011.645023http://books.google.com/books?id=1jbsSXc9rUQC&pg=PA93&dq=%22slut+shaming%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=TNO3UOHMEMjAiwK_4IGgCg&ved=0CDAQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=%22slut%20shaming%22&f=false As the article is quite short right now, I would favor merging into slut, but I believe a longer article could stand on its own Deletion of Slut-shaming WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
6435 15931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bionic (musician) User:Sarahj2107 10:05, 5 May 2015 (UTC) delete I couldn't find any significant coverage in reliable sources under either his stage name or real name. No indication that he meets Deletion of Bionic (musician) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6436 19436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Textbook411.com User:Coredesat 21:34, 27 June 2006 (UTC) delete ad for a non-notable company (fails and Deletion of Textbook411.com WP:CORP||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
6437 14936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roland De Wolk User:I 14:58, 5 August 2013 (UTC) keep Per additions from Crtew and comments by Cullen, both supporting and as a subject receiving |significant coverage Deletion of Roland De Wolk WP:JOURNALIST||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
6438 18640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Compensation Solutions, Inc. User:Ihcoyc 04:17, 23 September 2011 (UTC) delete Florid |neutrality issues, and the article is |about a payroll administration outsourcing business. ''After years in the Human Resource administration and salary survey fields, Mr. Cioffe started CSI with the aid of two financial experts, Joseph Occhiogrosso and Stuart Yannalfo. An entrepeneur himself, Mr. Cioffe sought to enable other small business owners to focus on their core business competencies and outsource their cost centers Deletion of Compensation Solutions, Inc. WP:NPOV||WP:B2B Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
6439 5461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ukrainian Artists Society of Australia User:Duffbeerforme 08:09, 9 February 2011 (UTC) delete """WP:OR|Original research |promoting the organisation, two things that Wikipedia |is not. Also from Wikipedia:Notability (organizations and companies), """"The source's audience must also be considered. Evidence of attention by international or national, or at least regional, media is a strong indication of notability. On the other hand, attention solely from local media, or media of limited interest and circulation, is not an indication of notability; at least one regional, national, or international source is necessary""" Deletion of Ukrainian Artists Society of Australia WP:SPAM||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Spam 112
6440 426 [[Wikipedia:Konfliktmeldung]] (erl.) Benutzer:Schlepper NONE keep Verstoß gegen entfernt Löschung von Wikipedia:Konfliktmeldung Wikipedia:KPA Wikipedia:No personal attacks 58
6441 13365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cochicken User:Armbrust 02:34, 15 February 2010 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Cochicken WP:MADEUPINONEDAY||WP:N Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
6442 1319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hard Luck Hank User:Tokyogirl79 08:20, 7 June 2016 (UTC) delete I can't find anything to suggest that Campbell is notable either. Sometimes authors can achieve independent notability even if their body of work fails NBOOK, but this isn't one of those cases. It looks like the only coverage he's received in RS has been the SF Signal interview. Everything else has been primary or in |self-published sources like blogs and the like, not in any place that Wikipedia would consider reliable Deletion of Hard Luck Hank WP:SPS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6443 2381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bojo User:Dustimagic 19:40, 7 March 2006 (UTC) delete per nom, Deletion of Bojo WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
6444 15304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National Portrait Gallery copyright conflicts [[User talk:Jennavecia|Lara]] 20:23, 29 July 2009 (UTC) delete per nom and others. This isn't notable, we're |not news. Wikinews covers it. Let it stand there. And this is a BLP issue, as the editor is named Deletion of National Portrait Gallery copyright conflicts WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6445 11800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Road FC User:Papaursa 16:52, 8 October 2011 (UTC) delete """New MMA organization whose admitted purpose is to train Korean MMA fighters for bigger things. They just put on their 4th show last weekend (article claims they've done """"numerous events""""). No indication of notable fighters, lacks good reliable sources, and doesn't seem to meet the criteria in . Apparently an earlier version of this article was PRODed in May""" Deletion of Road FC WP:MMANOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6446 11633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of HD DVD releases (2nd nomination) User:FOARP 15:45, 19 December 2018 (UTC) delete Indiscriminate, no Deletion of List of HD DVD releases (2nd nomination) WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
6447 4907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Hunt User:Wisdom89 21:38, 25 March 2008 (UTC) delete If an actor doesn't even appear on imbd (not that this is the best meter stick), there is some questionable notability a foot. I can't find any reliable sources detailing anything, so, as it stands, this is a failure to meet Deletion of Daniel Hunt WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6448 9592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip F. Deaver User:David 04:00, 14 November 2007 (UTC) comment It probably doesn't bear on whether this should be deleted, but nominator David Shankbone violated procedure by nominating this article a second time for . Once an article has been prodded and the prod removed, it is no longer an eligible candidate for the prod process. This should be taken into account when reading the exchange above in which Shankbone berates a contributor for removing the second prod Deletion of Philip F. Deaver WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
6449 10172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Musical instruments from The Legend of Zelda series User:Paddy 03:29, 4 March 2008 (UTC) delete no sources and #GAMEGUIDE Deletion of Musical instruments from The Legend of Zelda series WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6450 5685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deadly Medicine User:Qworty 22:58, 27 April 2013 (UTC) delete Just because a book is a bestseller doesn't mean it's going to meet . It might not pass , no matter how many copies were sold. However, a book that sold very poorly might have lots and lots of that satisfy . Notability for books is never based on sales alone. It's based on significant independent multiple coverage. Same notability standards as for any article on Wikipedia. Simple enough, huh Deletion of Deadly Medicine WP:BK||WP:42||WP:RS||WP:42 Wikipedia:Notability 77
6451 12410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caste-based prostitution user:Andrew 08:15, 29 May 2020 (UTC) keep The nominator does not want the page deleted and there's no reason to do so. The topic is clearly notable (e.g. https://theweek.com/articles/760001/how-caste-system-forces-women-into-prostitution; https://www.nytimes.com/2004/04/11/international/asia/caste-system-binds-nepalese-prostitutes.html; https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=oLWGAwAAQBAJ&pg=PA88) and the rest is then a matter of ordinary editing per ; and Deletion of Caste-based prostitution WP:ATD||WP:IMPERFECT||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
6452 21215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sa'id ibn Zayd User:Irishpunktom 21:24, 18 March 2006 (UTC) keep """Jersey Devils Crusade is a breach of |policy. """" Simply """"sister of Umar"""""""" - Simply a member of one of the most important families in world history.. what a ridiculous reason to out up an AFD""" Deletion of Sa'id ibn Zayd WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
6453 1215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Older Parthenon User:Akhilleus 16:05, 1 July 2007 (UTC) keep This should be a sub-article of Parthenon, in accordance with |summary style Deletion of Older Parthenon WP:SS Wikipedia:Summary style 34
6454 18794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blackjack Parsons User:SRX 16:30, 25 December 2008 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Blackjack Parsons WP:N||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6455 684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brothers Under the Bridge User:Esradekan 12:55, 17 July 2008 (UTC) delete all, fails notability per #Songs Deletion of Brothers Under the Bridge WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6456 19706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Veloes User:Angryapathy 16:38, 5 January 2010 (UTC) delete Another band that fails Deletion of The Veloes WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
6457 13074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alcides Moreno (2nd nomination) User:Redfarmer 15:59, 31 May 2009 (UTC) delete I still agree with my original assertion that this was . No evidence since has been presented that would suggest otherwise Deletion of Alcides Moreno (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6458 8422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shahbal User:The 22:34, 31 July 2007 (UTC) keep It defintely needs some |reliable sources to |verify its factuality, but it does appears quite |notable. Find sources and then I believe it falls under the laws of inclusion. Not that they are really laws, but just policy. Ahhh, you get my point Deletion of Shahbal WP:RS||WP:VERI||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6459 19323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Browning (YouTuber) User:Devonian 07:46, 30 June 2020 (UTC) keep first of all, the keep votes above do nothing but ramble on in the vein of and and make no claim to notability, but I do think this guy passes GNG. He has received significant coverage in numerous sources, such as: https://screenrant.com/youtuber-hacks-scammers/ YouTuber Breaks The Law To Protect People From Scammers, https://www.cbsnews.com/news/robocall-revenge-meet-the-techies-taking-down-scammers/ Robocall revenge: Meet the techies turning the tables on scammers, and https://news.avclub.com/tech-scammers-try-to-rip-off-hacker-get-their-cctv-cam-1842091672 Tech scammers try to rip off hacker, get their CCTV cameras and computers hacked in response, in addition to the sources brought up by Blake Gripling which easily assuage any BLP1E problems. These sources are enough to pass GNG Deletion of Jim Browning (YouTuber) WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6460 265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people speculated to have been syphilitic (2nd nomination) User:SkierRMH 09:19, 13 January 2007 (UTC) delete Speculated!!, by whom? The only way this list could be populated is by speculation, , , and violations Deletion of List of people speculated to have been syphilitic (2nd nomination) WP:POV||WP:OR||WP:V Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
6461 7310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Barnett (video game designer) user:H3llkn0wz 08:09, 18 October 2011 (UTC) keep per sources by Odie5533; cannot see how this does not pass . — Deletion of Paul Barnett (video game designer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6462 12057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of decision software User:Stuartyeates 10:27, 15 September 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of List of decision software WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6463 21079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elon Bomani User:Adolphus79 14:18, 19 March 2009 (UTC) delete """I just did a bit of cleanup on this article, and it does has a number of claims that hint at notability, but it needs a lot of work... as far as the provided links go, the Blacknews.com link is a self released press release (read: advertisement), the JET article makes her out to be more of a landlord than anything, and the Essence link provides only a teaser about 4 different women... there are no references provided for anything other than she has authored 2 books, is a landlord with a million dollars worth of property, and is """"creator of Bomani's Village Enterprises""""... no references for childhood or education, and no concrete proof of notability... being the CEO of a company does not automatically allow someone to pass , and as an author, I'm not 100% sure she passes either... She claims to have written a handful of books, but there is no mention of how successful those books were, nor how successful her company was... the concerns bother me also... unless references are added to prove why she passes the notability concerns, I'm leaning towards delete for now""" Deletion of Elon Bomani WP:N||WP:CREATIVE||WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6464 1916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Edwards (Australian footballer) User:GiantSnowman 17:56, 13 September 2013 (UTC) delete fails and . Coverage is not significant, relates to his famous dad and the fact he has signed for a club Deletion of Ryan Edwards (Australian footballer) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6465 6810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camp Eagle Hill User:Corpx 03:46, 5 September 2007 (UTC) delete per lack of |significant coverage from |independent sources Deletion of Camp Eagle Hill WP:NOTE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6466 15550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Formula One driver numbers User:Joseph2302 22:34, 25 February 2016 (UTC) keep It's a new concept, but it's widely commented on in |reliable sources. The prose IMO is good, as it highlights how/why different numbers are used, although it needs to be sourced Deletion of List of Formula One driver numbers WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6467 19567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mass Effect: Paragon Lost User:Rushyo 16:47, 25 May 2012 (UTC) delete with Mass Effect (series) per below. Fails . There's not enough information available to even begin justifying the article Deletion of Mass Effect: Paragon Lost WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6468 6075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/InDplay NONE NONE delete as David'''can'''""" 18.02, 29 Mayıs 2020 (UTC) delete Daha çok genç, yolun başında bir yazar göründüğü kadarıyla. Şimdiden basında bir miktar yer edinmiş fakat henüz kriterlerini karşılamıyor görünmekte. --Kullanıcı mesaj:Justinianus|'''justinianus Beyza Alkoç'un silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
6588 14467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evan Auyang User:Kraxler 16:35, 13 July 2015 (UTC) delete no claim of notability in the article, only trivial mentions in the sources. Subject seems to be striving hard to get some attention, but fails Deletion of Evan Auyang WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6589 4346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tilly Keeper User:AnemoneProjectors 09:47, 22 April 2016 (UTC) delete actually having read some of the other comments, I realise she fails as the sources are discussing the character rather than the actress. If she passes GNG and ENT in the future, the article can be written then Deletion of Tilly Keeper WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6590 14639 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas """"The Tank"""" Brooks""" User:danntm 20:21, 23 August 2006 (UTC) delete no sufficient assertion of notability, I agree with nom that this is likely """Deletion of Thomas """"The Tank"""" Brooks""" WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
6591 16500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rahul Kumar Pandey User:AngusMEOW 13:03, 18 September 2020 (UTC) delete """All the references are spam because there is no editor name mentioned. All of it says """"Partnered Content"""". Fails . The keep votes are from the socks, I have already reported them for SPI. This needs to be deleted""" Deletion of Rahul Kumar Pandey WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6592 7295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative Analysis - The Fourth Amendment User:Fan 16:18, 5 August 2006 (UTC) delete """original research, total violation of . Author has attempted to float a proposal, Wikipedia:New proposal for alternative analysis, to turn Wikipedia into a blog for people to float their personal """"analysis"""" of subjects. The response, on Wikipedia talk:New proposal for alternative analysis|the proposal's talk page, is 100% negative. Get a freewebs or blogspot page""" Deletion of Alternative Analysis - The Fourth Amendment WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6593 7854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D. F. Lewis User:Colapeninsula 10:53, 11 September 2017 (UTC) delete Does not meet or . He has some coverage in the world of small press publication (blogs and private websites as well as print), and has himself been published extensively in small press and self-published format as well as some stories in anthologies from bigger publishers. But that is not sufficient: there's a lack of reviews or other critical commentary in |reliable sources (which would include newspapers, magazines from major publishers, academic sources, independent websites with a proper editorial structure, etc), no evidence of major awards, and no indication of importance outside of a small, self-regarding world. Nemonymous should also be considered for deletion for its lack of coverage by independent third parties Deletion of D. F. Lewis WP:AUTHOR||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6594 9350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Non-disney villains User:Edison 18:22, 5 January 2010 (UTC) delete """Unencyclopedic categorization of exclusion. Fails |notability and OT|not an indiscriminate collection of information. The recentism of the list could be fixed by adding older cartoon villains such as Wile E. Coyote from the Roadrunner cartoons, Bluto from Popeye|Popeye the Sailor, """"Dr. Claw"""" from Inspector Gadget, """"Gargamel"""" from the Smurfs, """"Dishonest John"""" from Beany and Cecil,"""" """"Dudley Nightshade"""" from Crusader Rabbit, and """"Crabby Appleton"""" from Tom Terrific , but it would still be a bizarre partitioning of the cartoon villain universe. (See comment following""" Deletion of Non-disney villains WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6595 18892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Richards User:Sparklism 20:34, 11 August 2010 (UTC) keep Nicely summed up above, meets #1 through independent coverage. '''sparkl Deletion of Craig Richards WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6596 6895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kovacs method - Iteratively eliminating range voting User:Bfigura 04:07, 26 April 2009 (UTC) delete as |original research Deletion of Kovacs method - Iteratively eliminating range voting WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
6597 15263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ray Cowdery User:Icewhiz 06:45, 16 April 2018 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass GNG. Doesn't pass - I do not see significant coverage of the works, and the citation counts of his works are in the single digits per title on scholar Deletion of Ray Cowdery WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
6598 16380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Moore (wide receiver) User:Racepacket 15:17, 3 December 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Michael Moore (wide receiver) WP:ATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
6599 1408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Taylor (entrepreneur) User:The 16:11, 20 March 2018 (UTC) keep as subject seems to (barely) meet . We probably need criteria specifically for business people and entrepreneurs Deletion of Jeff Taylor (entrepreneur) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6600 15142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manama incident User:Ioeth 20:53, 31 August 2010 (UTC) delete per the nominators analysis and Deletion of Manama incident WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6601 19742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yaw Osei-Owusu User:Bearian 14:25, 21 April 2020 (UTC) delete per above. Total fail of . No touring, no contracts, no singles, no albums, no Grammy, no |coverage. Totally |run of the mill. If this were 2008, |we could understand a fan writing this, but it's 2020, and everybody knows that not every musician |gets a free page hosted on Wikipedia Deletion of Yaw Osei-Owusu WP:MUSICBIO||WP:SIGCOV||WP:MILL||WP:AGF||WP:NOTWEBHOST Wikipedia:Notability 77
6602 21634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tin Pei Ling User:RayAYang 01:02, 6 May 2011 (UTC) keep Sufficient media attention, meets Deletion of Tin Pei Ling WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6603 20401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ann Walker (died 1854) User:GretLomborg 05:36, 17 July 2017 (UTC) comment I am leaning delete. Are there any better sources about this woman? The only source listed is a blog that appears to be itself sourced directly from a primary-source diary. This seems a case where applies Deletion of Ann Walker (died 1854) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6604 15456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avinash Chiranjeev User:Xxanthippe 22:57, 15 May 2013 (UTC) delete 4 cites on GS for his work. Not enough. No sign of passing any of rof Deletion of Avinash Chiranjeev WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
6605 21448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reid W. Barton User:Sławomir 12:55, 1 July 2010 (UTC) keep """The appropriate test for inclusion seems not to be , but rather in this case : """"If a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to satisfy the inclusion criteria for a stand-alone article."""" The exposee in ''Science'' on the subject of the article easily meets these requirements. In addition, the subject seems to be clearly of essential interest to those researching mathematics competitions, as he is the first-ever four-time IMO gold medalist, and one of only seven people ever to achieve the maximum number of wins in the Putnam""" Deletion of Reid W. Barton WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6606 5955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jerkcity User:BradBeattie 07:02, 1 November 2006 (UTC) comment I brought it to AFD as I honestly believe it comes close to #A7, which states that an article is subject to speedy deletion if it ''does not assert the importance or significance of its subject. If the assertion is controversial or there has been a previous AfD, the article should be nominated for AfD instead Deletion of Jerkcity WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
6607 17680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twirley chassey User:Brewcrewer 14:12, 1 February 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Twirley chassey WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6608 21840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silex Flash CMS User:Werner 03:30, 16 January 2010 (UTC) keep per significant coverage in the available |RS, which demonstrates |notability Deletion of Silex Flash CMS WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6609 1857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011 Michigan vs. Notre Dame football game User:Paulmcdonald 22:02, 4 April 2012 (UTC) keep I'm quite sure that enough sources exist to more than surpass for inclusion of this article. I'll grant that they should be added to the article, but that is a content/editing issue and not a deletion issue Deletion of 2011 Michigan vs. Notre Dame football game WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6610 9392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prof. Hari Govind Choudhary User:Msnicki 21:12, 5 February 2015 (UTC) delete Lacks even a single reliable independent secondary source to establish notability as required by and completely fails to assert any possible reason why the subject might be considered notable even in lieu of sources under . Though not by itself a reason to delete, I note that the article appears to be an utobiography by an and that an earlier was contested by an IP editor, also an , quite possibly the same individual Deletion of Prof. Hari Govind Choudhary WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO||WP:A||WP:SPA||WP:PROD||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Notability 77
6611 21333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergei Markedonov User:Eric 01:00, 27 June 2009 (UTC) keep Whether the subject passes or not may be irrelevant in this case. I think it is hard to argue that the subject does not pass , given the subject’s http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=Sergei-Markedonov news coverage Deletion of Sergei Markedonov WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6612 21732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional books within the Discworld series [[User talk:63.3.19.130|talk]]) 05:08, 4 July 2011 (UTC) keep merge, or transwiki and redirect. Afdcruft. With common sense|verifiability due to the easily available references of the book series itself, the content is unoriginal research at best. The content itself could be improved with reception. Thus, the list meets the criteria of |appropriate topics for lists. Besides this, there are likely reliable secondary sources that cover these fictional books that figure into a major well-known series to presume that they meet the |general notability guideline or that the list topic has been discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources to presume that it is appropriate per the criteria of |notability for stand-alone lists. This article is a necessary split of ''Discworld'' and a needed |content fork for those interested in this notable series. Also, the list falls into what Wikipedia is by being a discriminate collection of information, so I, the article's authors, and those who come here looking for this information believe that it has a place in Wikipedia. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/63.3.19.130|63.3.19.130 Deletion of List of fictional books within the Discworld series WP:V||WP:SALAT||WP:GNG||WP:LISTN||WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6613 8872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gilmore Community School User:Noroton 21:34, 14 February 2008 (UTC) merge as per and as cited by Sting au. Cite enough and maybe it will become ''de facto'' policy Deletion of Gilmore Community School WP:N||WP:SCHOOLS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6614 16494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Britton Buchanan User:Snickers2686 19:02, 4 June 2018 (UTC) keep Meets . May be justified once other content is added. It's a work in progress Deletion of Britton Buchanan WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6615 16657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shuja Hyder User:J04n 22:33, 6 February 2016 (UTC) keep as the performer on multiple TV show soundtrack I believe the subject of this |BLP easily meets criterion 10 of |MUSICBIO. Two of these performances are supported by the citations on the page Deletion of Shuja Hyder WP:BLP||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6616 6429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Kraft User:Truth 11:06, 24 August 2014 (UTC) delete Teasing out the academic impact is made a bit harder as there is an homonym working at the Mayo Clinic and University of Minnesota, but the impact seems short of rof in any case. Going five SERPs deep, I could not find evidence satisfying either; some talks, but no about the subject Deletion of Daniel Kraft WP:P||WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Portal 85
6617 3218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Little Yay User:Bakazaka 07:06, 16 August 2018 (UTC) delete WP:COI and issues, repeated recreation after admin intervention, not to mention that the article creator blanked the AfD nominator's user page Deletion of Little Yay WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6618 13180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Till the End of Time (Mariah Carey song) User:Esradekan 08:02, 16 February 2009 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability per #Songs Deletion of Till the End of Time (Mariah Carey song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6619 5337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Md. Ziaul Haque User:Binksternet 23:42, 26 May 2014 (UTC) delete per . Not notable Deletion of Md. Ziaul Haque WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6620 16345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeleGate (networking) (2nd nomination) User:Dialectric 14:12, 16 September 2015 (UTC) delete Software article of unclear notability, lacking independent references. Previous afd turned no RS refs, just a list of links to others using the software. My more recent search turned up no significant coverage. It is possible Japanese-language coverage exists, but unless it is provided, there is no indication of notability Deletion of DeleGate (networking) (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6621 446 [[Unternehmensgruppe Schwabenverlag]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Dealerofsalvation NONE keep Kasten| Nicht einziger, aber stichfestester Grund: „Als relevant gelten Verlage … die als Zeitungs- oder Zeitschriftenverlag … mindestens drei relevante periodisch erscheinende Publikationen verlegen oder verlegt haben“. Zum Lemma: #Unternehmen|„Unternehmensname möglichst ohne Rechtsform und Namensanhängsel Löschung von Unternehmensgruppe Schwabenverlag Wikipedia:NK Wikipedia:Article titles 75
6622 10336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1898 Cowell User:Praemonitus 19:22, 3 April 2015 (UTC) merge per . No suitable references found Deletion of 1898 Cowell WP:NASTRO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6623 12558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alapaha Blue Blood Bulldog (2nd nomination) User:FOARP 07:32, 13 September 2019 (UTC) keep Apparent failure of . See following sources: https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=V7HDzKXAk2YC&pg=PA86&dq=%22Alapaha+Blue+Blood+Bulldog%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjMh6mLos3kAhWPasAKHc1_CxoQ6AEIVzAJ#v=onepage&q=%22Alapaha%20Blue%20Blood%20Bulldog%22&f=false 1 https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=9dcAAQAAQBAJ&pg=PA88&dq=%22Alapaha+Blue+Blood+Bulldog%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjMh6mLos3kAhWPasAKHc1_CxoQ6AEIUTAI#v=onepage&q=%22Alapaha%20Blue%20Blood%20Bulldog%22&f=false 2 https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=hz9WeFoj1pIC&pg=PT66&dq=%22Alapaha+Blue+Blood+Bulldog%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjMh6mLos3kAhWPasAKHc1_CxoQ6AEIRzAG#v=onepage&q=%22Alapaha%20Blue%20Blood%20Bulldog%22&f=false 3. Dorling Kindersley (publisher of the first two) is a reputable publisher, the third is harder to identify but at least has an ISBN Deletion of Alapaha Blue Blood Bulldog (2nd nomination) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6624 5929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erika Tymrak User:Dirtlawyer1 12:41, 23 October 2010 (UTC) delete Subject player is not a professional, has not played for a senior U.S. national team, and is no more or less notable than several of her current Florida Gators teammates. If she were a first-team All-American in her sport, I believe a case could be made under the general notability standards . . . but not yet Deletion of Erika Tymrak WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6625 5663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Four (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 05:37, 3 September 2010 (UTC) keep """and expand as release draws near. Or at the least, |userfy to its author for continued work away from mainspace. To respectfully disagree with the nominator, is being inapproproiately applied, as it specifically allows that """"| it ''is'' appropriate to report discussion and arguments about the prospects for success of future proposals and projects or whether some development will occur, if discussion is properly referenced""" Deletion of Four (film) WP:USERFY||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:CBALL Wikipedia:Userfication 87
6626 417 [[Babyzeichen]] (erl. bleibt) Benutzer:KaiMartin 17:14, 18. Sep. 2009 (CEST) comment Ohne belastbare Quellen aus der passenden Fachrichtung bleibt der Verdacht der |Theoriefindung beziehungsweise Begriffsetablierung. Es gibt auf dem Gebiet zu viele Dampfplauderer, als dass man jede öffentliche Äußerung als Quellenangabe nehmen könnte. Daher für den Nachweis, dass der Begriff in der Entwicklungspsychologie in der angegebenen Weise verwendet wird Löschung von Babyzeichen Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
6627 2351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The blackmarket kidney User:Bfigura 05:08, 30 April 2008 (UTC) delete Again, notable topic, and I'd suggest merging some of the info. But since it's not really apparent what references back up what statement, it's probably worth just deletiing this |synthetic |essay Deletion of The blackmarket kidney WP:SYNTH||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
6628 13546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Counterattack User:TallNapoleon 00:42, 10 October 2008 (UTC) comment I absolutely agree that the concept is notable. However, my fear is that any article that was sufficiently general would be a dictdef, and any that wasn't would be too focused on particular things. That said this should probably be closed per Deletion of Counterattack WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
6629 13895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aetolia, the Midnight Age User:Gary 14:50, 20 October 2006 (UTC) keep though meatpuppets/single-purpose accounts have attempted to sway this AfD, the article seems quite detailed. Note I have removed many of the external links: |Wikipedia is not a respoitory of links Deletion of Aetolia, the Midnight Age WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6630 15060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fred Cornforth User:KidAd 00:02, 9 April 2021 (UTC) keep """Article has existed for less than a day, but fine. Per , """"The following are presumed to be notable: {{tq|Politicians and judges who have held international, national, or (for countries with federal or similar systems of government) '''state/province–wide office'''}}. As the chair of a major party at the state-wide level, this individual meets """ Deletion of Fred Cornforth WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6631 14427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gyeonggi Suwon International School User:Winged 03:29, 22 April 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Gyeonggi Suwon International School WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6632 15257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Odrasoft User:AllyD 07:23, 11 November 2015 (UTC) delete Note that there is a Polish software consultancy of the same name http://www.odrasoft.pl/, established in 2010. As to this more recent Indian web development firm, searches provide no |evidence of |notability. At most it appears to be a firm going about establishing its business. Given the lack of claim to notability in the article (once the peacockery copied from their website was removed), I am also flagging this as CSD A7 Deletion of Odrasoft :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6633 5945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lokalise User:4meter4 12:08, 23 September 2019 (UTC) delete fails to meet the criteria at and Deletion of Lokalise WP:NSOFT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6634 15171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shelton Intermediate School (Connecticut) User:Coccyx 16:09, 28 May 2008 (UTC) keep per the changes made to the article, I believe the current sources confer notability and satisfy guidelines Deletion of Shelton Intermediate School (Connecticut) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6635 142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denzil Connick user:Andrew 17:52, 14 February 2021 (UTC) keep WP:SOLDIER is an essay with no official standing or consensus support. The nomination's claim that the subject does not pass the is false Deletion of Denzil Connick WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6636 12077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timeline-191 User:Shooterwalker 21:36, 12 March 2011 (UTC) comment my first preference is still for deletion. I don't think a rewrite makes sense here as I'm not sure we'd be talking about the same article or topic anymore. But if it will help to produce a consensus, I'll add my support to a rewrite if it will get this article in line with policy, especially #PLOT, by making it substantially more about the development and reception of the series and not just a plot summary Deletion of Timeline-191 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6637 18255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K-267 (Kansas highway) User:Imzadi1979 03:11, 24 September 2012 (UTC) keep state highways have generally been considered notable, based on past precedents at , /P and the proposed . The article is new enough that it hasn't had time to develop, and giving that time would not harm the encyclopedia. However, deleting a portion of the encyclopedia's complete coverage of state highways in Kansas, leaving a hole in that coverage, would harm the encyclopedia Deletion of K-267 (Kansas highway) WP:ROADOUTCOMES||WP:USRD||WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
6638 20031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taylor Behl User:Rosemaryamey 03:31, 10 February 2007 (UTC) keep """meets |criteria for notability, i.e. """"The person has been a primary subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the person""" Deletion of Taylor Behl WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6639 1242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samples of sans serif typefaces User:Batard0 07:48, 20 October 2012 (UTC) keep This is a list, and thus should be titled '''List of sans serif typefaces'''. As a list, it clearly meets . These typefaces have been treated ''as a group'' in multiple books, like http://books.google.ae/books?id=FUXhAAAAMAAJ&q=sans+serif+typefaces&dq=sans+serif+typefaces&source=bl&ots=HknH9SacoQ&sig=6Q7GGRmaOON0_wCxt7jk4qexStI&hl=en&sa=X&ei=Q1aCUKLeE8TKrAeliYHQCg&ved=0CC4Q6AEwAQ this one and http://books.google.ae/books?id=FiJ87ixLs0sC&pg=PA324&lpg=PA324&dq=sans+serif+typefaces&source=bl&ots=iIl6h5Ol9o&sig=wkGRsFS3ttzQcryfhOErITRyo0Y&hl=en&sa=X&ei=Q1aCUKLeE8TKrAeliYHQCg&ved=0CFwQ6AEwCQ#v=onepage&q=sans%20serif%20typefaces&f=false this one. The inclusion criteria are sufficiently clear and narrow from the title. Could be merged into List of typefaces if that seems more prudent, but given the potential size of this list it may be better to put a sampling of typefaces in the List of typefaces article and have separate ones for the various kinds of typefaces that are more comprehensive Deletion of Samples of sans serif typefaces WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
6640 12144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MyAnimeList (3rd nomination) User:Dream 07:24, 6 January 2010 (UTC) keep Its Alexa rankings does hint at its notability. It has over 1.3 million hits when I search for its name on Google. That many people talking about it, and Alexa proving that massive number of people regularly go to it, make the website quite notable. Over 200,000 people have used their forum! I don't care what the constantly changing suggested guidelines say, since they were passed by a very small number of people, without the vast majority of Wikipedia editors ever noticing. Wikipedia is not a set of rules, you suppose to use common sense, that a founding principle. A website should be considered notable if a hell of a lot of people use it Deletion of MyAnimeList (3rd nomination) WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
6641 15375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shannon Saunders User:Qwfp 16:44, 23 August 2014 (UTC) keep Meets & #1 as a //www.google.co.uk/search?q=%22shannon+saunders%22+disney+wiltshire+-wikipedia suitable search finds significant coverage in independent reliable sources including BBC News http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-wiltshire-15247558, the ''Gazette and Herald'' http://www.gazetteandherald.co.uk/news/headlines/9213058.Disney_girl___s_top_for_trees/ and the ''Wiltshire and Gloucestershire Standard'' http://www.wiltsglosstandard.co.uk/news/8401672.Wiltshire_singing_sensation_wins_top_Disney_talent_show Deletion of Shannon Saunders WP:BASIC||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6642 5665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Born for This (Paramore song) User:SkierRMH 21:39, 23 October 2007 (UTC) delete fails #Songs|Song notability on all five points Deletion of Born for This (Paramore song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6643 10207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Alfieri User:4meter4 09:14, 24 October 2019 (UTC) delete In terms of what is in the article rather than searching, does not meet the criteria at (in response to Deletion of Alex Alfieri WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6644 191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Blasey User:Dylanfromthenorth 08:17, 20 October 2010 (UTC) merge as per nom and Deletion of Scott Blasey WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
6645 21112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Free Melania (2nd nomination) User:Pharaoh 21:57, 3 July 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Free Melania (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NOTGOSSIP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6646 2735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Venezuelan British User:Guest9999 08:57, 25 December 2008 (UTC) delete """there are clearly people who have links to both Venezuala and Britain but I don't see there being any evidence of """"Venezuelan British"""" being a noted or accepted term for such a group - or any coverage detailing the group (its history, culture, etc.). Barring any evidence of |reliable sources covering the group (that amount to more than a numerical statistic in a survey) I do not see how an article is possible. Wikipedia is not a publisher of #OR|original work, if no one else has written about the group we cannot |cobble together a piece that identifies them as one""" Deletion of Venezuelan British WP:RS||WP:NOT||WP:SYN Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6647 9994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of skateboarders User:Mitaphane 06:31, 7 February 2007 (UTC) delete """per #IINFO and nom. Perhaps a list of just Pro Skateboaders would be good, however adding """"notable"""" skateboarders to the list turns it into a unmanageable mess""" Deletion of List of skateboarders WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6648 21816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aziz Shavershian (2nd nomination) User:MelbourneStar 22:15, 24 March 2012 (UTC) keep I won't write an essay as to why this article should ''obviously'' be kept, however that said, this article satisfies ; according to sources has merits to pass (#2) - and those news sources have given him overwhelming coverage, and ultimately wp:n|notability. It's one event - minus the videos; the drug story prior death; bodybuilding; cult following; book; protein line; webseries, and so on Deletion of Aziz Shavershian (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NMODEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6649 396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Washington Tower User:Hirolovesswords 06:25, 23 December 2014 (UTC) delete Fails . Has not received significant coverage in independent sources Deletion of George Washington Tower WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6650 3571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guardians of Ga'Hoole Book 15: The War of the Ember NONE NONE delete fails Deletion of Guardians of Ga'Hoole Book 15: The War of the Ember WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
6651 13159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonas Paul Eyewear User:HighKing 12:12, 1 October 2020 (UTC) delete I agree with above, none of the references meet the criteria. Also I am unable to locate any |significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, references to date fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic therefore fails GNG/ Deletion of Jonas Paul Eyewear WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6652 7926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Operation Tight Screw (4th nomination) User:Strikerforce 18:16, 8 August 2018 (UTC) delete and consider |salting. How did this get through the first AfD discussion? Entirely speculative, not enough coverage that meets |RS. |NOTNEWS applies, in my view Deletion of Operation Tight Screw (4th nomination) WP:SALT||WP:RS||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
6653 10227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IVVVO User:WikiDan61 14:03, 11 March 2015 (UTC) keep and improve. The article contains some spammy language about IVVVO's label Terrain Ahead, but that can be fixed. It also contains poor sourcing, but I believe a Google search will turn up more sourcing to indicate that this artist is, indeed, |notable, having been the subject of multiple independent stories Deletion of IVVVO WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6654 15574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Jenjira Ploy-angunsri User:Paul 01:12, 26 July 2018 (UTC) comment No opposition to redirecting for now, provided it is done ''without prejudice'' to a proper article being written in the future. This was among the most high-profile cases in 1990s Thailand, and has generated plenty of coverage, decades later. This is a content issue, not an AfD one. Also, please re-read Deletion of Murder of Jenjira Ploy-angunsri WP:LASTING||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6655 8864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Insoumise User:Bearcat 14:42, 9 October 2020 (UTC) delete """As noted, independent bookstores aren't automatically notable just because they exist — it's certainly possible for an independent bookstore to clear the bar if it has enough |reliable source coverage about it to pass , but that hasn't been shown here: of the five weblinks being shown as sources, three are Blogspot blogs and one is an archived e-mail message on a listserv, none of which are reliable or notability-supporting sources — and while one citation is to a real newspaper article, one of those is not enough all by itself. And on a ProQuest search for older sourcing that may not Google, I got absolutely nothing useful: even searching """"Insoumise Montreal"""" to filter out hits on La France Insoumise, I got just 21 hits of which about half were ''still'' about La France Insoumise rather than this, and the ones that ''were'' about this were just glancing namechecks of its existence (e.g. as a film screening venue in the movie listings) rather than notability-building coverage. And while the French article has a couple more sources than ours does, it still depends mainly on unreliable sources and student media rather than strong coverage — only one footnote (''La Presse'') that could be copied over from there actually meets a GNG-worthy standard, and even two newspaper articles still isn't enough""" Deletion of Insoumise WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6656 5638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karen Jessica Evans User:Bri 02:41, 30 May 2018 (UTC) delete """Certainly not a notable motorcyclist by any standard ever used for a bio known at ikiProject Motorcycling. Her name moniker """"Goth Girl"""" appears once in """"The 1%er Encyclopedia"""" and maybe she was in a documentary (we aren't sure about this even) ... no go. So, since it is also clearly failing , this is a delete""" Deletion of Karen Jessica Evans WP:W||WP:NCREATIVE Help:Watchlist 110
6657 14899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wheelchair Organizations User:Eaolson 01:05, 30 November 2006 (UTC) delete While this article may be useful if you're looking for organizations, it's not ''encyclopedic''. |WP is not the yellow pages. There's no assertion of notability for this collection of organizations, nor is there one for the individual orgs Deletion of Wheelchair Organizations WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6658 13217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Turaga (Bionicle) (2nd nomination) User:Stifle 19:38, 13 May 2008 (UTC) delete Because the article does not include |citations from |reliable sources, it does not appear to be in compliance with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Turaga (Bionicle) (2nd nomination) WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6659 9342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joanna Clapps Herman User:Guillaume2303 16:25, 6 July 2012 (UTC) delete """I agree with Agricola44 that this does not meet or . Whether or not this is """"eligible for a stub"""" is not a valid question: a stub is just an article waiting to be expanded (not a short article on borderline notable subjects), so our notability guidelines apply to stubs in the same way as to longer articles""" Deletion of Joanna Clapps Herman WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6660 17965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Koehler User:Blue 11:57, 7 August 2021 (UTC) delete per nom. I ran his professional name through a search and got only fan sites, blogs, and event listings. These generally don't meet for reliable independent coverage as the content is self-generated with no fact checking or editorial oversite Deletion of Jim Koehler WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6661 194 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Kurtuluş Yolu Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 06:52, 31 Ağustos 2014 (UTC) comment KD olduğunu düşünen arkadaşlar, bu kanıya hangi kriterleri göz önüne alarak vardıklarını belirtebilir mi? İlgili kriterler |burada Kurtuluş Yolu'nun silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
6662 4013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Pérez II User:David 22:47, 7 April 2015 (UTC) delete Assistant professors are usually to pass and I can see no evidence that he is exceptional in this respect. The article says only that he has published some things and won student and emerging-academic awards, none of which is sufficient Deletion of David Pérez II WP:TOOSOON||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
6663 14326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kanta Gupta User:David 17:10, 13 August 2017 (UTC) keep """FRSC is a clear pass of #C3 and her distinguished professor title is a clear pass of #C5. """"Death date not included"""" is an invalid reason for deletion, justifying a speedy keep. And the rest of the nomination statement makes clear that the nominator hasn't even considered , the appropriate notability guideline (not GNG) for this sort of case""" Deletion of Kanta Gupta WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6664 9840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashkenazi Jewish intelligence (2nd nomination) User:K 17:02, 12 October 2020 (UTC) delete per unclear notability, as well as . The article is mostly , tying together tangentially related bits of information to, apparently, promote a fringe theory Deletion of Ashkenazi Jewish intelligence (2nd nomination) WP:TNT||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
6665 18851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LU:KUS User:Asdklf 20:50, 1 September 2014 (UTC) delete just , they are still rookies so maybe later on, but as of now it cannot stand Deletion of LU:KUS WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
6666 19089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Gilly User:Xxanthippe 23:33, 31 October 2019 (UTC) keep GS citations pass rof#1. Nominator is urged to carry out efore in future Deletion of William Gilly WP:P||WP:B Wikipedia:Portal 85
6667 21236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of former Nestlé brands User:Peter 22:12, 15 May 2013 (UTC) keep or '''merge to List of Nestlé brands''' if too short for a separate list) - this meets as most brand names link to articles, and there's useful information that couldn't be included in a category Deletion of List of former Nestlé brands WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
6668 339 [[Christian Kallinger]] (LAE) Benutzer:AntonMüllerMeier NONE keep Kasten|, erfüllt die #Sportler|Sportler-RK; 1. Meister auf nationaler Ebene, 2. Weltmeister, 3. Einsatz in der Nationalmannschaft Löschung von Christian Kallinger Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
6669 15282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Da GV User:Stifle 15:32, 27 January 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Da GV WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
6670 8556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giovanni Navarria User:Movementarian 09:29, 15 December 2005 (UTC) delete """fails to meet criteria of . Generates 363 Google results http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Giovanni+Navarria%22&btnG=Google+Search. His """"claim to fame"""" aapears to be a paper published on OpenDemocracy.net http://www.opendemocracy.net/democracy-edemocracy/internet_china_2945.jsp""" Deletion of Giovanni Navarria WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6671 16882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noah Kirkman User:Metropolitan90 22:54, 28 May 2010 (UTC) delete per nom. This article appears to be a |one-sided description of a controversy involving a living person. The article appears to intrude on the privacy of a minor Deletion of Noah Kirkman WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
6672 12055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1699 Honkasalo User:Praemonitus 17:19, 2 May 2015 (UTC) merge per ; insufficient sources found to demonstrate notability. One photometric study.http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2011MPBu...38...73B Deletion of 1699 Honkasalo WP:DWMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6673 15508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur Rovine User:Beemer69 16:59, 22 June 2018 (UTC) delete Promotional, fueled by primary sources, and fails Deletion of Arthur Rovine WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6674 21289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Coquelin User:Libby 22:53, 30 October 2014 (UTC) keep I've found multiple sources – some in English – with a quick search. He passes |general notability even if the article needs some expansion and possibly help from someone who is a subject specialist so that his theories can be explained Deletion of Charles Coquelin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6675 3371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Highland Hills Mall User:Northamerica1000 05:40, 23 July 2014 (UTC) merge to Kitchener, Ontario as a reasonable Deletion of Highland Hills Mall WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
6676 565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nancy Eberhart User:Coolabahapple 06:32, 18 March 2020 (UTC) delete does not meet , of initial concern was single digit/zero library holdings (via WorldCat ie. https://www.worldcat.org/title/granny-goes-to-the-zoo/oclc/251338051&referer=brief_results ''The Adventures of Granny: Granny Goes to the Zoo'' one library, and a gsearch brings up just the usual book selling sites but |no reviews Deletion of Nancy Eberhart WP:NAUTHOR||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6677 3578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamal Orlando Omar Ibrahim User:GB 01:47, 17 May 2010 (UTC) delete The article has a credible verifiable claim to importance in the article which is all that it takes to fail #a7. That said, I can find nothing to establish notability. The only thing I have found is the Mr. World title with no significant coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Kamal Orlando Omar Ibrahim WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
6678 18666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William F. Vallicella User:Xxanthippe 11:04, 3 December 2009 (UTC) keep Seems not to pass rof #1 on GS cites but eccentric activities make him notable Deletion of William F. Vallicella WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
6679 11993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of shopping malls in Angola user:Andrew 09:50, 20 August 2020 (UTC) keep Contains notable entries, nomination fails , , &c Deletion of List of shopping malls in Angola WP:BEFORE||WP:IGNORINGATD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6680 18484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Digeri Dingo User:Stifle 08:38, 7 October 2008 (UTC) delete as the entire article fails , but '''redirect''' to Taz-Mania Deletion of Digeri Dingo WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6681 5534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ole Miss - Notre Dame football series User:Ad 06:22, 6 March 2014 (UTC) delete The article doesn't seem to meet or . But that is mostly a lack of sources, not inherent non-notability. If someone can find some decent sources I would probably change my mind Deletion of Ole Miss - Notre Dame football series WP:SPORTSEVENT||WP:NRIVALRY Wikipedia:Notability 77
6682 5693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yoni Sherbatov User:Papaursa 02:06, 12 September 2017 (UTC) comment This discussion appears to be attracting new users who don't understand the notability criteria for MMA fighters. Simply being a pro MMA fighter (or any other athlete) is not sufficient to show notability. See for the notability criteria for MMA fighters. They also don't realize that routine sports coverage does not make someone notable Deletion of Yoni Sherbatov WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
6683 17907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sion Eltnam Atlasia User:Collectonian 00:15, 25 January 2008 (UTC) merge to Melty Blood. Fails , has no notability outside of the game and is only seen in that single game. Completely fails the FICT notability standards, and seems to be full of OR and unreferenced information with no real-world notability to back up having her own article Deletion of Sion Eltnam Atlasia WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6684 14701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Takayuki Yanase User:jonny 06:22, 24 November 2007 (UTC) delete The current English article is just a straight translation of the :ja:柳瀬敬之|Japanese Wiki article, which is fine in and of itself. However, Google searching in both http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=takayuki+yanase&btnG=Search English and http://www.google.com/search?q=%E6%9F%B3%E7%80%AC%E6%95%AC%E4%B9%8B&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8 Japanese fails to yield any reliable sources that would indicate notability (although he ''is'' listed on IMDB). Furthermore, the claims raised in the article do not satisfy the criteria of , as he is only a minor contributor to the shows he's worked on Deletion of Takayuki Yanase WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6685 6086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guinn Run User:Colonel 11:09, 11 January 2012 (UTC) keep This and other locations at the battle of Gettysburg are documented in numerous works such as ''http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=qVIYrZ3MnYsC Gettysburg: a battlefield guide''. Whether they should be split into separate articles or be sections of a larger article is a matter of ordinary editing not deletion per our |editing policy Deletion of Guinn Run WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
6686 8989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leonard Horowitz User:Nsk92 22:40, 30 April 2008 (UTC) comment """He clearly fails . Apart from the GoogleScholar results cited by Espresso Addict, I did a Medline search for """"Horowiz L G"""". Medline gives 21 articles by him, most with 0 citations, a few in the 1-4 citation range and the top citation hit of 6 for an article published in 1985. These are extremely low citation results for a medical researcher. I am not sure if he passes but, based on the discussion above, I am not yet convinced that he does""" Deletion of Leonard Horowitz WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6687 19540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelly Wilson (comedian) User:Bonadea 19:41, 28 January 2018 (UTC) delete as failing the relevant notability criteria , , and . The sourcing is either primary or else trivial mentions. The YouTube video is a recording of one of her performances, which doesn't show notability. One of her books has been shortlisted for awards, but those awards don't appear to be notable, and being a finalist (as opposed to winning) an award is almost never a claim to notability Deletion of Kelly Wilson (comedian) WP:NAUTHOR||WP:ENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6688 19683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Bywater User:David 21:02, 1 June 2010 (UTC) delete """It's clear that he doesn't pass , and the only thing we can find sufficient reliable sources about is the single fact that Mark Bywater was awarded the title of master plumber, as spammed across half a dozen or so local newspapers. The title itself doesn't seem particularly impressive, and per : """"Evidence of attention by international or national, or at least regional, media is a strong indication of notability. On the other hand, attention solely from local media, or media of limited interest and circulation, is not an indication of notability."""" is more about places than people but I think the same principle applies""" Deletion of Mark Bywater WP:PROF||WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6689 3708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uladzimir Levaneuski (2nd nomination) User:Kj 21:32, 5 August 2020 (UTC) delete Definitely insufficient citations to meet , and no evidence passes any of the other criteria either. Might have more of a chance of passing based on the coverage, but again I'm not really convinced Deletion of Uladzimir Levaneuski (2nd nomination) WP:NPROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6690 161 [[Vorlage:Geni.com]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:CorrectHorseBatteryStaple 19:39, 23. Apr. 2018 (CEST) delete Ich halte geni.com als Anbieterin von User-generated content als Beleg gemäß WP:Q für ungeeignet. Eine eigene Vorlage dafür halte ich darum eher für kontraproduktiv. Siehe dazu auch diese Diskussion: /Fließband/Archiv/2017#geni.com Löschung von Vorlage:Geni.com Wikipedia:Belege Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6691 12446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Half Waif User:Gongshow 03:35, 8 January 2020 (UTC) keep per Sparklism and Andise1. Multiple pieces of significant coverage exist; subject meets Deletion of Half Waif WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6692 4486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deepstep (musician) User:Emily 19:56, 9 September 2018 (UTC) delete nom notable. Fails and Deletion of Deepstep (musician) WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6693 1187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julianne Benzel User:Bearian 16:06, 8 July 2019 (UTC) delete per - you'd be surprised by the number of teachers who are disciplined for what they say. Per |past long consensus, educators are not notable, even if they get into the news over an extended time. I'd cite an example, but I've gotten into trouble here for arguing otherwise Deletion of Julianne Benzel WP:MILL||WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
6694 6129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Marit User:Ron 00:04, 21 June 2010 (UTC) merge The article is a |BLP Deletion of David Marit WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6695 1452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RIMES (company) User:Lesser 07:16, 25 December 2014 (UTC) delete mdash;Not seeing any in-depth, independent coverage. Fails Deletion of RIMES (company) WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
6696 18426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmed Saad Al-Azhari User:Pharaoh 00:42, 14 January 2016 (UTC) delete Per nom fails . Now there are thousands of Islamic scholar not clear why this particular subject is notable.Further Ihsan Institute does not appear to be notable does not have a corresponding article and the article is promotional Deletion of Ahmed Saad Al-Azhari WP:GNG||WP:WTAF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6697 1961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Soulmate Project User:Geschichte 08:57, 5 November 2020 (UTC) delete per , no notability as a planned show Deletion of The Soulmate Project WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6698 8819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kannabiran (film) User:Cindamuse 10:52, 14 May 2011 (UTC) delete Notability has not been established in accordance with the |general notability guidelines or the criteria for |films Deletion of Kannabiran (film) WP:GNG||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6699 14499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hayes Grier (2nd nomination) User:And 02:02, 3 December 2015 (UTC) keep A C-list celebrity, yes, but he still meets . Plus, the reason for the nomination is a little puny Deletion of Hayes Grier (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6700 16071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Members of Bydgoszcz City Council User:Ventric 20:09, 10 December 2017 (UTC) delete Per . Per nom. For those reasons Deletion of Members of Bydgoszcz City Council WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6701 630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of landmarks User:Secret 02:32, 18 July 2012 (UTC) delete do not split or disambiguation. Landmark is such a vague term it violates |our policies in original research, and |neutral point of view Deletion of List of landmarks WP:NOR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
6702 10359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yahweh (disambiguation) User:Black 18:06, 15 February 2007 (UTC) delete """CSD.G6 allows for """"removing a disambiguation page that only points to a single article"""", so I'm not sure if this technically qualifies. This is the only time I've done this as far as I can remember: '''delete per """ Deletion of Yahweh (disambiguation) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
6703 3742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beau Gunderson user:bluedustmite 15:45, 13 November 2007 (UTC) delete per . A very minor candidate who received http://www.vote.wa.gov/Elections/Results/Results.aspx?e=a3501711-c318-45f4-8a03-1d926ac839b7&j=b1977cb9-5217-42c7-97d8-ca0290e4dfb3&o=9bbf583e-8934-4ec4-86ae-61268ea07070 less than four percent of the vote in a district election. No achievements, political or otherwise, and the only sources are his own website and local news coverage. &mdash Deletion of Beau Gunderson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6704 3506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Islam-related terrorist attacks User:Malik 02:20, 11 April 2017 (UTC) delete """A classic |POVFORK. If it survives this AfD, I will load it with every """"Islam-related terrorist attack"""" committed by Christian, Jewish, or Hindu terrorists against Muslims or Islamic shrines. — """ Deletion of List of Islam-related terrorist attacks WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
6705 4243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohamed Lahouaiej-Bouhlel User:Alaney2k 16:59, 15 July 2016 (UTC) merge per Deletion of Mohamed Lahouaiej-Bouhlel WP:PERPETRATOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
6706 3258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buddy Peace User:Trevj 01:22, 13 November 2013 (UTC) keep per . The subject has been interviewed at least a couple of times.http://thepoetryquestion.com/2013/05/20/interview-buddy-peace-the-man-who-produces-those-underground-emcees/http://www.dazeddigital.com/music/article/8078/1/buddy-peace Looks good enough to me, and I stopped searching after finding those two, so there could be more Deletion of Buddy Peace WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6707 7577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earwig the band User:Esradekan 01:25, 16 July 2008 (UTC) delete so close on #C1 for the allmusic review, but C1 calls for multiple published works, and I could find no more. Close, but no banana Deletion of Earwig the band WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6708 15753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Avanesyan User:Ymblanter 12:44, 27 October 2012 (UTC) delete no notability has been demonstrated according to . He did not qualified for the Olympics, and in the World Championships he only advanced to the second round and lost, and only because the Iranian refused to fight against him. May be later he will become prominent, but for now it is a case Deletion of Robert Avanesyan WP:ATHLETE||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6709 2505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stay (SafetySuit song) User:Rlendog 20:23, 28 July 2009 (UTC) keep As noted in the nominator's change of heart, both these songs did chart and thus do meet .http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&searchlink=SAFETYSUIT&sql=11:azfrxzt5ldse~T51 Billboard may be having a problem with its newly redesigned site right now Deletion of Stay (SafetySuit song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6710 16171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abject (band) User:Bryson109 01:34, 12 April 2007 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Abject (band) WP:N||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6711 824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plot of Les Misérables User:Noroton 03:13, 5 July 2007 (UTC) keep This is Les Misérables! Have you ever seen how thick the unabridged book is? You cannot do justice to even a summary of the plot in the space of an overall article on the book because a proper plot summary would overwhelm the article. And it's not as if the book is too unimportant not to have more than one article about it. This is the book that, when first published in installments, soldiers in the American Civil War waited to read as each new installment was shipped across the Atlantic. It's one of the most well-known classics of French literature (at least to the English-speaking world). What is the overwhelming reason why this plot summary must be included in the main article? A bureaucratic rule?!? This is a classic, classic situation where should be applied, but you could also apply guidelines having to do with inordinate space for certain sections of articles. I believe the Wikipedia servers can handle this Deletion of Plot of Les Misérables WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
6712 14900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019 Sydney stabbing attack User:Javert2113 13:58, 3 May 2020 (UTC) delete per Steve Quinn, I fail to see lasting impact that would generally be expected for events like this, per . &mdash Deletion of 2019 Sydney stabbing attack WP:LASTING Wikipedia:Notability 77
6713 16205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Anthony User:WWGB 10:59, 11 October 2008 (UTC) delete Unreferenced, non-notable local government politician, fails guideline Deletion of Andrew Anthony WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
6714 18306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Víctor Rolando Arroyo Carmona User:Grsz11 15:37, 23 October 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Víctor Rolando Arroyo Carmona WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6715 6141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khalil Saeed Hawayek User:DustFormsWords 04:04, 12 February 2010 (UTC) delete Doesn't matter whether it's verifiable, or a hoax, because it fails on more basic grounds. The article doesn't make an assertion of notability, it doesn't provide reliable sources justifying any such claim, and it doesn't meet the notability criteria at or Deletion of Khalil Saeed Hawayek WP:N||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
6716 17812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avenir School User:Edison 20:56, 21 November 2013 (UTC) comment """The nominator's mention that , a subsection of requires """"national coverage"""" led me to find that that guideline is in the midst of a smoldering edit war which seems to be stripping away any presumption of notability, with statements on the talk page that notability for schools might be based on their being one of the """"nation's 50 best"""" or some such blue ribbon criterion, as if we were a """"Michilin Guide to High Schools,"""" with some calling for very difficult requirements to avoid a high school article being deleted. It is hard to apply a guideline which is in a slow edit war. There seems to be one viewpoint present among AFD editors and perhaps a different one among those who contribute to the guideline talk page""" Deletion of Avenir School WP:NSCHOOL||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6717 16925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Future of GTA User:Mhking 03:16, 25 January 2010 (UTC) delete violates Deletion of Future of GTA WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6718 6522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesse Cowell [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']] 11:31, 9 March 2006 (UTC) delete A full article, but full of what? I see no evidence that a film director/producer who distributes their products via BitTorrent is notable. Appears to be cult at best. refers Deletion of Jesse Cowell WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6719 1979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan-Zico Black User:Simione001 09:57, 25 July 2012 (UTC) keep Has played in the FA Cup on a number of occasions and has also represented Northern Ireland at under 21 level. Easily meets with articles such as http://www.poppiesfans.com/2005/11/ryan-zico-black-signs-for-poppies/, http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/13222939, http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport2/hi/football/7624663.stm, http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/18072286, http://www.thisisguernsey.com/sport/2012/03/13/brazil-nut-%E2%80%98zico%E2%80%99-to-be-filmed/, http://thetwounfortunates.com/regionalism-week-guernsey-fcs-flying-start/, http://www.nonleaguedaily.com/news/index.php?&newsmode=FULL&nid=18392 Deletion of Ryan-Zico Black WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6720 21952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evolution of Sport User:DarjeelingTea 11:03, 26 February 2017 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Evolution of Sport WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
6721 314 [[Fairtragen]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Hofres NONE comment 1, was da inhaltlich an den Mann (generisches Maskulinum) gebracht wird ist eine Mischung aus Begriffs- und |Theoriefindung und so garnicht gut Löschung von Fairtragen Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
6722 14679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Managed digital allowance User:Bonewah 21:39, 16 December 2009 (UTC) delete also '''bleh''', sources dont confirm use of the word, kinda sorta confirm the concept as best as I can figure it out. , or you choose Deletion of Managed digital allowance WP:NEO||WP:OR Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
6723 12959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vision Éternel (2nd nomination) User:doomsdayer520 18:42, 23 December 2018 (UTC) delete The nominator is correct. This article is indeed informative with a lot of references to back it up, but it is like a towering skyscraper built on sand. Almost every source backing up a substantive point is self-published from the band's own website or related items. Independent coverage from sources like AllMusic are either dead links or |routine listings of the band's basic |existence. This article is an elaborate self-written biography of a band that must wait for someone else to notice their existence before they qualify for Wikipedia Deletion of Vision Éternel (2nd nomination) WP:ROUTINE||WP:EXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
6724 12732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loch Beag User:AllyD 10:35, 13 May 2019 (UTC) keep Usually, I avoid substantial repurposing of an article during AfD discussion. In this case, however, as recent edits had created the circumstance of the AfD rationale, I have https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Loch_Beag&type=revision&diff=896867159&oldid=896654314 in this edit restored, extended and referenced the previous version. I had previously been considering whether to propose a redirect to :Sound of Arisaig as a possible option, but I think the news and scientific report sources now in the article are sufficient for Deletion of Loch Beag :WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
6725 8929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gaucho Rivero User:Pfainuk 17:33, 26 March 2010 (UTC) merge probably to Re-establishment of British rule on the Falkland Islands, the article that deals with this part of Falklands history in relative detail. I am very doubtful that there actually ''is'' any useful content here. would seem to apply: this individual could only be described as notable for his part in the Gaucho murders of 1833 Deletion of Gaucho Rivero WP:SINGLEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6726 19017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clifford Blais User:Bearian 02:11, 11 December 2020 (UTC) delete per . In Canada, anybody can run for a party leader Deletion of Clifford Blais WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
6727 724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phillip W. Simpson User:Dushan 13:42, 10 May 2019 (UTC) delete as for this AUTHOR. Taking a closer look, the best source is Kirkus https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/phillip-w-simpson/rapture-rUSqHhoz/, although it is not the bluechip source it used to be. I am not confident that the review in School Library Journal, https://www.slj.com/?reviewDetail=minotaur isn real, i.e., it may be a post by a post-at-will, and is certainly extremely brief. And I take Deletion of Phillip W. Simpson WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
6728 20668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/South Harmon Institute of Technology User:Neil 18:22, 11 April 2008 (UTC) merge to ''Accepted'' and '''protect it'''. The movie is of course notable and contains sufficient information about this college and it's hilarious acronym - the fictional college is not - the article is rammed chock full of |original research and useless plot synopsis trivia Deletion of South Harmon Institute of Technology WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
6729 8234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ender Thomas User:Cricket02 05:44, 21 August 2011 (UTC) keep Passes #10 at usic, ''Has performed music for a work of media that is notable, e.g. a theme for a network television show, performance in a television show or notable film, inclusion on a notable compilation album, etc.''; namely, his role for the album and video ''Yanni Voices'' (showcasing four vocalists, Mr. Thomas being one of them). This debuted on Billboard's Top 200 and #1 on the New Age chart. The Spanish version, ''Yanni Voces'', debuted at #2 on Billboard's New Age chart, #5 on the Latin Pop chart, and #13 on the Latin overall chart Deletion of Ender Thomas WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
6730 7177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disability etiquette User:Doc 13:03, 24 August 2008 (UTC) delete A #HOWTO|howto #OR|essay Deletion of Disability etiquette WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6731 19226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave Lee (occultist) User:BlueValour 01:41, 23 September 2006 (UTC) delete for now. Thus guy might well be notable but the link to his website doesn't work and without sources it is impossible to see compliance with . I have no objection to him trying to come back with a sourced article Deletion of Dave Lee (occultist) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6732 9659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason chen (Yitong Chen) User:Voceditenore 16:46, 4 October 2013 (UTC) delete Comprehensively fails both and . Zero coverage of him in independent reliable sources, at least as far as I can find. No awards. No evidence of his music charting anywhere. Has not been signed to a notable label. AllMusic attempts to keep a record of every recording that has ever been published, including self-published ones. Being for sale at Amazon is likewise no evidence of notability. They sell thousands of non-notable self-published books and recordings, including copies of Wikipedia articles. Note that if this article is kept, the entire bio section is simply pasted in from http://jasondchen.com/about-2/ with some of the words replaced by synonyms and needs to be re-written. He's probably talented, but not yet notable. Having said that, if reviews or articles can be found in the Asian press, I'm willing to change my mind. He seems to have done some concerts there. e.g. http://www.tickethotline.com.my/concluded/jason-chen-and-clara-c-live-in-kuala-lumpur Deletion of Jason chen (Yitong Chen) WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6733 2839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HEWI London User:Cwmhiraeth 14:15, 18 November 2017 (UTC) keep The article should be rewritten to remove the puffery but I do think the subject is notable and meets . The references given include to articles in The Telegraph, Harpers Bazaar, Daily Mail and El Pais Deletion of HEWI London WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6734 153 [[Zigarettenmarken Österreich]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:AnnaS.aus I. 23:27, 25. Okt. 2017 (CEST) delete Listen anzulegen, die lediglich die vorhandenen Wikipediaartikel als Links auflisten. Diese Liste bringt null Mehrwert für den Leser. Überspitzt handelt es sich um einen Einkaufsführer - mit Enzyklopädie hat das wenig zu tun. Es gibt formale Ansprüche an Listen und die sollten auch eingehalten werden. (Es handelt sich darüber hinaus um Löschung von Zigarettenmarken Österreich Wikipedia:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
6735 1652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Casbolt User:Schuym1 13:46, 4 December 2008 (UTC) delete No reliable sources that show notability per Deletion of James Casbolt WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6736 9721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kalendar Koffee House User:EllisCHanna 04:06, 1 April 2006 (UTC) keep """Deleting Kalendar from the coffee house category is wrong. To claim that Kalendar is advertising is also incorrect. The Kalendar article lists date of opening and location with interior photo and complies with standards. The so called """"vanity"""" aspects have been removed from the article. Kalendar may not be as """"noteable"""" as the larger chains, but that should not preclude it from listing in the coffee house category. To call this article spam would be to call all listings in this category spam. The previous AFD article was edited down to be considered for inclusion - tis all. No harm intended. Please reconsider. The following is the opening paragraphs of the Starbucks listing. I imagine that all listings in this category are similar to this""" Deletion of Kalendar Koffee House WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
6737 6453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/September 1900 User:Edison 05:32, 4 March 2009 (UTC) delete """What reliable sources have significant coverage about this month, distinct from mentioning things that happened in the month? """"it isn't hurting anything"""" is hardly a valid """"keep"""" argument. Fails |notability""" Deletion of September 1900 WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6738 18871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shunsuke Kawamoto User:Lugnuts 18:38, 25 April 2019 (UTC) keep """per - has appeared at two Olympic Games. """"Not edited since Sept. 2018"""" is not a valid reason for deletion""" Deletion of Shunsuke Kawamoto WP:NOLY Wikipedia:Notability 77
6739 14096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Perelson User:Rosiestep 18:22, 12 July 2008 (UTC) keep Article meets . Three newspapers, the ''Washington Post'', ''The San Diego Union-Tribune'', and the ''North County Times'' cite major points Deletion of Alex Perelson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6740 11472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanveer Ali Hussain User:MightyWarrior 23:49, 2 June 2008 (UTC) delete Having |been bold and removed the obviously false information, the article no longer asserts sufficient notability to remain. Therefore I'm suggesting that it is speedy deleted Deletion of Tanveer Ali Hussain WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
6741 373 [[Liste von Frauen im SS-Gefolge, SS-Helferinnen und anderen Frauen in Diensten der SS]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Kriddl NONE delete So weit gefasst dürfte es Probleme mit geben. So der SS zugeordnet zu werden ist zweifelslos ehrenrührig. So müsste jede Tipse in irgendeinem SS-Büro oder die Köchin in der Kantine rein. Löschung von Liste von Frauen im SS-Gefolge, SS-Helferinnen und anderen Frauen in Diensten der SS Wikipedia:BIO Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6742 17622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerald Murray (Talent manager) User:Szzuk 08:03, 7 April 2018 (UTC) delete refs are related to the artists he managed and not the subject of the article Deletion of Gerald Murray (Talent manager) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6743 13067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tunde Aderonmu NONE NONE delete minus; The subject does not meet the notability criteria set forth in Deletion of Tunde Aderonmu WP:NSOCCER Wikipedia:Notability 77
6744 2111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bradley McGirr User:AusLondonder 22:05, 11 November 2015 (UTC) delete Fails and also . Promotional article Deletion of Bradley McGirr WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6745 1990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peaceful Anarchism User:Iridescenti 21:12, 24 April 2007 (UTC) delete """OR and total . """"The name was coined early in the 1990s shortly after knowlege of Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto became well known to the North American general public"""". I can't quite put my finger on why, but I suspect one or two of the North American general public had heard of Communism before that. (Apparently there were these countries called Russia and China. I believe the public could conceivably have heard of Cuba and Vietnam, too.) Zero Ghits on the http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&safe=off&q=%22Anarchy+and+Peace%22+%22george+wattson%22&btnG=Search&meta= alleged book governing this """"movement"""", unsurprisingly""" Deletion of Peaceful Anarchism WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
6746 12937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bat Ayin ax attack User:BabbaQ 22:27, 17 August 2012 (UTC) keep passes . significant event also Deletion of Bat Ayin ax attack WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6747 20810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Showera User:Fvasconcellos 18:27, 5 June 2008 (UTC) delete as |unverifiable Deletion of Showera WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6748 13487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A-Girl (2nd nomination) User:AnmaFinotera 05:59, 7 June 2010 (UTC) delete While its easy to argue that it must have sources because of its age and its being published in a ''kanzenban'' edition, without any actual evidence of said sources, we just can't |presume they exist. Any notability of the author does not confer to every book she's ever written. Nor does who published it, nor is the number of volumes. It was adapted into a single OVA. I did find the reference in ''Anime Encyclopedia'', a two-sentence mention as part of the entry on the Margaret Video Series, which the OVA was actually a part of. That, to me, does not constitute significant coverage, and nor one has yet to provide any actual demonstrable proof of probable sources. Redirecting to the author's page would also be appropriate, but as of now it fails and as no actual, |verifiable significant coverage has been produced Deletion of A-Girl (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL||WP:BK||WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6749 129 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/S*ktir Et """Kullanıcı:beyazmavibeyazmavi""" 16:09, 8 Ekim 2013 (UTC) delete Kitabı okumuştum:) Ancak bu kitabın kesinlikle #Kriterler|ilgili kriterleri sağlamadığını düşünüyorum. Zaten kitabın yazarı da mimarlık alanındaki kriterleriyle KD S*ktir Et'in silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
6750 5967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Famous born again christians User:Shalom 21:16, 28 June 2007 (UTC) delete """I'm not even certain that """"born-again Christians"""" would be a good category. Certainly it doesn't work as a """ Deletion of Famous born again christians WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
6751 14651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oscar Mink User:Cyrus 16:47, 20 September 2007 (UTC) comment The entire article is pretty much copied from here http://www2.agsm.edu.au/agsm/web.nsf/Content/News-LatestNews-WinningLeadership (you may have to scroll down a bit). This could be speedied as #G12|CSD G12, or just tagged as a copyvio Deletion of Oscar Mink WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
6752 1476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Choichirō Yatani User:David 06:27, 3 November 2013 (UTC) delete for lack of evidence of passing and for not enough continuing interest in his immigration case to pass . There are a few more recent hits mentioning the incident in Google books, but to me the coverage seems incidental — oh by the way here's another outrage that happened and shouldn't we be suspicious that they wouldn't show him their files? That's not much of a basis for an encyclopedia article Deletion of Choichirō Yatani WP:PROF||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6753 2768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hiroyuki Owaku User:Prime 11:38, 19 July 2011 (UTC) delete Fails |general notability criteria: no independent reliable sources with significant coverage, interviews with Owaku all centered on the game series rather than on the person. Article is a verbose version of the MobyGames credits, and impossible to expand without biographical information Deletion of Hiroyuki Owaku WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6754 1349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Tyler (musician) User:AngelOfSadness 17:38, 31 January 2008 (UTC) delete fails , no references that assert notability. The only assertion of significance if being a part of the band Walking Corpse whose article also may not meet the critera of Deletion of Jason Tyler (musician) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6755 13290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malia Obama User:Ilmari 21:57, 1 May 2008 (UTC) delete Completely and utterly devoid of any notability, save for being the daughter of a presidential candidate. Since notability is not contagious, I've half a mind to just speedy this as #A7|CSD A7 (non-notable biography), but maybe it's worth letting this farce play out Deletion of Malia Obama WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
6756 3927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Affiliation Quebec User:Eusebeus 13:27, 2 August 2007 (UTC) delete """Weighing in as a Montrealer, I have some familiarity with this """"party."""" The total whacko (Nutik) is setting up his new """"Equality Party"""" light as a vehicle for his own backyard ambition; he has thrice run unsuccessfully for the mayor of Westmount, garnering truly tiny amounts of votes. If he cannot even make a splash in a Westmount municipal election, running on de-merger, partition, and anglo issues, the chances of his establishing an Anglo-rights party a la Howard Galganov are virtually minuscule. Unfortunately, the emotion surrounding Quebec independence and anglophone/allophone rights & status is such that even such trivial efforts as this get some play-time. That should not, however, be conflated with notability. So, based on all that, this totally fails the standard laid out at . If, by some miracle, they get accreditation then the article can be restored. Meanwhile, I'll be at the local Sports Expert buying a new pair of skates to take with me to hell""" Deletion of Affiliation Quebec WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6757 4165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clackamas Town Center Shooting [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] 01:29, 12 December 2012 (UTC) comment Do these sorts of events ever ''not'' result in Wikipedia articles? may apply Deletion of Clackamas Town Center Shooting WP:RAPID Wikipedia:Notability 77
6758 9506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss Grays Harbor User:Ukexpat 15:22, 17 February 2010 (UTC) delete No ''significant coverage in |reliable sources'' as required to demonstrate notability Deletion of Miss Grays Harbor WP:IRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6759 3285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suparatana Bencharongkul (2nd nomination) User:7 01:30, 15 June 2020 (UTC) keep Meets . And for reasons cited at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suparatana Bencharongkul Deletion of Suparatana Bencharongkul (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6760 8677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carpathian (band) User:JPD 15:21, 6 July 2006 (UTC) delete Doesn't appear to be a hoax, but doesn't appear to meet , either Deletion of Carpathian (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6761 9567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wesneco Torch, The User:Kicking222 21:53, 24 July 2006 (UTC) delete It fails , and pretty much any other reasoning for keeping/deleting a page is immaterial if none of the page's info can be verified Deletion of Wesneco Torch, The WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6762 19158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karel De Smet User:Mentoz86 21:09, 17 August 2013 (UTC) keep """if I stumbled upon this article, I would have considered #A7 as """"... is a Belgian footballer who plays as centre back."""" is indeed no claim for notability. But as Struway's excellent research shows, this is a notable topic and the article should be kept and improved to show why the subject is notable""" Deletion of Karel De Smet WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
6763 18788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shoe City User:Cunard 21:28, 18 November 2009 (UTC) delete per the lack of |reliable sources. There are some sources at a better link, http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Shoe+City%22+Baltimore&btnG=Search&um=1&scoring=a here, but they aren't of the depth that would allow Shoe City to pass the notability guidelines Deletion of Shoe City WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6764 11819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blair McCreadie User:Sandals1 23:40, 13 July 2019 (UTC) delete He didn't head the national party, only a provincial branch--and they lost a lot of seats during that time. He doesn't meet . My search for coverage didn't find significant independent coverage of him. Mentions of him and his comments during press conferences are related solely to his position and are not enough to convince me he meets the GNG Deletion of Blair McCreadie WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6765 17984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bobby Bolt User:Jakejr 05:03, 8 August 2014 (UTC) delete Non notable hockey player who lacks the significant coverage required by Deletion of Bobby Bolt WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6766 5532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One Chance (film) User:Lugnuts 17:27, 2 September 2013 (UTC) keep """Clearly this novice user has never read . This film will premiere in 7 days at one of the most notable film festivals. A quick Google search of the film title and either the director or """"star"""" show dozens and dozens of results, easily meeting . I've tried discussing this with this newbie, but they revert my edits on their talkpage. I don't understand the rationale for redirecting to Syco, whatever that is. Why not the director's page? Infact, no real rationale for |redirecting has been presented without discussion on the article's talkpage. I've gone to the effort of spending a few minutes of using Google, finding references and expanding the article. It's not that hard to do""" Deletion of One Chance (film) WP:BEFORE||WP:N||WP:DE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6767 8202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jurrell Casey User:Namiba 19:18, 7 February 2011 (UTC) keep passes with http://articles.latimes.com/2010/aug/25/sports/la-sp-jurrell-casey-20100826 this story in the LA Times and http://wearesc.com/news/story.php?article=4078 this interview. asks you to see if independent sources exist '''prior''' to nominating for deletion and the nom clearly did not do this Deletion of Jurrell Casey WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6768 8309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TouchMail (2nd nomination) User:A 20:11, 17 October 2017 (UTC) keep The ''other'' 50% of the sources (n.b. there are two sources at the moment) is a ''Time'' magazine article about the software. There's a lot of hits from a (like https://thenextweb.com/apps/2014/01/24/microsoft-veterans-launch-touchmail-innovative-gesture-based-email-client-windows-8/ this NextWeb article and numerous Geekwire articles. I'm also at a loss as to how the tone of this article could be read as promotional. It is four very blandly descriptive sentences—if I hired someone to promote me and they came back with an article like this I'd refuse to pay Deletion of TouchMail (2nd nomination) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6769 16996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Marie Johnson (2nd nomination) User:BabbaQ 23:41, 25 February 2012 (UTC) keep per and . Has appeared also in numerous tv crime style shows Deletion of Sarah Marie Johnson (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:CRIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
6770 4762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shit, Shower and Shave User:Redfarmer 12:50, 3 January 2008 (UTC) delete fails #DICT. Possibly could be merged into List of U.S. Army acronyms and expressions Deletion of Shit, Shower and Shave WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6771 13311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Batbayar Khash-Erdene User:Gri3720 19:59, 10 May 2019 (UTC) keep regardless of whether we feel a 90th-minute substitute is notable ornot is irrelevant. It is enough for him to be considered notable under as he has appeared in a full-international match Deletion of Batbayar Khash-Erdene WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6772 12214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wolf Beats User:HighKing 13:32, 24 January 2018 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails GNG and Deletion of Wolf Beats WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
6773 12420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bensalem Jewish Outreach Center User:IRWolfie 21:26, 21 September 2013 (UTC) delete Non-notable per . All organisations are required to meet our notability criteria Deletion of Bensalem Jewish Outreach Center WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6774 6039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary Forrester User:Ohconfucius 04:23, 5 November 2007 (UTC) delete WP:COI|autobio of a non-notable apparent self-publicist. Article is based on and completely fails Deletion of Gary Forrester WP:SPS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6775 18381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon Caney [[User_Talk:SiobhanHansa|SiobhanHansa]] 21:43, 10 October 2007 (UTC) keep Easily meets - He's a Professor of politics at one of the best regarded universities in the world for politics and his book ''Justice Beyond Borders: A Global Political Theory'' is a set text in (graduate) university courses other than his own (e.g.http://www.st-andrews.ac.uk/intrel/ugcourses/IR3011.pdf St andrews(http://64.233.169.104/search?q=cache:Yxjf11ydOwoJ:www.st-andrews.ac.uk/intrel/ugcourses/IR3011.pdf+%22Justice+Beyond+Borders+A+Global+Political+Theory%22+site:.ac.uk&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=4&gl=us&client=firefox-a google html cache), http://people.pwf.cam.ac.uk/mpo24/GlobalJustice2006.pdf Cambrige http://64.233.169.104/search?q=cache:eo5U-kk-lmIJ:people.pwf.cam.ac.uk/mpo24/GlobalJustice2006.pdf+%22Justice+Beyond+Borders+A+Global+Political+Theory%22+site:.ac.uk&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=5&gl=us&client=firefox-a google cache), there are plenty more Deletion of Simon Caney WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6776 10459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Molyneux (footballer born 1989) User:Angelo 15:38, 8 July 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Lee Molyneux (footballer born 1989) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6777 18191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Esh Family Car Crash User:Rusf10 15:22, 11 January 2018 (UTC) delete as . A mention in one book does not establish lasting coverage Deletion of Esh Family Car Crash WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6778 12011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wings For Life World Run User:onel5969 13:10, 7 October 2015 (UTC) delete searches found some items, but not enough to meet . Might be a case of . Not sure it meets the road race guidelines, either, since it is unclear if any of the 35 races had the requisite 5000 entrants. Regardless, even if it did, that only is an indication that it ''may'' be notabl Deletion of Wings For Life World Run WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
6779 20520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Shanks User:Rjd0060 NONE delete NN. Article has been tagged since January, and thats plenty of time to fix up the article, which hasn't been done to meet Deletion of Josh Shanks WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6780 131 [[Massensterben von Vögeln in den USA]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Dionysos1988 NONE delete Ich bin auch für . Wieso soll Wikipedia alles als relevant aufgreifen, worüber ''ausnahmsweise'' mal etwas ausführlicher in der Presse berichtet wird? Ich denke mal, dass das Medieninteresse nur daher kam, dass man erst vermutete, die Vögel seien wegen Silvesterböllern vor Schreck vom Himmel gefallen. Das Lemma ist sowieso lächerlich: Wieso sollte man sich bei dem Thema nur auf die USA beschränken? Nun: Da |Wikipedia kein Nachrichtenportal ist, sollte der Inhalt nach Wikinews verschoben werden. Dies hier ist eine Enzyklopädie (sollte es zumindest sein) und keine Online-Zeitung. Das vergessen viele immer öfter... Gruß Löschung von Massensterben von Vögeln in den USA Wikipedia:Was Wikipedia nicht ist Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6781 14774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kolbrin Bible User:Pete 18:31, 21 November 2007 (UTC) delete I can see no secondary sources that meet wikipedia's criterion of |reliable sources that are independent of the subject (http://www.crystalinks.com/kolbrin.html this website does a nicer job than the wikipedia article, but is a totally unreferenced website). There's lots of website action, on UFO and planet-X websites discussing the book, and there's Glenn Kimball's book, but I don't see the reliable sources required to meet the content guideline. I too would be all for keeping if it's brought up to a standard of quality approaching that of the The Protocols of the Elders of Zion Deletion of Kolbrin Bible WP:RS||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6782 1788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mikey Gray User:ChrisTheDude 07:20, 16 June 2008 (UTC) delete Definitely doesn't meet requirements Deletion of Mikey Gray WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6783 21420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Columbus Girls Academy User:John 08:59, 6 June 2019 (UTC) delete This is not a school per se, but rather a treatment program with an education component. Fails by a mile and any exceptions we may afford schools do not apply Deletion of Columbus Girls Academy WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6784 9124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LifeCell International User:AllyD 06:32, 8 September 2014 (UTC) delete as per :User:JamesBWatson's analysis of the existing sourcing and separate searches under both the firm's current name and pre-2008 name (Asia Cryo-Cell Private Ltd) turning up no evidence of attained |notability. (Note that there is also a LifeCell part of Kinetic Concepts, which appears unrelated to this firm Deletion of LifeCell International :WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
6785 21819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bahwan CyberTek (2nd nomination) User:AllyD 19:01, 23 November 2016 (UTC) delete I have added a couple of references, one from the previous AfD. Visible coverage shows the firm operating in Indian municipal government http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/fresh-push-to-egovernance-in-municipal-bodies/article6325756.ece, in Dubai http://www.indiatvnews.com/business/india/kvb-implements-instant-remittance-service-for-nris-6702.html, in joint-venture call centres, etc. These passing announcements are sufficient to verify that it is a firm going about its business (despite the paucity of references), but I am not seeing |substantial coverage which can demonstrate |encyclopaedic notability Deletion of Bahwan CyberTek (2nd nomination) :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6786 6339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional books within the Discworld series User:Jfgslo 02:02, 2 July 2011 (UTC) delete With no |verifiability due to the lack of references, the content is |original research by synthesis at best. The content itself consists of a |plot-only description of a fictional work with no reception, significance or even real-world context. Because of this, the list does not meet the criteria of |appropriate topics for lists. Besides this, there are no reliable secondary sources that cover these fictional books to presume that they meet the |general notability guideline or that the list topic has been discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources to presume that it's appropriate per the criteria of |notability for stand-alone lists. This article is an |unnecessary split of ''Discworld'' and an unneeded |content fork. Also, the list falls into what WP:!|what Wikipedia is not by being |an indiscriminate collection of information, so I believe that it has no place in Wikipedia Deletion of List of fictional books within the Discworld series WP:V||WP:SYN||WP:PLOT||WP:SALAT||WP:GNG||WP:LISTN||WP:AVOIDSPLIT||WP:CFORK||WP:IINFO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6787 13072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicolas F. Frichot User:Jersey92 01:13, 22 December 2014 (UTC) delete No establish . This article may also have been a good candidate for db-spam Deletion of Nicolas F. Frichot WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6788 6 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/School prank (3rd nomination) User:Optichan 15:44, 19 June 2006 (UTC) keep Get rid of any |unverifiable stuff Deletion of School prank (3rd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6789 19825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joji Miyao User:Eddie 01:27, 30 July 2010 (UTC) delete Fails for notability as a tennis player and for his nefarious activity Deletion of Joji Miyao WP:ATHLETE||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6790 13591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon B. Gray NONE NONE keep """Most Division I athletic directors in the modern era are going to receive sufficient in-depth coverage in multiple, independent, reliable sources to satisfy the general notability guidelines per . The AD position has become high-profile in college sports, and they are often interviewed and often profiled. There were three linked footnotes in this article; one is now a dead link, so I can't evaluate it. Both of the remaining sources are pretty solid, but one is a trade publication and so I discount its value for determining notability. If the creator of this article wants to save it, go find another couple solid articles about the subject in mainstream publications. If he's truly notable, it should not be hard to do. If you cannot find another two mainstream articles about the subject in the next seven days, I may change this !vote to a """"delete""" Deletion of Simon B. Gray WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6791 6457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamino User:Protonk 04:22, 13 August 2008 (UTC) delete Like the other planets, this article does not cite independent sources which cover the subject in significant detail. That is the threshold for . Star wars material doesn't count. Google hits don't count. Notability isn't inherited from the series. Delete it Deletion of Kamino WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6792 7416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Hicks (American football) User:Ejgreen77 22:56, 21 January 2020 (UTC) delete Fails , , and , per all above Deletion of Mike Hicks (American football) WP:GNG||WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
6793 12434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Welch User:Morenooso 08:20, 22 April 2010 (UTC) keep as per . Her mainstream performances definitely fit the criteria for notability and inclusion Deletion of Lisa Welch WP:PORNSTAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
6794 742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The People's Cube User:GBRV 21:21, 4 January 2017 (UTC) comment """If anyone really thinks that a double standard isn't being used regarding """"reliable sources"""" and """"notability"""", I invite you to look at any of the uncountable articles about the Pokemon video game series, such as Bulbasaur evolutionary line - the scientific guide to the various species of Pokemons. Here you will find a taxonomic chart that includes the full evolutionary sequence (Squirtle evolves into Wartortle; Mega Lizardon X does not evolve, and so on). What do you suppose the """"reliable sources"""" are for this chart? Scientific journals? Biology textbooks? CNN? No, most of it comes from the game company's own """"Pokedex"""". There are tens of thousands of similar articles dealing with other video games, using sources that most of the people here would not consider reliable but which are usually deemed usable for that type of context. Don't accuse me of because articles like these are practically the norm, not exceptional cases. I fully expect the Deletionists to go through and get rid of all of these articles""" Deletion of The People's Cube WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6795 7413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haley Scarnato User:Corpx 04:49, 6 August 2007 (UTC) delete per #NEWS - Only claim to notability is appearance on a TV show Deletion of Haley Scarnato WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6796 12289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elias Grivoyannis User:Eric 01:19, 19 June 2009 (UTC) delete Seems to be a good professor, but I could not find enough to establish notability under . Does not seem to pass either. Citation impact http://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_sauthors=E-Grivoyannis seems to be low. Zero hits on WorldCat. News coverage http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Elias+Grivoyannis%22 not particularly impressive Deletion of Elias Grivoyannis WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6797 1922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Collins III User:Bkissin 15:43, 5 January 2021 (UTC) delete and '''Redirect''' to 2020 United States House of Representatives elections in California#District 43. Failed politician fails and I echo the PROMO concerns of {{u|Edawrdx Deletion of Joe Collins III WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6798 4605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pankajakasthuri User:HighKing 13:19, 18 April 2018 (UTC) delete References fail the criteria for establishing notability. The founder appears to be notable but notability is not inherited. Topic fails GNG and Deletion of Pankajakasthuri WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6799 273 [[Begriff (Umgangssprache)]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Mc-404 NONE delete """Die obige Wendung ''""""Endschrott"""" ohne Substanz und Quellen'' trifft es ganz gut. . Und wo bitteschön ist in ein Link auf ''diesen'' Artikel (nicht die BKL""" Löschung von Begriff (Umgangssprache) Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6800 3320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Straight panic defence User:Bikeable 05:25, 14 January 2008 (UTC) delete as evident hoax, and can we apply Deletion of Straight panic defence WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
6801 4924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Divisible polynomial User:David 18:52, 29 September 2014 (UTC) delete per . Apparently from the discussion here (I couldn't figure this out from the article itself) the topic is polynomials whose values for integer arguments are always composite numbers. There is likely something encyclopedic to say about them (they're mentioned for instance in {{jstor|2301357}}; relatedly see Sierpinski number and Schinzel's hypothesis H) but the article as written is so incomprehensible as to be not worth saving by any kind of merge or rename Deletion of Divisible polynomial WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
6802 9995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ohio Wesleyan University PhD productivity User:Bearian 18:13, 28 December 2007 (UTC) delete as a mess, any way you pull it. Spam, , , are all implicated. Perhaps merge with List of Ohio Wesleyan University people Deletion of Ohio Wesleyan University PhD productivity WP:SYNTH||WP:COI||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
6803 6861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jungle (Dannic song) User:JJMC89 16:07, 9 August 2016 (UTC) delete lacks significant coverage in reliable sources. Fails to satisfy /. —&thinsp Deletion of Jungle (Dannic song) WP:GNG||WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6804 16548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hestnutan Accident User:YSSYguy 22:23, 1 August 2012 (UTC) comment what sources there are ( or database-type entries, e.g. aviation-safety.net's wikibase) indicate that it was on the German civil register Deletion of Hestnutan Accident WP:SPS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6805 9050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Revaz Lordkipanidze User:Bearcat 03:01, 5 July 2018 (UTC) delete """I gave up even trying to figure out if he had a credible pass or not — this is written so badly that even if he were the frigging ''president'' of Georgia the |blow it up and start over principle would still apply. Also, this was deleted as an |autobiography three times in 2009 and 2010 before the creator of this version, differently named but still an , showed up in 2012 — and Lia Palavandishvili's talk page wishes for a """"happy future"""" are consistent with a pattern of comments wishing people a """"happy future"""" when the subject was more openly trying to create the article himself. So I'm betting this is still an AUTOBIO, and I don't expect too many people to actually take me up on the opposite side of that bet""" Deletion of Revaz Lordkipanidze WP:NPOL||WP:TNT||WP:AUTOBIO||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Notability 77
6806 2570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Carter (politician) User:Mkativerata 22:09, 12 March 2010 (UTC) delete A clear case on and no claim to |notability in general Deletion of Paul Carter (politician) WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6807 19676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fat feminism User:Cirt 04:55, 2 November 2011 (UTC) keep appears to be adequate coverage in secondary sources. &mdash Deletion of Fat feminism WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6808 10210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marilyn Manson's seventh studio album User:Quasirandom 15:00, 21 May 2008 (UTC) comment Can we get written into the comment that if the album name is not yet known, it almost certainly is not yet notable and so an article should not be created? There or , given just how often such articles don't survive AfD Deletion of Marilyn Manson's seventh studio album WP:MUSIC||WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Notability 77
6809 11321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adelio Lombardi User:Ravenswing 22:11, 19 December 2010 (UTC) delete So he's the ''agent'' of someone who produces music for other people? (That someone, DJ Frank E, had his article created by the same fellow who created this one, and it probably should be looked over.) Swear to heaven, if Jimbo ever dies and leaves me the Guru of Wikipedia title, one of my first acts will be to require a checkoff of as a prerequisite to creating one's first biographical article Deletion of Adelio Lombardi WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6810 10187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marc!o Mathers User:Adam12901 20:55, 6 January 2007 (UTC) delete Fails . I also listed their album Deletion of Marc!o Mathers WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6811 3447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Pokémon (1-20) User:Hbdragon88 19:21, 17 April 2007 (UTC) keep Active merger discussion is going on on said article's talk page. Quite a few people within the PCP project (A Man In Black before he left, Erik the Apperciator, You Can't See Me, Amarkov, me; even Zappernapper, but he favors evo line merging) do '''not''' agree that all the Pokemon are notable enough to each have their own articles. Please do not attempt to use to force merger decisions or to delete an idea that you disagree with Deletion of List of Pokémon (1-20) WP:AFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6812 18884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mechanoreception in star-nosed mole User:Mike 13:19, 13 December 2013 (UTC) merge per 101.119.15.226. The topic is notable but there's no reason to break it out from the parent article yet. Agree with others above that the article has multiple issues, but those are not valid -REASON|reasons to delete Deletion of Mechanoreception in star-nosed mole WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
6813 20861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/No Chinese User:Ottawahitech 21:48, 27 November 2016 (UTC) keep How can this be deleted using a rationale? This happened 5 years ago in 2011 Deletion of No Chinese WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6814 6822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National anthems of European Union member states User:KAP03 22:46, 28 January 2017 (UTC) delete as it fails as it is just a collection of media files without encyclopedic context Deletion of National anthems of European Union member states WP:NOTGALLERY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6815 10411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kendell McFayden User:Sir 16:20, 11 September 2015 (UTC) keep Having played for Rochester, he clearly passes Deletion of Kendell McFayden WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6816 19598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FriendlySeats User:Kiore 07:11, 16 November 2010 (UTC) delete """per my earlier comment & In addition, whois shows friendlyseats.com has a registrant address ending """"Kyiv, Kyiv 04211 Ukraine"""" while 82.193.99.76 is delegated to an address in Kiev Ukraine. According to the Kiev article, Kyiv is an alternate transliteration of Kiev. While an anon editor and a business being in the same city isn't remarkable I find it strange that the editor should edit a (to them) foreign language Wikipedia to promote non-notable software. I suspect |COI and agree with OSborn's assessment as |NN pam|spam with |RS problems""" Deletion of FriendlySeats WP:COI||WP:NN||WP:S||WP:RS Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
6817 6210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative names of Crayola crayons User:DanielRigal 22:46, 22 July 2018 (UTC) delete I'm not sure how |reliable that single website is although clearly somebody has put a lot of work into it. I don't think we should be rehashing their hard work to such an extent in a pointless, indiscriminate, list article when we can just refer to it as and when required (if required at all). Even if this is not actually copyvio it does seem to fall within the spirit of plagiarism. Let them be the undisputed god of Crayola trivia and good luck to them. We have an encyclopaedia to write Deletion of Alternative names of Crayola crayons WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6818 16924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Buffyverse objects User:Edison 22:01, 7 April 2009 (UTC) delete """a list of objects that have appeared in the Buffyverse"""" seems to fail and OT: """"Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information."""" Objects which had an important role in the series deserve mention in the article about the series or the sub-articles about episodes or characters where they are important. The fact that script writers made up some term like the """"Chordnash of Thagarug"""" does not mean that it belongs in a standalone article with all the other """"Glagafarbs"""" and other made-up throw-away Macguffins used to move one episode along. Other than a gimmick to move the plot, they have no importance""" Deletion of List of Buffyverse objects WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6819 16378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Bowker User:Reconsider 02:23, 14 July 2010 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Andrew Bowker WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6820 21675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danny Rose User:Jimbo 03:41, 15 March 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability at . I'm pretty sure this has been through an AfD I created before, bundled in with a few non-league footballers, therefore eligible for speedy deletion - if I can find the AfD Deletion of Danny Rose WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6821 5595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phil Barker User:Jeepday 03:22, 8 February 2007 (UTC) delete fails also the article Wargames Research Group is referenceless as the single link to subject web presence is a dead 404 link Deletion of Phil Barker WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6822 390 [[Spaghettiknoten]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Hoch auf einem Baum NONE delete Keine |Quellenangaben, . grüße Löschung von Spaghettiknoten Wikipedia:Quellenangaben Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6823 14169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hakim Dilbar Muhammad Khan User:Armbrust 17:35, 26 October 2010 (UTC) delete per the lack of coverage in |sources Deletion of Hakim Dilbar Muhammad Khan WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6824 8664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sonny Khan User:Ngrewal1 00:26, 10 June 2021 (UTC) keep Enough independent news media coverage there for him from reliable newspapers and third party independent sources (8 references) to show his notability. Passes Deletion of Sonny Khan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6825 21328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Davis Schneiderman User:Majoreditor 02:10, 15 January 2013 (UTC) delete He clearly fails . And he appears to fail . Getting mentioned in a modest feature article in small publication like the Victoria Advocate doesn't confer notability. Many of the other places he's mentioned are just glancing mentions and/or in rather obscure sources Deletion of Davis Schneiderman WP:ACADEMIC||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
6826 21885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hadley Corner (3rd nomination) User:Acnetj 00:44, 27 September 2019 (UTC) delete Fails GNG. strip mall Deletion of Hadley Corner (3rd nomination) WP:ROTM Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
6827 2863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexis Jayne Defoe User:JulesH 18:12, 28 May 2012 (UTC) delete Major role in one notable film. Appeared in a notable theatre production, but was not mentioned by name in reviews of it. Article may be worth creating in a few years, when she's likely to have acquired a more noteworthy portfolio, but at this point in time she does not meet or Deletion of Alexis Jayne Defoe WP:ARTIST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6828 10552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bahujan Kisan Dal User:BonkHindrance 23:54, 18 February 2020 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Bahujan Kisan Dal WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6829 4155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chester Doles User:Rpclod 22:38, 19 July 2014 (UTC) delete I agree with Huon. Further, neither element of is met Deletion of Chester Doles WP:PERP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6830 14611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bihar under Lalu Prasad Yadav User:Yoonadue 15:16, 16 February 2021 (UTC) delete """Not a good since it mainly offers a perspective about his rule than rely on facts. Equally . Comparing the subject with Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin is also far from making any sense because these individuals reigned has presidents of their nations. Lalu Yadav was just a chief minister. Once sections like """"Background"""", """"On Yadavisation"""", """"Colonial roots of underdevelopment in Bihar"""" and others have been removed then the article will become small already""" Deletion of Bihar under Lalu Prasad Yadav WP:CFORK||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Content forking 33
6831 11928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chess blogs User:FCYTravis 06:45, 18 December 2005 (UTC) delete per a Web directory or collection of external links Deletion of Chess blogs WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6832 18361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Telugu Tejam User:I 02:05, 18 August 2007 (UTC) delete This seems like a article to me. This is http://www.hindu.com/fr/2006/04/14/stories/2006041401100300.htm apparently an actual award, but I don't see anything to suggest that this is a notable award Deletion of Telugu Tejam WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
6833 4654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeromy Green User:Walwal20 16:50, 10 October 2020 (UTC) delete I reached same conclusions as nom. Has a very local importance, so does not meet . The fact that he landed one of Tony Hawk's tricks can be placed in Tony Hawk's article Deletion of Jeromy Green WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6834 17729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ra (channeled entity) (2nd nomination) User:Shoemaker 10:25, 20 August 2009 (UTC) delete as above. There don't seem to be any mainstream coverage, and you cannot make an article within Wikipedia policy using |only the statements of advocates of the |fringe theory Deletion of Ra (channeled entity) (2nd nomination) WP:UNDUE||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
6835 13675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zac Brooks User:Mikemor92 20:33, 6 October 2016 (UTC) keep Meets Deletion of Zac Brooks WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6836 12609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/La Reyna User:Gongshow 18:12, 14 December 2009 (UTC) delete per . There are online mentions of such an album to be released, but I can not find any information regarding a track listing or release date. With a lack of in-depth verifiable information from |reliable sources, this does not appear to meet Deletion of La Reyna WP:CRYSTAL||WP:RS||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6837 19404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Killing of the night (Book) User:Peridon 00:24, 2 January 2010 (UTC) delete If the book were published, there would be at least one hit on Google for the title + Bethany, or the title + Blayne. Apart from this article, of course. If it is written but not yet published, it would fall under . If it is published online, no-one will be able to find it at present. If it is not written, it is a hoax. In any of these cases, the only verdict can be 'delete'. It's quite a good plot idea, slightly reminiscent of Groundhog Day and another whose name escapes me, but different enough to succeed. If it is published - other than by a vanity publisher or self-publisher like lulu.com - then let us know who by and when. I doubt that this information can be given. If it is written but not published, then do keep trying to get it in print - even via lulu perhaps. That won't get it on here, but it might then get taken up by a bigger publisher Deletion of Killing of the night (Book) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6838 8822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Galbraith User:CactusWriter 16:53, 19 August 2019 (UTC) keep """per and . I agree with the analysis by RebeccaGreen. And the 2015 article """"https://issuu.com/faceoff-online/docs/fo_17 King George Created Goalie Revolution"""" in the Danish ice hockey magazine ''Faceoff'' pushes this beyond criteria""" Deletion of George Galbraith WP:BASIC||WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6839 9161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kommandant User:Bearian 19:25, 23 January 2008 (UTC) delete as |NN band, lacking any |real cites Deletion of Kommandant WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6840 15958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruno Marini User:Bearian 20:49, 23 October 2020 (UTC) delete A passing mention in a book and an ''AllMusic'' listing are not Deletion of Bruno Marini WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
6841 16018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robin Levitt User:Bearcat 04:22, 26 August 2019 (UTC) delete """Nothing stated here is """"inherently"""" notable for the purposes of guaranteeing him a Wikipedia article just because he exists, but the article is not referenced even remotely close to well enough to get him over in ''lieu'' of actually passing any subject-specific notability criteria""" Deletion of Robin Levitt WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6842 21002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Educology User:Rhododendrites 20:09, 24 June 2019 (UTC) delete I've gone back and forth on this one. I have strong reservations about the article, as I explained above, but haven't felt comfortable deleting, so I was debating whether or not to remain neutral or suggest |userfying, stopping short of since there's so much there. That's about where I was yesterday. But I see now that the user has been blocked after sockpuppeting in this thread. As that removes the possibility of userfication, and rather solidifies a bad faith approach to Wikipedia process, I'm now over on the weak delete side. &mdash Deletion of Educology WP:USERFY||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Userfication 87
6843 20967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crosslet, Dumbarton User:Tacyarg 00:21, 5 January 2018 (UTC) delete as fails Deletion of Crosslet, Dumbarton WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6844 9987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orville (cat) NONE NONE delete The article has plenty of |independent sources, but that is irrelevant for a news story. Because |Wikipedia is not a newspaper, stories like Orville (cat)|Orville the cat are assessed per , which has 5 criteria Deletion of Orville (cat) WP:IS||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:EVENTS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6845 4778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Vokes User:Pdcook 15:16, 28 November 2009 (UTC) delete Clearly fails . Although there is some local media coverage of him, I don't think he quite meets Deletion of Matt Vokes WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6846 15192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zombie Massacre (film) User:Armbrust 15:31, 26 September 2010 (UTC) delete as article fails |notability criteria for film. I haven't found any |reliable source about this film Deletion of Zombie Massacre (film) WP:NFILM||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6847 15694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Veracity of statements by Donald Trump (2nd nomination) User:Michepman 05:28, 19 December 2019 (UTC) delete This reads like potentially and . Obviously there's plenty of documentation for false statements made by Trump, but this article risks ballooning into an indiscriminate list of content that is only loosely related, which is something that is proscribed by and can be explained more at . It's easy to see why people may mistakenly believe that this article should be kept since it is obviously well sourced and the general topic is notable, but having it as a standalone article (rather than as a subsection of Donald Trump or a subsection of the topics he is talking about) is not really encyclopedic. (And of course you can find a lot of news articles about Trump being dishonest, but that isn't enough to justify an article. Much has been said about 'Honest' Abe Lincoln but no one would suggest putting together an article Veracity of statements made by Abraham Lincoln. Much has been said about Beyonce's talent but that won't be enough to save Beyonce listography. It's not enough to accumulate sources that touch on an article in general terms Deletion of Veracity of statements by Donald Trump (2nd nomination) WP:OR||WP:SYNTH||WP:NOTDIRECTORY||WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:No original research 65
6848 13869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Johnnyboyxo User:SpacemanSpiff 06:56, 9 August 2009 (UTC) delete no coverage to show |notability. -SpacemanSpiff Deletion of Johnnyboyxo WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6849 11112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wassim Azaz User:Govvy 10:51, 18 March 2018 (UTC) delete Player fails and Deletion of Wassim Azaz WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
6850 19274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Doctor Who historical characters User:Bondegezou 10:30, 14 November 2016 (UTC) comment """The use of historical characters in ''Doctor Who'' is certainly an important part of the show and its own history. That ''Doctor Who'' did this is something that should be and is described in the ''Doctor Who'' article, with some pertinent examples. That's where your first two references come in. However, that's not a reason for an unreferenced, -style list here that makes no distinction between the very different uses, from an perspective, of historical characters in the William Hartnell era with Barack Obama appearing in ''The End of Time'' or Nefertiti in """"Dinosaurs on a Spaceship"""". Your third reference fails RS (not independent), so only your fourth reference directly speaks to an article like this, and it's not the job of an encyclopaedia to replicate a lazy listicle clickbait article""" Deletion of List of Doctor Who historical characters WP:INUNIVERSE||WP:OUTUNIVERSE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
6851 9203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sushant Public School User:DoubleGrazing 13:36, 6 March 2021 (UTC) delete Nothing to suggest notability, even claimed, let alone demonstrated (as completely unsourced); a search finds nothing better than social media mentions, directory listings, etc. Hence fails / . (Could have been speedied, if only that was an option for educational establishments Deletion of Sushant Public School WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6852 9713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deeds of Derangement User:HĐ 15:58, 13 January 2021 (UTC) delete Does not satisfy notability requirements listed at . I also do not propose to redirect as the potential target article (Prostitute Disfigurement) is also doubtful in terms of notability Deletion of Deeds of Derangement WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6853 15720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World of Warcraft Professions [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 03:47, 16 March 2009 (UTC) delete article consists entirely of game guide material which is against Deletion of World of Warcraft Professions WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6854 7274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roman German hybrid User:Dl2000 02:09, 23 May 2007 (UTC) delete per nom & others, candidate Deletion of Roman German hybrid WP:BJAODN Wikipedia:Silly Things 72
6855 20700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammad Sahimi User:Location 20:29, 18 October 2010 (UTC) keep The subject obviously passes and there are other ways to deal with the abundance of inline citations if consensus is that there are too many. If the subject did create this article about himself, I think he did a good job portraying himself in an objective and neutral manner. (The SPA claim is quite ironic in that the nom is also an SPA: all seven of his edits were made over a 13 minute period regarding this article Deletion of Muhammad Sahimi WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6856 21157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Lyal (deceased) User:Daniel 18:56, 2 March 2007 (UTC) delete Interesting one. The sources provided in the article qualify as OR. I doubt the this article can be sourced from actual sources. Also I think we have a clear |conflict of interest issue Deletion of Adam Lyal (deceased) WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
6857 2295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/University of Florida Taser incident (2nd nomination) User:Mkdw 23:08, 17 March 2013 (UTC) keep """I am disturbed by the number of single purpose accounts here. I see two fundamental positions, and . Because Wikipedia is not offering a first-hand account nor is the event a event, technically does not apply here. NOTNEWS does state that if it was a news story it can still be included on Wikipedia as long as it was not routine and had lasting effects. The incident is part of the taser controversy, regularly cited, and """"don't tase me bro"""" became an internet meme. I largely feel the keep camp has shown LASTING and thus avoids NOTNEWS""" Deletion of University of Florida Taser incident (2nd nomination) WP:NOTNEWSPAPER||WP:LASTING||WP:ROUTINE||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6858 14685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Morris the Cat User:Kingofaces43 17:57, 13 December 2019 (UTC) merge """I have a slight preference for merging to 9Lives (cat food) over a straight keep as Metropolitan90 and Reywas92 discuss after reading the above sources in this discussion. Since it's all part of an advertising campaign, that's really the better home. Even though the mascot itself has some notability, I'm not seeing that notability being clearly distinguished from the company advertising or advocacy (i.e., the """"home"""" for Morris' notability already exists elsewhere). If there was a very clear delineation, I'd say keep instead, but in such a case, I'd expect content more worthy of a section at 9Lives rather than just the short sentence saying {{tq|It is best known for its mascot, Morris.}} I don't see that kind of high-level content coming out even with additional editing""" Deletion of Morris the Cat WP:SUMMARY Wikipedia:Summary style 34
6859 10909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mehdi Nassouli User:doomsdayer520 00:44, 25 June 2020 (UTC) comment leaning toward '''Delete''') - The above exchange about whether or not the musician is famous, based on whether you have or have not heard of him, doesn't really get us anywhere. A possible oversight countered with the fallacy. What matters is the notability requirements at . All of the sources added by the pro commenter above are mere announcements and reprints of press releases, which do not get past criterion #1. I can find no |significant and reliable coverage in English. I am willing to hold off on an official vote if anyone can find and discuss reliable sources in other languages that I have missed Deletion of Mehdi Nassouli WP:NEXIST||WP:ILIKEIT||WP:SINGER||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
6860 8464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Entredonneur User:Alba 05:06, 13 March 2006 (UTC) delete per . I hate anon deprodders Deletion of Entredonneur WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
6861 8251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albany poets User:SCZenz 02:58, 26 October 2005 (UTC) delete You might review and note that Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information. Also, as written, it rather reads like an advertizement Deletion of Albany poets WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6862 20834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nikki Flores (2nd nomination) User:Lankiveil 12:31, 25 March 2008 (UTC) delete would not appear to be notable either as a musician or an actor. Fails and Deletion of Nikki Flores (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6863 5448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Lu User:Crusio 08:32, 26 February 2009 (UTC) keep """per John Z. Postdocs are almost never notable, I guess this is the exception that confirms the rule. Publication and citation record is perhaps not yet up to , but the third-party coverage is enough to satisfy . The article needs cleanup, though (remarks like """"unprecedented success"""", """"landmark paper""""). The article history is weird, with quite a lot of vandalism, so the article should be watchlisted by several people after cleanup to keep it in a decent state""" Deletion of Peter Lu WP:ACADEMIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6864 20064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ironclaw (2nd nomination) User:discospinster 17:51, 7 October 2019 (UTC) comment I see a lot of results but not any |reliable sources; if there are some they should be added to the article Deletion of Ironclaw (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6865 2330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lancelin Boys Weekend User:Spongefrog 10:05, 5 December 2009 (UTC) delete Doesn't seem to be very |notable. No relevant, usable google hits. Can't find significant coverage Deletion of Lancelin Boys Weekend WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6866 5290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Recommended precaution (2nd nomination) User:Schizombie 06:11, 16 March 2006 (UTC) comment """Probably agree with nom, but what is the actual arabic term for """"recommended precaution""""? It should have been added to the article in the beginning. Additionally, if this stub were to be merged (per it cannot exist as it is), where should it go""" Deletion of Recommended precaution (2nd nomination) WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
6867 7401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gregory J. Hepburn User:Oiyarbepsy 03:16, 16 October 2015 (UTC) comment Previously |Prod deleted (https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&page=Gregory+Hepburn log entry) under the title Gregory Hepburn Deletion of Gregory J. Hepburn WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
6868 6691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steel Halo User:Mizu 05:12, 12 June 2008 (UTC) delete per Sephiroth, Masterpiece, and Happyme. Fails to meet Deletion of Steel Halo WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6869 10893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wii 2 User:MuZemike 23:01, 23 November 2008 (UTC) delete WP:V|Unverifiable |crystalballery. Note that article has since been recreated and deleted six times (see http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&page=Wii_2 log), so I think |salting the earth (creation protection) is in order; let the user to go |deletion review to create the article again. One could also possibly argue for #G4|G4 as this was deleted per Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of video game consoles (eighth generation) 2, but I personally think that is way too far back for a speedy (using |common sense and |ignoring some rules Deletion of Wii 2 WP:CBALL||WP:SALT||WP:DRV||WP:CSD||WP:COMMON||WP:IAR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6870 19082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Same Difference (Duo) User:Orangemike 20:37, 21 December 2007 (UTC) comment the above-cited rumor is factored from the '':Daily Star''. Is that really considered a |reliable source? |There is no deadline. If these folks ever genuinely become notable, then they can have their own article Deletion of Same Difference (Duo) :WP:RS||:WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6871 32 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Monday Night Football results (1990–2009) User:Prevan 15:06, 19 September 2016 (UTC) delete violates #STATS. We are not a statistics website Deletion of List of Monday Night Football results (1990–2009) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6872 21809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Society for Condensed Matter Nuclear Science User:Silver 08:01, 11 April 2010 (UTC) comment I have tagged this article for |rescue Deletion of International Society for Condensed Matter Nuclear Science WP:ARS Wikipedia:Article Rescue Squadron 98
6873 150 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Sigortam.net (2. aday gösterme) Kullanıcı:nanahuatlnanahuatl 17.17, 22 Şubat 2020 (UTC) keep """Madde zaten kaynaklandırılmış, içeriği de ansiklopedik. Ödüller, zaten kayda değerliğin bir parçası. Bir web sitesi maddesine ne yazılabilir daha fazla? sayfası dahi """"Site veya sitedeki içerik, bir kurum veya yayın organının verdiği, iyi bilinen ve bağımsız bir ödül almış olmalı"""" diyor, yazan kullanıcı(lar) da bunu göstermeye çalışmış. Madde kayda değer""" Sigortam.net (2. aday gösterme) yazısının silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda değerlik (İnternet) Wikipedia:Notability 77
6874 10742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blue Tuna User:Sp33dyphil 22:41, 14 December 2011 (UTC) delete Subject not notable, and as such, fails ; Ghits yield results about the fish, and there were only rare unreliable results about the company Deletion of Blue Tuna WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
6875 17641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Role Players Creed User:Kthapelo 02:17, 22 October 2009 (UTC) delete I created the article and than tried to show that it met , which of course is backward logic. My mistake Deletion of Role Players Creed WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6876 17760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DaFont User:Bmusician 22:11, 29 May 2012 (UTC) delete No coverage in |reliable third-party sources; fails and Deletion of DaFont WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:NWEB Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6877 4022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akash Arora User:Monicasdude 15:23, 19 February 2006 (UTC) keep Meets criteria for published writers, also involved in noteworthy event http://64.233.179.104/search?q=cache:lqAjRXtGT-IJ:messages.indiainfo.com/ubb/Forum99/HTML/000230.html+%22Akash+Arora%22+times+hindustan&hl=en&gl=us&ct=clnk&cd=3&client=firefox-a Deletion of Akash Arora WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6878 226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008 Ukrainian political crisis User:Ostap 02:38, 3 March 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. Its all Deletion of 2008 Ukrainian political crisis WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
6879 15075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/We Butter the Bread with Butter User:Contains 23:34, 3 September 2011 (UTC) keep The article cites two interviews and a review from three different publications, at least two of which appear to be professionally edited magazines (in addition to a paragraph in yet another |reliable-looking music magazine). This is sufficient to pass (criterion #1 Deletion of We Butter the Bread with Butter WP:RS||WP:NM Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6880 261 [[Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien/Wrestling]] (erl., zur Überarbeitung ins Portal verschoben) Benutzer:Weissbier 21:40, 21. Okt. 2007 (CEST) delete Sorry, aber ohne /Wrestling/Durchführungsverordnung und /Wrestling/Dienstanweisung zur Druchführungsverordnung ist das nur der halbe Spaß. Im Ernst: da blickt doch keine Sau mehr durch. Sogar die Marktordnung für Karamellbonbons ist leichter zu verstehen Löschung von Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien/Wrestling Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
6881 1959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disturbed's fifth studio album User:TenPoundHammer 13:33, 19 February 2010 (UTC) delete per . Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Special:Contributions/TenPoundHammer|Many otters • :User talk:TenPoundHammer|One bat Deletion of Disturbed's fifth studio album WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
6882 11361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xtube User:Koffieyahoo 05:57, 25 July 2006 (UTC) delete and bookmarked ;-) Doesn't meet Deletion of Xtube WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
6883 10277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prince Sani Gee User:4meter4 02:45, 24 September 2019 (UTC) delete fails GNG and . Likely an amateur wannabe article that is self created. Close per Deletion of Prince Sani Gee WP:NMUSIC||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Notability 77
6884 1797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solage (poetry) User:Dhartung 04:03, 29 May 2008 (UTC) delete per |Wikipedia is not for things made up at a poetry slam one day. Mr. Semmens, as well, appears unnotable -- almost all of the references to him are for an incident where he owned a domain name similar to one chosen by David Cameron Deletion of Solage (poetry) WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
6885 19635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darren Roberts (AVN Media Network) User:RightCowLeftCoast 19:16, 21 April 2011 (UTC) delete Most references given in the article do not meet |reliable source guidelines, and most do not appear to be independent of the subject of the article. A http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Darren+Roberts%22+AVN+source%3A%22-newswire%22+source%3A%22-wire%22+source%3A%22-presswire%22+source%3A%22-PR%22+source%3A%22-release%22+source%3A%22-wikipedia%22&btnG=Search+Archives&scoring=a google news search only gives 16 hits, and not all of them are about the individual, and some are from AVN news, a source not independent of the subject of this article Deletion of Darren Roberts (AVN Media Network) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6886 20484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles de Wolf User:Radagast3 10:06, 5 March 2010 (UTC) delete not reliably sourced, and so fails Deletion of Charles de Wolf WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
6887 19371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twisted Ear user:Beckstrous 16:28, 13 January 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Almost certainly Deletion of Twisted Ear WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
6888 2233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gül Kaplan User:CommanderWaterford 18:23, 24 March 2021 (UTC) delete fails plus , only amateur playings Deletion of Gül Kaplan WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6889 7698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Costello (baseball) User:Dmoore5556 05:55, 19 November 2019 (UTC) delete Although very unfortunate circumstances, as noted by others above, fails Deletion of Ryan Costello (baseball) WP:NBASE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6890 8294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Money Masters (2nd nomination) User:DCI2026 01:22, 9 March 2013 (UTC) delete There are abundant sources to substantiate the existence of this film, but not one of them is eliable|reliable, and, in the absence of appropriate, third-party sources giving significant coverage, |verifiability is unlikely Deletion of The Money Masters (2nd nomination) WP:R||WP:V Wikipedia:Redirect 56
6891 1317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Amanda Froistad User:Defendingaa 05:14, 20 February 2019 (UTC) keep as the article's creator. The extensive references unquestionably establish |notability. Keep in mind that this murder is '''not''' only notable as being an example of the Bystander Effect (as a couple delete votes incorrectly state); it is also notable and described in reliable third party sources as being an example of someone dying because of bureaucratic incompetence. For example: {{cite book|title=The Third Lie: Why Government Programs Don't Work—and a Blueprint for Change|last=Gelles|first=Richard|date=2016|isbn=1611320526|publisher=Routledge}}. I agree that the article currently is, at best, start class, and I hope to have some time this weekend to expand and improve it, but a new article being imperfect is not grounds for deletion Deletion of Death of Amanda Froistad WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6892 12753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shuo Scott Liu User:Obina 23:43, 13 February 2006 (UTC) delete I've tagged as '''speedy''' per a7 examples because claiming to be king of bulgaria is in fact not a credible claim of notability. clear hoax or Deletion of Shuo Scott Liu WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
6893 7101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/W. C. Clark (settler) User:Edison 03:54, 20 January 2018 (UTC) delete There are primary sources such as death certificates which might be interesting to descendants, but are not the |reliable secondary sources with significant coverage needed to satisfy . Then there is a directory listing that says he bred swine, and passing references as one of several early residents of a place. These, too, are not the significant coverage needed to satisfy and serve as the bases of an article. Being someone's ancestor is inadequate per .Instagram and the like are not |reliable sources. Descendants might wish to create an entry at Ancestry.com Deletion of W. C. Clark (settler) WP:RS||WP:BIO||WP:BIO||WP:NOT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6894 1880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lim Yee Xien User:L3X1 20:52, 9 February 2017 (UTC) delete Fails . Stub Deletion of Lim Yee Xien WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6895 20292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mauro DePalma User:Slowmover 18:22, 9 March 2006 (UTC) delete Verifiable, but meets delete criteria under Deletion of Mauro DePalma WP:VANITY Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
6896 3454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mountain Ridge High School User:danntm 01:58, 17 January 2007 (UTC) delete yet's at wait for the school to open before writing articles, alternatively, merge salvageable content to the community's article per Deletion of Mountain Ridge High School WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
6897 2162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Maguire (boxer) User:Jakejr 22:32, 21 May 2014 (UTC) delete Fails . I agree with the previous comments about him not showing notability Deletion of Michael Maguire (boxer) WP:NBOX Wikipedia:Notability 77
6898 21013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Belg der Belgen User:The 00:25, 13 October 2011 (UTC) keep As discussed above, this is (a) not copyvio, and (b) notable. Also (c) the vast AfD spam of the nominator, both with these and with coats-of-arms/flag pages, deserves a |application of soggy seafood Deletion of Belg der Belgen WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Whacking with a wet trout 74
6899 8613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Major television stations User:NellieBly 03:45, 18 April 2011 (UTC) delete """I don't see any notable third-party agreement of what """"major"""" means with respect to television stations, so this is original research. Worse, most of the entries in this list are not television stations but ''networks'', and only from a few countries at that. If kept, I think those logos have to go per """ Deletion of Major television stations WP:NONFREE Wikipedia:Non-free content 99
6900 9812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iconic Digital User:AllyD 18:09, 28 February 2014 (UTC) delete An article sourced to the firm's own site and press releases, some of which don't back up the claims they are placed to support. Fastest-growing listings and local awards do not amount to |evidence of attained |notability Deletion of Iconic Digital :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6901 12949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of attendance figures at anime conventions User:Calathan 18:30, 31 July 2013 (UTC) comment This discussion seems to have been left off the log page for today's AFD discussions. I've added it there now. Sinjanthu, please try to follow all the steps at when nominating an article for deletion Deletion of List of attendance figures at anime conventions WP:AFDHOW Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6902 12081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandra Simonds User:Bearian 22:33, 11 January 2021 (UTC) keep per and . Searches of Google and social media show that her poems are frequently quoted. There are already |three substantial reviews from reliable sources in the article Deletion of Sandra Simonds WP:BEFORE||WP:CREATIVE||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6903 1781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/King Myers User:Lemongirl942 00:01, 31 August 2016 (UTC) delete This is way too soon. The NYDailyNews is the best source we can get. The Newsday is a local source and a trivial mention talking about a rescheduling of a concern - there's hardly anything about the subject itself. The MTV source mentioned by {{u|K.e.coffman}} is a source and essentially a directory listing (See disclaimer below {{tq|This site contains content from artists, fans, and writers from around the internet in it's natural form. Such content is not representative of Viacom Media Networks.}}. Overall, this is just and a clear delete. I see this essentially as a promotional page for an upcoming artist Deletion of King Myers WP:USERGENERATED||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6904 1985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alt.talk.creationism User:Exit2DOS2000 07:56, 17 January 2008 (UTC) delete nothing this group may have done had a |Verifiable effect Deletion of Alt.talk.creationism WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6905 7282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joey Karam User:Cullen328 21:55, 16 December 2010 (UTC) keep and improve through normal editing. Notability guideline says that a musician is assumed to be notable if a member of 2 or more notable ensembles. This person has been a member of three notable groups. The article needs better references but should not be deleted Deletion of Joey Karam WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6906 12513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asmaar Peerzada User:K 03:37, 3 July 2017 (UTC) delete A7 material and Deletion of Asmaar Peerzada WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6907 2288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lord Tracy User:Michig 21:45, 4 February 2008 (UTC) keep Passes at least on criterion #6, and probably others if anyone's prepared to dig for references. The band features Pantera's ex-singer and have released several albums. Plenty of google hits, though not a lot of obvious quality Deletion of Lord Tracy WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
6908 15343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Liverpool F.C. matches in international competitions User:Joseph2302 15:44, 19 April 2021 (UTC) delete this subject is covered in a much better way at the FL Liverpool F.C. in international football, and we don't need an list of every match they played in these competitions. Usually I would say merge to that article, but there isn't any content here that would benefit that (really good) FL Deletion of List of Liverpool F.C. matches in international competitions WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6909 4290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elena Nozdran User:Stvbastian 05:26, 29 July 2017 (UTC) keep meet #1, 3, and 5 Deletion of Elena Nozdran WP:NBADMINTON Wikipedia:Notability 77
6910 15271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andre Holmes User:Gongshow 21:20, 11 November 2011 (UTC) keep per the sources found and added by Cbl62; subject satisfies Deletion of Andre Holmes WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6911 17847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Six Reasons Why (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 01:32, 14 September 2020 (UTC) delete """Films are not automatically notable enough for Wikipedia articles just because they exist — they need to show markers of ''significance'', such as major film awards and/or enough attention from film critics to clear . But there's no such claim being made here, this is written more like an advertisement for the film than a neutral encyclopedia article (|conflict of interest likely, as the article was created by a user named """"ImageEnt"""" and has subsequently been heavily edited by a user named """"MattCampagna""""), and even on a ProQuest search for decade-old coverage that might not have Googled, I still found only a bunch of smalltown community hyperlocals reprinting the exact same wire service article on the same day (thus combining into ''one'' data point, not several) and absolutely nothing from major media. That's not good enough.I should also note that both Matt and Jeff Campagna also had advertorialized autobiographical articles, with weak sourcing and no notability claim stronger than the existence of this film — see also Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Campagna (2nd nomination) and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Campagna""" Deletion of Six Reasons Why (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
6912 11365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burger King menu items User:Elaragirl 04:00, 31 January 2007 (UTC) delete """Fails and I don't see any sources, just a pile of external links. The topic is not encyclopedic and fails WP:NOT (for that matter so does the McDonald's one). And for God's sake, please stop with the """"Well Article X is here, so Article Y should stay"""". It's not a keep argument""" Deletion of Burger King menu items WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6913 17817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Croatian Operational Research Society User:David 18:16, 24 February 2015 (UTC) keep """Each of these is recognized by the International Federation of Operational Research Societies (the umbrella international organization for this discipline) as the major national society for their country — see http://ifors.org/web/national-societies/ the IFORS list of national societies (and in the case of Italy, see the Wikipedia article for the mismatch between what IFORS calls the society and what we call it — it's the same society under a different name). I don't want to suggest that any academic society that calls itself a national-level society is notable, but I think the ones in major disciplines (e.g. the topic of entire university departments) that are internationally recognized by their peer societies as the main society for their country are notable. As for the invocations of above: I think it would be a mistake to merge these into the """"parent"""" organization. They are not branches of IFORS (the way AEORS seems to be). They are independent societies that happen to hold memberships in IFORS, in the same way that people and corporations might happen to hold memberships in these societies. In particular, I think that recognition by IFORS should count towards notability as being independent of the subject, because these societies are separate entities rather than being part of IFORS""" Deletion of Croatian Operational Research Society WP:BRANCH Wikipedia:Notability 77
6914 5234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of filling stations in Martha's Vineyard User:Pepper 12:36, 27 January 2011 (UTC) delete Not notable at all, . ''':.:∙:∙∙:∙:.:| Deletion of List of filling stations in Martha's Vineyard WP:DIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6915 7423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chad Gould User:Nfitz 23:05, 4 July 2008 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Chad Gould WP:ATHLETE||WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
6916 19595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baw game of Scone User:Edison 03:10, 11 August 2008 (UTC) delete Wikipedeia is |not for things made up in Scone one day which in hundreds of years have not gained multiple independent and reliable sources with substantial coverage Deletion of Baw game of Scone WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6917 8962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Jones (AI Researcher) User:Wikicology 08:15, 24 January 2015 (UTC) delete I would have to agree. No evidence of |notability Deletion of Chris Jones (AI Researcher) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6918 21556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kolbrin Bible User:Xymmax 17:29, 21 November 2007 (UTC) delete I can't find a reliable source that will attest to this book's (ancient) existence. I actually agree with Black Butterfly above, and ultimately I think this may well end up with a page. However, I can't find any sources that WP considers reliable to use here. Per we shouldn't be the validating source to make a fringe idea mainstream. Once this topic has been addressed by a mainstream source, a page like The Protocols of the Elders of Zion or Face on Mars is appropriate Deletion of Kolbrin Bible WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
6919 5734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Badr Berrada User:Jack 11:18, 26 July 2020 (UTC) delete Coverage fails to meet the hurdle of or . Has the whiff of |UPE about it, and |Wikipedia is not for promotion Deletion of Badr Berrada WP:ANYBIO||WP:GNG||WP:UPE||WP:NOTPROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6920 21092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Knuckles the Echidna (comic character) User:TenPoundHammer 21:48, 26 June 2008 (UTC) merge to Knuckles the Echidna per . Significant enough overlap Deletion of Knuckles the Echidna (comic character) WP:MERGE Wikipedia:Merging 54
6921 16720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of veterinarians User:SMcCandlish 01:42, 6 September 2020 (UTC) keep It's standard operating procedure to impose on lists that attract the addition of non-encyclopedic entries (either of non-notable entries, or trivia entries to notable topics that are not notable for {{em|that}} topic Deletion of List of veterinarians WP:LISTCRITERIA Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
6922 11760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Petra Seeger User:Netherzone 22:36, 10 April 2021 (UTC) keep After doing a search, it's clear that she is notable; between the museum collection, multiple reviews of her work, extensive screening history and a notable award, she meets /{WP:NARTIST. I am guessing there is more to find as well, as {{u|Modussiccandi}} and I did not have to search long or deeply to find these sources, some of which have been added to the article Deletion of Petra Seeger WP:BEFORE||WP:FILMMAKER Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
6923 20374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maika Polamalu User:BU 09:57, 23 July 2015 (UTC) delete Fails and . I found some brief coverage about his decision to retire and then return, but that appears routine and wasn't sustained (all similar to the Capital Gazette article linked above). The Baltimore Sun story was clearly only written due to the family connections, and notability is not inherited. Even discounting that, a single regional piece on a college athlete does not meet , as this is not substantial coverage Deletion of Maika Polamalu WP:RLN||WP:NCOLLATH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6924 12362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CE Holkar User:CASSIOPEIA 14:20, 25 December 2017 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a place to house a collective list of athletes, wikipedia:INDISCRIMINATE|Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information, with vague names where statistical/directory source does not satisfy and hard to , failing to meet the core of criteria for any stand alone article to be created and stay in Wikipedia website unless they are accompanied with other references. If it is allowed to be kept, then millions of athletes in different disciplines with single statistical/directory source would flood Wikipedia and strip away/muddles two of the main Wikipedia policies/guidelines (GNG) and verifiability Deletion of CE Holkar WP:GNG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
6925 17709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kentucky Route 342 User:Quek157 16:56, 10 May 2018 (UTC) keep per , generally described. This will eventually end up keeping as sources clearly collaborate (unless it's a hoax Deletion of Kentucky Route 342 WP:ROADOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
6926 21089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World Urban Campaign User:Jeffrd10 19:03, 20 January 2014 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of World Urban Campaign WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6927 6653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Biomechanics of intrinsic gravity User:Bearian 22:46, 3 August 2010 (UTC) delete this is a |non-notable spin of astrology and |original research Deletion of Biomechanics of intrinsic gravity WP:FRINGE||WP:OR Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
6928 11187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaitlyn Burke User:Rikster2 04:32, 14 February 2013 (UTC) delete subject did not meet GNG by receiving significant coverage as an individual. Does not meet either Deletion of Kaitlyn Burke WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
6929 20994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arlie Metheny User:Anotherclown 11:26, 4 January 2012 (UTC) delete non notable under the Deletion of Arlie Metheny WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6930 91 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Davide Petrucci (2nd nomination) [[User_talk:ClubOranje|T]] 08:32, 5 March 2009 (UTC) delete per nom, fails notability criteria for footballers per and with no other claim to fame. No noticeable change to his notability status since previous AfD deletion.--ClubOranje Deletion of Davide Petrucci (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE||WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
6931 16620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corvid college User:Ravenswing 18:27, 4 May 2010 (UTC) delete """Wikipedia isn't even for |schools made up in school one day. (That being said, I've always had a giggle fit at the oxymoron of """"anarchic community""" Deletion of Corvid college WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
6932 9298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Payatas Baptist Church User:Metropolitan90 03:29, 1 December 2009 (UTC) delete No independent |reliable sources have been provided Deletion of Payatas Baptist Church WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6933 2569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hal Bidlack User:JoshuaZ 22:00, 16 November 2008 (UTC) keep Appears to meet . Bidlack's notable for a variety of different things. His work promoting skepticism probably makes him notable by itself. There are many reliable sources about him Deletion of Hal Bidlack WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6934 1708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohi (2nd nomination) User:Spirit 04:24, 14 April 2015 (UTC) keep per Schmidt. Article appears to be notable and its almost certainly going to be aired within a matter of weeks, so does not appear to be an issue Deletion of Mohi (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6935 6792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Painting the Invisible Man User:Coolabahapple 11:19, 27 December 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet or , WorldCat shows it https://www.worldcat.org/title/painting-the-invisible-man/oclc/166367238&referer=brief_results being held by 5 libraries which probably reflects the lack of |useable sources from a gsearch (including the reviews mentioned above), did find http://www.midwestbookreview.com/sbw/may_09.htm this from the Midwest Book Review but more is needed. ps. a redirect to the author, Rita Schiano may be appropriate Deletion of Painting the Invisible Man WP:NBOOK||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6936 20876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luma Health (2nd nomination) User:Aman 08:48, 6 March 2020 (UTC) delete Sources are mainly press releases or unreliable promotional websites where you can get article about your company published. Easily fails Deletion of Luma Health (2nd nomination) WP:ORGCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
6937 1890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2021 FIFA U-20 World Cup User:Sir 17:24, 25 February 2017 (UTC) delete As an obvious case of . While the tournament will obviously be notable at some point, there just isn't anything to say about it yet Deletion of 2021 FIFA U-20 World Cup WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
6938 14206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Srully Abe Stein User:IZAK 13:43, 16 November 2014 (UTC) delete """per User {{user|VQuakr}} and User {{user|Malik Shabazz}}. This article relies on personal blogs and self-promotion and no real RS at all. The article clearly violates & & . Maybe in a few years time, ''if'' the subject picks up fame/notoriety/whathaveyou and then gets ''seriously'' covered by the media (not just as part of minor family scandals) or is cited in reliable sources, the subject can be revisited, but for now there is not much of anything here to justify it as encyclopedic or """"noteworthy"""". Thank you""" Deletion of Srully Abe Stein WP:NOTSOAPBOX||WP:NOTSOCIALNETWORK||WP:NOTFORUM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6939 10797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SCII Arcade: Project Haven User:Czar 07:30, 23 November 2014 (UTC) delete A: When they're covered by abundant, secondary, reliable sources. Article topic lacks |significant coverage from |reliable, |independent sources. (|?) It did not have any meaningful hits in a /RS|video game reliable sources search. Would entertain a redirect to a ''StarCraft''-related article if there is a single secondary source that would host such a connection. Please ping me if more (non-English and offline) sources show in the future. czar Deletion of SCII Arcade: Project Haven WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:42||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6940 7872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southwest Airlines Flight 345 User:Ahunt 19:58, 29 July 2013 (UTC) delete No indication that this meets Wikipedia policy . All available information shows that this was a simple mechanical failure or pilot error accident, resulting in an accident with little continued news coverage. There is no indication that it will be a hull loss or have any lasting consequences, such as Airworthiness Directives, Service Bulletins, changes in ATC or training procedures or any other lasting effects. As noted above we don't retain articles that don't comply with Wikipedia's policies in case they become notable in the future Deletion of Southwest Airlines Flight 345 WP:NOTNEWSPAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6941 14894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charlie Powell (presenter) User:Superastig 10:47, 12 June 2020 (UTC) delete She's mentioned in several articles from ITV News. Other than that, I barely found anything about her. Easily fails Deletion of Charlie Powell (presenter) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6942 1782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Brown (politician) User:Rhododendrites 00:39, 17 December 2014 (UTC) keep Between what's cited and a cursory gsearch I'm seeing sufficient/significant coverage to satisfy . --&mdash Deletion of Sarah Brown (politician) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6943 13942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yellow arch studios User:Martin 18:24, 17 September 2009 (UTC) delete It's certainly verifiable it exists, but none of the mentioned sources in the article are significant (or about the studio ''itself'') thus not meeting the criteria for Deletion of Yellow arch studios WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6944 16988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Citilink Flight 800 User:WilliamJE 12:20, 22 April 2019 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Citilink Flight 800 WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6945 856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ice hockey at the 2019 Winter Universiade User:Bhockey10 23:14, 9 July 2017 (UTC) keep or '''Merge''' into 2019 Winter Universiade with possibility of building out as competition nears and more info becomes available. A quick google search does show there's verifiable articles about the event. It is the next Winter Universiade so does fall in line with conventions for large-scale international sporting events, creating the article a few years in advance. This does not fail which explicitly states that future events can be included on Wikipedia if they are notable and almost certain to take place Deletion of Ice hockey at the 2019 Winter Universiade WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6946 21795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashli Babbitt User:DMBradbury 15:17, 7 January 2021 (UTC) merge and '''Redirect''' to 2021 storming of the United States Capitol. See Wikipedia:BASIC & - Depth of coverage is not substantial enough to establish notability, and it isn't established that there is sufficient weight for a standalone article. Consider breaking this into its own page should these thresholds be met. Additionally, with four deaths now being reported, it seems likely that those will be their own section rather than four unique pages Deletion of Ashli Babbitt WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
6947 20753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Just like You (Roxy Music song) (2nd nomination) User:JD554 10:02, 24 April 2009 (UTC) merge to Stranded (album). Anyone who is aware of Wikipedia's or #Disambiguation guidelines may use this is a search term Deletion of Just like You (Roxy Music song) (2nd nomination) WP:DAB||WP:MUSTARD Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
6948 14341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jon Main (2nd nomination) [[User talk:60.48.246.75|talk]]) 10:38, 26 February 2009 (UTC) comment """Why keep mentioning ?, the subject already passes basic criteria for inclusion. This sentence is written under the '''''Additional Criteria''''' section, pls read it carefully """"'''Should a person fail to meet these additional criteria, they may still be notable under Wikipedia:Notability.'''"""" Jon Main may fail , but given that exceeds , he already passes the criteria for inclusion. Main also passes though Special:Contributions/60.48.246.75|60.48.246.75""" Deletion of Jon Main (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE||WP:N||WP:ATHLETE||WP:N||WP:ATHLETE||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6949 5787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lauren McLean User:Enos733 05:14, 11 November 2019 (UTC) delete for now (while allowing the article to be recreated in draft space). As others have stated, candidates are not presumed notable under . While there is a timing issue surrounding an AfD of a political candidate close to an election, the usual standard of a delayed AfD is about 8-10 days from an election (to account for one relist). As Bearcat points out above, there is a concern that Wikipedia could become a repository of campaign brochures in the waning days of an election (and I can attest, they do and they are hard to patrol especially when they come to AfD). In the interim, there is a possibility of a ''redirect'' to the 2019 Boise mayoral election Deletion of Lauren McLean WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6950 12367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prabhat Samgiita User:Location 21:14, 30 January 2013 (UTC) delete or '''redirect'''. Arguments are essentially the same as for Idea and Ideology: Lack of coverage in independent reliable sources means this fails (i.e. HathiTrust lists it as a http://catalog.hathitrust.org/Record/002936463 book) and (which pertains to topics related to music, including artists and bands, albums, and songs). I also have heavy concerns regarding given the context of many similarly-created articles Deletion of Prabhat Samgiita WP:NBOOK||WP:NMUSIC||WP:SOAPBOX Wikipedia:Notability 77
6951 18357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natural Beauties User:SlamDiego 08:41, 6 September 2008 (UTC) delete Lack of apparent |notability. But the Foundation should buy a copy of the book for me Deletion of Natural Beauties WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
6952 7794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Who Dunnit? (song) User:JamesBurns 06:37, 17 February 2009 (UTC) delete non-charting song that fails to demonstrate notability Deletion of Who Dunnit? (song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
6953 18918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ballycar National School User:Northamerica1000 06:50, 5 July 2014 (UTC) merge to Newmarket-on-Fergus per precedent documented at Deletion of Ballycar National School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
6954 15403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle of Saturn's Rings [[User talk:76.66.193.90|talk]]) 06:04, 3 March 2009 (UTC) comment this article is a plot summary of '''season one episode six''' of Robotech and would fall under Special:Contributions/76.66.193.90|76.66.193.90 Deletion of Battle of Saturn's Rings WP:EPISODE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
6955 18656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ritesh Agarwal User:Vinay089 04:59, 25 June 2016 (UTC) delete No grounds asserted for notability meeting . Agarwal's article looks like an advertisement & promotion page of the person and his new venture, who has done lots of PR online but didn't not received any significant awards/recognition - otability. Seems a good young business person from India but not notable Deletion of Ritesh Agarwal WP:BIO||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
6956 250 [[Männerdomäne]] (Fall für [[WP:LP]]) Benutzer:Gelli63 18:01, 16. Sep. 2013 (CEST) keep s.o. wenn überhaupt '''|Löschprüfung Löschung von Männerdomäne Wikipedia:LP Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
6957 19885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julius Soubise User:ryanpostlethwaite 12:40, 16 January 2007 (UTC) keep Now it has sources it meets , still think it could do with more of a cleanup however Deletion of Julius Soubise WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
6958 7201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hermann Bellinghausen [[User talk:2601:248:4500:9523:43C:32C0:AC8B:3F10|talk]]) 20:41, 15 March 2017 (UTC) delete Only coverage is one mention in an article so fails . Special:Contributions/2601:248:4500:9523:43C:32C0:AC8B:3F10|2601:248:4500:9523:43C:32C0:AC8B:3F10 Deletion of Hermann Bellinghausen WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6959 517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ice Age: Th4w User:Joe 00:40, 9 December 2009 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Ice Age: Th4w WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6960 16453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled Franchise User:Metropolitan90 02:38, 19 December 2010 (UTC) delete for being a hoax per #G3. It wouldn't take four to five years to get a show on the air which would just be a ripoff of Pop Idol/The X Factor (UK)|The X Factor; if this was an actual television show, it would be on the air no later than next year, and it would have a title, and there would be sources, but we can't even search for sources because the article creator didn't bother to make up a title for this fake show Deletion of Untitled Franchise WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
6961 15992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Voice from the Sky (2009 film) User:PC78 11:35, 11 January 2009 (UTC) delete Explicitly fails per nom Deletion of Voice from the Sky (2009 film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6962 14181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dragonfable (5th nomination) User:Danny 11:22, 23 December 2006 (UTC) comment """Then take it to . """"Good enough for an article"""" is not sufficient reason to overturn an AfD""" Deletion of Dragonfable (5th nomination) WP:DRV Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
6963 12045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs recorded by Mohammed Rafi User:Phil 20:58, 26 August 2013 (UTC) keep """and I'm shocked by the number of """"delete"""" opinions we have had here. We routinely have complete lists of songs for many barely notable British and American singers, but there are people who consider themselves qualified to decide what goes in an encyclopedia and say that we shouldn't have such a list for one of the greatest Indian popular music singers of all time. This is not , but such extreme systemic bias as to amount to institutional racism""" Deletion of List of songs recorded by Mohammed Rafi WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6964 12953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nazih Fares User:ZettaComposer 12:56, 5 October 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Nazih Fares WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6965 17659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Robinson (James Bond) User:Masem 18:50, 21 August 2012 (UTC) delete per Kung Fu Man. As a modern film character you would be expected to easily find sources through Google but I am not finding any. This fails #PLOT and among other policy/guidelines. Because its a disambig term, it is not a viable search term and ergo the article shoudl be deleted after the merge is complete Deletion of Charles Robinson (James Bond) WP:NOT||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6966 1680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dynamic Vision Assessment for Transportation User:ZimZalaBim 02:14, 27 September 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Wikipedia is also |not about |POV |vanity articles Deletion of Dynamic Vision Assessment for Transportation WP:NOT||WP:POV||WP:VAIN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6967 9107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth McCaul User:THF 23:03, 12 February 2009 (UTC) comment Sources are not | independent sources. One is text of a speech given by McCaul, two are press releases, and the last is essentially a copy of her bio from the company's website. This is why I questioned the | notability of the subject. However, I can see where New York's Superintendent of Banks may be inherently notable, as Deletion of Elizabeth McCaul WP:SOURCES||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6968 6430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Halloween III (2013 film) User:Erik 20:15, 7 January 2013 (UTC) delete per the |notability guidelines for future films. There's no indication that this is a film that is in production Deletion of Halloween III (2013 film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
6969 635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TamannaC User:AllyD 08:31, 2 August 2016 (UTC) delete """Despite the Economic Times piece on women claiming to have special healing powers and coverage of the two actors present at her book launch (apparently """"elated"""" to be part of the event, no less), I am not seeing |reliable evidence of |notability. If the launch-publicity coverage was to be considered as substantial (contrary to my opinion), then there is a consideration, as the vast majority of the article is non-encyclopaedic""" Deletion of TamannaC :WP:RS||:WP:BASIC||:WP:TNT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6970 317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My BFF User:Ward3001 22:15, 3 October 2008 (UTC) delete per #Songs and Deletion of My BFF WP:MUSIC||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
6971 7109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/True North Blogcasting User:WilyD 13:29, 28 July 2006 (UTC) delete but I disagree with nom. Should be deleted because it fails Deletion of True North Blogcasting WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
6972 9622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph wagstaff User:Mendaliv 20:35, 31 March 2009 (UTC) keep May meet . Needs wikification, research and some generous slicing out of personal details. A stub is fine. At worst, this should be |userfied. &mdash Deletion of Joseph wagstaff WP:MUSIC||WP:USERFY Wikipedia:Notability 77
6973 9893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2020 Franklinville Abductions User:Pichpich 21:40, 15 March 2020 (UTC) delete since |Wikipedia is not news, nor is it an Amber Alert system Deletion of 2020 Franklinville Abductions WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6974 18136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swami Shankarananda Saraswati (second nomination) User:Siva1979 03:20, 17 July 2007 (UTC) keep It is possible to find |reliable sources for this article. A http://www.google.com.sg/search?as_q=&hl=en&num=100&btnG=Google+Search&as_epq=Swami+Shankarananda+Saraswati&as_oq=&as_eq=wikipedia&lr=&as_ft=i&as_filetype=&as_qdr=all&as_occt=any&as_dt=i&as_sitesearch=&as_rights=&safe=images google search shows up quite a few reliable, published sources om the net. The article is also |verifiable. --|S Deletion of Swami Shankarananda Saraswati (second nomination) WP:RS||WP:V||WP:EA Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6975 121 [[Dieter Ber]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Dundak NONE delete Hier scheint meine Stimme verloren gegangen zu sein, also noch einmal: , ACK mit Uwe Gille, siehe Löschung von Dieter Ber Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
6976 11319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mock German User:Bearian 16:37, 5 October 2007 (UTC) delete Basically violates and . But I would change my mind and agree to keep if somebody else fixed it. (Not my cuppa tea Deletion of Mock German WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
6977 4263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Venaculas (2nd nomination) User:Artene50 19:08, 22 June 2012 (UTC) delete Most of the sources are not independent and the listed web links are connected to this band in some way Deletion of Venaculas (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
6978 483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asumiko Nakamura User:Cavarrone 07:41, 29 May 2016 (UTC) keep per , after https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Asumiko_Nakamura&action=historysubmit&type=revision&diff=722455717&oldid=722390128 the expansion it is clear that the subject passes GNG and NAUTHOR. Worth reminding the nominator her works being ''currently'' redlinked in en.wikipedia does not mean they are non-notable, and authors/works which are notable in Japan are perfectly suitable for having articles in en.wiki Deletion of Asumiko Nakamura WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
6979 4934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islam and pork User:Khorshid 09:07, 24 March 2007 (UTC) comment """I hate to tell you guys going for """"merge"""" this, but there is literally ''nothing'' of value in this article to merge. The only two links are to a Google search for """"pork + islam"""" and a blog (see ). So whats with people voting """"merge""""??? Weird""" Deletion of Islam and pork WP:BLOG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
6980 11040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lori Ann LaRocco User:Clarityfiend 06:41, 20 April 2015 (UTC) delete """Senior Talent Producer"""" apparently means """"booker""""http://www.forbes.com/2010/03/08/new-economy-business-finanace-forbes-woman-leadership-lori-ann-larocco.html (i.e. lining up guests), and being one for an early morning CNBC show isn't going to satisfy """ Deletion of Lori Ann LaRocco WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6981 13793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Jewish American entertainers User:DustFormsWords 05:28, 30 November 2010 (UTC) keep Non-trivial intersection and perfectly allowable under . What on earth is happening here? Did everyone drink the kool-aid? The criteria for allowable lists are immensely broad, and this one has a clearly defined scope and addresses an area of significant academic interest, namely the role of people of Jewish extraction in the American entertainment industry Deletion of List of Jewish American entertainers WP:SALAT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
6982 14674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shailesh Gupta User:Uncletomwood 09:47, 31 July 2016 (UTC) delete per Nominator, Fails . Notability isn't proved Deletion of Shailesh Gupta WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6983 10679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Redmond UK User:Blue520 13:40, 16 April 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Redmond UK WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6984 3138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Kelly (Entrepreneur) User:Dom 17:23, 7 July 2020 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Peter Kelly (Entrepreneur) WP: NOTLINKEDIN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
6985 11368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/India's Next Top Model (season 4) User:Mrschimpf 14:27, 29 October 2018 (UTC) keep Cycle is in progress and I'm not seeing issues that aren't dealt with through common warning and reverting or as has already been done, semi-protection. Also, the 'article creator' hasn't edited the article at all since creating it and I'm seeing nothing at all suggesting any sign of socking by them, nor any reach-out to them besides templating this nomination their way. Also, you can add sources yourself, so I don't know why you haven't done so rather than just reverting these contribs with a brusque 'come back when you have a source'. is needed, not deletion Deletion of India's Next Top Model (season 4) WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
6986 2843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CarProperty.com (2nd nomination) User:Kvng 22:02, 28 August 2020 (UTC) keep Easily clears new requirements Deletion of CarProperty.com (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
6987 11783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of guest stars on The Sonny & Cher Comedy Hour User:The 21:27, 30 August 2007 (UTC) delete I'm sorry but I think this is , and in regard to your question Richard Arthur Norton, I would say loosely associated would mean they are related because of something relativly non-notable or something that to many individuals belong to Deletion of List of guest stars on The Sonny & Cher Comedy Hour WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
6988 16562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Together Again (Jamahl Seden song) User:SummerPhD 19:24, 25 November 2008 (UTC) delete Yeah, the future/past confusion is an issue. In any case, does not meet #SONGS in any way. Not a hit, no coverage, etc Deletion of Together Again (Jamahl Seden song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6989 5672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The God That Failed (song) User:VasileGaburici NONE delete unless claims of notability are substantiated in the article. As it stands, it fails . Those claiming notability have to provide some details, not just vague claims that it's mentioned in some books, per Deletion of The God That Failed (song) WP:MUSIC||WP:BURDEN Wikipedia:Notability 77
6990 9613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Wallace Elementary School User:Kudpung 16:42, 26 September 2015 (UTC) merge to Halifax Regional School Board per . {{U|Derek Andrews|Nominator}} is evidently unaware of the years-old precedent evidenced by ''thousands'' of school AfD closed as redirect - one of the reasons why schools are exempt (per policy) from CSD A7 Deletion of Michael Wallace Elementary School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
6991 11302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Han shot first (4th nomination) User:SPNic 14:18, 11 September 2010 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Han shot first (4th nomination) WP:NOTAGAIN Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
6992 5479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Epsilon Iota Fraternity User:Truth 00:45, 26 July 2013 (UTC) delete Fails and alike. For what it's worth, the article has a balance problem and is poorly written too - it is not even clear what university(ies) this is about. But, no coverage anyway Deletion of Epsilon Iota Fraternity WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6993 13424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vipin Singh Maurha User:David 15:03, 23 September 2017 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails . Poorly sourced. Autobiography Deletion of Vipin Singh Maurha WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6994 14708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rosemarie Allen User:David 18:11, 28 January 2021 (UTC) keep She appears very far from passing any criterion, especially not #C1 https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=olDsSO4AAAAJ. And the article is puffed up with minor accomplishments and bad sources and should be trimmed to what can be found only in better sources. But two of the 21 sources listed in the article as nominated actually look to be in-depth, reliable, and independent: https://www.essence.com/in-her-we-trust/she-the-people-dr-rosemarie-allen-is-an-education-expert-who-wants-to-end-classroom-bias/ Essence and https://co.chalkbeat.org/2016/3/22/21092529/suspended-countless-times-as-a-child-this-professor-is-tackling-racial-disparities-in-preschool-disc Chalkbeat. So I think she scrapes out a pass of instead Deletion of Rosemarie Allen WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
6995 12633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Massimo Taccon User:NotButtigieg 11:09, 13 January 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Massimo Taccon WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
6996 13502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Non-productive activity User:Colonel 23:36, 27 August 2011 (UTC) delete The current content is wrong and tendentious. Determining what is or is not productive is a value judgement and so requires high-quality sources to avoid violating and . For example, the Marxist concept of non-productive activity would include finance and entrepreneurial activity of the capitalist kind. Or others might say that working on Wikipedia is non-productive because it is derivative and has no financial value. And don't get me started on whether AFD is productive Deletion of Non-productive activity WP:NPOV||WP:OR Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
6997 14151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bitcoin network analyzed by network science User:Wikimandia 04:02, 6 June 2015 (UTC) delete this is and can only ever be that Deletion of Bitcoin network analyzed by network science WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
6998 6296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miseria User:Esradekan 07:56, 15 February 2008 (UTC) delete Notability per Deletion of Miseria WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
6999 17679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wasl Asset Management Group User:The 18:40, 15 May 2020 (UTC) delete this |highly promotional text about a company that possesses no |independent notability. Most of what we have are advertorials, |self published verbiage, and name drops. Subject fails CORP Deletion of Wasl Asset Management Group WP:PROMO||WP:N||WP:SELF||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7000 2731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SN Systems User:Thibbs 12:35, 23 May 2013 (UTC) keep """Significant amount of RS coverage thus it meets the |GNG. Considering the length of the """"ProDG (software)"""" article, I see no problem with merging that one into """"SN Systems"""" for the time being, but there seems to be enough RS coverage of even """"ProDG (software)"""" to merit a standalone article down the road. Outright deletion of either article per the noms would be unhelpful""" Deletion of SN Systems WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7001 92 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ali Rıza Babaoğlan (2. aday gösterme) NONE 21:43, 21 Nisan 2013 (UTC) delete O zaman #Genel|G4. Daha önce silinmiş içeriğin büyük ölçüde aynısına sahip sayfalar silinebilir. uyarınca . --Kullanıcı mesaj:İncelemeelemani|i.e.Kullanıcı mesaj:İncelemeelemani|msj Ali Rıza Babaoğlan'ın silinmesi (2. gün Gösterme) yazısının silinmesi Vikipedi:HS Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
7002 14762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dheeraj Singh Moirangthem User:स 03:17, 12 October 2017 (UTC) comment I wonder that playing for a specific league is eligible for and but not for national team and FIFA tournaments. We need to review our policies Deletion of Dheeraj Singh Moirangthem WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
7003 12150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crocker Park User:Johnson8776 06:50, 1 December 2008 (UTC) comment Notwithstanding the sources added, I still think that it doesnt qualify for its own article. Sources are not reliable (in the sense that they are not '''independent''' WP:RS authored by 1) the company that owns Crocker Park and 2) the Crocker Park official site. In my opinion it does not satsify and is at odds with . I think that ''part'' of the article may be '''merged''' as a point of interest (as argued above), but on the whole it should '''not be redirected''' and be '''deleted Deletion of Crocker Park WP:CORP||WP:NOTADVERTISING Wikipedia:Notability 77
7004 1940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Dean (writer) User:Gongshow 01:15, 28 September 2017 (UTC) keep Coverage of this author's works in multiple reliable sources, which satisfies #3 Deletion of Josh Dean (writer) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
7005 14141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kid Mikaze User:Cwmhiraeth 13:56, 3 March 2017 (UTC) delete I did find http://www.onlineworldofwrestling.com/bios/k/kid-mikaze/ this profile but the subject fails to meet and and I am unable to find substantial outside sources showing notability Deletion of Kid Mikaze WP:GNG||WP:SPORTSPERSON Wikipedia:Notability 77
7006 13162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Byoblue [[User talk:(aeropagitica)|(aeropagitica)]] 21:38, 14 December 2006 (UTC) delete One particular hex colour used on a website? No claims as-to its notability, so delete because |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of Byoblue :WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7007 6529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of science fiction short stories User:Narky 11:14, 23 October 2018 (UTC) delete per . A total overlap with :Category:Science fiction short stories. Non-notable short stories would best be dealt with by {{tl|R from short story}} redirects categorised into that category and pointing to an article (author or collection) which mentions them. Other categories could also be added; that is commonplace with {{tl|R from song}} and the like, and helps navigation Deletion of List of science fiction short stories WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7008 8147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meta Knight User:Gavin 10:42, 25 January 2008 (UTC) delete as fails and the secondary sources do not provide any evidence of |notability Deletion of Meta Knight WP:NOT||WP:FICT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7009 14336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marco Leininger User:No 15:36, 14 November 2019 (UTC) delete Not entirely sure about the status of SK Austria Klagenfurt, but I understand they have never been fully pro so this player would fail on that basis. Even if he passes NFOOTY, there is nowhere near enough for the GNG Deletion of Marco Leininger WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
7010 21504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elijah Fields User:Cbl62 15:25, 14 August 2017 (UTC) keep Too many delete voters have not taken the time to check for sources. Fields is a clear pass with abundant significant coverage in multiple reliable news sources, including major metropolitan dailies such as the ''Pittsburgh Post-Gazette'' and ''Pittsburgh Tribune-Review'' as well as national sources such as ESPN.com and ''USA Today''. This is in addition to a whole lot of local coverage in his local hometown newspaper ''The Herald-Standard''. I suggest this be re-listed to allow folks to review newly-found sources Deletion of Elijah Fields WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7011 9363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arebhashe gowda User:Yamaguchi先生 20:26, 13 July 2016 (UTC) delete per Arjayay and others, this may qualify for speedy deletion #A10 under the circumstances. Regards Deletion of Arebhashe gowda WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
7012 14016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gin Wigmore User:BigDunc 14:14, 15 April 2008 (UTC) delete no notable and fails Deletion of Gin Wigmore WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7013 6073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Allington User:Inter 02:29, 16 June 2018 (UTC) delete as per above fails the notability requirements, at the age of 18 this is obviously and article can always be recreated if and when subject meets said notability guidelines Deletion of Sam Allington WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
7014 1495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Milcho Angelov User:Sir 15:10, 14 November 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage. As such, the article fails both and Deletion of Milcho Angelov WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7015 4966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John C. Bambenek User:Corpx 03:57, 12 July 2007 (UTC) delete those articles have to be about him, not mention him or quote his thoughts about a subject. See for more info Deletion of John C. Bambenek WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
7016 2821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hickey Ranch User:Bearian 23:22, 13 November 2020 (UTC) delete per - it used to be a ranch Deletion of Hickey Ranch WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
7017 14250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Subdued Sound (Book) User:Tokyogirl79 08:50, 2 April 2013 (UTC) delete """A search brings up nothing that would show that this book passes in any format. It might be speedyable as a promotion for the book, given the language used (""""Poet Shariq Us Sabah dips his thoughts in love and paints the pages with his emotions""""). I'll tag it as such, but in case it isn't deleted I wanted to voice my arguments for deletion""" Deletion of The Subdued Sound (Book) WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
7018 3964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Games Research Inc user:Andrew 09:58, 9 February 2021 (UTC) keep per the excellent evidence provided by Cunard above. Our numerous policies clearly indicate that deletion is not appropriate and include , , , , , &c Deletion of Games Research Inc WP:ATD||WP:IMPERFECT||WP:NEXIST||WP:NOTPAPER||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
7019 9078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sri Krishna Chaitanya Mission User:Stifle 21:34, 6 May 2008 (UTC) delete The lack of |citations from |reliable sources indicates to me that the article fails to comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Sri Krishna Chaitanya Mission WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7020 17796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of Kitty Pryde User:Archrogue 21:10, 27 September 2020 (UTC) merge I can see how this is redundant with the Kitty Pryde article with not much to cover outside of various plot summaries and excerpts. But there has been a consistent practice to merge comic characters with similar non-notable spinouts. See the AFDs for: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of Gambit|Gambit, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of Storm|Storm, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of Jean Grey|Jean Grey, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of Venom|Venom, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of the Thing|The Thing, and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of Rogue|Rogue, all of which were '''merged''' or '''redirected'''. Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of Daredevil|Daredevil was deleted, but that's an outlier. I'm sure I missed a few others. I think we should always strive to and use |alternatives to deletion. (Pardon the copy-paste rationale, which I used at a similar AFD for Deadpool, but the rationale is truly about consistent best practice across many similar articles Deletion of Alternative versions of Kitty Pryde WP:PRESERVE||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
7021 16826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Charles Whitman's victims User:Hit 13:34, 20 April 2007 (UTC) keep this is a textbook #PAPER situation, since the information is factual and verifiable, and it enhances our coverage of the topic Deletion of List of Charles Whitman's victims WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7022 12788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siege of Gordium User:Xymmax 22:23, 14 November 2008 (UTC) delete This completely fails . I too have searched independently for sources and simply cannot find reference to any siege conducted by Alexander or his proxies here at all. It does not even seem to be a topic of speculation for historians Deletion of Siege of Gordium WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7023 6797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of international matches umpired by Marais Erasmus [[User talk:IgnorantArmies|IgnorantArmies]] [[User talk:IgnorantArmies|(talk)]]''' 12:26, 29 October 2016 (UTC) delete """per , , and – """"Wikipedia is not a directory of everything in the universe that exists or has existed"""". There are at least two publicly available websites that list this information, and I'm sure anyone looking for a list of matches officiated by a particular umpire will already be aware of both of those""" Deletion of List of international matches umpired by Marais Erasmus WP:NOTSTATS||WP:NOTMIRROR||WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7024 190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ThreePeace User:Whpq 21:33, 14 July 2009 (UTC) delete There is no coverage in independent |reliable sources to establish |notability. None of the material identified as references in the article or noted in this discussiion establish notability Deletion of ThreePeace WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7025 19707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tribute to Nordberg NONE NONE delete Self-promotion. Does not meet otability (music)#Criteria for musicians and ensembles|notability criteria for musicians and ensembles Deletion of Tribute to Nordberg WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7026 10168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hedgeye Risk Management User:K 03:23, 7 December 2018 (UTC) delete """does not meet ; significant RS coverage not found. In re sources mentioned above, Bloomberg is a non-editorial directory listing, while Forbes is actually Forbes.com/sites which is a """"contributor""""-submitted area (non-editorial). Neither is suitable for establishing notability""" Deletion of Hedgeye Risk Management WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
7027 8105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheikh Jamal Dhanmondi Club in Asian Football User:Fenix 17:14, 18 February 2016 (UTC) comment I'm happy to merge as consensus if |de-statted Deletion of Sheikh Jamal Dhanmondi Club in Asian Football WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7028 18319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ese Stacey User:Jytdog 03:37, 24 May 2017 (UTC) keep I spent some time and pretty much completely re-did this, so the TNT is addressed. There was a bunch of unsourced content that just cannot be in WP per and . I think there is just enough left to keep, but it is a close call. I would not be surprised if others !vote delete Deletion of Ese Stacey WP:BLP||WP:V Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
7029 20418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kigo (Kim Possible) User:Davidpdx 12:24, 1 January 2007 (UTC) delete I agree this is fan fiction and should be deleted under Deletion of Kigo (Kim Possible) WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
7030 432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denis Smyth User:TenPoundHammer 16:08, 19 May 2007 (UTC) delete as #A7, seeing as no third party mentions are found Deletion of Denis Smyth WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
7031 9151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marilyn Schlitz User:Seofon 14:51, 20 May 2014 (UTC) delete """this article treats the oxymoronically named """"Institute for Noetic Science"""" as a serious academic enterprise, and lavishes praise upon this woman as being involved in said enterprise. Unfortunately the with half a brain can see through the nonsense that is """"noetic science"""". Fails , might meet if additional sources can be found, but delete until then. Additional notes (1) there's a copy of this at""" Deletion of Marilyn Schlitz WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7032 2965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luma Health User:Bearian 01:34, 19 October 2019 (UTC) keep Well, here's my two cents: a few of the sources are merely listings (''e.g.'' Bloomberg), while others (''WSJ'', Business review/journal articles; medical journal) are both |reliable and substantial. I'm leaning towards keeping because, overall, there is in fact |significant coverage of the corporation and its services Deletion of Luma Health WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7033 12349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marty Nemko User:Rameshnta909 19:38, 17 December 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Marty Nemko WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7034 16222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pornograph User:Scorpiondollprincess 19:12, 19 July 2006 (UTC) delete """as and . The only source provided (""""Emily Chesley Reading Circle"""") yields Ghits describing the site as """"parody and humor,"""" and """"hoaxes, pranks, practical jokes, frauds, tricks, and other forms of deception."""" Wikipedia describes the The Emily Chesley Reading Circle|site as """"a group of Canadian writers who have perpetrated a hoax."""" Hardly a |reliable source""" Deletion of Pornograph WP:HOAX||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
7035 17561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trap Nation User:Snowycats 04:38, 15 July 2018 (UTC) keep Passes , popular music channel that has many RS Deletion of Trap Nation WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7036 17834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethan Cooper User:SportingFlyer 17:11, 26 September 2018 (UTC) delete fails , the articles written on him above are routine articles from papers local to either his high school or the team he signed as an undrafted free agent with and were written in the same week. All other stories are routine transactional announcements Deletion of Ethan Cooper WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
7037 13224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Breast cancer campaign User:Potatoswatter 17:55, 24 May 2008 (UTC) comment """Although most AfDs follow arguments of notability, this does not. The problem with this article is systemic bias, even if you can't """"see"""" it. At best it duplicates material from the Campaign's website. Interested readers should go to that website if they want that information. It is not a positive contribution here. This article looks fine, but #The problem with autobiographies is that there is no problem. Along with the verifiable broad stokes will be the embellishments of an insider. This organization does deserve an article, but the article should be written by Wikipedians with proper standards""" Deletion of Breast cancer campaign WP:AB Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
7038 1869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC 83 User:Dreaded 03:29, 6 January 2008 (UTC) delete """per . Since this AfD was filed, the venue for the event http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=UFC_83&diff=182451026&oldid=182449694 has moved half-way around the world, """"supported"""" by a ref that doesn't contain any mention of UFC 83""" Deletion of UFC 83 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7039 16167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karl Dehesa User:Babymissfortune 12:51, 22 December 2017 (UTC) keep Easily passes WP:GNG although the PBA may not appear in list of leagues. He also played on the FIBA 3x3 world tour. Happy holidays Deletion of Karl Dehesa WP:NBASKETBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
7040 15365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Integration Point User:I42 21:38, 27 July 2009 (UTC) delete The nature of the business is such that it's unlikely to get much coverage in mainstream press, but that does not remove the requirement that there be third party references to establish notability. The references provided are weak - there's a passing mention, articles by members of the company or sponsored by the company and one substantial article - which appears to be a blog. The fact that the article is written from with an obvious raises further questions about notability Deletion of Integration Point WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
7041 10376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chiratae Ventures User:Tayi 01:42, 31 August 2020 (UTC) comment I'll have to agree in part that the coverage of the company does not seem to meet at least with the sources shown till now which have a greater requirements of coverage than to be considered notable Deletion of Chiratae Ventures WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7042 4990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gurumaa User:Iain99 14:41, 27 July 2007 (UTC) keep based on recent edits. http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Gurumaa&oldid=147325882 This version is just about OK, but edits like http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Gurumaa&oldid=146546860 this one are pure promotion. Note that to comply with |NPOV her teachings need to be clearly labelled as teachings, not described as fact Deletion of Gurumaa WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
7043 13458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oregon Progressive Party User:E 21:29, 7 May 2019 (UTC) keep """arguably enough gNews hits https://www.google.com/search?q=%22oregon+progressive+party%22&safe=active&client=firefox-b-1-d&source=lnms&tbm=nws&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiK4r_UrIriAhUpqlkKHeTKBc4Q_AUIDigB&biw=1731&bih=1099 for this tiny party to scrape past by the skin of it's teeth. But note that some of this news hits are for older """"progressive"""" parties, some are trivial, and the sources now in the article consist of 1 dead link, links ot the govt agency that monitors elections, and to the party itself. Woefully inadequate sourcing""" Deletion of Oregon Progressive Party WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7044 7015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disappearance of Joanna Yeates User:Smartse 20:10, 1 January 2011 (UTC) keep """per #Inclusion criteria, most significantly """"Events are also very likely to be notable if they have widespread (national or international) impact and were very widely covered in diverse sources"""" which I think it meets. means we won't have an article on a murder case http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-12102578 like this one reported earlier today, but for a case that has achieved so much coverage, we should have an article""" Deletion of Disappearance of Joanna Yeates WP:EVENT||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
7045 20849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Masonville Place User:Uzma 14:55, 27 August 2012 (UTC) keep """Larger malls impact a lot of peoples lives and take up lots of space in a community, so reliable sources tend to write about larger malls and events at large malls. An assumption that reliable sources tend to write about larger malls and events at large malls is why larger malls are generally considered to be notable. In this case, while there are a number of articles that mention Masonville Place, I didn't find any article that discussed Masonville Place itself in detail. Most of them are about events at Masonville Place, which usually are more newsy than encyclopedic. However, with enough coverage from such event articles, there usually is enought bits and piece of a topic (Masonville Place) from which to cobble together a Wikipedia article on Masonville Place from relaible sources. Some Wikipedian's don't think that is enought, particularly since specifically says """"received significant coverage,"""" so there's difference of opinions on this (hence my weak keep). I found only one article with Masonville Place in the title, but that was a press release and didn't really focus on Masonville Place itsef.http://www.newswire.ca/fr/story/373431/the-heart-stroke-put-your-heart-into-it-tour-is-making-a-stop-at-masonville-place""" Deletion of Masonville Place WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7046 2555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valdas Pocevičius User:Mkdw 22:13, 2 February 2013 (UTC) delete Nomination is solid against . No top tier fights, let alone 3, as described at . No significant coverage outside for his events and does not meet as the alternate policy Deletion of Valdas Pocevičius WP:NMMA||WP:MMATIER||WP:ROUTINE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7047 13795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Repellor vehicle User:Northamerica1000 09:33, 9 September 2011 (UTC) keep """spaced ndash}}The article may have some forms of in it, which would need to be corrected by editing, not deletion of the entire article. The initial rationale for deletion of the article as having or being comprised of """"original synthesis"""" inherent in the article is not enough to qualify blanket deletion. A topic's merits are based upon |General notability guidelines regarding reliable sources, not the prose within the article. To start, refer to this simple Google search http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&biw=1590&bih=777&q=Repellor+vehicle&oq=Repellor+vehicle&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&gs_sm=s&gs_upl=0l0l0l728203l0l0l0l0l0l0l0l0ll0l0 here. Books exist about the topic, refer to: http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/robotics-introduction-source-source-wikipedia/1103864852, http://www.amazon.co.uk/Unmanned-Ground-Vehicles-Autonomous-Driverless/dp/1155977025 and http://www.lybrary.com/driverless-technology-highimpact-emerging-technology-what-need-know-definitions-adoptions-impact-benefits-p-116996.html. Here's a link to an article about a repellor tank, which is a type of repellor vehicle: http://mocpages.com/moc.php/26063. These sources were found with ease after some simple searches, and there are very likely more sources available. It appears that the nominator didn't follow the guidelines listed in for source searching prior to nominating this article for deletion, which nullifies the basis of nomination for deletion, as does using the article's content as qualification for deletion, rather than the availability of sources""" Deletion of Repellor vehicle WP:SYNTHESIS||WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:No original research 65
7048 7453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayors of Teaneck, New Jersey (2nd nomination) User:Richard 20:08, 9 December 2017 (UTC) keep See: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayors of Teaneck, New Jersey closed less than an hour ago as keep, the concerns articles, not lists, and there is no mention of 40,000 anywhere in the GNG. If Teaneck, New Jersey article can have a list of mayors and it is too large, it gets its own standalone list Deletion of Mayors of Teaneck, New Jersey (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7049 15656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christmas Special 2009 User:Valerian456 09:50, 15 April 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Christmas Special 2009 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7050 869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cage Rage 11 User:Mdtemp 16:30, 24 May 2013 (UTC) delete The previous comments have said it all--there's merely routine sports coverage of events that fail Deletion of Cage Rage 11 WP:SPORTSEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
7051 10173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/University of Alabama in Huntsville varsity tennis team Playboy controversy User:Bobby 21:42, 24 May 2010 (UTC) delete Article subject is not notable for one event per , and is not notable as an athlete per ...she has not competed above college-level or participated in the Olympics. And this article title is somewhat misleading...the article is about one tennis player at the University of Alabama in Huntsville, not the whole team (which is where BLP comes in Deletion of University of Alabama in Huntsville varsity tennis team Playboy controversy WP:NOTNEWS||WP:ATH Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7052 7823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yadunandana Swami User:Xxanthippe 21:40, 20 February 2011 (UTC) delete Fails rof and sources are not adequate for anything else Deletion of Yadunandana Swami WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
7053 17731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alwayz Recording User:Kirbanzo 15:26, 6 May 2019 (UTC) delete fails . Appears to rely on |inherited notability. Kirbanzo Deletion of Alwayz Recording WP:NCORP||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
7054 20996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shulamit Almog User:Xxanthippe 22:06, 21 February 2010 (UTC) keep provisionally. Few GS cites, some books, editor-in-chief of some journals may pass rof #8. The nominator's claim that the article is under-sourced is ridiculous. There are ample sources: whether they are sufficient for notability remains to be decided Deletion of Shulamit Almog WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
7055 15309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akoustic Odyssey User:JamesBurns 09:20, 8 March 2009 (UTC) delete Lots of Google hits but mostly from blogs, download sites and MySpace. Nothing major of note. Deletion of Akoustic Odyssey WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
7056 11092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TalentLMS User:Piotrus 08:23, 4 December 2017 (UTC) delete Not seeing quality sources - PR/business as usual level of coverage only. Seems to fail Deletion of TalentLMS WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
7057 14612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harriet Yeo User:Just 12:51, 7 July 2019 (UTC) keep """the preamble to states """"It is a generally accepted standard that editors should attempt to follow, though it is best treated with common sense, and occasional exceptions may apply."""" In this case I think that the significant posts that this person has held means that in any real-world sense she is notable and, if necessary, she should be one of the """"occasional exceptions""" Deletion of Harriet Yeo WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7058 19555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boungcloud Attack User:Sjakkalle 08:59, 3 April 2008 (UTC) delete """Articles on chess openings are excellent for those openings where some professional has provided some analysis, or where it is played a lot. Now, in all fairness this opening ''has'' been played according to ChessBase (http://www.chesslive.de/), but with only six examples, and those examples probably being some silly joke in junior tournaments, that is not """"played much"""". There is no professional analysis or other reliable coverage for such a ridiculous and obscure move either. (Although I should say that """"ridiculous"""" and """"has reliable coverage"""" are not mutually exclusive concepts, e.g. Barnes Opening has reliable coverage in the ''Oxford Companion to Chess''.) If openings like this, which were |made up one day are accepted, then I should perhaps play 1.h4 and follow it through with 2.Rh2, and call the result the """"Sjakkalle Attack"""". (But then again, maybe not, I take the Hordaland Circuit Championship this weekend more seriously than that""" Deletion of Boungcloud Attack WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
7059 5820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Celebrity Sleuth User:Raaggio 16:54, 9 April 2010 (UTC) delete I don't even know how this article hasn't been eyed for deletion in a whole year; the subject is clearly not notable. I suggest a speedy delete per Deletion of Celebrity Sleuth WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
7060 453 [[Bahnhof Düsseldorf-Eller Mitte]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Global Fish NONE delete Nach #Schienenverkehr und Portal:Bahn/Anforderungen_an_Bahnartikel#Bahnhof soll ein eigener Artikel *nur* angelegt werden, wenn historische, architektonische oder verkehrstechnische Alleinstellungsmerkmale vorliegen und der Bahnhof nicht sinnvoll in einem Strecken- oder Übersichtsartikel abgehandelt werden kann. Die Alleinstellungsmerkmale liegen nicht vor, eine Unterbringung in einem Übersichtsartikel ist dagegen möglich (siehe z.B. den Vorschlag von Löschung von Bahnhof Düsseldorf-Eller Mitte Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
7061 11484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lifestyle X'nter User:The 07:00, 13 June 2012 (UTC) delete fails , is Deletion of Lifestyle X'nter WP:GNG||WP:RUNOFTHEMILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
7062 7628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rexhep Demi User:Tadija 16:52, 8 January 2010 (UTC) delete Completely nothing in books and literature. Also, fails otability. Not every signature is internationally important Deletion of Rexhep Demi WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7063 6283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/East Egg Realty User:Stuartyeates 21:10, 25 November 2011 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of East Egg Realty WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
7064 2377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gianni Cicogna User:Fosse8 10:01, 13 April 2012 (UTC) delete non-notable session musician and music teacher, no reliable sources and no indication of notability. Fails GNG and Deletion of Gianni Cicogna WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7065 9183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Sandefer User:Acdixon 00:24, 9 September 2008 (UTC) comment I am trying to educate this user on wiki-principles. Not sure he meets notability guidelines, but I'd ask for at least a couple of days for him to try and prove notability before the article is deleted. I have found him very in his discussions with me Deletion of Michael Sandefer WP:CIVIL Wikipedia:Civility 37
7066 5007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nisha JamVwal User:RegentsPark 14:30, 31 July 2014 (UTC) delete Can't find anything other than the TOI article. As Redtigerxyz says, that's one award and not a significant one. The links at the bottom of the article are all not really sources. And, merely being a reporter for a newspaper is nowhere near sufficient for Deletion of Nisha JamVwal WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
7067 713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdurrahman Roza Haxhiu User:GiantSnowman 16:27, 23 September 2009 (UTC) delete fails and . Having something named after you doesn't infer notability Deletion of Abdurrahman Roza Haxhiu WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7068 9581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gender stereotypes in Television Commercials User:Ohnoitsjamie 02:28, 10 December 2010 (UTC) delete Nothing but |original research Deletion of Gender stereotypes in Television Commercials WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
7069 8329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David MacLean [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']][[User talk:(aeropagitica)|''' (talk) ''']] 14:56, 14 June 2006 (UTC) delete Fanzine editor banned from football ground - not really notable according to Deletion of David MacLean WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7070 7188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barack Obama substance abuse controversy User:Allstarecho 04:08, 24 May 2009 (UTC) delete Created to make a by a user who nommed George W. Bush substance abuse controversy for deletion via Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George W. Bush substance abuse controversy|this Afd Deletion of Barack Obama substance abuse controversy WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
7071 10444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Restaurantslang User:Lilac 21:31, 8 March 2009 (UTC) delete WP:NOTDICT, , and all apply here Deletion of Restaurantslang WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
7072 6380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Purser User:Lightburst 15:54, 5 November 2019 (UTC) delete Does not pass Deletion of David Purser WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
7073 7285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grail (DC Comics) (2nd nomination) User:Colonel 16:47, 1 August 2009 (UTC) keep WP:DISRUPT|Disruptive renomination contrary to |deletion policy by an editor who already been sanctioned for disruptive nominations Deletion of Grail (DC Comics) (2nd nomination) WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
7074 7397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fatz Belvedere User:Rms125a 11:26, 26 September 2015 (UTC) delete as noted above, he fails , , and Deletion of Fatz Belvedere WP:GNG||WP:ENT||WP:CRIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
7075 11276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 Cowboys Classic User:Paulmcdonald 14:34, 9 October 2014 (UTC) merge 17 games are presently under and responses are being cut and pasted. These topics should be combined before further discussion and certainly before closing the issue Deletion of 2012 Cowboys Classic WP:AFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
7076 21041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Vandersteen User:Mrschimpf 23:22, 6 March 2021 (UTC) delete My local mayor, but he does indeed fair ; his mayoral run is purposefully stunted (as will future mayors of my community) due to the actions of Bob Ryan (mayor)|Bob Ryan, where an anonymous city administrator now does most of the city's day-to-day business Deletion of Mike Vandersteen WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
7077 4170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The World Factbook list of developed countries User:Bearian 18:29, 22 April 2019 (UTC) delete per . This is a mere restatement of what's in a publically available source, now long out of date Deletion of The World Factbook list of developed countries WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7078 19948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American hip hop User:Noian 01:33, 9 March 2010 (UTC) delete Agree with nomination. Barely referenced, original version failed , content fork, etc. etc. This article if rewritten would have be hard pressed to not be based on individuals opinions like the old version failing Deletion of American hip hop WP:OR||WP:BLP||WP:RS||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
7079 13860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nenad Antanasijević User:doomsdayer520 15:31, 6 June 2021 (UTC) merge to Piloti (band). His largely unknown activities after Piloti have received no |reliable and significant media coverage and do not need to be listed here Deletion of Nenad Antanasijević WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
7080 7000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Superstudio (company) User:K 05:15, 27 January 2018 (UTC) delete borders on A7; no incoming links. The awards listed are not significant or well known. or most likely never Deletion of Superstudio (company) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
7081 19256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Four Seasons Total Landscaping press conference User:Bearian 17:36, 13 November 2020 (UTC) keep per - ongoing, widespread commentary exists for this incident, which in many ways the media has taken to be representative of the Trump 2020 campaign. Since it is likely that so will historians and Americans in years hence, ''recentism'' doesn't apply. I agree with {{U|JoBrodie}}, {{U|Daniel Case}} {{U|Fippe}}, {{U|Saimouer}}, {{U|Hoary}}, {{U|TheMusicExperimental}}, {{U|Bazonka}}, and {{U|Acousmana}} in particular. |The consensus appears to be to keep Deletion of Four Seasons Total Landscaping press conference WP:HEY||WP:CCC Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
7082 5958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Khalife User:Pharaoh 18:27, 30 December 2020 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Peter Khalife WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7083 17039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Henderson (weightlifter) (2nd nomination) User:RonSigPi 04:08, 14 November 2016 (UTC) delete I have seen in Olympic sports competitors in World Championships not be presumed notable. This includes swimming and wrestling that, like weightlifting, do not have sport specific guidelines. While I tend to view World Championships as meeting , I don't see continental competitions and the like rising to that level. Can we really presume that sources exist to meet for all competitors at say the 1971 Asian Weightlifting Championships? I just see no evidence of that coverage existing and nothing has been provided to convinced me that such coverage can be presumed to exist. Also, this is a British/Welsh weightlifter that competed at the most recent European Championships. English online sources, if they exist, should be relatively easy to find since it's his native language and the sources would not have rotted yet. I did my own search and all I could find even remotely worthwhile was this - http://www.dailypost.co.uk/sport/other-sport/holyhead-continues-shine-world-weightlifting-9419411. And I still find that source routine. The rest appeared to be from pages of weightlifting governing bodies, so not independent sources. Unless the sources are found, then delete Deletion of Sam Henderson (weightlifter) (2nd nomination) WP:ATH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7084 19011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Little Fighter Online User:Starblind 02:31, 20 August 2007 (UTC) delete per and . Dhartung said it best so far Deletion of Little Fighter Online WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7085 3940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mindspace User:K 21:14, 17 February 2017 (UTC) delete per : strictly advertorial content, with no indications of notability or significance Deletion of Mindspace WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7086 10415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/European Academy of Sciences User:Wm335td 19:23, 2 January 2020 (UTC) keep sources exist. Epstein has found one. https://www.nature.com/articles/419865a ''Nature''. Deletion of European Academy of Sciences WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
7087 2699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Come Alive (Leona Lewis song) User:Trevj 15:42, 6 February 2013 (UTC) merge """to Glassheart, per . The coverage is not {{tq|more than a trivial mention}}.http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/music/news/a389265/leona-lewis-discusses-new-tracks-at-hackney-weekend.html Leona Lewis discusses new tracks at Hackney Weekend - Music News - Digital Spyhttp://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/jqpn BBC - Music - Review of Leona Lewis - Glasshearthttp://www.digitalspy.co.uk/music/thesound/a409004/leona-lewis-new-album-glassheart-first-listen.html Leona Lewis new album 'Glassheart': First listen - Music News - Digital Spyhttp://www.musicrooms.net/music/news/leona-lewis-inspired-faithless/2897/ Leona Lewis inspired by Faithless | Musicrooms.nethttp://www.digitalspy.co.uk/music/news/a431581/leona-lewis-faithless-inspired-new-album-glassheart.html Leona Lewis: 'Faithless inspired new album Glassheart' - Music News - Digital Spyhttp://www.digitalspy.co.uk/music/albumreviews/a430007/leona-lewis-glassheart-album-review.html Leona Lewis: 'Glassheart' - Album review - Music Album Review - Digital Spyhttp://www.virginmedia.com/music/reviews/leona-lewis-glassheart.php Leona Lewis: Glassheart Album Review - Reviews - Music - Virgin Mediahttp://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2012/oct/11/leona-lewis-glassheart-review Leona Lewis: Glassheart – review | Music | The Guardianhttp://www.thenational.ae/arts-culture/music/leona-lewiss-glassheart Leona Lewis's Glassheart - The Nationalhttp://steveandersonproductions.com/leona-lewis-at-hackney/ Leona Lewis At Hackneyhttp://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-312837130.html Good, but playing safe | Daily Post (Liverpool)http://www.shangay.com/nota/30224/critica-glassheart-de-leona-lewis Crítica - """"Glassheart"""" - de Leona Lewishttp://www.hitchecker.de/gehoert/cd-mp3/2236-leona-lewis-glassheart-cd-kritik.html Scherben-Risiko: Beats gefährden Leonas Herz aus Glashttp://www.ireport.cz/recenze/16488-recenze-leona-lewis-se-na-glassheart-posouva-vpred-jen-po-ma-lu.html RECENZE: Leona Lewis se na Glassheart posouvá vpřed jen po-ma-luhttp://www.4music.com/news/news/4957/Leona-Lewis-premieres-album-track-Come-Alive Leona Lewis premieres album track Come Alive | 4Music Consideration of stand-alone existence (as a split from the album) is not ''solely'' limited to the - however, that's close in this case (37 kB, 6329 words """"readable prose size"""" for ''Glassheart'')... but independent notability isn't established""" Deletion of Come Alive (Leona Lewis song) WP:GNG||WP:SIZERULE Wikipedia:Notability 77
7088 8393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahad's Constant User:Themfromspace 00:43, 22 March 2009 (UTC) delete I'm here from ANI, where this was just brought up along with http://www.publishedauthors.org/chatter-box-f3/cast-your-votes-for-ahad-s-constant-t1979.htm evidence of canvassing. This doesn't meet and the article as stands is |original research Deletion of Ahad's Constant WP:NEO||WP:OR Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
7089 14658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Winnit Club User:Gnangarra 01:32, 17 February 2014 (UTC) keep created by new user through the processeshttps://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Winnit_Club&diff=566021588&oldid=566020567 one doesnt need to on notability its already jump through those hoops. If one happened to miss the reference section it was the primary subject of a book in 1971http://trove.nla.gov.au/work/157832147, its apparently been the source and driving force behind significant projects, many notable in their right on the Island Deletion of Winnit Club WP:AFC||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Articles for creation 55
7090 13949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silver Sky User:Pixelface 09:53, 25 August 2007 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a collection of |unverifiable |speculation. No sources whatsoever Deletion of Silver Sky WP:V||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7091 20168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gliese 546 User:Praemonitus 23:34, 31 July 2013 (UTC) merge to List of stars in Boötes per : Doesn't satisfy WP:NASTRO or WP:GNG. No significant content found in suitable publications Deletion of Gliese 546 WP:NASTHELP Wikipedia:Notability 77
7092 7481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ferrari SP12 EC User:The 18:45, 29 May 2012 (UTC) keep A lack of refernces in the article is not grounds for deletion; |AfD is not for cleanup. Although based on the 458 Italia, this is a distinct model of its own (it's no different than, say, the Dodge Caravan and Plymouth Voyager - same chassis and kit) and it meets the . References added to the article accordingly Deletion of Ferrari SP12 EC WP:NOTCLEANUP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
7093 10999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Irish supercentenarians User:Oculi 16:38, 6 April 2019 (UTC) keep there seems to be an assumption that anything to do with the GRG should be deleted. There were several similar ill-considered noms at cfd recently. It is hardly or Deletion of List of Irish supercentenarians WP:SYNTHESIS||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:No original research 65
7094 12452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of mayors of Altamonte Springs, Florida User:Bearcat 13:32, 1 April 2021 (UTC) delete Regardless of any differences of opinion on whether the notability of the individual people in the list is a valid argument for deletion of the list or not, what a list of people ''definitely'' still needs to be is |properly referenced so that the information can be properly |verified as ''accurate''. But there are no sources here at all, the fact that there are large ''gaps'' in the information (some periods where no mayor is listed at all, and some mayors who are missing one or both of their start and end dates) demonstrates that the person who created this didn't actually use very solid sourcing in the first place since any genuinely worthy or reliable source would have ''filled in'' said gaps, and keeping a completely unsourced list of almost entirely non-notable people is not part of our mandate Deletion of List of mayors of Altamonte Springs, Florida WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7095 10544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luke Hemmings User:Dragonfire 12:05, 24 April 2014 (UTC) merge Clearly Colapeninsula is right. I would also add Deletion of Luke Hemmings WP:INHERIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
7096 9725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islam inside Hungarians User:Ihcoyc 14:34, 14 March 2007 (UTC) delete for reasons stated, and for apparent |original research. Bemusing title, though Deletion of Islam inside Hungarians WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
7097 21395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henk Keilman User:AKS 13:29, 15 July 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Henk Keilman WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7098 14649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eyewitness identification User:Edison 21:06, 8 January 2011 (UTC) keep """The question here is whether the topic is |notable. http://www.google.com/search?tbs=bks:1&tbo=p&q=%22eyewitness+identification%22&num=10#sclient=psy&hl=en&safe=off&tbs=bks:1&q=%22eyewitness+identification%22&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai=&pbx=1&fp=fc8aae4abccfd483 Hundreds of scholarly books and http://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_q=%22eyewitness+identification%22&num=10&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=&as_publication=&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_sdt=1.&as_sdtp=on&as_sdts=14&hl=en thousands of scholarly articles in peer-reviewed journals about eyewitness testimony amply demonstrate that the subject has received """"significant coverage in multiple reliable and independent sources."""" Rather than """"delete and restart from scratch,"""" try editing out anything which violates POV or which has |undue weight. This does not mean that the position that """"eyewitness testimony is nearly always right"""" should receive equal space. The information in the article is generally in accord with a vast number of published academic studies of the past 30 years or longer, showing that eyewitness testimony is often wrong, and that witnesses can be adamant in their incorrect identification of an accused person""" Deletion of Eyewitness identification WP:N||WP:NPOV||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Notability 77
7099 5579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chili cheese burrito User:Dennisthe2 17:28, 10 June 2008 (UTC) delete Aside from the POV problem, I think I see a Deletion of Chili cheese burrito WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
7100 2822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GeoDaSilva User:Bdell555 11:36, 16 June 2008 (UTC) keep """I created this article because while I was travelling in the Balkans, this guy seemed to be all over the radio and in the clubs. He accordingly satisfied the necessary and sufficient condition #11 so I created the article, thinking the rest of the world could be informed. He's from Romania, not Belgrade or even Serbia, so the argument that this guy is just a Belgrade phenomenon doesn't make sense. His presence on a CD titled http://www.tulumba.com/storeItem.asp?ic=MU901312CE683 """"Number 1 Hits 2008"""" marketed by a Turkish label is evidence he's big in Istanbul as well (or hit #1 somewhere else than just Belgrade). Google """"Geo Da Silva"""" and count the hits. Anyway, reject if you will, but do so for relevant reasons. If one thinks sourcing could be different, that's an argument for editing or deleted what's sourced, not the whole article""" Deletion of GeoDaSilva WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
7101 14373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josip Radošević User:Jogurney 03:35, 28 December 2011 (UTC) keep Article passes since Radošević has played in the fully-pro Croatian top flight and it should easily pass as well. I spent one minute searching for a reference and added it to the article; it will be easy for someone to add others based on the number of google hits Deletion of Josip Radošević WP:NSPORTS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7102 79 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JIGC Group User:Schuym1 23:11, 13 December 2008 (UTC) delete Does not show notability per Deletion of JIGC Group WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
7103 10220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loni maratha Kunabi (2nd nomination) User:Joe 00:45, 14 June 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this community Deletion of Loni maratha Kunabi (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7104 606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticism of Judaism User:Jayjg 21:42, 20 June 2006 (UTC) delete """This is a completely non-encyclopedic article, and I have a hard time imagining how an expansion would improve it. It's a hodge-podge of random negative thoughts, most of them having nothing to do with Judaism, and consisting almost entirely of |original research. If the other """"Criticism of """" articles are like this, then they should be deleted too""" Deletion of Criticism of Judaism WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
7105 921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Cvetkovic User:ChrisTheDude 07:25, 28 September 2016 (UTC) delete """clearly fails which requires him to have played in a |fully pro league, which the Luxembourg league is not. No in-depth coverage in reliable independent sources. If {{u|Profooty33}} thinks the player has received such coverage it would be helpful if he could point to some examples, rather than essentially saying """"just Google him"""". Of the refs currently in the article, most are match reports which mention him in passing or even don't mention him at all. Only one is centred on him and that is just a transfer announcement, which is |routine coverage and not enough to satisfy """ Deletion of Alex Cvetkovic WP:NSPORT||WP:FPL||WP:ROUTINE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7106 13431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NEC APC character set User:DreamLinker 20:45, 19 July 2017 (UTC) keep as this is a valuable article. Character sets are like historical artefacts and Wikipedia should try to preserve these. For example, we have List of Unicode characters. This particular set is from the 1980s, during the initial days of computing. There may be sources to pass which I am unable to access. Looking at the historical significance, I would suggest to keep it. I don't think merging is a good idea because there a lot of information here and the table could use a separate article Deletion of NEC APC character set WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7107 3380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TotalCon User:Welshboyau11 09:03, 6 September 2012 (UTC) delete Non-notable and does not meet Deletion of TotalCon WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
7108 19867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flyff (3rd nomination) User:Jasenm222 01:29, 19 September 2009 (UTC) comment """AFC is a process whereby a neutral third party is asked to create an article, based on some evidence of notability. """"The DMs asked me to write this"""" evidences some strong |conflict of interest. The fact that after two prior AfDs the """"article"""" is still basically a fluffy gamers guide with grossly excessive gaming information and in-universe narrative reflects the COI interests of primary author""" Deletion of Flyff (3rd nomination) :WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
7109 3870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Association of Proposal Management Professionals User:RoySmith 14:43, 12 August 2017 (UTC) delete My own searching failed to find any . Fails Deletion of Association of Proposal Management Professionals WP:RS||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7110 13347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Center for Contemporary Printmaking User:Kudpung 00:36, 20 September 2019 (UTC) delete Non notable and unsourced (practically the only sources are Wikipedia and their own web site). The |SPA creator has not edited for over 10 years. The fact this article exists is due to sloppy patrolling and the fact that NPP along with COI controls were in their infancy in those days. Fails GNG Deletion of Center for Contemporary Printmaking WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
7111 13468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mudassir Iqbal User:AssociateAffiliate 10:34, 23 February 2019 (UTC) delete South Korea did not qualify for the next qualification stage (which has t20 International status), with South Korea not scheduled to play any t20 International matches for some time. So sadly, these guys fail . Refreshing to see an associate playing mostly homegrown talent though Deletion of Mudassir Iqbal WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
7112 6008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Craft (politician) User:Muboshgu 23:04, 4 November 2013 (UTC) delete fails and . – Deletion of Thomas Craft (politician) WP:GNG||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
7113 1039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Royal Rumble participants User:TrueCRaysball 17:44, 17 May 2017 (UTC) delete per above. Also, it's getting |chilly in here Deletion of List of Royal Rumble participants WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
7114 6486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Pumpkin Patch User:Oxymoron83 06:08, 27 September 2007 (UTC) delete non notable as per Deletion of The Pumpkin Patch WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
7115 20519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of sources about claims that Vojsava Kastrioti was Albanian User:ZjarriRrethues 13:43, 15 April 2011 (UTC) delete per nom. and could be added to those arguments. Wikipedia articles can't be used as blog posts of source collections Deletion of List of sources about claims that Vojsava Kastrioti was Albanian WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7116 5937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcus Lindblom User:ThomasO1989 15:36, 10 July 2014 (UTC) keep Although wouldn't ordinarily apply to a video game localiser, he has coverage in multiple sources to meet . Also, sources have specifically and in detail focused on his work as a localiser, so you could make the case that his localisation is itself a work of art that has received critical attention, meeting that way. does not apply to creative works: you're still notable as a writer (etc) even if you've only written 1 book (etc), if you meet . Despite what Deletion of Marcus Lindblom WP:CREATIVE||WP:GNG||WP:CREATIVE||WP:BLP1E||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
7117 919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Embassy of Belgium in Ottawa User:Dl2000 00:22, 11 June 2007 (UTC) keep Numerous embassy articles are already established e.g. Embassy of Israel in London, Embassy of Ukraine in Washington, etc. and should be considered uniformly notable. Picking and choosing particular nation-to-nation diplomatic missions for deletion would constitute and therefore violate Deletion of Embassy of Belgium in Ottawa WP:BIAS||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
7118 15086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alpharetta ghost User:Mazca 19:06, 7 April 2009 (UTC) delete as failing . What content there is seems to be entirely lies and the single unverifiable source does little to demonstrate otherwise Deletion of Alpharetta ghost WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7119 17653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kiran Saldanha User:Abecedare 19:33, 4 February 2009 (UTC) delete No sources to verify any claims; would perhaps fail even if claims were verified Deletion of Kiran Saldanha WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7120 21430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Osborne Theomun Olsen User:Closeapple 18:51, 20 May 2020 (UTC) comment """The links to """"Osborne Art Studios"""" in the article are to the Wikidata item, not another article, so this biographical article is also the article for the studio/business. (No opinion on whether the business has either""" Deletion of Osborne Theomun Olsen WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
7121 9047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saint Andrew's School, Saratoga, California User:Aaron NONE delete """not that I think it will do any good. I ''surely'' do not see the point in saying something I don't believe as mooted by howcheng above. Keep nominating schools, or wrestlers, or battle ships if you feel it's the correct thing to do. Shouting down dissenting voices is anti-wiki. '''I''' do not nominate schools, and I don't go out of my way to find the nominations, but when they show up on my watch list I contribute. It doesn't take long, I am usually polite (well, recently at least), and if people want to keep doing this I'll keep doing it. I think that calls to """"stop nominating"""" while at the same time blocking all attempts to reach some -like accord are '''foul'''. If there was any sense of compromise, we could avoid all this nonsese""" Deletion of Saint Andrew's School, Saratoga, California WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7122 3929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The African-American Historical News Journal User:Kudpung 06:59, 10 June 2015 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of The African-American Historical News Journal WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
7123 9611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Piss-up User:Acalamari 21:10, 16 April 2007 (UTC) delete violates #DICT Deletion of Piss-up WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7124 9434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Upper Peninsula War User:Amatulic 21:42, 9 May 2007 (UTC) delete but archive somewhere at . It would be a shame to lose such an artfully crafted example of a hoax article Deletion of Upper Peninsula War WP:BJAODN Wikipedia:Silly Things 72
7125 163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vernes Selimović User:Mattythewhite 21:23, 26 June 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Vernes Selimović WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
7126 17704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Metropolitan Community Church of New York (2nd nomination) User:Cirt 03:38, 20 February 2012 (UTC) keep very clear violation by nominator. &mdash Deletion of Metropolitan Community Church of New York (2nd nomination) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
7127 5142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farooky Tooth Powder User:NewYorkActuary 02:57, 21 May 2017 (UTC) delete The article's sole source appears to be a dead link (at least, I couldn't find the article in the newspaper archive that the link sent me to). But the official website is interesting -- this tooth powder is also advertised to relieve or cure a variety of non-tooth ailments, including dysentery, cholera and swine flu. I think this article has serious problems under Deletion of Farooky Tooth Powder WP:MEDRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7128 11964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slinky Malinki User:The 06:08, 17 September 2019 (UTC) keep article does now meet Deletion of Slinky Malinki WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
7129 10869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Margaret Fitzgerald (supercentenarian) User:Bearcat 05:31, 14 June 2016 (UTC) delete While there ''used'' to be a consensus that reaching the age of 100+ was grounds for an article in and of itself, has considerably weakened that — and with just two references here, the volume of |reliable source coverage is ''not'' significant enough to claim that she passes . A weekly column about people in her age bracket, in her own ''local'' newspaper, does not make her special Deletion of Margaret Fitzgerald (supercentenarian) WP:BIO1E||WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7130 15323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Sokoloski User:onel5969 13:58, 7 May 2016 (UTC) delete Clearly fails , and with a high citation count of 5, doesn't come close to passing Deletion of Richard Sokoloski WP:GNG||WP:SCHOLAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
7131 12272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kopp's Frozen Custard User:Spudgfsh 22:06, 13 September 2013 (UTC) delete there is one item on there that is of minimal notability (the joe biden visit) the rest is Deletion of Kopp's Frozen Custard WP:NOTADVERTISING Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7132 21167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jan Schlösser User:Sir 16:24, 22 February 2012 (UTC) delete never appeared in a leage above the Regionalliga, meaning he fails . Also fails Deletion of Jan Schlösser WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7133 5020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad Ezz User:Hut 10:50, 16 May 2011 (UTC) delete per and unless someone can find a source. There are a few mentions of a political activist called Mohammed Ezzeldin but I'm fairly sure that's not the subject of this article. Appears to have been written by the subject ({{user|Mahmoud ez Deletion of Mohammad Ezz WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
7134 15164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hip Hop albums by year User:Mrgreen520 12:15, 11 May 2007 (UTC) comment As far as I see, an initial |systemic bias would by itself not be a reason for deletion, unless it is a deliberate POV fork. In any case, the same question arises with respect to the idea of having articles of the type 'year in hip hop', which I mentioned as a possible alternative to Deletion of Hip Hop albums by year WP:CSB Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
7135 17021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clement Olaloye Folayan User:Sambhil32 09:56, 23 December 2019 (UTC) comment I do not understand why it fails even . Because it passes the clauses #2, #3, #7 and #8 of . He is pioneer of the Nigerian cars. There are many scholarly sources about him Deletion of Clement Olaloye Folayan WP:GNG||WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7136 936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seriously Endangered Xobats User:Spada2 05:41, 7 July 2011 (UTC) delete per nom, fails usic Deletion of Seriously Endangered Xobats WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
7137 19876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Olamide Zaccheaus User:SportingFlyer 17:38, 29 April 2019 (UTC) delete the articles mentioned are either game coverage at the amateur level or local coverage not satisfying , I think he will probably become notable soon though but the season isn't for another few months I think Deletion of Olamide Zaccheaus WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
7138 13343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Young Rebel Goombas (2nd nomination) User:M 07:24, 25 November 2009 (UTC) delete per nom; even if New York Emmys are considered 'major', this band does not inherit notability from its band members (who in turn do not inherit notability from their Emmy-winning band). Whether above users are attorneys, friends of the band, or Robert Christgau is also irrelevant; the band fails notability Deletion of Young Rebel Goombas (2nd nomination) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
7139 8673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seven 13 Hustlaz Vol. 1 The Movement User:doomsdayer520 15:22, 23 March 2020 (UTC) delete An apparent vanity project that has not been reviewed, much less noticed, by anyone outside the rapper's circle. The only sources found are |typical retail/streaming sites Deletion of Seven 13 Hustlaz Vol. 1 The Movement WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
7140 13032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kitsuné Maison Compilation 2 User:Someone 22:27, 13 May 2010 (UTC) delete per , albums normally should have the same level of sourcing expected for films/video games or pretty much anything else. Since this is a compilation, not an artist album, it's even more important that it's sourced with significant secondary coverage. I couldn't find any such sources, none have been presented since the article's creation Deletion of Kitsuné Maison Compilation 2 WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
7141 2268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of attacks by the Armenian Secret Army for the Liberation of Armenia User:Yannismarou 19:11, 22 March 2007 (UTC) delete """at least as it is now) and '''merge''' any usefl information to ASALA article. Since I see in the ASALA article two sections named """"major attacks"""", and """"some other attacks"""" I fail to understand what this article adds to the subject. It does not fulfill (attackes are already listed in the ASALA article, and the prose is longer there), and the list doesn't add anything new. So, why couldn't it be just a template included in the ASALA article? If this article is to be saved, its editors must concentrate their efforts on making it useful and informative enough to stand on its own. As it is now, it doesn't. It looks as a fork, even if this is not your intention""" Deletion of List of attacks by the Armenian Secret Army for the Liberation of Armenia WP:SS Wikipedia:Summary style 34
7142 2147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peace sign position User:Whispering 18:27, 29 August 2006 (UTC) delete per and |Wikipedia is not for things made up in bed one day Deletion of Peace sign position WP:V||WP:NFT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7143 18888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Pyron User:Nsk92 19:19, 30 June 2010 (UTC) delete just a postdoc for now, fairly low citability, no significant awards. Does not pass Deletion of Alex Pyron WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
7144 3381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Escusa User:RightCowLeftCoast 23:57, 30 June 2011 (UTC) delete No significant coverage from reliable sources found, as stated in . Does not appear to pass Deletion of Jordan Escusa WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7145 6013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plastic Raygun User:Aguerriero 19:56, 10 July 2006 (UTC) keep as I have re-written to establish notability. The criteria for notability of record labels is not really specified in , but I believe releasing a top 20 single and releasing records for other prominent breakbeat artists is notable Deletion of Plastic Raygun WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7146 7358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Militant Islam NONE NONE comment Notifying users that an article they have once edited has been |Afd'd is standard policy Deletion of Militant Islam WP:AFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
7147 5521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Gaetz sexual misconduct allegations User:Slywriter 01:51, 3 April 2021 (UTC) merge Majority of the article is about the extortion attempt. This is an article engaging in sensationalism as very few facts are available to actually cite about the allegations. Instead, you can already see the oatrack to tie this to Q, Roger Stone and Human Sex Trafficking Deletion of Matt Gaetz sexual misconduct allegations WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
7148 15763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Computer and video game settings User:Wickethewok 18:27, 20 September 2006 (UTC) delete Categorizing worlds found in video games and determining them to be cliches makes this entire article and its premise |original research Deletion of Computer and video game settings WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
7149 19584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Genetic Priming [[User talk:202.124.74.110|talk]]) 01:10, 24 May 2011 (UTC) delete """fails and also has issues. The phrase """"genetic priming"""" is used in the literature, but with a different meaning to that of John Jacob Lyons. -- Special:Contributions/202.124.74.110|202.124.74.110""" Deletion of Genetic Priming WP:N||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
7150 11250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Knott User:Hrafn 04:32, 3 December 2011 (UTC) delete """blog posts should not be used on a ''at all'', and in any case do not establish notability. The only remaining sources appears to be Knott's own writings for the Washington Times, which likewise do not establish notability. Therefore no reliable independent coverage has been proffered to establish notability, and we're left with simply the claim that the topic is """"a long-serving staffer on the Washington Times"""" -- which would appear insufficient, on its own, to establish notability""" Deletion of Tom Knott WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
7151 3766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David K. Bernard User:E 14:32, 30 April 2018 (UTC) keep head of denomination as per and sourcing during AFD Deletion of David K. Bernard WP:CLERGYOUTCOMES||WP:HEYMANN Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
7152 10312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kasie Head User:Dan 01:25, 16 April 2019 (UTC) delete Fails only significant achievement is winning a state beauty pageant in 2002 (see ) no notable achievements otherwise Deletion of Kasie Head WP:ANYBIO||WP:1EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
7153 18759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lynn Denlon User:Inkpaduta 22:13, 12 February 2007 (UTC) merge all but Amanda Young, per . Most of the articles lack references, and could be included in the article on Saw. The Young article has a few references, but I wonder how to determine if they are reliable WP:RS and independent? Radiofree.com? Crave.com? Are they fansites or do they have a more substantial basis Deletion of Lynn Denlon WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
7154 118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gemini Wars user:Hellknowz 19:52, 29 April 2012 (UTC) keep as passing per reliable, secondary, independent VG sources above. It is not released, but media has given it reasonable attention and coverage. Ditto above, as does not automatically apply to unreleased products, though it does loom over this one a bit. Granted, this is not a lot of coverage, and definitely not in-depth in all of sources, but it's decent coverage in more than few outlets. — Deletion of Gemini Wars WP:GNG||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
7155 1190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam burke [[User: Allen3|Allen3]]'' [[User talk:Allen3|talk]] 20:59, 2 January 2007 (UTC) delete as per unless |reliable sources are provided in sufficient quantity to support the claims of the article and allow for the creation of a |neutral and verifiable article. While the fact that this person played a minor role in a minor movie is verifiable, the remainder of the article is pure |original research Deletion of Adam burke WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NPOV||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7156 14895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ann McNeill User:Colapeninsula 21:16, 6 February 2014 (UTC) keep She meets . By crude Google Scholar measures she has a h-Index of around 40, with ~19 papers cited over 100 times (#1) (note there's a few papers in there by other A McNeills but generally it's easy to sort). There's some debate as to how #5 should be applied to countries with the British system of professorships, but she's held full professorships at highly regarded British universities (formerly University of Nottingham, now KCL, both in the Russell Group).http://www.kcl.ac.uk/iop/depts/addictions/people/profiles/AnnMcNeill.aspx Also cited as an expert by the media ( #7).http://www.theguardian.com/education/2011/jan/11/tobacco-displays-encourage-smokinghttp://www.nottinghampost.com/City-expert-Tobacco-branding-misleads-smokers/story-12241617-detail/story.htmlhttp://www.reuters.com/article/2013/09/07/us-smoking-ecigarettes-idUSBRE9860JV20130907http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-12687458 Deletion of Ann McNeill WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
7157 19623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Scumaci User:Seattle 00:42, 28 March 2007 (UTC) delete This is , except by a musician instead of a company Deletion of Sam Scumaci WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
7158 20228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of ACM-W chapters User:BenKuykendall 22:21, 5 June 2019 (UTC) delete Remember |the policy: the notability of a list does not depend on the notability of each item of the list, rather, the ''set of items'' must meet the notability requirements. Thus, for this page to remain, we need significant coverage of the set of ACM-W chapters in reliable sources that are independent of the subject. However, outside of the organization's website and website's belonging to the individual chapters, I cannot find many sources. The few sources I can find https://cra.org/expanding-the-pipeline-acm-w-programs-expand-to-support-students-and-professional-women-in-computing/ 1 https://books.google.com/books?id=7lqBDQAAQBAJ&pg=PA158&lpg=PA158&dq=ACM-W+chapters&source=bl&ots=ZO2nB4s5nt&sig=ACfU3U0ZFy-TziH258Tu_yXJN7LhfJfW_A&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwivoorTr9PiAhUjvFkKHfKQAog4KBDoATAEegQICRAB#v=onepage&q=ACM-W%20chapters&f=false 2 speak more to the notability of the ACM-W than of this list Deletion of List of ACM-W chapters WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
7159 19656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D. J. Bryant [[User: Go Phightins!|'''Go''']] [[User talk:Go Phightins!|'''''Phightins''''']][[Special:Contributions/Go_Phightins!|'''!''']] 01:33, 15 October 2012 (UTC) delete I found http://www.stateofthetexans.com/?p=4665 this and http://www.wane.com/dpp/sports/local_sports/colts-cut-cb-king-among-many-moves this, but to me neither of these are enough to qualify under . There's a chance that he'll play in an NFL game someday which would immediately deem him notable per , but for now I vote delete Deletion of D. J. Bryant WP:GNG||WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
7160 3532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aircraft of Ace Combat User:Nenyedi 16:22, 15 August 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Aircraft of Ace Combat WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7161 8068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Columbia University rape controversy User:Isaidnoway 16:45, 10 May 2016 (UTC) keep It easily passes with widespread coverage in multiple sources, and the scope of this article extends beyond the focus of the other article which primarily covers the Endurance art|performance art aspect of this story. https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-437110652.html The Other Side of the College Sexual Assault Crisis; Allegations of Sexual Assault on Campus Are at Record Levels, as Are Lawsuits from the Accused, Including Paul Nungesser, Claiming Schools Discriminated against Them Based on Gender - https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1A1-09dc06f677314129b70b8bbe8542a41b.html Colleges face legal backlash from men accused of sex crimes - https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-37926379.html No Such Thing as Evidence of Innocence in Campus Sexual Assault Hearings - https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-37926563.html A Fine Line between Bullying and Free Speech - https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-37649528.html Former Columbia Newspaper Editor Admits Biased Reporting on Rape Due to Fear of Backlash Deletion of Columbia University rape controversy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7162 6676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hangry User:Armbrust 18:30, 8 August 2010 (UTC) delete as |Wikipedia is not a dictionary Deletion of Hangry WP:NOTDICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
7163 16639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khemed User:Sandstein 09:40, 27 September 2020 (UTC) delete or redirect. Fails . The commentary quoted above is about the ''Tintin'' books and their (fictional and real) politics, which are notable, not about the fictional location as such, which is not. Khemet is Hergé's pastiche of a stereotypical Arab emirate. How this culture is portrayed in ''Tintin'' is a matter of encyclopedic interest, but is best covered in context in the articles about the books and the series. What we have here is entirely in-universe description of the setting, i.e. fancruft fit only for fan wikis, but not Wikipedia (see MOS:FICTIONAL Deletion of Khemed WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7164 21007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Human Resources (gallery) User:Vrac 14:21, 14 January 2015 (UTC) keep Procedurally I'm not sure exactly how to handle the addition of the (non-profit) article to the AFD; my original delete nomination of the (gallery) article still stands but it seems to me that Mr. Troutman has improved the (non-profit) article enough for that article to pass Deletion of Human Resources (gallery) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7165 7502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amy Osmond Cook User:Bearian 17:26, 23 August 2016 (UTC) comment Ordinarily, a person who received such kudos might be notable, although |the sourcing is terrible. FWIW, I am representing the estate of a borderline notable LDS jurist Deletion of Amy Osmond Cook WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7166 341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leishenshan Hospital User:Hijiri88 01:23, 5 February 2020 (UTC) merge The only content in this article that doesn't more properly belong in the coronavirus outbreak article is the etymology stuff; if all we can write on a topic is etymological information on its name, it |doesn't belong here Deletion of Leishenshan Hospital WP:NOTDICT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
7167 16062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/From My Cold Dead Hands User:Lifebaka 14:24, 11 May 2008 (UTC) merge as a reasonable search term, but I don't see any reason to delete the old versions. Doesn't fD#How to discuss an AfD ask people not to !vote ''redirect and delete Deletion of From My Cold Dead Hands WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
7168 6747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charlotte Cleverley-Bisman User:Nicko 03:32, 18 July 2007 (UTC) keep Locally in NZ she is most likely very notable. In the article's notability may wain, but for now this should be kept and developed. Whilst , it is likely there will be media followup on the subject as time goes on Deletion of Charlotte Cleverley-Bisman WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7169 11262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Cretan Runner User:Mkdw 22:06, 2 February 2013 (UTC) merge I originally placed the PROD on the article after an inconclusive search. The fact that Tokyogirl79 couldn't find anything means it does not exist on the face of the earth as Deletion of The Cretan Runner WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
7170 768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victoria Taylor (2nd nomination) User:Rainbow 21:04, 15 July 2015 (UTC) delete I agree with the others stating and , she is only known for that one Reddit event. And it wasn't ''that'' big of an event, it has pretty much disappeared from the news by now. Other mentions of her in news sources before that event were typical of the job position she held, it's not like her former co-workers of the same level also have articles Deletion of Victoria Taylor (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
7171 9176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blatz (band) User:Seraphim 12:51, 16 June 2008 (UTC) keep Meets 1 of the criteria set out at the relevant |notability guideline () but contains |unverified information that needs |reliable sources to assert that it's not |original research and meets POV Deletion of Blatz (band) WP:N||WP:MUSIC||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:OR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
7172 8284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evo Technologies User:Fan 20:26, 1 May 2006 (UTC) delete no evidence that it meets . Google finds only about 65 unique (200 total) hits, and that includes other companies (a website developer and a maker of softball bats) using the name. Hundreds of companies are jumping into VOIP. Nothing to show this one's notable Deletion of Evo Technologies WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
7173 18413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/England 6s and 2s curse User:BDD 17:30, 25 June 2012 (UTC) delete without prejudice. As it stands, the article is nonsense, but there's no reason the topic can't get mentioned at Sports-related curses or even its own articles if pick up the concept Deletion of England 6s and 2s curse WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7174 16908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frerard User:Fredrick 22:21, 26 November 2007 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Frerard WP:NEO||WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
7175 2000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julia Jones (Date Movie) User:JuJube 01:10, 16 March 2008 (UTC) delete per ... oh wait, that's not valid criteria. Well it should be... completely non-notable character Deletion of Julia Jones (Date Movie) WP:WHOCARES Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
7176 7466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Campbell (Maryland politician) User:Bearcat 17:21, 10 September 2018 (UTC) delete Every candidate in every election can always show some degree of campaign coverage, so the existence of some campaign coverage does not automatically translate into a pass that exempts an unelected political candidate from having to pass . To deem a candidate notable without winning election to and thereby holding a notable NPOL-passing office first, we would need either (a) evidence that he already had preexisting notability for other reasons ''independent'' of his candidacies, or (b) evidence that his campaign coverage had exploded so far ''beyond'' the ordinary and routine and expected that he had a credible claim to his candidacy being a ''special case'' over and above everybody else's candidacies (e.g. Christine O'Donnell, who got ''so'' stanking much national and international coverage for having to deny that she was a witch that her article is actually three times as long and three times as |reliably sourced as the article about the actual senator she lost to is.) But neither of those things are being shown here at all Deletion of Tony Campbell (Maryland politician) WP:GNG||WP:NPOL||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
7177 9584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Bridge (2006 drama) User:Lexein 11:55, 5 October 2010 (UTC) keep Good additional RS sourcing and restructuring. Meets all criteria of Deletion of The Bridge (2006 drama) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7178 18542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles P. Gotwals NONE NONE delete per nom, fails Deletion of Charles P. Gotwals WP:MILPEOPLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
7179 20364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Schuler Books & Music User:Bkonrad 02:34, 7 October 2008 (UTC) keep Schuler Books is a fairly significant presence in mid-Michigan. While others scoff is not a very good reason, if we're keeping pokeman characters this is certainly of greater note than many such characters. Its mentioned in a few publications about the bookselling industry, http://books.google.com/books?id=J7yuxUHA3DsC&pg=PA249&dq=Schuler+Books&client=firefox-a&sig=ACfU3U1xG-c5Tk-hOIKvbaSaeLkHb9ohIg#PPA248,M1 ''Big-box Swindle'', http://books.google.com/books?id=HBuq-kHI2ZUC&pg=PA110&dq=Schuler+Books&client=firefox-a&sig=ACfU3U3e8MIufJIGE2G2TSNmKhszMupbrg ''Rebel Booseller Deletion of Schuler Books & Music WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
7180 6917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haymarket Line User:Davey2010 00:37, 6 September 2015 (UTC) keep as per above & sources, I will say however that table of shite does need removing as it obviously fails - Other than that see no reason to delete Deletion of Haymarket Line WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7181 933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Somewhere (film) User:Joe 22:30, 30 July 2009 (UTC) delete All that I can find is trivial mentions. Fails Deletion of Somewhere (film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
7182 17766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stray cow problem in India User:Wikireader41 07:51, 22 August 2010 (UTC) delete per without prejudice to creating an encyclopedic article on Stray animals in India. India has a problem with stray animals just like many other countries. focusing only on stray cows is not fair to the dogs, cats, snakes , sparrows, pigeons , rats, monkeys etc who run free all over India.http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/extract/325/7355/66/l, http://sify.com/news/dogs-day-out-in-delhi-sterilisation-in-a-fix-news-national-kicrkebabcc.html, http://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/18/world/asia/18iht-india.1.6710818.html, http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/22488488 Deletion of Stray cow problem in India WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
7183 10343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tool libraries in Canada NONE NONE keep the following four below. Meets . Sources below Deletion of Tool libraries in Canada WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7184 2715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Netconcepts User:WMMartin 13:48, 22 February 2007 (UTC) comment """Coming to this article as a new pair of eyes, my immediate reaction is deep unease. As it stands the article looks dangerously like spam/advertising. I'm deeply perturbed by the NZ Herald articles, which have all the hallmarks of lazy journalists cribbing from corporate press releases, and the other articles are slightly too hagiographic of the company's founder to make me feel they're unbiased. This is one of those """"snowball/heck"""" cases: I can see the way this debate's going, but my every instinct would be to '''delete''' for lack of real ( independent, non-press release ) sources. It doesn't seem to me that this article really passes , on the grounds that we don't have enough truly independent sources. At the very least, I'd like to suggest a good '''Clean up'''. I have a hunch we're being used here, but I can't put my finger on why""" Deletion of Netconcepts WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
7185 16194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Objectivism by country User:DrFleischman 20:59, 28 June 2017 (UTC) comment Arguably this article might be seen as a list of countries in which there is an Objectivist presence. If viewed that way, it does not seem to satisfy |our notability criteria for lists, as I don't believe there are any reliable, independent secondary sources discussing these countries as a set Deletion of Objectivism by country WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
7186 17218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karl Marlantes User:Drawn 11:01, 21 May 2009 (UTC) comment He has a lot of awards and honors, I don't know if any of them are considered important enough to satisfy or not, maybe the sum of them are. Also follow this link: http://www.elleonliteraryarts.org/authors.php from the article and there is a whole list of authors and I am betting more or all of them have articles and that some of them may not be notable Deletion of Karl Marlantes WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7187 1889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional Armenians User:Shooterwalker 16:06, 5 July 2010 (UTC) delete WP:NOTDIR|Wikipedia is not a directory. Arbitrary cross-categorization that fails and can only be written by synthesizing |original research. Wikipedia shouldn't be the first place to publish anything Deletion of List of fictional Armenians WP:SALAT||WP:OR Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
7188 5987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Errol Sawyer (3rd nomination) [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 09:42, 9 June 2013 (UTC) delete from my perspective, the article would need a lot more by way of |reliable sources to substantiate the notability of the subject. I've had a look online and couldn't find much that would help the cause. Using Facebook and blogs is a bad start, but a significant amount of the article is sourced to the subject's own self-published book and website. There's a few things ''by'' him, but not a lot ''about'' him. Not enough to meet or in my view Deletion of Errol Sawyer (3rd nomination) WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7189 7534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Savaş Polat User:Clean 17:17, 16 July 2015 (UTC) keep Passes notability for playing in a cup match. Deletion of Savaş Polat WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
7190 16119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michelle Xen User:Tgeairn 00:52, 3 October 2014 (UTC) delete This is a bit unusual, as the AfD notice has been removed from the article for some time now. The usual search for sources finds nothing to establish notability under Deletion of Michelle Xen WP:NENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
7191 18330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lost Spoilers User:Cailil 15:23, 7 May 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. No sources, non-encyclopedic and violates Deletion of Lost Spoilers WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7192 6066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avail Health User:Mendaliv 03:37, 24 June 2008 (UTC) delete as #A7|non-notable corporation with no assertion of notability. Srsly Deletion of Avail Health WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
7193 17040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nocton Dairies User:Kudpung 02:07, 1 August 2010 (UTC) delete WP:UNENCYC - local news item. : discusses an event that might not happen - and didn't Deletion of Nocton Dairies WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7194 17226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/In Vain (band) User:JamesBurns 07:09, 29 December 2008 (UTC) delete non-notable band Deletion of In Vain (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
7195 13618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wine n' about User:Esquivalience 19:15, 2 May 2015 (UTC) delete per #G11 and a bit of (as a ): fails and : no reliable sourcing ''at all''. Article, although not unambiguously promotional, was very likely created for promotion Deletion of Wine n' about WP:CSD||WP:IAR||WP:ADMASQ||WP:WEB||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
7196 13107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BhavyaBharat User:David 12:04, 6 October 2016 (UTC) delete in a basic I found literally ''no'' other sources than Wikipedia and their website Deletion of BhavyaBharat WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
7197 16828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Happyslip User:Indon 11:54, 21 August 2007 (UTC) merge to the subject's real name. There are some unreliable sources per , but it only needs some clean up. &mdash Deletion of Happyslip WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7198 8709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raw Engineering User:SamHolt6 02:54, 25 May 2018 (UTC) delete fails and due to a lack of in-depth sources and for failing to assert why Raw Engineering is distinctly notable when compared to similar companies. Note this article is about the ''company'' and not said company's ''software'', so the NCORP guideline is relevant Deletion of Raw Engineering WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
7199 7278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Traveler's Dream User:ShadowRangerRIT 17:31, 31 March 2010 (UTC) delete Enormous number of sources, virtually none of which have anything to do with this band. They support information related to prior performances by its members, cursory descriptive or playlist information (as opposed to actual reviews) or info on the genre, but they're basically a bunch of external links unrelated to the band. The few that do, as noted previously, appear to be college publications which are generally ignored for the purposes of . &mdash Deletion of Traveler's Dream WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7200 6987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 Cirrus SR-20 Crash User:Finlay 15:28, 23 July 2015 (UTC) delete a single light-aircraft accident is generally not notable and should not be included in Wikipedia, per and . There are hundreds of such accidents around the world every year, most no more notable than an ordinary car accident. WikiProject Aviation has some useful thoughts on the relative noteworthiness of aircraft incidents at Wikipedia:WikiProject Aviation/Aircraft accidents and incidents Deletion of 2015 Cirrus SR-20 Crash WP:GNG||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
7201 7074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irtishad Ahmad User:Nsk92 23:06, 7 August 2019 (UTC) keep weak-ish, but still. The nominator is correct that the article looked like a copy of a CV. I removed most of the promotional and unverified info. https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=35elQTkAAAAJ&hl=en&oi=ao Citability in GScholar is decent but not stellar for a high citation field, with an h-index of 20. He was indeed an editor-in-chief of a legit journal published by the American Society of Civil Engineers. I added a ref for that. Could be sufficient for #C8, although I am not sure how important the journal is (it is indexed in Scopus and in WebOfScience, and has impact factor of 3.269 in the latter). He also received an award in 2016 from the American Institute of Constructors. I added a ref for that too. Overall, seems to be enough here to satisfy #C1 Deletion of Irtishad Ahmad WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
7202 3156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheila Crowley (2nd nomination) User:Redditaddict69 05:28, 14 August 2018 (UTC) delete Former acting director and failed candidate for office. No notability whatsoever per , nor POL Deletion of Sheila Crowley (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:GNG||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
7203 8611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/No Regrets (Gob song) User:Esradekan 00:09, 18 May 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of No Regrets (Gob song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7204 15808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fairinvestment.co.uk User:RGTraynor 14:25, 8 April 2008 (UTC) delete Fails , . A search of Google News UK http://news.google.co.uk/news?oe=UTF-8&hl=en&tab=wn&ned=uk&q=Fairinvestment.co.uk&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&start=20 turns up only 24 unique hits, every single one either a press release or a quote on a web article from the ubiquitous James Caldwell, the outfit's director. None are articles ''about'' the company, as requires. Mr. Edwards is a new editor -- so no reason to |bite - but like others, I strongly recommend that he gain familiarity with the relevant Wikipedia policies, so that he can suggest an actual valid policy ground to keep this article Deletion of Fairinvestment.co.uk WP:WEB||WP:CORP||WP:RS||WP:BITE Wikipedia:Notability 77
7205 21951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/First International Symposium on Chinese Women and Their Network Capital User:Masumrezarock100 06:46, 26 June 2019 (UTC) delete obviously. No need to keep this non-notable article. Fails Deletion of First International Symposium on Chinese Women and Their Network Capital WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7206 7727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dope Boy Resurrection User:Dlohcierekim 23:59, 21 March 2010 (UTC) delete """Hoax or not, """"debut album to be released on UTP Records"""""""". A vanity label. Does not meet music or general notaility guidelines. The artist is Milly (rapper) does not meet music or GNG either. http://www.google.com/search?sourceid=navclient&ie=UTF-8&rlz=1T4GWYA_enUS325US234&q=%2bMilly+%2b%22Dope+Boy+Resurrection%22 Unable to locate on subject. Nothing helpful at Allmusic""" Deletion of Dope Boy Resurrection WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7207 601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unbox Therapy User:Mle 15:53, 17 May 2016 (UTC) comment ThePlatypusofDoom, I agree that applies to the original Article marked here for deletion, but seems off topic for this discussion as it would normally apply to the Wikipedia article in question for deletion rather than this particular discussion on whether to keep the article Deletion of Unbox Therapy WP:WAX||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
7208 1917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Norwood User:Ejgreen77 14:35, 2 January 2016 (UTC) keep """as a pass, per Cbl62's sources. I also note that the infobox on the pages states under """"Playing career"""" that Norwood played in the CFL for the Calgary Stampeders in 1989. If that is true, and he actually appeared in games for the Stamps, then he would automatically pass , anyways. Bottom line: either way, he's notable""" Deletion of Brian Norwood WP:GNG||WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
7209 11832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Revaz Getsadze User:IJA 16:48, 25 October 2014 (UTC) delete He hasn't played in a Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|Fully professional league and he doesn't have any senior international caps either therefore he fails Deletion of Revaz Getsadze WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
7210 13543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B Janakiraman [[User talk:NukeThePukes|Nha Trang]] 22:01, 23 October 2014 (UTC) delete I agree with Loriendrew, it's damn near a G1 speedy. No evidence this guy - presuming this isn't a |hoax article - passes WP:BIO or the GNG at any level. A and a issue, too, I figure Deletion of B Janakiraman WP:HOAX||WP:COMPETENCE||WP:BULLSHIT Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
7211 5689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Olicamera User:MichaelQSchmidt 01:28, 25 July 2014 (UTC) delete for currently completed unreleased film failing for lacking coverage in reliable sources. To be clear, my delete is '''not''' based upon the inapplicable complaints about length or distributor. Length is not a concern for film notability, as many short films have been found notable. And being distributed though YouTube is also not a deletion criteria, as some films released that way have indeed been the recipient of coverage to meet . The only valid issue in the nominator's statement is the lack of coverage. Allow undeletion or recreation after release and only if it gains coverage Deletion of Olicamera WP:NFF||WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
7212 306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sophie Costa User:Qworty 19:41, 3 June 2008 (UTC) delete """as a """"no context"""" and . Disruptive de-prodding, edit warring, and hardly constitute good reasons to drag out an AfD on a one-sentence article. All of the nominator's actions on this one, including the two prods and now the AfD, have been in good faith, so an early close would be appropriate here. Thank you""" Deletion of Sophie Costa WP:SNOW||WP:POINT Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
7213 4880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sreelakshmi Suresh (4th nomination) User:Northamerica1000 23:40, 29 August 2012 (UTC) keep spaced ndash}} Passes . Examples include: http://www.hindu.com/yw/2009/02/24/stories/2009022450280400.htm, http://www.hindu.com/2006/12/29/stories/2006122914400300.htm, http://www.arabnews.com/node/293715, http://www.gulf-times.com/site/topics/article.asp?cu_no=2&item_no=128557&version=1&template_id=40&parent_id=22 Deletion of Sreelakshmi Suresh (4th nomination) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7214 13262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IBN Sports User:Algébrico 01:43, 10 October 2009 (UTC) delete """The article is not based on independent reliable sources. The Reuters """"article"""" is in fact a #Press releases|press release, which does not stabilish notability""" Deletion of IBN Sports WP:THIRDPARTY Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7215 10819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benedict Cumberbatch Must Die User:Ivanvector 18:08, 10 June 2014 (UTC) delete per and as a potential violation based on the name. The time to ''include'' the article is when there ''are'' secondary sources/reviews cited which indicate notability. |We don't write about things in anticipation of them becoming notable - |notability is required Deletion of Benedict Cumberbatch Must Die WP:TOOSOON||WP:BLP||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
7216 8947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Forrest Peterman User:JohnCD 20:28, 10 March 2008 (UTC) delete """it's a |hoax. References to ''Mein Kampf'' and ''The Psychopathic God: Adolf Hitler'', and a book about slaughterhouses by """"A. Bullock""""; there's no trace of the alleged book on Peterman by J. Toland, '''but''' note that John Toland and Alan Bullock have both written books about Hitler. In the text, """"He graduated in the top 80 percent of his class"""" and """"...Brazil where he first discovered the fascinations of cows""""; and just look at the paragraph about """"waterboarding"""" cows! If not a hoax, it just ''might'' be an attack page on a real """"Forrest Peterman""""; either way, it should go, and speedily""" Deletion of Forrest Peterman WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
7217 8244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virtonomics (3rd nomination) [[User talk:Czar|czar]] 19:59, 2 January 2016 (UTC) delete A bunch of mentions, but not enough to constitute |significant coverage. If it had four reviews, it'd be fine, but it doesn't even have two. And I have my doubts about the major review under discussion—the one by ''Computerra''. Our article on the mag has its print circ at 60k (very low...) and the site has no staff posted. Perhaps it's just in decline after its print mag folded, but there's very little to instill confidence as it is. In any event, send this to draft if someone else wants it there, but I don't see enough in-depth secondary source coverage to actually write something of substance on this topic. When this topic becomes sufficiently popular, the reliable source coverage will follow Deletion of Virtonomics (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7218 8127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Novi Drumline User:Starblind 02:13, 25 February 2008 (UTC) delete per both and Deletion of Novi Drumline WP:MUSIC||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7219 6163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Johnson (cricketer) User:scope_creep 21:16, 25 April 2021 (UTC) delete Fails and NCRIC Deletion of Martin Johnson (cricketer) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
7220 10805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Our Last Summer (2nd nomination) User:Rlendog 17:55, 6 March 2009 (UTC) keep Meets due to coverage by multiple notable artists. Songs do not have to be released as singles to be notable. While most ABBA album tracks certainly are not notable, this one, in addition to ceverage by other artists, was deemed important enough for inclusion in an ABBA greatest hits album, plus of course it was covered in the Mamma Mia show and movie. And there are already a number of sources in the article and others available to expand the article further, if someone wants to. I'm not sure what changed since the prior AfD a few months ago resulted in a consensus to keep that warranted another AfD (only thing that changed that I am aware of is release of the Mamma Mia DVD that included this song, which should not have reduced its notability), but it still warrants keep Deletion of Our Last Summer (2nd nomination) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
7221 7966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/F90 Gundam Formula 90 (2nd nomination) User:Sharkface217 21:08, 30 December 2007 (UTC) delete A fun read, but unfortunately it falls under Deletion of F90 Gundam Formula 90 (2nd nomination) WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
7222 18145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CU Backslash User:Kinu 02:51, 25 March 2006 (UTC) delete no one's attacking anything, it's just that the subject isn't |notable or |encyclopedic Deletion of CU Backslash WP:N||WP:ENC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7223 12982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A'PEXi PowerFC User:TravisTX 12:43, 16 April 2008 (UTC) comment The formatting of the article has improved immensely since creation, however, it is still not Wikipedia material. The article consists primarily of technical information about a product. Yes, it is reference material, but Wikipedia is not a #HOWTO|technical manual, it is an encyclopedia. Also, even after all of the cleanup, the article still lacks independent |reliable sources showing evidence of |notability of the |product Deletion of A'PEXi PowerFC WP:NOT||WP:RS||WP:N||WP:CORP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7224 6945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/36 (song) User:Esradekan 03:02, 15 August 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Songs. While I am a SOAD fan, and the history of this song is interesting, there just ain't no references to back it up Deletion of 36 (song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7225 16311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bucharest Medical Students' Society (SSMB) User:ThePaintedOne 21:48, 10 February 2011 (UTC) delete quite a collection here. Doesn't appear to meet , lack of |reliable sources and the talk page comment shows |promotion and |COI (tagged as such Deletion of Bucharest Medical Students' Society (SSMB) WP:ORG||WP:RS||WP:PROMOTION||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
7226 9058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karen Hanton User:Charlene 12:17, 27 February 2007 (UTC) keep Meets with reliable secondary sources Deletion of Karen Hanton WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7227 9601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Good Friday (film) User:Joe 16:14, 4 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |film Deletion of Good Friday (film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
7228 1618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Generation Jones User:Hit 14:52, 16 August 2006 (UTC) keep """I disagree with any notion of a """"Google test"""", since 99% of the stuff on the web doesn't meet . That said, there are a fair number of reliable sources out there for this term: CNNhttp://archives.cnn.com/2000/ALLPOLITICS/stories/03/05/generation.jones/index.html, The Cincinnati Enquirerhttp://www.enquirer.com/editions/1999/11/12/loc_who_is_generation.html, The Columbia Daily Tribunehttp://www.columbiatribune.com/2006/Jul/20060724Life001.asp, Scoop (news website)http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/PO0509/S00161.htm, Entrepreneur magazinehttp://www.entrepreneur.com/article/0,4621,271536,00.html, etc. As such, the article needs cleanup, not deletion""" Deletion of Generation Jones WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7229 21060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Icy Hot Stuntaz (2nd nomination) User:Seraphimblade 02:53, 17 April 2007 (UTC) comment """I missed the """"first internet memes"""" criteria in , even after looking twice. I did see a requirement for multiple nontrivial reliable sources, though""" Deletion of Icy Hot Stuntaz (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7230 21115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian electronic dance music User:Atlantic306 20:39, 24 October 2020 (UTC) keep the article has references to significant coverage in multiple reliable sources so that is passed and deletion is unnecessary in my view Deletion of Christian electronic dance music WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7231 5162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Money (2016 film) User:Nagle 18:32, 21 September 2015 (UTC) delete """It's in production, and not a major film. Not notable yet. Can't find the movie (even searching for """"Martin Rosete"""") in The Hollywood Reporter. applies""" Deletion of Money (2016 film) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7232 4232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TeeKay-421 (2nd nomination) User:Legacypac 03:56, 29 May 2017 (UTC) delete as not passing and we have removed many more notable clubs before Deletion of TeeKay-421 (2nd nomination) WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7233 11511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyrannosaurus in popular culture User:Pixelface 05:45, 14 August 2007 (UTC) keep and perhaps rewrite like Stegosaurus in popular culture, although the article looks OK to me as it is. T. rex is the most widely recognized dinosaur in popular culture. There appears to be enough information to warrant it's own article. And the information is verifiable. I don't think the article counts as a #DIR|directory of loosely associated topics as claimed in the mass AFD. Wikipedia has many |list articles grouped by theme. applies to article '''topics''' -- every single sentence within an article is not required to meet the notability guidelines Deletion of Tyrannosaurus in popular culture WP:NOT||WP:LIST||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7234 3566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Rita Centura User:onel5969 18:20, 4 February 2021 (UTC) delete searches did not turn up enough in-depth coverage. Fails or . There's also the UPE issue Deletion of Anna Rita Centura WP:GNG||WP:NARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
7235 10051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of formations in American football User:Bagumba 17:31, 6 June 2012 (UTC) merge """to Formation (American football) or keep, but definitely do not delete. I'm always surprised when no attempt is made to information. This article is clearly well organized and uses to present all the formations along with diagrams; the information and organization is currently lacking in """"Formation (American football)"""". Also, the articles have been tagged for a proposed merger since November 2010; its disappointing that no discussion was started to support or oppose the merge suggestion before resorting to an AfD""" Deletion of List of formations in American football WP:PRESERVE||WP:SUMMARYSTYLE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
7236 4367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oh Paris (EP) User:Esradekan 00:32, 1 October 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of Oh Paris (EP) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7237 20604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Photo-Detecting and Image Capturing User:Arthur 21:10, 19 May 2006 (UTC) comment No vote, as I have a conflict of interest.'' It's a real system, run by my real-life employer. And it's not quite a road-rule enforcement camera, as its primary use is toll collection, although the article mentioned (probably as ) possible speed limit enforcement. I think the name may fail , but perhaps some article is appropriate. &mdash Deletion of Photo-Detecting and Image Capturing WP:OR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
7238 18530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernard Lewinsky User:Lithistman 01:56, 5 July 2011 (UTC) delete At some point, the quacking of the duck needs to be noted as belonging to a duck. That, and--as Protonk mentions-- concerns, as well as the fact that a merge and redirect (which I would have otherwise recommened) is unavailable, given the editing behavior at the article, lead me to this recommendation Deletion of Bernard Lewinsky WP:NPF Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
7239 308 [[K.Ö.H.V. Mercuria Wien]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Q-ß NONE keep Habe den Artikel überarbeitet; nach gilt Löschung von K.Ö.H.V. Mercuria Wien Wikipedia:Richtlinien Studentenverbindungen Wikipedia:Richtlinien Studentenverbindungen 45
7240 18351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of film roles based on ethnic stereotypes User:Ohconfucius 01:57, 18 August 2006 (UTC) delete Could be a good drinking game to play, to think up any role which could be construed as a racial stereotype, but wiki is not Deletion of List of film roles based on ethnic stereotypes WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
7241 21488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Endurance (2023 Film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 05:23, 11 May 2015 (UTC) delete """for (at most polite) being |waaaaay too soon, if at all. Lacks any verifiability in reliable sources. Its https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newryst_Studios """"production campany"""" has already been deleted. This should go too. '''''If''''' these youngsters ever do make a film and '''''if''''' it gets the requisite coverage in eight years, a recreation can be considered""" Deletion of Endurance (2023 Film) WP:NYF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
7242 8674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The New Pantagruel User:Shooterwalker 23:33, 2 September 2010 (UTC) delete I see a bare mention in the NYT, but nothing that can of this short-lived web publication. The NYT article is about a much bigger phenomenon. Unfortunately this article needs third-party sources to meet policies and guidelines Deletion of The New Pantagruel WP:verify notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
7243 13642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phillips Carbon Black Limited User:DaxServer 19:48, 29 July 2021 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Phillips Carbon Black Limited WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
7244 6907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Funny Business (musical) User:Stifle 19:20, 16 November 2007 (UTC) delete unless |citations from |reliable sources are provided in compliance with |verifiability policy Deletion of Funny Business (musical) WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7245 15043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Blakey User:Timtrent 17:41, 8 August 2012 (UTC) comment I believe we should ignore whether certain editors are or are not intimately connected with the article, and concentrate only on its technical merits. If sufficient references referring directly to the subject, not oblique references in passing can be added to it then it should remain. That would prove notability. If not then it should go, but without prejudice to its re-creation when notability can be established. A major contributor to the article has http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk%3AMastermusicgenius&diff=506407520&oldid=506362548 expressed resentment over being told (by me) of the apparent conflict of interest. It is important that we do not drive down the route of ad hominen comments. We must stick to the article itself, and deal only with its ability to meet the standards here. The editor raises a point that appears to many people to have some validity - that it has survived several years without being challenged - and that point may be worth an experienced and uninvolved person discussing with the editor as a separate issue form the discussion here Deletion of Michael Blakey WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7246 20703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonstar Official User:Bakazaka 19:12, 2 May 2019 (UTC) delete as unambiguous sourced to non-RS primary/promotional/non-independent sources. Wikipedia is not a platform for promotion Deletion of Jonstar Official WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7247 20427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TripHobo User:Unscintillating 01:38, 16 October 2016 (UTC) delete nbsp; Being a startup company in the news may satisfy WP:GNG, but Wikipedia is not interested in a company with potential. We have no deadline, so we can wait. If this company pans out, it will continue to attract attention from reliable sources. Fails . Articles about companies require neutral coverage, that is exactly what says, and this means that we should include coverage of why a company's products are attractive to the rest of the world. Deletion of TripHobo WP:NOTNEWSPAPER||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7248 4413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katarzyna Dolinska (3rd nomination) User:Misty 17:18, 9 April 2009 (UTC) keep Ranking on ANTM should not matter, a person is no more notable for being on the show is they rank 3rd than 5th. As a model, Katarzyna has a much higher notability than most other Top Model contestants, who articles, including some of the winners. She certainly is more notable than Heather Kuzmich, who also ranked 5th, but was voted over whelmingly to keep. If Katarzyna doesn't meet , than only Adrianne Curry, Kim Stolz and maybe 2 or 3 others do Deletion of Katarzyna Dolinska (3rd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7249 21411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/150 Watts User:Visor 22:27, 29 March 2008 (UTC) delete Fails : one studio album released under minor label, no assertion of notability, non notable musicians, tours and songs. No reliable and verifiable third-party sources, as per , Deletion of 150 Watts WP:MUSIC||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
7250 12429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warp Pipe (software developer) (2nd nomination) User:Someone 00:57, 10 June 2009 (UTC) delete Sources consist of two interviews, featuring a lot of hand-waving and techno-gibberish about something which apparently never went anywhere.. the crux of is that sources independent of the subject need to do the reporting in detail. The interviewers are not in a position to analyze the software, instead relying on sketchy details from the developer, that's no basis for an article. No prejudice against restoration if something should come of it in the future and it receives the necessary analysis, but there's currently a whole load of nothing to build an article with Deletion of Warp Pipe (software developer) (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7251 7095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lorena Pinot User:Gongshow 15:22, 25 March 2013 (UTC) delete Her main claim to fame to date is being a member for a couple years of the revamped Miami Sound Machine (2001-3). I'm unable to find any coverage for her beyond passing mentions http://books.google.com/books?id=yxIEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA14&dq=%22Lorena+Pinot%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=RmdQUdWuD4a8qgGR1oDQDA&ved=0CDwQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=%22Lorena%20Pinot%22&f=falsehttp://books.google.com/books?id=WxEEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA93&dq=%22Lorena+Pinot%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=RmdQUdWuD4a8qgGR1oDQDA&ved=0CDgQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=%22Lorena%20Pinot%22&f=falsehttp://news.google.com/newspapers?id=5eIvAAAAIBAJ&sjid=8zsDAAAAIBAJ&pg=6533,4825740&dq=lorena-pinot&hl=en. Miami Sound Machine does not have its own article, and redirecting to Gloria Estefan doesn't make sense. Subject also tried out for ''American Idol'' (season 7) but apparently did not make the top 24. She does not seem to meet or Deletion of Lorena Pinot WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7252 16615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crunkcore [[User talk:Snigbrook|Snigbrook]] 22:39, 13 November 2008 (UTC) delete """I searched on Google, and although the word """"crunkcore"""" returns several pages of results, I could not find significant coverage, or reliable sources to verify the definition in the article, so I don't think it meets Wikipedia's criteria for inclusion (specifically and """ Deletion of Crunkcore WP:GNG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
7253 18323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Black (cricketer) User:Spiderone 19:06, 18 January 2021 (UTC) merge to List of Otago representative cricketers per GNG failure and per Deletion of James Black (cricketer) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
7254 6142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Casualties of the 2010 Quit Kashmir Movement User:Redtigerxyz 17:00, 23 September 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Casualties of the 2010 Quit Kashmir Movement WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7255 9313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/@world record egg User:Lugnuts 08:19, 15 January 2019 (UTC) delete this is an EGG-cellent example of a |slow news day Deletion of @world record egg WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7256 8567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marek Semjan NONE NONE keep The player meets the following criteria at the . This guideline applies equally to singles and doubles players Deletion of Marek Semjan WP:NTENNIS Wikipedia:Notability 77
7257 3737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judaism and bus stops User:Snottywong 16:26, 6 October 2010 (UTC) delete Borderline hoax, textbook violation of . Do Jews go to bus stops? Yes. Is that notable? No. It is as notable as Jews walking on sidewalks, Jews going up and down stairs, and Jews riding the subway Deletion of Judaism and bus stops WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
7258 11188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bandersnatch (Known Space) User:Dhartung 04:58, 12 February 2007 (UTC) merge per above. All due respect to a much-beloved series, I'm not sure most of the articles at Known_Space#Species pass (exceptions, Kzinti & Pierson's Puppeteers), and could all be handled in a merged List of species in Known Space Deletion of Bandersnatch (Known Space) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
7259 15312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moulann User:Fairsing 16:53, 10 August 2006 (UTC) delete She comes close to meeting , but in the end can't quite clear the hurdle. Perhaps later in her career Deletion of Moulann WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
7260 10802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruth 3,000 Years of Sleeping Prophecy Awakened User:Accounting4Taste 22:24, 22 October 2007 (UTC) delete """because self-publishing (via Xulon Press, a """"Christian self-publisher"""") does not confer any |notability and there are no sources (I found no third-party comments in a brief search""" Deletion of Ruth 3,000 Years of Sleeping Prophecy Awakened WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7261 12256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Treasure hunt (game) user:Andrew 09:14, 31 July 2019 (UTC) keep The fact that there's a https://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/world-records/largest-treasure-hunt-game specific world record for this indicates that it's a separate topic with a distinct title. There are numerous books about the activity by this title and so it's quite notable and sourcing the topic will not be difficult. Other similar activities such as egg hunts or geocaching have separate and distinct features and, per , there's no need or benefit from trying to cram everything together Deletion of Treasure hunt (game) WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7262 14844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dee Workman Benedict User:The 12:40, 26 April 2019 (UTC) delete """This is a blatantly |promotional text for a |BLP about a non-Wikinotable subject who is yet another political operative. The sources cited, as well as those searched for, post nom, range from near-death weak to practically non-existent. E.g. The ''New York Times'' are grandly cited, yet, in their https://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/19/us/politics/in-south-carolina-romneys-mormon-beliefs-dont-carry-as-much-weight.html report (about voters now focusing less on cadidates' religion in the U.S.) there is one single drop of the subject, describing her as someone who """"spent the last several years working to muster support for Mr. Romney among Christian conservatives."""" From there on it goes downhill as far as |verifiable |notability is concerned""" Deletion of Dee Workman Benedict WP:PROMO||WP:BLP||WP:V||WP:NPERSON Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7263 20588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of sports team names and mascots of European origin User:Moreschi 10:11, 18 March 2007 (UTC) delete per various parts of and : this is completely unreferenced and isn't much more than conjecture Deletion of List of sports team names and mascots of European origin WP:NOT||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7264 17636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Cordopatis User:Crusio 07:52, 29 October 2008 (UTC) delete Although citation counting is a common and accepted way of establishing notability for academics (both on and off wiki), I think that 5 articles with 30 citations is nothing out of the ordinary for someone working in pharmacology (if anything, it's rather low). Fails Deletion of Paul Cordopatis WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7265 2292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caleb Lawrence McGillvary [[User talk:70.36.137.19|talk]]) 08:31, 17 May 2013 (UTC) keep """Despite NorthBySouthBaranof claiming that two incidents are """"basically a case,"""" last time i took a math class, two did not equal one. We have a rule -- not a BLP2E rule or a BLP3E rule -- and more people have viewed that video than have read many famous books or voted for many politicians. Those people will be following this second incident as well. Special:Contributions/70.36.137.19|70.36.137.19""" Deletion of Caleb Lawrence McGillvary WP:BLP1E||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
7266 7950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luka Magnotta (3rd nomination) User:Robofish 16:20, 31 May 2012 (UTC) keep but '''rename''') - the previous deletions were when he was just a model/porn star. He's now the lead suspect in a major crime investigation which has attracted international news coverage. However, I agree with the nominator that it's really the event that's notable here, not the suspect, so this article should be renamed and rewritten to focus on the crime, per and Deletion of Luka Magnotta (3rd nomination) WP:PERP||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
7267 112 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Savaş Buldan """Kullanıcı:maurice flesiermaurice flesier""" 12:40, 29 Temmuz 2015 (UTC) delete """Sadece Pervin Buldan'ın eşi olduğu için ve Susurluk Skandalı sebebiyle mi bu maddeyi tutmalıyız? kriterlerini karşılamayan bir madde VP:OA amacıyla yeniden oluşturulmuş. En ve Ku vikipedide olması bir kanıt olarak sunulamaz.""""İngilizce daha fazla içeriğe ve bilgiye sahip olabilir. ama bu tarafsız olduğu anlamına gelmiyor."""" sonuçta değil mi? İlgili içerik Pervin Buldan ve Susurluk Skandalı maddelerinde bir alt başlık altında aktarılmalıdır""" Savaş Buldan'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
7268 18011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wuhan New Era Football Club User:Gghenn2 14:46, 17 November 2018 (UTC) delete Though I tried my best to fix the article by correcting the typographical errors and restructure the grammar but then I feel it fails and Deletion of Wuhan New Era Football Club WP:GNG||WP:RELIABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
7269 4369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colombia–Cyprus relations User:Edison 19:36, 1 May 2009 (UTC) delete Fails and OT|not a directory. Foreign relations of the 203 sovereign countries are best discussed in the article about the country, or a standalone article if a major country, rather than in 20,000 such binary stubs. A link to the country's foreign ministry website will provide more up-to-date info than a robostub created and then neglected Deletion of Colombia–Cyprus relations WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
7270 484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jake Olson (photographer) User:Xe7al 01:12, 23 February 2016 (UTC) delete This appears to be an obvious violation of since the page appears to have been created by Jake Olson himself. Additionally, this does not fit the requirements established by , specifically in regards to and Deletion of Jake Olson (photographer) WP:COI||WP:NOTE||WP:NTEMP||WP:SPIP Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
7271 10966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David McJonathan-Swarm User:TruthbringerToronto 17:15, 23 August 2006 (UTC) keep """Notable broadcaster, among other things. Remember that states, """"vanity by itself is not a basis for deletion, but lack of assertion of importance is""" Deletion of David McJonathan-Swarm WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
7272 7206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Desire (Grey's Anatomy) User:Rlendog 21:26, 17 February 2012 (UTC) keep or '''redirect''' to season article. With all the serial noms, I do not have time to check each one for notability. But even any that are not notable should be redirected to the season article per Deletion of Desire (Grey's Anatomy) WP:TVEP Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
7273 8007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edna Jeffrey User:Dricherby 09:56, 13 May 2013 (UTC) delete The only reliable source in the whole article is the ''San Francisco Bay Guardian'', and that is only used to support ing of the awards that newspaper gave to Finnila's Bathhouse. There's no link to an online version but, from the way that source is used, I assume that it gives no significant coverage (probably none at all) to Jeffrey. In any case, |notability is not inherited by the owner of a possibly notable business. I was unable to find any reliable sources at all for Edna Jeffrey, her book or the movie that's allegedly being made of it so the subject seems to fail and . The article doesn't claim she's notable in any other way, so I don't see any other notability criteria that could be applied. Her book completely fails – I couldn't find a single review – and the movie is . I doubt it will ever be made, since the biography of the screenwriter cited in the article http://forbidden.bravesites.com/thom-racina- mentions nothing after 2005 and the domain movieforbidden.com (also cited in the article) was registered in 2009, suggesting that this material is several years old and going nowhere. I see no reason at to have a redirect and I disagree with a redirect since, if anyone is interested in Jeffrey, it is more likely to be because of her novel and/or the movie, than because of curiosity about a business that closed in 2000 Deletion of Edna Jeffrey WP:COATRACK||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR||WP:BK||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:REDIRECT Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
7274 13130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Mortal Kombat species [[User talk:Ceyockey|talk to me]]'') 20:02, 2 December 2007 (UTC) delete mdash;Create a short list with one- or two-line descriptors in Mortal Kombat as a new section; sourcing such a list in the context of the larger article from Primary Sources is allowable if the overall article topic has been established as notable via Secondary Sources; this is an aspect of using Primary Sources for verifiability but not for notability. The arguments for retaining the article are -based (either primary or by proxy for fans) and don't hold up under the requirement to have real-world relevance supported by Secondary Sources. --User:Ceyockey Deletion of List of Mortal Kombat species WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
7275 7380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Pryor User:Kittybrewster 12:39, 24 April 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Jonathan Pryor WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7276 21487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evangeline Spracklin User:Coolabahapple 12:41, 27 December 2019 (UTC) delete as |wp not selfpromotion Deletion of Evangeline Spracklin WP:NOTPROMOTION Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7277 9789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shouryya Ray User:MichaK 11:51, 4 June 2012 (UTC) delete """I've no doubt that he will meet in due time, but now he """"only"""" got the second prize in a yearly competition for German high school students. I won this once, and I've got no Wikipedia article""" Deletion of Shouryya Ray WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7278 329 [[Straßenbahnstrecke 5 (Wien)]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Global Fish 20:28, 3. Jul. 2012 (CEST) delete Zunächst mal, wie man auch immer zu diesen Artikeln stehen mag: das (und die beiden anderen unten auch) sind Wiedergänger gelöschter Artikel mit minimalsten Modifikationen. Das ist ein SLA absolut regelkonform, siehe #Metabegründungen. Es ist völlig legitim, diesen Artikel für nicht schnelllösch- oder löschwürdig zu halten, aber Leute, die einen regelkonformen SLA stellen so anzugreifen, wie es einige hier tun, halte ich für absolut daneben.Dass Straßenbahninfrastruktur als relevant angesehen wird, ist klar. Ob es aber prinzipiell sinnvoll ist, ein eng zusammenhängendes städtisches Netz (nein, ein Eisenbahnstreckennetz ist ein anderes Kaliber) in einzelne Strecken aufzuteilen, ist eine andere Frage. Ich würde sie klar verneinen. Bei einigen Außenästen in gar nicht oder erst spät eingemeindeten Orten mag das etwas anders aussehen; deswegen ist die 31 auch ein anderer Fall. Überhaupt diskutabel freilich würde die Sache erst, wenn belegt würde, dass genau *diese* Strecke tatsächlich offiziell als zusammenhängende (und die abzweigenden Strecken nicht) Infrastruktur angesehen wird. Das ist nicht der Fall. Insofern sieht es so aus, als würde hier so getan, als würden einige Teilstücke, die nur durch eine dort verkehrenden Linie zusammenhängen, auch als Infrastruktur zusammengehören. Das ist Verwirrung der Leser Löschung von Straßenbahnstrecke 5 (Wien) Wikipedia:Schnelllöschantrag Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
7279 11072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mobilize: A Film About Cell Phone Radiation User:Bobrayner 23:58, 5 June 2014 (UTC) delete """it's short of notability. Chubbles, why did you restore the article with an admonition to follow """"the usual channels"""", after the usual channels had decided to delete the article? And |linking to copyvio isn't a good idea either. https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/disconnect-a-film-about-cellphones-cancer Here's the Indiegogo page, it should give a hint of what we're dealing with""" Deletion of Mobilize: A Film About Cell Phone Radiation WP:ELNEVER Wikipedia:External links 76
7280 1120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ORY User:Hisashiyarouin 02:02, 26 March 2015 (UTC) comment """1) In fact ORY (all caps, 2006) is older than Ory (normal caps, 2014). (2) Technically nom """"suggest merge"""" and not deletion makes this in a wrong place to discuss (start a merger discussion per ). (3) Personally I see we can '''move''' Ory (normal caps) → Ory (surname) because that's all the current article stores, and then ORY → Ory as the main dab. '''野狼院ひさし""" Deletion of ORY WP:MERGE Wikipedia:Merging 54
7281 7833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Do a vince User:TenPoundHammer 04:44, 24 July 2007 (UTC) delete """as |made up one day. I, personally, would think that """"doing a Vince"""" would mean having a wonderful tenor voice and singing """"Go Rest High on That Mountain""" Deletion of Do a vince WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
7282 6644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charly Musonda Jr. User:Amitbanerji26 17:06, 18 May 2015 (UTC) delete Clearly fails Deletion of Charly Musonda Jr. WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
7283 3961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Screen 7 User:MarcoTolo 01:06, 22 July 2007 (UTC) delete WP:N, and apparently (not that COI is explicitly a deletion criteria Deletion of Screen 7 WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
7284 16487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Milburn User:Skeezix1000 19:54, 20 December 2005 (UTC) delete Merely being a candidate does not satisfy , unless other information can be added to the article to show that he is notable for other reasons. I just don't buy the argument that any credible candidate merits an article Deletion of Chris Milburn WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7285 11649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joan Gramatte User:Eggishorn 23:52, 15 October 2017 (UTC) delete Unfortunately, neither the current article after {{u|Cohd2}}'s additions nor searches disclose anything like the requirements of . The ''New York Times'' article, for example, merely mentions the article subject in passing in a parenthetical phrase. She may well have been an early pioneer in the American graphic design industry, but there aren't |verifiable sources to document it Deletion of Joan Gramatte WP:GNG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
7286 6247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Collapse (band) User:Angryapathy 21:55, 13 November 2009 (UTC) delete Impaled should read and in regards to our notability and reliable sourcing policies. This article does not meet our notability guidelines, and the sources provided (or any I could find) are not reliable sources from an independent third party Deletion of Collapse (band) WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7287 5004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cool Handshakes NONE NONE delete No notability whatsoever: and purely unencyclopedic material Deletion of Cool Handshakes WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7288 10844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lorkhan (Elder Scrolls) User:Gavin 08:55, 6 December 2007 (UTC) delete """as there are no primary source cited to |verify the """"content"""" of this article, which is unecessary #PLOT|plot summary anyway. There are no |reliable secondary sources to demonstrate the |notability of this fictional deity outside of the The Elder Scrolls canon""" Deletion of Lorkhan (Elder Scrolls) WP:V||WP:NOT||WP:RS||WP:FICT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7289 19335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Broda Otto Barnes (2nd nomination) User:Fences 21:40, 2 June 2010 (UTC) keep """Seems like he passes : """"The person has made substantial impact outside academia in their academic capacity"""" is passed as his 1976 book ''Hypothyroidism: the unsuspected illness'' has oodles of attention from the natural medicine field. His work is now outdated, he has been latched onto by fringe groups for a long time (this from 1980http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=dQgAAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA51), and his work on hypothyroidism has been criticised (e.g. http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=5fAdyHaHbTcC&pg=PA30http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/524955http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2595160/?tool=pmcentrez), but cannot be a reason to delete an article about a person, no matter how ridiculous the fan-boy adoration by CAM advocates gets. You want to delete this because you don't like quacks quoting him, not because of a genuine lack of notability. He published in JAMA,http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/summary/119/14/1072http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/summary/101/12/926 The Lancet,http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/13796871 Science,http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17814070http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17837041 JBC, and other medical and scientific journals a number of times over several decades from the '30s to the '70s, presented at FASEB,http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1915406/, and his work was prominent enough to be quoted in the abstract of a review in ''Geriatrics'' in 1979 on hormones and heart disease:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/447079. He was quoted as a medical expert in the press over several decades, e.g. http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=mdXjAAAAMAAJ&q=broda+barnes&dq=broda+barnes&lr=&as_drrb_is=b&as_minm_is=0&as_miny_is=&as_maxm_is=12&as_maxy_is=1990&as_brr=0&ei=6ssGTKrSIZG2ygS_6M37BQ&client=firefox-a&cd=18http://news.google.co.uk/newspapers?id=JNANAAAAIBAJ&sjid=GXcDAAAAIBAJ&pg=7029,1884564&dq=broda-barnes&hl=enhttp://news.google.com/newspapers?id=lFgbAAAAIBAJ&sjid=bkwEAAAAIBAJ&pg=5004,1533786&dq=broda+barnes&hl=enhttp://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/chicagotribune/access/467255202.html?dids=467255202:467255202&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:AI&type=historic&date=Apr+19%2C+1941&author=&pub=Chicago+Tribune&desc=SCIENTISTS+TELL+SOME+STARTLING+NEW+DISCOVERIES&pqatl=googlehttp://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/latimes/access/426357281.html?dids=426357281:426357281&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:AI&type=historic&date=Apr+09%2C+1953&author=&pub=Los+Angeles+Times&desc=THYROID+LAG+SEEN+IN+COLD+VICTIMS&pqatl=google. Much of the coverage of him and his work is hiding behind pay-walls and on dead trees in libraries, so do watch out for FUTON bias. Have a browse through this pre-1990 book search to get a feel for how much coverage he received over the decades:http://books.google.co.uk/books?client=firefox-a&lr=&as_brr=0&q=broda+barnes&btnG=Search+Books&as_drrb_is=b&as_minm_is=0&as_miny_is=&as_maxm_is=1&as_maxy_is=1990 Also, the nominator is a new account intimately familar with Wikipedia processes such as AfD, ANI and RfCs. I wonder if they need to be on the receiving end of another TLA: SPI""" Deletion of Broda Otto Barnes (2nd nomination) WP:PROF||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
7290 11453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Felicia Tang (2nd nomination) User:Justmeherenow 02:39, 4 October 2009 (UTC) keep per'' what says about |notable pop culture subjects covered in reliable sources Deletion of Felicia Tang (2nd nomination) WP:FANCRUFT||WP:N Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
7291 12683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dale Roberts (footballer born 1986) User:Malcolmxl5 21:46, 2 March 2008 (UTC) delete does not meet thlete at this time Deletion of Dale Roberts (footballer born 1986) WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
7292 21803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Smidge User:Cnilep 16:49, 1 January 2010 (UTC) merge to wikt:smidge per Deletion of Smidge WP:NOTDIC Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
7293 16986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eli Babalj User:Zanoni 05:47, 5 May 2010 (UTC) delete fails and - recreate if / when meets either criteria Deletion of Eli Babalj WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7294 16851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hear Kitty Studios User:Armbrust 21:45, 9 July 2010 (UTC) delete per #A7|A7, no indication of notability Deletion of Hear Kitty Studios WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
7295 18870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SafeMinds User:WeijiBaikeBianji 01:59, 20 September 2013 (UTC) delete Indeed, there do not appear to be sufficient reliable sources that mention this organization more than in passing to meet the requirements of Deletion of SafeMinds WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7296 82 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dustin-Leigh Konzelman User:Geymarfan 02:37, 6 March 2018 (UTC) keep I am surprised at this deletion discussion. Coverage in CBS, Fox News. 10news.com etc. Should pass WP:SIGCOV Deletion of Dustin-Leigh Konzelman WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
7297 13047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gael Etock User:Argyle 17:14, 3 July 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Gael Etock WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
7298 1673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erick Schat's Bakkerÿ User:Piotrus 05:08, 17 November 2015 (UTC) delete as failing (regional/in-passing coverage) but I'd also suggest that the content should be merged to Wikivoyage article about the city, where it can be a valid POI, with its current description copied there. http://legacy.utsandiego.com/uniontrib/20060212/news_1t12schats.html is good enough that it would warrant a mention of the business place at the city's article, too. But I don't feel it's enough to support a stand alone notability Deletion of Erick Schat's Bakkerÿ WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
7299 9634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emulators unlimited User:ColourBurst 02:17, 7 October 2006 (UTC) comment The notability of UltraHLE isn't in question here (the links you gave solved that one pretty thoroughly). The link between emuunlim and UltraHLE is harder, and if I ask Realityman, he will probably say you were influential in the distribution of UltraHLE. Unfortunately, Some of Wikipedia's principles are |Verifiability, not Truth and |No Original Research, which means that we couldn't use his statements unless they were published in a third-party reliable source. We also couldn't contact Nintendo for this information for the same reason Deletion of Emulators unlimited WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7300 12929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean O'Dwyer (artist) User:Coolabahapple 02:40, 4 November 2020 (UTC) comment has exhibited at Royal Hibernian Academy (http://www.nival.ie/collections/exhibitions-database/view/exhibition/exb-name/sculpture-open/ here), and Limerick City Gallery of Art (http://www.nival.ie/collections/exhibitions-database/view/exhibition/exb-name/ev-a-limerick-11/ here) but a lot more needed to meet Deletion of Sean O'Dwyer (artist) WP:NARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
7301 648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blossom Ozurumba User:Rhododendrites 14:32, 23 August 2016 (UTC) keep Looks to pass with the sources in the article and those linked by {{u|Montanabw}} and {{u|Stanleytux}}. &mdash Deletion of Blossom Ozurumba WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7302 7419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liam Mooney User:Ukexpat 02:19, 28 April 2009 (UTC) delete Clearly fails Deletion of Liam Mooney WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
7303 845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reece Horn User:Eagles247 03:40, 4 January 2021 (UTC) keep appears to pass from the sources I've added to the article: https://www.newspapers.com/clip/66848028/the-indianapolis-star/ ''The Indianapolis Star'' #1, https://www.newspapers.com/clip/66847838/the-indianapolis-star/ ''The Indianapolis Star'' #2, https://www.newspapers.com/clip/66847738/the-indianapolis-star/ ''The Indianapolis Star'' #3, https://www.nwitimes.com/ap/sports/former-colts-intern-horn-seeks-to-make-titans-as-receiver/article_4b980cae-1e24-5568-beea-f027ec1d9081.html Associated Press article, https://www.tampabay.com/sports/vipers/2020/02/21/the-unique-paths-that-brought-these-vipers-to-the-xfl/ ''The Tampa Bay Times''. Article would have been better served incubated in draftspace first since this is the first creation from a newer user and has many MOS/formatting issues Deletion of Reece Horn WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7304 4387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Little Soap and Water User:Colonel 17:53, 23 December 2010 (UTC) keep The sources provided demonstrate that the article passes both and Deletion of A Little Soap and Water WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7305 3493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Skinhead websites User:RJHall 18:33, 30 November 2005 (UTC) delete """per policy established with """"#Wikipedia is not a mirror or a repository of links, images, or media files"""". &mdash""" Deletion of List of Skinhead websites WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7306 1572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/YoungPrince User:Thisizprince 06:19, 13 October 2010 (UTC) delete Young Prince also needs to be salted. Lots of and no Deletion of YoungPrince WP:OR||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
7307 192 [[Christliche Psychotherapie]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Wuselmart 01:23, 6. Apr. 2007 (CEST) delete Das tolle und eigentlich dreiste ist, dass nach der ganzen Diskussion im /27. April 2006#Christliche_Psychotherapie Bleibt |Mai 06 der Artikel gelöscht wurde, von Löschung von Christliche Psychotherapie Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
7308 20196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eccpasian User:Evb 12:42, 7 June 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. No . Should be speedy as . It is Wikipedia:complete bollocks|complete bollocks Deletion of Eccpasian WP:RS||WP:NONSENSE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7309 200 [[BIFOA]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Darknesstaker NONE keep Sehe hier auch Relevanz aufgrund der besonderen Tradition und des überregionalen Wirkens gegeben. Zudem ist der Artikel durch die Überarbeitung nun strukturierter und recht gut belegt. Von daher und ggf. noch weiter für die |Oma ausfeilen Löschung von BIFOA Wikipedia:Oma Wikipedia:Allgemeinverständlichkeit 79
7310 8787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trump derangement syndrome User:E 21:00, 7 July 2019 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Trump derangement syndrome WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
7311 13531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Best of Times (TV pilot) User:Davidstewartharvey 05:59, 29 June 2020 (UTC) keep there is three independent reviews that show notability for gng, as they are not just statements but full reviews. The comment that ''The only reason this got newspaper coverage, in turn, was to fill space on a newspaper's television page'' is one of the daftest arguments I have ever heard! That would mean all TV reviews are rubbish and could not be used as notability, which would then mean most TV programs would not be on wikipedia. I also argue the case for ; Deletion of The Best of Times (TV pilot) WP:NOTPAPER||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7312 6832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anukriti Gusain User:NickCT 12:42, 17 April 2013 (UTC) delete She does get mention in several mainstream |RS, but she's most of the mention is in the form of lists of contestants. Probably not sufficient to meet notability guidelines Deletion of Anukriti Gusain WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7313 13584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ghost of a fallen age User:Llama 21:45, 18 January 2007 (UTC) delete per #A7|CSD A7, non-notable band. &ndash Deletion of Ghost of a fallen age WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
7314 15804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farseer Physics Engine User:Secret 03:27, 26 May 2012 (UTC) delete """no evidence of meeting , being useful for students isn't a valid reason for keeping this article, nor is neither. No evidence of Northamerica1000 assertion that this software is """"computing history"""", and no one countered SL93 evaluation about the reliability of the two sources that JulesH gave""" Deletion of Farseer Physics Engine WP:GNG||WP:IAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
7315 12841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daang Hari Elementary School User:Extraordinary 16:56, 26 April 2021 (UTC) delete primary schools are only rarely notable, and my searches find no coverage sufficient to meet the |GNG. No target for redirection is apparent Deletion of Daang Hari Elementary School WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7316 20399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brandon Buchanan User:GlassCobra 16:02, 14 October 2009 (UTC) delete per NawlinWiki and Royalbroil. Does not meet Deletion of Brandon Buchanan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7317 19466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Redaelli-Granoli User:Guillaume2303 17:28, 16 April 2012 (UTC) merge """Perhaps some people find it fascinating to learn that """"She likes cooking and eating tasty food, reading newspapers and watching television, and listen to football games"""". But that is not enough for notability. Does not meet . As the nom says, her high age falls under . If the outcome of this AfD is redirect, then please protect from recurrent IP vandalism""" Deletion of Maria Redaelli-Granoli WP:GNG||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
7318 7917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mahmood Khan (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 15:31, 6 April 2018 (UTC) delete """Wikipedia is not a free public relations platform for |advertorial self-promotion, but an encyclopedia. Our content needs to be referenced to |reliable source coverage in media, not to the subject's own press releases — and apart from an unverified claim that he topped """"the mainstream Australian music charts"""", which also fails to specify which chart provider is involved and thus could be iTunes for all we know, the only other notability claim here is """"got X views on a piece of social media content"""", which is not a valid notability claim in its own right. (And for the record, my only past involvement here was moving the article from an inappropriate category to a more correct one in a batch of categorization cleanup.) There are no references here that constitute reliable sourcing for a Wikipedia article, and the article doesn't state anything about him that's """"inherently"""" notable enough to exempt him from having to have reliable sourcing — and even if a new version can be recreated in the future that makes a better claim of notability and cites better sources for it, he still doesn't get to create the article himself per and """ Deletion of Mahmood Khan (2nd nomination) WP:NOTADVERT||WP:RS||WP:AUTOBIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7319 11655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tourparty User:Lankiveil 12:46, 11 January 2008 (UTC) delete would seem to be a non-notable camp that fails Deletion of Tourparty WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
7320 7456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avalon Park, Florida User:Pontificalibus 07:00, 14 August 2019 (UTC) keep Notable neighbourhood with significant coverage in reliable sources. Satisifes Deletion of Avalon Park, Florida WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
7321 3647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harvey Tolibao User:JayJay 19:03, 1 June 2015 (UTC) keep Meets Deletion of Harvey Tolibao WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7322 8837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/High-loss calculation User:TonyBallioni 00:41, 13 September 2017 (UTC) merge replyto|Tigraan|Kvng}}, looking over this again, I would be fine with a redirect here, no merge, but allowing the content to be kept in the history for a potential merge if the online source can actually be produced. There's nothing harmful in the page history, so a redirect would follow both and Deletion of High-loss calculation WP:PRESERVE||WP:V Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
7323 5434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A. D. Williams Engineering crashes User:MilborneOne 18:32, 15 September 2008 (UTC) delete two non-notable accidents, only link between company is that both aircraft had employees involved. Some information could be salvaged into a company article if the company was notable enough for its own article although nothing in the article mentions the effect on the company other that to act as a |memorial Deletion of A. D. Williams Engineering crashes WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7324 14890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna James (2nd nomination) User:Drm310 15:21, 8 April 2014 (UTC) comment Another user has provided a list https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk%3AArthistorygrrl&diff=603310649&oldid=601561214 of scanned images from printed publications. At least some of them appear to be from reliable sources and feature non-trivial coverage. Unfortunately they are hard to read, and some of them are foreign-language publications. It's unclear to me how many of them would count as and therefore satisfy Deletion of Anna James (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7325 17204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lake Malawi (band) User:Michig 21:07, 7 August 2015 (UTC) comment BBC 6 Music is a broadcast radio station. How about looking beyond what's in the article per ? There's plenty of Czech coverage of the band and some in English, e.g. http://www.radio.cz/en/section/arts/ex-charlie-straight-frontman-albert-cerny-moves-to-lake-malawi, http://www.lidovky.cz/nechci-delat-veci-ze-setrvacnosti-rika-albert-cerny-z-lake-malawi-pxy-/kultura.aspx?c=A141128_100300_ln_kultura_hep, http://www.novinky.cz/kultura/325514-zpevak-albert-cerny-ze-skupiny-lake-malawi-chtel-bych-od-fanousku-druhou-sanci.html, http://www.kzvalmez.cz/tiskovy-servis/Albert-Cerny-predstavi-novou-kapelu-Lake-Malawi-premierove-ve-Valmezu/#.VcUcu_NVjKA, http://www.melty.cz/lake-malawi-zkusime-v-britanii-stesti-rika-albert-cerny-v-rozhovoru-s-melty-a590.html, http://www.brainstormag.cz/neco-textu/442-rozhovor-lake-malawi-bude-lepsi-nez-charlie-straight-veri-albert-cerny, http://www.popmatters.com/post/187739-lake-malawi-chinese-trees-audio-premiere/, http://www.radio.cz/de/rubrik/tagesecho/lake-malawi-neustart-fuer-albert-cerny Deletion of Lake Malawi (band) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
7326 6431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Free World User:Cnilep 00:33, 29 October 2011 (UTC) keep """The current state of the article is indeed """"super flawed"""", but |deletion is not for clean-up. Potential sources exist, even if few are cited at present. DICDEF does not apply, as even in its current state the article goes far beyond just a definition, and there is potential for historical, political, and sociological discussion of the topic. Editors and the closing admin should also note the recent discussion at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leader of the Free World""" Deletion of Free World WP:UGLY Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
7327 7398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spine (Alcoholic Bevrage) User:Stifle 11:45, 9 October 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Spine (Alcoholic Bevrage) WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
7328 2778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Jewish Fellows of the Royal Society (3rd nomination) User:Morton_devonshire 07:29, 26 June 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. is prohibited by our rules here Deletion of List of Jewish Fellows of the Royal Society (3rd nomination) WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
7329 2622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jewish Life Network User:Arnzy 13:12, 20 June 2006 (UTC) delete per as nn organisation Deletion of Jewish Life Network WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
7330 5535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alleged Clinton Controversies User:AlexanderLevian 22:46, 28 July 2015 (UTC) delete There are no comparable articles for other past presidents. problems as well Deletion of Alleged Clinton Controversies WP:COAT Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
7331 17918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards (2nd nomination) User:DavidHOzAu 04:33, 16 February 2007 (UTC) keep per sources found above. I'd like to remind everyone here to remain |civil Deletion of Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards (2nd nomination) WP:CIVIL Wikipedia:Civility 37
7332 16309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathan Winneke User:SingCal 01:20, 29 February 2008 (UTC) comment Removal of controversial material doesn't necessarily signify a COI... see the guidlelines at Deletion of Nathan Winneke WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
7333 9947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William S. Evans User:Anotherclown 21:13, 15 November 2014 (UTC) merge doesn't meet , redirect to Band of Brothers article as probably still a valid search term Deletion of William S. Evans WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7334 10494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SpyCatcher User:Doc 22:19, 3 October 2009 (UTC) merge to Spycatcher as a likely search term. Current article does not meet Deletion of SpyCatcher WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7335 20976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AraPacis User:Cullen328 05:41, 2 January 2011 (UTC) comment Slugguitar who objected to deletion and has edited the article has a |conflict of interest. He openly admits he is Jerry Fielden, the lead guitarist and front man for AraPacis Deletion of AraPacis WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
7336 11828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pissing contest [[User_talk:Wolfkeeper|'''Wolfkeeper''']] 03:47, 10 November 2009 (UTC) comment the article is even a substantial of an article created by the same person at nearly the same time (Battle of egos Deletion of Pissing contest WP:content fork Wikipedia:Content forking 33
7337 13267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lindsay Lohan's Third Album User:Bfigura 00:04, 11 May 2008 (UTC) delete as there don't seem to be reliable sources that can verify this |crystal ball gazing Deletion of Lindsay Lohan's Third Album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7338 12094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J.R. Rodriguez User:Amalthea 11:36, 8 August 2008 (UTC) delete fails /. Production company is not (yet) notable Deletion of J.R. Rodriguez WP:BIO||WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
7339 16850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gengar User:Haleth 08:40, 23 June 2021 (UTC) keep based on the extent of the sourcing, and without doing a , I am not convinced that this article strictly fails as alleged by the nominator and other editors. In any event, this should have been the subject of a merge discussion as opposed to a deletion discussion since a few editors have proposed that a large swath of the content may in fact be salvageable Deletion of Gengar WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
7340 1412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelly Barrett User:Hell 00:56, 14 July 2013 (UTC) delete This was a pure promotion plain and simple. It was originally deleted as such then immediately recreated. The account that made it is the PR person or is the subject themself. Fails Deletion of Kelly Barrett WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7341 17308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siemon Allen User:Alan 05:01, 15 July 2011 (UTC) delete Contested PROD. Fails Deletion of Siemon Allen WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
7342 15655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Over The Top (company) User:Cwmhiraeth 11:40, 12 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and as I am able to find passing mention of the firm but unable to find substantial coverage in reliable, independent sources Deletion of Over The Top (company) WP:CORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7343 20850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ron Delezio User:Whpq 18:58, 12 January 2007 (UTC) keep meets with reliabble sources provided for verification Deletion of Ron Delezio WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7344 5686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Starfest User:Zxcvbnm 14:16, 14 December 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Starfest WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7345 14150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Game, Get Some!: What Women Really Want User:Coolabahapple 08:47, 20 April 2020 (UTC) delete does not meet or , a gsearch does not bring up any |reviews from reliable sources (the ''Ebony'' snip review might be ok if there was another with more depth but definitely not by itself), btw, being listed/reviewed/discussed on Barnes & Noble, Open Library, LibraryThing, OttoBib, Goodreads contributes zero wikinotability to a book Deletion of Game, Get Some!: What Women Really Want WP:NBOOK||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
7346 1479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laurie Calzada User:Joseph2302 10:33, 12 May 2015 (UTC) delete As above, she isn't notable as an entrepreneur, speaker or TV host, possibly as an author. However, this article isn't the one that's going to show that- if they are considered notable as an author, I would support , as this is a , with not enough focus on the only possibly notable thing Deletion of Laurie Calzada WP:TNT||WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
7347 16990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Wilks (musician) User:WikiDan61 21:20, 1 March 2016 (UTC) comment reply|Sandra.Samenkovic91}} The article does not assert either of those claims. Of what style is Wilks the most prominent representative, or of which city is he the most prominent musician? And where is the |verification of this claim? Also, of which substantial national broadcast segment was he the subject, and where is the verification of that claim Deletion of Steve Wilks (musician) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7348 21604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National Wild Turkey Federation User:Vulture19 17:27, 12 December 2009 (UTC) keep Publisher of quite a few papers regarding wild turkeys http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22National%20Wild%20Turkey%20Federation%22&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&tab=ns, it appears the conference they host is well attended by hunters and academics. Article should be POV tagged and an effort made to include some sources that aren't self-published. They definitely appear to meet per national scope and third party sources detailing activities (sources presented by Warrah Deletion of National Wild Turkey Federation WP:CLUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
7349 17800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robbie Best User:Fenix 14:34, 23 January 2014 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Robbie Best WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
7350 19066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International reaction to the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting User:Aircorn 08:37, 20 December 2012 (UTC) delete """This is not a as this content was not at the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting|main article when this one was created. Contrary to what is said above, Talk:Sandy_Hook_Elementary_School_shooting/Archive_4#Consensus_Restore_International_Reaction|the discussion on the talk page did not reach a consensus to create a new article. So this needs to stand on its own legs and satisfy the . To do that it needs """"significant coverage in reliable sources"""". So far what we have is news articles from various countries outside the US that have included the leaders reaction as a matter of course. Almost all the articles themselves are on the shooting, not the reaction. We have in effect synthesised them together to create this article. Maybe one day there will be scholarly studies that look at the reaction of the international community in relation to this event, but until then I don't think this meets our notability criteria""" Deletion of International reaction to the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting WP:GNG||WP:content fork Wikipedia:Notability 77
7351 21707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leah Zell User:MurderByDeadcopy 05:57, 30 January 2016 (UTC) keep Not only does Zell pass , but everyone here voting delete is saying that AfC is garbage and should be dumped as a horrible experiment because it doesn't work Deletion of Leah Zell WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7352 14953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Conway [[User talk:Orderinchaos|Orderinchaos]] 11:05, 7 October 2007 (UTC) delete If the guy's been approached by political parties to run, one would expect to find Factiva hits for him reflecting newspaper coverage. None have emerged. I tend to go with Zamphuor, SatuSuro and the nominator on this one on article lacking |notability and possibly an element of |complete bollocks. Also possible |BLP issues Deletion of Greg Conway WP:N||WP:CB||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
7353 20116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susie Field User:Guoguo12 00:35, 28 August 2010 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of Susie Field WP:A7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
7354 779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hitomi Mizutani User:Coccyx 16:54, 28 May 2008 (UTC) delete 9 minutes and counting, either way this still fails due to a complete lack of sources. My searches have turned up empty handed as well Deletion of Hitomi Mizutani WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
7355 11146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bêlit (2nd nomination) User:2pou 17:43, 17 August 2020 (UTC) keep I am swayed by the sources uncovered here. The article doesn't need to be long, but it seems that meeting the minimums of is done. I have no concern over short Stub- or Start-class articles. As a character that has also now starred in her own https://comicbookroundup.com/comic-books/reviews/marvel-comics/age-of-conan-belit comic book series, if a reader were to look up the character to discern interest, a standalone article would probably better serve them than sifting through extraneous information about the rest of the original work . There may be some character-specific discussion in those 16 reviews, but I don't think searching them for content that is probably not better than what has already been presented is necessary Deletion of Bêlit (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7356 10140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Third Intifada (2nd nomination) User:Marokwitz 08:54, 17 May 2011 (UTC) delete per . Wikipedia does not deal with speculated future historical events. No reliable sources say that this event actually happened. In the current form, should be speedily deleted Deletion of Third Intifada (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7357 1414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shannon lark User:Biruitorul 04:03, 12 February 2009 (UTC) delete for lack of multiple reliable sources. Ikip: Fangoria and Fearnet, being |self-published, violate our policy on |reliable sources Deletion of Shannon lark WP:SELFPUB||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7358 4818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Halfling (Dungeons & Dragons) User:Hog 02:49, 13 March 2020 (UTC) merge to Halfling. The topic of halflings as a whole is probably notable to some extent, and the D&D halflings would be part of that subject. However, the amount of detail in the entire article would be . A trimmed version should be merged, though Deletion of Halfling (Dungeons & Dragons) WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
7359 12444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aliens from Space: The Real Story of Unidentified Flying Objects NONE NONE delete per & complete lack of third-party sourcing to establish notability Deletion of Aliens from Space: The Real Story of Unidentified Flying Objects WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
7360 21071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of games with DirectX 12 support User:Ajf773 08:36, 20 June 2018 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of List of games with DirectX 12 support WP:NOTCATALOGUE||WP:NOTINDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7361 4317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grandayy User:Bakazza 18:13, 17 January 2019 (UTC) keep as per above and improve - It passes asic as per Deletion of Grandayy WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
7362 1503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Tudor pearl User:Uruiamme 07:25, 21 January 2015 (UTC) comment """I am somewhat taken aback that none of the comments so far have covered the blatant commercialized language in the article, as written. As I tried to make abundantly clear, the entire article, except its title, is written to promote the pearl that recently toured London. (Sure there are news articles about it, but See and .) But the problem is that there are two separate pearls. Are we needing three articles? One for pearl of Kuwait, one for La Peregrina pearl, and one for Mary Tudor pearl? That would be """"fair"""" by splitting off all of the claims and provenance stuff into the specific pearl articles, while the historical object gets its own page I guess? Modifying it is possible, but my opinion is severe curtailment until the sources roll in. The Mary Tudor pearl article is full of speculation as it is... no independent news article says all of these things, just your beloved encyclopedia. If some think the new pearl needs some space here in an article on Wikipedia, fine, but it needs a new title, sources to back up its claims, and cross-references to the controversial subject. Right now the encyclopedia looks to be making all the guesses for the pearl, while the news articles report the lack of provenance""" Deletion of Mary Tudor pearl WP:WHYN||WP:SPIP Wikipedia:Notability 77
7363 16162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Drudge User:Marasmusine 11:49, 10 July 2010 (UTC) delete None of this material is written within our guidelines for fiction (); no sources are presented that suggest these are notable topics Deletion of The Drudge WP:WAF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
7364 957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian Venables User:RGTraynor 20:17, 17 April 2007 (UTC) comment A survey of the links on a directed UK Google search (to eliminate an eponymous soldier and Wiki mirrors) http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=composer+%22Ian+Venables%22+-Wikipedia&hl=en&lr=&as_qdr=all&start=140&sa=N show only 87 unique ones, which is pretty poor. As against that, he does seem to have some small reputation. Unfortunately, none of the links represent |reliable, independent, published sources. Perhaps a backer of this article could find one, but the best I get are trivial mentions along the lines of Venables conducting concert X or musical group performing one of his works Deletion of Ian Venables WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7365 7908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Dicken User:Cunard 05:00, 3 March 2009 (UTC) keep Passes and . A pat on the back to Deletion of Peter Dicken WP:BIO||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
7366 7440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kokumo User:The 18:24, 4 March 2021 (UTC) delete possibly subject to OTRS request verification, in case this is a case of impersonation?) based on the combination of borderline notability and with the standard proviso that the article may be recreated at a later time if they become sufficiently notable that an article would be clearly appropriate Deletion of Kokumo WP:BLPREQUESTDELETE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
7367 19705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luxury Buyers User:AllyD 07:13, 12 July 2017 (UTC) delete """A promotionally-worded article which appears to have been referenced by just harvesting mention of the words """"luxury buyers"""" rather than articles about the particular firm of this name. I see |nothing to indicate |attained notability for this venture""" Deletion of Luxury Buyers :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7368 14273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamzah Aljahmi User:Jakejr 21:31, 28 December 2015 (UTC) delete All coverage related to his dying after his first pro fight so applies Deletion of Hamzah Aljahmi WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
7369 19851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fawad Hassan Fawad User:Ammarpad 06:57, 20 November 2017 (UTC) keep for bad nomination and many evidence that the subject is regularly mentioned in Pakistani press. I also see many sources https://tribune.com.pk/story/1399617/bureaucracy-creating-hurdles-says-industries-minister/ like this related to him. He certainly passes as well known government official. Also the nominator is merely looking for additional sources (per his statement above) and this is wrong place to ask that. There's template for such request like {{tl|refimprove}} and many others '' —'' Deletion of Fawad Hassan Fawad WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7370 6136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chappargram User:A 21:02, 10 April 2010 (UTC) keep """as per , our precedent is that """"cities and villages are generally kept, regardless of size, as long as their existence is verified through a reliable source."""" A government website is surely a reliable source""" Deletion of Chappargram WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
7371 7216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaolin Kickboxing Club User:Nsk92 14:21, 24 July 2008 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability of the club per or Deletion of Shaolin Kickboxing Club WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7372 12717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Chemical Romance's Upcoming Fourth Studio Album User:Darkspots 01:15, 29 June 2007 (UTC) delete Lacking independent corroboration, it's unverifiable--therefore it fails Deletion of My Chemical Romance's Upcoming Fourth Studio Album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7373 14959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lenny Pelling User:Pedro 00:45, 16 February 2008 (UTC) delete I'd love to be saying keep, but the assertions in the article don't seem to match up to reality. In addition for a policy based reason Deletion of Lenny Pelling WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
7374 11231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SOFTEC User:Ammarpad 19:45, 1 December 2017 (UTC) delete non notable event. An event in college/versity is very hard to be notable up to encyclopedic standardandeven meet . Completely sourced with self-published sources thus lackings reliable and independent secondary sources Deletion of SOFTEC WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7375 3960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Restore The Broken User:Eagleash 22:23, 3 July 2021 (UTC) delete No indication of notability does not pass ; unable to find much, if anything, in the way of SIGCOV Deletion of Restore The Broken :WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7376 19813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tribalwar User:Torinir 00:47, 22 July 2006 (UTC) comment Really, if the article was stripped to the bare-bones and rebuilt, it could be done right and done without the problems. The major issue would be trying to keep it clean and on topic Deletion of Tribalwar WP:VANITY Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
7377 39 [[Rumpelstilzchenproblem]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Jesi 04:43, 10. Aug. 2007 (CEST) delete Der http://www.knowtech2002.de/Eckardt_Detecon%20International_.pdf erste Google-Treffer führt zu einer Arbeit einer Frau Christiane Eckardt, die nächsten beiden im Prinzip ebenso, in dieser http://paper.joerg-rech.com/Studenten/Studienarbeit_Eberle.pdf Studentenarbeit wird auf die Arbeit von Frau Eckardt verwiesen, http://www.smb.spk-berlin.de/ifm/dokumente/mitteilungen/MIT006.pdf hier tritt das Lemma ein paar mal in Anführungszeichen auf. Ich denke, das ist ein Fall versuchter sein. Bin für Löschung von Rumpelstilzchenproblem Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
7378 2824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohamed Herida User:GiantSnowman 17:08, 31 August 2009 (UTC) delete non-notable player who fails and Deletion of Mohamed Herida WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7379 8041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One Month in Hell User:Makemi 17:40, 23 June 2006 (UTC) comment """I find nothing to indicate that the company making this film is notable either. A search for """"Larkin Street Angels"""" on google gives nothing either, and the website consists of one page announcing this film, with the barest minimum of information. To the above (195) I have seen no information on the writer, and the """"high profile cast"""" consists only of Jai Rodriguez, with no information on anyone else who might be in this film. If there's so much interest in this film there should be more information on it in the media. Once there is that interest in the media, and the film has been released and shown itself to be of interest, then write the article. |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball""" Deletion of One Month in Hell WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7380 18174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Gaudino User:David 18:54, 16 July 2020 (UTC) keep We have only a borderline case for (I found more full-length reviews of his first book so now we have three for it but only a brief review of the second) but I think together with the extensive -type coverage of his life and teaching I think it's enough Deletion of Robert Gaudino WP:AUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7381 18537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Audrish Banerjee User:Coolabahapple 08:38, 8 June 2020 (UTC) keep meets Deletion of Audrish Banerjee WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7382 19720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Son of Slaves and Lords User:Ghernandez152 21:56, 29 January 2010 (UTC) keep Satisfies #1 on (http://hhhdb.com/index.php?id=605 & http://www.ieweekly.com/cms/story/detail/atom_tha_immortal/681/ are two examples Deletion of Son of Slaves and Lords WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
7383 21484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/An injury to one is an injury to all User:Shoessss 00:58, 4 August 2008 (UTC) keep Sorry to disagree, but there does seem to be enough coverage of the slogan to at least expand on the article as shown here http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22An+injury+to+one+is+an+injury+to+all+%22&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8. I noticed that this coverage from well established – reliable – creditable – and trustworthy sources not only in the USA, but international outlets as well to establish otability|Notability Deletion of An injury to one is an injury to all WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7384 14917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of future tallest buildings in the world User:Lugnuts 12:40, 24 March 2014 (UTC) delete As being totally unsourced. The |burden is with the article creator, and by looking at their edit history, is reasonably experienced. Or maybe move to their sandbox so they can source this list before pushing it back into the article space Deletion of List of future tallest buildings in the world WP:BURDEN Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7385 3805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Austin Thomas User:Jerry_teps 08:35, 21 August 2008 (UTC) comment Nom is a . That's why I didn't take an indepth look at the article. I'm sorry and I wont make the mistake again. &ndash Deletion of Austin Thomas WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
7386 17526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Margaret Brown (criminal) User:Edison 01:25, 15 August 2008 (UTC) comment """Several of the """"delete"""" !votes are basically or """"So and sos are inherently nonnotable"""", ignoring the 168 word article about her long criminal career in the 1884 NY Times and the four book references.The one JohnZ presents http://books.google.com/books?id=ZrAXAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA375&dq=%22Mother+Hubbard%22+%22Margaret+Brown%22&output=html is definitely substantial coverage, stating that her face is familiar to detectives of every large country in the U.S. I have now located a copy of the 1929 """"Gangs of New York"""" and will check it when I get hands on it for the extent of coverage. Per Google Book Search, under her alias """"Mother Hubbard"""" she is discussed in """"The American Way of Crime"""" (1980) By Frank Browning and, John Gerassi,"""" page 283 along with her criminal associate Black Lena Kleinschmidt. She is mentioned in """"Women, Crime, and Justice"""" (1980), by Susan K. Datesman, Frank R. Scarpitti, page 193, in """"The Professional Fence"""" (1974) by Carl B. Klockars, page 176, and in """"Crime and justice: V.1"""" (1977) by Leon Radzinowicz and Marvin E. Wolfgang, Page 312""" Deletion of Margaret Brown (criminal) WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
7387 9875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason A. Haap User:xyzzy_n 01:39, 7 August 2006 (UTC) delete preferably speedily, for making unsourced negative |statements about a living person Deletion of Jason A. Haap WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
7388 11744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SDD Global Solutions User:Rpclod 04:45, 16 July 2015 (UTC) delete nothing shows notability Deletion of SDD Global Solutions WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7389 11906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Scanlan (logic historian) [[User_talk:Sanchom|Sancho]] 18:13, 23 December 2013 (UTC) delete """I tried cleaning up the article. Ended up having to delete the """"education"""" section since I couldn't find any references to support it. I can't find any evidence that Scanlan means , , or """ Deletion of Michael Scanlan (logic historian) WP:PROF||WP:BASIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7390 16752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hadith of loving and hating User:Charlene 16:06, 6 January 2007 (UTC) delete No |reliable sources given for the balance of the conclusions in this pro-Shia POV essay Deletion of Hadith of loving and hating WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7391 10897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/For the Sake of Mahdi (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:51, 11 May 2014 (UTC) comment I would urge thenominator to read to understand that sources, specially for an Arabic film not released in the USA, need not be in English. And toward his inability read the sources, I would suggest he use one of the many translators available online, and perhaps that they verify the article as required ''unless'' able to ''show'' that they do not Deletion of For the Sake of Mahdi (film) WP:NONENG||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7392 3268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Awaaz-e-Punjab User:Kraose 08:47, 30 July 2018 (UTC) delete per . A mention already exists on Navjot_Singh_Sidhu#Politics|main page Deletion of Awaaz-e-Punjab WP:INHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
7393 18697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trans-Christianity User:TedE 14:56, 16 June 2006 (UTC) delete as |original research, even though '''I''' like to dress-up Deletion of Trans-Christianity WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
7394 19939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Schlafly (3rd nomination) User:Fabartus 06:32, 14 July 2008 (UTC) keep """Per Notability Quote: The topic of an article should be notable, or """"worthy of notice""""; that is """"significant, interesting, or unusual enough to deserve attention or to be recorded."""" I fail to see how this guy '''isn't interesting''' to someone, and his IN-YOUR-FACE attitude and behavior is '''unusual''', so while David Eppstein almost had me convinced, the cites really don't matter a whole hill of beans relative to the overall mission. rules, as usual, in any case. {{indent|3}}What's there in footnotes certainly supports the brief sketch that is present. That last paragraph certainly is unclear, though. Stuff has to be written as if links aren't on the page, or the writing fails. When pray tell does another encyclopedia rely on link to find out why PZ whoever is in conflict with Schlafly, or the professor field of study? Poor writing there. """"Carl Zimmer stated that it was readily apparent that """"Schlafly had not bothered to read Lenski's paper closely"""",22 and PZ Myers criticized Schlafly for demanding data despite not having a plan to use it nor the expertise to analyze it.23. Schafly ignores the possibility of adressing the editor of the journal with publishing a comment."""" So who the heck is Carl Zimmer and why is he stating something? THAT's what needs fixed in this, not its presence. That double period on footnote 23 don't look to good neither. We have a Bot looking for those""" Deletion of Andrew Schlafly (3rd nomination) WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
7395 10783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Livingston Gilson Irving User:Cameron11598 21:54, 27 August 2012 (UTC) delete I agree with RightCowLeftCoast there is insufficent coverage , also fails Deletion of Livingston Gilson Irving WP:GNG||WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
7396 246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Senate bill 0099 User:Gnfnrf NONE delete Classic article. All of the pertinent information can (and has) go into the articles about what this article is actually about, the 2008 US Presidential campaign. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Senate bill 0099 WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
7397 10681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Andrew Roth User:Nsk92 11:26, 11 October 2008 (UTC) delete He works in algebraic geometry, which is perhaps the toughest area of pure math in terms of obtaining new results and where people do not publish a lot. I checked MathSciNet and he has 7 papers listed there (which does seem to be a bit low even for algebraic geometry). Two of them are in top-notch journals: one in Inventiones Mathematicaehttp://www.springerlink.com/content/1t5fdhvldupx4nqr/?p=b8ca9c75970e4a8da16287a6ce17a90d&pi=1 and one in Crelle's Journalhttp://www.reference-global.com/doi/abs/10.1515/crll.2004.045 That's very good but, in the absence of additional evidence, not good enough for passing . Citation hits, both in googlescholar and in mathscinet, are pretty low and neither the WP article nor his webpage give any other information (such as honors/awards, journal editorships, etc) that might indicate passing Deletion of Michael Andrew Roth WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
7398 1014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clive Parker User:Cindamuse 00:08, 26 April 2011 (UTC) comment These deletion discussions run for seven days, or until such time as consensus is reached. At that time, another editor will assess the discussion and close accordingly. You can find further information about these discussions at these links: , EQ, and . The forum is provided for editors to make recommendations on the notability and viability of an article, supported by policy. Editors often revise their recommendation according to the strength of the presentations made by others in the discussion. When an editor chooses to change their recommendation, they reflect this change by striking out the previous notation that they made. Feel free to ask questions any time Deletion of Clive Parker WP:AFD||WP:AFDEQ||WP:DISCUSSAFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
7399 1202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ted Frank User:TedFrank 19:54, 26 August 2007 (UTC) comment I said I wasn't going to participate in this, but people keep asking my opinion, so I'm here to make a statement. The reality is that I cannot express an opinion because it will be spun against me either way: if I say the article should be kept, I will be accused of self-promotion, and if I say the article should be deleted, I will be accused of seeking some sort of cover up. I am certainly amused by the number of !votes that are plainly based on the assumption that I want the article deleted, and seriously considered casting a !vote for keep just to see how many people on both sides changed their mind. (So maybe I do want the article kept? Or am I just saying that to encourage delete votes?) I hope I have now sufficiently sown enough confusion about my hidden desires that editors will now be forced to make their decisions and discuss their reasoning on the basis of and other Wikipedia policies rather than lobbying for or against what I want Deletion of Ted Frank WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7400 6589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SpaceShaft [[User talk:101.117.28.72|talk]]) 04:51, 10 July 2014 (UTC) delete No 3rd party sources found. Fails . -- Special:Contributions/101.117.28.72|101.117.28.72 Deletion of SpaceShaft WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7401 17285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ava Inferi User:Banime 16:04, 21 September 2008 (UTC) delete does not pass : ''It has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent from the musician/ensemble itself and reliable.'' That is not true, the article is almost completely unsourced and has no good verifiable third party sources Deletion of Ava Inferi WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7402 295 [[Teststrecke (Achterbahn)]] (erl., LAE) Benutzer:X-Weinzar 02:38, 15. Okt. 2009 (CEST) keep Antragssteller: ''keine Relevanz lt. '' - hmmmm, wo steht denn dort was zu Achterbahnen? Zufällig weiß ich, dass es mal andiskutiert wurde. Ergebnis: Jede individuelle Achterbahn ist relevant, also z.B. keine Wilde Maus|Wilden Mäusen. Was haben wir hier? - Einen Anton Schwarzkopf|Schwarzkopfschen Klassiker, mittlerweile 30 Jahre auf dem Buckel; erst stationär in Brasilien, dann stationär in Amiland, nun über Deutschlands Jahrmärkte tingelnd - na wenn das mal keinen Artikel wert ist! ;-) Unter den transportablen Bahnen Deutschlands wohl die zweit- oder drittgrößte, oder wars die zweit- oder drittgrößte mit Looping? Oder die zweit- oder drittgrößte mit mehr als einem Looping? Bin jetzt zu faul, dem auf den Grund zu gehen, wieviele Einschränkungen da nötig sind, damit die Behauptung stimmt. Irgendsowas stand jedenfalls auf mehreren Websites, die ich vorhin so durchgeguckt hab. Achso: Artikel neugeschrieben, spätestens jetzt swert Löschung von Teststrecke (Achterbahn) Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
7403 17342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/O Tahiti Nui Freedom User:Loriendrew NONE keep may not be as notable as the :Kon-Tiki expedition, but it does appear to at least meet as a recreation of historial significance (too lazy to fix that grammar).— Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of O Tahiti Nui Freedom WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7404 9752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of deceased anime characters User:Knowledgekid87 19:48, 5 September 2017 (UTC) delete """This list is deceased |here on Wikipedia. I want to add that in Puella Magi Madoka Magica per nom the characters are brought back multiple times. When you say """"deceased"""" do you mean The Princess Bride (film)|mostly dead, or all dead""" Deletion of List of deceased anime characters WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
7405 9775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marti Wright User:Bejnar 23:22, 25 June 2020 (UTC) delete lacks significant coverage, fails Deletion of Marti Wright WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7406 14974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Texvc User:Joe 14:31, 21 February 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of Texvc WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7407 17014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Academic racism User:MarcoTolo 23:33, 23 July 2007 (UTC) delete Article was http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Academic_racism&diff=132142158&oldid=97235381 added two months ago by an account which has made no other WP edits - at all. -o-meter is high on this one Deletion of Academic racism WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
7408 9556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ORT Software User:BradBeattie 13:28, 16 November 2006 (UTC) delete per . None of their games are notable Deletion of ORT Software WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
7409 20321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1922 Washington State Cougars football team User:Paulmcdonald 21:04, 20 October 2016 (UTC) keep """not only is it standard to keep season articles for current NCAA Division I FBS teams going back to the origin of the team, each season normally more than surpasses the |general notability guideline easily. Add to that the head coach for the season was Gus Welch, who was inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame. Plus, Washington State football goes back to 1894 and its membership in the Pacific Coast Conference started in 1917 (which they christened with a conference championship), confirming it was a top-level program even at the time. Oh, and they won the 1916 Rose Bowl to cap off an undefeated season of 7-0. This is most certainly not an """"obscure"""" program. This is a clearly an article that needs to be built up, not deleted""" Deletion of 1922 Washington State Cougars football team WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7410 13678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irene A. Bradford User:Cullen328 03:58, 18 March 2013 (UTC) delete per . This is a nicely done biography of an upstanding citizen known only in her community. I have several such individuals among my ancestors. I do not intend to write Wikipedia biographies of them. I do not believe that routine local newspaper coverage makes an ordinary hardworking person notable Deletion of Irene A. Bradford WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7411 5768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Kennedy (chemistry spokesperson) User:Deli 12:26, 8 October 2018 (UTC) comment As someone interested in food and chemistry, I'm familiar with the work of James Kennedy and I've seen his infographics in many places. But I'm not sure he meets criteria outlined at . I think his work trying to teach the public about chemophobia is worth mentioning somewhere on Wikipedia (Googling the term chemophobia and james kennedy turns up many results). He may be individually responsible for popularization of the term. At the very least, his name should redirect to that article Deletion of James Kennedy (chemistry spokesperson) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7412 14843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyaag (2013 film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 15:55, 17 November 2015 (UTC) delete for while not unsourcable, this 2-minute short film is this young filmmaker's debut projecthttp://manashdewanji.weebly.com/ and lacks enough coverage to meet Deletion of Tyaag (2013 film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
7413 3892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nikhil Utkal Adivasi Congress User:Soman 13:29, 21 June 2020 (UTC) keep I'll try to beef up the article with some additional refs over the coming 48 hours. There isn't a lot of material (tribal politics in Orissa in 1950s isn't very well covered by online refs...). But in the meantime, the party was represented in national parliament per https://loksabha.nic.in/members/partyardetail.aspx?party_code=88&lsno=1 and thus passes Deletion of Nikhil Utkal Adivasi Congress WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
7414 19818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mount Gravatt Plaza User:MichaelQSchmidt 05:10, 4 October 2008 (UTC) merge """to List of Centro Shopping Centres in Australia where the inclusion has merit and context. '''Delete'''. Maybe combine '''ALL'''these """"Australian shopping centre/mall"""" articles into one grand AfD... as responding one by one by one by one by one is getting tedious, and each has makes the exact claim or lack of notability... and all were authored by the same person. Fails as """ Deletion of Mount Gravatt Plaza WP:N||WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Notability 77
7415 17686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob TV Shows User:Yomangani 02:13, 13 August 2006 (UTC) delete per G7: seems the author doesn't want it any more either Deletion of Bob TV Shows WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
7416 17689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flavour Magazine User:Inother 17:55, 22 April 2015 (UTC) delete Does not meet the |general notability guideline Deletion of Flavour Magazine WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7417 15951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Sabisky User:StonyBrook 03:41, 20 February 2020 (UTC) merge with Second Johnson ministry. Agree that the article should not be retained in present form, being that it does smack of ; I do not think that applies here because the subject was mentioned in connection with more than just one event. Merging would also keep him listed at London Conference on Intelligence as a redirect, a good compromise between retention and outright deletion, due to the surrounding him Deletion of Andrew Sabisky WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BLP1E||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7418 17473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burges Salmon User:Cunard 17:56, 3 June 2009 (UTC) keep A http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Burges+Salmon%22&cf=all Google News Archive search returns a multitude of |reliable sources, proving that this company passes Deletion of Burges Salmon WP:RS||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7419 15041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Strata (band) (second nomination) User:Malber 17:46, 9 October 2006 (UTC) delete no citations from non-trivial publications (or any citations for that matter) to demonstrate notability. No listed releases on a major label. Fails . Note to {{user|Parsssseltongue}} AfD is not an attack on the subject, it's a crucible for the article. Try improving it Deletion of Strata (band) (second nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7420 6765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Genshi Media Group User:Ritchie333 11:41, 4 December 2012 (UTC) delete """Couldn't find any reliable third party sources whatsoever, even using the alternative term """"Genshi Toy"""", which is also used by them. Only their (unverified) assertion they are a record label saves me from !voting #A7""" Deletion of Genshi Media Group WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
7421 2256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liberty Deep Down User:Mifter 01:18, 6 April 2017 (UTC) delete as I stated in my PROD I do not believe that the article meets , it might pass notability eventually but it is very much Deletion of Liberty Deep Down WP:BAND||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
7422 5864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Painter (2nd nomination) User:Edwardx 10:59, 3 July 2017 (UTC) keep """We have , but is a new one on me. This does not appear to be a valid argument for deletion. Apart from the two claims to notability the nominator mentions, #5 applies, """"5. The person holds or has held a named chair appointment or distinguished professor appointment at a major institution of higher education and research""" Deletion of Richard Painter (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:BLP2E||WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
7423 777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Post goth User:TBC 05:51, 16 May 2006 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Post goth WP:SPAM||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Spam 112
7424 963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anger Management (FiRESiGN) User:Esradekan 11:15, 5 April 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Albums Deletion of Anger Management (FiRESiGN) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
7425 13263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sri Vishwanath (author) User:MezzoMezzo 10:09, 6 May 2013 (UTC) delete Fails due to a lack of independent coverage. That's undeniable and there's no reason for the discussion to move beyond that. What does call for scrutiny is the outrageous behavior of those pushing for the article to be kept; for such an obvious issues of and , one would almost feel pressed to call for meatpuppet investigations after this article is inevitably deleted Deletion of Sri Vishwanath (author) WP:GNG||WP:ADVERT||WP:FANPAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
7426 15512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/London Shootfighters User:Lesliechin1 08:25, 24 May 2021 (UTC) delete Agree with Nominator. Doe snot meet Deletion of London Shootfighters WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7427 5756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Sagg Taqwacore Syndicate User:DoriSmith 00:21, 3 March 2009 (UTC) delete I don't see how they meet or Deletion of The Sagg Taqwacore Syndicate WP:BAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7428 11870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clay Tarver User:Bondegezou 13:21, 18 August 2010 (UTC) keep He's in two notable bands, and co-wrote a notable film. He clearly meets Deletion of Clay Tarver WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
7429 6774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Konopelsky User:GiantSnowman 14:05, 5 May 2013 (UTC) delete failure of outweighs the fact he passes by the skin of his teeth. and past consensus supports this Deletion of Andrew Konopelsky WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:COMMONSENSE Wikipedia:Notability 77
7430 4249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WWE Rivalries User:LM2000 13:37, 4 January 2015 (UTC) delete I think that this may be one that passes notability requirements at some point but we're not there yet. It's a relatively new show that hasn't received much coverage out of the Deletion of WWE Rivalries WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
7431 4656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/No borders User:Coredesat 09:57, 24 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails , unverifiable Deletion of No borders WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
7432 990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Scarola User:Papaursa 17:56, 15 February 2015 (UTC) delete Has no top tier fights so he doesn't meet and he only gets passing mentions in most of the sources. Appearing on TUF and losing your first fight is not sufficient to support a claim of notability. In my opinion, his speedy departure from TUF does not merit even a redirect Deletion of Joe Scarola WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
7433 6844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MyEducator User:Dialectric 20:27, 25 February 2015 (UTC) delete Software company of unclear notability, lacking independent references. A search turned up no significant coverage of this company Deletion of MyEducator WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7434 20110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammad Abubakar Durrani User:Parslad 18:36, 16 March 2009 (UTC) delete fails thlete as has not competed at World Championship or Olympic Games. No notability Deletion of Muhammad Abubakar Durrani WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
7435 20176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Occurrences of numerals User:I 19:53, 30 December 2014 (UTC) delete I almost want to say speedy deletion here, as this material needs to be fundamentally rewritten to be encyclopedic; it's just not accessible. To boot, I don't really get what the topic is at all. And yes, I agree that the article in its current state |feels very much like an essay Deletion of Occurrences of numerals WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7436 17324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Electrical safety User:Bfigura 21:43, 11 October 2007 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is a how-to Deletion of Electrical safety WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7437 17609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vincent A. Witcher User:Mztourist 03:54, 14 October 2020 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Vincent A. Witcher WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7438 6873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of artists who have resided in Brooklyn User:Ukexpat 13:10, 14 July 2015 (UTC) delete pure Deletion of List of artists who have resided in Brooklyn WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
7439 6972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JS Moore User:Nancy 10:14, 5 December 2007 (UTC) delete can find no evidence of |notability, fails and does come over as somewhat |autobiograpical although this is not proven Deletion of JS Moore WP:NOTE||WP:BIO||WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Notability 77
7440 15179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Regressive left User:Phatwa 10:20, 4 January 2016 (UTC) keep 500+ sources that pass , not really sure why it's being considered for deletion anyway Deletion of Regressive left WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7441 18570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012–13 F.C. United of Manchester season User:Oldelpaso 17:09, 6 October 2012 (UTC) comment The article as it stands at the moment lacks independent sources for anything other than attendance figures. Perhaps the most likely source for regular independent material is the main local newspaper, the ''Manchester Evening News''. It carries exhaustive coverage of the League teams in Greater Manchester, plus larger Conference teams like Stockport and Macclesfield, but for teams further down the pyramid such as FC United and Droylsden, the depth of coverage is significantly reduced. Most of the MEN's FC United-related headlines are introductions to a general non-league round-up (http://menmedia.co.uk/manchestereveningnews/sport/football/non_league/s/1590332_rebels-seal-trophy-progress is an example from this week). This is below the level of coverage I'd expect in order for a season article to meet Deletion of 2012–13 F.C. United of Manchester season WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7442 5985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Shankland User:Sir 21:45, 14 August 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails and Deletion of Mark Shankland WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
7443 13676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I.F.S User:Metropolitan90 03:10, 11 May 2007 (UTC) delete If I understand this article, it is a fantasy in which the editor who created the article takes over the professional wrestling industry. As such, it violates ... let's see ... some combination of , , , , , and Deletion of I.F.S WP:NOR||WP:RS||WP:V||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HOAX||WP:WAF Wikipedia:No original research 65
7444 14603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Motorball User:Folken 18:01, 28 August 2013 (UTC) merge The topic certainly deserves a mention in the main Battle Angel Alita article as an important part of the plot. Otherwise, with no significant coverage from secondary sources, this fails and shouldn't be a stand-alone article Deletion of Motorball WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7445 21006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Kuh User:D 05:50, 4 March 2008 (UTC) delete """given lack of significant coverage by reliable sources that establish notability per Wikipedia:Notability (people). It has not been established that any of the Twin Galaxies rankings represent significant recognized awards, his role within ''King of Kong'' is overstated and appears to be an argument for notability through relation, and the ''Boston Globe'' piece makes one passing reference to Kuh that has been grossly exaggerated in earlier remarks. Guys, don't derail this AfD with confused discussion of what 'significant coverage' means; clearly lays out what is intended as a guide: """"Sources address the subject directly in detail, and no original research is needed to extract the content. Significant coverage is more than trivial but may be less than exclusive""" Deletion of Brian Kuh WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7446 7969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2020 in archosaur paleontology User:XOR 18:59, 3 January 2020 (UTC) keep """The function of this list as a navigational aid is clear enough for me. It's hard to argue that the topic of the list is narrow ''and'' that the list is """"indiscriminate"""" (maybe not impossible, but certainly hard). We could argue over the inclusion criteria, but this isn't the forum for that. Nor is |being """"speculative"""" really a concern here, when the """"future events"""" in question are things like a scientific paper, already accepted at a journal and scheduled for publication, being officially printed""" Deletion of 2020 in archosaur paleontology WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7447 13617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Last Glaciation User:Bearian 01:13, 28 February 2010 (UTC) delete complete , can not be |verified (too many false Ghits Deletion of The Last Glaciation WP:OR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
7448 14901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muslim Model High School, Lahore User:Störm 09:24, 19 January 2018 (UTC) delete as nothing in . Also see https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=&oldid=767023947#RfC_on_secondary_school_notability which states no school is inherently notable Deletion of Muslim Model High School, Lahore WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7449 8891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abhuman User:JediLofty 16:17, 19 August 2008 (UTC) delete for failing . I wish we could just cull all the fluff and have some 40K articles that are relevant to the GAME and not the STORY! -- JediLofty Deletion of Abhuman WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7450 18963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deepside Deejays User:Robofish 01:04, 27 March 2011 (UTC) delete appears to fail , unless better coverage in independent sources can be provided Deletion of Deepside Deejays WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
7451 16573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Galore Park NONE NONE keep WP:N|Notable. Meets . Source examples include Deletion of Galore Park WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
7452 10748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xtorrent (2nd nomination) User:MrMacMan 19:45, 4 February 2007 (UTC) delete Well as I said in the Talk section of the Xtorrent wiki... I was going to give them some time before I put it up for delete... but now that someone has gone and put up the Afd anyway. It is a delete under as stated previously. This article was worse than before with less content and still no notability Deletion of Xtorrent (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
7453 5334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PhpWCMS User:Joe 13:36, 4 August 2009 (UTC) delete All that I can find is trivial mentions. Fails Deletion of PhpWCMS WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
7454 15543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Smallville Korea voice actors User:Elfin341 17:56, 3 May 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of List of Smallville Korea voice actors WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7455 7121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Make mine Milk User:Rrburke 14:54, 13 April 2011 (UTC) delete no demonstrated noteworthiness |sufficient to merit a standalone article Deletion of Make mine Milk WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7456 230 [[Christiaan C. Wagener]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Kriddl NONE keep Wenn die #Schauspieler, Film-Stab, Moderatoren|Relevanzkriterien fordern, dass zur Relevanz jemand ''in wesentlicher Rolle (Regisseur, Schauspieler, Drehbuchautor, Produzent, Kameramann) an einem Film mitwirkten, der entweder auf einem Filmfestival gezeigt oder in den Filmverleih aufgenommen wurde'', dann betrifft das auch die Crew hinter der Kamera und damit auch die Bühnenbildner. Wenn, wie hier, bekannt ist, dass derjenige an relevanten Filmen auf diesem Gebiet mitgewirkt hat, dann genügt das für Relevanz. Damit ist das ein gültiger Stub Löschung von Christiaan C. Wagener Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
7457 17112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur Riedacker User:Nsk92 13:02, 19 February 2018 (UTC) delete """Any claim to a share of the 2007 Nobel Peace Prize is spurious. According to the award citation, IPCC received the prize for the totality of its efforts over several decades: """"Through the scientific reports it has issued over the past two decades, the IPCC has created an ever-broader informed consensus about the connection between human activities and global warming. Thousands of scientists and officials from over one hundred countries have collaborated to achieve greater certainty as to the scale of the warming"""". Moreover, in science, having reviewed/refereed an important article does not entitle you to a credit for that article. GScholar citations appear to be fairly low, even for a field like agronomy, with h-index around 7, and the top-cited article having only 30 citations. I am not seeing anything else here to justify passing on any other grounds""" Deletion of Arthur Riedacker WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
7458 6733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meelis Kubo User:Sander_S 09:02, 21 October 2009 (UTC) keep Fairly unknown person even in Estonia, but there are few articles about him. Probable by creator of the article (see the name of the http://www.miraakel.com/ official website). Image is copyrighted, I marked it for speedy in Commons Deletion of Meelis Kubo WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
7459 12030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suicide methods (3rd nomination) User:WilyD 17:34, 12 September 2006 (UTC) keep sourced, encyclopaedic. |Wikipedia, she ain't censored et cetera. Anyone who a) wants to kill themselves, and b) has access to the internet isn't going to find the lack of a ''Wikipedia'' article on the subject any sort of barrier Deletion of Suicide methods (3rd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7460 8749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wade Load User:Gavin 22:43, 3 January 2008 (UTC) delete as these articles have no |reliable secondary sources and so fail , as they have no notability outside of ''Kim Possible'' series. Merger is not appropriate as the articles content is possibly the worst example of #PLOT I have ever seen; reading these articles is like watching the series with through the medium of surtitles. These articles are begging to be deleted and transwikied to an appropriate fansite Deletion of Wade Load WP:RS||WP:FICT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7461 9249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aja (drag queen) User:L293D 13:24, 2 March 2018 (UTC) keep significant coverage, passes Deletion of Aja (drag queen) WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
7462 4832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Owen Honors User:Nick 07:59, 5 January 2011 (UTC) delete fails , and . The incident which led to his sacking could, and should, be covered in the article on the ship. A lot of the above keep votes appear to be variants of and (in that the commander of a large warship is deemed notable in isolation of any assessment of available sources) and aren't based on any policy Deletion of Owen Honors WP:BIO||WP:MILPEOPLE||WP:ONEEVENT||WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
7463 18340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mademoiselle K User:Shaundakulbara 04:50, 25 January 2007 (UTC) delete This article provides no |verifiable sources to establish |notability Deletion of Mademoiselle K WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7464 4544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orlando Pelayo j.r User:DrunkenSmurf 01:55, 31 July 2006 (UTC) delete I can find no sources to verify this 'actor' even exists. Article really needs to be sourced and some additional info added. Personally I think it is a |hoax but I'd be happy to be proven incorrect Deletion of Orlando Pelayo j.r WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
7465 4529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vembu Technologies User:Ihcoyc 14:21, 12 April 2013 (UTC) delete One of their products is a ''protection solution''; another, a ''management solution''. |MEGO Deletion of Vembu Technologies WP:B2B Wikipedia:Notability 77
7466 13173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zest Airways Flight 865 User:The 19:15, 31 December 2012 (UTC) delete with a plowload of Deletion of Zest Airways Flight 865 WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
7467 13787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Subset theorem User:Andyjsmith 18:06, 13 May 2007 (UTC) delete as a hoax. This could be speedied under Deletion of Subset theorem WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
7468 2974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comedy of Errors (band) User:Mattg82 02:11, 2 December 2011 (UTC) delete No significant coverage in |reliable sources, fails and Deletion of Comedy of Errors (band) WP:RS||WP:BAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
7469 20747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/India Crisis User:Wikihermit 01:33, 18 June 2007 (UTC) delete Per #G10|CSD#G10. '''''~'' Deletion of India Crisis WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
7470 5995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Versistasis User:Ihcoyc 15:52, 20 April 2012 (UTC) delete WP:OR|original research and |meaningless: ''....the novel expounds a theory of everything, deposing the objectivity/subjectivity typical in traditional logical equations of reality, by a post-modern rhetoric. Versistasis defines the forces typical in creation as being fractal concurrent powers, such as those typical of the planetary bodies in a astrological interpretation and of the human qualities inherent to them and the material universe.'' Wow! Postmodern rhetoric can do all that Deletion of Versistasis WP:NONSENSE Wikipedia:Patent nonsense 105
7471 9457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Joe Biden 2020 presidential campaign endorsements [[user talk:Anne drew Andrew and Drew|Anne drew]] 22:19, 30 September 2020 (UTC) keep """This AfD is a waste of everyone's time. The list clearly meets - if you Google search """"Biden endorsements"""" you will find hundreds of high quality sources discussing the topic""" Deletion of List of Joe Biden 2020 presidential campaign endorsements WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
7472 12585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timothy Walton (lawyer) User:power 20:09, 8 November 2017 (UTC) delete there's not enough here to meet or . The main reference is the California state bar's database, and the links TJRC found aren't enough for me Deletion of Timothy Walton (lawyer) WP:ANYBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7473 18200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fred Steak User:Coredesat 10:26, 25 June 2006 (UTC) delete advertisement, marinade recipe fails |Wikipedia is not a recipe book Deletion of Fred Steak WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
7474 12593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative Approaches to the Delimitation of the Arctic Continental Shelf User:AJHingston 10:43, 21 March 2013 (UTC) comment I can understand that the author feels discouraged but there is already an article on this at Territorial claims in the Arctic and it would be inappropriate to have another here - see for the policy on that. There are more articles on specific aspects of the topic. In addition, there are a number of other difficulties with the present article to do with the style which does not follow Wikipedia standards and can be difficult for users to follow, and because Wikipedia articles should not attempt to set out an individual's analysis and understanding of the issue but summarise from a neutral point of view using appropriate references as the Territorial claims in the Arctic and others articles seek to do. I suggest that the author looks at those related articles - there may be ways in which he or she thinks they might be improved and with his or her knowledge of the topic such a contribution would doubtless be useful Deletion of Alternative Approaches to the Delimitation of the Arctic Continental Shelf WP:FORK Wikipedia:Mirrors and forks 46
7475 21603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Byron Tyrer User:Closeapple 17:21, 12 June 2010 (UTC) delete """Wikipedia:Autobiography of a minor (in more ways than one), sporadic announcer on a minor station. Per : """"attention solely from local media, or media of limited interest and circulation, is not an indication of notability""" Deletion of Byron Tyrer WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
7476 9280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canada–Mongolia relations User:Jd027 16:32, 15 March 2009 (UTC) comment Some bilateral relations articles are notable, as evidenced by the apparent continuous existence of the San Marino–Uruguay relations article. In any case, the fact that Canada and Mongolia care enough to maintain bilateral relations in the real world means that it probably deserves a space here. Just my opinion. In any case, the case fails to assert lack of notability specifically through Deletion of Canada–Mongolia relations WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
7477 9580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ariel Levinson-Waldman User:Tiggerjay 05:40, 27 February 2013 (UTC) delete per , no significant sources found Deletion of Ariel Levinson-Waldman WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
7478 14761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of emo artists User:Bardin 06:41, 19 April 2008 (UTC) keep per 13Tawaazun14. Edit wars are a constant presence on many controversial subjects such as abortion and the Israel-Palestinian conflict. That's not much of a reason to delete an article, particularly since any controversy surrounding a music genre pales significantly in comparison to the more serious subjects like war and politics. Categories and lists are not the same thing and one is not a substitute for the other. There is no reason why both cannot exist for any given topic and other genres do have both a similar list and a category. This list actually has references and as long as it continues to rely on references, it is hard to imagine why there should be any contention if editors abide by the wikipedia policies and guidelines concerning |verifiability, |original research and |reliable sources Deletion of List of emo artists WP:V||WP:NOR||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
7479 751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ubiquiti Networks NONE NONE delete Opened last year and has 2 patents, so where's thenotability ??? Davideuvonia""" 11.58, 3 Haziran 2020 (UTC) delete Kayda değer olduğunu gösterir bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynaklar bulunmuyor. Bununla birlikte görebildiğim kadarıyla kriterleri de karşılanmamış. --Kullanıcı mesaj:Justinianus|'''justinianus İpek Filiz Yazıcı'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
8386 5660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nintoaster User:Jelly 08:20, 23 April 2012 (UTC) delete failing Deletion of Nintoaster WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8387 17586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yeti (programming language) User:Dialectric 05:28, 17 February 2016 (UTC) delete Software (programming language) article of unclear notability, lacking independent references. A search turned up no significant coverage of this language Deletion of Yeti (programming language) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8388 6319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Nguyen (3rd nomination) User:Alzarian16 14:08, 23 October 2010 (UTC) keep As per the non-trivial coverage in the three sources listed by the user above me, the guy appears to meet , specifically the subsection Deletion of Paul Nguyen (3rd nomination) WP:BIO||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8389 5563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ginger tom User:Capitalistroadster 05:42, 28 May 2006 (UTC) delete Has released an EP but doesn't seem to have had much impact. No signs that they meet |our music notability guidelines Deletion of Ginger tom WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8390 476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Barlock User:TonyTheTiger 19:43, 17 November 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Ryan Barlock WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
8391 2460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Aetherverse User:Gongshow 03:55, 22 September 2017 (UTC) delete I am unable to find coverage to show that this book meets or Deletion of The Aetherverse WP:GNG||WP:BKCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8392 7033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Wilson (martial artist) User:Papaursa 20:22, 16 August 2015 (UTC) delete I don't see the significant independent coverage required to meet or that he meets Deletion of David Wilson (martial artist) WP:GNG||WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8393 8515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rutatron User:Isotope23 19:18, 14 March 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Rutatron WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8394 7827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Viktor Band User:Kinu 18:27, 24 September 2006 (UTC) delete due to lack of |reliable sources indicating this band meets Deletion of Viktor Band WP:RS||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8395 7347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of D.Gray-man anime-only characters User:Xymmax 12:43, 6 May 2008 (UTC) delete I agree, a merge would be appropriate if these characters had any lasting significance to the anime, but, as it stands they fail |the guidelines for fictional characters Deletion of List of D.Gray-man anime-only characters WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8396 16267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pat Flynn (entrepreneur) User:QEDK 15:27, 11 October 2019 (UTC) delete Lack of any significant coverage. Fails Deletion of Pat Flynn (entrepreneur) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8397 7814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Collins (entrepreneur) User:Yeti 06:37, 26 December 2018 (UTC) delete """borderline |vanispamcruftisement as presently written. |Nearly fifty references but most of them some combination of self published, unreliable, primary, trivial or deadlinks. The """"best entrepreneur under 30"""" award (which is mentioned in several other sources) comes from Anthill Online, ''""""one of Australia’s largest online communities for entrepreneurs, business builders and innovators""""'' - I'm not even certain they would be independently notable, therefore an award from them certainly wouldn't be. I'd suggest merge into Mailman Group, but that article isn't any better and is of similarly unclear notability. Probably a bare pass of GNG with https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/the-deal-magazine/aussies-at-spacex-apple-google-planet-labs-and-emotiv-lead-the-talent-diaspora/news-story/31eafec66a919e9b1f78ace8b5b4a967?nk=96346a2239dc4a4e0b25a79056e1dfd5-1523203102 this from The Australian, but it doesn't make much of an assertion of notability - he founded a few companies of uncertain notability and got an award from an online community, also of uncertain notability. In its current state I think it's a delete; may change !vote if a successful effort is made to rectify spamminess and other issues""" Deletion of Andrew Collins (entrepreneur) WP:VSCA||WP:REFBOMB Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
8398 1989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moh Azima User:EdJohnston 19:43, 20 February 2007 (UTC) delete All this article's references are blogs. Apparently no press reviews of his work, no independent recognition. Does not meet . Even for feature-length movies we would expect to see press reviews to assure notability, and what's shown here is much less than that Deletion of Moh Azima WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8399 20989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Other Side of Burka User:Northamerica1000 08:46, 23 November 2016 (UTC) keep Meets . Below are some sources Deletion of The Other Side of Burka WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
8400 14943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rohan Pallewatta [[User talk:Obi2canibe|talk)]] 18:04, 19 May 2018 (UTC) delete Insufficient coverage in multiple, independent sources. Does not meet , or .--Special:Contributions/Obi2canibe|Obi2canibe Deletion of Rohan Pallewatta WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8401 14280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Descendants of Charlemagne User:GRBerry 03:33, 15 December 2006 (UTC) delete Per the Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not policy, particularly point 2 of the '''Wikipedia is not a directory''' section. These are contrary to policy. and do not trump policy Deletion of Descendants of Charlemagne WP:USEFUL||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8402 4850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Argh! User:ZeroOne 23:30, 24 February 2006 (UTC) keep """This article is quite good. It's got enough content and an explained code example. May I also remind you that """"non-notability"""" is not a deletion criteria (""" Deletion of Argh! WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
8403 16209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wings Of Illusion User:Guoguo12 15:02, 10 August 2010 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of Wings Of Illusion WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8404 8959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cargurus User:YoavShapira 21:53, 8 August 2006 (UTC) comment I found the site through DMOZ, which in my opinion meets criterion 2 of the ''Criteria for companies and corporations'' section of Deletion of Cargurus WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8405 20515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of animal rights groups in Goa User:Riddhidev 21:37, 6 October 2020 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of animal rights groups in Goa WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8406 8389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hollie Steel User:Doctorfluffy 05:31, 30 April 2009 (UTC) delete per . Non-notable gameshow contestant Deletion of Hollie Steel WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
8407 57 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Remzi Kitabevi """Kullanıcı:maurice flesiermaurice flesier""" 22:59, 19 Şubat 2017 (UTC) keep köy çeşmesinde yer alan bir kullanıcının yorumuna mı yoksa SAS sonucu silinen Evrensel Basım Yayın'a mı emsal teşkil ediyor? 'de böyle bir kriter(ler)e rastlamadım. Kayda değerliği güvenilir kaynaklar tarafından desteklenmiş. Birkaç kayak ekledim, müsait olduğumda içeriği de düzenleyebilirim Remzi Kitabevi'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
8408 18046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nazie Eftekhari User:Joe 07:14, 3 March 2013 (UTC) keep I'm seeing a little too much sourcing here for me to consider this borderline with respect to Deletion of Nazie Eftekhari WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8409 5300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beaucoups of Blues (song) User:HexaChord 00:27, 10 March 2009 (UTC) comment I did not suggest the song for deletion, but contested a proposal for deletion, since I'm quite sure that there's enough 3rd party coverage incl. libraries of secondary literature on everything any of the former Beatles members has ever recorded. I don't have any books on the topic, so can't improve the article much. I didn't even realise that it was released as a single until Nosleep coined the USA charts. Note that the infoboxes for songs and singles are quite often mixed up. It took me less than two minutes to find the charts entry for Germany. Musicline is the reliable source accepted by German Wikipedia (see: http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Charts#Deutschland link). IMHO the nominator should have done a small research on his own ''before'' proposing or nominating the article for deletion (see ). The best case would have been to improve the article and thus save a lot of time and energy. --''Avant-garde a clue Deletion of Beaucoups of Blues (song) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
8410 3670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Munay-ki User:Hyperion35 14:55, 22 May 2021 (UTC) delete """I could understand if this was some legitimate work of ethnology, but I don't even know how we document a belief that somehow involves Indus Valley civilization ideals transmitted by Siberians to the Andes, supposedly 30,000 years ago...I mean there are just so many different things wrong with this that it would need several paragraphs to explain. Again, if this was legitimate ethnology, we would have no problem saying """"The Inka believe that the deity they call..."""" etc. This is just . If the guy who invented this stuff is notable, we could merge a small paragraph of this into his article. We do have articles on BS artists where we accurately describe RS explanations for why they are BS artists (like that miracle water guy whose commercials are still running), but that would require good sourcing and it would probably require that this guy has gotten into some sort of trouble. If he's just an obscure loon, then we don't really need anything""" Deletion of Munay-ki WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
8411 12772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jilla (film) [[User talk:TheRedPenOfDoom|TRPoD aka The Red Pen of Doom]] 18:02, 24 March 2013 (UTC) merge it is still all entirely rumor and speculation (edited to add) and a kick off party . It fails . If the project were to get hung up between now and expected beginning of production there is nothing to indicate its demise would in anyway be of any lasting note to anyone. and contrary to the claims above, it most certainly does NOT meet Deletion of Jilla (film) WP:CRYSTAL||WP:NFF Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8412 5402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nguyễn Công Phượng User:GiantSnowman 08:42, 14 September 2014 (UTC) delete fails (no appearances confirmed by http://uk.soccerway.com/players/cong-phuong-nguyen/352987/ Soccerway) and Deletion of Nguyễn Công Phượng WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8413 16514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Gholami User:GiantSnowman 09:27, 26 July 2013 (UTC) delete fail and Deletion of Ali Gholami WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8414 19155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gladiators of Rome (2012 film) User:Mrschimpf 00:45, 1 February 2016 (UTC) keep Created by a sock but edited since then from other editors with actual sourcing. Unless we want to this only to restore the text this doesn't seem to be a viable deletion candidate Deletion of Gladiators of Rome (2012 film) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
8415 1121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric de Sturler User:Plastikspork 03:30, 16 January 2009 (UTC) comment """Article was first created by IP 128.174.245.145, which is at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Checking this first version http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Eric_de_Sturler&oldid=5402143 and an edit by """"DutchMom""""http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Eric_de_Sturler&diff=207202787&oldid=184753574 who only edits this pagehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/DutchMom, it looks like there could be a . Just FYI""" Deletion of Eric de Sturler WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
8416 20209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eoin O'Hainle User:Rjd0060 01:26, 2 December 2007 (UTC) delete Not speedy, as speedy deletion specifically states that hoaxes, no matter how blatant, do not qualify (unless this could be a case of |IAR). Obvious hoax though, delete Deletion of Eoin O'Hainle WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
8417 21121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Statistical threshold User:Mark 18:17, 11 August 2014 (UTC) merge """to Statistical significance. Merge would be OK, too, but there isn't much to merge. A simple search shows that the term is used as a synonym for """"threshold of statistical significance"""", e.g., in papers like http://bsb.eurasipjournals.com/content/2009/1/878013 Selection of Statistical Thresholds in Graphical Models, http://www.medicalbiostatistics.com/Diagnostic%20Threshold.pdf Diagnostic Thresholds of Medical Measurements (starting on the second page), and http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2288/14/34 The thresholds for statistical and clinical significance – a five-step procedure for evaluation of intervention effects in randomised clinical trials (used twice in the body of the paper). That the term is in use in reliable sources shows it to be a plausible search term and so a redirect is warranted""" Deletion of Statistical threshold WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
8418 15649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryan Towey User:Coolabahapple 00:47, 9 February 2021 (UTC) delete does not meet , nothing wikisignificant here Deletion of Bryan Towey WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8419 13669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OpenLiteSpeed User:DrStrauss 08:59, 13 September 2017 (UTC) delete the only sources I can find which are remotely independent are https://www.digitalocean.com/community/tutorials/how-to-install-the-openlitespeed-web-server-on-ubuntu-14-04 this and https://www.howtoforge.com/tutorial/how-to-install-openlitespeed-with-php_7-on-centos/ this which are no good for establishing |software notability because they are just how-to articles, and |Wikipedia isn't a manual. No indication of major reviews or the like, as I say, other than those two, most of the sources I can find are |self-published Deletion of OpenLiteSpeed WP:NSOFT||WP:NOTMANUAL||WP:SPS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8420 17466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roman usurper User:Xanchester 17:05, 24 October 2012 (UTC) keep The article needs to be |cleaned up. The subject is |notable, and a http://www.google.com/search?q=%22usurper%22+Roman+empire&btnG=Search&hl=en&tbo=1&tbm=bks search for books shows that there are plenty of |reliable secondary sources to use, like Edward Gibbon's ''http://books.google.com/books?id=pbdU_TqPYVkC&pg=PT428&dq=%22usurper%22+Roman+empire&hl=en The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire Deletion of Roman usurper WP:CLEANUP||WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
8421 4689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eurovision Song Contest 2010 User:This 23:00, 16 May 2009 (UTC) comment this AfD was, in |good faith, speedily closed; I reverted the speedy closure, and request that an admin review my actions. Cheers Deletion of Eurovision Song Contest 2010 WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
8422 2481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Let the bodies pile high User:FollowTheTortoise 17:03, 1 May 2021 (UTC) comment """I might be missing something, but I believe that the remark passes . The barrier is actually lower than some of the comments above might seem to suggest for '''significant coverage''': """"""""significant coverage"""" addresses the topic directly and in detail, so that no original research is needed to extract the content. Significant coverage is more than a trivial mention, but it does not need to be the main topic of the source material."""" Pretty much every UK news source has written at least one article about it (for example, BBC News has https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-56914432 this article, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-56890714 this article, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-politics-56915152 this shorter article, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-politics-56914397 this shorter article and https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-56897213 this article which is at least one third focused on the comment and as can be seen by https://www.bbc.co.uk/search?q=%22bodies+pile+high%22&page=1 this search result, the comment has not been limited to that selection of articles in the BBC's coverage) and so it is clear that it passes that precondition; while no book has been written about the comment, it's plainly not just a trivial footnote like the Bill Clinton example in . It's also worth noting that notability is not temporary, as per . Additionally, its overwhelming coverage combined with Peston's article cited above also make it clear to me that the remark is '''reliable''', '''independent of the subject''' and, finally, that there are multiple secondary '''sources'''. Whether the remark warrants its own page is something that I'm still not sure about, but I wanted to put forward the argument that it does pass """ Deletion of Let the bodies pile high WP:GNG||WP:NOTTEMPORARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
8423 270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jimmy Wales Foundation User:Vinodbasker 16:15, 8 October 2018 (UTC) keep This foundation has got attention from reliable independent sources and thus satisfies Deletion of Jimmy Wales Foundation WP:ORGIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8424 3263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Olga Kharitidi (2nd nomination) User:Sphilbrick 15:07, 19 December 2009 (UTC) delete Sometimes I see an article about an author with a recent book, and I wonder whether there will soon be coverage in |reliable sources, but her books go back over a decade. If she isn't getting any RS coverage, then merely having published books doesn't make her |Notable Deletion of Olga Kharitidi (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8425 1070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Border jack User:Hans 16:15, 1 May 2011 (UTC) delete or '''redirect''' to List of dog hybrids. This is a ridiculous sub-stub with not much chance that it will ever grow beyond, at most, stub size. Clearly fails . From an organisational point of view it just doesn't make sense to cover this on a separate page. That's how an encyclopedia differs from a dictionary. And no, a hybrid between races is not the same as a species. The species of all dogs is canis lupus (i.e. ''grey wolf Deletion of Border jack WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8426 16158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ǼLEX (2nd nomination) User:K 23:42, 6 April 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet / . Sourcing is of passing-mention / variety Deletion of ǼLEX (2nd nomination) WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:SPIP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8427 17387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pat Zalewski (2nd nomination) User:Msnicki 21:31, 4 April 2013 (UTC) delete Lacks reliable independent secondary sources required to establish notability under . The best I was able to find were interviews on blog sites, which are and lack the editorial oversight required to make them Deletion of Pat Zalewski (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:PRIMARY||WP:RELIABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8428 18387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Arth User:Paulmcdonald 21:56, 1 April 2016 (UTC) keep head coaches of college football programs are normally kept as they are found to generate enough coverage to pass as outlined at the essay Deletion of Tom Arth WP:GNG||WP:CFBCOACH Wikipedia:Notability 77
8429 10304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Ofori Antwi User:Nfitz 03:51, 12 January 2014 (UTC) keep the issue as far as I understand it is that he hasn't played for Amidaus Professionals which do play in a fully professional league. However his wiki page does claim he has one appearance. Other sources such as http://www.transfermarkt.com/en/eric-ofori-antwi/leistungsdaten-vereindetail/spieler_262596.html show more appearances. So he does meet after all Deletion of Eric Ofori Antwi WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8430 14434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reema Nawawi User:Till 06:16, 7 December 2011 (UTC) delete per nom, the subject in question violates Deletion of Reema Nawawi WP:MEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8431 17614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon Fraser University 1997 harassment controversy (Xth nomination) User:Jahiegel 05:21, 3 January 2008 (UTC) keep Comment''' GRBerry seems, as usual, to have it quite right. I would observe, largely unrelatedly but for the sake of clarity, that Rachel Marsden was not, to be sure, deleted pursuant to any specific ArbCom action (the ArbCom, after all, do not make policy or take editorial decisions, and I cannot imagine that the ArbCom would ever mandate the deletion of any specific article or even set forth an interpretation of policy that would arrogate absolutely the community's right to determine the policy-guided disposition of articles), but, instead, consistent with (an interpretation of) ; the link to the Bdj RfAr in the deletion summary means only to suggest that undeletion in the absence of a consensus for the restoration of Rachel Marsden as, for instance, a redirect to the instant page, is to be disfavored. Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Rachel Marsden is, one supposes, a bit more on point, but there is, of course, nothing there that should concern us with respect to the present version of the instant article, nor, for that matter, to our recreating Rachel Marsden as a redirect to the underlying page, something that I might propose at |DRV Deletion of Simon Fraser University 1997 harassment controversy (Xth nomination) WP:BLP||WP:DRV Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
8432 8596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CrossFire Fusor User:Ironholds 21:04, 16 October 2010 (UTC) delete complete lack of |notability, although the Cavalry should have learnt by now not to bandy the term pseudo-science around. Naughty boy; must be the seawater leaking into your ears. Safeguard, full clips Deletion of CrossFire Fusor WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8433 19286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luka Skrlep User:GiantSnowman 07:17, 25 April 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Luka Skrlep WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8434 12266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exposed: The Climate of Fear User:KimDabelsteinPetersen 20:37, 26 May 2007 (UTC) delete """I'm going to leave to others the argument about this show being notable (imho its not). And instead give some good reasons for it to be deleted as a strict issue: The entire article is based upon a specific editors selective quoting from the transcript of the show. Stringing these together is a series of statements, such as ''Beck proposed explanations for global warming, and while stating that the Earth is warming,'' ...continuing... ''his one-hour documentary presented the views of Scientists_who_oppose_the_global_warming_consensus|scientists who don't believe that global warming is caused by humans.''. For the first sentence: Where is that explanation? and what does it consist of? Answer: Ask the editor - since the show doesn't give such an explanation. For the second sentence: Say's who? Answer: The editor. John Christy for instance does believe that humans have a finger in global warming. (he contests the amount - or rather if its catastrophic). We do not have a |reliable source summarizing this show - or to give hints to the editors on which parts to focus or expand. Its a freebie ride to quote whatever random part of the show to match your own POV (or in this case the editors). For other examples, lets take headlines: """"Experts on Kyoto"""" ... says who? John Christy certainly isn't. Nice touch with the quote from Al Gore (very much taken out of context - but used in the same way in the show). """"Global Warming Crowd"""" who are these? The show doesn't say (transcript doesn't even have the word: Crowd). """"Intimidation Tactics"""" - the word Intimidation doesn't appear in the transcript - why is it in quotation marks? etc. etc. etc""" Deletion of Exposed: The Climate of Fear WP:NPOV||WP:OR||WP:RS Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
8435 1199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cancer.im User:Cazort 00:14, 14 September 2009 (UTC) delete I am also having trouble finding |reliable sources Deletion of Cancer.im WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8436 15096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chocolate Moose Media User:K 01:21, 2 May 2018 (UTC) merge to Firdaus Kharas: not independently notable; promo 'cruft. Does not meet and fails Deletion of Chocolate Moose Media WP:NCORP||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8437 3061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron beelner User:Jayden54 13:52, 2 January 2007 (UTC) delete not notable per Deletion of Aaron beelner WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8438 5895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Ciccone User:John537 16:27, 21 August 2020 (UTC) delete """Well, that's ten minutes of my life I'm not getting back ... see, I just went over the """"sources"""" recently added, and they're a bunch of cast lists, user-generated bits and namedrops. Not a single damn one provides |significant coverage ''to the subject'', as the GNG requires. In the filibustering above""" Deletion of Tony Ciccone WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
8439 2623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammed Sajid User:TheGreatWikiLord 03:26, 11 October 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet any of the criteria for perpetrators under . Most of the coverage is trivial Deletion of Mohammed Sajid WP:CRIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
8440 15138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solipeta Ramalinga Reddy User:Phil 20:50, 11 January 2021 (UTC) keep Obviously passes as a former MLA. What was the nominator thinking of by saying he fails Deletion of Solipeta Ramalinga Reddy WP:NPOLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8441 1731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sage G. Rafferty User:Metropolitan90 09:08, 24 February 2008 (UTC) delete per . Completely unsourced article about apparently non-notable campaign staff member Deletion of Sage G. Rafferty WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8442 18713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Speakersneakers User:Coredesat 22:05, 28 June 2006 (UTC) delete for eating ham and jam and |spam a lot. Already tagged for speedy deletion for copyvio Deletion of Speakersneakers WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
8443 13466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faizzudin Abidin User:GiantSnowman 10:50, 26 September 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Faizzudin Abidin WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8444 14403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elaine DiMasi User:Xxanthippe 10:21, 11 June 2020 (UTC) keep Passes rof#C1 with an h-index of around 25 Deletion of Elaine DiMasi WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
8445 8386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Claire Wright (politician) User:SportingFlyer 02:13, 12 January 2020 (UTC) delete It's all routine campaign coverage for an unsuccessful candidate. Even if applies, there's local consensus that losing candidates who don't receive coverage beyond the fact they're candidates are notable. I also think applies, even though she has run multiple times, as there's little to no coverage of her previous campaigns, and we can merge any relevant information to the results page Deletion of Claire Wright (politician) WP:GNG||WP:NOT||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
8446 17234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tonn nua User:Ultra 06:55, 13 November 2006 (UTC) delete although http://www.registerguard.com/news/2006/11/06/c1.cr.teenceltband.1106.p1.php?section=cityregion this constitutes a source, it's really obvious vanity and failse Deletion of Tonn nua WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
8447 4391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prince Constantine Alexios of Greece and Denmark (3rd nomination) User:VocalIndia 10:17, 31 August 2020 (UTC) keep I gave delete on the deletion requests for many royalty spam articles, but this one is different. First of all, being a member of a deposed royal family with enough multiple reliable sources and some sources in Greece grants . Second of all, he is also the future head of the deposed Greek royal family and is referenced in reliable sources Deletion of Prince Constantine Alexios of Greece and Denmark (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8448 1062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Lucey User:BrownHairedGirl 15:59, 4 March 2009 (UTC) comment WP:BLP#Deletion refers to summary deletion, not to AFD. This AFD is open for 7 days, which is quite adequate for an editor to find just one reference in a which verifies the central claim to notability. I am not suggesting that article needs to be expanded or fully referenced in that time, just that we need ''one'' reference to establish the existence of the subject and the claim to notability. If such a reference has been added by the time the AFD is closed, then obviously my !vote to delete will be invalid (and if I spot the change, I'll happily strike it my !vote once the ref is added) ... but if the article remains unreferenced after 7 days under the spotlight, then we are at last resort stage Deletion of Stephen Lucey WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8449 21356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Digital Entertainment Network User:Bearian 22:26, 17 December 2007 (UTC) delete as a |non-notable company Deletion of The Digital Entertainment Network WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8450 3146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Singapore gay portrayals on television User:Leidiot 14:14, 3 March 2006 (UTC) delete As per Deletion of Singapore gay portrayals on television WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8451 21427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Little (engineer) User:Number 15:26, 12 May 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Patrick Little (engineer) WP:NPOLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8452 3501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parimatch (company) User:Atlantic306 01:25, 29 June 2021 (UTC) delete as a case of . This promotional article was created and edited by a number of undeclared paid editors who based the article upon promotional and unreliable sources so is not passed in my view Deletion of Parimatch (company) WP:PROMO||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8453 10119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Middle-earth plants user:Andrew 00:33, 24 November 2019 (UTC) keep Another frivolous nomination. In this case, it appears that no effort has been made to even read the article, never mind searching for sources as required by . When one reads the article, one soon sees that the sources include a respectable book published by a university press which is all about the topic: ''https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=3CwpDwAAQBAJ Flora of Middle-Earth''. It's easy to find more books about this and related topics including ''The Plants of Middle-Earth''; ''Ents, Elves, and Eriador: The Environmental Vision of J.R.R. Tolkien''; ''A Tolkien Bestiary''; ''The Ecology of Middle Earth''; ''The Science of Middle Earth''; ''Representations of Nature in Middle-earth''; &c. This nomination seems so careless that the appropriate admin action is to impose a topic ban Deletion of Middle-earth plants WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
8454 7044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isabella Rositano User:Duffbeerforme 07:18, 30 January 2018 (UTC) delete """Just being a national champion does not always meet , especially for low profile or obscure sports. In Canoes case there is nothing in NSPORT that gives that a pass so we go with the standard """"for example, participated in a major international amateur or professional competition at the highest level (such as the Olympics)."""" ICF was only juniors. Since no pass there it comes back to GNG. There is a lack of Independent coverage for GNG. Looking at the four sources Haweye7 highlights, 1, UniSA, not independant, """"where UniSA student Isabella Rositano"""". 2, The governing body of the sport she competed in is not independent. 3, Only her name on a list, lacks any depth of coverage about her. 4, she works as an ambassador for Black Dog Institute are not an independent. None help with GNG. The same issues occur with the other sources in the article, a lack of independence or a lack of coverage. Other claims of notabilty. National team does not pass NSPORT. World record is one of those silly gimmicky ones and is team thing and lacks independent coverage. Football for Italy, does not pass . Scholarship holder, nothing that special there, lacks independent coverage. A Factiva search got zero hits for her unless she was also a student film director or actress (which she might be""" Deletion of Isabella Rositano WP:NSPORT||WP:NAFL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8455 5649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Brazilian footballers (2nd nomination) User:Lugnuts 17:17, 20 August 2009 (UTC) keep Lists and categories go hand-in-hand per Deletion of List of Brazilian footballers (2nd nomination) WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
8456 18170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hapanese User:Boricuaeddie 01:29, 20 August 2007 (UTC) delete WP:V|unverifiable and |non-notable EO|neologism Deletion of Hapanese WP:N||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8457 7737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derrimut Heath Primary School User:Savin 05:04, 5 June 2007 (UTC) delete There is no |Verifiable source stated in the article, and it doesnt appear to have been the topic of any third-party publication Deletion of Derrimut Heath Primary School WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8458 18010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Niki Smart (author) User:Nomader 00:03, 7 May 2016 (UTC) delete but not per author's rationale. The article (even though being wrongly titled 'author') is about a musician. There is the LA Times mention here (http://articles.latimes.com/1997-03-24/entertainment/ca-41496_1_stranglers-identity-song), but it's really not enough to write a whole article on and there's no other reliable sources that I can find. Delete because of Deletion of Niki Smart (author) WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8459 13403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Green Party of Saudi Arabia User:Drawn 18:42, 30 April 2009 (UTC) comment There are standards of notability that exisit for Wikipedia. This must meet . Please review it before claiming that this organization is notable Deletion of Green Party of Saudi Arabia WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8460 17331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artbox User:Badlydrawnjeff 03:18, 10 March 2006 (UTC) keep barely meets with their album ''Crush'' charting on the CMJ Radio 200 Deletion of Artbox WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8461 9588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All Points West (radio program) User:DoubleBlue 07:08, 13 October 2009 (UTC) keep Provincial-wide programme on CBC Radio One, said to be BC's top afternoon radio show. http://www.google.com/search?q=%22All+Points+West%22+cbc GoogleSearch #Programming Deletion of All Points West (radio program) WP:NMEDIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
8462 17595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inherent risk (accounting) User:Ansh666 03:11, 17 August 2013 (UTC) keep right now it's a , but is met per above Deletion of Inherent risk (accounting) WP:DICDEF||WP:N Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
8463 7200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yeshaya Labin User:Roscelese 04:31, 15 July 2011 (UTC) delete """sources attest only existence, they don't even pretend to attest notability. Fails as a) the Zidichover yeshiva is not a """"major academic institution"""" and b) he inherited the position from his father, rather than being """"elected"""" or """"appointed""" Deletion of Yeshaya Labin WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
8464 15352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of important publications in geology User:Exit2DOS2000 23:58, 1 October 2011 (UTC) delete Whom'' |says what is '|Important' (and by implication 'Unimportant'). Unless there are multiple reliable Secondary sources verifying the list, it is pure POV and OR. I am not going to repeat myself ''Ad infinitum'', all my reasoning is in the prior Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of important publications in biology|List of important AfD. Exit2DOS Deletion of List of important publications in geology WP:V||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8465 4868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Fredinburg User:Inter 22:26, 30 April 2015 (UTC) delete Subject is only known because he dated a famous person (which many other do) and died in a deadly earthquake (which killed thousands of other people). There are plenty of people who work for Google and its projects. In no way does any of this make this article pass . Keep advocates seem to be using a bit too much , but ''if'' there is more significant media coverage (which I don't think, but if) than the article should be kept. Till then delete Deletion of Dan Fredinburg WP:NN||WP:ARTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8466 6631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Stajcer User:Papaursa 18:39, 8 April 2018 (UTC) delete Fails to meet and coverage is local and/or typical of any minor league athlete. I don't see that is met Deletion of Scott Stajcer WP:NHOCKEY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8467 10492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Advertising 2.0 (3rd nomination) User:Pixelface 08:51, 13 August 2007 (UTC) delete No |reliable sources. and |Wikipedia is not a soapbox Deletion of Advertising 2.0 (3rd nomination) WP:RS||WP:SOAP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8468 8018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Alexander (Marine) User:Markeer 19:51, 10 June 2019 (UTC) keep due to significant non-trivial coverage of the subject in numerous editorially-managed secondary sources. BBC, Independent, Daily Mirror, Telegraph and Times all produced articles in which Alexander is the primary subject. I can't see any possible argument of for deletion based on or it's focused guidelines regarding people and soldiers. The article is very poorly written and needs to be cleaned up, but that's a subject for it's talk page, not for AfD Deletion of Sam Alexander (Marine) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8469 13710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skipp A. H. Williamson User:Aoziwe 11:21, 14 January 2019 (UTC) keep I think there is just enough IRS to satisfy to get over the GNG line Deletion of Skipp A. H. Williamson WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
8470 370 [[Österreichische Web-Analyse]] (Bleibt) Benutzer:SV Leschmann/Bewertung NONE delete Wiedergänger siehe auch /18. Juli 2006. Da bereits wiederholter Wiedergänger bitte '''Lemma sperren Löschung von Österreichische Web-Analyse Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
8471 17836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adora Cheung User:Hmlarson 04:59, 6 September 2016 (UTC) keep meets . Article could use cleanup, not deletion per Deletion of Adora Cheung WP:GNG||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
8472 12881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IMackulate Vision Gaming User:K 03:25, 26 January 2018 (UTC) delete as promotional 'cruft on a nn company. Fails & the article is literally about how they are campaigning to raise more funds. I requested a speedy deletion under A7 / G11; let's see if it takes Deletion of IMackulate Vision Gaming WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
8473 21785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 G-20 summit User:Lugnuts 19:20, 1 December 2015 (UTC) keep """per - """"Individual scheduled or expected future events should be included only if the event is notable and almost certain to take place""" Deletion of 2018 G-20 summit WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8474 7562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Money as Debt (2nd nomination) User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:44, 9 February 2010 (UTC) keep as documentary films rarely receive the coverage of mainstream blockbusters, and yet this one meets . Per , article will benefit from proper cleanup and expansion per http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&cf=all&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Money+as+Debt%22%2C+%22Paul+Grignon%22 available sources. No need to worry about removable bad cites if good ones are at hand... even if many are in French Deletion of Money as Debt (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
8475 7136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fun School 6 [[user talk:czar|czar]] 19:53, 25 July 2015 (UTC) merge all Fun School articles to Europress, the developer. If the subject is a valid search term, and it is, redirection to the series article is |always preferred to deletion. Redirection is Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap|more useful than deletion. As it stands, all of the Fun School games appear to lack |significant coverage from |reliable, |independent sources. (|?) FS6 had no meaningful hits in a /RS|video game reliable sources https://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=003516479746865699832:leawcwkqifq custom Google search. Probably could have just redirected the lot to the dev Wikipedia:Be bold|boldly with little fanfare. Might just want to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion#Withdrawing a nomination|withdraw the nom and do that, {{ping|TheLongTone|p=}}. Please {{tl|ping}} me you find more (non-English and offline) sources. – Deletion of Fun School 6 WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:42||WP:VG Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
8476 4555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Lash User:ARoseWolf 21:13, 21 June 2021 (UTC) delete As noted above, the originator of the draft and nominator points to a lack of reliable sources which assert claims of notability. I conducted my own search and turned up nothing of note in reliable sources. The subject fails our very basic notability policies and does not meet any SNG guideline either. Fails , Fails and no reliable sources can be found according to Deletion of Chris Lash WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG||WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
8477 11650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nightmare Creatures (film) NONE NONE delete This movie has not even confirmed to come out yet and this is not a |notable enough to be on Wikipedia, because it is not an film as big as Saw (series)|the Saw movies, etc...until all that becomes likely then delete this article until further notice Deletion of Nightmare Creatures (film) Wikipedia:Notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
8478 10847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shawn Harris User:Davidicke 17:53, 8 March 2007 (UTC) delete his band meets but there are no sources proving he has any notability independent of his band Deletion of Shawn Harris WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8479 1761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Real Girls Media User:MuffledThud 02:25, 24 March 2009 (UTC) keep 2 out of 9 references were press releases. I have now removed one, which leaves independent coverage in seven articles by third party |reliable sources, including the NYT and the SF Chronicle. It's a notable company Deletion of Real Girls Media WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8480 3609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prism3D User:MuZemike 04:46, 3 September 2008 (UTC) delete It also does not meet , as the article revolves around that list, in which the non-notability of the article itself comes into play Deletion of Prism3D WP:DIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8481 6981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bestial Warlust (2nd nomination) User:GarrieIrons 04:46, 30 November 2007 (UTC) delete """I don't actually see what part of they definitavely meet. It was my understanding that sites that accept reviews and articles from readers (ie:""""fans"""") don't generally meet please forgive me if AMG is an exception to this. I don't see that the band(s) that former members went on to participate in are/were any more notable than this band either""" Deletion of Bestial Warlust (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8482 11041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madan Maharaj FC User:NemesisAT 18:42, 11 August 2021 (UTC) keep Per , if additional sources are available then the article ought to be improved rather than deleted Deletion of Madan Maharaj FC WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
8483 4471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Narendra Modi's Google+ Hangout User:TheSpecialUser 01:52, 13 October 2012 (UTC) delete per Aurorion. Not at all notable and doesn't need any mention. It is just something done by a politician and I cannot see how is this notable. In past we have seen all articles regarding Twitter accs' of celebs getting deleted. On comparing them to this, this article isn't even near to what we call Deletion of Narendra Modi's Google+ Hangout WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8484 2426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Troll (2012 film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 03:44, 16 July 2011 (UTC) delete Way |too soon Deletion of Troll (2012 film) WP:TOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
8485 4087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Largest Air Forces User:Crum375 21:24, 23 May 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. plus ''ranking'' of fuzzy values is IMO Deletion of Largest Air Forces WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8486 6375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eastern Hills High School User:Burntsauce 18:05, 29 October 2007 (UTC) keep as notability is now demonstrated within the article. See also: Deletion of Eastern Hills High School WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
8487 11938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reginald Vaughn Finley, Sr. User:Guettarda 06:10, 22 January 2006 (UTC) keep Yet another bad faith nomination/ violation from Gastrich Deletion of Reginald Vaughn Finley, Sr. WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
8488 21219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Viana User:GiantSnowman 12:43, 20 September 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of David Viana WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8489 2707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Civilica User:Anachronist 17:18, 5 August 2021 (UTC) delete with regrets - it seems to be the primary indexing service for scholarly conference proceedings in Iran, and I see mentions (but not coverage) of it on non-Iranian sites. This is enough of a claim of significance to prevent speedy deletion, but unfortunately not enough to pass Deletion of Civilica WP:A7||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
8490 17220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2022 in film User:Lugnuts 19:06, 7 December 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of 2022 in film WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8491 7336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Brydges (2nd nomination) User:Colapeninsula 10:06, 7 August 2013 (UTC) merge to Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? (UK game show). We don't need an entry on everyone who wins a quiz - there's not an entry for every winner of Mastermind (TV series), for instance. This man hasn't done anything of note aside from his WWTBAM victory, and putting a paragraph in Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? (UK game show)#Top prize winners will suffice. As the proposer says, a classic case of , with no lasting/international significance Deletion of Robert Brydges (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
8492 21307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hartfield Academy User:ClemRutter 12:46, 4 December 2019 (UTC) keep Even the most simple Google on the school name and the road give results . One https://www.ccdarchitects.com/portfolio-item/hartfield-academy-renovation/ building renovation architect gives enough material for an article. I query whether 'I did a quick search' shows sufficient diligence to disprove notability Deletion of Hartfield Academy WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
8493 401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Wurn Technique User:MelanieN 19:19, 12 May 2012 (UTC) delete Promotional, not notable. Nothing but press releases at Google News. This is an alternative-medicine technique (and like many alternative-medicine techniques, it claims to be effective for an astonishing variety of unrelated issues, ranging from infertility to endometriosis to fallopian tube occlusion). It was invented (and apparently is only practiced) by a husband-and-wife team of physical therapists. It appears from their press releases that they have copyrighted the terms Wurn Technique® and Clear Passage Physical Therapy®. They have published several articles about their techniques http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=wurn+bf&hl=en&btnG=Search&as_sdt=1%2C5&as_sdtp=on, but the articles are not heavily cited enough to pass Deletion of The Wurn Technique WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8494 912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saturday (Basshunter song) User:SummerPhD 14:12, 15 July 2010 (UTC) comment """Soon premiere"""", YouTube views """"|will surely be"""" charted, etc. are not signs of notability. Please review . The sources you list do not address this either. Wiki projects are not reliable sources and the others merely demonstrate the song exists""" Deletion of Saturday (Basshunter song) WP:CRYSTAL||WP:NSONG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8495 18482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cheer Zone User:Ctempleton3 23:47, 25 March 2008 (UTC) delete Does not meet '''' policy Deletion of Cheer Zone WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8496 5816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fetal psychology User:Bearian 16:32, 10 August 2016 (UTC) merge to prenatal and perinatal psychology. This is clearly |an ideological fork of an existing article, but I am willing to give the benefit of the doubt that it may be a common-enough search term. It should be protected to prevent re-creation without sysop intervention. If that is not feasible, then go ahead and delete, but make sure to |salt it in any case Deletion of Fetal psychology WP:FORK||WP:SALT Wikipedia:Mirrors and forks 46
8497 13655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Italian Lesson User:SeanMD80 23:42, 22 March 2009 (UTC) comment """Yes, our encyclopedia is """"general-purpose,"""" but |it is not made of paper; it can be as broad or as specific as possible, so I don't think this is an argument against keeping this article""" Deletion of Italian Lesson WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8498 9402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Bura User:Wikipeterproject 20:32, 15 February 2010 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability whatsoever. Cannot find any reliable secondary sources that discuss the individual, his work or his achievements. Being quoted as a company spokesperson or mentioned in an article essentially not about the individual is in no way enough to establish notability. Even if the company the individual is associated with is notable, notability is |not inherited Deletion of Chris Bura WP:INHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8499 16067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 Auckland Open (darts) User:Ajf773 09:37, 9 January 2017 (UTC) delete Local tournament with no notable participants and fails . Support deleting articles for all years as per user Ajpolino Deletion of 2016 Auckland Open (darts) WP:SPORTSEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8500 5228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United States election audits and electoral fraud User:Mus 13:58, 5 April 2007 (UTC) delete This is entirely . The point of the article seems to be to articulate that machine politics leads to election fraud, and there are no sources backing that up Deletion of United States election audits and electoral fraud WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8501 21522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Microsoft Surface phone User:SmokeyJoe 07:08, 1 May 2017 (UTC) merge """to Microsoft Surface. """"rumoured"""". """"Microsoft is yet to make an official announcement for the Surface Phone. Its release has reportedly been delayed"""". It fails . Too soon""" Deletion of Microsoft Surface phone WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8502 350 [[LUMAS – Foto, Kunst, Editionen]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Nolispanmo 20:04, 17. Apr. 2008 (CEST) delete POV, Werbeprospekt, unterwandert, LD hilft da auch nicht weiter. Gem. WP:WWNI: gestellt Löschung von LUMAS – Foto, Kunst, Editionen Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
8503 18414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanner Price User:SportingFlyer 23:26, 21 January 2019 (UTC) keep passes with national feature article coverage on CBS Sports and ESPN Deletion of Tanner Price WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
8504 7249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delilah DiCrescenzo User:Niteshift36 07:09, 22 July 2009 (UTC) delete """She fails . The criteria doesn't say """"highest level in the US (or other country), it says """"highest level"""". That is Olympics or World Championships. The song thing.....you're kidding, right""" Deletion of Delilah DiCrescenzo WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8505 9528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deer Tick User:Esradekan 08:42, 12 July 2008 (UTC) keep article establishes notability as per #C1 for the above refs mentioned by TPH & Dr Strange. Also agree with the rename proposal by LonelyBeacon Deletion of Deer Tick WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8506 19044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Live in Oakland User:NJ 01:54, 5 June 2012 (UTC) keep I found several |independent sources discussing this tourhttp://www.realaspen.com/article/710/Celebrating-25-years-out-West-with-Widespread-Panichttp://www.honesttune.com/panic-rocks-the-fox-in-oakland/, so Wikipedia's |concert tour notability guideline has been met. Initially, I was going to suggest merger in Widespread Panic videography, but because of the large amount of material in this article, and the existence of articles for 14 Widespread Panic tour videos, merger is probably not possible, and keeping an independent article for each of their DVDs is a better idea Deletion of Live in Oakland WP:IS||WP:NCONCERT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8507 21903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lumiford User:AllyD 07:55, 13 April 2020 (UTC) delete An article about a company, supported by a press release and several reviews covering their loudspeaker and headphones. Searches did not locate the |coverage about the company itself required for Deletion of Lumiford :WP:RS||:WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8508 17113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miklos Kanitz User:Sharkface217 00:43, 12 January 2007 (UTC) keep Easily meets . Many of the delete votes make me sad Deletion of Miklos Kanitz WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8509 13459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alessandro Venezia User:Demitrius39 02:49, 10 January 2017 (UTC) delete I believe this person fails and . Not finding any coverage or documentation outside of uncredible sources to support article claims Deletion of Alessandro Venezia WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8510 2413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reference point User:RayAYang 21:25, 12 July 2008 (UTC) delete It is indeed already over at Wiktionary. Isn't |Speedy deletion criteria A5 for this specific case Deletion of Reference point WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
8511 2046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How to use iPhone Remote outside of your local network User:Majoreditor 04:54, 25 November 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of How to use iPhone Remote outside of your local network WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8512 5872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Endre Lund Eriksen User:Sam 11:22, 6 May 2016 (UTC) keep """Notability is based on |the existence of suitable sources, not on the state of sourcing in an article. Had the mandatory |due diligence been performed prior to AfD nomination, a mere look at :no:Endre Lund Eriksen would have eliminated a mistake such as {{gi|Basically this amounts to """"writer who exists""""}} as subject indeed has received ''several'' notable awards making him likely to pass per . Award wins are however not currently part of the section of the SNG as seems to be implied here. But subject ''also'' passes : his breakthrough book ''Pitbull-Terje går amok'' ({{Literal translation|}} ''Pitbull-Terje runs amok'') was turned into the film ''Pitbullterje'' (2005), with manuscript by Lund Eriksen, and won the 2006 Amanda Award for Best Children and Youth Film. All this and more is now properly referenced in the article with citations to reliable, secondary sources. An abundance exist on subject making him easily ''also'' pass the SNG criterion ; why were these not found prior to nomination""" Deletion of Endre Lund Eriksen WP:NRVE||WP:BEFORE||WP:ANYBIO||WP:AUTHOR||WP:NBIO||WP:AUTHOR||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8513 16092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cengage Education User:Jbhunley 04:07, 22 February 2017 (UTC) comment Tagged article for speedy deletion #A10 (Duplicate content Deletion of Cengage Education WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
8514 20325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hammurapi (software) User:AllyD 05:59, 30 August 2013 (UTC) delete No |evidence of notability found, so fails Deletion of Hammurapi (software) :WP:RS||:WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8515 1205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miroslav Barnyashev User:1292simon NONE delete Development wrestling category does not pass — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Miroslav Barnyashev WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
8516 12036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cristian Guerrero (2nd nomination) User:Dirtlawyer1 17:44, 11 December 2012 (UTC) delete Non-notable minor league baseball player. Never played a MLB game, therefore not entitled to a preromsumption of notability per . Insufficient depth of coverage in multiple, independent, reliable sources to satisfy the general notability guidelines per Deletion of Cristian Guerrero (2nd nomination) WP:NBASEBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8517 13443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mimi Fuenzalida User:Deflagro 03:32, 24 December 2007 (UTC) delete per . None of the films she has been in have their own articles. According to http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0225223/ IMDb she was just an extra in the move Broken (Women at accident Deletion of Mimi Fuenzalida WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8518 7779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward Lucien Bobinski User:Nick 23:15, 24 April 2014 (UTC) delete Not actually all that likely to be a very senior ambassadorial positions (Canada's top tier of postings would be Washington, NATO, the UK, Japan, France, etc, and not Saudi Arabia and especially not the Philippines) and the sourcing is rather thin. As such I see no reason to assume that is met here. As I've noted in previous AfDs, most ambassadors from Western-type countries are actually mid to lower-upper ranking public servants and have little public profile and it's not sensible to assume that they're notable. Only a small proportion of ambassadors actually hold senior positions in their ministry and/or have a strong public profile Deletion of Edward Lucien Bobinski WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8519 7083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Serenity Payload User:K 01:46, 20 August 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet ; promotional article, even including the pricing Deletion of Serenity Payload WP:NPRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8520 9972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tasmania official football team User:StAnselm 22:53, 11 March 2011 (UTC) keep per #1 Deletion of Tasmania official football team WP:KEEP Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
8521 19931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Koroake User:Tree 05:03, 18 June 2006 (UTC) delete per . Only 70 Google results http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Koroake%22 Deletion of Koroake WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
8522 17416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation User:Martintg 04:36, 2 November 2009 (UTC) keep notable per : a non-commercial organisation of international scope and information verifiable by http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&cf=all&ned=au&hl=en&q=%22Victims+of+Communism+Memorial+Foundation%22&cf=all third http://books.google.com/books?&as_brr=0&as_pub=-icon&q=%22Victims+of+Communism+Memorial+Foundation%22 party http://scholar.google.com/scholar?um=1&ned=au&hl=en&q=%22Victims%20of%20Communism%20Memorial%20Foundation%22&cf=all&sa=N&tab=ns sources Deletion of Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation WP:CLUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
8523 11693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maura Murray (2nd nomination) User:Kevin 02:47, 26 September 2009 (UTC) delete I note that the article has been moved, however that fails to address the fact that this still fails as a bio, or as an article on the disappearance. I do not see any lasting significance here Deletion of Maura Murray (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
8524 4932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noise Auction User:Snottywong 22:54, 12 July 2010 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Noise Auction WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
8525 11766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ivoclar Vivadent User:Mukilteoedits 03:16, 22 April 2020 (UTC) keep while the article in its current form needs significant improvements and additional sourcing, there do seem to be sources (above, and in my own search) showing the company meets Deletion of Ivoclar Vivadent WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8526 9254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miley Cyrus' fourth album User:Lprd2007 08:17, 20 June 2013 (UTC) delete As per Deletion of Miley Cyrus' fourth album WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
8527 8830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angelo Antonio Toriello User:WikiDan61 11:55, 19 January 2013 (UTC) comment DrKlain seems to be in sole possession of the documents that can verify the claims in this article. How is that so? Does the Democratic Republic of São Tomé and Príncipe not publish such official documents for public inspection? Is every newspaper that has ever reported about Toriello so backward as to not have web archives? I want to |assume good faith here, but the claims made about Toriello are too grandiose not to have left a footprint on the web Deletion of Angelo Antonio Toriello WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
8528 10497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Choksi User:Aarktica 22:06, 1 August 2007 (UTC) delete until such time when criteria are developed specifically for ''muckety mucks'' a la Deletion of Mary Choksi WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
8529 1793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marsaskala F.C. User:apple20674 14:35, 6 April 2021 (UTC) keep Passes , shown by participation in the Maltese FA Trophy here: https://www.mfa.com.mt/en/cups-competitions/cupscompetitions/bycategory/1/publish_date/asc/10/1/the--fa-trophy.htm?round=1&s=11 Deletion of Marsaskala F.C. WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8530 17498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wale Ojo User:Oluwa2Chainz 08:32, 23 May 2017 (UTC) keep Although the creator seems to be a sock and has a history of creating non-notable stub articles, this afd nomination is laughable. A simple search proves this subject meets per awards and nominations received in leading roles Deletion of Wale Ojo WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
8531 5577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eddie Pirkowski User:Corpx 02:22, 24 July 2007 (UTC) delete I think the person's historic notability could be in question here. He ran once for office and failed. I don't think that gives historic notability per #NEWS Deletion of Eddie Pirkowski WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8532 15406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jagiri Lal Sareen User:Extraordinary 00:27, 21 August 2021 (UTC) delete not presumptively notable under , and I can find no significant coverage that would meet the Deletion of Jagiri Lal Sareen WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8533 20887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Schemers User:Trevj 12:33, 4 July 2012 (UTC) merge to The Raindogs, per . The latter has apparently been tagged as unsourced for the past 5 years, and appears to be the more notable so sourced content should probably be added there first. If enough info in |reliable sources arises regarding The Schemers, the section can always be |spun out at a later date. Some sources I found are http://articles.latimes.com/1990-03-21/entertainment/ca-570_1_mark-cutlerhttp://articles.latimes.com/1990-03-22/news/vl-808_1_fiddle-playerhttp://www.bbc.co.uk/music/artists/f77546d8-c403-4eb3-a443-56d1c2e52608 Deletion of The Schemers WP:BAND||WP:SPINOUT||WP:reliable sources Wikipedia:Notability 77
8534 2879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One97 Communications (3rd nomination) User:AusLondonder 02:39, 16 September 2015 (UTC) comment This is a pretty serious case of . This is a fairly large Indian company, with thousands of employees, millions in turnover and significant coverage in reliable sources such as the daily Indian business newspaper The Economic Times. I ask all delete-voters here, would they nominate an American company in similar circumstances? With Wall Street Journal coverage? Absolutely shameful. The paid editing aspect is irrelevant, frankly. Clean it up if that is the concern Deletion of One97 Communications (3rd nomination) WP:GEOBIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
8535 818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LIST OF COUNTRY BY LENGTH OF DISTANE BETWEEN FAREST BORDER POINT User:Mz7 18:30, 1 January 2016 (UTC) delete Appears to be a textbook case of using Wikipedia as a |collection of indiscriminate information. Like the nominator, my searches found only material related to individual border sizes, not the distances between country borders Deletion of LIST OF COUNTRY BY LENGTH OF DISTANE BETWEEN FAREST BORDER POINT WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8536 14557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arkansas–Mississippi State football rivalry User:Cbl62 06:06, 13 July 2018 (UTC) delete First'', my searches did not turn up significant coverage of the type needed to satisfy . I found stories about individual games, but nothing dealing with the series in a historical or retrospective manner. (If anyone else finds such significant coverage, I'm willing to take another look.) ''Second'', my searches revealed no indication that this is considered a rivalry by either school's fanbase. No trophy, no game name, no long history, no coverage of the series as a rivalry. ''Third'', I see nothing that would warrant treating this as a historically significant series. The teams met only twice before 1992. Moreover, there is no history of matchups with national title or SEC championships on the line. Indeed, the teams have met only twice when both teams were ranked, and in neither of those cases was either team ranked in the top 10 (#12 vs. #22 in 1999 Arkansas Razorbacks football team|1999 https://www.newspapers.com/clip/21818494/arkansas_mississippi_state_1999/ here, #22 vs. #13 in 2010 Arkansas Razorbacks football team|2010 https://www.newspapers.com/image/185579514/?terms=%22mississippi%2Bstate%22%2Barkansas here). I'm just not seeing evidence to support a stand-alone article for either a rivalry or historic series Deletion of Arkansas–Mississippi State football rivalry WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8537 46 [[Oliver Schaper]] / [[The Country Channel]] (beide schnellgelöscht) Benutzer:Tox 00:26, 20. Okt. 2006 (CEST) delete Wegen Bearbeitungskonflikt doppleter LA) Ich werte die unkommentieret entfernung meines SLAs im Zuge von als wiederspruch und stelle nun einen Ordetlichen LA. Begründung: Glaskugel. Der sender soll demnäächst vieliecht starten, was aber durch tote Weblinks nicht Belegt werden kann. Eine Suche mit Der allwissenden Müllhlade nach Sendernamen und FFirmensitz ergab ebensowenig. Entwerde dreiste werbung oder schlechter Fake Löschung von The Country Channel Wikipedia:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
8538 1661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corinne Narassiguin User:Sylvainbruni 16:23, 12 May 2012 (UTC) keep I am a Frenchman in Boston and Corinne Narassiguin *is* a politician: she was elected in 2009 to represent French people who live on the East Coast of the United States (consular districts of Boston, New York, Washington, Atlanta and Miami) at the French Expatriates Assembly. She is the Vice-President of one of the commissions in the Assembly. She is very well known amongst French citizens in the United States. Furthermore, I disagree that she fails since she has been covered in independent French, Canadian and American media, including appearances on major national TV programs such as Charlie Rose (PBS) in the US or CBC in Canada.— Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Corinne Narassiguin WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8539 2007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Locaid User:K 05:04, 24 August 2017 (UTC) delete fails for lack of significant coverage. A redirect is unnecessary as the target article does not look to be notable itself, and the term is unlikely to be a valid search term Deletion of Locaid WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
8540 293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Himo User:Faizal 14:11, 3 December 2020 (UTC) delete Sources don't demonstrate notability. Fails and Deletion of Himo WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8541 13686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua D. Lewis User:ObiterDicta 02:37, 19 September 2007 (UTC) delete doesn't even come close to and suffers from massive COI to boot Deletion of Joshua D. Lewis WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8542 19562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Government Finance Officers Association User:Richfife 04:19, 20 October 2006 (UTC) keep """I expect I found this the same way you did (searching for """"Linda Christas"""".) That being said, I'm going with keep under this section of : """"Organizations are usually notable if the scope of activities are national or international in scale and information can be verified by a third party source"""". The organization covers the entirety of the USA and Canada per here: http://www.gfoa.org/services/links.shtml and here: http://www.gfoa.org/committees/canadian/. This is a webpage hosted by the Canadian government that includes an active forum dedicated to the GFOA: http://www.civicinfo.bc.ca/phpbb2/index.php?sid=acd827dd5d37599f028cc852a26a531c. This page refers to them as """"GFOA is the professional association of state/provincial and local finance officers in the United States and Canada, and has served the public finance profession since 1906."""" http://www.fpsc.com/helpful_links.htm. This is a page on the University of North Carolina's School of Government page discussing them: http://www.iog.unc.edu/organizations/ncgfoa/index.html. It's pretty clearly notable""" Deletion of Government Finance Officers Association WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8543 5238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of vehicles in The Simpsons (2nd nomination) User:JGardner 16:14, 15 November 2006 (UTC) delete """per #IINFO. I fail to see how any """"clean up"""" of this article can make a list of the vehicles seen on The Simpsons encyclopedic. If the vehicles were somehow vitally important to the dynamic of the show, I might be convinced; but they're not, they're just the animated equivalent of props. Pure fancruft""" Deletion of List of vehicles in The Simpsons (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8544 10215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Game (2013 film) User:Stuartyeates 07:54, 28 November 2012 (UTC) delete as Deletion of The Game (2013 film) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
8545 18123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Beckett (actor) User:TBrandley 01:44, 15 November 2012 (UTC) delete per Deletion of James Beckett (actor) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8546 12204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tangeline User:Charlene 11:03, 3 June 2007 (UTC) comment My concern here isn't racism: it's the idea that something more popular with women than with men might be considered automatically and without question immensely less notable than something that's more popular with men than with women. From some of the comments I get the impression that having articles on subjects more popular with women may even be considered embarrassing or stupid by some editors. This isn't new to AfD (for example, the AfD on Kim Kardashian had some of the same comments) but it really goes against . If this pairing is being talked about by independent, notable third parties (and not just outside of the soap opera world, either) it's notable enough for Wikipedia Deletion of Tangeline WP:CSB Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
8547 14604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Parrett User:Iamchrisryan 16:30, 30 September 2007 (UTC) delete Losing one house election doesn't make a person notable. Deletion of Brian Parrett WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8548 4141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tobi Bakre (2nd nomination) User:Dflaw4 05:25, 7 May 2020 (UTC) keep I understand where the nominator is coming from, because, in terms of , it could be said that the article was created a little prematurely. But, that aside, there is an abundance of coverage on the subject in reliable sources (even if some of the articles appear a little frivolous in nature). There's enough to pass both and NACTOR, in my opinion Deletion of Tobi Bakre (2nd nomination) WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8549 8593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Formosis User:Yvarta 21:22, 28 January 2017 (UTC) delete Searched several hundred google hits, and could not find anything that would help prove the topic passes . I also could not find any notable awards Deletion of Formosis WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8550 14475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clint Hickman [[User_talk:Bradv|Brad]][[Special:Contributions/Bradv|v]] 20:46, 4 January 2017 (UTC) delete fails . The only marginal claims of notability in the article are in the lede, which is unsourced. The references given in the article are mostly opinion pieces or only mention the subject in passing Deletion of Clint Hickman WP:NPOLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8551 2835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexia Koukotsikas User:Edison 15:01, 6 May 2011 (UTC) delete per .Also lacking demonstration of substantial coverage in multiple reliable and independent sources as required by . Also per OTNEWS, even if the politician's speech was echoed by the newspapers for a news cycle. Getting mentioned by a politician does not demonstrate notability. Known only for being displaced from one's home? Not notable Deletion of Alexia Koukotsikas WP:BLP1E||WP:N||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
8552 19504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Demilich (band) (2nd nomination) User:Johnson542 22:32, 2 March 2006 (UTC) keep The page was deleted in the past without weighing the evidence. It falls under the many of the requirements for non-mainstream music (note that a band is NOT required to have two albums, as stated by wknight94 in previous deletion, this is just one possible criteria for notability. The band does not even fall under this category. see . Band notability has been proven in the talk page for the demilich band site Deletion of Demilich (band) (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8553 4493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/San Diego Freeway User:Coccyx 19:30, 31 October 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. Possibly to prevent future recreation Deletion of San Diego Freeway WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
8554 3847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of controversial Don Imus quotes on women and minorities User:Craigtalbert 10:53, 15 April 2007 (UTC) delete article has already been transwikied, delete per as suggested previously Deletion of List of controversial Don Imus quotes on women and minorities WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8555 17559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Occupy Marines (2nd nomination) User:Planetary 07:46, 12 December 2011 (UTC) comment I don't see how would have anything to do with this article. The article is not about a website Deletion of Occupy Marines (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
8556 21535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keith McCarthy (footballer) User:Argyle 05:16, 19 March 2011 (UTC) delete Non-notable footballer who fails and doesn't appear to have done anything of note to pass Deletion of Keith McCarthy (footballer) WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8557 12250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The C word User:Extreme 21:31, 31 December 2005 (UTC) comment Many of these redirects were deleted as a consequence of the discussion at . A few were not deleted Deletion of The C word WP:RFD Wikipedia:Redirect 56
8558 7589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brad Voth User:Rlendog 16:56, 17 March 2017 (UTC) keep """Does not meet seem to meet NHOCKEY although http://www.theinfolist.com/php/SummaryGet.php?FindGo=Cardiff%20Devils this states that he was """"Captain for the South team for the 'All-Star Spectacular,'"""" which is not necessarily the same as a First Team All-Star per criterion #4 but not sure if the EIHL has the equivalent of such an honor. But he seems to have attracted a good amount of attention and coverage at Cardiff. http://prohockeynews.com/brad-voth-not-guilty/ This article is ostensibly about a particular incident Voth was involved in but also goes into significant detail about Voth himself. http://www.bbc.com/sport/wales/37692532 The BBC saw fit to give a short article about the retirement of his number. There is other coverage from WalesOnline such as http://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/ice-hockey/cardiff-devils-say-goodbye-legend-2041270 this and http://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/ice-hockey/big-brad-voth-returns-wales-12073212 this. The suspension he received in 2011 got some coverage in various British sources, albeit not really coverage of Voth himself. But he seems to have attracted enough attention beyond the typical player in a league that we assess in /LA as a lower level league such that keeping seems appropriate""" Deletion of Brad Voth WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
8559 3955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natsumi Harada User:Stifle 21:08, 20 September 2008 (UTC) delete The article does not |cite |reliable sources and as such does not comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Natsumi Harada WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8560 8143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mamiboy krisheno User:Unionhawk 01:39, 17 November 2009 (UTC) delete not enough significant coverage. Fails Deletion of Mamiboy krisheno WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8561 6558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Nackman User:JoshuaZ 04:39, 22 March 2006 (UTC) keep since meets , Monica, please remember . I don't see any evidence of bad faith here Deletion of Alex Nackman WP:MUSIC||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Notability 77
8562 15727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inverse vector User:Pmaccabe 23:06, 12 October 2017 (UTC) delete As noted with no independent coverage or other support Deletion of Inverse vector WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8563 18796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhys Lawrey User:Bearcat 17:28, 30 September 2016 (UTC) delete with a dose of '''salt'''. This is clearly an attempt to misuse Wikipedia as a platform for self-promotional PR, in defiance of . Local media can be easily suckered by a press release claiming a distinction (such as being in the Guinness Book of World Records) that isn't actually true, so if nobody can actually locate |verification that his name ''is'' in Guinness for holding the record in a ''recognized'' Guinness record category, the fact that a couple of media sources have uncritically repeated that claim is not enough Deletion of Rhys Lawrey WP:NOTADVERT||WP:V Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8564 48 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The 250 Most Important Albums of Latin Alternative User:Ohconfucius 03:42, 21 June 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. The |notability of Al Borde magazine has yet to be determined. OT#IINFO|Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of info Deletion of The 250 Most Important Albums of Latin Alternative WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8565 2670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle of the Birds User:Whpq 16:08, 17 September 2013 (UTC) comment What |reliable sources have documented this rivalry. There's a lot of books written about baseball. I was unable to find a single one that even mentioned this rivalry Deletion of Battle of the Birds WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8566 14872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Llama (computer culture) User:Daniel5127 05:15, 5 December 2007 (UTC) delete Per |Neologism Deletion of Llama (computer culture) WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
8567 10636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Demonization of the Serbs User:Devonian 22:35, 12 May 2020 (UTC) delete a blatant and horrifically written POVFORK that pushes conspiracy theories and anti-Croat and anti-Bosnian sentiment in lieu of any content even remotely encyclopedic. If they are any useful sources here for Anti-Serb sentiment, they most certainly do not help with any content in the article. most certainly applies here even in the off chance this is a notable topic Deletion of Demonization of the Serbs WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
8568 2601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sajad H Hamdani User:AllyD 20:36, 18 April 2013 (UTC) delete The article text just indicates that the subject completed a degree and has a job. The criteria require much more than that, and I have found no evidence that ths person meets these Deletion of Sajad H Hamdani :WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
8569 12288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baraimam pedda Amberpet User:Hut 10:08, 4 November 2016 (UTC) delete unless someone can cope up with a reliable source about the subject per #Notability. It's possible there might be foreign language sources I can't find Deletion of Baraimam pedda Amberpet WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8570 16031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kate Kotler User:Feezo 10:46, 4 February 2011 (UTC) delete mdash; lacks sufficient |reliable, |secondary sources for verification. Too few hits in the http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Kate+Kotler%22&btnG=Search+Archives&scoring=a Google news archive for the |general notability requirements. Also does not appear to meet any of the |criteria for creative professionals Deletion of Kate Kotler WP:RS||WP:SECONDARY||WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8571 4096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glyda User:Fan 01:46, 15 July 2006 (UTC) comment Forget JPS. Let me repeat: JPS does not matter to the discussion. What matters is the criteria at . Read them and explain how Glyda meets those criteria. Because it sure doesn't look like it Deletion of Glyda WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8572 9042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Woolsey User:Richwales 04:55, 2 August 2011 (UTC) delete No sources, and even if there were, I don't see enough here to establish notability per or Deletion of Matt Woolsey WP:PEOPLE||WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8573 15901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of COVID-19 deniers who died of COVID-19 User:DanielRigal 10:52, 30 August 2021 (UTC) delete """Most of the people listed do not have articles and not all of them were even actual full COVID deniers. The inclusion of a bunch of random local people who got limited or local press coverage is not only a violation of our policy against indiscriminate lists, it is needlessly cruel to their friends and relatives. That is a violation. The coverage of their deaths may have served the purpose of encouraging others to behave more responsibly at the time but there is no need to add them to a big list of people who died due to bad decisions in perpetuity. The section on the so-called """"Herman Cain Award"""" is also unacceptable. This is not an award. This is just some people on Reddit doing what people on Reddit do. Nobody cares about that. A similar article on this topic has already been deleted, and that one had a slightly less egregious title, so this one has no hope of legitimacy""" Deletion of List of COVID-19 deniers who died of COVID-19 WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8574 13845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devil (Dungeons & Dragons) User:VMS 22:37, 21 March 2016 (UTC) keep enough sourcing to pass Deletion of Devil (Dungeons & Dragons) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8575 17831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill's Arena User:Townlake 17:07, 30 June 2008 (UTC) delete and consider salting. not satisfied, and I don't see an alternative criteria of notability this passes. I agree with the appearance of COI, and the aggressive spamming of Bill's Arena to other articles is a problem Deletion of Bill's Arena WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
8576 3730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adana derby User:Abcmaxx 23:48, 15 March 2016 (UTC) keep It's a big rivalry, a quick google search shows several pictures of fans clashing and mobilising themselves and non-routine articles, therefore satisfying http://www.trthaber.com/haber/spor/adana-demirspor-adanaspor-macinda-sagduyu-cagrisi-210808.html http://www.ultras-tifo.net/photo-news/1423-adanaspor-adana-demirspor-24022013.html http://www.uisf.de/01-03-2014-1900-adana-demirspor-adanaspor-kuluebue-adana-derby/ http://www.casualultra.com/56-adanaspor-adana-demirspor-24-02-2013.html#.VuifWbwXcyg http://www.trthaber.com/haber/spor/adana-demirspor-adanaspor-macinda-sagduyu-cagrisi-210808.html Deletion of Adana derby WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8577 5029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acropolis (band) User:Esradekan 01:10, 16 July 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of Acropolis (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8578 4134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ravi Puravankara User:Bri 17:58, 21 January 2019 (UTC) delete routine businessperson BIO; being the 94th wealthiest Indian (with access to Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations/Itsmukeshhere|PR agents untroubled by ethics considerations?) does not qualify; |WP is not a list of wealthy people Deletion of Ravi Puravankara WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8579 4733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stotfield User:Gene93k 13:53, 14 February 2008 (UTC) keep It is not an independent settlement '''now'''. It originally was according to the Lossiemouth article. otability of settlements does not expire with annexation Deletion of Stotfield WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8580 3660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willis Jackson (character) User:Shooterwalker 21:42, 28 January 2012 (UTC) keep per JClemens. Reasonable belief that this article has if we give people time to look for print sources. Again, we can do another AFD later if we're wrong Deletion of Willis Jackson (character) WP:POTENTIAL Wikipedia:Potential, not just current state 11
8581 740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RussArt.com User:Starblind 13:41, 17 October 2006 (UTC) delete I don't see this passing at present. No coverage in reliable sources Deletion of RussArt.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
8582 10367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of online map services User:Ajf773 00:46, 22 January 2017 (UTC) keep as there are a few blue linked entries which would be enough to satisfy so the article just requires cleanup. Full support for deleting every single list entry that uses an external link as per . Which would be approximately 80% of them Deletion of List of online map services WP:LISTN||WP:NOTLINKFARM Wikipedia:Notability 77
8583 12895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Jackson (electronic sports player) User:Djith 23:14, 27 December 2006 (UTC) delete Subject has never appeared in any major international competition, nor made any notable achievements and therefore fails . For clarification regarding e-Sports, view e-Sports and 2006 e-Sports World Champions Deletion of Ben Jackson (electronic sports player) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8584 18108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Argo Design User:HighKing 22:04, 4 July 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and reads more like a paper published by a desperate company trying to get funding. There is literally nothing notable about this company and the language used is completely promotional. Wikipedia is not a platform for marketing or advocacy Deletion of Argo Design WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
8585 555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Kincaid User:Theroadislong 09:13, 29 July 2020 (UTC) keep seems to pass and director of notable films Robot Holocaust and ''Breeders (film)|Breeders Deletion of Tim Kincaid WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8586 4353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Italy–North Korea relations User:Colapeninsula 11:03, 16 March 2012 (UTC) merge with relevant foreign relations of X article. It only describes a single event, the opening of diplomatic relations, and it seems to fail . If more happens in the way of I-NK relations, then that would merit its own article Deletion of Italy–North Korea relations WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8587 5315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone User:Justinkunimune 21:45, 10 June 2020 (UTC) delete I contest the claim that this has received widespread coverage. A cursory google brings up coverage, but not by any sites that I would consider mainstream (CNN, New York Times, etc.) except maybe Fox News. If it gets more coverage in the next week or so then we can reinstate this article, but the fact that we don't know for sure yet whether this will be remembered in a year makes this a clear case of Deletion of Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
8588 8110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DBeaver User:Msnicki 01:17, 3 July 2012 (UTC) delete It's possible this is merely , but for now, the reliable independent secondary sources needed to establish notability as required by just don't appear to exist. I searched and found nothing useful Deletion of DBeaver WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
8589 21014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of common misconceptions (4th nomination) User:FourViolas 14:35, 27 September 2018 (UTC) keep """The topic of misperceptions (""""factual beliefs that are false or contradict the best available evidence in the public domain"""") is the subject of a small but interesting body of scholarship, reviewed on pp. 2-3 of https://www.dartmouth.edu/~nyhan/nature-origins-misperceptions.pdf this 2017 paper, so it passes . It also has reasonably clear selection criteria, so it satisfies . Therefore the list should be kept, I(DONT)LIKEIT arguments notwithstanding""" Deletion of List of common misconceptions (4th nomination) WP:LISTN||WP:SALAT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8590 7161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Laney User:Deepfriedokra 16:09, 29 September 2020 (UTC) delete """Subject doesnot meet or There is a dearth of content |cited from |reliable sources that are |unconnected with the subject and have a reputation for |fact checking."""" There is little independent coverage cited, let alone in depth from reliable sources""" Deletion of Robert Laney WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO||WP:IS||WP:V||WP:cite||WP:reliable sources Wikipedia:Notability 77
8591 10993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amit Agarwal (2nd nomination) User:AllyD 07:35, 20 August 2017 (UTC) delete """The article text is promotional, suitable for a personal website but not an encyclopaedia (''""""He is highly confident to unleash any format of technology in the field of film, television and animation which is created internationally and keeps himself updated all the times.""""'', ''""""It was no looking back for him as his dreams had already started taking shape.""""'', etc.). The passing mentions of the subject in the provided references do no more than indicate a person going about their business. The awards mentioned do not look intrinsically notable, and while searches are not helped by the Amazon executive of the same name, I am not seeing the substantial coverage needed for """ Deletion of Amit Agarwal (2nd nomination) :WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8592 10882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Misaki Amano User:Number 21:11, 12 December 2020 (UTC) delete per failure Deletion of Misaki Amano WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
8593 16997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timeline: Philippine Standout Events (2006-2007) (2nd nomination) User:Orangemike 17:30, 30 January 2008 (UTC) delete per nomination. I will add that much of this also smacks of |Original Research Deletion of Timeline: Philippine Standout Events (2006-2007) (2nd nomination) :WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8594 6183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/US Democratic Party-Iranian fundraising controversy User:Khodavand 22:19, 10 January 2007 (UTC) keep The article is sourced and meets all of Wikipedia's criteria for inclusion. See - these allegations are common enough in the media and again, '''sources have been provided''' (see ), so accusations of OR are silly. The above users appear to have a leftist, pro-Democratic POV. Wikipedia is not here to pander to partisans, but to represent all POVs. See Deletion of US Democratic Party-Iranian fundraising controversy WP:BIAS||WP:V||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
8595 302 [[TSV Carolinensiel]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:89.48.20.118 NONE delete schön, wir haben aber und das Vereinswiki Löschung von TSV Carolinensiel Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
8596 20151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 Indian Line of Control strike User:VitalPower 20:02, 11 May 2018 (UTC) keep I suggest (I read AfD instructions before jumping into these discussions dw Deletion of 2016 Indian Line of Control strike WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
8597 21186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yaghmai User:Bearian 20:06, 17 December 2020 (UTC) delete per - a not so large family with one notable member Deletion of Yaghmai WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8598 579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Killarney Celtic User:Fenix 15:49, 29 January 2015 (UTC) delete Non-notable team. Never played in a national competition per Deletion of Killarney Celtic WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8599 10925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sakthikulangara User:Northamerica1000 08:15, 18 February 2013 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Sakthikulangara WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
8600 15885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Storj Labs User:AllyD 14:27, 4 June 2020 (UTC) delete """An article on a start-up company, describing their product's features and sourced from announcements with quotations and interview Q&As from the CEO, etc. The best sources appear to be the Forbes item from 20 May, in which several paragraphs summarise the product proposition, and Thomas Claburn's piece in The Register (''""""Got a few spare terabytes of storage sitting around unused? Tardigrade can turn that into crypto-bucks: Just not very many – don't go all Bitcoin farming on this""""'', https://www.theregister.com/2020/05/14/tardigrade_storage_nas/ 14 May 2020). While these are more independent reviews, I would still see them as start-up proposition evaluations and insufficient to demonstrate attained notability""" Deletion of Storj Labs :WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8601 6783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Journal For Plague Lovers User:Kickstart70 19:45, 15 November 2008 (UTC) delete If it ever gets released, it can be recreated. As per stated above Deletion of Journal For Plague Lovers WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8602 21566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prasco Laboratories User:Serpent 21:24, 5 January 2008 (UTC) comment """Spurred by Rudget's efforts to clean up the article and my own affinity for |pulling things back from the brink, I've done all that I could to clean this up and source it appropriately. The real question for other AFD participants and the closing administrator is going to be whether or not enough of these sources are truly ''independent'' of Prasco. I'm not privy to the intricacies of the pharmaceutical industry or business reporting. I suspect that some or all of these publications are pay-to-play, and that their """"articles"""" are in fact just re-distributed press releases. ''Business Courier of Cincinnati'' might be a legitimate enough source to run with, however (although, for them, this is local business coverage). YMMV. I've done all I can""" Deletion of Prasco Laboratories WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
8603 16537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Triggering [[User Talk:PeterTheFourth|talk]]) 23:40, 30 October 2016 (UTC) delete This is a storm in a bottle- the event is not notable because it has no |lasting effect, nor |in depth or |lasting coverage. Policy specific to events says not notable enough for its own article. Special:Contributions/PeterTheFourth|PeterTheFourth Deletion of The Triggering WP:LASTING||WP:INDEPTH||WP:PERSISTENCE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8604 235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Hurley (doctor) User:DerbyCountyinNZ 04:01, 19 August 2015 (UTC) delete No indication of notability. Yet another in the plethora of articles about St Peter's College old boys who clearly fail Deletion of Peter Hurley (doctor) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8605 21477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Smokers Rights User:Davidruben 18:05, 27 September 2007 (UTC) delete """but I would accept formation of a new """"Smokers' rights movement"""" or the equivalent. There is no doubt that smokers have some claims on rights like the rest of us (just that our rights to health take priority) and that there is no doubt that some have opposed smoking restrictions (not just the tobacco industry fronting organisations). I've made limited edits or fact tag insertion to the article previously, whilst waiting/hoping that Naacats would start fleshing out the article rather than having it as """"Work under construction"""" that was way-off POV pushing and uncited - but for now the article remains fatally flawed in its approach and adherence to , ite, , and of course POV and the suggested alternative naming is more precise""" Deletion of Smokers Rights WP:N||WP:C||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
8606 440 [[JZ Microphones]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Tom_md 09:33, 23. Apr. 2014 (CEST) delete Relevanz nach #U nicht mal ansatzweise nachgewiesen Löschung von JZ Microphones Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
8607 8100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Undead/No. 5 EP User:Esradekan 12:53, 1 March 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Albums. Searching pulls up no |reliable, third-party, sources Deletion of Undead/No. 5 EP WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8608 9368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kalyanappittannu User:Donaldd23 16:29, 27 December 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Kalyanappittannu WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
8609 19424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary Wilkos User:Cbs527 17:51, 7 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and . Lot of puffery with no sources to back up. G-searches provided nothing to establish notability. Most of article vilolate Deletion of Gary Wilkos WP:GNG||WP:NATHLETE||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
8610 135 [[Erdspiegel]] (Gelöscht) Benutzer:Sicherlich NONE delete """kein artikel, dafür """"how to"""" , und geschichten, keine Quellen""" Löschung von Erdspiegel Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8611 20069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/24-Hour Vevo Record User:Staszek 01:28, 21 October 2015 (UTC) delete A good example for Deletion of 24-Hour Vevo Record WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8612 21400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iceage sugar User:AmaryllisGardener 16:04, 10 November 2014 (UTC) delete not notable, fails Deletion of Iceage sugar WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
8613 3981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2020 Safari Rally User:Unnamelessness 14:14, 31 May 2020 (UTC) keep Even if the subject fails , it might be able to receive an article as per . Not to mention the article actually passes the GNG Deletion of 2020 Safari Rally WP:GNG||WP:5P5 Wikipedia:Notability 77
8614 10635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Franz Ferdinand's third album User:Evb 12:15, 17 October 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Deletion of Franz Ferdinand's third album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8615 6144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Redneck-Asian User:Jeff 04:28, 8 March 2011 (UTC) delete per nom and close per . Deletion of Redneck-Asian WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
8616 11841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Yu-Gi-Oh! cards User:Knowledgekid87 23:13, 30 November 2013 (UTC) delete per can someone please explain to me how each card is notable here? The topic Yu-Gi-Oh! Trading Card Game is notable, the cards themselves dont seem to be Deletion of List of Yu-Gi-Oh! cards WP:INHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8617 20150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Household consumption expenditures User:Otolemur 10:34, 6 April 2008 (UTC) delete per #STATS Deletion of Household consumption expenditures WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8618 17371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunset Boulevard (2008 film) User:Steve 10:55, 31 January 2008 (UTC) delete The |notability guidelines for future films stipulate that a stand-alone article for a film should not be created until a project enters production. This is because many factors such as budget issues, scripting issues, and casting issues can interfere with the project. The article can be recreated when principal photography is confirmed to have begun Deletion of Sunset Boulevard (2008 film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
8619 19551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death Kills User:Csernica 06:44, 6 December 2005 (UTC) delete """Look, this isn't a formatting issue or anything like that. If it were, someone could just fix it. The problem is that this play isn't notable enough to be included in an encyclopedic compilation. It's not personal and no one is trying to """"get"""" you or embarrass you, it's a question of Wikipedia policy. See , especially """"Wikipedia is not a propaganda machine"""" and, as regards future notability, """"Wikipedia is not a crystal ball""" Deletion of Death Kills WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8620 2275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ley tunnel User:Phil 19:45, 21 September 2009 (UTC) delete or, if there is any useful content here that's not already in that article, '''merge''' with secret passage. That is the common English name for what is described in this article, and the linking of secret passages with ley lines seems like a piece of |synthesis that is unsupported by reliable sources Deletion of Ley tunnel WP:synthesis Wikipedia:No original research 65
8621 1271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Safoora Zargar User:Stifle 14:52, 28 May 2020 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Safoora Zargar WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
8622 7124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Great Falls Police Department User:Exit2DOS2000 NONE keep WP:Local is only an Essay, not a Guideline (besides, it deals with Artilces about places, not Police Dept's). Coverage in any is stil coverage in a ''no matter where it is located''. 1 previous AfD does ''not'' mean a consensus has been reached on an entire topic, and smacks of ''Other stuff does not exist, so why should this''. I see no valid reason to delete based upon this Nomination request Deletion of Great Falls Police Department WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8623 1332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alix Lynx User:Guilherme 01:14, 3 April 2018 (UTC) delete Fail in ? Yes. Fail in ? Perhaps. But all sources cite the fact about she leaves her corporate Job to Be a Porn Star. This is Deletion of Alix Lynx WP:PORNBIO||WP:GNG||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
8624 7869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United States Senate election in North Dakota, 2010 User:AliceJMarkham 01:33, 6 November 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Re-creation should occur when there is something to put in it, particularly from |reliable sources Deletion of United States Senate election in North Dakota, 2010 WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8625 1006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zhang Jingzhe User:Eagleash NONE delete Fails ... no appearances in a |fully professional league. Not enough to satisfy GNG Deletion of Zhang Jingzhe :WP:NFOOTY||:WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8626 15398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gordon Lennon [[User talk:81.96.65.76|talk]]) 21:51, 13 June 2009 (UTC) keep Hard to articulate my reasoning but I feel a combination of things means he should just about scrape it. He has a decent length career in the Scottish League (although semi-professional, it's not non-league as has been stated), he was a club captain (which makes him a big part of the club) received minor coverage before his death, and a lot afterward. A guy who made one appearance for a lowly League Two club would be notable as per but another who had a 20 year career in the division below would not be? There seems to be very little leeway in that guideline and perhaps it should not be such a black and white rule. Special:Contributions/81.96.65.76|81.96.65.76 Deletion of Gordon Lennon WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8627 18882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Core.onion User:Seattle 14:57, 16 November 2013 (UTC) delete """fails , specifically point one. Searches for """"Core.onion"""" do not yield """"multiple non-trivial published works"""" about the subject""" Deletion of Core.onion WP:WEBCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8628 168 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Bandırma Onyedi Eylül Üniversitesi Mühendislik ve Doğa Bilimleri Fakültesi """[[User:Styyx|'''~Styyx''']][[User talk:Styyx|''Evet''''?'']]""" 13.53, 15 Ekim 2021 (UTC) delete M6. Hakkında bağımsız, güvenilir ve kapsamlı kaynaklar bulamadım. 'ü karşılamıyor Bandırma Onyedi Eylül Üniversitesi Mühendislik ve Doğa Bilimleri Fakültesi'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:ÖRGÜT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8629 8285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019 Gamba Osaka season User:GiantSnowman 08:59, 24 June 2017 (UTC) delete too far in the future, Deletion of 2019 Gamba Osaka season WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8630 3054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stdlib.h [[User talk:202.124.72.20|talk]]) 04:31, 6 November 2011 (UTC) keep Plenty of sources exist, and is obviously satisfied. As to the redirect proposals, C miscellaneous operations is up for deletion, while C_standard_library#ISO_C_library_headers is just a table of article pointers, and requires '''this''' article to exist. -- Special:Contributions/202.124.72.20|202.124.72.20 Deletion of Stdlib.h WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8631 12573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twinn the Rap Rocky User:Panser 01:55, 7 April 2007 (UTC) delete Fails (and , with references like that Deletion of Twinn the Rap Rocky WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8632 8235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bells (Blackadder) (2nd nomination) User:Lugnuts 08:15, 9 January 2008 (UTC) keep """This smacks of by the nom. Meets the """"real world"""" notability (a ref I myself added on the last AFD nom). Why nominate this episode and not all the other Blackadder episodes? In a worst case scenerio, this should be redirected to List of Blackadder episodes, but it's notable enough to survive the AFD""" Deletion of Bells (Blackadder) (2nd nomination) WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8633 1437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bobby dabble User:Favonian 21:16, 3 January 2010 (UTC) delete per nom. The claims in the article deserve a deletion per #G3 Deletion of Bobby dabble WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
8634 852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prem C. Pandey User:Ekbal_anuj 07:26, 3 February 2008 (UTC) delete There seems to be some serious issues attached to this page, not to mention the issue of |notability. The edit history suggests that it was created by Dr. Pandey himself (see the user names), and if Deletion of Prem C. Pandey WP:COI||WP:N Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
8635 9266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Free Cocaine User:Rlendog 03:52, 8 February 2010 (UTC) comment As Doomsdayer points out, charting is not a requirement for album notability (it is not even part of the criteria). This album has an allmusic review (whose significance I disagree with the nominator on) and apparently coverage in a book. So it may meet notability. But if not, a merge or redirect to Dwarves (band) would be more appropriate under than deletion Deletion of Free Cocaine WP:NALBUMS||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8636 2541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diana Alouise User:SamHolt6 17:51, 19 September 2017 (UTC) delete Fails , porbably only exists due to paid editing by suspected paid editor (Undisclosed paid editing tag per Wikipedia:Conflict_of_interest/Noticeboard#Jabailey1 Deletion of Diana Alouise WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8637 7420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Jimenez User:Whisperjanes 16:05, 7 June 2020 (UTC) keep """per {{noping|XOR'easter}} and . He's done enough things to make him notable or """"worth knowing"""", since he's been a newscaster for so long, even getting an Emmy nomination as one. And like others have said, he's had other coverage (even though it's light) before the event""" Deletion of Omar Jimenez WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8638 13093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unusual Sex Acts [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']] 18:27, 3 March 2006 (UTC) delete WP:NPOV violation - by what criteria is a sexual act deemed unusual? Reading through the list, it is impossible to distinguish between those in which people do participate and those that are merely dreamed up and written about as sexual folklore. refers. In addition, no citations or references make this list useless for research in to cultural practises Deletion of Unusual Sex Acts WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
8639 14546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leon McPherson User:Corvus 00:45, 18 October 2005 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Leon McPherson WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8640 21011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kate Harper (The West Wing) User:Shooterwalker 22:05, 7 June 2012 (UTC) merge and summarize as a compromise. Not enough objective evidence to so a stand-alone article is inappropriate Deletion of Kate Harper (The West Wing) WP:verify notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
8641 6135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WRCH User:TomCat4680 01:51, 1 November 2010 (UTC) keep """All radio stations are notable. If it's """"poorly written"""", |re-write it""" Deletion of WRCH WP:SOFIXIT Wikipedia:Be bold 9
8642 10906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Personal life of Jennifer Lopez User:Trevj 08:23, 18 June 2012 (UTC) merge to Jennifer Lopez per , . Having a separate article for this subject matter gives it undue weight. The article length concerns of the main article can be addressed by splitting out other content, e.g. Career of Jennifer Lopez, List of songs recorded by Jennifer Lopez, etc. as Talk:Jennifer Lopez#Too long or too overly detailed? Need a split?|recently suggested by George Ho Deletion of Personal life of Jennifer Lopez WP:NOTTABLOID||WP:BLPGOSSIP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8643 13022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Trotskyist Committee for the Political Regeneration of the Fourth International User:Edison 02:34, 5 April 2011 (UTC) delete """per failure to satisfy the applicable notability guideline, . There is no guideline providing """"Inherent notability for tiny splinter political parties lacking multiple reliable and independent references with significant coverage."""" Verifying its existence via a directory listing is inadequate. No sources cited to satisfy the guideline""" Deletion of International Trotskyist Committee for the Political Regeneration of the Fourth International WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8644 7491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Search for the South's Funniest Accountant User:NickCT 20:35, 22 May 2015 (UTC) delete Smells like |self promotion.{{ping|Airplane Maniac}} - This should have been a speedy delete or a proposed deletion. Not sure you had to bring this to AfD Deletion of The Search for the South's Funniest Accountant WP:SELFPROMOTION Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
8645 4248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Gelin User:HelloAnnyong 15:03, 27 February 2008 (UTC) delete Fails . &mdash Deletion of Martin Gelin WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8646 18422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Initial D real-life locations and popularity User:danntm 01:35, 28 April 2007 (UTC) delete as OR and against the spirit of Deletion of Initial D real-life locations and popularity WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8647 21050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swathi Naidu User:SshibumXZ 13:24, 20 September 2018 (UTC) delete Fails by a mile or so. Also, I predict it would |snow today (or tomorrow, I am not a warlord an admin). Regards Deletion of Swathi Naidu WP:NACTOR||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Notability 77
8648 4469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unfuddle User:JoshuaZ 15:37, 3 August 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Unfuddle WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8649 10146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trans-Mediterranean Renewable Energy Cooperation User:Kickstart70 05:02, 5 August 2007 (UTC) comment Benderson2 is making a large effort to fix some of the NPOV issues with the page currently. However I'm unsure if he understands |the conflict he is in and will continue to be in, due to his role within the organization. Whether that has an impact here, I'll leave to your opinions Deletion of Trans-Mediterranean Renewable Energy Cooperation WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
8650 10604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013 Maria Sharapova tennis season NONE NONE comment """First and foremost, , by its own terms, only applies to """"individual seasons of teams in top professional leagues""""; any reliance on as a short cut in establishing the notability of a single season of a single professional tennis player is misplaced. To demonstrate the notability of any single season of one pro tennis player, that defined season -- not the player, not the individual tournaments played by the player during the season, not the player's promotions and endorsements during that season -- must satisfy the general notability guidelines per . That means the player's individual 2013 season -- not the player, not the 2013 tournaments in which the player participated, not the player's 2013 promotions, and not the 2013 WTA Tour season -- must have received significant coverage in multiple, independent, reliable sources per GNG. That's no small task, because tennis player's careers are not normally covered on the basis of single seasons like many team sports are""" Deletion of 2013 Maria Sharapova tennis season WP:NSEASONS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8651 2332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flaming Guitar User:Kizor 19:26, 20 August 2010 (UTC) delete """Forget notability: this one runs into |verifiability, the cornerstone of the project and one of the few Rules that define a good article instead of getting used as a club by deletion-happy (sorry, past trauma) being intended as a tool to help make good articles. V basically means that the word of an open wiki is not good for much. All articles have to be able to give a proper answer to the question """"Says who?"""" This is no minor issue. Check out the scam attempts after the Boxing Day tsunami, or better yet, don't. ''Flaming Guitar'' doesn't seem to have any third-party sources backing it up, nor can we expect it to acquire any in a reasonable length of time. If the authors or other people are interested in acquiring a copy of the article after the AfD closes, feel free to ask me or another admin""" Deletion of Flaming Guitar WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8652 11347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Steinhauer User:David 17:35, 7 May 2019 (UTC) delete With a single digit h-index, and apparently no books, it's pretty clear that #C1 and are out of reach. I don't see a pass of any other academic notability criterion. I can only find brief namedrops in local news (e.g. https://www.phillyvoice.com/villanova-opens-new-center-history-public-interest/) so I don't see much chance for . And the breathless primary-sourced reporting of every little non-notable thing he's done gives the clear appearance of promotionalism Deletion of Jason Steinhauer WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8653 16974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Green Springs Elementary School (Ohio) User:Squeamish 20:11, 11 October 2016 (UTC) merge to the school district article, '''merging''' some of the information about the Chromebook program if desired (if article length is a problem, there's some content in the district article that probably needs to be trimmed down to satisfy ). Entertaining the article creator's request, I looked for sources for this as if didn't exist at all. I found some (probably trivial, but still...) history about the school during https://books.google.com/books?id=3XiWT8FmUK4C&pg=PA109&dq=%22green+springs+elementary+school%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiElp7bw9PPAhVENj4KHSVZB1AQ6AEILTAB#v=onepage&q=%22green%20springs%20elementary%20school%22&f=false desegregation... no, wait, that's a ''different'' Green Springs Elementary School (in Louisa County, Virgnia, and no longer in service). Aaaand then we're pretty much done, except for the requisite |routine coverage that doesn't contribute to notability on any |local topic, elementary school or otherwise. The local newspaper's Halloween-season light news story suggesting that the school building is haunted by the ghosts of students from the ''original'' 19th century school is about the most interesting, but doesn't get within sight of being appropriate for an encyclopedia article. As an aside, the information in the article as it stands is problematic. The 2010 date in the infobox is apparently solely for the most recent building; the school operated under this name at least as far back as the early 1960s (based on https://books.google.com/books?id=JJC7zJ5o8ioC&pg=PA18201&dq=%22green+springs+elementary+school%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiElp7bw9PPAhVENj4KHSVZB1AQ6AEIMzAC#v=onepage&q=%22green%20springs%20elementary%20school%22&f=false this mention of its former principal in the Congressional Record, and, no, that contributes to the notability of neither the school nor the principal). There's almost certainly some elementary school, somewhere, that can sustain an article on its own merits; this is not that case Deletion of Green Springs Elementary School (Ohio) WP:BLP||WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES||WP:MILL||WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
8654 3347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Contact (word game) User:Jeff 02:22, 2 April 2013 (UTC) delete and salt per nom and Carrite. This article has been prodded twice (once by me) and deleted once already. Neither forums nor Google are -compliant. As far as I can tell, it has no redeeming qualities whatsoever. Deletion of Contact (word game) WP:VRS Wikipedia:The answer to life, the universe, and everything 7
8655 18160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/School of water business User:Kappa 21:06, 5 September 2006 (UTC) keep manga series which has run to at least 12 volumes http://www.amazon.co.jp/s/ref=sr_pg_1/503-1746056-1409531?ie=UTF8&keywords=%E9%83%BD%E7%AB%8B%E6%B0%B4%E5%95%86%21&rh=n%3A465610%2Ck%3A%E9%83%BD%E7%AB%8B%E6%B0%B4%E5%95%86%21&page=1. AFD is not here for cleanup or to promote |bias against non-English language topics Deletion of School of water business WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
8656 9970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The National Center of French-Speaking Students in Israel User:Number 12:44, 14 November 2018 (UTC) delete Don't believe this passes Deletion of The National Center of French-Speaking Students in Israel WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8657 6186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kumar Mahabir User:DoriSmith 04:12, 15 July 2009 (UTC) delete """According to this article, he has written seven books, and is CEO of """"Chakra Publishing House"""". According to http://www.geocities.com/chakrapub/ the Chakra Publishing House page (on Geocities!), they have published seven books written or edited by Kumar Mahabir—which means that all of his books are self-published. Other than his books, he has no claim to notability. And while being an |AUTOBIOGRAPHY isn't itself grounds for deletion, it's just bad practice to re-create it again after it's already been deleted twice""" Deletion of Kumar Mahabir WP:AUTOBIOGRAPHY Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
8658 14772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lady Mabel Fitzwilliam (2nd nomination) User:David 22:59, 12 June 2007 (UTC) delete """I've never been one to love discussing concerns, but the lack of """"multiple independent sources"""" et al part is what closes it for me""" Deletion of Lady Mabel Fitzwilliam (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8659 11789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Artisan User:Pharaoh 21:01, 14 December 2015 (UTC) delete Per Norvoid ,fails Deletion of Matt Artisan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8660 13887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticism of Hugo Chávez (3rd nomination) User:RutgerH 01:41, 2 July 2009 (UTC) delete It's a and often pushes the limits of scope when there's no need. I see no problems with a Public Image page (a renamed media representation) but I think just adding to that and the other relevant articles, rather than a merge, is a better idea Deletion of Criticism of Hugo Chávez (3rd nomination) WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
8661 6695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dalton Crossan User:Cbl62 12:55, 25 February 2018 (UTC) keep """The has been removed, and regardless of whether Crossan ever plays in an NFL game, he passes with significant coverage in multiple, reliable, and independent sources. Coverage includes: '''(1)''' ESPN profile referenced by SportingFlyer (http://www.espn.com/blog/new-york-giants/post/_/id/51367/dalton-crossan-the-next-chris-hogan-or-maybe-even-better here); '''(2)''' """"Dalton Crossan the next Chris Hogan? Or maybe even better?"""", ''Pro Football Weekly'', 4/10/17, 887 words (appears to be a duplicate of the ESPN profile); '''(3)''' """"https://www.bostonglobe.com/sports/patriots/2017/02/25/jim-mcbride-this-former-unh-star-isn-into-chris-hogan-comparisons-just-wants-make-man-roster/Bps5yYdLyS074yWuvfSiyK/story.html This former UNH star isn’t into Chris Hogan comparisons. He just wants to make the NFL"""", ''The Boston Globe'', 2/26/17 (full story requires subscription); '''(4)''' """"https://www.newsday.com/sports/football/dalton-crossan-agrees-to-sign-with-indianapolis-colts-after-going-undrafted-1.13543146 Dalton Crossan agrees to sign with Indianapolis Colts after going undrafted"""", ''Newsday'', 4/29/17; '''(5)''' """"https://www.foxsports.com/nfl/story/could-dalton-crossan-be-the-next-chris-hogan-021517 Could Dalton Crossan be the next Chris Hogan?"""", Fox Sports, 6/30/17'''(6)''' """"https://nesn.com/2017/04/the-next-julian-edelman-nfl-hopeful-dalton-crossan-sees-himself-in-patriots-star/ The Next Julian Edelman? NFL Hopeful Dalton Crossan Sees Himself In Patriots Star"""", New England Sports Network, 4/7/17; '''(7)''' """"http://americansportsnet.com/colonial-athletic-association/james-madison-dukes/from-multi-sport-athlete-dalton-crossan-morphs-into-all-purpose-football-star From multi-sport athlete, Dalton Crossan morphs into all-purpose football star"""", American Sports Network, 10/14/16; '''(8)''' """"49ers worked out New Hampshire RB Dalton Crossan"""", ''Pro Football Weekly'', 4/9/17 (495 words); '''(9)''' """"Crossan back to lead ground game"""", ''New Hampshire Union Leader'', 4/27/16; '''(10)''' """"http://www.fosters.com/article/20150814/sports/150819579 Playmaker Crossan wants the ball in his hands"""", ''Foster's Daily Democrat'', 8/14/15 (890 words); '''(11)''' """"http://www.fosters.com/article/20141211/GJSPORTS_01/141219781 Crossan gives Wildcats another playmaker"""", ''Foster's Daily Democrat'', 12/11/14 (743 words); '''(12)''' """"Versatile Crossan comes up big for the Wildcats"""", ''Foster's Daily Democrat'', 10/25/13; '''(13)''' """"Versatile Crossan comes up big for the Wildcats"""", ''Foster's Daily Democrat'', 10/25/13, 771 words; '''(13)''' """"http://www.sachemreport.com/2017/04/29/sachem-alum-dalton-crossan-signing-with-colts/ Sachem's Dalton Crossan To NFL's Colts"""", ''Sachem Report'', 4/29/17 (significant coverage, but source probably not reliable); and '''(14)''' """"http://www.concordmonitor.com/Dalton-Crossan-thinks-he-would-be-a-good-fit-with-Patriots-9165185 UNH’s Crossan has eyes on Patriots as draft approaches"""", ''Concord Monitor'', 4/7/17""" Deletion of Dalton Crossan WP:COPYVIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
8662 9421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethical Culture User:Tom 12:16, 5 March 2011 (UTC) keep Topic is notable in the history of atheism and religious thought. In fact, more notable than the page makes out as there are Ethical Society chapters outside the U.S. Many of what are now atheist or freethought organisations originated as ethical culture groups, and those often originated out of religious humanism, unitarianism etc. To understand the development of atheism, you need to understand the ethical culture movement. Improving the references shouldn't be too difficult. And COI shouldn't be too big of an issue here either: plenty of religious adherents edit or originate articles on religious topics. Answer is to get more eyes on the topic to make sure it adheres to Deletion of Ethical Culture WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
8663 20710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How to save a life (2011) User:MichaelQSchmidt 00:24, 5 June 2013 (UTC) delete Fails . Worse, the topic and principals fail . Film, director, producer, and cast are unverifiable Deletion of How to save a life (2011) WP:NF||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
8664 31 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ahmet Çamsarı """[[User:Styyx|'''~Styyx''']][[User talk:Styyx|''Evet''''?'']]""" 11.08, 29 Mayıs 2021 (UTC) keep Mersin Üniversitesi rektörü olduğundan VP:AKADEMİSYEN'deki #Ölçütler için açıklamalar|altıncı kriteri karşılıyor Ahmet Çamsarı'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
8665 21699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unqork User:Dilbert404 21:49, 21 August 2021 (UTC) comment It seems that the main issue here is a fundamental disagreement over what sources satisfy , whether or not is enough to indicate notability, and what sources count as independent. Maybe it's time for a happy medium, like one of Wikipedia's alternatives to deletion. Perhaps incubation or the addition of relevant tags? Let's work toward a solution Deletion of Unqork WP:ORGIND||WP:GHITS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8666 18098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Venturesome [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 20:32, 18 September 2006 (UTC) delete No assertions of notability that would meet any of the three criteria listed in . Entire article is unsourced and unverified, and as such does not meet . And while not a strict reason to delete, the entire article reads like an ; nothing worth salvaging here Deletion of Venturesome WP:CORP||WP:V||WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8667 15677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emily Glenister User:TheMagikCow 20:18, 1 January 2017 (UTC) delete The Sky News source appears to be dead. The Telegraph source is not about her - so can't be used to establish notability. A web search shows no evidence of anything with her as the focus - which shows that notability can't be esablish and should be deleted. I consider the sources online and identified in the article to be ''trivial coverage of a subject by secondary sources'' as they only '''mention''' her and and she is not the '''focus'''. Therefore, the criteria is failed Deletion of Emily Glenister WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8668 10122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fugenx User:Mikeman67 15:51, 9 June 2015 (UTC) delete although if kept, it should be moved to Fungenx Technologies, which appears to be its actual name. No in depth coverage whatsoever, no reliable sources, fails Deletion of Fugenx WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8669 2431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mac DVDRipper Pro User:OSborn 18:36, 16 December 2010 (UTC) comment Article creator is a probable |SPA: {{user|Macdvd}}. (Apparently now using the account {{user|Maknak Deletion of Mac DVDRipper Pro WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
8670 9685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Game events User:MrStalker 15:11, 13 June 2009 (UTC) delete Smells |OR all over the place Deletion of Game events WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8671 637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pirates of the Caribbean: 4 User:YechielMan 13:44, 18 June 2007 (UTC) delete per ; I might consider an IAR speedy here because this really has no chance of becoming a legitimate article Deletion of Pirates of the Caribbean: 4 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8672 17835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wesley Charles Jacobs Jr. User:Normal 20:31, 26 September 2020 (UTC) keep """per . I fixed all the citations, which were in poor shape but the information was there (just moved). One particular citation https://www.macfound.org/fellows/301/ explains Jacobs' work leading to the award. I wouldn't call the award minor. Today, """"The MacArthur Fellowship is a $625,000, no-strings-attached award to extraordinarily talented and creative individuals as an investment in their potential."""" https://www.macfound.org/programs/fellows/strategy""" Deletion of Wesley Charles Jacobs Jr. WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8673 12506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nate Powell User:Argento 14:09, 13 September 2018 (UTC) keep the guy won an Eisner award, which is the most prestigious award the comic industry has. I suggest the nominator review criteria 4c of Deletion of Nate Powell WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
8674 4648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Jamaican Americans NONE NONE keep The rationale for deletion given in Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of German Americans was #DIR. So these lists below should also be deleted if we want to be consistent Deletion of List of Jamaican Americans WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8675 12062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zaman Ali (philosopher) User:GPL93 22:18, 23 September 2019 (UTC) delete fails and , subject wasn't notable the first time the article was deleted and isn't notable now. Best Deletion of Zaman Ali (philosopher) WP:NPOL||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
8676 14734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anastasis Michael User:AgnosticPreachersKid 21:46, 14 April 2008 (UTC) delete I can't find any RS and as #Politicians states, just being a candidates doesn't make a person notable Deletion of Anastasis Michael WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8677 16868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deletionist versus Inclusionist Controversy User:Secret 01:04, 24 January 2008 (UTC) delete yes it's sourced, but it's textbook example of a violation, as the article can't never go beyond biased original research Deletion of Deletionist versus Inclusionist Controversy WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
8678 8400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IWA East Coast User:Nikki311 19:01, 15 September 2010 (UTC) comment the article needs to meet to be kept and nobody who has voted keep has proven how it does. Even the creator of the article admits that it doesn't (''The article may not meet the CORP notability guideline Deletion of IWA East Coast WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8679 7186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Satan LaVey User:Stifle 00:11, 13 March 2006 (UTC) merge to Anton LaVey. is quite clear that non-notable relatives of notable people are mentioned in the notable person's article, and don't get their own. ''This is not a keep vote Deletion of Satan LaVey WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8680 2283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuttichathan user:Andrew 16:21, 21 October 2019 (UTC) keep A survey of sources, such as seen in the search links above indicates that the topic is notable. The rest is then a matter of ordinary editing, not deletion per – which states clearly that brief starts on a topic are welcome. See also Deletion of Kuttichathan WP:IMPERFECT||WP:TLDR Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
8681 3206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Hamley user:Andrew 10:39, 1 February 2021 (UTC) keep """It's quite easy to find more sources such as http://news.bbc.co.uk/local/cornwall/hi/people_and_places/history/newsid_8710000/8710901.stm this. Per . """"''If editing can improve the page, this should be done rather than deleting the page""" Deletion of William Hamley WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
8682 5514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Functional Area 59 User:Anotherclown 07:56, 7 January 2011 (UTC) delete """non-notable organisational minutia IMO. A search of google books reveals very little, as does a web search. As such this subject seemingly lacks """"signficant independent coverage"""" in |reliable sources and therefore fails /N""" Deletion of Functional Area 59 WP:RS||WP:MILMOS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8683 4773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soviet technology of Command & Conquer User:Pete 19:36, 11 November 2007 (UTC) delete Game cruft. Not a single reference, let alone a reliable secondary source to establish the encyclopedic notability of this topic. must be satisified by an secondary source, this comes no where close. Transwiki it if you like, but this is essentially a fan essay, and just doesn't belong in an encyclopedia, be it paper or not Deletion of Soviet technology of Command & Conquer WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8684 3796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GUI Tar User:Joe 02:24, 25 December 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of GUI Tar WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8685 784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Insecticons User:Beemer69 01:24, 24 December 2016 (UTC) merge with List of Decepticons. Article is poorly sourced and consists almost entirely of |fancruft and original research. This isn't a wiki Deletion of Insecticons WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
8686 11201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007 Latin American Tour User:Steve 17:43, 11 June 2008 (UTC) delete Doing a search on http://au.search.yahoo.com/search?p=%222007+Latin+American+Tour%22&ei=UTF-8&fr=yfp&xargs=0&pstart=1&b=1 Yahoo, I found no sources that could be used to assert notability, as required by . I can't see how this could be merged into the Coldplay article, so I think deletion would be best, unless notability can be asserted Deletion of 2007 Latin American Tour WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8687 11085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vesicash User:Celestina007 09:03, 7 June 2020 (UTC) delete Fails to satisfy Deletion of Vesicash WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8688 15003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C. T. William User:97198 12:01, 28 July 2008 (UTC) delete WEBHOST, PAPERS, TEXTBOOK Deletion of C. T. William WP:NOT||WP:NOTTEXTBOOK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8689 11053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aksyn Elek User:Fosse8 09:13, 13 April 2012 (UTC) comment """And now it's ''four'' redlink SPAs... Everything you mention other than the newspaper coverage is irrelevant to , but the newspaper articles are the most convincing thing yet. Il Secolo XIX seems to be a local paper, and I can't find anything about the other two at all (Googling """"La Riviera"""" as you suggested brings up lots of restaurants, as well as media in the Californian town of La Riviera, but even using modifiers like newspaper, Italia, Ventimiglia I still find nothing on the first six or seven pages of hits); they look like articles covering him because he's a young musician from the area, not because he's inherently notable. But then I don't speak Italian and I'm at the mercy of translation software. It is noticeable the biggest articles all date from the end of 2010, as though Aksyn had sent press releases to all the local papers at around that time to plug his album. Also, pieces where the musician talks about themselves are usually excluded from 1 - what do others think""" Deletion of Aksyn Elek WP:MUSIC||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8690 9155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/York Hiking Club User:Bfigura 00:54, 3 June 2008 (UTC) delete as a nn local club that doesn't pass Deletion of York Hiking Club WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8691 13419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akoustik User:Alan 00:37, 26 September 2012 (UTC) delete per . It is unreferenced Deletion of Akoustik WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8692 13907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex D. Linz User:Jamesallain85 10:46, 16 July 2021 (UTC) keep Actor has been directly involved with numerous notable films besides the interview, passes #1 Deletion of Alex D. Linz WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8693 5447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WISEPC J234841.10-102844.4 User:David 00:45, 21 March 2013 (UTC) delete for lack of the independent nontrivial coverage required by Deletion of WISEPC J234841.10-102844.4 WP:NASTRO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8694 11970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julius Pruitt User:Giants27 18:44, 10 September 2009 (UTC) delete Fails , can be recreated when/if he's notable Deletion of Julius Pruitt WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8695 18960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Palombia User:Piotrus 05:01, 18 August 2020 (UTC) delete 100% that fails . My only concern is that this is what is for (when it is not abused by inclusionists Deletion of Palombia WP:FANCRUFT||WP:NFICTION||WP:PROD Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
8696 498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magdalena Zamolska User:Joseph2302 23:03, 27 April 2017 (UTC) keep This AfD is in bad faith from an editor trying to make a |point about the long standing notability consensuses of and Deletion of Magdalena Zamolska WP:POINT||WP:NCYCLING||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
8697 2825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heisenberg's paradox User:Verdatum 20:34, 21 April 2008 (UTC) delete """The article is titled in such a way as to seem that there is a known named concept called """"Heisenberg's paradox"""", however, such does not appear to be the case. While I don't doubt that heisenberg has raised many paradoxical topics, naming it in this manner can be considered . The article reads like a school essay. Because the article does not have a proper lead section, I am unable to improve it's content (beyond wikifying, and fixes to spelling and grammar). The topic fails Notability, it does not make a strong effort to define it's scope. Even with serious improvements, I cannot see any way this fits into Wikipedia""" Deletion of Heisenberg's paradox WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8698 18668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Xavier's School, Nevta User:Bearian 21:25, 21 January 2016 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of St. Xavier's School, Nevta WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
8699 6772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicolas Vandelli User:GiantSnowman 20:22, 14 August 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Nicolas Vandelli WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8700 7696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parimelazhagan Thangaraj user:Hannes 16:16, 27 March 2021 (UTC) delete """this is , he does not pass #1 (yet). In a high citation field, 2000 citations is not a lot. It is not clear how """"The person's research has had a significant impact in their scholarly discipline, broadly construed, as demonstrated by independent reliable sources."""" -- his two most cited works concern extraction methods of metabolits on certain plants, how does performing an acetone extraction on a plant and measuring several properties of it amount to a major """"significant impact""""? I think the """"Research projects and Patents"""" section says it all. The only argument I can muster is that we have Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Jones (scientist)|kept similarly weak cases recently""" Deletion of Parimelazhagan Thangaraj WP:TOOSOON||WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
8701 5301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naveen Bawa User:Adamstraw99 14:54, 26 August 2018 (UTC) delete lacks sufficient coverage and fails Deletion of Naveen Bawa WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
8702 21922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beynon Sports Surfaces User:Bakazaka 22:13, 26 March 2019 (UTC) delete as unambiguous sourced to blogs, press releases, and passing mentions. Article creator's activity focused entirely on adding material about this company and its products to the encyclopedia. By design and by policy, Wikipedia is not a platform for promotion Deletion of Beynon Sports Surfaces WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8703 17816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hero Alom User:ANKAN 07:38, 23 December 2016 (UTC) keep Alom obviously passes . USer:Pratyya Ghosh|Prattya has explained it quite clearly, so I think I don't need to repeat those words Deletion of Hero Alom WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8704 11 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All Good Things (film) User:Ravenswing 20:26, 13 May 2008 (UTC) keep If the movie is filming, it no longer violates Deletion of All Good Things (film) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8705 4864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alice of Ibelin User:Bearian 19:33, 23 July 2021 (UTC) merge to John of Lusignan. They were real people, but the subject was a |noblewoman by marriage; she was not actually queen of anything, and her father was a courtier Deletion of Alice of Ibelin WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
8706 10910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Showen User:Ohconfucius 08:41, 21 April 2011 (UTC) delete pure |Original research Deletion of Showen WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8707 6256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gonjasufi User:Ron 01:44, 30 June 2010 (UTC) merge The article is a |BLP Deletion of Gonjasufi WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
8708 6361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derrick Tribbett User:Scjessey 14:56, 13 July 2009 (UTC) delete http://www.news-press.com/article/20090707/LIFESTYLES/90707069/1013 single source found on Google News relates to appearance of VH1, but I can find nothing else of note. Fails Deletion of Derrick Tribbett WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8709 13971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dimo Nadeem User:Sir 15:17, 21 April 2014 (UTC) delete he has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Dimo Nadeem WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8710 193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zachary's Pizza User:Juliancolton 16:58, 22 July 2008 (UTC) delete violates Deletion of Zachary's Pizza WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8711 7980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conflicts of interest of President-elect Donald Trump User:Yoshiman6464 20:46, 3 December 2016 (UTC) delete Trump (as a businessman) had businesses around the world before he ran for president. Violates , especially when Trump isn't even the president Deletion of Conflicts of interest of President-elect Donald Trump WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
8712 2955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tehreek Dawat-e-Faqr User:Anupmehra 16:37, 7 January 2015 (UTC) delete WP:PROMO that fails , and has 90% copyright violation confidence-https://tools.wmflabs.org/copyvios/?lang=en&project=wikipedia&title=Tehreek_Dawat-e-Faqr Deletion of Tehreek Dawat-e-Faqr WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8713 8729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jess Perna User:Colapeninsula 11:15, 23 January 2013 (UTC) delete as failing and . No sign of notability as an artist - Perna is a commercial not a fine artist, and hasn't had gallery exhibitions, monographs, scholarly articles, reviews, etc. Insufficient coverage to meet Deletion of Jess Perna WP:GNG||WP:ARTIST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8714 10360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S. Meganathan User:AllyD 05:52, 11 August 2013 (UTC) delete References are primary; no to indicate that the subject has individual biographical notability Deletion of S. Meganathan :WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8715 11417 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John M. """"Jack"""" Sharp, Jr.""" User:RJC 01:24, 13 August 2008 (UTC) keep Clearly passes : 280 papers, former editor of ''Environmental and Engineering Geoscience'', named chair at a top research university, and the 2008-9 president of the Geological Society of America """Deletion of John M. """"Jack"""" Sharp, Jr.""" WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
8716 8897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Realize (Kelly Clarkson song) User:MER 05:02, 22 November 2006 (UTC) delete """I guess the #CBALL|title of the album says it all - """"Possibly""" Deletion of Realize (Kelly Clarkson song) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8717 19290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orphan 101 User:HitroMilanese 20:45, 8 July 2018 (UTC) delete Fails on and Deletion of Orphan 101 WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8718 15022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Surfing (Counter-Strike) (third nomination) User:Scorpiondollprincess 16:02, 31 July 2006 (UTC) delete per #Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information|Wikipedia is not an instruction manual. This is also |unverifiable and smells of |original research Deletion of Surfing (Counter-Strike) (third nomination) WP:NOT||WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8719 7972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boston, Ontario User:Mareino 22:12, 18 August 2006 (UTC) delete as per . For a verifiable settlement to be notable, it has to be the name actually recognized by the government. Here, from what I'm reading, they're calling it Waterford, not Boston Deletion of Boston, Ontario WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8720 8995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Maitland-Lewis (3rd nomination) User:Nordic 12:32, 22 February 2016 (UTC) delete per nom... appears that may have been used Deletion of Stephen Maitland-Lewis (3rd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8721 1374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arizona Wildcats football series records User:Ejgreen77 06:17, 8 January 2016 (UTC) delete """In addition to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Texas Longhorns football series records, these types of lists have discussed at some length Wikipedia talk:WikiProject College football#UB Bulls Football Records|here in Nov. 2015 and Wikipedia talk:WikiProject College football/Archive 16#Category:College football all-time series records|here in Sept. 2015. The consensus, which I support, is that we should not have such """"series results"""" lists. The real issues here are whether the lists satisfy and whether, even if the subject is notable, we ought to exercise editorial judgment under to opt against a stand-alone list/article. In this case, I favor our exercise of editorial judgment to avoid such articles for two reasons. First, I have concerns about our ability to maintain such sprawling lists, as the data at issue is massive (particularly if there are such lists for dozens and dozens of college football programs) and changes with great frequency. Second, the same data sets are published off Wikipedia by organizations (e.g., http://www.sports-reference.com/cfb/schools/texas/head-to-head.html here) that are better equipped to perform regular updates of the data. As for , it remains my view that a number of editors have incorrectly interpreted NOTSTATS and that deletionists will seek to exploit that misinterpretation. The purpose of NOTSTATS is to require context for stats and to avoid pure data dumps. If there is a statistical list that is notable and not indiscriminate, NOTSTATS suggests that any such listing should have contextual narrative text and citations. The introductory sentence of emphasizes precisely this: """"To provide encyclopedic value, data should be put in context with explanations referenced to independent sources."""" As""" Deletion of Arizona Wildcats football series records WP:LISTN||WP:PAGEDECIDE||WP:NOTSTATS||WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8722 21878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suzanne Hinn User:Hanako 17:09, 13 March 2007 (UTC) merge redirect''' to Benny Hinn.-- Fails but could redirect a few people to her husbands article, as he's the notable one Deletion of Suzanne Hinn WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8723 5887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roland Legrand User:Joe 23:05, 30 December 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |person Deletion of Roland Legrand WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8724 867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Imagineer Magazine User:RadioFan 16:18, 21 February 2010 (UTC) delete might be notable one day, might never produce another issue. Hard to tell and we dont have a |crystal ball. Today, it doesn't meet notability guidelines Deletion of Imagineer Magazine WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8725 1836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Home Sweet Home (2017 video game) User:The1337gamer 20:00, 25 January 2017 (UTC) delete Fails . As already pointed out, no hits from reliable video game source search Deletion of Home Sweet Home (2017 video game) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8726 21638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kangeiko User:Stifle 02:26, 9 January 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of Kangeiko WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
8727 3287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teresa Tease User:Horrorshowj 20:34, 23 December 2008 (UTC) delete nothing relevant found on either xbiz or avn, just trivial mention in a few film reviews. Fails to meet any either general or Deletion of Teresa Tease WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8728 16552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abhidnya Bhave User:SerChevalerie 19:48, 24 March 2020 (UTC) keep Subject meets with significant coverage by ''Times of India''. Article in its current state needs to be improved and expanded upon, though Deletion of Abhidnya Bhave WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8729 2818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Future of the NHS User:BethNaught 06:58, 27 July 2014 (UTC) delete certainly not enough coverage in RS to satisfy the GNG. I have also failed to find evidence of passing , though a Gsearch is hard as the title is also a common phrase Deletion of The Future of the NHS WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
8730 8516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bloodsucking Zombies From Outer Space User:Eusebeus 19:05, 13 September 2009 (UTC) delete as above. Fails Deletion of Bloodsucking Zombies From Outer Space WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
8731 17116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fritter roll User:Tryptofish 22:00, 27 July 2019 (UTC) merge """to fritter. I went carefully through the page history, and looked at ''every'' source that has ever been cited on the page. The sources that are no longer there do not actually include anything about fritter rolls, just assorted mentions of fritters in general. The two sources cited on the page as of when I write this comment (https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Fritter_roll&oldid=907899262) are web postings that appear to be blog-like (one of the two is explicitly someone's blog), and they are suspiciously similar to each other, such that one of them may have been written off of the other. I also did searches via the various Google sub-sites, and what keeps coming back is """"...fritter. Roll..."""". There is just enough reliable sourcing to say that the thing exists, but not enough to satisfy """ Deletion of Fritter roll WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8732 21217 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""Canon""""""" User:Keb25 19:43, 30 April 2011 (UTC) delete per """Deletion of """"Canon""""""" WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
8733 5549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dino Govoni User:Erechtheus 21:07, 1 September 2006 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Dino Govoni WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8734 4431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Afghan Television Voice of Christ User:Mrschimpf 02:09, 5 April 2020 (UTC) delete Another tele-preacher who clearly going by the nation's religious makeup, has paid to get their imported shows on TV in the region but probably has little to no viewership; definitely unfound here Deletion of Afghan Television Voice of Christ WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8735 16022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arnav Tripathy User:Pascal 11:39, 4 October 2006 (UTC) comment """First, I'd like to make it clear that what I said about rewriting is not simply """"reasonnable"""" as Mysmartmouth put it but it is a necessity per policy. Furthermore my personnal opinion is still that this guy does not meet . I did a search for Arnav Tripathy on the forum and what I come up with are trivial references to his name. In fact, he's one of the users so people often call him by his real name. The whole idea of establishing his notability through the fact that people on that forum know him is like saying that Can't sleep clown will eat me should be an article not on the Simpson's joke but on the Wikipedia admin {{user|Can't sleep, clown will eat me}}. After all, ask anyone on Wikipedia, they know him! Sure, but no one else does""" Deletion of Arnav Tripathy WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8736 727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Daly User:Sammy1339 00:30, 3 November 2014 (UTC) keep Authored several papers with hundreds of citations each. Extremely clear notability per Deletion of Martin Daly WP:SCHOLAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
8737 11313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ratchet (music genre) User:2Flows 17:00, 10 May 2014 (UTC) delete """I agree with Koala, all of the sources in the article site DJ Mustard describing his music as """"ratchet"""" (and no one else). There is no explicit statement that """"ratchet"""" is a real music genre, just a |synthesis of sources mentioning the word in various contexts""" Deletion of Ratchet (music genre) WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
8738 21460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elo hell User:Zxcvbnm 10:56, 19 August 2017 (UTC) comment """WP is not a dictionary, especially for niche gaming terms"""" Except for :Category:Competitive video game terminology? The article goes beyond just a dicdef and cites more than several reliable sources that made articles specifically about the topic, meaning it's not . I don't see the argument for delete beyond . As for suggesting it be merged, the term applies to a large number of games, not just League of Legends. It includes Overwatch, Rocket League, etc. And while it could be part of Elo rating system, there are enough references for it to be independently notable""" Deletion of Elo hell WP:NEO||WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
8739 3851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leon Fresco User:Hongkongresident 03:05, 19 November 2010 (UTC) delete A http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Leon+Fresco%22&hl=en&safe=off&rlz=1T4TSNA_enUS385US385&tbs=nws:1,ar:1&source=lnt&sa=X&ei=LejlTJngC8Gs8Ab-svG9DQ&ved=0CBEQpwU few references by the Miami Herald, but the mentions are trivial, thus not meeting the and guidelines. Article claims that the subject has won the awards, which may be true (although there's little out there to verify it), but it looks like none of them were major enough to merit any press coverage Deletion of Leon Fresco WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8740 2808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Speculation about the papal conclave, 2005 [[User_talk:Radiant!|>Radiant<]] 09:25, 7 August 2007 (UTC) delete obviously fails Deletion of Speculation about the papal conclave, 2005 WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8741 5264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of notable distant cousins of Barack Obama User:Otherlleft 03:04, 17 November 2008 (UTC) delete """even though I am an ardent defender of lists on Wikipedia. The phrase """"distant cousins"""" is incredibly vague; ''every single notable person'' that doesn't have a closer relationship with Obama is a distant cousin, and given enough time and research those relationships may very well be verifiable. I don't see how this fulfills the criteria laid out at and """ Deletion of List of notable distant cousins of Barack Obama WP:LISTS||WP:CLN Wikipedia:Lists 97
8742 18743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Breedlove User:Orangemike 21:20, 5 January 2012 (UTC) comment okay, I'll also refer you to , and Deletion of Ben Breedlove :WP:CRYSTAL||:WP:NODEADLINE||:WP:UPANDCOMING Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8743 13297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TXR2 User:MC10 01:06, 17 January 2010 (UTC) delete ndash; The author of this article violates because of http://www.newdesignworld.com/press/story/45016 this. Also, it fails |the notability test; just because the U.S. military or NASCAR uses this body cooler does not, of itself, make this product |notable Deletion of TXR2 WP:COI||WP:NN||WP:NN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
8744 10842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barry Halper User:TheOtherBob 05:35, 17 November 2007 (UTC) keep """Anybody who gets a 600+ word obituary in the New York Times is probably notable http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/20/sports/baseball/20halper.html?_r=1&oref=slogin. Similarly, USA Today covered him, as noted in the article. Articles appear in Cigar Aficianado (of all places) http://www.cigaraficionado.com/Cigar/CA_Archives/CA_Show_Article/0,2322,511,00.html, and CNN covered the auction. http://www.cnn.com/US/9909/24/halper.baseball.auction.01/index.html As noted by CNN, a gallery in the Baseball Hall of Fame is named for him. http://www.baseballhalloffame.org/news/download/HOF_Fact_Sheet.pdf. Sure, the """"pioneer in baseball memorabilia collecting"""" phrase could be written a bit better, but a quick run through a few |reliable sources with a Google search shows significant coverage, and what seems to me like clear notability""" Deletion of Barry Halper WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8745 10955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Business in Maryland User:Torchiest 14:53, 18 April 2012 (UTC) keep Clearly passes with all the sources in the article, and the other issues (original research, synthesis, peacock words) can be handled through normal editing. is also not a valid reason for deletion. If the article is too broad, parts of it can be spun off into new articles Deletion of Business in Maryland WP:GNG||WP:OTHERSTUFFDOESNTEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
8746 12727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rockette Morton User:Gaff 14:45, 9 May 2015 (UTC) keep """He recorded/performed with Captain Beefheart|Captain Beefheart & The Magic Band as well as Mallard (band), which should warrant a stand alone article per """"have demonstrated individual notability for activity independent of the band, such as solo releases."""" He has released at least one solo album. The Magic Band continues to perform internationally, without Beefheart (who died several years ago) and has a wide Facebook following. Both Mallard and the Magic Band have performed internationally. References available include the book """"LUNAR NOTES: Zoot Horn Rollo's Captain Beefheart Experience"""", which contains information about Mark Boston aka Rockette Morton. There is also listed an interview/article in Stomp & Stammer magazine. He has been performing and recording since the 1960s. I just found another interview http://louderthanwar.com/as-tribute-to-captain-beefheart-and-interview-with-the-magic-band-from-2004-by-john-robb/ here, which I can add to the article later. He is mentioned in https://books.google.com/books?id=oMWoAwAAQBAJ&pg=PA6&dq=rockette+morton&hl=en&sa=X&ei=uBxOVcfTB4qYyAT2ooDwDA&ved=0CCgQ6AEwAw#v=onepage&q=rockette%20morton&f=false this book about the album Trout Mask Replica. Quick Google Books search turns up other references, most of which are in connection to Beefheart, but given the connection with Mallard, I think it warrants a stand alone article. Definitely not a delete""" Deletion of Rockette Morton WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
8747 18070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paydin LoPachin User:Nosleep 08:18, 12 May 2009 (UTC) delete """Unequivocally fials , unless you consider """"Cheerleader #1,"""" """"Brody's Next Victim,"""" and """"Mary #2"""" to be significant roles. Pretty girl, though, and I wouldn't be too surprised if she gets notable roles later on in her career. But that's not a matter for this discussion""" Deletion of Paydin LoPachin WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
8748 5146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Capital City Green User:Jeni 08:17, 1 April 2010 (UTC) keep Easily meets the Deletion of Capital City Green WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8749 125 [[Handballverband Schleswig-Holstein]] (LAZ) Benutzer:Dk0704 15:39, 21. Apr. 2016 (CEST) keep Die Aussage des Antragstellers ''Wird aber bei den Handballverbänden nicht so gesehen. Die werden gelöscht, da diese in den Bundesverband eingearbeitet werden können, wenn sie angeblich keine besonderer Relevanz besitzen.'' von , bein Antrag zum Niedersächsischen Fußballverband legt nahe, dass es sich hier um eine |BNS-Aktion handelt, einen Rache LA, nachdem heute morgen ein Handball-Landesverband gelöscht wurde. Wir behalten regelmäßig kleine Studentenverbindungen mit z.T. angemessen Löschung von Handballverband Schleswig-Holstein Wikipedia:BNS Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
8750 15519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Designtheory User:Northamerica1000 03:11, 3 February 2015 (UTC) keep Topic passes (e.g. https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Design+theory%22&btnG=Search+Books&tbm=bks&tbo=1). Rename the disambiguation page at Design theory to Design theory (disambiguation), and then move the article to Design theory Deletion of Designtheory WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8751 6965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anurag Kumar User:Nsk92 19:21, 12 May 2008 (UTC) keep He is an elected fellow of IEEE, as confirmed herehttp://www.comsoc.org/socstr/org/operation/fellows/fellows06.html. I think that alone is enough to signify notability per . The CV on his website also says that he is a Fellow of the Indian National Science Academy (INSA), and has been a Fellow of the Indian National Academy of Engineering (INAE). That is also very good. GoogleScholarhttp://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22Anurag%20Kumar%22&hl=en&lr=&sa=N&tab=ns and GoogleBookshttp://books.google.com/books?tab=sp&sa=N&q=%22Anurag+Kumar%22&hl=en&lr= searches return pretty respectable results. Satisfies Deletion of Anurag Kumar WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
8752 20384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrian Davies User:Otr500 20:51, 19 May 2018 (UTC) delete """Fails |GNG. otability (people)|Notability is not |inherited and this subject has done nothing """"worthy of notice""" Deletion of Adrian Davies WP:GNG||WP:N||WP:INHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
8753 3004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shyanne Melendez User:Deli 21:51, 21 February 2008 (UTC) delete Without evidence of anything more than the one role mentioned in the article, the subject does not meet Deletion of Shyanne Melendez WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8754 707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric D. Snider User:Kinu 19:32, 15 September 2006 (UTC) delete ignoring the s' comments which hardly seem to cite inclusion policy; fails , no indicating notability Deletion of Eric D. Snider WP:SPA||WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
8755 3856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joey Stinson User:Jujutacular 03:59, 26 August 2009 (UTC) delete The only source is trivial (IMDB). |Non-notable Deletion of Joey Stinson WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8756 4091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myth of Tito User:Calthinus 15:49, 11 August 2020 (UTC) comment """A bit unsure here. Unlike some others, I think this is a notable topic, clearly -- {{u|WEBDuB}} is right on this. ''However'', the current page is such a POV eyesore (see below) that it is just on the edge of . If the page is to be rescued, I would like to see substantial work in (a) reducing the egregious POV-in-wikivoice on the page, (b) improving the prose which will require a fair amount of work, and (c) dealing with other aspects of the myth of Tito in historiography and elsewhere, such as the spread of the myth to the West as Tito (much like Ceaucescu later with Reagan) managed to portray himself as somehow friendly to capitalistic states, and how this led to the coalescence of the myth of Tito as a man who successfully brought quarrelling peoples together in some paradise state (side note: and that was, at the time was, though now amusingly, used as a model for the proposed One state solution for Israel/Palestine -- not in scope, but this is an aspect of the notability of the myth I would argue -- though perhaps that is the whole Bratsvo Jedinstvo myth more than Tito himself). And, of course, the legacy of that myth, as the state he built fell apart after his death. For examples of the sort of prose that is totally unacceptable on Wikipedia for how POV it is, here is one (which I ''agree'' with, but geez, this is just so unprofessional): {{tquote|In this atmosphere of faultlessness many catastrophic political moves were drawn which slowly but inevitably pushed the all country and its Communist leaders into total catastrophe and disintegration.3 The mythologized Tito and dreamland Yugoslavia never existed.8 }} Also, this {{tquote|Danko Popović emphasized that for half of the century movies and books published in Yugoslavia were used to nurture myth of Tito and distort image of Chetniks.7}} -- Popovic is a """"writer and playwright"""" so he is not even remotely , and in light of that, regardless of intention, this sentence will look to almost any informed Western reader like it was inserted just to rehabilitate the Chetniks. Last example: {{tquote|The Myth of Tito was almost unanimously accepted and parroted by western scholars}} -- no citation, and, well... ahem""" Deletion of Myth of Tito WP:TNT||WP:DUE Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
8757 16728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mras-Su River User:Gidonb 08:06, 12 September 2018 (UTC) keep Meets . I have expanded the article a bit and added a spelling variant. Nominations of major geographical features are always based in error Deletion of Mras-Su River WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
8758 13626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maad*Moiselle User:Rms125a 19:45, 28 December 2014 (UTC) delete copy and paste blatant |promotional article Deletion of Maad*Moiselle WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8759 4955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Newberger's summation formula User:THEN 17:25, 14 August 2008 (UTC) keep Ideally I would have suggested to merge it with something, but since the article deriving the relation has only been cited 13 about 17 times since 1982 it doesn't seem to warrant throwing a relationship which is apparently used very rarely in with something important (e.g. Bessel function) just as a token gesture. I added references so is OK, and as Ascidian pointed out it would seem a name change is in order. And maybe someone can figure out why it's used in plasma applications so to expand the article Deletion of Newberger's summation formula WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8760 15811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion//r/changemyview User:Deacon 15:59, 26 November 2018 (UTC) keep The NPR source is secondary and in-depth; taken with the rest this would seem to add up to a pass of . &ndash Deletion of /r/changemyview WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8761 13334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Washington Huskies starting widereceiver User:Joe 02:20, 2 December 2009 (UTC) delete Per #STATS Deletion of Washington Huskies starting widereceiver WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8762 5810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eugena Washington NONE NONE keep Background: tagged for by the nominator ({{u|Sportsfan 1234}}) with the comment Deletion of Eugena Washington WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
8763 16940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SportstalkNETWORK User:Bearcat 20:28, 6 April 2011 (UTC) delete An ''assertion'' of notability doesn't count for scratch if it can't be |verified by |reliable sources (the organization's own website doesn't count Deletion of SportstalkNETWORK WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8764 3671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nirn User:RMHED 19:00, 27 November 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Nirn WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
8765 6311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hussain Bhatti User:HitroMilanese 19:08, 16 July 2016 (UTC) delete He appeared in these two matches http://www.espncricinfo.com/ci/engine/match/491957.html and http://www.espncricinfo.com/ci/engine/match/491963.html. After doing some basic research, I conclude that these matches do not satisfy any of the 3 criteria at Deletion of Hussain Bhatti WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8766 4542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of mathematical artists user:Andrew 18:52, 7 June 2015 (UTC) keep Passes . See ''http://www.ams.org/samplings/feature-column/fcarc-art4 Mathematical artists and artist mathematicians'', for example Deletion of List of mathematical artists WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8767 12545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Cross'd Destiny User:Olaf 17:44, 15 August 2008 (UTC) keep A google search for the title together with 'webcomic' and 'award' gives http://www.ccawards.com/2005.htm this, which says the comic won an award in the 2005 Web Cartoonists' Choice Awards. Therefore it satisfies Deletion of Star Cross'd Destiny WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
8768 72 [[Liste von Medien mit ahoi-Wörtern im Titel ]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:KnightMove NONE delete Volle Zustimmung zum Antragsteller. Nach diesem Vorbild könnten wir zu jedem Wort (oder sei es nur jedes relevante) eine Liste mit entsprechenden Titeln anlegen - natürlich mit den damit verbundenen, multiplen Redundanzen. Das ist Aufgabe einer entsprechenden Datenbank mit Suchfunktion - und das |ist Wikipedia nicht Löschung von Liste von Medien mit ahoi-Wörtern im Titel Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8769 12098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Larson (2nd nomination) User:Davewild 13:08, 15 June 2008 (UTC) keep She has received plenty of significant coverage in reliable sources establishing notability per . This coverage is still continuing now - such as http://www.eonline.com/uberblog/marc_malkin/b142410_sarah_larsons_post-clooney_life.html this and http://www.ahlanlive.com/3793-clooneys-ex-lands-modeling-contract this which shows she has been signed up as a model by the fashion designer Christian Audigier. She is thus notable for the coverage in reliable sources and for more than one thing so not a Deletion of Sarah Larson (2nd nomination) WP:BIO||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
8770 20688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lauren Burk User:Malik 03:15, 9 March 2008 (UTC) delete For all the above reasons. Also, this y article's creator and principle editor is an Wikipedia:Suspected sock puppets/Auno3 (4th)|alleged sockpuppet of an editor whose interests include pretty white women killed by Black men Deletion of Lauren Burk WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
8771 16460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tottenham Hotspur F.C. 3–4 Manchester City F.C. User:Falastur2 19:19, 9 August 2010 (UTC) keep Angelo, with all due respect you started a debate on whether to remove these games, got a few responses over the course of '''two hours''' then made this AfD. If you want to base your decision on the consensus in that debate then you moved far too quickly - two hours just doesn't give time for people to respond, and true to form, the debate has now received a raft of opinions supporting keeping these articles. If you are simply proposing deletion on your own terms, then I fall back on the argument that what game is notable has not been defined properly by ootball and thus I would argue that their notability is set out by the fact that these are two of the more famous individual matches in English football history and they aren't even cup finals to boot. More detail on the debate page you linked above Deletion of Tottenham Hotspur F.C. 3–4 Manchester City F.C. WP:F Wikipedia:Non-free content 99
8772 641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marc Houalla User:Guillaume2303 19:32, 7 June 2012 (UTC) keep Highest elected position at a major academic institution. Article needs cleanup to conform to English usage (tense, for example) and Deletion of Marc Houalla WP:MOS Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
8773 18163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of 8-bit Atari game music User:IslaySolomon 15:50, 26 January 2007 (UTC) delete WP:V|Unverified, #IINFO|unmaintainable, |POV |OR |listcruft Deletion of List of 8-bit Atari game music WP:NOT||WP:POV||WP:OR||WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8774 21899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mahima Bakshi User:ह 07:00, 7 March 2015 (UTC) comment The given references in article are not reliable sources. We need mention of her in mainstream newspapers like TOI, Hindustan Times, The Hindu, etc. Please see what is counted as reliable source at Deletion of Mahima Bakshi WP:IRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8775 13307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joost de Valk (2nd nomination) User:Lightburst 02:30, 7 August 2020 (UTC) comment The article was made live on July 4, 2020 and nominated for deletion June 5, 2020. Honestly, I had hoped to have more time to let the article breath - Many times the start of an article is not all that is available and fleshing out articles in non-English media outlets is somewhat more difficult. I did some work today, looking for sources. I did not include all of the various announcements where de Valk was the keynote speaker at conferences. I have to look at another article now.{{pb}}I do not think any of the items below are in the article yet.{{pb}}He is referred to as an expert by these outlets. Meeting #2 and to a lesser degree #1{{pb}}The Guardian hired SEO Expert Joost De Valk to https://www.theguardian.com/info/developer-blog/2014/feb/18/how-the-guardian-successfully-moved-domain?fbclid=IwAR2CXzH0Lkht3J6XvKsNofMntkeU40VROSdvtpSIPK_Sx8Lw2wKUIj9Gxx8 move their domain name. In 2014 https://torquemag.io/2014/11/wordpress-community-shares-thoughts-microsofts-open-source-news/ Torgue Magazine quotes de Valk in their article about Microsoft. In 2017 The Guardian also called on de Valk as an expert in https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/oct/14/google-desktop-search-out-of-date-mobile?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other&fbclid=IwAR3ffS7MbI4IvMRQljkwqPHSfu9zfyRfYXN_crR6mpl3Mfhg0JXcodgqbWs this article about Google. In 2016 Business Insider quoted de Valk in a https://www.businessinsider.nl/google-algorithm-change-fake-news-rankbrain-2016-12/?fbclid=IwAR0t3HJP2DZEG78y5z_YlHl6mLVj_fGYDCi3saMPEFCSgmYcZQ5DtpDBKAw news article about a new Google algorithm.{{pb}}These other pieces are much less worthy but I present them here as things I came across researching. In 2010 this is Kind of a bloggy looking site - State of Digital. I am https://www.stateofdigital.com/summer-interview-with-joost-de-valk/ posting it here because 2010 was the year he started Yoast. In 2011 the same website covers de Valk https://www.stateofdigital.com/ses-amsterdam-search-is-changing-wake-up-and-get-to-work/ in an article about search. He is also https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=nl&u=https://www.yellowwalnut.nl/blog/ondernemer-van-de-week-joost-de-valk/&prev=search&pto=aue interviewed here (english translation) in a 2014 Yellow walnut|Yellow Walnut piece. (a bit bloggy also) And finally, in 2018 his hometown newspaper Wijchen News Netherlands https://wijchen.nieuws.nl/nieuws/20181012/schoolschaatsen-wijchen-schaatst-yoast/ published a short story quoting de Valk about sponsoring a free day of ice skating. I can keep looking if the clock does not run out Deletion of Joost de Valk (2nd nomination) WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8776 11856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Long Way Up User:MichaelQSchmidt 00:32, 2 December 2010 (UTC) delete as still being for a Wikipedia article. Nice that this film has been spoken of since 2007,http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Charley+Boorman%22%2C+%22Long+Way+Up%22&sourceid=ie7&rls=com.microsoft:en-US&ie=utf8&oe=utf8 but it seems no closer to filming than it was three years ago and fails as an exception to Deletion of Long Way Up WP:TOOSOON||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
8777 2564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Golden Stars International User:Joe 22:05, 14 September 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |album Deletion of Golden Stars International WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8778 10248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Felipe Nunes User:Jenks24 05:58, 13 February 2011 (UTC) delete Couldn't find any significant coverage myself and it appears Jogurney couldn't either. Doesn't meet or Deletion of Felipe Nunes WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8779 2156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avalon Motor Park User:B 14:01, 6 February 2012 (UTC) comment I've undone the redirection because it will disrupt this running discussion and you ''have'' to move the page history as well. I have restored the content of the original article, and have tagged the new one for deletion under #A10|A10 Deletion of Avalon Motor Park WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
8780 11888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leigh Goedecke User:Kinu 06:01, 31 July 2006 (UTC) delete obvious Deletion of Leigh Goedecke WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
8781 15449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdullah Azam Khan (2nd nomination) User:SalmanZ 21:27, 29 July 2019 (UTC) keep As a legislature of a state of India passes Deletion of Abdullah Azam Khan (2nd nomination) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8782 7692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sony Ziris User:Hrafn 17:01, 30 May 2011 (UTC) delete """that twelve sources are required to reference only 5 sentences argues strongly that depth of coverage is lacking. Likewise most of what little coverage there is appears to be limited to fairly specialised trade mags (cf requirement that """"at least some of these works serving a general audience""" Deletion of Sony Ziris WP:NBOOKS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8783 12968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BOL News User:Lemongirl942 10:39, 2 October 2016 (UTC) merge per . Not every news channel is notable. We consider the transmission history, presentation of original content as well as the references in third party sources. The sources need to be specifically about the channel itself and cannot inherit notability from the parent organisation. The controversy here is about the parent organisation and it cannot help to establish notability. I suggest a redirect here as it is clearly not independently notable Deletion of BOL News WP:INHERITORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8784 17047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amtech Systems User:Smartse 19:28, 13 March 2014 (UTC) delete I searched factiva and google books but could only find brief mentions, press releases and routine financial information. That isn't sufficient to meet Deletion of Amtech Systems WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8785 6800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ricky Shivers User:Jakejr 21:11, 23 December 2012 (UTC) delete With no fights for a top tier MMA organization, he obviously fails Deletion of Ricky Shivers WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
8786 17570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Dickson (2nd nomination) [[User:{{{User|ERcheck}}}|{{{User|ERcheck}}}]] ([[User talk:{{{User|ERcheck}}}|talk]]) 04:17, 16 December 2007 (UTC) delete mdash; Unreferenced = does not meet ; |Notability not established. &mdash Deletion of Andrew Dickson (2nd nomination) WP:VERIFY||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8787 3992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ecco II: Sentinels of the Universe User:Randomran 22:00, 22 August 2008 (UTC) delete unverifiable, non-notable, Deletion of Ecco II: Sentinels of the Universe WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8788 5570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sebastian Ciceri User:Lukeno94 09:36, 5 March 2014 (UTC) delete As per nom. Fails and . No substantial coverage in Deletion of Sebastian Ciceri WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8789 7065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John G. McCaskey User:TruthbringerToronto 16:49, 15 November 2006 (UTC) keep The list of references strongly suggests that he is the subject of multiple independent non-trivial publications, and hence passes . The fact that he has been dead for many years doesn't detract from his notability Deletion of John G. McCaskey WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8790 13632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Jones (political consultant) User:Bearian 16:03, 6 August 2020 (UTC) delete per nom and . He's worked for Black Rock, a political consulting firm, which in turn has worked for a bunch of campaigns Deletion of Brian Jones (political consultant) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8791 8820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luon User:Mark 23:42, 2 April 2014 (UTC) delete As far as I can tell, the concept of a ''luon'', an alternative name for a kind of plasmon, only appears in the one cited paper. The paper is a reliable source, per , but is a primary source. According to notability guidelines , a topic needs multiple, in-depth, secondary reliable sources that are independent of the creator. As a paper that was published just 2 weeks ago, this is a case of ; not been enough time has elapsed for independent reliable sources to develop, i.e., review papers, news stories from reputable publishers, etc. Without multiple RS, this article fails notability guidelines. An alternative to deletion would be to userfy the article Deletion of Luon WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8792 15641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gangnam Style phenomenon User:Alan 00:51, 3 December 2012 (UTC) delete per nom and Sue Rangel and Deletion of Gangnam Style phenomenon WP:RECENTISM Wikipedia:Recentism 10
8793 17225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nilesh Soni User:Peacemaker67 09:38, 20 May 2017 (UTC) delete per and lack of significant coverage in reliable sources to meet the GNG. Certainly doesn't meet Deletion of Nilesh Soni WP:NOTMEMORIAL||WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8794 9082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tympaki Airport User:Oakshade 22:28, 4 December 2008 (UTC) keep Not only are airports generally considered notable as indicated in (I've only seen the smallest of unpaved airstrips get deleted), but it's an air force base. To my knowledge we've never deleted an American or British air force base, past or present, and deleting non-American/British ones might appear as a case of Wikipedia:WikiProject Countering systemic bias|systemic bias. It's also Greece's most southerly airfield.http://www.avsim.com/greece/hvacc/scenery/fs200x/grairfields.htm This is very significant as it's the closest to Egypt and Lybia (countries that haven't been the most friendly to Greece) and its relative proximity to Cyprus, an island of extremely contentious sovereignty disputes between Greece and Turkey Deletion of Tympaki Airport WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
8795 2552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Underwater security User:Jamesontai 04:45, 31 July 2008 (UTC) delete as . I can see a version of this article stripped off of the , but it wouldn't be more than half a sentence remaining nor would it be notable Deletion of Underwater security WP:OR||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8796 452 [[Jörg-Michael Müller]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers 20:53, 2. Aug. 2012 (CEST) delete Kasten|1=. Keine ausreichende Relevanz nach |unseren Kriterien und den WP:RBK|Richtlinien Bildende Kunst dargestellt. Gruß Löschung von Jörg-Michael Müller Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
8797 2727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dark Galaxy (computer game) User:Ace 11:24, 2 August 2006 (UTC) comment I'm pretty sure that is only for web sites, not web-based games. This still needs to assert notability, though Deletion of Dark Galaxy (computer game) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
8798 13847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Academic job market User:LibStar 04:24, 1 June 2009 (UTC) delete the article is , and is not a well referenced article with third party sources on the subject Deletion of Academic job market WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8799 19498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexis Blue (2nd nomination) User:Franciscrot 01:53, 25 December 2008 (UTC) keep """Borderline notable, & seems a wee bit over-vigilant to me. Could do with a dose of NPOV (""""insightful"""" lyrics etc""" Deletion of Alexis Blue (2nd nomination) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
8800 5510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manchester Rangers User:K 23:34, 1 April 2017 (UTC) delete a amateur club; no sources listed nor found to establish notability. What sources are there are local; not enough to meet Deletion of Manchester Rangers WP:AUD Wikipedia:Notability 77
8801 14099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Aronson Award for Social Justice Journalism User:Accotink2 23:33, 16 July 2010 (UTC) comment """5 sentences in ''Time'' doesn't strike me as """"Significant coverage"""" per , you would agree that the others lack even that""" Deletion of James Aronson Award for Social Justice Journalism WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8802 5265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Polypop User:Omtay38 20:17, 12 July 2007 (UTC) delete and perhaps Deletion of Polypop WP:BJAODN Wikipedia:Silly Things 72
8803 113 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Sanat Deliorman Kullanıcı:efe7961efe7961 19.42, 6 Ağustos 2021 (UTC) delete Madde |KD değil Sanat Deliorman'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
8804 18036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farswal (2nd nomination) User:Falcon 05:37, 7 October 2016 (UTC) delete The only thing I can find about this is extremely similar text http://www.jatland.com/home/Farswal from another wiki, and it is referenced there, but equally terse. It clearly fails . As an aside, {{ping|Boleyn}}, why not make a single AfD disussion for each of these articles, or use Deletion of Farswal (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:PROD Wikipedia:Notability 77
8805 9495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Píča User:LinaMishima 04:32, 10 August 2006 (UTC) keep Wikipedia has a large number of systematic biases. Although not listed on , one of those is that articles on english-as-first-language countries are more common. The above is a bad reason to nominate the article, as there are many articles about subjects that have no interest to those outside of the USA (or the UK, for that matter Deletion of Píča WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
8806 13203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andi Ali User:5 18:17, 23 June 2012 (UTC) delete I have googled the author and can't see them meeting notability guidelines Deletion of Andi Ali WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
8807 15242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Markus Eliance User:Evalpor 01:50, 4 March 2010 (UTC) delete Non-notable per and . Self-promotional, most likely written, at least in part, by subject himself Deletion of Markus Eliance WP:BIO||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8808 4933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuririn User:Sesshomaru 21:47, 30 October 2007 (UTC) comment """doesn't matter how many keeps this page gets. Per policy, """"''Editors should provide a reliable source for quotations and for any material that is challenged or is likely to be challenged, or it may be removed""" Deletion of Kuririn WP:VERIFY Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8809 5565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LouišP Ltd User:HighKing 21:24, 5 February 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and . Topic does not appear notable Deletion of LouišP Ltd WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8810 1668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Divided Skies (2nd nomination) User:Tucoxn 06:13, 6 February 2017 (UTC) delete Does not meet because of a lack of significant coverage in reliable sources, even after a search Deletion of Divided Skies (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8811 4299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of QI episodes User:Paul 15:58, 7 September 2013 (UTC) keep Hang on a minute, don't we list all the HIGNFY episodes, who appeared, who won, etc? And don't we recap episode storylines in countless drama series in a similar way to what is done here? I don't personally think is a valid reason to delete here. That would only apply if someone decided to make an article for every single episode, rather than for each series. I tend to agree that comparing this to shows such as Deal or No Deal is misleading Deletion of List of QI episodes WP:EPISODE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
8812 6347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lists of rulers of Kenya User:Phil 18:07, 8 November 2010 (UTC) keep A useful navigational aid to help our readers find what they are looking for. (And, please, before making a |vague wave towards , read that essay to see what it actually says Deletion of Lists of rulers of Kenya WP:USEFUL||WP:vague wave Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8813 9234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Garcia User:Charlene 09:28, 3 June 2007 (UTC) delete Hasn't even stood next to the coffee maker yet. Fails Deletion of James Garcia WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8814 13917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cooliris User:RHaworth 17:09, 20 January 2008 (UTC) comment """neutral. Normally I would say """"delete - spam for non-notable product"""". But special:contributions/Eric4200|the nominator's contribution history indicates an account with the |single purpose of deleting the article""" Deletion of Cooliris WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
8815 10624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018-19 Randhir Verma Under-19 Bihar Championship User:Narky 15:51, 3 October 2018 (UTC) delete Fails to meet any of the requirements detailed in . (And it isn't a First-class cricket|first-class competition, which is what the article said before I came across it Deletion of 2018-19 Randhir Verma Under-19 Bihar Championship WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8816 20341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shooting of David Douglas User:MSJapan 01:37, 5 July 2016 (UTC) comment """ping|Autarch}}: Even with the addition of sources, there is still a problem, because you are now asserting notability for the individual via an an article on an event. This a common conflation - notability for an event is not notability of a person. If the event doesn't meet , then the event is not notable, and it largely doesn't matter ''who'' was involved in it, because applies. If instead. you want to indicate that the ''victim'' is notable, then we need to address and , which is a different discussion entirely. At this point, we are concerned with an article that says """"a career criminal was possibly shot due to his criminal career,"""" and I don't particularly think that's notable in ''any'' country. Moreover, the coverage has to be greater than - the people you cited as famous criminals are famous because they killed dozens of people and oversaw illegal empires that raked in millions. Shooting a cop and drug possession and almost getting killed once are, honestly, parr for the course. Being PIRA? If there were six folks in it, sure, but there were a lot more than six folks in it, and they don't all get articles for that, again per . So just be aware of all that""" Deletion of Shooting of David Douglas WP:EVENT||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:CRIME||WP:BIO||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
8817 21824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philippine National Heroes User:Whstchy 20:06, 31 May 2007 (UTC) delete reeks of , and agreed, major edit war bait Deletion of Philippine National Heroes WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8818 12316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agent K User:Canley 00:32, 14 September 2008 (UTC) keep Provides (minimal) real-world context as suggested by Deletion of Agent K WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
8819 11096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhlenberg Park, Pennsylvania User:Yilloslime 20:52, 4 April 2020 (UTC) delete Fails the clear wording of , and is no where remotely close to passing Deletion of Muhlenberg Park, Pennsylvania WP:GEOLAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8820 18199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tumi Aru Moi User:Spiderone 19:16, 19 September 2020 (UTC) delete due to concerns around and Deletion of Tumi Aru Moi WP:GNG||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
8821 9922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Family tree of The Phantom User:MacGyverMagic 23:35, 4 November 2008 (UTC) delete Unless one of the comics specifically printed this tree, it is synthesised and therefore |original research Deletion of Family tree of The Phantom WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8822 5440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cultured resonance User:Jreferee NONE delete No indications that this term is notable. Only two sources cited, both the work of one author. The current article text says that the term was first used in 2010. Google searches return only the works of this author, and completely unrelated hits, largely describing a tone of voice. This is a non-notable neologism at best, and as per does not belong here, at worst it is attempted promotion. I agree with Deletion of Cultured resonance WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8823 5450 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aja Watkins a.k.a """"Beautiful""""""" User:Kinu 04:25, 21 December 2006 (UTC) delete """a.k.a """"fails """". Possibly a speedy candidate due to the repeated blanking by the author (although I've restored the article, with the AfD template, per procedure""" """Deletion of Aja Watkins a.k.a """"Beautiful""""""" WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8824 14837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethnic nepotism User:Bearian 22:35, 19 August 2020 (UTC) merge with a possible smerge, per above and Deletion of Ethnic nepotism WP:FORK Wikipedia:Mirrors and forks 46
8825 20780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of victims of the Virginia Tech massacre User:FreeKresge 02:21, 20 April 2007 (UTC) delete This is a clear violation of . I understand and sympathize with those who with to honor the victims, but Wikipedia is not the place to do so. I prefer a merge to the Virginia Tech massacre|main article over a keep, but I do not believe that the list currently in the main article is necessary Deletion of List of victims of the Virginia Tech massacre WP:MEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8826 3546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Carabalí User:Hmlarson 04:11, 12 February 2018 (UTC) keep per a super-easy Google News search. Article could use expansion and improved referencing, not deletion per Deletion of Omar Carabalí WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
8827 9888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boycott of The Ingraham Angle User:E 21:45, 12 April 2018 (UTC) merge and merge to a summarized version at The Ingraham Angle. Rampant Deletion of Boycott of The Ingraham Angle WP:RECENTISM Wikipedia:Recentism 10
8828 1485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wellborn, Texas User:Pastor 02:08, 4 July 2009 (UTC) keep Meets standards Deletion of Wellborn, Texas WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8829 11186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Mary's Catholic College, Casino User:SportingFlyer 02:20, 1 March 2021 (UTC) keep looks like it passes just based on the sources currently in the article Deletion of St. Mary's Catholic College, Casino WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8830 18801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gentlemen's Chess User:Smile 21:10, 17 October 2008 (UTC) delete the plea at Talk:Gentlemen's Chess says it all! Fails . After the inevitable deletion it should also be removed from Chess variant Deletion of Gentlemen's Chess WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8831 18802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ninja (singer) (2nd nomination) [[User talk:Serial Number 54129|SERIAL]][[Special:contributions/Serial Number 54129|'''#''']] 16:41, 4 May 2020 (UTC) delete I have struck the sock !vote; I personally do not see how the available coverage meets either or Deletion of Ninja (singer) (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8832 2696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gabriel J. Chin User:Nsk92 03:41, 16 July 2008 (UTC) keep The newscoverage of him is fairly substantial and it is not limited to the McCain episode. There are also news-stories from 2002-2004 (see the GoogleNews results above). GoogleBooks results are also substantial http://books.google.com/books?q=%22Gabriel+J.+Chin%22+&btnG=Search+Books - 104 hits. Also, he holds a named chair appointment at the University of Arizona (Chester H. Smith Professor of Law). Having a named chair appointment at a major university is a very reliable indicator of academic notability. Passes Deletion of Gabriel J. Chin WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8833 13371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uh-Oh! (film) User:Bovineboy2008 13:22, 6 January 2019 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Uh-Oh! (film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
8834 10068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Midnightbox.com NONE NONE delete obvious spam. Website owners used sockpuppets and meatpuppets to create this article by offering rewards on their forum for this entry and are now doing the same to try to save this article. This entry is a blatant attempt to self promote another of their wesites and should be deleted. See 10:34, 17 March 2006 Deletion of Midnightbox.com WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
8835 16123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/South Otago User:SportingFlyer 06:20, 1 February 2020 (UTC) keep """Needs sources, but it's clearly the name of a region that will pass if we can get it there. This isn't an """"official"""" region but rather is the name the region is generally known by. The Otago Daily Times even has a South Otago section. https://www.odt.co.nz/regions/south-otago""" Deletion of South Otago WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8836 14566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sue Page (2nd nomination) User:ESkog 03:22, 6 January 2008 (UTC) comment Given that the previous result was a speedy delete, I don't think it's eligible for #G4 speedy deletion as recreation of deleted material. And Deletion of Sue Page (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
8837 15089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abolitionism (bioethics) User:Empamazing 15:59, 17 April 2016 (UTC) keep I feel this is being treated with an unfairly high standard of . Doesn't seem /PS because (a) it's treated seriously by philosophical authorities, (b) it doesn't seem to oppose any sort of scientific consensus Deletion of Abolitionism (bioethics) WP:NOTABILITY||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8838 11593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ron Bell (politician) User:SunCreator 15:50, 21 April 2009 (UTC) delete As this stage, notability to pass is not present Deletion of Ron Bell (politician) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8839 6286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IMerit (2nd nomination) User:nearlyevil665 20:00, 13 April 2021 (UTC) delete I nominated this a few weeks back but pulled the nomination after realizing the references weren't as bad as I thought. Having read that this was a byproduct of I say burn it down and let someone write it from scratch from a neutral point of view Deletion of IMerit (2nd nomination) WP:UPE Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
8840 3149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Similarities between the Bible and the Qur'an (2 nomination) User:Masaruemoto 04:36, 16 October 2007 (UTC) delete This is , even if the conclusions are correct. This needs to have reliable sources discussing these similarities, which was mentioned by several people in the previous AFD, but 10 months later those sources haven't been added Deletion of Similarities between the Bible and the Qur'an (2 nomination) WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
8841 3848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nedim Malicbegovic (2nd nomination) User:Thincat 23:46, 24 November 2015 (UTC) delete """because there is no demonstration of our notability guidelines being met. However, I'd like to put in a word for Adam who would be right to remove an A7 CSD if he genuinely believed there was an indication of importance or significance. I think the advice he has been given on his talk page is good but it should be regarded as advice, not instruction. Administrators (and old-timers like me) get things wrong sometimes. Some administrators do not understand that #A7 is not a notability criterion and really far too many do not understand that #G4 only applies to """"substantially identical"""" articles or versions. For me, ill-judged notability AFD nominations are generally a worse problem than CSD removals""" Deletion of Nedim Malicbegovic (2nd nomination) WP:CSD||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
8842 19269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhen Escaño User:Ultraexactzz 21:17, 7 March 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. In this case, the |usual caveats apply; she's a young actress, and might end up with enough notable roles to justify an article someday. But not just yet Deletion of Rhen Escaño WP:USUAL Wikipedia:Usual caveats 41
8843 10836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Afghanistan International Bank User:BabbaQ 14:50, 25 April 2015 (UTC) keep meets Deletion of Afghanistan International Bank WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8844 149 [[Soundcheck (Buch)]] (LAE) Benutzer:Exoport 07:49, 7. Sep. 2013 (CEST) keep kasten|Die Löschung wurde bereits einmal disktuiert, und Relevanz beschieden. Damit ist eine erneute Relevanz-LD überflüssig. Rezensionen sind vorhanden, dabei sind zwei im Artikel verlinkt, weitere finden sich z.B. http://www.faz.net/aktuell/feuilleton/buecher/rezension-sachbuch-hinweis-11303616.html in der FAZ. Der Autor ist relevant, das Buch in einem regulären Verlag erschienen, damit sind auch die #Literarische_Einzelwerke erfüllt. Ich mache hier Löschung von Soundcheck (Buch) Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
8845 17577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marijuana (word) User:Colapeninsula 17:29, 20 May 2015 (UTC) merge """as above: per , a Wikipedia article is about """"a person, or a people, a concept, a place, an event, a thing"""" not about a word. Alternative names of the drug extracted from Cannabis sativa belong in the article cannabis (drug""" Deletion of Marijuana (word) WP:NOTDICT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
8846 14821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miladin Vujošević User:Otapka 19:11, 9 March 2020 (UTC) keep Meets by multiple reliable and verifiable sources of national and regional media discussing the player and his career progress. Regarding - he participates in professional teams, although 2. Liga (Slovakia) is currently unrecognised as fully-pro by . May be fit for reconsideration. Also, the team is condending promotion to pro Slovak Super Liga Deletion of Miladin Vujošević :WP:NFOOTY||:WP:GNG||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8847 12189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ceziah Strickland User:RHaworth 08:36, 26 October 2011 (UTC) delete Notability is |not inherited. &mdash Deletion of Ceziah Strickland WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8848 4703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emily L. Spratt (2nd nomination) User:Bakazaka 15:21, 31 July 2018 (UTC) delete per thorough nom and previous discussions. Fails , and lacks an award, position, or impact that would pass Deletion of Emily L. Spratt (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
8849 1901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tønder concentration camp User:JohnCD 21:43, 11 April 2013 (UTC) delete """as failing unless some reliable source can be found. The Danish article :da:Koncentrationslejr mentions only Horserød and Frøslev. A search for """"Tønder koncentrationslejr"""" produced nothing relevant - one possible turned out to be about a resister from Tønder who was sent to a camp in Germany. Even if there was a camp of some kind at Tønder, what is described sounds like a transit camp rather than a concentration camp as that term is normally understood""" Deletion of Tønder concentration camp WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8850 14643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bulgarians in Albania User:Debate 12:37, 27 May 2008 (UTC) keep The primary objection here seems to be |POV, which is a content issue and not a criteria for deletion. There's a very obvious, simmering issue here of ethnic and national rivalry which is very notable in its own right. The fact that this article doesn't yet discuss this tension, or mention alternative views, is a good opportunity to e Bold and add that information Deletion of Bulgarians in Albania WP:POV||WP:B Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
8851 5849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Kids' Cookery School User:HighKing 12:27, 12 August 2019 (UTC) comment in response to the two Keep !votes above. This article is about the business, not about the founder - please read . The article contains more references but nothing has changes except the volume. Not a single one of the references that have been added meet the criteria for establishing notability - please read and especially ORGIND and CORPDEPTH. For example, https://www.telegraph.co.uk/foodanddrink/4815265/We-can-all-go-to-work-on-an-egg.html this Telegraph reference is classic churnalism and does not contain any Independent Content whatsoever, fails . Similarly the https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/life/features/giving-your-kids-a-taste-for-cookery-is-teaching-a-skill-for-life-35170701.html Belfast Telegraph reference contains quotations from Hamilton-Fairley and mentions the school as part of her title as Chief Executive. |Notability is not inherited. Article fails . The https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/fiona-hamiltonfairley/kids-cooking_b_4890244.html Huff Post reference is a PRIMARY source, published by Hamilton-Fairley and fails . The mention in https://www.deliciousmagazine.co.uk/kids-cookery-classes/ Delicious Magazine is part of a list of places that provide classes, fails and . The https://www.theguardian.com/society/2005/apr/12/lottery Guardian reference is marginally better but also fails Deletion of The Kids' Cookery School WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:NCORP||WP:ORGIND||WP:NOTINHERIT||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8852 6359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Kirksey User:Onebravemonkey 19:46, 22 October 2008 (UTC) delete for failing to |verify that the subject is notable, specifically with regard to . Having searched a fair bit I'm still drawing nothing but co-authorship and random mentions... neither of which really add up to much. Incidentally, the nominating editor has followed the |prodding process to the letter... I'm not too impressed with some of the criticism regarding that Deletion of Lee Kirksey WP:V||WP:PROF||WP:PROD Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8853 12262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PAOK Sports Center User:Sir 03:42, 13 January 2014 (UTC) delete per nom. There is no indication this article meets Deletion of PAOK Sports Center WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8854 9189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Highland Lake (Warren Center, Pennsylvania) User:Clarityfiend 12:46, 17 January 2013 (UTC) delete or '''redirect''' and add to List of lakes in Pennsylvania. It's on the USGS map (upper right corner)http://usgwarchives.org/maps/pa/county/bradfo/usgs/bradfolg.jpg, but none of the history is particularly notable or referenced at all, and location and altitude don't satisfy Deletion of Highland Lake (Warren Center, Pennsylvania) WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
8855 21844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Icebreaker International User:Northamerica1000 12:17, 24 February 2016 (UTC) keep Meets per a review of available sources Deletion of Icebreaker International WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8856 2522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kristin Fairlie User:SL93 01:30, 22 March 2017 (UTC) keep Per . She has had several significant roles in notable television shows and movies. Her significant roles, such as in Little Bear, can easily be found by just searching. A couple of seconds alone verified https://books.google.com/books?id=1N4Okbxfz5YC&pg=PA147&dq=%22Kristin+Fairlie%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi32Y6t-ujSAhUH12MKHcpbDZ0Q6AEIMDAE#v=onepage&q=%22Kristin%20Fairlie%22&f=false her role as Little Bear Deletion of Kristin Fairlie WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8857 16360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmed Ghanem User:Bearcat 23:36, 25 January 2015 (UTC) delete as badly written and poorly sourced mess — the question of whether he has the degree of notability required to qualify for a Wikipedia article is so utterly impossible to answer from the way this article is written that applies ''regardless'' of his eligibility or lack thereof. No prejudice against recreation in the future if somebody without a |conflict of interest can write and source a properly encyclopedic version which makes a proper claim of notability Deletion of Ahmed Ghanem WP:NUKEANDPAVE||WP:COI Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
8858 21403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Solidarity Party User:Steve 04:51, 30 July 2016 (UTC) comment I agree that Lawrence King's posted sources are not sufficient for GNG or ORG. I also agree they are passing mentions, or blogs that are not reliable sources, or connected to this topic, and therefore it lacks independent coverage. I think this article on Wikipedia is a case of . This organization is headed in the right direction for the decade of the 2010s by establishing a social media presence and a presence on the web. Unfortunately it is not noteworthy at this time. My Ivote (see above) is still the same. Also, this party actually appears to be one of many third choice parties - http://www.uselections.com/parties.htm - but it has not distinguished itself in the press as yet Deletion of American Solidarity Party WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
8859 17258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Ninja (2009 film) User:Erik 21:21, 28 October 2008 (UTC) delete per and agree with nominator about recreation. Creation of this article was too much of a knee-jerk after announcement of this planned film; if it does begin, never a guarantee in the film industry, recreate the article Deletion of The Ninja (2009 film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
8860 5946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spliff politics User:HisSpaceResearch 17:00, 22 June 2007 (UTC) comment I don't smoke pot myself and I have heard of this concept, the 'politics' of smoking cannabis, from a friend of mine who does. This may actually be notable, but it's that's the problem here. If we could try Googling for sources that may be helpful but probably not due to likely lack of Deletion of Spliff politics WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8861 1852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhapsody in Drew (2nd nomination) User:HighwayCello 16:43, 28 June 2006 (UTC) keep isn't this a breach of Deletion of Rhapsody in Drew (2nd nomination) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
8862 18038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alistair Slowe User:Argyle 01:50, 4 January 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Alistair Slowe WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8863 3324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Baggs User:Rorshacma 17:53, 5 June 2012 (UTC) delete Even if the company that this individual became CEO of (extremely recently, too, it seems) is notable itself, notability is . And there are no sources to show that this individual has any independent notability of his own Deletion of Michael Baggs WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8864 17058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zach Jemiola User:SportingFlyer 02:56, 30 April 2018 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Zach Jemiola WP:NBASEBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8865 11415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scottevest User:John 19:54, 16 December 2011 (UTC) keep needs more non-PR sources, but I think is ''just'' met Deletion of Scottevest WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8866 19268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of films considered the best (2nd nomination) User:Betty 21:46, 15 March 2016 (UTC) keep """I fail to see what the """"conflict of interest"""" is. Our standard policies should avert any serious problems with any single poll receiving coverage (I have just cut back some of the Sight & Sound stuff that was swamping the article). The article surveys an overwhelming number of different polls utilising many different methodologies, so the debate regarding which films are the greatest has been engaged in at every level (critics, the industry itself, audiences etc) and thus satisfying notability without any shadow of a doubt. While not particularly pretty in some ways I think this article represents Wikipedia at its best i.e. bringing together a huge amount of information and making it digestible for layman readers""" Deletion of List of films considered the best (2nd nomination) WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
8867 5051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shangwen Fang (2nd nomination) User:Broadweighbabe 03:35, 20 March 2009 (UTC) delete per WP:BLP1E and /CA Deletion of Shangwen Fang (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8868 7821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faisal Babu User:Msp7com NONE keep This article is in the category of the Wikipedia guidelines It seems that. With only 3 seats in the Indian House, it will not be a political party. The party is a major component of the Assembly in the South Indian states of Kerala & Tamil Nadu. Now of the youth wing (Muslim Youth League) of the National Party And office as National General Secretary He is also a former National Vice President. As such, this article is a public speaker and can be considered in that category as well Deletion of Faisal Babu WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8869 8270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/References and Similarities within Pirates of the Caribbean Films User:Fordmadoxfraud 04:16, 2 June 2007 (UTC) delete as , without any kooky pirate jargon Deletion of References and Similarities within Pirates of the Caribbean Films WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8870 10611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Munir Hussain (business) User:Ironholds 19:28, 30 December 2009 (UTC) delete """fairly obviously . """"single event"""" can refer to a single chain of events, not just a moment; the fact that there is other crap happening ''around'' a single event does not change its nature""" Deletion of Munir Hussain (business) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
8871 12795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Obsession (Shayne Ward album) (2nd nomination) User:AnemoneProjectors 12:52, 27 October 2010 (UTC) keep more information is known since the last AFD. The album has a title, a cover and tracklist, and is by a notable recording artist. Passes , passes Deletion of Obsession (Shayne Ward album) (2nd nomination) WP:HAMMER||WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
8872 18571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global Gathering 2005 User:power 02:15, 23 December 2020 (UTC) delete thoroughly unsourced (well, there's an implicit primary source of the festival's program), and largely promotional. We don't have stand-alone articles for each year of Burning Man (with 70k attendees), so I don't buy the argument. Best handled as a blgo post and/or having the program on archive.org, not as an article for each year's festival Deletion of Global Gathering 2005 WP:ITSNOTABLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8873 10 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rob McDowall (3rd nomination) User:Jbhunley 12:55, 17 June 2016 (UTC) delete Not enough coverage in |independent, |reliable sources to |verify or |sustian article. Fails |Wikipedia's General Notability Guidelines or and . I found some passing mentions and quotes but no significant coverage Deletion of Rob McDowall (3rd nomination) WP:IS||WP:RS||WP:V||WP:NRV||WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8874 16282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alotta Fagina User:Whpq 17:14, 26 February 2007 (UTC) merge as per , this is a minor character and should be merged into the main article Deletion of Alotta Fagina WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8875 438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taede A. Smedes User:David 23:33, 22 May 2019 (UTC) keep I found enough reviews of his books to convince me of a pass of , and there appears to be a lot more in the way of reliable sourcing about him, his books, and his views on religion available if you read Dutch Deletion of Taede A. Smedes WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
8876 618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skyy Black (porn star) User:LaMenta3 21:04, 23 March 2007 (UTC) comment """While I happen to agree with this particular nom, they are in no way """"flocking"""" to WP...many of the porn star articles up for AfD today were nominated by the same person within the span of a couple of hours as a suspected means of making a """ Deletion of Skyy Black (porn star) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
8877 9140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manny Ramirez Jr User:Muboshgu 18:11, 4 May 2018 (UTC) merge to Manny Ramirez#Personal life. Notability is . He's playing for an indy league team with the smallest of chances he becomes notable in his own right. I wouldn't argue with straight deletion, but redirects are cheap. – Deletion of Manny Ramirez Jr WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8878 2365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Contemporary Fighting Arts (2nd nomination) User:Astudent0 13:35, 4 May 2010 (UTC) delete This art appears to be taught at 1 school and has no independent coverage, except for the local papers. Clearly fails Deletion of Contemporary Fighting Arts (2nd nomination) WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8879 13003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aditi Technologies User:MezzoMezzo 04:12, 25 May 2013 (UTC) delete per . I mean, this article about a company called Aditi Technologies had much of its content added by a user called...Special:Contributions/Adititechnologies|Aditi Technologies Deletion of Aditi Technologies WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
8880 8728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Love Math User:Gamaliel 08:07, 3 October 2005 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of I Love Math WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8881 18685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peril Lies in Wait User:Accounting4Taste 19:29, 31 December 2007 (UTC) delete I was about to speedy it under , and I suggest it doesn't meet that standard. But this will ensure it won't be recreated until the topic is truly notable Deletion of Peril Lies in Wait WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
8882 12334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael T. Sauer User:Brian 22:42, 10 May 2007 (UTC) keep It is notable per Deletion of Michael T. Sauer WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8883 12109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muzammil Haque User:Bearian 21:27, 30 January 2020 (UTC) keep having three public buildings named after a subject indicates the subject |might be notable. I found some sources on Google Books that need to be examined Deletion of Muzammil Haque WP:BARE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8884 19250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard J. Novic, M.D. User:Bfigura 22:35, 12 April 2008 (UTC) delete as a non-notable person failing . Of course, the self-promotional angle helps things not at all Deletion of Richard J. Novic, M.D. WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8885 8115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hameed Vaniyambalam User:Kutyava 02:52, 13 October 2019 (UTC) delete Fails and . Subject was not elected Deletion of Hameed Vaniyambalam WP:GNG||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8886 3828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donatus Kaufmann [[User talk:2A02:C7F:4481:8300:90DC:E235:5074:54B0|talk]]) 20:22, 18 September 2019 (UTC) delete The sources do not have the necessary depth to meet . As an example, take the Wall Street Journal reference that has been highlighted. This is simply a directory entry. It is one of no less than 40 such entries on Thyssenkrupp executives. As an obiter dictum, all the 'keep' views have been made by accounts/IPs with little or no other contributions. Special:Contributions/2A02:C7F:4481:8300:90DC:E235:5074:54B0|2A02:C7F:4481:8300:90DC:E235:5074:54B0 Deletion of Donatus Kaufmann WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8887 14592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greek-Paraguayan relations User:Edison 19:37, 1 May 2009 (UTC) delete Fails and OT|not a directory. Foreign relations of the 203 sovereign countries are best discussed in the article about the country, or a standalone article if a major country, rather than in 20,000 such binary stubs. A link to the country's foreign ministry website will provide more up-to-date info than a robostub created and then neglected Deletion of Greek-Paraguayan relations WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8888 18907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Delisle User:Papaursa 15:32, 25 October 2017 (UTC) delete Fails to meet either or Deletion of Steven Delisle WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
8889 9059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jevon O'Neill User:AuthorAuthor 21:17, 22 September 2018 (UTC) keep """The article is now fleshed out and includes additional citations. The subject has received two film awards and was profiled in a https://www.lutontoday.co.uk/news/from-edlesborough-to-hollywood-1-1041100 British newspaper article. His first two films - not """"obscure"""" - have been reviewed by ''Variety'', ''The Guardian'' and ''https://www.timeout.com/london/film/bobs-weekend Time Out London''. His third film, ''Mr Benn'', is, according to news accounts, in production and being bankrolled by a large production company based in London. Subject passes and and meets notability guidelines""" Deletion of Jevon O'Neill WP:GNG||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8890 20428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Di Carlo User:Evalpor 21:34, 1 January 2010 (UTC) delete non-notable per Deletion of Tony Di Carlo WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8891 8179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carnage of the Devils User:Jakew 22:59, 24 May 2008 (UTC) delete Agree with nom - and problems. I had a look in Google News to see if there might be any reviews, etc, but found http://news.google.co.uk/archivesearch?q=%22Carnage+of+the+Devils%22&btnG=Search+Archives&hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8 nothing Deletion of Carnage of the Devils WP:N||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8892 7648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jon Smith User:Boneymau 02:04, 24 March 2017 (UTC) delete agree subject does not appear to meet WP:AUTHOR or Deletion of Jon Smith WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8893 5957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of radiata animal orders User:Nick 10:52, 28 August 2018 (UTC) delete """I agree with the rationale eloquently put forward by the OP and of {{u|Spinningspark}}. Artificially forcing modern taxa into this list is definitely , especially as there were clear shifting sands of the meaning of the group, and no references have been put forward to support it. The summary at Radiata seems to suffice, and I agree there's little value in turning this into a redirect. I would not expect to find a """"List of Vermes animal orders"""", but would expect to find a reasonable explanation of what both now-abandoned groupings meant to naturalists at the time, and over the centuries that followed""" Deletion of List of radiata animal orders WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8894 16096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of online-gaming slang User:Twinkler4 16:21, 14 August 2007 (UTC) delete I see this has a lot of and, thats all I have to say Deletion of List of online-gaming slang WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
8895 19654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/An Astrologer's Day User:Admrboltz 18:17, 1 February 2014 (UTC) keep per Tito and Deletion of An Astrologer's Day WP:AFDISNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8896 1846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tomás Carbonell (friar) User:E 11:52, 13 November 2017 (UTC) keep A well-sourced - if brief - page on a Bishop. See Deletion of Tomás Carbonell (friar) WP:CLERGYOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
8897 6448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slim Burna (2nd nomination) User:Samat 13:04, 8 October 2017 (UTC) delete fail , and . notability not found Deletion of Slim Burna (2nd nomination) WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8898 7211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monk (band) User:Chiro725 22:49, 9 April 2021 (UTC) delete Per nomination fails Deletion of Monk (band) WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8899 9052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Perkovic User:Walls 18:53, 14 June 2013 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of David Perkovic WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8900 13402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donnabella Mortel (3rd nomination) User:Acnetj 09:17, 3 April 2018 (UTC) delete Not notable. Deletion of Donnabella Mortel (3rd nomination) WP:NOTLINKEDIN||WP:NOTPROMOTION Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8901 20402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bilmuri User:doomsdayer520 15:58, 16 December 2020 (UTC) delete Concerning the questions in the previous comment, see which says that media coverage has to be in reliable sources AND it has to be significant or non-trivial. Bilmuri has indeed gotten some reviews, as already cited in the article, but they are all minor announcements that do not go into any critical depth, and every single one that I can find shows that Bilmuri was only noticed because the guy was previously in Attack Attack! (American band). Therefore kicks in as well. This article is also dependent on claims that an undefined body of fans liked stuff on social media. A Bilmuri article might be viable in the future, but not yet Deletion of Bilmuri WP:SIGCOV||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
8902 17373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jan Paul Huissoon User:Kj 10:12, 19 November 2020 (UTC) delete perhaps Deletion of Jan Paul Huissoon WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
8903 3890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AgileGraph User:PianoDan 00:46, 18 January 2013 (UTC) delete fails . I don't understand why it wasn't deleted the last time Deletion of AgileGraph WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8904 12739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zach Davis User:Papaursa 19:07, 5 June 2011 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Zach Davis WP:MMANOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8905 15639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Il-lojic User:Anturiaethwr 02:28, 7 July 2008 (UTC) delete Pretty close to an #A7|A7 speedy in my opinion Deletion of Il-lojic WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
8906 3527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brook Run Skate Park User:Cube 19:04, 6 March 2008 (UTC) keep Significant coverage in multiple articles in the AJC. Satisfies Deletion of Brook Run Skate Park WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8907 10097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nikola Tesla in popular culture User:Bearian 17:05, 19 March 2013 (UTC) keep per Gene93k, Jclemens, and Michig. |Well-documented topic, and any OR can be cleaned up Deletion of Nikola Tesla in popular culture WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
8908 12453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grassnews User:Otolemur 14:54, 5 April 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Grassnews WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8909 19511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth King (artist) User:Netherzone 22:52, 12 April 2017 (UTC) keep Elizabeth King is notable - actually, she quite famous, has been in featured in the Whitney Biennial, numerous publications, books, major museum collections, etc. Subject meets and Deletion of Elizabeth King (artist) WP:NARTIST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8910 17571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Kimura User:Sandals1 16:32, 5 September 2019 (UTC) delete Fails to meet either or the GNG Deletion of Kevin Kimura WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
8911 572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zackary (2017 film) User:Donaldd23 23:40, 11 February 2021 (UTC) delete Fails , minor award not enough to satisfy guidelines Deletion of Zackary (2017 film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
8912 7032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Eager User:David 22:44, 21 August 2011 (UTC) delete I don't think he passes (the most likely criterion is #C7, impact outside academia in his academic capacity, but we'd need sources documenting the actual impact he has made) nor . The sources are a mixture of self-published ones (e.g. his university web sites) and reliable news articles that are not actually about him, but mention him in passing or quote him. I don't think that's enough Deletion of David Eager WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8913 716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of U.S. cities with most households without a car User:Lugnuts 08:24, 12 December 2018 (UTC) delete seems like a one-off study that's been made into its own (useless) wiki-article. And Deletion of List of U.S. cities with most households without a car WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8914 3614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al-Jamiatul Ahlia Darul Ulum Moinul Islam User:Jeff 07:49, 8 August 2010 (UTC) delete """without any |verifiable |reliable sources, we would not keep articles for institutions and individuals """"that follow the familiar Euroamerican tradition"""" either. Per Ragib, the claims of UGC affiliation and of a similar article in the Bengali Wikipedia are outright falsehoods, so how can we possibly trust the person posting them? """ Deletion of Al-Jamiatul Ahlia Darul Ulum Moinul Islam WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
8915 54 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Sigortam.net Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 22:46, 30 Nisan 2013 (UTC) keep Yukarıda ''|İlgili kayda değerlik kriterlerimizin ikinci maddesi (Site veya sitedeki içerik, bir kurum veya yayın organının verdiği, iyi bilinen ve bağımsız bir ödül almış olmalı) gereğince KD kabul edilmiyor mu?'' şeklinde bir yorum yapmıştım. Bu kriteri karşıladığından kalmalı madde Sigortam.net'in silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
8916 8167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Harbic User:Suriel1981 05:02, 1 February 2012 (UTC) delete In addition to the accurate nomination, much of the article itself isn't about the subject. not met Deletion of James Harbic WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8917 2394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Piper Perri User:Gene93k 17:06, 13 February 2021 (UTC) delete Just enough notability asserted to avoid an A7 speedy. No claim of or WP:ENT notability supported by available RS coverage. An independent search yielded only trivial mentions Deletion of Piper Perri WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8918 11307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Birdies (company) NONE NONE delete """The criteria for establishing notability for companies/organizations is not GNG as indicated above but is . We require multiple sources (at least two) of deep or significant coverage with |in-depth information *on the company* and (this bit is also important!) containing |""""Independent Content"""". """"Independent content"""", in order to count towards establishing notability, must include ''original and independent opinion, analysis, investigation, and fact checking that are clearly attributable to a source unaffiliated to the subject''. None of the references in the article meet the criteria, they are some of the most obvious examples of advertorials you could come across. They fail NCORP guidelines as follows""" Deletion of Birdies (company) WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
8919 6441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FIFA 07 English cup User:YechielMan 02:16, 30 January 2007 (UTC) delete Article history shows two contributing users total. The subject is clearly a non-notable invention, or Deletion of FIFA 07 English cup WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
8920 8885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Brightwings User:Taroaldo 06:27, 27 March 2008 (UTC) keep """criteria which satisfy includes: """"Has performed music for a work of media that is notable, e.g. a theme for a network television show, performance in a television show or notable film, inclusion on a compilation album, etc."""" It appears that ''The Brightwings'' has some credits in this area""" Deletion of The Brightwings WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
8921 14517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kafue Province User:Alexf 12:02, 10 April 2012 (UTC) delete per |CRYSTAL Deletion of Kafue Province WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8922 13539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Semi-beautiful User:SoCalSuperEagle 17:52, 21 July 2011 (UTC) delete It's obvious that the definition contained in the article is in violation of Deletion of Semi-beautiful WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
8923 14640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loch Ness Monster in popular culture User:Coolabahapple 04:48, 13 March 2018 (UTC) keep """meets , there are https://www.worldcat.org/search?q=loch+ness+monster&fq=dt%3Abks&dblist=638&start=21&qt=page_number_link 100s of books that discuss/contain stories about nessie, from children's picture books to adult non-fiction, some notable, some not, as for """"listcruft"""", any trivial/non-notable entries can be removed""" Deletion of Loch Ness Monster in popular culture WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8924 17706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kobenz (musician) User:Spiderone 21:34, 18 December 2020 (UTC) delete per all of the above and per Deletion of Kobenz (musician) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
8925 21499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Portable bicycle User:Snottywong 16:29, 10 July 2011 (UTC) merge to Folding bicycle per Deletion of Portable bicycle WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
8926 4 [[Großer Preis von Japan 2006]] (LAE) Benutzer:Dk0704 NONE keep Die Weiterleitung führt genau dorthin wo die einzigen verfügbaren Daten zum Lemma zu finden sind. Damit ist die Weiterleitung sinnvoll, so lange kein Artikel zum Lemma vorhanden ist. Ein Verstoß gegen ist nicht ersichtlich. Im Sinne der Benutzerfreundlichkeit ist dieses Lemma m.M.n. zu , auch wenn die Redaktion Motorsport vielleicht ihre eigenen Ansichten hat Löschung von Großer Preis von Japan 2006 Wikipedia:WL Wikipedia:Redirect 56
8927 6709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beyond The Grave User:Randomran 14:59, 14 September 2008 (UTC) delete """the only sources that could be found on google books are either primary sources, or the common phrase """"beyond the grave"""" which don't focus on any specific topic. That's not enough to satisfy our |notability guidelines""" Deletion of Beyond The Grave WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8928 12075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farai - CCIE 42487 User:Amortias 14:37, 18 May 2014 (UTC) delete WP:AUTOBIO looks like it should go Deletion of Farai - CCIE 42487 WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8929 14848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank J. Vondersaar User:E 19:29, 9 August 2018 (UTC) delete Alaska is one of the smallest states, by population, and that may contribute to the dearth on on this perennial candidate. He gets few out of state mentions, for example, in a Washington Post political blog about the year;s worst candidate websites https://search.proquest.com/news/docview/1538360599/fulltext/56810D0E36484241PQ/6?accountid=10226 The awful campaign Web sites of 2014, bu tit's a sentence here, a sentence there. Even in Alaska, there wasn't much INDEPTH coverage of him, mostly obits and campaign coverage. This obit in the https://www.adn.com/voices/article/alaskas-vondersaar-never-dissembled-his-stump-rant-had-no-legs/2014/09/23/ Anchorage Daily News makes him out as a sort of novelty item Deletion of Frank J. Vondersaar WP:SIGCOV||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8930 20486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Double (Mariners) User:Kinu 01:11, 27 April 2007 (UTC) delete Based on the references provided, neither of the sources even refer to it by this title (the two footnotes which use the citations seem like afterthoughts that have little to nothing to do with said play). From a cursory search, I find nothing that does. Unless it can be properly sourced such that |notable media have referred to it as such, this is not encyclopedic. The Catch (baseball)|The Catch it ain't Deletion of The Double (Mariners) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8931 3907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rosary ASA User:danntm 01:05, 4 January 2007 (UTC) delete an organization at a single church is not national, thus fails Deletion of Rosary ASA WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8932 3231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Living Word Fellowship (4th nomination) User:Baileypalblue 15:42, 15 January 2009 (UTC) keep """Satisfies the notability requirements of , which says: """"Organizations whose activities are local in scope may be notable where there is verifiable information from reliable independent sources outside the organization's local area."""" The ''People'' magazine article and Ruth Tucker book cited satisfy this requirement""" Deletion of The Living Word Fellowship (4th nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8933 16210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Fuwape User:David 18:25, 8 April 2015 (UTC) comment """As vice chancellor (in a system where the nominally higher positions are ceremonial) he appears to pass the """"highest-level academic post"""" subclause of #C8. However I am highly dubious that Salem University, Lokoja would count as a """"major academic institution"""" as required by the rest of that criterion. In particular, https://books.google.com/books?id=QNB1rU73-6kC&pg=PA80 this source shows it as being both small and new. So I think we will have to look to other criteria for notability""" Deletion of Joseph Fuwape WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
8934 21526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erik Deutsch User:Timtrent 09:50, 7 April 2021 (UTC) delete Notability is not inherited from the notable artists this musician has worked with. Fails . Also depressing that the picture currently decorating the article is ''©2016 ShowLove Media || All rights reserved || Photo by John-Ryan Lockman'', now up for deletion on Commons Deletion of Erik Deutsch WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8935 17625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mahmood Zamir User:SportsOlympic 15:55, 18 January 2021 (UTC) keep Meets . Nominator didn't do a WP:BEFORE to show the opposite. The nominator nominated (automatically) a large amount of cricketeers. It would have been better to made a bunch of them in one nomination Deletion of Mahmood Zamir WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8936 2603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David C. Mabie User:Bearcat 17:36, 7 December 2016 (UTC) delete """As always, unelected candidates for office are not entitled to Wikipedia articles because candidate — if you cannot provide and source credible evidence that they get over another notability criterion for some other reason, then they do not pass until they ''win'' the seat. This makes no such claim, however, and its only """"source"""" is a (deadlinked) raw table of election results of the type that just nominally verifies ''all'' of the candidates' existences and vote totals, but fails to provide ''substantive'' content ''about'' them. There's just no grounds for an article here""" Deletion of David C. Mabie WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8937 3814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tallest buildings in Springfield, Missouri User:TimothyBlue 17:30, 5 December 2020 (UTC) delete Fails does not have in discussing this as a group. The city is not notable for tall buildings and the buildings are not notably tall. The list does not meet , there is nothing there that can assist in navigation. // Deletion of List of tallest buildings in Springfield, Missouri WP:LISTN||WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS||WP:CLN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8938 14448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B. H. Carroll Theological Institute (2 nomination) User:Wikipediatrix 18:54, 26 October 2006 (UTC) comment """Using the exact same standards, I could start my own unaccredited """"online bible school"""" out of my living room, send out press releases and get friends in the media to write puff-piece articles about it (not to mention the inevitable articles from religious media), create my own Wikipedia article for it, and point to this AfD if anyone squawks about it. Surely this is not what was intended by """ Deletion of B. H. Carroll Theological Institute (2 nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8939 4086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordin Sparks Second Album User:Flaming 21:27, 21 February 2009 (UTC) delete STOP → |Hammer Time Deletion of Jordin Sparks Second Album WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
8940 19947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamaica plain music festival User:Bgwhite 22:23, 10 September 2011 (UTC) delete I only see one reference of significant coverage and that is the boston.com one. Otherwise, it sounds like a local music festival in which the organization doesn't pass Deletion of Jamaica plain music festival WP:NONPROFIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8941 5409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of gay beaches in France User:Wikimandia 19:51, 12 June 2015 (UTC) delete per nom, also those beaches have not self-identified as gay in Deletion of List of gay beaches in France WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8942 10003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PRATT User:Psyphi 21:16, 3 January 2008 (UTC) delete Although the term PRATT is, from what I can tell by a quick Googling, a notable acronym and could be referenced, it does not meet the requirements of as it is not a type of acronym, it is simply one single acronym. --Special:Contributions/74.67.243.173|74.67.243.173 Deletion of PRATT WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8943 13688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karl Koch (musician) (2nd nomination) User:ConcernedVancouverite 14:40, 16 October 2011 (UTC) delete I have been unable to locate significant |reliable source coverage to to establish notability. Some of the difficulty in locating it may come from fact that there is a German hacker with the same name that turns up for most topic specific searches around technology/webpages/etc. I also tried music based searches though and had similar difficulty locating THIS Karl Koch Deletion of Karl Koch (musician) (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8944 3559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Protoss User:Jay32183 01:53, 4 September 2007 (UTC) delete Does not have significant coverage in multiple reliable secondary sources, fails Deletion of Protoss WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8945 4328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of self-referential songs (5th nomination) User:Moreschi 22:29, 27 August 2007 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not an indiscriminate collection of information. This is an unreferenced indiscriminate collection of information. No evidence presented that anyone cares Deletion of List of self-referential songs (5th nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8946 14305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noel Conway (Lecturer) User:David 00:30, 11 September 2018 (UTC) keep or '''Merge'''/'''Redirect''' to an article about assisted dying (or suicide) cases (I'm open to what others decide is the best target. I suggest you all make your !votes for the merge target easy for the closer to find. I believe you have agreed to Assisted suicide in the United Kingdom) -- independent in BBC (multiple times), https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/jun/27/assisted-dying-uk-court-rejects-noel-conway-challenge Guardian, https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/noel-conway-to-fight-assisted-dying-ban-in-supreme-court-after-appeal-fails-59bf3psd2 The Times, and https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/noel-conway-latest-terminally-ill-right-to-die-court-challenge-ruling-motor-neurone-suicide-a8165606.html The Independent. Because it appears these articles are all over one event, merge might be better Deletion of Noel Conway (Lecturer) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
8947 21297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DJ Pope User:Richard3120 17:38, 3 September 2020 (UTC) comment """re|Calliopejen1}} and others reading this discussion... the problem is that being the """"right-hand man"""" and DJ of a world-famous reggaeton star is a bit like being the drummer or backing singer for a world-famous rock star... nobody really talks about you except in passing and usually only when they are talking about that famous star, so it's a bit of a fame. However, I will say that the sources are mostly reliable: ''El Tiempo'' and ''El Espectador'' are two of the three most important newspapers in the country, ''Shock'' is long-established and Colombia's biggest music magazine (previously published in print form, but now entirely online), and W Radio is a recognised and popular national radio station. With this in mind, I'm inclined to keep the article, but it is a weak keep, and I have no strong opinion about it""" Deletion of DJ Pope WP:INHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8948 28 [[ETFexplorer]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Tom_md 11:16, 23. Okt. 2009 (CEST) delete Das generiert noch keine Relevanz nach . Demnach Löschung von ETFexplorer Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
8949 2249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omnibussimulator User:Jovanmilic97 20:47, 7 July 2019 (UTC) delete I don't see notability here. There is an article about the game on Rock, Paper, Shotgun https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2014/10/06/have-you-played-omsi-bus-simulator/, but nothing much else. I am mostly getting results for Oregon Museum of Science and Industry. Also, I would advise {{u|ThatLawStudent}} to read as to what has to be met which this subject fails (lack of significant coverage in multiple reliable sources). Plus not being promotional is not the reason to keep it as well Deletion of Omnibussimulator WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8950 2088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eggel (Egg Bagel) User:Northamerica1000 19:58, 9 May 2016 (UTC) delete Interesting idea, but the topic has received no (very little) coverage in reliable sources. Epic fail Deletion of Eggel (Egg Bagel) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8951 15276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dragon Ball episodes User:TheFarix 20:26, 19 February 2007 (UTC) comment """Whether there are other TV series that have episode articles is |irrelevant. My view is that this is better handled by List of Dragon Ball episodes instead of individual articles. The """"''Saga''"""" articles should be likewise merged because of #IINFO issues. In fact, I see that the Emperor Pilaf Saga is already ready to be merged so I'll probably do that in a short while""" Deletion of Dragon Ball episodes WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8952 20214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Y.H. Ku User:Gene93k 20:47, 12 September 2015 (UTC) keep I have no expertise with but Ku clearly passes as a member of a national legislature. Much thanks to {{u|David Eppstein}} for extensive improvements to the article since it was nominated Deletion of Y.H. Ku WP:PROF||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
8953 1410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joachim Christian Shah Mridhani Pahlavan-Nassab User:Bearian 00:32, 19 April 2017 (UTC) merge as suggested, and per and Deletion of Joachim Christian Shah Mridhani Pahlavan-Nassab WP:CHEAP||WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
8954 20032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noob tube User:DasallmächtigeJ 12:46, 12 January 2010 (UTC) delete by Deletion of Noob tube WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8955 15682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benjamin Bonetti User:Tom 15:02, 2 January 2012 (UTC) delete Cannot find any third-party published reliable sources at all to establish notability under the Deletion of Benjamin Bonetti WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8956 19910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Palmer User:Atlantic306 00:24, 9 July 2020 (UTC) delete as does not pass , there are also some issues here, imv Deletion of Jeff Palmer WP:GNG||WP:MEDRS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8957 19500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jake Brimmer (2nd nomination) User:GiantSnowman 19:30, 13 June 2017 (UTC) delete and SALT, fails and Deletion of Jake Brimmer (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
8958 722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Estophobia User:Edison 16:49, 11 July 2007 (UTC) keep """but '''Rename''' to Anti-Estonianism or other merely descriptive term, because the present title fails as a neologism and the references are not about it per se. I looked at a number of the references and did not find the term in them. The article, as is, is poorly written, and a series of """"TBA"""" headings would be better kept in the creator of the article's sandbox until he/she finds acceptable sources satisfying to use in writing them. The references do make the case that there are people who do not like Estonia and Estonians, and that there is and has been oppression and harrassment. This is hardly surprising, as there are people who do not like and who harrass, attack or kill Israelis, Arabs, Mexicans, people from the United States, the French, the Irish, the British, Asians, Jews, Christians, Moslems, Gypsies, Germans, Russians, Pakistanis, Indians, (and Indians of various castes), Native Americans, African Americans, African Africans who are White, African Africans who are Black, and many other definable racial/ethnic/national/religious groups. Wikipedia is not paper, so if there are multiple reliable and independent sources (such as presented for this article) with substantial coverage to show a history of hatred, discrimination, harrassment and prejudice against any such group, then it is not original research or synthesis to write an article based on those sources""" Deletion of Estophobia WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
8959 13328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian fantasy metal User:Bearian 14:47, 22 March 2010 (UTC) delete per |the usual outcomes for |brand new genres of music. See Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Electrocrunk Deletion of Christian fantasy metal WP:OUTCOMES||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
8960 45 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Gruenwald User:LibStar 03:23, 6 September 2011 (UTC) delete as per and . take away this crime and he is not known for anything. simple Deletion of Peter Gruenwald WP:PERP||WP:ONEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
8961 3491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Spatola User:Esradekan 08:57, 22 March 2009 (UTC) merge to the Hurt (band)|parent article per #Criteria for musicians and ensembles Deletion of Paul Spatola WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8962 8698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grand Hotel and Casino, Port Vila User:Spiderone 15:36, 15 November 2020 (UTC) delete not seeing any for this one Deletion of Grand Hotel and Casino, Port Vila WP:SIRS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8963 14709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Electrical wiring (United States) User:Roninbk 18:00, 10 February 2008 (UTC) delete Article needs |serious work before it can be considered encyclopedic Deletion of Electrical wiring (United States) WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
8964 14932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zero Gravity Pregnancy User:Cosmo0 19:50, 10 January 2008 (UTC) delete I think it's a bit premature (excuse the pun) to merge into Weightlessness#Health effects since that section deals with actual documented effects whereas the subject of Zero Gravity Pregnancy|zero gravity pregnancy is purely speculative at the moment. I agree that the article was written |in good faith, but there's too little verifiable information, beyond simply documenting the small number of discussions that have taken place on the subject. Perhaps it could find a place in space colonization or a related article Deletion of Zero Gravity Pregnancy WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
8965 12267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cam Winton User:AuthorAuthor 09:45, 29 October 2018 (UTC) delete per nom. This reads like an expanded resume for a job application. Media coverage is routine for a mayoral race and does not show notability. Fails as well as Deletion of Cam Winton WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8966 2533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheitaan User:Donaldd23 18:32, 7 February 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Sheitaan WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
8967 13078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gallery of Scout and Guide national emblems User:BigDT 17:59, 7 March 2007 (UTC) comment This issue isn't just a legal issue. I think I'm on solid ground when I say that under US copyright law, the doctrine of fair use makes us perfectly free to have this article. If the law were the only issue, that's a non-issue. If this were Gallery of news media photos, forget it, we would be infringing on their right to exclusively market their product. But a gallery of logos of non-profit organizations should not be a problem UNDER THE LAW. It is, however, a problem on WIKIPEDIA. Our |fair use policy is intentionally more restrictive than what we could get away with. This is because Wikipedia is a free-content encyclopedia. We only use non-free images under a claim of fair use when it is a necessity - we don't have articles that contain no free content. Sometimes, this is inconvenient. Sometimes it's annoying. I am a Scouter and have been involved with Scouting for 20 years. I like this article. I enjoy looking at it. But, for the ultimate goal of being a free-content encyclopedia, we sometimes have to make compromises and one of them is that we don't have articles containing nothing but non-free images Deletion of Gallery of Scout and Guide national emblems WP:FAIR Wikipedia:Non-free content 99
8968 5646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suffering Silence User:Tony 22:50, 3 February 2009 (UTC) delete as failing Deletion of Suffering Silence WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8969 9690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Koma Unwind User:GregorB 08:11, 26 July 2013 (UTC) delete A passing mention in Business Week plus a press release - not sufficient for meeting . Might be '''merged''' into the company article (if it existed and if the company was notable - I have no opinion on that one way or the other Deletion of Koma Unwind WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8970 464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malik Veazie User:Malcolmxl5 20:53, 17 September 2008 (UTC) delete Fails , as well as thlete per searches on talk page of the article Deletion of Malik Veazie WP:N||WP:BIO||WP:A Wikipedia:Notability 77
8971 2305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Rhea User:TrackerTV 19:51, 2 January 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. This is clearly a |conflict of interest, as Foleyef can be rearranged to E.F. Foley or Edward F. Foley. This is also patent |original research from there. « Deletion of Joseph Rhea WP:COI||WP:OR Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
8972 4687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanae Shimomura User:Griseum 12:30, 5 August 2010 (UTC) delete No evidence that there was enough discussion of this event to transform the subject from |NEWSWORTHY to ote|NOTEWORTHY Deletion of Sanae Shimomura WP:NOTNEWS||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
8973 794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Del Mar Academy User:E 12:01, 22 November 2016 (UTC) keep """as per longstanding consensus to keep verifiable secondary (American: """"high"""",) schools""" Deletion of Del Mar Academy WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
8974 6409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Film Companion User:Erik 22:20, 18 September 2017 (UTC) delete per as I cannot find significant coverage from secondary sources ''about'' this company Deletion of Film Companion WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
8975 9700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bloviate (2nd nomination) User:Edison 00:04, 5 July 2008 (UTC) keep """This world has a rich cultural history and several reliable sources which discuss the word specifically (rather than just using it.) Google news archive shows 616 entries for """"bloviate"""" including the Rocky Mountain News (1994) calling it """"a beautiful verb"""" in """"'BLOVIATE' A DELIGHTFUL, UNDISCOVERED VERB http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=RM&p_theme=rm&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0EB4DF4356451679&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM."""" The New York Times discussed its history and application in """"Journal; The Bloviators' Ball """"(1999)http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9C04E5DC153EF935A35752C0A96F958260 and earlier in 1972. Its long absence from dictionaries was discussed in the Boston Globe (April 4, 1999):""""The real mystery is why the lexicographers ignored bloviate for so many years. ... Like disconnect, bloviate somehow eluded the radar of most slang ..."""" If multiple reliable sources have substantial coverage in discussions of the word, it seems to be |notable. Most dictionary words lack such coverage (as opposed to simple usage). (Rather than deletion, perhaps it could be redirected to one of the blowhard radio talkers. I could make a recommendation""" Deletion of Bloviate (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
8976 4063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Pearce (philosopher) (3rd nomination) User:Gjmulder 20:06, 9 January 2014 (UTC) comment """Given then that he doesn't meet - out of the 11 sources cited in the article: 3, 6 and 8 (the latter only available on archive.org) are links to David's own websites, 4 and 7 are from the website of an organisation David co-founded, and 10 is a disingenuous partial copy of 3, so all six are . explicitly states that """"primary sources do not contribute towards the notability of an article"""". There has been no progress at providing non-primary sources, despite repeated requests on the talk page over the span of a number of years""" Deletion of David Pearce (philosopher) (3rd nomination) WP:ACADEMIC||WP:BLPSPS||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8977 512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flexible contracts User:Wikicology 23:06, 13 May 2015 (UTC) keep Per |significant coverages In multiple independent |reliable sources https://www.google.co.uk/search?as_eq=wikipedia&q=%22Flexible+contracts%22&num=50&gws_rd=cr&ei=cddTVdf7HuTP7QaitoDgCA Deletion of Flexible contracts WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
8978 4844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Tornambe User:Czj 06:44, 22 January 2007 (UTC) delete NN individual. Doesn't pass Deletion of Michael Tornambe WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8979 9440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skruff User:Esradekan 22:59, 16 March 2009 (UTC) keep along with the ref's Paul Erik has added, here are a few more; http://www.bbc.co.uk/northernireland/atl/review_specific174125.shtml bbc.co.uk gig review, http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio1/rorymcconnell/tracklistingarchive.shtml?20080731 radio 1, http://www.bbc.co.uk/northernireland/radioulster/electric_mainline/playlist.shtml bbc radio ulster, http://www.bbc.co.uk/northernireland/radiofoyle/programmes/electric/playlist_thu/2008playlists/jan08_playlist_thu.shtml bbc radio foyle, http://www.derryjournal.com/entertainment/Debut-Derry-gig-for-Fred.4893472.jp derry journal, and a slightly trivial mention in the http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/opinion/columnists/eamon-mccann/eamonn-mccann-see-ash-and-cat-malojian-at-glasgowbury-and-find-out-how-other-half-live-13920428.html belfasttelegraph. More than enough there to pass #C1 Deletion of Skruff WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8980 13094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Is Forever (Say Anything album) (2nd nomination) User:JohnCD 21:12, 22 April 2008 (UTC) delete why not speedy #G4 Deletion of This Is Forever (Say Anything album) (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
8981 8177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liz Wilde User:Rtphokie 02:03, 6 June 2008 (UTC) delete There are a number secondary sources (I added a number to this article before the COI edit war started) but these sources mention Wilde's move from station to station. This ''town to town, up and down the dial'' is the nature of radio and doesn't indicate notability. I'm not seeing mention of any lasting contribution to the radio industry or any awards per . Claims that she's the only/first female shock jock are without references to back them up. Also, given the persistent COI editing. Deletion and salting seems to be in order to prevent future headaches Deletion of Liz Wilde WP:BIO||WP:original research Wikipedia:Notability 77
8982 15381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. K. Jeffrey Miller User:Bearian 01:14, 8 August 2017 (UTC) delete a |run of the mill chiropractor and an allegedly |prolific scholar who's been cited exactly once according to Google scholar. This is bordering on |spam Deletion of Dr. K. Jeffrey Miller WP:MILL||WP:PROF||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
8983 13723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Megxit User:IJBall 01:00, 14 January 2020 (UTC) keep """Event is definitely notable, but I don't think """"Megxit"""" is the (this is not like """"Brexit""""), and it's a """"neologism"""" anyhow (it's nothing more than a tabloid creation, and we should not be following their lead""" Deletion of Megxit WP:COMMONNAME Wikipedia:Article titles 75
8984 10372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David L. Richards User:David 20:16, 24 September 2019 (UTC) delete per and the borderline nature of the case for notability evident here Deletion of David L. Richards WP:BLPREQUESTDELETE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
8985 16200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adithya Shivpink user:QueerEcofeminist 02:53, 10 September 2020 (UTC) delete Fails , no contribution to their field as actor or even as social worker. Thanks Deletion of Adithya Shivpink WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8986 5207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silver Bell User:SummerPhD 17:53, 2 February 2009 (UTC) delete Non-notable unreleased album. Fails Deletion of Silver Bell WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8987 9754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Broadbent User:RFerreira 04:38, 14 May 2007 (UTC) keep notable wine critic with ample references to meet guidelines Deletion of Michael Broadbent WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
8988 20021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shawn Hollenbach User:Ron 00:11, 28 September 2010 (UTC) merge The article is a |BLP Deletion of Shawn Hollenbach WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
8989 5785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Leycester Haymes User:RightCowLeftCoast 20:44, 8 October 2014 (UTC) keep """or '''redirect''' to Battle of Neuve Chapelle. Subject appears to meet criteria 6 of , """"Commanded a substantial body of troops in combat"""". Failing that the subject falls under and the article can be redirected to the battle where the subject's actions were notable at""" Deletion of Robert Leycester Haymes WP:SOLDIER||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
8990 5863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Persecution of Biharis in Bangladesh User:Mar4d 04:34, 11 June 2013 (UTC) keep This is a very notable human rights issue and has extensive coverage in many academic sources. It is worth noting that the nominating editor identifies as Bangladeshi and has been previously involved in POV disputes in this article. This is obviously very important to note as there is high chance of involved behind this AfD. The editor in concern has made several attempts to remove content from the article which purportedly does not shed Bangladesh in a very positive light. Since he could not get his way, he decided to take the dispute to the AfD route. I do not recognise this AfD as valid since it is essentially an issue of opposing POVs. The article topic itself is highly notable. It appears that this AfD is a classic case of , and the single sentence nominating rationale goes to show that this is an attempt to whitewash and this notable topic away from the encyclopedia Deletion of Persecution of Biharis in Bangladesh WP:COI||WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:CENSOR Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
8991 17635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barack Obama (disambiguation) User:LinguistAtLarge 18:05, 15 April 2009 (UTC) comment """that would seem to warrant a """"move to portal space"""" recommendation, not deletion, per , which, by the way is official policy and trumps the self-ref guideline. — """ Deletion of Barack Obama (disambiguation) WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
8992 14516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Israel vs Genocide User:Resolute 05:14, 29 December 2008 (UTC) delete Pretty obvious pushing Deletion of Israel vs Genocide WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
8993 3058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Travis Karter NONE NONE keep initially i was ambivalent to the overall debate, but i was able to find an additional, recent source from a national publication. I included it in the works cited of the article. I would vote to keep, as this article now sufficiently satisfies #1 of Deletion of Travis Karter WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
8994 9065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Pierre User:Kelapstick 12:58, 27 March 2010 (UTC) comment """someone competing at the fully professional level at a sport (i.e. the CFL) meets the threshold of notability for , so there is a """"claim of notability"""", although some sources are needed""" Deletion of Charles Pierre WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
8995 11172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jerome A. Prince User:INDIAN 07:10, 15 September 2020 (UTC) keep A notable politician from Indiana. Passes Deletion of Jerome A. Prince WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
8996 4040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kiyoshi Shiina (2nd nomination) User:Mdtemp 19:20, 9 December 2014 (UTC) delete This article was speedily deleted last week. There's no reason why this article should keep being recreated when there's no new evidence of notability. Lots of passing mentions and articles on some of his students do not give him notability ( Deletion of Kiyoshi Shiina (2nd nomination) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8997 20285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of kings of Rohan User:Reywas92 19:04, 5 August 2019 (UTC) delete None of these policies are ''carte blanche'' to keep anything and everything indefinitely. Unclear how your cookie-cutter links make this censorship. Not being paper does not mean we must reflexively keep . ATD says to look at improvements or alternatives (not that deletion is forbidden), none of which you have proposed - instead we could have a merge of the kings articles into an expanded List of Middle-earth characters or a single subpage, but this level of detail is quite the fancruft not covered in third-party sources Deletion of List of kings of Rohan WP:EVERYTHING Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
8998 17887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ossian productions User:WWGB 22:39, 30 March 2008 (UTC) delete Lack of independent references establishing notability, bordering on spam. Does not appear to meet Deletion of Ossian productions WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
8999 2940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Newport University (California) User:Shimeru 23:42, 12 November 2006 (UTC) delete per Fram and . I believe this one is noteworthy, but that's no good if we can't verify through independent sources, and it seems as if we can't Deletion of Newport University (California) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9000 12397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timothy Judd User:Gnome 12:39, 27 October 2014 (UTC) delete """I don't see how the subject of this biography meets . Even the """"one event"""" discussed above, winning a contest to name a shuttle mockup, hardly seems that notable in the context of an encyclopedia""" Deletion of Timothy Judd WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9001 12268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mitchell Schwartz (public figure) User:AlessandroTiandelli333 20:33, 29 November 2016 (UTC) keep Per above, passes Deletion of Mitchell Schwartz (public figure) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9002 454 [[Sahra Amir Ebrahimi]] (erl. LA zurückgezogen) Benutzer:Regi51 00:10, 26. Aug. 2008 (CEST) delete Wenn der Artikel nach diesen #Darstellende Künstler, Moderatoren, Film-Stab|Relevanzkriterien ausgebaut wird, nehme ich meinen ursprünglichen SLA sofort zurück, ansonsten: . Das bedauernswerte Schicksal einer Person, ob Schauspielerin oder nicht, in allen Ehren. Aber bei diesem Artikel geht es nicht um die Person als solche, sondern um die Schauspielerin. Wo ist sie aufgetreten? In welchen Filmen hat sie eine Hauptrolle gespielt usw. ''Das'' ist für eine Enzyklopädie interessant Löschung von Sahra Amir Ebrahimi Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9003 3048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zionist attitudes toward the Palestinian Arabs User:Shot 11:19, 1 January 2008 (UTC) delete """Doesn't read like something that appears in an encyclopedia. It seems to be a collection of material from various sources |welded together into an essay. The fact that it is from one editor is a little worrying inasmuch as that implies a lack of consensus, particularly with the |ownership issues from that editor. The article doesn't seem to follow the title but perhaps would be better retitled to """"Zionism and 101 reasons I dislike it..."""". Unfortunately the article does look beyond repair, not without gutting it to |neutralise the |forking going on""" Deletion of Zionist attitudes toward the Palestinian Arabs WP:SYN||WP:OWN||WP:NPOV||WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:No original research 65
9004 15644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adolf Hitler Uunona User:CountHacker 04:16, 17 December 2020 (UTC) keep I would argue that Adolf Uunona actually does met standards. He is a politician representing a major sub-national level as a Regional Councillor on the Oshana Regional Council. It is a position that might be equivalent to a MLA in Canada, or a Member of the Provincial Legislature in South Africa. There is a distinction between a Regional council and a Local (town) council in Namibia, and it is a false equivalence to compare his position to that of a town/city councillor Deletion of Adolf Hitler Uunona WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9005 19668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gino Polli User:Necrothesp 09:58, 3 December 2015 (UTC) delete Mid-ranking officer with no special achievements or notable decorations. Fails Deletion of Gino Polli WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
9006 2347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Panniwala Ruldu [[User talk:Usernamekiran|'''(talk)''']] 21:57, 29 June 2019 (UTC) keep passes as a village that can be verified per Phil's comment above. —usernamekiran Deletion of Panniwala Ruldu WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9007 4905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandee Westgate User:Panser 11:01, 7 April 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Also fails Deletion of Sandee Westgate WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9008 13761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Great Escape (film) fact versus fiction User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:32, 14 February 2009 (UTC) keep """as nicely sourced comparison of FACT versus FILM. Lends itself quite nicely to a reader's understanding of how filmmakers """"bend"""" reality in order to make sales. Any issues with Wikipedia:WikiProject Films/Style guidelines#Adaptations|Adaptations can be addressed by """ Deletion of The Great Escape (film) fact versus fiction WP:CLEANUP Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
9009 2448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teresa DeChant User:E 16:42, 23 October 2018 (UTC) delete mere for a non-notable interior designer Deletion of Teresa DeChant WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9010 17041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Venera Lightnings F.C. User:apple20674 15:57, 6 April 2021 (UTC) keep """Passes , because of the clause here: """"Teams that have played in the national cup (or the national level of the league structure in countries where no cup exists) generally meet criteria. Teams that are not eligible for national cups must be shown to meet broader WP:N criteria."""" as shown here: """"https://int.soccerway.com/national/malta/fa-trophy/20192020/preliminary-round/r53597/"""", in the 1st line. Also passes as they have significant coverage from the Maltese Football Association, which is reliable and official and a FIFA member, thus being naturally independant""" Deletion of St. Venera Lightnings F.C. WP:FOOTYN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9011 10543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Spanish flu cases User:Lightburst 02:04, 20 March 2020 (UTC) keep but name change to notable deaths.... keep per After 100 years we likely have a complete list Deletion of List of Spanish flu cases WP:NLIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
9012 8831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yen Chou [[User talk:137.73.68.56|talk]]) 12:37, 26 November 2009 (UTC) keep Independent coverage seems fine, although I am not very familiar with Special:Contributions/137.73.68.56|137.73.68.56 Deletion of Yen Chou WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9013 2559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayfair High School User:Alansohn 02:15, 26 November 2006 (UTC) keep based on awards received, championships won and notable alumni, all of which are sourced in full compliance with and , the school meets and exceeds the standards set by and deserves to be retained Deletion of Mayfair High School WP:RS||WP:V||WP:SCHOOL Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9014 14044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicholas Lamia User:Icewhiz 07:39, 11 December 2017 (UTC) delete Not as clear cut as presented above, the notability claim (per comes from the Legion of Honour award - which can be sourced from - http://triblive.com/news/allegheny/4027526-74/lamia-beach-german https://franceintheus.org/spip.php?article4337 - however it seems this was bestowed on a rather random group of veterans in 2003 that were still alive at the time. Sourcing in a BEFORE does not show he meets GNG - so presumption of notability, per SOLDIER (all be it the legion of honour award having issues in general due to amount of bestowals), is not enough Deletion of Nicholas Lamia WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
9015 21315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nomads (hostels) User:Coredesat 21:09, 24 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Nomads (hostels) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9016 20946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MKR (programming language) (2nd nomination) User:Arthur 15:35, 24 June 2008 (UTC) delete """Userfy. There are ''no'' sources other than the developers' mailing list. All other sources appear to refer to the field, rather than the specific """"language"""". Suggest that the developer restore than article ''if'' it gets some discussion in . As for the previous AfD, it found that COI is not a reason to delete. Absence of sources ''is'', and the matter was not brought up then. In favor of deletion, rather than waiting for sourcing, as a number of redirects have been created by the developer, which would probably be worthy of deletion even if the article were kept. , although not a reason to delete, ''is'' a reason to delete something more quickly than if a neutral party though it relevent in the absence of sourcing. &mdash""" Deletion of MKR (programming language) (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:COI Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9017 19597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Celi User:7 16:52, 23 April 2019 (UTC) keep Meets . I agree with the last three writers' reasoning Deletion of Elizabeth Celi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9018 463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iqbal Shailo, PhD User:Xxanthippe 22:26, 13 June 2021 (UTC) delete Non-notable fails rof and GNG Deletion of Iqbal Shailo, PhD WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
9019 6921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Augustus William Hare User:Deor 17:24, 30 May 2011 (UTC) keep Passes the |GNG; and there seems to be a number of sources available for expansion, such as http://books.google.com/books?id=VJoCAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA214 this extensive passage on his rhetorical skill as evidenced in his ''Sermons to a Country Congregation'', a collection that isn't even mentioned in our article but which, in addition to inspiring the aforecited ''Edinburgh Review'' essay by Henry Rogers (clergyman)|Henry Rogers, received an extensive review in ''http://books.google.com/books?id=4VcAAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA33 The Quarterly Review Deletion of Augustus William Hare WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9020 13061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nerds (film) User:HelloAnnyong 06:11, 16 January 2008 (UTC) delete Non-notable film, fails . &mdash Deletion of Nerds (film) WP:MOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9021 2575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fernanda Rubio User:HisSpaceResearch 13:12, 2 November 2007 (UTC) delete I must admit, that the idea of male-to-female transsexual porn stars could bring about a bias in me because , but doesn't appear to have any notability either on an objective level Deletion of Fernanda Rubio WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9022 3936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TeamCHS NONE NONE delete per nomination, or speedy A7: not mentioned in any (including the sources cited), only mentioned in claims on web forums Deletion of TeamCHS WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9023 2596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cwm Twrch transmitting station User:Trevj 10:28, 24 May 2012 (UTC) comment Similar deletion discussions have taken place in the past: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saddleworth Transmitting Station|AfD/Saddleworth Transmitting Station, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caradon Hill transmitting station|AfD/Caradon Hill transmitting station. The latter mentions Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/University of North Carolina Tower Chapel Hill|a number of such articles in the US. otability requires verifiable evidence|Notability requires verifiable evidence, so even an unsourced assertion isn't generally enough Deletion of Cwm Twrch transmitting station WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9024 11630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Burns (political strategist) User:ERcheck 01:08, 22 February 2006 (UTC) delete I boldly removed all frivolous information - Jeep driver, mustache, etc. Remaining information does not meet notability guidelines in . &mdash Deletion of Eric Burns (political strategist) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9025 13578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herb Ruby User:Mandsford 18:19, 8 May 2010 (UTC) delete """They have to prove notability under the |regular system of extensive coverage in independent and reliable sources. Major League Baseball players are inherently notable under . """"Minor league players, managers, coaches, executives, and umpires are not assumed to be inherently notable."""" (quoting from #Baseball which sums up the general interpretation by Wikipedia's baseball fans on how to apply inherent notability""" Deletion of Herb Ruby WP:GNG||WP:ATHLETE||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9026 4537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blood Red Renaissance User:Falcon8765 00:10, 10 July 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Blood Red Renaissance WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9027 3410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/E. J. Wells (musician) User:Master 03:43, 15 October 2008 (UTC) delete Because this is a clear |conflict of interest, and the subject is not notable enough for a Wikipedia article Deletion of E. J. Wells (musician) WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
9028 3582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salman Mohammad Abdullah User:WikiDan61 17:13, 26 January 2015 (UTC) comment The issue at hand here is not popularity or fame, it is the very strict concept of |notability as defined at Wikipedia. Wikipedia requires that the subject of an article has been the subject of multiple instances of significant coverage in independent media, so that we have unbiased source material from which to build the Wikipedia article. In the absence of such source material, the subject's popularity is irrelevant. If we have no material from which to build an article, then we cannot have the article Deletion of Salman Mohammad Abdullah WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9029 1802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sealand War of Independence User:Abductive 01:52, 11 January 2010 (UTC) delete this is and a . Sources are a blog, a court record (a primary source), and an article in Wired that might be appropriate for the main article, but not strong enough to support this page Deletion of Sealand War of Independence WP:SYNTHESIS||WP:CFORK Wikipedia:No original research 65
9030 8447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesse Liberty (2nd nomination) User:Hekerui 16:04, 17 July 2011 (UTC) delete """has not had significant coverage in reliable sources, no evidence a criterion of or is met with the introductory books he writes (and the """"best-selling"""" statistics of Amazon are not reliable sources""" Deletion of Jesse Liberty (2nd nomination) WP:AUTHOR||WP:SCHOLAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9031 7361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Klein User:Aseleste 11:06, 30 March 2021 (UTC) merge The subject does not meet as the nomination was withdrawn. For and , most eligible sources |found cover the failed nomination, so the combined coverage is not enough to satisfy and . is also failed here according to the published dates of sources.{{Paragraph break}}Redirect per -R. Content can be merged into the redirection target if warranted Deletion of Elizabeth Klein WP:NPOL||WP:BASIC||WP:GNG||WP:SET||WP:BASIC||WP:GNG||WP:SUSTAINED||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
9032 1144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Necessity Village User:JayJasper 18:31, 7 May 2013 (UTC) delete per Whpq. Coverage not sufficient to satisy Deletion of Necessity Village WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9033 595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World of Warcraft Launcher User:Percy 10:36, 2 March 2008 (UTC) delete One wiki entry isn't substantial secondary coverage. Fails Deletion of World of Warcraft Launcher WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9034 11785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Homosexuality in ancient Greece User:Consumed 08:34, 7 August 2006 (UTC) keep reeks of a bad faith or biased nomination. Sources are cited. More are needed, but this doesn't outright fail enough to be deleted Deletion of Homosexuality in ancient Greece WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9035 10194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/José Rodríguez Moreno User:Redoryxx 07:08, 13 January 2021 (UTC) delete Seems to be notable in general but doesn't meet or Deletion of José Rodríguez Moreno WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9036 14996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ritmo nuevo y vieja ola User:DagosNavy 14:42, 17 January 2021 (UTC) delete Non-notable light 1960's comedy, fails ; although directed by prolific filmmaker Enrique Carreras and featuring a famous cast, notability is not inherited Deletion of Ritmo nuevo y vieja ola WP:NFOE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9037 5966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Bluestone User:MacGyverMagic 09:02, 3 December 2008 (UTC) merge to List of Gargoyles characters and '''merge''' heavily condensed plot details as per . Also the name itself makes for a reasonable redirect. There might be little real-world content, but the lead and the first section can be given a home (at least the very first sentence is referenced). A lack of real-world value only shows the subject is fictional and might not be worth a separate article. It says nothing about not covering it at all Deletion of Matt Bluestone WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9038 10177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/What is physical fitness? User:Doc 06:42, 7 January 2020 (UTC) delete per , not written in Wikipedia style (literally begins with a dictionary definition! I didn't think that happened outside of comic strips and cartoons anymore), nothing especially salvageable, never establishes notability, contains numerous grammatical errors and factual inaccuracies (Hugh Jackman didn't retire Deletion of What is physical fitness? WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9039 489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stanford Mendicants (2 nomination) User:TenPoundHammer 01:43, 9 August 2007 (UTC) keep easily passes Deletion of Stanford Mendicants (2 nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9040 6057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solo family User:Jontesta 16:54, 31 January 2021 (UTC) delete a few of the individual characters have proven |notability with reliable sources. But this is |an original synthesis of those separate notable articles into a new topic that itself isn't notable. It's a and doesn't cover anything unique that isn't already covered at the individual articles. A redirect to Han Solo as the main notable character would be fine Deletion of Solo family WP:N||WP:SYNTH||WP:CONTENTFORK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9041 17929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Godi media User:Suneye1 17:24, 6 May 2021 (UTC) keep Easily passes . Some with significant coverage not yet in the article.{{Cite web|title=India’s Media Is Partly to Blame for Its COVID Tragedy|url=https://time.com/6033152/india-media-covid-19/|access-date=2021-05-06|website=Time}}{{Cite web|last=Singh|first=Prabhjit|title=Farmers at Kundli upset over media misrepresentation, accusations; confront “godi media”|url=https://caravanmagazine.in/news/farmers-at-kundli-upset-over-media-misrepresentation-accusations-confront-godi-media|access-date=2021-05-06|website=The Caravan|language=en}}{{Cite journal|date=2015-06-05|title=Farmers' Protest: A Roadmap for the Opposition|url=https://www.epw.in/engage/article/farmers-protest-roadmap-opposition|journal=Economic and Political Weekly|language=en|pages=7–8 Deletion of Godi media WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9042 16002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of country names in various languages (2nd nomination) User:Carlossuarez46 22:31, 6 January 2015 (UTC) keep toponymy is encyclopedic, and these are little different that the numerous other glossaries, gazetteers, etc., which form part of the ive pillars Deletion of List of country names in various languages (2nd nomination) WP:F Wikipedia:Non-free content 99
9043 20162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Letters of Iranian Supreme leader to youth in the West User:Sandstein 09:24, 22 December 2015 (UTC) delete as redundant of ''To the Youth in Europe and North America'' or ''To the Youth in Western Countries'', which are the better articles Deletion of Letters of Iranian Supreme leader to youth in the West WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
9044 21534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erin Morrow Hawley User:Smallbones 02:40, 2 December 2017 (UTC) delete per . I just don't see any claim to notability. Certainly not that she was a Future Farmers of America member, high school valedictorian(?), editor on the Yale Law Review might be notable *if* anybody ever choose to write an article on it, but our reference is just to the masthead (not in-depth coverage). The closest achievement she has that might be considered notable is as a clerk to Chief Justice Roberts (our reference for this is a blog of one of her friends). But our List of law clerks of the Supreme Court of the United States gives 55 other people who have served in the same position with Roberts and only one, her husband, has an article Deletion of Erin Morrow Hawley WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
9045 10505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Trump's Wisconsin Tele-Rally User:Zoozaz1 04:37, 20 July 2020 (UTC) delete As per Deletion of Donald Trump's Wisconsin Tele-Rally WP:EVENTCRITERIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
9046 16726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bitchface User:Edison 20:27, 18 July 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Bitchface WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9047 17986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert A. Hull II User:MastCell 21:29, 12 February 2007 (UTC) delete per , Deletion of Robert A. Hull II WP:BIO||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9048 16947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slag best enemies User:Darrenhusted 14:37, 29 June 2009 (UTC) delete fails |Nff Deletion of Slag best enemies WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9049 21623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alisha Davis User:Wine 10:47, 25 January 2010 (UTC) delete """Correspondents like Davis are a dime a dozen. , which covers """"television personalities"""", is often used for TV news people; she's not even close. The fact that she got a NYT wedding blurb suggests that she is well-connected, not that she is notable""" Deletion of Alisha Davis WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
9050 10480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Velle Baria User:Armbrust 14:36, 26 October 2010 (UTC) delete He is a non-notable |musician without any coverage in |reliable sources Deletion of Velle Baria WP:MUSICBIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9051 14409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unusual eBay listings User:Carrite 17:52, 30 July 2012 (UTC) delete """Sourcing and entertainment value does not make an encyclopedic topic. There is no way to define """"unusual"""" as it means different things to different people. What we are left with is a junk drawer full of entertaining oddities and ain't enough... List of funny things printed in the ''New York Times'' and List of unusual clothing wouldn't be encyclopedic either, for the same reasons""" Deletion of Unusual eBay listings WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9052 83 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ferhad Zeynalov Kullanıcı:seksen iki yüz kırk beşseksen iki yüz kırk beş / ggt 03.25, 19 Ocak 2021 (UTC) keep """Satırdan Kahraman'ın gösterdiği kaynaklarda kişinin kaliteli ve detaylı bir şekilde incelendiği anlaşılıyor. Bu durumda bu iki kaynak """"çoklu bağımsız kaynaklar"""" şeklindeki kriterinin karşılanması için yeterli""" Ferhad Zeynalov'un silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
9053 4322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Start Fitness User:Darylgolden 11:35, 3 April 2020 (UTC) delete """the third reference ''could'' be counted as significant coverage but the other Chronicle Live source focuses mainly only on the race. With significant coverage in only one source, the company does not meet . Searching on Google News also turns up no sources, but this could have been muddled by """"Start Fitness"""" being a common phrase""" Deletion of Start Fitness WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9054 7627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Davis Baseball User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable. Tagged as {{tl|nn-club}}. Merge would be okay but no article on HS seems to exist. &mdash Deletion of Davis Baseball WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9055 18168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Panic! at the disco User:Capitalistroadster 01:01, 13 October 2005 (UTC) keep and cleanup as per . They appear to be a relatively new band but their album has so far reached number 112 on the Billboard charts, #1 on the Heatseeker chart and top 10 of the Billboard indy chart see http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&token=ADFEAEE4781ED947A57520EFB71670E1FA5CDE2DFE62D9BA5007656392940454880C71ED59E695CCB1E574B666ADFF2EA11607D9CFE85CFCDB765D40&searchlink=PANIC|AT|THE|DISCO&uid=CAW050510122055&samples=1&sql=11:lxfxlfjescqe~T5. They were Spin's band of the day last week see http://www.spin.com/features/band_of_the_day/2005/10/051003_panic/ and are currently undertaking a tour of the US and Canada Deletion of Panic! at the disco WP:music Wikipedia:Notability 77
9056 44 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eamon McDonnell User:Dhartung 08:37, 31 May 2007 (UTC) delete Not sure about G2, but maybe G7? Regardless, fails , , and so forth. OT|Wikipedia is not for publishing homework assignments, and if your teacher assigned you to write a Wikipedia article that doesn't fit the project, please pass on that we would rather such things be done within the scope of |Wikipedia school projects. Thanks Deletion of Eamon McDonnell WP:V||WP:N||WP:NOT||WP:SUP Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9057 14977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Shanawar User:Nannadeem 16:00, 15 December 2015 (UTC) comment """Yes not notable is not notable. This is my stance too, but try to understand that who is here to represent the subject or a particular genre, that is why I am pleading. Please see at where it is clear that once a topic has been the subject of """"significant coverage"""" in accordance with the general notability guideline, it does not need to have ongoing coverage. '''The page is not new'''. Just before relisting it has been accepted by the page deletion proposer that he is popular among Shia and Sunni. It is my simple wording that rule of law is for justice/equilibrium - and not for only punishment or reward""" Deletion of Ali Shanawar WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9058 19969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vodkapundit User:Themfromspace 04:09, 9 March 2009 (UTC) delete per lack of |reliable sources actually discussing the website on hand instead of namedropping it. This doesn't meet our |notability criteria Deletion of Vodkapundit WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9059 5691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Binais Begović User:N2e 03:22, 31 January 2011 (UTC) delete notability not demonstrated in a |reliable secondary source Deletion of Binais Begović WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9060 480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shinigami (Bleach) (2nd nomination) User:Xymmax 16:32, 4 December 2007 (UTC) delete Great article, but its in the face of Wikipedia policy. Bleach is one of the ten most popular pages here, but this is OR, with no showing of real world notability, and written in an in-universe style. I personally like it, but I can't make it pass muster under . Additional comment. Having said all that, 6 weeks is pretty quick for a 2nd AfD. I know but I am concerned that we are destined to go through this process endlessly until we iron out exactly how applies to episodic programs Deletion of Shinigami (Bleach) (2nd nomination) WP:FICT||WP:CCC||WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9061 2595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flies Inside The Sun User:Nigelthefish 14:15, 28 March 2006 (UTC) keep Never heard of them but seems to fit Deletion of Flies Inside The Sun WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9062 19921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NyLon User:JohnCD 18:04, 12 November 2007 (UTC) delete """it's a eologism|neologism and one that I doubt will stick. Also, the first reference link provided is to a """"NYLON Magazine"""" - is this disguised spam""" Deletion of NyLon WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9063 21065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K-hole User:Colonel 12:42, 26 December 2008 (UTC) keep Ketamine is |too long and full of |jargon. This article does a better job of describing the mental effects of this drug Deletion of K-hole WP:SIZE||WP:JARGON Wikipedia:Article size 51
9064 12284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Owned User:Consequentially 07:25, 7 August 2007 (UTC) delete Any discussion of how it used, where it came from, or what it means is . The article sources ''examples'' of the word in use, but that demonstrates its existence. Not it's etymology, not its cultural significance, not its value to the human lexicon. When those sources start cropping up, then we've got something. But until then, this is just a dictionary entry steeped in editor's opinions, and that is unacceptable. Hell, even people in the gaming culture http://www.flexbeta.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=8359 laugh about this article Deletion of Owned WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9065 14005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Racism in the Palestinian territories User:Carwil 15:31, 23 August 2010 (UTC) comment """There is no """"illegitimate topic""""-based argument for deleting this article. Rather, there is a argument and an argument that the text can not be modified to Wikipedia standards. It would seem that ''Delete'' will not achieve consensus, but that does not exhaust the above discussion. Numerous people, mostly voting for delete, have argued that the article must be restarted. Two of us have proposed use of the ''Article Incubator'' or to fix the article. Please weigh in on whether you support that as you comment""" Deletion of Racism in the Palestinian territories WP:SOAPBOX||WP:TNT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9066 16474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keith Bardwell User:Eddie 16:27, 19 October 2009 (UTC) delete clear-cut failure of . Individual has done nothing of note other than show his ass on the national stage by refusing the license and will soon fade into the nothingness he so richly deserves Deletion of Keith Bardwell WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
9067 15692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James J. Riley NONE NONE keep Easily passes notability in academics, Deletion of James J. Riley WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9068 10582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dylan Thomas Theatre User:Accesscrawl 06:32, 29 August 2018 (UTC) keep Passes . New Sources mentioned in RS seems reliable Deletion of Dylan Thomas Theatre WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9069 3030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Micro Award User:HeartSWild 17:35, 3 September 2010 (UTC) merge to Flash fiction. This is a change from my ''keep'' vote. I disagree with some of Kinu's assertions above. I see three |reliable sources currently being used for notability (1, 7, 13). I think the other notable source I previously identified is the now broken link. #1 is not a press release and #7 and #13 are ''clearly'' reliable sources per . The rest of the references are also reliable, just not sources of notability Deletion of Micro Award WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9070 10483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battlefield Baptist Church User:Edison 02:54, 29 August 2007 (UTC) delete There are ways in which a church can be shown to be notable. Generally substantial coverage is required in multiple independent and reliable sources, to satisfy and the more specific . This article fails those Deletion of Battlefield Baptist Church WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9071 14047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/78violet's Yet-to-be-titled album User:Gongshow 19:00, 25 August 2013 (UTC) delete per and . No album title, tracklisting, or release date confirmed in reliable sources at this time; appears too early for this to meet Deletion of 78violet's Yet-to-be-titled album WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9072 21231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alicia Miguel User:Amarkov 23:13, 3 December 2006 (UTC) delete per void throwing a bunch of biased adjectives in to disguise the fact that you don't have much content, and of course the lack of sources. I'm sure some woman with this name exists somewhere, and she's almost certainly not notable Deletion of Alicia Miguel WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
9073 11635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Darwin [[User talk:2over0|2/0]] ([[Special:Contributions/2over0|cont.]]) 08:06, 31 May 2011 (UTC) delete WP:NOTINHERITED seems especially apropos here. is probably the closest subject-specific guideline, but the sources do not seem to support that or the |general notability guideline Deletion of Chris Darwin WP:AUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9074 3456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Hot Box User:Yomangani 14:42, 9 August 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of The Hot Box WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9075 14332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Town Pants User:AdventurousSquirrel 03:45, 11 June 2013 (UTC) delete exclusively self-published sources; fails Deletion of The Town Pants WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9076 21195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brady Hall User:MichaelQSchmidt 00:04, 24 August 2010 (UTC) keep """and improve |through regular editing. Well, as notability guidelines receive """"fine-tuning"""" over time, what was considered notable enough 4 years ago can indeed change. But one has to consider if his being writer/director/producer of several films might be seen as meeting . Did the films themselves receive critical response? As they appear to have received media attention, per , that notability is his""" Deletion of Brady Hall WP:ATD||WP:CREATIVE||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9077 2853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donnegy Fer User:Fenix 13:36, 29 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Donnegy Fer WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9078 19458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bif! Bam! Pow! Wow! User:Stormtracker94 12:08, 30 September 2007 (UTC) delete per and . {{User:Stormtracker94/sig Deletion of Bif! Bam! Pow! Wow! WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9079 13729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerdi Staelens User:Jack 07:34, 24 November 2017 (UTC) delete Insufficient coverage available to meet or Deletion of Gerdi Staelens WP:ANYBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9080 4526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sara Mohmand User:Hmlarson 04:10, 31 July 2017 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Sara Mohmand WP:NBADMINTON Wikipedia:Notability 77
9081 3687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kirsten Lea User:Eggishorn 20:31, 27 December 2016 (UTC) delete A good place to apply . No credible evidence of notability and hoddibly poor article Deletion of Kirsten Lea WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
9082 6220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ispiritista: Itay, may moomoo! User:Northamerica1000 07:12, 24 July 2012 (UTC) keep spaced ndash}} The nomination doesn't contain a valid rationale for deletion, per criterion listed at -REASON. The nomination appears to be based upon the state the article was previously in, rather than upon the ''availability'' of reliable sources. Per , |topic notability is about the ''availability'' of |significant coverage in reliable sources, and not based upon whether or not sources are present in articles Deletion of Ispiritista: Itay, may moomoo! WP:DEL||WP:NRVE||WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9083 6400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Long Point State Park User:Mrschimpf 20:56, 20 October 2013 (UTC) keep Not an article, but a good DAB. Issues with each of the articles should be dealt with individually with a good dose of on each Deletion of Long Point State Park WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9084 21036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All or Nothing (Glee Cast song) User:Chri 13:19, 12 May 2013 (UTC) delete The song has probably been heard by everyone who watched that episode of ''Glee'', so it's obviously been heard pretty widely. Still, from the perspective of , that in and of itself isn't enough for notability. The song hasn't charted independently, and most reviews of the song are also reviews of the episode. I would include a mention of the original song on the page for the episode if it itself is notable, and delete this article Deletion of All or Nothing (Glee Cast song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9085 11127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DMS Derivatives Market Specialist User:Rankiri 13:53, 13 June 2009 (UTC) merge to Canadian Securities Institute per : ''Information on products and services should generally be included in the article on the company itself.'' I don't see any good evidence of standalone notability Deletion of DMS Derivatives Market Specialist WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9086 1566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Amor Torres User:Piotrus 08:58, 18 August 2015 (UTC) delete Borderline. Not seeing anything reliable in books or GNews search. Self-marketed princess, but has some media presence. http://nation.lk/edition/fine/people-and-events/item/39230-the-comeback-of-princess-maria-amor-in-sri-lanka.html is short and mentions her in passing (despite the eye-catching title). http://vancouver.24hrs.ca/ur/story/985614 is similar. http://thehollywoodtimes.net/2014/08/12/princess-amor-is-crowned-as-the-traveling-princess/ is e better, but it seems to be a minor media outlet. No mainstream coverage, all I see is minor/vanity/combined with blogs (CNN entries are 'citizen journalism' - iReport). I think it's vanity entry, at best Deletion of Maria Amor Torres WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
9087 6145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antarctica Journal of Mathematics [[User talk:202.124.74.200|talk]]) 09:51, 1 May 2012 (UTC) comment """It rates a mention on the """"math fail"""" blog, but I don't think that helps at all. -- Special:Contributions/202.124.74.200|202.124.74.200""" Deletion of Antarctica Journal of Mathematics WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9088 616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Medice User:StewdioMACK 04:23, 20 March 2018 (UTC) delete Does not pass and seems to be the musician himself editing Deletion of Christian Medice WP:MUS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9089 16100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Ronald Shapiro User:David 17:29, 13 June 2015 (UTC) delete If there were evidence of notability, we could clean up the promotional material, but he doesn't seem to pass Deletion of Dr. Ronald Shapiro WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9090 10193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Will Viner User:GiantSnowman 23:38, 26 November 2009 (UTC) delete as per nom, fails and Deletion of Will Viner WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9091 9270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ankita Mishra User:DustFormsWords 05:50, 28 April 2010 (UTC) delete """and redirect to Indian Idol 3. The proposition |""""notability is not temporary"""" actually asserts the opposite of what the nominator is implying. It says that if a person is notable at any time, they are notable at all times. I think what the nominator was after was #NEWS, which asserts that Wikipedia is not a news source. That's also not relevant here; coverage of Ms Mishra is sustained over the course of the season and beyond, and is not merely a short burst of coverage. The relevant issue here is actually that |notability is not inherited - Ms Mishra does not appear to be notable independently of Indian Idol and insasmuch as she can be discussed anywhere on Wikipedia it should be at Indian Idol 3 or a similar article""" Deletion of Ankita Mishra WP:NTEMP||WP:NOT||WP:INHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
9092 12984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angolan Brazilian User:Descíclope 00:10, 26 December 2008 (UTC) delete Based on trivial primary source. Not |Notable Deletion of Angolan Brazilian WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9093 20342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sweep Over My Soul User:Jack 00:38, 25 July 2020 (UTC) merge To Luciano (singer) (whom created the album) as an . The album is insufficiently notable to support an independent article per and Deletion of Sweep Over My Soul WP:ATD||WP:NALBUM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9094 7847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dennis the Wild Bull NONE NONE keep meets - 'has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject' (don't have to be positive of the subject) and - '1.The book has been the subject of two or more non-trivial published works appearing in sources that are independent of the book itself' Here are some refs: {{cite web |url=http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1509628-dennis-rodman-writes-childrens-book-dennis-the-wild-bull|website= http://bleacherreport.com|title=Dennis Rodman Writes Children's Book 'Dennis the Wild Bull'|date=31 January 2013|author=Josh Benjamin|publisher= |accessdate=24 February 2015}} ;{{cite web |url=http://newsfeed.time.com/2012/08/02/dennis-rodman-writes-a-childrens-book/|website=http://newsfeed.time.com|title=Dennis Rodman, Terrible Role Model, Writes a Children’s Book|date=2 August 2012|author=Eliana Dockterman |publisher= |accessdate=24 February 2015}} ; {{cite web |url=http://nesn.com/2013/01/dennis-rodman-releases-childrens-book-dennis-the-wild-bull-to-preach-acceptance/|website=http://nesn.com|title=Dennis Rodman Releases Children’s Book ‘Dennis the Wild Bull’ to Preach Acceptance|date=31 January 2013|publisher= |accessdate=24 February 2015}} ; {{cite web |url=http://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/nba-ball-dont-lie/dennis-rodman-released-children-book-obviously-033554396--nba.html|website=http://sports.yahoo.com |title=Dennis Rodman has released a children’s book, obviously|author= Eric Freeman|date=30 January 2013|publisher= |accessdate=24 February 2015 }} ; {{cite web |url=http://uproxx.com/sports/2013/01/dennis-rodman-dennis-the-wild-bull-book-amazon/|website=http://uproxx.com|title=Hold On To Your Butts: Dennis Rodman Wrote A Book About Acceptance For Children Deletion of Dennis the Wild Bull WP:GNG||WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9095 8317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mustafa Hijri User:Reaper 20:23, 29 March 2011 (UTC) keep Meets Deletion of Mustafa Hijri WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9096 11376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pope John Paul II National School User:Davey2010 22:04, 5 July 2014 (UTC) merge to Malahide per long-standing precedent stated at Deletion of Pope John Paul II National School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9097 146 [[Bibelkritik]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Mordan 16:59, 17. Okt. 2007 (CEST) delete Der Artikel liest sich furchtbar und wirkt wie eine Ansammlung von Dingen, ''die man den Christen schon immer mal an den Kopf werfen wollte''. Das meiste Theoriefindung reinsten Wassers. Einige Punkte darin sind der Theologie als Wissenschaft bekannt und werden auch garnicht angezweifelt. Viele angeführten Punkte sind weniger ''Kritik an der Bibel'' als vielmehr ''Kritik an dem Umgang mit der Bibel'', also dem wörtlichen Auslegen einiger Hardliner. Hat alles seine Berechtigung, nur eben nicht hier, da das massiv gegen , WP:NPOV und WP:WSIGA Punkt 2.3, 2.5 verstößt Löschung von Bibelkritik Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
9098 3051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colloquy (company) User:Hut 14:42, 31 December 2011 (UTC) delete """a large number of sources have been added to the article in an attempt to rescue it, but they do not demonstrate notability. Apart from the company website (which is not independent) they are all news articles which report on surveys conducted by Colloquy. Coverage of the company itself is limited to brief descriptions such as """"a marketing consultant and publisher"""" and quotations from people associated with the company. requires that the coverage of the subject is significant and """"passing mention, such as identifying a quoted person as working for an organization"""" is specifically excluded. https://www.wpi.edu/Pubs/E-project/Available/E-project-042408-093903/unrestricted/MGMQPRamsdellRuscittiFinal2008.pdf is an undergraduate report and thus not very reliable, and coverage of the company itself is limited to a passing mention of """"a leading provider of loyalty-marketing information, consulting, research and education"""" in a paragraph about one of their surveys. A search on Google News produces a large number of hits, but on closer inspection they turn out to be brief quotes along the lines of those already in the article or press releases by the company itself. Based on this Colloquy does not satisfy """ Deletion of Colloquy (company) WP:CORP||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9099 4122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Directional Michigan (2nd nomination) User:Jayron32 14:27, 25 March 2010 (UTC) delete or possibly redirect to a term like Mid-major or Mid-American Conference. There is nothing here that can support an ''encyclopedia'' article. At best, we have a |dictionary definition with some sources that ''use the term''. The concept is not covered in depth by any sources, the words are used. There is a BIG difference between a term being ''used'' and a term being ''discussed indepth in reliable sources''. Where we have a Wikipedia article on a word or phrase, we need to demonstrate the latter condition. I don't see that here. The redirect to Mid-American Conference would actually probably work well, since the term ''may'' be a reasonable search term, and all three Directional Michigans are part of that conference Deletion of Directional Michigan (2nd nomination) WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9100 18355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Ron Paul campaign 2008 appearances User:HelloAnnyong 02:51, 2 January 2008 (UTC) delete as per nom. Entirely . &mdash Deletion of List of Ron Paul campaign 2008 appearances WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
9101 7212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delmart Vreeland User:Tiamut 10:47, 26 April 2010 (UTC) keep Delmart Vreeland is notable for what he has said about 9/11. The article in the Toronto Star is just one reliable source discussing this. Others include: http://books.google.ca/books?id=4qnyAAAAMAAJ&q=delmart+vreeland&dq=delmart+vreeland&hl=en&ei=LG3VS8mzF8iK_Abe49ChBA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CDcQ6AEwAA The big wedding: 9/11, the whistle-blowers, and the cover-up by Sander Hicks, originally published by Indiana University; http://books.google.ca/books?id=CA7SrCSWOjcC&q=delmart+vreeland&dq=delmart+vreeland&hl=en&ei=NG7VS9HpHYeC_Aamr53GDw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=6&ved=0CE0Q6AEwBTgK 9/11: the big lie by Thierry Meyssen, published by Carnot Pub; http://books.google.ca/books?id=8Syd6OtQuCIC&pg=PA138&dq=delmart+vreeland&hl=en&ei=LG3VS8mzF8iK_Abe49ChBA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=9&ved=0CFwQ6AEwCA#v=onepage&q=delmart%20vreeland&f= La Pentagate also by Meyssan, published by Ed. T. Paine, http://books.google.ca/books?id=2s1nkNDzUnEC&pg=PA65&dq=delmart+vreeland&hl=en&ei=NG7VS9HpHYeC_Aamr53GDw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=4&ved=0CEQQ6AEwAzgK#v=onepage&q=delmart%20vreeland&f=false The politics of anti-Semitism, edited by Alexander Cockburn and Jeffrey St. Clair in an essay by Kurt Nimmo published by AK Press; an many more. Clearly meets . Kudos to Itabletboy for beginning to clean up the article which was a bloody mess filled with half truths unrelated to the guy's actualy notability at the time of nom for deletion Deletion of Delmart Vreeland WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9102 12793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M.A.D Playhouse User:Gm545 14:51, 2 January 2014 (UTC) delete Not notable. References are press releases, primary sources or other types of sources that may not meet . Basically, it's just another theatre company that hasn't done anything special Deletion of M.A.D Playhouse WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9103 9905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joyce Burditt User:Bakazaka 21:23, 9 August 2018 (UTC) keep Verifiably played a major role in co-creating a significant or well-known work covered in multiple independent newspaper/periodical reviews, so seems to pass #3 Deletion of Joyce Burditt WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9104 13844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/YHWH Aleim User:Shirahadasha 17:29, 7 July 2008 (UTC) delete This is an essay, not an encyclopedia article. Article seems to be |synthesizing various |fringe sources to construct an argument not found in any of them, and seems to be essentially |original research Deletion of YHWH Aleim WP:SYN||WP:FRINGE||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9105 2739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mineral waste User:Alan 07:17, 28 October 2011 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Mineral waste WP:DICTDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9106 14456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Journal of MCH and AIDS User:Headbomb 10:35, 3 June 2018 (UTC) delete """per Randikitty, complete fail of /. The keep arguments above are meritless. This journal is literally indexed nowhere {{MIAR|2161-8674}} (save for DOAJ/PMC, which indexes everything OA/everything OA in medicine that isn't predatory and even then they still include predatory stuff), and with roughly 5 articles being cited more than 10 times through its life (now 6+ years), this journal made pretty much no/very little impact in medicine. Notability is more than just """"is this journal predatory?"""". It's """"did this journal make an demonstrable impact?"""" Could be a case , but right now the answer to that second question is ''no, it did not""" Deletion of International Journal of MCH and AIDS WP:NJOURNALS||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
9107 16497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harvest Raleigh User:Hanyangprofessor2 04:30, 3 April 2017 (UTC) delete Does not seem like a notable church/congregation. Fails (and Wikipedia:Notability (churches) didn't pass, so Deletion of Harvest Raleigh WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9108 354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Curb stomping User:Paiev 02:06, 14 December 2007 (UTC) delete per and . As a comment, it is not . There seems to have been an AfD on this before that I cannot find; however, the old page can at least be seen through a google cache. The deleted version was far more encyclopedic than this. —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Curb stomping WP:NEO||WP:DICT||WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9109 8994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Infinitism (religion) User:Sketch051 02:37, 23 April 2006 (UTC) keep """An obvious vote, since I'm the author; no, I am not David Haley. I like to peruse the philosophy portal and happened upon the article that I spun off into Infinitism (philosophy), which contained a brief sentence about Infinitism also being the name of a religion; subsequent Googling turned up Haley's site. It seemed sufficiently different from the infinitist epistomological concept to warrant a separate entry, but only a stub (which I tagged it as from the beginning). The reference to Universism was an admittedly hasty response to the first {{importance}} tag, and could be reasonably removed; the article was NOT """"set up as competition for the already barely-if-that notable Universism."""" Application of the policy, since this is in reference to religion, seems odd since most people would consider any religion other than their own """"things made up ... one day."""" I apologize if I inappropriately removed the {{importance}} tag; this is my first time creating an article (for future reference, who decides when an {{importance}} tag can be reasonably removed?). I can't respond to the """"nn"""" comment as I am not familiar with that abbreviation""" Deletion of Infinitism (religion) WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
9110 14961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virtual Family Kingdom User:Marasmusine 08:08, 24 May 2008 (UTC) delete article has not been built on ; no prejudice at all against recreation later, if it receives more attention from the press Deletion of Virtual Family Kingdom WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9111 943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rochester Institute of Technology Model Railroad Club User:LonelyBeacon 02:41, 13 December 2007 (UTC) delete The reference article is not about the club, but about a single event sponsored by the club. , I am pretty sure, states that single events like this do not establish notability, even if they are covered in a legitimate secondary source Deletion of Rochester Institute of Technology Model Railroad Club WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9112 3716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plotches User:Quarl NONE delete as Wikipedia:Avoid_neologisms|non-notable unverifiable unstable neologism, i.e. protologism (|Wikipedia is not a dictionary). &mdash Deletion of Plotches WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9113 10375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Louise Young User:Armbrust 13:12, 13 September 2010 (UTC) delete as article fails |notability criteria for pornographic actors Deletion of Sarah Louise Young WP:PORNSTAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9114 15855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cartoon-style shooter User:Stifle 20:37, 30 April 2008 (UTC) delete unless |citations from |reliable sources are added to comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Cartoon-style shooter WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9115 9958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SOCi (social media marketing) User:MelanieN 17:59, 15 April 2015 (UTC) delete """Fails . And no wonder considering that the company is less than 3 years old. The """"awards"""" are trivial, and the only sources are routine stuff about obtaining funding and hiring staff""" Deletion of SOCi (social media marketing) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9116 14965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bullying in academia User:Bearian 18:42, 10 March 2011 (UTC) keep per . When I remove a speedy or ProD tag, it is often only for procedural reasons, as was here. However, I think this has been extensively rescued. When I removed said tag http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bullying_in_academia&diff=416960057&oldid=416951264 it was a bare-bones stub, but is now a really |well-cited article Deletion of Bullying in academia WP:HEY||WP:RS Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
9117 17190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jin Jung Kwan Hapkido User:Piotrus 06:44, 6 October 2013 (UTC) delete as they currently stand they clearly fail Deletion of Jin Jung Kwan Hapkido WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9118 15262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Dean User:Szyslak 10:19, 13 November 2016 (UTC) delete per nom. This would not |merit an article if not for his brother Deletion of Charles Dean WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9119 10659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ThreeChess User:Rorshacma 16:55, 7 November 2019 (UTC) delete per concerns brought up by the nominator - this article is just on a single variant of chess created by a company to promote their website. It also seems to have been created by a whose only edits to Wikipedia were to create this page, and then promote it on various other pages. I am unable to find any reliable sources discussing this particular website, as well. All of the actual reliable sources being used in the article are actually referring to Three-player chess, not this specific website's variant of it. If it is deleted, its entry should also be removed from the Three-player chess article as well, for similar reasons of non-notability and promotion Deletion of ThreeChess WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
9120 440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/INVEA-TECH (2nd nomination) User:Stuartyeates 20:54, 11 March 2014 (UTC) delete as lacking in depth coverage in independent third party sources as required by the Deletion of INVEA-TECH (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9121 11632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Klemmer User:Pak21 14:08, 8 September 2006 (UTC) delete unless evidence showing they satisfy is found Deletion of Michael Klemmer WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
9122 6764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Massie User:GiantSnowman 12:40, 28 July 2011 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Steve Massie WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9123 20493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scorio User:TexasAndroid 16:23, 21 January 2011 (UTC) delete """Fails . At best we have one independent review. criteria 1 requires """"multiple"""". And 1 is not """"multiple"""". The arguments from the SPA parade above all are either or argue reasons for inclusion that have nothing to do with Wikipedia's inclusion criteria""" Deletion of Scorio WP:WEB||WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9124 18015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Every Avenue (rapper) User:Gongshow 00:23, 18 April 2013 (UTC) delete I'm not finding anything on Google to indicate this person was involved in the songs mentioned in the article. Even if this is not a |hoax, the subject does not meet or at this time Deletion of Every Avenue (rapper) WP:HOAX||WP:GNG||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
9125 7576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carson Optical User:Otr500 06:59, 7 August 2021 (UTC) delete """Per HighKing. Fails Wikipedia:NCORP|NCORP big time. Neither of the WSJ articles offers more than Wikipedia:Trivial mentions|trivial mention on the subject. The NYT article (''For a Boat or the Ball Game, Flexible Binoculars'') does not even mention Carson Optical only Richard Cameron, president, """"Copitar"""", the """"Japanese optics manufacturer"""" and """"Cameron International of Huntington, L.I."""", that """"imports electronic binoculars"""". This is the first three I randomly checked and the last one appears to only be |citation overkill. The American Hunter source is a ''Review: Carson RD-826'' with only one paragraph about the company and owner. The company info consists: """"that Carson Optical was started in 1990"""". That is zero for 4. The ''Indoor Outdoor source offers infor that ''Carson Optical Expands HQ''. This is far from in-depth sourcing on the company just about the expansion. The Bloomberg source offers one paragraph. The Long Island Business News is behind a paywall but is titled ''Carson Optical expanding in Ronkonkoma'' so both the last two are concerning the company expansion and are press-release type sources. I do not propose to offer that the company does not exist. I own a Carson PO-55 MiniBrite Pocket Magnifier. Notability means more than passing mentions and press releases (|routine coverage) showing that a company exists. """"Keep"""" comments because """"Wikipedia has a big shelf"""" or """"the article has useful information about the company"""" are really just |""""I like it""" Deletion of Carson Optical WP:REFBOMB||WP:ROUTINE||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Citation overkill 60
9126 6592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yahweh (disambiguation) User:Dacium 22:18, 15 February 2007 (UTC) keep as revised now it has for keeping. —The preceding Wikipedia:Sign your posts on talk pages|unsigned comment was added by Deletion of Yahweh (disambiguation) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
9127 6272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Field User:Lradrama 15:06, 16 October 2007 (UTC) delete fails otability. Non-notable, local stadium Deletion of Bruce Field WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9128 1394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chant Noël: Chants For The Holiday Season User:CooperDB 12:46, 16 August 2013 (UTC) keep This album peaked at http://www.allmusic.com/album/chant-noel-mw0000635665/awards 3rd position on the Billboard Top Classical Album chart in 1994. This may be sufficient to meet and . Certainly, if not, then the article should be merged with Chant (Benedictine Monks of Santo Domingo de Silos album) which is clearly notable Deletion of Chant Noël: Chants For The Holiday Season WP:NSONG||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9129 18243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shuang Sheng User:Simonm223 14:45, 13 September 2018 (UTC) delete This artist doesn't appear to meet standards, let alone Deletion of Shuang Sheng WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9130 16298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Redfield & Wilton Strategies User:Extraordinary 05:21, 16 May 2021 (UTC) delete the fact that |other stuff exists doesn't bear on notability: the question is whether there's significant coverage in reliable secondary sources. All I'm seeing is single-sentence |trivial mentions, which don't cut it. If in-depth coverage about the company itself is found, I'm glad to reëvaluate, but my searches aren't yielding anything Deletion of Redfield & Wilton Strategies WP:OSE||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9131 10024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dainin Katagiri User:Tychocat 09:45, 27 August 2006 (UTC) delete """for failing , not having multiple non-trivial third-party articles. also fails since no evidence his books have met any of those requirements (adopted as a textbook, best seller, mutiple major reviews). keep noms beg the question by stating """"appears to have notability"""" without documentation, or wishing for broader standards of notability - this is the standard we have now, and it's a level playing field for all. Change the notability guidelines if you must, but this is what we have to work with""" Deletion of Dainin Katagiri WP:BIO||WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9132 15412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of papabili in the 2013 papal conclave User:Purplebackpack89 05:06, 20 March 2013 (UTC) delete per what happened in 2005, per the fact that this can never be a discriminate list, since we'll never know who actually received votes, and per that long list of violations above Deletion of List of papabili in the 2013 papal conclave WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9133 873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Foodjunky.com User:Shoy 14:46, 24 July 2017 (UTC) delete Sources fails . Nothing notable in Deletion of Foodjunky.com WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9134 18966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nadine Dajani User:AllyD 10:40, 24 November 2013 (UTC) delete """There is a http://www.rtbookreviews.com/book-review/fashionably-late-0 Romantic Times Online review of her first novel, apparently also reviewed in """"Library Journal"""", but I am not finding anything to meet the criteria""" Deletion of Nadine Dajani :WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9135 4643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 Southeastern Conference football officiating controversy User:SportingFlyer 00:26, 14 May 2019 (UTC) delete you can probably write these sorts of articles for any season in any sport that gets covered in the media. The kicker for me on front is there is no article that covers the controversy as a whole, so there's a issue as well Deletion of 2009 Southeastern Conference football officiating controversy WP:GNG||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
9136 2892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rob Schwager User:Shirahadasha 09:42, 3 January 2007 (UTC) comment This article doesn't have any sources meeting at all, so as things stand vote would have to be '''Delete'''. If you have sources establishing Schwager's |notability etc., perhaps you could add them and this could be reconsidered Deletion of Rob Schwager WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9137 20722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hollie Hughes (politician) User:E 15:17, 5 November 2018 (UTC) keep has the to keep Deletion of Hollie Hughes (politician) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
9138 16406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicole Wood User:Carrite 14:12, 4 May 2011 (UTC) keep """The use of automated tools for mass deletions should not be allowed against large blocks of articles which have already been patrolled at New Pages. It is, simply put, a violation of — due diligence is not being done when these tools are being used in this way. """"Shoot them all and let the saps at AfD sort them out,"""" is apparently the line of thinking. While I am personally sympathetic to the idea of a very high bar for so-called """"Porn Bios,"""" this blasting of 100 articles at the rate of 1 per minute, judging from the time logs, is not conducive to the spirit or practice of AfD. It is putting DON'T LIKE IT ahead of the established article deletion process and is disrespectful both to the work of article creators and those of us who volunteer our time at AfD. We have seen similar automated mass annihilation efforts recently against modern Trotskyist political organizations and against fraternities and sororities. The net result of these efforts was a lot of lost time by article creators and AfD participants and a lot of lost information from those articles annihilated as part of these campaigns. Meanwhile, the backlog of crap at New Pages festers. Something needs to be done about this problem. Mine is not a unique view — see Wikipedia:ANI#Massive_number_of_Playboy-related_AFD_nominations_by_a_single_user at ANI. We need to keep them all as a matter of principle and ban the future use of automated tools in this way. ''This argument will be copied-and-pasted in the debate sections for all automated AfDs of this campaign""" Deletion of Nicole Wood WP:BEFORE||WP:I Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9139 12489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce K. Ferguson User:XOR 17:24, 7 September 2018 (UTC) comment I don't have time for a deep dive today, but it appears that Ferguson held a named chair up until his retirement in 2015 https://issuu.com/ccdp/docs/final-cednews-spring2015, being Franklin Professor of Landscape Architecture. In addition, he was elected a Fellow of the American Society of Landscape Architects in 1994 (verifiable through https://www.asla.org/fellowsdatabase.aspx). This suggests a pass of #C5 and #C3 Deletion of Bruce K. Ferguson WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9140 19737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Houston–Rice rivalry User:Ejgreen77 00:16, 23 April 2020 (UTC) keep Meets and per the sources brought forward above Deletion of Houston–Rice rivalry WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9141 21759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of dental practice management software User:Camaron1 13:05, 20 December 2007 (UTC) delete Article does not follow or . This kind of information can be included in individual software articles if they are notable anyway Deletion of Comparison of dental practice management software WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9142 8368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Superbook User:JTdale 11:37, 13 July 2014 (UTC) keep Deleting a page is definitely not the correct way to go about trying to fix it. isn't a policy either, and eletion_policy#Alternatives_to_deletion suggests that one should always edit not delete if possible. That said, we shouldn't be accusing people of being beginners because we disagree with them Deletion of Superbook WP:TNT||WP:D Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
9143 5610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Central European Diabetes Association User:Peterkingiron 22:56, 4 October 2009 (UTC) keep I suspect that the lack of Ghits is because any on the subject will be in German or other Central European languages, not English Deletion of Central European Diabetes Association WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9144 10967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander R. Povolotsky's problem 1 User:JohnCD 15:40, 11 October 2008 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not the place for first publication Deletion of Alexander R. Povolotsky's problem 1 WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9145 503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Freshwater library User:RC 02:47, 5 April 2008 (UTC) delete no refs, |non-notable public place Deletion of Freshwater library WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9146 10735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benjamin W.S. Lum User:Pharaoh 04:45, 1 December 2015 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Benjamin W.S. Lum WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9147 10829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeny & Zory User:Edtropolis 16:14, 14 June 2007 (UTC) keep Passes criteria of and Deletion of Zeny & Zory WP:MUSIC||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9148 4432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wade Load User:NickPenguin 21:22, 1 January 2008 (UTC) merge all non-major characters to List of Kim Possible characters, clearly. AfD is not a replacement for foresight and |being bold Deletion of Wade Load WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
9149 15934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Longview Solutions Inc. [[User_talk:Dlohcierekim| :) Dlohcierekim]] 01:46, 14 September 2006 (UTC) delete Found no evidence of Deletion of Longview Solutions Inc. WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9150 6463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crappling User:Haemo 02:24, 6 January 2007 (UTC) delete under Deletion of Crappling WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9151 21815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FLIRG User:Edison 04:09, 16 September 2008 (UTC) delete """Not every word uttered in a sketch on Saturday Night Live deserves an encyclopedia article, especially when no one agrees on what meaning is attached to it. This word is also spelled """"flurge"""" and is defined as """"flush and purge"""" as in cleaning your ear canals of ear waxhttp://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=flurge , http://profilesblog.com/2008/09/flurg-flerg-flerj/. Fails |verifiability and has no reason to remain in Wikipedia. There are no reliable sources with a history of the use of this word, however spelled. It was a comic utterance of no particular meaning, set in counterpoint to the sexually oriented four letter acronyms ending in """"ilf"""" descriptions of Palin, and thus not notable""" Deletion of FLIRG WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9152 17095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mole Listening Pearls User:Christopher 01:34, 14 August 2007 (UTC) keep It is a notable record label, it just may not seem so because most the artists are popular in Germany; however, some artists, such as Wax Tailor, Naomi (band)|Naomi, Anima Sound System, and De Phazz are somewhat popular in the U.S. and tour in the U.S. Further, objective evidence of notability per is shown on the Talk:Mole Listening Pearls |talk page and I will expand the article in the next few days Deletion of Mole Listening Pearls WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9153 1460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2Sides User:Kraxler 15:04, 1 August 2015 (UTC) keep passes , see http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/23299010-2sides this, http://www.insidefutbol.com/2014/10/29/it-oozes-class-like-an-essex-night-out-manchester-united-legend-rio-ferdinands-2sides-reviewed/168467/ this, https://emmaloubookblog.wordpress.com/2014/10/29/review-of-2sides-my-autobiography-by-rio-ferdinand/ this, http://isnsoccer.com/news/2014/11/06/2sides-rio-ferdinand-review/ this and http://www.wsc.co.uk/reviews/64-Players/12051-2sides this Deletion of 2Sides WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9154 3432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Covenant Reformed Presbyterian Church User:StAnselm 08:42, 22 September 2011 (UTC) keep Actually, I think all ''denominations'' (rather than churches) are ''de facto'' notable. Articles such as this are Wikipedia:Ignore all rules|useful to the encyclopedia for people wishing to navigate through the maze that is Presbyterianism. :Category:Presbyterian denominations and List of Presbyterian denominations in Australia illustrate the sort of thing I mean. |Size doesn't matter of course Deletion of Covenant Reformed Presbyterian Church WP:NOTBIGENOUGH Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9155 5527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tonite Reprise User:Fuzzy510 07:08, 13 August 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. A straight failure of Deletion of Tonite Reprise WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9156 2972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor Septimus Pretorius User:Cirt 17:45, 20 December 2007 (UTC) delete as per above, and as unsourced Deletion of Doctor Septimus Pretorius WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9157 11533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Extractable User:K 02:04, 22 September 2016 (UTC) delete per ; strictly advertising. No indications of notability or significance Deletion of Extractable WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9158 17995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Kushiel's Legacy characters User:Jfgslo 01:29, 17 September 2011 (UTC) delete Per the criteria of |appropriate topics for lists, this list of characters is a topic that is trivial, non-encyclopedic, or not related to human knowledge since it falls into what WP:!|what Wikipedia is not by being a |summary-only description of a fictional work, so it is not appropriate for Wikipedia. Also, |notability guidelines apply to the inclusion of stand-alone lists, and the subject of this one, a list of characters from a fictional series, has not been discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources, so the topic of the list does not meet the |general notability guideline. Because of this, I think this list is an |unnecessary split of the several Kushiel's Legacy-related articles, where the plot and main characters are already mentioned, so it should be deleted Deletion of List of Kushiel's Legacy characters WP:SALAT||WP:PLOT||WP:LISTN||WP:GNG||WP:AVOIDSPLIT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
9159 19625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of marathon fatalities User:Smartyllama 13:18, 8 May 2017 (UTC) keep but cleanup. It's a notable topic band consistent with various similar articles, but could use some work. Still, |AFD is not cleanup. So that's not a reason for deletion. And I should point out that many similar articles include non-notable individuals if their deaths received substantial coverage, but they weren't notable before then. So this article may be fine as is. In any event, that's a content dispute, not a deletion issue Deletion of List of marathon fatalities WP:AFDISNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9160 20089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alejandro Gómez Bermúdez User:Sulfurboy 07:33, 31 July 2015 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Alejandro Gómez Bermúdez WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9161 2914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Williams (businessman) User:Pharaoh 08:18, 16 April 2015 (UTC) delete per nom and fails Deletion of Ryan Williams (businessman) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9162 7067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/80,000 Hours User:Rhododendrites 14:33, 4 February 2014 (UTC) keep I have a problem with |COI editing as much as anyone, but the list of sources above seems pretty difficult to dispute. I haven't looked through all of them but already see 4 or 5 that quite clearly not just mention but ''cover'' 80,000 Hours. Passes GNG and CORPDEPTH given this list. --&mdash Deletion of 80,000 Hours WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
9163 3111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Verity Price User:E 20:14, 11 January 2019 (UTC) delete appears to be PROMO for a nonnotable performer, fails , fails . Not to be confused with the Verity Price who shows prize Herefords https://www.crookwellgazette.com.au/story/3821022/spotlight-on-verity-price Deletion of Verity Price WP:MUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9164 19836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nitro PDF User:Northamerica1000 09:50, 5 May 2013 (UTC) keep for passing : http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/nitro-pdf-reader-out-to-blow-away-adobe-1983068.html, http://www.bizjournals.com/sanfrancisco/print-edition/2010/12/10/nitro-pdf-detonates-sales.html, http://www.pcworld.com/article/230990/Nitro_PDF_Reader.html Deletion of Nitro PDF WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9165 13325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ten Towns User:Jclemens 05:31, 10 July 2017 (UTC) merge per BOZ and -M. I'll note that K.e.coffman's opinion is ''not'' policy based, in that primary sources are perfectly acceptable to verify uncontroversial content; they just don't count towards notability Deletion of Ten Towns WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9166 13615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LightON ~ enlight the enigma User:Dialectric 18:03, 17 March 2015 (UTC) delete software article of unclear notability, lacking independent references, created by an Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|SPA as promotional, as stated above. A search turned up no coverage of this software Deletion of LightON ~ enlight the enigma WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9167 21222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerry Joe Weise (2nd nomination) User:SportingFlyer 13:25, 21 October 2019 (UTC) comment By a quick count, 25 of the 198 sources presented in the article are refrenced to Vimeo. Many are offline. Picking thru whether he's notable will take a lot of work. If by chance any keep !voter wanders by, if you could present for me, that'd be much appreciated Deletion of Gerry Joe Weise (2nd nomination) WP:THREE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9168 13250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paris 1850 User:Tacyarg 20:49, 24 April 2019 (UTC) delete Does not meet Deletion of Paris 1850 WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9169 8104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vivek Venugopal User:Sodabottle 13:36, 29 December 2010 (UTC) delete per . There are a lot of articles by him, but none on him Deletion of Vivek Venugopal WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9170 13417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Index of Andhra Pradesh-related articles User:Colapeninsula 11:09, 24 July 2015 (UTC) comment An alphabetised list like this is totally inappropriate and impossible to navigate (although paradoxically it's probably easy to maintain, e.g. by robot). A properly categorised index would be really useful and definitely merit a keep (and could co-exist with a category per ). Even if it was trimmed down to a list of lists that would be useful: to pluck a few out at random List of birds of Andhra Pradesh, List of cabinet ministers of Andhra Pradesh, List of Chief Ministers of Andhra Pradesh, List of cities in Andhra Pradesh by population, List of dams and reservoirs in Andhra Pradesh. Rather than unilateral action, I'd like to see some consensus on what should be done, and AfD really isn't the best place for that Deletion of Index of Andhra Pradesh-related articles WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
9171 886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of nightclubs in Rome User:Spiderone 17:42, 6 December 2016 (UTC) delete per and several other policies already mentioned in the nom Deletion of List of nightclubs in Rome WP:NOTLINKFARM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9172 4162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon Larsson User:Rebbing 14:05, 16 March 2016 (UTC) comment The specific notability guideline for motorsports is . I don't have time to look into it properly, but a cursory look suggests that the subject doesn't meet either that specific guideline or the more general notability guidelines Deletion of Simon Larsson WP:NMOTORSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9173 21154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nazir Jahangir User:Flibirigit 18:45, 10 January 2008 (UTC) delete Fails , and Deletion of Nazir Jahangir WP:N||WP:BIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
9174 3954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Treanor (2nd nomination) User:Atlantic306 16:08, 4 May 2019 (UTC) keep as passes with prominent roles in notable productions so needs to be included in the encyclopedia Deletion of Michael Treanor (2nd nomination) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9175 2082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joel Britton User:Enos733 05:27, 25 April 2013 (UTC) delete I Only three of the sources cited in the article appear to be about the subject (all in relationship to an election). The Los Angeles Times did not cover his run in 1989, and did run a short bio in 2004 http://articles.latimes.com/2003/aug/16/local/me-bios16. My sense is that the subject has not been covered by multiple sources in a significant manner. The subject does not meet Deletion of Joel Britton WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9176 563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Statue of Thomas Cass User:Ad 03:40, 10 October 2019 (UTC) keep There are a large number of sources that discuss the subject, although some are brief. The subject is a well known artistic object within a nationally recognized historic site. While good faith is not in doubt, the nomination appears to have been premature and done without due regard for . I would encourage the OP to withdraw their nomination Deletion of Statue of Thomas Cass WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9177 6387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cults and new religious movements in literature and popular culture User:Otto4711 16:57, 22 February 2007 (UTC) delete """as an #IINFO|indiscriminate list and #DIR|directory which is designed to capture any reference to a """"cult"""" (which suffers from POV definitional problems) or """"new religious movements"""" that appear in any medium, regardless of the importance or lack of same either within the fictional work or the real world. The instinct to remove garbage information from the Cult article was a good one, but the proper solution is to delete the information entirely rather than turn it into someone else's problem by dumping it off into a trash bin list article. is not a justification for keeping this article""" Deletion of Cults and new religious movements in literature and popular culture WP:NOT||WP:NOT||WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9178 13853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Megan Kufeld (2nd nomination) User:Joseph2302 15:27, 16 May 2016 (UTC) keep The coverage about her is not just |run-of-the-mill, it is significant enough to pass Deletion of Megan Kufeld (2nd nomination) WP:MILL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
9179 12354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Facebook Four User:Closeapple 03:00, 16 January 2017 (UTC) merge """or just plain '''Delete''' as #A10: Duplicate topic to 2017 Chicago torture incident. We don't need a launched for it. I don't see """"Facebook Four"""" except on the CBS Chicago and its duplicate copies. If you do a Google search, """"the Facebook Four"""" was used for different groups of people over the last 10 years in different articles""" Deletion of The Facebook Four WP:CSD||WP:NEOLOGISM Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9180 8019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Davao Light & Power Co., Inc. User:Uzma 22:57, 26 August 2012 (UTC) keep per . It's the second biggest power utility in the Philippines. There's about 20 news articles with Davao Light in the title of the news article, http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=2479&dat=20020518&id=uq41AAAAIBAJ&sjid=dyUMAAAAIBAJ&pg=884,28627261, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-19931326_ITM, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-19959699_ITM, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-20546708_ITM, http://www.afrim.org.ph/Archives/2005/BusinessWorld/January/26/Davao%20Light%20and%20Power%20loan.txt, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/article-1G1-136537275/davao-light-substation.html, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/article-1G1-136873619/aboitiz-davao-light-sells.html, http://www.afrim.org.ph/Archives/2005/BusinessWorld/October/07/Davao%20Light%20purchase.htm, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/article-1G1-142670593/regulator-lets-davao-light.html, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/article-1G1-148393825/davao-light-goes-into.html, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/article-1G1-148652723/davao-light-commission-substation.html, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/article-1G1-159266225/davao-light-power-tapped.html, http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P3-1231648261.html, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/article-1G1-160519883/davao-light-boosts-plant.html, http://services.inquirer.net/mobile/08/06/19/html_output/xmlhtml/20080614-142635-xml.html, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/article-1G1-190140261/davao-light-offers-power.html, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/article-1G1-222300407/davao-light-signs-de.html, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/article-1G1-234051016/davao-light-and-power.html, http://positivenewsmedia.com/blog/2012/05/davao-light-firm-invests-p2-5-m-for-mobile-tracking-system/, etc., and 400+ more news articles mentioning Davao Lighthttp://www.accessmylibrary.com/search/?q=Davao+Light+%26+Power Deletion of Davao Light & Power Co., Inc. WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9181 6209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TRL Music User:Qworty 20:19, 23 October 2012 (UTC) delete It is nothing but the purest Deletion of TRL Music WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
9182 283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frazer Brown User:Mendaliv 12:13, 1 December 2008 (UTC) delete I'm not seeing anything to indicate this person passes or . &mdash Deletion of Frazer Brown WP:CREATIVE||WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
9183 21153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thodoris Moschonas (2nd nomination) User:Sir 15:18, 17 May 2011 (UTC) delete As stated above, he very clearly fails . The references all appear to be routine sports journalism and are therefore insufficient for Deletion of Thodoris Moschonas (2nd nomination) WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9184 4563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sea Urchin Editions User:SarahStierch 16:48, 6 April 2014 (UTC) delete Failed to pass and for me Deletion of Sea Urchin Editions WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9185 10561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandoz, California User:TimothyBlue 01:01, 26 July 2020 (UTC) delete Article does not meet . // Deletion of Sandoz, California WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9186 11759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ferenc Miskolczi User:David 08:30, 21 February 2014 (UTC) delete His mainstream scientific contributions do not have the impact (e.g. citation counts) to pass and his climate change sideline does not pass Deletion of Ferenc Miskolczi WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9187 7496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mission: Price User:onel5969 15:42, 6 November 2018 (UTC) delete Simply fails Deletion of Mission: Price WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9188 7399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Fugger User:BU 08:44, 22 August 2015 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass , , or . Very little coverage beyond routine information about sports transactions Deletion of Tim Fugger WP:GNG||WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
9189 7171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nikki Wong User:Eddie 00:12, 5 June 2009 (UTC) delete as unsourced . I mean, where does all the character detail come from? Is it OR Deletion of Nikki Wong WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
9190 12600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ajilimójili sauce User:Flyguy649 03:55, 24 April 2008 (UTC) delete per above and some are not in English. I'd suggest speedy, but speedy is excluded for terms ( see Wikipedia:Csd#Non-criteria Deletion of Ajilimójili sauce WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9191 8376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanveer Sipra User:Sdmarathe 04:17, 22 January 2018 (UTC) delete Fails per nom, no reliable sources provided to prove notability Deletion of Tanveer Sipra WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9192 5044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Chestney (2nd nomination) User:Xxanthippe 05:38, 30 June 2017 (UTC) delete Sources are not adequate to support or uthor Deletion of Kim Chestney (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:A Wikipedia:Notability 77
9193 4011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Saunders User:CaSJer 21:00, 19 December 2012 (UTC) delete Fails because he only has two fights for top tier organizations. Being a former UFC fighter doesn't make him notable, notability is not inherited. When/if he passes the MMANOT guidelines, the article can be recreated Deletion of Chris Saunders WP:MMANOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9194 14339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Marwood (2nd nomination) User:Jmorrison230582 14:35, 2 July 2014 (UTC) comment he appears to have been allocated squad number 10 by St. Mirren, which would indicate that he is more than likely to play for their first team this season. Although it does also appear to be a case of Deletion of James Marwood (2nd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
9195 11328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Pietrucha User:Joe 22:52, 30 September 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |director Deletion of Daniel Pietrucha WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9196 13185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rich Iott User:Davewild 16:40, 22 December 2010 (UTC) keep """Easily meets the main general notability guideline, with enough coverage for us to write a proper biography of his life, not being elected does not mean he is not notable. As olitician says """"Just being an elected local official, or an unelected candidate for political office, does not guarantee notability, although such people can still be notable if they meet the primary notability criterion of """"significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject of the article."""" This article does have significant coverage so he does meet olitician""" Deletion of Rich Iott WP:P||WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
9197 4082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barton Hawkins User:David 23:14, 22 November 2010 (UTC) delete I couldn't find any verification for his claimed biochemical advances, the idea of using the shareware model for creative content is not original to him, the citation record is not enough for , and what else is there Deletion of Barton Hawkins WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9198 13747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Louisville-Virginia football rivalry User:The 18:07, 25 June 2018 (UTC) keep The subject is a perhaps not very widely known but it is quite established, |in terms of Wikipedia, as |notable Deletion of Louisville-Virginia football rivalry WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9199 10301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Romulans (band) User:doomsdayer520 18:52, 13 February 2020 (UTC) delete WP:1E applies as the band only received reliable media coverage due to the lawsuit. As for their music, because they started in the early 80s there may be a shortage of online sources, but they seem to have reunited in the Internet era and there is still no |significant and reliable coverage online or elsewhere. I tried searching for the band name in conjunction with various members' names and found nothing beyond basic listings of their existence and modern social media attempts to drum up interest in their obscure history Deletion of The Romulans (band) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
9200 16101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Project Galactic Guide User:Starblind 17:08, 19 December 2009 (UTC) delete doesn't pass Deletion of Project Galactic Guide WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
9201 10979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Public asset management User:Bearian 18:40, 26 February 2013 (UTC) delete per or . I can't tell if it's ''actually'' |spam masquerading as a real article, because it's so poorly written Deletion of Public asset management WP:TNT||WP:COATRACK||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
9202 13121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Presidents (song) User:Blodance 07:51, 20 January 2010 (UTC) delete """Other than sites like YouTube and educational blogs/forums, I failed to find any RS mentioning this song. DRosenbach, does not override - Wikipedia is not about he Truth|The TruthTM, its about |verifiability. Anything not supported by RSs does not belong to Wikipedia, unless they are so obvious that virtually every reader either already believe in it(""""we can't live without food"""") or can verify it with reasonable ease(""""cutting your hand with a knife will cause pain""""). Same for |notablity: Wikipedia is OT|not an indiscriminate collection of info. In order to be worth including, they need to be notable, and notability is established by |reliable sources""" Deletion of The Presidents (song) WP:IAR||WP:5P||WP:T||WP:V||WP:N||WP:NOT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
9203 4229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pro-Hunter User:TenPoundHammer 17:59, 20 May 2007 (UTC) comment Forums are not |reliable sources. Also, if the watch was the subject of an auction, then that might mean that the ''auction'' is notable -- it doesn't necessarily mean the ''watch'' is Deletion of Pro-Hunter WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9204 12991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sporting Clube Ressano Garcia User:Stifle 22:37, 16 May 2008 (UTC) delete WP:V|Verifiability is an issue for this article which does not |cite any |reliable sources Deletion of Sporting Clube Ressano Garcia WP:CITE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9205 7247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baby mentor User:Stormtracker94 13:58, 14 October 2007 (UTC) delete per , , and Deletion of Baby mentor WP:NEO||WP:COI||WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9206 12318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vamosa User:Scorpiondollprincess 19:38, 17 July 2006 (UTC) keep but cleanup. It currently reads like a brochure for the company, and the only links provided are from the corporation itself. However, a google search yields plenty of other results, including a small amount of independent media coverage http://www.sundayherald.com/55591 http://econtentmag.com/Articles/ArticleReader.aspx?ArticleID=15949 http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0ECZ/is_2003_July_9/ai_104982495 satisfying criteria 1 of Deletion of Vamosa WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9207 12093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fang Liu (statistician) User:XOR 00:30, 22 August 2021 (UTC) comment Though I don't have examples at my fingertips, this sort of situation has arisen before: a woman is notable by some guideline like , an article is created, and she requests deletion even though, to a bystander, the article seems to contain nothing that wasn't already in her faculty profile website. It's worrisome. I'd prefer not to have holes in the encyclopedia's coverage, but I also don't want the encyclopedia to make innocent people's lives worse Deletion of Fang Liu (statistician) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9208 1626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natalie Rose LeBrecht User:Missvain 16:47, 21 May 2021 (UTC) delete Appears to be for the subject to have her own article. The sourcing in the article does not help her meet nor . I did my own due diligence, using her name and her stage name Greenpot Bluepot and found little to nothing. Her real name just brought up the usual suspects of primary sources and websites to download her music. Greenpot Bluepot had small fry local publications and blogs Deletion of Natalie Rose LeBrecht WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Too soon 40
9209 5061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cristy Joy User:Porqin 20:24, 8 August 2006 (UTC) delete Fails , no real estabilishment of |notability Deletion of Cristy Joy WP:BIO||WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9210 11100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josipa Kusić User:CaroleHenson 03:29, 14 December 2016 (UTC) delete I am not finding enough to prove |notability Deletion of Josipa Kusić WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9211 5013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Attard F.C. User:Aloolkaparatha 09:45, 22 April 2021 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Attard F.C. WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9212 14559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James C. Russell User:Bearian NONE comment either |blow it up or fix it up as a perennial candidate Deletion of James C. Russell WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
9213 16389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gulfstream Pictures User:HighKing 13:24, 18 May 2018 (UTC) delete No indications of notability, a run-of-the-mill company, fails GNG and Deletion of Gulfstream Pictures WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9214 10865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Knee bone football User:Gobonobo 08:23, 26 September 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Knee bone football WP:ONEDAY Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
9215 14714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 Swedish general election in Södermanland County User:Impru20 21:19, 23 January 2020 (UTC) delete per nom and Sjö. Would not object to the more common practice of creating Södermanland County (constituency)-style articles that provided input on results at the constituency level for all Swedish elections, but creating election-specific articles is an unnecessary ammount of detail, as per . I also agree that Marsh008 |may look suspiciously like a duck; in such a case, they should get a report at that determined whether this could be a sockpuppet of Glottran. Using an alternative account for creating an illusion of support for one position in discussions |is not allowed in Wikipedia. Nonetheless, this should be clarified at the appropiate venue, not here Deletion of 2018 Swedish general election in Södermanland County WP:NOTSTATS||WP:DUCK||WP:SPI||WP:ILLEGIT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9216 14665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Medical Dialogues User:Winged 13:58, 12 September 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and/or by a mile or so.Not an iota of significant coverage in reliable sources.Nothing in Hindi, either Deletion of Medical Dialogues WP:NORG||WP:WEBCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9217 14465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MTA Regional Bus Operations bus fleet User:Pontificalibus 16:25, 12 March 2021 (UTC) keep A notable topic (e.g. fleet details discussed https://www.google.co.uk/books/edition/The_Wheels_That_Drove_New_York/ here), it's reasonable to have a list, as List of bus types used in London. The level of detail and sourcing can be debated on the article talk page. Even if you strip out the content sourced to TTMG (which seems borderline whether it's an ), there are still other reliable sources out there which can be used to support a list of vehicle types. Personally I'd rename the article to make it broader and include the historical fleet, as notability isn't temporary Deletion of MTA Regional Bus Operations bus fleet WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9218 342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ditchconnect User:Onceonthisisland 16:42, 11 November 2007 (UTC) delete Obviously something made up by the creator of the article. #Wikipedia_is_not_a_publisher_of_original_thought Deletion of Ditchconnect WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9219 17115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yussuf Kazeem akande User:GiantSnowman 20:51, 10 March 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Yussuf Kazeem akande WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9220 21046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khaled Aghbariyya User:Bearcat 15:55, 21 June 2019 (UTC) delete Umm al-Fahm is not large enough to hand its mayors an automatic free pass over #2 just because they exist — but the only reference here is a glancing namecheck of his existence as a giver of soundbite in an article about an event that happened ''in'' Umm al-Fahm, not coverage that is ''substantively'' about ''him'' for the purposes of establishing that he would pass Deletion of Khaled Aghbariyya WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9221 3050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elika Associates User:Hrafn 06:27, 30 November 2010 (UTC) delete coverage is mainly in primary sources & trade rags, with only occasional & tangential coverage in more mainstream publications. Combine this with the obvious self-promotion/COI concerns (and I would note that Elika2010 has ''exacerbated'' those concerns by participating, quite incautiously, in this AfD, in violation of -- giving very little reason to assume that they wouldn't continue to edit the article), and I do not think keeping this article would be a wise decision Deletion of Elika Associates WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
9222 11359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs recorded by Trisha Paytas User:Gongshow 00:18, 7 August 2017 (UTC) delete I'm unable to find evidence to suggest that this meets Deletion of List of songs recorded by Trisha Paytas WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9223 1895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zee (rapper) User:Pharaoh 06:08, 31 May 2020 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Zee (rapper) WP:GNG||WP:NMUSICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9224 14662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moise Rimbon NONE NONE comment """A """"mixed martial arts"""" consensus should not apply to """"kickboxing"""" articles. There is a huge difference between a """"mixed martial artist"""" and a """"kickboxer"""" for those wondering. I cant wait to see when one of the users run into a mixed martial artist with a above .500 record in professional boxing and nominate it for deletion because the professional boxer who just so happens to be a MMA fighter does not meet """ Deletion of Moise Rimbon WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
9225 18983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manjeet Singh Riyat User:This 23:33, 25 April 2020 (UTC) keep as a borderline , otherwise I support {{ping|Rhyddfrydol2}}'s suggestion Deletion of Manjeet Singh Riyat WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9226 2785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Jones (scientist) User:Russ 10:56, 19 February 2021 (UTC) delete I think it's here. The awards I see are early career, and don't contribute much to notability; similarly for the CAREER grant (see https://www.nsf.gov/funding/pgm_summ.jsp?pims_id=503214). The citation record looks far short of C1 in what I believe to be a medium-high citation field. I don't see any other sign of notability Deletion of Lisa Jones (scientist) WP:TOOSOON||WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
9227 6890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henoc John Mukendi User:Alex 09:21, 10 November 2010 (UTC) delete another non-notable 16year old kid footballer, fails , fails , was candidate as a creation by Deletion of Henoc John Mukendi WP:NSPORTS||WP:GNG||WP:G5 Wikipedia:Notability 77
9228 17867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kali Ray (2nd nomination) User:Lemongirl942 19:20, 19 March 2016 (UTC) delete Fails . Hardly any independent coverage Deletion of Kali Ray (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9229 3977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Well Cementing User:Unscintillating 01:12, 14 October 2012 (UTC) merge """nbsp; This is a major topic in the news right now, associated with fracking. A search on fracking """"well cementing"""" gives http://www.savecoloradofromfracking.org/whatgoeswrong/cementing.html this as the first ref. Even though the nomination is not for notability, nominators should look for sources |before starting an AfD discussion. The tens of thousands of sources found by the first editor to try to look for sources is not a surprise. """ Deletion of Well Cementing WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9230 414 [[Turingmaschine Typ 2]] (bleibt) Benutzer:TMg 18:51, 28. Apr. 2008 (CEST) delete """Darf ich darauf hinweisen, dass in der Chomsky-Hierarchie zwar ein """"Typ 2"""" existiert, aber Turingmaschinen zum """"Typ 0"""" gehören? Beim """"Typ 2"""" spricht man von Kellerautomat. So etwas wie eine """"Turingmaschine Typ 2"""" existiert nicht. Der Autor hat offenbar nicht verstanden, wovon er schreibt. |TF""" Löschung von Turingmaschine Typ 2 Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
9231 3497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Dearden User:Pdcook 22:55, 27 February 2010 (UTC) delete The article doesn't even really assert the subject's importance, and the given sources don't seem to indicate notability. I don't see any evidence that he is highly cited or has won any awards. Many of the sources in the article are associated with BBC and thus are not independent. One of the sources is a blog, and I don't think it's an expert blog that can be considered a |reliable source. I'm not sure what http://www.careers.cam.ac.uk/eReg/AccessDenied.asp?Requested=http://www.careers.cam.ac.uk/sectors/media/earlybioglist.asp this source is as I cannot access it. http://www.google.com/search?rlz=1C1GGLS_enUS311US311&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8&q=Chris+Dearden+BBC A Google search turns up mostly the sources already in the article, but nothing that indicates notability per or in particular Deletion of Chris Dearden WP:RS||WP:BIO||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9232 14359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Research on the use and effect of computers in college students. User:Doomsdayer520 16:36, 12 March 2010 (UTC) delete This is clearly someone's research paper (and not a very good one) just copied and pasted. Even I have done graduate-level research on this topic but did not copy my work into WP. Delete per Deletion of Research on the use and effect of computers in college students. WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9233 12612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Recut Trailers User:MrOllie 15:05, 12 September 2013 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is a directory of external links Deletion of List of Recut Trailers WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9234 333 [[Opfer (Schimpfwort)]] (bleibt) Benutzer:In dubio pro dubio 23:50, 8. Apr. 2012 (CEST) delete erstens unter dem Lemma Opfer (Schimpfwort) schon diskutiert und damit Wiedergänger, zweitens auch aus den Belegen keine Relevanz des abgewandelten Neologismus erkennbar, ansonsten bitte Alda (als Ableitung des Jargons „Alter“), Hade, Hau rein (vgl ref #1) etc ebenso anlegen. WP ist kein Jargonwörterbuch, vgl Löschung von Opfer (Schimpfwort) Wikipedia:WIKW Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9235 20620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anveshi Jain (2nd nomination) User:TheAafi 14:39, 3 November 2020 (UTC) delete I'm not convinced by the article's sources. I even tried a bit searching about the actress. There's coverage in some reliable sources but not much which would meet the |significant coverage thing Deletion of Anveshi Jain (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
9236 12967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Team touchdown User:JohnCD 10:16, 18 November 2009 (UTC) delete """and '''salt'''. Actually, I think #A7 """"no credible claim of significance or importance"""" covers it exactly: the actual article makes no claim - it's just an under-14 indoor soccer team """"''made up of 8 players from Merewether High School''"""". The only reference is the website of a leisure centre, and even there I don't find any mention. However, as it's been PRODded and dePRODded we'd better go through with this""" Deletion of Team touchdown WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9237 16010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lightweight rail User:Arsenikk 09:01, 3 July 2011 (UTC) delete The entire lightweight rail article reads like an |essay, and is built up as a |non-neutral arguments for why this concept is so fantastic and bases itself on presenting |original research. We have an article about light railway, which covers the topic about railways which are lighter than normal, and we have an article about monorail. The article is constantly mixing terms; it tries to explain a science-fiction version of suspended monorails (real ones which are covered in the monorail article), but at the same time has selected incidents and examples from alleged short-comings from conventional railways which are used to support the authors point of view. Other claims are just not true: there are numerous elevated conventional railways; comparing the person-to-weight ratio of high-speed intercity trains (which for instance contains a dining car and needs more power output per tonne than, for instance a metro) to low-speed, high capacity people movers is mixing apples and bananas. No-where does it introduce any references from reliable sources, instead relying on the author's fanboy page on the issue. And don't get me going on the article being written in first person plural Deletion of Lightweight rail WP:FORUM||WP:POV||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9238 20062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boys Generally Asian [[User talk:173.88.112.95#top|talk]]) 13:38, 28 March 2017 (UTC) keep """Independent news sources around the world have acknowledged this group, per criteria item 1: """"Has been the subject of multiple, non-trivial, published works appearing in sources that are reliable, not self-published, and are independent of the musician or ensemble itself.""""— Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/173.88.112.95|173.88.112.95""" Deletion of Boys Generally Asian WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9239 8049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaleido360 User:Rjd0060 01:00, 14 October 2007 (UTC) delete Mostly per . Also, very little context. Give it some time, and it should be more notable and meet WP's guidelines Deletion of Kaleido360 WP:CBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9240 3349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skandha (disambiguation) User:FyzixFighter 17:33, 8 June 2018 (UTC) delete """per . IMO a compelling argument could be made that Skandha is the |primary topic (using Wikipedia's definition of primary topic) based on the relative number of adherents and number of hits from a google scholar search. Therefore a hatnote there should be sufficient, and Realphi has already added an additional bullet under """"see also"""" at Skanda for the Jainism topic""" Deletion of Skandha (disambiguation) WP:TWODABS||WP:PTOPIC Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
9241 21644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brett Kimberlin (2nd nomination) User:JoshuaZ 15:22, 13 March 2018 (UTC) keep Meets basic criterion. Most of the subjects reasons for deletion either are both false and irrelevant (e.g. the claim that the marijuana is legal now). Individual is also not BLP1E since there are a whole bunch of things they've done that have gotten attention. There's a substantial argument that the article has weight issues, and much more emphasis should be placed on Kimberlin's current work. I will note that the previous AFD was closed as keep by SNOW Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Brett_Kimberlin Deletion of Brett Kimberlin (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9242 20093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of books about charisma User:Alfadog 14:42, 24 December 2007 (UTC) delete Fails a reasonable interpretation of . Not a directory or collection of indiscriminate information. See also Deletion of List of books about charisma WP:NOT||WP:LIST Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9243 6530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti-globalization and antisemitism (5th nomination) User:Commodore 14:43, 29 January 2009 (UTC) delete """Massive violation. While there are some sources that connect these two concepts, there is not a body of scholarship or other published work recognizing this as a single concept or distinct category, and certainly the phrase """"anti-globalization related antisemitism"""" (as used in the info box) doesn't appear anywhere outside Wikipedia. There might be some quotations here that belong on other articles such as new antisemitism, but it seems particularly bizarre to treat this as a separate category""" Deletion of Anti-globalization and antisemitism (5th nomination) WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
9244 260 [[San Remo Konferenz]] (schnellgelöscht) NONE 18:44, 21. Apr. 2009 (CEST) keep Unfugantrag! und Antragsteller auf schicken Löschung von San Remo Konferenz Wikipedia:BNS Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
9245 281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Snitker User:Awyllie 22:38, 13 April 2010 (UTC) comment There is no distinction for seperate notability outside of a political campaign in , only that the sources are reliable and independent of the candidate Deletion of Alexander Snitker WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9246 8901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Guzman NONE NONE keep The |general notability guidelines for inclusion within Wikipedia require that the subject of the article has received significant third-party coverage. Guzman has been covered as the primary subject by Deletion of Christian Guzman WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9247 2805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shekhey pind [[User talk:180.172.239.231|talk]]) 02:05, 27 August 2014 (UTC) comment If it exists, will be met, since wikipedia has a gazetteer function. But I'm struggling to prove its existence. Anyway, a '''redirect''' to Jalandhar district does no harm. '''Keep''' per its verified existence.--Special:Contributions/180.172.239.231|180.172.239.231 Deletion of Shekhey pind WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9248 21341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Hunt User:Pharaoh 09:00, 22 August 2018 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Alex Hunt WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9249 5585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of artists influenced by Michael Jackson User:Georgethedragonslayer 02:19, 12 April 2021 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of List of artists influenced by Michael Jackson WP:FANCRUFT||WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
9250 16659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Trump and handshakes (2nd nomination) User:Cbs527 14:48, 9 September 2017 (UTC) delete """slightly over Merge) - This article doesn't seem to pass the notability criteria for a stand alone article at including . Having RS or coverage alone is not enough to merit an article. The article must also pass What Wikipedia is not. This article doesn't come close to passing OT on several levels, most notably OTEVERYTHING (aka: Encyclopedic content), OTPAPER and OTNEWS. IMO DT's handshake has a relatively short news cycle and is doubtful this will be in the """"Top 20 of most notable things about Donald Trump"""". Although I agree the merge comments to Donald Trump in popular culture are valid as well, I don't feel that it is on the same level as some of the other topics in that article""" Deletion of Donald Trump and handshakes (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:GNG||WP:NOT||WP:NOTEVERYTHING||WP:NOTPAPER||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9251 19965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Merchandize Liquidators User:Xtifr 00:45, 27 October 2006 (UTC) delete per #G11|CSD G11 or '''Delete''' per nom. Kill all spam Deletion of Merchandize Liquidators WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9252 15455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Creators Documentary User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:27, 13 August 2011 (UTC) keep """and clean up the format and tone problems. Sorry to disagree with the nominator about notability, but we DO have a |special set of problems when dealing with documentary films made in South Africa. I note that the article offers a very decent set of sources through a lengthy article in ''Huffington Post'' http://www.huffingtonpost.com/tamar-abrams/creators-south-africa-laura-gamse_b_838713.html and another in ''Mambo Magazine'' http://www.mambomagazine.com/nutshell-guides/arts-and-culture/ziff-film-review-the-creators While more would be better, we have """"just"""" enough very decent ones to allow this to remain and be improved. The original findsources above has problems as it will not even lead you to the film's IMDB page.. but I found it.http://www.imdb.com/name/nm4074930/ Also, in seraching for the director, Laura Gamse, I found that the film screened recently at the """"LA Film and Music Weekend"""".http://www.pomona.edu/news/2011/03/25-gamse-film-creators.aspx As a recipient of a Fulbright Scholarship, she moved to South Africa to make a documentary. The result was '''''The Creators'''''.http://www.filmcontact.com/south-africa/film-our-time-creators Considering that the film is only now hitting festivals, but HAS already been the recipient of critical commentary and review in some decent reliable sources, we can let it stay and be fixed. We will need a move to The Creators (documentary film) per naming conventions""" Deletion of The Creators Documentary WP:CSB Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
9253 20917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelly Meighen User:Lubbad85 21:53, 8 May 2019 (UTC) comment I believe this article has been relisted in violation of wikipedia policies and guidelines for closure of afd. We have . Editors disagree with the relisting assertion that the awards are not relevant and with the nominator's assertions. Also ignored are editor arguments about this person's philanthropic . (also posted on Deletion of Kelly Meighen WP:CONSENSUS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Consensus 78
9254 14111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bekey Mills User:doomsdayer520 16:12, 3 March 2021 (UTC) delete No coverage in any reliable sources, and he can only be found in the completely typical African paid promotion services that reprint his management's press releases. Purely in |promotional mode so far Deletion of Bekey Mills WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9255 17666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019–20 Formula E season (2nd nomination) User:Vorbee 16:28, 19 December 2017 (UTC) delete per Deletion of 2019–20 Formula E season (2nd nomination) WP: CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9256 21744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nurdin Rijal Ardhi User:GiantSnowman 10:40, 27 February 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Nurdin Rijal Ardhi WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9257 760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Niazi Express User:Ammarpad 07:05, 1 December 2017 (UTC) delete non notable organisation/ service. These kind of services can hardly passes talk less of . The only source available are primary and perhaps government press release which doesn't even exist in this case Deletion of Niazi Express WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
9258 2313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Society for Venturism User:DCI2026 00:00, 15 February 2013 (UTC) comment The above keep !votes do not establish why the article ought not to be deleted. First, the sources on the article really aren't reliable. Yahoo posts about Toronto's Bedford Day parties and wikis, postings, and articles from affiliates of this organization are not considered |in line with WP policy. As for the argument stating that an appropriate analogy is the Catholic Church article being sourced by other denominations' webpages, these, too, would not be considered reliable. Basically, this article needs sources from a well-established source not affiliated with the Society of Venturism or its affiliates in the cryonics movement, and clear indications that the topic has garnered sufficient notability Deletion of Society for Venturism WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9259 12105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mad monk 10k User:WWGB 08:25, 20 August 2011 (UTC) delete Non-notable race, fails Deletion of Mad monk 10k WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9260 9698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shawn Schmidt NONE 02:45, 25 July 2021 (UTC) delete does not meet Deletion of Shawn Schmidt WP:COLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
9261 21621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/June 2017 Melbourne attack User:Knowledgekid87 03:51, 6 June 2017 (UTC) delete or '''Redirect''' to List of terrorist incidents in June 2017 per . The only arguments I see above are opinions and a reference to |article x Deletion of June 2017 Melbourne attack WP:NOTNEWS||WP:OSE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9262 671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Love Story (Mariah Carey song) User:SWik78 12:51, 8 May 2008 (UTC) comment its a sure sign that it will be released''??? Have you ever read erifiability or eliable sources Deletion of Love Story (Mariah Carey song) WP:V||WP:R Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9263 5194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SFS Homes User:onel5969 13:15, 14 March 2016 (UTC) delete not enough independent coverage in reliable, independent sources to show they pass either or Deletion of SFS Homes WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9264 1983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Clements Caves User:MacGyverMagic 09:25, 9 January 2009 (UTC) keep It is long-standing practice to keep articles on verifiable georgraphical features like towns, rivers, and mountains. I believe caves about which enough can be written belong in the same group. A basic http://www.google.com/search?sa=N&tab=nw&q=%22%22st.%20clements%20caves google search indicates there's a potential for expansion and quite some reliable sources to meet Deletion of St. Clements Caves WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9265 11975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ProjectInsight User:Ihcoyc 16:34, 25 November 2009 (UTC) delete I nominated this for deletion. IT-related trade publications with a limited audience do not confer notability, and I see no general interest coverage; see the otability (software)|notability essay on software Deletion of ProjectInsight WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9266 2456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Innovation and its Discontents User:JD554 13:35, 4 March 2008 (UTC) keep I've added a couple of references which show that the book meets criteria #1 of Deletion of Innovation and its Discontents WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9267 1876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WWE Druid User:TheSpecialUser 10:24, 28 May 2012 (UTC) delete A PROD would have done the trick but no problem. There is no trace of Deletion of WWE Druid WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9268 21789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LYFE (video game) User:Ubiquity 19:37, 11 June 2015 (UTC) delete Fails . Deletion of LYFE (video game) WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
9269 17007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Feeding India User:DESiegel 01:25, 5 July 2015 (UTC) delete as per nom and all above. I looked at the previously deleted versions, there seems to be nothing notable here, unless there are sources unlisted and that my web search did not find. Time to think about a close Deletion of Feeding India WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
9270 18865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013 Moroccan protests User:TCN7JM 10:13, 8 August 2013 (UTC) delete """From , which is policy, by the way: ''""""While news coverage can be useful source material for encyclopedic topics, most newsworthy events do not qualify for inclusion.""""'' This, by the looks of it, just seems to be a newsworthy item that isn't notable enough for an article""" Deletion of 2013 Moroccan protests WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9271 9715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lyall Howard (2nd nomination) User:Sandstein 08:49, 19 July 2008 (UTC) keep Judging from the article, he seems to have received sufficient individual coverage to establish notability. While that is , said argument properly applies only to people who are not commented upon ''except in their capacity as a relative of a famous person'' (e.g. the Brangelina babies); this isn't the case here. Any POV or coatrack issues can be remedied through editing Deletion of Lyall Howard (2nd nomination) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9272 10884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VibroAcoustic therapy User:Mh29255 00:05, 27 December 2007 (UTC) delete While there are references on the Internet regarding the subject matter, it is not clear whether the article describes a prescribed therapy or a pseudo-scientific alternative remedy. Given the poor & unverified content of the article per and the likely personal research in violation of , it would be better to delete the article Deletion of VibroAcoustic therapy WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9273 14160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oink (water buffalo) User:TimVickers 17:47, 16 July 2008 (UTC) delete as per #NEWS animal known only for one newsworthy incident and with no long-term significance Deletion of Oink (water buffalo) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9274 7625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1st Valley Bank User:Raykyogrou0 15:15, 16 January 2014 (UTC) comment """The comments saying """"Speedy keep"""" or """"close"""" don't have actual |speedy keep criterion""" Deletion of 1st Valley Bank WP:SK Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
9275 20667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nabto User:Joe 15:03, 24 March 2014 (UTC) delete I don't see sources that would get this past Deletion of Nabto WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9276 18349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Failed history User:JJLatWiki 17:15, 26 January 2007 (UTC) delete lacks any citations, no evidence that the term exists, just a long list of disconnected factoids. , #DIR, , , Deletion of Failed history WP:NEO||WP:NOT||WP:NOR||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9277 5304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sixguns over tombstone User:JavierMC 04:27, 23 October 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Sixguns over tombstone WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9278 1450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taboo album User:RaNdOm26 11:25, 28 July 2007 (UTC) delete Just another case of , plus no reliable sources in the article as backup Deletion of Taboo album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9279 19868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kobe (artist) User:The 18:05, 15 May 2020 (UTC) delete Subject fails and even . The emotional investment of the main curator of the article does not make this discussion easy but Wikipedia policy must prevail. The text possibly belongs in specialist publications; not here. |This encyclopaedia is not a |listing of haphazard information Deletion of Kobe (artist) WP:NCREATIVE||WP:GNG||WP:5P1||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9280 10937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FightBack User:MuZemike 00:53, 19 November 2008 (UTC) delete per lack of |verifiability via ''independent'' secondary sources Deletion of FightBack WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9281 1827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Air Cadet squadrons in Canada User:ImperatorExercitus 21:03, 3 August 2009 (UTC) delete per , criteria 1. Cheers Deletion of List of Air Cadet squadrons in Canada WP:NOTYELLOW Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9282 8191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Fat Tail: The Power of Political Knowledge for Strategic Investing User:Cyclonenim 19:08, 8 February 2009 (UTC) delete per otability (books), which states unpublished book articles are strongly discourged unless they meet other notability guidelines, which this one doesn't. It also lacks multiple, independent references Deletion of The Fat Tail: The Power of Political Knowledge for Strategic Investing WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9283 19096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of So Random! sketches User:Reyk 10:59, 10 August 2015 (UTC) delete """yeah, it's inherently and fancruft. This article is hopelessly unsuitable for an encyclopedia. '''Bonus internet points''' to the nominator for the phrase """"fandom carbuncle""" Deletion of List of So Random! sketches WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9284 18342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trembulo (2nd nomination) [[User talk:TenPoundHammer|What did I screw up now?]]) 02:14, 15 June 2016 (UTC) delete The sources are clearly not |reliable, and I could find nothing verifying that this even exists. The only Books hit is a reprint of Wikipedia, and most of the 96 hits on Google don't actually even mention it. It's still a hoax. '''Ten Pound Hammer Deletion of Trembulo (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9285 15439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kirin Narayan User:Finngall 14:56, 6 July 2019 (UTC) comment Discussion page was created without the {{tl|afd2}} template and never transcluded to a daily log page. Fixed now--I have no opinion on the nomination itself at this time. {{ping|Scholar911}} For future AfD nominations, please fully follow the instructions at . Thank you Deletion of Kirin Narayan WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9286 16758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B is for Build User:Jmertel23 22:10, 1 December 2019 (UTC) delete As per nom, the subject does not meet Deletion of B is for Build WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9287 16991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christianity and Judaism User:Jfdwolff 19:52, 28 September 2008 (UTC) merge this sounds like Deletion of Christianity and Judaism WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
9288 2100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Piraya Film User:Gleeanon409 19:49, 21 October 2020 (UTC) comment HighKing, I think is the guideline for this subject Deletion of Piraya Film WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9289 372 [[Klickibunti]] (erl.) Benutzer:Micha L. Rieser 20:50, 11. Sep. 2007 (CEST) delete Mehr geht ja kaum nicht mehr. Das ist genauso ein Artikel, der aufgebläht wurde, weil er zuviel LAs überlebt hat. Leider mündet das Aufblähen in ''reine Theoriefindung''. Wo bitte schön Leute, sind die viel geliebten und geforderten '''Quellen??'''. Wurde der Begriff z.B. sprachwissenschaftl. einmal untersucht? - Zweitens, angenommen er ist als ''Begriff'' relevant, dann aber höchstens für ein Wörterbuch. Da ist am Artikel nix aber auch gar nix enzyklopädisches daran. Schlussendlich ist es nur ein Dysphemismus|dysphemistisches Synonym für GUI. Also: Reines Geschwurbel seit 2004 ... (sorry, für die harte Sprache Löschung von Klickibunti Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
9290 13266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul De Roy User:onel5969 13:36, 24 April 2016 (UTC) delete Searches turned up zero in-depth coverage of this individual. Fails Deletion of Paul De Roy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9291 951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Dominic Washington User:Hugsyrup 13:11, 19 July 2019 (UTC) delete There are RSs, but they are covering a single event, which is not sufficient per . Other than that single event, the individual would not meet the s Deletion of Jason Dominic Washington WP:BLP1E||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
9292 288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rashida Richardson User:Beccaynr 01:06, 7 February 2021 (UTC) keep """I have added sources from ''NBC News'', ''CBS News'', and ''Reuters'' that quote Richardson as an expert, and added a recent co-authored opinion article by Richardson in ''The Hill''. While the article still needs work, I have tried to update it to make the basis of her notability more clear, and I think the coverage she has recieved at minimum appears to meet , i.e. """"If the depth of coverage in any given source is not substantial, then multiple independent sources may be combined to demonstrate notability""" Deletion of Rashida Richardson WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9293 65 [[Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Stamminstrumentarium des klassischen Sinfonieorchesters]] (gelöscht, Themenring) Benutzer:Thornard 14:55, 23. Jun. 2007 (CEST) keep Dies ist kein |Themenring, da die Auswahl nicht subjektiv ist. Natürlich fehlt da viel, von Klassifizierung ganz zu schweigen. Man sollte sie vielleicht umbenennen und noch weiter eingrenzen. Entscheident ist das unglücklich gewählte Wort ''klassisch''. Sie enthält die klassischen Orchesterintrumente, wichtige Musikinstrumente der aktuellen abendländischen Unterhaltungsmusik Musik (Pop, Rock) und die wichtigsten Instrumente des Jazz. Sie ist zur Navigation durch viele wirklich gute Artikel dringend notwendig. Daher . Der Titel kann ja auch noch etwas passender formuliert werden. Zum Beispiel: ''Hauptinstrumentarium der Abendländländischen Musik.'' Alternativen wäre eine Eingrenzung wie ''Orchesterintumentarium der Wiener Klassik Löschung von Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Stamminstrumentarium des klassischen Sinfonieorchesters Wikipedia:Themenring Wikipedia:Themenring 103
9294 16447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pay Phone (Edson Song) User:Junior5a 16:43, 11 July 2020 (UTC) delete It's not hoax but likely fails |verification and Deletion of Pay Phone (Edson Song) WP:V||WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9295 10428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/De Minimis User:Mary 20:35, 9 April 2007 (UTC) delete school choir that does the things all school choirs do; completely fails Deletion of De Minimis WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9296 17802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Universal religion User:Farang 22:10, 9 July 2018 (UTC) keep per {{u|Johnbod}}'s arguments and sources. Currently, definitely |OR, but subject appears to be a notable theoretical framework. Might have to be stubbed for the time being Deletion of Universal religion WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9297 6226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thangtinlen Haokip User:GiantSnowman 12:24, 20 May 2014 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Thangtinlen Haokip WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9298 4856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stress Field Detector User:Margin1522 12:27, 28 November 2014 (UTC) delete """I found a couple of the dead links, but they were about commercial applications. No information about how it works except that it is a """"unique quantum method"""". The article itself says there is no published info. It's probably proprietary. Might find more if someone checked for patents, but that would be . – """ Deletion of Stress Field Detector WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9299 17443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional comics (2nd nomination) User:Finnusertop 10:38, 24 June 2019 (UTC) delete """unless significant coverage in RS that discuss """"fictional comics"""" as a thing is presented, per . – """ Deletion of List of fictional comics (2nd nomination) WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9300 3392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahool User:Alexbrn 19:49, 12 June 2018 (UTC) delete Not covered in ependent sources Deletion of Ahool WP:FRIND Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
9301 7927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enemy Unbound User:Jax 13:04, 10 July 2018 (UTC) comment """yo|Domdeparis}}, I am indifferent between Keep and """"Redirect with history"""", so long as the history remains in tact with this valid search term. If the band is non notable, then it too should be nominated for |AFD""" Deletion of Enemy Unbound WP:AFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9302 13507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional xenoarchaeologists User:Jayden54 21:20, 3 January 2007 (UTC) delete WP:OR|original research and no |reliable sources Deletion of List of fictional xenoarchaeologists WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9303 21919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of online-gaming slang User:Anonymous 10:40, 10 August 2007 (UTC) delete I personally think the topic is becoming overgrown with Deletion of List of online-gaming slang WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9304 6392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Revision World User:Starblind 19:27, 12 January 2010 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Revision World WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
9305 16264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virgil Howe User:Bluebonnet07 15:41, 13 September 2017 (UTC) keep The output seems to meet and the detail is good Deletion of Virgil Howe WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9306 431 [[Oliver Wehse]] (SLA) Benutzer:Robertsan NONE delete Wikipedia ist kein Ersatz für die private Website eines Autors und Herausgebers von eigenen Gnaden. Hier geht es um enzyklopädische Relevanz, dafür gibt es Relevanzkriterien, und die werden von Herrn Wehse nicht erfüllt. Bitte auch beachten Löschung von Oliver Wehse Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9307 15339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Authority Nutrition User:Mrschimpf 04:16, 15 January 2018 (UTC) delete WP:N// failure; it's an average clickbait site among many. Also don't bother with the H&I revision move; this was a hijacking by {{vandal|Patel the empty}} pure and simple, and why we let this go two years beyond their block is surprising Deletion of Authority Nutrition WP:WEB||WP:SPAM||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Notability 77
9308 12521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward J Kelly User:Useight 16:37, 19 May 2007 (UTC) delete Okay, the first part seems like a possible from http://www.edwardjkelly.com/main.html (which is where all the sources came from), unless, of course, the guy who wrote that also wrote this article, in which case there is a probable conflict of interest Deletion of Edward J Kelly WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
9309 16917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Trek: The Orphans of War User:RGTraynor 16:22, 10 December 2007 (UTC) delete Fails , , . This isn't even an unreleased, projected studio production. This is an unreleased, projected ''fan film''. I have serious doubts about the notability of fan flicks at all, never mind ones that don't yet exist Deletion of Star Trek: The Orphans of War WP:CRYSTAL||WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9310 14134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reiji Sato User:Narutolovehinata5 00:32, 17 March 2013 (UTC) keep even if it was stated that playing only in cups does not establish notability (but the consensus here appears to be that playing in cups can establish notability), the fact that he received coverage in Japan means he passes and Deletion of Reiji Sato WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9311 2018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2021 Washington Middle School Shooting User:Netherzone 14:18, 24 August 2021 (UTC) delete This school shooting was a tragic incident of senseless gun violence. However wikipedia is not a newspaper , and the event at this time does not pass notability criteria for an article. If it has an impact in the future on changing school policies within a wider net, or the specific event continues to have ongoing news coverage then an article may be appropriate in the future. Sad as it is to read about these awful shool shootings, especially with 13 year olds involved, we can't include each one as a separate article. It could however be added to the article List of school shootings in the United States along with associated citations Deletion of 2021 Washington Middle School Shooting WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9312 21602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ducky Wucky User:Fabrictramp 22:09, 5 July 2008 (UTC) delete The game is for sale on ebay, but that's the ''only'' non-wiki ghit, including gnews. issues lead me to believe this is an advert, and probably eligible for a G11 speedy Deletion of Ducky Wucky WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
9313 18529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amir Butler User:Assize 22:44, 10 May 2007 (UTC) comment That's a great primary reference. Thanks. Finally, a journalist who regards Butler as a peer journalist to be quoted and therefore meets . If somebody could update the article to reflect that, I'll go with a '''Keep'''. Well done everybody in improving the article Deletion of Amir Butler WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9314 12120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ira Singhal User:MB 17:38, 30 March 2016 (UTC) delete """The only coverage she has received are a few short articles that relates to being first on the exam and having a disability. I would say this is not notable. Fails """"Notable topics have attracted attention over a sufficiently significant period of time"""". We need to apply notability objectively. I believe many of the comments above are emotionally based""" Deletion of Ira Singhal WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
9315 2958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ray Coles User:Dlohcierekim 10:49, 20 June 2017 (UTC) delete does not have sufficient coverage in RS to meet the GNG, not withstanding Deletion of Ray Coles WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9316 12124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of suicides that have been attributed to academic pressures User:Ajf773 09:38, 22 February 2017 (UTC) delete Indiscriminate list relating to non-notable peoples. Sources are questionable and almost possibly violates Deletion of List of suicides that have been attributed to academic pressures WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9317 19079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Calculus I User:PRehse 18:11, 21 November 2016 (UTC) delete I agree wikipedia is Deletion of Calculus I WP:NOTTEXTBOOK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9318 16399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Genesis Park User:scope_creep 18:03, 24 September 2020 (UTC) delete No effective references. Run of the mill business news, funding, share growth and announcements. Fails Deletion of Genesis Park WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9319 8232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of technologies in Civilization III User:Peripitus 13:43, 2 June 2006 (UTC) delete as a #Wikipedia_is_not_an_indiscriminate_collection_of_information|simple collection of information. Either people have the game and don't need this list or don't and won't care Deletion of List of technologies in Civilization III WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9320 16969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southwest Airlines Flight 345 User:Bearian 16:45, 27 July 2013 (UTC) delete There is |fairly strong consensus for Wikipedia:AIRCRASH, even if it is not a guideline or policy, and this incident does not pass muster. I could go along with a redirect per Deletion of Southwest Airlines Flight 345 WP:CCC||WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Consensus 78
9321 86 [[Hippokratie]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Ahellwig 22:26, 25. Jul. 2009 (CEST) delete Wenn es korrekt ist, was weiter oben steht, nämlich dass der Begriff in Gullivers Reisen überhaupt nicht verwendet wird, bleibt nur eine Schlussfolgerung: der Begriff ist vom Artikeleinsteller selbst erfunden worden, da keinerlei weitere Quellen angegeben sind, wo er herstammen könnte. Als offensichtliche |Begriffsbildung Löschung von Hippokratie Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
9322 13681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dynastia User:Kudpung 00:51, 11 December 2016 (UTC) delete None of the sources are about the subject. Fails Deletion of Dynastia WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9323 2840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Mihaly User:Ethicoaestheticist 22:24, 3 April 2009 (UTC) keep The artist doesn't meet and I understand the concerns listed above. But he does meet , which sets a lower standard. He may not be a notable artist, but he's a notable subject for a WP article, which is a somewhat different thing Deletion of Robert Mihaly WP:CREATIVE||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9324 141 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Uğur Ersoy Kullanıcı:seksen iki yüz kırk beşseksen iki yüz kırk beş / ggt 17.09, 2 Mart 2020 (UTC) keep """ODTÜ gibi mühendislik bölümüyle tanınan bir üniversitede İnşaat Mühendisliği bölüm başkanlığı ve rektör yardımcılığı yapmış. 'in 5. maddesini karşılıyor, . Ek olarak, tecrübeli kullanıcıların yazdıkları maddeler üzerinde de kronik bir """"kayda değerlik devriyeliği"""" uygulaması görüyorum Türkçe Vikipedi'de. Kendi adıma kayda değer olduğunu bildiğim ama taslak olarak girmek istediğim maddeleri İngilizce Vikipedi'ye rahat girerken buraya girmediğim anlamına geliyor bu. Yapıcı görmediğim gibi şevk kırdığını düşünüyorum. Eforlarımızı vandallara ve reklama karşı birleştirelim""" Uğur Ersoy'un silinmesi Vikipedi:AKADEMİSYEN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9325 19291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tongil Tours User:Scope 14:33, 27 February 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Tongil Tours WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9326 16349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Club Kalamaria User:MetroStar 14:54, 10 June 2009 (UTC) delete """only claim to notability is its """"celebrities"""" side. No independent sources supplied, and I can find none - assuming that this is not Apollon Kalamarias F.C. which already has an article. To be fair to the author, he is blocked for two weeks, not banned, and with a bit of it may be that what he is doing is not deliberate hoaxing but dressing up, in neatly-presented articles, things that exist but are not |notable enough for an |encyclopedia article (though the dead-link web addresses presented in the first version of this and in the recent Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michalia|""""micronation"""" of Michalia don't look good). If he would read and apply and he could be a useful editor""" Deletion of Club Kalamaria WP:AGF||WP:N||WP:ENC||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
9327 12092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamdan Azhar User:Superastig 16:08, 30 October 2020 (UTC) delete Barely found anything about him. Search results return mostly articles where he's mentioned as the founding member of the Bitcoin Center. Perhaps a Deletion of Hamdan Azhar WP:RUNOFTHEMILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
9328 7210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Top Ten SEC on CBS Games User:Secret 18:29, 10 April 2014 (UTC) delete fails , only significant coverage is from CBS themselves which isn't independent Deletion of Top Ten SEC on CBS Games WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9329 19169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mecha as Practical War Machines (second nomination) User:Sharkface217 05:31, 11 February 2007 (UTC) delete As it is |original research and an essay.''' However, I shall note that those who wish to save it, I have currently (and temporarily) userfied the page http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Sharkface217/savestuff here Deletion of Mecha as Practical War Machines (second nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9330 13577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dick Hoven User:David 20:01, 18 October 2016 (UTC) delete as unprodder. Even if he does exist, and managed and produced Baha Men (something that I agree is inadequately sourced) and would still apply Deletion of Dick Hoven WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9331 15754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guadalajara: The Experience User:Burnzboy2 20:02, 1 September 2010 (UTC) keep """I believe that this page is a good contribution to Wikipedia. If someone sees this film for sale and wants to know about it, it is great to have on here. I understand that this """"needs"""" a |reliable critic's attention, but I strongly disagree. All customer ratings on the sites listed by Special:Contributions/75.170.60.176|75.170.60.176 are the best rating applicable. I believe the rules should bend a little for this article""" Deletion of Guadalajara: The Experience WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9332 13889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerald Balone User:Ginsengbomb 04:04, 1 December 2010 (UTC) keep He also has an article devoted to him in the Christian Science Monitor. I think, based on a strict read of the basic criteria, he passes muster...but it's a close thing, and the geographic limitation is an interesting point to raise. Regardless, I think barely passing the basic BIO criteria is grounds for a keep Deletion of Gerald Balone WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9333 5125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judwaa 2 NONE NONE delete According to our |notability guideline for films Deletion of Judwaa 2 WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
9334 12056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/220 Volt (band) User:Balle010 18:02, 20 August 2020 (UTC) keep because of . I think we should let this exist longer and see if more sources come up through this discussion Deletion of 220 Volt (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9335 2806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radicals for Capitalism User:Ihcoyc 15:21, 9 February 2009 (UTC) keep with some regret. This would appear to be a history of http://unionsong.com/u062.html economanic pseudo-libertarianism that has nevertheless been noted and reviewed by the ''New York Times'', ''The Guardian'', and other disinterested general interest publications. It would therefore appear to be |notable under the relevant specific guideline Deletion of Radicals for Capitalism WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9336 20183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manuel Franco (lawyer) User:Blue 01:01, 22 December 2012 (UTC) delete Fails - an appropriate standard since this article cites his television show Deletion of Manuel Franco (lawyer) WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
9337 8141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrienne Murphy User:Bdboyc 02:56, 13 September 2014 (UTC) keep notable, does not fails |notability Deletion of Adrienne Murphy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9338 13063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of RahXephon staff User:Ohconfucius 06:22, 16 March 2007 (UTC) delete Wiki is #DIRECTORY|not a directory of TV credits of all and sundry who have participated in making any given film or product. The more important staff members may warrant a mention in the RahXephon article, but the rest are of absolutely no encyclopaedic interest whatsoever, #PAPER|paper or otherwise Deletion of List of RahXephon staff WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9339 14468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maki Te Ju-Jitsu User:RGTraynor 17:31, 29 March 2007 (UTC) delete fails , , OR and by asserting that there's a genuine martial arts technique for fighting guns, . A Google search indicates that this is taught in a school up Seattle way, is word-for-word from the website, is the only Wikipedia activity of the creator. Just another bullshido studio, is my informed opinion Deletion of Maki Te Ju-Jitsu WP:ATT||WP:N||WP:NOR||WP:BULLSHIT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
9340 3599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atlas Honda User:K 22:22, 18 February 2017 (UTC) keep """largest manufacturer"""" is a sufficient claim to notability; the company is as well. The article is not terribly promotional at this stage; I removed self-citations""" Deletion of Atlas Honda WP:LISTED Wikipedia:Notability 77
9341 5710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Sampson User:Ceosad 16:54, 13 December 2015 (UTC) delete It might be also wise to protect the redirect for some time (a few months?) to block recreating this article. Just in case. I do not think there is much to preserve as the sources are very bad. Deletion of Andrew Sampson WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
9342 15329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Pitcock User:AndreniW 00:23, 16 February 2010 (UTC) keep He is notable for creating many softwares in use by many people. I found http://www.freesoftwaremagazine.com/columns/mister_pitcocks_wild_ride this as a source, but I'm not sure where exactly it could be used. If someone would like to |be bold and use it as an inline source for the article, that'd be awesome Deletion of William Pitcock WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
9343 11967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islamic terrorism crisis in France User:Finnusertop 01:10, 15 November 2015 (UTC) delete Claims of significance and notability entirely consist of OR and Deletion of Islamic terrorism crisis in France WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
9344 10831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scammers (band) User:TheGracefulSlick 15:32, 25 May 2018 (UTC) delete """Bandcamp is not a reliable source; that really is the extent of """"coverage"""" devoted to this band which says nothing for |GNG""" Deletion of Scammers (band) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9345 12776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mongolia during Tang rule User:Ikip 07:34, 26 February 2009 (UTC) keep Incredibly well researched article, which meets and exceeds all policies and guidelines. '''Please consider closing for canvassing reasons.''' I am notifying anvass of this issue Deletion of Mongolia during Tang rule WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
9346 7879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Jones (architect) (2nd nomination) User:Cynical 14:27, 15 August 2006 (UTC) keep per :'A process that resulted in article deletion or keeping, should generally be respected and the article not immediately re-nominated for deletion Deletion of Alan Jones (architect) (2nd nomination) WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9347 6159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles I. Ecker User:SportingFlyer 08:34, 4 June 2018 (UTC) delete """There's two sources which directly talk about him - one is his obituary, the other is a piece on his absolutely failed gubernatorial campaign. The Washington Post gave him a """"slim to none"""" chance of becoming governor in this interview with him: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/local/longterm/library/statewide/eckertrans.htm Clear fail""" Deletion of Charles I. Ecker WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9348 20273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ateneo Graduate School of Business User:SBKSPP 00:26, 26 June 2021 (UTC) merge to Ateneo de Manila University#Professional Schools. Fails per nom Deletion of Ateneo Graduate School of Business WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9349 659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Greenberg (soccer) (2nd nomination) User:Fenix 15:06, 17 November 2014 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Michael Greenberg (soccer) (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9350 5126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Peacock User:Hydronium 14:41, 13 March 2016 (UTC) keep MOS:DABRL also applies. This is probably a against criterion 1 given you don't appear to actually want the page deleted at this point, just edited down (?). The Devil's Dust line should be deleted since it's just a fictionalised/dramatised version of the real person (I've added a bit of crosslinking to the DD and KC articles Deletion of Matt Peacock WP:SPEEDYKEEP Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
9351 6115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaif Ali User:Eggishorn 19:13, 14 March 2017 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability under Deletion of Kaif Ali WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9352 7591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mareo Kamei User:4meter4 21:21, 25 September 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Mareo Kamei WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9353 8654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Watson (entrepreneur) User:BenKuykendall 04:57, 29 June 2020 (UTC) delete The German Order of Merit|Order of Merit has been awarded to over 200,000 people. Thus it alone is not sufficient to show notability. None of the other sources look like they help pass Deletion of Stephen Watson (entrepreneur) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9354 16448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Walzcak User:Mikaey 17:28, 26 March 2009 (UTC) delete I'd have to agree with Atmoz, this fails Deletion of Dr. Walzcak WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9355 13496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emirates Lounge User:Nsk92 00:09, 17 August 2008 (UTC) delete Looks to be a case Deletion of Emirates Lounge WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
9356 9732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamilton Moses Jr User:JulesH 11:53, 17 July 2007 (UTC) delete per #MEMORIAL Deletion of Hamilton Moses Jr WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9357 485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammad Hassan Khan User:Z1720 23:02, 29 September 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and . A candidate for office does not automatically get notability and there are no sources that show . A search of Google, JSTOR, and Academic OneFile and newspaper databases did not produce additional results Deletion of Muhammad Hassan Khan WP:NPOL||WP:GNG||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9358 15038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AlBaho Case User:Dhartung 22:19, 5 May 2008 (UTC) delete case with no notability regardless of its perceived earthshaking importance. Fails in most respects Deletion of AlBaho Case WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9359 8751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ed (Ed, Edd n Eddy) NONE NONE comment """I'm kind of going to stay neutral on whether the article should be kept or not. After all, it does comply with most of , but it could use a bit of work (probably with |tone, |trivia, and |in-universe perspective). On the other hand, if I wanted the admin to delete the article, much of the editors (especially Elaich and the IP who keeps experimenting with Linux) who edit List of characters in Ed, Edd n Eddy would be happy about it. There would be less """"|fancruft traps""" Deletion of Ed (Ed, Edd n Eddy) WP:FICT||WP:TONE||WP:TRIV||WP:WAF||WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9360 3764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Empowerment and Rights Institute User:Margin1522 11:32, 28 January 2015 (UTC) keep The organization's http://www.erichina.org/english/eariinthenews.htm own website has dozens of other references. They don't all mention it directly, but normally the 4 cites in the article should be enough. One thing is that all of those references are from 2005 or 2006, as were mentions in books. It might not exist anymore. But under , if it was notable in 2005 I think it's still keep. – Deletion of Empowerment and Rights Institute WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9361 7484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Space Battleship Yamato (spaceship) (2nd nomination) User:Daedalus969 09:18, 14 September 2008 (UTC) delete per nom, , Deletion of Space Battleship Yamato (spaceship) (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
9362 401 [[007 - Alles oder Nichts]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Christian140 21:41, 24. Aug. 2011 (CEST) keep Das Spiel ist jedenfalls . Der Artikel erfüllt #Video-_und_Computerspiele. Vor 6 Jahren wurde der Artikel wohl wegen POV gelöscht. Das ist hier aber nicht der Fall. Von daher: '''behalten'''. Gegebenenfalls sollten die Rechtschreibfehler noch korrigiert werden. Hab schonmal drübergeguckt, aber ein paar Blicke mehr schaden ja nicht Löschung von 007 - Alles oder Nichts Wikipedia:Rk Wikipedia:Notability 77
9363 930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Will Tucker User:Gongshow 13:58, 20 October 2012 (UTC) delete I'm unable to find sufficient evidence that the subject meets or at this time Deletion of Will Tucker WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9364 11919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DHVANI User:AllyD 07:52, 16 May 2020 (UTC) delete Such coverage as exists relates to the company's promotion of its mask initiative which in my opinion falls under ''Trivial coverage'' at . I see |nothing indicating |attained notability Deletion of DHVANI :WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:RS||:WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9365 3182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Caldwell (programmer) User:RFerreira 07:20, 2 December 2007 (UTC) keep agree wholeheartedly that is not grounds for deletion, just better policing of the article Deletion of Christopher Caldwell (programmer) WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
9366 7242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deathmatch Village User:Aoidh 22:58, 1 January 2021 (UTC) keep As a disclaimer I am the author of the article. The nom says that the article does not meet , however the game has been covered by Pocket Gamer, EuroGamer, neither of which were related to the article and were non-trivial mentions. Yes, it was a sxmall game that did not receive favorable reviews but I think the sources I added after the deletion nomination show that mention of the game is non-trivial especially in the context of its cross-play feature, which was not something that existed at the time in many other games, if any. Having a MetaCritic review is not part of the Deletion of Deathmatch Village WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9367 2702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Practicing for Love: A Memoir User:DESiegel 04:37, 18 May 2020 (UTC) delete unless multiple |independant published |reliable sources are found and cited. I looked and did not find any. There should be no prejudice against later recreation '''if''' proper sources to demonstrate notability become available later Deletion of Practicing for Love: A Memoir WP:IS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9368 11369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellen Stagg [[User talk:104.163.154.101|talk]]) 22:03, 10 December 2017 (UTC) keep This is a good example judging a book by its cover and the failure to do . I did my research and found three decent mentions in news and books in five minutes. I see more out there. The article is a mess, but why not improve it rather than delete? Notability (GNG)is established by sourcing. Special:Contributions/104.163.154.101|104.163.154.101 Deletion of Ellen Stagg WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9369 20476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uday Sathe User:AuthorAuthor 01:39, 8 September 2017 (UTC) delete Blatantly promotional attempt at writing a Wiki article. Fails and oldier Deletion of Uday Sathe WP:GNG||WP:S Wikipedia:Notability 77
9370 18044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Super Fartio Brothers User:Editor88 07:06, 24 May 2006 (UTC) delete all - This is a perfect example of Deletion of Super Fartio Brothers WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
9371 9744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of differences between Columbia's and Filmation's Ghostbusters User:Bulldog123 03:11, 12 July 2007 (UTC) delete Complete '' Deletion of List of differences between Columbia's and Filmation's Ghostbusters WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
9372 6683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raj Anadkat User:Mr 05:04, 8 July 2021 (UTC) keep per'' (). He is a popular television Actor, In this article there are some references Deletion of Raj Anadkat WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9373 389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Smidge User:Æk 02:50, 31 December 2009 (UTC) merge to wiktionary, per Deletion of Smidge WP:NOTDICT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9374 9545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Travelsupermarket.com User:Slgrandson 15:41, 2 August 2006 (UTC) delete per and . Alexa rank: http://alexa.com/data/details/main?url=travelsupermarket.com 13,647. --SlgrWikipedia:Esperanza|@ndson Deletion of Travelsupermarket.com WP:CORP||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
9375 3071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naomi Kent User:Tubezone 01:47, 22 November 2006 (UTC) comment She definitely is mentioned on the Leicester Sound web page, so she's not a hoax (although many radio personalities use stage names), but notability is another question. If the source of the interview can't be verified, this article should be speedied as an |attack page, looks like someone wants to make her appear to be a bimbo Deletion of Naomi Kent WP:APAGE Wikipedia:Attack page 100
9376 15595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jain Acharya Vijay Ratnakarsuri User:Anupmehra 14:40, 17 January 2015 (UTC) delete It simply fails and . Nothing helpful found on Google news, books, HighBeam, JSTOR and WP:INDAFD search engines Deletion of Jain Acharya Vijay Ratnakarsuri WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9377 252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Takuro Ueno User:Joe 20:27, 7 April 2011 (UTC) delete unless more reliable sources can be found. Unfortunately, the Marquis WW's aren't considered reliable (see, for example, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Noticeboard/Archive_53#Is_Who.27s_Who_a_reliable_source.3F), and I'm unable to find significant |secondary coverage of this consultant under this name or 上野拓朗, you'd think there'd be a news article or book that gives some in-depth coverage of him somewhere. AEA membership is not a criteria for notability, nor is being a teacher (see WP:PROF for guidance on that), but more important than questions of notability are the questions of verifiability. At present, we have no verifiable reliable sources that I can see, and WP:BLP and WP:V leave little room for any result but delete in such a case Deletion of Takuro Ueno WP:SECONDARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
9378 6808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pakleni otok User:GregorB 14:40, 26 July 2018 (UTC) keep Preserved in the Croatian State Archives,http://arhinet.arhiv.hr/details.aspx?ItemId=1_68861 therefore meets #4 Deletion of Pakleni otok WP:NFO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9379 12903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard V. Kahn User:Eric 22:01, 11 December 2011 (UTC) delete WP:COI is not a reason for deletion, by itself. Still, could not find enough to establish notability under . Does not seem to pass either. The subject’s h-index is 2, based on a GS search. The Green Theory & Praxis journal currently has an average of 0.86 citations per article; way too low at the moment to qualify the subject under criterion #8 (editor-in-chief of established journal Deletion of Richard V. Kahn WP:PROF||WP:BIO||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9380 11422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phoenix Order User:Metropolitan90 23:53, 21 October 2005 (UTC) merge per Mikka. Student organizations that exist at only a single school are generally non-notable; this one is |nonverifiable, too Deletion of Phoenix Order WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9381 11173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LEGERDEMAIN User:Alan 20:42, 20 September 2006 (UTC) delete """no redirect. Maybe worth a mention in the Amelia Earhart article if claims of """"only non-theory book ever published"""" can be verified, but otherwise this is a classic case of """ Deletion of LEGERDEMAIN WP:VANITY Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
9382 4649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 Ukraine train bus collision [[User talk:Jim Carter - Public|Jim Carter (''from public cyber'')]]''' 18:34, 28 July 2014 (UTC) keep needs some expansion. Event just passes . There are few more non English sources which can be added Deletion of 2014 Ukraine train bus collision WP:NEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9383 15570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucky commando films User:Kolma8 20:37, 21 March 2021 (UTC) delete per nom. Not enough to pass GNG, and imo Deletion of Lucky commando films WP:ORGCRIT||WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
9384 4804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Navarini User:SheffieldSteel 21:35, 29 April 2008 (UTC) delete While he holds a position of some authority, the available sources are trivial mentions. Fails Deletion of George Navarini WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9385 15593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stan Obal User:TJ 00:45, 18 November 2006 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Stan Obal WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9386 21261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tumor (Band) User:Esradekan 05:20, 23 September 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per . Article lacks |significant coverage in reliable sources. Even by admission of those above, the Tumor references are trivial. Seems to be enough for a Chris Pohl article though Deletion of Tumor (Band) WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9387 15525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nitrogen intoxication User:Non 01:01, 1 June 2015 (UTC) delete """based on I have no idea what this article is even talking about. As the nominator said, """"contains no encyclopedic content""" Deletion of Nitrogen intoxication WP:A1 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9388 7759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kushal (Hindi word) User:Bearian 01:02, 18 February 2020 (UTC) delete per above, and as an |ordinary name Deletion of Kushal (Hindi word) WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
9389 18118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kostas Stafylidis User:Sir 02:31, 7 September 2011 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro match and therefore fails , and he has not received significant coverage, therefore failing as well Deletion of Kostas Stafylidis WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9390 1982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/R3 Ring road (Belgium) User:Arxiloxos 16:32, 20 December 2012 (UTC) comment """Isn't this the kind of numbered, limited access, national road system highway that is generally kept, per and per the statement at Wikipedia:Notability (highways) that """"highways that are numbered and signed as part of a single, national highway network are generally notable and should have their own articles""""? Note that the Frenchhttp://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cat%C3%A9gorie:Ring_belge and Dutchhttp://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Categorie:Ringweg_in_Belgi%C3%AB Wikipedias, and others, have comprehensive coverage of the Belgian ring roads, and that a GNews search for turns up current coverage of this road https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&client=firefox-a&hs=aw4&tbo=d&rls=org.mozilla%3Aen-US%3Aofficial&biw=1680&bih=865&tbm=nws&q=r3+ring+Charleroi&oq=r3+ring+Charleroi&gs_l=serp.12...7913.8495.0.11990.5.5.0.0.0.2.123.475.3j2.5.0...0.0...1c.1.zVr-h-HBjqQhttps://www.google.com/search?q=r3+ring+Charleroi&hl=en&client=firefox-a&hs=UHk&tbo=d&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&tbm=nws&source=lnt&tbs=ar:1&sa=X&ei=FDzTUKrQDsKsjALfhYEQ&ved=0CCQQpwUoBQ&biw=1680&bih=865""" Deletion of R3 Ring road (Belgium) WP:ROADOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9391 19125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amador Tajanlangit User:E 13:57, 26 April 2017 (UTC) delete """He is listed at Candidates for sainthood, (only a fraction of the names on the page are bluelinked,) but he does not appear on the Congregation for the Causes of Saints list, where everybody gets bluelinked because the Church of Rome has officially recognized them as candidates for beatification. He doesn't get a an automatic pass from his status as an unofficial candidate. Notability therefore depends on meeting . Here's a 2014 source calling him """"Amador M. Tajanlangit"""" http://www.asianews.it/news-en/Filipino-Catholics-launch-petition-for-the-canonization-of-a-devotee-to-Our-Lady-31041.html. More sources under the honorific """"Tay Amador"""" - which brings up a lot of false positives https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Tay+Amador%22&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8, and a couple of news hits https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Tay+Amador%22&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8#q=%22Tay+Amador%22&tbm=nws. I also ran news archives searches on name and variants, and got zip - nothing at all - on proquest under any name I searched. To me, it looks like a recent flurry of interest, not quite sufficient for an article. Possibly """ Deletion of Amador Tajanlangit WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
9392 18623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ramon Sean Rivas User:onel5969 20:52, 25 July 2017 (UTC) delete agree with the nom's rationale, as well as searches not turning up enough in-depth coverage to show they meet Deletion of Ramon Sean Rivas WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9393 21156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of copyright case law User:Notecardforfree 19:06, 4 August 2017 (UTC) keep per . If the list becomes too large, we can subdivide if necessary, but that is no reason to delete this Deletion of List of copyright case law WP:LSC Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
9394 13661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hal houser User:Just 22:02, 4 January 2006 (UTC) comment seems like the MD of a large firm which clearly meets , does that not qualify automatically? If kept needs aggressive cleanup, though, as stated above Deletion of Hal houser WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9395 16664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carousel Theatre User:Peripitus 08:38, 2 June 2008 (UTC) keep """or am I missing something here. Certainly the article as nominated for AfD asserted no notability but I can see lots online. I can see numerous reviews on reviewvancouver.com http://www.reviewvancouver.org/th_much_ado06.htm http://www.reviewvancouver.org/th_odyssey07.htm , eight on vancouverplays (reviews by alleged Professor of English Jerry Wasserman) http://www.vancouverplays.com/search_results.shtml?cx=015530973997843538966%3Abmvcap3lhhk&cof=FORID%3A9&q=carousel&sa=Search#748 and others. There appear to be a number of useful news articles just through google searching, notable enough to be listed in guide books (Vancouver, Victoria and Whistler, 2007). Noted in ''Canada on Stage'' York University, 1982 as """"One undeniable bright spot in Vancouver theatre during the season was the work turned in by Carousel Theatre and Green Thumb, the city's two professional ..."""" . Noted in """"The Canadian encyclopedia"""", 1988 - """"The Oxford Companion to Canadian Theatre"""", 1989 and so on. All up there is clearly enough material from |reliable sources to write an informative and |verifyable article""" Deletion of Carousel Theatre WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9396 220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of casinos User:Mr 04:47, 12 February 2009 (UTC) keep """Sigh. Absolutely not redundant to category casinos, from: ists#Purposes of lists: ''""""Redundancy between lists and categories is beneficial because they are synergistic, and is covered in the guideline Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates.""""'' Please, don't be a list hater""" Deletion of List of casinos WP:L Wikipedia:Lists 97
9397 3718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ronilački klub Bosna User:Largoplazo 12:43, 23 November 2015 (UTC) keep The treatment of articles not in English is explained at ages needing translation into English. This nomination is premature by two weeks, after which the article, if not already translated or deleted for some other reason, will almost certainly be ROD|PRODded Deletion of Ronilački klub Bosna WP:P||WP:PROD Wikipedia:Portal 85
9398 5822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ravensword 2: Shadowlands NONE NONE keep EC}} There is easily enough coverage to satisfy the . I've gone and bulked up the reception section with 5 or so reviews, but there's plenty out there Deletion of Ravensword 2: Shadowlands WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9399 11045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Progri User:ThePaintedOne 09:30, 6 February 2011 (UTC) keep the re-write certainly aserts notability, and it looks to be cited. Of course I can't read the citations as they are in Albanian but I'm happy to |assume good faith that they say what they claim to say and have switched my vote accordingly Deletion of Ali Progri WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
9400 10192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Biocentric universe (2nd nomination) [[User talk:2605:8D80:6C0:775D:E830:4605:AB87:7879|talk]]) — [[Special:Contributions/2605:8D80:6C0:775D:E830:4605:AB87:7879|2605:8D80:6C0:775D:E830:4605:AB87:7879]] ([[User talk:2605:8D80:6C0:775D:E830:4605:AB87:7879|talk]]) has made [[Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|few or no other edits]] outside this topic. 00:18, 10 December 2016 (UTC) keep I was almost convinced by the Fringe arguments, so I read it. And while I was leaning to vote merge, the rules there changed my mind. The notability standard for Fringe, , includes the subsection “Notability versus Acceptance”, which very clearly states that being fringe is not a sufficient reason for deletion or merger. It cites general notability guidelines specifically as what should be applied, and as has been described above, the article very clearly meets . It states further that “a lack of peer-reviewed sources does not automatically mean that the subject should be excluded from Wikipedia,” which contradicts all arguments above claiming that peer-review is needed. Furthermore, I fear that a push to merge, especially if GNG is met, may be an effort to and in danger of violating . The Lanza page already mentions the theory, and so should there be a vote to merge or delete, no real changes would need to be made … so the merger argument seems highly redundant to me. It would not be needed to permit content on the idea on the Lanza page. Really, this is about keeping or deleting for me, black and white.Special:Contributions/2605:8D80:6C0:775D:E830:4605:AB87:7879|2605:8D80:6C0:775D:E830:4605:AB87:7879 Deletion of Biocentric universe (2nd nomination) WP:NFRINGE||WP:GNG||WP:FRINGEBLP Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
9401 2430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Institutions of learning in Pakistan during antiquity User:Adamant1 15:36, 12 May 2021 (UTC) merge to Ancient institutions of learning in the Indian subcontinent per Knox490, who's opinion I totally agree with. Also, I don't think it's historically correct to say these places had anything to do with Pakistan when they were around in pre-Pakistanian times. Anymore then it would be accurate for the United States to be cited as the originator or location of anything to do with pre-Colonialist Native American cultures, higher intuitions or otherwise. Doing so would both come off as nationalistic and |original research. That said, I'd cavate that the problem could potentially be solved through renaming the article and editing it to not have a nationalistic, original research bent to it, and I'm willing to give the creator the benefit of the doubt that they did not intend to write it that way, but I don't think it's necessary compared to just merging or redirecting it into the other article. Since keeping the article, especially as currently is (but even if it was heavily modified) clearly isn't the best option here Deletion of Institutions of learning in Pakistan during antiquity WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9402 17528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Res-q healthcare User:Huon 17:41, 8 July 2007 (UTC) delete as |unsourced, probably |spam. No Google News hits Deletion of Res-q healthcare WP:RS||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9403 14807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The supernatural in monotheistic religions User:205 19:30, 17 August 2006 (UTC) delete as a violation of . |Wikipedia is not the place to store college essays. Humor is always refreshing on AfD pages Deletion of The supernatural in monotheistic religions WP:NOR||WP:NOT Wikipedia:No original research 65
9404 18503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Big Gay Musical User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:30, 21 January 2009 (UTC) keep as the film is most definitely not and the improved article NOW tickles past Deletion of The Big Gay Musical WP:CRYSTAL||WP:NFF Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9405 10774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chad Focus User:KingAndGod 20:45, 7 April 2018 (UTC) keep """Passes (for musicians) criterion #2 as having a song chart on a national music chart. The charting song for Chad Focus is """"Dance With Me"""" which has charted on the Billboard Dance Club Songs chart, that is an acceptable chart per """ Deletion of Chad Focus WP:NMUSIC||WP:BILLBOARDCHARTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9406 16605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carmen Robertson User:Slawekb 10:33, 15 March 2016 (UTC) delete """I am not seeing any evidence of notability under . I was claimed that the book """"Seeing red"""" makes for an automatic pass under because of how impactful it was in the field. However, that book https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=seeing+red+carmen+robertson&btnG=&hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C33 only gets 35 GS citations, which makes claims of its significance rather unlikely""" Deletion of Carmen Robertson WP:GNG||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9407 125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/720 Degrees Debian User:Pak21 12:16, 26 February 2007 (UTC) delete while the howto part has been removed, there is no sign of any mention of this software in |reliable sources as required by |verifiability Deletion of 720 Degrees Debian WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9408 1655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antonio Siyaka User:BlameRuiner 18:12, 27 July 2014 (UTC) keep per . Here's some media coverage: http://fcdnepr.by/2407-kadry Siyaka promoted to Dnepr's senior team, http://by.tribuna.com/tribuna/blogs/orsha_terminal/639306.html This year's most promising young players of the league Deletion of Antonio Siyaka WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
9409 20603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martian Metals User:Chetsford 01:13, 24 February 2020 (UTC) delete The company clearly existed, and there are some (marginal) RS to prove that, but the mere existence of a thing is not proof of its . Due to the absence of , this fails our and CORP Deletion of Martian Metals WP:N||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9410 974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Christians (3rd nomination) User:Jreferee 19:58, 29 September 2007 (UTC) delete The membership criteria listed at the top of the article appears to be closer to meeting Wikipedia:Lists#Criteria_for_inclusion_in_lists|Criteria for inclusion in lists. However, it fails to mention anything about independent reliable sources. Including those people who have identified themselves as a Christian as noted on the article talk page violates the independent requirement of the Wikipedia:Notability#general_notability_guideline|general notability guidelines. The implementation of that criteria for individuals clearly is |original research whose selective inclusion in the list are designed to give a negative view of Christians. Despite the message sent by Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Christians (2nd nomination)|AfD#2, that message was not received by those who re-created this article. The re-creation of this article after deletion in unencyclopedic form and against policy creates a need to protect this topic from further re-creation until a new group of editors become interested in the topic and the old editors have moved on to other topics Deletion of List of Christians (3rd nomination) WP:OR||WP:POV Wikipedia:No original research 65
9411 5498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1. What is JMS ? Why JMS ? User:Doc 21:58, 27 February 2009 (UTC) delete This reads like |someone's homework. Wikipedia is not for posting |essays Deletion of 1. What is JMS ? Why JMS ? WP:NOTWEBHOST||WP:NOTOR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9412 8313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kieran Stewart User:Fenix 08:27, 21 October 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Kieran Stewart WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9413 5144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rafiqul Islam Masum User:CAPTAIN 21:42, 16 August 2017 (UTC) delete non-notable Deletion of Rafiqul Islam Masum WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9414 4948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victor Orta User:Fenix 15:23, 27 July 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG. The non-routine coverage of him seems to be localized to the Middlesborough area Deletion of Victor Orta WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9415 115 [[Roden (Roden)]] (bleibt) Benutzer:XY499395 14:37, 12. Jun. 2014 (CEST) keep Der Artikel ist allgemeinverständlich, da er sich von dem Artikel des anderen Ortsteils der Gemeinde abgrenzt, und deshalb benutzerfreundlich. Es spricht wohl nichts dagegen, den Artikel zu . Sollten doch wichtige Gründe dagegensprechen, geben Sie diese an oder ändern Sie die #Geographische_Objekte.2C_Siedlungen|RK Löschung von Roden (Roden) Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
9416 13590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Political privacy User:Bearian 17:49, 22 July 2016 (UTC) merge per Deletion of Political privacy WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
9417 21674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ann Louise Gittleman User:Cullen328 15:51, 8 March 2011 (UTC) keep This person is notable. The nominator was the original author of the article last June. Originally, the article was a self-promotional puff piece full of gushing praise for this nutritionist. Other editors re-wrote the article to remove peacock terms and reflect what the |reliable sources actually say about this person's work, and now the subject doesn't like the article. No convincing reason to delete the article has been offered Deletion of Ann Louise Gittleman WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9418 1282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Learn direct (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:34, 23 February 2013 (UTC) delete lacks |verifiability and feels of hoax. Of course, an indie or student film of extreme low budget ''might'' lack requisite coverage without actually being a hoax... but for this one, there is nothing at all... in RS or non-RS Deletion of Learn direct (film) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9419 1427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2021–22 Boreham Wood F.C. season User:Govvy 19:46, 21 June 2021 (UTC) delete For failing , {{u|Skyblueshaun}} Should know not create level 5 or lower season articles, unless under it's a special season Deletion of 2021–22 Boreham Wood F.C. season WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9420 285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nels J. Smith User:WilliamThweatt 08:32, 28 November 2015 (UTC) keep satisfies (1) of . Due to the era, online sources may be few, but having served 16 years as a state legislator, he's bound to be notable. The article has possibilities, it's just a matter of scrounging up some (most likely offline) sources Deletion of Nels J. Smith WP:POLITICIANS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9421 6869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tirion Fordring User:Quasirandom 00:30, 16 November 2007 (UTC) comment An article having plot summaries is |not a guideline violation. If the article is LARGELY plot summary, then there's a problem. Please be careful with your rationales Deletion of Tirion Fordring WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9422 18890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amulet (band) User:Chubbles 22:27, 24 March 2021 (UTC) keep The German entry indicates that the group charted in Norway, which meets . I do not have confidence in the work done here based on the nomination rationale Deletion of Amulet (band) WP:MUSIC||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9423 21058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of heroic fictional scientists and engineers User:Maclean25 06:27, 10 January 2007 (UTC) delete """as a subjective list with no sources. Inconsistent with . They are """"herioc"""" because the Wikipedia contributor says so""" Deletion of List of heroic fictional scientists and engineers WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
9424 14178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Souvik Pal User:Rms125a 17:28, 18 December 2017 (UTC) delete fails |NOTABILITY and |GNG Deletion of Souvik Pal WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9425 17025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben McKay (actor) User:Youngamerican 19:13, 5 April 2007 (UTC) delete The actor does not pass . I would argue against a G7, however, as the author didn't quite request deletion, but merely did not object Deletion of Ben McKay (actor) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9426 1361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fundamental Surprise User:Tevildo 12:20, 26 June 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails . G1 is tempting, but no Deletion of Fundamental Surprise WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9427 247 [[Reserve-Jäger-Bataillon Nr. 23]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Bomzibar 16:08, 12. Jul. 2013 (CEST) keep Nur mal so für Protokoll, damit das hier alle richtig verstehen können. Welche |Relevanzkriterien werden hier unterschritten bzw. nicht eingehalten?? Richtig gelesen - es gibt zu dem Themenfeld keine Relevanzkriterien. Von daher den Artikel . Diesen Löscheifer findet man eigenartigerweise nur in der deutschen Wikipedia Löschung von Reserve-Jäger-Bataillon Nr. 23 Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
9428 21680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cimmeria (Conan) User:Reyk 15:44, 11 July 2020 (UTC) delete """per Piotrus et al. I had originally thought to redirect to Hyborian Age#Nations and landmarks, but when I actually went and read that section I found it was nearly 100% |original reasearch. You can tell by all the """"perhaps derived from"""" and similar, without any attempt at sourcing. I think that whole section is ripe for removal or rewrite, so redirecting anything there seems to me to be futile and a bad idea""" Deletion of Cimmeria (Conan) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9429 10634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmad Irandoost User:Shfarshid 18:46, 4 January 2020 (UTC) keep per . Significant coverage Deletion of Ahmad Irandoost WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9430 13700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J. Math User:Anupmehra 02:44, 9 November 2016 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of J. Math WP:MUSBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9431 17250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clinton Foundation-State Department controversy User:Neutrality NONE delete A mishmash of political attacks, legitimate criticism, and selective quotation of sources, all cooked up for the pretty clear purpose of circumventing any attempt to build consensus at the main article, Clinton Foundation = a classic Deletion of Clinton Foundation-State Department controversy WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
9432 11879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United Express Flight 3411 [[User talk:173.227.169.66|talk]]) 00:16, 12 April 2017 (UTC) keep for now), per . The work (making the article) is done. It may become a noteworthy event, or it might join the leggings incident. Either way, per , it should be left until such time it is determined what the full impact of the incident is. If, at that time, it qualifies for and is voted to be deleted per , then the paragraph on UA's page will retain the noteworthy information. If it grows into a larger incident (or series of incidents), it may need to be moved to an appropriately titled page (such as a court case, etc). But, as stated, per , '''strong keep'''. Special:Contributions/173.227.169.66|173.227.169.66 Deletion of United Express Flight 3411 WP:RAPID||WP:RAPID||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:RAPID Wikipedia:Notability 77
9433 10039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Sams (2nd nomination) User:Eggishorn 00:00, 31 January 2018 (UTC) delete """The usual """"throw all the possible cites at the wall and see if enough stick"""" approach to article retention is evident. Many of the cites do not say what they are cited for saying, the cites that are significantly about this subject are not independent, and the cites that are independent are not significant. There's no sign of independent, significant sources in general searches, either. No way to pass or """ Deletion of David Sams (2nd nomination) WP:NBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9434 385 [[PocketPC.ch]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Tom_md 20:00, 11. Sep. 2013 (CEST) delete Nach #U irrelevantes Kleinstunternehmen Löschung von PocketPC.ch Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9435 4857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vernon Stewart Laurie User:The 19:16, 15 April 2013 (UTC) keep Between the various actions and honors this person did and achieved, there's more than enough here to estaiblish notability. |Being short is not a reason to delete Deletion of Vernon Stewart Laurie WP:TOOLITTLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9436 5364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dawn Valley Bible Methodist Church User:Green451 01:38, 23 November 2006 (UTC) delete per above comments. Just curious, is there a reason why something like this doesn't qualify for |CSD A7 Deletion of Dawn Valley Bible Methodist Church WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9437 18110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Power (actor) User:Ikip 22:05, 9 May 2009 (UTC) keep well referenced article, exceeds all notability guidelines. Editors delete votes seem to be ignoring and in their concentration on a subordinate set of criterias Deletion of Sean Power (actor) WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9438 8956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Wolfenden User:Peterkingiron 16:27, 17 September 2013 (UTC) delete There is clearly some content in the article (the Pope part, at least). Is he a person or a cartoon? I think the whole thing is a joke at WP's expense. Appearing twice at the Edinburgh Fringe (even if true) is not enouigh for notability Deletion of Martin Wolfenden WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
9439 12401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Velvet Cacoon User:Eleuthero 21:06, 6 January 2006 (UTC) delete """This group may shortly be notable, so userfying the information might be useful. At present it would appear to have only one actual signed release with """"Full Moon Productions"""" and thus does not meet usic (cf., http://www.fmp666.com FMP Prod.) The notability of FMP is also in doubt because of the 40,000 Yahoo! search hits, only ~1000 actually relate to that company (crosslink with search term """"black metal"""") with a number relating to a promotion company based in LA""" Deletion of Velvet Cacoon WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
9440 17131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PewDiePie User:Sergecross73 14:13, 24 July 2012 (UTC) delete """per JamesBWatson's commentary on sources. It takes more than an editors claims to """"rapid Youtube growth"""" to meet the . There doesn't seem to be significant coverages in |reliable, third party sources for this person""" Deletion of PewDiePie WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9441 6353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hawks PDX NONE NONE keep """Per on , """"Evidence of significant coverage by international or national, or at least regional, media is a strong indication of notability."""" Willamette Week and PQ Monthly are regional, not solely local. It states """"at least one"""" is needed, and here we have two (possibly three, if you count TripSavvy, which is national. I just don't know anything about that site.) Below is a breakdown of the sources currently on the page, none of which are """"simple listings or compilations"""" (ie: phone numbers and street address, etc.) Each is a review, excluding Oregon Bears, which covers events and services offered""" Deletion of Hawks PDX WP:AUD||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9442 13896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alden, California User:Cxbrx 14:26, 12 October 2020 (UTC) keep Being a post office is a legal recognition, which fulfills #1. (I know others don't agree.) Alden Post Office was named after https://localwiki.org/oakland/Solomon_E._Alden Solomon E. Alden, who owned a bunch of Temescal, Oakland, California. https://abitofhistory.website/2019/06/13/alden-farm/ Alden Farm was located south of this location Deletion of Alden, California WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9443 9702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siblu Europe User:Ihcoyc 15:19, 20 January 2012 (UTC) delete per nomination. This business ''sells holidays to 14 holiday parcs in France and also sells holidays to 10 independently owned holiday parcs in France, Spain and Italy''. References are to announcements that various facilities have opened or closed. No showing of |significant effects on history, technology, or culture Deletion of Siblu Europe WP:ORGIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9444 17989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/U'ujio User:Nsk92 14:52, 21 August 2008 (UTC) delete Almost certainly a hoax. In any case fails , and Deletion of U'ujio WP:V||WP:BIO||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9445 9386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benjamin Bradley (pornographic actor) User:Niteshift36 15:28, 7 July 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Benjamin Bradley (pornographic actor) WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9446 3221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Achyutanand singh User:Necrothesp 14:42, 25 February 2015 (UTC) keep Notable per Deletion of Achyutanand singh WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9447 19996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Trek versus Star Wars (4th nomination) User:Zunaid 15:56, 21 August 2007 (UTC) delete As with any |synthesis article, notability of the concept being synthesised into a topic must be demonstrated by referencing independent sources ''that have ALREADY made the synthesis''. Without such third party referencing this article is fails both NOR as well as notability guidelines Deletion of Star Trek versus Star Wars (4th nomination) WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
9448 14203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Herlache User:Safiel 22:20, 25 February 2013 (UTC) delete Other than a press release, no indication of notability. Fails Deletion of Michael Herlache WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9449 13329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wapedia User:JulesH 11:41, 10 August 2007 (UTC) keep http://www.vnunet.fr/articles/printView/fr/vnunet/news/2005/08/29/wikipedia-accessible-pda-mobile is an article primarily about this subject, as (apparently) is http://www.pctipp.ch/praxishilfe/kummerkasten/sonstiges/29653/wikipedia_fuer_pda.html (my German isn't as good as my French, so I can't say I entirely understand this article, but it certainly seems to be). Also reviewed briefly in http://www.pocketpcmag.com/_archives/nov05/whatsonline.aspx and http://www.pcworld.com/article/id,124883-page,3-c,freeware/article.html. I'm pretty sure between the four of them, that's enough coverage to meet Deletion of Wapedia WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
9450 7118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sophal Ear (2nd nomination) User:Horse 18:34, 29 April 2019 (UTC) keep the current page is weak but a quick search does seem to support the notion that the subject meets and is generally considered an expert in their field. See {{URL|https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/general/khmer-rouge-cambodian-volleyball-federation-president-death-squads-a8884316.html}} {{URL|https://www.economist.com/asia/2019/04/20/rapid-economic-growth-props-up-cambodias-strongman}}, {{URL|https://www.asiatimes.com/2019/04/article/hun-sen-has-a-one-china-dilemma/}},{{URL|https://www.abc.net.au/radio/programs/pm/crumbling-democracy:-sophal-ear-on-cambodian-pm-hun-sen/10044938}}, {{URL|https://www.cfr.org/blog/qa-cambodia-sophal-ear}},{{URL|https://theaseanpost.com/article/why-cambodias-opposition-failed-0 Deletion of Sophal Ear (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9451 8648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manfred van H. User:Colapeninsula 10:34, 1 October 2012 (UTC) merge to Blasphemy law#Germany or could use it as start of a separate article on German blasphemy law. As an article on the individual who is only known for one event it falls under . I wondered if the event might be notable, but a brief internet search (including German sources) suggests not: coverage is from around the time of his conviction with a lack of long-term interest aside from a few brief mentions. Finally, arguing against his notability as an individual, some newspaper stories don't even give his name, e.g.http://www.stern.de/politik/strafen-fuer-religionsbeschimpfung-im-deutschen-recht-1895970.html. German Wikipedia covers it in their article on blasphemy law, :de:Beschimpfung von Bekenntnissen, Religionsgesellschaften und Weltanschauungsvereinigungen, which isn't a deciding factor as different wikis have different policies, but may indicate its lack of notability Deletion of Manfred van H. WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
9452 21028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohd Zaidi Napiah User:GiantSnowman 21:51, 2 July 2010 (UTC) delete after further consideration, as there are no sources to prove that the player in question has actually ''played'' in a fully-professional league - simply being on the roster is not enough to pass Deletion of Mohd Zaidi Napiah WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9453 1790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Menachem Creditor (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 20:39, 12 May 2010 (UTC) keep per , although even more |sources would be helpful for a BLP Deletion of Menachem Creditor (2nd nomination) WP:HEY||WP:RS Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
9454 18354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suburban High School Hockey League User:Amarrg 05:29, 22 November 2007 (UTC) delete unless reliable secondary sources can be found and added to satisfy Deletion of Suburban High School Hockey League WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9455 3105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Godzilla (2012 film) (2nd nomination) User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:08, 9 February 2011 (UTC) comment Yes it is... but so what? IMDB is '''NOT''' a reliable source and has nothing to do with Wikipedia determination of what consitutes |notability. Their errors and lag time in making their own updates does not equate to us doing the same thing. We're faster, and we offer our readers actual sources for what is contained within our articles Deletion of Godzilla (2012 film) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9456 19837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Business & Decision User:Mkdw 08:38, 20 April 2013 (UTC) keep """DGG said """"non-notable business"""" but also pointed out which notes that publicly traded companies on major exchanges are notable.Euronext is the 5th largest stock exchange in the world and owned by the NYSE Euronext. is not a sure thing, BUT in less than a minute of conducting , I found sources about the company: http://www.reuters.com/article/2008/09/30/businessdecision-idUKLU51364120080930?type=companyNews Reuters, http://www.journaldunet.com/solutions/ssii/business-decision-1006.shtml Journal du Net (fr), http://pro.01net.com/editorial/349844/business-and-decision-privilegie-linternational/ 01net, http://investing.businessweek.com/research/stocks/private/snapshot.asp?privcapId=139438311 Bloomberg, http://finance.yahoo.com/news/infor-partners-business-decision-deliver-130000028.html Yahoo Finance, http://www.ibtimes.com/press-release/20120510/business-decision-named-qliktech-global-si-partner-year-663265 IBN, http://www.digitaljournal.com/pr/491314 Digital Journal, http://bx.businessweek.com/ims/view?url=http%3A%2F%2Fsend2pressnewswire.com%2F2011%2F01%2F03%2Fs2p4040_123056.php BusinessWeek, http://www.globes.co.il/serveen/globes/docview.asp?did=1000339740 Israel Business Arena, http://www.boursier.com/actions/actualites/news/business-et-decision-acquisition-de-la-societe-cognitis-iberica-172540.html Boursier.com (fr), http://www.lepoint.fr/actualites/2008-09-30/business-decision-compte-augmenter-son-activite-a-l-etranger/1037/0/278334 Le Point (fr). I won't list every source I found, that's not the point of AFDs, but suffice to say a company that has €249 million euros ($325 million dollars US) in capitalization in a year and 2,800 employees will likely have coverage and it does. Article's in horrible shape, but those are not -REASONs""" Deletion of Business & Decision WP:LISTED||WP:BEFORE||WP:DEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9457 2393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dogecoindark User:Dialectric 15:23, 17 July 2015 (UTC) delete Software (electronic currency) article of unclear notability, lacking independent references. The one ref listing blocks is not RS, nor significant coverage. A search turned up no significant coverage. Article was created by an Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|SPA as possibly promotional Deletion of Dogecoindark WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9458 12956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erodr User:Elmidae 20:13, 25 November 2019 (UTC) comment Well, technically |notability is not temporary - if it was sufficiently notable while in use, it remains notable now. So any arguments for deletion would have to be based on there never having been enough coverage in the first place. Do you posit that is the case? To my eyes, what's there is not particularly strong but it should do Deletion of Erodr WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9459 1328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DucKon User:Jbhunley 22:11, 22 October 2015 (UTC) delete Non-notable Con. Fails Deletion of DucKon WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9460 21570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Priya Abeweeragunawardana User:Anotherclown 09:44, 9 July 2015 (UTC) delete """not notable, subject lacks """"significant coverage"""" in |reliable sources per """ Deletion of Priya Abeweeragunawardana WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9461 4758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Warren (South Carolina politician) User:Firefly 08:16, 18 June 2018 (UTC) delete """fails (""""Just being ... an unelected candidate for political office, does not guarantee notability""""), and there isn't the |significant independent coverage to meet the |GNG either. As stated above, notability is about the here and now, not what could be. If the subject is elected, then the article can be recreated (and this content could be |undeleted if desired""" Deletion of John Warren (South Carolina politician) WP:NPOL||WP:42||WP:GNG||WP:REFUND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9462 3024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuran no Yami User:NeoChaosX 04:04, 5 July 2007 (UTC) delete as fan-created organization based on the series Naruto. Most fanfiction is non-notable per Deletion of Kuran no Yami WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9463 11178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Galya User:MichaelQSchmidt NONE delete and redirect to Jessie (TV series) without prejudice per otJustYet. While his short careerhttp://www.imdb.com/name/nm4433743/filmotype is |verifiable,http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Chris+Galya%22&hl=en&rls=com.microsoft:en-us&tbm=nws&source=lnt&tbs=ar:1&sa=X&ei=Tha4TqzSOcTkiALzrtxG&ved=0CBMQpwUoBQ it fails , and his lack of |coverage fails . We can at least send readers to the one place where he can be sourced in context to his work on that series Deletion of Chris Galya WP:N||WP:V||WP:ENT||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9464 20750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ERa Eternity User:Widefox 13:07, 20 July 2017 (UTC) comment the several arguments which are are to be avoided, so those !votes need weighing appropriately Deletion of ERa Eternity WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9465 8312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flightmare [[User talk:Czar|czar]] 18:55, 8 May 2021 (UTC) delete Article topic lacks |significant coverage from |reliable, |independent sources. (|?) It had no meaningful hits in a /RS|video game reliable sources https://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=003516479746865699832:leawcwkqifq custom Google search, just passing mentionshttps://www.techradar.com/uk/news/gaming/why-it-shouldn-t-be-left-to-pirates-to-keep-our-games-alive-1293355. There are no worthwhile redirect targets. If someone finds more (non-English and offline) sources, please {{tl|ping}} me Deletion of Flightmare WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:42||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9466 11399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randall Brown User:Armbrust 19:47, 18 September 2010 (UTC) delete as article fails |notability criteria for actors. He had no major roles and roles in school does not count Deletion of Randall Brown WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9467 16542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marc Y. Chenevert NONE NONE delete """He donated his work to the National Museum of Commercial Aviation and this counts under #4D """"represented within the permanent collections of several notable galleries or museums"""". The problem is the word """"several"""" as the National museum is just one. However the source also says """"All of Marc’s aviation artwork is included in this gift to the Museum with the exception of his Braniff International Airways drawings (which he plans to donate to a group in Dallas, Texas). This group is currently working towards a Braniff International Museum that will be exclusive to historical Braniff memorabilia, art and artifacts, including artworks by the renowned Alexander Calder as well as those of Marc Y. Chenevert."""" So if you count this second non-existent museum it would be """"several"""". Another problem is the complete lack of sourcing for , nobody has written about Chenevert anywhere (in reliable secondary sources). My guess is this artist will become better known now that donated artwork where it can be exhibited and written about, but it will take some time to see if that happens, so """ Deletion of Marc Y. Chenevert WP:ARTIST||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
9468 19987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kalusa (language) User:Bearian 18:15, 14 June 2011 (UTC) delete if someone can rescue this |through better sourcing, that would good, but I don't see how I can fix the problem Deletion of Kalusa (language) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9469 12893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Garfish Music User:SW3 16:29, 14 March 2017 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Garfish Music WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9470 9876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark McNeill User:Giants2008 01:11, 23 June 2011 (UTC) comment The 2011 NHL Entry Draft is going to start on the 24th, well within the period this AfD figures to run. According to what I'm reading on Google News, there's a strong chance this player will be selected in the first round. If that happens, McNeill will meet criterion 5 of . I won't say the article should be kept now ( and all that), but if he is picked in the first round you can consider this a keep Deletion of Mark McNeill WP:NHOCKEY||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9471 6627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global Gems User:Joe 21:56, 19 February 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |company Deletion of Global Gems WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9472 4407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/José Echenique User:Namiba 16:33, 3 July 2020 (UTC) keep passes having played at the highest international level Deletion of José Echenique WP:SPORTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9473 3773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comlink User:TheSandDoctor 05:36, 23 March 2018 (UTC) merge to Wiktionary (specifically, wikt:comlink or wikt:commlink) per . The title ''is'' searched for, has a relevant entry in Wiktionary, does not have a viable target for redirection here, and the title doesn't have much scope (largely science fiction oriented, so I do not think redirecting to transceiver would be appropriate). Therefore, I come to the conclusion that a soft redirect may be appropriate (per the steps outlined in Template:Wiktionary redirect Deletion of Comlink WP:POINTWIKT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9474 4038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Reinhart User:David 04:25, 9 May 2019 (UTC) delete The only form of notability claimed in the article is academic, but |our standards for academic notability explicitly exclude student awards. Merely having written a few review papers is inadequate for notability; the papers need to be heavily cited, and here they appear not to be. And the supposed references for the article are merely more things the subject has written, not anything that can be used as a reference about the subject. Far |too soon Deletion of Christopher Reinhart WP:PROF||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
9475 13264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saket Suman User:Randykitty 09:31, 18 June 2016 (UTC) delete No indication this meet , , or Deletion of Saket Suman WP:GNG||WP:NBIO||WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
9476 15226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeitgeist Project User:RHaworth 19:19, 23 March 2008 (UTC) delete Fractionally more substance than a typical |MADEUP article but nowhere near enough to justify inclusion Deletion of Zeitgeist Project WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
9477 17301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Features included in the Melways Street Directory User:Murtoa 03:51, 11 September 2008 (UTC) delete per . Irrelevant information Deletion of Features included in the Melways Street Directory WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9478 10138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dal Bahadur Thapa User:RightCowLeftCoast 15:03, 5 January 2011 (UTC) delete Fails & , bio specifically because neither of the current two references has the subject as the primary focus of what is being written Deletion of Dal Bahadur Thapa WP:SOLDIER||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9479 6507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hemant Birje User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:24, 8 December 2010 (UTC) keep per RS having been added to the article of this |prolific actor. I also note that morehttp://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Hemant+Birje%22+source%3A%22-newswire%22+source%3A%22-wire%22+source%3A%22-presswire%22+source%3A%22-PR%22+source%3A%22-release%22+source%3A%22-wikipedia%22&btnG=Search+Archives&scoring=ahttp://books.google.com/books?as_brr=0&as_pub=-icon&q=%22Hemant+Birje%22 are available for |improvement through regular editing Deletion of Hemant Birje WP:ENT||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
9480 947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LU:KUS discography User:Jersey92 03:37, 8 July 2014 (UTC) delete Unless someone produces that the subject is notable for some reason, it appears not to be Deletion of LU:KUS discography WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9481 3747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apto User:K 18:26, 4 November 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet ; significant RS coverage not found. Promotionalism only Deletion of Apto WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9482 16512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suspect guest house, Jalalabad [[User talk:98.119.158.59|talk]]) 02:27, 31 August 2009 (UTC) delete probably fails . Special:Contributions/98.119.158.59|98.119.158.59 Deletion of Suspect guest house, Jalalabad WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9483 13680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doug Morrison (character) [[User talk:DerbyCountyinNZ|Talk]] [[Special:Contributions/DerbyCountyinNZ|Contribs]]) 07:01, 26 April 2010 (UTC) delete """Undue eight|weight for a barely established character. The above comment that the character """"is featuring heavily currently and for the next few weeks"""" suggests a COI. {{#if:DerbyCountyinNZ|DerbyCountyinNZ|red""" Deletion of Doug Morrison (character) WP:W Help:Watchlist 110
9484 4279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avi Tuschman User:Jytdog 22:27, 21 May 2015 (UTC) delete per DGG - young scholar with one book. I will add that there have been two paid editors and an editor claiming to be Tuschman active at the article. I will be happy if we are able to delete this article and end all this pressure to violate Deletion of Avi Tuschman WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9485 4150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thengana User:TravisTX 00:54, 15 January 2008 (UTC) comment I spent 20-30 minutes researching this topic - I’m a bit of a map nut anyway - and the best I came up with is posted above. After another 15 minutes or so tonight, I found http://www.mapsofindia.com/maps/kerala/districts/kottayam.htm this map, which shows a place called ''Thanganal''. Google maps, however, has no entries for that name, and Google only turns up only two India-related hits. Between Google and several other searches, I still can’t find enough information to change my opinion. Maybe someone familiar with Southwestern India can shed some light on this. In the mean time, I’d like to suggest that you please |assume good faith on the part of the nominator. Regards Deletion of Thengana WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
9486 11349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plot of Hayate The Combat Butler User:Sephiroth 04:10, 27 June 2007 (UTC) delete clearly violates #IINFO|. We're getting a plot summary deletion trend Deletion of Plot of Hayate The Combat Butler WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9487 18957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Logan Brill User:Gongshow 23:32, 21 April 2014 (UTC) keep Coverage includes http://www.billboard.com/articles/columns/the-615/5740652/logan-brill-scars-exclusive-video-premiere ''Billboard'', http://www.cmtedge.com/2013/10/31/logan-brill-believes-in-chris-stapletons-ghosts/ CMT, http://www.suntimes.com/entertainment/music/22926573-421/story.html#.U1WnYFeypnJ ''Chicago Sun-Times'', http://www.knoxville.com/news/2014/mar/28/knoxville-music-logan-brill-rhythm-blooms-2014/?print=1 ''Knoxville News Sentinel'' (a local write-up, but seems to contain some worthwhile biographical info), and some shorter blurbs at country-specific sites http://theboot.com/logan-brill-bad-habits-song-premiere/http://www.roughstock.com/audio/audio-track-logan-brill-seven-year-rainhttp://www.engine145.com/song-premiere-logan-brill-nobodys-crying/. On the whole, there is enough material to pass and Deletion of Logan Brill WP:GNG||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9488 15377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Reffin Smith User:Safemariner 07:14, 7 January 2007 (UTC) keep Seems notable. More explicit references per would be good Deletion of Brian Reffin Smith WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9489 7498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dingli Swallows F.C. User:CommanderWaterford 18:12, 6 April 2021 (UTC) keep passes , see 2009–10_Maltese_Premier_League Deletion of Dingli Swallows F.C. WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9490 13587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heavy metal fashion User:CircafuciX 20:41, 15 March 2008 (UTC) delete I have made my decision finally and it should simply be deleted. It is laden with |POV issues, most of/or the entire article is full of |OR and not written with |NPOV in mind. It needs more sources (|reliable ones) which something really should have been done within the three years (hard to believe) of its existence. Also, the fact that we are taking ideas and pooling it as a generalized culture is enough to bare. If it doesn't get deleted then this is a wakeup call Deletion of Heavy metal fashion WP:POV||WP:OR||WP:NPOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
9491 19950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Formosa User:C 15:48, 20 September 2009 (UTC) keep Although the GNG says that the depth of coverage may vary according to the nature of the coverage, it does not disqualify local press entirely. He's lost one election, moved, and is preparing to stand for election again, so he doesn't quite hit the scope of . I have an editorial reservation or two about the article, but those aren't strong enough for me to say that the article should be deleted Deletion of Mark Formosa WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9492 7846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonny Beirne User:Blue520 15:47, 9 August 2006 (UTC) delete non verifiable Deletion of Jonny Beirne WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9493 8512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Achieving sex integration User:Roscelese 05:36, 11 June 2011 (UTC) delete Unlike in the other AfDs for articles by this user, there actually is a topic here, but a) it's redundant to Sex integration (integration is the state of being integrated, but also the process of ''achieving'' that state) and b) it's an unsalvageable mess. |Blow it up and get some other users down to Sex integration to knock that article into shape Deletion of Achieving sex integration WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
9494 12864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/London Buses route 79 User:Edison 06:11, 30 March 2010 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is a directory. No evidence this bus line satisfies Deletion of London Buses route 79 WP:NOT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9495 14625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Russert tributes User:23skidoo 14:06, 18 June 2008 (UTC) merge the most notable of these with the main article and '''delete''' this one. I agree a memorial. It would be interesting to add to the main article a (sourced) discussion as to why Russert's death had such a wide impact when his career was much shorter than that of, say, Jim McKay whose death went virtually unnoticed Deletion of Tim Russert tributes WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9496 7225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evestment User:Ihcoyc 17:39, 26 February 2013 (UTC) delete per nomination, also |spam and |too vague to improve by editing: ''a.... software solutions provider offering a SaaS-hosted database and analytic platform primarily used in the institutional investor and financial services community for analysis, reporting and research Deletion of Evestment WP:SPAM||WP:NONSENSE Wikipedia:Spam 112
9497 11582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Army Family Advocacy System of Records User:EricSerge 17:01, 26 August 2014 (UTC) delete does not meet . If the Army Family Advocacy Program does not yet warrant an article, how can its government contractor record system be notable enough for an article Deletion of Army Family Advocacy System of Records WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9498 19781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fernando Ledesma User:GiantSnowman 09:30, 15 May 2012 (UTC) keep meets , and Arsenalkid700 has offered to work on article to meet . Time should be allowed for this, and if it doesn't happen, we should review in future Deletion of Fernando Ledesma WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9499 16559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uruguay Football League User:Dubious 03:09, 10 January 2011 (UTC) delete as per . No mention of the UFL in Google News/Books or even Search, really Deletion of Uruguay Football League WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9500 975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faulter User:Ashleyyoursmile 12:03, 30 April 2021 (UTC) delete fails and . All I could find are reviews of their albums- https://www.punknews.org/review/5947/faulter-darling-buds-of-may and https://www.allmusic.com/album/darling-buds-of-may-mw0000469392. https://www.newuniversity.org/2005/03/14/battle_of_the_bands109/ This and https://www.mlive.com/news/bay-city/2015/07/second_night_of_fireworks_blas.html this are merely passing mentions/routine coverage. I'm seeing lack of coverage in multiple reliable sources that are independent of the subject. The recordings have not charted on national music charts, or received certifications or accolades Deletion of Faulter WP:BAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9501 13658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Car Spotting [[User Talk:Blaxthos|t]] / [[Special:Contributions/Blaxthos|c]] ) 03:14, 11 April 2008 (UTC) delete At best this is a |NEO, at worst it's |OR. USER:Blaxthos|Blaxthos Deletion of Car Spotting WP:NEO||WP:OR Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9502 9750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Graffiti (album) user:Ndenison 21:00, 11 August 2008 (UTC) delete Not verified as required by Deletion of Graffiti (album) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9503 16841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephanie Sheh (2nd nomination) User:VMS 01:50, 21 June 2014 (UTC) keep Enough sources are available to meet . The fact that no one has taken the time to cite them is not a valid reason for deletion Deletion of Stephanie Sheh (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9504 4120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gaming Realms User:HighKing 13:55, 28 May 2018 (UTC) delete Zero indications of notability, a run-of-the-mill company (with a marketing department) going about their business. Not a single one of the references meet the criteria for establishing notability. None are intellectually independent and they rely either on company announcements or quotations/interviews with company personnel. References fail and/or . Topic fails GNG and Deletion of Gaming Realms WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9505 117 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Selçuk bayraktar Kullanıcı:212.252.80.215212.252.80.215 19:41, 22 Şubat 2016 (UTC) comment kalsın}} (bkz. Yalnızca bir kullanıcı hesabı olanlar oy kullanabilir.) Sunulan bağlantılar, firma adresi, bilimsel yayınlar incelendiğinde kamuoyuna mal olmuş olduğu anlaşılıyor. --Özel:Katkılar/212.252.80.215|212.252.80.215 Selçuk bayraktarının silinmesi Vikipedi:OY Wikipedia:Administrators 89
9506 10995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James John Miles User:Xxanthippe 03:47, 18 August 2012 (UTC) comment """The only policy guideline that admits automatic notability by virtue of position held is rof##C6 which states """"6. The person has held a highest-level elected or appointed academic post at a major academic institution or major academic society."""" This applies to the chief executive officer of the institution (in this case the Vice-Chancellor). It has long been held on these pages that a Head of a Department does not qualify under this category""" Deletion of James John Miles WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
9507 15955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darren M Jackson [[User talk:Skomorokh|скоморохъ]] 09:47, 13 March 2008 (UTC) keep Afd is not cleanup, this subject appears to meet as the article references non-trivial coverage in multiple reliable sources independent of the subject Deletion of Darren M Jackson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9508 520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/L.E.F. Eden Garden Matriculation School User:Cordless 15:35, 30 November 2016 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of L.E.F. Eden Garden Matriculation School WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9509 383 [[Myclimate]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Hydro 14:00, 2. Jul. 2007 (CEST) keep Siehe /2._Juli_2007#Atmosfair Löschung von Myclimate Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9510 20017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gonzales–Rosewall rivalry [[User talk:Ravenswing|''' '' Ravenswing '' ''']] 17:16, 9 August 2017 (UTC) delete """As may be, but Mr. Peirce makes a few key errors. First off, the creator/maintainers of the List of tennis rivalries article have no authority or power to create Wikipedia notability guidelines. For another, it's settled policy that the criteria for inclusion in a list is much lower than the level of notability necessary to sustain a standalone article. For a third, the existence of similar articles (that likewise don't qualify for notability) |doesn't immunize this one from having to comply with notability guidelines. For a fourth, not only are sports rivalries not inherently notable, they're ''explicitly'' not notable, as per , which holds: """"Sports rivalries are not inherently notable. Articles on sports rivalries, such as Yankees–Red Sox rivalry, should satisfy the general notability guideline.""""But it's alright, because this article can easily be saved: just come up with reliable sources providing significant coverage ''to this rivalry,'' as the GNG enjoins. Barring that, I don't see it""" Deletion of Gonzales–Rosewall rivalry WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS||WP:NRIVALRY Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9511 9647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Schlund (2nd nomination) User:Ged 10:58, 25 February 2009 (UTC) delete Though it's close in my mind. There is a dearth of ''significant'' independent articles about him, beyond just referring to him doing a public event. It certainly feels like a vanity piece, and he does seem to be a |one event guy at this point Deletion of Dan Schlund (2nd nomination) WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
9512 16493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virtuous Pedophiles User:James 15:21, 23 August 2013 (UTC) comment """Little"""" notability is not the issue, many WP articles have only little notability. ''Enough'' notability is set by , which this topic meets (multiple RSs providing more than passing mention). Having other hits are not RS's does not take away from the number of sources that ''are'' RS's. NWEB pertains to the total number of locatable sources, not the proportion of hits that are RS's""" Deletion of Virtuous Pedophiles WP:NWEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
9513 14741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Philip King User:WikiDan61 13:56, 27 April 2012 (UTC) comment With http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Christopher_Philip_King&diff=489470168&oldid=489213121 recent changes added by the article's original author, the article has moved solidly into the realm of |blatant hoax Deletion of Christopher Philip King WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
9514 15668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of counterculture films (2nd nomination) User:Erik 16:58, 8 June 2007 (UTC) delete """because """"counterculture film"""" appears to be neologism, not landing a strong number of results with http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla%3Aen-US%3Aofficial&hs=vVh&q=%22counterculture+film%22&btnG=Search Google. The article for counterculture does not address counterculture in entertainment, but more societal topics, so the term seems even less appropriate than cult film. It would seem to be |synthesis to take a reference that explains how the film contests society and tie it into the term of """"counterculture film"""". List of cult films was similarly Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cult films|deleted for being highly interpretative, and I believe the arguments there also apply here even more strongly, especially with the term's lack of notability""" Deletion of List of counterculture films (2nd nomination) WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
9515 21906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hessle Rangers F.C. User:Mattythewhite 11:17, 5 June 2012 (UTC) delete Per nom; fails and consensus Deletion of Hessle Rangers F.C. WP:GNG||WP:FOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
9516 21779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/She's Real, Worse Than Queer User:Elaragirl 06:14, 14 February 2007 (UTC) delete The existance does not seem to meet the requirements for notability, more importantly, the article makes a vast number of complete unsourced statements with no sourcing per Deletion of She's Real, Worse Than Queer WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9517 7624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Greitens User:Samuel 03:10, 27 September 2015 (UTC) keep """The promotional aspect of this wanted to make me say delete. But his books """"Resilience: Hard-Won Wisdom for Living a Better Life"""" and """"The Heart and the Fist"""" both pass #1 and with two arguably books under his belt, I think he's going to qualify as notable himself. I think the best solution for minimizing cruft is going to be to merge all his books and his wife's article into one article""" Deletion of Eric Greitens WP:BKCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9518 12831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UP Yoddha User:NitinMlk 22:16, 1 February 2018 (UTC) comment A quick search shows that all relevant info about the team is covered in multiple independent reliable sources, e.g. http://indianexpress.com/article/sports/pro-kabaddi-league/2017/up-yoddha-team-profile-owners-fixtures-schedule-records-results-4771433/ 1, https://www.thequint.com/sports/pro-kabaddi-league-up-yoddha-team-profile 2, https://newsnexa.com/sports/up-yoddha-team-players-kabaddi/ 3, https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/topic/up-yoddha 4, https://www.instantkhabar.com/item/2017-07-25-pkl.html 5, https://hindi.firstpost.com/sports/others/pro-kabaddi-2017-the-new-franchise-uttar-pradesh-eye-on-maiden-title-43244.html 6, https://www.livehindustan.com/uttar-pradesh/lucknow/story-up-warrior-s-jersey-launch-in-lucknow-1202163.html 7, etc. In fact, thousands of other articles in English/Hindi national media can be found https://www.google.co.in/search?q=UP+Yoddha&source=lnms&tbm=nws&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjgxpSFwIXZAhVKP48KHaJLAtMQ_AUICygC&biw=1123&bih=631 here & https://www.google.co.in/search?q=%E0%A4%AF%E0%A5%82%E0%A4%AA%E0%A5%80+%E0%A4%AF%E0%A5%8B%E0%A4%A6%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%A7%E0%A4%BE&source=lnms&tbm=nws&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwje4JTbv4XZAhWLPY8KHfc_CNAQ_AUICigB&biw=1123&bih=631 here, and they cover every relevant detail of the team. Such coverage seems enough for . BTW, the parent article (Pro Kabaddi) is already quite lengthy. So the above article is a valid as well Deletion of UP Yoddha WP:GNG||WP:SPINOFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9519 12119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bleisure travel User:SeraphWiki 06:29, 25 April 2018 (UTC) merge """into Business travel — this article is a stub, its not like merging will overburden the main article. The term may have usage but NEOLOGISM, if you follow it links to — there's no need for a stand alone article about a recent slang word for """"sightseeing while on a business trip""" Deletion of Bleisure travel WP:NOTDICTIONARY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9520 17725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mitt Romney Cranbrook incident User:NJ 00:56, 19 May 2012 (UTC) merge into Mitt Romney presidential campaign, 2012. Wikipedia's policy for |notability of events says that an notable event will have a |lasting effect: ''Events are often considered to be notable if they act as a precedent or catalyst for something else. This may include effects on the views and behaviors of society and legislation. For example, the murder of Adam Walsh ultimately led to the Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act, among other notable subjects.'' This event has yet to have a lasting effect, and prohibits us from speculating about the future notability of a topic. The Mitt Romney presidential campaign, 2012 article already has discussions about the Etch-a-Sketch incident and other issues that effect this year's presidential campaign, but aren't really notable on their own. I see nothing wrong with merging this article into the Romney campaign article Deletion of Mitt Romney Cranbrook incident WP:EVENTS||WP:EFFECT||WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9521 21610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Cuomo's response to nursing homes during the COVID-19 pandemic User:KidAd 22:13, 19 February 2021 (UTC) delete Unnecessary . Merge any relevant information to Andrew Cuomo Deletion of Andrew Cuomo's response to nursing homes during the COVID-19 pandemic WP:CONTENTFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
9522 21122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss Universe Romania (2nd nomination) User:Gene93k 10:13, 22 December 2015 (UTC) delete No change in notability since the first deletion debate. Fails WP:ORG and . No reliable sources in article. None found in search Deletion of Miss Universe Romania (2nd nomination) WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9523 16310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SCTCC Cyclones Men's Basketball User:John 09:19, 5 June 2020 (UTC) merge per {{noping|Ejgreen77}} and |ATD Deletion of SCTCC Cyclones Men's Basketball WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9524 3544 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""Juiced ball"""" theory""" User:12 13:52, 4 January 2008 (UTC) comment """Seeing as the speedy tagger (DS2434) has opined as """"keep"""" and the above , would a passing third party please close this discussion as one big misunderstood """"keep"""". Regards""" """Deletion of """"Juiced ball"""" theory""" WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
9525 11500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashton Lunceford User:Edison 16:51, 30 September 2015 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Ashton Lunceford WP:BIO||WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
9526 355 [[Sonderrechte]] (erledigt) Benutzer:Wasabi NONE keep Unsinnige LA-Begründung, -tauglich, klar Löschung von Sonderrechte Wikipedia:ELW Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
9527 9978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard D. Robinson (engineer) User:Thsmi002 02:27, 12 May 2019 (UTC) keep per based on citation in Google Scholar as mentioned by Tataral above Deletion of Richard D. Robinson (engineer) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9528 16964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Archgoat (2nd nomination) User:RasputinAXP 18:46, 25 January 2006 (UTC) delete Sorry to jump on the dogpile, but this is just totally nn and fails Deletion of Archgoat (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9529 21921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rivian Automotive User:Student7 18:58, 19 March 2011 (UTC) delete 20 employees? Seems more like . Two refs are from blog. Only one from one article in local paper Deletion of Rivian Automotive WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
9530 4794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Casey Cott User:Insertcleverphrasehere 02:38, 25 March 2016 (UTC) delete WP:Too soon and doesn't meet Deletion of Casey Cott WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9531 14120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GTAGuides.com (2nd nomination) User:Kinu 08:02, 17 December 2006 (UTC) delete as failing . No indicating notability. Admins, is this a {{db-g4}}-able repost, or a substantially different article Deletion of GTAGuides.com (2nd nomination) WP:WEB||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9532 4192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sabrina Ho Chiu-yeng User:Dps04 05:43, 19 January 2021 (UTC) keep There is a decent amount of substantial coverage of the subject in English and Chinese-language sources. Examples include: https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/2189356/stanley-hos-daughter-sabrina-reveals-she-will-marry-harvard South China Morning Post, https://www.hk01.com/%E7%9F%A5%E6%80%A7%E5%A5%B3%E7%94%9F/512925/%E4%BD%95%E8%B6%85%E6%AC%A3-%E5%8D%83%E5%84%84%E5%A5%B3%E5%9C%98-%E5%90%84%E6%9C%89%E4%BE%86%E9%A0%AD-%E4%BD%95%E8%B6%85%E8%93%AE-%E4%BD%95%E8%B6%85%E7%9B%88%E9%96%A8%E5%AF%86%E5%9C%98%E6%9C%89%E7%BE%A9%E6%B0%A3%E9%9B%B6%E6%9E%B6%E5%AD%90 HK01, https://www.scmp.com/magazines/post-magazine/arts-music/article/2122384/unesco-partner-sabrina-ho-artfully-dabbles SCMP (again), https://www.straitstimes.com/lifestyle/entertainment/tycoon-stanley-hos-youngest-son-buys-hk500-million-home The Strait Times, to name a few. Enough coverage to pass and Deletion of Sabrina Ho Chiu-yeng WP:GNG||WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9533 14067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martín Almagro Basch User:Joe 13:25, 17 June 2017 (UTC) keep """ping|ImmaImmaTaco}} please read if you haven't already. We don't delete articles because they are orphans, or because they cite only a few sources (many excellent articles do). I presume that what you mean by """"I don't see enough historical significance for the person to sustain an article"""" is that the subject is not |notable. On the contrary, he appears to notable both as a figure in the Spanish Civil War https://web.archive.org/web/20070607041702/http://www.cefid.uab.es/files/comunicII-2a.pdfhttps://books.google.co.uk/books?id=0pnodpQ2yeYC&pg=PA422 and as an archaeologist https://digital.csic.es/handle/10261/31109http://s3.amazonaws.com/academia.edu.documents/31292988/almagro-gracia.pdf?AWSAccessKeyId=AKIAIWOWYYGZ2Y53UL3A&Expires=1497709248&Signature=4lHROJEIxsnxeE5bwcVptPM7DRw%3D&response-content-disposition=inline%3B%20filename%3DMARTIN_ALMAGRO_BASCH_I_EL_CLASSICISME_A.pdfhttps://books.google.co.uk/books/about/Archaeological_Encounters.html?id=sKQwBwAAQBAJ&printsec=frontcover&source=kp_read_button&redir_esc=y#v=snippet&q=almagro&f=falsehttps://doi.org/10.1017/S0003598X00045075. :es:Martín Almagro Basch looks well developed and good be a basis for expansion of our article. – """ Deletion of Martín Almagro Basch WP:BEFORE||WP:N Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9534 13635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dilyan Iliev User:Jimbo 12:23, 21 July 2008 (UTC) delete as per above and because he currently fails . Unless any reliable evidence can prove otherwise Deletion of Dilyan Iliev WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9535 12342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DBEdit 2 User:DavidWS 20:01, 27 November 2008 (UTC) delete ad-like article on |non notable software Deletion of DBEdit 2 WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9536 20836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flirtomatic User:71 22:56, 18 February 2007 (UTC) delete I appreciate the authors' contention that this article meets , but fail to see how we can write a |verifiable |neutral point of view article about a topic with no coverage in secondary sources. We can't, and are left with an article that is uncited promotional material and/or |original research by editors with an obvious |conflict of interest. I think in this case there is an inconsistency between the aforementioned principles of +++ and , and the first four principles should trump. Of course, if this has been the subject of nontrivial articles in reliable sources, then by all means keep, but I don't see those citations in the article Deletion of Flirtomatic WP:WEB||WP:V||WP:NPOV||WP:OR||WP:COI||WP:V||WP:NPOV||WP:OR||WP:COI||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
9537 1629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bianca Kmiec User:Power 18:13, 11 May 2017 (UTC) keep """As - """"Has a large fan base or a significant """"cult"""" following""" Deletion of Bianca Kmiec WP:NMODEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9538 20127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quantum Legacy (game) User:GRBerry 21:22, 1 August 2006 (UTC) delete No independent, |reliable sources used to provide any evidence of being |notable in accordance with the proposed standards at or the standards at Deletion of Quantum Legacy (game) WP:RS||WP:N||WP:SOFTWARE||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9539 10747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patricia Marx Ellsberg User:Julietdeltalima 01:00, 10 January 2017 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of Patricia Marx Ellsberg WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9540 15610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of passport offices in India User:Pharaoh 06:41, 8 January 2016 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of List of passport offices in India WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9541 10796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exiled Arts (webcomic) User:ColourBurst 03:25, 27 August 2006 (UTC) delete not only |nonnotable, but |unverifiable too Deletion of Exiled Arts (webcomic) WP:WEB||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
9542 3672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Cook (company) User:Walton_monarchist89 20:22, 6 March 2007 (UTC) merge to Thomas Cook AG. There was really no need to take this to AfD - just be |bold in merging unnecessary articles Deletion of Thomas Cook (company) WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
9543 21497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/North Shore Congregation Israel User:E 14:45, 17 March 2015 (UTC) keep Meets . noted architect Deletion of North Shore Congregation Israel WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9544 12498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vaibhav Choudhary [[User talk:usernamekiran|(talk)]] 16:05, 3 February 2020 (UTC) delete """I really want to say """"per Jimfbleak"""", but I cant for obvious reason. Even though :Delhi University Students' Union is a notable organisation, it is not a government body, office, or organisation. Getting elected as head of that organisation doesnt make the subject notable per |notability guidelines for politicians. Talking about wp:gng|general notability guidelines, the subject doesnt pass them either - as mentioned in the nomination, and in other comments, the subject lacks wp:sigcov|significant coverage. Talking about :Amar Ujala, I dont know about the print media, but the online version is like a tabloid. They cover, and spice up almost every topic. I havent read the source in discussion, but Amar Ujala online edition should not be considered for establishing a subject's notability. Other sources have been explained in the nomination. —usernamekiran""" Deletion of Vaibhav Choudhary WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9545 13289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chalk (short film) User:JJBers 17:16, 24 April 2017 (UTC) delete unnotable, basically at this point. &mdash Deletion of Chalk (short film) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
9546 19865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Index of breakfast-related articles User:Northamerica1000 19:29, 29 July 2018 (UTC) keep It is a ''discriminate'' index that does ''not'' qualify for deletion per . I agree with {{u|XOR'easter}}'s assessment above Deletion of Index of breakfast-related articles WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9547 18367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canadian Business College (2nd nomination) User:Piotrus 14:02, 14 October 2019 (UTC) delete If we remove sources, there is little to say outside a entry and maybe a short section on scandal. Schools should meet and I think such organizations like this are little better than degree mills, and we should not promote them. Now I have second thoughts on whether I should've withdrawn this nom a week weeks ago: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Panineeya Institute of Dental Sciences & Research Centre Deletion of Canadian Business College (2nd nomination) WP:PRIMARY||WP:YELLOWPAGES||WP:NORG Wikipedia:No original research 65
9548 18087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syrus Yarbrough User:Collectonian 01:46, 9 July 2009 (UTC) delete """fails and - single role on a """"reality"""" show = notable""" Deletion of Syrus Yarbrough WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9549 7053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of neopets species User:ImperatorExercitus 01:05, 20 March 2009 (UTC) merge I see no reason that a perfectly good article with nice solid facts be deleted. However, as per above, it has to be merged as a |decision in the above AfD. Cheers Deletion of List of neopets species WP:CONSENSUS Wikipedia:Consensus 78
9550 11462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marc Houalla User:Northamerica1000 11:22, 8 June 2012 (UTC) keep This person passes criteria #6 of , as the current director-general of the École nationale de l'aviation civile (French civil aviation university Deletion of Marc Houalla WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9551 5627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uthman Abdul Rahim Mohammed Uthman User:Metropolitan90 19:58, 27 December 2008 (UTC) delete per . Zero independent sources are provided within the article itself. The New York Times citation in the article is not to an article about the subject, just to a ''reprint'' on the NYT web site of ''primary sources'' relating to the administrative proceedings about his detention and combatant status review Deletion of Uthman Abdul Rahim Mohammed Uthman WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9552 22 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Sky Flag User:Quasihuman 16:54, 28 March 2011 (UTC) delete not notable, |Wikipedia is not for things made up one day Deletion of Big Sky Flag WP:ONEDAY Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
9553 9859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John G. DeMajo User:Netherzone 22:19, 10 July 2021 (UTC) delete I am not finding anything to substantiate the notability of this photographer; no exhibition history, no critical reviews, or articles or books on the subject of this article. Does not pass criteria for nor . The article seems to mainly have been developed by s with sourcing that is extremely weak Deletion of John G. DeMajo WP:GNG||WP:NARTIST||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Notability 77
9554 2454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Janne Grimholt User:Papaursa 17:30, 22 July 2018 (UTC) delete Sources consist of links to pages of individual statistics and two articles mentioning her moving from her team in Norway to one in Spain. Hard to say that constitutes sufficient coverage to meet . As for , the basic criteria for any sport is playing at the highest level. Since she has never competed at a world championship or Olympics, this standard is not met. In fact, she has never played for the Norwegian national adult women's team and success as a junior is usually not considered sufficient for notability Deletion of Janne Grimholt WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9555 15643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arent-Emil Hauge User:Nehme1499 23:52, 16 February 2021 (UTC) keep don't see why the page should be deleted. He has played three fully-pro games, easily passing Deletion of Arent-Emil Hauge :WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
9556 16122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mongolian passport User:Colonel 01:40, 27 January 2010 (UTC) keep I found no difficulty in finding a substantial source which discusses the topic of Mongolian passports at length and have added a brief citation to the article. There is no case to answer as the article is not in the slightest a dictionary entry - the nomination seems to confuse a stub and a dictionary entry - a common mistake, as explained at . All the other article should be kept too as this misunderstanding seems to be the common factor Deletion of Mongolian passport WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9557 9646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashish Bisht (2nd nomination) User:Rameshnta909 20:07, 10 December 2016 (UTC) delete According to and Deletion of Ashish Bisht (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9558 7220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delgado Street Bridge User:MarkH21 19:45, 12 May 2020 (UTC) keep Isn’t this listed in the National Register of Historic Places and therefore satisfies Deletion of Delgado Street Bridge WP:NBUILDING Wikipedia:Notability 77
9559 11261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xanadu (colour) (2nd nomination) User:LovesMacs 16:36, 12 September 2011 (UTC) delete """no sign of notability independent of the paint company. The article also makes |unsourced assertions about why the colour is called """"Xanadu""" Deletion of Xanadu (colour) (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9560 5045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter Ehrich User:Qworty 08:48, 5 February 2011 (UTC) comment The who is using Wikipedia to attack this living person also recently vandalized the AfD tag http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Walter_Ehrich&diff=prev&oldid=412119695. If I see any further policy violations on the part of the user I will bring the matter up at AN/I. This atrocious behavior is not what WP is supposed to be about Deletion of Walter Ehrich WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
9561 12275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grand Cities Mall User:Kirjtc2 13:58, 15 September 2006 (UTC) comment I'm not voting either way on this (I usually vote to keep malls, but I'm wishy-washy as to this one), but I think this AFD proves we need to have a discussion on shopping mall notability in general. There have been a lot of mall AFDs lately, many of which ''have'' been kept either on their own accord or by lack of consensus (see Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Carlingwood_Mall, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mall of Louisiana or Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Oakland_Mall). It is my opinion that applies more than here, as most articles don't necessarily pertain as to malls as a ''business'', but rather their status within a community as a landmark, economic power, etc. This places them within the same realm as parks or schools Deletion of Grand Cities Mall WP:LOCAL||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
9562 19285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emotions of Paradise User:Esradekan 21:07, 18 January 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Songs. If this gets deleted, the redirect can be speedied under Wikipedia:CSD#G8|CSD G8 Deletion of Emotions of Paradise WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9563 15889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beat Goes On (Madonna song) User:Wolfer68 NONE delete Fails usic#Songs. This song has no notability on its own yet. usic#C2 applies to musicians/artists not songs. - — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Beat Goes On (Madonna song) WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
9564 5470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IDF Tick Tock User:Lil 21:09, 20 July 2010 (UTC) keep precisely because it is |notable, it has received |extensive, worldwide coverage, and it is more than adequately |sourced. As for Deletion of IDF Tick Tock WP:N||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9565 6775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess Olufemi-Kayode User:Wiki 00:10, 25 February 2017 (UTC) keep This article makes a claim of notability, namely that she is a fellow in a society recognized on the English Wikipedia as notable. Furthermore, the references, do establish significant coverage. These perquisites being fulfilled means this article passes . Comparatively, a fellow in the Royal Society would be widely considered notable on Wikipedia and it would be bias to put undue weight on recognizing members of one society with established notability over another with likewise established notability. Wikipedia:Signatures Deletion of Princess Olufemi-Kayode WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9566 84 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Finansal sermaye kontrolleri uygulamaları Kullanıcı:utku tanrivereutku tanrıvere 07:46, 26 Kasım 2011 (UTC) delete Anerka'ya katılıyorum. Zaten kaynakçada belirtilmiş telifli kaynak. #G9|G9 ile HS işaretledim Finansal sermaye kontrolleri uygulamalarının silinmesi Vikipedi:HS Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9567 11656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MarketInvoice User:VMS 05:34, 5 March 2014 (UTC) keep Appears to be and the tone is fixable Deletion of MarketInvoice WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9568 19609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ricky Allman (3rd nomination) User:Tsistunagiska 16:12, 27 January 2021 (UTC) comment I personally don't see anything that would make this person notable according to the basic notability requirements but there are some mystical SNG's out there like that may have snuck in a little five word sentence somewhere giving this guy some special privilege making him notable here. I suggest to the nominator to look at those SNG's too. I concur with their BEFORE search that nothing I see would be considered definitively reliable and independent Deletion of Ricky Allman (3rd nomination) WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9569 18797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Strategic offensive User:Nsk92 09:54, 8 October 2008 (UTC) delete The topic probably deserves an article, but the text is way too and appears unsalvageable Deletion of Strategic offensive WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9570 8454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raxis User:Avraham 16:19, 20 February 2006 (UTC) delete WP:NG, |Vancarlimospacecraft, Unencyclopædic Deletion of Raxis WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
9571 315 [[Tonnerre (L9014)]] (LAE) Benutzer:Yen Zotto NONE keep """Das ist nicht praktikabel, denn in geht es stets um ''eigenständige'' enzyklopädische Relevanz, und das heißt, ein Artikel, dessen Gegenstand laut RK relevant ist, kann nicht einfach nach Gutdünken Einzelner in eine WL umgewandelt werden. {{""""|Die Formulierung in den RK sagt ja nicht, dass jedes relevante Schiff einen Einzelartikel haben muss}} verkennt insofern grundlegend die Funktionsweise der RK, die genau das regeln sollen. Der Kommandant der ''Tonnerre'' ist übrigens ein ''Capitaine de vaisseau'' (OF-5) https://www.defense.gouv.fr/marine/missions/mission-jeanne-d-arc-2013/capitaine-de-vaisseau-jean-francois-querat-commandant-le-bpc-tonnerre, damit ist das Schiff nach den RK eigenständig relevant. Der Artikel ist ein gültiger Stub. Also solange die RK nicht geändert werden""" Löschung von Tonnerre (L9014) Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9572 10602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danny Sheehan [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 19:28, 2 June 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and with no significant coverage.Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Danny Sheehan WP:NBOX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9573 16531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ferocia User:Rockphed 17:52, 24 September 2019 (UTC) delete No real sources means that this is entirely or and doesn't have anything worth preserving Deletion of Ferocia WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
9574 5469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melinda Anderson User:Lankiveil 01:05, 29 May 2011 (UTC) delete doesn't appear to meet - only published work is a redlinked book that she collaborated with another on Deletion of Melinda Anderson WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9575 20491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashli Babbitt User:Tsistunagiska 14:57, 7 January 2021 (UTC) keep Do we really want to consult the notability clause here on Wikipedia to decide this? Because according to she deserves an article. She receives significant coverage from reliable and independent sources. I know what says, not discounting that, but we literally have thousands of articles on individuals who are basically known for one thing. We jump at the chance to write an article on a new footballer who played their first match for a professional club. What happens if that player meets tragedy and no longer plays after one match? At some point the article is brought up for AfD and likely deleted. How is this any different? A redirect is sensible but I'd lean towards leaving this alone and coming back six months from now to see what has happened Deletion of Ashli Babbitt WP:N||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
9576 17261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Wrexham county borough User:Imzadi1979 00:59, 25 March 2013 (UTC) delete fails and . Lists like these should be transwikied to Wikivoyage rather than left on Wikipedia Deletion of List of bus routes in Wrexham county borough WP:GNG||WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9577 18107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iqua User:HighKing 14:50, 20 March 2018 (UTC) delete References all fail and/or . Topic fails GNG and Deletion of Iqua WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9578 14542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Llanview User:Tokyogirl79 03:33, 16 March 2012 (UTC) comment I just wanted to chime in and say that it doesn't matter how long a series runs or how many episodes were in a series. If we were to look at episodes as sources, they'd be considered primary sources. Why? Because they were made by the people who created the series and anything that's released by people involved with the show are considered to be primary. They can't show notability for anything, although you can use them to back something up. (Although even then you're only supposed to use primary sources if you have an independent and reliable source to back it up!) In order to show notability you need to have multiple '''independent and reliable''' sources to show that this town has notability apart from the show. Make sure that you realize that notability is not inherited by the show taking place in this fictional town (). If you want to keep the article then you need to come up with sources that ''aren't'' from the show or its producers. This would be something like magazine articles, books, or news spots that focused on the town. Again, it doesn't always matter how long a show has run. It matters more if you can show those independent and reliable sources to show that this town is notable. If it's run for 40 years then it should be a little easier to find said sources since there should be at least 3-4 sources to show this. If you do want this article to be kept, go find those sources rather than saying that everything should be notable because the show itself is notable. I don't mean to be harsh, but you'll get further with an argument backed up with reliable sources than arguments that are based around the idea of inherited notability and Deletion of Llanview WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9579 7789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NetSupport Manager User:SkierRMH 02:57, 20 November 2006 (UTC) delete simple advert Deletion of NetSupport Manager WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
9580 10226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stanley G. Ellis User:Rollidan 01:24, 25 July 2019 (UTC) delete I agree with most of the rationale discussed above. One clarification: most/all of the sourcing is not independent of the subject, (and since no other sources exist, this fails ) but I disagree with the assertion that they are primary sources. The authors of, for example, the church news, would not be the subject of the article and therefore this would be a secondary source. However, since it is not an independent source, that is where it falls short Deletion of Stanley G. Ellis WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9581 10947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bradley G User:Litholdor 22:43, 15 November 2018 (UTC) delete I could not find any significant coverage, no sources used throughout the article, and it certainly fails and . Definitely a delete vote Deletion of Bradley G WP:DJ||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9582 17038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Layte User:David 15:38, 31 August 2019 (UTC) keep """Many of his highly-cited papers in Google Scholar are multi-author, but if one looks only at the first-author or single-author ones they still have citation counts 153 (""""The association between income inequality and mental health""""), 133, 108, 104, 103, etc. That's enough to convince me of a pass of #C1. And the full professorship and department chair at TCD, while not enough for notability themselves, are also suggestive""" Deletion of Richard Layte WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9583 13990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Museum of Photography of Skopelos User:Edison 20:32, 10 January 2009 (UTC) delete """Being mentioned in a book or directory falls short of showing |notability , in that it is not """"substantial coverage in multiple reliable and independent sources."""" Someone created robotically stubs for every Greek """"museum"""" in some online directory. Some are notable, others are just a one room curio shop, or someone's small private collection. Each should have independent references (more than their own website) with more than directory type information such as location and hours. The directory apparently set a very low standard for what it called a """"museum""" Deletion of Museum of Photography of Skopelos WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9584 9753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dreamland Skate Center User:Coolabahapple 02:54, 28 August 2019 (UTC) delete as , and the incident listed is, well, |incidental Deletion of Dreamland Skate Center WP:NOTPROMOTION||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9585 12407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death Threat (band) User:Tarheel95 15:58, 30 March 2011 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of Death Threat (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9586 21502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Outreach.io User:K 02:21, 16 November 2017 (UTC) delete as corporate spam on a nn business. Fails / Deletion of Outreach.io WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
9587 13221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anarcho-stalinism User:Bobby1011 13:23, 22 February 2006 (UTC) comment That my friend is an interpretation and as such falls under |Original Research. Back it up with a reputable source Deletion of Anarcho-stalinism WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9588 21421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lescinel Jean-Francois User:Latouffedisco 09:59, 23 July 2008 (UTC) keep Has played in a fully professional league as Ligue 2 is a fully professional league. Therefore passes Deletion of Lescinel Jean-Francois WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9589 18249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antonio Raul Corbo User:Abishe 01:53, 6 February 2020 (UTC) delete per nom, fails and it is a type of . He has done only few roles so far and his career will rise in near future Deletion of Antonio Raul Corbo WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
9590 16049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rain (cryptocurrency) User:HocusPocus00 15:06, 2 February 2021 (UTC) delete I'm not seeing a lot of news coverage even amongst crypto news sites, let alone what we would consider . It seems like this topic is just not ripe yet for an article and may need to be revisited if additional coverage comes along Deletion of Rain (cryptocurrency) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9591 3770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Niger seed oil User:Djembayz 00:14, 22 August 2015 (UTC) keep Has three academic articles, so passes as notable article. Would be useful to merge and redirect, however, and have all the information on the seeds in one place Deletion of Niger seed oil WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9592 18358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/InVNT User:Claritas 17:55, 18 June 2010 (UTC) delete fails . , looks like Wikipedia:Vanispamcruftisement|vanispamcruftisement to me Deletion of InVNT WP:GNG||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9593 1195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dini Daniel [[User talk:Lourdes|Lourdes]]''' 09:14, 9 December 2017 (UTC) delete Perhaps some regional sources may exist that may convince me to change my !vote. My current search shows no reliable sources that can help push the subject over OR Deletion of Dini Daniel WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9594 19232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/StuRents User:Cobaltbluetony 13:49, 11 May 2009 (UTC) comment Article was tagged for issues (deleted without resolution) and |conflict of interest, as the creator and one subsequent major contributor accounts share the names of the founders of the service. - Deletion of StuRents WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
9595 16088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bhutan at the 2013 Asian Youth Games User:Malcolmxl5 11:55, 3 June 2016 (UTC) merge to the main games article. This could have been done |boldly without bringing this and others here Deletion of Bhutan at the 2013 Asian Youth Games WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
9596 5208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Smell User:TydeNet 04:34, 10 April 2006 (UTC) delete per nomination. See ; this is highly POV and reads like an advertisement. Has no place in an encyclopedia, and if it does, requires desperate re-write Deletion of The Smell WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9597 13 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Fethullah Gülen'in düşünce yapısı """Kullanıcı:sputnik1907sputnik""" 21:49, 6 Nisan 2016 (UTC) comment Yazılanların KD olmadığı görüşlerine şöyle bir soru sormak istedim. Acaba fethullah gülenin görüşleri midir kayda değer olmayan, yok sa kendisi hakkında kayda değer olan nedir. {{imzasız|88.255.159.106}} ( gereği yorum olarak değiştirildi Fethullah Gülen'in düşünce yapısının silinmesi Vikipedi:OY Wikipedia:Administrators 89
9598 13278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of non-pornographic films featuring nudity User:Mrschimpf 21:52, 26 March 2008 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not Mr. Skin. Probably a good list, but not for this venue Deletion of List of non-pornographic films featuring nudity WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9599 9535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William P. Hoar User:Location 04:06, 3 January 2015 (UTC) delete Fails . I did find a trivial mention in an article by Political Research Associates (i.e. http://www.publiceye.org/conspire/root_con.html). I have no objections to redirecting to John Birch Society Deletion of William P. Hoar WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9600 14106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hardcore trance User:Jayron32 05:05, 3 December 2006 (UTC) delete a http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Hardcore+trance%22&btnG=Google+Search google search turns up very few uses of this term as a distinct ''genre'' of music, the way that the article claims. There appears to MAYBE be a band with this name, but that band is of questionable notability, with only self-promoted sales of its only CD. As the article is written, it is |unverifiable, and thus |non notable, and thus deletable. There is not evidence that this genre of music actually is noted in the music press Deletion of Hardcore trance WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9601 4427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sephardic Pizmonim Project (3rd nomination) User:Leuko 20:53, 8 August 2007 (UTC) delete Not enough to satisfy the primary criterion of to write a , POV article Deletion of Sephardic Pizmonim Project (3rd nomination) WP:RS||WP:N||WP:V||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9602 5953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Aaker User:EricEnfermero 15:26, 9 May 2015 (UTC) keep We may be able to cut down on some promotional tone, but this has a lot of sourced prose, so it isn't too much like a resume and wouldn't require a rewrite. Some bulleted sections are allowed, particularly in standard WP biography sections like Publications or Bibliography (which might just be better renamed ''Further reading''). The subject is definitely notable per and (at least because of holding a named chair at a major university, possibly other criteria Deletion of Jennifer Aaker WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9603 11291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willie Levesque User:Dolovis 21:43, 12 August 2013 (UTC) keep Former pro hockey player has played more than 100 games in the AHL and ECHL and therefore specifically passes criteria #3 of |NHOCKEY Deletion of Willie Levesque WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
9604 83 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Illinois earthquake (3rd nomination) User:E 14:11, 2 October 2017 (UTC) merge with selective merge to Sandwich Fault Zone (consensus on 2nd AfD), partly as per - this this minor trembler was quite widely covered at the time. Plus, possibly because it does get pageviews https://tools.wmflabs.org/pageviews/?project=en.wikipedia.org&platform=all-access&agent=user&range=all-time&pages=2010_Illinois_earthquake, showing that it is a useful search term Deletion of 2010 Illinois earthquake (3rd nomination) WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
9605 12258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/African Heritage Studies Association User:Aditya 06:16, 27 June 2009 (UTC) delete Coverage is http://www.google.co.in/search?q=%22African+Heritage+Studies+Association%22&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a trivial at best which fails Deletion of African Heritage Studies Association WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9606 10029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Netism User:Shoessss 22:18, 5 January 2009 (UTC) merge in the policy of |AGF, in that I could not find any references and must believe the ones listed in the piece Deletion of Netism WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
9607 651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ENSCO Inc. User:Thryduulf 07:58, 16 November 2006 (UTC) delete """this looks like an """"about our company"""" type page. I can't see any evidence in the article that it meets """ Deletion of ENSCO Inc. WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9608 7749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ole miss riots of 2012 User:Phil 20:02, 10 November 2012 (UTC) delete """per basic common sense. What do we have here? A few students got drunk and got a bit unruly, and some people called it a """"riot"""" on a web forum. That sort of thing happens every day, and hardly merits the status of news, let alone meeting encyclopic standards which #NEWS|go beyond mere news. If for any bizarre reason this is kept then it needs to be renamed: """"Ole miss"""" is pure gobbledygook to many, if not most, of our readers""" Deletion of Ole miss riots of 2012 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9609 5836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sami Berik User:LlamaAl 17:41, 27 April 2013 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Sami Berik WP:GNG||WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
9610 5747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daitetsu Minase User:JBsupreme 18:06, 24 November 2008 (UTC) delete and per nom this is getting ridiculous Deletion of Daitetsu Minase WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
9611 5892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prime Number Distribution Series User:Smmurphy 15:56, 14 August 2017 (UTC) delete without more independent coverage, this fails (and NOR and ). I'm not sure if what the article says is true, and I agree with XOR'easter that FRINGE concerns may apply as well Deletion of Prime Number Distribution Series WP:V||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9612 18483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shiyas Kareem User:GSS 06:50, 6 November 2018 (UTC) delete per nom and fails NACTOR and GNG, I redirected this page to Bigg Boss Malayalam per -R as I found it non-notable by WP standard but it was removed by the creator so I'm afraid this will continue Deletion of Shiyas Kareem WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9613 11827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walther-Peer Fellgiebel User:Peacemaker67 04:12, 27 August 2020 (UTC) keep see my later comment) While he clearly doesn't meet criteria #1–7 of , I think we need to consider that his book was, for quite a period of time, considered a reference on Knight's Cross recipients, and he might meet criteria #8 on that basis Deletion of Walther-Peer Fellgiebel WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
9614 11775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/September 23rd Demonstration User:Leroyencyclopediabrown 23:24, 9 September 2006 (UTC) delete per and crystal ball Deletion of September 23rd Demonstration WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9615 11350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qantas Flight 692 User:Nick 10:37, 29 July 2008 (UTC) delete per nom and #NEWS. Given that this is a very minor incident it shouldn't be merged with Qantas - it's hardly rare for commercial airliners to turn back in flight due to a fault Deletion of Qantas Flight 692 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9616 413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J.C. Warren User:Cabayi 15:42, 5 February 2019 (UTC) delete self-promotion of a self-published author. Looks like |A7/|G11 material to me Deletion of J.C. Warren WP:A7||WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9617 18172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/House hugger User:Dhartung 19:16, 14 August 2008 (UTC) delete per , . We aren't urbandictionary Deletion of House hugger WP:NFT||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
9618 6820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harold W. Moll NONE NONE delete This soldier has some excellence work but unfortunately no independent source found, and does't have received much military awards, Template:Highest gallantry awards|highest award for valour etc. Fails as per Deletion of Harold W. Moll WP:MILPEOPLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9619 21599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Waiting for Normal User:Malinaccier 19:36, 6 September 2017 (UTC) keep """The book has received a number of awards according to the https://www.amazon.com/Waiting-Normal-Leslie-Connor/dp/0060890908 Amazon page: """"School Library Journal Best Book * ALA Notable Children’s Book * New York Public Library’s “One Hundred Titles for Reading and Sharing” * Chicago Public Library Best of the Best * Cooperative Children’s Book Center Choice * Connecticut Book Award Winner * American Library Association Schneider Family Book Award Winner"""". I think the ALA awards ensure that this meets our |notability guidelines for books""" Deletion of Waiting for Normal WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9620 2592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/V N Maurya User:Voceditenore 15:55, 30 April 2012 (UTC) delete I can find no evidence of passing either |general notability guidelines or Wikipedia:Notability (academics). Note that the url for Shekhawati Engineering Institute above is for the old version of their site. Unfortunately, http://sec.secd.ac.in/ the new version doesn't list any faculty. He does appear to be on World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology Scientific Committee and Editorial Review Board on Engineering and Physical Sciences http://www.waset.org/EngineeringandPhysicalSciences.php?page=110. But memberships in such editorial review boards are standard for working academics, and this one appears to be particularly non-selective, with editorial board membership open to anyone with a PhD Deletion of V N Maurya WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9621 6533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Playboy Playmates of 1961 User:Arxiloxos 20:12, 26 April 2011 (UTC) comment There may be a technical problem with this nomination, because it is not showing up at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2011 April 26 (or at /T Deletion of List of Playboy Playmates of 1961 WP:AFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9622 16816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emily Critchley User:Stuartyeates 02:46, 15 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Emily Critchley WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9623 9390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dean Willard (2nd nomination) User:Silver 19:15, 8 April 2010 (UTC) keep The discussion above about the reliability of the sources seems kind of silly to me. Regardless about the local newspapers, the Seattle Times is enough to establish notability by itself and the coverage of the article is about the guy, so it's not trivial. This clearly meets #3 of Deletion of Dean Willard (2nd nomination) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9624 1337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hirushi Jayasena User:John 16:22, 9 November 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Hirushi Jayasena WP:SINGER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9625 15899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swamp diggers User:The 16:42, 21 October 2005 (UTC) delete Concur - no sign it meets Deletion of Swamp diggers WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9626 2632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prime Plaza Hotels and Resorts User:HighKing 13:07, 17 September 2018 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a Yellow Pages nor a platform for promotion. None of the references meet the criteria for establishing notability as they all appear to rely or are based on company press releases or quotations/interviews with connected companies or people. References fail . Topic fails GNG and Deletion of Prime Plaza Hotels and Resorts WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9627 13834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Weaver (American football) User:Paulmcdonald 20:38, 27 November 2013 (UTC) delete no indication that he passes either. If anyone can find something, let us know Deletion of Jason Weaver (American football) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9628 18988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcus Stanley (pianist) User:Vicke1988 00:36, 23 June 2015 (UTC) keep Establishes notability and . Subject is linked to reliable source on CNN and Fox News Deletion of Marcus Stanley (pianist) WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9629 10403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Next constitution of Zimbabwe User:Bearian 19:32, 25 October 2010 (UTC) delete and empty per above, , and Deletion of Next constitution of Zimbabwe WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9630 21850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barvas Project Management Tool User:Dialectric 14:38, 29 July 2016 (UTC) delete Software article of unclear notability, lacking independent references. A search turned up no significant coverage Deletion of Barvas Project Management Tool WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9631 13028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irish bowline User:Stormtracker94 20:24, 2 October 2007 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of Irish bowline WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9632 340 [[Diskriminierung (Unterscheidung)]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Zaphiro NONE delete merkwürdige Lemmapolitik, es gibt doch keine Haupt-oder Nebenbedeutungen, sondern falls unterschiedliche Bedeutungshoheiten wie etwa Diskriminierung (Wirtschaft), Diskriminierung (Chromatographie) oder Diskriminierung (Psychologie) and so on, also Lemmata nach Wissenschaftsgebieten einteilen, falls artikelfähig (trifft nur teilweise zu). PS , Lemma ansich ist wohl alleine schon Löschung von Diskriminierung (Unterscheidung) Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
9633 3193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arungundram User:Curbon7 06:15, 14 August 2021 (UTC) keep Per , I believe this is a legally recognized village: https://censusindia.gov.in/2011census/dchb/DCHB_A/33/3304_PART_A_DCHB_VELLORE.pdf per the 2011 Indian census for the Vellore district, under the name Arunkundram. Took me a while to find since the district this was in was split in 2019 Deletion of Arungundram WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9634 15816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Three.js (2nd nomination) User:Mark 20:40, 6 April 2014 (UTC) keep """There are books devoted to the topic, such as http://books.google.com/books?id=6TVeAQAAQBAJ&printsec=frontcover&dq=Three.js&hl=en&sa=X&ei=i7ZBU-j-BaHNsQTgqoKgDg&ved=0CDUQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=Three.js&f=false Learning Three.js: The JavaScript 3D Library for WebGL and http://books.google.com/books?id=HY6kAQAAQBAJ&pg=PT179&dq=Three.js&hl=en&sa=X&ei=i7ZBU-j-BaHNsQTgqoKgDg&ved=0CDsQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=Three.js&f=false Game Development with Three.js and books which use the lib extensively throughout the text, such as http://books.google.com/books?id=uYnyaBClb3IC&pg=PA19&dq=Three.js&hl=en&sa=X&ei=i7ZBU-j-BaHNsQTgqoKgDg&ved=0CEEQ6AEwAw#v=onepage&q=Three.js&f=false WebGL: Up and Running. The first two books are published by Packt and the third is published by O'Reilly, both reputable publishers. The article lists other books in the Bibliography, but I have not checked those. There are enough multiple in-depth RS to pass notability. The article itself is somewhat promotional, for instance, the """"Selected Uses and Works"""" section is basically an ad for how widely it is used and could be cut back to just notable entries (those with WP articles themselves) and a couple of examples. But removing promotional content is a surmountable problem, per, ; there is no need to blow it up per . A notable topic and surmountable problems suggests keeping the article""" Deletion of Three.js (2nd nomination) WP:SURMOUNTABLE||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9635 27 [[Kramski Putter]] (erl. gelöscht) Benutzer:Beek100 18:55, 10. Apr. 2013 (CEST) delete Typisches Beispiel, wie man es als Werbetreibender nicht machen sollte. Dem Ersteller empfehle ich die Lektüre von . Diskutabel wäre allenfalls eine Relevanz der Muttergesellschaft, wo bei zwei Merkmalen immerhin fast 2/3 der automatisch relevant machenden Kriterien erfüllt sind (falls die Angaben stimmen) und man dann über die Produkte reden könnte. Aber das ist so indiskutabel Löschung von Kramski Putter Wikipedia:IK Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
9636 7104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cody Bollinger (2nd nomination) User:Ad 07:13, 21 January 2014 (UTC) delete Subject fails and Deletion of Cody Bollinger (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
9637 18804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Le Zombie NONE NONE keep per points 1, 3, and 4. It's on the low end of ''significant coverage'' unless I missed something Deletion of Le Zombie WP:CREATIVE||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9638 16366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How Students Learn User:Coolabahapple 12:55, 30 March 2020 (UTC) keep meets , as having been reviewed by multiple independent sources Deletion of How Students Learn WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9639 21909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Norman Grigg User:John 21:42, 20 June 2008 (UTC) keep """the 15-minute search test is well-populated, but my evidence was lost in cyberspace and I don't wish to take another 15 minutes recreating it. However, Ed will be happy to know a thorough Google search reveals plenty to build on and """"clearly fails"""" is inapposite (nom has also submitted AFD for the magazine instead of properly redirecting it). Author of 6 books; senior editor at John Birch Society; apparently now webmaster of Robert W. Welch Foundation (not related to Robert A. Welch Foundation); significantly covered twice by Los Angeles Times, also by Denver Post and other papers (for work towards impeaching Clinton); writes frequently for LewRockwell.com, plus American Conservative and a journal of studies in reformed theology; his work was cited in another reliable source; and I believe I saw the musical career in a reliable source too. Sufficiently significant collective body of work per . The problem is unencyclopedicity, not notability. ''Please keep in mind that if article is deleted rather than cut back, I will be compelled to recreate it from scratch, which I have successfully done with G. Edward Griffin: this option is, however, much easier when notability is already agreed on rather than when the fight is ongoing.'' Thanks""" Deletion of William Norman Grigg WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9640 6131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Frances Sey User:Maile66 22:36, 5 May 2018 (UTC) keep """for all that is named above, per """"The person has received a well-known and significant award or honor ... """" such as having a building (a """"hall"""") named after her""" Deletion of Elizabeth Frances Sey WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9641 14874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Janice Melnychuk User:Eddie 23:13, 16 August 2010 (UTC) delete ref. link is 404'd. Article fails Deletion of Janice Melnychuk WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9642 11210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baatein Ye Kabhi Na (2nd nomination) User:Atlantic306 21:22, 8 July 2017 (UTC) keep as the critical reception of the article shows reviews by reliable sources Zee TV, India.com and there is also coverage by Indian Express so is passed Deletion of Baatein Ye Kabhi Na (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9643 20247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sales NG User:Bmusician 00:13, 4 June 2012 (UTC) delete I http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Sales_NG&diff=495591261&oldid=495590266 prodded the article and all the article creator did after removing the PROD was to make the article read like an advertisement. Utterly non-notable software, falis and , no coverage in |reliable third-party sources Deletion of Sales NG WP:GNG||WP:NSOFT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9644 18706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Lipsky User:Fenix 09:30, 21 November 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Matthew Lipsky WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9645 4084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Van Stevens User:Cullen328 07:07, 20 November 2017 (UTC) delete She served as mayor of a tiny town for a little over two years and all of the references are to the routine small town coverage of her was published in that tiny town's newspaper. All local papers write about their current mayors, and such a coverage is run of the mill. When she resigned, she disappeared from the historical record. There is no known coverage in regional newspapers, in magazines or in history books. If she is notable, then every mayor ever elected is notable and there is no consensus for that in or in the outcomes of deletion debates. This is taking inclusionism to an extreme that I cannot personally accept Deletion of Mary Van Stevens WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9646 5779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meish Goldish User:Jayden54 10:02, 8 December 2006 (UTC) keep As SkierRMH said, he has written dozens of books, and I'm not sure if that means he's notable per the guidelines of , but for now I'm going to go with keeping the article, although a rewrite is certainly necessary Deletion of Meish Goldish WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9647 810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maurice Novoa User:Papaursa 20:49, 23 January 2021 (UTC) delete He doesn't meet the notability criteria for actors or martial artists and I don't believe the coverage is sufficient to meet Deletion of Maurice Novoa WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9648 6470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Placebo (at funeral) User:TimothyBlue 15:02, 20 January 2021 (UTC) delete good faith undersourced essay. This is a notable topic, it doesn't entirely fit in either suggested merge targets. Per ''Sometimes, the damage is fixable, but the effort in doing so dwarfs the effort involved in merely starting over''. This article deserves a do over. Article history would be broken and of dubious value. // Deletion of Placebo (at funeral) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
9649 3526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rheneas User:Reyk 14:11, 26 August 2020 (UTC) merge Recent AfDs of these TtTE characters have pretty much all determined that they're crufty and not individually notable, and this is no exception. It's probably safe to just |boldly redirect them going forward Deletion of Rheneas WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
9650 20516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gohulan User:Docether 19:23, 20 June 2006 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not for things made up in a (carpark) one day, including nonnotable neologisms like this one Deletion of Gohulan WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
9651 3219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manimala Girls High School User:Mkdw 09:09, 5 January 2013 (UTC) keep Nomination has failed to show how this case-by-case look at this school is any different than Deletion of Manimala Girls High School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9652 9519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Huffines Middle School User:Wizardman 04:19, 12 April 2007 (UTC) delete At first glance it looked like a notable article, but upon further inspection has a couple unsourced quotes and basically violates and . If the unsourced stuff (which isn't notable to begin with) is cut out almost nothing remains, better to just delete this one Deletion of Huffines Middle School WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9653 3733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Falcon global group holding User:Howicus 14:24, 19 June 2015 (UTC) delete I found no evidence of coverage in |reliable, independent sources. Does not meet |the notability guideline for corporations or |the general guideline. The state of other articles, though unfortunate, is not relevant here Deletion of Falcon global group holding WP:IRS||WP:CORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9654 9913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pizza delivery in popular culture (second nomination) User:Rossami 20:40, 18 June 2008 (UTC) delete It's a random list of trivia about a common occurrence. It is content which is not appropriate for the encyclopedia. I am also persuaded by the |original synthesis arguments raised above. The fact that individual instances can be sourced does not absolve all concerns. The compilation ''as a list'' must also be independent of Wikipedia Deletion of Pizza delivery in popular culture (second nomination) WP:SYN||WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9655 17697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Troll (singer) User:Ohnoitsjamie 05:14, 23 August 2014 (UTC) delete Doesn't come close to meeting notability for a singer Deletion of Troll (singer) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9656 324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Journal of Foreign Relations (2nd nomination) [[User talk:Jéské Couriano|V]] [[Special:Contributions/Jéské Couriano|S]] [[User: Jéské Couriano|M]] 04:01, 28 October 2011 (UTC) delete for want of sources to establish otability|notability. —''Jeremy'' v^_^v Components Deletion of Journal of Foreign Relations (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9657 17975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Snow Bowl (Green Bay) User:RC 21:36, 2 April 2008 (UTC) keep Hmm. I think it passes , seems fine to me Deletion of Snow Bowl (Green Bay) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9658 4602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kara Guggenmos User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable vanity biography Deletion of Kara Guggenmos WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9659 11806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theodore N. Kaufman User:DBaba 16:28, 17 April 2011 (UTC) delete per with a redirect to Germany Must Perish!. I don't see that, even if he really did address Congress, that would make him notable beyond the single phenomenon Deletion of Theodore N. Kaufman WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
9660 7536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nadia Jin User:OlYeller21 20:41, 29 September 2011 (UTC) delete Looking past the blatant advertorial content, the subject does not satisfy any inclusion guidelines. Fails with http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Nadia+Jin%22&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a#q=%22Nadia+Jin%22&oe=utf-8&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a&um=1&ie=UTF-8&hl=en&tbo=u&tbm=nws&source=og&sa=N&tab=wn&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.&fp=34a7939241002c5e&biw=1228&bih=675 no Google News search results and and no results from a http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Nadia+Jin%22&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a#q=%22Nadia+Jin%22&hl=en&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&tbm=nws&source=lnt&tbs=ar:1&sa=X&ei=yNaETrPwOsy2tgeYu8w-&ved=0CA4QpwUoBQ&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.&fp=34a7939241002c5e&biw=1228&bih=675 Google News Archive search. The only other applicable inclusion guideline I see is which is also not satisfied. Victoria Beckham wearing your print in a dress not made by you, does not make a person notable. It probably doesn't even make the company that made the dress notable Deletion of Nadia Jin WP:GNG||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9661 17151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Rust Punk Tribe User:Steffan 20:46, 14 July 2016 (UTC) keep I would consider this expansion upon Sin Quirin related information, and justify a stand alone article due to the joint nature of the project with multiple notable people. I would list Regen Magazine and other industry sources as independent sources qualifying Deletion of The Rust Punk Tribe WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9662 843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FAME FC User:Fenix 13:02, 12 June 2017 (UTC) delete fails , no indication the club has played in a national competition, no indication of any other achievements garnering sufficient significant, independent coverage to satisfy GNG Deletion of FAME FC WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9663 14683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World peace festival berlin 2010 User:Iowateen 08:41, 10 July 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of World peace festival berlin 2010 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9664 21858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Thieves User:Schuym1 22:51, 27 October 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of The Thieves WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9665 15929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Last Days of April (film) User:Joe 00:06, 1 June 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |film Deletion of The Last Days of April (film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9666 10074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vincent Ferrari (2nd nomination) User:Joe 19:29, 2 October 2009 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Vincent Ferrari (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
9667 6899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Space Elevator Consortium User:RockMagnetist 16:23, 31 August 2015 (UTC) merge with space elevator. None of the sources meet the |depth of coverage criterion for . For example, several sources simply include the Consortium as part of a list. Putting together the four sources mentioned by {{mention|Everymorning|p=}}, all we can learn about the Consortium is that it has an annual meeting and its president is Peter Swain. The articles mainly cover the subject of space elevators, so why not merge Deletion of International Space Elevator Consortium WP:ORGDEPTH||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9668 4863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Huma Abedin (2nd nomination) User:Silver 22:49, 7 April 2010 (UTC) comment I have tagged this article for |rescue Deletion of Huma Abedin (2nd nomination) WP:ARS Wikipedia:Article Rescue Squadron 98
9669 11446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MemoQ User:Ihcoyc 20:34, 7 August 2011 (UTC) delete Also entirely unreferenced |advertising: ''a translation environment tool created by Kilgray translation technologies which contains a number of features to enhance the translation process for both translators and project managers Deletion of MemoQ WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
9670 1657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Demo Collection 1992 - 1993 User:Darth 22:02, 2 August 2008 (UTC) delete per #Albums and Deletion of Demo Collection 1992 - 1993 WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9671 15708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Future Loss User:Whpq 13:40, 12 September 2011 (UTC) delete The article reads like a MySpace page, and Wikiedpia is |not a web host. There is no coverage about this band in reliable sources. They've only managed to put out one album for which I can't find any critical reviews Deletion of A Future Loss WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9672 7636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Eliza Williams User:Fiskje88 19:58, 15 November 2015 (UTC) keep Passes as she has received media coverage during more than one occasion. On top of that, she is also referred to outside the realm of news coverage, as evidenced by for instance https://books.google.nl/books?id=DJdx9Qg0Tz0C&pg=PA63&lpg=PA63&dq=anna+eliza+williams+1873&source=bl&ots=EJJFyEz1O9&sig=9ZGVh-CYOOzuQlGP9dlQNm8zABs&hl=nl&sa=X&ved=0CE8Q6AEwBzgKahUKEwiqrZOVmpPJAhWCOBoKHdxvCnI#v=onepage&q=anna%20eliza%20williams%201873&f=false, trying to establish what it is that made her grow to such an old age Deletion of Anna Eliza Williams WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9673 1507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K-Reen User:Missvain 23:27, 27 January 2020 (UTC) keep While I think it was ok to delete the album by her a few AfDs above, K-Reen is a superstar in French Guiana. She's won Lindor Awards, which is the Grammy's of French Guiana. I don't expect anyone to know that _ since I'm sure we don't have many editors from French Guiana, but, she is indeed notable and passes . Check out her https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/K-Reen French Wikipedia article for sources Deletion of K-Reen WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9674 17726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bridgette B (2nd nomination) User:Cavarrone 10:47, 7 April 2012 (UTC) comment """Just a couple of considerations, 1) WP does not require a full biography for article's subjects. Obviously articles like that must be improved, such as most the wiki's articles (ie see tons of articles about soccer players): for this reason we have rankings like ''Stub'', ''Start'', etc. WP is a work-in-progress website, and I don't know any article that could be considered """"finished"""" or not in need of improvements 2) IAFD could not be considered an user-submitted website... the opportunity of reporting by e-mail corrections or additions (that, as indicated, would be subsequently verified by IAFD) is not the same than generate by himself the content of a website; ie the same service is offered by the websites of mainstream newspapers such as ''La Repubblica'' or ''La Stampa'' 3) about the actor's real names see . Furthermore, we have articles about people we do not only do not know the real and/or complete names but of whom was even questioned their very existence""" Deletion of Bridgette B (2nd nomination) WP:BLPPRIVACY Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
9675 14392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simdesk User:Wrs1864 01:13, 15 October 2006 (UTC) keep At this time, there is nothing of value in this article. From my limited understanding of Simdesk, however, there *could* be an acceptable article written. There are enough reliable sources that this to pass . I will keep checking to see if this article gets expanded and will change my vote to '''keep''' if it improves Deletion of Simdesk WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9676 17734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al-Teymur User:Stuartyeates 08:25, 17 October 2011 (UTC) delete as failing for being completely unsourced. Suggest to the creator that they work on such pages one and a time and include (a) the arabic name(s) for the suburb and (b) two or three references or sources that talk about the neighbourhood Deletion of Al-Teymur WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9677 12765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jessica Meir (2nd nomination) User:Miniapolis 16:55, 26 February 2013 (UTC) keep While the sources aren't overwhelming, I think the article's subject just meets Deletion of Jessica Meir (2nd nomination) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9678 5622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thakur Shivam Singh (2nd nomination) User:Chris 14:30, 11 May 2020 (UTC) delete I'm not convinced the sources cited are all talking about the same person; with the broken English of the article, it's hard to ascertain. Subject certainly fails and . This article should be developed in the Wikipedia of the native language of the subject's area Deletion of Thakur Shivam Singh (2nd nomination) WP:NPOL||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9679 1913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salem Local Planning Authority User:Ab207 15:39, 3 September 2021 (UTC) merge to Directorate of Town and Country Planning#Salem LPA, its parent orgnaization. It's unclear whether this topic meets GNG, regardless the target article already duplicates the content present here and this topic can easily be covered there (per ). Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiruchirappalli Local Planning Authority resulted in a similar outcome Deletion of Salem Local Planning Authority WP:NOPAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9680 11182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Peterman User:Paulmcdonald 13:11, 6 October 2015 (UTC) keep based on passing and Cbl62's research. Great job Deletion of Eric Peterman WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9681 16502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jerusalem catholic User:Bejnar 07:11, 17 June 2013 (UTC) delete """Not notable under for lack of coverage in independent reliable sources. I also agree that there are insufficient independent sources available upon which to build a |neutral article. The title """"Jerusalem catholic"""" is a poor choice and potentially ambiguous, see disambiguation at :Church of Jerusalem; in the event that it is not deleted, it should be moved to Catholic Apostolic Church of Jerusalem""" Deletion of Jerusalem catholic :WP:ORG||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
9682 19548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicholas Montgomery Black User:Russ 17:21, 13 January 2021 (UTC) delete possibly speedy A7. It would be unusual indeed if a PhD candidate passed ; no sign of any other notability Deletion of Nicholas Montgomery Black WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9683 17468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ambra Moore User:ArcticDragonfly 15:38, 6 August 2017 (UTC) delete The article was created and edited by a SPA Special:Contributions/ACMM98|ACCM98 and edited by another SPA Special:Contributions/Hollywood98|Hollywood98. Both names indicate . The same accounts have also created Geoffrey R. Moore, And the Winner Isn't... and And The Winner Isn't. The last two makes it obvious that the two accounts are connected Deletion of Ambra Moore WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
9684 3114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deepak Kumar (artist) User:onel5969 13:54, 30 October 2018 (UTC) delete Does not pass . Agree with the rationale provided by Deletion of Deepak Kumar (artist) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9685 14123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syed A Naqvi NONE 18:23, 29 August 2015 (UTC) delete What a mess. Hardly need a reason in this case, but fails Curiocurio Deletion of Syed A Naqvi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9686 14158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islamic Online University User:Terence 06:37, 6 November 2006 (UTC) delete fails , , not a notable online university Deletion of Islamic Online University WP:WEB||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9687 7531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A bigger, better machine i will be User:HumbleGod 00:08, 6 August 2006 (UTC) delete neither the musician, his band, nor this album makes an appearance on Allmusic; no sources; apparently no meeting of any other or criteria Deletion of A bigger, better machine i will be WP:BAND||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9688 16780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Severed Fifth User:W 13:03, 1 July 2008 (UTC) delete massively non-notable project, not to mention unexceptional as ''an artist independent of the record industry trying to distribute himself'' has been done a million times already anyway. The only reason it's getting treated as novel, i suspect, is because of this man Bacon's crowd aren't particularly familiar with the topic and because he's decided to write |a future article about it Deletion of Severed Fifth WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9689 10523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Colson User:Lilac 21:24, 24 March 2009 (UTC) delete fails . He may become notable in the future, but doesn't appear to be so now. The fact that the team he plays for apparently isn't notable (at least, it doesn't have an article, but I realize this doesn't necessarily mean that it isn't notable) also indicates his lack of notability Deletion of Jason Colson WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9690 132 [[Liste der Minister für Verteidigung der DDR]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Matthiasb 22:15, 15. Jul. 2010 (CEST) keep Minister sind Personen -> Personenliste, Ministerien sind Behörden. Grundsatz per : zwei verschiedene Artikelgegenstände werden in zwei verschiedenen Artikeln beschrieben. Ergo: LA zurückweisen, '''behalten Löschung von Liste der Minister für Verteidigung der DDR Wikipedia:Artikel Wikipedia:Artikel 90
9691 571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ammar Campa-Najjar (3rd nomination) User:Magnolia677 23:31, 9 March 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and . I was unable to locate any significant biographical details, except for several mentions of him regarding the election. A bit too soon Deletion of Ammar Campa-Najjar (3rd nomination) WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9692 3643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Library (Seinfeld) User:Toughpigs 04:45, 2 December 2020 (UTC) keep """The sources provided above are fine for establishing GNG. Horacio Vara's assertion that """"reviews don't show notability"""" contradicts existing guidelines (""" Deletion of The Library (Seinfeld) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
9693 2385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of nascent delta functions NONE NONE delete Regardless of the fact that it's a fork (not necessarily a ) of Dirac delta function, and the history supplied by the nominator, the article doesn't stand on it's own. For (almost) ''any'' probability density function \varphi Deletion of List of nascent delta functions WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
9694 12822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hum Bhi Akele Tum Bhi Akele User:SunDawn 11:12, 19 May 2021 (UTC) keep the article now have reviews from National Herald, Indian Express, and Times of India. Enough to pass Deletion of Hum Bhi Akele Tum Bhi Akele WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
9695 3728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toronto Slutwalk User:Jonathanwallace 11:46, 29 April 2011 (UTC) comment I removed most of the and material. What is left is well sourced and I believe avoids because other such demonstrations are reported planned, so this is more of a protest movement than a random news event which happened one day Deletion of Toronto Slutwalk WP:OR||WP:COATRACK||WP:1E Wikipedia:No original research 65
9696 12780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanjiv Augustine User:Savonneux 06:13, 21 August 2015 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Sanjiv Augustine WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9697 19862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ocean View Abu Dhabi NONE NONE comment Under it is stated Deletion of Ocean View Abu Dhabi WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9698 14868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sorawit Panthong User:GiantSnowman 11:09, 25 March 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Sorawit Panthong WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9699 4989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Columbia University College Democrats User:Metropolitan90 09:02, 24 February 2008 (UTC) delete per as has been done with other similar organizations Deletion of Columbia University College Democrats WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9700 1703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Ohnesorge User:Angelo 10:39, 30 July 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. None of those sources are covering extensively in detail the subject, so they cannot be considered for Deletion of Michael Ohnesorge WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9701 13226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Story of toys User:CAPTAIN 22:12, 3 April 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Story of toys WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
9702 1772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EliteXC: Showdown User:TreyGeek 01:01, 15 April 2012 (UTC) delete The event never happened and the article fails to explain how a non-occurring event is notable. Seems to be a perfect example of why event article should not be created in advance of the event as per Deletion of EliteXC: Showdown WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9703 12876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MySupermarket (3rd nomination) NONE NONE keep but '''rewrite from scratch.''' (I have accordingly tagged the article with a {{tl|rewrite}} template.) The deletion advocates have a point about the majority of the sources. The principal problem with most of the sources is lack of independence: they are too heavily sourced from mySupermarket itself. On the other hand, enough independent, reliable sources remain that they should allow an article to be written. Also, some of the deletionist arguments, especially those based on the Terms of Use (m:TOU) and , are without merit, and some deletionist arguments stretch the locality criterion from beyond the breaking point Deletion of MySupermarket (3rd nomination) WP:NOT||WP:AUD Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9704 2630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kristy Holtfreter User:Joseph2302 16:22, 2 November 2020 (UTC) delete per - now that identity has been confirmed, BLPREQUESTDELETE says we can delete for marginally notable people, which applies here Deletion of Kristy Holtfreter WP:BLPREQUESTDELETE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
9705 12352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geeta Mehta User:AuthorAuthor 06:19, 28 May 2019 (UTC) keep """I found the opposite from nom's """"Not finding any independent in-depth coverage in reliable sources, either those in the article or elsewhere online."""" A search also led me to the opposite of the nom's statement that the subject is a """"Run-of-the-mill businesswoman."""" As an example of a search, the subject is included in a https://www.metropolismag.com/cities/citizen-jane-review-jacobs-pedestal-moses-bus/ """"who’s who of architects and thought leaders"""" in the 2017 full-length documentary https://www.6sqft.com/film-review-new-jane-jacobs-documentary-spotlights-her-achievements-in-nyc-and-legacy-around-the-world/ ''Citizen Jane: Battle for the City''. Also, in January 2019, the subject was named (but declined because of an upcoming election) by the Government of India as a recipient of the Padma Shri award https://indianexpress.com/article/india/writer-gita-mehta-naveen-patnaiks-sister-turns-down-padma-shri-cites-timing-before-polls/ for distinguished contribution to literature and education. The article has been cleaned up but still needs some work. As it stands now, however, with the reliable sources in the article that show notability, the subject easily passes as well as . A """"speedy keep"""" may be warranted""" Deletion of Geeta Mehta WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
9706 7561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seiyo Shorin-Ryu Karate and Kobudo User:Mdtemp 17:13, 1 July 2013 (UTC) merge to Dan Hausel. This style does not pass and a redirect would take care of any searches Deletion of Seiyo Shorin-Ryu Karate and Kobudo WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9707 20343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tourist guy (2nd nomination) User:Pokerdance 09:25, 23 July 2009 (UTC) keep Passes the |general notability guideline Deletion of Tourist guy (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9708 10525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noel Phillips User:Cbl62 02:35, 21 September 2017 (UTC) delete per nom. My searches did not turn up any significant coverage in reliable, independent sources of the type required to pass Deletion of Noel Phillips WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9709 2472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sit on My Face User:Shruti14 18:19, 21 August 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Sit on My Face WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9710 20981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Duran [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart111''']] [[User talk:Stalwart111|(talk)]] 00:06, 6 September 2012 (UTC) delete """I commented at the corresponding AfD that the subject had been described (on a |blog) as ''PeekYou's """"most influential comic on the web""""'' but I haven't managed to find any reliable sources to back even that claim up. As it stands I think the article itself fails . I also have concerns about Belligerence: The Journey of JJ Star (Note: the albums in his ''Discography'' link to redirects which link back to Jeff Duran""" Deletion of Jeff Duran WP:BLOG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9711 18719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2027 FIFA Women's World Cup User:Hmlarson 17:49, 9 June 2019 (UTC) keep several news articles related to the bidding process in numerous countries. Article could use expansion, improved referencing not deletion per Deletion of 2027 FIFA Women's World Cup WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9712 21461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Gratton User:Lankiveil 12:05, 5 February 2014 (UTC) keep the interview in Cambridge Business is pretty fluffy, but it is substantial and independent as far as I can tell. She's borderline, but I think just squeaks over the bar Deletion of Sarah Gratton WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9713 6095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phillip Silverstone User:Wildthing61476 21:40, 5 February 2008 (UTC) keep Being the host of a two-time Emmy-nominated show might be enough, but a few of the other items listed, if given proper sourcing, should be enough to meet Deletion of Phillip Silverstone WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9714 17013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samandar Paar User:MezzoMezzo 11:10, 6 May 2013 (UTC) delete Seems like an issue of Deletion of Samandar Paar WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
9715 5837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 MLS SuperDraft (2nd nomination) User:Mentoz86 20:44, 27 February 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of 2015 MLS SuperDraft (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9716 1295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scroffice User:Part 14:42, 21 February 2007 (UTC) delete obvious issues. Just prod this kind of crap; it's not worth even afding it Deletion of Scroffice WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9717 21024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brock Beukeboom User:Snottywong 23:46, 29 September 2011 (UTC) delete fails and claims that he ''will'' eventually be notable fail . No redirect necessary Deletion of Brock Beukeboom WP:NHOCKEY||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9718 7217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nissen Osterneck User:Papaursa 02:15, 24 December 2013 (UTC) delete Fails to meet either or Deletion of Nissen Osterneck WP:NMMA||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9719 13386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bellypunching User:Aeon1006 05:56, 8 August 2006 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Bellypunching WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9720 15110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of artists influenced by Michael Jackson User:LearnIndology 04:30, 16 April 2021 (UTC) delete Barely conclusive if we look at the done on this list Deletion of List of artists influenced by Michael Jackson WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9721 19611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LatentView User:onel5969 02:23, 5 November 2015 (UTC) delete per nom and SwisterTwister. Searches don't turn up anything to show they pass or Deletion of LatentView WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9722 321 [[Bibelkritik]] (bleibt) Benutzer:SVL 12:34, 19. Okt. 2007 (CEST) keep """Betrachten wir das Ganze mal relativ nüchtern. Bibelkritik ist immer - egal von welcher Seite sie auch kommen mag - mit TF behaftet. Dieses Lemma deswegen """"totschweigen"""" zu wollen ist geradezu absurd. Wir hatten zu diesem Artikel Anfang des Jahres einen umfassenden Review und mit über 500 KB (einschl. Unterseiten) einen der umfangreichsten /Artikel_Bibelkritik|Vermittlungsausschüsse, in dem über 4 Monate lang ein Konsens gesucht und weitgehend gefunden wurde. Jetzt mit der Argumentation zu kommen, dass hier der """"längste Neutralitätsvermerk"""" drinsteht, ist wohl das Hinterletzte""" Löschung von Bibelkritik Wikipedia:Vermittlungsausschuss Wikipedia:Mediation 96
9723 11916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beavershark User:Ispy1981 21:03, 20 June 2007 (UTC) delete per It's spreading to Georgia! I've actually heard of this one. Urban legend Deletion of Beavershark WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
9724 5206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr Schlong User:Bucketsofg 15:00, 5 May 2006 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Dr Schlong WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9725 231 [[Wolfhart-Motor]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:misterjack NONE delete Der Vergleich mit dem Perpetuum Mobile ist ein klassischer Verstoss gegen . Der Artikel ist als Wiedergaenger natuerlich zu Löschung von Wolfhart-Motor Wikipedia:BNS Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
9726 901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Watkins User:Struway2 11:16, 30 January 2012 (UTC) delete Player has never played in a fully-professional league or at senior international level, so fails . No evidence of sufficient non-trivial independent media coverage to show |general notability Deletion of Adam Watkins WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9727 21818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Digitally Imported User:NightRider63 19:44, 3 October 2007 (UTC) comment Regardless it does not assert its notability or has any outside sources see , and this is mainly edited by IP Addresses that Trace back to the address of the Sky.fm building that is a direct violation of Deletion of Digitally Imported WP:CORP||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
9728 6593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Eric Ruben User:David 00:37, 17 January 2016 (UTC) delete Our article presents no evidence of passing nor Deletion of Bruce Eric Ruben WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9729 19989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Superman curse User:Wolfview 04:20, 13 August 2010 (UTC) keep """Delete''' This is riginal research '''stupid'''. Bad things happen to almost everybody. What has been done here is to go through the list of every person with some connection to Superman and mention those who had some misfortune as victims of the """"curse."""" I know taste doesn't count for much on WP, but the whole thing is very offensive -- as the nom mentioned. But delete because it's just not notable '''keep because WP's mission is to reflect what is considered notable by """"reliable sources."""" No matter what the depth they will go WP must follow, by policy""" Deletion of Superman curse WP:O Wikipedia:Orphan 47
9730 14661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor Who: DWO Whocast User:Atlantic306 21:47, 15 May 2019 (UTC) keep as nationally published hard copy magazines are reliable sources despite the willful assertions above, passes Deletion of Doctor Who: DWO Whocast WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9731 13608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmed Zia Malik User:Saqib 17:28, 10 July 2017 (UTC) delete a local office holder fails to meet olitician and Deletion of Ahmed Zia Malik WP:P||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Portal 85
9732 3032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Australians in international prisons (2nd nomination) User:Krimpet 10:44, 7 November 2007 (UTC) delete The individuals themselves may be notable and merit articles on their plights, but the criteria used for this list seems overly arbitrary and seems to |use sources to advocate a specific point of view. (FWIW, I also strongly oppose capital punishment, yet agree that this list seems incongruent with our NPOV Deletion of List of Australians in international prisons (2nd nomination) WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
9733 15351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rimo Haq User:GraYoshi2x 17:59, 25 July 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Rimo Haq WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
9734 7616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colby Boothman User:Shawn 18:16, 8 August 2016 (UTC) delete doesn't yet meet either or . A bit part in a blockbuster, very few bona fide reliable sources and then a lot of other coverage in doesn't quite add up Deletion of Colby Boothman WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG||WP:BLOGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9735 3012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Itrw User:Srose 16:57, 8 September 2006 (UTC) merge """what is valid and isn't already in Ancient Egyptian units of measurement. Itrw appears to be an archaic term, per about 700 http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=Itrw+measurement google results for Itrw measurement. Many of these results are either Wikipedia (the article itself and its mention in Ancient Egyptian units of measurements), mirrors of the Wikipedia results, or completely unrelated blogs and/or businesses. After reading the RfAr, I'm quite sure that the reason I cannot find any online source (even an ''unreliable'' one) to back up half of the claims in the article is that they're |fabricated or |original research. I looked for confirming sources under the term """"atur"""" as well""" Deletion of Itrw WP:HOAX||WP:OR Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
9736 18967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Special Force - ParaCommando Division User:Icewhiz 08:16, 4 February 2019 (UTC) delete ping|Worldbruce}} Following an re-examination of the sources in the article - I concur with Worldbruce. Specifically, I don't see which source discusses this as being a division in the Forces Goal 2030 plan. Some of the sources (dailystar) are misrepresented (source says 2nd battalion -> article 2nd brigade). I apologize for not being through in evaluating the cited sources in the article, but would suggest that future nominations based a fail say state specifically that the cited sources are misrepresented. I am striking my merge !vote and changing to delete on the basis that the contents fail Deletion of Special Force - ParaCommando Division WP:V||WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9737 17180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe cell User:JeremyMcCracken 23:37, 16 May 2008 (UTC) comment Googling the book refs shows that they appear to be existing books (though possibly self published). G-hits turn up quite a bit, too. It looks to be a hoax device, but it might actually be attracting enough attention to pass . Simply put, the wide array of hits that google turns up (not the number, but the types of sites) makes it look like there is serious discussion about this thing Deletion of Joe cell WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9738 17222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Azusa shooting User:Parsley 20:29, 18 November 2016 (UTC) comment A shooting in which only one person died and three others were injured? Yeah, it doesn't even meet Deletion of Azusa shooting WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9739 18807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/YouSponge User:Consumed 09:16, 28 January 2007 (UTC) delete under A7 - website with no assertion of notability Deletion of YouSponge WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9740 514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of key MBTA bus routes User:Unscintillating 02:22, 26 December 2017 (UTC) keep nbsp; Merge was discussed and rejected back in 2008 on the talk page. The point is not to say that this topic should or should not be merged, but that it is a violation of eletion policy to use EL8 to delete topics with merge targets, and there is no argument made here for IAR. Deletion of List of key MBTA bus routes WP:D||WP:DEL8 Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
9741 12416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NGC 4993 [[User talk:129.68.81.110|talk]]) 20:19, 3 September 2017 (UTC) comment Since TR, the AfD nominator, agreed that clearly covers this article, and no other objection has been made, it seems this is a |Speedy Keep. According to , any user who has not commented yet may close this discussion, and so may TR, by following the instructions at the link. TR may be right that the bar has been set too low, but that would be a concern to discuss on 's Talk page, not here. Special:Contributions/129.68.81.110|129.68.81.110 Deletion of NGC 4993 WP:NASTRO||WP:KEEP||WP:NACD||WP:NASTRO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9742 21221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmed Emad Eldin User:Cullen328 18:05, 15 September 2018 (UTC) keep per . This article is dramatically better than it was on September 3, and the additional referenced content makes it clear that BLP1E no longer applies Deletion of Ahmed Emad Eldin WP:HEYMANN Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
9743 16107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sara Benincasa User:Evb 17:38, 26 October 2008 (UTC) keep WP:N|Notability supported by |reliable sources like http://www.newsweek.com/id/156986 this and http://abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/Story?id=5791053&page=2 this. See also http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&safe=off&q=%22Sara%20Benincasa%22&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=wn these Deletion of Sara Benincasa WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9744 8875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swaim Place, Wyoming User:Lightburst 15:04, 28 March 2020 (UTC) delete does not meet our requirements for Deletion of Swaim Place, Wyoming WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9745 5468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billy Hallowell (2nd nomination) User:Rpclod 05:05, 27 June 2015 (UTC) delete seems somewhat self-promotional. Isn't writing some articles and interviewing some people what journalists are supposed to do? Nothing suggests notability Deletion of Billy Hallowell (2nd nomination) WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
9746 7533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rockerrazzi User:Piotrus 06:43, 1 November 2016 (UTC) delete The one source I checked (Rolling Stones) does not seem to mention the company at all. Fails . At best could get a short entry at some List of American record labels or such Deletion of Rockerrazzi WP:NCOMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
9747 21652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ForkLift (File Manager) User:KAP03 15:12, 22 April 2017 (UTC) keep could be improved to meet the with the following references: https://www.engadget.com/2010/11/25/forklift-2-slick-file-management-fast-file-transfers/, http://www.macworld.com/article/1156245/forklift_2.html, https://www.macrumors.com/2012/05/22/binary-nights-puts-mac-file-transfer-app-forklift-on-sale-for-0-99/ and http://www.macworld.com/article/1058163/forklift.html Deletion of ForkLift (File Manager) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9748 9319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Pooley (Ebola patient) User:Secret 02:58, 16 October 2014 (UTC) merge as a and the original prod nominee Deletion of William Pooley (Ebola patient) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
9749 14728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flyer Frizbee User:Malevious 00:26, 19 December 2006 (UTC) delete per --Malevious Deletion of Flyer Frizbee WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
9750 61 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hasan Uzunhocaoğlu Kullanıcı:188.57.4.144188.57.4.144 16:22, 21 Ağustos 2016 (UTC) delete KD karşılamamaktadır... Özel:Katkılar/188.57.4.144|188.57.4.144 bkz. Hasan Uzunhocaoğlu'nun silinmesi Vikipedi:OY Wikipedia:Administrators 89
9751 2157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/North Carolina Green Party User:Me 03:02, 23 January 2017 (UTC) merge Fails . Suggest merge to List of state Green Parties in the United States Deletion of North Carolina Green Party WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9752 5507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicole M. Christie User:Chiro725 16:19, 6 April 2021 (UTC) delete no way to save this article, lacks Deletion of Nicole M. Christie WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9753 20926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Horse ripping compared to cattle mutilation User:The 10:55, 13 September 2006 (UTC) delete as |unverifiable, and |original research Deletion of Horse ripping compared to cattle mutilation WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9754 15071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/North Hudson, New Jersey User:SportingFlyer 03:07, 18 June 2019 (UTC) delete """After some research, the term """"North Hudson"""" appears to be a term for the general region, possibly a colloquialism, such as the sewerage authority and the fire authority. I don't see significant coverage of the definition of the region in any of the sources, and many of the sources in the article don't even use the term, making much of the article possibly . Happy to review any sources I may have missed""" Deletion of North Hudson, New Jersey WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9755 10744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of San Diego Padres no-hitters (2nd nomination) User:Bagumba 03:47, 10 April 2021 (UTC) delete Fails , as one item is neither a group nor set Deletion of List of San Diego Padres no-hitters (2nd nomination) WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9756 6594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southwest Air Lines Flight 611 User:The 22:27, 30 January 2012 (UTC) merge to Ishigaki Airport - notable in the context of the airport's history, but fails for an article of its own Deletion of Southwest Air Lines Flight 611 WP:PERSISTENCE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9757 6362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stage 3-1 User:Qworty 13:44, 7 May 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Stage 3-1 WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9758 14851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Wood (British businessman) [[User talk:192.160.216.52|talk]]) 17:10, 16 April 2018 (UTC) keep """No actual reason given for deletion."""" It's not the business of the article to establish notability, it's the business of the sources found by the nominator during . In this case there are plenty. See https://uk.reuters.com/article/meggitt-plc-moves-ceo/moves-meggitt-names-tony-wood-ceo-idUKL3N1NK4ES Reuters, https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/meggitt-lines-up-rolls-veteran-as-suitors-circle-tzhwgw6fm The Times, https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2017/01/28/elliott-sells-stake-meggitt-failing-find-buyer-aerospace-supplier/ The Telegraph. Could go on. Special:Contributions/192.160.216.52|192.160.216.52""" Deletion of Tony Wood (British businessman) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9759 16693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Schloß Pompon Rouge User:Mrschimpf 15:14, 16 October 2020 (UTC) keep Considering it aired a national network and it was one of the first series of its type after German reunification, it's a good keep. Great on this, Encyclopædius Deletion of Schloß Pompon Rouge WP:RESCUE Wikipedia:Article Rescue Squadron 98
9760 18626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akos Gurzo User:Mstuczynski 01:44, 26 February 2008 (UTC) delete This gentleman seems to be a good candidate for a Magyar Wikipedia, but until and unless English language references are added he should have no place on an English Wikipedia, erifiability Deletion of Akos Gurzo WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9761 3141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CoroCoro Comic User:Quasirandom 14:10, 3 September 2009 (UTC) keep Even without evidences of discussion, the magazine that initially serialized ''Doraemon'' and ''Pokemon'', among other important works, is clearly notable in some way. Do we have enough |snow falling yet Deletion of CoroCoro Comic WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
9762 17507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiger Blood User:Richard3120 18:37, 1 September 2017 (UTC) merge to The Quill (band): fails , none of the three sources in the article are reliable ones, simply a link to a blog review and two track listing databases Deletion of Tiger Blood WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
9763 15288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OpIndia.com User:GSS 10:03, 5 March 2018 (UTC) delete as |non-notable news website with no assertion of significance, no third-party references Deletion of OpIndia.com WP:NMEDIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
9764 14619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1318 Nerina User:Northamerica1000 12:29, 6 June 2015 (UTC) keep Meets per the sources provided above Deletion of 1318 Nerina WP:NASTRO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9765 11039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexandru Bănuță User:Nfitz 21:01, 19 February 2017 (UTC) keep meets appearing for CSM Ceahlăul Piatra Neamț in the Romanian Liga I in the 2007–08 Liga I season. This league is listed as fully-professional in . Here's a boxscore that showed he played https://www.weltfussball.com/spielbericht/liga-1-2007-2008-gloria-buzau-ceahlaul-piatra-neamt/ December 14, 2007 Deletion of Alexandru Bănuță WP:GNG||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9766 3951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dick Rodgers User:StAnselm 09:09, 23 October 2015 (UTC) keep definitely sources, but they're al in the The Common Good (political party)|party article.http://www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/midlands-news/northfield-priest-campaigns-in-newark-7212122http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-117764012.htmlhttp://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-143633110.htmlhttp://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-131849514.html Clear pass of Deletion of Dick Rodgers WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9767 12803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Etihad Player Of The Month User:Fenix 10:21, 30 October 2015 (UTC) delete obvious cruft. A non-notable internal fan-based award that has garnered no significant reliable coverage outside of |primary sources to even begin to satisfy GNG. The keep arguments above amount to nothing more than Deletion of Etihad Player Of The Month WP:PRIMARYSOURCE||WP:ITEXISTS Wikipedia:No original research 65
9768 10421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josephine Gillan User:Hijiri88 06:17, 8 July 2017 (UTC) delete Include questionably sourced -violating material, leave it as a , or delete. Only the third option is feasible Deletion of Josephine Gillan WP:BLP||WP:PERMASTUB Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
9769 1005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sumter Mall User:Me5000 14:32, 17 May 2014 (UTC) comment """Consensus is that malls do not need national coverage to be notable per these discussions: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southgate Mall (Missoula) Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Middlesboro Mall (Middlesboro, Kentucky) Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mall at Westlake Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Columbia Mall (Missouri) Almost no malls have national coverage. The sources I provided are not """"perfunctory""""(did you look at all of the source I provided or just a few?) and easily satisfy . Additionaly, consensus is that enclosed shopping malls and Regional Shopping Centers (this mall is both) are inherently notable""" Deletion of Sumter Mall WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9770 10880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary DeGrio User:Djsasso 16:29, 26 November 2015 (UTC) keep Meets by playing in the World Championships Deletion of Gary DeGrio WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
9771 384 [[Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien]] (bleibt vorläufig) Benutzer:Thomas S. NONE delete weil die Relevanzkriterien oft als Mindestanforderungen und damit falsch interpretiert werden. Und wem sie nicht passen, der beruft sich auf , woran nicht gerüttelt werden darf. Damit sind die Kriterien nicht verbindlich und somit sinnlos. Gleiches gilt für Wikipedia:Löschregeln. Die sollte man gleich mitlöschen. Es hält sich sowieso niemand dran Löschung von Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Ignoriere alle Regeln Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
9772 9853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My GRAIN User:Oli 17:47, 28 August 2007 (UTC) delete and '''salt''' per #G4|CSD G4 - the article was previously AfD'd as MyGRAIN, and subsequently speedied twice. Author has made no attempt to address , even after repeated prompting on Talk:MyGRAIN. Quite probable use of socks to remove speedy tags as well Deletion of My GRAIN WP:CSD||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9773 5607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grapefruit—Juicy Fruit User:Esradekan 02:37, 1 July 2009 (UTC) delete as an unlikely redirect term, fails notability per #Songs. No awards, no chart, no covers, no . Nothing to merge due to the lack of reliable, third-party, sources Deletion of Grapefruit—Juicy Fruit WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9774 10136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saheba Subramanyam User:CaptainEek 02:08, 7 January 2020 (UTC) keep I would caution the nom here that just because an article is short on sources, does not mean that it is not notable. Please remember to do and look up the article to check if sourcing exists. AfD is not for deleting bad articles, only those that are not notable or are irreversibly against policy. In terms of sourcing, I quickly found numerous reviews of the film: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/telugu/movie-reviews/saheba-subramanyam/movie-review/45505337.cms, https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Vijayawada/saheba-subramanyam-to-hit-screens/article6255076.ece, https://www.cinejosh.com/review/saheba-subramanyam-review/613, https://www.apherald.com/Movies/Read?id=63161, and there are clearly more out there Deletion of Saheba Subramanyam WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9775 5969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chronology of Shakespeare's plays – Oxfordian (2nd nomination) User:Smatprt 20:59, 9 November 2011 (UTC) comment There is disagreement over the Chronology of Shakespeare's plays, and there is disagreement over the Oxfordian version being discussed here. Both articles present competing viewpoints (although the main Shakespeare chronology disregards most early scholarship on the matter and some notable dissenting viewpoints). In this case, just because there is no wide-spread agreement is no reason to delete the article. Also, there is plenty of information in this article that is NOT repeated in any other article. Comments to the contrary are incorrect on this. The repeated information is there '''''so that NPOV is addressed and readers are clearly aware what the mainstream position is (the repeated bits) and what the minority viewpoint is (the non-repeated bits)'''''. As a ringe topic, views of the adherents are allowed, as long as they are published by independent mainstream publishers etc. That is precisely the case here with Ogburn and Anderson, for example Deletion of Chronology of Shakespeare's plays – Oxfordian (2nd nomination) WP:F Wikipedia:Non-free content 99
9776 21811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wand TV Tower User:Tghe 01:17, 17 December 2006 (UTC) delete I think it is the only way that this problem of non-notable masts will be resolved. I would also request a '''review''' of these mast articles with the Wikipedia:WikiProject Architecture, Wikipedia:WikiProject Television and Wikipedia:WikiProject Radio. Wikipedia is '''not''' the http://tx.mb21.co.uk/gallery/ MB21 transmission gallery of TV/Radio towers/masts. Any UK based mast information that isn't there should be given to the aforementioned website, and removed from Wikipedia. They won't grow beyond a stub and fail miserably as well as #DIR and #IINFO Deletion of Wand TV Tower WP:NN||WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9777 7831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theresa-Marie Rhyne User:Eluchil404 21:20, 4 July 2006 (UTC) keep appears to scrape by though it still needs some clean-up Deletion of Theresa-Marie Rhyne WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9778 1805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Bittner User:Stifle 02:02, 30 December 2005 (UTC) delete Currently no evidence of passing Deletion of Eric Bittner WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9779 11838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucky Captain Rabbit King Nuggets user:teh 16:06, 21 January 2007 (UTC) delete If this actually made any |difference in the world, then ''maybe'' it could be considered. But as stands, as a '''fictional''' food item, what's the point of it having an entry Deletion of Lucky Captain Rabbit King Nuggets WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9780 17871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Dotted Lines Mixtape User:Esradekan 11:55, 19 October 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per #Albums.2C_singles_and_songs|#Albums Deletion of The Dotted Lines Mixtape WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9781 20129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pickupp User:Girth 17:04, 2 May 2019 (UTC) delete per above - no sourcing in the article or elsewhere that I could find Deletion of Pickupp WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
9782 11653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rajkumar Kanagasingam User:Ocatecir 08:50, 18 March 2007 (UTC) delete Though he has had his name in the news, none of his accomplishments seem noteworth enough for an article. Also the comment above highlights the glaring |conflict of interest concerns. &mdash Deletion of Rajkumar Kanagasingam WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
9783 16730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lost Book of the Covenant User:Shirahadasha 05:02, 2 July 2006 (UTC) comment Postpone''' 1-2 weeks. Give the author a week or two to come up with acceptable sources for the thesis if she can, otherwise '''Delete''' per Deletion of Lost Book of the Covenant WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9784 17327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Fankhauser (2nd nomination) User:K 05:32, 14 October 2016 (UTC) delete per ; strictly a vanity page on an unremarkable actor. Nothing of substance here Deletion of Ben Fankhauser (2nd nomination) WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9785 3129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scientists for Future User:Matthiaspaul 21:26, 13 October 2019 (UTC) keep There are more than enough sources to fulfill , and many more could be brought by if necessary Deletion of Scientists for Future WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9786 3568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chandigarh Hand Ball Association User:ToonLucas22 01:46, 1 March 2015 (UTC) delete per |CSD A7 and '''Salt''' as recreation of Chandigarh Handball Association Deletion of Chandigarh Hand Ball Association WP:A7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9787 6496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcella Zoia User:Bearian 16:07, 30 July 2020 (UTC) delete per . She was a teenager who did something cruel and stupid. That could be a one of millions of people Deletion of Marcella Zoia WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
9788 18631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Origin of airport IATA codes-A User:Kraxler 01:01, 16 September 2015 (UTC) delete """unsourced, useless , most codes don't have a discernable alphabetic """"origin"""", because all the letters in the name were taken already""" Deletion of Origin of airport IATA codes-A WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
9789 3227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Mourdock pregnancy from rape Is 'something god intended' controversy User:Érico 02:49, 25 October 2012 (UTC) keep It makes no sense to keep Todd Akin 'legitimate rape' and pregnancy comment controversy, and delete this page; and Deletion of Richard Mourdock pregnancy from rape Is 'something god intended' controversy WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9790 6524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank Derickson User:Bearcat 15:46, 24 May 2020 (UTC) delete Chester IL (pop. 8K) is nowhere near large enough to hand an automatic presumption of notability to its mayors in the absence of a properly demonstrated pass of #2 — but this article is neither substantive nor well-sourced enough to get him over NPOL #2. The content is almost entirely ''unsourced'', in fact: there are just three footnotes in the entire article, of which two are |primary sources that are not support for notability at all, and the only one that counts as a genuinely ''reliable'' source is a book (admittedly a very famous book) being cited ''only'' to support a statement that Frank Derickson was ''mentioned'' in it — but being ''mentioned'' in a book, without being the ''subject'' of any ''significant'' content in that book, is not a notability clincher in and of itself if it's the ''best'' source you can come up with Deletion of Frank Derickson WP:NPOL||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES Wikipedia:Notability 77
9791 14745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/America's Got Talent (season 15) User:Mrschimpf 00:11, 10 October 2019 (UTC) delete Every year we go through this; barring the complete dissolution of NBC, we know a new season is happening, but October is way too early to create a new season article. However, this is possibly the return of the same vandal who has continued their Sisyphean effort to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/America's Got Talent (season 10)|fake season ten and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/America's Got Talent (season 9)|season nine's existence in the same time period. It may be time to start ing these season article titles (yes, up to at least season 20) until we have solid concrete details regarding the season start Deletion of America's Got Talent (season 15) WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
9792 8491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DDR Freak (3rd nomination) User:Dougk 06:29, 27 September 2007 (UTC) delete per nom; while article is not entirely self-sourced, permission to reproduce the copyrighted articles mirrored on the article's site is not clearly defined. They should link to the original source (or, at the very least, an appropriate bibliographic entry); as I recall, there may be potential issues with linking to copyrighted media such as this (see ). At the very least, those links should probably go Deletion of DDR Freak (3rd nomination) WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
9793 18825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Happy Holidays (Enuff Z'nuff song) User:TenPoundHammer 05:09, 3 December 2008 (UTC) delete Unlikely redirect term, song utterly fails Deletion of Happy Holidays (Enuff Z'nuff song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9794 3678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Freak Next Door User:CaroleHenson 06:43, 6 June 2013 (UTC) delete for failing . I was unable to find material about the films as well - the only source seems to be IMdB Deletion of The Freak Next Door WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9795 7571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nat & Alex Wolff: Live User:Gongshow 17:42, 10 February 2010 (UTC) delete per ; no confirmed album title, release date, or track listing found in |reliable sources. Violates and with no significant coverage for this yet, it does not meet Deletion of Nat & Alex Wolff: Live WP:HAMMERTIME||WP:RS||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
9796 4976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global storm activity of 2011 (2nd nomination) User:Atmoz 15:27, 29 January 2011 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a indiscriminate collection of weather reports. Deletion of Global storm activity of 2011 (2nd nomination) WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9797 1684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of anagrams User:Kinu 16:54, 26 August 2006 (UTC) delete intriguing as some of these might be, an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of List of anagrams WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9798 9398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Weiherburgbach User:Qwaiiplayer 13:19, 14 May 2021 (UTC) delete """fails . The """"river"""" only appears to be mentioned in maps and GPS databases""" Deletion of Weiherburgbach WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9799 11684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beant Singh (assassin) User:DBigXray 09:40, 11 September 2019 (UTC) keep """as a highly notable subject. This was not some random crime but Assassination of the then :Prime Minister of India. The Guideline that nominator is quoting above states """"..should not ''normally'' be.."""". Well the murder of the sitting PM is not a normal crime. The assassins of Kennedy, Lincoln etc are similar cases who have their own article. In such high profile cases the subject gets intense national and international coverage which makes the subject pass all criteria of . As expected Beant Singh's act made him popular and multiple notable events such as, election victory of his widow and father, in Lok Sabha, honour by Akal Takht, annual felicitation etc were caused as a result of this act. All of these cannot simply be merged to the assassination page. There are enough sources in the article, hence I dont feel the need to post here""" Deletion of Beant Singh (assassin) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9800 13969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ramat Ohunene Abdulkareem User:CommanderWaterford 11:47, 27 March 2021 (UTC) delete Fails , not enough cov for either Deletion of Ramat Ohunene Abdulkareem WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9801 18606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Northwest Airlines Flight 42 User:Tychocat 10:24, 27 August 2006 (UTC) delete as WP is not a newspaper per . See Wikinews. Also, NWA's labor problems are not the topic of this article Deletion of Northwest Airlines Flight 42 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9802 4411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Second Robotech War User:Sephiroth 04:28, 3 March 2009 (UTC) delete pretty blatant failure of #PLOT. No notability asserted either through any sources independent of the topic Deletion of Second Robotech War WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9803 20727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lac Terant User:Rorshacma 20:43, 30 August 2019 (UTC) delete """The current sources do nothing but establish the lake's existence and location, and does nothing to demonstrate notability. I have also been unable to locate any additional sources that go beyond this. Per , natural features are notable """"provided information beyond statistics and coordinates is known to exist"""", which does not appear to be the case with this lake. As an alternative, I would not be opposed if this were redirected to Lac-Walker, Quebec instead""" Deletion of Lac Terant WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9804 13594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exploding bird User:Nsk92 04:59, 4 August 2008 (UTC) delete The nom is correct: the article is filled with |OR and the topic does not appear to exist as a coherent subject discussed by any |reliable sources as a distinct subject Deletion of Exploding bird WP:OR||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
9805 18440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Afterburner (modification kit) User:Thibbs 17:13, 1 July 2009 (UTC) keep per ThaddeusB: significant Reliable Source coverage is apparent from brief |Google test Deletion of Afterburner (modification kit) WP:GOOGLE Wikipedia:Search engine test 38
9806 11027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apple Tree Railway User:Snigbrook 15:09, 18 June 2008 (UTC) delete railway does not exist, the information is about a model railway which fails the notability criteria due to lack of |reliable sources Deletion of Apple Tree Railway WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9807 19667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kittens At Play User:Craftyminion 00:01, 30 October 2009 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Kittens At Play WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9808 14474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emily Atack User:Decltype 11:38, 30 April 2009 (UTC) delete The nom sums it up for . No indication that the subject meets either Deletion of Emily Atack WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9809 14737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whose Line Is It Anyway? (U.S. TV series) User:Mandsford 16:40, 28 March 2010 (UTC) keep Why was this nominated anyway? Ya think we merge the two articles about ''The Office'' as well? on this one Deletion of Whose Line Is It Anyway? (U.S. TV series) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
9810 17617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ken Macklin (2nd nomination) User:Kusma 13:28, 19 October 2015 (UTC) comment I declined speedy deletion of the article as a #G4 repost as the previous AfD was ages ago and the subject has done some additional work since then. However, all of the mentions seem to be minor, and insufficient to properly write a biography. So unless further secondary sources can be found, deletion is probably the best option (just not ''speedy'' deletion Deletion of Ken Macklin (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9811 59 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Doğu Gözaçan """Kullanıcı:dbl2010dbl2010""" 02:24, 19 Mayıs 2006 (UTC) delete Bkz: Doğu Gözaçan'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Vikipedi ne değildir Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9812 3289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emsworth Cricket Club User:Edison 21:20, 29 January 2011 (UTC) delete Amateur sports club which got some routine local coverage over the centuries. Does not satisfy Deletion of Emsworth Cricket Club WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9813 4059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mountain View Cur (2nd nomination) User:Eduemoni 03:47, 3 February 2013 (UTC) delete It seems that the article's main author is involved with and also article does not meet general notability guideline Deletion of Mountain View Cur (2nd nomination) WP:SPS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9814 6309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Martin & Co User:TheSpecialUser 15:30, 30 May 2012 (UTC) keep it needs work, but there are enough , thus passes . The company is notable enough Deletion of James Martin & Co WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9815 17096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Signal (podcast) User:SportingFlyer 13:23, 26 June 2021 (UTC) delete Looked through the sources and like nom, I don't see how this passes . No issue with a merge Deletion of The Signal (podcast) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9816 14535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Niko Omilana User:Bondegezou 19:23, 2 May 2021 (UTC) delete RS coverage is of his mayoral candidacy. As per , people who are only candidates and whose RS coverage is for their candidacy are better dealt with under the election article and are not independently notable Deletion of Niko Omilana WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9817 17068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Softasking [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']] 10:47, 22 March 2006 (UTC) delete Non-notable company, refers. No claims to notability in article Deletion of Softasking WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9818 15918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amir bizzle User:Spiderone 19:01, 3 April 2021 (UTC) delete clear , possible spam Deletion of Amir bizzle WP:A7||WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9819 13035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raam Punjabi User:MichaelQSchmidt 23:45, 27 May 2010 (UTC) keep Sorry Kittybrewster, but this indivdual has great notability in Indonesia,http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Raam+Punjabi%22+source%3A%22-newswire%22+source%3A%22-wire%22+source%3A%22-presswire%22+source%3A%22-PR%22+source%3A%22-press%22+source%3A%22-release%22+source%3A%22-wikipedia%22&btnG=Search+Archives&scoring=ahttp://books.google.com/books?as_brr=0&as_pub=-icon&q=%22Raam+Punjabi%22 and notability in Indonesia is plenty good enough for en.Wikipedia. The project will benefit by |this article's expansion and sourcing through regular editing... but not through its deletion Deletion of Raam Punjabi WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9820 1589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lord Castrianni/Lord of Kensington (2007 creation) User:Eddie 03:45, 23 June 2007 (UTC) delete as omplete Bollocks Deletion of Lord Castrianni/Lord of Kensington (2007 creation) WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
9821 1373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cold Wars (gaming) User:SportingFlyer 05:29, 13 September 2018 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Cold Wars (gaming) WP:NEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9822 19394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Justin Bieber on Twitter User:Dennis 20:50, 30 June 2012 (UTC) delete """Per , """"Wikipedia articles are not: A complete exposition of all possible details. Rather, an article is a summary of accepted knowledge regarding its subject"""". Statements like """"Most fans respond favorably when he retweets their messages"""" and """"Bieber utilizes the tag #RandomTwitterHour in order to let his fans know he is making random comments"""" are not """"knowledge"""". And they are not """"accepted knowledge"""" by recognized experts. Reading an encyclopedia article should not result in filling your head with nothings and banalities. Reading an encyclopedia article should enrich your mind in some way, and not be an utter waste of your time. You should know more after you have read an encyclopedia article""" Deletion of Justin Bieber on Twitter WP:NOTEVERYTHING Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9823 1135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/تفاحتة User:PamD 18:54, 13 August 2012 (UTC) merge """using a title transliterated into roman alphabet, per : """"Names not originally in a Latin alphabet, as with Greek, Chinese or Russian, must be transliterated into characters generally intelligible to literate speakers of English""" Deletion of تفاحتة WP:UE Wikipedia:Article titles 75
9824 10821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicole Müller (linguist) User:Xxanthippe 21:37, 16 December 2016 (UTC) keep May just pass rof#C1 with a GS h-index of 14 and rof#C5 Deletion of Nicole Müller (linguist) WP:P||WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
9825 16993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruthless (Ace Hood album) User:Dylan620 10:46, 12 April 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. Only source is YouTube, which we all know is an |unreliable source Deletion of Ruthless (Ace Hood album) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9826 18155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meshup User:Wryspy 03:46, 20 September 2006 (UTC) delete this neologism per Deletion of Meshup WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9827 13770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bibhorr formula User:David 16:41, 28 February 2018 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Bibhorr formula WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
9828 12041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Business excellence user:Andrew 12:24, 8 September 2014 (UTC) keep """The topic is notable, as detailed above. The complaint that the page """"written in a subjective, essayish style"""" does not stand up as the style seems fairly bland and dispassionate. In any case, such stylistic considerations and other flaws are best addressed by ordinary editing per our |editing policy""" Deletion of Business excellence WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
9829 19090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Pugh (Conservative politician) User:Davewild 20:45, 8 March 2010 (UTC) keep I struggle to see how this can be described as a BLP1E, the article does not give undue weight to any incident and the article gives a reasonable coverage of the individual as a biography rather than centred on any one incident. I also agree with Phil Bridger that the article does pass and would happy that any such politician, who has enough coverage for us write this good an article, should be kept Deletion of David Pugh (Conservative politician) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9830 96 [[Hess AG]] (erledigt, bleibt) Benutzer:Tom_md 08:26, 21. Aug. 2012 (CEST) delete weitab von #U Löschung von Hess AG Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9831 2213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackson Junior High School User:Störm 09:37, 22 December 2017 (UTC) delete per nomination, fails Deletion of Jackson Junior High School WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9832 9336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heather Ratnage Black User:RJHall 17:45, 5 August 2012 (UTC) comment """Apart from the RAF article, there is little evidence for the notability of the """"RAF Skeleton Association"""" . Hence, to call it a prominent role is questionable. As for the above comments, I did click on the SkeletonSport web site, but did not see the subject in the pull-down menu. At this point I'm not convinced the article satisfies . The one reference is reliable but not independent. Regards""" Deletion of Heather Ratnage Black WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9833 1883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative names for USB flash drive User:DanielT5 15:48, 15 March 2007 (UTC) delete WP:N, , , and I could go on Deletion of Alternative names for USB flash drive WP:NEO||WP:ATT||WP:V Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9834 8544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hanging Perverts User:Kinu 06:11, 22 September 2010 (UTC) delete Available sources (or the lack thereof) seem to indicate this is a non-notable student film. IMDB is not a , and no significant coverage in actual reliable sources appears to be found Deletion of Hanging Perverts WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9835 14291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Air Europa Flight 41 User:WilliamJE 20:47, 16 September 2014 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Air Europa Flight 41 WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9836 18399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mullans User:Wesley 00:52, 12 August 2012 (UTC) comment WP:EURO|Project Eurovision from what I gather has gone through similar cases like this and was questioned many a time; and people were told that covers articles relating to Eurovision Song Contest participants, as the majority of them only ever participate once, with the odd handful making returns. As the contest is notable within its own right due to the grand scale of the contest and long-standing global recognition then an article relating to an artist participating in the contest would warrant an inclusion. That is the way I have interpreted it all this time based on comments/advice of others. But looking at the criterion at then this article most certainly covers points 9 and maybe even 10 in that list - and does state that at least one criterion needs to be met Deletion of The Mullans WP:BAND||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
9837 6070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antisemitism in the Labour Party User:The 04:00, 10 December 2017 (UTC) keep Per : https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/sep/27/labour-denial-antisemitism-party-dark-place ''Guardian'' http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/09/25/jeremy-corbyn-accused-having-ostrich-strategy-anti-semitism/ ''Telegraph''https://www.channel4.com/news/factcheck/factcheck-labour-and-antisemitism Channel 4 http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5048787/Scale-anti-semitism-Labour-party-revealed.html ''Daily Mail'' http://www.tabletmag.com/jewish-news-and-politics/247057/british-labour-corbyn-anti-semitism ''Tablet'' http://www.thetower.org/article/britains-labour-party-tries-to-whitewash-its-anti-semitism/ ''The Tower'' http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-41394265 ''BBC'' https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/anti-semitism-claims-hound-u-k-s-labour-party-despite-n781621 NBC https://www.ft.com/content/935cb198-a2d5-11e7-b797-b61809486fe2 ''Financial Times'' https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/top-writers-accuse-jeremy-corbyn-s-labour-party-of-antisemitism-2k9r9qnd6 ''The Times'' http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-4923670/RICHARD-LITTLEJOHN-anti-Semitism-Labour-Party.html ''Daily Mail'' https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/top-writers-accuse-jeremy-corbyn-s-labour-party-of-antisemitism-2k9r9qnd6 ''The Times'' https://news.sky.com/story/labour-could-face-brighton-conference-ban-over-anti-semitism-claims-11054721 Sky News http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/labour-activists-applaud-speaker-calling-11235449 ''The Mirror'' https://www.thejc.com/news/uk-news/baroness-chakrabarti-slams-labour-members-who-say-no-antisemitism-in-party-1.445232 ''The Jewish Chronicle'' https://www.timesofisrael.com/with-partys-lingering-anti-semitism-who-are-the-jews-running-on-britains-labour-ticket/ ''The Times of Israel'' https://www.haaretz.com/world-news/europe/1.821347 ''Haaretz'' http://www.lbc.co.uk/radio/presenters/maajid-nawaz/labour-institutionally-anti-semitic-maajid-nawaz/ LBC http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/british-jews-believe-labour-too-tolerant-of-anti-semitism_uk_599986fce4b0a2608a6ccd6f ''Huffington post Deletion of Antisemitism in the Labour Party WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9838 2663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shuai Xiaobing User:David 00:54, 20 September 2015 (UTC) delete He appears not to pass , but that may be less relevant than as he does not appear to be an academic any more. Regardless, I also didn't find any evidence that he passes GNG Deletion of Shuai Xiaobing WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9839 18064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Browser User:Hydrox 12:15, 16 April 2010 (UTC) delete as per nominator. See: #INTERNET Deletion of The Browser WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9840 12193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebel Pundit User:Tucsontammy 20:44, 17 June 2015 (UTC) keep I think that this CBS article http://chicago.cbslocal.com/2014/10/28/are-african-americans-abandoning-democratic-party/ constitutes more than a passing mention, as the article's topic is a video made by this website (Rebel Pundit). This The Hill http://thehill.com/blogs/ballot-box/senate-races/166111-indiana-senate-candidate-to-apologize-for-assault-on-conservative-blogger- article is also more than a passing mention. These two secondary sources, coupled with the others in the article, lead me to think the website meets Deletion of Rebel Pundit WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9841 1127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M2SYS Technology User:M2arman 19:24, 27 May 2008 (UTC) keep seems to meet with three valid references. I took the liberty of some copyediting. As for the nomination rationale, please provide evidence that Deletion of M2SYS Technology WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9842 20665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lugansk parliamentary republic User:Staberinde 15:52, 14 April 2014 (UTC) delete article about a country that nobody has even proclaimed yet? Just plain silly. rystalball fully applies Deletion of Lugansk parliamentary republic WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
9843 436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeepMap User:MER 16:46, 14 December 2019 (UTC) delete promotional article about an unremarkable startup. I wouldn't be surprised if this was undisclosed paid-for spam, so I've blocked the creator for Deletion of DeepMap WP:UPE Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
9844 17509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mucho Loma User:DarkGlow 09:55, 10 November 2020 (UTC) delete non-notable story arc. Per , an article for an episode should only be created once articles for the programme and its seasons are created, ''then'' notable episodes. There are a lot of articles of this kind worth having a look at deleting on Template:The Adventures of Rocky and Bullwinkle and Friends Deletion of Mucho Loma WP:EPISODE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
9845 15795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irfan Ismail (Quetta cricketer) User:Rugbyfan22 17:39, 26 February 2021 (UTC) keep Has played 2 FC and 4 List-A matches, passing him for Deletion of Irfan Ismail (Quetta cricketer) WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9846 13535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doejo User:Will 19:16, 8 February 2012 (UTC) delete """The article was created by an editor who also created an article about its founder, Phil Tadros, which was deleted and recreated several times. The same editor deleted a """"notability"""" tag from the article on spurious grounds.http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Doejo&diff=445674127&oldid=445673989 It's apparent that the editor is closely connected to the company and its founder. As for the company itself, there's only a single passing mention of it in the Proquest newspaper archive. Of the sources used in the article, most are about Tadros with just passing mentions of Doejo. The only one specifically about the company is an interview hosted on what seems to be a consulting firm's website,http://midventures.com/2010/12/10/designdevelop-holiday-tech-meetup-interview-series-doejo/ which wouldn't normally be considered a reliable source. Based on that, the company does not appear to meet the notability guideline: . """ Deletion of Doejo WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9847 19487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Between Home And Serenity User:Tevildo 20:10, 25 June 2006 (UTC) comment Copyvio from http://www.rustrecords.com/artists/betweenhomeandserenity/. That being said, the band themselves probably pass - Rust Records _seems_ to be a fairly reputable indie publisher Deletion of Between Home And Serenity WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9848 2291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Place of power User:Andy 02:53, 11 January 2017 (UTC) keep """Jytdog and QuackGuru should remember than MEDRS does not apply here. Perhaps this is all aery-faery nonsense, but it is also otable nonsense, believed by many people for thousands of years and written about by a good many of them. In particular, written about them since the coincidence of the 1920s boom in post-WWI English spiritualism and the rise of the private motor car for rural touring. Alfred Watkins and Julian Cope would be two obvious starting points for English or British and US sites. Perhaps Copey will follow ''Japrocksampler'' with a third volume of ''The Modern Antiquarian|The Japanese Antiquarian'', as that's a country rife with such sites and hardly discussed in Western, English language sources. There are plenty of sources for this topic, even limiting to pre-internet printed sources, so I fail to see why some (perhaps unwise) use of """"spam sites"""" changes this""" Deletion of Place of power WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9849 2236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Ellis User:BrownHairedGirl 11:56, 25 November 2007 (UTC) delete no evidence of substantial coverage in any independent sources, let alone reliable sources, as required by Deletion of Joshua Ellis WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9850 21628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DIE (band) User:Esradekan 05:38, 26 September 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability per Deletion of DIE (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9851 12201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omarius Hines User:PCN02WPS 13:35, 18 May 2019 (UTC) keep subject passes per the significant coverage presented by Cbl62 Deletion of Omarius Hines WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9852 17077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Killing My Darlings User:Nomoskedasticity 19:37, 12 May 2008 (UTC) delete straightforward failure to satisfy Deletion of Killing My Darlings WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9853 4289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How NOT to steal a SideKick 2 User:Blue520 09:29, 9 June 2006 (UTC) delete verifiability problems / Deletion of How NOT to steal a SideKick 2 WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9854 13734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Periannan Senapathy User:Hrafn 06:53, 21 April 2011 (UTC) delete """fails both & . No reliable third party sources cited in article, and the only one I could find elsewhere was a 25yo ''New Scientist'' article. The only argument presented to date, that of citations, is malformed as (i) ''mere citation'' is not """"significant coverage"""" & (ii) Senapathy is merely the co-author of the exceptionally highly cited article listed in Silver seren's search. I would further point out that, unlike reliable sources substantiating that """"the person's research has made significant impact in their scholarly discipline, broadly construed"""", which is what (1) ''explicitly'' demands, and which is ''wholly'' lacking, WP:OR conjectures based upon ''mere citations'' do not provide any usable content for inclusion in the article""" Deletion of Periannan Senapathy WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9855 2723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Recombinant text User:SeanMD80 03:46, 14 January 2008 (UTC) delete with regret. , Deletion of Recombinant text WP:OR||WP:COI Wikipedia:No original research 65
9856 8223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kohei Tezuka User:GiantSnowman 14:36, 17 December 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Kohei Tezuka WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9857 839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allen B. Reed User:Philafrenzy 11:10, 7 November 2016 (UTC) keep """The article has quite a lot of background material that is not about Reed and tends more to obscure him than enlighten us about his service. The article would be stronger if it was shorter in fact, but there is no doubt in my mind that he easily meets the . The senior commands he held, the Navy Cross, """"Captain Reed Day"""" all help too. I don't believe WP:NOTMEMORIAL is intended for cases like this""" Deletion of Allen B. Reed WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9858 4891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BMB Group User:Top 13:36, 9 November 2010 (UTC) keep per DGG above. I've cleaned up some of the worst of the already, but it needs more: I'll have a bash at that today. It will need occasional checking and de-spamification if it's kept, as there's an evident by its creator Deletion of BMB Group WP:PROMO||WP:COI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9859 17484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aura (song) User:Lankiveil 07:31, 20 October 2013 (UTC) keep Billboard chart would mean that it now passes Deletion of Aura (song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9860 18717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Out from Under (Song) User:Youngamerican 14:49, 15 August 2009 (UTC) merge or '''Delete'''. If anything from the article would improve Circus (Britney Spears album), merge into that article. If not, delete as a failure of and an unlikely search term due to the parenthesis Deletion of Out from Under (Song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9861 14987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Final Boss (electronic sports team) User:Teancum 12:36, 4 August 2011 (UTC) delete Or if nothing else trim down the obvious, excessive problem this and pretty much all other eSports team articles have Deletion of Final Boss (electronic sports team) WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
9862 14424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kingdom of Elleore User:RadioFan 13:25, 7 January 2012 (UTC) keep sufficiently referenced to meet Deletion of Kingdom of Elleore WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9863 11468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dee Watkins User:MrFish 19:48, 7 April 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Dee Watkins WP:BIO||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9864 3547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brock Lichthardt User:LACaliNYC 22:03, 29 July 2018 (UTC) delete Clearly fails the , and Deletion of Brock Lichthardt WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9865 9123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Merchants (video game) User:K 03:20, 30 August 2016 (UTC) delete per ; reads like something you would find on the cover of the DVD. I cannot local any better sources Deletion of Merchants (video game) WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9866 2848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roger Gold (music executive) User:The 10:30, 28 May 2019 (UTC) delete since subject fails Deletion of Roger Gold (music executive) WP:NCREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9867 21445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Modeneis - SouJava Leader User:Altered 15:12, 4 January 2013 (UTC) delete per nomination. He sounds like quite a cool guy, but there's no assertion of notability per , or . No significant coverage online in eliable sources Deletion of Thomas Modeneis - SouJava Leader WP:AUTHOR||WP:BIO||WP:ACADEMIC||WP:R Wikipedia:Notability 77
9868 8570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blake Ridder (2nd nomination) User:Perryprog 23:45, 6 February 2021 (UTC) delete sources aren't really significant coverage, and even it was, would probably apply. The now-deleted references look like PR/SEO spam Deletion of Blake Ridder (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
9869 7808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grae Worster User:XOR 15:29, 16 February 2018 (UTC) keep Passes #C1 with a GS h-index of 42 and #C3 as a Fellow of the APS Deletion of Grae Worster WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9870 9619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trakia blackout of 2013 User:CodeCat 15:17, 4 October 2013 (UTC) keep I don't see anything wrong with this topic and I don't see how applies. None of the points listed on that page seem to apply to the article, so how can it be used as a deletion reason. How is an event that affected millions of people for two hours not notable Deletion of Trakia blackout of 2013 WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9871 697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss International (USA) User:Utcursch 12:45, 22 February 2007 (UTC) delete unless |reliable sources are provided to establish notability. As of now, I don't see any references or links that indicate enough notability Deletion of Miss International (USA) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9872 5311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Miller (entertainer) User:The 01:48, 19 September 2016 (UTC) keep """The article is different in a number of ways from the deleted """"Filthy Frank"""" page, so I don't believe the previous deletion discussion can entirely apply to this article. The current article is written in a much better manner, the only issue is lacking a few citations, and that's mainly because he prefers to keep his personal life hidden, instead having most of the fame being attributed to his fictional alias. The individual himself does fall into the requirements of #Entertainers, as he has quite large cult following, and has influenced modern pop culture more-so than the average YouTuber. It would be foolish to delete this article, he will just become more notable and a discussion about having the article will arise in a year""" Deletion of George Miller (entertainer) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
9873 14779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cocomelon – Nursery Rhymes User:XOR 20:34, 9 August 2019 (UTC) delete """Unscrupulous paid editing; burn it to the ground. It ''might'' be possible to write a decent article using |reliable sources like https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/talkingtech/2019/06/22/nursery-rhymes-i-toy-story-porn-youtube-thats-kid-problem/1529724001/https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/mbznpy/youtubers-are-fighting-algorithms-to-make-good-content-for-kids, but where decent sources exist, they seem to discuss """"Kids YouTube"""" as a whole, rather than any particular channel. This page is a https://www.wired.com/story/youtube-kid-troubles-kids-core-audience/ shady and secretive company trying to manage its own reputation by violating Wikipedia policy. It needs to go""" Deletion of Cocomelon – Nursery Rhymes WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9874 5748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ocean Shores (Hong Kong) User:Noleander 03:02, 1 September 2011 (UTC) delete My research does not show sufficient ''independent'' sources that demonstrate notability. User Hmains raises a good point about the existence of 120 WP articles on similar buildings in Hong Kong, but that doesn't make ''this'' article notable (in fact, it just tells me that there are a lot of active WP editors in Hong Kong :-) ther stuff exists and all that Deletion of Ocean Shores (Hong Kong) WP:O Wikipedia:Orphan 47
9875 6230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kanakorn Pianchana User:Less 10:30, 28 February 2020 (UTC) delete Fails as well as meets all three criteria for - as stated in the nomination above Deletion of Kanakorn Pianchana WP:JUDGE||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
9876 18505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kristoffer Infante User:Ad 17:03, 16 August 2014 (UTC) delete Subject fails . A Google did not produce anything that rings the notability bell Deletion of Kristoffer Infante WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
9877 16376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Pino User:Drm310 14:49, 1 September 2017 (UTC) delete WP:AUTOBIO, not enough coverage in |third-party sources to meet Deletion of Nick Pino WP:IS||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9878 13803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magistrati User:Nenyedi 02:06, 17 August 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Magistrati WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9879 17389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Confruition User:BrownHairedGirl 07:53, 3 August 2006 (UTC) delete neologism, , etc Deletion of Confruition WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
9880 18035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hero's 10 User:BusterD 19:58, 19 November 2011 (UTC) delete Per , , and . Meets no section of . Not all sporting events are notable. Zero sources independent of the subject Deletion of Hero's 10 WP:RECENTISM||WP:NOTNEWSPAPER||WP:GNG||WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Recentism 10
9881 21658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bailey Pickett User:Davey2010 15:12, 6 November 2013 (UTC) keep per AussieLegend - The character '''is''' notable, AFD'ing a page per is bad faith Deletion of Bailey Pickett WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9882 4149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Altruism Society User:WikiDan61 19:52, 10 September 2014 (UTC) delete as a likely |hoax. Guidestar has no listing of any such organization, which indicates they have never filed a single federal non-profit tax return Deletion of The Altruism Society WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
9883 16228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Game (Life) User:Jamie 13:18, 28 October 2007 (UTC) comment as the original articles have since been deleted, I am not willing to contest them through a DRV as I do not know the content and cited sources, and so cannot positively comment on them. I was also unaware that this article had previously been created, hence the creation of this article. I would like to, through whatever process necessary, motion that this article replace the original one that was deleted as it has verifiable and well-spread sources. I understand that this is out-of-process, but would like to find out what the process is to either get the article restored in some way so that we can see what it originally stated, or have this article processed as a new, non-recreation so that the #G4 infringement can be excluded Deletion of The Game (Life) WP:SPEEDY Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9884 10779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/University of Sheffield Union of Students User:TheIslander 23:33, 9 December 2007 (UTC) comment """I did consider creating one AfD for the lot, but wasn't sure, and as per the guidelines for creating AfD's """"''...if you are unsure of whether to bundle an article or not, do not''"""". You state """"''...each student union is run in a different way and have different policies''"""". Well, not really. Granted there are slight variations here and there, and there are one or two unions that are just run in a completely different mannor that probably are notable enough for their own article, but on the whole all SUs are pretty much the same. There's pretty much nothing that differentiates one SU from the next, and I've made very sure that I've only nominated those that don't appear to have anything particularly notable about them. There are others that I may nominate, depending on the outcome of these few, but equally there are others that I won't nominate, 'cause I feel that they are notable enough to satisfy """ Deletion of University of Sheffield Union of Students WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9885 19356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shabdaguchha User:Niaz 10:26, 15 May 2011 (UTC) delete as per . This article seems to me an indirect self-promoting approach of the author himself Deletion of Shabdaguchha WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9886 5936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kia Jam User:FOARP 08:52, 14 November 2019 (UTC) delete WP:BLP1E is not a stand-alone , but typically a reason to rename/redirect/merge articles about the person into the article covering the event they are notable for. It should only result in straight deletion where the event you would otherwise rename/redirect to is itself not notable. In this case, the event (the fraud case) appears to be potentially not notable due to lack of evidence of impact (it was covered in May 2019 but not since) meaning this fails , and is possibly also a fail. As such there is no event to merge to. If this guy goes any further in the film-production business we may end up recreating this article, but for the moment we've got simple bare-mentions of him producing a single film in a couple of trade magazine articles Deletion of Kia Jam WP:DELREASON||WP:LASTING||WP:NEVENT||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9887 173 [[Kiddyspace Gütesiegel]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:AFBorchert 07:32, 6. Aug. 2014 (CEST) delete Kasten| Das Anliegen des Vereins ist sicherlich sehr anerkennenswert. Dessen ungeachtet liest sich der Artikel noch wie ein eigener Webauftritt und nicht wie ein enzyklopädischer Artikel. Der gesamte Artikel ist vollkommen unbelegt (siehe ), nur zwei Presse- und ein Fernsehbeitrag sind verlinkt, abgesehen von dem Link zu dem Verein. Unabhängige Außenansichten des Vereins sind nicht dargestellt. Essentielle Informationen, die insbesondere die Beurteilung der WP:RK#Vereine, Verbände, Netzwerke und Bürgerinitiativen|Relevanz erlauben würden, fehlen. Der Verein scheint auch noch recht jung zu sein und wurde womöglich erst 2013 gegründet (im Artikel stand nichts dazu). Ebenso wird die geographische Ausbreitung nicht dargestellt, momentan scheint das primär den Wiener Raum zu betreffen. In der Diskussion kam der Vorschlag, den Artikel ggf. in den Hilfe:Benutzernamensraum|Benutzernamensraum zu verschieben. Das kann gerne passieren, erfordert aber eine Hilfe:Benutzerkonto anlegen|Anmeldung, da der Artikel bislang unangemeldet geschrieben worden ist Löschung von Kiddyspace Gütesiegel Wikipedia:BLG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9888 6720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rondae Hollis-Jefferson User:Rikster2 13:28, 20 June 2015 (UTC) keep he absolutely meets based on his college career and the funny thing is that by the time this AfD takes his course he will have already been drafted in the first round of the NBA draft, for which he is a lock. That isn't my reason to keep, but I am pointing it out because only on Wikipedia would people push to delete an article to have it re-created a day or two later Deletion of Rondae Hollis-Jefferson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9889 1588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iceland in popular culture User:O 01:59, 17 July 2007 (UTC) delete In addition to , #IINFO|Wikipedia isn't an indiscriminate collection of information, which this article clearly is. It's also unsourced, as a number of people have already said. ({{fullurl:User talk:O|action=edit§ion=new}} →O Deletion of Iceland in popular culture WP:TRIVIA||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
9890 15175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 Roanoke Obama campaign speech User:LaMenta3 01:43, 15 August 2012 (UTC) delete or '''merge''' to Barack Obama presidential campaign, 2012 per many arguments above as a |POV fork and |coverage of a single, minor event that |was only covered immediately following the event Deletion of 2012 Roanoke Obama campaign speech WP:POVFORK||WP:NOTNEWSPAPER||WP:PERSISTENCE Wikipedia:Content forking 33
9891 20419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yurihonjo hinakaido [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 15:21, 17 March 2009 (UTC) comment I originally tagged as G11, especially because the material close to the bottom suggests that the article that it was created as promotion, notable or not. I have tagged as {{tl|advertisement}} and removed that last section as |spam; I'll leave for the community to do whatever to the rest Deletion of Yurihonjo hinakaido WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
9892 8425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faith Nkesti User:Atlantic306 21:45, 8 January 2020 (UTC) keep as has significant coverage in multiple reliable sources such as Cosmopolitan, Times Live, Standard (Africa), so passes and deserves to be kept, imv Deletion of Faith Nkesti WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9893 8189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syed Mohi uddin Ahmad Al- Hasani Wal Hussaini Ajmeri User:Optakeover 12:45, 24 September 2016 (UTC) delete as per #A7|A7 and #G4|G4. Also I have tagged the article for speedy deletion already Deletion of Syed Mohi uddin Ahmad Al- Hasani Wal Hussaini Ajmeri WP:CSD||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
9894 15505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AWH Engineering College User:Muhandes 07:45, 5 April 2021 (UTC) merge to APJ Abdul Kalam Technological University, the affiliating university, as is the common practice with non-notable affiliated colleges. Fails and Deletion of AWH Engineering College WP:NORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9895 14289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people speculated to have Asperger's Syndrome User:Crotalus 00:15, 15 April 2007 (UTC) delete no sources, blatantly violates , , and Deletion of List of people speculated to have Asperger's Syndrome WP:NOT||WP:NOR||WP:V Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9896 20447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Purely functional User:Diego 17:26, 28 July 2016 (UTC) merge to Referential transparency (P.S. or to Pure function) per . While there may be some nuances making them separate concepts, developers interested in the subject will be best served by reading about both concepts in the same page, as referential transparency is the primary benefit of using purely functional languages; and there's simply not enough context in this stub to properly explain the concept Deletion of Purely functional WP:PAGEDECIDE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9897 7723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sekute User:Blanchardb 21:50, 19 April 2010 (UTC) comment It has become apparent, from http://korporatekutie.blogspot.com/ this page, of which the article is a copyvio, that the neologism is a trademark, thereby making the article's very existence a violation of our policy on |promotional material. --''' Blanchardb''' Deletion of Sekute WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
9898 16544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zierzow User:Dhartung 06:39, 7 October 2007 (UTC) keep per , real place. http://www.amt-grabow.de/verzeichnis/objekt.php?mandat=19025 website http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zierzow de wiki Deletion of Zierzow WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
9899 7405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darren Isaiah User:Pharaoh 14:17, 27 February 2020 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Darren Isaiah WP:GNG||WP:NMUSICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9900 17886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shurpanakha User:onel5969 12:56, 29 December 2020 (UTC) keep sourcing is enough to meet Deletion of Shurpanakha WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9901 5525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pedro Scuro User:power 23:41, 29 January 2018 (UTC) delete doesn't appear to meet , which is the SNG that appears to be relevant. The article is a disaster and the only references (in a biography) are to scholarly papers by him and his associates Deletion of Pedro Scuro WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9902 9608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leo Smith (footballer, born 1998) User:GiantSnowman 20:28, 25 January 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Leo Smith (footballer, born 1998) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9903 14946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Casper TNG User:doomsdayer520 18:43, 13 February 2020 (UTC) delete """I acknowledge the previous voter's stance on criminal notoriety, but I lean toward , which states that a person is not notable """"If reliable sources cover the person only in the context of a single event"""" and """"If that person otherwise remains, and is likely to remain, a low-profile individual."""" This rapper was only in the news for one arrest (though it was a big one). Meanwhile his music has been largely ignored by the media, and most of the article's current music-related sources have him listed very briefly as a guest in someone else's work. His own music has not achieved |significant and reliable coverage, and the media coverage he really has achieved is about one time he got caught for acting stupid""" Deletion of Casper TNG WP:BLP1E||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
9904 14979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beaver Creek Elementary School User:Kingturtle 17:53, 15 November 2007 (UTC) keep WP:N & discuss this explicitly. Schools are notable Deletion of Beaver Creek Elementary School WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9905 199 [[Die Unterwasserstädte]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Magiers NONE keep """Kasten|1= gemäß Emeritus und in der Hoffnung auf """"Entschwurbelung"""" durch nfu-peng. Relevanz nach #Bücher sehe ich durch die zwei letzten Punkte gegeben (wesentliche Etappe des Autors, die Nachauflagen zeigen auch einen längerfristigen Erfolg, sowie die Bedeutung für zumindest die rumänische Sci-Fi). Dazu kommt einige Wahrnehmung in Sekundärliteratur. Der Artikel ist ja auch offensichtlich kompetent geschrieben. Er krankt halt daran, dass die Analysen nicht ausreichend mit Sekundärliteratur belegt sind. Ein Überarbeitungsbaustein ist sicher angebracht, zur Not kann man die interpretativen Stellen entfernen, ganz löschen muss man den Artikel deswegen aber nicht. Gruß""" Löschung von Die Unterwasserstädte Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9906 10299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of American television actresses User:Northamerica1000 01:36, 14 January 2014 (UTC) keep """per , """"It is neither improper nor uncommon to simultaneously have a category, a list, and a navigation template which all cover the same topic. These redundant systems of organizing information are considered to be complementary, not inappropriately duplicative. Furthermore, arguing that a category duplicates a list (or vice versa) at a deletion discussion is not a valid reason for deletion and should be avoided""" Deletion of List of American television actresses WP:NOTDUP Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
9907 6619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Priyanka Panchal User:Atlantic306 18:28, 7 June 2016 (UTC) keep as shown by the referenced Deccan Chronicle seems to have had enough prominent roles to generate coverage for to be passed Deletion of Priyanka Panchal WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9908 15151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Île de Susee User:Bearcat 01:34, 5 August 2017 (UTC) delete """Per , every geographical feature on the planet does not automatically qualify for a Wikipedia article just because it exists — we do ''not'' keep an article about every island, every lake, every hill, every pond, every river, every road, that ''exists'', but only about ''notable'' geographic features. What we require is |reliable source coverage ''about'' it, not just its location on Google Maps and a |self-published blog by whatever random person decided to name it themselves — and no, that coverage can't result from a directly affiliated person ''lobbying'' media outlets to cover it, either, but has to result from media ''organically'' paying it attention ''independently'' of a PR campaign. But literally the only acceptable reliable source present here is just supporting a very general statement about the nature of Canadian-American relations, not any content about the island. None of this is even close to enough to deem this notable. ''If'', and that's a very big ''if'', it someday ''does'' occasion a Canada-US border dispute of the type claimed here, ''then'' there may be grounds for a Wikipedia article — but the case for that will depend on """"an actual controversy actually happens for real"""", not """"one could theoretically happen in the future because reasons that are claimed here but not actually sourced as true"""". Stick to your blog, because nothing here makes this appropriate for inclusion in an encyclopedia""" Deletion of Île de Susee WP:GEOLAND||WP:RS||WP:SELFPUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
9909 8186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Regina Davis User:Rhododendrites 14:04, 13 September 2016 (UTC) merge to Black Panther Party#1977–82, where I just https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Black_Panther_Party&type=revision&diff=739227280&oldid=739035052 added Davis's significance to the history of that subject (so, sort of, '''Merge'''). Given it was the reason Brown left, and Brown's significance in the history of the organization, it seemed good to include there. I looked for more to justify a stand-alone article but just don't see it. I see statements that she was a leader in the BP's Oakland school, but very little detail. Mostly it's just the tragedy of her being beaten and how that affected Brown. Even if there's a weak case for (though it would be very weak), it seems and would apply. because while she clearly did a lot more, that's what we have sources about. &mdash Deletion of Regina Davis WP:BIO||WP:VICTIM||WP:NOPAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9910 10276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WayForward Technologies User:Bearian 13:46, 21 May 2008 (UTC) delete Its games may have been reviewed, but I do not see how this |corporation is in any way notable, which is not inherited. Am I missing something Deletion of WayForward Technologies WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9911 10895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bristol Commons User:Gorkymalorki 06:16, 30 July 2007 (UTC) delete Violates Deletion of Bristol Commons WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9912 11450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rodrigo Montt Swett User:Tnxman307 20:00, 16 June 2009 (UTC) delete Non-notable |politician, but if he is elected, article can be recreated Deletion of Rodrigo Montt Swett WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
9913 17329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bonerphonic User:Tivedshambo 09:37, 19 February 2008 (UTC) delete Neologism, or possibly |made up — Deletion of Bonerphonic WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
9914 11669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/That Handsome Devil User:Exerda 18:34, 6 August 2007 (UTC) comment I'm fairly neutral on the issue. They do seem to meet criteria #10 of , though that is, as far as I can tell, their sole claim of notability--which is weak for a standalone article. I had been hoping others would have come up with more info by now, but no one has come forward with any useful, verifiable info Deletion of That Handsome Devil WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9915 348 [[Von Engeln und Schweinen]] (bleibt) 81.173.169.225|81.173.169.225]] 11:02, 24. Jan. 2012 (CET NONE delete Meyer mag relevant sein, das Album ist es in dieser Form laut #MA nicht. 7 Tage zum Ausbau, sonst . Löschung von Von Engeln und Schweinen Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
9916 1189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Call Me Lightning User:Chubbles 05:31, 9 September 2007 (UTC) keep Meets Criterion 5 of by the discography alone, and I don't see why I have to add anything else to keep it from being speedied. Nevertheless, I added three reviews by top-flight press agencies. If you want more, I'll go find them Deletion of Call Me Lightning WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9917 17687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Disney films set in London User:Useight 05:46, 31 July 2007 (UTC) delete as |trivia, loosely-associated list, and intersection of two unrelated topics Deletion of List of Disney films set in London WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
9918 1601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jewbook User:E 16:55, 27 November 2018 (UTC) delete this online chat group fails Deletion of Jewbook WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9919 8719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Web Boxing League User:Brighterorange 22:50, 18 July 2007 (UTC) delete without independent reliable sources to establish notability. 2000 players a week isn't even a . — Deletion of Web Boxing League WP:BIGNUMBER Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9920 13950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chaitanya Giri User:Artene50 07:38, 25 December 2012 (UTC) delete Fails right at the start Deletion of Chaitanya Giri WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9921 17930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Una Healy User:GaGaOohLaLa 21:54, 30 November 2009 (UTC) comment """Not that I'm advocating your violation, but Ringo Starr is also a solo artist, MBE and actor. There is a clear sense of through these """"keep"""" !votes""" Deletion of Una Healy WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9922 20873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saabs in popular culture User:Corvus 18:07, 24 October 2007 (UTC) delete What isn't unsourced is sourced with non-reliable sources. Violates , and Deletion of Saabs in popular culture WP:OR||WP:V||WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:No original research 65
9923 18818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Archery at the 2016 Sukma Games User:Renata3 02:33, 16 January 2017 (UTC) delete per . Proliferation of sports statistics cruft that's best left to dedicated databases Deletion of Archery at the 2016 Sukma Games WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9924 12643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Going up Scalp User:Bucketsofg 14:22, 3 July 2007 (UTC) delete as failing and neologism Deletion of Going up Scalp WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
9925 13958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Entitlementia User:Scorpiondollprincess 20:12, 20 July 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Violates , , , and Deletion of Entitlementia WP:V||WP:OR||WP:NPOV||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9926 15698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Futuregrail User:MER 04:05, 23 December 2006 (UTC) delete """being """"|a seemingly mythical operation developed over fifteen years by someone called Sean Gallacher"""" doesn't help your cause. So tagged""" Deletion of Futuregrail WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
9927 5539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wheelie (Transformers) (2nd nomination) User:Snottywong 17:59, 31 August 2010 (UTC) delete Plenty of sources, except none of them are |reliable, and none of them establish the notability of this fictional character. Not notable enough for its own article. All of these transformers articles need to be merged into a list article Deletion of Wheelie (Transformers) (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9928 4015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergei Aleksandrovich Andreyev User:Pharaoh 09:08, 16 August 2016 (UTC) keep passes ooty .Note Russian Second Division or Russian Professional Football League is a fully Professional league as per PL Deletion of Sergei Aleksandrovich Andreyev WP:F||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Non-free content 99
9929 17643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Jason Gage User:Ohnoitsjamie 15:44, 19 September 2012 (UTC) delete Does not meet notability criteria Deletion of Murder of Jason Gage WP:CRIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
9930 18791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Upper Beeding F.C. User:HornetMike 01:44, 25 December 2006 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Upper Beeding F.C. WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9931 1754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twenty One Pilots (album by Twenty One Pilots) User:Sergecross73 16:45, 8 March 2017 (UTC) comment Similar to what I said in the last AFD, I think it possible that this album be comparable to Bleach (Nirvana album), where it failed to chart in its initial release and would have probably failed an AFD had Wikipedia existed in 1990, but went on to be very notable and sales success after the band had a later album release that was massively successful and won all sorts of awards. It seems such a scenario is very possible with Twenty One Pilots, with their recent platinum album and multiple Grammy Award wins. However, |I'm not sure we're there yet. Is right now comparable to 1990's Nirvana or 1995's Nirvana? My main hang up is that we're still unable to find a single album review or RS that covers ''this album'' in detail, correct Deletion of Twenty One Pilots (album by Twenty One Pilots) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
9932 2478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ultraviolet Sound User:Jo7hs2 21:32, 27 December 2008 (UTC) delete Fails notability requirements Deletion of Ultraviolet Sound WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
9933 1771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Rohingya villages User:Spiderone 23:31, 10 February 2017 (UTC) delete original research and fails anyway Deletion of List of Rohingya villages WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9934 10293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danielle Batist User:Esquivalience 22:40, 6 April 2015 (UTC) delete fails (only passing mentions and quotes in sources), and the subject has not created or contributed significantly to a ''significant'' work that is featured in a |independent book or feature-length film, or multiple independent periodical articles or reviews. nor does the subject meet any other criteria Deletion of Danielle Batist WP:BASIC||WP:JOURNALIST||WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
9935 9594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Information metabolism User:Niteshift36 15:55, 27 June 2009 (UTC) delete Agree is it a Deletion of Information metabolism WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
9936 11038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LGBT history in... User:Lugnuts 09:47, 14 February 2014 (UTC) keep """None of the articles are actually tagged for deletion. I've asked the nom to discuss the articles on the relevant talkpages, but has refused to do so. There ''may'' be some overlap, but these are different articles from the LGBT rights articles. A good example is how LGBT rights in Finland is different from LGBT history in Finland. These stubs have been created to populate the redlinks in the template {{Europe topic|LGBT history in}}, which already had half-a-dozen or so blue links before I started creating these articles. Finally, per , '''1.If the article can be fixed through normal editing, then it is not a candidate for AfD.''' All these article can be expanded to include a detailed timeline for the country it relates to. '''At worst''' redirect to the """"rights"""" article as a possible redirect""" Deletion of LGBT history in... WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9937 5294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brentyn Milverton (2nd nomination) User:LibStar 11:03, 29 May 2010 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Brentyn Milverton (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9938 21873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Brown (musician) User:Can 20:28, 25 March 2006 (UTC) delete as per Dbtfz, does not appear to meet guidelines Deletion of Craig Brown (musician) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9939 12826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LGFG Fashion House User:HighKing 12:53, 31 March 2021 (UTC) delete """I am unable to locate any deep or significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, references to date fail the criteria for establishing notability. The coverage for the """"shirt incident"""" provides no in-depth details on the company, fails CORPDEPTH. Topic therefore fails """ Deletion of LGFG Fashion House WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9940 13852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alsamarketing User:AllyD 09:02, 16 December 2013 (UTC) delete I am finding no substantial coverage of this firm. Fails Deletion of Alsamarketing :WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
9941 15187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hugo Robl User:Mandsford 15:38, 12 December 2010 (UTC) comment I'm wondering where he played in 1977, 1978 and 1979. Obviously, sitting on the bench of a great team from 1973-76 won't qualify under . There's a middle ground between leaving him off of a list of players in a European Cup, and creating an article for him to be linked to-- mention him, no brackets, no blue-link, no red-link Deletion of Hugo Robl WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9942 20313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canada Computers User:Colin 14:43, 29 October 2019 (UTC) delete """We have a fair number of passing mentions in RS, but I don't think they add up to . Possibly a case of . As a Torontonian, it ''feels'' notable to me - I think of it as one of the more iconic businesses in the nexus of computer stores around College and Spadina. Heck, https://www.blogto.com/city/2007/09/college_spadina_computer_stores_the_real_deal/ this BlogTO post describes them as """"the godfathers of this IT stretch"""". But I have to go with policy over my personal biases""" Deletion of Canada Computers WP:SIGCOV||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
9943 2324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edi Birsan User:Colonel 15:48, 27 January 2009 (UTC) keep The topic is notable and, even it were not, there would be better alternatives to deletion per our policies and . The article just needs improvement per and so I shall do some work upon it Deletion of Edi Birsan WP:BEFORE||WP:PRESERVE||WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
9944 13707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WebCE User:AllyD 18:08, 27 January 2021 (UTC) delete An article about a company, sourced to routine listings and acquisition notices, insufficient for . There is no article on the IRMI parent company which could serve as a redirect target. Searches do not find the |evidence needed to demonstrate |notability here Deletion of WebCE :WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:RS||:WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
9945 10213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Schlossberg (2nd nomination) User:Metropolitan90 05:28, 5 February 2021 (UTC) keep """If this were the first time this article had come to AfD, I might have recommended deletion, but this article has passed AfD with a """"keep"""" twice before, and the subject hasn't gotten ''less'' notable in the intervening three years since the last """"keep"""" verdict. In fact, he has since been the subject of articles in https://people.com/tv/john-f-kennedys-grandson-jack-schlossberg-blue-bloods/ People, https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/a33636638/jack-kennedy-schlossberg-jfk-grandson-facts/ Esquire, and the https://nypost.com/2020/08/29/jfks-grandson-may-be-last-hope-for-kennedy-dynasty/ New York Post. So he seems to pass the |general notability guideline""" Deletion of Jack Schlossberg (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9946 7843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kyle Davies (soccer) User:Jimbo 15:26, 1 May 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability at and . None of the sources given are about his exploits as a player, just a |blog and references to him signing contracts and being named in a youth source, which fails OTNEWS. Plenty of players sign contracts and never play a fully-professional game. Recreate if and when he does Deletion of Kyle Davies (soccer) WP:ATHLETE||WP:N||WP:RS||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9947 2919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stefanie Rabatsch User:Smmurphy 18:18, 17 January 2017 (UTC) comment """my feeling is that the importance of Rabatsch was not based on the real person, but on Hitler's ideal of her. In fact, many sources do not give a last name, only calling her Stefanie. However, """"Stefanie"""" has, in my opinion, been the subject of many in depth analyses. I've added a short section to the article discussing these analyses based on Zalampas' discussion of the research, citing, in addition to Zalampas, Werner Maser, Robert G. L. Waite, Bradley F. Smith, and Franz Jetzinger, all very notable Hitler biographers (note, I did not find Smith's work, and only cite it as being cited by Zalampas based on |say where you got it).https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Stefanie_Rabatsch&type=revision&diff=760549930&oldid=760144592""" Deletion of Stefanie Rabatsch WP:SWYGT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9948 2246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orders of magnitude (voltage) User:XOR 19:14, 17 October 2018 (UTC) keep """As indicated above, sourcing isn't a problem. Reliable sources include listings of voltages for disparate things, so we're not doing anything conceptually novel by assembling such a list ourselves. We can keep the list from growing too outsized or indiscriminate by following an inclusion criterion of the """"all items must be blue-linked"""" form. I don't see being a real concern here, either. This article is not written as textbookish prose, """"with leading questions and systematic problem solutions as examples"""". ( doesn't apply just because a thing ''exists'' in some textbooks; that would rule out our articles including figures and bibliographies, after all.) So, weighing the concerns, I can't see anything that requires deletion, just ordinary editing""" Deletion of Orders of magnitude (voltage) WP:NOTTEXTBOOK||WP:NOTTEXTBOOK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9949 10431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of largest airlines in Europe User:Russavia 02:41, 8 October 2007 (UTC) keep Please see relevant comments in Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of largest airlines in Oceania, to which this nomination is related to. A list of statistics, each entry of which is sourced, is not nor . I would have expected Deletion of List of largest airlines in Europe WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
9950 7088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Media independence User:Sadads 12:47, 10 July 2018 (UTC) keep We include work from the US Government and not reliable sources in the public Domain (such as the 1911 Encyclopedia Britannica). I don't see how this is any different, and the content is probably more reliable from the UN, than from other sources. Rewriting, cleaning up, and incrementally removing content, is much better than Deletion of Media independence WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
9951 19722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nolan Stevens User:WilliamJE 10:29, 10 April 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Nolan Stevens WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
9952 6349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haidy Ingeborg Wittmann User:Ben 21:31, 11 October 2018 (UTC) delete Does not meet . The newly added refs in Spanish are all local news from her hometown. Deletion of Haidy Ingeborg Wittmann WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
9953 17670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucy Hannah (3rd nomination) User:Canadian 22:34, 16 January 2016 (UTC) delete """There are not sufficient non-trivial, reliable sources to satisfy the requirements of and the circumstances surrounding this """"case"""" make it obvious that they do not exist, as noted in the nomination. There is no Wikipedia policy that states that longevity is in and of itself notable, so that is not a reason to keep this article""" Deletion of Lucy Hannah (3rd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9954 20843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arsames (band) User:Spada2 09:22, 22 January 2011 (UTC) delete Low G hits with low quality as the nom refered, refrences cant pas , the article fails to meet usic Deletion of Arsames (band) WP:RS||WP:M Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9955 14446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Charlebois User:Rlendog 13:53, 27 June 2016 (UTC) delete does not meet (as Joeykai correctly explained with respect to the Austrian Hockey League) and I am not finding coverage to warrant GNG. If there are sufficient Austrian sources that I haven't found but someone is able to dig up I'd be happy to change my !vote Deletion of Joe Charlebois WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
9956 8287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Constance Gadell-Newton User:Marquardtika 02:47, 24 May 2018 (UTC) delete fails . Not notable apart from coverage of candidacy. Elected officials get pages, but they have to actually be elected first Deletion of Constance Gadell-Newton WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9957 12478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Banky Edwards (2nd nomination) User:American 04:12, 1 April 2010 (UTC) merge per Erik. Not notable enough for stand-alone, and is mostly Deletion of Banky Edwards (2nd nomination) WP:PLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9958 15578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anglicans for Life User:Reference 13:04, 21 April 2011 (UTC) keep IDONTLIKEIT AfD pretending to be RS failure. As established above, it has enough coverage in reliable sources and passes Deletion of Anglicans for Life WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9959 15207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/139th meridian west User:BryanG 05:35, 6 February 2009 (UTC) delete Other than the nice round integer value (and remember, the Prime Meridian was selected arbitrarily), there's nothing particularly notable about this line. If it was used as a border definition it'd be different, but that's not the case here. As for previous AfDs, |consensus can change and I see no compelling reason to be bound by precedent here Deletion of 139th meridian west WP:CCC Wikipedia:Consensus 78
9960 1695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fleshbeast User:FreeRangeFrog 01:05, 16 February 2009 (UTC) delete Smells like a bit of a hoax to me, that alleged film production company website is just weird. In any case, and no third-party sources to support notability Deletion of Fleshbeast WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9961 15573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Revenge (Madonna song) User:Bsimmons666 00:30, 14 October 2008 (UTC) delete of course, per Deletion of Revenge (Madonna song) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9962 16429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kahlen Rondot (2nd nomination) User:Stifle 20:53, 9 April 2008 (UTC) delete unless |citations from |reliable sources are added to comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Kahlen Rondot (2nd nomination) WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9963 2687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jessie Elaban (2nd nomination) User:Sandals1 18:53, 8 January 2019 (UTC) delete Not close to meeting or , which is what pro wrestlers fall under. Only at the development level Deletion of Jessie Elaban (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
9964 5831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radha Krishn User:Username 12:50, 2 October 2018 (UTC) delete WP:CRYSTAL and [ Deletion of Radha Krishn WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
9965 13843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of mountains of Kuwait User:Ansh666 04:43, 21 August 2013 (UTC) delete """that's not a mountain...anyhow, Geography of Kuwait mentions this: """"Highest point: unnamed location 306 m"""" - there's no sources calling it """"Mutla ridge"""", apparently. Fails """ Deletion of List of mountains of Kuwait WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
9966 14680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rob Dobrenski User:Atlantic306 14:45, 30 June 2017 (UTC) delete after more consideration as the sources are not sufficient for although Kirkus reviews is reliable and a book article may possibly be notable Deletion of Rob Dobrenski WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9967 17409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Five (comics) User:Darkknight2149 22:35, 3 November 2020 (UTC) keep Sufficient coverage, per Deletion of The Five (comics) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9968 11822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Babies User:Bmusician 07:14, 22 May 2012 (UTC) keep Has significant coverage in |reliable sources - passes and . Deletion is absolutely not required here Deletion of The Babies WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
9969 8295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Nyambe User:GiantSnowman 18:13, 13 August 2015 (UTC) keep meets ; needs improving, not deleting Deletion of Ryan Nyambe WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
9970 2980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Employee relations User:Dominus 13:43, 18 October 2012 (UTC) delete Blatantly self-promotional OR that has zero utility as the basis of a future spinoff article. Right now, it's just a and whose primary purpose is to promote the business interests of the articles creator, and based solely on one extremely unreliable source. Best to flush it entirely, and build any future spin-off article on clean soil, rather than trying to salvage and expand on anything here. No evidence that a spin-off article is justified at the present time Deletion of Employee relations WP:DICDEF||WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
9971 4234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Library Corporation (TLC) User:Cullen328 04:41, 31 May 2011 (UTC) keep The nominator admits that two or three of the references verify notability. If the topic is notable, then the solution to a promotional tone is to edit the article to reflect a |neutral point of view , not to delete an article about a notable topic. We are here to improve an encyclopedia, not to reduce it or to delete legitimate encyclopedic content Deletion of The Library Corporation (TLC) WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
9972 11690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamsaya User:CaliforniaAliBaba 00:08, 4 June 2007 (UTC) comment """Many words which are not used in the English language are nevertheless notable and are covered by multiple reliable sources. The criteria for inclusion in enwiki is //, not being """"a part of regular English lexicon""""; """"not an English word"""" is ''not'' a deletion criterion. The question here is not whether this is a local dialect word or a widely-accepted term (and even if it were just a local dialect word, the best solution would be to ''redirect'' it to the widely accept it term); the question is whether this is notable and verifiable""" Deletion of Hamsaya WP:N||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
9973 20257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arvind Ravulavaru [[User talk:198.84.253.202|talk]]) 02:19, 24 April 2018 (UTC) delete per above. No reliable source which shows any evidence of . Special:Contributions/198.84.253.202|198.84.253.202 Deletion of Arvind Ravulavaru WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
9974 21255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D'Elboux My Elbow User:The 12:01, 3 May 2010 (UTC) delete """another reason why should be a CSD option. The excuse of """"it could be notable so should be debated first"""" is completely at odds with the requirement. Nothing notable here""" Deletion of D'Elboux My Elbow WP:MADEUP||WP:V Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
9975 4642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History on Fire User:Ddcm8991 18:18, 18 July 2016 (UTC) delete per nomination. Fails and Deletion of History on Fire WP:GNG||WP:42 Wikipedia:Notability 77
9976 459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dustin McClure User:Boing 14:05, 23 February 2010 (UTC) delete """Sorry, but """"fastest 5,000 meters while wearing a 40 lb. rucksack"""", while undoubtedly an impressive feat, doesn't sound to me like it satisfies the notability requirements of - and Wikipedia doesn't have articles for single-record Guinness record holders""" Deletion of Dustin McClure WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
9977 14628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Romance in Twelve Parts User:Bondegezou 09:37, 15 May 2013 (UTC) comment This book is a sort of spin-off from ''Doctor Who''. Vast numbers of ''Dr Who'' spin-offs have articles while lacking independent, reliable source citations, ''e.g.'' The Burning Prince, Dark Eyes (audio drama), Return of the Krotons, Voyage to the New World, The Veiled Leopard, Sympathy for the Devil (audio drama), Short Trips – Volume 4, Dead Men's Tales (audio drama), Gallifrey: Spirit, Midwinter Murders, The Demons (Doctor Who audio), Terror (Doctor Who audio)... and I could go on and on and on. To delete this article while ignoring those seems odd to me. However, I recognise this is an argument and so cannot be used in support of keeping this article Deletion of A Romance in Twelve Parts WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
9978 21690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Illusions of immortality User:David 11:15, 5 August 2006 (UTC) delete """nn per nom and . I think that the """"award"""" is something like the fourth best-reviewed video ''on that day""" Deletion of Illusions of immortality WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
9979 1931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angel Mendez User:Kges1901 22:06, 12 January 2021 (UTC) keep Meeting is coverage, not achievement based, and Mendez passes the coverage bar with significant coverage in multiple independent RS newspapers. He is the subject of a https://www.newspapers.com/clip/67492308/angel-mendez-navy-cross-upgrade/ front-page story in the ''Philadelphia Inquirer'', a large-circulation major city newspaper, and numerous news articles such as https://www.newspapers.com/clip/67492680/angel-mendez/ https://www.silive.com/news/2011/05/fighting_for_a_heros_place_in.html https://www.silive.com/northshore/2012/01/st_george_post_office_will_be.html https://www.silive.com/news/2012/04/staten_island_post_office_rena.html https://www.silive.com/life-and-culture/g66l-2019/04/f1fe76bf308221/marine-corps-league-renamed-sgt-angel-mendez-detachment-during-dedication-ceremony-in-sunnyside.html Deletion of Angel Mendez WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9980 1060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Floating Men User:Jahiegel 18:52, 31 July 2006 (UTC) delete per Gay Cdn's application of Deletion of The Floating Men WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9981 4765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rod Belcher User:Ejgreen77 23:26, 31 July 2017 (UTC) keep per Paulmcdonald and Cbl62. Good-faith article expansion has improved the article to the point where it meets Deletion of Rod Belcher WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9982 15331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Rosenbaum User:Calton 05:46, 18 December 2006 (UTC) delete Per JzG. Not all that notable to begin with, and the self-authored |vanispamcruftisement ain't helping matters Deletion of Jeff Rosenbaum WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
9983 240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tubes (Filesharing) User:Trebor 20:53, 16 January 2007 (UTC) delete no independent sources. If it's only in beta, it might be |crystalballery too Deletion of Tubes (Filesharing) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9984 14993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Galaga X6 User:Zxcvbnm 01:10, 15 July 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Galaga X6 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
9985 9554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/What is the average size of an F1 fuel tank User:JEdgarFreeman 20:04, 20 September 2008 (UTC) delete I believe this is a case for . Wikipedia is a not a place where an article, whose single purpose is to present a question followed by an original answer, is allowed Deletion of What is the average size of an F1 fuel tank WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
9986 14663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beep Beep (band) User:Bluedustmite 17:03, 22 August 2006 (UTC) delete It seems to be on the cusp of meeting , but not quite Deletion of Beep Beep (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
9987 8406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Alty User:L293D 15:55, 10 March 2018 (UTC) keep enough citations to pass #C1 Deletion of James Alty WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9988 11846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Title (command) User:Kephir 10:48, 2 November 2012 (UTC) delete Notability is judged individually, and it has not been demonstrated that this particular command has accumulated enough. I actually think that the inclusion of all the commands listed in the categories linked is quite questionable, on grounds of notability and , but challenging them all at once would be overwhelming. The least controversial items (notice how there is only one argument defending the article on its own) are a good start Deletion of Title (command) WP:NOTMANUAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
9989 15128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jean Paul Cara User:Armbrust 21:35, 16 July 2010 (UTC) keep """per s first (""""Has credit for writing or co-writing either lyrics or music for a notable composition."""") and fourth criterium (""""Has written a song or composition which has won (or in some cases been given a second or other place) in a major music competition not established expressly for newcomers."""") In this case: L'oiseau et l'enfant""" Deletion of Jean Paul Cara WP:COMPOSER Wikipedia:Notability 77
9990 4047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Middle Eastern Cold War User:Hawkeye7 22:35, 6 March 2017 (UTC) delete as Deletion of Middle Eastern Cold War WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
9991 19559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vinoo Mankad Trophy User:Spike 15:53, 11 October 2018 (UTC) comment I don't think the discussion referred to above has reached a consensus. I also deleted a load of refs from the article as it seemed to be a . I was going to add them in here to allow others to judge if they prove notability , but I see {{u|DBigXray}} has added them already (whilst there are lots of them, many seem to be Deletion of Vinoo Mankad Trophy WP:REFBOMB||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Citation overkill 60
9992 2927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/December 2018 Venezuela earthquakes User:FOARP 12:41, 14 May 2019 (UTC) delete Whilst the event received substantial coverage at the time of the quakes, there is no evidence of impact, and as such this fails Deletion of December 2018 Venezuela earthquakes WP:LASTING||WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
9993 4359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Last of us (film) User:Arxiloxos 19:39, 14 November 2014 (UTC) merge to ''The Last of Us'', where the in-development film is already discussed. As Google and GNews searches will bear out, the project is receiving coverage, such as http://www.forbes.com/sites/insertcoin/2014/07/27/naughty-dog-wants-game-of-thrones-actress-for-the-last-of-us-movie/http://www.ign.com/articles/2014/08/11/parts-of-the-last-of-us-movie-to-be-quite-different-to-the-gamehttp://variety.com/2014/film/news/screen-gems-to-distribute-feature-version-of-ps3-game-last-of-us-1201126996/, but I don't see that anything has happened yet that makes a separate article appropriate per Deletion of The Last of us (film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
9994 14340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Notable anime movies listed by year User:TheFarix 18:11, 1 January 2007 (UTC) delete """Arbitrary list with no |objective and |verifiable criteria of what defines """"notable anime""" Deletion of Notable anime movies listed by year WP:NPOV||WP:V Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
9995 13664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History, Process, Benefits, and Kinds of Miso User:Tokyogirl79 05:14, 23 March 2016 (UTC) comment This is a student entry, which explains the way it's written - it's fairly common for students to write something in an essay style since that's what they're used to. Offhand we don't really need this specific page because we already have an article at miso, but some of the information could probably be merged as long as it's sourced properly and is written to fit the Deletion of History, Process, Benefits, and Kinds of Miso WP:MOS Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
9996 4899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of the occult secret societies User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:11, 9 February 2010 (UTC) keep """per nice cleanup and continue further expansion and sourcing that have allowed this list of notable """"secret societies"""" to meet . This a list that should be encouraged for further ment and expansion per sources. Considering deletion in the face of does not allow it to meet its , and diminishes Wikipedia. Comparisons with non-existent lists is interesting, for if those topics had the wide coverage in sources as do these """"secret societies"""", they too might meet inclusion criteria. No matter the topic, it is the coverage of such in numerous reliable sources... books, academia, press... that allow them to meet . That digression aside, I note that this particular discussion is about a specific list that DOES have sources that meet the and so merit expansion to further improve Wikipedia""" Deletion of List of the occult secret societies WP:LIST||WP:IMPROVE||WP:ATD||WP:POTENTIAL||WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Lists 97
9997 11340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fashion faux pas (2nd nomination) User:Reyk 04:20, 12 September 2012 (UTC) delete poorly sourced, inherently |original research and |personal opinions. The article undeservedly survived last time, two years ago, so that the problems could be fixed. That has not happened, which must now be taken as evidence that the problems cannot be fixed Deletion of Fashion faux pas (2nd nomination) WP:OR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
9998 21340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pressure and Safety Systems [[User talk:TheRedPenOfDoom|The Red Pen of Doom]] 06:05, 22 June 2009 (UTC) delete """neither the """"Pressure and Safety Systems"""" business unit nor the Reeve Holding parent company appear to have third party sourcing indicating |notability per google news check. A generic article about pressure systems sounds like it has potential for an encyclopedia article, but it does not appear that such an article is likely to be generated from this base""" Deletion of Pressure and Safety Systems WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
9999 16219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ASTech User:4meter4 02:03, 1 March 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of ASTech WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
10000 17737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hakka Americans NONE NONE merge """to Taiwanese Americans. FYI I posted the same rationale to the current rticles for deletion/Hokkien_and_Hoklo_Americans|AFD for Hokkien_and_Hoklo_Americans. The few academic sources I found that specifically mention Hoklo and Hakka immigrants in the U.S. all said that in Taiwan and in the US, the Hoklo and the Hakka self-identify as """"native Taiwanese"""". For example, http://doi.org/10.1002/psp.428 this 2006 journal article by Christine Avenarius, who seems to be an authority on the topic, was the most in-depth coverage I found on Taiwanese subethnic groups in the US, and according to Avenarius (with my emphasis): {{talkquote|""""Immigrants interviewed for this research were...able to identify who was Hoklo, Hakka or a Mainlander among the members of their social networks. However, in their comments on social life in Taiwan and California in general, '''all informants grouped Hoklo and Hakka people together, referring to them as native Taiwanese''' (''bendiren'')...Given the small number of Hakka informants in the sample and the common practice of all immigrants from Taiwan to group both Hoklo and Hakka together under the label 'native Taiwanese' (''bendiren'') as introduced above, I aggregated Hoklo and Hakka informants in the analysis""" Deletion of Hakka Americans WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
10001 8794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diana Peacocke User:Esradekan 01:11, 7 April 2008 (UTC) delete fails #Politicians Deletion of Diana Peacocke WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10002 5536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marian Engineering College User:Nomadicghumakkad 04:07, 16 April 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Marian Engineering College WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10003 18187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/First image on the Web User:Coredesat 03:40, 6 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails in its current state. I have no problem with merging this to Les Horribles Cernettes, though Deletion of First image on the Web WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10004 20814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unification theory (2nd nomination) User:Cardamon 10:22, 10 May 2007 (UTC) delete There's no evidence in the article that this theory is Wikipedia:notability|notable or that its content can be erifiability|verified using |reliable sources. In other words, it needs good references. The article seems to have been shortened drastically since it was nominated; the original version was incoherent and too long; the current version seems not to have much content Deletion of Unification theory (2nd nomination) WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10005 7992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David L. Cook television appearances User:Biruitorul 04:19, 20 July 2009 (UTC) delete Canyouhearmenow, , , , , , may be of interest to you. I know, not all are guidelines, but several are Deletion of David L. Cook television appearances WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOT||WP:LISTCRUFT||WP:NOONECARES||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10006 19295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Purple Turtle User:Starblind 20:10, 13 March 2012 (UTC) delete I see nothing at all that even comes close to passing Deletion of Purple Turtle WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10007 17815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ROOM 1202 User:Neiltonks 15:45, 8 December 2017 (UTC) delete Non notable band and in any case pretty much the whole article is a from http://www.soundclick.com/bands/default.cfm?bandID=203810 this page on Soundclick.com Deletion of ROOM 1202 WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
10008 3508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/McMillan Fire User:Alex 07:55, 30 June 2019 (UTC) delete Ordinary local news Deletion of McMillan Fire WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10009 7985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Nicholls User:Carioca 19:28, 20 April 2010 (UTC) delete as he fails both and Deletion of Lee Nicholls WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10010 18013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 Pacific typhoon season User:Kingofaces43 17:06, 21 December 2017 (UTC) keep but prune. The text as it is is indeed too much crystal balling, but the topic itself fulfills the first bullet of . I would just stubify it until storms start making the news soon instead of having all the current filler Deletion of 2018 Pacific typhoon season WP:FUTURE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10011 1161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zoomcar User:Mz7 03:17, 7 May 2016 (UTC) keep The in-depth sources found by Northamerica indicate notability under . A HighBeam search also found https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P3-3664844171.htmlhttps://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P3-3737909631.htmlhttps://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P3-3556342261.html Deletion of Zoomcar WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10012 15409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Sloan User:David 23:41, 6 October 2010 (UTC) delete WP:CREATIVE seems more appropriate for this case than but I don't see any evidence (in the form of newspaper coverage, major label releases, etc) that he passes. And the level of textual similarity between this article and his MICA home page http://www.mica.edu/About_MICA/People/Faculty/Faculty_List_by_Last_Name/Jason_Sloan.html is troubling Deletion of Jason Sloan WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10013 20921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Ain't Perfect User:STATicVerseatide 05:06, 13 November 2012 (UTC) delete Fails in all ways Deletion of I Ain't Perfect WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10014 2127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miracle at the Meadowlands II User:Muboshgu 21:07, 15 March 2012 (UTC) delete for failing . – Deletion of Miracle at the Meadowlands II WP:SPORTSEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10015 4939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hugo Meira User:Cloudz679 22:49, 25 September 2014 (UTC) delete article about a subject which does not meet the Deletion of Hugo Meira WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10016 17547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of male film actors (L-Z) User:Lugnuts 12:14, 7 September 2008 (UTC) keep """Meets . Notability is implied, hence why it doesn't need the word """"notable"""" in the title. As for the arguement of it being listcruft, ALL lists could fall under that inclusion to someone who knows nothing about the topic. I look forward to future AfD's for List of monarchs of Korea, List of Naruto characters, List of peninsulas, List of J-pop artists and List of Batman animated episodes""" Deletion of List of male film actors (L-Z) WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
10017 11460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devil Bird User:Dan 04:16, 3 August 2020 (UTC) keep have added a number of |reliable sources - enough to easily satisfy Deletion of Devil Bird WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10018 15341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ebb (band) User:Dibbydib 01:49, 21 April 2020 (UTC) delete fails both and Deletion of Ebb (band) WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10019 4025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bluepill User:Verdatum 02:45, 30 January 2008 (UTC) delete Does not meet covered with . Seems like an attempt to start a Deletion of Bluepill WP:FICT||WP:PLOT||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10020 15145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indecision (band) User:Chubbles 18:01, 29 October 2009 (UTC) keep all. Most Precious Blood (band) rather spectacularly passes , with three releases on Trustkill Records and plenty of third-party coverage (Here's their http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sql=11:g9ftxqw0ldse~T1 AMG profile, for starters). Indecision http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sql=11:hnfoxqejldje~T1 also has an AMG profile and http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sql=10:hjfrxqekld0e several http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sql=10:jjfrxqekld0e album http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sql=10:fxfwxqqkldte reviews, got a review in http://books.google.com/books?id=VnJbAAAAMAAJ&q=indecision+%22release+the+cure%22&dq=indecision+%22release+the+cure%22 Maximum Rocknroll, was a http://books.google.com/books?id=GioEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA79&dq=indecision+%22release+the+cure%22#v=onepage&q=indecision%20%22release%20the%20cure%22&f=false top 5 metal act in CMJ in 2000, and so forth... Brannan might normally be a target for redirection to Most Precious Blood, but as the member of two notable bands, there is no single redirect target and so it's reasonable for him to have an article of his own Deletion of Indecision (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10021 15472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fate/stay Night the Movie: Unlimited Blade Works User:Tokyogirl79 17:44, 20 December 2012 (UTC) keep I did a major rehaul of the article, essentially re-writing most of it and deleting a ton of it. I've removed the entire plot section since it didn't make a whole lot of sense and couldn't really remain as it was. I also found two reviews from DVD Talk and ANN, as well as some news articles about it, one of which is in Chinese. I'm slightly hampered by the language barrier, but I did find enough to show that it should pass . It's still lighter than I'd like at the moment, but it appears to be notable Deletion of Fate/stay Night the Movie: Unlimited Blade Works WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
10022 21223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trio (Buffy the Vampire Slayer) NONE NONE keep """as an AfD outcome, but I have no objection to an appropriate merge to BtVS S6, which is an appropriate parent topic. At least, this article should be a subordinate to the S6 article, because the group only exists as """"the trio"""" within S6""" Deletion of Trio (Buffy the Vampire Slayer) WP:SS Wikipedia:Summary style 34
10023 18613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Scherf User:Doc 20:13, 4 December 2006 (UTC) comment The presence of |SPA tags appended to the comments of new contributors is not an attempt to discount their comments, nor does it imply trolling or other improper behaviour. These tags are widely used as a service to the closing admin, to provide them with background information potentially relevant to the discussion. I felt it was appropriate to use them here, despite the fact that the new contributors are supporting my nom of this article. Thanks for participating in the discussion; I hope you stay and make further contributions to WP Deletion of Steve Scherf WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
10024 4575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transformation of culture User:Smmurphy 15:42, 8 June 2017 (UTC) comment I agree with Fixuture, no one has opposed your merge suggestion, perhaps you could bring it up at Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Sociology, wait another week, and then e bold|Be bold Deletion of Transformation of culture WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
10025 1692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Avraham Nhamani User:Rlest 15:49, 23 July 2007 (UTC) delete This subject does not appear to be notable, as well as clearly failing the |verifiability policy. &mdash Deletion of Ben Avraham Nhamani WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10026 21839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/*Sixeyes User:Stifle 23:37, 3 April 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of *Sixeyes WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10027 17310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cardiac (comics) User:Argento 16:02, 18 July 2017 (UTC) merge to List of Marvel Comics characters: C. Nomination fails . A current lack of sources is not the same as no sources existing. Additionally, a previous bold merge to List of Marvel Comics characters: C was Talk:List of Marvel Comics characters: C#Proposed Cardiac merge|overturned as keep. Pinging {{ping|Spidey104}} and {{ping|Rtkat3}}, who participated in the merge discussion Deletion of Cardiac (comics) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
10028 6344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacqueline Ogeil User:Shaidar 04:15, 10 April 2018 (UTC) keep toured Australia, Europe and Canada. Has issued at least two albums. Passes Deletion of Jacqueline Ogeil WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10029 17521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Imogen Heap's third studio album User:Cliff 19:47, 18 September 2008 (UTC) delete this |speculation. Sourced info should be the artist's article Deletion of Imogen Heap's third studio album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10030 8219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hampus Lönn User:Fenix 15:29, 17 January 2018 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Hampus Lönn WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10031 14664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul C. Maxwell (politician) User:MB 01:42, 19 September 2016 (UTC) delete Article clearly promotional, probably qualifies for G11. Article written by SPA with likely COI. The subject fails and this article is an attempt to promote his current campaign Deletion of Paul C. Maxwell (politician) WP:politician Wikipedia:Notability 77
10032 216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chenva tieu User:Yomangani 11:29, 28 September 2006 (UTC) delete he has the Ordre National du Mérite (lowest rank) which might make him notable, but doesn't say anything about awards, and the text is a straight lift from his blog so fails , and it is not in English Deletion of Chenva tieu WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10033 11936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danny de Warren User:GregJackP 23:30, 27 March 2010 (UTC) comment article creator is also subject of article, violating |autobiography and has removed AfD tag from page (since restored Deletion of Danny de Warren WP:AB Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
10034 12888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaliyah (film) User:Amalthea 19:56, 28 August 2008 (UTC) delete is probably a hoax (no imdb entry, no other reliable sources to be found), and in any case fails Deletion of Aaliyah (film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10035 10913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sim Street episodes User:NickelShoe 21:44, 29 June 2007 (UTC) delete If the show isn't |notable, the episode guide is not useful Deletion of Sim Street episodes WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10036 17367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faber (band) User:Saberwyn 23:06, 19 February 2007 (UTC) merge to the new name to preserve contribution history. '''No stance''' on the band itself, or its ability to meet the |notability inclusion guideline for music-related articles Deletion of Faber (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10037 7287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Weyr (2nd nomination) User:Piotrus 09:19, 4 December 2019 (UTC) delete Terrible that fortunately survives in https://pern.fandom.com/wiki/Weyrs so nothing is lost Deletion of Weyr (2nd nomination) WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
10038 2372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oliver Konteh User:Sir 15:40, 9 December 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. He has received insufficient coverage to pass and all claims to notability under are unverified Deletion of Oliver Konteh WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10039 21653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christoph Hartmut Bluth User:David 16:47, 23 October 2020 (UTC) keep The case for #C1 is borderline but is clear enough Deletion of Christoph Hartmut Bluth WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10040 15407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michi-chan User:Esradekan 01:04, 1 May 2008 (UTC) delete WP:MUSIC and Deletion of Michi-chan WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
10041 5858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Molly Mormon User:TenPoundHammer 03:18, 31 July 2007 (UTC) keep article is more than a mere dicdef, is well referenced, and possible Deletion of Molly Mormon WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
10042 20015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clint Everts User:Ejgreen77 22:49, 22 August 2014 (UTC) keep as a pass per Muboshgu and Yankees10 Deletion of Clint Everts WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10043 19171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ajay Ahuja (businessman) User:scope_creep 10:51, 6 March 2019 (UTC) delete Entirely nn. Fails Deletion of Ajay Ahuja (businessman) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10044 15284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph McMoneagle (2nd nomination) User:LuckyLouie 14:49, 4 May 2009 (UTC) delete Attempted initial cleanup, but found that the article is based primarily on sources Deletion of Joseph McMoneagle (2nd nomination) WP:SELFPUB Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10045 21701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NCD International User:Shawn 14:51, 11 July 2016 (UTC) delete per . The banned sock accounts are now https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk%3ADeveloper22&type=revision&diff=729302975&oldid=729243066 requesting deletion Deletion of NCD International WP:G7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
10046 10766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Çağla Baktıroğlu User:Fenix 08:56, 29 August 2017 (UTC) delete Fails No indication of wide |GNG. Article is well referenced, however all sources are essentially databases, stat sites, |brief routine mentions or |primary sources. Would challenge other editors to provide a single instance of a significant, dedicated article on the player that might be used to support GNG. http://www.todayszaman.com/sports_turkish-canadian-hockey-star-cagla-says-erzurum-fans-great_234186.html This looks like it might be a start (though I would need to see more in order to be happy GNG is met) but I can't get the page to load Deletion of Çağla Baktıroğlu WP:NHOCKEY||WP:GNG||WP:MILL||WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
10047 21479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011 Leinster Senior Cup Final User:Fenix 08:12, 27 October 2016 (UTC) merge per , a plausible search term Deletion of 2011 Leinster Senior Cup Final WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10048 4997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BlogExplosion User:Xtifr 22:22, 25 October 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. I was tempted to suggest speedy per #G11|G11, but initial creator seems to be Wikipedian in good standing, so I don't think it was actually intended as spam Deletion of BlogExplosion WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
10049 7535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beamery User:HighKing 17:39, 10 September 2017 (UTC) delete References fail the criteria for establishing notability, fail and/or . Topic fails GNG and Deletion of Beamery WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:SPIP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10050 16595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Lawrence (ice hockey) User:Hockeyben 17:18, 21 August 2013 (UTC) keep Nom is incorrect about Lawrence not meeting . He meets either criterion 1 or 2 of the guidelines Deletion of Jim Lawrence (ice hockey) WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
10051 21243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathon Sharkey (5th nomination) User:The 22:58, 9 October 2011 (UTC) keep """Wikipedia is , if you're a public figure with verifiable facts in the public record, """"I don't want a page"""" isn't good enough to have a page taken down. We're not Italy (yet""" Deletion of Jonathon Sharkey (5th nomination) WP:NOTCENSORED Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10052 11524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seth neiman User:Ron 00:05, 5 August 2010 (UTC) merge The article is a |BLP Deletion of Seth neiman WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10053 3068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Escargo User:Metropolitan90 05:21, 30 December 2007 (UTC) delete as a |hoax given that the references are fake. But even if the article were completely true, it would just be a dictionary definition of an obscure slang word, and |Wikipedia is not a dictionary Deletion of Escargo WP:HOAX||WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
10054 15719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Hanna-Barbera works on DVD User:Matthew 14:37, 19 May 2007 (UTC) keep per Deletion of List of Hanna-Barbera works on DVD WP:SS Wikipedia:Summary style 34
10055 6352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Award User:Tokyogirl79 05:39, 4 February 2015 (UTC) delete I was able to find brief mentions of this award here and there, but it's almost solely a trivial mention in articles about award winners who went on to gain coverage for other awards or accomplishments. In other words, there isn't anything out there that focuses on the award itself. These sort of passing mentions are pretty routine, as most newspapers will list almost anything that a person has been awarded, be it a college award or a Bronze Swimming Certificate. Yes, some of the people have gone on to accomplish great things, but notability for later accomplishments does not translate into notability for this specific award, as notability is by later accomplishments or by the college itself being notable. As for the amount of hits on the article, that doesn't count towards notability either. It means that people may have found it useful, but being |useful does not count towards notability either. (Also, it could be that the large amount of hits were just from people coming in from AfD or from people who came to the page by mistake, so we can't guarantee that they came in there specifically to read about that award.) This could maybe be merged into the main article for the college, but I can't really find enough coverage to merit that either and it would potentially put undue weight upon an award given to a very specific group of students in a specific degree program and not students from the college as a whole Deletion of Adam Award WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:ITSUSEFUL Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10056 896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bangladeshi Ambassador to Portugal User:Chris 15:17, 25 October 2017 (UTC) delete The optimal solution here is to keep this content at Foreign relations of Bangladesh until such point that there's so much well-sourced content that it's ready to be |spun-out. A standalone article should not exist until it must Deletion of Bangladeshi Ambassador to Portugal WP:SPINOUT Wikipedia:Article size 51
10057 20767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rabble User:JackassCKA 16:46, 7 March 2006 (UTC) comment """Cite your sources. Last I looked rabble didn't have any original articles, they are all """"re-prints"""" which is specifically excluded in ? Oh but you knew that Mr. I have more edits then you. Right""" Deletion of Rabble WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10058 11268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Egypt's Sarcasm Society User:ToastyMallows 16:15, 3 April 2013 (UTC) delete I don't think it meets , in addition to not having enough sources and secondary sources Deletion of Egypt's Sarcasm Society WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10059 5473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/June 2010 West Bank shooting (2nd nomination) User:Tarc 13:59, 23 September 2010 (UTC) delete """just the same as AfD #1 which unfortunately was brought to DRV for """"I disagree with the result"""" reasons"""". This is WP:NOTNEWS|news, this is not a significant or historic event. Maybe it's a sad commentary on the state of world affairs that such attacks are considered almost routine news, but that's the way it is. The Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, not a vehicle to prop up importance of one's personal causes and interests. Elevating this |event to an article does exactly that. If appropriate, reuse/recycle some of the sources in a larger article on Israeli-Palestine conflicts""" Deletion of June 2010 West Bank shooting (2nd nomination) WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10060 6397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Rossant NONE NONE keep spaced ndash}} This person meets and , having received significant coverage in reliable sources per Deletion of John Rossant WP:BASIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10061 8848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Final Destination 5 (2011 film) User:Ttonyb1 05:58, 5 July 2010 (UTC) delete mdash; Pre-production film. Appears to fail Deletion of Final Destination 5 (2011 film) WP:NOTFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
10062 304 [[Anarchistisches Radio Wien]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Atlasowa NONE delete """Radiosendung mit 4 Stunden Sendezeit pro Monat, keine Rezeption in der Öffentlichkeit, bei Alexa wird nicht mal Traffic für die Website registrierthttp://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/a-radio.net. Keine Relevanz dargelegt als Radiosendung oder als Website. : """"''Negative Indizien: - Internetpräsenzen von Firmen, Künstlern oder Medien sollten grundsätzlich nur dann erwähnt werden, wenn sie eigenständige Inhalte anbieten (also über die reine Präsentation hinausgehen) und in der Regel im Hauptartikel eingearbeitet werden""" Löschung von Anarchistisches Radio Wien Wikipedia:Richtlinien Websites Wikipedia:Notability 77
10063 16196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John J. Kerrigan User:Bakazaka 17:33, 12 September 2018 (UTC) keep """Having read more carefully through the New York Times coverage, changing !vote to keep as a clear pass of . Editors may read the coverage differently. For example, in a """"passing mention"""" from the first article cited above, here is the text immediately following: """"The most outspoken committeeman is threeterm member Kerrigan, a father of two who professes to be so concerned about the future of education that he is pursuing a doctorate in education at the University of Massachusetts. He quits the meeting a little early to chat with a visitor. His office is cluttered with curios and he pointedly calls attention to his favorite, a plaster fist molded into an obscene gesture in front of a banquet‐table sign that reads “Reserved for the Press.” But he is relatively subdued and genial for this interview as he props his modish two‐tone high‐heel shoes on the desk. “Those who want to bus kids are out to bus your kids, not theirs,” he says, referring to those “friggin’ liberals in the suburbs” where there are almost no black people. “When they put their kids on the altar of social justice, then I'll put mine there, too""" Deletion of John J. Kerrigan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10064 14238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs about weather User:Hjal 23:45, 12 June 2007 (UTC) keep """all. It would be a better use of editors' time to establish a consensus guideline that clearly addressed the issue of """"List of songs about topics."""" There is some residue from previous discussions that suggests that work should be started up again. Regarding these specific nominees, I'm here because of List of songs about the environment. I came across that list a few weeks ago and found it interesting but clearly incomplete (and incapable of being """"complete""""). I added Little Boxes, which clearly fits any criteria that could be devised for a list with this name. I spent some time looking for other ommissions and for songs that didn't belong there, and I planned to do more. While I now know that this effort was to some, both sickening and laughable, I do not know what Policy clearly demands the erasure of this work. What the list of environmental songs needs is a link to an appropriate article or section on Songs about the environment or Environmental protest songs, or even Protest songs, where such a list would be needed and would be a useful research tool. I do not agree that most of these lists are . Their problem is , for the songs that do not already have articles (especially those that never will), and ongoing article maintenance. Most of these lists need cleanup and editing help, which should have been begun, or at least proposed, prior to initiating AfD. I realize that this multiple-list nomination is an efficient way for regular AfD participants to handle a bunch of stuff they don't like, but since this one nomination could eliminate thousands of edits by hundreds of editors, based on the particpation of a few dozen (mostly) flippant members and one administrator, it seems to me to be wholly inappropriate""" Deletion of List of songs about weather WP:NOT||WP:V Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10065 12291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nassau Junction, Missouri User:Hog 04:29, 22 April 2020 (UTC) delete A station used to exist there, see https://books.google.com/books?id=P5UpAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA696&lpg=PA696&dq=nassau+junction+missouri&source=bl&ots=ZFQzrLE4dT&sig=ACfU3U1j0kobeXh1q5QaClIk4Ozs5jYxNQ&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiC9p25l_voAhWDZM0KHZseASY4ChDoATAHegQICBAB#v=onepage&q=nassau%20junction%20missouri&f=false, https://books.google.com/books?id=LeZN1-pTN8YC&pg=PA359&lpg=PA359&dq=nassau+junction+missouri+railroad+station&source=bl&ots=C6KxiUcwDw&sig=ACfU3U1VgNeP6o97NUFOa8rrlOO7tRiD_A&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjA7_Xtl_voAhUCH80KHUthBowQ6AEwB3oECAkQAQ#v=onepage&q=nassau%20junction%20missouri%20railroad%20station&f=false, and https://www.modot.org/sites/default/files/documents/multimodal/techmemo2-existingconditionsfinal04-20-2012.pdf, but that looks like it's it. The brief mentions do not establish , and is not met by the nature of the location Deletion of Nassau Junction, Missouri WP:GNG||WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10066 20483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dim Gray Bar Press User:Newslinger 02:32, 30 July 2018 (UTC) delete Not notable. Doesn't meet or . No significant coverage from reliable sources. — Deletion of Dim Gray Bar Press WP:GNG||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10067 4549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teenu Arora (2nd nomination) User:Hako9 01:17, 11 August 2020 (UTC) delete The Zee news story is written by Indo-Asian News Service|IANS. See . Other stories are either short interviews or trivial mentions Deletion of Teenu Arora (2nd nomination) WP:SYNDICATED Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10068 4376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Berat Çetinkaya User:GiantSnowman 09:13, 20 June 2013 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Berat Çetinkaya WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10069 7396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samuel Pepper User:MPEGLA 22:00, 13 August 2010 (UTC) keep he is also known as a graffiti artist as the article says therefore he is notable and it doesn't breach Deletion of Samuel Pepper WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10070 2159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southeast North Dakota State University User:DARTH 10:36, 2 June 2011 (UTC) delete as failure to . Not a single source provided, and possibly even hoax Deletion of Southeast North Dakota State University WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10071 101 [[Nicht Abzocken]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Löschvieh NONE delete Fehlende Artikelqualität und POV läßt sich beheben, fehlende |Relevanz nicht. In manchen Fällen kann man mit etwas WP:AGF|gutem Willen ein gewisses Unterschreiten der RK tolerieren, wenn aber ein Artikelersteller mit solchen Aufrufen arbeitet, dann war der Artikel von Anfang an als reiner Werbeeintrag geplant. In diesem Fall knallhart auf die Erfüllung der Relevanzkriterien bestehen und, da sie offensichtlich nicht erfüllt werden können, Gerne auch schnell, bevor der Verein wegen des Löschantrags noch einen seiner berüchtigten DoS-Angriffe auf Wikipedia startet Löschung von Nicht Abzocken Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10072 15965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zicam NONE NONE keep Yes, this is a bad faith nomination. It's either gross incompetence or a violation. The background is found here: Talk:Homeopathy#Zicam. SMH! Khabboos just can't help being disruptive. This is just one bit of sand on the mile long beach of his disruptive behaviors, and a mile long section of beach has lots of sand on it. I suggest that editors begin to monitor him very closely Deletion of Zicam WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
10073 183 [[Wikipedia:Entwurf einer Entsperrrichtlinie]] (LA entfernt) Benutzer:Martina Nolte NONE merge Warum sollte dieser von der Community noch nicht beschiedene Entwurf einen prominenteren Platz bekommen als andere #In_aktiver_Vorbereitung|MBs in Vorbereitung? Bitte dorthin Löschung von Wikipedia:Entwurf einer Entsperrrichtlinie Wikipedia:MB Wikipedia:Meinungsbilder 80
10074 13580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hani Miletski user:Hannes 15:39, 31 May 2021 (UTC) comment """I found this review https://www.jstor.org/stable/3813759 in The Journal of Sex Research so her work is at least discussed in reputable sources. Whether she has a reputable degree or not will not affect or . The review is quite strong, it reads """"This is the best overall survey of bestiality that I have read."""" but a single review is generally not enough for or . Also all media coverage I could find about her related to her dissertation, so it sounds like a """ Deletion of Hani Miletski WP:NAUTHOR||WP:NPROF||WP:NAUTHOR||WP:NPROF||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
10075 11923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled Super Mario game (Wii U) User:Jelly 08:22, 23 April 2012 (UTC) delete without prejudice per Deletion of Untitled Super Mario game (Wii U) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10076 8361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marashino User:Dhartung 17:35, 20 July 2007 (UTC) delete with no evidence presented of passing . I would accept an Emergenza win as provisional notability, but not a ''Milwaukee'' win feeding into a ''Detroit'' regional semi-final that they http://www.emergenza.net/document/news/news.asp?id=1539 lost Deletion of Marashino WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10077 13374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Four Seasons Of Love User:Melchoir 18:54, 21 January 2006 (UTC) delete per nom, also and Deletion of Four Seasons Of Love WP:NOR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
10078 12341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crowd user:Andrew 17:47, 11 April 2018 (UTC) keep """Our articles are supposed to be essays, i.e. """"''A composition of moderate length on any particular subject''"""" (OED) This one started in 2004, over 13 years ago, and so has grown by accretion per our |editing policy. What it needs is improvement, not deletion, and |AfD is not cleanup. Note that there's no shortage of sources for the topic, such as ''The Crowd: A Study of the Popular Mind|The Crowd'', which is so notable that it has its own article""" Deletion of Crowd WP:IMPERFECT||WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
10079 14422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derek Abbott User:David 19:00, 28 October 2012 (UTC) keep as he is an IEEE Fellow and in so being passes #C3. With an h-index of 35 and seven papers with 100 or more citations in http://scholar.google.com/citations?user=vqD_0uQAAAAJ his Google scholar profile, he is also well above the usual threshold for #C1 Deletion of Derek Abbott WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10080 14442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oru Bhayankara Kamukan User:Longevitydude 12:19, 28 May 2017 (UTC) delete No indication that filming has begun. A case here. Fails . By the way Deletion of Oru Bhayankara Kamukan WP:TOOSOON||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Too soon 40
10081 8348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yimei Xiang User:Mr 12:40, 16 April 2012 (UTC) delete Unfortunately, she doesn't appear to pass our |notability guidelines for academics yet Deletion of Yimei Xiang WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10082 16786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Echizen ware User:Sam 18:39, 29 June 2016 (UTC) keep meets , I have added a handful of English language {{tl|Cite book}}s to sources. |Notability is based on the existence of suitable sources, not on the state of sourcing in an article, and doing a modicum of |mandatory searching prior to nomination saves time Deletion of Echizen ware WP:GNG||WP:NEXIST||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10083 8886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abbas Hashmi (3rd nomination) User:Scope 19:41, 3 September 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Abbas Hashmi (3rd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
10084 9026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barnsbury Estate User:AbbyKelleyite 23:45, 23 August 2010 (UTC) keep """From : """"If a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to satisfy the inclusion criteria for a stand-alone article. 'Significant coverage' means that sources address the subject directly in detail, so no original research is needed to extract the content. Significant coverage is more than a trivial mention but it need not be the main topic of the source material."""" The controversy over the proposed development of the neighborhood and the cancellation of those plans received significant coverage. See, e.g. http://www.getsurrey.co.uk/news/s/2021070_garden_grab_scheme_shelved""" Deletion of Barnsbury Estate WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10085 1032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Teal User:Masterpiece2000 08:24, 16 June 2008 (UTC) delete Teal played only 6 games in the National Hockey League. Fails Deletion of Jeff Teal WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10086 10822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wenvir N. Leyson User:Drm310 05:14, 4 June 2015 (UTC) comment Original author blanked the page, so I have nominated it for speedy deletion Deletion of Wenvir N. Leyson WP:G7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
10087 12197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Jackson's finances [[User talk:Crotalus horridus|*** Crotalus ***]] 18:01, 26 December 2007 (UTC) merge to Michael Jackson's main article. There is valid, |reliably sourced material here, but not enough for a separate article Deletion of Michael Jackson's finances WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10088 720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HESOPHIA HC12 User:Hobbes 23:21, 17 June 2012 (UTC) delete """This 6-week-old EP is the first release by this non-notable artist. Article is completely unsourced, and I didn't anything usefully from web searches. Makes a claim that the album charted for a week on...something--some random website? It's not clear. Unfortunately, ecord charts lists nothing for Indonesia. Article claims that first track """"Hesophia"""" is the most popular, and I did find it on Youtube, where it has racked up 38 total views. If decent sources can be found, happy to look again, but as it stands, not even close to being notable""" Deletion of HESOPHIA HC12 WP:RS||WP:R Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10089 6417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelsey Smith User:Edison 19:17, 6 June 2007 (UTC) delete """I fervently hope she is found ok, but Wikipedia is not a newspaper or True Crime Gazette. Per : """"The fact that someone or something has been in the news for a brief period of time does not automatically justify an encyclopedia article"""". A recent abduction story is better suited to Wikinews than to an encyclopedia. Fox News, CNN and newspaper editors use lurid stories about Missing white woman syndrome|missing white girls while ignoring other disappearances to boost readership/viewership, while encyclopedias try to assemble NPOV stories about facts of enduring historical importance""" Deletion of Kelsey Smith WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10090 10526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Accusations against Israel of war crimes during the Al-Aqsa Intifada User:Humus 12:05, 10 January 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. As admitted above, this is a to overcompensate for Islam and antisemitism and Islamic terrorism Deletion of Accusations against Israel of war crimes during the Al-Aqsa Intifada WP:SOAPBOX Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10091 13523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vlad (musician) User:Malcolmxl5 23:53, 23 March 2008 (UTC) keep Appears to have released two albums on a notable indie label, Orpheus Music, per . I note also that the nom nominated this for deletion within FOUR minutes of the article being createdhttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Vlad_%28musician%29&action=history, which is way too quick imo. Tag it up and give it longer Deletion of Vlad (musician) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10092 16288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Bennett Guitars (2nd nomination) User:Chris 19:58, 1 February 2012 (UTC) delete """but bear in mind that I am the nominator of the original AfD). I am now beginning to see that I shouldn't have withdrawn, as some original """"keeps"""" didn't really address the issue of notability that I had raised as the nominator. The problem of failing |GNG and |ORG still stands, and I think that it is still grounds for deletion""" Deletion of Greg Bennett Guitars (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10093 11886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tjeu User:Metropolitan90 20:53, 24 September 2006 (UTC) delete I was about to nominate this article myself. The article is a |dictionary definition of a |protologism with no relevant Google hits that I could find. The article was submitted for |proposed deletion, but the article's creator removed the PROD tag and added a source which was just the creator's own submission to Urban Dictionary, which is not a reliable source anyway Deletion of Tjeu WP:WINAD||WP:NEO||WP:PROD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10094 20358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thushar Vellapally User:Lefcentreright 20:58, 17 February 2020 (UTC) delete Fails . Party presidents aren't always notable Deletion of Thushar Vellapally WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10095 20817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wassim Almawi (2nd nomination) User:Abductive 05:35, 19 March 2010 (UTC) keep Top GS cites are 104, 76, 54, 39, 38 .... with h index = 16. May pass rof #1. A large amount of sourceable information was removed from the article before it was nominated for AfD. Restoration of this in part may allay the justified concerns of Deletion of Wassim Almawi (2nd nomination) WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
10096 11585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Parker User:Assize 02:56, 29 October 2007 (UTC) keep """As a former deputy mayor, he meets """"Major local political figures who have received significant press coverage"""" under """ Deletion of Jamie Parker WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10097 15926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scorcher: The Dirty Politics of Climate Change User:Lankiveil 09:56, 12 November 2008 (UTC) keep secondary coverage means it meets and Deletion of Scorcher: The Dirty Politics of Climate Change WP:BK||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10098 5497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rolf Prima User:Rms125a 14:57, 29 May 2016 (UTC) delete fails but meets Deletion of Rolf Prima WP:GNG||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10099 3500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hammerax (2nd nomination) User:7 00:12, 17 November 2019 (UTC) keep No reason for a do-over. Reasons cited in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Hammerax last nomination are sufficient. reserve No compliance with efore, which mandates that we are supposed to act on what the article ''could'' become, not what it was when nominated. Indeed, the cited sources NOW are ample to demonstrate Deletion of Hammerax (2nd nomination) WP:P||WP:B||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Portal 85
10100 8466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cass Boxing User:Stifle 21:57, 25 April 2006 (UTC) delete Its homepage is on Geocities. Seeing the name weblinked on every instance sets off my detector something fierce Deletion of Cass Boxing WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
10101 20186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Compendium Traditional Catechism User:KylieTastic 18:47, 11 November 2014 (UTC) delete No sign that it is notable - no reference to actual work outside Amazon link. If the importance actually met the claim on both the article and here you would expect outside references. Similarity of name would suggest the article author is the book author so clear |conflict of interest on the importance of the work. Also these 1 post 'keep' votes look like puppets, as does the single Amazon review Deletion of Compendium Traditional Catechism WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
10102 254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bart Caubergh User:GiantSnowman 09:33, 24 December 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Bart Caubergh WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10103 31 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Live At The NIGHT Volume 4 User:Esradekan 02:49, 4 April 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Albums. No significant coverage in |reliable, third-party, sources Deletion of Live At The NIGHT Volume 4 WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10104 20794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. S S Mantha User:CAPTAIN 20:37, 17 February 2017 (UTC) delete non-notable cademics and Deletion of Dr. S S Mantha WP:A||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Attribution 108
10105 7291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Kidd (cricketer) User:Wjemather 13:31, 3 March 2021 (UTC) delete or '''redirect''' to List of Oxford UCCE & MCCU players. No ; only wide-ranging databases, scorecards, etc. In fact fails all notability criteria including the very weak NCRIC; per my above comment, there is no automatic first-class—highest-level equivalence here. It should be noted that such matches no longer have first-class status as a result of this long-standing paradox Deletion of Matthew Kidd (cricketer) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
10106 17426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The She Spot (2nd nomination) NONE NONE comment """Kudos to DGG for noticing this as a promotional campaign on Wikipedia. I only wish DGG had placed both articles in the AfD. I am referring to the separate AfD linked above Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Witter. That AfD is an important component to this AfD. Both articles pertaining to these AfD's were started by the same red-linked account, which appears to me to be |single purpose account (see contributions here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Haley113) This first SPA only edited for the """"She Spot"""" and the author biography """"Lisa Witter""" Deletion of The She Spot (2nd nomination) WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
10107 19679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haileybury Astana NONE NONE comment Using as a guide but not a reason unto itself, my reasons for nominating were Deletion of Haileybury Astana WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
10108 8609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prince Nicolas, Duke of Ångermanland [[User talk:Ravenswing|''' '' Ravenswing '' ''' ]] 23:13, 12 August 2020 (UTC) delete """As in his sister's AfD, the nom hasn't advanced a valid deletion ground (""""no foreseeable public role"""" is as much soothsaying as any other violation), but other voters have. Being in line for a throne is not, as I've found, a valid part of any notability criterion on Wikipedia. Neither, despite some assertions above, is being the """"duke of Angermanland,"""" which the article itself admits is only titular. Those claiming a GNG keep plainly misunderstand the GNG, which is ''not'' a hundred namedrops in however-reliable sources, but actual |''significant coverage'', to the ''subject'', in reliable sources. This obviously has not been forthcoming, and to any voter who might respond """"Well, how much can you say about a toddler?"""" I answer, """"You're right. There isn't. Which is why the subject does not qualify for a Wikipedia article.""""And that being said, holy heck, could the venomous rhetoric above slow down a bit? Strange though it might seem to some, |one does not need to be a member of a vicious secret society to apply notability standards to articles and find them lacking, even if the subjects are adorable little children. Neither is there any evidence of anti-monarchical or anti-Swedish bias, although a couple of you are sure making a case for the converse""" Deletion of Prince Nicolas, Duke of Ångermanland WP:CRYSTAL||WP:SIGCOV||WP:CABAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10109 16501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Justin Ross Lee [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 13:03, 27 May 2013 (UTC) keep the problem here is that, with all due respect to the subject, he is most notable for being a bit of a dick, and we don't have a specific notability criteria for that (having read the source articles, something tells me he won't be offended, don't worry). There's plenty of coverage in reliable sources so I think he passes without too much trouble. Would ''strongly'' suggest, though, that the subject start respecting our |conflict of interest guidelines and ''stop'' editing his own article. Yeah Deletion of Justin Ross Lee WP:GNG||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
10110 11317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Hamilton (guitarist) User:Starblind 13:40, 15 September 2008 (UTC) delete per , and with a COI/vanity problem thrown in. Mikehamilton's behaviour in this AfD isn't helping matters any, either Deletion of Mike Hamilton (guitarist) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10111 8918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The canary press User:AmaryllisGardener 16:52, 5 May 2014 (UTC) delete per nom and RK, too young, failing Deletion of The canary press WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10112 7670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Aguirre User:Ohconfucius 09:59, 7 September 2009 (UTC) delete per . Neither his job, nor anything he has done (apart from dying) bestow notability Deletion of Peter Aguirre WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10113 6962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mddl Fngz User:Bearian 11:13, 16 March 2020 (UTC) delete per , , , and . Mixtapes? Myspace? ''Myspace Deletion of Mddl Fngz WP:SNOW||WP:MILL||WP:NBAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
10114 15042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katie Lohmann User:Carrite 09:28, 5 May 2011 (UTC) merge and '''merge''' to List of Playboy Playmates of 2001. Although she does not pass on her own, she could still be a search term, and whatever information is available here could simply be merged into the main article. All due respect to Deletion of Katie Lohmann WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10115 12123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Companies in Bangladesh User:Rebecca 12:24, 14 July 2007 (UTC) keep These were nominated ''last week'', and were closed as a keep. If you dispute the close, take that to . I see no other reason to go through this again Deletion of List of Companies in Bangladesh WP:DRV Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
10116 3751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samy Sana User:Papaursa 12:13, 19 August 2020 (UTC) keep He's won multiple world championships that are listed at and is currently ranked in the world top 10 (another criteria for showing notability). Much of the coverage can be considered routine sports reporting, but his accomplishments clearly qualify him as WP notable Deletion of Samy Sana WP:NKICK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10117 15887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bingle (2nd nomination) User:Elektrik 00:59, 16 July 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Bingle (2nd nomination) WP:NOTDIC Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10118 15588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zonalinfo User:Ayub407 18:38, 4 October 2015 (UTC) delete As per nominator, the article fails . I also can't find reliable sources Deletion of Zonalinfo WP:WEBCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10119 7509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of onomatopoeias User:ST47 13:47, 21 August 2006 (UTC) delete as per an indiscriminate collection of lists Deletion of List of onomatopoeias WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10120 16797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Regional Indian Penis Size User:Hyperdoctor 18:11, 15 April 2011 (UTC) delete as complete nonsense. Reference 3 does not have the title stated and does not address the topic stated in any way. The table is at best |original research with an unsupported explanation based on race. No evidence that a sensible article could be written on this topic Deletion of Regional Indian Penis Size WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10121 14704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deborah Winters User:Rhododendrites 23:33, 20 December 2015 (UTC) comment Fair enough. It looks like there's a case for and perhaps the issues are not as pervasive as they are with Chaney such that in this case it doesn't merit (especially considering it's pretty stripped down now). I'll just go ahead and withdraw this one. &mdash Deletion of Deborah Winters WP:NACTOR||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10122 12394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ingate Systems User:AllyD 06:32, 10 May 2013 (UTC) delete The article edit history shows significant editing by a succession of accounts associated with the company (one of which was blocked). That said, the current content is lacking in promotional overtones. But this just appears to be a firm going about its business; a Highbeam search turns up industry publication coverage of the firm's product announcements, but I am not finding evidence of |particular notability Deletion of Ingate Systems :WP:SPA||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
10123 11707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nagaruban Arumugam 2 [[User_talk:Josh Parris|Josh Parris]] 02:05, 31 January 2010 (UTC) delete """I was the proposer at 1st AfD. I've looked really hard at merging, but given the """"grueling"""" hours that Nagaruban Arumugam was working before his car crash was 50/week, and that the mention in the Australian Parliament was a one-liner in a multi-column question by a backbencher trying to make a point about health funding in his electorate (no parliamentary condolence motion, no further mention by that or any other member since), this is totally a and not worthy even of mention in Medical resident work hours. There has been no coronial attribution of crash, particularly to exhaustion which would justify mention in Medical resident work hours. In short, not notable due to and as best I can tell not worthy of even a mention in an encyclopedia""" Deletion of Nagaruban Arumugam 2 WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
10124 17534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Proctor User:Inter 02:46, 23 March 2021 (UTC) delete the opening sentence of the article already admits that the subject only plays semi-professionally so he obviously fails . Out of the three sources, one is from facebook, one doesn't mention him at all, and this one (see https://www.carmarthenquinsrfc.co.uk/welcome-to-the-mighty-quins-ben-leung here) is the most promising but it talks about a rugby player named Ben Leung, not Ben Proctor. Are they the same person? I don't know, and that source by itself would probably not be enough to pass Deletion of Ben Proctor WP:NRU||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10125 1194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/(Cry) All the Way Home User:Dhartung 20:08, 18 January 2007 (UTC) delete per and nomination. Strangely, it wasn't even bluelinked from Spinal Tap discography Deletion of (Cry) All the Way Home WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10126 11378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bicycle Safety Camp User:MichaelQSchmidt 23:36, 7 November 2014 (UTC) delete for failing . It's verifiable as a teaching aid and not something for wide for-profit distribution.https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Bicycle+Safety+Camp%22+video&num=50&source=lnms&tbm=bks&sa=X&ei=I1ddVJR7r5CKAraZgPgB&ved=0CA4Q_AUoAQ&biw=1024&bih=655https://www.google.com/search?num=50&q=%22Bicycle+Safety+Camp%22+video&oq=%22Bicycle+Safety+Camp%22+video&gs_l=serp.12..0.127114.129142.0.131178.7.7.0.0.0.0.96.611.7.7.0.msedr...0...1c.1.58.serp..0.7.611.iuZaq5kv0lU It ''might'' be mentioned within the article on American Academy of Pediatrics as one of their programs, but it lacks the level of notability required by guideline Deletion of Bicycle Safety Camp WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10127 13875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pink Five User:Yanksox 16:16, 6 June 2006 (UTC) keep Per Google Testhttp://www.google.com/search?sourceid=navclient&ie=UTF-8&rls=GGLD,GGLD:2004-27,GGLD:en&q=%22Pink+Five%22. Meets . Possible bad faith nom Deletion of Pink Five WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10128 21949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Übersite User:Michaelas10 17:56, 24 November 2006 (UTC) delete No verifiable references and a http://www.alexa.com/data/details/traffic_details?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ubersite.com very low traffic. Doesn't pass by any means Deletion of Übersite WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10129 3869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Daniel (film) [[User talk:Begoon|Begoon]] 11:16, 1 September 2019 (UTC) delete Fails . Note that there is also a draft, Draft:Jack Daniel (film) where work could continue if more coverage is found Deletion of Jack Daniel (film) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10130 19034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geoffrey Davis User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable biography. Recommend the article author see http://www.wikime.org/ WikiMe for writing biographies and/or http://www.wikitree.org WikiTree for writing genealogies. &mdash Deletion of Geoffrey Davis WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10131 13445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oh Doctor (band) User:Lugnuts 14:13, 14 May 2018 (UTC) delete per nom, seems a typical Myspace-esque band, failing . And for the record, I created the original page as a redirect, before it got hijacked by someone else three years later Deletion of Oh Doctor (band) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10132 11831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ViSalus User:BusterD 20:37, 1 October 2011 (UTC) delete Pretty much agree with the discussion of sources directly above. I see no sources ''about the company'' here which pass . Not impressed with passing . Unusual discussion, which has run over a month with no !votes Deletion of ViSalus WP:IRS||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10133 17257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blac Chyna User:WikiVirusC 22:30, 10 July 2017 (UTC) delete doesn't pass , and also applies. If it isn't a gossip magazine/column, the majority sources out there have to do with either relating to eitherRob Kardashian(and family) or Tyga. Redirect to Rob and Chyna after deletion, as it probably is a better place to put her bio then directly on Rob's page. Deleting first is preferable to just redirect, as this article has had a unreliable tag for over a year, and some of the older history contained even more issues with blp sources and reliability Deletion of Blac Chyna WP:NMODEL||WP:INVALIDBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10134 756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mathai Manjooran User:AllyD 21:00, 27 August 2017 (UTC) keep There is a summary biography https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=8CSQUxVjjWQC&lpg=PA85&dq=Mathai%20Manjooran%20Kerala&pg=PA101#v=onepage&q=Mathai%20Manjooran&f=false in this book which provides enough confirmation that the subject met criterion 1. (See also http://www.stateofkerala.in/niyamasabha/mathai_manjooran.php this biography Deletion of Mathai Manjooran :WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10135 3158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eddy Willems (2nd nomination) User:Boleyn 20:08, 15 August 2017 (UTC) comment So this article was created by {{u|GGGTeam}} (), then the other main contributors were {{u|G Kindermans}} and {{u|WikieWikie}} (also s). {{u|LiverpoolLorry}} made a handful of edits in 2011, then nothing until this AfD 6 years later. I am doubtful about both commenters above (or the same?) I'm calling . And the G Kindermans who has commented above is presumably Guy Kindermans, senior staff writer on Willems' blog http://eddywillems.blogspot.co.uk/2007/02/. Any needs to be clearly stated Deletion of Eddy Willems (2nd nomination) WP:SPA||WP:SPA||WP:DUCK||WP:COI Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
10136 2300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ceramic chemistry User:Mike 20:50, 14 February 2013 (UTC) comment More than enough exist to write a detailed article about the chemistry of ceramics, including: http://books.google.com/books?id=TYUvAQAAIAAJ ''The Chemistry of Ceramics'' (Wiley, 1996), http://books.google.com/books?id=Q58c6SBVnC0C ''Chemical Processing of Ceramics'' (CRC 2010), http://books.google.com/books?id=-kkNAQAAIAAJ ''High temperature chemistry of inorganic and ceramic materials'' (Chemical Society, 1977) and the older http://books.google.com/books?id=uCJDAAAAIAAJ ''Ceramic Chemistry'' (Davis Bros., 1912). I agree with comments on the Talk page that the article as it is currently written has serious issues, but it may still have were it to be rewritten; quality problems can be |surmounted by ordinary editing. My concern is that the topic may not be sufficiently differentiated from material already covered in other articles such as Ceramic, Ceramic materials and Ceramic engineering to warrant a separate Ceramic chemistry article Deletion of Ceramic chemistry WP:RS||WP:POTENTIAL||WP:SURMOUNTABLE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10137 7686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/N. Kumara User:Reyk 12:20, 8 August 2019 (UTC) delete This article is based on raw statistical entries that do not contain a word of prose between them. Given that we only have a first initial and a (common) surname for this player there might even be issues distinguishing him from similarly named people active around the same time. Harrias is correct that defers to the general notability guideline, and not the other way around. A '''merge''' to a suitable list article might be possible if there is a good target Deletion of N. Kumara WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10138 14014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 Arkema plant explosion User:Unscintillating 22:14, 6 September 2017 (UTC) keep due to upgrades by Deletion of 2017 Arkema plant explosion WP:HEYMANN Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
10139 11273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashfaq Ahmed Shareef User:DCI2026 01:25, 1 March 2013 (UTC) delete He does not pass and . I am a bit hesitant only because of the available RS about his election; other than this, however, no other reliable info on the subject can be found Deletion of Ashfaq Ahmed Shareef WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10140 18650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Hocker User:RayAYang 15:12, 12 November 2008 (UTC) delete Fails . Strong promotional tendencies as well, so even if kept, would need to be cut dramatically to a stub (i.e. ). Just short of a speedy, IMO Deletion of Paul Hocker WP:BIO||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
10141 19506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jimmyism User:LinguistAtLarge 20:16, 7 May 2009 (UTC) delete """Being a |neologism is not necessarily grounds for deletion, but being a |non-notable one definitely is. I couldn't find anything substantial in Gnews, Gscholar, or Gbooks. Note that """"jimmyism"""" was also used in other contexts, referring to other Jimmys as well. — """ Deletion of Jimmyism WP:NEO||WP:N Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10142 5562 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of scandals with """"-gate"""" suffix (2nd nomination)""" user:Andrew 07:21, 9 September 2017 (UTC) keep There's no case to answer -- see """Deletion of List of scandals with """"-gate"""" suffix (2nd nomination)""" WP:UNENCYCLOPEDIC Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10143 9420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delta Son User:K 02:22, 15 September 2016 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Delta Son WP:TOOSOON||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Too soon 40
10144 14031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marin Marić User:Lightburst 23:26, 5 November 2019 (UTC) keep Passes GNG with NBC Sports and Daily Chronicle reliable sources. Also the subject passes #1 for being the http://euromillionsbasketball.be/article?id=5769 Most Valuable Player of the week for the Pro Basketball League {{tq|The person has received a well-known and significant award or honor, or has been nominated for such an award several times Deletion of Marin Marić WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10145 3367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madison McKinley User:NinjaRobotPirate 23:42, 4 July 2014 (UTC) delete There certainly are trace elements of notability, but I'm thinking this might be a case of having been created |too soon. As the nominator notes, COI/promotional edits have also been a problem, which generally lead me to the conclusion that it's not ready to stand on its own two feet yet. Once there's more coverage in |reliable sources, the article can be recreated. Right now, there isn't really much to say except that she appeared on a reality TV show Deletion of Madison McKinley WP:TOOSOON||WP:RS Wikipedia:Too soon 40
10146 18843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/July 2009 cyber attacks User:Cazort 17:35, 11 July 2009 (UTC) delete """I think creation of this page was premature and violates . Although it may turn out that these attacks are notable in the long-run, it's too early to know this and I see no evidence of |notability yet. What is lost by waiting a few months before writing an article? What if there are more attacks in August? In September? Then the title and organization of this topic will be inaccurate. I also find no evidence that these attacks are notable ''as a topic in and of themselves''. There has been pretty much steady coverage of a variety of cyber attacks over the past several years and I have seen nothing that makes this particular one stand out. See this search: http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22cyber+attacks%22&cf=all. Also, searching in google for the phrase """"July 2009 cyber attacks"""" on google yields only hits that are mirroring or referencing this article. Also see this search: http://news.google.com/news?pz=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22july+2009%22+cyber+attack. The coverage is all within a 3 day time-window. Someone jumped the gun here and I say to delete both because I see no evidence of notability as a topic in and of itself, and also in order to discourage this sort of activity in the future""" Deletion of July 2009 cyber attacks WP:NOTNEWS||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10147 8969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Muslim soldiers User:DGG 04:31, 14 March 2009 (UTC) keep it's a perfectly fine list, and is |notable. Per Deletion of List of Muslim soldiers WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10148 9674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nature of life User:Salimfadhley 11:12, 17 August 2014 (UTC) delete WP:ESSAY Deletion of Nature of life WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10149 21677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mario Kart Drunk Dash User:Doc 16:08, 11 February 2008 (UTC) delete totally NN drinking game, looks |made up Deletion of Mario Kart Drunk Dash WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
10150 7059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cardano (cryptocurrency) User:Isenta 11:45, 30 January 2018 (UTC) keep clearly notable through extensive coverage in reliable sources. If the article has problems, fix them. That's not a reason to delete. Editor edit warring my Snow Keep should be sanctioned. Claiming 'none of the criteria' have been met and attacking the credibility of me and '90%' of the people voting keep. . Consensus is clear, this is a waste of time. There is no chance this article gets deleted Deletion of Cardano (cryptocurrency) WP:AGF||WP:NPA Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
10151 7807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Epic metal (2nd nomination) User:Prolog 07:59, 1 December 2006 (UTC) delete WP:V|Unverifiable and not very |notable characteristic Deletion of Epic metal (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10152 9708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesus clip User:First 01:01, 7 June 2010 (UTC) comment """No. In addition, the mountain bike reference actually has as the definition of """"Jesus Clip"""" as """"(see circlip)"""".http://books.google.com/books?id=xrqmmPXEP8sC&pg=PT158 The slang dictionary reference essentially says that it's a slang term, not a neologism. The first sentence of the article is the only part that is referenced. This could arguably be a one-sentence stub on a slang term, but then it would be going up against """ Deletion of Jesus clip WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10153 11148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Zenon User:Ejgreen77 05:24, 14 September 2020 (UTC) keep Meets and , per Cbl62's sourcing and improvements to the article Deletion of Jonathan Zenon WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10154 19227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeSoto Records User:Chubbles 16:08, 25 April 2021 (UTC) keep The nominator appears not to have considered any before this nomination; this label is run by two members of Jawbox and is distributed by Fontana Records, which means ''at most'' that a merge would be appropriate. A redlink here flatly does not serve readers interested in this topic, and DeSoto put out some of the more important indie rock releases of the 1990s. The label's dissolution (in 2002, mind you; how much coverage are we going to expect to find on Google?) was significant enough to attract notice from ''CMJ New Music Report'' (https://books.google.com/books?id=sC8jJAQBHtEC&pg=PA4&dq=%22desoto+records%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiWysCO45nwAhXHGs0KHR8rBXgQ6AEwAnoECAAQAg#v=onepage&q=%22desoto%20records%22&f=false) and ''Billboard'' (https://www.billboard.com/articles/news/74414/desoto-label-revamps-bands-regroup), which certainly indicates to me that the label fully deserves its own article Deletion of DeSoto Records WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
10155 18877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mariam Anwar User:Harrias 08:21, 26 August 2019 (UTC) delete regretfully, despite more research, I've failed to find additional sources to demonstrate that the subject meets . I suspect that it is unlikely that much will turn up, primarily because of the attitudes towards women playing sports in Pakistan Deletion of Mariam Anwar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10156 18660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dhaka University Model United Nations Association User:Kmzayeem 14:47, 8 August 2014 (UTC) keep passes going with the references given. Would have supported merger with University of Dhaka but that will give undue weight to the subject Deletion of Dhaka University Model United Nations Association WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10157 12779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/P.J.Vanston User:Joe 14:24, 8 May 2010 (UTC) delete Non-notable |author of one self-published novel Deletion of P.J.Vanston WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10158 179 [[Chantara]] (erl., gelöscht) Benutzer:Zxmt NONE keep """gem. #Musiker gilt als relevant, wer ''""""ein Werk komponiert, getextet oder interpretiert haben, das auf einem kommerziellen Tonträger eines renommierten Labels veröffentlicht wurde (keine Samplerbeiträge, Singles und EPs)""""''. Die Sängerin hat ein Album als Interpretin herausgebracht, welches beim Label Timezone (Musiklabel) erschienen ist. Das Label ist enzyklopdäsich relevant (in einer LD vom 6. April 2016 wurde auf """"behalten"""" entschieden) und es haben dort eine Reihe von enzyklopädisch relevanten Künstlern veröffentlicht; damit liegt nach unseren Kriterien ein """"renommiertes"""" Label vor. Da die RK Einschlusskriterien sind, ist eine weitere Diskussion oder Bewertung überflüssig: das RK ist erfüllt und die Person damit enzyklopädisch relevant. Nach unseren RK ist grundsätzlich und ausnahmslos jeder(!) Interpret relevant, der einen Tonträger bei einem renommierten Label veröffentlicht hat. Wem das nicht passt, der möge sich für eine Änderung der RK oder ggf. für WP:LP des Labels einsetzen; dann könnte man auch den Fall von dieser Sängerin möglicherweise anders bewerten""" Löschung von Chantara Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10159 20019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iranian famine of 1942–1943 User:Pahlevun 14:50, 10 December 2019 (UTC) keep per . Nominator fails to provide a valid rationale while there are many sources, like https://voxeu.org/article/famines-wwii this by one of leading experts on famine, Cormac Ó Gráda Deletion of Iranian famine of 1942–1943 WP:SKCRIT Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
10160 20244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Anna Frisch User:Wdchk 01:00, 30 July 2014 (UTC) delete """Article fails to support claim of """"World Renown"""" (''sic''). No independent sources. Just a promotional bio; for me, this is borderline """ Deletion of Dr. Anna Frisch WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
10161 12686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mithila (Nepal) User:Dwainwr123 03:59, 12 May 2012 (UTC) keep Article is poorly written, but topic is notable. I see at least 25 references to |independent reliable sources Deletion of Mithila (Nepal) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10162 17183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Superstar (2009 film) User:Stefka 16:00, 1 December 2020 (UTC) delete Not a notable film, failing Deletion of Superstar (2009 film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
10163 10104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Feature (band) User:Lewishhh 14:21, 16 June 2018 (UTC) keep Significant coverage and all sources are reliable music press, agree that it passes //. All are reviews, apart from perhaps one which is a premiere, so don't agree that they are promotional, it's just favourable coverage Deletion of Feature (band) WP:NMUSIC||WP:BAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10164 15585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Pitman User:JamesBWatson 10:27, 17 February 2011 (UTC) delete """I can fully sympathise with Timpitman, and I do understand his point of view. However, as is unfortunately very common among people new to editing Wikipedia, his conception of Wikipedia's purpose is mistaken. Wikipedia does not seek to maintain """"a database of football clubs and football players"""" which should be """"as comprehensive as possible"""", but rather to make readily available information on subjects which have a significant degree of |notability as demonstrated by coverage in |reliable sources. Timpitman, you are welcome to suggest changes in Wikipedia's guidelines and policies if you want to, but this deletion nomination will be decided on the basis of the guidelines and policies which exist at present, and unfortunately your reasons do not address those. (This is not the place for a detailed discussion of whether the notability guidelines should be changed, but it is worth mentioning that we have to draw the line somewhere, or we would have articles about my left sock. Wherever we draw the line someone will object, with cries of """"discrimination"""" and the like. It is reasonable to debate where the line should be drawn, but not to suggest there should be no line""" Deletion of Tim Pitman WP:NOTE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10165 8712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Alessi (2nd nomination) User:ColonialGrid 04:43, 11 February 2015 (UTC) delete doesn't seem to exceed 's general notability guidelines as there doesn't appear to be significant media/independent third party coverage. Carrite, Australian local municipalities are generally much weaker with less responsibility than American ones; they control little more than basic service provisions (rubbish, libraries, parks, local roads, etc) with major services (hospitals, policing, transport, education, major planning and planning overlay approval, etc) provided or controlled by state and federal governments. Queensland is an exception to this rule with Brisbane City Council covering much of the population, Melbourne on the other hand has over 30 councils of which Whittlesea is one. Also bear in mind that very few Australian mayors are popularly elected, with Whittlesea being no exception, so he wasn't elected as mayor, he was elected as a councillor and appointed mayor (it is now reasonably common to have a rotating mayor in Victoria Deletion of Sam Alessi (2nd nomination) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10166 2894 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of """"Occupy"""" protest locations""" User:Northamerica1000 05:58, 16 October 2011 (UTC) keep A functional, useful directory and list. Also passes : numerous references """Deletion of List of """"Occupy"""" protest locations""" WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10167 7997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdul Quddoos Khan User:Bearian 22:58, 23 March 2020 (UTC) delete per - only famous because |a terrorist was arrest in his house Deletion of Abdul Quddoos Khan WP:GNG||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
10168 16226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lukumanu iddrisu User:Rentier 23:55, 12 January 2018 (UTC) delete fails , due to lack of substantial coverage in multiple independent reliable sources. The award for his BS thesis does not establish notability by any stretch of imagination Deletion of Lukumanu iddrisu WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10169 4377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamisama Kazoku User:Knowledgekid87 21:57, 28 July 2014 (UTC) keep per Farix's reference findings. You might want to read before nominating things for deletion Deletion of Kamisama Kazoku WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
10170 11722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abyss of Chaos User:Motor 10:13, 17 June 2006 (UTC) delete db-nocontext added. Even if you overlook that, it reads like a howto for a game Deletion of Abyss of Chaos WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10171 4890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Midori Hayase User:Collectonian 15:08, 15 February 2010 (UTC) delete unnotable voice actress who fails and ; no significant coverage in any reliable, third-party sources, unable to craft any viable compliant article, must be deleted Deletion of Midori Hayase WP:BIO||WP:N||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10172 152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jelly Jump User:Kirbanzo 15:58, 20 August 2018 (UTC) delete fails , no notable Ghits Deletion of Jelly Jump WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10173 12228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beatrice Olivier User:PlotHelpful 10:16, 1 December 2018 (UTC) delete I couldn't find any and she fails Deletion of Beatrice Olivier WP:RS||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10174 12135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hörður Björgvin Magnússon (2nd nomination) User:GiantSnowman 17:47, 4 February 2011 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Hörður Björgvin Magnússon (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10175 1795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anjou Soares User:Mar4d 22:40, 28 October 2017 (UTC) delete fails . Note that he was CEO of a Diocese, not the Bishop. We keep Bishops even as stubs, with a diocesan administrator, we need sources. I ran some news archive searches, and failed to find anything Deletion of Anjou Soares WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10176 241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Statik G User:Lemongirl942 08:37, 27 November 2016 (UTC) delete This seems to be a bit . At the moment there are not enough coverage in reliable sources to satisfy or . No objection to a recreation should more sources be found in the future Deletion of Statik G WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Too soon 40
10177 11247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bigoted woman incident User:Reenem 16:33, 28 April 2010 (UTC) delete per . However, this should be mentioned in the articles that mention the elections Deletion of Bigoted woman incident WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10178 11977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thrive15 user:Tautomers 06:56, 30 June 2021 (UTC) delete References do appear to make it look well sourced, but none stack up to provide meaningful information. The company simply isn't notable at all and readily fails ; little appears in search. Company feels scammy too Deletion of Thrive15 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10179 8000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Foods/Products that contain High Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS) User:Ctjf83 09:56, 28 February 2010 (UTC) delete per Mercurywoodrose, also Deletion of Foods/Products that contain High Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS) WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10180 18980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Wagner (pastor) User:Skirts89 20:13, 16 January 2019 (UTC) delete This fails and is probably COI Deletion of John Wagner (pastor) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10181 6702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shady Is Back User:Doc 21:55, 6 September 2010 (UTC) delete WP:CRYSTAL|crystal ballery, no sources to prove existence and |way too early anyway Deletion of Shady Is Back WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:There is no deadline 35
10182 2070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Donnellan User:Rms125a 14:19, 29 May 2016 (UTC) delete as |insufficiently notable actor; possibly |too soon Deletion of Sean Donnellan WP:NACTOR||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
10183 20536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (Plot Summary) User:Malevious 21:49, 22 July 2007 (UTC) delete Per #PLOT, even though it was a good book it still doesn't need it own page for a plot. --Malevious Deletion of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (Plot Summary) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10184 8278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zubair Ahmed (doctor) User:Electiondata 02:43, 29 May 2020 (UTC) delete Non notable doctor.Fails Deletion of Zubair Ahmed (doctor) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10185 9215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Gartside User:MelanieN 15:30, 1 November 2011 (UTC) comment The article's creator (an , and based on the comments below possibly a as well) posted the following comment on the discussion page when he/she contested the prod Deletion of Robert Gartside WP:SPA||WP:COI Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
10186 12479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Saunders User:Necrothesp 12:24, 19 May 2021 (UTC) keep Deputy head and acting head of a significant agency of the UN. Clearly enough sourcing to meet Deletion of Christian Saunders WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10187 229 [[Vorlage:Geneall]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Kmhkmh 21:46, 12. Sep. 2010 (CEST) delete Im Portal Geschichte (siehe auch dortige Diskussion) ist man bisher einstmmig der Ansicht, dass diese Webseite und WP:WEB nicht erfüllt und eine Verwendung, wenn überhaupt nur in sehr seltenen Ausnahmefällen zulässig bzw. sinnvoll ist. Daher sollte keine Vorlage existieren, die einen andersweitigen Eindruck erweckt Löschung von Vorlage:Geneall Wikipedia:Q Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10188 13800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Golf Kingdoms user:Hellknowz 17:44, 4 July 2013 (UTC) delete No reliable WP::VG/RS hits. I see a http://www.148apps.com/reviews/golf-kingdoms-review/ 148apps.com review, which is not listed as VG/RS, but their editorial makes them situational at least. http://appadvice.com/appnn/2012/06/quickadvice-golfkingdom appadvice.coms is similar, but doesn't appear reliable, more like a blog. Besides press releases and directory entries, that's all I see though, not enough to pass . — Deletion of Golf Kingdoms WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10189 6554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Scott (footballer) (2nd nomination) User:Malcolmxl5 23:05, 2 March 2008 (UTC) delete Fails thlete Deletion of David Scott (footballer) (2nd nomination) WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
10190 9206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michel Bacos [[User talk:Nableezy|nableezy]]''' - 05:14, 21 June 2011 (UTC) comment Id like to make one note before I bid you all farewell. I dont think WP:BIO1E applies, what counts here is BLP1E. If there is some evidence that this person is no longer living I would withdraw the nomination, but as no such evidence exists I think we have to recognize that the standards of BLP1E , part of a policy (), which are a bit more stringent than BIO1E, which is part of a guideline (otability (people)), are what counts here. I dont think there is evidence that the subject meets any reasonable interpretation of the requirements of BLP1E, and the one offered above by Ep would essentially turn that part of the policy into nothing as all people notable for a single event are covered in the coverage of that event Deletion of Michel Bacos WP:BLP||WP:N Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10191 14389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ambulance Operators Association of Nova Scotia [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 05:31, 26 June 2013 (UTC) keep yeah, the article is an absolute mess and I'm tempted to cite . I might have a crack at cleaning it up. But there are a few sources that provide some early-90s detail and the organisation seems to have been an integral part of emergency service provision in that area, at that time. http://www.gov.ns.ca/health/ehs/background.asp This is the Government's take on their relationship with the organisation. http://www.collectionscanada.gc.ca/obj/s4/f2/dsk3/ftp05/mq22033.pdf This academic paper provides some detail about their political campaigns and builds on what is covered in the Government source. I'm inclined to think that an organisation considered by the Government to be part of the history of the area is likely to be notable. If the things claimed in the article actually happened, they would obviously have been the subject of much press coverage so we should keep digging Deletion of Ambulance Operators Association of Nova Scotia WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
10192 18830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank Bovalino User:Eddie 01:36, 30 July 2010 (UTC) delete As a candidate for office he clearly fails . Nothing else about him seems notable either wrt wiki policies Deletion of Frank Bovalino WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10193 20543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haji Saeed Ur Rehman Khan Karar User:Ifnord 21:10, 13 March 2020 (UTC) delete for failing to meet . I do not see a claim to notability that meets criteria in the article, never-mind the lack of references Deletion of Haji Saeed Ur Rehman Khan Karar WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10194 2114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hugo Maisnik User:Toughpigs 23:23, 21 June 2020 (UTC) keep Here's https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/features/la-billboard-diva-angelyne-bemoans-812987 coverage in The Hollywood Reporter. Per , the article should be retained and improved Deletion of Hugo Maisnik WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
10195 17711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tito Perdue (2nd nomination) User:Tillerh11 22:02, 21 August 2018 (UTC) keep And Nom for ignoring that AfD. I came upon this one going though the AUTHORS AfD; The discussion looked like a slam dunk delte. Nevertheless, I did as I usually do with authors and ran him through a proquest news archive search (I find starting with the search more efficient than startin by reading all the comments; which often look different after I've seen what comes up in a search,) and... '''WOW!''' His books were extremely widely reviewed. That was when I noticed Deletion of Tito Perdue (2nd nomination) WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Whacking with a wet trout 74
10196 20772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pet anus cover User:Esquivalience 02:34, 16 July 2015 (UTC) delete fails , no coverage, non-notable concept Deletion of Pet anus cover WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10197 1605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eon8 (2nd nomination) User:Ashibaka 16:22, 1 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Eon8 (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10198 18450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Whiteside user:Celestianpower 22:04, 30 July 2006 (UTC) delete While he's a great guy (I live down the road from him :P), he's certainly not notable, according to . I created the article about a year ago, while I was still relatively new and naive... &mdash Deletion of Martin Whiteside WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10199 10235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stalin (Card Game) User:GlassCobra 19:36, 22 October 2009 (UTC) delete not a G3, but definitely falls afoul of . No objection to a SNOW close, as this is a pretty obvious outcome Deletion of Stalin (Card Game) WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
10200 9728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ifeanyi Agu User:Anasskoko NONE delete No significant coverage in independent reliable sources, the ones in the main Article are just name check and pass by mention, only reference one talked about him, and the source is primary, atleast he didn't pass Deletion of Ifeanyi Agu WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10201 17057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MacroGeo User:Meatsgains 16:53, 4 October 2016 (UTC) delete Subject lacks coverage in RS and appears to be a case of Deletion of MacroGeo WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
10202 1682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/XS Malarkey User:Mr 08:48, 21 September 2010 (UTC) keep """Well it certainly exists, as even a perfunctory search will show. And according to ''The Guardian'' http://www.guardian.co.uk/stage/2008/jun/07/comedy here, and ''The Independent'' http://www.independent.co.uk/travel/uk/south-east-england/the-travellers-guide-to-comedy-england-950023.html here, it's popular. AfD is not , so it boils down to this: should comedy clubs be in Wikipedia? Back to ''The Grauniad'', this time http://www.guardian.co.uk/stage/2007/sep/22/comedy here; """"Running a comedy club for a decade is quite an achievement in any circumstances, but outside London, on a shoestring, it really is something to be proud of."""" So, keep""" Deletion of XS Malarkey WP:CLEANUP Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
10203 4090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Veracity of statements by Donald Trump (2nd nomination) User:Wikiacc 01:40, 19 December 2019 (UTC) keep """Political"""" is fine; POV is not. Do you see a violation? If so, where? Anyhow, there's nothing stopping you from making """"Veracity of statements by other president"""" articles, as long as they're notable""" Deletion of Veracity of statements by Donald Trump (2nd nomination) WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
10204 11518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pichenotte User:Gråbergs 07:18, 29 September 2020 (UTC) delete I didn't find any sources either, though I found one for Pitchnut I put in that article, so it has one ref now. I wonder if it would be a good idea to merge some of these articles for similar games into one artice, see :Category:Disk-flicking games, Football-style Deletion of Pichenotte WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10205 16216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thirdwatch User:AllyD 19:18, 16 January 2021 (UTC) delete An article created on the 11th edit by a briefly active new account, setting out a company's wares. Aside from the start-up funding announcement in 2017 and being one recipient of a non-notable industry award in 2018, searches find announcement-based coverage on their purchase by Razorpay in August 2019. There is insufficient |coverage for and no article on the acquiring company which could serve as a redirect target Deletion of Thirdwatch :WP:RS||:WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10206 1665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Sokol User:MER 07:46, 6 January 2007 (UTC) delete no evidence of meeting Deletion of Jason Sokol WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10207 13220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VMRay User:AllyD 08:37, 18 February 2021 (UTC) delete I tagged this to query notability in 2015 and that remains the issue. More recently, the article creator has indicated (https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk%3ACloeven&type=revision&diff=975303220&oldid=975302044 here) that they were employed by the company when the article was created. Leaving that issue aside, the article's material and references about the founders' academic work and the company's funding are insufficient for and the remainder is a product list. The SC Media positive review of the company's main product is also insufficient; my searches also found a recent paywalled Westdeutsche Allgemeine Zeitung item (https://www.waz.de/wirtschaft/wirtschaft-in-nrw/hackerangriffe-start-ups-staerken-die-firewall-mensch-id231594613.html Hackerangriffe: Start-ups stärken die Firewall Mensch) with some coverage of the firm, but I don't see enough for Deletion of VMRay :WP:COI||:WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
10208 7871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Most Viewed Porn Videos of All Time User:Blythwood 05:04, 12 January 2016 (UTC) delete I don't see how this can reliably be measured or therefore be an honest title. It seems to just |promote the porn video sites listed. Fails Deletion of List of Most Viewed Porn Videos of All Time WP:PROMO||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10209 7815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tatsumaki Senpuukyaku User:EEMIV 18:09, 28 October 2010 (UTC) delete and redirect. No assertion of or claim to |notability; no citations to |reliable sources Deletion of Tatsumaki Senpuukyaku WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10210 13833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Soares User:Reckless182 17:40, 24 January 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Alex Soares WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10211 14229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sub school charging User:Groupthink 09:22, 18 June 2007 (UTC) comment Does this thing have any realistic chance of survival? Would an admin be kind enough to kill as |snowballed Deletion of Sub school charging WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
10212 15188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dorris Francis User:TonyBallioni 15:17, 24 January 2018 (UTC) delete as a human interest piece that fails NOTNEWS. The GNG is only a guideline that is rebuttable presumption (click the WikiLink in and look at the endless talk page discussions there going back years on this subject). Whether or not this article passes the GNG is irrelevant to whether we should keep it per our guidelines. The GNG is not an absolute right for inclusion, consensus is policy and common sense must prevail. Depth of coverage does not only refer to the amount of coverage in a piece, but also the level of critical journalistic analysis. We don't have that here. This fails both points of , it is excluded by OT as routine news coverage, and it also lacks the depth of coverage we would expect under the GNG. Even if it meets the GNG, we are free to decide by consensus that it does not warrant an article because of the nature of the coverage: that has been the long established consensus at , and it must be considered here Deletion of Dorris Francis WP:N||WP:N||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10213 14459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United Express Flight 3411 User:AusLondonder 19:35, 11 April 2017 (UTC) keep """A lot of the arguments above and poor and not based in policy but overall I have to lean towards keep. Public relations damage and financial implications do appear to be materialising which gives this some lasting significance. actually states '''As Wikipedia is not a paper source, editors are encouraged to include current and up-to-date information within its coverage, and to develop stand-alone articles on significant current events'''. discourages """"routine news reporting on things like announcements, sports, or celebrities"""" - not major controversies""" Deletion of United Express Flight 3411 WP:NOTNEWS||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10214 11108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Romano (ER) User:Finnusertop 12:15, 27 June 2019 (UTC) comment """re|Lord Opeth}} """"mentions"""" are not enough. There needs to be significant coverage. Can you list sources that push it above ? – """ Deletion of Robert Romano (ER) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10215 3686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathan Future User:Ohconfucius 07:28, 17 August 2006 (UTC) delete Wrestled indy starting in 1999 and ending in 1999. Deletion of Nathan Future WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10216 6446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan McFaul User:GPL93 14:37, 28 February 2019 (UTC) delete fails , totally unsourced. Best Deletion of Ryan McFaul WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10217 2124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/G. B. Singh User:Qworty 18:26, 18 January 2011 (UTC) keep His books meet and he himself meets . His entry and the entries about his books appear to have become, from time to time, battlegrounds for POV warring. I am not completely familiar with the arguments used in the edit warring, and will only note that he and his books are notable and that edit warring has no place in the project Deletion of G. B. Singh WP:BK||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10218 11622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whale watching in Brazil User:Schwede66 20:00, 30 April 2014 (UTC) keep Whale watching in New Zealand is certainly notable, and I have just expanded the article to make it more encyclopaedic. One of the senior NZ admins had already rated the article for ikiProject New Zealand|Wikiproject New Zealand and has given it mid-importance, which further demonstrates the point. I have no opinion or knowledge about notability of other country articles Deletion of Whale watching in Brazil WP:W Help:Watchlist 110
10219 11179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CyborgLog User:Quirex 19:14, 13 December 2006 (UTC) comment """it doesn't have to mention that word, it is the same topic. You wouldn't expect academics to use slang. If you think it is an inappropriate title etc then suggest a renaming. The point is that this article is not about a silly word it is about the topic of """"glogging"""" (god that's a lame name, Stephen Mann should be ashamed). You can't claim it fails and with the shear amount of peer reviewed literature about the article. What this article could do more with would be an academic bibliography of glogging related articles but NONE of them have to mention the word glog or cyborglog. Side note did you check the academic literature? I did: http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=glogging&hl=en&lr=&btnG=Search. There are mentions of glogging in academic literature (most from Stephen Mann) and these appeared in peer reviewed workshops. Thus there are multiple non-trivial real world mentions of '''Glogging''' thus it passes and , and since and are satisfied so is criteria 1 of """ Deletion of CyborgLog WP:V||WP:RS||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:RS||WP:V||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10220 3170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy Coyle User:AbsolutDan 19:17, 1 July 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. It appears to be a |vanity article too Deletion of Andy Coyle WP:VANITY Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
10221 9918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burnt Oak Records User:Esradekan 05:03, 10 September 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability per Deletion of Burnt Oak Records WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10222 12580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Duke Mason (4th nomination) User:GretLomborg 18:32, 26 June 2017 (UTC) comment Considering this is the fifth AfD for this BLP, is this page a candidate for '''Wikipedia:Administrators%27_guide/Protecting#Salting_a_deleted_page|salting''' (), due to its deletion/recreation history Deletion of James Duke Mason (4th nomination) WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
10223 11778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bearcatbird User:MLauba 14:49, 12 October 2009 (UTC) delete No independent |reliable sources to indicate this passes our |inclusion guidelines. Nice one, though Deletion of Bearcatbird WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10224 9187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LesPAC User:SamHolt6 01:01, 20 April 2019 (UTC) delete """Nom is correct; the article's sources do not meet on account of them being either trivial in nature, standard business announcements, or press releases (the French ''communique''). In addition, none of the sources I read attested to the notability or |significance of the subject—I doubt being """"Quebec’s first-ever classified ad website"""" qualifies as being a credible claim to significance""" Deletion of LesPAC WP:NCORP||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
10225 14073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alliance Graduate School [[User talk:202.124.73.30|talk]]) 03:05, 19 May 2012 (UTC) comment The material is there on the web if you look properly, as in http://www.pcnc.com.ph/view-ngodetails.php?itemId=1936 this list of NGOs, various local government sites, and some news coverage. It's on a list of CHED-accredited colleges, but that's gone offline, and the archive on scribd is not really a . -- Special:Contributions/202.124.73.30|202.124.73.30 Deletion of Alliance Graduate School WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10226 16568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neo-shanty User:Dimitrii 19:36, 25 January 2009 (UTC) delete WP:OR Neologism, Give it some time to see if it takes off Deletion of Neo-shanty WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10227 15627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bobiwan User:Matticus78 21:40, 21 July 2006 (UTC) delete A site started this year, which is hosted on a free web space provider, with only one relevant GHit in the top 100 (and not the site itself, I might add). Definately doesn't pass there Deletion of Bobiwan WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10228 19904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Live streaming crimes User:Ajf773 08:11, 25 January 2017 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Live streaming crimes WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10229 16181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/San Francisco Anthem User:Esradekan 14:19, 23 September 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Songs Deletion of San Francisco Anthem WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10230 3354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heap pollution User:Bluerasberry 19:17, 15 July 2014 (UTC) delete No attempt is made to comply with Wikipedia's inclusion criteria at or otherwise Deletion of Heap pollution WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10231 18969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edwin Adams Cotto User:onel5969 19:16, 26 December 2020 (UTC) delete not enough coverage to pass Deletion of Edwin Adams Cotto WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10232 9599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Future of Forestry User:Hu12 21:04, 16 December 2006 (UTC) keep Looks like it passes . To Deletion of Future of Forestry WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10233 594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marjan Bojadziev User:Qrsdogg 00:21, 27 May 2011 (UTC) keep Looks like there is a clear case that he meets Deletion of Marjan Bojadziev WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10234 1704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pile-on User:Jayden54 14:52, 24 December 2006 (UTC) delete I believe it's quite a common term, but I can't find any reliable sources, so delete per and unless some reliable sources can be found Deletion of Pile-on WP:V||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10235 19019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kanchipuram (film) User:David 01:11, 19 October 2007 (UTC) delete a #Future films, incomplete films, and undistributed films|future film, no sources asserting the production itself is notable Deletion of Kanchipuram (film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10236 16269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prakash Chandra User:Wm335td 16:27, 7 October 2020 (UTC) delete This is Deletion of Prakash Chandra WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
10237 15563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Archeology (band) User:Gongshow 02:24, 6 March 2013 (UTC) delete I'm seeing bits of coverage around, including brief write-ups tied to upcoming concert appearances (e.g., http://www.boiseweekly.com/boise/archeology/Content?oid=2527053http://www.portlandmercury.com/portland/archeology-lakes-porches-and-alameda/Event?oid=2492764) and an interview with ''Filter (magazine)|Filter'' magazine http://filtermagazine.com/index.php/news/entry/qa_archaeology_plus_white_walls_exclusive_video_premiere. Seems too weak on the whole, however; not convinced there's enough to meet Deletion of Archeology (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10238 19148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gus Alzona User:Ohconfucius 08:42, 4 September 2006 (UTC) delete resumé per a soapbox Deletion of Gus Alzona WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10239 18634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gail Hershatter User:Necrothesp 13:01, 13 March 2015 (UTC) keep Actually, as a Distinguished Professor at the University of Californiahttp://history.ucsc.edu/faculty/profiles/singleton.php?&singleton=true&cruz_id=gbhers, she does meet #5 Deletion of Gail Hershatter WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10240 8547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/It's My Life (shelved Bollywood film) User:Chetsford 19:42, 13 May 2017 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of It's My Life (shelved Bollywood film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10241 11218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timothy W. Lynch User:Jrp 14:19, 26 January 2006 (UTC) comment Article has been updated with three points (in order of importance) which I believe may satisfy . First, that Mr. Lynch was a regular reviewer/colunmist for ''TV Zone'' magazine, for several years in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Second, that he was a writer for the trivia video game ''Star Trek: The Video Game''. (It's a Star Trek-themed ''You Don't Know Jack''-style game.) And finally, that he wrote the forward to the nonfiction book ''Net Trek''. The third is of debatable merit, but the combination of the first two seems to satisfy the guideline Deletion of Timothy W. Lynch WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10242 177 [[Harry Potter (fiktive Person)]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Streifengrasmaus NONE comment """Hmmmm... Auf der Diskussionsseite des """"unsäglich langen Sammelartikels"""" arbeiten wir schon seit längerem daran, ihn zu kürzen und übersichtlicher zu machen. Es gab kürzlich auch ein Meinungsbild zum Thema, das ohne rechtes Ergebnis endete: /Umgang mit Sammelartikeln zu fiktiven Welten. Die Umsetzung wird gerade auf der Diskussionsseite von Figuren der Harry-Potter-Romane diskutiert, da geht auch um Aufteilung oder Neustrukturierung. Ich werde dort mal auf diesen Artikel und die Löschdiskussion aufmerksam machen. Deshalb bitte dem Artikel zumindest die geben""" Löschung von Harry Potter (fiktive Person) Wikipedia:Meinungsbilder Wikipedia:Meinungsbilder 80
10243 2751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russian invasion of Ukraine (2014) User:Knowledgekid87 21:19, 1 September 2014 (UTC) delete per , No concrete evidence yet that Russia invaded Ukraine, might want to wait for a declaration of war or something, because it is not in Deletion of Russian invasion of Ukraine (2014) WP:POVFORK||WP:RS Wikipedia:Content forking 33
10244 8575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Catholic scientists User:Locke 07:30, 18 November 2005 (UTC) delete per and above Deletion of List of Catholic scientists WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10245 2566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ray Cesca User:CNMall41 06:10, 20 November 2015 (UTC) delete Unless he goes by another name, there is absolutely no press I could locate that could remotely be used to establish notability. Fails Deletion of Ray Cesca WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10246 16332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Japanese Prime Ministers by longevity User:Whispering 17:19, 13 July 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of Japanese Prime Ministers by longevity WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10247 4 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ocean State Green Party User:Heartmusic678 15:33, 8 September 2021 (UTC) delete Fails . None of the sources currently on the page are reliable and unrelated to the the party. I could not find any reliable secondary sources that pass Deletion of Ocean State Green Party WP:ORGIN||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
10248 8702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Westside Piru User:Pboyd04 16:03, 29 December 2005 (UTC) delete per A7 Deletion of Westside Piru WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
10249 4178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wombat Carnival User:Grandmasterka 02:29, 31 May 2006 (UTC) delete Immense |peacockery, doesn't seem to fit Deletion of Wombat Carnival WP:PEACOCK||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
10250 12009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trevor Grant (programmer) User:David 06:21, 25 February 2021 (UTC) delete The closest we have to a claim of notability is that he's one of five coauthors of an O'Reilly how-to book. Even if we had published reviews of that one book, it wouldn't be enough for (or anything else Deletion of Trevor Grant (programmer) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10251 7081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Challenge: A Sailing Simulation User:Videogameplayer99 22:05, 18 July 2018 (UTC) delete per nom, fails Deletion of American Challenge: A Sailing Simulation WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10252 5205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathan Sylvia User:Moonraker 07:22, 9 November 2020 (UTC) keep Poor article but still seems to meet , as at least one source is “substantial coverage”, viz. an article about Sylvia and not a brief mention Deletion of Nathan Sylvia WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10253 13704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Florida News User:Cuchullain 15:05, 25 September 2009 (UTC) delete """This defunct blog clearly fails . As Horologium points out it has not """"been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself""" Deletion of Florida News WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10254 12970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PhpLD User:Whpq 21:56, 20 February 2013 (UTC) comment I wouldn't expect something like phpLD to be covered in a general circulation newspaper, but a reliable source is any sort of publication which exercises editorial control in selection of topics to cover, and has a repuation for fact checking. If there is coverage in more specialised trade press, that can be used to establish |notability. If the software has been covered in academic studies, that might be useful for establishing a case for inclusion. If there is coverage in special books, that would help advance the argument for inclusion. For example, if there is coverage in one the O'Reilly Media|O'Reilly books, that would be considered a reliable source and count towards establishing notability Deletion of PhpLD WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10255 1292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SAGA (pop band) User:SSTflyer 11:14, 27 December 2015 (UTC) delete No evidence this passes Deletion of SAGA (pop band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10256 2442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Megaputer Intelligence User:Bearian 18:04, 3 February 2020 (UTC) delete per . The sources in the stub right now are tied to the company or are PR Deletion of Megaputer Intelligence WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
10257 18958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexandros Grigoropoulos User:Aramgar 01:19, 10 December 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. I feel sorry for the kid, but he is not |notable and does not need to be OTMEMORIAL|memorialized here. Sufficient detail already exists at 2008 Greek riots Deletion of Alexandros Grigoropoulos WP:N||WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10258 11876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SFContario User:Dravecky 11:05, 5 April 2011 (UTC) keep as nominator is mass-nominating a long list of science fiction conventions with the same cookie-cutter rationale, not grounded in facts or policy, without regard to content or sourcing (plus List of science fiction conventions), apparently as a result of Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MystiCon|this discussion. |Notability is ''not'' a competition and, um, I was not aware that an event was only notable if it involved people being shot during it Deletion of SFContario WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10259 16588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris MacManus User:Nasica 01:27, 13 January 2009 (UTC) delete Being a member of the local council of a small town does not make someone automatically notable (), and what little press coverage there is of him doesn't indicate that he's any more notable than an average local councillor. I wondered if being a member of Sinn Fein's national executive might mean he's a significant figure, but the only press coverage I can find of him in that capacity is references 3 and 4 in the article, neither of which focus on him. (#3 only lists him as a member of a delegation and doesn't mention him in the main article at all; #4 gives a brief quote but the article focuses entirely on the event he was speaking at, it isn't about the man himself Deletion of Chris MacManus WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10260 5803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wasim Akram (Producer) User:MichaelQSchmidt 20:21, 31 December 2011 (UTC) delete with enthusiasm. Unverifiability hints strongly of and along with similar film article ''Dead Morning'', as well as the director article Sridhar Teegala, and the ones for Gayathri (2013 film) and all created by |single purpose http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Wasirg User:Wasirg all seem to be set to promote the non-notable producer, his film company, and his films. None have verifiability Deletion of Wasim Akram (Producer) WP:HOAX||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
10261 11784 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noel """"Gene"""" Byars""" User:Morbidthoughts 16:35, 3 September 2008 (UTC) keep I believe he meets the basic criteria of and . Generally, mayors are notable under and he seems to have quite a history supported by sources """Deletion of Noel """"Gene"""" Byars""" WP:BIO||WP:POLITICIAN||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10262 946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bellal Amerkhail User:Punkmorten 07:47, 26 October 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Bellal Amerkhail WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10263 7326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mo Katz User:Moonraker 07:00, 9 November 2020 (UTC) keep Seems to me to meet , as the sources are “substantial coverage”, viz. articles about Katz and not brief mentions. Article does need better referencing Deletion of Mo Katz WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10264 13846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Source Dance Company User:onel5969 12:54, 24 November 2015 (UTC) delete searches didn't turn up enough in-depth coverage to show it meets either or Deletion of The Source Dance Company WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10265 12186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of British university Pro Vice-Chancellors and Treasurers User:Brianlucas 18:42, 4 October 2008 (UTC) delete """No content (in fact this article may meet the A3 """"no content"""" criterion""" Deletion of List of British university Pro Vice-Chancellors and Treasurers WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
10266 17396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Demand-side economics User:Eggishorn 16:56, 31 December 2016 (UTC) keep """Has significant coverage in beyond mere , which is all that really matters for AfD standards. Whether it is a """"rhetorical flourish"""" or an actual hypothesis is besides the point here and a matter for the article talk page""" Deletion of Demand-side economics WP:RS||WP:DICTDEF Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10267 10046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MAHANAYIKA User:Northamerica1000 16:54, 23 May 2016 (UTC) keep """per and the improvements to the article by {{u|MichaelQSchmidt}}, and because this meets . The delete !votes above appear to have not performed any source searching about the topic, and per , """"notability is based on the existence of suitable sources, not on the state of sourcing in an article""" Deletion of MAHANAYIKA WP:HEY||WP:NF||WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
10268 10684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Jay Center User:Smartyllama 19:59, 4 May 2017 (UTC) keep Consensus is that Division I college basketball venues are notable, and this was once a Division I college basketball venue. It no longer is, but |Notability is not temporary. So it's still notable Deletion of John Jay Center WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10269 88 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cardback User:ARUNEEK 09:40, 25 November 2016 (UTC) delete Fails .Relatively minor and trivial on-the-go coverage Deletion of Cardback WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
10270 20035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jorge Gracie User:Mdtemp 21:09, 18 September 2014 (UTC) comment """Again, our inclusionist/deletionist philosophies will likely never come to an accord on this issue, but please, let's be reasonable here; its more than clear he meets or exceeds a simple . The man has an independent and, insofar as I can tell, highly rated book significantly featuring his deeds (as one reviewer put it """"In Choque, it is evident by the sheer number of fights (fixed or otherwise) that George Gracie seemed to have an illustrious career as a ring fighter."""") on top of the BJJ heroes bio and the distinctly reputable Black Belt Magazine article. Yes, it was but a paragraph, but that still holds quite a bit of significance of weight toward notability in totality with the panoply of other citations. Again, as I mentioned before, no citation sort of a major expose in a major publication is like to dissuade you of your stance and I can respect that. My greater fear is that any legitimate nobility of this bygone prize fighter will suffer discrimination due to the time period of his accomplishments (well, WELL before systematic MMA/BJJ record keeping) and the anglocentric nature of this wiki in general as it hobbles a man who lived his entire life in Brazil speaking only português. Had he been born post-1980 and won a handful of gold medals at some IBJJF sanctioned tournament all this time and effort would have clearly been spared. Finally, the only reason this article has yet to have been updated since the September 2 was that I assumed it was becoming ''redundantly'' evident this man met the basic criteria. If you truly believe this to not be the case, perhaps then you and the (also my friend""" Deletion of Jorge Gracie WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10271 1875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One Direction's second studio album User:Cliff 18:57, 28 July 2012 (UTC) delete per : No title, no track listing and no release date. Information about this future album should remain at the artist's article until all of those have been verified Deletion of One Direction's second studio album WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10272 6752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Homo sapiens (Marvel Comics) NONE NONE keep There are numerous sources out there which cover this stuff, including the following. |Imperfect articles are welcome and |AfD is still not cleanup Deletion of Homo sapiens (Marvel Comics) WP:IMPERFECT||WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
10273 40 [[Gebetomat]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Diskriminierung NONE delete contra}} Ich sehe immer noch keine Relevanz für das Einzelkunstwerk. Besondere Originalität, die sich durch Nachahmer zeigte ist nicht erkennbar. Bitte mit einem Satz bei Oliver Sturm einbauen und als Lemma . Bitte beim Artikel beachten und Quellen nach WP:BLG einbauen. Löschung von Gebetomat Wikipedia:WEB Wikipedia:External links 76
10274 10912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Storm Hawks locations User:Sephiroth 18:44, 24 December 2008 (UTC) delete no notability asserted via significant coverage in |reliable sources independent of the topic. Fails #PLOT for being nothing more than an extensive list of in-universe locations Deletion of List of Storm Hawks locations WP:RS||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10275 7971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dănuț Marcu User:Staberinde 12:40, 21 February 2013 (UTC) delete """seems to fail . Also I consider it highly inappropriate to use to justify inclusion of BLP which is basically fully ''""""yeah, that guy plagiarized a lot""" Deletion of Dănuț Marcu WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10276 2644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Bale User:Papaursa 02:52, 17 April 2017 (UTC) delete """His appearance for Australia at the """"world championships"""" was several levels below what is necessary to meet and the coverage is not enough to meet """ Deletion of Jonathan Bale WP:NHOCKEY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10277 18850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Smoky Mountain Opry User:Duffbeerforme 08:02, 3 September 2012 (UTC) delete Lacks the coverage needed for Deletion of Smoky Mountain Opry WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
10278 10042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Vision International User:Dhartung 08:54, 13 April 2008 (UTC) delete No indication this company is |a notable business. Adding criticism may mitigate |bias, but that won't save it if it isn't notable Deletion of New Vision International WP:CORP||WP:POV Wikipedia:Notability 77
10279 16470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Summary deletion User:Salih 12:45, 26 December 2008 (UTC) delete as . Could not find any useful source Deletion of Summary deletion WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10280 6624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Howard Brown (2nd nomination) User:MorganaFiolett 13:49, 13 January 2010 (UTC) keep """he had a top 20 UK single- one of the notability criteria is """"Has had a single or album on any country's national music chart."""", and he wasn't just in one commercial he was the mainstay of Halifax's campaign for something like eight years. There are probably more sources to be found if you include """"Halifax"""" in the search as it's such a common name. A quick search gets results from national UK newspapers- the Telegraph, the Guardian and the Daily Mail (which I shall for now drop on the article's talk page since I'm pressed for time""" Deletion of Howard Brown (2nd nomination) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10281 13299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pragya Singh Thakur User:JFHJr 19:54, 21 February 2013 (UTC) delete Per . Even if a conviction is secured, this article should probably be rewritten from scratch Deletion of Pragya Singh Thakur WP:BLPCRIME Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10282 7354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mickaël Vendetta User:MichaelQSchmidt 21:31, 8 February 2010 (UTC) keep """per meeting as shown by http://news.google.com/archivesearch?as_user_ldate=2008&as_user_hdate=2010&q=%22Micka%C3%ABl+Vendetta%22&scoring=a&hl=en&ned=us&um=1&q=%22Micka%C3%ABl+Vendetta%22&lnav=od&btnG=Go coverage in numerous sources... and apparently most of them in French... so it seems he does indeed seem to be a person worth note to them. International standards? Wikipedia is not just for some subjective """"international"""" fame or note. Notable in France is plenty notable enough for en.Wikipedia. Kudos to the author for its creation. Far better to encourage the author to study and in order to add better sources and in the correct format, rather that |have him think his work is somehow not worth |improving""" Deletion of Mickaël Vendetta WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:CITE||WP:BITE||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
10283 20530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angels' Nectar User:SamHolt6 07:50, 25 November 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Angels' Nectar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10284 4222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Editorialist User:Ohnoitsjamie 19:27, 18 September 2016 (UTC) keep While not a slam dunk for , the coverage reasonable given that this is a niche topic area Deletion of Editorialist WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10285 18269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Humphrey User:Hullaballoo 19:07, 1 May 2016 (UTC) keep """as per above and because the nom has failed to comply with and dismisses without examination the significant body of academic criticism that even a cursory GScholar search turns up. """"'Teens Win': Purveying Fantasies of Effortless Economic Mobility and Social Attainment on Rich Teen Soaps"""" is hardly my idea of entertaining reading, for example, but lack of interest in the content of available sources doesn't justify ignoring their existence""" Deletion of Dan Humphrey WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
10286 13938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Trek versus Star Wars (4th nomination) User:TheFarix 18:12, 21 August 2007 (UTC) delete As much as I enjoyed such debate in my younger days, the result of this article can't be anything but |original research Deletion of Star Trek versus Star Wars (4th nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10287 12090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hoang Dieu Linh User:NawlinWiki 14:49, 30 April 2007 (UTC) delete totally unsourced, looks like something |made up in school one day Deletion of Hoang Dieu Linh WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
10288 4032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/420 ska mosh core User:Shaundakulbara 18:40, 30 January 2007 (UTC) delete does not establish |notability through |verifiable sources Deletion of 420 ska mosh core WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
10289 11988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Further Adventures in Babysitting (2016 film) User:Egsan 15:22, 14 January 2015 (UTC) delete If filming hasn't started yet, it's Deletion of Further Adventures in Babysitting (2016 film) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
10290 1031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Narrows Community Theater User:Davidpdx 12:20, 27 December 2006 (UTC) delete Non-noteable, fails . This should be nominated for the shortest article on Wikipedia Deletion of Narrows Community Theater WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10291 14255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/War from a Harlots Mouth User:Adamant1 19:56, 24 July 2020 (UTC) delete I don't think one notable album necessarily makes a band pass and the sources in the article seem to be primary or don't otherwise do it. That's just my interpretation of this though Deletion of War from a Harlots Mouth WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10292 1134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Townsend User:MER 08:22, 13 April 2007 (UTC) delete this |vanispamcruftisement Deletion of Bill Townsend WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
10293 8942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mordechai Shmuel Ashkenazi User:IZAK 05:45, 17 May 2015 (UTC) keep agree with {{u|Ism schism}}. He was a head rabbi of Kfar Chabad and famous Posek from 1983 until his death in 2015. The minimum sources cited are sufficient for . Thank you Deletion of Mordechai Shmuel Ashkenazi WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
10294 21225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Windsor municipal election, 1991 User:Edison 17:08, 18 May 2007 (UTC) comment """Note that there are millions of towns in the world which have had elections for a hundred years or more reported in muliiple local and regional papers. Too trivial to be in an encyclopedia. I could create 100 such articles for small towns with newspaper microfilms but it would be too y. """"We are not paper"""" is a poor excuse for limitless articles of no importance or use. Think of the number of stub articles if someone even stuck to elections for state assembly and nation office, by district. http://dca.tufts.edu/features/aas/states/index.html for instance lists local votes from the states and counties from the 1780's through the 1820's. Each of these local elections was certainly written up in state and local papers, but what purpose is served by importing the data from such an external archive of election results into Wikipedia? Whyt attempt to mirror all information there is rather than just linking to it? More articles means more potential for accidental error or vandalism as well, and more things to occupy space on the watchlists of editors""" Deletion of Windsor municipal election, 1991 WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
10295 8359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Powell (cricketer) User:SportingFlyer 15:59, 26 March 2021 (UTC) delete my source search brings up nothing apart from the statistics sites already in the article. Fails Deletion of Robert Powell (cricketer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10296 9290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ProductWiki User:SkierRMH 21:46, 6 January 2007 (UTC) delete Wow, SpamWiki! (now I want lunch) This doesn't meet from the stats on its own main page Deletion of ProductWiki WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10297 7020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MonsterMMORPG User:NawlinWiki 22:07, 9 January 2012 (UTC) delete the Gamespot reference is merely a directory entry stating that the game exists. The other references are the site itself or blogs. Fails and Deletion of MonsterMMORPG WP:WEB||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
10298 21733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/@world record egg User:Wumbolo 08:38, 15 January 2019 (UTC) keep Does not fall under , as this is not routine. There's a lot of analysis e.g. https://www.wired.co.uk/article/instagram-egg-world-record https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/13/style/egg-instagram-most-liked.html Deletion of @world record egg WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10299 12333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The new york sociologist User:Trialsanderrors 20:23, 7 February 2007 (UTC) comment """Well the Cortland journal makes it clear it's #CRYSTAL|crystal ballism: ''""""with the stated goal of publishing the highest quality scholarship across the full range of the social sciences. Submissions from faculty, researchers, and advanced graduate students exploring the problems of modern social life are welcomed.""""'' What about the other one""" Deletion of The new york sociologist WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10300 15545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arristimo User:Armbrust 16:34, 27 July 2010 (UTC) delete per and as |Wikipedia is not a dictionary Deletion of Arristimo WP:NEO||WP:NOTDICTIONARY Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10301 21469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charlene Downes User:Fredrick 10:30, 4 June 2007 (UTC) delete as per WP:NOT and I'd agree with the |coatrack article remark Deletion of Charlene Downes WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
10302 20288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derek Hansen User:E 01:46, 28 March 2018 (UTC) keep passes with in all of the major newspapers in New Zealand: profiles, book reviews,interviews, career retrospectives. Also some coverage in other countries. Many years and many books, some more popular than others. Searches may have been hampered by the usual factors: he started publishing years ago, so a good news archive produces more accurate results & there are other Dereks Hansen, so keywords help Deletion of Derek Hansen WP:AUTHOR||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
10303 228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of locations in Camp Lazlo User:Noahcs 02:54, 6 January 2008 (UTC) keep I agree with you on the fact that this article is mostly trivial material, however some locations such as Camp Kidney and Acorn Flats are considered Wikipedia:FICT#Notable topics|notable enough for inclusion. I think we should either merge to Camp Lazlo or |clean up the article per Wikipedia:Lists, both of which I am willing to do Deletion of List of locations in Camp Lazlo WP:CLEAN Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
10304 5903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ultimate X-Men (story arcs) (2nd nomination) User:Crystallina 14:59, 31 December 2006 (UTC) delete regardless of the first AfD, this is still unsourced - see - and questionable per the guidelines Deletion of Ultimate X-Men (story arcs) (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10305 907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Montree Promsawat User:Yellow 23:34, 12 July 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Montree Promsawat WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10306 15745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Mercer (2nd nomination) User:RadioFan 20:02, 20 February 2010 (UTC) delete no significant improvement since it was last deleted.Zero references. Fails Deletion of Ben Mercer (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10307 12936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PerimeterX User:TonyBallioni 03:12, 27 November 2017 (UTC) delete Naming notable topics in an article does not indicate that the article itself is notable, per . Per Deletion of PerimeterX WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10308 19617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CE Holkar User:RegentsPark 15:30, 21 December 2017 (UTC) delete """The mere existence of a statistic doesn't satisfy . We need to be able to say more convert that statistic into prose (""""he played in .. and scored""" Deletion of CE Holkar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10309 12657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Norwegian television series User:Athomeinkobe 07:05, 31 December 2016 (UTC) delete currently this list is in territory. Sure the topic is notable per se, but a tremendous amount of work is required. There's various suggestions above on how this list can and should be fixed. I'd happily change to a keep vote if someone actually does the work. Otherwise, the AFD will be closed, everyone will move on to the next topic, and this page will be left to rot for another 5 years Deletion of List of Norwegian television series WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
10310 17805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/P.s.a User:Twsx 12:29, 8 November 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of P.s.a WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10311 5515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cambridge University Wine Society User:MelanieN 04:25, 18 September 2010 (UTC) delete or '''Merge''' to List of social activities at the University of Cambridge. Is this club really 200+years old? If so, seems like it ought to have some real sourcing, but nothing at the article amounts to a Reliable Source. Google Books yields a mention or two http://books.google.com/books?id=y4udotMkzxgC&pg=PA21&dq=%22Cambridge+University+Wine+Society%22&hl=en&ei=iz2UTIeAFsKB8gbX3vGRDA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=2&ved=0CDcQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q&f=false, but overall this student club fails despite its claimed age. While we're at it we should delete Oxford University Wine Society as well (a mere newcomer, founded in 1999 Deletion of Cambridge University Wine Society WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10312 2002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American IronHorse NONE NONE delete Hardly the global coverage you would expect to establish notability for a manufacturer, which is the usual standard that applies to other manufacturing articles. All the references in the article are routine annoucements, which fail . Looking at the references above, most which are again hyper-local to the area, furthest away in Savannah in Georgia. Taking each one in turn Deletion of American IronHorse WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10313 6941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clarification On The Unsubstantiated Rumors Surrounding The Inter City Posse User:RPIRED 20:38, 9 August 2006 (UTC) delete on the title alone (ICP hasn't been known as '''Inner''' City Posse in over a decade), but works too, and... pretty much everything else Deletion of Clarification On The Unsubstantiated Rumors Surrounding The Inter City Posse WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10314 3852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beautiful (Aretha Henry album) User:Broccoli 21:46, 12 June 2018 (UTC) delete not notable, likely with article creators Deletion of Beautiful (Aretha Henry album) WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
10315 290 [[Fjordman]] (LAZ) Benutzer:Alabasterstein 14:41, 29. Jul. 2011 (CEST) delete """Man möge mir bitte die enzyklopädische Relevanz nach Richtlinien der de.wikipedia (#Lebende_Personen_.28allgemein.29|RK für lebende Personen) für """"aktiver Blogger"""", """"ist mir auch schon vor Breivik übern Weg gelaufen"""" und """"ist in en.wikipedia schon länger ein Artikel"""" schlüssig darlegen. Was haben wir hier? Einen Artikel zu einer anonymen Person, die in rechtsradikalen und islamophoben Foren und Blogs aktiv war (seine aktive Hochphase liegt ja wenn ich das richtig einschätze schon zurück, da er mittlerweile nur sowas wie """"Gastbeiträge"""" verfasst). Und worin bitteschön soll sein politischer Einfluss liegen? Das möge man mir stichhaltig erklären – denn der Artikel tut es leider nicht. Sind etwa bedeutende Parteien, Vereinigungen oder Bewegungen aufgrund seiner Thesen hervorgegangen oder hat er irgendwelche verhindert? Und auch wenn er in en.wp bereits länger erfasst ist, ist erstens bekanntermaßen diese keine Wegeleitung für uns und zweitens bezweifle ich, dass ohne Breiviks Terroraktionen dieser Artikel hier angelegt worden wäre. Wäre er ohne die Ereignisse angelegt worden, würde er wohl mittels Schnelllöschantrag längst erledigt. Die Popularität hat er in erster Linie den Ereignissen in Norwegen zu verdanken und der Blogger kann hinreichend im Biografieartikel von Breivik oder zum Attentat behandelt werden, so dass man der der notwendigen Aufklärung und Information genüge tut""" Löschung von Fjordman Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10316 2489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of online trading platforms User:Dr 21:35, 22 July 2021 (UTC) keep per . Ping me if you want me to give more detail about why nom is wrong here.— Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Comparison of online trading platforms WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
10317 17894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dukey User:Keithlaw 23:33, 21 February 2006 (UTC) delete per , probable forumcruft Deletion of Dukey WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10318 19122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heavy metal slang User:Tbo_157 16:34, 27 August 2007 (UTC) delete as per #DICTIONARY Deletion of Heavy metal slang WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10319 17795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Clancey's H.A.W.X. Bugs and Errors User:Tempodivalse 20:48, 31 March 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Tom Clancey's H.A.W.X. Bugs and Errors WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10320 7035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ngensolutions LLC User:Enric 10:52, 25 September 2010 (UTC) delete Those sources are press releases. It hasn't got independent sources so it can't possibly fit Deletion of Ngensolutions LLC WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10321 16654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stebin Ben User:Atlantic306 23:19, 17 August 2020 (UTC) keep as he has claims of passing by winning a major singing competition The Stage a televised series and he has also released on major labels Zee Music and Sony India, imv Deletion of Stebin Ben WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10322 6552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Racial disappearance [[User talk:140.247.249.78|talk]]) 22:19, 19 March 2009 (UTC) delete """how do you salvage an article with sentences like """"Political parties such as the British National Party have stopping racial disappearance as one of their objectives, although since social democracy is a euphemism for totalitarianism, such parties have little chance of gaining significant power, and indeed often face ostracization from the mainstream media and other political parties in their own countries.""""? I'm all for giving an article a chance but this ought to be speedied, such racist garbage could bring Wikipedia into disrepute. should apply, if nothing else. Special:Contributions/140.247.249.78|140.247.249.78""" Deletion of Racial disappearance WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
10323 9262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Compositional Guitar Tablature User:Nakon 08:55, 26 December 2010 (UTC) delete unsourced violation Deletion of Compositional Guitar Tablature WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10324 8174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wolfgang Jilke User:Ejgreen77 11:27, 23 January 2020 (UTC) keep as he appears to pass the requirements Deletion of Wolfgang Jilke WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
10325 2207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Freeda Foreman [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 19:05, 19 August 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and .Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Freeda Foreman WP:NBOX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10326 19961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Salvaggione User:ArcAngel 06:33, 31 January 2009 (UTC) delete for failing Deletion of Chris Salvaggione WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10327 15902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Open source 2.0 User:MuffledThud 07:45, 29 October 2009 (UTC) delete can find no mention of this online, fails Deletion of Open source 2.0 WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10328 18652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rowan Grebe User:HawkAussie 03:26, 24 December 2020 (UTC) comment I'm going to be honest and say their is a thing call where you could just redirect it (after doing a check). Also yeah it passes but until it reaches enough to have it's own separate article. I would say to '''Redirect Deletion of Rowan Grebe WP:BOLD||WP:BEFORE||WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Be bold 9
10329 16005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deaths in Harry Potter User:Zeno 21:45, 23 July 2007 (UTC) delete per #INFO Deletion of Deaths in Harry Potter WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10330 17110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti Dogmatism User:Boleyn 18:58, 6 May 2017 (UTC) delete My initial thought was to look at alternatives to deletion, and redirect to Moein Mohammadi, the artist. However, this is a potentially ambiguous title, so I think deletion is preferable Deletion of Anti Dogmatism WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
10331 5932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Coughlan (football) User:MrWooHoo 00:03, 18 September 2015 (UTC) keep Meets and meets per Nfitz and Fenix Deletion of Tom Coughlan (football) WP:SECONDARY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:No original research 65
10332 21161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naples United FC User:AlessandroTiandelli333 18:57, 21 March 2017 (UTC) keep No point deleting if they will soon pass Deletion of Naples United FC WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
10333 3463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AMG International User:MichaelBillington 11:54, 23 October 2006 (UTC) delete Reads as an advertisement, ( Deletion of AMG International WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
10334 939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abu Ghraib prisoner abuse reports/Gallery User:Mike 23:49, 17 September 2006 (UTC) keep The Photos are a major part of the story. In fact. the story probably would have never come to public attention without the photos. Including the all the photos with the article would be impractical in this case (due to the length of the two pages combined.), None the less, for someone to have as a complete understanding of this story as possible, these photos need to be accessible. I think a reasonable exception to could be made here Deletion of Abu Ghraib prisoner abuse reports/Gallery WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10335 42 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peleg Chandler User:Coolabahapple 15:08, 18 May 2018 (UTC) comment """although nominator has withdrawn i would like to add my '''keep''' as """"batter up, this afd is knocked out of the park"""":), Peleg Chandler is eminently notable, not only does he meet , but also no. 2 in the area of US law, and - his book ''American Criminal Trials'' is one of those texts with numerous reviews (see external links section of the article that i have added""" Deletion of Peleg Chandler WP:POLITICIAN||WP:ANYBIO||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10336 16367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shayan Italia User:EdJohnston 15:50, 6 September 2009 (UTC) delete """The inclusion guidelines at are quite specific. For instance, ''""""two or more albums on a major label.""""'' (There are other ways to qualify for an article, but this one is addressed to whether the person has a known quantity of musical output). Based on a quick web search I don't see any evidence that Shayan Italia has yet released even a single album, so I don't think he meets . Note http://www.amazon.co.uk/Deliverance-Deluxe-Shayan-Italia/dp/product-description/B000O175B2 the listing at amazon.co.uk for the 'Deliverance' album, which shows it as 'currently unavailable.' This suggests to me that it was never released, though he might have mailed out advance copies to a few people. The Amazon listing does not give the name of any record label who might have issued it, so 'major label' does not seem like a possibility. If he can ever get his stuff published, we could reconsider the matter later""" Deletion of Shayan Italia WP:MUSIC||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10337 9860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leader of the Free World User:Tigerboy1966 23:30, 20 October 2011 (UTC) delete just a definition of a term. #DICTIONARY. Page serves no purpose Deletion of Leader of the Free World WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10338 4638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Poray User:Vinegarymass911 19:56, 21 May 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet and . I am surprised by the number of votes saying oppose deletion and keep, which is a unique and rare way of voting Deletion of Anna Poray WP:NAUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10339 2290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bastian Emig User:BrownHairedGirl 11:07, 25 March 2013 (UTC) comment """As above, the where-to-redirect question is simple: redirect to the band he is most closely associated with. i.e. In Legend.I have just removed a lot of the content from the article, and it's now a stub again. Some of it was unreferenced, some of it misrepresented the sources (such as the claim that he is endorsed by MEINL); and much of what remains is referenced to the band's own website. That breaches Wikipedia:Biographies_of_living_persons#Using_the_subject_as_a_self-published_source, which says that such material may be used only if """"the article is not based primarily on such sources.""""Note also that #If_the_subject_is_not_notable: ''""""Wikipedia's goal is neither tiny articles that can never be expanded nor articles based primarily on what the subjects say about themselves""" Deletion of Bastian Emig WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10340 10254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shahira Barry (3rd nomination) User:Rockphed 11:48, 15 August 2019 (UTC) comment Contra the nom and other votes, I think it doesn't matter what her career actually looks like, it matters what the quality of the sources and their coverage is. I count 4 refs to ''The Mirror'', 1 in each of about 9 other british papers, 1 in a Filipino paper, and 1 reference to her own website. Are any of the british papers reliable (or even reliable adjacent)? I suppose someone should go see if any other sources exist rather than just . The last deletion discussion involved someone saying the articles were not a single flurry of activity, but were spaced out over months. That might indicate passing the {{strikethrough|third}} second criterion in Deletion of Shahira Barry (3rd nomination) WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:NMODEL Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10341 3161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sima Abd Rabo User:JamalFaris 03:35, 28 February 2021 (UTC) keep including per and the points raised by Deletion of Sima Abd Rabo WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
10342 16578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Cejka User:RGTraynor 16:26, 22 April 2008 (UTC) keep I'm not completely sold on the subject's notability, and there looks to be issues, but this is another in a string of insta-nominations by Ziggy (this one less than 120 ''seconds'' after the article's creation), and the creator has been continuing to improve the article in the meantime. Bad faith nomination Deletion of Mike Cejka WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
10343 1185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Den Klyuev User:Papaursa 03:08, 3 September 2015 (UTC) delete Despite a seemingly impressive record, there are no independent sources to support any of the claims so is not met. I'm also concerned about the accuracy of the claims. For example, the article claims he won a medal at the WKF world championships in 2013 but the WKF holds its world championships in even numbered years and I found no mention of a special shito-ryu division at the WKF website Deletion of Den Klyuev WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10344 101 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Blessing Mokgohloa """Kullanıcı:can'''can'''""" 12.02, 13 Mayıs 2020 (UTC) delete Kayda değer olduğunu gösterir bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynak saptayamadım. kriterleri de sağlanmamış gibi görünüyor. --Kullanıcı mesaj:Justinianus|'''justinianus Blessing Mokgohloa'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
10345 19955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Subhash Jha Vines User:Pharaoh 16:51, 23 June 2020 (UTC) delete per nom fails Deletion of Subhash Jha Vines WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10346 2887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mojiganga (band) User:Bearian 22:18, 18 October 2019 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Mojiganga (band) WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
10347 5273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim R. McGovern User:Eddie 14:53, 9 July 2010 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Jim R. McGovern WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10348 13757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy Powers User:Colapeninsula 16:14, 25 September 2013 (UTC) delete Not notable: person exists and the main facts of his career seem to be true, but without any coverage to meet and not successful enough for notability via . Article was created in 2009 by OReilly7, whose only other contributions are adding a reference to Powers to the page on Marty Reasoner (a more successful player who played alongside Powers for Boston College) and adding Powers as an alumnus to his high school's page. Page is an obvious example of OReilly7 writing a bio of a friend Deletion of Andy Powers WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
10349 4282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Wallis User:Devonian 12:36, 7 October 2020 (UTC) keep the articles in ''Vice'' and on CTV are both examples of SIGVOC in reliable sources, therefore meaning that he passes Deletion of Steve Wallis WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10350 16099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cancelled video games User:Jelly 21:42, 10 January 2011 (UTC) delete Largely unsourced. #FAQ|Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of List of cancelled video games WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10351 14192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of professional sports owners considered the worst User:Darkwind 00:25, 26 April 2010 (UTC) delete It would be practically impossible to write this in an |NPOV way, and it is indeed a huge risk for BLP violations Deletion of List of professional sports owners considered the worst WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
10352 21119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/55 Fiction User:TheSpecialUser 04:36, 24 June 2012 (UTC) keep it is notable and does pass as there are enough on the article as well as available online Deletion of 55 Fiction WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10353 12495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melissa Scheffler User:Adambiswanger1 03:18, 7 June 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Melissa Scheffler WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10354 12249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Coptic Orthodox Churches in the United States User:Snottywong 00:53, 20 May 2010 (UTC) delete """per . ''""""Wikipedia is NOT... mere collections of external links or Internet directories.""""'' This article is ''precisely'' a collection of external links""" Deletion of List of Coptic Orthodox Churches in the United States WP:LINKFARM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10355 13549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Lloyd (venture capitalist) User:Kudpung 02:20, 26 December 2013 (UTC) delete Listings, that's all the sources are, listings, but nothing that ammounts to . And for someone who is apparently so notable, no substantial Ghits. A very professionally drafted article however, so much so that it looks almost like a promotional piece for his companies masquerading as a biography. Maybe he ''is'' notable, but unfortunately fails to satisfy Deletion of Alexander Lloyd (venture capitalist) WP:BLPSOURCES||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10356 71 [[Robert Ditter]] (schnellgelöscht) Benutzer:XPac NONE delete Nur weil eine Person Rektor einer Schule ist, die einen Artikel in der Wikipedia hat, heißt das noch lange nicht, dass die Person per se relevant ist. Hier gilt: nicht erfüllt. Einbauen in den Schulartikel kann man ihn immer noch Löschung von Robert Ditter Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10357 4383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sohini Sengupta User:Abecedare 07:05, 23 March 2015 (UTC) keep The article needs clean-up, minor copyediting, more and better sources etc, but the notability of the subject is not in doubt. Two national level awards, Sangeet Natak Akademi's ''Ustad Bismillah Khan Yuva Puraskar'' (http://www.sangeetnatak.gov.in/sna/yuva2007.htm verification) and the 2011 National Film Award for Best Supporting Actress (http://iffi.nic.in/Dff2011/Frm47NFAAward.aspx verification; p. 30 as Sohini Haldar), themselves attest to notable contribution to theater and film respectively, and thus suffice to establish notability under standard Deletion of Sohini Sengupta WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10358 16749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Graziano Stefanelli User:Joe 13:19, 21 July 2009 (UTC) delete I couldn't find any reliable sources. Fails Deletion of Graziano Stefanelli WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10359 11647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shannon Nichol User:HouseOfChange 03:32, 22 March 2020 (UTC) comment per , the article that exists now bears little resemblance to https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Shannon_Nichol&direction=next&oldid=946132904 the article that was nominated for deletion. The article now includes more than two dozen RS that talk about SN, including her lead role in multiple notable projects and her being elected a member of the National Academy of Design. I don't know how to re-list this to ask for more people to take a look, but I wish somebody who knows how to do that would do it Deletion of Shannon Nichol WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
10360 6811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sophie Rose Cohen (2nd nomination) User:RGTraynor 14:46, 5 May 2008 (UTC) delete """Fails for lacking any relevant out-of-universe content, and for a character of an infant appearing briefly in the series finale, none will be forthcoming. That really does look like a botched initial AfD, where almost without exception, the Keeps were """"Keep per Matthew"""" and nothing else, parroting the fellow who gave ''no'' grounds to keep beyond """"WP is not paper"""" and """"This is a notable character."""" Based upon what definition of notability""" Deletion of Sophie Rose Cohen (2nd nomination) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10361 3918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Legal Community Against Violence User:J1nx1337 23:37, 15 February 2013 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Legal Community Against Violence WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10362 11830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samuel Lodato User:Smithers7 16:25, 26 November 2009 (UTC) delete This is strongly leaning toward A7|a7 Deletion of Samuel Lodato WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
10363 12173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Achondroplasia in children User:Snotbot 20:13, 26 November 2011 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2011 November 26 Deletion of Achondroplasia in children WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
10364 16619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uvuru-agada User:Shawn 11:55, 26 December 2015 (UTC) keep per . A quick Google search confirms its existence as a named populated place. Also, this is not the first nomination from this editor where he has been reminded of GEOLAND in cases such as this and to ''continue'' to bring these to Afd seems to be y behaviour and rather a waste of time Deletion of Uvuru-agada WP:GEOLAND||WP:POINT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10365 1623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of United States public officials accused of crimes User:Aaron 04:48, 20 October 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and Husond. Interesting concept, but definitely a concern and the list is potentially endless Deletion of List of United States public officials accused of crimes WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10366 14276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Serbophobia (third nomination) User:Estavisti 22:34, 23 November 2006 (UTC) keep """this reeks of (""""if you want to delete Bosniakophobia, then you should also delete Serbophobia""""). For what it's worth Bosniakophobia probably should be deleted, as it gets precisely '''ZERO''' hits in Google.http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=bosniakophobia Also, just because the article has been nominated for deletion (unsuccessfully) twice before, that doesn't mean it should have been deleted (""""Serbophobia was also nominated for deletion in the past etc, but nobody deleted it""""). Furthermore, there are 1,250 Google hits when you search for """"serbophobia -wikipedia -wiki"""" (i.e. when Wikipedia is eliminated).http://www.google.co.uk/search?num=100&hl=en&q=serbophobia+-wikipedia+-wiki&btnG=Search&meta= Granted, many are useless rubbish, but there are also many reputable sources in there. Finally, it's not clear why this being nominated for a third time (!) when no new arguments have been presented""" Deletion of Serbophobia (third nomination) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
10367 2356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ammini College of Engineering User:Adamant1 22:11, 1 April 2021 (UTC) delete There isn't even the usual trivial sources about this that exist for some school. Let alone anything in-depth. So, the article should clearly be deleted. Unless someone can find in-depth, reliable, non-trivial, independent sources so it will pass . I'm more then happy change my vote to keep if anyone can Deletion of Ammini College of Engineering WP:THREE||WP:NORG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10368 276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roy Cammarano User:Deathlibrarian 12:21, 20 May 2017 (UTC) delete As above, it appears to fail Deletion of Roy Cammarano WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10369 20544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seelie Court (Dungeons & Dragons) User:Jclemens 21:37, 15 September 2013 (UTC) merge Per Casliber. Also note that none of the delete votes above adequately justifies why a merge would not be the most policy-based alternative under Deletion of Seelie Court (Dungeons & Dragons) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
10370 11537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrian Switzer User:Maelnuneb 15:31, 6 October 2006 (UTC) delete does anybody read before creating articles Deletion of Adrian Switzer WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10371 8791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter Hammerl User:Hzh 14:09, 3 June 2018 (UTC) merge There does not appear to any evidence that he had done anything significant outside of EAV, and individual members of band without significance outside the band are normally redirected to the band per . However, if attempts at removing the redirect persist, then I'd suggest delete and salt Deletion of Walter Hammerl WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10372 5427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Losseny Doumbia User:Wikicology 22:43, 1 October 2014 (UTC) keep subject of the article obviously meet . I understand that the article needs much work but the subject meet Deletion of Losseny Doumbia WP:NSOCCER||WP:SPORTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10373 11284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Niana Guerrero User:Superastig 12:00, 3 March 2021 (UTC) keep I found some reliable sources about her: https://www.candymag.com/all-access/niana-guerrero-a00306-20201004-lfrm, https://entertainment.inquirer.net/399343/niana-guerrero-gets-minor-injury-after-tiktok-challenge, https://time.com/4861828/niana-despacito/, https://www.dancespirit.com/day-in-the-life-tiktok-star-2647710748.html, https://www.popsugar.com/latina/Niana-Guerrero-Despacito-Video-43740545, https://www.rappler.com/entertainment/things-to-know-pinoy-youtube-star-ranz-kyle-niana-guerrero-ytff-2018, https://www.thequint.com/neon/social-buzz/this-brother-sister-duo-is-giving-us-major-sibling-goals-ranz-niana-facebook-popular and https://www.firstpost.com/sports/meet-ranz-and-naina-kyle-who-are-taking-sibling-goals-to-the-next-level-with-their-viral-videos-3374488.html. She and her brother were among the nominees of a certain category in https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1063258 2019 Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards. The article needs a lot of clean-up. Other than that, it's good enough to pass Deletion of Niana Guerrero WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10374 10533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krsna in Krsna Consciousness User:Ronhjones 22:42, 5 August 2009 (UTC) merge to International Society for Krishna Consciousness. All very badly written, one cannot any of the data, as not one in-line reference. To keep would require a complete rewrite to obtain , and even then may still be in doubt Deletion of Krsna in Krsna Consciousness WP:VERIFY||WP:STYLE||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10375 6374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artemis DeLarge User:Danny 06:22, 21 May 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Artemis DeLarge WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
10376 4524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Tia Sharp User:Paul 22:18, 13 November 2012 (UTC) keep Lots of significant coverage on this. Meets . Why do we have to have these debates about every single murder case article Deletion of Death of Tia Sharp WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10377 21650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Animal Rescue Sofia User:Normal 19:47, 27 August 2020 (UTC) comment """What article? I don't find that information in the one non-self-published citation in the wiki article. Per , {{tq|""""A company, corporation, organization, group, product, or service is notable if it has been the subject of significant coverage in multiple reliable secondary sources that are independent of the subject.""""}} and {{tq|""""Note that an individual source must meet all of these criteria to be counted towards notability. i.e. each source needs to be significant, independent, reliable, and secondary. In addition, there must be multiple such sources that qualify.""""}} None of the citations in the wiki article meet these criteria. And nothing I found with an online search meets those criteria, either""" Deletion of Animal Rescue Sofia WP:ORGCRITE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10378 11767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solar cycle (calendar) User:Winner 16:13, 24 May 2015 (UTC) keep The Julian Solar cycle is extensively covered in many reliable sources as it is one of the major components of the Julian calendar. For example it is discussed in books such as https://books.google.com/books?id=jlZBAAAAcAAJ&printsec=frontcover#v=onepage&q&f=false Universal Technological Dictionary: Or, Familiar Explanations of the Terms Used in All Arts and Sciences and https://books.google.com/books?id=4J0NAAAAQAAJ&pg=PA141&lpg=PA141#v=onepage&q&f=false Fasti temporis catholici, and Origines kalendariæ and authoritative websites such as http://www.timeanddate.com/calendar/julian-calendar.html Timeanddate.com and http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/89368/calendar/59345/Complex-cycles Britannica. I can list more sources if you wish as there are thousands of references to it. This concept can be made into a complete article by itself by passing Deletion of Solar cycle (calendar) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10379 120 [[Akatsuki (Naruto)]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:defchris NONE delete wir hatten erst vor wenigen Wochen einen erweiterten Artikel zum Manga Naruto, den wir schnellgelöscht haben (/26._Oktober_2007#Itachi_uchiha_.28erl..2C_gel.C3.B6scht.29|vgl. Itachi uchiha). Vielleicht sollte man andere mögliche Lemmas auch vorabsperren. :: Löschung von Akatsuki (Naruto) Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
10380 8958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur Morgan (character) User:Lordtobi 20:27, 28 December 2018 (UTC) delete per nom. Easily identifiable as and in-universe-only topic Deletion of Arthur Morgan (character) WP:GAMECRUFT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
10381 4700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of female Egyptologists user:Andrew 13:10, 27 December 2016 (UTC) keep the list but disable the bot. The list should be kept because the topic passes – see ''https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=jWltAAAAMAAJ Women Travellers in the Near East'' or ''https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=MsXQEkPLf-0C You Can Be a Woman Egyptologist'', for example. The bot should be blocked or disabled because the note on the article indicates that it has been set up to always revert to its preferred version and that is contrary to Deletion of List of female Egyptologists WP:LISTN||WP:EDITWAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10382 10191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syed Ghulam Mohiyyuddin Gilani User:Kashmiri 06:40, 1 September 2018 (UTC) keep per as evidenced by the current references, including those added recently by {{u|Ngrewal1 Deletion of Syed Ghulam Mohiyyuddin Gilani WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
10383 1779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Viulen Ayvazyan User:Sir 17:33, 25 October 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not played in a fully pro league or a senior national team, nor has he received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Viulen Ayvazyan WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10384 14906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nokia 6810 User:TerriersFan 23:50, 14 November 2007 (UTC) delete as failing . Phones have no free pass from the notability requirement. The fact that it exists and is sold is not enough. There are no secondary sources cited to demonstrate that this phone has anything to mark it out from all other phones Deletion of Nokia 6810 WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10385 15447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mualigbe Keita User:Hobbes 21:56, 14 December 2011 (UTC) delete High school soccer player. Web search shows little evidence of substantial coverage from sources, mostly social media and directory listings Deletion of Mualigbe Keita WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10386 19743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Harris (train surfer) User:Avraham 17:40, 7 July 2009 (UTC) delete Doing something extremely stupid and paying the ultimate price is not gorunds for notability in and of itself. is not even applicable as the event itself is not notable; sad and tragic, but not notable. See also Deletion of Martin Harris (train surfer) WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10387 10775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hannibal Mejbri User:Davidlofgren1996 14:46, 26 August 2020 (UTC) keep """I feel Mejbri meets with significant independent coverage. The fact that he """"''hasn't actually done anything yet''"""" is just not true. He's played for two top European clubs and accumulated a high total transfer fee in the process, while being seen as one of Europe's top prospects. He has more coverage than a young player who has just made his debut in League Two, for example""" Deletion of Hannibal Mejbri WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10388 13111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Lawrence (jockey) User:Clarityfiend 12:58, 29 June 2015 (UTC) delete per . Also , as it appears that at least part of the article was written by Lawrence himself Deletion of Brian Lawrence (jockey) WP:NHORSERACING||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
10389 11011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CAF Nations League User:HawkAussie 02:03, 13 September 2019 (UTC) delete Until we get more information about this league, I would say this falls under Deletion of CAF Nations League WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
10390 3151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doyle (Andromeda) User:Sgeureka 08:06, 1 September 2010 (UTC) merge to List of Andromeda characters. No established , and it is short enough to neatly fit in the LoC. &ndash Deletion of Doyle (Andromeda) WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
10391 562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One Network Bank User:Raykyogrou0 09:17, 16 January 2014 (UTC) comment """The comments saying """"Speedy Keep"""" or """"Close"""" are not actual |speedy keep criterion""" Deletion of One Network Bank WP:SK Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
10392 16662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph G. Clemons User:onel5969 11:25, 11 December 2017 (UTC) keep """While I agree he doesn't meet WP:NSOLDIER, I think there's enough coverage for him to clearly meet . Although, most of the coverage is offline. He is covered significantly in ''Against All Odds!'' by Bryan Perrett. He is also covered in ''Tragedy at Chu Lai'' by David Venditta, although I don't know how extensively (it's more than a trivial mention, but not sure it is """"significant coverage""""). He has significant coverage in ''Combat Films'' by Steven Jay Rubin (https://books.google.com/books?id=uHNvAeD4yR4C&pg=PA75&dq=%22Joseph+G.+Clemons%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiM76WQ6YHYAhWr7IMKHUGYDxMQ6AEIJzAA#v=onepage&q=%22Joseph%20G.%20Clemons%22&f=false Google books link here), as well as in ''The Screen Is Red'' by Bernard F. Dick. ''On Hallowed Ground'' by Bill McWilliams also covers him extensively (https://books.google.com/books?id=jvB3CgAAQBAJ&pg=PT86&dq=%22Joseph+G.+Clemons%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiM76WQ6YHYAhWr7IMKHUGYDxMQ6AEIWjAJ#v=onepage&q=%22Clemons%22&f=false see here). ''Korean War Filmography'' by Robert J. Lentz also goes into him in https://books.google.com/books?id=0Zk-CgAAQBAJ&pg=PA276&dq=%22Joseph+G.+Clemons%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi9j7n064HYAhWi5IMKHVN6Aqw4ChDoAQgsMAE#v=onepage&q=%22Clemons%22&f=false some detail""" Deletion of Joseph G. Clemons WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10393 8997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International scientific-practical journal «Commodities and Markets» User:Piotrus 11:11, 25 July 2016 (UTC) delete Fails , and Randykitty explains well why it fails our more detailed criteria for journals. In other words, it is a tiny journal nobody cares about except few people who run it. Not encyclopedic Deletion of International scientific-practical journal «Commodities and Markets» WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10394 13412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RG Premium User:Neiltonks 17:02, 6 November 2017 (UTC) delete My initial thought on this was to Keep it because the rationale given in the nomination are largely reasons to improve the article not delete it. However the acid test is whether there are which talk about this particular guitar. My searches have failed to find anything. The first few pages of Google results are sites which sell the guitar, or user-submitted stuff or items which are obviously regurgitated press releases and therefore not independent. Google books and scholar results aren't any more enlightening Deletion of RG Premium WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10395 18763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samina Khan NONE NONE keep This person is an elected politician in a Pakistani state legislature. As such, she easily passes the criteria for Deletion of Samina Khan WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10396 17412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wilfred Spears, American TV Producer User:Omni 10:13, 30 June 2016 (UTC) delete IMDB is not a reliable source which can be used to show the notability of someone, and all of the other references are short mentions which don't really help to show that the subject passes Deletion of Wilfred Spears, American TV Producer WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10397 5914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Get Rude User:4meter4 00:34, 30 September 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Get Rude WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
10398 21611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Henen User:IJA 18:30, 14 August 2014 (UTC) delete He hasn't played in a Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|Fully professional league & he doesn't have any international caps therefore he fails Deletion of David Henen WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10399 15903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mouldings Industry Association User:Whpq 15:48, 11 February 2013 (UTC) delete I can find no coverage about this organisation. I agree wtih Peterkingiron that large industry associations ought to be notable, but in this case, the lack of coverage would indicate that notability is not met, and indeed, |verifiability is an issue as I found no third party sources that confirm any information in the article Deletion of Mouldings Industry Association WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10400 3275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kurt Boone User:Northamerica1000 10:02, 18 May 2012 (UTC) keep """Per , ...""""The absence of citations in an article (as distinct from the non-existence of sources) does not indicate that the subject is not notable."""" This topic easily passes , and sources are readily available. Boone has received extensive coverage in numerous reliable sources, including: The New York Times http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/05/nyregion/thecity/05mess.html, The New York Post http://www.nypost.com/p/news/local/queens/cambria_hts_author_delivers_his_teaYWCKmbONbPWqj91j1RO, New York Daily News http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/queens/message-delivered-a-book-article-1.227135, New York Daily News http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/queens/messenger-literary-hope-article-1.466502, Courier Magazine http://www.couriermagazine.com/Content.asp?CID=133&offset=6, Metro New York http://www.metro.us/newyork/local/article/817692--60-seconds-with-the-delivery-man""" Deletion of Kurt Boone WP:NRVE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10401 9322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deepa Miriam User:Schuym1 23:41, 26 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Deepa Miriam WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10402 195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daisy Watkins User:TTN 00:57, 28 October 2020 (UTC) delete No real world information from reliable sources to meet on any of them Deletion of Daisy Watkins WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10403 18466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Abbotts User:Whouk 16:24, 30 June 2006 (UTC) merge """useful info into the by-election article and '''Delete''' - fails . """"Will probably be picked for a more winnable seat"""" is |crystal-balling. &mdash""" Deletion of Ben Abbotts WP:BIO||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10404 20024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Bills User:Paulmcdonald 13:07, 29 November 2016 (UTC) delete I am unable to find any worthy sources to indicate passing Deletion of Craig Bills WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10405 759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katta Russeforening User:Dhartung 09:30, 26 April 2008 (UTC) delete local youth organization, fails Deletion of Katta Russeforening WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10406 18772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Merritt E. Cornell User:Cewbot 22:30, 8 September 2020 (UTC) comment This nomination has had limited participation and falls within the standards set for |lack of quorum. There are no previous AfD discussions, undeletions, or current redirects and no previous PRODs have been located. This nomination may be '''eligible for |soft deletion''' at the end of its 7-day listing Deletion of Merritt E. Cornell WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
10407 7822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Social and economic stratification in Appalachia user:Andrew 16:48, 4 May 2017 (UTC) keep The topic is clearly notable and so our |editing policy applies. The rest is then a matter of ordinary editing not deletion and |AFD is not cleanup Deletion of Social and economic stratification in Appalachia WP:PRESERVE||WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
10408 10496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013 Rawalpindi riots User:WikiDan61 12:47, 16 December 2013 (UTC) comment """I'm not sure I understand the basis for this """"weak keep"""" ''!vote''. BabbaQ admits that the event is to recent to evaluate whether it will have any long term impact, which means that it does not qualify for inclusion under . So why keep it? (As an aside, the fact that there has been no update to the article since its first creation to show even any immediate impact suggests that long term impact is probably not forthcoming""" Deletion of 2013 Rawalpindi riots WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10409 7962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti-rocker User:Cleared 23:37, 3 February 2006 (UTC) delete per and the fact that it's basically just a dictionary definition and I don't see a whole lot of room for expansion Deletion of Anti-rocker WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10410 683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jill Chill User:Kubigula 23:04, 19 February 2007 (UTC) delete I can't find multiple nontrivial sources regarding the character. Article raises concerns about Deletion of Jill Chill WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
10411 4326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tejasvi Surya (2nd nomination) User:Highpeaks35 02:36, 25 May 2019 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Tejasvi Surya (2nd nomination) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10412 11501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Namiq Qaraçuxurlu User:Timtrent 06:41, 4 August 2020 (UTC) delete as failing and . The COI is of interest, but not of itself a reason to delete Deletion of Namiq Qaraçuxurlu WP:NACTOR||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10413 10054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional characters who can manipulate water User:Bfigura 03:21, 4 September 2007 (UTC) comment """Despite some of the (amusing) comments above, the list clearly defines it's criterion as """"...fictional characters with the paranormal or superhuman ability to create or manipulate water."""" That seems clear enough to satisfy demand for inclusion parameters. It probably still fails and , but I just thought I should clarify this point""" Deletion of List of fictional characters who can manipulate water WP:LIST||WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Lists 97
10414 12946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Melungeons User:Mukadderat 17:31, 9 December 2009 (UTC) delete based on |reliable sources Deletion of List of Melungeons WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10415 15825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cristovao Vilela User:Zanoni 12:31, 2 May 2010 (UTC) delete fails both and Deletion of Cristovao Vilela WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10416 21100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Judge (writer) User:K 03:17, 22 September 2018 (UTC) keep the role in the recent controversy has produced in-depth profiles of his writings, such as http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2018/09/meet-brett-kavanaughs-alleged-accomplice-mark-judge.html Meet Mark Judge; https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2018/09/18/mark-judge-what-we-know-brett-kavanaugh-classmate/1344707002/ What We Know About Mark Judge; https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/arts-and-entertainment/wp/2018/09/17/what-the-man-accused-of-helping-kavanaugh-assault-a-woman-wrote-about-female-sexuality/ What Mark Judge Wrote About Women; https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2018/09/mark-judge-brett-kavanaugh-writing/570631/ Mark Judge ... has opined about rowdy-young-male behavior for years, etc. BIO1E no longer applies. Also, meets (or almost meets) with reviews of his books. Everything combined meets Deletion of Mark Judge (writer) WP:NAUTHOR||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10417 20853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hello India User:Michaelzeng7 02:43, 7 April 2012 (UTC) delete No reliable sourcing available. Fails as the nominator suggested. So until there is firm evidence that the film shall be released ( should apply on this matter too) and is notable, its independent article should not be created Deletion of Hello India WP:NFF||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10418 830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moralistic therapeutic deism User:Fences 01:35, 9 January 2010 (UTC) keep This is an nomination. It's got significant and ongoing coverage in reliable sources.http://news.google.co.uk/archivesearch?q=%22Moralistic+therapeutic+deism%22&btnG=Search&um=1&ned=uk&hl=en&scoring=a I removed the nominator's personal opinions from the end of the article; they should re-read Wikipedia:No original research Deletion of Moralistic therapeutic deism WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10419 17323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cameron Norman User:ArsenalFan700 22:55, 8 January 2016 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Cameron Norman WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10420 19685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/*repeat repeat (2nd nomination) User:Ifnord 15:36, 18 August 2017 (UTC) delete for failing notability requirements under . This doesn't mean they are a bad group, somehow illegitimate, or don't make music. It means that, at it currently stands, the band is not notable enough for an encyclopedic article Deletion of *repeat repeat (2nd nomination) :WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10421 8363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adil Ray NONE 07:25, 28 May 2007 (UTC) keep Subject meets as a notable British radio and television presenter. http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Yamaguchi%E5%85%88%E7%94%9F&action=edit§ion=new Yamaguchi先生 Deletion of Adil Ray WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10422 17574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shadi Aswad User:Safiel 03:10, 17 July 2011 (UTC) delete Fails otability (music Deletion of Shadi Aswad WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10423 6632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Beautiful Losers User:Esradekan 02:04, 11 June 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of The Beautiful Losers WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10424 5554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Comic Issue User:Kinu 05:00, 28 August 2006 (UTC) delete definitely some crazy form of and a how-to guide that isn't close to being encyclopedically relevant information. Yeah, thanks for telling me that Issue #2 comes after Issue #1 Deletion of A Comic Issue WP:OR||WP:NOT Wikipedia:No original research 65
10425 7612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bell and Bowles User:Kinu 07:10, 8 December 2020 (UTC) delete lacks the sourcing in to suggest notability Deletion of Bell and Bowles WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10426 19300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Piper User:Lady 20:00, 4 June 2014 (UTC) delete he doesn't have any significant coverage on him which fails Deletion of Tim Piper WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10427 17944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dieter Fleig User:Blueboar 14:06, 8 June 2009 (UTC) delete does not pass (or ... I can not find any reference to to indicate what accademic field ''Dr.'' Fleig earned his degree in Deletion of Dieter Fleig WP:AUTHOR||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10428 8676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Azmir User:Danny 22:14, 15 April 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Azmir WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
10429 7713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian Farnworth User:Panyd 10:32, 5 December 2010 (UTC) delete I tried to verify the claim but I can't find any significant third-party coverage of this person at all. Fail #SPORT until it can be verified Deletion of Ian Farnworth WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10430 21310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TrueCrypt User:WOFall 19:51, 14 July 2014 (UTC) keep TrueCrypt remains significant because of its historical significance. Should we delete the article on because they've died? See #TEMP. As the grounds for this nomination are invalid, there is little need for extended discussion Deletion of TrueCrypt WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10431 774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyborg 009 Alternative User:CaliforniaAliBaba 00:53, 16 July 2007 (UTC) delete """Apparent fanfic; Google search on the author's screenname """"Beamknight"""" in Korean gives 32 non-duplicate hits, among which there are zero . http://www.google.co.kr/search?q=%EB%B9%94%EB%82%98%EC%9D%B4%ED%8A%B8&complete=1&hl=ko&lr=&newwindow=1&safe=active&start=100&sa=N""" Deletion of Cyborg 009 Alternative WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10432 12099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leslie Bates User:Pharaoh 01:32, 5 September 2021 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Leslie Bates WP:GNG||WP:FILMMAKER Wikipedia:Notability 77
10433 2066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reception of the iPad User:Barts1a 02:42, 14 March 2012 (UTC) keep """Nominator's argument is an advanced form of the |""""I don't like it, therefore delete"""" argument with several words added to pad it and make it sound like it's not said argument""" Deletion of Reception of the iPad WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10434 20382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ross Wilkinson User:Number 19:32, 27 September 2007 (UTC) delete None of them have played in a fully professional league and therefore all fail . In the case of Rothery, England appearences at youth level do not make someone notable Deletion of Ross Wilkinson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10435 1745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tension & Trauma Releasing Exercises User:Bearian 22:20, 16 March 2019 (UTC) delete merely | spam Deletion of Tension & Trauma Releasing Exercises WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
10436 6236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bonnie Mercado User:Kudpung 10:07, 22 October 2017 (UTC) delete Fails on . Non neutral, possibly written by a fan Deletion of Bonnie Mercado WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10437 6326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Linda Seger User:Ideaorigin 09:30, 19 December 2019 (UTC) keep as there's a case for C3 with reviews like the one at Script, Kirkus, Publisher's Weekly, with some support from GNG (newpapers seem to call her when they someone to talk about script-fixing). Some further references could be added to the article. Comment that Deletion of Linda Seger WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10438 18127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Murray (politician) (4th nomination) User:Ubelowme 15:46, 16 June 2012 (UTC) merge to the election in which he's running, as per . This gentleman still doesn't meet ; I looked at the references and found that they were very localized (the ''Washington Post'' link is a blog post from a blog devoted to his state's politics and has little information Deletion of Patrick Murray (politician) (4th nomination) WP:POLITICIAN||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10439 1768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ori (Stargate) User:Daranios 20:46, 17 July 2020 (UTC) keep The nominator found screenrant as one source, but was there also a search in Google Scholar? So far I have found two in-depth sources there: https://books.google.de/books?hl=de&lr=&id=cFQicvXd5bwC&oi=fnd&pg=PA267&dq=ori+stargate&ots=xo6loT9Brz&sig=dhSNJ_lcADmtgQGJlF1rr8_XaQw&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=ori&f=false The Essential Science Fiction Television Reader has a chapter comparing the Ori and the Ancients (Stargate)|Ancients; https://books.google.de/books?hl=de&lr=&id=0KA83tzzEBkC&oi=fnd&pg=PA9&dq=ori+stargate&ots=cpT33c-grs&sig=Q-2zew9jN7koHugj0Yxvd4-xgBU&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=ori&f=false The Emancipation of the Soul analyses the metaphorical significance of the Ori as a science-fiction trope and more. These three together should satisfy . Then https://books.google.de/books?hl=de&lr=&id=ZH701fKb2dgC&oi=fnd&pg=PR6&dq=ori+stargate&ots=Rb-3SRKO8p&sig=CQ37KDG2ElBP8oC6_j8dX1ThDc8&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=ori&f=false Science Fiction Experiences comments on the Ori from the view-point of the TV watcher. And there are a number of shorter appearances in secondary sources, e.g. https://books.google.de/books?hl=de&lr=&id=lMqoAgAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PA67&dq=ori+stargate&ots=Plnvq3OYZ-&sig=iu6XjWUjWf_-LyGTezcqg0fze0Q&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=ori&f=false, https://books.google.de/books?hl=de&lr=&id=RbJ_CgAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR7&dq=ori+stargate&ots=dTYtUocuNP&sig=ksBc4-j1SwBYvwoneYUBieMrdzA&redir_esc=y#v=snippet&q=ori&f=false, https://books.google.de/books?hl=de&lr=&id=shHxWHqkG5IC&oi=fnd&pg=PR9&dq=ori+stargate&ots=9kEDD-T0kt&sig=Lj_smBf23dPPgMsqLEgqH0NV_fw&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=ori&f=false Deletion of Ori (Stargate) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10440 7923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avenue D (band) User:KnightLago 02:21, 9 August 2006 (UTC) delete Fails per nom Deletion of Avenue D (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10441 19143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Oppong User:Fenix 12:17, 18 February 2016 (UTC) delete Fail |NFOOTY as have not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subjects have garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Brian Oppong WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10442 7768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Autobots User:Knowledgekid87 15:12, 21 February 2020 (UTC) delete """per . I see overlap here as we already have multiple lists for the Lists of Transformers characters|characters in Transformers. Do we really need ones that include """"By affiliation""" Deletion of List of Autobots WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10443 95 [[SV Eintracht Frankenhain]] (erledig zurückgezogen LA Steller net aufgepasst) Benutzer:GraceKelly 16:38, 12. Aug. 2009 (CEST) keep die #Sportvereine|Relevanzkriterien sind hier eindeutig: „in vom IOC anerkannten Individualsportarten in der höchsten Wettkampfklasse der Erwachsenen mehrere Medaillengewinner (auch in Staffeln/Team-Wettbewerben) bei Olympischen Spielen, Welt- oder Kontinentalmeisterschaften, Gesamt-Weltcup oder ähnlichen Bewerben oder mehrere nationale Meister gestellt haben“: Das ist mit den im Artikel erwähnten Wintersportlern wie Katrin Apel, Jens Filbrich und Daniel Graf (Biathlet)|Daniel Graf der Fall. Durch die Ausrichtung der Sommerbiathlon-Weltmeisterschaften 2009 greift zudem die Formulierung „besondere mediale Aufmerksamkeit auf sich ziehen“ im darüber liegenden Abschnitt Löschung von SV Eintracht Frankenhain Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
10444 10448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Domination Through Impurity User:HackJandy 22:01, 29 November 2005 (UTC) delete possibly speedy. Copyvio, does not fullfill , has not been published, no AM, WP is not a crystal ball Deletion of Domination Through Impurity WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10445 13104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greeneyes User:Xuanwu 05:11, 7 December 2005 (UTC) keep """The fact it has served as an inspiration at least one notable web comic (Tsunami Channel) is certainly evidence supporting a claim of """"setting a trend"""" (see ). Though finding other references to it by other authors would be helpful. I'll come out and say right now I've used it as a reference for Okashina Okashi, another notable comic (though I'm a bit biased when it comes to OO""" Deletion of Greeneyes WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10446 17022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Kominas (2nd nomination) User:Pharaoh 21:35, 19 September 2014 (UTC) keep Passes and have added References Deletion of The Kominas (2nd nomination) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10447 12409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David W. Roberts User:Morenooso 04:53, 2 May 2010 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails as names gets few ghits and |reliable third sources Deletion of David W. Roberts WP:POLITICIAN||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10448 8878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of articles related to children's rights User:Phil 21:20, 4 April 2008 (UTC) keep How often does it have to be repeated that categories and lists are not redundant to each other? We get several articles per day listed at AfD with this claim, and several times a day it has to be pointed out that |this is not a reason for deletion. From the point of view of a reader who wants to use Wikipedia to find out information on this topic this article clearly has encyclopedic value Deletion of List of articles related to children's rights WP:CLS Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
10449 10629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Accelerated Learning Solutions User:Zipezap 14:41, 9 April 2014 (UTC) delete No notability per Deletion of Accelerated Learning Solutions WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10450 13071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank Carney User:Tstrobaugh 21:28, 11 June 2007 (UTC) delete per lacking |reliable sources to |verify any |notability claims in the article (also known as a failure of Wikipedia:Attribution). Also, to Deletion of Frank Carney WP:RS||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10451 21233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List Of Dictators Who Had Pet Cats User:Jjjjjjdddddd 00:07, 6 August 2016 (UTC) delete per and , as well as being a POV magnet. Though I do think it's a notable topic, however, because heads of state are inherently notable, I think List of state leaders who had pet cats covers this topic nicely Deletion of List Of Dictators Who Had Pet Cats WP:LISTCRUFT||WP:V Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
10452 7691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Menstruation and the origins of culture User:Sdedeo 22:49, 30 December 2006 (UTC) keep cleanup, delete massive swathes of , and possibly merge. I am not an anthropologist, but the theory sounds very silly. However, it seems to have been the subject of a peer-reviewed ''book'' from YUP. I'm aware from my own field that having these kinds of articles is intensely irritating because of the weirdos they attract, but really that YUP text does it for me. Do drop me a line on my talk page if there is something going on I don't see Deletion of Menstruation and the origins of culture WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10453 2557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James W. LaBelle User:David 05:46, 6 February 2018 (UTC) keep per #C5, thanks to Gnome's improvements Deletion of James W. LaBelle WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10454 17957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rusty Cooley User:Goodvac 10:58, 12 November 2010 (UTC) delete does not meet . The Google News search does not show significant coverage in independent reliable sources Deletion of Rusty Cooley WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10455 9531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cathi Bond User:LEvalyn 19:26, 29 June 2021 (UTC) keep The book unambiguously passes so if Bond herself is not considered notable, the existing material should be moved to a new article on the book as a “background” section. Since notability is not inherited, that might be the most strictly accurate way to do it. But especially with Bearcat’s finds, I think there’s enough out there for GNG. And I dislike the move option because there’s less scope for growth and improvement of the narrower book article, so I prefer to keep the bio Deletion of Cathi Bond WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10456 4045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carolyn Banks User:Gidonb 01:20, 30 April 2019 (UTC) keep Meets both and . and also apply Deletion of Carolyn Banks WP:AUTHOR||WP:GNG||WP:NOTCLEANUP||WP:SNOWBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10457 19587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jessie McKay (2nd nomination) User:Rick 02:11, 19 June 2010 (UTC) delete Not notable and upon a check Justa Punk is right about |COI. '''RICK Deletion of Jessie McKay (2nd nomination) WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
10458 13042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of free disk cloning soft User:Alexius08 23:43, 20 May 2008 (UTC) delete as a directory and a |how-to Deletion of List of free disk cloning soft WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10459 1327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jen Taylor Friedman User:Jon513 11:38, 23 July 2007 (UTC) delete I agree with IZAK. I would also add that as Friedman only coverage is because she is a novelty (female torah scribe) it is not enough (per ) to have an article about her. The subject can be better dealt with in Sofer#Women and Sofrut Deletion of Jen Taylor Friedman WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10460 4729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Law User:Spiderone 20:59, 4 May 2021 (UTC) keep the coverage in ''Scotsman'' and ''Six Nations Rugby'' is just about enough for in my opinion Deletion of Sarah Law WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10461 13607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bea Priestley User:Laurel_Wreath_of_Victors 05:28, 14 March 2017 (UTC) delete fails , page itself seems to be copied entirely from http://prowrestling.wikia.com/wiki/Beatrice_Priestley here Deletion of Bea Priestley WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10462 2325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thy Catafalque User:Blackmetalbaz 17:51, 10 August 2010 (UTC) comment The ezines clearly do not pass in any way, shape or form. Prog Archives, like Discogs, MusicMight and Metal Archives do also not confer notability. That leaves the Hungarian sources, which I confess I am struggling to evaluate... being distributed worldwide is not a signifier of notability, and having released four albums is not grounds for invoking in the absence of coverage in |reliable sources; in this case Hungarian media will be fine, as long as it is not simply a webzine. Print media distributed by a third-party source is your friend Deletion of Thy Catafalque WP:RS||WP:IAR||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10463 16436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/European Basketball Player of the Year Awards User:Bagumba 20:57, 19 September 2015 (UTC) delete No prejudice if there is consensus later for to repeat information already found on the individual award pages because this grouping is inherently notable, but no arguments have come forth after two weeks that is met Deletion of European Basketball Player of the Year Awards WP:IAR||WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
10464 11055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jake ihn User:Agüeybaná 22:38, 19 September 2007 (UTC) delete does not comply with our |verifiability policy, as it does not cite any reliable, third-party sources Deletion of Jake ihn WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10465 10532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pakistan Women Muslim League User:Hmlarson 02:44, 27 June 2017 (UTC) keep First women's political party in Pakistan = notable. I have added a few English references. There are more available in Urdu per the party's website as a start. Article could use expansion, not deletion per Deletion of Pakistan Women Muslim League WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
10466 19180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Colonel (Monty Python) user:Andrew 17:26, 28 May 2014 (UTC) keep """It's easy to find |significant coverage which confirms the character's importance in the structure of the show. For example """"The Colonel is again acting as the arbiter of good taste, and also -- as a replacement for a punchline or a traditional link -- he is a transitionary tool. His outbursts remind the viewer of the constructedness of the performance, of its artificiality, and of the fact that it can be directed and re-directed by the characters and elements within the diegetic world. This narrative chicanery is the Pythons' tilting at Auntie BBC -- the ancien régime of Light Entertainment to be rebelled against -- and will come to characterize the narrative structure of ''Flying Circus""" Deletion of The Colonel (Monty Python) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
10467 12499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elise Andaya User:GretLomborg 19:58, 12 July 2017 (UTC) delete Seems to fail per nom. It doesn't seems right to judge the notability different scholars by different standards based on how they choose to publish their work (e.g. in book form vs. peer reviewed papers). Seems like a fairly average anthropologist professor Deletion of Elise Andaya WP:NSCHOLAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10468 5721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/R. Joe Brandon User:Peripitus 11:39, 31 August 2006 (UTC) delete he's coauthored a number of papers ( according to googlescholar ) but does not meet the Professor criteria of and clearly fails the author section Deletion of R. Joe Brandon WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10469 1186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Papy Abedi User:Beansy 07:04, 18 December 2012 (UTC) keep I was going to not vote and simply comment that I didn't see the point of nominating articles for people who have a 90% chance of passing within a year (since he's still in the UFC), but after looking at his record Abedi had a fight for Shooto in addition to two for the UFC. That makes three fights for top-tier organizations per . He passes . He should not be up for nomination Deletion of Papy Abedi WP:MMANOT||WP:MMANOT||WP:MMANOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10470 11638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samanta Institute of Science and Technology User:Shaliya 23:57, 13 March 2012 (UTC) comment """As anyone would notice, there are several """"deletes"""" above that are accounts or IPs with few edits. And as anyone would notice, there is a {{tl|not a ballot}} note at the top of the page. I am not saying that accounts with few edits should be excluded from participation here. But the real problem is that this article is being judged negatively based on the way it appeared when it was initially proposed for deletion, which is radically different from the originial version, and based on the fact it has been edited by many SPAs. The nom even stated inaccurately that it was created by an SPA. The reality is that I, a veteran editor, created the article after seeing a segment about it on the news, and http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Samanta_Institute_of_Science_and_Technology&oldid=367134208 this is my original version. It contained plenty of sources, enough to meet the |general notability guideline. Many of those |links have rotted since, but LINKROT is not a reason for deletion. I have not really paid much attention to editing of this article since then, and I have actually edited Wikipedia very little in the past several months""" Deletion of Samanta Institute of Science and Technology WP:GNG||WP:LINKROT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10471 1807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Tse (2nd nomination) User:Kosm1fent 08:56, 9 September 2012 (UTC) keep seems to pass , but also seems to fail . And despite what T. Canens says, GNG and NFOOTY are '''not''' independent from each other, as standalone articles are required to meet GNG (#Applicable policies and guidelines). Participation in a fully professional league is a indication that maybe there is enough coverage on the player to satisfy GNG, but there could be none of value. In this case, there is no indication that the player's single participation in a fully pro league made him more notable than before. However, I'm willing to assume good faith on T. Canens' part that there is good-quality coverage on him in reliable Chinese sources, mostly because I can't speak or read or understand any Asian language and I'm not willing to start now. &ndash Deletion of Sean Tse (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
10472 18430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frances Lynn User:HisSpaceResearch 12:26, 3 December 2007 (UTC) delete Some notability claims, but still appears to fall short of Deletion of Frances Lynn WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10473 223 [[Integrale Medizin]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:JHeuser 16:10, 2. Jun. 2007 (CEST) delete keinerlei Quellen für den Begriff in anerkannter Fachliteratur, damit klarer Fall von |Theoriefindung Löschung von Integrale Medizin Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
10474 5727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wikiislam (2nd nomination) NONE NONE comment """Weak Keep): The user who created the article is most likely not familiar with the policies of Wikipedia. The criteria for inclusion on Wikipedia is notability and for a website, that has been linked in this discussion already: Wikipedia:Notability (web) which says ''""""The content itself has been the subject of '''multiple non-trivial''' published works whose source is independent of the site itself. ... This criterion includes '''reliable''' published works in all forms""""''. So we need multiple reliable non-trivial sources. So far the user who created the article (Dawnshine; https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikiislam&action=history page history) has not provided any reliable sources with significant coverage. If anyone wants to save the article, there ''may'' be some reliable sources found on their About page: http://wikiislam.net/wiki/WikiIslam#References . You will have to look for yourself and see if anything can qualify for a reliable source with non-trivial coverage. The website has been the subject of two research papers by the same author (Goran Larson). His name is present on the references list there and the author of the article has used one of those papers http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs11562-007-0002-2. This may or may not qualify for . I personally dont believe there is enough non-trivial coverage found in multiple reliable sources. Other than that the author is also violating (this has also been pointed out above) by making statements like these""" Deletion of Wikiislam (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:OR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10475 5504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clare Venema User:Niteshift36 13:53, 9 July 2009 (UTC) delete Notability is really a matter of . If she gets notable later, it can be re-written Deletion of Clare Venema WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10476 6118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ravage (Transformers) User:4meter4 18:36, 25 September 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Ravage (Transformers) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10477 5855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Royalty Check User:Joe 02:29, 15 December 2009 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Royalty Check WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10478 20203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Crowder (2nd nomination) User:onel5969 12:14, 14 February 2019 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass , or Deletion of Tom Crowder (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:GRIDIRON||WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
10479 1020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Life internet User:S 06:49, 13 October 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Life internet WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
10480 13849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raja Erij Zaman Khan User:Tiller54 14:53, 7 October 2014 (UTC) keep English language search engines probably aren't the best places to find sources about a Pakistani clan chief. But, as a member of the West Pakistan legislative assembly, he would pass Deletion of Raja Erij Zaman Khan WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10481 21855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Born in the Streets User:ArcAngel 17:46, 4 February 2009 (UTC) delete per failing Deletion of Born in the Streets WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10482 8523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pusa Call User:Qworty 04:40, 31 January 2011 (UTC) delete Completely non-notable , and may even be Deletion of Pusa Call WP:OR||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:No original research 65
10483 5381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tres Watson (2nd nomination) User:Mackensen 13:20, 19 March 2017 (UTC) delete Lacks significant coverage in reliable sources. Doesn't pass Deletion of Tres Watson (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10484 14384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nelson Monhon User:Jimbo 11:12, 8 February 2010 (UTC) delete as original PRODer, he has not played at a fully-professional level failing . No significant media coverage to pass either Deletion of Nelson Monhon WP:ATH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10485 14512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delroy Denton User:Moritheil 11:31, 2 May 2009 (UTC) keep Notable. BBC reported it. eadline; article will eventually be improved Deletion of Delroy Denton WP:D Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
10486 2143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Troubles in Silverbridge User:Guliolopez 11:36, 19 February 2019 (UTC) merge """to Silverbridge, County Armagh. Per nom. And (""""page is very short and is unlikely to be expanded within a reasonable amount of time""""; 13 years seems like a """"reasonable amount of time"""". As the content hasn't been expanded beyond a bullet or so in that time, it seems appropriate to merge that bullet elsewhere""" Deletion of The Troubles in Silverbridge WP:MERGEREASON Wikipedia:Merging 54
10487 13428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I am the Lord your God User:S 00:08, 4 September 2009 (UTC) merge """to ten commandments. I agree with WikiDan61 that the article is well-structured, well-referenced, and well-balanced, and I believe requires us to consider where to put well-sourced content when deciding a subject is not suitable for a separate article.However, I also agree with Elen of the Roads and OwenX that this is a fork. I do not agree that it is |original research; it may be a |synthesis, but it does not advance a particular position.All the above would indicate a """"keep"""" outcome, but I think it better to have a smaller number of articles, each of which is longer and watched by more interested editors, than a plethora of small articles each watched by only a few. I think the Wiki model works best when more editors are involved, and I also think it helps end-users of the encyclopaedia if thematically-grouped content is kept together in the same article so they do not have to search or follow links to find the information they need. And further, I think much of the content of this article is duplicated in ten commandments so a merge would be more economical in terms of reading time for end-users""" Deletion of I am the Lord your God WP:PRESERVE||WP:OR||WP:SYN Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
10488 15386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Schnaged [[User talk:reddogsix#top|talk]]) 02:32, 1 January 2013 (UTC) delete not a word in general use. Certainly and . USER:reddogsix|reddogsix Deletion of Schnaged WP:NOTNEO||WP:ONEDAY Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10489 10826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Life in stereo User:Seattle 06:56, 28 March 2007 (UTC) delete Another band that fits the speedy criteria #A7(band), there is no claim/source of any notability Deletion of Life in stereo WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
10490 20164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Neville, 11th Baron Braybrooke User:Kbabej 18:47, 11 April 2020 (UTC) keep """He appears in https://www.ukwhoswho.com/view/10.1093/ww/9780199540884.001.0001/ww-9780199540884-e-289642/version/1 UK Who's Who, which meets criteria number three. While I am aware of dependent coverage in , ''UK Who's Who'' is """"The oldest and best-known is the annual publication Who's Who, a reference work on contemporary prominent people in Britain published annually since 1849"""" (per the current WP Who's Who|Who's Who article). That leads me to believe it is not the scamming vanity projects most ''Who's Who'' are today""" Deletion of Richard Neville, 11th Baron Braybrooke WP:ANYBIO||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10491 19826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The County User:Tnxman307 02:59, 4 June 2008 (UTC) delete """As original prodder (?). Article is about a TV show currently in production. Using phrases like """"rumored"""" and """"strongly speculated"""" does not help either. Fails """ Deletion of The County WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10492 11720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rachel preciouses User:Bearcat 17:45, 13 October 2005 (UTC) delete """Non-notable. Does not meet . """"Power Chord"""" is not a ''genre'' of music. And on, and so forth. Just delete""" Deletion of Rachel preciouses WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10493 9144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Einar Selvik User:Celestina007 08:45, 01 November 2017 (UTC) delete Although subject of aforementioned article does have some notability, it does not satisfy Deletion of Einar Selvik WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10494 20246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/USCG Station Montauk User:Srich32977 04:40, 12 September 2010 (UTC) delete WP:ITEXISTS, , don't help Deletion of USCG Station Montauk WP:ARTICLEAGE||WP:LOTSOFSOURCES Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10495 19153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lene Brøndum User:Mendaliv 16:48, 6 January 2018 (UTC) keep Meets as having had significant roles in multiple notable films, at least as far as I can tell (two of the three listed in the article were at least submissions for Best Foreign Language Film at the Academy Awards; while that's not sufficient for those articles' notability, I think it's a good indicator the films were notable in their nations of origin). And the awards would seem to satisfy Deletion of Lene Brøndum WP:NACTOR||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10496 6545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Medical Eponyms Discouraged Because of Nazi Associations User:Peterkingiron 20:14, 29 October 2010 (UTC) keep probably renamed (as AniMate). This seems to me a notable topic, to which articles on the current names may want to link in explaining a previous name for the same condition. Yes, there are POV issues, but the whole thing seems to be based on a artciel in an academic journal (not that I know anything of the subject Deletion of List of Medical Eponyms Discouraged Because of Nazi Associations WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10497 10978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Washin-Ryu Karate-Do User:JJL 18:32, 30 June 2013 (UTC) keep Washin-Ryu Karate-Do as a notable style. Looking at , this style has existed at least since the 1960s (claims a longer history), has notable practitioners (Hidy Ochiai and Mike Stone (karate)), is the subject of several books (notably Ochiai's The Essence of Self-Defense, Hidy Ochiai's Complete Book of Self-Defense, and Hidy Ochiai's Living Karate http://www.amazon.com/Hidy-Ochiai/e/B001K8FUKG/--despite the titles having been selected for broader appeal, the first two are indeed on Washin-ryu) and mentioned in The Martial Arts Encyclopedia by John Corcoran and Emil Farkas and An Illustrated History of Martial Arts In America: 1900 to Present by Emil Farkas (verifiable by search at Amazon), numerous magazine articles (e.g., Karate Illustrated Jan. 1984, on its Sanchin kata http://www.ma-mags.com/Mags/KIl/KIl%201984-01%20Cov.jpg and Official Karate Jan. 1977 on the modernity of the style http://www.ma-mags.com/Mags/OK/OK%201977-01%20Cov.jpg, among numerous others), basis of programs at SUNY Cortland http://www2.cortland.edu/offices/recreational-sports/non-credit-instruction/Washin-Ryu-Karate/ (see also http://books.google.com/books?id=dgFVOliv_FkC&pg=PA3&lpg=PA3&dq=washin-ryu&source=bl&ots=ipDAzybOM5&sig=h3Fh6BLZKbO44gDbHfsd4COVLZ4&hl=en&sa=X&ei=lHXQUcPNBsiYygHu3oHQCg&ved=0CDcQ6AEwAjgy#v=onepage&q=washin-ryu&f=false) and SUNY Binghamton. Notable, noted style Deletion of Washin-Ryu Karate-Do WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10498 3310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Rise of Victimhood Culture User:XavierItzm 23:40, 3 January 2019 (UTC) keep Meets . Excellent sourcing. People may quibble on the very notable article vs. the recently published book with the exact same topic with the same thesis by the same two authors: that conversation belongs on the TP. AfD is not cleanup and can never be Deletion of The Rise of Victimhood Culture WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10499 15048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jiz Lee User:Colapeninsula 12:55, 28 July 2015 (UTC) keep WP:PORNBIO is not the be-all and end-all when it comes to proving notability. Indeed it's a far from great guideline and frequently contested. Lee meets , a far more reliable and long-established standard that derives directly from Wikipedia policies and Deletion of Jiz Lee WP:GNG||WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
10500 5203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ACF Car Finance User:Themfromspace 19:52, 27 January 2012 (UTC) delete I also can't find significant coverage of this subject in reliable sources, to meet our |general notability guideline Deletion of ACF Car Finance WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10501 15443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlton K. Mack User:Guettarda 13:13, 13 April 2021 (UTC) keep Nationally significant figure. Easily passes the GNG. He was a pioneer of the grocery business in Trinidad and Tobago and a leader of the Chinese community. Built the first shopping mall, which bore his name: {{tq|JT Allum company pioneered the first concept of a mall in San Fernando when they built Carlton Centre in 1965}}https://newsday.co.tt/2019/10/08/mack-family-gets-keys-to-city/. Was profiled by Fr. Look Lai in his bookhttps://www.google.com/books/edition/The_Chinese_in_the_West_Indies_1806_1995/fMrit6tcO_AC?hl=en&gbpv=1&kptab=overview&bsq=carlton%20mack (which was published by an academic press). Inducted into the Business Hall of Fame by the Trinidad and Tobago Chamber of Industry and Commercehttps://chamber.org.tt/business-hall-of-fame-inductees. (Profile linked from that page https://chamber.org.tt/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/2013-mack.pdf). Per you should really take a moment to search for people before AFDing them Deletion of Carlton K. Mack WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
10502 16756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Past life healing User:Daniel5127 02:59, 23 March 2007 (UTC) delete Unvertifiable, and utter nonsense, violation of |NOR. Therefore, this article should be deleted anyways Deletion of Past life healing WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10503 11103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacqueline Fitzsimon User:Dhartung 04:11, 22 June 2007 (UTC) delete nothing remotely relevant found in Google Books (other than confirming the existence of the book allegedly covering the story) or Google News Archive. Hoax, fails , fails as notable hoax Deletion of Jacqueline Fitzsimon WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10504 3020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diana Gomez User:STATicVapor 18:24, 9 September 2014 (UTC) delete Certainly does not meet in any way Deletion of Diana Gomez WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10505 731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacob Jaffe User:Agricola44 16:26, 2 December 2010 (UTC) delete """In addition to the above, pointers to his work """"Land of Dreams"""" are actually self-referential and much of the article is for discussing """"Land of Dreams"""" and """"Hobgoblins""" Deletion of Jacob Jaffe WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
10506 11514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wizards world user:czar 05:02, 14 April 2015 (UTC) delete Well, article topic lacks |significant coverage from |reliable, |independent sources. (|?) It had no meaningful hits in a /RS|video game reliable sources https://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=003516479746865699832:leawcwkqifq custom Google search. There are no worthwhile redirect targets. Please ping me if more (non-English and offline) sources show in the future. czar Deletion of Wizards world WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:42||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10507 21170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brittany Hatch User:Pmedema 23:12, 5 April 2008 (UTC) delete Agreed. Not enough to bring it above the bar of Deletion of Brittany Hatch WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10508 4226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harald Ende User:Ben 20:14, 2 February 2014 (UTC) delete Nothing found about him, even not in german sources, that could make him notable. He is an orchestral musician that played for a notable band leader, doesn't makes himself |notable Deletion of Harald Ende WP:PEOPLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10509 3026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MundoNick.com User:Rjd0060 03:21, 25 September 2007 (UTC) delete I would say redirect to MundoNick, but it doesn't exist, so just delete it. per Deletion of MundoNick.com WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10510 14731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rudolf Yanson User:Power 11:31, 23 November 2009 (UTC) keep Lack of Google footprint for a Russian academic in a specialist field is a weak deletion rationale, in particular with this list of publications, susceptible to and general concerns about negative evidence Deletion of Rudolf Yanson WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
10511 11887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wellbeing software group User:Whpq 20:39, 7 June 2015 (UTC) delete I cannot find significant coverage in multiple |reliable sources to establish |notability when searching for the parent company nor for any of the subsidiary companies. The company exists, and I am able to find press release material like http://www.ehilive.co.uk/page.cfm/action=Press/libID=1/libEntryID=156 this, but press releases do not establish notability. The first two references in the article are to business databases which can be used to confirm facts about the company but does nothing to establish notability. The third reference is to the company's own web site and represents a |primary source Deletion of Wellbeing software group WP:RS||WP:N||WP:PRIMARYSOURCE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10512 1216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Perspectives on Human Sexuality User:Dennisthe2 01:29, 13 May 2007 (UTC) delete as |original research, not really POV. It gives a brief explanation to the issue at hand and doesn't really violate the NPOV clauses. I have to dissent with the need to salt this at this time; we'll cross that bridge if we come to it Deletion of Christian Perspectives on Human Sexuality WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10513 13306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Material Girl The Musical User:Paul 04:26, 20 August 2010 (UTC) delete I could find |no sources to support it, other than user-generated content http://www.facebook.com/pages/Material-Girl-The-Musical/145090542182712 at Facebook; it's possibly a copyright violation Deletion of Material Girl The Musical WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10514 16874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Drowned User:Superastig 02:20, 15 June 2020 (UTC) keep Per reasons above. |Article needs some cleanup. Other than that, it easily passes Deletion of Ben Drowned WP:NOTCLEANUP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10515 1149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brock Miller User:Cbl62 00:13, 24 March 2017 (UTC) delete Nominator is correct that Miller does not satisfy , though a college football player can also qualify under . Here, however, I am not finding significant coverage in multiple, reliable, independents sources, as is needed to satisfy GNG. Brief transactional announcements such as http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/san-francisco-49ers-sign-punter-brock-miller-per-report/ this do not IMO constitute significant coverage of the type needed per GNG. Willing to reconsider if more significant coverage is found Deletion of Brock Miller WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10516 15581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dele Alampasu User:GiantSnowman 18:30, 26 March 2014 (UTC) delete fails both and Deletion of Dele Alampasu WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10517 4023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marion Kozak User:Quasihuman 02:04, 3 August 2012 (UTC) merge """after reviewing what sources I can find on the internet, the subject does not appear to pass , as the https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&tbm=bks&tbm=bks&q=inauthor:%22Marion+Kozak%22&sa=X&ei=WCwbUNKADuvuiQLu9IHgAw&ved=0CDkQ9Ag four publications does not appear to pass the third criteria of said guideline. Additionally subject does not appear to pass ; although the subject is mentioned multiple times in news sources, and mentions in books, none of them appear to meet ''Significant coverage''. One possible exception is http://www.telegraph.co.uk/family/7730052/The-miraculous-escape-of-Marion-Miliband.html this article in the Telegraph, however it can be argued that the """"piece together"""" nature of the article, as the article itself states, can mean it (the article) is more about the events around the subject and not the subject herself. All that being said, what content that can be |verified can be merged with the article & section Ralph Miliband#Personal life, as suggested by""" Deletion of Marion Kozak WP:AUTHOR||WP:GNG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
10518 13376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Schelle User:LinguistAtLarge 16:13, 2 April 2009 (UTC) keep I declined the PROD, and while I think Rjanag makes a reasonable argument, I also think |there is room for an article on this fully professional player, even though he only played one game. It is obvious that there are varying degrees of notability for professional sports players, but I think we can and should have an article on every ''professional'' sports player. — Deletion of Jim Schelle WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10519 4853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bilel Henider User:Bettia 13:26, 1 September 2009 (UTC) delete Fails as he has yet to play at a Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|fully professional level, and a quick Google search only brings up http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=uk&hl=en&q=Bilel+Henider two match reports and a http://www.google.com/search?client=opera&rls=en&q=Bilel+Henider&sourceid=opera&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8 shedload of Wiki mirrors and profile pages, which aren't enough to satisfy |general notability guidelines Deletion of Bilel Henider WP:ATHLETE||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10520 21597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/April Grace (2nd nomination) User:IJBall 20:29, 4 January 2016 (UTC) delete """Lithorien is correct that there's a body of work here. The problem is that it's almost exclusively as a TV ''guest star'' and in minor film roles. demands """"significant roles"""" and I just don't see that here... Note also that the """"SAG Award nomination was for Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Theatrical Motion Picture alongside her co-stars in 1999"""" in ''Magnolia (film)|Magnolia'' so the """"SAG award nomination"""" wasn't even specific ''to her""" Deletion of April Grace (2nd nomination) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10521 14004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hartselle City School District User:Cullen328 00:59, 2 March 2013 (UTC) comment The only way to determine if any given one of these school districts meets would be to make a good faith effort to look for coverage in reliable sources for that specific school district. Consider the case of one of the nominated articles, Benicia Unified School District, a district which I happen to be familiar with. This district operates seven schools enrolling nearly 5000 students. Using Google News Archive, I was easily able to find 100 articles about this district in seven different newspapers, three of which are major regional papers, namely the Sacramento Bee, the Oakland Tribune and the San Jose Mercury News. Unfortunately, almost all of these articles are hidden behind pay walls, but the snippets available make it clear to me that this district meets . How many other such indisputably notable districts are hidden in this mass deletion Deletion of Hartselle City School District WP:ORG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10522 18096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drugdiablo User:Paste 12:59, 17 April 2011 (UTC) delete I added the SD tag and am as surprised as others that we are here at an AfD, fails Deletion of Drugdiablo WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10523 3209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lars Vilks Muhammad drawings controversy User:Fnagaton 23:38, 29 October 2007 (UTC) keep mdash; Reproducing the images for the purposes of creating an article about this notable subject is not inappropriate. This user has a history of trying to censor the images based on his point of view without wanting to seriously talk about his changes first. For example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Lars_Vilks_Muhammad_drawings_controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Techana. The article itself operates within as far as I can see and does not present bias. The images are certainly notable enough and pass erifiability Deletion of Lars Vilks Muhammad drawings controversy WP:NPOV||WP:V Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
10524 9953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pierre et Marie Curie School User:ComplexRational 13:28, 4 August 2019 (UTC) delete I found no sources describing this school besides its website (already linked). This is not adequate sourcing to satisfy or Deletion of Pierre et Marie Curie School WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10525 20298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Romain Gauthier User:Andrea105 22:29, 8 November 2009 (UTC) keep per sources above meeting Deletion of Romain Gauthier WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10526 20112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pocketful of Mint User:Metropolitan90 06:50, 29 December 2011 (UTC) delete This article appears to be a copyright violation of the book's jacket copy. http://mint.steadivision.com/ At any rate, no |independent reliable sources have been provided to establish that the book satisfies any of the |notability criteria for books Deletion of Pocketful of Mint WP:RS||WP:BK Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10527 9109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Byron Somerset Public School User:Mh29255 23:51, 26 December 2007 (UTC) delete per nom and no assertion of notability per Deletion of Byron Somerset Public School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10528 1570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vira Konstantynova User:Etzedek24 19:07, 7 July 2019 (UTC) delete Interviews can't be used to establish notability per Deletion of Vira Konstantynova WP:IS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10529 3224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rohit Ugale (2nd nomination) User:Georgetgeorge 17:25, 3 September 2021 (UTC) keep The person is notable and has featured in many news and magazines. One of the independent sources I found is here https://www.outlookindia.com/website/story/outlook-spotlight-big-day-for-rohit-ugale-young-businessman-award-at-international-glory-awards-by-sonu-sood/393499 and easily passes Deletion of Rohit Ugale (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10530 2999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maliz E. Beams User:Coolabahapple 12:55, 21 September 2018 (UTC) comment """i note that (nearly) all the other Counselor of the United States Department of State|counsellors have individual wikiarticles (i know that being in this position does not automatically make the person wikinotable but does reflect the notableness of such people), also that the article presently has 8 references, is there anything wrong with them (need more depth, not |reliable?)?, here are some more that editors may want to have a look at: from ''The Boston Globe'' - http://archive.boston.com/business/personalfinance/articles/2010/01/17/a_shift_from_retirement_planning_to_lifelong_planning/ """"From retirement planning to lifelong planning"""" - interview with Beams about the implications for retirement investors post GFC growth (subcription required), ''American Banker'' - https://www.americanbanker.com/slideshow/most-powerful-women-in-finance-2013 """"The 25 Most Powerful Women in Finance"""" - Beames is no. 8, ''Puget Sound Business Journal'' - https://www.bizjournals.com/seattle/news/2018/09/17/voya-maliz-beams-board-cannabis-investment-network.html """"Ex-Voya CEO joins Bellevue-based cannabis investor group's advisory board"""" (subscription required""" Deletion of Maliz E. Beams WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10531 1998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omaha, NE (Comic) User:ST47 11:42, 20 August 2006 (UTC) delete as per and Deletion of Omaha, NE (Comic) WP:NN||WP:NFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10532 14470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sophie Ellis-Bextor's Fourth Studio album User:TenPoundHammer 01:52, 14 June 2009 (UTC) delete per . Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Special:Contributions/TenPoundHammer|Many otters • :User talk:TenPoundHammer|One bat Deletion of Sophie Ellis-Bextor's Fourth Studio album WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
10533 5009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people from Harvey, Illinois User:Lugnuts 18:55, 11 March 2014 (UTC) keep per Deletion of List of people from Harvey, Illinois WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
10534 15777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cohort (computer science) User:Pmedema 18:03, 12 December 2010 (UTC) delete This is a that is not even mentioned in the Computer science article Deletion of Cohort (computer science) WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10535 8895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Israeli helicopter disaster in Romania User:Roscelese 22:15, 24 January 2012 (UTC) delete """Keep"""" votes citing the amount of coverage are ignoring the necessary rider to . ''does'' ask for persistence of coverage and/or lasting effects (and also incidentally states that geographical scope of coverage is ''not'' sufficient - which makes sense, since lots of things get short-term international coverage in Our Global Age but ultimately fade into oblivion""" Deletion of 2010 Israeli helicopter disaster in Romania WP:NOTNEWS||WP:GNG||WP:EVENT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10536 21737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spells of Everquest User:Recury 17:58, 12 July 2006 (UTC) delete the guy who made that must really like Spirit of Wolf. I agree, would be a game guide if expanded, and that would violate Deletion of Spells of Everquest WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10537 17541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wolf Beats User:78 14:41, 17 January 2018 (UTC) delete although several of the artists have blue links, all but one of them re-direct back towards the label's page. Single notable act (and it seems barely notable) is under the management company, and gets a brief, brief mention. https://www.youredm.com/edm-premiere-silva-hound-cool-friends-murtagh-veschell-remix is the only independent source I could find. I have no idea regarding its reliability. Even if highly reliable, I don't think this is a notable record label, as there is no significant roster of notable artists, nor does it meet , nor does any source claim the label has otherwise had a significant impact on the development or history of a genre or regional musical culture Deletion of Wolf Beats WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10538 4813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Control-left User:Hazarasp 04:13, 2 September 2017 (UTC) delete I could not find any use of this term outside blogs or minor media sources; as such fails Deletion of Control-left WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10539 18856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andres Cortes User:Wikicology 10:00, 26 October 2014 (UTC) delete Sadly no evidence of notability. Subject fails . The CV can be published elsewhere but certainly not here Deletion of Andres Cortes WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10540 9738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Symitar User:Rjd0060 04:32, 27 November 2007 (UTC) keep http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&ned=us&q=%22Symitar+%22&ie=UTF-8 Google news search brings back a number of relevant results, from reliable sources. Some of the results' headlines imply that the articles are specifically about the company, thus, appearing to meet |notability requirements Deletion of Symitar WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10541 17381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Counter-Life User:Swatjester 15:03, 3 March 2006 (UTC) comment This nomination was made as part of a . Nlitement is upset over his article being nominated for AfD as unnotable, so he is nominating several other mods as AfD in retaliation Deletion of Counter-Life WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
10542 4622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tumiso Rakgare User:Enos733 03:10, 11 February 2021 (UTC) keep meets as a member of the Botswana Parliament Deletion of Tumiso Rakgare WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10543 7014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BRAAAAAINS! User:Northamerica1000 02:15, 4 September 2012 (UTC) delete spaced ndash}} Fails . After some searching, not finding any coverage in reliable sources whatsoever Deletion of BRAAAAAINS! WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10544 2792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Smoke (Australian band) User:1292simon 01:33, 17 December 2012 (UTC) delete Does not pass Deletion of The Smoke (Australian band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10545 11488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flashcard Exchange User:Carlh 03:13, 26 November 2010 (UTC) delete """Not notable enough to meet . There is no """"historic significance"""" here. Many similar sites exist: none with Wikipedia pages. A mention that online flashcards and sites exist is already included in the main Flashcards page. That is enough""" Deletion of Flashcard Exchange WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10546 11852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sankar nair User:Becksguy 09:29, 3 January 2008 (UTC) delete Completely agree with TheBilly and nom as obvious and patent nonsense. This is a no-brainer. Suggest speedy delete to mitigate drain on editors time and energy Deletion of Sankar nair WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
10547 21776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kanga League 2009 User:Smartyllama 17:30, 8 November 2016 (UTC) merge to Kanga Cricket League as says that is preferable to deletion when individual seasons aren't notable. Which this isn't Deletion of Kanga League 2009 WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10548 11825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank Blackburn (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 17:56, 27 March 2019 (UTC) delete """Bossier City is large enough that a mayor (interim or otherwise) might get over the bar if the article were really well-referenced, but it is not large enough to hand him an automatic inclusion freebie just because he existed as a mayor — and this is not really well-referenced, but depends two-thirds on |primary sources and one-third on local media coverage that isn't even fully cited enough for us to even identify what it was. (Small-town city councillors, for example, have ''not'' received """"significant press coverage"""" for the purposes of NPOL #2 just because you can reference their vote totals to a raw table of election results, which is what I suspect the ''Shreveport Journal'' citation might be given the context of what it's being used to footnote""" Deletion of Frank Blackburn (2nd nomination) WP:PRIMARYSOURCES Wikipedia:No original research 65
10549 19510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Event Management in Pakistan User:Isotope23 16:26, 16 June 2006 (UTC) delete this appears to be an unnecessary fork in a way. What makes ''Event Management in Pakistan'' conceptually different than ''Event Management'' in any other country? If this article somehow laid out a strong case that Event Managment in Pakistan comprised a set of unique cirmcumstances that did not apply to Event Management anywhere else in the world I might be persuaded to opine Keep, but that does not appear to be the case. The only difference is that the examples are localized (names of companies, costs of certain services, etc.)... taking those out, this could refer to Event Management anywhere, thus this article is too narrowly focused. Also, content in several places seems to violate a how-to guide Deletion of Event Management in Pakistan WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10550 1784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Brother 10 (US) User:Amarrg 08:46, 6 December 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Big Brother 10 (US) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10551 18978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gordon Cheng (3rd nomination) User:JRG 00:46, 7 April 2007 (UTC) keep """this has already been nominated and renominated for deletion, with no new information added as to why this should be deleted. The claims to notability are already made out. This should be closed immediately. The nominator has nominated this article |to make a point because I kept removing the word """"priest"""", which is inaccurate""" Deletion of Gordon Cheng (3rd nomination) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
10552 16491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of quote databases User:Headbomb 02:52, 30 June 2009 (UTC) keep while each database may not be notable on the individual level, the concept of databases of quotes certainly meets (see Deletion of List of quote databases WP:N||WP:LSC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10553 15705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elections in Pichilemu User:Sfs90 06:46, 22 September 2015 (UTC) delete As said before, per and hyperlocal coverage Deletion of Elections in Pichilemu WP:GEOSCOPE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10554 20171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russell Malton (2nd nomination) User:Kugao 18:05, 15 January 2011 (UTC) delete fails and . Recreate when/if he become notable in the future Deletion of Russell Malton (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10555 6543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darwin Brown User:Rodhullandemu 18:19, 24 January 2009 (UTC) delete Just another run of the mill killer Deletion of Darwin Brown WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10556 13125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Tulp User:Josalm64rc 21:15, 2 August 2019 (UTC) delete No in any sources. Just a non notable radio host which there are many of Deletion of James Tulp WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
10557 15111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S. David Wu User:XOR 22:11, 15 September 2019 (UTC) keep The https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=HLgW39MAAAAJ Google Scholar profile doesn't seem curated; it includes papers by other people in other fields. For example, none of the top three are actually by the article's subject. Two include as co-author an S. L. Wu who is a physicist https://link.springer.com/article/10.1140/epjc/s10052-011-1630-5https://journals.aps.org/prd/pdf/10.1103/PhysRevD.85.072004, and the third is a cellular biology paper with three Wu's on the author list, none of them S. David https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.4161/auto.19496. The fourth paper in the GS list is by this S. David Wu, but the fifth was co-authored by Sizong Wu. There's probably enough left after a more careful filtering to still pass #C1, but the #C5 case for the named chair is simpler Deletion of S. David Wu WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10558 7671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Johto [[User talk:.:Alex:.|.:]][[User:.:Alex:.|Alex]][[User talk:.:Alex:.|:.]]''' 11:40, 7 June 2008 (UTC) keep """as per Kanto and Hoenn nominations. """"|Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point""" Deletion of Johto WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
10559 147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher R. Wight User:Richwales 06:11, 9 August 2011 (UTC) delete per , , , and Deletion of Christopher R. Wight WP:RS||WP:INDY||WP:POLITICIAN||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10560 21943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Re:invention User:Coredesat 07:29, 14 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Re:invention WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10561 14655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John tedeschi User:Capitalistroadster 07:09, 2 September 2005 (UTC) delete as copyvio. However, Tedeschi would appear to qualify under io for a legitimate article please see his website bio. http://www.johntedeschi.net/biography/index.html Deletion of John tedeschi WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
10562 15548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rafael Páez User:IJA 13:17, 23 August 2014 (UTC) delete He hasn't played in a Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|Fully professional league & he doesn't have any international caps therefore he fails Deletion of Rafael Páez WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10563 4400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alyssa Carson (2nd nomination) User:Xxanthippe 00:02, 30 June 2020 (UTC) delete No significant improvement since last time. Certainly no pass of rof and sources are too flimsy, exaggerated and promotional for . Still no significant achievements to her name that would warrant notice by Wikipedia Deletion of Alyssa Carson (2nd nomination) WP:P||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Portal 85
10564 12747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indresh Kumar User:The9Man 06:08, 7 September 2020 (UTC) delete No notable positions held. Not meeting Deletion of Indresh Kumar WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10565 15619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ripper: A Heavy Metal Odyssey User:Kinu 06:38, 26 August 2006 (UTC) delete no evidence of meeting , and that the only link provided is to a Myspace page doesn't do much for either Deletion of Ripper: A Heavy Metal Odyssey WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10566 5363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Realjamesh User:Jack 10:26, 8 January 2021 (UTC) delete Per all above. Spam verging on |complete bollocks. Sourcing is primarily dodgy SEO crap; none of which contributes a red cent to notability. |Wikipedia is not for promotion Deletion of Realjamesh WP:CB||WP:NOTPROMO Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
10567 5728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luigi Verderame User:Monterey 04:49, 25 January 2011 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Luigi Verderame WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10568 15 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Burak Oyunda """Kullanıcı:tmy e12'''''tmѱ e12'''''""" 18:17, 26 Şubat 2017 (UTC) comment Kullanıcıya biraz süre verelim eğer bu süre zarfında madde 'yi sağlamazsa silinsin'''--User:By erdo can|''By erdo can'' • User talk:By erdo can|msj Burak Oyunda'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
10569 3344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JoAnn Giordano (2nd nomination) User:Coolabahapple 23:39, 1 August 2020 (UTC) keep meets , & , article has been improved (thanks {{u|Netherzone}}:)) since nomination to reflect this person's wikinotability Deletion of JoAnn Giordano (2nd nomination) WP:ARTIST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10570 11626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jayden Head User:GiantSnowman 18:42, 30 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Jayden Head WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10571 10876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chief Choc User:Eggishorn 15:06, 11 February 2017 (UTC) keep WP:NTEMP|Notability is not temporary. Chief Choc was well-covered in a significant debate about racism and college team mascots. The fact that it was ten years ago does not eliminate that coverage. Ongoing coverage is not necessary for Deletion of Chief Choc WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10572 5034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gail Leven Pollock User:Ohnoitsjamie 14:32, 27 December 2015 (UTC) delete Passing mention in the NYT is about all we have here. After three weeks, no one has been able to drop any info here regarding how she could possible meet or Deletion of Gail Leven Pollock WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10573 19314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yurdanur Salman User:Mr 21:42, 6 February 2007 (UTC) delete Consider . No awards, no independent sources attesting her notability, no broad body of publications Deletion of Yurdanur Salman WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10574 1299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of YouTubers (3rd nomination) User:Hijiri88 11:37, 30 April 2018 (UTC) comment noping|Fishhead2100}} should probably be warned about if they haven't already. Even if https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Contributions&dir=prev&offset=20180429190210&limit=129&contribs=user&target=Fishhead2100&namespace=3&tagfilter=&start=&end= these 129 identical messages were sent indiscriminately to all commenters on both sides of the previous AFDs (many of which are very old and date to a time when canvassing was for some reason considered acceptable as long as it was in favour of keeping articles that were at AFD, so they aren't a reliable precedent anyway), the wording of the message was blatantly non-neutral Deletion of List of YouTubers (3rd nomination) WP:CANVAS Wikipedia:Canvassing 93
10575 1497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miles Fisher User:Cirt 11:30, 7 September 2008 (UTC) comment """I have emailed {{user|Erwinfletcher}} in an attempt to resolve the possible issue related to text from http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0279702/bio Miles Fisher's bio page on IMDB, which says it is written by """"Erwin Fletcher"""". If the user agrees to release the work under the GFDL, then that is no longer an issue. In any event, I will work to remove all that info anyways and source everything in the article to additional / secondary sources (though I noticed some were already included as external links, and I have begun to format those and add more""" Deletion of Miles Fisher WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10576 13878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sakari Momoi User:Canadian 22:08, 16 October 2015 (UTC) keep Being the oldest anything does not, ''in and of itself'' confer automatic notability, but it does appear in this case that the subject of the article has met the coverage requirements of Deletion of Sakari Momoi WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10577 19048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emma Hutchins User:Tony 19:43, 20 August 2007 (UTC) delete minimal mentions in the David Tennant sphere of influence (on his site, a couple of fan sites), but nothing in the media to indicate anyone's picked up on the show. Fails Deletion of Emma Hutchins WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10578 8469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scintilla Iceland (2nd nomination) User:Spiderone 13:31, 10 November 2020 (UTC) delete obvious Deletion of Scintilla Iceland (2nd nomination) WP:G4 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
10579 632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eurofins Scientific User:Northamerica1000 17:39, 25 October 2012 (UTC) comment """This company passes per the independent sources comprised of significant coverage about it that were added to the article by User:Tijfo098. Regarding the nomination for deletion being partially based upon the article being unsourced at the time of its nomination, please note that per , topic notability is not correlated with whether or not articles have sources in them: """"The absence of citations in an article (as distinct from the non-existence of sources) does not indicate that the subject is not notable."""" See and for further information""" Deletion of Eurofins Scientific WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:NRVE||WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10580 9017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nucleus Research User:Eddie891 12:12, 16 September 2020 (UTC) delete per nom and highking, this seems to be a pretty clear fail of / Deletion of Nucleus Research WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10581 21859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mikie Sherrill User:Alansohn 16:57, 7 June 2018 (UTC) keep The in-depth articles about her as a female U.S. Navy helicopter pilot / attorney / mom who has become a politician establish her strong claim of notability. In addition to the area coverage, the articles about her in ''USA Today'', ''The Wall Street Journal'' and https://www.glamour.com/story/mikie-sherrill-running-for-congress this piece in ''Glamour'' all provide the significant coverage needed to establish her notability per Deletion of Mikie Sherrill WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10582 7803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Randall User:Last_Malthusian 09:24, 18 January 2006 (UTC) delete anyone can write religious magazines, every school has a leader, and apparently pretty much anyone can get a diploma from LBU. To meet we need evidence that people outside himself and his flock have paid him or his magazines any attention. Google searches on him and his magazines suggest that they haven't Deletion of Mike Randall WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10583 8881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Temple of Spooky Electric User:William 23:17, 10 September 2006 (UTC) comment I looked and couldn't find anything. The only thing stopping me from agreeing with the nom is that one reference to an out-of-print, obscure book. Alas, it looks like the author of this article has http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Contributions&target=Zerofri only edited this article, making me wonder about . More info from anybody would be greatly appreciated, but if it doesn't turn up, I'll likely end up favoring deletion Deletion of Temple of Spooky Electric WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
10584 19365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of our village malcha User:Peterkingiron 19:22, 16 March 2014 (UTC) delete """or userify as Malcha (New Dehli). This seems to be a soapbox for a community that thinks it was unjustly deproved of its ancestral land. However, the article provides no context. It is written in the first person plural (our), but does not make clear who """"we"""" are. No adequate sourcing (so that it appears to be ). Too many problems for an uninvolved editors easily to solve""" Deletion of History of our village malcha WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10585 3269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Cooley User:KevinJardine 01:14, 11 November 2018 (UTC) keep The sourcing appears solid enough to satisfy . I found the arguments of Deletion of Adam Cooley WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10586 5847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Birlik, Kazakhstan User:Mandsford 00:50, 21 May 2010 (UTC) keep Dr. Blofeld has done an excellent job of adding sourced content to the article, so I hope this will close soon as a Deletion of Birlik, Kazakhstan WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
10587 9339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Essay:Israel vs genocide User:Umbralcorax 19:25, 5 February 2009 (UTC) delete I see its up for speedy deletion. If that, for some reason is denied, I still want to make sure my vote's heard so this garbage can be |snowballed out of here Deletion of Essay:Israel vs genocide WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
10588 7478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NewtonX, Inc. (2nd nomination) User:scope_creep 12:10, 12 October 2019 (UTC) comment Knox490 we only the discuss the references here. Nothing else. Your comments smack of and . I've checked every one of the references. I'll check that one again Deletion of NewtonX, Inc. (2nd nomination) WP:MERCY||WP:TRIVIAL Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10589 13198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fire sand bucket User:Yomangani 13:34, 8 September 2006 (UTC) keep it currently violates and and interestingly Uncle G's link is the only verification I can find of its existence even though they are commonplace (just proves Google isn't all encompassing). I've alerted the author, so hopefully they will provide some sources Deletion of Fire sand bucket WP:OR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
10590 1598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krishan Lal Chugh User:Northamerica1000 06:56, 2 July 2016 (UTC) comment The article is tagged for speedy deletion per , and in its present state it will likely be deleted per this. However, the subject actually meets (see some source examples below). As such, no prejudice against recreation of a neutral article based upon what reliable sources report about the subject Deletion of Krishan Lal Chugh WP:G11||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
10591 19790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Most Viewed On YouTube User:Barek 14:51, 26 September 2008 (UTC) delete Arbitrary list with no unifying |justification for selecting the particular artists presented. Also agree with prior comments of and issue and maintainability Deletion of Most Viewed On YouTube WP:NOTDIRECTORY||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10592 16430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glee: The Music, Volume 4 - Road To Inter-nations User:Tarheel95 02:11, 9 May 2010 (UTC) delete per |that policy about fortune telling Deletion of Glee: The Music, Volume 4 - Road To Inter-nations WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10593 20933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PacMania User:TheAwesomeHwyh 23:29, 5 April 2020 (UTC) delete not a otability|notable game Deletion of PacMania WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10594 6354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Magic: The Gathering artists User:Armbrust 07:06, 18 June 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of Magic: The Gathering artists WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10595 8756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arvind Patel User:The9Man 11:06, 13 February 2020 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet the notability criteria. Doesn't satisfy . Almost no coverage, just a single article mentions his name inside Deletion of Arvind Patel WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10596 11861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Kershaw User:Xxanthippe 23:08, 14 August 2011 (UTC) keep """On searching GS for """"David Kershaw law"""" I found an h-index of 5, which is not enough for rof#C1. A better search might improve this. Just publishing a book is not enough""" Deletion of David Kershaw WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
10597 9553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Hurley User:Gnangarra 07:05, 28 November 2008 (UTC) delete salting the page. considering the redirect looking at article traffic statshttp://stats.grok.se/en/200811/Chris_Hurley this month so far 260 odd times with a 20%(51 hits) of the traffic in the one day since the commencement of this discussion, other months have between 110http://stats.grok.se/en/200807/Chris_Hurley-280http://stats.grok.se/en/200810/Chris_Hurley hits per month with those figures I dont see a need for the redirect given that it raises concerns as Hurley was found ''not guilty'' in relation to the 2004 Palm Island death in custody, though maybe a redirect to Queensland Police as he is/was QLD police officer Deletion of Chris Hurley WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10598 8768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexandria Potomac Little League (second nom) User:Nuttah68 13:36, 28 February 2007 (UTC) delete as no claim to notability or as a re-post if applicable. Either way, fails Deletion of Alexandria Potomac Little League (second nom) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10599 19445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Parker (Mormon) User:Firefoxman 00:21, 14 November 2007 (UTC) delete Falls within 's A1 criteria Deletion of John Parker (Mormon) WP:SPEEDY Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
10600 11283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seigo Inoue [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 17:10, 24 February 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and not otherwise notable.Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Seigo Inoue WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
10601 7952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manny Alvarez (baseball) User:Go 04:08, 2 September 2012 (UTC) delete """Not only does this article fail and , I think that since the only """"source"""" is career stats for BR that there are some issues. All of these point to a delete""" Deletion of Manny Alvarez (baseball) WP:GNG||WP:NSPORTS||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10602 14233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Norris (Interim Athletic Director) User:Resolute 01:08, 25 June 2010 (UTC) delete no assertion of notability, fails Deletion of Jim Norris (Interim Athletic Director) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10603 12556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of enemies in Doom (2nd nomination) User:Marasmusine 08:43, 24 July 2009 (UTC) delete per . Real-world context is crammed into the last two small sections, which are easily subsumed into :Doom (video game) and :Making of Doom Deletion of List of enemies in Doom (2nd nomination) WP:WAF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
10604 9154 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin """"Cool Cat"""" Chalek""" User:Walton_monarchist89 17:54, 1 April 2007 (UTC) delete unsourced, so no evidence of multiple non-trivial coverage in third-party sources to establish notability per . Delete unless sourced by the end of this AfD. (As a side point, strange that he has the same nickname as the nominator """Deletion of Kevin """"Cool Cat"""" Chalek""" WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10605 148 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Yandaş medya Kullanıcı:195.142.92.9195.142.92.9 17:31, 30 Mayıs 2016 (UTC) delete Madde açıkça ihlali. ''Yandaş medya'' deyimi kime göre, neye göre kullanılan bir tanım. Ansiklopedide yer almamalı düşüncesindeyim. Ayrıca lütfen '''VP:İÜYYKÜD|İçerik üzerine yorum yapınız, katılımcı üzerine değil!''' User:bora|Bora_User talk:bora|mesaj gönder Yandaş medyanın silinmesi Vikipedi:TBA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
10606 13985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greatest Times of All User:Smile 02:19, 10 June 2008 (UTC) delete no convincing evidence of meeting and no significant coverage in reliable secondary sources Deletion of Greatest Times of All WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10607 2960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adult FriendFinder User:Gwernol 12:44, 1 February 2008 (UTC) keep while the current article has multiple problems and a notable lack of editors willing to improve it, the subject is, for better or worse, notable. The company is real and has attracted media coverage, so a |verifiable article could be produced. I'd suggest reducing what we have to a stub and making sure that the only properly sourced material is added back Deletion of Adult FriendFinder WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10608 6419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gandhi's racism User:Arkyan 15:20, 27 March 2007 (UTC) delete due largely to this being an essay and failing . The author has done a good job of writing an essay on the topic but as we all know Wikipedia is not a place for essays, it's a tertiary source of information Deletion of Gandhi's racism WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
10609 6211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Chmykhalov User:Wingtipvortex 23:30, 2 April 2013 (UTC) keep per Cullen328 and . He is clearly notable as far as WP is concerned Deletion of Alexander Chmykhalov WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
10610 15464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/These Are The Days User:Mailer 19:14, 25 November 2006 (UTC) delete unless |sourced Deletion of These Are The Days WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10611 9327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sovprime User:Joe 22:37, 4 February 2010 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Sovprime WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
10612 21467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordis Unga User:Location 05:22, 27 August 2009 (UTC) keep AS IS, the article does not meet ; however, many independent, reliable sources do exist in GoogleNews and elsewhere (e.g.http://music.msn.com/rockers/jordis/). In determining notability, consideration given to #1, #5 #9, and #12 in as she finished fifth in the Rock Star: INXS competition and received much press while on the show Deletion of Jordis Unga WP:V||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10613 5990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spencer Carbery [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 18:32, 30 July 2014 (UTC) delete """Fails . Coverage is routine sports coverage from the local paper--""""Coach, how do things look for the new season?"""".Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231""" Deletion of Spencer Carbery WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
10614 16634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of famous tall men (2nd nomination) User:Lost 02:51, 9 September 2006 (UTC) delete I take it somebody has read Deletion of List of famous tall men (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10615 6826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Topological painting User:Narky 14:59, 28 November 2018 (UTC) delete I agree with nom's and Rosguill's analyses{{snd}} and . (Leonardo da Vinci{{snd}}really Deletion of Topological painting WP:SYNTH||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10616 6398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aparna Mishra User:Sunshine1191 03:29, 3 December 2020 (UTC) delete per nom. A few episodic roles and one recurring role in a current series, even if popular, is not enough to fulfill |NACTOR Deletion of Aparna Mishra WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10617 18223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Problems of the Day User:Universal 07:50, 28 January 2013 (UTC) comment per . The book '''does''' find significant coverage in reliable sources independent of the subject. There are plenty and entirely independent Indian newspapers and magazines that devote passages from this book as a column or entire page. Some more time is needed to find them as they are usually in Hindi, rarely in English and Bengali Deletion of Problems of the Day WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
10618 8806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Newton da Costa User:PWilkinson 20:50, 28 February 2016 (UTC) keep With an h-index of 38 according to Google Scholar, a very clear pass of #1 in a field (mathematical logic) that does not generally have high citation rates. The article itself either needs pruning or far better sourcing - it is probably generally accurate, as the topics discussed match the subject's most highly-cited papers, but while the citation rates establish the subject's notability, we still need verification for individual claims Deletion of Newton da Costa WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10619 10682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amy Warner User:Spiderone 08:41, 11 June 2016 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Amy Warner WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10620 11357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Masters of the Universe vehicles User:Niteshift36 14:55, 7 January 2010 (UTC) delete Notability and are issues Deletion of List of Masters of the Universe vehicles WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10621 20754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FASTLANE(Zootopia) User:Omni 08:46, 26 July 2016 (UTC) delete Fails . This would be A7-worthy, but unfortunately A7 doesn't apply to books. I can't seem to find any RS out there. On an unrelated note, it's cases like this where it just goes to show that we really need to make A9 apply to books Deletion of FASTLANE(Zootopia) WP:BKCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10622 16699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Auto Destruct User:Ferret 16:33, 13 October 2017 (UTC) keep I don't believe was done. Lack of content and references is not a valid deletion rationale. The article contains one reference as a source already. I've added two more reviews to the talk page, as well as a link to GameRankings which shows there were 5-6 print magazines who issued reviews for the game. As an older game, online sourcing is harder to find, but I believe is met Deletion of Auto Destruct WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
10623 11465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional salespeople User:Themfromspace 03:44, 25 March 2011 (UTC) delete too broad of a criteria for inclusion leads to sloppy and ill-defined lists, per . Just because all of the characters on the list are notable doesn't mean that their intersection as fictional salespeople is notable Deletion of List of fictional salespeople WP:SALAT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
10624 13378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Garth User:Cindamuse 11:02, 18 February 2012 (UTC) delete Notability is not established in accordance with |general or |topical notability guidelines for bands. Unsigned band with recordings consisting of self-published and unreleased material. Sourcing is limited to local press, local band/scene rags, and local public radio. Best regards Deletion of Brian Garth WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10625 6393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burden Brothers User:Armbrust 13:50, 25 June 2010 (UTC) delete as article fail (http://www.google.hu/search?hl=hu&rls=com.microsoft%3Ahu%3AIE-SearchBox&rlz=1I7GGLJ_hu&q=%22Burden+Brothers%22&btnG=Keres%C3%A9s&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai= no reliable third party sources) and Deletion of Burden Brothers WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10626 8112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Zoey 101 characters User:Folken 12:27, 17 September 2012 (UTC) merge """to Zoey 101. Though stand-alone lists of characters are permitted, nowhere are they described as automatically notable. The only actual community practices regarding list notability are described at which states that """"Notability of lists (whether titled as """"List of Xs"""" or """"Xs"""") is based on the group. A list topic is considered notable if it has been discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources"""", and obviously that is not the case for Zoey 101 characters. Moreover, states that """"Editors are cautioned not to immediately split articles if the new article would not meet the general notability criterion"""" (which is the case) and """"If a concept can be cleanly trimmed or removed, or can be merged elsewhere on the wiki, these steps should be undertaken first before some new article is created"""". Per #Summary style approach (""""just because the spinout article is given more space to grow does not mean that |excessive plot summaries or fictional character biographies are appropriate""""), the list of Zoey 101 characters, with its excessive average of 5kb of plot dump per character, can obviously be trimmed down to an acceptable size so that it can perfectly be merged back into the main article, since the topic in itself is not notable anyway""" Deletion of List of Zoey 101 characters WP:LISTN||WP:AVOIDSPLIT||WP:WAF||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10627 13480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gruagach (Hellboy) User:Zxcvbnm 15:37, 17 June 2018 (UTC) delete Pure fiction cruft, only of interest to fans and fails Deletion of Gruagach (Hellboy) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10628 934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dying Shadows User:AllyD 07:06, 5 May 2017 (UTC) delete An article on a book published via Authors Press. The given sources are primary and a basic Goodreads page, neither of which meet the |referencing requirements. My searches, including the tailored Wikiproject India search, are finding nothing better than sales sites. Fails , . (The contributing editor has also created a page on :Surendra Pratap Singh (author), whose notability looks dubious Deletion of Dying Shadows :WP:RS||:WP:NBOOK||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10629 7040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moosewood Restaurant User:Gobonobo 14:49, 22 April 2015 (UTC) keep Iconic restaurant that spurred a series of cookbooks. Easily meets with Northamerica1000's sources Deletion of Moosewood Restaurant WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10630 18812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/We Are The Ocean User:JamieS93 17:52, 3 May 2008 (UTC) delete A fairly classic non-notable-band case to me. Although they have their own website (not just a MySpace), the two reasons I see for lack of notability per is that they haven't received much third-party media coverage from notable/reliable sources, as well as not being signed to any record label. A pretty extensive Google search doesn't prove otherwise, either. After the band gets some more media coverage, I wouldn't be opposed to recreation; but at this point they're simply not notable enough for Wikipedia Deletion of We Are The Ocean WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10631 14783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adaptive A.I. User:Srose 19:49, 27 July 2006 (UTC) delete This |reads like a TV commercial and the company itself fails Deletion of Adaptive A.I. WP:SPAM||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Spam 112
10632 13013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liberal Party of Australia leadership election, 2009 User:JRA_WestyQld2 04:32, 1 December 2009 (UTC) keep as above to Liberal Party of Australia leadership spill as it is not a leadership election as such. ikiProject_Baseball|JRA_ Deletion of Liberal Party of Australia leadership election, 2009 WP:W Help:Watchlist 110
10633 19797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Gilani User:CAPTAIN 20:58, 24 February 2017 (UTC) delete Non-notable Deletion of Ben Gilani WP:FILMMAKER Wikipedia:Notability 77
10634 11131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SYS Linux User:Minimaki 12:03, 17 March 2008 (UTC) delete As above. Reading the very last paragraph in the article, I guess the author mis-understood the purpose of Wikipedia somewhat, it's specifically #DIR|not trying to be a directory on all possible Linux distributions Deletion of SYS Linux WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10635 19289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyler clementi User:Jclemens 18:15, 1 October 2010 (UTC) keep to the event per the various reasons above. lists plenty of examples of trivial news that we don't cover: this doesn't fit by any stretch of the imagination Deletion of Tyler clementi WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10636 19593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barbara Jayne Orser User:Rhododendrites 13:17, 15 September 2016 (UTC) keep """Named professorship = notability per . Her http://www.telfer.uottawa.ca/en/directory/professors/orser-barbara title is """"Deloitte Professor in the Management of Growth Enterprises"""". Unless """"Deloitte"""" has some sort of meaning like """"tenured"""" that I've not come across, that sure looks like a distinguished professorship. Given the article is not problematic/promotional enough to need , that would seem to be that, no? &mdash""" Deletion of Barbara Jayne Orser WP:NACADEMIC||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10637 6258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Bardavid User:Danny 18:02, 9 April 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Joshua Bardavid WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
10638 15122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Hunter (novelist) User:Kinu 00:32, 9 November 2012 (UTC) delete Barring the presentation of sources ''about'' the subject rather than ''by'' him (as indicated above), I see no evidence that this author meets or . No prejudice to a separate deletion discussion about the magazine itself Deletion of Tom Hunter (novelist) WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10639 138 [[Telemotive]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Tom_md 11:17, 11. Jul. 2009 (CEST) delete Firmenspam ohne #U|Relevanz. , gern auch schnell Löschung von Telemotive Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10640 5178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keser User:DMacks 13:56, 10 July 2007 (UTC) keep as meeting , though major rewrite needed...the article feels like PR, mainly because large parts of it are written as a list of bullet points aimed at satisfying the requirements Deletion of Keser WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10641 21394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Palermo Airport (disambiguation) User:Lightburst 03:29, 3 August 2020 (UTC) delete does not fulfill the purposes outlined in Deletion of Palermo Airport (disambiguation) WP:D Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
10642 433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mastering Jenkins User:onel5969 13:47, 6 November 2015 (UTC) delete nothing in search engines shows that it passes either or Deletion of Mastering Jenkins WP:GNG||WP:NBOOKS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10643 195 [[Berliner_Büchertisch]] (bleibt) Benutzer:W-alter NONE keep """Wozu gibt es eigentlich /Regel_der_QS-Seiten, wenn entgegen dieser Regel nach 4h ein Löschantrag gestellt wird? Und, Schmitty, in welcher """"jeder Stadt"""" gibt es ähnliches? @TomK32: Richtig, denn Bookcrossing hat ein völlig anderes Ziel und einen völlig anderen Hintergrund, Dein Vergleich hinkt""" Löschung von Berliner_Büchertisch Wikipedia:Qualitätssicherung Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
10644 19378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheila Bilyeu User:AllyD 06:19, 19 August 2013 (UTC) delete Highbeam turns up mentions in various articles, about various campaigns, but nothing that meets Deletion of Sheila Bilyeu :WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10645 327 [[Kinder des Judas]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Christan Bach 09:55, 10. Jun. 2010 (CEST) keep Ich bin fürs . Wenn wir #Literarische Einzelwerke wirklich so ernst nehmen sollen, wie es hier manche von euch tun, dann kann man circa ein Drittel der Artikel, die ein literarisches Werk behandeln, löschen! Es gibt weitaus schlimmere Bucharttikel wie zum Beispiel Die Insel (Richard Laymon). Ich finde, dass wenn der 1. Punkt erfüllt ist und der 2. nur Ansatzweise, dann sollte man ein Auge zu drücken können Löschung von Kinder des Judas Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10646 2850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Winner Ozelis User:B 03:11, 3 December 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Wikipedia is not a memorial, and thousands of people are medical test subjects every day (this takes care of ). My sympathies, but no Deletion of Elizabeth Winner Ozelis WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10647 8291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Analytica (trade fair) User:SailingInABathTub 19:46, 3 April 2021 (UTC) delete fails , , and Deletion of Analytica (trade fair) WP:GNG||WP:NCORP||WP:NEVENTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10648 2624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Alan Gallant User:Coredesat 07:32, 28 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Greg Alan Gallant WP:BIO||WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10649 11080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gregory Paul (singer) User:Nuttah68 09:21, 7 March 2007 (UTC) delete as failing . The article reads like spam, offers no sources so fails and on searching there are no obvious sources Deletion of Gregory Paul (singer) WP:MUSIC||WP:ATT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10650 19925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Fishel (filmmaker) User:Jujutacular 14:57, 4 November 2009 (UTC) delete I couldn't find significant coverage of him, and his awards do not seem to allow him to pass Deletion of David Fishel (filmmaker) WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10651 14220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Ireton User:Huon 21:05, 6 September 2006 (UTC) delete as non-notable and unverifiable. Obviously fails Deletion of Adam Ireton WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10652 12300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Disabled (band) User:Hobbes 03:27, 23 April 2012 (UTC) delete I had a tough time finding even trivial secondary coverage, let alone anything substantial and . Their Last.fm http://www.last.fm/music/The+Disabled page shows a total of 9 listeners, ever. Fails , fails Deletion of The Disabled (band) WP:RS||WP:NBAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10653 20444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bootstrap paradox in fiction (2nd nomination) User:I 06:59, 11 November 2011 (UTC) merge Bootstrap paradox. Is it bothersome to anyone else that Bootstrap paradox still has an tag on it? I have no problems with comprehensiveness as mentioned by DGG above, and agree that the use of this concept has occurred often. But there is a fine line between comprehensive and |indiscriminate collections of information. Because nearly all of the examples are unsourced, that Bootstrap_paradox#Definition|definition section of the main article on the bootstrap paradox is currently unsourced, and unsurprisingly, that http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Bootstrap_paradox there has also been disagreement on the inclusion criteria on talk page for Bootstrap paradox, the current article ''also'' feels too much like |original research Deletion of Bootstrap paradox in fiction (2nd nomination) WP:OR||WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10654 13679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albert Jack User:JMHamo 23:32, 11 July 2015 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Albert Jack WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10655 10645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dolores Bernadette Grier User:Qworty 08:11, 9 January 2011 (UTC) delete Fails , , and . Just a non-notable private person who happens to be against abortion. That's not enough to justify an article Deletion of Dolores Bernadette Grier WP:BK||WP:AUTHOR||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10656 10799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irish Payment Services Organisation User:Megtetg34 00:04, 26 January 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Irish Payment Services Organisation WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10657 19422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Civilization One (band) User:Deliriousandlost 22:05, 10 November 2009 (UTC) keep Meeting criterion 1 still meets . Thanks to Gongshow for finding sources. The singer has been part of other notable bands, though his BLP needs some clean-up Deletion of Civilization One (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10658 19059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergey Pavlov (mass murderer) User:Bearian 23:39, 21 September 2019 (UTC) delete a |soapbox slathered in |BLP violations Deletion of Sergey Pavlov (mass murderer) WP:SOAP||WP:BLP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10659 14364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iphone app after-life User:AntiCommons 23:49, 10 July 2011 (UTC) delete Fails to meet . Where the product is being sold is not a source and there is not significant enough coverage on the app to prove notability Deletion of Iphone app after-life WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10660 2614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angela Little (singer) User:JamesBurns 00:40, 2 January 2009 (UTC) delete insufficient notability, as per Deletion of Angela Little (singer) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10661 75 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Fox (lacrosse) User:Ben 22:17, 22 February 2013 (UTC) delete Player of Box Lacrosse and coach for amateur Lacrosse. Nothing found that could support Deletion of Chris Fox (lacrosse) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10662 452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The myths of December 25th User:Kesh 01:50, 8 November 2007 (UTC) delete as |copyright violation, as indicated at the top of the article's Talk page. The primary author claims to have an email asserting the article is usable under the GDFL but 1) its apparently in Portugese and 2) we cannot take the editor's assertion that the email is real. Beyond that, it appears to be |novel synthesis or pure |original research. No reliable sources cited Deletion of The myths of December 25th WP:COPYVIO||WP:SYN||WP:OR Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
10663 5211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shivani kapoor User:Evb 16:44, 25 August 2007 (UTC) delete """per nom. I tagged it for speedy, which was denied based on the award won. I also searched for and added one reference. None of the sources I came across was hugely reliable, and her """"accomplishments"""" are not that great, . . . yet? Fails in my book""" Deletion of Shivani kapoor WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10664 21136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emmalina (3rd nomination) User:Agent 20:55, 14 October 2006 (UTC) delete Does not meet and is no more notable than any other youtuber, blogger, or internet user Deletion of Emmalina (3rd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10665 16131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oxygenstartank User:Hetar 17:17, 4 May 2006 (UTC) delete as a failure of . Please ignore the sock puppets Deletion of Oxygenstartank WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10666 4398 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""Carl Dundas""""""" User:Mendaliv 16:47, 6 September 2008 (UTC) delete this is pretty clearly just an |autobio of a |non-notable person. Also, we know for sure that {{user|Tartansoxdundas}} ''is'' the subject, considering the OTRS confirmation on :Image:Carl Dundas.JPG. I'd say speedy, but it looks like there's an assertion in there... &mdash """Deletion of """"Carl Dundas""""""" WP:AB||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
10667 12757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NVA Holdings User:Eggishorn 06:34, 31 March 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and for the reason that the significant coverage is either not reliable or not independent and the independent coverage is not actually about them at all Deletion of NVA Holdings WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
10668 19240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shpendi Sollaku Noé User:J04n 23:16, 1 October 2011 (UTC) delete unable to find any significant coverage in |reliable sources independent of the subject of this unsourced |BLP Deletion of Shpendi Sollaku Noé WP:RS||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10669 5723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fantastic Four TV game User:GabeIglesia 22:03, 1 April 2016 (UTC) delete Fails . No sources. A little surprised that this article lasted 10 whole years Deletion of Fantastic Four TV game WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10670 6581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mishpachah Lev-Tsiyon User:Neil 12:04, 3 October 2007 (UTC) delete per the above (looks familiar! :p ) No reliable sources, not met (I've also searched for any, but no good). Similarly, notability is not asserted (again, I've looked elsewhere and can find no evidence of any Deletion of Mishpachah Lev-Tsiyon WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10671 7541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tajik people User:Crisco 07:43, 24 July 2011 (UTC) keep and invite the nom to read a few of our policies, specifically on |notability, POV|neutral point of view, and |what AFD is for. No point trouting an editor with fewer than 100 edits Deletion of Tajik people WP:N||WP:NPOV||WP:AFD Wikipedia:Notability 77
10672 13995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy Lehrer (2nd nomination) User:David 00:59, 23 November 2011 (UTC) delete for the same reason I gave in Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy Z. Lehrer: the only third-party source with any nontrivial information about the subject, the Rognes review, is highly negative, and applies. Speedy deletion G4 could be considered, but the article differs enough from the previously deleted version that I'm uncomfortable tagging it for that. And given the history of repeated recreation of this article in defiance of past AfD results, it should be protected against further recreation, as Andy Z. Lehrer already has been Deletion of Andy Lehrer (2nd nomination) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10673 11341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henry Doktorski User:TenPoundHammer 18:53, 16 March 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. This is fairly well disguised advertising, and although there are many sources, the performer seems to fail entirely Deletion of Henry Doktorski WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10674 6012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IndUS Aviation NONE NONE comment Does anyone yet have a single showing that IndUS aviation have built and shipped a single aircraft Deletion of IndUS Aviation WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10675 40 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benn Zarin McCord User:Wikicology 23:20, 20 September 2014 (UTC) delete per #G3. Article was deleted by {{u|INeverCry}} and {{u|CactusWriter}} per G3 in april and January 2013 respectively. Here is the https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special%3ALog&type=delete&user=&page=Benn+Zarin+McCord&year=&month=-1&tagfilter=&hide_patrol_log=1&hide_review_log=1&hide_thanks_log=1 deletion log Deletion of Benn Zarin McCord WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
10676 20763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skepticwiki User:Darquis 22:58, 30 April 2006 (UTC) delete Not notable, doesn't meet , doesn't meet , etc Deletion of Skepticwiki WP:WEB||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
10677 13792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eva Bella User:Atlantic306 22:43, 24 November 2019 (UTC) keep as passes criteria 1 with prominent roles in notable productions such as Shimmer and Shine tv series top billing and film roles with coverage such as omaha.com, imv Deletion of Eva Bella WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10678 15645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lawrence Gullo User:JCO312 14:28, 12 February 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Lawrence Gullo WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10679 13603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sabah Husseini Shobar User:Darth_Panda 15:07, 28 October 2008 (UTC) comment I would argue that this just barely fails but fails . However, he is linked to from List of Ayatollahs; is this person one and the same? If so, this information (that he is an Ayatollah) needs to be added to the page and he would therefore pass Deletion of Sabah Husseini Shobar WP:A7||WP:BIO||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
10680 3750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stagecoach Gold bus route S2 (2nd nomination) User:Pontificalibus 15:04, 5 February 2020 (UTC) merge to Stagecoach in Oxfordshire. There is not the significant coverage in reliable sources that would allow us to write a proper article per . It seems the Stagecoach Gold article would only ever list this route, whereas Stagecoach in Oxfordshire seems more amenable to the inclusion of additional information related to Oxford Deletion of Stagecoach Gold bus route S2 (2nd nomination) WP:WHYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10681 18927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of animal rights groups in Goa User:Ajf773 03:28, 6 October 2020 (UTC) delete Obvious violation of Deletion of List of animal rights groups in Goa WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10682 19401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Niki Belucci User:Malik 02:37, 29 July 2015 (UTC) delete Fails , , and . — Deletion of Niki Belucci WP:PORNBIO||WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10683 19901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lalov Egrek User:AllyD 11:40, 27 February 2018 (UTC) delete A longstanding unsourced article, only describing the development proposition. Searches are finding |nothing to indicate |notability Deletion of Lalov Egrek :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10684 429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josep Irla i Bosch User:Valenciano 14:25, 3 March 2012 (UTC) keep Sources readily exist and some have been added, the nominator should at least observe Deletion of Josep Irla i Bosch WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
10685 7281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Somdip Dey User:Vejvančický 11:43, 19 July 2012 (UTC) delete as an |autobiography of a not notable person Deletion of Somdip Dey WP:AUTOBIO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
10686 15514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ferdinand Belmont User:Mztourist 11:20, 7 August 2021 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Ferdinand Belmont WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10687 20070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Modern Stoicism User:Bearian 12:58, 6 January 2017 (UTC) comment It exists, and I just read a blog about it |recently somewhere online, but I'm not sure |if it is notable yet Deletion of Modern Stoicism WP:NEO||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10688 8672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leftist-Islamist Alliance User:Otolemur 14:32, 3 April 2008 (UTC) delete Per and Deletion of Leftist-Islamist Alliance WP:SOAP||WP:SYN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10689 1441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rafael Vargas-Bernal User:Nsk92 17:04, 31 August 2008 (UTC) delete Clearly fails . No evidence of significant citability of his work. Very little in GoogleScholarhttp://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=%22Rafael%20Vargas-Bernal%22&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=ps, GoogleBookshttp://books.google.com/books?tab=sp&sa=N&hl=en&q=%22Rafael+Vargas-Bernal%22&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N, nothing at all in WebofScience and nothing in MathSciNet. No significant academic awards or honors beyond the grad student level, according to the June 2008 CVhttp://octi.guanajuato.gob.mx/octigto/formularios/cicti/curricula/Curriculum%20Vitae%2017%20de%20Junio%20de%202008.pdf Deletion of Rafael Vargas-Bernal WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10690 405 [[Wenn Nicht Jetzt-Verlag]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Justus Nussbaum 19:24, 7. Jun. 2021 (CEST) delete Stimme zu, dass die #Verlage|Einschlusskriterien für Verlage nicht erfüllt sind. Könnte jemand den Text für eine Ausweichlokation à la Vereinswiki anmelden? Muss man hier wohl erstmal Löschung von Wenn Nicht Jetzt-Verlag Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10691 5390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ziwo yixiang User:Nsk92 12:25, 21 September 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and . Google turns up nothing relevant (certainly nothing that would pass ) except for a few wikipedia mirrors and clones. The article is 4 years old and still no improvements and no references found Deletion of Ziwo yixiang WP:V||WP:OR||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10692 243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annette Groves User:A 19:53, 4 August 2010 (UTC) comment for Freshacconci -- when you get the chance, please check out the 2 external links I provided above as well as the material in section 3 of . Thanks Deletion of Annette Groves WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10693 7876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Macbeth (2009 film) User:Lugnuts 18:24, 4 June 2015 (UTC) delete Film was never released and fails Deletion of Macbeth (2009 film) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10694 21351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raphael Samuel User:Daniel5127 00:23, 29 August 2006 (UTC) keep This person is notable. So, It stands otability, and he was book publisher Deletion of Raphael Samuel WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10695 5856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Forward User:Newshunter12 17:53, 19 September 2020 (UTC) delete Fails due to a complete lack of in independent reliable sources. Just a producer Deletion of Steve Forward WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:RUNOFTHEMILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10696 9777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Claire Dames User:Red 01:15, 6 May 2013 (UTC) delete This one's honestly a tough call and probably in the gray area a little bit, but I don't think she quite fits the notability guidelines. Not enough notability to meet as established earlier, and it's nice to have a stub article referenced with more than two references, but there's not enough of a body here to make use of them. Most likely, I'd say that's because there's not enough notability to have any available |verifiable information to put in the body of the article Deletion of Claire Dames WP:PORNBIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
10697 18741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SDMT Prabhavati Public School User:KGirlTrucker81 20:27, 21 January 2017 (UTC) keep per : Even there's only primary sources, that warrants an own article about the school. So, it's not a valid reason for deletion Deletion of SDMT Prabhavati Public School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
10698 6314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Jarvis (2nd nomination) User:Zingarese 01:16, 7 July 2018 (UTC) keep The conductor plays the largest role in the ensemble. Jarvis has, as conductor, made numerous recordings for such notable labels as Koch and CRI; as such, he passes . His reviews in NY Times and numerous pieces composed for him adds to his notability Deletion of Peter Jarvis (2nd nomination) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10699 8933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Connection economy [[User talk:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) '''''' (talk) ''']] 04:31, 5 July 2006 (UTC) delete as a proto/neologism created by the author, refers Deletion of Connection economy WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10700 7948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DJ Kidd User:R45 07:16, 8 August 2009 (UTC) delete Not notable, fails . I am from Trinidad and I'm pretty sure I've never heard of him. I consider myself very knowledgeable in the Trinidad Music/Carnival Scene; this guy is not notable in those arenas. The article itself has nothing encyclopedic (which doesn't matter for an Afd but just saying). For example information about his SEA (Secondary Entrance Assessment Examination) results do not belong on Wikipedia; that exam is the equivalent of the SATs in the US at the middle school level. All the content is a stretch to bypass a speedy delete. The article doesn't even have real notability claims that warrant much further investigation. I'm a inclusionist but this really is a simple delete Deletion of DJ Kidd WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10701 19785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Ridgway (scholar) User:Nuujinn 18:39, 31 October 2010 (UTC) comment I'm sure he's a fine fellow, but which of these match criteria at ? The bar for notability of academics is pretty high, simply being published isn't enough, neither is work as a professor. The festscritft is a possibility I suppose, although my experience with them is that they are generally a kind of vanity publication, an honorific from close associates and friends Deletion of David Ridgway (scholar) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10702 21325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KGUBrass User:1292simon 02:58, 6 September 2020 (UTC) delete notability not established, Deletion of KGUBrass WP:NOTPROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10703 7832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Streets and squares of Romney, West Virginia User:TenPoundHammer 02:00, 22 May 2007 (UTC) delete not even worth merging. City isn't that big to begin with; and furthermore, #DIR|Wikipedia is not a directory of streets Deletion of Streets and squares of Romney, West Virginia WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10704 2087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alodia Almira Gosiengfiao (2nd nomination) User:TheFarix 02:36, 22 June 2007 (UTC) delete I was not exactly sure how to comment on this, but I will have to go with . Not much of the information is verifiable through reliable third-party sources. Instead, the bulk of it cites a primary source, her deviantART account. This gives the article a vanity feeling. Also the only third-party source for the entire article is a blog entry for the Maxim offer. Blogs are generally not considered |reliable sources Deletion of Alodia Almira Gosiengfiao (2nd nomination) WP:BLP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10705 3503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toyota's Best Doggone Zags Show User:AnmaFinotera 23:34, 21 May 2010 (UTC) delete Unnotable speciality show and apparently promotional piece. Fails with no significant coverage of this show Deletion of Toyota's Best Doggone Zags Show WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10706 19974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Turtle Rock Elementary School User:Cumulus 18:25, 22 January 2008 (UTC) keep We don't delete articles because they're vandalism targets. This article is as notable as any other stub-class elementary school article and it should be placed at |Wikiproject:Schools with a request for help before its put up for AfD. This one already has the proper templates and would just be more work for someone else if it was hastily deleted Deletion of Turtle Rock Elementary School WP:SCH Wikipedia:Notability 77
10707 15750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nissae Isen User:OlenWhitaker 03:05, 10 March 2008 (UTC) delete per . Neither the article nor a Google search provide any evidence of notability. There are a number of ghits but only to state that she has done voice work for this or that production. I could locate no sources that meet criteria Deletion of Nissae Isen WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10708 590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wako-Pro World Grand Prix 2011: Hungary vs Croatia (2nd nomination) User:Papaursa 23:17, 23 March 2012 (UTC) delete I'm not sure is the right reference, but is. Also, the kickboxing notability guidelines indicate that an event should be on the scale of the K-1 individual world championships to be truly notable, while this event is very minor. It was to be part of an 8 nation tournament, but they couldn't get enough countries interested, so they cancelled the tournament and held some individual matches Deletion of Wako-Pro World Grand Prix 2011: Hungary vs Croatia (2nd nomination) WP:MMAEVENT||WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10709 21912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kristina Webb User:Possibly 18:16, 28 January 2021 (UTC) delete the lack of makes this a clear GNG fail Deletion of Kristina Webb WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10710 12821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Holiday Cheer Daisy User:Rorshacma 19:51, 16 October 2020 (UTC) delete There is absolutely nothing that should be merged, as not only is it entirely unsourced, but most of the information here seems to either be or plain . And I agree with ApLundell above that this is not even worth a Redirect Deletion of Holiday Cheer Daisy WP:OR||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:No original research 65
10711 6041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Akburç User:Fenix 11:39, 16 August 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Ali Akburç WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10712 9926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lana Rhoades User:Morbidthoughts 19:11, 23 July 2017 (UTC) keep Passes with her XBIZ Award|XBIZ Best New Starlet Award, with the award being notablewell-known and the category significant. There is enough non-contentious biographical information to support the article beyond being a stub Deletion of Lana Rhoades WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10713 21449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Works Tour User:Esradekan 00:56, 7 April 2009 (UTC) delete a non-notable tour that fails to satisfy the |general notability guideline with significant coverage in |reliable, third-party, sources. Just an |indiscriminate collection of |fancruft Deletion of The Works Tour WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10714 377 [[Julia Seeliger]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Roroma NONE keep Der Artikel entstand in seiner jetzigen Form im Rahmen eines /3._Dezember_2006#Julia_Seeliger_(erledigt)|Qualitäts-Sicherungs-Prozesses an dem Artikel. Dort war niemand der Meinung, dass die Relevanz für den Artikel fehlt – im Gegenteil wurde während des Prozesses der Artikel kräftig ausgebaut. Was den Parteirat der Grünen angeht: Formal ist dies ein beratendes Gremium, tatsächlich aber das entscheidende Machtzentrum der Partei. Dies zeigt auch die Liste der Personen, die darin vertreten sind. Auch in den Medien wird der Parteirat immer wieder entsprechend eingeordnet. Die Süddeutsche Zeitung vom 24. Januar 2007 schrieb etwa auf Seite 9: „engster Führungszirkel einer Partei“. In derr Berliner Zeitung vom 13. Dezember 2006 hieß es: „oberster Führungszirkel der Grünen“. Laut Frankfurter Allgemeine vom 30. November 2006 ist der Parteirat sogar wichtiger als der Bundesvorstand: „Von politisch größerem Gewicht ist der Parteirat. Dieses Gremium ist vor vier Jahren geschaffen worden, um Landespolitiker besser förmlich in die politische Parteiarbeit einzubeziehen, überhaupt um die laufende Willensbildung zwischen den Parteitagen zu formalisieren“. Die Welt vom 10. Januar 2006 bringt es auf die knappe Formel: „Grünen-Führungszirkel“. In der Wikipedia darf es bei der Bedeutung der Relevanz nicht nur um die formale Relevanz gehen, die sich aus der Satzung einer Partei ergibt, es muss auch die tatsächliche Relevanz eine Rolle spielen. Und weil der Parteirat der Grünen tatsächlich ein entscheidendes Gremium ist, sind auch deren Mitglieder relevant im Sinne der WP-Relevanzkriterien. Also Löschung von Julia Seeliger Wikipedia:Qualitätssicherung Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
10715 1549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Airbrite User:HighKing 15:38, 20 August 2018 (UTC) comment No. |Notability isn't inherited applies Deletion of Airbrite WP:NOTINHERIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10716 5094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Normal ECG User:Drchriswilliams 19:15, 29 December 2016 (UTC) merge """to :Electrocardiography as :ecg already does. As HyperGaruda observes, within this two-sentence article there isn’t particularly anything of any value to merge- even the image used on this page is from a signal generator (and there is nothing """"normal"""" about that). I can see there are currently seven separate articles on the different waveforms that appear on ecgs. Interpretation of the ecg to exclude any abnormalities isn't straightforward by any means, but I suppose redirects are |cheap""" Deletion of Normal ECG :WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
10717 15478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fender Roscoe Beck Bass User:Rms125a 19:58, 3 June 2016 (UTC) delete as fairly blatant, IMO, business |promo Deletion of Fender Roscoe Beck Bass WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10718 190 [[GFC AntriebsSysteme]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Tom_md NONE keep da historisch #U mitz der Mitarbeiterzahl erfüllt Löschung von GFC AntriebsSysteme Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10719 21443 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of North American """"Occupy"""" protests""" User:Snottywong 18:29, 8 November 2011 (UTC) delete Unnecessarily duplicative. deals with lists and categories overlapping, not with lists that are copied and pasted from a section in another list """Deletion of List of North American """"Occupy"""" protests""" WP:NOTDUP Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
10720 13536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dilbagh singh User:GSS 11:26, 11 March 2017 (UTC) comment I have extended the article a little bit and included some sources but I'm unsure if it passes Deletion of Dilbagh singh WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10721 15609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alicia Bamboo Ensemble User:SBKSPP 00:46, 10 July 2021 (UTC) delete Fails per nom Deletion of Alicia Bamboo Ensemble WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10722 8720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acid Dreams- The Original User:Gongshow 18:47, 2 December 2009 (UTC) keep """The album appears to have been re-released in 2009, which earned it coverage http://allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sql=10:k9fyxz90ld0e here and http://www.terrascope.co.uk/Reviews/Reviews_April09.htm#AcidDreams here, which I believe, in addition to the http://www.popmatters.com/pm/review/72325-various-artists-acid-dreams/ PopMatters review already provided in the article, is enough to satisfy . I also suggest removing """"The Original"""" from the title and renaming it simply Acid Dreams""" Deletion of Acid Dreams- The Original WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10723 8559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Infrasound gun User:Ice 02:13, 21 March 2008 (UTC) delete After a quick search, I was unable to find any sources. The two papers referenced in the article do not appear to be about the gun. Therefore, the subject is not |notable Deletion of Infrasound gun WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10724 11658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brad Swancott User:Devonian 02:21, 20 April 2021 (UTC) keep passes , Newcastle, New South Wales is a populous enough area for its local media to be reliable Deletion of Brad Swancott WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10725 1145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Softwareload User:Superastig 12:09, 16 July 2020 (UTC) keep It has received some coverage, though most of them are in German. With sources indicated above, the article is good enough to pass Deletion of Softwareload WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10726 168 [[Literatur Quickie]] (Bleibt) Benutzer:Magiers NONE keep Ich verstehe nicht, was gegen Relevanz sprechen soll: #Verlage: „Als relevant gelten Verlage die in ihrem Belletristik- oder Sachbuchprogramm urheberrechtlich geschützte Werke von mindestens drei bekannten oder historisch bedeutenden Autoren verlegt haben“ ist ja wohl mehr als deutlich übertroffen. Dazu noch die erhebliche Wahrnehmung in der Presse, die http://de.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Literatur_Quickie&diff=84669800&oldid=84665428 hier vom Autor selbst wieder aus dem Artikel gelöscht wurde. Ich würde übrigens durchaus empfehlen, einige der umfangreicheren Artikel mit weiterführenden Infos unter Weblinks einzustellen. Nur Links, die nichts direkt mit dem Artikelthema zu tun haben, gehören da nicht hin und habe ich deshalb rausgenommen. und falls noch zu werbend in die WP:QS. Gruß Löschung von Literatur Quickie Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10727 12058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faithless daughters User:StuartDouglas 15:01, 26 March 2007 (UTC) keep Borderline |OR is a danger for all of the literary motif articles since they rely on opinion rather than fact, but there's enough evidence provided in this one to satisfy me that it is a legitimate motif Deletion of Faithless daughters WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10728 11197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Final Story User:Schuym1 16:04, 4 September 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Final Story WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10729 12963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VINAS Businesses User:AllyD 06:08, 14 June 2021 (UTC) delete The article makes no claim to encyclopaedic notability, merely listing the location and registration of the firm, along with a list of the companies and websites which have commissioned services from them. Searches find no |evidence of attained |notability Deletion of VINAS Businesses :WP:RS||:WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10730 1159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KUMM User:Dravecky 00:53, 25 February 2012 (UTC) comment """The """"FCC License"""" comes into play from the top of the section. """"{{xt|Notability may be presumed for a radio and television broadcast station if it verifiably meets through reliable sources, one or more of a variety of factors, such as importance to and history in the station's market, as well as the uniqueness of the programming.}}"""" That """"reliable source"""" would be the Federal Communications Commission or FCC (a US Government entity) and the """"FCC License"""". The other """"factors"""" are also covered, since the programming is unique (ie: not from a satellite network like K-LOVE) and it has importance to the community (in this case the University of Minnesota-Morris community). Those are the main standards for creating a radio station page. Now, granted, I would like to see more of a history to the page and I can find a resident radio research""" Deletion of KUMM WP:BROADCAST Wikipedia:Notability 77
10731 12916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abraham Katzir User:Oceangreenn 19:19, 31 August 2012 (UTC) comment In my view being a professor by itself does not satisfy . I added six {{citation needed}} to all the chairmanships and memberships of governing boards of international scientific organizations the article attributed to the subject. In my opinion, if there are secondary reliable sources that establish these assertions, then the subject satisfies ; otherwise, I will agree with deletion Deletion of Abraham Katzir WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10732 12553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hindutva pseudoscience (2nd nomination) User:Dbachmann 12:30, 26 March 2007 (UTC) keep """now that it has been moved to Hindutva propaganda and expanded. My merge and delete vote in the Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hindutva pseudoscience|previous AfD was because of """"Hindutva pseudoscience"""" in the title and a little content that could easily fit into Hindutva. The content of the article is legit, but it has a POVish tone, which makes it look like an essay/|original research -- this needs to be fixed. I would request""" Deletion of Hindutva pseudoscience (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10733 4286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sâmbure de drac User:Gongshow 04:45, 3 September 2011 (UTC) delete doesn't appear to meet . The coverage I found, at best, looks trivial (e.g., http://www.libertatea.ro/detalii/articol/animal-x-single-nou-342684.htmlhttp://www.evz.ro/detalii/stiri/nisip-purtat-de-vant-de-la-animal-x-826372.html Deletion of Sâmbure de drac WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10734 10757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kari Lee User:Ammodramus 04:14, 28 October 2015 (UTC) delete """Google search for (""""kari lee"""" gymnast) turns up coverage in some Utah media, most of it not in great depth. I don't find any meaningful coverage outside of Utah sources. Lee's achievements to date don't appear to meet the criteria at . She might achieve notability later, but at present it's """ Deletion of Kari Lee WP:NGYMNAST||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
10735 21123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abhidnya Bhave User:Dflaw4 05:57, 27 March 2020 (UTC) keep In my opinion, there are at least two adequate ''Times of India'' sources contained in the article, which go towards , and the subject has probably done enough work to make a case for , too Deletion of Abhidnya Bhave WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10736 18554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of women with very long hair User:Ohconfucius 07:31, 18 December 2006 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not |an indiscriminate collection of information. It may even be |original research. Hair length is unlike physical anatomical height, and may vary if the subject decides to have it cut. Who's going to police the claim and remove those who have had it cut Deletion of List of women with very long hair WP:NOT||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10737 9406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Thomas Dunn NONE NONE comment """As I has posted earlier, I gave several examples that all above articles meet the Wikipedia notability articles. I also politely request that you re-read the Wiki notibility guidelines , specifically the section that states, """"People who satisfy at least one of the items below generally merit their own Wikipedia articles, as there is likely to be a good deal of verifiable information available about them and a good deal of public interest in them. '''This is not intended to be an exclusionary list; just because someone doesn't fall into one of these categories doesn't mean an article on the person should automatically be deleted""" Deletion of Michael Thomas Dunn WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10738 19092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shuǐ diào gē tóu User:Madalibi 04:15, 15 August 2011 (UTC) keep """but rename. Arsonal's Google Books search shows that |notability can be established. One problem is that the article as it reads now claims to be about a tune, but ends up being a presentation of Su Dongpo's poem, which is known after the tune's name. (Incidentally, someone needs to find the source of this translation. For all we know, it might be under copyright.) I propose we rename this wiki either """"Shui diao ge tou"""" (without the pinyin marks, as per Wikipedia:Naming_conventions_(Chinese)#Characters which should only appear in glossaries or language textbooks) or """"Song of the Water,"""" which seems to be a common translation in |reliable sources""" Deletion of Shuǐ diào gē tóu WP:RS||WP:notability Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10739 8311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ICM Stellar Sports User:Joseph2302 08:18, 20 May 2021 (UTC) merge to Jonathan Barnett (sports agent) as an Deletion of ICM Stellar Sports WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
10740 19354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucid dreaming in popular culture User:Spazure 09:18, 15 July 2007 (UTC) delete If they're going to admit in the intro that it's a list and that's all it'll ever be, then I'm going to admit that it violates |indiscriminate |trivia and should go away Deletion of Lucid dreaming in popular culture WP:NOT||WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10741 18282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AVI Sound International User:Joe 17:22, 28 November 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |company Deletion of AVI Sound International WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10742 10515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The linear User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable. &mdash Deletion of The linear WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10743 16526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sherpa Capital User:SwisterTwister 22:53, 30 November 2016 (UTC) comment """An article that is overspecific with such PR materials such as its """"portfolio"""", """"key people"""" and """"services"""" is advertising and is nothing else but that; simply because |Other Articles Exist is not an explanation why we should accept this one, especially since the sources themselves are still in fact PR. There's no use in redirecting its founder to this article since he's not best known as anything else and both were clearly started as an advertising campaign, regardless of """"potential notability""" Deletion of Sherpa Capital WP:OSE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10744 17242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sin Boards User:Fan 17:34, 20 September 2006 (UTC) delete per . My alma mater has forums, too. They're not listed here. How many thousands of universities are there? Every one has a forum nowadays Deletion of Sin Boards WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10745 3097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A.J. Coyle User:Kinu 05:49, 15 December 2006 (UTC) delete violates . The store's site cannot be considered a third-party source per Deletion of A.J. Coyle WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10746 139 [[Belz (chassidische Bewegung)]] (bleibt nach Überarbeitung und Verschiebung) Benutzer:Inschanör NONE delete Nach Rückumbennung und somit Einschränkung auf 4 verstorbene und einem lebenden Rabbiener wg. #Religiöse Gruppen da Nachweis 200000 Anhänger fehlt und falsche Lemma. Oder behalten wenn Korrektur Lemma und Beibehaltung in Artikel als Gruppe Löschung von Belz (chassidische Bewegung) Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
10747 5330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Taylor (basketball) User:Dirtlawyer1 02:41, 28 November 2012 (UTC) keep """Having reviewed the sources available regarding the subject to date, I am satisfied that he and/or his record satisfy the general notability guidelines per . I was less convinced that the subject was not a """"one-hit"""" wonder, subject to the """"one event"""" exception per . However, please note the following quoted language from : """"some subject specific notability guidelines such as Wikipedia:Notability (sports) provide criteria that may support the notability of certain individuals who are known chiefly for one event."""" This exception to the """"one event"""" exception seems to cover exactly this sort of notable sports event. I might also add that I explored whether Wikipedia has an appropriate """"list of"""" article that includes American college basketball record-holders; we do not. So, congratulations, Mr. Jack Taylor, I think you get to have your very own Wikipedia article""" Deletion of Jack Taylor (basketball) WP:GNG||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
10748 7029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess Leonore, Duchess of Gotland (2nd nomination) User:TompaDompa 22:31, 28 March 2021 (UTC) delete WP:LOWPROFILE child for whom privacy is a serious concern, where the illusion of otability is purely due to familial ties (but notability is OTINHERITED). See : {{tq|That person ''A'' has a relationship with well-known person ''B'', such as being a spouse or child, is not a reason for a standalone article on ''A'' (unless significant coverage can be found on ''A''); wikipedia:NOTINHERITED|relationships do not confer notability. However, person ''A'' may be included in the related article on ''B''. For example, Jason Allen Alexander is included in the article on Britney Spears and the page Jason Allen Alexander merely wikipedia:R|redirects to that article Deletion of Princess Leonore, Duchess of Gotland (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:INVALIDBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10749 10657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arnolds (2nd nomination) User:HighKing 13:07, 5 July 2021 (UTC) delete I am unable to locate any deep or significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, references to date fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic therefore fails Deletion of Arnolds (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10750 4505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicholas Lawson User:Lightdarkness 02:14, 14 April 2006 (UTC) delete CSD A7, fails and meets speedy criteria, tagged as such Deletion of Nicholas Lawson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10751 4837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernadette Ní Ghallchóir User:FOARP 08:57, 30 October 2019 (UTC) keep """per , at least two instances of in more than one reliable source are needed. The first is https://www.independent.ie/entertainment/the-diary-red-rocks-new-writer-brendan-courtneys-new-web-show-bts-weddings-and-the-leinster-stars-new-pub-30544847.html this Irish Independent article which gives her three short paras and highlights the reasons for her notability (introduced the Irish language to many people in Ireland, hosted Eurovision) - nb. this is not a case of """"inherited"""" notability because that would be editors saying, without supporting sources, that she was notable for hosting Eurovision, rather than having a reliable source state that this is the case. From that article, I see she now goes under the name Bernadette Ó hUiginn, and searching for that name I see she is also covered in this https://www.irishtimes.com/news/irish-on-parade-and-on-show-1.162848 Irish Times article. http://www.nival.ie/collections/artists-database/view/artist/name/ni-galchoir-bernadette/ I also see from the Nival database that she has had a number of exhibitions for her artwork including at Dún Aimhirgin which is a https://www.independent.ie/regionals/braypeople/news/artists-to-present-show-at-dept-of-arts-and-culture-27601174.html """"prestigious state-run gallery"""" in Ireland. Additionally there's https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=-HgkAQAAIAAJ&pg=PA11636&dq=Bernadette+hUiginn&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi-4IuC0MPlAhXGEcAKHZgYB3UQ6AEIPzAD#v=onepage&q=Bernadette%20hUiginn&f=false this coverage in the US Congressional records (EDIT: this appears to have been a story published in the Washington Post which https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1999/02/11/the-art-of-understanding/6dd336e5-06d8-4732-bf85-b4fde60e9cf8/ can be read here). As with a lot of Irish gaelic names, searching in this case is complicated by the large number of variants of each name so there's probably more out there, but even with what's been found thus far seems like a pass for and also (particularly 4(b""" Deletion of Bernadette Ní Ghallchóir WP:BASIC||WP:SIGCOV||WP:BASIC||WP:NARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
10752 1098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert T. Tobin User:MER 12:10, 28 January 2018 (UTC) delete as a #Addressing contributors|presumptive copyright violation Deletion of Robert T. Tobin WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
10753 8436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M.S. Dhoni: The Untold Story (soundtrack) User:Redtigerxyz 12:21, 8 October 2016 (UTC) merge The length of the article does not justify Deletion of M.S. Dhoni: The Untold Story (soundtrack) WP:SUMMARYSTYLE Wikipedia:Summary style 34
10754 15858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Slammer User:Macwhiz 00:06, 27 June 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and , no signs of additional coverage out there Deletion of Mark Slammer WP:MUSICBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10755 3911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of television and radio stations in Zamboanga City User:Hmains 17:34, 12 November 2007 (UTC) keep No reason to target this Phillipines city radio and TV stations list. The :Category:Lists of radio stations and :Category:Lists of television channels shows that such lists are well established for various cities throughout the world. Argument made about 'directory' #DIR can be used against each and every list in WP, but WP accepts lists as part of WP so deletion argument has no merit Deletion of List of television and radio stations in Zamboanga City WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10756 13442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BTG (software) User:Spaceman7Spiff 07:14, 12 June 2009 (UTC) delete couldn't find any |RS, and the website isn't exactly RS or independent Deletion of BTG (software) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10757 3211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heidi Sorenson User:Carrite 14:25, 4 May 2011 (UTC) keep """The use of automated tools for mass deletions should not be allowed against large blocks of articles which have already been patrolled at New Pages. It is, simply put, a violation of — due diligence is not being done when these tools are being used in this way. """"Shoot them all and let the saps at AfD sort them out,"""" is apparently the line of thinking. While I am personally sympathetic to the idea of a very high bar for so-called """"Porn Bios,"""" this blasting of 100 articles at the rate of 1 per minute, judging from the time logs, is not conducive to the spirit or practice of AfD. It is putting DON'T LIKE IT ahead of the established article deletion process and is disrespectful both to the work of article creators and those of us who volunteer our time at AfD. We have seen similar automated mass annihilation efforts recently against modern Trotskyist political organizations and against fraternities and sororities. The net result of these efforts was a lot of lost time by article creators and AfD participants and a lot of lost information from those articles annihilated as part of these campaigns. Meanwhile, the backlog of crap at New Pages festers. Something needs to be done about this problem. Mine is not a unique view — see Wikipedia:ANI#Massive_number_of_Playboy-related_AFD_nominations_by_a_single_user at ANI. We need to keep them all as a matter of principle and ban the future use of automated tools in this way. ''This argument will be copied-and-pasted in the debate sections for all automated AfDs of this campaign""" Deletion of Heidi Sorenson WP:BEFORE||WP:I Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
10758 20800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nepalese American User:SkierRMH 08:27, 13 November 2006 (UTC) delete per nom; and for entire group of dash-Americans Deletion of Nepalese American WP:CITE||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10759 1946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Håkon Winther User:Jogurney 04:09, 10 August 2008 (UTC) delete it appears that author/subject of the article has never played in a fully professional league (until sources are provided to demonstrate otherwise) and I doubt that his founding of the playerhistory.com website is sufficient to pass . Perhaps there are reliable sources that demonstrate notability related to the website activities, but none are provided Deletion of Håkon Winther WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10760 8046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KNS Records User:Erechtheus 21:51, 25 September 2006 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of KNS Records WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10761 11455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St Peter's RC Primary School User:Dahliarose 19:57, 13 May 2012 (UTC) keep This is a useful encyclopaedic article on a historic school. It satisifies the core Wikipedia policies and . is just one small part of which is a guideline not a policy. It is any case impossible to judge what sources will be available to satisfy this guideline as many of the sources will be in books or in local history journals which are not available on the internet. Given that the school has been in existence for nearly two hundred years, it is inconceivable that further sources will not be available to expand the article. The difficulty will be that the school will probably have undergone several name changes. Primary schools did not exist when the school was first founded Deletion of St Peter's RC Primary School WP:V||WP:NOR||WP:GNG||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10762 19943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Home-Based Bookstore User:Jwestbrook 23:57, 31 December 2005 (UTC) delete good old fashioned |vanispamcruftisement Deletion of The Home-Based Bookstore WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
10763 13354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gunay Aliyeva User:Missvain 17:03, 21 May 2021 (UTC) delete American chiming in here. {{smiley|wink}} I believe she fails English Wikipedia's and if you want to go there regarding her medical career. While yes, she appears on a TV show, that doesn't inherently mean you're notable or meet our inclusion guidelines. One source in the article is an interview, the closest thing to an reliable secondary source. The others are passing mentions or photographs from events she's hosted. Perhaps there are more non-English sources, but, I struggled to find any online Deletion of Gunay Aliyeva WP:GNG||WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10764 15990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Easy Metropolitan Community Church User:MelanieN 22:42, 6 October 2012 (UTC) delete or '''Merge/redirect''' to UpStairs Lounge arson attack. The point here isn't how many members the church has, or whether it has a building. The point is whether it has received |significant coverage from multiple reliable sources. Based on the sources in the article, I would have to say that this church has not. Most of the sources provided are from special interest publications such as The Advocate and Ambush Magazine. The mainstream sources provided are either dead links or else are about something else (e.g. Hurricane Katrina). BTW I was living in New Orleans at the time of the fire and it was reported entirely as an attack on a bar or lounge; I can't remember any of the coverage ever mentioning a church Deletion of Big Easy Metropolitan Community Church WP:42 Wikipedia:The answer to life, the universe, and everything 7
10765 8898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Worldwide energy supply (2nd nomination) User:Mark 02:00, 13 November 2016 (UTC) keep The article sources and a style search shows multiple in depth reliable sources for this topic, e.g, http://www.americanscientist.org/libraries/documents/20110411120400vqiscvo4gy/2011411121708479-2011-05Smil.pdf, https://books.google.com/books?id=MZ3DklIQuT0C&pg=PA408&dq=Global+%22energy+supply%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjnue6S0aTQAhVhxVQKHXA0BvgQ6AEIPjAF#v=onepage&q=%22energy%20supply%22&f=false. This topic seems solidly notable and just the sort of topic we should cover in an encyclopedia.Although it is clear that there is some sort of long-running editorial dispute, we don't delete articles because of contented sources; rather we build consensus and delete any original research. A notable topic with no insurmountable article problems suggests keeping the article Deletion of Worldwide energy supply (2nd nomination) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
10766 6889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Bastyr User:K 03:15, 20 October 2016 (UTC) delete redirect to Bastyr University; a article at this point Deletion of John Bastyr WP:MEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10767 1222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Ju Ae User:Green 14:34, 11 September 2013 (UTC) comment This AfD really should be procedurally closed since it's a clear of Kim Ju-ae, it's the same article. We can't vote merge or delete for this article since the article already exists elsewhere which is not under AfD. This AfD should have never happened, I don't think the nom realized there was a fork condition Deletion of Kim Ju Ae WP:FORK Wikipedia:Mirrors and forks 46
10768 5037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Seven Worlds (2nd nomination) User:Jfdwolff 11:31, 20 October 2006 (UTC) delete """If this conceptual framework exists at all in Kabbalah (which is not quite clear to me) it is not worth its own article. Presently it is unclear why it is titled this way, it is |unsourced (just blindly citing ''Kabbalah'' as a source is like saying that """"smoking causes cancer, says ''science''""""). No merge candidate, no context available for a good merge""" Deletion of The Seven Worlds (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10769 2342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bad born User:MichaelQSchmidt 16:14, 29 April 2014 (UTC) delete I agree after a lot of digging that at the very kindest this film topic article is |TOO SOON Deletion of Bad born WP:NYF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
10770 6573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Barker User:Kinu 03:22, 11 March 2006 (UTC) delete non-notable per Deletion of Ben Barker WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10771 4619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zac Corker User:Coredesat 08:13, 19 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Zac Corker WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10772 8419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Allsop User:Mattythewhite 16:33, 17 August 2010 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Ryan Allsop WP:ATHLETE||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10773 21763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Bigger Picture Malta User:KCVelaga 16:36, 18 August 2018 (UTC) delete The article appears to be business listing, and is promotional in tone, per . As mentioned above, fails GNG and NCORP. I was able to get a few links from Google search, but they seem to be user-generated business listings or blog-type of pages, so there isn't anything to that can help us to improve this article and establish notability Deletion of The Bigger Picture Malta WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10774 19533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/High School Republicans of Texas User:Odie5533 16:32, 3 December 2012 (UTC) delete Does not meet Deletion of High School Republicans of Texas WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10775 21124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Damage (The Culture) User:Amorymeltzer 03:29, 10 June 2009 (UTC) delete per . It doesn't even seem to be notable within the book, not to mention an encyclopedia. ~ Amory Deletion of Damage (The Culture) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10776 17410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paddywhackery User:Bejnar 01:30, 5 October 2015 (UTC) delete as non-encyclopaedic. . It may be a less than subtle promotion of the television program Deletion of Paddywhackery WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10777 1315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Turning points during World War II User:Bungle 19:55, 18 July 2021 (UTC) delete on the basis of my view above and the admission by Loafiewa that this is |opinion driven Deletion of Turning points during World War II WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10778 5618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shon Harris User:DoriSmith 01:38, 20 January 2010 (UTC) delete """if—and only if—the subject has requested deletion. I believe that this falls under eletion policy#Deletion discussion, which says, """"Discussions concerning biographical articles of relatively unknown, non-public figures, where the subject has requested deletion and there is no rough consensus may be closed as delete."""" I think that she'd be borderline notable (meets due to her http://orlabs.oclc.org/identities/lccn-n2002-152994 books being held in 1272 libraries) but it would be difficult to find sufficient sources ''about'' her to write a solid article""" Deletion of Shon Harris WP:D||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
10779 3520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Basalaj User:Sir 14:43, 22 February 2014 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Scott Basalaj WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10780 20541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brad Sugars User:Pedro 19:27, 14 June 2009 (UTC) delete I have in fact heard of this guy as it goes, but I've also heard about a tree in the woods next to my house. |notability is dubious at best Deletion of Brad Sugars WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10781 20141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bisley (solitaire) User:Thincat 09:07, 28 February 2017 (UTC) keep """I have never heard of it but it's in my ancient ''Scarne's Encyclopedia of Games'' and, as Unscintillating has discovered, on many web sites. is a guideline for which there are """"occasional exceptions"""", not a set of rules, but in this case applying the criteria leads me to think we should presume an article to be merited. Having an article looks just fine to me""" Deletion of Bisley (solitaire) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10782 9814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Last Star User:Bongwarrior 05:44, 13 September 2007 (UTC) keep The band Halfcocked has had an article on here for years, which probably means they are notable, which probably means their ''albums'' are notable, according to . While it's true these articles aren't much more than tracklistings, the three Halfcocked album articles up for deletion haven't exactly had much time to grow, being created only yesterday Deletion of The Last Star WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10783 12644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taxologist (2nd nomination) User:Hzh 22:54, 27 March 2019 (UTC) delete It's no more than a term invented by a tax and accounting firm for publicity purposes. Until the wider world has taken notice of the word that can be substantiated with sources outside of the tax industry, it should not have its own article per . Taxology is actually another word for Taxonomy (biology)|taxonomy - https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/taxologyhttps://www.thefreedictionary.com/taxology used since the 19th century (a taxologist is therefore a taxonomist), it is therefore quite wrong to usurp the definition an older word still in use https://books.google.com/books?id=PtxBAQAAIAAJ&q=%22Taxologist%22+-wikipedia&dq=%22Taxologisthttps://books.google.com/books?id=D_N1AAAAMAAJ&q=%22Taxologist%22+-wikipedia&dq=%22Taxologist without showing that the new definition has gain wider currency outside of these companies. Redirect to taxonomy is therefore another possibility Deletion of Taxologist (2nd nomination) WP:NOTNEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10784 6947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohamed Zied Chaari User:Omni 07:51, 23 May 2016 (UTC) delete Per . He appears to be only notable for his invention of the wireless charging system, but that is something which in itself doesn't appear very notable Deletion of Mohamed Zied Chaari WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10785 20169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RationalPlan User:YellowFives 18:13, 10 November 2009 (UTC) delete http://www.constructionsoftwarereview.com/learning_center/user_reviews/multi-project/rationalplan-software-review This is what we have in lieu of |third party reliable sources Deletion of RationalPlan WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10786 12560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of television stations in New York User:Xanchester 20:41, 27 October 2012 (UTC) keep The list is not |indiscriminate, has a defined selection criteria, and serves as an internal navigational aid for articles within Wikipedia Deletion of List of television stations in New York WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10787 9119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Occupy Ashland User:Northamerica1000 22:12, 28 October 2011 (UTC) keep These topics have encyclopedic value, and will into the future. It's premature to delete these articles while occupy events continue to occur, locally, nationally and globally. Also, both topics pass Wikipedia's |general notability guideline for topic notability. While |Wikipedia is not a newspaper, these topics are suitable for inclusion in a digital encyclopedia, in part due to the lasting, ongoing nature of the Occupy protests, which strongly correlates with the likelihood of enduring notability, and as a reference for these respective topics. Outright deletion of these articles would be overly-hasty and brash in terms of building a comprehensive, digital encyclopedia Deletion of Occupy Ashland WP:GNG||WP:NOTNEWSPAPER Wikipedia:Notability 77
10788 21625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cliff Schecter User:SportingFlyer 01:38, 29 October 2019 (UTC) delete looking at the sources in the article, he wrote most of them. Looking at the book reviews, there's only one specifically on his book (Vanity Fair.) Fails Deletion of Cliff Schecter WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10789 2859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MissbrauchsOpfer Gegen InternetSperren User:SoWhy 19:27, 25 November 2009 (UTC) keep """WP:NOTDE|This project is not the German Wikipedia. We have different guidelines and policies to apply and things that are not notable enough for inclusion in the German Wikipedia can and are included on this project. If you claim that it does not meet Wikipedia:Notability (organizations and companies), please use an argument that does not consist of either """"not notable for de.wikipedia"""" or """"|just not notable"""". The article lists half a dozen sources explicitly talking about the subject and crediting them with having a major impact on the movement against internet censorship in Germany, which imho meets the requirement of our notability guidelines. And of course the aforementioned deletion on de.wikipedia added quite a bit of coverage that also referenced the subject multiple times. Regards""" Deletion of MissbrauchsOpfer Gegen InternetSperren WP:JNN Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10790 18476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christa Ehrmann-Hämmerle User:RebeccaGreen 01:27, 15 December 2018 (UTC) keep """Searching on """"Christa Hämmerle"""", the name that appears as author on books and articles, I find many reviews and citations of her work. I believe that she does meet #1, """"The person's research has had a significant impact in their scholarly discipline, broadly construed, as demonstrated by independent reliable sources."""" I have added some reviews to the article - more could be added, as well as more information about the areas of her research and its impact in the discipline""" Deletion of Christa Ehrmann-Hämmerle WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10791 2729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Mediacorp Channel 8 Upcoming Drama Series User:P199 15:27, 16 October 2012 (UTC) delete Clearly fails Deletion of List of Mediacorp Channel 8 Upcoming Drama Series WP:NOTTVGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10792 2513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Markus Fjørtoft User:Leeds 13:19, 9 July 2018 (UTC) keep """Admittedly fails but passes . Page creator has provided more sources, and I and other members of the football community have been aware of this young man's name for years independent of any Sounders association. The only reason he hasn't started professionally is because of MLS international roster slot rules, which while I understand is irrelevant to is something that should be mentioned. It would be unfortunate to browse the pages that link to him and not be able to access more information, and as a user above states, he's a """"possible search term."""" Again, coverage looks to be more than passing mentions to me. Cheers""" Deletion of Markus Fjørtoft WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10793 16319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Remixography of Mariah Carey user:Radman1 07:01, 2 September 2005 (UTC) keep as per . &mdash Deletion of Remixography of Mariah Carey WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10794 21531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conservative Christian Dragon fiction User:Pmedema 13:20, 12 December 2010 (UTC) delete Alot of with some and a dash of is how I would describe this article. Completely fails and as such, not worthy of inclusion Deletion of Conservative Christian Dragon fiction WP:OR||WP:SYNTH||WP:COATRACK||WP:N Wikipedia:No original research 65
10795 786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khairul Asyraf (2nd nomination) User:Fenix 08:36, 6 June 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Khairul Asyraf (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10796 126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Dodge User:Mike 10:35, 30 July 2014 (UTC) keep per |GNG. GNG doesn't care whether the coverage was motivated by human interest; it only asks if there are reliable independent sources that are specifically about the subject of the article. I can't see any way that GNG is not met here. I have some sympathy with the suggestion that applies, but in this case I don't see a better outcome by applying it -- typically ONEEVENT leads to embedding the information in the sources in the article about the event. Information about Mark Dodge doesn't belong in the 9/11 articles, but given the sources, we should put information about him ''somewhere''. An article about him seems the most sensible choice Deletion of Mark Dodge WP:GNG||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10797 15849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/6 December (film) [[User talk:Erpert|(let's talk about it)]] 18:35, 17 December 2010 (UTC) comment It would help if you state ''|why'' this article should be deleted. '''Erpert Deletion of 6 December (film) WP:NOREASON Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10798 14532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of films about school User:B 19:48, 1 July 2007 (UTC) delete """The reason for deletion is #DIR, #1, """"Lists or repositories of loosely associated topics"""". Thse films have in common only that they refer to school or education in some way; but """"film about school"""" is not an encyclopedic topic, at least the list does not give any hint why it should be""" Deletion of List of films about school WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10799 9418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Berkshire User:Stuart 12:50, 23 March 2013 (UTC) delete """Transwiki to Wikivoyage or Wikia, or otherwise remove from Wikipedia. The policy |Wikipedia is not a travel guide does apply here, as does """"Wikipedia is not a directory"""" on the same policy page. Various routes have been to AfD but there's no real strategy as to which are taken to AfD and which we retain. Because of the pendulum swing from editors voting keep and delete there was an RFC at the village pump which equally could not draw a single consensus for keeping or deleting but advised that each list should be nominated individually. This article is only likely to ever be sourced to primary sources (either 1st party the bus company, or 3rd party the local authority) it's unlikely that any secondary sources will be found to establish either the individual routes or the list of routes as |notable and meeting the GNG. London is the rare alternative where there are reliable secondary sources but even it should be replaced by a prose article rather than a list with a list only to specifically notable routes, but the debate for that is probably some way off. Also broadly through nomination, there has been a clear consensus formed for deletion with multiple bus route list articles deleted in the very recent past (past 6 months) this compares to prior to that time when there was no consensus whatsoever with most AfDs tied and the occasional few closing either way""" Deletion of List of bus routes in Berkshire WP:NOTTRAVEL||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10800 8724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Frecon User:Location 23:50, 18 September 2010 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Alex Frecon WP:BIO||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10801 21251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/We R One User:JohnCD 08:31, 23 November 2008 (UTC) delete newly-released song, fails #Songs as it has not ''been ranked on national or significant music charts, ...won significant awards or honors or ...been performed independently by several notable artists Deletion of We R One WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10802 9603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boutique La Vie en Rose [[User: Phoenix B 1of3|Phoenix B 1of3]] [[User talk: Phoenix B 1of3|(talk)]] 16:55, 21 October 2011 (UTC) keep Provides enough accurate citations to help back up anything in the article that is in question, very salvageble, I feel is fully met Deletion of Boutique La Vie en Rose WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10803 17978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jgerda Church (Adagua mountainous area) User:Bearian 15:29, 13 October 2020 (UTC) delete I conducted several searches online and found |nothing reliable. An old church can be presumed notable, but you still need sources Deletion of Jgerda Church (Adagua mountainous area) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10804 4125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karen Loren Agustin User:ApprenticeFan 00:42, 16 January 2016 (UTC) merge to Miss Universe 2002. No evidence of though failed to advance into the top 15 Deletion of Karen Loren Agustin WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10805 8529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HR-XML User:MER 11:05, 1 July 2007 (UTC) delete as . Author was one {{user|Chuckhr-xml Deletion of HR-XML WP:COI||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
10806 18762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Cowlin User:Hullaballoo 22:34, 21 July 2009 (UTC) keep """Milenko is on target. The fact that an article may prove difficult to expand beyond a stub is not a good reason to delete it. Perhaps it would be better to merge the content into an article about the publishing company, but since there is no such article that's not an option. The """"news"""" section on Cowlin's own website shows more than 25 radio interviews in the last few months, averaging about two per week, quite a few with the BBC. (It's in a frame without scrollbars, so you have to fiddle around with it to get it scroll.) Plus newspaper coverage, coverage of individual books, etc. So the coverage is out there, but probably hard to access online. But sources being hard to access is very different than sources being hard to find. And allows notability to be demonstrated by a """"well-known . . . '''body of work'''"""", which has been the standard applied by consensus to creators of works (like comic books) that are individually ephemeral but collectively noteworthy""" Deletion of Chris Cowlin WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10807 3562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Dines User:BrownHairedGirl 15:07, 16 September 2012 (UTC) delete The orphaned status of the article is cause for concern, but it is not a reason for deletion. However, I can't see that Dines meets , and he seems to fall short of . Two of the references are to non-trivial articles http://www.hkclubbing.com/articles/nightlife/kris-lopez-in-da-house-in-hong-kong.html, http://themst.com/interviews/from-spiritual-house-to-human-potential-exclusive-interview-with-christopher-dines, but the first doesn't look like a reliable source and second of the two is a blog Deletion of Christopher Dines WP:MUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10808 172 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Uluslararası güçler listesi Kullanıcı:Khadkhallkatkılar 20:23, 5 Aralık 2012 (UTC) delete """cano söylemiş zaten: ''""""Sorun kaynaksa, böyle bir konuda kaynak tuhaf olur. Çünkü her bir kaynak farklı bilgi sunuyor. Hangisi doğru peki? Çin süper güç mü, büyük güç mü yoksa her ikiside mi? """"'' peki kim karar veriyor buna?biz mi? tam da bu nedenle böyle bir liste en azından bu şekilde yapılamaz. . --Kullanıcı mesaj:Kibele|'''kibele""" Uluslararası güçler listesinin silinmesi Vikipedi:ÖAY Wikipedia:No original research 65
10809 9146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Walt Disney and Buena Vista video releases (2nd nomination) User:Mrschimpf 19:29, 7 November 2018 (UTC) delete This is the very definition of and has gotten way too out of control. At this point if a film doesn't come out on any video format, it's an anomaly Deletion of List of Walt Disney and Buena Vista video releases (2nd nomination) WP:NOTWEBHOST Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10810 138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chi iota kappa User:Nsk92 05:09, 13 September 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. No evidence of notability under either or Deletion of Chi iota kappa WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10811 9405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International eGames Committee User:Rrachet 15:44, 5 July 2017 (UTC) delete I found this http://www.cnbc.com/2016/08/15/twitch-beam-olympics-microsoft-1-billion-e-sports-gaming-industry.html CNBC article talking about this org, but that a bit week, so I agree that this article is a bit Deletion of International eGames Committee WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
10812 8382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sican language User:Edison 21:22, 4 October 2011 (UTC) delete Found no sources at Google Books or Google Scholar. Fails |verifiability Deletion of Sican language WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10813 9239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dreamora.com User:Arnoutf 20:40, 20 October 2006 (UTC) delete non-notable on global scale Deletion of Dreamora.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10814 14928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yashu Dhiman User:Wikicology 17:30, 1 October 2014 (UTC) delete I can't find significant |reliable sources that establish its notability. Subject obviously fails and Deletion of Yashu Dhiman WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10815 5802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WorldVenture User:Angusmclellan 22:14, 11 January 2007 (UTC) keep Searching Google Books for ''WorldVenture'' doesn't find a lot, but there are plenty trivial and not-so-trivial mentions of its older name, ''CBFMS'', and too many gnews archive hits to make weeding the out the trivial, obits which mention it in passing, very easy. Seems to me that this meets (''the scope of activities are national or international in scale and information can be verified by a third party source'') and . If it needs cleanup, clean it up, but it doesn't seem egregiously POV or spammy Deletion of WorldVenture WP:ORG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
10816 8912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bambi Magazine User:Ukexpat 02:31, 17 June 2012 (UTC) delete completely fails Deletion of Bambi Magazine WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10817 4936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MetaMask User:N2e 11:14, 29 November 2020 (UTC) keep the article is brief, but well-sourced. Wikipedia core policy is |verifiability and the fact that the MetaMask software seems to have played a role in the emerging technology of blockchain for several years now, as is documented by the sources. Clearly meets the notability criteria for an article to exist about it, and I see nothing that would appear |non-neutral Deletion of MetaMask WP:V||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10818 7120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terence Lewis (choreographer) User:Dwaipayanc 14:58, 9 November 2012 (UTC) keep Meets (appearance in TV shows Deletion of Terence Lewis (choreographer) WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10819 19762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M-Files User:Mark 01:20, 3 February 2017 (UTC) delete While the name makes it a challenge to search for (Matlab m-files dominate some searches), I was unable to find in-depth reviews of this software. The topic then fails and notability thresholds. I don't see any good merge targets, either. Hence, delete Deletion of M-Files WP:GNG||WP:NSOFTWARE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10820 20571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vermont Auditor of Accounts election, 2012 User:Bearian 23:14, 19 November 2012 (UTC) merge per Deletion of Vermont Auditor of Accounts election, 2012 WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
10821 20623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marc Allan Feldman User:Rollins83 19:20, 1 February 2016 (UTC) merge """per Hydronium Hydroxide. The Delete !voters have made compelling policy-based arguments that the subject doesn't satisfy (or other relevant notability guidelines), as opposed to the Keep !voters who have offered only unsubstantiated assertions (""""he seems to be"""" or """"is clearly"""" notable) or arguments of the or (...""""seems like he'll be in politics for some 15 more years"""") type. That being the case, I cannot support keeping the article at this time. However, states """"If a topic does not meet these criteria for establishing notability but still has some verifiable facts, it might be useful to discuss it within another article"""" Given that there are verifiable facts and that the subject is already included in the Libertarian primaries article, redirecting to that page would be a fair and sensible move""" Deletion of Marc Allan Feldman WP:GNG||WP:OTHERSTUFF||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10822 381 [[VdS-Journal]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Wangen 18:05, 22. Apr. 2008 (CEST) delete Nach #Zeitungen_und_Zeitschriften|Relevanzkriterien nicht relevant, auch sonst keine relevanzstiftenden Merkmale in Sicht. Kann bei im Artikel eindeutig angegebener Vereinigung (also die der Sternfreunde) eingearbeitet werden, hier aber Löschung von VdS-Journal Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10823 21613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National Highway 145 (India) User:Accesscrawl 18:38, 27 July 2018 (UTC) delete No evidence yet. Fails Deletion of National Highway 145 (India) WP:GOLDENRULE Wikipedia:The answer to life, the universe, and everything 7
10824 5280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hunter Biden laptop controversy User:CutePeach 16:13, 15 August 2021 (UTC) keep """this is an independently controversy that is out of the scope for Biden–Ukraine conspiracy theory, as it is currently named. This controversy is reported by RS to involve 1) the Democratic party which - on behalf of Joe Biden - denied an allegation that is possibly supported by laptop data, 2) a group of 50 former intelligence professionals who made the widely publicised but unsubstantiated claim - during the 2020 election - that this laptop is part a Russian information operation and 3) elements of the mainstream media are allegedly suppressing this story due to lack of access to primary data - just like they did with another topic we all know about - and 4) Federal officials delaying """"actions"""" so as not to adversely effect the outcome of the 2020 elections in favor of alleged Russian's goals. I created this article in good faith because I read the sources referenced here and also read the comments of multiple editors on the Biden–Ukraine conspiracy theory talk page who do not believe its claims are verifiable or neutral. I would agree to a merge this page with that page if it is renamed as '''Biden–Ukraine controversy''', or something similarly neutral, and reworked to reflect more up-to-date sources""" Deletion of Hunter Biden laptop controversy WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10825 7551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Region Free Xbox Games User:Porqin 11:51, 10 August 2006 (UTC) delete Not |cited and is |orginal research Deletion of List of Region Free Xbox Games WP:CITE||WP:OR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10826 13065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Map of the Past User:Kww 11:38, 19 February 2012 (UTC) delete """From :""""''In a few special cases, an unreleased album may qualify for an article if there is sufficient verifiable and properly referenced information about it''"""". No argument can be made that this is a special case.&mdash""" Deletion of Map of the Past WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10827 4406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plus (band) User:Atlantic306 22:58, 31 May 2020 (UTC) keep as passes criteria 2 of with albums and singles placed on a national chart, namely Oricon, imv Deletion of Plus (band) WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10828 14190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J. J. Milan User:Ejgreen77 05:08, 16 April 2020 (UTC) keep Meets and , per the sources provided by Cbl62 Deletion of J. J. Milan WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10829 2175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philadelphia transplant User:Ezeu 10:28, 21 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails and . Not a single reference given by those who want it kept despite this AFD being here for five days. The only argument is that one must visit philadelphia to verify this, and that reveals how obscure a phenomenon this is Deletion of Philadelphia transplant WP:NOR||WP:NEO Wikipedia:No original research 65
10830 9001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finest Hour (quartet) User:Ultraexactzz 19:42, 10 August 2017 (UTC) delete for lack of notability. may apply, of course, and if they won awards that are judged notable, then you might have a case for inclusion. I mean, 28th in the world at anything is pretty impressive. But is a redlink, so Deletion of Finest Hour (quartet) WP:USUAL||WP:NPRETTYIMPRESSIVE Wikipedia:Usual caveats 41
10831 9428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guelph Campus Cooperative User:CASSIOPEIA 06:00, 1 July 2018 (UTC) delete Cant find |reliable source to pass Deletion of Guelph Campus Cooperative WP:RS||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10832 19798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Shadow Raiders planets User:Matthew 08:34, 25 April 2007 (UTC) keep nominator gives no deletion rationale, and remember: #PAPER. Topic appears notable enough, merging wouldn't help Deletion of List of Shadow Raiders planets WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10833 326 [[Katholische Familienstiftung für Soldaten]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers 16:19, 13. Jul. 2012 (CEST) delete Kasten|1= gemäß Diskussion. Die #Stiftungen werden offensichtlich nicht erfüllt, weder über den hauptamtlichen Geschäftsführer noch über die Medienaufmerksamkeit. Die vom Ersteller angesprochene Katholische Militärseelsorge und Mittelbayerische sind nun natürlich genau nicht die geforderten überregionalen (und natürlich auch unabhängigen) Medien. Der Artikel ist vollkommen unenzyklopädisch geschrieben und nach dem Einspruch gegen den SLA wurde weder die Gelegenheit genützt in die Löschdiskussion einzugreifen, noch den Artikel zu verbessern und Relevanz herauszustellen. Gruß Löschung von Katholische Familienstiftung für Soldaten Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
10834 11456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John W. Loftus User:JFHJr 06:41, 16 December 2011 (UTC) delete I didn't find any better reliable, third party sources substantially covering this subject. He appears to fail requirements Deletion of John W. Loftus WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10835 16036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hot 100 Airplay number-one hits of 1997 (USA) User:TenPoundHammer 20:18, 17 July 2007 (UTC) keep encyclopedic list of chart toppers. I hate to argue that |other crap exists, but this list is no less notable than, say, 1997 in country music, which features all of the Hot Country Songs number-one singles and other major hits. I don't see any copyryight violations here at this list or any other Hot 100 Airplay lists Deletion of Hot 100 Airplay number-one hits of 1997 (USA) WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10836 20067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cult films (3rd nomination) user:Andrew 09:47, 13 February 2019 (UTC) keep There are numerous books about cult movies and so the topic easily passes . is not policy; the actual policies are and Deletion of List of cult films (3rd nomination) WP:LISTN||WP:TNT||WP:IMPERFECT||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10837 19457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Evans (politician) User:Bearian 21:47, 7 November 2019 (UTC) keep there has been lots of |significant coverage - a local official can be notable, but is not automatically presumed notable Deletion of Jordan Evans (politician) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
10838 12606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shahnawaz Farooqui User:RGTraynor 13:44, 15 December 2009 (UTC) delete """And sources which describe the subject as """"renowned"""" ''do not satisfy or .'' To satisfy either one, there must be |reliable sources which """"discuss the subject in significant detail."""" These G-News articles ''quote'' Farooqui, but they're not about him. Does anyone have any which do to submit""" Deletion of Shahnawaz Farooqui WP:N||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10839 11628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Golden Rooster Award lists User:Lugnuts 18:12, 18 September 2012 (UTC) keep Notable film awards for/in China. Passes Deletion of Golden Rooster Award lists WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10840 4281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Busty Dusty User:Edgarde 13:42, 13 November 2008 (UTC) delete I know this performer exists, but I doubt she meets any standard Deletion of Busty Dusty WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10841 10127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shasta Cascade Broadcasting Corporation User:K 05:29, 6 February 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet / & significant RS coverage not found. There's nothing here that's worth merging to any of the stations Deletion of Shasta Cascade Broadcasting Corporation WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
10842 11558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrian Alvarstein User:Geschichte 21:04, 17 February 2017 (UTC) delete per above, at best Deletion of Adrian Alvarstein WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10843 7989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criminal rock throwing User:TheGracefulSlick 16:13, 24 May 2018 (UTC) keep The article isn't well-written but eletion is not cleanup|deletion is not cleanup. I hate invoking that because it promotes poor effort and sourcing, but the topic is certainly discussed thoroughly in much better sources than what were chosen; the time really should have been taken to create a comprehensive article Deletion of Criminal rock throwing WP:D Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
10844 4030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mythili Kumar User:Xxanthippe 05:07, 23 June 2009 (UTC) comment Would not pass high standard of W:Prof. May pass other Deletion of Mythili Kumar WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10845 194 [[Liste von weitesten Schussentfernungen zur Tötung von Menschen durch Scharfschützen]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Knoerz NONE keep """Und ewig grüßt das Murmeltier: Es wurde kein gültiger Löschgrund angegeben und es ist auch keiner erkennbar. Moralisch mag das Thema nicht für alle schön sein. Das ist (wieder) der einzige Grund für den LA. Die Relevanz ist bereits im ersten Satz dargestellt: """"beinhaltet die weitesten bestätigten und veröffentlichten Schussentfernungen von Scharfschützen zur Tötung von Menschen. Seit ... werden diese ... dokumentiert und teilweise veröffentlicht."""" Allein die Suche nach """"Longest confirmed sniper kill"""" liefert über 1,3 Mio Treffer. Das Thema ist Thema und ob Bild oder Welt oder Stern und ihren ganzen englischen Pendants von einzelnen als Regenbogenpresse gesehen werden, ist für diese Disk eher irrelevant. Eine geeignete Quelle gem WP:Q sind sie in jedem Fall. Der darauf folgende Inhalt ist ausreichend mit Quellen belegt und ich werde ihn gern um noch etwa 45 Refs oder auch gut 10 Bücher ergänzen und den Artikel erweitern. (Was ich allerdings gern vermeiden würde, da die Liste vollständig und aus meiner Sicht inhaltlich ausreichend ist und wir sonst Artikel wie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Longest_recorded_sniper_kills Longest recorded sniper kills oder https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Record_de_distance_de_tir_l%C3%A9tal_pour_un_tireur_d%27%C3%A9lite Record de distance de tir létal pour un tireur d'élite bekommen) Die Ergebnisse dieser Liste beruhen auf (übrigens haarklein) dokumentierten Tötungen durch Soldaten (hier konkret Scharfschützen) in den verschiedenen Streitkräften. Teilweise werden diese mit Absicht veröffentlicht, teilweise werden sie öffentlich durch Recherchen verschiedener Medien. Der vor über 6 Jahren gelöschte und in meinen BNR verschobene Artikel hat nichts mehr mit diesem hier zu tun. Das war ursprünglich eine schlecht belegte Auslagerung aus dem Artikel. Zusammenfassend aus meiner Sicht ist die Liste daher zu da die Relevanz ausreichend dargestellt ist und die Inhalte gem. WP:Q belegt sind. Diese Liste mit allen bekannten Einträgen, ist übrigens eine , wie sie in der WP überall genutzt wird, um den Hauptartikel nicht aufzublähen und keine TF""" Löschung von Liste von weitesten Schussentfernungen zur Tötung von Menschen durch Scharfschützen Wikipedia:Listen Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
10846 11269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of sister cities in New England User:Markvs88 00:18, 15 February 2011 (UTC) keep WP:notdir does not apply on any of its seven points. likewise does not apply on any of its seven points. The list has a scope and is of a factual nature. Best Deletion of List of sister cities in New England WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10847 7013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/9/12 Candidate User:Johnuniq 08:39, 3 July 2009 (UTC) delete Fails and Wikipedia is not a free web hosting or promotion service Deletion of 9/12 Candidate WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10848 1637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Linda George (Assyrian singer) User:TonyTheTiger 21:08, 6 March 2015 (UTC) comment I deded this because however modest her notability may be it is likely understated on ENG WP due to the nature of her notability being a non-English artform. I think we English speakers may have just brushed her aside and I want this case to be given full consideration Deletion of Linda George (Assyrian singer) WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
10849 3315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhonda towns User:WJBscribe 23:50, 29 April 2007 (UTC) delete does not appear notable enough per and there are no reliable sources mentioning her. Do not redirect to the category, cross-namespace redirects should be avoided Deletion of Rhonda towns WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10850 14902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesse Dudas (2nd nomination) User:Nurmsook 17:26, 3 April 2018 (UTC) keep Meets #6 per above Deletion of Jesse Dudas (2nd nomination) WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
10851 9900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Schweitzer User:GiantSnowman 10:07, 31 January 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Jordan Schweitzer WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10852 171 [[:Vorlage:Landesstraße B|Vorlage:Landesstraße B]] (bleibt) Benutzer:DanielHerzberg NONE keep Ich finde das ja interessant, wie du das Ergebnis des Meinungsbildes deutest. Aber auf steht als Ergebnis, dass alles beim Alten bleibt (außerdem ist das noch lange kein Löschgrund). Deshalb Löschung von :Vorlage:Landesstraße B|Vorlage:Landesstraße B Wikipedia:Meinungsbilder Wikipedia:Meinungsbilder 80
10853 6018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Now That's What I Call Music! 36 (U.S. series) User:Starcheerspeaksnewslostwars 19:36, 20 October 2010 (UTC) keep Although an extension of the requirements of , since this series is the most notable of all compilation albums, it should follow that individual albums within that series are notable. However, I am not against a redirect of many of the ''Now'' album articles for those that are nothing more than track lists. I'd prefer a redirect over delete here Deletion of Now That's What I Call Music! 36 (U.S. series) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10854 18213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dylan Bates User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable biography. Recommend the article author see http://www.wikime.org/ WikiMe for writing biographies and/or http://www.wikitree.org WikiTree for writing genealogies. &mdash Deletion of Dylan Bates WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10855 15015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Venant Nkurunziza User:Bearian 22:00, 2 April 2017 (UTC) delete fails . We also almost always delete such shadow cabinet members Deletion of Venant Nkurunziza WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10856 1012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terrorism against Israel before 2000 User:Sandstein 06:13, 10 June 2006 (UTC) delete The underlying problem appears to be that we have lots of |redundant chronological lists of that type (see below), of which some try to source their claims and list casualties on both sides, and some do not (and obviously, most have POV problems, but that's not a problem for AfD). This is probably more for a centralised discussion, but in the meantime we should just delete per all of these lists and/or entries that do not have sources, and leave it to someone else to merge the rest into one useful list. We'll probably not destroy much information that way, as I'm sure there are advocacy groups around on both sides publishing this sort of list, which we then can use to fill (with sources!) any gaps so created Deletion of Terrorism against Israel before 2000 WP:POVFORK||WP:RS Wikipedia:Content forking 33
10857 629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alif Hilmi Azmir User:Scopecreep 10:08, 27 March 2012 (UTC) delete per nomination: it's an autobiography of a student, and while his record sounds very nice, even if it's true it wouldn't make him notable enough for inclusion under Deletion of Alif Hilmi Azmir WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10858 567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michi-chan User:EdJohnston 02:30, 30 April 2008 (UTC) delete Touring, awards, or releases on major labels: these are things that can show notability under . I don't see any of those here Deletion of Michi-chan WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10859 20663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Everafter (webcomic) User:Haemo 07:23, 16 June 2007 (UTC) delete the proof is, as they say, in the pudding. And pease porridge in the pot, still needs |reliable sources to back up |notability, nine days old or not Deletion of Everafter (webcomic) WP:RS||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10860 16041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darron Gee User:Govvy 12:11, 21 February 2013 (UTC) keep 27 citations! I think that's enough to just pass ! And he has been assistant manager too some league clubs, doesn't that also pass Deletion of Darron Gee WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10861 10800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naked Truth (band) User:Wikimandia 18:55, 31 May 2015 (UTC) keep if the band put out two albums on Sony label it qualifies per Deletion of Naked Truth (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10862 9034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Vescovi User:Finngall 00:45, 26 August 2014 (UTC) delete per above. No independent sources to verify his playing in KBL, doesn't satisfy otherwise. Article creator has just earned a one-week block for removing AfD tags from this article immediately after the expiration of a 24-hour block for the same activity Deletion of Joshua Vescovi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10863 1239 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Got a """"D"""" in Salami""" User:ManicSpider 11:27, 9 February 2011 (UTC) keep This book seems to me to be notable. It is recommended reading for teaching learning disabilities in the classroom http://books.google.com.au/books?id=Ctx9gC9tLEAC&lpg=PA78&dq=%22I%20Got%20a%20%22D%22%20in%20Salami%22&pg=PA78#v=onepage&q=%22I%20Got%20a%20%22D%22%20in%20Salami%22&f=false here, it was also used http://books.google.com.au/books?id=uuvX5Gpbx9UC&lpg=PA184&dq=%22I%20Got%20a%20%22D%22%20in%20Salami%22&pg=PA184#v=onepage&q=%22I%20Got%20a%20%22D%22%20in%20Salami%22&f=falsehere as a teaching resource for reading cognition, is mentioned as a high-interest resource in http://books.google.com.au/books?id=rdm5BrFHOg8C&lpg=PA39&dq=%22I%20Got%20a%20%22D%22%20in%20Salami%22&pg=PA39#v=onepage&q=%22I%20Got%20a%20%22D%22%20in%20Salami%22&f=false this book on teaching kids with trouble reading and it was mentioned in the article ''Fictional Characters with Dyslexia: What Are We Seeing in Books?'' and in the book ''Children's Book Corner: A Read-Aloud Resource with Tips, Techniques, and Plans for Teachers, Librarians, and Parents : Level Grades 3 and 4'' but I can't access those because of paywalls. The same for the articles available on a Google News Archive search. Meets #4 """Deletion of I Got a """"D"""" in Salami""" WP:NBOOKS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10864 12384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nichole Galicia User:Lankiveil 13:29, 7 July 2014 (UTC) delete I think that the evidence makes it pretty clear that they're both the same person, but even if they are I think that with only one notable role it's stretching it a bit to say she meets Deletion of Nichole Galicia WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
10865 10078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Galaxy Express Corporation User:Starblind 17:21, 20 December 2009 (UTC) keep appears to pass in my opinion. If it's true that their main project is cancelled and they fade into obscurity, that can be addressed if and when it happens Deletion of Galaxy Express Corporation WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10866 9903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fernanda Staniscuaski User:Beccaynr 04:11, 7 April 2021 (UTC) keep it looks like there is notability from multiple independent and reliable sources, and that her biographical information, including being a parent, e.g. as reported in https://science.sciencemag.org/content/369/6504/609.full Science, is relevant to her advocacy. It also appears that non-English sources Deletion of Fernanda Staniscuaski WP:BASIC||WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
10867 10290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Administrator Training Centre User:Hansnesse 07:50, 14 February 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Total users at present is listed on the site as 198, which fails Deletion of Administrator Training Centre WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10868 20531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Five-fret stretch User:Dom 08:15, 30 August 2020 (UTC) delete per . I can't see an obvious redirect target Deletion of Five-fret stretch WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10869 18083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/College West User:Takeaway 23:15, 9 October 2014 (UTC) delete Not a governmental subdivison so doesn't apply. And too early to know if this Business improvement district will be significant enough to be notable. As yet no significant coverage Deletion of College West WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10870 1115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finders Keepers (casual game) User:Perfect 17:04, 27 August 2008 (UTC) delete NN. Deletion of Finders Keepers (casual game) WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10871 15549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Bogard User:Mattythewhite 21:24, 7 March 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Daniel Bogard WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10872 8173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diane Hoh User:Bearian 18:44, 8 October 2012 (UTC) keep """per , , and DGG. According to the Heymann standard, Tokyogirl79 has done a fine job of fixing up the problems noted in the nomination, especially in sourcing. I have great """"Respect for contributors willing to improve articles of questioned notability...."""" In the past, articles about authors often must be fixed up, sometimes due to ''bad'' paid editing. In agreement with DGG, reviews and quantity of translations are often the only ways to prove that an author is notable; see, ''e.g.'' Amy Krouse Rosenthal, which infamously went from speedy deletion to DYK status in two days. Finally, we have to be more welcoming of women's BLPs""" Deletion of Diane Hoh WP:HEY||WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
10873 8602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Folan User:Carioca 21:46, 12 June 2010 (UTC) delete He fails and Deletion of Stephen Folan WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10874 1037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vladislavs Gutkovskis User:Sir 14:17, 15 September 2015 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Vladislavs Gutkovskis WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10875 4706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unniceness User:Marasmusine 17:28, 26 February 2008 (UTC) delete per above and Wikipedia is |not a dictionary. If the nominator agrees, I would also suggest adding Unnice to this AfD Deletion of Unniceness WP:DICTDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10876 21303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atsuoko Suda User:Ma 11:12, 14 January 2018 (UTC) comment Subject-specific guideline in , emphasizes foremost upon . should be considered after basic criteria is met Deletion of Atsuoko Suda WP:ATHLETE||WP:SPORTBASIC||WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10877 7090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anunnaki chant User:Armbrust 13:22, 26 October 2010 (UTC) delete This is absolutely |unverifiable, a |made up term or even a |hoax Deletion of Anunnaki chant WP:V||WP:MADEUP||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10878 5230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevvu Keka User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:08, 14 September 2012 (UTC) delete """per . While ''some'' coverage of its """"launch"""" (essentially an announcement party) and pre-production is availble,http://www.indiaglitz.com/channels/telugu/article/81467.htmlhttp://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2012-07-25/news-interviews/32847420_1_allari-naresh-kevvu-keka-anrhttp://www.supergoodmovies.com/43189/tollywood/gabbar-singh-songs-rocking-tollywood-news-details tells us we wait until we have more before we have an article""" Deletion of Kevvu Keka WP:NYF||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
10879 11634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Post experience growth User:Bearian 00:55, 27 August 2015 (UTC) delete as a |non-notable neologism created in 2010, as part of a |non-notable alternate idea, by a |non-notable scholar. |Wikipedia is not a webhost or |soapbox for new ideas. This essay is little more than a |content fork of other articles' citations mixed liberally with |spam Deletion of Post experience growth WP:NEO||WP:FRINGE||WP:PROF||WP:NOTWEBHOST||WP:SOAP||WP:FORK||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10880 2584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fast Walker (second nomination) User:Wsiegmund 15:49, 12 July 2006 (UTC) delete see . Article asserts that only one satellite detected the event; consequently, no confirmation exists that it even occurred Deletion of Fast Walker (second nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10881 932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nuke the fridge User:RyanLupin 09:07, 26 May 2008 (UTC) delete it was coined by a bunch of kids on a message forum? Hardly |notable and definitely not |verifiable. Also OTDICDEF comes into play here Deletion of Nuke the fridge WP:N||WP:V||WP:NOTDICDEF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10882 176 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Tunceli Türkmenleri Kullanıcı:dr. coaldr. coal 20.17, 2 Temmuz 2020 (UTC) comment """tarafından 2,5 gün önce """"maddenin gereğince kaynaklandırılarak düzenlenmesi, aksi halde iddia olunduğu şekilde VP:ÖAY dolayısıyla M8 maddesi kapsamında silinebileceği"""", Tartışma:Tunceli Türkmenleri|tartışma sayfasında belirtilmiş. {{ping}} kullanıldığı için bildirim gitmemiş olabilir, bana gelmiyor mesela. O nedenle fark etmemiş olabilecekleri için {{seslen|Tiraktor}}, {{seslen|Laz}} ve {{seslen|Vitruvian}}'a bir de buradan seslenmek isterim. Maddeyi oluşturan kullanıcı {{seslen|Tiraktor}}, geçtiğimiz süreç içinde etkindi zira. Eğer madde, VP:GÜVEN|güvenilir kaynaklar kullanılarak ve """"bu kaynaklarda doğrudan yer alan"""" bilgiler yorum veya hatalı çıkarımlara yer verilmeksizin geliştirilebilecekse bunun yapılmasını tercih ederim. Özgün araştırma bağlamında kaynakta yer alan bilgiye sadık kalınarak kullanımı özellikle vurguladım, zira kullanıcının oluşturmuş olduğu """"Dersim Alevileri"""" maddesinde de iki ayrı kaynaktan alınmış iki apayrı bilgi sanki birbiriyle bağdaşık ve ilgiliymiş gibi sunulmuştu. Her neyse, eğer '''VP:D|doğrulanabilirlik sağlanamıyorsa silinsin""" Tunceli Türkmenleri'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:D Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10883 19242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spellborn User:Rudget 12:44, 16 December 2007 (UTC) delete """as above, and as per |advertisement. Lines like """"Spellborn distinguishes itself from other MMORPGs"""" are unacceptable""" Deletion of Spellborn WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
10884 11648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Sanjoy Mukherji User:Jytdog 04:42, 25 April 2017 (UTC) delete fails GNG and this is promotional and full of Deletion of Dr. Sanjoy Mukherji WP:SPS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10885 10506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bunyan Randolph Cooner User:TimothyBlue 07:45, 25 January 2021 (UTC) merge """to USS Cooner per above. Doesn't pass for a stand alone article, but the content will improve the target article, be less fragmented, and give the content more readership. Per , ''""""Editors may use their discretion to merge or group two or more related topics into a single article.""""'' The article as a stand alone will receive minimal readership, but as part of the target will receive much more. There is no benefit to fragmenting the content. I ce'd the article to help with the merge. // """ Deletion of Bunyan Randolph Cooner WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10886 10908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Every Heart Broken User:Cliff 14:35, 29 September 2008 (UTC) delete per above: |crystal ballery Deletion of Every Heart Broken WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10887 19702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whitehall Time Travel Therory User:Gnfnrf 05:11, 6 December 2008 (UTC) delete """due to lack of funding and the inability to create wormholes."""" Errr, seriously, this is a prime case of """ Deletion of Whitehall Time Travel Therory WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
10888 6425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Only You Can Save Mankind The Movie User:Erik 01:17, 11 January 2008 (UTC) delete per the lack of |notability determined by |verifiable coverage from |reliable sources Deletion of Only You Can Save Mankind The Movie WP:N||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10889 7248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Galaxy (video game) User:MuZemike 16:27, 15 October 2008 (UTC) delete per lack of |verifiable, third-party sources establishing |notability for this game. The forecast also calls for Deletion of Galaxy (video game) WP:V||WP:N||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10890 7318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fulbourn Institute F.C. User:Qwghlm 11:15, 25 August 2006 (UTC) delete have never played in levels 1-10 of English football league system, fails , no other claim to notability Deletion of Fulbourn Institute F.C. WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10891 888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yeh Dil Kisko Doon User:Narky 19:49, 20 September 2020 (UTC) comment The new sources are passing mentions in articles about actors, singers and composers. Notability is not . We need sources about the film itself, not about something else Deletion of Yeh Dil Kisko Doon WP:INHERITED||WP:RS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
10892 21107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of PNAC Members associated with the Administration of George W. Bush User:Alanscottwalker 00:27, 15 March 2015 (UTC) merge """or Keep No substantiated policy reason is given to throw away all this work entirely, per . The OR and SYNTH objections are without merit even to the term """"members"""" given the sourcing and the words the sources use (thus, no BLP issue). The FORK issue, while having perhaps more purchase, is not sustained in the body of the list article where there is no Wikipedia POV shown, just a recitation of facts: these people did this and this. In short, these relatively few people notably articulated the governing principles of the group and/or as sourced signed on to a notable piece of lobbying of government by the group, and later were notably in government - in a way the sources draw a direct notable line between. All that is well sourced, and yes both overlapping sets can be discussed and identified by name in the merge candidate or as a sub-list-article, which appears to have been the intent. (Wikipedia:Article titles|Naming issues should be addressed elsewhere""" Deletion of List of PNAC Members associated with the Administration of George W. Bush WP:LISTPEOPLE Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
10893 10710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clergyman-naturalist User:Dhartung 03:24, 3 June 2008 (UTC) delete I believe this falls under as a loosely connected topic. Naturalists came from many walks of life with the same necessary attributes as the clergy. (Some money, and more time, basically Deletion of Clergyman-naturalist WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10894 20140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carolyn Howard-Johnson User:Lifebaka 20:35, 21 December 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. From my Google search, all of the content in the article appears to be factual, but I doubt that truly |reliable sources can be found to |verify much of it Deletion of Carolyn Howard-Johnson WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10895 108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Cheetham User:Claritas 13:40, 25 May 2010 (UTC) delete borderline fails - the relevant policy in this case. Replace with an article on James Cheetham, the biographer of Thomas Paine Deletion of James Cheetham WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
10896 6505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mouthwash (band) User:Michig 09:44, 8 February 2020 (UTC) delete After several searches, I couldn't find much besides the Allmusic bio and review. While these are perfectly valid sources, it doesn't look like any criterion of is satisfied here Deletion of Mouthwash (band) WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10897 9329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of male porn stars User:Night 20:12, 7 October 2006 (UTC) delete """we have a general list of people on wikipedia, but something like """"list of porn stars"""" makes an assertion about people that really needs to be sourced under the terms of , the issues involved with maintenance makes it seem like this would be better served by a category, or a narrower list, like lists of award winners for each year or something (to prove notability""" Deletion of List of male porn stars WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10898 14804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Mantos User:Dhartung 03:25, 17 August 2007 (UTC) delete """fails . This appears to be part of an effort to document people in the est/Landmark movement; we've previously deleted several """"training leaders"""" or whatever they're called""" Deletion of Jack Mantos WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10899 20778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kennedy Leigh User:Hanswar32 02:40, 15 February 2014 (UTC) keep Although she does not meet requirements of according to the current criteria, it's reasonable to assume that she'll soon pass it due to her young age (19) and as already mentioned an AVN award already under her belt. A ton of other articles on pornographic actresses exist that fail PORNBIO and have much less potential in ever passing that are not challenged for deletion which leads me to assume (I'm probably wrong) that there are other criteria in play when judging to keep/delete or that the process is selective according to who has the motivation to nominate an article Deletion of Kennedy Leigh WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10900 5692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of foreign-born Australians User:Coolabahapple 03:43, 17 December 2017 (UTC) comment """Vague list of people, mostly politicians."""", so expand it, this is not a deletion reason, there are numerous books that discuss notable australians that were born overseas so this would meet , that said i envisage this turning into a megalist of 1000s of people (again not a reason to delete) that can be organised into various sections (with their own articles?) ie. all these pollies into a """"Politics and Government"""" section, authors in another, artists in another and so on""" Deletion of List of foreign-born Australians WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
10901 18210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jay Snyder (musician) User:Esradekan 00:52, 12 August 2009 (UTC) delete fails stand alone notability per . Searching finds no significant coverage in |reliable, third-party, sources Deletion of Jay Snyder (musician) WP:MUSICBIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10902 19516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coate's User:SamHolt6 21:19, 14 September 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and due to lack of coverage Deletion of Coate's WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10903 6093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Line of succession to the former throne of Waldeck and Pyrmont User:TompaDompa 21:23, 26 July 2020 (UTC) delete per -REASON 6: {{tq|Articles that cannot possibly be attributed to wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable sources, including wikipedia:Avoid neologisms|neologisms, wikipedia:No original research|original theories and conclusions, and articles that are themselves wikipedia:Don't create hoaxes|hoaxes (but not articles describing notable hoaxes)}}. It is impossible to attribute the current line of succession to this throne to sources, because there is no current line of succession, because the Principality itself doesn't even exist anymore Deletion of Line of succession to the former throne of Waldeck and Pyrmont WP:DEL||WP:RELIABLE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
10904 20118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Non-Muslim view of Ali (second nomination) User:Jersey 18:42, 14 May 2006 (UTC) delete """if you actually look at the article it is a list of random quotes by """"non-muslims"""". Content fork, indiscriminate collection of information, , etc... The Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Non-Muslim view of Ali|first nomination was kept by no consenus with keep arguments being about my supposed """"bad faith conduct"""" not the merits of the article itself""" Deletion of Non-Muslim view of Ali (second nomination) WP:NOT||WP:OWN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10905 7900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bed Talks User:Pharaoh 23:59, 9 August 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Bed Talks WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10906 16027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Taub (journalist) User:Otr500 03:19, 24 April 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |GNG as WP:notable (people)|not notable. This is a |Pseudo-biography of a freelance journalist. With over 3000 papers in the US, thousands worldwide, 7000 magazines (US) and 82 billion a year (US) in digital forms of media there is nothing unique or encyclopedic about this |BLP. I do like his writing style but I am sure that is not a valid reason to keep Deletion of Ben Taub (journalist) WP:GNG||WP:PSEUDO||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
10907 8705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Legality of bestiality by country or territory User:Mikehawk10 06:08, 1 June 2021 (UTC) keep It's an odd topic, and there's certainly plenty of issues, but it appears to have coverage in multiple reliable sources and thus passes . These sources include a https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00224499.2015.1100701 2016 paper published in ''The Journal of Sex Research'', a https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25492066/ 2014 paper in the ''Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law'', and a https://www.cabdirect.org/cabdirect/abstract/20053199840 2005 paper from Purdue University. I'm also finding law review articles (such as https://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/jael1&div=12&id=&page= this one) that cover the topic from a U.S.-centric perspective. It's unclear to me if this would be better in a list format or if this information would be better incorporated into an existing article or if this article is -worthy, which is why my !vote for keep is a weak one, (update: I think it's probably -worthy) though I believe that the legality of bestiality passes the bar in significant coverage when we consider academic sources. If we do keep it, the article needs significant revision to be in line with and Deletion of Legality of bestiality by country or territory WP:OR||WP:GNG||WP:TNT||WP:TNT||WP:NOTADVOCACY||WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
10908 18793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tbilisi this week User:Joe 21:41, 28 November 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this magazine Deletion of Tbilisi this week WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10909 18447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Kimberly Nees [[User talk:Mysterytrey#top|Mysterytrey]] 23:23, 15 March 2014 (UTC) delete per . Routine news stories are not notable unless there is anything out of the regular. The suspect being released after trial didn't spark any controversy and was not widely covered and didn't have much impact Deletion of Murder of Kimberly Nees WP:EVENTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10910 144 [[Bahnstrecke Neumünster-Ascheberg]] (erledigt, zurückgezogen) Benutzer:Loegge NONE keep Laut #Verkehrswege/-bauwerke sind Eisenbahnstrecken relevant. Ich sehe daher keinen Grund für einen LA Löschung von Bahnstrecke Neumünster-Ascheberg Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10911 8272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salvatore Ruocco User:Lugnuts 12:41, 20 March 2021 (UTC) delete per nom. Judging by the username of the page's creator, probably a case of / too Deletion of Salvatore Ruocco WP:COI||WP:SELF Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
10912 7024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Koteski User:GiantSnowman 19:52, 16 January 2011 (UTC) delete this player appears to fail and Deletion of Daniel Koteski WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10913 13728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Zulevic User:Samir_grover 05:31, 7 March 2006 (UTC) keep I also think he is notable enough; he's done work with ''Second City'', and he has some film and TV credits. As an aside, |be nice Deletion of Jim Zulevic WP:CIVIL Wikipedia:Civility 37
10914 17848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zombietime User:George 07:30, 17 September 2009 (UTC) delete or merge) per ChrisO above. Only http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:WhatLinksHere&target=Zombietime&namespace=0 a single page links to this article, even though it has been around for almost three years. Fails to meet notability beyond one event per Deletion of Zombietime WP:SINGLEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10915 10751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fantasy online User:Jayen466 21:41, 14 March 2011 (UTC) comment The topic may be notable, but as it is written the article falls foul of . It cites no sources, is written in the first person, and promises to develop into a directory of internet sites (which Wikipedia is not for Deletion of Fantasy online WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10916 19573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benjamin DeJesus User:Phil 23:10, 17 March 2009 (UTC) comment """I haven't done the research needed to give an opinion about the disposition of this article, but I feel I must commend the nominator on the way the nomination is written. AfD usually seems to be a place where |civility policy is completely ignored, with accusations of """"vanity"""" or worse being made on the slightest of evidence, so I hope the wording of this nomination will act as an example to other nominators""" Deletion of Benjamin DeJesus WP:CIVIL Wikipedia:Civility 37
10917 9989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Water export User:TenPoundHammer 21:41, 29 July 2007 (UTC) delete as an essay, violation of Deletion of Water export WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
10918 2168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of National Football League records (team) User:Arxiloxos 16:35, 14 January 2015 (UTC) keep As {{U|Cbl62}} says, such a list of ''records'' is core information in the coverage of any notable sport, and not the sort of thing to which is addressed Deletion of List of National Football League records (team) WP:NOTSTATSBOOK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10919 12274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bisan George User:GiantSnowman 16:45, 8 January 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Bisan George WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10920 1339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trivaeo User:JohnCD 16:17, 11 February 2009 (UTC) delete per #Articles on neologisms and - a look at http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&q=Trivaeo&btnG=Google+Search&meta= Google confirms that this termis only in use in connection with this company and its products Deletion of Trivaeo WP:NEO||WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10921 14860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alfred Wentworth User:Leflyman 06:00, 22 April 2007 (UTC) delete Entirely non-notable fictional character, fails -- will never be more than a stub. Merge to Law & Order characters Deletion of Alfred Wentworth WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
10922 7016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nima Lepcha User:Lefcentreright 18:20, 30 March 2020 (UTC) delete Fails . Serving as the vice president of a tiny party is not enough for him to have an article Deletion of Nima Lepcha WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10923 13342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Benson User:onel5969 17:58, 7 April 2017 (UTC) delete and as PRehse suggests, salt due to disruptive editing. Searches did not turn up enough in-depth sourcing to show they meet , and they definitely don't meet Deletion of Alex Benson WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10924 9372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Real Social Dynamics (2nd nomination) User:Elaragirl 10:57, 6 February 2007 (UTC) delete complete spam. The critical sources don't meet , the trivial ones make up too much of the core of the article, and the entire article fails . Multiple whitewashes and edit warring only compound the fact that, at best, the article should be deleted and if solid source can be found, created as a stub Deletion of Real Social Dynamics (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10925 11425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exodus (role-playing game) User:Nizolan 14:40, 28 May 2021 (UTC) delete per . After trawling through Google the only source even approaching reliable that I could find is the three paragraphs on it here https://geekandsundry.com/5-ways-to-get-your-fallout-tabletop-rpg-geek-on Deletion of Exodus (role-playing game) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10926 444 [[Harry Bushh!!]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Tom_md 08:16, 3. Jul. 2012 (CEST) delete Klares , unser werden (noch) nicht erfüllt Löschung von Harry Bushh!! Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10927 20781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dustin Software, Inc. User:AmitDeshwar 00:47, 27 September 2006 (UTC) delete I agree that its not really self-promotional. However it fails and . Show verifiable evidence that it satisfies either of those and then it should stay. The key thing is that this company, or its forum, needs to have verifiable sources. If the company or the forum has been covered several times in the media, for example would establish both notability and provide verifiable sources Deletion of Dustin Software, Inc. WP:CORP||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10928 12990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noach (parsha) User:Cullen328 01:04, 10 July 2012 (UTC) comment Much has been made of the lack of specific references within this article to establish the notability of the topic of the parsha itself. Though this is a valid criticism, it is not a reason to delete the article, but instead an argument for improving the article. |Significant coverage of this (and of the other parashot) in |reliable sources is so extensive and varied that any questions about notability ought to be moot - the challenge is to identify and select among the vast array of sources readily available to include those of the highest academic quality and that reflect the full range of significant points of view about the topic. I do not have the expertise to identify those sources, but I am absolutely certain that they exist in abundance and winnowing them is the task at hand. I offer just one example - http://books.google.com/books?id=tuBQviuPidMC&printsec=frontcover&dq=parsha+weekly+Torah+reading&hl=en&sa=X&ei=_nv7T_P9PKWC2gXfuonrCw&sqi=2&ved=0CDYQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=parsha%20weekly%20Torah%20reading&f=false Entering Torah: Prefaces to the Weekly Torah Portion a 2009 book by Reuven Hammer, a mainstream commentator on Jewish topics. This book devotes five pages (11-15) to analysis of Noach, and a similar amount to the other parashot. There must be thousands of other examples published over many hundreds of years. These parashot are notable as individual subjects of intensive and focused study and published commentary of the most rigorous academic standards. That makes them notable enough for Wikipedia articles Deletion of Noach (parsha) WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
10929 153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Mackenzie Davidson User:GPL93 12:46, 30 March 2019 (UTC) delete Fails . Best Deletion of William Mackenzie Davidson WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10930 4775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Devil Hunter Yohko video games User:Jovanmilic97 00:14, 24 January 2020 (UTC) merge to Devil Hunter Yohko#Video games as an obvious per above. Doesn't serve the navigational purpose as there is only one game with Wiki article (also having questionable notability on it's own), and there aren't many sources that talk about the games to support the list. The section is quite sufficient to cover the subject Deletion of List of Devil Hunter Yohko video games WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
10931 6516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lemon girl User:Metropolitan90 06:51, 5 January 2015 (UTC) delete The article does not indicate that this book is considered notable under Deletion of Lemon girl WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10932 12061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelly's of Cornwall User:Sagaciousphil 12:51, 13 August 2016 (UTC) keep meets the |notability guide; looks as if it's possible to expand about the earlier company history too Deletion of Kelly's of Cornwall WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10933 16444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mo (slang) User:DMacks 18:01, 9 October 2007 (UTC) delete as , , , or |uncited...take your pick Deletion of Mo (slang) WP:NFT||WP:NEO||WP:DICT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
10934 21142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hill Climb Racing (mobile game) User:Supernerd11 18:56, 24 September 2014 (UTC) delete This one only has a ref in Finnish (I don't know Finnish, so I can't vouch either way on its reliability), and the original article's only got a first-party source. Looking around online doesn't show any |RS's, either Deletion of Hill Climb Racing (mobile game) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10935 13482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sajjad Ullah Baqi User:Cowlibob 18:22, 9 May 2015 (UTC) keep wikify to remove promotional tone. Sajjad Ullah meets as a member of the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Assembly one of the four provincial governments of Pakistan as verified by official government source. http://www.pakp.gov.pk/2008/member/pk-61 Deletion of Sajjad Ullah Baqi WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10936 16172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Davies (filmmaker) User:NawlinWiki 21:06, 30 August 2011 (UTC) delete not notable per Deletion of Ryan Davies (filmmaker) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10937 434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eline McGeorge User:Tagishsimon 01:20, 25 March 2017 (UTC) keep I sure there's a google tutorial somewhere. I see https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=Eline+McGeorge page after page after page of results, many from arts magazines ... ten pages of results in and we're getting to the Norwegian press. This is another very very poor AfD. Perhaps another close read of would be helpful Deletion of Eline McGeorge WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
10938 16420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carson DeVries User:ArcAngel 15:18, 14 March 2008 (UTC) delete """Google comes up with a 10 year old under this name from Palatine, IL who ran in a mini-marathon, so the article appears to be a """"wish"""" article, so - fails """ Deletion of Carson DeVries WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10939 14185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmad El Jammal User:Sir 22:29, 2 February 2010 (UTC) delete per previous comments. He fails both , and , meaning there is no grounds for keeping this article Deletion of Ahmad El Jammal WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10940 10163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Harris (professor) User:GreenMeansGo 13:59, 12 August 2020 (UTC) keep Yes, there is a flood of coverage in relation to his daughter. While WP:NOTINHERITED is a thing, it does not mean that coverage in relation to his daughter is entirely left off the balance sheet in deciding |whether we can write a policy compliant article, when combined with unrelated coverage of his own independent work and accomplishments Deletion of Donald Harris (professor) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10941 13406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Hubbard (entrepreneur) User:K 02:24, 14 November 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet ; significant RS coverage not found Deletion of Jack Hubbard (entrepreneur) WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10942 17651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of important publications in mathematics User:Salix 03:58, 2 October 2011 (UTC) keep per , does this article improve the quality of the encyclopaedia: yes in my view. We have a collection of the landmark texts in mathematics, it the past it has some cruft but these have now been weeded out. Yes the article does need some secondary sources but not outright deletion Deletion of List of important publications in mathematics WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
10943 8391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shmuel Auerbach User:RGTraynor 13:44, 2 April 2007 (UTC) delete """fails , for politicians. It would be great if he actually was, but in point of fact his party (Degel HaTorah) has any seats at all in the Knesset only through an electoral alliance with the more prominent United Torah Judaism. Auerbach does not himself sit in the Knesset in either of the two seats assigned to DHT, nor is he listed in DHT's article as any manner of party leader or functionary. Being a junior """"leader"""" of the ''thirteenth'' most important party in Israel doesn't strike me as significant""" Deletion of Shmuel Auerbach WP:ATT||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Attribution 108
10944 2866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Wilbur User:Walter 00:32, 8 September 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and there is no music bio to support the subject's claim to notability, but again, no sources recognize the subject and so we do not need to either Deletion of Josh Wilbur :WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10945 15676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maureen Storey [[User talk:203.171.197.23|talk]]) 03:47, 14 July 2013 (UTC) keep An h-index of 16 is a little low, but the APRE and ABA activities clearly pass #7. The fact that some people view those activities as bad just makes her all the more notable. -- Special:Contributions/203.171.197.23|203.171.197.23 Deletion of Maureen Storey WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10946 19116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Posillico User:GiantSnowman 19:04, 3 October 2010 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Joseph Posillico WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10947 8290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Macrohistorical battles tied to the existence of European civilisation User:Dystopos 19:25, 25 February 2007 (UTC) delete """The terms used in the article title would have to be explained at great length to justify it with respect to and . The concept of the article appears to be controversial in that it assumes a non-problematic """"European civilisation"""" whose existence is threatened by forces from outside. Factual information can easily be merged into more relevant topics""" Deletion of Macrohistorical battles tied to the existence of European civilisation WP:NOR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
10948 17470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Roszak (2nd nomination) User:Piotrus 05:29, 24 August 2020 (UTC) keep I agree that living to a 100+ years is not enough, in itself, to be make a person notable. But it can generate sufficient coverage to make someone pass NBIO. And this person also got the Righteous award. And when you combine those two, it is no surprise to find that there is plenty of coverage out there. Yes, the news sources present in the article are, IMHO, niche Polish portals, but https://sprawiedliwi.org.pl/pl/historie-pomocy/historia-s-cecylii-marii-roszak is a biographical entry at the reliable portal about the Righteous maintained by large and internationally famous museum (the POLIN Museum) and https://righteous.yadvashem.org/?search=roszak%20cecylia&searchType=righteous_only&language=en&itemId=4044117&ind=0 here is a link to her corresponding bio in the Yad Vashem entry. And a simple google search helps to find a lot more coverage (was followed? Seems doubtful...): there was also more coverage of her death in bigger news outlets (one thing to note is that they sometimes user her name Cecylia, as in Cecylia Roszak): https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/sister-cecylia-roszak-obituary-cs6wp3zrg (The Times), https://www.timesofisrael.com/polish-nun-who-helped-hide-vilna-ghetto-rebels-during-holocaust-dies-at-110/ (Times of Israel), https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2018/11/22/sister-cecylia-roszak-polish-nun-dies/2085263002/ (USA Today) , https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/oldest-nun-hide-jews-dies-110-sister-cecylia-roszak-poland-a8644721.html (The Independent), https://www.telegraph.co.uk/obituaries/2018/11/23/sister-cecylia-roszak-polish-nun-honoured-righteous-among-nations/ (The Telegraph), https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/funeral-for-polish-nun-who-rescued-jews-during-holocaust/2018/11/22/c7543464-ee72-11e8-8b47-bd0975fd6199_story.html (Washington Post), and of course Polish (https://www.wprost.pl/kraj/10168893/nie-zyje-siostra-cecylia-roszak-byla-prawdopodobnie-najstarsza-zakonnica-na-swiecie.html - Wprost), https://krakow.wyborcza.pl/krakow/7,44425,24177042,w-krakowie-zmarla-najstarsza-siostra-zakonna-miala-110-lat.html - Gazeta Wyborcza). That's a ton of reliable, first-class sources, and it is not just obituaries, as she had biographies in the Righteous databases long before her death (also there may be some archival news coverage of her receiving the award in 1984). She seems to have been written about in this Polish book https://books.google.co.kr/books?id=lnG0DwAAQBAJ&pg=PT276&dq=%22Maria+Roszak%22+-wikipedia&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjniZX5jrPrAhUT62EKHTiIDyoQ6AEwAXoECAYQAg#v=onepage&q=%22Maria%20Roszak%22%20-wikipedia&f=false but I am not sure if the coverage is extensive (can't access most content) and if the publisher is reliable (through I think I tried looking into it a while ago and did not conclude it wasn't). IMHO it's a clear pass and, sorry to say, for the nominator and the voter above who didn't bother with BEFORE Deletion of Maria Roszak (2nd nomination) WP:BEFORE||WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
10949 13209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philo (Internet television) User:DGG 05:47, 8 December 2016 (UTC) delete Promotionalism is all by itself a reason for deletion. A $20 million internet company is very unlikely to be notable, and in fact, there are no substantial sources. As for Foursquare, see instein. Someone writing an article on a very minor company who thinks it compares it with a leader in the field shows a lack of proportion that typically goes with promotional editing Deletion of Philo (Internet television) WP:E Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
10950 8215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Ann Lutz User:Herostratus 22:40, 6 February 2017 (UTC) delete I think. There is one piece where she is described and even quoted, but it's really just about an election, not her. And that seems to be it, at least as currently in the article. want's ''multiple'' in-depth pieces. Monrovia has 40,000 people so it's not Podunk, but still... not large enough to presume that being mayor is enough, I don't don't think. Falls into the Just Another Accomplished Person category I think Deletion of Mary Ann Lutz WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
10951 13352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam's Law User:FiggyBee 18:40, 19 March 2007 (UTC) delete as Deletion of Adam's Law WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
10952 5066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susan Wands User:Ravenswing 13:54, 30 June 2011 (UTC) delete """The ''NY Times,'' ''Variety'' and ''Playbill'' are certainly reliable sources, but not a single damn source either in the article or in the laundry list posted above discuss Wands in pretty much ''any'' detail, let alone the """"significant detail"""" the GNG requires. Her name is ''mentioned'' in articles mentioning several other actors, and that's about it. Quite aside from the probable issue, the Keep proponents seem bedazzled by """"OMG look, a list of SOURCES!!!!"""" without actually examining those sources to see if they mention the subject in significant detail. I've yet to examine one that does. WP:GNG '''explicitly''' states that a sentence or two constitutes a trivial mention, and few of these sources devote as much as a single sentence to Ms. Wands""" Deletion of Susan Wands WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
10953 13097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of the Hmong in Merced, California User:RightCowLeftCoast 03:18, 12 March 2012 (UTC) keep although the article appears to have sprung up independently, if it were to be merged into Merced, California or Hmong American articles, it would already be large enough to be |spunout into its own separate article per . Furthermore, there are sufficient reliable sources for the subject to pass Deletion of History of the Hmong in Merced, California WP:SPINOUT||WP:TOOLONG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Article size 51
10954 10384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glen At Work User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable. &mdash Deletion of Glen At Work WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10955 12859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmed Mohamed (student) User:Callinus 12:38, 21 September 2015 (UTC) delete WP:BLP1E and . See Zero tolerance (schools)#Media attention - there are other cases similar that this doesn't deserve coverage over, and other places a condensed version of the content can go Deletion of Ahmed Mohamed (student) WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10956 16078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meeting architecture User:Drawn 12:31, 9 June 2009 (UTC) merge to Event planning. It appears to be a but is a likely search term based on G-hits Deletion of Meeting architecture WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10957 20856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Those Days (band) User:FuriouslySerene 16:45, 21 April 2016 (UTC) delete not able to find any coverage of this band. No claim of notability and coverage seems to be insufficient to meet the or Deletion of Those Days (band) WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
10958 619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christianity and the Rwandan Genocide User:Markeer 15:59, 8 August 2007 (UTC) delete for underlying POV and I suspect . The underlying assumption of the article (typified by the title) is that Christianity as a whole bears a responsibility based on the actions of a few members (e.g. the clerics in Rwanda mentioned in the article). As the nom mentions there is a section of the main article addressing Christianity, this article would be redundant even if it weren't of extremely questionable POV Deletion of Christianity and the Rwandan Genocide WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
10959 817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesse La Flair User:Theroadislong 09:22, 1 March 2013 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Jesse La Flair WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10960 2934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sri Parthasarathy Rajagopal Chari User:Ultraexactzz 17:40, 19 October 2007 (UTC) delete I'm forced to agree that the article has violations severe enough to warrant deletion. No objection to the recreation of a properly sourced, neutral article that avoids such problems Deletion of Sri Parthasarathy Rajagopal Chari WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10961 3710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donnie Davies (3rd nomination) User:danntm 21:45, 2 February 2007 (UTC) keep a well-known Internet phenom covered with eight citations. To try to distinguish away all the citations will do violence to Deletion of Donnie Davies (3rd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10962 13370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Get Him to the Greek User:Steve 13:41, 1 July 2008 (UTC) delete The |notability guidelines for future films stipulate that a stand-alone article for a film should not be created until a project enters production. This is because many factors such as budget issues, scripting issues, and casting issues can interfere with the project. This project is a prime example of this; Apatow is attached to about 600 projects. The article can be recreated when principal photography is confirmed to have begun Deletion of Get Him to the Greek WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
10963 8353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hek Ki Boen Eng Chun Kungfu User:Papaursa 19:05, 6 June 2012 (UTC) delete This article reads like a debate without any supported facts (he said/she said). I didn't find significant coverage in independent sources nor did I find evidence to show it meets the notability criteria of Deletion of Hek Ki Boen Eng Chun Kungfu WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
10964 20664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lyle Roebuck User:Agricola44 15:47, 3 May 2011 (UTC) delete """This article seems to be not much more than a recitation of awards that the subject ''didn't'' win (but claims he was a """"finalist"""" for). Article claims he is a writer, but he seems to be a high-school teacher at Elgin Academy (Elgin, Illinois)|Elgin Academy. Moreover, I can't actually find anything he's written. For example, WorldCat does ''not'' seem to be aware of http://www.worldcat.org/search?qt=affiliate&ai=Washington_cmanton&q=Ovid%27s+Heroides+with+Notes+and+Vocabulary&wcsbtn2w.x=63&wcsbtn2w.y=10 'Ovid's Heroides with Notes and Vocabulary' (so that's probably """"self published"""") and WoS shows no scholarly contributions. Article was created by now-blocked- Special:Contributions/Uofcboi|Uofcboi and has been heavily serviced by Special:Contributions/Ltroebuck|Ltroebuck and several Special:Contributions/75.57.145.133|anons like this one, all of which Geolocate shows to be in the same locality as Roebuck. Consequently, it's likely that this is little more than a vanity or fan page. Uncontroversial delete. Thx""" Deletion of Lyle Roebuck WP:SPA||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
10965 9593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CAFOD User:Fuebaey 03:17, 1 August 2015 (UTC) keep Meets . Along with Christian Aid and Tearfund, CAFOD is one of a number of Christian charities discussed for GCSE Religious Studies in the UK (https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/403357/GCSE_RS_final_120215.pdf see page 12). As such, there are quite a few study books describing its work: https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=I4AVbUIIygQC&pg=PA90&dq=cafod&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CCkQ6AEwAWoVChMIhIfL-eiGxwIVSlnbCh0YAASY#v=onepage&q=cafod&f=falsehttps://books.google.co.uk/books?id=mPlr0J7kJagC&pg=PT33&dq=cafod&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CE4Q6AEwCWoVChMIhIfL-eiGxwIVSlnbCh0YAASY#v=onepage&q=cafod&f=falsehttps://books.google.co.uk/books?id=Dxq_ZiHVAIYC&pg=PT140&dq=cafod&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CD4Q6AEwBmoVChMIl6PN9eiGxwIVCyDbCh0pJANR#v=onepage&q=cafod&f=false. Alternatively, there is a chapter in https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=dLqLdhJo1U4C&pg=PA3&dq=CAFOD&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CD8Q6AEwBTgeahUKEwiFrdrD8IbHAhWSB9sKHW56AW0#v=onepage&q=CAFOD&f=false this book (p3-6) analysing its activities and also a section in https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=43HOUw9_qvIC&pg=PA172&dq=CAFOD&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CDcQ6AEwBjgUahUKEwiCg6e774bHAhVyR9sKHSpiBpc#v=onepage&q=CAFOD&f=false this book (p172-175) detailing its role in East Timor Deletion of CAFOD WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10966 16449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ImDisk User:Snottywong 16:21, 7 July 2011 (UTC) delete Fails . Obviously someone trying to promote their own product/company Deletion of ImDisk WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10967 2692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Kerruish User:Crystallizedcarbon 21:06, 9 February 2020 (UTC) keep Does Meet as there is non-trivial coverage by multiple reliable sources Deletion of Sarah Kerruish WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10968 10786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philosophical Investigations (wiki) User:Wikipeterproject 20:39, 15 February 2010 (UTC) delete """Fails the notability criteria of , which sets out what is needed for a website to be considered notable. In short, the policy requires the website's content to have been """"''the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself...''"""" The policy specifically mentions that press releases, advertising and newspaper articles that merely mention the website are not considered """"non-trivial"""". Social networking sites and blogs are not """"published works"""". If the website hasn't been subject of such published works, it can still be notable if it a) has won a notable award or b) it is distributed by a respected, independent medium independent of its creators. Social networking sites and blogs are specifically excluded from the last criteria. This website does not pass come close to meeting any of the three notability limbs of """ Deletion of Philosophical Investigations (wiki) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
10969 18183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Five Mountains User:Cbs527 02:44, 15 November 2016 (UTC) delete Fails otability Reads like an advertisement. Appears that article creator is connected in some way to subject. Zero sufficient coverage from any media source Deletion of The Five Mountains WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10970 1560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Funstead User:HisSpaceResearch 18:34, 28 October 2007 (UTC) delete WP:NOT#DICT, , Deletion of Funstead WP:V||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
10971 21110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of RTC Transit routes User:Charlesdrakew 08:44, 25 April 2014 (UTC) delete per , and per Mangoe Deletion of List of RTC Transit routes WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10972 1504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 IBSA World Blind Football Championship User:Thine 18:38, 13 September 2015 (UTC) keep Large amounts of coverage and meets easily Deletion of 2010 IBSA World Blind Football Championship WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10973 3233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Epileptic Gaming (2nd nomination) User:Tivedshambo 21:24, 31 March 2009 (UTC) comment but feel it fair to point out that the nominator is also a |single purpose account — Deletion of Epileptic Gaming (2nd nomination) WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
10974 4671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of commercial goods allowed/banned for import into Gaza User:Tarc 11:02, 3 July 2010 (UTC) comment This is about due for a close today, and I;d like to urge the closer to look at whether or not reliable sources confer notability on the specific list of goods or is the notability conferred on the general fact that there is an import/export ban. Many of the keep calls see no difference between the two. I feel it is the later, and note the analogy to the US' Cuban embargo above; the embargo is notable, and examples of what is banned are cited by RS in support of that notability, but to put an exhausting list of what ''is'' banned is clear-cut IMO. We are not a repository for spreadsheets, and the full laundry list of info could either be accessible via an external link or perhaps if it is published by an NGO, it can go to wikisource Deletion of List of commercial goods allowed/banned for import into Gaza WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10975 1033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas & Friends Candy Train Models User:Icarus3 05:03, 18 July 2007 (UTC) delete per nom, and also because Wikipedia is |not an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of Thomas & Friends Candy Train Models WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10976 15141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grasshopper (company) User:Ihcoyc 22:27, 4 February 2012 (UTC) delete This is a phone answering service business, |one of many such businesses. They got a story in the Wall Street Journal about a promotional stunt involving chocolate covered grasshoppers. They got their startup covered in the Boston Globe, which is their local paper. I don't see either of these things as being the |significant effects on history, culture, or technology that would turn this business into an encyclopedia subject. This article also appears to be only about the phone service, and the promoters apparently operate several separate businesses under the Grasshopper brand. We certainly don't need separate articles about each of them Deletion of Grasshopper (company) WP:MILL||WP:ORGIN Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
10977 12485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World of Warcraft Professions User:Themfromspace 15:29, 13 March 2009 (UTC) delete Per above. applies pretty well to this article as a whole, as well as Deletion of World of Warcraft Professions WP:GAMEGUIDE||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10978 18234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nessesidy User:FreelanceWizard 02:28, 6 August 2006 (UTC) delete """By the article's creator this comic doesn't exist anywhere on the web. """"No profit is made from Nessesidy and it is not displayed anywhere else therefor this is not a promotion nor a webcomic."""" In fact, it seems like this is |original comicbookery wherein the article's creator is using Wikipedia as something akin to a free web host. It's non-notable, |original research (uh, sort of), and |unverifiable""" Deletion of Nessesidy WP:OR||WP:OR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
10979 8027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robbie's IMDb Celebrity Big Brother 3 User:Darth 08:01, 31 July 2008 (UTC) delete per all the reasons above, fails so many standards. , and just to name a few Deletion of Robbie's IMDb Celebrity Big Brother 3 WP:OR||WP:WEB||WP:N Wikipedia:No original research 65
10980 11612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Root Souljah User:Tree 01:32, 1 July 2006 (UTC) delete per nom; fails and ; 73 Google results http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Root+Souljah%22&btnG=Google+Search Deletion of Root Souljah WP:BIO||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
10981 18585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Modern empires' loss of European territory User:Jimmy 20:34, 25 September 2010 (UTC) delete """The content of the list is already covered, in more detail and more accurately, at List of sovereign states in Europe by date of achieving sovereignty. This present list is redundant, misleading and over-simplifies some very complicated historical processes (eg formation of the United Kingdom -- to reduce this to the """"unification of England"""" in 927 is fatuous). Per the original nom, there are issues about and """ Deletion of Modern empires' loss of European territory WP:OR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
10982 158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thanksgivukkah User:Reywas92 10:33, 14 October 2013 (UTC) delete """Another awful that has no long-term notability. References in do not make it a notable topic. You have got to be kidding me if you think a made-up portmanteau for a one-time coincidence is a """"singular cultural phenomenon"""", even if buzzfeed made a list about it. The has no short- or long-term impact, even if the hyperactive media has mentioned a meaningless coincidence. As Shinmawa pointed out, CRIT makes it clear that routine water cooler talk is not notable""" Deletion of Thanksgivukkah WP:NEOLOGISM||WP:NEWS||WP:EVENT||WP:EVENTCRIT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
10983 6224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pamela Northam User:E 22:20, 23 February 2018 (UTC) delete """Spouse of an American governor is not automatically notable (spouse of a President is.) And although many First Ladies and Gentlemen of American States have articles :Category:First Ladies of Virginia, their notability has to be supported by , my searches http://www.nbc12.com/story/37210117/meet-virginias-new-first-lady-pam-northam show very little for coverage of Pamela Northam. See: ''""""The fact of having a famous relative is not, in and of itself, sufficient to justify an independent article. Individuals in close, personal relationships with famous people (including politicians) can have an independent article even if they are known solely for such a relationship, but only if they pass WP:GNG""" Deletion of Pamela Northam WP:SIGCOV||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
10984 21085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marlena Starr Kovacevich User:Ijanderson977 22:53, 27 January 2009 (UTC) delete because it fails Deletion of Marlena Starr Kovacevich WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10985 7655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phil Nickson User:Edison 20:57, 12 June 2007 (UTC) delete """A man, not otherwise notable, was hit in the head and killed by an unknown person in 1985. That does not make an encyclopedia article. Per """"The fact that someone or something has been in the news for a brief period of time does not automatically justify an encyclopedia article""" Deletion of Phil Nickson WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10986 18464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dulam Satyanarayana User:D4iNa4 13:02, 9 November 2017 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON and suspicious creation. Only pages that are dedicated to him or his activities are social media sites that are not Deletion of Dulam Satyanarayana WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
10987 10627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sekou Odinga (2nd nomination) User:Niteshift36 04:27, 18 June 2009 (UTC) delete per /CA. I don't see the persistent coverage shown under that standard. Later coverage wasn't about the crime, but more about people trying to free him. The most notable thing he did was commit a crime....and it doesn't qualify him Deletion of Sekou Odinga (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
10988 6588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of abandoned highways in the United States User:Fredddie 18:47, 12 December 2018 (UTC) delete """If the """"unused"""" portions of each highway are worth mentioning at all, which I don't think they are, they should be listed on each highway's respective article. At best, they are """ Deletion of List of abandoned highways in the United States WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
10989 7002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Accusations of rape against United States presidents (second nomination) User:23skidoo 21:23, 20 March 2007 (UTC) delete I don't think this is necessary. Any notable -- and verifiable -- information would already be covered in the applicable biographical articles, and I have concerns regarding the sections about living presidents Deletion of Accusations of rape against United States presidents (second nomination) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
10990 5531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reds Bagnell NONE 16:27, 23 June 2021 (UTC) keep clearly passes and . Nominator references but that's the other kind of football and doesn't apply Deletion of Reds Bagnell WP:GNG||WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
10991 17873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeremy Ryan User:LenyTee55 00:26, 16 August 2018 (UTC) keep I would acknowledge that his political notability passes off as a very minor one and could grow but he is very notable as a frequent protester in the Madison, Wisconsin. The news articles about him cannot be said to be trivial or entirely about his criminal records as most of those articles are wholesomely reliable secondary sources that were specifically written independent of him and some were completely about him not just trivial mentions. He was significantly involved in protests that led to the upturning of the rule that prohibited the holding of signs in the rotunda in Madison, Wisconsin, which has significant coverage in various reliable news sources. Moreover, this article I think does not violate what EVERYTHING. As per the issue of Cells R' Us, I agree with you on that and it has been removed as that is an unfounded assertion that cannot be verified at the moment Deletion of Jeremy Ryan WP:GNG||WP:NOT||WP:NOTEVERYTHING Wikipedia:Notability 77
10992 1081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oldest living United States president [[user talk:sottolacqua|talk]]) 15:40, 2 July 2011 (UTC) delete per #STATS Sottolacqua Deletion of Oldest living United States president WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
10993 19734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of breweries in South Carolina User:Ellin 17:00, 21 January 2014 (UTC) keep """Per , lists may contain nonnotable entries; in fact - they may be set up to contain nothing but non-notable entries. These lists are valid for navigation. More reliable sources can be sought, merely place the correct """"citation needed"""" tags on the page and one of the citation finders will pop over and fix it. I updated parts of several of these lists including List of breweries in California. It was not hard and I learned that beer brewing is one of the largest non-durable industries in the U.S. and growing at a rate of up to 20% per year. Therefore I think the entire topic is relevant. I have worked on many lists in Wiki before and never encountered this sort of situation because does not demand citations on each line and states that a list may contain non-notable entries""" Deletion of List of breweries in South Carolina WP:CSC||WP:CSC Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
10994 17798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Babm User:XDanielx 23:44, 8 August 2007 (UTC) keep """I'm not convinced that """"All attempts to find reliable sources in which article information can be verified have failed"""" (). Languages are generally notable, unless there's very good reason to believe otherwise. It's a very decent stub, work has been put into it, and it's certainly more helpful to readers than a """"this article has been deleted"""" message. When it doubt, keep""" Deletion of Babm WP:DP Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
10995 536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nil Eryılmaz User:Papaursa 03:02, 22 August 2017 (UTC) delete Does not meet or . Routine sports coverage (which is all that is provided) is insufficient to meet Deletion of Nil Eryılmaz WP:NHOCKEY||WP:NSPORTS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
10996 21869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cordectomy User:Ultraexactzz 18:47, 3 January 2008 (UTC) keep per . There is enough material to expand this article Deletion of Cordectomy WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
10997 13599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin G. Summers User:Dhartung 22:29, 7 April 2008 (UTC) delete while he has been in Star Trek anthologies, there is no evidence any of his works satisfy Deletion of Kevin G. Summers WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
10998 6119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dreadful User:Edison 14:17, 25 June 2007 (UTC) delete """We have references (though not ones satisfying which claim that railfans in a given country yell """"My lordz its dreadful"""" (or at least that one called Wellington (apparently not Arthur Wellesley, 1st Duke of Wellington) did so once) when they are enjoying looking at a train. First, Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary. Second Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up in school one day seems to apply here, although the fans are not identified as schoolboys. A small group made up a word or word usage which lacks currency in general use. Same thing. Last, #INFO|Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information""" Deletion of Dreadful WP:A||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
10999 14417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmed Adams User:BDD 22:20, 13 May 2013 (UTC) keep Passes , though I note this was not demonstrated at the time of nomination Deletion of Ahmed Adams WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
11000 5210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Same-sex marriage and procreation User:Verdatum 17:52, 13 February 2008 (UTC) delete I fail to see why information on this topic cannot be in Same-sex marriage; it does not follow , nor is it even linked to by the obvious parent article. appears to be an essay and I can't think of any way to fix it Deletion of Same-sex marriage and procreation WP:SUMMARY Wikipedia:Summary style 34
11001 14164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yosef Adler User:Agricola44 16:16, 28 February 2011 (UTC) delete A person holding said positions (high-school principal, congregational leader) is not notable ''per se'' and there are no additional assertions of notability. Only support is two webpages, which are not . Respectfully Deletion of Yosef Adler WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11002 3738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global Garrison High School User:Operator873 02:44, 8 December 2017 (UTC) delete Fails ... Secondary schools have precedent to be included so long as their existence can be verified... which can't be accomplished with this one Deletion of Global Garrison High School WP:VERIFY Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11003 13509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nigel Hipster User:The 17:21, 15 January 2007 (UTC) delete as Deletion of Nigel Hipster WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11004 7798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KredX User:HighKing 14:06, 31 January 2018 (UTC) delete No indications of notability, a run-of-the-mill company, topic fails GNG and Deletion of KredX WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11005 185 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Atiker Yazılım Kullanıcı:dr. coaldr. coal 14.46, 9 Mart 2020 (UTC) delete """Maddeye hızlıca bir bakıldığında dahi """"Türkiye’de yerli üretici olarak Android ve IOS üzerinde ERP çalıştıran ilk ve tek ana ürün geliştirici yazılım firması"""" ifadesinin '''kalın''' yazıyla vurgulanmış olması, reklam kastını açıkça ortaya koyuyor. Reklama yönelik ifadeler çıkarıldığında maddede kayda değer bir bilgi kalmayacağından ötürü, #Not:_Reklam_ve_promosyon|ilgili yönergeye göre hızlı silinebilir. Anılan firma ve bağlı kuruluşların buradaki tanıtım faaliyetleri üzerine ayrıca bir inceleme de yapmak gerekir""" Atiker Yazılım'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
11006 16110 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aja Watkins a.k.a """"Beautiful""""""" User:Kicking222 03:03, 21 December 2006 (UTC) delete """Fails ; obvious |COI; only 26 unique and 42 total Google hits for """"Aja Watkins""" """Deletion of Aja Watkins a.k.a """"Beautiful""""""" WP:BIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
11007 2994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sofitel Chicago Magnificent Mile user:Andrew 11:49, 17 November 2020 (UTC) keep """WP:Run-of-the-mill is an |essay and """"''Essays have no official status, and do not speak for the Wikipedia community""" Deletion of Sofitel Chicago Magnificent Mile WP:ESSAY Wikipedia:Essays 31
11008 6004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Hussey User:Carioca 21:16, 17 October 2009 (UTC) delete Non-notable player, fails and Deletion of Chris Hussey WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11009 10419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UPS Airlines Flight 1354 User:Mjroots 12:06, 2 October 2013 (UTC) keep The fact that the aircraft was on a cargo flight does not, IMHO, reduce the notability of this accident. Whilst a large number of deaths adds weight to the case for notability, a low number or lack of deaths does not necessarily detract from the case. Percentage-wise, this was a 100% fatality rate. Per precedent, hull loss accidents generally are notable enough to sustain articles subject to via Deletion of UPS Airlines Flight 1354 WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11010 20765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chester Stone User:Citing 23:15, 13 May 2021 (UTC) delete Not enough coverage from |independent reliable sources to meet |verifiability standards. Follower counts are not reliable metrics of anything. I'd also ask the nominator |not to bite the newbies Deletion of Chester Stone WP:RS||WP:V||WP:BITE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11011 16885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lubeidak User:MichaelQSchmidt 05:42, 10 April 2016 (UTC) keep After learning that this pre-internet film won multiple Kerala State Film Award|State Film Awards (a decent assertion of notability), I decided to give the thing https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Lubeidak&type=revision&diff=714507472&oldid=714435059 a face-lift under MOS:FILM . While difficult |to find, sources are available... so this will benefit from editorial attention, not deletion Deletion of Lubeidak WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
11012 8126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blue Lakes Mall User:Edison 23:18, 31 December 2007 (UTC) comment I don't know whether this mall satisfies our |notability standards such as but the comment that it no longer exists implies that notability is temporary, which is not in accord with the policy on notability . We do not delete articles on buildings, organizations, people, or other entities because they no longer exist, if they were ever notable Deletion of Blue Lakes Mall WP:N||WP:ORG||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11013 18109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akatsuki Daze User:AnmaFinotera 00:11, 24 January 2009 (UTC) delete G11 - pure self-advertisement for some stuff that likely violates as well Deletion of Akatsuki Daze WP:MADEUP||WP:COPYRIGHT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
11014 5245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayra Rivera User:Tsistunagiska 20:47, 22 January 2021 (UTC) keep Can't argue here. Apparently is the only guideline which a person can completely fail the basic litmus test for notability to be included and yet still be notable just because they are a member of academia. Must be nice to not have to be held to higher standards than this. Significant coverage be damned. Is that a primary source? Meh, who cares, they are a professor, scholar or and a member of the superior caste of academia Deletion of Mayra Rivera WP:PROF||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11015 18161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Movana Chen User:Piotrus 06:18, 4 November 2014 (UTC) delete Based almost entirely on self-published sources, fails as written. The SCMP mention that Nlu refers to is not even in the article itself Deletion of Movana Chen WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
11016 16408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agha Waqar's Water Fuelled Car User:DBigXray 12:59, 8 August 2012 (UTC) delete per and . Agree with Nom this is just a hoax by a Pakistani Quack. Amusingly the Pakistani Scientific community is still unable to expose the misdeeds of this quack. On a side note I am anxiously waiting for a water-Powered Al-Khalid tank.http://dawn.com/2012/08/03/bad-science/ Pity the sorry state of affairs Deletion of Agha Waqar's Water Fuelled Car WP:10YT||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:Recentism 10
11017 9231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pets Reunited Online User:Kinu 03:37, 2 August 2006 (UTC) delete fails , no to indicate notability Deletion of Pets Reunited Online WP:WEB||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11018 20900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nate Rothacker User:Yappy2bhere 09:02, 25 March 2021 (UTC) delete """fails , fails . I don't think a redirect is appropriate. Trainwreck (band)|Trainwreck was a """"side project of a side project"""" of Jack Black fronted by an """"almost famous actor"""" backed by """"whatever guys could form a rhythm section in any given city in which a show was scheduled."""" https://www.redlandsdailyfacts.com/2010/07/08/kyle-gass-has-fun-as-tenacious-sideman/https://www.pressreader.com/usa/the-columbus-dispatch/20070208/282355445274439 No one's coming to WP looking for the drummer. They're finding the drummer because he's linked from Trainwreck. (And probably finding Trainwreck Tenacious D|the Tenacious D (TV series)|same Jack Black|way.) |Redirects are used to help people arrive more quickly at the page they want to read. A redirect here won't do that""" Deletion of Nate Rothacker WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:R Wikipedia:Notability 77
11019 10383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laure Killing User:RebeccaGreen 11:46, 27 November 2019 (UTC) keep She meets , with significant roles in multiple notable productions, including the TV shows ''Paris enquêtes criminelles'' and ''Tomorrow is Ours'', and film ''The Teddy Bear'', among others. There are certainly other obituaries which could be added as sources, as well as older sources which confirm her roles in things like ''{{ill|Une femme en blanc|fr}}'' https://books.google.com.au/books?id=P15tyiOSRz0C&pg=PA147&dq=%22Laure+Killing%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi_vp3ro4rmAhXGeisKHffeCecQ6AEIKTAA#v=onepage&q=%22Laure%20Killing%22&f=false; ''Écrans de Sable'' / {{ill|Écrans de sable|fr}} (different Wikidata numbers, unfortunately) https://books.google.com.au/books?id=yv1BH5Wz-ekC&pg=PA151&dq=%22Laure+Killing%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi_vp3ro4rmAhXGeisKHffeCecQ6AEIMjAB#v=onepage&q=%22Laure%20Killing%22&f=false, etc. I agree with {{u|scope_creep}} that there would be more coverage in French media from the late 1980s on, which could be added by anyone with access to it Deletion of Laure Killing WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
11020 7940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Traylude User:Richard3120 14:18, 23 April 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and . Contributed to some tracks on a 1998 album as a hired vocalist, and doesn't seem to have been active in music since then Deletion of Traylude WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11021 17065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Otherwize User:Walton_monarchist89 10:06, 23 March 2007 (UTC) delete unsourced, so no evidence of multiple non-trivial coverage in independent sources to establish notability per . Delete unless sourced by the end of this AfD Deletion of Otherwize WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11022 5621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ximena Zamora User:Bri 18:37, 10 November 2020 (UTC) delete clearly this was meant to be included by the !voters in the prior two AfDs. If the closer needs a clear policy-based reason, it is Deletion of Ximena Zamora WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11023 15156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Hankins User:NeoFreak 18:25, 27 November 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and . Only on wikipedia Deletion of David Hankins WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11024 15268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Memecoin User:LFaraone 03:53, 30 May 2013 (UTC) delete None of the mentioned actually talk about memecoin; the rest are either non- or aren't significant coverage Deletion of Memecoin WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11025 16585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skoosh (2nd nomination) User:Ushau97 16:49, 20 April 2013 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Skoosh (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11026 1603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Company of Heroes: Eastern Front User:Joe 16:49, 2 January 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this video game mod Deletion of Company of Heroes: Eastern Front WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11027 8868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Montaylah cheng User:Matt 04:08, 15 February 2009 (UTC) delete G3 - |hoax. You'd think after nude pictures of her are apparently circulating the internet there'd be at least a handful of non-Wikipedia Google results Deletion of Montaylah cheng WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
11028 18677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frederic Wehrey [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] 19:09, 25 January 2015 (UTC) keep I believe the subject is notable under . He has been cited by http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/middle-east-instability-a-test-for-relations-between-obama-and-new-saudi-leader/2015/01/24/ab634d10-a40e-11e4-b146-577832eafcb4_story.html ''Washington Post'', http://foreignpolicy.com/2013/12/31/the-middle-east-channels-best-of-2013/ ''Foreign Policy'', http://time.com/3642616/libya-oil-egypt-tobruk-tripoli/ ''Time'', http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Foreign-Policy/2015/0123/Despite-new-king-US-Saudi-relations-likely-to-see-more-continuity-than-change-video ''Christian Science Monitor'', http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/24/world/middleeast/king-abdullah-saudi-arabia-funeral.html?_r=0 ''New York Times'', and quite a few other notable publications Deletion of Frederic Wehrey WP:SCHOLAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
11029 19390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mordecai Tendler (2nd nomination) User:Ukexpat 15:18, 1 April 2011 (UTC) delete clear Deletion of Mordecai Tendler (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11030 10150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Child Support Policy User:DanielEng 09:02, 25 October 2007 (UTC) delete or '''Redirect.''' User has (has published anti-child support articles online) and has attempted on several occasions to advance his own (factually inaccurate) viewpoint on other child support pages. Material on this page is rejected stuff that he tried to introduce to the Child support article. Sourced pages on child support issues already exist on Wiki and these are unnecessary Deletion of Child Support Policy WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
11031 15024 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beijing Spring (90's """"soft rock"""" band)""" User:Realkyhick 08:04, 30 August 2007 (UTC) delete Promotional, no sources, fails badly """Deletion of Beijing Spring (90's """"soft rock"""" band)""" WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11032 7728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GAPS Diet User:Jytdog 17:56, 15 December 2013 (UTC) delete This is health related content; I searched and there is no discussion of this in articles indexed by pubmed. As per there are no reliable or notable sources upon which to base an article Deletion of GAPS Diet WP:MEDRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11033 2962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Semen fetishism User:Eqdoktor 08:50, 15 January 2007 (UTC) merge into Bukkake if |ref sources are found, '''Delete''' as |original research if not Deletion of Semen fetishism WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11034 21916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/9/9/99 User:wknight94 02:31, 9 September 2006 (UTC) delete Unreferenced and sounds like violation Deletion of 9/9/99 WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11035 13650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdul Hakeem Bin Abdul Halim User:Isotope23 20:39, 15 February 2006 (UTC) delete per unless I'm completely off base and track is enormously popular in Singapore... Too bad these couldn't have all been combined Deletion of Abdul Hakeem Bin Abdul Halim WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11036 384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nobody's Angel (Lindsay Lohan Album) User:Stifle 17:35, 14 October 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Nobody's Angel (Lindsay Lohan Album) WP:CBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11037 9669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacqueline Silva User:Shoessss 19:33, 12 July 2018 (UTC) keep More than meets the requirements under as shown here with a quick Google News search https://www.google.com/search?biw=1745&bih=849&tbm=nws&ei=JapHW_7bAcib_QamjpqgDQ&q=%22Jacqueline+Silva%22+surfer&oq=%22Jacqueline+Silva%22+surfer&gs_l=psy-ab.3...428677.433518.0.434635.10.10.0.0.0.0.439.1645.0j7j1j0j1.9.0....0...1c.1.64.psy-ab..1.0.0....0.rGQM2G9BaGA Deletion of Jacqueline Silva WP:SPORTBASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11038 12913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cultural Vibe User:Accounting4Taste 03:55, 20 January 2008 (UTC) delete I read this carefully and it seems that the only |notability is from remixing a piece of music which has some small notability for having been used in a video game -- the piece of music, but NOT the remixes. Anyway, no |reliable sources for the assertions Deletion of Cultural Vibe WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11039 14765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Janette Geri User:Lankiveil 03:23, 22 December 2007 (UTC) keep meets criteria 11 of through rotation on ABC Radio National. The lack of Google sources is probably explained by the fact that she was big before the Internet came around, and also occupies a rather niche sub-genre Deletion of Janette Geri WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11040 9500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TVARK User:Redvers 13:57, 6 May 2009 (UTC) delete failure to pass standards, barely scrapes #A7 Deletion of TVARK WP:N||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Notability 77
11041 4968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ongiara (ship, 1885) User:Geo 13:24, 19 June 2012 (UTC) keep """I started this article, and a bunch of other articles on ships. No one ever challenges whether we should cover Naval vessels, coast guard vessels, research vessels, because, I suggest, maritime vessels are ''different'' from the vehicles the advice in the essay otability (vehicles) is aimed at. Some years ago I attended a conference where a speaker gave a surprisingly interesting and memorable talk on what we could learn about life in the middle ages from the extensive notes kept by the torture teams employed by the Roman Catholic Church's inquisition. The most memorable point he made is that historians have many mysteries about peoples' lives in the past because certain kinds of information seemed ''""""common knowledge""""'' -- and there was a tendency to not record what was considered ''""""common knowledge""""''. There is the same tendency today to not record ''""""common knowledge""""''. His final point about the inquisition, was that the inquisition's clerks' detailed recording of every tortured confession back then actually answered a lot of historian's questions. I suggest there is a class of topics, that we should cover, even if they seem ''""""common knowledge""""''. Topics that seem """"common knowledge"""", are worth covering, when we have good, reliable sources, because """"common knowledge"""" can be wrong, because this is a world-wide project, and what seems obvious to locals is opaque to readers in ohter parts of the world. Because When we rely on important infrastructure, like ships, ports, railways, airports, rapid transit, expressways, I suggest they are worth covering here, even if nothing out of the ordinary happened, provided we have reliable sources. I suggest even the normal functioning of important infrastructure is worth covering. The advice in the otability (vehicles), in so far as it has value, is addressed to artifacts that are (1) essentially identical to all the others in their class; (2) undertake essentially identical missions to all those in their class; (3) often they undertake routine tasks with other artifacts in their class -- fighter aircraft fly in squadrons; freight trains require multiple locomotives per train; buses keep schedules with other identical buses. An argument can be made that there is no value in individual vehicles, like this, even if they are expensive, because their missions are generally routine and repetitive. Ships aren't like that. Patrol vessels get called upon to perform unscheduled rescues, freighters may go to different ports, on each voyage, because they carry different cargos. Even ships like the Ongiara, which spent most of her working life on one mission, can't adequately be covered in a list article on river ferries, as each river is different""" Deletion of Ongiara (ship, 1885) WP:N||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11042 19007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/G. V. Vijayagovindan User:Æåm 10:14, 4 November 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. Clearly fails , and . No references Deletion of G. V. Vijayagovindan WP:N||WP:BIO||WP:VANITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
11043 1038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zoids Restoration User:Kunzite 21:57, 23 December 2006 (UTC) delete How to manuals do ||not belong on Wikipedia. The author should try Wikibooks Deletion of Zoids Restoration WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11044 10528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jess Dunsdon User:JamesBurns 07:09, 21 December 2008 (UTC) delete no independent 3rd party sources, non-notable Deletion of Jess Dunsdon WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11045 10124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sabah Lawson User:Strike 13:52, 14 January 2015 (UTC) delete Fails GNG and as he hasn't played any professional match yet. No international caps as well Deletion of Sabah Lawson WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11046 1381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noynoying User:RightCowLeftCoast 20:51, 24 March 2012 (UTC) merge to Benigno Aquino III. Although the subject has received some media coverage perhaps it is for the subject to pass . In the mean time the article can be summarized, created into a section regarding the present President of the Philippines|President of the Fifth Republic of the Philippines; if it later gets too large and the article reaches 100K per it can be |spun out, or if it does pass & later the redirect can be recreated as an article again Deletion of Noynoying WP:TOOSOON||WP:EFFECT||WP:TOOLONG||WP:SPINOUT||WP:GNG||WP:EVENT||WP:EFFECT Wikipedia:Too soon 40
11047 3082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacob Anthony Matthews User:Bearian 00:58, 15 April 2020 (UTC) delete per {{U|Caro7200}}, , and . No evidence of making it as a musician. Rappers are supposed to collaborate with DJs, etc. He seems very run of the mill. He should have gone to college like Christopher Reid Deletion of Jacob Anthony Matthews WP:MUSICBIO||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11048 1011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Indonesia Forum User:Crisco 10:08, 18 April 2016 (UTC) keep """as article writer. Yes, I have a declared COI with the IIF. I have noted this on the talk page. There are numerous secondary sources cited, including a highly negative review of a book published by the forum (if this were meant for promotion, I would not include that, now would I?). Notability is shown. And a """"|hoax""""? Really? Did you even check the sources? — """ Deletion of International Indonesia Forum WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
11049 6759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of YouTubers (3rd nomination) User:LaundryPizza03 20:36, 29 April 2018 (UTC) delete I don’t see many unlinked/redlinked entries, but the list is very long and addition of non-notable YouTubers seems likely. Neither of the previous nominations mentioned or the category Deletion of List of YouTubers (3rd nomination) WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11050 2532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Confession (band) User:Schuym1 00:07, 20 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Confession (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11051 5574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Logan Martinez User:Bearcat 15:56, 4 March 2021 (UTC) delete As always, people do not get Wikipedia articles just for standing as candidates in elections they did not win — to actually get a Wikipedia article, he would have to either (a) show that he had preexisting notability for other reasons, ''independently'' of the candidacy, that would already have gotten him into Wikipedia ''anyway'', or (b) show a credible and well-sourced reason why his candidacy should be deemed much ''more'' significant than most other people's candidacies, in some way that would pass the |ten year test for enduring significance. This demonstrates neither of those Deletion of Logan Martinez WP:10YT Wikipedia:Recentism 10
11052 18066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Restore All Things in Christ Party User:MuZemike 08:49, 9 November 2008 (UTC) delete there seems to be an apparent |conflict of interest with the user in question regarding this topic. In either case, I only see one source from a newspaper regarding anything about him. The |general notability guideline requires multiple |reliable sources independent of the topic. All other sources I see from doing a basic Google search indicates no other nontrivial references Deletion of Restore All Things in Christ Party WP:COI||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
11053 9629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shweta Bajpai User:Spiderone 19:06, 9 December 2020 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Shweta Bajpai WP:NACTOR||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11054 20886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myles Jeffrey User:Bearian 20:48, 1 May 2020 (UTC) delete per and - his roles are too small; for example, he voiced a chimp in the ''Babe'' sequel Deletion of Myles Jeffrey WP:NACTOR||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11055 9430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trinidad and Tobago 2–1 United States (2018 FIFA World Cup qualification) User:SounderBruce 23:41, 16 October 2019 (UTC) keep The article doesn't do a good job of examining the |lasting impact of the event, which was the canary in the coal mine for U.S. Soccer. Within two years, the entire organization has changed (new managers, new executives, unseating the decade-long tenure of the USSF president) and the match is still used as a comparison, for example https://www.espn.com/soccer/united-states-usa/story/3966028/berhalters-us-in-crisis-following-trinidad-esque-defeat-to-canada this article comparing it to another humiliating defeat last night Deletion of Trinidad and Tobago 2–1 United States (2018 FIFA World Cup qualification) WP:LASTING Wikipedia:Notability 77
11056 913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Purple Pussy User:Dragonfiend 09:39, 4 January 2007 (UTC) delete """fails pretty much all of our content policies and guidelines. an internet guide and this is all original research with no reliable sources, let alone enough sources to write from NPOV. We can't keep an article that fails all of our official content policies by trying to stretch the notability guideline. Notability is what we turn to to decide whether neutral, verifiable articles are on topics important enough to cover. It is not the backdoor to writing original research on """"notable"""" topics. That said, I'll point out that consensus has been that sites like Keenspot do not automatically confer notability (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/God_Mode, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Crazy_in_Love_%28comic%29, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Alien_Dice, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/No_Pink_Ponies, various other AFDs, PRODs and A7 CSDs). Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards nominations are similarly non-notable as about 125 of them are handed out every year""" Deletion of Purple Pussy WP:NOT||WP:WEB Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11057 10340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Glassett User:Wikishagnik 05:20, 13 October 2012 (UTC) delete Nothing in Google Books and news. Found some facebook and twitter pages only on Google. Does not meet any criteria for Deletion of Andrew Glassett WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11058 5841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Niz-r User:Malik 23:28, 4 January 2012 (UTC) delete No assertion of importance. Nominate it under |A7. — Deletion of Niz-r WP:A7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11059 7112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Guild Wars characters User:Phirazo 17:04, 2 November 2007 (UTC) delete OT#PLOT|Plot summary, and no reliable secondary sources to establish |notability Deletion of List of Guild Wars characters WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11060 7585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Starcraft II Confirmed Units and Structures User:Floria 10:30, 5 June 2007 (UTC) delete It is simply a sorry excuse for a list. Poorly written, no sources, complete |Original Research, speculation based on fan sources, repeat of information previously listed, and simply bad grammar + formatting. Putting that aside, the article itself is pointless, and completely violates , , and possibly . Serves no use whatsoever in an encyclopedia as it cannot be properly sourced. Suited for a fansite, and nothing else. I'm actually surprised this kind of discussion has gone on for so long Deletion of Starcraft II Confirmed Units and Structures WP:OR||WP:NOT||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:No original research 65
11061 5052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Carter III User:Fieari 03:32, 21 June 2016 (UTC) keep Obscure yes, but meets with multiple bylined articles from notable, non-local-only newspapers Deletion of George Carter III WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11062 392 [[Haftpflichtgemeinschaft Deutscher Nahverkehrs- und Versorgungsunternehmen Allgemein]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Nörglmann 09:06, 22. Jun. 2015 (CEST) delete ohne Mitarbeiter und mikrigem Umsatz sinnlos. Die sind keine Wissenvernichtungsgründe sondern eindeutige Relevanzkriterien. Hier versucht ein Account in einem Artikelbereich fehlerhafte Artikel zu eliminieren, voll unterstützt durch die WP:RKU. Im Wirtschaftsunternehmensbereich werden seit jeher die RK hart ausgelegt. Es liegt der Verdacht nahe, dass hier kleine Unternehmen versuchen, Werbung zu betreiben (Interessenskonflikt). Innovativ und Vorreiterrolle fehlt Löschung von Haftpflichtgemeinschaft Deutscher Nahverkehrs- und Versorgungsunternehmen Allgemein Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
11063 10931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Tragedy of Macbeth Part II User:power 01:07, 6 January 2018 (UTC) merge to Noah Lukeman; I'm not sure he's notable, but that's not an issue here. (I wouldn't recommend an AfD of that page). There's no evidence this passes Deletion of The Tragedy of Macbeth Part II WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
11064 6255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Secret Plot (2nd nomination) User:Quasirandom 18:22, 29 June 2009 (UTC) comment OTOH, the French edition (mentioned in the current article) does seem to have gotten some notice. The one French review site to mention it I know is |reliable, currently referenced in the article, didn't actually review it, and the other hits on title/publisher I cannot evaluate -- we need a French reader to assist here. But if enough coverage can be demonstrated, I will change my !vote to keep Deletion of Secret Plot (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11065 13764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christina (Gundam) User:AnmaFinotera 15:54, 24 May 2009 (UTC) delete beyond minor character by any reasonable standards. Clearly unnotable and fails both and OT. No need for a redirect not a likely search term Deletion of Christina (Gundam) WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11066 18095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/André Couteaux User:Mizu 23:30, 9 August 2008 (UTC) delete Fails the google test. This isn't always a valid reason unto itself, but it's a pretty good warning singn that this fails , and . &mdash Deletion of André Couteaux WP:V||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11067 9847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global Data Intelligence Limited User:Otr500 20:16, 2 May 2019 (UTC) delete Appears written as |advertising. The possible reason why reliable independent sources haven't been found is that there doesn't appear to be any and I went through two pages on a search. {{Ping|Trymemore}} Thanks for the contributions but on this one I don't see that there is anything. If it was drafted I don't think sources could be found to provide a |HEY Deletion of Global Data Intelligence Limited WP:NOTADVERTISING||WP:HEY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11068 15880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fragile Gravity User:Isotope23 15:28, 21 April 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Fragile Gravity WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11069 2647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Teens Against Crime User:Bearian 14:45, 12 November 2019 (UTC) delete per . I don't normally get involved in discussions about fictional organizations, but this one seems truly |common Deletion of American Teens Against Crime WP:SNOW||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
11070 17633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kyle Hupfer User:GPL93 17:44, 14 April 2021 (UTC) delete This is an NPOL fail per : {{tq|Leaders of major sub-national (state, province, prefecture, etc.) parties are usually deleted unless notability can be demonstrated for other reasons.}}. Best Deletion of Kyle Hupfer WP:POLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
11071 5393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yamie Chess User:Atlantic306 17:26, 21 November 2016 (UTC) delete does not pass as the independence of two of the given references has been questioned (see article talk page). I did deprod this but in view of the doubtful sources have changed opinion Deletion of Yamie Chess WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11072 15209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Easterns Automotive Group (2nd nomination) User:nonsenseferret 20:16, 2 February 2013 (UTC) delete I can't find significant independent coverage that would support a claim to notability within . I am very surprised this was kept at the first nomination for deletion Deletion of Easterns Automotive Group (2nd nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11073 8445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isis Love User:Davey2010 14:57, 1 June 2013 (UTC) delete per nom, Fails & , (Specsavers|Doesn't she look pretty Deletion of Isis Love WP:GNG||WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11074 18531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Destiny Express Redux User:MichaelQSchmidt 10:16, 26 May 2015 (UTC) delete """This does not belong here as it is '''not''' actually a film, it a """"non-existent 2009 film by American director Tobe Hooper that exists only in the confines of his novel, Midnight Movie"""". As it is a """"film"""" never actually made, it fails . However, the novel http://www.slantmagazine.com/house/article/the-formulaic-shock-and-awe-of-tobe-hoopers-midnight-movie Midnight Movie ''might'' be worth an article, and this unmade project ''might'' then be spoken of there. Perhaps after deletion it can be redirected to the author Tobe Hooper""" Deletion of Destiny Express Redux WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11075 4509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marygiri Public School User:Bbx 10:20, 21 January 2007 (UTC) merge to Koothattukulam per Deletion of Marygiri Public School WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
11076 9213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amy Demboski User:Vapidlyyours 23:58, 9 February 2015 (UTC) comment Looking at she is a notable person in the city of Anchorage. Her coverage for the Mayor's race is auxiliary to the article. Our politicians are notable. That is the first and most important guide-line. The coverage of her only goes to add credit to her being a notable figure in the community. She is currently part of an 11 person assembly that makes decisions for the citizens of Anchorage, that alone deserves an article. If you feel so strongly about the mayoral addition it can be removed - but that won't stop her from doing it Deletion of Amy Demboski WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11077 4371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corporate Representatives for Ethical Wikipedia Engagement User:Gobonobo 23:28, 12 March 2012 (UTC) delete While reliable sources mention CREWE in passing, the coverage is not significant and is insufficient to pass the |general notability guideline. I wonder if some of this shouldn't be merged to the Edelman (firm) article, since this effort seems to be coming from Mr. Gomes' company Deletion of Corporate Representatives for Ethical Wikipedia Engagement WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11078 8647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gavin Lewis User:ChrisTheDude 19:24, 13 November 2011 (UTC) delete does not seem to have ever played professional football, so fails , no significant source coverage so fails Deletion of Gavin Lewis WP:FOOTYN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11079 7375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tallest buildings in Aylesbury User:Ajf773 20:23, 1 January 2019 (UTC) delete per and . A town of around 50,000 isn't going to be as notable as any similar list to a big city such as Manchester or London Deletion of List of tallest buildings in Aylesbury WP:NOR||WP:LISTN Wikipedia:No original research 65
11080 2896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United States Capitol shooting incident (2013) (2nd nomination) User:SteveStrummer 20:30, 5 December 2013 (UTC) keep """Two whole! months have passed without lasting effect"""" is humorously circular reasoning, but saying that it's an event that's """"only notable the day it happened"""" is empirically false: anyone can http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws&authuser=0&q=%22Miriam+Carey search the news for """"Miriam Carey"""" and find |continuous, |in-depth coverage by |diverse sources for virtually every single day up to the present""" Deletion of United States Capitol shooting incident (2013) (2nd nomination) WP:CONTINUEDCOVERAGE||WP:INDEPTH||WP:DIVERSE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11081 312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Direct Save Protocol User:Mark 19:43, 19 September 2018 (UTC) merge This is a verifiable protocol per the spec linked to in the external sources. It is a small but important addition of the X drag and drop protocol. It is then worth merging the first sentence into X_Window_selection#XDND with the spec as a source verifying as an |alternative to deletion. --{{u| Deletion of Direct Save Protocol WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
11082 13835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tommy Smith (footballer born 1990) User:Number 09:52, 17 June 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and consensus is that youth caps do not confer notability Deletion of Tommy Smith (footballer born 1990) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11083 14954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thrifty Girl KICKS YOUR FINANCIAL BUTT User:Captain 21:14, 12 September 2008 (UTC) delete No |reliable sources provided or could be located, book fails Deletion of Thrifty Girl KICKS YOUR FINANCIAL BUTT WP:RS||WP:BK Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11084 2420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United States presidential election, 2024 (2nd nomination) User:Anarchyte 07:18, 26 May 2016 (UTC) delete and temp salt. Deletion of United States presidential election, 2024 (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11085 11959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hannah Montana: Disney's Karaoke Series (album) User:JForget 23:36, 30 June 2008 (UTC) merge not meeting although it can be merged elsewhere, perhaps a mention at Hannah Montana 2: Meet Miley Cyrus or any related one Deletion of Hannah Montana: Disney's Karaoke Series (album) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11086 19526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fire needle acupuncture User:Rhododendrites 01:35, 24 March 2016 (UTC) comment Since is playing a prominent role in this discussion, and people are talking about it in contradictory ways, I've asked for clarification at WT:MED. &mdash Deletion of Fire needle acupuncture WP:MEDRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11087 15768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annotated bibliography of fly fishing User:Nick 10:36, 2 June 2008 (UTC) delete as orginal research and per the precedents set by the near routine deletion of 'annotated bibliography' articles like this. What reliable third party source(s) says that these books are particularly notable and supports the annotations? This material is, I image, quite useful to people with an interest in the topic, but it isn't encylopedic and should be moved onto a more suitable website than this one - |Wikipedia is not a web host or a blog Deletion of Annotated bibliography of fly fishing WP:NOTBLOG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11088 13158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Marc User:MikeWazowski 18:05, 7 December 2011 (UTC) delete per . This article is excessively promotional and the coverage from independent reliable sources just isn't there Deletion of Kevin Marc WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
11089 11863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeekdober User:MacGyverMagic 11:32, 29 November 2008 (UTC) merge Establishing |notability independent of Zoids is only neccesary for independent article, merging only requires verification it exists. (see Deletion of Zeekdober WP:N||WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11090 6021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clinical trials on Ayurvedic drugs User:Bearian 20:21, 5 August 2020 (UTC) delete per , , and . Wikipedia has avoided merely publishing United States government meta-studies, and this article is a prime example of why we all agree Deletion of Clinical trials on Ayurvedic drugs WP:SYNTH||WP:CCC||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:No original research 65
11091 12364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Scott (British Politician and Social Entrepreneur) User:Chris 08:26, 12 February 2010 (UTC) delete Two mentions in local papers is way short of notability. Clear failure of Deletion of Jack Scott (British Politician and Social Entrepreneur) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11092 13270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ernest R. House User:Jonesey95 22:04, 22 November 2017 (UTC) comment I have no objections to keeping it if the person is notable. My initial reading of the article was that it did not make any sort of claim of notability. If criterion 1 is met (and this criterion could be made clearer to help non-specialist readers like myself), the article should summarize the person's influence and contributions. That is cleanup, not AfD, as noted, however. As a start, maybe one of the commenters here could link to the professor's citations and reviews in a section on the talk page Deletion of Ernest R. House WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11093 20156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Elvir User:Pharaoh 09:10, 11 October 2014 (UTC) keep Has played in the CONCACAF Champions League the regional equivalent of the UEFA Champions League in 2011–12 CONCACAF Champions League Group Stage for Motagua as per http://int.soccerway.com/players/omar-josue-elvir/196829/ this and http://int.soccerway.com/matches/2011/09/30/nc-america/concacaf-champions-league/ld-alajuelense/cd-motagua/1184698/ this and http://www.footballdatabase.eu/football.joueurs.omar.elvir.145496.en.html this and he is 25 years old.Football is the most popular sport in Honduras. Passes http://www.concacaf.com/article/marathon-victoria-win-in-honduras-playoffs http://www.diariosports.com.ar/noticia/futbol/18/04/2014/obligado-a-ganar http://lanoticia.hn/deportes/omar-elvir-ante-marathon-queremos-los-tres-puntos/ this Deletion of Omar Elvir WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11094 851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Media Line International User:DarkAudit 14:09, 30 January 2008 (UTC) comment """There is no assertion of notability in any of these articles you claim are """"valid stubs"""". There are no reliable, verifiable, and independent sources of any kind. Mere existence is not enough. and are simply not met""" Deletion of Media Line International WP:N||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11095 6680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Love in October User:David 18:57, 11 August 2007 (UTC) delete having their music video played on a few music TV channels is not enough. And there aren't really any ''non-trivial'' references. See also Deletion of Love in October WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
11096 22 [[Jurassic Park IV]] (verschoben & Redirs gelöscht) Benutzer:Sampi NONE keep Das Löschargument, dass der Film noch nicht gedreht wurde, ist unzulässig. Laut heißt es explizit, dass ''Artikel über aktuelle und zukünftige Ereignisse erwünscht sind, selbst wenn die Fakten sich kurzfristig ändern können''. Nachdem die Glaskugelguckerei (unbelegte Gerüchte) entfernt worden ist, handelt es sich IMHO um einen gültigen Stub. Wenn Jurassic Park I, II und III weltweit bekannt sind, gehe ich einmal stark davon aus, dass auch der 4. Teil relevant sein wird. Dass im Artikel nichts über die Handlung steht, liegt am Antragsteller dieses LAs. Aus erkenntnistheoretischer Sicht ist es ein enormer Unterschied, ob nichts über die Handlung geschrieben wird oder erwähnt wird, dass die genaue Handlung derzeit unbekannt ist. Dass die Handlung noch nicht feststeht, ist IMHO eine relevante Information, die sich von den derzeit kursierenden stark abgrenzt. Dass es sich um den Fertigsstellungstermin 2008 (auch eine relevante Information) um eine Ankündigung handelt, wird auch klargestellt, usw. Zusammengefasst ist das Lemma relevant (vermutlich unumstritten), der Artikel am aktuellen Kenntnisstand (auch wenn nicht auf dem zukünftigen Erkenntnisstand) und von Gerüchten befreit. Solange so lautet, wie so lautet Löschung von Jurassic Park IV Wikipedia:LR Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
11097 7884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farewell (band) User:A1octopus 18:38, 6 December 2007 (UTC) delete Not notable enough for an article under usic ''yet.'' May become so at a future date. At present there are insufficient non-trivial secondary sources and the music output is not sufficient. Brett Gurewitz scouting them is irrelevent because notablity is not transferable Deletion of Farewell (band) WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
11098 3654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fly Gibraltar User:Chris 20:28, 12 June 2007 (UTC) delete A putative airline with plans which were put on the back burner; these plans have now been officially cancelled. Fails Deletion of Fly Gibraltar WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11099 14173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orsu Metals User:The 19:29, 26 March 2018 (UTC) delete for failing Deletion of Orsu Metals WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11100 13356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melissa Smith (2nd nomination) User:We66er 05:39, 23 September 2008 (UTC) delete minor stuff on reality tv and fails . Has little value other than promotion Deletion of Melissa Smith (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11101 15157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sustainability in Higher Education User:Slakr 02:58, 12 October 2007 (UTC) delete as this appears to be #OR|original research. The main thing I'm not seeing is any peer-reviewed references. I also noticed a similar AfD over at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sustainability at Berea College from another article created by this author Deletion of Sustainability in Higher Education WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11102 11727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inacronym User:JJL 18:14, 27 February 2008 (UTC) delete nn, , adv Deletion of Inacronym WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11103 12154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melissa Smith User:Dhartung 14:15, 22 May 2008 (UTC) delete no appearance of meeting , and non-winners of reality shows are not considered inherently notable Deletion of Melissa Smith WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11104 18658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucy Fleck User:Ejgreen77 01:17, 22 December 2015 (UTC) keep as a pass, per Dravecky Deletion of Lucy Fleck WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11105 12675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Temi Olajide User:Celestina007 22:40, 22 May 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Temi Olajide WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11106 2770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rafael Leão User:PeeJay2K3 18:40, 29 August 2011 (UTC) delete Any assumption of notability would be based on a violation of Deletion of Rafael Leão WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11107 5353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sydney bus routes 100-199 (2nd nomination) User:JROBBO 05:19, 22 August 2006 (UTC) comment can people please address the issues at hand? I have clearly said that there is historical information available for some of these routes, which would make them notable. I don't have time to add them or research it at the moment, but they exist. There are historical remnants of the old tram routes along some of these bus routes, like old bus shelters and bus-only lanes which were used as tram lines before the trams were torn up. Secondly, this is NOT a timetable or bus schedule. I have said elsewhere that the timetable-like information would be deleted leaving just the bus routes and where they go, which has been established elsewhere as being worth keeping. Sydney is the biggest city in Australia. Why are its bus routes not worth keeping, whereas everywhere else is? Please answer that question and don't just quote all the time. There has been no non-notability established for lists of bus routes. Individual bus stops are not notable, but that is not being debated Deletion of Sydney bus routes 100-199 (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11108 5057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Republican establishment User:Bearian 20:52, 9 May 2016 (UTC) keep an essential topic in this year's United States elections, and it is not so bad as |to require a complete re-do Deletion of Republican establishment WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
11109 8877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticisms of Harry Reid (3rd nomination) User:Colonel 06:33, 18 May 2011 (UTC) delete Inherently one-sided and so contrary to |core policy Deletion of Criticisms of Harry Reid (3rd nomination) WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
11110 18639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lords of Lords User:Blowski 17:43, 25 August 2006 (UTC) delete fails . It's not nearly notable enough, and I can't find any independent mentions on search engines Deletion of Lords of Lords WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11111 3991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blatant Doom Trip User:doomsdayer520 14:45, 27 March 2018 (UTC) delete A tribute to a notable band featuring other notable bands, but the album itself has attracted little notice. It has a fairly substantial review at AllMusic and a mention at Consequence of Sound https://consequenceofsound.net/2010/10/guided-by-voices-tribute-album-features-flaming-lips-blitzen-trapper-thurston-moore/. Those might be enough for #1 but I consider that to be a bit of a stretch. Otherwise the album's only notice has been in a few fan blogs Deletion of Blatant Doom Trip WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
11112 21382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chief visionary officer User:Amarkov 15:41, 9 November 2006 (UTC) delete http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=%22chief+visionary+officer%22+-Wikipedia 16800 google hits, but only one seems to be actually talking about the term. Thus, it doesn't meet Deletion of Chief visionary officer WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11113 4408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UrbanClap (3rd nomination) User:Cunard 04:16, 11 October 2016 (UTC) keep """The articles provided by {{user|Northamerica1000}} clearly demonstrate that the subject passes Wikipedia:Notability#General notability guideline. For example, here is coverage from the ''First Post'' article: Roommates at IIT, Varun Khaitan and Abhiraj Bhal, had always wanted to solve a really big consumer problem in India by leveraging mobile technology. After graduating from IIT, Abhiraj went on to IIM Ahmedabad, while Varun joined Qualcomm as an engineer. Eventually, they both joined the Boston Consulting Group. While in the US, a common friend introduced them to Raghav Chandra, an engineer at Twitter who shared their vision.After returning to India, the three realised that the industry of local services had seen no innovation for at least a decade, and decided to focus on solving this problem. UrbanClap was launched in November 2014, in a tiny office at Bhikaji Cama Place in South Delhi, offering services in 5 categories and with 100 partners on board.The organisation grew rapidly as the team grew from 3 to 35 odd members and, by April 2015 UrbanClap raised $1.6 million in the seed round of funding, from SAIF Partners, Accel Partners and the founders of Snapdeal, Kunal Bahl and Rohit Bansal. At the time, the service offering had grown to 46 categories and 2000+ professionals were registered on its platform.Barely two months later, as UrbanClap expanded to other metropolitan cities in India, the company raised another $10 million, in Series A funding from its existing investors SAIF and Accel Partners. This discusses UrbanClap's foundation, history, and products in detail.The article from ''Entrepreneur (magazine)|Entrepreneur'' notes: Brainchild of IIT Kanpur alumni Varun Khaitan and Abhiraj Bhal, UrbanClap claims itself as the India’s largest marketplace for local services. Whether you are looking for a plumber, beautician, a yoga trainer or a wedding photographer, UrbanClap is a one stop destination for all local services.All you need to do is place your requirements on the UrbanClap app or website and within short span of time platform will bring these professionals to you.Headquartered in Gurgaon, this startup offers services in more than 75 categories across Delhi NCR, Bengaluru, Mumbai, Chennai and Pune. Today, they serve 5000 customer requests per day, and have built a base of over 20,000 service professionals – who together represent the gold standard for trusted services in India.Every month, UrbanClap sends them business worth $200 million annually (current run rate) which include Rs 200 from small carpentry jobs, to a large interior designing assignments worth several lakhs. This provides extensive coverage of UrbanClap's product. is clearly met.I reviewed the current text of the article and do not find it promotional: '''UrbanClap''' is an India|Indian online service marketplace that connects customers to service professionals. The company was founded in 2014 and is is based out of Gurgaon, India. In December 2015, UrbanClap was servicing 5,000 requests from customers per day, and had a """"base of over 20,000 service professionals"""" who provide labor for UrbanClap's users.As of 2016, UrbanClap has raised $37 million in funding from Bessemer Venture Partners, Accel Partners, SAIF Partners, Kunal Bahl, Rohit Bansal, and Ratan Tata.UrbanClap acquired HandyHome, a Mumbai-based after sales service platform in January 2016""" Deletion of UrbanClap (3rd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
11114 20578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chile–Estonia relations (2nd nomination) [[User talk:98.154.26.247|talk]]) 00:41, 12 June 2009 (UTC) keep I believe this article is encyclopedic and informational. When a tourist or person interested in foreign relationships of the two countries, he/she expects to find quick and valuable ''information'' about the two countries. And, with the principle I always follow: |Wikipedia is '''not''' a paper encyclopedia, this article should still be kept. --Special:Contributions/98.154.26.247|98.154.26.247 Deletion of Chile–Estonia relations (2nd nomination) WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11115 535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ron-Robert Zieler (2nd nomination) User:Baileypalblue 12:35, 3 February 2009 (UTC) delete per nom, possibly '''speedy delete''' #General|G4. I haven't seen the original article, but it sounds as though it was re-created in substantially the same form without addressing the rationale for deletion in the first AfD Deletion of Ron-Robert Zieler (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11116 182 [[Friedhelm Franken]] 2 (gelöscht) Benutzer:Cimbail NONE keep Edit-war, PAs gegen das Lemma und den Autoren und den LA-Steller und den Verteidiger von allen. Ich liebe es! Für den Edit-war könnte man IMHO zwei Sperren verhängen, seid froh dass ich keine Knöpfe habe und gerade die Seite #Andreas Parker nicht finden kann. Anzuwenden sind die Relevanzkriterien für Autoren. Da kommt er als Allein-Autor nicht drüber, sein Sohn muss ihm schon helfen (das ist aber so auch für 70jährige notorische PR-Profis nicht vorgesehen). Anzuwenden sind hilfsweise die Relevanzkriterien für Journalisten. Aufgrund seiner diversen Funktionen im Kanzleramt und anderen Behörden überfliegt er die Relevanzschwelle förmlich, erst recht in der Kombination Autor/Herausgeber/Journalist. , Löschung von Friedhelm Franken Wikipedia:Vandalismusmeldung Wikipedia:Vandalism 29
11117 511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amin Ellahi Shaikh User:EditorE 05:00, 14 February 2016 (UTC) delete as it seems the subject has yet to escape status Deletion of Amin Ellahi Shaikh WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11118 10551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian D. Marsden User:Dream 07:39, 5 November 2012 (UTC) keep Google doodles get ample coverage, and he made the first one ever, as the reliable source I added a reference to in the article clearly proves. ''3. The person has created ... a significant or well-known work ..that has been the subject ... of multiple independent periodical articles or reviews.'' So he passes that. Perhaps number 4 also, not sure. Number 3 is enough though Deletion of Ian D. Marsden WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
11119 17763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madsen family curse User:MartinDK 21:13, 28 November 2006 (UTC) delete """Being Danish I have never heard of this before. Sounds like cruft to me. Where are the sources verifying that this is anything else than your own Do you have any idea how many people are called """"Madsen""""???? (hint: it is more than you think""" Deletion of Madsen family curse WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11120 18307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nabil Guedioura NONE NONE delete Has not played fully professional - so the subject fails Deletion of Nabil Guedioura WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
11121 1308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eko Hotels and Suites User:Smartse 14:11, 3 April 2016 (UTC) delete """Like restaurants, hotels are bound to be mentioned in published sources of some form as this is an essential part of generating business. However to be included we need some sources which provide more than the run-of-the-mill reviews and these do not appear to exist. Trip Advisor is obviously of no use for demonstrating that is met. I also share Takeaways concerns about where the content came from as the https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Eko_Hotels_and_Suites&oldid=668246068 first version appears to have copied content from http://www.africatravelsguide.com/nigeria/lemeridienekohotelandsuites/ this site. e.g. article: """"serves sizzling hot barbecues and grills spiced with suya."""" source: """"sizzling hot barbecues and grills spiced with suya are served to your taste."""" etc""" Deletion of Eko Hotels and Suites WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11122 11761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bit Riot Records User:Duffbeerforme 02:21, 14 July 2014 (UTC) delete Business lacks coverage in independent reliable sources. Not |notable. Notability is not inherited. Notable artists do not make a business notable Deletion of Bit Riot Records WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11123 1051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cosmonaut (Angels and Airwaves song) User:TenPoundHammer 11:48, 1 July 2007 (UTC) delete as |crystal ballery. Seriously -- a single that's not going to be released until September?! Whoever wrote this article needs to |chill. (I like Angels & Airwaves too, but dang Deletion of Cosmonaut (Angels and Airwaves song) WP:CRYSTAL||WP:CHILL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11124 1027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of most-subscribed YouTube channels User:Spirit 03:29, 11 February 2019 (UTC) keep Meets due to the widespread coverage of the topic, most recently in the form of the PewDiePie vs T-Series dispute. Matters of taste are not elements of notability, and statistics are permitted if given context and palced into tables for ease of sorting (as is done here Deletion of List of most-subscribed YouTube channels WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11125 5124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Your Own Decay User:Jayden54 22:21, 19 December 2006 (UTC) delete fails : no coverage by reliable sources, no internation tours or awards, and their albums aren't available on amazon, which means they can't be very notable Deletion of Your Own Decay WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
11126 11868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anwar Hared (2nd nomination) User:Ajraddatz 06:25, 25 March 2016 (UTC) keep meets and , with no indication of what has changed since the last time. Non-English sources do not equate a lack of reliable sources Deletion of Anwar Hared (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
11127 2878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soyombo Revival Society [[User talk:24.151.50.175|talk]]) 15:33, 20 January 2020 (UTC) delete Fails as best I can determine. Special:Contributions/24.151.50.175|24.151.50.175 Deletion of Soyombo Revival Society WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11128 446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Greatest Show User:The 14:17, 7 September 2006 (UTC) delete as a |non notable wrestling show Deletion of The Greatest Show WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11129 2543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kingdom of the Slavs NONE NONE keep per . As Usernameunique says, it's easy to find high-quality sources writing about Orbini and ''Kingdom of the Slavs''. For example Deletion of Kingdom of the Slavs WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
11130 8685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Management University User:AllyD 06:25, 31 July 2018 (UTC) delete An article on a start-up business. At best : no |evidence of |notability provided or found Deletion of American Management University :WP:TOOSOON||:WP:RS||:WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Too soon 40
11131 5869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Public domain book User:Savonneux 07:27, 20 August 2016 (UTC) delete I actually thought about nominating this about a week ago. Fails Deletion of Public domain book WP:SALAT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
11132 19769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ysabel Birkbeck [[User talk:198.58.158.1|talk]]) 08:47, 14 March 2017 (UTC) keep I saw five or six good mentions in Google books before I stopped counting. meets .Special:Contributions/198.58.158.1|198.58.158.1 Deletion of Ysabel Birkbeck WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11133 12323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hillfolk User:Jbhunley 13:11, 18 August 2018 (UTC) keep The product reviews contain significant coverage which seems to be independent of the publisher. While the Dana Jones Award does not, in itself, establish notability it ''does'' give a solid marker for significance ie it shows that the reviews are likely not just 'we have to find some game to discuss in this issue' and greatly decreases the likelihood that the reviews are the result of native advertising or a publisher's PR campaign. The material that exists in the article is not, in my opinion, quite enough to demonstrate notability but, I think it likely that |sufficient sources exist to get it past GNG Deletion of Hillfolk WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
11134 20912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jean Claude Jacob User:Mccapra 04:12, 4 December 2019 (UTC) keep The en.wiki article wasn’t linked to the fr.wiki article so I’ve fixed that. From the fr.wiki piece we can see there are portraits of the subject, a street named after him, and some sources not used in the en.wiki article. I’ll try and do some work to improve this in the next few days but it’s pretty clear this subject passes Deletion of Jean Claude Jacob WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11135 2409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fabricio Fernández User:Fenix 17:47, 20 February 2015 (UTC) delete Player fails as has not played in a |fully professional league, nor senior international football. No indication of any other achievements that have garnered sufficient, significant coverage to satisfy Deletion of Fabricio Fernández WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11136 7097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Africans in Poland User:Piotrus 04:27, 11 September 2014 (UTC) delete """The topic is notable, but the article at present fails to provide any useful and referenced information. The section in the racism article Irina points to is better than this mess, and the article as it stands could be simply redirected there. That said, I'd like to point out that the article as https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Black_Africans_in_Poland&oldid=110875745 originally created was more informative; unfortunately it since got hijacked by some trolls bound on portraying Poland as racist, with the prior content replaced by a """"Poland is racist"""" rant-type content. Gutting of useful content at https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Black_Africans_in_Poland&diff=506738586&oldid=503342449 IMHO, while supported by , removed any vestige of usefulness from that article. I did some search trying to find out information to restore this, but I couldn't find much; interestingly a portal dedicated to the topic states that there are no official statistics for the number of Black Africans in Poland (http://afryka.org/afryka/ilu-murzynow-mieszka-w-polsce-,news/). The best I found is the said NGO's publication (a free ebook) about the history of Black Americans (known in Poland in a more politically correct terms as Africans) in Warsaw: http://afryka.org/afryka.pdf. At this time I have, however, no time to read it. One could also try emailing the NGO at undacja@afryka.org , the odds are good they have an English speaking staff who may point to more publications. If somebody can point me to some, preferably online, I volunteer to at least stub this topic in a reliable way. PS. If this is kept, I'd suggest moving this to African diaspora in Poland (per category structure""" Deletion of Black Africans in Poland WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11137 7642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor Who 2008 Christmas special User:Cirt 07:22, 6 July 2008 (UTC) keep certainly notable, already has plenty of discussion in / secondary sources Deletion of Doctor Who 2008 Christmas special WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11138 735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fan Wars (1999 film) User:Karaboom 20:22, 2 August 2007 (UTC) delete No secondary reliable sources, as defined in and . The movie director is not an independent source Deletion of Fan Wars (1999 film) WP:NOTE||WP:PSTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11139 3908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harrogate bus route 36 User:Strato6 08:43, 26 February 2017 (UTC) keep some more cites needed, but secondary coverage from multiple sources has resulted in an article that is more than just a copy of a timetable. And with no listing of frequencies, hours of operation, fares etc anyone trying to plan a journey using the article would not find enough info here, making a moot point Deletion of Harrogate bus route 36 WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11140 7867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paulville, Texas User:Dhartung 23:51, 12 May 2008 (UTC) delete per . Some recent announcements, but no indication this will actually move forward Deletion of Paulville, Texas WP:CBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11141 11864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plastic Keys to Paradise User:Pburka 17:27, 20 March 2011 (UTC) keep Even if a myth, it's notable given how widespread coverage of it was in the media. Should probably be renamed to Plastic key to paradise or Key to paradise per rticle titles Deletion of Plastic Keys to Paradise WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
11142 13387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Marsden User:Thivierr 06:35, 31 August 2008 (UTC) keep Independent sources given non-trivial coverage. |notability is easily established Deletion of David Marsden WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11143 4756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Breakwater Marina User:Mayalld 15:39, 2 September 2008 (UTC) delete part of a tranche of articles seeking to create a directory of largely nn marinas, contrary to Deletion of Breakwater Marina WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11144 10221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MetaTeam (software) User:Ihcoyc 20:20, 14 April 2010 (UTC) delete """More software relating to the supervision of computer programmers --- ''a collaborative team governance Web application'' --- that really needs evidence of notability in a wider world. None here: even a general Google search finds only download and internal sites. Attempts at claiming significance''In the area of project management software MetaTeam is notable for its focus on the governance issues of work teams as a first-class concern, rather than as secondary to scheduling, budgeting and documents. This attention is paid in the context of how the organization activities are specified by standards like the PMBOK, in its Project Human Resource Management skill area''and arguing notability in the article itself---''cited as the exemplar for the Team Governance category in a report on virtual teams''... ''well-reviewed by bloggers... was a finalist in the Worcester Polytechnic Institute's WPI Venture Forum Business Plan Contest'' fail to convince of significance outside IT departments, and instead the self-congratulatory nature of all these """"references"""" pushes the article in the direction of |advertising""" Deletion of MetaTeam (software) WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
11145 16185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaw Theory User:Markeer 13:37, 17 February 2007 (UTC) delete per , , and possibly . I find it troubling to see an article about a 'theory proposed by a scientist' that doesn't even cite the article or articles that scientist proposed the theory in. Scientific theories aren't something they mused about to a friend over lunch, they are formalized with publication. Except this one, which seems to have no evidence or assertion of it's existence Deletion of Shaw Theory WP:OR||WP:V||WP:N||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:No original research 65
11146 13602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Once (Diana Vickers song) User:AnemoneProjectors 23:33, 19 March 2010 (UTC) delete Fails , but no objection to recreation if it charts, which will not be until at least 23 April. That's over a month away Deletion of Once (Diana Vickers song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11147 4358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chakra (operating system) User:Gaba_p 22:40, 26 September 2013 (UTC) keep given its presence in a number of . I'll add one more to the list: http://www.muylinux.com/2013/02/14/chakra-linux-2013-02-llega-con-kde-sc-4-10/ MuyLinux (a very big Linux site in Spanish) Regards Deletion of Chakra (operating system) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11148 20871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Association of Policy Market Makers User:Hro 14:26, 17 June 2008 (UTC) comment Not a hoax: it is verifiable per http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/2004/jan/25/endowments.observercashsection. I don't think COI is a reason for speedy. However still borderline and almost certainly not E|notable Deletion of The Association of Policy Market Makers WP:NOT||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11149 5839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annabel (band) User:Andise1 NONE keep The sources in the article demonstrate notability and pass Deletion of Annabel (band) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11150 8446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Travis Miller (musician) User:Atlantic306 21:38, 4 December 2019 (UTC) keep has significant coverage in reliable sources already in the article such as The Fader, Pitchfork, Acclaim, Mass Appeal, Pigeons and Planes, Fact magazine and others so passes criteria 1 (only one criteria needed) and also . There are also some unreliable sources in the article that need replacing but to ignore the good sources is not helpful, imv Deletion of Travis Miller (musician) WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11151 16419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flexy Da Don User:Versace1608 10:26, 24 January 2020 (UTC) delete A non-notable musician who doesn't meet any criterion of and . Neither him or his music have been discussed in reliable sources Deletion of Flexy Da Don WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11152 1004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Angelone User:Stuartyeates 03:35, 15 April 2013 (UTC) delete as failing and , author can ask for userfication should he make it big-time Deletion of Anthony Angelone WP:NSPORTS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11153 2757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael L. Baird User:John 05:33, 25 September 2018 (UTC) delete """Seems to also fail , since he's only notable for the Dannielynn Stern case and not for academia (or, technically, being a """"media consultant"""" for NBC w/ OJ). Perhaps redirect to Dannielynn Stern if somebody ever wanted to look him up on here, but I don't think that's warranted""" Deletion of Michael L. Baird WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11154 12582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ewife User:Carlosguitar 07:12, 30 May 2007 (UTC) delete AS INACCURATE: THERE IS NO WOMAN PLAYING MMORPG. LOL just joking, but it is obvious |neologism and |unattributed article Deletion of Ewife WP:NEO||WP:ATT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11155 17397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Religion and the internet User:Kuzaar 18:22, 2 August 2006 (UTC) delete unless rewritten per DJ Clayworth above. The article's sources are direct, making this |original research. If the same article were made up of the detailed claims that this article currently has, but cited the arguments from a |reliable source, the article would be entirely appropriate to include, because it is a notable phenomenon. However, since it does not, original research has no place in the project Deletion of Religion and the internet WP:OR||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
11156 1380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Louis Siciliano User:Cavarrone 06:54, 15 July 2013 (UTC) keep """Composer of the Year"""" award at the 67th Venice Film Festival and 2006 Nastro d'Argento award for Best Score are quite enough to pass 's first requirement. The coverage that was listed above is also fine""" Deletion of Louis Siciliano WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11157 12855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hayden gerson User:Alf 15:41, 29 January 2007 (UTC) delete unless properly sourced and referenced i.a.w. by end of this AfD Deletion of Hayden gerson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11158 9589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ClearTax (company) NONE NONE delete """The criteria for establishing notability for companies/organizations as per WP:NCORP is for multiple sources (at least two) of deep or significant coverage with |in-depth information *on the company* and (this bit is important!) containing |""""Independent Content"""". """"Independent content"""", in order to count towards establishing notability, must include ''original and independent opinion, analysis, investigation, and fact checking that are clearly attributable to a source unaffiliated to the subject''. Lets look at the references posted above which have been put forward as meeting the criteria for establishing notability""" Deletion of ClearTax (company) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
11159 7430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Upfront mortgage lender User:Mrschimpf 04:48, 1 June 2010 (UTC) delete The lede screams |spam as the certification is made by a commercial site, not a neutral third party. Obviously a fake certification designed to get page clicks Deletion of Upfront mortgage lender WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
11160 6420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Benac User:CAPTAIN 16:18, 20 July 2017 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability per and olitician Deletion of David Benac WP:PROF||WP:P Wikipedia:Notability 77
11161 12371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Poetry of Menotti Lerro User:Tokyogirl79 05:05, 16 May 2015 (UTC) merge While notable people are involved with this work, that notability is by that association. This can make it more likely that there will be sources, but this is never a guarantee. Sometimes books can fly solidly under the radar despite having a host of notable persons involved. This is especially true with anything released via an academic publisher, since those tend to be almost always ignored by everyone except for journal articles and scholarly websites. The end result is that we cannot base notability on whether or not the people involved are notable- we have to be able to show how this book is independently notable and I cannot find anything that would back this up Deletion of The Poetry of Menotti Lerro WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11162 7583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of After Colony mobile units User:Sephiroth 04:02, 23 August 2007 (UTC) delete no |reliable, |verifiable out-of-universe third party sources to establish its |notability Deletion of List of After Colony mobile units WP:RS||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11163 13083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of California public officials charged with crimes User:AndyTheGrump 18:15, 20 March 2012 (UTC) comment """For further evidence of how this list is contrary to Wikipedia standards, see """"A person may be included in a list of people if all the following requirements are met... The person meets the Wikipedia notability requirement. An exception to this requirement may be made if the person is famous for a specific event, the notability requirement need not be met..."""" How exactly does a """"""""Supervisor... indicted for rendering and collecting fraudulent claims against the county for road work on Union Avenue"""" - ''and then acquitted'' fall within such criteria? Do we have an article on the Road works in Union Avenue? The unorthodox way the article uses wikilinks between the names on the list and sections within it (which I've not seen used elsewhere) gives the misleading impression that we ''do'' have articles about these individuals. But no, almost al of these individuals neither meet Wikipedia notability requirements, and nor are they 'famous' for anything. ''Even those convicted of such crimes are ''not'' automatically suitable for inclusion on such lists'' unless (a) they independently meet Wikipedia notability standards, or (b) the crime in which they are involved in does. This is policy. If anyone thinks the policy is wrong, then propose that it be changed - but not here, we don't rewrite policy in AfD discussions""" Deletion of List of California public officials charged with crimes WP:LISTPEOPLE Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
11164 17515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanya aka T6 User:MuffledThud 12:52, 1 November 2009 (UTC) delete WP:PROMOTION for act that fails all twelve guidelines of , no significant coverage online from reliable sources per , can only find some blog coverage in GNEWS search. evident from creator: see http://thebestoftanya.com/blog/2009/09/12/hunter-the-associates-dame-grease-and-dj-benihana-presents-tanya-aka-t6-the-introduction-download-link Deletion of Tanya aka T6 WP:MUSICBIO||WP:RS||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
11165 10430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hi-C (rapper) User:Wisdom89 20:06, 24 March 2008 (UTC) comment """I'm really not understanding the motivation for this AfD - given the claims and the nominator stating """"for the record"""" that it's a weak keep, this discussion shouldn't technically be taking place. . I'm also going to go out on a limb and declare that this is going to be a |snow clause candidate in the near future""" Deletion of Hi-C (rapper) WP:COMMON||WP:SNOW "Wikipedia:What ""Ignore all rules"" means" 62
11166 7045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lower level design User:FreeRangeFrog 04:50, 28 December 2012 (UTC) delete Lower level design, because it's a neologism at best and at worst. However, '''Keep''' High level design, since it's a valid term, widely used and easily sourced (although it's a mess right now). I don't know that it was a good idea to nominate these two in the same AFD Deletion of Lower level design WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11167 7194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Pensa User:Lugnuts 10:28, 14 December 2014 (UTC) keep """per - """"The person has received a well-known and significant award or honor, or has been nominated for one several times"""". Has been nominate for several other awards. And per , too""" Deletion of Martin Pensa WP:ANYBIO||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11168 6617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Moran (supercentenarian) User:Green 16:05, 8 September 2013 (UTC) delete Three sources exist which verify his claimed age, but subject does not meet . It's not possible to check the Conner source since the book is rare, not held in any libraries,http://www.worldcat.org/search?q=ti%3AThis+is+Grundy+County+au%3Aconner&qt=advanced&dblist=638 not helping claims of notabilty Deletion of James Moran (supercentenarian) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11169 365 [[Jochen M. Wilms]] (gelöscht) NONE NONE keep Hat m.E. ausreichend Relevanz, sowohl wegen seiner Leistungen als Unternehmer wie auch als Mitproduzent für den Amnesty-Song, wodurch er in reputablen und fachbezogenen Medien ziemlich starke Beachtung erfahren hat. Siehe z.B. Presseberichte wie http://www.derwesten.de/staedte/schwerte/jochen-wilms-produzierte-id6613975.html diesen, http://www.alternativmusik.de/neuigkeiten/toast-to-freedom-eine-hymne-an-die-freiheit/ diesen, http://www.alternativmusik.de/neuigkeiten/toast-to-freedom-eine-hymne-an-die-freiheit/ diesen, http://www.rocktimes.de/news/news.php?NewsOffset=15 hier und weitere. - Damit erscheint erfüllt Löschung von Jochen M. Wilms Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
11170 12118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Hana User:Wildthing61476 16:56, 18 October 2006 (UTC) keep There seems to be enough |reliable sources to validate him, plus he seems to be the New Zealand equivalent of the Shakespeare Lady Deletion of Ben Hana WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11171 3656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big data (3rd nomination) User:BDD 22:23, 25 July 2012 (UTC) keep It may not be a well defined concept, but that hasn't kept it from being heavily discussed in . From the first page of Google hits alone you have discussions from IBM, McKinsey & Company, and ''Forbes''. I'm not surprised that it was deleted in 2009, but the second nomination was a pretty clear keep over two years ago, and the idea has only become bigger since. It was also a http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2685/4461757843_7869b5d691.jpg cover story in ''Nature (journal)|Nature'', one of over 8000 Google Scholar hits. References already in the article include ''The Economist'' and ''Harvard Business Review''. It's a bit of a buzzword (buzzphrase?) these days, so I'm sympathetic if you want it to go away, but this isn't the way it will happen Deletion of Big data (3rd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11172 20616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Kassel User:GiantSnowman 14:39, 26 November 2009 (UTC) delete fails and ; a college career isn't enough, recreate if and when this guy ever plays as a professional Deletion of Matt Kassel WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11173 14776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Costas Pilea User:GiantSnowman 07:02, 21 July 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Costas Pilea WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11174 4814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lily Blake Capwell User:Bearcat 22:15, 19 February 2018 (UTC) delete To be considered notable, a television character needs to be |reliably sourceable to media coverage which suggests some real-world context for notability — it's ''not'' enough to just write an in-universe summary of her own story arc, if you can't demonstrate that she had any ''impact'' on ''real life''. But nothing here demonstrates any real-world notability, and none of the content is sourced to justify merging Deletion of Lily Blake Capwell WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11175 7371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moonies User:Cirt 14:28, 27 September 2009 (UTC) keep """very noteworthy. Satisfies . Topic has received significant coverage in Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable Wikipedia:No original research#Primary, secondary and tertiary sources|secondary sources that are Wikipedia:Verifiability#Sources|independent of the subject. Literally ''thousands'' of possible sources in http://books.google.com/books?&as_brr=0&as_pub=-icon&q=%22Moonies%22 books and http://scholar.google.com/scholar?&q=%22Moonies%22 scholarly sources. '''Note:''' Among the books and scholarly sources, ''multiple'' sources have the very ''title'' of their works using """"Moonies..."""" in the title""" Deletion of Moonies WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11176 16215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IANAL (2nd nomination) User:TheBilly 09:06, 2 January 2008 (UTC) delete """Popularity, age, and hilarity (lol, anal) are irrelevant. Length of the article is also irrelevant. Don't be wowed by its long article, people; the content, however long, is in clear violation of #DICT and . An article should not exist just to 1) define a term (#DICT) 2) advise how it's used - """"Wikipedia is not a jargon or usage guide"""" (#DICT) 3) describe its etymology (). This article does all of these but nothing else. Triple whammy. It should be archived as a good example of a terrible jargon article, but it should be deleted nonetheless""" Deletion of IANAL (2nd nomination) WP:NOT||WP:NEO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11177 13176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gilaki and Mazandarani User:Gorthian 03:20, 15 January 2017 (UTC) comment ping|Uanfala|Cnilep}} It sounds as if this is more of a than just a straightforward dab page. Do either of you want to take it on, to make it into an article? Even a stub? I am woefully inadequate in these fields, and have little access to anything other than free online sources Deletion of Gilaki and Mazandarani WP:DABCONCEPT Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
11178 8160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Openbiz Cubi User:BenTels 00:56, 11 August 2012 (UTC) delete Does not seem to meet the requirements of either or . Given the nature of the framework, is not likely to meet the significance requirements of even if sources are found Deletion of Openbiz Cubi WP:GNG||WP:NSOFT||WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11179 18931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beaglier User:Kingofaces43 17:40, 13 December 2019 (UTC) delete in general. is the relevent policy requiring ''significant'' sustained useage, and I agree with what appears to be the current consensus that List of dog crossbreeds handles these generally non-notable cross-breeds fine. Cunard's listings above don't really convince me otherwise on those areas. As Fish+Karate said though, I do think Cockapoo, Goldendoodle, and Goldador could warrant having their own individual AfD instead (with no prejudice against the filer for filing these as all one). Those might be more likely to be redirects instead (e.g., golden lab already redirects to Labrador Retriever, and using goldador tries to bypass that, but individual AfD is the best place for that kind of focused cleanup. Overall though, encyclopedic articles would be sticking to mostly https://www.akc.org/press-center/facts-and-stats/breeds-year-recognized recognized breeds as one standard. Simply doing a cross and making up a name and having a few sources that are fairly indiscriminate , does not meet notability Deletion of Beaglier WP:NEOLOGISM||WP:NOTCATALOGUE Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11180 14916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slidefinder User:Bonadea 08:11, 16 July 2009 (UTC) delete Fails , all search hits in Google (including Swedish-language ones) are press releases or business-card type information in business directories Deletion of Slidefinder WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11181 3261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Fontaine User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:37, 5 August 2010 (UTC) delete """I tried to make it prettier and even learned that one of the films she was in (''Look (film)'') actually has a Wikipedia article... and though some of her roles do appear to be lead roles and might push at , after my going through the 99 """"Jennifer Fontaine"""" results afforded by http://news.google.com/archivesearch?as_user_ldate=1992&as_user_hdate=2010&q=%22Jennifer+Fontaine%22+source%3A%22-newswire%22+source%3A%22-wire%22+source%3A%22-presswire%22+source%3A%22-PR%22+source%3A%22-press%22+source%3A%22-release%22+source%3A%22-wikipedia%22&scoring=a&q=%22Jennifer+Fontaine%22+source%3A%22-newswire%22+source%3A%22-wire%22+source%3A%22-presswire%22+source%3A%22-PR%22+source%3A%22-press%22+source%3A%22-release%22+source%3A%22-wikipedia%22&lnav=od&btnG=Go THIS search, I found one 2006 silver award from WorldFest-Houston International Film Festival for a film she produced in 2005, and only a very few mentions of her in regards other folks being in her film ''Stealth''... but nothing substantive that would support a BLP""" Deletion of Jennifer Fontaine WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11182 17513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Birth Certificate Jeddah User:Cocytus 01:41, 3 January 2010 (UTC) delete difficult to determine what this even ''is''. At any rate, it's either nonsense, or, more likely, a soap-box/rant with some ostensibly mixed in to boot. References are non-sense, it seems Deletion of Birth Certificate Jeddah WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11183 8876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pradeep Bashyal User:Amrit 16:42, 7 October 2017 (UTC) keep He is a notable journalist here in Nepal. He has also written for international media like https://thediplomat.com/2017/05/demystifying-everest/ The Diplomat , https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/american-climber-dies-on-mount-everest-authorities-say/2017/05/21/7567c3a0-4db2-4528-a6e6-c928e3a9f43c_story.html Washington Post, https://www.buzzfeed.com/anupkaphle/nepals-hospitals-are-running-out-of-medicine-as-blockade-sho?utm_term=.go47Vj51A#.auWDqWGoE Buzzfeed. And also he is the editorial of Nepal Magazine.So, since reliable sources are used for the notability of and since he has been writing and co-writing newspaper article for reliable magazines like Washington Post,this article satisfy the guideline Deletion of Pradeep Bashyal WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
11184 17452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randa Markos User:Papaursa 04:11, 16 December 2014 (UTC) merge She definitely fails to meet and the article could reasonably be deleted. I agree with Peter's reasoning about the redirect and that appearing on TUF shouldn't merit an automatic redirect Deletion of Randa Markos WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
11185 1162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Tollett User:Blue 14:35, 1 January 2016 (UTC) delete """for failing . Not known for anything other than """"also ran"""" in a beauty pageant. State title holders don't meet on that alone""" Deletion of Lisa Tollett WP:ANYBIO||WP:PAGEDECIDE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11186 18504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flood in Thamirabarani River in 2015 [[User talk:SSTflyer|sst✈]] 04:45, 31 December 2015 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Flood in Thamirabarani River in 2015 WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11187 21284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phil Verity User:Rushyo 18:47, 21 December 2012 (UTC) merge He needs independent notability, it is not transferred from Mazars (although that fact may form part of the justification for an article, it's not nearly sufficient for ). In addition is not a legit argument Deletion of Phil Verity WP:N||WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11188 20782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amarachi Okafor User:scope_creep 09:44, 17 December 2019 (UTC) keep I think there is sufficient notability here. Certainly the classic artist type, with a long history of work. It will be a wee seed article satisfying until she becomes internationally famous Deletion of Amarachi Okafor WP:THREE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11189 18467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anya Shevchenko User:Inter 01:47, 24 March 2021 (UTC) delete Subject fails right now, the majority of citations in the article are from non-reliable or primary sources like Getty images, magazines, and IMDB Deletion of Anya Shevchenko WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11190 12725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emily Lipari User:DarkAudit 18:47, 19 November 2009 (UTC) delete does not pass . No Olympic or World Championships appearances. No world or national records. Just a very talented runner at the state level. requires more than that Deletion of Emily Lipari WP:ATHLETE||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11191 18137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/H Dice Game User:Kolbasz 16:24, 2 April 2016 (UTC) delete Pure promotion. This article should have been speedied under as soon as it got created Deletion of H Dice Game WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11192 10584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Macclesfield Chess Club User:Stalwart111 07:32, 28 January 2015 (UTC) delete local club that wouldn't seem to meet Deletion of Macclesfield Chess Club WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
11193 9236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greeks in the Philippines User:CaliforniaAliBaba 13:45, 26 April 2009 (UTC) delete WP:BIGNUMBER|size and |worries about precedent-setting aren't reasons for deletion, but the lack of |non-trivial, reliable sources (i.e. something larger than one embassy page and random bits of trivia about individual Greeks who did things in the Philippines) certainly is Deletion of Greeks in the Philippines WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS||WP:N Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11194 3640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shayna hetzel User:Montco 04:11, 11 February 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Shayna hetzel WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11195 2688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pink's fifth studio album User:Esradekan 01:35, 13 August 2008 (UTC) delete Go The Deletion of Pink's fifth studio album WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
11196 21500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ned Gamble User:DoomsDay349 17:03, 10 June 2007 (UTC) delete per #A1 and #A7 Deletion of Ned Gamble WP:CSD||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11197 3611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jessica Hammer User:David 18:29, 16 January 2017 (UTC) keep Her https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=vSvRUAkAAAAJ Google scholar shows three well-cited papers but then it drops off steeply. I don't think there's enough depth there for #C1, although it's a case of — she should be there eventually. I can't read the Pensacola or Capital stories, but of the rest, only the Tribune and Kill Switch pieces are actually in-depth, independent, and about her or her work. (The NYT story, for instance, only gives a pull quote by her, not relevant for notability.) But maybe that's enough for Deletion of Jessica Hammer WP:PROF||WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11198 14132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dance of the Goblins [[User talk:DatRoot|DatRoot]] 00:11, 15 November 2007 (UTC) delete per above. I wish her luck with the film but until it's made, fails Deletion of Dance of the Goblins WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
11199 20733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agoda User:Masterpiece2000 08:30, 11 June 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Agoda WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11200 14998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2022 United States Senate election in California User:Yompi20 23:49, 20 November 2019 (UTC) keep This article relates to the next upcoming election, and is therefore notable and certain to take place. I see no violation of Deletion of 2022 United States Senate election in California WP:NOTCRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11201 406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Lee Dumas NONE NONE delete forbes, inc and entrepreneur alone are not sources with sufficient editorial oversight to create notability on Wikipedia, especially as the above linked sources are contributor pieces, not staff writers. In other words, those pieces are written by marketers and bloggers and not journalists. I acknowledge that sources like these are often used to fill out details in an article such as this but we should not rely on these types of sources entirely for notability, especially with respect to . Thus, doesn’t apply here. There is a genuine question surrounding subject’s notability Deletion of John Lee Dumas WP:BLP||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11202 4603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of articles on criticism in Wikipedia User:MER 06:46, 27 January 2007 (UTC) merge to project space, where it should find a good home. Too |self-referential Deletion of List of articles on criticism in Wikipedia WP:ASR Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
11203 3437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Ellen Niver User:Bearian 00:26, 21 April 2015 (UTC) delete """per . One of the worse written articles I've ever seen in 8 years as an active Wikipedian. """"Local Expert"""" means |run of the mill travel blogger. """"Are you serious""" Deletion of Lisa Ellen Niver WP:TNT||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
11204 954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TV IV (3rd nomination) User:DHowell 04:02, 31 May 2007 (UTC) keep or '''Merge''' into Something Awful until independent notability can be better established. If this doesn't strictly meet the guidelines, this ought to be an exception to those guidelines Deletion of TV IV (3rd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11205 8641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Order of Mata Nui User:Tnxman307 14:56, 17 May 2008 (UTC) delete Sources seem to point towards forum posts and the like. As nom said, article duplicates material found elsewhere. Article does not meet Deletion of Order of Mata Nui WP:PLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11206 9488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irob0t User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable website. &mdash Deletion of Irob0t WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11207 5730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Extraterrestrial skies User:RockMagnetist 19:14, 3 April 2013 (UTC) keep I don't see among the -REASON|reasons for deletion. It may contain some , but not exclusively; and it easily meets the |general notability criteria. There are plenty of facts that either have citations or for which they could be found - after all, we have sent satellites to most of these bodies, and even taken pictures from the surfaces of some Deletion of Extraterrestrial skies WP:OR||WP:DEL||WP:OR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:No original research 65
11208 9481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Municipal Autonomy Study in Puerto Rico User:Stifle 23:47, 13 February 2006 (UTC) delete per above. Deletion of Municipal Autonomy Study in Puerto Rico WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11209 7164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Optare Sigma user:Andrew 12:29, 17 January 2021 (UTC) keep """No, that's not it – the nomination is quite mistaken. The subject is covered in detail in the ''https://www.google.co.uk/books/edition/The_History_of_Optare/DFf9DwAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=Optare+Sigma&pg=PT7&printsec=frontcover History of Optare'', as one would expect. Our policy applies, """"''If editing can improve the page, this should be done rather than deleting the page""" Deletion of Optare Sigma WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
11210 16413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary Schwartz (actor) (2nd nomination) User:Msteckl 22:35, 28 August 2019 (UTC) keep The concern for insufficient substance to meet |acting notability is noted: Thank you. While the article satisfies the first element of the notability guidelines by pointing to a longstanding IMDb body of work including lead character in an Oscar-winning film, it perhaps does not adequately describe or quantify the second element; celebrity status and following among a specific fan base. The voice is well known in the gamer community and the characters are followed by an established international network of fans. So while he enjoys a degree of public anonymity because he is visually not as easily recognized alongside his celebrity peers in narrative film and television, he holds an elevated status when it comes to animated work. It is true that the article needs to better address the third element of notability; that of describing significant or unique contribution to a discipline of the entertainment industry. The focus on his work as a subject matter expert in the art of mime, improvisation and game techniques falls into this arena because it is rare and sought after, yet not fully developed in the article. As an Alternative to Deletion, I suggest that further expansion of the article content and additional citations could fully satisfy all three elements and eliminate notability concerns Deletion of Gary Schwartz (actor) (2nd nomination) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
11211 8725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The amazing race 17 User:Cocytus 18:24, 1 December 2009 (UTC) delete who's to say this will actually happen? Delete per Deletion of The amazing race 17 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11212 68 [[Frutanismus]] (erl., Redirekt) Benutzer:Nepenthes 20:05, 24. Jun. 2007 (CEST) merge Im April gabs übrigens /8._April_2007#Frugivore_Ern.C3.A4hrung_.28erl._gesch.C3.BCtzter_Redirect.29|eine ähnliche Diskussion über den Begriff Frugivore Ernährung die mit Redirect auf Frutarier gelöst wurde. Und das wird wohl auch in diesem Fall die beste Lösung sein. Inzwischen verweisen zusätzlich bereits Fruganer, Fruitaner, Fructarier, Frutaner, Fruganismus, Fruitarier und Frutarismus auf diese Seite. Also und gut ist's Löschung von Frutanismus Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
11213 3759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raging Fetus User:AmitDeshwar 01:21, 21 September 2006 (UTC) delete Having a my space account does not meet (of course if some how information is dug up showing that they meet , then I'm all for keeping Deletion of Raging Fetus WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11214 4117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cocknubbing User:Part 14:55, 21 February 2007 (UTC) delete Fails . Just prod this kind of crap; don't even bother with afd Deletion of Cocknubbing WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11215 16889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dauros User:Biruitorul 01:14, 12 September 2009 (UTC) delete no, http://tfwiki.net/wiki/Rise_Up!!_Pretenders a fan wiki is not a reliable source; neither is a http://www.geocities.com/oblivionsgallery13/techsmasterforce.html GeoCities fan page, http://www.animevice.com/transformers-masterforce/11-1548/all-images/84-48423/transformersmasterforce/83-2900/ a picture posted on a blog, or http://www.absoluteanime.com/transformers_masterforce/index.htm a forum post. Mathewignash, after 3 and a half years on Wikipedia, it's high time you read and , and applied those policies in practice Deletion of Dauros WP:RS||WP:SPS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11216 9984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lowell Greenough - Artist and Anti War Activist User:Bahamut0013 20:14, 28 February 2011 (UTC) delete fails , , , and . No proof of notability, massive |NPOV and |COI issues, the only three |RSs only prove he was a conscientious objector and some of his art was exhibited in LA, and the article as it stands is a mess Deletion of Lowell Greenough - Artist and Anti War Activist WP:GNG||WP:BIO||WP:ARTIST||WP:MILPEOPLE||WP:NPOV||WP:COI||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11217 3092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kanon Wakeshima [[User talk:76.222.241.44|talk]]) 04:23, 3 January 2009 (UTC) keep I draw your attention to criteria #2 of . She has landed a charted position on a national chart (#22 w/ her first single Still Doll on the Oricon daily), and therefore is a notable artist. She must only meet one item for her to be included as a notable artist. —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/76.222.241.44|76.222.241.44 Deletion of Kanon Wakeshima WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11218 15695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vamos a la playa (Righeira album) User:Synthwave 14:49, 31 March 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Vamos a la playa (Righeira album) WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
11219 2500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vakhtang Kvaratskelia User:GiantSnowman 10:36, 31 January 2013 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Vakhtang Kvaratskelia WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11220 19070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Spirit of the Beast User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:52, 11 August 2012 (UTC) delete for complete failure of . It ''might'' exist, but no one has written of it... giving us the additional headache of failing Deletion of The Spirit of the Beast WP:NF||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
11221 12667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coje Ya Menia (creature) User:Eggishorn 20:37, 13 August 2020 (UTC) merge reduced version to List_of_cryptids#Aquatic_or_semi-aquatic. The only source that meets requirements and is is Ley (1959) ''Exotic Zoology''. This is enough to demonstrate that it has been discussed outside cryptozoology circles (Ley was a postwar general science writer) but not enough to demonstrate GNG coverage for an independent article Deletion of Coje Ya Menia (creature) WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
11222 14306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bartimaeus (Bartimaeus trilogy) User:DHowell 23:49, 17 November 2008 (UTC) keep """While I'd never heard of him before, this is apparently the main character of a best-selling book series, and there is plenty of reliable source coverage of the books and the trilogy—and it is logical that any coverage of the books and trilogy is going to cover the main character. """"No current assertion for future improvement of the article"""" seems to be simply a """"|no effort"""" argument and is not a valid reason for deletion""" Deletion of Bartimaeus (Bartimaeus trilogy) WP:NOEFFORT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11223 6892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karen Filippelli (fictional character) User:onel5969 13:59, 20 December 2020 (UTC) merge the reception section as stated above, the subject itself fails Deletion of Karen Filippelli (fictional character) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11224 13850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sir Cecil Bisshopp, 10th Baronet (2nd nomination) User:Sirfurboy 12:14, 24 February 2020 (UTC) delete very well. Although the nom. has presented no valid deletion rationale, {{User|Debresser}} has done so, and thus I have considered this. I took a look at the previous deletion discussion and am persuaded by the previous nominator's argument. The subject was a clergyman and a baronet. He may have been an archdeacon, but this is unclear. Nevertheless only bishops are considered notable by virtue of their position alone. Likewise a baronet is not notable for being a baronet alone. The sources uncovered are all of a level and depth one would assume for a clergyman and baronet, but as the previous nominator noted, they do not establish notability for a biographical article. This subject does not meet . Arguments in the previous AfD failed to address this question of what specifically makes this clergyman/baronet notable. One of the previous arguments was that the page should be kept for now, and allowed to sit until September 2013 to see if it could be improved, and failing that it could come back to AfD. It is now 7.5 years beyond that deadline and the article is unimproved. Although deletion is not for cleanup, it is my view that it is not improved because there is nothing more to be said about the subject. He is not notable. He does not receive significant coverage in reliable sources, except for the reason that he was a baronet and clergyman Deletion of Sir Cecil Bisshopp, 10th Baronet (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11225 12920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Government warehouse (fiction) User:Suriel1981 07:13, 29 May 2012 (UTC) delete High time this went. I've checked out 10 different revisions in the page history and not found a time when the article didn't violate and . In 8 years, nobody has ever demonstrated the subject itself has been the source of discussion in any reliable sources Deletion of Government warehouse (fiction) WP:GNG||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
11226 4185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Starpoint Gemini user:H3llkn0wz 18:40, 26 August 2011 (UTC) keep Secondary sources are in the article, fully satisfies . Developer's notability is irrelevant per . — Deletion of Starpoint Gemini WP:GNG||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
11227 8953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Wii modchips User:FangzofBlood 23:30, 10 December 2007 (UTC) delete fails in |notablity and seems like an Wikipedia:Spam|ad as well Deletion of List of Wii modchips WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11228 15700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UniLang User:Can 08:18, 19 December 2005 (UTC) keep It appears to be notable enough for inclusion, based upon my reading of Deletion of UniLang WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11229 17685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hit Collection 2000 User:Gongshow 18:34, 10 July 2017 (UTC) delete """no significant coverage found; appears to fail and . I might have supported a redirect but there are """"Hit Collection 2000"""" compilations for other artists""" Deletion of Hit Collection 2000 WP:GNG||WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
11230 20890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trigun yaoi (second nomination) User:TBC 03:07, 7 April 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Trigun yaoi (second nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11231 6836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Freddoso User:Pdcook 03:23, 7 September 2010 (UTC) keep Seems to meet through coverage in reliable sources Deletion of David Freddoso WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11232 19073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inez Melson User:Falcon 01:39, 31 December 2020 (UTC) delete She doesn't notability from Marilyn Monroe. Anything that should be said about her in the context of her work could probably be said there, but I'm not seeing anything in this article worth merging Deletion of Inez Melson WP:INHERIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11233 8678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FreeRice User:Ultraexactzz 20:50, 18 November 2007 (UTC) keep The sources provided seem to establish (some) notability. My research pulls some of the same sources, so I know that they at least appear to be legitimate. Does the nom have sources that contradict the claims of the article? Even if the project is not successful, or is not yet successful, it has still received enough independent coverage to satisfy notability. If further research shows the subject to be , then I'll happily advocate deletion. I don't see any evidence of that at this time, though Deletion of FreeRice WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
11234 7973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CHHIP User:Mark 03:47, 16 June 2016 (UTC) comment I've added the Lancet Oncology piece to the article. So far I am seeing a number of reliable but primary papers on the topic; nothing yet -worthy Deletion of CHHIP WP:MEDRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11235 10647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mortal Kombat storyline User:NeoChaosX 23:34, 1 June 2007 (UTC) delete Is this article really necessary? The storyline for each game is explained in the individual game articles already, and unlike other (mostly Japanese-developed) series, there isn't much outside of the games that add to the series' canon. If it is kept, however, move it to Mortal Kombat plot or some other name that fits the |Manual of Style Deletion of The Mortal Kombat storyline WP:MOS Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
11236 1736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Merit (band) User:Bren 07:03, 12 June 2007 (UTC) comment """re the two deletes after the AfD relist: can I get an explaination of ''why'' this article fails ? Point one states """"It has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent from the musician/ensemble itself and reliable."""" The article has now been modified to meet this criteria, so I'd just appreciate a little more on your reasoning. Thanks""" Deletion of Merit (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
11237 20241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of blues-rock cover songs User:Wurzburgwatch 22:42, 17 January 2010 (UTC) delete """Unnecessary , listcruft. The format and content can easily be accommodated in the pre-existing article List of blues standards, which has plenty of room for more entries. In fact that list already includes a number of blues-rock songs including """"Travelling Riverside Blues""" Deletion of List of blues-rock cover songs WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
11238 10958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chhedilal User:Bearcat 18:46, 21 July 2018 (UTC) delete """There's a credible notability claim being made here, but it's not supported by any |reliable sourcing to verify that it's actually true. We've had a ''lot'' of articles created over the years about """"notable"""" politicians who ''didn't'' really hold the political office they were claimed to have held, like the Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Snipplet hoax — so it's not the unsourced ''claim'' of holding a notable political office that gets a person over , but the reliable sourcing that can be shown to properly |verify that the claim of holding a notable political office is ''true''. I'm willing to reconsider this if somebody with better access to Indian media sourcing than I've got can find proper verification — but the baseline for inclusion in Wikipedia is not just what an article claims, but how well it ''sources'' what it claims""" Deletion of Chhedilal WP:RS||WP:NPOL||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11239 13905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luke George (footballer) User:Sir 15:06, 13 August 2017 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Luke George (footballer) WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11240 5530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mexico–Serbia relations User:Marcusmax 00:05, 11 May 2009 (UTC) keep This article meets all the standards of a good Wikipedia article, referenced with multiple reliable sources and those who are not are referenced with secondary sources meet Deletion of Mexico–Serbia relations WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
11241 5140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Byron User:Djsasso 03:19, 3 July 2009 (UTC) delete Non-notable amateur player who has yet to play professionally so fails to meet or . Also fails 's guidelines for player notablity /PPF#NOTE. Can be recreated when/if he plays professionally or otherwise achieves notability Deletion of Paul Byron WP:ATHLETE||WP:N||WP:HOCKEY||WP:HOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
11242 10609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in West Lancashire User:Beagel 14:52, 26 March 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of bus routes in West Lancashire WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11243 6712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derek Pasquill User:Mkativerata 07:42, 12 April 2010 (UTC) delete """A very very clear . If it were not for the legal issue, this guy would be thoroughly unnotable. I need not point out that is policy (through ), not a guideline. Unless there are compelling reasons not to, it must be followed if we accept that this is a BLP1E case. If this was a """"test case"""", lets have an article on the case""" Deletion of Derek Pasquill WP:BLP1E||WP:BLP1E||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11244 4206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jasmin Čampara User:J 19:42, 2 April 2011 (UTC) delete fails and . Recreate the article if he does go on to play at professional/international level in future Deletion of Jasmin Čampara WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11245 20284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HRnetGroup User:SailingInABathTub 14:17, 17 April 2021 (UTC) delete doesn't meet , sources are limited to trivial business activities and PR Deletion of HRnetGroup WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11246 14271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ron-Robert Zieler (2nd nomination) [[User_talk:ClubOranje|T]] 10:46, 4 February 2009 (UTC) delete fails and in that has not played yet in anything notable, recreate if and when--ClubOranje Deletion of Ron-Robert Zieler (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE||WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11247 19120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Fife (Captain Billy Fife) User:Dru 12:16, 23 November 2011 (UTC) delete With regrets. Fascinating unencyclopedic attested to by the author's five I's 'I have outlined the true facts...', 'I will look at the facts...' 'I would like to state...', 'I agree that...', and 'I would ask you to think... (excepting the quote); no claim of coverage in books or , and I was not able to locate any, either Deletion of William Fife (Captain Billy Fife) WP:OR||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
11248 3358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joaquim Ferreira (fighter) User:LiberatorLX 23:21, 23 October 2013 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet , he did beat a UFC champion though, so maybe passes Deletion of Joaquim Ferreira (fighter) WP:NMMA||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11249 17746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Claudio D. Zivic User:Bakazaka 03:38, 22 October 2018 (UTC) delete """A significant portion of this article is not actually about the subject or his work at all. That said, the sources listed in the article are either not independent (''Church News'', ''Ensign'', lds.org, ''Liahona''), trivial mentions (''Deseret News''), not reliable (""""Grampa Bill""""), or primary (quotes from a speech in the blog ''Meridian Magazine''), so they don't establish notability under . Search finds passing mentions of ceremonial duties like opening a temple or short quotes from speeches, some apparently in ''Deseret News'' but actually produced by the official ''Church News'' staff. Having a name or a quote in an article is not . It's trivial. So subject does not appear to meet . Open to alternatives if significant coverage emerges""" Deletion of Claudio D. Zivic WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11250 10862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lynn Chadwick (radio) (2nd nomination) User:Hansi667 09:54, 30 August 2015 (UTC) delete Not even close to meeting . The sources should be about her, not just mentioning her and this doesn't seem to be the case Deletion of Lynn Chadwick (radio) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11251 21181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenza Drider User:Sionk 23:07, 18 June 2012 (UTC) keep the article needs fleshing out using the available sources, she is clearly a notable campaigner for the right to wear the veil. The http://www.digitaljournal.com/article/311818 Digital Journal also refers to other coverage in the Daily Mail and Saudi Gazette. Meets Deletion of Kenza Drider WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11252 6440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minor characters in the Ranma ½ manga User:Quasirandom 04:29, 26 February 2008 (UTC) keep valid of an article for a very ''large'' and complicated franchise. Needs hella cleanup and sourcing, but I note that a group of editors were already discussing how to handle the organization of the suite of articles before the AfD got started -- step back, let 'em |do their job, and when the dust settles, revisit if there are remaining notability concerns Deletion of Minor characters in the Ranma ½ manga WP:SPINOFF||WP:EP Wikipedia:Content forking 33
11253 362 [[Carmeq GmbH]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Blunts NONE delete Auch für Tochterfirmen von VW gelten die |Relevanzkriterien Löschung von Carmeq GmbH Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
11254 6932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iskra Menarini User:RebeccaGreen 12:47, 16 December 2019 (UTC) keep """From the information in the article, it seems that this musician may meet #6: """"is a musician who has been a reasonably prominent member of two or more independently notable ensembles"""". She certainly was a """"reasonably prominent member"""" of Lucio Dalla's group, being his vocalist for 24 years, including on a single, {{ill|Attenti al lupo|it}}, that was No 1 for 4 weeks in 1990/91. She was also vocalist with Samuele Bersani, Vasco Rossi, Raffaella Carrà, and others, on albums/singles at least some of which also reached the top 10. The article now has sources. It certainly needs editing, and it would be good if someone could find the offline sources used in the Italian article, and indeed find other offline sources, but she does appear notable. I will try to edit the article and add citations for as much information as possible from online sources""" Deletion of Iskra Menarini WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11255 17730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henri Vincent-Anglade User:Comte0 10:04, 13 July 2020 (UTC) delete per . I found him in the Benezit Dictionary of Artists|benezit (https://www.oxfordartonline.com/benezit/view/10.1093/benz/9780199773787.001.0001/acref-9780199773787-e-00191437?rskey=7H80Tr&result=1) and I believe he's notable, but that article is a copyvio. Regards Deletion of Henri Vincent-Anglade WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
11256 19108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ross Aubrey User:Movementarian 08:01, 1 January 2006 (UTC) delete Does not appear to meet requirements in Deletion of Ross Aubrey WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11257 8718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DirectStarTV User:Ravenswing 20:19, 18 May 2006 (UTC) delete per nom as failing . This is like an outfit claiming notability because they're Charlotte's leading Toyota dealership. Stipulating so, so what Deletion of DirectStarTV WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11258 9511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Thompson (politician) User:Bearcat 14:57, 19 December 2020 (UTC) delete """without prejudice against recreation if somebody can write and reference something more substantial. To be fair, he isn't interim ''president'' of the party, he's interim ''leader'' of the party — that is, he's not the person who presides over the party's internal board meetings, he's the person who would be the party's candidate for ''premier of the province'' if New Brunswick were to hold an election tomorrow. (But it won't, as it just had one a few months ago that resulted in a majority government for a different party than Thompson's.) But that said, being a party leader is not an automatic notability freebie under if the person isn't also an actual MLA in the legislature — to actually warrant an article, he would have to show ''substantive'' coverage of his work ''in'' the role, not just technical verification of his selection. So just being a party leader isn't enough in and of itself — and while the """"interim leader"""" vs. """"permanent leader"""" distinction doesn't have any direct bearing on the notability of a party leader per se, as interim leaders ''can'' be genuinely notable, it does ''tend'' to tamp down on the depth and volume of coverage that an interim leader actually gets. So he would need to have quite a bit more media coverage than this, enabling us to write something quite a bit more substantial than just """"Chris Thompson is a political party leader who exists"""", before he qualified for a Wikipedia article""" Deletion of Chris Thompson (politician) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11259 10904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mamiboy krisheno User:ConCompS 17:00, 16 November 2009 (UTC) delete per usic as previously stated above Deletion of Mamiboy krisheno WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
11260 12734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mr Hamburger User:onel5969 17:12, 30 November 2017 (UTC) delete not enough in-depth coverage from independent, reliable sources to show that it passes either or Deletion of Mr Hamburger WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
11261 17081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tegan Summer Productions User:Athaenara 03:06, 26 March 2008 (UTC) delete per #ADVERTISING policy and above Deletion of Tegan Summer Productions WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11262 7650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C. V. Savitri Gunatilleke User:Netherzone 16:10, 1 January 2019 (UTC) keep Seems like a solid keep based on her contributions to the field and reception of her work and research. Passes by way of #2, #3. #C1. May be worth investigating variations of her name Deletion of C. V. Savitri Gunatilleke WP:NACADEMIC||WP:NACADEMIC||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11263 2782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Santore User:Piotrus 16:23, 30 December 2016 (UTC) delete I couldn't find any coverage of him in GNews or GBooks. As written, the article fails . Verdict: non-notable artist Deletion of Robert Santore WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11264 5317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hellboy fictional timeline User:Shooterwalker 02:10, 7 March 2011 (UTC) delete putting aside how much I enjoy the timeline and the series... the timeline is entirely a plot summary, which fails what Wikipedia is not. See #PLOT which has been a policy in good standing for several years, despite failed attempts to come up with a better alternative. I suppose you can add some third-party sources that cover the reception and development of the series, but then that would belong in the main series article, not a devoted to repeating the same plot summary in list form Deletion of Hellboy fictional timeline WP:NOT||WP:CONTENTFORK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11265 11506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Nigro User:McJeff 23:13, 28 June 2008 (UTC) keep Person in question is on a professional team, and that clearly renders him notable per . I also find it troublesome that the nominator removed information from the articlehttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Anthony_Nigro&diff=222359093&oldid=222322816 before nominating it for deletionhttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Anthony_Nigro&diff=222359184&oldid=222359093 Deletion of Anthony Nigro WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11266 1732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/E-Land Puma FC User:Mattythewhite 14:56, 11 March 2012 (UTC) keep """Per . This says that """"All teams that have played in the national cup (or the national level of the league structure in countries where no cup exists) are assumed to meet criteria"""", which this team has, with the evidence supplied by Number 57""" Deletion of E-Land Puma FC WP:FOOTYN||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11267 10534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Don't Matter to Me User:SomeoneNamedDerek 05:32, 3 July 2018 (UTC) keep While this might be since the song has not charted in any countries yet and may not meet the three criterion of yet, the song has received a lot of attention in the news (about 3,560,000 results on https://www.google.com/search?tbm=nws&q=don%27t+matter+to+me+drake Google) and therefore can be a standalone article. On a side note, sources (including http://www.officialcharts.com/chart-news/drakes-new-album-scorpion-is-set-to-dominate-this-weeks-official-charts__23294/ Official Charts), indicate that this song in addition to other Drake songs in the album will chart after this week's tracking period; it will likely be notable for its own article next week Deletion of Don't Matter to Me WP:TOOSOON||WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
11268 15101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roll (Fab Morvan album) User:Esradekan 06:39, 20 May 2008 (UTC) delete WP:CRYSTAL, Deletion of Roll (Fab Morvan album) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11269 6322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Boulos User:Bearian 22:14, 25 January 2021 (UTC) delete he is |run of the mill as a business person, and |has has not done anything notable. We are Wikipedia, not |15SecondsOfFamepedia, nor Conservapedia, nor |a free web host, and |in 2021 everybody knows that Deletion of Michael Boulos WP:MILL||WP:GNG||WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTWEBHOST||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
11270 1594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rob Wyda User:Anotherclown 13:04, 13 August 2013 (UTC) delete """minor official lacking """"significant coverage in reliable sources"""" to constitute notability per (a few brief articles in minor newspapers hardly equals """"significant coverage""""). Kendrick7 pls don't bother reply to me too, it really is unseemly replying to every delete vote. You had your say, now let the rest of us do so in good faith pls""" Deletion of Rob Wyda WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11271 626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ajay Kapur User:Ajf773 23:38, 6 November 2019 (UTC) delete Hardly remarkable. Fails Deletion of Ajay Kapur WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11272 7824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lose a Shoe User:Persian 01:59, 5 January 2007 (UTC) delete seeing as the tag has now been placed and is unquestionably |patent nonsense Deletion of Lose a Shoe WP:NONSENSE Wikipedia:Patent nonsense 105
11273 4674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Una Healy User:GaGaOohLaLa 20:20, 25 November 2009 (UTC) delete these three singers have no notability outside of The Saturdays, therefore failing Deletion of Una Healy WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11274 4278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uzi-Eli Hezi User:The 16:12, 11 July 2020 (UTC) delete this |promotional text about a non-|notable subject Deletion of Uzi-Eli Hezi WP:PROMO||WP:NPERSON Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11275 20109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Science and Technology Center in Ukraine User:AllyD 19:52, 17 July 2011 (UTC) comment No rationale offered, but the page text is essentially a from http://www.stcu.int Deletion of Science and Technology Center in Ukraine :WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
11276 13649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/People Against Censorship User:Carlossuarez46 17:51, 7 June 2007 (UTC) delete """group fails in particular #Notability is not temporary; there is no evidence for anything but a quick dash of reflected glory in the press as Don Imus was self-destructing. Really little more notable than the driver of the """"red pickup"""" who allegedly was involved in Jon_Corzine#Motorcade_accident|The Governor of New Jersey's 90-MPH car crash during his attempt to get 15 minutes of political capital from the Imus incident""" Deletion of People Against Censorship WP:N||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11277 21084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashes fall User:JzG 19:17, 20 January 2007 (UTC) delete does not say that any band that ever featured anyone who went on to play in a notable is thereby notable, it says that this ''may'' be an indication that sufficient sources will exist. Aside from the fact that Mortal Treason barely passes , I could not find a single reliable independent source for this band anywhere on the internets, and that means ''policy'' says no article whatever ''guidelines'' might think. The primary notability criterion is multiple non-trivial coverage in reliable independent sources. I was not able to find ''any'' provably independent coverage for this band, trivial or not Deletion of Ashes fall WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11278 6089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chuck Loeb User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable vanity biography. &mdash Deletion of Chuck Loeb WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11279 3925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Gul Mallah (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 17:39, 6 January 2021 (UTC) delete per - it has already been deleted Deletion of Ali Gul Mallah (2nd nomination) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
11280 20790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aqua Jones User:MLauba 23:13, 4 April 2009 (UTC) comment in respect with underconstruction tag, however, a cursory google search / news check turned up nothing useful in terms of |reliable third party sources. Will change my vote to keep if sources turn up within a reasonable timeframe, delete otherwise Deletion of Aqua Jones WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11281 18432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marguerite Ceschi-Smith User:Bearcat 19:46, 21 July 2017 (UTC) delete This was created (not by me) at a time when was considerably looser about the notability of local political figures than it is now — technically, the notability claim here wasn't so much her role as a city councillor but her role with the Federation of Canadian Municipalities, but being on the board of directors of an organization isn't a free notability pass anymore either. The depth and breadth of coverage shown here don't pass what we now require for a person at this level of significance: even the FCM work is sourced only to local media in the city where she was a municipal councillor, and not to any evidence of ''wider'' media attention for it (and for a role of ''national'' scope, the ''lack'' of nationalized coverage ''does'' argue ''against'' deeming her notable for it.) So it was a good faith creation at the time, but Wikipedia's standards have been considerably tightened up over the years and it doesn't pass the test anymore Deletion of Marguerite Ceschi-Smith WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11282 12925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hans Roser User:Piotrus 08:49, 24 January 2021 (UTC) delete Unsourced, fails Deletion of Hans Roser WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11283 17279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Azam Khan (cricketer, born 1998) User:Spike 17:10, 13 August 2018 (UTC) delete first 3, they all fail NCRIC, no evidence they pass Deletion of Azam Khan (cricketer, born 1998) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11284 9606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alfonso Smith (running back) User:Freja 06:40, 19 August 2011 (UTC) keep Does not fail #American football/Canadian football Deletion of Alfonso Smith (running back) WP:ATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
11285 2012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Scott User:Captain 00:19, 12 May 2006 (UTC) keep Are all of these really good faith nominations? I don't believe they are. At best, I think we're well in territory; at worst, this smacks of vandalism Deletion of Greg Scott WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
11286 2506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyler Ward (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep per meeting and | #1. WP:MUSICBIO instructions are that at least one of the listed criteria be met.. and #1 is. It does not require that more than one, or that all of the great list shared by the nominator, need be. We also do not expect a singer who meets GNG and MUSICBIO also ''has'' meet the criteria set for |actors. I never heard of Tyler Ward before tyoday, and whether or not the nominator actually reseached his deletion nomination, a very |quick look finds international coverage for both his current music career and even his past sports career Deletion of Tyler Ward (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:MUSBIO||WP:ENT||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11287 13965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ancient Treasure Hunters NONE NONE delete I simply don't see the necessary number of independent and |reliable sources for this subject. Tangent: Nice website. Did you bother to get permission to use the Howie Day song Deletion of Ancient Treasure Hunters WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11288 16489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/23 Deluxe User:Óðinn 10:00, 18 December 2008 (UTC) delete fails usic Deletion of 23 Deluxe WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
11289 16467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ALinux User:NinjaRobotPirate 01:45, 22 October 2015 (UTC) delete Does not have significant coverage in reliable sources. Yes, it's possible that a stub was created just so that it could be added to a list of Linux distributions. However, we are under no obligation to keep these kinds of articles. We're not a |directory listing or |indiscriminate collection of information. Articles must satisfy our inclusion criteria. There are other places on the Internet that can and do catalog every single Linux distribution, such as DistroWatch Deletion of ALinux WP:NOTDIR||WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11290 7512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhys Morgan User:Bobrayner 13:44, 3 December 2011 (UTC) keep Multiple reliable sources attest that the subject ''really exists''; it's no hoax. Notability is not the strongest but I'm confident that it's past the benchmark. It's not really helpful that lots of people have turned up to make their first edit at this AfD, because decisions here are supposed to be based on the strongest policy-based arguments rather than who can muster the most friends (or sockpuppets). I would encourage people to frame their arguments in terms of policy, and to |assume good faith - deletion discussions can often be stressful or hostile, so resist the urge to escalate the conflict. However, if any of you recent editors would like to stick around and improve the article or - even better - improve other bits of the encyclopædia, I'd love to help Deletion of Rhys Morgan WP:NPEOPLE||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11291 10578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Olson (MInnesota Political Figure) User:Philosopher 05:01, 29 June 2009 (UTC) delete Doesn't show notability. Simply running for Congress doesn't meet the requirements of and there's nothing to suggest that he meets generally Deletion of Bob Olson (MInnesota Political Figure) WP:POLITICIAN||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11292 13682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Darden User:Bearian 20:27, 8 February 2021 (UTC) keep per and {{U|Blythwood}}. He appears to have designed a whole family of typefaces, ''Freight'', that has a cult fan base in the field of graphic design. For example, his work is discussed in the 2009 and 2011 editions of ''Graphics Design, Referenced'', https://www.google.com/books/edition/An_A_Z_of_Type_Designers/jxV4qEolEo8C?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=%22Joshua+Darden%22+-wikipedia&pg=PP112&printsec=frontcover a leading text of type design, a survey of African-American history|African-American historical https://www.google.com/books/edition/Energy_Experimentation/yIgwAQAAIAAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&bsq=%22Joshua+Darden%22+-wikipedia&dq=%22Joshua+Darden%22+-wikipedia&printsec=frontcover artists and designers, and |many other sources easily found online. The arguments for deletion are a tautology Deletion of Joshua Darden WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11293 4831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Enterprise Coaches User:SkierRMH 08:56, 10 December 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. fails Deletion of New Enterprise Coaches WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11294 7944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad Zubair (Pakistani cricketer) User:Rugbyfan22 09:23, 25 April 2021 (UTC) merge 6 FC and 5 LA games but as usual for Pakistani domestic cricketers we're struggling for sources. Sources may well exist offline or in local language sources. Redirect a suitable for now unless someone can find anything else Deletion of Mohammad Zubair (Pakistani cricketer) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
11295 13867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pardon of Joe Arpaio (2nd nomination) User:Sławomir 14:22, 14 November 2017 (UTC) keep Easy pass of Deletion of Pardon of Joe Arpaio (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11296 20002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nurse Ratched User:Hrafn 11:25, 20 July 2011 (UTC) delete WP:INUNIVERSE-only treatment of fictional material. Can be recreated if analysis providing a non-fictional perspective can be found Deletion of Nurse Ratched WP:SECONDARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
11297 15033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tsai Chia-Hsin User:Leebo 18:00, 9 April 2007 (UTC) keep """Passes as an athlete who has """"competed at the highest levels of amateur sports. 99DBSIMLR, please note this sentence as it applies to Olympic athletes before nominating any more for deletion""" Deletion of Tsai Chia-Hsin WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11298 3816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guillaume Bianchi User:Smartyllama 12:40, 31 July 2019 (UTC) keep Whether he meets is irrelevant because the sources are enough to meet Deletion of Guillaume Bianchi WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11299 4237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elixir institute of information technology User:Erpert 04:11, 26 May 2011 (UTC) delete per #G11|G11; tagged as such. Blatant advertisment for non-notable company; article |created by its founder. In addition, the company name barely has ten Ghits. '''Erpert Deletion of Elixir institute of information technology WP:CSD||WP:COI Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11300 2039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Politics in the British Isles User:BrownHairedGirl 13:28, 27 May 2012 (UTC) delete """This piece is yet another y creation by KarlB, a |synthesis of disparate topics created in furtherance of his campaign to construct the notion of a common polity across the so-called British Isles, and designed to serve as a head article for his self-created :Category:Politics of the British Isles. The topics covered are primarily a hybrid of 1) A fork of Ireland–United Kingdom relations, and 2) a description of government structures and international relations in the islands. Neither aspect is best described as """"politics"""".There may be some content in here which could be re-used in neutrally-focused articles, so I would be happy for the page to be userified""" Deletion of Politics in the British Isles WP:POINT||WP:SYN Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
11301 16701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boris Malagurski User:Yilloslime 07:06, 26 September 2009 (UTC) delete Fails . There are no independent, secondary sources that directly discuss this person in any detail. None are cited in the article, and I can't find any else Deletion of Boris Malagurski WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11302 5458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finduilas of Dol Amroth User:Hog 18:00, 28 November 2019 (UTC) delete Minor character and not a likely search term. Fails Deletion of Finduilas of Dol Amroth WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11303 17738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sgha User:Kinu 13:48, 17 August 2006 (UTC) comment The AfD process is designed to allow for improvement of the article within the five day course of listing. I feel that enough good faith has been given to Zinco100 (and any of the other supporters of the article, for that matter), despite the personal attacks, generalizations, violation in nominating another article for deletion. I have seen no desire by the supporters to improve the article to meet as explained herein, despite repeated requests to do so, and thus there is no need to break process in this instance Deletion of Sgha WP:POINT||WP:V Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
11304 8790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Statue of Responsibility (2nd nomination) User:Peterkingiron 15:26, 15 July 2019 (UTC) merge to Viktor Frankl. This currently fails Deletion of Statue of Responsibility (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11305 21264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of concluded webcomics User:Ravenswing 16:34, 26 October 2010 (UTC) delete Wow. Alright, this probably is a more useful list than List of webcomics referencing penises in their 150th issues, but not by a whole lot. I agree with Andrew that a viable category could be sustained, but I can't see how an article is appropriate; this is close to a failure Deletion of List of concluded webcomics WP:BULLSHIT Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
11306 7994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beyond the shadow of a doubt User:Solarra 23:08, 28 July 2014 (UTC) merge This article reeks of , but we need to look at the notability of the phrase itself. The phrase https://www.google.com/search?q=beyond+the+shadow+of+a+doubt&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a&channel=sb is notable but I don't see a need for a separate article Deletion of Beyond the shadow of a doubt WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11307 1800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter McFadden User:Ejgreen77 01:11, 17 June 2014 (UTC) keep as a straight-up pass. Stats linked to in the article confirm that McFadden played in the NFL Deletion of Walter McFadden WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
11308 9064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenneth Brian User:Cindamuse 07:14, 5 August 2010 (UTC) delete I have researched available resources online in comparison with the criteria and find that this individual does not meet notability for inclusion Deletion of Kenneth Brian WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11309 17129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yodasnews.com User:Bfigura 23:19, 30 April 2008 (UTC) delete as a non-notable website failing Deletion of Yodasnews.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11310 11183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Banjo Billy's Bus Tours User:Coolabahapple 08:31, 19 July 2019 (UTC) keep looked as if this would be a delete as, although the article has plenty of sources, they are nearly all local, until the indomitable {{u|Cunard}} cast their eye upon this and has provided sources that are non-local, so is met as well as Deletion of Banjo Billy's Bus Tours WP:AUD||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11311 20804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vengara (Kannur) User:Nuttah68 13:04, 16 September 2007 (UTC) keep as a village per Deletion of Vengara (Kannur) WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
11312 8814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boys and expression of healthy emotions User:Arthistorian1977 11:25, 14 August 2016 (UTC) delete as failing Deletion of Boys and expression of healthy emotions WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11313 4991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toy Meets Girl User:DHowell 02:31, 18 August 2007 (UTC) merge """to List of Robot Chicken episodes. says nothing about deleting articles, rather it says """"''If the article(s) contain little content, consider merging or redirecting them into another article (e.g. an article about the show itself, an article that is a list of episodes of the show, or an article that summarizes the plot for one season of the show""" Deletion of Toy Meets Girl WP:EPISODE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
11314 8833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Alton, Bordon and Tadley area (2nd nomination) User:Metropolitan90 16:08, 26 May 2012 (UTC) delete because Wikipedia is not a |directory or |travel guide. This article is completely unsourced, and I'm not sure what benefit it provides; anyone wanting to know how to get from one place to another in the Alton-Bordon-Tadley area would be better off consulting the bus company web site in order to find the routes and schedules of the buses, as opposed to this article which doesn't provide, and can't practically provide, such information. A similar article was deleted recently at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Huntingdon, St Ives and St Neots Deletion of List of bus routes in Alton, Bordon and Tadley area (2nd nomination) WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11315 16424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marius Dewilde User:Mikeman67 01:38, 6 March 2014 (UTC) comment That means it was essentially and against #NEWS. Particularly in the mid 20th century, a person claiming an extra-terrestrial encounter that generated temporary media coverage can hardly be said to be notable. It's not like there's even a section of the book dedicated to him (let alone an entire book or article), it looks like just a page in the book as an example Deletion of Marius Dewilde WP:ONEEVENT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11316 9841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sudarshan Venu User:AllyD 06:27, 15 July 2017 (UTC) comment """The Wikipedia:Help_desk/Archives/2017_July_6#Sudarshan_Venu_-_Noindex_tag_to_be_removed|question which was asked about who are the """"we"""" who ''""""want TVS Motor JMD's (Sudarshan Venu) Wiki Profile Page to be shown up in Search Results""""'' remains unanswered. Either / both a and a COI tag are needed""" Deletion of Sudarshan Venu :WP:DISCLOSE Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
11317 21088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crow stew User:Mkdw 00:58, 2 February 2013 (UTC) keep There are now |reliable sources addressing . The content largely avoids and puts it in line with other disk articles. Perhaps it is more obscure a dish, but notability is decided in the independent and reliable sources Deletion of Crow stew WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11318 9834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beemos User:Otolemur 19:52, 26 May 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Beemos WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11319 19450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Sabisky User:KartikeyaS343 07:48, 6 March 2020 (UTC) delete per with no prejudice to re-creation Deletion of Andrew Sabisky WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11320 13978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Biblical names User:Torritorri 18:50, 18 May 2010 (UTC) delete per and Mandsford's arguments, possibly transwiki to Wikisource if it is truly all from one source Deletion of List of Biblical names WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11321 9494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Homelessness in popular culture [[User: Allen3|Allen3]]'' [[User talk:Allen3|talk]] 01:03, 18 May 2009 (UTC) delete as per |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information and #OR|Wikipedia is not a publisher of original thought. Unbounded and |unsourced list of I-spy trivia bound together by the |new and novel concept that homelessness composes a significant part of popular culture Deletion of Homelessness in popular culture WP:IINFO||WP:NOT||WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11322 9260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Galla Aruna Kumari User:Salih 15:23, 13 July 2009 (UTC) keep Easily passes as per http://www.portal.ap.gov.in/Government/Lists/Council%20of%20Ministers/DispForm.aspx?ID=24 this. I would say a minister in state cabinet is inherently notable Deletion of Galla Aruna Kumari WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11323 19258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rudra The Beginning User:Hagennos 05:54, 28 January 2018 (UTC) delete Could not find any references other than primary sourced. The film has not been released yet and could not find any coverage of the upcoming film which will make it notable. Might be a case of and delete as it fails Deletion of Rudra The Beginning WP:TOOSOON||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Too soon 40
11324 12071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darkest of Days User:Gary 20:04, 24 April 2008 (UTC) keep Passes and with flying colors Deletion of Darkest of Days WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11325 6805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rashmi Sharma User:Spiderone 19:44, 13 October 2020 (UTC) delete due to lack of Deletion of Rashmi Sharma WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
11326 17818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Goofing off [[User Talk:Blaxthos|t]] / [[Special:Contributions/Blaxthos|c]] ) 02:36, 11 April 2008 (UTC) delete low hanging |fruit USER:Blaxthos|Blaxthos Deletion of Goofing off WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11327 6386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harris J (2nd nomination) User:Atlantic306 00:43, 11 June 2020 (UTC) keep as has significant reliable sources coverage such as https://tribune.com.pk/story/1485569/muslim-justin-bieber-releases-childrens-book-peace/ here,https://www.npr.org/2015/10/24/451456711/harris-j-pop-music-meets-islam here and https://www.cnnindonesia.com/hiburan/20161206200501-227-177813/laris-lewat-lagu-religi-harris-j-raih-platinum here. The third source from CNN Indonesia shows that he had an album released on a major label namely the Indonesian imprint of Warner Music and that album went platinum so he has claims to pass both and criterion 2, so there is no valid reason for deleting the article in my view Deletion of Harris J (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11328 14024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Linz sisters User:Sr13 23:59, 6 April 2007 (UTC) keep I suspect that the article passes , but I am skeptical Deletion of Linz sisters WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11329 21391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Todd Dunphy User:Papaursa 23:54, 13 June 2016 (UTC) delete Some tournament results, IMDB listings, and local coverage (by someone who thinks kata is a martial art) are insufficient to meet . He also doesn't meet and, as Mdtemp mentioned, rank and martial art halls of fame do not confer WP notability Deletion of Todd Dunphy WP:GNG||WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11330 13066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yulia Pochynok User:Ohnoitsjamie 04:20, 19 September 2016 (UTC) delete I don't see anything that indicates notability or for that matter; is essentially a CV Deletion of Yulia Pochynok WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11331 2724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bookmap User:Whpq 21:08, 12 September 2006 (UTC) comment the second google search turns up a little more than that. There is a PDF file reporting from Dutch Ministry of Education studying the use of this learning tool. There's a bunch of entries that appear to be in Dutch which I am not able to read and evaluate. This learning tool may be locally notable in the Netherlands, but since I can't read Dutch, I can't tell. But I don't think it is a slam dunk failure of Deletion of Bookmap WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11332 14368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angela Pulvirenti User:Whats 09:12, 26 April 2017 (UTC) delete Largely routine coverage that doesn't meet notability requirements for bios. As written, the article reads much like with a lot of padding Deletion of Angela Pulvirenti WP:NOTPROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11333 157 [[Gerónimo Gutiérrez Fernández]] (LAE) Benutzer:NCC1291 NONE delete Das ist meilenweit weg von . Bitte Löschung von Gerónimo Gutiérrez Fernández Wikipedia:Artikel Wikipedia:Artikel 90
11334 11797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zachtronics Industries user:H3llkn0wz 14:55, 2 May 2011 (UTC) comment """I want to say """"keep"""" since the topic of the page is now """"Zachary Barth"""" (the page should not have been moved mid-AfD though). However, as far as is concerned, there are two direct sources: http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2011/01/20/my-chemical-romance-zach-barth-interview/ RPS interview and http://www.indiegames.com/2011/03/indiegamescom_podcast_17_zach.html IG interview, both primary sources, but from a reliable publisher (/RS). The indirect sources are for ''Infiniminer'', the game as inspiration and the contribution to the """"blocky"""" genre. As I said above """"Should we because Barth contributed to """"blocky"""" genre and made ''SpaceChem''? I don't know."""" That said, it's still days until Friday and I am open to (''constructive, policy/guideline addressing'') opinions. — """ Deletion of Zachtronics Industries WP:GNG||WP:VG||WP:IAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
11335 21146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Pezzin User:CactusWriter 15:01, 13 March 2017 (UTC) delete """per . Also fails our """"Significant coverage"""" criteria for |General Notability and |Biography. References are all trivial mentions from local sources about a single event""" Deletion of John Pezzin WP:1E||WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11336 7951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Funky monkey magazine User:Darth_Panda 14:51, 19 November 2008 (UTC) delete A lack of , fails , falls under . There is not a single reason to keep this Deletion of Funky monkey magazine WP:RS||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11337 1764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/X-COM: UFO Defense (Russian novel) User:Someone 01:14, 3 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can find nothing resembling a |reliable source for this, isn't satisfied let alone . No prejudice against reinstatement if it can be sources, but I can't support a merge as there's no sources to verify it, it's not clear if this is even an ordinary novel or a work of fan fiction, if it's the latter then there would be zero need to mention it unless it was notable Deletion of X-COM: UFO Defense (Russian novel) WP:RS||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11338 17254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taishan Dong (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 00:04, 4 March 2015 (UTC) keep Passes . Source examples include: http://usa.chinadaily.com.cn/world/2014-07/21/content_17854347.htm, http://espn.go.com/boxing/story/_/id/12334186/sky-limit-taishan, http://fightland.vice.com/blog/the-yao-ming-of-boxing, http://www.npr.org/2014/08/26/343245046/chinas-great-wall-takes-a-hit-at-u-s-heavyweight-boxing, http://www.foxsports.com/boxing/story/fox-sports-1-golden-boy-taishan-dong-perks-of-being-the-great-wall-of-china-022315 Deletion of Taishan Dong (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11339 21716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008 Murshidabad beheading User:Handyunits 05:08, 1 April 2013 (UTC) keep Bad faith nomination by political activist. This nomination is part of a campaign carried out by nominator to get articles on incidents carried out by South Asian Islamic militants deleted. See http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk%3AMrwikidor&diff=548012286&oldid=547314361 this diff, as well as http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=2013_Canning_riots&diff=547993606&oldid=547990550 this racist edit summary made by editor that casts false aspersions on established wikipedia editors, violating and Deletion of 2008 Murshidabad beheading WP:CANVASS||WP:AGF||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Canvassing 93
11340 3657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Tenants (2019 film) User:Bearian 16:57, 3 September 2019 (UTC) delete per and . It may never be released outside of Lagos Deletion of The Tenants (2019 film) WP:HAMMER||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
11341 13086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Youngren User:Amalthea 01:04, 26 September 2008 (UTC) delete Close call. I ended up with the same articles Samuel J. Howard listed, but I don't think they add up to the significant coverage in multiple reliable sources required by Deletion of Peter Youngren WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11342 3299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 Australian constitutional crisis User:Fremantle99 01:27, 20 August 2017 (UTC) keep """Given the size and scale of the issue, it definitely qualifies as an article under . One sub-chapter of another article can't quite capture the scale of the issue. An omission of this issue from Wikipedia's growing database of articles would be at best a severe oversight. On another point, people looking for information regarding these disqualifications will be more inclined to look up """"dual-citizenship disqualifications"""" or something similar rather than """"Section 44"""". Maybe the title of the article needs changing for the meantime but link the section on the disqualifications on the Section 44 article to this as a main article""" Deletion of 2017 Australian constitutional crisis WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11343 6835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William The Accountant User:Gongshow 15:01, 28 July 2014 (UTC) delete I'm not finding sufficient coverage to warrant an article at this time; does not appear to meet or Deletion of William The Accountant WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
11344 13766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bobby Allen (basketball) User:Jrcla2 18:59, 5 August 2013 (UTC) keep """per |NBASKETBALL, specifically #1 which ends """"or a similar major professional sports league."""" Allen played in the highest league in the Philippines, which may not sound impressive to people who don't know international basketball, but the Philippine Basketball Association is a notable league which has been accepted in previous discussions to qualify as a """"similar"""" major league""" Deletion of Bobby Allen (basketball) WP:NBASKETBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11345 4960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kobort Koffa User:Fenix 13:33, 24 July 2015 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG. I am concerned that a lot of of superficially looks like signfiicant coverage is in fact overtly promotional Deletion of Kobort Koffa WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11346 14377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/To (play) User:James500 05:18, 28 July 2018 (UTC) keep Satisfies criteria 5 of the guideline . The author, Czesław Miłosz, won a nobel prize for literature (and other important awards). No comment on whether a rename is necessary Deletion of To (play) WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
11347 105 [[No Limits]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Achak NONE delete Lemma wird nicht sinvoll erklärt. Relevanz nicht wirklich feststellbar. Gab es schon mal: /23._Januar_2006#No_Limits (gelöscht Löschung von No Limits Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
11348 4018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of nude celebrities User:TonyBallioni 15:09, 10 November 2007 (UTC) delete """Can those claiming that this is notable please explain why they think it is so. As of now it looks like a clear example of and I am leaning towards delete but I am willing to """"vote"""" for keep if it can be explained why this is notable""" Deletion of List of nude celebrities WP:DIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11349 19542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Off-Beats User:Stuartyeates 07:29, 6 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of The Off-Beats WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11350 16163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrian Chirici User:Lunala 20:06, 26 June 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Adrian Chirici WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11351 128 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Brüksel Kürt Enstitüsü Kullanıcı:manco capacmanco capac 08:28, 9 Kasım 2009 (UTC) comment Aslına bakarsanız bulundukları ülkelerde kurulmuş olan ilk Kürt Enstitüsü olmaları bile kayda değerlik açısından bize yetmektedir ki 'a bakarsanız bu durumun oradaki bir kriter ile eşleştiğini görmüş olursunuz. Ancak yine de ben tek madde altında birleştirilebileceğini fakat daha sonra genişleme ihtiyacı halinde kendi maddesinin yaratılacabileceği kanısındayım. Fakat bu durum var olan '''kayda değer''' bir maddeyi silmek için de bir gerekçe değil. Gelin siz karar verin Brüksel Kürt Enstitüsünün silinmesi Vikipedi:OKUL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11352 18551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Have a Nice Life User:Michig 05:38, 21 April 2015 (UTC) keep Sufficient coverage to pass / Deletion of Have a Nice Life WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11353 1500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Roman Catholic priests accused of sex offenses User:NancyHeise 20:24, 8 October 2007 (UTC) delete Per Wikipolicy #Directory. There are numerous wikipolicies in to justify deletion of this list of names of accused priests. Besides that, it is really an unethical use of Wikipedia to have a list of accused persons. What if some of these priests are innocent as may be the case with a certain percentage. How cruel is that to have a Directory on Wikipedia with your name on it even if you have never been convicted and are possibly innocent? Also, why would there only be a list for priests? Why not a list for accused public school teachers having sex with students? Once you open the bottle, its hard to put the genie back in. I think this bottle should stay closed (and delete this list Deletion of List of Roman Catholic priests accused of sex offenses WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11354 13425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judy Coser User:Kbabej 17:01, 20 April 2021 (UTC) delete per ; subject has requested deletion, and is relatively unknown Deletion of Judy Coser WP:BIODEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
11355 5688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michèle Audette User:Guy 02:11, 8 May 2017 (UTC) keep Meets Deletion of Michèle Audette WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11356 8849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Freeman Joshua-Lee User:MCB 06:49, 9 April 2006 (UTC) delete as vanity/nn-bio; no |verifiability of any actual notability or fame Deletion of Freeman Joshua-Lee WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11357 1514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grizzly City 3 User:Joaquin008 17:50, 29 August 2010 (UTC) delete Fails |notability criteria for albums Deletion of Grizzly City 3 WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
11358 18475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monique Bingham [[User talk:137.200.32.38#top|talk]]) 13:50, 10 January 2018 (UTC) comment The article doesn't read like a promo, and the subject is, in fact, otable|notable. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/137.200.32.38|137.200.32.38 Deletion of Monique Bingham WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11359 7162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs containing covert references to real musicians (2nd nomination) User:Arkyan 19:24, 2 April 2007 (UTC) delete Trivia at its worst, lists like this do belong Deletion of List of songs containing covert references to real musicians (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11360 17018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laetitia Toureaux User:Gene93k 09:22, 17 June 2016 (UTC) comment The article has been moved to :1937 Laetitia Toureaux murder. An admin deleted the original title per |CSD G5 Deletion of Laetitia Toureaux WP:G5 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11361 12426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tryad (4th nomination) User:Kraxler 16:57, 17 July 2015 (UTC) delete contrary to the statement here above, there seem to be no reliable sources independent of the subject (please say which ones you consider RS), all sources in the article are primary, self-publiushed, or blogs, perhaps except the ''Ars Technica'' ref which has a trivial mention of Tryad, only. Fails and Deletion of Tryad (4th nomination) WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11362 20666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mahad Dar User:Ravenswing 09:54, 20 January 2012 (UTC) delete """A lot of hot air and self-promotion, accompanied by a complete lack of |reliable, independent sources. That he has his own """"webshow"""" just puts him up with millions of other wannabe """"auteurs,"""" that he's one of dozens in a single indie documentary wouldn't come remotely close to fulfilling the requirements of , and that he's allegedly someone's manager bumps against the well-known principle that |notability is not inherited. The article was shot down at Articles for Creation on three separate occasions over a two year span for a lack of reliable sources, and one would think that the string of anon IPs and SPAs that keep trying to put this article up would be better served by waiting until the subject's done something deemed worthy of notice by the world""" Deletion of Mahad Dar WP:IRS||WP:CREATIVE||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11363 2013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fineberg Mushrooms User:Dhartung 06:34, 20 December 2007 (UTC) delete fails , and I hope this is a hoax. If it weren't one it probably would have been a major issue for the vendor Deletion of Fineberg Mushrooms WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11364 1520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The London Theatre – New Cross User:SwisterTwister 11:58, 16 May 2016 (UTC) keep as found sources confirm Deletion of The London Theatre – New Cross WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11365 15158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exposition Boy User:DustFormsWords 04:43, 15 March 2010 (UTC) delete Fails . Good faith searches fail to establish notability. Appears to be a non-notable neologism. Even TV Tropes hasn't picked it up Deletion of Exposition Boy WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11366 258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Teal User:Mendaliv 09:01, 16 June 2008 (UTC) keep """Passes : """"Competitors who have competed in a fully professional league..."""" He played in the NHL. Sadly that's it""" Deletion of Jeff Teal WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11367 18679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Secrets (band) User:Bfigura 05:19, 18 August 2007 (UTC) delete Fails strongly. I also find it someone amusing that apparently the band includes a James_Bradley|member who died in 1762, but played congas in a band with Eddie_Williams|someone born in 1964. Possible hoax, or sloppy linking Deletion of Secrets (band) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11368 12192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Rupe User:Robert NONE keep As Arxiloxos has indicated, subject does pass notability guidelines and does not |own the article. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Bob Rupe WP:OWN Wikipedia:Ownership of content 86
11369 18352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DJ Pusspuss User:Allstarecho 08:00, 4 January 2008 (UTC) keep Meets Deletion of DJ Pusspuss WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11370 6518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of English words of Slovak origin User:Kvng 15:47, 27 July 2020 (UTC) comment """Sorry for being terse/cheeky in my deprod rationale. I'm refering to this bit: {{tq|There is no present consensus for how to assess the notability of more complex and cross-categorization lists (such as """"Lists of X of Y"""")}}. List notability is not easily gaugued so these are not good prod candidates. Especially so here because of the existence of many other '''English words of ''x'' origin''' articles. If you are making a argument, that is also not a good use of prod""" Deletion of List of English words of Slovak origin WP:LISTN||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11371 7812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunil Kant Munjal User:Jupitus 14:28, 12 June 2021 (UTC) comment The subject is notable and probably merits a keep. But the thought of a editor with an obvious |conflict of interest getting his way at the behest of hard working volunteer editors is probably the reason why more participation is not seen in this discussion Deletion of Sunil Kant Munjal WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
11372 6235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yemen at the 2013 Asian Youth Games User:Malcolmxl5 11:02, 3 June 2016 (UTC) merge to the main games article. This could have been done |boldly without bringing this and others here Deletion of Yemen at the 2013 Asian Youth Games WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
11373 13137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stressed Out (Twenty One Pilots song) User:War 05:24, 29 April 2015 (UTC) keep """I'm the editor who doesn't believe the tag needs to be there as this clearly passes , I added references to the articles to better establish notability before this AfD. If nothing else, at least the MTV and Radio.com references are |reliable sources, and with this many google news hits so shortly after it's release it's obviously a notable single from a notable artist. It's unfair for the nominator to state that the above links are the """"best available"""" on the net, he just picked the refs directly from the article, the first one is just a lyric yes (added by the original page creator) and is obviously not a good source, even more obviously not one of the """"best available"""" (although the fact that it is already up on every major lyrics website says something about the notability of this song as well) so I encourage other editors to do their own research before giving their input. Finally, since when do we start counting the number of sentences per article to determine if something is significant coverage or not? Articles specifically talking about the song, and it's meaning are plenty for a start or stub class article, and will obviously expand beyond that quickly. The coverage is significant enough""" Deletion of Stressed Out (Twenty One Pilots song) WP:NSONG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11374 13 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saturday Disney User:De 23:57, 3 December 2015 (UTC) keep The show passes , since it's a long-running network show with national broadcast scope, a small amount of cultural importance (a number of Australian TV hosts got their start on the show), and a cursory search reveals plenty of RS. The problem is that you'd never know any of this from the article itself! And the nominator is 100% right about the hair colour thing... ugh. Lots of work needed Deletion of Saturday Disney WP:TVSHOW Wikipedia:Notability 77
11375 2530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Justice 4 All Women & Children User:Piotrus 06:18, 12 November 2020 (UTC) delete Fails NORG/GNG. Is this even a real organization? I can't locate a website outside a blog on wordpress. No mentions in the news. Seems like it is just a Facebook group or something similar. etc Deletion of Justice 4 All Women & Children WP:NOTYELLOWPAGES Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11376 18912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AmazingSuperPowers User:RHaworth 20:15, 18 April 2008 (UTC) delete but without predjudice against someone with no |COI re-creating it Deletion of AmazingSuperPowers WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
11377 7218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC 140 (2nd nomination) NONE NONE comment """I do not believe any and all UFC events are inherently notable and that many UFC events do not meet Wikipedia's notability guidelines. For now I am going to refrain from !voting on this AfD because I'm on the fence. I will say, that the article in its current state does fail as the article consists mostly (if not nearly entirely) of a collection of results and 'statistics'. says, """"Articles about notable games should have well-sourced prose"""", which this article doesn't have much of; even the background section is really just a list of facts about the event in sentence form""" Deletion of UFC 140 (2nd nomination) WP:SPORTSEVENT||WP:SPORTSEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11378 367 [[Anastassija Eduardowna Baburowa]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Kai Jurkschat NONE keep Zugegeben, es ist ein Grenzfall, und die Subsumtion unter die #Personen|aktuellen Relevanzkriterien für Personen fällt nicht leicht. Man fragt sich allerdings, wie russische Wikipedianer im Sommer 1967 den Fall Benno Ohnesorg beurteilt hätten, hätte es die Wikipedia und eine gelebte Meinungsfreiheit damals schon gegeben. Dabei war Ohnesorgs politische Sendungskraft und publizistische Aktivität weniger intensiv als diejenige Baburowas. Diese war — das kann man sich schnell „http://www.google.de ergooglen” oder „erjandexen” (yandex.ru) — vielfach außerparlamentarisch in ökologisch-pazifistischen, kapitalismuskritischen oder „libertär-kommunistischen” Inititiativen und bei der Entlarvung und Bekämpfung von deren rechtsextremen und/oder staatshörig-nationalistischen Gegnern engagiert. Wie man etwa dem http://www.rabkor.ru/?area=articleItem&id=1238 frühen Kurznachruf der „Arbeiterkorrespondenten” im Internet entnehmen kann, spielte Baburowa u. a. bei den Protestlager veranstaltenden „Rainbow Keepers/Chraniteli Radugi”, bei der Organisation der von den Behörden gemaßregelten globalisierungskritischen Konferenz „Antikapitalism-2008 (AKAP-2008)” und bei diversen Bürgerprotesten eine führende Rolle, mindestens „im zweiten Glied”; auch dies floss in ihre Zeitungsberichte ein, die sie bereits während vor Abschluss ihrer Ausbildung in so prominenten Organen wie den „Iswestija”, der „Wetschernjaja Moskwa” und der „Nowaja Gaseta” plazieren durfte. Für derartige Aktivisten der Bürgergesellschaft (die in Russland wegen der allgemeinen Gleichschaltung des zugelassenen Parteienwesens, wegen fehlender geschichtlicher und staatsbürgerlicher Bildung und wegen der frustrierenden politischen Polarisierung oft nicht ohne provozierende „exotische Labels” wie „Libertärkommunismus”, „Nationalbolschewismus” u. dgl. auskommt) fehlt in den aktuellen Relevanzkriterien der Wikipedia ein Platz: Journalisten werden mit einem eher „hierarchischen” oder „erfolgsorientierten” Ansatz goutiert, Politiker dito, Schriftsteller müssen ein Mindestmaß an größeren Werken geliefert haben … — ich frage mich, was mit den heute bekannten Politikern der GRÜNEN in lexikalischer Hinsicht passiert wäre, wäre es ihnen nicht gelungen, parlamentarische Mandate und öffentliche Ämter zu erreichen. Für lesenswert halte ich immer noch die als „veraltet” bezeichneten Wikipedia:Archiv/Themendiskussion/Biografie|früheren Relevanzkriterien, mit denen man in anderen Wikipedien immer noch arbeitet, insbesondere zu „sonstigen Personen”. Über die russische Wikipedia, deren Löschdiskussion auch unter dem Einfluss der deutschen Diskussion immer mehr zur Milde tendiert (die niederländische, finnische und englische erwägen keine Löschung), sind Pressezitate erschließbar mit dem Hinweis auf die fortschreitende Eliminierung des Informationsflusses über „heiße Themen” durch Beseitigung der investigativen Journalisten, deren Tod spürbare Einbußen am öffentlichen Wissen etwa zu Korruptionsangelegenheiten und den Menschenrechtsverletzungen am Kaukasus bewirkt habe — nun soll es schon gefährlich sein, neben einem investigativen Journalisten zu stehen. Nenne dies einer „Theorienfindung” … ich bleibe bei . Löschung von Anastassija Eduardowna Baburowa Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
11379 13009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Kacaniklic User:Sir 15:21, 5 September 2010 (UTC) delete Fails both and Deletion of Alex Kacaniklic WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11380 13228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dario Hunter 2020 presidential campaign User:E 22:44, 19 June 2019 (UTC) delete or '''Merge''', with preference for delete. Page looks good at a glance, but on second look it is largely a copy paste of Dario Hunter. Hunter has gotten press, but his campaign has garnered near-zero attention. the local NPR station did run a local story when he announced. No coverage for his national tour. He did get a little novelty attention by visiting Israel, but there is not enough coverage of coverage of this campaign to justify a page Deletion of Dario Hunter 2020 presidential campaign WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11381 11587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Preeze 36 User:Theroadislong 14:18, 20 November 2017 (UTC) delete Unreferenced autobiography which fails Deletion of Preeze 36 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11382 3325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2003-04 NHL transactions User:Madchester 02:29, 8 August 2006 (UTC) comment Is the trade of Tom Koivisto for future considerations notable? Important trades should be included in the respective NHL season articles instead. The trades are ''factual'' and ''verifiable'' but they fail Deletion of 2003-04 NHL transactions WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11383 20748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carbon Literacy User:Fraudy 23:49, 11 June 2008 (UTC) delete per . Textbook definition of a neologism. The potential of it being spam as raised above is also concerning Deletion of Carbon Literacy WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11384 20639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maximilian Rothenbücher User:Yellow 02:11, 24 July 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Maximilian Rothenbücher WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11385 18085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jon Ausman User:Ukexpat 14:27, 6 December 2012 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Jon Ausman WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11386 4538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barrie Needham User:David 22:48, 27 December 2010 (UTC) delete I couldn't find enough citations in Google scholar to convince me of a pass of #C1, and I couldn't find enough articles about him or his works in Google news to convince me of a pass of Deletion of Barrie Needham WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11387 12839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qoof User:TravisTX 16:53, 29 July 2007 (UTC) delete this time per #G11. Sources may be independent, but they still don't establish notability (blogs and PR).(edit conflict Deletion of Qoof WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11388 7970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emelio Bruno User:Papaursa 22:45, 25 September 2016 (UTC) delete No evidence he meets or . Coaching a U.S. team on a Japanese tour is insufficient to show notability Deletion of Emelio Bruno WP:GNG||WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11389 9083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scarlett Pong User:HongQiGong 19:31, 3 January 2009 (UTC) delete Failed to get elected to LegCo twice. She's an elected member of the District Councils of Hong Kong|District Council, but that is a 2nd level sub-national political office and does not pass notability per . She's a TV presenter for RoadShow, but I'm not sure that passes notability in and of itself Deletion of Scarlett Pong WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11390 20811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Somaya Reece (2nd nomination) User:Haemo 01:45, 8 May 2007 (UTC) delete incredibly poorly sourced. If this was seriously kept last time, on the basis of |reliable sources existing, then why is the sourcing still so poor Deletion of Somaya Reece (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11391 16287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carly Flynn User:DerbyCountyinNZ 10:13, 7 January 2017 (UTC) keep Clearly passes AND . Should have been speedy kept along with other bad-faith nominations by blocked user Deletion of Carly Flynn WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
11392 17404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 Yavneh attack (2nd nomination) User:Galatz 13:14, 14 August 2017 (UTC) keep Per it is too early to judge what future coverage will be and the nomination is based purely on speculation that it wont be covered. This article was nominated too quickly per Deletion of 2017 Yavneh attack (2nd nomination) WP:LASTING||WP:RAPID Wikipedia:Notability 77
11393 6817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Danza User:GiantSnowman 10:26, 18 February 2013 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Josh Danza WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11394 21679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Johnny Lee Clary (2nd nomination) User:SiobhanHansa 19:12, 30 August 2006 (UTC) merge While notability in all areas is reasonably weak, I think that it's enough. We have a conversion story that's compelling enough to get coverage in numerous specialist (i.e. Christian) publications and on a couple of national TV shows, along with a pro-wrestling career (as unimpressive as it may be). While I might have thought each one just missed the mark on its own, when there are a combinations of factors for notability I don't think individual ones need to be as strong. io is a non-comprehensive guideline. The article needs major clean up though. Both of the current ones read like press releases Deletion of Johnny Lee Clary (2nd nomination) WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
11395 15006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allegations of state terrorism by Israel User:Malik 01:40, 26 January 2009 (UTC) delete Seems like ; you can't just list every allegation of state terrorism by Israel and call it an article Deletion of Allegations of state terrorism by Israel WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
11396 6506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Internet phenomena 3 User:Gwernol 23:15, 26 January 2008 (UTC) keep I sympathize with Seriousspender's intentions and applaud his well-written nomination, however I'm afraid I come down on the side of those arguing that the article is well enough sourced. I join Tarinth in suggesting that all editors should rigorously apply our |notability guidelines and especially our |sourcing policy to this article. But as long as there are reliable sources showing that an independent, published |reliable source has recognized a particular entry as a phenomenon (or a reasonable equivalent of that), then the entries are okay. Best Deletion of List of Internet phenomena 3 WP:N||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11397 8066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of TEDx conferences User:Normal 18:19, 2 September 2020 (UTC) delete Non-notable topic that fails for the list itself. An example of /. Also violates MOS:EXTERNALLINKS with dozens of inappropriate external links including ext lnks camouflaged as pseudo-citations. Violates eliable sources by using its own website for citations. In total, violates hat Wikipedia is not Deletion of List of TEDx conferences WP:GNG||WP:LISTCRUFT||WP:FANCRUFT||WP:R||WP:W Wikipedia:Notability 77
11398 2951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Airline Empires User:Siva1979 01:24, 21 August 2006 (UTC) delete Non-notable and reads like a game guide. Fairs poorly on too. All these compelling cases point that this article should be deleted. --Wikipedia:Esperanza|S Deletion of Airline Empires WP:GOOGLE Wikipedia:Search engine test 38
11399 10096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clifford Law Offices User:Lankiveil 08:06, 8 June 2015 (UTC) merge to Robert A. Clifford, not independently notable, despite some claims above Deletion of Clifford Law Offices WP:ITSNOTABLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11400 13701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Adam Gooden User:Starblind 16:19, 26 February 2008 (UTC) delete doesn't pass or . Local newspapers generally aren't reliable sources, especially when that's all an article has, so fails too Deletion of Lee Adam Gooden WP:BIO||WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11401 3952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crumbs improv User:Stifle 17:31, 14 October 2007 (UTC) delete per , , and so on. If kept, move to a proper name Deletion of Crumbs improv WP:ORG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
11402 2664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tyrants (second nomination) User:Targeman 03:08, 8 August 2007 (UTC) delete per pure . There is absolutely no way this kind of list could ever be anything but a PoV dump. It's like making a List of stupid politicians, there isn't the slightest chance of any kind of consensus ever arising here; a guaranteed trollfest and edit battlefield, AfD magnet, surefire ArbCom customer, a waste of everybody's time, another unwanted stain on Wikipedia's reputation, I could go on and on Deletion of List of tyrants (second nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11403 7930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pedro Rodríguez (politician) User:Howard 20:25, 18 May 2019 (UTC) keep Nominator depressingly did not follow . Member of the first Philippine Assembly, the forerunner of the current Philippine House of Representatives, which is a national legislature. The Philippine Assembly was the first fully elected national assembly of its kind in Asia outside Japan. Easily satisfies . To the nominator, please exercise in satisfying nominating articles such as this Deletion of Pedro Rodríguez (politician) WP:BEFORE||WP:POLITICIAN||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
11404 991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dale Shirkie User:GiantSnowman 15:47, 15 December 2019 (UTC) keep I am concerned that the nominator has not done (again) given that a very quick Google search brings up sources such as https://www.glasgowtimes.co.uk/sport/juniors/13494024.troon-are-in-good-shape-after-jim-kirkwood-rebuild/ this, https://www.cumnockchronicle.com/sport/13733338.dale-gets-dealt-in/ this and https://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/motherwell-promote-five-promising-youth-1129297 this which go towards GNG. Given ongoing career and meeting I say we keep the article. The nominator is also (again) confusing GNG and NFOOTBALL Deletion of Dale Shirkie WP:BEFORE||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
11405 310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethnoburb (2nd nomination) User:Colonel 19:00, 3 November 2010 (UTC) keep The topic is notable and so should be kept in accordance with our |editing policy Deletion of Ethnoburb (2nd nomination) WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
11406 8310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kirrin Island User:Jfgslo 18:15, 2 March 2011 (UTC) delete No evidence of real-world |notability. The article itself is a |plot-only description of a fictional work, written with an -U|in-universe perspective that lacks #Real-world perspective|real-world perspective, and it is an unnecessary |content fork. The subject of the article does not meet the criteria of the |general notability guideline since there is no significant coverage in #Reliable_sources_and_other_principles|reliable third-party sources independent of the subject to presume notability. All Google hits show notability for ''The Famous Five (series)|The Famous Five'' book series, but, with the exception of mentions about the book ''Five on Kirrin Island Again'', all mentions about Kirrin Island are trivial and do not show significant coverage for the fictional location Deletion of Kirrin Island WP:N||WP:PLOT||WP:IN||WP:WAF||WP:CFORK||WP:GNG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
11407 13132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grand Admiral Daelin Proudmoore User:Doctorfluffy 05:25, 3 November 2007 (UTC) delete Fails , unlikely reliable secondary sources can be found to establish notability, and violates #PLOT Deletion of Grand Admiral Daelin Proudmoore WP:FICT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11408 19675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marc D Grossman User:TJRC 04:01, 6 August 2016 (UTC) delete WP:NOTRESUME; I agree this could have been speedied as , but may as well let the afd run its course to nail it down Deletion of Marc D Grossman WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11409 16909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zainab Abbas User:Sahrudayan 12:57, 21 February 2018 (UTC) comment Subject has received significant press coverage in Pakistan and abroad. Also received significant media coverage in India especially after subject commented on Indian cricketers. See these Hindi news articles from mainstream Indian news media https://hindi.news18.com/photogallery/sports/cricket-pakistans-women-cricketer-syeda-nain-abidi-appreciates-virat-kohli-after-his-35th-odi-century-1275581.html CNN-News18 (in 2018), https://khabar.ndtv.com/news/zara-hatke/pakistan-journalist-zainab-abbas-viral-sach-1712075 NDTV (in 2017), and https://aajtak.intoday.in/sports/story/pakistans-off-spinner-saeed-ajmal-has-reportedly-accused-ravichandran-ashwin-and-harbhajan-singh-of-chucking-1-840561.html AajTak/IndiaToday (in 2015). However, most likely fails GNG as per guidelines Deletion of Zainab Abbas WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
11410 19502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of supercouples User:Flyer22 02:51, 17 February 2008 (UTC) keep How is this article based on opinion? It's not. As Orlady points out, this is not a case of . If the public, media, and critics don't define who is a supercouple, then who will? When it comes to lists on Wikipdedia, this is one of the better ones, considering that most lists on Wikipedia are unreferenced or mostly unreferenced. It's not an opinion which couples are supercouples, but a fact. Just like the ''Associated Press'' points out that it is fact that Spider-Man (Peter Parker) and Mary Jane Watson are a supercouple.http://media.www.ndsmcobserver.com/media/storage/paper660/news/2008/01/18/Scene/Comic.Book.Supercouple.Splits.Fans.Cry.Collective.Tear-3157300.shtml This list was originally in the Supercouple article to give readers a more in-depth view and history of the many supercouples that have come and gone, or are still present today. That's what this article does, with valid references. It was too big to stay in the Supercouple article and needed its own article. It's not that different than having a List of fictional anti-heroes. Except that this list is better formatted. As for only one reference in the lead working, I'll check on that. The others should work, but two of them may not be able to be viewed anymore due to needing to buy the books to read those two sources online. Other than that, there is no reason that this list shouldn't exist. And the Supercouple article a right mess? Not the mess it was before I got to it. It's not in bad shape at all, and is no worse shape than than the Superhero article. It needs an origin of the term section and some tweaks, but that's about it. But, really, the origin is already stated in the lead. There isn't much more to state than that Deletion of List of supercouples WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11411 4644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gustavo Andres Hincapie User:AllyD 07:30, 5 June 2016 (UTC) delete A article supported by two passing mentions in El Tiempo and a link to the subject's Youtube channel. These confirm the subject as a man going about his business but I am seeing nothing to indicate encyclopaedic notability. (If this article does survive, it will need editing attention to achieve English language conformity and to remove ery Deletion of Gustavo Andres Hincapie :WP:SPA||:WP:PEACOCK Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
11412 570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The New Cinema User:Metropolitan90 16:47, 21 October 2010 (UTC) delete No |independent reliable sources have been provided to help establish this publication's notability. Furthermore, the article appears to be promotional rather than taking a |neutral point of view Deletion of The New Cinema WP:RS||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11413 16386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Penn State Nittany Lions volleyball all time record User:Doc 14:01, 10 August 2008 (UTC) delete per #STATS and Deletion of Penn State Nittany Lions volleyball all time record WP:NOT||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11414 1001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Papathanasiou Marek User:Evb 19:20, 8 June 2007 (UTC) delete completely fails Deletion of Papathanasiou Marek WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11415 737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arturo Rodríguez Quezada User:Smartyllama 13:48, 1 February 2019 (UTC) keep Passes per above, as any remote amount of would have shown Deletion of Arturo Rodríguez Quezada WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11416 4109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Rothfuss User:Plasticup 13:02, 8 July 2008 (UTC) keep Google supplies http://www.google.com/search?source=ig&hl=en&rlz=&q=%22Chris+Rothfuss%22 plenty of notability. Not only does his http://www.greenriverstar.com/articles/2008/06/09/news/doc484d7a556a5b3457324290.txt local paper report on his candidacy, here he is in a http://www.examiner.com/a-1429274~Wyo__festival_to_offer_chances_to_dunk_a_Democrat.html national newspaper and in a http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2008%5C06%5C09%5Cstory_9-6-2008_pg9_11 Pakistani newspaper. He satisfies the basic criteria of : ''the subject of published secondary source material which is reliable, intellectually independent, and independent of the subject Deletion of Chris Rothfuss WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11417 16621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/YuuWaa User:Lesser 13:58, 5 August 2014 (UTC) keep mdash;Appears to be significant coverage in http://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/review/1561286/yuuwaa-usb-backup-drive The Inquirer, http://www.engadget.com/2009/05/18/yuuwaas-hardware-flash-drives-combine-serious-online-storage-wi/ Engadget, http://www.pcadvisor.co.uk/new-product/pc-peripheral/3271312/yuuwaa-memory-stick-and-online-storage-bundle/ PC Advisor and http://www.geek.com/news/yuuwaa-go-4gb-usb-stick-includes-20gb-cloud-storage-1263085/ geek.com. Despite the service being halted, I think the historical coverage meets Deletion of YuuWaa WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11418 15802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darian Shirazi (4th nomination) User:Bearian 15:02, 30 October 2019 (UTC) delete per , , , and . This is a totally ordinary computer person. His first claim to fame is being Facebook's first intern. Notability is not inherited from whom you work or who's your relatives, except in extraordinary cases (such as collaboration between a world-famous musician and her piano player, like Bette Midler, or Jared Kushner). This has been deleted or merged three times already. I can't see |consensus changing Deletion of Darian Shirazi (4th nomination) WP:MILL||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:OUTCOMES||WP:SALT||WP:CCC Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
11419 17512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faerghail User:A1octopus 01:28, 8 October 2007 (UTC) delete Inadequate evidence of passing usic Deletion of Faerghail WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
11420 10318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Matejka User:JamesBurns 06:24, 7 January 2009 (UTC) delete agree with The Hammer here. Deletion of Mark Matejka WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11421 3460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emily Henderson User:Number 20:08, 2 October 2016 (UTC) delete per failure. The reason there are only three fully-pro women's leagues is because there is less interest in them, and therefore the players don't have the same level of notability Deletion of Emily Henderson WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11422 19145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanuj Mahashabde User:DBigXray 22:51, 29 June 2012 (UTC) delete per nominator. The info that is in the stub has already been covered in the article on the TV serial Taarak Mehta Ka Ooltah Chashmah. Fails Deletion of Tanuj Mahashabde WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
11423 4980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caleb Shomo [[User talk:76.252.203.242|talk]]) 21:43, 11 June 2010 (UTC) keep if the notability from was included. Special:Contributions/76.252.203.242|76.252.203.242 Deletion of Caleb Shomo WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11424 11698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kre-alkalyn User:Coredesat 08:45, 27 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Kre-alkalyn WP:CORP||WP:ADS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11425 10406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Magic: The Gathering characters: H User:Shooterwalker 19:54, 30 November 2012 (UTC) delete """I've left a comment at """"G"""". Nothing to of this group of characters in accordance with . (Leave replies/rebuttals at """"G""" Deletion of List of Magic: The Gathering characters: H WP:NLIST||WP:verifynotability Wikipedia:Notability 77
11426 6536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Beautiful Losers User:TenPoundHammer 22:40, 10 June 2008 (UTC) delete Fails the reliable sources test, and therefore as well Deletion of The Beautiful Losers WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11427 454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of titles of Harry Potter books in other languages (2nd nomination) User:Motor 10:39, 17 June 2006 (UTC) delete there might be reasons for mentioning some translated names of Harry Potter characters (on the HP article), such as any that caused particular problems in certain languages. This, however, is cross-Wiki-language list-cruft with severe verifiabilty and problems. It does not justify its own article Deletion of List of titles of Harry Potter books in other languages (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11428 15448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Warmolts User:GiantSnowman 17:54, 29 July 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Stephen Warmolts WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11429 6535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Semih Çalışkan User:Mathglot 10:49, 4 May 2017 (UTC) comment I'm not bothered by the fact that there are no English references, nor by the fact that Turkish uses Latin (I read non-Latin scripts as well). What I am bothered by, is that nobody is citing any policies or guidelines in their responses, which to my way of thinking, makes them all which are not countable votes. Please go back to which has four bullet points; and this author, as I see it, meets none of the four criteria, therefore is not notable. I'm willing to be persuaded otherwise, but please cite policies, not preferences, and maybe I'll come around; thanks Deletion of Semih Çalışkan WP:ILIKEIT||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11430 19556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyrillization of Georgian (2nd nomination) User:Kirbanzo 03:57, 28 August 2018 (UTC) delete upon review, this article is a case of . Tagging article as a blatant |hoax and requesting speedy deletion, in case an admin agrees Deletion of Cyrillization of Georgian (2nd nomination) WP:G3||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11431 12535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/On Our Way User:Graywalls 18:23, 12 June 2020 (UTC) delete doesn't meet Deletion of On Our Way WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11432 6201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HMCHL User:ST47 21:55, 18 August 2006 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of HMCHL WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11433 1837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Szczuczyn pogrom User:E 13:49, 5 December 2017 (UTC) keep Article can be cleaned up using massive number of s provided by Icewhiz Deletion of Szczuczyn pogrom WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11434 4380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Church of the Members User:Stifle 23:29, 3 April 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Church of the Members WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
11435 8803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pro-Islamic bias on Wikipedia User:Chiswick 11:31, 19 April 2017 (UTC) delete as an unencyclopedic personal polemic, failing , , and probably speediable as nonsense under G1, but never mind, deletion at AfD will suit its lack of content perfectly Deletion of Pro-Islamic bias on Wikipedia WP:GNG||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
11436 17208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Mboya Dada User:Quarl NONE delete all as |unverifiable, possible |hoax. Probably a 419 scam in the making. &mdash Deletion of Joshua Mboya Dada WP:V||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11437 14393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stuart little 4 (2nd nomination) User:Erik 20:31, 20 July 2008 (UTC) delete per ; no verifiable information about this project Deletion of Stuart little 4 (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11438 14490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Johannes Rojola User:Anarchyte 06:10, 21 April 2017 (UTC) merge Re-instate the redirect to his only notable product, My Summer Car. If he makes more games then maybe he'll become notable, but it's to have one now Deletion of Johannes Rojola WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
11439 55 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nature Camp User:SilkTork 17:15, 10 March 2010 (UTC) delete sources are local. No national coverage. Does not meet criteria in Deletion of Nature Camp WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11440 3499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sricharan Pakala User:Ab207 20:53, 31 August 2020 (UTC) keep """Per , {{tq|""""Has credit for writing or co-writing either lyrics or music for a notable composition.""""}}, which includes notable films and there are at least fifteen in this case. Also received coverage from sources such as The Hindu""" Deletion of Sricharan Pakala WP:COMPOSER Wikipedia:Notability 77
11441 11905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barry Aspinell User:Charlene 19:49, 10 March 2007 (UTC) keep Passes with a large number of articles specifically about him from reliable third parties such as UK newspapers Deletion of Barry Aspinell WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11442 1962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelvin Castillo User:IJA 10:59, 25 October 2014 (UTC) delete He hasn't played in a Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|Fully professional league and he doesn't have any senior international caps either therefore he fails Deletion of Kelvin Castillo WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11443 10144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SolidFire (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 13:13, 28 October 2016 (UTC) keep Meets . Source ''examples'' include, ''but are not limited to'': http://www.techrepublic.com/article/solidfire-acquisition-breathes-new-life-into-netapp/, http://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/12/15/solidfire_a_contrary_view/, http://www.networkworld.com/article/2952721/cloud-computing/11-deploys-solidfires-storage-for-its-new-cloud-servers.html, http://www.cio.com/article/3078659/netapps-new-solidfire-software-option-is-buy-once-use-anywhere.html, http://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/09/01/netapp_founder_dave_hitz_says_solidfire_is_for_people_who_fking_hate_storage/, http://www.zdnet.com/article/netapp-solidfire-offers-flexible-purchasing-model-for-datacenter-storage/, http://www.computerweekly.com/blog/Quocirca-Insights/NetApp-SolidFire-a-new-powerhouse-or-straws-grasping-at-each-other, http://blogs.wsj.com/venturecapital/2014/10/07/solidfire-raises-82-million-for-pooled-storage-on-flash-memory/, http://venturebeat.com/2015/12/21/netapp-acquires-flash-storage-vendor-solidfire-for-870m/, and https://www.google.com/search?tbs=bks:1&q=%22SolidFire%22#q=%22SolidFire%22&tbm=nws more coverage in bylined news articles written by staff writers that have been published in independent, wp:rs|reliable sources. Concerns about tone in the article can be addressed by |copy editing it Deletion of SolidFire (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:COPYEDIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11444 15369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Architects (song) User:Rlendog 02:05, 23 February 2011 (UTC) merge to the album per Nouse4aname. No evidence of notability as of now, but even if it was not released as a single that is not a valid deletion reason. The appropriate remedy per is a redirect Deletion of Architects (song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11445 14360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wiki-Surfing User:Eleland 15:10, 23 September 2007 (UTC) delete as . I don't understand why people remove prod tags from content that doesn't stand a 's chance of surviving. < Deletion of Wiki-Surfing WP:MADEUP||WP:SNOWBALL Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
11446 3383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katti batti marathi movie User:Anupmehra 22:15, 22 January 2015 (UTC) delete """Subject fails and . There are absolute zero coverage on this film. ''Not to be confused with """"Katti Batti"""" (Hindi film) that has some sort of http://searchindiannews.in/#gsc.tab=0&gsc.q=%22Katti%20batti%22&gsc.sort= coverage starring Kangana Ranawat and Imran Khan""" Deletion of Katti batti marathi movie WP:NF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11447 2511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ANC Today NONE NONE keep The publication ANC Today does meet and ournals, there are many independent and verifiable references that quote ANC Today Deletion of ANC Today WP:WEB||WP:NJ Wikipedia:Notability 77
11448 16711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeremy Buff User:Cyclonenim 19:24, 23 November 2008 (UTC) delete although this could have been |speedied Deletion of Jeremy Buff WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11449 16482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Night Runners User:Gwalla 22:27, 27 August 2014 (UTC) comment """Speaking as an admin here, there is no way for an admin to officially """"approve"""" an article. I'm not sure where you got that idea but it's not how things work on Wikipedia. The criteria for ''speedy'' deletion are similarly irrelevant; the criteria for speedy deletion are necessarily much narrower than for deletion in general, because """"speedy deletion"""" is """"nuke on sight without discussion"""". If it had met the speedy criteria, we would not be discussing it here because the article would already be gone. The """"articles for deletiojn"""" process, which is what we're engaged in right now, ''does'' take notability into consideration, specifically in this case the WP:general notability guideline|general notability guideline and the |notability criteria for bands and musicians. &mdash""" Deletion of The Night Runners WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
11450 16028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Everest: A Climb for Peace User:ImmortalGoddezz 04:53, 23 January 2008 (UTC) comment """when an article is a copy violation you're supposed to """"replace the contents of the page with the {{copyvio}} tag"""" etc per """ Deletion of Everest: A Climb for Peace WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
11451 5187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ICharts [[User talk:Hirsutism|talk]]) 20:57, 4 July 2017 (UTC) delete per nom. The only independent source is the one from CNET, and that's not sufficient for . --Special:Contributions/Hirsutism|Hirsutism Deletion of ICharts WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
11452 1963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Lalli User:GiantSnowman 17:39, 6 April 2009 (UTC) delete they all fail Deletion of Tony Lalli WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11453 8362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Fournier User:K 02:44, 26 January 2018 (UTC) merge to Students for Trump; not independently notable. Leaders of minor groups are generally redirected to respective orgs; there no reason to deviate from this practice. and lacks that's ''independent'' of his group Deletion of Ryan Fournier WP:TOOSOON||WP:SIGCON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
11454 14767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whiskerville User:Sjakkalle 09:18, 31 August 2006 (UTC) merge to Whiskervilles who are featured in a number of Scrooge McDuck's life stories. This particular webcomic does not appear to pass guidelines Deletion of Whiskerville WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11455 19114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Manolatos User:XinJeisan 09:12, 24 January 2012 (UTC) delete Per nom, no |significant references about the subject exist Deletion of Tony Manolatos WP:NRVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11456 18557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lauren Dinh [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 21:17, 22 January 2015 (UTC) delete Non-notable skater. She fails and has no significant coverage to meet GNG. Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Lauren Dinh WP:NSKATE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11457 9514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Digital Performance (2nd nomination) User:Tokyogirl79 04:19, 12 November 2011 (UTC) delete per nom reasons. It's definitely an essay. To '''Alannamm90''', I heavily recommend that you talk to your professor about not assigning any projects that involve creating pages on wikipedia, at least not creating any without the article going through the Afc process first. I'm not trying to discourage anyone from contributing but not everything needs to be here on the wiki and sourcing doesn't really disguise that this is still an original research essay. At least putting it through the Afc process would help save our time and yours if it's found to be something that doesn't need to be on Wikipedia. (That way we won't have to continue deleting it if it's unencyclopedic and you won't waste your time re-adding it if it's found to be unencyclopedic in any format.) I also heavily recommend that your professor look into using Wikia since that's a site where you can create your own wikis without having to go through Wikipedia and it won't get (potentially) continuously deleted. I don't mean to sound harsh, I'm just trying to save everyone time and effort Deletion of Digital Performance (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11458 7505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Masura Parvin NONE NONE keep per . Article could use expansion, not deletion per . A few sample references to start Deletion of Masura Parvin WP:BASIC||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
11459 21214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phyllis Keino (2nd nomination) User:Melcous 07:46, 12 August 2016 (UTC) delete as per nomination, nothing to indicate this meets or Deletion of Phyllis Keino (2nd nomination) WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11460 15049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of vaporware (2nd nomination) User:Gavin 07:56, 18 April 2010 (UTC) delete as this list fails #DIR as it has no verifiable source, without which it is just istcruft|listcruft without any externally validated rationale for inclusion in Wikipedia. A list needs some form of external validation in accordance with to demonstrate that it is not entirely novel or the product of |original research, and looking at the content of this list, its lack of souring that suggest it is ''entirely'' original research Deletion of List of vaporware (2nd nomination) WP:NOT||WP:L||WP:BURDEN||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11461 9142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Problem-reaction-solution User:Jersey 23:37, 1 August 2006 (UTC) delete article is based on a neologism, reads like a #Wikipedia is not a publisher of original thought|personal essay, and is essentially created as a fork article to promote 9/11 truth points of view Deletion of Problem-reaction-solution WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11462 11583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Romuald Rat User:LeaveSleaves 02:03, 12 November 2008 (UTC) delete under . The article is about person's role in a single incident. Can be easily incorporated into aforementioned article. ''Special:Contributions/LeaveSleaves|Leave Deletion of Romuald Rat WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11463 19517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gameknight999 (character) User:Joseph2302 15:51, 13 June 2015 (UTC) delete Character from a book not notable enough for a Wikipedia article. Fails Deletion of Gameknight999 (character) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11464 3712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Brief History of the Empire User:RMHED 17:59, 27 November 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of A Brief History of the Empire WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
11465 16570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akash soukhee User:WikiDan61 13:30, 19 October 2012 (UTC) comment The article's author has http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Akash_soukhee&diff=518699019&oldid=518692372 blanked the page. Could this be considered a #G7 speedy deletion candidate at this point Deletion of Akash soukhee WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11466 13671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moshpit (french band) User:ShadowHalo NONE comment As it stands, the article does not meet . It states that the band is currently touring; how large is the tour? Providing a |reliable source would also be very helpful Deletion of Moshpit (french band) WP:BAND||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11467 519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Géza von Neményi User:TSO1D 00:18, 8 December 2006 (UTC) delete Appears to be somewhat notable, having published a book and being mentioned in various articles, but probably still does not pass Deletion of Géza von Neményi WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11468 3428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stereotype space User:MarkH21 01:48, 15 April 2020 (UTC) delete to Reflexive space#Other types of reflexivity: Per the arguments made by Taku and D.Lazard, this is not a term widely-used by independent secondary sources to the point that is not met and can apply.{{pb}}Once could argue for a merge to topological vector space, the greater class of objects for which there is substantial secondary sources and standard terminology, but very little content in this article should be merged there on the basis of Deletion of Stereotype space WP:GNG||WP:NEOLOGISM||WP:DUE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11469 254 [[Amarna B. Starnitzky]] (SLA) Benutzer:Logograph 09:47, 23. Jun. 2017 (CEST) delete Für den Inhalt gibt es keinerlei , nur Selbstauskünfte Löschung von Amarna B. Starnitzky Wikipedia:Quellen Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11470 10890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Civilian perspectives on media freedom User:SupernovaExplosion 01:43, 27 April 2012 (UTC) delete Article is an essay with Deletion of Civilian perspectives on media freedom WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
11471 285 [[Jörg Hasse]] (erl, LA zurückgezogen) Benutzer:Tilman Berger NONE keep Ach Gott, hast du denn irgendwo gesucht (außer bei Google), bevor du den Löschantrag gestellt hast? Internetkataloge wie der http://kvk.ubka.uni-karlsruhe.de/|KVK liefern im Handumdrehen drei Bücher von ihm, die ich jetzt in dem Artikel nachtrage. Davon, dass nach den #Wissenschaftler|Relevanzkriterien alle Professoren an Unis relevant sind, will ich gar nicht reden Löschung von Jörg Hasse Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
11472 3423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Audrey Denney NONE NONE keep """The current content and depth/range of sources in this article is somewhat thin, but Wikipedia:Deletion policy says """"If editing can improve the page, this should be done rather than deleting the page."""" I took a quick look for potential sources, and I found many newspaper articles from a range of regional papers with in-depth analysis of why this campaign was unusual for this region and interesting in the context of patterns in the overall 2018 midterm election. I see a reasonable argument for this topic passing . I haven't yet found any larger national papers such as the ''LA Times'', ''Washington Post'', or ''New York Times'' covering her campaign in detail - with that, I would have a stronger Keep vote, but I think this is reasonable enough coverage for GNG""" Deletion of Audrey Denney WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11473 8957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corporation (university) [[User talk:174.212.211.253|talk]]) 20:51, 18 May 2021 (UTC) delete multiple reasons. First, it seems to me that if we have an article at this title, it should be about the legal structure of a university (or possibly about training programs like Hamburger University). The title violates . Since the title is so unclear, it's impossible to locate sources; and as the article is unsourced, it's a clear failure of |pillar policy . Again, since the subject is unclear, I can't see how a reasonable argument for |notability could possibly be made. |TNT is the only solution. Special:Contributions/174.212.211.253|174.212.211.253 Deletion of Corporation (university) WP:CONCISE||WP:5P||WP:V||WP:N||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Article titles 75
11474 21415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tsonka ball User:Joe 00:14, 24 November 2009 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Tsonka ball WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11475 14279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glow (song) User:Acalamari 23:28, 13 November 2007 (UTC) delete as |crystal-ballism Deletion of Glow (song) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11476 15544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mars Holiday User:Agent 20:07, 29 November 2006 (UTC) delete """in fact, '''speedy delete''' as nonsense) Far too many references to """"little known"""" and other weasel words, it's something |made up in school. Lots of """"references"""", but none for this fictitious holiday""" Deletion of Mars Holiday WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
11477 7963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Borg User:Euryalus 01:22, 18 May 2007 (UTC) delete not currently notable (as already mentioned, 6th in national championships is best result). Future notability is possible but |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball. An internet search reveals multiple mentions but the majority are either incidental (eg. lists of contestants) or press releases from the Aaron Borg website Deletion of Aaron Borg WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11478 16393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Takashi Nagasako User:TheFarix 12:49, 5 June 2009 (UTC) keep Passes with several significant roles in multiple notable anime series, particularly Lewis in ''Blood+'' and Pedro (Noooooooooooooo!) in ''Excel Saga''. Ans since the article is almost entirely a , there really is no issues. The article simply needs more depth and detail about the voice actor Deletion of Takashi Nagasako WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:LOW||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11479 14208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Old Trinity Grammarians Soccer Club User:Nick 23:09, 2 March 2013 (UTC) delete No evidence that is met, and it is unlikely that this non-professional team is notable. Wikipedia is not a directory of amateur sporting teams Deletion of Old Trinity Grammarians Soccer Club WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11480 20331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jerome C. Glenn User:Amortias 23:48, 8 May 2014 (UTC) delete Nothing found that could qualify it for , no links to any of the 200 organisations does damage its credibility as well Deletion of Jerome C. Glenn WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11481 362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arpita Mukherjee (2nd nomination) User:scope_creep 10:14, 27 August 2020 (UTC) delete Tenuous arguments. There is no claim to fame here. Almost completely non-notable. The competition aren't that special now. There is so many of them. Fails as well. Where is the social media?? There is nothing there Deletion of Arpita Mukherjee (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
11482 7223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The World May I Championships User:Sue 01:12, 10 December 2012 (UTC) delete not notable possible Deletion of The World May I Championships WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
11483 12269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Hills gold jewelry User:Gobonobo 22:14, 21 January 2013 (UTC) keep per Arxiloxos. This is a distinctive style of jewelery and the http://books.google.com/books?id=44W1CxEZzlcC&pg=PA133&dq=Black+Hills+gold+jewelry&hl=en&sa=X&ei=1rz9UOaSCYXaqgHBroHoCg&ved=0CE8Q6AEwBA#v=onepage&q=Black%20Hills%20gold%20jewelry&f=false official jewelery of the state of South Dakota. Needs some cleanup, but sufficient sources exist to establish notability, making this pass Deletion of Black Hills gold jewelry WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11484 16286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Female telenovela villains User:Juliancolton 17:53, 6 June 2008 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Female telenovela villains WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11485 10939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elevator Air Conditioning User:2 04:08, 24 June 2009 (UTC) delete Neat concept, but has no |N or |V. Wikipedia is OT|not the place to post your invention idea Deletion of Elevator Air Conditioning WP:N||WP:V||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11486 217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Café Allegro User:Expertwikiguy 23:53, 17 August 2020 (UTC) keep Passes per . Seems like its got enough sources Deletion of Café Allegro WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11487 18507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Witchcraft VII: Judgement Hour User:Atlantic306 22:03, 6 April 2019 (UTC) keep as per Reader of the Pack as there is enough coverage to barely pass such as AV Club and TV Guide and others Deletion of Witchcraft VII: Judgement Hour WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11488 8424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ISentia User:Northamerica1000 22:11, 17 November 2015 (UTC) keep Meets ; some of the coverage transcends , providing background information and overviews about the company Deletion of ISentia WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11489 15693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sporebook User:Joe 19:24, 18 December 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this product Deletion of Sporebook WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11490 16242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicolas Perrin User:Stifle 12:31, 30 August 2008 (UTC) keep Misinterpretation of by the nominator — it refers to an article about a person who has appeared in a single newsworthy event (over a short space of time) but is not otherwise notable in their daily life. SBB Cargo is a division of SBB-CFF-FFS, the national railway line of Switzerland, and the CEO of this company would seem to me to be notable. Thanks to Ameliorate for telling me of the nomination; note that being an admin doesn't give me any extra rights to deprod pages, and that was just a normal editorial action Deletion of Nicolas Perrin WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11491 19467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Royden User:Fiftytwo 04:26, 24 March 2018 (UTC) delete no to indicate notability nor claims in the article that would indicate it. Nom's due diligence seems sound Deletion of Royden WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11492 16900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Somrit Ornsomjit [[User_talk:ClubOranje|T]] 23:12, 13 March 2011 (UTC) keep per Struway, verifiable international footballer passes --ClubOranje Deletion of Somrit Ornsomjit WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11493 14537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Newark Boys Chorus User:Edison 00:21, 29 December 2011 (UTC) comment """Undecided. The chorus has toured internationally, and performed at well known venues, but so have many high school choruses, bands and orchestras, and many college a capella groups, whose articles have been deleted. The article's subject seems """"on the bubble"""" as to whether it satisfies notability, either through coverage as a school via or as a musical group via Wikipedia:Notability (music) . It has a stronger case than the average small private elementary school""" Deletion of Newark Boys Chorus WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11494 21633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ainvayi Ainvayi User:onel5969 13:27, 22 September 2015 (UTC) delete I'm going to have to agree with the nom on this one. The lack of RS kills this one. Without those RS, it fails , and I can't find them Deletion of Ainvayi Ainvayi WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11495 72 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Counter-Strike 2D """Kullanıcı:mustafa alperen seki̇m.a.seki̇""" 08:42, 7 Kasım 2014 (UTC) comment Yavaş yavaş maddenin kayda değer olmadığına inanmaya başladım ve silinmesinde problem görmüyörum ancak benzeri bir karışıklığin birdaha olmaması için http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability_(video_games) buraya benzer bir şekilde sayfası oluşturulmalı Counter-Strike 2D'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
11496 11586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eva Sayer (2nd nomination) User:HalJor 03:45, 24 January 2020 (UTC) delete """Doesn't quite pass enough, which requires """"significant roles in multiple notable (productions)"""" -- not really significant (mid-level) and just barely multiple (2""" Deletion of Eva Sayer (2nd nomination) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
11497 21771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mental disorders in film User:Coolabahapple 07:29, 28 July 2020 (UTC) keep meets , article includes references (books) that discuss this grouping Deletion of Mental disorders in film WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11498 20232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Wainer User:Esradekan 23:42, 3 July 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of Michael Wainer WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11499 12741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lightsaber users User:Evb 12:05, 19 October 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. In-universe-only |trivia. #INFO Deletion of Lightsaber users WP:TRIVIA||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
11500 5538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Capital Steez User:Gongshow 00:00, 24 October 2013 (UTC) keep A sampling of available material http://www.thefader.com/2012/02/27/video-joey-bada-f-capital-steez-survival-tactics/http://www.mtvhive.com/2012/09/12/capital-steez-free-the-robots-video/http://www.hiphopdx.com/index/album-reviews/id.1978/title.capital-steez-amerikkkan-korruption-reloaded-mixtape-reviewhttp://pitchfork.com/news/49008-joey-bada-collaborator-capital-steez-of-pro-era-has-died/http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1699408/capital-steez-remembered-pro-era.jhtmlhttp://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1705177/capital-steez-apex-video.jhtmlhttp://www.villagevoice.com/2013-04-17/music/the-sad-tale-of-beast-coast-architect-and-pro-era-emcee-capital-steez/http://www.xxlmag.com/news/2013/04/pro-eras-cj-fly-says-proceeds-from-capital-steezs-album-will-go-to-family/http://www.billboard.com/articles/columns/the-juice/1568857/smth-capital-steez-last-straw-exclusive-song-premiere suggests that this artist had started to garner attention from notable sources prior to his death, and coverage for him has multiplied in subsequent months (not only in late December), enough to satisfy and Deletion of Capital Steez WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11501 19085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oscar DeRosa User:Dane 02:05, 13 December 2016 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Oscar DeRosa WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
11502 17339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exodus of Ethnic Macedonians from Greece User:Raso 08:34, 30 October 2008 (UTC) keep Typical . lol Deletion of Exodus of Ethnic Macedonians from Greece WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11503 18989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sonic Earth User:TheFarix 01:56, 7 September 2006 (UTC) delete as Deletion of Sonic Earth WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
11504 7813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenneth B. Raper User:Xxanthippe 07:19, 24 October 2019 (UTC) keep GS citations pass rof easily Deletion of Kenneth B. Raper WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
11505 199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victor Carrion User:Alpateya 18:52, 17 March 2020 (UTC) delete Lacking strong Deletion of Victor Carrion WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11506 6591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Video Industry User:NeoChaosX 03:54, 8 June 2007 (UTC) delete as a copyvio and per Wikipedia not being #PUBLISHER|a publisher of original research Deletion of Video Industry WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11507 12439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhd Asyraf Azan [[User talk:86.17.222.157|talk]]) 17:41, 23 August 2016 (UTC) keep In the absence of any good reason why squash players should be treated differently from those in most other sports this should be kept as passing by virtue of the subject participating in world championships. The only racquet sport with a world championship that has a specific guideline in is badminton, so it seems sensible to set the bar for squash players at a similar level. Special:Contributions/86.17.222.157|86.17.222.157 Deletion of Muhd Asyraf Azan WP:SPORTCRIT||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11508 3472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helene Rask (2nd nomination) User:SWik78 15:20, 17 April 2008 (UTC) keep Correct me if I'm wrong but I'm guessing it's being nominated for deletion due to a perceived advertisement or . Even if the current version contains such flaws, the article has been around since late 2004 so it's definitely fixable Deletion of Helene Rask (2nd nomination) WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
11509 14635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of celebrity inventors User:Matthew 10:02, 12 March 2007 (UTC) keep per 23skidoo and #PAPER Deletion of List of celebrity inventors WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11510 12777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fox Valley Bible Church User:Radioinfoguy 01:48, 19 July 2008 (UTC) delete Massively fails Deletion of Fox Valley Bible Church WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
11511 14770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kimber W. Malmgren User:David 07:09, 28 July 2007 (UTC) delete I know, , but her case seems noticably weaker than that of Mitchell J. Nathan, a professor of the same rank in a similar research area at the same institution also up for AfD: fewer pubs (20 vs 30), many fewer citations (11 for the best vs 95), no grant mentioned. I didn't think Nathan's case showed anything exceptional that would make it noteworthy and the same goes double here Deletion of Kimber W. Malmgren WP:WAX Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11512 4357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Govt Elementary School Kantrila User:Ammarpad 19:04, 6 December 2017 (UTC) delete It is high schools that are ''presumed'' notable if they have some sources not primary or middle and whatnot. Utterly non notable. No independent sources. It only exists and ≠N|existence is not notability Deletion of Govt Elementary School Kantrila WP:E Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
11513 17996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Montenegro Airlines destinations User:PennySpender1983 15:32, 1 January 2010 (UTC) merge back into Montenegro Airlines with a redirect. By the guideline, this list can be put back into the article about the airline without causing readability issues. When the main article gets long enough to warrant a split, then this list should have its own article. There is enough clean up needed for this airline that the WikiProject should consider keeping it as a single article. (For instance, the :File:YM-Des.svg|article map shows flights to South America even though the official website and the list article do not show flights there.) Concentrating on one article (until size warrants a split) will make it easier to keep the information up to date Deletion of Montenegro Airlines destinations WP:SIZE Wikipedia:Article size 51
11514 7205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Path We Chose (band) User:Richard3120 13:49, 18 September 2018 (UTC) delete fails and . Article created by band member, and no decent independent sources whatsoever – just a couple of run-of-the-mill quotes from an article in ''The Street'' about how Connecticut hip hop is finally getting recognised, nothing about the group itself https://web.archive.org/web/20131029210837/https://www.thestreet.com/story/11103310/1/connecticut-hip-hop-out-of-the-shadows.html?cm_ven=RSSFeed. It's not clear whether the group is still active – their last YouTube posts were five years ago, and their official website is simply a holding page Deletion of The Path We Chose (band) WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
11515 19677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Snit Beer Chaser User:Joe 21:46, 5 January 2010 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Snit Beer Chaser WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11516 56 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/X-Systems [[User talk:69.204.153.39|talk]]) 01:58, 20 October 2015 (UTC) comment The company would appear not to be notable, as stated, but the sources indicate that one or more of its products may well qualify for inclusion. As a process matter, I would ask that we avoid recommending speedy deletion (even though A7 does in fact provide for organizations) except in the gravest of circumstances where has failed us and the integrity of the encyclopedia is at stake. To my mind, this is more of a case of mis-stated notability. --Special:Contributions/69.204.153.39|69.204.153.39 Deletion of X-Systems WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
11517 8162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Economic history of the Christians User:Griswaldo 12:52, 2 April 2011 (UTC) delete per Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Economic history of the Jews. This article was created as a counter- to the Jewish one. There is a viable topic here but the entry is too tainted to exist and should be deleted so someone who isn't violating policy () can start afresh Deletion of Economic history of the Christians WP:POINT||WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
11518 2619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Åke Raask User:onel5969 19:00, 18 October 2015 (UTC) delete searches did not turn up anything on the subject which meets the notability criteria for either or Deletion of Åke Raask WP:NFICT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11519 11255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle of Ramelle User:Obina 09:18, 18 March 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Battle of Ramelle WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11520 15773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Basketball baseball kickball [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 14:45, 21 January 2009 (UTC) delete At least try to be like ''BASEketball'' or something! Definitely Deletion of Basketball baseball kickball WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
11521 12327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harlan Hill (2nd nomination) User:Joseph2302 16:36, 26 September 2017 (UTC) delete as notability is |not inherited, and a few mini-bios aren't enough to pass Deletion of Harlan Hill (2nd nomination) WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11522 2117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shallan Meiers User:Morbidthoughts 19:19, 1 May 2011 (UTC) keep Consistent coverage by Las Vegas Review-Journal adds up. No playmatehood exception in the GNG or . Nominator is confusing trivia as the importance of the topic rather than the depth of coverage. See note 6 in Deletion of Shallan Meiers WP:BASIC||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11523 11121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BrowseAloud (3rd nomination) User:Hut 18:55, 20 February 2018 (UTC) delete yes there are sources, but that doesn't mean we should have an article on it. All the good sources cover the recent incident where the plugin was hacked, which means this article is essentially a for an article about the hack. We can't have an article on the hack because of . Of the non-hack sources http://www.publictechnology.net/modules.php?op=modload&name=News&file=article&sid=13070&mode=thread&order=0&thold=0 is a dead link, http://www.morpethherald.co.uk/news/Northumberland-health--now-you.5238884.jp is a local newspaper (in the UK these are generally not reliable), https://web.archive.org/web/20120204223553/http://www.newstatesman.com/nma/nma2004/nma2004winners.htm an insignificant award which doesn't count for much, http://groups.google.co.uk/group/comp.infosystems.www.authoring.html/msg/0931bf4408880d54 a newsgroup post (useless as a source), http://www.karlgroves.com/2012/04/19/can-assistive-technology-make-a-website-accessible/ some guy's blog. That just leaves https://avsm.org.uk/accessibility/, an explanation of what it does on the website of an organisation which uses it and http://www.digitalaccessibilitycentre.org/index.php/articles/61-text-to-speech which is the site of an company/organisation offering to make your website more accessible. I don't think those are collectively enough to establish notability Deletion of BrowseAloud (3rd nomination) WP:COATRACK||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
11524 4349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Place of power User:DrFleischman 19:07, 24 January 2017 (UTC) delete """Just because a handful to reliable sources use the same combination of three words doesn't mean they're referring to the same thing (i.e. subject). There is no evidence that """"place of power"""" as used across these sources is anything other than a phrase. As such, I agree with {{u|JudeccaXIII}} that applies, and in particular . Since I don't believe we have any reliable sources covering the social or historical significance of the phrase """"place of power,"""" I do not believe it is sufficiently notable for inclusion in Wikipedia. (I'm not watching this page so please ping me if you want my attention""" Deletion of Place of power WP:NAD||WP:WORDISSUBJECT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11525 20050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kwame A.A Opoku User:Bearian 21:42, 18 October 2019 (UTC) delete yet another |run of the mill businessman. No notable awards, lacking |significant coverage Deletion of Kwame A.A Opoku WP:MILL||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
11526 6973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zul'jin (2nd nomination) User:Nicholas 10:14, 24 February 2008 (UTC) delete as per original Afd and this nom. Still not and won't be a contender as per Deletion of Zul'jin (2nd nomination) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11527 6054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Game Industry Map User:Disavian 00:47, 11 August 2008 (UTC) delete appears to fail Deletion of Game Industry Map WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11528 8795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Genevieve Beauchemin User:benlisquare 03:44, 11 October 2009 (UTC) delete No (a CTV biography is not an external, reliable source), fails , fails Deletion of Genevieve Beauchemin WP:RS||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11529 13955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ultima Morgan User:Iridescent 19:22, 23 September 2007 (UTC) delete """I'm the one who de-speedied it, as IMO """"one of the primary partners"""" is a sufficient assertion to make it past A7. Nothing to pass , though, and I don't see how it could be expanded""" Deletion of Ultima Morgan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11530 20697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Logo extraction puzzles User:Mindmatrix 21:41, 25 September 2006 (UTC) merge to Logo. Excluding Wikipedia mirrors, there are less than 500 hits for http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=+-wikipedia+%22logo+extraction logo extraction, and just a few for http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=+-wikipedia+%22logo+extraction+puzzles logo extraction puzzles. While this isn't a definitive measure, it does suggest that this topic doesn't necessarily merit its own article. Moreover, the two inline external links in the article don't meet the |criteria for inclusion (but that's a separate argument). By the way, I agree with the comment that it doesn't matter ''who'' created the article, only whether the article is worth keeping in Wikipedia Deletion of Logo extraction puzzles WP:EL Wikipedia:External links 76
11531 20881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michal Heiman (2nd nomination) User:Malik 17:53, 13 October 2011 (UTC) keep satisfies — Deletion of Michal Heiman (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11532 16774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harold Terry User:Tiller54 22:39, 28 September 2014 (UTC) keep I agree with Billy Hathorn, he easily passes Deletion of Harold Terry WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11533 20131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Momentum (company) User:Shinmawa 18:58, 3 March 2013 (UTC) delete per nom. As stated by nom, all relevant sources are press releases or otherwise primary sources. Unable to find any relevant or substantial secondary sources. Fails Deletion of Momentum (company) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11534 20276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ram Ray (associate professor) User:Spiderone 07:51, 26 November 2020 (UTC) delete no decent coverage in Deletion of Ram Ray (associate professor) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11535 16059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harry MacDowell User:Collectonian 17:45, 12 September 2008 (UTC) delete fails , and . No significant coverage on this character in reliable, third-party sources Deletion of Harry MacDowell WP:N||WP:PLOT||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11536 437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Local Education Agency User:John 09:32, 25 March 2020 (UTC) delete honestly, this is likely a notable subject. But as the nom said, it is little more than a dictionary definition. That could be fixed, but as it exists, it is so shallow and incomplete as to be a disservice to our readers. does apply Deletion of Local Education Agency WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
11537 8859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Turbulence modeling User:Kkmurray 17:57, 6 November 2010 (UTC) keep This should be handled with a redirect, if necessary, per . All of the cited articles are roughly start class with multiple issues. I would suggest moving them all toward C and B class and as you do, a consensus will develop as to what goes where Deletion of Turbulence modeling WP:REDIR Wikipedia:Redirect 56
11538 19131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alek Skarlatos User:Pincrete 09:03, 6 September 2015 (UTC) comment These are all rystal arguments, of course his present fame MAY lead to him being known beyond this event, but at present this one event is the sole reason for the coverage Deletion of Alek Skarlatos WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
11539 18559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adria Airways destinations User:Lugnuts 09:55, 31 January 2018 (UTC) keep Each list meets the criteria for a |stand alone list, with a clearly definined |inclusion criteria on a notable topic. Picking one off the list at random (Air Canada) you |easily find coverage of routes in |news sources (https://www.usatoday.com/story/travel/flights/todayinthesky/2017/11/29/air-canada-keeps-up-u-s-push-six-new-routes-three-new-cities/904691001/, https://www.meetingscanada.com/air-canada-adds-6-international-destinations/), which can be used to expand the article. Instead of looking at ways to delete all these lists, the reverse can be applied: There are two Featured Lists (List of Braathens destinations|example), so there is the potentinal to have 442 more Featured Lists, instead of 442 deleted articles Deletion of Adria Airways destinations WP:LSC||WP:LISTPURP||WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
11540 9621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Linda Tripp User:Phil 21:45, 22 November 2012 (UTC) keep """per point 1. The nominator is asking for redirection, not deletion. That is an editing action that can be discussed on the article talk page, as it doesn't require any administrator to hit the """"delete"""" button. Bringing this to AfD seems to be more a personal attention-seeking device rather than a considered action designed to improve this encyclopedia""" Deletion of Linda Tripp WP:SK Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
11541 7705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thein Naing Oo User:Nfitz 17:01, 2 September 2019 (UTC) keep Nomination is erroneous, as easily meets . We wouldn't be having this discussion in any English-speaking nation where football is the number one sport. Ergo to delete this article is a clear example of Deletion of Thein Naing Oo WP:N||WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11542 10706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Microbiology of Prokaryotes User:Badgerpatrol 22:42, 13 May 2006 (UTC) delete per omplete Bollocks|this important and widely applicable policy Deletion of Microbiology of Prokaryotes WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
11543 11937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of ideas inspired by food in STEM fields User:Colapeninsula 15:18, 17 July 2015 (UTC) delete Amusing trivia but not encyclopedic. Concept doesn't appear to be covered in |reliable sources Deletion of List of ideas inspired by food in STEM fields WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11544 3069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eva Zu Beck User:Piotrus 04:54, 12 July 2021 (UTC) delete I concur that the notability is pretty much due to one incident. in my book Deletion of Eva Zu Beck WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
11545 2271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyberscore User:Richwales 20:08, 8 August 2011 (UTC) delete """per and . Almost all the cited """"sources"""" are references to the subject's own web site (hence not independent). The other """"source"""" is from a forum or blog (not generally reliable per ). I couldn't find any other usable source in a Google search""" Deletion of Cyberscore WP:RS||WP:INDY||WP:SPS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11546 21138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keighley and district service 760 User:Tom 14:42, 19 June 2006 (UTC) delete per - indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of Keighley and district service 760 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11547 18157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arena Premier League User:ArsenalFan700 22:18, 2 October 2020 (UTC) delete Yeah, definitely fails . Funny league, the teams make it look like a Canadian arena World Cup type league Deletion of Arena Premier League WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11548 13110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Strangelove (computer game) User:Lemonsawdust 23:12, 19 April 2007 (UTC) delete Not notable enough in itself. All I can really see is having the reference to the film included in the film's trivia section. Beyond that, it doesn't hold up to Deletion of Strangelove (computer game) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11549 9222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dhananjay Kumar User:David 17:26, 11 May 2011 (UTC) delete This is just a cv, not an article, so even if kept it would need major work to get into shape. The Google scholar citation counts (60, 55, 48, etc, for an h-index of 17) aren't impressive enough to convince me of a pass of #C1. And the awards listed are all very minor. As the nominator concludes, he does not appear to pass Deletion of Dhananjay Kumar WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11550 9710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elvis Hernandez User:Giants27 01:23, 17 April 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Elvis Hernandez WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11551 9308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Critical Care Emergency Medical Transport Program User:Papaursa 01:21, 29 September 2018 (UTC) delete No significant independent coverage to meet Deletion of Critical Care Emergency Medical Transport Program WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11552 18734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emin Amiraslanov User:GiantSnowman 21:07, 14 January 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Emin Amiraslanov WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11553 3901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Refined sugar and ritalin User:Dustimagic 03:46, 12 February 2006 (UTC) delete per nomination, |POV Deletion of Refined sugar and ritalin WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
11554 3 [[Schweizerische Text Akademie]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers 10:35, 4. Aug. 2012 (CEST) delete Kasten|1=. Keine Relevanz gemäß #U vorhanden, eine sonstige Relevanz ist auch nicht ersichtlich. Gruß Löschung von Schweizerische Text Akademie Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
11555 908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gregory Zanetti User:Lesliechin1 23:31, 5 July 2021 (UTC) keep meets notability and Deletion of Gregory Zanetti WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11556 20589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Restorative justice in social work User:Staberinde 11:45, 16 February 2020 (UTC) delete or '''Merge''' into Restorative justice. The article is clearly , that said I am not sure if it has any content worth preserving not already covered in Restorative justice Deletion of Restorative justice in social work WP:REDUNDANTFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
11557 20177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sildëyuir User:The 00:50, 19 October 2013 (UTC) merge """per Mark viking and BOZ. As explained, this is unsuitable for a standalone article, however as a line in the target article would be logical, and redirects are cheap. Redirects can also easily be '''salted''', """"|the redirect would need protection"""" isn't a reason to delete instead of redirect""" Deletion of Sildëyuir WP:LIKELYVIOLATION Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11558 19701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Video index of the most influential rock music User:Fat 16:26, 8 January 2011 (UTC) delete per nom, per User:Erpert, and primarily because it's nothing more than a compilation of |LINKVIOs Deletion of Video index of the most influential rock music WP:LINKVIO Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
11559 21184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Court Martial (1978 film) User:Daß 22:22, 27 July 2018 (UTC) keep per , preserved by Croatian State Archives and received awards at notable festivals http://arhinet.arhiv.hr/details.aspx?ItemId=1_69245 Deletion of Court Martial (1978 film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
11560 20018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Hitchens's critiques of public figures User:Brandmeister 11:16, 18 December 2011 (UTC) delete Aside from |NPOV, the article is a and can of worms; from what I see, there was no significant response to the critiques. The article can be summarized in the Christopher_Hitchens#Critiques_of_specific_individuals|existing relevant section and all other quotations can be moved to Wikiquote Deletion of Christopher Hitchens's critiques of public figures WP:NPOV||WP:SOAP||WP:NOTADVOCATE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
11561 10239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miyama Chiharu User:Satori 01:52, 31 August 2006 (UTC) delete I could find absolutely no English-language Ghits that weren't Wikipedia mirrors of this article (I know she's a Japanese actress, but there should be ''something''). Even if it's not a , it completely and utterly fails Deletion of Miyama Chiharu WP:HOAX||WP:V Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
11562 8079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Street Fighter Anniversary Collection Stratey Guide User:Ihcoyc 14:24, 16 October 2007 (UTC) delete with some reluctance. The relevant notability guideline would appear to be for |books, and it does not appear that it meets any of the criteria for ''per se'' inclusion. The claim that this guide was much better received than other BradyGames guides would appear to need sourcing from reliable sources, although IMO gaming websites might be reliable on these matters. Without that, it's just an article about a game guide. If kept, it should '''move''' to a properly spelled title Deletion of Street Fighter Anniversary Collection Stratey Guide WP:NB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11563 9256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chip Berlet (2nd nomination) User:Carolmooredc 23:02, 25 July 2008 (UTC) keep Obviously Mr. Berlet has the right to remove any allegedly libelous info that does not come from . Meanwhile the page is protected. If he stops editing here, and editing the page, he probably will become less of a target over time. Wikipedia can't have a policy where high profile people - especially people whose views are frequently quoted in wikipedia articles - can just demand that non-libelous articles be removed. Carol Moore Deletion of Chip Berlet (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11564 15741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bela-Vista (football club) User:Sir 15:25, 24 May 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. In the absence of any refnerences or any other indication of significant coverage, this article clearly fails Deletion of Bela-Vista (football club) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11565 4882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Intellectual Darwinism User:Rushyo 13:40, 4 December 2011 (UTC) delete per . The sources are not reliable or have tangental relevance and whilst one or two of the references are okay they're not actually being cited and seem to have been put there just as a weak attempt at preventing deletion. A little bit of as well - the Software Architecture analogy is just... weird Deletion of Intellectual Darwinism WP:NEO||WP:OR Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11566 15137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Disick (4th nomination) User:Rms125a 22:06, 24 June 2015 (UTC) delete """for the same reasons it was deleted three times previously. This is an idiotic abuse of process and of the community's patience. Appearing as an in-law on a reality show (which by definition is not """"acting"""") or being mentioned in gossip magazines do '''not''' indicate lasting notability. Regardless of his fan club. DO NOT REDIRECT. '''Why was this article not |SALTED""" Deletion of Scott Disick (4th nomination) WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
11567 8246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of schools of the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Chicago User:Accesscrawl 05:03, 9 May 2020 (UTC) keep But retain only those items that meet Deletion of List of schools of the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Chicago WP:NLIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
11568 11150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pioneer Records User:Bearian 21:07, 20 May 2018 (UTC) delete only issued a single notable record in 1987. Deletion of Pioneer Records WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11569 1511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rap brief User:Xymmax 14:51, 29 January 2009 (UTC) delete """not that this particular AfD has a chance post-Uncle G's response. Bethbar5, the ABA Journal and appellate court's opinion and AP story confirm that the rapping occurring, and was successful - verifiable if you prefer. It still isn't notable. It's a (legal) news story about something novel. The sources do not describe a """"techinque"""" - the article makes a leap that the sources do not. This interplay between and OTNEWS is often confused, and I don't pretend that I always get it right. Still, this is not currently, and lacks sources to become, an encyclpedia article""" Deletion of Rap brief WP:N||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11570 21359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nina Hossain User:Eludium 18:13, 15 January 2007 (UTC) keep Subject enjoys name recognition in the UK; while such fluff as http://www.thesun.co.uk/article/0,,2006570537,00.html this from ''The Sun'' and http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/tm_objectid=15926368&method=full&siteid=94762&headline=mugger-s-threat-to-kill-nina--name_page.html this from the ''Daily Mirror'' have no place in the article, they demonstrate notability per Deletion of Nina Hossain WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11571 21083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Owl (software) User:Msnicki 17:08, 30 July 2012 (UTC) delete Lacks reliable independent secondary sources to establish notability as required by . Googling, the only thing I could find were some mentions of very obviously different Owl Software in the early 80s. I couldn't find anything on this company nor can I see a reason why it even might be notable. Wikipedia is not for Deletion of Owl (software) WP:GNG||WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
11572 19100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ubisoft Singapore User:Protonk 20:01, 16 August 2008 (UTC) keep More than enough sources are listed by SkyWalker for the article to meet the . If it meets the general guideline it doesn't need to meet . Even if they haven't produced products yet, the sources listed above are more than enough for a start class article on the subject Deletion of Ubisoft Singapore WP:GNG||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11573 21814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harold Covington User:VQuakr 04:16, 26 June 2012 (UTC) keep Per : ''A person is presumed to be notable if he or she has been the subject of multiple published secondary sources which are reliable, intellectually independent of each other, and independent of the subject.'' The references already in the article clearly demonstrate that the subject meets this criterion, and the rest of the deletion rationale is not a valid reason for deletion Deletion of Harold Covington WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11574 4157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/On the Wave Productions User:Warrah 14:18, 19 December 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of On the Wave Productions WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11575 5829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khabararmani.com User:Dragquennom 05:42, 1 May 2011 (UTC) delete Fails , no sources that indicate notability Deletion of Khabararmani.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11576 18971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Lumley User:Argyle 21:26, 18 November 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Stephen Lumley WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11577 14754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brazil as an emerging superpower User:PJM 17:58, 13 October 2006 (UTC) delete per above: Deletion of Brazil as an emerging superpower WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11578 14127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coskel University User:Kaz14 14:06, 17 December 2006 (UTC) keep remarkable. qualified under , featured in national newspaper, major magazines and TV network —The preceding Wikipedia:Sign your posts on talk pages|unsigned comment was added by Deletion of Coskel University WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11579 506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delhi School of Internet Marketing User:CaroleHenson 11:06, 1 December 2016 (UTC) delete WP:COI issues, fails Deletion of Delhi School of Internet Marketing WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11580 17266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Electromagnetic pulse in fiction user:BlindEagle 16:19, 27 September 2007 (UTC) delete This fails the first test of #DIR|this list Deletion of Electromagnetic pulse in fiction WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11581 1112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LeninFighters User:Coredesat 08:52, 3 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of LeninFighters WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11582 10542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Godfrey Poku User:GiantSnowman 11:02, 30 January 2012 (UTC) delete fails both and Deletion of Godfrey Poku WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11583 20091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dawn Padmore User:Wikipeterproject 22:43, 3 February 2010 (UTC) keep Meets the notability criteria of Deletion of Dawn Padmore WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11584 13050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Shankland (2nd nomination) User:Jenyire2 07:07, 25 January 2021 (UTC) keep Meets Deletion of Mark Shankland (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
11585 7056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Demal User:Mark 04:27, 21 June 2016 (UTC) merge into Molar concentration or into Mole_(unit)#Related units. A simple style search shows other sources discussing this unit. I added three reliable sources and expanded the article beyond a dictionary definition. The sources don't discuss the unit in enough depth to pass notability thresholds, but there is enough verifiable material for a short section on this minor but interesting story in the history of conductivity measurement. Indeed, you can still buy demal-quantified calibration products.http://www.hach.com/kcl-0-1d-conductivity-standard-500-ml-0-1-demal-kcl-12-85-ms-cm-at-25-c-radiometer-analytical/product?id=7640532123 As a unit of concentration, it makes more sense to merge it into Molar concentration, but I'd be fine with it going into Mole_(unit)#Related units; the important thing is to preserve verifiable material per our policy Deletion of Demal WP:BEFORE||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
11586 7638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled eighth-generation Codemasters Formula One project User:Ansh666 17:13, 1 October 2014 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Untitled eighth-generation Codemasters Formula One project WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
11587 16564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Lowenthal User:Secret 22:36, 19 October 2010 (UTC) merge or delete Deletion of Mark Lowenthal WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11588 10141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Winter Park Village User:MB 03:26, 26 September 2017 (UTC) delete Just a shopping center. No indication of notability Deletion of Winter Park Village WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
11589 20954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andreas Kraniotakes User:Jakejr 03:00, 4 January 2013 (UTC) delete Subject fails since he has none of the 3 required top tier fights Deletion of Andreas Kraniotakes WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
11590 5190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deji (YouTuber) User:Bearian 00:56, 22 April 2020 (UTC) keep he has 8 million subscribers, but the coverage is decidedly weak considering his popularity. Maybe Deletion of Deji (YouTuber) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
11591 7805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/McKinney Acres, Texas User:Lugnuts 18:25, 21 October 2019 (UTC) keep With more than 800 people living there, it would pass Deletion of McKinney Acres, Texas WP:NPLACE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11592 15176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/At the Zoo (2012 Film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 19:18, 9 January 2012 (UTC) delete or '''Userfy''' back to author per . Non-RS tell us that director Parker Stanfield sought funding,http://www.indiegogo.com/Parker-Stanfield and began shoting his film,http://www.cinesouq.com/profile/parker-stanfieldhttp://www.hv20.com/showthread.php?44301-AT-THE-ZOO-(Screenshots-with-the-Director)http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fKnPZ17MeTU '''If''' or '''when''' this is completed, gets screened and receives coverage in reliable sources, an article ''might'' be considered... but nope... |Not Just Yet Deletion of At the Zoo (2012 Film) WP:NFF||WP:NYF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11593 20809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K narender User:AllyD 07:28, 21 February 2014 (UTC) delete The article text is a close paraphrase (he for I) of the subject's own Wix webpage. No |evidence of |notability Deletion of K narender :WP:RS||:WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11594 14166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Armands Strazds User:Hillman 00:46, 22 June 2006 (UTC) delete as vanity autobiography as per -. It's tough to make it as a composer, particularly a non-pop composer, but |Wikipedia is not a directory Deletion of Armands Strazds WP:VAIN||WP:AUTO||WP:WIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
11595 15522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/European Cases of the Reincarnation Type [[User talk:2over0|2/0]] ([[Special:Contributions/2over0|cont.]]) 06:31, 29 May 2010 (UTC) merge The http://ajp.psychiatryonline.org/cgi/reprint/162/4/823.pdf AJP review is written by a parapsychologist; this severely limits its usefulness as a source, but they appear to be independent enough for the purposes of . The JNMD source does not appear to be a substantive review. The JPR source is currently only being cited to support a statement that it exists; if there is good material here, it looks like it should probably be added to the article. On balance, treatment of this book looks like it would fit better at Ian Stevenson than as a stand-alone artcle Deletion of European Cases of the Reincarnation Type WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11596 15316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of given names User:Ctjf83 18:39, 23 October 2010 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of List of given names WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11597 6778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nina Prinz User:Hydronium 13:22, 9 February 2016 (UTC) keep She appears to meet requirements for , and (#1 & #3) given the larger (but unsourced) list at :de:Nina Prinz (eg: she was http://www.sportbikes.com/articles6c1d.html?id=28852 2007 and http://www.roadracingworld.com/news/prinz-wins-womens-1000cc-european-championship-race-at-misano/ 2008 European Women's 1000cc Champion), and the coverage shown at https://www.google.com.au/search?q=%22nina+prinz&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&gws_rd=cr&ei=M9i5VsqQHMW8mAW_07yADg#safe=off&tbm=nws&q=%22nina+prinz%22 GNews, for instance http://www.crash.net/motogp/news/206289/1/moto2-nina-prinz-earns-sachsenring-wildcard.html Moto2 wild card, and http://thepeninsulaqatar.com/sports/qatar-sport/197404/qmmf-eye-return-to-world-endurance-after-home-win member of the first mixed-gender team to win a round in FIM Endurance racing Deletion of Nina Prinz WP:GNG||WP:SPORTCRIT||WP:NMOTORSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11598 1036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dale Shirkie User:RaiderAspect 01:27, 23 December 2019 (UTC) delete """Only passing references or routine coverage, nothing even remotely substantial. He's a 24 year old playing in the '''fifth''' level of Scottish Football (only the top two meet FPL, so he's nowhere near it), who spent 9 minutes on the field in a FPL six years ago. itself says """"will ''generally'' be regarded as notable"""". If that word has any meaning whatsoever, it applies here""" Deletion of Dale Shirkie WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11599 6173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mana Bar User:NawlinWiki 01:04, 16 May 2010 (UTC) keep clearly a |notable establishment with plenty of |reliable sources to back it up. It seems the IP that kept tagging with speedy is doing so in bad faith, and they don't seem to have any established editing history, thus probably not knowing the standards by which an article can stay. Sounds like on the IP user's part. Kudos to Deletion of Mana Bar WP:N||WP:RS||WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11600 10603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of books to which Stephen King has written an introduction User:AllynJ 20:19, 1 October 2007 (UTC) delete far too trivial to even be worth keeping track of on Wikipedia. Pretty #DIR|loosely associated, too; nothing substantial links these books aside from this. ''Maybe'' consider merging to Stephen King bibliography, but I'd prefer to see it gone altogether personally Deletion of List of books to which Stephen King has written an introduction WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11601 9498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malacca Craft Centre User:Liz 19:50, 22 July 2015 (UTC) delete I found information about Melaka online but the only information I could find on the Malacca Craft Centre was a promotional site for the area (http://amazingmelaka.com/) and a Foursquare check-in. Fails Deletion of Malacca Craft Centre WP:ORGSIG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11602 4341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chaminade College School User:Cunard 06:55, 15 May 2010 (UTC) keep per the arguments outlined in the essay . All high schools are notable. This school has received sufficient coverage in reliable sources to verify the information Deletion of Chaminade College School WP:NHS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11603 17695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muneer Lyati User:Whiteguru 10:14, 4 June 2021 (UTC) delete Non-notable mechanical engineer; does not pass Deletion of Muneer Lyati WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11604 181 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Selçuk ERAT """Kullanıcı:levent abilevent abi""" 22:55, 10 Ağustos 2008 (UTC) delete Umarım ilerde |kayda değer bir şair olur ve biz bu kararımızdan dolayı üzülürüz. Ama şu aiçin ne yazık ki oyum böyle Selçuk ERAT'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
11605 16506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Run Wild: Zombies User:Atama 19:24, 4 May 2011 (UTC) delete I declined the speedy deletion on the article, but I suggested an AfD might be appropriate. I can't find any evidence of |notability through coverage in reliable sources, and it probably violates as a game that hasn't even been created yet (and may never be created Deletion of Run Wild: Zombies WP:N||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11606 18308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rodney Sneijder User:GiantSnowman 14:14, 8 August 2011 (UTC) delete fails and . I agree with the SALTing suggestion as well Deletion of Rodney Sneijder WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11607 16315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Blue Mountains School (Ooty) User:RationalPuff 18:08, 5 February 2021 (UTC) delete No indication of nobility. Fails Deletion of The Blue Mountains School (Ooty) WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11608 451 [[Vorlage:Redundanz]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Matthiasb 23:07, 26. Apr. 2012 (CEST) keep Kasten|1=Ich sehe keinen Sinn darin, dass bleibt, aber die dazugehörige Vorlage hier gelöscht wird, daher die Vorlage auch. Löschung von Vorlage:Redundanz Wikipedia:RED Wikipedia:Redundanz 95
11609 2280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miser (film) User:The 11:43, 17 April 2019 (UTC) delete since subject fails Deletion of Miser (film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11610 18394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Reidenbach User:Bearian 23:25, 15 August 2018 (UTC) delete per and . He fails Deletion of Scott Reidenbach WP:TOOSOON||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Too soon 40
11611 16184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valeri Minkenen User:J 15:54, 13 December 2010 (UTC) delete http://news.google.co.uk/archivesearch?q=Valeri+Minkenen Google News, from the articles I put through a translator, only seems to give him trivial mentions, so fails Deletion of Valeri Minkenen WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11612 11394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CureMD, Inc User:onel5969 14:01, 2 January 2016 (UTC) delete Passes neither nor Deletion of CureMD, Inc WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
11613 14830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mystery Method: How to Get Beautiful Women into Bed User:Snotbot 19:08, 17 June 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 June 17 Deletion of The Mystery Method: How to Get Beautiful Women into Bed WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
11614 200 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/RockA Kullanıcı:dr. coaldr. coal 00:21, 23 Mart 2016 (UTC) delete Grubu, kendisinden bağımsız biçimde ele alan |güvenilir kaynak bulamadım. Varsa, maddede gösterilmesi gerekir RockA'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:GÜVEN Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11615 7305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ash (artist) User:Macys123 18:29, 23 February 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Ash (artist) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11616 9693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HD 154577 User:Cyclopia 09:44, 11 September 2013 (UTC) keep This is an excellent example of failure, as explained in Wikipedia_talk:Notability_(astronomical_objects)#NASTRO_possible_failures|this thread. Lots of third party, sourced information allows us to build a perfectly encyclopedic article, without any need of original research, even if no single source is fully devoted to it Deletion of HD 154577 WP:NASTRO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11617 8401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gun Choi User:David 16:31, 11 August 2018 (UTC) delete unless substantive, clearly-independent sources turn up (the language barrier makes this possible even when English-language searches fail). There are reasonably well cited publications on spinal issues by someone with his name (most likely him) in Google Scholar, so he could squeak out a pass of #C1, rather than having to rely on , but even in that case we need adequate sources for our content about him. And while normally we would accept self-published sources such as a cv by a researcher, for factual details about their career, the vanity-press awards cast even that into doubt Deletion of Gun Choi WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11618 10418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bagus Kahfi User:GiantSnowman 11:53, 26 August 2019 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Bagus Kahfi WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11619 63 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Onur Ustaoğlu Kullanıcı:nanahuatlnanahuatl NONE comment Öncelikle şunu belirteyim bir |kayda değerlik kriterimiz var. Vikipedi'de biyografinizin kalıp kalmayacağına buna göre karar veriyoruz. Bir iki röportaj yeterli değil maalesef. Kaynakların sizin hakkınızda daha detaylı bilgi vermesi lazım. Ve kaynakların güvenilir ve birbirinden bağımsız olması da önemli. Vikipedi'de herkesin biyografisine bu nedenle yer veremiyoruz. Biyografinizin Vikipedi'de yer almaması yaptığınız çalışmaların değerli olmadığı anlamına gelmez. Sadece biyografinizin Vikipedi'ye uygun olmadığı anlamına gelir. Kimsenin önünü açmak gibi bir vizyonumuz yok. Eğer Vikipedi'de biyografinizin yer almasını istiyorsanız öncelikle bunu başka alanlarda başarmanız lazım. Eğer yeterince başarılı olur da adınızdan söz ettirebilirseniz Vikipedi'de biyografinize seve seve yer veririz. Eğer biyografiniz silinirse kullanıcı adınızla başka maddelere içerikler ekleyerek katkıda bulunmaya devam edebilirsiniz. Size aşağıda iki bağlantı bırakıyorum, lütfen dikkatle inceleyin Onur Ustaoğlu'nun silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
11620 8684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shadow Proclamation User:Paul730 00:21, 13 April 2008 (UTC) delete Throwaway line with no real world relevance. Perfect for the Doctor Who Wikia, unsuitable for Wikipedia. Deletion of Shadow Proclamation WP:PLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11621 9454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Guingona User:SportingFlyer 02:16, 4 May 2018 (UTC) delete per nominator: fails and Deletion of Mike Guingona WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11622 4599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Maccabeats User:DRosenbach 13:17, 19 May 2011 (UTC) keep As per this new information, let's get this over with quickly -- Deletion of The Maccabeats WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
11623 15183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dooyoo User:Satori 03:12, 31 July 2006 (UTC) delete The article does not assert notabilty that would satisfy any of the various criteria listed under or Deletion of Dooyoo WP:CORP||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11624 427 [[Witze der DDR]] (Gelöscht) Benutzer:Thomas Tunsch 08:35, 22. Jun. 2007 (CEST) keep """Das Thema ist als Bestandteil der Portal:Alltagskultur|Alltagskultur relevant (siehe auch #Sachen – Themengebiete von A bis Z|Relevanzkriterien). In den ersten 3 Absätzen und im Abschnitt Witze der DDR#Ossi-Wessi-Witze|Ossi-Wessi-Witze werden Aussagen zu politischen und soziologischen Bezügen gemacht, die eine enzyklopädische Berechtigung haben. Hinsichtlich des Übergewichts der Beispiele und der Vollständigkeit der Beschreibung des Phänomens gibt es Qualitätsmängel, die aber m.E. keineswegs eine Löschung rechtfertigen, daher sollte der Artikel werden. Die sprachlichen, soziologischen und historischen Eigenarten rechtfertigen wohl auch die Aufzählung charakteristischer Beispiele, die wegen der Vielfalt des Themas leicht als """"Sammlung"""" mißdeutet werden. Gerade bei Witzen erklärt vielleicht der Witz selbst mehr als eine ausführliche Auslegung""" Löschung von Witze der DDR Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
11625 19441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RobLuna User:Sam 23:41, 19 November 2015 (UTC) delete and both RobLuna and Rob Luna, fails and does not qualify for anything under Deletion of RobLuna WP:SALT||WP:BASIC||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
11626 3780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ten (manga) User:AnmaFinotera 06:03, 7 June 2010 (UTC) delete Fails and - a minor mention in ANN alone is not significant coverage, and non-reliable sources of course cannot establish notability at all. Without actual demonstrable, |verifiable coverage, claims of probably coverage also cannot make it notable as they are not actually shown to exist. As it is now, it is an unnotable book and deletion is appropriate. Recreation as a redirect to Nobuyuki Fukumoto would be appropriate if there are links to it Deletion of Ten (manga) WP:BK||WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
11627 15840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phakamani Mngadi User:Smartyllama 19:24, 8 February 2019 (UTC) keep As others have pointed out, he passes , and passing a is typically sufficient. And for whatever it's worth, he has two appearances with fully pro clubs - he played in a Belgian Cup match between two teams in 2016-17 as well Deletion of Phakamani Mngadi WP:NFOOTY||WP:SNG||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11628 8157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vince Stravino User:Sir 15:22, 9 October 2016 (UTC) delete Since the international matches he played were not Tier 1, the article does not meet Deletion of Vince Stravino WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11629 7320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colin Winkelmann [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 20:06, 12 September 2014 (UTC) delete Article has no reliable sources. Even if reliably sourced I don't his bike jump record is enough to make him notable and his accident would be .Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Colin Winkelmann WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11630 19361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Mischief Makers characters User:Marasmusine 12:08, 30 November 2008 (UTC) delete not written within guidelines; no interesting out-of-universe material to merge. Great game though. Shake shake Deletion of List of Mischief Makers characters WP:WAF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
11631 16602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kyle Duncan (soccer) User:GiantSnowman 19:09, 22 February 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Kyle Duncan (soccer) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11632 13385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crying Lightning User:COMPFUNK2 16:06, 30 June 2009 (UTC) comment """Rexpolsion, """"this will chart top 10 in the UK charts""""? How do you even know this? I'm a big Arctic Monkeys fan myself, but what you just said violates """ Deletion of Crying Lightning WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11633 13139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Pusey User:Anonymous 06:22, 28 August 2007 (UTC) delete as Deletion of Mark Pusey WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11634 19650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/File 18 [[User talk:24.210.149.223|talk]]) 03:32, 26 April 2015 (UTC) delete Not finding any real argument for notability other than . There's a complete paucity of relevant sources and the keep arguments aren't really asserting notability, but personal belief of importance. For an obscure newsletter that was published for a short period by a small audience 25 years ago needs quite a bit more than this to aspire to notability.Special:Contributions/24.210.149.223|24.210.149.223 Deletion of File 18 WP:ITSIMPORTANT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11635 13020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brent Woods, Indiana (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 16:33, 19 March 2020 (UTC) delete while it exists, GEOLAND does not overrule , , or . Even a populated place needs to be verified by more than three extremely brief listings Deletion of Brent Woods, Indiana (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV||WP:V||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11636 151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SDSS J140821.67+025733.2 User:Aldebarium 00:24, 5 July 2018 (UTC) delete object fails . The black hole mass estimate is almost certainly spurious, this is an oddball quasar with a weird spectrum and the usual methods to get rough estimates of black hole masses probably don't work well for an object like this. Note that Kozlowski did not even mention this object in the text of his paper. Presumably if the author had thought it was noteworthy to find a BH with mass 10 times bigger than any previously known from direct dynamical measurement, he would have mentioned that fact in the paper. Instead, this is probably just a case of an automated measurement and mass estimate going wrong and giving a spurious outlier result. As such, this doesn't really even belong in the list of largest known black holes. This is not a reliably measured mass and shouldn't be treated as though it was Deletion of SDSS J140821.67+025733.2 WP:NASTRO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11637 13894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Vaughan (teacher) User:Euryalus 05:54, 14 November 2008 (UTC) keep fails the guideline for |academics but narrowly meets the |general notability guideline as has been the subject of limited coverage in reliable secondary sources, for example http://www.elmundo.es/suplementos/magazine/2005/314/1128105087.html here and http://europeforvisitors.com/europe/news/vaughntown.htm here. The two guidelines are independent of each other - passing either one is sufficient. The article also includes some Spanish-language links from reliable sources which clearly feature Vaughan in some detail, though the precise content requires better language skills than mine. On balance, the coverage in reliable secondary sources is present if a little limited, and with some |good faith re the Spanish language references it seems sufficient to meet the notability criteria Deletion of Richard Vaughan (teacher) WP:TEACHER||WP:N||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11638 5537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Babar Azam statistics in International Cricket User:Dmehus 14:47, 26 January 2020 (UTC) merge into Babar Azam per {{u|PenulisHantu}} and Draft:Babar Azam Statistics, per my comments at Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion/Draft:Babar Azam Statistics. If these charts are already in Babar Azam and were created there ''first'', then '''delete''' is fine; however, if they were created in this article ''first'', requires us to preserve the |attribution history and merge Deletion of Babar Azam statistics in International Cricket WP:ATT||WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
11639 11260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mastered Trax Latino User:Gongshow 18:14, 14 May 2017 (UTC) delete no significant coverage found; does not appear to meet or Deletion of Mastered Trax Latino WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11640 6606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Rickers User:AllyD 13:31, 15 September 2016 (UTC) delete The article was created by a long-standing contributor of articles on TV subjects, so the vanity publishing suggestion is not right. As to this page, though, the subject was a presenter on one children's show, with the sole substantial reference relating to new bosses dismissing him and his co-presenter in cutbacks. There is also some coverage available of his appearance in panto (https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-245281970.html Liverpool Daily Post, 2010 {{Highbeam}}), but I don't see enough to justify a biographical article per , though perhaps a redirect to :Toonattik could be possible Deletion of Jamie Rickers :WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11641 1286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eisenhower Tree User:Viriditas 02:25, 21 February 2014 (UTC) keep as a separate article about the tree. Is the nominator the least bit familiar with ? If not, they should stay away from AfD until they've read and understood it. The Eisenhower Tree is a notable American landmark in the world of golf Deletion of Eisenhower Tree WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
11642 5650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raven De La Croix User:Lacypaperclip 05:48, 16 January 2018 (UTC) keep as per Megalibrarygirl with articles from the 70's and a couple books, plus she meets Deletion of Raven De La Croix WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
11643 2497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexandra Huynh User:SportingFlyer 04:37, 16 June 2018 (UTC) delete it does fail (see my argument at Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Nicole_Simonsen) and more importantly for women's soccer Deletion of Alexandra Huynh WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11644 364 [[Paul Falk (Bensberg)]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:rene78 21:37, 30. Mär. 2010 (CEST) delete """vgl. #Personen """"wegen ihrer Beteiligung an historischen, politischen oder sonst nachrichtenwürdigen Ereignissen bekannt"""" -> vgl. Google News Suche zur Person. Klares""" Löschung von Paul Falk (Bensberg) Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
11645 4817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avraham Solomon User:Yoninah 22:12, 15 September 2014 (UTC) delete per nom. No |secondary sources or significant coverage; does not satisfy or Deletion of Avraham Solomon WP:SECONDARY||WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:No original research 65
11646 11851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Motormaster (2nd nomination) user:Andrew 17:38, 31 October 2019 (UTC) keep Disruptive repeat nomination per Deletion of Motormaster (2nd nomination) WP:DELAFD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
11647 21927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cabal Online User:Ste4k 09:45, 2 July 2006 (UTC) delete Blatant ad. fails ,,self published resources Deletion of Cabal Online WP:VER||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11648 7984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Disick (3rd nomination) User:Dolovis 03:49, 11 August 2014 (UTC) keep It pains me to say this, but the subject of this article passes as evidenced by the sources found in the article and many other independent and significant sources found elsewhere. This guy is a reality shows celebrity and tabloid fodder, and all those stories published about him (like http://www.bustle.com/articles/34732-scott-disick-goes-crazy-at-versace-mansion-kuwtk-finally-shows-us-what-really-went-downhttp://www.webpronews.com/scott-disick-is-filthy-rich-and-wants-you-to-see-it-2014-08http://www.inquisitr.com/1404109/scott-disick-steps-out-with-kourtney-kardashian-in-rare-public-appearance and many more such stories) demonstrates that he is notable; like it or not Deletion of Scott Disick (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11649 11139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dangerous Rhythm (single) User:Esradekan 08:36, 4 January 2009 (UTC) delete as a non-plausible search term, fails notability per #Songs Deletion of Dangerous Rhythm (single) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11650 551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jetman (video game) User:Billscottbob 03:45, 10 January 2008 (UTC) comment This game is one of the most popular Facebook applications today. I would say Keep per and but on the other hand facebook applications hardly have enough history and dynamicism to warrant its own article, so maybe Merge and Redirect would be more appropriate Deletion of Jetman (video game) WP:POTENTIAL||WP:N Wikipedia:Potential, not just current state 11
11651 14205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Graham Bencini User:EC 15:30, 15 September 2017 (UTC) delete agree fails and does not Deletion of Graham Bencini WP:GNG||WP:CS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11652 15036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jon Burklo User:Sir 05:42, 12 January 2014 (UTC) keep Given that Mr. Burklo has played in the fully pro USL Division 2, the article meets Deletion of Jon Burklo WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11653 11470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Preston Marshall User:K 22:30, 18 March 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet and significant RS coverage not found Deletion of Preston Marshall WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11654 3517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mapping (fandom) User:Bearian 22:00, 1 December 2020 (UTC) comment I am a mapper, so I'd like some of it kept somewhere, but the current article |truly terrible. I'd be willing to take on the project. I'm happy with a soft redirect or userfy it Deletion of Mapping (fandom) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
11655 12766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National super hero day User:RC 15:44, 29 April 2008 (UTC) delete Iron Man (film)|Oh yeah, we can delete. BTW, fails Deletion of National super hero day WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11656 9269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John K. King Books User:NJ 01:03, 19 May 2012 (UTC) delete Not notable per . Lacks multiple independent references Deletion of John K. King Books WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11657 19095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandra Grant Bennett User:Wm335td 19:44, 10 September 2020 (UTC) keep I am going to swim against the current here. She passes even without her marriage to a superstar, and relationship with a legend Mrs. Robinson (song)|where did you go Joe DiMaggio?. Some sources in the article go toward notability https://pagesix.com/2007/09/26/didnt-leave-heart-with-tony/ 1. https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0335639/?ref_=fn_al_nm_1 Her IMDb shows that she has been an actress and was in noteworthy productions: she had recurring roles on The Lieutenant (TV series) (It aired on NBC on Saturday evenings in the 1963–1964 television schedule.) as well as other lesser roles in Hollywood productions. If we must remove I suggest a merge with Tony Bennett as a Deletion of Sandra Grant Bennett WP:NACTOR||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
11658 14337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chumbly Biscuits User:Capitalistroadster 22:17, 20 December 2005 (UTC) delete under and not a crystal ball. If and when, they are the next big thing or at least meet at least one of our musical criterion, they can have an article Deletion of Chumbly Biscuits WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11659 11373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Fundator User:David 22:11, 6 February 2020 (UTC) delete Google Scholar shows only single-digit citations (totalled over all publications), far below #C1. No other evidence of notability is apparent Deletion of Michael Fundator WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11660 6553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scooby Doo 3: Unleashed User:Erik 15:47, 31 July 2008 (UTC) delete per since there is no verifiable coverage about this project Deletion of Scooby Doo 3: Unleashed WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11661 5994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eagles Nest Cafeteria User:Northamerica1000 05:26, 18 March 2015 (UTC) delete Fails per a lack of significant coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Eagles Nest Cafeteria WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11662 6769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Royal inserts User:Aurochs NONE delete fails Deletion of Royal inserts WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11663 7367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008 Texas vs. Texas Tech football game User:Dirtlawyer 13:57, 29 October 2014 (UTC) keep I have to agree with Falcon's rationale for GNG, and I'm disturbed in this pattern of what I believe to be misapplied guidelines such as -- I've asked for clarification on this specific one at Wikipedia talk:Notability (events)#Requesting feedback on and no one from that project has responded as of yet (There is, of course, a response from Deletion of 2008 Texas vs. Texas Tech football game WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11664 19723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bagged & Boarded User:Tedder 03:37, 15 February 2011 (UTC) delete per nom. No given or found to establish notability of a something Deletion of Bagged & Boarded WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11665 12631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hello Beautiful User:JD554 18:15, 24 September 2008 (UTC) delete """both: Neither article meets the criteria for notability at . The awards claimed in both articles fail and are not """"major music competitions""" Deletion of Hello Beautiful WP:BAND||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
11666 3303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spencer Paige User:Mazter00 13:37, 24 December 2012 (UTC) delete Fails with 2/0 (notable opponents/notable events) where 3/3 is required. The potential is not here as he figths for a smaller promotion. TUF fight are pro fights, not amateur fights. Since TUF Season N (I'm guessing around 5, maybe before that) UFC required that fighters who wanted to be on the show to be 21 years of age AND at least 3 or more pro fights. Amateurs are no longer allowed on TUF (where there ever? Maybe season 1). http://www.sherdog.com/fighter/Jason-Thacker-12690 Found one, Jason Thacker, no pro figths when entering season 1 Deletion of Spencer Paige WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
11667 21362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Selman Munson & Lerner User:AllyD 07:40, 19 October 2017 (UTC) delete A article about a |firm going about its business. No |evidence of encyclopaedic notability provided or found. Fails Deletion of Selman Munson & Lerner :WP:SPA||:WP:RUNOFTHEMILL||:WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
11668 5316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Adams (Character) User:Ihcoyc 15:05, 10 March 2010 (UTC) comment This article is about a character from the film ''The Magnificent Seven''; see also rticles for deletion/Bernardo O'Reilly. Suggest that the two discussions share a common outcome, whatever that may be Deletion of Chris Adams (Character) WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
11669 11787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Contortionist User:Stuartyeates 08:04, 9 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of The Contortionist WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11670 6528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muntadar al-Zaidi User:Badagnani 07:31, 16 December 2008 (UTC) keep and close per Deletion of Muntadar al-Zaidi WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
11671 2185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enslavement of Beauty User:Chubbles 01:29, 21 June 2012 (UTC) keep Two albums on the Head Not Found label meets bullet 5 Deletion of Enslavement of Beauty WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11672 7874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rabbi rabbit User:Coredesat 05:47, 6 July 2006 (UTC) delete as |hoax (untruthful article) and non-notable. Fails Deletion of Rabbi rabbit WP:HOAX||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
11673 13903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rajavardan User:Pahiy 00:19, 1 September 2020 (UTC) delete or '''Weak Delete''': Another case of an article failing Deletion of Rajavardan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11674 12908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tufail Khan Rigoo User:Anupmehra 20:33, 21 September 2016 (UTC) delete Not seeing a single substantial coverage of subject in any of the reliable sources. Fails & Deletion of Tufail Khan Rigoo WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11675 19316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Guild Home Video and Pathé releases User:Ajf773 21:24, 1 September 2017 (UTC) delete clear case of Deletion of List of Guild Home Video and Pathé releases WP:NOTCATALOG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11676 2902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ma-Haw-Tha-Dha User:GO 19:40, 25 June 2008 (UTC) delete as nonsense. http://www.excite.com Excite search has more than two results, but none of them appear to mention anything similar to what this article contains. and #G1 both come into play here Deletion of Ma-Haw-Tha-Dha WP:HOAX||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
11677 13261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ġnejna Bay User:Siva1979 04:08, 26 July 2007 (UTC) delete A http://www.google.com.sg/search?as_q=&hl=en&num=100&btnG=Google+Search&as_epq=%C4%A0nejna+Bay&as_oq=&as_eq=wikipedia&lr=&as_ft=i&as_filetype=&as_qdr=all&as_occt=any&as_dt=i&as_sitesearch=&as_rights=&safe=images google search brings out no |reliable hits for this subject. Moreover, there are also |notability concerns as well. --|S Deletion of Ġnejna Bay WP:RS||WP:N||WP:EA Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11678 20724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alofoque User:Mangojuice 20:19, 12 June 2006 (UTC) delete Their website may assert notability, but they don't even have a list of albums, if they even have any, and from , an international tour needs publication in a reliable source to back it up. Their website is ''not'' a reliable source Deletion of Alofoque WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
11679 6570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isidor Sauers User:Dhartung 00:32, 29 November 2007 (UTC) delete as Google Scholar shows multiple publications, but only one has as many as a couple dozen citations. Doesn't seem to meet Deletion of Isidor Sauers WP:PROFTEST Wikipedia:Notability 77
11680 3695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Composite Index of National Capability [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart111''']] [[User talk:Stalwart111|(talk)]] . 04:34, 29 August 2012 (UTC) comment of the four provided references, one is anonymous (though the organisation is identifiable by working back through the URL), one is a presentation for which the author can be theorised (again, back through the URL - it's on his section of his faculty's site but the document itself contains no details), one is a fairly well-referenced university thesis for which the author is known and the other is an excel sheet with a list of numbers (clearly not a reliable source). I would venture to suggest that only the university thesis would constitute a ''reliable'' source and one single reliable source surely does not constitute ''significant coverage''. I do, however, think this is a |surmountable problem but the article needs some work. It may be easier to '''Merge''' as others have suggested. Cheers Deletion of Composite Index of National Capability WP:SURMOUNTABLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11681 16905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of video games notable for negative reception User:Spy 00:03, 6 April 2021 (UTC) keep Clearly meets Deletion of List of video games notable for negative reception WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11682 7623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandeep Lamichhane User:Joseph2302 21:40, 2 March 2016 (UTC) delete U-19 cricketer fails and Deletion of Sandeep Lamichhane WP:NCRIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11683 6610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carwood Lipton User:Alansohn 23:59, 5 November 2017 (UTC) keep the extensive coverage means he meets with ease, and as Deletion of Carwood Lipton WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11684 2917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Handjob User:Caknuck 01:24, 3 January 2007 (UTC) keep Usage is too widespread to use as justification for deletion Deletion of Handjob WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11685 20155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khalnazar Agakhanov User:Postdlf 02:01, 17 April 2013 (UTC) keep """Wikipedia should have articles on all permanent ambassadors for the same reason it should have articles on all national legislators, judges on national courts, etc. You can call that """"inherent notability"""" if you like, or a presumption that GNG will always be satisfied for such individuals; I really don't care because satisfying notability guidelines (which are a good but not perfect proxy for determining what is or isn't important enough to include) should not be a concern with obviously important subjects such as this, so long as we follow the policies of V, OR, NPOV (which actually are important all the time). Or you can call it an invocation, because deleting articles on permanent ambassadors does not improve the encyclopedia in any way""" Deletion of Khalnazar Agakhanov WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
11686 11543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cork Street User:Coldmachine 06:42, 3 September 2007 (UTC) delete Per |WP not being a directory, but I'm open to changing this !vote if someone has a different interpretation of Deletion of Cork Street WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11687 13920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of most-followed Instagram accounts (2nd nomination) User:Skirts89 19:56, 17 February 2019 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of List of most-followed Instagram accounts (2nd nomination) WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
11688 4919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cariphalte (3rd nomination) User:Usernameunique 20:32, 22 February 2021 (UTC) comment """A cursory Google search establishes that lots of sources exist, and make it clear that this is a well-known product in the industry. These include at least two peer-reviewed studies (5 and 6 in the links that follow), contrary to one of the professed reasons for nominating this article (""""the sourcing doesn't establish how well it performs or anything close to in depth""""). Examples of sources: https://www.highwaysmagazine.co.uk/Shell-Cariphalte-50-years-and-counting/4092 1; https://hub-4.com/news/the-bugatti-circuit-of-le-mans-starts-afresh-thanks-to-shell-cariphalte-racetrack 2; http://www.haythink.com/news/detail.asp?ID=10158 3; https://web.archive.org/web/20200811135706/https://www.worldhighways.com/wh6/products/researchers-trial-3d-printing-both-concrete-and-asphalt-roads 4; https://clicsearch.csp.edu/discovery/fulldisplay?docid=cdi_proquest_journals_1563382657&context=PC&vid=01CLIC_CONCORDIA:CSP&lang=en&search_scope=CSP_all_P_and_E&adaptor=Primo%20Central&tab=CSP_Library_physical_and_online&query=sub,exact,%20ROAD%20PROJECTS%20,AND&mode=advanced 5; https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/SHELL-CARIPHALTE-M-THE-A14-A-CASE-HISTORY-Preston/a970f354e3275d464712ab5d0f1e66554280377d 6; https://highways.today/2017/01/18/shells-innovations-bitumen-research-development/ 7; http://revistavial.com/shell-bitumen-lanza-al-mercado-shell-cariphalte-am3-fresh/ 8. Other sources were also raised in this article's previous nominations; they simply have not been incorporated into the article. {{u|Johnpacklambert}} and {{u|TenPoundHammer}} appear to be basing notability off of the state of the article, but that is otability#Article content does not determine notability|not how notability works. Incidentally, the nominator's claim that there were """"Two No Consensus AfDs"""" is just flat-out false: The first was closed as a keep""" Deletion of Cariphalte (3rd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11689 717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cricket dolls User:Ritchie333 16:07, 17 July 2013 (UTC) keep Mentioned in http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=Y1JUAAAAMAAJ&q=%22Cricket+doll%22&dq=%22Cricket+doll%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=X7_mUbiwJK2d0wWw_oHYDg&redir_esc=y Vanguard Volume 17 (Vancouver Art Gallery., 1988), http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=emoB6nlNoMEC&pg=PA117&dq=Cricket+doll+tape&hl=en&sa=X&ei=4L_mUf4fhJfUBYH9gbAD&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=Cricket%20doll%20tape&f=false Social World of Pupil Assessment: Processes and Contexts of Primary Schooling Ann Filer, Andrew Pollard {{ISBN|9781847143969}} p.117 and http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=0srtp8elakMC&pg=PA262&dq=Cricket+doll+tape&hl=en&sa=X&ei=4L_mUf4fhJfUBYH9gbAD&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=Cricket%20doll%20tape&f=false Out of the Garden: Toys, Tv, and Children's Culture in the Age of Marketing Stephen Kline Verso 1993 {{ISBN|9781859840597}} p.262 . Lots more coverage in nostalgia blogs and sales on eBay, but those three sources, plus the coverage Andrew picked up, ought to be enough to meet . Should be at least possible to |wipe out any copyvios and start again Deletion of Cricket dolls WP:GNG||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11690 3837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of unarmed African Americans killed by law enforcement officers in the United States User:BabbaQ 16:51, 19 July 2021 (UTC) keep meets and verifiable info Deletion of List of unarmed African Americans killed by law enforcement officers in the United States WP:NLIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
11691 12462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disney James User:Kashmorwiki 17:20, 18 February 2021 (UTC) delete I did a efore. The real problem here is that its hard to find sources because when I search his name, I am getting results about Disney and related subjects in both English and Malayalam due to its popularity. Thus the subject clearly fails as there are no sources available to establish notabilty. But sources may exist because the subject has appeared in some major films in Malayalam movies.Regards Deletion of Disney James WP:B||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Bots 21
11692 17823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arif Nezami User:Worldbruce 06:12, 9 March 2016 (UTC) delete """The ''Dhaka Tribune'' is usually a reliable source, but in this case they've republished a list put out by SD ASIA, a company that creates """"marketing access for entrepreneurs"""" and specializes in """"PR & branding"""". Being on their """"Inspiring individuals to follow in 2015 in Bangladesh"""" list is meaningless notability-wise. Searches of the usual Google types, HighBeam, and EBSCO found no significant coverage in independent reliable sources, so fails """ Deletion of Arif Nezami WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11693 692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of modelled aircraft in IL-2 Sturmovik: Cliffs of Dover User:Rorshacma 16:42, 26 May 2021 (UTC) delete The game is certainly notable, which is why we IL-2 Sturmovik: Cliffs of Dover|have an article on it. This list, however, is complete material, per the arguments presented in the nomination Deletion of List of modelled aircraft in IL-2 Sturmovik: Cliffs of Dover WP:GAMEGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11694 21856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashtree Primary School (3rd nomination) User:GRBerry 19:50, 12 November 2006 (UTC) delete No assertion of encyclopedic |notability. No non-routine coverage from |independent sources to show that anyone else considers it notable. No more notable than the local Marks & Spencer Deletion of Ashtree Primary School (3rd nomination) WP:N||WP:INDY Wikipedia:Notability 77
11695 18633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stewart Green User:Bearian 01:38, 24 June 2017 (UTC) keep Olympians |almost always pass muster Deletion of Stewart Green WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
11696 1326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Dragonlance artifacts User:FreeRangeFrog 21:35, 12 January 2013 (UTC) delete As listcruft, collection of dubious value, no standalone notability for anything there, no encyclopedic need for a 'breakout' article of that magnitude and especially #PLOT. I'm sure there's a Wikia somewhere that would be a better host for this Deletion of List of Dragonlance artifacts WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11697 19819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ray Narvaez, Jr. User:Bearian 17:56, 18 March 2016 (UTC) delete due to even the allegation of notability. Not all Internet celebs are automatically notable. If |better sources were found, there could be an argument for |general notability, but I'm not getting it Deletion of Ray Narvaez, Jr. WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11698 14476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Bilyeu User:Jimcastor 06:38, 18 December 2019 (UTC) delete no reliable source , and obvious Deletion of Thomas Bilyeu WP:REFBOMB||WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:Citation overkill 60
11699 10475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Priya Prakash Varrier User:Insertcleverphrasehere 20:47, 12 February 2018 (UTC) delete Doesn't qualify for , as no film roles in released films (would require multiple anyway). Viral maybe, but no significant coverage of the actress herself in reliable sources except in relation to the viral video. applies to the viral video she became internet famous for (for a wink in a viral song video of all things). Does not meet notability requirements Deletion of Priya Prakash Varrier WP:NACTOR||WP:BLP1E||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11700 123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syed Ahmed2 User:Mike 07:48, 8 August 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Syed Ahmed2 WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11701 311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Weihwa Chinese School User:CaliforniaAliBaba 04:33, 31 December 2009 (UTC) delete Zero signs of non-trivial coverage either http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=annandale+weihwa&btnG=Search+Archives&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&scoring=a in English or http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22%E7%B6%AD%E8%8F%AF%E4%B8%AD%E6%96%87%E5%AD%B8%E6%A0%A1+&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&btnG=Search+Archives in Chinese Deletion of Weihwa Chinese School WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11702 5696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tshepo Stanley Ramodisa User:Bearian NONE delete per and for |lack of reliable sources Deletion of Tshepo Stanley Ramodisa WP:TOOSOON||WP:RS Wikipedia:Too soon 40
11703 16477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Motherland magazine User:Randykitty 18:02, 25 February 2014 (UTC) delete No sign of any notability. Does not meet Deletion of Motherland magazine WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11704 14464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sepehr Salehi User:Dflaw4 13:41, 20 March 2020 (UTC) delete The subject might meet criterion 2 of given his social media following, but fails , as far as I can tell. He has been in a couple of big films, although his roles seem to have been relatively minor. It's a bit for an article on the subject, I think Deletion of Sepehr Salehi WP:ENT||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
11705 13471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walt Langendorfer User:Icewhiz 06:09, 22 August 2019 (UTC) delete While being involved in gun design (and patents) may be lead to notability, in this particular case I don't see how sources in the article establish notability and I don't see much more in my - fails GNG Deletion of Walt Langendorfer WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
11706 19324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Speed racer pass User:Alexius08 05:10, 10 October 2008 (UTC) delete as a |neologism Deletion of Speed racer pass WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11707 14455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cincinnati-Columbus rivalry User:Elspamo4 22:26, 13 March 2019 (UTC) delete per . The article is probably based off https://www.wcpo.com/news/insider/yes-hell-is-real-cincy-and-columbus-fans-finally-have-the-rivalry-theyve-been-itching-for this news item that talks about the possibility of a derby once FC Cincinnati debuts in the MLS. As of right now they've had only one match, so it most definitely isn't a derby yet Deletion of Cincinnati-Columbus rivalry WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11708 20223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Holmes (football player) User:DarkAudit 01:50, 7 July 2008 (UTC) comment College football is not considered an amateur sport because there is a fully professional level of competition. He is not played in a professional league, so does not meet the guideline. Even as a college football player, there isn't much here but a lot of peacock words that make him sound more notable than he is. Nothing here to show that he is notable even on his own team. The majority of the references are for the drug bust and the aftermath. Not only is it a |single event, the coverage is all local. Local as in towns of 20,000 or less local. There is coverage, but mere coverage is not sufficient per guidelines. It needs to be significant coverage. It isn't Deletion of John Holmes (football player) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11709 8507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qoob Realtime Frontend Page Builder for Wordpress User:Robert 02:33, 21 August 2017 (UTC) delete Non-notable software. Contains just enough description to avoid |G11, but that doesn't make it pass |software notability Deletion of Qoob Realtime Frontend Page Builder for Wordpress WP:G11||WP:NSOFTWARE Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11710 19579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Otaka's scoop [[User talk:Yngvarr|Yng]][[Special:Contributions/Yngvarr|varr]] 16:29, 28 December 2007 (UTC) delete """Couldn't this be sent under #A7, no assertion of significance? A very brief search turns up one hit: itself. I haven't looked at Cosmos, BlogPulse, or the other """"blogspheres"""", but I'm not sure if that would even add to notability""" Deletion of Otaka's scoop WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11711 19686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Griffin Myers User:Gongshow 18:05, 19 December 2012 (UTC) delete I'm unable to find evidence that this person meets or Deletion of Griffin Myers WP:BASIC||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11712 8405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Corre (professional wrestling) User:Oakster 21:42, 22 January 2011 (UTC) merge with Wade Barrett or Nexus (professional wrestling) per Nikki311's explanation of . None of the keep statements so far has noted why it's notable ''now'' as opposed to ''possible'' notability in the future. -- Deletion of The Corre (professional wrestling) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11713 733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Major:The Film User:Otr500 06:40, 24 March 2019 (UTC) delete """Does not pass Wikipedia:Notability (films). A |BLP related article with one dead source, that has an apparently unrelated title: """"2 NSG men killed, six others injured in Mumbai gunbattles"""", could likely be speedy deleted""" Deletion of Major:The Film WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11714 693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rolling Stone Queen of Pop Index User:HĐ 04:40, 2 March 2021 (UTC) delete No indication of notability per Deletion of Rolling Stone Queen of Pop Index WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11715 8038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Bair User:WaterwaysGuy 14:50, 9 May 2019 (UTC) delete fails to meet Deletion of John Bair WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11716 240 [[Corps Guestphalia Erlangen]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Alcibiades 10:00, 21. Sep. 2007 (CEST) delete Keine Relevanz nach gegeben. Zumal Moneyranch festgestellt hat, dass die „Persönlichkeiten“ nur zugeliehen sind Löschung von Corps Guestphalia Erlangen Wikipedia:Artikel über Studentenverbindungen Wikipedia:Richtlinien Studentenverbindungen 45
11717 16623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avonair Curling Club User:Ajraddatz 02:17, 13 March 2016 (UTC) delete fails ; I can't find any reliable sources about it, only some of its members. And those are very sparse Deletion of Avonair Curling Club WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11718 14565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas J. Nichols User:AusLondonder 23:13, 4 February 2017 (UTC) delete Fails both and Deletion of Thomas J. Nichols WP:NPOL||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11719 8490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Attal: Lords of Doom User:Sephiroth 02:25, 2 June 2007 (UTC) delete per . Zero verifiable sources Deletion of Attal: Lords of Doom WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11720 10801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hicks Withers-Lancashire user:Andrew 09:57, 8 June 2021 (UTC) keep Multiple obituaries including the ''The Times'' and so the subject passes and Deletion of Hicks Withers-Lancashire WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11721 19067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sruli Recht (2nd nomination) User:Dennis 14:21, 2 May 2013 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass . The only book sources I found are essentially copies of this article and other promotional type articles. The one Huffington Post article is reasonable, but by itself is insufficient to demonstrate the individual meets the criteria for inclusion Deletion of Sruli Recht (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11722 12187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gersh Kuntzman User:Qworty 06:45, 12 February 2012 (UTC) delete Fails , , , Deletion of Gersh Kuntzman WP:AUTHOR||WP:BIO||WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11723 3820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bader Al-Deayea User:GiantSnowman 15:49, 2 April 2011 (UTC) delete no evidence that he has played in a fully-pro league, failing Deletion of Bader Al-Deayea WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11724 5049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of lifestyles (2nd nomination) User:Stifle 19:15, 9 April 2008 (UTC) delete per points 3, 6 and 8 Deletion of List of lifestyles (2nd nomination) WP:LC Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
11725 4634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comb Ball User:BusterD 23:30, 12 February 2008 (UTC) delete Note the references date previous to the supposed creation date of the subject and are therefore completely irrelevant. This has all the notability of |Baseketball (before the BASEketball|movie Deletion of Comb Ball WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
11726 20238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of flags by number of colors (2nd nomination) User:Ajf773 18:44, 8 May 2018 (UTC) delete per previous AfD. This is and Deletion of List of flags by number of colors (2nd nomination) WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11727 21322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Wednesday User:Nsk92 16:56, 20 September 2008 (UTC) keep and a to the nominator. Please do a few quick searches first, before nominating for AfD. A quick googlenews searchhttp://news.google.com/news?hl=en&q=%22A%20Wednesday%22%20%22Neeraj%20Pandey%22&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=wn shows that there is a very substantial amount of in-depth and specific coverage of the film by independent sources. The article needs to be expanded and improved, but that is not a reason for deletion Deletion of A Wednesday WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Whacking with a wet trout 74
11728 4195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1893 De La Salle Institute football team User:SportingFlyer 04:17, 23 May 2020 (UTC) delete the season itself isn't notable, just a couple routine game blurbs, no . Just because a team played Notre Dame doesn't make their season notable. If there's a requisite Notre Dame season article some of the information can be moved there, or to any De La Salle article we might have Deletion of 1893 De La Salle Institute football team WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11729 662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bricemanning [[User talk:Ultimus|'''UlTiMuS''']] 09:54, 29 August 2006 (UTC) delete """To anon: it is not our job to prove that this term is worthy of inclusion in an encyclopedia. It is yours, since you are making the claim. All you have to do is provide a single reliable source per and I promise to vote for a keep. The problem is that you almost surely can't, and so this is nothing more than a non-notable, non-verifiable neologism that's only used by a few users on a few forums (""""narrow scope"""" per myself before""" Deletion of Bricemanning WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11730 19209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Scarborough User:Isotope23 19:45, 12 October 2006 (UTC) delete as subject does not meet as well as the lack of sourcing Deletion of Mark Scarborough WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
11731 14270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ollie Ox User:BlueValour 02:59, 1 August 2006 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Ollie Ox WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11732 20073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan-Zico Black User:Bald 11:23, 27 July 2012 (UTC) keep there's no doubt he fails by a country mile, but the media interest he's recently attracted in Brazil (including having a documentary filmed about him by TV Globo, one of the largest TV companies in the world) means that he easily passes the |general notability guideline.http://www.clicksergipe.com.br/blog.asp?pagina=1&postagem=57043&tipo=esportesbrhttp://www.thisisguernsey.com/sport/2012/03/13/brazil-nut-‘zico’-to-be-filmed/http://globoesporte.globo.com/futebol/futebol-internacional/futebol-ingles/noticia/2011/08/xara-de-idolo-do-fla-zico-britanico-vive-o-lado-nada-brilhante-do-futebol.html Deletion of Ryan-Zico Black WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11733 1092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian M Barnett User:Nikki311 05:37, 25 January 2016 (UTC) comment """he didn't perform """"in the highest level in two sporting fields."""" In baseball, he was in the minor league and training. In wrestling, he worked dark matches, tryouts, and as a jobber. I'll leave it to someone else to decide whether his mentions in the ''Phoenix News Times'' count as significant third party coverage to meet """ Deletion of Brian M Barnett WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11734 14460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/T.O.'s Law User:Bethling 00:05, 8 September 2006 (UTC) delete per the time tested Isotope23's law ;). Godwin's law is widespread enough that its existence has been cited in several reliable sources. With out that same sort of coverage outside the web, it's just a |neologism that lacks |notability Deletion of T.O.'s Law WP:NEO||WP:N Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11735 13711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Short cases of Clinical Medicine User:Worldbruce 21:43, 30 January 2017 (UTC) keep """or merge to ABM Abdullah, the author. The |notability criteria for academic and technical books is very different from . The textbook is published by a major academic publishing company, and is in its fifth edition. On the subcontinent, online lists of prescribed textbooks are all but nonexistent, so I can't prove that it's required reading at, say, Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib Medical University|Bangladesh's only medical university, where the author teaches, but common sense suggests the publisher wouldn't keep printing new editions if it weren't used at one or more educational institutions. The non-English sources that nom dismisses as """"more about the book's author than the book itself"""" are about the author winning an award ''for the book'' from the University Grants Commission (Bangladesh)|apex body of all universities in Bangladesh, which shows the book is regarded as an important work.http://thedailynewnation.com/news/46207/ugc-award-announced.htmlhttp://www.prothom-alo.com/bangladesh/article/478324http://www.kalerkantho.com/print-edition/news/2015/03/15/198821""" Deletion of Short cases of Clinical Medicine WP:TEXTBOOKS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11736 16976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Narcissism user:ackoz 13:40, 18 June 2006 (UTC) keep The editor is trying to create an article here, it doesn't mean that if it is short, it will not be longer. By deleting this, you, who do not edit the article, thus are incompetent, only discourage the editor in his efforts. I have saved the wiki source code for this article, and if deleted, I will restore it per Deletion of Narcissism WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
11737 4528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jefferson Souza Araújo Menezes User:Spiderone 21:43, 23 June 2021 (UTC) delete WP:BEFORE clearly done by nominator. I attempted to find sources myself but could not locate any coverage towards ; only wide-ranging databases with a stats profile page about him like https://www.sport.de/fussball/pe265108/jefferson/ Sport.de Deletion of Jefferson Souza Araújo Menezes WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11738 18315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeera P. Charnoe (Zee Charnoe) User:Snappy 17:53, 29 December 2010 (UTC) delete Not notable, fails . Possible vanity/puff piece Deletion of Zeera P. Charnoe (Zee Charnoe) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11739 1069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monte Snavely [[User talk:64.107.182.4|talk]]) 19:28, 16 July 2008 (UTC) merge fails . Special:Contributions/64.107.182.4|64.107.182.4 Deletion of Monte Snavely WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11740 9916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dhani Kumharan, Taranagar User:Northamerica1000 09:33, 16 April 2016 (UTC) keep Meets as a legally recognized place (http://www.censusindia.gov.in/PopulationFinder/View_Village_Population.aspx?pcaid=847880&category=VILLAGE, https://books.google.com/books?id=xrfUAAAAMAAJ&q=%22Dhani+Kumharan%22&dq=%22Dhani+Kumharan%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwij8p7H7JLMAhVKwWMKHV76CN0Q6AEIMDAE Deletion of Dhani Kumharan, Taranagar WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
11741 20424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sudwerk User:Mark 00:35, 3 March 2016 (UTC) keep a marginal keep per and David's nice rewrite to include RS and to create a more neutral POV Deletion of Sudwerk WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
11742 13737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Electoral results for the district of North West User:Unscintillating 13:55, 3 December 2011 (UTC) comment nbsp; Miracle Pen probably needs to consider that the community does not accept the incivility and corresponding disregard for the force of reason shown in this AfD, and that the corresponding insistence on creating articles that don't satisfy 's sourcing policy can lead to a one-month topic ban. Deletion of Electoral results for the district of North West WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11743 15311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arrowhead-like matrix User:Nick 00:39, 2 February 2018 (UTC) comment Without any references, this article is well beyond my paygrade to assess. Nothing found on Google scholar. Surprisingly, nothing in the aily Mail, either. Lots of other scary stuff found in :Category:Matrices. I'm not a believer in stamping on insects (or articles) because we're scared of them and don't understand them. I have no idea what this is. Why not a redirect to Arrowhead matrix if all else fails? Like=similar Deletion of Arrowhead-like matrix WP:D Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
11744 20651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natural Doctrine User:benlisquare 09:56, 9 October 2013 (UTC) keep I don't seem to understand how WP:CRYSTAL negates |notability, or how WP:CRYSTAL is relevant in the first place. This is the first game that is independently developed by Kadokawa, which in Japan is a really big name in the games industry. Not to mention, really important people are behind the project: many people in Japan know individuals like Atsushi Ikariya. Can you explain how this topic is not ''notable''? Keep in mind that |there is no deadline, and that improvement of the article content is always possible Deletion of Natural Doctrine WP:N||WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11745 6906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quek Kim Hock User:Mdtemp 17:55, 19 April 2012 (UTC) delete Unsourced BLP about a fighter that fails Deletion of Quek Kim Hock WP:MMANOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11746 10278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CASH line User:Alaney2k 21:23, 3 December 2007 (UTC) comment But we are talking about a ''current'' line. In some sense, we are trying to set a bar for notability in a specific area, even a new area. The encyclopedia has articles about current things, like the players and teams themselves. Do we go or not into having articles about current lines? There might be some value there. If it is a article about this line, separate from any hype, would that be acceptable then? The article is not , is it? (aarggh, now I am using the shortcuts! :-) As for naming, they are generally given almost immediately. Names are discarded if the name is not notable are broken up, also immediately. The CASH line name has 'stuck,' though. Another question, what is the level of recognition of a name that is required Deletion of CASH line WP:NPOV||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
11747 9813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apoorva (2008 film) [[User talk:Usernamekiran|(talk)]] 20:22, 5 January 2020 (UTC) delete the subject fails wp:gng|general notability guidelines, as well as |notability guidelines for films. —usernamekiran Deletion of Apoorva (2008 film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
11748 3116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Singapore User:Slakr 09:08, 20 December 2014 (UTC) delete """mdash; I was going to close this but I don't want my weekend marred by the inevitable DRV. Closing rationale: """"Strongest policy and guideline-based arguments given for deletion: #DIR|indiscriminate directory-style entries (NOT#DIR), |lack of notability (GNG). Strongest policy and guideline-based arguments given for retention: |verifiable () and |reliably sourced""" Deletion of List of bus routes in Singapore WP:NOT||WP:GNG||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11749 19328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Countdown (card game) User:BaronVonYiffington 19:54, 23 February 2010 (UTC) delete violates Deletion of Countdown (card game) WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
11750 17474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michelle Leonard User:Doc 00:51, 29 January 2008 (UTC) keep per |The Heymann Standard. it's been rewritten, and with the new citations, it meets now Deletion of Michelle Leonard WP:HEY||WP:N Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
11751 16308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S. Devapriya User:Blue 13:32, 7 March 2021 (UTC) delete """as failing and . Nothing in this article as currently written shows participation """"...in a major amateur or professional competition or won a significant honor..."""". The sole citation is behind a paywall and makes impossible""" Deletion of S. Devapriya WP:SPORTSPERSON||WP:SIGCOV||WP:VERIFY Wikipedia:Notability 77
11752 11945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cherkasov Denis Vladimirovich User:Piotrus 15:57, 12 April 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Cherkasov Denis Vladimirovich WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11753 17682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hobbart & Hobbart User:Epinoia 02:21, 16 May 2019 (UTC) delete """does not meet (""""If the individual organization has received no or very little notice from independent sources, then it is not notable...merely because it exists"""") - therefore, delete""" Deletion of Hobbart & Hobbart WP:ORGSIG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11754 3290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BugAware User:Joe 23:31, 13 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of BugAware WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11755 12546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Milo Evarts User:Mztourist 03:12, 26 January 2021 (UTC) merge """to USS Evarts (DE-5). Fails (Ltjg posthumously awarded a Navy Cross. Having a ship named after him during WWII is not a """"significant award or honor"""") and . No SIGCOV in multiple RS so not notable""" Deletion of Milo Evarts WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11756 18058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sebastián Díaz User:Fenix 16:43, 17 March 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Sebastián Díaz WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11757 217 [[ATEcare]] (SLA) Benutzer:Seader NONE delete """Keine Erfüllung der http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien#Wirtschaftsunternehmen Relevanzkriterien für Wirtschaftsunternehmen. Siehe auch Punkt 7.2. bei |""""Was Wikipedia nicht ist"""". In Verbindung mit dem Benutzernamen des Erstellers dieses Artikels""" Löschung von ATEcare Wikipedia:Was Wikipedia nicht ist Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11758 13170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amr sobhy User:DustFormsWords 02:21, 30 September 2009 (UTC) delete """WP:BLP recommends immediate deletion of unsourced statements in biographies of living people, which in this case would require blanking the article. Further, he fails , which requires """"verifiable objective evidence to support a claim of notability"""". That's not present here, as there are no sources. (Were there to be sources, I still don't think the matters asserted by the article are notable""" Deletion of Amr sobhy WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11759 1862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kivi Sotamaa User:RayAYang 09:59, 20 November 2010 (UTC) delete Fails and . Basically nada under Gscholar for citations, nada in the way of significant coverage Deletion of Kivi Sotamaa WP:BIO||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11760 21422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I & K Motors User:Blueboy96 15:01, 15 December 2007 (UTC) delete No notability asserted that I can see. Possible issues to boot--author's name is {{user|TheStephenator}}, and the dealership is owned by a guy named Steve Innes. I suspect there's also some sockpuppetry going on with this article as well--{{user|Innes2k7}} tried to add this company to List of Scottish companies Deletion of I & K Motors WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
11761 15989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bay of Bengal Cooperative Air Traffic Flow Management System User:RedRiver660 19:50, 26 May 2020 (UTC) delete The referencing doesn't meet Deletion of Bay of Bengal Cooperative Air Traffic Flow Management System WP:NRV Wikipedia:Notability 77
11762 2187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Butta Creamé (2nd nomination) User:JBsupreme 07:16, 7 July 2008 (UTC) delete fails to demonstrate notability under guidelines Deletion of Butta Creamé (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11763 51 [[Hessing-Klinik (Augsburg)]] (erl. gelöscht) Benutzer:Jbergner NONE keep """im text steht """"größte europäische Kur- und Heilanstalt"""". das ist ein nach gefordertes alleinstellungsmerkmal, das den artikel relevant macht. also""" Löschung von Hessing-Klinik (Augsburg) Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
11764 9507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rosemarie Falk User:Ammarpad 02:11, 26 November 2017 (UTC) delete Because of lack of significant coverage to establish notability that can meet or . The article is written prematurely as mom said, (perhaps as part of campaing sttategies). Almost all the sources are in banal format A is contesting for this, A will contest for that If eventually she wins, there will be more coverage of her of course, and will easily meet and but in the event she didn't succeed, all this media hype will recede and it will be confined to historical dustbin. Since we don't know what will happen next and Wikipedia |doesn't predict the future, the right thing to do is to delete until when substantial coverage is no longer doubtful and extend beyond banal news of A is contesting for X in Y election Deletion of Rosemarie Falk WP:GNG||WP:POLITICIAN||WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG||WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11765 5341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roshni Haripriyan User:Bapinghosh 19:56, 23 August 2021 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Roshni Haripriyan WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
11766 347 [[Georg-Simon-Ohm-Schule Köln]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Sarkana NONE keep Nun, daß ich schätze dürfte ja mittlwerweile klar sein. Daß ''Alleinstellungsmerkmal'' unglücklich sein mag, gebe ich dabei durchaus zu. Ein Umformulierung bringt aber nur eine unnötiges Aufweichung. Letzlich geht es um irgendwas, was die Schule aus den andern herraushebt. Eine Überarbeitung halte ich für nicht übermäßig sinnvoll. Über die ''freundliche'' Hypothese geh ich mal insofern hinweg, als das umnotiviertes Beschimpfen niemanden weiterbringt. Was die Zeit angeht: Ich wiederhole mich ja mal wieder, aber scheinbar ist das mit dem lesen und drüber nachdenken beim ersten Mal imme rnicut möglich, liger werden ander Diskussionsteilnehmer herrabgewürdig oder beschimpft, und Überarbeitungen für halb WP gefordert, obgleich man selber dies auch lieber bleiben läßt. Also nochmal ganz sachlich: Artikel über eine bestimmte Schule zu verbessern ist mangels Informationen im Netz für Außenstehende sehr schwer -und slbst diejenigen die am lautesen nach Verbesserungen usw. rufen haben festgestellt, dasß die Schulen an sich auch nciht sonderlich auskunftsfreudig - geschweige denn zur Zusdammenarbeit bereit sind. Es gibt Themengebiete in denen eine recht kurze Internetrecherche in der Tat reich würde, um einen WP-Artikel halbwegs anständig zu verbessern - Schulen gehören eher nicht dazu. So, was nun diese Schule angeht: 1. Es ist jetzt klar, was die Schule aus den anderen herraushebt - es gibt also so etwas wie ein Alleinstellungsmerkmal, welches (ganz wichtig) auch aus dem Artiklel hervorgeht. 2. Der historische Abriss als solcher wäre bereits WP-würdig - könnte aber IMO duchaus noch etwas Erweiterung vertragen. Auf jeden Fall entspricht der Artikel jetzt auch den geforderten Kriterien von 3. Das Ganze ist jetzt wirklich ein anständig geschriebener und lesenswerter Artikel. Fazit: JETZT Löschung von Georg-Simon-Ohm-Schule Köln Wikipedia:Artikel über Schulen Wikipedia:Artikel über Schulen 4
11767 1255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jay Spearing (2nd nomination) User:Otolemur 16:51, 17 February 2008 (UTC) delete per nom, fails Deletion of Jay Spearing (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11768 17863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fancy Gadam User:Colapeninsula 11:13, 12 May 2017 (UTC) keep Meets notability requirements. He's widely covered in West African media (see links on the article, and e.g. http://pulse.com.gh/music/vgma-2017-fancy-gadam-and-i-have-a-song-together-sarkodie-id6503201.htmlhttp://www.graphic.com.gh/entertainment/music/fancy-gadam-fancies-his-vgma-chance.htmlhttp://www.ghanaguardian.com/fancy-gadam-grabs-sarkodie-medikal/). Has won at Ghana Music Awards which may meet #8 depending on your interpretation. Nomination is feeble (see ): it doesn't properly set out grounds for deletion or any evidence of or any reason for dismissing the existing references on the article Deletion of Fancy Gadam WP:BAND||WP:AADD||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11769 5795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SONIC CRUISE User:Toon05 22:48, 29 December 2008 (UTC) delete no notability outside of the album, redirect all to album page, per Deletion of SONIC CRUISE WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11770 752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stratogent NONE NONE delete #G11|unambiguous advertising, deliberately uninformative #G1|patent nonsense, and typical |IT related spam Deletion of Stratogent WP:CSD||WP:B2B Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11771 526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bloof User:PMDrive1061 23:39, 6 February 2009 (UTC) delete under - might not be vandalism, but it's certainly nonsense Deletion of Bloof WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
11772 11440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shamrock Shake User:MacGyverMagic 11:00, 31 March 2009 (UTC) merge If it was merged once, it needs to be redirected for attribution purposes per (a merge is always followed up with a redirect). Claims that something or someone is notable without any evidence to back it up can be ignored (when sources are questionable, they should be discussed Deletion of Shamrock Shake WP:MERGE Wikipedia:Merging 54
11773 12392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keyboard Maestro User:Northamerica1000 01:17, 14 June 2017 (UTC) keep Passes WP:GNG. Source examples from my searches: http://www.macworld.com/article/2686838/keyboard-maestro-8-unexpected-uses-for-the-old-school-mac-hacking-tool.html, http://www.macworld.com/article/2040496/mac-gems-keyboard-maestro-6-is-a-genius-at-repetitive-tasks.html, http://www.macworld.com/article/1150914/keyboardmaestro42.html, http://tidbits.com/article/15826, http://tidbits.com/article/13784, https://tidbits.com/article/12321, https://www.macobserver.com/columns-opinions/dr-macs-rants-raves/become-maestro-mac-macros Deletion of Keyboard Maestro WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
11774 8739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Ricky Ponting's achievements and statistics User:Wjemather 22:07, 24 September 2020 (UTC) delete per ; article consisting mostly of indiscriminate trivia, anything significant should already be included in the main article Deletion of List of Ricky Ponting's achievements and statistics WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11775 9874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jan Van Loon User:CAPTAIN 19:24, 8 March 2017 (UTC) delete He does not seem to meet the notability criteria for Deletion of Jan Van Loon WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11776 13341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trans Artists Foundation (2nd nomination) User:Citobun 10:11, 17 November 2015 (UTC) delete still doesn't meet notability criteria after eight years with an article on Wikipedia. Still has very few Google results with no indepth coverage in secondary sources. Run-of-the-mill Deletion of Trans Artists Foundation (2nd nomination) WP:ARTSPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
11777 1178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yuka Ishikawa User:Kraxler 16:17, 30 August 2015 (UTC) delete fails and no coverage to pass GNG Deletion of Yuka Ishikawa WP:NSKATE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11778 7422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/E Squared (novel) User:Ravenswing 10:49, 7 September 2009 (UTC) delete """Unfortunately, the Keep arguments are all based on fallacies. Let's review the notability criteria for books. """"The book has been the subject of multiple, non-trivial published works whose sources are independent of the book itself."""" No. It hasn't been. """"The book has won a major literary award."""" No. It hasn't. """"The book has been considered by reliable sources to have made a significant contribution to a notable motion picture, or other art form, or event or political or religious movement."""" What reliable sources would those be, please? """"The book is the subject of instruction at multiple grade schools, high schools, universities or post-graduate programs in any particular country."""" Nope. """"The book's author is so historically significant that any of his or her written works may be considered notable. This does not simply mean that the book's author is him/herself notable by Wikipedia's standards; rather, the book's author is of exceptional significance and the author's life and body of work would be a common study subject in literature classes."""" Once again, fails. There is nothing in this criteria giving a free pass for sequels. There is nothing in this criteria guaranteeing notability for every book Bantam publishes. There is nothing in this criteria guaranteeing notability for epistolary novels written in e-mail. And ... beyond that, """"Sources will become avalible sic in time"""" is a garbage Keep rationale; ''requires'' that |reliable sources exist, not at some indefinite point in the future, but as the fundamental requirement to sustain an article. To quote from , """"If no reliable, third-party sources can be found for an article topic, Wikipedia should not have an article on it""" Deletion of E Squared (novel) WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11779 7197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Project Manager (software) User:Ihcoyc 15:09, 6 April 2010 (UTC) delete per nomination. Non-notable software or website, does not meet |the product or |the website notability guidelines. Claim for notability seems to revolve around the notion that something else used to be at their website, not the current content. That's an original twist Deletion of Project Manager (software) WP:CORP||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11780 2882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/P.K. Firos User:onel5969 01:28, 16 April 2021 (UTC) delete what a mess. {{u|Bearcat}}'s assessment is spot on. Kudos also to {{u|DoubleGrazing}} to making me smile. And more kudos to {{u|Beccaynr}} for their source assessment. Fails and Deletion of P.K. Firos WP:GNG||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11781 2440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Kelly (ecologist) User:Dpbsmith 01:32, 9 February 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and per |verifiability policy mentioned under every edit box. Can be re-created at any time '''if''' proper source citations, as described in and are provided that correspond to the key facts mentioned in the article Deletion of Paul Kelly (ecologist) WP:V||WP:V||WP:CITE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11782 18055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Audience Figure User:Satori 20:56, 15 July 2008 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Audience Figure WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11783 19669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Catahoula bulldog User:AReaderOutThataway 00:05, 15 August 2019 (UTC) merge """to what is presently Louisiana Catahoula Leopard dog; they're just multiple names for the same breed (or cross-breeds involving it). Move the merged result to Catahoula Cur, the name used by the registry (a reliable source), and also per . While there's lots of Internet chatter about """"Catahoula bulldog"""", e-commentary in forums and blog posts by nobodies are not reliable sources; nor are websites of dog breeders and breed/cross-breed promotion groups (they have a monetary interest, ergo they fail .) There's nothing reliable here that establishes that a """"Catahoula Bulldog"""" has somehow breed-forked from the rest of the Catahoula dogs and is accepted by the public as a breed in its own right; that's just and and . WikiProject Dogs, after its re-start a while back, has been successfully merging various articles, and this should continue. If two organizations (kennel clubs, breeder groups, etc.) have two different names for essentially the same dogs, that's a single breed, covered by a single article, with its multiple names listed. Crosses get mentioned in summary form at the articles on the parent breeds. Sub-breeds are covered at the main breed article. Same goes for cat breeds, horse breeds, etc. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of Catahoula bulldog WP:CONCISE||WP:INDY||WP:POV||WP:COI||WP:SOAPBOX||WP:CONTENTFORK Wikipedia:Article titles 75
11784 19760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/R. Yesurathnam User:Radagast3 08:44, 9 March 2010 (UTC) delete Notability probably hangs on his principalship, rather than publications (which don't seem to be widely cited: http://books.google.com.au/books?q=%22Regunta+Yesurathnam%22+OR+%22R.+Yesurathnam%22 GB, http://scholar.google.com.au/scholar?q=%22Regunta%20Yesurathnam%22%20OR%20%22R.%20Yesurathnam%22 GS) or third-party references (which are not to be found in the article). Andhra Christian Theological College is a theological college with 24 staff (by my count). Is that significant? Now that I look at, it seems a little vague. However, I assume that the link to Senate of Serampore College (University) constitutes accreditation: at least the http://www.wcc-coe.org/wcc/what/education/mf101.pdf World Council of Churches thinks so. Yesurathnam might also be notable under for his involvement in Hindu-Christian dialogue, although third-party references would need to be dug up on that Deletion of R. Yesurathnam WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11785 11297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gasturb User:Ihcoyc 16:07, 11 December 2009 (UTC) delete This is ''a gas turbine performance simulation program'' without any indication of either |general interest sources or recognition of historical or technical importance Deletion of Gasturb WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11786 6116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irfan Adelbi User:Knightrises10 09:18, 26 August 2018 (UTC) keep Competed in Olympics which is a thing of notability, and thus passes Deletion of Irfan Adelbi WP:NOLYMPICS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11787 2844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rodney Ascher User:Coredesat 20:26, 23 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Rodney Ascher WP:BIO||WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11788 16575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LetsGoBlues.com User:Cini 16:55, 25 April 2006 (UTC) delete Barely notable and difficult to verify. Fails to satisfy the necessary criteria in Deletion of LetsGoBlues.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11789 17402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emotional tone scale User:The 11:02, 20 January 2019 (UTC) delete """per nomination. The text is unsupported by |acceptable sources and reads like the |personal effort of people interested in |promoting the subject and |advocating for Scientology. (See, for instance, the recommendations for further reading.) Texts that are not |duly supported by citations that establish their subjects' |encyclopaedic value are neither """"merged"""" nor """"used"""" elsewhere in Wikipedia; they're deleted""" Deletion of Emotional tone scale WP:RS||WP:OR||WP:PROMO||WP:ADVOCACY||WP:V||WP:5P1 Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11790 14795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin O'Halloran User:Rms125a 21:58, 1 October 2014 (UTC) delete notability not acquired solely through |victimology, as is well-established Deletion of Martin O'Halloran WP:VICTIM Wikipedia:Notability 77
11791 10711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Navin Khambhala User:Bearian 22:55, 18 March 2017 (UTC) delete per nom. |This is one of thousands of YouTubers Deletion of Navin Khambhala WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
11792 74 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Donanimhaber Kullanıcı:sonsavascisonsavasci 06:06, 13 Temmuz 2007 (UTC) delete Bu hali ile ansiklopedi maddesinden |çok site tanıtım sayfasını andırıyor. --User:renegade|'''renegade'''User_Talk:renegade|''msj Donanimhaber'in silinmesi Vikipedi:VND Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11793 13453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hawaiʻi Football League User:Secret 22:05, 4 January 2011 (UTC) delete Google news comes up with nothing, no independent third party sources, fails Deletion of Hawaiʻi Football League WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11794 9706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HomeFix Corporation User:AllyD 07:45, 31 January 2015 (UTC) delete A company going about its business, but accreditations and placings in top-25 or top-3% of non-notable rankings do not substantiate encyclopaedic notability; searches are turning up a couple of mentions of telemarketing judgments but I am seeing no coverage that meets Deletion of HomeFix Corporation :WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
11795 17658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sal's Realm of RuneScape User:Stifle 00:40, 1 April 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Sal's Realm of RuneScape WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11796 18745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Torrent finder User:Schutz 12:26, 5 July 2006 (UTC) delete Non-notable website, Deletion of Torrent finder WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11797 5572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sister Jean Dolores-Schmidt User:L293D 02:30, 27 March 2018 (UTC) keep enough s to assure notability Deletion of Sister Jean Dolores-Schmidt WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11798 18710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of management consulting firms User:VernoWhitney 21:20, 7 May 2010 (UTC) keep per : overlapping with categories is allowed. I see no reason that this doesn't function as a coherent list article since it has been trimmed to blue links and well-sourced Deletion of List of management consulting firms WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
11799 6697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artistic program of the Olympic opening ceremonies User:Mangoe 15:36, 27 February 2018 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Artistic program of the Olympic opening ceremonies WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11800 8407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Childs User:Corpx 06:25, 25 August 2007 (UTC) delete per #NEWS because I do not think we should have articles for everyone who commits a horrendous murder Deletion of John Childs WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11801 448 [[E³-Lichttechnologie]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Weissbier 13:16, 2. Sep. 2009 (CEST) delete E3 ist ein Produkt von Herrn Wammes und wird auf der als Quelle genannten Webseite (ebenfalls von Herrn Wammes) massiv beworben. Genau so wie halt hier auch. Hier liegt werbliche (keine Sekundärquellen) zu einem nicht erkennbar relevanten Konsumgut vor Löschung von E³-Lichttechnologie Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
11802 16576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Dungeons & Dragons pop culture references User:Dpbsmith 18:24, 17 May 2006 (UTC) delete as not meeting |the verifiability policy. The number of entries for which published sources meeting can be found is probably much smaller than this list and these entries can go into the article. There's no reason to have a completely unselective list of pop culture references to D&D; only the important ones need to be in the main article, and you'll never convince me that all of these entries are important. The verifiability policy is probably sufficient to trim them down in an objective way Deletion of List of Dungeons & Dragons pop culture references WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11803 2797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clarence Smith (actor) User:Artene50 09:41, 30 July 2008 (UTC) delete as a likely The article's creator removed the content but I restored it for people to view Deletion of Clarence Smith (actor) WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
11804 14778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MobileIron User:Unforgettableid 23:09, 8 August 2013 (UTC) delete Please. As Xxanthippe said, the article is just an ad. If you refuse to delete it, and if someone commits to fix it, then please '''incubate''' Wikipedia:Article Incubator|here instead. I've read through this entire discussion. I'm still not convinced that MobileIron meets . Plus, the article fails even though it's already three years old; it doesn't deserve to stay on Wikipedia at all, let alone in mainspace. Dear all: Can anyone please point us to two independent non-churnalistic reliably-sourced articles about MobileIron, preferably balanced articles which discuss the relative merits of both MobileIron and its competitors? Cheers, &mdash Deletion of MobileIron WP:GNG||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
11805 11132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ToTs (rapper) User:Duffbeerforme 08:50, 20 January 2011 (UTC) delete Lacks coverage in independent reliable sources. None of the references with one exception provide significant coverage about ToTs. The one exception is the blog article by Mattise but this is a guest reader on a blog so is not a |reliable source. Nothing in the external links is significant coverage in independent reliable sources Deletion of ToTs (rapper) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11806 5485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JJS Karate Dojo User:Eusebeus 23:47, 18 November 2008 (UTC) delete clearly fails Deletion of JJS Karate Dojo WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11807 4887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/US-Bangla Group User:Worldbruce 19:45, 5 December 2017 (UTC) merge to US-Bangla Airlines. In theory the airline is the tail, and the group is the dog, but in practice the group (and its other companies) receives no significant, independent coverage in reliable sources, only passing mentions in articles about the airline. The group does not satisfy Deletion of US-Bangla Group WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11808 15 [[Blau Mobilfunk]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Hannibal21 NONE delete Die Form des Antrags ist eine Sache, aber der Artikel ist nahezu ein wörtlicher Wiedergänger. Blau mag relevant sein, hab letztens sogar eine Radiowerbung von denen gehört, aber Artikel ist ein Werbeflyer und KEIN enzyklopedischer Eintrag und wie Schnatzel festgestellt hat Löschung von Blau Mobilfunk Wikipedia:URV Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
11809 17009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Turkish Brazilians User:Nosebagbear 13:12, 10 January 2019 (UTC) merge to Turkish Diaspora) - nom's arguments are correct, but since Brazil isn't currently in the Diaspora article, and should be, it needs to be a merge. While in this particular case GNG might also apply, the key argument for all of these is . However, we can't decide mid-AfD which other articles should go. There is a place for separate articles to cover large country groupings. As to whether that should be some ad hoc decision or should be written up I've no idea (numbers vs % of population vs coverage would be a hell of a squabble Deletion of Turkish Brazilians WP:REDUNDANTFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
11810 672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hindi Blogging ka Itihas User:Pharaoh 13:29, 19 August 2014 (UTC) delete As per Dharmadhyaksha and fails Deletion of Hindi Blogging ka Itihas WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
11811 19938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy Smith (programmer) User:EC 02:41, 19 September 2017 (UTC) delete lacks needs to Deletion of Andy Smith (programmer) WP:BIO||WP:CS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11812 10000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Subtropical Cyclone Lexi User:Nova 03:40, 3 October 2018 (UTC) delete I proposed the redirect/merge for failing , and since that has failed... Deletion of Subtropical Cyclone Lexi WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11813 20114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexio Kawara User:Pharaoh 20:08, 7 October 2020 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Alexio Kawara WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11814 8807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Damon Bryant User:Mr 03:33, 17 June 2012 (UTC) delete The only sources I could find were passing mentions that he was a producer of the films mentioned in the article, and a couple of quotes of his about Noel Clarke.http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/movies/news/a178024/noel-clarke-making-thriller-4321.htmlhttp://www.yaez.de/Kino/171-Es-muss-Interaktion-geben.html Doesn't pass or Deletion of Damon Bryant WP:BASIC||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11815 977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Project Heart and Soul User:Finealt 13:55, 10 December 2013 (UTC) delete As per above. The title isn't even official yet. Appears to be a case of Deletion of Project Heart and Soul WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11816 21212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sportpursuit User:Ken 17:40, 22 July 2021 (UTC) delete Per David Gerard. |REFBOMBed and the overall structure of the article as of now is very poor Deletion of Sportpursuit WP:REFBOMB Wikipedia:Citation overkill 60
11817 289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Casino Tropez User:2005 09:40, 5 February 2007 (UTC) merge """While the above is not accurate (the article establishes notoriety via the eGaming Review reference), and its pure nonsense to say the search brings up nothing but """"gambling spam"""", since the company is privately held and does not have the more significant notoriety of, for example, Golden Palace, it doesn't meet or with any certainty. It isn't that far away though, so I would redirect it to Playtech until such time as the company plainly meets or """ Deletion of Casino Tropez WP:CORP||WP:WEB||WP:CORP||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11818 5122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Youth Arts Collective User:Brewcrewer 06:31, 23 February 2008 (UTC) delete per nom, (barely not a speedy Deletion of Youth Arts Collective WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11819 1089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beer-In-Hand (2nd nomination) User:MartinDK 16:59, 22 November 2006 (UTC) delete per the above arguments and Wikipedia is not for things |made up on St. Patricks Day. One question: Isn't there a no drinking rule when voting given that this passed a previous AfD he he Deletion of Beer-In-Hand (2nd nomination) WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
11820 10907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of exclamations by Robin NONE NONE comment PostPdf - You may want to strike the trolling bit, since it's not true, and a violation of WP:CIVIL. Comment on the content, not the contributor Anyhow, I '''do''' realize list '''can''' be kept per | Not Dir within articles if certain conditions are met. It's not met here, in fact, this isn't an article, but rather a definition of WP:NOT DIR #1 Deletion of List of exclamations by Robin WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11821 21109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Imagination (film) [[User talk:Erik|talk]] | [[Special:Contributions/Erik|contribs]]) 23:20, 2 September 2010 (UTC) keep """per reasonable though not overwhelming coverage. is intended as a specialized version of , but that does not mean is inapplicable. What you quoted are """"attributes that generally indicate, when supported with reliable sources, that the required sources are likely to exist"""", because some films, especially older ones, may not reflect their notability so readily in search engine results. I find the presence of reviews at ''Variety'' and ''Journal International'' to be a good indicator; we just may not be able to find additional references with an easy Google search. Actually, that might not be true... I found http://www.ioncinema.com/news/id/1395 this just now with a little searching. It may be that this article will not be large in size, but I think there is sufficient material to sustain a minimal article. Erik""" Deletion of Imagination (film) WP:NF||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11822 7235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jan Mencwel User:Lubbad85 01:10, 27 March 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Jan Mencwel WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11823 15517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canadian Ethnic Cleansing Team (2nd nomination) User:Tarc 02:00, 16 October 2013 (UTC) comment """Not sure on this one yet. AfD #1 contains some of the typically sparse """"keep its notable"""" votes typical of the Wiki-Prehistoric Era of 2007, but the nominator claim OF """"The removal of the law cancels any claim of notability"""" is deflected by |notability is not temporary. If it was indeed notable once, and it prompted legislation (since repealed) to be passed, there may be a case to be made for an article on that event and not the website itself""" Deletion of Canadian Ethnic Cleansing Team (2nd nomination) WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11824 4197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jude Rawlins User:Dhartung 09:02, 23 December 2006 (UTC) delete The nomination makes a nonstandard argument against notability. But the article lacks reliable sources -- this and Subterraneans (band) are both largely sourced from a self-published autobiography by Rawlins. There is an intriguing magazine profile, but by itself this apepars to fail Deletion of Jude Rawlins WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11825 12110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flower Drum User:Atlantic306 00:25, 5 July 2016 (UTC) keep in view of the multiple reliable sources identified above that mean is passed Deletion of Flower Drum WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11826 16134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CPD -572874 User:David 16:39, 6 August 2013 (UTC) keep per (and #3 Deletion of CPD -572874 WP:HEY||WP:NASTRO Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
11827 21281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aliens Gone Wild User:Galobtter 09:11, 8 November 2017 (UTC) delete """hahaahaha that """"immortal classic"""" quote is amazing. Anyway being broadcast by a major network is not a notability criteria. Others are only passing mentions and it does not pass any of the other criteria at """ Deletion of Aliens Gone Wild WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
11828 11683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Candyland (musician) (2nd nomination) User:Magnolia677 00:20, 14 November 2016 (UTC) delete """Fails , , and . Despite having one song """"chart"""" at #47, there are few reliable secondary sources to support notability""" Deletion of Candyland (musician) (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11829 17476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Manson in popular culture User:Arkyan 15:35, 13 July 2007 (UTC) delete It's just a list of loosely associated topics (per ) and is not an article treating the subject of Charles Manson in pop culture Deletion of Charles Manson in popular culture WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11830 2345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Don't Stop Rappin' User:Azealia911 01:40, 27 July 2015 (UTC) merge to Too Short, fails and Deletion of Don't Stop Rappin' WP:GNG||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11831 11780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Bessler User:Xxanthippe 00:23, 20 January 2013 (UTC) keep Recognition of his work in GS contributes to rof#C1 Deletion of John Bessler WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
11832 10649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MyBusTickets User:Redrose64 08:17, 18 October 2013 (UTC) delete per #G11 - I'm almost in a mind to place the {{tlx|db-promo}} myself Deletion of MyBusTickets WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11833 17856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dj Ernesty User:Piotrus 02:00, 15 April 2020 (UTC) delete The sources cited are poor. Interview, and few paragraphs in newspapers that are not known for international reliability, and that coverage reads like rewrites of press releases. On the other hand, there is . Should we accept low quality sources since for that part of the world they may actually be good quality? Overall, I think the answer is not, our criteria have to hold things to the same standard, whether it's UK or Nigheria. I don't see how the subject meets NMUSIC, and as for NBIO, I think the coverage is on the wrong end of borderline Deletion of Dj Ernesty WP:SYSTEMICBIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
11834 16190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/City Spice User:HighKing 16:47, 5 September 2019 (UTC) delete """Wikipedia isn't a Yellow pages nor a platform for promotion. Also """"significant coverage in reliable sources"""" is only half of the criteria - the coverage must also contain """"Independent Content"""" (as defined in ) and the coverage must be about the company. As the nom pointed out, the """"awards"""" are not significant for the purposes of notability. The Independent review of the food contains independent content (independent opinion) but does not meet the definition of in-depth coverage (of the company). The rest of the references all rely entirely on quotations/interviews with people affiliated with the restaurant. Topic fails GNG and """ Deletion of City Spice WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11835 1066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kansas City Royals minor league players User:Muboshgu 15:03, 5 November 2014 (UTC) keep Alex is being y and I've already ed him. We have a long standing consensus on how to do this that he doesn't seem to comprehend, and now he's wasting our time and resources on this farce. – Deletion of Kansas City Royals minor league players WP:POINT||WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
11836 15739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karakoram Motors User:HighKing 12:47, 21 August 2019 (UTC) delete I've searched for any references that meet the criteria for establishing notability under the current name and the older name and all I can find are mentions-in-passing or directory listings. Topic fails GNG and Deletion of Karakoram Motors WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11837 114 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Atlılar (dizi) """Kullanıcı:guzelonlu'''güzelonlu'''""" 12:25, 5 Aralık 2012 (UTC) delete Şu durumda kriterlerini karşılamıyor Atlılar (dizi) silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
11838 8356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mitchel P. Goldman User:Esquivalience 01:28, 21 March 2015 (UTC) keep and fix: The subject's publications have been cited 9,375 times, with an h-index of 55 (i.e. 55 of the subject's publications have been cited over 55 times): which clearly shows that the subject has made a significant impact in his field, thus it meets #1. I don't see any very major issues in the article (not much promotional content): no need to delete and start over again (see § c1). The article has since (after the block of {{u|Morning277}} for long-term abuse and sockpuppetry) been substantially edited by non-affiliated editors to remove the promotional content Deletion of Mitchel P. Goldman WP:NACADEMICS||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11839 18 [[Wolfgang Priklopil]] (erl, redirect) Benutzer:Chaddy/Bewertung NONE keep Ich zitiere mal aus : Unter anderem sind solche Personen relevant, ''die wegen ihrer Beteiligung an nachrichtenwürdigen Ereignissen bekannt werden Löschung von Wolfgang Priklopil Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
11840 11483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shit on your neighbor User:Coccyx 15:43, 15 July 2008 (UTC) delete per , which this card game apparently is Deletion of Shit on your neighbor WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
11841 9770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OMG! Ubuntu! User:Czar 16:34, 23 April 2013 (UTC) delete """So no one is doubting that the site isn't very good at what it does, if not the best, but it doesn't pass : {{tq|""""The content itself has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself.""""}} I've checked all of the sources, and the closest to a contender is ubuntu-user.com. The sources from Iketsi are either SPS interviews (don't help with notability) or casual mentions from other sites (which may prove a reliance, but OMG is never a subject of a non-trivial work). It looks like http://people.canonical.com/~dholbach/11.10-dev-docs-survey.pdf it's worth mentioning its influence in some Ubuntu culture article, but it doesn't pass the criteria for its own article""" Deletion of OMG! Ubuntu! WP:NWEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11842 8671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blackout (David Bowie song) User:Coolmarc 09:54, 23 May 2020 (UTC) merge per Deletion of Blackout (David Bowie song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11843 5106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bert M. Petersen User:Ukexpat 15:31, 10 September 2010 (UTC) delete per nom and OrangeMike; fails Deletion of Bert M. Petersen WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11844 18643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ephraim Shapiro (2nd nomination) User:Xyz7890 05:53, 9 December 2010 (UTC) keep Being notable means having reliable sources that exist on the subject. There is no guideline states that the sources have to have been around during the person's lifetime. By the nom's logic, Emily Dickinson and Vincent van Gogh would not be worthy of Wikipedia articles. http://www.toptenz.net/top-10-people-who-became-famous-after-death.php Here is a list of people who got famous after their deaths (these example included). Ephraim Shapiro may not have become famous for all the desirable reasons of the people in this list. But the coverage is there. And Mr. Shapiro's case has had the |effect of other allegations being investigated Deletion of Ephraim Shapiro (2nd nomination) WP:LASTING Wikipedia:Notability 77
11845 21347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Internet of Garbage User:Nosebagbear 17:27, 6 August 2018 (UTC) keep Given an apparent bad faith nomination, coupled with the fact that is satisfied - some of the coverage is more like large mentions, but there is certainly sufficient reviews etc to cover it well enough for our purposes, I would advise a speedy close as there is no non-keep statement at this point Deletion of The Internet of Garbage WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
11846 4594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011 failed Gothenburg terrorist attack User:P199 13:46, 19 September 2011 (UTC) delete per : no indication this will have any lasting coverage or effect Deletion of 2011 failed Gothenburg terrorist attack WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11847 9676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uroš Poljanec User:GiantSnowman 11:05, 4 November 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Uroš Poljanec WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11848 19806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indianapolis Heights, Indiana User:Nyttend 01:26, 15 February 2014 (UTC) delete An appropriate article can be written on this subject, but Indyguy makes a good point: we can't trust anything currently in this page. deletion and let's start over Deletion of Indianapolis Heights, Indiana WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
11849 3974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. K. Loganathan User:Mr 13:44, 5 November 2014 (UTC) delete unless evidence of notability can be found. Every source currently in the article either doesn't seem to mention Loganathan or is written by him. So there is no evidence of otability|significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, nor is there evidence that he meets any of the criteria at Deletion of Dr. K. Loganathan WP:N||WP:SCHOLAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
11850 3098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Strongsville City Teachers' Strike of 2013 User:AutomaticStrikeout 02:18, 15 March 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Strongsville City Teachers' Strike of 2013 WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11851 18285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rocco Perrotta User:GiantSnowman 17:44, 28 April 2014 (UTC) delete fails (no significant coverage) and (has not played or managed in a |fully-professional league. Being a fitness coach in one is not sufficient Deletion of Rocco Perrotta WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11852 20682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacob Morris User:Bearcat 13:37, 29 October 2016 (UTC) delete """People do not get Wikipedia articles just for being as yet unelected candidates in future elections (or failed candidates in past ones, either). If you cannot demonstrate and |reliably source credible evidence that he was ''already'' eligible for a Wikipedia article for some other reason ''independent'' of his candidacy, then he has to ''win'' the election, not just run in it, before the election itself can |""""meet the politician requirements"""". But there's no other claim of notability even being made here ''at all'', let alone one strong enough to actually pass a Wikipedia inclusion bar""" Deletion of Jacob Morris WP:RS||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11853 334 [[Aletta Mondré]] (LAE) Benutzer:Stephan Tournay 21:42, 6. Sep. 2020 (CEST) keep Die Person Aletta Mondré ist nach #Wissenschaftler|WP-RK für Wissenschaftler automatisch relevant, wenn sie eine Professur an einer anerkannten Hochschule innehält und es sich dabei nicht um eine Juniorprofessur handelt. Mal abgesehen von ihrer Monografie, den zahlreichen Schriften und ihre bisherigen Leistungen, Auszeichnungen etc. und einem gewissen berechtigten öffentlichen Interesse, stimme ich für und '''LAE''', was ich auch gerne mache. Schönen Abend {{s Löschung von Aletta Mondré Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
11854 1707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angelus Church User:GRBerry 01:09, 11 September 2006 (UTC) delete """as |unverifiable. Excluding """"Wikipedia"""" from my google searches, I got no results. The article has no references to support any statement in it. Smells so strongly of hoax that I've marked it as such""" Deletion of Angelus Church WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11855 3976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ClearView User:Kinu 01:21, 31 March 2006 (UTC) delete per . Optionally recreate as redirect to Clearview if the Wiki software won't automatically recognize it as such Deletion of ClearView WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11856 4782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Sentinel (Staffordshire) User:Sam 13:07, 9 January 2018 (UTC) keep Sourcing an article about a newspaper dating from 1854 is seldom a problem, and we are here well passed GNG based on a review of available sources. The other problems mentioned in the nomination are basically all . On a side note: Apart from 1 !vote, all other delete/merge opinions have been made by accounts created ''after'' this discussion was opened. Also, this is not the third discussion, the article has never been up at AFD before and should be moved from its current location at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Sentinel (Staffordshire) (3rd nomination) to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Sentinel (Staffordshire Deletion of The Sentinel (Staffordshire) WP:SURMOUNTABLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11857 16201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Umrah Passport User:Edison 19:22, 13 June 2017 (UTC) delete """This is clearly a """"How-to manual"""" and as such does not belong in Wikipedia. says """"Instruction manuals. While Wikipedia has descriptions of people, places and things, an article should not read like a """"how-to"""" style owner's manual, cookbook, advice column (legal, medical or otherwise) or suggestion box. This includes tutorials, instruction manuals, game guides, and recipes. Describing to the reader how people or things use or do something is encyclopedic; instructing the reader in the imperative mood about how to use or do something is not.4"""" That said, these special passports might well be notable enough for an article, but this is not that article""" Deletion of Umrah Passport WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11858 20308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ACS Chemical Neuroscience User:Antorjal 03:22, 8 November 2009 (UTC) comment """I removed the prod and I apologize if it was a mistake. I will not comment on the AfD since I contributed to expanding the article (though I did not create it). Thanks also for pointing out the guidelines in otability (academic journals). I was unaware since from the history it seems to be relatively new. I have two questions relavent to this AfD. Are SCI and Scopus (which are the only scientific databases mentioned in the guideleines) the only acceptable ones per guidelines? Are CAPlus and SciFinder, databases of Chemical Abstracts Service not appropriate or inadequate? I ask (as an aside) because as a chemist by training, there are a number of journals that I refer to that are not indexed in Scopus and this makes me feel a bit inferior. There is also a practical matter; List_of_scientific_journals_in_chemistry starts with a ranking based on Chem Abstracts which I will delete from the article if Chem Abstracts is an irrelevant database for scientific journals. I guess other journals might qualify for inclusion in Wikipedia if they are cited by """"reliable sources"""" and have a """"significant"""" history (which the journal in this AfD CLEARLY does not have). I was planning to work on other articles on journals, however, I request a bit more more clarity on what is a """"reliable source"""" and a """"significant history."""" Thanks so much""" Deletion of ACS Chemical Neuroscience WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11859 17161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silvia H. Allred (2nd nomination) User:Rollidan 19:02, 6 August 2019 (UTC) delete As a member of the church pertaining to this article, I understand the push for more coverage. However, as significant coverage does not exist in independent, reliable sources, the individual fails Deletion of Silvia H. Allred (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11860 19784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanjeevan Gurung User:AKS 13:28, 15 July 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Sanjeevan Gurung WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11861 4116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bagra (caste) User:Spiderone 16:40, 24 July 2017 (UTC) delete no evidence of Deletion of Bagra (caste) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11862 447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jozef Kohut User:The 12:32, 16 May 2019 (UTC) delete since subject fails Deletion of Jozef Kohut WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
11863 2545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Century Record Manufacturing Company User:Walter 21:35, 3 May 2017 (UTC) keep The source, while not all online, seem to help the subject meet at least if not . Thanks to Eurodog for finding them and improving the article Deletion of Century Record Manufacturing Company :WP:COMPANY||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11864 19759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fazrul Amir User:Dr 19:04, 25 March 2021 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Fazrul Amir WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
11865 14727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Latarsha Rose User:MichaelQSchmidt 23:28, 7 June 2012 (UTC) keep Subject is covered in enough sourceshttps://www.google.com/search?q=%22Latarsha+Rose%22&tbm=nws&tbs=ar:1#q=%22Latarsha+Rose%22&hl=en&tbs=ar:1&tbm=nws&psj=1&ei=0RvRT_iOLqbM2AX1w-CLDw&start=10&sa=N&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.r_qf.,cf.osb&fp=119d693c4ec9a097&biw=855&bih=495 so that this is not a failed BLP, and an encyclopedic article can be maintained for our readers. As with any actor, we do not judge notability by the least of their roles, but by the best... and we can then factor in length of career, and yes... even those minor roles. She first received media attention in 2002 for her appearances in the Bravo TV series ''The It Factor'',https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Latarsha+Rose%22&tbm=nws&tbs=ar:1#hl=en&tbs=ar:1&tbm=nws&sclient=psy-ab&q=%22Latarsha+Rose%22%2C+It+Factor&oq=%22Latarsha+Rose%22%2C+It+Factor&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&gs_l=serp.3...7135969.7138422.1.7138672.11.11.0.0.0.0.344.2314.0j6j4j1.11.0...0.0.aIBbKsAtJE8&psj=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.r_qf.,cf.osb&fp=d3a82f0016748be5&biw=855&bih=495 and while since then not starring in as many ''major'' productions as many Hollywood notables, nor getting massive amounts of coverage, she has done enough per and has ''just'' enough coverage per so that she as a topic is worthy of being retained and expanded and improved over time and through regular editing. Wikipedia does not restrict its coverage to ''only'' Academy Award winners... and even if seen by some as only ''minor'', |notability is still notability Deletion of Latarsha Rose WP:ENT||WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11866 15432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dean Dass User:Dee03 12:58, 6 August 2019 (UTC) delete or '''redirect''' per Blue Square Thing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Village_pump_(policy)/Archive_135#The_criteria_of_WP:NSPORT_here_are_too_inclusive This RfC has already confirmed that {{xt|no subject-specific notability guideline, including |Notability (sports) is a replacement for or supercedes the |General Notability Guideline. Arguments must be more refined than simply citing compliance with a subguideline of in the context of an Articles for Deletion discussion Deletion of Dean Dass WP:NSPORTS||WP:GNG||WP:NSPORTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11867 11657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Mulherin User:Papaursa 03:28, 11 September 2019 (UTC) delete Doesn't appear to have the coverage required to meet . He also fails to meet any of the criteria of Deletion of Bruce Mulherin WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
11868 16791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lalitham Sundaram User:Kailash29792 12:13, 24 August 2021 (UTC) keep Satisfies ; it has completed shooting Deletion of Lalitham Sundaram WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11869 6225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Sproule User:Valenciano 12:06, 11 August 2011 (UTC) keep """Canadian Ambassador would seem to meet the """"international office"""" criteria in section one of """ Deletion of David Sproule WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11870 1075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Family Plastics User:HighKing 18:57, 26 April 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and GNG. Pure corporate advert, not one notable feature Deletion of Family Plastics WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11871 11779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Sheffield Private School User:RoySmith 16:31, 13 October 2017 (UTC) delete No evidence this meets . I found lots of first-party sources, blogs, social media, forums, directory listings, and the like. Nothing, however, which could be considered a . https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=&oldid=767023947#RfC_on_secondary_school_notability RfC on secondary school notability makes it clear that ''Secondary schools are not presumed to be notable simply because they exist Deletion of The Sheffield Private School WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11872 8541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nichole Mikko-Causby User:Johnuniq 05:09, 9 June 2009 (UTC) delete Fails . A presenter at conferences and a Young Scholars Grant is not sufficiently notable Deletion of Nichole Mikko-Causby WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11873 16817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuliza Technologies User:Anupmehra 21:07, 4 November 2016 (UTC) delete I'm not sure where the Promo or Spam thing is coming from because I don't see anything like that in this article (at least, blatant promo or what we do normally observe in company related articles). It should be deleted because it fails Deletion of Kuliza Technologies WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
11874 14862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Catherine Lynch User:Catlemur 12:12, 11 March 2018 (UTC) delete The article relies heavily on newspapers of local significance as such she cannot be considered notable even outside her hometown (). As such the person described in the article is not different from any other common early 20th century British prostitute. She is not related and had never interacted with any people worthy of an article. Had she been a man or were born later into the century the article would have been speedily deleted without a single objection (), yet people want to keep it simply for the quality of its prose. With a variety of sources available one might write millions upon millions of articles on people of her caliber, we DO NOT need that to get an insight of her profession or era when articles such as Prostitution in the United Kingdom exist Deletion of Catherine Lynch WP:NOTNEWS||WP:NOTOBITUARY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11875 1630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bülent Gökay User:PWilkinson 12:20, 13 April 2013 (UTC) comment """Stubbing a fairly long article and then stating """"virtually no information"""" as the primary reason for deletion is probably not to be recommended as a course of action - although stubbing, in this case, was admittedly almost completely unavoidable as the original article was an unwikified resume probably copy and pasted (by someone with obvious COI) from somewhere else. As to the subject's notability - I'm completely undecided. A professor at a middle-ranking English university has a good, but far from certain, chance of meeting on one or more criteria. Though, looking at the likely ones - British professorships are sufficiently less common than, for instance, American ones that the possibility of #5 should be considered, but they are sometimes awarded for administrative responsibilities one or two levels below what could justify #6, and this looks quite possible in this case. Otherwise, the subject has what looks like quite a long and respectable publication record, mostly in English but partly in Turkish, some of which looks probably well-cited considering his areas of research. The problem, made more difficult by the rather random order of the GScholar results, is judging whether he meets #1 - chances are, I think, that he doesn't quite, but I'm really not sure""" Deletion of Bülent Gökay WP:PROF||WP:PROF||WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11876 12687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative facts User:E 00:05, 23 January 2017 (UTC) comment that a great many articles were created on similar politics-related neologisms during the past year. Many (Cf. Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Basket of deplorables were created and deleted soon after the term hit the news cycle. Others (Cf. Act of Love (political statement and advertisement) and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernie Bro were not merely created months after the first time the was in the new cycle, they were created after political journalists had had time to write about the origin, use and impact of a newly coined phrase itself Deletion of Alternative facts WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11877 4327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Parents Favorite Music User:Atyndall 03:07, 15 July 2008 (UTC) delete 0 google news results, no notable sources, user has been asked to add good sources. I think it fails |music notability criteria. Deletion of My Parents Favorite Music WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11878 12723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blaire White User:Jeff5102 14:31, 29 August 2018 (UTC) keep https://www.yahoo.com/news/unfiltered-harder-come-right-wing-trans-223158024.html This will make her pass the -guideline too. Regards Deletion of Blaire White WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11879 17193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vinod Prasad Yadav User:Tristan 09:18, 30 November 2020 (UTC) keep Politicians who have held statewide office in a federated state (which India is) are presumed notable according to Deletion of Vinod Prasad Yadav WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11880 7142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Israel–Gaza conflict timeline 2006–2008 User:RightCowLeftCoast 01:54, 13 February 2013 (UTC) comment I am concerned regarding what is written above, as this maybe seen as |POV advocacy. It shouldn't matter whether one groups casualties is more or less than another. It should be that one is only concern about documenting casualties, period Deletion of Israel–Gaza conflict timeline 2006–2008 WP:NOTSOAPBOX Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11881 6366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aproplan User:HighKing 16:14, 23 May 2018 (UTC) delete No indications of notability, references fail the criteria for establishing notability, fails GNG and Deletion of Aproplan WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11882 6102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gronland User:EliminatorJR 11:38, 19 June 2007 (UTC) keep Gronland (the record label), appears to be reasonably notable. '''Delete''' Sol Seppy and Half Cousin as they don't pass . Therefore also '''Delete''' the rest as they are records by those two artists. Note: there also appear to be other NN artists linked from the Gronland page Deletion of Gronland WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11883 20224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boraj Tanwaran User:Largoplazo 15:22, 23 June 2014 (UTC) delete """I don't see that the content is unfixable, because """"Boraj Tanwaran is a small village in Salumbar tehsil, Rajasthan, India"""" would be a perfectly good stub. But I find no usable sources for it in English and none in Hindi. (I didn't try Rajasthani, since I don't have a source for its spelling in Rajasthani.) Therefore, it appears to fall short of and """ Deletion of Boraj Tanwaran WP:NGEOG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11884 15235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ninja (Puppet Master) User:Sgeureka 08:53, 2 June 2012 (UTC) delete to List of Puppet Master characters. No established , no sourced real-world information () and rather stubby (). &ndash Deletion of Ninja (Puppet Master) WP:NOTABILITY||WP:WAF||WP:AVOIDSPLIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11885 21259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Ground House (film) User:Artene50 08:52, 9 June 2008 (UTC) delete There isn't a single independent verifiable source. Secondly, Wikipedia is not a Deletion of The Ground House (film) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11886 20672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Memory Will Never Die User:Fishhead64 17:56, 14 April 2007 (UTC) delete nn per Deletion of The Memory Will Never Die WP:MUS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11887 12938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keyence NONE NONE keep Keyence is a Japanese-headquartered multinational corporation founded in 1974 with a U.S. office since 1985, thousands of employees, and multi-billions of dollars in annual sales. Qualifies under and . From https://www.forbes.com/companies/keyence/#598071c17efa ''Forbes'' business ranking website Deletion of Keyence WP:CORP||WP:LISTED Wikipedia:Notability 77
11888 3416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Path Solutions (2nd nomination) User:HighKing 14:44, 9 January 2018 (UTC) delete As per nom, fails GNG, references fail and/or Deletion of Path Solutions (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
11889 19015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virgilio Salentes User:Stifle 15:48, 19 April 2008 (UTC) delete unless |citations from |reliable sources are added to comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Virgilio Salentes WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11890 12138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faizan User:Huon 15:41, 8 January 2012 (UTC) delete """the topic is non-notable because there's no indication of significant coverage in reliable secondary sources per the |general notability guideline. All we have are entries in lists of baby names, more akin to directory entries than to significant coverage. I have doubts about their reliability, too - especially since they claim the same word means """"flood"""", """"ruler"""" and """"grace"""" (Google translates it as """"flood"""", by the way). The article's claim about the name's widespread use is not supported by the given source""" Deletion of Faizan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11891 5533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shelly Glover User:Walton 19:38, 24 February 2007 (UTC) delete no evidence of multiple coverage in independent sources, so no proof of notability per . Delete unless sources can be found Deletion of Shelly Glover WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11892 201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denise Oliver User:2604 18:56, 2 April 2020 (UTC) comment Leaning redirect to List of Canadian voice actors#O as not all entries there are bluelinked, and roles indicate is likely satisfied; with ECP applied to prevent tendentious recreation. However, there seems to be some conjecture above that sources will eventually be found, in which case it can be converted to a userspace draft to work on until the sourcing is good enough to pass through the AFC process, and moved in over redirect. Pinging {{U|Dflaw4}} to see if there is any interest in hosting this in userspace Deletion of Denise Oliver WP:LSC Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
11893 6171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernard Coleman Memorial Square User:Bearian 20:03, 17 September 2008 (UTC) delete sorry, but a lost case, see above. Also, this violates these rules: |notability, |reliable sources, OT|notability of a plaza is not inherited from a neighborhood. This is a tiny space on a tiny island Deletion of Bernard Coleman Memorial Square WP:N||WP:RS||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11894 19197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1990s retro movement User:Kinu 02:54, 24 July 2006 (UTC) delete what is this? |Crystal |ballzzzz Deletion of 1990s retro movement WP:NOT||WP:BALLS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11895 14933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chele Farley User:YankeesFan85 16:14, 20 June 2018 (UTC) keep """Farley is running for the United States Senate. She also is running in the third largest state in the country, which has the #1 media market in the country, and her opponent (Kirsten Gillibrand) is considered by many to be a top tier contender for the 2020 election for President in the Democratic Party. Furthermore, as noted by DES, this year is shaping up to be quite contentious, and interest in this race will be high at not only the state and national levels, but also the international level. It is currently only June but I think it’s safe to say that there will be a lot more coverage of Farley as election day approaches. Some of you are citing , though I don’t think it’s fair to characterize a long process that has many individual events over the course of a year as “simply one event”. There will be many more incidents and stories that will occur over the next 5 months which will be covered by national press, as this will be a race that affects not only the 20 million residents of NY state, but the country of 300 million as a whole. Furthermore, Farley’s coverage extends beyond just local publications in New York. Her actions have received coverage from '''multiple international news sites''', including the https://www.jpost.com/International/Visiting-Senate-candidate-NYs-Gillibrand-not-pro-Israel-554806 Jerusalem Post and https://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/243322 Arutz Sheva, two major reliable publications in Israel. How many non-incumbent candidates for US elected office receive international coverage? Unlike Ringelstein who some have compared Farley to, a candidate who struggles to get coverage in local Maine publications, Farley has been covered in major national publications like The Wall Street Journal, Politico, The Hill, and Breitbart, among others. Additionally, she has been covered by many of the significant local papers throughout the state, including those both in the City as well as Buffalo, Syracuse, Albany, Long Island, Rochester, and others. I believe this is overwhelming evidence that there is '''significant interest in Farley from the international, national, and local press.''' Also, this coverage is not solely limited to biographical information. Many of these publications are interested in her beyond simply the fact that she is running: they’re interested in who she is and what she stands for, and therefore an article covering all of this verifiable information is appropriate. Again, Farley blows the requirements of out of the water - you do not get covered by international news publications for being """"non-notable""" Deletion of Chele Farley WP:BLP1E||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11896 21457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jake E User:Insertcleverphrasehere 22:09, 7 October 2016 (UTC) comment the only thing I'm seeing here regarding any kind of notability for the subject himself (rather than the band) are two interviews, http://www.metal-discovery.com/Interviews/amaranthe_interview_2011.htm and http://www.rm-media.org/interviews/2007/interviews2007_004.php. I would say these represent significant coverage, as they are both direct interviews with just Jake E. They seem to be independent sources, but reliability might be the sticking point as it isn't clear if there is any editorial oversight here. While they are not particularly high profile sources, they do seem to just barely satisfy the criteria outlined at if deemed reliable sources. If someone else could weigh in on whether or not these two sources are reliable or not, that should give us our answer to this AfD. I will !vote accordingly Deletion of Jake E WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11897 12365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tilly Keeper User:Aoidh 02:58, 13 April 2016 (UTC) keep """EastEnders'' is not a """"daytime soap"""" and is in fact one of the most successful programs in TV history, and List of EastEnders characters (2001)#Louise Mitchell|her role appears to be a significant one, now List of EastEnders characters#Regular characters|back in the show for the fourth time as a regular character. She has received extensive coverage (see the """"news"""" results from the """"Find sources"""" link above) and from all appearances easily passes . Also, I endorse what""" Deletion of Tilly Keeper WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11898 13142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Will Guthrie [[User talk:Orderinchaos|Orderinchaos]] 18:45, 9 December 2007 (UTC) delete fails , seems to be self-publishing and no evidence of commercial career or performance, hence no available either Deletion of Will Guthrie WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11899 16268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John E. Bacon User:Margin1522 20:51, 10 December 2014 (UTC) delete Stub, fails . http://history.state.gov/departmenthistory/people/bacon-john-edmund? This is a better summary of his 3-year diplomatic career, but we don't need it. This was a miserable period in the history of Paraguay, and it would be interesting to know what he did there. Without that, no reason to keep the article. – Deletion of John E. Bacon WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11900 19590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russophobia User:KeithTyler 16:48, 16 July 2007 (UTC) keep """AFDs on discrimination topics need keen attention and a higher bar than just mobs of people with poor arguments for their vote (which *FD are not supposedly based merely upon). Clearly anti-Russian sentiment does and has existed, and the article presents evidence of it. I find it very troubling that some of the people that voted to delete Estophobia are voting to keep Russophobia or likewise among other ethnic discrimination articles. BTW, bad title e.g. """"it's a neologism, nuke!"""" is not an argument for deletion, but for the simple act of renaming. And PS: Does anyone ever actually check to see if accusations of or are real, or just made as the result of POV? Pointing out acts of discrimination or prejudice are just that. And prejudice -- much prejudice -- really does exist in the world, believe it or not, and as such has encyclopedic merit""" Deletion of Russophobia WP:SYNTH||WP:POINT Wikipedia:No original research 65
11901 12607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paula Fatic User:Jkelly 18:00, 7 August 2006 (UTC) delete unless enough |reliable sources can be found to write an article. All we have is their personal webpage Deletion of Paula Fatic WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11902 12292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alfie Whattam User:Uncle 15:36, 1 November 2013 (UTC) comment Without judging the merits of this AFD, I will say that I suspect some serious negative |conflict of interest between the nominator and the article subject based upon both this AFD and the numerous suspect IP edits to the article over the last 2 days. --| Deletion of Alfie Whattam WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
11903 9367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaali Sudheer (2nd nomination) User:GSS 05:16, 18 February 2019 (UTC) delete and salt +Sudheer Mopperthy. Film producers do not get an automatic inclusion freebie on Wikipedia just for being producers. They get Wikipedia articles when they're the subject of reliable source coverage which verifies passage of a specific notability criterion, namely — they do not get an automatic notability pass just because they exist Deletion of Kaali Sudheer (2nd nomination) WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
11904 3968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James William Middleton User:Zoeydahling 05:17, 3 May 2011 (UTC) keep Although obviously not as well covered in the media as his sister Kate, James has been the subject of a number of articles in reliable news sources and is clearly of public interest. I believe he meets and therefore !vote for the article to be kept Deletion of James William Middleton WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11905 1256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nassau Royal User:Robofish 22:20, 30 May 2011 (UTC) delete I agree with the nominator that he doesn't seem to satisfy at this time. I can't find significant coverage in reliable sources either Deletion of Nassau Royal WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11906 17464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Renegade1116 User:IslaySolomon 17:27, 29 September 2006 (UTC) delete """as ''""""an article about a person that does not assert the importance or significance of the subject. (CSD A7)""""''. |Wikipedia is not: a directory, an advertising service, a webhost, a publisher of original thought. It is, however, an encyclopedia, a concept that Renegade1116 should probably familiarise himself with""" Deletion of Renegade1116 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11907 5395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dragonmead User:ThaddeusB 15:48, 20 February 2015 (UTC) keep sufficient sourcing to establish notability under the |GNG. Also a Wp:trout|trouting is in order for an inappropriate use use speedy deletion by RHaworth - there were many past revisions without the slightest hint of promotionalism. Can I get any article I want speedy deleted by dumping promotional text into it now? Additionally, speedy deletion is only for unambiguous advertising, not mere promotional language, and the text and the time of deletion did not meet that Deletion of Dragonmead WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11908 10889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emma Ferrante User:Mysmartmouth 03:04, 28 September 2006 (UTC) delete per , nom Deletion of Emma Ferrante WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11909 3330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of alleged UFO-related entities [[User talk:Eldereft|Eldereft]] ([[Special:Contributions/Eldereft|cont.]]) 18:53, 13 November 2008 (UTC) delete for lack of inclusion criteria backed by reliable sources. A historical analysis of trends in reported characteristics might make an interesting |sociology essay, though Deletion of List of alleged UFO-related entities WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11910 976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aleksandr Salimov User:GiantSnowman 08:02, 13 July 2012 (UTC) delete fails , which outweighs Deletion of Aleksandr Salimov WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
11911 17702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GREY PAPER User:Spongefrog 13:41, 10 November 2009 (UTC) delete Really, just a |dicdef right now, so delete. And also per the nominater's reasons. What's with all the caps Deletion of GREY PAPER WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11912 14672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wind Jet Flight 243 User:Ohconfucius 05:16, 4 October 2010 (UTC) delete or transfer it to WikiNews. This incident is banal, and inconsequential, and quite lacking in |encyclopaedic notability Deletion of Wind Jet Flight 243 WP:UNENC Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11913 3758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Don User:Chzz 00:50, 14 February 2011 (UTC) delete no sign of notability per , lacks significant coverage in reliable sources ; per not notable Deletion of Eric Don WP:GNG||WP:BIO||WP:VRS||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
11914 5886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alenka Hubacek User:Lankiveil 04:14, 2 May 2011 (UTC) delete while she meets the letter of , I'm not sure that a single wildcard doubles appearance, where she was soundly defeated by an unseeded player, really meets the ''spirit'' of that guideline. As good a time as any to Deletion of Alenka Hubacek WP:NTENNIS||WP:IAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
11915 5198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anil Nair User:Legis 05:03, 11 December 2011 (UTC) delete Seems to me to be a clear case of failing Deletion of Anil Nair WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11916 80 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fandom Talk User:Tychocat 09:17, 26 July 2006 (UTC) delete as original research, advertisement, and looks like a neologism. Fails for lacking multiple non-trivial articles by third-parties Deletion of Fandom Talk WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
11917 16273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Late Night Delight User:doomsdayer520 20:43, 27 June 2019 (UTC) delete Only |routine retail/streaming sites and minor social media promos can be found. It has no coverage in |reliable sources. I wonder if they got proper authorization to put their song on top of the old McDonalds commercial and call it a video Deletion of Late Night Delight WP:ROUTINE||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
11918 20185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamilton Electors User:Tdl1060 00:08, 20 December 2016 (UTC) merge with Faithless electors in the United States presidential election, 2016. Now that the electoral college has voted, it is no longer a violation of to presume that faithless electors will exist in the 2016 cycle. However, the Hamilton Electors' goal failed to materialize at any level, as there was no alternative candidate to receive votes from both Democratic and Republican electors. As such, Hamilton Electors is only notable enough to warrant a mention in the article Faithless electors in the United States presidential election, 2016 Deletion of Hamilton Electors WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11919 19721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ina Fried User:Edison 06:07, 30 September 2008 (UTC) keep """Google News archive http://news.google.com/news?as_q=&svnum=10&as_scoring=r&btnG=Google+Search&as_epq=ina+fried&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_drrb=q&as_qdr=&as_mind=30&as_minm=8&as_maxd=29&as_maxm=9&as_nsrc=&as_nloc=&geo=&as_occt=any&aq=f shows 1360 hits for """"Ina Fried"""" indicating satisfaction of and , via Fried being the not only the author of articles in ZNET but featured on National Public Radio and quoted in Newswireless.net, UK, Gearlog, New York, iTwire, Australia, Motley Fool, and Seattle Times. Fried was called """"la experta en Windows"""" by Diario TI, Spain. Fried's work at Znet/CDnet has led to worldwide notability. Google book search also shows that Fried's work has been cited numerous times. http://books.google.com/books?lr=&q=%22ina+fried%22&as_brr=3. Metroweekly had a feature article about Fried's gender change http://www.metroweekly.com/feature/?ak=3712""" Deletion of Ina Fried WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11920 11588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/December Baby User:HĐ 11:02, 28 February 2021 (UTC) delete or '''Redirect''' to JoJo discography. Fails and Deletion of December Baby WP:GNG||WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
11921 17772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Southern Cat Rocks On User:Canley 07:56, 30 January 2008 (UTC) keep """Gene Summers is clearly notable, says that his albums are notable too. Is it the word """"compilation"""" that's confusing? In addition, there are plenty of references and material to sustain an article, they're not inline cites but they indicate to me that the notability is not only claimed but quite obvious""" Deletion of The Southern Cat Rocks On WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11922 19469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ostrander, California User:Dlthewave 19:55, 16 July 2020 (UTC) delete Fails , appears to be a rail stop and not a community Deletion of Ostrander, California WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
11923 177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evan Carmichael User:Gidonb 02:52, 5 December 2017 (UTC) keep According to my research meets the Deletion of Evan Carmichael WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11924 11666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tuza User:Paddles 15:03, 27 May 2006 (UTC) delete Possibly a candidate for |speedy A1 but borderline Deletion of Tuza WP:SPEEDY Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11925 5926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Florence Devouard (3rd nomination) NONE NONE keep as Deletion of Florence Devouard (3rd nomination) WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11926 5307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miami Beach Visitor and Convention Authority User:Ajf773 19:06, 23 October 2018 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Miami Beach Visitor and Convention Authority WP:NOTPROMO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11927 1405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monster Trux Extreme: Offroad Edition (2nd nomination) User:Videogameplayer99 19:39, 13 December 2019 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Monster Trux Extreme: Offroad Edition (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11928 19163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zidm User:Sam 09:48, 24 October 2018 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Zidm WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11929 19462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cohearence User:Porqin 12:09, 24 July 2006 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Cohearence WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
11930 9102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/City View Center User:CASSIOPEIA 10:11, 9 February 2019 (UTC) keep A found sources. Added sources into article. Pass Deletion of City View Center WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
11931 870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Total Fight Night User:TreyGeek 18:28, 24 December 2011 (UTC) delete I can find no sources to support the notability of this single event. Due to the date, more coverage would likely exist in print media, of which the article cites only one source (the external link in the article is also broken). Without someone coming forward with additional sources, event appears to fail and certainly fails and Deletion of Total Fight Night WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE||WP:SPORTSEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11932 18609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Trump chessmaster meme User:Smuckola 17:14, 17 January 2018 (UTC) delete This is ephemeral pop culture detritus which obviously should not exist. But I think it's still probably anywhere else except maybe as a long collection of sources at the end of the one quotation Deletion of Donald Trump chessmaster meme WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
11933 13450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Live2Support User:Whpq 00:08, 20 March 2013 (UTC) comment WP:OTHERSTUFF|Much worse articles may just mean they ought to be deleted too, and has no bearing on this article. If the number of clients make them |worthy of note, the we expect to see significant coverage in independent |reliable sources. I see no such coverage Deletion of Live2Support WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11934 19389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stuckey and Murray User:Herostratus 14:30, 22 August 2016 (UTC) keep """I guess. Maybe. It's borderline. The ''Charleston City Paper'' says """"videos like 'Awkward Sex' and 'Auto Phone Sex' (not related) have amassed millions of views"""" on YouTube. If that's true, doesn't that show evidence of meeting #2, """"Has a large fan base or a significant 'cult' following""""? Not sure, maybe millions of views is common. If it is common, they might not make the cut. The ''Post & Courier'' review is a plus, but the 'Charleston City Paper'' is not worth much, so you probably don't have multiple in-depth references. It does look like a promotional article. I dunno, I better stop before I talk myself out of my vote""" Deletion of Stuckey and Murray WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11935 9931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kidnap and ransom insurance User:CRGreathouse 03:13, 10 October 2007 (UTC) keep and Deletion of Kidnap and ransom insurance WP:SNOWBALL Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
11936 17797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/In the Hills of California User:Stifle 18:52, 29 April 2008 (UTC) delete unless |citations from |reliable sources are added to comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of In the Hills of California WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11937 407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saad Alzahrani User:David 21:42, 7 March 2017 (UTC) delete per and . Graduate students are almost always not yet notable (because their papers haven't had enough impact yet and it is too difficult to disentangle their contributions from the contributions of their more notable coauthors) and I don't see any evidence that this one is exceptional Deletion of Saad Alzahrani WP:TOOSOON||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
11938 13581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Huebner User:Kierano 22:23, 30 May 2013 (UTC) keep the BLP issues have been resolved. As for notability, it's probably skirting the edges of , but I feel like the one paper he is known for was high-profile enough, in both the press and the academic literature, to warrant keeping the article. (The very fact that it attracted BLP violations, though unfortunate, also supports this Deletion of Jonathan Huebner WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
11939 9354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enigma.io NONE NONE keep Meets per Deletion of Enigma.io WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
11940 20336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Films notable for negative reception User:Mitaphane 21:34, 29 April 2007 (UTC) comment """Like with Films considered the greatest ever, I don't think the concept violates WP policy. There's alot of references out there that this article is built on that satisfies WP:V & . However, this article builds a taxonomy(B-movies,Star Vehicles, etc...) which it defines itself with no resources (). On top of that, the title """"Films notable for negative reception"""" is |POV as 'notable' is a subjective term. """"Films considered the worst ever"""" is more neutral in my opinion""" Deletion of Films notable for negative reception WP:OR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
11941 13100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dodgyism User:Gwernol 23:24, 5 August 2006 (UTC) delete per Omicronpersei8. Unless |reliable, independent sources that show this to be true are added to the article, this is a clear . Google returns zero hits for Dodgyism. We should not allow Wikipedia to be used to perpetrate this sort of |nonsense. Also violates , obviously Deletion of Dodgyism WP:RS||WP:HOAX||WP:BALLS||WP:NFT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11942 19478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malwana International School User:LaMona 23:57, 7 July 2016 (UTC) delete This may be a for the founder - but I'm not sure. The school appears to have had a maximum of 200 students at its peak. I don't find anything about in it searches but that isn't surprising given that it no long exists, was tiny, and located in Malwana, Sri Lanka Deletion of Malwana International School WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
11943 18024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eta Sigma Gamma [[User talk:65.129.40.90|talk]]) 21:37, 6 February 2021 (UTC) delete Fails . There isn't a single reliable independent source that discusses the subject in detail on the entire article and BEFORE shows nothing better. And FYI, WikiPryjects do not own the articles they watch. Special:Contributions/65.129.40.90|65.129.40.90 Deletion of Eta Sigma Gamma WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11944 16903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hillary Clinton's Enemies List User:Borock 01:15, 6 January 2015 (UTC) delete Poorly sourced negative material on a living person. () The book does seem to be notable, having been reviewed in several well-known publications, and has its own article: HRC: State Secrets and the Rebirth of Hillary Clinton. That should be enough Deletion of Hillary Clinton's Enemies List WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11945 7715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Creepmime User:JD554 12:42, 23 December 2008 (UTC) keep Having released two albums with an important independent label, meets criteria #5 at . Mascot Records are defined as an important independent label (that doesn't necessarily mean notable) as it has a ''roster of performershttp://www.mascotrecords.com/index.php?cid=2, many of which are notable'' as per criteria #5 Deletion of Creepmime WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11946 4443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Wainer User:Artene50 10:23, 4 July 2008 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Michael Wainer WP:BAND||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
11947 14231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Max After Dark User:AnmaFinotera 19:42, 8 April 2009 (UTC) merge the prose, leave out the list. The time block, with its various names, is an appropriate thing to mention in the main Cinemax article, as with other channels with blocks. It isn't notable enough for its own article, though, and a list of a ton of unknown softcore flicks that are nearly impossible to verify isn't needed (many channel articles are also moving away from such lists anyway, per Deletion of Max After Dark WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11948 15956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brunei Music Society User:Yoonadue 13:05, 24 October 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Brunei Music Society WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11949 21376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Max Högquist User:Schuym1 18:25, 30 October 2008 (UTC) keep This is a very tricky one. doesn't seem to mention royalty Deletion of Max Högquist WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11950 18237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Nobel laureates in Chemistry by age User:Crisco 02:42, 7 May 2011 (UTC) merge to the lists of laureates, making those lists sortable tables. Not |OR Deletion of List of Nobel laureates in Chemistry by age WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11951 12170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Income Tax Department (Bangalore) User:Whpq 17:55, 9 February 2012 (UTC) delete As a sub-sub-unit of an organisation with local juridisdiction, and no particular claim to notability beyond what the parent organisation does, it fails to meed the inclusion guideline for Deletion of Income Tax Department (Bangalore) WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11952 8302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unlock Reality User:ColourBurst 19:16, 15 September 2006 (UTC) delete per Uncle G. I trust his opinion of Wikipedia policy a lot more than a newly created Deletion of Unlock Reality WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
11953 21565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/University of Toronto student groups User:Dhartung 04:08, 30 July 2007 (UTC) delete as a #DIR|directory of information which falls short of encyclopedic standards. Student groups are almost always unnotable (not to mention ephemeral), and the few that might be are best handled in the school's main article Deletion of University of Toronto student groups WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11954 9810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whitney Ann Jenkins User:Sionk 14:01, 23 February 2020 (UTC) delete there's no evidence of major television or film roles, neither do her recordings show signs of proven success. Insufficient independent significant news coverage to pass Deletion of Whitney Ann Jenkins WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11955 8269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coverfox User:K 01:40, 24 December 2016 (UTC) delete """per ; the content is strictly advertorial with typical sections such as """"Accolades and Mentions"""", """"Recent Activities"""" etc. This content belongs on a company web site, not here""" Deletion of Coverfox WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11956 17803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warren Ounjian User:Walwal20 04:49, 14 October 2020 (UTC) delete No participation in international competitions. No good rankings in any competition at all. Very little coverage on the subject. Fails and Deletion of Warren Ounjian WP:SPORTSBASIC||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11957 7230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesus, Friend Of Sinners [[User talk:202.124.74.168|talk]]) 07:07, 28 April 2012 (UTC) keep The sourcing in the sandbox version indicates a pass of . -- Special:Contributions/202.124.74.168|202.124.74.168 Deletion of Jesus, Friend Of Sinners WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11958 9983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ross Clifton User:Papaursa 03:49, 5 February 2013 (UTC) delete Fails with no top tier fights and meets no other notability criteria Deletion of Ross Clifton WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
11959 7816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salva Me User:R 23:13, 12 October 2005 (UTC) delete """Don't see anything that establishes them as anything but some local band. Only a self-released album, and a dubious claim of being a """"national touring group"""" (bands like this, when they tour, generally play small gigs and lose alot of money; maybe they play weddings?). All their reference links are to their homepage. claims to passing seem unverified""" Deletion of Salva Me WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11960 5202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stelios Coucounaras User:Ben 09:17, 13 June 2015 (UTC) delete Have searched for German sources (one states that he has been living there for fifty years).http://www.komponistenlexikon.de/content/komponisten.php?id=249 There are only a few mentions, mostly for his composing for brass, esp. tubas. Seems to be liked by advanced instrumentalists.http://www.nmz.de/artikel/virtuose-tuba-im-konzertsaal But that is not enough for Deletion of Stelios Coucounaras WP:COMPOSER Wikipedia:Notability 77
11961 9971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marketing term User:DARTH 18:04, 14 October 2010 (UTC) delete Lacks sources, also per Deletion of Marketing term WP:DICTIONARY Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
11962 4946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Kennedy in Palestine (1948) User:Mangoe 20:35, 12 March 2010 (UTC) delete as someone's thesis. Every cite is essentially from a primary source; the thesis itself comes from the article's author Deletion of Robert Kennedy in Palestine (1948) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
11963 324 [[Christian Rommel]] (BNR) Benutzer:HerrSonderbar NONE delete Es braucht ja schon eine gehörige Portion Geltungssucht, so über sich selbst zu schreiben... In dieser Form ist das jedenfalls ein Interessenkonflikt, ein klarer Verstoß gegen das |Neutralitätsgebot und kann auf gar keinen Fall so bleiben; ob da die QS noch Abhilfe zu verschaffen vermag, wage ich zu bezweifeln, ohne die Lobhudelei bleibt von dem Artikel nicht mehr allzuviel Substantielles übrig, fürchte ich. Jemand, der mal im Ausland gearbeitet, dabei irgendwelche Sachen gesammelt und sie freundlicherweise mal ausgestellt hat und ein bisschen was im Eigenverlag herausgibt. Beeindruckend. Rezeption ausschließlich in gewerblichen Fach(nischen)magazinen, sonst null. Ich würde den Artikel Löschung von Christian Rommel Wikipedia:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
11964 4473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harrison J. Fuller User:Bearcat 21:43, 6 November 2018 (UTC) delete Filmmakers do not automatically qualify for Wikipedia articles just because their work can technically be metaverified by its own presence on YouTube or Vimeo, or because it has IMDb pages — a filmmaker gets over the CREATIVE bar when his films have resulted in |reliable source ''media'' outlets doing ''journalism'', such as film reviews and/or profiles of him as a person, ''about'' him and his work. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, not a free PR platform — the presence or absence of ''media'' coverage ''about'' him tells us whether he gets in here yet or not, not his own desire to be in here for the publicity Deletion of Harrison J. Fuller WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11965 7158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Gau User:Lilac 14:38, 11 March 2009 (UTC) delete very ''very'' that IMDB doesn't have these under his name - they are, |unlikely Wikipedia fairly indiscriminate, in my experience. Been tagged for notability since 2006, so we're not going to get anywhere with this Deletion of John Gau WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11966 17382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad Mehdi Nooripour User:MA 19:28, 21 April 2020 (UTC) delete Per nom and fails Deletion of Mohammad Mehdi Nooripour WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11967 1406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chickenshit Conformist User:Uzma 10:12, 28 September 2012 (UTC) merge """There's a mention in http://search.wn.com/?template=cheetah-search-adv/index.txt&action=search&results_type=news&search_string=nazi%20punks%20fuck%20off!&language_id=1&sort_type=-pub-datetime&corpus=current&search_type=expression Do politics and rock remain a viable mix? Montreal Gazette October 6, 2001 (""""Rock'n'roll will always have an enemy, whether for the DKs or Elvis. That enemy is complacency, and if a song called Chickenshit Conformist counters the kind of thinking that might seek to rehabilitate the """"Reagan Revolution,"""" all the better.""""). Another mention in http://www.miaminewtimes.com/2002-02-07/music/better-dead/ Miami New Times February 7, 2002"""" """"The final studio effort, 1986's Bedtime for Democracy, pushed for musical innovation with the disturbing """"Chickenshit Conformist"""" and """"DMSO."""" """". Unlikely to meet """ Deletion of Chickenshit Conformist WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11968 8059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Indian Graph User:Jersey92 17:18, 3 July 2014 (UTC) delete Easily fails and is missing reliable references Deletion of The Indian Graph WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
11969 13497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madeleina Kay User:Vilcxjo 10:51, 17 October 2017 (UTC) delete Self-written publicity piece, padded with excitably stated non-notable facts, fails to meet any of the criteria (, , POV, etc etc Deletion of Madeleina Kay WP:BIO||WP:N||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
11970 7852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seapunk (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 02:43, 21 June 2014 (UTC) keep Passes having received significant coverage in multiple independent reliable sources. Source examples include, but are not limited to, http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/04/fashion/Seapunk-a-Web-Joke-With-Music-Has-Its-Moment.html?_r=0 ''The New York Times'', http://www.theguardian.com/music/2012/dec/14/seapunk-has-now-gone-pop ''The Guardian'' and http://www.chicagoreader.com/chicago/seapunk-twitter-tumblr-ultrademon-zombelle-molly-soda/Content?oid=5389539 ''Chicago Reader Deletion of Seapunk (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11971 6693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sir Keith Arbuthnot, 8th Baronet User:BrownHairedGirl 20:38, 11 March 2007 (UTC) keep """after some hesitation. This is a difficult issue: it is clear from the discussions about the proposed Wikipedia:Notability (royalty) guidelines that there is cuurently no consensus either way about whether hereditary nobility itself confers a presumption of notability.Some of the arguments in this AFD discussion appear to me to be concerning themselves with whether people approve or disapprove of the system of honours and nobility. That's irrelevant: I'm sure that all of us can pints to huge swathes of Wikipedia which cover things we dislike, disapprove of, or think are over-rated.Other parts of the discussion appear to be a re-run of the arguments which were (or should have been) made wrt to the rejected guideline. I think it would have been useful to have some guideline, whatever it said, to avoid re-inventing the wheel each time this issue arises; but there isn't one, and there's no point proceeding as if we are devising a guideline on either heredity or nobility. Without a special guideline we have to fall back to assessing ''this particular article'' under and .It seems to me that the 8th Baronet here is a marginal case wrt to : numerous entries in works on nobility and a Who's Who entry seem to me to go a long way to meeting , but without unambiguously getting there. The discussion above includes well-reasoned arguments both for against this baronet meeting .As to , I can't find anything there which suggests that this is a special case.However, I am persuaded by the arguments above by Charles01: """"Whatever you think about the British honours system (... I myself find it significantly batty and, on a serious note, potentially corrupting) it is a part of public life in the UK that seems to interest plenty of folks in UK and anglophone places which used to be 'owned' by UK. These guys enjoy disproportionate influence"""".That's what clinches it for me: the fact of being the latest title-holder in a family which includes several notable people and apperas to somewhat influential. However, I don't think that ''all'' baronets pass that test: not all families of baronets have anyone notable, and plenty of baronetcies were sold by Maundy Gregory or awarded to otherwise obscure people who happened to find favour with the government of the day""" Deletion of Sir Keith Arbuthnot, 8th Baronet WP:NN||WP:BIO||WP:NN||WP:NN||WP:NN||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11972 10010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Lavoie User:Carrite 13:54, 4 May 2011 (UTC) keep """The use of automated tools for mass deletions should not be allowed against large blocks of articles which have already been patrolled at New Pages. It is, simply put, a violation of — due diligence is not being done when these tools are being used in this way. """"Shoot them all and let the saps at AfD sort them out,"""" is apparently the line of thinking. While I am personally sympathetic to the idea of a very high bar for so-called """"Porn Bios,"""" this blasting of 100 articles at the rate of 1 per minute, judging from the time logs, is not conducive to the spirit or practice of AfD. It is putting DON'T LIKE IT ahead of the established article deletion process and is disrespectful both to the work of article creators and those of us who volunteer our time at AfD. We have seen similar automated mass annihilation efforts recently against modern Trotskyist political organizations and against fraternities and sororities. The net result of these efforts was a lot of lost time by article creators and AfD participants and a lot of lost information from those articles annihilated as part of these campaigns. Meanwhile, the backlog of crap at New Pages festers. Something needs to be done about this problem. Mine is not a unique view — see Wikipedia:ANI#Massive_number_of_Playboy-related_AFD_nominations_by_a_single_user at ANI. We need to keep them all as a matter of principle and ban the future use of automated tools in this way. ''This argument will be copied-and-pasted in the debate sections for all automated AfDs of this campaign""" Deletion of Jennifer Lavoie WP:BEFORE||WP:I Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
11973 13213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dopeman Twizzy NONE NONE comment """According to """"If a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to be suitable for a stand-alone article or list"""". A meticulous review of the sources will show that the subject has received massive coverage from almost all national dallies in Nigeria and the subject discussed in-depth. It is also worthy to note that when Nigerian musicians release new songs media houses publish same without remuneration""" Deletion of Dopeman Twizzy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11974 7729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Proti všem User:Carrite 14:07, 22 July 2018 (UTC) keep Bad faith nomination, one of six (!!!) made in a single minute. is being flouted and (semi-)automation abused Deletion of Proti všem WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
11975 16079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs from Family Guy [[User talk:Pomte|Pomte]] 03:41, 10 March 2007 (UTC) keep Family Guy is a show notable for its song parodies. Not so much as it is not currently verified, and if some reliable source did study these song parodies then you bet they would have the same conclusions using SENSE. If delete, interested readers must go through every single episode article to dig out all the songs, when they could just use this list. If this information belongs anywhere, it belongs here as well (#PAPER). Fancruft would be trivia that has absolutely nothing to do with the outside world. This list does, and if anyone wonders how Family Guy could be important in relation to other culture, then this list would prove valuable encyclopedic use without making an OR synthetic statement Deletion of List of songs from Family Guy WP:OR||WP:COMMON||WP:NOT Wikipedia:No original research 65
11976 3791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donuts N' Glory User:Jasynnash2 09:34, 24 September 2008 (UTC) delete they may meet one of the many criteria at but, unless it's made clear which one in the article (and referenced) I have to stick with delete for lack of notability and verifiability Deletion of Donuts N' Glory WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11977 21820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avalon (webcomic) User:Balancer 01:55, 22 February 2007 (UTC) keep WCCA awards qualify the comic for notability per . Nomination apparently in bad faith per Deletion of Avalon (webcomic) WP:WEB||WP:POINT Wikipedia:Notability 77
11978 12091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malin to Mizen User:BrownHairedGirl 17:06, 8 May 2008 (UTC) keep """As the Google search above confirmed, this is a well-known challenge route between the opposite ends of the island of Ireland. (Mhockey asked for view of an Irish wikipedian, and I'm one of them. I don't think that Malin-to-Mizen s quite as notable in Ireland as """"Lands End to John O'Groats"""" is in England, but it's way more than notable enough to satisfy . The article itself may require cleanup, but that's a different matter""" Deletion of Malin to Mizen WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11979 19206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melchior Borg (2nd nomination) User:Bfigura 06:06, 2 September 2007 (UTC) keep per . If he did an international tour, that should satisfy notability issues. Still needs cleanup and sourcing though Deletion of Melchior Borg (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11980 7999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Principality of the pontinha User:Shawn 20:07, 23 December 2015 (UTC) delete """It isn't really """"self-proclaimed,"""" it's http://www.odditycentral.com/news/portuguese-man-buys-tiny-island-successfully-establishes-his-own-kingdom.html this guy. He also got a piece published in ''The Guardian'' on http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2014/nov/14/experience-i-founded-my-own-country why he did it. It was this or a sports car, apparently. I've no objection to an article that properly contextualizes what this is -- or maybe an article on the island's purchaser, if that doesn't violate (a big if) -- but the stub article as it exists now is rather misleading. Little would be lost if we removed this until such time as someone wants to right a more accurate article, so I think applies""" Deletion of Principality of the pontinha WP:BLP1E||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
11981 6290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/E-Vision User:Ihcoyc 18:59, 23 March 2013 (UTC) delete """#A7|no minimal claim of significance and #G11|unambiguous advertising: ''""""E-Vision"""" is a Digital Cable Television Service Platform Operated and Provided by Etisalat in the United Arab Emirates with the following facilities with a Variety of Basic and Premuim TV Packages.'' The remaining article text is a list of things you can buy from them. So tagging""" Deletion of E-Vision WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
11982 9416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bomberman Collection Vol.2 User:Odie5533 15:50, 11 November 2012 (UTC) merge to List of Bomberman video games. Delete both and remove links from Template:Bomberman series. I could not find for the game compilations. I don't think the name makes a great redirect. Unless someone disagrees then I believe they should be deleted Deletion of Bomberman Collection Vol.2 WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11983 6986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SpaceX Crew-3 [[User talk:JTZegers|Speak]][[Special:Contributions/JTZegers|Aura]] 14:27, 18 November 2020 (UTC) keep """Fails """" my butt. Passes and also passes . Kill two birds with one stone.JTZegers""" Deletion of SpaceX Crew-3 WP:CRYSTAL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11984 14103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pass the pickle User:84 17:02, 28 May 2006 (UTC) comment """Though I think I agree it's eminently deletable and |Complete Bollocks, it's not Wikipedia:Patent Nonsense as it is comprehensible, and bollocks-ness is not a . If you want to tag it Speedy, please tag it (e.g.) """"db|AFD discussion consensus"""" otherwise stupid people like me remove the notice""" Deletion of Pass the pickle WP:BALLS||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
11985 20610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siobhan Benita User:Bondegezou 06:57, 6 May 2012 (UTC) comment """In reply to Colonel Warden, I do not see the applicability of here. Any material about this individual can be moved to London mayoral election, 2012 in keeping with . In reply to DGG, while I accept the London mayoral contest is an important one, I struggle to see how the argument supports keeping a candidate who came 5th with 3.8% of the vote. In reply to others, I would appreciate discussion of , which suggests that our coverage of her should """"be limited to the article about that event"""". Finally, can I refer everyone to a related AfD on another of the losing candidates: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlos Cortiglia""" Deletion of Siobhan Benita WP:PRESERVE||WP:PRESERVE||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
11986 14296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of words ending with -uck User:Rorshacma 21:14, 22 June 2020 (UTC) delete """I have found zero reliable sources that discuss the concept of """"words ending with uck"""", thus this is a complete failure of the and """ Deletion of List of words ending with -uck WP:GNG||WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
11987 1804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Demon's Boy User:Gene93k 22:34, 15 January 2010 (UTC) delete per nom. I couldn't find any trace of this book outside Wikipedia and its mirrors either. Fails Deletion of The Demon's Boy WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
11988 15603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hitman Assassins User:MLauba 07:46, 19 March 2009 (UTC) delete not a single secondary |source makes this 100% |original research Deletion of Hitman Assassins WP:RS||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
11989 11486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Park (scottish name) User:AlexTiefling 16:16, 27 January 2009 (UTC) delete as a |hoax Deletion of Park (scottish name) WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
11990 17475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Socially or Historically Significant Persons Bearing the Surname McNulty User:Ansh666 21:39, 24 April 2013 (UTC) merge """with McNulty. First, capitalizing every word in the title is kind of a red flag for a """"bad"""" article. Second, everyone listed on McNulty is by default """"socially or historically significant"""" because of otability, so there is no need for a separate article. Any historical or genealogical researchers would go to that page first, in any case""" Deletion of List of Socially or Historically Significant Persons Bearing the Surname McNulty WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
11991 8991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Koiko User:MER 04:50, 13 December 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Koiko WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11992 19045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Game Six of the 2011 World Series User:Davidfreesefan23 23:02, 21 March 2012 (UTC) keep I feel that the game easily deserves an article. This isn't just my case of . Many sources (ESPN among them) seem to agree that this game is an instant classic Deletion of Game Six of the 2011 World Series WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
11993 9471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Lower East Side of Life User:Dream 09:36, 30 January 2012 (UTC) keep Two reliable sites have reviewed this album, so it passes just fine Deletion of The Lower East Side of Life WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
11994 9928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nic nolan User:Peripitus 02:12, 30 October 2007 (UTC) delete clearly fails to establish sufficient notability and a resume to boot. No news articles about Nick (he's mentioned as getting married, and as being at a party in articles about others), no books, no articles and nothing that meets the |biographical notability requirements Deletion of Nic nolan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
11995 3421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Assassination threats against Donald Trump User:Muboshgu 17:07, 17 August 2016 (UTC) delete WP:PROFRINGE, . – Deletion of Assassination threats against Donald Trump WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
11996 12730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of rulers of Gaza User:Northamerica1000 23:52, 3 August 2012 (UTC) keep spaced ndash}} Per . Two sources and several inline citations have been added to the article since the time of it's nomination for deletion. Per these sources, this article appears to meet Deletion of List of rulers of Gaza WP:HEY||WP:NLIST Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
11997 14508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Gave You Power User:JediLofty 16:33, 13 August 2008 (UTC) delete for failing #Songs, as the song has not been ranked on national or significant music charts, has not won a significant award or honour, and has not been performed independently by several notable artists, bands or groups. -- JediLofty Deletion of I Gave You Power WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
11998 14374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Compass direction using a watch User:Guest9999 02:02, 24 April 2008 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is #GUIDE|not a guide, no encyclopaedic content Deletion of Compass direction using a watch WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
11999 18678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 Moscow–Constantinople schism User:Jayron32 16:35, 17 August 2021 (UTC) keep The subject is clearly, self-evidently |notable enough for an encyclopedia article about it. Disputes over terminology, naming, and other issues are part of the normal editing process, and should be carried out via discussions on the article talk page and not through the deletion process. This AFD nomination clearly appears to be out-of-process and there is no chance that an article in this state of development will be deleted. Recommend speedily closing this as keep per Deletion of 2018 Moscow–Constantinople schism WP:N||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Notability 77
12000 5917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Lucey User:Jenuk1985 19:35, 3 March 2009 (UTC) keep Definitely meets , no sources is not a valid reason to delete an article, should be tagged as unreferenced. It appears the nominator has nominated a collection of Irish related articles with little knowledge of the sports in general Deletion of Stephen Lucey WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12001 21309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Public relations design User:Esquivalience 04:47, 5 August 2015 (UTC) delete WP:GNG|Non-notable concept, possibly |original research Deletion of Public relations design WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12002 21320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denis Conway User:Anachronist 05:06, 14 August 2018 (UTC) delete I don't see any criteria in met by this actor Deletion of Denis Conway WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12003 364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Avery User:Isotope23 15:41, 3 April 2006 (UTC) delete doesn't meet criteria... borderline speedy CSD:A7 Deletion of Matthew Avery WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12004 5513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dani Gómez User:GiantSnowman 18:51, 23 November 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Dani Gómez WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12005 17206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Snowden Run 3D (2nd nomination) User:Czar 22:58, 1 March 2014 (UTC) keep As the subject of several dedicated, reliable articles, this topic meets the |GNG. If no further sources arise and a better merge location appears, I'd entertain that, but there certainly isn't ample reason for deletion in its current state. And if it helps, when I think of whether a seemingly inane VG article will survive an AfD, I compare it to ''Microshaft Winblows 98''. File:Eye close font awesome.svg|14px|link=user:czar/watching|I am no longer watching this page—whisperback if you'd like a response czar Deletion of Snowden Run 3D (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12006 15501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/W34CR User:Stuartyeates 02:47, 15 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails , which requires multiple reliable sources Deletion of W34CR WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12007 18578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Recovery Centers of America User:MenfesKidus40 01:47, 20 November 2019 (UTC) keep kind of hard to say but this is not really stuff, and other users mention and . I am noticing some good results like https://www.inquirer.com/news/pennsylvania/drug-addiction-recovery-center-devon-pa-main-line-emergency-calls-20190321.html but others are also passing mentions. I think this one passes Deletion of Recovery Centers of America WP:MILL||WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
12008 10513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Jackson (defensive end, born 1996) User:Cbl62 19:45, 16 August 2017 (UTC) keep WP:NCOLLATH is an inclusionary standard not an exclusionary one. College athletes who receive significant coverage in multiple reliable sources can also qualify under the over-arching standard. Here, Jackson has received such significant coverage in a number of major metropolitan newspapers (in addition to smaller outlets). Examples include http://caneswatch.blog.palmbeachpost.com/2016/11/11/true-freshman-joe-jackson-and-his-gladiator-body-a-big-part-of-miami-hurricanes-future/ this from ''The Palm Beach Post'' and http://www.miamiherald.com/sports/college/acc/university-of-miami/article122931034.html this from the ''Miami Herald'' and http://www.sun-sentinel.com/sports/miami-hurricanes/fl-um-football-1218-20161217-story.html this from the ''Sun-Sentinel''. Enough to pass GNG already, and this guy is just getting started and expected to be a superstar Deletion of Joe Jackson (defensive end, born 1996) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12009 6033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of geniuses (Catharine Cox Miles) User:Coolabahapple 01:52, 13 January 2019 (UTC) comment this list may be of interest to wikireaders (i am surprised that we dont appear to have a general list of geniuses article or even a category covering this, although i acknowledge the difficulties that would arise from such), but without appropriate |references this is a '''delete''', btw, agree with nom that the book ''Genetic Studies of Genius: The Early Mental Traits of Three Hundred Geniuses'' is notable Deletion of List of geniuses (Catharine Cox Miles) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12010 20193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Paul West User:Lankiveil 12:02, 6 May 2009 (UTC) delete per the thorough nomination, this person would not appear to meet the notability guidelines at the present time Deletion of Stephen Paul West WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12011 19786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFL Premiere Season User:Hippopotamus 03:23, 12 March 2009 (UTC) comment """The NFL is somewhat more notable and has been playing for over 80 years. With regards """"discrimination"""", see , amongst other pages""" Deletion of UFL Premiere Season WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12012 482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shirli Kopelman User:Kj 15:56, 23 August 2020 (UTC) comment Regarding subject requests to delete a page, see , and Deletion of Shirli Kopelman WP:BIODEL||WP:BLPDEL||WP:BLPREQUESTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12013 9639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/What Are We Waiting For User:doomsdayer520 00:52, 27 September 2020 (UTC) delete """of the songs in the list compiled by Nkon21 above. Or, if anyone is particularly concerned about |alternatives to deletion, '''Redirect all''' to Now United. The nominator is correct about the originally-nominated song and his reasoning applies to all the others to varying degrees. Some of the songs made the charts in scattered countries but for purposes of brevity this can be mentioned at the group's page. All of the articles are overwhelmingly |fancruft (or """"managercruft""""), as it takes a certain mindset to assume that every single one the group's songs deserve separate promotional articles, and note the so-called """"Controversies"""" in several of them, which are just the imagined complaints of a few TV viewers supposedly outraged about their language being excluded""" Deletion of What Are We Waiting For WP:ATD||WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12014 2319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JMU Party Posse User:Jjjsixsix 23:10, 21 May 2006 (UTC) delete basically a club, and maybe (for things made in school one day Deletion of JMU Party Posse WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12015 7424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Able and Baker (5th nomination) User:Starblind 18:52, 14 January 2007 (UTC) delete no change of vote) there's still no sources, so problems with , , and still exist. I'm inclined to think that if after all this time and effort no sources have been found, it's probably because they don't exist. It certainly isn't due to lack of attention to the article Deletion of Able and Baker (5th nomination) WP:V||WP:RS||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12016 17990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albany Records User:Bearian 00:40, 25 January 2010 (UTC) keep It is |certainly notable in Albany, New York, where I live, and has produced CDs by Albany Symphony Orchestra and live shows at the Saratoga Performing Arts Center. Peter Kermani is a big socialite here in Upstate New York, but not notable by himself. I'm not sure whether there's notabilty nationally. In any case, this stub needs ''a lot'' of work. Please give me and the WikiProject:Capital District a few days to attempt to rescue it. If not, then it goes Deletion of Albany Records WP:BARE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12017 18813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of Israeli nationality User:Icewhiz 17:09, 20 November 2018 (UTC) delete draftify also possibly if someone wants to work on this, though I don't think the present article is much use). As I https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:History_of_Israeli_nationality&diff=853124766&oldid=815574886 commented on the talk page in a merge proposal - the topic itself clearly has merit as a standalone topic. However, the contents of this article as it stands is a summary/copy-paste of other articles in Wikipedia from 2007 and is very poorly developed - as such it is a (and out of date one no less) and a dose of is in order Deletion of History of Israeli nationality WP:REDUNDANTFORK||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Content forking 33
12018 17318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Blair, Minister User:Tony164 NONE keep """as I have checked The only criteria that might possibly apply is the one forbidding formless collections of information. These all relate to the the sometimes tempestuous history of a significant parish in Scotland (meaning the people and events are well in the mainstream of Scottish history and not replicated elsewhere). In that, they give exemplary life to broader treatments elsewhere. John Robertson and James Meek wrote siginificant historical documents - still consulted today. Others to be added have had similar significant impact on the history of Scotland in turbulent times. The others you mention (Blair, Houston, Calderwood) are I admit there to fill in the historical record, but this is not formless or meaningless. I have not yet tracked down the criteria for """"notability"""" and will have to take your advice on this, but I would have thought that the sharing of this sort of well established historical knowledge is just what Wikipedia does best. I appreciate not everyone is interested in history, especially local history, but loads are. It's not all pub quiz material! — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of Robert Blair, Minister WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12019 23 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ihar Dolbik User:Fosse8 10:29, 1 June 2016 (UTC) delete Lack of coverage in reliable third-party sources beyond routine reporting of results; nowhere near enough to establish individual notability per the GNG. Regarding the point on other similar articles, if those also have similar problems establishing notability and verifiability then they should be nominated too Deletion of Ihar Dolbik WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12020 5177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dominic McDowall-Thomas User:timtempleton 00:13, 23 August 2018 (UTC) delete co-founded the second incarnation of a single company that is just barely notable itself, and doesn't have much media coverage. Anyone else notice that the first two sentences say he's known for two different unrelated things? Fails Deletion of Dominic McDowall-Thomas WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12021 9811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Paul Jose User:Purosinaloense 11:51, 15 May 2021 (UTC) delete Fails , lacks news coverage Deletion of John Paul Jose WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12022 9607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rickshawala (1993 film) User:Newshunter12 03:13, 28 April 2019 (UTC) delete This article fails and because it lacks sufficient or any real coverage at all except that it exists. There is nothing any editor could do to make this article have a place on Wikipedia, as the coverage just isn't there Deletion of Rickshawala (1993 film) WP:GNG||WP:NFILM||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12023 14454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyr (journal) User:Kathryn 22:22, 6 December 2007 (UTC) comment Looking over the article, it seems to me to have some outside sources. I would like to see more sourcing on the earlier sections of the article, but as these seem to largely be statements from the journal or editors themselves, I don't think sourcing statements of self-definition from the journal itself is particularly controversial. There are certainly notable contributors. In terms of WP notability, I would say the low number of issues combined with the high profile of the contributors and the very high page count for a journal makes it more analagous to a pretty sizable anthology (book). We do not have a WP article on every anthology published. However, 718 pages by these particular contributors seems notable to me, particularly in a field where there aren't yet many publications. I don't have personal knowledge of how influential this journal was, but I would tend to assume it had an impact, and will continue to if they produce more issues. What troubles me about this AfD is that it is emerging from an edit war and content dispute. It doesn't look good when someone edit wars for a particular perspective in an article, and then nominates the article for deletion when consensus doesn't go their way. On that fact alone, I'd say this is a nomination. Combine that with the probability that the journal is notable in the field, and I'd say this is a keep Deletion of Tyr (journal) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
12024 10690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Search2.net (2nd nomination) User:WikiDan61 12:25, 30 November 2011 (UTC) delete """I had nominated this page for speedy deletion for #A7|notability but that was declined with the note that there is a """"credible claim of notability"""". I don't know what that credible claim might be. The only tenuous claim to notability is the site's size (5 million sites indexed), but this is a really thin claim to notability, and cannot be verified. If the site claimed 5 million users (which would represent a significant portion of its home country's (Israel) population), that would be something""" Deletion of Search2.net (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12025 12868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leroy Jethro Gibbs (3rd nomination) NONE NONE keep """and clean up! - Far from """"consisting entirely of fancruft"""", as indicated by the nominator, these articles contain quite a lot of encyclopaedic, biographical information. If these articles were Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons|biographies of living persons, instead of """"biographies of fictional persons"""" we'd be praising them because of the amount of information that they contain. All of the articles are about the lead characters of a highly rated television series that, to date, has been running for over 6.5 years and has aired 157 episodes in NCIS (TV series)#International distribution|at least 39 countries. The characters are clearly notable from that alone. may say that when an article is created, the subject's real-world notability should be established but that's really irrelevant because we're well beyond that. The article has been created, kept as the result of an AfD, nominated again, kept as the result of another AfD,http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Leroy_Jethro_Gibbs&action=historysubmit&diff=255539184&oldid=255538183 redirected against consensus, (ironically by the same editor who removed the AfD notice)http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Leroy_Jethro_Gibbs&action=historysubmit&diff=255605453&oldid=255539184 was then the result of a massive redirect/unredirect edit war.http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Leroy_Jethro_Gibbs&action=historysubmit&diff=272445946&oldid=255605453 It was finally rebuilt and then worked on for well over a year before it was again redirected against consensus with questionable justification,http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Leroy_Jethro_Gibbs&action=historysubmit&diff=357548345&oldid=357415135 After reversion of that it was then nominated again and that's where we are now, well beyond the point where the statement was relevant""" Deletion of Leroy Jethro Gibbs (3rd nomination) WP:WAF||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
12026 11491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/English words with uncommon properties User:Thibbs 23:30, 1 November 2011 (UTC) keep """per alf.laylah.wa.laylah. I've worked on several lists like this and so I appreciate the arguments by LSC and I have a strong distaste for """"|unbounded lists"""". Nevertheless, when the topic is notable then I find that strict editing is the best solution in the end, not deletion. The examples in this article have been the subjects of numerous logological puzzles and challenges through the years. Many have appeared in print and in reliable sources. I consider this article to be the linguist's analog to mathematical puzzle - another rough list of recreational applications that have appeared in the RSes within the field of math""" Deletion of English words with uncommon properties WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12027 5442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Brown (accused murderer) User:Racklever 15:44, 25 January 2011 (UTC) keep The person is notable as their case has been mentioned in many newspapers. Deletion of Jordan Brown (accused murderer) WP:COMMONSENSE "Wikipedia:What ""Ignore all rules"" means" 62
12028 2380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Youngtron User:The 15:16, 9 September 2006 (UTC) delete as failing as |non notable Deletion of Youngtron WP:CORP||WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12029 19840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruneau (restaurant) User:The 04:25, 8 December 2017 (UTC) keep There is enough here that can be satisfied Deletion of Bruneau (restaurant) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12030 9007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giri (Sanskrit) User:Ihcoyc 15:43, 6 August 2007 (UTC) keep This article, |referenced to what looks like to be |reliable sources, explains one of the epithets of Krishna and a Sanskrit honorific. That strikes me as meeting any reasonable notability requirements and #PAPER|Wikipedia is '''''still''''' not paper. When the Big Hard Drive gets to be 98% full, we might consider deleting some Sanskrit titles that |only Sanksrit speakers know about, but that time has not yet come Deletion of Giri (Sanskrit) WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NOT||WP:IDONTKNOWIT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12031 8039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Argument from fallacy User:Bearian 02:21, 27 October 2009 (UTC) keep used by http://scholar.google.com/scholar?&q=%22Argument+from+fallacy%22 at least by a few scholarly works. |This is an easy rescue Deletion of Argument from fallacy WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
12032 745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diary Of A Wimpy Kid: The Worst Summer Ever [[User talk:68.219.240.190|talk]]) 13:48, 18 September 2010 (UTC) delete per G3. Pure nonsense. -Special:Contributions/68.219.240.190|68.219.240.190 Deletion of Diary Of A Wimpy Kid: The Worst Summer Ever WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12033 2468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Calvins Masawa User:GiantSnowman 20:16, 17 January 2020 (UTC) delete fails (lack of significant coverage - needs to be more than routine/trivial pieces about injuries and transfers etc.) and (has not played in a |fully-professional league or for the national team Deletion of Calvins Masawa WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12034 21094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ma timi bina marihalchhu User:PC78 16:24, 31 July 2008 (UTC) delete Google search reveals little, but having no knowledge whatsoever of Nepalese cinema, this could easily be a case of |systematic bias Deletion of Ma timi bina marihalchhu WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
12035 1825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suphat Onthong User:GiantSnowman 11:42, 4 July 2009 (UTC) delete per nom; non-notable player who fails Deletion of Suphat Onthong WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12036 19589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ndukwe Onuoha User:Less 16:09, 9 October 2020 (UTC) delete Fails . There's no significant coverage to indicate notability Deletion of Ndukwe Onuoha WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12037 14717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Tabar User:Otr500 06:28, 29 January 2018 (UTC) delete """Per nom. |Refbombing thirteen references at the end of a sentence in the lead does not advance . According to the ABA there are 1.1 million licensed attorneys in the United States alone so nothing """"special"""" about this person to warrant an article""" Deletion of Sam Tabar WP:REFBOMB||WP:notability Wikipedia:Citation overkill 60
12038 2968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Yozamp User:Clarityfiend 06:16, 5 September 2017 (UTC) delete One non-starring credit? C'mon. Way Deletion of Elizabeth Yozamp WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
12039 21721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sony Ericsson W600 User:EJF 21:09, 1 January 2008 (UTC) keep notably the first Walkman phone by Sony. Article meets the 3 core content policies , and . On another point I think perhaps taking the mobile phones issue up to policy level may be a better way of getting things done, or perhaps a mass AfD. Also is '''not a guideline''' is '''not a policy''' and is just a point of view Deletion of Sony Ericsson W600 WP:NOR||WP:NPOV||WP:V||WP:WAX Wikipedia:No original research 65
12040 20346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1660 Safed massacre User:Jonathanwallace 06:41, 31 March 2011 (UTC) comment """by nominator. I would argue Peters is not a reliable source. At last no controversial assertion of historical fact should be sourced solely to Peters. (From our article on From Time Immemorial citing a 1985 NY Times article: """"Israeli historian Yehoshua Porath described the book as a """"sheer forgery,"""" stating that """"in Israel, at least, the book was almost universally dismissed as sheer rubbish except maybe as a propaganda weapon."""") Nor could I find other reliable sources saying there was a massacre in Safed in 1660. Scholem, a reliable source, says there wasn't. says, """"Material must be attributable to a source with a reputation for fact-checking and accuracy, which is appropriate for the claim being made."""" Peters doesn't qualify, so we have no such source to support the article""" Deletion of 1660 Safed massacre WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12041 5284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WotWentWrong User:Northamerica1000 21:43, 20 December 2013 (UTC) keep Meets . Source examples include: http://abcnews.go.com/Health/singles-dating-website-lets-called-back/story?id=15683556#.T88e9rS6SuK ABC News, http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2012/05/30/why-people-break-up_n_1556032.html?just_reloaded=1 Huffington Post, http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/02/06/us-app-romance-breakup-idUSTRE81513420120206 Reuters Deletion of WotWentWrong WP:WEBCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12042 14049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathan L. Henry User:Qworty 20:10, 19 February 2012 (UTC) delete Non-notable writer. Fails and . Reads like Deletion of Nathan L. Henry WP:AUTHOR||WP:BK||WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12043 10178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PlanetFurry User:Isotope23 19:22, 4 April 2006 (UTC) delete per criteria... and Swatjester, try to be a bit more when nominating articles. Citing reasons for deletion is sufficent Deletion of PlanetFurry WP:WEB||WP:CIVIL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12044 8169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LinuxQuestions.org (2nd nomination) User:Dark 22:50, 31 July 2006 (UTC) keep """per . """"Not notable"""" with an Alexa rank of 5,258? That's quite a laugh""" Deletion of LinuxQuestions.org (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12045 13049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cradle Song (1981 film) User:Forest90 12:21, 20 July 2019 (UTC) delete the article. As above the article fails , |reliable source and Deletion of Cradle Song (1981 film) WP:NFILM||WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12046 17355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yang Wen-li User:Quasirandom 20:03, 15 September 2008 (UTC) merge per common consensus and to List of Legend of the Galactic Heroes characters, which needs the material anyway Deletion of Yang Wen-li WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
12047 21942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrea Jennifer Shubert User:Namcokid47 22:23, 28 August 2020 (UTC) delete for failing Deletion of Andrea Jennifer Shubert WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12048 12167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Code Lyoko around the world [[User talk:Treelo|treelo]] [[Special:Contributions/Treelo|radda]] 09:23, 26 September 2008 (UTC) delete per #G5, tagged jus' li' that Deletion of Code Lyoko around the world WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12049 7146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IPhone SE (2020) User:Lightburst 02:30, 4 April 2020 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON Deletion of IPhone SE (2020) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12050 8699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Gooderham and Maxine Arnold User:Corpx 02:39, 26 July 2007 (UTC) delete per #NEWS - No historic notability Deletion of Terry Gooderham and Maxine Arnold WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12051 3699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/North America (Americas) User:Haemo 00:21, 3 March 2007 (UTC) delete contains no useful material that could not be merged into North America, and appears to simply advance one POV in an academic argument. Also, the violations are really offensive, and degrade the Encyclopedia. Anyone engaging in such practices should be ashamed Deletion of North America (Americas) WP:CANVASS Wikipedia:Canvassing 93
12052 5313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Occupations of the future User:Silly 14:19, 6 February 2009 (UTC) delete This falls squarely under and Deletion of Occupations of the future WP:CRYSTAL||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12053 17240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Rogers (politician) User:Carrite 04:42, 4 December 2011 (UTC) keep """Individual politician bios are not peas from a single pod and should not be nominatable by group as """"similar articles."""" Each case is different and they should be all brought up on their own merits after is followed by the nominator""" Deletion of Jim Rogers (politician) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
12054 5598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tove Jensen (2nd nomination) User:Gene93k 21:03, 5 March 2008 (UTC) delete per . Tove has been a widely known porn legend for 30 years, but I have never seen anything about her from a credible source. Aside from a small, but memorable body of work, there are few facts and stories conflict Deletion of Tove Jensen (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12055 203 [[Alfred J. Gertler]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Zenwort 15:13, 20. Jun. 2013 (CEST) keep Bundeverdienstkreuz reicht nach alleine schon aus, daher auch wenn sonst ziemlich mager. (Vielleicht zeit die RK zu verschärfen Löschung von Alfred J. Gertler Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12056 12726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bawesome User:Tokyogirl79 09:39, 8 August 2012 (UTC) delete I can see where it's in use but usage does not mean notability per . There are no sources that I could find that would be considered reliable sources that cover the origin and usage of bawesome. This just isn't notable enough for Wikipedia at this point in time Deletion of Bawesome WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
12057 14117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hans the Werewolf User:Stifle 09:03, 25 September 2008 (UTC) delete due to the lack of accessible, |reliable sources. Just saying they exist isn't good enough Deletion of Hans the Werewolf WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12058 19088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Vanneman User:The 17:14, 1 May 2019 (UTC) delete since subject fails . On some rare occasions, |kamikaze accounts create worthwhile Wikipedia articles. This is not one of them Deletion of Alan Vanneman WP:NAUTHOR||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Notability 77
12059 18630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Ravnsborg User:Gaarmyvet 19:59, 31 May 2017 (UTC) delete Definitely does not meet . He would have to rise much higher in politics to meet and fails Deletion of Jason Ravnsborg WP:SOLDIER||WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12060 4204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mr. Moseby (2nd nomination) User:Jontesta 15:11, 22 August 2020 (UTC) delete after a review of the sources. There are some questoins of whether Mr. Moseby is a racial stereotype, but nothing enough to establish the of the character, and really more about racial representation in children's programming as a whole. In the sources he's cited as a brief example in a much wider conversation about representation, when we really need more to explain this character's real world reception overall Deletion of Mr. Moseby (2nd nomination) WP:NOTABILITY||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12061 18229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ken Goldstein (2nd nomination) User:AkankshaG 16:53, 20 December 2010 (UTC) keep Subject has been covered in Variety Magazine, Coco Eco Magazine, X Media Lab, and Juxtapoz Magazine, all of which are independent of the subject of the article and are independently edited, meeting the requirements of and otability (people). Note: There seems to be some confusion -- the Ken Goldstein mentioned in the previous nomination is a former vice presidential candidate, not this person Deletion of Ken Goldstein (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12062 11547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wikipedia on The Colbert Report User:jonny 08:32, 13 November 2007 (UTC) delete per , , and the above. Any chance of taking the current version of the article meta, say to Deletion of Wikipedia on The Colbert Report WP:NOR||WP:N||WP:HUMOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12063 6424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allie Jablon User:IslaySolomon 22:41, 5 July 2006 (UTC) keep """per . She probably just scarpes: ''""""television personalities who have appeared in well-known films or television productions""""'', plus there is a precedent of other Apprentice contestants having their own articles. Google hits are mediocore http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Allie+Jablon%22&btnG=Google+Search at best and I'm on the wrong side of the pond to judge """"name recognition""" Deletion of Allie Jablon WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12064 14352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jérémy Hélan User:97198 12:58, 11 June 2008 (UTC) delete as failing Deletion of Jérémy Hélan WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12065 21150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Armando Villarreal User:USA 20:00, 24 November 2015 (UTC) keep This idea that MLS referees shouldn't have pages in absurd. Every BPL referee has a page that is acceptable in terms of . The MLS and BPL are both full professional leagues, so why the double standard Deletion of Armando Villarreal WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12066 7246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lumenergi User:RightCowLeftCoast 03:54, 19 June 2011 (UTC) delete There is some mention in multiple reliable news sources, but none that appear to be significant coverage to pass Deletion of Lumenergi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12067 17104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Kolar User:Hughesdarren 03:45, 23 November 2019 (UTC) delete certainly fails or needs far more reliable sources if it is ever to leave draftspace Deletion of Ryan Kolar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12068 11087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kammron Taylor User:Bagumba 22:58, 25 February 2014 (UTC) keep I also found and added significant coverage from http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/09/sports/ncaabasketball/09wisconsin.html The New York Times and http://www.jsonline.com/sports/badgers/29182714.html Journal Sentinel. Meets with significant coverage from multiple independent sources Deletion of Kammron Taylor WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12069 11015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Who i am and what i want (book) User:Gongshow 16:19, 31 March 2013 (UTC) delete lots of GHits but I'm not finding anything that would indicate this satisfies or Deletion of Who i am and what i want (book) WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12070 4908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Duntsch user:Andrew 14:48, 17 February 2017 (UTC) keep The subject is covered in multiple books over several years including ''https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=EJf1DAAAQBAJ&pg=PT116 The Remarkable Case of Dr Christopher Duntsch'' and ''https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=EJf1DAAAQBAJ&pg=PT116 The Truth About Big Medicine''. There are multiple events here and ample coverage per Deletion of Christopher Duntsch WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12071 17532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kovilthottam Church User:Oakshade 23:22, 19 July 2014 (UTC) keep The management of WP is strongly encouraging us to edit and improve monuments articles with the https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Wikipedia_Summer_of_Monuments Summer of Monuments initiative. If the church dates from the 1700's, it's likely notable and would certainly be no question of its notability if this were in the US. Does the initiative |not apply to India Deletion of Kovilthottam Church WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
12072 2254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gav Richards User:ArcAngel 21:17, 2 March 2008 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Gav Richards WP:N||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
12073 2833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Group 90 User:Dream 03:51, 13 September 2011 (UTC) keep Has done exhibitions at notable galleries. 4b has been met Deletion of Group 90 WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
12074 3662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tomer Aviram User:TheGreatWikiLord 03:34, 11 October 2018 (UTC) delete fails per nom. May one day meet guidelines for notability, but not today Deletion of Tomer Aviram WP:DIRECTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12075 21049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticism of the 2019 Hong Kong anti-extradition bill protests User:Citobun 07:31, 4 September 2019 (UTC) delete as and . Most of the content is simply an arbitrary list of events Deletion of Criticism of the 2019 Hong Kong anti-extradition bill protests WP:POVFORK||WP:OR Wikipedia:Content forking 33
12076 16888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disney Mothers User:Bearian 22:37, 26 March 2008 (UTC) keep and re-title, per , . Much improved, better sourced, scholarly and popular interest Deletion of Disney Mothers WP:HEY||WP:RS Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
12077 12605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plebs Association of Law Teachers User:Qasaur 18:31, 15 June 2015 (UTC) delete As the requestor stated, the website seems entirely new and lacks in any kind of information. Not to mention the lack of any coverage on notable and |reliable sources Deletion of Plebs Association of Law Teachers WP:RELIABLE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12078 7480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DART First State New Castle County bus routes User:Rusf10 22:32, 5 May 2021 (UTC) delete As per . Usefulness is irrelevant. What is equally as useful though would be placing a link to the bus schedule website within the main article about the bus system Deletion of DART First State New Castle County bus routes WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12079 11375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Viktoh [[User talk:Music Boy50|(talk to me)]] 21:00, 10 November 2016 (UTC) delete """Fails and . can""""t find any reliable source here --Music Boy""" Deletion of Viktoh WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12080 2932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Little Red Riding Hood (Disney) User:MichaelQSchmidt 06:35, 6 April 2010 (UTC) keep of a film that easily meets through its significance to cinematic history, and it still being written of nearly 90 years after its release for its historical context to the film industry, Walt Disney, Rudolf Ising, and early silent animation. |Notable since 1922 is still notable in 2010. And to the nom... and with respects... sourcing was quite easy to find in both http://books.google.com/books?ei=CLK6S-08iuz1BJemuO0H&ct=result&q=%22Little+Red+Riding+Hood%22+Disney&btnG=Search+Books books and http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&tbo=p&tbs=nws%3A1&q=%22Little+Red+Riding+Hood%22%2C+Disney&btnG=Search&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai= news Deletion of Little Red Riding Hood (Disney) WP:NF||WP:NOTTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12081 3635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kohana (web framework) (3rd nomination) User:Whpq 16:37, 3 August 2011 (UTC) delete Lacks the significant coverage in independent reliable sources to meet |Wikipedia's inclusion guidelines Deletion of Kohana (web framework) (3rd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12082 5547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chittagong City Center User:আফত 23:59, 1 August 2021 (UTC) delete per User:力, also there is no Deletion of Chittagong City Center WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12083 15430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/West Corporation User:Orlady 16:35, 17 February 2011 (UTC) keep I did a little research with the aim of finding new sources to expand the article. I added one other third-party reference and I found some West subsidiaries and corporate acquisitions, at least two of which had separate Wikipedia articles (and at least one of which was a publicly traded company before being acquired by West). I figure that the fact that I had never heard of this company is mostly a result of its using a plain-vanilla name; it seems to be a very large business operating with a lot of other brand names. It looks to me like a WP:notable business, and the stubbification of the article has resolved the issues that seem to have inspired this AfD Deletion of West Corporation WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12084 15600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Dorman (broadcaster) User:Niteshift36 19:02, 31 December 2009 (UTC) delete Fails or . Take your pick Deletion of Lee Dorman (broadcaster) WP:AUTHOR||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12085 9343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative theories regarding Hurricane Katrina (2nd nomination) User:Wronkiew 05:02, 22 October 2008 (UTC) keep Probably better to keep it, as it does satisfy and the NPOV problems are not severe enough to smite it. The article should be renamed to something more encyclopedic, but I don't have a better idea than the current title Deletion of Alternative theories regarding Hurricane Katrina (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12086 7182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canadian Voices (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 17:30, 25 June 2021 (UTC) delete """Previous discussion was closed """"no consensus"""", almost entirely because of a single person who argued that BCAST criteria were met while completely ignoring the fact that passing BCAST isn't a matter of ''saying'' that the topic passes BCAST, but of the quality and depth of the |reliable sources that can or can't be shown to ''independently verify'' that the topic passes BCAST. Notability-supporting coverage was lacking the first time, and hasn't improved since""" Deletion of Canadian Voices (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12087 12850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Durga Nanda Jha User:Cricketgirl 08:46, 31 May 2008 (UTC) comment """I still don't see proof of notability here. """"nominal Ghits are Wikipedia mirrors"""" - I know that Ghits are not the be all and end all - but usually they are a decent measuring stick. My comment about """"last substantive edit"""" was to indicate that the article's creator appears to have abandoned it, not as a """"we should delete this because it isn't active"""". If someone edits the article to show notability (and preferably references it) I will gladly withdraw the nomination. But last time I checked, failing was a pretty good reason for deletion""" Deletion of Durga Nanda Jha WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12088 13692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Barnett User:Papaursa 20:32, 3 November 2013 (UTC) delete Fails to meet Deletion of Chris Barnett WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
12089 5135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sosumi User:Green 18:39, 8 October 2013 (UTC) keep """I expanded the article. Per , the """"topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject"""". Two books, four newspapers (there are more in NewsBank), a couple reliable websites. One source called it a """"classic sound"""". It has influenced other works, including appearing in a major film""" Deletion of Sosumi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12090 5405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Saffron Swastika NONE NONE delete against ,also seems heavily dependent on qoutation by one news against wiki:NEWS Deletion of The Saffron Swastika WP:BKCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12091 2095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tomáš Bučič User:INeedSupport 16:35, 10 May 2019 (UTC) delete Agree with OP. Fails on all categories Deletion of Tomáš Bučič WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12092 12381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Nuestra Belleza México states User:Omni 10:23, 3 May 2016 (UTC) delete Clearly a blatant violation of |no original research, especially considering the entire article is an unreferenced list Deletion of List of Nuestra Belleza México states WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12093 21503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jasmine Mai User:Vartanza 05:22, 1 June 2009 (UTC) delete Agreed that she doesn't pass or Deletion of Jasmine Mai WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12094 6636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cherry Poppens User:Edtropolis 14:16, 12 June 2007 (UTC) delete as per otability. Haven't heard of this person. Is she a fictional parody of the fictional character Mary Poppins Deletion of Cherry Poppens WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12095 16854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Illuminati X (3rd nomination) User:Bearcat 13:55, 29 August 2018 (UTC) delete Nothing here passes any criterion, and the sources aren't reliable ones for the purposes of getting them over Deletion of Illuminati X (3rd nomination) WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12096 12588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barbary Coast Trail User:Northamerica1000 13:19, 19 March 2013 (UTC) keep This topic entirely passes Deletion of Barbary Coast Trail WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12097 62 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticism of the Anti-Defamation League User:Cobaltbluetony 17:34, 15 June 2009 (UTC) keep In line with articles like Controversies regarding Jehovah's Witnesses, it makes sense to take a large amount of significant criticism to its own article, because it really does seem to be an unwieldy subtopic. Not too happy with the suggestion that the creator exhibited |bad faith through POV-forking. - Deletion of Criticism of the Anti-Defamation League WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
12098 15783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John E. Pike User:ArcAngel 19:39, 1 March 2008 (UTC) delete Per . Security consultants aren't usually famous, since they like to work so that others are unaware of them even being there. Therefore this person, to me, isn't that notable outside of the field he works in Deletion of John E. Pike WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12099 17165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William R. Gruber (2nd nomination) User:Necrothesp 13:04, 14 August 2020 (UTC) keep Clearly notable per , which is generally held as being the standard notability guideline for general officers (despite its status as an essay Deletion of William R. Gruber (2nd nomination) WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
12100 10608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tile Factory Outlet User:AllyD 06:37, 10 June 2015 (UTC) delete A firm going about its business but no |evidence of |notability provided or found. (Searches turn up multiple false matches on similarly named businesses in the same field across the world Deletion of Tile Factory Outlet :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12101 433 [[Julian Hessenthaler]] (SLA) Benutzer:KurtR NONE delete gestellt, da Name in keinem Qualitätsmedium genannt wird, Persönlichkeitsrechtsverletzung, beachten Löschung von Julian Hessenthaler Wikipedia:BIO Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12102 11372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rafael Leão User:ArcAngel 20:16, 5 September 2011 (UTC) delete Hmmm...is it |snowing Deletion of Rafael Leão WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
12103 5965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Civmec (2nd nomination) User:HighKing 19:23, 9 January 2021 (UTC) comment Press Releases and company announcements do not meet the criteria for establishing notability as per Deletion of Civmec (2nd nomination) WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12104 4527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of The Kapil Sharma Show episodes (2nd nomination) User:Mrschimpf 05:10, 1 February 2017 (UTC) keep """This nomination is entirely confusing in structure; you look at the 'list of's presented thinking they're bundled nominations, but they're '''expired''' nominations, trying to muddle the pool towards a delete by throwing random nominations out that are merely related by airing on Indian television. That's not how this works. Meanwhile on the '''actual''' topic of the AfD I'm seeing something sourced by multiple different sources and a lot of ing by the nominator just for the sole reason of them being """"promotional newbies"""", which immediately bends me towards an automatic keep (especially based on your previous history of weak-reasoned AfD's regarding Indian television topics). Clean up this nom, don't attack other editors (no matter if they have 1 or 100,000 edits) and use the proper way of presenting it; as it is this is just a solution looking for a problem (and use other avenues like before coming to AfD""" Deletion of List of The Kapil Sharma Show episodes (2nd nomination) WP:BITE||WP:RFP Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
12105 16081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Greatest Game Ever Played (disambiguation) User:Labattblueboy 21:39, 16 December 2009 (UTC) delete This is a dab page about a generic phrase. If someone is interested in developing a list called List of Greatest Games Ever Played with that would be great and far more appropriate. However, this is not currently a dab. page as in intended by , it's a very poor list that is unsupported Deletion of The Greatest Game Ever Played (disambiguation) WP:RS||WP:NCDAB Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12106 21413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solicitor General of Washington User:Chetsford 10:09, 10 January 2019 (UTC) delete I've just spent the better part of a half-hour searching for sources and can find nothing. Indeed, if it weren't for the coverage about Purcell himself and the OSG's own website, there would be no evidence this position even existed. It doesn't even appear to be an office codified under the Revised Code of Washington, but rather is an administrative creation. It doesn't have inherent notability under and certainly doesn't pass the GNG. (For the record, I oppose a redirect to Purcell since he is not Solicitor-General-for-Life Deletion of Solicitor General of Washington WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12107 1689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/To Court the King User:Skeletor3000 19:30, 22 January 2020 (UTC) comment I agree that the award nominations and Games of Tradition review are not enough on their own, for reasons outlined by Beemer69. I'm still curious about the cited Games Magazine article, but even if it meets , we still need multiple instances of significant coverage Deletion of To Court the King WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12108 2084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blue Bee User:AllyD 06:32, 11 July 2015 (UTC) delete No |evidence found from searches on Google, Highbeam, Questia or Guardian that this firm has attained |notability Deletion of Blue Bee :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12109 15877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James J. Devine User:Clarityfiend 22:38, 2 April 2015 (UTC) delete as a local, unelected politician who fails and Deletion of James J. Devine WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12110 8743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 Texas pool party incident User:Edison 19:50, 16 June 2015 (UTC) keep """Nationwide coverage continues, rather than it fading out after a day as some editors' crystal balls told them it would do. See https://news.google.com/news/story?ncl=ddvdhHKKNPd6IOMOeF5EA4ZM319FM&q=mckinney+casebolt&lr=English&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CCoQqgIwAGoVChMIrrHbpvyUxgIVCgOsCh1XyACM today's Google news coverage from numerous US states of the prosecutor's request that the Texas Rangers investigate the incident. The Dallas Morning News http://www.dallasnews.com/news/community-news/mckinney/headlines/20150615-texas-rangers-asked-to-investigate-mckinney-pool-party-incident.ece said today """"Video of Casebolt’s role in breaking up the party in the Craig Ranch neighborhood flung McKinney into a national debate about race and police relations"""" This shows that the event had the required """"impact."""" . Satisfies and OTNEWS""" Deletion of 2015 Texas pool party incident WP:N||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12111 6957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Detroit Tigers minor league players (3rd nomination) User:Edison 16:20, 5 November 2014 (UTC) delete """This list may indeed be interesting and useful for fans, but since many of the individuals lack the references needed to establish notability by Wikipedia standards, this and similar lists violate the guideline , which says in part: """"A person may be included in a list of people if all the following requirements are met: The person meets the Wikipedia notability requirement...."""" Having a list of bios of nonnotable minor league baseball players is similar to including nonnotable residents of some town in the article about the town, or nonnotable alumni of a college in the article about the college. Wikipedia is |not a directory. There are other places on the internet where fans can look up the present roster of a minor league team. The team being notable does not justify having an article which is a directory of all its nonnotable members, any more than a college being notable justifies having a list of all its alumni, students or faculty. The only argument which has any traction would be an """"ignore all rules"""" justification that these lists are a way to avoid having articles about all the individual nonnotable players""" Deletion of Detroit Tigers minor league players (3rd nomination) WP:LISTPEOPLE||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
12112 16836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Chalets User:Teemu08 05:56, 5 October 2006 (UTC) keep meets Deletion of The Chalets WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12113 6343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wiggle Ltd NONE NONE keep seems fairly notable, with a lot of good secondary coverage online from Deletion of Wiggle Ltd WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12114 2989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Junaid Azim Mattu User:Iamreallygoodatcheckers 06:26, 16 February 2020 (UTC) keep """per . He is the mayor of a city with 1,800,000 people, and that city is capital of the territory. The city he is mayor should fall under """"regional prominence"""" stated in POLOUTCOMES""" Deletion of Junaid Azim Mattu WP:POLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12115 4404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Levinson ML-3 User:Inkpaduta 15:53, 8 February 2007 (UTC) comment """Photographs exist of a great many things that are not notable ebough for Wikipedia articles. Wikipedia's notability policy and reliable source policy require that something has been the subject of multiple nontrivial coverage in independent and reliable sources. The fansite listing equipment made by the company is neither of those. """"IT IS HARMLESS"""" is not a valid reason for keeping an article about a piece of audio eequipment if it was not notable in its time. Perhaps someone can dig up a couple of reviews in an audio magazines from the days when it was for sale. That would help. Otherwise the articlew should be deleted""" Deletion of Mark Levinson ML-3 WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12116 1899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herbert Cecil Potter User:Bejnar 07:43, 22 September 2014 (UTC) keep Potter was a Brigadier-General, and was awarded both the CMG and the DSO. Seems to meet Deletion of Herbert Cecil Potter WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
12117 20583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oscar Hernandez (politician) User:Bearcat 23:52, 29 February 2020 (UTC) merge per nom; Bell CA is a small town which cannot hand all of its mayors an automatic inclusion freebie just because they exist, and three of the six footnotes here are |primary sources that are not support for notability, while the three that are real media are all covering him in the context of a single incident that just makes him a rather than a topic of enduring encyclopedic interest in his own right. That said, Buidhe is correct that you don't need AFD's permission to redirect it to the event article — you can just do it unilaterally, as long as your edit summary explains your actions. AFD can certainly be asked to weigh in later on if somebody ''opposes'' you on it afterward, but doesn't have to weigh in before you're allowed to act the first time Deletion of Oscar Hernandez (politician) WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:No original research 65
12118 134 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Tolga Görsev Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 21:22, 11 Şubat 2016 (UTC) comment Değerlendirmeleriniz ve zamanınız için teşekkürler. Aldığı ödüller ve diskografisi yönünden kriterlerinde besteciler için tanımlanmış maddelerden birden fazlasını karşıladığını düşündüm. Kriterlerde aranjörler ve yapımcılar için bir başlık yok, bu sebeple besteciler için tanımlı kriterler geçerli olmalı. Kaynakçada ilk sırada bulunan Discogs bağlantısındaki diskografi detaylarında görülebileceği gibi Candan Erçetin ve Teoman için yaptığı çalışmalarla dahi besteciler için tanımlı kriterlerden ilki, dolayısıyla müzisyenler için tanımlı kriterlerden dördüncüsünü sağlayabileceğini düşünüyorum. Albüm kartonetleri de koleksiyonumda mevcut, gerekli görülürse ismin geçtiği bölümleri paylaşabilirim. Saygılar. --Kullanıcı mesaj:Kozmolog|Kozmolog Tolga Görsev'in silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
12119 1026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indus Center for Academic Excellence User:CRGreathouse 05:03, 5 June 2008 (UTC) delete appears to fail and Deletion of Indus Center for Academic Excellence WP:ORG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
12120 19338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kammron Taylor User:Rikster2 19:09, 25 February 2014 (UTC) delete But because the subject fails in addition to NBASKETBALL Deletion of Kammron Taylor WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12121 15658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathan Williams (American football) User:Paulmcdonald 11:29, 31 October 2013 (UTC) keep according to this simple https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Nathan+Williams+%28American+football%29%22&tbm=nws&tbs=ar:1#q=%2B%22Nathan+Williams%22+%2Bfootball+%2Bohio&start=10&tbm=nws&tbs=ar:1 web search there appear to be many, many newsworthy articles mentioning the subject. At this volume of content there is clear interest in the individual and clearly passes Deletion of Nathan Williams (American football) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12122 17100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Trek 2 (2013 film) User:IndigoAK200 14:06, 25 November 2011 (UTC) keep If we follow and delete this article, it's just going to be recreated in two months by somebody who watched the calendar like a hawk for when principle photography began. Deleting this article would be both wasting the time of whomever has already worked on this article and potentially wasting the time of whomever works on the article if it has to be recreated sixty days from now. Also, the odds of something happening in the next sixty days that completely cancels this project is slim to none Deletion of Star Trek 2 (2013 film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12123 6788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loomia (2nd nomination) User:AllyD 16:03, 14 December 2018 (UTC) delete There has been some recent to-and-fro changing of the article to change focus from its original subject (the defunct San Francisco based tracking-recommendation platform) to the more recent New York based smart fabric start-up. Staying with the former, which gave rise to the longstanding notability tag: the provided references were largely routine funding and partnership announcements; the most substantial may be the Richard Becker blog entry. Searches are finding only more of the same, and nothing to provide detail on the company's demise sometime around 2010 - it seems to have sunk without being noticed. In sum, I don't see enough to demonstrate or notability. (Briefly considering the more recent start-up, while the Wired product review https://www.wired.co.uk/article/smart-materials-loomia-clothes-sensors may begin to contribute, I don't see enough to demonstrate attained notability yet - it is probably at best and the text contributed by an IP was promotional Deletion of Loomia (2nd nomination) :WP:NCORP||:WP:NWEB||:WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
12124 18683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Objects visible from space User:Timneu22 19:46, 11 May 2010 (UTC) comment At this point I'd go as far as deleting based on . &mdash Deletion of Objects visible from space WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
12125 9099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suburban Secrets (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 19:11, 13 February 2016 (UTC) keep """per due diligence showing this not-porn but adult-themed sexploitation film by Joseph W. Sarno as ''just'' meeting and . Was really |quite easy to find authored reviews at http://www.dvdverdict.com/reviews/suburbansecrets.php ''DVD Verdict''. http://10kbullets.com/reviews/suburban-secrets/ ''10k Bullets'', http://www.dantenet.com/er/ERchives/reviews/s_reviews/suburbansecrets.html ''Exploitation Retrospect'', http://www.plume-noire.com/movies/reviews/suburbansecrets.html ''Plume Noire'', and others.http://www.mrqe.com/movie_reviews/suburban-secrets-m100023685 I politely remind that since a topic's notability is found |through sources being available, '''used or not''', no article ever has to specifically say """"I am notable because"""". This simply needs editorial attention, and not deletion for a lack""" Deletion of Suburban Secrets (film) WP:GNG||WP:NF||WP:BEFORE||WP:NPOSSIBLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12126 16557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poet as well as Civil servant of Bangladesh User:Ragib 20:30, 27 September 2010 (UTC) delete per , , , Deletion of Poet as well as Civil servant of Bangladesh WP:OR||WP:RS||WP:NOT||WP:N Wikipedia:No original research 65
12127 8222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Company Folders User:Piotrus 01:50, 17 November 2015 (UTC) delete Not seeing anything beyond press-releases, niche trade journals and pure PR. Fails on a number of counts Deletion of Company Folders WP:NCOMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
12128 7362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hello Beautiful User:EdJohnston 19:08, 24 September 2008 (UTC) delete This band doesn't meet the conventional criteria of for being an important band: no national tours or well-known awards, and they are not issued by a major label. The only way they could qualify is if their press coverage puts them over the bar. I don't see the listed references as showing importance. There is no full-length review of the music listed there by anybody who I recognize as being a reliable independent reviewer Deletion of Hello Beautiful WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12129 15373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashok Kundapur User:Ashok 14:29, 24 November 2006 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet , and the article's creator Deletion of Ashok Kundapur WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12130 1824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nasalevtsi: Poor vs. Rich User:MichaelQSchmidt 20:06, 26 July 2015 (UTC) delete per (still) being |TOO SOON. It is not at surprising that an incomplete, non-English, Bulgarian film has no English language coverage, but it does have some Bulgarian-language http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3687952/literature coverage. Allow undeletion once we have release and MORE actual coverage Deletion of Nasalevtsi: Poor vs. Rich WP:NYF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
12131 10524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vinay kuyya(channel) User:SamHolt6 16:34, 16 September 2018 (UTC) delete an interesting case, but I'm opting for a delete vote. The channel has accrued coverage in , but this coverage (including the ''Times'' source, which is filed under a Hyderabad News tab) is strictly regional in regards to Hyderabad. One source (the Deccan Chronicle) is also not independent as it is based around an interview with one of the interviewers. This being said, I think should be applied here, as the channel only has '''87,000''' subscribers (TOI source says 63,000) and 20 videos (according to Mirichi9). This is a trivial amount by YouTube standards; as an editor who has created three articles about YouTube channels, the least subscribed to channel I wrote about (that of Jesse Cox (YouTuber)) has '''963,000''' subscribers, and he is considered a small to medium sized channel when compared to his contemporaries. In short, I feel it is subject that is not notable enough for an encyclopedia despite its reliable-yet-regional coverage Deletion of Vinay kuyya(channel) WP:RS||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12132 2193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Netwitness User:Bearian 22:05, 20 November 2012 (UTC) keep the ''New York Times'' article mentions the copmany in the lead. The rest of the coverage also looks |fairly deep. The article ''is'' spammy, but bad writing can be fixed through the normal editing processes, not by AfD Deletion of Netwitness WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12133 8874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Call To Action User:WikiDan61 17:20, 21 November 2014 (UTC) comment Not necessarily. The notability issue is a tricky one at Wikipedia. We're not trying to run a popularity contest. Rather, the notability requirement serves to assure the availability of |reliable sources from which to write a |verifiable article. The inclusion of Riordan in this national radio programme tells us that BBC looks to her as a source of input, but it tells us nothing at all about the organisation. We do not get any more verifiable information about the organisation from this source Deletion of A Call To Action WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12134 8416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrian Parr User:LibStar 03:09, 24 January 2013 (UTC) delete created by a |single purpose editor. looks like a blatant WP:AUTOBIO Deletion of Adrian Parr WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
12135 9998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Profile Defenders (2nd nomination) User:Momer313 19:54, 25 November 2020 (UTC) delete as it fails to meet the notability requirements, especially those set in . While there are a lot of sources mentioned most of them are blogs and interviews (as already mentioned above) which are neither independent nor original Deletion of Profile Defenders (2nd nomination) WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12136 9141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2038 FIFA World Cup User:Vorbee 08:03, 2 July 2018 (UTC) delete per Deletion of 2038 FIFA World Cup WP: TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
12137 16898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kido Blanko User:Celestina007 NONE delete Per essay |42. No in-depth significant coverage in reliable sourcess Deletion of Kido Blanko WP:42 Wikipedia:The answer to life, the universe, and everything 7
12138 20551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John F. Ashton User:David 06:50, 2 May 2012 (UTC) delete """The case for is weak, as discussed above; the case for is even weaker (very little about him to be found in Google news or Highbeam, and not nontrivial enough coverage to suffice). The philosophy section seems problematic in its convoluted reading of its sources, and in any case seems to be largely about the content of a book that Ashton merely edited. The strongest case I can see for him is as the author of the """"chocolate a day"""" book — that, at least, has some hits (14 on google news, 17 in highbeam) and while these sources still don't give nontrivial coverage of Ashton himself, they at least cover one of his theories in a little depth. But I think it was too much a flash-in-the-pan and thing to form the basis of an entire biography""" Deletion of John F. Ashton WP:PROF||WP:GNG||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
12139 3232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Preston King (academic) User:David 00:50, 16 January 2013 (UTC) keep I think there are enough in-depth sources on him to pass . I did some cleanups to the article, enough I think to demonstrate notability — it still needs a lot more, and Barney Barney Barney's stubbornness in insisting that it's ok as it is isn't helpful, but AfD isn't for cleanup Deletion of Preston King (academic) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12140 1573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muni Pranamyasagar NONE NONE delete Fails . Look at each source none of them are indepth about Pranamyasagar and are about the event and visits to different states of India Deletion of Muni Pranamyasagar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12141 17099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A True Church User:N 19:06, 29 January 2007 (UTC) delete Perhaps not a hoax, but we have only one reliable source -- the Washington Post article -- and requires multiple sources. The question of whether that article is really a source at all is important, but unless another source is found it doesn't actually matter. I'm also concerned about owing to the lack of reliable sources; remember, the criterion is ''verifiability'', not truth. —The preceding Wikipedia:Sign your posts on talk pages|unsigned comment was added by Deletion of A True Church WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
12142 14074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pegasus Award NONE NONE delete Whether or not an article is included in the encyclopedia is based on our policies and guidelines. This article seems to fail the notability criteria for a stand alone article at including . Both and require multiple sources with significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject. I have been unable to find any sources in the article or G-searches that meet all 3 of the requirements to establish notability Deletion of Pegasus Award WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12143 15360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lilly Ann User:MichaelQSchmidt 08:43, 22 August 2009 (UTC) keep per meeting Through appearances in ''Penthouse'', ''Hustler'', ''Barely Legal'', and ''Club (magazine Deletion of Lilly Ann WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12144 14719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Green Standard User:Snotbot 19:19, 15 December 2011 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2011 December 15 Deletion of Green Standard WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
12145 2152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clinton Foundation-State Department controversy User:Muboshgu 17:07, 9 September 2016 (UTC) delete WP:POVFORK, , , , , . – Deletion of Clinton Foundation-State Department controversy WP:PROFRINGE||WP:SYNTH||WP:OR||WP:V||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
12146 12074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Mächler User:Bearcat 15:04, 19 April 2017 (UTC) delete Nothing claimed in the article constitutes an automatic pass, and the referencing is entirely to |primary sources and |blogs with no evidence of the |reliable source coverage needed to clear Deletion of Patrick Mächler WP:NPOL||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:BLOGS||WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12147 6501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Ballad of Lucy Jordan User:Hullaballoo 04:14, 29 September 2010 (UTC) keep """Once again, we have a completely uninformed nomination of a major song by a major songwriter, possibly the worst since the Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Dead_Flowers|Dead Flowers AFD. says that """"that have been independently released as a recording by several notable artists, bands or groups are probably notable""""; when that holds, as here, it's a waste of other editors' time to advance a nomination without any rational explanation of a claim of non-notability, especially when there's no effort made to determine if sources are available. There's more than enough coverage of the song in the reviews and related coverage of the the 1970s Marianne Faithfull album alone, print coverage that can't be readily ound online. The Google Books search results are just the tip of an iceberg""" Deletion of The Ballad of Lucy Jordan WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12148 16759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roy Chiongbian User:HueMan1 08:26, 11 April 2021 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of Roy Chiongbian WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12149 20467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LIFX User:Northamerica1000 13:57, 15 January 2014 (UTC) keep Passes . Source examples include http://www.brw.com.au/p/entrepreneurs/lifx_shipping_its_bulbs_after_taking_mR6vfA4mUZRlxJP2EsA4mK, http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2012-09/17/lifx-lightbulb, http://www.gizmag.com/lifx-smartphone-led-lights/24201/. See also: , section D. Thanks Deletion of LIFX WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12150 372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jayden Jaymes User:Rebecca1990 08:50, 10 December 2014 (UTC) keep """She passes because she has won a well-known and significant industry award; AVN's Best Body fan award in 2014, and she has been featured multiple times in notable mainstream media; she has a lot more than just an MTV appearance. Winning two fan voted awards over a period of five years is evidence that she also passes 's criteria #2 which states """"Has a large fan base or a significant """"cult"""" following""" Deletion of Jayden Jaymes WP:PORNBIO||WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
12151 633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skyy Black (porn star) User:Edison 16:48, 23 March 2007 (UTC) delete Apparently promoters and fanciers of pornography have established a guideline to create an easy route for promoting such performers via the high web presence of Wikipedia. This article has no independent sources at all, and thus should be deleted because it fails and Deletion of Skyy Black (porn star) WP:PORNBIO||WP:ATT||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12152 13946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arkansas Vibe User:CyberGhostface 21:22, 24 September 2008 (UTC) comment """Whether or not you meant it to be advertising, writing about yourself or something that you are associated with still constitutes as |conflict of interest. And as you yourself stated, """"''ArkansasViBE is newer and not as established''"""". That's pretty much an indication that it's not notable enough for inclusion here""" Deletion of Arkansas Vibe WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
12153 14176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Betty Barratt User:Saalstin 10:56, 14 August 2009 (UTC) delete She doesn't appear to meet the |GNG, and certainly not - Mayor of a town, and Chairman of a District Council don't qualify. Chris Neville-Smith says leaders of County Councils are notable, whilst that is the case, even if this had been a CC, she wasn't its leader, she was its Chairman, which may be a notable position, but occupants I don't think would be. So, for so many reasons, delete Deletion of Betty Barratt WP:N||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12154 20102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cralotte User:Edison 15:53, 12 June 2009 (UTC) delete Fails |notability, |verifiability, and OT|not for things made up in school one day Deletion of Cralotte WP:N||WP:V||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12155 1277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Null (scanlation) User:Ultra 07:51, 14 October 2006 (UTC) delete 11,700 http://www.google.com/search?q=Null+scanlation+-wikipedia ghits, a poor http://alexa.com/data/details/traffic_details?url=http://n-u-l-l.net/ alexa ranking, no verifiability, (an entrance on another wiki does ''not'' make it verifiable and the other link provided has barely any information on it), and a failure of Deletion of Null (scanlation) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12156 3509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Paper Mario series characters (2nd nomination) User:Zxcvbnm 23:35, 2 December 2009 (UTC) delete Wikipedia has a policy against listing minor characters without citations. All major characters are already at Paper Mario (series) and the series doesn't need an in-depth character list. Listing all minor characters and enemies like this is practically material. Finally, the people who keep arguing to keep the article are completely unwilling to clean it up, probably because doing so is practically impossible without any external references besides game guides and the game itself. Unless there is cultural significance, articles about characters belong in FAQs, specialized Wikis and the like Deletion of List of Paper Mario series characters (2nd nomination) WP:GAMEGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12157 1551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/H. L. Willis User:Clarityfiend 20:25, 26 August 2016 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails , and . Then also delete the other mayors of Pineville, Louisiana, who have the same notability problems, and the mayor template Deletion of H. L. Willis WP:GNG||WP:BIO||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12158 5091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/202-456-1414 User:Rackabello 22:22, 11 August 2007 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not 555-1212 Deletion of 202-456-1414 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12159 21244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mossy Kilcher User:Atlantic306 00:28, 11 July 2021 (UTC) keep as there is substantial coverage in multiple reliable sources such as a dedicated article in the New York Times and reviews that show a pass of so that deletion is unnecessary in my view Deletion of Mossy Kilcher WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12160 12468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Debt evasion User:Kuyabribri 17:40, 26 March 2009 (UTC) delete In addition to arguments already put forth, the article seems to be taking a how-to or how-not-to tone. Borderline Deletion of Debt evasion WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12161 21828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of Greek and Hindu Gods User:Colonel 20:47, 3 September 2011 (UTC) keep AFD is not cleanup — it is our |policy to improve articles in mainspace. If the nominator thinks he can do better then he is free to perform a complete rewrite using ordinary editing tools. Here's http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=ZxNg_7gZwygC&pg=PA268 a source to help the matter forward Deletion of Comparison of Greek and Hindu Gods WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
12162 17392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of NCAA Men's Division I Elite Eight appearances by coach User:Jrcla2 15:12, 15 May 2015 (UTC) delete per nom. This is fancruft and a non-notable characteristic of a college basketball head coach. The head coaches are historically judged by Final Four appearances, not Elite Eight. There aren't sources to satisfy this list per |GNG either Deletion of List of NCAA Men's Division I Elite Eight appearances by coach WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12163 17599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/City of the Plague God User:Barkeep49 15:13, 9 October 2020 (UTC) merge to Rick Riordan Presents. This is a clear |alternative to deletion and the target page could contain information useful to a person interested in the book. Also it's irrelevant at this AfD whether or not the series is notable (I suspect it is, but haven't looked because it's not what's up for discussion). If this were to be redirected and the target page is deleted this will end up deleted as well. But if this is redirected and the book later proves notable (which is a bit of a toss-up in my mind) we've upheld policy by preserving content. Best Deletion of City of the Plague God WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12164 7132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cambodia at the 2013 Asian Youth Games User:Malcolmxl5 11:53, 3 June 2016 (UTC) merge to the main games article. This could have been done |boldly without bringing this and others here Deletion of Cambodia at the 2013 Asian Youth Games WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
12165 4736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wonder Woman's Power User:IslaySolomon 07:09, 7 December 2006 (UTC) delete Redundant |OR |cruft Deletion of Wonder Woman's Power WP:OR||WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:No original research 65
12166 494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eugene P. Watson User:Billy 21:02, 5 June 2007 (UTC) comment Really? Shouldn't the author creating a page review as well to ensure they are entering someone who would pass the test? Especially someone as prolific as Deletion of Eugene P. Watson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12167 16792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guitar in popular culture User:Useight 22:24, 12 July 2007 (UTC) delete as Deletion of Guitar in popular culture WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
12168 9891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Borghild Project User:Rorshacma 15:32, 22 July 2021 (UTC) delete """The topic, and subsequent reveal that it was a hoax, got a small bit of coverage, but I agree with the nom that its just not sufficient to pass the as a notable hoax. The one Sex Doll book is pretty much the only good source - the rest are either brief """"interesting fact"""" mentions or are from tabloids""" Deletion of Borghild Project WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12169 65 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Türklerin tarih içinde uğradığı soykırımlar listesi """Kullanıcı:sağlamcısağlamcı""" 16:55, 26 Kasım 2007 (UTC) delete Kaynak yok, düzene uygunsuz, 'ya aykırı. Bence çok uzun durmuş Vikipedi'de. Saygılar.Resim:Barnstar of Reversion2.png|25px Türklerin tarih içinde silinmesi soykırımlar listesi Vikipedi:TBA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
12170 432 [[Alexander Küper]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Carsaig 18:00, 4. Aug. 2014 (CEST) delete keine Relevanz nach sichtbar, und als Bewerbungsmappe ziemlich schlecht gemacht Löschung von Alexander Küper Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12171 5909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allegations of apartheid (fifth nomination) User:Masterpiece2000 06:54, 12 July 2008 (UTC) keep """It is a notable article. The article is heavily referenced and the sources are reliable. I don’t think the article is based almost entirely on |original research and |synthesized research. I don’t agree that no body of literature exists that discusses """"allegations of apartheid"""" or """"the apartheid analogy"""" in a general sense. In the article, reliable sources are tied together by the """"apartheid"""" concept""" Deletion of Allegations of apartheid (fifth nomination) WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
12172 4490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FiscalityONE ERP MRP WMS User:SamHolt6 14:02, 19 July 2017 (UTC) delete subject lacks significance and fails to meet criteria Deletion of FiscalityONE ERP MRP WMS WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12173 19936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cakerolling User:The 18:19, 4 December 2008 (UTC) delete I agree with Ten Pound Hammer: this is an article about a web phenomenon with no sources given, speedy-deletable under the criteria Deletion of Cakerolling WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12174 6696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Pierce User:Bikeable 02:06, 3 December 2006 (UTC) delete as failing Deletion of Tony Pierce WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12175 15752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vector (physical) User:Colonel 22:47, 28 February 2008 (UTC) keep This is not a content fork in that Vector (spatial) is mainly a mathematical treatment while this article proposes a treatment from the standpoint of physics/engineering, which, from the outline section headings, seems to be quite different. The competing article Vector (spatial) seems to explain the topic poorly and, for example, has almost no inline citations to support its detailed content. It also seems to be too much of a #HOWTO|how to. We have a variety of even worse articles such as Coordinate vector (which has no sources at all) and so the contention that this subject must be covered within a single article seems overdone. There is some contention within the talk page for Vector (spatial) as to the best name for the article and this further supports the idea that other article titles and treatments are worth trying Deletion of Vector (physical) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12176 14112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Virtual Aviation Organisation User:Scott 19:41, 12 October 2006 (UTC) keep Very notable within it's own field. While I agree that the article needs a good re-write to comply with (heck, a general cleanup would be good), that is not a valid reason for deletion (nor is lack of notability in itself), and the problem could probably be best solved with some cleanup tags; there's a lot in the article that could be re-used. See also discussion at Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Virtual_Air_Traffic_Flight_Simulation_Network; much of that could also apply to IVAO Deletion of International Virtual Aviation Organisation WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
12177 11115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015–16 Threave Rovers F.C. season User:Steel1943 01:35, 28 August 2015 (UTC) delete Agreed, this fails Deletion of 2015–16 Threave Rovers F.C. season WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12178 657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luke Hamill (model) User:Gene93k 14:21, 14 December 2009 (UTC) delete Fails . All I could find was a European Gay Porn Awards nomination along with passing mentions at AVN/GayVN. Not enough Deletion of Luke Hamill (model) WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12179 15652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Obara User:MER 10:16, 14 November 2006 (UTC) delete violates Deletion of Robert Obara WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
12180 13621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poison Bite User:Shooterwalker 21:35, 2 September 2010 (UTC) delete despite proposed exception to at otability (fiction), that exception has failed. No evidence to of this character. Would also support a merge if it will help reach a consensus Deletion of Poison Bite WP:N||WP:N||WP:verify notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
12181 10102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RJ Tolson (2nd nomination) User:KickStartWrit 09:51, 23 July 2016 (UTC) comment """You want to """"salt"""" the article because he is """"barely notable even locally""""? I didn't even know |coatracking was a thing, I just thought this met the notability guidelines so i create the article to contribute to wikipedia. The whole point of this is either to see if there are sources enough to provide even more notability, because as established there is some, and when I checked there was more each time I contributed (which is why I did to help the article I created be better), and if not, then to delete the page. How does salting the article benefit to this situation? """"I see every reason to salt the page so this situation doesn't recur."""" Please explain the reasons as you see every reason to delete the page filled with sources more reliable than not, so that it makes sense for anyone in the future that has sources that meet the notability guidelines better (as we seem to think they don't currently) they can contribute""" Deletion of RJ Tolson (2nd nomination) WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
12182 11983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evan Viveiros User:JaimeLesMaths 01:34, 27 January 2007 (UTC) delete Unverified, non-notable, and seems to be a clear violation Deletion of Evan Viveiros WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
12183 10990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terence Ford User:ScrapIronIV 17:45, 25 April 2016 (UTC) delete Fails and , with no sources found for improvement Deletion of Terence Ford WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12184 2728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of African American neighborhoods (2nd nomination) User:Fences 18:05, 7 December 2009 (UTC) comment """Has ''anyone'', including the nominator (see ), made any effort at all to look for sources? If reliable sources define an area as an """"African-American neighborhood"""" or a synonym, then we can accept that for the purposes of this article. So it's perfectly possible to make such a list. There's a whole book about the African-American neighborhoods in St. Petersburg, Florida.http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=0ph7kJD1EpcC There was a documentary made about Como, Fort Worth, Texas.http://cbs11tv.com/local/New.Documentary.Film.2.1348956.html Here's a source for Fountain Park, St. Louis.http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5g9TVnWjPbn2ouDVtpm2T_xEFyHsgD9C5MREO5""" Deletion of List of African American neighborhoods (2nd nomination) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
12185 2163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Tutak User:AKS 13:35, 20 October 2015 (UTC) delete Seems to be failing & Deletion of Robert Tutak WP:ARTIST||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12186 12450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agape International Missions User:E 21:16, 12 November 2015 (UTC) keep The issue is whether it passes . Moreover, what Callinus calls a ''puff piece'' other readers might describe as a feature article, or a reported story. More to the point, the coverage that comes to the top on simple news search, here: https://www.google.com/search?q=agape+sex+cambodia&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8#q=agape+sex+cambodia&tbm=nws is persuasive that this organization has the sourcing to pass Deletion of Agape International Missions WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12187 15423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of neurofibromatosis clinics User:Ajf773 20:04, 22 April 2017 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of List of neurofibromatosis clinics WP:NOTDIRECTORY||WP:NOTLINKFARM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12188 19006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/H.O.B.E.F User:Terenceong1992 14:18, 1 March 2006 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of H.O.B.E.F WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
12189 3986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Middlebrook User:Ohnoitsjamie 15:17, 24 April 2018 (UTC) delete Likely paid-promotion; not seeing how subject meets or . His consultancy group has been quoted in some BBC articles, but that's about it as far as third-party coverage Deletion of Peter Middlebrook WP:ACADEMIC||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12190 7395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MPPF (disambiguation) User:Shhhnotsoloud 12:04, 30 May 2021 (UTC) delete A disambiguation page is not required ( Deletion of MPPF (disambiguation) WP:2DABS Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
12191 16691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Immersion Games NONE NONE comment To add my comment on the Izno's post, companies are held to a bigger standards per . It is just not a notable company. Those are the links I have found as well, which are Deletion of Immersion Games WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
12192 10109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keifer Brooks User:Cocytus 04:46, 13 January 2010 (UTC) delete 1 Google news hit, might not even be him. Doesn't seem to come close to passing Deletion of Keifer Brooks WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12193 78 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Caroline Yılmaz """Kullanıcı:birazdangelicem'''birazdangelicem'''""" 18.40, 5 Şubat 2021 (UTC) delete Madde aslında biraz amatörce hazırlanmış ve kaynaklar içeriği referanslamıyor. Kaynaklar kapsam derinliği ve kalite olarak yetersiz. (bkz: |Kayda değerlik) Maddede bulunan kaynakların çoğu VP:BK|Bağımsız Kaynaklarda gazeteler kişiler için bağımsız kaynak olarak gösterilse de kişiden bağımsız değil. Müzikografi için verilmiş https://www.haberler.com/en-cok-onlar-dinlendi-13785932-haberi/ Kaynak 16daki haberde ne kişiden ve şarkılarından ne de kişinin sahibi olduğu yapım şirketinden bahsedilmemiş. Hangi sebeple eklenmiş çözemedim. Sunuculuğunu yaptığı programın haberleri (Acunn, TV8,5) TV programını yapan medya grubunun yayın organları, kişiden bağımsız değil. Kaynaklarda 7 tane youtube linki var kişinin kendi yayınları ve şarkıları, bağımsız kaynak değeri taşımıyor. Radyo programı için verilen kaynaklar; Miss & Mr Model of Turkey yarışmasındaki jürilik haberi, aynı yarışmada dereceye girmiş modelle video klip çekmek istediğine dair haber, Serdar Ortaç için açıklama yaptığı magazin haberi ve magazinde öne çıkanlar haberi. Bu kaynaklar VP:D|Doğrulanabilirlik ihlali yaratıyor. Sadece hakkında haber var demek için verilmiş kaynaklar ve radyo programı yaptığını kanıtlayan kaynaklar değil. Kaynak 3 ve 4 kurduğu medya şirketinden bahsediyor, ilk albümü kendisine yapacağından bahsedilmiş ama ortada bir albüm ve yapım şirketi aracılığıyla çıkmış başka bir sanatçı albümü yok. Bunların yanı sıra verilen kaynaklardaki haber organları (milliyet, hurriyet, fanatik gibi) fikirsel olarak birbirinden bağımsız değil. Aynı medya grubunun haber organları. Diğer katılımcıların ısmarlama haber şüphesini destekler nitelikte. Madde bu haliyle kaynak bakımından bağımsızlıktan ve güvenilirlikten uzak gibi görünüyor. İyi çalışmalar Caroline Yılmaz'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
12194 2329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Get On Your Boots User:Esradekan 07:52, 20 January 2009 (UTC) keep while technically correct, I believe this is a time for |common sense and |ignore all the rules Deletion of Get On Your Boots WP:COMMON||WP:IAR "Wikipedia:What ""Ignore all rules"" means" 62
12195 20413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethnic nepotism User:AleatoryPonderings 05:50, 20 August 2020 (UTC) delete Not notable as a term, and a redirect gives this concept a platform Deletion of Ethnic nepotism WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
12196 801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prime Directive (retrospectives) User:LaughingVulcan 01:15, 22 June 2007 (UTC) delete """not speedy. The context is pretty simple to figure out - project management and evaluations following a project. I assume that it's """"Prime,"""" because in software projects (and any other kind of group retrospective analysis) assigning blame is a discussion killer. Yet it happens a lot. So setting a guideline like this makes sense. (I mention the previous just to indicate that figuring out context on this isn't all that hard.) I suppose you could speedy it under G11 for apparently advertising the book, but I'd recommend against that. Since it was nommed twelve minutes after creation by a first time contributor, it could well be a stub that the creator intends to build on. (Or not...) I don't know how notable this particular concept is, and would agree that if it reaches normal end of AfD that it be deleted on and EO""" Deletion of Prime Directive (retrospectives) WP:N||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12197 4570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Differences between book and film versions of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone User:Koffieyahoo 04:19, 10 August 2006 (UTC) delete per , unless someone can find a reputable source that describes these differences Deletion of Differences between book and film versions of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12198 2862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dennis Hart User:Col_tom 00:40, 26 April 2006 (UTC) keep albeit in a drastically cut down fashion. Way too much unnecessary info in here, but the list of publications does suggest that it meets or comes close to the |professor test there. The listed awards fail the test, tho, IMO Deletion of Dennis Hart WP:PROFTEST Wikipedia:Notability 77
12199 18959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pincus v. Yahoo! Inc. User:Bearian 22:10, 11 February 2014 (UTC) merge per above, to the Criticism or the Litigation article. That will save any article history. We |almost never keep articles about recently filed lawsuits, which are |very common, and earlier in my life, I contributed mightily to the flood of paper in our nation's courts Deletion of Pincus v. Yahoo! Inc. WP:OUTCOMES||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12200 18673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pulp.Net (2nd nomination) User:Starblind 13:01, 7 October 2010 (UTC) delete per , and I agree this is likely an advertising attempt Deletion of Pulp.Net (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12201 13956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of deceased characters in Prisoner User:Shooterwalker 23:58, 12 March 2011 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not |indiscriminate info or a complete exposition of all possible details. If there are notable characters on the show, give them an article, or put them into a single list Deletion of List of deceased characters in Prisoner WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12202 17472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prithviraj Productions User:onel5969 10:16, 2 January 2019 (UTC) merge to Prithviraj Sukumaran. Not currently notable enough for a standalone article. Might be a case of Deletion of Prithviraj Productions WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
12203 18287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of re-education through labor camps in China User:Horse 20:49, 27 January 2020 (UTC) keep the contention that the re-education though labor program ended in 2013 is simply not factual, have repeatedly found that statement to be as much of a lie as the promise that all the Xinjiang camp prisoners have been freed. I agree with buidhe that we should keep this consistent with the pages on forced labor and political re-education camps in other brutal regimes Deletion of List of re-education through labor camps in China WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12204 16760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dean Rankine User:SwagGangster 12:46, 26 February 2019 (UTC) keep This article should be kept, Dean Rankine does pass , but this article needs to be improved Deletion of Dean Rankine WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12205 696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hypnos (band) NONE NONE delete Ok, lets take a look at the criteria Deletion of Hypnos (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12206 18292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PWCT (software) User:AmericanAir88 13:44, 27 July 2019 (UTC) keep There are strong sources that have been found. The programing guides and articles meet Deletion of PWCT (software) WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12207 1900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Nabil Elhussieny User:Jersey92 20:16, 14 August 2014 (UTC) delete Not a full pro. Fails Deletion of Omar Nabil Elhussieny WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12208 11872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World Universities Debating Ranking User:Bfigura 04:01, 9 September 2007 (UTC) delete per . Wikipedia isn't a collection of random (possibly unverifiable) stats Deletion of World Universities Debating Ranking WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12209 394 [[Hakim Said]] (LAE) Benutzer:CorrectHorseBatteryStaple 16:14, 20. Sep. 2017 (CEST) keep Als Gouverneur von Sindh gemäß #Politiker relevant Löschung von Hakim Said Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12210 2899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahvaz National Resistance User:Redditaddict69 23:40, 26 September 2018 (UTC) keep Passes w/ coverage in several sources (many not cited, just do a quick google search). Even BBC covered this... it's notable Deletion of Ahvaz National Resistance WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12211 13174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Shankbone User:JohnWBarber 04:18, 19 October 2009 (UTC) keep Delete''' The sources don't address the subject in substantial detail, so this doesn't meet . All we have is a pile of trivia. He acts like a journalist and gets a lot of interviews -- so do thousands of other people who get published. Same goes for photographs. Even the Columbia Journalism Review article, which might have substantial coverage of him, is used for trivia. There doesn't seem to be any source out there that gives us the depth of coverage needed for an article Deletion of David Shankbone WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12212 20898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Talent Development User:HisSpaceResearch 15:42, 19 December 2007 (UTC) delete OR, unencyclopedic tone, essay, how-to, fails , neologism. I wouldn't object if an actual encyclopedia article could be written here with verifiable citations to reliable sources Deletion of Talent Development WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12213 12430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mother of Peace Community User:The 11:12, 16 July 2018 (UTC) delete for subject failing . This is one of those occasions where some arguments are so strongly infected by |sentiment and emotion that we need to douse the place afterwards with a repellent Deletion of Mother of Peace Community WP:GNG||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12214 15402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arena51 User:Bobet 17:45, 6 January 2006 (UTC) delete http://www.arena51.be has http://www.alexa.com/data/details/?url=www.arena51.be Alexa traffic rank of 43,735 (|rank of 10,000 needed for website to be considered notable). No other claim of notability Deletion of Arena51 WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12215 6147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ionică Minune User:Atlantic306 02:05, 17 February 2021 (UTC) keep as per the multiple reliable Romanian sources identified above that show significant coverage of the subject so that is passed and deletion is unnecessary in my view Deletion of Ionică Minune WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12216 6 [[Vorlage:Einzelnachweise]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Armin P. 21:55, 3. Okt. 2011 (CEST) delete Heftig fand ich den Kommentar hier, wenn den Leuten etwas falsches in einer Umfrage vorgespielt worden ist, hätten sie sich besser informieren sollen. Zur Sache: a) eine rechtfertigt nicht gelöschte Inhalte wiederherzustellen und besitzt im Gegensatz zu einem WP:MB keine Verbindlichkeit b) Vorlage ist ein Wiedergänger c) diese Meinung bringt http://de.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia%3AL%C3%B6schkandidaten%2F3._Oktober_2011&action=historysubmit&diff=94331559&oldid=94331515 meinen Standpunkt gut zum Ausdruck Löschung von Vorlage:Einzelnachweise Wikipedia:Umfrage Wikipedia:Umfragen 15
12217 2234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Index of Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 1st edition monsters User:RoySmith 19:58, 5 October 2019 (UTC) delete as , not to mention cruft Deletion of Index of Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 1st edition monsters WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12218 19872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Vaughan (teacher) User:Michellecrisp 22:56, 11 November 2008 (UTC) delete fails badly Deletion of Richard Vaughan (teacher) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12219 20043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ying (state) User:Goldsztajn 08:37, 13 October 2019 (UTC) keep https://books.google.com/books?id=cHA7Ey0-pbEC Cambridge History of Ancient China (1999) has specific mentions of the state (pp. 312, 407-8), in terms of archaeological significance and as part of the Zhou-era expansions and enfeoffment processes into Eastern China. The state is mentioned in the writings of Mencius|Mengzi (孟子). Clearly oS problems with the article as it currently stands, but seems extreme here since only a little work is required to repair Deletion of Ying (state) WP:M||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Mediation 96
12220 457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Notre Dame Fighting Irish football series records User:UCO2009bluejay 23:56, 30 March 2016 (UTC) comment """Does this list pass and ist or fails ? Some of the sources such as """"winsipedia"""" are unreliable. '''Also, the prior discussions had the consensus that these lists should not exist at all""" Deletion of Notre Dame Fighting Irish football series records WP:GNG||WP:L||WP:NSTATS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12221 9054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zachary Rolfe User:Sam 18:45, 29 August 2018 (UTC) delete WP:PSEUDO|Pseudo-biography on a BLP1E-individual, fails the |basic notability guideline for people Deletion of Zachary Rolfe WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12222 7898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dinamicos User:Metropolitan90 03:38, 10 December 2007 (UTC) keep per . Sources for a Trinidad and Tobago-based band may be more difficult to find than for a band based in the U.S. or U.K., but this band's songwriting members did apparently win an award from the Copyright Organization of Trinidad and Tobago, which is the equivalent of Broadcast Music Incorporated|BMI in the U.S. or Performing Right Society|PRS in the U.K Deletion of Dinamicos WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12223 7042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yanny or Laurel User:Tavix 18:05, 17 May 2018 (UTC) keep As the references show, this topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources, which is |all we require for inclusion in Wikipedia Deletion of Yanny or Laurel WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12224 13410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Peratt User:JoshuaZ 15:00, 16 July 2007 (UTC) delete per comments by nom and 76.214 among other reasons. The best test for writing an article about any person is whether there are reliable sources that are about the person (as described at , and relevant to this case ). There are no reliable sources about Peratt, only about his work. It might make sense to merge some of the information here to other articles Deletion of Anthony Peratt WP:N||WP:BIO||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12225 17290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Satyr (Dungeons & Dragons) User:Shimeru 19:53, 1 February 2007 (UTC) delete Appears to be a copyvio from the D&D ''Monster Manual'', although there's just enough conversion of tables into prose that it might squeak by. Still fails , though. Furthermore, a satyr in D&D is nothing more than the legendary creature represented in terms of the D&D game system. I doubt that this article could be expanded, unlike more original creations like the Beholder. At most '''merge''' as a small section to satyr Deletion of Satyr (Dungeons & Dragons) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12226 18691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pancakes! User:Turlo 17:09, 12 April 2011 (UTC) keep OP states and unencyclopedic - both of which are specifically listed as reasons not to use in an AfD. However, I think Dennis has it right. Multiple coverage by multiple reliable sources. Notability is met Deletion of Pancakes! WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12227 15565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Storage Made Easy User:HighKing 11:39, 29 January 2021 (UTC) delete I am unable to locate any |significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, references to date fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic therefore fails GNG/ Deletion of Storage Made Easy WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12228 17703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Macrophilia User:Uzma 05:36, 27 August 2012 (UTC) keep There was and is enough coverage in Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable sources that are Wikipedia:Independent sources|independent of the subject for a stand-alone article per . In addition, after a quick search, I added more sources from which to add material to the article.http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Macrophilia&diff=509374146&oldid=508810263 There's plenty of more Wikipedia reliable source material out there. I don't see why this article was listed for deletion Deletion of Macrophilia WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12229 5283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shermco Industries (2nd nomination) User:Pharaoh 06:46, 1 October 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Shermco Industries (2nd nomination) WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12230 16149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Chana Radcliffe User:Kubigula 04:03, 4 April 2007 (UTC) keep I'm not sure about the status of this AfD as the concern that prompted the nomination has been addressed by WJBscribe, whose editing also intentionally or incidentally removed the AfD tag from the article. To the extent that this AfD is still in progress, I note that there do appear to be sufficient secondary sources to meet - http://www.calgarysun.com/cgi-bin/publish.cgi?p=125188&x=articles&s=lifestyle http://www.cjnews.com/viewarticle.asp?id=8562 http://www.jewishtribune.ca/tribune/jt-060330-24.html Deletion of Sarah Chana Radcliffe WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12231 531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stuart Harvey User:Quantpole 12:48, 25 January 2010 (UTC) delete Does not meet and searching does not come up with anything to meet Deletion of Stuart Harvey WP:ATH||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12232 16165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Innate intelligence User:Jytdog 03:48, 16 December 2016 (UTC) delete good lord this article has existed in this sorry state for 11 years. If it is not a WP article by now it is never going to be one; right now it is mostly and non-independently source in-bubble nonsense Deletion of Innate intelligence WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12233 3159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deadbird User:wknight94 15:37, 28 January 2006 (UTC) delete Non-notable band that has only released one album which doesn't meet the standard of two full-length albums on major labels. Only the one album on Amazon and Allmusic. Listed for speedy but admin sent it here Deletion of Deadbird WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12234 10739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Osyluth User:Doctorfluffy 17:53, 5 January 2008 (UTC) delete Fails . Fancruft Deletion of Osyluth WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12235 109 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Şükrü Sözen Kullanıcı:assyrtikoassyrtiko 13.20, 30 Temmuz 2022 (UTC) keep kasırga operasyonu, görevden alınması, beraat edişi, Manavgat yangını sırasındaki iddaalar ile birlikte, 250 bin nüfuslu bir büyükşehir ilçe belediyesinin 3 dönem seçilmiş belediye başkanı olması gerekçesiyle kişi hakkında yeterli kapsam ve derinlik olduğu görülmüş, olduğu kanaati ile kalmasının yerinde olacağı değerlendirilmiştir Şükrü Sözen'in silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
12236 12613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sahil Kerimov User:GiantSnowman 17:35, 10 April 2014 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Sahil Kerimov WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12237 18117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sonyaa Ayodhya User:scope_creep 17:29, 17 June 2020 (UTC) delete Case of {WP:TOOSOON. Fails Deletion of Sonyaa Ayodhya WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12238 176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Orange Lights User:Kurtis 18:24, 11 July 2016 (UTC) delete No assertion of notability whatsoever. I actually think this article would be a viable candidate for speedy deletion per |A7 Deletion of The Orange Lights WP:A7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12239 17531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dániel Nagy (racing driver) User:C 21:11, 19 February 2016 (UTC) delete I'm leaning more toward GNG as the reason for the delete rather than NMOTORSPORT, since the article cites all of one newspaper article about him. Remember that the subject has to ''already'' be notable to have an article; we can't create one in anticipation of future notability. If there is more coverage of Nagy in newspapers in the future, or if he races on a major circuit, then let's create an article for him. However, I think QueenCake hit the nail on the head: it's too soon to start an article for him. |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball Deletion of Dániel Nagy (racing driver) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12240 17330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Tony Danza User:Schizombie 06:28, 18 April 2006 (UTC) delete CSD G4 as recreation of The Tony Danza sex move. Should not be merged or redirected to any other article since it is not Deletion of The Tony Danza WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12241 13473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kiat Goh User:ProcrastinatingReader 14:14, 26 June 2020 (UTC) comment WP:NSINGER does not appear to be met (except, perhaps, point 1 which trends along a clarification of GNG). Whether is would depend on how reliable these sources are. I'm not too familiar on them myself. I'll probably look into the sources and update this comment. I think some input from the WikiProject might also be of help. From a look at the sources currently, I'd trend towards at this stage. Input from the WikiProject may be of value Deletion of Kiat Goh WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
12242 2918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/System Crash (TV series) (2nd nomination) User:Davey2010 21:05, 10 May 2020 (UTC) keep per Bearcat, Even tho I wasn't around pre-2010 even I know Wikipedia was ''very'' different then to what it is now, Bearcat has since improved and although it could do with more work . Sourcing the article is fine and imho meets GNG Deletion of System Crash (TV series) (2nd nomination) WP:AFDISNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12243 6055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014–15 Chester F.C. season User:Number 14:26, 26 August 2020 (UTC) delete per failure Deletion of 2014–15 Chester F.C. season WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12244 11801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Destination: Dewsbury User:GeoffreyT2000 03:59, 2 December 2016 (UTC) delete The prod tag you added was removed because it is against policy to restore a removed prod tag, unless the page was blanked (which may then be speedy deleted under #G7 in some cases) or replaced with vandalism content. Anyway, the film fails as the Yorkshire Times reference is not reliable enough Deletion of Destination: Dewsbury WP:CSD||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12245 13925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Janet Boynes User:Kinu 14:14, 15 September 2009 (UTC) delete There are no reliable sources; most information appears to be her own website, and really doesn't indicate how she meets . The article also reads like a plot summary of her autobiography, rather than a true researched biography. Also, call me cynical, but part of me can't help but wonder if there is some -pushing in the tone as well. If somehow she does meet , the article needs to explicitly say so and be substantially cleaned up Deletion of Janet Boynes WP:BIO||WP:POV||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12246 7699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poprocks & Coke User:Nouse4aname 09:21, 12 June 2009 (UTC) delete and '''redirect''' to International Superhits. Fails Deletion of Poprocks & Coke WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12247 12751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethnic conflicts in western Poland NONE NONE delete """as |original research in it's current form. The extremely brief introduction states that this article concerns """"Polish-German relations"""" (a broader, but more concrete, topic than the actual title), and then gives about one paragraph each to that topic in a variety of different eras. There are three line citations, which is always a good thing, but the problem here is an underlying assumption that there is a multi-generational link between each era on the topic of ethnicity and ethnic relations. THAT assumption is not cited at all. Do I believe that people who have lived in the area of modern day Germany have had encounters with people who lived in the area of modern day Poland? Of course. Do I believe that events between those peoples in 1565 have a direct relationship to events between such peoples in 1820? Maybe, maybe not. Causality is always a challenge for historians even with the most detailed and extensive research, which is not the case here""" Deletion of Ethnic conflicts in western Poland WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12248 18086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Barresi User:Jreferee 07:26, 2 September 2007 (UTC) delete The article is nothing but |Synthesis of published material serving to advance a position. Fails . The was a Paul Barresi who was known as an Anthony Pellicano operative. The article makes no mention of it. Just about all the footnotes are not independent from Paul Barresi. Delete, however with no objection to recreating the article using |reliable source material that is independent of Paul Barresi Deletion of Paul Barresi WP:SYN||WP:OR||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
12249 4111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lifoti User:Coolabahapple 15:18, 27 December 2016 (UTC) delete """as this is and , have been unable to find any |useable sources, not averse to haveing a couple of lines about this magazine added to KJIVA|founders article. ps. being on Amazon and having an isbn does not make a publication notable. pps. this article did not get """"approved"""" (it did not go thru """ Deletion of Lifoti WP:PROMOTION||WP:TOOSOON||WP:RS||WP:AFC Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12250 15159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Remaining, Part One User:Gongshow 03:56, 25 March 2014 (UTC) delete I could find no coverage to demonstrate that this meets or Deletion of The Remaining, Part One WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12251 18549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryan Kanu User:Mentoz86 15:27, 29 December 2012 (UTC) delete per Struway's research. No evidence that the subject passes . Also fails due to lack of coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Bryan Kanu WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12252 7043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 Pakistan heat wave User:Patrug 05:51, 17 May 2017 (UTC) comment Now 15 of the 17 sentences are just recitations of temperature measurements from local news sources that routinely report the weather every day. These sentences provide no significant info beyond the table of recorded temperatures. The only non-local source, a premature story from Al Jazeera, does not support any of the content in the Wikipedia article. The only claimed fatalities, 4 unknown seniors, with unknown causes of death, are not reliably attributed to the heat wave. This is simply not encyclopedic content for a stand-alone article following , , and our policy against routine news reporting. Nothing changes the above recommendations to merge into List of extreme weather records in Pakistan, which is where such events are properly recorded Deletion of 2017 Pakistan heat wave WP:GNG||WP:SUSTAINED||WP:NOTNEWSPAPER Wikipedia:Notability 77
12253 18880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kiley Gaffney User:Lankiveil 12:50, 11 January 2014 (UTC) keep I think that she meets criteria #5 of by virtue of having two albums on major labels Deletion of Kiley Gaffney WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12254 4904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HoverRace User:Marasmusine 19:05, 14 July 2007 (UTC) delete Not a single reliable, independent reference, per . To elaborate: forums and wikis are not eliable sources Deletion of HoverRace WP:V||WP:R Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12255 15224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rolf Dinsdale User:Valenciano 09:04, 26 November 2013 (UTC) merge """to Walter_Dinsdale#Personal_Life. If he were a.n.other candidate in a local election, I'd probably support deletion. However, the election which Rolf Dinsdale stood in was a federal one, not a local one and he nearly won, coming within 400 votes of victory in a seat previously held by his father. So, while that doesn't merit a standalone article, it does mean that he's a plausible search term. says: """"In the case of candidates for political office who do not meet this guideline, the general rule is to redirect to an appropriate page covering the election or political office sought in lieu of deletion. Relevant material from the biographical article can be merged into the election or political office page if appropriate."""" I believe in this case, brief mentions in context in the father's article would be more appropriate than deletion or a simple redirect to the election article, redirects being cheap""" Deletion of Rolf Dinsdale WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12256 16335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harker House User:Anne 18:11, 28 September 2015 (UTC) delete """The article doesn't mention anything notable about this house. There's no mention of unique architecture. If it was built for a bank manager it can't be one of the oldest houses. There is no indication that it had newsworthy history before it was demolished. Wikipedia is not an collection of information. The article about Magrath doesn't mention the bank, but even if a small section was added about it, not more than one sentence about the manager's house would be needed. It's listed as an """"attraction"""" in the Magrath article, but with no indication of what made it interesting. &mdash""" Deletion of Harker House WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12257 7848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Legend of Boruta User:Greg 17:02, 3 December 2007 (UTC) keep Notable entry for a song/movie/story as per etc. Made it to the festivals on both hemispheres, winner of Grand Prix. Needs some more work concerning edition structure, though Deletion of The Legend of Boruta WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12258 7028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acer N series User:Djm 11:29, 14 November 2018 (UTC) keep Following improvement article demonstrates , on online resources alone let alone offline resources which were typical of its period Deletion of Acer N series WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12259 18921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Brown (accused murderer) User:Robofish 22:52, 25 January 2011 (UTC) delete premature, and raises serious BLP issues (both because the crime is only alleged at the moment, and because he is a minor). ''If'' he is convicted of murder as an adult, he would probably be notable; apparently in such a circumstance he would be the youngest American to be sentenced to life imprisonment. But that's a long way off (and hypothetical), and at the moment I don't think an article can be justified under Deletion of Jordan Brown (accused murderer) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12260 6787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elective caesarean section User:Chiswick 07:39, 25 September 2014 (UTC) merge seems an uncontroversial matter per ; the issue is not whether the material should be kept within the encyclopedia but whether there should be multiple articles on the matter. Whether an operation is 'elective' or not, it's an operation. Clearly it's not just a redirect because the reasons for having the operation may vary, and may have medical and ethical implications, but still, it's the same op. BTW it's hard to see why there should be more than one article on Caesarean section: certainly not three Deletion of Elective caesarean section WP:FORK Wikipedia:Mirrors and forks 46
12261 8013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amjad Ayub Mirza User:Ma 13:41, 25 March 2018 (UTC) delete it as it doesn't pass Deletion of Amjad Ayub Mirza WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12262 10749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Vasco Era User:Closenplay 17:46, 11 May 2007 (UTC) keep Absolutely meets Deletion of The Vasco Era WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12263 20540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Windows games starting with A User:Cybercobra 02:26, 8 September 2009 (UTC) keep per ; thought it probably needs some cleanup & TLC Deletion of List of Windows games starting with A WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
12264 16441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Noack User:Dricherby 09:19, 26 May 2012 (UTC) delete Other than plenty of mentions of the fact that he's the CFO of Australian Vintage, the only source I could find was this http://investing.businessweek.com/research/stocks/people/person.asp?personId=12914810&ticker=AVG:AU short profile at Businessweek and that's not enough for Deletion of Michael Noack WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12265 4077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucy Thane User:Binksternet 17:56, 11 November 2020 (UTC) keep The cited ''Impose'' magazine source is very good, and in-depth sources can also be found in the https://www.villagevoice.com/2016/05/16/spectacles-grrrl-germs-film-series-captures-the-agony-ecstasy-and-diversity-of-riot-grrrl/ ''Village Voice'' and the https://wp.nyu.edu/specialcollections/2016/02/18/adding-context-the-lucy-thane-riot-grrrl-videos/ NYU Library Special Collections publication ''The Back Table'', to satisfy . Thane's work is cited by others, too many to list, which shows that she is important in her field. I think we have a good reason to host this information for our readers Deletion of Lucy Thane WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12266 7920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patricia Farr User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:47, 11 October 2014 (UTC) keep as suitable https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Patricia_Farr&diff=629150079&oldid=629144634 now-sourced and further sourceable stub that preserves a piece of American cinematic history. {{u|Tokyogirl79}}'s work inspired me to look, and I found that she has been noted in multiple reliable sources and her body of verifiable work meets | #2. While it would be wonderful to have reams of 1930s-40s media covering her work, her career sadly ended with her 1948 death. This may likely never be as all-inclusive and copious an article as something on Marilyn Monroe, but so what? It serves the project to inform our readers Deletion of Patricia Farr WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12267 1402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Public bathroom User:Colonel 11:23, 2 July 2012 (UTC) merge to public bathing which is the most direct context for this. Usage of bathroom to mean a water closet is a |euphemism and so is best avoided Deletion of Public bathroom WP:EUPHEMISM Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
12268 21453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Md. Yousuf Gazi User:Kmzayeem 18:03, 23 September 2020 (UTC) delete fails , a mere lecturer Deletion of Md. Yousuf Gazi WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12269 6646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/So All Alone User:Metropolitan90 06:14, 13 August 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. Bootlegs should |not be considered notable unless reliable independent sources are provided in support of their notability Deletion of So All Alone WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12270 13662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vivek Vij User:Clarityfiend 01:32, 28 February 2017 (UTC) delete for failing and . The article is totally unreferenced, especially for all of the listed awards Deletion of Vivek Vij WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12271 10037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lynton Goss User:Fenix 12:32, 17 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Lynton Goss WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12272 21542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dale Shirkie User:Smartyllama 00:58, 16 December 2019 (UTC) keep Passes per the above sources by {{u|GiantSnowman Deletion of Dale Shirkie WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12273 13269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathan Larson (politician) User:Cupper52 10:10, 25 December 2020 (UTC) keep Was nominated for deletion three years ago and all the users voting said keep. The article also meets and is rated C-Class in WP Biography Deletion of Nathan Larson (politician) WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12274 16543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Sarkeesian Effect User:MichaelQSchmidt 15:06, 20 October 2014 (UTC) delete """per being way |Too Soon. This """"in development"""" article is premature. Allow undeletion or recreation when filming begins and onlyif it gets coverage to meet """ Deletion of The Sarkeesian Effect WP:NYF||WP:NF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
12275 1612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henrietta the four-legged chicken User:Sandstein 07:03, 7 February 2007 (UTC) delete Trivial news item, wich for Deletion of Henrietta the four-legged chicken WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12276 10592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vorarephilia User:NeoFreak 21:40, 30 January 2007 (UTC) delete """I feel quite foolish as I had just finished reviewing the macrophilia article when I came over here to this AfD. The ref I was referring to was in fact on that page. Although the rest rings true here for this article that doesn't mean the article escapes the criteria for deletion. While the paraphilia no doubt exists it is too fringe (or maybe just to young) to create |reliable sources in order to provide the mandatory level of |verifiability for any article on wikipeida. This means that until reliable sources can be found this article cannot support itself here. Of course many people are registering accounts here to """"vote"""" on this AfD (no doubt after being recruited to do so at vore community sites) this AfD is not a vote and """"I'm real and I'm into this stuff"""" is not a valid reason to retain this article. This article fails to meet policy requirements and should be deleted as failing , and very possibly since no objective coverage is available as all the knowledge of the subject is coming from people intimate with or involved in the subject material's """"community"""". I ask the closing admin considers the policy question and the single purpose nature of the participants of this AfD as well as """"community consensus""" Deletion of Vorarephilia WP:RS||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:V||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12277 15932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Land Mine (relist nomination) User:Brian 21:33, 3 May 2006 (UTC) delete """Appeared in Hamilton College in 2004"""" equals """ Deletion of Land Mine (relist nomination) WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
12278 3029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Alexander King's World War III Trilogy User:MichaelQSchmidt 05:10, 6 August 2008 (UTC) delete per Wikipedia:Notabilty & . Not a source in the entire article, which smacks of Wikipedia:OR. And if its here only as a place to post a proposal, is a violation of Wikipedia:COI Deletion of Matthew Alexander King's World War III Trilogy WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
12279 8432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miguel Tevez User:Pak21 08:18, 23 October 2007 (UTC) keep distinctly non-trivial coverage in at least three reliable independent sources, including ''The Sun'' http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/sport/football/article360909.ece, the ''Daily Mail'' http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/sport/football.html?in_article_id=487826&in_page_id=1779 and the ''Lancashire Evening Post'' http://www.lep.co.uk/sport/United-linked-with-new-Tevez.3380142.jp means he meets the |notability criteria, independent of whether or not he's played a professional match Deletion of Miguel Tevez WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12280 2845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WikiIndex User:Piotrus 09:14, 31 May 2019 (UTC) delete No in-depth, independent, reliable coverage. Fails Deletion of WikiIndex WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12281 358 [[Tells Bells]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Kulmbacher NONE delete Dieses Festival ist lediglich von regionaler Bedeutung. Die Bands, die dort spielen, entsprechen weitestgehend nicht den . Daher nicht enzyklopädisch relevant Löschung von Tells Bells Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12282 9049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carolyn Mary Kleefeld User:Bearian 21:25, 13 November 2012 (UTC) keep at what point does |a hot mess means that we delete an articles whose subject is otherwise |marginally notable Deletion of Carolyn Mary Kleefeld WP:TNT||WP:BARE Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
12283 19519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avenue Beat User:Joelirby 08:06, 31 July 2020 (UTC) keep Addressing comments about radio play above, MusicRow article https://musicrow.com/2020/07/avenue-beats-viral-tiktok-hit-f2020-earns-pop-radio-attention/ here mentions that their song 'F2020' has been played globally by more than 70 pop stations. Two of those stations are Z100 in New York and KIIS in Los Angeles which shows a greater support across iHeart radio outside of the Nashville station mentioned above. I don't know if Spotify charts are considered, but the article also discusses placement at number six globally and number three in the US for Spotify Viral 50. I think both of these point to notability as far as Deletion of Avenue Beat WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12284 20080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandeep Tyagi User:Germcrow 10:51, 14 December 2016 (UTC) keep There's enough in the write-up to get past . I just took a closer look at the references used. The page is also factual and non-promotional in essense Deletion of Sandeep Tyagi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12285 13235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cooking Kumares User:DarkGlow 18:57, 27 December 2020 (UTC) delete does not appear to meet Deletion of Cooking Kumares WP:NTV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12286 4183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Labbayk (2nd nomination) User:Mhhossein 17:12, 12 October 2018 (UTC) keep Per #4. The group has performed some international concert tours Deletion of Labbayk (2nd nomination) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12287 16970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/So Fresh: The Hits of Autumn 2008 User:HisSpaceResearch 16:11, 19 December 2007 (UTC) delete per #CRYSTAL. It doesn't actually meet any of the speedy deletion criteria, but we could still |snowball delete Deletion of So Fresh: The Hits of Autumn 2008 WP:NOT||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12288 13646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Idris Olagoke Badmus User:GPL93 22:14, 4 February 2020 (UTC) delete Sourcing does not indicate a pass. Best Deletion of Idris Olagoke Badmus WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12289 8999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexandros Galitsios User:GiantSnowman 11:25, 8 January 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Alexandros Galitsios WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12290 14673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twin Skies User:Pmedema 17:14, 2 October 2008 (UTC) keep passes and . If anything it is a borderline |crystal ball Deletion of Twin Skies WP:N||WP:RS||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12291 13839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cliché (band) User:Carlossuarez46 02:21, 24 February 2009 (UTC) delete no indication that this meets Deletion of Cliché (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12292 18938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Roy (2nd nomination) User:Shelbystripes 22:55, 1 October 2017 (UTC) delete Fails -- I also agree that Jonathan Roy (singer) should be moved to this page as Deletion of Jonathan Roy (2nd nomination) WP:NHOCKEY||WP:PRIMARYTOPIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12293 18158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Doig User:NativeForeigner 05:10, 4 April 2010 (UTC) delete Falls short of , fails and the above source does not assert 'significant' coverage Deletion of Nick Doig WP:GNG||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12294 18550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of albums censored by Wal-Mart User:Philosopher 02:51, 27 February 2015 (UTC) delete These fail . Consider - we don't maintain lists of what items a store ''does'' carry, so why would we maintain lists of what they ''don't'' carry? – Deletion of List of albums censored by Wal-Mart WP:NOTCATALOG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12295 5518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Lynch User:GiantSnowman 17:27, 22 November 2009 (UTC) delete fails and ; recreate when and if any of these two concerns are met in the future Deletion of Chris Lynch WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12296 19476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Caplan User:Motor 11:34, 7 June 2006 (UTC) delete a very odd and weirdly enjoyable article that reads like a hoax, but isn't (at least not completely since Amazon backs it up)... but it does fail and the guy doesn't justify an article based on the information provided and that I've found Deletion of Bruce Caplan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12297 2732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Menzoberranzan User:Zahakiel 17:01, 4 December 2007 (UTC) keep """Per my arguments at Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Rod_of_Seven_Parts, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artemis Entreri, Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Mielikki_%28Forgotten_Realms%29, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruenor Battlehammer and the arguments of others at the similarly ill-advised Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Furyondy and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faerûn (this last is particularly relevant as it is a similar setting, and was almost - and should probably have been since there were many """"keeps"""" and only one """"merge"""" - snowball kept). Tedious, almost pointy nomination that ignores editor consensus; unfortunately becoming quite common in Articles for Discussion discussions. Amazing""" Deletion of Menzoberranzan WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12298 11383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salakhat Agaev User:CaliforniaAliBaba 15:17, 17 August 2009 (UTC) keep WP:N|covered by multiple non-trivial newspaper articles({{find|Салахат Агаев}}) as well as meeting by playing for FC Inter Baku, a team in a national top-level division. The ruwiki article is quite well sourced and can be used to expand this article further Deletion of Salakhat Agaev WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12299 16450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Broadbent User:W 19:49, 12 May 2007 (UTC) keep """seems to meet per http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&ned=us&ie=UTF-8&q=%22Michael+Broadbent%22+wine. Described by Decanter (magazine) http://www.decanter.com/news/118580.html as """"one of the international wine industry's most admired figures""" Deletion of Michael Broadbent WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12300 11265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Passons User:power 02:27, 13 February 2018 (UTC) delete doesn't meet . http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/lifestyle/making-a-difference/sdut-omar-passons-united-way-north-park-volunteer-2014mar04-story.html is substantial coverage not related to the election, but everything else is local election coverage that is routinely ignored for the purposes of GNG. Due to the obvious promotional editing I don't think a reasonable page can be maintained at this time Deletion of Omar Passons WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12301 6217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Assistant teacher (2nd nomination) User:David 18:15, 29 September 2017 (UTC) delete """per . The examples chosen for this article seem to have been included primarily because of the similarity of name (the words """"assistant"""" and """"teacher"""" in some order) rather than because they have any close relation to each other than that similarity of naming would already suggest. We have no sources on the broader meaning that this purports to be about. And we already have specific articles on the individual subjects linked here. These articles (in their proper names) are not even easily-enough confused to need a disambiguation page or set-index article; at best we need hatnotes between Foreign Language Assistant and Assistant Language Teacher""" Deletion of Assistant teacher (2nd nomination) WP:NOTDICT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
12302 3554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FeelTheDeal [[User: Allen3|Allen3]]'' [[User talk:Allen3|talk]] 17:59, 9 December 2005 (UTC) delete as per #Wikipedia is not a propaganda machine|Wikipedia is not a propaganda machine. The site is either too new or has too little traffic to generate an Alexa rating.http://www.alexa.com/data/details/?url=www.feelthedeal.com A Google search turns up a handful of mentions to the site in chatrooms, but nothing resembling a |reliable source for the information in the article Deletion of FeelTheDeal WP:NOT||WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12303 4546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United States House of Representatives elections, 2010 - predictions User:Safiel 22:33, 5 August 2010 (UTC) delete per or at very least merge back into the main article Deletion of United States House of Representatives elections, 2010 - predictions WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12304 21507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LiveAuctioneers User:MatthewHoobin 15:05, 23 February 2017 (UTC) keep May only be a stub, but it appears to pass Deletion of LiveAuctioneers WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12305 1457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bradley Maslen-Jones User:Sir 14:43, 11 April 2016 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Bradley Maslen-Jones WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12306 807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Tripp User:Jonathan 09:07, 27 April 2020 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Martin Tripp WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12307 4005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Althaus User:Phantomsteve 12:30, 11 October 2010 (UTC) delete I can find no |reliable |independent sources which would indicate that she meets the criteria for inclusion Deletion of Mary Althaus WP:RS||WP:IS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12308 21329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Administrators (Wikipedia) user:Andrew 15:17, 26 January 2014 (UTC) keep The main article about Wikipedia is 188K which, per , is much too large and so should be divided into sub-topics per . How we divide the content is a matter of editorial discretion and, if the split isn't quite right, would be amended by merger not deletion, per our |editing policy Deletion of Administrators (Wikipedia) WP:SIZE||WP:SPLIT||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Article size 51
12309 6900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Death Cookie [[User talk:Crotalus horridus|*** Crotalus ***]] 21:15, 1 January 2008 (UTC) merge """Looking back, I agree that too much of the article is devoted to plot summary, but there are at least two |reliable third-party sources. Catholic Answers is described on Wikipedia as """"one of the largest Lay apostolates of Catholic apologetics and evangelization in the United States,"""" so their opinion on this issue is probably notable enough to include. (See http://www.catholic.com/library/sr_chick_tracts_p5.asp). Another discussion of the comic is on About.com. According to Wikipedia, """"The content is written by a network of over 600 journalists, called Guides, who are experts in their particular fields."""" Since http://atheism.about.com/library/FAQs/rr/blfaq_rr_chick_religion.htm this discussion was published on About.com, a former Top-10 website that is owned by ''The New York Times'', and written by an expert in the field of atheism/agnosticism, it also deserves inclusion. This article could be condensed into a paragraph-length summary in the main article on Chick tracts""" Deletion of The Death Cookie WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12310 18842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryce Welker User:Dlohcierekim 16:43, 2 June 2017 (UTC) delete coverage shy of what is required to meet in terms of depth or breadth. There's also an interview and something written by the subject. The things smacks me as being overly promo Deletion of Bryce Welker WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12311 16438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leathermouth's first studio album User:Esradekan 02:11, 2 August 2008 (UTC) delete per & Deletion of Leathermouth's first studio album WP:HAMMER||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
12312 15879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prook User:Robofish 22:32, 20 November 2009 (UTC) delete essentially a , with nothing to say about the subject other than a list of claimed examples Deletion of Prook WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
12313 10853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vital needs User:Kinu 17:22, 17 December 2006 (UTC) delete given the inability to find |reliable sources (peer-reviewed journal, etc.) other than the one that is already in the article. Suspected and Deletion of Vital needs WP:RS||WP:OR||WP:COI Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12314 28 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/ETG Danışmanlık Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 08:37, 13 Mayıs 2013 (UTC) delete Ne yeterli kaynak var ne de sayfasındaki kriterleri sağlayan bir içerik ETG Danışmanlık'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
12315 10231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yogacharya Sri Raghavendra Guruji User:Mrt3366 15:34, 4 December 2012 (UTC) delete seems to be failing and Deletion of Yogacharya Sri Raghavendra Guruji WP:PROMOTION||WP:G11 Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12316 4786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Treacherous User:Ikh 16:14, 30 May 2007 (UTC) delete agree with nom. Not notable, unsourced, does not meet Deletion of Treacherous WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12317 18453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Wilson (presenter) User:Rillington NONE comment I'm not sure how you can argue that someone who has been presenting on television and radio for nearly 40 years is not notable. has easily been met. I've also added more independent references Deletion of Michael Wilson (presenter) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12318 14313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darrin Lamoureux User:Bearcat 23:49, 16 September 2020 (UTC) delete """We long ago deprecated the idea that every leader of a political party was automatically handed an """"inherent"""" notability freebie just for existing, without regard to his sourceability or lack thereof. The standard is now that leaders of political parties who are ''not'' also actual MLAs need to clear on their ''sourcing'', which is a significantly higher bar than just being able to verify that they exist — rather, the requirement is to demonstrate the ''significance'' of his leadership, not just the fact of it, and this article isn't doing what's needed""" Deletion of Darrin Lamoureux WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12319 19024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minakshi Mukherjee User:Extraordinary 22:34, 22 May 2021 (UTC) keep By its own terms, does not require the deletion of articles that pass the . The sources presented by Beccaynr do indeed satisfy the GNG, consisting of thorough profiles instead of routine campaign coverage. And the fact that she wasn't obscure prior to running prevents any concerns, as NOT|this essay cogently explains Deletion of Minakshi Mukherjee WP:NPOL||WP:GNG||WP:BLP1E||WP:BLP1ENOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12320 135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Forest Rangers Football Club (Australia) User:Thewinchester 12:21, 22 April 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Article does meet , Deletion of Forest Rangers Football Club (Australia) WP:NOT||WP:ORG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12321 2737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dead rappers User:Arkyan 15:19, 12 April 2007 (UTC) delete as failing . No need to categorize either, doing so would be overcategorization Deletion of Dead rappers WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12322 12860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Immigration Watch Canada User:Kvng 14:41, 29 June 2016 (UTC) keep WP:ORGDEPTH and appear to be met. Excepting , which doesn't apply here, there doesn't seem to be good consensus on deletion based on arguments. In the absence of consensus, we keep Deletion of Immigration Watch Canada WP:GNG||WP:1EVENT||WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12323 2248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zelda Comic User:Coredesat 04:58, 11 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Zelda Comic WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12324 13346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PunishHER User:A1octopus 18:10, 17 April 2007 (UTC) delete Obvious and unsourcable rystal|crystalballery Deletion of PunishHER WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
12325 21239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael J Coudrey User:4meter4 12:22, 24 June 2021 (UTC) delete Fails . The sources are reliable but not significant coverage of the subject. Mere quotes of the subject do not constitute in depth coverage. Further interviews lack the independence necessary to pass GNG. This is not even close to meeting our notability criteria Deletion of Michael J Coudrey WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12326 19557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of prolific songwriters User:K 23:10, 13 January 2018 (UTC) delete WP:NOTINDISCRIMINATE & subjective criteria for inclusion. Does not meet Deletion of List of prolific songwriters WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12327 12106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Handmade Lace Wigs [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 13:30, 12 September 2013 (UTC) delete clearly just an opportunity to link to an e-commerce site, but that's |not what Wikipedia is about Deletion of Handmade Lace Wigs WP:NOTPROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12328 251 [[Hauke Löffler]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Andy king50 10:03, 12. Jun. 2011 (CEST) delete """Es ist Relevanznachweis für die Person nach den Kritierien in #Personen erforderlich und der fehlt. Man kann sicher einiges zum Gründer in dem Artikel des Wiki einbauen, dazu die üblichen 7 Tage (wer möchte kann sich den Text ja auch auf die Festplatte sichern); Als eigenes Lemma dann löschen. Auch aus """"größtes Stadtwiki der Welt"""" folgt nicht, dass die Person relevant ist. Wann sie relevant ist siehe oben verlinkte Kriterien. Wenn er vielleicht Gründer des Bedeutensten Wiki überhaupt (WP ?) wäre oder das erste Wiki überhaupt erfunden hätte, sähe es anders aus""" Löschung von Hauke Löffler Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12329 15203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Clements University User:Arbustoo 15:44, 11 September 2006 (UTC) comment What source do you have that it is an educational institution Deletion of St. Clements University WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12330 15362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nawab Ali Tariq User:BMWcomputer 07:37, 7 August 2012 (UTC) delete For lack of evidence passing . Also looks out of reach Deletion of Nawab Ali Tariq WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12331 12027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GhostSingles.com User:Boneso 10:26, 9 May 2018 (UTC) delete The article is promotional in its nature and (according to the 11 references) has appeared 10 times in articles from October 2013; four being (Time, news.com.au & CBS). definitely applies. Does not meet because there is no substantial coverage in evident. Just because people are still talking about it does not make it notable and google hits are not an indication of notability , =N Deletion of GhostSingles.com WP:PROMO||WP:RS||WP:NEWSBRIEF||WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:GHITS||WP:E Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12332 15143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aedra User:RMHED 18:07, 27 November 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Aedra WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
12333 11312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philippine Prudential Life Insurance Company User:AllyD 13:48, 12 January 2018 (UTC) delete """No |evidence of |notability provided or found. (The present article text is also missing significant change - http://business.inquirer.net/219001/insurance-commission-places-philippine-prudential-under-conservatorship """"Insurance Commission places Philippine Prudential under conservatorship"""", Dec 2016, and subsequent https://www.insurance.gov.ph/Notice/StayOrder-PPLICI stay order - which would need to be edited into the article were it to be retained""" Deletion of Philippine Prudential Life Insurance Company :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12334 17843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Architect of Murder User:Cliff 17:17, 26 August 2008 (UTC) delete per nom: |unreleased book, can be recreated once released if it passes Deletion of The Architect of Murder WP:CRYSTAL||WP:BK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12335 5214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scooby-Doo and the Goblin King User:Ecoleetage 04:22, 14 July 2008 (UTC) keep The film exists - it will be available shortly, so does not apply Deletion of Scooby-Doo and the Goblin King WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12336 15672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Kujawski User:David 16:06, 8 July 2013 (UTC) delete for lack of evidence of passing . Citations too low and no other reason for keeping apparent Deletion of Adam Kujawski WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12337 157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cerro del Quinceo (2nd nomination) User:JeepdaySock 11:38, 11 March 2010 (UTC) delete """seems to fail , there are only trivial mention in references, and half of those refer to it as """"Pico de Quinceo"""", which brings in questions of do the references on the article support the article; are there two minor """"de Quinceos"""" or one with two differetnt names? The lack of response at Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Mexico go to support the complete lack of nobility for this hill""" Deletion of Cerro del Quinceo (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
12338 12682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Usenet cabal [[User talk:Kaustuv|Kaustuv Chaudhuri]] 21:47, 30 July 2006 (UTC) comment this is not a '''''neo'''''logism, and the idea is not ficticioushttp://www.faqs.org/faqs/usenet/cabal-conspiracy-FAQ/, but the current article fails . It should be cleaned up. '''No vote Deletion of Usenet cabal WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12339 7693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CardLife User:Videogameplayer99 20:50, 14 August 2018 (UTC) delete article seems to fail Deletion of CardLife WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12340 18373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chinazi User:Onebravemonkey 16:01, 26 June 2008 (UTC) delete """as an |unverified |neologism. The bulk of the article is not about the term """"Chinazi"""" but rather about China's human rights record, and the professed sources are primarily in support of those statements (and don't contain the term). The two sources that do refer or define the term are for the relevant urbandictionary site and for a simple google search, which should be brought into question anyway as, having had a look through a few of the results, the term appears to be used in several different contexts. Also counting against it is the overwhelming |POV flavour of the writing""" Deletion of Chinazi WP:V||WP:NEO||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12341 13382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zinho Gano User:GiantSnowman 00:59, 12 June 2011 (UTC) delete player fails both and Deletion of Zinho Gano WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12342 6897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Veronica Finn (3rd nomination) User:The 20:23, 28 March 2008 (UTC) merge to innosense, or delete. Finn by herself fails usic, at least by the sources quoted in the article Deletion of Veronica Finn (3rd nomination) WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
12343 20702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willie wortel User:Terence 03:25, 28 May 2006 (UTC) delete nn, fails criteria Deletion of Willie wortel WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12344 12787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spike band User:Lifebaka 22:32, 15 March 2008 (UTC) delete Lacks sources to pass and many statements appear to be . I'd be perfectly happy if someone wanted to improve it, but it hasn't happened for the past two years Deletion of Spike band WP:N||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12345 7446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ModeFRONTIER User:Stifle 19:59, 27 November 2008 (UTC) delete The lack of |citations from |reliable sources indicates to me that the article doesn't meet Deletion of ModeFRONTIER WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12346 1285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mr. Monk and the Man Who Shot Santa User:DHowell 22:35, 21 December 2007 (UTC) keep per |significant coverage in multiple reliable sources: http://www.nwanews.com/adg/Style/209808/ Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, http://www.dailyherald.com/story/?id=90186 Chicago Daily Herald, http://www.cinemablend.com/television/TV-Review-Monk-Mr-Monk-And-The-Man-Who-Shot-Santa-7554.html CinemaBlend, and http://www.buddytv.com/articles/monk/monk-returns-tonight-for-a-hol-14521.aspx BuddyTV Deletion of Mr. Monk and the Man Who Shot Santa WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12347 21725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of guitarists (2nd nomination) User:MacGyverMagic 12:53, 10 March 2009 (UTC) keep per . This is a list that provides functionality not provided by categories which makes them valid navigational aides. The length probably warrants sublists, but that can be handled through editing instead of deletion Deletion of List of guitarists (2nd nomination) WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
12348 13242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Remiro NONE NONE keep This article meets rime requirements Deletion of Joe Remiro WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
12349 4568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nondance Records User:Redfarmer 00:36, 29 January 2008 (UTC) delete WP:BAND, Deletion of Nondance Records WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12350 1351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/P.K.(2014 film) User:Tokyogirl79 19:46, 22 January 2013 (UTC) keep I agree with Schmidt- this looks to be one of those rare circumstances that a film meets without being a major Hollywood film and without starting principal filming. If all else fails, this should be incubated so that if/when filming does start by the end of the month, it can be re-added Deletion of P.K.(2014 film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12351 10311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thefurniture.com User:High 23:24, 8 August 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. The assumption that any company becomes notable after a few years of existence, even if it is not larger than an average supermarket, is false. I might be wrong, but it seems not unlikely that the article's creator might be in some relationship with the company. In that case, please read . Regards Deletion of Thefurniture.com WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
12352 16411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti-Hungarian sentiment User:Duja 14:16, 4 June 2007 (UTC) delete """fails . See also my refute to """"keep and improve"""" arguments at the http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia%3AArticles_for_deletion%2FSerbophobia_%28fifth_nomination%29&diff=135782744&oldid=135779833 Serbophobia AfD""" Deletion of Anti-Hungarian sentiment WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
12353 8799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Truck (game) User:ST47 11:15, 23 August 2006 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of Big Truck (game) WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
12354 4663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jana Sanchez User:Less 11:20, 20 January 2021 (UTC) delete The number of sources cited is not the only proof of notability. The subject is widely covered above all as a candidate, who did not make it all the way to the Congress. This she fails . She would have passed only if at least 3 independent reliable sources covered her in detail APART from the election process. However this is not the case - all of the sources are tied to her activities performed within the election process. So in my opinion, she is not eligible for an article Deletion of Jana Sanchez WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12355 6401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Daughters of Bristol User:Rune 20:45, 21 October 2005 (UTC) delete Does not meet guidelines of Deletion of The Daughters of Bristol WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12356 7001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelechi Iheanacho User:Pbradbury 19:15, 26 June 2015 (UTC) keep Meets especially with all the coverage in Nigeria, sources don't all have to be western to make someone notable in there own country Deletion of Kelechi Iheanacho WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12357 9014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad Naeem (cricketer, born 1959) User:DevaCat1 17:54, 26 February 2021 (UTC) keep as with a huge range of other AfDs, the correct standard is not , but which is passed by virtue of playing both first class and List A cricket Deletion of Mohammad Naeem (cricketer, born 1959) WP:GNG||WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12358 20411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phil Price (sculptor) User:Lopifalko 18:03, 21 October 2019 (UTC) keep """With ThatMontrealIP's work on this, it easily passes with just the """"Permanent collections"""" alone""" Deletion of Phil Price (sculptor) WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
12359 21492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Love You Breathe (song) User:Esradekan 23:27, 27 February 2009 (UTC) delete as a non-plausible search term, fails notability per #Songs Deletion of This Love You Breathe (song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12360 20099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Tepper User:Bagumba 06:39, 17 August 2011 (UTC) delete Fails , having never played at highest level. Fails with lack of non-|routine coverage in multiple independent reliable sources. would suggest not to speculate on future notability based on whether the undrafted player ever plays in the NFL Deletion of Mike Tepper WP:NSPORTS||WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12361 180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raymond E. Foster User:Grey 07:19, 24 February 2019 (UTC) delete Clearly promotional in tone and content. Unlikely to meet Deletion of Raymond E. Foster WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12362 229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcello Serpa User:The 13:02, 10 February 2018 (UTC) keep I see many online (and added a few), for a highly notable ad exec winning top awards in his profession: these could easily have been found an AFD Deletion of Marcello Serpa WP:RS||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12363 15528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelloggsville [[User talk:Cometstyles|Cometstyles]] 15:30, 1 March 2007 (UTC) delete Not of criteria Deletion of Kelloggsville WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12364 13517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gabrielle Giffords User:Wine 00:51, 16 July 2006 (UTC) keep Borderline, but as a state senator and per I lean slightly in favor of this one Deletion of Gabrielle Giffords WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12365 3322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teebeedee User:Shell_Kinney 22:22, 12 March 2008 (UTC) delete fails |notability requirements, could almost be deleted as advertising Deletion of Teebeedee WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12366 12432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of articles about local government in the United Kingdom User:Ahunt 13:10, 25 October 2011 (UTC) delete Non-notable list, fails . This could be made into a category Deletion of List of articles about local government in the United Kingdom WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12367 9194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Critchlow User:Trackinfo 09:03, 17 November 2017 (UTC) keep Passes as above, already proven by the first source. Referring to the delete vote, from our permanently delete voting member, if additional sources are necessary suggests he could have looked for more. I have added a few Deletion of Joe Critchlow WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12368 55 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Oruç Aruoba Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 21:12, 30 Eylül 2016 (UTC) delete Emeğin için teşekkürler. Sunulan kaynakların hemen hepsi şahsın kendi yazıları, metinleri, çevirileri ile çalıştığı kurumların sitelerini içeriyor. |Bağımsız olmayan kaynak oldukları için kayda değerliğin ispatı hususunda göz önüne alınmaz. http://www.academia.edu/10548289/Düşünceden_Dile_Oruç_Aruoba_da_Metafor Şu kaynak güzel ama tek başına yeterli değil maalesef Oruç Aruoba'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:Bağımsız kaynaklar Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12369 20732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank Finnerty (2nd nomination) User:Alansohn 18:17, 26 April 2007 (UTC) comment """I agree 100%. There is no claim that he is notable """"just because"""" he's an elected official. At the top of the list on where you pulled the """"just because"""" clause, is a statement that '''""""This list is only a guideline, and should not be used an absolute test of notability; each article should stand or fall on its own merits.""""''' The claim that this individual is notable is based on the fact that there are nearly a dozen independent, reliable and verifiable sources all of which demonstrate notability. The claim stands proven""" Deletion of Frank Finnerty (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12370 255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pepperpot (Monty Python) User:Schizombie 00:09, 27 December 2009 (UTC) delete That an article hasn't improved much in X years or referenced after being tagged for X years is not evidence it couldn't, but even as a Python fan I have to agree there's not much could say about these characters, for a general encyclopedia anyway. http://books.google.com/books?q=%2Bpepperpot%20%2B%22monty%20python%22&hl=en&sa=N&tab=sp Google Books (including a ''Monty Python Encyclopedia'') and http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%2Bpepperpot+%2B%22monty+python%22&hl=en&btnG=Search&as_sdt=2001&as_sdtp=on Google Scholar if anyone wants to look for substantial coverage. It's been mirrored by the Monty Python Wiki, so they have it if they want it. I guess it could be merged to List of recurring characters in Monty Python's Flying Circus or a ''Glossary of Monty Python'' could be created following but I am not inclined to create one myself Deletion of Pepperpot (Monty Python) WP:RS||WP:WPGLOSSARY Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12371 21588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/XBLite User:Stifle 20:36, 30 April 2008 (UTC) delete unless |citations from |reliable sources are added to comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of XBLite WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12372 5915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheikh chilli User:MER 12:53, 3 February 2007 (UTC) delete appears to be a non-notable |neologism Deletion of Sheikh chilli WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
12373 5437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helen Gloag User:MichaelQSchmidt 19:28, 23 June 2009 (UTC) keep as article is now properly expanded and sourced per Deletion of Helen Gloag WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
12374 4175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of the best positions of Spain in the Olympic Summer events User:KartikeyaS343 16:55, 12 March 2020 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of the best positions of Spain in the Olympic Summer events WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12375 19615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canada and the 2016 United States presidential election User:Satellizer 10:49, 14 May 2016 (UTC) delete """a and listing of every time Canada has been invoked in the United States election. Just the opening phrase """"so far Canada has played a very minor role in the upcoming US presidential election"""" suggests such an article shouldn't exist, or at least not currently""" Deletion of Canada and the 2016 United States presidential election WP:COATRACK||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
12376 5348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tejinder Singh User:Dlohcierekim 20:27, 31 August 2013 (UTC) delete Significant and living, but does not meet Deletion of Tejinder Singh WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12377 17783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indian century (3rd nomination) User:Mar4d 17:37, 18 January 2015 (UTC) delete into Asian Century per . It's a purely speculative concept that isn't going to become a reality any time soon and is probably as much meaningful as a Brazilian Century or for that matter a Somali Century. We may as well have articles like The end of Earth and the Reign of the Martians. Just because a couple of sources speculate a concept that is itself nothing more than speculation (I say this after having thoroughly reviewed sources available on the topic) does not translate into being notable enough for a standalone article Deletion of Indian century (3rd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12378 15868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Thomson (politician) User:Silver 23:39, 8 May 2010 (UTC) comment I have tagged this article for |rescue Deletion of Sarah Thomson (politician) WP:ARS Wikipedia:Article Rescue Squadron 98
12379 3748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Kevan User:Ultra 06:19, 2 October 2006 (UTC) delete as vanity, failure, and per the above arguments Deletion of Tim Kevan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12380 10113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Information source User:Clarityfiend 20:23, 22 January 2020 (UTC) delete as a . It's just not a source of much information Deletion of Information source WP:DICTDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
12381 8903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southwest Airlines Flight 1763 User:Oakshade 04:55, 14 January 2012 (UTC) keep """As the topic passes , the nom has given absolutely no rationale as to why they think the topic doesn't pass GNG. As Arxiloxos elaborates, this topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject and the definition of is """"If a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject,"""" then it passes """ Deletion of Southwest Airlines Flight 1763 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12382 6776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marijan Rističević User:JulieSpaulding 15:16, 26 January 2010 (UTC) comment The only truly reliable source I can find is the http://translate.google.ca/translate?&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.naslovi.net%2F2008-01-26%2Fpress%2Fmarijan-risticevic-podrzao-nikolica-u-drugom-krugu-izbor%2F555630 English translation of the reference cited on the page. prefers multiple sources as opposed to just one Deletion of Marijan Rističević WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12383 17158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J. O. Matthewson User:The 06:13, 16 June 2018 (UTC) delete per nomination, on account of subject failing Deletion of J. O. Matthewson WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12384 1575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Thought I'd Seen Everything (Stevie Vann song) User:Esradekan 12:49, 5 June 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of I Thought I'd Seen Everything (Stevie Vann song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12385 18835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Our Space In Time [[User talk:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) '''''' (talk) ''']] 09:47, 20 August 2006 (UTC) delete as a non-notable band, refers Deletion of Our Space In Time WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12386 5118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/June Swann User:Davey2010 01:11, 10 September 2015 (UTC) keep per MKDW - |Before nominating any article editors ''are'' expected to search for sources which judging by this AFD the nominator clearly hasn't done that!, Anyway article's been expanded and judging by MKDW's findings i'd say notability's certainly there Deletion of June Swann WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
12387 2390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Necrosis (band) (2nd nomination) User:Nosebagbear 12:23, 3 May 2019 (UTC) delete and salt'') - {{ping|Shirt58}} - me and Salvidrim felt this was actually a different article, but I'll focus on it in current form in any case. Notability clearly not established - distinct failure to satisfy Deletion of Necrosis (band) (2nd nomination) WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12388 21527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muzik 4 machines User:Brewcrewer 08:29, 4 December 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Muzik 4 machines WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12389 15624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2027 Rugby World Cup User:Lugnuts 19:25, 22 March 2016 (UTC) delete Nothing in the article to support this. It ''probably'' will happen, but as the bidding hasn't started, seems to fail Deletion of 2027 Rugby World Cup WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12390 17349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/'The Night Mail' User:UnnamedUser 03:02, 21 November 2019 (UTC) merge as non-notable poem that is relevant to the film it was written for. No particular information needs to be preserved since the article already gives some mentions of it. All sources I can find are blogs or lyrics sites, or they only give a short mention of the poem. (If they copy-paste the poem but don't elaborate on it beyond a single sentence, it still fails Deletion of 'The Night Mail' WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12391 3905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Youth Friendship Games User:AO 10:58, 17 January 2007 (UTC) delete I heard about it, but no one else I know does. It fails Deletion of Youth Friendship Games WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12392 3933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Thomas (basketball) User:Edgars2007 11:13, 15 June 2012 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Ben Thomas (basketball) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12393 3519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mikhail Volkenshtein User:Terence 11:49, 7 March 2006 (UTC) keep meets Deletion of Mikhail Volkenshtein WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12394 5088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Posillico User:Carioca 20:35, 5 October 2010 (UTC) delete he fails both and Deletion of Joseph Posillico WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12395 9756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Godi media User:Shankargb 01:01, 4 May 2021 (UTC) delete per my request above. Subject fails Deletion of Godi media WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12396 14903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IA Collaborative User:RileyBugz 23:07, 10 July 2017 (UTC) delete Basically promotion, and not enough coverage to pass Deletion of IA Collaborative WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12397 274 [[Kumulative Habilitation]] (erl.) Benutzer:NearEMPTiness NONE keep Mit ''wikt:Fug|Fug'' und Recht möchte ich klarstellen, dass es sich bei diesem Artikel - anders als beim Löschantrag - keineswegs um ''Unfug'' handelt. Eine kurze https://www.google.at/search?q=Kumulative+Habilitation Google-Recherche hätte dem Löschantragsteller eigentlich mit 19.000 Ergebnissen in 0,31 sec vor Augen führen müssen, welch wichtige Funktion die kumulative Habilitation im deutschsprachigen Raum in einigen Fachbereichen inzwischen einnimmt. Anhand dieser Quellen, war es leicht, den Artikel auf drei durch Einzelnachweise belegte Sätze aufzublähen sic!, obwohl doch eigentlich in der Kürze die Würze liegt. Ich schlage vor, diesen Artikel zu und sich auch rege an der /Mai_2017#Kumulative Dissertation - Dissertation|Redundanzdiskussion zur Kumulative Dissertation|kumulativen Dissertation zu beteiligen Löschung von Kumulative Habilitation Wikipedia:Redundanz Wikipedia:Redundanz 95
12398 18146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellie Robinson (politician) User:Mccapra 04:29, 26 August 2020 (UTC) delete as does not meet Deletion of Ellie Robinson (politician) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12399 5879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Picaboo User:Crystallizedcarbon 11:06, 5 July 2017 (UTC) keep Bloomberg, TechCrunch and the WSJ provide more than just trivial mentions, so I believe that it barely meets our |general notability guidelines and that it does not violate |what Wikipedia is not. I have removed from the article the content sourced by the corporate page and the related references to eliminate the promotional tone. The remaining stub I believe meets, just barely, our criteria for inclusion. At the beginning of the article there is a disambiguation note pointing to Snapchat Deletion of Picaboo WP:GNG||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12400 13751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ice Tropez User:DustFormsWords 23:04, 19 October 2009 (UTC) delete per - no reliable independent sources. Article clearly established as self promotion and assertion of notability within the article is unclear at best Deletion of Ice Tropez WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12401 88 [[Hilla M. Faseluka]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers 17:57, 10. Aug. 2012 (CEST) delete """Kasten|1=. #Autoren werden nicht erreicht, da Veröffentlichungen über epubli nicht als """"reguläre Verlage"""" zählen (d.h. Verlage, die bei der Veröffentlichung wirklich ein verlegerisches Risiko tragen und deswegen genau auswählen müssen, wann sie das Risiko tragen). Gestutzt bin ich über den Deutscher Buchpreis|Deutschen Buchpreis, aber tatsächlich handelt es sich um eine Teilnahme am """"http://www.hillafaseluka.at/aktuell/ Neuen Buchpreis"""", einem epubli-internen Wettbewerb, also sicher keinem Literaturpreis von Bedeutung. Gruß""" Löschung von Hilla M. Faseluka Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12402 9675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Internet slang User:Friday 14:40, 21 February 2006 (UTC) delete per , but this is purely academic. The only reason this exists at all is so that silly little kids who forget how to get to urban dictionary have a place to put their unverifiable cruft. On a pure cost-benefit analysis, this article does not benefit the project. There's little or no encyclopedic value, and keeping it in any kind of reasonable shape is more effort than people have been willing to put in. Those that want to cut it down and merge it to Internet slang have a reasonable idea, but they've forgotten to be practical. The reason it exists is that people wanted Internet slang to be in some kind of reasonable shape so they moved all the crap to another article Deletion of List of Internet slang WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12403 49 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Adnan Kazmaoğlu Kullanıcı: evuntiaevuntia 10.42, 22 Mayıs 2021 (UTC) delete Eserleri, |Yaratıcı meslek KD kriterlerini karşılayacak nitelikte değil. Capitol veya Akhisar Stadyumunun mimarileriyle nam saldıklarını düşünmüyorum Adnan Kazmaoğlu'nun silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
12404 15623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thornlea Secondary School User:Camaron1 10:22, 29 August 2007 (UTC) keep The article is in need of a cleanup but a search indicates it can potentially pass and Deletion of Thornlea Secondary School WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
12405 388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bapunagar Darpan User:GPL93 12:50, 28 February 2020 (UTC) delete None of the sourcing is reliable or independent. Fails and . Best Deletion of Bapunagar Darpan WP:GNG||WP:NMEDIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
12406 1000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Business Value of Social Networking User:Doc 17:05, 21 January 2008 (UTC) delete per and #WEBSPACE Deletion of Business Value of Social Networking WP:OR||WP:NOT Wikipedia:No original research 65
12407 20854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roses (Kanye West song) (2nd nomination) User:TheJazzDalek 13:39, 1 April 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Roses (Kanye West song) (2nd nomination) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12408 21253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanjay Chauhan (politician) User:Bearcat 15:49, 15 February 2020 (UTC) delete Shimla is a large enough city that a ''substantive'' and ''well sourced'' article about a mayor could potentially be kept, but this article is nowhere near substantive or well-sourced enough to pass #2 Deletion of Sanjay Chauhan (politician) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12409 7721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mural of Marcus Rashford User:Bilorv 19:31, 19 July 2021 (UTC) keep I'll tell you how famous this mural is—it came up in conversation recently between me and my mother, who have the least awareness of football that it's possible to have while being English. |GNG is passed by the sources in the article, particularly https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/striking-a-pose-for-marcus-rashford-xbbzf3plt ''The Times'', https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-54897367 BBC, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/13/world/europe/marcus-rashford-soccer-racism-mural.html NYT and the https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-57803161 BBC again. Note that substantial coverage comes from multiple events (unveiling and vandalism) so it's not . The article is sufficiently long that not all of the information can be merged into Marcus Rashford without exceeding length or due weight sensibilities, and it can definitely be expanded further Deletion of Mural of Marcus Rashford WP:GNG||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
12410 5148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of wars involving Nepal User:Mkdw 17:55, 15 January 2017 (UTC) keep WP:LISTCRUFT is an essay -- not a policy based argument for deletion. The topic is likely widely covered and cited by other encyclopedias and meets our criteria for Deletion of List of wars involving Nepal WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12411 9856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William A. Griffin (Christian Churches/Churches of Christ) User:Rrburke 01:02, 21 February 2010 (UTC) delete non-notable former university president. Sporadic mentions in news sources, mostly local, but no |significant coverage Deletion of William A. Griffin (Christian Churches/Churches of Christ) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12412 126 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ali Mehmet Kocaoğlu Kullanıcı:corioliscoriolis 13:49, 19 Şubat 2012 (UTC) keep """1998 yılında Türk Hukuk Enstitüsü tarafından yılın hukukçusu seçilmesi, 2003-2006 yılları arasında Türkiye İlim Edebiyat Sahipleri Meslek Birliği’nin başkanlığını yapması nedeniyle yönergesindeki """"kişinin, önemli sayılan ödüller kazanmış olması"""" ve """"yaratıcı meslekler"""" bölümünde yer alan """"kişi meslektaşları veya ardından gelenlerce önemli bir kişilik sayılmakta"""" kriterlerini karşıladığını düşünüyorum. Belki de http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability_(academics) şu yönergeyi çevirmek gerek. --Kullanıcı mesaj:Seksen iki yüz kırk beş|seksen""" Ali Mehmet Kocaoğlu'nun silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda değerlik (kişi) Wikipedia:Notability 77
12413 4534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Farman User:Fenix 15:50, 22 November 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Paul Farman WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12414 6599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ESPN College Football on ABC results User:Clarityfiend 23:12, 19 September 2016 (UTC) delete per . One-eyed horse thieves in Montana would be offended to be left out if trash like this were kept Deletion of ESPN College Football on ABC results WP:SALAT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
12415 17890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jobspeed User:Lankiveil 00:24, 27 June 2010 (UTC) delete despite the lack of a rationale, I'm not sure that this site meets Deletion of Jobspeed WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12416 2471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/La Conecta User:Esradekan 07:51, 19 April 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of La Conecta WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12417 829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coney Island Hot Dog Stand User:Oakshade 03:29, 21 February 2007 (UTC) keep The multiple published works that are primarily about this subject satsify Deletion of Coney Island Hot Dog Stand WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12418 4024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanga International School User:Edinburgh 22:29, 6 January 2012 (UTC) delete does not meet or current school guidelines Deletion of Tanga International School WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12419 5782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SamBakZa User:Wsiegmund 03:58, 21 March 2006 (UTC) delete The web site has an Alexa rank >900k. . http://www.alexa.com/data/details/?url=sambakza.net Deletion of SamBakZa WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12420 20883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vishal Jolly User:Bearian 19:59, 14 February 2020 (UTC) delete per , , and . Lost their only campaign for public office, as I did Deletion of Vishal Jolly WP:NPOL||WP:SIGCOV||WP:SOAP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12421 2929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/On My Knees: The Best of Jaci Velasquez (album) User:John 20:39, 30 October 2019 (UTC) delete There are no suitable sources; other than e-commerce sites and AllMusic/Discogs, all I can find with a Google Search is https://www.jesusfreakhideout.com/cdreviews/OnMyKneesTheBestOfJaciVelasquez.asp this, which appears to be slighly |BLPSPS. Also, even if we take Dodger67's comment at face value, such a reduction in notability is temporary; this came out in 2006, and having not achieved notability in the intervening 13 years means that it probably wouldn't do so anytime soon. &ndash Deletion of On My Knees: The Best of Jaci Velasquez (album) WP:BLPSPS Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12422 17568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark MacMillan User:Djsasso 14:15, 9 June 2015 (UTC) delete Non-notable amateur player who fails to meet Deletion of Mark MacMillan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12423 16206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wagaman Reference Lines User:B 04:16, 16 October 2008 (UTC) delete per |Wikipedia is not a place for something made up in school one day. Not sourced; in fact, the article basically states that it's |original research Deletion of Wagaman Reference Lines WP:NOT||WP:NOR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12424 10610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/European Waterways User:The 22:40, 2 October 2012 (UTC) keep The operator meets , while the articles on the barges are articles on ''ships'', and long consensus has shown that ships over 100 feet in length or 100 tons in displacement - which all of the listed ships are - are likely to be found notable, which they do, indeed, appear to be Deletion of European Waterways WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12425 17424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Forward (generic name of socialist publications) [[User talk:71.175.53.239|talk]]) 14:04, 3 May 2012 (UTC) comment Articles in ''not'' patent nonsense, hence does not fall under #G1 Special:Contributions/71.175.53.239|71.175.53.239 Deletion of Forward (generic name of socialist publications) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12426 16794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yuwen Zhang User:PCock 20:13, 5 August 2010 (UTC) keep """No visits to page"""" would not be a valid reason to delete a Wikipedia article, even if it were true. The subject of this article appears to meet Wikipedia's criteria for inclusion as outlined at """ Deletion of Yuwen Zhang WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12427 9201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Narnia in video games User:Rorshacma NONE delete The topic is already covered in greater detail at Adaptations of The Chronicles of Narnia#Games, and neither that article nor section is long enough that a is appropriate. This article is also almost completely unsourced, and I question the validity of most of the information included in it (studios that did not exist until the 90's are being credited with developing games from the early 80's, for example). So none of this unsourced material should be preserved or merged anywhere Deletion of Narnia in video games WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Splitting 57
12428 15729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2*Sweet User:Guest9999 10:28, 24 October 2008 (UTC) delete """I can't find any |reliable sources upon which a |verifiable p|encyclopaedia article and http://www.purevolume.com/2sweetil """"we are proudly unsigned and love playing for anyone, anywhere, anytime."""" to me indicates that there probably aren't any to be found""" Deletion of 2*Sweet WP:RS||WP:V||WP:5||WP:5p Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12429 14790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Operation Oxpecker User:Jimfbleak 13:38, 23 January 2012 (UTC) delete Obvious cut-and-paste (note the reference to Appendix 4???, absence of wikilinks, non-standard formatting). Clearly taken from |OR of unknown copyright status, creator still hasn't clearly identified the source. No indication that any proper academic sources have been consulted Deletion of Operation Oxpecker WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12430 9450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert V. Bartlett User:David 05:27, 20 February 2020 (UTC) keep I just added seven reviews of four of his books to the article, found only through searching jstor (probably more can be found elsewhere). So as well as #C5 (which is anyway an easy keep) I think he also passes Deletion of Robert V. Bartlett WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12431 21335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Evans (boxer) User:Astudent0 17:46, 26 March 2012 (UTC) delete No indication of notability. Article consists of the statement he's a professional boxer. He's now had 5 professional fights and obviously fails #Boxing Deletion of Mark Evans (boxer) WP:NSPORTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12432 8247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dart Drug User:CASSIOPEIA 05:20, 29 March 2018 (UTC) delete fails to be a stand alone article in Wikipedia Deletion of Dart Drug WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
12433 14519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gamergate (disambiguation) User:Feminist 01:34, 28 December 2018 (UTC) keep Three ambiguous articles, one of which is the . A disambiguation page is preferred to a long hatnote Deletion of Gamergate (disambiguation) WP:PTOPIC Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
12434 18398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monopoli (band) User:Davey2010 11:26, 9 July 2014 (UTC) delete per nom - Found no evidence of any notability, So Fails Deletion of Monopoli (band) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12435 5129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taharrush gamea User:E 15:51, 13 January 2016 (UTC) keep although I would prefer an English name for this phenomenon. The fact is tha tcoverage of this is now massive http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/12/world/europe/swedish-police-coverup-sexual-assault.html and multiple incidents http://www.dw.com/en/swedish-police-accused-of-covering-up-festival-sex-assault/a-18972345 have been revealed, some are enumerated in the Cologne article. As a topic, it passes Deletion of Taharrush gamea WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12436 328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Wood User:David 19:59, 15 April 2016 (UTC) delete Sources are either by him or don't mention him, and the major claims of the article have no reliable sourcing. I didn't see any highly cited publications in Google scholar. No evidence of passing or Deletion of Matt Wood WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12437 20756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Klondike Kalamity User:Orangemike 00:12, 21 February 2008 (UTC) delete unless we can come up with some kind of |reliable sources that discuss it, a few Googlehits is not enough to meet |notability requirements. Surely the author ought to have some clippings from theater trade journals, etc Deletion of Klondike Kalamity :WP:RS||:WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12438 17751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/E(38) boson User:Cyclopia 14:27, 29 August 2014 (UTC) keep per DGG and... nominator, who states that it had actual coverage in press. It thus passes . {{tq|There's lots of things with general press coverage.}} - Yeah. And these things are notable per our policies and guidelines Deletion of E(38) boson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12439 14695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angela Hondru User:Xxanthippe 22:17, 21 February 2014 (UTC) delete No evidence of passing rof Deletion of Angela Hondru WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
12440 6988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spencer Clark User:Arnzy 10:00, 27 May 2006 (UTC) delete doesnt meet for me Deletion of Spencer Clark WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12441 16130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harold Terry User:Carlossuarez46 17:42, 14 October 2014 (UTC) delete """not notable per nom & Bearcat. If this level of """"notability"""" were acceptable, nearly every elected or appointed official of any level would meet it. Many are veterans; others have no doubt had """"interesting"""" careers, all documented by alumni magazines, local rags, and governmental websites. . Wikipedia:Trivial mentions""" Deletion of Harold Terry WP:TRIVIAL Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12442 20646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of startups in Pakistan User:Ajf773 12:16, 7 November 2018 (UTC) delete WP:NOTDIRECTORY and . I'm pretty sure this article has been deleted before under a different title Deletion of List of startups in Pakistan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12443 20831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rohit Pande User:Northamerica1000 16:08, 25 April 2012 (UTC) keep The topic passes . For starters, see http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-01-03/news/30584848_1_slow-learners-tablet-education-system and http://www.dnaindia.com/money/report_iitian-devises-tablet-for-the-classroom_1631375 Deletion of Rohit Pande WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12444 21203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Engineering Research Building User:Ammarpad 09:35, 6 December 2017 (UTC) delete and don't redirect. Because though the building deserves mention on Wikipedia but no content enough for whole standalone article . No about it to warrant that. I also are with the thought above that redirect is not appropriate here due to the genericity of the name. So new section in the main article is more appropriate thing here Deletion of Engineering Research Building WP:NOPAGE||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12445 15696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Tucker (singer) User:Tedius 09:10, 4 August 2009 (UTC) keep per and Deletion of Lisa Tucker (singer) WP:RS||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12446 17807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angelina Valentine User:Davey2010 00:59, 23 December 2014 (UTC) keep per everyone above - Passes Deletion of Angelina Valentine WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12447 4645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kalabhavan Road User:Animeshkulkarni 13:35, 23 July 2012 (UTC) comment Why not redirect? After all |they are cheap. This article can be redirected to Kochin. {{small|(I am gonna do that on almost all AfDs now Deletion of Kalabhavan Road WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
12448 18953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wikipedia Art controversy User:DanielRigal 16:20, 30 April 2009 (UTC) comment """As a domain name dispute it is so minor as to be laughable. It would be receiving no coverage at all if it wasn't for the people involved hyping it and seeking to present it as something it isn't. It seems that there is an attempt to use the domain name dispute as an excuse to reopen the argument about the rights and wrongs about the original deletion of the """"Wikipedia Art"""" article (the one that was supposed to be an artwork in itself, rather than an encyclopaedia article and hence got deleted from this encyclopaedia for not being an encyclopaedia article). Domain name disputes are ''normally'' only notable if they get to court, and even then only if they are significant cases, but this seems to be picking up some limited RS coverage despite it being a complete non-story. The problem is that RS coverage is RS coverage. We can't pick and choose which RS coverage can be used to reference an article just on the basis that we suspect it to be poor or trivial journalism. I am yet to be convinced that the coverage in RS sources is """"significant"""", as is required, but I can see that it is close. The other hurdle to overcome, which nobody has mentioned yet, is . I am not sure whether this article falls foul of that or not. Maybe it is too early to say.Maybe there is a case to keep this article. After all, there are many other Wikipedia articles about subjects which are only notable because somebody chose to hype them and the RS press chose to allow itself to be hyped. We can tut and roll our eyes but we can't sweep them all away. An encyclopaedia has to cover everything notable, including the shallower and more minor things to become noted in the world. This doesn't bother me. What does bother me is that '''the article may be an ongoing source of disruption'''. (Note: I am not suggesting that this itself is a reason to delete.) It will need to be monitored closely to ensure that it stays on-topic (i.e. keeps to the domain name dispute), only relies on genuine RS references, does not give give |undue, |biased or promotional coverage of what remains a very minor matter""" Deletion of Wikipedia Art controversy WP:NOTNEWS||WP:UNDUE||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12449 19159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter fossey User:Accurizer 02:52, 30 December 2006 (UTC) delete does not satisfy or Wikipedia:Notability (academics), claim of medal not supported by http://www.ais.org.au/overview/games/honourrollcg86.asp as noted in my prod nomination Deletion of Peter fossey WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12450 16175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ecogen User:DrStrauss 15:34, 28 August 2017 (UTC) delete no indication of |corporate notability. No coverage in |independent, reliable sources Deletion of Ecogen WP:NCORP||WP:IRS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12451 16777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of FIFA U-20 World Cup hat-tricks User:Fenix 12:01, 14 September 2015 (UTC) delete No indication that the notion of hat tricks at the U20 WC has achieved any significant level of coverage as a subject itself. this is just pure Deletion of List of FIFA U-20 World Cup hat-tricks WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12452 13062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sayeed Abubakar (Poet) User:Spiderone 20:16, 31 July 2021 (UTC) delete no reliable, independent coverage so clearly fails Deletion of Sayeed Abubakar (Poet) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12453 448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GoPets (2nd nomination) User:Monty845 08:06, 26 March 2011 (UTC) keep I fixed the transclusion on the AFD page for today, and looking at this http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Gryphoness talk page, I see links to http://www.redherring.com/Home/17516 and http://rpgvault.ign.com/articles/747/747270p1.html both of which seem satisfy Deletion of GoPets (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12454 20758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthropomorphobia User:Arkyan 20:47, 26 June 2007 (UTC) delete Completely unreferenced, no reliable sources, and has a faint hint of to it Deletion of Anthropomorphobia WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12455 4961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/General Motors Impact User:Electric 23:34, 11 February 2011 (UTC) keep I think that the page may be a content fork, however it does have specific information about the concept car (Impact) that does not affect the EV-1. It also does not have issues. Everything it talks about is neutral and factual that has supporting quotes and information from the people talked about Deletion of General Motors Impact WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
12456 4437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iran at the 2016 Asian Beach Games User:Comatmebro 16:13, 2 October 2016 (UTC) delete Could not locate third-party coverage of this specific country in the Asia Beach games. Per nom, fails and should be deleted Deletion of Iran at the 2016 Asian Beach Games WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12457 18150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Eve Carson User:Fritzpoll 07:47, 30 July 2009 (UTC) keep """notable per the general notability guideline and otability (criminal acts) - significant, ongoing coverage about the event, which is the subject of this article indicates notability. Can I also mention that """"merge and delete"""" is almost certainly illegal due to our licensing here. and that Bugs and I were on opposite sides of this debate last time""" Deletion of Murder of Eve Carson WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12458 3966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faisal Sanitary Fitting User:HighKing 13:02, 30 April 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and GNG. Could have been speedy deleted. I tried to edit the article to strip away puffery and irrelevant details and I was left with a modified opening sentence Deletion of Faisal Sanitary Fitting WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
12459 1028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar & The Spitmonkeys User:Malo 17:42, 20 October 2005 (UTC) delete http://www.allmusic.com allmusic.com has no results for either this band's name, or its lead singer. I am unable to find any matchup with guidelines for notablity. I got zero google results Deletion of Omar & The Spitmonkeys WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12460 4696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark L. Hunt User:Lubbad85 01:51, 27 March 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Mark L. Hunt WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12461 21237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greeks in Poland User:Alexikoua 09:04, 4 May 2009 (UTC) keep the article establishes notability with |multiple non-trivial, reliable sources cited in the References section (Fleming paper). The refugees weren't just composed of ethnic Macedonians but of ethnic Greeks as well (possible 50-50 Deletion of Greeks in Poland WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12462 1274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sitanshu Yashaschandra User:Rpclod 22:14, 19 July 2014 (UTC) keep I think that Nizil saved this article by demonstrating substantial coverage. As such, the subject meets among other criteria Deletion of Sitanshu Yashaschandra WP:SCHOLAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12463 20947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scissett Football Club User:Reaper 21:55, 24 February 2011 (UTC) delete This fails Deletion of Scissett Football Club WP:CLUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12464 10750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary oak's cheerleaders User:Bsimmons666 00:08, 3 November 2008 (UTC) delete No real world relevance indicated; Deletion of Gary oak's cheerleaders WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12465 11570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twisted (2001 film) User:Hobbes 02:38, 16 April 2012 (UTC) delete Little coverage, none of it substantial and , that I can see. Fails Deletion of Twisted (2001 film) WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12466 5825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Megumi Tano User:Rms125a 20:06, 3 June 2016 (UTC) delete non-notable voice actress with minimal credentials. Maybe just |TOO SOON Deletion of Megumi Tano WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
12467 14438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Fellman User:Zanoni 18:16, 6 October 2009 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Daniel Fellman WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12468 4292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joey Clement User:Michig 10:09, 29 January 2012 (UTC) keep or '''Redirect''' to Selena Gomez & the Scene. Member of two notable bands, if that can be verified, so passes ctiterion 6 - I couldn't find a reliable source for his membership of the Midwest Kings and none of the sources in that article mention him. If we can't verify that, redirect to the other band per standard practice for musicians without individual notability Deletion of Joey Clement WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12469 79 [[Verteidige dein Netz]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Tom_md NONE delete Wo soll das denn ein gültiger sein?? In einem solchen ist die Relevanz nachgewiesen, das hier ist ein verzichtbarer Ein-Satz-Stummel Löschung von Verteidige dein Netz Wikipedia:Stub Wikipedia:Artikel 90
12470 1518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenneth Montgomery Keillor User:Capitalistroadster 06:09, 5 December 2005 (UTC) delete """some claims to notability but not nearly enough to meet . Besides, """"I know virtually every Postmaster in B.C. and Alberta and you are the most articulate Postmaster I have met across fully two provinces"""" could possibly go on BJAODN""" Deletion of Kenneth Montgomery Keillor WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12471 9076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniella van Graas User:Lubbad85 19:35, 16 April 2019 (UTC) keep subject is and passes the article should be developed as the subject appeared in notable meadia. Deletion of Daniella van Graas WP:GNG||WP:ENT||WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12472 20044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Polandball User:Russavia 04:57, 26 March 2012 (UTC) keep The article is clearly referenced to numerous |reliable sources, so it easily passes . This nomination seems to be an attempt to keep the article from appearing at DYK on 1 April as per Template:Did_you_know_nominations/Polandball Deletion of Polandball WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12473 20023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lyle Roebuck User:Jonathanwallace 10:24, 28 April 2011 (UTC) comment by nominator: PROD removed. Most Ghits are social media, others merely confirm he was an award finalist (which does not establish notability). Does not appear to pass either or Deletion of Lyle Roebuck WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12474 20414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Goldenboy User:Sparklism 10:22, 21 January 2013 (UTC) keep The 'external links' section alone contains enough coverage to meet Deletion of Goldenboy WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12475 15191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sana-Software User:Ihcoyc 14:12, 25 September 2009 (UTC) delete """likely '''speedy delete''', a non-consumer tech business (''develops .NET software platforms for e-commerce, e-learning, and web content management'') blowing its own horn. The non-words """"e-commerce"""" and """"e-learning"""" should be grounds for speedy deletion ''per se'', but any text containing them is sure to be #G11|obvious advertising""" Deletion of Sana-Software WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12476 1512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeremy Tolleson User:Shelbystripes 03:59, 12 January 2020 (UTC) keep Based on sources found and linked by above commenters, this appears to pass , and with it, Deletion of Jeremy Tolleson WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12477 20662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayhill Fowler User:Antivenin 06:27, 30 October 2008 (UTC) delete as per Qqqqqq and nom. Fails also as her comments on Obama provoked a short burst of news topics, nothing more Deletion of Mayhill Fowler WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12478 2631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roll a D6 User:Torchiest 20:00, 23 November 2011 (UTC) keep Meets the requirements, as it has significant coverage in multiple independent reliable sources Deletion of Roll a D6 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12479 20525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Horsfall User:Oysterguitarist 03:42, 3 August 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Steve Horsfall WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12480 10450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zoombombing User:Interstellarity 13:24, 2 April 2020 (UTC) merge to Zoom Video Communications. I don't feel this is notable just yet per Deletion of Zoombombing WP:RECENTISM Wikipedia:Recentism 10
12481 165 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Mete Gündoğan Kullanıcı:85.181.132.7885.181.132.78 20:54, 7 Mart 2015 (UTC) comment mete gündogan gibi bir insan mutlaka ama mutlaka vikipedide yer almalidir. --Özel:Katkılar/85.181.132.78|85.181.132.78 (geçersiz Mete Gündoğan'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:OY Wikipedia:Administrators 89
12482 14785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Setsucon (2nd nomination) User:Whpq 14:25, 4 January 2012 (UTC) comment The |state of other articles is not under discussion here. Those other conventions may also be non-notable and possibly be deleted to. Simply claiming that press releases and directory entries impart notability does not make it so. I too would like to see more substance taken from newspaper articles. The problem here is that is no such coverage with which to develop the article. If there are such newspaper articles, I am unable to find them, and nobody else has provided any either Deletion of Setsucon (2nd nomination) WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12483 6649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grand Duke George Mikhailovich of Russia User:TheRedDomitor 04:01, 18 September 2020 (UTC) keep There is enough material to warrant an article in the mainspace per . Also, these endless nominations of biographies only on the basis that they have a former royal title in front of their names () is getting tiring now Deletion of Grand Duke George Mikhailovich of Russia WP:SIGCOV||WP:IDONTLIKE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12484 16515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marina Barrage MRT Station User:The 08:33, 8 November 2011 (UTC) delete blatant failure of Deletion of Marina Barrage MRT Station WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12485 1422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rodney Pocceschi NONE NONE comment Note that is a ''guideline'', not policy. From Deletion of Rodney Pocceschi WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12486 16053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Santa Barbara County Office of Arts and Culture User:Eggishorn 00:56, 11 December 2016 (UTC) delete Admitted by article creator that this is a basic problem, as well as lack Deletion of Santa Barbara County Office of Arts and Culture WP:NOTWEBHOST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12487 9159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian Erix User:Whpq 14:05, 2 March 2011 (UTC) comment Nobody doubts that Ian Erix has a musical career. At issue is whether this article meets the |inclusion guidelines in general, or specifically for |musicians. This can be established with sources writing '''about''' him, and not by linking to video clips of his performance Deletion of Ian Erix WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12488 5506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dike Eddleman Athlete of the Year User:Epinoia 04:14, 15 May 2019 (UTC) delete """the award is not mentioned on the University of Illinois website - I would recommend a Redirect, but the award is not mentioned in any of the University of Illinois campus articles - does not meet - has not """"received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject"""" - therefore, delete""" Deletion of Dike Eddleman Athlete of the Year WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12489 21171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Herlihy User:Northamerica1000 05:31, 6 February 2013 (UTC) delete Several searches in Google News and Books are not yielding coverage about this subject. Appears to fail Deletion of John Herlihy WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12490 6557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liberation psychotherapy User:Drchriswilliams 19:43, 20 July 2017 (UTC) delete As per , there is a need for more coverage than a selection of books from an author who is a proponent of this. I couldn't see anything in PubMed, for example. Notability has not been established Deletion of Liberation psychotherapy :WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
12491 18397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MapleStory game issues User:NeoChaosX 21:42, 22 December 2006 (UTC) delete since none of the issues are |sourced; if someone can come up with some sources on any of these issues, then they can be merged into the main article Deletion of MapleStory game issues WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12492 14489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/South Bound User:Mkdw 19:47, 18 May 2013 (UTC) delete The article doesn't make a credible assertion to notability and the reference is user submitted content. Does not meet and the artist does not have an article (A9 Deletion of South Bound WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
12493 14618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harrison Street Real Estate (2nd nomination) User:Bejnar 21:20, 8 July 2021 (UTC) delete definitely fails for lack of significant coverage, or any deep coverage. Billions sounds impressive, but doesn't grant notability Deletion of Harrison Street Real Estate (2nd nomination) :WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12494 18897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orff's Carmina Burana in popular culture User:Black 07:42, 15 March 2007 (UTC) delete """per , but '''not''' as an indiscriminate collection of information (requires ridiculously broad interpretation of #IINFO), a directory, """"cruft"""" (pointless term that doesn't actually specify what's wrong with an article), """"useless trivia"""" (a subjective opinion), or an inadequately represented """"precedent"""". There was some originally some prose in the main article that was deleted for some reason. I have re-added it so this article becomes mostly unnecessary""" Deletion of Orff's Carmina Burana in popular culture WP:TRIV||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
12495 4635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thin (body) User:TenPoundHammer 03:47, 28 July 2007 (UTC) delete Violates #DICT. We don't need these dicdef pages Deletion of Thin (body) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12496 5291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Little Portugal, San Jose User:Qworty 11:56, 28 November 2012 (UTC) delete for failing Deletion of Little Portugal, San Jose WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12497 19259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Na Na Na (Na Na Na Na Na Na Na Na Na) User:Rlendog 04:35, 26 September 2010 (UTC) comment per , if this song is not notable, it should be merged or redirected to the album article rather than deleted. But if it is scheduled to be released as a single in a few days, it makes sense to withhold judgement until then Deletion of Na Na Na (Na Na Na Na Na Na Na Na Na) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12498 1908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amit Offir User:Dial911 23:23, 22 September 2018 (UTC) delete Most of the references are OCLC number of his books. The article, at its current state fails Deletion of Amit Offir WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12499 19612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nay Shwe Thway Aung [[User talk:73.170.255.4|talk]]) 07:29, 19 December 2020 (UTC) delete """I don't want to use my account for fear of real-life repercussions (He once bulldozed a restaurant for disagreeing with him). That aside, in all fairness, the subject certainly does not meet . (Update below, he may meet GNG but still not notable due to """"trivial coverage""""). His coverage is either gossip that doesn't meet or is about his granddad. For example: """"Pho La Pyae arranges a meeting between Aung San Suu Kyi and Than Shwe."""" You can see that it's not him that is the focus of the article. He himself hasn't done anything notable. For example, there are millions of people who attack business rivals every day. Hundreds of millions write songs nobody ever watches. That doesn't mean they deserve an article on Wikipedia. By the way, based on what is known about his behaviors and the value he puts on Wikipedia article, the above IP is really fishy. I don't know about the nominator, but even if he has violated some rules, it shouldn't affect this deletion discussion. This discussion should be all about whether to delete the article. Special:Contributions/73.170.255.4|73.170.255.4""" Deletion of Nay Shwe Thway Aung WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12500 8944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Telerik Test Studio User:Raeky 16:55, 13 February 2013 (UTC) delete First off we should bring up which this thing seems to be clearly in violation of, then look at , which I can't find any evidence that it meets those criteria. — Deletion of Telerik Test Studio WP:SPIP||WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12501 13810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Economist editorial stance User:Bearian 16:54, 24 March 2009 (UTC) keep """see . The Economist's editorial policy is actually quite significant in its own way, and it is easily verifiable. '''One example''': ''just last night'', I was reading Michael Brook's """"13 Things That Don't Make Sense"""" (ISBN 978-1-60751-666-8), which had arrived fresh fromn the Quality Paperback Book Club as a featured special. There is a full paragraph on page 67 in that book merely about the magazine's support for cold fusion experiments and the philosophy of science, with a quote and an analysis of the same. You can rename, merge, whatever, but don't delete it, because it is notable""" Deletion of The Economist editorial stance WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
12502 15769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled Jennifer Lopez Greatest Hits (2009) User:Esradekan 02:49, 30 October 2008 (UTC) delete per |The Hammer Deletion of Untitled Jennifer Lopez Greatest Hits (2009) WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
12503 15985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GIK Institute Clock Tower User:Faizan 12:19, 10 December 2014 (UTC) keep Being a monument and a real place, per Deletion of GIK Institute Clock Tower WP:GEOFEAT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12504 3462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Pentland User:RayAYang 16:54, 1 August 2008 (UTC) keep notable as an |academic. He's a tenured, chair professor at MIT Deletion of Alex Pentland WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12505 11003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Cascone User:Whpq 16:22, 29 August 2013 (UTC) comment """Every statement regarding Cascone's history must be properly sourced"""" does not pertain to |notability; it pertains to |verifiability. Given the |conflict of interest, I agree that all of the material needs to be meticulously sourced. But that does not negate the fact that the coverage of his work shows that |general notability guidelines have been met""" Deletion of Kim Cascone WP:N||WP:V||WP:COI||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12506 3431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Alers [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 18:01, 26 March 2014 (UTC) delete Second tier championships don't show notability. Fails . Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Jim Alers WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
12507 14104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shelby Gem Factory User:Samat 15:02, 29 September 2017 (UTC) keep Meets Deletion of Shelby Gem Factory WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12508 12454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayoral elections User:Enos733 15:53, 20 April 2020 (UTC) keep There may be notable reasons to keep many (or some) of the articles. And, much of the content may be able to be merged into other articles. In general, though, I believe that mayoral campaigns, properly covered by reliable, independent news sources should have the presumption of notability by meeting Deletion of Mayoral elections WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12509 1139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kiam Wanesse User:GiantSnowman 07:44, 7 June 2019 (UTC) keep meets ; needs improving, not deleting Deletion of Kiam Wanesse WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12510 14723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hassal Sharif User:Uzma 17:44, 26 August 2012 (UTC) delete """Hassal Sharif is situated 75 KM (one driving hour) south of Rawalpindi, Pakistan and Google maps {{Coord|33.209647|73.121151|format=dms|display=inline}} confirms the Hassal Sharif name and location. So does http://www.hassalsharif.com/ hassalsharif.com However, there are no English sources mentioning Hassal Sharif. The Urs festival mentioned in the article is held in Eidgah Sharif,http://www.thenews.com.pk/Todays-News-6-112922-Urs-at-Eidgah-Sharif-starts-today not Hassal Sharif. The """"presently famous Sufi scholar Syed Mehmood Shah Bukhari"""", """"Spiritual Leader/Teacher who Lives in Hassal Sharif"""" mentioned in the article resides in Railway Colony behind the Cantt Railway Station,http://dawn.com/2011/01/30/saint-and-stones/ but I was unable to determine whether Railway Colony was in Hassal Sharif. The topic might be notable via reliable sources published in Pakistan. However, Hassal Sharif seems like a small location and, until reliable source material comes forward, I'll have to side with does not meet """ Deletion of Hassal Sharif WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12511 6711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of celebrities who were obese in childhood User:OfficeGirl 21:40, 15 November 2006 (UTC) delete Violates , impossible to make this into anything that would remotely add to the knowledge base of Wikipedia. Besides that, it's mean Deletion of List of celebrities who were obese in childhood WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12512 4838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Florian Roșu User:Rugbyfan22 19:33, 7 February 2021 (UTC) delete Fails and . Was named in the most recent international squad but the match was cancelled due to COVID. With no scheduled games in the near future that would allow him to pass it seems a clear case of . Could potentially be draftifyed until notable but has been in main space for just under a year Deletion of Florian Roșu WP:NRU||WP:GNG||WP:NRU||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
12513 1705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stan Medalie User:CreativeNorth 14:46, 18 August 2020 (UTC) delete Also agree with the nom and the page itself is written like an advert under which means it fails Deletion of Stan Medalie WP:PROMOTION||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12514 7801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Ericsson-Zenith User:David 21:55, 27 April 2011 (UTC) delete His company seems on the side to me rather than being a famous research institution so I think he is not automatically notable for being its principal investigator; rather, should apply, and I don't see any significant coverage of him in Google news archive, only some short coverage of a different company he founded for fielding complaints. As for academic notability, he'd need significantly higher numbers of citations than I'm seeing in Google scholar to pass the bar of #C1 Deletion of Steven Ericsson-Zenith WP:FRINGE||WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
12515 505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UIU Electrical & Electronics Club User:SalmanZ 21:18, 17 August 2019 (UTC) delete Fails & Deletion of UIU Electrical & Electronics Club WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12516 9771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brody Kalwajtys User:Anturiaethwr 19:37, 16 July 2008 (UTC) delete Sorry, Brody, but none of the conditions in or seem to apply to you Deletion of Brody Kalwajtys WP:CREATIVE||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12517 20789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devin DeRay User:James086 01:00, 27 January 2007 (UTC) delete per nominator. Doesn't pass (despite it being disputed). Appeared in Living Single but not as a regular cast member so I'm guessing it was an extra or a one-off character Deletion of Devin DeRay WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12518 13379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Texe Marrs (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep I |assumed good faith and assumed that the sources added by 81 are primarily about Marrs and/or his claims. In the face of a further delete remark on the grounds that no sources met the notability guideline, I decided to examine each newspaper article as best as I could Deletion of Texe Marrs (2nd nomination) WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
12519 14593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Table mouse User:Peridon 19:17, 31 March 2010 (UTC) delete """From my PROD: """" Yet another of those made-up school or student games with no chance of notability."""" The article even states: """"created by two students of the University of Louisville""" Deletion of Table mouse WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
12520 11952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/16874 Kurtwahl User:StringTheory11 17:41, 23 June 2014 (UTC) merge to List of minor planets: 16001–17000 per Deletion of 16874 Kurtwahl WP:NASTRO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12521 8239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Golden Sun characters User:Jclemens 05:23, 18 August 2017 (UTC) merge to Golden Sun (series) per nom and -M. All this information is clearly not needed in the target article, but the basics would be reasonable to include. Nothing in the content is harmful, just excessively detailed, so there's no reason for a deletion to hide the history of the article Deletion of List of Golden Sun characters WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12522 11487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Garush Hambardzumyan User:Ad 14:47, 20 October 2020 (UTC) comment Clearly fails . With respect to GNG, there are a couple of short profiles cited. Why are these not considered / Deletion of Garush Hambardzumyan WP:SOLDIER||WP:RS||WP:IS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12523 13593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pippa Middleton (2nd nomination) User:Edison 20:15, 30 April 2011 (UTC) delete or '''Merge''' to an article on the family. Notability is not inherited from a sister, and news coverage from being a maid of honor runs afoul of , however massive it was in one news cycle. See also . lease do not clutter this AFD with reports of what German Wikipedia did in an AFD, or with Google hits, or page view counts on the day a billion people watched a Royal Wedding. A mention in an article on Kate's family is more encyclopedic Deletion of Pippa Middleton (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12524 10563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roland Sparkes User:Ukexpat 20:25, 5 January 2010 (UTC) delete clearly fails , . N.B. applies to any participation in editing an article about oneself, not just creation of such article Deletion of Roland Sparkes WP:BIO||WP:AUTHOR||WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12525 21714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bsnes User:Randomran 01:07, 27 May 2008 (UTC) delete fails the |general notability guideline that requires coverage in reliable sources independent of the subject. This is pretty central wikipedia policy Deletion of Bsnes WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12526 16305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cathryn Mataga User:Wirenote 17:56, 18 May 2014 (UTC) delete Fleeting mentions in reliable sources referring to the subject, does not qualify as significant coverage to be quoted a few times. is not met; career is otherwise unremarkable Deletion of Cathryn Mataga WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12527 4266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1944 Cheshunt B 24 Bomber crash User:Armbrust 17:36, 2 August 2010 (UTC) delete per . It doesn't has long standing impact Deletion of 1944 Cheshunt B 24 Bomber crash WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12528 1487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kathleen Maltzahn User:Solarra 08:59, 5 June 2014 (UTC) delete per nom. has a pretty high standard when it comes to notability guidelines, on that alone is grounds for deletion. Also, as the nom indicates, this individual's http://books.google.com/books/about/Trafficked.html?id=Qc9VpvBKuvEC one book fails as well Deletion of Kathleen Maltzahn WP:NPOL||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12529 5934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tamaskan Dog User:Isotope23 20:49, 21 November 2006 (UTC) delete as this cannot be |verified by |reliable sources Deletion of Tamaskan Dog WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12530 71 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ermeni terörizmi Kullanıcı:emyilemyil 23:21, 5 Mayıs 2013 (UTC) comment İsminden önce maddede ciddi sorunu var Ermeni terörizminin silinmesi Vikipedi:TBA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
12531 19575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Complete Greatest Hits (Foreigner album) User:Rlendog 00:49, 5 December 2009 (UTC) keep """per , """"In general, if the musician or ensemble that recorded an album is considered notable, then officially released albums may have sufficient notability to have individual articles on Wikipedia."""" No reason this album would not qualify""" Deletion of Complete Greatest Hits (Foreigner album) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12532 21801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beethoven Javier [[User_talk:ClubOranje|Oranje]][[User_talk:ClubOranje|T]] 23:59, 20 August 2017 (UTC) keep As an Uruguayan international, sourced, he clearly meets . Club Deletion of Beethoven Javier WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
12533 17557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sohail Khatri User:Fenix 07:26, 18 July 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Sohail Khatri WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12534 18082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twenty Year Rule User:danntm 23:37, 29 September 2006 (UTC) delete I agree with Mangojuuice, this term could be useful, but we have to be careful about |neologisms. Thus, the article has to be better |verified Deletion of Twenty Year Rule WP:NEO||WP:V Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
12535 11926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Home Alone (The Dumping Ground) User:Lukeno94 23:17, 14 January 2014 (UTC) merge I'm sorry, but this is just a common-or-garden TV show, and none of the episodes have any lasting, or external, notability. If an episode won a major award, or makes a significant contribution to culture, then we could look at those individual episodes having articles. At present, the episodes will fail as all of their coverage in is primary. Simply put, this TV show is not big enough to justify individual episode articles either; comparing it to Only Fools and Horses is like comparing the Queen to a baby born a month ago in Birmingham, and, as such, that is an absolutely bizarre comparison to make Deletion of Home Alone (The Dumping Ground) WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12536 17356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of organizations in the Honorverse (2nd nomination) User:Rorshacma 16:31, 7 June 2019 (UTC) delete The article contains nothing but completely unsourced, in-universe . Simply merging unsourced information from one article to another article does nothing to solve either of these problems Deletion of List of organizations in the Honorverse (2nd nomination) WP:PLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12537 16007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keisuke Fujiwara User:Papaursa 18:09, 18 June 2010 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Keisuke Fujiwara WP:MMANOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12538 1449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philadelphia Artists Equity User:Celestina007 11:55, 19 November 2019 (UTC) delete per rationale provided by {{ping|ThatMontrealIP}} , It is a non notable organization & fails per Deletion of Philadelphia Artists Equity WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12539 1706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The City (group) User:Doktorbuk 06:04, 20 August 2006 (UTC) keep as per above and Deletion of The City (group) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12540 13775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dorp (town) User:Gidonb 13:14, 6 March 2020 (UTC) merge """into village. This article should never have been prodded or AfDd. Nevertheless, it was part of a massive prod then AfD spree of articles that typically get kept or merged. All this is unnecessarily straining community resources (time that could have been spent more productively!) and in strong violation of our policy. There is a merge procedure that is """"merge to"""". Please use it to start the appropriate discussions""" Deletion of Dorp (town) WP:PRD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
12541 5410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 North American spring User:Dodger67 14:18, 25 October 2016 (UTC) delete per and . There's nothing ''per se'' peculiar or special about any given spring season on any given continent. Notable meterological events are covered in the respective tornado and hurricane season articles, which are part of long established and organized article series Deletion of 2016 North American spring WP:SYNTH||WP:N Wikipedia:No original research 65
12542 1947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maniak (2008) [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] 12:49, 2 June 2013 (UTC) delete The film's producer was spamming these films and the director across Wikipedia until they were blocked for a username violation. This article lacks available reliable sources and fails Deletion of Maniak (2008) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
12543 17006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bitcoin SV User:David 11:02, 29 November 2018 (UTC) delete at present it's an event in the history of Bitcoin Cash, there's a story to tell here that actually got a little mainstream coverage ... but it's a Deletion of Bitcoin SV WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
12544 11788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peters Township Middle School User:Joseph2302 22:46, 1 March 2016 (UTC) merge to the school district listed above, per Deletion of Peters Township Middle School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12545 677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zaman Ali (philosopher) User:Bearian 14:35, 23 September 2019 (UTC) delete per and - this is a twenty-something writer without major publications Deletion of Zaman Ali (philosopher) WP:TOOSOON||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Too soon 40
12546 3564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cheeks (Multimedia Artist) User:VernoWhitney 21:28, 17 February 2010 (UTC) delete WP:ENTERTAINER directs us to which he fails. The title song to Side Effect would only make him notable if Side Effect itself was notable Deletion of Cheeks (Multimedia Artist) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12547 1306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Durham Union Society User:The 23:37, 9 October 2014 (UTC) delete to List of social activities at Durham University#Durham Union Society. Does not meet so not separately notable. What has happened is that following the merge pursuant to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Durham Union Society this article has been created as a copy and paste from the original article causing attribution issues (hence delete first). Clearly, there is no need for a merge because the merge was previously carried out Deletion of The Durham Union Society WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12548 14896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of holiday colors User:Otto4711 07:30, 9 March 2007 (UTC) delete no |sources that indicate that ''any'' holidays have colors associated with them, let alone that the colors noted in the article are associated with any holiday Deletion of List of holiday colors WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
12549 2753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFO sightings in China User:Bobrayner 00:25, 2 June 2014 (UTC) delete as a vague non-notable -magnet. Although I would not oppose demerging Meng Zhaoguo or starting a fresh article there Deletion of UFO sightings in China WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
12550 481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sexuality in Star Trek (2nd nomination) User:Colonel 23:11, 19 December 2010 (UTC) keep The nomination seems counter-factual as the article contains sources such as ''Sexuality and Sex-Role Stereotyping in Star Trek'' which clearly support the topic. And the rest just seems to be the argument to avoid of which is not policy. And the article still has reasonable scope for improvement per our |editing policy. For example, the source ''http://www.jstor.org/pss/4239567 Sex and Star Trek'' hasn't been mentioned yet Deletion of Sexuality in Star Trek (2nd nomination) WP:WEDONTNEEDIT||WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12551 17182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SBA destinations User:Bearian 00:06, 25 February 2018 (UTC) merge per Deletion of SBA destinations WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
12552 11805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Life of Nephi User:Bearian 17:58, 26 January 2021 (UTC) delete Lost films are difficult to |verify Deletion of The Life of Nephi WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12553 7228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BUNT User:Starblind 13:44, 29 July 2010 (UTC) delete as hoax. While there may be a band calling themselves that, nobody can sell 3 million copies without the media noticing, especially as that would have meant about half the total population of Serbia would have bought it. Deletion of BUNT WP:BULLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
12554 21040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Ng User:Jakejr 03:19, 23 May 2014 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet nor (at least from what I can read Deletion of Philip Ng WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12555 7565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pimpleshwar Mahadev (Saldi) User:The NONE comment The text, created by a couple of |quite dedicated contributors, reads like pure |original research. The Keep suggestions are difficult to understand, coming on as |prersonal preferences more than anything. And all the cited sources are unadulterated from mentions of the temple Deletion of Pimpleshwar Mahadev (Saldi) WP:SPA||WP:OR||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
12556 2916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dominique Piek User:Hrafn 11:02, 6 December 2010 (UTC) delete what little coverage there is seems to be thoroughly Deletion of Dominique Piek WP:TABLOID Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12557 19442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebel (2011 film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 20:59, 18 March 2011 (UTC) delete While the stub's meager two sentences make searches possible,http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=Rebel%2C+Raghava+Lawrence&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&btnG=Search+Archiveshttp://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=Rebel%2C+Anushka+Shetty&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&btnG=Search+Archives the predictive nature of the limited coverage would seem indicative of this stub beeing Deletion of Rebel (2011 film) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
12558 9444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chicken slacks User:MER 01:47, 24 December 2006 (UTC) delete slang |dictdef Deletion of Chicken slacks WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
12559 9492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Crayola paint colors User:Ajf773 10:16, 25 July 2018 (UTC) delete Crayola is a brand and the colours are products so this is essentially breaches Deletion of List of Crayola paint colors WP:NOTCATALOGUE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12560 2651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arkam Asylum User:Esradekan 15:45, 3 July 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of Arkam Asylum WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12561 1801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob advanced User:Sycthos 02:44, 15 January 2006 (UTC) delete as this is an article of |vanity Deletion of Bob advanced WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
12562 8574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erli Çupi User:GiantSnowman 09:36, 18 June 2017 (UTC) keep meets ; needs improving, not deleting Deletion of Erli Çupi WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12563 5792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Mediacracy User:MelanieN 02:52, 30 November 2014 (UTC) delete Fails due to lack of coverage by Independent Reliable Sources. The only real source listed at the article gives this subject only a passing mention. In a search I found nothing to add Deletion of New Mediacracy WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12564 8845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tora (band) User:Lankiveil 12:16, 15 May 2014 (UTC) delete I have to admit I don't see how they meet . There are lots of references, but they're pretty much poor quality, self-published stuff that's been thrown at the article like a handful of mud to see if anything will stick Deletion of Tora (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12565 15023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cleethorpes Town F.C. User:Argyle 23:27, 7 April 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Cleethorpes Town F.C. WP:FOOTYN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12566 5616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Coates (longevity claimant) (2nd nomination) User:Britishfinance 19:08, 18 July 2019 (UTC) keep """He has enough quality references to meet at least a technical pass of (I added two more from the Washington Post, and a lesser mention from the Wall Street Journal). There are also several books that mention the hoax (which I think it was). A hoax that lasted many years (the Washington Post first did an article in 1999 with follow-ups in 2002, and 2004), cannot really be an """"event"""". I think the case would be interesting to a reader wanting to know the facts of what actually happened here""" Deletion of William Coates (longevity claimant) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12567 299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Circle hand game (Second nomination) User:Amarkov 22:59, 8 December 2006 (UTC) delete """WP:V, , the like. Also note that is not a reason for keeping, and isn't an """"I don't have to give sources"""" card""" Deletion of Circle hand game (Second nomination) WP:OR||WP:IKNOWIT||WP:IAR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12568 19547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Tschugguel User:VocalIndia 19:42, 18 January 2021 (UTC) keep per above. What??? the nominator you are Deletion of Alexander Tschugguel WP:IDONTLIKE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12569 994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ariana Jollee User:MichaelQSchmidt 10:40, 16 April 2016 (UTC) keep per meeting through awards notable and significant to and through coverage by her industry, even if in non-genre media Deletion of Ariana Jollee WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12570 5102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/27 Club User:Edtropolis 13:15, 20 June 2007 (UTC) delete per and possibly Deletion of 27 Club WP:NEO||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
12571 13440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Sian O'Callaghan (2nd nomination) User:Petri 21:12, 31 March 2012 (UTC) comment and futher '''objection''' to the way this is now handled. The locked and censored Death of Sian O'Callaghan|page now states ''This page has been indefinitely protect in order to conform to the requirements of Wikipedia:Biographies_of_living_persons#Crime_perpetrators,'' giving at least a very strong impression that this is community decision or at least follows olicy|community guidelines. This is '''NOT''' the case. The policy cited does not mandate this drastic form of censorship nor does it make any mention of special treatment of British crime suspects. Do we start bowing to legal demands form every country? Should we delete Tiananmen Square protests of 1989 because it is a collection of criminal hate speech and misinformation? The hat note on the page should clearly state that the decision to censor the page lies with Wikimedia Foundation of the Wikipedia:Oversight|oversighters. It should also ''explicitly'' mention the request with a reference number or at least a date, so that the censorship could be challenged in a British court of law Deletion of Death of Sian O'Callaghan (2nd nomination) WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
12572 8577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexandra Bounxouei User:Atlantic306 22:03, 14 February 2020 (UTC) keep the article has been significantly improved with additional reliable sources references so that asic is passed and deletion is unnecessary, imv Deletion of Alexandra Bounxouei WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
12573 10361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sidd Bikkannavar User:E 16:24, 15 February 2017 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of Sidd Bikkannavar WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12574 19662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/People's Climate March (2017) [[User talk:58.187.165.232|talk]]) —Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|undated]] comment added 15:09, 22 April 2017 (UTC) keep It's notable, and is talked about in numerous news sources, even if it's not neutral that doesn't mean that It's automatically not notable or eligible for deletion, it just means that the article needs more neutral and/or negative citations rather than an immediate deletion. Personally I don't even agree with what the group stands for but they're notable nonetheless. So I would say keep based on . --Special:Contributions/58.187.165.232|58.187.165.232 Deletion of People's Climate March (2017) WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
12575 14471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ISO 13407 User:Colonel 18:22, 2 May 2011 (UTC) keep The current state of the article is irrelevant to the question of deletion because it is our |editing policy to improve weak starts, not to delete them Deletion of ISO 13407 WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
12576 9587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wendi and Brenda Turnbaugh User:Bearian 20:26, 12 May 2015 (UTC) delete per - we usually, but not always, delete stubs on child actors who have not had major roles Deletion of Wendi and Brenda Turnbaugh WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12577 1809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdul Hassan(united states) User:RightCowLeftCoast 19:05, 2 April 2013 (UTC) merge to United States presidential election, 2012; subject of this AfD has received |significant coverage from multiple non-primary |reliable sources, as indicated in http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Abdul+Hassan%28united+states%29%22&tbm=nws&tbs=ar:1#hl=en&tbs=ar:1&tbm=nws&sclient=psy-ab&q=%22Abdul+Hassan%22+President+candidate&oq=%22Abdul+Hassan%22+President+candidate&gs_l=serp.3...165161.166921.4.167051.12.12.0.0.0.0.276.2009.0j7j4.11.0...0.0...1c.1.8.psy-ab.DPXIP0bHT8Y&pbx=1&bav=on.2,or.r_qf.&bvm=bv.44697112,d.b2I&fp=2e744af069b2e730&biw=1034&bih=751 this search. That being said, the subject has received most of that coverage related to the subject of the article United States presidential election, 2012 and therefore falls under . As the subject is primarily notable due to a single event or series of event that falls within the scope of the suggested article, a redirect is in order if we are to follow BLP1E. Furthermore, also informs us that a redirect is the proper outcome of this type of AfD Deletion of Abdul Hassan(united states) WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS||WP:BLP1E||WP:POLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Notability 77
12578 12527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Independent Republic of Vojvodina User:Duja 16:13, 28 September 2006 (UTC) delete per crystal ball and . The issue can (and should) be addressed at Politics of Vojvodina, although such views are a real minority Deletion of Independent Republic of Vojvodina WP:NOT||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12579 16446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/You Can't Tell the People User:Hrafn 06:25, 3 January 2009 (UTC) delete no indication that this book meets . Non-notable book about a notable incident. Sources relating to the underlying Rendlesham Forest Incident do not add notability to ''this'' topic, for which no non-trivial third party references exist Deletion of You Can't Tell the People WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12580 8267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fondation René Touraine User:MelanieN 15:59, 21 February 2013 (UTC) delete Fails for lack of independent coverage Deletion of Fondation René Touraine WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12581 5582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Water Centre User:Qrsdogg 13:57, 2 June 2011 (UTC) keep Gets a decent amount of coverage in Google News, looks like there is enough to meet . I added one source to the article, certainly potential for a decent article here Deletion of International Water Centre WP:NGO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12582 11447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Green Car Motel User:Esradekan 06:28, 1 February 2009 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability per Deletion of Green Car Motel WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12583 2982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/YouTube statistics User:Stuartyeates 05:29, 25 November 2012 (UTC) delete all the references are to youtube sources. If it is rewritten from independent reliables sources, as required by , ping my talk page Deletion of YouTube statistics WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12584 1378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laurel Schwulst User:MrOllie 22:05, 9 September 2020 (UTC) delete Lots of citations, but I don't see any that any of them are independent with |significant coverage Deletion of Laurel Schwulst WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12585 4998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Burton (footballer) User:Fenix 12:30, 4 January 2013 (UTC) delete fails and . Difficult to think of a more minor footballer Deletion of Paul Burton (footballer) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12586 18049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harari College Worldwide User:Bearian 18:50, 26 October 2019 (UTC) delete per . Unaccredited, proprietary, and defunct school that only offered online AP classes Deletion of Harari College Worldwide WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
12587 17031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skyline Builders (2nd nomination) User:HighKing 11:32, 24 August 2017 (UTC) delete Fails GNG and Deletion of Skyline Builders (2nd nomination) WP:SPIP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12588 9618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Johnny Vega User:SamHolt6 04:30, 7 May 2018 (UTC) delete Fails to meet or criteria Deletion of Johnny Vega WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12589 10848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fantasy Clichés User:Reyk 00:39, 24 July 2010 (UTC) delete Yoenit has said almost all that needs to be said. Can we add a line to to the effect that Wikipedia and TvTropes are not the same thing Deletion of List of fantasy Clichés WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12590 18260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ankit Singh Chandel User:Eagleash 18:02, 22 February 2021 (UTC) delete unelected politician; fails and little if any, coverage Deletion of Ankit Singh Chandel :WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12591 3195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dude User:Hersfold 01:49, 10 March 2008 (UTC) keep This is considerably more than a dicdef. I'm not sure it'll get much longer, but we don't delete stubs for being stubs. Only reason I'm not ing this is because there seem to be some questions about inclusion, but I'm sure this is snowable Deletion of Dude WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
12592 18452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/R. C. Johnson User:Boing 16:27, 5 March 2010 (UTC) delete """As the prod said, """"holding a position at a university does not in itself satisfy """". Can't see any other notability""" Deletion of R. C. Johnson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12593 625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shikha Khanduja Kaul User:Harshil169 09:16, 24 July 2019 (UTC) delete No reference in . Fails otability Deletion of Shikha Khanduja Kaul WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12594 17262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Schade User:TheSandDoctor 05:13, 17 November 2020 (UTC) delete per failure of and Deletion of Chris Schade WP:NRU||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12595 7344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gurdwaras in India User:Dzlife 14:08, 3 October 2011 (UTC) delete redundant Deletion of Gurdwaras in India WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
12596 11128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Capt Muthukrishnan Iyyappan User:Icewhiz 10:20, 20 September 2018 (UTC) delete Army captains do not pass . It does seem his military service or tenure as CEO of Eka Academy garnered SIGCOV for GNG Deletion of Capt Muthukrishnan Iyyappan WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
12597 1110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2617 Jiangxi User:Padenton 15:14, 2 May 2015 (UTC) merge to List of minor planets: 2001–3000 per (specifically ) and . ― Deletion of 2617 Jiangxi WP:NASTRO||WP:NASTCRIT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12598 20736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/E/OS user:czarkoff 19:40, 16 August 2012 (UTC) delete no indication of |notability. In fact, this pretty ordinary Linux distribution is described the way that it's not obvious that it is a Linux distribution at all; just one step away from #A1. — Deletion of E/OS WP:CSD||WP:notability Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12599 21017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alt.usage.english User:Radioinfoguy 14:31, 19 July 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Article mentions how the newsgroup is filled with off-topic garbage Deletion of Alt.usage.english WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12600 638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mustapha Farrakhan User:Epinoia 16:37, 19 September 2019 (UTC) delete article is very negative in tone and based on allegations - even if the allegations are true, there doesn't seem to be anything to establish notability per Deletion of Mustapha Farrakhan WP:BLPBALANCE||WP:SUSPECT||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12601 9172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kirby: Right Back at Ya! User:Vaati 16:49, 7 May 2013 (UTC) keep I see no promotions at all in the articles, just some episode summaries, air dates, and language titles. As well as information for stuff relating to and about the Kirby Franchise also, no solid argument for deletion in anyway at all, per Deletion of Kirby: Right Back at Ya! WP:UGLY Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12602 13014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eternity: Our Next Billion Years User:Tokyogirl79 09:23, 11 June 2015 (UTC) keep meets thanks to addition of references by Deletion of Eternity: Our Next Billion Years WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12603 1220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hai-Sha Ni User:CaliforniaAliBaba 08:59, 22 April 2007 (UTC) delete Dr. Ni is a controversial figure, so having an unsourced or poorly-sourced article about him is a violation of . An article |verifiable by reference to |multiple instances of non-trivial coverage in |reliable sources ''could'' be written about Dr. Ni, as demonstrated by Google searches above. However, the page as it stands is ''not'' such an article, and we lose absolutely nothing by deleting it. My vote changes to keep if the article is improved to the extent that most statements have inline citations to newspapers (either English newspapers or Chinese newspapers are fine Deletion of Hai-Sha Ni WP:LIVING||WP:V||WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12604 11899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Sad Day on Pluto User:Frank 01:59, 17 April 2008 (UTC) delete fails there are not many |reliable sources about the band or album either Deletion of A Sad Day on Pluto WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12605 1778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zoot Rumpus User:Siva1979 13:25, 29 September 2007 (UTC) delete The lack of |verified content is a major concern here. A quick http://www.google.com.sg/search?as_q=&hl=en&num=100&btnG=Google+Search&as_epq=Zoot+Rumpus&as_oq=&as_eq=wikipedia&lr=&as_ft=i&as_filetype=&as_qdr=all&as_occt=any&as_dt=i&as_sitesearch=&as_rights=&safe=image google search shows up no |reliable hits for this subject. Moreover, this article is in violation of as well. --|S Deletion of Zoot Rumpus WP:V||WP:RS||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:ESP Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12606 9940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BSTJ papers User:Anjouli 08:48, 30 December 2006 (UTC) delete per #DIR Deletion of BSTJ papers WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12607 11290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Diarrhea Song User:Stifle 21:35, 1 May 2006 (UTC) delete per , with optional BJAODN Deletion of The Diarrhea Song WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12608 5827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whiteblack User:Blue520 14:18, 7 May 2006 (UTC) delete interesting but & Deletion of Whiteblack WP:NOR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
12609 2756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Norwegian photographers (2nd nomination) User:Scapler 23:31, 26 December 2008 (UTC) keep """Per ists: """"Redundancy between lists and categories is beneficial because they are synergistic"""" and ategories, lists, and navigation templates: """"Lists can include items that are not linked...or items for which there are yet no articles (red links)"""" and """"Categories do not support other forms of tracking, such as adding red links. (Red links are useful as gap indicators and as task reminders to create those articles""" Deletion of List of Norwegian photographers (2nd nomination) WP:L||WP:C Wikipedia:Lists 97
12610 2289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Air Canada Flight 018 Stowaway incident user:Tautomers 23:02, 26 June 2021 (UTC) keep While this story has gotten new coverage after 9 years since it's initial reporting, it's more of a burst of news and doesn't really count as . The story is unusual and kind of head turning, and I would not agree that this is nor do I agree with . The news reporting shows there was more to this story and had ongoing pieces to it. Nevertheless, the story is only a little bit and a little bit and it appears the story has now come to a resolution, and the initial event isn't very big and probably worth deleting. However, I was initially going to say weak delete but I feel a weak keep due to arrests occurring indicating this news story had broader implications beyond the incident itself indicates it has significance, passes and Deletion of Air Canada Flight 018 Stowaway incident WP:LASTING||WP:RUNOFTHEMILL||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BROAD||WP:DIVERSE||WP:GNG||WP:EVENTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12611 13358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of all U.S. NBC, ABC, CBS, and FOX affiliates User:UnitedStatesian 04:52, 14 March 2009 (UTC) delete """This list would be duplicative to the 4 already existing lists. Based on the size of those four, the """"one stop article"""" would violate , the same reason we do not have a List of all companies one stop article""" Deletion of List of all U.S. NBC, ABC, CBS, and FOX affiliates WP:SIZE Wikipedia:Article size 51
12612 6468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M.I.A.'s third studio album User:Doc 18:35, 25 October 2008 (UTC) delete per . Of all the listed things in this page, nothing actually says that she's even in the ''studio'' yet. Just clips from interviews of what she ''might'' do on her third album Deletion of M.I.A.'s third studio album WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
12613 3422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Robb (writer) User:7triton7 05:38, 12 February 2009 (UTC) delete Falls short of , but it's a close call. Not enough on Google to convince me Deletion of Bruce Robb (writer) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12614 3172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sexpressionism User:Doczilla 07:07, 8 January 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Sexpressionism WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12615 6262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reema Thareja User:Vincentvikram 16:52, 8 April 2021 (UTC) delete per nom. Does not pass NPROF. The books mentioned in the list appear to be recently published college text books on regular topics with no evidence that it satisfies #4 Deletion of Reema Thareja WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12616 13529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benjamin Smith User:Bearcat 17:48, 29 July 2017 (UTC) delete Being deputy leader of a political party is ''not'' an automatic pass in its own right — it can be enough ''if'' they can be sourced over for it, but it is not a freebie that ''exempts'' a person from having to be |reliably sourced. And being the ''youngest'' holder of an otherwise non-notable political role isn't an inclusion freebie either — Wikipedia's notability criteria are based solely on what the achievement ''is'', and accord ''no'' special weight to the ''age'' at which somebody achieved it. But of the five footnotes here, three are |primary sources, one is a university ''student'' newspaper (a class of sourcing that can be used for supplementary sourcing of stray facts ''after'' GNG has already been covered off, but does not count ''toward'' GNG in and of itself), and the only one that's an acceptable |reliable source is a purely |routine list of ''all'' the candidates in a by-election he ran in. So no, the article does ''not'' have enough sources to be on Wikipedia. No prejudice against recreation in the future ''if'' somebody can source it ''better'' than this, but ''none'' of the sources here are good enough Deletion of Benjamin Smith WP:NPOL||WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:RS||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12617 19127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GovX User:HighKing 20:00, 5 April 2021 (UTC) delete I am unable to locate any deep or significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, references to date fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic therefore fails Deletion of GovX WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12618 7739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Cooley (artist) User:Bearian 13:40, 30 July 2019 (UTC) delete per , |no reliable sources, and |run of the mill producer Deletion of Chris Cooley (artist) WP:SNOW||WP:RS||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
12619 8231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Maier User:Stuartyeates 18:50, 7 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Daniel Maier WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12620 8250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valentina Vaughn User:Niteshift36 08:17, 3 September 2009 (UTC) delete She fails . Speculating on what changes may or may not occur to that standard aren't reasonenough to keep this article Deletion of Valentina Vaughn WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12621 19879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yale Model United Nations User:Pekaje 21:20, 8 July 2007 (UTC) comment Come on, do you expect anyone to think that ''The '''Yale''' Herald'' and '''''Yale''' Daily News'' are independent sources of information on an article about a '''''Yale''''' activity? Their |reliability has not been established, and while they may not have any direct affiliation with the subject of the article, they must certainly have a bias in favor of it. Or could you perhaps link to other of their articles where they give equal coverage to the Model UN of some other institution not affiliated with Yale in any way? They fail as sources without even reading the text, which looks like some fairly trivial coverage anyway Deletion of Yale Model United Nations WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12622 11374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Legal Aid Society of Orange County User:Reyk 13:13, 21 July 2015 (UTC) delete Keep voters assert that |there must be sources out there somewhere, yet the sources don't seem to be out there anywhere. I've looked, nominator has looked, and there's just nothing substantial Deletion of Legal Aid Society of Orange County WP:MUSTBESOURCES Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12623 21722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luke Pritchard User:Atlantic306 02:45, 9 July 2016 (UTC) keep as agree his projects outside the band have gained him enough coverage that he has independent notability for an individual article and that is passed Deletion of Luke Pritchard WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12624 3781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lions' Gate stabbings User:Debresser 22:12, 15 December 2018 (UTC) keep passes , . Plus Deletion of Lions' Gate stabbings WP:NCRIME||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12625 11602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Virtual Aviation Organization (3rd Nomination) User:FreeKresge 18:02, 23 April 2008 (UTC) delete unless there is an independent, |reliable source to confirm that there are 80,000 active members in the organization. The membership number is an impressive ''claim'' to |notability, which would nullify a speedy deletion. However, the article still needs a source to confirm that the number is accurate and not puffery on the part of the organization Deletion of International Virtual Aviation Organization (3rd Nomination) WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12626 21348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minakshi Datta User:Ragib 08:40, 14 November 2008 (UTC) delete per . Being the daughter or wife of notable persons do not make one notable Deletion of Minakshi Datta WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12627 17874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Pasqualetti User:Legis 07:21, 11 December 2011 (UTC) delete seems to clearly fail Deletion of Mike Pasqualetti WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12628 4031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eternal Decision User:NawlinWiki 13:31, 27 January 2007 (UTC) delete fails , arguably speediable but probably better to settle it here Deletion of Eternal Decision WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12629 1830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frankie Adams User:MSJapan 00:27, 27 March 2006 (UTC) delete nn vanity article. Meets none of the requirements for , particularly wrt athletics Deletion of Frankie Adams WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12630 1538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Who's Who in Federal Politics in Alberta User:Gilderien 11:08, 21 May 2013 (UTC) delete as it does not meet . The only mentions I can find are vendors or catalogues. It has not won any major literary awards, nor received multiple (or indeed, any) 3rd party reviews, etc Deletion of Who's Who in Federal Politics in Alberta WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12631 21103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Warschauer User:Dave6 08:55, 21 February 2007 (UTC) delete Depending on the version you look at, it's either obvious , or just an article about a non-notable assistant professor. I replaced the version that looks like an encyclopedia article, since the cut-and-paste research paper looks like recent vandalism (or possibly just a serious misunderstanding of what Wikipedia is), not a real version of the article Deletion of Mark Warschauer WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12632 17427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Wilson (director) User:Hydronium 09:26, 29 August 2020 (UTC) keep WP:SK1 appears to apply from the comment alone, and this and is confirmed by {{u|AppoWeb}}'s followup. Length or the lack of it is not a valid reason for deletion, and even a one sentence stub article can be retained if the claim to |notability is strong enough and its |sourcing is sufficient ( might be useful reading). No need for SK2 unless things continue -- and all Deletion of Joe Wilson (director) WP:SK3||WP:NOTABILITY||WP:SIGCOV||WP:ATA||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
12633 14196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dylan Thomas Andrews User:Blue520 13:06, 31 May 2006 (UTC) delete non-notable on grounds of or Deletion of Dylan Thomas Andrews WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12634 5486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lila Rajiva (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep per #People_still_alive Deletion of Lila Rajiva (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12635 20472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leishenshan Hospital [[User talk:5LZ|5LZ]] 07:30, 5 February 2020 (UTC) keep per and Deletion of Leishenshan Hospital WP:ORGCRIT||WP:NHOSPITALS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12636 11673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fine Fair Shopping Centre User:SpacemanSpiff 02:05, 14 July 2016 (UTC) delete as failing , not just . &mdash Deletion of Fine Fair Shopping Centre WP:V||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12637 7657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Lahore User:Eustachiusz 03:06, 7 March 2018 (UTC) keep apart from anything else, too many lists of different standards bundled together: at the very least, there should have been individual discussions on the obscure ones. Also, as pointed out above, doesn't apply. A time-wasting nomination Deletion of List of bus routes in Lahore :WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12638 19937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mushroom Kingdom Fusion (2nd nomination) User:Sloane 03:52, 10 March 2009 (UTC) delete Spam. Fails ote Deletion of Mushroom Kingdom Fusion (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12639 1536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ROSE Online User:Havok 10:10, 15 November 2006 (UTC) keep Notable, and actually a little bit fun. At least the beta was when I played it. What information that breaks can be removed. Oh, and Google isn't the be all and end all of research; http://www.gamespot.com/pc/rpg/roseonline/index.html GameSpot and http://pc.ign.com/objects/722/722780.html IGN both have information about this game Deletion of ROSE Online WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12640 18326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/For You (Film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:00, 7 July 2015 (UTC) keep per meeting per Arabic language coverage (https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=For_You_%28Film%29&type=revision&diff=670442885&oldid=670373636 now added). Sorry to disagree {{u|Diannaa}} and {{u|Kierzek}}, but currently used sources DO offer more than trivial |non-English coverage to meet .https://www.lebanese-forces.com/2015/03/12/men-ajlikom/http://www.lorientlejour.com/article/917942/-min-ajlikom-ou-la-passion-reactualisee.html and it was nominated for best film at the Pontifical Council for Culture#International Catholic Film Festival|International Catholic Film Festival.http://www.mirabiledictu-icff.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=52&Itemid=78 And, as the Vatican's Pontifical Council for Culture does not seek press for its film festivals, I will look for more in non-English languages Deletion of For You (Film) WP:NF||WP:NONENG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12641 3679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chatty Café Scheme User:MrsSnoozyTurtle 09:06, 1 September 2021 (UTC) keep the scattered pieces of coverage barely gets it over the line for in my book Deletion of Chatty Café Scheme WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12642 9697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Westfield North Rocks User:Elonka 22:23, 5 February 2007 (UTC) delete """According to , a business is notable """"If the organization has been the subject of multiple non-trivial, reliable published works whose source is independent of the organization itself."""" This article has none of that. I would also point to : """"Editors adding new material should cite a reliable source, or it may be challenged or removed by any editor. The obligation to provide a reliable source lies with the editors wishing to include the material, not with those seeking to remove it""" Deletion of Westfield North Rocks WP:CORP||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
12643 13825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Project Zee User:Schuym1 14:43, 29 November 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Project Zee WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12644 19634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John McCain lobbyist controversy User:MCB 22:59, 23 February 2008 (UTC) delete not because of or issues, but because I'm not convinced that this is other than an ephemeral news story or is of lasting encyclopedic merit. Yes, it was on page A1 of the NY Times, and there are hundreds if not thousands of stories in other sources. But it has been a story for only a couple of days, and may well be pretty much forgotten about in coming weeks or months, when there is other, fresher campaign news. I think for now it needs only a couple of sentences maximum, with citations, in John McCain presidential campaign, 2008 and in Vicki Iseman. Wikipedia is not a newspaper or news source Deletion of John McCain lobbyist controversy WP:BLP||WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12645 2276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Bennett Cohen User:Stuartyeates 03:59, 19 August 2013 (UTC) merge as above due to lacking in depth coverage in reliable sources as required by the . If such sources get added to the article, feel free to ping my talk page Deletion of David Bennett Cohen WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12646 561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Freespace Collective User:Coredesat 20:28, 23 June 2006 (UTC) delete per |CSD:A7. There is absolutely no notability here Deletion of Freespace Collective WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12647 837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noise, Noise and More Noise [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 21:23, 30 June 2008 (UTC) delete as insufficiently notable. Perfect example of why it's just silly that #A7 covers bands but not albums Deletion of Noise, Noise and More Noise WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12648 7300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K. P. Mohammed Kutty User:Sting_au 11:37, 13 January 2008 (UTC) delete as nn. Article subject fails Deletion of K. P. Mohammed Kutty WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12649 12322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Murphy (1965 - ) User:MichaelQSchmidt 16:53, 5 October 2008 (UTC) keep Passes io with flying colors. Did several searches for this gentleman... (Paul Murphy, writer), (Paul Murphy, author), (Paul Murphy, critic), (Paul Murphy, artist)... and despite the common name, if one checks the source text to eliminate the wrong ones, one finds plenty to suport the article. It requires cleanup and wikification, not deletion Deletion of Paul Murphy (1965 - ) WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
12650 8017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/521 Skateboards User:Ikh 01:20, 22 June 2006 (UTC) delete """Non-notable: Google gives only 24 hits on """"521 Skateboards"""" http://www.google.ca/search?hl=en&q=%22521+Skateboards%22&btnG=Google+Search&meta=, most of which are """"omitted"""". Two of the displayed hits come from some leftist forum postings, and remaining three are from Myspace.com. Hence, clearly does not satisfy , and should be deleted""" Deletion of 521 Skateboards WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12651 19464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dewvoids User:Bobet 02:39, 19 November 2005 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Dewvoids WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12652 18729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Foster (candidate for Congress) User:Charlene 13:19, 1 July 2007 (UTC) comment Clearly would fail if his candidacy were the only matter, but he may be notable as a physicist. The man won the Rossi Prize, although he won it as part of a group and I'm not sure if it's notable. Perhaps someone with more knowledge of his work could advise as to whether he is considered notable by his peers Deletion of Bill Foster (candidate for Congress) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12653 4862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of most-subscribed YouTube channels User:Paintspot 20:25, 11 February 2019 (UTC) keep per above. Satisfies ). Has enough secondary source coverage. Also, a big mass deletion of all these YouTube articles doesn't seem to be the best idea Deletion of List of most-subscribed YouTube channels WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12654 4759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Desktop Scientific User:Ottawa4ever 18:14, 12 August 2010 (UTC) delete Does seem to read as promotional. No real establishment of secondary sourcing either. As the article stands currrently fails Deletion of Desktop Scientific WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12655 13287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Adventures of Robloxian Hearts User:Jeremjay24 13:49, 27 August 2009 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet the |notability guidelines. It's just a random YouTuber. Not even Richard Michael Alvarez could have his own article Deletion of The Adventures of Robloxian Hearts WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12656 1799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan W. Gates User:Dhartung 18:03, 19 September 2007 (UTC) delete No attribution of notability to independent sources; fails Deletion of Ryan W. Gates WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12657 3075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Novik User:Canuckle 22:48, 18 June 2007 (UTC) delete To the creator, the encyclopedia is for articles on ''notable'' people judged by secondary, reliable sources to have wide recognition, influence or impact. Simply being a company executive isn't enough. Someday I hope that my company's CEO and Board Chair are notable enough for their own article. Until I'm certain they pass the guideline otability (people), I'll wait to post and I'll flag the conflict of interest, too Deletion of Steven Novik WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12658 996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katie Rodan NONE NONE delete """I've been thinking a lot about this one. DGG and Doc James make good sense. If this was created as a promo piece to help her earn more money, then it should be deleted. We have the clear ''""""https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:List_of_policies_and_guidelines_to_cite_in_deletion_debates#Favoring_deletion List of policies and guidelines that can be used for making one's case in proposing a page for deletion""""''. One of them is . So, was this created for that reason? Quite obviously. The creator has admitted working for Rodan, has made only edits to this article and https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Farzad_Nazem&type=revision&diff=646847259&oldid=634072303 one other. Both of these are about corporate people. It is very likely the creator is a business associate being paid rather than, say, someone in her sewing circle doing her a favour""" Deletion of Katie Rodan WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12659 1231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 India–Pakistan military confrontation User:NadirAli 19:34, 1 October 2016 (UTC) comment """If such an incident is not supported by a diverse international media and more importantly evidence, it should be stated that this was claimed and not written as some sort of """"proof"""". And I argue this the same for the so-called Osama Bin Laden killing which till this day has not been supported by any sufficient evidence aside from American government an media claims. That article should just state the name of the operation and include affirmative and negative arguments. Otherwise NPOV is pretty much dead or lost to |democracy""" Deletion of 2016 India–Pakistan military confrontation WP:DEM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12660 15153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dynamite (roller coaster) User:MBlaze 03:51, 4 September 2018 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Dynamite (roller coaster) WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12661 21369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of wind turbines User:DieSwartzPunkt 09:26, 18 November 2013 (UTC) delete The comparison with List of aircraft engines and List of automobiles is completely invalid. Both of those articles are simple lists that link (or are intended to link - in the case of articles yet to be provided) to a full article on the individual entry. List of wind turbines does not even purport to fulfill that role. It is clear that the list itself is intended to contain the technical details and even an illustration of each and every wind turbine in existence. I have made an attempt at trying to find ''secondary'' sources to support some of the details in the list and singularly failed. The apparent total absence of secondary sources, is clear evidence of the lack of |notabilty of the subject and that no one else cares. I also note that the list contains several in-line URLs which are not permitted in articles. I assume that these are a half hearted attempt at providing some references, but being |primary sources, they do not really qualify. This article is thus unlikely to ever be properly referenced and should be deleted Deletion of List of wind turbines WP:NOTABILITY||WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
12662 4093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mixed Company (Swarthmore College) (2nd nomination) User:BlueValour 02:52, 5 September 2006 (UTC) delete Merge is really a Keep since it allows the author to recreate). Fails Deletion of Mixed Company (Swarthmore College) (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12663 10856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inu Gundam User:Tikuko 18:08, 26 June 2013 (UTC) delete completely fails Deletion of Inu Gundam WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12664 21218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robby Shelton User:Nigej 18:58, 13 February 2017 (UTC) keep Category 1 of is normally regarded as including the Walker Cup, thus enabling strong amateur golfers to qualify for inclusion. He played in the 2015 Walker Cup and is included in the List of American Walker Cup golfers. He was also in the 2014 Palmer Cup and 2015 Palmer Cup teams, which also have a List of American Arnold Palmer Cup golfers page where he appears Deletion of Robby Shelton WP:NGOLF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12665 2648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Israt Jahan Ratna User:Govvy 09:25, 23 September 2020 (UTC) delete I don't think the creator of this article is SR Alamgir Khan, his editing was far more competent, and frankly this article and the others created by {{u|Sanyhd}} are far more naive. Back to the article, Bangladesh doesn't have a professional woman's league, it's more amateur level at current. If she was to play full international games that might be a different story but at the moment article fails . I really don't see met either Deletion of Israt Jahan Ratna WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12666 14705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lizzie Miller User:Simon 15:41, 10 September 2009 (UTC) delete per , unless there is some evidence that she was notable as a model apart and aside from this one photograph and the response to it.- Simon Dodd Deletion of Lizzie Miller WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12667 9152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian G. Walker (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 02:49, 5 April 2018 (UTC) delete """People do not get Wikipedia articles just for being candidates in elections they didn't win — if you cannot demonstrate and reliably source that he was already notable enough for an article for some other reason before becoming a candidate, then he has to win the election, not just run in it, to become notable as a politician. But this article cites no |reliable sources at all, instead merely |linkfarming a directory of |primary source links to directly affiliated """"references"""" like his own campaign website and the websites of organizations he was employed by, and it makes no claim of preexisting notability that's """"inherently"""" notable enough to exempt him from having to have reliable source coverage. I don't know where the OBE claim in the original discussion came from, because the article text doesn't state or source that Walker has an OBE, and didn't even state or source that at the time of the original discussion either — and even if it were actually verifiable at all, we still only accept the ''higher'' ranks (CBE and above) as a notability claim, not the lower MBE or OBE ranks""" Deletion of Ian G. Walker (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:NOTLINKFARM||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12668 19117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Davies User:A1octopus 16:29, 6 October 2007 (UTC) delete Have voted keep for the band as a whole as they do meet but the invidual band members are not notable for anything other than being part of the band so they do not (as individuals) qualify as notable under io Deletion of Alex Davies WP:MUSIC||WP:B Wikipedia:Notability 77
12669 11721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eminem's fifth studio album User:Kylohk 10:31, 21 May 2007 (UTC) delete """Rumors"""", """"could be"""", many unconfirmed content in the article. Until solid confirmations are released, this article should not be here per """ Deletion of Eminem's fifth studio album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12670 7345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PSU TV User:Mailer 05:54, 29 March 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of PSU TV WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12671 14 [[Aziz Alili]] (bleibt) Benutzer:CroMagnon 16:43, 10. Jul. 2008 (CEST) comment """Hm, als Obmann einer Hauptstadtgemeinde könnte er durchaus die """"Funktion eines Bischofs"""" () besitzen. Herausgestellt wird es im Artikel aber nicht und der Artikel ist auch sehr dürftig, daher""" Löschung von Aziz Alili Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12672 10281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sexuality and pregnancy User:Robchurch 18:08, 27 September 2005 (UTC) delete had my eye on this one to go as |original research as it is Deletion of Sexuality and pregnancy WP:ISNOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12673 8341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rome 2.0 User:Narky 12:04, 20 August 2018 (UTC) delete A search turned up nothing relevant about either the organisation or the self-proclaimed emperor. Fails Deletion of Rome 2.0 WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12674 5910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Satish Chandra Agrawal User:Bgwhite 06:08, 31 October 2011 (UTC) keep per he is inherently notable regardless of how little sources there are to be found Deletion of Satish Chandra Agrawal WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12675 7775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hubert Paul Chatelain user:Andrew 18:01, 24 January 2021 (UTC) keep """A warship was named after him which is a """"''significant award or honor''"""" and so passes """ Deletion of Hubert Paul Chatelain WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12676 17956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss Grand User:VocalIndia 07:57, 14 July 2021 (UTC) keep I strongly agree with Paul_012. Btw, so poor are arrived there🤣. Unfortunately, AfD is not a vote poll.... So sad Deletion of Miss Grand WP:IDONTLIKE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12677 2694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of rock epics User:Stifle 18:25, 6 March 2009 (UTC) delete """as an inherent violation of and . There is simply no way to independently determine whether a song is a """"rock epic""" Deletion of List of rock epics WP:NOR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
12678 16046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Insularity User:Bearian 18:04, 17 December 2014 (UTC) keep if it becomes sourced. See and Deletion of Insularity WP:BEFORE||WP:HEY Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
12679 1719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Goodhart User:Epinoia 21:14, 26 August 2019 (UTC) delete """does not meet which requires """"a well-known and significant award or honor"""" and/or """"made a widely recognized contribution"""" - does not meet which requires """"significant roles"""" (parts in two minor reality shows are not that significant) - does not meet which requires """"significant coverage""""; of the sources provided, the Newcastle Chronicle, Capital FM, MTV, and OK-TV mentions are all run-of-the-mill press-release style promos of upcoming shows () - the BBC article gives her coverage, but she is not the main subject of the article and The Florida Post gives a mere one-line mention - not enough for notability, therefore, delete""" Deletion of Sarah Goodhart WP:ANYBIO||WP:NACTOR||WP:BASIC||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12680 6350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Brodeur User:Dolovis 03:22, 8 July 2013 (UTC) merge to Martin Brodeur. This AfD is not necessary as the nom could/should have redirected this article, as it is his stated preference, per Deletion of Anthony Brodeur WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
12681 12722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Óttar Magnús Karlsson User:Sir 05:17, 28 December 2013 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage meaning the article fails and Deletion of Óttar Magnús Karlsson WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12682 5775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anzela Abbasi User:RebeccaGreen 09:58, 6 February 2019 (UTC) keep """Meets , with major roles in three blue-linked TV shows (""""Has had significant roles in multiple notable .. television shows""" Deletion of Anzela Abbasi WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12683 13237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shibuli User:SailingInABathTub 10:30, 13 April 2021 (UTC) keep the nominator does not propose a valid -REASON. The nominator does not say which notability guideline this article fails to meet Deletion of Shibuli WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12684 4581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of World War II Bronze Star Medal recipients User:Ventric 21:10, 31 December 2017 (UTC) delete per above. I agree with the / argument and the highly selective nature of this list with regard to the staggering number of recipients of this award. This specific information of this award should be on the article of the |notable person; not the other way around Deletion of List of World War II Bronze Star Medal recipients WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:DEFINE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12685 19141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minhocão (legendary creature) User:ComplexRational 22:44, 13 January 2019 (UTC) keep The rewritten version appears to satisfy (sources are plentiful, and the ones I can access make non-trivial mentions), though I would prefer if more open-access sources could be provided Deletion of Minhocão (legendary creature) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12686 18254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scientists' March on Washington User:Gfcvoice 04:30, 28 January 2017 (UTC) comment The organizers |may or may not follow through with that promise about an event |that may or may not occur. There's no need for this article until then. All we have right now is a big group of people joining a Facebook group Deletion of Scientists' March on Washington WP:CRYSTAL||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12687 2700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sei Muroya User:GiantSnowman 15:57, 5 March 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Sei Muroya WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12688 280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nichapat Suphap User:Sarahj2107 14:28, 19 October 2016 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet . I can't find any coverage in reliable sources. The two references currently in the article are not independent Deletion of Nichapat Suphap WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12689 2170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edificio Someillan User:Cewbot 00:02, 6 January 2021 (UTC) comment This nomination has had limited participation and falls within the standards set for |lack of quorum. There are no previous AfD discussions, undeletions, or current redirects and no previous PRODs have been located. This nomination may be '''eligible for |soft deletion''' at the end of its 7-day listing Deletion of Edificio Someillan WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
12690 20323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess Kaguya (ship) User:DAJF 05:52, 4 July 2008 (UTC) keep Properly sourced and verifiable. This is not speculation. says: ''1. Individual scheduled or expected future events should only be included if the event is notable and almost certain to take place. If preparation for the event is not already in progress, speculation about it must be well documented.'' The largest cruise ship ever to be built is notable, and planning is well-documented Deletion of Princess Kaguya (ship) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12691 14487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mikelle Biggs User:Dhartung 05:08, 23 March 2008 (UTC) delete #NEWS, #MEMORIAL Deletion of Mikelle Biggs WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12692 14676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bark Bark Bark User:TheSpecialUser 00:32, 9 September 2012 (UTC) keep per Michig and Gongshow, it meets Deletion of Bark Bark Bark WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12693 5433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muslim Action Committee User:Batard0 14:24, 25 October 2012 (UTC) merge to Mohammed cartoons. There were three or four BBC articles around the time of the controversy, when this group was organizing protests, but there's no evidence of a single drop of coverage outside of that. What this amounts to is essentially news that took place around these protests; but . It may warrant a sentence or two in the article about the controversy, however, since there clearly was significant coverage Deletion of Muslim Action Committee WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12694 14591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shatru of Kathmandu User:Tokyogirl79 06:16, 15 November 2011 (UTC) delete Unfortunately this just doesn't meet notability guidelines at this time as far as goes Deletion of Shatru of Kathmandu WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12695 1176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Baines User:CrazyAces489 22:46, 17 March 2015 (UTC) comment I am not going to walk you through the references like I did for Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Thompson (Judo). If I put it in there, it is probably there. Part of AFD is using ... '''Search for additional sources, if the main concern is notability.''' The 3 of you fail to do this for many of the articles that you are nominating. You can have the articles deleted if you choose. Arguing with all three of you is pointless to me. None of you are researching the articles as I clearly saw with Brewster Thompson Deletion of Greg Baines WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
12696 19643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colegio La Fe User:Danjel 05:15, 4 June 2012 (UTC) keep I worry that there might be room for consideration of here. I would prefer seeing some input from local wikipedians before deleting. '''&tilde Deletion of Colegio La Fe WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
12697 5883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Reagle User:David 01:14, 7 March 2015 (UTC) merge or redirect to the book again per . Re Geogene's comment about biases: my experience with AfD discussions is that we are usually more critical, not less, when the subject is Wikipedia-related, but nevertheless I don't see any source of notability beyond the one book in this case Deletion of Joseph Reagle WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
12698 15357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liana Ruppert User:Zxcvbnm 17:00, 18 December 2020 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Liana Ruppert WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12699 2880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Wars Chronicles (SW: JKA) [[User talk:72.64.62.51|talk]]) 01:55, 12 November 2007 (UTC) keep Well you know turkish, french, spanish wikipedia accept mods, i tought why not english, even though wikipedia is not trying to be like google this info doesnt hurt anyone, and main reaseon i put this here was to help people, i didnt put it just to have fun,... I really think it is peoples right to put in any appropirate info here. read this if you said delete '''Tukish, spanish, french, and some other languages accept this kind of content''' since wikipedia is one company even though it has diffrent moderators for diffrent languages english should accept too. so if you delete this article you have to delete every single mod or add-on or any kind of games realted expansions from all languages of wikipedia. If you delete this it is my right to ask to have more than 1000 articles deleted from wikipedia.. —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/72.64.62.51|72.64.62.51 Deletion of Star Wars Chronicles (SW: JKA) WP:ALLORNOTHING Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12700 20409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Immersive book User:Ipsign 14:13, 18 September 2011 (UTC) delete per G11, if doesn't qualify - simply delete on the basis of and/or Deletion of Immersive book WP:NOTPROMO||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12701 5826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rihards Gorkšs User:Jogurney 03:13, 11 September 2009 (UTC) keep Freimanis appears to meet per Skomorokh's research above; while Kalns, Soleičuks and Spole played in the UEFA Cup first round proper which should satisfy . None of the others have played in a fully-pro league, senior UEFA competition (other than qualifying rounds), or senior internationals. Some have played in the CIS Cup, but I don't think that would satisfy , and Azamat Baimatov claims to have played for his senior national team but I'm dubious of the claim since I can't verify it Deletion of Rihards Gorkšs WP:GNG||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12702 952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cthulhu in popular culture User:Carlossuarez46 05:44, 13 July 2007 (UTC) merge """relevant parts into Cthulhu mythos; Cthulhu mythos is not solely a creation of HP Lovecraft, but has been expanded on - both canonically and non-canonically - by others. Some elements of this article (with proper sourcing) would fall into the non-canonical usage. A quick search for """"Cthulhu"""" at Amazon shows numerous (non-canonical) books about the Cthulhu mythos sufficiently demonstrating to me that there are es that there is a notable """"popular culture"""" aspect to this, but I feel it would be better handled in the mythos article. Second choice would be keep""" Deletion of Cthulhu in popular culture WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12703 17652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cordiant User:Coredesat 04:20, 28 June 2006 (UTC) delete ad, fails Deletion of Cordiant WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12704 5487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of guidebooks about the Sierra Nevada User:Ohyeahmormons 17:13, 3 June 2008 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not |a directory Deletion of List of guidebooks about the Sierra Nevada WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12705 8266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Is Heavy Metal User:Lawrencekhoo 06:46, 25 June 2010 (UTC) delete Per |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball Deletion of This Is Heavy Metal WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12706 2802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Nimo (3rd nomination) User:Jimbo 08:29, 11 September 2008 (UTC) delete fails the criteria at #Athletes as he has never played in a fully-professional league or competition yet. Recreate if and when he ever does Deletion of Alex Nimo (3rd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12707 14383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bharat Overseas Bank Ltd. User:Terence 15:14, 27 August 2006 (UTC) keep meets and refrences has been cited Deletion of Bharat Overseas Bank Ltd. WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12708 19062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trivikram Srinivas User:Ashershow1 18:14, 5 March 2011 (UTC) keep as per Deletion of Trivikram Srinivas WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12709 14473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DJ Mickey Bono User:Absurdist 04:19, 23 July 2007 (UTC) delete Fails . It has so many myspace links, and a lack of reliable third-party sources Deletion of DJ Mickey Bono WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12710 18636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Kontras (2nd nomination) User:GPHemsley 03:57, 9 April 2010 (UTC) keep """Sidestepping the obvious and admitted cyberstalking and persistent vandalism, it appears to me that Adam Kontras fulfills the criteria of ''Creative professionals'': """"The person is known for originating a significant new concept, theory or technique."""", as well as ''Entertainers'': """"Has made unique, prolific or innovative contributions to a field of entertainment."""". In addition, as happened with the last AfD, even more sources have been uncovered, including one in a physical book: http://books.google.com/books?id=grhR1eYswPkC&lpg=PA37&dq=%22Adam%20Kontras%22%20-inpublisher%3Aicon&as_brr=0&pg=PA37#v=onepage&q=%22Adam%20Kontras%22%20-inpublisher:icon&f=false Naked Lens: Video Blogging & Video Journaling to Reclaim the YOU in YouTube™ by Michael Sean Kaminsky. It has been cited in source after source that Adam Kontras is the first known video blogger. That in itself should be enough to fulfill the notability requirements. However, Kontras has also hosted a segment on CBS's The Early Show, and prior to moving to California was a radio personality on two different stations in Columbus. Some of this is already cited in the article; some of it may not be. Either way, the """"self-references"""" are not inherently bad, as they help provide more detailed information. All of the major facts are also cited from external sources. I hope this discussion can focus on the actual content of Adam Kontras the article instead of whatever vendetta Charles Grove has against Adam Kontras the person. &mdash""" Deletion of Adam Kontras (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12711 17893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quickmix (Transformers) User:Knowledgekid87 20:31, 1 October 2019 (UTC) merge to List of Autobots per Deletion of Quickmix (Transformers) WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
12712 15340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/បីសាចគួរអោយស្រលាញ់់ User:Pharaoh 22:46, 31 July 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of បីសាចគួរអោយស្រលាញ់់ WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
12713 10587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gill Fielding User:Coolabahapple 03:17, 19 February 2017 (UTC) comment have been unable to find any reviews of Fielding's books from |reliable sources (Helen Fielding|''Bridget'' book reviews popping up didn't help!), minute/non-existent WorldCat library holdings of her books ie. https://www.worldcat.org/title/riches-the-7-secrets-of-wealth-you-were-never-told/oclc/751675572&referer=brief_results ''Riches'', 1 library, https://www.worldcat.org/title/wealth-alphabet-the-abc-of-wealth-creation/oclc/137312741&referer=brief_results ''The wealth alphabet'', 3 libraries, https://www.worldcat.org/title/solving-the-property-puzzle/oclc/960492943&referer=brief_results ''Solving the Property Puzzle'', 1 library, other titles not listed, so doesn't appear to meet Deletion of Gill Fielding WP:RS||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12714 11792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keith Buckley (Irish footballer) User:Mattythewhite 00:08, 28 May 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Keith Buckley (Irish footballer) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12715 1587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harrison Odjegba Okene User:WilliamJE 17:45, 5 December 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Harrison Odjegba Okene WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12716 3581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Super Trooper (card game) User:JIP 05:25, 3 September 2011 (UTC) delete no claims to notability, no references. Might just as well be |made up at school one day Deletion of Super Trooper (card game) WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
12717 15941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ch. Vasantha Rao User:Nsk92 20:01, 15 March 2010 (UTC) delete per nom. Being a college principal is not enough for passing ; not much else in the record to indicate academic notability Deletion of Ch. Vasantha Rao WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12718 12379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gregory Katz User:David 17:41, 26 May 2020 (UTC) delete He clearly does not pass #C1. #C5 is more plausible, but that criterion is only for chairs given for great scholarly accomplishment, clearly not the case here. The paid editing and promotionalism is also not helping Deletion of Gregory Katz WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12719 9453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ticket Ghana User:HighKing 14:51, 22 May 2020 (UTC) delete I am unable to locate any |significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, references to date fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic therefore fails GNG/ Deletion of Ticket Ghana WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12720 11998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amritha Aiyer User:GSS 19:11, 7 June 2018 (UTC) delete per nom two isn't multiple and its Deletion of Amritha Aiyer WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
12721 15477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Niloy Rashid Jaki User:GPL93 21:49, 1 August 2020 (UTC) delete per A7 & G11 and . Best Deletion of Niloy Rashid Jaki WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
12722 19334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hasmik Avetisyan User:Joe 01:05, 24 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |artist Deletion of Hasmik Avetisyan WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12723 9739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Sashen User:nonsenseferret 17:02, 16 February 2013 (UTC) delete cannot find substantial independent reliable coverage such as would bring this within and Deletion of Steven Sashen WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12724 10949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Muñoz User:Sir 23:46, 27 February 2011 (UTC) delete he fails , and he has not played professionally so he also fails Deletion of Paul Muñoz WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12725 7391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Osu!! Karate Bu User:Papaursa 23:32, 10 April 2017 (UTC) delete My search found nothing to show this topic meets . The article has no references and the external links do not lead to any significant independent coverage Deletion of Osu!! Karate Bu WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12726 11966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Far future in fiction User:Rhododendrites 18:17, 2 October 2020 (UTC) delete Whether the topic is notable seems apart from the question. More relevant seems WP:SALAT and WP:NOT. There might be a notable ''topic'' somewhere, but there isn't one scrap of this article that should be part of an article on that notable topic. There's not on independent reliable source in the bunch, instead comprising entirely in-universe fandom/trivia. It's unclear whether a different version of this article would be notable, because it's unclear what a completely different article would look like. i.e. at minimum. &mdash Deletion of Far future in fiction WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
12727 20378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brenda Jones-Matthews User:power 01:43, 20 November 2017 (UTC) delete there's no sign of or being met here. I can't even find the coverage I'd expect of the mayor of a medium-sized American town. The only reference is a trivial one-line mention in election coverage Deletion of Brenda Jones-Matthews WP:NPOL||WP:GNG||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12728 14128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gun Nut User:Isotope23 23:53, 11 July 2007 (UTC) comment Not that it appears to be having any real effect, but the article creator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/BillyTFried has engaged in some fairly blatant |canvassing Deletion of Gun Nut WP:CANVASS Wikipedia:Canvassing 93
12729 10371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Yellin User:Lukeno94 14:33, 22 October 2012 (UTC) delete has no sources at all, fails otability by miles Deletion of Adam Yellin WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12730 14730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sujoy Roy User:Marasmusine 11:01, 14 January 2009 (UTC) keep above items are convincing, but obviously need implementing as the article currently fails Deletion of Sujoy Roy WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12731 4859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magical Circus User:K 02:13, 27 June 2018 (UTC) delete Does not meet ; significant RS coverage not found. I don't see any content / sources worth merging, and the tour appears to be too insignificant for the name to have become a plausible search term Deletion of Magical Circus WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12732 18080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Earthbound User:FOARP 16:02, 11 June 2020 (UTC) keep No evidence that was followed and good evidence that it probably wasn't as this was part of a mass-nomination of dozens of articles about Greek culture over the course of a hour Deletion of The Earthbound WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
12733 6866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of streets in Oslo User:Sandstein 08:49, 5 April 2017 (UTC) delete """per ; no indication that this topic, """"streets in Oslo"""", has been covered as such in reliable sources""" Deletion of List of streets in Oslo WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12734 19144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Badduke User:Papaursa 18:35, 20 November 2017 (UTC) delete He meets none of the hockey notability criteria and also fails to meet . A little coverage about his frequent fighting penalties in local papers is the best I could find and I don't think that's enough Deletion of John Badduke WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12735 4342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scot and Maurine Proctor User:Dennisthe2 16:06, 1 March 2010 (UTC) delete Sources available do not convey notability of this couple. This said, regardless of the pairing, I'm thinking that, once they attain |notability, they should each have an article that stands up to our standards Deletion of Scot and Maurine Proctor WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12736 11757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Rockney (male model) User:SunStar 23:27, 25 February 2007 (UTC) delete This appears to be a joke/hoax article of some sort. I can find no third-party sources, or indeed, anything that assesses notability of the subject. This doesn't meet Deletion of Tom Rockney (male model) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12737 20353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trevor Engle User:Paulmcdonald 22:50, 8 March 2010 (UTC) delete I'm not ready to call it a hoax, but without |reliable sources it doesn't matter. No source, no article Deletion of Trevor Engle WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12738 9097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Republican Party Sex Scandals User:Aagtbdfoua 00:30, 5 January 2008 (UTC) delete Election year already? Delete unless these are going to be sourced to (WP:V, WP:RS, WP:NPOV) sources that talk about the phenomenon of Republican Party Sex Scandals. Stringing together a laundry list of 'scandals' and asserting a phenomenon called 'Republican Party Sex Scandals' seems pretty to me. Article would also need to justify fork from general Political scandals in US article (i.e., there would have to be WP:V, WP:NPOV cited substantial difference between handling of scandals in parties). Even then, seems excruciatingly minute for an encyclopedia. The after-thought of an article about the Democrats should share the same fate Deletion of Republican Party Sex Scandals WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12739 13484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ole Jensen (neuroscientist) User:Russ 12:21, 21 July 2020 (UTC) keep per C1. His top-cited five publications have over 1000 citations each, and I don't see any other red flags (though the article could use some trimming). Comment that the nominator is themself an SPA Deletion of Ole Jensen (neuroscientist) WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12740 20619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryan Meredith (soccer) User:GiantSnowman 16:01, 30 January 2011 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Bryan Meredith (soccer) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12741 1192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Air characters User:Soetermans 09:32, 12 April 2016 (UTC) delete """A list of in-game characters without any sources fails . Just because does not mean it should stay. The main article might've passed GA, but this long, unsourced and trivial list wouldn't have made that possible. Wikipedia articles, also """"list of x characters"""", have to be properly sourced. Now, looking through /RS custom Google https://cse.google.com/cse/home?cx=003516479746865699832:leawcwkqifq search engine, using search terms like """"air characters"""", """"key air characters"""", """"air kano misuzu minagi"""", etc., does not bring up any in-depth sources. I also urge other editors in this discussion to look up possible sources first, before voting keep""" Deletion of List of Air characters WP:GNG||WP:ITEXISTS||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12742 12494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellis Lankster User:Stifle 14:50, 3 January 2009 (UTC) delete for now, seems to fail / in general Deletion of Ellis Lankster WP:ATHLETE||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12743 533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raja salesh mandir User:Newshunter12 05:36, 28 October 2018 (UTC) delete This article fails because it lacks even the coverage to create an article about the topic, let alone have enough to prove notability. I am also troubled by the naked COI editing described above, which adds to the need to remove this article, since such conduct shouldn't be rewarded Deletion of Raja salesh mandir WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12744 2742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Palestinian rocket attacks on Israel User:Knowledgekid87 21:35, 13 July 2014 (UTC) delete per and . The rocket attacks on Israel are notable, do we need a list of every single attack though? No, the main article pretty much sums up the attacks and people killed. I find this list un-encyclopedic just as a list of rocket attacks by Israel would be, its overkill in terms of details, and the attacks have become routine news Deletion of List of Palestinian rocket attacks on Israel WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12745 210 [[Drakan: The Ancients' Gates]] (redirect) Benutzer:HoHun NONE keep """Kein Alleinstellungsmerkmal"""" ist kein von den vorgesehener Löschgrund, daher . """"Nur ein Konsolenspiel"""" ist ein von den ausdrücklich ausgeschlossener pauschalisierender Löschgrund, also erst recht behalten""" Löschung von Drakan: The Ancients' Gates Wikipedia:Löschregeln Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12746 12162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John C. Hench Division of Animation and Digital Arts User:Cordless 22:49, 10 December 2017 (UTC) merge to USC School of Cinematic Arts. University schools and departments don't always qualify for standalone articles, let alone divisions of those schools and departments, and this one doesn't appear to meet Deletion of John C. Hench Division of Animation and Digital Arts WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12747 16571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shupikaya Chipunza User:Bejnar 19:04, 13 May 2017 (UTC) delete as failing , the Falkland Islands official football team does not qualify as belonging to a :Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|Fully professional league, unlike the Faroe Islands Premier League. Thee is no other basis for notability Deletion of Shupikaya Chipunza WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12748 16012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Journal of Creative Computing User:Tigraan 12:55, 21 March 2016 (UTC) delete per nom. Publishing in a journal ≠ thinking it is influential (especially for a first issue!), so I fail to see the Jpbowen's claim on #1 Deletion of International Journal of Creative Computing WP:JOURNALCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12749 21353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaydex User:Celestina007 11:27, 03 October 2017 (UTC) delete """subject of article does not satisfy nor qualify for a stand-alone article on the encylopedia as the subject of the article fails primary notabiliy guidelines and policies. Example : and and furthermore; {{u|Darreg}}, to add to your thesis, it is my understanding that of recent most individuals have started to realize that creating pages for others or themselves is relatively easy, and not as """"hard"""" nor is it a prerogative of only staffs employed at Wikipedia as erroneously believed in times past, hence the hike we all are currently experiencing as regards the creation of pages of non-notable persons. it would get worse as this knowledge becomes more widely known""" Deletion of Kaydex WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12750 2439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lester Leaps In User:Edison 19:03, 26 August 2011 (UTC) delete """Fails otability and |verifiability as a compilation album. First: Verifiability problems: Amazon lists two CD compilations of Lester Young's recording with this title, but they have different tunes on them. There may well be a CD compilation with this title and these tunes, but there is no reference to prove it, and not even a mention of the record company or record number. Second: Notability issues: There is no information provided, nor could I find evidence, that this particular compilation was a notable one, with reviews , critical commentary, high sales, or placing in jazz recording charts. That said, the individual tune named """"Lester leaps in"""" could very easily be shown to be a notable http://www.google.com/search?q=%22lester+leaps+in%22&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a#q=%22lester+leaps+in%22&hl=en&safe=off&client=firefox-a&hs=Ihh&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&prmd=ivns&ei=iOlXTsn5O42CsgKKr7jDDA&start=10&sa=N&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.&fp=b62454da27284b07&biw=1272&bih=853 jazz classic, popular in Young's own 1939 jazz instrumental """"Lester Leaps In, http://books.google.com/books?id=oPPMbb0cGuYC&pg=PA170&dq=%22lester+leaps+in%22&hl=en&ei=OuxXTo2nFoivsAK66_iJDA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=10&ved=0CFIQ6AEwCTgK#v=onepage&q=%22lester%20leaps%20in%22&f=false widely http://books.google.com/books?id=Zc4Lh9KC2MIC&pg=PA558&dq=%22lester+leaps+in%22&hl=en&ei=OuxXTo2nFoivsAK66_iJDA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=7&ved=0CEQQ6AEwBjgK#v=onepage&q=%22lester%20leaps%20in%22&f=false discussed in http://books.google.com/books?id=pJvzEzjahkQC&pg=PA133&dq=%22lester+leaps+in%22&hl=en&ei=J-1XTti_CZOssALhnrmyDA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CCkQ6AEwADgU#v=onepage&q=%22lester%20leaps%20in%22&f=false books about http://books.google.com/books?id=AFlK4gzldw4C&pg=PA202&dq=%22lester+leaps+in%22&hl=en&ei=J-1XTti_CZOssALhnrmyDA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=2&ved=0CC4Q6AEwATgU#v=onepage&q=%22lester%20leaps%20in%22&f=false jazz, http://books.google.com/books?id=Zfn0lH_ZnGsC&pg=PA74&dq=%22lester+leaps+in%22&hl=en&ei=vO1XTsPCBMPjsQLYxPCeDA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=4&ved=0CDUQ6AEwAzge#v=onepage&q=%22lester%20leaps%20in%22&f=false and widely played by notable jazz bands and musicians, and http://books.google.com/books?id=fqGe7Sv71qgC&pg=PT12&dq=%22lester+leaps+in%22&hl=en&ei=SetXTr6XMM-msALt8PSsDA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=6&ved=0CEQQ6AEwBQ#v=onepage&q=%22lester%20leaps%20in%22&f=false discussed in books about jazz standard tunes. The tune :Lester leaps in"""" is ranked http://www.jazzstandards.com/compositions-2/lesterleapsin.htm 219 in the top 1000 jazz standards at Jazzstandards.com. So it would be appropriate for someone to create a new article about the tune """"Lester leaps in,"""" and if they do there should be no suggestion they were """"recreating a deleted article""" Deletion of Lester Leaps In WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
12751 12360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Contemporary Australian Left User:Quarl NONE delete as |original research, not NPOV. &mdash Deletion of The Contemporary Australian Left WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12752 12466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamal Karna Roy User:JoshuaZ 17:59, 3 February 2008 (UTC) delete All sources are primary thus failling . Has serious and issues Deletion of Kamal Karna Roy WP:N||WP:OR||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12753 0 [[Markilux]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Andy king50 NONE delete """Einer der typischen Artikel nach dem Motto """"ich will da mal was aus eigenem wirtschaftlichen Interesse in die WP schreiben und was die Regeln betrifft, die auf der Seite zum Hochladen neuer Artikel stehen wie und WP:RK, die mag ich eigentlich garnicht lesen, die interessieren mich einen Sch...., weil ich will einfach nur diese Firma hier reinbringen. WP:RK deutlich verfehlt, bitte wiederkommen wenn nachweislich erfüllt. Das hier""" Löschung von Markilux Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12754 16953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chromatic Assesment in Education User:Gamall 06:52, 8 April 2017 (UTC) delete The current article is terribly written and describes ideas of almost breathtaking inanity (this based on reading the sources in French; the article itself is not very informative). Fortunately, said ideas do not seem to have caught on overmuch. The ref indicates that a couple of primary schools have tried it. That's pretty much it. No |notability to speak of Deletion of Chromatic Assesment in Education WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12755 14736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TurningWheels for Kids User:Rorshacma 15:16, 6 May 2020 (UTC) delete I'm finding one bit of decent sized coverage in The Mercury News, but that appears to be it. All other coverage appears to be only in local sources, or merely mentions of the charity with no further information. That single source would not allow this to pass the Deletion of TurningWheels for Kids WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12756 11880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David G. McAfee (2nd nomination) User:Bmbaker88 18:18, 6 May 2018 (UTC) delete This article does not meet and seems to be written to |advertise the subject Deletion of David G. McAfee (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NOTADVERTISING Wikipedia:Notability 77
12757 2169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarmayacar User:Gidonb 14:01, 2 March 2021 (UTC) delete As an independent entity, no clear merge or redirect target. Between keep and delete, it's delete for the reasons mentioned by the nominiator. Also fails the Deletion of Sarmayacar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12758 12382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/South Callaway High School User:GaryECampbell 23:32, 3 July 2008 (UTC) delete """Nothing in this article's content demonstrates notability. Article is a newsletter soap box, """"This year our football team dramatically improved.."""" Delete as per , , """ Deletion of South Callaway High School WP:V||WP:NOBJ||WP:NOTSOAPBOX Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12759 17933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Borna (Persian given name) User:Citrusbowler 15:58, 16 June 2013 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Borna (Persian given name) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12760 13714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sixty Minute War User:ItsZippy 20:22, 5 February 2012 (UTC) delete The topic is not notable - the only sources are from the books themselves. Completely in-universe and with no evidence of real-world notability. Neither of the keep votes go beyond Deletion of Sixty Minute War WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12761 11835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/4 Pics 1 Word User:Mark 22:50, 21 March 2013 (UTC) keep Since the nomination, Lukeno94 did an excellent job of rewriting the article almost from scratch. All the earlier promotional material is now gone and what's left is a good start-class article with reviews in reliable sources such as PC Advisor, WhatMobile, and Inside Social Games. The game seems to pass notability guidelines per and spam is not longer an issue, which suggests that this article be kept Deletion of 4 Pics 1 Word WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12762 17060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Masada User:Northamerica1000 00:06, 8 April 2016 (UTC) keep """The subject passes . Source examples include, but are not limited to: {{cite web|url=http://articles.latimes.com/2009/apr/05/business/fi-himi5|title=Laugh Factory owner is serious about comedy|work=Los Angeles Times}}, {{cite web|url=http://variety.com/2014/voices/columns/laugh-factory-jamie-masada-funniest-person-competition-1201330070/|title=Laugh Factory’s Jamie Masada Looks for Funniest Person in the World - Variety|author=Brian Lowry|work=Variety (magazine)|Variety}}, {{cite web|url=http://variety.com/2014/scene/lifestyle/jamie-masada-continues-delivering-thanksgiving-alms-at-the-laugh-factory-1201362300/|title=Jamie Masada Continues Delivering Thanksgiving Alms at the Laugh Factory|author=Kevin Noonan|work=Variety}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.foxnews.com/entertainment/2011/02/14/stand-comedians-receive-free-psychological-treatment-hollywoods-laugh-factory/|title=Stand-Up Comedians to Receive Free Psychological Treatment at Hollywood's Laugh Factory|author=Hollie McKay|work=Fox News}}, https://books.google.com/books?id=Gi2gZQ7XygwC&pg=PA46 ''Variety's """"The Movie That Changed My Life""""''. pp. 46–48., https://books.google.com/books?id=1XQ6xt25aREC&pg=PA296 ''Vintage Tomorrows''. pp. 296–. {{paywall}}, http://www.canyon-news.com/artman2/publish/Features-Aug-2007/The_Laugh_Factory_and_Jamie_Masada_No_Laughing_Matter_printer.php """"The Laugh Factory And Jamie Masada, No Laughing Matter"""". ''Canyon News''., https://books.google.com/books?id=KKqk3l2N6ZQC&q=%22Jamie+Masada%22&dq=%22Jamie+Masada%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi939Tl4P3LAhUEjJQKHVj1CwQQ6AEIOjAF ''Comic Insights''. pp. 264–269 (and maybe more) {{paywall}}, https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-161022244.html """"Masada goes into spin tale"""". ''Variety''. {{paywall}}, https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-158152748.html """"Jamie Masada"""". ''Variety''. {{paywall}}, https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-388827370.html """"Stand-Up Guy"""". ''Los Angeles Magazine''. {{paywall}}, https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-37047366.html """"Laugh Factory Founder Hopes to Unite Countries through Search for 'Funniest Person in the World'"""". ''Los Angeles Daily News''. {{paywall}}, https://www.highbeam.com/Search?searchTerm=%22Jamie+Masada%22 More articles.... I have copy edited the article to address copyvio, close paraphrasing and promotional tone; it is now clear of any infringement (https://tools.wmflabs.org/copyvios/?lang=en&project=wikipedia&title=Jamie+Masada&oldid=&action=search&use_engine=1&use_links=1&turnitin=0 Earwig's Copyvio Detector results""" Deletion of Jamie Masada WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12763 13739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judy Moran User:Lankiveil 01:00, 3 May 2008 (UTC) keep plenty of secondary sourcing, was portrayed in Underbelly_(TV_series)|a major Australian TV series... so definitely notable. should be a concern for this article, but that is no reason for deletion Deletion of Judy Moran WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12764 17223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Charles Rockefeller User:Bearian 16:51, 3 September 2019 (UTC) delete """He's done nothing but """"was influenced by his grandfather"""" and """"|follows closely"""" a well-known teen activist. He's |riding on the coat-tails of his ancestors and a 15-year-old girl""" Deletion of Michael Charles Rockefeller WP:WEASEL||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
12765 6071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Notable figures of the 1980s User:The 23:05, 1 March 2008 (UTC) delete per . This is an exceedingly broad list and seems to be rather pointless Deletion of Notable figures of the 1980s WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
12766 9174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sahar (singer) (2nd nomination) User:doomsdayer520 02:00, 6 January 2021 (UTC) delete """I vowed above to stay neutral for a while, but am compelled to cast my own vote in light of the poor knowledge of Wikipedia policies displayed by the """"Keep"""" and """"Weak Keep"""" voters here. I am absolutely convinced that the Iranian media suppresses talented entertainers, but that is a problem that is much bigger than Wikipedia, and Wikipedia is not equipped to fix it. The larger problem could be discussed at Censorship in Iran, but helping to promote unlucky entertainers is not one of Wikipedia's functions. If anyone thinks that |notability guidelines should be loosened for Iranian entertainers but nobody else, go to Wikipedia:Village pump (policy) and try to make a convincing argument there. This particular discussion is about the notability of Sahar, and (as mentioned above) her Persian stage name and birth name are freely available in the article. Via Google Translate, a search brings up sites that are invariably promotional announcements and social media chatter that are informative but unreliable for our purposes here. Therefore she is not notable, as already decided multiple times over in Persian Wikipedia. Good luck to her""" Deletion of Sahar (singer) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12767 13941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Garageresource User:Stifle 01:58, 5 February 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Garageresource WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12768 15252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Going By User:TheFarix 16:33, 10 January 2010 (UTC) delete as no one has yet show that the information on the page can be |verified, much else that the song could passes Deletion of Going By WP:V||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12769 7284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Sweeney User:Bwithh 23:25, 6 August 2006 (UTC) delete as per nom. Wikipedia is not a news report database. Case of ecentism here Deletion of Craig Sweeney WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
12770 16166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmed Abdultaofik User:Sir 18:33, 1 June 2011 (UTC) delete he fails , and he has not appeared in a fully pro league meaning he fails Deletion of Ahmed Abdultaofik WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12771 8450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunrise (Puffy AmiYumi single) User:Schuym1 01:33, 7 November 2008 (UTC) merge to Puffy AmiYumi. Fails Deletion of Sunrise (Puffy AmiYumi single) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12772 7720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dense (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 23:00, 4 January 2009 (UTC) keep as I have now expanded and sourced the article per film MOS. Notability is currently thin, but I think it just nudges to the plus side of . I have tagged to article for Deletion of Dense (film) WP:NF||WP:RESCUE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12773 21561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alone (Remake) User:Yngvarr 23:15, 10 July 2008 (UTC) delete no merge, no redirect. Maybe later, if the movie ever gets beyond the phase Deletion of Alone (Remake) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12774 11522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rory Jenkins (Footballer) User:GiantSnowman 12:49, 12 April 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Rory Jenkins (Footballer) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12775 6539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crowd for Angels User:Gongshow 07:41, 6 June 2014 (UTC) delete appears to be too early for this to meet , , etc.; I am unable to find coverage in independent reliable sources Deletion of Crowd for Angels WP:GNG||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12776 17390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al Dini User:LaundryPizza03 09:47, 10 September 2018 (UTC) delete """that dot isn't even in UAE – it's in the exclave of Oman. Borderline |G3. There is nothing at that exact coordinates except for a nearby place called """"Limah"""" ({{lang-ar|لیمه}}) that I didn't find here or at arwiki""" Deletion of Al Dini WP:G3 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12777 21608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tremors: The Thunder From Down Under User:Ryan4314 06:09, 10 December 2008 (UTC) delete per rystal Deletion of Tremors: The Thunder From Down Under WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
12778 12007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alien Stash Tin User:Joe 19:09, 1 November 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |band Deletion of Alien Stash Tin WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12779 15302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boogerman User:MuZemike 20:36, 23 September 2008 (UTC) merge to ''Boogerman: A Pick and Flick Adventure''. #OR|Wikipedia is not a publisher of original thought Deletion of Boogerman WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12780 15391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pleasure Valley, Indiana User:Epinoia 16:15, 17 May 2019 (UTC) delete """the guidelines say nothing about a """"minimal threshold"""" - if there is a """"minimal threshold required per community consensus"""" then the guidelines need to be updated to reflect this consensus, but as it stands we must follow the guidelines as written - says that """"geographical features meeting Wikipedia's General notability guideline (GNG) are presumed, but not guaranteed, to be notable"""" - meeting GNG means having """"significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject"""" - this place lacks significant coverage (mentioned in a list or appearing on a map is a passing reference, not significant coverage) - says that places without legal recognition (like this unincorporated community) can be considered notable """"given non-trivial coverage in multiple, independent reliable sources"""" - also says that places may be notable """"because notability encompasses their entire history"""", but this place has no notable history - just existing does not establish notability - the article does not meet , therefore delete - also, """"Two sentences does not an encyclopedic article make,"""" and """"All articles that are only one or two sentences long should be either expanded or deleted."""" per """ Deletion of Pleasure Valley, Indiana WP:NGEO||WP:GEOLAND||WP:GNG||WP:2S Wikipedia:Notability 77
12781 19150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/José Luis Gayá User:Mikemor92 19:47, 17 December 2012 (UTC) delete They did play for in a Cup match, but it wasn't against a fully pro club. Therefore, they fail and Deletion of José Luis Gayá WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12782 12749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nestor Velazquez User:Green 04:59, 26 August 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Nestor Velazquez WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12783 10628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mumpsimus User:Mr 15:09, 19 February 2013 (UTC) keep per . I was on the fence before, but the expansion clinches it. The current sources in the article seem to be enough to satisfy Deletion of Mumpsimus WP:HEY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
12784 5522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uchechukwu Otti User:Dom 19:56, 11 September 2020 (UTC) delete Falls far short of all criteria at Deletion of Uchechukwu Otti WP:NMUSICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12785 20393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yordan Tushev User:Argyle 20:34, 15 March 2011 (UTC) delete Non-notable footballer. Fails and Deletion of Yordan Tushev WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12786 1344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julia Allison (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 20:31, 7 April 2021 (UTC) delete First, off the promotional tone screams . I see a few articles ''by'' her, but ''absolutely nothing'' in | reliable sources ''about'' her. She has 49,000 followers on Twitter, a testament to her follow-back and self-promotion strategies. This is a total fail of . I can't believe this was kept in 2009 Deletion of Julia Allison (2nd nomination) WP:TNT||WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
12787 3243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roberto Jacoby User:Snotbot 19:22, 15 April 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 April 15 Deletion of Roberto Jacoby WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
12788 4434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samantha Smith (actress) User:Tomwsulcer 11:53, 10 August 2014 (UTC) comment """There may be an issue with her name being so common (sometimes it is even """"Sam Smith"""" which is even more common). When I googled this search string -- (""""samantha smith"""") -Maine -plane -crash -Andropov -Soviet (actress OR winchester OR paranormal OR supernatural) -- and https://www.google.com/search?q=(%22samantha+smith%22)+-Maine+-plane+-crash+-Andropov+-Soviet+(actress+OR+winchester+OR+paranormal+OR+supernatural)&espv=2&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=51vnU_DnH5PisATekoGQDA&ved=0CAYQ_AUoAThG&biw=1086&bih=862 perused the photos, it was not clear to me exactly who was the ''real'' Samantha Smith, like there are at least two different actresses with the name Samantha Smith. If the photos are all of the same person, ie Samantha Smith the actress, then when she is sometimes blonde, sometimes brunette, with different looks, (needed obviously to play different roles) well it is somewhat difficult to ascertain with certainty exactly who is ''the'' Samantha Smith. Is it http://www.zimbio.com/pictures/bKHDDdBCuQP/Rage+Official+Launch+Party+Inside/UotnvpctMF_/Samantha+Smith this person? Or http://www.therisinghollywood.com/2011/11/22/rising-actress-samantha-smith/ this person? Or http://www.supernaturalwiki.com/index.php?title=Samantha_Smith this person? Or http://www.samanthasmith.co.uk/ this person? If we look at http://www.gettyimages.com/editorial/samantha-smith---actress-pictures Getty images, seems like there are two different persons. That said, using the best search string I could concoct, after searching 10 SERP pages, I did not see much in the way of multiple independent reliable nontrivial sources as required by the although it may be there was so much fan cruft that it needs somebody to search through perhaps another 10 to 20 SERP pages. Or, maybe she is a character actor who somewhat flies under the radar of name recognition""" Deletion of Samantha Smith (actress) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12789 12121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Four to the Floor (film) User:Satori 18:50, 7 May 2010 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Four to the Floor (film) WP:NFF||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
12790 20586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Resignation of Shirley Sherrod [[User talk:71.52.140.113|talk]]) 22:05, 21 July 2010 (UTC) merge to United States Department of Agriculture. No need for a stand alone article, per and , unless it grows into something bigger, which is very unlikely. It's already discussed at United States Department of Agriculture (in fact, I think it violates there). Special:Contributions/71.52.140.113|71.52.140.113 Deletion of Resignation of Shirley Sherrod WP:NOTNEWS||WP:RECENT||WP:WEIGHT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12791 3009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Havasu 95 Speedway User:Darkwind 20:06, 17 January 2013 (UTC) comment When evaluating the PROD, I found several newspaper articles, implying that further research might turn up enough coverage to meet , so I contested the PROD on that basis. &mdash Deletion of Havasu 95 Speedway WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12792 9205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sha Dixon User:MelanieN 02:18, 20 March 2011 (UTC) delete """Non-notable, no news hits at all found. An example of ; she """"received her first break in 2011"""". Maybe she will become notable later, but she is not at this time""" Deletion of Sha Dixon WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
12793 4914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Felix Peng User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable biography Deletion of Felix Peng WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12794 5271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tour de Kits User:Kinu 19:28, 25 August 2006 (UTC) comment """No, nothing really """"deserves"""" to be on Wikipedia if it does not comply with policy, such as . |Reliable sources carry significantly more weight than impassioned claims around these parts""" Deletion of Tour de Kits WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12795 8738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wayne Shaw (footballer) User:Struway2 11:55, 21 February 2017 (UTC) delete """GNG takes more than a couple of tabloidy pieces. There are always """"human interest"""" stories in the media when a small club play a big club in the FA Cup, whether tragic, heartwarming or, as in Mr Shaw's case, comic. Mr Shaw is the goalkeeping coach to Sutton United, a fifth-tier team drawn to play Arsenal in an unexpectedly late stage of the competition, who happens to be very fat. The sources currently present in the article are from the local paper from the Sutton area, the non-RS ''Daily Mail'' website, and the ''Evening Standard'', a free-sheet that's given away in London to read on the train.The pieces mentioned by {{u|Mattlore}} are two versions of the same story: that Mr Shaw apparently took advantage of a betting promotion connected with a major tabloid newspaper to make himself a few quid by eating a pie during the match, embarrassed his team by so doing, and might get into trouble with the football authorities.A few articles in the lightweight end of the last few days' media hung on a fat bloke's non-playing involvement with a non-league team reaching the last 16 of the FA Cup doesn't convey individual notability. (E)#People notable for only one event says that """"People known only in connection with one event should generally not have an article written about them. If the event is notable, then an article usually should be written about the event instead."""" If the event were notable, a redirect would be appropriate, but I suspect it isn't; had Sutton beaten Arsenal, it might have been. cheers""" Deletion of Wayne Shaw (footballer) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12796 7279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sportsshoes.com (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 14:01, 3 March 2021 (UTC) merge to Bruce Bannister, which only has one short sentence about this company that he founded. Merging a bit of the content will improve that article (-M Deletion of Sportsshoes.com (2nd nomination) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12797 10612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Adopted Son (1917 film) User:MarnetteD 21:43, 28 April 2019 (UTC) keep meets neither item mentioned by the nom is a reason for deletion Deletion of The Adopted Son (1917 film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
12798 14327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Individualistic Punks User:Reflex 17:13, 28 October 2005 (UTC) delete Does not meet Deletion of Individualistic Punks WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12799 17950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe DeRosa (comedian) User:ToonLucas22 20:54, 6 March 2015 (UTC) keep While the article may not have enough sources, you can notify people with the {{t|ref improve}} (or {{t|BLP sources}} in BLP pages), and he seems to be notable for various events, and part of your argument seems to be Deletion of Joe DeRosa (comedian) WP:GOOGLEHITS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12800 10558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 Louisville Bats season User:Ravenswing 18:24, 22 November 2010 (UTC) keep """Yes, I see the precedent. Who says? Sub-top-flight season articles widely exist in the soccer team articles, and they certainly exist in the college football and basketball team articles, areas where no one can claim that they represented the """"highest level"""" possible. Why would anyone claim that coverage that would meet the GNG not exist? Let's look at a couple of the cities Wizardman cites. Ottawa? Columbus? Charlotte? No one questions whether the Columbus Blue Jackets has enough press coverage to sustain season articles. No one questions whether the Ottawa Senators or the Ottawa Rough Riders merit season articles. No one questions the ability of the Charlotte press to source Charlotte Bobcats season articles. Why so here? Plainly this particular article needs sourcing, but I don't doubt that sourcing exists. I want more than a for a deletion ground""" Deletion of 2009 Louisville Bats season WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12801 8199 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dimitri """"El Boss""""""" User:Michig 18:32, 19 September 2010 (UTC) delete No significant coverage found. No indication that the subject meets any of the criteria at """Deletion of Dimitri """"El Boss""""""" WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12802 5774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Curio (magazine) User:TerriersFan 00:31, 22 August 2007 (UTC) delete Bootleg (magazine). The reference indicates that it has been published but there are no s to indicate that it has any notability . A bad failure of Deletion of Curio (magazine) WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12803 20404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nordan Shat User:Sergecross73 13:53, 12 April 2016 (UTC) merge He fails the , I don't see a single third party |reliable source dedicated directly around the subject. His group has its own article though, so it could be a viable search term Deletion of Nordan Shat WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12804 15801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HD 269700 User:MarnetteD 22:24, 8 July 2017 (UTC) delete At this point in time there just isn't enough info to meet or the more specific . If this changes in the future the article can always be recreated Deletion of HD 269700 WP:GNG||WP:NASTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12805 5645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebel Pundit User:Mnnlaxer 15:48, 6 July 2015 (UTC) delete """fails : """"The content itself has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works"""". This criteria excludes trivial mention, such as the current sources""" Deletion of Rebel Pundit WP:WEBCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12806 10503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Y-Zet User:Miniapolis 23:08, 6 June 2019 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Y-Zet WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
12807 12095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liam Crowe User:JMHamo 13:12, 31 March 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Liam Crowe WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12808 9934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Red Queen Hypothesis - non-Darwinian view [[User Talk:JzG|Just zis Guy you know?]] 16:39, 6 April 2006 (UTC) delete this uncited |idiosyncratic |original research. Create a redirect if anyone thinks it's a likely search term (I don't). Article is an orphan. Aeropagitica, please clarify - when you say blank the text do you mean blank it and leave the history, or do you mean delete the history as well Deletion of Red Queen Hypothesis - non-Darwinian view WP:NPOV||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
12809 16553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teeboy Kamara User:Zanoni 08:26, 16 June 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Teeboy Kamara WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12810 17572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/118th Avenue massage parlour User:Mrschimpf 00:46, 11 July 2013 (UTC) delete """Slow news day local news hyped to the national news level solely because """"holy crap massage parlor they do 'things' in there"""". Didn't even get beyond the planning stages. So it was covered by national news sources; said national news sources seemed to only take it to either fill time or empty column space or get in some Edmonton coverage. """ Deletion of 118th Avenue massage parlour WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12811 9275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Italian supercentenarians User:Undead 02:23, 11 October 2008 (UTC) delete Contains giant amounts of |original research, fails and , and fails . A list about people who have lived to be a certain age is non notable and does not deserve a page on wikipedia Deletion of List of Italian supercentenarians WP:OR||WP:N||WP:RS||WP:LIST Wikipedia:No original research 65
12812 5581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gene Freidman User:World 03:02, 4 August 2017 (UTC) comment """I am amazed by the level of distortion and outright dishonesty I've seen in this discussion. There are a '''total''' of 48 edits to this article since it was created in 2015. That includes bot edits and edits since it was put up for deletion. Phrases like """"constantly pushed into being a SOAPBOX"""" and claims of violations based on false readings of the guideline make me question whether everyone here is acting in good faith, or simply arguing to justify a foregone conclusion, namely that since the article was created by an editor who was part of a paid editing sockfarm that it must be deleted regardless of the article itself""" Deletion of Gene Freidman WP:BLPCRIME Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12813 8165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WWE 2-21-11 User:ThePaintedOne 23:34, 7 February 2011 (UTC) delete unremarkable advert, only possible notability would be if the 'mystery person' turned out to be something truly spectacular, but right now that is and even if they were the required article wouldn't be about the promo but the event Deletion of WWE 2-21-11 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12814 201 [[Guter Bulle, böser Bulle]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Asthma NONE delete Ohne |Quellenangaben völlig unbrauchbares Brainstorming Löschung von Guter Bulle, böser Bulle Wikipedia:Quellenangaben Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12815 540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandra Appiah User:Knox490 03:49, 1 September 2019 (UTC) keep """I agree with User: RebeccaGreen who wrote: """"...added some more sources and information... There is enough coverage about her to meet ."""" In some cases it is better to upgrade and source an article rather than be quick to try to delete it. Many of the AfD nominations could be completely avoided if people did this. So much drama and unproductive work could be avoided if more editors were like User: RebeccaGreen. Also, User:Senegambianamestudy made a strong argument. Namely, User:Senegambianamestudy wrote: """" plenty of reliable sources that establishes notability https://www.blackenterprise.com/face2face-africa-young-innovators-publish-new-magazine/, https://thegrio.com/2013/01/24/young-africans-in-america-on-a-mission-to-rebrand-homeland/, https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:olfZN27k_KkJ:https://www.bet.com/news/lifestyle/2013/01/17/bet-com-chats-with-face-2-face-africa-magazine-creators.html+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=uk a catched copy of a 2013 interview by BET, http://madame.lefigaro.fr/societe/sandra-appiah-25-ans-entrepreneuse-060315-95141, and one of the https://www.ghanaweb.com/GhanaHomePage/business/12-Ghanaians-named-among-2019-100-Most-Influential-People-of-African-Descent-under-40-761618# Most Influential People of African Descent (MIPAD) as well as https://www.pulse.com.gh/news/business/ceo-of-afro-arab-group-ranked-among-50-young-ceos-in-ghana-2018/tx47y1j one of the top 50 CEOs in Ghana."""" After all is said and done there is sufficient depth and breadth of coverage to keep the article. Finally, doing business is very challenging in many parts of Africa due to excessive regulation and that it is a developing country.https://triblive.com/opinion/john-stossel-in-africa-bad-law-keeps-people-poor/ So why make it harder on her? I think it is great that she has an article and I find her work admirable. She could have done business in the USA easily, but she chose the tougher path. But I am sure it is very rewarding for her (I know a couple of people who have done business in Africa and it rewarding to make a poor country more prosperous""" Deletion of Sandra Appiah WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12816 13516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bromance (2nd nomination) User:Dialectric 14:35, 24 February 2015 (UTC) keep concept is clearly notable per per SilverserenC's references above; concept is clearly independent of ''friendship'' per academic literature mentioned by Fieari above. Multiple sources use the term as a central concept, not an incidental one. Article quality issues can be addressed by a rewrite Deletion of Bromance (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12817 8377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Huffines Middle School User:Jerry 22:12, 13 April 2007 (UTC) keep all schools are notable. is a ''proposed guideline'', not a policy, and seems not to apply to this discussion in any meaningful way Deletion of Huffines Middle School WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
12818 20614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Madaris User:Harlowraman 03:46, 17 August 2007 (UTC) delete clearly fails usic Deletion of Bob Madaris WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
12819 20959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abraham Jennison User:Gnangarra 09:44, 30 September 2010 (UTC) keep Theres the http://henrietta.liswa.wa.gov.au/search~S2?/aJennison/ajennison/1%2C2%2C2%2CB/frameset&FF=ajennison+abraham&1%2C1%2C/indexsort=- letter itself, and then theres http://members.iinet.net.au/~perthdps/convicts/conwad03.htm passengers list for the vessel while this is a reproduction obviously the originals are available on paper. another source ''Convicts in Western Australia, 1850-1887'' by Erickson & O'Mara UWA press 1994 isbn:0855642785. isnt applicable because isnt Jennison isnt notable for an event, he's a convict who's been documented in reliable sources Deletion of Abraham Jennison WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
12820 757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syria national football team results 2012 User:Sir 23:52, 30 October 2011 (UTC) delete per nom. This is a clear cut case of . No prejudice to recreation once there are some actual results Deletion of Syria national football team results 2012 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12821 10642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valentina Harizanov User:David 03:39, 14 July 2009 (UTC) comment Her name comes up #1, #3, #5, and #8 in http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22computable+structure+theory%22 a search for computable structure theory (and similarly for http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=%22computable+model+theory%22 computable model theory), so that's a good sign. Is it a sufficiently important area that one of its top researchers can inherit notability from it? I don't know. The same searches, by the way, show Julia F. Knight to be even more well cited in the same area, but our lack of an article on Knight should not be used against Harizanov: Knight clearly passes by virtue of her named chair at Notre Dame Deletion of Valentina Harizanov WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12822 15350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011 in kickboxing User:Papaursa 20:47, 18 February 2012 (UTC) comment All that I see is a list of results, thus failing . There's nothing that shows any of these events are notable Deletion of 2011 in kickboxing WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12823 20922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sludgecore User:Stormtracker94 12:35, 21 October 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Sludgecore WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12824 10108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roger Fuckebythenavele User:The 15:05, 30 March 2021 (UTC) keep Under section 2 of , I would argue the nature of the crime is sufficiently unusual enough and there has been sustained coverage of him beyond the casual mention in the court rolls Deletion of Roger Fuckebythenavele WP:PERP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12825 789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Onyx Moonshine User:Justlettersandnumbers 08:53, 17 May 2016 (UTC) delete """u|DGG}} makes an important point with """"the intent was promotional"""": this was created by a paid editor in order to publicise the company and/or product. It is thus an advertisement, and Wikipedia does not allow advertisements, of any kind, anywhere. That I've subsequently hacked at it to make it look a little more like an encyclopaedic article doesn't change that. Paid editing of articles is very strongly discouraged; in practice, about the only form of discouragement we have is to undo or delete those unwelcome edits. |Delete this, without prejudice to re-creation of a real Wikipedia article by a non-involved editor if the stuff turns out to be notable (which, personally, I doubt it will""" Deletion of Onyx Moonshine WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
12826 2938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jaye Mortualia User:Starblind 15:25, 29 February 2008 (UTC) delete per . All bands mentioned are redlinks, no reliable sources. http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Jaye+Mortualia%22&hl=en&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&hs=cmR&start=20&sa=N 17 Google hits, mostly Myspace and similar Deletion of Jaye Mortualia WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12827 14311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of movie theatres in Bahrain User:Edison 18:49, 26 April 2009 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not a directory Deletion of List of movie theatres in Bahrain WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12828 8161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wonderland (Sea of Treachery album) User:Joe 23:41, 28 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |album Deletion of Wonderland (Sea of Treachery album) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12829 5952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesse Imeson User:Bob 20:47, 16 May 2011 (UTC) delete WP:PERP and , we aren't a database of bog-standard criminals Deletion of Jesse Imeson WP:ONEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12830 20138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neocollyris oblita User:Chris857 18:04, 18 November 2020 (UTC) keep """per , """"All species that have a correct name (botany) or valid name (zoology) are inherently notable""" Deletion of Neocollyris oblita WP:SPECIESOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12831 15437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Veracity of statements by Donald Trump (3rd nomination) User:Nihlus 22:14, 28 May 2020 (UTC) keep This is easily notable and not an attack. If repeating your words back to you is considered an attack, then I think the issue is with what you are saying. Also, I find it odd that users are saying that how the media's reporting of the seemingly unlimited number of lies from the president is somehow Wikipedia's narrative. doesn't work in deletion discussions, and this isn't the place to address POV issues Deletion of Veracity of statements by Donald Trump (3rd nomination) WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12832 14983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/O meu marido esta a negar User:Cavarrone 09:25, 11 March 2012 (UTC) keep per above, lack of Deletion of O meu marido esta a negar WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
12833 18834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maxim Jakubowski User:Wm335td 20:22, 8 January 2020 (UTC) keep The subject meets criteria. His work is reviewed Deletion of Maxim Jakubowski WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12834 21829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Hoffer User:Chicken 21:39, 3 April 2010 (UTC) delete In addition to |conflict of interest concerns, the subject does not appear to be a very notable chess player. The subject may very well be a good player, but good and notable are different things Deletion of Michael Hoffer WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
12835 14692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Regional Masters in Human Rights and Democratisation User:1292simon 02:17, 15 December 2012 (UTC) delete Unnotable Deletion of Regional Masters in Human Rights and Democratisation WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
12836 6157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vulnerability equilibrium User:Joe 00:19, 20 November 2009 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Vulnerability equilibrium WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
12837 5110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Cawthorne Haines User:JhonsJoe 22:38, 3 September 2014 (UTC) keep He meets . also, the article (created by me) Steven Joel Sotloff was made before he was killed. David Haines is all over the news and is a hostage of ISIS. This is part of an ongoing situation, we should keep this by all costs. Like James Foley, and Steven Sotloff, people want to hear about this guy Deletion of David Cawthorne Haines WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
12838 13918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emmanuel Weyi (2nd nomination) User:Namiba 21:56, 30 October 2017 (UTC) keep I see evidence of passing Deletion of Emmanuel Weyi (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12839 7414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ron Greer (Wisconsin politician) User:Cullen328 07:40, 4 October 2013 (UTC) delete Fails to meet our |Notability guideline for politicians Deletion of Ron Greer (Wisconsin politician) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12840 12514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muzz (talent manager) User:AllyD 08:02, 29 February 2020 (UTC) delete """Aside from the brief mention in the 2003 Phoenix New Times article about The Format, there are a couple more mentions for the subject as """"Mike Jarmuz"""" but I am seeing |nothing specifically about the subject which could demonstrate attained notability, whether as a promoter, band manager or technician. Fails and """ Deletion of Muzz (talent manager) :WP:RS||:WP:MUSICBIO||:WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12841 11924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gameplay of The Sims 3 user:H3llkn0wz 07:11, 24 September 2011 (UTC) delete as trivia. If sources do exist, then the sourced material belongs in the parent article per unwarranted and . Subtopics like this are made when there is enough sourced material to cover, or it spans several games, like Gameplay of The Elder Scrolls series. — Deletion of Gameplay of The Sims 3 WP:OR||WP:SPLIT||WP:CSPLIT Wikipedia:No original research 65
12842 14000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kayla Martell (2nd nomination) User:Taketa 09:22, 6 January 2017 (UTC) keep , - Meets , and is not a single event subject, as shown by the sources provided by user GRuban in the last nomination. Johnpacklambert please do not nominate again unless there is new information Deletion of Kayla Martell (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12843 10063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sports Flashes User:HighKing 11:57, 7 August 2020 (UTC) delete I am unable to locate any |significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, references to date fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic therefore fails GNG/ Deletion of Sports Flashes WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12844 16719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Krovatin User:Guinnog 18:28, 4 August 2006 (UTC) delete strong possibility it breaches . Even if not, nn writer Deletion of Christopher Krovatin WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
12845 391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward L. Cochran User:Xxanthippe 22:42, 14 August 2013 (UTC) keep Passes rof#1 with a GS h-index of 18, plus political activities Deletion of Edward L. Cochran WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
12846 2852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jubilee Hospital Radio User:Anthony 01:29, 13 December 2006 (UTC) delete However worthy the project, it fails on . I do not see the attack claimed by the above editor Deletion of Jubilee Hospital Radio WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12847 19583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disha Ravi User:Srijanx22 22:12, 14 February 2021 (UTC) delete Per analysis of sources by Aman.kumar.goel. Lacks significant coverage in reliable sources apart from those who are talking about recent arrest. See Deletion of Disha Ravi WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12848 2777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Ogletree User:Pdcook 15:29, 14 January 2011 (UTC) delete Only one acting credit listed on IMDB, and it's a minor one. Lack of coverage in RS. The NYTimes link is just a profile, not a full article. Fails and Deletion of Jennifer Ogletree WP:ENT||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12849 3693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elise window seal User:B 04:38, 10 May 2008 (UTC) delete """Mr. Cut and Ms. Paste have visited a forum (see above), the text (and photo links, all broken) lifted and deposited here. If it weren't for the copyvio, I'd still urge a delete as |Wikipedia is not a """"how-to"""" guide""" Deletion of Elise window seal WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12850 17091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Universe of the Metroid series User:Stifle 16:48, 30 September 2007 (UTC) delete per Apostrophe and . Severely excessive for Wikipedia, which is an encyclopedia. Could be considered |fancruft Deletion of Universe of the Metroid series WP:IINFO||WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12851 16032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hypography User:Gary 16:51, 19 March 2008 (UTC) delete It is non-notable per Deletion of Hypography WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12852 9985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of albums containing a hidden track User:Ijanderson977 10:41, 12 May 2008 (UTC) keep Seems to be a good article and meets ist Deletion of List of albums containing a hidden track WP:L Wikipedia:Lists 97
12853 20408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paperwavium User:Quarl NONE delete as |hoax. &mdash Deletion of Paperwavium WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
12854 7488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devil's Weed User:SRX 20:22, 17 August 2008 (UTC) delete fails and per Annette's comment, couldn't say any better Deletion of Devil's Weed WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
12855 763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Droll humor User:Bearian 23:13, 5 April 2010 (UTC) merge or merge into Deadpan, per Deletion of Droll humor WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
12856 1388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rugby Challenge NONE 21:17, 18 November 2010 (UTC) comment Article still lacks |independent, reliable sources needed to establish notability. If they are added, consider my delete recommendation withdrawn. Chopper Dave, please |assume good faith in your edit summaries. Thank you Deletion of Rugby Challenge WP:RS||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12857 10011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Crabbe (2nd nomination) User:GPL93 14:50, 20 January 2019 (UTC) delete Sources are either primary or coverage. Best Deletion of Bruce Crabbe (2nd nomination) WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12858 19035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TradeSports User:Pan 15:52, 6 October 2006 (UTC) keep Passes following a Lexis-Nexis search. Examples of sources to come...Sources whose primary subject is Tradesports added to references section Deletion of TradeSports WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12859 8745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phyzix User:Narutolovehinata5 11:40, 12 April 2010 (UTC) delete nothing but MySpace, last.fm, no reliable sources and also fails Deletion of Phyzix WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
12860 21780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Purble Place User:Dream 15:59, 9 July 2013 (UTC) keep The guideline pages say there are occasional exceptions, as does . Just common sense. Hundreds of millions of people have this on their computer, unknown millions have tried it, and nothing gained by deleting the article Deletion of Purble Place WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
12861 17830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon Palfrey User:Bduke 00:41, 25 June 2007 (UTC) keep I have added some references. There are many reviews and descriptions of his books. Being a Rhodes Scholar is not in itself notable, but being a Fellow of an Oxford College could well be notable depending on what the Fellow has done. In this case I suggest his publications meet . It needs more work. If it is not deleted, it will be reasonably easy to add references to this article from other articles Deletion of Simon Palfrey WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12862 3064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dennis Herrick User:Jmertel23 17:20, 3 July 2018 (UTC) delete listed sources are either for his personal website, his publishers' websites, or to organizations' main pages, which don't include info about him. No Deletion of Dennis Herrick WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12863 7907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leosville User:Kinu 18:55, 11 April 2020 (UTC) delete per #A11 as clearly made up by the article's creator, who has been vandalizing other related articles with content related to this. Tagged as such Deletion of Leosville WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12864 7096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Festival-day User:Yoninah 16:38, 22 December 2015 (UTC) delete """per nom and per . Firstly, it is ridiculous to translate the term Yom Tov into English because no one uses the term """"Festival Day"""" – they all say """"Yom Tov"""" or """"Jewish holiday"""" (or """"Jewish festival""""). Secondly, all this information is already in the Jewish holiday article""" Deletion of Festival-day WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
12865 2748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albi Sulo User:Ultraexactzz 18:24, 15 April 2010 (UTC) delete for now. Per , I'd imagine that Albi Sulo has a bright future ahead of him, both in the Tennis world and otherwise. However, an article is premature. If he is participating in the Davis Cup (a fact that isn't yet indicated at the Davis Cup website), then there will be some mention of his performance in the international press - and that might be enough, if he does well. But right now, all that we have is the fact that Tenniseurope.org once included him in its player rankings (but does not at present, according to their http://www.tenniseurope.org website). That's not enough for an article. I appreciate that there isn't really much of an Albanian Tennis Federation (per the above), but local offline press (newspapers and such) would also help to establish that Mr. Sulo is |notable. Lacking sources, though, we must delete Deletion of Albi Sulo WP:AGF||WP:N Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
12866 4721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Downs (writer) User:DiamondRemley39 13:31, 1 January 2021 (UTC) keep as he sure meets . Just getting started with improvements--all of which have been available on the open internet so far. could have been stronger. Also: AfD is not cleanup Deletion of Greg Downs (writer) WP:NAUTHOR||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12867 4219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adhil Bakeer Markar User:EricSerge 17:40, 23 October 2016 (UTC) delete per nomination and Deletion of Adhil Bakeer Markar WP:ONEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12868 18722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Nuttall (2nd nomination) User:Colapeninsula 17:56, 14 November 2013 (UTC) delete It's suspicious taht the article doesn't mention claims Nuttall rigged an electionhttp://www.thebarrieexaminer.com/2010/12/15/john-spinks-report-regarding-alex-nuttall. However regardless of POV issues, he doesn't seem to meet . One of the article links (to cottagecountrynow.ca) doesn't work for me and the simcoe.com link is a brief mention, so we're limited to coverage in the Barrie Examiner, which is only a single source and hardly the ''New York Times''. Local councillors get routine coverage in local media; that doesn't make them notable Deletion of Alex Nuttall (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12869 14048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Golden Stars International User:Ironholds 13:23, 14 September 2009 (UTC) keep see ; almost ''all'' albums are notable enough for articles, and I've yet to see a convincing argument as to why this one isn't Deletion of Golden Stars International WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12870 6971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Werner User:Paulmcdonald 18:46, 17 October 2013 (UTC) keep not a lot of college players are given six seasons of eligibility due to injury. Looks like that's starting to pull some coverage and is enough to pass Deletion of Jason Werner WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12871 19408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mirza Džafić User:GiantSnowman 15:08, 8 May 2011 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Mirza Džafić WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12872 11644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gagan Sharma User:Pharaoh 21:29, 22 March 2019 (UTC) delete Fails and .Upcoming not notable at this point Deletion of Gagan Sharma WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12873 14985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Macklin Robinson User:Fenix 08:16, 30 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Macklin Robinson WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12874 6338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Army Fortresses in Japan proper User:Quasirandom 22:38, 15 April 2008 (UTC) keep and fix -- notify the relevant wikiprojects and they'll add 'em to their list of TBDs. It's a situtation, eh Deletion of List of Army Fortresses in Japan proper WP:SOFIXIT Wikipedia:Be bold 9
12875 525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/In-N-Out Burger menu items User:Absurdist 05:20, 23 July 2007 (UTC) delete A menu is like a #DIR|sales catalog, and the article reads like a #HOWTO|how-to guide for ordering burgers Deletion of In-N-Out Burger menu items WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12876 18061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IPlum User:Allthefoxes 04:58, 25 February 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of IPlum WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12877 10654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cliffjumper (other incarnations) [[User talk:70.80.234.196|talk]]) 21:32, 27 February 2011 (UTC) delete per . The various merger proposals in Transformers articles appear to not change over time because the handful of editors who edit/visit those pages are usually the fans who make them into these sprawling |fictional plot articles in the first place, and usually don't vote for merge. AfD's are the only way to attract attention of the larger Wikipedia editing population.--Special:Contributions/70.80.234.196|70.80.234.196 Deletion of Cliffjumper (other incarnations) WP:NFICT||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12878 9447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carishma User:QuiteUnusual 23:44, 28 December 2011 (UTC) delete Fails to meet and lacks any notability Deletion of Carishma WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12879 19642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delview Secondary School User:TerriersFan 18:13, 4 November 2008 (UTC) keep sufficient sources are available to meet . High school articles should be expanded and not deleted Deletion of Delview Secondary School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12880 9248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heaven's Army User:S 12:16, 24 March 2009 (UTC) merge and '''protect''' as unsourced and unsourceable from |reliable sources. Consider whether the MMORPG guild deserves a side-mention in Ragnarok Online Deletion of Heaven's Army WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12881 9475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cat Zingano User:LiberatorLX 12:48, 12 December 2013 (UTC) keep Passes , top fighter, was going to be TUF coach til she got injured Deletion of Cat Zingano WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12882 21206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Burrows User:Peter 16:51, 7 December 2020 (UTC) keep It's better to have a complete set of articles here for than maintain a complete set on another site and a separate incomplete set here. Subject-specific guidelines are more important than as a reason to delete an article, there's no reason to say they shouldn't be as a reason to keep an article Deletion of Jamie Burrows WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12883 3786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suzan Bushnaq User:RayAYang 15:39, 11 November 2010 (UTC) comment More important than diversity on Wikipedia is our ability, as a community, to |verify the significance and facts claimed in the article. If we can't get a sufficient number of Arabic-speaking editors to verify this article and the subject's notability, it should be deleted Deletion of Suzan Bushnaq WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12884 8764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Undergroundscene.co.uk User:Just 21:08, 6 December 2005 (UTC) delete per above with reference to Deletion of Undergroundscene.co.uk WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12885 8955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Big Five (late-night talk show franchises) User:Ylee 04:26, 17 September 2010 (UTC) delete """When, a while ago, I added discussion of the """"big five"""" talent agency|talent agencies to that article, I could easily find |reliable sources using the phrase. No such citability exists for this article""" Deletion of The Big Five (late-night talk show franchises) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12886 2277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malthusian Selection User:Kusma 15:02, 17 December 2005 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Malthusian Selection WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12887 6916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dream Pod 9 User:RightCowLeftCoast 01:31, 10 July 2019 (UTC) delete based on google searches the company does not appear to meet , and I am not finding any |significant coverage, to show that the subject meets . The subject isn't a White Wolf Publishing, or a TSR (company)|TSR, at least at this point. Perhaps it is Deletion of Dream Pod 9 WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:NCORP||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
12888 8607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Crowder (2nd nomination) User:SportingFlyer 22:28, 25 February 2019 (UTC) delete Per my comments in the deletion review thread, fails , Deletion of Tom Crowder (2nd nomination) WP:GRIDIRON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12889 16001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Famous armenian murderers released from imprisonment User:Hydrox 03:46, 27 September 2012 (UTC) delete """Inherently unencyclopedic due to a serious issue where the wiki-editor primarily decides which cases are """"famous"""". Looks like an article anyway due to use of sensational categories like """"terrorists"""" etc""" Deletion of Famous armenian murderers released from imprisonment WP:UNDUE||WP:ATTACK Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
12890 14033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alton Parkway User:Imzadi1979 13:22, 19 November 2019 (UTC) delete fails to meet Deletion of Alton Parkway WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12891 16265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boom Boom (Dareysteel song) User:CASSIOPEIA 08:55, 15 February 2019 (UTC) merge Article does not meet requirements Deletion of Boom Boom (Dareysteel song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12892 8128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elliott Killian User:onel5969 13:17, 1 December 2015 (UTC) delete Fails . Searches do not show they pass Deletion of Elliott Killian WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12893 13372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Still (3rd nomination) User:RightCowLeftCoast 01:15, 29 March 2013 (UTC) merge to United States third party and independent presidential candidates, 2012, per . Subject has received https://www.google.com/search?q=Bill+Still+2012+president&aq=f&oq=Bill+Still+2012+president&aqs=chrome.0.57j0.10201&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8#q=%22Bill+Still%22+2012+president+libertarian&hl=en&safe=off&source=lnms&sa=X&ei=JOpUUdrLLIaIiAKTkICoDQ&ved=0CAYQ_AUoAA&bav=on.2,or.r_qf.&bvm=bv.44442042,d.cGE&fp=2c77bef039babc35&biw=953&bih=650 some coverage, but none that I would be considered |significant coverage. As those mentions are about a notable event, it could be said that the subject may fall under . Per POLOUTCOME, a redirect should be left in the article space to the event which is the subject of the article United States third party and independent presidential candidates, 2012 Deletion of Bill Still (3rd nomination) WP:POLOUTCOMES||WP:SIGCOV||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12894 2720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of Mary Jane Watson User:TTN 14:56, 22 September 2020 (UTC) delete The topic fails and . It is not a proper content split, and the current content is not particularly worth merging Deletion of Alternative versions of Mary Jane Watson WP:GNG||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12895 1367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pro Wrestling Alliance Australia User:Music1201 20:34, 15 May 2016 (UTC) merge to Pro Wrestling Women's Alliance. This article was originally created as a redirect to Pro Wrestling Women's Alliance and was later created as an article, although, an independent article for this topic should not be included in an encyclopedia because it fails the |general notability guideline. &mdash Deletion of Pro Wrestling Alliance Australia WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12896 7363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Fraize User:David 20:48, 1 July 2009 (UTC) keep The sources seem to check out, he has a reasonable amount of attention from a major newspaper (the Washington Post), he has contributed to many albums at least one of which is from a bluelinked label, and he has toured internationally. A plausible case for criteria 1, 4, and 5 of Deletion of Peter Fraize WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12897 8096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christobelle Grierson-Ryrie User:XLerate 05:13, 7 June 2009 (UTC) keep the news coverage by stuff.co.nz and the New Zealand Herald satisfies , independent and more than trivial Deletion of Christobelle Grierson-Ryrie WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12898 14309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monash Residential Services (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 02:29, 12 July 2008 (UTC) merge per above - no |independent sources, no evidence of notability is even |likely Deletion of Monash Residential Services (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12899 6882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of kosher restaurants User:Alansohn 03:11, 2 May 2017 (UTC) keep This is exactly how lists work in Wikipedia. :Category:Lists of restaurants includes 94 different articles, including the directly overlapping article for Lists of restaurants, which includes lists that aren't in the category. This list under discussion is a well-defined, encyclopedic, properly sourced list of notable kosher restaurants that would benefit tremendously from expansion, not deletion. Per , the list and the corresponding category should co-exist and be used to expand each other synergistically. Once the literally thousands of kosher restaurants over the whole world, including a few thousand in Israel, all have Wikipedia articles and included on this list, we can consider splitting it up by country Deletion of List of kosher restaurants WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
12900 18324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cmed User:Aranda56 22:26, 25 December 2005 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Cmed WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12901 13038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mathematical methods User:Gamall 15:06, 1 April 2017 (UTC) delete way too vague to be really useful in any non-contrived scenario. That's what search functions are for; Deletion of Mathematical methods WP:PTM Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
12902 12435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmad Milad Karimi User:Ammarpad 10:45, 19 March 2018 (UTC) keep Meets , well sourced. Also this is vague nomination from an account whose only mainspace edit is one PROD of another good article and this misnomation Deletion of Ahmad Milad Karimi WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12903 19185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of German Americans User:Carlossuarez46 16:41, 28 August 2007 (UTC) delete """suffers from the same problems all these ethnic lists suffer from: how """"German"""" must one be to be on the list? What es tell us that the individual is at least that much German, and is being that much German any different from being just a little less German? Also, German is both an ethnicity and a nation, so German-Americans could include ethnic members who have never been to German, spoken German and have non-German names, and also people of non-German backgrounds who are from Germany and later became Americans. So ultimately not defining, POV, and largely OR. And why is WP in the business of categorizing people by race and ethnicity anyway""" Deletion of List of German Americans WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12904 4269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Japanese exonyms User:Finnusertop 21:49, 20 November 2016 (UTC) delete not enough RS to confirm that this meets /. Even if such sources are presented, this article is dubious in terms of . – Deletion of Japanese exonyms WP:GNG||WP:LISTN||WP:NOTDICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12905 18465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thakur Shivam Singh (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 18:29, 11 May 2020 (UTC) delete As always, holding a role in ''student'' government is not a notability claim, I'm still waiting for an answer as to why editors in India seem so much more uniquely convinced that it would be than editors anywhere else on earth are, and the article is not |reliably sourced even close to well enough to make him more special than everybody else in student government Deletion of Thakur Shivam Singh (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12906 17982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Presidency (theology) User:Bearian 16:25, 1 November 2010 (UTC) delete this is ''not'' the theology of ''any'' Apostle's Creed|credal Christian church, and the two examples cited are not notable. Unless someone can source this |unsourced stub, it smells of something made up by a |fringe denomination in one day Deletion of Presidency (theology) WP:RS||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12907 2416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zones of EverQuest User:Edward321 06:09, 10 November 2007 (UTC) keep Nominator appears to have a serious agenda since they talk of nominating over 100 articles for deletion, which will overwhelm the system. Reasons given by nominator |unsourced, |original research, and |fancruft are grounds for improvement, not deletion, and by nominator's own admission may not be relevant to this article. Nominator claims |unnotable and yet provides no indication of what notability criteria they think this article fails. Most importantly claim by nominator that topic is non-notable because non-fans would not read it shows a lack of understanding of notability. I am not a fan of hip-hop or opera - but the 'fact' that only fans would read those articles does not mean those articles are non-notable Deletion of Zones of EverQuest WP:SOURCE||WP:OR||WP:CRUFT||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12908 21346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Friendly Adult Presence User:ItsZippy 16:41, 23 October 2011 (UTC) delete I've had a brief look for sources and most are unreliable - the majority being websites for Quaker groups. To be deemed notable, I think there really needs to be use of the term outside the Quaker community. For that reason, I would propose deletion of the article as a non-notable |neologism Deletion of Friendly Adult Presence WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
12909 16295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fastest production cars by acceleration User:Sailing 10:18, 30 July 2011 (UTC) keep I do not find that claim that the article is convincing. sources are allowed if used carefully and the article contains sources as well. Having dismissed the claim, I see no other #REASON in the arguments presented above. This fD seems to be motived by an editing war. This is concerning, especially in light of the fact that no effort has been make on the talk page of this article to resolve the disputes in question Deletion of List of fastest production cars by acceleration WP:OR||WP:PRIMARY||WP:SECONDARY||WP:OR||WP:DEL||WP:A Wikipedia:No original research 65
12910 654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muaad Mohamed Aboud User:Angelo 12:33, 13 August 2009 (UTC) delete fails and . All other claims and opinions are not supported by notability guidelines Deletion of Muaad Mohamed Aboud WP:N||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
12911 10559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Videojuicer User:Michaelzeng7 01:01, 5 June 2013 (UTC) comment I am surprised at the total lack of participation for 4 straight weeks in this AfD. Perhaps would apply here Deletion of Videojuicer WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
12912 11807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Male menstruation User:Lord 07:39, 5 June 2021 (UTC) keep """The article needs to be heavily re-worked, but there is enough coverage of this concept to warrant keeping a standalone article. As noted above, there are plenty of academic sources about the myth of male menstruation in ancient Judaism. I found an additional article about the concept of male menstruation in the work of Sigmund Freud.{{cite journal |last=Gilman |first=Sander L. |title=The Struggle of Psychiatry with Psychoanalysis: Who Won? |journal=Critical Inquiry |date=Winter 1987 |volume=13 |issue=2 |page=302 |jstor=1343494 |quote=The central sign of male periodicity for Fliess (and for Freud) is male menstruation. And its representation, according to Freud in his letter of 20 July 1897 to Fliess, is an 'occasional bloody nasal secretion' (''FF'', p. 256).}} I also found an article about """"male rituals of pseudo-procreation"""" among Aboriginal Australians that entail """"the men 'menstruating' by making their noses bleed, cutting their arms, subincising their penises, inducing diarrhoea (as a substitute for menstrual blood) or in other ways"""".{{cite journal |last=Knight |first=Chris |title=Levi-Strauss and the Dragon: ''Mythologiques'' Reconsidered in the Light of an Australian Aboriginal Myth |journal=Man (journal)|Man |date=March 1983 |volume=18 |issue=1 |pages=21–50 |jstor=2801763}} This seems to be a specific case study about the general anthropological concept of male menstruation that is described in two of the sources found by {{u|Qwaiiplayer}} (https://www.pep-web.org/document.php?id=ijp.058.0017ahttps://www.proquest.com/openview/2ebcdd59df3c92570baa8400e18028b4/1?pq-origsite=gscholar&cbl=1816657). Although it would be quite difficult to write an encyclopedic article that cohesively ties all of these angles together, fD is not cleanup|that alone is not a reason to delete""" Deletion of Male menstruation WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
12913 8834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monique Fuentes User:Epbr123 12:43, 22 August 2008 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet Deletion of Monique Fuentes WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12914 16879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stump (game) (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 09:30, 30 March 2016 (UTC) merge to List of drinking games, to enhance the article per Deletion of Stump (game) (2nd nomination) WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
12915 3618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luther Jackson Middle School User:TerriersFan 05:00, 10 December 2007 (UTC) keep """this is an important school historically. For example """"opened its doors in 1954 as Fairfax County's sole high school for black students"""" from http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-218775.html here. Plenty of sources to meet , see also http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-163432081.html, http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-2786572.html, http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-1409991.html, http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-2786420.html, http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-210820.html, and so on""" Deletion of Luther Jackson Middle School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12916 18463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jenova Reunion User:KarasuGamma 09:10, 14 April 2020 (UTC) delete per . — Deletion of Jenova Reunion WP:A9 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12917 11893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/6G telecommunication networks User:Serial 07:53, 24 April 2019 (UTC) delete per ; and, {{u|Eastmain}}...I hope that's a joke Deletion of 6G telecommunication networks WP:NOTCRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12918 2788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Woodburn User:Fenix 08:02, 21 July 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Ben Woodburn WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12919 21048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Filling Station In Ghana User:Ajf773 08:13, 15 July 2021 (UTC) delete Not much at all to this article except Deletion of List of Filling Station In Ghana WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12920 19558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Future World Music (2nd nomination) User:HighKing 17:58, 2 June 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and GNG. Completely unreferenced article. Wikipedia is |not a marketing platform Deletion of Future World Music (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12921 5432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ronald Presley User:AlwaysOnion 08:31, 16 October 2008 (UTC) delete Non-notable, and | Wikipedia is not myspace, facebook, a fan gathering site, webhost Deletion of Ronald Presley WP:MUSIC||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12922 2228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Loverterian's Decree User:Cullen328 05:29, 31 August 2011 (UTC) delete """We could make it a contest, and see how many legitimate reasons to delete this """"article"""" can be advanced before someone closes this debate. One per customer, please. I will take |no original research""" Deletion of The Loverterian's Decree WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
12923 1556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bean Ball Benny User:Videogameplayer99 05:28, 5 November 2017 (UTC) delete As the article stands now, and per nom, it fails Deletion of Bean Ball Benny WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12924 4440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Books associated with Oxford User:Becksguy 09:09, 16 August 2007 (UTC) keep as per Jonathan Bowen and . Develop as per Bduke above. If Oxford University Press|OUP isn't the single most important English language university press in the world, especially in the scholarly field, it's damn close to it. It's aura practically confers notability on anything associated with it, including this article. And it isn't just OUP, it's the literary associations of the town. Also, it's not about the completeness of the list, that's not a reason to delete. After all, Wikipedia isn't complete. I just don't see this as tenuous or indiscriminate, they are tied together because of their association with Oxford. The article does need more work, but compare it now from when it was started Deletion of Books associated with Oxford WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
12925 16927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pets Keeping in Tanzania User:DrStrauss 15:24, 31 August 2017 (UTC) delete while pet-keeping is obviously notable, as is Tanzania, put them together and you don't have a topic |notable enough for its own page. A sub-section in Pet is, at the very most, all this article deserves. The article is also written |like an essay and appears to contain |original research Deletion of Pets Keeping in Tanzania WP:NOPAGE||WP:NOTESSAY||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12926 6138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paternity (House) User:Hearfourmewesique 19:50, 10 March 2011 (UTC) keep """If the nominating editor and anyone else thinks that the individual episode articles fail , then – pardon my French – get off your asses and do some actual work because I'm positive many of those articles can have at least a """"review"""" section added to them, with at least a couple of . """"Scrubbing"""" is always the easy way out""" Deletion of Paternity (House) WP:NOTABILITY||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
12927 16975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of minor Star Wars Jedi knights User:Disavian 05:09, 6 November 2007 (UTC) comment By your rationale, should all of the lists in :Category:Lists of Star Wars characters be nominated for deletion under Deletion of List of minor Star Wars Jedi knights WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12928 6802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fey (Dungeons & Dragons) (2nd nomination) User:Sgeureka 07:59, 23 December 2019 (UTC) delete Not even deemed notable enough to be mentioned in Monsters in Dungeons & Dragons. Listing all Fey submonsters appears to fail . &ndash Deletion of Fey (Dungeons & Dragons) (2nd nomination) WP:GAMEGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12929 9523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Besse (2nd nomination) User:David 06:03, 11 September 2018 (UTC) delete I came here via the academic deletion sorting list and while the article mentions some academic affiliations there is nothing there that looks likely to lead to notability. Certainly there is no documented notability in that direction and Google Scholar doesn't show any legal publications by anyone with a similar name and with enough citations to make a case for #C1. So it seems that all we have to go on is the obvious: a city council member running for higher office, clearly not enough for Deletion of Dan Besse (2nd nomination) WP:PROF||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12930 8357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alesso User:Dominus 15:12, 7 August 2011 (UTC) delete Clearly soes not meet the criteria for inclusion under Deletion of Alesso WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12931 3014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matty Wilkinson User:Number 22:21, 26 February 2017 (UTC) delete """per the failure. Playing for a """"professional team"""" isn't relevant here""" Deletion of Matty Wilkinson WP:RLN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12932 17857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Down Under the Big Top User:Paviliolive 23:14, 4 February 2014 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Down Under the Big Top WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12933 5894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional characters by IQ User:Bearian 15:55, 9 April 2008 (UTC) keep such a specific list is allowed by . Every entry has a citation, which is |verifiable, although they could be |better. Yes, the test for speedy deletion is fairly lax, but |the main articles for deletion page explicitly lists the |reasons for deletion. Each of the characters are |major ''persona'' in |fictional works. I can't see any reasons to delete, and to keep is the default setting. I have a lax reason to keep: a high school student may find the list useful for research Deletion of List of fictional characters by IQ WP:LIST||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:AFD||WP:DELETE||WP:N||WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Lists 97
12934 20711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natalie Khawam User:Unscintillating 23:47, 25 November 2012 (UTC) keep nbsp; Deletion nominations should take care to protect the material in our encyclopedia, as we are here to build an encyclopedia. One way they can do this is by analyzing the |WP:Alternatives to deletion. The current nomination argument shows no content deriving from WP:BEFORE. Nor does it expand on the basic theory of how Wikipedia deals with the combination of a non-notable topic and reliable material about that non-notable topic. This deficiency is so great in this case that because of the alternatives to deletion that are available, there is no deletion to discuss here, either of the redirect or the edit history. Any close here other then keep or speedy keep will encourage more defective nominations and more wasted time by AfD volunteers. Deletion of Natalie Khawam WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12935 2515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manuel Rivera Jr. User:The 18:10, 11 January 2021 (UTC) merge to List of Puerto Rican military personnel, where he is mentioned. His service is appreciated, but |Wikipedia is not a memorial, and I don't see , , or being met here Deletion of Manuel Rivera Jr. WP:NOTMEMORIAL||WP:GNG||WP:NPERSON||WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12936 15817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/We Are The Ocean User:Ijanderson977 17:18, 30 April 2008 (UTC) keep """Seems notable to me. I think it fairly to say that the band is unknown. usic says """"Notability is met if the musician has been the subject of a broadcast by a media network."""" I think been on several radio stations and magazines is classed as """"subject of a broadcast by a media network"""" therefore is Notable according to wikipedia""" Deletion of We Are The Ocean WP:POV||WP:M Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
12937 1309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gloria Campaner User:RebeccaGreen 14:40, 4 November 2018 (UTC) keep The article states that she has won prizes at major international competitions, and Criterion 9 of is: Has won first, second or third place in a major music competition. So she does meet . Sources can be found online - eg re the Paderewski Competition this http://ijpaderewski.org/wpd/author/ignacy/ or this https://www.poloniasf.org/english/images/nop201006s4.pdf, her profile on the Borletti-Buitoni Trust, from which she won a £20,000 fellowship in 2014 https://www.bbtrust.com/2014/fellowships/gloria_campaner_1.html?view=biography, possibly this interview in Avvenire https://www.avvenire.it/agora/pagine/gloria-campaner-pianista (I don't know what constitutes reliable sources in Italy) - and there are other articles, like this one about her becoming artistic director of a musical association https://www.tempostretto.it/news/musica-gloria-campaner-nuovo-direttore-artistico-associazione-bellini.html, and I'm sure it would be possible to find reviews of performances, particularly searching in Italian, Greek, etc Deletion of Gloria Campaner WP:MUSICBIO||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
12938 1939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sonic Next Gen Series User:Plm209 17:03, 23 January 2008 (UTC) delete Simply a list of links to sonic characters with their own articles. Falls under Deletion of Sonic Next Gen Series WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
12939 132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Political activities of the Koch family User:Collect 23:34, 2 February 2011 (UTC) delete Not only SYNTH, but also a clear POVfork, since the material which is reasonable for individual articles is already in those articles, and this is a home for material which was barred from the other articles by WP policies and consensus. Jane Mayer's opinion piece is now covered in about ten articles - there is absolutely no need for this article on WP. Also note that charges of criminal activity can not be sourced to an opinion piece per . The only proper cource is therefore deletion and salting of this article Deletion of Political activities of the Koch family WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12940 13089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mason Barbera User:Papaursa 17:54, 1 February 2018 (UTC) delete I don't believe the coverage I can find is sufficient to meet because I don't see significant independent non-routine coverage from multiple sources. I also don't believe that driving in the Dunlop Super2 Series meets Deletion of Mason Barbera WP:GNG||WP:NMOTORSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12941 8539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Piotr Lato User:Reyk 22:44, 8 November 2008 (UTC) delete game show contestants are generally not notable, even if they have been on two game shows. A quick Google search yields a lot of facebooky and myspacey links, but nothing that would satisfy the reliable secondary source criterion at . The mob from the Polish Wikipedia got this one right Deletion of Piotr Lato WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12942 13870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Skinner (surgeon) User:Mztourist 04:00, 14 January 2021 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Alexander Skinner (surgeon) WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12943 16813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Woodhall Spa Cottage Museum NONE NONE comment would be a vote, but there is no point here to vote further) {{u|onel5969}}, While in any other case this should have been closed as a clear keep consensus, the discussion of it is really, really, REALLY poor, consisting of , saying but not showing which books does it have significant coverage in (per ), per XYZ person....jeez. In any case, this will surely not be deleted and would at best be closed as no consensus for another discussion, but I wanted to discuss the sources by an analysis Deletion of Woodhall Spa Cottage Museum WP:ILIKEIT||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12944 9448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Open smart grid protocol User:QbeTrue 16:15, 15 September 2012 (UTC) delete and then merge smart grid, per . LonWorks == OSGP == ESNA == Echelon. There are three smart grid standards at this moment: 1 SGIP-NIST, USA started in 2009 by Obama. Is a truelly open standard activity backed by nearly 800 companies. 2 SG-SC formed by the SG-TFhttp://ec.europa.eu/energy/gas_electricity/smartgrids/taskforce_en.htm by command of the European Union, is backed by severel hunderes of companies. 3 OSGP backed by ESNA an organisation started by Echelon and backed by 8 others including universities. Is a completely private initiative not backed by countries. The number of installed devices mentioned in many publications are all installed in Italy, Italy was the first country that between 1998 and 2005 switched to remote metering because of the fraud that took place. Since LonWorks was not accepted by the European commision as being the future network for Smart Grid a new organisation was started (ESNA) to support the marketing of LonWorks at that time already renamed into OSGP a name that is very similar to SGIP. Its better to start ONE smart grid article that will include all forms of smart grid that are in development. I am a participating member of the SGIP-NIST working group and a member of the SG-SC in Europe. My company tried to become a member of ESNA but this was refused since our business is closely related to Echelon's. For people that do not believe me simply do a WHOIS on www.esna.org and look who is the person who registrated the name in 2005, next check who is in the board of directors of ESNA the Echelon boss ?. Uhmm the same name Deletion of Open smart grid protocol WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12945 21352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lanka Silat User:Edison 17:34, 16 February 2011 (UTC) delete No references were provided in the article. The search tool above shows some coverage (extent unknown) in one book and nothing in the news archives. Since it was created almost four years ago as the only edit of User:Lankasilat, there have been no additions to the text except for tagging and minor housekeeping Wikignome edits by others. There seems to be no likelihood of making it more encyclopedic. Fails |notability, questionable on |verifiability, seems to be |original research Deletion of Lanka Silat WP:N||WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12946 441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PSKT Kemutar Telu West Sumbawa (2nd nomination) User:21 22:26, 9 December 2018 (UTC) keep as per previous comments and the previous AFD, meets Deletion of PSKT Kemutar Telu West Sumbawa (2nd nomination) WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
12947 11534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NexusBPM User:AllyD 10:47, 15 February 2014 (UTC) delete No |evidence that this jBPM extension achieved |notability. (Also lacks updates in the past 5 years Deletion of NexusBPM :WP:RS||:WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12948 2419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corinne Narassiguin User:Northamerica1000 11:06, 15 May 2012 (UTC) keep The topic appears to pass . (Multiple sources/articles can be used to establish topic notability Deletion of Corinne Narassiguin WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12949 17056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gérard Rozenknop User:Northamerica1000 11:06, 8 June 2012 (UTC) keep This person passes criteria #6 of , as a former director-general of the École nationale de l'aviation civile (French civil aviation university Deletion of Gérard Rozenknop WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
12950 21886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zelda Universe User:Wrathchild 17:22, 27 February 2006 (UTC) comment Name conflicts with an official site is not a criteria for listing. Let the lawyers sort that out. However, with an Alexa rank of 72,971 I don't know if it meets . &mdash Deletion of Zelda Universe WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12951 18421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Latino Women and their Migrations to America User:PennySpender1983 19:10, 23 November 2015 (UTC) keep for several reasons ... ((1)) after a review of available sources and coverage, I consider the subject to be notable (to me, does not apply): (a) here is a https://www.dukeupress.edu/Women-and-Migration-in-the-US-Mexico-Borderlands/ book published by Duke University (b) here is a http://www.un.org/esa/population/meetings/ittmigdev2005/P14_JMartinez_ECLAC.pdf United Nations publication that has a lot of detail on immigration of Latino women vs men, (c) here is an http://www.ipsnews.net/2006/03/migration-latin-america-many-women-seek-new-life-across-borders/ article specifically on the subject of migration of Latino women; ((2)) based on the availability of sources mentioned, the article can develop such that it will not read as original research (yes, there are ''possible'' reliable sources, so to me, does not apply). The nomination reason is ''unsourced'', but this is not one of the -REASON|fourteen reasons for deletion. Instead the deletion policy (reason #6) focuses on the ''impossibility'' of reliable sources for attribution; ((3)) this subject may seem obscure to most editors/contributors, but let's remember and realize that there is room in WP for articles that are tightly focused, they simply must be notable, as I consider this subject to be after my review of this nomination Deletion of Latino Women and their Migrations to America WP:DEL8||WP:DEL6||WP:DEL||WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12952 9992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I'm Not Sorry.net User:Severa 12:59, 16 October 2007 (UTC) keep I believe that notability has been established per , as the site has been covered in magazines like ''Salon.com|Salon'', ''World (magazine)|World'', and ''The Nation''. It was also mentioned by the writer Judith Warner in an entry on her ''New York Times''-hosted blog. I have attempted to improve the organization of the article by creating thematic sections and have also added more content Deletion of I'm Not Sorry.net WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12953 1506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nova Scotia Paramedic Society User:PKT 16:26, 18 June 2013 (UTC) delete fails and . Not notable Deletion of Nova Scotia Paramedic Society WP:GROUP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12954 1559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OSIP User:GoldenRing 13:24, 28 April 2014 (UTC) delete I'm not convinced that the sources cited amount to significant discussion in secondary literature. And if the wikipage contains information useful to software developers, well, Deletion of OSIP WP:NOTMANUAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12955 14803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jayda Fransen User:Bearcat 13:59, 29 October 2016 (UTC) delete """Being deputy leader of a small fringe political party is not, in and of itself, a free pass that ''exempts'' a person from having to clear on the ''sourcing'' — but ''none'' of the sourcing here gets her over GNG at all. What we have here for """"referencing"""" is |primary sources and blog entries, not real coverage in real media — but real coverage in real media is what you need to actually get someone over the Wikipedia inclusion bar""" Deletion of Jayda Fransen WP:NPOL||WP:GNG||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES Wikipedia:Notability 77
12956 6114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald R. Mitchell User:Arkyan 15:57, 20 July 2007 (UTC) keep easily passes the criteria listed in . The timing and substance of this nomination does cast a pretty heavy shadow of and should likely be closed as soon as possible Deletion of Donald R. Mitchell WP:BIO||WP:POINT Wikipedia:Notability 77
12957 19869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Horace B. Griffen User:CNMall41 17:45, 31 August 2021 (UTC) keep A focus on narrow topical guidelines misses the mark. Multiple news sources that discuss the person in depth meets Deletion of Horace B. Griffen WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12958 19425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin L. Walker (2nd nomination) User:Duffbeerforme 07:27, 26 September 2016 (UTC) delete Blatant over the top |promotion Deletion of Kevin L. Walker (2nd nomination) WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
12959 9293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laredo, Texas UFO crash User:QTxVi4bEMRbrNqOorWBV 23:44, 10 June 2014 (UTC) delete No sources appear to be forthcoming for this particular subject Deletion of Laredo, Texas UFO crash WP:FRIND Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
12960 159 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ab-ı Hayat (gazete) Kullanıcı:seksen iki yüz kırk beşseksen iki yüz kırk beş / ggt 22.41, 30 Ocak 2021 (UTC) keep Maddeye birkaç kaynak daha ekledim. Öyle ya da böyle, haberleri dolayısıyla farklı zamanlarda bağımsız kaynaklara konu olmuş bir gazete. Bu nedenle de genel kriterini karşılıyor. Faaliyette bulunduğu dönem dolayısıyla muhtemelen daha fazla kaynağa çevrimdışı olarak da erişilebilecektir Ab-ı Hayat (gazete) silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
12961 4651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Granny women User:SheepNotGoats 17:24, 17 December 2008 (UTC) keep The article needs some work, but it appears to be a legitimate historical term that appears in many |reliable sources (http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rlz=1C1GGLS_en-USUS299US303&q=%22granny+women%22+appalachia&btnG=Search Google results minus all the porn). (Also, it would help if the nom's deletion rationale were more specific Deletion of Granny women WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12962 14960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Will Keane User:Argyle 16:07, 26 May 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Will Keane WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12963 3689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bundeloafe II: The Return of Jaffar (film) User:Eternal 03:38, 25 August 2020 (UTC) delete Fails both AND Deletion of Bundeloafe II: The Return of Jaffar (film) WP:NFILM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12964 21196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Celine Dion awards and accomplishments User:AQu01rius 23:34, 13 April 2007 (UTC) delete Subject may be notable due to Celine Dion's wide influence, but I think having a huge list like this for one singer is potentially . Notable information is already covered in Celine Dion anyways, which is a featured article. AQu01rius Deletion of Celine Dion awards and accomplishments WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
12965 8990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quick-Garden User:HighKing 13:59, 11 February 2018 (UTC) delete A run-of-the-mill business with no indications of notability, references are either passing mentions (or http://growingfamily.co.uk/garden-design/5-tips-creating-perfect-garden-room/ don't reference the company at all), or rely on quotations from the company. References fail and/or , topic fails GNG and Deletion of Quick-Garden WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGING||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12966 764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terhi Holster User:Cordless 10:45, 19 August 2019 (UTC) comment The search links above do not return many results for the purposes of , although the article mentions achievements from the mid-1990s, which might only have been reported on in print. We don't have a specific guideline for ski-orienteerers, but there is Wikipedia:Notability (sports)#Orienteering Deletion of Terhi Holster WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12967 11677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Budapest International Documentary Festival User:The 17:25, 29 December 2018 (UTC) delete for failing . As Deletion of Budapest International Documentary Festival WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
12968 18084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Assignment (unreleased film) User:Mkdw 06:05, 28 December 2012 (UTC) delete This film does not have the coverage to meet or Deletion of The Assignment (unreleased film) WP:NFILM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12969 6737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 Florida State Mall shooting user:Crow 23:31, 17 January 2015 (UTC) comment Note also Elizabeth Trickle and Donna Evans, witnesses to the event and likely violations. Currently re-directed to this article Deletion of 2015 Florida State Mall shooting WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12970 775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Case study in psychology User:Beccaynr 03:33, 12 February 2021 (UTC) keep """Case studies in psychology are distinct from medical case reports, just based on the descriptions in each article, and the case report article mentions how they are typically not case studies, so a merger does not seem logical from a navigational standpoint. Also, the Case study article does not seem to be written in a way that easily lends itself to incorporating the contents of this article into it, and it might introduce confusion about the topic if it was merged at this time - the case study article is currently tagged with 'expert needed,' and the note """"Case studies have numerous definitions in different fields and are intertwined with similar concepts in those fields"""" and a quick review of the sources seems to suggest why - there are sources from a variety of disciplines combined together, including business, political science, and social sciences generally, without this being made clear in the article. At some point in the future, if there is a reorganization and rewrite of the case study article, a merge might make sense to consider. I empathize with the instinct of the nom, but I think it is premature to consider a merge before a major revision or of the case study article""" Deletion of Case study in psychology WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
12971 17352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Cat User:Sgeureka 08:44, 14 May 2010 (UTC) delete the recurring characters, '''neutral''' on Jerry and Tom because there may be enough notability independent on the current state of their articles. The articles on the recurring characters consist mostly of either unsourced material or |original research, and the long Appearances sections are just and shouldn't be there anyway. There already is adequate coverage in Tom_and_Jerry_(MGM)#Characters for them, but I wouldn't mind a spinout List of Tom and Jerry characters. &ndash Deletion of Tom Cat WP:OR||WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:No original research 65
12972 7918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SimpliVity User:Jbhunley 14:52, 19 October 2016 (UTC) delete fails . No indication the company is notable for anything other than getting funding. At best at worst SEO/PROMO Deletion of SimpliVity WP:ORGDEPTH||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
12973 15772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beaver contest User:Rafaelgriffin 16:57, 17 January 2014 (UTC) delete Like said above fails Deletion of Beaver contest WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12974 15218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hyper Crush [[User talk:Ceyockey|talk to me]]'') 11:26, 28 August 2008 (UTC) keep """The """"press statement"""" addition would not be considered a reliable source, but sufficient for . The """"wiki-page"""" addition is a dated news article with a real-name by-line, which would count as a reliable source; it is not subject to editing by passers-by but is subject to appending of comments. --User:Ceyockey""" Deletion of Hyper Crush WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12975 11028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The house at riverton User:Edtropolis 19:37, 21 June 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails criteria in Deletion of The house at riverton WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
12976 13805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BuzzerBeater User:Someone 22:38, 29 July 2008 (UTC) delete A search for the developer and game name brings up 38 results - http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&safe=off&client=firefox-a&rls=com.google%3Aen-GB%3Aofficial&hs=Qtx&q=%22Digital+Field+Theory%22+%2B+BuzzerBeater+&btnG=Search&meta= oh dear. Don't confuse it with the basketball manga Buzzer Beater with your searches (presumably this is where it got its name). It's either PRs, the game itself or WP and its mirrors, doesn't establish any |notability at all Deletion of BuzzerBeater WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
12977 14223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cain and Abel (film) User:Johnuniq 03:10, 23 December 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Cain and Abel (film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
12978 4065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HypnosNLP User:Trialsanderrors 21:54, 25 June 2006 (UTC) comment nice but where is the |outside verification? Fails Deletion of HypnosNLP WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12979 21082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stupid.com (second nomination) User:Bucketsofg 00:13, 10 March 2007 (UTC) delete as failing Deletion of Stupid.com (second nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
12980 6065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Handley User:Eggishorn 05:01, 4 May 2018 (UTC) delete Qualifies for and nothing is gained by preserving Deletion of Craig Handley WP:BLPREQUESTDELETE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
12981 11237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SFIMA User:Ipatrol 22:34, 3 April 2009 (UTC) delete File:Symbol speedy vote.svg|20px As per |G11 Deletion of SFIMA WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
12982 21227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Bamford (stunt coordinator) User:Papaursa 18:18, 4 June 2014 (UTC) delete I don't see the significant independent coverage in reliable sources that's required to meet . I also don't see that he meets Deletion of James Bamford (stunt coordinator) WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12983 8839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emobetting User:Accounting4Taste 17:07, 18 May 2008 (UTC) delete Zero google hits, apparently an idiosyncratic protologism with no |references Deletion of Emobetting WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12984 5612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seb Buddle User:Fenix 07:35, 1 August 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Seb Buddle WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
12985 11274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gabriel Vasconcellos Ferreira User:Mattythewhite 22:43, 23 May 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Gabriel Vasconcellos Ferreira WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
12986 4842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dark and Shattered Lands User:PresN 14:32, 4 August 2006 (UTC) delete Non-notable, fails . 125 users at a time isn't big enough to be notable Deletion of Dark and Shattered Lands WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12987 10382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RiverVoyages.com User:AllyD 14:28, 22 May 2020 (UTC) delete """Staying with the notability aspect of the original nomination, the nearest to a claim in the article text is the assertion (from the firm's website) that this was """"one of the first travel agents to specialise in river cruises"""". That claim has a lot of elasticity, which is probably needed given that people have been going on river cruises long before the 9 years lifespan of this firm. Even if supported by |references, I don't see that as a strong claim anyway. My searches are not finding better than routine coverage of this and World Travel Holdings' other brands. Fails """ Deletion of RiverVoyages.com :WP:RS||:WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12988 4947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hungarian Spectrum User:D 16:53, 7 April 2020 (UTC) keep """This AfD has been open by a IP who tries clearly to delete this article for pure political reasons. The content of the article satisfies all Wikipedia policies, including . The only thing that deserves a discussion here is whether the blog satisfies the notability guidelines, and specially whether it has an international coverage. The fact that the blog is archived by Library of Congress (reference 4) is a first positive indication. A Google search on """"Hungarian spectum"""" provides almost 600 hits, and the entries of the first page of results include medias of France (La Croix), Belgium (RTBF), Italy, Brazil (Zero Hora) and Romania. So, it is clear that this Hungarian blog has a significant international coverage""" Deletion of Hungarian Spectrum WP:SPA||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
12989 12136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Retina display User:Roodog2k 18:48, 15 June 2012 (UTC) keep There is no valid claim against guidelines made by the nom for deletion of this article. Classic example of Deletion of Retina display WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
12990 7023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gretchen (band) User:Cyrus 12:35, 18 May 2007 (UTC) keep Simply because this nomination was not carried out in the manner that it should be. There is no reason given for deletion other than listing a policy. Perhaps some input from the nominator on ''how'' this article fails would have persuaded me otherwise. I'm not going to delete simply because an editor mentioned a policy. If you're going to nominate an article, provide a valid reason for doing so Deletion of Gretchen (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
12991 3238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/System wars User:Capitalistroadster 16:48, 9 December 2005 (UTC) delete as another piece of Internet forum navelgazing with no reference to Deletion of System wars WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12992 2626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sissy nation User:DeadlyAssassin 09:34, 11 February 2008 (UTC) delete or at the very least a complete overhall to focus on the book as long as notability can be established. I concur that the content appears to be nothing more than an ad for the book and it's author at the moment. There does not appear to be , certainly no references to trusted sources - it is perhaps telling that the top returned links on Google are the books' own website. Fails the standards in Deletion of Sissy nation WP:V||WP:NB Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
12993 6481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Team Dixie User:Lowercaserho 10:32, 28 February 2019 (UTC) merge to Dixie Carter (wrestling)#Dixieland (2013–2014), as -R. I'm not sure if there's anything there that's worth merging (though wouldn't object to it either), but at the very least this is a plausible search term that could act as a useful redirect Deletion of Team Dixie WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
12994 12004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flaps Podcast User:Starblind 23:28, 25 February 2012 (UTC) delete doesn't pass at this time. Per the above, appears to be some COI/SPAM going on as well Deletion of Flaps Podcast WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
12995 1358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annie Le User:Dennisthe2 23:10, 14 September 2009 (UTC) keep on this one. There are the concerns, and it's geared to basically be an obituary, more or less, but I want to see this one develop. Something about |instinct on this one Deletion of Annie Le WP:BIO1E||WP:IAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
12996 8533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Željko Srdić User:Coolabahapple 07:05, 24 August 2016 (UTC) comment """article was created by an (almost) |spa {{u|ZeljkoArtist}} so there may be |coi issues, the serbian wikipedia doesn't appear to have an article on this artist - https://sr.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?search=%C5%BDeljko+Srdi%C4%87&title=%D0%9F%D0%BE%D1%81%D0%B5%D0%B1%D0%BD%D0%BE:%D0%9F%D1%80%D0%B5%D1%82%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%B6%D0%B8&go=%D0%98%D0%B4%D0%B8&searchToken=1fnbnkoj4dq2lvwgl7b96rdfz, a gsearch under """"Željko Srdić"""", """"Željko Srdić exhibitions"""", and """"Željko Srdić изложбе"""" brings up nothing |useable just facebook, blogs and mirror sites, have been unable to find citations for notable exhibitions""" Deletion of Željko Srdić WP:SPA||WP:COI||WP:RS Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
12997 4106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative metal (2nd nomination) User:Pmedema NONE keep I agree with Bretonbanquet - The topic to me seems of note. I'd like to see some more |reliable sources and some cleaning up of the article; maybe removing alot of the references to bands and relying on description instead Deletion of Alternative metal (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
12998 12165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Centina Systems User:AllyD 07:43, 6 October 2016 (UTC) delete My searches return routine announcements about deployment of this firm's products (noting false positives from other firms' products also named vSure), but I am not seeing the substantial coverage needed for , nor are the listed awards sufficiently specific to be notable in themselves Deletion of Centina Systems :WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
12999 12418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Early American editions of The Hobbit user:Andrew 15:15, 3 May 2020 (UTC) keep There's an obvious |alternative to deletion – merger to English-language editions of The Hobbit – per Deletion of Early American editions of The Hobbit WP:ATD||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13000 15396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sain (musician) User:BenLinus1214 22:05, 29 August 2015 (UTC) delete no reliable sources found that prove notability. Page created by a who appears to also be the subject. Johanna (formerly Deletion of Sain (musician) WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
13001 14870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bang Bang Bang (Selena Gomez & The Scene song) User:SummerPhD 20:03, 12 June 2011 (UTC) comment There is no question that it has been released. The question is whether it is |notable Deletion of Bang Bang Bang (Selena Gomez & The Scene song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13002 17251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Subtle asian traits User:Jmertel23 13:21, 11 January 2019 (UTC) keep """I completely agree with Squeamish Ossifrage - I fully expected to suggest deletion prior to digging into the references. It easily meets the requirement of """"The content itself has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself""" Deletion of Subtle asian traits WP:WEBCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13003 11833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TriFame User:4meter4 01:09, 26 October 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of TriFame WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
13004 12784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian A. Miller User:N 03:22, 25 February 2007 (UTC) comment Given that this person clearly has done notable things, it would be too bad to delete the article -- but I'm not seeing sources, and I worry about . Perhaps despite his activities, he hasn't got any sources about him? That would be surprising Deletion of Brian A. Miller WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13005 15690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Country Music Association Award for Male Vocalist of the Year User:SoWhy 21:14, 2 February 2017 (UTC) keep I agree with Montanabw's analysis. Those are notable topics in their own right and could be fleshed out even if they are not yet. Even if one were to think that they should be removed, the correct solution per would be to '''redirect''' to the main article, since as the correct names for the awards they are plausible search terms. Regards Deletion of Country Music Association Award for Male Vocalist of the Year WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13006 12271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy Scott Harris User:JoshuaZ 04:00, 9 November 2009 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet . Doesn't meet . Claims otherwise are very hard to take seriously. Given that his scenes in Angels and Demons were deleted it is hard to claim that he has a major enough role. The general lack of reliable third party sourcing moves me to favor deletion Deletion of Andy Scott Harris WP:BIO||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13007 2837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ender Bowen User:Bridgeplayer 19:16, 15 June 2007 (UTC) delete whom? Notability comes from secondary sources and none of the articles have any. Fails Deletion of Ender Bowen WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13008 6196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James W. Prescott User:Cyde 23:46, 22 January 2006 (UTC) keep as blatant violation of . Also, the nominator of this article has a currently ongoing Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Jason Gastrich|RFC and his motives are clearly suspect Deletion of James W. Prescott WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
13009 13339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MadGibbs User:Batard0 16:12, 26 October 2012 (UTC) delete There is http://www.hiphopdx.com/index/news/id.17769/title.blu-reveals-secret-album-ucla-produced-entirely-by-madlib/ this article, where it's mentioned in one line at the end, but there's also this http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/music_blog/2011/11/madlib-freddie-gibbs-thuggin-ep.html LA Times blog, which I think is a reliable source for this. There's also http://allhiphop.com/2012/10/12/exclusive-freddie-gibbs-preps-mad-gibbs-project-with-madlib-planning-movies-for-esgn-label/ this, which I judge to be some significant coverage in a semi-reliable source. This is all I can find, though, and I don't think it quite meets the criteria. The coverage has been relatively light, and is all on blogs; even if those blogs are considered reliable to a degree, you'd expect more coverage in the usual newspapers and magazines if this was indeed a significant release. I think it's likely there will be more significant coverage once this is released. Delete with no prejudice to recreation if solid sourcing appears in future Deletion of MadGibbs WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13010 5276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Priya Radhakrishnan User:Loriendrew 23:42, 5 February 2017 (UTC) delete As above, Deletion of Priya Radhakrishnan WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
13011 15026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Lighthill House User:Onthegogo 00:40, 22 March 2011 (UTC) keep A review of the sources listed in the article and those found by Rangoon11 has convinced me that this article passes Deletion of James Lighthill House WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13012 15258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meidata User:HighKing 16:04, 10 May 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and GNG Deletion of Meidata WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
13013 19854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trust It (album) User:Michig 08:10, 30 November 2009 (UTC) keep The nominator really should read and stop wasting our time with these nominations. The album has received plenty of coverage, with an Allmusic review already linked in the article, plus http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/5cw6 BBC, http://www.residentadvisor.net/review-view.aspx?id=1735 ResidentAdvisor, http://www.accessmylibrary.com/article-1G1-113755319/junior-jack-trust-defected.html Music Week, and http://www.ln-online.de/artikel/1345367/Junior_Jack:_Trust_It.htm this Deletion of Trust It (album) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13014 678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scarab (band) User:Cannibaloki 16:13, 17 February 2009 (UTC) delete can also be a |conflict of interest. Remember: Wikipedia ≠ Encyclopaedia Metallum Deletion of Scarab (band) WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
13015 14871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of selectmen of Freetown, Massachusetts User:Edison 13:46, 15 June 2011 (UTC) delete """Wikipedia is |not a directory. There is no """"inherent notability"""" for every selectman from a small town. As a member of a governing committee, a selectman seems less notable than a mayor. Even in modern times, some of the winners only received a few hundred votes. The past practice in AFD is summarized at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Common outcomes#Politicians which says in part: """"Municipal politicians are not inherently notable just for being in politics, but neither are they inherently non-notable just because they are in local politics. Each case is evaluated on its own individual merits. Mayors of cities of at least regional prominence have usually survived AFD, although the article should say more than just """"Jane Doe is the mayor of Cityville"""". Mayors of smaller towns, however, are generally deemed not notable just for being mayors, although they may be notable for other reasons in addition to their mayoralty. Note that this criterion has not generally been as restrictive as the criterion for city councillors. City councillors and other major municipal officers are not automatically notable, although precedent has tended to favor keeping members of the main citywide government of internationally famous metropolitan areas such as Toronto, Chicago, Tokyo or London""" Deletion of List of selectmen of Freetown, Massachusetts WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13016 4552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Health effects of wind power User:Artw 15:11, 8 August 2009 (UTC) comment the article as it stands appears to have major problems - for the article to stay (or be merged) they would need to be addressed Deletion of Health effects of wind power WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
13017 21246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antigone Sharris User:David 04:41, 27 March 2017 (UTC) delete The NYT article gives some notability to the gadget camp, but doesn't have enough about Sharris separately from her work with the camp to pass , and there doesn't seem to be anything else of significance here. Even the NYT article would not be enough by itself to support an article on the camp (although it would go a long way towards notability for it); it's definitely not enough by itself for Sharris Deletion of Antigone Sharris WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
13018 16392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonah Cristall-Clarke User:AllyD 22:33, 16 May 2011 (UTC) delete The references in the article show he has picked up student awards and a decent review of his 2005 performance with a workshop group, but it isn't enough to meet the criteria at the moment. Not to say he won't in the future though Deletion of Jonah Cristall-Clarke :WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13019 16832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nintendo's Tech Support Forums User:Sjones23 17:24, 29 March 2013 (UTC) delete this article fails the obviously Deletion of Nintendo's Tech Support Forums WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13020 15839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Franklin (2nd nomination) User:Bakazaka 19:09, 7 September 2018 (UTC) delete and salt. Second attempt at by undeclared editor who changed to their current username from Wikipedia:Changing_username/Simple/Archive214#Mrfranklin101 → A Washington II|Mrfranklin101 for probably obvious reasons Deletion of Michael Franklin (2nd nomination) WP:AUTOBIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
13021 15576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ragnarok (Norwegian band) User:Lugnuts 18:01, 30 March 2010 (UTC) keep """Passes |#5 """"Has released two or more albums on a major label or one of the more important indie labels"""" - 2 albums on Regain Records, http://www.discogs.com/artist/Ragnarok per this source""" Deletion of Ragnarok (Norwegian band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13022 20348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Test Soon Development User:Mr 02:36, 8 April 2009 (UTC) delete Couldn't find anything on this, appears to be |made up Deletion of Test Soon Development WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
13023 3041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Hopewell User:Spitfire 19:43, 1 April 2009 (UTC) delete This simply does not meet : it has not been non-trival subject of any secondary sources Deletion of New Hopewell WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13024 13069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bhakti Ballabh Tirtha Goswami Maharaj User:Shruti14 23:20, 26 March 2008 (UTC) delete non-notable (see ) - head of a relatively small institution, contains little information and few sources to establish notability. There are many small institutions within Hinduism and many leaders of these, many of whom are non-notable for their size and relative contributions to the religion. I think the subject of this article is no exception Deletion of Bhakti Ballabh Tirtha Goswami Maharaj WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13025 20316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hugo Austin [[User talk:Moondyne|Moondyne]] 00:49, 7 July 2009 (UTC) delete This is not what Wikipedia is for, IMHO, and everything is unverified per . I suggest the fans create their own wiki, if there isn't one already. &ndash Deletion of Hugo Austin WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13026 21199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tobacco references in music User:Oshwah 03:32, 13 July 2016 (UTC) delete The above reasons are all legitimate. The article appears to be an and looks to be based off of |original research Deletion of Tobacco references in music WP:ESSAY||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Essays 31
13027 15572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HumorFeed User:Delta 19:33, 10 October 2020 (UTC) delete as per what the AFD nominator has presented, after doing a rough search I didn't find much in favor of notability for this page, it seems like there's a little coverage by other known websites and outlets, but little to meet or create notability, more of a Deletion of HumorFeed WP:FAILN Wikipedia:Notability 77
13028 11424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abol-Bashar Mirza Farman Farmaian User:Cullen328 07:14, 23 December 2020 (UTC) delete This person's father was notable, but notability is |not inherited Deletion of Abol-Bashar Mirza Farman Farmaian WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13029 6060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Holm User:Nfitz 19:12, 6 July 2014 (UTC) keep Comments from the teams football director are clear that he's been made part of the first team with the expectation of playing http://www.jv.dk/artikel/1761930:Sport--Talenter-faar-chancen-i-Broendby as such it's almost certain he will play and meet . The season starts in 14 days, it's a waste of time and energy to delete an article that would very likely be recreated in a few weeks. There's no rush to delete this article before then. There are no firm rules that say this article needs to be deleted before we see happens, and there is . This article remaining in place for a few weeks does no harm, so let's show a bit of ; if something bizarre happens over the summer, the article can simply go to AFD at that time Deletion of Daniel Holm WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:NORUSH||WP:COMMONSENSE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13030 17879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CapAcadie.com User:Steve 02:12, 24 December 2017 (UTC) delete I am unable to find evidence that this is presently connected to L'Acadie Nouvelle. The newspaper presently has its own website under its own name. Bearcat indicates this is a former title of the newspaper's website. But I can't seem to verify that. No sources indicate this is worthy of a stand alone page on Wikipedia. Fails and . I can't see merging any of this content to L'Acadie Nouvelle without verification in reliable sources Deletion of CapAcadie.com WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
13031 987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devin Goda User:ONUnicorn 16:43, 15 April 2021 (UTC) keep I wonder how much |before was done before nominating this for deletion? Admittedly, the article as nominated only cited non-|independent sources, which do not contribute to |notability, but |independent sources do exist in sufficient quantities to meet |general notability guidelines. I have {{Diff|diff=1017973243|oldid=1015821189|label=added}} 3 such additional sources to the article Deletion of Devin Goda WP:BEFORE||WP:IS||WP:GNG||WP:IS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13032 20335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Masked Avengers' prank on Sarah Palin User:Jclemens 07:18, 4 November 2008 (UTC) merge to Public image and reception of Sarah Palin. It fails NOT#NEWS, but can live there per Deletion of The Masked Avengers' prank on Sarah Palin WP:NNC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13033 8706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Junction Solutions [[User Talk:Blaxthos|t]] / [[Special:Contributions/Blaxthos|c]] ) 02:37, 20 March 2008 (UTC) delete Sources do not directly deal with the subject of the article. ''En passant'' mention does not qualify regarding issues... this seems more like an advertisement than an appropriate article. /USER:Blaxthos|Blaxthos Deletion of Junction Solutions WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13034 43 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Teymur Mustafayev Kullanıcı:seksen iki yüz kırk beşseksen iki yüz kırk beş / ggt 11.34, 17 Eylül 2020 (UTC) keep """Anerka'nın belirttiği doğrultuda """"Halk Sanatçısı"""" unvanı taşıması dolayısıyla 'de yer alan """"Kişinin, önemli sayılan ödüller kazanmış olması."""" kriterini yerine getirdiğini düşünüyorum. Elbette VP:KİŞİ 0 olarak kayda değerdir anlamına gelmiyor diyen bir yönerge, ama burada istisnai bir durum olması için bir argüman göremiyorum. """"Yeterince kaynak bulunmuyor"""" yeterli bir argüman değil, zira bu durumda VP:KİŞİ yönergesinin varlık sebebi ortadan kalkıyor (genel kayda değerlik yönergesine alternatif olarak var). Bunun yanı sıra uzun süreli bir müzik hayatı olan birine dair """"Google testi"""" yapmak, hele de buradaki çoğumuzun kültüre aşina olmadığı bir durumda, """"kaynak yok"""" argümanının temelini yetersiz kılıyor""" Teymur Mustafayev'in silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
13035 17895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mina Başaran User:TheGracefulSlick 14:36, 18 March 2018 (UTC) merge Keep voters have not demonstrated how this coverage--dependent on the plane crash--is not a pure example of . All we mostly have here is a condensed version of her death, or, in other words, a smaller version of an article that ''already exists''. It is tragic, but we are not here to build |a memorial Deletion of Mina Başaran WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13036 6202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Superstition Meadery User:Maproom 09:20, 6 December 2016 (UTC) comment the three existing references do nothing to establish |notability, as the first is not independent and the other two contain no discussion. But better references exist, ''e.g.'' http://www.dcourier.com/news/2016/apr/03/downtown-prescotts-superstition-meadery-has-explod/ this Deletion of Superstition Meadery WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13037 3896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St Joseph School, Gagalangin User:Narutolovehinata5 12:37, 13 February 2018 (UTC) delete It appears that is no longer binding, so because the school appears to lack coverage in reliable sources (and indeed, the school does not even appear to have much online presence either), this fails Deletion of St Joseph School, Gagalangin WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13038 3067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2020 Gamba Osaka season User:Fenix 11:47, 27 June 2017 (UTC) delete per, insufficient information for an article at this moment Deletion of 2020 Gamba Osaka season WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13039 2201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Intelligent community User:Calgary 22:56, 17 August 2007 (UTC) delete For the length of the article the number/detail of the cited references is strongly lacking. Also the article is very heavily interwoven with analysis, in a manner that is expressly covered by as being inappropriate for Wikipedia Deletion of Intelligent community WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13040 6621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barry Charles Honig (2nd nomination) User:Qworty 00:03, 14 October 2012 (UTC) delete Fails per . Is pure . The edit history also really bothers me. suggests that a couple of accounts that are and have been at work promoting this man Deletion of Barry Charles Honig (2nd nomination) WP:BIO||WP:RS||WP:ADVERT||WP:DUCK||WP:SOCK||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Notability 77
13041 18316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CodeLobster User:Joe 20:23, 10 January 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of CodeLobster WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13042 9665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The God of Wealth User:Sunshine1191 02:44, 4 October 2020 (UTC) keep Even though the second review is very brief, everything put together there might be about enough content and valid refs to scrape through Deletion of The God of Wealth WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
13043 15250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthea Montessori House of Children User:onel5969 13:02, 29 October 2015 (UTC) delete no notability established. Fails Deletion of Anthea Montessori House of Children WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13044 21920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hiago Rodrigues Reis de Queirós User:Gunnex 08:01, 2 July 2009 (UTC) delete Fails . Doesn´t indicate any notability. No independent reliable sources (note: Afd-pt was also influenced by self-constructed fake-sources). Obvious COI/cross wiki spam case. Btw: next envolved sock identified in :pt:Wikipedia:Pedidos a verificadores/Arquivo/2009/06#Willkon D C E Deletion of Hiago Rodrigues Reis de Queirós WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13045 3262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hristijan Srkeski (footballer) User:Sir 13:18, 7 April 2014 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Hristijan Srkeski (footballer) WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13046 13396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Narcomey User:Phil 20:58, 20 April 2008 (UTC) keep There are sources to demonstrate notability, and in most cases they talk more about the subject as an individual rather than AIM. is not relevant here - this is someone who has led an ongoing campaign, not someone who has got caught up in a news event Deletion of David Narcomey WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13047 4819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Downtown Markham, Ontario User:Mindmatrix 22:31, 16 June 2008 (UTC) comment although I think this is a notable subject, there is little in the current article that is sufficiently convincing to keep it. Reliance on one source, the developer's website for the planned community, is inadequate per . I'm certain there should be a few reliable sources which discuss the nature of the planned community, and the reason for its existence, in reasonable depth. In fact, it has been the centre of discussion and debate regarding new techniques in urban planning, so it's just a matter of finding these sources. I'm willing to give interested editors time to find and incorporate them into the article in order to salvage it, but I'll refrain from rating this as a ''keep'' until I see evidence of this. As is stands, this article doesn't merit inclusion in Wikipedia Deletion of Downtown Markham, Ontario WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13048 2633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Beckett User:Pharaoh 03:30, 2 October 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and the coverage is routine.Now the the subject has played http://www.espncricinfo.com/australia/content/player/10268.html just 1 List A Match in which his contribution was insignificant and has retired now the subject technically meets as he has played just 1 Match but the subject comprehensively fails the |General Notability Guideline and has long retired thus ending any scope of future contribution or any hope of meeting General Notability Guideline Deletion of David Beckett WP:GNG||WP:NCRIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13049 5997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magic and Other Misdemeanors User:Karanacs 19:41, 18 May 2009 (UTC) delete Fails and OT#PLOT. Links Hobit notes above don't appear to meet the notability criteria for books Deletion of Magic and Other Misdemeanors WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13050 14638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Access america transport User:Alphachimp 01:53, 18 July 2006 (UTC) delete Not just , also Deletion of Access america transport WP:SPAM||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Spam 112
13051 21594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan MacLeod User:Joe 22:09, 9 June 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |author Deletion of Jordan MacLeod WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13052 13813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William F. Rolleston User:scope_creep 11:25, 8 March 2019 (UTC) delete Some mentions in GBooks, particularly in the Journal, but really no sustained coverage or instance of biography to verify the article. The letter references are mostly name drops and certainly verify the existence and position of the man, but not much else. Fails both and Deletion of William F. Rolleston WP:BIO||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
13053 4877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sri Sathya Sai Super Speciality Hospital User:Winged 04:46, 13 October 2019 (UTC) delete Unadulterated spam, per my original tagging; part of the Sai-Baba-walled-garden, that was subject to 2 Arbitration cases, in the wild west days of Wikipedia. FWIW, I spot no '''|minimally significant''' coverage of the subject in |reliable sources except in {{Cite book|url=https://chicago.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.7208/chicago/9780226396248.001.0001/upso-9780226396071|title=The Distressed Body: Rethinking Illness, Imprisonment, and Healing|last=Leder|first=Drew|publisher=University of Chicago Press|year=2016|isbn=9780226396071|pages=78,79|doi=10.7208/chicago/9780226396248.003.0006|chapter-url-access=subscription|chapter=Rethinking Clinical Practice: Toward a More Materialistic Medicine|chapter-url=https://chicago.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.7208/chicago/9780226396248.001.0001/upso-9780226396071-chapter-006}}; the subject thus fails Deletion of Sri Sathya Sai Super Speciality Hospital WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS||WP:GEOFEAT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13054 19629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tadhg Flynn User:FlyingToaster 21:25, 3 March 2009 (UTC) keep The article definitely needs some references, but independent of this the subject does meet Deletion of Tadhg Flynn WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13055 12072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jay Sebring User:MelanieN 22:41, 8 February 2015 (UTC) keep """Thanks for the ping. Yes, he fails , but he passes . He was quite notable for his hair styling career even before he was killed. According to sourced material in the article, he """"invented a whole new way of cutting men's hair"""", and his techniques are still being taught 40 years after his death, via his still-existing company Sebring International. Seriously, I thought I had firmly established this person's notability with the recent sources I added: I doubled the prose portion of the article and added four new sources, all of which are about him and his career, not about the murders. The NYT article you linked to above is 3 pages long and is entirely, significantly about him and his hair styling career; it was written more than 30 years after his death which should establish his lasting significance. Oh, and as of 2013 a biopic movie about him was reportedly in the works.http://www.philly.com/philly/blogs/hautehouse_row/James-Franco-to-direct-and-star-in-biopic-of-murdered-celebrity-hair-stylist-Jay-Sebring.html If the murder portion of the article needs more sources, those can readily be added; but those are about the crime and thus are less important to the article than the material about HIM""" Deletion of Jay Sebring WP:VICTIM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13056 14272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nu Gospel User:Justlettersandnumbers 21:38, 27 November 2015 (UTC) merge to Gospel music, per {{u|TheRedPenOfDoom|TRPOD}} and ; beyond the sources analysed by {{u|I JethroBT}} (the same that I found), the BBC source in the article is also evidence that the neologism may be gaining some minimal currency. If sources can be found, this could be a section of the main article until – if ever – it becomes clear that a separate page is needed; without sources, there's nothing to merge, so a redirect is all that's needed Deletion of Nu Gospel WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
13057 5705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Axialis IconWorkshop User:Joe 19:27, 4 August 2009 (UTC) delete All the sources in the article are trivial except forhttp://www.pcworld.com/downloads/file/fid,23549/description.html?&page=11 this. Fails Deletion of Axialis IconWorkshop WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13058 21130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/In the Whale user:swpb 20:44, 16 November 2015 (UTC) delete """per nominator. Re: """"I based this post on no less than 5 other artist profiles"""": please note that |the existence of similar content is not a valid argument for inclusion. The page creator may have """"150 articles"""" about the band, but we only need a few, so long as their coverage is ''significant'', ''reliable'', and establishes that the subject meets . What we have so far may come close, but I don't think it's there""" Deletion of In the Whale WP:OSE||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13059 13927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maren Knudsen User:Clavdia 15:14, 4 March 2012 (UTC) keep From a quick google search, I found evidence of non trivial coverage in multiple independent reliable sources. http://fotballmagasinet.no/index.php?mode=news&id=16975 http://www.ba.no/sport/ungsport/article3943672.ece http://www.fotball.no/Landslag_og_toppfotball/spillerutvikling/Unge-profiler/2011/Maren-Knudsen/ Therefore passes . Nom might consider in future Deletion of Maren Knudsen WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13060 18405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daitec User:Kicking222 11:22, 26 August 2006 (UTC) delete The article makes little claim of notability, and I couldn't find anything on Google that would help it pas Deletion of Daitec WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13061 10764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chongqing No.68 Middle School User:onel5969 15:08, 13 May 2018 (UTC) delete Middle school with no indication of notability. Fails Deletion of Chongqing No.68 Middle School WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13062 6946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Freedom Debt Relief User:Mrschimpf 22:19, 27 October 2020 (UTC) delete The tone is so insufferable even in the sections where states took action against them, that there's no hope of rescue here. In order to keep this, someone needs to remove the horrid tone and restore neutrality to this copy Deletion of Freedom Debt Relief WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13063 14162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elements of Rehearsal in the Bleak Midwinter User:SSTflyer 16:01, 6 December 2015 (UTC) delete does not meet , and insufficient coverage from a web search for this to meet (this is a 2014 production Deletion of Elements of Rehearsal in the Bleak Midwinter WP:NFILM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13064 7641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abigail Kelly User:Voceditenore 08:50, 3 October 2014 (UTC) keep """Delete''' See my comment below She passes none of the criteria for nor . Yes, some singers have emerged from ETO to go on to significant careers, but this singer has not done so yet, although she is obviously talented. When she passes the criteria, she should have an article—not before. The place to wait for that is as a draft in user or draft space, not an article in main space. She has not sung a single leading role with a single major opera company. Even if you look at her roles with the second tier company, English Touring Opera, they are invariably minor ones. You can see that from the press section on her own website http://www.abigailkellysoprano.com/index.php/press-reviews/press-reviews. She has no significant concert career, i.e. as a soloist with leading orchestras in major concert halls. She has no recordings, even in minor roles. She has won no significant awards or placed in any major singing competition. The list of roles/operas/concerts on her website (from which the article is very heavily paraphrased) is very vague, probably intentionally so, as on doing a bit of research, the potentially leading roles pertain to youth opera and student productions. She ''covered'' the role of Così fan tutte|Despina (arguably her only leading role with ETO) but only performed it at the dress rehearsal when the scheduled singer was ill. See the ETO press office http://englishtouringopera.org.uk/about-eto/press-office/ """"Please note that Paula Sides, singing the role of Despina in ETO’s tour of Così fan tutte, was unwell during the dress rehearsal, when these photos were taken, so Abigail Kelly, covering the role of Despina, appears in these shots instead of Paula."""" The concerts are with local choral groups, very minor local """"festivals"""", schools outreach, etc. After searching for more coverage which would qualify the subject for , I cannot find anything apart from the """"local girl makes good"""" article in the ''Birmingham Post'' and http://jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/20100813/news/news2.html this very similar article in the ''Jamaica Gleaner'' from four years ago""" Deletion of Abigail Kelly WP:MUSICBIO||WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13065 376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naukrigulf.com User:AllyD 08:46, 31 March 2017 (UTC) delete to the parent: A market-specific employment portal alongside :Naukri.com and others, under :Info Edge (India). While there is |evidence of the operation, it does not indicate independent notability Deletion of Naukrigulf.com :WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13066 4512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marc Lesser User:Papaursa 17:57, 18 October 2018 (UTC) delete He seems to be successful, but that's not a notability criterion. He can't inherit notability from his various teachers and I don't see significant independent coverage from multiple independent reliable sources to support the claim that he meets Deletion of Marc Lesser WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13067 18382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PokéBattlers User:DX 01:05, 4 November 2008 (UTC) comment article has been |userfied into Deletion of PokéBattlers WP:USERFY Wikipedia:Userfication 87
13068 16496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emi coco User:TheSpecialUser 21:50, 26 May 2012 (UTC) delete fails . There are not many notable results (in fact rarely few). Not notable enough Deletion of Emi coco WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13069 18075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucie Chan User:Theredproject 17:37, 25 March 2018 (UTC) comment re|Bearcat}} and Special:Contributions/104.163.147.121|104.163.147.121 you have stated that an organization's website (even if that organization is the National Gallery of Canada) does not constitute a but is considered . That really surprises me. Especially with regional and national museums. I have understood that a listing on a museum or other major institution's website constitutes a to establish that an event did happen; it is because it is authored by the curator and goes through ''extensive'' curatorial and editorial steps before arriving on the website. Is there anywhere that this has been noted or recorded? Pinging established AfD participants {{ping|Arthistorian1977|Megalibrarygirl|Mduvekot|DGG}} for objective/neutral clarification and discussion. And to be clear here: I want to understand established practice, and build consensus amongst key AfD participants about what does or does not count as in this kind of situation Deletion of Lucie Chan WP:RS||WP:SELFPUB||WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13070 15558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ormand Cup User:Aarktica 01:19, 11 August 2007 (UTC) delete article desperately using possibly notable subject (i.e. Charles Ormand) as a |COATRACK-like tool to justify its presence on Wiki Deletion of Ormand Cup WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
13071 2425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henrik Breimyr User:GiantSnowman 12:25, 16 December 2011 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Henrik Breimyr WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13072 17269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shivin Narang User:Atlantic306 18:44, 23 May 2020 (UTC) keep passes with leading roles in notable Indian national television series such as: Suvreen Guggal – Topper of The Year, Ek Veer Ki Ardaas...Veera, Internet Wala Love and Beyhadh 2 as confirmed in reliable sources in the article. The article is minimal and needs expansion but that is not a reason for deletion, imv Deletion of Shivin Narang WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13073 1525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucy Parker (transsexual) User:TSO1D 04:14, 27 December 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails Deletion of Lucy Parker (transsexual) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13074 5282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donington Park services User:Necrothesp 02:09, 24 September 2006 (UTC) comment """No, unsourced material is not necessarily """"original research"""". This term has started to be bandied around a little too freely in recent months, usually by people trying to support their desire to delete something. It's a good idea to read to see what actually constitutes original research on Wikipedia - it's summarised in the little box at the top. This clearly states the position - stating a fact (e.g. """"Donington Park services is a motorway service station off the M1 motorway and A42 interchange near Derby, England"""") is not original research; advancing a theory which has not been published by a reputable source is. Yes, it's always better to source articles, but don't just dismiss articles as OR because they're unsourced""" Deletion of Donington Park services WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13075 21286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cookie Crisp User:Rhododendrites 15:21, 19 January 2016 (UTC) keep Meets . Seems like one of those subjects that is such a part of popular culture that ''good'' sources get buried. NA1000's sources scrape the surface sufficiently. &mdash Deletion of Cookie Crisp WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13076 12921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chilltime User:Cunard 09:12, 10 May 2009 (UTC) keep Appears to pass and . There are several sources that attest to this website's notability. http://www.jornaldenegocios.pt/index.php?template=SHOWNEWS&id=354154 Here is an article from ''Jornal de Negócios'' and http://tecnologia.pt.msn.com/noticias/article.aspx?cp-documentid=14846095 this article from MSN, http://www.dnoticias.pt/default.aspx?file_id=dn04010802050309 this article from Dnoticias, and http://www.meiosepublicidade.pt/2009/03/09/sic-mulher-com-dedicatorias-para-as-mulheres/ this article from Meios & Publicidade. These sources seem to show that this company passes . ''I don't read Portuguese, so hopefully a Portuguese-speaker can evaluate whether the sources I have cited are reliable enough Deletion of Chilltime WP:WEB||WP:V||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13077 8923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian James (broadcaster) User:Flowanda NONE delete Multiple searches on variations of name produce nothing that can be used to establish notability for this person or this article. Being listed as part of a BBC show does nothing to establish notability, especially when that link is the only reference. Without significant coverage in mainstream media meeting , there is no reason to keep this article Deletion of Ian James (broadcaster) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13078 13025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guillaume Boucard User:Bagumba 09:54, 2 January 2019 (UTC) delete Fails with lack of significant coverage from multiple, independent sources. Does not meet Deletion of Guillaume Boucard WP:GNG||WP:NBASKETBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13079 5339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunwest Solutions User:AllyD 13:11, 16 November 2016 (UTC) delete """This AfD and my CSD A7 were placed near-simultaneously. Anyway, this article has a similar pattern to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nettech Ltd in that the article asserts claims sourced only to a Yellow Pages listing and uses the Design Museum website as a """"reference"""" (which mentions neither firm). No |real evidence of |notability""" Deletion of Sunwest Solutions :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13080 8829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phantom Mobile Device Vibration Syndrome User:Imoeng 02:26, 27 October 2006 (UTC) delete Fails . And the sentence ''It is not known how many people experience these phantom sensations in their left or right thighs...'' clarifies it's non-notability and OR (also with unreliable sources). Cheers Deletion of Phantom Mobile Device Vibration Syndrome WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13081 7883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Winkler (ice hockey) User:Shelbystripes 22:48, 1 October 2017 (UTC) delete Fails , I see nothing else that supports notability Deletion of Scott Winkler (ice hockey) WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13082 2106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Newcomers (film) User:Donaldd23 21:33, 7 July 2020 (UTC) keep """I found a review online https://theskykid.com/the-newcomers-2000/, but not sure if the source is considered """"reliable"""". It does meet the """"independent"""" criteria of reviews. Even if that doesn't count, I believe that this film meets the """"Inclusionary criteria"""" of under the following criteria, which states, """"The film features significant involvement (i.e., one of the most important roles in the making of the film) by a notable person and is a major part of his/her career."""" This is the film debut of Chris Evans, a now well-known actor (Captain America). To remove an acting debut of a successful person just because they weren't known at the time, or the film had only a limited release would mean that films such as ''Three Rooms in Manhattan'' (Robert De Niro), ''Las Vegas Nights'' (Frank Sinatra), ''Can I Do It... 'Til I Need Glasses?'' (Robin Williams), and ''Another Nice Mess'' (Steve Martin) would also need to be removed as they are all pretty much non-notable films, except for the fact that the individuals appeared in them and they went on to have huge careers. Add in the fact that Evan's role in the film was much larger than any of the other actor's debut performances""" Deletion of The Newcomers (film) WP:NFO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13083 854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mighty Psyducks User:RGTraynor 00:00, 25 April 2008 (UTC) delete """They even have jerseys? Errr ... every Little League town team in the country has jerseys. *I* have several hockey jerseys hanging in my closet. While I'm unsure as to the utility of """"broadening their fanbase"""" (what, someone from Detroit's going to take in a game?), I'm sure that Myspace is sufficient to their needs. Wikipedia, however, requires |reliable sources and |notability, and this band of players in a beer league have neither""" Deletion of Mighty Psyducks WP:V||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13084 1833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wunderlist User:scope_creep 15:50, 31 August 2013 (UTC) delete Startup company|Startup only recently created. Fails . Not much else to say Deletion of Wunderlist WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13085 802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theory of Consciousness User:Neurolysis 11:19, 26 October 2008 (UTC) delete Author admits that this article is in breach of . &mdash Deletion of Theory of Consciousness WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13086 15737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/INTP User:Squidfryerchef 20:25, 14 April 2008 (UTC) comment As far as the lists of famous people go, most books about the MBTI written for the popular or business press have similar lists. I'd suggest walking into any public library if there's a question about published sources. Also the whole nomination smacks of Deletion of INTP WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13087 21760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RisingDark User:Dchall1 02:17, 10 December 2007 (UTC) delete per . ''...one of the most ambitious gaming projects of the century''. Right Deletion of RisingDark WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13088 10041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Highwinds Network Group User:Arsenikk 09:45, 10 May 2008 (UTC) keep Company in question has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, and these are included in the article (thus meets ). I would like to ask the nominator the rationale for nomination, as it is not described in the nomination. Is it being contended for lack of notability, or for other reasons Deletion of Highwinds Network Group WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13089 2803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan and Ken User:GarrieIrons 01:08, 7 June 2007 (UTC) comment """if you can provide RS for their being finalists you will probably find sufficient sources for each presenter to pass . Unless of course, nominations are based on """"your own station nominates every show for every eligible award""" Deletion of Dan and Ken WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13090 11996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bite Me (song) User:RadioFan 16:04, 21 February 2010 (UTC) delete no indication that this song meets , lacks coverage in 3rd party sources Deletion of Bite Me (song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13091 14443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rocky Patel Premium Cigars User:HighKing 23:32, 11 November 2020 (UTC) keep """due to at least two analyst reports available on this company which meet the criteria for establishing notability. '''Delete''' None of the references meet the criteria for establishing notability. ''""""Plenty of hits""""'' also isn't a reason because all the hits I can find fail . I am unable to locate any |significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content which are the requirements, topic therefore fails GNG/""" Deletion of Rocky Patel Premium Cigars WP:NCORP||WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13092 6423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Botkin User:power 00:53, 31 October 2018 (UTC) delete a very bad CV; simply being a professor is not enough to meet Deletion of Sean Botkin WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13093 3411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Other researchers who claim or may claim their crucial roles in the discovery of graphene User:Warrah 20:51, 7 December 2009 (UTC) delete WP:NPOV and issues Deletion of Other researchers who claim or may claim their crucial roles in the discovery of graphene WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13094 10397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mansfield Parkrun User:Snowycats 16:27, 15 July 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Mansfield Parkrun WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13095 17155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maya (2016 film) User:Dan 09:07, 21 June 2016 (UTC) delete based on the above search criteria I can not find anything apart from Facebook and YouTube pages that refer to this film. Two out of the three references cited in the article don't even mention the film at all. There is nothing to substantiate compliance with Deletion of Maya (2016 film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
13096 17444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Haunting in Salem [[User: Phoenix B 1of3|Phoenix B 1of3]] [[User talk: Phoenix B 1of3|(talk)]] 19:45, 28 October 2011 (UTC) keep per article is still under construction when nominated, and since its nomination it has already become better cited and referenced article approaching Deletion of A Haunting in Salem WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13097 14757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Frederick Holmes User:Dhartung 06:34, 23 September 2007 (UTC) delete fails . Some visible roles in moderately successful films, but accomplishment is not notability, even when you're an actor Deletion of Lee Frederick Holmes WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13098 2966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Barrott User:Chubbles 03:53, 24 June 2015 (UTC) comment The article now includes an Allmusic bio and an ''Exclaim!'' review (both international press), as well as two reviews from UK outlets, and a Pitchfork Media longform about Ibiza music which includes an entire section about Barrott. This, particularly with the last one, ordinarily would hurdle the sourcing/exposure requirements for bands, based on past precedent. The musician meets Deletion of Mark Barrott WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13099 3337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yugg [[User talk:2604:2000:8FC0:4:617F:E9A7:AF1C:4546|talk]]) 18:07, 10 December 2019 (UTC) delete Even if the fanfic met notability thresholds this would fail as an inappropriate split, the author should consider alternative outlets. Special:Contributions/2604:2000:8FC0:4:617F:E9A7:AF1C:4546|2604:2000:8FC0:4:617F:E9A7:AF1C:4546 Deletion of Yugg WP:BKD Wikipedia:Notability 77
13100 9719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Firefly (company) User:K 16:38, 19 January 2019 (UTC) delete Does not meet ; significant coverage not found. Sources are passing mentions, routine notices and / or . Also fails . Launch publicity does not equate to encyclopedia notability in this case Deletion of Firefly (company) WP:NCORP||WP:RS||WP:SPIP||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13101 10189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rob Heinsoo User:SummerPhD 16:21, 14 March 2011 (UTC) delete """Fails and . Has not been """"the subject of multiple published secondary sources which are reliable, intellectually independent of each other, and independent of the subject."""" Not notable""" Deletion of Rob Heinsoo WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13102 5377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bahamas–Russia relations User:Johnuniq 03:37, 4 June 2009 (UTC) delete Article has no useful content. No sources discuss these relations. Fails |notability Deletion of Bahamas–Russia relations WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13103 11958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arun Budhathoki User:HalfLifeDelta 12:37, 4 Jun 2019 (UTC) delete No evidence of passing on merit Deletion of Arun Budhathoki WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13104 7366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Versace User:Winkelvi 05:19, 1 August 2015 (UTC) comment Should be speedy deleted per . Was created by a block evading sock of an indeffed user Deletion of Daniel Versace WP:G5 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
13105 18248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Thomas (tennis) User:Spiderone 16:43, 11 May 2021 (UTC) comment I found an article in the https://www.lancashiretelegraph.co.uk/sport/4447253.wimbledon-hope-blackburn-tennis-ace/ Lancashire Telegraph and also one in the https://www.clitheroeadvertiser.co.uk/sport/ribble-valley-coach-elizabeths-elite-opportunity-2702559 Clitheroe Advertiser. Not sure if there's enough to show there Deletion of Elizabeth Thomas (tennis) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13106 6048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew VanDyke User:Northamerica1000 08:51, 20 November 2011 (UTC) keep No valid argument for deletion exists in the nomination. Topic easily passes . See references section of the article Deletion of Matthew VanDyke WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13107 8070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Sadler User:ChrisTheDude 14:28, 2 April 2007 (UTC) delete unless it can be proven that he also played for a team in The Football League or a cricket team in the County Championship - both teams he is listed as having played for don't even come close to satisfying (Barnet having been in the Athenian League during the 1950s Deletion of Michael Sadler WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13108 1313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gaby Borges User:Kudpung 04:02, 4 September 2016 (UTC) delete fails to meet criteria at and . If this person were notable there would be more on the Internet than the usual raft of sn sites and IMDB, none of which are considered eliable sources for the purpose of asserting notability Deletion of Gaby Borges WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:R Wikipedia:Notability 77
13109 19265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Molesworth User:Jmertel23 12:20, 13 September 2018 (UTC) delete As mentioned above, the wedding announcement is really the only the reliable, in-depth reference. The others either do not mention the subject or do so only in passing. For example, https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/about-us/awards/ this website used as a reference mentions nothing about Molesworth. Perhaps it lends itself to notability of the film, but certainly not to the person. And notability is |not inherited. Overall, fails and Deletion of Mark Molesworth WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:SIGCOV||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13110 8974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jules Boykoff User:Fenix 15:19, 29 October 2014 (UTC) keep per GS, seems to be significantly more than just an academic. Might fail , but plenty out there about the rest of his life to satisfy GNG Deletion of Jules Boykoff WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13111 15020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MAGAkids incident User:MPS 21:27, 23 January 2019 (UTC) keep """Already mentioned briefly at another article"""" is not a good reason to delete a lengthy and well sourced article on a notable-in-itself topic. As the guy who |boldly forked the article from Indigenous Peoples March in the first place, I did so based on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Indigenous_Peoples_March#Propose_splitting_the_article attempts to discuss on the talk page first and also based on the fact that the crux of the incident did not actually occur '''during''' the IPM or in conjunction with the IPM. I think the topic is clearly notable based on mainstream media coverage (19 million ghits for https://www.google.com/search?q=covington+catholic+incident&num=100 Covington Catholic Incident), and I think its notability derives from the clash and subsequent culture war implications rather than from the Indigenous Peoples March. The event is """"already covered"""" not only by the Indigenous People's March, but also by the March for Life, Covington Catholic High School, Black Hebrew Israelites, and other wikipedia articles. The IPM article was bloated with incident specific details / reactions unrelated to the planning and conduct of the Indigenous People's March. Merging to any one of these articles (Indigenous People's March, March for Life, Covington Catholic High School, or Black Hebrew Israelites) would bloat it up with incident specific details and media interpretations at the expense of otherwise distinct and clear articles. This is a textbook |Recentism editor disagreement, since some people think it is obviously notable and others think it is a news blip. In any case, it is incontrovertably attracting a lot of buzz on we won't know whether it will stick... but in the mean time there is a lot of reliable source coverage trying to dissect what exactly happened -- something that Wikipedia is extremely good at assimilating. Again, refer to for some thoughts on what to do in this case. I am not committed to the name, but I could not think of a better one that maintained . Peace and WikiLove""" Deletion of MAGAkids incident WP:BOLD||WP:RECENT||WP:RECENT||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Be bold 9
13112 122 [[Horze]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Jesi 12:02, 21. Aug. 2007 (CEST) keep Ich hab schon bei einer anderen Löschdiskussion die Meinung vertreten, dass wir hier den Spielraum, den uns gibt (erste zwei Absätze, besonders der fettgeschriebene Satz im 2. Absatz), doch ausnutzen sollten. Es ist ein seit fast 20 Jahren bestehendes Unternehmen, das international agiert (wenn ich richtig gezählt habe in 7 Ländern bis Australien). Ich will jetzt nicht polemisch werden (wäre auch hier am falschen Platze), aber wir haben schon manches Sternchen stehen gelassen, das gerade mal eine CD veröffentlicht hat. Hier bin ich für Löschung von Horze Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
13113 17138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GOB3L.Y3R.201.2 User:Omni 08:08, 18 July 2016 (UTC) delete Nowhere near notable enough to meet , no reliable coverage whatsoever. I would also be OK with a redirect to We Bare Bears Deletion of GOB3L.Y3R.201.2 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13114 3229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rockajazz User:Coredesat 04:06, 30 June 2006 (UTC) delete non-notable neologism, fails Deletion of Rockajazz WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13115 20655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thrash Clash 2 - Diamond Plate vs Oppression User:Atsme 20:33, 23 September 2017 (UTC) delete fails (music). The cited sources don't exist. The band Diamond Plate should also be deleted. Appears to be promo spam Deletion of Thrash Clash 2 - Diamond Plate vs Oppression WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13116 20787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Will Precious User:Seraphimblade 10:03, 19 February 2007 (UTC) delete note: potentially negative and unsourced information was removed). No indication why this person is |notable Deletion of Will Precious WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13117 1952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacob Barnett (3rd nomination) User:K 03:27, 15 November 2016 (UTC) delete per (literally); the subject is not yet notable Deletion of Jacob Barnett (3rd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
13118 19569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aralt Mac Giolla Chainnigh User:Xxanthippe 00:14, 2 October 2009 (UTC) delete on basis of . Comments from Canadians would be helpful Deletion of Aralt Mac Giolla Chainnigh WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13119 7195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DJ P User:Doomsdayer520 18:40, 10 December 2010 (UTC) delete The article is a straight-up violation of and he has not been noticed except in self-generated social networking and downloading sites. Though maybe his bland name makes it difficult to find news about him Deletion of DJ P WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13120 17606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rocco Did It Again! User:Expertwikiguy 22:56, 7 February 2021 (UTC) keep Meets by having Billboard #34 track, although article can be improved with more citations if there are any Deletion of Rocco Did It Again! WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13121 81 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hazar Ergüçlü Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 15:13, 21 Haziran 2016 (UTC) keep """Kriterleri karşıladığı bariz olan birisi. Gereksiz adaylıklarla topluluğun vakti çalınmamalı. |""""Kayda değer filmlerde, televizyon ve sahne gösterilerinde ve diğer prodüksiyonlarda önemli rol oynamış olanlar."""" kriterini sağlıyor, bunu da politikayı okumamış olanlar için not düşeyim""" Hazar Ergüçlü'nün silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
13122 16073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Women's Work: the Montana Women's Centennial Art Survey Exhibition 1889-1989 User:Coolabahapple 05:34, 16 May 2018 (UTC) comment an interesting and informative article, but no |citations that lead to notability, and have been unable to find any, allbeit using gsearch only, so its a '''delete''' from me Deletion of Women's Work: the Montana Women's Centennial Art Survey Exhibition 1889-1989 WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13123 119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arnold Kwok User:DrStrauss 18:05, 10 March 2017 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Arnold Kwok WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13124 34 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Eski Bir Alkoliğin Günlüğü Kullanıcı:86.67.141.17186.67.141.171 18.54, 27 Şubat 2018 (UTC) comment 2- Son olarak: incelendi. Diğerleri de incelendi ve {{ping|İncelemeelemani}} de ona göre düzenlemeleri yaparak bu maddeye KD kaynakçalar ekledi. İçeriğinde ne olduğu zaten belli, Alkolizm ile mücadeleyi anlatan bir Kitap, Basılmamış ya da hayali bir madde değil ki bu. Hani İsim Soyad maddelerine olan hassasiyetinizi yıllardır WK'de anlıyorum da Kitaplara karşı bari böyle sert olmayın. Mantıklı düşünürseniz sevinirim. Başkalarının kitapla yazdıkları da zaten Röportajlarda ve Tanıtımlarda var olmasa neden ısrar edeyim eklenmesi için? Lütfen İsimsiz bir Kullanıcı olarak bu madde kalsın. Uyduruk bir madde olsa bu kadar yazar mıydım? Bunu düşünün derim. Gerisini de Eski Bir Alkolün Günlüğünün silinmesi Vikipedi:Bağımsız kaynaklar Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13125 12504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zoran Ducić User:Sir 23:38, 8 February 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Zoran Ducić WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13126 20464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008–09 Eastbourne Borough F.C. season User:Joseph2302 14:43, 31 March 2016 (UTC) delete Fails and , as all coverage is |run-of-the-mill for any club Deletion of 2008–09 Eastbourne Borough F.C. season WP:NSEASONS||WP:GNG||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13127 1 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BBC One logos User:The_Thadman 02:26, 3 February 2007 (UTC) delete An article on Wikipedia is |not just a group of images Deletion of BBC One logos WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13128 12947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pakistan International Airlines Flight 605 User:SunDawn 03:35, 3 May 2021 (UTC) delete the incident is regrettable, but per this should not be included. Hull loss is bad, but the cause of the incident would likely be common, and there are no fatalities. Of course, the mention of the incident could be placed on Pakistan International Airlines and the airport Deletion of Pakistan International Airlines Flight 605 WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13129 363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Chilton (game developer) [[User talk:66.191.253.210|talk]]) 07:36, 27 March 2008 (UTC) delete This person is not notable enough to have a Wikipedia article. He is only known within the World of Warcraft(WoW) community and that is only due to his attendance to company (Blizzard) sponsored conferences. There are not Wikipedia article about the lead designers of Microsoft Office or Visual Studio,are there? The work Tom Chilton has done with WoW is intellectual property of Blizzard/Vivendi, it belongs to that company, not Tom Chilton. Also, citing Blizzard's websites as sources is not adhereing to . The company is not a reliable source for unbiased information regarding its development team.Special:Contributions/66.191.253.210|66.191.253.210 Deletion of Tom Chilton (game developer) WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
13130 9964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Washington Nationals minor league players User:Muboshgu 15:18, 5 November 2014 (UTC) keep Alex is being y and I've already ed him. We have a long standing consensus on how to do this that he doesn't seem to comprehend, and now he's wasting our time and resources on this farce. – Deletion of Washington Nationals minor league players WP:POINT||WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
13131 19018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brianna and Brittany McConnell User:NinjaRobotPirate 01:10, 29 April 2015 (UTC) delete I don't see any coverage in reliable sources. There isn't really a good redirect target, either. A handful of minor roles listed on the IMDb is not enough to satisfy Deletion of Brianna and Brittany McConnell WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13132 18062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michele Abeles User:Colonel 01:32, 6 July 2016 (UTC) keep Subject has received quite a bit of coverage; there's http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/17/arts/design/michele-abeles-english-for-secretaries.html?_r=0 a ''New York Times'' review, http://www.wmagazine.com/people/insiders/2014/04/michele-abeles-arts-post-internet-pioneer/ a review in ''W magazine'', and her work has been featured at the Museum of Modern Art. That's enough to pass . As for the , the article may only be deleted if there is no rough consensus. What we have here seems to be rough consensus, so I would be against that Deletion of Michele Abeles WP:ARTIST||WP:BLPREQUESTDELETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13133 17067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cutting (in line) User:Corpx 08:02, 23 July 2007 (UTC) comment I'm definitely opposed to this, but I cant find any (solid) policy grounds to voice my opposition. Could this fit under #DICT as in this is basically a dictionary definition and some examples Deletion of Cutting (in line) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13134 9437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lily Klee User:Coolabahapple 03:49, 7 April 2021 (UTC) comment """can one of the """"keepers"""" above actually say how Lily Klee meets ? being a piano teacher, any awards/significant awards? nope, spouse of a notable artist? nope, parent of a theatrical director? nope, this looks like an example of """ Deletion of Lily Klee WP:ANYBIO||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
13135 10329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jerry Balmuth User:David 00:03, 27 August 2019 (UTC) keep I can't find notability through his publications — he seems to have only single-digit citations on Google Scholar and no books. But as the article makes clear, he held an endowed professorship at Colgate, giving him a pass of #C5. And there's plenty of material to expand the article with at https://news.colgate.edu/scene/2018/02/professor-jerome-jerry-balmuth-a-life-examined.html although (because published by his employer) it doesn't contribute to notability Deletion of Jerry Balmuth WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13136 16734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisolette Gilcrest User:JFHJr 16:09, 15 November 2012 (UTC) delete This subject fails for lack of substantial coverage in reliable sources. She does get lots of mention in lists of names, in somewhat reliable and unreliable sources. But |nothing significant. Going through , sources showed the article contained a lot of puff. The in fact indicate http://eroticsignature.com/joomla2/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=72&Itemid=83 a brief mention, http://www.eroticsignature.com/joomla2/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=74&Itemid=86 her name among 119 artists exhibited, and http://www.eroticsignature.com/joomla2/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=154&Itemid=134 her name in a long list of book prize recipients. There's also her name in a pile of very brief http://thenewsherald.com/articles/2008/10/24/entertainment/doc48ff26c24a56b895355034.txt?viewmode=fullstory entertainment listings, and a minuscule mention in the promotional http://www.realdetroitweekly.com/detroit/stae-and-canvas-february-6-2008/Content?oid=1203282 upcoming event announcement. The first shows she exists; the second can't really support prose on events that hadn't happened as of publication. I found confirmation in the Detroit Free Press that she had an exhibit at a local arts festival, but the coverage was about the festival, and only mentioned this subject. All of this indicates she falls short of both and Deletion of Lisolette Gilcrest WP:GNG||WP:42||WP:BEFORE||WP:LOTSOFSOURCES||WP:CREATIVE||WP:ANYBIO||WP:42 Wikipedia:Notability 77
13137 18451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/86 (term) User:Cnilep 06:53, 19 October 2020 (UTC) delete as not satisfying . Almost all of the cited sources relate to etymology, and the remainder verify usage. No objection to soft redirect to :Wiktionary:eighty-six. I would, however, compare 23 skidoo (phrase). Like ''86'', there is enduring mystery about the origins of ''23'' and ''23 skidoo''. Unlike ''86'', though, ''23 skiddoo'' has added notability as apparently the first slang fad of the twentieth century Deletion of 86 (term) WP:WORDISSUBJECT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
13138 20863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaahin Mohajeri User:Esradekan 11:24, 7 March 2009 (UTC) delete While a COI isn't a reason for deletion, a huge lack of |reliable, third-party, sources is. Fails notability per Deletion of Shaahin Mohajeri WP:RS||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13139 7714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of redundant expressions (2nd nomination) User:Malleus 19:44, 16 June 2008 (UTC) delete Indiscriminate list of non-encyclopedic information, plus apparent |original research Deletion of List of redundant expressions (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13140 12927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Beautiful Letdown (band) User:ShelbyMarion 09:27, 2 June 2018 (UTC) delete Sourcing is problematic, as mentioned previous. Apparent vanity article; author's 4 year edit history is exclusive to pages that are directly related to the promotional interest of this band and related subjects. This article specifically, at best, is Deletion of The Beautiful Letdown (band) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
13141 18180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nic Atkinson User:Guest9999 23:31, 24 March 2008 (UTC) delete does not establish significance. Already |speedyed once today http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&page=Nic_Atkinson Deletion of Nic Atkinson WP:SPEEDY Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
13142 11604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nurarihyon no Mago (3rd nomination) User:DustFormsWords 21:47, 29 September 2009 (UTC) comment """Collectonian's certainly a smart and eloquent editor with a long history of constructive improvement of manga articles on Wikipedia. But her arguments should stand or fall on their own merits; saying """"She's been right before so she's probably right now"""" is no more helpful than saying """"She was wrong those couple of times so she might be wrong now"""". See """ Deletion of Nurarihyon no Mago (3rd nomination) WP:ADHOM Wikipedia:No personal attacks 58
13143 3931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 Alabama Crimson Tide football team User:LM2000 07:48, 17 January 2014 (UTC) delete per Deletion of 2015 Alabama Crimson Tide football team WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13144 118 [[Anna Margareta Wrangel Gräfin von Salmis]] (erledigt, bleibt) Benutzer:Frank Schulenburg NONE keep """Zitat aus den |Löschregeln: ''Folgende Kriterien kommen als Begründung nicht in Frage: Begründungen, die Inhalte grundsätzlich betreffen: Bis auf die unter Was Wikipedia nicht ist aufgeführten Inhalte sollen pauschale Löschanträge wie """"Wollen wir für jedes XY einen Artikel"""" oder """"Artikel über XY gehören nicht in Wikipedia"""" unterbleiben""" Löschung von Anna Margareta Wrangel Gräfin von Salmis Wikipedia:Löschregeln Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13145 10009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fawaz Hussain User:Stammer 09:01, 19 November 2006 (UTC) keep """Googling """"Fawaz Husên"""" yields a couple of hundred hits, most of them in Turkish or Kurdish, often traceable to the subject's literary activity. is clearly relevant here""" Deletion of Fawaz Hussain WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
13146 587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Charlie's prostitution of a child User:Softlavender 05:51, 9 May 2015 (UTC) delete Even the lead asserts no notability whatsoever. Delete per , not-notable, one event, . Most of the coverage in the majority of citations is barely a paragraph in length. This article creator seems sadly bent on creating massive walls of text about insignificant localized events concerning prostitution, events which are better suited for a single journalism article or blog post, not for an encyclopedia. There is nothing remotely encyclopedically relevant in this article, in my opinion Deletion of Stephen Charlie's prostitution of a child WP:ROUTINE||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13147 92 [[Liste der Söhne und Töchter der Stadt Stockholm|Stockholm]] (zurückgezogen) Benutzer:Matthiasb 19:57, 2. Jul. 2007 (CEST) keep Diese Listen sind sinnvolle Auslagerungen aus den Ortsartikeln. Verstoß gegen Löschung von Liste der Söhne und Töchter der Stadt Stockholm|Stockholm Wikipedia:BNS Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
13148 9166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theory of Hitler´s escape User:FrankTobia 19:56, 4 May 2008 (UTC) delete Looks like original research, maybe an essay. It worries me that there are no sources. If this is a notable and verifiable conspiracy theory, we need sources or else it's no better than idle speculation. Generally I agree with M0RD00R's comment, and I feel that it would need a rewrite from the ground up to be a decent article, so a delete wouldn't hurt anyone. At the same time, the facts are pretty hard if they can be supported with references, but even then it still violates Deletion of Theory of Hitler´s escape WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
13149 6819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Humza Bin Masood (2nd nomination) User:AllyD 19:04, 5 November 2015 (UTC) delete A article recreating the biography of a student who is involved in student societies and inter-block speech competitions. No |evidence of attained biographical notability Deletion of Humza Bin Masood (2nd nomination) :WP:SPA||:WP:RS Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
13150 5406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ranveer Allahbadia User:Epinoia 02:24, 9 May 2019 (UTC) delete """promotional article, """"trained so many celebities"""" - does not meet - not notable by any criteria""" Deletion of Ranveer Allahbadia WP:NOTPROMOTION||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13151 12503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acequeen La DeFrancisco user:bluedustmite 16:35, 6 November 2007 (UTC) delete per StarBlind. Utterly lacking in |verifiability. &mdash Deletion of Acequeen La DeFrancisco WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13152 17243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ralph Smart (YouTuber) User:Bearian 18:54, 9 April 2020 (UTC) delete vloggers are |run of the mill, and anybody with a YouTube account can be one. This one seems to be very ordinary, and short of |significant coverage about him Deletion of Ralph Smart (YouTuber) WP:MILL||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
13153 8185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Threadneedles Hotel User:Piotrus 08:27, 26 November 2020 (UTC) delete """The only claim for notability this building has is that it is a Listed building. That warrants a page in Wikidata, and an entry in Wikivoyage, but I am not convinced it also makes the building notable. states """"Buildings, including private residences and commercial developments, may be notable as a result of their historic, social, economic, or architectural importance, but they require significant in-depth coverage by reliable, third-party sources to establish notability."""" Such coverage has not been presented here (there are some claims of minor awards/listings but no references have been given for them so far, making this seem like an ad""" Deletion of Threadneedles Hotel WP:NBUILD Wikipedia:Notability 77
13154 3790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergio Savarese User:Cavarrone 17:28, 18 January 2013 (UTC) keep per above. Passes Deletion of Sergio Savarese WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13155 15827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GB3LH User:Walton_monarchist89 19:55, 19 March 2007 (UTC) delete amateur radio isn't inherently notable, and there are no references to demonstrate multiple non-trivial coverage in independent sources to establish notability per . Delete unless sourced by the end of this AfD Deletion of GB3LH WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13156 21661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Slater User:Gidonb 03:06, 13 August 2010 (UTC) keep to JetBlue Airways Flight 1052 or something of the sort. The incident is notable, yet the person fails Deletion of Steven Slater WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13157 10434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Outbound Cruise User:Sam 07:56, 28 September 2018 (UTC) delete As no entity is clearly defined, G11 does not apply. Looks much more like a test edit of some sort, perhaps related to some NASA venture as Touch-And-Go Camera Systems are mentioned. Suggest deletion under Deletion of Outbound Cruise WP:G2 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
13158 21592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Open source games User:Tuxide 00:56, 27 September 2007 (UTC) comment I never said the subject was notable enough for inclusion; I just didn't bother citing as a reason for deletion. There is already an article called free games which in my opinion is the correct word for what this article is about, but proposing a merge just because I said that would be original research since it doesn't cite the definition either. Since this discussion has already started, I'm not going here Deletion of Open source games WP:N||WP:ALLORNOTHING Wikipedia:Notability 77
13159 9092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barry Sullivan (lawyer) User:Necrothesp 16:33, 22 February 2017 (UTC) keep Appears to hold a named chair at a major university, so passes Deletion of Barry Sullivan (lawyer) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13160 4824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sewing Dragon User:Robertbcole 22:07, 29 November 2006 (UTC) delete Although the above user's argument has a certain appeal, the issue ends up coming down to |verifibility. In the Yeti case, we can verify that there is a notable myth. In this instance, I can find http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&q=%22sewing%20dragon%22&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=wn little evidence to convince me that the Sewing Dragon is a myth subject to significant debate. The article's pictures also leave something to be desired Deletion of Sewing Dragon WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13161 15057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thoudang User:AllyD 17:25, 2 June 2019 (UTC) delete A photo array showing people attending a cinema is far from sufficient to support an article and my searches are not finding any reliable sources to support the article text and demonstrate |notability Deletion of Thoudang :WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
13162 9410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mandy Haberman User:Cuoxo 18:44, 4 March 2021 (UTC) keep Current sources passes Deletion of Mandy Haberman WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13163 9806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blueboy (band) User:LonelyBeacon 09:35, 13 July 2008 (UTC) comment Under #Criteria for musicians and ensembles, criteria 5 & 6 may cover an assertion of notability. I would like to hear what other think. This does not save the need for , but that ''may'' be a starting point. It should also be noted: keep the conversation here related to the AfD, not off-handed swipes at the nominator Deletion of Blueboy (band) WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13164 14671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Babbitt User:Mwalcoff 22:37, 12 November 2005 (UTC) comment I'd like to point out that congressional candidates now meet . Two weeks ago, I suggested on the talk page that congressional and legislative candidates should be considered automatically notable. The only objection was that it should be limited to credible candidates. I went ahead and made the change before reading AfD Thursday. Anyway, it seems to that BIO lists people who should gain automatic recognition but does not claim that anyone not on the list should be deleted Deletion of Paul Babbitt WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13165 12211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of compositions by Franz Liszt (S.1 - S.350) User:Oakshade 05:43, 13 October 2007 (UTC) keep """Just by being a list doesn't mean it """"fails #DIR"""". Perhaps the nom should become acquainted with , not to mention the text of #DIR that clearly states lists are permitted per policy. Franz Liszt (no pun intended) was one of the most prolific and popular composers of the Romantic music|Romantic era and certainly a list of his compositions, which are far too great in number to be included in the Franz Liszt main article, is both 100% encyclopedic and verifiable""" Deletion of List of compositions by Franz Liszt (S.1 - S.350) WP:NOT||WP:LISTS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13166 1248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SilverBuildIT User:Ihcoyc 14:23, 10 October 2011 (UTC) delete Article about ''|a multinational IT Company'' that tells us that ''was started by building web applications for companies'' but ''expanded to making applications for iPhone and Android... and Facebook'' and that the ''founders of the company are a team of entrepreneurs with more than 10 years of experience from IT, Telecom, Finance and Customer Service.'' Yes, but what do these things '''''do'''''? #G11|Unambiguous advertising and #A7|no minimal claim to encyclopedic importance. So tagged Deletion of SilverBuildIT WP:B2B||WP:CSD||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Notability 77
13167 18891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Todd Wider (2nd nomination) User:Sethacus 18:43, 16 September 2007 (UTC) delete as nom, per and failure to show non-trivial coverage of the subject himself Deletion of Todd Wider (2nd nomination) WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13168 18908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bipolar (Rock Band) User:PeterPan23 23:39, 10 April 2006 (UTC) delete Not really notable in the spirit of , but not too far off Deletion of Bipolar (Rock Band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13169 12914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dylan Thomas Trail User:Gidonb 01:43, 6 August 2018 (UTC) keep as clearly |Notable. Per EXIST this trail was notable also before the nomination. That said, thanks for referencing, all Deletion of Dylan Thomas Trail WP:N||WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
13170 20360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michaele Salahi User:Andrewlp1991 19:23, 28 November 2009 (UTC) delete Honestly, how many articles need to be created Deletion of Michaele Salahi WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13171 13259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Staring at the Sun (Grey's Anatomy) User:Rlendog 21:21, 17 February 2012 (UTC) keep or '''redirect''' to season article. With all the serial noms, I do not have time to check each one for notability. But even any that are not notable should be redirected to the season article per Deletion of Staring at the Sun (Grey's Anatomy) WP:TVEP Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
13172 19054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asian Football Hall of Fame User:Pharaoh 19:43, 25 April 2020 (UTC) keep passes per above Deletion of Asian Football Hall of Fame WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13173 7039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 UEFA Super Cup User:Fenix 15:38, 16 June 2015 (UTC) delete per Deletion of 2017 UEFA Super Cup WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13174 15740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zingano BJJ User:Papaursa 02:37, 29 March 2013 (UTC) delete """The sources are either not independent or provide only passing mentions (such as """"so and so of Zingano BJJ fought ...""""). The closest thing I found to coverage of the school itself were the two articles talking about adding well known individuals as the Muay Thai and wrestling coaches, but these were more in the form of press releases (""""for more information contact ...""""). In addition, when I checked the school's website neither of those persons are among the 25 instructors listed (most of whom are blue belts)--although the article mentions them as coaches. Even if they were, it would probably still be a case of , but it might give the school some additional notability. I believe the school itself simply lacks the necessary to meet """ Deletion of Zingano BJJ WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13175 11565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evolution (MMOG) User:Agent 22:08, 25 September 2006 (UTC) comment """The revisions have not persuaded me to change my mind. The lack of notability is highlighted by statements such as """"''The game is still considered to be in the beta stage of development''"""". Smacks of |crystal ball gazing""" Deletion of Evolution (MMOG) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13176 6656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gameplanet User:203 03:40, 1 June 2006 (UTC) keep Does not fail . http://campbelllive.tv3.co.nz/ Google does not define all of human knowledge Deletion of Gameplanet WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
13177 2556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bombshell (Transformers) (2nd nomination) User:Lightburst 21:59, 1 November 2019 (UTC) keep passes with Deletion of Bombshell (Transformers) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13178 17770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fred W. Hunt User:Ironholds 09:40, 26 September 2009 (UTC) delete searches I've made show (as the nom attests) that an AskArt entry (which due to the submitter fails , since it isn't third party or independent) is all there is. This is a comprehensive failure of , without even a single reliable source, let alone multiple ones Deletion of Fred W. Hunt WP:BIO||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13179 5986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bath Fitter User:Tucoxn 23:40, 22 November 2013 (UTC) delete Does not pass Wikipedia:Notability (organizations and companies):the topic has not been the subject of significant coverage in reliable, independent secondary sources. Also, |wikipedia is not a soapbox or means of promotion Deletion of Bath Fitter WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13180 8390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled Spider Man Reboot (2017 film) User:MarnetteD 18:31, 14 March 2015 (UTC) delete per . Some info might be moved to Spider-Man in film#Future but, until there is a confirmed release date, there isn't a reason to have an article or redirect with 2017 in the title Deletion of Untitled Spider Man Reboot (2017 film) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
13181 11122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arabic media User:TimothyBlue 00:11, 26 August 2020 (UTC) delete Article is a combination of and // Deletion of Arabic media WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
13182 9748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Public housing estates in Ping Shan User:Sun8908 15:17, 7 March 2021 (UTC) merge """back to Public housing estates in Ngau Tau Kok and Kowloon Bay. When I heard of """"Ping Shan"""", I could only retreived Ping Shan|the one in Yuen Long, which is not the one specified in this title. Even when searching in Chinese (google:""""平山"""" 香港, google:""""平山"""" 九龍), nothing related can be found except for it being a hiking spot. It is possibly to include those public housing estates in such list article""" Deletion of Public housing estates in Ping Shan WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13183 18423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tarah Loera User:HitroMilanese 13:05, 19 July 2009 (UTC) delete """per nom. 80% of article is blatantly copied from Kids Incorporated. Fails . """"might be working with Larry Rudolph and Britney Spears"""" , """"good friend's with Paris Hilton, Lindsay Lohan, Johnny Depp"""" and """"she's gonna be big"""", what to say about those""" Deletion of Tarah Loera WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13184 10179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henry Alonzo User:Hurricanefan25 16:45, 3 November 2011 (UTC) delete Not enough or sufficient coverage; really not that notable per . In addition, possible |COI here. (see creator Deletion of Henry Alonzo WP:RS||WP:PEOPLE||WP:COI Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13185 11478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/InternetReputation.com User:Cindamuse 06:29, 8 April 2013 (UTC) delete """I've attempted to clean up this article. In essence, it included removing quite a bit of copyvio and press releases used as citations. I can't find a reliable or independent source to support the awards asserted. http://www.internetreputation.com/about/ and http://internetreputation.com/InternetReputation.com_Overview.pdf offered nothing that we can use to support or establish notability. At this point, there are two citations, albeit with questionable reliability. http://entrepreneuropps.com/2013/02/internetreputation-serves-clients-around-the-world/ This source appears as a press release masquerading as an independent article. Same for http://www.reviewharbor.net/internetreputation-com-review-comprehensive-reputation-management-for-everyone/ this source, which is a blog that essentially duplicates content from the organization's website, then closes with """"The Verdict: InternetReputation.com is an award-winning reputation management company that has successfully removed offending information for numerous businesses and individuals."""" Sorry, at this point, there's simply a lack of |significant coverage in reliable and independent sources. Best regards""" Deletion of InternetReputation.com WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13186 15389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Konakovo Power Station NONE NONE keep obviously notable. I don't know why anyone would think that a large power station would not be notable, but a proper would soon have set you straight. The effect of warm water from the station on the lake ecology has been extensively studied Deletion of Konakovo Power Station WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13187 19505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticism of Bill O'Reilly (political commentator) (3rd nomination) User:Ramsquire 00:16, 31 July 2009 (UTC) comment Just as an FYI-- but this is actually the fifth AFD nomination for this article, as there were two others prior to the name change. They can be found rticles for deletion/Criticism of Bill O'Reilly|here and rticles for deletion/Criticism of Bill O'Reilly (2nd nomination)|here. I am not sure how to get them added to the list at the top Deletion of Criticism of Bill O'Reilly (political commentator) (3rd nomination) WP:A||WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
13188 17454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sally Krumdiack User:LiberatorLX 22:51, 2 December 2013 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass Deletion of Sally Krumdiack WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
13189 21485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Esc 2009 User:Davewild 17:53, 11 June 2007 (UTC) delete as per until nearer time when more details can be written Deletion of Esc 2009 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13190 12440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al Fara' User:Lugnuts 16:49, 12 September 2018 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Al Fara' WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13191 1359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Fox Glacier FU-24 crash User:HumanBodyPiloter5 23:03, 14 August 2021 (UTC) keep Seems to fairly easily meet Deletion of 2010 Fox Glacier FU-24 crash WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13192 18885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seattle National Hockey League team User:Fiset35 20:45, 2 July 2013 (UTC) delete by - complete speculation. If the vote is nay on 02 JUL 2013, we likely won't know for weeks where the potential franchise will be anyways Deletion of Seattle National Hockey League team WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13193 9323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Kale User:Kemalcan 09:47, 21 January 2021 (UTC) keep per and co-writing American Woman, in the Canadian Music Hall of Fame Deletion of Jim Kale WP:COMPOSER||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13194 6300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sober Nation User:Kraxler 19:56, 30 July 2015 (UTC) delete promo advert of the website/organization, no in-depth coverage anywhere, the sources are trivial mentions at best, and one is about the alleged founder, but just mentions the name of the org. fails Deletion of Sober Nation WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
13195 11624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Replica manga User:Knowledgekid87 18:40, 29 May 2012 (UTC) delete We cant do much here without sources this fails per and Deletion of Replica manga WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
13196 19312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skos Shuttle (software) User:Gongshow 08:11, 11 October 2017 (UTC) delete I'm unable to find sufficient evidence that this meets or Deletion of Skos Shuttle (software) WP:GNG||WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13197 16398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naturesave trust User:DoubleGrazing 09:30, 4 December 2020 (UTC) delete Unsourced promo piece on a minor corporate greenwashing initiative. Could not find a single RS reference, never mind sigcov. Fails / , and even basic verifiability (beyond the existence of the organisation) is dubious Deletion of Naturesave trust WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13198 4583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Seventh-Day Adventist churches in Jamaica User:Bakazaka 22:21, 31 December 2018 (UTC) delete as Wikipedia is a web hosting service for religious organizations, nor is it a directory. Readers can use Google to find the Adventist directory/yearbook sites, and there's no reason for Wikipedia to serve as a database clone or backup copy of those sites Deletion of List of Seventh-Day Adventist churches in Jamaica WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13199 755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giovanni DonCara User:Shotwell 19:55, 2 December 2006 (UTC) comment I don't think that possible hoax articles can be speedily deleted. #G1 specifically excludes hoaxes (although you've tagged it under G3) and Wikipedia:Hoaxes calls for AfD Deletion of Giovanni DonCara WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
13200 13829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Varley User:Mkativerata 21:10, 6 August 2010 (UTC) delete Obviously fails as an unelected candidate. I can't entertain any real claim to GNG as the coverage does not go beyond very limited mentions in local news on the election. That's not enough for a biography Deletion of Nick Varley WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
13201 10229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Elliot User:Coolabahapple 06:50, 10 December 2016 (UTC) keep """meets , reviews include: ''An Unexpected Light'' - ''New York Times'' - """"''An Unexpected Light'' is often unexpectedly funny and constantly perceptive, but it is also profound.""""http://www.nytimes.com/books/01/04/08/reviews/010408.08goodwit.html, ''Mirrors of the Unseen'' - ''The Guardian'' - """"In these sad and dirty days of demonisation and prejudice few books could be more apposite than Jason Elliot's thoughtful portrait of Iran.""""https://www.theguardian.com/books/2006/apr/22/featuresreviews.guardianreview2; ''The Network'' - ''New York Times'' - """"An unlikely candidate for the espionage genre, Elliot is known primarily for “An Unexpected Light,” a much-praised narrative of his travels in Afghanistan published a decade ago. And here he takes us back to that place and time — the innocent days when the words “Al Qaeda” and “Osama bin Laden” would have drawn blank stares at the water cooler.""""http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/10/books/review/Harshaw-t.html?_r=0; ''The Daily Telegraph|The Telegraph'' - """"Vividly descriptive, wittily discursive, archly plotted and unusually paced, this radiates the charm of an author as curious about the Vauxhall property market as he is about convoluted Afghan politics.""""http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/books/bookreviews/7978087/Genre-Thrillers.html, to mention just a few""" Deletion of Jason Elliot WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13202 5287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam D Brown User:Bearcat 06:11, 1 September 2017 (UTC) delete Nothing here passes a notability criterion, and the sourcing isn't cutting it in the least — he has to be the ''subject'' of the coverage, not just glancingly namechecked in coverage of other things, to pass GNG. Wikipedia also does not ''owe'' anybody an article, as the creator seems to think. Also, I share the view expressed above that there's a fairly obvious |conflict of interest here Deletion of Adam D Brown WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
13203 11457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ICity User:Rosguill 22:47, 2 June 2020 (UTC) keep there's an ok amount of coverage in Russian-language sources such as TASS, although a lot of it cleaves a bit too close to just quoting press releases published elsewhere. Might be a case of . Merging content to Moscow International Business Center, where the towers are located, is another option. signed Deletion of ICity WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
13204 202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kimi no Naka de Odoritai User:Esradekan 12:28, 23 May 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of Kimi no Naka de Odoritai WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13205 12737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John F. Ashby User:DiamondRemley39 20:28, 15 November 2020 (UTC) comment He does not meet the general notability guideline. Two sources from the same publication count as one. One of those pieces isn't significant coverage anyway. His employer's piece on him cannot be considered independent coverage. Biographical topics that don't qualify for specific notability guidelines should meet . For all the keep votes here, it seems I'm the only one who looked for/found anything since the AfD started. Someone else look now and make us look fools--make us want to change our votes. Until then, no reason to keep this as a standalone article Deletion of John F. Ashby WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13206 133 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Adana Fen Lisesi """Kullanıcı:goktr001goktr-""" 14:03, 8 Ağustos 2009 (UTC) keep Tabii içerisindeki abartılı bilgiler çıkarılması şartıyla... 'un 6. maddesi gereğince kalmalı...--User:Sabri76|'''Sαвяí¢αи76'''User Talk:Sabri76|'''ileti Adana Fen Lisesinin silinmesi Vikipedi:OKUL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13207 11242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spanish language rock and roll User:FisherQueen 13:20, 14 April 2007 (UTC) delete This is kind of an |indiscriminate collection of information, isn't it Deletion of Spanish language rock and roll WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13208 13091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Super Sirloin User:Are 20:33, 25 August 2010 (UTC) delete no independent reliable sources establish independent notability. Fails and Deletion of Super Sirloin WP:GNG||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13209 19080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vossed User:Spongefrog 20:17, 5 December 2009 (UTC) delete I don't think it's quite blatant enough to fall under |G3 (pure vandalism), but it definitely comes under . Maybe even Deletion of Vossed WP:G3||WP:NEO||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
13210 4769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The French Democracy (2nd nomination) User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:04, 30 January 2009 (UTC) keep IMDB does not confer notability. Plenty of Reliable Sources have. No need to delete as it is now a matter of Deletion of The French Democracy (2nd nomination) WP:CLEANUP Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
13211 14534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diligence User:Bearian 21:14, 15 March 2011 (UTC) keep per Col. Warden, and based on - see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sisu, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Velleity, and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chaos. Core concepts are kept, rather than deleted or sent to WikiSiberia Deletion of Diligence WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13212 19903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Australian National Judo Championships User:Mattinbgn 21:39, 22 October 2010 (UTC) keep Clearly the national championships of an Olympic sport is an encyclopedic topic. Tests such as Google News searches are pretty pointless in my opinion and quite frankly the lazy man's AfD argument. Believe it or not, the world contains much more than Google knows. NOTSTATS does not apply here either for the simple reason that the article is '''not''' a table of statistics! It is a table listing the winners of events and it is not indiscriminate - there are clear criteria for inclusion. The article is clearly referenced and I can't see a valid reason for deletion. is not a valid reason for deletion. Having said all that, the article could be improved and some context added but we don't delete articles simply because they need improvement Deletion of Australian National Judo Championships WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13213 15794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geomajas User:Joe 02:37, 6 February 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of Geomajas WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13214 2722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Periodicity User:Tavix 21:06, 30 January 2016 (UTC) keep as |useful. The disambiguation is used thousands of times a month and someone would definitely be looking for one of those topics. Deletion would be harmful as it would be harder for someone to get to one of those topics Deletion of Periodicity WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
13215 5103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Curb mining User:Colonel 17:34, 29 August 2013 (UTC) keep I recall reading that happens in Japan, where bulky items are put out for disposal. The topic(s) should be retained for reuse and recycling per , rather than being hauled off to the dump immediately Deletion of Curb mining WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
13216 16045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dheeraj Singh Moirangthem User:Royroydeb 15:31, 11 October 2017 (UTC) delete Simply fails . Player is yet to play in a fully pro league Deletion of Dheeraj Singh Moirangthem WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13217 13586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebecca Sommer User:SkyGazer 14:47, 4 June 2018 (UTC) keep A quick https://www.google.com/search?source=hp&ei=bk8VW4jqFsnYtQWBjpDoCQ&q=Rebecca+Sommer&oq=Rebecca+Sommer&gs_l=psy-ab.3..0l7j0i10k1j0l2.1709.1709.0.2108.1.1.0.0.0.0.118.118.0j1.1.0....0...1c.2.64.psy-ab..0.1.117....0.cLS-diV07fs Google search shows many independent sources that cover this topic significantly, so it seems to meet . I do agree that the wording is promotional, and the layout is very messy. However, it does seem notable, and if we can get the article cleaned up I think it would make a great addition to Wikipedia. I'm going to try to clean it up some Deletion of Rebecca Sommer WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13218 17087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctoranytime User:Nosebagbear 20:46, 15 June 2019 (UTC) comment ping|Elberoin}} - what sources do you think demonstrate is satisfied Deletion of Doctoranytime WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13219 493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MusicMaster (music notation software) User:Haakon 18:55, 24 November 2009 (UTC) delete per nom; promotional for non-notable product by |SPA Deletion of MusicMaster (music notation software) WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
13220 6831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Lim User:Darthgriz98 18:44, 1 April 2007 (UTC) delete violates and the subject does not seem notable Deletion of Larry Lim WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
13221 19327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohamed Sadek User:NZ 17:46, 7 January 2018 (UTC) keep meets having played in a professional league Deletion of Mohamed Sadek WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13222 8076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rakesh Reddy User:Bearcat 15:19, 9 September 2017 (UTC) delete Being a political party spokesman is not an automatic notability freebie in the absence of enough |reliable source coverage about the person to clear — but exactly ''zero'' of the references here are to reliable or notability-assisting sources Deletion of Rakesh Reddy WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13223 6568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gregory Smith (Child Prodigy) User:Edison 03:51, 17 July 2011 (UTC) delete as failing . The Nobel claims should be removed if not better documented Deletion of Gregory Smith (Child Prodigy) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13224 7620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plymouth pine User:Seicer 16:05, 5 April 2007 (UTC) delete Per nom, Deletion of Plymouth pine WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
13225 6345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jon Leuer User:Cindamuse 16:31, 30 October 2010 (UTC) comment You can find more information about notability for college athletes Wikipedia:Notability_(sports)#College_athletes|here. You can also find more information |here. Please make sure to sign your comments and posts on Wikipedia with four tildes ~~~~. Thanks Deletion of Jon Leuer WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13226 8545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Liddicoat User:Adamtt9 18:04, 14 February 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Sean Liddicoat WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13227 1163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Website Baker User:Kylohk 00:59, 4 August 2007 (UTC) delete The article fails , since I can't find any independent non-trivial reliable sources on the Internet (just its official website and countless download pages). The live demo link the article provides is not functioning as well, so this software is not notable Deletion of Website Baker WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
13228 1893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allie Marie Evans User:GrammarFascist 00:41, 20 August 2017 (UTC) delete """There's coverage of both her acting (mostly about her role in ''Maximum Ride'') and her earlier """"beauty vlogging"""" (which I guess is a thing?) but seemingly nothing substantial, and it's largely dubiously-reliable sources, though there were some exceptions (e.g. ''LA Times''). Maybe just """ Deletion of Allie Marie Evans WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
13229 18309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Knightmare Frame User:Craw 22:51, 30 June 2008 (UTC) delete All of the reasons that Collectonian gives are valid. Non-primary sources have been difficult to find in my searches (clarification: |reliable non-primary sources, i.e. not youtube, other wikis, or fan sites). Tranwiki to a more appropriate place if desired Deletion of Knightmare Frame WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13230 20036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billion Surprise Toys User:K 16:12, 24 August 2019 (UTC) delete fails & Deletion of Billion Surprise Toys WP:NORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13231 301 [[Merb (Webframework)]] (gelöscht) NONE NONE delete Relevanz und Verbreitung wird nicht dargelegt. Artikel folgt nur ansatzweise den Anforderungen aus . So . Löschung von Merb (Webframework) Wikipedia:Richtlinien Software Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
13232 16152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Schelske (2nd nomination) User:Ttonyb1 23:15, 23 May 2011 (UTC) delete ndash; Failed politician lacking GHits and GNEWS of substance. Fails and Deletion of Craig Schelske (2nd nomination) WP:BIO||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
13233 3623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hunter Ligon User:Trident13 21:50, 1 April 2007 (UTC) delete self written bio, need I say more? Also, sources are poor and resultantly fails . Rgds Deletion of Hunter Ligon WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13234 15144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camp Minsi User:Stifle 18:05, 14 October 2007 (UTC) delete Amazingly detailed but still of questionabe notability. Furthermore, there do not appear to be any references to |verify the article Deletion of Camp Minsi WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13235 11205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Girls Kissing Girls User:Cavarrone 07:40, 16 December 2011 (UTC) comment All the above discussion is futile and a little bizarre, as it tries to apply WP:PORN'''BIO''' on something that is not a '''BIO'''... We have only a guideline for films and it is . It requires Awards, not nominations Deletion of Girls Kissing Girls WP:NOTFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
13236 9518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Buntine User:Bearian 21:01, 9 May 2016 (UTC) keep per . This article has been shown to be notable enough Deletion of Robert Buntine WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
13237 4511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007 New Hampshire General Court Session User:Amarrg 17:35, 14 November 2007 (UTC) delete The article fails #INFO 2.9.4 and does not seem to convey anything meaningful to the general reader Deletion of 2007 New Hampshire General Court Session WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13238 19481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ralph Mercier User:S 12:12, 15 February 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Ralph Mercier WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13239 1561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irit Rosenblum User:BusterD 22:29, 9 July 2012 (UTC) merge to New Family Organization. Presented references insufficient, IMHO, to pass or ; a reasonable search finds nothing directly detailing, but other more determined searchers may find something which meets WP:IRS. I think a merge is the best option Deletion of Irit Rosenblum WP:BIO||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13240 1874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/On The Clock Draft User:ColourBurst 19:21, 29 September 2006 (UTC) delete as |vanispamcruftisement Deletion of On The Clock Draft WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
13241 14602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Universal Mobile Interface User:AleatoryPonderings 15:40, 11 August 2020 (UTC) delete or '''redirect''' to mobile operating system (not a fantastic target, but thought I'd suggest it in any case). It's a that hasn't been picked up Deletion of Universal Mobile Interface WP:NEOLOGISM Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
13242 3257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antler-Subway Records User:ThePointblank 06:25, 31 October 2008 (UTC) delete As per . I do not see a third party article on the record company, nor do I see a reason why it is notable Deletion of Antler-Subway Records WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13243 9681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arfeen Khan User:Shruti14 19:49, 17 August 2007 (UTC) delete currently fails Deletion of Arfeen Khan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13244 16234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Escape to donegal User:Cerebellum 22:13, 6 December 2009 (UTC) merge with Alan Cumming per Deletion of Escape to donegal WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13245 1074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prosa SA/SD/RT Modeller User:Seraphimblade 23:27, 2 December 2013 (UTC) delete while I initially intended to close this discussion, the discussion got too off-track to really have a good result. Having done my own evaluation of the sources, the sources cited are either instruction manuals, or mentions in passing in sources which are not ''about'' this software, but only mention and perhaps briefly review it as one possible piece of software that does this. Passing mentions do not establish |notability and are insufficient to sustain a full article, and the length of time the software has been around is irrelevant to that as well. While not in itself a reason to delete, the article currently reads like a glossy brochure, and the dearth of reference material makes this largely unfixable Deletion of Prosa SA/SD/RT Modeller WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13246 10837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Don Bluth's unrealized projects User:StraussInTheHouse 22:02, 7 March 2019 (UTC) delete GameSpot and Polygon aren't exactly the gold standard of sourcing but they're the most reliable citations we've got in this article. If all the content which references |unreliable sources such as Imgur and TVTropes is removed, we're left with so little content it might as well be redirected to Don Bluth. A |dynamite case methinks Deletion of Don Bluth's unrealized projects WP:UNRELIABLE||WP:DYNAMITE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13247 19755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karina Pinilla User:Bearian 17:35, 11 September 2014 (UTC) comment she |might be notable enough, but right now there's not enough evidence of English sources. Can we userfy this page Deletion of Karina Pinilla WP:BARE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13248 20357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philosphy of everything User:Kzollman 02:43, 5 October 2005 (UTC) delete as |original research --best, kevin Deletion of Philosphy of everything WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13249 1377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Plummer User:Amisom 14:35, 8 May 2017 (UTC) delete not seeing any |significant coverage in reliable source Deletion of Mike Plummer WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
13250 15651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlo Kemp User:Paulmcdonald 22:02, 7 June 2019 (UTC) delete no coverage exists that I can find to suggest passing and the article doesn't suggest that it could be found. Subject may achieve notability in the future so no prejudice to re-create at that time Deletion of Carlo Kemp WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13251 3294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Georgia Ann Laster User:Whisperjanes 19:38, 4 November 2020 (UTC) keep Plenty of in-depth coverage in newspapers to pass Deletion of Georgia Ann Laster WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13252 11931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paolo Puddu User:AllyD 07:10, 5 October 2016 (UTC) delete An article on a poet publishing through print-on-demand self-publisher :Lulu (company). No |reliable 3rd party sources provided or found. Fails all and broader criteria Deletion of Paolo Puddu :WP:RS||:WP:NAUTHOR||:WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13253 16963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2023 Formula One World Championship User:Eagleash 12:35, 15 April 2020 (UTC) delete Much 'too soon' and ; not enough available information at this time Deletion of 2023 Formula One World Championship :WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13254 15815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Changes (band) User:Northamerica1000 12:49, 7 January 2014 (UTC) keep The Changes (band) as meeting . Then merge Today Is Tonight into the The Changes (band) article Deletion of The Changes (band) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13255 21293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solar system warming User:A 17:14, 27 February 2007 (UTC) delete """Very'' misleading article. Although referenced, the credible references like NASA, astronomy.com and the journal Nature, ''never'' talk about a """"theory of solar system warming"""". Absolutely unacceptable. As the nom points out, this is textbook """ Deletion of Solar system warming WP:SYNT Wikipedia:No original research 65
13256 5614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ted & Ralph User:pd_THOR 16:37, 15 October 2008 (UTC) delete This article is mostly constitutive of |unreferenced |plot reiteration and |personal interpretation. There is not evidence of this topic having received significant coverage in Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable Wikipedia:No original research#Primary, secondary, and tertiary sources|secondary sources that are Wikipedia:Verifiability#Sources|independent of the subject as stipulated by the |notability guideline Deletion of Ted & Ralph WP:V||WP:PLOT||WP:OR||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13257 9540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wokai User:TheAsianGURU 16:47, 22 September 2008 (UTC) delete Per otability & maybe even Deletion of Wokai WP:N||WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13258 24 [[Sandrina Zander]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:MBq NONE keep Das Jugendarbeitsschutzgesetz erlaubt Ausnahmen für Schauspieler http://bundesrecht.juris.de/jarbschg/__6.html. - , da wesentliche Rolle in einer Fernsehserie (#Schauspieler Löschung von Sandrina Zander Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
13259 5964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cookham Reach Sailing Club User:jamesslong NONE keep """Per . I read other Wiki entries for sailing clubs before creating this page and structured it in the same way, providing the same sort of information. When the article is about a club it is hard not to write an article about the club without including """"advertising"""" information, because that is the nature of the organisation - information about it provides detail about what it does. Reference - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Ship_Club. If you believe I need to change the content format, please can you suggest what I change? I will add more external references to the club as suggested""" Deletion of Cookham Reach Sailing Club WP:NOTADVERTISING Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13260 11672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Digital Times User:DeniedClub 02:16, 21 December 2018 (UTC) delete per nom. search only brought up small mentions. Could not find anything that would meet . If someone can read Russian they ''might'' be able to find a better source Deletion of Digital Times WP:BEFORE||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13261 15597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dish monkey User:Hrafn 04:49, 3 January 2011 (UTC) delete article is simply a of a minor slang phrase Deletion of Dish monkey WP:DICTDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
13262 17762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giorgos Fountoulis User:Dlohcierekim 16:24, 3 December 2013 (UTC) delete WP:BLP1E|They are just not notable for even one event Perhaps one or two lines on a general terrorism article, such as Terrorism in Greece. |Wikipedia is not a memorial, and this does not improve the encyclopedia Deletion of Giorgos Fountoulis WP:MEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13263 376 [[Französische Annexionspläne]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Assayer NONE delete Der Artikel genügt nicht den qualitativen Anforderungen von Wikipedia. Der Lemmatitel entspricht nicht dem Artikelinhalt. Nähme man die Definition des Lemmas ernst, müßte man das Lemma: ''Versuche Frankreichs Gebietsteile sic! im Osten zu annektieren'' nennen, was ansich nicht lemmafähig wäre. Um Annexions''pläne'' geht es im Artikel nun gerade nicht. Zum einen, weil hier eine reine Ereignisgeschichte geboten wird; zum anderen weil bspw. koloniale Annexionspläne gar nicht erwähnt werden (und nach der Lemmadefinition auch gar nicht dazu gehören würden). In einem Parforceritt durch vier Jahrhunderte (unter rätselhafter Ausklammerung des 19. Jhds., womit sowohl Napoleon, Napoleon III. als auch der Deutsch-Französische Krieg unter den Tisch fallen) und unter frappanter Ignorierung jeglichen historischen Kontextes, worunter man bspw. die Problematik der Nationalstaatenbildung in Mitteleuropa vor, während und nach dem 19. Jahrhundert abhandeln müßte, wird eine quasi überhistorische Politik Frankreichs konstruiert. So als ob es eine ungebrochene, lineare Entwicklung von Ludwig XIV. zu de Gaulle geben würde. Statt einer differenzierten Darstellung von Befürwortern und Gegnern werden die ''Annexionspläne'' ohnehin nur mit ''Frankreich'' identifiziert. In dieser Form handelt es sich um TF. Denn eine solche Darstellung findet sich nicht in historischer Sekundärliteratur. Dementsprechend stützt sich der Artikel auf eine Studienarbeit, belegt einen einfachen Satz wie ''Bei den Friedensverhandlungen 1919 in Versailles strebte der französische Ministerpräsident Georges Clemenceau für sein Land die Rheingrenze an.'' mit einmal 96 und einmal 80 Seiten Sekundärliteratur (man darf vermuten, dass die Darstellung dort differenzierter war), und belegt ansonsten mit einem erratischen Zitat, und zwei Spiegel-Artikel (von 1959 und 1947). Unter den Weblinks findet man eine Website, die nicht genügt, und auf der man so informative Sätze findet wie: ''Die Franosen sic gingen äußerst raffiniert vor, um doch noch in den Besitz der beanspruchten Gebiete zu gelangen. Sie setzten ihre Hoffnung nicht auf militärische Gewaltaktionen oder auf die Besetzung, sondern sie wählten den scheinbar legalen Weg, indem sie ordentliche Gerichtsverfahren vor eigens eingerichteten Reunionskammern durchführen ließen. Mit diesem verfassungsrechtlich höchst fragwürdigen Trick sollten die französischen Ansprüche auf Reichsterritorium durchgesetzt werden, um das traditionelle Ziel der französischen Außenpolitik, die Gewinnung der Rheingrenze, zu realisieren. Die Krönung dieser dreisten Politik war die Annexion der urdeutschen Stadt Straßburg im Jahr 1681.'' (Das ist dann so in etwa der POV von 1899). Der Text von Thomas Höpel wäre brauchbar, wurde aber entweder nicht ausgewertet oder ignoriert. Jedenfalls findet sich im Artikel nichts über die französischen Grenzkonzepte oder etwa über Ersuchen linksrheinischer Gemeinden um Angliederung. Statt Überarbeiten, Lückenhaft und Neutralitätsbaustein zu setzen, plädiere ich deshalb für Löschung von Französische Annexionspläne Wikipedia:WEB Wikipedia:External links 76
13264 11405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Open Organization User:Joe 23:44, 2 August 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Open Organization WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13265 20469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brigid Hanrahan User:Aoziwe 12:32, 7 January 2017 (UTC) keep Borderline wikipedia technical general notability but works being held by the NGA I suggest confirms notability. NGA holding meets / Deletion of Brigid Hanrahan WP:CREATIVE||WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
13266 6072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judith Blegen & Frederica von Stade: Songs, Arias & Duets User:Niggle1892 12:30, 22 September 2019 (UTC) keep per The article's COPYVIO issue has now been addressed - brief quotes from reviews will be added in due course. See ''Opera'', July 2011, p. 670 for further discussion Deletion of Judith Blegen & Frederica von Stade: Songs, Arias & Duets WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
13267 6755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Narcissistic nationalism [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] 13:06, 11 June 2017 (UTC) delete Fails as a coherent subject. There are a couple of books that define it differently than it's current passing usage. Appears to be nothing more that an occasionally-used label lacking a consistent definition Deletion of Narcissistic nationalism WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13268 12820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Imran Khan (cricketer, born 1991) User:SportingFlyer 19:22, 27 February 2021 (UTC) delete scorecards (the entire scope of referencing in the article) do not pass Deletion of Imran Khan (cricketer, born 1991) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13269 14079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ਗਾਲ਼ਾ User:Armbrust 16:25, 2 May 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of ਗਾਲ਼ਾ WP:NOTDICTIONARY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13270 5889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert G. Allen (author) (2nd nomination) User:A 01:29, 4 January 2010 (UTC) keep An advertisement? The tone is not promotional. Does not fulfill any purpose? The purpose is to provide encyclopedic coverage of a prominent author. AfD is not for cleanup. Notability concerns are not raised, but because they were in the first AfD: The subject of this article meets easily; as a matter of fact, he has http://www.amazon.com/Biography-Allen-Robert-Contemporary-Authors/dp/B0007SJU38/ref=sr_1_14?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1225860025&sr=1-14 an entry at Gale Contemporary Authors Deletion of Robert G. Allen (author) (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13271 19699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Pokémon items User:Peregrine 23:24, 9 March 2007 (UTC) keep per , , , #PAPER. Actually, keep because there is no reason to delete it. Listcruft is the reason given, I guess they mean #Wikipedia is_not_an indiscriminate collection of information. This is not indiscriminate, and it's not a game guide. I wish a real reason had been given so that I could address it. Hopefully I guessed what you meant by listcruft Deletion of List of Pokémon items WP:SUMMARY||WP:LIST||WP:POKEMON||WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Summary style 34
13272 17142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My.BarackObama.com User:Hu12 02:08, 24 August 2007 (UTC) delete or Redirect '''Merge''' to Barack Obama. otability#Notability_is_not_temporary. Should be at most be a section on the Barack Obama. Sadly only Notable as a result of Barack Obama's election run. Short burst of present news coverage about a topic does not necessarily constitute objective evidence of long-term notability. I see no evidence predating 2007 that long term coverage has been sufficiently demonstrated for Notability Deletion of My.BarackObama.com WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13273 10576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ITM Power User:Xanchester 23:08, 25 October 2012 (UTC) keep Significant coverage by reliable secondary sources. Company has been given detailed coverage by the ''The Economist|Economist'' and the ''http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/7496331.stm BBC''. Meets the |general notability guideline and |the notability guideline for organisations Deletion of ITM Power WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13274 3179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kranuan F.C. User:Fenix 11:20, 12 September 2017 (UTC) delete fails , has not participated in a national competition. Not seeing any indication of wider GNG ad would not expect to see much more than |routine match reporting for a club playing in a low level regional league Deletion of Kranuan F.C. WP:FOOTYN||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13275 4046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fighter X [[User Talk:Blaxthos|t]] / [[Special:Contributions/Blaxthos|c]] ) 20:34, 31 August 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and . / USER:Blaxthos|Blaxthos Deletion of Fighter X WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13276 9657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 FIFA World Cup broadcasting rights User:Mrschimpf 20:57, 28 June 2018 (UTC) keep 66 sources, done for every Cup since 1998. doesn't apply to the layman (we've got plenty of articles here I could argue the same, but someone else likes them and sources them well, so I won't take them to deletion); we've got sourcing and any vandalism is reverted quickly Deletion of 2018 FIFA World Cup broadcasting rights WP:IDLI Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13277 1138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farm Fresh To You [[User talk:NukeThePukes|Allons!]] 22:57, 7 July 2016 (UTC) delete No significant coverage, no sense of notability beyond the local area and no proof of notability within it. |Wikipedia is still not a web host. ''' ''Nha Trang Deletion of Farm Fresh To You WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13278 322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryos (DJ) User:Paulmcdonald 19:35, 23 September 2016 (UTC) delete supporting speedy. Violates , a long-established guideline. Wikipedia is not a free web hosting server Deletion of Ryos (DJ) WP:ADV Wikipedia:External links 76
13279 7799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jolanta Bledaite User:AngelOfSadness 21:05, 1 June 2008 (UTC) delete as they are only notable for |one event - their death Deletion of Jolanta Bledaite WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
13280 13854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Corvino on Homosexuality User:discospinster 23:15, 26 July 2006 (UTC) delete per Ptkfgs. It's all |original research that keeps getting re-created under different titles Deletion of John Corvino on Homosexuality WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13281 13483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Hindori [[User talk:TheRedPenOfDoom|TRPoD aka The Red Pen of Doom]] 20:00, 11 November 2015 (UTC) keep """if I read this right, https://books.google.com/books?id=u7nKehGDofUC&pg=PA109&dq=George+Hindori+suriname&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CCUQ6AEwAGoVChMI_YfnjpOJyQIVyz4mCh2aUQS7#v=onepage&q=Hindori%20OR%20hindori's&f=false Hindori was a politician of the national parliament of Suriname and thus merits inclusion under . he also merited a biographical entry here https://books.google.com/books?id=NF1sAAAAMAAJ&dq=George+Hindori+suriname&focus=searchwithinvolume&q=Hindori+OR+hindori%27s (although in the snippet view, its hard to see anything particularly notable) but google translate says this source https://books.google.com/books?id=fD5KAAAAYAAJ&q=George+Hindori+suriname&dq=George+Hindori+suriname&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CE0Q6AEwB2oVChMI_YfnjpOJyQIVyz4mCh2aUQS7 says """"What is hard is the fact that in the history of the independent genesis of Suriname, the breakthrough came when the one Hindustani, George Hindori, with the Creole block came along. And the history of the independent""" Deletion of George Hindori WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13282 14346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Piers Morgan Tonight episodes User:Soxwon 23:19, 4 February 2011 (UTC) delete Per nom, there is no reason to list every appearance. To do so seems |crufty Deletion of List of Piers Morgan Tonight episodes WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
13283 2120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/White Cap Marine Towing and Salvage User:Stalwart111 02:36, 6 August 2014 (UTC) delete """the problem is that the NYTimes article is (quite clearly) from the """"N.Y. / Region"""" section of the paper. It benefits from the rigorous editorial standards of the NYTimes but it is unquestionably local in focus. In that context, the NYTimes is the same as any other local or regional paper covering subjects of interest to locals. It's disingenuous to suggest that local coverage of a local subject is """"international"""" or """"national"""" in that context. The NBC source doesn't even mention the subject - it mentions the owner in the context of an article that couldn't possibly be considered significant coverage of the subject in any context. There's clearly not enough for the subject to pass """ Deletion of White Cap Marine Towing and Salvage WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
13284 10114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Champion User:Cloth 14:21, 6 September 2006 (UTC) delete as |unverifiable, unnotable. I was a KCL student at this time and anyone (like me) who wasn't seriously into the intricacies of student union politics and sub-politics won't have come across him Deletion of Michael Champion WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13285 11167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Singapore Sea Brothers User:Alba 03:40, 11 October 2006 (UTC) comment Top 30 of ''what''? That is an assertion of |notability, but for it to be valid you must show third-party documentation -- someone else's website showing that your website is popular. '''Abstain''' until notability is established or disproven Deletion of Singapore Sea Brothers WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
13286 1152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glenn Fisher User:CAPTAIN 19:47, 15 March 2017 (UTC) delete Does not meet Deletion of Glenn Fisher WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13287 10133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick John Bernard Jellicoe, 3rd Earl Jellicoe User:Tyrenon 05:26, 4 June 2009 (UTC) delete """per above. Pre-1999 there would be the """"seat in the national legislature"""" argument (which is based on implied notability...which is another issue altogether), but after then that doesn't exist. Thus in this case this article fails """ Deletion of Patrick John Bernard Jellicoe, 3rd Earl Jellicoe WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13288 7168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The ABC's of being Me User:RGTraynor 13:11, 22 May 2007 (UTC) delete fails . Amazon sales rank of #807,847, which pretty much sucks for a recently released book Deletion of The ABC's of being Me WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
13289 6308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fraser Hobday User:Taketa 15:53, 28 October 2014 (UTC) delete WP:GNG, - Has not played in a fully professional league, has not played in a senior international match. Lacks significant coverage in reliable secondary sources Deletion of Fraser Hobday WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13290 18140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Varadarasanar User:Eric 02:17, 18 April 2009 (UTC) keep But make it a stub, until someone decides to improve it, or rather write a proper article. The article creator apparently http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Sureshmaran “retired” soon after he http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Varadarasanar&action=history created the article. The problem is not only with the lack of refs., but also incomplete sentences and apparently incorrect information. This http://books.google.com/books?q=Varadarasanar Google Books search suggests that the subject probably passes , not as much by the number of hits, but by the nature of several of the references to the subject Deletion of Varadarasanar WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13291 15210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ralph Alvarez User:Ronbo76 06:24, 11 January 2007 (UTC) keep The second external link is for the Forbes profile on this corporate president which meets the first criterion of this ''person has been the primary subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the person''. Also meets Deletion of Ralph Alvarez WP:BIO||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Notability 77
13292 17691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor Who campfire trailer User:Rlendog 20:42, 1 October 2009 (UTC) keep Agree that it is unusual that a trailer would be notable. On the other hand, this trailer did receive coverage in multiple sources, so appears to meet |the general notability requirements. And it managed to be promoted to a good article, so even if the notability is less than normal, I'd give the benefit of the doubt to not deleting a GA. And anyway, I'm not sure deletion is appropriate at all - given the significant sourced content, at worst a merge should be considered (even the nom seems to acknowledge this). For which a merge discussion would be more appropriate than AfD. But, given its GA status, I don't even think we should consider merging unless it fails a GAR. And if merged, the content would still remain due to the sourced content, so given that it at least has marginal notability based on significant coverage in multiple reliable sources, I think keeping this one makes most sense Deletion of Doctor Who campfire trailer WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13293 12642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ewald series User:Tokyogirl79 06:04, 8 April 2013 (UTC) delete There are plenty of and otherwise unusable sources out there to show that this book series exists, but existing is not notability. () We need coverage in reliable sources, which doesn't exist Deletion of Ewald series WP:PRIMARY||WP:ITEXISTS Wikipedia:No original research 65
13294 7137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WISEPC J234841.10-102844.4 User:Mike 16:43, 13 March 2013 (UTC) delete """Unless """"significant coverage"""" in multiple, non-trivial published works exists for one or more of these brown dwarfs, there is no justification for keeping these articles per . (Admittedly though, I only searched for sources on two of the brown dwarfs listed, so I cannot confirm the lack of sources for all.) The content is quite specific to the individual brown dwarfs, so I don't see anything sufficiently generalized that could be merged to the main brown dwarf page. There is also a List of brown dwarfs, but the items to which a list article provides links should be sufficiently notable to have their own WP articles. Otherwise such a list will devolve into a massive collection of red links that are largely non-notable""" Deletion of WISEPC J234841.10-102844.4 WP:NASTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13295 13909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robbie Brady User:Carioca 20:01, 21 September 2010 (UTC) delete he fails and Deletion of Robbie Brady WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13296 17627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of ancient Jedi (2nd nomination) User:Ultraexactzz 21:19, 14 January 2013 (UTC) comment Wait a tic, are you saying that List of Star Wars characters (the article you tagged) should be deleted? Or that the redirect List of ancient Jedi should be deleted? Or both? If it's the redirect, you need to head over to |Redirects for discussion Deletion of List of ancient Jedi (2nd nomination) WP:RFD Wikipedia:Redirect 56
13297 11454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comic Book Rumbles User:Just 16:54, 31 December 2005 (UTC) delete blatant |vanispamcruftvertisement Deletion of Comic Book Rumbles WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
13298 14037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Jewish heavy metal musicians User:Griswaldo 13:24, 1 December 2010 (UTC) delete Non-notable intersection amounting to vanity and trivia listcruft. Also a violation of Deletion of List of Jewish heavy metal musicians WP:BLPCAT Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13299 256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taxpayers’ Choice Debt Reduction Act [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 04:41, 24 February 2013 (UTC) delete """as with the other related AFDs, the standard to be applied is and in this case I don't think the subject passes. I couldn't find a single """"news"""" items on the subject, just legislative registries (routine), a couple of blogs (non-|RS) and WP mirrors""" Deletion of Taxpayers’ Choice Debt Reduction Act WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13300 18522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Easy Electronics User:ST47 16:45, 18 August 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and as per , , Deletion of Easy Electronics WP:OR||WP:NPOV||WP:VANITY Wikipedia:No original research 65
13301 1443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of minor Star Wars droids User:Seraphimblade 18:32, 8 February 2007 (UTC) delete """and as to previous keep, note that the sources must be multiple, non-trivial, '''reliable''', and independent-this is not a """"pick any three"""", said sources must satisfy '''all four'''. Star Wars fandom coverage would not be reliable sourcing, and therefore fails. The two """"external links"""" cited don't remotely begin to satisfy the |reliability guidelines. However, I'm entirely willing to change my opinion if such sources can be found. Anyone !voting """"keep"""" should be prepared to cite sources, and be prepared to show or argue why those sources are independent (not affiliated with the Star Wars franchise), non-trivial (cover the subject in a sufficient depth for an encyclopedia article), and reliable (written by a source which is subject to editorial control or academic peer review.) I love Star Wars, but this just doesn't belong here""" Deletion of List of minor Star Wars droids WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13302 20460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Being professional User:Northamerica1000 17:03, 11 March 2016 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Being professional WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13303 12632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon Radley (surgeon) User:Jfdwolff 20:25, 13 December 2011 (UTC) delete Typical CV for a succesful surgeon. This article does not explain why he should have an article more than the several hundred British surgeons who have a similar career. I have a number of publications to my name. Does that make me notable? No. Doesn't pass Deletion of Simon Radley (surgeon) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13304 3363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jorge Gotor Blas User:MbahGondrong 17:39, 5 May 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Jorge Gotor Blas WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13305 2209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K. K. Dodds User:Canley 10:43, 13 March 2007 (UTC) keep Not sure I agree with the assertion that minimal information fails . Fairly borderline notability, but has a small recurring role of note in ''Prison Break'', and several major movie credits (small roles however Deletion of K. K. Dodds WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13306 2328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darwin Brown User:Canadian 21:24, 24 January 2009 (UTC) delete per . It's pretty much all been said. Cheers Deletion of Darwin Brown WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13307 17405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Lennon User:Agent 21:03, 9 February 2007 (UTC) keep If one were to remove all reference to his father and mother, the article would still contain plenty of info that satisfies Deletion of Sean Lennon WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13308 17237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The One (Mariah Carey song) User:Esradekan 08:02, 16 February 2009 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability per #Songs Deletion of The One (Mariah Carey song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13309 2243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sérgio Trindade (2nd nomination) User:JFG 11:23, 23 November 2020 (UTC) delete However respectable this person's work is, it still fails the criteria for inclusion spelled out at . Neither can notability be |inherited from the full IPCC organization, comprised of thousands of scientists, that received a Nobel Prize. The only new event since the first AfD reason Mr. Trindade received some attention in 2020 is that he died of COVID. Sadly that doesn't make him more notable Deletion of Sérgio Trindade (2nd nomination) WP:NACADEMICS||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
13310 3898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manoj Srivastava User:Bearian 22:32, 28 July 2014 (UTC) delete per and . I could see, by scanning the references, that this was poorly sourced. In cleaning up the citations, I noted immediately (1) one cite was to another Wikipedia article, and (2) one had http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/bollywood/news-interviews/Film-shoots-in-Goa-Rs-100-cr-biz/articleshow/7770082.cms?referral=PM the barest of passing mentions. Two references are from http://iffigoa.org his own organization's website, and two more are passing references from the Indian MPAA. I actually found some additional sources, but http://www.bestmediainfo.com/2014/07/5th-jagran-film-festival-concludes-in-delhi-to-travel-across-15-more-cities/ this one is another passing mention and https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Manoj+Srivastava%22+site:news.google.com/newspapers&source=newspapers&gws_rd=ssl this one is a syndicated article about his reaction to a flood Deletion of Manoj Srivastava WP:42||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:The answer to life, the universe, and everything 7
13311 8 [[Mumenthaler]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Ich liebe ELKE NONE keep Der LA-Steller hat anscheinend nur den ersten Satz des Artikels gelesen, ansonsten ist die Begründung des LAs nicht verständlich. Der Kommentar (durch den LA Steller) ''Achtung euere Meinung wird die RK beeinflussen'' sowohl hier in der Diskussion als auch im Artikel ist nicht zielführend. Hier wirdeine Familie, die seit Generationen (hauptsächlich) Mediziner hervorbrachte in einem Artikel zusammengefasst. Ein guter historischer Überblick. Den Autor (1704-1780), den Professor, evtl. auch dem Chemiker können gerne eigene Artikel gewidmet werden. Damit sind in dem Artikel genügend relevante Personen genannt. QS ist für den Artikel angebracht, das stand jedoch schon vor dem LA drin. , gerne LA nach Fall 2 entfernen Löschung von Mumenthaler Wikipedia:ELW Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
13312 16034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malaysia–Philippines relations User:BlueSquadronRaven 14:27, 27 May 2009 (UTC) delete Not one single statement in the article is sourced, and the list of External Links are |an indiscriminate collection of news articles, none of which show notability of the topic as a whole Deletion of Malaysia–Philippines relations WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13313 20534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rick McGhie User:Hyperbole 21:37, 9 November 2006 (UTC) delete """at least in its current form, which makes no (or an insignificant) claim to notability. The article does not meet or as it stands. Googling """"Rick McGhie"""" returns 582 hits, which is pretty low. I'm led to suspect he's just another one of millions of local musicians around the world""" Deletion of Rick McGhie WP:BIO||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13314 6663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of The Colbys episodes User:23skidoo 01:00, 18 June 2007 (UTC) keep as there is clear precedent for articles such as this instead of trying to roll this information into the main article (and far beyond the scope of Deletion of List of The Colbys episodes WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13315 18074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seedrioru User:SkyGazer 15:07, 13 November 2018 (UTC) delete A search doesn't show enough significant coverage in independent sources to meet . Even if it did, this is probably a case of Deletion of Seedrioru WP:BEFORE||WP:NCORP||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13316 5047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cheese for Chee Day User:Tyrenius 18:34, 19 May 2006 (UTC) delete Anyone can edit wikipedia, but there are some guidelines to read, like . However, good luck with the fund-raising Deletion of Cheese for Chee Day WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13317 14967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Institute of American and Talmudic Law User:StonyBrook 19:42, 14 July 2020 (UTC) keep It might pass , as there are multiple reliable secondary sources mentioning it (even Antonin Scalia attended one of their conferences according to ''The New York Times'').https://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/18/technology/internet/18link.html They are also mentioned in ''The Forward'', but I don't know how significant the coverage is because I experienced difficulty opening the link that is in the article Deletion of The Institute of American and Talmudic Law WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13318 12455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/P. Imadura User:Abishe 17:06, 8 January 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of P. Imadura WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13319 11174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ucraft User:Rpclod 02:29, 10 February 2018 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a corporate |directory Deletion of Ucraft WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13320 8592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Heartsfield User:Jasynnash2 12:26, 7 August 2008 (UTC) delete fails , , , and Deletion of Terry Heartsfield WP:ATHLETE||WP:N||WP:V||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13321 18838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cass McCombs User:Ravenswing 14:02, 14 April 2008 (UTC) keep However much the subject has (allegedly) requested deletion, a very casual Google search turned up that one of his albums was named on Amazon.com's Best of 2007 list, he was featured in separate half-hour AND fifteen minute pieces on NPR's World Cafe last October and December, respectively (the transcripts of which are linked off of NPR's website), he was signed last fall by Domino Records, a major indie label ... folks, this meets going away Deletion of Cass McCombs WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13322 3731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enrichi Finica User:onel5969 19:46, 11 April 2021 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Enrichi Finica WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13323 14077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jose Dario Julio User:J04n 13:01, 29 November 2010 (UTC) delete unable to find coverage in any |reliable sources. Searched with and without his middle name combined with each team that he is reported to have played for and found nothing. Without |verification cannot keep Deletion of Jose Dario Julio WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13324 17939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheila Cameron (artist) User:Bbb23 04:46, 27 September 2015 (UTC) comment Folks, let's get back to the issue of and drop the issues of the subject requesting an article about herself and GrammarFascist creating the article. Some of the accusations, both against GrammarFascist and the subject herself, are unsupported and border on violations or personal attacks. In any event, it's a distraction to the appropriate discussion of the subject's notability and will not assist the closing administrator in assessing consensus Deletion of Sheila Cameron (artist) WP:GNG||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13325 6078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amy Angel Series User:Otolemur 21:19, 9 December 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Amy Angel Series WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13326 3190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur Griffiths (British Army officer) User:Barney 22:09, 25 May 2014 (UTC) comment I am somewhat sympathetic to having an article on this individual. Two MCs on active service are not insignificant; there is no doubt a story to tell, and he does seem to have been a pioneer of tank warfare. isn't generally a helpful notability guideline. However, I would have expected information for when he was commissioned and promoted (from the Gazette), and where and when information for the the MCs, and the author to have checked the regimental histories for the Royal Tank Regiment, and constructed something from that. There is much to be said for writing your articles properly Deletion of Arthur Griffiths (British Army officer) WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
13327 20466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bastard Sons of Dial-Up User:Scientizzle 18:10, 7 August 2006 (UTC) comment I agree that removal of |POV material would help, but the article would still suffer from a lack of established |notability Deletion of Bastard Sons of Dial-Up WP:POV||WP:N Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
13328 17523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toitures Du St Laurent User:Gparyani 09:22, 26 May 2015 (UTC) delete per |A7 (and/or |G11). However, the revenue numbers do constitute a |credible claim of significance, despite their being unverified and unsourced Deletion of Toitures Du St Laurent WP:A7||WP:G11||WP:CCS Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
13329 4896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flo Jalin (second nomination) User:EyeSerene 18:38, 21 September 2007 (UTC) comment Most of the copyvio stuff has now been rewritten, and the article ''is'' looking better. Even so, I still don't think Flo meets Deletion of Flo Jalin (second nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13330 1621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IF function User:Andjam 01:08, 23 April 2006 (UTC) delete Nothing wrong with it, except that Wikipedia is |not an instruction manual. More suited to wikibooks, but transwiki probably isn't appropriate unless there's an existing project on this topic Deletion of IF function WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13331 1426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Paffrath (2nd nomination) User:Cullen328 01:35, 24 May 2021 (UTC) keep based on the coverage in the New York Times, Curbed and the Nashville Post that Empire3131 pointed out earlier. He is marginally notable as a real estate investor and YouTuber. I am taking a look ''only'' at the coverage that pre-dates his candidacy because he obviously fails as an unelected candidate with routine campaign announcements and interviews in a race likely to have a massive field of candidates. The references are a shambles, and the article needs a lot of work, and the most important thing is that the article must not be permitted to become a campaign brochure. Many of the people commenting above have been canvassed and have negligible knowledge of Wikipedia's policies and guidelines. The closing administrator will have to discount those comments and give highest priority to the informed, policy based comments, but that's why administrators get paid far more than YouTube influencers, right? Just kidding Deletion of Kevin Paffrath (2nd nomination) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13332 6877 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clarence """"Jeep"""" Jones""" User:MelanieN 01:41, 26 March 2015 (UTC) keep """The article needs more references, and it needs to lose a few puffery terms like """"outstanding"""". But he certainly looks notable to me. Granted, he does not meet , but he almost certainly meets - among other things for being the first African-American to hold a number of city positions. Serving on the Boston Redevelopment Agency would not be notable by itself, but serving on it for more than 30 years and chairing it for 24 of them sounds a little more significant. The city thought he was notable enough to name a park after him""" """Deletion of Clarence """"Jeep"""" Jones""" WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13333 20479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eleka Moore User:WilliamJE 12:39, 29 July 2014 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Eleka Moore WP:NGOLF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13334 2335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Statistics Discussion Lists User:GRBerry 02:04, 17 September 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Statistics Discussion Lists WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13335 4190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DigitalThink NONE NONE keep """spaced ndash}}Per a plethora of significant coverage in reliable sources. Per , """"Notability is not temporary: once a topic has been the subject of """"significant coverage"""" in accordance with the general notability guideline, it does not need to have ongoing coverage""" Deletion of DigitalThink WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13336 3883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parenting practices User:Ihcoyc 15:27, 16 May 2008 (UTC) merge """to Parenting practices and social stratification in the United States and '''keep'''. This is not """"|original research"""" by our definition; the views expressed in the page are a synopsis of published research by an authority in the field. I don't see how this is a |how-to guide at all. As noted above, the article is quite readable and clear, and is otherwise an ''excellent'' contribution. The problem is that the title """"parenting practices"""" gives rise to an expectation of a general article about parenting, with a worldwide perspective: and this article is not that. Moving this to a title that actually describes its content fixes that""" Deletion of Parenting practices WP:OR||WP:HOWTO Wikipedia:No original research 65
13337 19411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aasan R. Rajendran User:Simonm223 11:55, 22 October 2018 (UTC) comment My well-known gripes about and notwithstanding, I'll defer to WBG's judgment here as they have a better grasp of the local media landscape. I tend to err inclusionist WRT BLPs, and I still probably lean slightly toward keep but not enough to want to try and argue to keep it if the general sense from others is that it should be deleted. TL;DR - I'm not sure whether my keep !vote would be more policy derived or based on my particular policy complaints and am stepping out of this one Deletion of Aasan R. Rajendran WP:MANOTE||WP:MMANOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13338 18205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kismet (DC Comics) User:The 05:28, 11 September 2019 (UTC) delete outright this text that's practically free of |sources. We do not redirect elsewhere in Wikipedia material that's unsuitable and unreferenced; we throw it away. |Wikipedia is not a depository of comics' history Deletion of Kismet (DC Comics) WP:RS||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13339 7208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fallout: The Health Impact of 9/11 NONE NONE delete per nom fails Deletion of Fallout: The Health Impact of 9/11 WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13340 4345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samuel Middleton Fox User:Missvain 21:27, 4 June 2021 (UTC) delete Fails GNG after my research and delete per Deletion of Samuel Middleton Fox WP:NOTGENEALOGY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13341 10850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colorado balloon incident [[User talk:75.34.181.114|talk]]) 14:11, 16 October 2009 (UTC) keep """While it's true that | Wikipedia is not news, WP does cover major news events. You may or may not know this, but on the homepage of WP is an entire section devoted to breaking news. Yes, a family seeking media attention doesn't have the same global weight of something like the October 2009 Lahore attacks or some guy getting canonized by the pope, but guess what? Both stories are on the homepage. Maybe the fanatics should go delete those """"news articles"""". Sheesh. On Twitter the Falcon's story dominated trending topics for the entire day. The pope never made a blip on the radar. You can't dispute the notoriety that millions of people were concerned with the subject. --Special:Contributions/75.34.181.114|75.34.181.114""" Deletion of Colorado balloon incident WP:NOTNEWS||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13342 871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anand Ranganathan [[User talk:2402:3A80:474:ED80:D9FB:7AD4:C9F7:5|talk]]) 00:28, 24 January 2019 (UTC) keep passes has been a member of the Indian Academy of Sciences AND MEETS point 3 The person is or has been an elected member of a highly selective and prestigious scholarly society or association.https://www.ias.ac.in/describe/associate/Ranganathan,_Dr_Anand Indian Academy of Sciences Anand and .Special:Contributions/2402:3A80:474:ED80:D9FB:7AD4:C9F7:5|2402:3A80:474:ED80:D9FB:7AD4:C9F7:5 Deletion of Anand Ranganathan WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13343 5968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/England 2030 FIFA World Cup bid User:SportingFlyer 17:58, 20 September 2018 (UTC) keep through the sourcing, passes . Per , ''It is appropriate to report discussion and arguments about the prospects for success of future proposals and projects or whether some development will occur, if discussion is properly referenced.'' That is the case here Deletion of England 2030 FIFA World Cup bid WP:GNG||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13344 4215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rome Rule User:Aatomic1 16:13, 11 April 2008 (UTC) keep Passes with significant coverage from |reliable sources Deletion of Rome Rule WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13345 16712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kiley Dean User:Dionyseus 02:47, 22 August 2006 (UTC) keep per Joelmills, passes Deletion of Kiley Dean WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13346 2889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul LaViolette (3rd nomination) User:Radagast3 08:38, 12 August 2010 (UTC) delete for the reasons in the previous AfD, and because this is an inadequately sourced Deletion of Paul LaViolette (3rd nomination) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13347 8767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Great Wall of Lucy Wu User:The 17:30, 28 July 2014 (UTC) keep in addition to the sources and reviews in the article I came across http://www.washingtonindependentreviewofbooks.com/features/recommended-titles-for-tweens-through-teens this. Now meets Deletion of The Great Wall of Lucy Wu WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
13348 8 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Pontus (kitap) Kullanıcı:mavrikantmavrikant 19:06, 9 Mayıs 2017 (UTC) comment Evet kataloglama kayda değerliği belirleme için büyük bir ölçüt değil. Tartışma sayfasında benim asıl dikkatimi çeken akademik atıflar oldu. Eğer http://dergipark.gov.tr/search?q=Öztürk,+Özhan+pontus§ion=articles bu linke bakarsanız kitaba 20 makalede atıf verildiğini görebilirsiniz. Google Akademik üzerinden de https://scholar.google.com.tr/scholar?cites=272336393002756186&as_sdt=2005&sciodt=0,5&hl=tr 8 atıf görebiliyorum. Dolayısı ile sayfasındaki 1. kritere göre bu kitap '''kesinlikle''' kayda değer Pontus (kitap) silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
13349 7113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sophia Yan User:Alphax 14:21, 25 January 2006 (UTC) comment does this meet and/or ? If so, keep. If not, delete. Simple Deletion of Sophia Yan WP:BIO||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13350 16442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camel toe (2nd nomination) User:nsaum75 00:05, 21 June 2011 (UTC) keep Satisfies |GNG, also, as Malik says above, I have concerns that the AfD may be y in nature Deletion of Camel toe (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:POINT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13351 4198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Moriarty User:CASSIOPEIA 10:40, 21 June 2018 (UTC) delete Local politician needs significant press coverage nationally or internationally to pass and it is not showing here Deletion of Patrick Moriarty WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13352 17675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soccer Star 2017 Top Leagues [[User talk:Fuebaey|talk]]) 15:06, 22 April 2017 (UTC) delete Recently released Android game that fails . Its so new (or !notable) that I haven't been able to find it listed on the developer's website, even though it's being used as a reference. might've been a good bet. Special:Contributions/Fuebaey|Fuebaey Deletion of Soccer Star 2017 Top Leagues WP:GNG||WP:PROD Wikipedia:Notability 77
13353 435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wayne Messam User:Muboshgu 00:43, 29 June 2021 (UTC) keep Meets for the sources covering his life, including his mayoralty and presidential campaign. – Deletion of Wayne Messam WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13354 20739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Calland User:Papaursa 02:28, 28 May 2015 (UTC) delete I agree with the previous comments. I don't believe that simply appearing at a world championship is sufficient to show notability and I think he lacks the coverage necessary to meet Deletion of Josh Calland WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13355 21632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krishna Prasad Lamichhane [[User talk:Lourdes|Lourdes]]''' 17:12, 20 September 2017 (UTC) comment """Perhaps some passing admin could invoke ({{tq|""""Poorly sourced biographical articles of unknown, non-public figures, where the discussions have no editor opposing the deletion, may be deleted after discussions have been completed.""""}}) than witness this being listlessly resisted""" Deletion of Krishna Prasad Lamichhane WP:BIODEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13356 13898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The gypsy queens User:Jimsteele9999 01:22, 9 August 2012 (UTC) delete That's one good source. But I can't find any other independent, verfiable sources and don't think it meets Deletion of The gypsy queens WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13357 14437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Football at the 2015 Pan American Games User:Vanjagenije 12:00, 30 January 2014 (UTC) keep This is obviously not a case of rystal, as this is not ''unverifiable speculation''. Pan American Games are a major sports event, and there are many sources about the upcoming 2015 games. We have Football at the 2016 Summer Olympics, so there is no reason to delete this article Deletion of Football at the 2015 Pan American Games WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
13358 12707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher O'Neill User:Julle 14:26, 9 May 2018 (UTC) keep as there is sufficent in-depth coverage in independent reliable sources to pass . In this I discount '''all''' the kungahuset.se references and notably take into account the sources mentioned by Deletion of Christopher O'Neill WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13359 4447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comikey user:Hellknowz 09:41, 17 July 2021 (UTC) delete as a non-notable company failing and with no reliable independent in-depth sources (at least what English search returns and what is listed above). The given sources are not GNG-compatible and are only briefly paraphrasing press releases and official and routine material. Possibly , but these sort of companies rarely receive in-depth coverage. — Deletion of Comikey WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
13360 8233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Weaver's Antique Service Station User:E 13:54, 31 December 2018 (UTC) keep per Doncram's upgrade of sourcing. It is common for the individual buildings in historic districts to have stand-alone articles; we have a long list of them :Category:Gas stations on the National Register of Historic Places Deletion of Weaver's Antique Service Station WP:HEYMANN Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
13361 21446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bellaparker User:Haeleth 19:33, 8 December 2005 (UTC) delete per the proposal. If we kept ''everything'' that was verifiable, we'd have individual articles for practically every single copy of practically every single issue of practically every newspaper ever. &mdash Deletion of Bellaparker WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13362 14348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Genesis V. Cordoba User:Bearian 21:40, 27 October 2015 (UTC) delete no |reliable sources, and costume designers are |all too run of the mill in film. May be a case of Deletion of Genesis V. Cordoba WP:RS||WP:MILL||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13363 12952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Medusa (Dungeons & Dragons) User:Folken 19:35, 15 June 2011 (UTC) delete No significant coverage of the topic in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, thus non notable and does not deserve article, per Deletion of Medusa (Dungeons & Dragons) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13364 10998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herman Farr User:Novaseminary 18:31, 4 August 2011 (UTC) delete No coverage sufficient for / Deletion of Herman Farr WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13365 13211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K kalan User:Anupmehra 12:37, 13 December 2014 (UTC) keep """recognized geographical places are considered to be notable for inclusion on Wikipedia per . However, the village name 'K Kalan' is quite confusing here as in 'K Kalan', 'K' seems to be abbreviation of something unknown. Searching for 'K Kalan' in Census of India official website results many http://www.censusindia.gov.in/(S(ksz0cd45b2l1e155hvw3yr45))/pca/Searchdata.aspx entries. Looking close in census directory for any similar village name in Bijbehara tehsil in Anantnag district, the most plausible name appears to be, """"Khush Roi Kalan"""" (census data added by original creator, also matched). I've re-written the article as a whole from Special:Diff/636621047|this to Special:Diff/637901165|this. It should be OK now. {{U|Kikichugirl|Nominator}} may want to withdraw their nomination""" Deletion of K kalan WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
13366 11348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gethen User:Sgeureka 09:15, 11 November 2019 (UTC) merge to Hainish Cycle, where this fictional element can be better covered with . &ndash Deletion of Gethen WP:DUEWEIGHT Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
13367 1291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kekkei genkai User:Doctorfluffy 02:09, 3 November 2007 (UTC) delete Regardless of how notable this may be in-universe, there are still no reliable secondary sources to indicate notability per Deletion of Kekkei genkai WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13368 9823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of ACM-W chapters User:Ajf773 20:15, 5 June 2019 (UTC) delete per . All chapters appear non-notable therefore the article is not suitable for merging either Deletion of List of ACM-W chapters WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13369 20422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finders Keepers Crew User:Whpq 16:17, 15 August 2008 (UTC) delete I found http://www.teknemedia.net/archivi/2005/03/06/mostra/10097.html this and http://www.arte.go.it/eventi/2007/0691.htm this which are both in Italian. Based on a google translation, they are passing mentions but does seem to imply some notoriety within the art community. However, there does seem to be a complete lack of sourcing for which to meet |verifiability which is a concern Deletion of Finders Keepers Crew WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13370 12153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krishanti O'Mara Vignarajah (2nd nomination) User:Enos733 08:53, 29 January 2019 (UTC) delete """I am not sure that a redirect to 2018 Maryland gubernatorial election makes sense. The current lede of the article does not say anything about the subject's run for office (and she finished third in the statewide primary), suggesting she is more notable for other parts of her life. Nothing shows that there is """"significant coverage in multiple published secondary sources,"""" and would fail """ Deletion of Krishanti O'Mara Vignarajah (2nd nomination) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13371 2521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John J. Flood User:Bearian 20:51, 23 July 2020 (UTC) delete It may be 100% true, but if he's not |covered significantly in reliable sources, he's not |notable as we define it. Zero news articles on Google, passing mentions in a book, few citations to his work (if it's the same person Deletion of John J. Flood WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13372 15648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/King Edward Avenue (Vancouver) User:The 21:46, 27 April 2014 (UTC) merge to Vancouver#Transportation. We do not give streets, even major thoroughfares, a pass on notability; they must pass . This is a plain, common, unremarkable road with no evidence of passing . However, there may be some here that can be added to the section of the city's article regarding transportation, and redirects are cheap Deletion of King Edward Avenue (Vancouver) WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13373 435 [[VW-Käfer-Tuning]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:MBq/Bewertung 21:11, 31. Mär. 2007 (CEST) keep Löschbegründung ungeeignet, da ''pauschal'' (guckstu ), ohne auf den Inhalt des Artikels einzugehen Löschung von VW-Käfer-Tuning Wikipedia:LR Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13374 105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1906 United Kingdom heat wave User:The 21:10, 30 August 2018 (UTC) delete per nomination. |A hot summer in Britain, indeed Deletion of 1906 United Kingdom heat wave WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13375 170 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Kadın Severse """Kullanıcı:can'''can'''""" 11.18, 11 Nisan 2020 (UTC) delete """Eklenen kaynaklar daha ziyade oyuncularıyla ilgili haberlerde diziye ismen değinmekte olan kaynaklar. Sabah Sabah gazetesi kaynağında diziyle ilgili """"nispeten"""" bilgi bulunuyor fakat onu da bağımsız sayamayız (Sabah ve atv aynı gruba ait). Hatta https://www.medyatava.com/haber/atvnin-hulya-avsarli-yeni-dizisi-11-aralikta-ekranda_20668 Medyatava ve https://www.haberturk.com/haber/haber/459-iste-avsar-kizinin-jonu Habertürk kaynakları da Sabah gazetesinden alıntılanmış. Ayrıca baktığımda kriterleri de karşılanmamış gibi görünüyor. Belki birden fazla tarafsız, bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynak kriteri sağlanmış denebilir, fakat burada dizinin değil, oyuncularının haber temeline alınması ve diziden sadece ismen bahsedilmiş olması nedeniyle kayda değerliğin sağlanmış olduğunu düşünmüyorum. --Kullanıcı mesaj:Ravages|'''ravages""" Kadın Severse'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:TV Wikipedia:Notability 77
13376 7956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yumi Song User:Arthistorian1977 12:13, 20 March 2016 (UTC) keep It's a usual problem with non English Artists that sources are not that easily searchable. I've searched her by her Kanji name and did find some sources which just need to be translated. So, by info in English on her site, she passes , but it need support by verifiable sources. So, unless someone persuade me, they do not exist on Japanese, it's a keep for me Deletion of Yumi Song WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13377 19954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Jagannath Kuberappa Dange User:Pharaoh 03:52, 10 September 2015 (UTC) delete per Bgwhite and Fails and Deletion of Dr. Jagannath Kuberappa Dange WP:GNG||WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13378 18837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raheem Sterling (3rd nomination) User:Michig 06:52, 22 April 2011 (UTC) keep Easily passess . Still Deletion of Raheem Sterling (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13379 10491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blancride User:Mailer 23:53, 11 April 2015 (UTC) delete Listed sources do not provide significant coverage for subject matter (rather, it is Uber and general issues surrounding it). Lack of |reliable sources covering the app, fails Deletion of Blancride WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13380 970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/If You Don't Love Me At My User:Wumbolo 21:11, 21 April 2018 (UTC) comment I added more references, including some from yesterday. So the coverage still continues, and it is too early to predict that it will end per Deletion of If You Don't Love Me At My WP:RAPID Wikipedia:Notability 77
13381 8710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teresa May (actress) User:Super 14:58, 23 February 2017 (UTC) delete As written, the article doesn't establish notability beyond the |one event. Nothing has changed from the circumstances in which the article was originally deleted Deletion of Teresa May (actress) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13382 17291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Smith (footballer born 1977) User:GiantSnowman 10:18, 28 April 2011 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Paul Smith (footballer born 1977) WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13383 1217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Whispering Woods User:Dream 07:48, 25 February 2010 (UTC) keep Article is well done, plenty of valid information to fill it. The suggested guidelines are not binding in any way. Policies are all that matters. |Ignore all rules clearly states if a rule gets in the way of improving Wikipedia, you ignore it. All guidelines were done by a small number of people, usually less than a handful at a time, without the rest of the Wikipedia noticing, and can't really be taken seriously. Note, am now copying this to several AFD, which are the same, nominated by the same person, with the same invalid argument about mindlessly following the guidelines passed by deletionists campers as an excuse to get rid of things they personally don't like Deletion of The Whispering Woods WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
13384 53 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Emin Kuz """Kullanıcı:maurice flesiermaurice flesier""" 21:28, 19 Ocak 2018 (UTC) comment bütün bu KD mi/değil mi? Ansiklopedik mi/değil mi? tartışmalarının temel sebebi politikalardaki yetersizlik ve belirsizlik. Bir kullanıcıya göre 0 kayda değer olan bir şahıs diğerine göre olmayabiliyor. politikası 2018 şartlarında ve binlerce maddenin olduğu bir ansiklopedide artık yetersiz kalıyor Emin Kuz'un silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
13385 19847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rafael Popper User:danntm 19:11, 28 February 2007 (UTC) delete lacks the sources to pass , and obvious concerns Deletion of Rafael Popper WP:BIO||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
13386 41 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaina-e-Ghazal User:Stuartyeates 08:58, 11 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Aaina-e-Ghazal WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13387 20627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blue Lakes Mall User:Vegaswikian 08:41, 3 January 2008 (UTC) delete as just another run of the mill small mall. At best, merge anything of note into the city article. Fails . and Deletion of Blue Lakes Mall WP:V||WP:RS||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13388 9023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terra Universal User:CAPTAIN 21:00, 10 March 2017 (UTC) delete Blatant Deletion of Terra Universal WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13389 3062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robbin Harms User:RebeccaGreen 20:24, 22 June 2019 (UTC) keep """As far as I can see, he meets #3 """"Competed in a series or race of worldwide or national interest"""", and perhaps also #1 (though I don't know what counts as """"a fully professional series""""). This guy has raced in Grand Prix races in many countries (definitely of national interest in those countries, and some also definitely of international interest). Not having sources is not a reason to delete an article, per , so why bring it to AfD? Why not just find and add """"at least one source that supports at least one statement made about the person in the article""""???? I have added one source, so it's no longer unsourced, but I am really not interested in motorsports. Did the nominator do , especially """"The minimum search expected is a normal Google search, a Google Books search, a Google News search, and a Google News archive search""""? and note """"If you find that adequate sources ''do appear to exist'', the fact that they are not yet present in the article is not a proper basis for a nomination. Instead, you should consider citing the sources""" Deletion of Robbin Harms WP:NMOTORSPORT||WP:NEXIST||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13390 21554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1channel.ch User:LordMaldad2000 03:34, 9 April 2013 (UTC) delete So far much of the sources provided are not satisfactory (either self produced, user submitted, or trivial) which leads me to believe it fails to fulfill the |general guideline requirements. |Significant coverage is something that this subject seems to be lacking Deletion of 1channel.ch WP:GNG||WP:VRS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13391 6445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Food Matters User:Novusuna 18:11, 18 November 2013 (UTC) keep There's not much, but the references we have seem to just barely squeak past . It may be propaganda, but it's far from the only heavily biased film we have an article for Deletion of Food Matters WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13392 17649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wererat User:Rorshacma 15:30, 30 April 2020 (UTC) comment """At the very least, the article would need to be renamed and refocused, as the intro specifically talks about therianthropic creatures called wererats, where as many of the examples that then follows are just a collection of a bunch of random rat-related creatures that do not fit that definition at all, many of which are never actually referred to as """"wererats"""". The current article is also mostly unsourced, and has quite a bit of that should not be kept, regardless of the fate of the article. Perhaps this could be simply used as a Redirect to Rat#Fiction, with an added mention in that section of rat-like men being a common element in fiction, until some kind of general ratperson article can actually be developed with reliable sources""" Deletion of Wererat WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13393 3109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ivan Bosnar User:Sir 11:25, 29 August 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Ivan Bosnar WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13394 7704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Institute of Inspection Cleaning and Restoration Certification (IICRC) User:ChaseAm 23:37, 2 April 2013 (UTC) keep """After a quick search I found a few compelling articles. It seems that being """"IICRC certified"""" is a well known certification. Take a look http://interact.stltoday.com/pr/business/PR031413110312190 here, it mentions """"Amant’s technicians are IICRC certified"""".http://www.marketwatch.com/story/paul-davis-provides-spring-storm-safety-tips-2013-03-26 This as well states """"Qualified technicians are certified from The Institute of Inspection, Cleaning and Restoration Certification (IICRC)."""" https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws&q=IICRC&oq=IICRC&gs_l=news-cc.3..43j43i53.2618.4166.0.4361.8.6.0.2.0.0.170.502.3j2.5.0...0.0...1ac.1.gvZYC3__BRs Here's where I found it, take a look for yourself. What are your thoughts on that? I think, seeing what I found, this article should be kept and certainly cleaned up/made more encyclopedic . Hmm, says """"Trivial or incidental coverage of a subject by secondary sources is not sufficient to establish notability"""", so perhaps not, but the context of it makes it sound to me as though it's reputable in the world of cleaning. What do you think with what I've given? I'm actually quite stumped on this one, I want to see what some other peoples' input (which of course is why we're here""" Deletion of Institute of Inspection Cleaning and Restoration Certification (IICRC) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13395 7311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevan Shaw User:Gigs 00:07, 27 March 2009 (UTC) keep Seems to be notable enough to have a good scattering of secondary source coverage. Should be trimmed down to standards though Deletion of Kevan Shaw WP:NPF Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13396 8821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oralno doba User:MichaelQSchmidt 19:46, 17 June 2010 (UTC) comment """Since even Babelfish and GoogleTranslate show that the Serbian media sources deal entirely with the show and/or its host, and since they are not simply pocket reviews or trivial mentons in a list or database, their coverage meets """"significant"""" per guideline. As for determiniing the reliability of a Serbian national media source to cite articles on Serbian media topics, that question is now at Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Countering_systemic_bias#Serbian_sources_for_articles_on_Serbian_topics|WikiProject Countering systemic bias, the Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Noticeboard#Serbian_sources|eliable sources noticeboard, and Serbian-related pages Talk:Serbia#Serbian_sources_for_articles_on_Serbian_topics|Talk:Serbia and Talk:Cinema of Serbia#Serbian sources for articles on Serbian media topics|Talk:Cinema of Serbia. As I had noticed the question had not been asked where it might best '''BE''' asked, I went and asked. While you are free to go over and call them """"tabloids"""", many European eliable sources|reliable sources make use of Tabloid#Europe|that accepted smaller format and it does not hold the same onus in Europe as it might in the US... so it might be best to await input from editors able to make a neutral determination""" Deletion of Oralno doba WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
13397 19572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Second Bloody Valentine War User:moritheil 20:51, 25 October 2009 (UTC) comment Those objections all seem to be quality issues (mentioning development, production, real-world impact, encyclopedic tone.) Certainly they are important, but I'm not sure they have bearing on deletion. Quality can be improved over time, as per and Deletion of Second Bloody Valentine War WP:NOTPAPER||WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13398 37 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Delila - Bir Genç Kadın Gerillanın Dağ Günlükleri """Kullanıcı:maurice flesiermaurice flesier""" 22:15, 12 Kasım 2016 (UTC) keep """Kitap kriterleri bakımından dediğiniz gibi kayda değer değil fakat Rapsar'ın dediği gibi VP:KD 'ı genel olarak kapsadığı için ilk önce bu referans alınıyor. Bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynaklar tarafından ele alınması ve kitabın yasaklanmasına dair haberler olması nedeniyle """"genel olarak"""" KD. Buna benzer benim tarafımdan açılmış bir madde bile var. Bknz: İmralı'da Bir Tiran: Abdullah Öcalan""" Delila - Bir Genç Kadın Gerillanın Dağ Günlükleri'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
13399 8102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Browser Backgrounds User:Rankiri 13:48, 14 July 2009 (UTC) delete Google, Talk:Browser Backgrounds and Browser_Backgrounds#References show no signs of |nontrivial coverage Deletion of Browser Backgrounds WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13400 9650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shahjadpur User:Smartyllama 12:16, 13 June 2017 (UTC) keep Satisfies . Remember, |AFD is not cleanup Deletion of Shahjadpur WP:GEOLAND||WP:AFDISNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13401 17064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John A. Smolin User:David 03:23, 21 August 2009 (UTC) keep Per Gsbsmith, a clear pass of #1 Deletion of John A. Smolin WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13402 16773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unusual You User:Dylanfromthenorth 11:47, 17 August 2009 (UTC) merge Because according to http://www.billboard.com/#/song/britney-spears/unusual-you/12074402 Billboard and http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sql=11:kpfuxq9jldte~T22 Allmusic it hasn't been released as a single and hasn't charted, despite the article claiming it has. It therefore fails |the criteria for songs and should be redirected according to that guideline. Unusual You (Song) actually already does exactly that Deletion of Unusual You WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13403 11705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Man utd anthem User:Mr 12:43, 13 March 2008 (UTC) delete can't find any possible secondary sources for this, sounds like |OR to me Deletion of Man utd anthem WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13404 13864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naruto geography User:Ambuj 13:53, 15 July 2006 (UTC) keep Meets . &mdash Deletion of Naruto geography WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
13405 113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GreySpark Partners User:AllyD 19:04, 23 March 2012 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability in the article (refs to company's own site, Linkedin, and a PR release about a previous company); there are a couple of slightly better refs available: http://www.hedgeweek.com/2010/02/24/36314/capital-markets-consultancy-greyspark-launched on their formation, http://www.ftseglobalmarkets.com/index.php?option=com_k2&view=item&id=3102:greyspark-partners-opens-hong-kong-office&Itemid=161 on their opening another office but these are routine financial news items falling short of Deletion of GreySpark Partners :WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
13406 6753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tomer Amos User:Sir 20:45, 27 August 2015 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Tomer Amos WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13407 12037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yaakov Horowitz User:Bearian 18:20, 8 February 2021 (UTC) delete per . Genealogy plays a huge role in secular European society, but we have eliminated literally hundreds of articles about minor nobility who are unsourced except to family lists Deletion of Yaakov Horowitz WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13408 21786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cecil Hammond User:Mahveotm 14:32, 3 November 2019 (UTC) delete Cecil Hammond, fails . Keep Rhythm Unplugged obviously notable Deletion of Cecil Hammond WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13409 47 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Onur Ustaoğlu """Kullanıcı:turgut46turgut46""" 00.13, 25 Temmuz 2021 (UTC) delete Maddeye eklenen kaynaklar ''Bolu Olay'' gibi ne idüğü belirsiz kaynaklar (''Star'' hariç). Kaynaklardan biri de yazarın kendi kitabı, dolayısıyla bağımsız kaynak değil. Kayda değerliğini ispat edebilecek |güvenilir kaynaklar olmadığı için silinmesi taraftarıyım. Ayrıca Nick Vujicic muhtemelen bu kişiden daha fazla medyanın konusu olmuştur Onur Ustaoğlu'nun silinmesi Vikipedi:Güvenilir kaynaklar Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13410 1080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pyramid (game show) broadcast history User:Mandsford 13:05, 27 October 2010 (UTC) keep """It's a legitimate spinoff from the article about the longstanding (on and off since 1972) show. Some people enjoy articles with what the nom describes as """"way, way, way, way too much information"""" on the page, and they simply call it """"information"""". In the case of programs with a long history, articles are spun out for such things as episode guides, lists of characters, and so forth. It's funny how redirects to something that makes no mention of either TV or televsion. Wikipedia is not as heavy on TV show articles as it used to be-- when I first came here, we had lots of articles about individual episodes and biographies about minor or even one-show characters, and relatively few about real events and real people-- and I think that over the last several years, it's become less of a TV guide than it had been""" Deletion of Pyramid (game show) broadcast history WP:NOTTVGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13411 16632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Table of LaTeX symbols User:Boffob 14:12, 7 November 2008 (UTC) delete as useful as it is, this is a clear case of Deletion of Table of LaTeX symbols WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13412 15273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mechanical Beasts User:TheFarix 22:50, 26 September 2012 (UTC) merge """Warrior Beasts and Mechanical Beasts into Mazinger Z and Great Mazinger respectively. While the lists of """"beast of the week"""" is trivial and would violate , the main concept of both groups of villeins do play a central role in the television series. But deleting them is affectively throwing the baby, which you want to keep, out with the bath watter""" Deletion of Mechanical Beasts WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13413 3592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Strategic Marketing Inc. User:HighKing 18:24, 20 July 2017 (UTC) delete Fails GNG and Deletion of Strategic Marketing Inc. WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
13414 8800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Happn User:Cunard 03:40, 24 October 2016 (UTC) keep """per the comment from {{user|99.162.153.185}}: Meets from coverage http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/news/11906570/Happn-bringing-the-real-world-back-into-online-dating.html, http://www.telegraph.co.uk/women/life/dating-app-happn-uses-fake-profiles-to-shine-a-light-on-the-dome/, http://www.couriermail.com.au/news/queensland/concerns-over-dating-apps-creepy-tracker/news-story/2653126b997de72e5a07b45c7a339ab9, http://www.campaignasia.com/article/w-asia-picked-to-promote-dating-app-happn-in-singapore/429946, http://www.ladn.eu/news-business/marques/nescafe-et-happn-vous-reunissent-autours-dun-cafe/, https://www.bustle.com/articles/155412-10-mistakes-youre-making-on-dating-app-happn, https://www.bustle.com/articles/179566-heres-the-most-popular-opening-line-on-dating-app-happn, http://www.businessinsider.com/dating-app-happn-is-launching-see-you-there-feature-2016-5?r=UK&IR=T, http://thenextweb.com/apps/2016/05/12/happns-new-feature-lets-tell-dates-youll-later/#gref, http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/software/french-dating-app-happn-off-to-a-good-start-in-india/articleshow/52408882.cms, https://techcrunch.com/2016/01/19/dating-app-happn-reaches-10-million-users-adds-voice/, http://www.businessinsider.com/a-million-people-in-the-uk-now-use-the-happn-dating-app-2016-4?r=UK&IR=T, http://nypost.com/2016/03/01/new-yorkers-are-falling-for-hyperlocal-dating-app-happn/, http://www.businessinsider.com/happn-cant-be-used-for-stalking-2015-12?r=UK&IR=T, http://dailybruin.com/2016/05/19/love-apptually-not-much-going-on-with-dating-app-happn/, http://www.teenvogue.com/story/dating-app-happn-homelessness-notifications, http://www.marieclaire.co.uk/life/sex-and-relationships/happn-what-you-need-to-know-about-the-newest-dating-app-on-the-scene-53061, https://techcrunch.com/2015/09/30/happn-attracts-14-million-for-its-dating-app-powered-by-real-life-interactions/, http://www.businessinsider.com/happn-ceo-didier-rapport-voice-messages-are-coming-and-well-catch-tinder-by-2017-2015-11?r=UK&IR=T, http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-07-29/dating-app-happn-raises-awareness-of-homelessness/7672884, http://tech.co/dating-app-happn-violates-its-own-privacy-terms-2016-02, https://techcrunch.com/2014/07/16/happn-is-a-dating-app-powered-by-real-life-interactions/, http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/news/happn-voice-messages-online-dating-a6823936.html. The app has received international coverage in publications based in Australia, India, the United Kingdom, and the United States. The article is neutrally written: '''Happn''' is a mobile dating application developed by FTW & Co. The application is compatible with Android, iPhone That there is """"actual off wiki evidence that this is paid editing"""" does not compel deletion because the article is neutrally written""" Deletion of Happn WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13415 15254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mb-microtec User:Extraordinary 17:44, 2 March 2021 (UTC) delete no sources to be found aside from insubstantial entries on lists. Fails Deletion of Mb-microtec WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13416 13730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaylee Matuszak User:power 03:08, 11 November 2017 (UTC) delete simply being on iTunes isn't enough to meet ; I see a few local Duluth sources (the best one being http://www.duluth.com/duluth-com-the-magazine-passion-to-perform-kaylee-matuszak-finds-her-way/) but not enough to keep Deletion of Kaylee Matuszak WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13417 9132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Diarra User:GiantSnowman 11:09, 15 August 2010 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Ali Diarra WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13418 5619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chantra User:Ravenswing 16:40, 18 December 2009 (UTC) delete """Beyond the comments above, I strongly object to the charge that deleting an unsourced article involves cultural bias, just because the subject pertains to another country. is an absolute: """"All quotations and any material challenged or likely to be challenged must be attributed to a reliable, published source using an inline citation ... If no reliable, third-party sources can be found for an article topic, Wikipedia should not have an article on it."""" Period. There is nothing in giving a free pass to article topics involving foreign countries""" Deletion of Chantra WP:V||WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13419 12412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Sebastián Monesterolo User:Smartyllama 13:14, 4 June 2018 (UTC) keep Meets . |AFD is not cleanup Deletion of Omar Sebastián Monesterolo WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:AFDISNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13420 6088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FK Milutinac Zemun User:Fenix 10:23, 5 January 2015 (UTC) delete Don't see any evidence of the team having competed in the nationals stages of any competition, which is the usual benchmark for club notability. A case of |too soon at best Deletion of FK Milutinac Zemun WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
13421 8667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lotball User:ApolloCreed 14:35, 8 March 2006 (UTC) comment """This AfD is not meant to be a personal attack. I am not """"holding anything against anyone."""" I was just pointing out the notability guidelines. More importantly, the article does not cite any of it's statements from sources so it isn't |verifiabile and because you are so closely tied to the game, the content is likely to be |biased |original research. &mdash""" Deletion of Lotball WP:V||WP:NPOV||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13422 6364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael T. Sauer User:Aboutmovies 08:02, 10 May 2007 (UTC) keep """as a notable person and an article that can be improved by proper sourcing. Per : ''Major local political figures who have received significant press coverage''. Deletion is not cleanup, and should not be used as """"cleanup with a deadline"""". If you can't firmly cite policy, you probably should not be making comments in the deletion process. This judge has received a lot of press in the past week about just him and I’ll go out on a limb and say he will get even more as the appeals process runs its course""" Deletion of Michael T. Sauer WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13423 18272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eugene, California User:FOARP 19:11, 9 December 2020 (UTC) delete As with all the other similar articles that have come down, this fails Deletion of Eugene, California WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
13424 366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rod D. Martin (2nd nomination) [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 13:50, 17 September 2006 (UTC) delete While the subject appears to be on the cusp of achieving the required level of notability, I am more concerned with the quality of sources for much of the information presented. Besides the ''Washington Post Online Live'' interview transcript and the FEC press release, '''all''' of the other sources are either completely self-published or at the least self-submitted autobiography. And while self-published sources may be used in some cases to flesh out information on already notable subjects, they cannot be used to ''establish'' notability. Other than the fact that he has co-edited one book and that his campaign committee for a failed U.S. House run was fined by the FEC, almost every other statement in this article should be removed as improperly verified per . When Mr. Martin achieves the required level of notability, we will be able to find reputable, third-party sources from which to write the new article Deletion of Rod D. Martin (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13425 8861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pop Carn (2003 film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 21:34, 7 April 2015 (UTC) keep Expanded |searches find this topic spoken of in multiple reliable sources. is met. IE: http://www.sify.com/movies/tamil/preview.php?ctid=5&cid=2423&id=11921472 ''Sify'', http://www.thehindu.com/lf/2002/01/23/stories/2002012300400200.htm ''The Hindu'', http://www.sify.com/movies/tamil/interview.php?id=12572822&cid=2408 ''Sify'' and more Deletion of Pop Carn (2003 film) WP:BEFORE||WP:NF Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13426 8455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Four State Area User:Split_Infinity 00:45, 19 December 2006 (UTC) delete fails , etc Deletion of Four State Area WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13427 6191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vevo Certified User:Bejnar 19:02, 23 December 2014 (UTC) delete Can be mentioned in the Vevo article, but does not merit the redirect suggested by merger. As the nominator indicates it runs afoul of #ADVERTISING and Deletion of Vevo Certified WP:NOT||WP:SINGLEVENDOR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13428 18294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mostfit User:Ihcoyc 04:10, 19 March 2010 (UTC) delete WP:CSD#G11|Unambiguous advertising: ''full fledged and extremely flexible Management Information System(MIS) for Microfinance(MFIs).'' |Patent nonsense: ''It is an hosted MIS provided in SAAS model to the MFIs.'' (Oh, '''''that Deletion of Mostfit WP:NONSENSE Wikipedia:Patent nonsense 105
13429 19791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jann-Fiete Arp User:Guy 03:10, 17 May 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Jann-Fiete Arp WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13430 19956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Linda Michelle Darnell User:Bearcat 18:13, 11 November 2017 (UTC) delete Being a non-winning candidate for office is not a notability criterion — a person has to ''win'' the election and thereby ''hold'' office, not just run for it and lose, to clear , but this makes no claim that she has preexisting notability for any other reason. And the depth of |reliable source coverage shown here is ''not'' adequate to get her over in lieu, as Joezasada claims above: of the six footnotes, one is a clarifying note rather than a reference; two are her own |primary source content about herself, which cannot support notability at all; two (''Reason'' and ''The Story Exchange'') just glancingly namecheck her existence in stories in which she is ''not'' the ''subject''; and the C-SPAN reference isn't coverage about her but merely a one-minute video clip of her speaking. These do not represent coverage ''about'' her — they represent the kind of purely |run of the mill sources that ''any'' candidate in ''any'' election could ''always'' show, not evidence that her candidacy was somehow a special case over and above everybody else's Deletion of Linda Michelle Darnell WP:NPOL||WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13431 13384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wicked Spring User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:15, 15 July 2013 (UTC) keep Meets and . While I can sympathize with the nominator's (otherwise addressable) concerns toward format and sourcing, I do not understand his comment about lack of reliable sources. I |was able to quickly find it written of in reliable independent sources http://movies.nytimes.com/movie/296063/Wicked-Spring/overview ''New York Times'' and full length articles in http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=zXAiAAAAIBAJ&sjid=Qq0FAAAAIBAJ&pg=1301,4697494&dq=wicked-spring&hl=en ''Argus Press'' (1), http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=3XQyAAAAIBAJ&sjid=tK8FAAAAIBAJ&pg=1494,3228726&dq=wicked-spring+hershberger&hl=en ''Argus Press'' (2), and http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=RWciAAAAIBAJ&sjid=_6wFAAAAIBAJ&pg=2227,4105540&dq=wicked-spring+hershberger&hl=enhttp://news.google.com/newspapers?id=RWciAAAAIBAJ&sjid=_6wFAAAAIBAJ&pg=2227,4105540&dq=wicked-spring+hershberger&hl=en Argus Press'' 93) as well as in http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=Ly4zAAAAIBAJ&sjid=dAgGAAAAIBAJ&pg=2291,8842932&dq=wicked-spring+hershberger&hl=en ''Free Lance Star'' and pay-walled http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=VP&p_theme=vp&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=1103177E156AECE8&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM ''Virginia Pilot'' http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=RO&p_theme=ro&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F7EB3E6A77FB682&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM ''Roanoke Times'' (1) http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=RO&p_theme=ro&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0EAEA0C846AA32DC&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM ''Roanoke Times'' (2) http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=RO&p_theme=ro&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=10DEB6806A34F268&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM ''Roanoke Times'' (3). Article is currently being fixed.http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wicked_Spring&diff=564329449&oldid=564209001 Any additional help would be appreciated Deletion of Wicked Spring WP:NF||WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13432 20000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dimitrijevic Aleksa User:Gilesbennett 12:06, 4 January 2008 (UTC) delete no independently verified notability, so fails . —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Dimitrijevic Aleksa WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
13433 14310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yung Trace (actor) User:SanAnMan 20:26, 9 May 2016 (UTC) delete fails , not -worthy. All sources are as well Deletion of Yung Trace (actor) WP:MUSBIO||WP:GNG||WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13434 20338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Cleare User:CalJW 16:43, 2 April 2006 (UTC) keep Meets by competing at the highest level, ie the Olympics Deletion of Aaron Cleare WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13435 9666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OmarGosh User:Yngvadottir 18:57, 3 February 2017 (UTC) delete """I feel a bit guilty about advocating deletion of an article about a 14-year-old, but it's way too soon. Trending on social media is not one of our indices of notability, and the only close to reliable source cited is the WN piece, which while enthusiastic does not suggest that """"elche"""" is a reliable music critic; in any case, we'd need at least one more substantial piece to meet . Search is complicated by the coincidence of names with the subject of OmarGoshTV, whose history is tangled up with that of this article since there was a hijacking during the run of Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OmarGoshTV; that article has now been restored and in fact almost all the hits for """"Omar Gosh"""" are for the other Omar Gosh whose YouTube channel is OmarGoshTV (and who is not a rapper). But I failed to find anything potentially useful on this person""" Deletion of OmarGosh WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13436 21155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Calderón User:Nfitz 02:44, 27 September 2020 (UTC) keep to suggest that the top Ecuadorian league isn't fully professional is laughable. It's not listed on WP:FPL because of a lack of sources - but simply common sense says that teams in a relatively wealthy country in front of tens of thousands of people are fully-professional. No one has ever found any sources saying they aren't fully-professional either! And not surprisingly, they meet , as you'd expect for a player with years of experience in fully-professional leagues, see https://www.elrelatoec.com/2020/09/26/richard-calderon-busca-rescindir-contrato-con-barcelona-s-c-y-espera-fichar-por-macara/ one, https://ecuador.goltv.tv/es/noticiasroot-lat/73778-richard-calderon-me-estoy-ganando-un-lugar-en-el-equipo two, https://www.elcomercio.com/deportes/futbol-ecuador-campeonato-richardcalderon-sebastianabreu.html three, https://web.archive.org/web/20160221235800/http://www.hinchaamarillo.com/noticias/9888-consider-retirarse-del-ftbol-hoy-es-titular-en-el-ms-grande-audio.html four Deletion of Richard Calderón WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13437 13273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wire 98.3 User:Vegaswikian 02:38, 6 May 2007 (UTC) delete per above. If and when some reliable sources are found then maybe the article can return. The other option is to merge the stations into new articles on the owners. That way there is a place for information to be developed so that it can be split out to new articles when we have |reliable sources and notability is established Deletion of Wire 98.3 WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13438 881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sagar Institute of Research & Technology User:Rockphed 18:53, 30 September 2019 (UTC) delete """I can't find any sources. I haven't checked local language sources (which probably won't show up for an english search), but absent someone with local language skills, I don't think we are going to find any sources. The extent of sourcing in the current article amounts to """"there is an accredited institution with this name"""", which violates """ Deletion of Sagar Institute of Research & Technology WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13439 8590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ecaddindia User:Pamri 05:13, 25 December 2005 (UTC) delete does not meet criterion at Deletion of Ecaddindia WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13440 2750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrian Wykes User:Dane 05:09, 27 March 2018 (UTC) keep Appears to pass Deletion of Adrian Wykes WP:NSPORTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13441 3574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Beightol User:Gonzo_fan2007 16:38, 16 February 2021 (UTC) keep per {{U|Usernameunique}}. Seems to be enough to meet Deletion of Larry Beightol WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13442 4680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jody St. Michael User:Clarityfiend 23:18, 5 June 2016 (UTC) delete for failing with insufficiently notable credits. Longevity in the business isn't enough (even if she's the gorilla your dreams, Montanabw Deletion of Jody St. Michael WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13443 11294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ulrich Mohrhoff User:Xxanthippe 00:26, 17 August 2013 (UTC) delete On data above-too early. May pass rof later Deletion of Ulrich Mohrhoff WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
13444 14153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Only Girl User:Peridon 22:50, 28 August 2010 (UTC) delete I can't see why some artistes have an article for every single when there's nothing particularly special about them to differentiate them. Singles like 'MacArthur Park' and 'Layla' obviously have more case as there is interesting and/or important information in them. As to this one, it's not yet released so I feel that applies - even if the company have released rumours about it. I see this sort of thing is promotional, trying to build up a demand Deletion of Only Girl WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13445 13796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamida Khanom User:Eric 03:58, 24 February 2009 (UTC) delete Nice person who should be congratulated, but who passes neither nor Deletion of Hamida Khanom WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13446 8983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ankit Kukreti User:CAPTAIN 08:02, 13 November 2017 (UTC) delete Non-notable .fails Deletion of Ankit Kukreti WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13447 14624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/XCubeLabs User:Walter 05:41, 19 March 2016 (UTC) delete In the Google search I found paid listings and press releases but nothing to satisfy Deletion of XCubeLabs :WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13448 19958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Impeachment resolution against Mike DeWine User:Twassman 16:51, 1 December 2020 (UTC) delete into Mike_DeWine#Impeachment_resolution. Certainly worth covering, but probably does not merit its own article per Deletion of Impeachment resolution against Mike DeWine WP:NOPAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13449 6729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/4-D (The X-Files) User:Pixelface 08:14, 11 February 2009 (UTC) keep per and over http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wiki_is_not_paper&oldid=917 seven years of precedent for episode articles. It's an episode of a notable TV show. That's why you could create all those Doctor Who episode articles, Sceptre Deletion of 4-D (The X-Files) WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13450 11574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GitPrime User:HighKing 11:16, 29 May 2018 (UTC) delete Zero indications of notability. Wikipedia is not a platform for promotion nor a substitute for a corporate website. Fails GNG and Deletion of GitPrime WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13451 11989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Jackson (conductor) (2nd nomination) User:Voceditenore 16:24, 24 September 2015 (UTC) delete """There are two ways this could pass the criteria for inclusion. (1) the general notability guideline () which requires significant in depth coverage from multiple independent sources. (2) The alternative criteria at . Re (1), the only reference that remotely qualifies is an interview which ORF (broadcaster)|ORF publishes for the (many) recipients of its grants to promising young musicians. None of the rest qualify. Note that the first reference http://www.allesklassik.org/2013/06/a-maestro-is-born-stroke-of-luck-for.html looks like an article about him but it's a PR piece from ''""""AllesKlassik-PR&Organisation- Salzburg. Excellent references for classical artists""""''. The remainder are all minor festival notices and potted bios (not independent of the the subject). Re (2), the subject fails to pass any of the criteria, e.g. two recordings with a notable classical music label or winning a major prize (none of the ones listed fall remotely into the category) or being the permanent conductor of a major symphony orchestra (or the guest conductor of multiple major symphony orchestras). Some of the ones that the article claims he has conducted are major, but seem to have been conducted not as part of the orchestra's regular concert season but as part of master classes and conducting courses which the subject took. The fact that not a single review can be cited for the major orchestras he claims to have conducted further suggests that. The London Symphony Orchestra is referenced to a broken link and I can find no mention of him on the LSO site""" Deletion of George Jackson (conductor) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13452 215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Smooth Island (Ontario) User:AadaamS 09:38, 21 December 2014 (UTC) merge and '''Redirect''' to Ontario article. The island can be mentioned there, article only has to be verifiable, not notable Deletion of Smooth Island (Ontario) WP:V||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13453 20812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russia national bandy team User:Snottywong 17:34, 1 November 2010 (UTC) keep as bandy is, after all, a Russian sport and they appear to be probably the best team in the world, and therefore probably the most well-known. However, I still think that '''merging''' all of these national bandy team articles to something like List of national bandy teams would be the best result. The Russian team is probably the only one that has enough verifiable information for anything close to a full article. Perhaps it could be |split from the list article Deletion of Russia national bandy team WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Splitting 57
13454 10753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salim Rambo User:ArcAngel 07:24, 7 December 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Salim Rambo WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13455 14780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grace Lutheran Church Sheyenne, ND User:Pmedema 17:22, 27 March 2008 (UTC) delete to Sheyenne, North Dakota. This church is mentioned in that article. I can't find anything that puts this church above the standards in or Deletion of Grace Lutheran Church Sheyenne, ND WP:N||WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13456 5032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Get Paper User:RP459 22:03, 14 February 2010 (UTC) delete fails & no significant 3rd party coverage which would allow it to pass Deletion of I Get Paper WP:NOTABILITY||WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13457 6678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yugioh the abridged series User:206 17:32, 27 December 2006 (UTC) delete As much as |I like it, that's no reason to keep it. Perhaps someday, if someone reputable outside the Youtube community recognizes it, then it might be notable. It's not right now Deletion of Yugioh the abridged series WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13458 4050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gjertrud Fitje User:Mentoz86 20:22, 26 January 2012 (UTC) delete Only found http://www.firdatidend.no/nyhet.cfm?nyhetid=4022 this - doesn't pass Deletion of Gjertrud Fitje WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13459 596 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The CIA, al-Qaeda, and the """"war on terror""""""" User:Doc 15:13, 13 September 2008 (UTC) delete WP:SOAP|Soapy #OR|personal essay """Deletion of The CIA, al-Qaeda, and the """"war on terror""""""" WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13460 16195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antonio Barbucci User:Scope 20:59, 17 November 2007 (UTC) keep I don't this he does fails . Rolling into Genoa Joint Laboratories would be a good idea Deletion of Antonio Barbucci WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13461 8343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doyle Beatenbough User:AuthorAuthor 03:16, 20 August 2019 (UTC) delete per nom. Coverage of the subject is not wide enough to show notability, thus it fails Deletion of Doyle Beatenbough WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13462 9276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manut pa User:Amatulic 16:21, 1 December 2014 (UTC) delete """agree this is a dictionary definition, and appears to be based completely on |original research. Not only does the article contain its own OR, but its citations are also pure OR. Of the 3 sources cited, the blog citation is not appropriate, the manager.co.th is an editorial piece, and the Bangkok Post piece consists of more OR and personal commentary by the author in the Lifestyle section — hardly authoritative sources. As to the coverage identified by Paul_012 above, only one of them might be considered a bona-fide article; all the others are purely personal commentary. Is an obscure """"lifestyle"""" writer's original research worthy of representation in a global encyclopedia?That said, the content of this article ''could'' be kept as part of a larger list article on Thai vocabulary, similar to Singlish vocabulary, which includes similar terms""" Deletion of Manut pa WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13463 7400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clairgnosis User:JohnCD 18:58, 18 November 2009 (UTC) delete """as neologism and self-promotion. sets a high bar for articles about neologisms: """"''Articles on protologisms are usually deleted as these articles are often created in an attempt to use Wikipedia to increase usage of the term.''"""" In this case I note that the article is by {{user1|Shealyhealy}}, an |SPA, and that the references are a book by Sherry Healy and the website shealyinternational.com""" Deletion of Clairgnosis WP:NEO||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
13464 4245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Liw User:Lepricavark 16:46, 17 January 2018 (UTC) keep weak nom statement that indicates failure to do and lack of familiarity with the subject. These reckless nominations really need to stop soon, or a topic ban will be pursued Deletion of Daniel Liw WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13465 7432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Starbucks Workers Union (2nd nomination) User:Namiba 03:37, 13 February 2021 (UTC) keep it easily passes with stories about the organization itself in the Boston Globe, Seattle Times, New York Times, and Wall Street Journal to name a few. A quick search of newspapers.com also reveals a number of other sources in newspapers across the United States. There is also https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=w277BgAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PA1&dq=%22Starbucks+Workers+Union%22&ots=ODV8knsUlY&sig=YdImzVsL8q5KcOnh41rIO-6II08 a book written about it by Staughton Lynd and numerous other mentions of varying levels of depth available via Google Scholar Deletion of Starbucks Workers Union (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13466 12665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Episource LLC User:The 16:34, 13 June 2021 (UTC) delete on account of lack of significant coverage in multiple sources. All we have are advertorials such as https://aws.amazon.com/solutions/case-studies/episource/ this, an |interview with the CEO (see https://insidebigdata.com/2017/08/24/big-data-makes-mobile-health-care-apps-healthier/ link), etc. The text, incidentally, has been created by the latest mutation of the |single-purpose account: within the space of a few days, we get a flurry of irrelevant contributions (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bora_Bora&diff=prev&oldid=1027441257 here, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=David_Tyrrell_(physician)&diff=prev&oldid=1027586105 here, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=South_Mumbai&diff=prev&oldid=1027595914 here, etc) and then the pay shot of the https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Episource_LLC&action=history acticle creation. A clear case of |promotional work Deletion of Episource LLC WP:PSTS||WP:SPA||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:No original research 65
13467 12678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 America East Men's Soccer Tournament NONE NONE keep Per my comment above, the article ''meets'' the notability guidelines of for the following reasons Deletion of 2017 America East Men's Soccer Tournament WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13468 2221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 Chick-fil-A gay-marriage freedom of speech controversy User:Casprings 02:40, 4 August 2012 (UTC) keep Meets no question Deletion of 2012 Chick-fil-A gay-marriage freedom of speech controversy WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13469 4227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Consumption junction User:Royboycrashfan 00:26, 1 March 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Consumption junction WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
13470 7925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kleargear (2nd nomination) [[User talk:5.104.108.125|talk]]) 19:04, 10 July 2014 (UTC) delete The Company is not notable fails and why should it be kept ? Further William Franklin Bermender has nothing to do with Kleargear controversy why has his NAME been put up he quit in 2007 .MOST OF THEM VOTING KEEP ARE NOT SAYING THE COMPANY IS NOTABLE ONLY THE CASE IS PLEASE DELETE AND REWRITE AN ARTICLE ON THE CASE.Special:Contributions/5.104.108.125|5.104.108.125 Deletion of Kleargear (2nd nomination) WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13471 2685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2002 George W. Bush pretzel incident (2nd nomination) user:mikkalai 19:11, 3 July 2007 (UTC) keep And write George Bush visits a Bulgarian Hospital if there are multiple reliable sources with sufficient text to write an article which will be more than a simple expansion of the article title. |Wikipedia is not paper. Public activities of notable public figures are notable Deletion of 2002 George W. Bush pretzel incident (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13472 5805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1944 D-Day Operation Overlord (videogame) User:Haemo 06:31, 27 July 2007 (UTC) delete as |crystal ballery. This is a game by an indie publisher with no fixed release date, which may (or may not) come out Deletion of 1944 D-Day Operation Overlord (videogame) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13473 7619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pixie Davies (2nd nomination) User:Bakazaka 06:19, 14 January 2019 (UTC) keep """If this is about the broader notability guidelines, Wikipedia talk:Notability (people) is thataway. Pretty much no one accepts that a single AfD is some binding notability guideline update. (Neither does the nominator, obviously, since they are rejecting a previous AfD.) The subject meets #1 with verifiable """"significant roles in multiple notable films, television shows, stage performances, or other productions."""" There are sources available for verification and expansion, including the ones that Lourdes pointed out in the last AfD""" Deletion of Pixie Davies (2nd nomination) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13474 13113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Head User:Jonathanwallace 17:40, 30 April 2011 (UTC) keep notable for being a female employed in an unusual and dangerous occupation. means that we should not cover random events which happen one day, but should not be used to delete articles which have additional subtext and significance, such as this one. Similarly, is usually used as an argument to delete very generic repetitive events (non-notable murder, disappearance or death sentence). When we reach the point when female bomb disposal experts are everywhere, those arguments will pertain to this kind of article Deletion of Lisa Head WP:1E||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13475 18495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sagar Pradhan User:CAPTAIN 20:42, 30 March 2017 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability per Deletion of Sagar Pradhan WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13476 13323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lauren Anderson User:Hrafn 17:25, 2 May 2011 (UTC) delete """no indication of """"''significant'' roles in multiple ''notable'' films, television shows, stage performances, or other productions"""", so fails """ Deletion of Lauren Anderson WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13477 6277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mouse That Ate The Cat User:Roscelese 04:45, 10 June 2011 (UTC) delete The BBC playlist is a reliable source, but it doesn't establish notability. No coverage, no acclaim that satisfies Deletion of The Mouse That Ate The Cat WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
13478 21102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Berg v. Obama User:Nrswanson 02:03, 21 October 2008 (UTC) delete The long term notability of this case is not clear and since notability is not a temporary thing on wikipedia this article really should be deleted. Wikipedia is #NEWS|not the news. However, the case probably should be mentioned under Barack Obama presidential primary campaign, 2008#Issues about Obama's ethnic and religious affiliation during the campaign Deletion of Berg v. Obama WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13479 4133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ITunes version history User:Shoyrudude555 02:14, 24 September 2007 (UTC) delete Not encyclopedic. (Can you imagine looking this up in Brittanica?) While , borders on listcruft Deletion of ITunes version history WP:ITSUSEFUL Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13480 8088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clyde Lewis (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 16:00, 8 May 2018 (UTC) delete """Having or not having a Wikipedia article is not a question of free speech vs. censorship, it's a question of notability vs. non-notability — but notability is not established by ''what'' an article says, it's established by how well the article |reliably sources what it says. However, the referencing here is ''far'' too dependent on his own |primary source content about himself, which does ''not'' help to establish notability: people get Wikipedia articles by being the ''subject'' of reliable source coverage, ''not'' by being the ''author'' of their own |self-published sources about ''themselves''. The only reference that actually counts as a reliable or notability-assisting source is a piece in his own hometown alt-weekly — so that reference would be fine ''if'' the rest of the sourcing around it were better, but it does not singlehandedly confer a pass all by itself as an article's ''only'' valid source. Nothing here is """"inherently"""" notable enough to hand him an automatic inclusion freebie just because he exists — but the sourcing is simply not cutting it""" Deletion of Clyde Lewis (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:SELFPUB||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13481 2583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beaverton, Montana User:Carlossuarez46 22:23, 6 January 2015 (UTC) keep obviously; meets , real place recognized by the US govt; being a gazetteer is one of the Wikipedia:Five pillars Deletion of Beaverton, Montana WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
13482 17045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Forever (website) (2nd nomination) User:HighKing 18:14, 19 January 2017 (UTC) comment Actually the opposite is true. None of the sources you've mentioned meet since none are independent of the subject (and if you read them, it is very clear that the articles epitomize the definition of an advertorial Deletion of Forever (website) (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13483 10230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Freckle fetishism User:Isotope23 14:27, 3 August 2006 (UTC) delete as this is not |verified. Google hits I see are blogs and forums... not |reliable source... while I'm sure there are people out there who have this fetish, this is an excellent example of what refers to when it states '''verifiability, not truth Deletion of Freckle fetishism WP:V||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13484 10508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Public menorah User:Brewcrewer 23:22, 19 December 2009 (UTC) merge """per above. The article name is a made up term (a menorah is inherently """"public"""") and the article includes a bunch of . The topic of the First Amendment vis a vis these """"public menoras"""" is notable and if formatted correctly worthy of its own article, but this whole / article started off on the wrong track""" Deletion of Public menorah WP:SYNTH||WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
13485 12852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paula Fatic User:Coredesat 18:51, 7 August 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Paula Fatic WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13486 15602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019 Sri Lankan Swiss embassy controversy User:Juxlos 17:19, 5 December 2019 (UTC) keep I don't see this as a event and this clearly passes GNG. Not a major reason to delete Deletion of 2019 Sri Lankan Swiss embassy controversy WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13487 21111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oil pulling (2nd nomination) User:Lesion 11:16, 29 March 2014 (UTC) keep """someone can demonstrate that it can be expanded using reliable sources enough to justify a stand alone article, otherwise seems like duplication currently. Atm, there is little content on oil pulling which has been easily merged... but there is room to expand a stand alone article if someone is willing to do the work. Problem is reliable sources. To discuss the effects of oil pulling on health, we would need sources. Only 7 sources on PubMed with search """"oil pulling""""... most appear to be primary sources. However, there are ~170 results for search terms like """"essential oil mouthwash"""", not sure if it would be OR to link these to the oil pulling article if those articles do not explicitly use the term. I had a look for sources on oil pulling in google books too, and the first few pages were Alt med industry type books which were not reliable sources so I gave up. Might be worth also pointing out that oil pulling could be significantly expanded using non MEDRS sources, from a historical and cultural point of view, as long as such sources were not used to suggest that these essential oil mouthwashes have health effects, or to contradict what the more reliable scientific sources are saying""" Deletion of Oil pulling (2nd nomination) WP:MEDRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13488 19944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/City Fidelia User:No 09:25, 12 December 2016 (UTC) delete Not enough independent coverage to satisfy or . https://noisey.vice.com/en_ca/article/city-fidelia This source might constitute significant coverage, but there would need to be others Deletion of City Fidelia WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13489 13196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sintax User:Geschichte 13:20, 18 August 2021 (UTC) delete Band of niche interest. I do not see a breakthrough as of yet. Fails and the or, with a positive twist, we can call it Deletion of Sintax WP:NBAND||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
13490 331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eisenman Synagogue User:Antwerpen 18:20, 9 February 2011 (UTC) keep Meets all the requirements of and in particular the '''General notability guidelines Deletion of Eisenman Synagogue WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13491 9910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of musical artists from Japan User:Shirik 01:17, 6 February 2010 (UTC) keep Definitely not indiscriminate. Qualifies as an index of articles under Deletion of List of musical artists from Japan WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
13492 15290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bier Suppe User:Dragonfiend 06:14, 21 February 2006 (UTC) delete does not appear to meet Deletion of Bier Suppe WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
13493 13959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robby Todino User:B 02:00, 26 October 2008 (UTC) delete per . His 15 minutes of fame are over; all speculation should be removed should this article be kept Deletion of Robby Todino WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13494 10169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Midori (actress) User:Missvain 16:00, 13 January 2020 (UTC) keep I rewrote Midori's article. Sourcing is very interesting sometimes for pornographic actors, not always your typical mainstream coverage. While a few sources are interviews, I do think her historical significant is valuable in porn, women's history, and black history. Also she's consistent with her stories in multiple interviews, when I use oral history (and I do regularly, including when I was Wikipedian in Residence at the Smithsonian) that is something I look for - consistency. Oral history is invaluable in subjects where mainstream media might not be covering the subject. Also see regarding the plethora of reliable secondary sources that we combined to create a substantial piece about her. Anyway, I hope Midori is kept Deletion of Midori (actress) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13495 18848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Happy Corner (2nd nomination) User:Philg88 06:56, 3 August 2014 (UTC) delete """This is a clear case of without prejudice to its recreation under a different title. The current title does not appear to be the |common name in Chinese - """"Happy Corner"""" is only mentioned as an afterthought in the corresponding Chinese article. The only extant content for which sourcing is available is """"Sawing"""" as mentioned above and """"Aruba"""" (the Taiwanese name for the same thing). I would suggest a new article under one of those titles WITHOUT all the wild unreferenced claims made in the """"Working methods"""" section""" Deletion of Happy Corner (2nd nomination) WP:TNT||WP:COMMONNAME Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
13496 15946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Climate change denial (3rd nomination) User:Sumthingweird 15:07, 2 September 2008 (UTC) keep Whitewashing this article would violate Deletion of Climate change denial (3rd nomination) WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
13497 3543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fritz Pflaum Hut User:7 13:53, 7 December 2015 (UTC) keep Clearly a notable and noted structure and an important waypoint for climbers. Given its high perch and relative inaccessibility, the amount of coverage is telling. Moreover, there was no compliance with efore Deletion of Fritz Pflaum Hut WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
13498 2995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vincent Salafia User:Shenme 01:39, 25 April 2006 (UTC) delete per and per Deletion of Vincent Salafia WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13499 17152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of mugshot websites User:Lugnuts 14:15, 12 August 2015 (UTC) delete per NOTDIRECTORY/. A list of non-notable entries. Spam Deletion of List of mugshot websites WP:LINKFARM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13500 1482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bina Bangsa School User:Phil 15:57, 29 November 2011 (UTC) keep per |our usual practice with http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2006/11/28/schools-stepping-out-thriving-pluit.html verifiable high/secondary schools Deletion of Bina Bangsa School WP:NHS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13501 20796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sasha Raskin User:J04n 23:58, 1 April 2013 (UTC) delete unable to find coverage in reliable sources independent of the subject, does not meet Deletion of Sasha Raskin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13502 16622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K. P. Rajagopal User:Pawfeet 11:57, 20 September 2019 (UTC) delete the article fails to meet . Lack of significant coverage to have an independent page. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of K. P. Rajagopal WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13503 3139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/By Time User:Spada2 17:17, 6 May 2020 (UTC) delete not notable enough for Wikipedia, sources can not pass Deletion of By Time WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13504 16103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of the Jews in Haiti User:IZAK 12:12, 12 February 2014 (UTC) keep """firstly because the nominator's application of """""""" is absurd, since relates to misapplication of POVs and has ''nothing'' to do with """"lack of size"""". Secondly, all countries where Jews have lived almost always have unique Jewish histories. The Jewish people and Jewish history in all countries where Jews have lived (no matter how large or small their numbers) are notable subjects as the vast parent :Category:Jewish history by country shows and needs no endorsements from latter-day judges. Thirdly, as Users {{User|Alansohn}} and {{User|CyberXRef}} aptly and ably prove there are multiple and sources that back up and enrich this topic. Just because something is """"small"""" does not make it unimportant or not notable. Finally, the article is a stub and therefore is good advice to let it be. By the way, Jews and Judaism are not a """"sect"""", that is a rather demeaning description""" Deletion of History of the Jews in Haiti WP:UNDUE||WP:RS||WP:V||WP:DONOTDEMOLISH Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
13505 17688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Protection Forum for Bengalee Hindus of Assam User:Starblind 00:13, 15 April 2013 (UTC) delete per . Only briefly mentioned in the lone source given Deletion of Protection Forum for Bengalee Hindus of Assam WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13506 12589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SJK (C) Sin Kwang User:Lemongirl942 14:55, 4 June 2016 (UTC) merge to List of schools in Kedah. This is a legit primary school (See http://ppdkmy.moe.gov.my/index.php/module-styles/jenis-kebangsaan listing at Malaysia MOE). However it doesn't have any claim to notability. Redirecting per seems best Deletion of SJK (C) Sin Kwang WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13507 20003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/August 2010 rocket attack on Eilat/Aqaba User:Supreme 09:44, 1 September 2010 (UTC) delete a non notable news article, per Deletion of August 2010 rocket attack on Eilat/Aqaba WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13508 1653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Murtagh User:Guliolopez 23:35, 24 April 2008 (UTC) delete """per nom and . Precedent is interesting though. There are several other articles on '':Category:Rose of Tralee|Roses'', all of reach read like NN bios plucked from competition press packs. Only Aoibhinn Ní Shúilleabháin has any notability beyond the event. Unless you count some subjects participation in the (...ahem...) """"Celebrity"""" Charity You're A Star""" Deletion of Lisa Murtagh WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13509 12998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prof. Crispus Makau Kiamba User:Coolabahapple 11:46, 16 June 2019 (UTC) keep lets make a |snowman Deletion of Prof. Crispus Makau Kiamba WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
13510 18509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xtreme Football League User:Fuhghettaboutit 13:22, 18 March 2007 (UTC) delete This |unattributed, never-get-beyond-stub material is already present in af2, so no merge necessary Deletion of Xtreme Football League WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
13511 6316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew K User:Stifle 10:03, 21 April 2009 (UTC) delete doesn't seem to meet to me Deletion of Andrew K WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13512 20389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mangos (band) user:Janejellyroll 02:14, 31 December 2006 (UTC) delete Going to be hard to hold to with self publication and, as per Deletion of Mangos (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13513 2589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Sofocleous User:Twinkler4 22:29, 12 July 2007 (UTC) delete """How in the world can this article be improved? It says """"Not much information is available on Sofocleous"""", also if there was someone who could put more info on him I'm guessing it wouldn't follow , because it also says """"it is common knowledge within professional drum circles"""" there will probably be no references or citations""" Deletion of Aaron Sofocleous WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13514 19431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charlie Ahearn User:JoshuaZ 20:44, 13 October 2006 (UTC) comment Could someone explain to me how he meets Deletion of Charlie Ahearn WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13515 14877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Car Mein Music Baja User:Cewbot 00:02, 23 June 2020 (UTC) comment This nomination has had limited participation and falls within the standards set for |lack of quorum. There are no previous AfD discussions, undeletions, or current redirects and no previous PRODs have been located. This nomination may be '''eligible for |soft deletion''' at the end of its 7-day listing Deletion of Car Mein Music Baja WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
13516 9480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Strategic Counsel User:Bearcat 21:52, 16 January 2019 (UTC) delete Just to be clear, from its creation in 2005 the article was always only about the Canadian company until just 12 days ago, when somebody added the Australian lobbying firm as brand new content that was never in the article before this year — but ''neither'' topic has the proper sourcing to support its notability per or , as the Canadian company cites no sources at all (and has never previously had any sources in it before) while the Australian firm cites only its own self-published primary sourcing. And I can't find solid sourcing on a ProQuest search to repair the Canadian company's notability, either — I get a lot of glancing namechecks of its existence in coverage of other things (mainly political or social stories in which SC happens to have done some polling), but I can't find adequate coverage ''about'' SC as a ''subject''. No prejudice against recreation if somebody can actually find the correct kind of sourcing to give one or the other of them much more depth than just a brief statement that it exists, but neither of these topics is cutting it under our notability and sourcing criteria as they actually stand Deletion of The Strategic Counsel WP:CORP||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13517 17551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corpsie User:Dynaflow 22:41, 27 May 2007 (UTC) delete """This is exactly the kind of in-group thing a forum would create its own """"internal"""" wiki for, like http://www.lurkmore.com/wiki/index.php?title=4chan the one those lovely folks at 4chan seem to have put together. There is no need for it to be on Wikipedia, and it doesn't even come close to satisfying . It probably runs afoul of and as well""" Deletion of Corpsie WP:NOTE||WP:OR||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
13518 4592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 asian games User:Black 17:58, 17 March 2007 (UTC) keep per the references added since the start of the AFD (see http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=2018_Asian_Games&diff=114886609&oldid=114598158 diff). no longer seems applicable (it ''is'' notable and almost certain to take place Deletion of 2018 asian games WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13519 5741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joey Bond User:MurderByDeadcopy 05:54, 30 January 2016 (UTC) keep passes & per Collect Deletion of Joey Bond WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13520 9128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Green Guys User:Orangemike 19:08, 1 October 2009 (UTC) comment """Local ABC affiliate coverage (brief); anybody, including me, can have an IMDb listing - see {{imdb name|2271158|Michael J. """"Orange Mike"""" Lowrey}}; and |you don't """"catch"""" notability by working with notable people""" Deletion of Green Guys :WP:NOTCONTAGIOUS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13521 7241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Forgue User:Arxiloxos 20:20, 15 October 2016 (UTC) delete As a newly created article lacking sources, this article could be deletable under . And my searches turned up no sources to indicate |notability Deletion of Eric Forgue WP:BLPPROD||WP:N Wikipedia:Proposed deletion of biographies of living people 66
13522 1244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Hardy (professional boxer) User:Papaursa 18:48, 27 July 2013 (UTC) delete I see nothing that shows notability. He obviously fails to meet and I don't see the coverage necessary to meet Deletion of Anthony Hardy (professional boxer) WP:NBOX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13523 21876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Beake User:onel5969 11:17, 28 July 2018 (UTC) delete as per nom. A journeyman assistant coach who doesn't pass or Deletion of Chris Beake WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13524 4959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruth Lovell Stanners User:PKT 13:42, 19 September 2014 (UTC) delete the news pieces I found were all local news outlets referring to her candidacy or her marriage, save the one Globe and Mail article dealing with the airport naming issue. I don't see enough to meet guidelines Deletion of Ruth Lovell Stanners WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
13525 15628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paula Schwarz User:Eggishorn 21:15, 20 March 2020 (UTC) keep Irish Times'' is a RS and there is in ''TechCrunch'' and ''https://mashable.com/2015/11/08/refugees-technology-aid/ Mashable'' plus Forbes' ''30 Under 30'' is a significant award. It adds up to GNG compliance. AFD is not cleanup also applies Deletion of Paula Schwarz WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
13526 891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mualigbe Keita User:Nwlaw63 17:16, 14 December 2011 (UTC) delete As above, a player in development academy isn't close to qualifying under Deletion of Mualigbe Keita WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13527 4172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frederick Butterfield (2nd nomination) User:K 06:08, 22 October 2016 (UTC) merge after delete) to List_of_British_supercentenarians#Chronological_list_of_the_oldest_living_person_in_the_United_Kingdom_since_1963 where the subject is already discussed. Not enough source material to build a balanced article and thus this falls under Deletion of Frederick Butterfield (2nd nomination) WP:WHYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
13528 2049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Schwartz (3rd nomination) User:Bearian 21:17, 23 October 2020 (UTC) delete per . He may be a mover and shaker, and up and coming, but has not had significant coverage in reliable sources. The ''Forbes'' pages do not count towards notability Deletion of Adam Schwartz (3rd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
13529 4405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of narrative forms User:Cybercobra 09:13, 7 October 2009 (UTC) keep Meets with the editing that happened subsequent to my previous vote Deletion of List of narrative forms WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
13530 3926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fixiraq.com User:Coredesat 09:44, 22 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Fixiraq.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
13531 15018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Affle User:Narky 10:55, 17 August 2018 (UTC) delete I looked at all 104 citations, and concur with nom's analysis. I did not see a single independent in-depth source. A classic case of . Fails Deletion of Affle WP:RS||WP:REFBOMBING||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13532 15021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dj Ernesty User:Jacwizy 17:54, 28 March 2020 (UTC) keep meets and Deletion of Dj Ernesty WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13533 17199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013 Elon Phoenix football team User:Paulmcdonald 01:31, 26 July 2013 (UTC) keep """there presently is already information in the media about the season. Although the first game of the season has yet to be played, significant discussion about the season has begun and that is enough to pass the requirement of , specifically point 1: """"Individual scheduled or expected future events should be included only if the event is notable and almost certain to take place."""" The season clearly passes for notability and it is almost certain to take place, thus clearly passing the threshold""" Deletion of 2013 Elon Phoenix football team WP:CRYSTAL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13534 18103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Catholic University Law Review User:Bearian 01:08, 30 July 2009 (UTC) keep academic journal, Impact factor|well known in the Legal community. |Catholic University is not my favorite school, but so what Deletion of Catholic University Law Review WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13535 13799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sound object User:Walter 23:28, 15 July 2021 (UTC) keep A bit of would have led the nom to see it is notable: https://www.sfu.ca/sonic-studio-webdav/handbook/Sound_Object.html https://www.audiokinetic.com/library/edge/?source=Help&id=what_is_sound_object https://monoskop.org/images/0/01/Chion_Michel_Guide_To_Sound_Objects_Pierre_Schaeffer_and_Musical_Research.pdf I also found two scholarly articles that used the concept of sound objects in their titles. We do not look that the state of an article to determine if a subject is or is not notable Deletion of Sound object :WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13536 1785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russ Canzler User:Ohnoitsjamie 18:07, 5 October 2009 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet requirements Deletion of Russ Canzler WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13537 15973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minds Eye Entertainment User:Dmehus 01:16, 6 February 2020 (UTC) delete """per because ''as written'', that's all this is: an article that says this is the name of the film production company and these are a partial list of films this company has produced. We can get this from IMDb. Like {{u|MarkH21}}, I noted the same article that likely meets , but we need ''at least'' one more article to meet (|three to five would be ''better''). So it's ''maybe'' otability|notable, but even then, I'm not sure we get to . I wouldn't be opposed to draftification (arguably, this article should've been draftified or PRODed to save us the AfD), but there's nothing here worth keeping. Most of the coverage I found was |reliable source coverage about films they've made or are going to make, which I doubt qualify as they're not ''about'' the ''company'', such as http://www.kelownadailycourier.ca/news/article_3cdedd32-c2d1-11e9-b20d-3ffc0f38f7bc.html this one about a film called """"Endless,"""" shot in my hometown and principal residence of Kelowna. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatoon/minds-eye-entertainment-wesley-snipes-regina-2016-1.3711290 This one about ''The Recall'', a Total Recall (1990 film)|Total Recall remake from 2016 starring Wesley Snipes, which was also shot in Kelowna, might get us closer to qualifying as it does discuss the company in a minimal way, whereas https://okanaganedge.net/2018/06/19/big-film-set-okanagan/ this one meets our criteria of it coming from a |reliable source, but it's not ''about'' the company""" Deletion of Minds Eye Entertainment WP:NOTCATALOGUE||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG||WP:THREE||WP:N||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13538 19391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hai-Lung Dai User:Randykitty 12:50, 29 June 2016 (UTC) comment """The nominator is also the article's creator and seems to have included the rationale in the edit summary instead in the text of the nomination, it was """"I would like to delete this entry as the provost is no longer in this role"""". This is, however, an invalid reason. The article has major issues regarding neutrality, but this is also not relevant. What is, is the fact that it may be failing . I'll ping""" Deletion of Hai-Lung Dai WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13539 3513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buck’s Store Museum User:Lightburst 01:02, 10 September 2020 (UTC) delete or '''Merge''' per Onel5969.s suggestion. I had hoped I would be able to dig up some newsprint from 1888-present, but I searched every way possible and found none. As it is this is a local curiosity and perhaps a source of pride for a small community. As -M would fit with our policy Deletion of Buck’s Store Museum WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13540 17217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One Chance (film) User:Ohnoitsjamie 22:38, 2 September 2013 (UTC) keep Enough references to easily pass Deletion of One Chance (film) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13541 6896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of current members of the United States House of Representatives by age User:Notecardforfree 19:24, 30 December 2015 (UTC) delete I agree that this is a with Current members of the United States House of Representatives, which you can sort by the members' year of birth (see -REASON). The author clearly put a lot of work into this page, and if they want to preserve the information, I would encourage them to add the date and month of birth for current members at Current members of the United States House of Representatives (but please make sure to substantiate all assertions with citations to reliable sources Deletion of List of current members of the United States House of Representatives by age WP:CONTENTFORK||WP:DEL Wikipedia:Content forking 33
13542 15444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LeafyisHere User:Kyle1278 00:26, 12 April 2016 (UTC) delete one source; it does not come close to one refrence for a bio article is not near enough for notability. Just like it says on the Talk:List of YouTubers 'YouTube ranking and Google hits do not make an account notable Deletion of LeafyisHere WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13543 13430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Bentley User:GiantSnowman 14:32, 16 July 2011 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Daniel Bentley WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13544 4262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pak Watan User:Boing 09:22, 14 March 2012 (UTC) delete Ignoring all the arguments about interaction bans, bad faith, etc, the article only has a definition of the word plus examples of its uses in song lyrics - and that looks like a textbook to me. If there are sources out there that refer to it in more than a dicdef way, I'm not seeing them - but if anyone can find any and expand the article with what they say, I'll be happy to change my mind Deletion of Pak Watan WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
13545 2389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Summersteps Records User:Joe 00:29, 25 January 2010 (UTC) delete Having two notable acts doesn't equal notability per Deletion of Summersteps Records WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13546 15786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AVI Sound International (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 13:26, 5 May 2017 (UTC) delete The first AFD closed no consensus, and even that was primarily due to low participation rather than any particularly strong evidence of notability — the only keep vote present there was from an SPA who worked ''only'' on articles about loudspeaker manufacturers, with a rationale that amounted to pleading for time to strengthen the sourcing without actually showing any concrete evidence that improved sourcing was actually possible. And no improvement took place afterward either, as that participant made only four further edits to Wikipedia after that discussion concluded of which ''none'' were to ''this'' article. The depth of sourcing needed to make it notable simply is not there, and nothing stated in the article entitles it to a free presumption of notability in the absence of a pass Deletion of AVI Sound International (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13547 16304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Jones (scientist) User:Jesswade88 20:04, 28 February 2021 (UTC) keep Note, I started this page. I don't think that citations are a very useful metric, Jones has contributed to both scientific discoveries and education/academic culture. Jones developed a novel structural probe to better understand cell membranes. She serves as co-Director of the Meyerhoff Graduate Fellowship Program, which produced distinguished scholars such as Kizzmekia Corbett. I see in keeping this page up Deletion of Lisa Jones (scientist) WP:NOHARM Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13548 21575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erin Morrow Hawley User:Galobtter 08:46, 6 December 2017 (UTC) merge per DGG. It's clear that she doesn't so far have enough publications or cites in them for showing influence. Whether most law clerks for the supreme court eventually become notable is not important as she's not notable right now - perhaps an article can be created later but not now. Most women law professors would not meet because most professors don't - it's based on the average professor test: someone has to be more influential than the average professor Deletion of Erin Morrow Hawley WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13549 7826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SYKOM User:Bejnar 21:08, 20 July 2014 (UTC) delete as #G11|CSD G11 promotional only, despite the thin veneer of apparent objectivity. Otherwise, this is pure nothing, no book (), first novel, self-published, no independent sources, two non-existent sequels, etc. Fails , fails Deletion of SYKOM WP:CSD||WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
13550 11407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Where Troy Once Stood NONE 21:02, 8 October 2006 (UTC) keep weak deletion reason. See . Feureau Deletion of Where Troy Once Stood WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13551 12872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SynapseIndia User:Ihcoyc 15:28, 23 October 2013 (UTC) delete WP:MILL|Yet another |IT outsourcing business |advertising on Wikipedia. Article says nothing that would make this business worthy of remembrance in an encyclopedia Deletion of SynapseIndia WP:B2B||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
13552 2628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Kastle User:Pburka 18:14, 21 February 2009 (UTC) keep Signed to a major record label. Well sourced. Easily passes Deletion of Richard Kastle WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13553 4068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Dicks User:JoshuaZ 23:55, 15 October 2006 (UTC) keep Seems notable and the basic matters seem sourced. Unsourced problematic info should be subject to of course but that doesn't mean we shouldn't have an article. Furthermore, most of the unsourced comments (like being the nephew of Givens) is not a problem Deletion of James Dicks WP:LIVING||WP:LIVING Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13554 12800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Discworld languages User:Quasirandom 17:45, 8 November 2007 (UTC) merge per , probably per Pinball22's suggestion to a Language's section in Discworld Deletion of Discworld languages WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13555 21669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rupert Sandilands User:Spiderone 22:15, 3 November 2020 (UTC) keep meets due to England caps; also http://www.englandfootballonline.com/TeamPlyrsBios/PlayersS/BioSandilandsRR.html is a source. Not sure why you want to delete footballing Ruperts Deletion of Rupert Sandilands WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13556 13817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fistgate User:N5iln 13:29, 22 March 2011 (UTC) merge to MassResistance article. Not sufficiently notable for a standalone article, borderline which may actually dictate deletion Deletion of Fistgate WP:SCANDAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13557 2032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Margaret Gel User:discospinster 15:04, 9 July 2021 (UTC) delete """As I said in the proposed deletion: """"No indication of notability per or . The sources provided are not ''about'' her, but she is only mentioned. I am unable to find multiple reliable sources with significant discussion of the individual""" Deletion of Margaret Gel WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13558 6166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Sumner User:Niteshift36 14:00, 21 May 2010 (UTC) delete Fails . A couple of self-pubs books and some pieces in a niche website aren't going to get him past it Deletion of Alex Sumner WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13559 20906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Everest of Apples User:Tree 08:50, 30 June 2006 (UTC) delete per , non-notable charity. Only 803 google results http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Everest+of+Apples%22, few of which are relevant Deletion of Everest of Apples WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13560 20745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Highway Cricket Club User:Joseph2302 19:44, 3 August 2016 (UTC) delete Non-notable club, fails and . I've lived in Tile Hill and never heard of them before Deletion of Highway Cricket Club WP:GNG||WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13561 4066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Doran User:GiantSnowman 18:09, 25 January 2014 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Christopher Doran WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13562 6893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Infinito 2017 (2nd nomination) User:Potatoswatter 08:11, 26 October 2008 (UTC) delete interviews aren't secondary sources and don't establish notability. The article itself says nothing about his music besides listing the album/track names. It's just a laundry list bio and therefore likely Deletion of Infinito 2017 (2nd nomination) WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
13563 14211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of -cons User:Sephiroth 02:20, 5 September 2007 (UTC) delete per #INFO and above. Giant directory of links Deletion of List of -cons WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13564 2188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chantra User:Ihcoyc 15:57, 18 December 2009 (UTC) delete Notability is |not inherited, and it looks like this disc is simply a compilation that distributes software that could all be had from other sources, and as such seems trivial. This is like saying that since Jingle Bells is a notable song, if I make a holiday mix disc that contains Jingle Bells, my mix disc is an encyclopedia subject too Deletion of Chantra WP:INHERIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13565 10712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canonist User:Urthogie 21:50, 11 February 2007 (UTC) comment I recognize this will probably be deleted, but I think it's unfair to claim this is based on any objective measure. If you got to , you see that its criteria are ''disputed.'' This page was created on the basis of having been references in the mainstream media, and contrary to what has been said here, it is not referenced solely in regards to being one of the many jewish blogs. Just thought I'd say this. Carry on Deletion of Canonist WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
13566 6922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Alghawi User:Qworty 00:47, 26 September 2012 (UTC) delete The guy wants a career in politics, so he thinks the way to do it is to come here and write an article about himself. Well, that's not how it works on Wikipedia, and it's not how it works in the political world, either. Fails --by a landslide Deletion of Aaron Alghawi WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
13567 16540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bikash Narjinary User:GiantSnowman 21:17, 5 April 2012 (UTC) delete non-notable player who fails and Deletion of Bikash Narjinary WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13568 16904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erin Hardy User:Joseph2302 09:54, 13 November 2016 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Erin Hardy WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13569 21132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Ramsey User:Dhartung 10:31, 5 October 2006 (UTC) delete per even if it were verifiable Deletion of Matt Ramsey WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13570 16740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nokia 1600 (3rd nomination) User:Edison 17:31, 10 June 2008 (UTC) delete No references to show that it satisfies |notability requirements. Simply being a product offered for sale by a large company in no way provides inherent notability. Wikipedia is not a surrogate of the vendor's webpage. If being offered for sale by a large company was sufficient notability to justify an article, then since notability is not temporary, every product '''ever''' offered for sale by a large company would be notable. I would not oppose a redirect to a list of Nokia products, although even such a list will sometimes have questionable notability. Imagine a list of every product ever sold by Sears|Sears Roebuck in the last 115 years Deletion of Nokia 1600 (3rd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13571 4187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Marvel Comics endearments User:J 05:42, 23 March 2007 (UTC) delete """I can see how this has some value. But that value is geared more towards an encyclopedia covering either comic books or marvel specifically. In a general use encyclopedia it seems out of place. Also, looking at the guide lines for the creator articles () and character article () it seems the inclusion of """"nicknames"""" is frowned on in those places. Since that is where you would normally expect to find this stuff, this list begins to look very out of place. (''Note:'' the character nicknames were not limited to use in the editorial texts, they permeate the scripted dialogues through out the comics in question. I'm surprised that Hulk's terms for other characters didn't make the list""" Deletion of List of Marvel Comics endearments WP:BIO||WP:CMC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13572 343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PEOBASE User:Qwertyus 08:20, 13 June 2015 (UTC) delete """per #A7: """"does not indicate why its subject is important or significant""" Deletion of PEOBASE WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
13573 21066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sexual abuse scandal in the Anglican Diocese of Sydney [[User talk:202.124.75.207|talk]]) 02:34, 4 February 2012 (UTC) comment There seems to be a breach of here, given that the case described by the article did not involve a finding of guilt by the Royal Commission, the civil action failed, and there was no criminal case. If there is a story here, it is how and why the Anglican Diocese of Sydney improved its processes, but apart from the actual Diocesan policies, I can't find any material on that. -- Special:Contributions/202.124.75.207|202.124.75.207 Deletion of Sexual abuse scandal in the Anglican Diocese of Sydney WP:PERP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13574 5387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Dorri Nowkoorani User:Blue 18:47, 19 May 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. I can't find anything to show he passes Deletion of Ali Dorri Nowkoorani WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13575 17122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Florida State–Notre Dame football rivalry User:SportingFlyer 13:06, 19 November 2019 (UTC) delete At the time both teams were excellent (1993–94) the Tampa Bay Times did a survey showing Florida State fans at least somewhat viewed Notre Dame as a rival: www.newspapers.com/image/339689502/. However, I'm still a delete !vote - it's not a true in the sense that USC-Notre Dame, Michigan-Notre Dame, et cetera would be, and there's no coverage outside of about 1994 or 1996, when the teams played important games against each other Deletion of Florida State–Notre Dame football rivalry WP:NRIVALRY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13576 5777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of national IQ estimates from Lynn and Vanhanen (2002, 2006) User:RJHall 21:38, 27 December 2011 (UTC) delete because of a lack of independent sources. I think this table is already adequately represented with the :File:InvertedIQbyCountry.png image used in the ''IQ and the Wealth of Nations'' article. The reasons supplied by the nom. carried no weight for me (with regard to this AfD) because they are irrelevant to the question of satisfying . Regards Deletion of List of national IQ estimates from Lynn and Vanhanen (2002, 2006) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13577 11354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dremora (band) User:Eliz81 19:34, 12 August 2007 (UTC) delete only just released their first EP, fails at least for now. Once they release a full album, it might be a different. situation Deletion of Dremora (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13578 13044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quechev User:Euryalus 02:54, 7 December 2007 (UTC) delete """fails the |notability guideline - there is no significant coverage in reliable sources (in fact there is no coverage anywhere at all, insignificant or otherwise). Fails both points at EO - the article is an attempted dictionary definition and even the article creator acknowledges there is no evidence to support its widespread use (other than vague statements about growth in """"major population centres""""). With respect, this has the classic signs of something simply |made up one day""" Deletion of Quechev WP:N||WP:NEO||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13579 17884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southern Ontario Model United Nations Association User:Metropolitan90 01:48, 17 May 2020 (UTC) delete fails basic and - there just isn't in-depth coverage. Model United Nations organizations with hundreds of attendees are a dime a dozen Deletion of Southern Ontario Model United Nations Association WP:GNG||WP:CLUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
13580 16341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colegio La Fe User:TerriersFan 23:53, 10 June 2012 (UTC) keep the claim in the nomination that the page lacks sources is not a reason for deletion; it's a reason for improvement. No evidence of a search for sources in Spanish nor that a local search has been carried out. We delete when a subject is inherently non-notable or when the necessary sources have been shown not to exist. Neither applies here; no reason to assume that cannot be met. The way we build Wikipedia is by extending content not by lazy deletions Deletion of Colegio La Fe WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13581 251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arbella Ewing User:David 15:59, 31 December 2015 (UTC) delete """There's nothing encyclopedic here.The lede has more information about other people than it does about the subject. It's all about where the subject stood in relation to other especially long-lived people in a mythical competition to breathe longer.The body is similarly bereft of anything that belongs in an encyclopedia. Her family considered her a gem and attributed her longevity to positive thinking. Her parents were from Mississippi. She broke her hip at one of her last birthday parties and wound up in a nursing home. She lived, worked, married, had a child and died. Far from """"an exceptionally strong claim of notability"""", there's barely any at all.|Notability requires |significant coverage in multiple, independent |reliable sources. What we have here is profoundly insignificant coverage, and all for the non-inherently notable attribute of deferring the visit of the Grim Reaper a bit longer than most. Birthday greetings and an obit, plus a mention on a GRG table of old people who died in 2008 just doesn't cut it.Arguing in the alternative, if others think this null set of a subject does scrape by our |general notability guideline, (although how, I cannot imagine) then OPAGE counsels that a list and not a stand-alone article is the proper resolution here""" Deletion of Arbella Ewing WP:N||WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:NOPAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13582 21268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/November 1998 TRL Countdowns User:QuiteUnusual 21:57, 21 October 2006 (UTC) delete per everyone else, falls foul of Deletion of November 1998 TRL Countdowns WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13583 293 [[Calvin Hollywood]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Magiers NONE keep Kasten|1= gemäß Diskussion. Auch wenn nicht alles im eigentlichen Sinne Bücher sind, sind die #Autoren aus meiner Sicht erfüllt. Gruß Löschung von Calvin Hollywood Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
13584 16884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MystiCon User:Hobit 03:29, 8 April 2011 (UTC) keep I'd been aware of the large number of convention nominations from ANI, but got here via Erfworld. Looking at the sources, I see WP:N being met and not applying as this isn't clearly an (Events in this context don't normally repeat for example). I don't think the World Series (for example) should be considered an event, nor should the State of the Union speech. As WP:N is met with non-trivial coverage in multiple sources (if weakly) I see no problem Deletion of MystiCon WP:GEOSCOPE||WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13585 1160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 Gisborne Blackout User:Ajf773 23:09, 18 December 2016 (UTC) delete Non-notable event and . Article also lacks any sources Deletion of 2016 Gisborne Blackout WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13586 8963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Robert Shauger User:GPL93 16:16, 16 April 2020 (UTC) delete Per . Best Deletion of Daniel Robert Shauger WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13587 14815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billie Faiers User:Less 09:59, 11 July 2020 (UTC) keep She passes - there's a lot of articles dedicated to her in multiple sources such as Hello https://www.hellomagazine.com/tags/billie-faiers/ here, Irish Mirror https://www.irishmirror.ie/all-about/billie-faiers here, Standart https://www.standard.co.uk/topic/billie-faiers here, as well as https://closeronline.co.uk/life-style/fashion/billie-faiers-in-the-style-summer-collection/ this and many more Deletion of Billie Faiers WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13588 2520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alisa Krylova User:SamHolt6 13:54, 19 July 2017 (UTC) keep Needs improvement and more verification, but the subject appears to meet criteria Deletion of Alisa Krylova WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13589 8108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How to get higher search engine ranking User:LinguistAtLarge 19:45, 12 December 2008 (UTC) delete per , #WEBHOST, #OR, HOWTO Deletion of How to get higher search engine ranking WP:COI||WP:NOT||WP:NOT||WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
13590 5493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Galore Nation User:Gongshow 00:04, 6 January 2010 (UTC) delete WP:GNG is not met; no significant coverage found, and does not meet Deletion of Galore Nation WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13591 15830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Srinagar bypoll election killings 2017 User:Capitals00 08:59, 12 May 2017 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Srinagar bypoll election killings 2017 WP:PROPAGANDA Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13592 19610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Lost City of Geraptiku User:Coredesat 09:25, 27 June 2006 (UTC) delete nonsense, ad for some Neopets quest. |Wikipedia is not a promotional tool Deletion of The Lost City of Geraptiku WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13593 129 [[Café-Konditorei Schatz]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Peter200 NONE keep Ach nöö, das hat nichts mit einer Lösch- oder Behaltensfraktion zu tun. Wer Salzburg und seine Durchhäuser nicht kennt, kennt sie halt nicht. Vielleicht reicht ja die deutlich überregionale namentliche Nennung im http://books.google.de/books?id=QHCgrPAe7YIC&q=%22Konditorei+Schatz%22&dq=%22Konditorei+Schatz%22&hl=de&sa=X&ei=J5QJT7LKL5KksgaqsKiDDw&ved=0CFQQ6AEwBg „Great Europ Itinerar“ aus 1987 oder http://books.google.de/books?id=yTmpQDQbHCoC&q=%22Konditorei+Schatz%22&dq=%22Konditorei+Schatz%22&hl=de&sa=X&ei=J5QJT7LKL5KksgaqsKiDDw&ved=0CFoQ6AEwBw „Fodor-Austria'90“ aus 1989. Vielleicht bedarf es auch der http://books.google.de/books?id=7QErAQAAIAAJ&q=%22Schatz-Konditorei%22&dq=%22Schatz-Konditorei%22&hl=de&sa=X&ei=oJYJT-epAcnJswbmkfWBDw&ved=0CFQQ6AEwBQ „The Illustrated London news“ aus 1991 oder des http://books.google.de/books?id=6IAX3xOUEpkC&q=%22Schatz-Konditorei%22&dq=%22Schatz-Konditorei%22&hl=de&sa=X&ei=oJYJT-epAcnJswbmkfWBDw&ved=0CGIQ6AEwCA „Exploring Rural Austria“ aus 1990 um eine Relevanz nachzuweisen. Dass die #Wirtschaftsunternehmen|RKWs hier nicht ausreichen steht außer Debatte. Dass sie hier aber überhaupt als LA in Erwägung gezogen wurden ebenfalls. Denn hier dreht es sich nicht um Umsatz, sondern Tradition, Wiedererkennungswert und Bekanntheit. Die hier aufgeführten Links sind nur eine kleine Auswahl, liese sich aber beträchtlich erweitern (aber Sonntage gehören bei mir der Familie, darum WP-Faulheit), sollten aber ausreichen um die internationale Bekanntheit zu untermauern. und weiter ausbauen (besonders im Bereich Geschichte - zur NS-Zeit hatten da die Salzburger NSDAP-Häuptlinge ihre Plauderstündchen - eine Etage drüber war nämlich ihr Büro : Psst, bitte nicht weitersagen, sonst kommt vielleicht noch ein Anderer zu dem Schluss, dass man das Café behalten müsste Löschung von Café-Konditorei Schatz Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
13594 11813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colin Crouch User:Rhododendrites 17:58, 6 August 2016 (UTC) keep Nom is an SPA who started by doing some blanking at Cultural assimilation and then started nominating for deletion several articles that seem vaguely related to P2P research, without any apparent knowledge of what is. &mdash Deletion of Colin Crouch WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13595 6009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nijananda sampradaya User:Vcessayist 00:19, 7 October 2012 (UTC) delete due to a lack of third party sources. Cannot meet the Deletion of Nijananda sampradaya WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13596 1567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Cully User:Jakejr 14:20, 20 June 2015 (UTC) delete Being tall is not enough to show notability. None of the boxers mentioned meet and there is no significant independent coverage for either Cully or Potgieter Deletion of Jim Cully WP:NBOX Wikipedia:Notability 77
13597 13528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Michael User:David 07:30, 3 April 2010 (UTC) delete The Robinson prize issue lessens my trust in the accuracy of the sources about him, so is an issue as well as . I did some more searching and found http://www.h-net.org/aha/1997/robinson.html this nomination for the Robinson prize for H-net, which (as with other verifiable sources about the Robinson prize) fails to mention Michael. Our article has only one primary source, and although I did find a secondary source about Michael, http://h-net.msu.edu/cgi-bin/logbrowse.pl?trx=vx&list=H-Africa&month=1003&week=a&msg=C%2B1kIUWBHspMOi2IIhzz/g&user=&pw= this obituary, it appears to be so closely paraphrased from our own article (including the Robinson prize claim with as little justification) that it seems to me unusable for fear of circular sourcing Deletion of Robert Michael WP:V||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13598 299 [[Klauenschiftung]] (zur ÜA verschoben in BNR) Benutzer:SVL 20:24, 23. Okt. 2009 (CEST) comment Durchaus interessanter Artikel - für Werftarbeiter vermutlich gut zu verstehen. |OMA braucht aber beim Lesen ein neues Gebiss - wegen dem starken Klappern. zum Ausbau durch Sachkundige Löschung von Klauenschiftung Wikipedia:OMA Wikipedia:Allgemeinverständlichkeit 79
13599 1798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean C. Ewing User:Bearcat 16:16, 25 July 2021 (UTC) delete """Mebane NC is not a global city for the purposes of securing the """"inherent"""" notability of its municipal councillors, but this article neither suggests that he has any preexisting notability for other reasons (e.g. having previously held a more notable political office) nor demonstrates the depth of |reliable source coverage about him that it would take to deem him a special case of significantly greater notability than the norm for smalltown municipal councillors""" Deletion of Sean C. Ewing WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13600 16042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maxime Masson (medical student) User:Hisashiyarouin 12:18, 4 April 2015 (UTC) comment """The main claim of importance is rather dubious IMHO: """"writing to (notable?) journals and got posted"""" seems rather unremarkable, like a slight step-up to letters to newspapers. or ask for the subject's work to receive critical attention, like being highly cited or received thorough peer review in the field. There is none provided in the article or here in AfD so far. '''野狼院ひさし""" Deletion of Maxime Masson (medical student) WP:ACADEMIC||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13601 21667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marlon Patersson User:Matt91486 20:52, 3 August 2009 (UTC) keep for having played in a fully professional competition. Perhaps some going on because of lasting debate over Irish players Deletion of Marlon Patersson WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
13602 17076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abyssinian Creole User:Truth 10:58, 6 May 2013 (UTC) delete Short of . Trivial media visibility, with the one review of a local concert I found lukewarm at that Deletion of Abyssinian Creole WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
13603 17483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TheAmazingAtheist User:Otterathome 15:44, 12 March 2009 (UTC) keep coverage was widespread in ''multiple'' languages in at least 15 articles of which I can find, also satisfies #2 of Deletion of TheAmazingAtheist WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
13604 3002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helping Angels User:Wqwt 16:04, 21 February 2018 (UTC) delete """There are no in-line references but the """"Sources"""" section doesn't seem too great either. i. and iii. are broken links. ii. seems like a personal site. iv. Young Leadership International is not a reputable source. v. Sk-II Nona interview is broken as well and I couldn't find them on Google, but I only looked briefly. vi. and vii. are personal sites. viii. The Star interview is broken as well. In fact, none of the links are working. There is just no evidence of otability""" Deletion of Helping Angels WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13605 190 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Türkiye'de ağalık düzeni """Kullanıcı:maurice flesiermaurice flesier""" 13:08, 17 Haziran 2016 (UTC) comment Silinsin}} KD olmaktan çok uzak. FBugraKagan (#Oyların geçerliliği|VP:OY gereği Türkiye'de ağalık düzeninin silinmesi Vikipedi:Oylama Wikipedia:Administrators 89
13606 368 [[Scantrust]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Holmium 20:19, 7. Sep. 2020 (CEST) delete Kasten|1= per Antrag und (Firmenselbstdarstellungen bitte auf eigener Webseite platzieren): der vorgelegte Artikel beschreibt ausführlich, was Scantrust macht, machen möchte, welche Partner man gefunden hat, lässt jedoch die Darstellung der breiten(!) Verbreitung, die Wahrnehmung als etablierte Technologie etc. vermissen. Die Einzelnachweise erwähnen Scantrust nicht im Sinne einer annähernd die Bedeutung zeigenden Betrachtung, sondern teils nur als bloße Nennung, generell nur als einen von vielen Beteiligten. Eine Relevanz ist nicht erkennbar geworden; auch ob eine Technologie «einzigartig» ist, ist bei einer enzyklopädischen Relevanzeinschätzung bedeutungslos und wird in der Diskussion zu Unrecht thematisiert. Sie müsste beispielsweise etabliert sein, bedeutend, wahrgenommen und z. B. in der Fachliteratur als Hauptthema eines Berichts oder einer Marktanalyse aufgegriffen werden. Zudem nennt mindestens ein vorgestellter Beleg das Unternehmen ein Start-Up. Diese Einschätzung spricht für sich: wir stellen Start-Ups nur dar, wenn sie im Sinn einer neutralen Bewertung, eines neutralen Beleges nachgewiesene Bedeutung z. B. im Markt, in Forschung oder Wissenschaft haben, was ich nicht herauslesen kann. Es bleibt zur Löschung keine Alternative Löschung von Scantrust Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13607 248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magnesium oil User:Northamerica1000 19:54, 10 January 2015 (UTC) keep Passes . Source examples include https://books.google.com/books?id=w5LNq9JIiScC&pg=PA152&dq=%22Magnesium+oil%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=RYGxVMGoBs25oQSNx4HIDg&ved=0CD4Q6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=%22Magnesium%20oil%22&f=false, https://books.google.com/books?id=aqMPZM9gk_0C&pg=PT289&dq=%22Magnesium+oil%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=RYGxVMGoBs25oQSNx4HIDg&ved=0CEkQ6AEwBA#v=onepage&q=%22Magnesium%20oil%22&f=false, https://books.google.com/books?id=p0KriJuFl1IC&pg=PA269&dq=%22Magnesium+oil%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=RYGxVMGoBs25oQSNx4HIDg&ved=0CDgQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=%22Magnesium%20oil%22&f=false, https://books.google.com/books?id=bXUIBgAAQBAJ&pg=PT435&dq=%22Magnesium+oil%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=uIGxVMa1Lor6oQTO5YK4Bg&ved=0CFwQ6AEwCTgK#v=onepage&q=%22Magnesium%20oil%22&f=false, https://books.google.com/books?id=aqMPZM9gk_0C&pg=PT289 (partial preview). Furthermore, https://books.google.com/books?id=VrZBxNPnmZoC&pg=PA49&dq=%22Magnesium+oil%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=-YGxVKrREYW1ogTw54LACg&ved=0CEAQ6AEwAzgU#v=onepage&q=%22Magnesium%20oil%22&f=false this source states that Magnesium oil is another name for Transdermal Magnesium. Source examples for Transdermal Magnesium include https://books.google.com/books?id=p0KriJuFl1IC&printsec=frontcover, https://books.google.com/books?id=3uEuBAAAQBAJ, http://naturalmedicine.co.za/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=1840:transdermal-magnesium&catid=913:natural-remedies Deletion of Magnesium oil WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13608 7858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guitar legends User:HisSpaceResearch 18:32, 28 October 2007 (UTC) delete per #CRYSTAL and Deletion of Guitar legends WP:NOT||WP:V Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13609 18259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Mello User:Esradekan 11:08, 19 September 2008 (UTC) keep meets notability per #C5 for multiple album releases on Rap-a-Lot Records Deletion of Big Mello WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13610 8140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fourth Studio Album User:Doc 20:21, 19 July 2008 (UTC) merge any sourced material to Kelly Clarkson. Alot of this is |crystal ballery Deletion of Fourth Studio Album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13611 12347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruna Ferraz User:Horrorshowj 13:43, 20 February 2010 (UTC) delete No returns on AVN or Xbiz. Only one trivial mention on gnews, nothing that looks promising on ghits. Fails and Deletion of Bruna Ferraz WP:GNG||WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13612 9788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Battlestar Galactica (2004 TV series) locations User:SW3 03:38, 27 December 2016 (UTC) delete per and |Somebody did this instead of their homework. That's a real thing, you know. Of interest to fans only, not much use for general reader Deletion of List of Battlestar Galactica (2004 TV series) locations WP:FANCRUFT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
13613 17134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blood Out (film) User:Reyk 21:10, 19 June 2010 (UTC) keep Covered in enough reliable, independent sources to make it |notable regardless of what FF says Deletion of Blood Out (film) WP:N||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13614 8095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maurice Bou Kanaan User:Jrcla2 16:46, 13 September 2016 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Maurice Bou Kanaan WP:NBASKETBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13615 18727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheraz Ali Muskrahat (2nd nomination) User:Saqib 04:53, 5 December 2017 (UTC) delete fails to meet Deletion of Sheraz Ali Muskrahat (2nd nomination) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13616 21230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sacramento Islamic Mosque User:E 13:38, 4 September 2018 (UTC) delete """article claims that """"The Muslim Mosque Association is the oldest mosque in the United States west of the Mississippi River, at 411 V St. in Downtown Sacramento, California."""" cited to an article in the ''Sacramento Press'' and the claim is that it was built in 1946. """"oldest"""" claims can be difficult to prove/disprove, but this one is clearly '''wrong'''. The oldest surviving mosque building in the United States is the Mother Mosque of America in Cedar Rapids, built in 1934; Cedar Rapids is west of the Mississippi River. Older American mosques (congregations) exist. The Sacramento Press appears to have been relying on facts supplies by the congregation. It is a local source, and the problem is that it is is the best source in the article. I assume that whoever wrote """"oldest"""" in the article took the word of the newspaper as reliable, but having a page that is clearly wrong on what appears to be this mosque's sole claim to notability is problematic. Mosques, like churches, need to pass . they tend to do so by being very big, very old, architecturally notable, or very significant within a particular religious community or in the career of a notable cleric. I see no indication that this mosque is notable, and no """ Deletion of Sacramento Islamic Mosque WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
13617 8226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dominique Guinard User:Xxanthippe 22:02, 3 January 2017 (UTC) keep GS h-index of 28 may be just enough to pass rof#C1 in very high cited field Deletion of Dominique Guinard WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
13618 10674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Debapriya Mukhopadhyay User:Anarchyte 11:53, 26 June 2015 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Debapriya Mukhopadhyay WP:GNG||WP:CCOS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13619 301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Sprachman User:Alansohn 18:41, 27 March 2015 (UTC) keep Passes , as laid out by Deletion of Paul Sprachman WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13620 9533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peko Precision Products User:Joe 21:37, 4 January 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |company Deletion of Peko Precision Products WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13621 663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kingswood Elementary School (Nova Scotia) [[User talk:174.254.193.84|talk]]) 19:16, 4 March 2021 (UTC) merge to Upper Hammonds Plains, Nova Scotia#Schools per and the longstanding precident of doing just that described at . Special:Contributions/174.254.193.84|174.254.193.84 Deletion of Kingswood Elementary School (Nova Scotia) WP:ATD||WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13622 9261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fusinus amadeus User:Cinadon36 18:44, 20 May 2021 (UTC) keep per . This is snowballing Deletion of Fusinus amadeus WP:NSPECIES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13623 18019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Branislav Tošić User:SportingFlyer 20:07, 6 September 2019 (UTC) keep """Spent some time on this one. Initially thought this was one of the """"greyest"""" AfDs I had come across - Tošić had passed the guideline by leaps and bounds, and yet I kept running into the same problems some of the other !voters have with the sources. I've now gone ahead and added prose and referenced the article and have written a stub about the player's career. What's especially difficult is the differing levels of coverage from country to country, and I've been thinking a lot about how this plays into athlete notability guidelines, especially with the oppose on {{noping|Barkeep49}}'s admin request, and a cricket DRV. Going off of Tošić for a second, I like the test: has the player done something notable (, but not ''always'')? and can we write a properly sourced stub about the player (, )? As noted, Tošić clearly passes , and the article is now a properly sourced stub. The article's sourcing isn't the greatest (only one article directly on him, from his time in the third division, one of the four non-Soccerway cites is primary, and it took a fair amount of searching to get enough hits due to the common name/Latin and Cyrillic issues) but there's lots of routine coverage of him as well. I found another offline newspaper apart from Jogurney which claims to discuss him (though I couldn't find the citation as it did not allow me to search in Cyrillic) which also gives me hope other offline sources exist and this can be expanded further, especially from the area around Srem, but I think we're now at a point where the encyclopedia would get worse if we delete this article""" Deletion of Branislav Tošić WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG||WP:BLP1E||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13624 3121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gaudencio Hernández Burgos User:Necrothesp 12:44, 14 May 2014 (UTC) keep Obviously meets the criteria of Deletion of Gaudencio Hernández Burgos WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
13625 2232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mirraw User:Hagennos 05:50, 28 January 2018 (UTC) delete Non-notable company. Fails and Deletion of Mirraw WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13626 12111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Balboa Capital Corporation User:Walkabout14 18:14, 14 March 2015 (UTC) delete I am struggling to understand what this company is supposed to notable for, lending to pizza makers or opening an office in Florida? There is one good recent story from the LA Times, but even that is about the company's growth, not about the uniqueness of its business model, or anything that makes it notable. So while there is a |reliable source, it doesn't really establish notability under Deletion of Balboa Capital Corporation WP:RS||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13627 15582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nahum Shahaf User:THF 19:00, 12 March 2010 (UTC) keep I'd like to see better sourcing outside of the al-Durrah incident, but seems to meet Deletion of Nahum Shahaf WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13628 11546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kinzie User:RGTraynor 20:57, 4 August 2007 (UTC) delete No resume. No contract. No production. No big gigs. No albums. No nothing. No passing . Oh, wait. They have a Myspace page. Gosh, the Billboard Top 100 is next Deletion of Kinzie WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13629 16509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fallout Wiki User:Enjoyer 03:37, 22 June 2021 (UTC) keep passes . There are five references that are significant coverage along with additional four Deletion of Fallout Wiki WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13630 20396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noah Raby (2nd nomination) user:Andrew 21:06, 19 May 2019 (UTC) keep The age of the sources is irrelevant per . And what really seems to be driving the nomination is systematic |dislike of old people contrary to |core policy Deletion of Noah Raby (2nd nomination) WP:ITSOLD||WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13631 16159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Wars Tales Volume 3 User:Rorshacma 15:26, 21 May 2021 (UTC) merge to Star Wars Tales - None of these individual collections are notable enough, nor have enough coverage in reliable sources, to warrant a from the main article. The actual pieces of information for the individual issues, such as the publication and creator info, would be better included in the main article on the series Deletion of Star Wars Tales Volume 3 WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Splitting 57
13632 7820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011 Ukraine mine accidents User:Wackywace 16:57, 6 August 2011 (UTC) delete Two unrelated incidents. Wikipedia is not the place to group arguably similar incidents together because it might show problems with the Ukrainian mining industry. Whether both incidents are |actually worthy of an article or not is another matter, but they certainly should not be in the same one Deletion of 2011 Ukraine mine accidents WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13633 5540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aleksandra Alač User:Jack 01:47, 5 March 2017 (UTC) delete There is one source cited (IMDB) and no other reliable sources available (failing ). Based on those roles she has held, she does not meet the criteria in to justify the existence of an article. Does not otherwise meet . I cannot see any other justification to keep Deletion of Aleksandra Alač WP:NRV||WP:ENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13634 57 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wilson Villa User:Adamant1 10:57, 4 October 2020 (UTC) delete """The article is about """"an Ecuadorian '''singer and composer'''."""" Therefore, it should pass and no where does it say a musician is notable for dying or getting coverage of their death. While it does have the exception that the person is notable if they """"Have been the subject of multiple, non-trivial, published works appearing in sources that are reliable, not self-published, and are independent of the musician or ensemble itself"""", but someone dying (or getting coverage for it) is the epitome of triviality. That said, a lot of the sources on his death are extremely trivial and/or primary anyway. Especially the Twitter mentions, but also other ones. So, as things currently stand there is nothing worth keeping the article over""" Deletion of Wilson Villa WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13635 8836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Crossing (South African TV series) User:Mrschimpf 16:28, 5 October 2017 (UTC) delete """Although no official broadcaster has yet been confirmed""""...we don't have a network to air it on, we don't have an article. We're not an for the South African television industry to consider this show on; in reverse, America's ''Crossing'' has a network and will air in midseason, so it's got that minimum hurdle overcome""" Deletion of The Crossing (South African TV series) WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
13636 9312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jocelyne Couture-Nowak User:Pablosecca 04:37, 21 April 2007 (UTC) comment """If you read , you find the sentence """"Trivial, or incidental coverage of a subject by secondary sources is not sufficient to establish notability."""" While the coverage for Couture Nowak may not have been trivial, it is strictly incidental. The Oxford English Dictionary defines incidental as """" 1. a. Occurring or liable to occur in fortuitous or subordinate conjunction with something else of which it forms no essential part; casual."""" This individual's notability is subordinate to the narrative of the tragedy at VTech""" Deletion of Jocelyne Couture-Nowak WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13637 399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Athanasios Gelinos User:Stifle 18:37, 14 May 2008 (UTC) delete As there are no |reliable sources |cited, I am persuaded that the article does not comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Athanasios Gelinos WP:RS||WP:CITE||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13638 13913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wright's law User:ArcAngel 23:53, 7 February 2011 (UTC) comment Valid question here - is this term covered BY NAME in-depth by any source? If not, then it passes . Therefore the |burden is on the article creator to come up with diffs that support the notability of the phrase. That is the crux of this discussion. Furthermore, I feel that the two keep !votes have a vested |conflict of interest as they are both based at Dartmouth College Deletion of Wright's law WP:MADEUP||WP:BURDEN||WP:COI Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
13639 18120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nasim Fekrat User:SharabSalam 02:14, 25 May 2020 (UTC) delete absolutely not notable except for one event . And all I can see are passing mention references. Not to mention, the doxxing-like tone that was in the article. His tribe journey is irrelevant Deletion of Nasim Fekrat WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
13640 5233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of American politicians convicted of crimes User:The 20:30, 26 November 2010 (UTC) delete per nom. Plus another kind of subject. Politicans commit crimes, whoda thunk Deletion of List of American politicians convicted of crimes WP:DOGBITESMAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
13641 275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/London Buses route 77 User:Mkativerata 03:44, 30 March 2010 (UTC) delete but '''weak on 66'''. Essentially per BrownHairedGirl. I'm gobsmacked at the sources put forward by Eastmain. How anyone on earth could consider them reliable is beyond me. |GNG is an important guideline and shouldn't discarded lightly. It is important for good reason. Without significant coverage in reliable sources, it is usually impossible to have an encyclopaedic article about a subject that is properly verified. These bus route articles are a case in point: they are littered with original research and for all we know could be totally inaccurate. The reason they are littered with original research is because the reliable sources aren't there. For that reason, the original research is fatal and unsalvageable Deletion of London Buses route 77 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13642 11427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aryana farshad User:Amwestover 13:18, 18 December 2008 (UTC) comment Re: Schmidt's post to my user talk; I see that you've put a lot of work into the article, but Farshad still does not satisfy . She was audience choice at a non-notable film festival, and received a non-notable award that's given to thousands of people every year for commercials and non-broadcast video. She hasn't made significant or unique contributions, and she doesn't have a cult following. All she has is coverage by Iranian media and indiscriminate sources on the subject, and even according to IMDB she hasn't done much work Deletion of Aryana farshad WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
13643 19102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam H. Toubin User:Dhartung 15:48, 25 October 2007 (UTC) delete """No indication of notability beyond |local prominence. This game of Jewish Geography gets old. Just being successful does not make you """"important to Jewish history"""" whether it's Texas or Tel Aviv. -- —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of Sam H. Toubin WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
13644 17776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Between You & Me User:Doc 18:11, 3 November 2008 (UTC) merge This song fails , but a redirect to Ali Lohan would not make sense. Instead, I suggest to Between You and Me, a notable song by Christian rock group dc Talk, as that would be a likely alternate spelling for that song Deletion of Between You & Me WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13645 17315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dispyz User:Blue520 13:45, 13 July 2006 (UTC) delete article currently fails to show or assert |verified notability to the levels outlined by Deletion of Dispyz WP:V||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13646 10306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional characters who can manipulate weather User:Elton 15:17, 2 July 2010 (UTC) delete """I'm not sure what Jclemens means by """"Not a trivial intersection"""", but """"no other deletion rationale given"""" is certainly not true, as is given. seems to be exactly right. Claritas's objection to merging seems to me a good one. If anyone thinks anything from this list can usefully be added to Weather control#in popular culture then they can be added individually. That can be done without wholesale merging from this list, and since this list contains nothing that needs preserving, such as sources to support such additions to the other list, there is no reason why adding to that list should be treated specifically as merging from this one""" Deletion of List of fictional characters who can manipulate weather WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13647 21806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Sherwin User:Ca2james 20:31, 21 October 2017 (UTC) delete as subject fails GNG and as there just isn't sourcing attesting to his notability anywhere, including the academic world. That he has some published works is par for the course for academics and does not make him notable on Wikipedia. There're no independent sources talking about how he's done groundbreaking research (I know the memorial thing exists but that's a personal memorial, not an academic RS discussing his contributions). I realize the subject was a Wikipedia editor and that those !voting keep above were wikifriends with this editor and contributed to this article but being a Wikipedia editor doesn't make the subject notable, either. Perhaps someone could publish this memorial page on a blog; given , it does not belong in Wikipedia Deletion of Chris Sherwin WP:NACADEMIC||WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13648 14121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dusán Sžetzetižicž User:Jkudlick 16:22, 21 November 2015 (UTC) delete I thought perhaps he had actually played for F.C. Castiglione, but I can find no evidence of playing for that club, either. As there are no |reliable sources to verify the match data provided, I have to assume he fails and . — Deletion of Dusán Sžetzetižicž WP:RS||WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13649 11809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teri Sue Wood User:Jerry 22:37, 9 April 2007 (UTC) delete Unsourced article in violation of Deletion of Teri Sue Wood WP:LIVING Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13650 1974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Realm (magazine) User:Newshunter12 10:18, 22 September 2018 (UTC) delete The article fails because the magazine lacks that it was or remains notable. I would also note that the article has only one citation after nearly 14 years in existence and it didn't even work when I tried to use it. I was able to find no information about this magazine when I did a search Deletion of Realm (magazine) WP:NMEDIA||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
13651 83 [[Musikzeit (Lafite)]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers 16:33, 7. Okt. 2012 (CEST) delete Kasten|1= gemäß Diskussion. Die Wikipedia ist keine Darstellungsplattform für Namenskreationen und Verlagswerbung. Bitte dazu auch beachten. Gruß Löschung von Musikzeit (Lafite) Wikipedia:Interessenkonflikt Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
13652 10811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amy Sequenzia (2nd nomination) User:Ritchie333 15:19, 19 June 2019 (UTC) keep Meets , having been name-checked in significant detail in publications such as ''The Guardian'', ''LA Times'' and ''Slate (magazine)|Slate''. I expanded the article a bit and added a bunch of references Deletion of Amy Sequenzia (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13653 17423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bullet Points (comics) User:Piotrus 05:09, 11 July 2020 (UTC) delete As written, clearly fails . BEFORE does now show anything outside primary sources and unreliable mentions in passing Deletion of Bullet Points (comics) WP:NFICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
13654 6443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poet Tree (2nd nomination) User:Theodore 15:18, 10 July 2013 (UTC) delete fails . I found a source that mentions it here http://www.writers.net/writers/82611 but it is hardly sufficient Deletion of Poet Tree (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13655 20309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/January 2016 Paris police station attack User:Pharaoh 16:31, 20 January 2016 (UTC) keep Passes it has been covered by major media outlets worldwide including New York Times and Wall Street Journal now whether this has a impact is difficult to say at this point Deletion of January 2016 Paris police station attack WP:GNG||WP:LASTING Wikipedia:Notability 77
13656 8775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siam–Burma Death Railway (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 10:25, 22 October 2014 (UTC) keep """per ''just'' meeting . We have a released documentary film whose production is receiving coverage. IE: http://www.dinamani.com/edition_villupuram/puducherry/2014/08/24/சயாம்--பர்மா-மரண-ரயில்-பாதை-ஆவ/article2395317.ece ''Indian Express'' http://www.dinamalar.com/news_detail.asp?id=1055456&Print=1 ''Dinamalar'' Being in the Tamil language does not make these sources somehow non-existent (just harder to track down), and |notable in Tamil is notable enough for en.Wikipedia. Having a """"theatrical"""" release is not a guideline requirement, and documentaries rarely get the same level of coverage as do their big budget-big studio brethren. {{ping|Michitaro}}, {{ping|Shoessss""" Deletion of Siam–Burma Death Railway (film) WP:NF||WP:NONENG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13657 20990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poing (video game) User:Videogameplayer99 18:23, 23 October 2019 (UTC) delete per above, fails Deletion of Poing (video game) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13658 3007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Porno Valley User:Wikipedian 10:18, 15 September 2012 (UTC) keep nbsp;– the links provided by Morbidthoughts can be used to put together a article passing Deletion of Porno Valley WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13659 9538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mustafa Ülgen User:Agricola44 18:37, 1 June 2009 (UTC) delete """The main tests I could see applying here are criteria 1 and/or 4. His textbook would seem to claim #4, but I'm not in a position to judge its impact. However, his publication record looks insufficient for #1. Web of Science, liberally searching on """"Author=(ulgen m*), Refined by: Subject Areas=(DENTISTRY, ORAL SURGERY & MEDICINE)"""", lists 4 publications, all from Am. J. Orthodontics & Dentofacial Orthoped., having 12, 10, 5, and 5 citations respectively. Note that this article lists a veritable boatload of other publications (some of which seem to be various editions of his textbook). Most of the """"journal articles"""" are from """"Faculty of Dentistry Magazine"""" from several different universities – these are almost certainly not peer-reviewed research publications. Likely ditto for """"Pedodontics Magazine"""". Roughly a dozen other articles from """"Turkish Journal of Orthodontics"""", but it is unclear whether this is a standard research journal for the profession. Answer seems to be in the nagative, since it is not in the list of over 50 dental journals indexed by WoS (J. Dent. Res., J. Endodontics, J. Clin. Peridontology, etc.). Respectfully""" Deletion of Mustafa Ülgen WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13660 12438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rex Rundgren (2nd nomination) User:Muboshgu 18:39, 7 May 2011 (UTC) comment the main issue here is whether young Rex has notability on his own or if it is |inherited from his famous father. I think it is obvious that there wouldn't be sources covering him at all if not for his father being famous, although the sources are covering him, but in relation to his father. So, I'm unsure exactly how much of his notability is inherited and how much of it is authentic. I don't care about how many articles there are with him as a subject, I still feel that as someone we wouldn't talk about if not for his father being famous, it means he's not notable on his own. – Deletion of Rex Rundgren (2nd nomination) WP:INHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13661 10101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pirates of the caribbean the fountain of youth User:Cube 13:53, 20 December 2007 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Pirates of the caribbean the fountain of youth WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13662 16601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mortal Kombat announcer User:Otto4711 13:05, 20 August 2007 (UTC) delete the notability of the game series does not confer notability on every aspect of the game. No sources that are about the specific topic of the MK announcer voice and the attempt to assign racial/ethnic identities to the various incarnations of the voice are |original research Deletion of Mortal Kombat announcer WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13663 12945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Connect-A-Pedia User:THE 14:21, 8 March 2007 (UTC) delete """Connect-A-Pedia is a game that was invented by Australian High-School student Daniel Doyle. All the game requires is for the player to be browsing on the wikipedia website."""" This is a textbook example of something non-notable that shouldn't be included on wikipedia. Reference as per above - also the fact that the creator of the game is involved in this discussion is very fishy""" Deletion of Connect-A-Pedia WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
13664 12519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Júnior Lacayo User:Fenix 11:31, 15 December 2014 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG. There appears to be some level of coverage, but the simple fact is that this individual has played only a handful of games of football in a league not deemed to be fully professional. It is difficult to see how he could be deemed to be a notable player |at this stage Deletion of Júnior Lacayo WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
13665 11309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Mackey User:Jeffrd10 13:47, 21 January 2014 (UTC) delete does Not promotional however it does fail Deletion of Bruce Mackey WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13666 257 [[Justfab]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Hephaion 01:01, 16. Apr. 2013 (CEST) delete Kasten|1= gemäß Diskussion und #U. Hier geht es um den Artikel Justfab und nicht um verschiedene andere, die aus verschiedenen anderen Gründen einen Artikel haben. Dieser Artikel ist gemäß RK nicht relevant, so einfach ist das. Löschung von Justfab Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
13667 8841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kyron Aguilera User:Edwardx 10:52, 16 July 2021 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Kyron Aguilera WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13668 4821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zelda tetras curse User:MER 13:12, 6 December 2006 (UTC) delete as |unsourced and unverifiable |crystal ballery, |conflict of interest, failure of Deletion of Zelda tetras curse WP:V||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:COI||WP:SOFTWARE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13669 8566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/José Martínez (football manager) [[User Talk:Trevanbaxter]] 23:50, 31 March 2019 (UTC) keep """ says """"manager"""" which does qualify him, as other sports such as basketball allow pages such as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casey_Hill to remain, even though he has no top-tier or professional, head coaching or playing experience. The definition needs to be clarified before this case is ruled on. To address SIGCOV he has articles such as the one above, and the following are other examples from just his transfer to Malmö FF alone: http://mff.se/sv-SE/aktuellt/nyheter/Nyheter/2019-01-31_valkommen-till-mff-jose-martinez, http://fotbolltransfers.com/site/news/104119, http://www.nyheter-sverige.ga/kvallsposten/sport/fotboll/allsvenskan/efter-fjellstroms-uppbrott-fran-mff-han-ersatter/, https://www.skd.se/2019/01/31/spansk-tranare-klar-for-mff/, https://www.sydsvenskan.se/2019-01-31/har-ar-fjellstroms-ersattare-martinez-ny-i-mff-staben, https://www.svt.se/nyheter/lokalt/skane/han-blir-ny-assisterande-i-malmo, https://www.allsvenskan.se/nyheter/nyheter-fran-allsvenskan.se/malmo-ff-anstaller-ny-assisterande-tranare, https://www.njus.me/se/nyheter/fotboll/0/3045517/lang-intervju-med-jose-martinez-fjellstroms-ersattare-i-mff-vill-ha-arbetssat, https://theworldnews.net/se-news/har-ar-fjellstroms-ersattare-spanjor-ny-i-mff-staben, http://www.fotboll.se/view/news/news_id/278601/id/36""" Deletion of José Martínez (football manager) WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13670 3860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elazar Abuhatzeira User:Nsk92 10:55, 4 August 2011 (UTC) keep There is certainly plenty of ongoing coverage of his death, including international coverage. This might have qualified under but he appears to have been a prominent and controversial figure before his murder as well. E.g. there are articles about him from 2010 in Ha'aretzhttp://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/u-s-prosecutors-probing-israeli-rabbi-over-fraud-1.263504,http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/n-y-jews-accuse-be-er-sheva-kabbalist-of-massive-fraud-1.263772 and in New York Posthttp://www.nypost.com/p/news/local/brooklyn/rabbi_runs_kabbalah_con_in_ny_qbrPadCHtGP6LspsGPzPqI, again Ha'aretz in 2003http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/fraud-probe-against-abuhatzeira-dropped-1.16734, Jerusalem Post in 2004http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/jpost/access/620487351.html?dids=620487351:620487351&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&date=Apr+15%2C+2004&author=David+Rudge%2C+Etgar+Lefkovits%2C+Dan+Izenberg%2C+Abigail+Radoszkowicz&pub=Jerusalem+Post&desc=News+in+brief&pqatl=google, etc. As Cullen328 notes, presumably many more sources exist in Hebrew language press. Passes Deletion of Elazar Abuhatzeira WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13671 7209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Takaaki Musha User:Bm 16:08, 8 January 2008 (UTC) delete """Non-notable engineer working on a barely-notable pseudoscience topic. Lest anyone think he might pass , let's look at his publications: """"Physics Essays"""" is not peer-reviewed. """"Electric Spacecraft Journal"""" and """"Infinite Energy"""" are non-academic fringe newsletters. """"Speculations in Science and Technology"""" was a semi-mainstream journal (now defunct) that acknowledged, editorially, that its articles were probably mostly wrong but that it saw value in publishing creative speculation. """"Journal of Theoretics"""" is held in two university libraries; """"Electrogravitics II"""" is a book, found in two university libraries and two public libraries---any mainstream journal you can think of, no matter how obscure the field, is held in a hundred or so libraries. What's left? One engineering article and one conference proceedings? Forget about , this would fail WP:Grad_Student. —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of Takaaki Musha WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13672 8686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global warming skepticism User:ScienceApologist 21:08, 13 August 2010 (UTC) merge WP:IAR and merge the MastCell list into one article. Then |fork properly Deletion of Global warming skepticism WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
13673 2038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kerry Chamberlain User:Xxanthippe 00:51, 20 January 2011 (UTC) keep GS cites give h index of 24. This is enough to meet rof#C1 Deletion of Kerry Chamberlain WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
13674 12966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magdalen Berns (2nd nomination) User:Hypnotist 23:26, 8 June 2021 (UTC) delete The article seems a classic case of , is much longer than reliable sources allow, and generally comes close to the edge of GNG. Cites #6 and #7 might have persuaded me but both are written by single contributors to their respective publications (one was by Posie Parker who actually seems more notable than Berns from my source scan, but who doesn't have a page as far as I can see). If kept and properly improved, it seems to me like the article itself would be very lean given the limited set of - with nearly all the RS dealing with an event better mentioned on JK Rowling's page. That makes me think it fails too. It feels very well described by IMO Deletion of Magdalen Berns (2nd nomination) WP:OVERCITE||WP:RS||WP:ONEEVENT||WP:PSEUDO Wikipedia:Citation overkill 60
13675 20242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roxanne Allison Baeyens User:Piotrus 05:29, 12 October 2020 (UTC) comment Re: Milena Sadowska. Polish Wikipedia assumes all winners of Miss Polonia are notable by default, as the winners of the Polish biggest and oldest beauty pageant (see :pl:Wikipedia:Poczekalnia/biografie/2020:10:11:Milena Sadowska). That said, while I considered 'weak keep' for her, there is zero coverage of her outside winning the award, so per , having her name mentioned in the Miss Polonia winners should be enough so I suggest soft deletion and ''redirect'' for her. I did not have time to review the other entries Deletion of Roxanne Allison Baeyens WP:ONEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13676 1919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tian Bing User:Zanhe 22:58, 6 June 2018 (UTC) keep as the first Chinese person to compete in WWE, he has received significant coverage from both Chinese- and English-language media, as shown by Lee Vilenski above. Meets Deletion of Tian Bing WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13677 161 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Anarşist Komünist İnisiyatif Kullanıcı:nosferatünosferatü 14:01, 24 Mayıs 2006 (UTC) delete Çünkü, bir örgüt bildirgesi buraya kopyalanıp, yapıştırılmış. Bakınız --User:renegade|'''renegade'''User_Talk:renegade|''msj Anarşist Komünist İnisiyatifin silinmesi Vikipedi:Vikipedi ne değildir Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13678 3409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Tennessee Volunteerz User:Galatz 14:16, 11 June 2019 (UTC) delete Not finding anything that meets Deletion of The Tennessee Volunteerz WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13679 12808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hilary S. Parker User:Jessamyn 15:37, 2 October 2020 (UTC) keep Notability is tricky when dealing with people who don't usually get a lot of mainstream coverage, but I think her StitchFix citations hit general notability and, as AmeliaMN says above #7 can apply Deletion of Hilary S. Parker WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13680 16363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chadminton User:NawlinWiki 15:24, 22 February 2008 (UTC) delete yet another unknown and made-up sport. See Deletion of Chadminton WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
13681 2320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mumbly Cartoon Show NONE NONE keep """per and sources currently cited in the article. NTV says, """"Generally, an individual radio or television program is likely to be notable if it airs on a network of radio or television stations (either national or regional in scope)."""" ''The Mumbly Cartoon Show'' aired on ABC. I've added some more information to the page using several sources, including""" Deletion of The Mumbly Cartoon Show WP:NTV Wikipedia:Notability 77
13682 419 [[Augapfeltattoo]] (erl., LAZ) Benutzer:THWZ 22:44, 27. Sep. 2011 (CEST) delete Die bisher angegebenen Quellen belegen noch keine Relevanz im Sinne der allg. RK. Lt. gehört eine - zumindest anhand der angegebene Belege noch längst nicht etablierte - flüchtige Modeerscheinung nicht zu den Topics einer Enzyklopädie. Jetzt , ein paar Jahre abwarten und dann - falls noch nicht in Vergessenheit geraten - neu einstellen Löschung von Augapfeltattoo Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13683 13479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Sesame Street crew User:Ajf773 20:00, 30 December 2017 (UTC) delete as . Very few of the names pass Deletion of List of Sesame Street crew WP:LISTCRUFT||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
13684 21131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alie Layus (2nd nomination) User:Versace1608 14:02, 22 March 2020 (UTC) delete The subject fails and . A Google search of the subject doesn't show her being discussed in reliable sources Deletion of Alie Layus (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13685 10846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thee (2007 film) User:SkierRMH 03:55, 22 October 2007 (UTC) delete No reliable 3rd party coverage, no IMDB or AMG listing. Deletion of Thee (2007 film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13686 4495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bantha (2nd nomination) User:Mark 17:46, 29 December 2019 (UTC) keep Whatever it’s state at the start of the AfD, this article has developed into a well-written article with many reliable sources. A solid keep per . —{{u| Deletion of Bantha (2nd nomination) WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
13687 19657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pasado, Presente & Futuro (Past, Present, And Future) (album) User:J04n 00:44, 1 February 2010 (UTC) delete can find no significant coverage independent of the subject in any reliable sources, does not meet or Deletion of Pasado, Presente & Futuro (Past, Present, And Future) (album) WP:GNG||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13688 13823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/YTF Legacy User:Gongshow 00:41, 1 October 2012 (UTC) delete I'm unable to find significant coverage in reliable sources for this collective; does not appear to meet , , or Deletion of YTF Legacy WP:GNG||WP:ENT||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13689 19512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IPhone 6 User:Autarch 17:40, 27 December 2012 (UTC) delete per Deletion of IPhone 6 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13690 10499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/July 29 in rail transport User:Agathoclea 18:13, 27 November 2008 (UTC) keep per Deletion of July 29 in rail transport WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13691 18341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyrannis User:Gwalla 23:50, 20 March 2010 (UTC) delete One guy's bedroom project. He's recorded one self-released album. Fails by a long shot. Fails too: not credited with any notable compositions, his works have won no awards and have not been used in other notable works, and he's not an influence on anyone. &mdash Deletion of Tyrannis WP:BAND||WP:COMPOSER Wikipedia:Notability 77
13692 18374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Japan Airlines Flight 2 User:FoxyOrange 17:08, 7 December 2013 (UTC) keep I think the fact that the accident was picked up by Peter Greenberg and that it was covered in the ''San Francisco Chronicle'' in 2011 (http://blog.sfgate.com/parenting/2011/04/20/the-japan-air-lines-miracle-water-landing-of-1968-photos/) shows that there is some kind of lasting significance as required to pass . It's also to be mentioned in the book ''The Fifth Discipline'' (but as this book not about aviation and I don't know the extent of its coverage of the accident, I wouldn't use it to make a point). Last but not least, there is this http://www.airliners.net/aviation-articles/read.main?id=1 article at airliners.net. (is this considered a reliable source at all?) It indicates that the aircraft was ''repaired'', even though being damaged by salty water, which could be some kind of a unique event, putting more weigh on the significance of the accident. More/better sources should be found, though Deletion of Japan Airlines Flight 2 WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13693 2957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss Diva - 2018 User:K 23:58, 13 January 2018 (UTC) delete unlikely to be independently notable and Deletion of Miss Diva - 2018 WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13694 18196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tootsie (dog) User:Drmies 00:32, 30 November 2008 (UTC) delete indeed; QuiteUnusual is right. Even if it were there (and I'm baffled--why couldn't the author supply the specific article??), this still wouldn't satisfy Deletion of Tootsie (dog) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13695 18962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krzysztof Kulak User:Mkdw 22:12, 2 February 2013 (UTC) delete Subject has mainly fought for KSV but it is not recognized as a top-tier promotion at and ultimately does not meet . No significant coverage outside for his events and does not meet as the alternate policy Deletion of Krzysztof Kulak WP:MMATIER||WP:NMMA||WP:ROUTINE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13696 7741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebellion Beer Company User:Zad68 18:24, 21 June 2013 (UTC) keep Meets , sufficient independent sourcing available. Also, conforms with the Wikipedia content policy of Deletion of Rebellion Beer Company WP:NCORP||WP:THEIRBEERISDELICIOUS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13697 4777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mushtaque Ahmad User:Mosesheron 15:43, 3 February 2021 (UTC) delete """Local madrasah teacher. His major claim to fame seems to be his attainment of a PhD as the """"first scholar to study at Qawmi Madrasa"""" which I honestly regard as a great achievement on the part of Bangladesh's Qawmi Madrasas. Sadly, however, subject fails and . Sorry""" Deletion of Mushtaque Ahmad WP:GNG||WP:NSCHOLAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13698 18148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orlando Fundora Álvarez User:Grsz11 15:43, 23 October 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Orlando Fundora Álvarez WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13699 4179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cat Palmer (artist) User:Freshacconci 13:32, 18 January 2011 (UTC) comment Just to be clear: which part of does she satisfy Deletion of Cat Palmer (artist) WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
13700 9311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/...Seishunchuu! User:KrebMarkt 08:28, 13 May 2009 (UTC) delete Seishunchuu!'' a 2 volumes (complete) series by Kurihara Mamoru. No licensor in US/UK, France, Germany, Spain & Italy. No ANN reference. Lack of third party coverage to assert erifiability | Verifiability and | Notability Deletion of ...Seishunchuu! WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13701 19648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alagie Ousman Jeng User:GiantSnowman 16:38, 24 June 2014 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Alagie Ousman Jeng WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13702 9258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raw tune jr. User:ShadowHalo 04:19, 14 January 2007 (UTC) delete Fails , conflict of interest Deletion of Raw tune jr. WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13703 11356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swivel New Media User:Darryl 00:55, 22 May 2020 (UTC) delete Seems promotional and without any independent sources. Fails Deletion of Swivel New Media WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13704 3369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dustin Kellogg User:WilliamJE 16:24, 1 November 2014 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Dustin Kellogg WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13705 17114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EliteAnswers.com User:Amalthea 03:36, 26 September 2008 (UTC) delete Each and every reference given in the article or found via google originiated from a press release or similar PR (including the interviews). EliteAnswers/Eliteweb fails , & Deletion of EliteAnswers.com WP:WEB||WP:CORP||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13706 4737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Hayden Jr. User:Unscintillating 22:13, 4 January 2018 (UTC) comment nbsp; The policy ATD prevails over the policy DEL8 when there is a -M|merge target that allows a policy-required |preservation of content contributions. Deletion of John Hayden Jr. WP:ATD||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13707 1892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctors for America User:NickCT 18:51, 21 December 2020 (UTC) keep I do have trouble finding direct coverage in secondary sources, but the group seems to have received at least passing mention in virtually every news outlet out there (e.g. https://www.miamiherald.com/news/health-care/article247668425.html Miami Herald, https://www.politico.com/newsletters/playbook-pm/2020/11/25/the-trump-biden-split-screen-490997 Politico, https://www.latimes.com/politics/story/2020-12-06/joe-biden-xavier-becerra-health-and-human-services-secretary LA Times, https://www.wsj.com/articles/joe-bidens-white-house-and-cabinet-picks-11606160202 WSJ, https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-texas/houston/article/As-coronavirus-cases-increase-at-detention-15303943.php Houston Chronicle, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-05-01/doctors-call-for-u-s-czar-to-coordinate-equipment-tests Bloomberg, https://newyork.cbslocal.com/2020/08/26/cdc-covid-19-testing-guidelines-change-doctors-react/ CBS, https://www.washingtonpost.com/washington-post-live/2020/09/10/americas-health-future/ WaPo, https://www.nytimes.com/live/2020/11/09/us/joe-biden-trump NYT). Even if there isn't any direct coverage, the indirect coverage so broad as to meet Deletion of Doctors for America WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13708 12924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ozi Amanat (2nd nomination) User:DreamLinker 05:27, 6 January 2018 (UTC) delete as it seems the individual himself is not notable. He himself did not do any investments, but rather the company he was part of did it. So this means, the achievements are that of the company, not this guy himself as per . Media reports quote him as an executive of the company or as Chief Investment Officer, but they do not say that these were his own personal achievements. In any case, simply doing a bunch of investments and being a millionaire is nothing notable anyway. So delete Deletion of Ozi Amanat (2nd nomination) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13709 8551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Data center automation User:SamJohnston 18:31, 21 March 2009 (UTC) delete per nom, and see also Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Shell curses. Deletion of Data center automation WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
13710 13118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of scientists who disagree with the scientific consensus on global warming User:Crossroads 21:36, 13 November 2019 (UTC) delete per and , and per the other points made above. Cranks are well-known to maintain such lists of authoritative-sounding people to bolster their own legitimacy, and this list is just another in this genre. Long past time to kill it Deletion of List of scientists who disagree with the scientific consensus on global warming WP:UNDUE||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
13711 1792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julien david User:Usrnme 12:31, 7 January 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. Also probably points 4 and 5 Deletion of Julien david WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13712 17733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Roman Emperors from modern Serbia User:Frank 02:10, 4 June 2008 (UTC) delete I'm not real fond of lists of this type which represent and are generally hard to maintain. Presumably this one's a bit easier since the Roman Empire hasn't had much activity lately. Nevertheless, there's lots of original research, and only one reference, and it does seem to be a fairly nationalistic list. I always get comments when I suggest a instead, but...I think that's the way to go on this one. It acknowledges a commonality and allows the interested reader to navigate through without being obtrusive and looking like it is pretending to be complete (as an encyclopedic list almost must by definition Deletion of List of Roman Emperors from modern Serbia WP:OR||WP:CATEGORY Wikipedia:No original research 65
13713 18094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brea Canyon User:Walton_monarchist89 15:25, 6 April 2007 (UTC) delete no evidence of notability; news reports on deaths on the road do not necessarily make the road itself notable per . What we really need is a specific notability guideline on geographical locations, to weed out articles like this (at the moment, many users seem to think that all major roads are inherently notable Deletion of Brea Canyon WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13714 209 [[Martini-Klinik]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Andante NONE delete """Kleines Privathaus, das keine relevanzschaffenden Merkmale aufweist, weder historisch, noch wirtschaftlich oder wissenschaftlich (#Krankenh.C3.A4user|WP:RK#Krankenhäuuser). Kooperationen wie die erwähnte hat quasi jedes Haus. Und das """"tollstebestewirksamstes"""" Produkt bietet ja bekanntlich jedes Wirtschaftsunternehmen an""" Löschung von Martini-Klinik Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
13715 21390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Race, ethnicity, and religion in various censuses User:Uzma 10:38, 28 September 2012 (UTC) keep """This falls under : The list is a valuable information source. """"This is particularly the case for a structured list. Examples would include lists ... grouped by theme."""" The state of the current list is that editors do not appear to be guessing what may be added to the list, so the list's inclusion criteria appears to be appropriate. I suggest the page include a sortable table format having columns for country and each of race, ethnicity, religion, or some combination, and when the feature was first added to the census. That way, you could see which countries count their populations by race, bor example, and when the first started doing so (which would help the reader see where this started and how it spread about the world""" Deletion of Race, ethnicity, and religion in various censuses WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
13716 10171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebekah Davis User:Mkativerata 20:05, 13 April 2010 (UTC) merge to Nebraska's 3rd congressional district, as the general rule prescribed by requires for otherwise unnotable political candidates Deletion of Rebekah Davis WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
13717 13628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul D'Amour User:Lugnuts 13:30, 2 March 2019 (UTC) keep apart from being a founding member of a major band, there's a |ton of stuff online, such as https://www.bassplayer.com/artists/paul-damour-escaping-the-undertow, https://silaslikesmusic.wordpress.com/2011/10/18/feersum-ennjin-interview-with-paul-damoure/, https://www.alternativenation.net/maynard-james-keenan-talks-psychic-tool-firing-bassist/, http://metalassault.com/Interviews/2011/11/28/interview-ex-tool-bassist-paul-damour-talks-about-new-band-feersum-ennjin-audio/, etc to meet any notability requirements Deletion of Paul D'Amour WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13718 1987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/King of the Gypsies User:Lacypaperclip 04:41, 14 January 2018 (UTC) keep The article is well sourced and passes Deletion of King of the Gypsies WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13719 8703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hugh Smith (news anchor) User:A 18:02, 14 June 2009 (UTC) comment after weeding out advertisements, blog posts, duplicate links, and very brief offhand mentions (less than half a sentence) in articles chiefly about other subjects, the article looks like http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hugh_Smith_(news_anchor)&oldid=296387231 this. The remaining references are a non-biographical profile of all of the news anchors of Tampa Bay, a brief mention that WTVT changed news directors (mentioning Hugh Smith as the second of two job changes), and an article that is about Hugh Smith getting a radio job after his television career was ruined. All are in the ''St. Petersburg Times''. Two peripheral mentions and one article about Hugh Smith, all in the same newspaper, are not |significant coverage in reliable sources. The only significant coverage is an obvious candidate. This is not sufficient for an encyclopedia biography Deletion of Hugh Smith (news anchor) WP:GNG||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13720 1334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Millie Binks User:Edison 23:11, 4 January 2009 (UTC) delete Seems to fail |notability and Deletion of Millie Binks WP:N||WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
13721 7264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russian influence operations in Estonia (2nd nomination) User:Multixfer 22:20, 4 August 2009 (UTC) keep If the title is POV, move the article to a better title: we don't delete entire articles because of disputes over what to name them. A argument has no bearing on whether to keep or delete this article. Article is well-cited Deletion of Russian influence operations in Estonia (2nd nomination) WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13722 19444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernard Cheong (2nd nomination) User:Edwardx 21:55, 9 February 2018 (UTC) keep Article is too promotional, but there is enough to pass Deletion of Bernard Cheong (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13723 15647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Prunty User:Gwalla 20:06, 21 July 2014 (UTC) keep per Czar above. I should remind Bearcat that the only requirement is that the sources exist, not that they be added to the article (though of course it would be nice): #Article content does not determine notability. &mdash Deletion of Ben Prunty WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13724 5644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Average frustrated chump (4th nomination) User:A 05:12, 29 December 2009 (UTC) keep """First of all, does not prohibit articles on neologisms; it merely states that they often aren't notable enough for an article of their own: """"Some neologisms can be in frequent use, and it may be possible to pull together many facts about a particular term and show evidence of its usage on the Internet or even in larger society. It may be natural, then, to feel that Wikipedia should have a page devoted to this new term, and this is sometimes but not always the case."""" This is such a neologism; it has entered the popular culture and can be found in many, many reliable sources (just glancing at the Google News and Google Books search results). The article as it stands is not , either; it cites multiple reliable sources, and while Strauss's book is the main reference, it is far from the only one. (Newspaper sources include ''The New York Times'' and ''The New York Sun''.) If anything, the article has improved since the last AfD (where the consensus was to keep""" Deletion of Average frustrated chump (4th nomination) WP:NEO||WP:OR Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
13725 4713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mexico–Serbia relations User:Edison 06:18, 5 May 2009 (UTC) delete """After 6 months, it is still a pathetic stub with no references showing notability. How many books or journal article have been written on the topic of """"Relations between Mexico and Serbia?"""" Seems like a mere directory listing, which violates """ Deletion of Mexico–Serbia relations WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13726 21405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/First Signs of Frost User:Precious 09:17, 10 July 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Claims of media coverage are |unverifiable Deletion of First Signs of Frost WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13727 21365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Goran Zorić User:GiantSnowman 11:56, 14 May 2011 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Goran Zorić WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13728 17011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Elliott (footballer) User:Malcolmxl5 23:47, 21 July 2008 (UTC) delete Completely non-notable! Fails thlete by some margin Deletion of Steve Elliott (footballer) WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
13729 5356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sand Frizzle User:Doc 04:01, 2 September 2008 (UTC) delete WP:NFT|made up |nonsense. No applicable non-Wikipedia http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla%3Aen-US%3Aofficial&hs=Qth&q=%22sand+frizzle%22&btnG=Search ghits Deletion of Sand Frizzle WP:NONSENSE Wikipedia:Patent nonsense 105
13730 6257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sebastian Osigwe User:Redditaddict69 20:04, 30 September 2018 (UTC) delete Doesn't satisfy Deletion of Sebastian Osigwe WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13731 5862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Angel Locsin's Commercials and Endorsements User:Wisdom89 00:19, 30 March 2008 (UTC) delete per article content/POV |forking. If it becomes a problem in the future, perhaps , but I don't think that's the case here. Also, this list has some cruftiness to it. It's pretty unenyclopedic in nature Deletion of List of Angel Locsin's Commercials and Endorsements WP:FORK||WP:SALT Wikipedia:Mirrors and forks 46
13732 6002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lost, Scotland User:Elomis 20:19, 21 November 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. does make the unfortunate and regretable concession that somehow every backwater non-notable town which may be folded up tomorrow can have it's article. I'm going to cite |Wikipedia: ignore all rules and suggest deletion. This rule about in that every hole on the planet can have an article is a bad thing, and for the benefit of Wikipedia should be ignored Deletion of Lost, Scotland WP:NOTABILITY||WP:IGNORE||WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13733 18738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lokeswara Rao Sajja User:Xxanthippe 22:14, 22 July 2014 (UTC) delete A gS h-index of 7 is nowhere near enough to pass rof#1 in this highly cited field Deletion of Lokeswara Rao Sajja WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
13734 1146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trembulo User:Czar 09:57, 24 December 2012 (UTC) delete """I searched for this during the RFC but came up dry other than a website that """"discovered"""" this instrument care of Wikipedia citogenesis. No relevant hits in Google Books. No |RS. No deal. (Note that there is a full Commons category to clean up if this is deleted: :commons:Category:Trembulo""" Deletion of Trembulo WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13735 4397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vinay Deolalikar User:Personman 19:00, 10 August 2010 (UTC) keep He seems trivially notable under . There are multiple traditional news articles, as has been pointed out, and even if the proof is flawed it is generally acknowledged that much of the work in it is good and will contribute to other results in the field. (For one example of this see issue #4 https://rjlipton.wordpress.com/2010/08/09/issues-in-the-proof-that-p%E2%89%A0np/ here Deletion of Vinay Deolalikar WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13736 1854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rajesh Shah (3rd nomination) User:Zefr 14:57, 25 September 2017 (UTC) delete """Shah is a charlatan preying on ignorance and gullibility. He claims to have an MD (Homeopathy), an oxymoron because no Higher education accreditation|accredited university provides such a degree, which dishonors the rigor of a true MD. The article contains weak, non-expert, one-sided sources, and is a disguise behind apparent research to blatantly promote his online business at https://www.askdrshah.com/online.aspx where an """"interview"""" begins with step 1, """"Make payment"""". I removed this personal website per . The article should be nominated for speedy deletion per under numerous criteria, including """"unambiguous advertising"""" and """"blatant hoax""" Deletion of Rajesh Shah (3rd nomination) WP:ADMASK||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Spam 112
13737 17209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trenton Oldfield User:Peterkingiron 18:43, 8 April 2012 (UTC) merge to the Boat race. This is clearly a crank, who will get his deserts in due course. '''protect the redirect''' from editing. applies: this is a classic case of a news story Deletion of Trenton Oldfield WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13738 7180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Uprights User:NeoFreak 14:49, 21 February 2007 (UTC) delete The article fails the |attribution policy Deletion of The Uprights WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
13739 15673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/White Palace (Dhamdachha) User:Sidtever 16:41, 26 January 2020 (UTC) keep it passes with the current coverage from stateman and other reliable sources. We cant say that these are paid articles until they explicitly says that, it totally based on user's perception and if there is a doubt it must definitely go in favor of the creator. Until you cant prove it, there is no point of bringing it Deletion of White Palace (Dhamdachha) WP:NBUILD Wikipedia:Notability 77
13740 10963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cecilia Aros Hunter User:Sc 20:10, 3 October 2007 (UTC) delete per nom and fails Deletion of Cecilia Aros Hunter WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13741 17628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cover the spot User:Northamerica1000 22:34, 27 May 2016 (UTC) merge to Carnival game, which presently only has a link to the article in its See also section. Does not appear to meet ; source searches are only providing passing mentions (e.g. https://books.google.com/books?id=VbmGAAAAIAAJ&q=%22Cover+the+spot%22+carnival+game&dq=%22Cover+the+spot%22+carnival+game&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiL1qyRp_vMAhVbImMKHQg6CoAQ6AEIXzAJ, https://books.google.com/books?id=jq2DBQAAQBAJ&pg=PA155&dq=%22Cover+the+spot%22+carnival+game&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiL1qyRp_vMAhVbImMKHQg6CoAQ6AEIOzAC#v=onepage&q=%22Cover%20the%20spot%22%20carnival%20game&f=false Deletion of Cover the spot WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13742 16281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heenal Raichura (2nd nomination) User:Chris 22:28, 28 June 2011 (UTC) keep I stand by what I said last time. It's not whether we being the youngest doctor ever should be considered notable, it's whether independent reliable third-party sources found it notable enough to write about it. I disagree that we should be dogmatically disregarding the coverage because of - she is not an event, and she remained the youngest doctor for two years after the initial coverage died down. In any case, there has been subsequent coverage and awards since she became the youngest doctor on an international scale, so I think it's sustained and widespread enough to qualify for event coverage. One alternative might be to merge all these youngest doctors into, say, Youngest doctor in the UK (I think the information in this article is mergeable), but I disagree that this should face outright deletion Deletion of Heenal Raichura (2nd nomination) WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
13743 5083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of films portraying paedophilia or sexual abuse of minors User:Kendrick7 02:41, 8 February 2010 (UTC) delete Probably there are enough academic sources to create a general Pedophilia in popular culture overview, but we have ategories which are a perfectly good substitute for such lists Deletion of List of films portraying paedophilia or sexual abuse of minors WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
13744 5038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pacific Paranormal Investigations User:LuckyLouie 20:37, 23 September 2010 (UTC) delete """per as there are no reliable sources found that confer notability. Content such as """"This group has its own Facebook page"""" is also a likely sign of """ Deletion of Pacific Paranormal Investigations WP:NOTE||WP:VANITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13745 51 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Semra Algül Kullanıcı:nanahuatlnanahuatl 07.30, 9 Mart 2021 (UTC) delete Birkaç yerde adı geçiyor, birtakım etkinliklere katılan isimler arasında; ancak kayda değer olduğunu ispat edecek bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynaklara rastlayamadım. Maddedeki kaynak da TRT, yani çalıştığı kuruma ait bir kaynak, dolayısıyla |bağımsız olmayan bir kaynak Semra Algül'ün silinmesi Vikipedi:BK Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13746 13732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derek Powers User:2pou 17:46, 27 August 2020 (UTC) merge to the list as noted above for a -R where he's already mentioned Deletion of Derek Powers WP:CHEAP||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
13747 13408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kofi Koranteng User:Webmaster862 03:18, 15 January 2021 (UTC) keep The article meets guidelines Deletion of Kofi Koranteng WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13748 3407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sicmed User:Doctree 15:54, 4 July 2012 (UTC) delete per nom and . I found many mentions of the project but no results, no |reliable sources to establish |notability. If the project produces results later, it can be recreated but its not suitable as an article now per Deletion of Sicmed WP:TOOSOON||WP:RS||WP:N||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Too soon 40
13749 12883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samuel Gebru User:Rhododendrites 17:58, 1 March 2015 (UTC) keep To clarify, '''Speedy Keep''' if the deletion rationale is taken at face value, as there are many claims to significance in the article. '''Keep''' if we assume the deletion rationale concerns notability. I'm actually on the edge of weak keep and regular keep, but regardless, I think the sourcing as it is, without even looking for more, gets by . The article needs some serious editing, though, as while there are enough good sources for notability purposes, many of these sources are primary/poor. I went through and combined repeated refs into named refs to better assess the article, but didn't make any real revisions to the article. I will also be !voting for a selective merge to this article at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethiopian Global Initiative. &mdash Deletion of Samuel Gebru WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13750 7945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Is Genesis History? (2nd nomination) User:Ian 14:04, 29 May 2018 (UTC) delete """I'll admit that I haven't gone through every single source in every single version of the article. But establishing notability really is not so hard that I should have to do that. |It is the responsibility of the """"keep"""" !voters here to link us to just three reliable sources (preferably from more than a regional level) that are independent of the subject but specifically about it. |Citing (or worse, just mentioning) a bunch of sources that only barely mention the subject, or that are only sorta not related if you don't look directly at it, or are only ''almost'' reliable is a tactic used to obfuscate a lack of notability (|I'll assume it's accidental and not #One_who_demands_that_others_find_sources_for_his/her_own_statements|intentional). A http://www.indiewire.com/2018/01/documentaries-box-office-2017-1201910072/ quarter-sentence mention in an article in a broader trend doesn't work. Creationist sites do not work. Blogs masquerading as newspapers do not work. A blurb in a podunk newspaper only announcing that """"i'z gun'be sho'n at da the'dur nex'ta Unc'a-Daddy Jim-Bob's Gunz-n-Fry'd Chik'n"""" does not work. |Saying that there are sources out there while expecting us to find them does not work. I'm even going to ignore the deletion argument that an article should meet either NFILM or NFRINGE and can't just cherry pick to ride some weird middle ground -- the """"keep"""" !voters simply are not presenting any good reason to keep the article and if they were !voting """"keep"""" in both full knowledge and honesty they should be able to present just three sources""" Deletion of Is Genesis History? (2nd nomination) WP:BURDEN||WP:CITEKILL||WP:AGF||WP:TEND||WP:BURDEN Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13751 17097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pierre Piskor User:Sir 16:47, 18 November 2010 (UTC) comment As the nominator, I'm now satisfied that he meets and willing to withdraw the nomination Deletion of Pierre Piskor WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13752 12437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Hive (Resident Evil) User:Gavin 08:49, 29 November 2007 (UTC) delete as there is no valid argument for merge. Firstly, it has no primary sources to |verify its content, so merger will just move this problem elsewhere. Secondly, it has no |reliable secondary sources to demonstrate real-world |notability. Lastly it has no encyclopedic content, as it primarily #PLOT|plot summary with a heavy in universe perspective Deletion of The Hive (Resident Evil) WP:V||WP:RS||WP:FICT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13753 14629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lila Sawyer User:Gavin 13:52, 4 June 2009 (UTC) delete as these articles fail #PLOT as well as all three of Wikipedia's core content polices. There are no reliable sources to verify their content which is filled with opinions about these fictional characters that is pure original research. These articles are basically |content folks, as they provide no commentary, criticism, context or analysis that is not already contained in the article Hey Arnold Deletion of Lila Sawyer WP:NOT||WP:CFORK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13754 17721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buffalo International Film Festival User:Shruti14 19:49, 17 August 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Buffalo International Film Festival WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13755 8051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Watchfinder (2nd nomination) User:Fieari 03:39, 23 September 2016 (UTC) delete I note that there do seem to be a small number of citations that MIGHT convey notability... but the problem is that this page is so severely an advertisement that even if it is notable, there's nothing to salvage for a real article. So even if notability applies, I'm actually going to buck my long-standing trend of avoiding , and say that applies here IFF notability is actually established. Delete without prejudice for being recreated WITHOUT being an advertisement and firmly establishing notability with real, valid, reliable sources Deletion of Watchfinder (2nd nomination) WP:TNT||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
13756 2921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prabhakar Thokal User:KylieTastic 16:15, 19 December 2020 (UTC) delete no indication passes / Deletion of Prabhakar Thokal WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13757 1228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008 United States presidential election controversies and attacks NONE NONE keep """Biophys (""""criticism is good"""" is not an inclusion criterium), JeremyMcCracken and Everyking (""" Deletion of 2008 United States presidential election controversies and attacks WP:USEFUL Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13758 4653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter J. Burien Jr. User:MelanieN 01:10, 12 June 2010 (UTC) delete """Non-notable. Subject has never held office, fails . He has never written a book, fails . He has a couple of patents, but that does not confer notability. He has occasionally been interviewed on the radio http://www.coasttocoastam.com/guest/burien-walter/43097. Other than that I could not find any significant or reliable coverage about him. Lots of stuff on blogs and such, but nothing from mainstream sources. Google News provides nothing at all for """"Walter R. Burien Jr."""" and only five hits for """"Walter Burien"""" - none of them from reliable or notable sources.http://www.google.com/search?num=50&hl=en&tbs=nws%3A1&q=%22Walter+Burien%22&btnG=Search&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai=. Mr. Burien claims that Google gives 400,000 hits for Walter Burien, but that undoubtedly includes sites with just """"Walter"""" or just """"Burien"""". A search for """"Walter Burien"""" with the quotation marks actually provides 70,000 hits - many of them things like an e-mail he wrote to somebody. """"Walter Bubien"""" does no better. (He claims he changed his name out of fear of reprisal - reprisal for exactly what is not clear; he claims that he and his friends and the station he appeared on """"came under attack,"""" but no trace of that attack can be found on Google.) The article itself is a mess, a cross between resumé and narrative essay, but it could be rewritten if the subject himself was notable per Wikipedia's standards - which in my opinion he is not""" Deletion of Walter J. Burien Jr. WP:POLITICIAN||WP:AUTHOR||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13759 10985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Campus Destinations, Inc. User:Siva1979 13:45, 17 September 2007 (UTC) delete Fails |notability guidelines. Moreover, a http://www.google.com.sg/search?as_q=&hl=en&num=100&btnG=Google+Search&as_epq=Campus+Destinations%2C+Inc.&as_oq=&as_eq=wikipedia&lr=&as_ft=i&as_filetype=&as_qdr=all&as_occt=any&as_dt=i&as_sitesearch=&as_rights=&safe=image google search shows up no |reliable sources for this company. --|S Deletion of Campus Destinations, Inc. WP:N||WP:RS||WP:ESP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13760 3085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tocquigny User:Kinu 18:53, 31 October 2014 (UTC) delete I'm not seeing enough coverage to satisfy or . The ''Advertising Age'' story and the Zagat article (which is really a promotional piece) linked above barely mention the agency. I don't see much in the way of anything that might meet and that isn't routine local coverage. The awards, quite frankly, don't appear to convey any sort of notability Deletion of Tocquigny WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13761 18878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Is The Life (album) User:TenPoundHammer 23:41, 25 June 2007 (UTC) delete as the artist herself doesn't ''seem'' to be notable as per . She could be, but I don't see anything in the article that says she is. If she's not notable, then her album is likely non-notable too Deletion of This Is The Life (album) WP:HOLE Wikipedia:I wouldn't know him from a hole in the ground 12
13762 16633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burak Kaan Bülbüloğlu User:onel5969 15:10, 5 September 2015 (UTC) delete Searches failed to turn up anything which will meet Deletion of Burak Kaan Bülbüloğlu WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13763 18218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Human rights in Asia (2nd nomination) User:Khu 19:08, 9 May 2020 (UTC) delete This article is far too broad for any meaningful analysis or examination. As it stands right now, this article could cover all of Asia, throughout all of history. The human rights of different regions of Asia, and different countries can be extremely different from one another. As it is now, the article mostly focuses on East Asia, with a little bit about Central and South Asia included as well (the Middle East is not mentioned at all). Nearly all of these analyses are not written in a very encyclopedic form, much more like an |ESSAY, with a lack of meaningful sources for most Deletion of Human rights in Asia (2nd nomination) WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13764 17943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashtree Primary School (3rd nomination) User:Coredesat 15:56, 14 November 2006 (UTC) delete This article has hardly changed since the last very strange AFD, and despite the prose, there is nothing here that indicates|notability Deletion of Ashtree Primary School (3rd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13765 17401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Elissee [[User talk:WikHead|talk]]) 23:12, 31 August 2012 (UTC) delete I fully agree with User:Oceangreenn (above). I was tempted nominate this as self-promotion piece myself, but hesitated in hopes that some non-English would eventually come forward to properly establish notability of this individual. -- Special:Contributions/WikHead|WikHead Deletion of Andrew Elissee WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13766 10804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexis Mendiola User:IJA 15:13, 5 November 2014 (UTC) delete He hasn't played in a Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|Fully professional league and he doesn't have any senior international caps either therefore he fails Deletion of Alexis Mendiola WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13767 5027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Demba Diakhaté User:GiantSnowman 08:36, 13 August 2013 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Demba Diakhaté WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13768 19360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Max Cater User:Squeamish 21:31, 13 March 2015 (UTC) delete GB Taekwondo is an affiliate of the World Taekwondo Federation; the Bosnia Open, Turkish Open, and Swiss Open are not the highest level of competition for that organization (which would be the WTF World Taekwondo Championships and/or the Olympics). I do not believe that the levels of competition described for the article's subject satisfies #Martial artists criterion 4 (and has no evidence of satisfying the standards' other options Deletion of Max Cater WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13769 10224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Life of African Women User:VanTucky 22:09, 21 July 2007 (UTC) delete talk about |indiscriminate...this list could go on for billions of entries Deletion of Life of African Women WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13770 16401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ISOWORG User:Shooterwalker 15:24, 21 February 2011 (UTC) delete Lack of sources to of this fictional term Deletion of ISOWORG WP:verify notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
13771 15298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Channy User:Darth_Panda 21:07, 27 October 2008 (UTC) comment Couldn't find a good way to describe nonsense without linking to , sorry Deletion of Channy WP:PN Wikipedia:Patent nonsense 105
13772 15728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of relationships with age disparity User:Thivierr 06:33, 16 June 2006 (UTC) delete """No useful information, or navigation potential from the list. It engages in a bit of """"guilt by association"""" (by mixing adult-only relationships with adult/minor relationships). It has great potential for attacks on |living people. It has no citations whatsoever, despite the nature of some entries. That seems to be a violation of policy. Here's a dubious example: """"''Woody Allen and Soon-Yi Previn, 35 years. She was his stepdaugher and 22 years''"""". Now, to my knowledge, Woody was involved with Soon-Yi's mother (Mia), but was not legally married to Mia, and Soon-Yi was never a step-daughter. If she was his legal step-daughter, he would be guilty of a serious criminal offence. Further, there have been conflicting reports as to whether Soon-Yi's exact age is known. Now, my understanding of facts, may well be totally wrong. I would love to check the sources, to verify the information, but of course, no source is cited""" Deletion of List of relationships with age disparity WP:LIVING Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13773 15972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alejandro Guerrero User:J 20:23, 31 July 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Alejandro Guerrero WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13774 6485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sippai User:MichaelQSchmidt 19:31, 29 March 2015 (UTC) keep per meeting | (paragraph 3) for a slow-moving project which has begun filming and is not yet released.https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Saravanan%2C+Sippai%22&tbm=nws Even |were this to be never released, we'd have |coverage to show its failure as meeting inclusion criteria. Or perhaps the topic can be spoken of in the director's article? ''IF'' there ever is one Deletion of Sippai WP:NFF||WP:CBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13775 2206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VS Media User:Citobun 07:34, 13 November 2015 (UTC) delete or '''rewrite entirely'''. Article written by single-purpose account for promotional purposes. |Wikipedia is not a vehicle for advertising. The quality of the writing is that of a promotional release, not an encyclopedia article; there is very little encyclopedic content here and the notability of the company is not clear. If it can be demonstrated that the company meets the relevant Wikipedia:Notability (organizations and companies)|notability criteria then the article should be rewritten as an Wikipedia:Neutral point of view|NPOV encyclopedia article. If not then it should be deleted for now Deletion of VS Media WP:NOTADVERTISING Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13776 8087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Alliluyev User:Darth_Panda 14:50, 3 November 2008 (UTC) delete Notability is not inherited. However, in this case, is known (not well) in the http://www.russia-ic.com/news/show/7332/ news and in http://books.google.com/books?sa=N&tab=np&q=Joseph%20Alliluyev books, yet they all stem from his status as the grandson of Stalin. I would argue that he still fails Deletion of Joseph Alliluyev WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13777 11430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Forrest Lin User:Tevildo 14:34, 21 November 2009 (UTC) delete """per nom. I suppose is the relevant guideline, and the competition he's allegedly notable for does not appear in the official World Cube Association|WCA listings (http://www.worldcubeassociation.org/results/competitions.php?eventId=®ionId=&years=only%2B2009&list=List) for 2009, which is presumably the """"highest amateur level"""" of this particular competitive activity""" Deletion of Forrest Lin WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13778 10718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rohan Rangarajan User:CAPTAIN 12:55, 14 March 2017 (UTC) delete This cricketer has not played any First Class/List A cricket.Fails Deletion of Rohan Rangarajan WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13779 19224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tsewang Gyaltson User:CAPTAIN 20:03, 24 February 2017 (UTC) keep Passes Deletion of Tsewang Gyaltson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13780 14286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jess Jackson User:Cullen328 22:41, 19 February 2011 (UTC) delete unless |reliable sources can be found that discuss this particular person in depth. I found lots of articles about California wine producer Jess Jackson. Maybe we should have an article about him instead Deletion of Jess Jackson WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13781 20347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susan Boyle User:Jon 21:19, 13 April 2009 (UTC) comment can't this just be |snowballed now? In case not, strong keep per media coverage Deletion of Susan Boyle WP:SNOWBALL Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
13782 1677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ron Dwight User:Ahunt 13:05, 21 November 2017 (UTC) delete """no indication of here, no independent third party sources to establish notability. The prevalence of accounts all supporting """"keep"""" above while not providing any refs is a concern, see """ Deletion of Ron Dwight WP:GNG||WP:SPA||WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13783 9804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of online charity donation services in the United Kingdom User:Kashmiri 15:50, 14 January 2016 (UTC) keep and consider renaming to ''List of online charity donation services in the United Kingdom''. There is nothing wrong with having detailed lists of items which have some shared characteristics - see Comparison of crowdfunding services, Comparison of video codecs, and countless others. does not really apply to list-type articles which, by their nature, cannot delve into minute details of the items they list. Personally, I am perfectly fine with articles titled ''List of...'' – although I have reservations with regard to ''Comparison of...'' since such titles suggest a substantial degree of (comparing things is a creative work; mere listing them is not); hence my rename suggestion Deletion of Comparison of online charity donation services in the United Kingdom WP:NOTGUIDE||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13784 20844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jessica Betancourt User:Metropolitan90 04:13, 6 December 2006 (UTC) delete due to insufficient evidence that she satisfies yet Deletion of Jessica Betancourt WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13785 21683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yusif Khalil Abdallah Nur User:Iqinn 23:38, 13 February 2011 (UTC) delete """lacks """"significant independent coverage"""" per as primary sources can not establish notability""" Deletion of Yusif Khalil Abdallah Nur WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13786 17861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prayukti User:Rameshnta909 12:24, 5 December 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |GNG Deletion of Prayukti WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13787 15784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Betsy Beutler User:FisherQueen 11:39, 27 April 2009 (UTC) delete This actor may appear on television, but she doesn't appear to be playing main characters, nor could I find any |reliable sources discussing her Deletion of Betsy Beutler WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13788 13556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rat Salad [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] 05:39, 10 December 2012 (UTC) delete per and per nom Deletion of Rat Salad WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13789 2043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Warcraft locations (2nd nomination) User:onel5969 12:07, 27 December 2017 (UTC) delete complete , full of Deletion of List of Warcraft locations (2nd nomination) WP:GAMECRUFT||WP:OR Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
13790 15854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C++ grammar User:Andy 20:23, 2 November 2012 (UTC) keep It's a week old. Has the nominator made any effort to either improve this article, or to raise the issues with its creator? As it stands, this is far too much like Deletion of C++ grammar WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13791 6265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kilgore Books & Comics User:Deor 23:26, 25 February 2009 (UTC) delete No evidence of significant treatment in |reliable sources that would allow this to satisfy the requirements of . The final bulleted item at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Common outcomes#Companies is also relevant Deletion of Kilgore Books & Comics WP:RS||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13792 16934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marlabs (2nd nomination) User:CNMall41 19:43, 5 December 2018 (UTC) delete A search found references that were brief mentions, press releases, unreliable, or general announcements. Nothing to satisfy . A stub article has nothing to do with notability. The company is either notable or it is not. In this case, I believe it is not based on not receiving the type of in-depth coverage required Deletion of Marlabs (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
13793 4540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flesh on Fire: Addicted to a Dream User:Devonian 22:32, 9 November 2020 (UTC) delete sourced to IMDb, a passing mention and a press release, fails Deletion of Flesh on Fire: Addicted to a Dream WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13794 13963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tracey Johnston-Aldworth User:Tomwsulcer 01:57, 9 August 2014 (UTC) keep Notable Canadian businesswoman and environmental spokesperson with multiple in-depth independent reliable sources such as http://www.waterloochronicle.ca/news/print-queen/ this one and being on the cover and featured in http://www.exchangemagazine.com/html/newpublic/Xmedia/ExchangeVol22No2/pdfs/ExchangeVol22No2pgs01-11.pdf this business magazine, plus numerous awards for environmental action such as http://www.grandriver.ca/index/document.cfm?Sec=14&Sub1=66&Sub2=47 special recognition from the government of Ontario. That said, the previous article was too long, with |undue emphasis on spurious details, but the article has been shortened Deletion of Tracey Johnston-Aldworth WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
13795 11436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saturn Films User:HighKing 13:10, 31 January 2018 (UTC) delete """or Merge with Nicolas Cage filmography#As producer. The Keep !votes above such as """"a useful index page"""" and """"production company of several notable films"""" are not convincing reasons since Wikipedia is not a Yellow Pages or Directory and notability is not inherited. There is no indication of independent notability for this company and no independent references exist. Topic fails GNG and . No references exist that meets criteria for establishing notability""" Deletion of Saturn Films WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13796 13836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rockingham bus station User:Deus 23:17, 11 June 2021 (UTC) merge to List of Perth bus stationsRockingham railway station, Perth. Suitable |alternative to deletion Deletion of Rockingham bus station WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
13797 3333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chronology of Star Wars User:pd_THOR 18:00, 15 April 2009 (UTC) delete This is nothing but |''Star Wars''{{'}} plot sourced solely from |primary sources. I agree with AMIB in that this seems to border on being a |copyright violation Deletion of Chronology of Star Wars WP:PLOT||WP:PSTS||WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13798 19112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stryver User:Shooterwalker 01:54, 23 November 2020 (UTC) merge as there is insufficient coverage in reliable third party sources to meet the . I do see some which aren't enough to meet the , but still enough to potentially be preserved if someone really thinks it adds value and feels like doing a very selective merge Deletion of Stryver WP:GNG||WP:TRIVIALMENTIONS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13799 7372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simtropolis (2nd nomination) User:Chriscf 19:07, 11 February 2007 (UTC) comment A merge is clearly not appropriate, and the site is potentially notable (large userbase, largest SimCity 4 fansite), but I'm not seeing the ''|multiple, independent, reliable sources'' here Deletion of Simtropolis (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13800 2194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pavle Stanimirovic [[User_talk:ZfJames|chat page ]], [[Special:Contributions/ZfJames|contribs]]) 01:55, 15 May 2018 (UTC) delete This article certainly fails , but the fellow has a lot of media coverage... I'm somewhat conflicted, but I say 'delete' because there is not a lot of coverage that isn't incidental (i.e. he happens to be referenced as an 'expert' on a specific crime group in a few articles). '''- zfJames''' ''Please Template:Reply_to|ping me in your reply on this page Deletion of Pavle Stanimirovic WP:PERPETRATOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13801 17319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/V-ology User:Ohconfucius 04:56, 4 September 2006 (UTC) delete per . Non-notable religion mad up to sell energy drink. Even the follower above admits it's advertising Deletion of V-ology WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
13802 4014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crowne Plaza Abu Dhabi Yas Island User:Bearian 22:56, 18 October 2016 (UTC) delete per above. Also, see and . We are not a free webhost for the for-profit Intercontinental hotel brand; ''we are a charity''. This is merely one of six hotels on a small resort island that is off the main tourist trails. I don't see how it's special or |notable in any way Deletion of Crowne Plaza Abu Dhabi Yas Island WP:NOTWEBHOST||WP:MILL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13803 18836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quantification of randomness User:David 00:16, 21 November 2017 (UTC) delete per . The title could be something interesting but the content is useless and vague twaddle with no valid sources Deletion of Quantification of randomness WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
13804 15584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josephine Gillan User:AffeL 11:46, 6 July 2017 (UTC) keep This article obviously meets . Their are many reliable sources about her and this page can be expanded, also she's on Game of Thrones Deletion of Josephine Gillan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13805 6901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bush–Clinton era User:Cbl62 06:37, 31 January 2018 (UTC) delete as . There are not reliable sources covering something known as the Bush-Clinton era. It is a purely arbitrary combination of two U.S. Presidential tenures Deletion of Bush–Clinton era WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13806 19439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pull a Family Guy User:Nsk92 17:17, 8 July 2010 (UTC) delete pure unsourced Deletion of Pull a Family Guy WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13807 18481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crime Prevention through Neighborhood Watch Programs User:Chris 23:39, 11 December 2012 (UTC) delete as an |essay full of |original research, and also because Wikipedia |isn't the Web host for your essays. The professor assigning this appears to misunderstand the goal of Wikipedia. There's no reason why students should have to upload their essays here rather than e-mailing them, or, better yet, handing it printed copies Deletion of Crime Prevention through Neighborhood Watch Programs WP:NOTESSAY||WP:NOTWEBHOST||WP:original research Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13808 374 [[K.D.St.V. Nibelungia (Brünn) Darmstadt]] (gelöscht) Benutzer Diskussion:Gunther|Gunther 15:37, 12. Jul 2005 (CEST NONE delete Kein Herausstellungsmerkmal gemäss erkennbar. Bitte Relevanz im Artikel belegen oder auf der angegebenen Seite über die Kriterien diskutieren. Ansonsten . Löschung von K.D.St.V. Nibelungia (Brünn) Darmstadt Wikipedia:Artikel über Studentenverbindungen Wikipedia:Richtlinien Studentenverbindungen 45
13809 13665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SmarteScript User:Ihcoyc 00:22, 23 October 2009 (UTC) delete """per nomination. This is ''a GUI-driven software test automation tool for automating the testing of software applications''; a tool for computer programmers, apparently, and as such falling within the skewed-towards side of |Wikipedia's inherent bias. Mentioning the Gartner """"magic quadrants"""" in the article's text and making a plea for its importance (""""''a recognition given only to those with significant market presence''"""") suggests clutching at straws on the notability front. Note also that this is yet another article that sprung full blown, complete with infobox, at its creation""" Deletion of SmarteScript WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
13810 18616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Rankin Junior School User:Colonel 21:37, 26 December 2011 (UTC) keep The topic is notable, per , being covered in detail in independent, reliable sources such as http://www.ofsted.gov.uk/provider/files/974517/urn/109825.pdf this. It is our |editing policy to retain such notable topics Deletion of John Rankin Junior School WP:GNG||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13811 10892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Locke and Demosthenes User:Antandrus 02:38, 29 August 2006 (UTC) delete not appropriate for Wikipedia, because it blatantly violates our rule. I strongly recommend that they write about it ''somewhere'', but this isn't the right website for that essay Deletion of Locke and Demosthenes WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13812 13809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah York User:JamesBWatson 22:00, 21 March 2010 (UTC) delete """Not notable at all. The """"lots of reliable sources"""" mentioned above look to me like a fairly moderate number of sources, many of which make only brief mention of Sarah York, and all of which, as far as I can see, refer to one incident. I totally fail to see how this gets past """ Deletion of Sarah York WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13813 17078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C. Liegh McInnis User:Pburka 17:33, 20 March 2011 (UTC) delete He's been quoted a few times in newspapers, but the lack of in-depth third party coverage means he fails Deletion of C. Liegh McInnis WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13814 19875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Retro housewife User:Colonel 22:45, 21 February 2010 (UTC) keep """It seems easy to add sources which testify to the notability of this post-feminist phenomenon. I have added a couple including a book entitled """"''Retro Housewife''"""". Given the ease with which this article can be improved in just a few minutes, the article should be kept for further improvement in accordance with our |editing policy""" Deletion of Retro housewife WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
13815 21745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Paras User:Barmitzg 19:06, 21 December 2020 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Dr. Paras WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13816 12814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abby Norman User:K 00:37, 31 August 2016 (UTC) delete per ; the subject is not notable. In case a redirect is chosen by the closer, suggest deleting before the redirect Deletion of Abby Norman WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
13817 17471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Average frustrated chump (2nd nomination) User:SecondSight 09:20, 26 April 2008 (UTC) keep """per Edison. I am the main author of the article. I voted to delete in the last AFD, because I was unsatisfied with the quality of the article and was having conflicts with other users maintaining it. However, in light of its large number of appearances in Google News that Edison points out, the term has clearly gained a lot of mainstream popularity recently. There are reliable sources on it, so it cannot be excluded on the basis of . Contrary to the nom, it is simply not true that """"usage of the word is confined to pickup guides and supporters of the """"pickup community."""" See this article in the http://www2.nysun.com/article/65300 New York Sun which finds the term useful for describing Steve Carrell's role in the 40-year-old Virgin: ''To borrow some terminology from VH-1's smarmy reality series 'The Pick-Up Artist,"""" Mr. Carell embodies an Average Frustrated Chump who transforms himself into an unlikely babe magnet through the magic powers of emotional revelation.'' While there isn't enough justification to delete the article, it is certainly in need of improvement. (I might support merging it into Seduction Community, except that the latter article is already very long and getting longer""" Deletion of Average frustrated chump (2nd nomination) WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
13818 1955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Awards User:GarrieIrons 05:10, 12 January 2007 (UTC) keep even discounting the reference to channel V, there are plenty of entertainment organisations talking about them. Hopefully, they'll still be around in five years and still have the same sponsor Deletion of Jack Awards WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
13819 12299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marko Milutinović User:Fenix 12:55, 21 March 2018 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Marko Milutinović WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13820 14055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anope User:Artene50 00:18, 4 August 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Anope WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13821 3250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daddy, What's a Train? User:Chiswick 15:22, 31 March 2019 (UTC) delete https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Daddy,+What%27s+a+Train%3F%22+-wikipedia+-youtube+-shop+-store+review&ei=2dqgXPCPKYPhxgOHhZjIBQ&start=60&sa=N&ved=0ahUKEwiw4I-b16zhAhWDsHEKHYcCBlk4WhDy0wMIOw&biw=1235&bih=873 a search finds almost no critical coverage, and unsurprisingly there's no indication of notability in the article either, so this does not meet Deletion of Daddy, What's a Train? WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13822 1157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Advantage User:Swerdnaneb 21:21, 20 September 2007 (UTC) keep Easily meets . They have two albums with a 5 Rue Christine|notable label (this needs sourcing) and Spencer Seim|a musician who brings notability from Hella (band)|another band Deletion of The Advantage WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
13823 2950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CrossCharge User:AllyD 07:06, 8 June 2020 (UTC) delete A article by {{u|Evcharging}} describing a start-up company's proposition, with the text featuring superlatives about their product being the first and safest such product, maximising convenience, etc., without |reliable 3rd party sources. Aside from routine listings, searches find a 2015 brief Q&A with the company founder https://www.prospectsv.org/people-of-prospect-connectmyev/ and a February 2018 announcement about the venture arm of :Stanley Black & Decker taking a minority stake in the company https://www.clearygottlieb.com/news-and-insights/news-listing/stanley-ventures-invests-in-connectmyev but I am not finding the |independent coverage which would be needed ( / ) to sustain an article here, even if pruned of promotional wording Deletion of CrossCharge :WP:SPA||:WP:RS||:WP:RS||:WP:PRODUCT||:WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
13824 610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC Fight Night: Stevenson vs Guillard User:Djohns21 22:09, 1 August 2011 (UTC) delete """I think there is a lot of confusion on whether or not a martial arts event is notable. To begin with, states that individual events are ''not'' notable. Even though I would delete this one, I disagree that there should be a blanket ban every event. I would propose the following guidelines: Events that meet are notable. (This would require coverage ''outside'' of martial arts sources) Events are notable if a title is at stake. Finally, if a group of events are qualifiers for a notable event, such as in a tournament, they are notable as a group. Otherwise, the just aren't notable. Lets be honest, UFC 9 was entertaining, but it doesn't matter. No titles changed hands, no one died, the matches are not the defining moment of any of these fighters lives. We need to have a community wide discussion where we discuss exactly what notability should be for Martial Arts (that doesn't consist of a slugging match between people who think that every match is noteworthy and people who think that no event is """"encyclopedic"""") , but until we do I'm gonna say delete on this one""" Deletion of UFC Fight Night: Stevenson vs Guillard WP:MMANOT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13825 20607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Find My User:Djm 07:40, 8 November 2019 (UTC) comment This is probably a case where addressing ''Consider improving the page to address the concerns raised.'' prior to dePROD especially where the PRODer can take you to is a better course of action unless one wants to make a Deletion of Find My WP:AFD||WP:POINT Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13826 16567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global Officials of Dignity Awards User:Ronz 16:11, 23 August 2015 (UTC) delete Sources are simply public relations pieces. Notability not met. and violation. Redirect to Torres' article if it passes AfD Deletion of Global Officials of Dignity Awards WP:SOAP||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13827 17374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lloyd Banks's third studio album User:Simon 16:53, 15 August 2009 (UTC) delete per and .- Simon Dodd Deletion of Lloyd Banks's third studio album WP:NALBUMS||WP:HAMMERTIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
13828 4791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fish Hoek Library User:HelenOnline 11:38, 25 July 2014 (UTC) keep per subject to removal of off-topic |forking. Fish Hoek is a separate article Deletion of Fish Hoek Library WP:LOCAL||WP:CONTENTFORK Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
13829 15318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelly Coakley User:RayAYang 20:29, 23 January 2010 (UTC) delete per , #NEWS, as nominator says. If she had won her case, that would be something else Deletion of Kelly Coakley WP:BLP1E||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13830 16485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Impact of the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami on the video game industry User:Guyinblack25 15:10, 18 March 2011 (UTC) keep """I suspect that there are a number of emotions involved in this overall discussion, so I'll try to stick to policy.A number of editors have stated that the coverage does not meet thresholds, specifically with the coverage outside the video game industry. does not state that we cannot use the industry experts to discuss the industry. Even then, we have industry's journalist talking about the industry's producers. For example, http://www.mcvuk.com/news/43524/Further-delays-announced-in-Japan MCV, http://www.shacknews.com/article/67815/video-game-industry-feels-earthquakes Shacknews, and http://www.next-gen.biz/news/game-industry-hit-as-nikkei-slumps Edge.That being said, the topic has received coverage outside gaming publications: http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/03/17/nintendos-3-d-players-are-on-schedule/?scp=2&sq=video%20game%20earthquake&st=cse NY Times about the N3DS, http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/interest/2011-03-16/more-relief-efforts-for-march-11-earthquake/tsunami ANN about the relief efforts of the VG industry among others, http://techland.time.com/2011/03/14/quake-knocks-japanese-games-offline-delays-release-of-others/ TIME about the delays and server shutdowns, http://www.aolnews.com/2011/03/17/video-game-community-rallies-to-support-japan-tsunami-victims/ AOL News about the relief efforts, http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/108462-Publishers-Developers-and-Gamers-Respond-to-Japanese-Disaster The Escapist about the relief efforts, http://www.wired.com/gamelife/2011/03/street-fighter-japan-donation/ Wired about the relief efforts, http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/video-games/8383384/UK-release-of-Motorstorm-Apocalypse-delayed-in-light-of-Japan-tsunami.html The Telegraph about the Motorstorm release and industry relief efforts, and http://content.usatoday.com/communities/gamehunters/post/2011/03/land-of-video-game-giants-japan-hit-by-earthquake-tsunami-social-networks-deliver-updates-/1 USA Today about the condition of the gaming employees.In regard to the neutrality of the article, I think the comments about are misconstruing the intent of the policy, which is mainly about presenting controversial viewpoints in a balanced manner. While I understand that the policy extends beyond that, I think this article still complies with it. The scope of the article is clearly defined and presents the relevant information without bias. The fact that other articles about the economic impact don't yet exist is no fault of the article. The information is out there, and I'm sure similar articles will be written later. G members were just the first to take the initiative. If you take a look at our G/FC|Featured and G/GC|Good article output, that may not surprise you.Regardless of all that, per Wikipedia:Neutral point of view/FAQ#Lack of neutrality as an excuse to delete, """"''there is usually no need to immediately delete text than can instead be rewritten as necessary over time.''""""While the main earthquake article probably doesn't mention anything about the video game industry, I assure you that it will was the article is stable. The number of third-party articles that covered the gaming industry's response is too great to ignore. I for one always leave current event articles to those more adept at dealing with such liquid articles. And I suspect that others share that view.In closing, I want to say that I think this AFD is premature. I concede that this article might have been created prematurely, but it quickly morphed into a quality article. Regardless of the number of voices hear, I hope that the closing admin sees the timing and the type of arguments here and realizes that this should be discussed at a later time""" Deletion of Impact of the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and tsunami on the video game industry WP:V||WP:NPOV||WP:VG||WP:VG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13831 15052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of things described as pied User:Propaniac 20:40, 23 November 2009 (UTC) delete """This absolutely does not meet the purpose of a disambiguation page, because virtually none of these entries are referred to as """"pied."""" For example, it is not reasonable that someone would refer to the Northern Pied-babbler as """"pied,"""" or that they would search for that bird under the title """"pied,"""" or expect the article about that bird to be located at the title """"pied."""" These topics are not ambiguous and, as pointed out above, our disambiguation guidelines (#Partial title matches) explicitly say that this sort of thing should ''not'' be included on a disambiguation page. I was the one who redirected the list (back when it was a disambig page) to Piebald, because it appeared to be the only topic listed that was actually (occasionally) referred to as just """"Pied"""" (and I wouldn't object to such a redirect being reinstated). As for the argument that this article should be kept because Wikipedia should have a page or article defining every single word in the English language, whether or not there's anything else to say about it: that is what a dictionary is for""" Deletion of List of things described as pied WP:D Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
13832 16232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C&A Industries User:MuZemike 17:58, 8 December 2008 (UTC) delete Lack of sources demonstrating any |notability. Please |enact creation protection and make the article's (apparently clueless after seven deletions) creator make a case with |deletion review for recreation next time Deletion of C&A Industries WP:N||WP:SALT||WP:DRV Wikipedia:Notability 77
13833 17827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DDT (zine) User:Bearian 00:41, 7 November 2019 (UTC) delete WP:RS|unsourced stub about a |run of the mill zine Deletion of DDT (zine) WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
13834 12013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vincent M. Ward User:MichaelQSchmidt 23:59, 3 April 2013 (UTC) comment """I feel is met, specially as notability is not a popularity contest to see who has the most press coverage. See . Ward's having more-significant roles in television projects and smaller roles in multiple notable film's '''is''' verifiable.http://movies.nytimes.com/person/1329586/Vincent-Wardhttp://www.thehour.com/news/norwalk/actor-vincent-ward-to-visit-norwalk-for-fundraiser/article_8b66b9cf-d207-5b98-a735-f1c570c13d04.htmlhttp://www.vibrantmags.com/#!fashion-show/c7k8http://dailydead.com/meet-the-walking-deads-vincent-ward-oscar-this-friday-in-atlanta/http://dailydead.com/new-details-on-the-walking-dead-season-4-from-robert-kirkman/http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/delawareonline/access/1914748181.html?FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Dec+03%2C+2009&author=%22Grouchy%22Greg+Watkins&pub=The+News+Journal&desc=Entrepreneur+blends+love+of+sports%2C+hip-hop+to+help+community&pqatl=google While the is the easiest or laziest (no offense intended) manner through which to allow presumption of enough notability to merit an article, it is not the only way... else there would be no need for any of the various common sense 's in the first place. Though it makes our task in informing our readers more difficult, we do not """"punish"""" those perhaps-notables for keeping a low media profile.... '''But''' as Ward himself states in a http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xe2f6EBeegg 2012 interview, that despite the non-disclosure agreements he signed (production's means to keep plots secret and stifling spoilers and related coverage) he feels ''The Walking Dead'' is the true beginning of recognition for his acting career"""", perhaps we can '''incubate''' this for a while as he now finally gets the coverage he is due""" Deletion of Vincent M. Ward WP:ENT||WP:GNGACTOR||WP:GNG||WP:SNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13835 91 [[Bianca Braun]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Klar&Frisch 12:06, 3. Apr. 2010 (CEST) delete """http://www.vdm-verlag.de/index.php?&act=nav&nav=10016 Verlag Dr. Müller (VDM) und zählt somit gemäß #Schriftsteller_und_Sachbuchautoren nicht. Das Buch """"Staying private ..."""" ist ihre Dissertation siehe http://www.unisg.ch/hsgweb.nsf/f03e351c4ef8e43ac12572f00034cb6b/cb304e620a2b0558c12574c50048fecc/$FILE/Promotionsfeier_15.9.2008_AbsolventInnenliste.pdf hier. Bleibt also für die Relevanz nur 1 Sachbuch. und eventl. in ein paar Jahren wieder kommen""" Löschung von Bianca Braun Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
13836 13984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kane Tanaka User:SportingFlyer 09:22, 9 August 2018 (UTC) delete """The only sources in the article are feature articles, and the article is about a living person who is only notable for the """"event"""" of being the world's oldest person, which violates . She is no different from any other person who holds the title for being the world's oldest; there will be the same routine feature articles written about the next old person, and the next old person. Per , ''Unless news coverage of an individual goes beyond the context of a single event, our coverage of that individual should be limited to the article about that event, in proportion to their importance to the overall topic.'' No reason not to include her in a list or summary description somewhere, but she doesn't appear independently notable. Also note given the current state of this AfD I'm un-watching the AfD and will not respond to any replies""" Deletion of Kane Tanaka WP:ROUTINE||WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13837 10077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Childs Gould User:Gene93k 15:24, 20 February 2013 (UTC) keep Members of a national parliament pass Deletion of James Childs Gould WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
13838 21149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PhysicsOverflow User:XOR 13:21, 18 June 2019 (UTC) keep """The first of the three references in the list above is a |primary source. The second is an interview with one of the site's creators, but that ''is'' evidence of the world (or at least the physics community) taking note, so it is a point in favor. The Alexa rank of a specialist website is pretty much an irrelevant datum. Likewise, whether the site itself counts as a """"reliable source"""" is a topic for |a different place and doesn't really bear upon the question of keeping this page one way or the other. (After all, we have plenty of articles about publications that we do ''not'' consider reliable sources.) There are just enough verifiable items of evidence that physicists use and recommend the site that we can justifiably have a page about it. I might not object to a merge, if a suitable target were proposed, but that is also a discussion for another day and place""" Deletion of PhysicsOverflow WP:PRIMARY||WP:RSN Wikipedia:No original research 65
13839 1102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PoPo Patrol User:Meters 23:51, 25 March 2017 (UTC) delete """I can't find any sources for this group to show that it meets or GNG. The only source currently in the article is the group's facebook page. Originally there were two more refs, but neither of them actually mentioned the group. One was to OPRAH.COM, to support the more than a bit dubious claim that """"The band was the reason behind Oprah's Book Club"""" and the second was to http://www.fueledbyramen.com/ in support of a claim that the band was signed to Fueled by Ramen. Neither of these claims was supported by the cited sources. I'm also rather dubious of the claim that the band is currently touring with Blink-182, Sum 41, Twenty One Pilots and other bands. Note that the band's Soundcloud account has all of three followers, two of whom are the band members""" Deletion of PoPo Patrol WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13840 5760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Ryckman User:Bearcat 07:30, 17 February 2021 (UTC) delete """City manager is not an """"inherently"""" notable role that guarantees an article under , especially not in a city with a population of just 11K — I live in a city with a population ''244 times'' the size of Corning, and ''our'' city managers have ''never'' had Wikipedia articles — but the article is not |reliably sourced anywhere near well enough to deem Ryckman more special than the norm""" Deletion of Mark Ryckman WP:NPOL||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13841 10806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wild Bunch Paintball Team User:Somedifferentstuff 15:34, 5 May 2016 (UTC) delete This is a no-brainer; once I finished removing all of the sources that didn't meet , there's nothing left Deletion of Wild Bunch Paintball Team WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13842 419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrea Montgomery User:RFerreira 06:34, 12 June 2007 (UTC) delete What the nominator meant to say was that this article does not demonstrate any notability about the subject whatsoever, and is completely lacking in multiple non-trivial sources, and fails rather miserably Deletion of Andrea Montgomery WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13843 1307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Progressive Bloggers (2nd nomination) User:MaNeMeBasat 14:46, 10 February 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Progressive Bloggers (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
13844 13571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Migasfree User:Tigraan 13:56, 14 February 2015 (UTC) delete I saw that on page patrol, and let it go about notability, because I could not read Spanish and the sources looked legit. Now, delete as per Margin1522's comment () and Deletion of Migasfree WP:AGF||WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
13845 288 [[Katharina Biber]] (schnellgelöscht) Benutzer:Dr.Heintz 08:15, 4. Sep. 2012 (CEST) delete Erfüllt mMg. nicht annähernd die einschlägigen #Bildende_K.C3.BCnstler|Relevanzkriterien oder die Wikipedia:Richtlinien_Bildende_Kunst|Richtlinien Bildende Kunst. Sämtliche Einzelnachweise die Hauptautor Löschung von Katharina Biber Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
13846 4258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mustang Ironheart User:Bakazaka 21:38, 29 April 2019 (UTC) delete per . The DVD(s) existed at some point, and the college paper once had a story on these two low-budget filmmakers, but that's not enough to establish notability, and the rest is traceable only through user-created sites and copies of the Wikipedia article, meaning that it fails . A newspaper archive search came up empty as well Deletion of Mustang Ironheart WP:V||WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13847 5156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flowers upon the Grave User:Joe 19:01, 10 June 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |demo Deletion of Flowers upon the Grave WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13848 17991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One-21 User:Debate 00:56, 11 May 2008 (UTC) delete """I've had a pretty good look around. The name isn't helping, but I can't find anything substantial. The Band has never charted on the Christian Music charts, according to Billboard. The only possible argument I can see per is if someone wants to argue that the band's label is """"one of the more important indie labels"""" but I can't find any evidence to support that either""" Deletion of One-21 WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
13849 17868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B. J. Nilsen User:Bearian 15:19, 1 October 2007 (UTC) keep as passing |musical notability -- notable in his genre, several albumns or CD's on a major label Deletion of B. J. Nilsen WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13850 13932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shoke Xerabadi User:GeoffreyT2000 16:05, 28 July 2016 (UTC) delete A Google search gives mostly |mirrors and forks of Wikipedia Deletion of Shoke Xerabadi WP:MIRROR Wikipedia:Mirrors and forks 46
13851 10438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Micheal Fitzgerald User:Whpq 20:06, 23 March 2011 (UTC) delete """Arguably fails |verifiability but definitely fails |notability not matter how one chooses to look at it. For general notability, I cannot find any coverage of significance to match this Micheal Fitzgerald regardless of it being pelled """"ea"""" or """"ae"""". As an actor, his imdb resume shows only one acting credit being """"Agent #1"""" in a single episode of a TV series. As a race car driver, it is asserted he races Formula Ford which is a lower level series, and for which I can find no coverage to indicate that he is a notable driver. Perhaps somebody with some motorsport expertise can weigh in on whether he passes any of the motorsport critieria set out in SPORT""" Deletion of Micheal Fitzgerald WP:V||WP:N||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13852 3789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Horerczy User:Ad 18:22, 17 August 2014 (UTC) delete Cited sources appear unreliable and the article fails . Additionally I have doubts that this article passes as there seems very limited prospects for expansion into a stand alone encyclopedic article. Am open to reconsideration if sufficient RS sources are found. Absent at least some kind of RS sourcing there is nothing to merge Deletion of Horerczy WP:V||WP:STUB Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13853 13820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Sayce user:Cholmes75 16:54, 12 October 2006 (UTC) keep It's a mess, but seems to meet Deletion of Philip Sayce WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13854 18692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Max Karson User:Ali 19:46, 22 April 2007 (UTC) delete I greatly sympathize with all of the victims and families of this shameful incident, but Wikipedia is |not a memorial Deletion of Max Karson WP:MEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13855 20927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Chow User:GiantSnowman 12:11, 30 June 2014 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Tim Chow WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13856 6289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nessex User:Piotrus 09:38, 30 May 2017 (UTC) delete Coverage seems very niche. Seems to fail Deletion of Nessex WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13857 14136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Junioritis User:danntm 23:10, 18 October 2006 (UTC) delete WP:NFT, Deletion of Junioritis WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13858 10260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shane Easson User:Cabrils 07:02, 11 April 2019 (UTC) delete Agree, subject is not . This appears to be a promotional page created by the subject at about the time he was looking for a new job after completing his contract with the ALP Deletion of Shane Easson WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13859 20635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Civic Beauties [[User talk:Lourdes|Lourdes]]''' 15:38, 11 December 2017 (UTC) delete or better, '''Redirect''' to C. D. Payne. Although I found this http://www.herald-dispatch.com/news/putnam_news/youth-in-revolt-shows-promise-from-new-to-film-director/article_4a5f5323-1da3-524f-bbff-9d1fb2f5a499.html Herald-Dispatch source claiming the book was made into the movie ''Drop Dead Gorgeous (film)|Drop Dead Gorgeous'', something doesn't add up (the movie and the novel seem to have different plots). Couldn't find any other source to push the subject over or standards Deletion of Civic Beauties WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
13860 17036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Schembri User:Sir 15:01, 18 February 2010 (UTC) keep per above. Since played for Malta national football team|Malta, he clearly passes thlete Deletion of Eric Schembri WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
13861 10719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bellarmine University Radio User:Gene93k 20:10, 20 February 2008 (UTC) merge """or merge to Bellarmine University. Not independently notable per or , but verifiable enough to earn a mention under """"Activities""" Deletion of Bellarmine University Radio WP:WEB||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13862 6681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Janne Mortil User:Samsmachado 04:06, 11 July 2020 (UTC) delete Article does not cite any sources, no reliable sources appear within the first 10 pages of a google search, only 1 hit in my university library databse (a one sentence reference to Mortil in a play in Toronto). Nothing to indicate any reliable sources exist, so unlikely that the article will ever meet WP:GNG. The credits attributed to her via IMDb/the Wikipedia page in question make no argument for her meeting criteria 2 especially given that her claim to fame is an appearance in the Titanic tv miniseries Deletion of Janne Mortil WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13863 3328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Furtling (2nd nomination) User:Zouavman 21:40, 11 August 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Furtling (2nd nomination) WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
13864 13598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helen Hollick User:Tellyaddict 18:57, 14 March 2007 (UTC) keep I too am chaging my vote to keep, now refs have been added it meets and I think it gets a pass on Deletion of Helen Hollick WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13865 55 [[Langzeittest.de]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Kurt Jansson NONE delete """Beim /23._August_2005#Langzeittest.de_.28bleibt.29|letzten Eintrag auf den Löschkandidaten stimmten mehrere nicht angemeldete Benutzer, bzw. Nutzer, die sich nur für diesen einen Kommentar einen Account zugelegt hatten, für """"behalten"""". Die Argumente waren nicht sehr überzeugend (""""gänzlich ohne Werbung"""", """"Schließlich ist ... auch der ADAC aufgeführt"""", ...). Das Projekt mag unterstützenswert sein, für einen Enzyklopädieartikel reicht es aber m.M.n. nicht; Der Beitrag sollte werden""" Löschung von Langzeittest.de Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13866 21743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timelines of modern history User:Coolabahapple 04:52, 3 January 2021 (UTC) keep meets as a wikireader navigational aid, also okay with a rename Deletion of Timelines of modern history WP:NLIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
13867 15703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clemmie Moodie User:Ritchie333 12:52, 12 March 2013 (UTC) keep A lot of |reliable source coverage is tabloidish and ''written by'' her as opposed to being ''about'' her, and coverage in the Daily Mirror is problematic as it's a |primary source, but as well as the Guardian source mentioned I also see coverage in the http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/entertainment/tv-radio/razz-girl-clemmie-moodie-becomes-1424021 Daily Record and http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b017zqks BBC Radio 1 Review Show. If not keep, it should at least redirect to The 3AM Girls. I can't remember if being a journalist for a major national newspaper is inherently notable Deletion of Clemmie Moodie WP:RS||WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13868 11403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Fellowship of the Ring User:Hog 04:13, 28 January 2020 (UTC) keep Just because the trilogy could be covered at one article, doesn't mean it has to be. Easily passes and . Cleanup is needed, especially with the issues, but that doesn't mean the article should be deleted. There are some incidents of books meant to be published together having a single article (I and II Samuel share Books of Samuel), but there isn't a precedent that that has to be done. I don't see a strong enough reason to combine three books that all easily pass and into one article on the trilogy just because we can Deletion of The Fellowship of the Ring WP:NBOOK||WP:GNG||WP:ALLPLOT||WP:NBOOK||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13869 21332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blogging in Burma User:Pohta 02:10, 20 February 2010 (UTC) delete I acknowledge the scarcity of sources, especially Burmese ones, but I'm also concerned about this article being a |historical research source or possibly |activism. I'd like to see some secondary sources used, as opposed to just links to the blogs themselves (). I'll revisit this if the article improves Deletion of Blogging in Burma WP:PRIMARY||WP:OR||WP:SOAP||WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13870 16713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moulton Falls bridge incident User:Domdeparis 00:26, 22 August 2018 (UTC) delete or userfy as per NOTNEWS. Come.on were talking about a prank that ended up with 5 broken ribs and and a punctured lung. If this had not been filmed and posted on the net this would not have ever been reported. Userfy is a viable option as per RAPID as this should have not been created yet as per . Let's be perfectly honest here this subject will '''never''' be an encyclopedic one. Do we really want Wikipedia to be simply a collection of viral stories that have no significance a part from the fact that the video was seen X millions of times Deletion of Moulton Falls bridge incident WP:DELAY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13871 16815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dundas Data Visualization, Inc. User:Ipsign 15:55, 19 November 2010 (UTC) comment if there is anybody trying to protect the article by using , note that it has a strong negative effect rather than positive. For example, it was difficult for me to say ''keep'' after all the promotional activity related to the article Deletion of Dundas Data Visualization, Inc. WP:SOCKS Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
13872 5761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EqualiTV(Canada) User:Blueboy96 23:26, 5 January 2011 (UTC) delete Doesn't appear to be on the air yet, so appears |crystalish at present Deletion of EqualiTV(Canada) WP:CBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13873 20969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Effective Inspirations User:Fredrick 08:16, 13 May 2007 (UTC) delete Check my conversation with the author on the talkpage - he agrees that there are no sources that meet about the organisation Deletion of Effective Inspirations WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13874 12040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Signs (Bloc Party song) User:Seraphim 23:32, 1 May 2009 (UTC) keep This song doesn't even need to chart for wikipedia to have an article on it due to the fact that it has 7 |reliable sources which justify its inclusion. The sources are numerous and |independent of the subject and thus establish |notability. Bear in mind that work has been carried out on the article since its nomination Deletion of Signs (Bloc Party song) WP:RS||WP:SOURCES||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13875 1698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fernanda Staniscuaski User:Darwinek 21:12, 6 April 2021 (UTC) delete per nom. quite yet Deletion of Fernanda Staniscuaski WP:NOTJUSTYET Wikipedia:Too soon 40
13876 9389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Techmare User:DustyRain 08:56, 20 October 2008 (UTC) delete References are NOT about the org, they are about the concept. Misleading references. Delete as per , , Deletion of Techmare WP:N||WP:V||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
13877 21687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/František Flos User:Carrite 13:57, 22 July 2018 (UTC) keep Bad faith nomination, one of three made in a single minute. is being flouted and (semi-)automation abused Deletion of František Flos WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13878 21917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1996 Texas Tech vs. Kansas State football game User:Paulmcdonald 00:41, 9 October 2014 (UTC) keep """these so-called """"established precedents"""" and """"consensus"""" go against previous history and are nothing more than the opinions of a few editors. To that, the game clearly passes and the coverage is far beyond the guideline as coverage is more than just sports scores and announcements of the game but provides the detail demanded (see essay ). As to the """"Trivia"""" argument, that is not a reason to delete see and specifically. The article is well sourced in reliable sources, it is more than just routine box scores, has widespread coverage, and by any measure available passes the general notability guideline. Nominator has a recent pattern of Wikipedia talk:WikiProject College football#Articles for Deletion: regular season single-game articles|bias against articles about regular season games""" Deletion of 1996 Texas Tech vs. Kansas State football game WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE||WP:NOTROUTINE||WP:TRIVIALCOVERAGE||WP:TRIVIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
13879 12177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akhtar Hussain Malik User:Necrothesp 11:58, 16 February 2015 (UTC) keep as a general officer per coupled with longstanding precedent and consensus Deletion of Akhtar Hussain Malik WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
13880 992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergio Fabian Ezequiel Aguero User:Spiderone 18:53, 4 January 2017 (UTC) delete per nom; fails GNG and Deletion of Sergio Fabian Ezequiel Aguero WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13881 7302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fawn Liebowitz User:Claritas 15:42, 28 June 2010 (UTC) delete no significant coverage in reliable sources. Fails Deletion of Fawn Liebowitz WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13882 19513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dagna O. Constenla User:Agricola44 16:36, 17 February 2014 (UTC) delete """This person works in several sub-specialties in medicine that are associated with very high reference/citation rates. She is early-in-career, but has nevertheless published quite a few papers. Her h-index is 13 (WoS). I agree with Xxan that this is not sufficient for a medical researcher to be counted as """"notable"""", otherwise a large fraction of this enormous workforce would likewise be notable at this threshold. It's . If she continues on her current trajectory, she will certainly have a WP article in the future""" Deletion of Dagna O. Constenla WP:TOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
13883 421 [[Kenia-Koalition]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Felix König 18:56, 14. Aug. 2012 (CEST) delete """Konsequenterweise , vergleiche auch /12._Mai_2012#Spanien-Koalition_.28gel.C3.B6scht.29|LD zur """"Spanien-Koalition"""". Die Konstellation ist auf Bundesebene auch in Österreich (von Deutschland gar nicht zu sprechen) unrealistisch, und das """"Beispiel für eine existente Kenia-Koalition"""" in Oberösterreich ist weniger eine von den beteiligten Parteien gewünschte, gezielt geschlossene Koalition als vielmehr eine Folge des Proporzsystems""" Löschung von Kenia-Koalition Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13884 17876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PeachDish User:Edwardx 10:24, 16 May 2017 (UTC) delete Promotional article of a company that is only a small local firm, and with no in-depth coverage in reliable sources to be found. Fails and Deletion of PeachDish WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
13885 4745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meisha Johnson User:WilliamJE 10:34, 21 May 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Meisha Johnson WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
13886 18901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poe Darli Theintan (2nd nomination) User:Armbrust 17:51, 1 September 2010 (UTC) delete as article fails |notability criteria for musicians Deletion of Poe Darli Theintan (2nd nomination) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
13887 19147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rory Gaffney User:Fenix 14:59, 26 May 2015 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Rory Gaffney WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13888 21059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vinay Deolalikar User:Kenilworth 19:36, 10 August 2010 (UTC) delete as a clear case of Deletion of Vinay Deolalikar WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13889 19367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kepple Disney (2nd nomination) User:TravisTX 17:23, 30 August 2007 (UTC) delete """on notability grounds - I don't see how a being notable makes one's grandfather notable. However, it sounds like the article meets #G4, """"Recreation of deleted material""" Deletion of Kepple Disney (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
13890 2567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Praydon Darmoo User:Ukexpat 16:37, 7 July 2011 (UTC) delete per A7 (and yes I do understand the speedy deletion criteria, thank you). Per (not an A7 after recent minor additions Deletion of Praydon Darmoo WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13891 12034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Newton User:Can 19:57, 14 June 2006 (UTC) keep as per Kicking222, notable athlete who played at the highest level for a prestigious university, thus meeting our guidelines Deletion of Greg Newton WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13892 17502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Security Check User:Esradekan 04:22, 4 November 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Albums.2C_singles_and_songs|WP:JANNMT Deletion of Security Check WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13893 19074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Master Hughes User:Shalom 08:35, 2 July 2007 (UTC) delete It was a violation from the very beginning in 2005 Deletion of Master Hughes WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
13894 3079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayapa User:Rsrikanth05 19:42, 7 May 2019 (UTC) keep Satisfied Deletion of Mayapa WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
13895 8129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amar Prasad Reddy [[User talk:157.235.66.80|talk]]) 17:41, 1 November 2016 (UTC) delete Holy linkspam, botman. I'm on the fence about this, but I'm pretty sure his appearances are entirely as a representative of someone else who's actually in charge. Even as (additional) director, he hasn't actually done anything notable within his organization. If nothing else, it's Special:Contributions/157.235.66.80|157.235.66.80 Deletion of Amar Prasad Reddy WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
13896 19251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keisuke Ono User:Inter 02:14, 4 September 2018 (UTC) delete fails and . Article can be recreated if and when article meets said requirements Deletion of Keisuke Ono WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13897 4894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of video game companies [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 19:57, 1 May 2009 (UTC) delete WP:PERNOM|per nom. This is not a history article, it's a half-fast spinout of the list articles as mentioned above. History articles need stuff like prose and |summary style; this page has neither Deletion of History of video game companies WP:SUMMARY Wikipedia:Summary style 34
13898 21835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John(Jack)Graham User:Metropolitan90 02:01, 10 April 2006 (UTC) delete The subject is the mayor of a town in Quebec that Wikipedia doesn't even have an article about; that's not sufficient to satisfy Deletion of John(Jack)Graham WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13899 8258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mexico gallery User:Elfin341 01:00, 30 May 2007 (UTC) delete some interesting photos worth keeping, but seeing that they are already in commons, fails #REPOSITORY Deletion of Mexico gallery WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13900 1382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/In der Falle User:Roscelese 15:19, 25 April 2011 (UTC) keep Passes criterion #5 of as the author has won a Nobel in literature Deletion of In der Falle WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
13901 18553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Master in Entrepreneurship and Innovation (MEI), Luxembourg Business Academy (LBA) User:Bearian 22:38, 23 January 2012 (UTC) delete per , and by extension, Deletion of Master in Entrepreneurship and Innovation (MEI), Luxembourg Business Academy (LBA) WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13902 19302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samajvadi Kranti Party User:Pharaoh 04:50, 3 October 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Samajvadi Kranti Party WP:NORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13903 2635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/109th and Broadway fire User:Calvin 05:19, 18 July 2008 (UTC) delete fails the notability standard: a quick mention in the NY Times isn't enough. #NEWS also another thing Deletion of 109th and Broadway fire WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13904 746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quantum Legacy (game) User:Vizjim 23:10, 31 July 2006 (UTC) delete this article Deletion of Quantum Legacy (game) WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
13905 13432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karl Waheed Avocats User:N4 03:26, 7 February 2014 (UTC) delete WP:V failed due to lack of references making it difficult to establish notability. From what I gather, there is no real claim to notability and the article fails and the Deletion of Karl Waheed Avocats WP:CORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13906 19072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robotshop (2nd nomination) User:Adamant1 10:04, 27 September 2020 (UTC) delete This is clearly an advert article and lacks reliable sources. Plus, it should be deleted on grounds also since it would take a fundamental rewrite to present the company in a neutral none advertising way. Although, it's unlikely it could be re-written in accordance with the guidelines given the lack of reliable sourcing Deletion of Robotshop (2nd nomination) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
13907 19733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Myth of National Defense User:Nick 10:31, 25 August 2008 (UTC) delete This doesn't meet any of the notability criteria at - some reviews in mass media, major awards, etc are needed to establish notabilty. This book ranks http://www.amazon.com/Myth-National-Defense-Hans-Hermann-Hoppe/dp/0945466374/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1219659874&sr=1-1 736,090th on Amazon.com's sales rank, which strongly suggests that it hasn't gotten much interest since it was released in 2003. The above keep arguments seem to basically be . As a note, Google searching book titles isn't a good way to establish notability as such searches always return hundreds of book seller websites which have the book on their databases Deletion of The Myth of National Defense WP:BK||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13908 8103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brad Schreiber User:Rhododendrites 20:08, 17 July 2015 (UTC) comment When I looked for sources, most of the good ones I found were about the book he co-authored, ''Becoming Jimi Hendrix''. In fact, there were enough reviews to justify an article per . I'm still not sure about Schreiber's notability, but at least now there's a redirect target: Becoming Jimi Hendrix. &mdash Deletion of Brad Schreiber WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
13909 6598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Hislop User:Dan 12:02, 21 August 2016 (UTC) keep addresses Deletion of John Hislop WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13910 31 [[Waftability]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Tom_md 10:18, 18. Apr. 2011 (CEST) delete Unbelegt, riecht stark nach Löschung von Waftability Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
13911 14867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Are You Ready Now User:Europe22 21:31, 7 May 2010 (UTC) comment No, it's wrong : the page given as reference for the Dutch chart is a mirror page of the Gary Barlow article = not reliable. Hung Medien site (listed as ) shows the song didn't chart in this country.http://dutchcharts.nl/showitem.asp?interpret=Gary+Barlow&titel=Are+You+Ready+Now&cat=s Deletion of Are You Ready Now WP:GOODCHARTS Wikipedia:Record charts 13
13912 16784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khawaja Mohammad Kazim Banday User:Comatmebro 16:06, 2 October 2016 (UTC) delete Per everything above. Does note meet guidelines as well Deletion of Khawaja Mohammad Kazim Banday WP:STYLE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
13913 16746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rattling Blanket Woman User:Magnolia677 09:55, 25 September 2020 (UTC) comment I'm concerned about merging this article into the genealogy section of another article, when a longstanding consensus has been that |Wikipedia is not a genealogy Deletion of Rattling Blanket Woman WP:NOTGENEALOGY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13914 10658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Knucks User:Gwernol 09:36, 5 July 2006 (UTC) delete WP:N|Non-notable |neologism with no |sources so |unverifiable Deletion of Knucks WP:NEO||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
13915 728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thach Thi Ngoc User:Lugnuts 16:58, 3 May 2015 (UTC) delete Per nom. This person didn't compete at the Olympics. This article was created by a user who is now blocked for long-term copyright issues, and I suspect this could easily be a of some kind. The only saving grace for the article is that she held the national high-jump record. But this is unsourced, so the is on the article creator to source this, if it is indeed true Deletion of Thach Thi Ngoc WP:COPYVIO||WP:BURDEN Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
13916 21665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave London User:Atama 21:39, 11 June 2009 (UTC) comment Thanks for including that. The reason why I created this AFD was to give the article's creator a chance to argue for its inclusion. There was a |proposed deletion that was about to expire, but it was clear that the creator contested the deletion Deletion of Dave London WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
13917 20103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Principality of Vikesland User:205 10:02, 3 October 2006 (UTC) delete per and complete and utter failure of both angles of the 100 year test Deletion of Principality of Vikesland WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
13918 8411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kiriti Rambhatla User:Mkdw 05:15, 3 March 2013 (UTC) delete While he's an accomplished person, he is not notable enough for this encyclopedia as he does not meet Deletion of Kiriti Rambhatla WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13919 18861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Resident Evil: Begins User:Crisco 14:22, 14 May 2011 (UTC) merge to Resident Evil (film series)#Future. |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball Deletion of Resident Evil: Begins WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13920 18281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flying Rainbow Fan User:Nate1481 09:04, 4 November 2008 (UTC) delete Non-notable art reads like an advert, I would have tagged it for |a speedy Deletion of Flying Rainbow Fan WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
13921 20158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Dao [[User talk:2601:188:1:AEA0:65F5:930C:B0B2:CD63|talk]]) 21:50, 11 April 2017 (UTC) delete per nom. I watched the initial post and redirect, and felt that this was a good example of . Person isn't notable. Special:Contributions/2601:188:1:AEA0:65F5:930C:B0B2:CD63|2601:188:1:AEA0:65F5:930C:B0B2:CD63 Deletion of David Dao WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13922 19536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toronto poker User:Jahiegel 06:47, 25 March 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and as, irrespective of the advertising, non-notable per in any case Deletion of Toronto poker WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13923 10730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lewinsky (neologism) User:Quigley 23:15, 7 July 2011 (UTC) keep the neologism is documented in dictionaries and a number of other |reliable sources that discuss the term rather than just using it in passing Deletion of Lewinsky (neologism) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13924 6816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Endless Online (2nd nomination) User:Rory096 07:49, 6 May 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. How does it meet #3? It's hosted on its own domain and is not distributed by any well known entity Deletion of Endless Online (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
13925 14839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/So Fresh: The Hits of Summer 2012 + The Best of 2011 User:Stuartyeates 05:34, 11 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of So Fresh: The Hits of Summer 2012 + The Best of 2011 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13926 11056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/File Access Manager User:Bearian 18:42, 3 November 2009 (UTC) keep per , . A simple Google search reveals one third of a million (''not a typo'') Ghits: http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22File+Access+Manager%22+-blog+-wiki&aq=f&oq=&aqi=, and dozens on Google scholar: http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22File%20Access%20Manager%22%20-blog%20-wiki&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&tab=ns as well as Google Books: http://books.google.com/books?q=%22File%20Access%20Manager%22%20-blog%20-wiki&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=sp. Alternately, '''merge''' into File locking or Microsoft software Deletion of File Access Manager WP:BEFORE||WP:N Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13927 10870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/King's Lynn in popular culture (2nd nomination) User:Themfromspace 21:57, 26 February 2010 (UTC) delete The subject lacks notability and the content consists of nothing but |trivial details. (this is my same opinion as before since the article hasn't become less of a trivia farm nor has the subject gained any notability Deletion of King's Lynn in popular culture (2nd nomination) WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
13928 21431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frylock User:Jfgslo 19:26, 23 June 2011 (UTC) merge The individual fictional character does not meet |general notability guideline to warrant a stand-alone article. Most of the article describes the character as a |plot-only description of a fictional work, without providing reception or significance. The only section that gives something different is ''Other appearances'' which appears more a trivia-like section. |Search engine tests (including Google books, news and scholar) show no evidence that #Notability|reliable third-party sources address the fictional character in detail or giving it analytic or evaluative claims to deserve a stand-alone article. |Google hits in tertiary sources are not evidence of notability, particularly when said sources are for the TV series where the fictional character is only addressed as part of the plot. Since the character is already covered in List of Aqua Teen Hunger Force / Aqua Unit Patrol Squad 1 characters and the article title is a plausible search term, I believe that a redirect is the best alternative. I would not be against a merge since the description in the list lacks references Deletion of Frylock WP:GNG||WP:PLOT||WP:SET||WP:V||WP:GHITS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13929 280 [[Krunoslav Šebrek]] (LAE) Benutzer:Altkatholik62 01:34, 27. Jun. 2012 (CEST) keep Ja, vielen Dank für die Mühe, Brodkey65. Die #Darstellende_K.C3.BCnstler.2C_Moderatoren.2C_Film-Stab|Relevanzkriterien sind erfüllt, daher Löschung von Krunoslav Šebrek Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
13930 12500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Democrat Party (phrase) User:LinguistAtLarge 15:53, 5 March 2009 (UTC) keep """edit conflict) simply because a valid reason for deletion has not been given. """"Absolute nonsense"""" doesn't apply, as it's not gibberish, it's a coherently written article. The reference to Dubya really falls under and is an invalid argument. Note also that a Google search, while not conclusive proof of anything, does return 900,000+ hits for http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22democrat%20party%22 """"democrat party"""". Based on some of those hits, the focus of the article should be changed to include a non-US point of view as well. — """ Deletion of Democrat Party (phrase) WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13931 1835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alison Rogers User:Pburka 22:53, 12 August 2020 (UTC) comment Also curious to see a rationale. At least one of her books attracted a number of reviews (''https://therealdeal.com/issues_articles/diary-of-a-real-estate-rookie-a-fresh-look-from-the-front/ Real Deal'', ''https://www.publishersweekly.com/978-1-4277-5465-3 Publishers Weekly'', ''https://observer.com/2007/06/a-realestate-newbie-reports-back-from-the-front/ New York Observer'') so she might pass #3 Deletion of Alison Rogers WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13932 14956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Kniginyzky User:BRMo 18:08, 19 April 2009 (UTC) delete """Statistics or brief mentions in articles about minor league teams do not constitute """"significant coverage in reliable sources,"""" as required by """ Deletion of Matt Kniginyzky WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
13933 14978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Joseph Watson (2nd nomination) User:Jobrot 02:20, 27 February 2016 (UTC) delete """Whilst I did attempt to substantiate the page, I did so to give Wikipedia an accurate starting point in understanding his noxious nature as a """"reporter""""/controversy hound (who goes as far as to https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ksajP0hOggY openly mock minorities). On notability, both reddit and google report back a high number of hits, but that's a argument and not something Wikipedia cares about. Ultimately there is no higher level sourcing for him, not from academia, the mainstream media or even (other than his own). So I agree with the deletion vote on policy grounds""" Deletion of Paul Joseph Watson (2nd nomination) WP:GHITS||WP:NEWSBLOG Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13934 7178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karma: The New Revolution User:Michitaro 12:35, 5 April 2012 (UTC) comment """First, let me mention that the SPI against Buddhakahika, who created this article and voted above, has confirmed that Buddhakahika is a sockpuppetteer who has misused multiple accounts: Wikipedia:Sockpuppet_investigations/Buddhakahika. Wikipedia911, who also voted above, is one of those accounts. All the confirmed accounts have been blocked indefinitely. Truth be known 888, who voted above (and who clearly has violated ), has been determined """"possibly bordering on likely"""" to be Buddhakahika, and administrative action is pending. While Buddhakahika's efforts to manipulate this AfD are one reason the user has been blocked indefinitely, it should be stressed that the multiple accounts were first used to litter Wikipedia with statements presenting the particular views of a single religious organization run by an individual as historical fact (and to promote the products of that individual, including this film and the Zenji Museum). I wrote a summary of these activities on MichaelQSchmidt's talk page""" Deletion of Karma: The New Revolution WP:CIVIL Wikipedia:Civility 37
13935 19200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christos Tsoutsouvis User:RebeccaGreen 14:14, 7 March 2019 (UTC) keep """The subject does meet . I think the nominator has misunderstood the meaning of """"significant coverage"""": explicitly states that """"Significant coverage is more than a trivial mention, but it does not need to be the main topic of the source material."""" , the notability guideline for People, says """"If the depth of coverage in any given source is not substantial, then multiple independent sources may be combined to demonstrate notability ..."""" There is no requirement for a """"comprehensive work about the life of Tsoutsouvis""" Deletion of Christos Tsoutsouvis WP:GNG||WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13936 1850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Its greek to me foods User:Eliz81 01:49, 22 September 2007 (UTC) delete Fails and while presumably tasty, reeks of and Deletion of Its greek to me foods WP:CORP||WP:COI||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
13937 1678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qantas Flight 72 User:Jclemens 16:58, 9 October 2008 (UTC) comment WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS + y argument == You're not helping your cause Deletion of Qantas Flight 72 WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
13938 12174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Szczuczyn pogrom User:Pharaoh 21:01, 11 December 2017 (UTC) keep per |good work by {{u|Icewhiz Deletion of Szczuczyn pogrom WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
13939 415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malamanteau User:Colapeninsula 09:30, 11 September 2012 (UTC) keep """Blogs published by established reliable news media sources, such as The Economist, or written by experts like Language Log can be notable per : """"Some news outlets host interactive columns they call blogs, and these may be acceptable as sources so long as the writers are professional journalists or are professionals in the field on which they write and the blog is subject to the news outlet's full editorial control"""", """"Self-published material may be acceptable when produced by an established expert on the topic of the article""" Deletion of Malamanteau WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13940 4577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TryBishop User:Mothman 16:24, 28 May 2019 (UTC) delete Subject fails all notability including . The coverage referenced here is not coverage but trivial mention at best. 'His name appears' does not constitute signifant coverage. A news search recommended trying 'tray bishop'. Eight pages of google search did not reveal any coverage. advises that such articles should not exist. Wikipedia is not the place to discover the hidden gems of the midwest hip hop scene. Set up a web site to do that Deletion of TryBishop WP:MUSIC||WP:SUBNOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13941 20490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Robertson (Louisiana politician) User:Reywas92 01:37, 17 May 2019 (UTC) delete Does not pass NPOL, does not have sources beyond local news Deletion of Bill Robertson (Louisiana politician) WP:REFBOMB Wikipedia:Citation overkill 60
13942 14806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M.W.A. User:Morgan 20:33, 13 June 2007 (UTC) delete dicdef neologism. Does not meet the definition of Wikipedia:Patent nonsense|patent nonsense but arguably a candidate Deletion of M.W.A. WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
13943 9197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reworkability User:LinguistAtLarge 20:51, 25 March 2009 (UTC) comment A quick Gsearch will make it clear this is not something |made up in one day. — Deletion of Reworkability WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
13944 655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher O'Neill User:Julle 13:44, 6 May 2018 (UTC) keep Sources are good enough for verifiability and the subject passes with flying colours, as far as I'm concerned. As for his role as merely husband to someone who happens to belong to the Swedish royal family, and that he has undertakes no royal duties, well, he's still become part of the family whether he likes it or not, he's been treated much like Princess Sofia, Duchess of Värmland|Sofia or Prince Daniel, Duke of Västergötland|Daniel in the Swedish press, where he has definitely not been out of the spotlight, as the sources here, in the Swedish Wikipedia article and even more so a basic search in w:sv:Mediearkivet|Mediearkivet show. It's unfortunate in some ways, but it's not for him to decide Deletion of Christopher O'Neill WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13945 18889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/...Short Strut to the Brassy Front User:JamesBurns 02:51, 28 December 2008 (UTC) delete notability not established, as per Deletion of ...Short Strut to the Brassy Front WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13946 12621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laith Salim User:Vejvančický 09:40, 30 August 2010 (UTC) delete No sources found = subject fails . I can't find his name on IMDB. All I found is http://www.nextcat.com/kinglaith7 this personal profile Deletion of Laith Salim WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13947 20869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Gifty Opoku-Agyeman User:Co2ke 02:35, 7 June 2020 (UTC) keep This person co-founded the Sadie Collective and is CEO, she is notable under the criteria. She also came up with and organized BlackBirdersWeek in response to the Cooper bird-harrassment event in NYC, which was an internationally influential social media week that was reported on by noteworthy news such as National Geographic, CNN, and Forbes magazine. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Anna Gifty Opoku-Agyeman WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13948 6756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Flask User:SW3 17:46, 12 June 2014 (UTC) delete per nom. Does seem like a hoax with the weasel words and lack of . Fails , , no |reliable sources found Deletion of Charles Flask WP:V||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13949 17035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poetísical User:Graymornings 01:58, 21 December 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Poetísical WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
13950 16187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ivan Shokoloff User:Fan 00:25, 26 March 2006 (UTC) delete Fails . I don't know if this is a total hoax, or just a non-notable person whose importance is being inflated. Sometimes there are issues with how Russian names are rendered in English, and it's possible he might show up somewhere under a different spelling. Clearly he's not either of the two notable Ivan Sokolovs, the Russian pianist/composer born 1960 or Ivan Sokolov|the Bosnian/Dutch chess master born 1968 Deletion of Ivan Shokoloff WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13951 15265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dirtfedd (2nd nomination) User:The 11:07, 16 July 2018 (UTC) delete on account of subject failing Deletion of Dirtfedd (2nd nomination) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13952 3937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karl Keogh User:Carioca 21:19, 12 April 2010 (UTC) delete He fails both , and Deletion of Karl Keogh WP:GNG||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13953 7601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyclades Corporation User:Wine 19:38, 24 July 2006 (UTC) delete Makes no assertion of notablity per , was de-prodded without reason, parent company Avocent also NN, and now has prod tag Deletion of Cyclades Corporation WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13954 21645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luc Beausoleil [[User talk:162.95.216.224|talk]]) 22:19, 9 January 2015 (UTC) keep """Meets criteria 1 - played 7 games in the Alpenliga per http://www.eliteprospects.com/player.php?player=83941&lang=en. Alpenliga is categorized on WP under """"Top-level Ice Hockey Leagues"""". — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/162.95.216.224|162.95.216.224""" Deletion of Luc Beausoleil WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
13955 878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Friends and Heroes User:ClaudeDavid 06:47, 17 April 2020 (UTC) keep Easily meets . Even a quick google search is lined with mentions of the subject. Example: https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0955534 Deletion of Friends and Heroes WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13956 3065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of car crash songs User:Carlossuarez46 21:16, 2 August 2007 (UTC) delete """although not technically so titled, this is a """"songs about"""" list, and devoid of such guidance telling us how much """"about"""" the subject the song must be and es telling us each song so listed is at least that much about the subject matter. Apparently the list despite its title includes motorcycle crashes as well, if kept it should be retitled to reflect that topic creep""" Deletion of List of car crash songs WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13957 359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 Christmas message of Italian Catholic Priest Piero Corsi User:JohnCD 22:45, 22 January 2013 (UTC) delete """An non-notable person says something controversial, and there is a short-lived fuss about it. Yawn. See #NEWS #2 on """"enduring notability""" Deletion of 2012 Christmas message of Italian Catholic Priest Piero Corsi WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13958 4300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zii User:Schuym1 18:37, 31 December 2008 (UTC) delete Doesn't show notability per Deletion of Zii WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
13959 2026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sea Scouts (band) User:Rlendog 18:37, 28 May 2009 (UTC) comment I am not sure if this band meets notability, but it does have a (admittedly sparse) allmusic page, so it is clearly more than just a YouTube band. Ideally, sources can be found. Not sure what effort has been made to find sources per Deletion of Sea Scouts (band) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
13960 15567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pattie Mallette User:Green 03:28, 23 November 2012 (UTC) keep """per . Multiple reliable sources cover the subject in depth: http://ca.omg.yahoo.com/news/biebers-mother-says-pop-star-found-her-harrowing-203031371.html The Canadian Press, http://www.usatoday.com/story/life/people/2012/09/18/for-justin-biebers-mom-nowhere-but-up/1577475/ USA Today, http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2205101/Justin-Biebers-mother-Pattie-Mallette-endured-years-sexual-abuse-age-4.html Daily Mail, http://seattletimes.com/html/entertainment/2019250745_apusjustinbiebersmom.html?prmid=head_more Seattle Times, http://arts.nationalpost.com/2012/09/25/justin-biebers-mom-pattie-mallette-reveals-struggles-with-depression-abuse-in-new-memoir/ National Post, http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/celebritology/post/justin-bieber-releases-turn-to-you-for-his-mom-four-other-songs-about-mothers/2012/05/11/gIQAskAQIU_blog.html Washington Post, http://news.yahoo.com/bieber-mom-pattie-mallette-writes-painful-past-204356433.html Associated Press. Nom has cited however it is an essay, not a notability guideline, and shouldn't be used to over-rule . She also may meet #3, """"multiple independent periodical articles"""" about the book""" Deletion of Pattie Mallette WP:GNG||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13961 20690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Leonard User:Nishkid64 21:37, 21 August 2006 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Tim Leonard WP:BIO||WP:GOOGLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13962 2854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Republican Party vice presidential candidate selection, 2012 User:Ddcm8991 18:37, 3 November 2013 (UTC) keep per rationale of LtNOWIS above. Obviously satisfies Deletion of Republican Party vice presidential candidate selection, 2012 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13963 21248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jenny Morrison User:Deus 10:19, 1 March 2021 (UTC) keep clearly meets WP:BIO and many more references likely available. This is the second article this user has nominated where there is clear sourcing available - their only argument seems to be Deletion of Jenny Morrison WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13964 11598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abhishek Kumar Amber User:Bearian 00:37, 19 October 2016 (UTC) delete """per . Read the article. This is a sixteen year old """"poet""" Deletion of Abhishek Kumar Amber WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
13965 21069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandrembi Chaishra User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:52, 22 August 2015 (UTC) delete for while not utterly unsourcable, this brand new article is apparently |TOO SOON. I found that a music video of a major song from the film was only recently released,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nCdfh6mEDBY and this might indicate the film will follow within six months. Allow |undeletion when |inclusion criteria are met. If the author wishes it placed in a no-wiki'd draft space for work as release approaches, I'd say let him have it Deletion of Sandrembi Chaishra WP:NYF||WP:REFUND||WP:NF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
13966 17947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aelita Andre User:Newshunter12 06:16, 28 October 2018 (UTC) delete The article should be deleted for issues (not explicit violations but the spirit of these guidelines) because its subject is a young child. We shouldn't be publishing such information about relatively obscure children such as her or arguably help parents exploit their own kids Deletion of Aelita Andre WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
13967 17160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Jipping User:David 07:30, 30 June 2019 (UTC) delete His citation record does not make the case for #C1 notability, and the sources available do not make the case for #C7 or GNG Deletion of Thomas Jipping WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13968 21884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Arbuthnot, 6th Viscount of Arbuthnott User:Wangi 00:02, 9 June 2007 (UTC) comment I'm amazed the nominator doesn't know the simple difference between England and Scotland... Anyway, '''keep''' as notable... as in we have gour |reliable sources. Thanks Deletion of John Arbuthnot, 6th Viscount of Arbuthnott WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13969 15866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Compass direction using a watch User:Pmedema 02:40, 24 April 2008 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a guide Deletion of Compass direction using a watch WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13970 10243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mozart Mass K. 139 (Claudio Abbado recording) User:Smerus 07:08, 19 September 2019 (UTC) delete note that it also fails '''''' and ''''''. The main bulk of the article consists of long paraphrases of critics reviews - these are certainly violations of copyright Deletion of Mozart Mass K. 139 (Claudio Abbado recording) WP:NALBUM||WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13971 9862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NCircle network security User:RightCowLeftCoast 04:04, 22 February 2013 (UTC) delete I have not found sufficient |significant coverage from non-primary reliable sources to indicate that the subject is notable per or . The subject may receive significant coverage, where the subject is the primary subject of what the source is written about in the future, but right now it is my opinion that it maybe |too soon for the company to have a Wikipedia article Deletion of NCircle network security WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG||WP:CORP||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
13972 21034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warduke User:Rorshacma 21:31, 23 December 2019 (UTC) delete The character's only claim to fame was the number of appearances he has made in various official D&D products, but without reliable, secondary sources discussing him, he just does not pass the . Searching for sources brings up a few mentions here and there, but nothing in-depth, or going much beyond just mentioning products he appears in Deletion of Warduke WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13973 5340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virtual Digital Cable User:SorryGuy 01:09, 14 August 2006 (UTC) delete Seems to meet criteria and intention of to me Deletion of Virtual Digital Cable WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
13974 172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/786 (number) User:Jacqui 03:54, 3 November 2005 (UTC) keep helps |counter systemic bias Deletion of 786 (number) WP:CSB Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
13975 10249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Neese User:Bearcat 22:37, 7 August 2019 (UTC) delete People do not get Wikipedia articles for being candidates in elections they did not win, but this article is not properly demonstrating that she has preexisting notability for other reasons. It certainly ''thinks'' it is, because it's written like a résumé, but it's not |reliably sourced for the purposes of ''demonstrating'' the notability of her career: it is referenced ''entirely'' to |primary sources except for a single news article about her winning a minor local award that isn't a magic notability clincher all by itself Deletion of Terry Neese WP:RS||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13976 906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gideon Polya User:Aoziwe 01:46, 24 January 2020 (UTC) delete Fails as I discussed above. His CRC book had a review, but his political books look to be self-published and unreviewed. I don't think that makes . The coverage found by Deletion of Gideon Polya WP:NPROF||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
13977 12712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jahbulon (3rd nomination) NONE NONE delete or '''Merge''' - The article also has problems with , in that 1) the bulk of the article is little more than dictionary definitions, (speculative ones at that) and 2) the article is a subtle form of POV Agenda bashing, which goes against the soap box provision Deletion of Jahbulon (3rd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13978 21868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Domaduir User:Originalmess 20:31, 1 August 2018 (UTC) delete is not Wikipedia:Verifiability|verifiable and possibly falls under . No sources support that this exists, and most of the entire article was copied from Erbusaig. Could probably PROD it instead Deletion of Domaduir WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
13979 21270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burger King menu items User:Iced 22:29, 31 January 2007 (UTC) delete Wikipedia |is not an indiscriminate collection of information, nor is it a directory Deletion of Burger King menu items WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
13980 7731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muslim presidents of Indian National Congress User:Smmurphy 21:24, 28 November 2016 (UTC) delete As is, this pushes pretty far into , unless there is independent sources that concern themselves directly with the religious affiliation of INC presidents. If so, an article similar to Religious affiliations of Presidents of the United States|List of Presidents by religious affiliation, but for the INC might be more encyclopedic Deletion of Muslim presidents of Indian National Congress WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
13981 1634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Kontras (3rd nomination) NONE NONE delete Fails . From the last discussion Deletion of Adam Kontras (3rd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
13982 1619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beachbody User:CNMall41 02:35, 26 January 2019 (UTC) keep The company is best known for P90X which was a workout fad about 10 years back and could be a likely merge target. However, based on https://www.forbes.com/sites/laurengensler/2018/04/10/beachbody-carl-daikeler-shakeology/#2eae874f7960 this Forbes piece which appeared in print and online from a staff writer and https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-beachbody-20170829-story.html this Los Angeles Times article which isn't flattering, the company meets . What I would suggest is a merger of the P90X and PiYo pages into the Beachbody page as the others are merely s of the company's products. It this is kept, ping me and I will be happy to perform the merge Deletion of Beachbody WP:NCORP||WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Notability 77
13983 17413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FirstCom User:Crh23 15:53, 29 March 2016 (UTC) delete per nom. Found no relevant secondary sources (many were talking about an Irish marketing agency). Article is almost entirely written by a single editor, the majority of whose contributions have been to that article. Fails and probably too Deletion of FirstCom WP:ORG||WP:PLUG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13984 162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Becca Berg User:WikiDan61 12:36, 15 March 2012 (UTC) delete as a |hoax. This is apparently the fantasy land of the author Deletion of Becca Berg WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
13985 12487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hemp Gru User:Kakofonous 20:12, 9 March 2008 (UTC) delete Though the group gets a fair amount of hits, I was not able to find any |reliable sources to verify any information Deletion of Hemp Gru WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
13986 1531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TestingWhiz User:Gongshow 06:10, 6 November 2012 (UTC) delete I am unable to find coverage in reliable sources for this subject; does not appear to meet Deletion of TestingWhiz WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
13987 3999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shivarama Varambally User:Trusilver 21:46, 20 October 2011 (UTC) delete He's just as notable as about 80% of the rest of the doctors in the world. Totally fails Deletion of Shivarama Varambally WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
13988 7958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bellypunching User:Zoe 17:04, 8 August 2006 (UTC) delete existence is not notability, fails and Deletion of Bellypunching WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13989 673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gregory G. Smith (2nd nomination) User:Crusio 15:21, 31 October 2008 (UTC) delete per Nsk92, does not meet Deletion of Gregory G. Smith (2nd nomination) WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13990 11001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs from Family Guy User:Kzrulzuall 06:46, 4 March 2007 (UTC) delete obvious fancraft and |original research Deletion of List of songs from Family Guy WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
13991 7707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Putinjugend User:DonaldDuck 07:44, 16 December 2008 (UTC) delete per , and Deletion of Putinjugend WP:ATP||WP:NEO||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Attack page 100
13992 9945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fluoride Action Network User:Hu12 14:23, 2 October 2012 (UTC) comment """WP:NRVE|Notability requires verifiable evidence. A """"''simple Google search''"""" showing mentions on """"''''' other anti-fluoridation sites'''''"""" does not demonstrate notability merely because it exists, nor is notability |inherited. Additionaly, Primary sources, no secondary reliable sourcing and insufficient trivial coverage fails , and the subject fails both and """ Deletion of Fluoride Action Network WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:CORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
13993 15047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stan Nicholls User:Baileypalblue 04:06, 21 February 2009 (UTC) keep Author has published dozens of books, distributed in over 20 countries, including titles that have sold millions of copies, and has been nominated for multiple awards, demonstrating the respect of his peers. As such, he easily satisfies the notability requirements of . None of the other issues cited in the nomination are valid reasons for deletion: AfD is not cleanup, and there is no time limit for improving Wikipedia articles Deletion of Stan Nicholls WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
13994 15055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrian Solgaard (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 18:39, 12 February 2018 (UTC) delete Inventing something is not an automatic free pass over our notability standards for businesspeople in and of itself, but the sourcing here is not adequate to get him over in lieu — the references are all either his own |self-published primary sources about himself, or glancing namechecks of his existence in sources that aren't ''about'' him. And even some, although admittedly not all, of the glancing namechecks are in |blogs rather than |reliable sources, to boot. There might, ''maybe'', be enough coverage to support articles about his ''products'', but there isn't the kind of sourcing we require to properly support a ''biography'' of ''him Deletion of Adrian Solgaard (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:SELFPUB||WP:BLOGS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
13995 17932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Resident Evil glossary User:Dark 17:22, 10 September 2006 (UTC) comment Fancruft is not grounds for deletion. A violation of guidelines such as or is. &mdash Deletion of Resident Evil glossary WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
13996 20297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Springfield's state User:Scorpion0422 19:13, 29 April 2008 (UTC) keep While Capital City did deserve to be deleted, Springfield's state is in important and much talked about aspect of the show and I could easily dig up more articles that speculate about which one it is, which proves its notability per Deletion of Springfield's state WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
13997 2077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leila J. Rupp User:Vartanza 06:59, 22 January 2010 (UTC) keep Clearly meets Deletion of Leila J. Rupp WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
13998 7025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Swifts User:PullToOpen 19:59, 22 December 2006 (UTC) delete Fails miserably Deletion of The Swifts WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
13999 11896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Pariso User:TenPoundHammer 12:13, 31 July 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Steve Pariso WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14000 17891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Violin Diary User:Themfromspace 09:15, 8 November 2008 (UTC) delete per and . Fails notability requirements Deletion of The Violin Diary WP:BK||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14001 7077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moni Aizik (3rd nomination) User:Mdtemp 18:26, 19 April 2012 (UTC) keep There are no sources for any of his championship claims, but there seems to have been enough coverage of him to pass . I'm not sure he's notable in the non-WP sense of the word Deletion of Moni Aizik (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14002 940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Garbagemen (band) User:PJM 17:07, 22 September 2006 (UTC) delete per . Since the article seems farcical and doesn't assert notability, in my view, I would not object to a '''speedy Deletion of Garbagemen (band) WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14003 15511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Actuarial Outpost (2nd nomination) User:HighInBC 15:13, 9 November 2006 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Actuarial Outpost (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14004 16410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Temple Emanuel (St. Louis, Missouri) User:Bearian 16:55, 29 June 2011 (UTC) keep """Notable for being a fairly large (300 families) for a Reform Jewish temple, and because of its architectural significance (both in design/shape and notability of the architect - and yes, this is another exception to ). Those are the two most used reasons for claiming notability of houses of worship. I added """"The Temple is notable not only for its size, but for its unique modern architecture."""" to the lead""" Deletion of Temple Emanuel (St. Louis, Missouri) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14005 15766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Online Film & Television Association Award User:AffeL 14:09, 10 March 2017 (UTC) keep Looks good and it passes Deletion of Online Film & Television Association Award WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14006 17713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gutter punk User:SummerPhD NONE keep Passes . In addition to the many sources posted above by Deletion of Gutter punk WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14007 14188 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""The Board"""" in Hollywood FL""" User:Peridon 19:57, 13 December 2010 (UTC) comment """It would be nice to have an accessible proof of the existence of this group. Please see and . Also, please do not tell us how Wikipedia runs - we already know. """"Not all social groups and situations are sourced in this context."""". True. This is an encyclopaedia, not a directory. There are many things not in Wikipedia. Some of those not here should be. Many shouldn't. Our encyclopaedia, our rules (translation: our ball and our field, our rules""" """Deletion of """"The Board"""" in Hollywood FL""" WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14008 21409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finland does not exist User:Ivanvector 19:57, 6 November 2017 (UTC) keep whether it's a bona fide conspiracy theory (people really believe the Japanese invented Finland out of nothing to preserve fishing rights halfway across the planet) or a satire of conspiracy theories (some bored redditor decided to see if they could convince others that Finland is fiction, with hilarious results) the story has been reported in-depth by multiple news agencies generally considered reliable, and has been analyzed by well-known conspiracy debunking organizations. Some refs: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/oct/27/jk-rowling-doesnt-exist-conspiracy-theories-internet-cant-resist https://www.vice.com/en_id/article/xyd48w/this-dude-accidentally-convinced-the-internet-that-finland-doesnt-exist https://theculturetrip.com/europe/finland/articles/does-finland-exist-many-dont-think-so/ https://skeptoid.com/episodes/4573 https://www.msn.com/en-gb/travel/news/a-man-managed-to-convince-internet-that-finland-doesnt-exist/ar-AAoBcbr?li=AA5afI https://www.indiatimes.com/news/world/a-man-is-trying-to-convince-everyone-that-finland-doesn-t-exist-it-s-all-kinds-of-bizarre-326327.html, all from Google's first page. http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/finland-does-not-exist KnowYourMeme explains that this originated on Reddit in December 2014; the earliest of these refs I've posted is from December 2016 (two years later) and there has been consistent detailed coverage of the meme throughout 2017. This doesn't need to be Paul is dead to be a notable conspiracy theory, it meets our |general criteria for notability, and |notability is not temporary Deletion of Finland does not exist WP:GNG||WP:NOTTEMPORARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
14009 20658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Slavin (3rd nomination) User:Xxanthippe 21:28, 21 November 2020 (UTC) keep Clear pass of rof#C1 on GS citations Deletion of Robert Slavin (3rd nomination) WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
14010 11614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Couture User:Pohta 14:24, 8 February 2010 (UTC) keep http://www.usatoday.com/printedition/sports/20081120/c3mma20_st.art.htm Covered in USA Today, and FOX News http://www.foxnews.com/search-results/m/21355193/kim-couture-returns.htm, so meets Deletion of Kim Couture WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14011 7094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Treacy (video blogger) User:Barkeep49 03:26, 15 June 2019 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass or GNG. Best Deletion of Sean Treacy (video blogger) WP:NDIRECTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14012 6154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ami Adini User:Lukeno94 13:16, 5 July 2013 (UTC) delete per nominator. An article being a work in progress is not a reason to keep it; the vast majority of all articles could be said to be in that stage. Two clear SPAs trying to keep the article - one has a name that is a clear violation of the username policy, the other also suggests a COI, or paid editing. Anyway, to the merits of this article: there are simply no non-trivial, non-routine, in-depth, secondary sources on this person, and thus he fails Deletion of Ami Adini WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14013 9578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Los Marziano User:MichaelQSchmidt 05:16, 19 February 2010 (UTC) keep with kudos to the translator. Notability in Argentina is notable enough for en.Wikipedia, and coverage in reliable sources meet the requirements of and Deletion of Los Marziano WP:CRYSTAL||WP:NFF Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14014 14869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Armagh ladies hockey club User:Atyndall 04:28, 15 July 2008 (UTC) delete Google news turns up 0 results and little on Google, I find this is unusual for a club that has supposedly produced so many champions. I think it fails |orgniasation notability criteria. Deletion of Armagh ladies hockey club WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14015 14563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mustafa Yucel User:Mkativerata 22:35, 16 July 2010 (UTC) delete A very obvious case. Fails by a mile and is totally unverified Deletion of Mustafa Yucel WP:ATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
14016 18122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wye School User:Sam 21:30, 26 December 2015 (UTC) keep """As says: """"Most independently accredited degree-awarding institutions and high schools are usually kept ''except'' when zero Wikipedia:Independent sources|independent sources can be found to prove that the institution |actually exists."""" Sources that verifies the school exists are found, and I have added one more""" Deletion of Wye School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
14017 11300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Black (actor) User:MarnetteD 00:44, 20 January 2018 (UTC) keep Meets . IBDb is a reliable source since it is not Deletion of William Black (actor) WP:NACTOR||WP:USERGENERATED Wikipedia:Notability 77
14018 12755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Perilous Journey User:Delicious 19:50, 12 June 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and already mentioned in article suggested for merge (which is itself lacking refs establishing its notability Deletion of The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Perilous Journey WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
14019 21055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SM Center Muntinlupa User:Me5000 21:41, 14 March 2014 (UTC) comment I think malls(or at least regional malls which is what this is) are inherently notable now. This mall is around the same size as a mall I recently nominated for deletion Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Columbia Mall (Missouri). The attempt was a colossal failure. One person cited as a reason to keep which I thought was just another form of , but as you see the article was not deleted, so I guess this applies here as well. Another thing that came up was that I needed to provide evidence to prove that the mall wasn't notable which included making a trip to the areas local library to look at newspaper archives. Sounds ridiculous to me, but again the article wasn't deleted, so I guess this is the way deletion discussions work now (I hadn't participated in one since 07 or 08 Deletion of SM Center Muntinlupa WP:OUTCOMES||WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
14020 14063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gamers' Choice Awards (2nd nomination) User:DocFreeman24 03:54, 5 May 2021 (UTC) keep We just had this debate 12 months ago and I don't really understand what's changed such that we should have it again. Looking at the article and the sources cited therein, it seems to me that is met. A lot of the points raised in this AFD seem directed towards the fact that this was a crappy award show. Maybe it was, maybe it wasn't, but I don't personally feel that the quality of something should bear on the issue of notability. It was broadcast on a national network (CBS) and attracted, IMHO, significant coverage due to the show itself, the awards/nominations given, and the subsequent litigation. And a quick search indicates that it's still be referenced when people talk about games that won/were nominated (see e.g., https://gamerant.com/best-first-person-shooters-play-xbox-one-metacritic/, https://www.courier-journal.com/story/news/education/2020/01/29/kentucky-high-schools-banned-playing-fortnite-e-sports-events/4607659002/, https://sports.inquirer.net/376974/how-to-spectate-arena-of-valor). Do I, in my personal, subjective opinion, think we need an article about this award show? No, not really. But do I think it meets our notability guidelines? Yeah, probably and I don't think we need to revisit this debate a second time Deletion of Gamers' Choice Awards (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
14021 3439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dominique Xardel User:Rhode 15:43, 21 October 2012 (UTC) delete Clearly does not meet notability requirements as an author (see ) and has received negligible coverage by secondary sources Deletion of Dominique Xardel WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14022 8696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 Mumbai stampede User:Fortuna 15:23, 5 October 2017 (UTC) keep as plenty of |in-depth coverage in |reliable sources passes ; concerns regarding '|long-term' notability should probably be raised and addressed when ''more than a week'' (!!!) has actually passed. &mdash Deletion of 2017 Mumbai stampede WP:DEPTH||WP:RS||WP:EVENT||WP:PERSISTENCE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14023 5445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dopamine (band) User:Yamaguchi先生 08:23, 29 June 2006 (UTC) keep per comments above, meets guideline Deletion of Dopamine (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14024 14011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of anarchists User:WilyD 16:48, 6 September 2006 (UTC) keep sourced, encyclopaedic. Please see |Wikipedia:Categories cannot replace lists. Please stop claiming that when it's plainly false for that issue. Unsourced additions to the list can be excised, but since many are sourced, the list shouldn't be deleted. AfD is not cleanup Deletion of List of anarchists WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
14025 8818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terri hollowell User:Bearian 23:59, 14 September 2007 (UTC) keep per Crickey02 and . The article asserts that she had a hit on Billboard. Needs more cites, for sure Deletion of Terri hollowell WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14026 15353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/StereoKiller User:Sarah_Ewart 09:16, 18 August 2006 (UTC) delete per . Reads like spam, nn site Deletion of StereoKiller WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14027 12977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Huw Evans User:WilyD 15:32, 29 June 2006 (UTC) comment The easiest rule of thumb to apply on is that if someone writes an article about themselves, their band or their website, that's a fabulous reason to delete it. If its worthy of an entry, someone else will make it Deletion of Robert Huw Evans WP:AFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14028 3255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebirth Of Genesis: Final Fantasy VII User:Someone 20:28, 3 March 2010 (UTC) delete A ''Final Fantasy'' game that the entire gaming community has somehow missed? |Complete bunch of crusty old bollocks Deletion of Rebirth Of Genesis: Final Fantasy VII WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
14029 5963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe and Ellen User:Gwalla 22:48, 20 November 2009 (UTC) comment And that is . You may want to read through Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions|Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions to familiarize yourself with the sorts of arguments that are routinely rejected out of hand at Articles for Deletion. If you think that Joe and Ellen qualify for an article under Wikipedia's guidelines (see ), you should address those guidelines and how the subject meets them, and eschew arguments that amount to special pleading. &mdash Deletion of Joe and Ellen WP:ILIKEIT||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14030 12508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trinity versus Aquinas User:Inks 22:06, 19 May 2011 (UTC) delete Is just an article about trivia and does not meet pass Deletion of Trinity versus Aquinas WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14031 1767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlton Players, Birkenhead (2nd nomination) User:Stifle 11:16, 5 September 2008 (UTC) delete WP:CITE|Citations from |reliable sources are required by the |verifiability policy but don't appear to be present Deletion of Carlton Players, Birkenhead (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14032 7007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Little Einsteins Preschool User:Roller26 12:18, 25 September 2020 (UTC) delete As per , and . The sources mentioned above are routine announcements in PTI which was carried by a number of newspapers. It does not in anyway convey significant coverage. Looking at all the sources and news reports, I could only come up with these which need attention. https://education.siliconindia.com/others/institution/little-einsteins-equipping-young-minds-with-multiple-intelligence-cid-322.html https://techplusmedia.com/education/2017/09/27/little-einsteins-identifying-and-harnessing-students-interest-using-multiple-intelligence-as-a-tool/ https://indiaeducationdiary.in/little-einsteins-preschool-forays-international-market-invest-usd-500000-europe-africa/ https://edtechreview.in/news/3522-little-einsteins-preschool-expands-to-american-market https://www.zeebiz.com/companies/news-little-einsteins-preschool-to-expand-footprint-in-the-us-to-invest-5-million-in-next-12-months-102292. All these contain very PROMO material with huge chunks being just interviews with the organization executives. Hence huge question of independent coverage is there. A number of them being trade journals would hardly qualify as reliable source. The requirement for notability for private organizations is pretty high and I don't think they have significant coverage in even one independent RS let also multiple to establish notability Deletion of Little Einsteins Preschool WP:ORGDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NSCHOOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14033 13017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myra Amiti User:Atlantic306 21:03, 6 October 2019 (UTC) delete as with only one short film to her credit as an actress up to now, but she is only 21 so there is plenty of time for her career to develop and qualify for an article in the future, thanks Deletion of Myra Amiti WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
14034 2417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Warfield User:Cwmhiraeth 14:46, 22 December 2019 (UTC) delete seems to have only had minor roles and fails to meet Deletion of Joe Warfield WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14035 19348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rob.stp User:Joe 21:03, 13 February 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |musician Deletion of Rob.stp WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14036 18488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AKR Global Group User:AllyD 20:17, 3 November 2014 (UTC) delete Multiple searches turn up no |evidence that this firm is |notable Deletion of AKR Global Group :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14037 18455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Honey Creek Elementary School User:Anupmehra 00:52, 9 November 2016 (UTC) merge per Deletion of Honey Creek Elementary School WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
14038 15530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bicester group User:Thephotoman 03:39, 19 December 2005 (UTC) delete does not meet Deletion of Bicester group WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14039 8863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amber DeLuca User:Belinrahs 06:09, 30 October 2016 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of Amber DeLuca WP:ATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
14040 6193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Levon Khachigian User:Xxanthippe 07:12, 18 August 2013 (UTC) keep A GS h-index of around 48 easily satisfies rof#1 even in this highly cited field. Nominator is reminded that ompetence provides for the removal of editing privileges of people who are unable to edit Wikipedia with competence Deletion of Levon Khachigian WP:P||WP:C Wikipedia:Portal 85
14041 5662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Panjeta (2nd nomination) User:Primefac 20:49, 31 October 2016 (UTC) keep per . Small-village stubs are perfectly acceptable provided they can be shown to exist (which this one does Deletion of Panjeta (2nd nomination) WP:NPLACE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14042 7493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pierre Estable User:Bearian 06:05, 25 January 2010 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Pierre Estable WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14043 15713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of monsters User:Gavin 12:02, 17 February 2010 (UTC) delete """as although the defintion of what a """"monster"""" may be clear in the minds of some editors, without a verfiable defintion, it is not clear to anyone else. Without an external source, there is no rationale for inclusion. Wikipedia is not a paper encyclopedia, but that is not a free pass to inclusion for lists of loosely associated topics. List articles that have not been externally validated in any way are istcruft|listcruft, not encyclopedic content""" Deletion of List of monsters WP:L Wikipedia:Lists 97
14044 5298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Automatic Request Generator User:Joe 22:42, 21 May 2010 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Automatic Request Generator WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14045 3887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Priyanka Fernando User:Mztourist 15:18, 18 May 2020 (UTC) delete """while rank satisfies #2 of that is just a presumption of notability, i.e that """"they have received significant coverage in multiple verifiable independent, reliable sources."""" I'm not seeing that for Fernando""" Deletion of Priyanka Fernando WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
14046 4132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Concert Zap User:Metropolitan90 02:17, 10 January 2015 (UTC) delete I don't see any independent |reliable sources cited here Deletion of Concert Zap WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14047 19069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meek family of York User:Colonel 09:03, 23 April 2011 (UTC) keep """Obviously notable per : """"''mayors of cities of at least regional importance are likely to meet this criterion''"""". This family was six times Lord Mayor of York, Q.E.D""" Deletion of Meek family of York WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14048 2924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticism of Vladimir Putin User:DonaldDuck 04:28, 30 December 2008 (UTC) delete as Deletion of Criticism of Vladimir Putin WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
14049 21339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Stuart Curry User:GiantSnowman 15:03, 30 September 2010 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of James Stuart Curry WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14050 15238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Betty Clawman User:Bearian 19:48, 14 February 2020 (UTC) keep per . This was nominated as editors were fixing the issues. AfD is not for normal editing issues Deletion of Betty Clawman WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
14051 16798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of questionable diagnostic tests User:Lugnuts 17:43, 21 August 2015 (UTC) keep per Deletion of List of questionable diagnostic tests WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
14052 21547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Royal Standard of England User:Paularblaster 22:19, 27 January 2008 (UTC) comment Serving beer at least since 1841, and licensed premises since 1863, and possibly with singular mentions in CAMRA from the 1970s ... Is that not notable enough despite the blatant to be found in the current version of the article Deletion of The Royal Standard of England WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
14053 10237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacula (fumetti) User:Cavarrone 22:51, 30 January 2015 (UTC) keep """I have no idea which kind of the nominator has done, obviously a general Google research for a comic which ended its publications 33 years ago could be difficult, but it requires very little effort to find dozens of reputable sources in Google Books, including ''The Vampire Book: The Encyclopedia of the Undead'' by J. Gordon Melton which refers to the comics as """"possibly the most successful vampire comic book of all time"""" or ''Drawn and Dangerous: Italian Comics of the 1970s and 1980s'' by Simone Castaldi which cites Jacula """"among the most popular, and the least amateurish"""" Italian fumetti. It is so notable as to name several books covering the topic of the Italian """"fumetti vietati"""", eg ''Pornograffiti: da Jacula a Oltretomba, da Cappucetto Rotto a Mercenari'' by Laura Barbiani and Alberto Abruzzese, ''Sukia, Jacula, De Sade, Lando, Il Tromba: la grande epopea della Edifumetto di Milano'' by Giovan Battista Brambilla and ''Vietato ai minori. Vamp e vampire: Jacula, Zora, Sukia e Yra'' by Graziano Origa. Note that the Spanish version of the article includes several reliable sources""" Deletion of Jacula (fumetti) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14054 14589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ibiza RC User:Cewbot 00:03, 15 July 2020 (UTC) comment While this discussion appears to have |no quorum, it is '''NOT eligible for |soft deletion''' because it has been Special:Diff/284702499|previously PROD'd (via summary Deletion of Ibiza RC WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
14055 3691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frede Blaabjerg User:Xxanthippe 21:41, 2 October 2016 (UTC) keep Would nominator like to comment on relevance of subject's GS citation record to rof criteria Deletion of Frede Blaabjerg WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
14056 21543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/So Fresh: The Hits of Autumn 2008 User:Doc 14:35, 19 December 2007 (UTC) delete per , also all of these songs were hits in the Fall of 2007...Now why would they be featured on something like this. I think that this also fails and Deletion of So Fresh: The Hits of Autumn 2008 WP:CRYSTAL||WP:MADEUP||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14057 20928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Hatter User:TheNickHatter 02:30, 31 January 2019 (UTC) delete Fails , interviews are not independent coverage Deletion of Nick Hatter WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14058 7303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maro Perak User:Mdtemp 16:48, 24 June 2013 (UTC) delete Clearly fails both and Deletion of Maro Perak WP:NMMA||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14059 16379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dawn Covington User:David 20:35, 16 October 2010 (UTC) delete as not passing . Like the nominator, I can't find anything in Google news about her under either name, and the only properly sourced factoid in the article is that she wrote an essay. That's not enough, and the fact that some other authors of essays in the same book are notable is irrelevant per . She also doesn't appear to come close to passing Deletion of Dawn Covington WP:GNG||WP:INHERITED||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14060 9960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rodney Marks User:Bondegezou 11:12, 16 June 2013 (UTC) comment Let me be clearer, is merely an essay. is a guideline, and is policy Deletion of Rodney Marks WP:TNT||WP:FIXIT||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
14061 15924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malcolm McCulloch User:Drawn 03:08, 30 April 2009 (UTC) delete does not meet for scientists or professors. Non-notable Deletion of Malcolm McCulloch WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14062 21316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criminal Records User:CASSIOPEIA 06:55, 3 May 2019 (UTC) delete A found 2 interview articles https://www.pastemagazine.com/articles/2011/09/benefit-announced-for-atlantas-criminal-records.html 1 and https://www.pastemagazine.com/articles/2011/09/co-founder-of-record-store-days-atlanta-store-expe.html 2, (not independent sources) indicating the possibility of closing the company and a source https://www.atlantamagazine.com/bestofatlanta/record-store-criminal-records/ 3, appear to be promotional. Fails Deletion of Criminal Records WP:BEFORE||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14063 9289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World Congress for Justice and Human Rights User:Gr1st 12:32, 3 June 2008 (UTC) delete No Google hits at all outside Wikipedia. Probable hoax, but fails in any case Deletion of World Congress for Justice and Human Rights WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14064 21277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richie Garnet User:Ohconfucius 09:21, 30 June 2009 (UTC) delete WP:BIO|non-notable to the extreme and |hoaxy at worst. At best, it fails . References to Pixie Geldof, Chanelle Hayes and Kevin Spacey are walking violations of and could certainly be considered andalism|vandalism. This |walled garden of articles, created by |a single purpose account, should be removed #G3|at blinding velocity Deletion of Richie Garnet WP:V||WP:MYSPACE||WP:BLP||WP:V||WP:WALL||WP:SPA||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14065 1384 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""A"""" Is for Alibi""" User:Dravecky 08:28, 26 December 2010 (UTC) comment While several of the articles are currently referenced stubs, that's a reason to expand the articles, not to delete them. They ''all'' meet the clear guidelines. Please note that the nominator has jumped right to AfD without tagging any of the articles or working to improve them ( """Deletion of """"A"""" Is for Alibi""" WP:NBOOK||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14066 4780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/V sinizter User:Darkspots 01:10, 22 May 2007 (UTC) delete Fails --no evidence of reliable, independent coverage Deletion of V sinizter WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14067 20891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slim surfing User:TenPoundHammer 17:31, 22 July 2007 (UTC) delete obviously |made up one day. I really wish that were a speedy criterion Deletion of Slim surfing WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
14068 2956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gaming Realms User:Lee 10:53, 25 May 2018 (UTC) keep A quick search finds loads of suitible references https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=%22Gaming+Realms%22&safe=off&rlz=1C1GGRV_enGB751GB751&source=lnms&tbm=nws&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjdnMTx2KDbAhXIMewKHaYnAEkQ_AUICygC&biw=1280&bih=893 Deletion of Gaming Realms WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14069 16946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC 33 User:Gamezero05 00:46, 9 June 2012 (UTC) keep This is an obvious y nomination. Portillo actually disagrees with deleting these articles. He's only doing it out of frustration to make a point Deletion of UFC 33 WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
14070 13980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All Caps (band) User:Doomgaze 17:15, 5 April 2011 (UTC) delete fails and . Shame to see someone's research go to waste, perhaps the creator could move the contents to his/her user page, in case the band does become notable one day Deletion of All Caps (band) WP:BAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14071 1866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christos Antoniou User:GiantSnowman 17:40, 2 April 2021 (UTC) delete technically meets with 9 minutes professional play in the Football League Greece in the 2018–19 season (confirmed by https://int.soccerway.com/players/christos-antoniou/504811/ SW), but there is longstanding consensus that scraping by on NFOOTBALL with one or two appearances is insufficient when GNG is failed so comprehensively, as is the case here. If sources are found please ping me Deletion of Christos Antoniou WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14072 3785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Foerster + Rutow User:Stuartyeates 10:17, 7 September 2011 (UTC) delete a) I smell a rat in that all their stuff appears to be in German, yet there is no transwiki link; (b) there's lots of stuff they've done, but it's not clear how much of it is about them as required by Deletion of Foerster + Rutow WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14073 3080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Novak Djokovic in 2011 User:Armbrust 21:41, 25 May 2011 (UTC) keep as there are enough references to pass |GNG Deletion of Novak Djokovic in 2011 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14074 1297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Sneddon (kidnap victim) User:Michitaro 01:36, 25 August 2013 (UTC) delete """The issue really revolves around the conditions outlined in and . If one believes there should be an article, should it be about the victim or about the event? """"When an individual plays a major role in a minor event"""" (as is the case here) """"it is not generally appropriate to have an article on both the person and the event."""" Currently there is only an article on the person. But in this case, the individual is only known through the event, and is also a """"low profile individual"""" according to . This, and the low significance of the event, seems to satisfy the three conditions of , which then recommends only mentioning the individual in the event article. But the problem we face here is judging whether there really has been an event. The anonymous IP's arguments that such an event is impossible are poorly supported if not spurious. Given past kidnappings, it is clearly in the realm of possibility and the press coverage that exists entertains the possibility as a realistic one. But even the WSJ article, which strongly leans towards asserting the kidnapping really happened, does not declare it outright. BLP1E moves us to merge the individual into the event article, but for Wikipedia to have an article on an event that may not have happened--and even provide an article title that definitely asserts it did happen--is problematic and touches on issues of and . One would need considerably more coverage out there to justify an article on an event that may not have happened. At best this is """ Deletion of David Sneddon (kidnap victim) WP:BIO1E||WP:BLP1E||WP:V||WP:NPOV||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
14075 18053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Short Stories (Band) User:MelbourneStar 09:19, 14 May 2014 (UTC) delete I've tagged it with |CSD#A7 for the above reasons, and also because no real significance has been established. Anyone can form a non-notable band, and release a non-notable EP Deletion of Short Stories (Band) WP:A7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14076 8771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Michigan Review User:THF 14:27, 11 March 2009 (UTC) keep and '''Improve'''. Independent sources available,http://news.google.com/archivesearch?pz=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22michigan+review%22+%22affirmative+action%22http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/chicagotribune/access/789638381.html?dids=789638381:789638381&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&date=Feb+07%2C+2005&author=Robert+Gutsche+Jr%2C+Special+to+the+Tribune&pub=Chicago+Tribune&desc=%27Right-on%27+gets+new+take+at+UW-Madison+%3B+Conservative+paper+to+bow+on+campus&pqatl=google and meets Deletion of The Michigan Review WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14077 5333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Long Way Up User:Ginsengbomb 09:27, 1 December 2010 (UTC) delete I see no evidence that this TV series has |commenced principal photography Deletion of Long Way Up WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14078 20076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Émilie Simon's fourth studio album User:Esradekan 02:35, 30 July 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability per , #Albums & Deletion of Émilie Simon's fourth studio album WP:HAMMER||WP:MUSIC||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
14079 8621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional spaceships User:Jclemens 22:15, 26 November 2008 (UTC) delete per . It's already broken out into subcategories, even Deletion of List of fictional spaceships WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
14080 13763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/P.O.L.O. (Players Only Live Once) (3rd nomination) User:Yoenit 08:49, 1 October 2010 (UTC) delete Recreation of deleted material. Was used for the second AFD and also applies in this case. Perhaps also the page to prevent it from being recreated yet again Deletion of P.O.L.O. (Players Only Live Once) (3rd nomination) WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
14081 5523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gyidi User:Ampimd 22:30, 22 May 2021 (UTC) delete The singer doesn't meet the nor , the article stayed on for a long time without being seen as one that had failed all Deletion of Gyidi WP:MUSICBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14082 14810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spanking Love (2nd nomination) User:MichaelQSchmidt 03:27, 7 May 2010 (UTC) keep """The film assuredly meets , in it being the feature film debut of an actual modern-day cannibal Issei Sagawa, and in having commercial re-release 5 years after its original release. Heck, even Jeff Dahmer never starred in a film, so this is indeed a very unusual and notable """"first"""". With respects to the nom, this meets criteria for inclusion and should be allowed to remain and |be improved (or not) over time and through regular editing. Even Wikipedia understands that it is itself |imperfect and grants that |improvements do not have to happen immediately. Better that we consider the precepts of |Project:CSB, as Japanese cult films rarely get wide coverage in Western sources, and so be more active in getting input from Japanese language-reading Wikipedians, rather than tossing due to """ Deletion of Spanking Love (2nd nomination) WP:NF||WP:ATD||WP:IMPERFECT||WP:DEADLINE||WP:CSB||WP:UNKNOWNHERE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14083 311 [[Mischepaper]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Fecchi 17:56, 5. Okt. 2007 (CEST) delete Ich darf mal wieder auf Punkt 9 verweisen und für eine plädieren Löschung von Mischepaper Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14084 30 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Kate Maravan Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 18.19, 4 Mart 2018 (UTC) delete """Kayda değer olduğunu ispat edecek bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynaklar yok. sayfasında oyuncular için belirtilen kriterleri de sağlamıyor. """"Şu rolüyle bilinir/tanınır"""" gibi ifadeler zaten subjektif olduğundan maddelerde yer almamalı""" Kate Maravan'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
14085 18975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bashshar Habibullah User:Eggishorn 04:00, 2 July 2020 (UTC) delete """Is """"absolutely execrable' a valid deletion rationale? Why, |yes, it is""" Deletion of Bashshar Habibullah WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
14086 16432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/His Highness Chu (2nd nomination) User:Tim 00:28, 17 August 2009 (UTC) merge It should be ''Qiansui'', and moving the article to, say The Five Highnesses may be warranted. The problem is finding for and . It's hard to do it in China (where I am at the moment), as it's mostly a Taiwanese religion, and mainland China blocks a ridiculously large number of Taiwanese websites. But from what I can gather from a brief Google search http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rlz=1C1GGLS_enUS317US317&q=五府千歲&aq=f&oq=&aqi=, apparently they are officials of the early Tang Dynasty who were somehow deified. The name can refer to a number of gods, but those five listed in the article are apparently the most common. The English was pretty messy, but I don't think that's a basis for deletion Deletion of His Highness Chu (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14087 21366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sudden Attack User:Randomran 03:49, 14 October 2008 (UTC) keep with no prejudice towards nominating again if someone can't prove once and for all that this can meet and . Definitely needs a cleanup to remove the Deletion of Sudden Attack WP:N||WP:V||WP:GAMECRUFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14088 15461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rocket Mobile User:Librarianofages 01:28, 5 July 2006 (UTC) delete per nom Deletion of Rocket Mobile WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14089 13948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chelsea Food Services User:K 02:53, 28 July 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet . There's nothing to merge, as the article lists no 3rd party sources. What is there to merge? Corporate cruft and using Wikipedia as a free means of promotion Deletion of Chelsea Food Services WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14090 21557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Romantic Tragedy (2nd nomination) User:onel5969 13:08, 1 November 2015 (UTC) delete and even if the one album appeared on a national music chart, that only means the group '''''may''''' be notable. Nothing on the search engines to show that they meet , and imho they don't pass Deletion of This Romantic Tragedy (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14091 13413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave London User:Jennavecia 23:26, 17 June 2009 (UTC) delete Unreferenced BLP fails Deletion of Dave London WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14092 7057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muntazir Ahmad User:Chiro725 00:28, 1 May 2021 (UTC) delete Only two significant coverages as in https://thekashmirimages.com/2018/12/01/young-athlete-from-boniyar-uri-features-in-discovery-channels-reality-show/ and https://www.thebetterkashmir.com/muntazir-the-first-athlete-from-boniyar-uri-features-in-discovery-channels/, both are local news papers and not seem independent and reliable. Other references has trivial mentions. Fails and Deletion of Muntazir Ahmad WP:SIGCOV||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14093 6415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drexel Squash User:Schuym1 16:57, 21 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Drexel Squash WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14094 7578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ventraq User:Ihcoyc 16:04, 16 February 2012 (UTC) delete It ''|provides data integration, business analytics and personalization solutions for communication service providers (CSPs).'' Reference is to PRweb Deletion of Ventraq WP:B2B Wikipedia:Notability 77
14095 12719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Personalities Renowned By Mother Names User:Carlossuarez46 05:01, 2 October 2007 (UTC) delete exegetical posting without sourcing appears to be Deletion of Personalities Renowned By Mother Names WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14096 15016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hick Munsell User:Giants27 15:31, 19 December 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Hick Munsell WP:ATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
14097 17671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nayak Prasad Singh User:AllyD 08:33, 30 November 2017 (UTC) delete An unreliably-sourced article which makes no claim of the subject's notability. The article text is one of the poorest that I have seen, full of repetitions of blocks of sentences and within sentences, with an excess of exclamation marks, and appearing to be a machine translation: even if notability could be established, would be appropriate as there is nothing here which serves the encyclopaedia. Nor am I seeing a claim to encyclopaedic notability in the article's stream of family history or finding better in searches. Fails , Deletion of Nayak Prasad Singh :WP:TNT||:WP:ANYBIO||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
14098 7888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beatty Secondary School User:TerriersFan 03:12, 2 December 2007 (UTC) keep plenty of awards to establish notability and the key facts are now sourced to meet Deletion of Beatty Secondary School WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14099 12026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander C. Feldman User:GabeIglesia 18:24, 22 March 2016 (UTC) keep The article meets . The subject's roles as a former Assistant Secretary of State (a high-level position appointed by the President of the United States), and as the current president of a US-ASEAN Business Council|notable organization gives the subject sufficient notability Deletion of Alexander C. Feldman WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14100 21777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kattu Vannu Vilichappol User:Donaldd23 13:13, 30 December 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Kattu Vannu Vilichappol WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
14101 14707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gloom User:Claritas 10:05, 19 February 2012 (UTC) keep """The topic is obviously notable per the as it is the subject of independent, reliable sources such as ''http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1475-1313.1987.tb01014.x/abstract """"The physiological basis for the sensation of gloom'' and ''http://lrt.sagepub.com/content/21/3/89.abstract Gloom as a psychophysical phenomenon''. No specific synthetic proposition is detailed and so that is just name-calling unsupported by logic or evidence. The nomination seems quite improper in several respects: the authors of the article were not notified; there was no talk page discussion; and there's a history of disruption of this article being |harassment by the banned sockmaster""" Deletion of Gloom WP:GNG||WP:HARASS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14102 613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of dictators (2nd nomination) User:Czello 07:42, 29 May 2021 (UTC) delete as above. Seems very arbitrary, not a single citation to be found. Pure Deletion of List of dictators (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14103 16217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geoff Mendicino User:Edgar181 13:09, 8 December 2006 (UTC) delete does not appear to meet Deletion of Geoff Mendicino WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14104 9321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amanda Evangeline Ting User:Ohconfucius 05:47, 16 August 2006 (UTC) delete as per , in no way does subject meet . ALso her webpage is a dead end Deletion of Amanda Evangeline Ting WP:VAIN||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14105 578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bright Commodity Broker User:Ioannes 21:05, 20 September 2006 (UTC) delete does not assert notability according Deletion of Bright Commodity Broker WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14106 10002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Betty Currie User:Iowateen 15:48, 5 May 2009 (UTC) keep Passes Deletion of Betty Currie WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14107 19262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ric Romero User:Ansell 13:33, 13 April 2006 (UTC) keep He is both an internet and TV celebrity, what more is there to satisfy and Deletion of Ric Romero WP:BIO||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14108 6161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Survivors Strike Back User:A 17:35, 7 April 2007 (UTC) delete """fails . Wooyi's argument above means that """"Survivors Strike Back"""" may merit a mention on the Survivor article and the respective articles of the bloggers, but not its own article""" Deletion of Survivors Strike Back WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14109 18217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ross Mark User:Nurmsook 19:03, 1 December 2008 (UTC) delete Fails , ...Also, A7 Deletion of Ross Mark WP:N||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14110 2107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shintaro Yamada User:Dragquennom 17:55, 20 April 2011 (UTC) keep meets , reliable sources were found Deletion of Shintaro Yamada WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14111 9863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amy Pond User:Elen 21:29, 25 December 2009 (UTC) keep good improvement, article will no doubt gather more material, but there's enough there already to keep. doesn't seem to be an issue - nominator is perhaps unaware that in the UK we tend to shoot whole seasons in one go, prior to airing the first episode Deletion of Amy Pond WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14112 18525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Continental Airlines Flight 1760 User:TheCatalyst31 21:18, 26 December 2011 (UTC) delete Fails rather badly, as well as . Seems like a pretty minor incident Deletion of Continental Airlines Flight 1760 WP:GNG||WP:AIRCRASH Wikipedia:Notability 77
14113 8610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/L. L. Clover User:Unscintillating 12:06, 16 April 2011 (UTC) keep """nbsp; Clover founded a seminary–which seminary is a major academic institution for members of the American Baptist Association of 2000 churches. Having 54 students in 1972, this is by seminary standards a large seminary. The action of founding a seminary has a long-lasting effect on society, as is shown by the careers of graduates of this seminary. For example, one graduate likewise founded a seminary. Clover also founded a bookstore, wrote books, and founded a newsletter.Regarding related guidelines, otability (people) states, """"The topic of an article should be notable, or 'worthy of notice'; that is, 'significant, interesting, or unusual enough to deserve attention or to be recorded'"""", which certainly applies to L. L. Clover. otability (people) further states, """"Many ...scholars (collectively referred to as """"academics"""" for convenience) are notably influential in the world of ideas without their biographies being the subject of secondary sources."""" Many of the criteria in Wikipedia:Notability (academics) are aimed at research professors, and routine positions like president of a university, so while relevant need to be read in the context of an individual whose impact on society is not just as an academic but as a founder of the academic institution itself. """ Deletion of L. L. Clover WP:N||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14114 6053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EBabe User:JJL 15:17, 30 December 2007 (UTC) delete as Deletion of EBabe WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
14115 20317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wells Fargo account fraud scandal User:Arjayay 16:23, 15 May 2017 (UTC) keep Clearly notable per and adequately sourced - to merge would unbalance the existing Wells Fargo page Deletion of Wells Fargo account fraud scandal WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14116 9529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Tuck User:Ultraexactzz 14:51, 17 October 2011 (UTC) merge I have to agree with Gongshow, a redirect here makes a lot of sense. |Usual Caveats apply, as... well, as usual. If the subject's solo career takes off, then an individual article might be appropriate Deletion of Matthew Tuck WP:USUAL Wikipedia:Usual caveats 41
14117 2992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Anis User:SW3 03:40, 20 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Black Anis WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14118 872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Harvey Callahan User:WWGB 08:02, 25 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails notability requirement, his notoriety as a murderer is just Deletion of James Harvey Callahan WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14119 21385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Little pichu! User:Uncle 23:57, 30 August 2010 (UTC) delete per #A10|CSD A10. Duplicate of older revision of Pichu with nonsense title Deletion of Little pichu! WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14120 4055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taobao User:Qrsdogg 17:46, 13 July 2011 (UTC) keep The fact that a company closes (or is split) is really no reason to delete the article (). This article can cover the history of the company from 2003-2011 and the split versions (presuming they are notable) can cover 2011 on Deletion of Taobao WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14121 7448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ross Worner User:Alzarian16 20:44, 15 August 2010 (UTC) keep Passes thanks to his League Cup appearance. The League Cup qualifies as fully professional as all the teams in it are, unlike in other cup competitions which don't count, and his appearance can be easily http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/league_cup/8882725.stm verified Deletion of Ross Worner WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14122 11922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denis Naidanow User:SamHolt6 13:45, 23 July 2017 (UTC) delete Cites the traditional do-no-cites of Soundcloud and Discogs, which present content that is generated by the article subject. Also cites the subject's website. Fails both and Deletion of Denis Naidanow WP:GNG||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14123 11216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bihari lal User:Joal 19:44, 20 May 2010 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Bihari lal WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14124 3440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oak Forest, Florida User:MB 04:33, 17 December 2016 (UTC) delete I found a youtube video that says it has 250 homes/condos and a community center with a pool, weight-room and tennis courts. Seems to be a very neigborhood Deletion of Oak Forest, Florida WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
14125 20707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/English royal descent from Muhammad User:AlexTiefling 11:31, 12 November 2008 (UTC) delete Unverifiable, borderline . I feel Descent of Elizabeth II from the Franks suffers from many of the same problems, and should probably go as well. Comments Deletion of English royal descent from Muhammad WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
14126 16043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oscar Otazu User:Sir 18:29, 9 December 2012 (UTC) delete I think this pretty clearly falls under the part of that says that not all articles that meet its criteria must be kept. The article only just passes , but clearly fails Deletion of Oscar Otazu WP:NSPORT||WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14127 14013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malev (military unit) User:Jpatokal 11:27, 20 February 2019 (UTC) keep """The deletion rationale is nonsensical: what exactly is a """"foreign word""""? More importantly, per , national """"battalion-level or equivalent"""" units are notable, and an Estonian malev is larger than a battalion""" Deletion of Malev (military unit) WP:MILUNIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14128 160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Listen Here! User:Totnesmartin 22:27, 6 August 2011 (UTC) delete I can't find much outside sales sites, and a passing mention on Ralph McTell's website doesn't really cut the mustard Deletion of Listen Here! WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14129 14156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Echoplex Digital Pro User:Red 14:54, 1 August 2019 (UTC) delete Overly promotional tone, and a lack of third-party reliable sources suggests this is not a notable product. in writing doesn't help the situation, either Deletion of Echoplex Digital Pro WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14130 4650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pokemon-Safari.com User:Haeleth 23:02, 4 September 2006 (UTC) delete """per .For those concerned about loss of information, let's be honest: the only ''information'' in the article can be summed up as """"Pokemon-Safari is a popular Pokemon fansite. It was founded in 1999 in Spanish. It became popular in 2006 when an English version was launched."""" There's no reason those three sentences need to be surrounded by an entire article of cruft, when the ''useful and verifiable information'' from this article could easily be made even more useful by putting it in some sensible context and adding those three sentences to a more general article on Pokemon fansites. &mdash""" Deletion of Pokemon-Safari.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14131 11736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anisong Chareantham User:GiantSnowman 16:05, 13 April 2020 (UTC) keep has nominator heard of ? Sources do exist and show player meets . Article needs improving, not deleting Deletion of Anisong Chareantham WP:BEFORE||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14132 16853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unknown Centerfold July 1970 User:Metropolitan90 02:26, 5 December 2005 (UTC) delete under A3 due to lack of content. It would be impossible to write a useful article under this title; if the model were identified, the article would be under her own name (either a real name or a modeling name Deletion of Unknown Centerfold July 1970 WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14133 1624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Wesley Rawles User:Bulldog123 00:07, 3 May 2008 (UTC) delete Weak notability, . Everything said by Verdatum really Deletion of James Wesley Rawles WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
14134 2766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sri Maruthi Yuvajana Sangam User:Elton 15:43, 7 July 2017 (UTC) delete fails . Non sourced article, found no reliable source while performing --Elton-Rodrigues — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Sri Maruthi Yuvajana Sangam WP:ORG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14135 245 [[TSG 1899 Hoffenheim/Namen und Zahlen]] (LAE) Benutzer:SteMicha NONE keep Bereits im /12. August 2008#TSG 1899 Hoffenheim/Namen und Zahlen (bleibt)|August 2008 wurde diese Löschung diskutiert und im Grunde genommen Löschung von TSG 1899 Hoffenheim/Namen und Zahlen Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14136 16426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Ryan Anderson User:Guest9999 19:03, 3 September 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find any coverage in RS|reliable sources (significant or otherwise) as required by the |general notability guideline and the |specific guideline for people. The article claims he is best known for being in Hannah Montana but http://www.imdb.com/name/nm2062262/ his IMDb profile says he was only in five episodes and the role doesn't seem to have received any coverage Deletion of Patrick Ryan Anderson WP:NN||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14137 5722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moldova–Switzerland relations User:Bearian 18:50, 19 August 2009 (UTC) keep this appears to meet the |consensus that well-referenced bilateral relations articles ought to be kept, and with all the |citations and information |now in it, this certainly makes the grade Deletion of Moldova–Switzerland relations WP:CCC||WP:RS||WP:HEY Wikipedia:Consensus 78
14138 10593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Straw polls for the Democratic Party 2008 presidential nomination User:Niteshift36 01:42, 11 November 2008 (UTC) delete Was always a with dubious criteria Deletion of Straw polls for the Democratic Party 2008 presidential nomination WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
14139 20258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TamilNadu State Transport Corporation - Kumbakonam User:Ab207 12:13, 24 July 2021 (UTC) delete per nom. No indication of meeting . With the mispelling and the hyphen, I don't think redirect is going to be very helpful here Deletion of TamilNadu State Transport Corporation - Kumbakonam WP:BRANCH Wikipedia:Notability 77
14140 13429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MXPie User:Carlossuarez46 22:11, 4 October 2007 (UTC) delete nn product, fails & Deletion of MXPie WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
14141 11200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orcon User:Capitalistroadster 01:07, 7 December 2005 (UTC) keep Appears to meet with three Google News hits from significant New Zealand papers see http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&ned=&q=Orcon&btnG=Search+News Deletion of Orcon WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14142 13136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Walker (businessman) User:Gachangi 06:12, 29 January 2017 (UTC) delete A CEO of a non notable company. The mere mentions in the sources only speak about him in passing mentions while doing what an ordinary company would be doing in its day to day running. Nothing encyclopedic about this subject and a search online doesn't return any coverage in a |reliable source Deletion of Craig Walker (businessman) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14143 21406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Freemuse User:Dekisugi 11:42, 3 January 2008 (UTC) delete Yet another non-notable organization. Per , the article does not show enough supports from |non-trivial coverage of independent and |reliable sources. At this form, I'd say delete Deletion of Freemuse WP:ORG||WP:SOURCES||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14144 16739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Hudecki (2nd nomination) User:Hobit 18:49, 3 January 2010 (UTC) keep appears to meet WP:ENT, but I'm worried a bit about how much |usable material we can find about him Deletion of Peter Hudecki (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14145 3213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dezfoolian User:Edison 18:39, 6 May 2009 (UTC) delete """Wikipedia is |not a directory of every """"semi-common surname."""" Fails |notability as well""" Deletion of Dezfoolian WP:NOT||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14146 21614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hans F. Petersen User:Bakazaka 00:40, 18 October 2018 (UTC) comment Note that the single cited source is the old Latter-day Saint Biographical Encyclopedia, which was written by a church historian, published by a church-owned press, and distributed free of charge to LDS stakes/wards. It is not an independent source (see Deletion of Hans F. Petersen WP:IIS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14147 6341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamel Abu Saqer User:Sam 11:35, 17 May 2016 (UTC) delete No sources found the suggest subject meets /. With a https://tools.wmflabs.org/copyvios/?lang=en&project=wikipedia&title=Kamel_Abu_Saqer 99.5% copy-vio score of http://gulflegaldocs.com/page_contents.php?sel_id=1 I would have tagged this G12 myself Deletion of Kamel Abu Saqer WP:BASIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14148 9516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Viacheslav Georgievich Borshchev User:Papaursa 21:14, 21 July 2019 (UTC) delete There's no evidence he meets any of the notability criteria for kickboxers. I also couldn't find significant independent coverage that shows is met. Routine sports coverage/results are not sufficient to show notability Deletion of Viacheslav Georgievich Borshchev WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14149 5380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Taylor polyhedra User:DeVerm 20:51, 12 June 2016 (UTC) delete Article does not pass . {{ping|Polystar}} you can go to to read the guideline on sourcing. You need secondary, reliable sources in addition to your primary sources Deletion of List of Taylor polyhedra WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14150 7050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brenda Ford User:Storkk 14:55, 9 October 2006 (UTC) delete until she's elected or does something else |notable Deletion of Brenda Ford WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14151 14972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grey dwarf User:QTxVi4bEMRbrNqOorWBV 03:30, 25 September 2013 (UTC) delete This shouldn't even be a conversation given previous AfDs. Article creator seems to be disrupting Wikipedia to prove a on his blog Deletion of Grey dwarf WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
14152 20827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1976 Canary Island UFO sighting User:Location 22:10, 26 July 2014 (UTC) delete Fails , especially because there are no reliable sources discussing it. An alleged event near the Canary Islands in 1979 does appear to get some coverage, though: http://www.google.com/search?q=canary%20island%20ufo%20site:news.google.com/newspapers&source=newspapers Deletion of 1976 Canary Island UFO sighting WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14153 14152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kalvithanthai Haji. S.M.S. Shaik Jalaludeen User:Ohnoitsjamie 15:28, 28 January 2020 (UTC) delete Fails ; insufficient sourcing to establish this person as meeting Deletion of Kalvithanthai Haji. S.M.S. Shaik Jalaludeen WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14154 7031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian White (soccer) User:K 03:21, 24 January 2018 (UTC) delete routine coverage; fail . Wikipedia does not aspire to be a directory of nn athletes Deletion of Brian White (soccer) WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
14155 1509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inside (Movie) User:MichaelQSchmidt 21:37, 24 September 2015 (UTC) keep as the https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Inside_%28Movie%29&type=revision&diff=682646498&oldid=682509955 poorly written '''brand new''' article |sent to AFD here as a poor translation from https://sr.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%A3%D0%BD%D1%83%D1%82%D1%80%D0%B0_(%D1%84%D0%B8%D0%BB%D0%BC) Serbian Wikipedia or the https://hr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unutra_(Film) Croatian Wikipedia is a topic https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Inside_%28Movie%29&type=revision&diff=682637871&oldid=682509955 proving itself improvable... and under its Serbian name ''Unutra'' appears to just meet .http://www.seecult.org/vest/odgovornost-za-izborhttp://rs.sputniknews.com/vesti/20150307/542907.htmlhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inside_(Movie)#Reception Folks, is really a nice tool to use Deletion of Inside (Movie) WP:BITE||WP:NF||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
14156 2036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SupaCrankIt User:Northamerica1000 05:21, 15 June 2017 (UTC) delete Not finding any coverage in reliable sources at this time; does not meet Deletion of SupaCrankIt WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14157 5885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ravi Kumar Panasa User:Theroadislong 07:57, 18 July 2018 (UTC) delete references are merely passing mentions with no in-depth coverage, fails Wikipedia:DIRECTOR and Deletion of Ravi Kumar Panasa WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14158 12840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ten Floors User:Cyrus 17:15, 20 September 2007 (UTC) comment The battle of the bands was a local competition for a radio station, as explained in the article itself. Also, the sources being presented are all local newpspaers or publications. Those are not exactly |reliable sources. They have not had extensive coverage outside of the city that they live in. That is not an assertion of notability. http://www.channel4.com/music/myband/tenfloorsbelowsociety - This says that they are unsigned, they do not even have a record contract Deletion of Ten Floors WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14159 8852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kresimir Chris Kunej (2nd nomination) User:Agricola44 15:21, 22 April 2010 (UTC) delete """The article's focus is on the learned work that the subject has done (translating textbooks, writing technical papers, and such), so is indeed the appropriate metric. As with the majority of hopefuls, he has to be tested on #1 because he clearly does not pass any of the other criteria. (With all due respect, there seems to be some basic confusion on what constitutes a pass on some of these criteria, for example testimonials on how someone's work changed the protocol in a narrow area of study or how their work was required reading at one specific institution certainly don't satisfy #4 – see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kresimir Chris Kunej|prev AfD for specifics.) Disinterested inspection of the body of his work is conclusive: he has 0 hits and 0 citations (h-index = 0) for research work in the standard indexes (WoS, GS). The article clearly claims research publications, but my guess is that these articles actually appear in something like trade publications. For example, """"Translator: Journal of the Croatian Association of Scientific and Technical Translators"""" seems to be the official publication of a http://www.drustvoprevoditelja.htnet.hr/desni_engl.html translation agency. (Article seems to confirm this: """"Kunej's most notable publication is a professional article/paper he wrote in 2003 entitled “Analysis of Translations from Croatian to English and Vice-Versa Along with Suggestions for Improving the Profession” 1 that was published by the Croatian Association of Technical and Scientific Translators 5 in their trade publication""""). The article is also heavily loaded with pointers to other white-papers and unpublished material that contribute nothing toward notability. There is also the usual confusion related to the media, i.e. mistaking a brief appearance related to an event for substantive coverage of the subject himself. The red-flags are numerous, including listing how many minutes into the broadcast the subject appears, listing individual institutions that make trivial mention of his work, e.g. """"the wedding customs book is mentioned also online on the Rijeka City Library website"""", etc. I think it is very clear that the article's content strains to manufacture notability where none (perhaps yet) exists. Respectfully""" Deletion of Kresimir Chris Kunej (2nd nomination) WP:PROF||WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14160 17236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Yarkot User:Bearian 19:06, 17 November 2020 (UTC) delete per and . Even if this mess could be fixed, I don't see any reliable sources Deletion of James Yarkot WP:TNT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
14161 13674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norayr Gyozalyan User:I 04:25, 10 November 2011 (UTC) delete per notability guidelines at . Banants Yerevan, Impuls FC Dilijan, and Ulisses are all FCs that are not fully professional. No other coverage appears to exist for each player to support notability per , so I support the deletion of all pages nominated Deletion of Norayr Gyozalyan WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14162 9344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Nottinghamshire User:Beagel 14:37, 26 March 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of bus routes in Nottinghamshire WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14163 4201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mattia Destro User:Nfitz 03:10, 17 July 2009 (UTC) keep Easily meets (which trumps with articles in many countries about him such as http://www.internazionale.fr/article-3259-destro-ce-debut-avec-l-equipe-est-deja-un-reve-pour-moi.html, http://www.puntosport.net/pageview2.php?i=17787&sl=1, http://www.calciomercato.com/index.php?c=23&a=129743, http://www.tuttomercatoweb.com/inter/?action=read&idnotizia=5175, http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-1029706/QPR-believes-Inter-Milan-youngster-Destro-right-man.html Deletion of Mattia Destro WP:N||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14164 7445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clan Nova Cat User:Snottywong 21:33, 12 July 2010 (UTC) delete No |reliable sources exist to establish the notability of this subject. All mentions of this are on fan-sites, and contain in-world fancruft Deletion of Clan Nova Cat WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14165 14912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Discrimination against girls in India User:Alarichall 10:46, 24 March 2019 (UTC) keep I agree that this article is poorly written and sourced: it's meandering and the material needs consolidating and expanding. It is clearly a sub-topic of Gender inequality in India, and needs to be edited to sit effectively alongside Female foeticide in India, Female infanticide in India, and Violence against women in India. On the other hand, there's no question that discrimination against girls specifically in post-natal health, education and employment is the subject of huge amounts of academic research, and it makes sense to have a proper article on this, cited as a 'main' article at the relevant paragraph in Gender inequality in India. Just to demonstrate notability, I've rather tentatively begun Discrimination against girls in India#Some further reading based on a quick scholar.google.com search. This is by no means an expert selection, and of course what this article really needs is proper in-line references, but I believe it indicates that the topic readily meets . As for the point that other similar entries don't exist for other countries, that's not an argument to delete this piece. Maybe they should exist! But either way, India is such a vast country that it's bound to sustain articles on subjects that would be too niche for many other countries Deletion of Discrimination against girls in India WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14166 12714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/APVTH User:Erpert 00:43, 22 May 2011 (UTC) delete per #G3|G3; tagged as such. The band's name (including the supposed former name) combined with each album title comes back to absolutely nothing on Google. It also doesn't help that the article was |created by the bandleader. '''Erpert Deletion of APVTH WP:CSD||WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14167 18065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James M. Russell User:David 05:16, 24 July 2020 (UTC) keep """but discount the previous inane opinion). Despite having a named professorship, I'm a little skeptical of his pass of #C5, because """"professor of teaching excellence"""" sounds more like a title given to someone doing an unwanted but important teaching task than for scholarly excellence, and because his cv shows he was given it at the same time as promotion to full professor while #C5 is really looking for something that's a step above full. However, doing a Google Scholar search of his name and looking only at the earth science publications among the results (because he has a common name and there is at least one other well-cited James M. Russell) shows a pass of #C1""" Deletion of James M. Russell WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14168 15410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of television stations in Arizona by city of license User:Arkyan 15:22, 17 August 2007 (UTC) delete """as being redundant to List of television stations in Arizona. I disagree that is the reason to delete here, lists of television channels by state seem to be OK by wikipedia standards, and there is certainly nothing wrong with wanting to sort it by city. This list however is an incomplete effort at doing so. What would make better sense is to present the information in the other list (and indeed in all of the """"List of television stations in ''state''"""" articles) in sortable, tabular format""" Deletion of List of television stations in Arizona by city of license WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14169 16522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/What's the Difference (song) [[User talk:Erpert|(let's talk about it)]] 06:29, 4 April 2010 (UTC) merge to ''2001 (album)'' per . It's a great song, but it doesn't warrant its own article (and to say the article has POV problems would be an understatement). '''Erpert Deletion of What's the Difference (song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14170 17012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greenfinger (2nd nomination) User:S 00:44, 2 March 2009 (UTC) comment I'm sorry, but the definitions belong on Wiktionary rather than Wikipedia and the |good faith attempt at encyclopaedic content belongs in Gregory Benford Deletion of Greenfinger (2nd nomination) WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
14171 19586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John rindlaub User:Capitalistroadster 04:07, 31 January 2006 (UTC) delete Marketing guy at an airline. While he may be good at his job (although I had'nt heard of it), nothing in the article or online appears to indicate that he meets the criteria outlined at Deletion of John rindlaub WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14172 21428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DJ Sonny User:Richard3120 21:48, 22 November 2018 (UTC) delete fails and . Little more than a bedroom DJ, no evidence at all of notability Deletion of DJ Sonny WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14173 10951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lake Nokopen, California User:Hog 21:33, 10 September 2020 (UTC) delete minor camp with a minor post office for a few years. Brief post offices don't indicate notability. Certainly not a populated place in the sense expected by Deletion of Lake Nokopen, California WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14174 9278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pooja K. Doshi User:Atlantic306 19:43, 14 August 2017 (UTC) delete as as has just made her debut in an unreleased film that has no article. She does have a leading role so may well be notable after further projects Deletion of Pooja K. Doshi WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
14175 6037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of scientists opposing the mainstream scientific assessment of global warming (4th nomination) NONE NONE comment the nominator and other editors argue that this list is -- but, if so, so is every other list in the encyclopedia. Making a list involves editorial choices, generally by many editors. See, for example, the http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=List_of_science_fiction_authors&action=history Revision history of the List of science fiction authors -- or virtually any other list in the encyclopedia Deletion of List of scientists opposing the mainstream scientific assessment of global warming (4th nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14176 2901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lightsaber combat (4th nomination) User:RGTraynor 20:48, 7 March 2007 (UTC) delete as above, violates and is little but a heap of supposition and personal opinion Deletion of Lightsaber combat (4th nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14177 19534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Khan Tareen User:Störm 06:49, 8 January 2018 (UTC) delete currently fails Deletion of Ali Khan Tareen WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14178 21685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NEStimulator User:Anarchyte 12:16, 18 August 2015 (UTC) delete both articles as they are not sourced by |reliable sources Deletion of NEStimulator WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14179 5087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flags of country subdivisions User:Stuartyeates 08:45, 11 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails . Completely unreferenced Deletion of Flags of country subdivisions WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14180 5350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jude Calvert-Toulmin User:Yunshui 23:10, 4 February 2012 (UTC) delete """None of the sources, including those listed above, come near to the requirements for |notability. The Sheffield Star article is about the best thing out there, but since it takes the form of an interview it veers to close to a |primary source for my tastes (and seriously, local papers shouldn't really count towards notability - I've been in my local rag numerous times, and I'm sure as hell not notable.) Blogs and IMDb are no-go per , and listings, as either a photographer or TV cast member/guest don't fulfil the requirement in for """"significant coverage""" Deletion of Jude Calvert-Toulmin WP:N||WP:PRIMARY||WP:USERG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14181 14320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Winge User:Tom 06:44, 7 July 2011 (UTC) delete Wikipedia isn't a collection of things |you just made up. Not a shred of notability Deletion of Winge WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
14182 86 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K. Johanna (Joana) Altmann User:Deli 13:11, 26 July 2019 (UTC) delete This article is blatantly promotional and entirely the work of single editor with a clear conflict of interest. I don't think it matters whether the subject meets Wikipedia's notability criteria because applies to this article. Just delete it and if she's notable, start again from scratch Deletion of K. Johanna (Joana) Altmann WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
14183 11743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Capsule (film) User:MarnetteD 00:37, 10 December 2016 (UTC) delete as it fails at this time. It looks like it is a early film for the makers and is making the circuit of small film festivals. If it ever achieves significant coverage than it can be recreated. I also tried to find an article that it might be redirected to but came up empty Deletion of Capsule (film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
14184 13154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Freddy Awards User:Hunter 18:36, 14 June 2017 (UTC) keep I am the creator of this article. The Freddy Awards were the subject of a feature-length documentary film that was broadcast by the Oprah Winfrey Network. That ''alone'' means it satisfies and . The article as it stands right now is heavy on regional sources because they are the best sources of information. Even putting that aside, those regional sources ARE |reliable sources (The Express-Times, The Morning Call, WFMZ, etc.), so the article passes and with them alone. However, there ARE other non-regional reliable sources out there that discuss the Freddy Awards, such as the http://voices.washingtonpost.com/answer-sheet/guest-bloggers/antidote-to-an-educators-depre.html Washington Post, http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/showtracker/2010/11/own-acquires-three-documentaries-.html Los Angeles Times, the http://www.tennessean.com/article/20110422/ENTERTAINMENT04/110422009/Nashville-Film-Festival-announces-winners-?odyssey=nav%7Chead. Tennessean, etc. The article as it stands now could be expanded upon and improved with more outside sources (including the feature-length documentary about it), but |there is no deadline for such improvements, so it shouldn't be deleted for that reason. And even putting that aside, the article meets notability standards as it is Deletion of The Freddy Awards WP:N||WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14185 5354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of media using the Wilhelm scream User:O 02:51, 12 September 2007 (UTC) comment Please take a look at Special:Contributions/Viperix and Wikipedia:Village pump (policy)#Canvassing on RfX's and similar pages. It is apparent that this user has been posting notifications about this AFD to pretty much random users and is considered |excessive cross-posting. Just wanted to give a heads up Deletion of List of media using the Wilhelm scream WP:CANVASS Wikipedia:Canvassing 93
14186 19270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asia-2 (2nd nomination) User:Coolabahapple 06:12, 10 May 2019 (UTC) comment """Again (see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asia-1), is this a """"legally recognised (it is populated) place""""? if yes than according to it is """"typically presumed to be notable"""" and can be kept, if not legally recognised than probably best to redirect to Kapayapaan Village, Canlubang (i note this does appear to be a small neighbourhood of 4 paruks""" Deletion of Asia-2 (2nd nomination) WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14187 19928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hammerax (2nd nomination) User:Lightburst 21:11, 16 November 2019 (UTC) keep Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hammerax|AfD closed exactly three days ago. Refer to renomination. Once notable always notable Passes http://www.musicgearreview.com/article-display/3785.html Music Gear review prodcut Mentioned in https://drummagazine.com/5000-years-in-3000-words-cymbal-history/ Drum Magazine https://drumproductreviews.blogspot.com/2010/11/hammerax-18-boomywang.html Drum Product Review Deletion of Hammerax (2nd nomination) WP:DELAFD||WP:DISRUPTIVE||WP:NTEMP||WP:PRESERVE||WP:ATD||WP:NOTCLEANUP||WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
14188 12544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aspie Quiz User:Zad68 13:21, 9 August 2013 (UTC) comment Before we even need to get into a discussion of the quality of the journal itself, the requires that the significant coverage be independent. In this case, the journal article was written by the author of the Aspie Quiz itself, so the coverage is not independent, and cannot be used to satisfy Deletion of Aspie Quiz WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14189 14477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Concentrated benefits and diffuse costs NONE NONE keep Why would comments have to be found ''about'' the phrase as a term? Wikipedia |is not a dictionary Deletion of Concentrated benefits and diffuse costs WP:NOTDIC Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
14190 2260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Echobox User:K 19:47, 23 June 2018 (UTC) delete sourcing does not meet new and improved ; it's in passing and / or . ''Mediashift'' is closer to what's needed, but it's still . The company has not achieved anything significant just yet. Just a promotional directory listing at this point Deletion of Echobox WP:NCORP||WP:SPIP||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
14191 9451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S.V.S. Rathinam User:Bonadea 08:26, 21 July 2014 (UTC) keep """there is certainly a claim to notability for this person. That Thomas Rathnam is not notable is irrelevant in the context of this article, and we have to |assume good faith when it comes to other editors and their motivations. Most of the references do not appear to be |reliable sources (which is an entirely different thing from being """"bogus"""") but there may very well be other usable references; I do not read Tamil so can't find sources in that language. Please note that references do not have to be online, but they (obvously) have to exist in some form. In the interest of counteracting ystemic bias|systemic bias it is important to include notable people outside the Western world - provided they ''are'' notable""" Deletion of S.V.S. Rathinam WP:AGF||WP:RS||WP:S Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
14192 12871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Sweeney User:Location 03:24, 20 August 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Daniel Sweeney WP:POLITICIAN||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
14193 9074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Thomas Orthodox Church Vellukutta User:Metropolitan90 16:49, 1 November 2009 (UTC) delete per nom and . No independent sources have been provided Deletion of St. Thomas Orthodox Church Vellukutta WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14194 5053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hair tongs alarm User:DMacks 08:32, 5 November 2009 (UTC) delete """Can't find any RS, none supplied by article contributors either. The key claim is that these can keep me from using a curling iron that is too cool and risk """"potentially life-threatening hair damage""""? O...kay. """"Many students choose the hair tongs alarm as a project option for electronics GCSE."""" That seals it.../ non-notable school project""" Deletion of Hair tongs alarm WP:NFT||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
14195 6951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enrique Máximo García User:Rocy 22:03, 4 January 2009 (UTC) keep As Phil Bridger, I think he has the enough notability required by Deletion of Enrique Máximo García WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14196 11865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laboratory Robotics Interest Group User:Piotrus 10:02, 30 May 2017 (UTC) delete The article doesn't even has a link to their webpage, total failure of , in addition to GNG and likely OR Deletion of Laboratory Robotics Interest Group WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14197 4176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenichi Osada User:David 06:14, 27 April 2019 (UTC) keep Despite the unusually stubby state of the article it already documents a clear pass of Deletion of Kenichi Osada WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14198 16340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Youth Journalism International User:timtempleton 20:57, 2 April 2018 (UTC) delete insufficient coverage in reliable sources - fails Deletion of Youth Journalism International WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14199 21539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nelly Furtado:The Hits User:Schuym1 12:41, 28 October 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Nelly Furtado:The Hits WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14200 1465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/On Meaning User:SBKSPP 03:46, 4 September 2021 (UTC) keep Meets with sources presented by Ofir. They're reliable enough IMV Deletion of On Meaning WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14201 7856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qi-Yo Multi-Yoga User:Ahecht 21:31, 19 March 2014 (UTC) delete |Lots of citations that aren't to |reliable sources do not establish notability. Per , a topic must received significant coverage in reliable sources that are |independent of the subject to be suitable for a stand-alone article. None of the sources meet the exceptions in , and the fact that there are doesn't change that Deletion of Qi-Yo Multi-Yoga WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:IS||WP:JUSTABLOG||WP:LOTSOFSOURCES Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14202 12265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Subvertising User:Noian 06:30, 10 December 2010 (UTC) delete When define:subvertising turns up only wikipedia as the source (http://www.google.com/search?q=define%3Asubvertising&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a), not even urban dictionary or any other semi-reliable sources google gives, you know it's a eologism. I trust define: over a normal google search that brings up anything from the dredges of the internet for words Deletion of Subvertising WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14203 19351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Argyle Academy User:Adashiel 12:07, 28 May 2006 (UTC) comment It looks like the author, who doesn't appear to have an article, ''might'' make . There was an article about him in the Washington City Paper, which is available (if you want to cough up 3 bucks) https://secure.washingtoncitypaper.com/cgi-bin/Archive/abridged2.bat?path=q:%5CDocRoot/2005/050408/BONES&search=lowery&SearchString=lowery&AuthorLastName=&IssueDate=mm%2Fdd%2Fyyyy&SelectYear=All&next.x=0&next.y=0 here or (if you want to go blind) http://www.thomasmlowery.com/mike.pdf here. However, this journal comic seems to be a fairly new project and it wasn't mentioned in the article Deletion of Argyle Academy WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14204 17449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bambi Kevichüsa User:scope_creep 10:59, 28 May 2020 (UTC) delete Insufficient sourcing to establish , never mind Deletion of Bambi Kevichüsa WP:BASIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14205 6560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rodney Marks User:Bondegezou 10:40, 16 June 2013 (UTC) comment I don't understand Duffbeerforme's argument. If he's notable, then Deletion of Rodney Marks WP:FIXIT Wikipedia:Be bold 9
14206 15782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 Austin shooting User:Prevan 14:26, 31 July 2016 (UTC) delete article creator seems not to comprehend |Wikipedia is not the news Deletion of 2016 Austin shooting WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14207 7522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karalina Tjapko User:RonSigPi 22:43, 15 October 2014 (UTC) comment A few points. First, its worth pointing out that is an essay and not a guideline, similar to . Second I dont know how one 'fails' as it merely shows how notability or deletion are supported. Of a similar note, I dont see how any of the listed points, either for deletion or notability, are relevant for this person and thus dont know how its 'failed'. Third, it seems like the martial arts project wants to expand its reach. Not only a wrestler being claimed as one that the martial arts project has authority over, but even boxing seems to be getting roped in (see deletion discussion for Mickey Goodwin). While one can argue if wrestling and boxing are martial arts, the are not written with a wrestler in mind. There is no 'finding of a wrestling style' as would be needed for 2. The 2nd half of 3 states that world champion of an 'organization', but that seems more geared to UFC/Bellator than what is commonly considered a governing body. There are no 'belts' in wrestling as 4 discusses and typically books in an 'art' are not common in wrestling. That leaves 1 and the first part of 3, which would apply to almost any athlete, not specifically a martial artist. I just dont see it carrying weight here. That leaves us with WP:GNG and I think as said before WP:SPORTCRIT is met and thus a presumption of GNG applies Deletion of Karalina Tjapko WP:MANOTE||WP:CFBCOACH||WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14208 2094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Benoit and Dean Malenko User:Theophilus75 18:39, 18 June 2007 (UTC) comment It's not just about having one source, it's about having sources that are considered that meet the criteria of proving . If that one source now listed did that, then I'd be thrilled (it would make our lives a whole lot easier in the pro-wrestling project). What would be even harder with this article though, is to find a that meets that shows that ''this'' article needs to exist, and not an article about the Triple Threat, Four Horsemen (professional wrestling)|The Four Horsemen and The Radicalz Deletion of Chris Benoit and Dean Malenko WP:RS||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14209 18130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The gate coach User:Anupmehra 10:47, 14 January 2015 (UTC) delete Article reads and fails and , and also is a from http://thegatecoach.blogspot.com/2013/06/start-your-ies-preparation-now.html here, http://juitsynapse.org/exams/gate.html here and many https://tools.wmflabs.org/copyvios/?lang=en&project=wikipedia&title=The_gate_coach other places Deletion of The gate coach WP:PROMO||WP:ORG||WP:GNG||WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14210 17173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deaths by Russian roulette User:Bluerasberry 18:07, 25 July 2017 (UTC) delete and '''redirect''' to Russian roulette. An interesting case. We would surely reject articles about any of these individual mentions as , but do they merit mentions in another article? I'm inclined to agree with Deletion of Deaths by Russian roulette WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14211 14265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thierry Ambrose User:Fenix 13:27, 21 January 2015 (UTC) delete Player fails as has not played in a |fully professional league, nor senior international football. No indication of any other achievements that have garnered sufficient, significant coverage to satisfy Deletion of Thierry Ambrose WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14212 14462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan neiwert User:TBC 05:06, 2 November 2006 (UTC) delete Many of the Neiwert's claims to notability, such as having content hosted on MySpace or Blogtalkradio, are considered #_note-6|trivial as everyone, regardless of background or credentials, are allowed to submit content to said websites Deletion of Dan neiwert WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14213 19129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global Leveraged Capital User:Jayron32 16:42, 27 May 2009 (UTC) delete Borderline case, but there does not as yet appear to be the depth of coverage necessary to support inclusion of this article, as spelled out in and Deletion of Global Leveraged Capital WP:N||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14214 5750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackie Weaver User:Qazwsx777 09:18, 11 February 2021 (UTC) merge It does certainly go against and as famous does not mean notable. The content is solid and well referenced so as per it should be merged into Handforth Parish Council or Cheshire East Council bullying and misconduct allegations Deletion of Jackie Weaver WP:BLP1E||WP:1E||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
14215 17866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pier Giuseppe Monateri User:JFHJr 20:21, 10 February 2013 (UTC) delete Regarding criteria, I don't find these particular Italian-language pieces to be of adequate |reliability, especially for purposes. The content about 1E|someone else's murder violates CRIME and doesn't add constructively to having an encyclopedic biography. Otherwise, the SPS source does not lead me to believe the subject has met any of the alternative criteria under that might show automatic notability in WP terms. His http://code.google.com/p/citations-gadget/ h-index is 9, which I don't consider encyclopedically notable on its own Deletion of Pier Giuseppe Monateri WP:BASIC||WP:IRS||WP:BLP||WP:BLP1E||WP:BLPCRIME||WP:BLPSPS||WP:PROFESSOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14216 11777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Chinese dragons in popular culture User:Useight 17:27, 6 August 2007 (UTC) delete as |trivia collection and #DIR|loosely-associated list Deletion of List of Chinese dragons in popular culture WP:TRIVIA||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
14217 11331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Langdon Morris (2nd nomination) User:SamHolt6 20:02, 12 January 2018 (UTC) delete Subject fails . True, the subject is a prolific author, but has not created the significant works needed for inclusion as laid down by the our points in Deletion of Langdon Morris (2nd nomination) WP:AUTHOR||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14218 21190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Winnipeg city councillors User:K 07:49, 28 August 2016 (UTC) delete as not meeting ; recent related AfDs closed as delete Deletion of Winnipeg city councillors WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14219 11176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Campus Center for Appropriate Technology User:Jenks24 15:32, 12 April 2011 (UTC) keep per MelanieN; the sources she has found show this article passes Deletion of Campus Center for Appropriate Technology WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14220 17846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irfan Ismail (cricketer, born 1992) User:Lugnuts 13:02, 27 February 2021 (UTC) keep played in multiple matches across all three formats, meeting Deletion of Irfan Ismail (cricketer, born 1992) WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14221 2146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sokratis Dioudis User:GiantSnowman 10:45, 10 August 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Sokratis Dioudis WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14222 14541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Barnowski User:Cyrus 13:27, 11 April 2007 (UTC) delete non notable kid. Does not pass Deletion of Nick Barnowski WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14223 18664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skrein User:J04n 22:57, 28 March 2011 (UTC) delete unable to find significant cover in |reliable sources independent of the subject of this unsourced |BLP Deletion of Skrein WP:RS||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14224 832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wu Yongning User:Anna 09:07, 17 December 2017 (UTC) comment """He passes GNG. Wikipedia goes like ''""""Passes GNG, however NOTABILITY GUIDELINE says no article""""''. In this case, it is that says that, clearly. So, if moved to Death of Wu Yongning, because that is what the event was, then we look at . It requires """"enduring historical significance"""" or """"significant lasting effect"""" or """"notable if widespread impact""""? Nope. It also says """"Routine...news events...including...deaths...""""shock"""" news...stories lacking lasting value such as """"water cooler stories,""""...whether or not tragic or widely reported at the time...are usually not notable unless something further gives them additional enduring significance..."""" and that says to me Death of Wu Yongning is not notable. Counter that argument and I'll """"keep"""", otherwise I'll """"delete"""". Thoughts""" Deletion of Wu Yongning WP:OTHER||WP:ONEVENT||WP:EVENTCRITERIA Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14225 19736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timonia User:RUL3R 21:04, 9 October 2009 (UTC) delete per , and as nonsense Deletion of Timonia WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
14226 224 [[Carola Rackete]] (LAZ) Benutzer:MovGP0 10:00, 30. Jun. 2019 (CEST) keep gemäß der '''#Lebende_Personen_(allgemein)|Relevanzkriterien''' („wegen ihrer Beteiligung an historischen, politischen oder sonstigen nachrichtenwürdigen Ereignissen bekannt,“) &mdash Löschung von Carola Rackete Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
14227 4571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/April Sanders User:GPL93 18:23, 17 June 2020 (UTC) keep Clearly passes as Sanders was a member of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia. Best Deletion of April Sanders WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14228 14886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jagiri Lal Sareen User:TipsyElephant 20:59, 22 August 2021 (UTC) delete does not pass or Deletion of Jagiri Lal Sareen WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14229 18574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pierre Foldès User:Ciotog 05:36, 15 March 2007 (UTC) keep an award winning book was written about his work, as well as a number of news articles, clearly meeting . However, they are generally French sources. Even so, his work is pioneering - he's not just doing boob jobs Deletion of Pierre Foldès WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14230 958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BrokeNCYDE (2nd nomination) User:JamesBurns 07:43, 23 December 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish significant notability, per Deletion of BrokeNCYDE (2nd nomination) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14231 19665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CAH Cheras Futsal Team User:Bennv3771 12:26, 2 September 2018 (UTC) delete per nom. Cannot find any coverage of this local amateur club in Deletion of CAH Cheras Futsal Team WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14232 18548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Kill Bill characters User:Betty 21:27, 18 June 2017 (UTC) delete per . It is basically a page of fictional character biographies and per Wikipedia should only be providing a description of fictional works to the extent it supports real-world commentary Deletion of List of Kill Bill characters WP:NOTPLOT||WP:JUSTPLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14233 15504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Edwin Thomas User:Lugnuts 19:21, 19 February 2013 (UTC) delete No long-term notability and too Deletion of Murder of Edwin Thomas WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14234 16666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DigitalOcean (2nd nomination) User:Rwendland 16:25, 12 November 2015 (UTC) keep """I think there are enough """"international or national"""" """"multiple independent sources"""" cited per to establish notability""" Deletion of DigitalOcean (2nd nomination) :WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
14235 30 [[Grimmelshausen-Gymnasium Offenburg]] (LAE) Benutzer:Wicki und Halva NONE keep """Ist ggf. sogar ein ausländischer Schulabschluss möglich, zum Beispiel Baccalauréat?"""" (aus ). Ja ist es. sogar. Also natürlich relevant, dazu von 1660. Dass das Schulgebäude von 1647 (ehemaliges Kloster) unter Denkmalschutz steht, davon kann man ausgehen. Also bitte . User:Okmijnuhb|Okmijnuhb·BD:Okmijnuhb|bitte recht freundlich 12:22, 31. Jan. 2011 (CET""" Löschung von Grimmelshausen-Gymnasium Offenburg Wikipedia:AüS Wikipedia:Artikel über Schulen 4
14236 5416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chad Copeland (Photographer) User:Narky 09:42, 30 May 2017 (UTC) delete I could find nothing in the citations other than brief mentions or acknowledgments. A search turned up no independent coverage. I found CC's http://www.imdb.com/name/nm8495016/ IMDb entry (non-), but can see no evidence of notability in it. Fails ; and at best Deletion of Chad Copeland (Photographer) WP:RS||WP:BIO||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14237 2176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prophet Isa El-Buba User:Jack 11:43, 30 June 2020 (UTC) delete Google reveals facebook, youtube, newsletters, the odd book, and a solitary one-paragrapher about how he predicted a politician would lose an election - not a thing to indicate notability. The article itself is outrageously |promotional, bordering on |complete bollocks. |Nuke it from orbit Deletion of Prophet Isa El-Buba WP:NOTPROMO||WP:CB||WP:TNT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14238 5991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Verdo User:Bearian 20:15, 1 April 2020 (UTC) delete per , , , , and Deletion of Verdo WP:GNG||WP:MILL||WP:SIGCOV||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
14239 3398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Burkett (cricketer) User:Reyk 16:17, 19 January 2021 (UTC) delete doesn't meet the . A rebuttable presumption of notability isn't an exemption from sourcing requirements, no matter what some would have us believe Deletion of Michael Burkett (cricketer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14240 20048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional characters on the autism spectrum User:Jfgslo 05:24, 15 October 2011 (UTC) delete As |notability guidelines apply to the inclusion of stand-alone lists, and the subject of this one, a list of fictional characters identified with conditions in the autism spectrum, has not been discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources in the way in which the article presents them, so I do not believe that the topic of the list meets the |general notability guideline. More importantly, I believe that this list goes against |Wikipedia is not a directory and |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information since the inclusion criteria is not unambiguous because it includes notable characters with articles with non-notable characters that have a single appearance in a show and do not have articles, character which may or may not have autism, and the majority of the notable listed characters are not notable for their autistic conditions, so I do not think that it is an appropriate list-topic per the criteria of |appropriate topics for lists since it falls into what WP:!|what Wikipedia is not. I believe that the cited sources do not show a list which has the same criteria as the one in the article and they are more apt for an article about depictions of autism in popular culture, not for a list of non-notable fictional characters that may or may not be notable by their condition Deletion of List of fictional characters on the autism spectrum WP:LISTN||WP:GNG||WP:NOTDIR||WP:IINFO||WP:SALAT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14241 11930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cypress Woods High School User:Coredesat 07:02, 4 August 2006 (UTC) delete the school apparently has not opened yet, and there is absolutely no assertion of notability. Fails |verifiability policy for being contradictory (established in 2005, opens in 2006?). |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of crystal balls or information Deletion of Cypress Woods High School WP:V||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14242 15940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tallest buildings in Rockhampton User:Bearian 17:07, 26 November 2014 (UTC) delete per , and per past outcomes Deletion of List of tallest buildings in Rockhampton WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
14243 8396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Metoogle User:Zero 00:17, 21 May 2006 (UTC) delete per nom; sounds like to me. &mdash Deletion of Metoogle WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
14244 17445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valence Mike User:Kevin 18:35, 18 February 2007 (UTC) delete I'm reluctant to support a nomination which is based on the nominator's subjective opinion, but I would expect to see more chatter on the web about a notable contemporary musician. The one independent references does not seem significant enough to meet standards, and I don't see it as being likely that more will be found Deletion of Valence Mike WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14245 15099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Motorcycle oil User:Tedder 00:25, 31 December 2009 (UTC) keep I disagree, dbratland. There are |reliable sources discussing this and talking about the difference between motorcycle and automotive oils. That's a sufficient reason to keep- because there is a difference. It |may need to be rewritten, but not completely deleted Deletion of Motorcycle oil WP:RS||WP:UGLY Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14246 4480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Céline Bethmann User:K 21:15, 17 June 2017 (UTC) merge to Germany's Next Topmodel (cycle 12). A plausible search term, but it's (per available sources) for a stand-alone article. Not notable independent of the show, hence the redirect Deletion of Céline Bethmann WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
14247 7490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victoria Talwar User:Russ 17:51, 22 January 2020 (UTC) comment As far as C3 goes, she is also a fellow of the Association for Psychological Science and of the https://rsc-src.ca/en/fellows Royal Society of Canada. The citation record looks like an easy pass of C1. The only thing that stops me from an immediate keep !vote is that it looks like her most highly-cited papers are coauthored with her former PhD advisor. Otherwise, she looks notable, nothing borderline about it Deletion of Victoria Talwar WP:NPROF||WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14248 12652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jan Oltmanns User:K 02:27, 16 November 2017 (UTC) delete does not meet and looks like a tribute page Deletion of Jan Oltmanns WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14249 6739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Catherine Winchester User:Stuartyeates 21:28, 2 December 2011 (UTC) delete as per lack of Deletion of Catherine Winchester WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14250 1749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/POLICE PISTOLCRAFT User:Pohta 17:38, 12 February 2010 (UTC) delete """Two book reviews have been added, but only one might qualify as http://www.officer.com/web/online/POSA/Police-Pistolcraft-Book-Review/30$48147 officer.com, the other is forum/blog post without a byline http://connect.lawofficer.com/group/firearmsinstructors/forum/topics/a-report-on-michael-e-contis. The editorial policy of officer.com is unclear as well (no """"about us"""" link on their page that I can find, only how you can advertise with them). They also take user-submitted news stories. This could well be one or be an advertorial""" Deletion of POLICE PISTOLCRAFT WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14251 2523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fabian Benko User:Hallward 21:11, 11 February 2016 (UTC) delete In my view, this fails fairly easily. I am particularly persuaded by the responses of Fenix and Ravenswing to Görlitz's claims to the contrary Deletion of Fabian Benko WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14252 4239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marugoto Anjyu Gakuen User:Dream 21:58, 11 February 2009 (UTC) keep Google its name and get 41,700 hits. I value the community over that of the opinions of reviewers, and of course not being officially released in English yet, and the fact that those you consider notable media do not review manga, means you can't really get a fair coverage of it. Even those sites that do review manga, don't do it for all types out there. But if this many people talk about it, clearly its worth noting. Remember, the polices are just suggestions, everything decided by consensus. Read: Deletion of Marugoto Anjyu Gakuen WP:BURO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14253 8123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zsolt Turi User:EricEnfermero 04:32, 29 March 2015 (UTC) delete """Non-notable postdoctoral fellow. I took out the bit about his """"professional striping"""" and considered that this might have been set up as a hoax or an attack page, but that's the only issue I can see""" Deletion of Zsolt Turi WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
14254 19342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quillan Roberts User:Nfitz 18:14, 10 January 2014 (UTC) keep Roberts easily meets with national media coverage. For example http://www.theglobeandmail.com/sports/soccer/toronto-fc-promotes-teenage-goalie-quillan-roberts/article4099252/ which is a long feature article on him, from almost 2 years ago, in Canada's largest mainstream national newspaper; the article was from Canada Press, and was carried that day in many large local and regional papers across the nation. There's other mainstream articles such as http://www.torontosun.com/2012/04/09/source-tfc-signs-brampton-teen-roberts http://www.citynews.ca/2012/04/09/toronto-fc-signs-bramptons-quillan-roberts/. Previously had received international media attention for a stunning goal (Roberts is a keeper) he scored against England in a U-17 World Cup match http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/watch-canadian-goalkeeper-score-amazing-2462520 http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-2007173/England-U17-draw-Canada-freak-goal.html http://digitaljournal.com/article/308309 http://www.theglobeandmail.com/sports/soccer/canadian-goalkeeper-makes-history-with-goal-at-u-17-world-cup/article584267/ http://www.citynews.ca/2011/06/23/cdn-goalkeeper-scores-goal-at-u-17-world-cup/ http://www.thestar.com/sports/soccer/2011/06/23/video_canadian_goalkeeper_scores_miracle_goal_at_under17_world_cup.html. I admit that media coverage for much of the last 2 years hasn't been met but older coverage does. And I ask you ... can you name an MLS player who has sat on the bench for more league matches, and doesn't have a minute of playing time Deletion of Quillan Roberts WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14255 21451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sinem Yalçındağ User:Smartyllama 13:40, 7 August 2017 (UTC) keep Passes per above. Clearly nominator didn't do any as evidenced by his mass AfD's and PRODs all within a very short timespan. Maybe it's time we take this to {WP:ANI? It's getting out of hand Deletion of Sinem Yalçındağ WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14256 12241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CFD-Wiki User:Adrian 23:23, 1 March 2006 (UTC) delete as |non-notable website Deletion of CFD-Wiki WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14257 20670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Configure One (2nd nomination) User:Sandals1 15:52, 28 December 2017 (UTC) delete It's highly questionable that the Illinois Business Daily article is significant and independent coverage. Even if it is, that's only one source and not enough to meet or Deletion of Configure One (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14258 7335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamez User:W 04:30, 5 November 2005 (UTC) delete seems to fail usic. (Vermont has a ghetto Deletion of Jamez WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
14259 12858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Clement User:Number 21:41, 17 January 2013 (UTC) delete per failure Deletion of Jordan Clement WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
14260 11706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acharya S (3rd nomination) User:Aelffin 18:26, 29 December 2009 (UTC) keep Though she's fringy and restricted to a cult following, she ''has'' been discussed at length in a number of |reliable sources--this in itself establishes |notability. Since ''Acharya S'' appears to be the name under which she is most commonly discussed, D.M. Murdock should be merged and redirected here Deletion of Acharya S (3rd nomination) WP:RS||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14261 18803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nokia E70 User:Mikeblas 02:39, 8 January 2008 (UTC) comment """While """"the world having noticed it"""" might meet ''your'' definition of notable, it doesn't not meet |Wikipedia's definition of notability for commercial products""" Deletion of Nokia E70 WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14262 20866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Dekay User:Bearian 14:25, 28 December 2016 (UTC) delete per above, and as |entirely lacking any real sources. I note that the image shows him performing before an audience of perhaps one hundred people. We are |not a web host such as MySpace Deletion of Matthew Dekay WP:RS||WP:NOTWEBHOST Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14263 11737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Halverson User:Papaursa 05:00, 4 December 2013 (UTC) delete Fails to meet Deletion of John Halverson WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
14264 18611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rodger Koopman User:Niteshift36 03:18, 21 June 2009 (UTC) comment I'm going to reserve judgement for now, but I'd like to point out that there might be 100 articles from local papers, but only 3 sentences in the article deal with his political office. It is almost all about his non-notable military career and non-notable business career. If anything, this needs a major re-write to demonstrate his notability. Also the article was authored by a Deletion of Rodger Koopman WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
14265 8106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 Trader Joe's Hostage Incident User:XavierItzm 08:13, 28 July 2018 (UTC) keep per . Plus, shooting of an innocent bystander by a trained professional in law enforcement. Most def a keeper Deletion of 2018 Trader Joe's Hostage Incident WP:RAPID Wikipedia:Notability 77
14266 6542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delta English School User:Kudpung 11:21, 28 January 2017 (UTC) delete preferably fast per G11 and . This is clearly intended as a promotional piece. OUTCOMES does not suggest that we have keep blatant advertising, and it would be an affront to the good will and commitment of our volunteers to rewrite it for the school however strong our dedication to the Wikipedia Deletion of Delta English School WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
14267 10084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MV Global Mercy User:BabbaQ 16:55, 4 October 2018 (UTC) keep This is not Deletion of MV Global Mercy WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
14268 8948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ivan Pervushin User:David 21:39, 15 May 2016 (UTC) keep The Russian Wikipedia article has convincing sources for (in two Russian-language print encyclopedias, but sources don't need to be in English). I also found what appears to be a journal article about him, but only by reference (I haven't found the article itself): A. E. Raik. Ural'skii matematik Ivan Mikheevich Pervushin. ''Istoriko-Matematicheskie Issledovaniya'' 6 (1953). 535-572 Deletion of Ivan Pervushin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14269 8132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Let's Swing Again User:HisSpaceResearch 20:23, 23 December 2007 (UTC) delete as violating and totally Deletion of Let's Swing Again WP:V||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14270 960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The New Andy Griffith Show User:Arxiloxos 15:10, 18 June 2014 (UTC) keep This was a separate network TV series, not a part of ''The Andy Griffith Show''. It received substantial news coverage at the time (for example, a Google search for yields results from the limited Google News archive such as http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=13glAAAAIBAJ&sjid=0vIFAAAAIBAJ&pg=2573%2C2256477http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=MIwiAAAAIBAJ&sjid=CaoFAAAAIBAJ&pg=4406%2C5224334http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=zEsaAAAAIBAJ&sjid=eSgEAAAAIBAJ&pg=7561%2C3886083http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=uoUlAAAAIBAJ&sjid=1vIFAAAAIBAJ&pg=1887%2C4294701http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=A4hQAAAAIBAJ&sjid=uhEEAAAAIBAJ&pg=2327%2C1654424), and it is covered in multiple book sources, two of which are already cited in the article. #Broadcast media and note that national network TV series are normally notable, and there's no reason this one would not be Deletion of The New Andy Griffith Show WP:OUTCOMES||WP:TVSERIES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
14271 21896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nasim Yousaf (2nd nomination) User:Guillaume2303 09:55, 29 January 2012 (UTC) delete The previous AfD was in 2006, so re-nominating it rather than speedily deleting as a re-creation is the proper procedure to follow. However, as far as I can see, this still does not meet or Deletion of Nasim Yousaf (2nd nomination) WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14272 3900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Division Street, Manhattan User:Bearian 19:41, 28 December 2007 (UTC) delete per Grutness. I know the area, and it is ''not'' |notable in any sense of the word. This is a side street. Most of the sites cited are actually ''not'' on Division Street (for example, Eldridge Street Synagogue, Seward Park (Manhattan), and Confucius Plaza are ''off'' Division Street). The other sites are just plainly not notable - no links or would-be red links. Sorry, folks, this does not cut k, the most revelant guildline/essay. Possibly redirect to Lower East Side Deletion of Division Street, Manhattan WP:N||WP:50 Wikipedia:Notability 77
14273 4922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of breweries in Connecticut User:Spinningspark 08:41, 21 January 2014 (UTC) keep per and Deletion of List of breweries in Connecticut WP:CSC Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
14274 9883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radyo Kabayan User:MSJapan 20:25, 27 June 2016 (UTC) delete Fails GNG, . CSD requested and declined. This article was (apparently) prodded, then DRVed by the creator, who is an SPA. The only edits made in two years are to this article. The article creator is , and there is a strong likelihood that he will recreate the article if it is deleted, and seems to not be interested in following policies Deletion of Radyo Kabayan WP:PROMO||WP:NOTHERE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14275 9641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noomap User:SW3 17:23, 19 June 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and . No |reliable sources. Not mentioned in any third party review or article. Looks like the article was created to generate |publicity Deletion of Noomap WP:GNG||WP:PRODUCT||WP:RS||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14276 6597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pota R Marudyan User:Ireneshih 07:39, 27 October 2014 (UTC) delete Clearly fails and notability Deletion of Pota R Marudyan WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14277 1470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dieselpunk (3rd nomination) User:Duggy 22:04, 3 June 2010 (UTC) keep """Issues with |original research, |verifiability, and |notability are best handled by editing adding tags, removing uncited/poorly cited material. If that leaves a stub or something that needs merging or deleting it can be brought up then. The claim that """"It attempts to retroactively place creative works into a genre when their creators had no intent to do so, or likely any knowledge of it"""" is confusing intent & result. If citable experts say that something was """"the beginings of"""" a genre, """"show signs of what was to become"""" a genre or are """"proto""""-genre then add them. Creators often refuse labels because they like to see themselves as unique or are too close to their own work. Deletion is not the answer, work is. If you think this article needs deletion, remove bad citation, add cite tags, remove bad content, if you think it needs keeping find better citations. Once that's been done we will be in a better position to decide what to do with it""" Deletion of Dieselpunk (3rd nomination) WP:OR||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:No original research 65
14278 20642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Weapons in Seven Samurai 20XX User:Mattbuck 19:42, 10 December 2007 (UTC) delete per #GUIDE Deletion of Weapons in Seven Samurai 20XX WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14279 2738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antoinette Clinton User:Alf 16:22, 31 January 2007 (UTC) delete unless properly sourced and referenced i.a.w. and/or Deletion of Antoinette Clinton WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14280 1043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chemistry Misconceptions User:Kinu 21:46, 9 August 2006 (UTC) delete patent , the picture may be a copyvio nope, it's just an MS Paint job Deletion of Chemistry Misconceptions WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14281 7929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Western Reserve Conference User:Lankiveil 08:07, 28 December 2013 (UTC) delete as ballery Deletion of Western Reserve Conference WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14282 21781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamilia Abdelfattah User:4meter4 02:44, 26 October 2019 (UTC) comment She appears to have established a lot of university child psychology programs at major universities in Egypt. If that can be verified, I do think she might meet criteria #4 of for her services in bringing child psychology training/studies to her nation. That's a pretty big deal Deletion of Kamilia Abdelfattah WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14283 16520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sukuracchi Kouzai User:TheFarix 17:56, 4 January 2010 (UTC) delete If not an outright then it definitely fails . Google search turms up very view hits, none of which are reliable. I'll also note that the article's created has not made any other edits beyond creating this article Deletion of Sukuracchi Kouzai WP:HOAX||WP:NFT Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
14284 12526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lantronix, Inc. User:Jmertel23 15:21, 24 September 2018 (UTC) delete WP:MILL|Run-of-the-mill company with no |independent, reliable sources. Article was declined at AfC multiple times before user simply moved to mainspace Deletion of Lantronix, Inc. WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14285 5624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alfred Sommer (aerospace engineer) User:Seattle 19:55, 25 March 2007 (UTC) delete Totally non-notable, patri-biography by son Mark Sommer. And I think it is obvious what to make of http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Del_West&action=history this and the entire Del West article, it appears to be advertising spam in violation of #G11. I've added a {{tl|db-spam}} tag to that page. It is the work of multiple single-purpose sock-puppet accounts, each named similar to the son of the company president, our own subject here (see Special:Contributions/Marksommer, Special:Contributions/Marksommer1, and Special:Contributions/Mjsommer), along with a single-purpose IP Special:Contributions/71.106.51.37. Blatant adverti-spam, with no evidence of notability or secondary sources Deletion of Alfred Sommer (aerospace engineer) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14286 19549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucy Dixon User:Sallicio 08:41, 15 February 2008 (UTC) merge into parent article, actress falls short of on her own, but still is mentionable in the parent Deletion of Lucy Dixon WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14287 19899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ravi Shankar (poet) User:B 18:58, 13 December 2006 (UTC) keep Publications reviewed by journals that have national (U.S.) reputation, editor of a national poetry journal, and commentator on a national radio network satisfy Deletion of Ravi Shankar (poet) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14288 5668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allan Dameron User:Coredesat 21:03, 23 June 2006 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Allan Dameron WP:BIO||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
14289 1275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gunners Greatest 50 Players User:Bettia 12:16, 8 January 2009 (UTC) delete An unencyclopaedic article based entirely on opinion. Although there's no doubt that these players are great, there's no set grounds given for their inclusion or ranking. It would be almost impossible to make this conform to Wikipedia standards, especially and Deletion of Gunners Greatest 50 Players WP:OR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
14290 19423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of National Football League attendance figures User:GiantSnowman 11:35, 14 September 2013 (UTC) delete clear case of Deletion of List of National Football League attendance figures WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14291 14023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dražen cerović User:HisSpaceResearch 14:47, 14 March 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Dražen cerović WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
14292 9046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jimmy Smith (martial arts fighter) User:Brewcrewer 07:35, 20 December 2007 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Jimmy Smith (martial arts fighter) WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14293 14801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DisneyMania 7 User:T 23:38, 11 June 2008 (UTC) delete odds are that an article of this name will be released in 2009 but for now Deletion of DisneyMania 7 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14294 14788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kasia Boddy User:Pburka 03:27, 8 April 2021 (UTC) keep per hroest and Deletion of Kasia Boddy WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14295 6705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tight A$ User:Rlendog 21:52, 18 December 2012 (UTC) keep """The subject passes . There are several books that cover the song in some detail, for example Blaney's ''Lennon and McCartney: together alone : a critical discography of their solo work'', du Noyer's ''John Lennon: Whatever Gets You Through the Night'', Johnny Rogan|Rogan's ''The Complete Guide to the Music of John Lennon'', Madinger and Easter's ''Eight Arms to Hold You'' and Urish and Bielen's ''The Words and Music of John Lennon''. And that's just a non-exhaustive list from books in my personal collection. Notability is determined by the availabilty of multiple published sources independent of the subject - those do not just include those available on the Internet. The nominator made similar claims about the non-notability of other Lennon songs, such as """"Meat City"""" http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Meat_City&diff=528197061&oldid=524328971 and """"Well Well Well (John Lennon song)|Well Well Well"""" http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Well_Well_Well_%28John_Lennon_song%29&diff=528198848&oldid=502136494 and those were quickly turned into decent articles. It will take some time to complete all the songs that the nominator wishes to redirect, but their notability is similar to """"Meat City"""" and """"Well Well Well (John Lennon song)|Well Well Well"""" and so should be kept. Further, contrary to the nomination, at least two of the facts in the article as it exists today are not covered in the ''Mind Games'' article: the specific instruments played (and by whom) and the fact that the song is on ''Gimme Some Truth''. It is particularly inappropriate that the nominator wishes to """"delete and redirect,"""" since deletion prior to redirecting (even if redirecting were appropriate) would unnecessarily require an editor to perform additional work to restore the information that currently when expanding the article""" Deletion of Tight A$ WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14296 50 [[EatUrMusic]] (Weiterleitung) Benutzer:Elendur NONE merge verfehlt Löschung von EatUrMusic Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
14297 5132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daytonnati User:Kieran207 23:54, 23 April 2021 (UTC) delete My BEFORE search came up with this article, a few Wikipedia mirrors, a Reddit post, a DGuide entry, the 1998 newspaper article cited here (and a similar one published one week later by the same paper), and another website that's just a copy and paste of this article. Also fails .-- Deletion of Daytonnati WP:NEO||WP:WPTC Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
14298 5702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prada and Prejudice User:Spicy 02:14, 15 July 2020 (UTC) keep """I found three other reviews on Gale: Miller, Donna L. """"Prada and Prejudice."""" Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, vol. 53, no. 6, 2010, p. 523. Gale General OneFile, https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A221600797/GPS?u=wikipedia&sid=GPS&xid=00d1cd9e. Accessed 14 July 2020. doi:10.1598/JAAL.53.6.9 Schultz, Jennifer. """"Hubbard, Mandy. Prada & Prejudice."""" School Library Journal, vol. 55, no. 7, July 2009, p. 85. Gale In Context: Biography, https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A203954504/GPS?u=wikipedia&sid=GPS&xid=c6296d7a. Accessed 14 July 2020.Cooper, Ilene. """"Prada & Prejudice."""" Booklist, vol. 105, no. 18, 15 May 2009, p. 53. Gale In Context: Biography, https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A200916077/GPS?u=wikipedia&sid=GPS&xid=58544196. Accessed 14 July 2020. The reviews are fairly brief, but I think there is just about enough here to pass """ Deletion of Prada and Prejudice WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
14299 19075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Am Boleyn (musician) User:scope_creep 11:49, 22 November 2019 (UTC) comment Her stuff is already being heavily remixed for the club circuit, so there is quite a strong awareness of her music. There is no coverage so it is all underground. I agree, I don't think it will be long before she is huge. Deletion of I Am Boleyn (musician) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
14300 5809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Egyptian Pong User:Satori 14:13, 11 December 2008 (UTC) delete """per : ''""""If no reliable, third-party sources can be found for an article topic, Wikipedia should not have an article on it""" Deletion of Egyptian Pong WP:VERIFY Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14301 811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asklepios (manga) User:Themfromspace 22:09, 26 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails the |general notability guidelines. No in-depth coverage in 3rd party reliable sources can be found Deletion of Asklepios (manga) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14302 16802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/100s BC (disambiguation) User:power 01:47, 24 October 2018 (UTC) delete per nom; clear Deletion of 100s BC (disambiguation) WP:TWODABS Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
14303 16418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Mary's Orthodox Church, Avaneeswaram User:DBigXray NONE merge with Avaneeswaram which is a small village where this non notable church is located. The Church itself fails due to lack of detailed coverage or . So the stand alone article for this church without is not feasible Deletion of St. Mary's Orthodox Church, Avaneeswaram WP:NBUILD||WP:GNG||WP:SOAPBOXING Wikipedia:Notability 77
14304 2653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Meyer (American football official) User:Paulmcdonald 15:12, 2 October 2012 (UTC) comment for now. I don't think he's notable with his career as an NFL official because... well... there just aren't articles written about officials by name. I'm confident that the guideline does not extend to officials. However, he MIGHT be notable through other means, such as his college baseball career if there was significant coverage Deletion of Greg Meyer (American football official) WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
14305 11461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparisation of alternative ICE fuels User:Martin 19:55, 19 September 2009 (UTC) delete I agree with NTK. As it is written, the entire basis for the article (comparison) is Deletion of Comparisation of alternative ICE fuels WP:SYNTHESIS Wikipedia:No original research 65
14306 17457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Aleksander User:Bolivian 19:14, 27 April 2007 (UTC) keep assuming that version can be rescued from deleted history; if not, delete under #G11 Deletion of Adam Aleksander WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14307 13553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Lego Movie User:JPG 05:55, 22 December 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Deletion of The Lego Movie WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14308 18519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CMS Station Brokerage User:SW3 16:15, 19 June 2014 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails ompany. Fails Deletion of CMS Station Brokerage WP:C||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
14309 2 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian's Indie User:MisterHand 16:47, 15 January 2006 (UTC) delete nn and apparent |vanity Deletion of Ian's Indie WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14310 4902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giga-Tube NONE 13:09, 24 September 2011 (UTC) delete Lacks to satisfy . Happy Editing! — '''{{User|70.21.12.213 Deletion of Giga-Tube WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14311 19140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blessed Virgin Mary (Roman Catholic) User:Malke 11:35, 4 December 2010 (UTC) comment Blessed Virgin Mary (Roman Catholic) is not just a content fork, it's also a POV content fork. Veneration of Mary should take a paragraph, not two dozen articles all saying the exact same thing. And always with St. Louis de Montfort and his True Devotions. And everything is cited with trivial citations from Google book previews. Wikipedia policy states that |redundant content forks are inappropriate and should be deleted. Also, the wider community consensus supports this policy and that takes precedence over the consensus generated by a small group of editors at one point in time Deletion of Blessed Virgin Mary (Roman Catholic) WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
14312 16324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/References to imps in popular culture User:Yllosubmarine 12:35, 24 July 2007 (UTC) delete """as unreferenced, loosely connected, indiscriminate trivia. Most of the """"pop culture"""" is apparently from video games and can be summed up in the main article as """"Imps often appear in video games."""" There is no need to violate #INFO with such encyclopedic material""" Deletion of References to imps in popular culture WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14313 15553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LION (Band) User:MidwestSalamander 14:30, 13 April 2019 (UTC) delete for now per , move the article to a draft to be expanded and posted again at a later time, if the creator is interested. Of the sources named above, only the ''Independent'' and ''Lock Magazine'' articles are hefty enough to help prove . The others look negligible, in some cases only show announcements Deletion of LION (Band) WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
14314 1757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tombola (raffle) User:Bejnar 05:31, 9 December 2015 (UTC) merge to Bingo if we are talking about the content of the Italian article. The UK raffle lacks coverage and hence lacks notability, fails Deletion of Tombola (raffle) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14315 7837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Admission to an event or establishment User:Roodog2k 18:46, 15 March 2013 (UTC) delete WP:COATRACK. You see it now, since the article has a lot of talk about discrimination and being DENIED admission... take out the talk about discrimination/denial... and you have a dicdef and or a This is a no brainer. Delete Deletion of Admission to an event or establishment WP:ESSAY Wikipedia:Essays 31
14316 4909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Official Association of Professional Table Tennis Athletes of North America (2nd nomination) User:Cewbot 00:02, 16 January 2021 (UTC) comment While this discussion appears to have |no quorum, it is '''NOT eligible for |soft deletion''' because it was Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Official Association of Professional Table Tennis Athletes of North America|previously discussed at AfD and the result was no consensus Deletion of Official Association of Professional Table Tennis Athletes of North America (2nd nomination) WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
14317 495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007 TTC subway murder User:Mhking 22:14, 21 April 2007 (UTC) delete violates Deletion of 2007 TTC subway murder WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14318 2712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of animated feature films submitted for the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film User:Erik 21:04, 21 June 2017 (UTC) delete per ; this rather specific cross-categorization does not seem to be discussed or listed outside Wikipedia Deletion of List of animated feature films submitted for the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film WP:NOTESAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14319 12690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2034 FIFA World Cup User:Smartyllama 17:59, 24 May 2018 (UTC) keep WP:SNOWBALL is not a valid deletion rationale. Assuming nom meant , it still doesn't apply because there is ample information available Deletion of 2034 FIFA World Cup WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14320 3774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chantal Wiertz User:Bri 10:28, 10 February 2021 (UTC) delete as , no inherent notability attached to beauty contests Deletion of Chantal Wiertz WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
14321 3230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CHICKENMAN User:Kinu 21:44, 15 December 2006 (UTC) delete WP:NOT a memorial, does not otherwise meet based on Deletion of CHICKENMAN WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14322 15090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noridasu User:MER 04:55, 29 November 2006 (UTC) delete per above and Deletion of Noridasu WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14323 19084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antisemitism in early Christianity User:IZAK 04:03, 5 August 2013 (UTC) keep """since this albeit shortish article (as it stands now, but will hopefully be improved soon) that, reflecting a core of a topic is that it has been around for '''six''' years now http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Antisemitism_in_early_Christianity&dir=prev&action=history (WP must take the length of its own existence seriously!) and it does a few good . This is serious topic in and of itself that deserves at """"worst"""" a Template {{tl|Expand""" Deletion of Antisemitism in early Christianity WP:CONSENSUS||WP:NOTABLE||WP:CITE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Consensus 78
14324 10981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Three-Way Automotive Group User:SkierRMH 08:32, 16 December 2006 (UTC) delete all per and spam. No merge, parent company/merge still isn't notable Deletion of Three-Way Automotive Group WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14325 15683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aozora Bunko: A User:Anturiaethwr 18:25, 30 April 2008 (UTC) delete per nom, and because there are probably no possible third-party sources for this list. isn't a criterion for deletion, but it certainly applies in this case Deletion of Aozora Bunko: A WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14326 1076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phone Call to Putin (3rd nomination) User:Neurolysis 04:03, 19 January 2009 (UTC) merge into Human rights in Russia. Per the title is a non-notable neologism and hence the content should be merged. On a procedural note, it was inappropriate for Deletion of Phone Call to Putin (3rd nomination) WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
14327 12307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artjom Dmitrijev User:GiantSnowman 13:11, 22 March 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Artjom Dmitrijev WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14328 14277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antichrist (film) User:Gene93k 10:48, 26 August 2008 (UTC) delete per . According to semi-reliable/unreliable sources, this film is lining up its cast as of August 2008. The article is near-copyvio of the IMDb entry anyway. No loss for creating a proper article when the film is shot Deletion of Antichrist (film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14329 13614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coco Eco User:Ubiquity 16:08, 19 August 2016 (UTC) delete I removed a reference to the magazine's homepage, which was not independent anyway, but also turned out to be a dead link, and a second reference to a page which did not mention the magazine. With those meagre references gone, the article has absolutely no |verififiability. The editor, Anna Griffin, appeared to be notable because her name was wikilinked, but I removed this too because it linked to Anna Griffin|a completely unrelated fictional character. What remains is an article that has absolutely no legitimate assertion of |notability Deletion of Coco Eco WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14330 2432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hellshire Hills User:SportingFlyer 07:16, 18 December 2018 (UTC) keep Appears in local news articles, easily passes Deletion of Hellshire Hills WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14331 13712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dark Angels (Warhammer 40,000) User:A 03:05, 17 July 2008 (UTC) delete """Fan cruft (extra bit to annoy Le Roi: CRUFTcruft''cruft''cruftcruftcruuuuuuuuft) of the most useless sort. GW periodically introduces variations on their armies for their games, to justify selling books that amount to game advantages for painting models a certain color. Nobody but WH40K fans really cares about this, most WH40K fans don't care about the paper-thin setting justifications, and, most importantly, nobody's seen fit to comment on any of these in reliable sources of any sort. (In before useless links to essays or """" is totally disputed! Seriously guys""" Deletion of Dark Angels (Warhammer 40,000) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14332 2809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crocker Highlands Elementary School User:DoubleBlue 04:49, 2 March 2008 (UTC) keep Enough reliable sources to establish a |verifiable, |NPOV, |NOR article, which are the inclusion requirements Deletion of Crocker Highlands Elementary School WP:V||WP:NPOV||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14333 20322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Advent Technologies User:scope_creep 09:06, 6 November 2020 (UTC) delete References are a mix of profile pages (the majority), churnalism, and business news. How could it be possible for it to be accepted at Afc in that state? Fails , , Deletion of Advent Technologies WP:MILL||WP:ORGIND||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:SIRS Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
14334 9185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Makan Dembélé User:Mattythewhite 01:54, 6 January 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Makan Dembélé WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14335 15012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Happy-clappy User:Keahapana 18:38, 31 December 2010 (UTC) comment """We can all agree on . It's true that Google Scholar counts aren't research, but they are a common metric for notability. It's false that happy-clappy is only adjectival. The ''OED'' gives, '''happy-clappy''' ''n''. and ''a''. ''colloq''. (''joc''. or mildly ''derog''.), """"A. ''n.'' A member of a Christian charismatic group. B. ''attrib''. passing into ''adj''. Of or pertaining to such a group."""" ''My Traitor's Heart'' has the earliest recorded noun usage, """"Both were members of the Apostolic Church, happyclappies in South African slang — into the laying on of hands, faith healing, and speaking in tongues""" Deletion of Happy-clappy WP:NOTDIC Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
14336 9899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Morris Waxler (2nd nomination) User:Eric 20:04, 27 October 2013 (UTC) comment Maybe I am missing something here, but the subject seems to be a researcher with a legitimate record http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=Morris+Waxler. I'm not sure it is enough to pass though: h-index=8, most cited pub with 164 cites. I don't think the advocacy is grounds for deletion Deletion of Morris Waxler (2nd nomination) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14337 11613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timeline of popular Internet services User:Lemongirl942 13:01, 23 September 2016 (UTC) delete """per #OR. This is patent original research. There is no way to decide what is """"popular"""" without a bit lot of OR. I see this list as totally unencyclopeadic and considering that the information already exists in other forms, I will go with a delete. No point in wasting time to find out a criteria for inclusion""" Deletion of Timeline of popular Internet services WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14338 16535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Philadelphia Eagles - New York Giants game User:Daniel 01:12, 20 December 2010 (UTC) keep for now but '''rename''', as the Giants and Eagles played two games this year. |Recentism notwithstanding, I think that there's a good chance this game may be remembered enough to warrant its own article. It's true there are a lot of fourth-quarter comebacks. It's not true that many involve scoring four touchdowns in the ''last half'' of the fourth quarter (I had last glanced at the game when Kevin Boss made his big catch and really thought the Giants had this one in the bag) to overcome a 21-point deficit. It's as true of the original The Miracle at the Meadowlands|Miracle at the Meadowlands that it was won on an improbable play involving a fumble in the last 30 seconds. It's also the continuation of a sports rivalry that has seen a number of other amazing late-game reversals in a new stadium. To nominate this one for deletion within hours of it being over is, to me, the equivalent of nominating September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks for deletion that evening on the grounds that they weren't more notable than other terrorist attacks. notwithstanding, sometimes |we just ''know'' things will be notable before they acquire it through our usual criteria Deletion of 2010 Philadelphia Eagles - New York Giants game WP:RECENT||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:IAR Wikipedia:Recentism 10
14339 6155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Horace Knapp User:Hydronium 10:59, 11 December 2015 (UTC) delete this and Purdy Schoolhouse. While Knapp founded Purdy, it's relatively small (1544 people for the CDP as of the 2010 census), he doesn't meet , nor does he meet any of the other criteria at . I've edited Purdy, Washington to fold in relevant info (except for the section about the road to Gig Harbour, which I've inserted but commented out given the lack of reliable source and tone) and add a couple of sources, though it's still not in good shape Deletion of Horace Knapp WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14340 2286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jorge Gotor Blas User:GiantSnowman 17:50, 27 April 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Jorge Gotor Blas WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14341 12104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Enough Rope with Andrew Denton guests in 2006 User:Belinrahs 02:25, 19 November 2009 (UTC) delete per Abductive. Fails Deletion of List of Enough Rope with Andrew Denton guests in 2006 WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14342 1303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jibber Skabing User:Beano 23:15, 25 October 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and . I honestly would not have any objection if someone |G1'd this article Deletion of Jibber Skabing WP:N||WP:CS||WP:PN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14343 5758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samurai Aerobics User:Nihonjoe 08:22, 19 February 2010 (UTC) delete as completely-not-even-close-to-notable. The book it's based on isn't notable, and neither is the author of the book. This article fails to meet on every level Deletion of Samurai Aerobics WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14344 7138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cristy Coors Beasley User:Gongshow 07:03, 2 November 2014 (UTC) delete roles to date do not appear to meet , and I'm unable to find coverage in independent reliable sources to show that subject meets Deletion of Cristy Coors Beasley WP:ENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14345 4294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oh my actual god User:Coredesat 21:49, 27 June 2006 (UTC) delete nonsense, fails Deletion of Oh my actual god WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
14346 4337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Counter-Strike Online User:Gavin 08:40, 15 October 2007 (UTC) delete Single sentence stub and lack of |secondary sources means this article fails to demonstrate |notability Deletion of Counter-Strike Online WP:V||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14347 1944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henry Evans Maude User:David 06:49, 1 December 2008 (UTC) keep Two books about him seems enough for Deletion of Henry Evans Maude WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14348 387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Heath (footballer) User:Peter 17:01, 7 December 2020 (UTC) keep It's better to have a complete set of articles here for than maintain a complete set on another site and a separate incomplete set here. Subject-specific guidelines are more important than as a reason to delete an article, there's no reason to say they shouldn't be as a reason to keep an article Deletion of Nick Heath (footballer) WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14349 17924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Wilhelmsen User:Jkudlick 02:01, 28 March 2016 (UTC) delete Subject fails – I cannot find a single |reliable source. Regional League Division 2 is not on the list of |fully-professional leagues and subject has not played senior international football, so is also failed. — Deletion of David Wilhelmsen WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:FPL||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
14350 2537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC Fight Night 12 (2nd nomination) user:east718 NONE keep Unlike last time, there is |verifiable information about a confirmed date and matchup from a |reliable source (Dann Stupp is an expert in the field, and a sportswriter for Yahoo! Sports, the Dayton Daily News, MLB.com, and the San Francisco Chronicle). doesn't apply anymore since the event is notable and guaranteed to take place Deletion of UFC Fight Night 12 (2nd nomination) WP:V||WP:RS||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14351 19142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Synagogue shooting User:Icewhiz 14:46, 11 November 2018 (UTC) keep but rename to List of synagogue shooting (or perhaps - a more widely scoped attacks). Meets Deletion of Synagogue shooting WP:CSC Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
14352 16065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plonker User:Sp33dyphil 07:43, 22 August 2011 (UTC) delete per . Now what is this? Will each and every slang word receive an article? I don't think so Deletion of Plonker WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
14353 8308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Sailor Moon actors [[User Talk:Blaxthos|t]] / [[Special:Contributions/Blaxthos|c]] ) 03:01, 11 April 2008 (UTC) delete as duplicitous list|cruft. USER:Blaxthos|Blaxthos Deletion of List of Sailor Moon actors WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
14354 394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Barnett [[User talk:Jhall1|talk page]]) 09:49, 18 March 2011 (UTC) keep comfortably meets notability requirements of and . JH Deletion of Alex Barnett WP:ATHLETE||WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14355 10067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael E. Arth (2nd nomination) User:XOR 19:48, 12 November 2019 (UTC) delete per . It's possible that enough reviews could be scraped together to make a wiki-notability case for ''something'' in this walled garden, but even in that hypothetical case, writing non-promotional material would require starting from scratch Deletion of Michael E. Arth (2nd nomination) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
14356 10251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Interact Club of Hindu College Colombo User:Snotbot 17:21, 26 January 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 January 26 Deletion of Interact Club of Hindu College Colombo WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14357 12340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phil Rock User:Bearian NONE delete The lead appears to claim that he invented the ATM. In fact, he merely owns an independent ATM company. Even if he were the first one, that is |not a notable achievement Deletion of Phil Rock WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14358 15520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evandro de Carvalho Brandão User:Alexf 14:25, 29 September 2007 (UTC) delete per . Non-notable Deletion of Evandro de Carvalho Brandão WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14359 16132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hatable User:Northamerica1000 13:49, 30 March 2015 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Hatable WP:NOTDIC Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
14360 7744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DBC (hip hop) [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']][[User talk:(aeropagitica)|''' (talk) ''']] 10:26, 26 May 2006 (UTC) delete as a {{tl|hoax}} unless sources can be cited and notability proven under or usic Deletion of DBC (hip hop) WP:BIO||WP:M Wikipedia:Notability 77
14361 16374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fastest-selling products User:Northamerica1000 12:01, 27 December 2012 (UTC) keep Because this article has a well-defined criteria for its content located in its lead section, and also keep Deletion of List of fastest-selling products WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
14362 19525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kunt and the Gang (band) (2nd nomination) User:Michig 06:33, 6 June 2009 (UTC) comment """If anyone comes here arguing that the band's name is offensive, or that the article is """" a magnet for self-promotion"""", that is going to be ignored by any decent closing admin. There is plenty of coverage to pass , and easily criterion 1""" Deletion of Kunt and the Gang (band) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14363 1965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saint-Germain-des-Prés Café User:Stuartyeates 22:56, 10 September 2011 (UTC) delete as failing alternatively '''Merge&redirect''' and tag as needing references Deletion of Saint-Germain-des-Prés Café WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14364 8325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virtuaroid User:Haipa 14:55, 1 June 2009 (UTC) delete and '''redirect'''. Plausible search term, but little more than a violation of #PLOT, never mind Deletion of Virtuaroid WP:NOT||WP:V Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14365 1052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DOGMA (1994 film) User:Tokyogirl79 16:51, 26 August 2012 (UTC) delete This is one of many potentially COI articles created to form a walled garden around the director. A search brings up no reliable and independent sources to show that this film is notable. Now even if River Phoenix were to star in the film, having a notable person in the film does not guarantee that the film will be notable. (Plus there's concerns over it being a hoax, although even if it's not one source is not enough to keep the article.) In any case, this just isn't notable in the slightest. It fails by a mile Deletion of DOGMA (1994 film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
14366 8352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Channel One Cup (football) User:Boguslavmandzyuk 00:59, 29 November 2013 (UTC) keep """This tournament had a lot of media coverage in Russia and Ukraine as well as other former Soviet states. I am always baffled when people with no knowledge in certain topics will take it upon themselves to rid Wikipedia of articles that don't matter to them just because they never heard of them. This nomination for deletion is a just another example of ias, because certain editors only want to present the """"Anglophone Wikipedian's version of the world""" Deletion of Channel One Cup (football) WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
14367 4164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Náttfari User:הסרפד 23:09, 13 June 2014 (UTC) keep while the nominator isn't merely asking that the article be cleaned up, but is actually doubting its authenticity, applies; the legend of Náttfari appears in hundreds of source after one Google search (for an accessible source, see this http://books.google.com/books?id=I1ugAAAAMAAJ&pg=PA255 1911 book Deletion of Náttfari WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14368 19783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss Universe country rankings User:Kraxler 17:59, 8 August 2015 (UTC) delete unnecessary Deletion of Miss Universe country rankings WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
14369 19182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magic in Negima (2nd nomination) [[User talk:76.116.247.15|talk]]) 13:46, 28 March 2009 (UTC) keep Per and . Special:Contributions/76.116.247.15|76.116.247.15 Deletion of Magic in Negima (2nd nomination) WP:NOTAGAIN||WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14370 8458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J. Allen Carnes User:GPL93 14:58, 19 March 2019 (UTC) delete Clearly fails and . Best Deletion of J. Allen Carnes WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14371 12647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sebastian Plewinski User:JohnCD 19:50, 29 January 2009 (UTC) delete per above. Also, the username of author {{user1|Management artists}}, the nature of the article, and repeated removal of the AfD template by Polish-registered IPs with no other edits, suggest a promotional agenda and a possible |COI. That's not itself reason for deletion, but it causes one to look extra hard at the evidence for notability, and I don't think this reaches the standard required by #Criteria for musicians and ensembles Deletion of Sebastian Plewinski WP:COI||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14372 12220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandra Rujević User:Hmlarson 03:41, 30 July 2017 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Sandra Rujević WP:NBADMINTON Wikipedia:Notability 77
14373 21145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dipali Goenka User:GN 16:40, 11 February 2019 (UTC) delete Obvious fail of Deletion of Dipali Goenka WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14374 3226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D. W. MacKenzie User:Nsk92 16:58, 31 May 2010 (UTC) delete No evidence of passing . Scant citability, no significant academic awards mentioned, no journal editorships and nothing else in the record to show satisfying Deletion of D. W. MacKenzie WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14375 3386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tina Jung User:Bearcat 23:37, 18 July 2017 (UTC) delete An actress does not get an automatic free pass over just because she's had a role — her role in ''Kim's Convenience (TV series)|Kim's Convenience'' was a minor guest appearance in two episodes, not a main character, and we have no way to know whether she's playing a major or minor character in ''Jigsaw'' since the casting has been announced but the plot and characters aren't known at all yet. For an actress to be considered notable just for having had roles, she has to be the ''subject'' of enough |reliable source coverage to clear — but exactly ''zero'' reliable sources about her are being shown here, since the sourcing consists of her IMDb profile, an alumni profile on the website of her own alma mater, and a casting announcement for ''Jigsaw'' which just namechecks her existence while failing to contain even one word of content about her besides her name. This is not the kind of sourcing that it takes to get an actress into Wikipedia. No prejudice against recreation if and when the sourcing can be improved Deletion of Tina Jung WP:NACTOR||WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14376 11144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LearnAlberta.ca User:Bearcat 17:06, 11 August 2017 (UTC) delete Digital repositories, even if they're operated by a provincial government, are not granted an automatic presumption of notability just because they exist — they would need to be the ''subject'' of enough |reliable source coverage in media to clear , but none is being shown here at all and I can't locate any either Deletion of LearnAlberta.ca WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14377 20714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Days Of Rae User:Res2216firestar 02:24, 6 October 2008 (UTC) delete Per above; Also Deletion of Days Of Rae WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14378 21807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melanie Novis User:Panyd 23:37, 5 March 2010 (UTC) keep I've stubbified the article and added sources. It looks like she just about meets Deletion of Melanie Novis WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14379 3103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Astriga Film Industry User:Schuym1 19:39, 14 December 2008 (UTC) delete No chance of passing Deletion of Astriga Film Industry WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14380 2110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rum Babas User:SorryGuy 02:38, 10 February 2008 (UTC) delete Some references that are non-reliable and can not be cited exist, which leads me to believe that this is not a hoax. However, if you look at the ARIA list of award nominations (http://www.ariaawards.com.au/history-by-award.php?awardID=15), you can see that for 1990 and 1991 the list of nominees is not present, only the winners are listed. So while I think it is possible that the band meets , with no references present, it definitely does not meet , unless someone has an old newspaper or such Deletion of Rum Babas WP:MUSIC||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
14381 4811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dirk Bezemer user:Hannes 20:52, 3 July 2019 (UTC) keep clearly relevant according to #C1 with 4 publications with > 100 citations. But I agree, the article needs some work Deletion of Dirk Bezemer WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14382 14118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alvin Singh (activist) User:Tchaliburton 03:19, 4 August 2014 (UTC) delete Reads like a CV and fails . Simply nothing notable here Deletion of Alvin Singh (activist) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14383 12493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zülow User:Dhartung 06:43, 7 October 2007 (UTC) keep per , real place. http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z%C3%BClow de wiki Deletion of Zülow WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
14384 18832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Young vampires chronicles of the hunters User:Tokyogirl79 05:33, 2 July 2014 (UTC) delete I can't find anything to show that this book is ultimately notable. It looks like this is https://twitter.com/robert_desilva/status/426433145739542529 the author creating his own page, so I've pointed him towards our policy Deletion of Young vampires chronicles of the hunters WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14385 6762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Viktor Vidović User:GregorB NONE keep Both the ''Nacional'' source given above (now included in the article) and the search at http://www.concoursgeneve.ch/index.php/en/the-prizewinners.html confirm that he won the guitar 1st prize in the 1988 Geneva International Music Competition. Arguably this means that the article meets #9. —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Viktor Vidović WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14386 10064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asif Abbasov User:GiantSnowman 21:08, 14 January 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Asif Abbasov WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14387 3245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Haggerty & The Wanted User:Jayden54 14:27, 4 January 2007 (UTC) delete not notable per Deletion of Steve Haggerty & The Wanted WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14388 21435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Overclock.net User:Witchfire 08:12, 25 January 2007 (UTC) keep """Notability has been established multiple times throughout this discussion, via webpage hits, mentions in mass publications, multiple sources of sponsorship, and a verifiable large member base. By Wiki's own criteria in notability has been established. Quote: """"1. The content itself has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself."""" Unquote. Maxim Magazine and The Chicago Tribune cover that handily. Also, having hosted segments for Tech TV multiple times should establish notability, seeing as Tech TV is considered 'notable' enough to have an existing entry in Wikipedia""" Deletion of Overclock.net WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14389 17219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dimitar Hristov User:Mdtemp 18:00, 30 April 2013 (UTC) delete Doesn't seem to meet specific notability criteria and lacks the sources to meet Deletion of Dimitar Hristov WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14390 14648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adobe Distiller User:David 18:31, 17 August 2013 (UTC) keep The article as nominated was poorly sourced, but I've cleaned that up and I believe it should now be clear that it passes . Although obsolete now, this should be irrelevant for notability as Andy Dingley has already noted. I don't think the proposed merge to the parent Acrobat article would be helpful (and in any case AfD is not for proposing merges): that article is already clogged with version history and lists of components, and doesn't really cover any of those components in any depth Deletion of Adobe Distiller WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14391 8370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dalia Danish User:Youreallycan 21:40, 30 December 2012 (UTC) delete Spamish - extremely low wiki notability - I am sure she is important to some but En Wikipedia's objective is to imform and publish reliably referenced content about otable things, places and people and not here to ''promote'' people - regards Deletion of Dalia Danish WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14392 19307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flint Dille User:Robofish 01:18, 14 February 2011 (UTC) delete doesn't seem to pass . While he's been involved in plenty of notable franchises, he doesn't appear to be notable himself Deletion of Flint Dille WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14393 15278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bobby Hill (King of the Hill) User:Carrite 15:46, 8 October 2014 (UTC) comment """Close call. Certainly not a public icon on the scale of Bart Simpson, but the case can be made that this is a lesser icon worthy of encyclopedic coverage rather than a typical in-universe character. Needs massive editing, such characters should not be treated as """"real"""" biographical subjects. I'm almost persuaded that is the best approach here""" Deletion of Bobby Hill (King of the Hill) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
14394 9397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Panikera User:Gene93k 15:44, 23 December 2015 (UTC) keep References added since nomination confirm this village satisfies . Human settlements are considered notable regardless of size per editor consensus, and this one has about 1,110 people.http://www.censusindia.gov.in/pca/SearchDetails.aspx?Id=614348 Deletion of Panikera WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14395 3761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesús Joaquín Fernández Sáenz de la Torre User:GiantSnowman 00:27, 19 September 2010 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Jesús Joaquín Fernández Sáenz de la Torre WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14396 11057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Turning Point UK User:Tsumikiria 20:58, 9 February 2019 (UTC) merge non-notable spin-off attempt organization that fails with a recentist coverage. Organization hasn't gained any coverage for their major activities and events in the UK. At present time, unworthy of an article that would possibly be a PR magnet. Organization will probably have no lasting notability or impact Deletion of Turning Point UK WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14397 19208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MAHSA University User:AllyD 16:40, 7 November 2018 (UTC) keep I have added a couple of Malaysia and UK newspaper references and noted their association with :Northumbria University. This institution is also specifically mentioned as an example in a June 2018 reported speech by the Malaysian Health Minister: http://www.thesundaily.my/news/2018/06/10/six-measures-best-health-services-dzulkefly. Enough for Deletion of MAHSA University :WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14398 4374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandra de Helen User:NeemNarduni2 22:50, 6 February 2016 (UTC) delete per nomination, no indication of notability per Deletion of Sandra de Helen WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14399 8214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Park furniture user:Andrew 08:07, 1 August 2021 (UTC) keep """per . The nomination """"''fails to advance any argument for deletion''"""" as it seems to be completely blank""" Deletion of Park furniture WP:SK Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
14400 3130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Lindsay (author) User:Pascal 01:22, 27 November 2006 (UTC) delete Unclear whether or not he meets but the page should be userfied and deleted. It is probably a good-faith mistake to have created the page in the first place. If it is not then we simply cannot tolerate autobiographical entries because of the underlying |conflict of interests Deletion of Chris Lindsay (author) WP:BIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
14401 2220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/True Detective User:Necrothesp 14:44, 1 April 2014 (UTC) keep This has already been fully discussed on the Talk:True Detective (TV series)|talkpage. Perfectly acceptable disambiguation page per when no primary topic has been determined Deletion of True Detective WP:TWODABS Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
14402 15008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bulma (2nd nomination) User:Sjones23 22:17, 30 October 2007 (UTC) comment I also agree with Sesshomaru on , , and as well as all of the policies I have in mind. My vote is '''neutral Deletion of Bulma (2nd nomination) WP:VERIFY||WP:NOR||WP:WAF||WP:NN Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14403 6611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harvey Chochinov User:Patar 18:24, 11 March 2017 (UTC) keep I think he would still meet 's 5th criterion since he's both a Distinguished Professor at UManitoba, and the only Tier 1 Canada Research Chair in his field. Outside of academia, he's also an Officer in the Order of Canada, alongside other awards academic and civilian for his research, which would help him meet . http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/winnipeg-s-harvey-chochinov-gets-order-of-canada-for-palliative-care-work-1.3325093 http://news.umanitoba.ca/professor-appointed-to-the-order-of-canada/ http://www.chairs-chaires.gc.ca/chairholders-titulaires/index-eng.aspx?r=harvey&k=#results http://www.cspcp.ca/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Harvey-Chochinov.pdf Deletion of Harvey Chochinov WP:ACADEMIC||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14404 20734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Attacks on humanitarian corridors in Chechnya User:DonaldDuck 16:19, 12 March 2010 (UTC) delete as . Bombing of market in Grozny is already described in detail in Grozny ballistic missile attack article Deletion of Attacks on humanitarian corridors in Chechnya WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
14405 45 [[Vorlage:Tipp des Tages/58]] (LAZ) Benutzer:Flominator NONE keep Ich bekomme beim Bearbeiten eines Artikels angezeigt, wenn das Wort im Text auftaucht. Bisher war der Stil noch in jedem Fall so umgangssprachlich, dass der Text nach Umschreibung wirklich professioneller aussah. Dies deckt sich mit #Standardsprache statt Umgangssprache Löschung von Vorlage:Tipp des Tages/58 Wikipedia:Wie schreibe ich gute Artikel Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
14406 15378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Reisler User:Atlan 14:52, 18 August 2009 (UTC) keep Plenty of third party sources available to satisfy Deletion of Paul Reisler WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14407 12689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PC Flame User:Captain 15:27, 16 July 2006 (UTC) delete per nomination. As for the predictions that the site will grow quickly, |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball Deletion of PC Flame WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14408 15895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kyo Rioku Jutsu User:Stuartyeates 06:29, 9 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Kyo Rioku Jutsu WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14409 13315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farhan Zameer User:JohnCD 15:45, 15 February 2012 (UTC) delete autobiography of a student who has released music on Myspace and the like, and is working on a not-yet-released film. He may reach the standard of in due course, but he's some way off yet Deletion of Farhan Zameer WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14410 21099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergeant Bluff-Luton Primary School User:Capitalistroadster 04:20, 1 May 2007 (UTC) delete per and . I am opposed to merging the information here per , particularly in light of the accuracy concerns raised by Deletion of Sergeant Bluff-Luton Primary School WP:N||WP:V||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
14411 14616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jon Barron User:Eleland 08:17, 29 March 2008 (UTC) delete per < Deletion of Jon Barron WP:VANISPAMCRUFTISEMENT Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
14412 5942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Simmons (baseball player) User:Jaranda 23:30, 3 July 2007 (UTC) delete as failing , non-notable minor league draft picks Deletion of James Simmons (baseball player) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14413 20344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The golden cue User:Cyclopia 22:45, 8 May 2010 (UTC) keep Meets and that's enough for keeping Deletion of The golden cue WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14414 15591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paulie Ayala (featherweight boxer) [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 16:01, 24 June 2014 (UTC) keep Meets . Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Paulie Ayala (featherweight boxer) WP:NBOX Wikipedia:Notability 77
14415 15400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Brazil User:GiantSnowman 17:48, 8 August 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Jack Brazil WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14416 4701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lukas Spalvis User:GiantSnowman 18:35, 12 September 2013 (UTC) delete fail and Deletion of Lukas Spalvis WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14417 9409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dexter's Odyssey: A Tale of The Tim Box Wars User:Lid 06:43, 22 October 2006 (UTC) delete that would be I - zero google results and judging by the opening alone it is either non-notable, nonsense or falls under |made up in school one day. –&ndash Deletion of Dexter's Odyssey: A Tale of The Tim Box Wars WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14418 21778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FLEEK User:onel5969 13:30, 20 January 2016 (UTC) delete while there are a ton of hits, they are not about this subject. Can't find enough in-depth coverage from reliable independent sources to show they pass Deletion of FLEEK WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14419 3594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bindi Mwerre Anthurre Artists User:Cabrils 04:55, 13 December 2019 (UTC) keep """I've just added 4 substantive articles from ''The Australian'' (national newspaper): Rothwell, Nicolas (25 April 2006). """"Shifting landscapes"""". The Australian; Canberra. p. 14.; Rothwell, Nicolas (26 March 2004). """"Barriers given the brush"""". The Australian; Canberra. p. 17.; Rothwell, Nicolas (13 September 2012). """"Desert Mob lays out the legacy"""". The Australian; Canberra. p. 15; Rothwell, Nicolas (11 April 2008). """"The dark wings of desire"""". The Australian; Canberra. p. 14. And 3 articles from state papers mentioning exhibitions. I'm confident Bindi satisfies . — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of Bindi Mwerre Anthurre Artists WP:IRS||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14420 13398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bocca User:Chzz 12:19, 22 August 2009 (UTC) delete per above. I suspect there may be a |snowstorm on its way. Sorry, Thebfjj, but please read Deletion of Bocca WP:SNOW||WP:FIRST Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
14421 6915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Patrick Acquaviva User:Spiderone 07:49, 17 October 2015 (UTC) delete fails due to a lack of significant coverage from reliable third-party sources Deletion of John Patrick Acquaviva WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14422 10625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luke Milanzi (2nd nomination) User:Inter 05:04, 22 February 2017 (UTC) keep subject of the article has played in a FIFA-recognized international match, thus satisfying Deletion of Luke Milanzi (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
14423 16290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crixás UFO Incident User:Schuym1 21:18, 1 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Crixás UFO Incident WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
14424 14356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helping Brainz User:FreeRangeFrog 21:22, 27 April 2015 (UTC) delete Looks like everything out there that could serve as a source is social media or self-generated. Thoroughly fails Deletion of Helping Brainz WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14425 20594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Students' Union University of Greenwich User:GretLomborg 15:53, 26 July 2017 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails to meet and . All the coverage I can find is very shallow of the passing mention variety Deletion of Students' Union University of Greenwich WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14426 20473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Botswana rock scene User:Doc 15:04, 7 July 2008 (UTC) delete Fails . Is filled with . No |Reliable Sources as most are to MySpace and Geocities Deletion of The Botswana rock scene WP:MUSIC||WP:OR||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14427 6750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kujo Yardwear User:JamesG5 20:58, 29 July 2017 (UTC) comment """The """"Keep"""" vote above is from the company founder, from a new account with yet more undeclared """ Deletion of Kujo Yardwear WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14428 10268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anneke Lucas User:Rhododendrites 18:59, 8 January 2017 (UTC) keep """either as a biography or reframed as Liberation Prison Yoga. Passes . Problematic content and sources ''currently'' in the article is not relevant to AfD unless the ''entire'' article would need to be deleted and rewritten from scratch in order to be acceptable (i.e. ), and it doesn't look like that's the case. We have an article in http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2014/02/bringing-yoga-to-prison/283490/ The Atlantic, about a third to half of which is about Lucas/her work (i.e. significant coverage). We have an article in https://mic.com/articles/111976/meet-the-woman-changing-the-prison-experience-one-yoga-mat-at-a-time Mic about her and her work (the title is """"Meet the woman who..."""", so I don't understand those writing this off as being about yoga in prisons rather than about her and ''her work'' bringing yoga into prisons). Additional coverage in http://www.theepochtimes.com/n3/1958639-prison-yoga-is-meditation-the-cure-for-recidivism/?photo=3 Epoch Times. Published interview in http://www.sutrajournal.com/interview-anneke-lucas-prison-yoga-by-vikram-sutshi Sutra Journal. Small bit of press in http://www.villagevoice.com/best-of/2016/civic-life/best-yoga-for-an-underserved-community-9237311 Village Voice. She was also the subject of an interview on http://www.huffingtonpost.com/rob-schware/yoga-prisons_b_3051948.html Huffington Post. On that subject, I want to address a couple things that come up at AfD from time to time. First, an interview is a primary source in the sense that it came from the subject and so can't be viewed as neutral; since it was an interview conducted by and published by an entity with no connection to the subject, it is nonetheless helpful for establishing notability. Second, the Huffington Post is a hugely popular source that absolutely contributes to notability. It has a blog format, but it's one with editors (the extent to which they exercise editorial oversight is spotty, of course, but it's not a personal blog). There are indeed ''many'' contexts in which it's not a reliable source, to be sure, and the ideal would be not to use it in most cases, but for notability purposes it works. There are plenty of sources which aren't known for rigorous, accurate reporting, and yet support notability (think about someone being the cover story in People or Entertainment Weekly or something) because notability is about what's worthy of note, so mainstream sources (assuming we're not talking about a venue that promotes fringe views, etc.) certainly helps notability. Then there are some other not-bottom-of-the-barrel-but-not-great blogs like https://esme.com/resources/content/incarceration/anneke-lucas-liberation-prison-yoga ESME. This seems like GNG to me. &mdash""" Deletion of Anneke Lucas WP:GNG||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14429 13116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manager-Mania User:RyRy 20:06, 25 July 2008 (UTC) delete per #G11. Blatant advertising. Thanks Deletion of Manager-Mania WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14430 15526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rafi Radityo Daniswara User:JavaHurricane 05:35, 13 October 2020 (UTC) delete per |A7. No credible claim of importance made Deletion of Rafi Radityo Daniswara WP:A7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14431 21165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nichole Marie Blackwell User:TenPoundHammer 16:19, 20 May 2007 (UTC) keep as it passes and . I'd suggest a rename, but I can't think of anything it could be renamed to Deletion of Nichole Marie Blackwell WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14432 18869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of armoured to unarmoured flight deck designs User:BilCat 09:55, 27 January 2011 (UTC) delete Per nom - not much more can be added to that, but a lot of the article is |synthesis Deletion of Comparison of armoured to unarmoured flight deck designs WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
14433 17495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hexes (band) User:Expertwikiguy 00:13, 8 January 2021 (UTC) delete """It's tough to find anymore news on this one, due to the word """"Hexes"""" being a common term used a lot on the web. I don't think that one review in """"ox-fanzine"""" is enough. If there is only 4 news articles on them, it is definitely not notable and I don't see that they meet criteria""" Deletion of Hexes (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14434 11221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AJ Rafael User:timtempleton 20:44, 12 November 2018 (UTC) delete I'm not seeing sufficient media coverage to demonstrate notability. A simple Google search turns up little about him in reliable sources. Fails Deletion of AJ Rafael WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14435 14955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marolyn Morrison User:Enos733 01:37, 29 June 2017 (UTC) delete or move to draft space. At this point, there is not enough sourcing to meet . There could be a claim that the subject, a mayor of Caledon, Ontario, population 53,000 (in 2017) may have sufficient sourcing to warrant an article. However, at this point, the only reliable sourcing is a lengthy http://torontolife.com/city/battleground-caledon/ article in Toronto Life that describes her battle against development within her city, and several pieces of local community news. I am not sure the article could be improved to meet from what I found, but there could be enough for an article with more research Deletion of Marolyn Morrison WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14436 13493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tricomplex numbers User:Kmhkmh 17:41, 16 November 2017 (UTC) delete due to and as such failing notability as well Deletion of Tricomplex numbers WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14437 9653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jefferson Debate User:danntm 02:49, 3 January 2007 (UTC) delete I like this neologism, and the fact that some people still value logic in discourse. However, this still lacks the sources establish the import of the phrase, as required by Deletion of Jefferson Debate WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
14438 16255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aftab Ahmed (cricketer, born 1931) User:DevaCat1 20:33, 3 April 2021 (UTC) keep He played in six first class matches, and in those matches took 20 wickets, including the (rare) feat of a ten wicket match. It's vanishingly unlikely that there was not meaningful coverage of a ten wicket match in a first class game, but that coverage is likely to be in hardcopy sources in Pakistan. Any cricketer with a ten wicket match is notable. For point of comparison, there were only 19 occasions on which that was accomplished in English first class cricket in 1991 (a randomly chosen year)- I know this because it's sufficiently significant that Wisden has a specific section on it (Wisden 1992, p. 290). It would likely be one of the best half a dozen bowling performances in Pakistani cricket in 1954/5. This isn't someone who has just played a single List A match for a minor county- he has accomplished a truly major accomplishment in the career of any professional bowler, which will have led to significant coverage. This one is really about none of those sources being online, rather than not existing; he would be able to pass given proper research Deletion of Aftab Ahmed (cricketer, born 1931) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14439 21463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry L. Mathis User:Gongshow 10:22, 14 October 2017 (UTC) delete I'm not finding coverage in independent reliable sources to satisfy or Deletion of Terry L. Mathis WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14440 7072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary C. Whitman User:Taemyr 18:08, 25 July 2007 (UTC) keep Due to apparent consensus that her title is sufficent to pass . Still feels a redirect would be better unless there are more content that could be added to the page. Also speedy close due to no editors(nominator included) suggesting deletion Deletion of Mary C. Whitman WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14441 8170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Screenwise (2nd nomination) User:Uzma 14:50, 22 February 2011 (UTC) keep There's plenty of coverage independent of the school itself to meet . Newcastle Herald, Canterbury Bankstown Express, Tabrett Bethell’s Films, Film Ink, Inside Film, Last.fm, Socialite Life, Sydney Morning Herald, Sydney Weekly Courier, Tabrett Bethell Films, The Daily Telegraph, The Footy Show - Channel 9, TV Week, and Woman's Day, reposted at http://www.screenwise.com.au/index.php/press/ Screenwise Press Room, provide significant coverage. In addition, {{Find sources|Screenwise}} brings up even more source material Deletion of Screenwise (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14442 6728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iceland–Mexico relations User:Biruitorul 19:39, 1 May 2009 (UTC) comment all sources found so far are either not independent of the subject, or are primary sources, or do not provide significant coverage of the subject. Seriously: does just get thrown out the window for this string of nonsense articles Deletion of Iceland–Mexico relations WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14443 1395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Institute for International Research NONE NONE delete This easily qualifies as entirely #G11|unambiguous advertising Deletion of Institute for International Research WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14444 19009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James William Middleton User:TreasuryTag 12:20, 3 May 2011 (UTC) keep since he clearly meets the |general notability guideline, in that he has received coverage, directly and in detail, from multiple reliable sources – such as the ones which are |clearly listed in the article for instance. Goodness me Deletion of James William Middleton WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14445 10062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aziz Cem User:Piotrus 12:43, 25 July 2014 (UTC) delete I was about to AfD this due to concerns. Not seeing any mainstream sources Deletion of Aziz Cem WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14446 1455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Organizations influenced by the Muslim Brotherhood User:Dennisthe2 06:43, 9 April 2012 (UTC) delete Housekeeping). Will be tagged momentarily. In the future, given the nature of this article, this should have been posted in Deletion of Organizations influenced by the Muslim Brotherhood WP:RFD Wikipedia:Redirect 56
14447 5104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Selçan Hatun User:TTN 21:03, 21 October 2020 (UTC) delete or redirect - Added sources seem like typical daily pop-culture dribble, so this still fails Deletion of Selçan Hatun WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14448 7494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exodwarf planet User:Ka 19:25, 25 November 2010 (UTC) comment I think the sign Yisraelasper is referring to is a previous |proposed deletion (PROD) notification {{diff|Exodwarf planet|398601661|398595424|here}} (and another one {{diff|Exodwarf planet|398604739|398666825|here}}). The seven days talked about in that notice refer to the fact that if the notice is not removed in seven days an admin will review it and make a decision whether to delete it or not. It is believed that if no one removes the notice during those seven days then the community generally feels that this article shouldn't exist (see ). This is fD. What's happening here is a discussion about whether the article should exist or not. The discussion usually lasts 7 days and the article shouldn't be deleted during that time. Captain Hindsight feels that feels this article is about a neologism and thus fails . For the article to be kept it's necessary to show that the article doesn't fail that policy. Captain Hindsight was not acting against the rules to nominate this article for deletion here (see ).The problem with the article, as I see it, is that is the *only* reference to the word outside of blogs and the Merriam-Webster equivalent of wiktionary are the course lecture notes the (Dr Jeffrey reference). A search for Extrasolar Dwarf Planet does, indeed, bring up a http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/719/1/803 peer reviewed paper so if the article's kept I'd prefer it was moved to that location per published literature Deletion of Exodwarf planet WP:PROD||WP:PROD||WP:A||WP:NEO||WP:DEPROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
14449 16807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of LiveJournal users User:Cbs527 17:58, 15 April 2017 (UTC) delete """Fails basic policy of on several levels of what ''""""Wikipedia articles should not be""""''- ({{cite web|title=Wikipedia is not a mirror or a repository of links...|url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:What_Wikipedia_is_not#Wikipedia_is_not_a_mirror_or_a_repository_of_links.2C_images.2C_or_media_files}}) and ({{cite web|title=Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information|url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:What_Wikipedia_is_not#Wikipedia_is_not_an_indiscriminate_collection_of_information}}). Even if were added, we would still have an article that would be unacceptable per """ Deletion of List of LiveJournal users WP:NOT||WP:RS||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14450 15778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katie Hopkins User:TenPoundHammer 19:52, 15 July 2007 (UTC) keep easily passes as a ''very'' well-sourced B-class article on a highly notable person. Article could use a bit of tidying and trimming, but the number of sources alone is enough to have me convinced that she's a person of note Deletion of Katie Hopkins WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14451 20262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bulraga User:Who 19:46, 5 July 2009 (UTC) delete no notbility, no claims of notability, fails Deletion of Bulraga WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14452 15222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LMN Triangle User:Ufwuct 19:16, 8 August 2006 (UTC) delete """Even a Google search of """"LMN Triangle"""", Miami gives only http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22LMN+Triangle%22+Miami two results, both on Wikipedia. It looks like |OR and is ''certainly'' |non-notable""" Deletion of LMN Triangle WP:OR||WP:NN Wikipedia:No original research 65
14453 2215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vitor Ribeiro User:east718 NONE keep You should list it at then, and besides, this seems like a clear-cut case where it's ''our'' content being stolen. ''' Deletion of Vitor Ribeiro WP:CV Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
14454 4834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nirnnayakam User:Hut 21:28, 2 June 2015 (UTC) comment the nominator has been indefinitely blocked as a block-evading sockpuppet and the article they created about this film has been deleted under #G5. I don't see any point in deleting this now as it's no longer a duplicate article, although we could still move it if desired Deletion of Nirnnayakam WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14455 20726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mandy (Jonas Brothers song) User:Esradekan 08:59, 12 July 2009 (UTC) delete as an unlikely redirect term, fails notability per #Songs. No awards, no chart, no covers, no Deletion of Mandy (Jonas Brothers song) WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14456 10032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Israelisms User:Jon513 18:45, 19 August 2006 (UTC) delete this article has done a better job than some at asserting notablity with the section ''Awards and Featured Articles'', however I still think it fails . I also think that most of the article in :Category:Podcasts should be deleted and should not be used as a precedent Deletion of Israelisms WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14457 9460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BIG KIDD User:Aoziwe 11:38, 3 April 2019 (UTC) delete PROMO, and very poor English. At best Deletion of BIG KIDD WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
14458 15875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bhakharwadi (TV Show) User:4meter4 02:25, 28 October 2019 (UTC) keep per . Passes Deletion of Bhakharwadi (TV Show) WP:HEY||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
14459 12359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yaroslav Pavulyak User:Stuartyeates 23:35, 14 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails , unless can be found Deletion of Yaroslav Pavulyak WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14460 13790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Green Completions User:Mike1901 12:22, 6 January 2017 (UTC) delete agree regarding notability being (just about!) there, but yes is a good description of what needs to happen here to get it into an encyclopedic state Deletion of Green Completions WP:BLOWITUP Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
14461 13988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Fassler User:Ohnoitsjamie 22:43, 29 June 2006 (UTC) delete Fails ; somewhere between vanity and comedy Deletion of Joe Fassler WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14462 21735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hoofmaster User:Adambro 21:42, 5 May 2007 (UTC) delete """I don't wish to get involved in the whole did he/didn't he graduate debate. For the purposes of this AfD whether he has a degree is irrelevant. Personally, I would doubt whether the alumni website would list all graduates. The real matter for consideration is whether the subject meets the primary criterion set out in ; """"A person is notable if he or she has been the subject of secondary sources that are reliable, intellectually independent, and independent of the subject."""" I do not think the subject meets this basic requirement, there seems to be just the one article in the newspaper about him. For this reason I suggest this article is deleted""" Deletion of Hoofmaster WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14463 21117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lakhumal Hiranand Hiranandani User:Vibhijain 11:57, 12 August 2012 (UTC) keep Although I was going to speedy close this following , I think that an admin is best to do that. Reasons for my !vote are (1)the nominator has not provide any rational, (2)the article needs work, but I feel that it stills meets the notability guidelines, (3)AfD is not for cleanup Deletion of Lakhumal Hiranand Hiranandani WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
14464 19055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Ferrara User:Richwales 03:53, 8 August 2011 (UTC) delete per and per nom. Cited sources do not establish notability per Deletion of Eric Ferrara WP:INDY||WP:PERSON Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14465 3877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuldip dhindsa User:Ohconfucius 12:39, 24 June 2008 (UTC) delete not hard to believe this is a |spammy |vanity article, but harder to believe it is a |copyright violation for its poor English for a man of such impeccable credentials (''sic Deletion of Kuldip dhindsa WP:SPAM||WP:COI||WP:COPY Wikipedia:Spam 112
14466 3274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sin Sizzerb User:Ted87 07:14, 23 June 2007 (UTC) delete Mixtapes themselves are borderline notabile. So one by an artist who himself is unnotabile definatly doesn't meat Deletion of Sin Sizzerb WP:NM Wikipedia:Notability 77
14467 10596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott oliaro User:Psinu 21:41, 18 December 2007 (UTC) keep but dear God, do something more than dump the guy's resume on here. I don't have time to mess with it, but did a quick search on Google and discovered at minimum that Mr. O a) was a record-breaking Ivy League athlete and b) is a published (author? subject matter expert?) on head trauma injury. Will send a note asking for revision by original author, who I HOPE is not Scott Oliaro himself (ahem, Deletion of Scott oliaro WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14468 4257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Nirenberg User:RayAYang 04:18, 31 January 2013 (UTC) delete is for people who are primarily notable as scholars. Subject is a podiatrist who speaks to reporters, and does not appear to have a significant scholarly role which would qualify him to pass #C7. Thus, we default to the GNG/, which he does not pass Deletion of Michael Nirenberg WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14469 12238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Awkward Animals User:December21st2012Freak 20:18, 21 December 2009 (UTC) delete per . Not enough sources Deletion of Awkward Animals WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14470 17837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Senad Gashi User:Mdtemp 17:41, 5 July 2016 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet and the coverage is mainly routine sports reporting so is not met Deletion of Senad Gashi WP:NBOX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14471 19523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rachel Starr (2nd nomination) User:Tarc 13:57, 7 February 2011 (UTC) delete I am fairly certain that there was an old discussion regarding this and the ridiculously retarded guideline that is . IIRC, it drew the notability line at excluding nominees for group awards Deletion of Rachel Starr (2nd nomination) WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14472 107 [[Günther Rechn]] (erledigt) Benutzer:Ziko NONE keep Franke hat sich viel Mühe gegeben und konstruktiv mitgearbeitet, und es sind höchstens noch Kleinigkeiten, die am Artikel verbessert werden müssten. An die, die es angeht: Bitte seid freundlicher zu Neulingen und denkt an unseren Grundsatz ! Einverstanden Löschung von Günther Rechn Wikipedia:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
14473 1578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Alured Faunce User:Rinfoli 14:36, 18 April 2014 (UTC) delete WP:GNG and fail Deletion of Thomas Alured Faunce WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14474 18231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DYIK [[User talk:Serial Number 54129|'''S'''erial]] | 19:20, 16 June 2021 (UTC) delete per . I disagree with the premises (such as they are) advanced by those !voting keep. Superstig's is pretty much a variation on WP:ITEXISTS, and argues—incorrectly—that this is sufficient to pass our notability guidelines; the same goes, of course, for 'per astig'. There's a slightly curious 'Keep Tony A.', and I have no idea how to pass that as either an argument, or indeed, an |argument to avoid. Neutralhomer does admittedly challenge SpportingFlyer, but this challenge is based on an as-yet unresolved RfC, so of less value, unfortunately, right now, as it might be in future discussions. SBKSSP—the article's creator—argues in support of two already less that effectual arguments.{{pb}}For the record, there has been little to no independent, third party coverage of the station in reliable sources, either https://www.google.com/search?q=DYIK+%2B+tanjay&client=firefox-b-d&biw=2159&bih=850&tbm=nws&sxsrf=ALeKk01catsZnql12guncQ-f1Cv-0eFMmw%3A1623870894237&ei=rk3KYKmIDovKgQaUuqmQBw&oq=DYIK+%2B+tanjay&gs_l=psy-ab.3...2206.2972.0.3316.2.2.0.0.0.0.76.148.2.2.0....0...1c.1.64.psy-ab..0.0.0....0.n12WvELGCc8 news outlets or https://www.google.com/search?q=DYIK+%2B+tanjay&client=firefox-b-d&tbm=bks&sxsrf=ALeKk03x_rV0_aYxnydposSH2aztok8Osw:1623870898402&source=lnms&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiXm73A7pzxAhWZi1wKHf0eB3QQ_AUoAXoECAIQCw&biw=2159&bih=850&dpr=1.09 literature. While is often relevant with non-English, non-Western topics, this is sufficiently recent that a solid digital footprint would be expected. There is none. So, the article fails also. Special:contributions/Serial Number 54129 Deletion of DYIK WP:NOTDIRECTORY||WP:ATADD||WP:OFFLINE||WP:NORG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14475 6127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unusual Sex Acts User:Ikkyu2 07:04, 3 March 2006 (UTC) delete No sources, fails , no way to prove it's not |original research Deletion of Unusual Sex Acts WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14476 11379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Batesville High School (Arkansas) User:Pan 19:07, 14 December 2006 (UTC) delete unless sources are provided to show that this school is the |subject of multiple external non-trivial sources that show notability, and that we could use to write a verified encyclopedia article. The only sources in the article now are websites associated or affiliated with the school. After a cursory look at Google and Lexis-Nexis I see nothing non-trivial (this is not a surprise since most schools are not the subjects of external sources Deletion of Batesville High School (Arkansas) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14477 20675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dazey Corporation [[User: Electriccatfish2|Electric Catfish]] ([[User talk: Electriccatfish2|talk]]) 18:52, 30 September 2012 (UTC) delete Fails both and as the 2 sources are unreliable. --v/r Deletion of Dazey Corporation WP: GNG||WP: CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14478 18201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scottish Gaelic punk User:Epbr123 20:20, 7 December 2007 (UTC) keep Passes per ''The Scotsman'' article Deletion of Scottish Gaelic punk WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14479 18293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of shopping centres in Norway User:Arsenikk 12:05, 8 December 2010 (UTC) keep going by the number of blue-links, it seems that most shopping centers are notable. Almost every new shopping center creates a large local debate, so I'm pretty sure nearly all the shopping centers are notable. Per , it is acceptable to create lists which have a minimum degree of notability or a cut-off point (for instance 20 or 50 stores Deletion of List of shopping centres in Norway WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
14480 11921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Www.lavamus.com User:Zzuuzz 21:38, 12 August 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Www.lavamus.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14481 2579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 UPSL season User:GiantSnowman 15:11, 9 February 2018 (UTC) comment to all those !voting 'keep'; the presence of sources does not equate to notability, and neither does the existence of other similar articles (). I have yet to see a meaniningful 'keep' !vote, everything is simply coming across as Deletion of 2018 UPSL season WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14482 4019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Social software in education User:Atmoz 00:13, 28 October 2008 (UTC) keep A well-written, well-sourced article. But please be aware of Deletion of Social software in education WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14483 17418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Blessed Book of Beasts User:Kinu 17:53, 6 November 2014 (UTC) delete """Actually, I fail to see how is met. It's the ''same review'' by the Catholic News Service that happens to have been syndicated on two sites that aggregate such content. I don't believe that the """"multiple"""" aspect of criterion #1 is met. One review by one person, regardless of whether he is an expert in the field as suggested by the article, is not enough coverage upon which to base an article""" Deletion of The Blessed Book of Beasts WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
14484 16259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bodies of water of capital cities of the United States User:LearnIndology 15:18, 30 April 2021 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of List of bodies of water of capital cities of the United States WP:OR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
14485 2279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Final Fantasy X-3 [[User talk:Ultimus|'''UlTiMuS''']] 10:19, 2 September 2006 (UTC) delete unless sources show up, this is Deletion of Final Fantasy X-3 WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14486 1352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Greater Manchester User:Imzadi1979 00:50, 25 March 2013 (UTC) delete fails and . Lists like these should be transwikied to Wikivoyage rather than left on Wikipedia Deletion of List of bus routes in Greater Manchester WP:GNG||WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14487 11423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MySupermarket NONE NONE keep Notable. Passes . Promotional tone can be addressed by copy editing the article. Source examples include Deletion of MySupermarket WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
14488 11798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Resurrection (Michael Jackson album) User:Mitaphane NONE delete no references, first 50 Google Hits for Michael Jackson Resurrection give nothing creditable, this is somewhere between & #Wikipedia_is_not_a_crystal_ball|. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Resurrection (Michael Jackson album) WP:V||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14489 4352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alertsec Xpress User:Pohta 15:44, 11 January 2010 (UTC) delete Obvious spam, and the sources don't meet . It gets exactly one google news hit, a mention in passing http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=Alertsec+Xpress+source%3A%22-newswire%22+source%3A%22-wire%22+source%3A%22-presswire%22+source%3A%22-PR%22+source%3A%22-press%22+source%3A%22-release%22+source%3A%22-wikipedia%22&btnG=Search+Archives&scoring=a here Deletion of Alertsec Xpress WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14490 18380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boffin (2nd nomination) User:Colonel 18:32, 17 June 2012 (UTC) keep """We have separate articles for nerd, geek, egghead and anorak (slang) which are all quite similar and so it seems that this class of words is among those allowed for by : """"''In some cases, a word or phrase itself may be an encyclopedic subject''"""". As examples of sources which discuss this type in detail see ''http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=y87qYiZcnocC&pg=PA55 Typical Men: The Representation of Masculinity in Popular British Cinema''; ''http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=_BeTDR_Sp28C&pg=PT145 Churchill's War Lab: Code Breakers, Boffins and Innovators''; ''http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=XXQqCAWcZ8cC&pg=PA115 Movers And Shakers: A Chronology of Words That Shaped Our Age''. These approach the topic in various ways: cinematic stereotypes; wartime history; influential words, and so demonstrate a depth of coverage which satisfies """ Deletion of Boffin (2nd nomination) WP:NAD||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
14491 20564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Pillay User:Anotherclown 11:16, 15 July 2011 (UTC) delete """subject appears to lack """"significant coverage"""" in |reliable sources and is therefore likely not notable under the |General Notability Guideline""" Deletion of Michael Pillay WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14492 10325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jay Byrne User:Dhartung 01:09, 11 July 2008 (UTC) delete fails . He is quoted in media as a spokesman, but this is not coverage of him as a person. His positions are also of minor importance -- an executive appointee, but two levels (at least) below the head of a department or agency; and a campaign spokesman, but for the campaign's operations in a single state (Ohio). A person whose name appears in the media may be notable, but there are no independent sources indicating real notability Deletion of Jay Byrne WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14493 17380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathan Rooney User:Cloudz679 18:47, 13 January 2013 (UTC) delete Player has not played at a notable senior level, thus failing to generate significant coverage and failing Deletion of Nathan Rooney WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14494 6823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Belarus–Croatia relations (2nd nomination) User:Biruitorul 03:04, 30 November 2009 (UTC) delete """a collection of meaningless trivia, not a valid encyclopedic topic. Yes, they have ambassadors (though not in each others' capital); yes, minor officials from both once met in Switzerland; yes, they both belong to Central European Initiative|some obscure body; yes, a few million dollars are exchanged between them annually; yes, they've signed a few pieces of paper together. And yes, I'm sure Croatian officials could find Belarus on a map, and vice versa. But '''no''', none of this is in the least tantamount to the """"significant coverage"""" demanded by . It's stuff we'd never normally notice outside this series of nonsense articles that some have decided to """"expand"""" in a game of """"watch me do this"""", and it's not something we should countenance""" Deletion of Belarus–Croatia relations (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14495 9334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akane-chan Overdrive User:Neier 23:08, 5 February 2009 (UTC) comment how is this ''in process'' when process () clearly states that AFD is not to be used for discussing redirects? So, there was a disagreement over whether the article should be redirected or not – it should be settled on the talk page or other places; but not at AFD Deletion of Akane-chan Overdrive WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14496 10639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Olivier Fortier User:Stormtracker94 19:23, 18 October 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Olivier Fortier WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14497 18950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Midnight (video game) User:Corpx 04:10, 2 July 2007 (UTC) delete This article is about an unreleased game. I think this game might deserve an article once its actually released () depending on the reviews. The interviews conducted are not from established media sites Deletion of Midnight (video game) WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14498 17377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terence James O'Dwyer User:FisherQueen 16:53, 14 February 2007 (UTC) delete The source verifies that O'Dwyer is a director of Metal Storm, but I don't see the kind of independent writing about him that would make him notable per Deletion of Terence James O'Dwyer WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14499 8601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Upcoming Bollywood Movies of 2018 User:Ajf773 08:23, 25 January 2017 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of Upcoming Bollywood Movies of 2018 WP:NOTCRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14500 20421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Colerick User:Jmertel23 NONE delete Clearly fails , though I would have started the deletion process with a PROD Deletion of Jim Colerick WP:GNG||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14501 431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shmuel Yerushalmi User:Jayvdb 22:30, 23 February 2007 (UTC) keep the nomination blurb has been proven incorrect (no harm done by the nom though for listing it on Afd); the subject meets and is not an issue Deletion of Shmuel Yerushalmi WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
14502 2877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanklet User:Richwales 03:51, 11 August 2011 (UTC) delete per (no sources ''at all'', and I couldn't find anything relevant in a Google search); (can't verify without any sources); (no sources at all, thus no independent sources to substantiate notability); and (the article is written like an advertisement Deletion of Tanklet WP:RS||WP:V||WP:INDY||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14503 427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kovas Boguta User:Boookabooo 11:46, 2 February 2007 (UTC) delete as it fails Deletion of Kovas Boguta WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14504 14068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oh No They Didn't NONE NONE keep I believe ONTD passed ''''''. First, as requested I am disclosing that I do have a vested interest in this community as I am a long time member. According to NW Guidelines I believe this article falls under categories 1 and 3 Deletion of Oh No They Didn't WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14505 8271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hong Kong Trade Centre User:Bejnar 17:00, 12 April 2014 (UTC) delete per'' nomination. This building, built in 1982, is on a major thoroughfare, Des Voeux Road, in Central Hong Kong, but is no different from many buildings there. It has not received specific, detailed coverage in independent reliable sources, although the information provided is certainly erifiability|verifiable. The lack of citations is understandable, most of the mentions were in Chinese, but not significant Deletion of Hong Kong Trade Centre :WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14506 11338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salman Saeed (2nd nomination) User:Störm 10:59, 20 March 2021 (UTC) keep with 5 first-class matches and 5 top-class T20s, it is highly likely that there is coverage somewhere; this is exactly the type of case that is designed to pick up. With another four AfDs from the same nominator on the day of this nomination, I'm sceptical that the nominator has done sufficient searches, including across a range of non-English sources, to ascertain that there is no coverage. The nomination lacks any meaningful level of detail; there is no evidence of which sources Deletion of Salman Saeed (2nd nomination) WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14507 10768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C. George Boeree User:Nomoskedasticity 20:36, 28 December 2010 (UTC) delete not even close to meeting Deletion of C. George Boeree WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14508 12236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susan Mayer User:Paul730 20:31, 17 April 2008 (UTC) comment I don't like to disagree with you, Flyer, but the |burden of evidence does lie with the editors who add material or want material to be kept, not the editors who nominate material for deletion. I have to question the agenda behind this AfD however; Ultra, do you seriously believe this character isn't notable, or are you just trying to motivate people to establish that notability in the article Deletion of Susan Mayer WP:PROVEIT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14509 8218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Circles (comic book) User:NeoFreak 12:58, 27 March 2007 (UTC) delete This article has been on my radar for some time. In addition to the article format, it does in fact appear to be a non-notable comic only published by a genre vanity press. I'm not throughly familiar with the genre though so if some realiable sources emerge from other editors that can |verify |notability I could be swayed. Since it is printed material and I'm always more inclined to give printed media a little more slack Deletion of Circles (comic book) WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14510 21113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of football matches broadcast on SingTel mio TV User:ChrisTheDude 08:40, 20 February 2013 (UTC) delete horrendous failure, I simply can't think of any reason why this level of detail would be even remotely encyclopedic Deletion of List of football matches broadcast on SingTel mio TV WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14511 4003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ohio River Bearcats User:DARTH 16:07, 2 February 2011 (UTC) delete per , non-notable. As per nom, seems that it also violates Deletion of Ohio River Bearcats WP:NSPORTS||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
14512 1226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victor Quinteros User:Ryan 14:56, 3 May 2007 (UTC) delete http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&q=%22Victor+Quinteros%22+peru&meta= 65 g-hits, non on them |reliable sources Deletion of Victor Quinteros WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14513 21751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coming Home (2013 film) User:Ultraexactzz 14:22, 5 December 2012 (UTC) delete per the above. A thing can exist and not (yet!) be notable. Once there are |Reliable sources that discuss the production, or once the film's release is confirmed and imminent, an article might be appropriate Deletion of Coming Home (2013 film) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14514 5231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Little London (band) User:Nuttah 20:04, 30 May 2010 (UTC) delete Nowhere near meeting Deletion of Little London (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14515 1322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Folk Guy's Always with You User:Raysonho NONE keep First of all, we need to understand that this is an article translated from Chinese. So google searching the English name does not reflect the actual popularity of this song. Second, and the most important point is, this is not purely an article about the song, but also the impact of this song to the Hong Kong Culture. It was covered by local media in HK. So I don't believe we should use the guidelines from Deletion of Folk Guy's Always with You WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14516 9991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Beautiful Robe User:Sergecross73 12:40, 16 April 2018 (UTC) merge per my comments above. Additionally, per , no page move should occur. It's already at its correct location Deletion of My Beautiful Robe WP:AT Wikipedia:Article titles 75
14517 21189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of shopping malls in Michigan User:Chuck 18:49, 11 March 2008 (UTC) comment """Categories and lists serve two different purposes, as categories can contain WP articles (and other categories) only, while lists may validly contain items which are not only not WP articles ''now'', but also items which might ''never'' have WP articles. I don't think """"the list is redundant with the category"""" is a valid reason for deletion. I |boldly edited the list to change all redlinks to non-links. At the same time, I'm not convinced that the list should be kept, either""" Deletion of List of shopping malls in Michigan WP:BB Wikipedia:Be bold 9
14518 21030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Na'ama Yehuda User:Nephron 10:20, 19 August 2006 (UTC) delete Non-notable - Deletion of Na'ama Yehuda WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14519 3127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/East Bengal the Real Power User:SabyaC 06:26, 21 February 2020 (UTC) keep The article passes with all the references listed in the article and also as a Supporters' groups|Supporters' group, the East Bengal the Real Power is India's first officially registered supporter's group who are in existence from 2006 and have been under media highlight for more than a decade. The article is encyclopedic and is relevant for Football in India Deletion of East Bengal the Real Power WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14520 2671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of art galleries in Colombia User:Ajf773 20:33, 9 February 2019 (UTC) delete Per . Only one linked entry, the rest are probably non notable Deletion of List of art galleries in Colombia WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOTPROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14521 14333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gregory Stafford User:Barno 02:17, 8 May 2006 (UTC) delete from article-space. No indication of being cited in |reliable sources. I'm not persuaded that the political-staffer job nor being an officer of the groups listed are enough to get past . Article creator's only contributions Special:Contributions/Gregorystafford have been to his own bio, that of another political flack, and a group of which both are officers. Deletion of Gregory Stafford WP:RS||WP:BIO||WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14522 7504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Klone Records User:Cyrus 15:28, 1 May 2007 (UTC) delete per #A7|CSD A7. No sources to back up the claims in the article Deletion of Klone Records WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14523 12260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charlton McIlwain User:David 05:18, 30 December 2018 (UTC) keep per (h-index is the wrong way to measure productivity for the kind of academic whose main output is books Deletion of Charlton McIlwain WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14524 21192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas J. Dolan NONE NONE keep """Personal involvement of an ex-IBM executive in the Aaron Swartz case in this manner is notable; indeed it has garnered subsequent coverage in the UK http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2013/jan/15/aaron-swartz-husband-prosecutor-criticises Guardian. Dolan sought public attention via his Twitter posting. His prior career clearly satisfies . Dolan's notability is comparable to other spouses such as Silda Wall Spitzer and Ruth Madoff. References to """"geekstorm"""" clearly fail NPOV: this usage seeks to minimize the contributions of Aaron Swartz and marginalize those interested and concerned by the subsequent events""" Deletion of Thomas J. Dolan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14525 8421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Veronica Grey (3rd nomination) User:I 03:47, 23 July 2011 (UTC) comment Her literature is unlike any other artists ever. '' Just saying |her literature is really great is not really a good reason to keep this article, unless you can find third-party independent sources that describe it as such Deletion of Veronica Grey (3rd nomination) WP:ITSIMPORTANT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14526 10752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SC4EVER User:JChap2007 03:09, 11 November 2006 (UTC) delete """per nom. Oppose merge per TBC and also becuse """"I remember hearing something..."""" isn't a standard for encyclopedic |verifiability""" Deletion of SC4EVER WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14527 16137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emma Chamberlain User:Lubbad85 22:18, 4 June 2019 (UTC) keep per Subject is GNG per above comments Deletion of Emma Chamberlain WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
14528 2297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manuel Jiménez (boxer) User:Papaursa 12:09, 14 June 2020 (UTC) delete Fails to meet and my search didn't find the significant independent coverage required to meet . Winning a title in one of the many minor boxing organizations is not enough to show notability, especially when he won less than half his fights Deletion of Manuel Jiménez (boxer) WP:NBOX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14529 9839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chantel Zales User:PohranicniStraze 20:47, 1 August 2018 (UTC) delete WP:MILL|Run-of-the-mill model/actress. Lack of |reliable source coverage to meet Deletion of Chantel Zales WP:RS||WP:NMODEL Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14530 17304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C&H Distributors User:Bearian 17:12, 7 January 2008 (UTC) delete per nom et al. Minimal sources, all but one |unreliable. 35 is not ranked very high Deletion of C&H Distributors WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14531 1233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Memory Lane (Sittin' in da Park) User:Esradekan 03:52, 7 August 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Songs Deletion of Memory Lane (Sittin' in da Park) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14532 13208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lava Kusa – The Warrior Twins User:ApprenticeFan 12:55, 21 November 2009 (UTC) delete future film doesn't meet per guidelines Deletion of Lava Kusa – The Warrior Twins WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14533 6019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of surviving veterans of the Spanish Civil War User:The 20:20, 13 August 2018 (UTC) delete """I fail to see |purpose to the list. Moreover, it's bound to remain incomplete and inaccurate: There are many people who took part in that conflict and who are alive today but will never be included because of lack of sources. Plus, there's always the issue of how """"took part"""" is defined, i.e. who qualifies as a veteran? Only soldiers? The nurses? The civil service administrators of either side? A veritable Pandora's box""" Deletion of List of surviving veterans of the Spanish Civil War WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
14534 8867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natalia Baron User:Niteshift36 01:21, 7 April 2015 (UTC) delete A series of guest appearances don't get past , nor does an infrequent supporting role on a show Deletion of Natalia Baron WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14535 14204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hell Is Real User:21 23:57, 21 November 2018 (UTC) keep now that FC Cincinnati is in MLS, this will become a regular rivalry, played (likely) three times per year. It already has quite a bit of to help it meet , and should continue to get more as it is played in the future. I plan on rewriting the page in the near future to better reflect that this wasn't just a one-off match Deletion of Hell Is Real WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14536 7946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transport puzzle User:timtempleton 02:29, 28 August 2018 (UTC) delete no sourcing whatsover, here or with a Google search - term fails Deletion of Transport puzzle WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14537 12344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disappearance of April Jones User:MevaTheCHCSPrefect 15:08, 15 November 2012 (UTC) delete http://uk.news.yahoo.com/april-jones-search-expected-end-weeks-040743576.html;_ylt=AlB_JHqUkc.Gl.Y03yRUpCbp0Mh_;_ylu=X3oDMTR1Z2MxcjF2BGNjb2RlA3ZzaGFyZWFnMnVwcmVzdARtaXQDTmV3cyBmb3IgeW91IFJIIGNvbCBvbiBuZXdzBHBrZwMyN2M5NjE5Ny0yY2FjLTM3MTgtYTdkNC04MTQ0ZmQ4NjQ4MGIEcG9zAzIEc2VjA25ld3NfZm9yX3lvdQR2ZXIDOGJiYmYxMTMtMmYwOC0xMWUyLWJlZGItMTgyNDY5MzVjNTA5;_ylg=X3oDMTJqajhqZWtxBGludGwDZ2IEbGFuZwNlbi1nYgRwc3RhaWQDN2RiZTMwMGUtNTUxYS0zNTRhLTk2NzEtMjg0YzBjZTRhNmViBHBzdGNhdAMEcHQDc3RvcnlwYWdl;_ylv=3 This case is coming to a close and let's face it, , The media dropped 'Disappearance of Megan Stammers' as soon as it got cold and I've heard nothing of this for a few weeks until about now when I saw this on Yahoo which shows that it's going to follow the same route as the one I mentioned before. And since it's ''apparently'' breaking four rules it's good to get out Deletion of Disappearance of April Jones WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14538 19907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Birahim Gaye User:onel5969 16:35, 28 December 2020 (UTC) keep as per Deletion of Birahim Gaye WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
14539 15326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Esha Tewari Pande User:Timeraner 08:38, 24 June 2015 (UTC) comment looks like romo. Article focus is on awards from a website without its own article Deletion of Esha Tewari Pande WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
14540 169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Odaine Démar User:Joaquin008 19:16, 28 May 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Odaine Démar WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14541 12854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Toshok (2nd nomination) User:JTtheOG 07:33, 1 April 2018 (UTC) delete as per nom. Subject clearly fails with not enough RS Deletion of Chris Toshok (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14542 8277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wayne Hoffman (author) User:EuroCarGT 04:36, 12 November 2014 (UTC) keep fully meets , won several notable book awards. Has significant coverage to establish inclusion Deletion of Wayne Hoffman (author) WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14543 13337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Memes through Enchanted of Beauty and Handsomeness User:Donaldd23 11:22, 27 June 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Memes through Enchanted of Beauty and Handsomeness WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14544 1015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grace Clawson User:Galloglass 14:22, 9 December 2007 (UTC) delete Non notable as per Deletion of Grace Clawson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14545 705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nuits d'été & La damoiselle élue User:Niggle1892 17:33, 22 September 2019 (UTC) keep per . The article's COPYVIO issues have now been dealt with - brief review excerpts will be supplied in due course Deletion of Nuits d'été & La damoiselle élue WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
14546 2709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taylor Atelian User:Rzvas 19:29, 18 December 2018 (UTC) delete Fails FWIW Deletion of Taylor Atelian WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14547 19627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Basanta Kumar Nemwang User:AllyD 09:56, 15 February 2018 (UTC) keep """The subject is described as a """"former UML lawmaker"""" in http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2016-03-12/cdp-funds-being-misused-to-build-party-building.html this 2016 source and as a """"former parliamentarian from Panchthar"""" in http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2017-03-19/nea-mulls-building-762mw-project-on-tamor-river.html this March 2017 source. And http://www.myrepublica.com/news/32357/ this source lists the subject as winning a House of Representatives seat in December 2017. Meets #1""" Deletion of Basanta Kumar Nemwang :WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14548 17185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wild Cherries User:Chaser 08:32, 19 June 2006 (UTC) delete I found some evidence of local chart placing http://www.milesago.com/Artists/wildcherries.htm here, (word search for chart) but the references to critics' opinions seems self-serving. Also, please be cautious of |biting the newcomers Deletion of Wild Cherries WP:BITE Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
14549 140 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hariçten Gazel Kullanıcı:seksen iki yüz kırk beş82 ~145 11:28, 24 Haziran 2011 (UTC) delete Verilen kaynakların ikisi de güvenilir ve/veya bağımsız değil. Bilgilerin doğru olması değil, bilginin birden fazla, bağımsız, güvenilir kaynakta geçmesi önemli, bkz. ve VP:KD Hariçten Gazel'in silinmesi Vikipedi:Güvenilir kaynaklar Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14550 19410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Counter-Strike equipment User:Angusmclellan 20:03, 20 July 2006 (UTC) delete game guide and for those Deletion of Counter-Strike equipment WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14551 21925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Labour Party (UK) leadership election, 2007 User:Terence 16:04, 9 September 2006 (UTC) keep not crystal ball and sources are verifiable, notable future event and Blair has stated that he is going to resign in May next year. The election is very likely not definitely going to be held, please read before saying anything about crystallbalism Deletion of Labour Party (UK) leadership election, 2007 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14552 18760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Language of Liberty Institute User:Bearian 15:59, 18 January 2021 (UTC) delete per - part of a alled garden of libertarian stubs that |only cite each other's websites Deletion of Language of Liberty Institute WP:SIGCOV||WP:W||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14553 12067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amish episode User:J 03:03, 31 July 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Amish episode WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14554 1808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Balmer User:Bearian 20:00, 23 September 2014 (UTC) delete a |run of the mill local radio evangelist Deletion of Mark Balmer WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
14555 14594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nasty Little Man User:Tokyogirl79 05:54, 3 March 2015 (UTC) delete A search brought up the PR firm in passing (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/02/15/jack-white-open-letter-guacamole_n_6689040.html, http://www.stereogum.com/1706155/foo-fighters-sort-of-respond-to-jack-white-dis-jack-white-sort-of-apologizes/news/, http://www.digitalmusicnews.com/permalink/2015/02/24/nearly-14-itunes-users-listened-u2-january) but not really anything that truly focuses on the firm itself. Other than them being the inspiration for the song ''Hello, Nasty'' and some mild coverage about http://www.billboard.com/articles/events/grammys-2015/6465738/beck-grammys-album-year-pr-firm-nasty-little-man NLM having a catfight with another record company, there really is nothing out there and the aforementioned claims to fame aren't even remotely enough to warrant having an article. This is pretty much a classic example of where you have someone/something that deals with notable people but none of those deals ever translated into coverage for the PR firm Deletion of Nasty Little Man WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14556 5613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BizTech College User:Ifnord 03:07, 23 December 2018 (UTC) delete for failing any claim to Deletion of BizTech College WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14557 20908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Morrissey (Arizona politician) User:MB 19:29, 8 September 2019 (UTC) keep agree the office doesn't meet , but I think there is enough coverage for GNG. Lots of articles in the https://azcapitoltimes.com/news/tag/tom-morrissey/ AZ Capitol Times, https://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/news/women-accuse-art-bill-tonnesen-sexual-misconduct-phoenix-11353902 Phoenix New Times, https://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/news/women-accuse-art-bill-tonnesen-sexual-misconduct-phoenix-11353902 Huff Post, https://www.azcentral.com/story/politicalinsider/2014/07/06/arizona-political-insider-state-news-july6/12169611/ Arizona Republic, https://www.knau.org/post/az-electoral-college-delegates-voted-today NPR, https://www.politico.com/story/2012/12/birther-gop-chair-leaving-office-085396 Politico, https://www.huffpost.com/entry/tom-morrissey-arizona-birther_n_2332819?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAMJoYTwT54QWVdLI2xTHIj7TTqXW1BOSoDnMbfuj0JCx1zO8XnL4AuOSEgtZcSNIk6bhvyAJDighuFRDTCBcNPYR36C4fClXUbItSN-Z5swV_RWdH_mW2RM2RhcwPVQOVlCgkB9KAtDxFFDqRinBUYaPIsnVWB_Oq7VGFxDOpuTI Huff Post again. Much of the coverage came from the birther controversy which isn't even in the article Deletion of Tom Morrissey (Arizona politician) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14558 11381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sudden Sniffing Death Syndrome User:Paul 14:01, 20 July 2009 (UTC) delete I too could find nothing about them beyond their MySpace page, and agree that #A7|CSD A7 would be fine Deletion of Sudden Sniffing Death Syndrome WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14559 8134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khalsa Sporting Club NONE NONE merge Per GS, non-notable amateur team, no indication of team has participated at a level to fulfil let alone GNG Deletion of Khalsa Sporting Club WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14560 7009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meghadootha (Short Movie) User:Anupmehra 04:08, 25 November 2016 (UTC) delete Unable to find any independent coverage. Fails Deletion of Meghadootha (Short Movie) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
14561 13731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deletionpedia (4th nomination) User:Umbralcorax 04:53, 21 February 2010 (UTC) keep Sources in the last AFD show that it meets the , and there's no other policy based reason (copyvio, for deletion. Repeatedly putting the article up for AFD won't change that Deletion of Deletionpedia (4th nomination) WP:GNG||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
14562 16860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willie Cullinane User:Kierzek 15:04, 18 October 2016 (UTC) delete not notable for stand alone article or stub. Just one of many. applies Deletion of Willie Cullinane WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14563 3932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ultimate Fantastic Four (story arcs) User:Psyphics 04:47, 16 October 2006 (UTC) delete per and ; all pertinent information is in Ultimate Fantastic Four already Deletion of Ultimate Fantastic Four (story arcs) WP:WAF||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
14564 1355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Neider User:Trackinfo 02:53, 10 October 2014 (UTC) keep """Yeah it was poorly written, bad links, no sources. It certainly needs some clean up, some of which I added. Had a been done, it is clear this guy is the leader of a notable recording act that has released three albums (though it was a red link because the original editor doesn't know what he's doing). The guy found old tapes that were important enough Dave Grohl got involved remixing and releasing it. The group is going on an """"international"""" tour in 2014, also documented in blacklisted sources that also have interviews with this guy, but confirmed by the Village Voice. I also pointed to another interview with the guy that is not blacklisted. As an individual, he has played in multiple groups, sourced. He achieves several points on for notability as an individual""" Deletion of Mike Neider WP:BEFORE||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14565 13368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Freedom of speech versus blasphemy User:Philg88 06:59, 28 May 2014 (UTC) delete """The """"lede"""" reads like an |essay. It is also unreferenced and inherently |non-neutral. As for the rest of the article, that is an ndiscriminate|indiscriminate list of random factoids and offers no support as to the |notability of the topic""" Deletion of Freedom of speech versus blasphemy WP:ESSAY||WP:NPOV||WP:I||WP:N Wikipedia:Essays 31
14566 16680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Audrey Jones Beck User:Beccaynr 02:14, 15 July 2021 (UTC) keep per above and . Biographical information is also available from https://www.sfgate.com/realestate/article/Quaint-house-listed-to-sell-Hansel-Gretel-2512881.php SFGate, 2003, and there is a nontrivial mention in https://www.texasmonthly.com/articles/the-top-10-foundations/ Texas Monthly, 1997 Deletion of Audrey Jones Beck WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14567 13 [[Benutzer:Bassbottle/Bassbottle]] (erl.) Benutzer:misterjack NONE delete Nutzer 2206 - es grenzt schon arg an zu fordern, den Benutzer zu sperren. Man kann nicht von Neulingen erwarten, sich sofort in unseren Regelwerken auszukennen. Ich habe auf die Unterseite gestellt: ''Nach eigenen Bekunden irrelevant, siehe Löschdiskussion Löschung von Benutzer:Bassbottle/Bassbottle Wikipedia:KPA Wikipedia:No personal attacks 58
14568 2355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Society for Venturism User:Chiswick 15:10, 18 February 2013 (UTC) delete This appears to be pure ; the sources appear to be entirely within that fringe world, and the keep reasons appear to be even where lack of is accepted. It is difficult to see how anything other than delete could reasonably result under WP policy, though perhaps a merge to Cryonics would work Deletion of Society for Venturism WP:FRINGE||WP:ITSUSEFUL||WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
14569 16848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Online sales tricks User:Colonel 18:29, 17 July 2008 (UTC) keep This is not a neologism since these are common words with a straightforward meaning. And, in any case, if there's a problem with the title, we just move/merge the article to a better title - neologism is never a reason to delete, only to rewrite. As for the examples, I have extended the article somewhat and it is open to other editors to flesh it out further per our |editing policy Deletion of Online sales tricks WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
14570 17778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kia Luby User:Mkdw 00:56, 2 February 2013 (UTC) merge As mentioned above, redirect to the cast. Does not meet and a redirect seems appropriate per Deletion of Kia Luby WP:NACTOR||WP:REDIRECT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14571 15440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arab AcademyWikiArticle.pdf User:JohnCD 11:00, 29 February 2008 (UTC) delete this isn't a useful way to put information into WP, but as articles they would get deleted anyway; no |sources, the first document indicates no |notability for its subject, the second is OR|OR Deletion of Arab AcademyWikiArticle.pdf WP:V||WP:N||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14572 13881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/London Surreyshire User:CoffeeCrumbs 06:20, 8 October 2013 (UTC) delete Not remotely encyclopedic about, well, anything. This smells more like a #G1 to me Deletion of London Surreyshire WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14573 6633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled Marilyn Manson album User:Salgado96 15:51, 20 March 2011 (UTC) delete This is a subject that likely will be notable down the road, but not today. If you sift through this article and remove all of the tentative and speculative information, you're left with the group's departure from Interscope Records and two conflicting statements on what the album will sound like (death metal and punk rock are entirely different genres). , and are all looking for concrete verifiable details about an upcoming album, of which there are very little for Marilyn Manson's next album at this point in time. Also Deletion of Untitled Marilyn Manson album WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14574 9381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/R5 productions User:Coredesat 06:09, 29 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of R5 productions WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14575 13520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stubble (webcomic) User:Proto 12:20, 28 February 2006 (UTC) merge to Josh Mirman. Do not keep, fails Deletion of Stubble (webcomic) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14576 13163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lemon Wallet User:Nick 11:57, 1 January 2018 (UTC) keep I've never heard of this product, but independent |reliable sources clearly have. That's what counts Deletion of Lemon Wallet WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14577 8392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glass the Land User:ColourBurst 07:28, 7 August 2006 (UTC) delete Not quite patent nonsense, but pretty close. I have speedied Thenomo as it falls under Deletion of Glass the Land WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14578 12595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gujjula Ravindra Reddy User:Mortee 00:42, 8 January 2018 (UTC) keep """to 'Ravindra Gujjula'. A bit of Googling found http://www.hvk.org/1997/0797/0119.html this, archived from the ''Sunday Times of India'': """"He is Germany's first non-white mayor"""". A bit more googling finds https://www.thelocal.de/20090914/21911 lots http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-national/tp-andhrapradesh/Ravindra-Gujjula-felicitated/article15180723.ece more http://www.nytimes.com/1993/12/21/world/altlandsberg-journal-if-germany-has-a-fever-can-this-doctor-help.html coverage http://www.bild.de/regional/berlin/ravindra-gujjula-hat-geheiratet-8640300.bild.html of http://www.tagesspiegel.de/themen/brandenburg/ravindra-gujjula-rueckt-in-den-landtag/1059676.html him http://www.dw.com/en/indian-born-german-is-running-for-parliament/a-5214125 under http://www.taz.de/!5155683/ this name, which I'd say meets the . I'd guess his middle name is Reddy and the page name is a mistake meant as """"Gujjula, Ravindra Reddy"""". I'd be happy to make the move and start folding the sources in, but perhaps best to wait for the AfD to finish before moving the article""" Deletion of Gujjula Ravindra Reddy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14579 12710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Zealand Young Farmers User:Alan 06:15, 1 September 2011 (UTC) keep Sufficiently notable per and surely that trumps Deletion of New Zealand Young Farmers WP:ORG||WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14580 4368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peddy D User:J04n 20:25, 14 September 2010 (UTC) delete unable to find any reliable sources independent of the subject. Does not meet or Deletion of Peddy D WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14581 7471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Allen Lambert User:Shot 22:52, 8 November 2007 (UTC) delete fails (and per above) and just |not notable Deletion of David Allen Lambert WP:PROF||WP:BIO||WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14582 5224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tests on rollers User:MSJapan 01:24, 20 June 2016 (UTC) delete This is sourced to whatever some random auto club decides they're going to do on YouTube with whatever car they can get their hands on at the time. for sure. This isn't based on |reliable sources; it needs manufacturer's data, not some random silliness in a parking lot Deletion of Tests on rollers WP:CRUFT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
14583 7370 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""Alpha-SEO""""""" User:Morenooso 20:13, 5 June 2010 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails as few if any |veriable |reliable sources can be found. Most are circular to the company website """Deletion of """"Alpha-SEO""""""" WP:CORP||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14584 17119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Is Forever (Say Anything album) User:Doc 16:18, 21 March 2008 (UTC) delete I've heard nothing, i've got nothing from the band and everything in the article is either |crystal ballery or |original research. Considering that the band hasn't even released the second single off their current album yet, i'd wait a bit before making an article about a rumored fourth album Deletion of This Is Forever (Say Anything album) WP:CRYSTAL||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14585 5439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shalwan Pora User:Anupmehra 11:19, 8 November 2016 (UTC) keep Legally recognised populated villages should be kept per . Content issues can be fixed by editing the article or discussing it on article's talk page Deletion of Shalwan Pora WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14586 6814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elixio (2nd nomination) User:Vacation9 18:35, 4 November 2012 (UTC) delete Only one of the sources given independently covered Elixio and it seems like the article is not notable per Deletion of Elixio (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14587 2935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hon-Atsugi Station User:Dekimasu 13:05, 18 February 2007 (UTC) keep per regarding relative notability of train stations in various locations as noted by Deletion of Hon-Atsugi Station WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
14588 18827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Side Down [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']] 07:44, 15 February 2006 (UTC) delete tl|db-band}} candidate, no albums, singles or notable members as per Deletion of This Side Down WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14589 20945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hak Ja Han User:Redddogg 11:09, 23 March 2009 (UTC) comment """for """"keep"""" voters: The article now has 35 sources. Could you refer me to one that would give me any substantial information about Mrs. Han? If not how is this WP article not riginal research? Thank you""" Deletion of Hak Ja Han WP:O Wikipedia:Orphan 47
14590 14569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of current Australian Football League coaches User:Flickerd 11:36, 25 November 2017 (UTC) comment Not at all , but just my interpretation of what was linked to in the original nomination and notability considering the current articles have zero refs. I've had a look at List of current Premier League and English Football League managers which is a and I'm open to withdrawing the nomination (may wait a few days first to see other !votes first just in case) if people believe the AFL pages can emulate that page, for example, I do think that some of the information in the list is still excessive which are available on each coaches Wiki page (i.e. assistant coach club/player club) and the list should solely focus on their current role as a senior coach of the club (which all of the listed examples only focus on current role as senior coach), and not entail their whole career Deletion of List of current Australian Football League coaches WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:FL Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14591 4826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of richest actors User:Northamerica1000 18:07, 10 January 2015 (UTC) keep Passes because the topic has been covered as a group/set by reliable sources. Source examples include: http://abcnews.go.com/Business/richest-actors-world-expect/story?id=23815462 ABC News, http://variety.com/2014/biz/news/jerry-seinfeld-shah-rukh-khan-top-actors-rich-list-1201187780/ Variety, http://magazine.foxnews.com/celebrity/and-worlds-10-richest-actors-possibly-are Fox News Magazine. Also passes and Deletion of List of richest actors WP:LISTN||WP:NLIST||WP:LSC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14592 19878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lanny Silva NONE NONE delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG. With reference to the specific sources in the article Deletion of Lanny Silva WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14593 18007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chinese folklore User:Mermaid 04:04, 27 March 2007 (UTC) keep this is a highly notable subject, with many sources available for satisfying of , and I have no idea how a category could do the same job Deletion of Chinese folklore WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
14594 5767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019 Cricket World Cup User:Eludium 10:45, 26 December 2006 (UTC) keep Passes . Event is scheduled, notable, location is known, and is as certain to take place as anything twelve years hence can be Deletion of 2019 Cricket World Cup WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14595 5204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jahres-Bericht über die Fortschritte der chemischen Technologie für Fabrikanten, Chemiker, Pharmaceuten, Hütten- und Forstleute und Cameralisten User:David 20:54, 15 April 2021 (UTC) keep I found and added two brief reviews of this journal in another journal (both in the same other journal). They're not independent of each other, so the case for is weak, but I think that and the other in-passing references already in the article might barely be enough Deletion of Jahres-Bericht über die Fortschritte der chemischen Technologie für Fabrikanten, Chemiker, Pharmaceuten, Hütten- und Forstleute und Cameralisten WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14596 2079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional characters who can manipulate wind User:Sesshomaru 22:47, 5 September 2007 (UTC) delete per #INFO Deletion of List of fictional characters who can manipulate wind WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14597 4468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Hill (councillor) (2nd nomination) User:Lefcentreright 15:06, 2 December 2019 (UTC) delete Local politician lacking notability. Consequently fails & Deletion of Martin Hill (councillor) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14598 16609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marisa Ingemi User:Coolabahapple 01:57, 3 February 2021 (UTC) delete """does not meet or , nothing found that ticks wikinotability boxes ps. see my (rambling) """"comment"""" @ Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellen Bork""" Deletion of Marisa Ingemi WP:ANYBIO||WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
14599 16577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/N.f.g. User:Royboycrashfan 01:26, 8 March 2006 (UTC) delete a bit shy of 's standards Deletion of N.f.g. WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14600 6474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prof. E.S. Dwarakadasa User:NortyNort 02:22, 12 October 2010 (UTC) keep """per Phil and future improvement. Further """"Notes and examples"""" #11""" Deletion of Prof. E.S. Dwarakadasa WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14601 16876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Cofer User:CaSJer 20:55, 19 December 2012 (UTC) delete Fails , at least for now. If he has a third fight in the UFC, the article can always be recreated Deletion of John Cofer WP:MMANOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14602 16737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Attu tamil short film User:Drm310 15:42, 10 June 2017 (UTC) delete non-notable film; obvious from now-blocked editor Deletion of Attu tamil short film WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14603 16074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mormon men in black User:Thewinchester 05:22, 4 June 2007 (UTC) delete As violating CSD G10, Attack page. As a less active member of the organisation, with a father who was a Bishop, and I myself with significant roles within the church organisation know of no such organisation like this. The article does not meet and , and appears to be original research Deletion of Mormon men in black WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14604 13457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FreeCommander user:czarkoff 22:19, 7 October 2012 (UTC) keep I {{diff2|516538495|added 5 references}} from the first page of Google News search (see link above). All of these are attributed to respected and reliable sources (though none is in English and Žive.cz is a Czech version of Slovak youth-oriented news media to my knowledge), and four of them may be used for purposes. (The fifth one is a download site with editor's review; it is a primary source, so it isn't usable for GNG purposes, but it is comprehensive and thus usable for verification of content.) I didn't search further as these reference seem to be enough for establishing notability of this software. That said, an article is in very poor state, so it probably should be rewritten, which is a problem that can be addressed with editing Deletion of FreeCommander WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14605 3081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Gifty Opoku-Agyeman User:Jayzlimno 22:36, 6 June 2020 (UTC) keep This is a well-referenced article and clearly satisfies . Opoku-Agyeman's establishment of Black Birders Week alone warrants notability which has been covered in many news outlets including CNN and Smithsonian, among others. As others have already stated, this article was not self-created and is properly reporting on a notable figure Deletion of Anna Gifty Opoku-Agyeman WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14606 17683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Children of the Prime Ministers of Canada (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 16:00, 25 July 2018 (UTC) delete Children of Prime Ministers are not inherently notable for that fact — while there are obviously some individual exceptions for people who attained their own standalone notability claims in their own right, they don't automatically |inherit a free notability pass just because their dad was notable. Justin Trudeau and Ben Mulroney and Caroline Mulroney are notable because of their ''own'' accomplishments as ''adults'', not just because their dads happened to be prime ministers. There's no serious value in maintaining a list of the names of every child of every prime minister, however, because most of them aren't of any public interest at all — and the few who are can't reasonably claim to be |defined by the fact as a ''group''. And as I noted above, a decade-old discussion that closed no consensus is not a controlling precedent in and of itself for having to keep this — we need to discuss this strictly on its own merits or lack thereof, not on the fact that we couldn't manage a clear decision on a different article 11 years ago Deletion of Children of the Prime Ministers of Canada (2nd nomination) WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:DEFINING Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14607 19372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanwariaji Mungana User:Bluerasberry 21:22, 5 November 2013 (UTC) delete I am not going to say that this temple does not merit a Wikipedia article, but its creator has not presented evidence of its notability and none seems available though English-language search. Delete for failing and lack of |verifiable sources Deletion of Sanwariaji Mungana WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
14608 456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dudley Henriques User:Lankiveil 11:23, 24 April 2008 (UTC) delete does not meet the notability criteria Deletion of Dudley Henriques WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14609 3166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Azure Flame User:SkierRMH 08:51, 16 December 2006 (UTC) delete per , smells like a 'lets use Wikipedia for advertismnet' ploy Deletion of Azure Flame WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14610 13422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Early Check research study User:Domdeparis 18:08, 23 November 2018 (UTC) delete """as failing to have the necessary sources to pass . The sources are simply reposting what was fed to them as per this quote from ncmedsoc """"We will share more updates with you as we receive them from RTI."""" a couple are almost identical word for word""" Deletion of Early Check research study WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14611 11272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Prator User:Bearian 20:29, 15 April 2010 (UTC) comment There are a few stories about this drummer I found on Google news - http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/sptimes/access/51873073.html?dids=51873073:51873073&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Oct+27%2C+1994&author=MIKE+TAPP&pub=St.+Petersburg+Times&desc=%60Combination'+of+Satriani+and+Van+Halen+Series%3A+Sound+Bite%3B+I.D.+TAMPA&pqatl=google, http://www.sptimes.com/2004/02/15/Floridian/Rhythm_change.shtml, http://www.mtv.com/music/artist/iced_earth/artist.jhtml, http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/tampatribune/access/26089024.html?dids=26089024:26089024&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Jun+06%2C+1997&author=Curtis+Ross&pub=Tampa+Tribune&desc=Skynyrd+remembers&pqatl=google, and http://www.prweb.com/releases/2007/04/prweb517578.htm. Are these enough for him to pass Deletion of Mark Prator WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14612 21523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Killing of Lee Pomeroy User:CoolSkittle 20:06, 6 January 2019 (UTC) delete Almost nominated this myself. Deletion of Killing of Lee Pomeroy WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
14613 17332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/God Is in the TV Zine User:Rhododendrites 18:08, 1 October 2016 (UTC) delete Not finding sufficient reliable sources/coverage to pass . &mdash Deletion of God Is in the TV Zine WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14614 16484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saranga Shrestha NONE NONE keep On basis. I will attempt to convince you of the same (I do have a bias as the creator of the article Deletion of Saranga Shrestha WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
14615 1769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neuralink User:Bilorv 19:09, 8 October 2018 (UTC) keep """I've been mulling this one over for a few days but I'm decided against a merge. I don't know whether Jytdog has me in mind when referring to """"keeping out the typical Musk hype"""" and """"Musk's fanbase in Wikipedia"""" but it should be noted that despite a strong personal dislike of Musk, I stand by my position in Talk:Neuralink/Archive_1#Musk's_timeframes|a lengthy argument I had with Jytdog in April 2017, as the commentary about the timeframes Musk claims (which included criticism) fall under CRYSTALBALL's """"It ''is'' appropriate to report discussion and arguments about the prospects for success of future proposals and projects or whether some development will occur, if discussion is properly referenced"""". This content would make the article a bit more substantial if included. SpinningSpark also notes the presence of sources around Neuralink which are sufficient for GNG (even discounting the examples of theirs which are unreliable""" Deletion of Neuralink WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14616 1622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick McClean User:CAPTAIN 18:44, 10 April 2017 (UTC) delete non-notable footballer. Fails Deletion of Patrick McClean WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
14617 21278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southfork (band) User:Kudpung 17:54, 11 March 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Southfork (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14618 4532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Two Words (film) User:Donaldd23 14:32, 17 January 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Two Words (film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
14619 14012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Mazochi User:QueenCake 18:25, 8 April 2016 (UTC) delete per nom, and also romotion Deletion of Michael Mazochi WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
14620 20793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Bickley (UKIP) User:Graham11 08:29, 15 November 2015 (UTC) delete """per and . If and when he does something notable that provides |significant coverage (such as winning the seat joke|or developing a hobby more interesting than """"walking"""", as the article currently indicates), the article can be rewritten""" Deletion of John Bickley (UKIP) WP:NPOL||WP:POLOUTCOMES||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14621 19465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Micki Free User:Kristen 03:19, 18 January 2009 (UTC) keep per Drmies meets criterion 8 Deletion of Micki Free WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14622 16694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nana Gbewonyo User:Bejnar 20:00, 4 October 2015 (UTC) delete for lack of coverage. Fails . I found one substantive newspaper story about his highschool ball. {{Cite news|author=Bresnahan, Mike|title=Cross-cultural Force |date=29 January 1999|newspaper=The Los Angeles Times |url=http://articles.latimes.com/1999/jan/29/sports/sp-2952 }}. I added it to the article, even though I don't think the article is long for this world Deletion of Nana Gbewonyo WP:BLPNOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14623 15562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nature therapy User:Lubbad85 22:39, 10 April 2019 (UTC) keep Worthy article well sourced and Deletion of Nature therapy WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14624 3469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valdas Pocevičius User:CaSJer 16:54, 19 February 2013 (UTC) delete fails the intention of . The guidelines may not specifically call out that Rings Lithuania isn't the same as :Fighting Network RINGS, but common sense dictates that it's not a top tier organization Deletion of Valdas Pocevičius WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
14625 7702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James E. Robinson (singer) User:Bearian NONE merge he's not independently notable, yet we have Deletion of James E. Robinson (singer) WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
14626 9794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charlie davy User:Stifle 00:08, 27 February 2006 (UTC) delete per and Geogre's law Deletion of Charlie davy WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
14627 12386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of common cold drugs user:Andrew 09:31, 7 March 2015 (UTC) keep A cough is not the same as a cold. References demonstrating that the list satisfies are easy to find - see http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Cold-common/Pages/Treatment.aspx NHS choices, for example Deletion of List of common cold drugs WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14628 6838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Kominas (2nd nomination) User:Sergecross73 12:53, 18 September 2014 (UTC) keep Please, nom, follow through on in the future. Its hard to believe you tried very hard to research this one. Plenty of reliable sources, per above Deletion of The Kominas (2nd nomination) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14629 16862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Reksulak User:Bearian 17:28, 6 March 2020 (UTC) delete per and . I have to point out that https://www.law.gmu.edu/faculty/directory/ he is not even listed as law school faculty and https://masonlec.org/about/leadership-staff/ he is two steps below the center's dean, who in turn reports to the dean of the law school, who in turn .... Sorry Deletion of Michael Reksulak WP:MILL||WP:PEOPLE Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
14630 10518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunny Vaghela User:Ohnoitsjamie 14:23, 3 February 2017 (UTC) delete Yes, he's quoted in the sources, but that's about it. There is zero Wikipedia:Notability_(people)#Basic_criteria|depth of coverage, and as such the subject does not meet Deletion of Sunny Vaghela WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14631 21546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coming Soon (2008 film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 09:14, 16 April 2009 (UTC) keep with no disrespects to the nom, as per |WP:AFTER I have researched, expanded, and sourced the film's article. The assertion in the article, now well sourced, is that it was the director's debut film. Must have been missed when nominating. That aside, it has had multiple reviews (somehow missed too?), some of which I added to the article's reception section. It was not well received, but it managed to get a lot of coverage Deletion of Coming Soon (2008 film) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14632 136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darkrai User:Randomran 01:37, 15 October 2008 (UTC) comment Discussion is certainly preferable to edit warring. |AfD is where Wikipedians discuss whether an article should be deleted, whether we support deletion, keeping, or anything in between. If someone reverts a redirect, soliciting discussion is exactly the right approach Deletion of Darkrai WP:AFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14633 386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giveaway User:Onebravemonkey 12:41, 25 September 2006 (UTC) delete Simply a couple of lines of half-arsed non-specific |VSCA. Hardly worth the trouble Deletion of Giveaway WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
14634 13848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of films featured in ''A Story of Film: An Odyssey'' User:Chris 18:59, 2 February 2012 (UTC) comment See #CRYSTAL. Yes, it's an essay, but the argument is laid out quite well. As for keeping or deleting this list, I'm still undecided Deletion of List of films featured in ''A Story of Film: An Odyssey'' WP:ATA Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14635 20950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Strobl User:Colapeninsula 09:34, 13 May 2013 (UTC) keep per as the co-creator of a significant work. At worst, it should be merged to ''Taking Chance Deletion of Michael Strobl WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14636 11621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Forward (generic name of socialist publications) NONE NONE keep spaced en dash}} The topic meets Wikipedia's |General notability guideline per Deletion of Forward (generic name of socialist publications) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14637 16014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DXFP User:SBKSPP 00:28, 5 June 2021 (UTC) keep Meets per Astig's argument Deletion of DXFP WP:BCAST Wikipedia:Notability 77
14638 16177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atheist's Wager (2nd nomination) User:N2e 23:59, 15 August 2010 (UTC) delete no notability demonstrated in a |reliable secondary source. Merging a lot of unnotable information into Pascal's Wager is not good wikipractice. If however it is merged, only the single claim that is sourced should be merged, even though that source alone does not make the topic notable Deletion of Atheist's Wager (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14639 2881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles H. Thompson (Wisconsin) User:Royalbroil 03:59, 20 February 2014 (UTC) keep Wisconsin Department of Transportation is a major cabinet-level statewide office http://www.jsonline.com/news/statepolitics/112671249.html - NOT obscure. Easily passes point #1. I don't understand how this is being discussed. And per unanimous keeps at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles H. Thompson (besides the same nominator Deletion of Charles H. Thompson (Wisconsin) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14640 10236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lauren Bangs [[User talk:DerbyCountyinNZ|Talk]] [[Special:Contributions/DerbyCountyinNZ|Contribs]]) 19:54, 30 December 2012 (UTC) delete As per nom. Clearly fails . DerbyCountyinNZ Deletion of Lauren Bangs WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14641 20051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Awesome (window manager) User:Psychonaut 15:41, 21 February 2010 (UTC) delete WP:ILIKEIT, , and seem to be the only arguments put forth by those wanting to keep the article. Where are the independent third-party sources Deletion of Awesome (window manager) WP:WELLKNOWN||WP:USEFUL Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
14642 4707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kalanjukittiya Thankam User:Shushugah 15:14, 10 September 2021 (UTC) keep Specifically B7 of says: ''{{green|Check if there are interlanguage links, also in the sidebar, which may lead to more developed and better-sourced articles. Likewise, search for native-language sources if the subject has a name in a non-Latin alphabet (such as Japanese or Greek), which is often in the lede Deletion of Kalanjukittiya Thankam WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14643 5877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JD Scott User:InverseHypercube 18:59, 26 September 2020 (UTC) keep The article meets the notability criteria for individuals in and . JD Scott has articles about them in notable secondary sources, such as ''The Rumpus''https://therumpus.net/2020/06/the-rumpus-interview-with-jd-scott/ and ''Electric Literature''https://electricliterature.com/all-the-best-weird-fiction-comes-from-florida/. They have also received notable awards, such as being a Lambda Literary Fellowhttps://www.lambdaliterary.org/faculty_and_fellows/jd-scott/ and being included in the ''Best New Poets'' anthology Deletion of JD Scott WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14644 9281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yousuf Gabriel User:Kashmiri 17:10, 2 February 2016 (UTC) delete Fails : no independent coverage except for a mention in a local newspaper (I mean, a ''very'' local paper: an internet magazine proudly called ''The Times of Sost'', which is a Pakistani village of a hundred houses or so). Has recently published a single book, itself failing . No slightest indication of significance, either Deletion of Yousuf Gabriel WP:NAUTHOR||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
14645 15970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Young Soulja the Realest User:bojo1498 22:46, 23 March 2017 (UTC) delete Certainly some notability there, but not enough to justify an entire article, per , as mentioned Deletion of Young Soulja the Realest WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14646 15870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frances Fox Piven User:Gavia 02:02, 14 February 2011 (UTC) keep Meets and probably meets for her activism alone, without considering her academic standing. The article definitely needs watching for BLP issues, but it shouldn't be deleted Deletion of Frances Fox Piven WP:ACADEMIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14647 5213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christophe Aubanel User:Govvy 09:35, 15 April 2019 (UTC) keep Easily passes there are sources out there, has played way enough professional football to qualify for an article regardless of its poor quality. Also the nominator should of had a look at the French wikipedia page and would of seen the difference to know this player passes the guideline instead of wasting peoples time with this AfD Deletion of Christophe Aubanel WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14648 3154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MTV Generation (2nd nomination) User:RichyBoy 13:47, 8 September 2007 (UTC) keep The phrase 'MTV Generation' is just as well known and comparable to phrases such as the Swinging Sixties - they are phrases which capture the zeitgeist. However the article absolutely must be re-written as without in-line citations the article is partly a |synthesis and comprises |original research. Also, there is absolutely no-way an article like this is a candidate for speedy deletion Deletion of MTV Generation (2nd nomination) WP:SYN||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14649 19362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shane McKay User:Alzarian16 15:04, 24 January 2011 (UTC) merge to the list. None of the sources actually address the character in any great detail and I couldn't find anything else by searching, so he would appear to fail and on his own Deletion of Shane McKay WP:GNG||WP:NFICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14650 5131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drane Scrivener User:Wjemather 14:58, 26 February 2021 (UTC) delete lack of overrides any trivial pass of any part of . We can keep his name in a list, if a suitable one exists Deletion of Drane Scrivener WP:SIGCOV||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14651 8441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evolutionary Relativity User:SudoGhost 07:03, 10 April 2011 (UTC) delete as per . Possibly as well Deletion of Evolutionary Relativity WP:OR||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:No original research 65
14652 5751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NASCAR Criticism User:Koweja 23:49, 31 December 2007 (UTC) keep it's not a POV fork, it's a page split. See NASCAR#Criticism and . It should be moved to Criticism of NASCAR to keep in line with naming conventions, but the content is perfectly acceptable Deletion of NASCAR Criticism WP:SPINOUT Wikipedia:Article size 51
14653 15098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tintanga Estate User:DEFCON5 14:12, 15 April 2021 (UTC) delete agree with the nominator that it fails to exist as a separate article Deletion of Tintanga Estate WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14654 21372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdullah Nabeel Al Ahmad (2nd nomination) User:GiantSnowman 11:56, 17 September 2009 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Abdullah Nabeel Al Ahmad (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14655 17657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacqueline Bobak User:Bearian 00:30, 31 March 2015 (UTC) keep per . The reviews at ''Variety'' and the ''LA Times'' are substantial enough to push her over the GNG threshold Deletion of Jacqueline Bobak WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
14656 6799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wu Cheng Yi User:Collectonian 07:31, 10 January 2008 (UTC) delete unnotable character that fails . Would say redirect, but article doesn't actually say what show(s) the character is in Deletion of Wu Cheng Yi WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
14657 11063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trey Scott Atwater User:Mark 03:36, 11 January 2012 (UTC) delete Looks like a textbook case of to me Deletion of Trey Scott Atwater WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
14658 13526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Banco de Ponce (disambiguation) User:Siuenti 07:03, 10 May 2017 (UTC) keep """or '''redirect''', plausible search term for anyone who doesn't know how many notable entities there are called """"Banco de Ponce"""". No need to create inkrot""" Deletion of Banco de Ponce (disambiguation) WP:L Wikipedia:Lists 97
14659 4401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Brothahood User:ShadowHalo 21:54, 16 December 2006 (UTC) delete Fails , very weak assertion of notability Deletion of The Brothahood WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14660 7941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of concerts at Barclays Center User:Diego 07:39, 13 January 2014 (UTC) keep """per or merge per Trevj. Indiscriminate doesn't apply, as the list is finite, relatively short and with a clear inclusion criterion, so it doesn't match in any way what INDISCRIMINATE is about. WP:INDISCRIMINATE was created to avoid the project become everything2 or DMOZ; but this is not a """"list of all ISP providers in Indiana"""" or """"list of health-related websites"""". The problems that the 2014 section may have don't justify deleting the whole page""" Deletion of List of concerts at Barclays Center WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14661 14945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Serron Noel User:Barrettsprivateers 05:14, 10 May 2020 (UTC) keep he meets the requirements Deletion of Serron Noel WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14662 6650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alasdair Fraser User:Craig 15:03, 16 February 2006 (UTC) keep as per Deletion of Alasdair Fraser WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14663 6493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spacepol User:Jreferee 05:23, 16 August 2007 (UTC) delete Spam and libelous allegations can be fixed. However, I could find no English |reliable source material for this topic. If that source material is in Finnish, then it should be at least back by someone vouching for its content as posted on the English Wikipedia. Until then, delete as not meeting Deletion of Spacepol WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14664 6058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Parker (California politician) User:onel5969 18:44, 24 August 2015 (UTC) delete doesn't meet either or Deletion of Mike Parker (California politician) WP:GNG||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14665 1490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Anthony Hall User:Crisco 13:29, 6 August 2011 (UTC) delete as blatant self-promotion and advertising under |G11 Deletion of David Anthony Hall WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14666 4667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Actuarial Outpost User:Kicking222 15:32, 19 May 2006 (UTC) delete per many of the editors above. The NY Times article means nothing- it ''mentions'' actuarialoutpost. It's not like the article is ''about'' the site. The site fails , period Deletion of Actuarial Outpost WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14667 4601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evolution of Music Management User:Nsk92 18:55, 8 May 2008 (UTC) delete Almost pure Deletion of Evolution of Music Management WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14668 9565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Social Concerns episodes User:Sarilox 21:28, 2 December 2009 (UTC) delete Hoax. No evidence that this show exists. I had already |PROD'd the article as a hoax and no one had removed it so AfD was a little premature, but now that we're here... This article was modeled after List of Cory in the House episodes, just as the other article I PROD'd, Social concerns, was also modeled after Cory in the House. The similarities are obvious and some of the information wasn't even changed Deletion of List of Social Concerns episodes WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
14669 19842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Save the Eyes Foundation User:Pharaoh 02:35, 28 November 2017 (UTC) delete per nom Fails and .Started only in 2016 not notable at this point and only coverage in Non RS sources is about fund raising Deletion of Save the Eyes Foundation WP:ORG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
14670 1172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr Schlong user:DakotaKahn 05:05, 6 May 2006 (UTC) delete nn band fails Deletion of Dr Schlong WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14671 21533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aranye Maniac Killer Mystery User:Sam 17:45, 26 January 2017 (UTC) delete Sources to meet have not been found; delete per Deletion of Aranye Maniac Killer Mystery WP:NFP||WP:DEL8 Wikipedia:Notability 77
14672 19906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rick Donovan User:Joe 15:35, 5 December 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |pornographic actor Deletion of Rick Donovan WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14673 13585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kavalsky (2nd nomination) User:MrsSnoozyTurtle 11:02, 31 August 2021 (UTC) delete lacks sources to establish Deletion of Kavalsky (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14674 5323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finest Hour (quartet) User:Aguyintobooks 09:25, 3 September 2017 (UTC) keep I see enough sources to (just) meet and guidelines. There is no requirement for any 'non-music source', nor is their getting an award discounted due to the award not having an article. Despite various arguments about their world prominence, that is not relevant, the world number 124,000th quartet has an equal chance of being notable, what matters are |reliable independent sources Deletion of Finest Hour (quartet) WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14675 2740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gopal Krishna Trivedi User:AustralianRupert 04:57, 5 November 2016 (UTC) delete doesn't seem to satisfy the requirement for |significant coverage. Regards Deletion of Gopal Krishna Trivedi WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
14676 21564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/L.I.F.E political party NONE 22:13, 18 October 2007 (UTC) delete """like the previous editor said, Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day|Wikipedia is not for things made up one day ... a ''two day old'' political party is by definition """"non-notable"""" ... too bad it doesn't qualify as a #A7|speedy delete (A7). —{{User|72.75.79.128""" Deletion of L.I.F.E political party WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14677 398 [[Richard Fiedler (Ingenieur)]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Carsaig 14:11, 18. Sep. 2014 (CEST) delete Wo ist der Mehrwert für den Leser? Über Richard Fiedler erfährt man in diesem Artikel rein gar nichts über diejenigen Informationen hinaus, die schon im Artikel Flammenwerfer stehen. Der halbe Text beschäftigt sich zudem mehr mit seinem Konkurrenten bzw. Parallelerfinder Reddemann. Da würde ich mich als Leser schlicht verar... fühlen, wenn ich im Artikel Flammenwerfer auf einen Artikel zum Erfinder stoße, diesen neugierig anklicke und dann keinerlei neue Informationen bekomme. Lediglich die Liste von Fiedlers Patenten ist eine zusätzliche Information, aber dazu fällt mir nur , Punkt 7 ein. Patente zu halten macht alleine eh nicht relevant Löschung von Richard Fiedler (Ingenieur) Wikipedia:Was Wikipedia nicht ist Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14678 21902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elaine Kim User:Mendaliv 06:59, 24 June 2008 (UTC) merge """She may have some coverage in |reliable sources. Check Google News for ''""""Elaine Kim"""" fashion''; though many of the sources are not available to me. The article as it is written is unacceptable, however, and definitely violates |conflict of interest and is probably largely |original research""" Deletion of Elaine Kim WP:RS||WP:COI||WP:OR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14679 6662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Possessions (film 2009) User:MichaelQSchmidt 23:27, 10 August 2009 (UTC) delete without prejudice and allow back when it gets more |press. Film is not a hoax, as it has been covered by ''http://login.vnuemedia.com/hr/login/login_subscribe.jsp?id=HkzkwiNFFSENWCNfh6yWsLz6Xpz5LMmcGzlivJFIARvrmio%2BfslMoVlFBZbyFUEcCRlozHsNQL35%0AwBJLB8%2B8eVboWQw7wD%2Fpi%2FqLBuNoXQfKZH%2BnYKnzK%2B%2FrdtG7r8J9J2MVpEACIF4tW%2BmcZ7N1XUls%0A0wkCsU%2F25%2Bj37qFTZIndNM9ShBVYCnGJw3PAuLlzlroe4oabmH1eSkzMpt9bP5xgzqfbSISMmtat%0Ah76Sp3E4JiAtnV3Hyjapi5Fk9EG18Tn1lk3Ny7d4wE%2BgYF37toKj3WUXDdak0Cq56UGELkKkznYh%0AYTmg0gk%2BlXyO7pd5zgyy%2BdHJpzh3dZMrmLe0ZeXqTVXLjW84%2F2tn3C%2BL50s%3D Hollywood Reporter'' and ''http://www.cinematical.com/tag/TrentFord/ Cinematical'', but it needs a bit more to meet |notability guidelines Deletion of Possessions (film 2009) WP:GNG||WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14680 19025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Wyllie User:GiantSnowman 17:57, 27 July 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Aaron Wyllie WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14681 16275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr who and harry potter User:Otolemur 15:20, 16 February 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Dr who and harry potter WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14682 10322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vector Prime User:Dream 15:43, 23 July 2014 (UTC) keep Star Wars novels get reviewed at places that review this sort of thing. http://www.theforce.net/books/reviews/r_apracticalman.asp Its ridiculous to delete articles that are confirmed bestsellers, while thinking a book that failed to sell any reasonable number of copies can have an article because two random people reviewed it in a couple of obscure low selling newspapers somewhere. does apply here Deletion of Vector Prime WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
14683 21323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brooke Montgomery Lessig User:Icewhiz 12:25, 11 November 2018 (UTC) delete Colonel - doesn't pass . In my BEFOREing I mainly see some coverage from Military Order of the Loyal Legion of the United States, a congressional testimony in his capacity there, and a bit of local press (over many years) from Pottstown, Pennsylvania publications Deletion of Brooke Montgomery Lessig WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
14684 14321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Opencola (company) [[User_talk:Black Kite|Black Kite (talk)]] 16:39, 2 April 2018 (UTC) delete and possibly redirect to OpenText afterwards). As described above, in no way is met here. A few mentions in minor sources about a technology they created does not provide sufficient notability for the company itself Deletion of Opencola (company) WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
14685 15283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Titan Fighting Championships 16 User:El3ctr1csheepz 04:33, 14 June 2013 (UTC) delete Not notable enough to meet requirements Deletion of Titan Fighting Championships 16 WP:SPORTSEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14686 3055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khao Chang Puek User:Antepenultimate 05:59, 19 November 2016 (UTC) comment after https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Khao_Chang_Puek&curid=52272719&diff=750356042&oldid=750109967 removing a great deal of promo fluff, this seems to be an article about a mountain rather than a hike, and as such should be judged by standards. No comment as yet whether it passes those standards Deletion of Khao Chang Puek WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14687 15605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naseer Soomro (2nd nomination) User:Bonadea 18:52, 14 April 2018 (UTC) delete I cannot see that is met Deletion of Naseer Soomro (2nd nomination) WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14688 19893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank Miniter User:Bearcat 04:34, 26 August 2019 (UTC) delete """Having written a purportedly but not sourcedly best-selling book might get him over AUTHOR if the article were |properly referenced, but it is not an """"inherent"""" notability freebie that ''exempts'' a person from actually having to have any sources — bestsellerdom is a thing that writers ''often'' falsely claim to have achieved in their publicity materials when they actually achieved no such thing at all, so the notability test is not what the article does or doesn't ''say'', but how well it does or doesn't ''reference'' the things it says to ''reliable sources'' that properly ''verify'' those things as ''true''. And being a guest on talk radio is not a notability claim either — he has to be the ''subject'' being spoken ''about'', not the person ''doing'' the speaking on some other subject, for a reference to support his notability, so the improperly cited Q&A interview in which he's talking about hunting does not help""" Deletion of Frank Miniter WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14689 9749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Telephone bill User:Yoninah 20:40, 23 June 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Telephone bill WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14690 2790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paolo Sitanggang User:GiantSnowman 19:20, 28 January 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Paolo Sitanggang WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14691 714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas J. Devine User:I9Q79oL78KiL0QTFHgyc 03:44, 13 May 2015 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Thomas J. Devine WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14692 6334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcus Stanley (pianist) User:TTTommy111 00:51, 30 June 2015 (UTC) delete I really want to find a reason to keep this article as it is a great story http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2014/12/02/he-was-shot-eight-times-with-a-45-caliber-and-what-he-says-he-saw-while-he-believed-he-was-dying-he-describes-as-supernatural/, but unfortunately there is not enough to show . Also, I normally would not vote to salt an article; however, there is a big reason why I will for this. The article was previously created under Marcus Stanley and deleted after discussion. The fact that is was recreated under a disambiguation shows me that someone is trying to get around the system. As such, I would vote to salt both this and the original. Have them take it to Articles For Creation next time Deletion of Marcus Stanley (pianist) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14693 8636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arman Aharonyan User:TreyGeek 01:12, 16 January 2012 (UTC) delete """Can find no information about an MMA fighter by this name. Article states that the subject is """"semi-pro"""" and thus likely fails """ Deletion of Arman Aharonyan WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14694 5176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanguinary User:wknight94 03:56, 31 January 2006 (UTC) delete Non-notable band per . Released only one full-length album - suggests two full length albums on major labels. No mentions on Amazon or AllMusic. Discography present so I didn't speedy Deletion of Sanguinary WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14695 20456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MyNCRE (My No Commission Real Estate) User:Cedars 04:03, 26 August 2006 (UTC) delete poorly written, does not meet and not suitable for Wikipedia Deletion of MyNCRE (My No Commission Real Estate) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14696 19435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inconsistencies in Gilmore Girls User:Peripitus 23:20, 4 January 2007 (UTC) delete as completely |original research no references of any type and searching around I can't find any that are not fanzines/blogs Deletion of Inconsistencies in Gilmore Girls WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14697 6310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Sinnicks User:Aust331 16:00, 25 June 2016 (UTC) delete The strongest references I could find within the article were these two CBC links: http://music.cbc.ca/#!/artists/Big-Eddy-and-The-Trailer-Park-5 and http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/news/men-without-hats-psychedelic-furs-and-big-wreck-headline-festival-of-friends-1.3126204, both of which would not qualify the article for Deletion of Steven Sinnicks WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14698 9474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Love $ Greed User:Encyclopædius 07:56, 12 July 2020 (UTC) delete I looked for something substantial but there is nothing out there that could possibly satisfy . All the sources proffered in the article or above by Deletion of Love $ Greed WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
14699 20395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethiopian Orthodox Tehadeso Church User:Bearian 17:12, 21 November 2014 (UTC) delete unreferenced and |unable to verify and claims Deletion of Ethiopian Orthodox Tehadeso Church WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14700 4506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alfredo Angulo vs. James Kirkland User:Secret 02:42, 27 September 2011 (UTC) delete fails , nothing confirmed Deletion of Alfredo Angulo vs. James Kirkland WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14701 14361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank Whitney (boxer) User:Jakejr 06:24, 27 May 2014 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet or Deletion of Frank Whitney (boxer) WP:NBOX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14702 12512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of Buddhist Monasteries in the Asia-Pacific Region User:Ajf773 15:41, 7 February 2017 (UTC) delete per and . Article does not appear encyclopedic either Deletion of Comparison of Buddhist Monasteries in the Asia-Pacific Region WP:NOR||WP:NOTINHERETED Wikipedia:No original research 65
14703 2182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amb Jogi User:Atlantic306 19:16, 30 March 2018 (UTC) keep passes criteria 12 of having been the subject of national television coverage, and has coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Amb Jogi WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14704 18584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fuse (Oddbods) User:Masumrezarock100 03:21, 23 June 2019 (UTC) delete Obviously fails . Wikipedia is not a |fanwiki Deletion of Fuse (Oddbods) WP:GNG||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14705 15497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Thessalonians User:Student7 20:25, 30 July 2010 (UTC) keep Notability is defined by having an article for all of Wikipedia. See . Complaint above seems to say that lede should be changed to reflect notability requirements, which are the same throughout the encyclopedia. I do not agree with this, nor think that an Afd is the proper way to get the lede changed, in any event Deletion of List of Thessalonians WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14706 17941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grammarly (2nd nomination) User:K 05:22, 5 March 2019 (UTC) keep meets and the article is not G11-promotional Deletion of Grammarly (2nd nomination) WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14707 12975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Renée Gunter [[User talk:Jim Carter - Public|Jim Carter (''from public cyber'')]]''' 09:40, 20 August 2014 (UTC) keep per the improvements by Melanie and Tomwsulcer. Meets Deletion of Renée Gunter WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14708 10334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Degree programs at Duke University User:JohnCD 16:40, 16 March 2009 (UTC) delete per and . This level of detail is not appropriate for an encyclopedia - anyone interested can go from the Duke University article to their website, where the information is more likely to be kept up-to-date Deletion of Degree programs at Duke University WP:IINFO||WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14709 3015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Yamaha Portasound keyboards User:Superastig 06:12, 28 May 2020 (UTC) merge to Yamaha Portasound: Article easily fails . My vote stands Deletion of List of Yamaha Portasound keyboards WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14710 1925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DWER User:4meter4 22:34, 6 November 2019 (UTC) delete Lacks RS. Fails Deletion of DWER WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
14711 15948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people who became famous through being terminally ill User:Serpent 14:05, 25 December 2006 (UTC) delete """Probably an |indiscriminate list of information, but that argument aside, fundamentally requires unacceptable POV determinations. does not provide the tools for editors to determine whether a terminally ill person became """"famous"""" as a result of their illness or accessory to it, nor does it empower a determination of what """"famous"""" entails for these purposes. The latter could be somewhat mitigated by renaming the list to """"...notable..."""", but that is a poor solution that would allow the inclusion requirements to change if and when is revised further and that does nothing about the editorial determination issues regarding the cause of fame/notability""" Deletion of List of people who became famous through being terminally ill WP:NOT||WP:NPOV||WP:BIO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14712 5717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seamus (dog) (2nd nomination) User:Tarc 15:13, 24 April 2012 (UTC) delete Or merge. Simple ; dog tied to car, ideological foes make hay of it during political silly season. Give it a mention in Romney's campaign article if need be, the sources mentioned justify that much . Not a standalone Deletion of Seamus (dog) (2nd nomination) WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14713 118 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ali Rıza Babaoğlan """Kullanıcı:levent_abilevent abi""" 18:34, 7 Eylül 2007 (UTC) delete """Aslında isimsiz yüzlerce kahramandan biri. Sıradan bir """"hacker"""" olma yerine tutup üretmeyi seçmiş, olumlu yönde ve bilimsel bir alanda çalışıyor. Ama var ortada""" Ali Rıza Babaoğlan'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
14714 981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MyBusTickets (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 04:53, 19 November 2016 (UTC) delete Per source searches and analysis of available sources, this company/website does not meet or at this time Deletion of MyBusTickets (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:WEBCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14715 5971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Munna Yadav User:Narky 09:41, 30 November 2020 (UTC) keep """Per - """"The following are presumed to be notable: Politicians ... who ... (for countries with federal or similar systems of government) ... have been members of legislative bodies at those levels."""" India is in that class of country, just like e.g. USA""" Deletion of Munna Yadav WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14716 3393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marc Gracie User:VMS 03:25, 10 January 2015 (UTC) keep Available cites may be a little on the thin side, but mainly oppose because y is a misuse of this process Deletion of Marc Gracie WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
14717 8043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fred White (musician) NONE NONE keep This page meets , , specifically:Section 1.of (under Has been the subject of multiple, non-trivial, published works appearing in sources that are reliable, not self-published, and are independent of the musician or ensemble itself) and passes Deletion of Fred White (musician) WP:NMG||WP:NMUSIC||WP:NM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14718 7277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vougar Garadaghly User:RayAYang 15:56, 19 December 2012 (UTC) delete Subject may be notable in his native language, but that is not demonstrated by anything so far in the discussion, and is not verifiable by any means we who do not speak Azeri or Russian possess. We may need to stick in some sort of codicil to our notability criteria that reminds people that this is an ''English'' language site, so subjects so far outside the cognizance of the English-speaking world as to not have good sourcing on them in English might not be good subjects for English Wikipedia articles. So this might be closer to a fail of than Deletion of Vougar Garadaghly WP:V||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14719 17 [[Kernkraftwerk Visaginas]] LAE 217.5.204.78|217.5.204.78]] 14:19, 21. Mai 2010 (CEST NONE keep so groß angekündigtes Projekt hat alleine durch die relativ großen regionalen Medien Wirkung, alleine, dass bereits jetzt schon begonnen wird, die Infrastruktur des alten KKW für das neue umzulegen. Ähnliche Diskussion /13. April 2008#Kernkraftwerk Leningrad II (bleibt)|gab es bereits bzgl. des Kernkraftwerk Leningrad II. Das Projekt war ungefähr zu dieser Zeit genauso fortgeschritten wie aktuell die Arbeiten für ein Kernkraftwerk in Visaginas, daher meine Beurteilung. Grüße Löschung von Kernkraftwerk Visaginas Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14720 19712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ken Evoy User:Ronz 18:31, 26 January 2007 (UTC) delete The information now available in Talk makes an insufficient case for notability per Deletion of Ken Evoy WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14721 21105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of modern production plug-in electric vehicles user:Andrew 16:07, 28 January 2021 (UTC) keep There are obviously more types of vehicle than cars -- there are cycles, trucks, buses, &c. This probably should become a list of lists but organising that is not a matter for AfD per Deletion of List of modern production plug-in electric vehicles WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14722 13981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Shape of Things to Come (The O.C.) User:Jclemens 19:02, 3 October 2011 (UTC) merge Per , to a season or list of episode articles. There's no reason to delete this entirely, as it can meet V by being primarily sourced Deletion of The Shape of Things to Come (The O.C.) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
14723 17439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Good Man User:Rjd0060 13:57, 9 October 2007 (UTC) delete Per above. (|NN Deletion of A Good Man WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14724 7722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Latifa Mammadova User:Gilded 15:26, 24 July 2019 (UTC) keep I added several sources-- I think the subject passes , though it can be tricky to find sources due to language barriers / different transliterations of her name Deletion of Latifa Mammadova WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14725 10921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RTextDoc User:Msnicki 02:45, 1 December 2013 (UTC) delete Lacks reliable independent secondary sources to establish notability as required by . Sources offered are primary and thus unsuitable. Googling turns up nothing useful Deletion of RTextDoc WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14726 19216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radio Alpine User:Ohconfucius 04:32, 6 June 2008 (UTC) delete Again, another |non-notable radio station. The citations in the article are to personal websites or fansites, which fail Deletion of Radio Alpine WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14727 14560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mandaluyong high school User:TerriersFan 01:23, 16 July 2011 (UTC) keep """the reasons why keep high schools are given in the essay . No article is """"fundamentally flawed"""". The way forward is to add verification sources and cut it back to a stub. Google searches are of limited us for Filipino schools because of their poor Internet presence. To avoid systemic bias ample time should be given for local sources to be found""" Deletion of Mandaluyong high school WP:NHS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14728 21783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Imtiaz najim User:Toddst1 19:02, 14 July 2016 (UTC) delete The assertion of significance fails the two part test at Wikipedia:Credible claim of significance - it is not credible. CSD#A7 decline was in error. It is also a Hoax - #G3 Deletion of Imtiaz najim WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14729 1550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Georgi Yochev User:Chiro725 17:49, 22 April 2021 (UTC) comment A silver in 2018 European Youth Weightlifting Championships|European Youth Weightlifting Championships counts for . Not sure about Deletion of Georgi Yochev WP:NSPORTS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14730 10471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs portraying sexual attraction to children or adolescents User:Spellcast 06:24, 8 April 2008 (UTC) delete Fails , , #5, and largely amounts to |original research. The cited http://s-fe.com/Singing_the_song_of_child_sexual_assault ref (which uses copyvio YouTube videos and lyrics) is of course not a reliable source because it's just a wiki Deletion of List of songs portraying sexual attraction to children or adolescents WP:V||WP:RS||WP:DIRECTORY||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14731 21437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All Too Flat User:Quarl 09:27, 30 December 2005 (UTC) delete as |non-notable website. &mdash Deletion of All Too Flat WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14732 1387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Activate (organisation) User:Bonadea 09:44, 6 April 2018 (UTC) keep even a cursory look at the sources shows that there is significant coverage in multiple reliable and independent sources, so the group easily meets |the relevant notability guideline Deletion of Activate (organisation) WP:ORGCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14733 13141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tropical cyclones in popular culture User:Otto4711 12:52, 25 July 2007 (UTC) delete """I am curious as to what exactly would lead someone reading this AFD to conclude that """"the guys who don't like these articles seem to think its pretty good."""" I mean, one person said that it's not as bad as other similar articles but how one goes from that to the above conclusion is more than a little mystifying. Regardless, as with so many other articles of this ilk, this one is a #DIR|directory of loosely associated topics. This list does not increase our understanding of tropical cyclones, the fiction from which the references are drawn, how the listed items relate to each other, or the real world""" Deletion of Tropical cyclones in popular culture WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14734 20824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ozark Air Lines Flight 982 User:Necrothesp 12:13, 19 June 2019 (UTC) comment I'm not going to comment on the notability, but it certainly does ''not'' fail or and I'm mystified as to why you think it does Deletion of Ozark Air Lines Flight 982 WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14735 1214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aziz Shavershian User:A412 03:10, 2 March 2012 (UTC) keep """Quoting the |GNG, """"If a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to satisfy the inclusion criteria for a stand-alone article or stand-alone list."""" It does not matter what he is being covered for, but that he is being covered. See - unless we are going to have an article titled """"Death of Aziz Shavershian"""", the article about him should be created instead. As for the content concerns, remember that |AFD is not cleanup""" Deletion of Aziz Shavershian WP:GNG||WP:1E||WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14736 11900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Víctor Ortiz User:IJA 11:26, 8 October 2014 (UTC) delete Neither have played in a Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|Fully professional league and they don't have any senior international caps either therefore they both fail Deletion of Víctor Ortiz WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14737 12763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S&m User:Mendaliv 19:38, 24 June 2008 (UTC) delete This is yet another |non-notable drinking game violating FT. Don't forget to kill the images :Image:S&m drinking game score rules.jpg and :Image:N620395836 1371802 100.jpg that have no purpose other than this article Deletion of S&m WP:N||WP:NFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14738 13286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Hogg User:CookieMonster755 17:17, 21 February 2018 (UTC) keep """let's examine what is being put on the shelf here. Mainly, and . If we take a look at , it states that a topic is presumed to be suitable for a stand-alone article when certain conditions apply. This condition includes the following: {{tq|""""Significant coverage"""" addresses the topic directly and in detail, so that no original research is needed to extract the content}} – based on the sources that Tomsulcer provide, the sources in the article and outside sources, there are several articles that discuss this subject in depth. He does meet this criteria for a stand alone article. All sources that are discussing him and his work in depth are reliable. The second thing we must examine is . His notability ''initially'' came from his status as a survivor of the Stoneman Douglas High School shooting, but now includes his work for gun control advocacy ''after'' the shooting took place. Now we beg the question, is the ''shooting'' and its ''aftermath'' a ''different'' event from the coverage and discussion regarding 2018 ''gun control advocacy'' – though these events are related, are they considered ''two'' different events? Well, let's look at BLP1E. It states {{tq|Being in the news does not in itself mean that someone should be the subject of a Wikipedia article. We generally should avoid having an article on a person when each of three conditions is met}} – the first condition is {{tq|If reliable sources cover the person only in the context of a single event}}. Does David Hogg, in which articles discuss him, only feature him on the context of a single event? It seems, based on several factors, that the 2018 gun control advocacy and the shooting at MSD are ''separate'' events. Reliable sources discuss his role in both of these events, focusing on the latter and his involvement in gun control advocacy. The second criteria is {{tq|If that person otherwise remains, and is likely to remain, a low-profile individual}}. Based on reliable sources, it is ''unlikely'' that David Hogg will become a low-profile individual based on his work in the 2018 gun advocacy movement following the MSDHS shooting. Based on factoring of these criteria, I support a weak keep. We can ''always'' examine notability at a later time. Wikipedia is not in a rush to delete, create or re-create articles if needed""" Deletion of David Hogg WP:GNG||WP:BLP1E||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
14739 17164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeek User:K 05:35, 28 September 2016 (UTC) comment at this point, the article establishes that it exists solely to promote the business. It should be delete as . Once Wikipedia starts accepting such promotional articles, it will lose its value as an encyclopedia. also apply Deletion of Zeek WP:PROMO||WP:ENN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14740 15650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward Vinatea (2nd nomination) User:Jrod2 17:56, 16 September 2010 (UTC) keep Drmies is looking to establish as as a musician...Yo, thats not why this subject has an article here. He is an audio engineer and became worthy of WP inclusion the moment one of his artists was nominated for a Grammy (check http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/0e/Pop_grammy_list_for_-Best-Pop-Vocal-2006.pdf Ashley Altman Grammy award nomination 2006 (listed as #6) from the book itself) Some stuff can be found at Allmusic.com & some stuff at http://www.discogs.com/Ashley-Altman-Dont-Stress/release/1493948 Discogs. It's obvious the Allmusic doesn't list him as engineer on so many titles. Case in point is http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sql=10:wxfuxqrdld0e~T2 Altman's album. He also works with professionals you've never heard of like Ed Chalpin which you made a personal attack here http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Edward_Vinatea&diff=prev&oldid=385086746 and Kimo Kaulani. To verify all this, Google is your best friend, use it Deletion of Edward Vinatea (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14741 15279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rusty trombone (3rd nomination) User:HisSpaceResearch 17:45, 8 July 2007 (UTC) comment Wikipedia is not a directory of (definitions of and references in pop culture to) slang, vulgar definitions of highly uncommon extreme sex acts which are known more as apocryphal jokes than as things that people actually do. Who would truly dispute that per Deletion of Rusty trombone (3rd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14742 18271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark William Shaw NONE NONE keep Besides the earlier cited qualifying https://www.nj.com/sports/ledger/dorfman/2011/08/dorfman_mark_shaw_is_making_th.html August 2011 article in the The Star-Ledger I have found https://books.google.com/books?id=JuoCAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA176&q=%22The%20Great%20Fall%22#v=snippet&q=%22The%20Great%20Fall%22&f=false this which was published in the September 2001 ''Indianapolis Monthly'' and both covers the subject and his opinions/thought about an event Deletion of Mark William Shaw WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14743 21338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edvard Hovhannisyan User:Edgars2007 17:38, 20 November 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Edvard Hovhannisyan WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14744 15029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cat Zingano User:Mkdw 03:30, 15 December 2013 (UTC) keep WP:SIGCOV supersedes the MMA guideline in this case as does Deletion of Cat Zingano WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14745 134 [[Felix Thönnessen]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Gerbil NONE delete Der Versuch, zumindest zu touchieren, wurde vom Ersteller gar nicht erst versucht. (Nebenbei: Die Polemik gegen bestimmte TV-Sparten gehört absolut nicht in eine LD Löschung von Felix Thönnessen Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
14746 9807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Payne User:Angelo 15:04, 26 September 2008 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Josh Payne WP:ATHLETE||WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14747 15798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce A. Block User:Michig 15:24, 19 October 2008 (UTC) keep This article in no way reads like an advertisement. Enough contributors to suggest a violation is doubtful. Sources, Google hits, and allmovie details suggest notability Deletion of Bruce A. Block WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14748 15675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emma Hunton User:Captain 11:12, 30 May 2008 (UTC) keep """She has appeared in multiple stage performances as shown in these sources, ''Spring Awakening'' http://www.playbill.com/news/article/115176.html and ''Les Miz'' http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-689054_ITM, Distracted http://www.broadwayworld.com/viewcolumn.cfm?colid=17010. The article does need work but as it states in """"If the page can be improved, this should be solved through regular editing, rather than deletion""" Deletion of Emma Hunton WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
14749 6878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gōzoku User:Cullen328 08:04, 25 November 2011 (UTC) comment """Student7 asks """"Is gozuku commonly used as a term in English"""", and in response, I would say that yes, this is the common term used in English for discussing this specific topic in Japanese history. Student7 also ask """"Will the policy regarding the use of commonly used terms in English"""" be enforced or not?"""" My response is that I see nothing about the title or the article itself that violates the policy , Can you please quote specific policy language that you believe is violated here? Thank you""" Deletion of Gōzoku WP:TITLE Wikipedia:Article titles 75
14750 16080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jekejeke Prolog User:Yakushima 15:43, 10 May 2012 (UTC) comment Jan Burse has extensively tampered with the discussion. As of this comment of mine, I have reverted a great deal of edits he made that deleted a number of comments, mine included. (I haven't bothered to add back in the comments he added in the process.) In so doing, he is also disguising the fact that he voted '''Keep''' originally, and that he has a for this article Deletion of Jekejeke Prolog WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14751 21838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paintmash User:Tellyaddict 16:43, 16 March 2007 (UTC) delete Could be seen as |spam per the comment by another user above, low |notability and its too irrelevant to even consider a move to wiktionary Deletion of Paintmash WP:SPAM||WP:NN Wikipedia:Spam 112
14752 1096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jubbly User:Miquonranger03 16:50, 9 September 2008 (UTC) delete per (and above), since all I can find is people using the phrase wubbly-jubbly again and again. Even that's not appropriate for inclusion, since it seems to be a neologism Deletion of Jubbly WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14753 18418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brandon K. Rush User:The 10:15, 12 September 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Brandon K. Rush WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14754 13336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Political game theory User:Mark 18:21, 11 March 2016 (UTC) keep As mentioned in my comment above, there exist in depth reliable references that discuss the topic of political game theory, so the topic looks notable. The article is poor, the barest stub, but sources are there to develop the article; it has problems. Reading some of the book I referenced, it is clear to me that political game theory is more that just a textbook application of game theory to political science; there are particular issues with application that have in part caused this to develop into an interdisciplinary field. In the same way the Physical chemistry is more the Chemistry#physics this topic, albeit much newer and less developed, is more than Game_theory#Political_science. In the interest of consensus, I would not be opposed to a '''merge''', but the source materials for a standalone article are there Deletion of Political game theory WP:SURMOUNTABLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14755 26 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steep turn (aviation) User:Stalwart111 23:32, 4 December 2014 (UTC) keep per and . There are plenty of references, they just need to be added to the article. In furtherance of my vaguewave: http://books.google.com.au/books?id=owcCXZAVZ60C&pg=PA87&dq=steep+turn&hl=en&sa=X&ei=YO2AVLKlLcXbmgWfpIKIDg&ved=0CDMQ6AEwBA#v=onepage&q=steep%20turn&f=false, http://books.google.com.au/books?id=_4nGtx-_jHUC, http://books.google.com.au/books?id=RRcnAgAAQBAJ, http://flighttraining.aopa.org/students/maneuvers/skills/steepturns.html, and http://www.langleyflyingschool.com/Pages/Turns,%20Steep%20Turns,%20and%20Collision%20Avoidance%20Manoeuvering.html. That's from the first Google results page Deletion of Steep turn (aviation) WP:BEFORE||WP:FIXTHEPROBLEM Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14756 21005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jay Manalo User:Oakshade 01:56, 14 November 2006 (UTC) keep While I agree this looks like it was written by the subject's publicist and should look more NPOV, he does appear to satisfy . Just with a little research I'm finding that this is a notable Philippino actor and have already found a few articles from eliable Sources|reliable sources about him http://www.inq7.net/ent/2003/jun/15/ent_3-1.htm http://www.planetphilippines.com/archives/oct16-30/current/features_current/feature4.html http://www.inq7.net/globalnation/sec_sho/2003/jul/28-01.htm (will insert into article). Plus an extensive credit list on IMDB http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1105803 Deletion of Jay Manalo WP:BIO||WP:R Wikipedia:Notability 77
14757 3745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lungs (song) User:Richwales 05:20, 28 July 2011 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Lungs (song) WP:RS||WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14758 11069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Socialbutter User:Seicer 21:58, 7 March 2007 (UTC) delete WP:WEB|Non-notable and |spam Deletion of Socialbutter WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
14759 11883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/G. V. Loganathan User:StuffOfInterest 01:04, 18 April 2007 (UTC) delete Delete unless notability can be established as per . Just being the victim of a crime does not make someone notable. Please set emotions aside, this is an encylopedia not an obituary Deletion of G. V. Loganathan WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14760 10697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abstract nonsense User:MuZemike 14:29, 16 September 2008 (UTC) keep Just heard it the other day from a professor. Nom rationale seems like a case of Deletion of Abstract nonsense WP:WHOCARES Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14761 15093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drawloop User:Blueboy96 21:21, 7 June 2007 (UTC) delete Blatant advertising, plus author's name is a clear Deletion of Drawloop WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14762 12400 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Places in West Virginia with names involving """"Dale""""""" User:Ansh666 07:11, 17 August 2013 (UTC) delete WP:HTRIV|pure trivia for which |original research is required to extract, also fails """Deletion of Places in West Virginia with names involving """"Dale""""""" WP:OR||WP:LISTN Wikipedia:No original research 65
14763 548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad Ilyas (cricketer, born 1996) User:Riteboke 16:18, 13 April 2021 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Mohammad Ilyas (cricketer, born 1996) WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14764 5797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rafael E. Pino User:PohranicniStraze 05:20, 11 October 2018 (UTC) delete Lack of independent reliable source coverage to establish notability under Deletion of Rafael E. Pino WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14765 18810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mari Kaimo User:Sam 09:39, 24 October 2015 (UTC) keep I added a few sources and more are available. Meets Deletion of Mari Kaimo WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14766 1123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raxola User:Alan 23:06, 16 January 2013 (UTC) delete per and a stronger delete per and Deletion of Raxola WP:BAND||WP:TNT||WP:BACKLOG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14767 10918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zahid Ali (politician) User:Sdmarathe 13:24, 14 September 2018 (UTC) delete Lack of necessary coverage in Deletion of Zahid Ali (politician) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14768 5069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Shells User:Talkingbirds 16:45, 13 September 2009 (UTC) delete no charting albums (actually, that unreleased album should be up for AFD too), non-notable label (which was recently speedied), nominated for a minor award that they might not even win (we'll see tonight). No prejudice against recreation if they do explode onto the charts overnight...or something like that. As of now, they fail for the reasons described above Deletion of The Shells WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14769 18902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Arbuthnot, 6th Viscount of Arbuthnott User:RGTraynor 15:21, 5 June 2007 (UTC) delete """I was about to (very reluctantly) concur with Edison on the criteria, but I stopped for a moment and considered this beautiful phrase: """"... meeting one or more {criteria} does not guarantee that a subject should be included."""" Given the long odds that this fellow ever sat in the Lords and the complete lack of evidence that he ever did so, and given that there's no information here that couldn't have been picked off of Burke's, there's just not much of a reason to keep this""" Deletion of John Arbuthnot, 6th Viscount of Arbuthnott WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14770 8508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Otona no Onnaryoku Kentei User:Alexandra 22:13, 16 January 2021 (UTC) merge to List of Konami games (or alternatively delete). I did a search for it in Japanese (大人の女力検定), it just does not meet - the little coverage this game has in RSs does not constitute significant coverage. https://www.inside-games.jp/article/2007/04/10/20297.html Inside Games basically just verifies that it exists along with a brief explanation of the premise; same with Dengeki Online (https://dengekionline.com/data/news/2007/6/1/152b2510b2e7273c1bee7380650d9163.html,https://dengekionline.com/data/news/2007/4/10/942c21a55b376a672287b5fe8de013f2.html). https://www.famitsu.com/games/t/8889/ Famitsu has no coverage whatsoever for it aside from an entry in its games database with publisher/release date/genre/etc. I could not find anything else Deletion of Otona no Onnaryoku Kentei WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14771 19094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Little Neck–Douglaston Community Ambulance Corps User:Fortuna 17:24, 29 April 2017 (UTC) delete per . &mdash Deletion of Little Neck–Douglaston Community Ambulance Corps WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14772 14696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nyctohylophobia (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 15:45, 6 August 2011 (UTC) merge into Hylophobia as is usually done. Also redirect fear of forests, to the same, which I can do if |I feel bold Deletion of Nyctohylophobia (2nd nomination) WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
14773 18905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amanda Knox User:Ginsengbomb 19:17, 15 June 2010 (UTC) comment """The relevant portion of the guidelines which I think makes a separate article on Knox more than appropriate is: '''""""If the event is significant and the individual's role within it is substantial, a separate biography may be appropriate. Individuals notable for well-documented events, such as John Hinckley, Jr., fit into this category. The significance of an event or individual should be indicated by how persistent the coverage is in reliable sources.""""''' Hell in a Bucket's above GNews link http://news.google.com/archivesearch?&as_src=-newswire+-wire+-presswire+-PR+-press+-release+-wikipedia&q=%22Amanda+Knox%22 strongly suggests, to me, that Amanda Knox has indeed been the subject of persistent, ongoing coverage. If you review the sources in that link -- all of which are extremely reliable -- their subject is ''not'' the murder and/or trial but is instead ''Amanda Knox.'' The Hinckley example listed in the BLP1E guidelines is a somewhat interesting corollary but I think it is best-suited to merely illustrate the point -- there are a multitude of individuals notable for, loosely construed, """"one event"""" that are still very clearly notable enough for inclusion in the encyclopedia. I argue that the persistent nature of the coverage ''focused on Amanda Knox'' passes this hurdle (and, in my opinion, does so by quite a wide margin, but that is more subjective""" Deletion of Amanda Knox WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
14774 9459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stereotypes of Black Women on the Internet User:LordFixit 18:12, 18 April 2014 (UTC) delete Nothing wrong with feminism, but this article is a clear case of a breach of Deletion of Stereotypes of Black Women on the Internet WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14775 20274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Resignation of Sarah Palin (2nd nomination) User:Proofreader77 23:20, 9 October 2009 (UTC) keep """develop it into an article. ''Smiling, but not joking.'' That it has not progressed is THE ONLY argument that should have been raised for having another time-wasting AfD so soon. ''Again, smiling but not joking.'' and are as unpersuasive now as they were last time (at least to those who know the full complexities of the matter). '''Merge?, no.''' (See previous parenthetical.)BEGIN SOAPBOX Speaking as a rhetorical analyst, the rhetorical argument presented is: ''Sarah Palin is a flash in the pan ... Clearly the resignation of a flash in the pan is of momentary interest (news), certainly not historical ... because, um, Sarah Palin is flash in the pan. '' Whether or not one is a fan of Sarah Palin, she, and her notable/controversial resignation (marking a surprising turning point in her career) is of more historical significance than huge swaths of what we cover in Wikipedia—not that our opinion on that matters, of course. Which is why such opinions should not be the basis for a time-wasting re-run Afd. BOTTOM LINE: Asserting and is not persuasive. Rhetorical handwaving of personal opinion of the historical significance of Sarah Palin is less so. HOWEVER (AS PER ABOVE) What is there (on the page) is NOT improving toward article-hood. Let us wave a stick at those who say """"KEEP"""" to do something about that. (SOTTO VOCE) ''And yes, Ms Palin, I'll be happy to help you write your speeches, for a very reasonable fee—which will not include editing your Wikipedia articles, which costs extra, plus Jimbo's cut.'' :) META COMMENT If I'm going to have to waste my time on another time-wasting AfD, I'm gonna sure as heck have fun. I have. Cheers""" Deletion of Resignation of Sarah Palin (2nd nomination) WP:NOTNEWS||WP:RECENTISM||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:RECENTISM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14776 5163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dominic Aquila User:Aecis 23:02, 11 October 2006 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass either or . Wikipedia:Requests for adminship/Aecis|A Deletion of Dominic Aquila WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14777 7005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DexOS User:Heavyweight 13:20, 31 January 2010 (UTC) delete WP:EXIST|Existence does not equal notability, and there are no reliable third-party sources to establish that or |verifiability; the references on the page consist of a home page and blog posts, which are not considered |reliable sources Deletion of DexOS WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14778 2786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hack, (political slang) User:Coredesat 02:50, 25 August 2006 (UTC) delete as |unverifiable; |Wikipedia is not a slang dictionary Deletion of Hack, (political slang) WP:V||WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14779 161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Probability derivations for making low hands in Omaha hold 'em User:Coredesat 19:56, 24 June 2007 (UTC) delete blatant |original research. Alternatively, transwiki it to Wikiversity Deletion of Probability derivations for making low hands in Omaha hold 'em WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14780 9080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007 Black Sea Games User:Chetsford 18:30, 9 May 2018 (UTC) delete There is serious absence of in the article, or outside it. It certainly does not pass the . The extensive tables listing medalists are the only content in the article but can't be sourced to anything and may, therefore, be a issue Deletion of 2007 Black Sea Games WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14781 238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TCM - Time Critical Manufacturing User:MichaelQSchmidt 00:13, 10 October 2008 (UTC) delete as an |advertisement that fails |notability Deletion of TCM - Time Critical Manufacturing WP:ADVERT||WP:N Wikipedia:Advertising 107
14782 15790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rasheda Abdul-Rahman User:Number 10:58, 11 February 2017 (UTC) delete """per failure. Disappointing although not unsurprising to see the continued wikilawyering around the exact wording of the guideline from the user above. The word """"adult"""" is not used because """"Tier 1 International Match"""" and """"competitive senior international match"""" are the formal ways of describing adult football as opposed to youth football (e.g. U17 or U20""" Deletion of Rasheda Abdul-Rahman WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
14783 1166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flapamba User:Andrewa 23:00, 8 January 2013 (UTC) keep The article isn't encyclopedic in tone but the topic is encyclopedic. It could be stubified or perhaps merged to Emil Richards for the moment, but deletion is not the best way forward, and will just lead to more recreation. The solution is to develop good coverage of the topic(s). Disagree that it's purely part of a ''spam cluster'', but there are definitely possible COI issues that nobody seems to have addressed, remembering (diffs please if there have been attempts I've missed). Happy to work with the contributor(s) to resolve the issues Deletion of Flapamba WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
14784 1529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of 88 Films releases User:MichaelQSchmidt 12:12, 15 October 2016 (UTC) keep as a suitable |list article and borrow sources from the MANY blue-linked films on that list. Expand with info from the studio's article Deletion of List of 88 Films releases WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
14785 9168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Ticknor (journalist) User:AleatoryPonderings 20:51, 30 September 2020 (UTC) keep In addition to the entry in the (possibly unreliable) encyclopedia on which the article is based, there is also https://books.google.ca/books?id=rV4mAQAAMAAJ&pg=PA692, which corroborates the information in Appletons'. I'd say two biographical dictionary entries is enough for , but these sorts of reference works were a dime a dozen back then, so it's not super clear. There's also https://books.google.ca/books?id=c5jOAAAAMAAJ&pg=PA125 (for purposes of , not Deletion of George Ticknor (journalist) WP:BASIC||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14786 15809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Impact of illegal downloading on the film industry User:Hartboy 06:30, 26 April 2011 (UTC) delete Seems like a classic example of a |case study Deletion of Impact of illegal downloading on the film industry WP:NOTCASE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14787 3545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Kropschot (2nd nomination) User:SportingFlyer 07:14, 27 September 2018 (UTC) delete Fails , . Very poorly sourced article Deletion of Joseph Kropschot (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
14788 14137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clinical Development Services Agency (2nd nomination) User:Drchriswilliams 13:44, 20 March 2016 (UTC) delete As noted above, the CDSA is an agency of THSTI which itself appears not to be notable. The only mentions of the CDSA that I can see are on job advert sites and brief mentions of Indian government sites. The CDSA site doesn't really talk about things it has done but rather sets out some intentions and aims. The organisation has been in existence for seven years but I can't find anything to indicate that it has achieved anything of note over this time. With the promotional wording removed there isn't much left to suggest notability and the lack of reliable coverage is a real problem. It doesn't have and doesn't pass Deletion of Clinical Development Services Agency (2nd nomination) WP:ORGDEPTH||WP:NONPROFIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14789 12596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Night of the Living Rednecks User:Mr 05:04, 6 October 2012 (UTC) merge to Give Me Convenience or Give Me Death, where the song is mentioned in the track listing. If a song is not notable then says that it should be merged or redirected, not deleted Deletion of Night of the Living Rednecks WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14790 214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WTrak User:AllyD 09:05, 9 June 2013 (UTC) delete No |independent 3rd party evidence found of attained notability Deletion of WTrak :WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14791 425 [[Ron Paulik]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers NONE delete Kasten|1= gemäß Diskussion. Ein Erreichen der #Musiker und Komponisten ist nicht dargestellt. Downloads reichen dazu alleine nicht. Daneben war der Artikel aber auch qualitativ als reine Selbstdarstellung ohne WP:Belege|Belege aus Sekundärquellen so nicht haltbar. Bis eine größere Bekanntheit auch für reputable Quellen sorgt, im http://musik.wikia.com/wiki/Ron_Paulik Musik-Wiki besser aufgehoben. Gruß Löschung von Ron Paulik Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
14792 182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy Kleinman User:K 00:17, 28 December 2017 (UTC) delete nothing here suggests notability or significance; affiliation with a nn gaming company does not help. and fail per review of available sources Deletion of Andy Kleinman WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
14793 967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James E. Atwater User:Hunting 19:57, 1 June 2008 (UTC) keep """on first examination seems to pass , as """"The person is regarded as a significant expert in his or her area by independent sources"""" as seems widely cited, including here Extended_Duration_Orbiter#cite_note-osu-10 - (incidentally article doesn't have notification on it at moment so deletion nomination is a bit broken""" Deletion of James E. Atwater WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14794 11360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Vegan flag User:Beemer69 14:59, 28 July 2017 (UTC) delete WP:GNG and . Is there a flag for ''everything'' nowadays Deletion of The Vegan flag WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
14795 15680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ann J Wilson User:Ravenswing 16:01, 23 March 2007 (UTC) delete """fails , . Heaven knows why, but take a look at that posted """"Times"""" jpg. It is very blatantly and clumsily doctored. Even ''without'' the doctoring, the subject is otherwise insignificant, dead over a century, and her sole claim to fame was that she was (in some small English village) accused of murdering her infant and acquitted""" Deletion of Ann J Wilson WP:ATT||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Attribution 108
14796 20993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poomkavu Church User:Joe 14:22, 12 December 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Poomkavu Church WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14797 21883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marie-Lucie Tarpent User:Shudde 09:47, 7 January 2018 (UTC) delete """Largely per the comments of Agricola44. Looks like she fails and she definitely looks to fail . While we have to be very careful not to just look at an academic's citation count and H-index before deciding whether they are notable, we also can't just say """"it's a small field"""" and ignore their publication record. Are there any independent secondary sources that actually discuss Tarpent and her impact on her field in any depth? And we have to be careful here, if we define an academic's """"field"""" narrowly enough then nearly all academic researchers would pass criteria 1 of . One sentence in one report doesn't meet a reasonable threshold in my opinion""" Deletion of Marie-Lucie Tarpent WP:NACADEMIC||WP:GNG||WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14798 15679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donny Gillies User:Triwbe 20:56, 27 May 2010 (UTC) keep Maybe it is , maybe it is Wikipedia:Autobiography but {{find|Dirty Donny Gillies}} does show a few independant reviews to just pass otability|Notability Deletion of Donny Gillies WP:UGLY||WP:N Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14799 12901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World Hockey Centre User:Keira1996 08:23, 28 May 2017 (UTC) delete Fails as above. When one of the first search results is a Wikipedia mirror, I think it quite clearly is not notable enough for inclusion Deletion of World Hockey Centre WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14800 1219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gordon Wagner (economist) User:Kraxler 14:01, 27 October 2014 (UTC) delete """Fails . Fails because none of sources are """"independent of the subject"""", almost all of them are from his employers, one is about his doctoral thesis. Just one of a myriad of university professors worldwide. Also see: Point 4. The LDS may highly esteem the late professor, but that doesn't establish notability""" Deletion of Gordon Wagner (economist) WP:ACADEMIC||WP:GNG||WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14801 7915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albania–Estonia relations User:Resurr 09:51, 30 April 2009 (UTC) delete fails . Note that they don't even bother to have actual embassies in each other's countries. Florent Çeliku is simultaneously ambassador to Ukraine, but resides in Warsaw. ''He'' might deserve an article Deletion of Albania–Estonia relations WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14802 675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional vehicles (4th nomination) User:Softlavender 03:01, 15 September 2017 (UTC) keep This is a standard article, which are accepted throughout Wikipedia, as well as being useful reference articles to keep information handy and in one place. Any cleanup required can be done by editing; AfD is not cleanup. articles always exist in addition to and along with Categories; one ''never'' precludes the other and both are encouraged Deletion of List of fictional vehicles (4th nomination) WP:LISTOFLISTS||WP:LIST Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
14803 13557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pita Pit User:Whpq 13:13, 30 October 2019 (UTC) keep There is a lot of routine coverage about stores opening or closing in specific locations so it can be difficult to pick out the coverage. Here are some. Coverage about https://business.financialpost.com/entrepreneur/franchise-focus/international-strategy-will-serve-pita-pit-well-as-competition-heats-up-at-home international expansion. Their https://www.thewhig.com/news/local-news/pita-pit-partnering-with-pot-grower-but-not-opening-pot-stores partnership with a pot grower to https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/weedmd-and-pita-pit-strike-joint-venture-to-open-pot-shops-across-canada-1.1196907 get into the cannabis business. Their https://www.apnnews.com/mumbaikars-get-ready-to-binge-on-fast-fit-food-from-pita-pit/ expansion into parts of India. The https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/lifestyle/2019/05/kiwi-customers-outraged-after-pita-pit-incurs-fillings-limit.html customer backlash in Australia over one of their menu offerings. Growth in a https://www.bizjournals.com/jacksonville/news/2018/07/31/pita-pit-franchisees-talk-successful-growth-in.html local market. As an example in a https://books.google.ca/books?id=se2EAAAAQBAJ&pg=PA247&dq=%22pita+pit%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj2rrTm28LlAhUEc98KHTN2AkwQ6AEIPjAC#v=onepage&q=%22pita%20pit%22&f=false book about franchising. That is sufficient coverage in reliable sources to meet |notability Deletion of Pita Pit WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14804 19977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2034 FIFA World Cup User:Gidonb 16:49, 2 June 2018 (UTC) keep Significant sports event, by now |sufficiently covered in the media Deletion of 2034 FIFA World Cup WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
14805 3005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles W. Heyl User:JackFromReedsburg 19:04, 7 April 2021 (UTC) keep Meets . This article needs major work and attention, but not to be deleted Deletion of Charles W. Heyl WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14806 10763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aleka Stratigou User:Davey2010 23:48, 5 January 2016 (UTC) keep There's tons of books under her English name https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=Aleka+Stratigou&oq=Aleka+Stratigou&aqs=chrome..69i57j69i60&sourceid=chrome&es_sm=93&ie=UTF-8#q=Aleka+Stratigou&safe=off&tbm=bks and tons of News articles under her Greek name https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=%CE%91%CE%BB%CE%AD%CE%BA%CE%B1+%CE%A3%CF%84%CF%81%CE%B1%CF%84%CE%B7%CE%B3%CE%BF%CF%8D&oq=%CE%91%CE%BB%CE%AD%CE%BA%CE%B1+%CE%A3%CF%84%CF%81%CE%B1%CF%84%CE%B7%CE%B3%CE%BF%CF%8D&aqs=chrome..69i57&sourceid=chrome&es_sm=93&ie=UTF-8#safe=off&tbm=nws&q=%22%CE%91%CE%BB%CE%AD%CE%BA%CE%B1+%CE%A3%CF%84%CF%81%CE%B1%CF%84%CE%B7%CE%B3%CE%BF%CF%8D%22.... Was even followed Deletion of Aleka Stratigou WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14807 5327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lorca Cohen User:Scope 17:14, 29 May 2017 (UTC) delete Poor quality sources make it non notable. Fails Deletion of Lorca Cohen WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
14808 15491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of proposed provinces and territories of Canada user:Hannes 17:56, 10 June 2021 (UTC) keep Per , the items are even independently notable. As Bearcat mentioned, it is irrelevant if these proposals come to fruition or not, only if they are notable Deletion of List of proposed provinces and territories of Canada WP:NLIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
14809 17974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jimmy Shaw User:Niteshift36 16:57, 28 August 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Jimmy Shaw WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14810 19417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Huf Haus User:Schuym1 02:12, 10 December 2008 (UTC) keep Reliable sources shows that it passes Deletion of Huf Haus WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14811 20980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vrock User:Sirfurboy 11:27, 10 February 2020 (UTC) delete Per , wikipedia is not a game guide and this is not notable outside of the guide Deletion of Vrock WP:GAMEGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14812 11688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gallery of coats of arms of the United Kingdom and dependencies User:Colonel 20:18, 7 October 2011 (UTC) keep """WP:NOTGALLERY refers to articles """"''with no text''"""". This article contains text and, if we should want more, this is best done by further editing in accordance with our |editing policy, not by deletion. The topic has a clear and coherent theme and so is quite proper""" Deletion of Gallery of coats of arms of the United Kingdom and dependencies WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
14813 2136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg H. Sims User:Oakshade 03:32, 6 November 2008 (UTC) keep A producer and writer of many films and per sources provided by MichaelQSchmidt above, seems to pass Deletion of Greg H. Sims WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14814 19135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pat Zalewski (2nd nomination) User:Gnangarra 00:09, 5 April 2013 (UTC) delete not entirely comfortable with that...as I can verify that the book written by Robert Ellwood in 1993 and cited in article existshttp://www.amazon.com/s?search-alias=stripbooks&field-isbn=9780824814878 AGF on content and that he was inducted into the NZ hall Martial Arts hall of Fame http://www.itkd.co.nz/about-taekwon-do/awards/martial-arts-hall-of-fame-inductees.php in 2000, Hall of Fame does indicate notability within the Association and should be sufficient in establishing notability but doesnt make that leap for any sport. Given both of these sources add to it that he competed pre-internet makes it difficult. International_Traditional_Karate_Federation article does match the http://www.itkf.org/members/itkf-member-national-federations/?tx_vimembers_pi1letter=N#text the ITKF site but neither show NZ as a member, which is troubling in that a non-member country is unlikely to be able to compete, though I do concede membership can wain over time Deletion of Pat Zalewski (2nd nomination) WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14815 3707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steffen Vroom User:GiantSnowman 14:08, 24 April 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Steffen Vroom WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14816 13119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chants d'Auvergne, Vol. 2 NONE NONE keep per . The article's COPYVIO issue has now been addressed - brief review excerpts will be supplied in due course Deletion of Chants d'Auvergne, Vol. 2 WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
14817 12900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emanuela Rei User:TheFallenPower 15:07, 3 April 2020 (UTC) keep She meets with her main role in Maggie & Bianca, and she has gotten coverage in Italian papers: https://www.ansa.it/sito/notizie/cultura/cinema/persona.shtml?KEY=392871&TYPE=B ANSA, https://issuu.com/edizionilafreccia/docs/2017_03_note_11/10 Note, https://ricerca.repubblica.it/repubblica/archivio/repubblica/2017/10/01/maggiee-biancaFirenze10.html la Repubblica. (There are also a lot of news articles to source her other roles like https://www.lastampa.it/torinosette/eventi/2019/12/05/news/aladin-al-teatro-alfieri-523661 this that don't go in-depth as those.) Unfortunately the article was created without any sourcing and poor translations Deletion of Emanuela Rei WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14818 13249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cruze, Rachel User:Bonadea 10:26, 10 August 2015 (UTC) delete No indication of notability, neither nor is met. I don't see how sending it to AfC could change the basic lack of notability. I'm always wary of articles that appear to be commissioned to advertise the subject of the article and increase their notability, rather than document existing notability Deletion of Cruze, Rachel WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14819 10630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of PKNA short stories User:Ajf773 18:45, 1 December 2017 (UTC) delete as . Even the parent article has questionable notability Deletion of List of PKNA short stories WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
14820 7991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Renae Maihi User:Whisperjanes 18:37, 14 February 2020 (UTC) keep She has had coverage since 2017 from her films (specifically ''Waru'') in addition to the Bob Jones events Deletion of Renae Maihi WP:SUSTAINED Wikipedia:Notability 77
14821 2568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Oxygen User:Ritchie333 15:19, 13 February 2013 (UTC) keep per the chart success found by Grandmartin11, which satisfies Deletion of Black Oxygen WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14822 4694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bambang Parmanto User:Coredesat 20:55, 24 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Bambang Parmanto WP:PROFTEST Wikipedia:Notability 77
14823 2640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ATI video card suffixes User:Sirfurboy 23:27, 16 January 2020 (UTC) delete per nom. Not sure what the creator was even thinking. I would think a list of products would make more sense, but then so it still should go Deletion of ATI video card suffixes WP:NOTCATALOG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14824 20281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ante Delija [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 19:33, 11 May 2015 (UTC) delete Unsourced BLP about an MMA fighter who fails . No evidence of notability. Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Ante Delija WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
14825 7417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/T. G. Baynes Solicitors User:Bridgeplayer 14:24, 21 August 2011 (UTC) delete Likewise I have had a good look for sources and found none that would enable this firm to meet Deletion of T. G. Baynes Solicitors WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14826 7406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sista Afia User:Abishe 13:32, 18 April 2020 (UTC) delete The subject fails and fails Deletion of Sista Afia WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14827 11230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional deities user:Andrew 10:02, 23 June 2020 (UTC) keep Passes . For example, see ''Any gods out there? Perceptions of religion from Star Wars and Star Trek''; ''Melting the Ice Gods: The Creation and Destruction of Old and New Gods in British Fiction, 1880–1955''; ''Filming the gods: Religion and Indian cinema''; ''Heathen gods in Old English literature''; ''Dying gods in twentieth-century fiction''; '' Do the Gods Wear Capes?: spirituality, fantasy, and superheroes''; &c Deletion of List of fictional deities WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
14828 3307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teambox (2nd nomination) User:michokest NONE comment """User|michokest}} self identified as the founder (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Undelete&target=Talk%3ATeambox×tamp=20100104114752&diff=prev """"''I am the founder of Teambox.''"""") also !voted twice in the first AFD http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Teambox&diff=337226236&oldid=337044514http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia%3AArticles_for_deletion%2FTeambox&action=historysubmit&diff=337769572&oldid=337766850 was has used multiple accounts to create, canvass and !vote for Teambox's's inclusion""" Deletion of Teambox (2nd nomination) WP:SOCK Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
14829 1063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frode Fredriksen User:Govvy 12:24, 10 February 2021 (UTC) keep Seriously, there are enough decent hits in google for the guy, I can't understand the language hits know, the article has currently seven citations, although could be better written. He has won the 1. divisjon (OBOS-LIGAEN) 2001,https://www.eurosport.co.uk/football/frode-fredriksen_prs423801/person.shtml and there must be more offline sources. I am getting fed-up with these nominations that clearly lack Deletion of Frode Fredriksen WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14830 9819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Laird User:Imoeng 07:49, 27 October 2006 (UTC) keep Jamie Laird. He plays in the second division English league, which is a professional career. However sources should really be included in the article. If not, fails and Cheers Deletion of Jamie Laird WP:NOR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
14831 21914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Republic of Ireland vs France (2010 FIFA World Cup Play-Off) User:Quantpole 13:08, 24 November 2009 (UTC) keep I would normally err on the side of delete for recent articles, but really, for something that has attracted massive worldwide coverage, I cannot see a reason to delete. The principal reason to delete being given is , however the emphasis on that is ''routine'' media coverage, or coverage of individuals. The amount of coverage this has garnered simply shows that it is not a routine event. Neither is it a 'fluff' bit of news that goes around the world quickly, but equally dies down as quickly. This match has received more coverage, and is likely to have more longer lasting consequences than champions league finals (2007 UEFA Champions League Final|some of which are featured), which have articles. I know that is a bit of an 'other stuff exists' argument, but it is an indication that individual football matches can certainly be notable. I do not see that there are BLP issues to deal with, which is a common issue with recent news events Deletion of Republic of Ireland vs France (2010 FIFA World Cup Play-Off) WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14832 205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M. J. Maddox User:BradBeattie 06:10, 27 October 2006 (UTC) delete as author fails . I tried looking the author up on google, but considering the number of pseudonyms used, I gather it'd be difficult to get an accurate number of GHits. Nevertheless, the article fails to assert notability Deletion of M. J. Maddox WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14833 12849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marianna Gartner User:Tomwsulcer 01:01, 22 March 2015 (UTC) keep There is a http://www.theglobeandmail.com/arts/2009-cultural-olympiad-todays-highlights/article1155288/ mention here, plus https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Marianna+Gartner%22+(site%3Anews.artnet.com+OR+site%3Aartnews.com+OR+site%3Aartsjournal.com+OR+site%3Aartdaily.com+OR+site%3Aartistsnetwork.com+OR+site%3Aaestheticamagazine.com+OR+site%3Anyartsmagazine.com+OR+site%3Ahifructose.com+OR+site%3Aartinamericamagazine.com+OR+site%3Avulture.com+OR+site%3Adustmagazine.com+OR+site%3Aartistdaily.com+OR+site%3Aflashartonline.com+OR+site%3Afineartmagazine.com+OR+site%3Acityartsonline.com+OR+site%3Afrieze.com+OR+site%3Ascene360.com+OR+site%3Adigitalartsonline.co.uk)&rlz=1CAASUA_enUS604US605&oq=%22Marianna+Gartner%22+(site%3Anews.artnet.com+OR+site%3Aartnews.com+OR+site%3Aartsjournal.com+OR+site%3Aartdaily.com+OR+site%3Aartistsnetwork.com+OR+site%3Aaestheticamagazine.com+OR+site%3Anyartsmagazine.com+OR+site%3Ahifructose.com+OR+site%3Aartinamericamagazine.com+OR+site%3Avulture.com+OR+site%3Adustmagazine.com+OR+site%3Aartistdaily.com+OR+site%3Aflashartonline.com+OR+site%3Afineartmagazine.com+OR+site%3Acityartsonline.com+OR+site%3Afrieze.com+OR+site%3Ascene360.com+OR+site%3Adigitalartsonline.co.uk)&aqs=chrome..69i57.254j0j9&sourceid=chrome&es_sm=122&ie=UTF-8 media attention here. Meets the Deletion of Marianna Gartner WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14834 14980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Under the Lights at the Big House User:Paulmcdonald 15:03, 5 September 2013 (UTC) keep I guess I'm funny that way. Certainly there has been enough coverage to more than surpass and that's always been a good rule of thumb. I think the name of the article is hideous, but that's all editing issues to be handled later Deletion of Under the Lights at the Big House WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14835 5724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Individual Counter-Strike maps User:Fuhghettaboutit 23:07, 17 July 2006 (UTC) merge into Counter-Strike, Counter-Strike maps, Custom Counter-Strike maps, etc. and '''delete'''—skirts OR; too derivative. Though I agree that there is too much information here for a complete merge, the information can and should be drastically cut down with all trivia removed. If this vote ends in no consensus, and given that this afd is specifically tailored to end the debate, I would think , and vote speedy keep in any future afd unless there were extenuating circumstances Deletion of Individual Counter-Strike maps WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
14836 19022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sabar Koti (2nd nomination) User:Bonadea 12:11, 13 July 2018 (UTC) keep the sources I can read (and the rudimentary translations provided by Google Translate for the rest) indicate that is met. A couple of them are press releases and there's one I can't access at all, but there's definitely sufficient coverage, especially from around the time of his death. I think can probably be said to be met as well at this time (note that the previous AfD discussion was seven years ago and ended in a soft delete Deletion of Sabar Koti (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14837 19473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ravi murdianto User:GiantSnowman 21:06, 14 January 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Ravi murdianto WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14838 6919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Warriors Trial User:A 15:52, 17 January 2009 (UTC) delete while is not a valid reason for deletion, I am unable to verify this article's content through reliable sources from Google Books, Google News, Amazon.com, etc. I agree that ''Wikipedia'' should not include articles that are essentially about unpublished stories we editors have written. Best Deletion of A Warriors Trial WP:JNN Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14839 16083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dwayne Rudd User:Capitalistroadster 17:09, 13 November 2005 (UTC) keep Meets as a professional sportsman playing seven seasons in the NFL Deletion of Dwayne Rudd WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14840 27 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Sinem Sevindik """Kullanıcı:diyapazon'''diyapazon'''""" 12:08, 22 Nisan 2015 (UTC) delete İleride belki olabilir ama şuan için kayda değer değil. |İlgili kriterleri sağlamadığını düşünüyorum Sinem Sevindik'in silinmesi Vikipedi:MÜZİK Wikipedia:Notability 77
14841 13512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Scream Factory releases User:Ajf773 20:18, 7 November 2018 (UTC) delete Obviously Deletion of List of Scream Factory releases WP:NOTCATALOGUE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14842 15232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Pritchard (2nd nomination) User:Kevin 22:18, 6 October 2009 (UTC) delete """He's only notable for |one thing, and is not independently notable, despite the """"large number of sources""" Deletion of Greg Pritchard (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
14843 4007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omer Nadeem User:JediLofty 15:19, 27 August 2008 (UTC) delete for failing and . The article is written in a very promotional way; I thought it was a but a quick Googling didn't find anything Deletion of Omer Nadeem WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO||WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14844 1218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of MySpace Events User:Dacium 07:26, 3 May 2007 (UTC) delete it should at least pass Deletion of List of MySpace Events WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14845 2638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/El Gaucho (Israeli restaurant) User:Galatz 17:00, 26 February 2020 (UTC) keep The two people who said delete appear to only be looking in the article, unlike the nominator. The sources need to exist to establish notability, not just in the article. I have added about 4 sources to the article which are more than enough to meet the criteria for . There are many more out there, a search in Hebrew will come up with plenty of sources, searching in English will not, but being that this is an Israeli chain it makes sense to find mind in Hebrew Deletion of El Gaucho (Israeli restaurant) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14846 9801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hall High School Chess Team User:Inks 06:13, 9 August 2011 (UTC) delete I can only find one reliable source for the club, and it generally fails Deletion of Hall High School Chess Team WP:CLUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14847 2466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Čelopek, Zvornik User:Wikimandia 05:06, 15 December 2015 (UTC) keep per . Other articles are better fleshed out ie :fr:Čelopek (Zvornik). Nom should have followed and checked interlanguage links Deletion of Čelopek, Zvornik WP:GEOLAND||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14848 11076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eclipse Records User:Carlossuarez46 23:04, 2 March 2009 (UTC) delete this label is not sufficiently notable (see ) so as to permit any artist who has released two albums on it to be intrinsically notable as per Deletion of Eclipse Records WP:CORP||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14849 14654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giedrius Karavackas User:Papaursa 20:08, 18 January 2014 (UTC) delete No sources except for a link to his fight record. Doesn't meet or Deletion of Giedrius Karavackas WP:NMMA||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14850 6669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samir Masimov (3rd nomination) User:Nfitz 16:36, 12 September 2014 (UTC) keep Meets with an unusual amount of Russian and Azerbaijani media coverage http://azerisport.com/football/20140523124915811.html http://echo.az/article.php?aid=3736 http://klubnayaliga.ru/support/interview/1773-masimov-samir-v-moskve-samye-silynye-shloky.html http://sport.day.az/football/20140523124915811.html http://sports-info.ru/samir-masimov-na-nashey-igre-skazalas-krasnaya-kartochka/ http://extratime.echo.az/article.php?aid=306873&frm=16 http://www.sovsport.ru/news/text-item/678074 Deletion of Samir Masimov (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14851 9117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jenna Rose (3rd nomination) User:MichaelQSchmidt 01:35, 9 October 2011 (UTC) keep as being '''too soon''' after the no-consensus keep of last AFD just Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jenna Rose (2nd nomination)|THREE WEEKS AGO. The better option if one disagrees with an AFD outcome is to wait a reasonable length of time before renominating (and pardon, but I do not think 3 weeks is a long enough period to be considered reasonable), or taking it to DRV if an editor feels there was a flaw in the earlier close per consessus. We can revisit this in a few months... not a few days or a few weeks. With respects, the nominator's reasoning seems to be '''A)''' there has |not been enough effort since last keep, and '''B)''' an apparent wish to use this third AFD in order to force the cleanup that was the seen as possible at the last AFD. And '''NOTE''': Toward and , we ''DO'' have some quite decent reliable independent secondary sources available toward this person and her work: http://www.webcitation.org/62IMLvcsp ''Herald'' http://www.webcitation.org/62IMVfkYf ''Newsday'' 1 http://www.newsday.com/entertainment/music/backstage-pass-1.811987/the-jenna-rose-my-jeans-phenomenon-grows-1.2776234 ''Newsday'' 2 http://www.newsday.com/entertainment/tv/dix-hills-girl-to-debut-new-song-1.2781031 ''Newsday'' 3 http://www.newsday.com/long-island/towns/long-island-now-1.1732330/dix-hill-teen-s-music-vid-joins-the-list-of-li-s-viral-videos-1.2774963 ''Newsday'' 4http://halfhollowhills.patch.com/articles/july-12-fireman-fair-graduate-school-and-safari-art ''Patch'' 1 http://halfhollowhills.patch.com/articles/jenna-rose-to-appear-on-tv-friday-morning ''Patch'' 2 http://halfhollowhills.patch.com/articles/april-22-earth-day-good-friday-jenna-rose ''Patch'' 3 http://www.lasr.net/travel/videos.php?JENNA+ROSE-SHY-GOT+TALENT+CONTEST+2009&VideoID=316406 ''Leisure and Sports Review'' We are to respect |consensus and understand that |addressable issues are reasons to |address the issue proactively and not #REASON|valid reasons to |renominate for deletion Deletion of Jenna Rose (3rd nomination) WP:NOEFFORT||WP:NRVE||WP:GNG||WP:CONSENSUS||WP:ATD||WP:ITJ||WP:DEL||WP:KEEPLISTING Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14852 8522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cesar Salazar (VC) User:FeatherPluma 06:15, 14 July 2012 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Cesar Salazar (VC) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14853 12976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alikreukel Apartment Block User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable. &mdash Deletion of Alikreukel Apartment Block WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14854 5880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Keith Ashwin User:GDX420 16:28, 22 October 2020 (UTC) comment Have we considered Deletion of Terry Keith Ashwin WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
14855 20755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019 Pilatus PC 12 crash User:Inter 02:52, 6 April 2020 (UTC) keep I'm leaning towards keeping the article at the moment, with coverage from sites such as the BBC https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-50639537 1 and NY Post https://nypost.com/2019/12/01/nine-members-of-idaho-family-including-two-kids-die-in-plane-crash/ 2, as well as coverage spanning the month of December 2019 (not just one day), I'll venture to say that this event passes and does not qualify for the definition set forth by Deletion of 2019 Pilatus PC 12 crash WP:GNG||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14856 16456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adata Needle User:Chiro725 23:53, 11 April 2021 (UTC) delete Fails also, written like a an advert Deletion of Adata Needle WP:BOOKCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14857 20555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Vithoulkas User:Maustrauser 22:11, 7 March 2007 (UTC) delete possibly also shaky on . Some of the references aren't strong. Eg. PubMed lists everything regardless of quality or where it has been published. This is often made as some claim for notability but it isn't Deletion of George Vithoulkas WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14858 8028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ignition (video game) User:Jovanmilic97 11:52, 14 July 2019 (UTC) keep Found the Gamezone (Germany), PC Player (German magazine) and PC Games (magazine) reviews at https://www.gamezone.de/Bleifuss-Fun-Spiel-19098/Lesertests/Bleifuss-Fun-Gib-Gas-hab-Spass-Leser-Test-von-baktakor-1001834/, https://archive.org/details/PC-Player-German-Magazine-1997-11/page/n155 and https://archive.org/details/pcgamesmagazine-1997-11/page/n117 (Moby says it was reviewed in the October issue, but it happened in the November one). I think it should pass now with PC Powerplay https://archive.org/details/PCPowerplay018/page/n85 , Computer and Video Games https://web.archive.org/web/20070222111655/http://www.computerandvideogames.com/article.php?id=8068, Pelit https://www.pelit.fi/artikkelit/ignition/ and Game.EXE https://archive.org/details/Game.EXE_10_1997/page/n45. All seem to be reliable per /RS (except PC Player which never had a discussion there, but is likely reliable as well). Kind of surprising there is only 1 really in-depth review of this game in English, but every language is acceptable for GNG Deletion of Ignition (video game) WP:GNG||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14859 10583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stress measurement in aviation User:Bluerasberry 18:34, 19 November 2015 (UTC) delete """For the article to remain someone has to confirm that the subject of this article meets Wikipedia's notability criteria as defined in . I would change my """"delete"""" recommendation if someone found 2-3 sources per which featured the subject of this article as their own subject. The effort is nice but the base of a Wikipedia article is 2-3 good sentences backed by 2-3 good sources - someone please show that base to me""" Deletion of Stress measurement in aviation WP:GNG||WP:42 Wikipedia:Notability 77
14860 4897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evangelical Renewal Therapy User:Timneu22 13:49, 17 May 2010 (UTC) delete This article is written about a topic and/or is research by Patrick Saucer. Patrick Saucer also wrote the article. Clearly this is . Also, this article reads like an essay, is clearly , and comes to conclusions (repentance is achieved through...). This is not an encyclopedic article now, and written by the author himself, is unlikely to become one. I do not even know if the title of the article is valid in the mainstream study, or if it was coined by the author. Essays like this Wikipedia talk:CSD|should fall under some CSD; I wish they would. &mdash Deletion of Evangelical Renewal Therapy WP:COI||WP:POV Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14861 14773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rat-Cigarette Lifespan Theory User:Tigerboy1966 22:21, 16 November 2011 (UTC) delete Nothing to show this isn't a . Either that or the creator is just lazy Deletion of Rat-Cigarette Lifespan Theory WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
14862 1666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jan Pulsford User:Coren 00:44, 8 September 2007 (UTC) delete notability is indeed |not transitive, and I can find no indication that this musician has notability of his own, so he falls much short of . — Deletion of Jan Pulsford WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14863 4253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aqua Jones User:Esradekan 23:41, 4 April 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per . Searching finds no significant coverage in |reliable, third-party, sources. Just another facebook/myspace/|garage band. Hell, garageband.com is one of their external links Deletion of Aqua Jones WP:MUSIC||WP:RS||WP:GARAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14864 19735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cash room puzzle User:Drawn 17:15, 10 May 2009 (UTC) delete by letting it get sucked out the vent the money came through. Deletion of Cash room puzzle WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
14865 3167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susan Ford User:Agent 22:52, 27 September 2006 (UTC) keep I agree with Fram that notability by association ''in and of itself'' is insufficient; however, in this case, the subject of the article meets the criteria of on her own merits Deletion of Susan Ford WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14866 636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 Freiburg gang rape User:Pudeo 21:16, 7 November 2018 (UTC) keep """Although doesn't give much help, there is extended coverage of this crime and it seems to be tied to the media theme about the influx of refugees and public safety. Removals in the article itself seem to be just motivated by the belief that the mere coverage of high-profile crimes and the criminals' immigration status itself is """"racist""""https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=2018_Freiburg_gang_rape&diff=prev&oldid=867704174&diffmode=source""" Deletion of 2018 Freiburg gang rape WP:NCRIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
14867 15966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeet Singh User:AllyD 18:10, 25 April 2020 (UTC) delete The current sources are poor: a 1997 college alumni listing and a local writers' group biographical posting. The latter indicates the subject won an EY New England Entrepreneur of the Year award in 2000: there is nothing to verify this on the EY website and a regional award wouldn't be inherently notable anyway. There is also a Computer Weekly item from the same year https://www.computerweekly.com/feature/Up-close-and-personal-Jeet-Singh but I am inclined to regard that as relating to his then :Art Technology Group role. Boston Business Journal had an item in 2018 about the subject buying an expensive house https://www.bizjournals.com/boston/news/2018/02/01/venture-capitalist-pays-6-7-million-for-beacon.html but, again, that does not carry automatic notability. The subject does not meet the criteria; as a businessman he may be closer to meeting , but I don't see enough beyond his Art Technology Group role to merit a distinct article Deletion of Jeet Singh :WP:MUSICBIO||:WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14868 19751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I eat pandas User:Thin 08:49, 15 August 2007 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of I eat pandas WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14869 17174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Rain User:Lankiveil 11:31, 5 January 2008 (UTC) delete fictional character with no notability outside the movie he appears in. Fails Deletion of Alex Rain WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
14870 8467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brunson Elementary School User:Mkdw 00:35, 6 February 2013 (UTC) merge Not enough content or to warrant a standalone article. Redirect as directed at Deletion of Brunson Elementary School WP:SIGCOV||WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Notability 77
14871 1025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joop Sanders User:Shawn 23:41, 5 April 2009 (UTC) keep for me, as well. While good refs are a little hard to track down, Google reveals he was a notable figure in the American Abstract Expressionist movement and his exhibitions appear to easily satisfy Deletion of Joop Sanders WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14872 6103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/X Vietnam (album) User:Thivierr 17:32, 27 May 2006 (UTC) keep The band Quilapayún (not mentioned in original version) appears to meet , so the album is automatically included Deletion of X Vietnam (album) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14873 15040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/V. Saajan NONE NONE delete as it stands. Film editors are rarely notable, and there's nothing here that suggests that the subject meets the notability requirements. copy includes Deletion of V. Saajan WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14874 2376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J. N. Kellett Elementary School (2nd nomination) User:Spyder_Monkey 19:15, 8 February 2012 (UTC) merge to Seneca, South Carolina per #Schools Deletion of J. N. Kellett Elementary School (2nd nomination) WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
14875 3720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Radevski (2nd nomination) User:MichaelQSchmidt 00:06, 17 July 2012 (UTC) keep """Possibly a WP:AUTOBIO''"""" does '''not''' mean it is one... and while COI is always a concern, it is not a strong deletion rationale for notable topics (see Jimmy Wales), and even if it ''were'' a COI (not established)... the author has not touched the article for nearly two years. The 2009 nominator returning it again to AFD is fine so that we can revisit the issues of November 2009 and see how this person's career may have progressed in the interim. However, being """"''just a director''"""" can be notable enough if works or director are covered reliable soucres. We do not expect nor demand that a person notable to Australia be notable world-wide, nor do we demand that their career grows, nor that they stay in the news |if they had enough coverage in the past. Conversely, having ''enough'' coverage in reliable sources '''''IS''''' a valid reason to """"weak keep""""... but yes, the article needs work. Okay. Being improvable, even if |not done, does not automaticaly equate to deletion. So... what do we have that could assist in improvements |some time in the future? http://www.smh.com.au/news/tv-reviews/inside-australia-the-prodigal-son/2006/05/02/1146335720355.html ''Sidney Morning Herald'' speaks toward the filmmaker or his works in a more-than-trivial fashion. So does http://www.theage.com.au/news/tv--radio/seeing-both-sides/2006/04/25/1145861347223.html ''The Age'' and http://www.nysun.com/arts/returning-home-somewhat-changed/63996/ ''The New York Sun'' The filmmaker being an editor at ''National Library of Australia#Trove|Trove'' means little, as we do not delete Roger Ebert simply because he authors works in places other than Wikipedia. The University of Notre Dame Australia offers some background.http://www.nd.edu.au/sydney/schools/arts/staff/tradevski.shtml ''Culture Unplugged'' offers more.http://www.cultureunplugged.com/storyteller/Tony_Radevski His films have screened internationally. Anyone check for coverage of them""" Deletion of Tony Radevski (2nd nomination) WP:NTEMP||WP:NEGLECT||WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14876 4835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gabrielle Bennett User:RightCowLeftCoast 04:07, 30 April 2013 (UTC) delete subject has received passing mention in multiple non-primary reliable sources, however none of these sources give |in-depth |significant coverage to the subject of this AfD; therefore the subject appears to fail & , let a lone Deletion of Gabrielle Bennett WP:INDEPTH||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14877 6928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laine Hitz User:Cewbot 00:03, 28 August 2020 (UTC) comment This nomination has had limited participation and falls within the standards set for |lack of quorum. There are no previous AfD discussions, undeletions, or current redirects and no previous PRODs have been located. This nomination may be '''eligible for |soft deletion''' at the end of its 7-day listing Deletion of Laine Hitz WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
14878 3521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Smith (footballer born September 1985) (2nd nomination) User:RGTraynor 14:48, 28 April 2008 (UTC) delete Fails . The Keep proponents base their POV on the premise that Smith plays for a fully professional club, but this is what, fifth rung, and that only barely Deletion of James Smith (footballer born September 1985) (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14879 8176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alien Presence User:Celestina007 00:14, 11 July 2021 (UTC) delete per rationale by {{u|Bovineboy2008}}, I too do not see met Deletion of Alien Presence WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
14880 11018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sports Development Foundation Scotland User:AllyD 18:28, 27 June 2020 (UTC) delete The article text presents the organisation's charity registration (but not its deregistration) and sets out its original aspirations, some as mundane as registering with the :JustGiving site, none of which amounts to achieved notability. In 2009 the Scottish Sun had https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/archives/news/28332/can-you-make-ours-a-guinness/ a passing mention of a fundraising event. The motion by a then-:Member of the Scottish Parliament|MSP about its formation may be the most substantial (even if no longer verifiable), but I don't see that a congratulatory motion at formation confers lasting |notability, and might be countered by the overall silence apparent about the organisation's demise. Fails Deletion of Sports Development Foundation Scotland :WP:GNG||:WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14881 15388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Booze Exchange Party Noun User:Cullen328 16:02, 12 November 2010 (UTC) delete per Metropolitan90, and also because the article is unreferenced and written in an unencyclopedic style. It seems to be Deletion of Booze Exchange Party Noun WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
14882 8078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Stevie Ray Vaughan [[User talk:71.17.141.228|talk]]) 17:19, 26 January 2011 (UTC) keep per . Merging this into the main article would make it much too long. Special:Contributions/71.17.141.228|71.17.141.228 Deletion of Death of Stevie Ray Vaughan WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Splitting 57
14883 1980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baha Alzalg User:BernardoSulzbach 02:25, 3 January 2020 (UTC) delete """The thing that I dislike the most about this is that it was entirely written by the person the article is about using their own sources, which makes the """"independent of the subject"""" invalid""" Deletion of Baha Alzalg WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14884 16945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mavelikkara Additional District Court User:Eggishorn 03:50, 11 February 2017 (UTC) delete District court buildings are not inherently notable, and there is no sign of significant independent coverage in Deletion of Mavelikkara Additional District Court WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14885 20210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dumb Blondes User:Livitup 18:19, 6 January 2012 (UTC) delete Reluctant, but still a delete. I put some effort into searching, since it really looked like someone put some effort into writing the article, but they just aren't notable and I don't see a case for here Deletion of Dumb Blondes WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
14886 12842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roger E. Moore NONE NONE keep per Esprit15d. | G7 does allow for speedying if Deletion of Roger E. Moore WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14887 13610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Sudan-related topics (2nd nomination) User:Themfromspace 00:43, 14 January 2010 (UTC) merge any relevant information to Outline of Sudan. Both articles are about the same general topic, and we don't need duplicates. The goal of outlines is to provide a general overview of a topic and the goal of lists is to provide an encyclopedic investigation into a topic. This topic is |too broad for an encyclopedic investigation, hence my preference for the outline Deletion of List of Sudan-related topics (2nd nomination) WP:SALAT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
14888 21425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ayman Sadiq User:K 03:51, 20 August 2018 (UTC) delete """not independently notable of 10 Minute School; does not meet either. Just a page on an unremarkable entrepreneur. """"30 under 30"""" is an insufficient claim of significance""" Deletion of Ayman Sadiq WP:NAUTHOR||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14889 6414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jayme Dee (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep This person meets . Examples include Deletion of Jayme Dee (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14890 8548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Zatch Bell! chapters User:VigilancePrime 17:01, 6 January 2008 (UTC) keep What the nominator said is correct, the article ''is'' unencyclopedic and there isn't anything salvagable there. BUT, the article could expand greatly, as with the other list pages given above. I think that this is a legitimate comparison per (and one of the lists even had more, next-level lists!) and sets the precedent for this. Someone has another related page {{tl|inuse}} and would do well to work on this list page next. On a note, I don't see a personal attack above either, though I can see where a comment made could be taken as one. Let's all |assume good faith here and not take ANYTHING too seriously. It's the internet after all Deletion of List of Zatch Bell! chapters WP:OSE||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14891 6731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/April Jace (2nd nomination) User:Trackinfo 06:04, 10 February 2018 (UTC) keep We are back with the same NOM as the previous AfD, which resulted in a '''Keep.''' Obviously he is not satisfied with the previous decision so he is making us re-litigate the previous decision. OK, mom said no, so lets wait and ask dad. What we established previously was that Jace was a world champion masters track and field athlete prior to her murder. She obviously is not going to keep generating news on her athletic career. Her subsequent murder by her actor husband overwhelms a simple google search, but like the previous AfD, still does not apply. Since the previous AfD, the trial of her husband/murderer occurred. While we did not keep the article up to current news, the story was not stagnant. I have added additional sources including two quotes from the trial where her running career was a factor in her husband's jealousy, which led to her murder and the pre-meditated methodology of the murder Deletion of April Jace (2nd nomination) WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14892 597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jimmy the Gypsy User:The 10:47, 29 June 2007 (UTC) delete Definitely a hoax, seems to be something made up in school or work one day, not a single |source or actual information to make it satisfy the |notability guideline Deletion of Jimmy the Gypsy WP:V||WP:NN Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14893 267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuwaiti Arab User:Colonel 20:58, 19 May 2012 (UTC) keep The people of Kuwait are obviously notable and we have other articles about them such as demographics of Kuwait and Kuwaiti Arabic. Per our |editing policy, we should use ordinary editing to improve our coverage of this topic Deletion of Kuwaiti Arab WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
14894 18258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pilis problem User:Ermenrich 21:00, 5 March 2020 (UTC) delete Looking at the original Hungarian page, it appears to be an unfinished page there as well that was written by the blocked person translating it into English. Doesn't belong on Wikipedia at all Deletion of Pilis problem WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
14895 14743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corpus Delicti (band) User:Zeibura 22:22, 27 June 2007 (UTC) keep passes criterion 5 of by having 2 compilations (including a best of album) released on Cleopatra Deletion of Corpus Delicti (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14896 20514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omroep Zeeland User:Toughpigs 08:01, 25 February 2020 (UTC) keep per . The article has been significantly improved by Gidonb since the nomination. If some of the 25 sources now cited in the article are independent and reliable, then GNG is met. I think that demanding more sources in order to pass GNG just encourages the addition of more trivia, like the sexual assault incident. This article is fine; we should move on Deletion of Omroep Zeeland WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
14897 9504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrián Vásquez User:Cewbot 00:02, 23 April 2021 (UTC) comment This nomination has had limited participation and falls within the standards set for |lack of quorum. There are no previous AfD discussions, undeletions, or current redirects and no previous PRODs have been located. This nomination may be '''eligible for |soft deletion''' at the end of its 7-day listing Deletion of Adrián Vásquez WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
14898 14706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shahjad khan User:GSS 11:24, 3 March 2017 (UTC) delete possible CSD A7): This teenager's autobiography has no indication of passing Deletion of Shahjad khan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14899 8689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Royal Insight Forum User:Newslinger 10:44, 17 July 2018 (UTC) delete Non notable. Absolutely no reliable sources. Article appears to be |original research Deletion of Royal Insight Forum WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14900 9226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Parente User:Edison 18:52, 6 May 2009 (UTC) delete Per , and per . A splash of news coverage, but no indication it is causing any effects on society. Wikipedia is not a compilation of every murder or murderer Deletion of William Parente WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14901 8145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agumon382 User:Sjakkalle 09:51, 30 January 2006 (UTC) delete Autobiographical article (written in first person) which meets A7 Deletion of Agumon382 WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14902 7462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jewish Israeli stone throwing User:XavierItzm 00:36, 19 May 2018 (UTC) comment """the nomination is defective. The nomination alleges that «The incidents listed in the article have nothing in common, certainly not a common topic. '''Moreover they are sourced to news reports''' merely show that stones were thrown». This is incorrect. The article is not based on """"news reports."""" Currently the article cites the following nine books:1. Book: Bethell, Nicholas (1979). ''The Palestine Triangle''.2. Book: Nachman Ben-Yehuda, ''Theocratic Democracy: The Social Construction of Religious and Secular Extremism''3. Book: Samuel C. Heilman, ''Defenders of the Faith: Inside Ultra-Orthodox Jewry''4. Book: W. Gordon Lawrence, ''Tongued with Fire: Groups in Experience''5. Book:Roger Friedland; Richard Hecht (2000). ''To Rule Jerusalem.''6. Book: Jonathan Boyarin, ''Palestine and Jewish History: Criticism at the Borders of Ethnography'' 7. Book: Nora L. Rubel, ''Doubting the Devout: The Ultra-Orthodox in the Jewish American Imagination'' 8. Book: Lev Luis Grinberg, ''Politics and Violence in Israel/Palestine: Democracy Versus Military Rule'' 9. Book: Adam LeBor, City of Oranges: ''Arabs and Jews in Jaffa''Furthermore, the article cites the following government, non-governmental organization books, and scholarly articles, which are not news:1. Government: U.S. Govm't Printing Office, ''Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 2009''2. NGO: Human Rights Watch, ''Center of the Storm: A Case Study of Human Rights Abuses in Hebron District'' 3. Scholarly Journal: Journal of Israeli History: Politics, Society, Culture, Volume 24, Issue 1, 2005; Benny Morris, ''The Historiography of Deir Yassin''There are, in addition, 27 citations from news sources. News sources should not be disparaged. News sources are routinely cited on Wikipedia articles. The sources on this article come from unquestionable , such as the ''Jewish Telegraphic Agency'', ''The Los Angeles Times'', the ''Jerusalem Post'', ''Haaretz'', the ''Times of Israel'', etc.In conclusion, we have a defective nomination which does not withstand an examination of the actual sources""" Deletion of Jewish Israeli stone throwing WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14903 7125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The CODE for Global Ethics User:MelanieN 15:34, 23 July 2010 (UTC) delete """or '''Userfy''' until some external sources can be found. The book exists, it is published by a real publisher (not self-published), and it is available through normal commercial channels; so far so good. However, I could not find a single reference about the book in reliable sources. There are a lot of Google hits, but they are to blogs etc. So it currently fails the notability test. Suggestions for the author if she decides to improve the article and try again: first, read the notability requirements at ; the absolute requirement is that there must be independent reliable sources talking about the book. If there aren't, then no amount of rewriting is going to make the article notable enough for Wikipedia. Those sources need to be cited in the article in a references section; you can learn how to do that Help:Contents/Editing_Wikipedia|here. The article currently does too much advocating for the author's viewpoint, instead of presenting information ABOUT the book. There are too many """"see also"""" entries, many only tangentially related to the book. Finally, if the article is userfied, the name should be changed to """"The Code for Global Ethics"""", losing the all-caps CODE""" Deletion of The CODE for Global Ethics WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14904 6525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sacred Gin User:Dennisthe2 13:51, 11 May 2009 (UTC) delete I can't in good conscience say otherwise when three articles are ''about'' to be published on account of . This is great and all, but still. That, and this sounds more like a promotional article to begin with, aside from the |notability issues. On top of that, the article is all over the map - explains briefly the gin, and then goes into recipes to be used, amongst other things. If it's to stay, it needs to be notable, and needs a rewrite as well Deletion of Sacred Gin WP:CRYSTAL||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14905 19823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valin Shinyei User:B 12:31, 22 August 2019 (UTC) delete Article was NEVER approved for move from |article for creation but it was moved by Deletion of Valin Shinyei WP:AFC Wikipedia:Articles for creation 55
14906 3429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rahul Rajasekharan User:4meter4 20:47, 16 June 2021 (UTC) keep per sources found by GRuban and those cited in the article. Passes Deletion of Rahul Rajasekharan WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
14907 15542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evangeline Beechler User:KidAd 00:18, 9 April 2021 (UTC) keep """Seems to be a part of a coordinated deletion attempt, made minutes after Fred Cornforth was nominated. As I said there, per , """"The following are presumed to be notable: {{tq|Politicians and judges who have held international, national, or (for countries with federal or similar systems of government) '''state/province–wide office'''}}. As the chair of a major party at the state-wide level, this individual meets """ Deletion of Evangeline Beechler WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14908 14881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peninsula Gaming User:Toohool 20:31, 15 April 2015 (UTC) keep """I've expanded the article with more references that should make it clear that is satisfied. Though I'm not sure why this AfD was opened without even an argument for deletion from the nom. Neither the fact that the company is small, nor the fact that most of the refs were """"about their attempts to acquire property"""" are reasons for deletion""" Deletion of Peninsula Gaming WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14909 19118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MXW Pro Wrestling User:Warrah 17:37, 19 March 2010 (UTC) keep Barely passes requirements Deletion of MXW Pro Wrestling WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14910 14856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of alien species in the Honorverse User:The 09:17, 6 June 2019 (UTC) delete since there are no |sources |verifying the independent notability of the subject. It's a purely unsourced text, the result no doubt of |personal enthusiasm and seemingly hard work, but |Wikipedia is not a place for fans' loving entreaties. We cannot merge away anything: When a text is unsupported by references to outside sources, we do not dump it elsewhere in Wikipedia; we delete it Deletion of List of alien species in the Honorverse WP:RS||WP:V||WP:OR||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14911 7560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TCOLondon User:Bakazaka 18:41, 14 April 2019 (UTC) delete as unambiguous . The article is an extension of the company's promotional efforts. The approach, citing passing mentions and even sources that do not mention the company at all, just illustrates how little actual coverage there is of this company. For those who prefer guidelines to policy, the company fails Deletion of TCOLondon WP:PROMO||WP:REFBOMB||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14912 3734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert C. Suggs User:Slon02 23:07, 31 October 2010 (UTC) delete I could not find any sources to verify notability, so the article fails Deletion of Robert C. Suggs WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14913 13227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Panuganti shalem raju -madigas pride in andhrapradesh User:Bejnar 22:05, 25 July 2014 (UTC) delete can't find any coverage, fails Deletion of Panuganti shalem raju -madigas pride in andhrapradesh WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14914 266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rudra soni User:Piotrus 13:00, 6 December 2016 (UTC) delete Minor coverage, no main roles (IMDb has a single entry). to be in an encyclopedia Deletion of Rudra soni WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
14915 20219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chasing Shadows (EP) User:doomsdayer520 21:50, 23 September 2019 (UTC) keep I wonder if the nominator and the previous voter really searched for sources of if they just looked at the present state of the article. The EP made the Billboard charts, a fact that is presently cited in the article, and thus qualifies for #2. Professional notice was admittedly scanty but it was covered briefly at LouderSound (https://www.loudersound.com/news/angels-airwaves-stream-chasing-shadows-ep) and a few other places, and received a robust review at Sputnik Music (https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/70374/Angels-and-Airwaves-Chasing-Shadows/). Thus it has a few reliable sources per #1 Deletion of Chasing Shadows (EP) :WP:NALBUM||:WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
14916 13394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dominik Uher User:Giants2008 00:05, 14 July 2011 (UTC) delete Found some articles on Google News mentioning him in game and draft recaps, but what I saw didn't establish that he meets or Deletion of Dominik Uher WP:GNG||WP:NSPORTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14917 12614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mutahir Showkat User:Netherzone 21:03, 23 March 2021 (UTC) delete The subject of the article fails and . The source assessment table crafted by {{u|Spiderone}} is helpful in determining the weakess of the sourcing. Wikipedia is not the right venue to advertise books Deletion of Mutahir Showkat WP:GNG||WP:NARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
14918 16638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Secret Pakistan NONE NONE keep This article needs work, yes, |but so what Deletion of Secret Pakistan WP:PROBLEM Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
14919 7307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shri Kamalkishor Kadam User:Fitindia 11:02, 28 January 2017 (UTC) keep Notable Nationalist Congress Party leader and has been a minister in the Indian state of Maharashtra clearly passes Deletion of Shri Kamalkishor Kadam WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14920 15654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Was it the Walrus User:Bearcat 18:26, 15 August 2016 (UTC) delete Makes no claim of notability that would pass , and isn't sourced to anything like the kind of coverage it takes to pass . As always, Wikipedia is ''not'' a free public relations platform where any band is ''entitled'' to an article just because they ''exist Deletion of Was it the Walrus WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14921 13997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francesca Ortolani (2nd nomination) User:Shalom 19:39, 2 July 2007 (UTC) delete per nom and not a single reference for criteria Deletion of Francesca Ortolani (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14922 14180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/4shared User:Bigger 18:18, 9 September 2010 (UTC) delete Fails , and reads quite like a promotional page Deletion of 4shared WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14923 9134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The 20 Year Internet Outlook User:TBC 22:55, 26 March 2006 (UTC) delete per above, |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball Deletion of The 20 Year Internet Outlook WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14924 17793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Esteban Abada Elementary School (2nd nomination) User:RightCowLeftCoast 15:31, 14 March 2013 (UTC) merge to Quezon City#The Project Areas|Project 7 or appropriate school district article. Subject has received multiple mentions in multiple non-primary |reliable sources; that being said if added up the sum does not equal |significant coverage. Therefore, the subject of this AfD is not notable as defined by or . That being said the |common practice is to redirect elementary school articles to the school district which governs them, or if such an article does not exist, to the community where they are located Deletion of Esteban Abada Elementary School (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG||WP:ORG||WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14925 320 [[Protein-coated Disc]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Man77 NONE delete Grenzfall trifft es wohl recht gut. Die RK für Alltagsgegenstände verlangen eine Bedeutung aus wissenschaftlicher Sicht. Die kann man wohl argumentieren, jedoch sehe ich in dem Gegenstand bzw. in dem Entwicklungsvorhaben keinen ''Alltags''gegenstand. Drum scheint es mir angebracht, es eher auf Basis der allgemeinen Kriterien zu beurteilen, und da fehlt mir bei ca. 100 bereinigten Google-Hits und genau 2 Funden im News-Archiv von Google die Basis für die Annahme, dass eine breite oder zeitüberdauernde Öffentlichkeitswirkung heute angenommen werden kann. Dass, was wissenschaftliche Veröffentlichungen anbelangt, ein besonderes Interesse anzunehmen ist, sehe ich tendenziell nicht so, diesbezüglich könnte man mich, Stichwort aber eventuell vom Gegenteil überzeugen. In diesem Sinne Löschung von Protein-coated Disc Wikipedia:LP Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
14926 10253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jenna Miscavige Hill User:Cyclopia 01:05, 3 January 2011 (UTC) keep Notable per as shown above by several editors Deletion of Jenna Miscavige Hill WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14927 15905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ern Condon User:Bearcat 12:10, 9 June 2020 (UTC) delete """To be fair, this was created in 2004, a time when we ''did'' extend an automatic """"inherently notable"""" freebie to all leaders of political parties regardless of their degree of electoral success or failure — but our notability standards for politicians have been tightened up considerably in the intervening 16 years, and this is not an article-clinching notability claim anymore if the person cannot be shown to get over on the quality of his ''sources''. But literally the only source here is a raw table of election results, which is not a notability-making source""" Deletion of Ern Condon WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14928 7379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Samizadeh User:Pharaoh 08:44, 4 July 2020 (UTC) keep Passes Deletion of Alex Samizadeh WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
14929 20674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Horner User:Bearcat 21:42, 4 August 2021 (UTC) delete """People do not get Wikipedia articles just for running as candidates in elections they did not win — the notability test at is ''holding'' a notable political office, not just running for one, and no, whether you define the party he ran for as """"major"""" or """"minor"""" doesn't make a difference to that at all, as """"losing candidate for a major party"""" still isn't a notability criterion. Notability is also ''not'' boosted by sources where Tom Horner is the ''author'' of content about other ''things'', so none of Tom Ruen's hits above help at all — notability can ''only'' be established by sources where Tom Horner is the ''subject'' of third party analytical content written by other ''people'', and the existence of |run of the mill campaign coverage of a losing candidate is ''not'' enough in and of itself if he can't be shown to have garnered any non-trivial coverage in other contexts as well, precisely because ''every'' losing candidate in ''every'' election ''everywhere'' can ''always'' show some evidence of campaign coverage. To be notable enough for a Wikipedia article, rather, it would have to be demonstrated that either (a) he had preexisting notability for other reasons that would have already gotten him into Wikipedia ''independently'' of an unsuccessful election candidacy, or (b) he could show a strong reason why his candidacy should be regarded as much more ''special'' than everybody else's candidacies, in some way that would pass the |ten year test for ''enduring'' significance. Neither of those things are in evidence here, however""" Deletion of Tom Horner WP:NPOL||WP:MILL||WP:10YT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14930 2437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camille Cleverley User:Edison 16:26, 18 September 2007 (UTC) delete """The article can be judged on its merits irrespective of any prior conflicts between the nominator and other editors. This is a tragic incident wherein a non-notable young person fell to her death in a possible accident. Hundreds of thousands of people annually die just as tragically in accidents and do not merit encyclopedia articles. Fox News or """"America's Most Wanted"""" selects stories to boost ratings, and encyclopedia editors have different criteria for what is notable or encyclopedic, as stated in the essay as well as the policy #NEWS. Wikipedia is neither a memorial site to remember the departed nor a news archive to forever report every accidental death. The fact that the media chose to print several stories about a missing young blond white woman does not mean that is satisfied""" Deletion of Camille Cleverley WP:NOTNEWS||WP:NOT||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14931 4746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled Second Fergie Album User:Rjd0060 02:04, 29 September 2007 (UTC) delete Per and that article is horribly written (at least couple sentences that make up the article are Deletion of Untitled Second Fergie Album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14932 3046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disappearance of Amy Fitzpatrick User:BabbaQ 14:57, 1 September 2011 (UTC) keep does not fail , per coverage. and does not apply in my opinion to any article as Wikipedia IS in fact built on news. Without news no article about any person would have been made. Most wikipedia articles are sourced with news-sites material. Anyway notable disappearance article Deletion of Disappearance of Amy Fitzpatrick WP:VICTIM||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14933 15964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Ladas User:MelanieN 15:54, 22 February 2013 (UTC) delete This surgeon is not notable, although I wish the nominator had expanded on their reasons for saying so. Ladas was the subject of one significant item in an independent source: the Daily Mail article which is already cited. One such article is not enough. Otherwise he seems to be a competent but run-of-the-mill surgeon. The puffery in the article is uncited, and large parts of the article are cut-and-pasted from his bio page at the hospital where he practices.http://www.rbht.nhs.uk/healthprofessionals/consultants/ladas/ http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=George+Ladas&btnG=&as_sdt=1%2C5&as_sdtp= Google Scholar finds him as one of multiple authors on some moderately-cited papers; that's not enough to qualify per Deletion of George Ladas WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
14934 4035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Hardin [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 16:05, 24 June 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and . Is not listed on the all American team at the AP's web sitehttp://collegefootball.ap.org/article/ap-all-america-team-list.Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Greg Hardin WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
14935 1969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atongko (film) User:Pharaoh 18:47, 13 January 2016 (UTC) delete Fails and lacks reliable third party sources Deletion of Atongko (film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
14936 12181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cameron Gaunce User:Nurmsook 02:54, 1 February 2011 (UTC) delete Rationale for removing the prod was that the subject passes , but didn't and the other sport specific notability guidelines replace ? Regardless, there is no evidence that the subject passes , and of course, he does not pass either Deletion of Cameron Gaunce WP:ATHLETE||WP:NHOCKEY||WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
14937 17259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judicial activism in the European Union User:Alpha 04:38, 3 March 2012 (UTC) keep the subject has received |significant coverage in |reliable third party sources and meets the |notability guidelines. There does appear to be enough content to build a complete article, through if this is not possible, I would support a merger Deletion of Judicial activism in the European Union WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14938 7755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shopping Palace User:Adamant1 21:50, 7 November 2020 (UTC) delete I linked it's Wikidata page. Which seems to have articles on it in other languages. None of which are referenced. I couldn't find anything that would pass in a search for it either. So, is a clear delete in my book Deletion of Shopping Palace WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14939 15632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sahra Şaş User:TimothyBlue 18:07, 25 August 2020 (UTC) delete Does not pass or . No just mentions, press releases, promo articles // Deletion of Sahra Şaş WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
14940 1741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anabond Limited [[User talk:98.215.48.213|talk]]) 11:56, 13 May 2008 (UTC) comment """The second reference in the article, as currently listed, has been deleted at its' source. Per , """"A company, corporation, organization, team, religion, group, product, or service is notable if it has been the subject of coverage in secondary sources. Such sources must be reliable, and independent of the subject. The depth of coverage of the subject by the source must be considered."""" Are there enough references in depth in the article to justify notability? I don't see it, myself. Special:Contributions/98.215.48.213|98.215.48.213""" Deletion of Anabond Limited WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14941 304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheetal Prashad Pal User:Mrt3366 16:18, 17 February 2013 (UTC) delete per nom and perhaps is applicable here Deletion of Sheetal Prashad Pal WP:G3 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
14942 325 [[Reinhold Anderlitschek]] (erl. gelöscht) Benutzer:TStephan 15:20, 5. Sep. 2011 (CEST) keep Träger des Verdienstkreuzes 1. Klasse wurden hier meines Wissens bisher stets behalten (/7._Februar_2011#Harald_Link_.28bleibt.29|Beispiel). Aber vielleicht ist es ja diesmal anders Löschung von Reinhold Anderlitschek Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14943 6664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Phineas and Ferb songs User:Superastig 16:39, 15 May 2020 (UTC) merge to Phineas and Ferb: Per nominator. Definitely Deletion of List of Phineas and Ferb songs WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
14944 5343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spikor User:A 00:16, 23 February 2010 (UTC) keep as this particular character is notable to people in the real world with even a http://civilizedpigdom.com/motu/spikor/img/cover.jpg cover titular appearance of a publication in addition to being on the show and as a http://www.timelesstrinkets.com/HeManSheRa/Images/HeManSpikorComplete.jpg toy. As nominator offers a merge location above, at worst we would follow and and do that instead of redlinking. Sincerely Deletion of Spikor WP:BEFORE||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14945 2031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zoom Vacations User:TonyTheTiger 01:42, 5 May 2020 (UTC) keep I think the point of is that there needs to be a way to account for subjects that have enough non-trivial coverage to amount to substantial coverage. rules out non-notable awards as passing mentions that amount to trivial coverage. However, if we deem these awards to be notable in the field, then the subject probably passes BASIC Deletion of Zoom Vacations WP:BASIC||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14946 18247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sir John Kothalawala Maha Vidyalaya (school) User:VMS 12:00, 3 February 2016 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Sir John Kothalawala Maha Vidyalaya (school) WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
14947 8344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nadine Jansen User:Guest9999 14:56, 6 January 2010 (UTC) delete Not only is there no evidence of ''significant coverage'' by independent |reliable sources - a requirement of the |general notability guideline and the basic criterion given in the |specific criteria for people (of which the criteria for |pornographic actors is part) but there doesn't appear to be ''any'' coverage by |reliable sources at all. The current article is copy pasted from an older version but it only gives apparently unreliable sources such as IMDb as well as obscure, unreliable, non-NN|notable pornographic websites and magazines including http://www.amontillado.it/ and Voluptuous Magazine. Whilst I have to admit I am not familiar with these publications I would imagine that the information contained within them is designed more to titillate rather than to be an accurate source for a ''high quality'' encyclopaedia - I can find no evidence that any of the sources have a reputation for fact checking and accuracy. This a |biography of a living person, the fact that the individual works in a industry from which individuals do not receive a lot of mainstream - or other reliable - coverage does not change the fact that no |reliable sources should mean no article Deletion of Nadine Jansen WP:RS||WP:NN||WP:BIO||WP:PORNBIO||WP:RS||WP:BLP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14948 13245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aelita (album) User:Gongshow 07:19, 27 December 2011 (UTC) keep Significant coverage at http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/10434-aelita/ Pitchfork and http://www.popmatters.com/pm/review/tied-tickled-trio-aelita PopMatters is sufficient to meet . I've added these sources to the article Deletion of Aelita (album) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14949 1973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Affluenza: When Too Much is Never Enough User:Lankiveil 09:58, 12 November 2008 (UTC) keep meets and due to secondary coverage in reliable sources. Suggest that it's time to consider a Snow Keep Deletion of Affluenza: When Too Much is Never Enough WP:BK||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14950 7352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/YTD Video Downloader User:MelbourneStar 05:01, 13 August 2013 (UTC) delete Reads just like an |advertisement, before and after clean-up unfortunately Deletion of YTD Video Downloader WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
14951 19477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khalid Ali-M Aldawsari User:Cullen328 03:04, 17 August 2013 (UTC) keep """I don't think that applies to someone sentenced to life in prison for a plot to assassinate a former president of the United States. That is a massive claim of notability that trumps """"one event"""" concerns""" Deletion of Khalid Ali-M Aldawsari WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
14952 11392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Slovene Argentines User:Themfromspace 23:53, 5 March 2010 (UTC) delete as we are |not a directory. Just because we have a category on this isn't a reason to have a list of it as well, because lists and categories are not one and the same; each have different criteria and expectations. Having a category for this is appropriate because it ''categorizes'' the information and allows one to quickly see which of Wikipedia's articles are about Slovene Argentines. Having a list is not appropriate because the list is in article in itself, and as such it needs to abide by policies such as and , and the subject of the article (''List of Slovene Argentines'') must be notable in itself Deletion of List of Slovene Argentines WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOTDIR||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14953 11682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Not the Bradys XXX User:Atlantic306 20:23, 24 June 2018 (UTC) delete does not pass or and be aware that although the article gives the impression this is softcore porn it is very much hardcore and is not covered in reliable sources, thanks Deletion of Not the Bradys XXX WP:NFILM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14954 5018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lacework User:HighKing 18:25, 30 January 2018 (UTC) delete No indications of notability, references fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic fails GNG and . Article is also overly promotional both in tone and content, fails Deletion of Lacework WP:NCORP||WP:SPIP Wikipedia:Notability 77
14955 6534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laurence D. Smith User:Xxanthippe 22:55, 2 July 2017 (UTC) keep Four publications with over 100 cites each on GS satisfies rof#C1 Deletion of Laurence D. Smith WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
14956 12720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daryl Wine Bar and Restaurant (2nd nomination) User:Agne27 22:09, 7 February 2011 (UTC) delete """per lack of that establishes notability beyond an isolated regional scope. Any restaurant can get the same amount of trivial coverage in regional news sections and sources. It is a farce to the '''global''' readership of Wikipedia to say that such """"local-centric"""" coverage makes the business notable enough for a global encyclopedia""" Deletion of Daryl Wine Bar and Restaurant (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
14957 18754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryan Kent User:Sliggy 21:33, 27 March 2006 (UTC) delete Does not meet guidelines Deletion of Bryan Kent WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14958 20712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Everyone's A Wally User:Xtifr 11:49, 22 October 2006 (UTC) keep WP:SOFTWARE is not a guideline, merely an in-progress proposal subject to change without notice. Most of the cases where I see it raised, there's also obvious |conflict of interest or spam issues, but in this case, we're talking about a historical program for defunct machines, so that's clearly not the case. I think the early days of personal computing are underdocumented (especially on-line, so ghits is not a reliable measure), and of great historical interest, so, while I would prefer to see more assertions of notability and verifiability, I think it would be reasonable to merely mark this as a stub for now Deletion of Everyone's A Wally WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
14959 21249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laurie Geltman User:Northamerica1000 23:07, 27 March 2015 (UTC) keep Meets . Source examples: https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1817&dat=20080125&id=TDAzAAAAIBAJ&sjid=vqcEAAAAIBAJ&pg=3752,3274542&hl=en, https://books.google.com/books?id=YbQC3aRdheAC&pg=PA142 (pp. 142-143), http://www.metrowestdailynews.com/article/20080123/News/301239831, http://www.metroactive.com/papers/metro/04.15.99/audiofile-9915.html, https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=2457&dat=19980622&id=aaRJAAAAIBAJ&sjid=hQ0NAAAAIBAJ&pg=6175,2193148&hl=en and https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=2457&dat=19980622&id=aaRJAAAAIBAJ&sjid=hQ0NAAAAIBAJ&pg=1223,2214284&hl=en. See also: , section D Deletion of Laurie Geltman WP:BASIC||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14960 17510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unofficial Graal Communication Center User:Jagen 03:10, 24 July 2006 (UTC) delete agree with others that it fails Deletion of Unofficial Graal Communication Center WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14961 14201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Molloy (footballer) User:GiantSnowman 15:17, 27 July 2009 (UTC) delete """player fails (as he hasn't """"competed at the fully professional level of a sport"""") and (as he hasn't """"received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject""" Deletion of Jason Molloy (footballer) WP:ATHLETE||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
14962 17644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deletionpedia (4th nomination) User:David 17:19, 24 February 2010 (UTC) keep In any society with free speech, there is a dynamic between publishing with no censorship and publishing with censorship to protect people from libel, copyright violation, trade secret violation, being exposed to extreme forms of pornography and illegal acts, and other violations of their rights and the protection of minors. In other words, it is not always clear whether the right to free speech overrides other rights in specific cases. Since WP is an encyclopedia, used by anyone including children and people residing in countries opposing the idea of freedom of speech, I believe that WP should be self-censored with respect to protecting people's rights. However, I also believe that deleted articles and text deleted from articles should be accessible from a separate website (such as Deletionpedia) which proclaims itself as completely uncensored. This arrangement makes it possible for search engines and governments to block this separate site easily when desired, yet to provide a source for investigating rights violations and satisfying other valid inquiries. Clearly, a WP article about such a site is and does not ''a priori'' compromise the self-censorship of WP Deletion of Deletionpedia (4th nomination) WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14963 8338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of human deities in Dungeons & Dragons User:Devonian 01:22, 6 May 2020 (UTC) delete a list of useless fancruft that fails and . Article is not a useful redirect, and contains nothing of relevance to Merge Deletion of List of human deities in Dungeons & Dragons WP:LISTN||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14964 18365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reactions to the 2016 Lahore suicide bombing (2nd nomination) User:Yamaguchi先生 20:45, 17 October 2017 (UTC) delete per K.e.coffman and others, as an |indiscriminate collection of information, lacking . Regards Deletion of Reactions to the 2016 Lahore suicide bombing (2nd nomination) WP:NOT||WP:LISTN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14965 13161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional tobacco products User:Bearian 17:33, 12 December 2007 (UTC) delete as |unsourced and |non-useful lists Deletion of List of fictional tobacco products WP:RS||WP:LIST Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14966 7276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Perfect rhyme NONE NONE comment Yes, this is long, but I have been doing some homework on the applicable policies, and would rather just spell it out one time. I think you may be reading the guidelines too narrowly, and misinterpreting the intent. Lets look at the actual policies at hand. At least two of us are confident that it can be expanded (even if we aren't the experts to do so). My reading of wp:AFD (ie: ''If the article can be fixed through normal editing, then it is not a good candidate for AfD.'') says this isn't a good candidate for AFD, as we have explained how to fix it. I don't question the |faith of the nom in the least, it is just that others here may have more imagination when it comes to the potential for the article here. That it hasn't been expanded really isn't a strong argument to delete, via . If the consensus thinks there is no hope to ever expand, that still doesn't mean it fails WP:DICDEF automatically. DICDEF says a couple of important things that apply, including ''All stubs should have the potential to develop into full articles. A stub that has no possibility whatsoever for expansion beyond stub status is presenting the verifiable information in the wrong way. Wikipedia should not have single-fact articles.'' which I take to mean that if the article COULDN'T be expanded, then it should be merged into something else, and yes, single fact articles shouldn't be kept if they '''can't''' be expanded. I am arguing it can. Even so, DICDEF almost contradicts itself later when it says ''This does not mean that stubs that have no possibility for expansion should be copied to Wiktionary. They are still encyclopedia articles, not dictionary articles.'' so even if it WAS a single use, that doesn't automatically qualify it as a WP:DICDEF to be deleted or transwiki'ed (already there), and there may be circumstances where a short article with a single use is valid. It seems to boil down to two basic issue, and a YES to either one says we have to keep Deletion of Perfect rhyme WP:AGF||WP:NOEFFORT Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
14967 7681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hawks' Club User:Johnbod 02:11, 16 June 2007 (UTC) keep Please explain how this article does not meet notability criteria of . I notice this editor has put up a raft of AfDs which seem to relate exclusively to Oxford and Cambridge university societies. Some may be justified; others are certainly not - see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Experimental Theatre Club Deletion of Hawks' Club WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14968 2415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergio Ortega Leguias User:Struway2 20:58, 17 November 2018 (UTC) keep Subject has represented his country at senior international level, thus passing , and there seems to be a reasonable amount of RS coverage at non-trivial level to suggest a GNG pass even at my limited free-online access to Panamanian media. Incidentally, the nomination refers to an incomplete speedy deletion: I see no sign of any such thing in the article history. cheers Deletion of Sergio Ortega Leguias WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
14969 6038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of anime clichés User:Dark 22:14, 4 November 2006 (UTC) delete It might be possible to make an encyclopedic list of this sort... but at the moment its completely |OR and almost totally useless. &mdash Deletion of List of anime clichés WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
14970 21260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Organic food User:Zad68 00:57, 30 November 2012 (UTC) keep please see , this is a bad-faith AFD nomination and should probably be speedy-closed Deletion of Organic food WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
14971 36 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carmelo Bertolami User:Edison 16:00, 21 December 2007 (UTC) delete The claim of reaching 107 does not appear to satisfy and in general the requirements of and do not appear to be satisfied Deletion of Carmelo Bertolami WP:V||WP:BIO||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
14972 3132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Érin Geraghty User:Tim 06:54, 22 October 2018 (UTC) delete Though it is difficult to maintain that an article about an actor ''ipso facto'' breaches his or her privacy, I concur with the immediately preceding comment that the bulk of the citations do not conform to , and also that the notability of the performer is far from demonstrated. The statement that the article is materially inaccurate, though we are not told the details, is another reason to suggest to me that Wikipedia would do well to delete this article. I take all the points made above by Bakazaka, but on balance I think deletion is decidedly the best course Deletion of Érin Geraghty WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
14973 9493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ginebra–Meralco rivalry User:Metropolitan90 21:54, 14 October 2017 (UTC) delete The fact that two teams are in the same league or play each other often doesn't establish that they have a |notable ''rivalry''. None of the sources cited in the article discuss the rivalry between the two teams, per se Deletion of Ginebra–Meralco rivalry WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14974 10575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019 Prince Philip Road Accident and Licence Surrender User:Holotony 06:12, 10 February 2019 (UTC) delete Still clearly , all the arguments from the Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019 Prince Philip road accident|previous AFD still apply Deletion of 2019 Prince Philip Road Accident and Licence Surrender WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14975 4496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whipple Van Buren Phillips User:Pastor 02:22, 22 August 2009 (UTC) delete The subject's notability is linked solely to being the grandfather of a famous writer. The article offers no evidence that Mr. Van Buren meets requirements Deletion of Whipple Van Buren Phillips WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14976 5161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Force of Reason User:AllyD 17:29, 30 July 2011 (UTC) comment """Like """"The book was a bestseller in Europe"""" for example? Fair enough, it isn't cited but as per you could try that Google Books thingy (best combining author name with book title) to see various published discussions of this very book""" Deletion of The Force of Reason :WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
14977 8961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Lewis Dear User:Epicgenius 22:34, 29 November 2015 (UTC) merge and redirect to 2015 Colorado Springs shooting, because Deletion of Robert Lewis Dear WP:1EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
14978 1984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WikiFur (2nd nomination) User:DyslexicEditor 19:39, 3 November 2006 (UTC) delete Why it fails . It's sources are Wikipedia, Wikia, Wikimania wiki, a something awful forum post, and the only media reference http://www.cparchives.com/archive.cfm?type=Main%20Feature&action=getComplete&ref=6353 here is not about Wikifur, but about furries and only mentions Wikifur as a reference. It is basically no more a source http://observer.guardian.co.uk/magazine/story/0,,1497856,00.html than this reference to a different wiki and that wiki article got deleted. I've seen articles full of sources and even gotten on television by MSNBC and they've been deleted. Basically one vague mention in a newspaper article doesn't cut it for most articles and I see hundreds deleted each month with similar sources and they all just aren't notable enough Deletion of WikiFur (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
14979 959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2023 Formula One World Championship (2nd nomination) User:WilliamJE 12:03, 11 September 2020 (UTC) delete per Deletion of 2023 Formula One World Championship (2nd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
14980 2338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aishwarya Sheoran User:Robert 15:34, 7 August 2020 (UTC) delete WP:MILL|Run-of-the-mill model and beauty contestant. The article says that she scored 93 on what appears to be the national civil service exam, and that she was a beauty contestant. Google search shows that she exists and uses social media, and that she was a beauty contestant and that she scored 93 on what appears to be the national civil service exam. Nothing is |notable about having been a finalist in a beauty contest. No ontext|context is provided as to what a score of 93 signifies or what the distribution of scores is (but the number was probably meant to dazzle or amaze rather than to inform Deletion of Aishwarya Sheoran WP:N||WP:C Wikipedia:Notability 77
14981 18404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Woodcock User:Alan 02:57, 26 October 2006 (UTC) comment Hi Elonka. Just to make sure you're up to speed, the issues of (perceived) |vanity and |conflict of interest are a big part of why this article was nominated for AfD. In short, the unfortunate authorship/editing is interfering with the debate on Bruce's actual notability Deletion of Bruce Woodcock WP:AUTO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
14982 20012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hykko User:Angr 12:22, 6 January 2011 (UTC) delete not because it violates (it doesn't) but because it's completely unsourced and violates erifiability. Searching Google Books for this term revealed nothing useful, so unless reliable sources get added, we have no way of knowing that this isn't a WP:hoax|hoax Deletion of Hykko WP:DICT||WP:V Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
14983 10653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trelew (band) User:BalthCat 19:38, 14 May 2010 (UTC) keep Perhaps a nomination to merge would have been better than a brute redirect. As it stands, the article asserts notability. (''Release of the record led to being featured in Uruguay newspapers such as Brecha, La Diaria and El Observador'') Sourcing is a problem with a solution, not a cause for deletion. Deletion of Trelew (band) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
14984 7100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/José Francisco Cevallos, Jr. User:Cloudz679 14:48, 13 January 2014 (UTC) delete subject doesn't meet the |general notability guideline, no counter-arguements have been presented. Whether or not it meets FOOTYN is unclear but certainly not established. And since Wikipedia doesn't qualify as a |reliable source, versions of the article in different languages add no reason to keep the English-language edition Deletion of José Francisco Cevallos, Jr. WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
14985 5780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Hui User:Walton_monarchist89 14:36, 9 April 2007 (UTC) keep """there are lots of references provided, but most are in Chinese (which I don't speak), so I can't tell whether they constitute """"multiple non-trivial coverage in independent sources"""" as required to meet . An opinion from a neutral Chinese speaker would be helpful here""" Deletion of Jack Hui WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
14986 894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Corenswet User:FOARP 16:50, 31 October 2019 (UTC) keep based on the following instances of significant coverage in reliable sources: https://vmagazine.com/article/directors-cut-david-corenswet/ 1 https://www.eonline.com/uk/news/1078435/meet-david-corenswet-the-politician-star-everyone-is-talking-about 2 https://www.cosmopolitan.com/entertainment/tv/a29386391/who-is-david-corenswet-the-politician/ 3. Passes , Deletion of David Corenswet WP:BASIC||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
14987 19194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Political nihilism User:Bearian 17:10, 13 January 2017 (UTC) merge back or redirect to Nihilism. The stub is so short as to be essentially a |mere dictionary definition and does not contribute much to the broader discussion Deletion of Political nihilism WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
14988 17849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twirlin' [[User_talk:Benjiboi| -- Banjeboi]] 05:58, 3 January 2009 (UTC) keep The naming may be off but those organizations who employ canes in the step-dancing routines certainly have helped define this dance form independent of regular Stepping (African-American)|Stepping - another article that also needs work. The only issue remains sourcing which hardly seems improbable. These fraternities stage shows and competitions so it makes more sense to talk about the dance style than the fraternities or competitions themselves. We're also dealing with when dealing with minority groups and not having their reliable sources being listed alongside google news hits. http://books.google.com/books?id=PsVA9GTexK4C here's a book on the subject; cane dancing, btw, is an old artform of African dance /tap and jazz. This dance form is directly tied to the National Pan-Hellenic Council, and more broadly, African American Greek lettered fraternities and sororities Deletion of Twirlin' WP:CSB Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
14989 144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheldon Siegel User:TonyTheTiger 02:27, 25 April 2019 (UTC) delete Not . Does not pass AUTHOR or Deletion of Sheldon Siegel WP:N||WP:NAUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14990 16091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lorong Boys User:Boneso 00:22, 12 June 2018 (UTC) keep Meets ''12. Has been a featured subject of a substantial broadcast segment across a national radio or TV network.'' To avoid confusion and are shortcuts to the same notability criteria Deletion of Lorong Boys WP:BAND||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
14991 9617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrei Semenchuk User:GiantSnowman 18:11, 12 July 2012 (UTC) delete fails , which outweighs Deletion of Andrei Semenchuk WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
14992 20549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeituni Onyango User:Khoikhoi 21:20, 3 November 2008 (UTC) merge with Family of Barack Obama per and Deletion of Zeituni Onyango WP:BLP1E||WP:RECENTISM Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
14993 5899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rechtub klat User:Princess 16:04, 13 April 2007 (UTC) delete per the above - protologism & |kscollob Deletion of Rechtub klat WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
14994 20622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gholam Ruhani User:Joshuaism 04:43, 12 August 2012 (UTC) merge to Afghan detainees at Guantanamo Bay; multiple passing mentions of the subject, but nothing that I would consider ''significant coverage'' per . The Washington Post article linked by Deletion of Gholam Ruhani WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
14995 20914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AUTOECO User:AllyD 21:47, 15 July 2020 (UTC) delete I added a brief review of the autumn 2007 event and a preview of another event in spring 2008 can also be found (https://www.ecomotori.net/saloni/torino-il-4-aprile-prende-il-via-la-seconda-edizione-di-autoeco-rassegna-dellautomotive-ecologico/ link) but unless someone can identify more detailed coverage I don't think there is enough to meet Deletion of AUTOECO :WP:EVENTCRITERIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
14996 4720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natalie Khawam User:Edison 17:07, 21 November 2012 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not a newspaper, and has different standards for who we have articles about. There have been lots of breathless and prurient tabloidish articles about the breaking news story. That is not the stuff a good encyclopedia is made of. Clear case of . If she and her sister in the future become as frequently on the covers of supermarket tabloids as the Kardashians, then we can reconsider Deletion of Natalie Khawam WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
14997 19986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gauri Naidu User:SamHolt6 14:05, 26 April 2018 (UTC) delete fails . Does not inherit notability from films they produced costumes for unless costumes were noted by sources as being significant Deletion of Gauri Naidu WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
14998 7771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of appearances of C96 in popular culture User:Mathmo 10:22, 11 February 2007 (UTC) keep """editor appears to be making a |point aganst ''""""..in popular culture""""'' articles""" Deletion of List of appearances of C96 in popular culture WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
14999 11892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/88 modern constellations in different languages User:Alex 09:04, 3 January 2019 (UTC) delete I agree with Deletion of 88 modern constellations in different languages WP:NOTDICT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
15000 8608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conversion of John Randolph of Roanoke User:Bearian 21:12, 6 April 2009 (UTC) merge into parent article per , and Deletion of Conversion of John Randolph of Roanoke WP:COAT||WP:UNDUE||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
15001 2098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rumours and conspiracy theories about the July 2005 London bombings User:Morton_devonshire 20:37, 7 November 2006 (UTC) delete Fails to cite to reliable sources meeting Wikipedia’s requirements under , and is mostly original research violating . Further, Wikipedia prohibits http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/#Synthesis_of_published_material_serving_to_advance_a_position “Synthesis of published material serving to advance a position”. This article is a cruft-swamp-magnet. Image:Matt_Devonshire2.jpg|20px Deletion of Rumours and conspiracy theories about the July 2005 London bombings WP:RS||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15002 16584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/After Three Seconds User:Nuttah68 09:25, 7 March 2007 (UTC) delete nothing to indicate that this band meet Deletion of After Three Seconds WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15003 8811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Breedlove User:Bgwhite 07:41, 30 December 2011 (UTC) delete Case of and Wikipedia not being a memorial Deletion of Ben Breedlove WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15004 6768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NobleTrading User:Peripitus 09:58, 9 March 2007 (UTC) delete cannot find anything that satisfies Wikipedia:Notability#The_primary_notability_criterion |the notability requirement of non-trivial published works. Fails Deletion of NobleTrading WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15005 17284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crocodillos User:OlYeller21 12:18, 19 February 2009 (UTC) delete While is somewhat vague on where the line is drawn on what a reliable source is, I believe the Travel Channel to be a reliable source. TC is notable and a third party. While it may be considered weak, it has obtained notoriety from a reliable source. In my opinion, it should be kept Deletion of Crocodillos WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15006 8350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of German Ministers-President by longevity User:David 19:01, 4 January 2016 (UTC) delete """Per , there are no sources to suggest that the topic covered by this list is notable. Perhaps some lists in the nature of """"List of x with attribute y"""" are notable. There's no overarching consensus on the matter. See . But even if some are, this one ain't""" Deletion of List of German Ministers-President by longevity WP:NLIST||WP:NOTESAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15007 330 [[Myoreflextherapie]] ( Erl. Gelöscht. ) Benutzer:M.ottenbruch NONE delete Vood^W Löschung von Myoreflextherapie Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
15008 14711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SME Branding User:4meter4 02:10, 1 March 2020 (UTC) delete I couldn't find any quality sources on this company. Fails Deletion of SME Branding WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
15009 10072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simran Bassi User:AllyD 16:15, 21 June 2017 (UTC) delete The article as it stands is a froth of PR backed only by primary sources. My searches, including the tailored Wikiproject India search, are finding nothing better. Fails , Deletion of Simran Bassi :WP:ANYBIO||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15010 8118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sermon of the roar of a camel (3rd nomination) User:Mhhossein 17:20, 4 January 2016 (UTC) keep It's a well known and and notable sermon of Nahj al-Balagha. The |notablity is supported by sources such as https://books.google.com/books?id=clgqAAAAYAAJ&q=Al-Shaqshaqiya+sermon&dq=Al-Shaqshaqiya+sermon&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi7v-GwzJDKAhVDw3IKHetkCncQ6AEIIjAB, http://rch.ac.ir/article/Details?id=8649 (An article of 'Encyclopedia of Islam' in Persian) and https://books.google.com/books?id=L3TiAAAAMAAJ&q=shiqshiqiya+sermon&dq=shiqshiqiya+sermon&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiO5Mb6yZDKAhWq8HIKHYbODckQ6AEIHjAA Deletion of Sermon of the roar of a camel (3rd nomination) WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15011 16971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Failed predictions (2nd nomination) User:Evb 12:11, 31 October 2007 (UTC) delete per #INFO Deletion of Failed predictions (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15012 16709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Masters of the Universe vehicles User:Schizombie 15:38, 1 January 2010 (UTC) delete Fancruft, Toys, and Essays don't deserve mention, but and are relevant. Masters of the Universe is a notable toyline ''in general'' ($1B profit, supposedly per ''Toy Monster: The Big, Bad World of Mattel'' p. 129), and can be found mentioned in books on toys, Mattel, Saturday morning cartoons, media and children's psychology and so on. ''Specific MOTU toys,'' or the ''MOTU vehicle line in general'', I don't believe get such coverage. Items in a list don't have to rise to the same level of notability as the subject of an article, but are still subject to content policies Wikipedia:Lists#Listed items. That the items are redlinked and that some have already been created is also a problem; a Wikipedia:Red link asserts article-level notability and , which I don't believe will be the case Deletion of List of Masters of the Universe vehicles WP:N||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
15013 20944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hannah Cotton User:Xxanthippe 06:24, 3 September 2010 (UTC) keep GS cites give h index of 9. Probably good for a little cited field so may pass rof #1 Deletion of Hannah Cotton WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
15014 21765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finland does not exist user:filelakeshoe 09:30, 3 November 2017 (UTC) delete """I suppose my least favourite Wikipedia guideline applies here. Articles about conspiracy theories need a significant depth of sources, this was just a flash in the pan internet meme. And an article which gives this much weight to the views of the """"conspiracy theory"""" certainly wouldn't be allowed for certain other """"fringe"""" topics""" Deletion of Finland does not exist WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
15015 10975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virginia Lewis (10th Kingdom) User:Themfromspace 20:18, 22 April 2009 (UTC) delete """As nothing has been shown that this character is |notable ''in the real world''. Notability isn't inherited from a notable show to its characters. Each subject in itself must meet by being the subject of in-depth discussion by reliable, third-party sources, and nothing in this article, or in my searches, has shown that it meets . This article also violates as its written from an in-universe perspective. Everything mentioned about her from the real-world has only been a trivial mention. There hasn't been a degree of ''discussion about her'' that warrants an encyclopedia article. Most of this information ''shouldn't be preserved'' as its not encyclopedic. The in-universe plot summary is much too long per and . No offense to Michael Q Schmidt, but no amount of cleanup in the world can magically make a subject fit for an encyclopedia if it doesn't meet the notability guidelines and isn't discussed adequately in the real-world. The other material can be cited and look nice, but its still inappropriate. Verifiability != Notability. A redirect would also be acceptable, but I doubt that many people would search """"Virginia Lewis (10th Kingdom)"""" and Virginia Lewis already redirects to the 10th Kingdom""" Deletion of Virginia Lewis (10th Kingdom) WP:N||WP:N||WP:N||WP:WAF||WP:PLOT||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15016 5796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Budgie (desktop environment) User:Syrenka 23:17, 6 September 2017 (UTC) keep Reliable sources do appear to exist: http://www.zdnet.com/article/hands-on-solus-linux-and-the-budgie-desktop/ ZDNet https://www.infoworld.com/article/3190875/linux/ubuntu-budgie-17-04-review.html ''InfoWorld'' http://www.datamation.com/open-source/best-new-linux-desktop-environments.html ''Datamation'' and possibly http://www.datamation.com/open-source/best-new-linux-desktop-environments.html ''OCS-Mag'' (the author for the last can be identified by name from the http://www.ocsmag.com/editors/ ''OCS-Mag'' Editors Page, though he uses a pseudonym in the article itself). The nominator cannot be blamed for not having done diligence on all of these, as some are so recent that they were published after the nomination! But they still establish notability and provide material to incorporate into the article Deletion of Budgie (desktop environment) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15017 20465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isabelle leon User:CactusWriter 22:50, 2 May 2011 (UTC) delete No credible assertion of significance. Article was correctly speedied three times already (once as Isabelle Leon) per . A child appearing in grade school productions and who may (or may not) have a non-notable role in a unreleased film does not pass Deletion of Isabelle leon WP:A7||WP:ACTOR Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15018 14300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellen Hamilton Latzen User:onel5969 12:43, 2 January 2017 (UTC) delete I would say redirect, but there isn't really a solid single target. Would it be to the vacation film? Fatal Attraction. If I had to pick, it would be the vacation film, as that was her most significant role. But definitely not enough in-depth coverage to pass , and she definitely doesn't pass Deletion of Ellen Hamilton Latzen WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
15019 19349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sindiket Sol-Jah User:Bmusician 08:31, 14 February 2012 (UTC) delete per #A7|CSD A7, no indication of notability, completely unreferenced. (The page creator had removed the speedy tag when I nominated it in the first place, so I have restored it Deletion of Sindiket Sol-Jah WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15020 5067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exercise High Mark User:Petebutt 18:45, 30 December 2014 (UTC) delete Iconcur with Milborne. Excercise are run of the mill, unencyclopaedic, (unless somethinghappens because of one that is notable in it's own right), and non-notable., notnews, etc.etc Deletion of Exercise High Mark WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15021 7385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mehdi Abeid User:Sir 15:39, 8 June 2011 (UTC) delete Having never played in a fully pro league, and due to a lack of significant coverage, he clearly fails both , and Deletion of Mehdi Abeid WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15022 6049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013–14 Veria F.C. season User:Fenix 10:55, 22 April 2014 (UTC) keep Article is a record for a club playing in a top professional league as required by , see no reason why sourced prose cannot be added. Agree with Nfitz that the state of the article is nearly identical to that of many others. Needs improving, but no reason whatsoever given current consensus to consider this as a non-notable subject Deletion of 2013–14 Veria F.C. season WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15023 16598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Region Free Xbox Games User:Kicking222 13:02, 10 August 2006 (UTC) comment I actually do not believe this qualifies as original research under #Primary_and_secondary_sources; the games themselves are the primary source, so I don't think simply popping the game into Xboxes from various regions qualifies as OR Deletion of List of Region Free Xbox Games WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
15024 19953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Climate change denial (4th nomination) User:Tarc 16:23, 3 March 2010 (UTC) comment this nomination was made in bad faith to make a |point about Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Climate change exaggeration|another AfD. Not all criticisms are equally noteworthy, and if some editors were to finally come to understand that, this topic area would be much less tense than it is now Deletion of Climate change denial (4th nomination) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
15025 4033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Love Thy Neighbor: The Tory Diary of Prudence Emerson User:Starblind 03:09, 11 June 2008 (UTC) merge to Dear America. Notable series, but each individual one of the 40 or so volumes doesn't individually pass Deletion of Love Thy Neighbor: The Tory Diary of Prudence Emerson WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
15026 4641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben 10 Ultimate Alien: Fame User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:20, 25 September 2010 (UTC) keep And |work on sourcing through regular editing. The premiere episode of a notable series is often the most notable of all, as it sets the pace for all that follows in that series. And as the series itself is geting coveragehttp://www.google.com/search?q=%22Ben%2010%20Ultimate%20Alien%22&rls=com.microsoft:en-US&oe=utf8&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tbo=u&tbs=nws:1&source=og&sa=N&hl=en&tab=wn and accquiring a fanbase,http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Ben+10+Ultimate+Alien%22&sourceid=ie7&rls=com.microsoft:en-US&ie=utf8&oe=utf8, that notability began with this premiere episode Deletion of Ben 10 Ultimate Alien: Fame WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
15027 19448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blondi User:Peripitus 12:34, 22 April 2007 (UTC) keep I can find http://www.google.com.au/books?q=Blondi+hitler&btnG=Search+Books&as_brr=0 over 150 google books and http://news.google.com.au/archivesearch?hl=en&tab=pn&q=Blondi+hitler&ie=UTF-8 lots google news archive hits which ,from what small snippets I've read, shows that the article will be |attributable to reliable sources. Has attracted enough attention to sustain an encyclopediac article Deletion of Blondi WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
15028 9712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AIR Faizabad (2nd nomination) User:Mythdon 06:49, 15 October 2018 (UTC) merge """to All India Radio. There's no possible content through |reliable sources such that a meaningful article can be written that doesn't just read """"radio station is a radio station that broadcasts in broadcast area with a frequency of this many Mhz"""". There does not need to be hundreds of stubs that only read as such. A table listing All India Radio's translators should also be made as per """ Deletion of AIR Faizabad (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:BROADCAST Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15029 15575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryan Brandenburg NONE NONE keep From the guidelines: (Brandenburg was CEO/Partner of Zygote - over 90% of google hits on zygote appear to be from Brandenburg era Deletion of Bryan Brandenburg WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15030 19703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcel Leonard Petrisor User:GiantSnowman 16:22, 4 October 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Marcel Leonard Petrisor WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15031 15019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vulcan (Star Trek planet) User:Verdatum 21:31, 27 May 2008 (UTC) merge in terms of Vulcan (Star Trek) is not bursting at the seams. The only way I see this content signifigantly growing is through abuses of . If it grows with good stuff, split it off later Deletion of Vulcan (Star Trek planet) WP:SIZE||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:Article size 51
15032 11637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dorinha Wear User:Sandstein 20:48, 9 June 2006 (UTC) delete as |copyvio (so marked), '''close AfD'''. There is no need to list an article on AfD if the text is obviously copy-pasted from some website, as a Google search will reveal at once Deletion of Dorinha Wear WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
15033 4312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fergie second studio album User:Bondegezou 12:14, 10 December 2007 (UTC) comment """As I see it, this project ''already'' exists. That is, there has been a body of activity creating something. Even if the project was abandoned today, it would still warrant some sort of mention (probably in Fergie (singer)). So, that's why I think the """"almost certain to take place"""" bit of is not relevant here. As a body of work, something has already taken place. Thus, looking at all of , and , it seems to me the most important criterion is verifiability. I accept your case elsewhere that there's only one reliable citation given. Unless more turn up, that's insufficient for a standalone article and the material should be merged with Fergie (singer). If more become available, it seems to me that an article is warranted (and allowed under ). So, basically, I agree with your last bit above, if I might quote selectively: """"Information ... can be merged into Fergie (singer) ... Unless ... there is considerable non-trivial coverage""" Deletion of Fergie second studio album WP:CRYSTAL||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:MUSIC||WP:N||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15034 16992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dane Cook: Vicious Circle User:Jujutacular 21:11, 12 November 2009 (UTC) keep per the |significant coverage cited by Joe Chill Deletion of Dane Cook: Vicious Circle WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15035 3234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Ruby Yacht User:DarkGlow 10:09, 11 November 2020 (UTC) delete non-notable story arc. Per , an article for an episode should only be created once articles for the programme and its seasons are created, ''then'' notable episodes Deletion of The Ruby Yacht WP:EPISODE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
15036 18485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guerilla wiki User:Muchness 19:22, 6 December 2007 (UTC) delete per above as an unreferenced |neologism with no |reliable sources to demonstrate notable usage Deletion of Guerilla wiki WP:NEO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
15037 9282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Line of succession to the former Bulgarian throne User:Devokewater 14:38, 22 August 2020 (UTC) delete this is a defuct Royal Family that will never have any prominence in Bulgaria, see Deletion of Line of succession to the former Bulgarian throne WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15038 14681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Mossack User:Sdmarathe 15:54, 8 November 2018 (UTC) delete There was coverage about the subject in 2016 when the article was created, but this is not enough to meet Deletion of Peter Mossack WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15039 108 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Zekeriya Önge Kullanıcı:symphon115symphon115 10:34, 25 Mayıs 2015 (UTC) delete bu varsa şu da olmalıdır diye değil, 'deki kriterlere uygun olup olmadığına bakılarak karar veriliyor. --Kullanıcı mesaj:Kibele|'''kibele Zekeriya Önge'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
15040 18250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Russo (2nd nomination) User:AllyD 06:41, 3 August 2013 (UTC) delete possibly CSD G4 if it resembles the previously deleted article? The article is sourced only to the subject's own site and I am finding nothing better. Fails Deletion of Jonathan Russo (2nd nomination) :WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15041 350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skruff User:Eusebeus 18:02, 16 March 2009 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Skruff WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15042 461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Courtesy flush User:Rossami NONE delete again. You could try a transwiki but I don't think this would meet even their standards for sourcing of usage. The current version is nothing more than a dictionary definition of a neologism (both inappropriate for the encyclopedia). One of the alleged sources cited in this article isn't even about this subject - it's about a |not-particularly notable product Deletion of Courtesy flush WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15043 193 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Murat Yanıklar Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 23:32, 23 Temmuz 2013 (UTC) delete Kimin yazdığı önemli değil de, |kayda değer olarak yaptığı tek bir şey göremedim maddede :) Ansiklopedik olmadığını düşünüyorum Murat Yanıklar'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
15044 222 [[Amoklauf von Ansbach]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Camtronix 06:41, 23. Sep. 2009 (CEST) keep Erst einmal, ich bin fuer . Um die zugrundeliegende Frage der Aufnahme von aktuellen Ereignissen in Wikipedia zu klaeren, bin ich dabei das Meinungsbild /Newsbezogene Artikel zu reaktivieren. Schaut Euch den Entwurf bitte einmal an und passt es ggf. an. Vielen Dank Löschung von Amoklauf von Ansbach Wikipedia:Meinungsbilder Wikipedia:Meinungsbilder 80
15045 1237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Management consulting conference User:Nuujinn 19:23, 2 April 2010 (UTC) delete no references establishing Deletion of Management consulting conference WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15046 16072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Magyarized geographical names User:Daizus 20:36, 16 October 2011 (UTC) delete It's and PUSH. When not , it may be (some of the sources cited above are not , e.g. ''Lumea'' is not a peer-reviewed journal). But mostly , as pointed above such a list prompts some questions: what is Magyarization? can we deal with facts and not with (minority) opinions? should we have lists for all places and languages? (just imagine the lists of Akkadianized, Gothicized, Aztecized, Mongolized, Arabized, etc. geographical names Deletion of List of Magyarized geographical names WP:POV||WP:POVPUSH||WP:OR||WP:FRINGE||WP:RS||WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15047 10265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agricultural output in Italy User:Mike 17:52, 28 March 2013 (UTC) merge to Economy of Italy#Agriculture. An encyclopedic, properly sourced, article could be written on this topic, although Agriculture in Italy would be a preferable title as it would invite a broader treatment of the subject than merely presenting agricultural output statistics. So the subject matter does have some . I do agree with the nom though that little salvageable material is present in the article under review, and what could potentially be salvaged from the lead is already better stated over at Economy of Italy#Agriculture. So it seems to me that a redirect would be best for now, although I have no prejudice against the creation of a new article about Italian agriculture (or someone completely rewriting the existing article Deletion of Agricultural output in Italy WP:POTENTIAL Wikipedia:Potential, not just current state 11
15048 19807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Z Szilagyi User:Bearian 17:44, 6 July 2010 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Bob Z Szilagyi WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
15049 17157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Still Life (1974 film) User:Girolamo 01:31, 24 January 2008 (UTC) keep """Btw, your link is for WikiProject Films.) This film has been directed by Sohrab Shahid-Saless|one of the foremost members of pre-revolution Iranian cinema, it has won significant festival prizes (Silver Bear at Berlin, 1974). The article was created because it is about to be included on the WikiProject's """"Core"""" list, and we wanted all list topics to at least be at Stub level prior to starting editing contests intended to encourage the expansion of Core articles. As a rule, I generally do not AfD films that the most cursory of Google searches shows to be notable, even if the article is miniscule. By all means give it maintenance tags up the wazoo, but requesting deletion of a clearly viable subject is a waste of editing time and reeks of |SNOW. Thank you""" Deletion of Still Life (1974 film) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
15050 6910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Living prime ministers of New Zealand User:Edge3 16:33, 5 September 2021 (UTC) delete per on-encyclopedic cross-categorizations Deletion of Living prime ministers of New Zealand WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15051 5002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prateek Parmar User:Timtrent 14:01, 18 June 2020 (UTC) comment """I don't think you can dismiss the sources as """"only social networks"""" though I agree that it could and should be better sourced. I accepted the draft aware that it is a created article, conscious that it would need to fight its corner in a deletion process. I have decided to stay '''neutral''' in the discussion""" Deletion of Prateek Parmar WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
15052 13912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Ray Bower User:MichaelQSchmidt 00:50, 10 December 2011 (UTC) keep per and Deletion of Michael Ray Bower WP:ANYBIO||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
15053 1018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Otometeki Koi Kakumei Love Revo!! User:Prosfilaes 19:17, 28 September 2008 (UTC) keep DS and PS2 games have enough sources to make them notable. It's just a matter of finding them. MuZemike is wrong as to Wikipedia policy here; for one, Japanese Wikipedia has the same rules we do, so we can't transwiki something there that we're deleting for failure of , and two, non-English sources are perfectly acceptable, as | says Deletion of Otometeki Koi Kakumei Love Revo!! WP:V||WP:V||WP:NONENG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15054 12205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yogacharya Sri Raghavendra Guruji User:Green 18:38, 7 December 2012 (UTC) comment """I'd happily re-write the article from scratch to fix the PROMOTION. For notability, this from http://www.hindu.com/2006/05/03/stories/2006050300810400.htm ''The Hindu'' says Sri Raghavendra Guruji """"secured the prestigious Pathanjali Award"""" presented by the """"former President of Costa Rica"""". Seems like a major (""""prestigious"""") award which might clear . But having difficultly finding any sources to actually write an article with, there's nothing to cite other than 1 mention in ''The Hindu""" Deletion of Yogacharya Sri Raghavendra Guruji WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15055 7622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Varieng User:ImmortalWizard 18:14, 14 February 2019 (UTC) comment As long it meets , it should be kept, regardless of the sources. '''THE NEW Deletion of Varieng WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15056 11606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tam Chun Hei User:Csgir 03:57, 27 June 2019 (UTC) keep as per #1 and #2 point in the badminton section of . The article needs to be rewritten though Deletion of Tam Chun Hei WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15057 17137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beacon Park User:Deskana 20:29, 9 February 2006 (UTC) keep """apply , categorise, general cleanup really. """"Beatufiul"""" sounds POV. But I'd say it's worth the time to cleanup""" Deletion of Beacon Park WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15058 14342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karate needer User:SkierRMH 05:47, 13 December 2006 (UTC) delete as probable hoax/ listing Deletion of Karate needer WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
15059 7766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sydney underground railways User:Kraxler 18:45, 3 September 2015 (UTC) comment """the information is mostly duplicated at Railways in Sydney#Underground sections and Railways in Sydney#Disused tunnels. The only question here is: Should this info remain at Railways in Sydney and the subject of this AfD be merged/redirected to there; or should the info be |splitted to this article, and the two sections at Railways in Sydney have only a short sentence and a """"main article"""" template directing the reader here. Please comment""" Deletion of Sydney underground railways WP:SPINOUT Wikipedia:Article size 51
15060 5935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Rubbo User:Likeminas 23:51, 22 July 2010 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Donald Rubbo WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15061 14805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aisling McLaughlin User:KidAd 08:09, 21 July 2020 (UTC) delete Fails . Appears to be a fairly run-of-the mill (local?) theatre actress Deletion of Aisling McLaughlin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15062 15429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lounge Ghost User:Hetar 21:00, 25 May 2006 (UTC) delete With no IMDb page, and no other |reliable sources this really doesn't belong here Deletion of Lounge Ghost WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15063 9835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alain Andrianov User:Papaursa 03:54, 2 July 2016 (UTC) delete Success at the collegiate judo championships is not competing at the highest level. If we was a national champion in Bulgaria, and there doesn't appear to be independent evidence of this, it was as a junior since he and his family left there when he was 15 or 16. As far as his accomplishments being superior to those of other sports, that's not true. For example, if he was a boxer he wouldn't meet as he never fought in a national championship bout. He arguably does meet , but not strongly, and there's a lack of significant coverage to show he meets Deletion of Alain Andrianov WP:NBOX||WP:MANOTE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15064 15983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emma Dalmayne User:SpicyMilkBoy 12:17, 19 February 2020 (UTC) delete """I was surprised to see that this made it through AfC. The only independent RS here is the ''Guardian'' piece and while it has some coverage of her, it's mainly about the MMS stuff, with little substantive biographical info on Dalmayne. The rest, as OP pointed out, are affiliated sources or blogs/social media posts. She does get quoted in a few news articles https://www.google.com/search?q=%22emma+dalmayne%22&source=lnms&tbm=nws&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjs5OaJy93nAhUsWN8KHf1HDCwQ_AUoA3oECBAQBQ&biw=1680&bih=936 but this does not contribute to notability; per : {{tq|""""Significant coverage"""" addresses the topic directly and in detail, so that no original research is needed to extract the content.}} We can't write a BLP based on a couple instances of """"Emma Dalmayne, an autism rights advocate, said""" Deletion of Emma Dalmayne WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
15065 12774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Taylor (music producer) User:George 21:23, 18 July 2016 (UTC) keep If he meets neither WP:NMUSIC nor GNG, he probably meets #Creative professionals (or ), either criterion #3 or #4. He made contributions to well-known artists Deletion of Mark Taylor (music producer) WP:BIO||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
15066 16801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matis Weinberg User:Yoninah 12:42, 3 November 2020 (UTC) delete per . The author has written some pretty neat books, but as far as I know he doesn't meet GNG Deletion of Matis Weinberg WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15067 19945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Campaign for Free Education User:Jytdog 16:15, 30 July 2018 (UTC) delete this hijacked page is the definition of . It is not a WP article Deletion of Campaign for Free Education WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15068 2304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muslim Guardian User:I 17:43, 8 September 2006 (UTC) delete cruft factory, see also for why this shouldn't be on wikipedia Deletion of Muslim Guardian WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15069 8588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cape Codder (cocktail) User:Blanchardb 23:06, 14 July 2008 (UTC) delete Possible #A3|Speedy A3. --Blanchardb Deletion of Cape Codder (cocktail) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15070 5683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unknown Spectacular Spiderman remake User:Phantomsteve 22:25, 18 November 2009 (UTC) delete If there had been anything verifiable here, I would have suggested that it be merged into The_Spectacular_Spider-Man_(TV_series)#Future, but as it stands, this is unfounded speculation, with shades of Deletion of Unknown Spectacular Spiderman remake WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15071 18171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/April Jace (2nd nomination) User:Chetsford 18:12, 16 February 2018 (UTC) keep Does not meet any of the criteria of as Masters championships seem not to apply. However, on the basis of significant coverage under it seems to be a narrow keep Deletion of April Jace (2nd nomination) WP:NTRACK||WP:NCRIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
15072 18115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled seventh studio album User:Doc 01:40, 13 August 2008 (UTC) delete a case of |crystal |hammer, a Seven Nation Army couldn't hold me back from that decision (I made a funny. Hah). The only instances this article uses for the album's existance is the surprise appearance of Meg White at a show by Jack White|Jack's other band, The Raconteurs and a few statements from Jack. Come back to me when they have a release date and/or a title and/or some |reliable sources Deletion of Untitled seventh studio album WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER||WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15073 5812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmad Jawed User:Nipsonanomhmata 14:03, 23 April 2011 (UTC) delete In its current form I have to agree with WikiDan61. It doesn't meet or any other Wikipedia standard that I can think of Deletion of Ahmad Jawed WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15074 5193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/True20 User:MrFish 02:19, 13 April 2008 (UTC) keep per Deletion of True20 WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
15075 14032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of hardware random number generators User:Ajf773 20:20, 12 August 2018 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Comparison of hardware random number generators WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15076 9508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/StepGreen User:AllyD 19:36, 10 February 2017 (UTC) delete The article content is effectively documentation and how-to guidance for this terminated site/project. Aside from their surviving Wordpress project blog, Google Books shows a few passing mentions, but I am not seeing anything strong enough to indicate notability, whether by or Deletion of StepGreen :WP:ORGDEPTH||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15077 17951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disk Space Fan User:Peridon 19:05, 16 February 2013 (UTC) delete Probably does a good job - I couldn't see anyone dissing it. Does sound rather like a cooling device... However, apart from http://www.pcmag.com/slideshow_viewer/0,3253,l=261510&a=261510&po=56,00.asp which may be reliable but is rather brief and more of a list entry, I could find nothing to fit in ten pages of ghits Deletion of Disk Space Fan WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15078 21857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madloku Ganapathi User:Priyanath 17:51, 30 September 2009 (UTC) delete with no redirect. There is no |''Wikipedia'' notability shown for what appears to be an idol that is important and notable to a particular family Deletion of Madloku Ganapathi WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15079 5637 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manly """"Little Pickles"""" Ortega""" User:SummerPhD 15:16, 9 May 2011 (UTC) comment It's also unfortunate that doesn't protect him from the scandalous claims in that source that he is the father of that bitch Noodle's pups """Deletion of Manly """"Little Pickles"""" Ortega""" WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15080 9348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xtreme world wrestling User:MER 07:50, 27 December 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Xtreme world wrestling WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15081 7904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samuli Torssonen User:Captain 04:44, 7 June 2006 (UTC) keep """Are you kidding me? He produced, starred in, made the special effects for and edited what is most likely the most popular movie to ever come out of Finland. (It has already been downloaded at least 3.5 million times, as reported in Helsingin Sanomat, the largest Finnish newspaper about six months ago -- I wasn't able to track down how many more times it's been downloaded since then.) Yes, it's free to download from the internet, but that's not really the point; I think he ''easily'' passes on the ''""""Multiple features in ... national newspapers""""'' front; the movie and Torssonen himself have gotten a lot of coverage in Finland. He's been on national TV more than once. He was just recently http://www.digitoday.fi/showPage.php?page_id=11&news_id=55949 featured on the popular and influential Finnish IT business web publication digitoday.fi over the deal his production company made with Hewlett-Packard|HP. He gets over 40 000 Google hits (and his movie gets over six million of them). I mean, what exactly are we debating here? This is not some guy in a garage who makes a five-minute clip of crappy lightsaber combat for TheForce.net, he's pretty much responsible for a minor (inter)national phenomenon. Seriously""" Deletion of Samuli Torssonen WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15082 16706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sigma Chi Omega, Multicultural Fraternity, Inc. User:Qrsdogg 19:35, 10 June 2011 (UTC) delete Sorry, but it looks like it doesn't pass our notability requirements for |such organizations Deletion of Sigma Chi Omega, Multicultural Fraternity, Inc. WP:CLUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
15083 5134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DJ Matter User:Esradekan 21:31, 3 June 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of DJ Matter WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15084 13189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Z.E.B.R.A. User:HisSpaceResearch 03:50, 20 December 2007 (UTC) delete as |patent nonsense and |don't feel the trolls Deletion of Z.E.B.R.A. WP:PN||WP:NOFEEDING Wikipedia:Patent nonsense 105
15085 2173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sharepointboost User:Encycloshave 16:05, 13 May 2012 (UTC) delete """Fails . ProQuest, a considerable and reliable news database that includes computer and Microsoft-related publications, returned one hit from M2 PressWire, which gave this disclaimer: """"M2 Communications disclaims all liability for information provided within M2 PressWIRE. Data supplied by named party/parties."""" Hardly a reliable source., so zero at ProQuest. LexisNexis returned nothing on the company. And while I think a list of awards would be fine if it were used to reference a company's receiving that award, SharePoint Village citations are not being used for that purpose. I've also looked at CMS Wire, and their reviews have conflict of interest issues. They publish reviews on products from the same companies that buy advertising at CMS Wire, and these reviews are not comprehensive, critical reviews. See my notes at the Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard#CMS Wire as a reliable source?|reliable sources noticeboard for further details""" Deletion of Sharepointboost WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15086 20699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tibbehah County, Mississippi User:TTTommy111 19:59, 4 June 2015 (UTC) comment I don't have experience with fictional places, but if it meets , then I would advise keep. Otherwise we need to get rid of all fiction places (Neverland). Doesn't have the coverage that Neverland does, but has coverage Deletion of Tibbehah County, Mississippi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15087 10970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephanie Fryar (2nd nomination) NONE NONE comment u|RonSigPi}}, Guess what? I wrote much of what is now at NRODEO, shepherded through the changes, and I am quite familiar with the topic of rodeo. I actually am generally an inclusionist, but I really didn't see significant coverage here when I did my . Here's what we have Deletion of Stephanie Fryar (2nd nomination) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15088 6181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Satyajeet Tambe User:ARUNEEK 14:00, 28 October 2016 (UTC) delete Fails .This is not a PR platform,as said above Deletion of Satyajeet Tambe WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15089 2621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Future Naruto User:NeoChaosX 07:18, 3 January 2007 (UTC) delete This in violation of so many policies it's not even funny. a crystal ball, fan fiction doesn't meet notability guidelines, it's unverifiable (), has no reliable sources () and is entirely original research ( Deletion of Future Naruto WP:NOT||WP:FICTION||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NOR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15090 16803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andriux's fun house user:Hellknowz 14:06, 9 December 2013 (UTC) delete as basically a piece for a non-notable game-centered community. I don't see any -worthy sources. — Deletion of Andriux's fun house WP:PROMO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15091 19343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Johnson: 2017 Tour User:Menaechmi 18:42, 15 September 2017 (UTC) merge to All the Light Above It Too. Currently, the tour doesn't seem to have any notability outside of the album, and nothing that seems to pass , but it potentially could before it ends Deletion of Jack Johnson: 2017 Tour WP:NTOUR Wikipedia:Notability 77
15092 9826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Eyre User:Chris 07:33, 14 September 2009 (UTC) merge and '''Redirect''' to Birmingham Hodge Hill by-election, 2004. If we do count candidates for by-elections as more notable than the usual Parliamentary candidates (and I'm still not sure I'd count as candidate who never stood a chance in that constituency), it's still a Deletion of Stephen Eyre WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15093 2544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manual (musician) User:Sparklism 08:59, 20 May 2019 (UTC) keep Meets through the coverage shown by Michig above Deletion of Manual (musician) WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15094 10130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CITYpeek NONE NONE keep Meets . These sources were found simply by opening the Google News archive search above Deletion of CITYpeek WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15095 12129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rosalina Lydster User:Gobonobo 23:16, 7 December 2013 (UTC) keep """The substantial write-ups in the http://archives.starbulletin.com/2005/12/01/features/story02.html Star-Bulletin and http://www.asianweek.com/2003/08/22/bijoux-bijoux/ Asian Week should be enough to meet . Besides co-designing the Miss Universe crown, she was an official jeweler for the Academy Awards and is something of a jeweler to the stars, counting """"Jessica Alba, Paris and Nicky Hilton, Tori Spelling, Tara Reid, Pamela Anderson and Eva Longoria"""" among her clients""" Deletion of Rosalina Lydster WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15096 10830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judea Declares War on Germany (2nd nomination) User:Simonm223 20:28, 22 September 2009 (UTC) delete as per if this was a notable source of Nazi propaganda perhaps it could be mentioned as an example under Nazi propaganda Deletion of Judea Declares War on Germany (2nd nomination) WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15097 11821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bespoke BBQ Company User:The 17:19, 13 August 2012 (UTC) merge to God-Grilla and rescope - the King of all BBQ Grills seems like it's attracted enough attention to pass , not the company (at least |not yet), and |notability is not inherited. And now I'm craving pulled pork Deletion of Bespoke BBQ Company WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
15098 14139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Environmental Conservation Right User:Bejnar 22:52, 20 June 2017 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON. It is a novel concept introduced into Chilean law. It will take some time to see if it garners significant notice and can fulfill at some later time (ten years Deletion of Environmental Conservation Right WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15099 16220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oskari Lehtonen User:GiantSnowman 19:41, 17 September 2013 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Oskari Lehtonen WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15100 8047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Like the Way (You Move) User:Youngamerican 15:30, 6 August 2009 (UTC) keep per #Songs Deletion of I Like the Way (You Move) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15101 3165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Armed Recordings User:LakesideMiners 13:27, 21 November 2018 (UTC) delete so promotional. This looks like it could be tagged with Deletion of Armed Recordings WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15102 10677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aneta Buena User:Valrith 19:21, 6 July 2007 (UTC) delete No coverage in |reliable sources. Very litle work done in the pornography world and none of it notable. Fails all criteria for notability in either or Deletion of Aneta Buena WP:RS||WP:BIO||WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15103 8111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tushar Kanti Barua User:David 01:08, 3 March 2018 (UTC) delete """Fellowship in the Royal Anthropological Institute (FRAI) would be a pass of #C3 but I can't find him in their directory https://www.therai.org.uk/rai-directory-of-fellows. And I can't find any evidence that the American Anthropological Association has or had Fellow as an elevated membership class in the sense of #C3 — they offer """"fellowships"""" but that means funding for research visits, not an honor for distinguished research. With one well-cited publication (""""Prestige and Culture: A Biosocial Interpretation"""") in which he is in a middle position among 15 co-authors, and everything else much farther down in citation counts, I can't see a pass for #C1 — yes, this subject has very different citation patterns than biomedicine, so we can't take this record as meaning that he isn't notable, but it also isn't evidence that he is. And directorship of the Ethnological Museum, Chittagong sounds significant but the article makes clear that it was only for a short term while the museum was still in its planning stages, long before it opened to the public. So I don't see a basis for keeping the article. But I'd be happy to change my mind if the FRAI or fellowship of the AAA can be confirmed, or if other evidence of notability turns up""" Deletion of Tushar Kanti Barua WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15104 5801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mo Furu User:Necrothesp 14:18, 6 May 2014 (UTC) keep General officers are considered to be notable under Deletion of Mo Furu WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
15105 175 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Mensucat Santral Anadolu Lisesi Kullanıcı:çalıştay..:çalıştay:.. 07:33, 29 Temmuz 2011 (UTC) comment Yukarıda denildiği gibi görünüşte sadece 1 şartı karşıladığı için 'a göre KD'liği tartışmalıdır. Taraflı ve kehanet içeren ifadeleri kaldırdım, bu çok da büyük bir sorun değildi. Gerçekten KD olup olmadığını araştırmak gerek, içimden KD olmadığı geçse de en kısa zamanda aslını araştıracağım...--User:Sabri76|'''Sαвяí¢αи76'''User Talk:Sabri76|'''ileti Mensucat Santral Anadolu Lisesi'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda değerlik (okul) Wikipedia:Notability 77
15106 11660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lithuania–Romania relations User:Martynas 02:09, 16 July 2009 (UTC) keep per http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=Lithuania%E2%80%93Romania+relations&cf=all cursory |WP:AFTER. If even only 10 of the 3,820 news hits dealt with the relationship, it would be enough to show notability per guideline... even if the other 3,810 of the hits did not. However, sources found by Deletion of Lithuania–Romania relations WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15107 3589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Strensham services (2nd nomination) User:Amalthea 11:23, 17 August 2008 (UTC) delete I do not share the opinion of the AfD I quoted that motorway service stations are inherently notable, comparable with train stations. It fails lacking significant coverage. Probably candidate for G4 since it was previously deleted on grounds of notability, too Deletion of Strensham services (2nd nomination) WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15108 546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lewis Stanson User:Prewitt81 03:49, 9 March 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Lewis Stanson WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15109 12706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lo (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 08:37, 1 June 2011 (UTC) keep Article has been improved. through a |little work, the 117 word unsourced http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Lo_%28film%29&action=historysubmit&diff=431540333&oldid=431540028 stub that was nominated has become a 922 word well-sourced http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lo_(film) start class film article. Topic meets . Best Deletion of Lo (film) WP:HEY||WP:NF Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
15110 8358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harold John Ellison User:TimothyBlue 01:54, 28 January 2021 (UTC) merge """to USS Harold J. Ellison (DE-545) per above. Doesn't pass for a stand alone article, but sourced content could improve the target article, overall it will be less fragmented, and give the content more readership. Per , ''""""Editors may use their discretion to merge or group two or more related topics into a single article.""""'' The article as a stand alone will receive minimal readership, but as part of the target will receive much more. There is no benefit to fragmenting the content. No objection to merging properly sourced content. // """ Deletion of Harold John Ellison WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15111 8473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World 44 User:Blackcap 20:22, 28 September 2005 (UTC) keep Might be a joke, but this is pretty interesting. I say we let this one slide. - Edit actually by Special:Contributions/128.36.59.253|128.36.59.253. See Deletion of World 44 WP:SOCK Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
15112 19440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pensole User:Cunard 04:46, 24 October 2016 (UTC) keep Pensole received significant coverage in ''Fast Company (magazine)|Fast Company'', ''The Oregonian'', ''Portland Business Journal'', and ''MarketWatch'' so passes Wikipedia:Notability#General notability guideline. is met by the coverage in ''Fast Company (magazine)|Fast Company'', the major regional newspaper ''The Oregonian'', and ''MarketWatch''. I disagree that a source fails if it contains quotes from the company's employees. It is good journalistic practice to interview the subject of an article Deletion of Pensole WP:AUD||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15113 8227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Location inference NONE NONE keep This is unfortunate. It's not a notability or a copyvio problem, if anything it's . This is a novel, but growing topic. It's a good candidate for WP. The problem is that this article is written by the author of its one cited reference Deletion of Location inference WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
15114 1528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TuneUp Utilities User:FleetCommand 20:24, 28 November 2010 (UTC) keep Article has already established its notability via http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2371494,00.asp PC Magazine (2010), http://www.pcworld.com/article/183313 Gralla, Preston (2009), http://www.laptopmag.com/review/software/tune-up-utilities-2009.aspx Wilson, Jeffrey L (2009), http://majorgeeks.com/review.php?id=18 MarjorGeeks (2004) and http://download.cnet.com/TuneUp-Utilities-2010/3000-18512_4-10206416.html Rosenblatt, Seth (2009). The nominator should definitely read |Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions § Just Not Notable and |Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions § Not Encyclopedic. If there is advertisement in the article, we can re-write that section from a language; but deletion is out of question Deletion of TuneUp Utilities WP:JNN||WP:UNENCYCLOPEDIC||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15115 6264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Garcia Twins User:Bsf 06:24, 13 August 2007 (UTC) delete per and , as there are no reliable sources cited that significantly discuss the subject to evidence notability. --''' Deletion of The Garcia Twins WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
15116 19952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twinnie Lee Moore User:MichaelQSchmidt 15:53, 14 September 2010 (UTC) keep as assertion of notability is there, article is sourced, and more sources are available. And wow... |a new editor is called SPA because he/she has so far worked on one article. Eveyone has to start someplace. The article is |emminently improvable by editors with greater experience in addressing style and additional sourcing than has the newcomer Deletion of Twinnie Lee Moore WP:BITE||WP:POTENTIAL Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
15117 21367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larson Financial User:Snotbot 13:15, 8 March 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 March 8 Deletion of Larson Financial WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15118 16525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Droeloe User:AnUnnamedUser 16:42, 14 August 2019 (UTC) delete """I agree with the previous statements. Also, this article blatantly violates by continuously praising Droeloe by phrases such as """"signature skill,"""" """"emphasis on music,"""" """"weave intricate stories,"""" and """"a new force to be reckoned with""" Deletion of Droeloe WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15119 10036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elijah Manley User:Ddcm8991 22:59, 25 January 2016 (UTC) delete per the nomination and comments of Bearcat. Subject does not meet the criterion of or the notability guidelines as laid out in Deletion of Elijah Manley WP:NPOL||WP:42 Wikipedia:Notability 77
15120 17819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michele weiner davis User:Bearian 18:41, 24 September 2009 (UTC) delete does not meet Deletion of Michele weiner davis WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15121 11907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael abowd User:Wine 21:45, 27 July 2006 (UTC) delete articles without |verifiable |sources Deletion of Michael abowd WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15122 9780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mirror, Mirror (Desperate Housewives) User:KelleyCook 15:18, 17 October 2008 (UTC) delete Per . This ''particular'' episode fails notability. In general almost all of the 100 or so episodes fail this test and should be merged back into their respective Desperate Housewives season # list per Wikipedia guidelines Deletion of Mirror, Mirror (Desperate Housewives) WP:EPISODE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
15123 18823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Demiri User:Joseph2302 18:22, 30 May 2015 (UTC) delete Fails and . The only reason it wasn't speedied is because I wanted to be sure they weren't notable (along with the 10 other articles Deletion of Ali Demiri WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15124 4626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Murphy (baseball fan) User:Edison 20:10, 8 August 2007 (UTC) delete and '''Redirect''' to Barry Bonds, per the above arguments, and per failure to satisfy . 15 minutes of fame does not make a lucky person encyclopedic. Otherwise everyone who won $400,000 in a lottery would be entitled to an article (they are not Deletion of Matt Murphy (baseball fan) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15125 15838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caloocan local elections, 2016 User:RioHondo 00:53, 17 October 2015 (UTC) keep Passes the basic requirements of and Deletion of Caloocan local elections, 2016 WP:NEVENT||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
15126 19409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Brown Derbies User:Whpq 17:43, 22 December 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of The Brown Derbies WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15127 7530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bordeaux International School User:TerriersFan 16:51, 4 September 2011 (UTC) keep experience shows that high schools meet with sufficient research. We need to avoid systemic bias by allowing ample time for local sources to be researched Deletion of Bordeaux International School WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15128 13058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/StarCraft: Enslavers II User:Otto4711 16:48, 9 August 2007 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of StarCraft: Enslavers II WP:PLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15129 10537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Littletown Breadmill User:Keeper76 22:12, 19 December 2007 (UTC) delete as spam. And not notable. And spa. and everything Wikipedia |isn't Deletion of Littletown Breadmill WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15130 10812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacob Johnson (father of Andrew Johnson) User:Icewhiz 18:24, 26 March 2019 (UTC) keep """invalid nomination, as our criteria in is {{tq|""""or """"significant, interesting, or unusual enough to deserve attention or to be recorded""""}} in the lead, and per - {{tq|""""People are presumed notable if they have received significant coverage in multiple published4 secondary sources that are reliable, intellectually independent of each other,5 and independent of the subject.}}. The reason for the subject being recorded in history is irrelevant. It seems reliable sources take note of Presedential relations, for modern examples see - Mary Anne MacLeod Trump or Ann Dunham. As for our subject here, there is in-depth coverage in: https://books.google.co.il/books?id=_n9akv4qj98C&pg=PA166&dq=%22Jacob+Johnson%22+1812&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj-l9DXs6DhAhWu0KYKHS8ODk0Q6AEILzAB#v=onepage&q=%22Jacob%20Johnson%22%201812&f=false here, https://books.google.co.il/books?id=BI22SihvFJwC&pg=PA350&dq=%22Jacob+Johnson%22+1812+canoe&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjcgeyItaDhAhXKD5oKHTUICy0Q6AEIMDAB#v=onepage&q=%22Jacob%20Johnson%22%201812%20canoe&f=false here, https://books.google.co.il/books?id=gejhoRgwLXwC&pg=PA108&dq=%22Jacob+Johnson%22+1812+canoe&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjcgeyItaDhAhXKD5oKHTUICy0Q6AEISzAG#v=onepage&q=%22Jacob%20Johnson%22&f=false here, https://worldhistory.us/american-history/father-of-president-andrew-johnson-saved-two-men-from-drowning.php. I shall note that Jacob Johnson's death (who died when Andrew was 3) was notable as it occurred in heroic circumstances - saving the life of a colonel Thomas Henderson, editor of the ''Raleigh Star'' - who happened to report about this at the time in the ''Raleigh Star""" Deletion of Jacob Johnson (father of Andrew Johnson) WP:BIO||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15131 20204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aliana User:Brewcrewer 18:52, 23 December 2007 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Aliana WP:CRYSTAL||WP:V Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15132 132 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Tayfun Duygulu Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 09:03, 22 Nisan 2013 (UTC) keep """Kendi albümleri var ulusal çapta yayınlanan (güvenilir kaynak olmasa da http://eksisozluk.com/tayfun-duygulu--116076?a=find&keywords=albüm bkz.). Diğer yandan """"Hadi Yine İyisin"""" şarkısıyla da |buranın 3. kriterini de sağlıyor. KD olduğunu düşünüyorum""" Tayfun Duygulu'nun silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
15133 17253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bioentrepreneurship in India User:BarkingNigel 16:30, 3 October 2012 (UTC) delete This article does not meet the |notability requirements as bioentrepreneurship in general is a very under-covered subject; bioentrepreneurship in India is even more obscure. There are also problems with the |style of this article as it reads very much like a school essay and the references are not provided in accordance with Deletion of Bioentrepreneurship in India WP:NOTE||WP:STYLE||WP:CITE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15134 13595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ang Mo Kio Bus Depot (SBS Transit) User:DreamLinker 15:33, 18 March 2018 (UTC) comment I am curious is there is anybody else who is specifically opposed to redirection to List_of_bus_stations_in_Singapore#Depots_and_bus_parks (or any other article). I myself do not support it staying as an independent article but I do want to keep a redirect with the history preserved. Considering that edirects are cheap, I don't see a problem with this Deletion of Ang Mo Kio Bus Depot (SBS Transit) WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
15135 3648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wheelers Primitive Baptist Church User:Headbomb 13:53, 4 June 2020 (UTC) delete simply put, this fails Deletion of Wheelers Primitive Baptist Church WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15136 16198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nina West User:Woodensuperman 13:58, 2 May 2019 (UTC) comment I'm a little concerned by https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_RuPaul%27s_Drag_Race&diff=895172040&oldid=895060645 this edit. I know it's not exactly , but notifying a small group of fans of the show could certainly lead to and skew the discussion Deletion of Nina West WP:CANVASSING||WP:VOTESTACKING Wikipedia:Canvassing 93
15137 13749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madame Blueberry User:Jclemens 01:46, 25 July 2013 (UTC) keep Multiple independent RS'es exist and are documented in this AfD sufficient to show that is met Deletion of Madame Blueberry WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15138 11620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clean Green Cayo User:Whpq 16:05, 27 June 2013 (UTC) delete A laudable initiative but does not meet the |inclusion criteria for Wikipedia as there is no coverage in independent |reliable sources Deletion of Clean Green Cayo WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15139 20105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Santon (Transformers) User:Terraxos 04:19, 10 April 2008 (UTC) delete fails with no evidence of real-world notability, and no coverage from anything that could fairly be described as a |reliable source. This is nonetheless better referenced than 90% of Transformers articles I've seen, but that just means there are a ''lot'' of them out there that ought to be deleted Deletion of Santon (Transformers) WP:FICT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15140 21627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chien Chih-hsiang User:NeujorK 09:12, 12 February 2021 (UTC) keep Many Taiwanese students in my institute know him. zh.wiki shows sufficient sources to pass . en.wiki needs more references Deletion of Chien Chih-hsiang WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15141 16923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deletionpedia User:Explodicle 13:51, 18 September 2008 (UTC) merge to Deletionism and inclusionism in Wikipedia until we have a few more sources for a |split. It's got sources so it's worth mentioning, but not well covered enough for its own article Deletion of Deletionpedia WP:split Wikipedia:Splitting 57
15142 8634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oru Ponnu Venum User:Dai 16:22, 17 February 2015 (UTC) delete fail and Deletion of Oru Ponnu Venum WP:WEB||WP:NFILMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15143 6139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Szews User:Jytdog 01:35, 9 June 2015 (UTC) delete I was PRODing this at the exact same time. Bizarre. Fails Deletion of Charles Szews WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15144 7928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seoul Global Center User:onel5969 13:04, 15 December 2018 (UTC) delete clearly does not meet , as already pointed out, simply an advertisement Deletion of Seoul Global Center WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15145 13251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bread shop User:Vegaswikian 06:49, 10 June 2008 (UTC) delete Dictdef. If it can be expanded then maybe a keep can be justified. Fails , and Deletion of Bread shop WP:RS||WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15146 12834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cameron Casey User:Epbr123 08:27, 9 August 2010 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Cameron Casey WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15147 985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrius Genys User:Jersey92 15:16, 17 June 2015 (UTC) delete Seems to fail and . At best maybe . If the result of this AfD is not delete the article needs to be rewritten Deletion of Andrius Genys WP:BIO||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
15148 13653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michelle Obama's influence on style and fashion User:KimDabelsteinPetersen 16:29, 17 June 2009 (UTC) delete as trivia. This is exactly what an encyclopedia shouldn't document, perhaps it will at some time in the future change the way we see arms on woman - but that is one for the |crystal ball, and not for an encyclopedia. As for Grundle2600's comments: Not everything that gets written about in reliable sources is material for an encyclopedia Deletion of Michelle Obama's influence on style and fashion WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15149 8372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Margita Bangová User:Dl2000 21:45, 19 June 2007 (UTC) keep easily meets due to coverage in multiple secondary sources and demonstrsble name recognition among substantial populations of Canada and beyond. Also recent addition of sources was addressing {{tl|fact}} tag concerns Deletion of Margita Bangová WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15150 3715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Castro (singer) User:Jujutacular 15:41, 28 July 2009 (UTC) keep """from : """"9. Has won or placed in a major music competition"""". I would call American Idol a major music competition, and I would think fourth place warrants inclusion""" Deletion of Jason Castro (singer) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15151 3613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tribal Wars (2nd nomination) User:MuZemike 22:20, 17 September 2008 (UTC) delete and '''|salt again''' — See http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special%3ALog&type=delete&user=&page=Tribal+Wars&year=&month=-1 deletion log and http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special%3ALog&type=protect&user=&page=Tribal+Wars&year=&month=-1 protection log. The poor quality of this article suggests that this has not improved at all from the other umpteen times this article was recreated or unsalted. This is simply blatant recreation of deleted material and meets G4. Also recommend |salting the earth again; make a user present his/her case to admin for recreating the article again instead of disrupting Wikipedia like this Deletion of Tribal Wars (2nd nomination) WP:SALT||WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
15152 6575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Najarian User:GPL93 18:44, 17 January 2020 (UTC) keep passes . Best Deletion of Peter Najarian WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
15153 8245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clint Eastwood in the 1970s user:Andrew 16:05, 23 September 2019 (UTC) keep It's this discussion that is redundant and non-encyclopedic. Clint Eastwood is obviously a huge topic but we don't need six more pages to discuss how best to organise it. See ; ; ; ; ; &c Deletion of Clint Eastwood in the 1970s WP:ATD||WP:BEFORE||WP:LIGHTBULB||WP:NOTPAPER||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
15154 5632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CTA International User:Silver 04:50, 28 March 2010 (UTC) comment I have tagged this article for |rescue Deletion of CTA International WP:ARS Wikipedia:Article Rescue Squadron 98
15155 10381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The History of Submarine Squadron Four, US Navy User:EricSerge 14:36, 25 June 2014 (UTC) merge to Submarine Squadron 4. Wikipedia is an online encyclopedia, not a repository for non-notable details of every military unit. Commanders who are notable (by the WP definition of notability) might be worth mentioning, commanders who filled a billet for a few years probably are not. Remember, none of us |own an article. If it is feared the information may be lost and useful to something other than Wikipedia, userfy the info until it can be transferred elsewhere Deletion of The History of Submarine Squadron Four, US Navy WP:OWN Wikipedia:Ownership of content 86
15156 10790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Allington User:NZ 03:08, 14 June 2018 (UTC) delete Its the guys personal blog created on Wikipedia. Doesn't meet Deletion of Sam Allington WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15157 14287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A. Amaranath User:Masem 14:32, 10 October 2017 (UTC) comment I'm coming at this from discussions on notability guidelines elsewhere, but has there been a proper attempt to find offline sources per ? This article ''does'' meet the presumed notability set by NSPORT, and thus appropriate for a stand-alone. But the nom or those !voting delete should be discussing their lack of ability to show that no other sourcing exists, not just what the current state of sourcing is. I'm inclined to believe there is little (region + only played one game), but there is a process set forth by that hasn't been followed that I can tell Deletion of A. Amaranath WP:BEFORE||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15158 701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I'm Bout Tha Stax (Intro) User:Iowateen 00:58, 18 July 2009 (UTC) keep The article passes criteria 2 of . Has had a charted single or album on any national music chart Deletion of I'm Bout Tha Stax (Intro) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15159 9170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanjay Purohit User:onel5969 02:57, 25 July 2021 (UTC) delete promotional piece which does not meet Deletion of Sanjay Purohit WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15160 11979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/InstaLoad User:SamHolt6 03:09, 24 October 2019 (UTC) delete the topic accrued some speculative coverage in 2010, but a search for sources by date do not reaveal any sources published post 2010, which indicates to me the subject fails (which also covers company products Deletion of InstaLoad WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15161 21845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert A. J. Gagnon User:David 20:26, 25 June 2013 (UTC) comment On second thought, after reviewing the article talk page, I think he may pass for the controversy raised by his views on homosexuality. However, nothing of that controversy, nor the sources raised on the talk page concerning it, are present in the article as nominated. If the article is to remain as it is, a neutered piece that makes him look like an uncontroversial and non-notable religious scholar, it must be deleted, because it omits the basis for his notability and is also problematic from the point of view of Deletion of Robert A. J. Gagnon WP:GNG||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
15162 148 [[Space Marines]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Marinebanker NONE delete """Der Artikel ist gemessen an den Ansprüchen einer Enzyklopädie unbrauchbar, insbesondere die Abschnitte """"Charakteristika"""" und """"Space Marine- Rüstungen"""". Dass die Verwendung von Heinlein ausgeht und andere Autoren beeinflusst hat, ist nicht belegt. Schaut man sich die Literaturliste an, wird evident, dass es sich um Theoruriefindung im Sinne von handelt: Kein einziges Stück Sekundärliteratur, nur Romane/Kurzgeschichten und ein fiktives technisches Handbuch. (und gerne dann neu schrieben, wenn Literatur über die Verwendung des Begriffes im SF ausgewertet wurde""" Löschung von Space Marines Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
15163 15559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flogging a dead horse (2nd nomination) User:Borock 16:11, 31 May 2013 (UTC) comment The real dead horse is Deletion of Flogging a dead horse (2nd nomination) WP:NOTADICTIONARY Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
15164 6134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sherrard Harrington User:2kxericthomas 14:32, 12 November 2019 (UTC) keep I disagree on it failing , , and . The sources are transactional/injury-related due to the outcome of his career in Colorado. He never participated but he was on the roster, according to (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Colorado_Buffaloes_football_team). Regarding the Wikipedia:Verifiability policy, (https://www.denverpost.com/2013/07/19/former-cu-cornerback-and-current-student-moves-from-field-to-boardroom/ here) and (https://www.billboard.com/articles/columns/hip-hop/7439086/justin-combs-angus-t-jones-entertainment-company-tonite) are credible sources in the entertainment space Deletion of Sherrard Harrington WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:PROMO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15165 18177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of shops and business enterprises in Butwal User:Pharaoh 17:16, 21 October 2014 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of shops and business enterprises in Butwal WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15166 19452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arrow-Ray Editora User:Jersey92 00:50, 16 October 2015 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Arrow-Ray Editora WP:CORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15167 13303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Catholic Church in the United States (3rd nomination) User:Ambrosiawater 09:37, 26 March 2021 (UTC) keep Coverage is limited but its enough available to satisfy Deletion of American Catholic Church in the United States (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15168 21727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RingDNA User:Smartse 17:16, 30 March 2014 (UTC) delete doesn't meet Deletion of RingDNA WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15169 6871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Space Girl User:Marasmusine 12:07, 19 September 2010 (UTC) merge use where unnotable, and redirect to publisher or developer. Brief mention at http://uk.psp.ign.com/articles/775/775312p1.html IGN (although from 2007). Note there is a http://uk.psp.ign.com/articles/959/959391p1.html substantial 2009 IGN review of ''No Gravity'', so perhaps '''move''' if another good source can be found Deletion of Space Girl WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15170 11140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rohit Saxena (2nd nomination) User:Ab207 18:29, 22 September 2020 (UTC) delete """No indication that the cited sources, bhadas4media, samachar4media, NewsDog etc are reliable. Hindustan (newspaper)|''Hindustan'', the only reliable source makes a trivial mention of subject. The position """"Senior advisor of Media & Entertainment Skills Council"""" does not remotely satisfy """ Deletion of Rohit Saxena (2nd nomination) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15171 5362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of NBC slogans User:Peripitus 09:51, 28 March 2007 (UTC) delete as clearly #IINFO|indiscriminate information for the sake of information Deletion of List of NBC slogans WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15172 3433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sindhu Joy (2nd nomination) User:scope_creep 12:27, 8 April 2021 (UTC) keep I checked several of the references in Beccaynr's table and they are good. Excellent work Beccaynr. Easily passes Deletion of Sindhu Joy (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
15173 19165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randy White (porn star) User:SynergeticMaggot 16:53, 22 July 2006 (UTC) comment And we should keep every porn bio just because they were in 100 movies? Over night, the claim hes won 2 awards was thrown into the article, and none of the article is meeting . My stance on bio's conforms to |notability and Deletion of Randy White (porn star) WP:V||WP:NN||WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15174 1119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pacific Square User:Exit2DOS2000 21:53, 17 November 2011 (UTC) keep its not ''just'' a local shopping centre. Its a combination of shopping centre/apartment complex with onsite medical assistance for the residence ... ''that'' is unusual and worthy of ote. Exit2DOS Deletion of Pacific Square WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15175 5656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven A. Garan User:David 02:44, 2 May 2010 (UTC) delete The publication record and academic administration record doesn't rise to the level of passing . The walled garden here seems to mirror a real-life walled garden at his CREA and ARC affiliations but not big enough of one to make him notable Deletion of Steven A. Garan WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15176 8535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandra Cisa User:Snottywong 18:08, 2 November 2010 (UTC) delete Fails , poorly sourced BLP Deletion of Sandra Cisa WP:NMODEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15177 10038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Peruvian companies NONE NONE keep """Lists in general can be valuable because redlinks serve as a reminder of articles that need to be created. As for the concern about """"no criteria for inclusion"""", probably serves as an adequate set of criteria""" Deletion of List of Peruvian companies WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15178 9623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cathedral (US band) User:Narssarssuaq 13:26, 22 May 2009 (UTC) keep This band doesn't meet . From those rules it is obvious that Wikipedia as a rule only wants to keep track of mainstream bands playing mainstream music. I think this is riduculous, as it would exclude fringe genres such as progressive rock almost entirely. They've released a record, it's got 15-20 reviews online even if the record was released 30 years ago - so why can't people read facts about them here? (Obviously, they've released another record two years ago Deletion of Cathedral (US band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15179 19680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kierkan Rufo User:Doctorfluffy 19:12, 3 November 2007 (UTC) delete violates #PLOT and unlikely reliable secondary sources can be found to establish notability per Deletion of Kierkan Rufo WP:NOT||WP:FICT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15180 7236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heron Cross Pottery User:Whiteguru 06:42, 13 July 2011 (UTC) delete fails - in particular ''independence of sources''. As above, Google search turns up little of consequence Deletion of Heron Cross Pottery WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15181 14887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bangkok–Chonburi bid for the 2030 Summer Youth Olympics User:Kaffe42 22:16, 3 August 2021 (UTC) keep it appears to meet GNG, though the article could use some cleanup and rewriting. The article might not be relevant anymore, but that doesn't mean it loses notability, see . Many Olympic bids have their own pages, but I don't think the Wikipedia:WikiProject Olympics|Olympics Wikiproject has a specific guideline for bid pages and whether or not the Youth Olympic bids are notable enough for their own pages. We might need to open up a discussion about that. The page is decent enough as it is, despite it needing a cleanup, and I find it hard justifying deleting it at this moment Deletion of Bangkok–Chonburi bid for the 2030 Summer Youth Olympics WP:NOTTEMPORARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15182 330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jake Quickenden User:Fenix 11:17, 15 December 2014 (UTC) keep per GS, fails , but X Factor plus IMACGMOOH appearances probably enough for GNG Deletion of Jake Quickenden WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15183 391 [[Sehnsucht Deutschland]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Codeispoetry/Kritik NONE delete Relevanz nicht ersichtlich. Die Kriterien sind relativ einfach unter #Zeitungen_und_Zeitschriften nachzulesen („Bei allen übrigen Gattungen überregionaler periodischer Druckmedien …“), andere Anhaltspunkte für eine besondere Bedeutung wurden nicht geboten Löschung von Sehnsucht Deutschland Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
15184 10991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How's It Working Out For You User:Mdd4696 21:13, 29 January 2006 (UTC) delete album and band pages. They do not meet . ~ Deletion of How's It Working Out For You WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15185 15165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harringay Online User:Tedder 22:37, 7 May 2009 (UTC) keep I've had conversations with hjuk on this in the past, and I've proposed it for deletion. Certainly there are COI issues and it is only borderline notable, but the award and mentions are (barely) sufficient to satisfy Deletion of Harringay Online WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15186 14334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ZZ Top equipment User:Colonel 09:47, 10 November 2013 (UTC) keep """per , """"''fails to advance an argument for deletion—perhaps only proposing a non-deletion action such as moving or merging''. Also, the nomination's claim that a detailed inventory of their equipment cannot be made seems quite false as the article already points to http://www.guitargeek.com/billy-gibbons-zz-top-guitar-rig-gear-setup-pedalboard-diagram-2003/ a source which does exactly that, from the Dunlop Gel guitar picks to the Celestion speakers. I'm so impressed by the sources which are out there for this that I now plan to start a list of guitars and corresponding articles about the most notable instruments such as Billy Gibbons' ''Pearly Gates""" Deletion of ZZ Top equipment WP:SK Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
15187 5396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Le bal des actrices User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:44, 3 September 2008 (UTC) keep per and . Article needs major expansion, but film is getting international coverage. The notability is there. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=Le+bal+des+actrices&btnG=Google+Search&aq=f&oq= Google search brings up http://www.premiere.fr/film/le-bal-des-actrices__1 premiere.fr, http://movies.uk.msn.com/film.aspx?P_MediaID=36993 MSN (UK) Complete cast list, http://www.unifrance.org/film/28484/le-bal-des-actrices unifrance.org, http://www.screenrush.co.uk/film/fichefilm_gen_cfilm=128873.html Screenrush (UK) Production year 2007, http://us.cinemotions.com/modules/Films/fiche/31297/Le-Bal-des-actrices.html cinemotions.com, http://www.allocine.fr/film/fichefilm_gen_cfilm=128873.html Allcine (FR) Complete cast/production info, http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x3eosz_le-bal-des-actrices Dailymotion film's trailer, http://dvdtoile.com/Film.php?id=48330 dvdtoile.com, and more. Wish I could read French Deletion of Le bal des actrices WP:GNG||WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15188 5560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moglix User:Cunard 15:23, 8 November 2016 (UTC) keep The article needs a lot editing to make it encyclopedic and to conform it more closely with . It's not very good right now. That, however, is not a reason to delete it, at least not where the subject has been garnered |significant coverage in multiple, independent |reliable sources. Please note, the test is not whether the sources currently appear in the article; the test is whether they exist Deletion of Moglix WP:NPOV||WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15189 4147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United States anti-government unrest User:LjL 00:08, 22 February 2016 (UTC) delete """as baseless of various loosely-related topics, some of which are plausibly not anti-government at all in the first place, but rather asking for """"more"""" government""" Deletion of United States anti-government unrest WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
15190 18396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Roby (hacker) User:Gm545 14:35, 2 January 2014 (UTC) delete Minor criminal with a small part in . Plus, I'm pretty sure WP puts less editorial rigor on their blogs section. The others are primary sources so there's a lack of Deletion of Richard Roby (hacker) WP:ONEEVENT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15191 9073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tarik Hamza User:Sam 12:09, 14 January 2018 (UTC) delete No, he is not listed currently on https://www.allsvenskan.se/lagen/ifk-norrkoping/ the rooster, so fails the |notability guideline for association football figures, and I find nothing that makes him pass the |general notability guideline for people. Delete per Deletion of Tarik Hamza WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:BASIC||WP:DEL8 Wikipedia:Notability 77
15192 4403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JB & the gang User:Dissolve 06:36, 8 August 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of JB & the gang WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15193 20527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AEDesign User:Sionk 01:25, 16 March 2012 (UTC) delete Can't find (or see in the article) |anything of any substance about the company. Does not meet the notability requirements of . It looks like this article's number is up Deletion of AEDesign WP:IRS||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15194 3684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward Qiu User:Metal 16:42, 29 November 2013 (UTC) delete can found no evidence that he exists. Without the Chinese name nor can we really know who this article is refering to. article doesn't give anything that's verifiable. Could just as well be a madlib-style test edit. see . no content changes (just style and formatting) since the first edit in 2007. If someone was going to add some kind of details to help us they've had plenty of time already Deletion of Edward Qiu WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15195 16391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David W. Wolkowsky User:Gonzonoir 13:28, 16 April 2009 (UTC) keep """http://news.google.co.uk/archivesearch?um=1&ned=uk&hl=en&q=%22The+pier+house%22+wolkowsky&cf=all simple Google News search establishes that he does indeed run and own the http://news.google.co.uk/archivesearch?um=1&ned=uk&hl=en&q=%22pier+house%22+%22key+west%22&cf=all notable Pier House. Here the NYT calls Wolkowsky Key West's http://www.nytimes.com/1982/01/31/travel/what-s-doing-in-key-west.html?sec=&spon=&pagewanted=all """"richest and busiest entrepreneur"""", a weighty quote from a good |reliable source. I found http://news.google.co.uk/archivesearch?q=%22david+wolkowsky%22&btnG=Search&um=1&ned=uk&hl=en 37 Google News hits, many in prominent news sources and some in national ones. Good enough for me""" Deletion of David W. Wolkowsky WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15196 21018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pranaya Marmaram User:SL93 09:54, 2 April 2017 (UTC) delete I found no significant coverage per Deletion of Pranaya Marmaram WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15197 21472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Lanka Premier League umpires User:Joseph2302 12:18, 12 January 2021 (UTC) delete as , as per Deletion of List of Lanka Premier League umpires WP:LISTCRUFT||WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
15198 16109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lauren Southern User:Opencooper 20:05, 27 August 2016 (UTC) comment """Just a note to both sides that prefacing your vote with """"strong"""" will not change how they are interpreted, nor is this a vote. The closing admin will weigh the arguments based on policy, so please try to adhere arguments to our actual |notability guidelines. Thanks""" Deletion of Lauren Southern WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15199 16240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Down with the Clown User:Danny 20:16, 19 August 2006 (UTC) delete per nom with a whiff of Deletion of Down with the Clown WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
15200 7436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kripparrian User:BDD 20:08, 4 February 2014 (UTC) delete I see appeals and arguments about what a good gamer he is or how many followers he has, but none of those address . We'll have to do better than forum posts to demonstrate that Deletion of Kripparrian WP:MUSTBESOURCES||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15201 6062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hazard High School User:Lifebaka 03:05, 11 January 2008 (UTC) delete Lacks claims to |noability or sources to back up such claims. I'd like to see the article given a little time, though, as it was just created today. A PROD might've been more appropriate Deletion of Hazard High School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15202 18312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Milwaukee Brewers minor league players User:Dirtlawyer1 21:48, 5 November 2014 (UTC) keep """The listed minor league baseball players are those who have been determined to be of some measure of notability under the general notability guidelines per , but WP:BASEBALL and the larger community believe would be better served by inclusion in an """"incubator"""" list article such as this one. '''''The Wikipedia community, WP:BASEBALL, and/or the participants in this AfD may """"conclude that the topic actually should not have a stand-alone article,"""" and that the subject matter may be better covered as part of another article''''' per GNG. This is just such a case, and well supported by the long-standing consensus of WP:BASEBALL, and several years of consistent AfD outcomes: '''KEEP""" Deletion of Milwaukee Brewers minor league players WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15203 11799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Same-sex marriage and procreation (2nd nomination) User:Jayron32 19:28, 24 September 2009 (UTC) merge relevent and non-redundant information with Same-sex marriage and leave a redirect behind. Per , that is likely the best way to handle this one Deletion of Same-sex marriage and procreation (2nd nomination) WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
15204 3309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Pearson (priest) [[User talk:Sirfurboy|talk]]) 12:51, 11 February 2020 (UTC) comment I am leaning towards delete, but this article is less of a stub than many I have seen. Not notable as a priest - which is to say that per , priests are not considered notable for being priests, but could be notable for other reasons. He could be notable for his missionary work in Uganda, but so far I find no evidence for this. Have you done a ? What were your results? So far I have found https://dacb.org/stories/uganda/pearson-charlesw/ this biography but the only source given is Crockford's and that is just a list of all clergy, so does not meet . I will come back again after I have done some more research. -- Sirfurboy File:Emojione1 1F3C4.svg|20px|Emojione1 1F3C4 Deletion of Charles Pearson (priest) WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15205 12604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swoopo User:Vartanza 03:55, 17 February 2009 (UTC) keep NYT gives it push over IMHO Deletion of Swoopo WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
15206 4223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greyson Michael Chance User:Oakshade 04:42, 17 May 2010 (UTC) keep Having over 15 17 million views in itself demonstrates notability. And since this AfD started, he signed with Interscope Records (same label as Lady Gaga). Oh yeah, and he's had very in-depth coverage from reliable sources, the core criteria of . At this point, editors |crystal ball speculation of the future ''non''-notability of this person is willful ignorance Deletion of Greyson Michael Chance WP:NOTABILITY||WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15207 7740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orgrimmar User:Lankiveil 06:03, 6 January 2008 (UTC) delete """as put in one of the previous discussions, """"Per , it does not have any significance outside of World of Warcraft and its players."""" Could not put it better myself""" Deletion of Orgrimmar WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15208 13767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Frankie Tan User:Surachit 23:47, 14 August 2021 (UTC) keep Meets and the case has received significant coverage over a span of years Deletion of Murder of Frankie Tan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15209 16061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Genetic poverty User:Hobbes 18:21, 18 September 2011 (UTC) delete """I think that the CSD should have been accepted on grounds: """"2. Content that, while apparently intended to mean something, is so confused that no reasonable person can be expected to make any sense of it. '''If the meaning cannot be identified, it is impossible to accurately copy-edit the text.'''"""" ''(emphasis added)'' Completely unsourced. Anyway, to the miniscule extent that this phrase seems to exist, it mostly seems to refer to a lack of genetic diversity within a species or ecosystem, which I don't ''think'' is what the author meant, but who can tell""" Deletion of Genetic poverty WP:NONSENSE Wikipedia:Patent nonsense 105
15210 3817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 UCLA throat slashing User:Edison 02:53, 12 March 2011 (UTC) delete Nothing which could be merged to the article about the university, even a single sentence, without giving the incident |undue weight. There was local press coverage and an AP story. Total Google News archive coverage only was during October 8-12 2009. Classic instance where and justify deletion of the stabbing incident. Otherwise every bar fight with a broken beer bottle and every knife attack in the history of every school in the world should be added to the articles about the schools. Wikipedia is not a chronicle of every case of attempted murder Deletion of 2009 UCLA throat slashing WP:UNDUE||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15211 1656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al Hayr User:Lugnuts 16:48, 12 September 2018 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Al Hayr WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15212 9116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aliana User:Orangemike 20:02, 26 December 2007 (UTC) delete """unreleased albums may not yet be notable without substantial coverage ''from reliable sources''.'''"""" |Wikipedia is not on deadline""" Deletion of Aliana :WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:There is no deadline 35
15213 15533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mukhtar Abayomi Sanusi User:Eagleash 13:44, 27 February 2021 (UTC) comment Does not yet satisfy or but is a recent signing for a club considered a member of a |professional league and could thus pass the footy guidelines at almost any moment (). Although there is a danger of 'move-warring' it should at least be returned to draft until such time as he satisfies the requirements. The alternative would be to delete (it should not be kept as it stands) and if returned to main without improvement it should be deleted Deletion of Mukhtar Abayomi Sanusi :WP:NFOOTY||:WP:GNG||:WP:FPL||:WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
15214 13673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unter Null User:Thisistimothy 15:26, 4 April 2011 (UTC) keep meets , reliable sources were found, signed on major label (Alfa Matrix), etc. To the nominator, please read the notability guidelines |before nominating Deletion of Unter Null WP:BAND||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15215 17442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Colbert at the 2006 White House Correspondents' Association Dinner (2nd nomination) User:Jmundo 05:17, 19 March 2009 (UTC) keep """this is a feature article and is well sourced. """"If a subject has met the general notability guideline, there is no need to show continual coverage or interest in the topic"""", """ Deletion of Stephen Colbert at the 2006 White House Correspondents' Association Dinner (2nd nomination) WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15216 4477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of selfie-related injuries and deaths (2nd nomination) User:Smartyllama 18:50, 15 June 2016 (UTC) keep Claims are well-sourced. Whether there are scientific studies is irrelevant. It's still notable due to all the coverage. |Whether or not you like the coverage is irrelevant Deletion of List of selfie-related injuries and deaths (2nd nomination) WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15217 18540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Narayanpur High School User:আফত 17:22, 12 June 2021 (UTC) delete sorry but fails , . No significant coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Narayanpur High School WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15218 18590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Wegmans Store Locations User:Milowent 02:54, 16 October 2012 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of Wegmans Store Locations WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15219 4728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008 NCRHA Division I Collegiate Roller Hockey National Championships User:TonyBallioni 20:42, 9 January 2017 (UTC) delete per DanielRigal. Unreferenced lists of subjects that don't really add anything to the encyclopedia. Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information, let's delete these per Deletion of 2008 NCRHA Division I Collegiate Roller Hockey National Championships WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15220 13488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur Lounsbery User:MrWooHoo 01:59, 25 March 2016 (UTC) keep Passes and and after references were added in, article should be kept Deletion of Arthur Lounsbery WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15221 7550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Newquay 2006 User:MarkBuckles NONE delete This appears to be a |vanity article about someone's experience at Newquay, for which there is already an article. Violates . — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Newquay 2006 WP:VAIN||WP:ENC Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
15222 7306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Expenditure incidence User:Colonel 06:54, 29 April 2011 (UTC) keep The concept has great notability as a book search immediately indicates. The current poor state of the article is not a reason to delete - please see our |editing policy Deletion of Expenditure incidence WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
15223 13966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Igor Burger User:Hazarasp 14:56, 22 June 2017 (UTC) delete Seems to fail and as my searches have yielded no independent sources with extensive coverage; there is https://translate.google.co.nz/translate?hl=en&sl=sk&u=https://domov.sme.sk/c/7742916/sudca-burger-isiel-do-penzie-odvolal-sa-na-dochodkovy-vek.html&prev=search this, but unless he got extensive plastic surgery, it is a different guy Deletion of Igor Burger WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15224 18841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mara MacDonald User:CASSIOPEIA 11:33, 14 January 2018 (UTC) delete No significant achievements or influence. Fails Deletion of Mara MacDonald WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15225 18490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Veda Scott (2nd nomination) User:LM2000 01:25, 24 July 2014 (UTC) comment Starship weeded out unreliable sources and specifically searched for sites which the Pro Wrestling Wikiproject have deemed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:WikiProject_Professional_wrestling/Style_guide#Sources reliable. That said, most are passing mentions. Those which include her in the headline are videos (http://www.wrestleview.com/roh-indy-wrestling-news/49208-video-veda-scott-talks-aiw-absolution-ix-on-6-29http://www.wrestleview.com/roh-indy-wrestling-news/48663-video-veda-scott-talks-tonight-s-5-23-aiw-live-event) or http://slam.canoe.ca/Slam/Wrestling/Microgalleries/ShimmerApr2014/2014/04/14/21601556.html this. She's definitely covered more than she was when the first AfD happened but I'm not sure if she passes the yet Deletion of Veda Scott (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15226 3873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Earl Hughes User:Narutolovehinata5 23:22, 26 March 2010 (UTC) comment It's getting pretty |snowy around here. Mind if someone or I could close this as snowball keep Deletion of Robert Earl Hughes WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
15227 13831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tattoo TV shows user:Andrew 06:27, 22 August 2020 (UTC) keep The topic meets – for example, see the ''https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=s0122BsqrZwC&pg=PA271 Encyclopedia of Body Adornment''. Q.E.D Deletion of List of tattoo TV shows WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
15228 346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Markoff User:AniMate 01:38, 25 April 2009 (UTC) delete per . Every high profile murder isn't encyclopedic, and massive coverage only means news agencies want to sell a salacious story for more viewers or readers. Sadly, media manipulation seems to be lost on many Wikipedia editors Deletion of Philip Markoff WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15229 5185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle of Az Zawiyah User:Abductive 18:46, 26 February 2011 (UTC) comment Are there sources on this that pass and ? Because even if the event is notable, if none of the information can be verified, the page must be deleted Deletion of Battle of Az Zawiyah WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15230 753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joanne Jonas User:Less 18:00, 19 December 2020 (UTC) delete I have found no significant coverage, no independent secondary sources. Fails and Deletion of Joanne Jonas WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
15231 12490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sangeeta N Kale [[User talk:24.151.10.165|talk]]) 23:25, 9 March 2015 (UTC) keep """per #6 and . As Vice-Chancellor (Note: the full Chancellor position is honorary) of the Defence Institute of Advanced Technology http://www.punemirror.in/pune/civic/Low-priced-sensor-to-find-fuel-adulteration/articleshow/45340298.cms, http://www.punemirror.in/pune/civic/Sun-chips-in-more-power/articleshow/45196064.cms. """"Criterion 6 may be satisfied, for example, if the person has held the post of President or Chancellor (or Vice-Chancellor in countries where this is the top academic post) of a significant accredited college or university, director of a highly regarded notable academic independent research institute or center (which is not a part of a university)...."""" Other coverage: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/Defence-Institute-of-Advanced-Technology-scientists-to-lead-national-research-on-nanotech-products/articleshow/12513326.cms and http://archive.indianexpress.com/news/nanotech--centre-at-diat-by-yearend/827431/. Special:Contributions/24.151.10.165|24.151.10.165""" Deletion of Sangeeta N Kale WP:NACADEMIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15232 18635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TIP31 (2nd nomination) User:Kingofaces43 16:06, 28 December 2015 (UTC) delete In addition to being too technical, applies here as well. If there is something noteworthy about such a specific type of transistor, someone should be able to write a decent general overview in Bipolar junction transistor and split the content out. This doesn't seem to pass that test Deletion of TIP31 (2nd nomination) WP:NOTCATALOGUE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15233 10363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Da Realist User:Amalthea 13:03, 3 September 2008 (UTC) merge to Plies (rapper), album fails , no mergeworthy, verifiable content that isn't already in target article.The name of the album is backed by the reliable, primary source given above. Primary sources can very well be used to extract facts, and it is in that respect the most reliable source of ''all Deletion of Da Realist WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15234 17019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sonia Ben Ammar User:RebeccaGreen 12:16, 11 January 2019 (UTC) keep I don't get this. There are four references which provide significant coverage in reliable, independent sources. No matter what the state of the article, she certainly meets , and anybody could use those sources and add more information to the article, without even searching for more Deletion of Sonia Ben Ammar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15235 1616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Subconscious User:Bearian 23:56, 15 March 2010 (UTC) keep """whether it exists or not doesn't matter at enWP; only that it can be |verified. The article states, """"In everyday speech and popular writing, however, the term is very commonly encountered as a layman's replacement for the unconscious mind. The ... term is prominent in the New Age and self-help literature, in which investigating or controlling its supposed knowledge or power is seen as advantageous."""" If you ask 10 Wikipedians, probably 7 would agree it's a notable term. It's defined by http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&source=hp&q=subconscious+definition&aq=4sx&aqi=g-s2g-sx1g-s1g-sx6&aql=&oq=subconsious hundreds of dictionaries. There are http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&source=hp&q=subconscious&aql=&oq=subconsious&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=ws over 100,000 Ghits at Google scholar. It's a word used in the news http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&source=hp&q=subconscious&aql=&oq=subconsious&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=sn hundreds of times each week. This is an easy rescue""" Deletion of Subconscious WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15236 9924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/École Mondiale World School User:Haeleth 20:08, 6 December 2005 (UTC) keep the rewritten stub meets the proposal. &mdash Deletion of École Mondiale World School WP:SCH Wikipedia:Notability 77
15237 11021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Grehan NONE NONE delete Virtually any author and any book will get a few ghits, as these do. The book, though, does not seem to be notable per , and I don't think its publication gives much notability to its authors. (This, of course, could change pretty easily, and the book might become popular. Then an article would be reasonable and appropriate Deletion of Larry Grehan WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
15238 17162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rocky De La Fuente User:akrewson 03:26, 30 December 2015 (UTC) keep per with multiple reliable sources covering the topic. New coverage from Ballot Access blog: (http://ballot-access.org/2015/12/29/rocky-de-la-fuente-submits-18000-signatures-to-be-on-north-carolina-democratic-presidential-primary-ballot Deletion of Rocky De La Fuente WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15239 7606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Gore Effect User:TreasuryTag 09:45, 10 June 2010 (UTC) keep this is an exceptionally interesting article on a topic I had previously never heard of. The existence of the concept (not its truth, obviously, but the notability of the satire itself) appears to be well-covered by numerous reliable sources including the ''Washington Post'', the ''New York Times'', the ''Daily News'', ''Politico'', ''The Times'' and ''The Washington Examiner'' to name but a few. Sure, it's sarcastic – but we have an article on pastafarianism. Sure, it's perhaps demaning to Al Gore – but |that's no reason to |omit it. Well-cited articles on notable topics should not be deleted Deletion of The Gore Effect WP:NPOV||WP:CENSOR Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15240 1562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Billboard Top Contemporary Christian Albums number ones of the 1990s User:Pburka 22:27, 10 August 2020 (UTC) keep """Per , """"a chart is normally considered suitable for inclusion if it meets both of the following characteristics: 1) It is published by a recognized reliable source. This includes...Billboard magazine... 2) It covers sales or broadcast outlets from multiple sources."""" See also """ Deletion of List of Billboard Top Contemporary Christian Albums number ones of the 1990s WP:CHARTS||WP:BILLBOARDCHARTS Wikipedia:Record charts 13
15241 7296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grooming a dog User:Amarrg 08:48, 3 December 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Grooming a dog WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15242 1488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orwood, California User:Eggishorn 22:02, 13 August 2020 (UTC) delete Yet another erroneous GNIS designation. Post offices are not indicators of passing because they are not legal recognition and in the context of a RR station a post office may be tied only to postal rail functions and not to a populated place Deletion of Orwood, California WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15243 7231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Schallmo User:Snowycats 04:24, 15 July 2018 (UTC) delete Fails . issues Deletion of Daniel Schallmo WP:GNG||WP:RESUME Wikipedia:Notability 77
15244 6479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brendan Burke User:Hekerui 21:51, 8 February 2010 (UTC) keep exceeds per prior appearances in print and on tv and had what amounts to significant coverage, and also influence with regard to gay issues in sports Deletion of Brendan Burke WP:ONEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15245 19622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spirit animals User:AdventurousSquirrel 10:02, 27 April 2014 (UTC) delete I agree, the few mentions of the launch I was able to find, lacking substantial coverage on the books themselves, seems not to indicate a sufficient degree of notability - by encyclopedic standards (see ) - to warrant a standalone article at this point. As mentioned above, it may be Deletion of Spirit animals WP:N||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
15246 2459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennie Wood User:Lear 04:18, 14 March 2011 (UTC) delete No indication on Google or in the article that the subject meets the |general, |biographical or |author notability guidelines. Deletion of Jennie Wood WP:GNG||WP:BIO||WP:author Wikipedia:Notability 77
15247 19765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CINB-FM User:Bearcat 19:24, 1 October 2014 (UTC) keep """For the reasons I explained above, the station ''does'' pass . Sourcing improvements are certainly still needed, so the article should be tagged for {{tl|refimprove}}, but the core criteria — duly licensed station that broadcasts over the air (satisfying """"established broadcast history"""") and actually produces at least some of its own distinct programming (satisfying """"unique programming"""") — ''have'' been properly met here""" Deletion of CINB-FM WP:BROADCAST Wikipedia:Notability 77
15248 11066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucky Di Unlucky Story User:Anupam 04:06, 19 February 2013 (UTC) keep A simple search in Google demonstrates that the film is indeed otable|notable. Moreover, there are several sources that would make a great addition to this article. I hope this helps. With regards Deletion of Lucky Di Unlucky Story WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15249 5737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Ars Supernova User:Gongshow 18:35, 22 November 2009 (UTC) delete per nom's explanation, which are my findings as well. Sources seem limited to a local newspaper, an write-up in a university paper, and a few blogs. Does not appear to meet the criteria of Deletion of The Ars Supernova WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15250 3854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Olaolu Akorede Olabode (2nd nomination) User:PohranicniStraze 04:27, 15 July 2018 (UTC) delete Being nominated for an award is not enough to meet . Lack of |reliable source coverage to prove notability Deletion of Olaolu Akorede Olabode (2nd nomination) WP:NFILMMAKER||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15251 7979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matias Viegener User:Curiocurio 00:56, 16 December 2018 (UTC) delete No significant coverage - book blurbs & reviews, primary sources, and glancing mentions in relation to Kathy Acker. Fails Deletion of Matias Viegener WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15252 15474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Degree programs at the Pamantasan ng Lungsod ng Maynila User:Elcosamagna 20:11, 6 March 2009 (UTC) delete """Wikipedia is #DIRECTORY|not a directory. No independent, reliable sources about this topic, fails . Suggest that the rest of the """"Degree Progams at ____"""" articles found by""" Deletion of Degree programs at the Pamantasan ng Lungsod ng Maynila WP:NOT||WP:V Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15253 19234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Save Our State User:Mysidia NONE keep It appears there are editing disputes over the content of the article, bias, especially in certain versions, and what should be included, but I believe the content is salvageable. Wholesale deletion of the article about a notable subject is not the best way to resolve issues and content disputes Deletion of Save Our State WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15254 9769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seth Lobato User:Alex 06:41, 4 October 2019 (UTC) delete No significant coverage for a college player, does not meet or Deletion of Seth Lobato WP:NCOLLATH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15255 19207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of international goals scored by Harry Kane User:Alex 13:47, 10 June 2021 (UTC) delete Not a useful topic, i agree with the nom. that this article is Deletion of List of international goals scored by Harry Kane WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15256 16729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roadkill Bill Jabanoski User:discospinster 13:34, 19 February 2007 (UTC) delete """No independent sources to attest to the artist's |notability, or to the fact that he has """"had a major influence on hundreds of thousands of people"""". Do these cult fans not have Internet access""" Deletion of Roadkill Bill Jabanoski WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15257 3665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spy6teen User:Sharksaredangerous 19:12, 25 April 2011 (UTC) delete """Does not meet the standard of """"significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject""" Deletion of Spy6teen WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15258 17462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 Pakistan heat wave User:KN2731 11:13, 7 May 2017 (UTC) merge into List of extreme weather records in Pakistan. Little to no coverage of the heatwave's impact by major news websites exist, i.e. isn't met. Right now the content only includes temperature records, and List of extreme weather records in Pakistan|there's already an article for that. ~ Deletion of 2017 Pakistan heat wave WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15259 1383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ifan Ifeanyi Michael User:Kudpung 06:48, 29 December 2019 (UTC) delete Fails . Probably a vanity page Deletion of Ifan Ifeanyi Michael WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15260 21072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corey schafer [[User talk:Ravenswing|''' '' Ravenswing '' ''']] 19:40, 21 May 2013 (UTC) delete """I just went through ALL of the Google hits for """"Corey Schaefer"""" + """"squash,"""" and found nothing but a sentence here and there of her high school and college sports doings (explicitly debarred as counting towards notability by ) ... not even the usual social media sites. Oddly enough, I couldn't find a thing pertaining to her alleged professional squash career. Since squash is not covered under the various notability guidelines in NSPORTS, she has to rely on the GNG ... and fails that going away""" Deletion of Corey schafer WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15261 12785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Never (word) User:MuZemike 04:31, 2 December 2008 (UTC) delete """pure |dictionary definition. If """"never"""" is not already in Wiktionary, then I would start wondering what in the world is going on over there""" Deletion of Never (word) WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
15262 17639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Donkeys (band) User:Sparklism 10:44, 9 May 2013 (UTC) keep Plenty of coverage from reliable sources found through Google, some of which is already in the article. Meets Deletion of The Donkeys (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15263 17563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/President v congress User:Just 15:35, 5 December 2005 (UTC) delete per , and chool essays belong on your Geocities page, not Wikipedia Deletion of President v congress WP:NOR||WP:NPOV||WP:S Wikipedia:No original research 65
15264 3180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Martin Petcare User:Shoessss 14:58, 5 January 2009 (UTC) keep A company that holds in excess of 25% of the pet care industry in the UK, as shown here, http://www.alacrastore.com/storecontent/markintel/DATAMONITOR-50128256, is pretty otable|notable to me. Likewise, did you do a quick Google News search? I was able to find multiple sources as shown here, http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Bob+Martin%22+Pet+Care&sa=N&start=20. Overall, I think it is a keeper Deletion of Bob Martin Petcare WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15265 9094 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alecs Nastoiu User:Piotrus 09:04, 10 April 2017 (UTC) delete List of links, reads like a CV, nothing suggests the individual meets Deletion of Alecs Nastoiu WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15266 14207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Spanos User:GiantSnowman 12:31, 29 July 2013 (UTC) keep meets ; needs improving to meet , not deleting Deletion of John Spanos WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15267 6531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Hyatt User:David 07:25, 13 January 2021 (UTC) keep """The associate professor rank is totally irrelevant, but his citation record https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=Rg4jLF0AAAAJ is probably not enough for . However, as an author of both Crafty and Cray Blitz and as a very well known chess programmer, I believe he passes #1 (""""regarded as an important figure""""), #2 (""""known for originating a significant new concept"""", in this case rotated bitboards, a major feature of both programs), #3 (""""created or played a major role in co-creating a significant or well-known work or collective body of work"""", namely Crafty and Cray Blitz; note that Cray Blitz is the subject of multiple publications by people who were independent from its creation including """"Cray Blitz and Hitech: Parallel Search and Parallel Evaluation"""", Newborn, 1997, and """"Cray Blitz-A Computer Chess Playing Program"""", Marsland, 1985, as well as many news pieces about its individual performances such as https://www.nytimes.com/1986/10/12/arts/chess-computers-tie-for-the-championship.html in the NYT; Crafty is not as heavily covered by independent sources but there exists at least """"Performance Characterization of Parallel Game-tree Search Application Crafty"""" by Ying et al, and """"Tuning evaluation functions by maximizing concordance"""", Gomboc, 2005), and plausibly #4 (""""been a substantial part of a significant exhibition"""", namely the participation of these programs in major computer chess competitions). If he had only one notable program a merge might have made sense per but not when there are two. This seems part and parcel with the recent Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Computer Games Association (successful) and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ICGA Journal (unsuccessful) as an effort to erase from Wikipedia the history of computer chess, a significant subject with a significant history""" Deletion of Robert Hyatt WP:PROF||WP:CREATIVE||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
15268 21797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Badanamu: Learn and Play User:Aoba47 19:08, 21 October 2016 (UTC) delete per K.e.coffman's comments. The keep vote does not provide adequate enough reasons for the article to stay, and I agree with WikiDan61 in that it falls more into than anything Deletion of Badanamu: Learn and Play WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15269 20397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Post Oak Mall User:Elonka 06:05, 9 October 2007 (UTC) delete No indication that it meets Deletion of Post Oak Mall WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15270 10424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dubbo College User:ClemRutter 10:03, 23 May 2021 (UTC) keep As a technicality, this is a state funded college- only applies to private schools. So applying , we have to prove there will be independent references- not find or evaluate them. In one minute of looking at one of the schools (there are multiple)Portal pages I was directed here. https://www.dailyliberal.com.au/story/5761007/aboriginal-student-results-show-strong-trend-towards-closing-the-gap-at-dubbo-college/ Closing the gap. Another ref is about community scolarships. I am not an expert on the education of Native peoples- but do see this as an equalities issue too. Another few minutes and other references will be there. Can we please we withdraw this AfD Deletion of Dubbo College WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15271 19233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward vs Lazlo User:Sephiroth 07:18, 8 September 2007 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Edward vs Lazlo WP:CRYSTAL||WP:NOR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15272 8561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jigme Lodro Rinpoche User:GeoffCapp 04:30, 23 July 2013 (UTC) comment from Nom: News search reveals only this article; 5 results in Books, three of which are wiki compilations and the other two catalogs of names. Article is barely more than a of http://www.dharmakirti.org/about_teachers.htm an uncited webpage, and has had Template:Primary sources since April 2009 with no secondaries available or forthcoming. Only 4 inbound wikilinks from Article space, two of which are dabs and the other two uncited. There are notable Lamas, and this isn't one of them. ETA: creator and all substantive editors of the article now have been notified of this AfD Deletion of Jigme Lodro Rinpoche WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
15273 7384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hutstep User:Unionhawk 12:33, 24 August 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. contested |PROD, I suppose Deletion of Hutstep WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
15274 4242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jagvir Singh User:Joseph2302 14:40, 20 June 2021 (UTC) merge until he makes a first team appearance, as a valid Deletion of Jagvir Singh WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
15275 4772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Collins User:Clarityfiend 01:41, 9 June 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. No ''independent'' references that I can see. is a bad argument to make. The only possibly notable Matt Collins I could dig up is the Yugoslavian in the Rockabilly Hall of Famehttp://www.rockabillyhall.com/MasterIndex.html Deletion of Matt Collins WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15276 171 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Bayanlar Baylar Kullanıcı:tacci2023tacci2023 04:27, 23 Ocak 2012 (UTC) delete KD olması için maddelerinden en az birini karşılasa yeterli oluyor ama 2. madde hariç hiç birine kesinlikle uymuyor madde. 2. madde için de yeterli kaynağa ben de erişemedim forum ve çevrimiçi video izleme siteleri var sadece. Ve yine ulusal bir kanalda yayınlanmış olması KD'liği sağlar mı bilemiyorum doğrusu, kriterlerde öyle bir madde yok. -- User:Sayz|sayz'ınUser talk:Sayz| usu ✍ Bayanlar Baylar'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
15277 5274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scottevest User:Snotbot 05:16, 24 December 2011 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2011 December 24 Deletion of Scottevest WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15278 7294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tetris & Dr. Mario User:Lrrr 04:24, 11 July 2007 (UTC) keep There were changes to the actual games, enough to justify a seperate articles. I don't want to play the card, but we have plenty of articles on other compilation games Deletion of Tetris & Dr. Mario WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15279 3996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Team Sting User:carterdriggs 18:19, 15 October 2007 (UTC) delete per nom and due to it not even being close to meeting Deletion of Team Sting WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15280 20599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TransferMate User:Guliolopez 13:35, 22 December 2016 (UTC) keep as and seems to be demonstrated and verifiable (Google news search returns a reasonable amount of non-trivial coverage). That said, as noted by the nominator and other editors, at the time of nom this article was appallingly promotional in tone - something that needs addressing and monitoring (if kept Deletion of TransferMate WP:CORP||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
15281 3645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mannoroth User:Doctorfluffy 05:22, 3 November 2007 (UTC) delete Fails , unlikely reliable secondary sources can be found to establish notability, and violates #PLOT Deletion of Mannoroth WP:FICT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15282 20983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/E la Carte User:HighKing 16:07, 6 June 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and GNG. References are press releases and/or advertorials and fail . No evidence of notability Deletion of E la Carte WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15283 8336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sigma alpha sigma User:Gtstricky 15:06, 12 December 2007 (UTC) delete does not meet |notability guidelines. Should be included (merged?) List of social fraternities and sororities|here. They have not had independent coverage that would meet the guidelines. They are mentioned in articles simply as a descriptor or on the school's website as an approved organization Deletion of Sigma alpha sigma WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15284 15999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rappelz User:Teancum 18:08, 6 December 2010 (UTC) delete I was hopeful when running a http://www.google.com/cse?cx=009782238053898643791:8naerdbd-oy&q=Rappelz reliable sources search, but all the results were trailers, press releases (|self-published), or forums Deletion of Rappelz WP:SPS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15285 19647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sri Lanka at the 2009 Asian Indoor Games User:Malcolmxl5 11:19, 3 June 2016 (UTC) merge to the main games article. This could have been done |boldly without bringing this and others here Deletion of Sri Lanka at the 2009 Asian Indoor Games WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
15286 19508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Postscripts User:Philosopher 23:02, 18 November 2014 (UTC) keep Award-winning publication. Passes . – Deletion of Postscripts WP:NBOOKS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15287 9148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lil Eazy-E User:thedeadlypython 17:24, 26 August 2007 (UTC) delete Based on what #CRYSTAL|What Wikipedia is not, and the fact that ''at this point in time'' he does not fall into the guidelines for artists to deserve a page, I agree with those that say this deserves deletion. When his album comes out and if it pushes him into the guidelines, then he can have an article created about him that will then have more content Deletion of Lil Eazy-E WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15288 14509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank and Mary's Restaurant and Lounge User:Cunard 05:16, 27 August 2009 (UTC) keep """I have found sufficient sources that allow this restaurant to pass . http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=-gwSAAAAIBAJ&sjid=S-oDAAAAIBAJ&pg=4757,2337143&dq=frank-and-mary%27s+pittsboro Here is a restaurant review written by ''Chicago Sun-Times'' from Jane and Michael Stern. After perusing through the contents of this article, I have determined that it is a review, not a republishing of a press release. The article says, """"Waitresses work fast and are friendly ..."""" Although this is not a critical review, it proves that the reviewers tried out the restaurant.The second source I discovered was http://www2.indystar.com/articles/8/066578-1028-P.html this article by Susan Guyett of ''The Indianapolis Star''. This is a fully-available article, and a cursory look at it proves that it is a |reliable review.Third, http://sports.espn.go.com/rpm/columns/story?seriesId=2&columnist=newton_david&id=2952493 this article by David Newton of ESPN discusses Frank and Mary's in relation to Jeff Gordon, who always ate there """"because there's really no other place to eat.""""Finally, I was able to obtain http://books.google.com/books?id=ha0f9HfmaoYC&pg=PA15&dq=%22Frank+and+Mary%27s%22&ei=hROWSoDDI5TkMLaGjdUH#v=onepage&q=%22Frank%20and%20Mary%27s%22&f=false this Google Books entry, which provides a 3-page review for this restaurant. Although this is a travel guide, notability is clearly established because the other restaurants in this book receive on average a half-page review.These four sources are all in-depth reliable sources about the subject. If this were a BLP or a novel, notability would be fully established. Why would it be any different for a restaurant? It shouldn't be because this restaurant easily passes """ Deletion of Frank and Mary's Restaurant and Lounge WP:N||WP:RS||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15289 6076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kolabtree User:SamHolt6 00:15, 26 March 2020 (UTC) delete article fails to meet due to a lack of independent, in-depth coverage surrounding it. As seen with Highking and Chaos' analysis of the article's sources, many - on close inspection - do not posses the needed depth or intellectually independence to meet NCORP; as always, it is the quality of coverage, not the number of sources, that determine's a topic's encyclopedic notability on Wikipedia Deletion of Kolabtree WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15290 14147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Autism Research Institute User:Canyouhearmenow 12:07, 25 July 2014 (UTC) keep I agree that it is , however, i also think as many others do that this does in fact have plenty of reliable sources to support its remaining here on wikipedia. I do not see where it fails rules Deletion of Autism Research Institute WP:FRINGE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
15291 853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Persepolis 3–2 Esteghlal (2012) User:Hhhhhkohhhhh 14:05, 29 January 2018 (UTC) delete No need. An non-notable article. However, {{ping|Govvy}} is only for players Deletion of Persepolis 3–2 Esteghlal (2012) WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15292 11661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jocelyne Couture-Nowak (third nomination) User:Dhartung 23:17, 29 May 2007 (UTC) delete as material already exists in other articles. |Wikipedia is not a memorial and there is nothing indicating real notability for this person other than coverage of her murder Deletion of Jocelyne Couture-Nowak (third nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15293 12210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hand Hug User:Bearian 01:58, 17 December 2009 (UTC) delete per . It was invented by some guy in 2003, and has gotten no news coverage since Deletion of Hand Hug WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
15294 15878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IBLS User:Carlosguitar 13:56, 8 June 2007 (UTC) delete WP:N|non-notable distribution that seems dead, also fails and Deletion of IBLS WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15295 19503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhd Jafri Muhd Firdaus Chew User:Spiderone 16:31, 18 December 2015 (UTC) delete can be recreated if and when he passes Deletion of Muhd Jafri Muhd Firdaus Chew WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15296 13105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gustavo Bermúdez User:Tnxman307 14:19, 26 May 2008 (UTC) delete I can't see how this actor meets . If there were some sources listed or evidence that he has been in several TV shows, that would help Deletion of Gustavo Bermúdez WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15297 19303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Char Seawell User:Epinoia 03:04, 13 September 2019 (UTC) delete """does not meet - no significant coverage in multiple reliable secondary sources, no charting singles or albums released by major labels, etc. - the coverage on her band, Windfall, in the HeraldNet from Everett WA is one writeup, but does not satisfy which says """"attention solely from local media...is not an indication of notability""" Deletion of Char Seawell WP:MUSICBIO||WP:AUD Wikipedia:Notability 77
15298 3997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Move Closer to Your World User:SummerPhD 18:44, 27 May 2011 (UTC) comment """The """"obscure"""" book is from a professor at the Cronkite School at ASU. IMO, it is certainly a |reliable source""" Deletion of Move Closer to Your World WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15299 5907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michelle Belanger (2nd nomination) :Usernames_for_administrator_attention&diff=287047446&oldid=287045132] [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&page=User%3AKheperu]. Now on this new trend of continuous attempts at bringing back this article in consecutive AfD/DRV requests, I want to mention that not all of the issues with NPOV were addressed, and that the articles' language does not fully comply with a scholarly accepted encyclopedic style. Stating that an individual is a ''psychic vampire'' is not appropriate in an encyclopedia, since it is subject to personal belief. It would be like stating that someone is an alien from Mars, if that was his belief or the belief of his personal cult. An encyclopedia must present well researched and established facts, not personal opinions or beliefs. This points to a conflict with NPOV on the proposed new version of the article. Adding to that, most of the new sources that were provided do not really comply with the [[Wikipedia:RS|RS]] policy, which clearly should not be user-uploaded images on imageshack or articles that just refer the subject or interview him, but do not review his work or discuss him in detail. There is not one single in depth reference addressing this individual from a single reliable source. This is not an indicator of notability NONE delete This article was previously deleted by Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Michelle_Belanger|AfD because it was considered promotional in a clear violation of the |NPOV policy and failing the |notability guidelines in Wikipedia standards. After its closure by a general consensus, it was again endorsed for deletion at a previous Wikipedia:Deletion_review/Log/2009_April_29|DRV for the exact same reason, in a once again very clear attempt at relaunching the promotional activity for this individual by herself or her agent. That DRV was requested by an user who's single edit was to open that deletion review, using an account with the name of Belanger's ''vampire cult''. That same account {{user|Kheperu}} was blocked as a ole account|role account. http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia Deletion of Michelle Belanger (2nd nomination) WP:NPOV||WP:N||WP:R Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15300 17194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swathi Lakra User:CoffeeWithMarkets 18:30, 29 May 2016 (UTC) delete Having a medium to high level police position isn't inherently notable, and the here-and-there mentioning of her and her work only seem to be |run-of-the-mill coverage, nothing special for major officers. Whether or not she's doing a good job, has helped a lot of people, etc doesn't affect notability guidelines Deletion of Swathi Lakra WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
15301 15723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Control Freak (villain) User:Eusebeus 19:21, 28 June 2008 (UTC) delete per nom or, fail that, merge per Hobit. Fails to assert real world significance or to demonstrate encyclopedic value or |notability that would require an independent article Deletion of Control Freak (villain) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15302 1021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Hope (actor) (2nd nomination) User:Ponyo 23:05, 9 May 2011 (UTC) keep This actor has appeared in many significant productions; meets Deletion of William Hope (actor) (2nd nomination) WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15303 13914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Olivier kemen User:GiantSnowman 18:02, 20 July 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Olivier kemen WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15304 12659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Super Bowl XXVII halftime show User:Ejgreen77 03:54, 5 February 2018 (UTC) keep Meets , per all above. Not all Super Bowl halftime shows are notable, but this innovative and ground-breaking one definitely is Deletion of Super Bowl XXVII halftime show WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15305 16890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theaghenis Dhionysatos User:Suriel1981 13:39, 13 January 2012 (UTC) keep """per : """"''Players who have appeared, and managers who have managed, in a fully professional league, will generally be regarded as notable''"""" - class the Greek Football League 2 as a fully-pro league""" Deletion of Theaghenis Dhionysatos WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15306 5828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victoria Taylor User:Dalahäst 03:56, 8 July 2015 (UTC) keep perhaps a borderline notability case before the recent events, but what's happened in the last week or so puts this article safely within the realm of notability, I think. It's true that |Wikipedia is not a newspaper, but this article isn't about an event and discusses more than just the recent firing. might apply if the article were solely about Victoria in light of her being fired, but it also describes the important role she held at Reddit prior to that happening. More content about her time at Reddit before being fired would definitely be a welcome addition, that said Deletion of Victoria Taylor WP:NOT||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15307 17743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Morningside Avenue (Toronto) User:SimonP 23:28, 3 February 2011 (UTC) keep It took me about 15 minutes to find three different media sources talking about this road. With only a bit of research a lot more well referenced content could be added. Easily meets Deletion of Morningside Avenue (Toronto) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15308 16208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The lost generation (t.l.g) User:Gongshow 01:10, 4 December 2009 (UTC) delete """I can find no in-depth coverage for this band, and they do not satisfy any of the other criteria for . Their best bet probably would have been criterion 5, but Rustyjukebox appears to be neither a """"major label or one of the more important indie labels""" Deletion of The lost generation (t.l.g) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15309 4220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charlotte Sweeney User:reddogsix 22:35, 16 February 2015 (UTC) delete fails to demonstrate any |notability Deletion of Charlotte Sweeney WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15310 13405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Payne User:GiantSnowman 15:25, 26 September 2008 (UTC) delete per nom, fails Deletion of Josh Payne WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15311 1266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magdalen Berns (2nd nomination) User:Timtrent 17:20, 4 June 2021 (UTC) comment There is no validity to well meaning thinking on . The outcome, while ''likely'' is not ''indisputable''. This renders a speedy/snow close to be unwise. The article on Berns deserves a full discussion. If not then Wikijustice will not be seen to be done Deletion of Magdalen Berns (2nd nomination) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
15312 4915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Empires (band) [[User Talk:JeremyMcClean|Talk]]) 01:45, 24 September 2010 (UTC) delete """Do I need to explain? The references here are a joke. There are five """"references,"""" three of them are interviews, another is a press article, and the last is a profile on some sort of forum. Obvious that this should be deleted. Might be a speedy on riteria for speedy deletion#A7|CSD A7 for a band. This should be closed due to . JeremyMcClean""" Deletion of Empires (band) WP:C||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
15313 5332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KOMPRESSOR User:Dnofos 22:35, 14 December 2005 (UTC) keep Is there a reason to expunge this piece of information from wikipedia? I think this artist meets the criteria for 'notable', only in a way not foreseen by Deletion of KOMPRESSOR WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15314 12209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tia Norfleet User:The 03:25, 19 May 2012 (UTC) keep Does indeed fail /, but that is not the be-all and end-all; I believe she meets the . http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/05/20/tia-norfleet-tries-to-become-first-female-african-american-nascar-driver_n_864690.html Huffington Post article, http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1389270/Tia-Norfleet-aims-female-Africa-American-driver-NASCAR-history.html Daily Mail article, http://www.prlog.org/11865324-tia-norfleet-to-headline-safety-event.html Safe America Foundation promo and http://chronicle.augusta.com/sports/2012-04-27/overtime Augusta Chronicle article about same, http://aol.sportingnews.com/nascar/story/2011-05-22/as-young-black-female-tia-norfleet-aims-to-change-nascar Sporting News article, http://www.stylemagazine.com/tia-norfleet-1st-black-female-nascar-driver/ Style Magazine article, http://www.blacknews.com/news/tia_norfleet_first_black_female_nascar_driver_support101.shtml BlackNews.com article, http://www.bet.com/news/sports/2011/06/17/tia-norfleet-is-racing-to-become-first-black-woman-driver-in-nascar.html BET article, http://www.dallasweekly.com/sports/article_efcb9c4e-0544-11e1-9467-001a4bcf6878.html?mode=image&photo=0 Dallas Weekly article, and I could go on Deletion of Tia Norfleet WP:NSPORT||WP:NMOTORSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15315 4062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A V Denham User:NJ 00:35, 20 May 2012 (UTC) keep Denham has written at least nine published books which are available for purchase at amazon.com.http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss_2?url=search-alias%3Daps&field-keywords=denham+%22robert+hale%22 Denham meets the notability standard: ''The person has created, or played a major role in co-creating, a significant or well-known work, or collective body of work Deletion of A V Denham WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15316 983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wayward Queen Attack User:MaxBrowne 12:39, 12 November 2015 (UTC) comment """It's very strange that people insist that this sequence of moves (I refuse to dignify it with the word """"opening"""") is notable enough to deserve its own article, just because some bratty 17 year old played it a few times. Other fringe openings like Grob's Attack at least have a few books written about them - this one has no books written about it, and doesn't even have a footnote in ECO, MCO or any other reputable openings book. Nobody even seems to agree on what it's called. The name """"Wayward Queen Attack"""" apparently stems from the very poorly regarded book ''Unorthodox Chess Openings'' by Eric Schiller (""""utter crap"""" according to Tony Miles) and is far from being a mainstream usage. The earliest reference I've found to 1.e4 e5 2.Qh5 is in the Dubuque Chess Journal 1875, where it is called the """"Kentucky Opening"""", then in the early 20th century it becomes the """"Danvers Opening"""" (named by Elmer Ernest Southard after the insane asylum where he worked). Then it becomes the Terrorist Attack, Used Car Salesman Attack, Parham Attack etc etc. Giving a sequence of moves which doesn't even have an accepted name its own article is clearly |undue weight and a violation of . At best it deserves a passing mention in the Open Game article - this reflects its relative importance among chess openings""" Deletion of Wayward Queen Attack WP:UNDUE||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15317 18740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Depenbusch User:Esradekan 00:04, 2 February 2009 (UTC) keep Yes, and that would be 1 of the 12 criteria of WP:Music, #C1 is another, which she passes for the references, which were already in the article |before it was nominated. |Non-English sources is not a valid reason for deletion Deletion of Anna Depenbusch WP:MUSIC||WP:BEFORE||WP:NONENG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15318 15881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Jesus Experience User:Rhododendrites 23:13, 5 May 2017 (UTC) delete Not seeing sufficient coverage to satisfy . &mdash Deletion of The Jesus Experience WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15319 19374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tomislav Uskok User:Sir 18:50, 29 November 2015 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Tomislav Uskok WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15320 9673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Andrews User:Dhartung 21:42, 15 March 2008 (UTC) delete fails . We've deleted several officials of national youth parties and similar groups. Although they have an above-average likelihood of eventually, say, holding political office, they are not inherently notable and are generally not known outside the organization. In the few cases where someone holds this office and is otherwise notable, it's based on better and more in-depth sourcing than http://www.smh.com.au/news/national/libs-stage-boycott/2008/02/13/1202760398971.html providing a quote during a protest Deletion of Tim Andrews WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15321 1885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NextStep ReUse [[User talk:71.166.157.40|talk]])}}''' 02:57, 8 October 2010 (UTC) delete Article lacks sufficient ttribution|Attribution for erifiability|Verifiability of the notability criteria, which is why I stuck a {{tl|Db-inc}} on it … given that it has been deleted twice already (#G12|G12 and #A3|A3), perhaps it should be |salted? The author should have used (and in the future, should use) a |sandbox/sub-page to add some (should any exist) and ''then'' move it into article space. Happy Editing! — '''{{#if:71.166.157.40|{{User|71.166.157.40}}|Special:Contributions/71.166.157.40|71.166.157.40 Deletion of NextStep ReUse WP:A||WP:V||WP:CORP||WP:CSD||WP:CSD||WP:SALT||WP:SUB||WP:RS Wikipedia:Attribution 108
15322 7127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tevita Pangai User:Doctorhawkes 06:20, 12 January 2015 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Tevita Pangai WP:RLN Wikipedia:Notability 77
15323 12910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Thomas (wide receiver, born 1991) User:Ejgreen77 05:45, 15 August 2019 (UTC) keep Meets and , per Cbl62's sources Deletion of Eric Thomas (wide receiver, born 1991) WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15324 8254 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""six pack speak""""""" [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']][[User talk:(aeropagitica)|''' (talk) ''']] 21:21, 15 June 2006 (UTC) delete Non-notable college message board, violation """Deletion of """"six pack speak""""""" WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
15325 3621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave Teo User:AustralianRupert 08:07, 16 April 2016 (UTC) delete While I can see a lot of work has been done to fully reference the article for which its editors should be commended, I really don't think the subject is notable enough for a stand alone biography article. Would such an individual be covered in a biographical encyclopedia (for instance, does Singapore have an equivalent of ''Who's Who'', such as the ''New Zealand Dictionary of Biography'' or the ''Australian Dictionary of Biography''? If so, would they qualify for appearance in that? If not, then I suggest perhaps we are reaching in our inclusion.) The subject appears to have received quite a bit of coverage in the context of that one incident, but otherwise they will likely remain a low profile individual. As such, it seems to me like BLP1E applies here, although as Anotherclown suggests perhaps the topic could be covered as a small part in a wider article (if a suitable one is agreed upon, and obviously being careful not to breach ). Beyond this, surely the other consideration is the subject's privacy and not impacting upon their ability to rehabilitate on release. Regards Deletion of Dave Teo WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15326 9560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur And Company User:NeoChaosX 00:48, 21 May 2008 (UTC) delete as hoax. Regardless of any claims of notability, the article is a hopelessly unsourced vanity piece full of unsourced |peacocking. As Deletion of Arthur And Company WP:PEACOCK Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
15327 15842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Left-wing insurgency in Greece User:FenixFeather 18:28, 30 August 2018 (UTC) delete """Insurgency"""" is a very serious claim that implies an active, shooting conflict between the government and leftist groups, which obviously isn't the case here. This article is a violation of and . We would've seen mainstream coverage of this if leftists and the Greek government were in a state of war. &ndash""" Deletion of Left-wing insurgency in Greece WP:NPOV||WP:OR Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15328 8530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelakovski User:Coredesat 04:26, 5 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Kelakovski WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15329 10591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CryptoHeaven User:Deli 12:13, 4 May 2008 (UTC) delete Does not seem to meet Deletion of CryptoHeaven WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15330 18758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary-Jess Leaverland User:RadioFan 23:54, 2 July 2011 (UTC) delete Fails her win could be sufficiently covered under the article on the contest, the promotional tone only strengthlens the need for deletion Deletion of Mary-Jess Leaverland WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
15331 14544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Space (NewsRadio episode) User:Sceptre 00:51, 1 December 2007 (UTC) keep per 's request not to AfD Deletion of Space (NewsRadio episode) WP:EPISODE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
15332 4410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jared Martinelli User:Sir 21:50, 27 April 2014 (UTC) delete none of them have played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning all these articles fail and . Additionally, none of them meet either Deletion of Jared Martinelli WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG||WP:COLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
15333 12006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rrahim Pacolli [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] 11:44, 31 October 2015 (UTC) delete I found three sources, but the coverage is slight and not biographical. Fails Deletion of Rrahim Pacolli WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15334 3765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roland Sparkes User:LibStar 12:26, 5 January 2010 (UTC) comment a number of guidelines are relevant here regarding Roland Sparkes self editting. , , , and clearly . the use of twitter as a reference is clearly a breach of Deletion of Roland Sparkes WP:COI||WP:POV||WP:OWN||WP:NOTRESUME||WP:AUTOBIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
15335 12128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arctic MUD (2nd nomination) [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 02:31, 4 August 2010 (UTC) delete Until there is something more concrete out there beside it appearing on Usenet (which there is no way to |verify this as I cannot access any of this), then I'm afraid I have to agree with the nom here Deletion of Arctic MUD (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15336 13953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beyond Car Forums [[User talk:Alphachimp|'''Alphachimp''']] 19:13, 4 November 2006 (UTC) delete I proposed this for deletion a while back. Fails Deletion of Beyond Car Forums WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
15337 7652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syria at the 1994 Asian Games User:Malcolmxl5 11:17, 3 June 2016 (UTC) merge to the main games article. This could have been done |boldly without bringing this and others here Deletion of Syria at the 1994 Asian Games WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
15338 9245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Waleed Tariq Saigol User:Bearcat 22:38, 8 October 2018 (UTC) delete """While strictly speaking the notability test for a politician is the ''holding'' of a notable office rather than the question of whether he was elected or appointed to it, I have to agree that """"caretaker"""" ministers, generally civil servants who held the office solely by virtue of being the top person in the line of succession between the end of the previous holder's term and the appointment or election of the official new permanent holder, are not entitled to the same automatic presumption of notability that a regular cabinet minister would get. If he could be sourced well enough to clear , then things would be different — but the mere inclusion of his name in a ''list'' of ''all'' the caretaker ministers who took office at the same time is not enough sourcing to deem him notable all by itself""" Deletion of Waleed Tariq Saigol WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15339 1861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sons of Sam Horn (2nd nomination) User:Diana 17:30, 11 May 2009 (UTC) delete It is merely a fan blog, it fails |notability Deletion of Sons of Sam Horn (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15340 1606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George B. Mowad User:WilliamJE 23:54, 2 April 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of George B. Mowad WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15341 17176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Dragon Queen(2nd nomination) User:Atlantic306 20:52, 21 November 2018 (UTC) keep as passes with multiple reviews in reliable sources and also passes Deletion of The Dragon Queen(2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
15342 6153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Sandra Cantu User:LGA 20:50, 21 August 2013 (UTC) delete This is a newsworthy event but it does not meet the |inclusion policy; the article does not demonstrate or make any claim that it was (or will be) a |precedent or catalyst for something else of lasting significance It received |news coverage because it was a news story, but the event has no ''|significant impact over a wide region, domain, or widespread societal group''. The coverage in this is secondary, because it needs to demonstrate that lasting significance or significant impact to be in policy Deletion of Murder of Sandra Cantu WP:NOTNEWS||WP:LASTING||WP:PRIMARYNEWS||WP:GEOSCOPE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15343 17435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brett Olson (disambiguation) User:Boleyn 15:59, 21 December 2014 (UTC) keep All meet MOS:DABMENTION and are . I added two, but actually there are several others which would meet MOS:DABMENTION. There are target pages {{u|Ravenswing}}, they are articles which MOS:DABMENTION|mention the person rather than a full article on them, but that's still useful to a reader who has typed it in. {{u|Tchaliburton}}, your comment indicates a withdrawal of nomination, but unless {{u|Ravenswing}} strikethrough his/her comment, the discussion will probably continue for a while, and I don't think it needs to. What do you think, Ravenswing Deletion of Brett Olson (disambiguation) WP:USEFUL Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15344 168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dangerous Dan User:GentlemanGhost 03:30, 29 March 2013 (UTC) delete No |reliable sources Deletion of Dangerous Dan WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15345 10650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paranet Continuum User:Location 20:52, 10 July 2015 (UTC) comment The only reliable source I found is a blurb in ''Billboard''.https://books.google.com/books?id=SggEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA97&lpg=PA97&dq=ParaNet+UFO+Continuum&source=bl&ots=4UEE24-BBD&sig=ca9KcdJDf0dKor2LFA4IS_fEjmc&hl=en&sa=X&ei=sy-gVby0L8eZoQSPyIboAQ&ved=0CEQQ6AEwBw#v=onepage&q=ParaNet%20UFO%20Continuum&f=false I'm not sure that this is enough to pass . Are there any others Deletion of Paranet Continuum WP:RPRGM Wikipedia:Notability 77
15346 3150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kigo (Kim Possible) User:NeoChaosX 03:17, 1 January 2007 (UTC) delete as failing for being fanfiction Deletion of Kigo (Kim Possible) WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
15347 1911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Esperanto Pen Pal Service User:Ihcoyc 14:49, 21 April 2006 (UTC) merge """per Hyperbole, but '''w/o prejudice''' to recreating a better version. The concept is almost self-explanatory; on the other hand, organizing Esperanto pen pals has long been a project of the Esperanto movement, and an explanation of that aspect of the movement may make a good article. In this case, the article should no longer be """"about a website"""" and may not apply""" Deletion of Esperanto Pen Pal Service WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
15348 7942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of LGBT elected British politicians User:Joe 16:09, 11 April 2014 (UTC) keep """It's not a trivial intersection, to pick a single example, this book: http://books.google.com/books?id=vmc4lwEACAAJ&dq=%22gay+politicians%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=SxJIU8vYEKXiyAHOl4HoCw&ved=0CCsQ6AEwAA is """"analysis of the changing representation of gay politicians in UK newspapers."""" , while that author is the only full work I can find dedciated to the subject, there is other signficant coverage of the gay/politican/UK intersection that appears to rise to notability via . The table appears to include some information which would not be available in a category, so I don't believe there's a redundancy argument, and as far as sourcing issues are involved, I believe those can and should be solved via normal editing, and quickly for BLPs. Inclusion on this list must be limited by our policies regarding sexual orientation, and this list must not include """"alleged to be""""s""" Deletion of List of LGBT elected British politicians WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
15349 8184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flashflight User:Edison 17:11, 16 December 2009 (UTC) keep The links DGG cites are in fact significant and independent coverage in reliable sources, and are not catalog listings, since the publications do not offer them for sale. Barely satisfies , though more sources with deeper coverage would help. More information about the developers, about their company would help in writing an article that was more than a product description Deletion of Flashflight WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15350 1929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of the Saudi government and the Islamic State User:Cowlibob 21:14, 22 August 2015 (UTC) delete Article topic doesn't meet GNG. Only one source on the article refers to similarities between the two entities in reference to penal punishments which if deemed worthy could be included in other articles. Article reads very much like an essay by the article creator. The very first sentence is a very contentious claim that the Saudi Arabia government directly helped ISIL over a number of years. Something even our article on ISIL doesn't make, indeed it makes the opposite statement. The last sentence refers to ISIL as a country which is a claim not recognised by any state/country in the world. At best this is an attempt by the article creator at synthesis while at worst I fear it is an attempt to advocate for ISIL by pointing out similarities between it and one of the leading Muslim countries Deletion of Comparison of the Saudi government and the Islamic State WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
15351 4799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Luxury Cars User:LonelyBeacon 01:13, 21 July 2008 (UTC) delete """this is another well intended list that is inherently . Even getting rid of the lead-in describing cars as """"desirable or expensive"""" as these are highly relative terms depending on where you are in the world. In that sense, it takes on a very First World POV. If the list were better tailored to something like: Cars with suggested retail values of over >>insert monetary value here""" Deletion of List of Luxury Cars WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15352 13568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sword and crown (module) User:S 15:32, 10 September 2008 (UTC) merge to List of Dungeons & Dragons modules#Other Modules (1992 - 2000) per BOZ. I disagree with Richard Pinch that this is an |advert since it refers to a product no longer in print from a publisher that no longer exists. I feel deletion without redirect would be overly strong because I'd heard of this product in the past, and I'd expect to find at least some reference to it on Wikipedia Deletion of Sword and crown (module) WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
15353 10437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zebraplop User:Cocytus 02:25, 15 January 2010 (UTC) delete fails badly; YouTube videos are not nearly enough to merit inclusion. Seems to lack significant coverage by reliable third parties Deletion of Zebraplop WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15354 4037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elonka Dunin (3rd nomination) User:Shot 00:22, 5 November 2008 (UTC) delete if it weren't the fact that the person in question wasn't a high editcount admin, this would be a clear cut case of failure due to . However I can see that it's just going to be a personality vote unfortunately Deletion of Elonka Dunin (3rd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15355 5851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gavin Paul Carter User:Izzy007 23:28, 30 May 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Gavin Paul Carter WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15356 18493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mindblister User:Evb 12:20, 20 November 2007 (UTC) delete per nom & Aecis. My money is on obvious Deletion of Mindblister WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
15357 21893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mexican Dream User:Anonymous 21:56, 2 July 2021 (UTC) delete fails |NFILM and . The large number of awards won by this appear to be non-notable (such as minor festivals and student awards Deletion of The Mexican Dream WP:NFILM||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15358 7244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lie To Me (Gary Barlow song) User:Gongshow 17:43, 8 May 2010 (UTC) merge to ''Twelve Months, Eleven Days'', the parent album. I can't find significant coverage for this song sufficient for it to warrant an independent article; does not meet Deletion of Lie To Me (Gary Barlow song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15359 18047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles H. Dillemuth User:Dhartung 20:52, 22 May 2007 (UTC) comment """The statement, """"It was determined in March or April that congressional nominees of either major party automatically met 'notability'"""" is patently false. There's never been any such determination, and, in fact, each of the four times the subject has come up on WP:BIO discussion pages, the majority sentiment has been exactly the opposite: that such individuals are ''not'' notable automatically. Dillemuth may yet meet in his own right. (Per""" Deletion of Charles H. Dillemuth WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15360 6532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lenovo IdeaPad S10-3s User:Hobbes 05:13, 30 December 2011 (UTC) merge to IdeaPad. As the reviews linked to the article point out, this is not even a new product, just an upgrade, so let's just upgrade the IdeaPad article, too. Sources provided and ghits are primary, sales sites, consumer reviews. Deletion of Lenovo IdeaPad S10-3s WP:NOTCATALOG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15361 11211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kill the Sun (Xandria Demo) User:Ben NONE delete to Kill the Sun as the article about a Demo fails . ---- Preceding !vote added by Deletion of Kill the Sun (Xandria Demo) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15362 15211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen A. Unger User:RadioFan 11:43, 30 April 2009 (UTC) keep the references do need to be cleaned up removing any that dont meet but appearing in a top 100 list in Sporting News demonstrates notability Deletion of Stephen A. Unger WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15363 7340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Human Society (Parts 1 and 2) User:Abhidevananda 08:05, 9 February 2013 (UTC) keep """This nomination starts off with a false assertion. These books are '''not''' self-published. Furthermore, the fact that the material in them has been republished in the """"PROUT in a Nutshell"""" series does not mean that the original books are somehow not notable by reverse inheritance (although I should mention here that I still consider the """"PROUT in a Nutshell"""" series to be notable). As the nominator himself states, there are several citations in relation to these books. And the books are referenced on several Wikipedia pages, perhaps most notably at Law of Social Cycle. Hence, I believe that the notability of these books is adequately established, especially in light of the usual problems of |systemic bias. I have no doubt that many relevant documents can be found with a painstaking search of Indian sources in English, Hindi, Bengali, and so on. However, given the fact that Wikipedia is not a full-time job for me and I am coping with nine (9) concurrent AfD nominations from this same nominator, not to mention questionable edits on other articles not yet nominated for deletion by him, I would prefer to forgo such a time-consuming exercise""" Deletion of Human Society (Parts 1 and 2) WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
15364 2145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Duck and Cover (South African band) User:Grandruskiy48 17:17, 31 May 2021 (UTC) delete Fails no reliable sources available Deletion of Duck and Cover (South African band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15365 7202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kissin' U User:Doomsdayer520 18:47, 17 April 2010 (UTC) keep the article was created a few weeks too early and presented a problem for a while, but now that the song has charted in the http://www.billboard.com/#/artist/miranda-cosgrove/1008601 Billboard Hot 100 history has caught up with the article Deletion of Kissin' U WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15366 2658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Amazing Maurice User:Robert 21:08, 8 November 2020 (UTC) delete Please read |the film notability guideline in detail again. The guideline is often misread, and films in production sometimes get accepted because the guideline is misread, but films in production are only notable if production itself is notable. Normally notability does require reviews, and reviews require that the movie be viewed. The fact that the guideline is often misread doesn't change the guideline, which is that unreleased films are seldom notable Deletion of The Amazing Maurice WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
15367 4305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Digital anomie User:Stuartyeates 10:49, 6 July 2015 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of Digital anomie WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
15368 13446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of housing cooperatives in Canada (2nd nomination) User:The 19:32, 8 July 2018 (UTC) delete per nomination, further to which not much more can be said. Let's be gracious (four items on the list?!) and claim Deletion of List of housing cooperatives in Canada (2nd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
15369 9196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/King Soon Come User:Richard3120 12:59, 23 April 2018 (UTC) merge to Foxy Brown. Very much – no confirmation anywhere of a definite release date, or that the album will definitely see the light of day in 2018. Best redirected to the artist's page for now, and can be recreated as and when a concrete release date is announced Deletion of King Soon Come WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15370 13824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Opusmodus User:Ammarpad 19:16, 1 December 2017 (UTC) delete Delete fundamentally for lack of significant coverage to establish notability. Also for covert attempt of |promotion against Wikipedia policies. The SPA author has never edited any mainspace page except this article since account creation in 2015. This is enough indicator of what he is here for Deletion of Opusmodus WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15371 5738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marion Crane (band) User:Yilloslime 22:28, 2 October 2009 (UTC) delete The only independent, reliable source cited is http://www.eujacksonville.com/. (Consensus at WP:RSN is that examiner.com is no better than a blog). I'd need to see media attention by more than the just the local alt weekly before believing that #1 is fulfilled and a wikipedia article is justified Deletion of Marion Crane (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15372 20299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Gale [[User talk:180.172.239.231|talk]]) 10:19, 30 August 2014 (UTC) keep Numerous reliable sources regarding her death（http://www.foxnews.com/story/2009/04/03/shelters-fine-tuning-policies-to-better-serve-transgender-homeless/http://www.dallasvoice.com/trans-womans-death-shines-light-on-plight-of-homeless-1018519.htmlhttp://blogs.dallasobserver.com/unfairpark/2008/12/former_mayoral_candidate_jenni.phphttp://austin.twcnews.com/content/news/227266/perennial-political-candidate--jennifer-gale--found-dead/http://www.legacy.com/obituaries/statesman/obituary.aspx?n=Jennifer-Gale&pid=121490633http://www.wfaa.com/story/local/2014/08/30/13455004/http://www.statesman.com/blogs/content/shared-gen/blogs/austin/cityhall/entries/2008/12/17/jennifer_gale_found_dead.html/http://www.burntorangereport.com/showDiary.do?diaryId=7655http://www.statesman.com/blogs/content/shared-gen/blogs/austin/blotter/entries/2009/02/11/gale_died_of_cardiovasular_dis.html/http://www.austinchronicle.com/daily/news/2008-12-19/718507/http://cityhallblog.dallasnews.com/2008/12/jennifer-gale-colorful-perenni.html/http://www.newsradioklbj.com/news/austin-local-news/austin-city-council-honor-jennifer-gale-today）and her candidacy.（http://austin.twcnews.com/content/news/19144/jennifer-gale-runs-for-mayor-for-2nd-time/http://www.austinchronicle.com/gyrobase/Issue/story?oid=oid%3A616212http://www.austinchronicle.com/gyrobase/Issue/column?oid=oid:212988http://www.statesman.com/news/content/news/stories/local/04/09/0409forum.htmlhttp://www.austinchronicle.com/gyrobase/Issue/column?oid=oid%3A212988) (210 articles in http://www.austinchronicle.com/gyrobase/Archive/search?Search=Jennifer+Gale&Start=21)The article doesn't need to rely on primary sources, since we can write a good article based on the given sources. The nominator's rationale sounds rather and . --Special:Contributions/180.172.239.231|180.172.239.231 Deletion of Jennifer Gale WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:POV Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15373 13231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Sheffield Bell User:Alzarian16 15:04, 4 May 2010 (UTC) keep Terry has it right. He meets, , and . I see no policy-based reason to delete this Deletion of David Sheffield Bell WP:PROF||WP:BASIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15374 4945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Health Insurance Innovations User:Newshunter12 12:05, 8 September 2018 (UTC) delete The article fails and is nothing more then a promotional piece for the company. Being listed on a stock exchange doesn't automatically make a company notable Deletion of Health Insurance Innovations WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15375 12626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFO sightings in outer space (2nd nomination) User:LuckyLouie 22:09, 15 April 2014 (UTC) delete Basically |unverifiable. A complete lack of reliable sources that could be used to cite the material presented Deletion of UFO sightings in outer space (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15376 3374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International T-Shirt Day User:Alexius08 09:02, 21 May 2009 (UTC) delete as a poorly-|sourced article about a |hardly-celebrated holiday Deletion of International T-Shirt Day WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15377 13143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Sweeney (soccer) User:Govvy 13:50, 22 July 2019 (UTC) delete The whole article feels very much promotional, I would go so far and say this should be delete per Deletion of Patrick Sweeney (soccer) WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15378 17916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World Karate Union User:K 02:34, 10 July 2018 (UTC) delete with prejudice :-). Fails / Deletion of World Karate Union WP:NORG||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15379 18427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Renaissance Capital (US company) User:Bearian 22:40, 21 May 2012 (UTC) keep I have now identified exactly three good sources (''LA Times, BusinessWeek,'' and Dec. 2006 ''Stcoks & Commodities'') that discuss the firm and its philosophy, but not all in depth. I agree that |it passes at least barely Deletion of Renaissance Capital (US company) WP:BARE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15380 8888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abraham Gancwajch User:Shmaltz 14:19, 31 January 2008 (UTC) keep as shameful as it is the nazis could have not done it without the Jewish help they received and he was one of them. As for enough good sources have been given Deletion of Abraham Gancwajch WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15381 9009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Jawad (Journalist) User:GeoffreyT2000 06:04, 27 November 2017 (UTC) delete This journalist has no significant coverage, so he fails . Not to be confused with the British Paralympic powerlifter with the same name Deletion of Ali Jawad (Journalist) WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15382 1716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randy Graf User:Jersyko 17:58, 6 October 2006 (UTC) keep I see no reason to refer to notability guidelines to prove that this article should be kept; this is a candidate for a major party for a national office, in any event. Though this article needs to be sourced, it's obviously |verifiable in |reliable sources, as the information at Arizona 8th congressional district election, 2006 is. It's relatively |NPOV. · Deletion of Randy Graf WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15383 6032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Devotion Bidwell User:RGTraynor 03:08, 13 August 2008 (UTC) comment """Mmm ... except that explicitly holds that members of a local council are """"likely"""" to be notable if that council is of a """"major metropolitan city."""" A selectman of a town that's never in its history broken 1200 people is leagues below that""" Deletion of John Devotion Bidwell WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
15384 5143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ponte dei Bareteri User:Matthiaspaul 16:32, 28 July 2015 (UTC) keep """It is obvious that this stub needs expansion, but I see our basic notability criteria per fulfilled. There are articles in several other Wikipedias, Google turns up with lots of hits, and it is covered in several books. One of them lists is as """"bridge 26"""" of 100 Venecian bridges (http://venice100bridges.blogspot.de/2014/05/bridge-twenty-six-ponte-dei-bareteri.html). Venipedia has a detailed description of it as well (http://www.venipedia.org/wiki/index.php?title=Ponte_dei_Bareteri). With enough time at hands, I'm sure more in-deep sources can be turned up as well, so I think the article has potential to grow""" Deletion of Ponte dei Bareteri WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15385 5651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anders Lundkvist User:Shoessss 14:15, 5 November 2008 (UTC) keep But just barely. I understand there are virtually no English language references to Anders Lundkvist|Mr. Lundkvist. However, in my opinion, Wikipedia extends beyond just language and is chartered with the dissemination of knowledge and information regardless of culture – language or location. With that said, there is enough Swedish coverage from reliable – certifiable – creditable – and verifiable sources, as shown here http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Anders+Lundkvist%22&sa=N&start=10, to meet the criteria for inclusion under otability|Notability Deletion of Anders Lundkvist WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15386 2140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fashionpop User:Joe 20:38, 16 November 2009 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Fashionpop WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
15387 21648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Boum User:Joaquin008 10:27, 12 April 2013 (UTC) keep The article needs improvement but it passes Deletion of Joseph Boum WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15388 7434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Losh User:Randykitty 13:57, 4 June 2015 (UTC) keep Fas as I can see, this does not meet . Dismal citation record (even for someone who is early career in a low citation-density field), but David Eppstein makes a good case that this squeaks by AUTHOR Deletion of Elizabeth Losh WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15389 11600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mickey Renaud (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep Other than the fact that the subject of the article is deceased, this is an eerily similar discussion to one that happened a few weeks back regarding numerous articles about U.S. college soccer players who had been selected in the first round of the MLS draft. The problems with that discussion, as with this one, are contradictory interpretations of and projects on the specific sport that set notability guidelines that were more strict than the general ones Deletion of Mickey Renaud (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15390 3286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anton Medan User:NeoFreak 06:15, 29 March 2007 (UTC) delete Fails |attribution and |verifiability policies and after that long I'm not seeing that change Deletion of Anton Medan WP:ATT||WP:V Wikipedia:Attribution 108
15391 187 [[Landtagswahl in Nordrhein-Westfalen 2010/Umfragen und Prognosen]] (bleibt) Benutzer:KaiMartin 05:41, 18. Apr. 2011 (CEST) delete """Punkt 7 aus lautet: Wikipedia ist keine Rohdatensammlung"""". Dieser Artikel liefert nun aber genau dies. Daher (und nicht wieder in den Ursprungsartikel einbauen""" Löschung von Landtagswahl in Nordrhein-Westfalen 2010/Umfragen und Prognosen Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15392 14721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MIddle East: Shuttle Diplomacy of Bush (Dr.Abdul Ruff Colachal) User:Srpnor 12:31, 6 February 2008 (UTC) delete and agree, should be and some polite user education Deletion of MIddle East: Shuttle Diplomacy of Bush (Dr.Abdul Ruff Colachal) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
15393 5629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manhattan Fruitier User:Ben 06:43, 9 August 2015 (UTC) comment on ''draft/userfy'': The author is a who left wikipedia one minute after his creation of the article. — Deletion of Manhattan Fruitier WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
15394 8658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brickster User:Shooterwalker 15:01, 15 August 2010 (UTC) delete clearly fails policy such as and due to a lack of third party sources Deletion of Brickster WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15395 7357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Axel Tuanzebe User:Sir 20:00, 16 July 2016 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully professional league and has not received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Axel Tuanzebe WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15396 20579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chillum (pipe) User:Ssbohio 01:19, 11 January 2008 (UTC) keep This article's topic meets the basic standards of |notability and |verifiability, even if lacking in other areas. It clearly needs more |citations, but the topic itself appears to meet the standard for inclusion. |Stubbify at the extreme, but the subject should be covered here. If no sources arise, then the article can always be merged into smoking pipe. Our goal needs to be to make bad articles |better, maybe even |the gold standard, not merely to delete whatever doesn't measure up ''at this moment Deletion of Chillum (pipe) WP:N||WP:V||WP:CITE||WP:STUB||WP:GA||WP:FA Wikipedia:Notability 77
15397 16133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Farrell (soccer) User:Bald 11:00, 29 January 2013 (UTC) keep but only just. At the moment he fails , but the honours he has recently won (Big East Defensive Player of the Year and List of NCAA Division I men's soccer First-Team All-America teams|First Team NSCAA All-American) are pretty notable awards, and the media coverage they've given him are just about enough to satisfy the |general notability guidelines, in my opinion Deletion of Andrew Farrell (soccer) WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15398 15587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Share-aunt User:Adrian 22:04, 2 March 2006 (UTC) delete as |unverifiable and/or |original research / dictdef / protoneologism Deletion of Share-aunt WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15399 11152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/100 Greatest TV Moments User:SuperMarioMan 01:56, 18 September 2011 (UTC) delete """Following Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/100 Greatest TV Moments from Hell, I considered starting a mass AfD just like this one, only I was distracted by other business on-Wiki and it kept slipping my mind. They're interesting pages, but the nominator's concerns regarding are still completely nevertheless seem accurate. Furthermore, none of these articles meaningfully substantiates the |notability of the TV programmes in question, which is probably a strong rationale for deletion in itself. Similar ''100 Greatest/100 Worst'' spin-out articles not listed in this AfD have been (often more than once, depending on whether or not the article was re-created) variously AfDed, PRODed or SPEEDYed over the years. In my experience, """"countdown""""-style pages such as the ones listed above are also popular targets for vandalism (people oh-so-subtly changing poll results to reflect their own opinions as to which is the best/worst TV show/comedy film, etc.). For multiple reasons, therefore, deletion is seems to me to be appropriate""" Deletion of 100 Greatest TV Moments WP:COPYVIO||WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
15400 7552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Chemistry Set (American band) User:Paul 03:14, 15 December 2011 (UTC) keep In addition to what was already identified, I found an entire article about the band in the ''Corpus Christi Caller-Times'', now added to the article. The subject meets criterion #1 Deletion of The Chemistry Set (American band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15401 9153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Child Watch Phuket User:Jack 01:06, 6 April 2010 (UTC) keep as above. |Snow due in Thailand, soon Deletion of Child Watch Phuket WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
15402 3248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Cotter User:PRehse 08:58, 1 August 2015 (UTC) delete As per nominator. This is essentially an advert and does not meet . The first reference which is the only one that discusses the subject is a subject written advert Deletion of Steve Cotter WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15403 18749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tha Carter III: The Leak User:Master 05:06, 30 December 2007 (UTC) delete per . If it does happen, recreate it; right now there isn't enough evidence for the article to remain Deletion of Tha Carter III: The Leak WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15404 8211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zu Shenatir User:Location 20:36, 9 September 2014 (UTC) keep per WP:GNG. This person and his crimes appear to have lasting notability 1,500 years later due to coverage in academic sources discussing serial killing, sex crimes, and crimes against homosexuals. The historical notability of his crimes pass , but it makes more sense to title articles like these after the serial killer rather than the events. I would like to see a discussion about promoting the essay to guideline status in that it does a much better job than and in cases like these Deletion of Zu Shenatir WP:EVENT||WP:MURDEROF||WP:PERP||WP:VICTIM Wikipedia:Notability 77
15405 19166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hearts Over Rome [[User: Cielomobile|Cielomobile]] [[User talk:Cielomobile|talk]] / [[Special:Contributions/Cielomobile|contribs]] 05:48, 31 May 2007 (UTC) delete Fails . They don't even have their own website anymore; are they a now defunct band or something Deletion of Hearts Over Rome WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15406 12529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hollie Robertson User:Usernameunique 22:08, 23 February 2021 (UTC) comment """u|Devokewater}}, did you """"Search for additional sources"""" before nominating the article for deletion, |as required? Your comment suggests that you did not, and fails to acknowledge that """"otability#Article content does not determine notability|if the source material exists, even very poor writing and referencing within a Wikipedia article will not decrease the subject's notability"""". Had you conducted such a search, you would have found plenty of sources. Examples: https://www.shropshirestar.com/entertainment/2009/06/07/what-hollie-did-next/ 1; http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/shropshire/5264554.stm 2; http://www.bbc.co.uk/pressoffice/pressreleases/stories/2006/06_june/03/fever.shtml 3; https://www.digitalspy.com/tv/a36013/dance-fever-winner-speaks-about-attack/ 4; https://www.digitalspy.com/tv/a33815/street-dancer-wins-strictly-dance-fever/ 5; https://www.londontheatre.co.uk/theatre-news/news/strictly-dance-fever-winners-darrien-wright-hollie-robertson-to-join-cast-of 6; https://www.gazettelive.co.uk/news/local-news/hes-strictly-no1---darren-3769937 7; https://www.rte.ie/entertainment/2006/0426/406759-strictlydancefever/ 8""" Deletion of Hollie Robertson WP:BEFORE||WP:N Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15407 12685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alrosa Villa User:Dlabtot 18:56, 27 January 2010 (UTC) delete per . What happened at the bar is notable. The bar is not Deletion of Alrosa Villa WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15408 12366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laura Steel User:Qwyrxian 15:47, 12 August 2010 (UTC) delete """editor added a """"reference,"""" but it's only an interview from just before she performed at a festival. That alone is not enough to meet . Some might argue that appearing on a national chart qualifies under , but I certainly don't believe that project specific notability guidelines can override GNG""" Deletion of Laura Steel WP:GNG||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15409 8993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How I Braved Anu Aunty and Co-Founded a Million Dollar Company User:Skr15081997 05:21, 7 June 2015 (UTC) keep Here's http://www.tribuneindia.com/2012/20120624/spectrum/book2.htm another review published in ''The Tribune (Chandigarh)|The Tribune''. Together with the ''Times of India'' review, this satisfies Deletion of How I Braved Anu Aunty and Co-Founded a Million Dollar Company WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
15410 5739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1001 Video Games You Must Play Before You Die User:Ginsengbomb 17:48, 3 January 2012 (UTC) keep per Sergecross73's source discoveries. Significant coverage in multiple reliable sources. Reviews of a book are considered sufficient sourcing per Deletion of 1001 Video Games You Must Play Before You Die WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
15411 6708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Like Me (musical) User:onel5969 13:57, 25 March 2017 (UTC) delete can't find enough in-depth sourcing to show it passes Deletion of Like Me (musical) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15412 13383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robin T. Cotton User:Leflyman 05:07, 26 June 2006 (UTC) keep """with re-write to remove the barrage of |peacock language like """"world-renowned"""", """"groungbreaking"""", """"one of the busiest"""" and """"large international attention"""" which makes this sound like a puff piece. The awards section can be clipped, too, as they aren't even notable enough to merit their own articles""" Deletion of Robin T. Cotton WP:PEACOCK Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
15413 20451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hugo E. Martinez (3rd nomination) User:Bakazaka 03:09, 24 September 2018 (UTC) merge to List of general authorities of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Contrary to what the above editor claims, proposals to exempt LDS leaders from the have consistently failed to achieve consensus support (see examples in Wikipedia_talk:Notability_(people)/Archive_2014#Religious_leaders|2014, Wikipedia_talk:Notability_(people)/Archive_2016#Leaders in The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and other religious organizations|2016, Wikipedia_talk:Notability_(people)/Archive_2017#Exception Proposal for General Authority Seventies of the LDS_Church|2017, and Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2018 August 3|2018), so the subject has to be evaluated under . Most sources currently in article are not independent under (''Liahona'', lds.org, ''Church News'' reprinted verbatim in ''Deseret News'') that do not count toward establishing notability. (Note that the previous AfD failed to account for the fact that some ''Deseret News'' coverage is simply reprinted ''Church News'' and therefore not independent even though ''Deseret News'' sometimes produces independent coverage.) The other two sources are 1) two mentions of subject's name in routine coverage of church activities in ''The Spectrum'', and 2) 140 words in an 1800 word ''Daily Herald'' story on new leaders in the church. That's not significant coverage, and search does not find sufficient coverage in independent reliable sources to meet , only the usual passing mentions in routine coverage and brief quotes reprinted from church sources. A sensible alternative to deletion is to redirect to List of general authorities of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, where information on the subject already exists. Open to alternatives if in-depth coverage emerges Deletion of Hugo E. Martinez (3rd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:GNG||WP:IIS||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
15414 2553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Cooper (missing person) User:Esquivalience 14:27, 21 June 2015 (UTC) delete per : only notable for the event Deletion of Elizabeth Cooper (missing person) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15415 7645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Australian Consulate General in Chennai (2nd nomination) User:Bejnar 20:21, 6 October 2015 (UTC) delete no redirect. It fails the significant coverage guideline of . It can be listed at a future article about the High Commission in Delhi, should that ever prove notable for an article. But in general, embassies, and high commissions do not receive the level of in depth coverage that results in notability, much less consulates. Remember Wikipedia is not a directory. Deletion of Australian Consulate General in Chennai (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15416 12935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/El Rancho High School Teen Court Program User:Xanchester 05:12, 16 November 2012 (UTC) delete A search indicates that a lot of counties in the United States have teen court programs. The scope of this article is ridiculously small, and |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of El Rancho High School Teen Court Program WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15417 18286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesse Warn User:Wikimandia 08:24, 15 May 2015 (UTC) keep per . The New Zealand Film Awards satisfies the requirement as a major award Deletion of Jesse Warn WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15418 7271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ned's Fate: The Glory Days User:JamesBWatson 14:44, 13 August 2015 (UTC) delete """No evidence at all of notability. ({{Ping|Narutolovehinata5}} #A7|Speedy deletion criterion A7 applies only to """"a real person, individual animal(s), organization, web content or organized event"""", and this does not fall under any of those categories.) ''The editor who uses the pseudonym""" Deletion of Ned's Fate: The Glory Days WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15419 11616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of plays in English on the Internet User:Roscelese 15:07, 13 March 2012 (UTC) delete per my PROD rationale: Intentionally and by nature a . While it is potentially useful in user space or even project space, this does not belong in mainspace Deletion of List of plays in English on the Internet WP:LINKFARM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15420 2 [[Click.to]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Derlangemarkus 09:38, 30. Aug. 2011 (CEST) keep """Laut |der Richtlinien für Software-Artikel dürfte eine Relevanz gegeben sein. Berichte in TechCrunch, c't, Chip (Computerzeitschrift)|Chip etc (siehe http://www.clicktoapp.com/de/awards/). zeugen für mich von der benötigen """"nennenswerter Erwähnung in der Presse"""". Ergo""" Löschung von Click.to Wikipedia:Richtlinien Software Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
15421 7677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Damion Lowe User:IJA 15:18, 5 November 2014 (UTC) keep After reviewing the comments by other editors here on this AfD, I'm going to say this article just scrapes the standards of due to ''significant'' media coverage Deletion of Damion Lowe WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15422 902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devil dogs User:Joe 15:07, 25 August 2011 (UTC) comment Much of the information on Yodels and Ring Dings is unsourced, and seems difficult to source. Wouldn't this article similarly tempt to occur Deletion of Devil dogs WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
15423 21624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of gay, lesbian or bisexual people (5th nomination) User:AV3000 03:02, 7 September 2011 (UTC) keep Article/subarticles appear to be reliably sourced and satisfy #List_articles; any problematic individual entries can be fixed or removed as applicable. Regarding the issue of vs. #List_articles, there are many, many :Category:Lists of people|list articles regarding people, so it's unclear why this particular case deserves undue attention. Perhaps the nominator should initiate a more general policy discussion Deletion of List of gay, lesbian or bisexual people (5th nomination) WP:LIST||WP:NOTDIR||WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
15424 7256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Backwell User:Untick 04:35, 21 March 2009 (UTC) delete """Does not meet reative. Her only acting roles as Pandora in """"Skins"""" is not a """"significant roles""" Deletion of Lisa Backwell WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
15425 12974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/So You Think You Can Dance (American season 16) Top Ten finalists User:Epinoia 00:20, 26 August 2019 (UTC) delete looks like a repeat of information largely already in So You Think You Can Dance (American season 16) - Wikipedia:Overlistification|Overlistification, Deletion of So You Think You Can Dance (American season 16) Top Ten finalists WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
15426 1748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chlex User:Jreferee 07:31, 2 September 2007 (UTC) delete Importance/significance gets it past #A7. However, to get past |Notability, Chlex needs to have received significant coverage in Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable sources that are Wikipedia:Verifiability#Sources|independent of the subject. The topic fails notability Deletion of Chlex WP:CSD||WP:N Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15427 4977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bonnie Blossman [[User talk:202.124.73.31|talk]]) 06:56, 8 July 2013 (UTC) comment Fails with a h-index of 2. I'm seeing some news coverage relating to conflicts between the cast of the TV show, but that's . Given the bizarre combination of interests the subject has, there may be coverage I've missed. -- Special:Contributions/202.124.73.31|202.124.73.31 Deletion of Bonnie Blossman WP:PROF||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
15428 7185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glenn Sasscer User:Dhartung 03:50, 13 May 2008 (UTC) delete No sources, no indication of passing or , nothing found in a search of Google News Archive. EverettGee, promoting a new author is |not what Wikipedia is all about, sorry to say Deletion of Glenn Sasscer WP:BK||WP:BIO||WP:NOTMYSPACE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15429 10787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oncology Reports User:Headbomb 12:35, 26 July 2013 (UTC) keep is indexed by major and selective databases (Medline, Scopus, CAS, CSA, and many others), has impact factor, and thus meets with flying colors Deletion of Oncology Reports WP:NJOURNALS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15430 13522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Velocitron User:Snottywong 18:11, 24 August 2010 (UTC) merge to Transformers: Cybertron and/or List of Transformers planets. Not notable enough for its own article. Deletion of Velocitron WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
15431 20431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of things considered foul smelling NONE NONE keep Easily passes . Here's a selection of sources and you may be sure that there are many more Deletion of List of things considered foul smelling WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
15432 16915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FK Multibanka Rīga User:Lightburst 15:41, 8 December 2019 (UTC) keep per HawkAussie; Deletion of FK Multibanka Rīga WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15433 21098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 BWF World Junior Championships – Boys' doubles NONE NONE keep Passes . Junior world championship by BWF is certainly a notable sports event Deletion of 2016 BWF World Junior Championships – Boys' doubles WP:SPORTSEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15434 14070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zionist editing on Wikipedia User:Ynhockey 08:30, 20 August 2010 (UTC) delete obviously. Non-notable event that generated little media attention blown up out of proportion by Wikipedians who want to highlight it. Among other thing, the article is against , , and (the line that mentions living persons without a reliable source Deletion of Zionist editing on Wikipedia WP:1E||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:SYNTH||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15435 12651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Conglomerate User:Jonel 22:16, 11 January 2006 (UTC) keep record on major label, coverage in two of Australia's largest circulation newspapers, seems quite notable to me. Certainly meets the level of exposure the criteria of suggest Deletion of The Conglomerate WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15436 173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Calvin Cheng (2nd nomination) User:Jane 10:15, 11 December 2017 (UTC) keep Subject is notable in Singapore. Suggest raising the level of protection to permanently since a lot of those edit warring stuff by representatives of the subject through sock puppets can be avoided. Editors shouldn't be wasting unnecessary time dealing with COI users whose objective is at tonewalling and Deletion of Calvin Cheng (2nd nomination) WP:BLUELOCK||WP:S||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
15437 14633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nenad Stanković User:Vickser 06:53, 8 August 2008 (UTC) delete He's close with the Faroe Islands player of the year http://www.soccerandequipment.com/player-of-the-year-2007-faroe-islands.html (not sure if that's a 100% RS), but I don't think there's enough here to invoke use of . If people could provide some newspaper articles or verify Bogulav's claim that he played in the Champions League (my research is showing he didn't), I'd be open to changing my vote. As is, I can't find enough reliable sources on the guy to merit an article Deletion of Nenad Stanković WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
15438 4012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jewish Israeli stone throwing User:Icewhiz 19:25, 16 May 2018 (UTC) delete With the exception of the last two sources (one of which is a rather primary travel warning) none of the sources discuss the topic. What we do have is multiple individual incidents strung together - in which an Israeli (or Palestinian pre 48) Jew threw a stone. As such, connection of the strung together incidents to a topic is . Settler violence is already covered in Israeli settler violence. I suspect Haredi violence may be notable standalone. Ethiopian-Israeli (essentially once incident) probably not. All the various sub sets are not discussed jointly in RS, and arise/occur in completely different circumstances. As such we fail GNG since the sources do not address the topic (of '''Jewish Israeli''' stone throwing Deletion of Jewish Israeli stone throwing WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
15439 739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judy Wood User:David 23:11, 14 April 2007 (UTC) delete Ph.D.s having wacky theories is not in and of itself notable, and self-published theories on web sites are not reliable secondary sources of notability. The academic paper and letter in a journal by two others debunking her theories are such a source, but not enough of a source to convince me that anyone takes her theories seriously or that she's an important part of the 9/11 conspiracy theory world. Put it this way: if we were evaluating a non-crackpot Ph.D. for notability using , one self-published paper with only two citations would be very far from satisfying that guideline Deletion of Judy Wood WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15440 13689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faizan Mirza User:Gnome 14:44, 6 October 2014 (UTC) delete This article clearly meets criteria for speedy deletion, #A7 Deletion of Faizan Mirza WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15441 3819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Béla Sipos User:David 06:19, 8 May 2021 (UTC) delete Badly sourced, with no evidence of or based notability. In particular, his economic works appear to have single-digit citations in Google Scholar, far below the standard for macroeconomics in general and for work on economic cycles more specifically. The language barrier cannot be blamed as many of these works are in English Deletion of Béla Sipos WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15442 834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Alldredge User:Dhartung 05:13, 26 February 2008 (UTC) delete Wacky underdog campaigns may be , but they are not inherently notable Deletion of Bill Alldredge WP:INTERESTING Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15443 9885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alabama–Clemson football rivalry User:Quidster4040 23:04, 2 January 2019 (UTC) keep I think there is from reliable, third party sources (i.e. https://www.postandcourier.com/columnists/sapakoff-alabama-vs-clemson-is-the-best-top-level-football/article_fb3ee112-0d2a-11e9-aaa2-6b0222cc92f3.html 1, http://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/21931900/round-iv-alabama-crimson-tide-clemson-tigers-college-football-playoff-rivalry-bring-on 2, https://www.ncaa.com/video/football/2019-01-02/fbs-versus-cfp-clemson-alabama-national-championship 3, http://www.espn.com/video/clip?id=25659292 4, https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/colleges/alabama-oklahoma-tide-rolls-into-the-college-football-playoff-final-with-45-34-win/2018/12/29/7b7cfd38-0b90-11e9-85b6-41c0fe0c5b8f_story.html?utm_term=.312cb498dd5a 5) of the topic of the rivalry, but the coverage only seems to be |routine during the time of the College Football Playoff National Championship Deletion of Alabama–Clemson football rivalry WP:SIGCOV||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15444 17581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orioles-Pirates rivalry User:Dewelar 02:11, 19 August 2011 (UTC) delete """Not only do all these articles fail by a wide margin, there's nothing in any of these articles asserts the notability of these rivalries in any way -- indeed, they do not even assert the '''presence''' of a rivalry between the two teams. Heck, given the content of the articles, they could all simply be retitled """"List of cool things that happened in games between (x) and the Pirates"""", which, while it might be interesting, makes them nothing more than |lists of trivia""" Deletion of Orioles-Pirates rivalry WP:GNG||WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
15445 13248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riaz Afridi User:AssociateAffiliate 16:21, 25 July 2014 (UTC) keep possibly the worst ever cricket AfD ever! He's a Test cricketer, who played for his country in international matches at the highest level!!! Not to mention having a substantial domestic first-class career! Easily meets , , by extension Deletion of Riaz Afridi WP:CRIN||WP:ATH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15446 14122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crazy retarded guy User:Steel359 20:52, 26 June 2006 (UTC) delete per |Wikipedia is not YouTube Deletion of Crazy retarded guy WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15447 5195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sun Water Systems User:Ayub407 17:50, 15 September 2016 (UTC) delete Not at all notable. Fails and Deletion of Sun Water Systems WP:GNG||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15448 19632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FS (logic) User:Ravenmasterq 00:23, 29 July 2007 (UTC) delete Without references, the point seems moot. OR and fails , I would think Deletion of FS (logic) WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15449 11932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Whillians User:Guy 09:19, 14 May 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of David Whillians WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15450 14817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phupu Lamu Khatri User:Jersey92 03:44, 11 October 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and /N Deletion of Phupu Lamu Khatri WP:GNG||WP:WPMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
15451 6647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hugh Smith (news anchor) User:MichaelQSchmidt 21:42, 15 June 2009 (UTC) comment """The http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hugh_Smith_%28news_anchor%29&diff=296387732&oldid=296264419 removal of many sources toward have been repaired by the addition of 2 in-depth articles written of the subject by the two major newspapers in that area... the Tampa Tribune (http://www.burrellesluce.com/top100/2008_Top_100List.pdf #38 in the nations top 100 newspapers) and the St. Petersberg Times (http://www.burrellesluce.com/top100/2008_Top_100List.pdf #20 in the nation's top 100 newspapers). Their serving an area of nearly 3 million people http://recenter.tamu.edu/Data/popm/pm8280.htm, shows coverage to nearly 10% of the http://www.google.com/publicdata?ds=uspopulation&met=population&tdim=true&q=US+population U.S. population. Guideline does not mandate coverage to be national or international to be considered """"significant""""... and whether for """"just"""" 3 million or for 300 million, notability is notability. The subject meets and """ Deletion of Hugh Smith (news anchor) WP:V||WP:RS||WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15452 2920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William B. Roberts User:Eric 18:28, 19 February 2009 (UTC) delete Pass neither nor . In addition to the points made by Yobmod, independent news coverage http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22William+B+Roberts%22+composer seems to be nonexistent Deletion of William B. Roberts WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15453 17777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/La gauche User:Hut 10:20, 8 August 2007 (UTC) delete fails , school newspapers usually do Deletion of La gauche WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15454 19599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isabel S. Martinez User:Ohnoitsjamie 14:45, 27 June 2007 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability Deletion of Isabel S. Martinez WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15455 12501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of CAD editors for computer-aided engineering User:Shooterwalker 06:24, 11 August 2010 (UTC) merge reads like a |guide rather than an encyclopedia article and this topic or comparison also seems to be original research. Nothing to of the comparison of CAD editors, and so inappropriate to have an article outside the main CAD editor article Deletion of Comparison of CAD editors for computer-aided engineering WP:NOTGUIDE||WP:verifynotability Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15456 782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Baines User:Niteshift36 16:18, 23 March 2015 (UTC) delete Admittedly I didn't go through every listed source, but the ones I did check were usually mentions. The standard is ''significant'' coverage. Fails . I wouldn't oppose the redirect Deletion of Greg Baines WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15457 4501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jared Hyatt User:Borgarde 11:48, 4 April 2009 (UTC) keep Professional athlete as per who has played in a fully professional league Deletion of Jared Hyatt WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15458 9882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moustache May User:Dougofborg 15:18, 1 May 2009 (UTC) delete not , and unreferanced Deletion of Moustache May WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15459 10324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faizan Shaikh User:Alpha3031 05:57, 20 August 2018 (UTC) comment reply|Dial911}} I've looked at the Dawn and Express Tribune articles, and they appear to be passing mentions, concentrating more on the shows. Can you provide the |most significant mentions that you think contributes to ? I'll be withholding my !vote until someone evaluates the sources available Deletion of Faizan Shaikh WP:THREE||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15460 14249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Mayer User:Blue520 13:22, 10 April 2006 (UTC) delete WP:HOAX|Hoax. The only person who was not a posthumous teacher is Bertrand Russell (Arnold Sommerfeld|Sommerfeld died in 1951). Secondly there is a chance that it may fail Deletion of Alex Mayer WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15461 16907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle Frontier User:Zappernapper 19:35, 21 February 2007 (UTC) keep """article meets WP:N as a ''major'' change to the RSE lineup and significant plot line of the anime. The info is sourceable and verifiable, and ''does not give instruction'' (merely description - which is completely ok accoding to info at and ) therefore these claims of """"game-guide"""" are unfounded. I went through a few months ago and rm a lot of info that gave suggestions and strategy hints. A couple sentences throughout thew article could be removed becuase they specualate, and the anime section needs to be rewritten - but a large portion is fine and would constitute too large of a section to be properly merged""" Deletion of Battle Frontier WP:WAF||WP:RS Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
15462 20806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Belinda Ferrari User:David 20:08, 8 May 2018 (UTC) keep """17 years out from her Ph.D. is not """"early-career"""". Being early in one's career is not in itself a reason for deletion. The """"not senior author on any"""" claim is mistaken; she is first author on her second-most-cited paper, """"Microcolony cultivation on a soil substrate membrane system selects for previously uncultured soil bacteria"""". She has attracted significant media attention including a story in ''Newsweek'' for her research on antarctic air-eating bacteria http://www.newsweek.com/bizarre-antarctic-bacteria-live-air-alone-could-show-exactly-how-alien-life-742631 http://www.news.com.au/technology/science/space/bacteria-discovery-in-antarctica-prompts-rethink-of-humanitys-search-for-alien-life/news-story/29e6b683bea747a132ef5d1ececa1ae7?from=rss-basic https://cosmosmagazine.com/biology/air-eating-bacteria-found-in-antarctica; although this work is too new to have attracted many academic citations yet, I think it says something that it was published in ''Nature'' https://www.nature.com/articles/nature25014; she is last author, and the media stories call her """"senior author"""". And in general, her citation counts on Google Scholar look above threshold for #C1 to me""" Deletion of Belinda Ferrari WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15463 19978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiago Ghidotti NONE NONE delete The subject fails every point in , and is simply a promotional fluffed up article Deletion of Tiago Ghidotti WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15464 5155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rajesh Kumawat User:Bearian 15:15, 30 October 2019 (UTC) delete one of |thousands of local party officials and candidates Deletion of Rajesh Kumawat WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
15465 19266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Durga (1990 film) User:Dricherby 09:06, 26 May 2012 (UTC) delete No notability found. http://www.imdb.com/find?q=durga&s=all IMDB lists several films named Durga but none was released in 1990. OTOH, perhaps we're being ed — I wouldn't expect there to be many English-language sources on the web about a 20-year-old Tamil movie Deletion of Durga (1990 film) WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
15466 17623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Malisow User:One 20:50, 25 July 2007 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Craig Malisow WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15467 16643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raq n staxx User:Ydam 12:09, 3 June 2006 (UTC) delete per unverifiable and for things made up in university one day. It would appear that the rules are so simple they don't even have to be explained Deletion of Raq n staxx WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15468 7451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roy Moller User:Trident13 01:09, 23 January 2008 (UTC) delete fails . Rgds Deletion of Roy Moller WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15469 1860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herchel Smith Professorship of Pure Mathematics User:Jack 06:00, 21 April 2009 (UTC) keep per , , with non-trivial coverage in major news media (UK Telegraph & BBC NEWs) - also, as to notability, the bequest was the largest ever donated to the university Deletion of Herchel Smith Professorship of Pure Mathematics WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
15470 8711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ateneo Art Gallery User:Superastig 16:00, 15 June 2021 (UTC) keep The article needs some clean-up by removing anything promotional. Other than that, I managed to find some reliable sources about the museum. There's a https://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q=cache:SgSPs9HtyiUJ:scholar.google.com/+%22Ateneo+Art+Gallery%22&hl=en&as_sdt=0,5&as_vis=1 paper about the museum. It is discussed in a few books: https://books.google.com.ph/books?id=I6ifAAAAMAAJ&q=%22Ateneo+Art+Gallery%22+%22ZOBEL%22&dq=%22Ateneo+Art+Gallery%22+%22ZOBEL%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiLr5KgwpfxAhXWc94KHUqOBPQQ6AEwB3oECAsQAg and https://books.google.com.ph/books?id=IwANAQAAMAAJ&q=%22Ateneo+Art+Gallery%22+%22ZOBEL%22&dq=%22Ateneo+Art+Gallery%22+%22ZOBEL%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwikmofDwpfxAhWTdd4KHZ5jDuc4FBDoATAIegQICBAC. It is briefly described in https://books.google.com.ph/books?id=6_XVAAAAMAAJ&dq=%22Ateneo+Art+Gallery%22+%22ZOBEL%22&focus=searchwithinvolume&q=%22Ateneo+Art+Gallery%22 this book as the first museum of modern art in the country. It is also briefly discussed in https://books.google.com.ph/books?id=27ifAAAAMAAJ&q=%22Ateneo+Art+Gallery%22+%22ZOBEL%22&dq=%22Ateneo+Art+Gallery%22+%22ZOBEL%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiLr5KgwpfxAhXWc94KHUqOBPQQ6AEwBHoECAUQAg this book. With these, the article is good enough to pass Deletion of Ateneo Art Gallery WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15471 9000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disassociation/Association (relist nomination) User:Angusmclellan 20:26, 3 May 2006 (UTC) delete notability and verifiability are not all that's required; see Deletion of Disassociation/Association (relist nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15472 3022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fictional portrayals of psychopaths in film (2nd nomination) User:SirFozzie 00:35, 30 August 2007 (UTC) delete Unfortunately, it's and Well-written, but it's complete and utter Deletion of Fictional portrayals of psychopaths in film (2nd nomination) WP:USEFUL||WP:OR Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15473 11845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matzav (2nd nomination) User:Havradim 03:51, 30 October 2019 (UTC) delete and salt. This classic |coat rack article is ostensibly about an Israeli slang term or euphemism, yet it is somehow being classified under journalism. Note that the similar-but-encyclopedic term Nakba is redirected to 1948 Palestinian exodus; there is no comparable Israeli topic to redirect this to at present. Would be better suited to a Wiktionary or urban dictionary-type site, not an encyclopedia. The relevant background can already be found at Matzav.com Deletion of Matzav (2nd nomination) WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
15474 20096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Jordan Dorner User:Oknazevad 20:54, 9 February 2013 (UTC) merge per . It doesn't help that the page has devolved into a reproduction of his screed Deletion of Christopher Jordan Dorner WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15475 2975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mario Party 9 User:WilliamH 14:20, 24 May 2008 (UTC) delete It may certainly be so, that ''it is highly likely'' the game will be made, but until this is verifiable then firmly applies Deletion of Mario Party 9 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15476 3256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashleigh Townsend (2nd nomination) User:Papaursa 23:03, 6 May 2019 (UTC) delete I said at the first AfD discussion that he didn't meet or . A month later nothing has changed Deletion of Ashleigh Townsend (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15477 18911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christine Belle User:Capitalistroadster 02:24, 1 February 2006 (UTC) delete There is nothing in the article to indicate that she meets our |music notability guidelines Deletion of Christine Belle WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15478 5993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yu-Gi-Oh!: The Abridged Series User:Kunzite 01:12, 18 October 2006 (UTC) delete as mentioned before it doesn't pass . The target is a copyvio too. I think we have a policy against generally not linking to those in Deletion of Yu-Gi-Oh!: The Abridged Series WP:WEB||WP:EL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15479 14354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exscientologykids.com User:Scientizzle 20:43, 7 January 2011 (UTC) keep based on the cites present in the article satisfying ...and Jenna Miscavige Hill should be merged & redirected to this article. &mdash Deletion of Exscientologykids.com WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15480 2362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vivien Saunders User:Nigej 07:25, 8 May 2017 (UTC) keep Satisfies . Category 1: Competed in Curtis Cup. Category 3: Won Women's British Open. Category 5: Probably, need to check. Category 6: Played on the LPGA Tour. One of the leading British lady golfers of her era. Just because there's little about Women's golf on the internet is no reason to exclude her Deletion of Vivien Saunders WP:NGOLF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15481 9432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stable Micro Systems User:MuffledThud 14:02, 18 November 2009 (UTC) delete failes , also note : creator's name is also the name of a manager at the companyhttp://www.stablemicrosystems.com/press.htm Deletion of Stable Micro Systems WP:CORP||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
15482 12101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Schwartz (2nd nomination) User:Calton 05:47, 19 February 2013 (UTC) delete """Minor actor. If this meets , then that means the standard has been watered down to little more than """"has gotten a paycheck"""" and """"has a pulse"""". Let IMDB handle that""" Deletion of Aaron Schwartz (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15483 6413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/F. E. Zip Zimmerman User:Pmedema 16:02, 12 March 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and really dosen't have any usefull information. Obliteration is required Deletion of F. E. Zip Zimmerman WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15484 20233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Square One (1997 film) User:Lugnuts 07:19, 3 October 2019 (UTC) keep the film has won a couple of awards, at the San Diego Film Festival and the St. Kilda Film Festival, with some coverage https://www.smh.com.au/national/robert-herbert-filmmaker-with-encyclopaedic-knowledge-of-cinema-history-20170713-gxape9.html here and https://www.screenaustralia.gov.au/the-screen-guide/t/square-one-1997/7085/ to |verify that. {{ping|Dutchy85}} - do you have any more info? Thanks Deletion of Square One (1997 film) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15485 7703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Misty Plowright (2nd nomination) User:Instaurare 23:49, 25 November 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Misty Plowright (2nd nomination) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
15486 20893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valentina Nappi User:Rebecca1990 15:44, 4 January 2015 (UTC) keep """More than enough mainstream media coverage to satisfy . GNG also states """"Sources do not have to be available online or written in English."""" Раціональне анархіст insists he isn't a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Redban Redban ock puppet, but he has just added one more thing to his https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia%3ASockpuppet_investigations%2F%D0%A0%D0%B0%D1%86%D1%96%D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%B0%D0%BB%D1%8C%D0%BD%D0%B5_%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%B0%D1%80%D1%85%D1%96%D1%81%D1%82&diff=640844479&oldid=640831787 list of similarities with Redban, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia%3AArticles_for_deletion%2FRebeca_Linares&diff=637929079&oldid=637928418 these https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia%3AArticles_for_deletion%2FValentina_Nappi&diff=640908152&oldid=640906412 comments. Believing that foreign language sources aren't acceptable is not a common misconception among editors, so this is a very big coincidence""" Deletion of Valentina Nappi WP:GNG||WP:S Wikipedia:Notability 77
15487 3117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plural verbs with Elohim as God User:Nsk92 14:50, 7 July 2008 (UTC) delete Looks like an |OR essay Deletion of Plural verbs with Elohim as God WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
15488 10162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mrahccigam User:Toddst1 22:11, 12 March 2008 (UTC) delete WP:NN, Deletion of Mrahccigam WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
15489 14596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cellular respiration experiment User:Mikeblas 16:51, 13 January 2006 (UTC) keep I don't see anything about science projects at . See also :Category:Science experiments Deletion of Cellular respiration experiment WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15490 11509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pakistani Atheists & Agnostics User:Avenue 03:07, 14 August 2011 (UTC) delete No notability established per and/or . (I was just about to add this but Drmies beat me to it Deletion of Pakistani Atheists & Agnostics WP:ORG||WP:NGO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15491 3920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devoucoux (2nd nomination) User:Boston 22:20, 16 March 2009 (UTC) comment certainly |notability is not established but I suspect notability might actually exist. I'm going to try to rescue this one Deletion of Devoucoux (2nd nomination) Wikipedia:Notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
15492 18305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andres A Pena User:Carioca 03:51, 10 October 2009 (UTC) delete Non-notable player, fails and Deletion of Andres A Pena WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15493 2191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jenny Bae User:VQuakr 08:24, 20 July 2012 (UTC) keep per . Significant coverage http://www.asianpacificpost.com/article/electrifying-violinist-new-face-asian-music here and http://view.koreaherald.com/kh/view.php?ud=20090526000096&cpv=0 here provided the sources are regarded as reliable Deletion of Jenny Bae WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15494 4000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 Russian military intervention in Ukraine User:My 17:40, 11 August 2014 (UTC) comment Person who started this AfD was identified as a |sockpuppet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Sockpuppet_investigations/Constance_Lahaye here. This entire discussion is a violation of rules. Please close Deletion of 2014 Russian military intervention in Ukraine WP:SOCK Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
15495 7328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dangmattsmith User:Superastig 10:00, 7 February 2021 (UTC) delete Barely found anything about him. Per , having millions of subs does not make him notable Deletion of Dangmattsmith WP:ARBITRARY Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15496 847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RuPaul's Drag Race Season 3 User:Joal 12:44, 8 May 2010 (UTC) delete per . No prejudice in recreating the article when the program is actually broadcast and is subject to proper reference sources Deletion of RuPaul's Drag Race Season 3 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15497 11281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Memetic institutionalism User:Mikael_Sandberg 06:49, 3 November 2020 (UTC) delete The article has been created by the author himself Deletion of Memetic institutionalism WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
15498 8855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K. C. Armstrong User:Mangojuice 19:04, 1 May 2007 (UTC) delete with respect to Nowhitenoise for a good argument. The thing is, this is a |biography of a living person, not an article about a character on a show. As a character on a show, he's clearly important enough, but the article is a biography, and includes some rather negative claims with nothing to back them up. I actually think the guy might be notable enough for an article, but we need to find the reliable sources first and write the article after that Deletion of K. C. Armstrong WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15499 17983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Webindia master User:AllyD 20:03, 23 May 2014 (UTC) delete Promotional page for a firm offering ordinary wares (though I am intrigued by the idea of AltaVista search engine optimisation in this day and age). No |evidence of |notability Deletion of Webindia master :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15500 18961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leonard Barry Smith User:David 21:39, 29 March 2018 (UTC) delete Highly promotional with no actual evidence of notability through or other criteria Deletion of Leonard Barry Smith WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15501 8554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Day (2nd nomination) User:Cazort 01:01, 11 September 2011 (UTC) keep """I argued to delete in the first deletion discussion: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Alex_Day The majority of sources cited do not meet . The article needs serious cleanup. But I'm now convinced of notability because of the combination of: http://www.digitalspy.com/tv/s7/doctor-who/tubetalk/a158350/introducing-trock-songs-about-doctor-who.html, http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/07/26/brits-visit-walmart-find-_n_909671.html, and http://www.asylum.co.uk/2011/07/27/liam-alex-brits-wal-mart-video/, and the fact that http://www.wired.com/geekdad/2008/09/geekdad-hiptrax/?intcid=postnav identifies him as """"genre founder"""" -- I think this person was not notable during the last AfD but has since become notable""" Deletion of Alex Day (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15502 7528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jevan Snead (2nd nomination) User:Giants27 21:28, 25 April 2010 (UTC) keep Passes Deletion of Jevan Snead (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15503 2287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indira gandhi's 20 point program User:Williamborg 02:53, 4 September 2006 (UTC) delete mdash; '''Merge or Keep if & only if it undergoes a major rewrite''' - The topic meets ; a position by a major political figure is noteworthy. But it is almost assuredly a copyright violation unless released by the author or the Government of India, so needs to be summarized in an academic fashion. Attempted to rewrite it to salvage it but could NOT find independent material and was unable to confirm to my satisfaction that it is the work of Indira Ghandi. Does not meet Deletion of Indira gandhi's 20 point program WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
15504 8494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/German tank aces User:Peterkingiron 18:52, 9 October 2016 (UTC) merge """to Panzer ace to match text. The question of who counts as one is probably subjective, but if they are selected by an author, not as , I see no objection. """"in popular culture"""" normally means film etc and is not appropriate to a historical topic""" Deletion of German tank aces WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
15505 8760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vladan Đogatović User:Sir 23:29, 30 March 2011 (UTC) delete per nom. None of them have played in a fully pro league, and all of them fail Deletion of Vladan Đogatović WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15506 12044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vertcoin (3rd nomination) User:scope_creep 11:46, 1 January 2019 (UTC) delete All the work above describes exactly in terms that are entirely generic to other 100's of cryptocurrencies that exist, and have no special meaning outside those cryptocurrency companies. The premise seems to be based on the tweak to their algo to favour GPU's, isn't enough for standalone notability, as the reason for the high cost of NVidia cards is due to the miners emptying the shelves, and Vertcoin arent the only cryptocoin company that favours GPU's, against FPGA or ASIC's. So a solid Delete by Deletion of Vertcoin (3rd nomination) WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15507 2224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adify User:Steve NONE merge """to Cox Media Group. This topic is not historically significant. It is another startup or youngish company that was bought by a larger company. This is business as usual. Also, just because there is coverage in publications like The New York Times and The Washington Post does not mean this topic is notable. Both of these published articles are small business announcements and do not qualify as sources. The coverage is routine business announcements with a quote from a company source - a senior vice president . The other sources mentioned do the same. Coverage in these so-called """"news"""" articles rely only on company executives for information. This is not independent coverage as required when using |reliable sources to determine notability""" Deletion of Adify WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15508 13837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roomy Pak User:Chris 01:51, 17 June 2020 (UTC) delete Subject fails . Another case where article author {{u|Mitzi.humphrey}} included herself in the article but never made the required CoI disclosure. The citations are content Mitzi wrote, or mere mentions Deletion of Roomy Pak WP:NARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
15509 16178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Gudenus User:Alison 22:35, 29 October 2009 (UTC) delete I think he's marginally notable, per but this article will always suffer from issues and I don't think we'll ever be in a position to balance it out. Rght now, it seems to only exist to say 'zOMG holocaust denier!!' and little else Deletion of John Gudenus WP:POLITICIAN||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15510 14518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jasmine Murray User:Fritzpoll 17:04, 12 March 2009 (UTC) delete or '''redirect''' to American Idol (season 8). Whilst the nomination appears a little pointed, I think these should be discussed on the same grounds as the participants at Alexis Grace mentioned. A lack of notability beyond the ''single event'' (per ) of being in American Idol. WikiProject precedents or standards are irrelevant in comparison to our own policies - we already have an article covering the event, so individual articles can be merged there if there is any additional material, in which case a redirect should take place Deletion of Jasmine Murray WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15511 2137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan McGillivray User:LlamaAl 16:58, 20 December 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Ryan McGillivray WP:MMANOT||WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
15512 6376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Webbed Feet UK User:MB 18:53, 25 June 2016 (UTC) delete fails , WP is not a business directory. Not notable, one of tens of thousands of businesses Deletion of Webbed Feet UK WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15513 8757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Fraternities and Sororities at Southern Miss User:JimMillerJr 18:44, 24 July 2008 (UTC) keep A list of notable organizations with local chapters at a notable institution. There isn't a redlink on the page. I also see no policy based cause for deletion. Seems to be a list organized by theme in accordance with . The existance of each organization at this campus may need citations for verification, but that is a cleanup issue, not grounds for an AfD. The list is discriminate, entirely composed of notable entities, and useful Deletion of List of Fraternities and Sororities at Southern Miss WP:LISTS Wikipedia:Lists 97
15514 1891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MediaShout User:EEMIV 14:23, 23 September 2008 (UTC) delete not-notable, |unreferenced Deletion of MediaShout WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15515 21197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adajja User:Glenfarclas 21:51, 14 January 2010 (UTC) delete She does indeed fail |PORNBIO, as her three AVN nominations are from the same year (and for the same movie). A search in the GNews finds nothing, and I don't see any other significant coverage Deletion of Adajja WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15516 20740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Martin (boxer) User:Jakejr 02:58, 28 December 2014 (UTC) comment I believe we have agreement--it boils down to whether or not you believe a junior/youth competitor is notable if they meet the same conditions as an adult/senior competitor. I believe there is ample precedent to show they've not been considered that in the past. This has been discussed several times at and never have things like the Youth Olympics been agreed upon as showing sufficient notability. The most recent discussion I found was at Wikipedia talk:Notability (sports)/Archive 13#Youth_Olympics. I also found AFD discussions of martial artists who won medals at the Youth Olympics--they were also deleted (see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antonia Katheder and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Davit Ghazaryan). Since Martin didn't even compete at the Youth Olympics, much less win a medal, I don't believe he meets Deletion of Ryan Martin (boxer) WP:NSPORT||WP:NBOX Wikipedia:Notability 77
15517 7590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aldebaran in fiction User:Sangrolu 16:04, 12 April 2011 (UTC) keep per Random Critic amd Dravecky. The mass nomination seems heavy handed and indiscriminate to me. Per you should really make good faith attempts to establish notability for each; I don't think that's been done here. Each can be re-evaluated, some may need better referenced or pruned and thereafter merged back into the main article Deletion of Aldebaran in fiction WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15518 18099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Decred User:Preaky 01:33, 24 November 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Decred WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15519 17792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blitz Identity Provider User:FeatherPluma 21:20, 15 April 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Blitz Identity Provider WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15520 17575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abraham Reuel User:Qrsdogg 23:58, 8 May 2011 (UTC) keep Sourcing isn't great, but between http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=CmQzAAAAIBAJ&sjid=FusFAAAAIBAJ&pg=2218,1623147&dq=karl-heinz-schneider+hitler&hl=en this newspaper article and http://books.google.com/books?id=PqFVRQV-Bb0C&lpg=PP1&ots=rEDAwgO7If&dq=a%20treasury%20of%20jewish%20anecdotes&pg=PA5#v=onepage&q&f=false this book source I think is reached, albeit not by much Deletion of Abraham Reuel WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15521 6137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delta Humane Society & SPCA User:Cavalryman 04:28, 24 August 2020 (UTC) delete per nom, the few press mentions described above fail and I could find nothing else Deletion of Delta Humane Society & SPCA WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
15522 4379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bachelor in Homoeopathic Medicine & Surgery User:Wikicology 02:17, 18 May 2015 (UTC) delete Sadly, no evidence of |notability Deletion of Bachelor in Homoeopathic Medicine & Surgery WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15523 10588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frosty the Dopeman User:Gongshow 21:30, 17 August 2017 (UTC) delete I'm not finding any significant coverage to demonstrate that this meets or Deletion of Frosty the Dopeman WP:GNG||WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15524 20518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nate Barcalow User:Ponyo 20:40, 22 October 2010 (UTC) merge as he has not performed any notable (by Wikipedia standards) work outside of Finch (American band)|Finch, the article can simply be redirected to the band as advised at Deletion of Nate Barcalow WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15525 1981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of international goals scored by Abby Wambach User:Harrias 17:33, 13 April 2013 (UTC) keep although the article is clearly in a bad way, breaching a number of our manual of style article, that is irrelevant when determining notability. The parent article is long enough that to add this list onto it would not be viable, and it is my belief that given the extraordinary number of goals that she has scored, and that |Wikipedia is not a paper encyclopaedia this is a justified standalone list Deletion of List of international goals scored by Abby Wambach WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15526 14227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anwar Knight (2nd nomination) User:benlisquare 03:10, 11 October 2009 (UTC) delete Fails , , , , Deletion of Anwar Knight (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:V||WP:N||WP:BIO||WP:OR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15527 14854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of inventions shown on American Inventor User:Douglasr007 09:09, 4 August 2007 (UTC) delete This is ''exactly'' what I said when someone brought up making a list of this on the Bulletball AfD. The list fails #INFO and . I've said this from the start Deletion of List of inventions shown on American Inventor WP:NOT||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15528 1593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disappearance of Joanna Yeates User:ResidentAnthropologist 23:13, 29 December 2010 (UTC) keep We can revisit this in a few months to examine enduring notability is hard to judge at the moment of the NEWS. I suspect greater weight for aruements once coverage is slopps off Deletion of Disappearance of Joanna Yeates WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15529 13877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kurt Wagner (musician) User:Schuym1 21:48, 29 October 2008 (UTC) keep Passes Deletion of Kurt Wagner (musician) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15530 7468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Way Out Record for Children User:Faithlessthewonderboy 09:46, 8 April 2008 (UTC) keep If Bruce Haack is indeed notable, then an LP released by him is probably notable enough per (the operative word here being ''if''). Yes it's a poor article, but that is not a reason to delete Deletion of The Way Out Record for Children WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15531 5460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fetu User:Bearian 15:22, 29 June 2021 (UTC) delete as a or redirect Deletion of Fetu WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
15532 20270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A A Baig & Co., Chartered Accountants User:Blaxthos 14:11, 1 July 2007 (UTC) delete Spammy goodness (|SPA/|COI diatribe not withstanding Deletion of A A Baig & Co., Chartered Accountants WP:SPA||WP:COI Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
15533 4740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parent revocation User:Yunshui 09:11, 24 September 2012 (UTC) delete I actually deleted an earlier version of this owing to its hefty copyright violation of http://www.cde.ca.gov/sp/se/lr/om010609.asp this letter, not to mention violating , , , and . This version is no better. The author seems determined to push their article into Wikipedia (I've just reported them at ANI for issuing a legal threat on their talk page in response to the last deletion of it), and clearly |isn't here for any constructive purpose Deletion of Parent revocation WP:SOAP||WP:NOTREPOSITORY||WP:NOTMANUAL||WP:ESSAY||WP:OR||WP:NOTHERE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15534 2590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rod Allen Drinking Game User:Bschott 17:20, 8 August 2006 (UTC) comment Sorry, 69.241.235.195, but I struck your last keep because you have already had your say. Also, Unregistered or new users are welcome to contribute to the discussion, but their recommendations may be discounted, especially if they seem to be made in bad faith (for example, if they misrepresent their reasons). Conversely, the opinions of logged in users whose accounts predate the article's AfD nomination are given more weight. (what was per the page Deletion of Rod Allen Drinking Game WP:AFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15535 19483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Big Lebowski in popular culture User:Erik 15:33, 6 July 2007 (UTC) delete per nominator's argument. Completely unsourced article pieced together by editors' |firsthand observations, not to mention that the entries are not notable as a result of mentioning ''The Big Lebowski'' in passing or in some context. It's just trivia Deletion of The Big Lebowski in popular culture WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
15536 4465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Neill User:TripleRoryFan 11:05, 10 February 2018 (UTC) comment I don't know exactly when a subject is considered to pass so I'm not going to vote. As far as I can tell there are two non-trivial mentions of Neill online are http://www.espncricinfo.com/ireland/content/player/302056.html here (his Cricinfo profile which just has his basic details and the matches he's umpired) and http://www.cricketireland.ie/news/article/irish-umpires-named-on-icc-panel here (which just explains that he became a member of the ICC Associate & Affiliate Panel of International Umpires for 2016), but I don't know whether or not those two pages (which are already used as refs in the article) are enough to say it passes GNG Deletion of Alan Neill WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15537 7719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Air Hawke's Bay User:Unscintillating 14:01, 29 October 2011 (UTC) comment """nbsp; A healthy deletion discussion needs to understand eletion policy and the eletion policy#Alternatives to deletion section therein . As per eletion policy, """"Deletion of a Wikipedia article removes the current version and all previous versions from public view."""" This is an outcome for extreme cases, where both the material and the topic are objectionable, which is not the case here. says,Disputes over page content are usually not dealt with by deleting the page, except in severe cases....Deletion discussions that are really unresolved content disputes may be closed by an uninvolved editor, and referred to the talk page or other appropriate forum""" Deletion of Air Hawke's Bay WP:D||WP:D||WP:D||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
15538 16529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marvin Harris (inventor) User:Doc 19:34, 16 October 2009 (UTC) delete notable for a |solitary - and non-notable - event. The claim that the subject of the article was the inventor of the transistor radio had a source, but it was removed as it was not reliable Deletion of Marvin Harris (inventor) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15539 16112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spacing User:Houseboater 23:46, 18 March 2008 (UTC) delete per nom; #OR also Deletion of Spacing WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15540 66 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Uluslararası Kıbrıs Üniversitesi Atatürkçü Düşünce Kulübü Kullanıcı:tembelejderhatembelejderha 06:04, 3 Ağustos 2006 (UTC) delete Bkz. Maddeler 6 --User:renegade|'''renegade'''User_Talk:renegade|''msj Uluslararası Kıbrıs Üniversitesi Atatürkçü Düşünce Kulübü'nün silinmesi Vikipedi:HS Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15541 20442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antifa apocalypse User:Mangoe 14:59, 7 November 2017 (UTC) delete as bog-std. example of Deletion of Antifa apocalypse WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15542 4142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Lewis (Audio Engineer) User:Wikipedian2 15:53, 15 April 2011 (UTC) delete As per verifiability Deletion of Mark Lewis (Audio Engineer) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15543 1596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abd-Allah ibn Rawahah User:Jersey 06:50, 16 March 2006 (UTC) delete one sentence article that does not meet (no sources) and doesn't really establish notablility Deletion of Abd-Allah ibn Rawahah WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15544 7924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cliff's Amusement Park User:Ansh666 21:10, 13 August 2014 (UTC) keep The others are correct. Sufficient coverage to pass . While Deletion of Cliff's Amusement Park WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15545 2396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wikipedia community User:JoshuaZ 00:12, 11 March 2007 (UTC) comment Could you explain what {WP:OR|original research is in the article? Also, as I have pointed out before is a style issue, it says nothing about not having well-sourced, well-cited articles like Wikipedia and Jimbo Wales Deletion of Wikipedia community WP:SELF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
15546 6927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Life Within A Day User:Gongshow 06:00, 4 June 2012 (UTC) keep per Arxiloxos; there appears to be sufficient coverage in the above links to warrant an article (meeting Deletion of A Life Within A Day WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15547 13961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Playing Away User:Stifle 19:00, 14 May 2008 (UTC) delete As there is just one |reliable source |cited and it is a minor mention, I am persuaded that the article does not comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Playing Away WP:RS||WP:CITE||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15548 10607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SmoothVideo Project User:Dialectric 15:44, 22 August 2016 (UTC) delete Software article of unclear notability, lacking independent references. Refs provided are from the developers or forum posts. A search turned up no significant coverage. Article was created by an Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|SPA as possibly promotional Deletion of SmoothVideo Project WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15549 10605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clean Sadness User:Daniel 05:38, 26 November 2007 (UTC) delete does not appear to meet Deletion of Clean Sadness WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15550 18770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Peoples Republic Of Katanga User:MER 09:33, 23 December 2006 (UTC) delete WP:NFT. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=%22The+Peoples+Republic+Of+Katanga%22&btnG=Search Zero ghits, fails Deletion of The Peoples Republic Of Katanga WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15551 2429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slum (film) (2nd nomination) User:MichaelQSchmidt 09:25, 8 June 2014 (UTC) keep brand new article on released film that has enough coverage in reliable sources to meet . Sure, it was initially poorly sourced when first nominated, but when |they ARE available that is not a #REASON|deletion criteria, nor are the issues of an early different topic by this same name to be visited upon this new film article. We have |solutions that do not mandate a deletion Deletion of Slum (film) (2nd nomination) WP:NF||WP:NRVE||WP:DEL||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
15552 15005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asia Without Borders User:MelanieN 15:22, 12 February 2011 (UTC) delete Zero coverage found, although the phrase has been used many times in other contexts http://news.google.com/archivesearch?&as_src=-newswire+-wire+-presswire+-PR+-release+-wikipedia&q=%22Asia+Without+Borders%22. I'm sure this is a worthy project, but it simply isn't |notable by Wikipedia's criteria Deletion of Asia Without Borders WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15553 18862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg M. Sarwa User:Qworty 05:04, 27 October 2012 (UTC) delete for failing and Deletion of Greg M. Sarwa WP:AUTHOR||WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
15554 21168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sudanese goat marriage incident (2nd nomination) User:Edison 19:09, 23 July 2008 (UTC) delete """This was a """"water-cooler"""" story or humorous filler for newscasts, and a mild """"internet phenomenon. The """"obituary"""" was described as a joke, and the naming """"Rose"""" was described as a joke. This is not a jokebook. Per #NEWS """"Wikipedia considers the historical notability of persons and events. News coverage can be useful source material for encyclopedic topics, but not all events warrant an encyclopedia article of their own."""" Per the earlier essay NEWS, """"News organizations have different criteria for their content than the criteria used by encyclopedias. A violent crime, sensationalized event or accidental death may be notable enough to reporters and news editors to justify coverage in the news, but not be of encyclopedic importance."""" This was sensational and humorous to some, but was a one-off with no demonstrated lasting importance""" Deletion of Sudanese goat marriage incident (2nd nomination) WP:NOT||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15555 10756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nana Boakye-Yiadom (footballer) User:GiantSnowman 10:55, 4 April 2021 (UTC) keep player actually has https://www.soccerbase.com/players/player.sd?player_id=75856&season_id=144 4 apps for a professional club, meeting NFOOTBALL by some way - and has ongoing career, albeit at a lower level. Article needs improving, not deleting. clearly not complied with, again Deletion of Nana Boakye-Yiadom (footballer) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15556 19518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brad Hammett User:Resolute 01:41, 30 December 2013 (UTC) delete """per nom. As noted, there is no such thing as a """"AAA"""" or """"AA"""" league in hockey, so please don't waste our time trying to pass the ECHL's marketing pap off as a sign of notability. Beyond that, it is notable that Dolovis is trying to bank on an arbitrary SNG that only ''presumes'' notability rather than showing the existence of |reliable sources that cover the subject in a non-trivial manner. There is no indication that the presumption of notability is warranted in this case""" Deletion of Brad Hammett WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15557 11596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nutri Ventures – The Quest for the 7 Kingdoms User:Nabla 16:40, 10 May 2014 (UTC) comment """First, note that I couldn't care less if this gets deleted or promoted to featured article status (well, I'd be more likely to delete than to promote) Second, yes, I am portuguese, but I have never eared of this before. The comment is: How is this different from the gazillions of TV series that have articles? Sometimes, many-times, articles per episode! (and yes I am aware of , but I guess that """"not popular in the US"""" is not a good argument either, is it? :) This has at least one strong reference in the media: http://expresso.sapo.pt/nutri-ventures-encontra-se-com-michelle-obama=f831281 ''Nutri Ventures encontra-se com Michelle Obama'' (''Nutri Ventures meets Michelle Obama''), Expresso (Portuguese newspaper) is one of the main Portuguese newspapers, the show made the news there, some people from the team met Michelle Obama, and it is (according to the reference) aired in 23 countries. I think we have awaaay too many TV series' articles, but I can't figure why, by WP's standards, this is to be deleted""" Deletion of Nutri Ventures – The Quest for the 7 Kingdoms WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15558 20271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacewon User:Esradekan 09:20, 1 May 2008 (UTC) delete WP:MUSIC, Deletion of Jacewon WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
15559 10166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vornado Air Circulation Systems User:Reyk 00:21, 23 August 2008 (UTC) delete I can find nothing to indicate notability except some stuff about a petty legal dispute with another company. http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/NewsSearch?st=Vornado%20Air%20Circulation%20Systems%20Inc. This is particularly telling. There's lots of companies in the world. Most, including this one, just aren't |notable Deletion of Vornado Air Circulation Systems WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15560 7995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Claudia Florentino User:Number 15:17, 2 January 2021 (UTC) delete per failure Deletion of Claudia Florentino WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15561 13305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Pussy Bonpensiero User:Hunter 15:34, 20 December 2019 (UTC) keep I understand the inclination to bring articles like this to AFD, since they are largely just plot summary. But I feel like much of the time if just a cursory search for sources is done, it's easy to establish |notability, and in the case of this character in particular I think he ''does'' satisfy . There are a great deal of books that analyze ''The Sopranos'' from a critical perspective, and with just a little bit of minor searching I was able to find several that discuss this character. For example, the book ''Sopranos and Philosophy: I Kill Therefore I Am'' discusses how the character reflects mob culture, and how his act of betrayal runs counter to that culture; and the book ''Tony Soprano's America: Gangsters, Guns, and Money'' discusses how Tony's feelings about Bonpensiero's death reflect the recurring feelings of guilt Tony occasionally feels for actions, and also has some interesting discussions about how the way Bonpensiero manifests himself in visions and dream sequences post-death are some of the show's strongest examples of postmodernism. Those are just a few examples, there are more. And there are a number of news articles that discuss the character as well; one strong example I found very quickly is this https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2012/04/sopranos-oral-history oral history by Variety which discusses how the cast and crew of the show had issues with the way this character was killed off, and how it affected production of the show afterward. These are just a few examples of |reliable sources that help establish notability here. The problem here isn't that the article needs to be ''deleted''; it needs to be ''improved''. I'd love to try to do so myself during the AFD process to help demonstrate that notability, as I've done in the past and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bantha (2nd nomination)|am currently doing on other pages, but especially with the holidays and all I just don't think I'll have the time. But |there is no deadline for such improvements to be made, so in the meantime I believe the article should be kept Deletion of Big Pussy Bonpensiero WP:N||WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15562 16614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timothy Smart User:Jbhunley 18:21, 9 May 2015 (UTC) delete not Merge Ambassadors have no inherent notability. Not enough coverage in |reliable sources to |verify or |sustain an article. Does not pass or Deletion of Timothy Smart WP:RS||WP:V||WP:NRV||WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15563 10468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christina Gough User:RebeccaGreen 06:19, 12 July 2019 (UTC) keep """I don't understand the exclusion in #4 of women's Regional Finals. If it was a men's Regional Final of a Twenty20 International match, she would be presumed notable. Despite the fact that Women's Twenty20 International says """"In April 2018, the ICC granted full Women's Twenty20 International (WT20I) status to all its members. Therefore, all Twenty20 matches played between two international sides after 1 July 2018 will be a full WT20I"""", has somehow decided that some women's Twenty20 matches played between two international sides do not meet Wikipedia standards""" Deletion of Christina Gough WP:NCRICK||WP:NCRICK Wikipedia:Notability 77
15564 3084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evolution of cooperation User:Colonel 19:10, 11 May 2013 (UTC) keep The nominator's user page hasn't been deleted; I suppose he just hasn't created one. Anyway, the arguments for deletion are either false or not in accordance with our editing policies of and . |AFD is not cleanup Deletion of Evolution of cooperation WP:IMPERFECT||WP:PRESERVE||WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
15565 16778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denise Lester User:Ttonyb1 15:59, 7 April 2010 (UTC) comment ndash; please explain how this meets the criteria in Deletion of Denise Lester WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15566 18372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boraq Tower User:Snottywong 02:03, 3 December 2009 (UTC) delete per . If the building ever starts construction, the article can be re-created Deletion of Boraq Tower WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15567 335 [[RedDot]] (bleibt) Benutzer:JohnnyB 20:07, 10. Okt. 2008 (CEST) keep Bei der Aussage nach den Relevanzkriterien stellt sich die Frage, welche Relevanzkriterien betrachtet werden: Betrachtet man die #Wirtschaftsunternehmen|Relevanzkriterien für Wirtschaftsunternehmen, ist eine Löschantrag gemäß Mitarbeiterzahl eventuell gerechtfertigt (Mitarbeiterzahl ~ 200, Umsatz nicht angegeben). Betrachtet man allerdings den Punkt ''bei einer relevanten Produktgruppe oder Dienstleistung eine marktbeherrschende Stellung oder innovative Vorreiterrolle haben (unabhängige Quelle erforderlich)'' ist der Löschgrund anzuzweifeln, da RedDot im Bereich von kommerziellen Web-Content-Management-Systemen durchaus eine wichtige Rolle spielt (Siehe Gartner Inc.|Gartner-Studie: http://www.produkt-global.de/news/2/03b0393c77d.html RedDot erhält Bestnote von Gartner, http://www.contentmanager.net/magazine/news_h23284_reddot_receives_positive_rating_in_gartners_wcm.html RedDot Receives Positive Rating in Gartner's WCM MarketScope Report). Worauf ich eigentlich hinaus will: RedDot stellt in diesem Artikel einerseits das Unternehmen dar, andererseits die Produkte, sprich Content-Management-Systeme. Daher gelten auch die Wikipedia:Richtlinien Software|Relevanzkriterien für Software. Und danach ist der Artikel durchaus relevant. Man betrachte nur einmal die Artikel in der Kategorie :Kategorie:Web-Content-Management-System|Web-Content-Management-System. Dort gibt es reichlich Artikel, deren Relevanz anzuzweifeln sind, da keinerlei Angaben über die Verbreitung etc. angegeben sind. Freeware / OpenSource CMS sind wohl von Relevanzkriterien ausgenommen oder wie? Eine Einarbeitung bei Open Text halte ich für nicht sinnvoll, da die Produkte unter RedDot und nicht Open Text bekannt sind. Weitere Indizien für die Relevanz, sind Artikel in anderssprachingen Wikipedia-Artikeln Löschung von RedDot Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
15568 21274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Masuran User:Tohd8BohaithuGh1 15:07, 2 November 2008 (UTC) delete violation of |MUSIC, |conflict of interest and ancruft|Fancruft Deletion of Masuran WP:MUSIC||WP:COI||WP:F Wikipedia:Notability 77
15569 6969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alipio Ponce User:Necrothesp 15:08, 7 August 2017 (UTC) keep This does appear to be an official status conferred by the state by individual legislation on a fairly small number of individuals and entails reburial in the Crypt of the Heroes in Lima. I think it definitely meets the criteria of both and #1 Deletion of Alipio Ponce WP:SOLDIER||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15570 3879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IBM 1130/snoopy calendar User:Work 17:05, 6 May 2007 (UTC) keep Sometimes you have to . This is part of computing history. Agree it's not well sourced but of course this was before email and ftp Deletion of IBM 1130/snoopy calendar WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
15571 20332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russ Dalbey User:Rileybuddha 13:57, 4 June 2007 (UTC) delete fails , , . The subject of this obvious infomercial adspam has oodles of Google hits to various bucketshop make-$-now websites, but in five minutes of perusing I couldn't find a single hit to a reliable, unbiased source. There's an assertion that he trained with the Olympic cycling team, but after directed searches I couldn't find any verification of that, or reference to for what group or college he may have raced competitively. This article is the sole Wikipedia activity of Deletion of Russ Dalbey WP:SPAM||WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Spam 112
15572 8193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keith Abbis User:Kosack 07:32, 28 January 2018 (UTC) keep The source provided (although requiring subscription) supports that he passes having played in a fully professional league. In any case, I've added more sources that don't require subscription to support that Deletion of Keith Abbis WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15573 14149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hayze User:Daniel 03:03, 20 August 2006 (UTC) delete Looking at , they don't quite make the cut Deletion of Hayze WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15574 7011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Gill (football manager) User:GiantSnowman 09:03, 30 October 2018 (UTC) delete fails and . {{ping|Abcmaxx}} interpretation of NFOOTBALL is just wrong. The LOI is not a |fully-pro league Deletion of John Gill (football manager) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15575 12351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Haque User:Coretheapple 16:13, 9 October 2013 (UTC) delete Even if the subject hadn't requested deletion, this article simply doesn't meet Deletion of Nick Haque WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15576 20528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Connecticut workplace shooting User:Patsw 04:39, 5 August 2010 (UTC) keep plus . To answer the nominator's question: some murders are encyclopedic entries, like this one: Colin Ferguson (convict) from 17 years ago, and so should this article Deletion of 2010 Connecticut workplace shooting WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
15577 9778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Semi-Royal Shakespeare Company User:Agent 17:18, 17 November 2006 (UTC) delete per Andrew Lenahan; however, I would hate to see the article deleted based on the draft guideline, which I believe to be quite deficient and ought not be relied upon in its current state Deletion of The Semi-Royal Shakespeare Company WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15578 3839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Incarceration Rate, Military Spending, and Surveillance among the World Superpowers User:ZimZalaBim 18:43, 7 December 2008 (UTC) delete as |original research. AfD could possibly be simply combined with Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Surveillance and Incarceration in the U.S., Russia, and China Deletion of Incarceration Rate, Military Spending, and Surveillance among the World Superpowers WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
15579 14246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Descent from antiquity User:Wikishagnik 02:53, 12 June 2012 (UTC) delete A lot of confusion in the above comments but broadly this article falls in the category of . A lot of conclusions and broad announcements made without any reference to a reliable source. The oroginal premise and all conclusions of this article seems to be that of the contributors Deletion of Descent from antiquity WP:ORIGINAL Wikipedia:No original research 65
15580 15933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Rovics (2nd nomination) User:Michig 15:07, 3 October 2020 (UTC) keep Sufficient coverage exists to satisfy , e.g. https://www.stuff.co.nz/ipad-editors-picks/9055435/Radical-musician-barred-on-way-to-Nelson-gig, https://www.popmatters.com/david-rovics-halliburton-boardroom-massacre-2496179507.html, https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=vwzvCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA153&dq=%22David+Rovics%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiN46-V15jsAhWRoVwKHWNzD_8Q6AEwAnoECAYQAg#v=onepage&q=%22David%20Rovics%22&f=false, https://www.allmusic.com/album/for-the-moment-mw0000250598, https://folkworks.org/reviews/folkworks-cd-dvd-reviews/40588-david-rovics-meanwhile-in-afghanistan Deletion of David Rovics (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15581 10280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/8 Strategies to Having a Great Website User:Red 22:28, 7 August 2011 (UTC) delete Guide/how-to, Deletion of 8 Strategies to Having a Great Website WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15582 6828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hugo Meira User:IJA 10:24, 26 September 2014 (UTC) delete He hasn't played in a Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|Fully professional league and he doesn't have any senior international caps either therefore he fails Deletion of Hugo Meira WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15583 5654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ralph Holden User:Fenix 09:04, 29 March 2016 (UTC) keep Passes |NFOOTY, has played in a |fully professional league or in a match in the competition proper (i.e. not qualifying rounds) of a cup competition which involved two teams both from FPLs. |Article size is not a valid reason for deletion Deletion of Ralph Holden WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:ASZ Wikipedia:Notability 77
15584 8716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Intellicus Technologies User:Abecedare 04:25, 13 February 2010 (UTC) delete Company doesn't satisfy standard of notability (the only distinctions seems to be the 'Red Herring 100 Asia finalist 2008' and shortlisted in 'NASSCOM IT Innovation Award 2007', which are not sufficient). The article is unambigious advertisement, which is not surprising given that it is largely a copyvio of the http://www.intellicus.com/redherring-hongkong.html company's press release. Arguably speedyable, but may as well let the AfD run its course now that it has started Deletion of Intellicus Technologies WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15585 1545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Way of a Man with a Maid User:Pablomismo 20:47, 15 October 2009 (UTC) keep This article badly needs rewriting, but there seems to be enough sourcing. |WP:ZOMG!!!!!VICTORIANPR0N!!! is not in itself a valid reason to delete. Deletion of The Way of a Man with a Maid WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15586 3417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mandalasana User:APerson 13:38, 28 April 2015 (UTC) delete per |NOTMANUAL Deletion of Mandalasana WP:NOTMANUAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15587 233 [[Wolkenkratzerdorf]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers NONE delete Kasten|1= gemäß Diskussion. Typischer Fall von |Theoriefindung. Den Begriff gibt es, aber er ist nach allen Internetfundstellen ein scherzhafter Spitzname für Bad Gastein. Zu allem anderen (allgemeine Defintion eines Wolkenkratzerdorfes, Stotel und Siegendorf als Beispiel) gibt es aber weder einen Beleg im Artikel, noch Fundstellen in google und google books. Damit als Artikel nicht haltbar. Maximal könnte ich mir eine Weiterleitung zu Bad Gastein vorstellen, wobei es fraglich ist, wie verbreitet und relevant so ein Spitzname wirklich ist. Gruß Löschung von Wolkenkratzerdorf Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
15588 5070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orange paper reading User:Nsk92 14:54, 14 May 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. Nothing to show notability per . The article lists a single reference which is a broken linkhttp://bellcreek.org/studentministries%7C Deletion of Orange paper reading WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15589 1114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Welsh Conference Junior League User:The 02:55, 13 December 2017 (UTC) keep We generally keep articles on ''leagues'', as a sporting competition's governing/organising body is generally notable. There is a lack of prose, but |that's for improvement, not deletion. Now, given this is a ''junior'' competition, there is the possiblity of merging to South Wales Premiership, the adult league it is apparently affiliated with, if sourcing cannot be found Deletion of Welsh Conference Junior League WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15590 21555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Entry clearance [[User talk:Lambiam|Lambiam]] 01:00, 12 August 2011 (UTC) comment I don't understand in what sense or respect Entry clearance is to be considered |original research, a |neologism, or lacking |reliable sources. It would seem to me that the web page referred to in the article, which is a page published by the UK Border Agency of the Home Office, can be considered a reliable source with regard to entry requirements of the UK, and the terminology and information in the article are in close agreement with that provided on that web page. Deletion of Entry clearance WP:original research||WP:neologism||WP:reliable sources Wikipedia:No original research 65
15591 15524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Fadil (2nd nomination) User:HM NONE delete He has a lot of film credits. But roles may not be notable. Does not meet . No significant secondary RS coverage whatsoever. No real notability established, may be a case of TOOSOON Deletion of Tony Fadil (2nd nomination) WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15592 19908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OnRPG Forum User:LrdChaos 19:41, 7 April 2006 (UTC) delete Does not meet . &mdash Deletion of OnRPG Forum WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
15593 20063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Wilson (ice hockey) User:Papaursa 16:32, 6 May 2017 (UTC) delete Fails both and Deletion of Anthony Wilson (ice hockey) WP:NHOCKEY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15594 12894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Menwhopause User:Beeblbrox 20:10, 3 July 2008 (UTC) keep I don't see how they fail |notability guidelines for musicians, and the nom is not very explicit. Frankly, a rock band from India being invited to play the South by Southwest festival seems pretty darn notable to me Deletion of Menwhopause WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15595 9041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elisa Bernerström User:Zeborah 23:05, 28 December 2007 (UTC) comment """Someone has just added a line to the article asserting notability in that """"She is one of two confirmed women to have been decorated for bravery in battle in Sweden before the 1900s."""" I don't know the source of the """"two confirmed women"""" part, but even if this phrasing were deleted, the original source does say she was decorated for bravery in battle (""""Med anledning av detta tilldelades hon medaljen för tapperhet i fält."""") Certainly many women have fought in wartime but few indeed, particularly in such an era, have been decorated for it, and this seems a reasonable fact on which to base notability: see """"The person has received significant recognized awards or honors""" Deletion of Elisa Bernerström WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15596 17552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Ross, Jr. User:Papaursa 16:01, 20 January 2018 (UTC) delete There's no doubt that he's been successful, but that's not a WP notability criteria. He doesn't meet the notability criteria for golfers and I'm not seeing the significant independent coverage of him that requires. Notability is also not inherited from having met or been associated with well-known figures Deletion of Bob Ross, Jr. WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15597 18702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Svitlana Nianio User:Walkingpoodle 23:56, 12 December 2020 (UTC) keep Meets criteria of Deletion of Svitlana Nianio WP:SINGER Wikipedia:Notability 77
15598 12907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Afsar khan ( politician) User:AllyD 14:10, 29 February 2016 (UTC) keep The subject passes criterion 1 by being a multiply-elected MLA. (The article title should be standardised after the conclusion of the AfD Deletion of Afsar khan ( politician) :WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
15599 11170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Akintayo (2nd nomination) User:Robert 19:35, 10 August 2020 (UTC) delete WP:PROMO|Promotional, and does not satisfy |general notability Deletion of Stephen Akintayo (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15600 15635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Sanders (creator) User:Jd22292 13:04, 4 November 2017 (UTC) keep First, AFD is . Second, Inquisitr has covered Sanders' switch to Disney https://www.inquisitr.com/3926406/thomas-sanders-disney-channel-sitcom/ here. Coverage in this source appears significant Deletion of Thomas Sanders (creator) WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15601 14394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shardul Pandey User:Bmusician 12:46, 20 May 2012 (UTC) delete no significant coverage in reliable sources. Fails ; article also is overly |promotional. The SPA IP's should note that Wikipedia is |not a democracy and that deletion arguments should be grounded in |policy Deletion of Shardul Pandey WP:BIO||WP:SPAM||WP:DEMOCRACY||WP:PAG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15602 9324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Everest Cast User:K 00:29, 22 December 2017 (UTC) delete completely non notable and promotional in nature. Fails / . Sources re mostly or otherwise not suitable for notability Deletion of Everest Cast WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:GNG||WP:SPIP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15603 4350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trenseta User:Bubba 11:11, 6 January 2007 (UTC) delete ndash; |unverifiable. Can only find blogs and boards Deletion of Trenseta :WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15604 7333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesús Alvarez User:Inter 17:23, 19 September 2017 (UTC) delete fails & by a pretty comprehensive margin Deletion of Jesús Alvarez WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15605 1245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kerim Memija (2nd nomination) User:Davey2010 21:53, 7 January 2016 (UTC) delete fails . and Deletion of Kerim Memija (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15606 17908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternatives Federal Credit Union User:Dennis 15:49, 13 October 2014 (UTC) keep I don't blame the nom, it could have almost passed for A7 as it was, but added a bit of content, including sources from two different books (with urls) and one award, and would note that the mission and success of the organization would warrant inclusion. It wasn't obvious before, but after some searching, I'm convinced it is now. It still needs more content, I just added enough to get it to pass Deletion of Alternatives Federal Credit Union WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15607 3596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iqbal Masood Nadvi User:Xxanthippe 11:04, 10 September 2016 (UTC) delete No evidence of passing rof. Claims for should be explicated Deletion of Iqbal Masood Nadvi WP:P||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Portal 85
15608 12700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of IMAX venues (2nd nomination) User:Spellcast 07:21, 7 August 2007 (UTC) delete """If """"notable"""" theaters are merged (assuming it can even be determined that one is more notable than the other), the list on the IMAX page will grow and could call for the creation of a separate article again. What encylopedic purpose does this serve? This is something you expect to find in a tourist pamphlet when you're on vacation. Wikipedia is not a #TRAVEL|travel guide or a #DIR|directory. I'm sure we wouldn't have a List of McDonald's restaurants. Also, :Category:IMAX venues serves a better purpose for this""" Deletion of List of IMAX venues (2nd nomination) WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15609 12742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Guadalupe Frias User:Kinu 21:48, 25 March 2006 (UTC) delete Time's up. Delete as an author test or author request. Why people don't realize that a message board, I don't know Deletion of Maria Guadalupe Frias WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15610 2704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Favorite Highway User:Darth_Panda 05:10, 23 November 2008 (UTC) delete Only http://news.google.com/news?q=%22My%20Favorite%20Highway%22&ie=UTF-8&oe=utf-8&rls=com.ubuntu:en-US:unofficial&client=firefox-a&um=1&sa=N&tab=wn three Google News hits from non-mainstream news sources. I'd almost argue that this falls under . Either way, they fail and deserve deletion Deletion of My Favorite Highway WP:A7||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15611 19086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Langford Wellman Colley-Priest User:Bearian 01:21, 23 July 2020 (UTC) keep There's three stories about his life and his ... death (I was not expecting that last line in the lead). That's easily . This is the sort of article that ends up on the section Deletion of Langford Wellman Colley-Priest WP:SIGCOV||WP:DYK Wikipedia:Notability 77
15612 15681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Young Mahasi User:Ammarpad 09:42, 27 November 2017 (UTC) delete for numerous reasons. Failing for lack of independent significant coverage. Failing completely; even the article admit he is wannabe musician not signed to any major label. External links in reference to download Mp3 file directly is |covert pamming. The SPA creator is either fawning fan or narcissistic autobiographer; 2 years after account creation he never edited any page (his viewable edits) except this one and their G11 deleted user page. This is professional subtle |promotion so as to game G11. With these and many more reasons above this page should be deleted Deletion of Young Mahasi WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:SPAM||WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
15613 14910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antiwikipedia User:TheKMan 06:24, 31 May 2006 (UTC) delete Does not meet . Deletion of Antiwikipedia WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
15614 10877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dinmore Hill Woods User:Antepenultimate 00:23, 22 December 2016 (UTC) keep nice find doncram, as an SSSI it meets the conditions of : {{tq|Artificial geographical features that are officially assigned ... protected status on a national level and which verifiable information beyond simple statistics are available are presumed to be notable.}} Agree the sourcing needs improvement. I'm going to tag the article as such and do some quick cleanup while I'm there Deletion of Dinmore Hill Woods WP:GEOFEAT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15615 4399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of northernmost items (2nd nomination) User:Mangoe 13:30, 23 April 2019 (UTC) delete Looking at citations at random, for the most part they do not actually say, independently, that the thing in question is the northernmost, making this a huge fest. I'm not sure how many of those that do are telling the truth. And besides, most of it is trivia. Let Guinness handle this one Deletion of List of northernmost items (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
15616 1438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Très.B User:Royboycrashfan 00:56, 4 April 2006 (UTC) delete per , , and . Homepage on MySpace makes this an obvious delete Deletion of Très.B WP:MUSIC||WP:VANITY||WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Notability 77
15617 10540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SUPERPOWER the Movie User:MichaelQSchmidt 20:13, 21 September 2008 (UTC) delete without prejudice, as this film is only just now making the festival rounds. If or when notability can be established through , bring it back Deletion of SUPERPOWER the Movie WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15618 13713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Romania–Singapore relations (2nd nomination) User:Yilloslime 05:37, 14 July 2009 (UTC) delete Per everyone above. Also, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Romania–Singapore relations|last time around, several editors felt that the four news blurbs unearthed by WilyD were enough to demonstrate notability, but I remain unconvinced. (I also note that none of them have been incorporated into the article.) Each of these tiny articles deals with the President of Romania's 2002 visit to Asia which included Singapore, but this coverage does not meet the |bar of direct, detailed coverage. And even if it did, the event itself is non-notable per . It simply doesn't make sense that the notability of the more general topic of Romania–Singapore relations could be inherited from a non-notable event Deletion of Romania–Singapore relations (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15619 4604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islamic State of Iraq and Syria User:Zangar 02:33, 12 January 2014 (UTC) merge to Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant - this does seem to be a |content fork. Should events (and sources) indicate a separation of the two named states then the article could be reinstated in its own right Deletion of Islamic State of Iraq and Syria WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
15620 18198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/In-N-Out Burger timeline User:Terence 17:12, 27 January 2007 (UTC) delete cruft. Yes, the eatery is notable, but this article is totally irrelevant to this encyclopedia. an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of In-N-Out Burger timeline WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15621 19753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Bill, 2019 User:Harshil169 11:46, 6 August 2019 (UTC) keep I am creator of page. What a bad and unrelated reason to nominate? The page no where mentions the statistics and person nominated here by saying this is list of statistics. This bill will decide the future of Indian Jammu and Kashmir which is historical in itself. Bill received enough coverage in to pass and it can have Wikipedia page. '''The user who put template on this article has mostly made edits after I did any edit.''' You can check his contribution section for comparison. Also, original template he put was when I submitted one article for deletion. He copied it and pasted here. '''Clearly, it shows and I will demand two way interaction ban with him.''' And yes, {{ping|Edward Zigma}}, if you are commenting on every one's contradictory view here then you must read Deletion of Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Bill, 2019 WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:DLC||WP:BLUD Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15622 21185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finlay Milne User:Fenix 11:26, 8 February 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Finlay Milne WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15623 14241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jia Sharma (2nd nomination) User:Cutest 06:42, 2 October 2014 (UTC) delete as per #G4.— Deletion of Jia Sharma (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15624 20581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monster Mack User:Kneel17 19:48, 20 July 2007 (UTC) delete makes crazy assumptions, no credible claims that can be verified and certainly doesn't meet the entertainer section of Deletion of Monster Mack WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15625 8665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Duwayne Ewart User:GiantSnowman 21:23, 23 May 2016 (UTC) keep meets ; needs improving, not deleting Deletion of Duwayne Ewart WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15626 64 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Sarvar Şirin Kullanıcı:superyetkinsuperyetkin 12.00, 20 Eylül 2019 (UTC) comment kalsın}} Güvenilir ve bağımsız kaynaklar çoktur. Tekrarlanan kaynaklar şöyle verilsin: a b c d e f g h i j --Türk imparatorlukları-- bkz. Oylamanın başlangıç tarihi itibarıyla kullanıcı 60 günlük üye değil Sarvar Şirin'in silinmesi Vikipedi:OY Wikipedia:Administrators 89
15627 14787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Banstead Woods Parkrun 2 User:Arms 23:39, 22 August 2018 (UTC) delete """There isn't any |substantial coverage in independent reliable sources, and there doesn't even seem to be any ''in''substantial coverage in such sources, with the exception of the very brief mention in the BBC source cited in the article. The Banstead Woods event isn't mentioned in the Parkrun article, so redirecting this there would not be helpful to the reader. {{ping|Middledistance99}} You might be interested in the essay Wikipedia: What notability is not, which explains that """"{{tq|'notable' does not simply mean 'noteworthy,' which is a standard way that the term is defined by a dictionary. On Wikipedia, notability is a test used by editors to decide whether a given topic warrants its own article.}}"""" You might also find otability#Why we have these requirements|Notability: Why we have these requirements useful, if you haven't read it. – """ Deletion of Banstead Woods Parkrun 2 WP:42||WP:N Wikipedia:The answer to life, the universe, and everything 7
15628 19459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs recorded by Udit Narayan user:Jayantanth 15:31, 18 August 2013 (UTC) delete This is a list of no notable items. This fails . Delete all this kind of article, except article split due to Deletion of List of songs recorded by Udit Narayan WP:SAL||WP:TOOLONG Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
15629 20001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Franz Vohwinkel User:JBsupreme 15:14, 25 June 2010 (UTC) keep """Please note that this is not a vote, and if the best you can do is say """"same user doesn't like this"""" then your comments are likely to be discounted by the closing administrator. Furthermore, your implied accusation is false, I am more ambivalent or neutral than anything about the subject matter. The problem lies with a huge walled garden of unsourced and non-notable articles plaguing Wikipedia. And if you're saying I don't like ''that'', then you would be right. I don't""" Deletion of Franz Vohwinkel WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15630 9656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chhatra Lok Janshakti NONE NONE delete This party fails the |GNG. The results in Google News archive are all trivial mentions Deletion of Chhatra Lok Janshakti WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15631 13095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aminur Rahman,Khosru User:RightCowLeftCoast 08:52, 17 August 2012 (UTC) delete subject appears to fail , , & within the field of MILHIST fails Deletion of Aminur Rahman,Khosru WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO||WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
15632 14549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gravmar & the Gravediggers User:Mattg82 22:12, 10 October 2011 (UTC) delete Band does not pass . Some Norwegian sources but no significant coverage Deletion of Gravmar & the Gravediggers WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15633 20423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pizza delivery in popular culture User:Father 21:18, 9 June 2008 (UTC) keep per . The article as re-written by GRC in the last couple of days is in every way superior to to article that was nominated. The article everyone disparaged above is gone by virtue of the rewrite, and the rewritten article should not be confused with it or deleted in its place. Re-list the new article if you must; I doubt it'd get the same negative response that the earlier article did Deletion of Pizza delivery in popular culture WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
15634 2492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diego Bartolotta User:Hypogaearoots 16:37, 9 May 2021 (UTC) delete non-notable footballer fails Deletion of Diego Bartolotta WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15635 11171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raven & Kreyn (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 21:41, 7 November 2019 (UTC) delete no evidence of passing . |We typically delete articles about DJ's, especially those whose forte tends to be just remixes. There is an impressive-looking wall of references, but AllMusic (footnote 1) doesn't even mention them, and about 20 of the others are |unreliable Deletion of Raven & Kreyn (2nd nomination) WP:MUSICBIO||WP:OUTCOMES||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15636 19916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Lesson Is Learned but the Damage Is Irreversible NONE NONE keep Wikipedia:Notability|Notability appears to be the only grounds I know of to argue removal of this article. The original deletion proposal noted that the comic was defunct, which is true, but |notability is not temporary and there are many articles on other webcomics (and other media) which has ended Deletion of A Lesson Is Learned but the Damage Is Irreversible WP:NOTTEMPORARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15637 10652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sailor sandwich User:Antepenultimate 01:23, 3 July 2015 (UTC) keep """Easily passes both the spirit and the letter of , with the ''http://www.richmond.com/entertainment/article_9d476505-ada6-56e1-85da-c10c00cbf560.html Times-Dispatch'' and ''https://insight.vcu.edu/2010/10/19/a-sandwich-richmond-can-call-its-own/ VCU Insight'' articles doing the bulk of the heavy lifting, and the other refs providing additional verifiability and details. The argument that an article is not 'independent' due to it being published in the same city as its subject is not supported by the actual definition of independence found at GNG - and neither of the two articles I've linked here are in any way the """"buddy-buddy"""" type of article The Banner is alluding to above. Full disclosure, I'd never heard of this sandwich before seeing it added to the List of sandwiches, but it is now my life's mission to try one after having now read about it""" Deletion of Sailor sandwich WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15638 6263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Psych Desktop 2 User:DJBullfish 05:21, 13 February 2008 (UTC) delete But only under . The nominating editor states that it fails , however this '''''cannot''''' be, '''as it's an article about a program, not a living person'''. So right out of the box one of the two reasons for the nomination is clearly shot down. With regard to notability though, it's previous deletion made me take a hard look, and I'm just not sure it passes the smell test for notability. It appears to be an advert - encyclopedic in tone but an advert nonetheless - for a seemingly new product with little note among third parties Deletion of Psych Desktop 2 WP:N||WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15639 19636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrian Main User:Fortuna 14:45, 29 April 2017 (UTC) delete per {{u|Woody}} and {{u|John Pack Lambert}}; does not seem to have actualy played in a professional leage, and as such fails the requirements of . &mdash Deletion of Adrian Main WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15640 21073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phantom (operating system) User:Greg 17:15, 13 April 2009 (UTC) comment There are various articles about it, but they've all come through the one from the Register, which is linked in the article. Whilst I'd say the Register is a good source, it all seems a bit to me - yet to be released, still in progress. Whilst it may be notable in the future, there's a bit too much speculation here for me to think keep Deletion of Phantom (operating system) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15641 17093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George William (actor) User:MichaelQSchmidt 19:03, 23 July 2010 (UTC) delete Alternate searches using assertions in the article find nothing. Fails Deletion of George William (actor) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15642 1663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Bossé User:Papaursa 00:06, 17 February 2014 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet , , or Deletion of Steve Bossé WP:NMMA||WP:NHOCKEY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15643 12405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albert Edward (soccer) User:Hack 05:13, 26 January 2014 (UTC) delete fails , hasn't played in a fully professional football league. Fails as he hasn't been the subject of significant coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Albert Edward (soccer) WP:NSPORTS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15644 10555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Barr McKay User:Ammarpad 11:35, 22 October 2017 (UTC) delete fails as he is not subject of discussion in any reliable independent source Deletion of William Barr McKay WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
15645 6914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Animal (Doctor Who audio) (2nd nomination) User:DustFormsWords 04:22, 19 May 2010 (UTC) delete Sorry, I love the Big Finish audios to death, but (a) this fails , (b) the article is currently a plot-only description of a fictional work, and (c) there's no evidence of independent notability. Much in the same way as every episode of a notable TV series isn't automatically entitled to an article, neither should these be, with the obvious exception of particularly notable audios like The Sirens of Time, Jubilee, etc. I'd vastly prefer to see Rob Shearman's work on Jubilee (audio drama)|Jubilee done justice by having that article fixed up than see you waste your time defending speculative articles about future releases Deletion of Animal (Doctor Who audio) (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15646 14504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of alderpersons of Carrboro, North Carolina User:Bearcat 17:12, 11 August 2017 (UTC) delete No prejudice against listing the town councillors in an article about the town council itself, if it can be shown to clear , but we do not maintain standalone lists of municipal councillors — even New York City doesn't have one of these, and it's a global city where the city councillors are actually deemed to pass (which Carrboro's are not Deletion of List of alderpersons of Carrboro, North Carolina WP:GNG||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15647 14105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clocks (band) User:Eludium 11:23, 12 January 2007 (UTC) comment """Jdwhite states that there has been non-trivial coverage in the NME. This is a reliable source, so is the Epsom Guardian. Adding details of these works ''to the article'' would be a significant help, as the onus of proof is on the person wishing to insert the information. That things are """"extremely likely"""" to happen is insufficient to pass """ Deletion of Clocks (band) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15648 16748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of After Colony mobile units User:FrozenPurpleCube 01:31, 23 August 2007 (UTC) keep as a reasonable way to cover a defining subject in a clearly notable anime saga. And believe it or not, people do write guide books to this series. It is clearly a list of fixed scope, namely mobile units in a given anime, which is hardly indiscriminate. Content could be improved, but that's not a deletion reason. Oh, and try to be more explicit than just Deletion of List of After Colony mobile units WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15649 9173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warlord (manhua) User:Fee 01:03, 23 December 2007 (UTC) delete fails and probably , no sources Deletion of Warlord (manhua) WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15650 2399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acousticophilia User:Guest9999 12:56, 1 March 2008 (UTC) delete one trivial mention inhttp://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/1911674.cms other than that I can't find any references to suggest the phenomenon is |notable - there is no evidence of significant coverage by |reliable, independent sources Deletion of Acousticophilia WP:NN||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15651 10767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Panda Hotel User:Kafziel 18:44, 18 October 2006 (UTC) delete Insert a mention at Tsuen Wan District. It seems to narrowly meet but there doesn't seem to be enough verifiable info at this point. I don't see too many mentions of it online, but I'll bet there are more independent sources for it apart from English language ones. Maybe if someone created a better version on the Cantonese Wikipedia, enough info could eventually be gathered to support a separate article here. Maybe not Deletion of Panda Hotel WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
15652 4698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Hunt (professor) User:David 19:31, 26 December 2017 (UTC) keep """His Chancellor's Professor title (https://carleton.ca/secretariat/wp-content/uploads/Chancellors-Professors-Policy.pdf policy on this title) gives him a pass of #C5, and I suspect that one can find sufficient reviews of his books to also pass . AfD is not for cleanup, and calling this a """"vanity article"""" is both a |personal attack and a violation of , but I removed the list of courses as I agree they are non-encyclopedic""" Deletion of Alan Hunt (professor) WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR||WP:NPA||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15653 2009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Four Quarters Magazine [[User talk:122.162.52.204|talk]]) 17:19, 27 December 2013 (UTC) keep check out the search results in google scholar (http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22The+Four+Quarters+Magazine%22) for |notability — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/122.162.52.204|122.162.52.204 Deletion of The Four Quarters Magazine WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15654 6282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miracle-Gro AeroGarden User:K 00:44, 2 May 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet new and improved ; likely UPE. Let's not encourage spammers by keeping their articles. If this company is indeed notable (of which I'm not convinced), then a volunteer editor will create an article in due time. There's no hurry to get to such a state, however Deletion of Miracle-Gro AeroGarden WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15655 5158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laura Massey User:Morenooso 23:05, 3 May 2010 (UTC) keep The search, ''Laura Massey+xbox'' gets ghits but nothing that would most likely be considered . I have a feeling that in the gaming community, she would be fairly notable Deletion of Laura Massey WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15656 583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Henderson (doctor) User:Dirtlawyer1 17:37, 23 August 2014 (UTC) keep Notable British/Australian motor vehicle and traffic safety expert and published author. His early and significant involvement in automobile safety issues has had a lasting impact on the design of racing and passenger cars, including seat belt design and the enactment of mandatory seat belt laws in Australia, the United States and elsewhere, and leading to significant cultural changes in the Anglosphere regarding driving safety. The present footnoted sources in the article are more than sufficient to demonstrate significant coverage in multiple, independent, reliable sources to satisfy the general notability guidelines per . Yes, the subject is a little bit obscure, no, the subject is not a household word, but this is exactly the sort of well-sourced biographical article that Wikipedia should have if it claims to be a serious encyclopedia Deletion of Michael Henderson (doctor) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15657 323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fraser Harding User:Crusio 09:07, 5 January 2009 (UTC) delete Givne that even the article creator agrees, I suggest someone closes this now per or something like that Deletion of Fraser Harding WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
15658 17178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Village of La Jolla NONE NONE keep subject has received sufficient mentions in multiple reliable sources, although it can be argued that none have been |significant, in order to meet . See Deletion of Village of La Jolla WP:SIGCOV||WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15659 16796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silver Giorgio Armani dress of Cate Blanchett User:Lukeno94 21:03, 10 April 2013 (UTC) delete My grief, there's articles on individual dresses being made now? *headdesk* Blatant violation, although what criteria it would fit (probably multiple ones), I'm not sure Deletion of Silver Giorgio Armani dress of Cate Blanchett WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15660 14157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SAC Vasanth User:Rhododendrites 05:27, 24 January 2015 (UTC) keep Seeing sufficient sources to meet . --&mdash Deletion of SAC Vasanth WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15661 236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Dakshana Foundation User:onel5969 16:33, 11 November 2015 (UTC) delete nothing but trivial mentions and press releases in the searches. Fails Deletion of The Dakshana Foundation WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15662 18956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MystiCon User:Stephen 22:32, 4 April 2011 (UTC) keep Meets as interpreted through . Local newspaper plus File 770 (a notable sci-fi publication) seem sufficient for sources. Article is not written as an advertisement. Comments made by Cekesner2 are irrelevant to determining this article's status; he did not create the article, and only contributed one extremely minor edit to it. Any problems with the article should be corrected by editing and expanding, not by deleting the article Deletion of MystiCon WP:N||WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15663 962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Ignatius Borissow User:DarkGlow 10:32, 16 August 2021 (UTC) delete no Deletion of Christian Ignatius Borissow WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
15664 8275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liam O'Shea User:Tree 01:11, 12 July 2006 (UTC) delete per and #Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of Liam O'Shea WP:BIO||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15665 16539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Schlossberg (3rd nomination) User:Tarc 13:35, 6 March 2014 (UTC) delete """as |Notability is not inherited, expanding on my https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Deletion_review/Log/2014_February_23&diff=prev&oldid=597300197 DRV argument. When a subject's perceived """"notability"""" is evaluated, there is broad precedent in this project that if it stems from a famous relative, i.e. the subject would likely not receive the amount of coverage he/she does absent the famous relation, then that is not suited for a standalone article. Much the same as a (1E is not being argued her,e just used as a reference) case is considered; absent the event, is that person still notable? We have evaluated similar cases in the past such as Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al Gore III (8th nomination)|Al Gore's son (it took awhile to stick), Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcus Bachmann|Michelle Bachmann's husband, and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicky Diaz|Meg Whitman's housekeeper. Any argument of """"it just meets the GNG"""" should be weighed next-to-nothing in the final tally here, just as they would be in BLP1e discussion""" Deletion of John Schlossberg (3rd nomination) WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15666 1130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ralph Cuomo User:SimonKnowsAll 23:06, 25 July 2012 (UTC) delete It fails and is not well cited Deletion of Ralph Cuomo WP:CRIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
15667 7922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thinstuff User:Kylohk 15:09, 18 July 2007 (UTC) merge Has been mentioned in http://www.linuxjournal.com/article/8952 Linux Journal, an authoraitative publication about Linux, so it does satisfy that it's mentioned by independent reliable sources. The ad like tone can always be rewritten Deletion of Thinstuff WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15668 10071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dynamic theory of gravity User:Someguy1221 01:59, 23 April 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Dynamic theory of gravity WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15669 4456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alien (software) User:Mark 21:02, 10 May 2013 (UTC) keep There is a modest http://www.linuxjournal.com/content/alien-use-any-package-any-distribution Linux Journal article on the software and it pops up on commercial howto sites like http://www.howtogeek.com/howto/ubuntu/install-an-rpm-package-on-ubuntu-linux/ How-To Geek. Debian uses it to Linux Standard Base#Limitations on Debian|help improve conformance to the Linux Standard Base. http://www.tldp.org/LDP/www.debian.org/doc/manuals/debian-reference/ch11.en.html#_miscellaneous_data_conversion The Linux Documentation Project has an entry for the software. Joy and Grandmartin11 have shown that there are thousands of GBook hits for the software. Between the LJ article, which I consider marginally in depth, some shorter articles on commercial howto sites and thousands of citations in books, I consider the software notable. In my opinion, in judging notability allows for many small references in RS like books to substitute for an in-depth one: ''The number and nature of reliable sources needed varies depending on the depth of coverage and quality of the sources. Multiple sources are generally expected.'' There seems to be enough secondary material out there to support a modest article. With a notable topic and no major problems in the article, I recommend keeping the article Deletion of Alien (software) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15670 7602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Club Docmur User:Dumelow 14:35, 12 December 2007 (UTC) delete obvious |hoax Deletion of Club Docmur WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
15671 21590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhys Taylor (2nd nomination) User:Rlendog 03:08, 21 July 2010 (UTC) keep First of all, this is not a speedy candidate, since the article is far more than a recreation of the previously deleted content, and indeed provides refs to at least indicate the subject's importance, even if notability is in question. From my perspective, there are at least 3 separate news articles cited which are specifically about this person. So he seems to pass , even if somewhat marginally and even though he doesn't pass (at least not yet). But since GNG is sufficient to demonstrate notability, regardless of the subject's chosen profession, he seems worthy of keeping, at least for the time being. If his notability remains marginal a few months hence and/or if the article becomes a vandalism magnet, it may be worth reconsidering Deletion of Rhys Taylor (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15672 6340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cat Zingano User:Courier00 02:45, 14 December 2013 (UTC) keep As above, passes , will be fighting for the championship of a major professional sports organization Deletion of Cat Zingano WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15673 14030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Starship Trooper User:Doc 08:06, 16 March 2008 (UTC) delete WP:NFT|made up and beside the sources given aren't |reliable and I get no Google News hits for it (as I expected Deletion of The Starship Trooper WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15674 16076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Renato Cipriano User:JavaHurricane 02:50, 21 December 2020 (UTC) delete Spam. |G11 is the solution here Deletion of Renato Cipriano WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15675 13285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicolás Aguirre User:Yosemiter 01:47, 21 March 2017 (UTC) comment """The """"keep"""" commenters on this page are all attempting to circumvent reasonable Wikipedia guidelines and practices, which maintain content integrity, and a sort of order. Guidelines have developed—they're not sacrosanct, and they do evolve. As reads today, Aguirre fails , largely because the Argentine league isn't recognized as top tier""" Deletion of Nicolás Aguirre WP:NBASKETBALL||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15676 6655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BC13 - EP (brokeNCYDE EP) User:Esradekan 10:58, 19 February 2009 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability per #Albums Deletion of BC13 - EP (brokeNCYDE EP) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15677 792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/For Lies I Sire User:Dennis 18:31, 21 November 2008 (UTC) delete If the release date (or lack of) was published in a secondary source, then I would have said keep, but this is just too thin. It can be recreated later when/if the album is released or someone publishes something useful to say about it. This isn't about crystalball (which doesn't apply here), this is about the inability to |verify through |reliable sources, which is impossible at this time Deletion of For Lies I Sire WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15678 15426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Harriman User:Argyle 00:53, 18 April 2011 (UTC) delete Clearly fails and Deletion of Michael Harriman WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15679 11911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesus Melliza User:Fenix 17:07, 23 April 2018 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Jesus Melliza WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15680 20815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Insurrextion (2003) User:Galatz 20:03, 20 April 2018 (UTC) keep Firstly, it sounds like the nominator should have taken this to articles to merge rather than delete, but that is beside the point. Consensus has always been that all WWE pay-per-view events due to their nature and coverage are independently notable. Every single WWE pay-per-view outside of this series, had their own pages prior to their creation. His rationale given here https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Slashme&diff=837428550&oldid=837379635&diffmode=source sounds to me like his biggest issue is that they are stubs, which is not reason for deletion, it just means I haven't finished expanding yet. Also there are several that still mention these in more recent years http://www.skysports.com/wwe/news/14203/10929535/vote-worst-wwe-pay-per-view-names https://superluchas.com/los-ocho-peores-nombres-pay-per-view-ha-tenido-wwe-historia/ https://www.vavel.com/en-us/wrestling/2017/12/08/856514-wwe-reportedly-discussing-australian-ppv.html Deletion of Insurrextion (2003) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15681 3078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ayttm User:Lulu 08:04, 15 January 2010 (UTC) keep This nomination, like a number of software noms by the same few editors, seems outright crazy and y. This software is cited in multiple independent sources, indicating notability. Moreover, the tone of the article is generally neutral, factual and informative. Any moderate improvements to tone or content are just normal editing Deletion of Ayttm WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
15682 15146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Brother 2009 (UK) (2nd nomination) User:Banime 16:11, 21 September 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Big Brother 2009 (UK) (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15683 11953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kwabena Boahen User:Truth 15:20, 22 June 2014 (UTC) keep Passes rof well enough Deletion of Kwabena Boahen WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
15684 21319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamsterball (video game) user:czar 01:50, 23 March 2015 (UTC) keep Regardless of current condition, burden is on the nominator to look for sources |before coming to AfD. Indeed there's nothing on the Raptisoft game, but there's enough on the TikGames game—reviews in three major /RS|video game publications: IGN, Eurogamer, and Play (UK magazine) (see the http://www.metacritic.com/game/playstation-3/hamsterball Metacritic listing). So we're looking at repurposing and dropping the disambig after this closes. Those reviews are enough, but there are a few other small articles in a /RS|video game reliable sources search. Please ping me if more (non-English and offline) sources show in the future. czar Deletion of Hamsterball (video game) WP:BEFORE||WP:VG||WP:VG Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15685 549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monaken Lodge User:Dhartung 22:35, 23 February 2008 (UTC) delete per . We have Order of the Arrow, but we don't even have articles on scouting units below the national level, e.g. Scouting in the United States. As to the claim of notability, the awards it has won are not independent of scouting Deletion of Monaken Lodge WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15686 20197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/East Carolina Pirates future football schedules User:Edinburgh 00:30, 10 January 2012 (UTC) comment Don't take offence to what is say I'm just stating facts there is no guarantee these matches will take place you will also note in my delete vote i did not quote one of the few people against this that didn't. If we were taking this year or next then maybe but 2018. Anyway its a fixture list i cannot see how it is notable in any way shape or form. As i said the club is there seasons are but a fixture list. The coverage is tottaly routine. One of the sources even says they have agreed in principal no guarantee there Deletion of East Carolina Pirates future football schedules WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15687 21944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ConnecticEnergy.com User:Davewild 10:49, 10 June 2007 (UTC) delete no notability established, fails Deletion of ConnecticEnergy.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
15688 16845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Killer Instinct 3 (2nd nomination) User:Schuym1 18:21, 27 November 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Killer Instinct 3 (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15689 9253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Student Recreation Center User:Polyamorph 08:15, 16 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Student Recreation Center WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15690 13815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Srikaran Kandadai (2nd nomination) User:Eternal 00:31, 3 July 2020 (UTC) delete fails easily as well Deletion of Srikaran Kandadai (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15691 4586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of different maze types User:ComplexRational 16:03, 23 February 2019 (UTC) delete """As per nom, this appears to be a list of anecdotes. There can be no comparisions if there is not enough information to classify """"types"""" of mazes rather than single mazes, and this presentation of a comparison chart seems to make a generalization – . The cited examples can be merged into labyrinth or maze if they are not already there""" Deletion of Comparison of different maze types WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15692 1302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gundisalvus of Lagos User:Necrothesp 10:09, 11 August 2021 (UTC) keep Passes and although not canonised, he has been beatified. That's enough for notability Deletion of Gundisalvus of Lagos WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15693 4971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EVO Smart Console User:Mike 21:39, 8 February 2013 (UTC) comment """I was able to locate a few secondary sources after spending some time with Google, including a http://annistonstar.com/view/full_story/2638093/article-Pushing-Buttons--EVO-console-is-lacking review published in the Anniston Star and http://www.maximumpc.com/article/columns/evo_the_unholy_hybrid_opensource_computing_and_consoles another review published in Maximum PC. I also discovered that Thunderbolt (website)|Thunderbolt also http://www.thunderboltgames.com/features/article/under-the-radar-envizions-evo-2-dx-handson-review-for-all-none.html published a review of the EVO 2, but it's Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Video_games/Sources/Archive_2#Thunderbolt|debatable whether that qualifies as a . It seems rather odd to me though that a game console would receive such a minimal amount of media coverage. For anyone doing additional searches on the topic, take note that some media reports described the product as the """"Evo Console"""" or even the """"Evo Game Console""" Deletion of EVO Smart Console WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15694 8107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HBS Towers (2nd nomination) User:Guliolopez 12:03, 17 June 2020 (UTC) delete """per nom and . As noted in the https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=HBS_Towers&diff=873922500&oldid=852539183 amends and https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=HBS_Towers&type=revision&diff=920558552&oldid=920544383 tags I'd applied to this promotional guff over the last few years, this article seems to stand only as an example of why we have and guidelines. Frankly I think we need to have a broader look at our guidelines. As this project is (in my view) cluttered up with a lot of out-dated information on proposed building projects. Many of these fall between the cracks of . Where, probably because newspapers are reliant on advertising revenue from property developers and the like, we often find a reasonable level of coverage of these planned/proposed development projects in what are otherwise independent and reliable sources. But, in reality, the subject might never even be afforded planning permission. And hence barely even exists """"in potentia"""". Not to mention ever existing in reality. In my view, should probably be applied (in extremis) to these types of subjects. And, even if there does seem to be some coverage of the planned project to the extent that newspapers are republishing the developer's plans and press-releases, we shouldn't necessarily be doing the same. In this case, the article should just be deleted. This project is not improved by hosting an out-of-date press release for a property developer's proposal/daydream""" Deletion of HBS Towers (2nd nomination) WP:NOTCRYSTAL||WP:NOTCRYSTAL||WP:NOTADVERT||WP:NBUILDING||WP:SIGCOV||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15695 7975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pokémopolis User:TheFarix 14:13, 2 September 2006 (UTC) merge it and other Kanto (Pokémon)|Kanto region :Category:Kanto locations|locations into into List of Kanto region locations per Deletion of Pokémopolis WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15696 3039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Kuya's Wedding User:MichaelQSchmidt 19:37, 23 January 2016 (UTC) keep per topic meeting . Yes the inexperienced editor created a |poor article, which was https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=My_Kuya%27s_Wedding&type=revision&diff=701154938&oldid=701123559 quickly sent to AFD... but even though |AFD is not meant to force cleanup, the topic was easy to https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=My_Kuya%27s_Wedding&type=revision&diff=701302748&oldid=701154938 improve. There is really no need for this to remain listed. It serves the project that this remain and be further improved over time and through regular editing Deletion of My Kuya's Wedding WP:NF||WP:UGLY||WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15697 10455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Fellman User:Nyttend 20:53, 2 October 2009 (UTC) keep """looks like he is someone """"|who has competed at the fully professional level of a sport"""", as the article on the league says that it's fully professional""" Deletion of Daniel Fellman WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15698 11168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sinus infection symptoms and effective treatment User:Ironholds 00:43, 26 November 2010 (UTC) delete fails #MANUAL and contains heady doses of Deletion of Sinus infection symptoms and effective treatment WP:NOT||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15699 13230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swenzy User:Nagle 19:46, 29 January 2014 (UTC) delete """The discussion at Talk:Swenzy describes the problems in detail. In brief, this was originally a promotional article, and and issues were raised. After several editors looked for better sources, it was discovered that 1) the company has no verifiable existence as a company, 2) their """"registered trademark"""" isn't registered with the USPTO or WIPO, 3) their business is creating fake web sites, hoaxes, fake """"likes"""" and Youtube views, and other """"black hat"""" search optimization techniques, and 4) their """"About"""" page points back to the Wikipedia article. They have lots of web references, but they're mostly of their own making. There's so much fake content associated with this business that we can't sort out the real from the fake. In any case, they don't verifiably meet the business criteria for . In other words, this is spam. Spam with a lot of effort behind it, but spam""" Deletion of Swenzy WP:COI||WP:SPA||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
15700 6109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Street Kings (gang) User:SquidSK 06:52, 31 December 2009 (UTC) delete unsourced, at best, at worst Deletion of Street Kings (gang) WP:OR||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:No original research 65
15701 17320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eminéire User:White 03:48, 4 May 2010 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Eminéire WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15702 12198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark D. Poindexter User:Alf 17:28, 4 February 2007 (UTC) delete unless sourced and referenced i.a.w. by end of this AfD Deletion of Mark D. Poindexter WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15703 13519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Bluckert User:Stuartyeates 04:00, 26 September 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Peter Bluckert WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15704 5167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reactions to the July 2016 Kabul bombing User:Nannadeem 12:45, 28 July 2016 (UTC) comment """WP:GNG says: If a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to be suitable for a stand-alone article or list. also prescribes that """"notability not temporary"""". Per First (perhaps the only) keep vote the page should be dealt with . I think this is rule position, but I have seen the fate of page Reactions to the 2016 Nice attack + https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Reactions_to_the_2016_Nice_attack/ (1); more importantly the page view statistics and international reactions with huge difference itself speak for humanitarianism and dual standard for terrorism. So with this academic background I stand neutral at this PROD""" Deletion of Reactions to the July 2016 Kabul bombing WP:NTEMP||WP:DUE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15705 5655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Value Research User:KGirlTrucker81 19:34, 19 August 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |GNG Deletion of Value Research WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15706 16445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wizard staffing User:Bfigura 01:40, 23 October 2007 (UTC) delete as it sounds like it's . No refs found here either Deletion of Wizard staffing WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
15707 19778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robo-FTP Server (2nd nomination) User:MrOllie 20:29, 24 August 2020 (UTC) delete lacks sourcing, fails and Deletion of Robo-FTP Server (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NSOFTWARE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15708 7214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hill jumping User:Ohconfucius 02:16, 24 March 2011 (UTC) delete agree with nom. Seems to be an attempt at a without the aid of reliable sources Deletion of Hill jumping WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
15709 10644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris O'Neal (author) User:Cwmhiraeth 13:08, 1 August 2018 (UTC) delete Self-published author. I am unable to find substantial coverage in reliable sources. Fails Deletion of Chris O'Neal (author) WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15710 8722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward Flagot User:Eddie 03:25, 1 June 2007 (UTC) delete as obvious hoax and for being omplete Bollocks Deletion of Edward Flagot WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
15711 18534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Édmée Schneerson (2nd nomination) User:Protector 05:45, 5 September 2010 (UTC) delete This article fails , , and . Highland14 claims that Schneerson influenced the decision of her relatives to move to Paris. That, by itself, is no indication of notability, per . http://www.google.com/search?&q=%22%C3%89dm%C3%A9e+Schneerson%22&num=50 A Google Search retrieves no |reliable sources or ''any'' sources for that matter (besides Wikipedia and mirrors) to demonstrate the notability. My question to the creator regarding : what has Schneerson done besides her role in a single event (precipitating her relatives to move Deletion of Édmée Schneerson (2nd nomination) WP:ANYBIO||WP:V||WP:INHERITED||WP:ONEEVENT||WP:RS||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15712 6956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CzechWar User:Marasmusine 08:38, 19 July 2007 (UTC) delete Not important (per ), no independent references Deletion of CzechWar WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15713 11104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erik J Rosales User:Sandahl 19:09, 14 May 2010 (UTC) delete fails , , non notable amateur athlete Deletion of Erik J Rosales WP:BIO||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15714 2237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Supercell (mobile network) User:Newtonslaw40 15:34, 29 September 2016 (UTC) keep The article meets notability guidelines. The area of the world may be remote, and the network relatively small, but it meets notability guidelines and supported by multiple . Clearly it's a stub and needs a lot of work, but no reason to delete it - if it is kept it stands a chance of being further developed in time Deletion of Supercell (mobile network) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15715 16457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Crano User:Jayvdb 09:25, 10 June 2007 (UTC) keep per DGG. Nominating immediately after creation is |inappropriate Deletion of William Crano WP:BITE Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
15716 17048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Barresi User:SatyrTN 18:29, 6 September 2007 (UTC) keep """What is all this nonsense about self-published sources being """"against Wikipedia's policies?"""" Anyone who thinks so, read . This article has undergone recent vandalism by a group of editors who have a political agenda, one in opposition to the personage of Paul Baressi. Editors making comments here should familiarize themselves with the protocols for adding comments, and they should know what they're talking about before posting. The fact is, this person is notable under and , warrants an article, and should have an article. Echoing""" Deletion of Paul Barresi WP:SELFPUB||WP:PORNBIO||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15717 6077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Júlio César Alves (2nd nomination) User:Steve 18:35, 7 September 2019 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Júlio César Alves (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15718 7273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ghulam Nabi (footballer) User:Sir 16:14, 13 January 2012 (UTC) delete as original PROD'er. This footballer fails , and has not played in a fully pro league, meaning he fails Deletion of Ghulam Nabi (footballer) WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15719 16962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Lancashire User:Beagel 14:32, 26 March 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of bus routes in Lancashire WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15720 12679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BioTherm Energy User:Cewbot 00:02, 5 August 2020 (UTC) comment While this discussion appears to have |no quorum, it is '''NOT eligible for |soft deletion''' because it has been Special:Diff/935919356|previously PROD'd (via summary Deletion of BioTherm Energy WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
15721 18752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All Headline News (second nomination) User:William 00:44, 13 September 2006 (UTC) delete Even their http://www.allheadlinenews.com/corp/press.shtml press page doesn't persuade me they've crossed the hurdle. Good luck to them getting there, but I don't see it yet Deletion of All Headline News (second nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15722 3201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marek Stachowski (linguist) User:David 22:05, 17 November 2012 (UTC) delete I can't find evidence that his journal is a major one of the type that would pass #C8, or that he passes any other criterion Deletion of Marek Stachowski (linguist) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15723 2392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/R.S. Praveen Kumar User:K 21:06, 10 February 2018 (UTC) delete """a BLP that lacks sources that discuss the subject directly and in detail. The coverage is passing mentions and / or . Agree with nom: this has the hallmarks of COI / UPE, with troubling creation history and language such as """"...widely known as the brain behind the success story of the Everest conquerors""" Deletion of R.S. Praveen Kumar WP:SPIP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15724 21172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Fletcher (Comedian & Entrepreneur) User:Animalparty 17:41, 20 October 2014 (UTC) delete No evidence of significant secondary coverage per or . Heavy citation/linkage to of official website or commercial sites appears promotional Deletion of Ben Fletcher (Comedian & Entrepreneur) WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15725 20943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Macorden User:Wafulz 14:31, 24 August 2006 (UTC) delete Vanity, fails and , with no |reliable sources to back anything up Deletion of Macorden WP:BIO||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15726 8168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael A. Ryan User:Life 22:07, 12 February 2012 (UTC) keep Flag/general officers considered notable per Deletion of Michael A. Ryan WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
15727 6920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Galvatron User:JohnCD 11:21, 11 February 2009 (UTC) delete not notable. Wikipedia is |not for cocktails made up one day Deletion of The Galvatron WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
15728 262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rocker Panel Productions User:Coredesat 02:50, 27 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Rocker Panel Productions WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15729 16645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valery Fedorenko User:CaliforniaAliBaba 05:30, 27 October 2009 (UTC) comment """Most of the GHits on the name in Russian are for an unrelated businessman, but there's a few mentions of him in Kyrgyzstan media like http://www.msn.kg/ru/news/27771/ which confirms the basic outline: he lives in America and has some weightlifting world records (the one they metnion there is in 63-kilogram """"снаряда"""" --- shell (projectile)|shells?? my Russian and my knowledge of pro weightlifting ain't so great, so don't ask me). Don't know whether this qualifies him under """ Deletion of Valery Fedorenko WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15730 8599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Factory life during the industrial revolution User:Redfarmer 07:26, 17 January 2008 (UTC) comment Per , being unencyclopedic by itself is not a reason to delete and I don't see it so much as an issue of OR as much as an issue of lack of sources, which is a cleanup issue. Can you clarify your reason for wanting to delete it Deletion of Factory life during the industrial revolution WP:UNENCYCLOPEDIC Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15731 5389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mariam Khalique User:Pharaoh 15:33, 6 October 2017 (UTC) delete per nom and above Fails Deletion of Mariam Khalique WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15732 10887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liquid Courage (Wax album) User:Jax 15:35, 12 September 2016 (UTC) keep Keep or merge to Wax (rapper)|Wax per Deletion of Liquid Courage (Wax album) WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
15733 20142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/R. M. Engelhardt User:Rnb 22:47, 27 June 2009 (UTC) delete Appears to fail , cannot find references to establish notability otherwise Deletion of R. M. Engelhardt WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15734 9138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apartheid in Saudi Arabia User:RJHall 16:55, 5 April 2011 (UTC) delete merging if necessary—There is no reason to have separate Human rights in Saudi Arabia and Apartheid in Saudi Arabia articles. The content can be covered in the former and it is better kept together unless there is a legitimate reason to fork (such as ). That being said, there is plenty of scope for expansion of the human rights article.&mdash Deletion of Apartheid in Saudi Arabia WP:SS Wikipedia:Summary style 34
15735 5584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Donnelly (journalist) User:Mkdw 05:50, 13 February 2013 (UTC) delete I support the delete camp's argument that the individual does not seem to meet , either as an athlete or a journalist. In regards to the relisting, anyone may if they feel consensus has not been adequately established, and not restricted to admins even in close calls. A relisting is different than a close Deletion of Daniel Donnelly (journalist) WP:ANYBIO||WP:RELIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
15736 18433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wanker (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep From Deletion of Wanker (2nd nomination) WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
15737 21201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FunnyFest Calgary Comedy Festival User:ConcernedVancouverite 04:07, 1 February 2010 (UTC) delete This article has been deleted and recreated 6 times now: http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&page=FunnyFest+Calgary+Comedy+Festival. Most recently it was protected for a period of 6 months, which expired last month. It now has been recreated once again. It still does not appear to satisfy |notability requirements for an event. I refer specifically to Wikipedia:CONTINUEDCOVERAGE|continued coverage. There is very limited coverage of this event in the media, and it generally occurs only right around the time of the event. The bulk of the coverage is also just |routine and mostly based upon press releases from the organizer. The first few incarnations of the article were speedily deleted for blatant spam. Overall this just doesn't seem notable enough to warrant coverage Deletion of FunnyFest Calgary Comedy Festival WP:N||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15738 3655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Masago User:ColourBurst 02:42, 3 September 2006 (UTC) delete does not satisfy Deletion of Masago WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
15739 194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tellows User:Kirbanzo 16:35, 3 September 2018 (UTC) delete seems to be a case of . Tagging as such in case an admin agrees Deletion of Tellows WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15740 14420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anworth Mortgage Asset Corporation User:Drawn 19:04, 5 June 2009 (UTC) keep """This is a mortgage REIT, publically traded on the NYSE with a market cap of about 0.7 billion USD. A shadow of its former self but still considered notable per . Plenty of references like Hoovers and BusinessWeek profiles and also coverage in news because of the financial """"crisis"""". Triplestop, if you look at in the sub-sub-section """"Publicly traded corporations"""" you'll see it meets. And the LA Times, NY Times, etc. are not considered merely """"local""" Deletion of Anworth Mortgage Asset Corporation WP:CORP||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15741 9720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atul Kumar Anjan User:Manasbose 11:19, 4 October 2020 (UTC) comment A number of the references in the article are just Deletion of Atul Kumar Anjan WP:BOMBARDMENT Wikipedia:Citation overkill 60
15742 12257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kate McCann User:Edison 01:36, 9 September 2007 (UTC) merge to Disappearance of Madeleine McCann. Being a parent and a General Practitioner is absolutely non-notable. Creating a separate bio article about a parent of a child who disappeared and who is notable for nothing else violates . I agree with TerriersFan that some brief well sourced bio material about the parents could be include in the article about the disappearance Deletion of Kate McCann WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
15743 9330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Time To Think (band) User:Esradekan 04:12, 27 November 2008 (UTC) delete for failing to meet the |12 criteria. Completely non-notable project of 2 people who link to disambig pages (or are red linked Deletion of Time To Think (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15744 297 [[Kaukapedia]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Voyager 20:32, 29. Apr. 2010 (CEST) delete erreicht keine der |Relevanzschranken. Das wurde bereits beim Ur-Löschantrag festgestellt. Damals vermeinte man lediglich, das die vielen Behaltensstimmer auf wandeldende RK hinweisen. Dem ist leider nicht so, auch die heutige Fassung erkennt keine allgemeine Bedeutsamkeit in partikulären Fan-Wikis. MfG, Löschung von Kaukapedia Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
15745 5604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyprus–Norway relations (3rd nomination) User:Tarc 23:33, 15 May 2010 (UTC) delete """No notability established by reliable sources for these relations. Simply listing treaties and other agreements and calling it a """"relation"""" is |synthesis""" Deletion of Cyprus–Norway relations (3rd nomination) WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
15746 7978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Who saved the electric car User:Suriel1981 03:46, 12 January 2008 (UTC) delete Although the fourth 'reference' made me burst out laughing this is and cannot stay. Having looked at the creator's username and some of the vaunted Google links I have come to the conclusion this is Deletion of Who saved the electric car WP:OR||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:No original research 65
15747 12939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander R. Povolotsky's problem 1 User:Ecoleetage 02:29, 14 October 2008 (UTC) delete I don't bring my problems to Alexander R. Povolotsky - why is he bringing his here? Problems with sink this one Deletion of Alexander R. Povolotsky's problem 1 WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
15748 3583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robyn Maby User:Flibirigit 01:26, 23 January 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Robyn Maby WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15749 21752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omarius Hines User:Cbl62 07:10, 16 May 2019 (UTC) keep """The article needs improvement, but Hines was a play-maker at tight end, wide receiver and running back for Florida in the Urban Meyer years. He passes . The following are examples of significant coverage in multiple, reliable sources spanning an 11-year period from 2007 to 2018: '''(1)''' """"https://www.corsicanadailysun.com/sports/gator-made/article_27e4f2dc-c937-5802-884f-607bb464c188.html Gator made"""" (Hines profile), ''Corsicana Daily Sun'', 11/27/07; '''(2)''' """"Waiting for his chance"""" (Hines profile), ''Corsicana Daily Sun'', 9/3/09 (477 words); '''(3)''' """"Omarius Hines to try his hand at tight end"""", ''St. Petersburg Times'', 8/13/10 (153 words); '''(4)''' """"Omarius Hines, Trey Burton give UF a chance to be tricky"""", ''The Florida Times-Union'', 8/22/12 (677 words); '''(5)''' """"Florida Gators’ Omarius Hines is ‘a threat ... a weapon’,"""", ''The Miami Herald'', 8/25/10 (533 words); '''(6)''' """"Omarius Hines ready to show off his versatility with Gators"""", McClatchy-Tribune Regional News, 8/26/10 (471 words); '''(7)''' """"Gators focus on new wild card Hines could become another playmaker who is hard to pin down"""", ''The Florida Times-Union'', 8/27/10 (466 words); '''(8)''' """"Gators to take advantage of Hines' versatility"""", ''The Gainesville Sun''; '''(9)''' """"Florida Gators' Omarius Hines more than tight end"""", ''The Miami Herald'', 9/2/10 (503 words); '''(10)''' """"Omarius Hines will take over for Chris Rainey"""", ''St. Petersburg Times'', 9/5/10 (176 words); '''(11)''' """"Florida TE Omarius Hines might get call to provide offensive spark"""", ''The Florida Times-Union'', 10/17/10 (361 words); '''(12)''' """"http://www.tampabay.com/content/florida-gator-omarius-hines-ready-make-lost-time/2020262 Florida Gator Omarius Hines ready to make up for lost time"""", ''Tampa Bay Times'', 8/23/12; '''(13)''' """"UF's versatile Hines"""", ''The Gainesville Sun'', 8/27/12 (473 words); '''(14)''' """"Hines, Corsicana native, is Gators' versatile weapon"""", McClatchy-Tribune Regional News, 9/6/12 (559 words, reprinted https://www.theeagle.com/aggie_sports/football/corsicana-native-hines-is-gators-versatile-weapon/article_f16cff39-2c7d-5c71-a06d-e7a235ee423d.html here); '''(15)''' """"Versatile Hines hard to handle"""", ''The Gainesville Sun'', 10/9/12 (269 words); '''(16)''' """"Former Gators Frankie Hammond, Omarius Hines to play in All-Star game today"""", ''Tampa Bay Times'', 1/11/13 (247 words). In addition, his abuse at the hands of the Florida coaching staff was a notable point in the 2018 expose of Urban Meyer found at '''(17)''' https://www.projectveritas.com/2018/08/02/an-unfair-game-urban-meyer-a-history-of-abuse/ here""" Deletion of Omarius Hines WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15750 14733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael J. Gillis User:Eusebeus 11:19, 20 July 2007 (UTC) delete The bar is set pretty low as is; no need to engage in hard squinting (as above) to try to distinguish notability. This fails the standard and should go Deletion of Michael J. Gillis WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15751 13232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hardeek Joshi User:Pharaoh 19:36, 1 April 2020 (UTC) keep He has acted in Tujhyat Jeev Rangala is a hit and a notable TV show ongoing since 2016 with over which has run over 1100 episodes here he is the male lead. With an ongoing career see little point in delating it.Further there is coverage in the Marathi Language .With the coverage from The Times of India feel it will scrape through Deletion of Hardeek Joshi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15752 19004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of emo artists User:Divinediscourse 20:17, 19 April 2008 (UTC) delete per item 7 of and apparent difficulty in maintaining a stable page Deletion of List of emo artists WP:LC Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
15753 10477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hockey in Rochester NY User:Vrac 04:02, 10 January 2015 (UTC) delete I understand it to be a list of youth hockey teams; delete for failure of Deletion of Hockey in Rochester NY WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15754 748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Worthy to Say User:Nouse4aname 20:15, 31 May 2011 (UTC) merge to appropriate album article. Fails and . A separate article is not necessary for this song Deletion of Worthy to Say WP:MUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15755 21897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emil Balayev (2nd nomination) User:IJA 16:29, 18 January 2015 (UTC) delete Fails as he hasn't played in a |fully professional league and he doesn't have any senior international caps Deletion of Emil Balayev (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15756 14610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paula Rosenthal User:Ryan 21:37, 28 June 2011 (UTC) delete """per . When I did a search for """"Paula Rosenthal the inventor of modern sex"""" I found only wikipedia and mirror sites. A simple search for Paula Rosenthal revealed only the Wikipedia site and other unrelated Paula rosenthal's""" Deletion of Paula Rosenthal WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
15757 13330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kostas Novakis (2nd nomination) User:Pmedema 14:05, 16 May 2016 (UTC) delete Agreed. All elaborate conversations aside the article fails otability (music) and is not qualified for inclusion Deletion of Kostas Novakis (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15758 13589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zitch dog User:Coolabahapple 05:53, 8 August 2016 (UTC) delete """does not meet , a g search yields lots of you tube/personal blogs and other |no useable bits ie. """"Zitch Eastern Europe""""http://gibsongirlguides.com/brittanyinwanderland/ (cute but no), did find these: ''LA Times'' - """"Bro! Here are 'How I Met Your Mother's' best long-running jokes .. Other miscellaneous picks: ... the road trip game Zitch Dog,""""http://articles.latimes.com/2014/apr/01/entertainment/la-et-st-how-i-met-your-mother-best-longrunning-jokes-20140328/3, ''Rolling Stone'' - """"HIMYMania: The 30 Best 'How I Met Your Mother' Moments .. 15. """"I'm Gonna Be (500 Miles)"""" (Season 2, """"Arrividerci, Fiero"""") .. frizzy-haired Ted (aka Doctor X) gets his ass kicked in Zitch Dog by Marshall, a champion game player even then.""""http://www.rollingstone.com/movies/pictures/himymania-the-30-best-how-i-met-your-mother-moments-20140326/15-im-gonna-be-500-miles-season-2-arrividerci-fiero-0468415, and a book ''How I Met Your Mother and Philosophy'' - """"About The Authors: Elize de Mul gets violently competitive when playing Zitch Dog.""""https://books.google.com.au/books?id=gXiXAgAAQBAJ&pg=PT133&lpg=PT133&dq=zitch+dog&source=bl&ots=tH8esiUEat&sig=YMdG3oaxS8dDJnnHSqVQfa8yf8k&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi_w-mKirHOAhWLHZQKHQe3DEY4WhDoAQgcMAA#v=onepage&q=zitch%20dog&f=false, but not enough for a stand alone article, if need be, some extra words could be added at Car game#Car tag|Car game""" Deletion of Zitch dog WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15759 3833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sentic computing User:Jmajeremy 02:52, 7 March 2012 (UTC) delete Erik Cambria seems a little too popular in the reflist. If it contains new and information, then it could be added to the existing paragraph at Sentiment analysis#Methods Deletion of Sentic computing WP:VERIFIABLE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15760 5609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethan Clerc User:Ryan 03:41, 8 March 2017 (UTC) keep """ holds that """"If a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to be suitable for a stand-alone article or list."""" Significant coverage is defined as when the sources address the subject directly and in detail and are not a trivial mention. This is the case for all of the news articles used in the article. You describe the press as """"indiscriminate"""" and local; however, while the two articles from the Citizen are examples of local press, the articles from the ''Daily Globe'', ''Marshall Independent'', and KEYC are all large regional publications/media outlets. While Clerc is based within the circulation area of both the ''Citizen'' and the ''Daily Globe'', neither of the other two publications circulate there. {{u|duffbeerforme}}, could you elaborate on which aspect of you feel this article does not meet? """ Deletion of Ethan Clerc WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15761 14129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Needs Convenience User:BoojiBoy 13:11, 23 June 2006 (UTC) keep They're all over Atlantic Canada, passes easily Deletion of Needs Convenience WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15762 12293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sela Guia User:Bakazaka 19:34, 17 January 2019 (UTC) merge to MNL48. The group is notable under , but this member of the group is not independently notable. Notable members of other idol groups often became notable for film, television, solo work, charting with a subgroup, etc as the group becomes more prominent, but it's still early days for MNL48. Additionally, for form's sake maybe nominator {{u|Whpq}} could sort out their signature Deletion of Sela Guia WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15763 3642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enzo Martinez User:Sir 23:56, 9 April 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. The coverage of this footballer is , and he is yet to play in a fully pro league. As such, the article fails both relevant notability guidelines, namely and Deletion of Enzo Martinez WP:ROUTINE||WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15764 9304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randy Mengullo User:Cunard 08:17, 5 December 2008 (UTC) comment The information written by {{user|Jjskarate}} is very extensive, but the lack of sources about this individual, along with how knowledgeable this editor is about this topic, leads me to believe that Jjs has a |conflict of interest with this karate instructor and with this karate school. See Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JJS Karate Dojo, particularly http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/JJS_Karate_Dojo&diff=prev&oldid=253549021 this edit for evidence Deletion of Randy Mengullo WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
15765 20265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trader Sam's Enchanted Tiki Bar User:RightCowLeftCoast 02:49, 15 September 2018 (UTC) keep subject appears to meet requirements set forth in as it has received significant in depth coverage in multiple reliable sources, not limited to the ones already stated above, but as well as in https://medium.com/@austincarroll/the-story-behind-disneylands-enchanted-tiki-bar-trader-sam-s-5016a561af3c ''Medium'', https://www.ocweekly.com/orange-countys-tiki-bars-of-the-past-and-present-help-you-to-forget-about-your-boring-life/ ''OC Weekly'', https://www.ocregister.com/2012/03/02/be-careful-what-you-order-and-where-you-sit-at-trader-sams/ ''OC Register'', and surely others Deletion of Trader Sam's Enchanted Tiki Bar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15766 4705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joel Chukwuma Obi User:GiantSnowman 04:29, 9 July 2010 (UTC) delete fails and , recreate if/when player becomes notable Deletion of Joel Chukwuma Obi WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15767 9167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noemi Letizia User:Greg 16:26, 2 June 2009 (UTC) delete predominantly Deletion of Noemi Letizia WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15768 20475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Front User:Location 00:48, 25 June 2010 (UTC) keep """Notable racist group easily passes . Searching """"American Front"""" + """"skinhead"""", I find lots of http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22American+Front%22+%22skinhead%22&btnG=Search+Archives&ned=us&hl=en&scoring=a GNews hits from the late 80s to early 90s related to related to many different unrelated events, as well as 183 http://www.google.com/search?q=%22American%20Front%22%20%22skinhead%22&ned=us&hl=en&tbo=u&tbs=bks:1&source=og&sa=N&tab=np GBooks hits. Plenty of other independent references including the Anti-Defamation League|ADLhttp://www.adl.org/learn/ext_us/american_front/default.asp?LEARN_Cat=Extremism&LEARN_SubCat=Extremism_in_America&xpicked=3&item=american_front and the Southern Poverty Law Centerhttp://www.splcenter.org/get-informed/intelligence-report/browse-all-issues/2006/summer/a-skinheads-secret""" Deletion of American Front WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15769 4344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Civilian perspectives on media freedom User:Dennisthe2 16:44, 26 April 2012 (UTC) delete We are |not for essays Deletion of Civilian perspectives on media freedom WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15770 16285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emer O'Loughlin User:David 00:58, 23 October 2008 (UTC) delete per . I don't see anything in this article that would make this case noteworthy among the many tragic unsolved murder cases that exist Deletion of Emer O'Loughlin WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15771 449 [[Christoph 23]] (erledigt, geloescht) Benutzer:Ulz NONE delete Widergänger vom /11._Juli_2006#Christoph_23_.28gel.C3.B6scht.29|11. Juli Löschung von Christoph 23 Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15772 8208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Future Earth (TV series) User:MarnetteD 04:45, 28 July 2015 (UTC) delete A show that never entered production has a hard time meeting Deletion of Future Earth (TV series) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15773 968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swahili Imports User:Xymmax 13:52, 3 December 2007 (UTC) delete per , the company doesn't seem to be notable Deletion of Swahili Imports WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15774 10715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nibblecode User:Nonstopdrivel 20:15, 23 June 2007 (UTC) delete for failure to assert notability in violation of . Interesting as the proposal may be, this is probably |original research, and may fall into the category of |stuff made up in school in one day. There are precisely two Ghits on this term, one of which is the article itself Deletion of Nibblecode WP:N||WP:OR||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15775 15248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EqualityMaine User:Joe 01:22, 10 April 2011 (UTC) keep I added a few things I found to the article, there's a fair bit more, but certainly in comparison with the last AfD I !voted in, this subject has a veritable treasure-trove of sourcing. As a result, I believe it demonstrates notability under and . I'll look and see if the appropriate redirects from older names exist Deletion of EqualityMaine WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15776 16960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marilyn K. Jones User:David 02:20, 11 September 2011 (UTC) delete The article fails to make any assertion of notability, and provides no sources that could pass . Additionally, I suspect that it conflates more than one person with the same name. There's a Marilyn K. Jones who has a reasonable citation record on the subject of women and alcoholism, but that's not a subject one would expect a dentist to publish on, and there's a different Marilyn K. Jones (now http://apps.mni.mcgill.ca/research/jonesgotman/ Marilyn Jones-Gotman) who looks more likely to be the expert on that subject. If we can't even verify that we're talking about a single person or multiple unrelated people, we shouldn't have an article Deletion of Marilyn K. Jones WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15777 18632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The October User:Cwmhiraeth 12:29, 15 September 2017 (UTC) delete Fails . This article seems to be about a future film of an experimental nature and an article may be apopropriate when the film is in production but not at this early stage Deletion of The October WP:NFO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15778 1198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Newfoundland and Labrador First Party User:DorisH 18:39, 12 March 2007 (UTC) keep I read the same way other users have done above and then I think any party that has gotten any votes in an election should be encyclopedic. However, I tend to support Arkyan's idea to have a Minor parties in Canada article Deletion of Newfoundland and Labrador First Party WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15779 17417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DelFest User:Phantomsteve 02:00, 25 August 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of DelFest WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15780 174 [[Christoph Wilke]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Bennsenson/Warum Socken an die Füße gehören 20:49, 20. Apr. 2011 (CEST) delete Der Antragsteller hat alles Wesentliche gesagt. Zu ergänzen wäre noch, dass hier gleich dutzendfach billiges name dropping betrieben wurde, um Relevanz zu suggerieren. Ganz klar . Falls der Single-Purpose-Account, der den Artikel erstellt hat, tatsächlich von Herrn Wilke selbst ist, was der Benutzername nahelegt, sei ihm zur Lektüre #Eigendarstellung|WP:Eigendarstellung empfohlen Löschung von Christoph Wilke Wikipedia:Interessenkonflikt Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
15781 20111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Superbike World Championship season User:Junkcops 13:20, 28 January 2009 (UTC) comment May will be re-AFC after end of the 2009 series? And is this a violation of Deletion of 2010 Superbike World Championship season WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15782 4940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Smith (racing driver) User:Willsome429 19:00, 1 May 2020 (UTC) keep a search turned up coverage from https://www.foxsports.com/nascar/story/drive-for-diversity-profile-jonathan-smith-012209 Fox Sports and https://blacksportsonline.com/2013/03/bso-interview-with-up-and-coming-nascar-driver-jonathan-smith/ Black Sports Online, as well as PR churns from https://speedwaydigest.com/index.php/news/xfinity-series-news/14679-jorkai-motorsports-to-run-jonathan-smith-in-the-nascar-nationwide-series Speedway Digest and https://bleacherreport.com/articles/113241-baby-its-cold-outside-but-jonathan-smith-is-turning-up-the-heat Bleacher Report, and passing mentions from https://bleacherreport.com/articles/114231-nascar-drive-for-diversity-lineup-announced Bleacher Report and https://theundefeated.com/features/bubba-wallace-nascar-diversity-program-working-or-struggling/ The Undefeated. When I have more time, I will conduct a more extensive search for sources Deletion of Jonathan Smith (racing driver) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15783 21198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transition of education in Japan User:Nyttend 14:04, 24 December 2014 (UTC) delete per unless someone feels like doing a complete rewrite Deletion of Transition of education in Japan WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
15784 6303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bay Alarm Medical User:Northamerica1000 01:00, 14 May 2012 (UTC) delete Not finding significant coverage in reliable sources for this company. Therefore, the topic appears at this time to fail Wikipedia's |General notability guideline for inclusion in the encyclopedia Deletion of Bay Alarm Medical WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15785 16930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aquaretics User:Tanthalas39 23:10, 26 December 2007 (UTC) keep """I don't believe that objects need to adhere to the same guidelines as people; classes of drugs do not need to win awards or be repeatedly cited by mainstream periodicals. In the ote summary """"A topic is presumed to be notable if it has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject"""", the only word here that can really be debated is """"significant"""". I think that Oxford University Press is significant and reliable, and the others aren't easily dismissed""" Deletion of Aquaretics WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15786 4244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Guinean films of 1994 User:Atlantic306 18:48, 11 November 2018 (UTC) merge as above, does not pass LIST,thanks Deletion of List of Guinean films of 1994 WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15787 9469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Synergy Pharmaceuticals (2nd nomination) User:User3749 11:51, 22 September 2020 (UTC) delete I think this article is definitely |promotional. Looking at the https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&page=Synergy+Pharmaceuticals deletion log for this page, I can tell that this is a recreate Deletion of Synergy Pharmaceuticals (2nd nomination) WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15788 10174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liam O'Donnell User:Comatmebro 22:09, 3 November 2016 (UTC) delete Per nom, subject fails and secondary sources are not reliable enough to establish notability Deletion of Liam O'Donnell WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
15789 21834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robe. User:Kinu 07:19, 18 December 2006 (UTC) delete a band created at some point this year with self-produced MP3 tracks and online reviews attributed to non-media sources doesn't meet . Quite possibly a text dump of their Myspace page Deletion of Robe. WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15790 4454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of wars between democracies User:Robofish 00:55, 19 July 2010 (UTC) merge to Democratic peace theory, or '''Delete'''. This article seems to have and issues; at the very least, it should be renamed to List of alleged wars between democracies, as the inclusion of some or all of the conflicts here is contentious. Preferably though, it should be merged into Democratic peace theory as a list of alleged counterexamples, but only the parts that are sufficiently referenced as such Deletion of List of wars between democracies WP:POV||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15791 8843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Easter Eggs in Grand Theft Auto User:B 18:44, 9 June 2008 (UTC) delete per (plot summaries, manual or guidebook, original research Deletion of Easter Eggs in Grand Theft Auto WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15792 8261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Mophun games User:Videogameplayer99 23:57, 6 December 2020 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of List of Mophun games WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15793 20267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jody Raffoul User:Bearcat 18:35, 6 February 2018 (UTC) delete Nothing here passes — a concert tour has to be supported by |reliable source coverage ''about'' the tour, not just asserted, to count as a ''notable'' tour that makes its artist wikipediable, and nothing else stated here even ''attempts'' to pass any other criterion at all — and this isn't reliably sourced. The only properly footnoted reference is a press release on a concert listings platform, not a reliable or notability-assisting media outlet, and the only other source here is a BBC News article, linkfarmed as an external link rather than being cited as a footnote, which isn't ''about'' Jody Raffoul, but merely mentions him in passing within an article about the general economic travails of Detroit. So that's not a source that actually demonstrates Raffoul's notability either. I also think either I might be having a stroke or somebody needs to go hunting, because I could literally ''swear'' that we've seen an article come to AFD before about a musician from Detroit whose main notability claim was getting to open for Bon Jovi Deletion of Jody Raffoul WP:NMUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15794 5089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Decades in Colour User:MichaelQSchmidt 01:35, 7 April 2015 (UTC) delete per being |TOO SOON. Even though we might consider an official New Zealand http://www.nzonair.govt.nz/news/articles/colourful-line-up-of-programmes-get-the-green-light/ government source reliable enough, the un-aired project lacks enough other coverage to meet | (paragraph 3 Deletion of Decades in Colour WP:NYF||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
15795 9373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quake Wars: Ray Traced User:Zxcvbnm 08:46, 1 August 2020 (UTC) delete A non-notable tech demo that fails Deletion of Quake Wars: Ray Traced WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15796 8029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emmett Brown User:Shooterwalker 16:32, 10 October 2011 (UTC) keep there's some sources beginning to appear here. The 100 greatest movie characters list does begin to . Ideally there would be more sources to give a sense of weight, so we can tell what's important about this character instead of just piling on details. No prejudice against a merge if further sources aren't found Deletion of Emmett Brown WP:verify notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
15797 3553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Davenport (rock band) NONE NONE delete Article created by band, one Google hit for band name + (probably self-released) album title, does not meet Deletion of Davenport (rock band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15798 2115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Customary stone user:Andrew 12:49, 3 February 2015 (UTC) merge into stone (unit). As explained at that article, there were a large variety of stone weights used through Europe and the UK. The ''customary stone'' here was a popular weight used by butchers which was 8 pounds of meat or cheese. This appeared in tables of weights and measures in works such as https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=TUMsAAAAMAAJ&pg=PA423 Whitaker's Almanac, where it was contrasted with the legal stone of 14 pounds, which was commonly known as the ''horseman's weight'' because it was used to weigh jockeys in handicap races. tells us to bring topics together by their meaning and the stone (unit) page seems to be best place to cover all this Deletion of Customary stone WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
15799 6253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khalil El-Amin User:Ejgreen77 07:06, 24 January 2020 (UTC) delete Fails , , , and Deletion of Khalil El-Amin WP:GNG||WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:NCOLLATH||WP:CRIMINAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15800 18242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danagog User:Ttonyb1 16:06, 18 June 2010 (UTC) delete ndash; Non-notable individual lacking GHits and GNEWS of substance. Appears to fail and Deletion of Danagog WP:BIO||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15801 16331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wicked (energy drink) User:Kudpung 04:15, 27 September 2010 (UTC) keep Energy drinks'' is a recognised category. As long as the article is not a blatant advert it shoud be kept for possible expansion and appropriate tags should be aded. Other articles in this cat also have little more content. See 180 (drink). (BTW, I ''do'' know about Deletion of Wicked (energy drink) WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15802 17632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Un-convention User:Murph9000 21:33, 1 October 2016 (UTC) delete """without prejudice to creation via AfC draft process, with clear notability. Per nom and all above. Good luck to them on ever SEO-ing their way above a gazillion pages talking about the """"United Nations Convention"""" on everything. I'm not certain, but I think this article is basically an advert for a probably not-yet-notable startup company that possibly didn't think through their name in terms of search engines. It might not be an attempt at an advert, as there's too little there to reach much of a firm conclusion other than on lack of notability. It does meet A7|CSD A7, but I'm content to just let the AfD run""" Deletion of Un-convention WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15803 8985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MAGAkids incident User:Sir 16:16, 25 January 2019 (UTC) keep I have since revised my initial opinion on this matter and believe this incident is deserving of its own article. The fact is this event happened when three separate groups - March for Life, Indigenous Peoples March, and the Black Israelite group - all came together and this incident occurred. To say this event should be merged as a subset of the Indigenous Peoples March page to me goes against because it would downplay this event's notability. Most people's interest in this matter seems to comes from the incident itself, not that it occurred in conjunction with the Indigenous Peoples March Deletion of MAGAkids incident WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15804 10440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Town of Odyssey User:Starblind 20:18, 5 May 2007 (UTC) delete per , content is ludicrously trivial (i.e. a list of forum moderators). An external link in the main article would be okay, and I see that's already in place Deletion of The Town of Odyssey WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
15805 3038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nash Engineering Company User:VMS 23:54, 1 August 2015 (UTC) keep as passing Deletion of Nash Engineering Company WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15806 664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gnuboy User:MuZemike 05:37, 26 August 2008 (UTC) delete this looks a lot like many of the video game articles out there. In addition, this borders on Deletion of Gnuboy WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
15807 18867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fleur Beale User:Esradekan 01:48, 20 July 2008 (UTC) keep http://www.bookcouncil.org.nz/writers/bealefleur.html NZ Book Council site confirming awards, and http://www.bookcouncil.org.nz/events/awards/nzpostfinalistwinners.html here too, also http://www.longacre.co.nz/awards.html this one, but I'm not 100% it's , but it does cover off . Enough to pass notability per Deletion of Fleur Beale WP:RS||WP:V||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15808 11227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticism of Hugo Chávez (3rd nomination) User:Niteshift36 04:15, 29 June 2009 (UTC) delete I dont like the guy one bit, but this is a clear Deletion of Criticism of Hugo Chávez (3rd nomination) WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
15809 2130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eileen Davies User:Pmedema 16:50, 13 July 2008 (UTC) delete simply fails and therefore fails Deletion of Eileen Davies WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15810 11241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Árni Guldborg Nielsen User:Sir 16:38, 3 October 2014 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Árni Guldborg Nielsen WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15811 3202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Almshouse Road (road in Bucks County, Pennsylvania, USA) User:Imzadi1979 21:59, 17 October 2016 (UTC) delete as a failure to meet for an independent topic. Assuming ''ad arguendo'' for a moment that this were retained, the title would need to be simplified, and the prose would need to be fixed to comply with the expectations of encyclopedic writing style Deletion of Almshouse Road (road in Bucks County, Pennsylvania, USA) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15812 15939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Immaculate Conception Of Saint Joseph User:Edison 03:56, 15 August 2013 (UTC) delete """Poorly referenced fringe religious beliefs held by only a handful of people do not require encyclopedia articles and do not require some artificial """"balance"""" of pro and con writers. Stating some bit of particular nonsense, then stating that """"it is a minority position within the Catholic Church"""" violates """ Deletion of Immaculate Conception Of Saint Joseph WP:DUEWEIGHT Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15813 2374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Principal clock User:Footlessmouse 21:17, 29 October 2020 (UTC) delete per . If moving the content to Wikitionary is an option, go for it, but remove the page from this encyclopedia, as it is not a dictionary Deletion of Principal clock WP:NOTDICT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
15814 3995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Global Surgical Consortium User:Dps04 12:35, 14 June 2016 (UTC) delete this article, at least in its current form, per Deletion of The Global Surgical Consortium WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15815 17881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Forced Entry (band) [[User talk:TenPoundHammer|What did I screw up now?]]) 17:27, 22 January 2015 (UTC) keep per efforts from all involved. '''Ten Pound Hammer Deletion of Forced Entry (band) WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
15816 14421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/August 2010 rocket attack on Eilat/Aqaba (2nd nomination) User:Tarc 14:18, 23 September 2010 (UTC) delete """just the same as AfD #1 which unfortunately was brought to DRV for """"I disagree with the result"""" reasons"""". This is WP:NOTNEWS|news, this is not a significant or historic event. Maybe it's a sad commentary on the state of world affairs that such attacks are considered almost routine news, but that's the way it is. The Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, not a vehicle to prop up importance of one's personal causes and interests. Elevating this |event to an article does exactly that. If appropriate, reuse/recycle some of the sources in a larger article on Israeli-Palestine conflicts""" Deletion of August 2010 rocket attack on Eilat/Aqaba (2nd nomination) WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15817 10 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Niğde Fen Lisesi Kullanıcı:seksen iki yüz kırk beşseksen iki yüz kırk beş / ggt 21.36, 30 Ekim 2021 (UTC) keep VP:OKUL yönergesinde açıkça belirtildiği üzere fen liseleri M6'dan silinemez, topluluk kararı gerekir. Daha önce de başka adaylıklarda belirttiğim üzere, gerekçelerde hızlı silinsin kullanıldığında bu her zaman argümanı güçlendirmiyor, bazen yönerge incelemesinin veya kaynak taramasının detaylı yapılmadığını düşündürerek görüşe daha az ağırlık verilmesini sağlıyor, en azından benim için böyle. VP:OKUL kriterlerine baktığımızda, #6 doğrudan karşılanıyor. #8 de, Niğde ilindeki ilk fen lisesi olması dolayısıyla karşılanıyor (zaten ilde iki tane var, bu lise 1990'da açılmış, Bor'daki ise 2011'de açılmış). Bu durumda kriterlerini karşıladığından doğru olacaktır Niğde Fen Lisesinin silinmesi Vikipedi:OKUL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15818 6212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alfonso Chartier User:Jayden54 22:02, 19 December 2006 (UTC) delete """Although the article makes some vague claims of notability (""""a professional gamer"""") I can't find a lot of reliable sources through either http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Alfonso%20Chartier%22 Google or http://news.google.com/news?q=%22Alfonso%20Chartier%22 Google News, so this person appears to fail """ Deletion of Alfonso Chartier WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15819 6616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Marick User:onel5969 21:35, 7 December 2016 (UTC) delete he is accomplished, but I don't if I'd say he had made a significant contribution. Searches did not turn up enough to show they pass Deletion of Brian Marick WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15820 6260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maheshinte Prathikaaram: Original Score User:Anupmehra 23:18, 27 October 2016 (UTC) delete Fails . If you can find a |reliable source or two, write it about in Maheshinte Prathikaaram (soundtrack) or Maheshinte Prathikaaram articles. Two albums of a single film are not totally independent of each other. Write in there that score album was released XX days after soundtrack or on DDMMYYYY. Gaana, Saavan, itunes, etc. are not going to justify this standalone piece. Note that, |notability is not inherited Deletion of Maheshinte Prathikaaram: Original Score WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
15821 15974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tesshin Okada User:KartikeyaS343 07:11, 2 March 2020 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Tesshin Okada WP:NBOX Wikipedia:Notability 77
15822 738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hbomberguy User:Onetwothreeip 01:35, 22 January 2019 (UTC) keep """per User:Ihaveacatonmydesk and for being covered in multiple sources for multiple events. Proposer is likely only familiar with the recent """"charity stream"""" and not Brewis' other notabilities. Article may need a title change too""" Deletion of Hbomberguy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15823 10156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of programs broadcast by Colors User:Postdlf 17:10, 17 July 2015 (UTC) keep """as noted by TRPoD, it is standard to index notable television series by their network of original broadcast. These are not """"directory listings"""" but are rather of historical value, being a significant fact about both the series and the networks that satisfies and (as a complement to :Category:Colors (TV channel) series), not to mention fully compliant with as per its intro (""""Wikipedia encompasses many lists of links to articles within Wikipedia that are used for internal organization or to describe a notable subject. In that sense, Wikipedia functions as an index or directory of its own content."""") and item 4 (""""historically significant program lists and schedules may be acceptable""""). This misconception unfortunately recurs periodically. Nominators really need to read the whole text (not to mention look at general practice) before concluding something is """"in violation"""" of it, and not just latch on to key words or catchphrases""" Deletion of List of programs broadcast by Colors WP:LISTPURP||WP:CLN||WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
15824 9118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Environmental impacts of pig farming User:Seraphim 18:06, 14 April 2017 (UTC) keep Environmental impact of meat production is general and does not include specifics of any industry (pig, cattle, etc.) - the article needs a rewrite and I think it should be templated. The title is and the subject is notable, this has also been a major issue in China in recent years documented by like Reuters, The Economist, The Guardian - I don't think AfD is a substitute for editing and improving an article that currently has problems Deletion of Environmental impacts of pig farming WP:NPOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15825 20992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J Stalin User:Gwernol 01:28, 22 February 2008 (UTC) keep the SF Bay Guardian is a perfectly acceptable |source. There is enough here to provide |notability Deletion of J Stalin WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15826 11185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Winslet (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 19:49, 19 September 2012 (UTC) comment she hasn't gotten many reviews of her own work, from what I see; it appears that she may be |just famous for being someone famous's sister. I'd support its retention if someone could get good sources Deletion of Anna Winslet (2nd nomination) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15827 18647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Bleach episodes (season 11) User:Guest9999 21:20, 10 January 2009 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is #CBALL|not a crystal ball, there doesn't appear to be any substantial information about the season at this time apart from an a list on upcoming episode titles. When the episodes have aired or sufficient information has become available the article can be recreated Deletion of List of Bleach episodes (season 11) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15828 14605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Snowball Fight Techniques User:Doc 16:38, 16 March 2008 (UTC) delete as #HOWTO|Wikipedia isn't a how-to guide. Also filled with |original research Deletion of Snowball Fight Techniques WP:NOT||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15829 21106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cover me (urban legend) User:Edison 15:33, 13 December 2011 (UTC) delete Fails |notability as an urban legend, and seems like a |dictionary definition Deletion of Cover me (urban legend) WP:N||WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15830 12576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CLAWS [[User talk:129.21.179.32|talk]]) 00:17, 1 April 2009 (UTC) delete Does not meet general notability. Sourced only from http://www.unifieddiff.com/ the project's own webpage and http://www.unifieddiff.com/ one of the project members' blogs. Two attempts to solicit have failed: http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=CLAWS&diff=279701418&oldid=279684959 first by removal, then http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=CLAWS&diff=next&oldid=280301626 by sourcing a conference announcement. —Special:Contributions/129.21.179.32|129.21.179.32 Deletion of CLAWS WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15831 2591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dhadak (song) [[User talk:Usernamekiran|'''(talk)''']] 19:36, 22 July 2018 (UTC) delete a few mentions in independent , but most of the other coverage is from the websites that cover almost every song. Fails . —usernamekiran Deletion of Dhadak (song) WP:RS||WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15832 1513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Little User:Resolute 00:17, 27 March 2007 (UTC) delete nonsense, likely , probable hoax. Reads like a very poorly written autobiography Deletion of Chris Little WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
15833 18227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annabel Ritchie User:NealeFamily 06:39, 18 August 2012 (UTC) keep As per because she has competed at International Rowing Events. Has sufficient media coverage from reliable sources - her concerns with any inaccuracy could be easily addressed by editing the article. A quick Google search seems to verify the information in the article as it presently stands. There does not seem to be anything that is not already in the public arena Deletion of Annabel Ritchie WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15834 8595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Galveston.com & company User:GregJackP 04:35, 5 June 2010 (UTC) comment yup, if it is not notable, it doesn't belong here. See Deletion of Galveston.com & company WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15835 10093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Running List of Euphemisms for Penis in Email Spam User:Doc 20:26, 8 March 2008 (UTC) delete not encyclopedic, filled with |original research. Looks like it could be a |spam magnet Deletion of Running List of Euphemisms for Penis in Email Spam WP:OR||WP:BEANS Wikipedia:No original research 65
15836 1044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Astro (television) User:Narutolovehinata5 02:25, 16 December 2017 (UTC) keep but stubify to a neutral state - Although I'm not Malaysian, I am aware of the company as being one of the biggest, if not the biggest television service provider in Malaysia, and a search confirms this status and results in coverage for the company: enough to pass . However, the article is quite a mess and is essentially a promotional piece; as such, if the article is to be kept, the closer or any other editor should probably reduced the article to a short neutrally-worded stub then work from there. Basically without destroying the building Deletion of Astro (television) WP:NCORP||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15837 187 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Andıç olayı Kullanıcı:yurekli74yürekli 16:12, 28 Temmuz 2008 (UTC) delete Bkz. Andıç olayının silinmesi Vikipedi:VPND Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15838 12551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Logos and uniforms of the Cleveland Browns User:Stuartyeates 10:31, 7 September 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Logos and uniforms of the Cleveland Browns WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15839 16998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Hoffman (businessman) User:Dhartung 20:48, 23 October 2007 (UTC) keep based on LavaMind, which is a possible article. Some of his other roles are not as notable or simply behind the scenes, though he's clearly well-regarded by his peers Deletion of Steve Hoffman (businessman) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15840 21668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randle McMurphy User:TreasuryTag 15:17, 22 July 2011 (UTC) merge into One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest (novel) – let's be clear about this: unless anyone can cite |significant coverage of this particular character then he does not satisfy the |GNG and that is that Deletion of Randle McMurphy WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15841 3605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Knowles (footballer) (3rd nomination) User:GiantSnowman 21:51, 19 June 2012 (UTC) delete hasn't played in a pro league and not enough significant coverage, fails and Deletion of James Knowles (footballer) (3rd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15842 20405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Novus Consulting User:Jacqui 23:58, 4 November 2005 (UTC) comment I'm not sure it meets , but at the same time, to me it doesn't look anything like a flier or anything like that. I think a lot of time and effort actually went into this page, and we should spend the same time and effort researching it before we take it away. I think the recent edits have helped a lot Deletion of Novus Consulting WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15843 7304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brooks Powell User:Daniel 00:32, 21 October 2006 (UTC) delete per . A google search of his name and the battle he was in brings up nothing reliable, though it does bring up some information about him, so it may not be a complete hoax Deletion of Brooks Powell WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15844 16174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karen Sparks User:Rms125a 22:41, 2 July 2015 (UTC) delete does not meet threshold for |notability as an EQUESTRIAN|equestrian Deletion of Karen Sparks WP:N||WP:NEQUESTRIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
15845 16377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alberto Miná User:Mdtemp 18:36, 15 January 2014 (UTC) delete Non-notable as an MMA fighter, losing a first round fight at the Abu Dhabi Pro championship isn't enough to meet , and doesn't meet Deletion of Alberto Miná WP:MANOTE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15846 6859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sylvie Silva (2nd nomination) User:Anachronist 05:30, 22 September 2019 (UTC) comment This article was deleted on 17 September in accordance with because it was created by a banned user. Then on 21 September it was re-created by {{user|Triila73}}. All of the history has been restored so anyone can examine it. '''The new version from 9/21 is dissimilar to the deleted version from 9/6''' and in spite of a sockpuppet of the banned user returning to edit the new version, it remains substantially different. Therefore, the rationale of this nomination isn't valid Deletion of Sylvie Silva (2nd nomination) WP:G5 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15847 1533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mulan (2020 film) User:Nkon21 02:09, 24 July 2020 (UTC) keep film should be kept per . This film has received plenty of reliable and significant coverage and it had already premiered in Hollywood. It would be quite ridiculous to simply delete it Deletion of Mulan (2020 film) WP:NFP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15848 729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ehrman Mitchell User:power 17:10, 4 January 2018 (UTC) keep """I think GNG (and possibly ) is met. https://books.google.com/books?id=Jh7ecV24_uAC&pg=PA637&lpg=PA637&dq=Ehrman+B.+Mitchell&source=bl&ots=q3pfJAsqdW&sig=kmZ5RcKLV0ovzpkPB8N40CT1YZA&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiPnIeU5b7YAhWC6oMKHdu_DjY4ChDoAQgqMAE#v=onepage&q=Ehrman%20B.%20Mitchell&f=false (from the Almanac of Architecture & Design, which I can't vouch for), http://pcad.lib.washington.edu/person/987/ (Pacific Coast Architecture Database, which isn't user-generated but does include """"relatively unknown and unhearlded designers""""), and https://www.nps.gov/parkhistory/online_books/allaback/vc2a.htm (National Park Service bio) are all significant coverage""" Deletion of Ehrman Mitchell WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15849 9302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glen atwell User:Nelgsta 13:31, 12 August 2006 (UTC) keep I am the author of this article. Glen writes for newspapers in Melbourne. he does the VFL show on Sundays on radio. While far from a national identity, thousands of people search his name to find and read articles, mostly those related to sport. The radio show coincides with the broadcast of a VFL match and 3SER's coverage rivals SEN1116 for ratings. Glen hosts the Sunday Roast and interviews people from AFL clubs (eg. David King last weekend). He also does boundary riding for the VFL radio broadcasts and I believe is notorious for being involved in newsworthy events . Try a Google search test! http://www.google.com.au/search?hl=en&safe=off&q=glen+atwell&btnG=Search&meta=cr%3DcountryAU Glen Atwell - Google Australia. Looks like he also writes for http://www.cool.com.au Cool Australia Deletion of Glen atwell WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15850 14087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Everest Brand Solutions User:Marquardtika 03:29, 3 October 2018 (UTC) delete No to meet Deletion of Everest Brand Solutions WP:SIGCOV||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15851 8006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erdős–Bacon number (3rd nomination) User:Winged 15:33, 22 March 2017 (UTC) keep Easily passes .And it's not a hoax Deletion of Erdős–Bacon number (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15852 18755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Metea Valley High School User:Tellyaddict 17:59, 17 March 2007 (UTC) keep Well the article has refs so it now meets and it also passes Deletion of Metea Valley High School WP:V||WP:SCHOOL Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15853 16511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/T. G. Baynes Solicitors User:Belovedfreak 16:43, 15 August 2011 (UTC) delete I can't find any significant coverage in |reliable sources, and nothing on their website that suggests to me that they meet Wikipedia:Notability (organizations and companies) or Wikipedia:Notability. Notable cases do not make the firm notable, since notability is not inherited Deletion of T. G. Baynes Solicitors WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15854 5261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marco Del Rossi User:Protonk 23:44, 19 September 2008 (UTC) delete I am given no indication that this or any other deletion represents some watershed event. The nominator is just adding deletion nominations and merge suggestions of fictional subjects one by one. No part of that is some broad scheme to force us to make a proxy decision for every article out there. This particular article cites no sources (and hasn't for 6 months), covers a fictional subject in a manner that is entirely |plot repetition and http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Marco+Del+Rossi%22+-wikipedia+-wiki+-myspace&btnG=Search appears to http://books.google.com/books?id=CFXgj7a55agC&pg=PA679&dq=%22Marco+Del+Rossi%22&ei=rDjUSKjbFYzaigGTjP3mAw&sig=ACfU3U1ODeO6GpPhTwRbiOzt9goLyZrKFA receive at best trivial coverage from http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tab=pn&q=%22Marco+Del+Rossi%22 reliable sources Deletion of Marco Del Rossi WP:PLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15855 5983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle of Az Zawiyah User:Anotherclown 08:36, 27 February 2011 (UTC) delete """Currently this topic lacks """"signfificant independent coverage"""" under . As such merge the little cited information to a parent article like 2011 Libyan uprising and ditch the rest""" Deletion of Battle of Az Zawiyah WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15856 9595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christoapokalypsisperihopreteriteprotocenturiaworldjewryology User:StAnselm 19:14, 1 May 2015 (UTC) delete This perhaps sets a record for being the most neo- of |neologisms Deletion of Christoapokalypsisperihopreteriteprotocenturiaworldjewryology WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
15857 10044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kathleen Maltzahn User:Bearcat 23:54, 9 June 2014 (UTC) delete per nom. While it's certainly ''possible'' that she ''might'' meet another notability rule as Oakshade suggests, ''this'' article as written does ''not'' adequately demonstrate that. Almost every source cited in the article is a |primary or |unreliable one — her own website, the websites of organizations she's involved in, her own Twitter account, and on and so forth — and virtually ''none'' of it is sourced to ''media coverage'' substantive enough to actually get her past any of our notability rules (no, not even has been surpassed here.) No prejudice against future recreation ''if'' someone can write and source a version that actually properly establishes and properly sources whatever notability she might have as a writer, but ''this'' version fails to do so and is not entitled to stick around in this form just because Oakshade ''asserts'' that she has more notability than the article has demonstrated Deletion of Kathleen Maltzahn WP:PRIMARYSOURCE||WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:No original research 65
15858 15997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Davidson Wilson User:MelanieN 18:08, 10 February 2011 (UTC) delete Non-notable. He was one of the seven founders of a society which qualifies as notable under Wikipedia guidelines, but that does not make him individually notable. Notability requires significant coverage by independent reliable sources, which I have not seen and cannot find. This article is part of a alled garden of articles about the Phi Alpha Literary Society, and IMO the separate articles about the founders should be deleted unless they are shown to be notable for something else. Their mention in the primary article is enough Deletion of Robert Davidson Wilson WP:W Help:Watchlist 110
15859 10969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Navicoder User:Joe 22:46, 3 January 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of Navicoder WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15860 8813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Major Saab User:Gene93k 14:11, 8 December 2008 (UTC) comment and '''question'''. The article was re-created after speedy. The new stub article appears to fix the main problems cited in the nomination and comments above. Since is a separate issue, is a '''procedural close''' in order? This is unusual Deletion of Major Saab WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
15861 8726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vijoo Krishnan User:Boneso 04:49, 30 May 2018 (UTC) keep The article, as is stood at the time of nomination, was poor and deserved the nomination. There are a number of references providing a history of Krishnan's activities in the Indian media. His activities prior to the long march did not gain as much media attention as the long march, but they are reported in reliable sources. Information about his student union activities are scarce on the web and may be stuck in a library well out of my reach. The fact that he motivated up to 50K farmers to march for 3 days in a protest speaks for his notability in India, he is the youngest member of the central committee of the Communist Party of India (Marxist) and the joint secretary of the All India Kisan Sabha the largest farmers' organisation in the country. He is about to embark on an ambitious political campaign to relieve the plight of farmers in India, and if his plan comes together it will receive international media coverage. I have improved the article with some material but there is so much more available. I am not from India and do not have enough of an understanding of Indian politics to make worthy additions. Hopefully the creator of the article {{ping|User:Shagil_Kannur}} might be able to help out. While notability is borderline, I have added 7 new references and another editor has added an infobox with a photo. |WP:People notable for only one event no longer applies Deletion of Vijoo Krishnan WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
15862 14407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burragubba User:Euryalus 22:26, 22 September 2008 (UTC) keep Thank you to Lankiviel for locating the secondary sources, which I added to the article yesterday. There is sufficient coverage of Burragubba (mostly for his politics) to narrowly meet the |biography notability criteria - the school page is a little weak but the ABC and AAP stories are genuine secondary sources. I appreciate these weren't in the article at the time of the AfD nomination, and trust the nominator's concern is now addressed Deletion of Burragubba WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15863 21617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mahavir Singh User:Piotrus 16:51, 2 January 2018 (UTC) delete Unreferenced. Nothing in the bio suggests he would pass anyway Deletion of Mahavir Singh WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15864 10134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Chachoua User:Delta13C 09:58, 4 February 2016 (UTC) comment """The argument to support either delete or redirect has never been about allegations of being a """"quack."""" The argument has always been about , as there is a gaping paucity of reliable sources prior to his run in with Charlie Sheen. Just because Sheen found this guy does not justify Chachoua's notability. Editors have used the word """"quack"""" as shorthand within the confines of the discussion not argumentation for any outcome of the AfD""" Deletion of Sam Chachoua WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15865 20633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Locked Door (2012 film) User:Ammarpad 12:02, 31 October 2017 (UTC) delete as this is clear , since the article at present obviously fails , and the person who deprodded it has made no attempt |to improve it Deletion of The Locked Door (2012 film) WP:SOFTDELETE||WP:NFILM||WP:HEY Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
15866 8388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julia Shaw (psychologist) User:K 04:16, 26 October 2017 (UTC) keep meets in my mind, irrespective of . Sample coverage http://www.wired.co.uk/article/false-memory-syndrome-false-confessions-memories ''Wired'', etc Deletion of Julia Shaw (psychologist) WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15867 10449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Hamilton Scobell User:Bearian 23:17, 7 February 2017 (UTC) comment after 10 years hear, I've been a big fan of , but I also feel that any controversial deletions need to be discussed here for seven days. A reasonable argument could be made that she's notable as a royal-hanger-on Deletion of Mary Hamilton Scobell WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15868 18829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Sauermann User:Lukeno94 15:44, 14 May 2013 (UTC) keep Nomination by a brand-new user that is purely and - no policy-based reason for deletion Deletion of Lisa Sauermann WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:NOTNOTABLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15869 11950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Undercover: The True Story of Britain's Secret Police User:AusLondonder 14:30, 13 May 2015 (UTC) keep Creator) Unfortunately, this appears to be yet another clearly vexatious nomination. Per , before nominating an article for deletion an editor is required to 'Search for additional sources, if the main concern is notability' which does not seem to have taken place. Thanks to Tokyogirl79 for adding the sources, however I would like to indicate to the nominator that the article was clearly notable before the reviews were added Deletion of Undercover: The True Story of Britain's Secret Police WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15870 21213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ted Cruz extramarital affairs allegation User:Rebbing 23:40, 25 March 2016 (UTC) comment I don't believe the arguments raised so far can support speedy deletion under the |speedy-deletion policy. Is a deletion discussion permitted to close as speedy delete for a reason not given in the policy Deletion of Ted Cruz extramarital affairs allegation WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15871 18868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Proworkflow User:DustyRain 19:27, 12 January 2010 (UTC) delete as per - non notable, no trusted 3rd party coverage, their only reference is a self reference from their own website Deletion of Proworkflow WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15872 8404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeitgeist Artist Management User:Ukexpat 03:09, 18 February 2012 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Zeitgeist Artist Management WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15873 16855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skullptura User:Bearian 16:16, 13 February 2010 (UTC) delete I removed the speedy because I saw 1,000s of Ghits, and arguably the text said in so many words that it was notable. I disagreed with the speedy, but agreed it had little in terms of , so I prodded it. Did I make an error? Sometimes Prodding or AfD allows editors a few days to find obscure sources Deletion of Skullptura WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15874 1391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Duke Terrell User:Ben 17:29, 2 May 2011 (UTC) delete Fails per , no substantial secondary sources, the rest of the article is promotion by name dropping. The article sources his former band and his business management but not the musician. I'm accusing the author of and |gaming the system: Talk:Duke Terrell Deletion of Duke Terrell WP:MUSICBIO||WP:RELIABLE||WP:COI||WP:GAME Wikipedia:Notability 77
15875 19672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Esther Dingley User:Samsmachado 19:14, 2 December 2020 (UTC) delete """Definitely - only coverage of subject exists in reference to her disappearance. We would rename/move the page only """"in the event"""" (pun intended) that the event itself is notable per . It's way too soon to ave any idea about the event's lasting notability. Per event crit. 2, events are likely notable {{green|if they have widespread (national or international) impact and were very widely covered in diverse sources}}. There's a weak claim to this because of coverage in the New York Times in addition to UK coverage, but that doesn't cut it IMO. HOWEVER, I think we should delay any decision on the notability of the event (and thus the feasibility of the move) per as it is impossible to know the events lasting impact at this time""" Deletion of Esther Dingley WP:ONEEVENT||WP:EVENTCRIT||WP:RAPID Wikipedia:Notability 77
15876 2269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matty Miles [[User talk:GetDumb|Get]][[Special:Contributions/GetDumb|Dumb]]''' 01:12, 23 September 2009 (UTC) delete Fails badly. Mention of therefore brings up the likelihood of a violation as well Deletion of Matty Miles WP:N||WP:COI||WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
15877 12039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tactical Sekt User:Dom 19:29, 16 September 2020 (UTC) delete per nomination: falls short of criteria at . Can we bundle their three albums, ''Geneticide'', ''Burn Process'' and Syncope (album)|''Syncope'' (album) into this nomination? I can't find anything that would pass for any of them Deletion of Tactical Sekt WP:NBAND||WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
15878 19972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brfxxccxxmnpcccclllmmnprxvclmnckssqlbb11116 (3rd nomination) User:Jake 21:37, 7 December 2009 (UTC) comment Covers the intended name, not the person. |BLP1E doesn't apply Deletion of Brfxxccxxmnpcccclllmmnprxvclmnckssqlbb11116 (3rd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15879 8735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judah Miller User:Ventric 20:07, 10 December 2017 (UTC) keep Meets the threshold Deletion of Judah Miller WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15880 11107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blue Collar Wrestling Alliance User:Codf1977 15:02, 18 July 2010 (UTC) delete Fails no evidence of any real coverage of any significance, and very spamy Deletion of Blue Collar Wrestling Alliance WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15881 6218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Kimball User:IRWolfie 09:27, 28 August 2013 (UTC) delete No significant coverage in reliable, independent secondary sources. Fails and Wikipedia:FRINGE#Notability Deletion of Paul Kimball WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15882 3016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of works for the theatre portraying paedophilia or sexual abuse of minors User:Pohta 12:16, 9 February 2010 (UTC) delete Unsourced . I'm not opposed to someone adding well-referenced, culturally relevant plays two the articles on pedophilia and child sexual abuse. These are not necessarily the same theme, and conflating them is a bad idea. The editor doing that might as well start from scratch Deletion of List of works for the theatre portraying paedophilia or sexual abuse of minors WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
15883 9605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kitten (porn star) User:Epbr123 20:10, 7 April 2007 (UTC) keep She passes by appearing in the mainstream media when she was on Blind Date Deletion of Kitten (porn star) WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15884 1099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of BattleTech characters User:Zxcvbnm 14:14, 9 January 2020 (UTC) delete Unadulterated fancruft, delete per Deletion of List of BattleTech characters WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
15885 17446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Godzilla: Battle Royale User:Donaldd23 12:15, 1 November 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Godzilla: Battle Royale WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
15886 20434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mr Fuddlesticks User:Tokyogirl79 06:56, 22 December 2011 (UTC) delete I hemmed and hawed over this because while there has been several news stories about this, I think that this qualifies as . There might be some issues of freedom of speech, but this just hasn't really gone all that far or gotten that much attention, all things considering. I've cleaned the article up dramatically, but this just doesn't seem to have any lasting notability at this time Deletion of Mr Fuddlesticks WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15887 1397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Lukes User:Doctorfluffy 21:13, 11 January 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. Unlikely reliable, secondary sources exist to satisfy Deletion of Martin Lukes WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15888 16597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tahir Ahmad (ludo player) User:Whpq 17:32, 5 July 2011 (UTC) delete """as unverifiable, and likely |made up. I'm assuming Ludo refers to Ludo (board game). This http://ludochampionship.blogspot.com/ blog would indicate its just some friends and family making up a """"World championship"""". Refer to the first post where a 7 year old wins the championship.; as well as all the other posts""" Deletion of Tahir Ahmad (ludo player) WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
15889 2379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Jewish Bolshevism (2nd nomination) User:IZAK 19:15, 7 October 2013 (UTC) merge """to Jewish Bolshevism#The Jewish Bolshevism. I have extracted and transferred all the key information into that sub-section (part of Jewish Bolshevism#Works that propagate Jewish Bolshevism) which is more befitting WP's reader-friendly style with sufficient space for this minor topic. The so-called """"Bibliography"""" here is just padding that violates and . In fact, this article could ''very easily'' fit somewhere into the more important topic of Nazi propaganda#Media as one concise paragraph. As the article stands now, it seems that quite possibly it is trying to sneak in and propagate its contents in unnecessary detail in violation of in a more subtle fashion as well""" Deletion of The Jewish Bolshevism (2nd nomination) WP:NOTDIRECTORY||WP:NOTTEXTBOOK||WP:NOTSOAPBOX Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15890 13260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ymmv radio User:Quarl NONE delete patently |non-notable podcast. No Alexa rank. Website doesn't load. &mdash Deletion of Ymmv radio WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15891 13046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hemachandra Wijeratne User:CCamp2013 01:02, 18 September 2016 (UTC) delete This would be considered !E Deletion of Hemachandra Wijeratne WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
15892 20654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WRAJ Internet Radio User:Calton 04:44, 1 February 2007 (UTC) delete """Yet Another """"internet radio"""" station, with not the slightest reliable source or even credible assertion of notability. Note also the |conflict of interest by article creator {{User|Wrajradio""" Deletion of WRAJ Internet Radio WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
15893 17672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee LaHaye User:Ihcoyc 14:01, 8 September 2006 (UTC) delete and suggest '''speedy delete''' per A6, as an attack page. Blog rumours that the CFO of a right-wing Christian organization is gay strike me as unreliable, and likely to be considered defamatory by someone in such a position Deletion of Lee LaHaye WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15894 18270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bmcabana SF (2nd nomination) User:Xclusivzik 21:57, 4 August 2021 (UTC) delete subject doesn’t satisfy Deletion of Bmcabana SF (2nd nomination) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15895 8367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Takahiro Yoshikawa User:Fthobe 10:50, 29 May 2020 (UTC) comment Hey {{reply|Lullabying}}, I think there should be a consideration about different standards for different kind of music. In this case we are talking about a Solo Pianist who's playing as a regular at the worlds leading opera house (La Scala is according to National Geographic the leading opera house in the world){{cite web |url=https://www.nationalgeographic.com/travel/top-10/opera-houses/ |website=National Geographic}}, still, as most pianists, he will probably never chart in his life. We have plenty of examples of that, most notably would be the bio article of Ian Parker (Canadian pianist), that is referenced very poorly but still his picture is on the article page Pianist and he has a bio article all on it's own. I am not disagreeing with you about requiring a treshold, I am just saying that maybe being a little bit more open towards the qualification foreign sources (he has been in all top 3 newspapers in Italy multiple times and had multiple TV broadcasts in Japan, I added some ref) and maybe consider that not everybody will achieve the degree of commercial success that you would apply to pop musicians, but still be relevant enough in his category to be documented (something expressively desired in . Additionally, I am up to 5 rotation in NHK radio last year. It's not easy to get everything straight when it£s written in Kanji, but the more I look the more I find. Knock yourself out: https://www.nhk.or.jp/classic-blog/100/301185.html . I think the current interpretation of the rules massively disfavours classical live artists Deletion of Takahiro Yoshikawa WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15896 18798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Merlin and the Book of Beasts User:Hzh 16:00, 12 July 2018 (UTC) delete can't find coverage of the film apart from listing sites and some reviews from non-notable critics https://www.somethingawful.com/movie-reviews/merlin-book-beasts/2/http://filmcriticsunited.com/bookofbeasts.html, therefore fails Deletion of Merlin and the Book of Beasts WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
15897 4572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Internet Computer Chess Tournament User:Red 21:51, 21 July 2020 (UTC) merge per above. The search term seems perfectly plausible as a Deletion of Internet Computer Chess Tournament WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
15898 17748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Datameer User:Magnolia677 20:28, 10 February 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Datameer WP:GNG||WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
15899 16029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brains (web series) User:WikiDan61 11:13, 3 June 2016 (UTC) delete """As the editor who tagged it for speedy deletion, I could find no sources to indicate that this series has received any significant independent coverage. The film festival selections appear impressive, but the festivals are little known, and their selection processes do not appear all too rigorous. The """"barrage of complaints"""" at Talk:Brains (web series) are all from |SPA contributors, expressing arguments""" Deletion of Brains (web series) WP:SPA||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
15900 17611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julian Schratter User:Pharaoh 01:14, 3 July 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Julian Schratter WP:NMODEL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15901 14491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of criticism and critique articles User:Northamerica1000 01:44, 12 July 2012 (UTC) keep spaced ndash}} This is a useful navigation page for Wikipedia pages whose titles are based upon criticism and critiques. How does deletion of this list improve the encyclopedia? Also, per , this list is complementary to :Category:Criticisms, rather than inappropriate. Also, this article doesn't particularly appear to fail (It's a focused list, not indiscriminate) nor (article lists and indexes for Wikipedia are common, not included in Deletion of List of criticism and critique articles WP:NOTDUP||WP:NOTDIR||WP:SELFREF Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
15902 11014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jerry Piddington User:Astudent0 14:55, 27 August 2016 (UTC) delete Agree with previous comments. Neither nor GNG is met Deletion of Jerry Piddington WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15903 9773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of current fast bowlers in international cricket User:Ajf773 02:27, 27 January 2019 (UTC) delete We don't keep lists of ''current'' sportspeople. Plus the whole list is a violation of Deletion of List of current fast bowlers in international cricket WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15904 13672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/University of NSW FC User:CASSIOPEIA 08:21, 23 July 2019 (UTC) delete No notable sport team. Fails and Deletion of University of NSW FC WP:NTEAM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15905 21051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Faulks User:PJM 12:37, 27 March 2006 (UTC) delete Based on what I find, http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Martin+Faulks%22+&btnG=Google+Search, the subject does not satisfy . Also, the article is unsourced Deletion of Martin Faulks WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15906 20163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Branded e-mail User:Ydam 08:30, 2 June 2006 (UTC) delete per fails and dicdef Deletion of Branded e-mail WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15907 11974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 Herat shooting User:WilliamJE 17:52, 27 July 2014 (UTC) delete Tragic but Deletion of 2014 Herat shooting WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15908 1582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Violence against animals in India User:ChunnuBhai 12:57, 27 September 2020 (UTC) delete Fails . none of the incidents are notable and are usual news items Deletion of Violence against animals in India WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15909 17105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sacred Heart School (Bethlehem) User:EJF 09:33, 10 June 2008 (UTC) merge to Schools of the Sacred Heart or Bethlehem%2C_Pennsylvania#Primary_and_secondary_education. Little reliable source coverage to show |notability, and certainly not enough to build a viable |verifiable encyclopaedia article Deletion of Sacred Heart School (Bethlehem) WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
15910 16894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1911 Wisła Kraków season User:Jovanmilic97 19:50, 22 November 2019 (UTC) delete all. Lightburst's argument does not hold since there is nothing be preserved here as it's referenced only to a fan wikia, and there is no appropriate page to redirect these since Wisła Kraków has no mentions or seasons sections. As every of these fail (I am unable to find reliable references to support the article and is a policy), and (there is no significant coverage in reliable sources in my searches), plus Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1906 Wisła Kraków season which was attended properly... delete is the only choice here Deletion of 1911 Wisła Kraków season WP:ATD||WP:V||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
15911 5492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hugo Broch User:Fortuna 15:53, 29 April 2017 (UTC) keep plenty of coverage in https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=Hugo+Broch+flying+ace&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&gws_rd=cr&ei=bbUEWf7mC8uOgAbt74qQBQ#tbm=bks&q=%22Hugo+Broch%22+flying+ace military / history texts; I agree that the sheer number of kills, relative to the theatre, conveys notability sufficient to pass and (arguably he 'played an important role in a significant military event') . &mdash Deletion of Hugo Broch WP:GNG||WP:MILPERSON Wikipedia:Notability 77
15912 20895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arcteq User:DrStrauss 18:51, 30 August 2017 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Arcteq WP:PROMO||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15913 1865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caiçara Esporte Clube User:Arsenalkid700 23:56, 29 July 2012 (UTC) comment The Copa is the top domestic cup in Brazil. Playing in it should warrant notability as long as the club passes which I shall check. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Caiçara Esporte Clube WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15914 2022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jiang Shen (Debbie) User:Bakazaka 23:48, 31 March 2019 (UTC) merge to Super Impassioned Net Generation. Subject is not independently notable, but readers searching for the name might find it useful to be directed to the group of which the subject is a member, so redirect per -R Deletion of Jiang Shen (Debbie) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
15915 3077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keas Bees User:Afluent 10:31, 21 January 2007 (UTC) merge to Streetlight Manifesto. |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball, and this album has not been officially announced, at least, from the information I gather. I do support the attempt to bold redirect, but it appears that the consensus is against that atm Deletion of Keas Bees WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15916 11531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Endless Winter User:Argento 14:32, 27 January 2021 (UTC) keep """If this wasn't so poorly constructed, this would be an easy keep because publications from DC can almost always pass GNG. A basic search turns up coverage that could be used to craft a publication history section (per https://bleedingcool.com/comics/phillip-kennedy-johnson-was-hired-by-dc-for-5g-but-not-on-superman/ this and https://www.comicsbeat.com/dcs-endless-winter-to-start-also-end-in-december/ this, it was planned to last two months but was compressed to five weeks). https://www.gamesradar.com/inside-december-dc-event-endless-winter-and-how-it-sets-up-black-adam-john-stewart-more-in-2021/ This talks about its broader impact. The """"niche"""" resource CBRU is a review aggregator that acts as Rotten Tomatoes for comics. I can't support the way it's used in the article currently, but it's an excellent resource for locating reviews of the comic from reliable sources ''and'' making sure there's an accurate representation of the reviews. Still, may apply here, as I don't have the time to implement any of these improvements. If another enterprising editor does, please ping me""" Deletion of Endless Winter WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
15917 7435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KOI 701.03 [[User talk:64.229.101.119|talk]]) 20:18, 5 February 2011 (UTC) delete """to its star article (whatever that may be, the article does not say). It is not overly notable until it is confirmed. As it is a candidate, it is not a real """"geographic"""" location, it is only postulated. Its star is a real """"geographic"""" location. If we can't determine the star, then delete per , it is not a location article, since the location specified in the article is not confirmed to actually exist, and many candidate planets are later found to not exist, so candidates are not inherently notable, unless the candidature has some other effect other than just being announced. Special:Contributions/64.229.101.119|64.229.101.119""" Deletion of KOI 701.03 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15918 2657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gun Nut User:Calgary 21:11, 11 July 2007 (UTC) delete It is little more than a definition, with virtually no grounds for espansion, so it fails #DICTIONARY. Also, it's very POV, in that it discusses a POV topic not from a neutral standpoint, but as an excuse to coyly suggest that gun control is irrational by pointing out a Second Ammendment|conterargument that makes up the bulk of the article Deletion of Gun Nut WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15919 771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disappearance of Sunil Tripathi User:Richard 19:14, 25 April 2013 (UTC) keep """WP:BASIC requires """"subject of multiple published secondary sources which are reliable, intellectually independent of each other, and independent of the subject."""" The author (Gruesome Foursome) has established those. While might give the impression this should be merged into the Boston Marathon Bombing, what happen here has nothing to do directly with the event, but as a seperate consequence of the event""" Deletion of Disappearance of Sunil Tripathi WP:VICTIM Wikipedia:Notability 77
15920 14608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Octaviano Tenorio User:Kierzek 20:02, 15 July 2016 (UTC) delete """fails in the end; so he served in """"various positions"""", not notable and even if he has since been promoted up-the-ladder, so to speak, not inherently notable""" Deletion of Octaviano Tenorio WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15921 17365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brandon Newton User:Jakejr 21:41, 28 December 2015 (UTC) delete Fails the GNG and Deletion of Brandon Newton WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
15922 13254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gringalet (film) User:Atlantic306 00:36, 1 February 2021 (UTC) keep as per the reliable sources reviews identified above such as Variety and Spanish sources that show a pass of so that deletion is unnecessary in my view Deletion of Gringalet (film) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15923 18411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kazuki Sakamoto User:GiantSnowman 12:25, 17 January 2013 (UTC) delete fail and Deletion of Kazuki Sakamoto WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15924 9872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Restless Boards User:Jayden54 16:04, 29 November 2006 (UTC) delete fails as I can't find any news articles or reviews on this company. No sources either to show any notability, so it also fails Deletion of Restless Boards WP:CORP||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
15925 13194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Doll-Steinberg User:Edwardx 11:28, 5 October 2017 (UTC) delete Not finding independent in-depth coverage in reliable sources - lack of . Fails and Deletion of Daniel Doll-Steinberg WP:SIGCOV||WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15926 17066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nintendo 3ds Update History User:The1337gamer 17:22, 28 July 2017 (UTC) delete per . Doesn't belong on an encyclopedia Deletion of Nintendo 3ds Update History WP:CHANGELOG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15927 18682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global apartheid User:Pecher 14:00, 1 June 2006 (UTC) delete """Not sure about the motives of the article's author, but the spurious creation of several articles with """"apartheid"""" in their title does smack of . The article does not provide any sources discussing the ''notability'' of the term; therefore, it will be original research to conclude that the term is notable based on several sources using it""" Deletion of Global apartheid WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
15928 5408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theneworiginals001 User:Accounting4Taste 04:10, 27 October 2007 (UTC) delete If it's not even very popular on YouTube, it can't possibly have enough otable|notability for Wikipedia. No sources/references Deletion of Theneworiginals001 WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15929 11030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ronan Keenan User:Alf 23:03, 1 February 2007 (UTC) delete unless sourced and reference i.a.w. and by end of this AfD —The preceding Wikipedia:Sign your posts on talk pages|unsigned comment was added by Deletion of Ronan Keenan WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
15930 955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wes Bellamy User:AuthorAuthor 08:42, 8 February 2018 (UTC) delete Appears to be a typical small-town mayor with a few headlines here and there but no sustaining coverage of the subject. Nothing notable in sources and nothing notable in a search for sources. Does not pass and fails to meet Deletion of Wes Bellamy WP:GNG||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15931 8369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ennui (Film) User:Joe 00:12, 20 November 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |film Deletion of Ennui (Film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15932 12658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bloodshadows User:Shooterwalker 16:57, 22 January 2011 (UTC) delete no sources with any significant out of universe information exist. Article fails #PLOT and as many campaign settings for games would Deletion of Bloodshadows WP:NOT||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15933 58 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Bekir Kavruk Kullanıcı:mukaddime'''mukaddime''' 09:24, 30 Temmuz 2013 (UTC) delete Vikipedi:Kayda değerlik (kişiler), ve VP:TBA sorunları var Bekir Kavruk'un silinmesi Vikipedi:Otobiyografi Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
15934 8939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of highest-income places in the United States User:davidwr 02:51, 20 August 2015 (UTC) keep """but okay with """"delete and immediately rewrite with current data"""" - '''''' arguments ''probably'' don't apply. I didn't read the raw census data but 1) it's probably ''obvious'' from the raw data that the information was true as of the 2000 census, and 2) the very nature of census data lends itself to this kind of data-extraction. says """"Articles may not contain any new analysis or synthesis of published material '''that serves to reach or imply a conclusion not clearly stated by the sources themselves'''. ''emphasis added''"""" Although I did not actually read the census data, if it is like most census data then '''the part of that I put in bold does NOT apply in this case''' and if the article is to be deleted, it needs to be deleted on other grounds, such as """"hopelessly stale, time to light the fuse on the and re-write it with 2010 census data""" Deletion of List of highest-income places in the United States WP:OR||WP:OR||WP:OR||WP:TNT Wikipedia:No original research 65
15935 9204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leadership in 2020 User:FreeRangeFrog 23:05, 7 June 2013 (UTC) delete This is not an encyclopedic subject, and we are |not a web hosting service or a blog. The author seems to be promoting a series of viewpoints that rely on |original research and |synthesis. I'd say it's |snowing in June Deletion of Leadership in 2020 WP:NOTWEBHOST||WP:OR||WP:SYNTH||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15936 20027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chinese virus User:Funplussmart 17:36, 21 March 2020 (UTC) merge to Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2. This should be used as a redirect due to the term's appearance in reliable sources. This is not an attack page because of that fact. It could be considered offensive (I don't think it is), but |we don't remove material just because it may be objectionable. Also, consider the above comments about Spanish flu and French disease, neither of which are proper names for the infection but we still have the pages Deletion of Chinese virus WP:CENSOR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15937 6550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Payne User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable biography, userfy is OK. &mdash Deletion of Christian Payne WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15938 6194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angels Wake User:Antaeus 21:12, 24 December 2005 (UTC) delete cos.....heck I just WANNA! because there is no evidence that the band meets , and none of the people who complain about those guidelines ever seem to come up with a more practical standard of notability for musical artists. Some of the people who complain don't even seem to understand the current standard Deletion of Angels Wake WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15939 15944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timeline of food User:Northamerica1000 13:03, 17 June 2013 (UTC) keep per . The article has been completely revised compared to its state at the time of nomination for deletion (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Timeline_of_food&diff=prev&oldid=559474315 diff page). It is now a well-sourced and formatted article of significant encyclopedic value Deletion of Timeline of food WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
15940 12980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parvez family User:SshibumXZ 00:48, 18 February 2018 (UTC) delete """Clearly |original research, with no |reliable sources to back up the claims. Also, the creator of these pages, {{noping|Makhamakhi}}, has been indefinitely blocked because of """"wikipedia:Disruptive editing|Disruptive editing'': Continuation of same behavior on a shocking scale, even after they were explicitly warned that they'd be indefinitely blocked if they kept it up''"""" by {{noping|Swarm}}. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of Parvez family WP: OR||WP: RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
15941 2794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neston High School User:UserBob 22:52, 20 January 2021 (UTC) delete Fails not only , but it also astoundingly fails . School has received no major awards or accolades, just a regular, non-notable secondary school Deletion of Neston High School WP:GNG||WP:INDEPENDENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15942 2358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Find and replace User:I 09:11, 16 August 2012 (UTC) delete I'm in agreement with JIP. Find and replace is undoubtedly a useful feature in word processing, but the article falls in line with both and Deletion of Find and replace WP:NOTHOWTO||WP:NOTDIC Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15943 17370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quadrapop User:Teancum 12:45, 1 December 2009 (UTC) delete Fails both and . Couldn't enough sources to back this one up. I have no issue with the two sources listed in the article, but that's all I could find that's actually worth anything Deletion of Quadrapop WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15944 14808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ertaizi [[User talk:Usernamekiran|'''(talk)''']] 21:07, 11 February 2018 (UTC) delete In current circumstances it fails , also for —usernamekiran Deletion of Ertaizi WP:NGEO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
15945 13693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simplify Recordings User:Netherzone 14:32, 27 December 2020 (UTC) delete This is a PROMO article, with what seems like an obvious COI. I agree that it is an attempt to puff up notability. As of today now artists are starting to add themselves to the article, likely for promotional reasons. This is not what the encylopedia is for. They need a good website instead of using Wikipedia for that purpose. Does not pass criteria, and the sourcing lacks significant coverage. General notability fail Deletion of Simplify Recordings WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
15946 11343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter O. Halloran User:Guliolopez 20:31, 26 August 2017 (UTC) delete """per nom and . As per {{u|AllyD}}'s note above, after a quick glance at the references one might think that is met. However, as soon as you scratch the surface it is clear that all those """"reference"""" links relate to at least three different men. There may be an innocent explanation for that (newbie exuberance or good faith mistake), but it does lend to hoax-ish overtones (or possible paid-editing/COI attempts to feign GNG). Delete""" Deletion of Peter O. Halloran WP:ANYBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15947 13448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lady Gaga: Queen of Pop (2nd nomination) User:J04n 04:27, 5 June 2010 (UTC) keep per the good work done by Cirt. The works used to source the 'Reception' section alone satisfies criterion 1 of Deletion of Lady Gaga: Queen of Pop (2nd nomination) WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
15948 5266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Compound Document Comparison User:Dialectric 23:33, 25 November 2015 (UTC) delete Software article of unclear notability, lacking independent references. A single Patent ref does not do anything to establish notability, and a search turned up no significant coverage. Article was created by an Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|SPA as an apparent POV/Promo fork of Compound document Deletion of Compound Document Comparison WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
15949 21009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Afanc (Dungeons & Dragons) User:Sangrolu 12:36, 12 June 2012 (UTC) merge to List of Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 1st edition monsters. ''' does not apply'''; there is nothing about this article that tells you how to play the game. That said, there are no secondary references to support that would merit it having its own article. There is nothing to really merge; the article is not of encyclopedic quality and likely never will be Deletion of Afanc (Dungeons & Dragons) WP:NOTMANUAL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15950 773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alleged irregularities in the 2020 United States Presidential election User:Hunter1471 18:35, 15 November 2020 (UTC) keep As mentioned above, Wikipedia has similar articles for other tragedies but also give arguments that disprove the theories. Keeping this article, but also disproving the information would be the best course of action. Not as many Trump supporters believe it as has been reported widely by the news, so no solid mainstream view. Not either, as election result questioning to this extent in a US election is unheard of Deletion of Alleged irregularities in the 2020 United States Presidential election WP:FRINGE||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
15951 6898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acoustic 1993 User:DustFormsWords 07:18, 7 April 2010 (UTC) delete per - I am unable to find significant coverage for this bootleg. I considered suggesting merge to Midnight Oil discography but there appears to have been a deliberate decision on that article to not include bootlegs. Note that ''Acoustic 1993'' is also the name of a release by Roxette Deletion of Acoustic 1993 WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15952 26 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hasan Sami Bolak """Kullanıcı:yabancı'''yabancı'''""" 18:56, 10 Mart 2009 (UTC) comment """Adım geçtiği için küçük bir açıklama yapma gereği duydum. Yukarıdaki yorumum sayfasında yazanları işaret etmekten ibaretti, o sayfayı okumuş olanlar anlamıştır zaten. ''""""Önemli olan kitaplarda ve makalelerde Ülkücü olarak adının geçmiş olması""""'' değildir. Önemli olan şunlardır: ''""""Söz konusu kişiden bağımsız olarak, birden fazla, birbirinden fikirsel olarak bağımsız, yayımlanmış, güvenilir ikincil kaynaklar tarafından bu kişinin konu edilmiş olması.""""'', ''""""Eğer bu kaynak tarafından işleniş biçimi derinlemesine değilse, kayda değerliğin belirlenebilmesi için birden fazla bağımsız kaynak gösterilmesi.""""'', ''""""Kişi hakkında gösterilen ikincil kaynakların konuyu sıradan bir şekilde işlemiş olması kayda değerliği belirlemek için yeterli değildir.""""'' Kaynak var demek yetmiyor, o kaynağın niteliği ve kişiyi nasıl konu ettiğidir önemli olan""" Hasan Sami Bolak'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
15953 9572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/9/11: The Great Illusion User:Mr 01:23, 17 August 2006 (UTC) delete per nom, also has |no reliable sources Strike that, it has no sources at all Deletion of 9/11: The Great Illusion WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15954 15452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Do not pass Go. Do not collect $200. user:Andrew 23:05, 25 November 2018 (UTC) keep It's easy enough to find a source such as the ''https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=jLqXM3U_pzEC Encyclopedia of Play in Today's Society''. The worst case would be merger to Monopoly (game), which we would prefer to deletion per and Deletion of Do not pass Go. Do not collect $200. WP:ATD||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
15955 19426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Brother Henry User:Schuym1 19:52, 22 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of My Brother Henry WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
15956 8695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aircraft graffiti (2nd nomination) User:Arxiloxos 21:08, 20 April 2012 (UTC) comment """Right now this article reads like |original research. But there actually may be a topic out there to be written. We already have a decent article on Nose art, which is the best known variety of aircraft graffiti and certainly a notable topic. Also, there's a continuing art project called """"The Boneyard Project"""" http://theboneyardprojects.com/ that involves using abandoned aircraft as the medium for art projects: it's currently on display at the gigantic Pima Air & Space Museum in Tucsonhttp://blog.makezine.com/2012/03/16/wwii-aircraft-as-canvas-the-boneyard-project/http://blogs.phoenixnewtimes.com/jackalope/2012/04/the_great_paper_airplane_proje.phphttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/16/the-boneyard-project-brings-old-planes-to-life_n_1291737.html. For the moment, I'd suggest redirecting/merging this topic to Nose art""" Deletion of Aircraft graffiti (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
15957 5625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trust Me, I'm Dr. Ozzy User:Stuartyeates 09:25, 11 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Trust Me, I'm Dr. Ozzy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15958 14036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zodiac smith User:Coredesat 03:52, 6 July 2006 (UTC) delete per #A7|CSD-A7, no assertion of notability Deletion of Zodiac smith WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
15959 16624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lt.quade and the hit squad User:Storkk 14:33, 14 December 2007 (UTC) delete could have been speedied as there is no assertion of otability Deletion of Lt.quade and the hit squad WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15960 11024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Communist-led riot User:Tikiwont 11:56, 20 September 2007 (UTC) delete """Most articles are in :Category:Riots in Singapore, but """"Communist-led"""" is inherently difficult to define and |POV prone""" Deletion of Communist-led riot WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
15961 1867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennet Taylor User:Coredesat 19:53, 10 August 2006 (UTC) delete fails . No |verifiable information with |reliable sources Deletion of Jennet Taylor WP:BIO||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
15962 18543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rob Miller (South Carolina politician) (2nd nomination) User:Mkativerata 22:24, 2 September 2010 (UTC) delete or '''redirect''' The first AfD proceeded on the false premise that satisfying GNG is a ''guarantee'' of notability. It isn't. It only creates a ''presumption'' of notability. We have |specific standards for politicians and this subject clearly fails them. The presumption of notability is, in my view, rebutted by the fact that just about all of the coverage emanates from the candidacies and the community's view is that mere candidates are not notable. He's merely a low-mid ranking military officer who happens to have been on a ballot in a seat held by the opposing party. I am fully aware that I'm arguing for the deletion of an article about a person who meets the GNG. That's entirely consistent with the GNG's status as a guideline and the meaning of ''presumption'' of notability Deletion of Rob Miller (South Carolina politician) (2nd nomination) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
15963 822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2030 FIFA World Cup (2nd nomination) User:Coredesat 13:18, 10 July 2006 (UTC) delete Looking into my #Wikipedia is not a crystal ball|crystal ball, I see that these articles' days are numbered. They can be recreated in 2026 Deletion of 2030 FIFA World Cup (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15964 21852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stoner Witch (Band) User:Esradekan 23:46, 30 August 2009 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability per Deletion of Stoner Witch (Band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15965 13420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juridical racialism User:Beeblbrox 23:49, 21 May 2008 (UTC) merge per above, does not seem |notable on it's own Deletion of Juridical racialism WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
15966 18026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tammie Souza User:MichaelQSchmidt 08:25, 13 June 2009 (UTC) keep per passing and as a http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-17459769_ITM 3-time Chicago Emmy winner (not exactly a tiny town) who has been covered in more-than-trivial fashion by reliable sources for 11 years... and yes, in relationship to her professional field. Some examples: http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=HN&p_theme=hn&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F942722D3F55AF3&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM Herald News (2003), http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=ADHB&p_theme=adhb&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F8C771744FFFFFC&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM Daily Herald (2003), http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-96574624.html Daily Herald (2003), http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-96574624.html Daily Herald (2003), http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=ADHB&p_theme=adhb&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=1067021D71802B9B&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM Daily Herald (2004), http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=CSTB&p_theme=cstb&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=123189E2764B1028&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM Chicaho Sun-Times (2006), http://www2.tbo.com/content/2008/sep/10/101810/chicago-meteorologist-headed-wtsp-tampa/ Tampa Tribune (2008), etc. There's more and yes, the article need proper sourcing. But that's a matter for , not |deletion Deletion of Tammie Souza WP:GNG||WP:BIO||WP:CLEANUP||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
15967 6685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aayatya Gharat Gharoba User:Johnbod 14:41, 24 December 2020 (UTC) keep Do you speak Marathi, Donald? Can you even read its script? If not, your search is near-worthless Deletion of Aayatya Gharat Gharoba WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
15968 10550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Technopark, Kollam User:Omni 05:22, 6 March 2016 (UTC) delete as per . The few reliable sources it has aren't independent of the topic, which clearly isn't enough to establish notability Deletion of Technopark, Kollam WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15969 6237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suppression of dissent User:XOR 04:43, 31 May 2018 (UTC) delete per . A fantastically broad topic, supported by fantastically narrow sourcing of remarkably dubious quality. We don't demand perfection, but we need our content to be better than this, and nothing here needs to be saved. (And Wikipedia:List of hoaxes on Wikipedia#Hoaxes extant for at least four years|longevity is no guarantee of quality Deletion of Suppression of dissent WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
15970 10791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hindu Taliban User:Phil 20:29, 12 November 2008 (UTC) merge with Hindutva per #DICT. Encyclopedia articles, as opposed to dictionary defintions, are supposed to be about concepts, not words or phrases. As this article says in its first sentence its title is simply another word for a concept on which Wikipedia already has an article. A note can be added to the Hindutva article to say that this is an alternative name used by the movement's opponents, and any other encyclopedic information can also be merged Deletion of Hindu Taliban WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15971 12827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of starships in Stargate User:SudoGhost 17:51, 28 November 2012 (UTC) delete """or '''Redirect''' - Fails . None of the references, including the ones discussed in the AfD, show any notability for """"List of starships in Stargate"""" specifically. A few give a brief mention of ''Prometheus'' (although those for the most part appear to be talking about the ''episode'', not the ship), but in passing as part of a single sentence, not in enough detail to make an entirely separate article. Other sources discussed are about Stargate itself, and mention the ships in passing as part of the Stargate franchise if at all, the sources do not describe the ships as something notable enough to exist outside of that context. Reliable sources do not see this subject as notable outside of the context of the primary subject, and only briefly mentioning them inside that context. I don't think it's appropriate for Wikipedia to give so much detail to a topic |that reliable sources do not, and not in a separate article that has no notability. If the content is kept, it needs to be trimmed down considerably and merged into Stargate or an appropriate article, but the sources in the article and the sources discussed in the AfD do not warrant a separate article on the topic""" Deletion of List of starships in Stargate WP:GNG||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Notability 77
15972 767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/E-Healthcare Solutions User:Jayden54 22:35, 17 December 2006 (UTC) delete as the company fails and this article is nothing more than an advertisement (might even be speedy deleted Deletion of E-Healthcare Solutions WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
15973 2422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Cornerstone Institute User:Mrschimpf 22:23, 24 August 2021 (UTC) merge Just came into existence in February; we're not under to see if it does anything outside be a second line on the bottom-third graphic when Dr. Carson is on a show, and doesn't really serve a purpose Deletion of American Cornerstone Institute WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:There is no deadline 35
15974 8584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Javier Manquillo User:Mattythewhite 17:30, 4 July 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Javier Manquillo WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
15975 17747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pur (Belgaum) User:Gene93k 14:24, 15 May 2018 (UTC) keep Ping|ZfJames}} Legally recognized human settlements are notable per regardless of size. 2011 census says a population of 587.http://www.census2011.co.in/data/village/598020-pur-karnataka.html Deletion of Pur (Belgaum) WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
15976 20057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Low Level Radiation Campaign User:Catervula 14:21, 25 August 2008 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a for claims. This article appears to be a |coatrack hanging the subject (LLRC) over the arranged evidence about Low Level Radiation exposure. This organization needs to meet the daughter guidelines for organizations () or the general notability guideline (). Right now, it doesn't meet either. I understand the fervor that Deletion of The Low Level Radiation Campaign WP:SOAPBOX||WP:COATRACK||WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15977 3631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conley family User:Nagle 04:00, 26 November 2015 (UTC) delete Seems to be a for bios of non-notable people. Is any individual there notable enough for a standalone article? Wikipedia sometimes has family articles, but they're to tie together the articles of individually notable people. Also, 15 SPAs for this article alone indicate a big and problem Deletion of Conley family WP:COATRACK||WP:COI||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
15978 4541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Schlafly (3rd nomination) User:Edison 05:16, 11 July 2008 (UTC) delete Refs seem to be trivial mention or passing reference, not the substantial coverage needed to satisfy . Notability is not inherited, so being the son of the woman who prevented the Equal Rights Amendment from being added to the Constitution is insufficient. He seems to get only passing reference in coverage of Conservapedia Deletion of Andrew Schlafly (3rd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15979 20842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lakka-Lakka-Ding-Dong User:Kinu 06:03, 31 July 2006 (UTC) delete no. Pick your poison: , , , something Deletion of Lakka-Lakka-Ding-Dong WP:BALLS||WP:RS||WP:OR Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
15980 5296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alim Ahmed Fatah User:Scoobycentric 10:05, 5 June 2009 (UTC) comment How is providing elaborate evidence for your case against deletion an attempt to overload/exhaust or worst 'questionable' conduct? I'm being told he doesn't pass /BIO but nobody elaborates where/why he fails?, i'm disappointed with that, this shouldn't be a 'vote' only with a few cryptic sentences accompanying it. Point by point i have addressed the requirements of and several times i have had to re-iterate a point already answered, giving me the suspicion none of the sources i have provided was actually read. Secondly reliable sources have been dismissed because of the 'proponent for deletion' unfamiliarity with them, which i think is unfair, the equivalant would be for me to dismiss the 'Hindustan times' serving predominantly the Indian community because i know nothing about it Deletion of Alim Ahmed Fatah WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15981 3496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Tyler User:Mallocks 16:49, 7 October 2005 (UTC) delete fails , has released no CDs either as solo or ensemble as near as I can make out Deletion of Philip Tyler WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15982 6523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karri o. User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable biography. &mdash Deletion of Karri o. WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15983 2869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony De Ieso User:Coredesat 08:56, 26 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Anthony De Ieso WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
15984 5567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jazz Mellor (2nd nomination) User:AdventurousSquirrel 03:17, 3 February 2013 (UTC) delete coverage in national news sources, but as you say, not particularly substantially so. Probably fails Deletion of Jazz Mellor (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
15985 7457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcio Stambowsky (2nd nomination) User:Smartyllama 18:38, 16 June 2017 (UTC) keep The current references in the article are significant and substantial enough for the subject to pass Deletion of Marcio Stambowsky (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15986 13427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henry Gee User:Joe 13:16, 18 January 2017 (UTC) keep """reluctantly, per {{u|E.M.Gregory}}'s comments. Given that multiple editors have argued to keep on the basis that Gee is a """"public figure"""", and the article itself is well sourced and has a long history, I don't think we can apply here after all. However, I think this is a good example of why we could do to strengthen that guideline. The """"right to be forgotten"""" (for low-profile individuals) that {{u|cromercrox}} mentions below is something we should be protecting per . – """ Deletion of Henry Gee WP:BIODEL||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
15987 5056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Schaack User:Nsk92 12:03, 20 October 2017 (UTC) keep I had earlier (after the AfD nomination but before DE updates and revisions to the article) added a mention to the article regarding the Lynwood W. Swanson Promise for Scientific Research Award from the M.J. Murdock Charitable Trust, which is a reasonably significant award, certainly counting towards #C1. A few comments to the nominator: The NSF grant in question was not an ordinary grant but a National Science Foundation CAREER Award. These grants are much more prestigious and harder to get than ordinary grants, and they do contribute to academic notability, at least somewhat. In fact I think this info should be re-added to the article. About the h-index of 18. There is no such thing as a standard h-index for an Associate Professor. H-index varies greatly by discipline (and also by the source of data used, GScholar, WebOfScience, Scopus etc). In lower citation disciplines like mathematics most full professors probably retire with GScholar h-index lower than 18. Sarah Schaack works in a higher citation field but still even there, for somebody to reach an h-index of 18 in ten years (her Phd is from 2008) looks impressive to me. In any case, I think there is enough here to satisfy #C1, for the reasons above and those given by David Eppsein Deletion of Sarah Schaack WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
15988 10598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Restorative leadership User:MrsSnoozyTurtle 03:01, 22 May 2021 (UTC) delete WP:NEOLOGISM article by author. An alternative could be redirecting to Triple bottom line Deletion of Restorative leadership WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
15989 7750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph O. Legaspi User:Epinoia 21:01, 18 May 2019 (UTC) delete """does not meet - is not """"regarded as an important figure or is widely cited by peers or successors"""" - is not """"known for originating a significant new concept, theory, or technique"""" - has not """"created or played a major role in co-creating a significant or well-known work or collective body of work. In addition, such work must have been the primary subject of an independent and notable work (for example, a book, film, or television series, but usually not a single episode of a television series) or of multiple independent periodical articles or reviews"""" - work has not """"won significant critical attention"""" - therefore, delete""" Deletion of Joseph O. Legaspi WP:POET Wikipedia:Notability 77
15990 5736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Thomson Club User:Jmorrison230582 07:54, 1 December 2016 (UTC) delete """Scottish goalkeepers and the """"clean sheet"""" statistic exist, but the term """"John Thomson Club"""" is made up. Complete fantasy. """ Deletion of John Thomson Club WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
15991 13433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MajorMUD (2nd nomination) User:Satellizer 09:05, 4 May 2016 (UTC) delete """Simply shouting isn't a valid rationale for keeping. Even guidelines like require participants to at least |prove the existence of reliable sources. It's worth noting that the previous AfD was also littered with such bogus """"IAR"""" claims; the article can be moved to Draftspace if people are so convinced sources exist""" Deletion of MajorMUD (2nd nomination) WP:ITSNOTABLE||WP:NEXIST||WP:BURDEN Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
15992 6718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IBall (company) User:Ugog 17:18, 3 August 2014 (UTC) keep Subject seems to pass , I https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=IBall_%28company%29&diff=619697573&oldid=619624801 added +3 refs and a custom Google search engine https://4d1fac7452666a9f1a1e7b6fa5af791fa725173b.googledrive.com/host/0B3ke7sJYbO1gVkRjUVh6bmtqeVU/IndianEnglishNewspaperSearch.html#gsc.tab=0&gsc.q=Iball%20company&gsc.sort= gives more favourable results Deletion of IBall (company) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15993 5678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon cobb User:ChrisTheDude 21:27, 24 January 2007 (UTC) delete """Subject does not even come close to meeting , and signing a contract with non-league Kings Lynn F.C.|Kings Lynn certainly won't change that. Note that none of the """"Keep"""" puppets !voters ''(I'm being charitable)'' have offered any argument other than """ Deletion of Simon cobb WP:BIO||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
15994 6261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brain fart User:Kendrick7 18:50, 29 April 2008 (UTC) keep """an actual phenomenon per the scientific paper mentioned in the external links,http://www.pnas.org/cgi/content/abstract/105/16/6173 for which """"brain fart"""" is decidedly the common name (see ) per the secondary source. I wouldn't object strenuously, however, to renaming the article to """"maladaptive brain activity change"""" but that's a secondary issue to keeping the article around""" Deletion of Brain fart WP:NAME Wikipedia:Article titles 75
15995 15684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Straight from the Lab (2nd nomination) User:Gongshow 01:00, 30 July 2017 (UTC) keep enough coverage to meet , in my view. In addition to Allmusic and Complex, there are a pair of MTV write-ups http://www.mtv.com/news/1480894/eminems-benzino-dis-turns-up-in-the-lab/http://www.mtv.com/news/1480946/eminem-apologizes-for-old-track-that-dissed-black-women/ which I added to the article that go into a fair amount of detail and can help to further expand the page Deletion of Straight from the Lab (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
15996 18003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2XL (band) User:Chubbles 15:25, 16 April 2008 (UTC) keep Sources provided above establish notability per Deletion of 2XL (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
15997 15909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011 WDF World Cup User:Suriel1981 22:51, 16 September 2011 (UTC) keep WP:GNG is met, see WDF World Cup. #STATS is not violated as this is not a ''long and sprawling list of statistics'' and contains ''tables to enhance the readability''. As far as , I quote: ''Individual scheduled or expected future events should only be included if the event is notable and almost certain to take place''. This event is both Deletion of 2011 WDF World Cup WP:NOT||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
15998 50 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hatvan Katliamı Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 19:09, 1 Haziran 2012 (UTC) comment Yalnız bir nokta var. Arama sonuçlarına bakınız. Bir katliamdan bahseden kaynaklar bulamadım yeterince. 'ya girer bu Hatvan Katliamı'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:ÖA Wikipedia:No original research 65
15999 6944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Humans in popular culture User:Tim 01:43, 10 September 2009 (UTC) keep per rticles for deletion/Earth (2nd nomination)|precedent. Surely the sources here are better than that article because at least we have (penguin-ish) sources here that are somewhat more independent of the subject? Seriously, though, '''delete''' per all of the above. Snow, anyone Deletion of Humans in popular culture WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
16000 13244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PayPlay User:My 10:26, 11 September 2006 (UTC) delete but not after congratulating them on getting their press release into Wikipedia! Enjoy it while it lasts. Can't '''fully''' verify that they fail because the only real info I can find out about their company is that they're an LLC, and probably based in the US. 100% complete lack of independent news coverage (other than press release reprints) points strongly to deletion Deletion of PayPlay WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16001 19369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Achcham Enbadhu Madamaiyada [[User talk:TheRedPenOfDoom|TRPoD aka The Red Pen of Doom]] 12:13, 19 October 2015 (UTC) merge the coverage is merely rehash of promotional materials Deletion of Achcham Enbadhu Madamaiyada WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16002 14647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chelsea McEachran User:onel5969 17:25, 30 November 2017 (UTC) delete clearly does not meet , and has the nom pointed out, fails Deletion of Chelsea McEachran WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16003 8478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Teo User:David 04:27, 13 June 2010 (UTC) delete """This doesn't look like one of those cases where the encyclopedia will be harmed by honoring the subject's deletion request. The article is oddly vague at some points (He went to """"various universities""""? He invented """"various medical devices""""? He is commercializing """"some instruments""""?) and lacking in reliable sources, so if it were kept it would require major cleanup, and it doesn't present strong evidence that the subject passes """ Deletion of Richard Teo WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16004 18500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CIDEB User:MER 11:55, 18 December 2006 (UTC) delete non-notable school, fails . I could find no evidence on Google that this exists Deletion of CIDEB WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16005 4531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 Long Branch shooting User:Alansohn 22:44, 1 January 2018 (UTC) delete per . Sadly, the murders of *ONLY* four people in a mass shooting is tragically too ordinary to merit the kind of long-term coverage that would establish notability. Any meaningful content could be preserved by a merge to Long Branch, New Jersey Deletion of 2018 Long Branch shooting WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16006 4225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global pharmaceutical prices User:SlamDiego 18:35, 31 January 2008 (UTC) delete Indeed notable, but this article is |“original research” and appears to be written to push a |point-of-view Deletion of Global pharmaceutical prices WP:OR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
16007 16221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Metropolitan bias User:Bearian 00:39, 3 June 2018 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Metropolitan bias WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
16008 21900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank Penale User:RightCowLeftCoast 21:51, 3 March 2012 (UTC) comment per #Appropriate notification to get additional editors to comment, I have left a message at the WikiProjects for Military History, New York (state), and Baseball Deletion of Frank Penale WP:CANVASS Wikipedia:Canvassing 93
16009 4052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jón Pauli Olsen User:Mattythewhite 21:23, 25 May 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Jón Pauli Olsen WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16010 4798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Icy Hot Stuntaz User:Isotope23 19:18, 29 March 2006 (UTC) keep and this is a good reason why meme criteria should be established as an offshoot of Deletion of Icy Hot Stuntaz WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16011 11540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abd al Malik Abd al Wahab User:Lawrence 20:36, 25 October 2007 (UTC) delete """A http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Abd+al+Malik+Abd+al+Wahab%22+-wikipedia+-wiki+-answers.com+-blog+-forum+-.mil&hl=en&pwst=1&start=20&sa=NGoogle search excluding non-RS sources, and excluding .mil U.S. government sites (as they are Primary sources for this case) doesn't show much. http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.ilustrados.com/publicaciones/EEulAFykupeOfzMrFq.php&sa=X&oi=translate&resnum=7&ct=result&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522Abd%2Bal%2BMalik%2BAbd%2Bal%2BWahab%2522%2B-wikipedia%2B-wiki%2B-answers.com%2B-blog%2B-forum%2B-.mil%26start%3D10%26hl%3Den%26sa%3DN%26pwst%3D1 This translated Spanish page is trivial at best; he's mentioned in passing. This http://web.amnesty.org/library/index/engamr510932005 Amnesty International reference is trivial at best, he's mentioned only in one sentence out of a significantly larger story. Every other search result (there are a couple of word spam sites in there, and another Wikipedia mirror) are not anything. So, we have no sources there. A http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Abd+al+Malik+Abd+al+Wahab%22&btnG=Search+Archives&hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8 Google news search, all dates has '''0''' hits. We're left with not one compliant anything with which to build a biographical article about """"Abd al Malik Abd al Wahab"""". Based on that, and , ''Delete'' on either/or reasoning or notability reasoning. We can't make an article ''about'' the man--no sources. We can't demonstrate notability per our standards. Delete""" Deletion of Abd al Malik Abd al Wahab WP:RS||WP:BLP1E||WP:BLP||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16012 9400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Nazism User:A 15:13, 8 November 2009 (UTC) delete per and/or . Speedy under G3 (for vandalism and blatant hoaxes) was declined Deletion of New Nazism WP:HOAX||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
16013 21790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sneha Krunal Thakker User:Cutest 08:24, 30 October 2014 (UTC) delete Fails |biographies of living people and |notability even it seems to be self-promotional article Deletion of Sneha Krunal Thakker WP:BLP||WP:N Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16014 4177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malini Subramaniam User:Topcipher 08:00, 17 April 2017 (UTC) keep per ; subject meets criteria 1 - ''''The person is regarded as an important figure or is widely cited by peers or successors''''. Besides https://www.cpj.org/awards/2016/malini-subramaniam-india.php the award, another major event that has received significant coverage in the media about the subject - is being threatened for her works, harassed - so much so that she had to leave her hometown, as covered in -1. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/committee-to-protect-journalists/journalists-in-india-thre_b_9377444.html Huffington post2. https://thewire.in/22100/activists-allege-state-persecution-for-flagging-human-rights-violations-in-chhattisgarh/ The Wire3. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/raipur/Chhattisgarh-journo-Malini-Subramaniam-forced-to-pack-up-quit-Bastar/articleshow/51059878.cms Time of India4. http://www.news18.com/news/india/human-rights-activists-demand-restoration-of-law-and-order-in-bastar-1343380.html News18and so on...many of which are major independent daily newspapers, news channels in India which sufficiently passes notability for more than single event ()i.e. award winning) per Also, there are sources that talk about the subject too (about their notability, claiming significance); example -1. http://indianexpress.com/article/entertainment/entertainment-others/covering-conflict-nupur-basu-women-journalists-in-conflict-zones-velvet-revolution-4551591/ Indian Express2. http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/gurinder-chadha-viceroys-house-huma-qureshi-partition-india-uk-pakistan/1/889373.html India Todayetc Deletion of Malini Subramaniam WP:JOURNALIST||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
16015 3464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artyom Dubovsky User:TheSpecialUser 11:12, 4 July 2012 (UTC) delete Not played in a full pro league and not enough done at 3rd level game. Fails and Deletion of Artyom Dubovsky WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16016 10049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohabbat Khawab Safar User:Eggishorn 00:31, 26 July 2017 (UTC) delete No verifiable indication that establishes notability under or Deletion of Mohabbat Khawab Safar WP:GNG||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
16017 30 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nirvanafanclub User:Zzuuzz 01:53, 26 October 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Nirvanafanclub WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16018 12622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aryanah Indoor Sports Hall User:Bagumba 08:59, 29 August 2018 (UTC) delete No eviedence presented that this meets Deletion of Aryanah Indoor Sports Hall WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16019 21635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of swear words User:Otto4711 04:57, 17 February 2007 (UTC) delete as an #IINFO|indiscriminate list Deletion of List of swear words WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16020 16550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peekvid.com (Second nomination) [[User talk:Pomte|Pomte]] 00:57, 4 March 2007 (UTC) keep Notable per by non-trivial secondary RS Deletion of Peekvid.com (Second nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16021 19585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Health intervention User:Waddie96 17:40, 9 April 2018 (UTC) keep A ridiculous nomination as nom has stated no valid reason for deletion. First of all, because topic X is part of topic Y does not mean that topic X does not get its own article. Second, that there's no cited material in the article is not a reason for deletion per . That being said, the subject of health intervention massively, overwhelmingly, satisfies the GNG. Just e.g. look at https://books.google.com/books?id=M2xFyBVL8SsC&pg=PA75&dq=%22public+health+intervention%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjqgbuY3a3aAhVDSK0KHeQcD8AQ6AEIODAE#v=onepage&q=%22public%20health%20intervention%22&f=false, https://books.google.com/books?id=mo9y1Tt-JeAC&pg=PA211&dq=%22public+health+intervention%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjqgbuY3a3aAhVDSK0KHeQcD8AQ6AEISDAH#v=onepage&q=%22public%20health%20intervention%22&f=false, https://books.google.com/books?id=L9BsBQAAQBAJ&pg=PA14&dq=%22public+health+intervention%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjqgbuY3a3aAhVDSK0KHeQcD8AQ6AEIUTAJ#v=onepage&q=%22public%20health%20intervention%22&f=false, and on and on and on and on. As for Deletion of Health intervention WP:ARTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16022 34 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/North Lindsey League User:Spiderone 16:39, 17 September 2020 (UTC) delete clearly fails due to lack of reliable sources covering the subject in depth; this is clearly an amateur competition and none of the teams or players involved seem to meet the notability guidelines either Deletion of North Lindsey League WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16023 6107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abigail Hopkins User:Less 11:26, 3 April 2020 (UTC) delete Haven't found any significant coverage except for her mentions in the articles about her father. Fails as well as Deletion of Abigail Hopkins WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16024 7572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaurya Doval User:Otr500 09:36, 19 April 2018 (UTC) delete """and '''Comments''': I am sure it has happened but the first instance I have seen. What is the protocol here? The article doesn't belong, being turned down 4 times, but somehow was created """"almost"""" identically (apparently the citations are the same just placed differently) to the ones rejected. It appears there must have been some collaboration to get an article created regardless of accepted community practices. Is there a """"speedy"""" criteria so should this be brought to the attention of an admin? If no speedy criteria is there other reasoning this can be dealt with by an admin as a breach of accepted community practices or possible """"socking""""? Was the circumvention successful so we must go through the deletion process and possibly seek |salting that can be just as easily circumvented? If an SPA (or anyone) removes a template without justification they should be warned but notability is certainly questioned with an AFD. """"IF"""" consensus is still a deciding factor then there is currently two """"delete"""" WP:!vote|!votes, one """"comment"""" and two involved editors that have not yet weighed in on the matter. However, it does seem there would be a way to prevent this from happening, or needs to be, else creativity has found a loophole that can be used in the future""" Deletion of Shaurya Doval WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
16025 15325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack McClellan User:Jack 04:11, 23 May 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Jack McClellan WP:BIO||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16026 3565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of albums considered the best User:Clarityfiend 10:18, 3 August 2014 (UTC) keep but clean up. The media keep churning out these album lists, so it deserves to be here. However, the median ranking business is . I'd rather go with albums in the top 10 on at least one component listing. Also, get rid of some of the weaker sources Deletion of List of albums considered the best WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16027 10274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/APPSeCONNECT User:Djm 10:55, 5 November 2018 (UTC) delete or Incubate): Too much focus on the corporation rather than the product and the hype may be clouding anything good and I'm not sure fixable, may be . Might be tempted to change my mind if more in depth about how APPSeCONNECT works rather than connecting a load of high level buzzwords together. ''Possibly'' no obvious vulnerability handling which may be a concern but not a concern from an article viewpoint. No obvious 100% independent review found, perhaps https://www.business-software.com/product/insync-appseconnect/ Business Software is one of the nearest but I have qualms about verification and independence of reviews. The Nascomm award is possibly borderline notable Deletion of APPSeCONNECT WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16028 19205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Eagan Holmes NONE NONE keep As it says, should be applied only to low-profile individuals, and after about a month of continuous worldwide news coverage about his person, I'd say it would be quite a stretch of the term to call Holmes still low-profile. Furthermore, you don't need a crystal ball to know with quite a bit of certainty that intermittent reporting about him will continue at least as long as his trial is ongoing, which will in all probability be for another year or two, as similar cases have shown repeatedly. And you may call all you want, but there are articles about Jared Loughner, Nidal Hasan, Robert Bales and numerous other mass shooters, and as the aforementioned guideline states Deletion of James Eagan Holmes WP:BLP1E||WP:OSE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16029 13056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kimberley Curtis User:Agricola44 13:52, 25 July 2012 (UTC) delete """I concur that Curtis' academic record of basically a single book having http://www.worldcat.org/title/our-sense-of-the-real-aesthetic-experience-and-arendtian-politics/oclc/41368333&referer=brief_results reasonable holdings is remarkably average. (Others having comparable records have been deleted in recent AfDs, e.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Christine_Mallinson&oldid=496323171 here.) Northern Arizona University|NAU lists her as an """"instructor"""" (checkable in the directory http://nau.edu/ here), so she seems no longer to be a tenure(track) academic. Her notoriety does seem to stem from secondary events in the wake of the Duke lacrosse case, but all I can readily find are some angry blog posts, e.g. http://liestoppers.blogspot.com/2007/12/professor-kim-curtis-husband-leaving.html here and http://ethicalduke.blogspot.com/2007/12/kim-curtis-gone.html here. The picture I ultimately come away with is of an average academic who had some fleeting notoriety""" Deletion of Kimberley Curtis WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16030 11668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yll Hoxha User:Zanoni 18:15, 6 October 2009 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Yll Hoxha WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16031 5783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/General stone User:Kinu 01:43, 7 February 2006 (UTC) delete Demos are ''not'' albums. If the album is yet to be released, it fails and the #Wikipedia is not a crystal ball|crystal ball Deletion of General stone WP:MUSIC||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16032 20040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liberty High School (Bakersfield, California) User:Shimeru 06:19, 28 December 2006 (UTC) delete It is verifiable that the school exists, but the article passes no other content policies except . (I suppose is arguable, but I find the bit about the administration and the coach somewhat suspect.) I don't think that's enough to keep it, in the absence of any sources (Google News brings up only 4 or so mentions, all in passing; will try Lexis-Nexis when I can, though), when it fails and . No opposition to merge/redirect Deletion of Liberty High School (Bakersfield, California) WP:WINAD||WP:NPOV||WP:SCHOOLS3||WP:SCHOOLS Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
16033 9961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kyle Fuller User:Paulmcdonald 04:50, 28 January 2014 (UTC) keep I wasn't expecting to find the coverage that I actually found in the news. A simple web search returns many articles in the news from third party reliable sources about his college football playing. That, in my opinion, is more than enough to pass Deletion of Kyle Fuller WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16034 20376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of PlayStation 2 games compatible with PlayStation 3 User:Grapefruit17 20:24, 21 November 2017 (UTC) delete """WP:OR for sure, and further more, the topic for these two lists seems not to meet . There is no real reason that anyone would need to know what PlayStation 1 and or 2 games are compatible with the ps3 for research purposes, this just seems like a page to answer the question of """"is my copy of __for the ps1 or ps2 playable on my ps3?"""". Wikipedia is not an answers site and this list is certainly not encyclopedic content. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of List of PlayStation 2 games compatible with PlayStation 3 WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16035 10252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joel Rudewicz User:Thinboy00 03:43, 30 June 2008 (UTC) delete against recreation with appropriate citations and a backed assertion of notability. Possibly |snowball it Deletion of Joel Rudewicz WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
16036 21558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack E. Conger User:Mztourist 03:11, 10 June 2020 (UTC) keep meets and we tend to have pages for aces Deletion of Jack E. Conger WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16037 16241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Children's immigration crisis User:Ukexpat 14:00, 9 July 2014 (UTC) delete per (some of the text may be a candidate for Wikinews Deletion of Children's immigration crisis WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16038 20079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Late bloomer User:Colonel 23:37, 30 December 2008 (UTC) keep Just needs development in accordance with our |editing policy Deletion of Late bloomer WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
16039 8721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kick Bong User:Pincrete 18:40, 23 May 2015 (UTC) delete No | reliable sources are given and the article does not indicate notability Deletion of Kick Bong WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16040 13327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rory Loy User:Nfitz 21:20, 29 June 2008 (UTC) delete Although the Scottish Premier League is a top-level league, Rory Loy is yet to play in it, and as such doesn't meet Deletion of Rory Loy WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16041 8954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Idiot: The Motion Picture User:Doc 20:09, 4 July 2008 (UTC) merge back to American Idiot#Movie adaptation, of which most of this article comes from. Most of article is |speculation mixed with out of date information (it might not be made at all, due to Foxboro Hot Tubs|other projects the members of Green Day are involved with Deletion of American Idiot: The Motion Picture WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16042 17345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lakoda Rayne (2nd nomination) User:A 19:41, 12 August 2012 (UTC) keep I only spent about 5 minutes and came up with these sources: http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/live-feed/x-factor-simon-cowell-lakoda-rayne-265525 hollywoodreporter.com, http://www.people.com/people/article/0,,20546214,00.html People, http://www.rollingstone.com/music/news/the-x-factor-recap-paulas-groups-are-dropping-like-flies-20111111 Rolling Stone, http://www.latina.com/entertainment/tv/watch-mexican-singer-hayley-orrantia-performs-somebody-you-x-factor Latina, http://www.eonline.com/news/274570/the-x-factor-elimination-who-s-breaking-down-under-the-pressure-hint-it-s-a-judge E Online, http://tv.yahoo.com/news/x-factor-why-steve-jones-shouldnt-hated-lakoda-043700269.html Yahoo! News, http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/tv-column/post/the-x-factor-stereo-hogzz-are-gonerzz/2011/11/08/gIQAmu0PAN_blog.html Washington Post, http://www.digitalspy.com/tv/s141/the-x-factor-us/interviews/a353538/x-factor-lakoda-rayne-qa-people-didnt-get-to-know-us-enough.html Digital Spy, http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-31749_162-57330947-10391698/the-x-factor-leroy-bell-lakoda-rayne-x-ed-out/ CBS News, http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1674164/x-factor-results-stereo-hogzz-lakoda-rayne.jhtml MTV News. Seems |notable enough to me Deletion of Lakoda Rayne (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16043 10776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barack Obama's first 100 days User:AlexTiefling 12:00, 21 January 2009 (UTC) delete Indiscriminate criterion, and Wikipedia is |not a crystal ball Deletion of Barack Obama's first 100 days WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16044 94 [[Lilli Hollein]] (erl., gelöscht) Benutzer:Docmo 13:53, 11. Sep. 2007 (CEST) delete Die Lemmata Tulga Beyerle, Lilli Hollein, Thomas Geisler und Neigungsgruppe Design wurden sämtlich von BenutzerNaitsabone|Naitsabone eingestellt. Demnach für mich PR-Arbeit; Inhalte entsprechen mE nicht den Löschung von Lilli Hollein Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
16045 6379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Er Beshi Bhalobasha Jay Na User:Epinoia 01:27, 6 May 2019 (UTC) delete doesn't meet Deletion of Er Beshi Bhalobasha Jay Na WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
16046 14344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunset Coast CLC [[User talk:Orderinchaos|Orderinchaos]] 10:31, 20 June 2009 (UTC) delete per nom and /. I know of this church (live not far from it) and it's not even notable or significant within its community (cf. Victory Life Centre and Riverview Church Deletion of Sunset Coast CLC WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16047 19816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anchalpur User:PohranicniStraze 17:53, 7 July 2021 (UTC) delete Just an |ordinary street, with no indication of being notable Deletion of Anchalpur WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
16048 3425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Dougherty (police officer) (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 23:00, 8 December 2020 (UTC) keep WP:SIGCOV|plenty of coverage. Even if he had not been Marilyn Monroe's first husband (which I do not concede is precluded by ), as the first SWAT trainer, he's notable Deletion of James Dougherty (police officer) (2nd nomination) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16049 20254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lu Ann Homza User:Kenirwin 15:33, 23 April 2018 (UTC) keep Thanks to the recently added citations, I'd agree that she passes muster as Deletion of Lu Ann Homza WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16050 5919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yoshi (band) User:N2e 02:49, 4 April 2010 (UTC) delete no notability demonstrated in a |reliable secondary source Deletion of Yoshi (band) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16051 3970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blumpster User:Quarl NONE delete as Wikipedia:Avoid_neologisms|non-notable unstable neologism, i.e. protologism (|Wikipedia is not a dictionary). &mdash Deletion of Blumpster WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16052 13469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tough mudder User:RP459 18:59, 15 March 2010 (UTC) comment I should have also included per as this http://www.foxbusiness.com/story/tough-tough-mudder-announces-toughest-day-endurance-race-planet/ indicates that its first race will be held on May 16 2nd 2010 Deletion of Tough mudder WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16053 13633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evil Adam User:Friday 16:41, 23 March 2006 (UTC) comment The claim to fame seems to revolve around their music being used in various animes and in some upcoming movies from Troma. They're not a pretend band or garage band like we so often get articles about, but I'm not sure they meet either Deletion of Evil Adam WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16054 8477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Turkish mafia User:Simonm223 04:01, 27 September 2009 (UTC) delete In addition to the nominator's statement, which is correct, Wikipedia is not for true crime stories and with no references there is no indication this is a notable gang. For all we know could apply Deletion of Turkish mafia WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
16055 11351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tehseen Fawad User:Bearcat 18:15, 7 March 2018 (UTC) keep Serving in a provincial or state legislature is a clean pass of #1. Certainly the article needs improvement, but as long as we can properly |verify that a person actually held the role they're claimed to have held (as opposed to being an outright ), people at this level of inherent notability are kept and just flagged for refimprove. Also I'm willing to bet that the nominator just searched for English sources, which would obviously be sparse, and didn't invest the same amount of energy into searching for the ''Urdu'' sources that would be much more likely available — and, for that matter, we don't require all of our sources to be online ones either: if there are newspapers in the Punjab that cover provincial politics but ''don't'' have websites, they're still perfectly valid sources Deletion of Tehseen Fawad WP:NPOL||WP:V||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Notability 77
16056 295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ghanada User:Cewbot 00:02, 29 November 2020 (UTC) comment While this discussion appears to have |no quorum, it is '''NOT eligible for |soft deletion''' because it has been {{fullurl:Special:Log|page={{urlencode:Ghanada}}}} previously PROD'd Deletion of Ghanada WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
16057 11643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Intellectual Dark Web User:Bmcollier 06:41, 27 May 2018 (UTC) delete Agree that this is sourced to an opinion piece which is attempting to discredit a group of thinkers by attaching a sinister label to them. Keeping the article on Wikipedia would wreak a rather unpleasant sort of mischief. So, - perhaps if the term is actually in mainstreamuse in a year or two the situation would be different Deletion of Intellectual Dark Web WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16058 1667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Singapore Hokkien Huay Kuan User:Lionratz 08:02, 6 January 2015 (UTC) keep The article meets most, if not all of the criteria set out in . The problem seems to stem from poor referencing practices by editors, which I have now rectified Deletion of Singapore Hokkien Huay Kuan WP:NONPROFIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16059 3273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Internet Movie Firearms Database User:Ansh666 09:51, 14 September 2013 (UTC) keep per Dream Focus. I've seen more es (as I frequent the site and they sometimes post about articles about themselves) but I can't find them as Google News hates me Deletion of Internet Movie Firearms Database WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16060 4610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Study abroad information User:Bfigura 04:26, 29 April 2008 (UTC) delete indeed, Wikipedia is #HOWTO|not a howto guide. Not convinced there's something worth merging here Deletion of Study abroad information WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16061 20477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Herbert, 18th Earl of Pembroke User:Moonraker 07:33, 9 March 2014 (UTC) keep """notable per , a significant figure in the West of England, although sources need to be improved. ''NB'' also the comment of Jimbo Wales at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Gordon, 7th Marquess of Aberdeen and Temair and elsewhere: """"There is usefulness in having a compete set of entries on hereditary peers, even if some peers are less prominent or noteworthy than others, even when the article must of necessity remain something of a stub. Considering these articles in isolation, i.e. not noting that they are part of a wider series, is mistaken""" Deletion of William Herbert, 18th Earl of Pembroke WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16062 16937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Western australia wildflowers User:Gnangarra 12:46, 9 September 2007 (UTC) delete 100% advertising(#G11 even) wouldnt redirect, title is nonsense wouldnt be a normal searched for item, Western Australian Wildflowers or Wildflowers of Western Australia are more likely to be searched for Deletion of Western australia wildflowers WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
16063 115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack and George User:Evb 14:07, 20 December 2007 (UTC) delete per |verifiability policy, , and |crystal ball Deletion of Jack and George WP:V||WP:COI||WP:NN||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16064 20386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Infamous Gaming User:Jovanmilic97 11:51, 13 December 2019 (UTC) keep There seems to be is some decent coverage in El Comercio (Peru) https://elcomercio.pe/tecnologia/videojuegos/dota-2-infamous-gaming-homenajeado-seattle-participacion-mundial-noticia-noticia-448032-noticia/, Perú.21 https://peru21.pe/videojuegos/infamous-gaming-equipo-peruano-dota-2-emociono-lagrimas-narradores-video-498265-noticia/, and La República https://larepublica.pe/videojuegos/1433027-dota-2-infamous-eliminado-dreamleague-season-11-luego-caer-team-secret/, enough to meet . The article needs to be cleaned out of unreliable esports sources Deletion of Infamous Gaming WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16065 20693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Swann User:ChrisTheDude 08:42, 19 March 2010 (UTC) delete fails and by a country mile Deletion of Richard Swann WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16066 5587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stefan Denkovich User:Argyle 20:35, 14 August 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and . The Red Star stats are false Deletion of Stefan Denkovich WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16067 8730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Cranmer User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:46, 3 March 2009 (UTC) keep improved article as meeting even if weak for Deletion of Bob Cranmer WP:PEOPLE||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16068 19320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Piskei User:GiantSnowman 12:34, 26 August 2011 (UTC) delete no evidence of notability, fails and Deletion of Peter Piskei WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16069 4154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sand Castles (film) User:Johnnylego88 20:25, 30 January 2015 (UTC) keep Like mentioned above, I managed to find quite of bit of articles and talk about the film and Sand Castles (film) has been edited with more notable and efficient sources since AfD started and is met. Also, since this discussion began, the film was announced alongside other notable films to be showcased in February at the 21st Sedona International Film Festival http://www.sedonafilmfestival.org/SIB/files/GRID%20-%20Official%2015.pdfhttp://www.sedonafilmfestival.org/Page.asp?NavID=162. Though a film's trailer popularity doesn't say if a film is notable or not, I think it is worth mentioning that the film's trailer was recently released and has tens of thousands of views already on one of many channels.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ywmnst3zGgl Deletion of Sand Castles (film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16070 15734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whitney Stevens User:Sharveet 17:55, 1 January 2009 (UTC) keep Award nominations means she meets Deletion of Whitney Stevens WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16071 13816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alpha Phi Epsilon (3rd nomination) User:NinjaRobotPirate 21:10, 12 January 2014 (UTC) delete Does not receive |significant coverage in independent |reliable sources. Sorry, but the mere fact that |it exists is not good enough. The fact that |other stuff exists is also a poor argument to keep ''this'' article. If there are other articles in even worse condition, they should be nominated, too. Adding more |primary sources will not help to establish |notability; instead, you should work to find coverage in newspapers, magazines, books, and other secondary sources Deletion of Alpha Phi Epsilon (3rd nomination) WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS||WP:ITEXISTS||WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS||WP:PRIMARY||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16072 46 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deangelo Martin User:J04n 13:22, 20 September 2020 (UTC) delete No claims to notability outside of what they are accused of, clear violation of |BLPCRIME Deletion of Deangelo Martin WP:BLPCRIME Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16073 5058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danny Abbadi User:Lifebaka 22:39, 16 April 2008 (UTC) delete The guy only has four fights, which doesn't indicate notability. No other indication is given. Also lacks references for most of it, so most of the content fails Deletion of Danny Abbadi WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16074 4906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norullah Noori NONE NONE keep """As I pointed out in the original {{tl|afd}} says individuals who have held senior government posts -- like Governor -- are considered notable. I offered links to substantiate that Noorullah Noori had been the Taliban's Governor of Balkh province. Noori was listed Wikisource:Denied_Persons_Pursuant_to_UN_Security_Council_Resolution#A._The_list_of_individuals_belonging_to_or_associated_with_the_Taliban|as number 90 on the United Nations' 1267 list of sanctioned individuals. The list transliterates his name as """"Nurullah Nuri"""", and asserts that not only was he Governor of Balkh, but he was also the administrator of the Northern Region. If I understood the closing administrator's post-facto justification for this deletion he or she could not accept considering the United Nations a reliable source for the positions of government officials like Noori""" Deletion of Norullah Noori WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16075 15601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monika (Doki Doki Literature Club!) User:Archrogue 01:57, 24 January 2021 (UTC) merge to Doki Doki Literature Club!. I remember I tried to source this one months ago and I'm shocked there aren't more people talking about the writing in this game. But really most of the articles talk about the writing and character design more generally. I'm sure there is something to Deletion of Monika (Doki Doki Literature Club!) WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
16076 6024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rape in the United States of America User:Alan 20:28, 18 November 2009 (UTC) comment """Let us not focus on the """"copy and paste"""". That is now fixed since I have deleted the duplicated material from the rape page. Since WP is always growing it follows that some articles should be |split. Due to the large amount of US info in the article it was a logical move to split it out""" Deletion of Rape in the United States of America WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Splitting 57
16077 10843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FOB Productions User:Madchester 03:25, 13 January 2006 (UTC) delete Lots of talk, but no references to back it up. Wikipedia is neither #Wikipedia is not a soapbox|a vehicle for self-promotion/advertising nor is it a #Wikipedia is not a free host or webspace provider|free webspace provider Deletion of FOB Productions WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16078 15208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 United States tomato shortage User:Shadowjams 10:05, 23 October 2010 (UTC) delete I'm dismayed at how this AfD seems to have been neglected because it plainly fails . It's basic OTNEWS and seasonal fluctuations in produce or any other crop do not make an encyclopedia article. Context matters a lot more than how many references you can quantify. This does not have any notability in the sense anyone really means that term Deletion of 2010 United States tomato shortage WP:N||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16079 16225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cloob User:UnitedStatesian 01:04, 8 March 2008 (UTC) delete WP:CSB says nothing about ignoring core WP policies, like , in articles of interest in the 3rd world. Nothing in the article is verifiable via significant coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Cloob WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16080 14755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Small, local, or niche genre conventions User:Falcon 06:03, 5 August 2008 (UTC) delete This may be a lot of things (specifically, a category or a project page), if only it were written as one. What it is not is an article. See #DIR Deletion of Small, local, or niche genre conventions WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16081 8762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swanston estates User:Edison 03:25, 4 May 2009 (UTC) delete """Neighborhoods (or zipcodes, for that matter) are not inherently notable.The """"courtesy notability"""" given to villages does not includeu every developer's tract in a city. Is there any evidence it satisfies """ Deletion of Swanston estates WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16082 19521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethel Farrell User:DerbyCountyinNZ 07:19, 4 May 2015 (UTC) delete or '''Merge''' to List of Australian supercentenarians. As noted above, debatable/negligible encyclopedic content and nothing to justify a separate article. No indication of . Note that almost all the entries at List of British supercentenarians#People have more substantial content than this article Deletion of Ethel Farrell WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
16083 4597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of female performers in lesbian porn films User:Suomi 20:23, 13 August 2010 (UTC) delete """A potential BLP concern, although with proper sourcing that's not ''necessarily'' a reason to delete. I fail to see how it's encyclopedic though, as acting in """"lesbian"""" porn is hardly a defining moment for porn actresses. To me, this looks like . It's also not a mirror of List of male performers in gay porn films, since the vast, vast majority of """"lesbian"""" porn films are not aimed at lesbian audiences and cannot be considered """"gay porn"""" in any way. I'm also not quite sure why""" Deletion of List of female performers in lesbian porn films WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16084 19932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tushar NAIN User:GermanJoe 09:27, 17 August 2015 (UTC) delete """self-promotion of non-notable student. Only sources are SPS, minor listings, and references for details that are not directly about him. The main claim for notability, """"Project Yantr"""", is carefully described as a ''future'' project in development (aka. not currently working) and is not covered by reliable sources. Aside from the self-promotion against policy this is also far """ Deletion of Tushar NAIN WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16085 5375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amrish Ranjan Pandey User:Grailcombs 16:54, 11 March 2021 (UTC) delete Present amount of sources are not enough to meet Deletion of Amrish Ranjan Pandey WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16086 13684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salute picture User:Boleyn 07:33, 6 September 2014 (UTC) delete No coverage, does not meet . Potential transfer (and maybe soft redirect) to Wiktionary Deletion of Salute picture WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16087 16825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Kelly (Freeholder) (2nd nomination) User:Calton 08:19, 1 May 2007 (UTC) delete by nom and Caknuck's reasoning Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sue Schilling (2nd nomination)|here. Not even close to meeting , no matter how much mud Alansohn tries to stir up to obscure this Deletion of Joe Kelly (Freeholder) (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16088 5166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Binayak Giri User:Spike 11:52, 18 May 2018 (UTC) delete Fails , having not played any 1st class, list A nor T20 games or any national games at a suitable level. Does not pass for me. I can't find a page for them on cricinfo Deletion of Binayak Giri WP:NCRIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16089 10345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Songs about clothes User:Cirt 17:53, 20 December 2007 (UTC) delete as per above, and as unsourced Deletion of Songs about clothes WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16090 3534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stadium Rave User:Esradekan 23:32, 14 April 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Songs. No awards, no chart, no covers, no Deletion of Stadium Rave WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16091 8084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kayavak (beluga whale) User:Alison22 23:43, 20 December 2009 (UTC) keep per : There's tons of coverage in Wikipedia:Reliable sources about this particular whale, including http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/chicagotribune/access/56577663.html?dids=56577663:56577663&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Jul+19%2C+2000&author=William+Mullen%2C+Tribune+Staff+Writer&pub=Chicago+Tribune&desc=SHEDD+COOING+OVER+BABY+BELUGA+NEWBORN+ADAPTING+QUICKLY%2C+KEEPERS+SAY&pqatl=google http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/chicagotribune/access/47854814.html?dids=47854814:47854814&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Dec+28%2C+1999&author=Lisa+Fingeret%2C+Tribune+Staff+Writer+Tribune+staff+writer+William+Mullen+contributed+to+this+report&pub=Chicago+Tribune&desc=BELUGA+CALF+%27GETTING+THE+HANG%27+OF+EATING+AFTER+MOM%27S+DEATH&pqatl=google http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/chicagotribune/access/770774521.html?dids=770774521:770774521&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Dec+26%2C+2004&author=William+Mullen%2C+Tribune+staff+reporter&pub=Chicago+Tribune&desc=A+%27labor+of+love%27+pays+off+%3B+After+being+raised+by+humans+in+a+tireless+survival+effort%2C+Kayavak+learns+how+to+be+a+whale&pqatl=google http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-126687159.html http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=CSTB&p_theme=cstb&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0EB42445A0B6F551&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-4558601.html Deletion of Kayavak (beluga whale) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16092 325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom D’Agostino User:Bearian 13:52, 21 August 2018 (UTC) delete """people who run """"marketing|distribution"""" companies are |dime a dozen until Betsy DeVos|they own at least four yachts. Husbands do |not inherit notability from their wives unless Prince Phillip|they get an HRH in front of their names""" Deletion of Tom D’Agostino WP:MILL||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
16093 19940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grace Nicklin User:Cullen328 03:33, 20 December 2011 (UTC) delete Speedy? Though this article may have an element of satire, it is pretty much an |attack page about a non-notable person Deletion of Grace Nicklin WP:ATTACKPAGE Wikipedia:Attack page 100
16094 8732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Savage Hypocrisy User:Otolemur 11:50, 11 April 2008 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Savage Hypocrisy WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16095 2793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/8 Flavahz [[User talk:132.3.17.68|talk]]) 20:10, 13 July 2012 (UTC) keep """The crew is notable for more than just ABDC as the members have appeared in music videos, movies, and other television performances and the author has provided citations for almost all of these events. I guess references were added after this article was nominated for deletion. References are also provided for the """"history"""" section which discusses how the group formed before appearing on ''America's Best Dance Crew''. This happened namely through World of Dance which, from my understanding, is a fairly large scale street dance competition. After reviewing the references, I feel that they meet the grounds of establishing the crew's notability as outlined in . They are all secondary sources so they meet as well. I just fact checked all the refs. The CollectiveUth ref wasn't working for me and the Hollywood Reporter ref doesn't prove that Charlize was in Rage Crew and/or present during that performance. However, the other 11 citations were working and they did validate the sentences that they supported. Aside from that, the article's tone is appropriate since it doesn't sound like an advertisement and it isn't unambiguously promotional. My only qualms are the """"Flavah"""" column in the members' table as I view this as pure and the """"dance competitions"""" category tag which is inappropriate since 8 Flavahs is not a competition but a dance crew that has participated in competitions. However, these are easily rememdied by simply removing them. For all these reasons, I vote """"keep"""". Special:Contributions/132.3.17.68|132.3.17.68""" Deletion of 8 Flavahz WP:GNG||WP:THIRDPARTY||WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16096 5173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Koltz User:MelanieN 14:04, 16 August 2010 (UTC) delete """This writer's claim to fame is that he ghost-wrote a couple of books by General Zinni (not quite ghost-wrote, since he is credited as co-writer) and that he wrote two of the """"Choose Your Own Adventure"""" books. Not even close to meeting """ Deletion of Tony Koltz WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16097 14863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ysera User:Doctorfluffy 05:26, 3 November 2007 (UTC) delete Fails , unlikely reliable secondary sources can be found to establish notability, and violates #PLOT Deletion of Ysera WP:FICT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16098 4974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kate Melton User:DiamondRemley39 14:45, 17 May 2020 (UTC) comment """Looking at : """"People are likely to be notable if they meet any of the following standards"""" as relates to . So: it does not need to meet . She played a notable character, Daphne Blake, in two films, and there is at least one review out there that talks of her performance in one of those popular films. The article now has a reliable secondary source. Still could use more sources, but that's a whole different animal""" Deletion of Kate Melton WP:ANYBIO||WP:ENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16099 10820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Holistic Management International (3rd nomination) User:Paleorthid 22:37, 18 February 2019 (UTC) keep Passes . Scale is good, and https://www.google.com/search?ei=uDBrXOOiMMia_QaRrrWYDg&q=%22Holistic+Management+International%22+-wikipedia+-holisticmanagement.org&oq=%22Holistic+Management+International%22+-wikipedia+-holisticmanagement.org importance is established with reliable sources. The Savory article does not cover HMI and there is resistance to Talk:Allan_Savory#Bias_from_criticism_section|doing so Deletion of Holistic Management International (3rd nomination) WP:NONPROFIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16100 21577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Human Kinetics (publisher) User:K 04:12, 31 August 2016 (UTC) delete """per and . With sections such as """"Corporate responsibility initiatives"""" one knows that this unambiguous advertising""" Deletion of Human Kinetics (publisher) WP:PROMO||WP:WEBHOST Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16101 2003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rabble of Devilkin User:Shooterwalker 23:25, 2 June 2010 (UTC) merge and '''redirect''' to Lord of the Nine Hells. No sources to meet but could fit in another article in the mean time Deletion of Rabble of Devilkin WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16102 647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WWE 2K (Mobile Game) User:Joseph2302 22:59, 6 April 2015 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON, Deletion of WWE 2K (Mobile Game) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16103 21031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Menville [[User talk:Fishhead2100|Hey yo!]][[Special:Contributions/Fishhead2100|I didn't do it!]] 18:59, 10 February 2013 (UTC) keep """It seems as though by reading some comments that is being used as a reason to get this article deleted. It seems as though what is being said is """"similar articles were deleted, so this one should be too."""" With so many actors and voice credits to his name, I also find it difficult to see how he isn't notable. Mr. C.C""" Deletion of Scott Menville WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16104 9347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Menstruation and the origins of culture User:Demiurge 14:17, 30 December 2006 (UTC) delete although it is not |original research, the article is written to advocate a particular theory and does not use an encyclopaedic tone, thus violating . This theory may be worthy of a paragraph in Culture and menstruation Deletion of Menstruation and the origins of culture WP:NOR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
16105 13182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Acey Aquino User:Bearian 20:35, 19 October 2010 (UTC) delete Aquino has had guest roles on major TV shows (see ''Nagsimula sa Puso'') but nothing really starring. We should hold her to |the entertainer guideline, and for that, she fails. The Philippines is a market of 90 Million and we should treat its stars equally with those of other large countries. When she gets a starring role, then she will rank for |inclusion in Wikipedia. Until then, she's off the air Deletion of Acey Aquino WP:ENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16106 4987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 Australian Open – Women's singles final User:Local 06:03, 26 June 2021 (UTC) delete I think this narrows down to what 'significant' means in the context of 'significant coverage in reliable sources independent of the subject'. Many tennis matches in grand slam series will receive coverage in reliable sources - you will be able to find a dozen or so when Djokovic beats Federer in a semi-final, but this doesn't make every semi-final notable and thus worthy of an article (subject to ). The coverage should be a dominating event - such as if something absolutely groundbreaking happened (eg, the 'ground' on the tennis court broke open) - causing it to be a notable event. I think that's a way this issue can be reconcilled. There is nothing particularly notable about this match. It should be deleted. Mostly neutral on whether intro content should be merged, but I don't think that the set-by-set breakdown is really necessary Deletion of 2018 Australian Open – Women's singles final WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16107 2681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2002 Dudley earthquake User:Mikenorton 16:42, 14 March 2018 (UTC) comment """The problem with putting this earthquake back into the list (which was recently drastically shortened by me) is that such standalone lists should be lists of notable topics (assuming that this is an example of the first type mentioned in ) so for inclusion they should individually meet the criteria - to quote """"This standard prevents Wikipedia from becoming an indiscriminate list, and prevents individual lists from being too large to be useful to readers"""", which in my opinion the previous version of the list article was (~50k). I will try to think of other ways in which such non-notable events could be recorded without recreating the list as it was. We should not be trying to match the full British Geological Survey list of earthquakes""" Deletion of 2002 Dudley earthquake WP:CSC Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
16108 3316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Live Rushfeldt Deila User:Malo95 07:26, 13 June 2021 (UTC) keep First as information: handball is not a small sport it is under the five biggest team sports in the world and the clear number two in Europe. To the AfD: I found several sources about her and according to this https://www.aftenbladet.no/sport/i/AlpMWq/datter-til-tidligere-viking-spiller-har-signert-for-sola she signed in February a professional contract. According to https://zip.news/dk/index.html?ordering=PUBLISH_DATE&country=NO&mediaType=NEWS&query=Live+Rushfeldt+Deila zip.news there are 50 articles about her. I my eyes she will pass Deletion of Live Rushfeldt Deila WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16109 13082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael G. Breece User:MER 11:30, 4 January 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Michael G. Breece WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16110 13401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gina Green User:Morgan 16:41, 20 July 2007 (UTC) keep The disconnect between Fanficgurl and the keepers on her notability is disturbing. Either she (Fanficgurl) needs to read or she has bad intentions Deletion of Gina Green WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16111 21180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wayne Hall (ice hockey) User:The 14:13, 14 October 2013 (UTC) keep Passes . See also , Deletion of Wayne Hall (ice hockey) WP:NHOCKEY||WP:NOEFFORT||WP:TOOLITTLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16112 4995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rizky Syawaludin User:Argyle 16:43, 16 January 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Rizky Syawaludin WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16113 5481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ghost deer User:Rhododendrites 03:10, 23 August 2017 (UTC) delete """There are some ghits for """"ghost deer,"""" but there's not enough about ''this'' ghost deer to satisfy . &mdash""" Deletion of Ghost deer WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16114 6645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giulia Anghelescu User:Cavarrone 07:10, 20 February 2015 (UTC) keep """failed , clearly a celebrity, she regularly receives tons of coverage in Romanian newspapers, magazines and other news sources: eg, http://www.eva.ro/divertisment/stiri/giulia-anghelescu-noua-solista-dj-project-articol-15141.html, http://www.topromanesc.ro/giulia-lanseaza-un-nou-single-si-videoclip-jocuri-deocheate/38388, http://jurnalul.ro/timp-liber/monden/giulia-anghelescu-vine-la-splash-vedete-la-apa-la-indemnul-so-ului-vlad-huidu-668844.html, http://www.libertatea.ro/detalii/articol/cea-mai-eficienta-metoda-de-slabit-e-la-indemana-oricui-giulia-anghelescu-a-slabit-18-kilograme-rap-514218.html, http://www.romaniatv.net/veste-cumplita-pentru-giulia-insarcinata-in-aproape-opt-luni-cantareata-a-aflat-ca-are-probleme-cu-sarcina_201512.html, http://www.revistatango.ro/stil-de-viata/beauty-news-style/indragosteste-te-de-viata-cu-farmec-si-giulia-anghelescu-7375.html, http://www.libertatea.ro/detalii/articol/giulia-nastere-cu-riscuri-524079.html, http://www.romaniatv.net/anunt-de-ultima-ora-giulia-anghelescu-este-insarcinata_180605.html, http://www.click.ro/comunitate/romanesti/giulia-anghelescu-s-decis-ce-spune-despre-divortul-de-vlad-huidu, http://www.gandul.info/magazin/cum-a-slabit-giulia-anghelescu-18-kilograme-dupa-nastere-fara-sa-tina-regim-13712395, http://www.viva.ro/vedete-si-evenimente/giulia-anghelescu-la-30-de-ani-uite-prin-ce-schimbari-de-stil-trecut-2347094, http://www.ele.ro/giulia-anghelescu/stiri-giulia-anghelescu/cum-arata-giulia-anghelescu-insarcinata-in-patru-luni-44304, http://www.romaniatv.net/anunt-de-ultima-ora-giulia-anghelescu-este-insarcinata_180605.html, http://www.ziare.com/vedete/vedete-romanesti/giulia-anghelescu-despre-perioada-candy-dj-project-prietenii-din-showbiz-si-visul-sau-secret-interviu-1304018, http://www.ele.ro/fashion/stiri-fashion/verdictul-stilistului-andreea-banica-vs-giulia-anghelescu-si-alina-chivulescu-in-salopete-vezi-cine-le-poarta-mai-bine-41331, http://www.click.ro/comunitate/romanesti/divorteaza-giulia-anghelescu-de-vlad-huidu-ce-spun-parintii-celor-doi, http://www.enational.ro/showbizmonden/monden/giulia-si-a-facut-freza-cu-grilaj-317719.html/, http://www.cancan.ro/showbiz/showbiz-intern/giulia-anghelescu-vlad-huidu-isi-doresc-copil-fetita-pentru-imbracat-239699.html, http://www.bzi.ro/la-asta-nu-te-asteptai-adevaratul-motiv-pentru-care-giulia-anghelescu-nu-divorteaza-de-vlad-huidu-437999, http://www.realitatea.net/giulia-a-slabit-18-kg-cu-ceai-din-cozi-de-cirese_1400129.html, http://www.revistavip.net/Stiri_de_ultima_ora/Giulia_Anghelescu_si_Vlad_Huidu_si-au_spus_adio!/2933/, http://www.puterea.ro/monden/satula-de-speculatii-giulia-anghelescu-vorbeste-despre-divort-93011.html, http://adevarul.ro/entertainment/celebritati/giulia-nascut-sunt-cea-mai-fericita-mamica-1_50aea1e77c42d5a6639e99e9/index.html, http://www.evz.ro/giulia-adorata-de-comunitatea-gay-din-romania-962404.html, http://monden.acasa.ro/vedete-din-romania-320/giulia-anghelescu-in-depresie-afla-motivul-179964.html, http://stirile.rol.ro/giulia-insarcinata-pentru-a-doua-oara-vezi-cum-arata-foto-939929.html, there are dozens of pages about her on Google News. And I just checked for """"Giulia Anghelescu"""", not for """"Giulia"""" which is her stage name. She appears to be some sort of local Rihanna and she apparently receives news coverage on daily basis, I can't see how a Romanian-born editor could fail to see that in their . Article |is in bad shape, but Wikipedia:Deletion is not cleanup|AfD is not cleanup""" Deletion of Giulia Anghelescu WP:BEFORE||WP:BEFORE||WP:UGLY Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16115 21104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Fallon (Columban Priest) User:Guliolopez 16:15, 20 May 2017 (UTC) merge Per nom, , and . Notwithstanding subject's other activities (missionary priest), references and claims of notability seem to relate substantively to subject's death. Per {{u|Edison}}, and with every respect to subject's own circumstance, the relevant guidelines (1E/VICTIM/NOTMEMORIAL) therefore would seem to apply. These guidelines suggesting that such content should be dealt with in an article focusing on the event - rather than an article focusing on the victim/etc. Hence merge/redirect to the article on the event. Like Manila massacre Deletion of Peter Fallon (Columban Priest) WP:1E||WP:VICTIM||WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16116 11452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional medicines and drugs User:Reyk 19:50, 20 September 2010 (UTC) delete """Being sourced entirely to editors' interpretations of the various primary sources, this list is inherently prone to |original research. If you chop the words """"List of"""" off the front of the article title, do you get a topic that could stand on its own two feet in terms of verifiability and notability? No. So a ''list'' of these things is even less appropriate""" Deletion of List of fictional medicines and drugs WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16117 6148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Oban derailment [[User talk:70.80.234.196|talk]]) 23:48, 6 June 2010 (UTC) delete per .--Special:Contributions/70.80.234.196|70.80.234.196 Deletion of 2010 Oban derailment WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16118 5379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of regular expression software User:Rhododendrites 23:04, 22 August 2016 (UTC) delete """When I first noticed this nomination I figured """"regular expression software"""" must be a type of program for, say, assisting with regular expressions. But it looks to be a list of software that supports regular expressions. That seems |indiscriminate, and we would need to see some reliable sources which treat them as a group to establish . I'm not seeing that. &mdash""" Deletion of List of regular expression software WP:IINFO||WP:LISTN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16119 18346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Red Bar Radio User:Kinu 03:56, 5 February 2006 (UTC) delete Not notable, except maybe for local or cruft interest; reeks of Deletion of Red Bar Radio WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
16120 10025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salamander Crossing User:Bakazaka 22:13, 23 February 2019 (UTC) keep """as pass of , see e.g. """"Folk Music; Salamander reaches crossroad."""" Gewertz, Daniel. ''Boston Herald'', 03 Dec 1999: S23, and """"Music: Salamander Crossing."""" Bialczak, Mark. ''The Post - Standard'', 07 May 1999: 4, and the especially thorough profile/review """"Bottleneck Dreams."""" Lewis, George H. ''Popular Music and Society'' Vol. 25, Iss. 3/4, (Fall 2001): 121-124. That's in ''addition'' to the later coverage of the band in the context of the members' subsequent work""" Deletion of Salamander Crossing WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16121 17118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/You, Me & The Devil Makes 3 User:Esradekan 21:33, 4 January 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Songs. No chartage, no awards, no cover versions, = no article. Even if it had met any of those criteria it still wouldn't pass since there is not enough info for a reasonably detailed article Deletion of You, Me & The Devil Makes 3 WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16122 9628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rob Level User:Antonioatrylia 02:34, 27 July 2017 (UTC) comment The blp prod was removed according to policy, (see my talk page) or read over section 2 and 3 at under section objecting. There was a disagreemnt as to whether all the references could be considered unreliable Deletion of Rob Level WP:BLPPROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion of biographies of living people 66
16123 2535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Gravediggers User:Gavin 09:31, 13 October 2007 (UTC) delete as they are not |notable characters. Compare and contrast with Rosencrantz & Guildenstern Are Dead|Rosencrantz & Guildenstern whose notability is derived from adaptations outside of the play's context. I have already merged the text with Gravedigger#Gravediggers in literature|Gravediggers in literature, where I think the content of this stub should be laid to rest Deletion of The Gravediggers WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
16124 165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ricky Holland User:Lankiveil 23:55, 11 April 2009 (UTC) delete tragic, but a classic case of Deletion of Ricky Holland WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16125 21762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wesley Gibson User:Happyme22 02:26, 3 July 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Wesley Gibson WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16126 3123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shooting arm sleeve User:Hersfold 03:44, 25 July 2008 (UTC) delete """I'm not finding any reliable references for this, mostly sites trying to sell them, and I don't see that this is notable enough to be covered. """"Target for advertisement"""" isn't a reason for deletion in itself, but there's not enough context to maintain an encyclopedic article on this. Maybe redirect if an appropriate target can be found, but I see no reason for this to remain without some |significant work""" Deletion of Shooting arm sleeve WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
16127 12640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skin friction lines [[User talk:202.124.74.22|talk]]) 07:37, 3 September 2012 (UTC) keep and to the nom. Bad-faith nomination, with hundreds of reliable sources existing. -- Special:Contributions/202.124.74.22|202.124.74.22 Deletion of Skin friction lines WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Whacking with a wet trout 74
16128 19480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Borg (scientist) User:GenuineArt 18:48, 20 December 2018 (UTC) delete As per nom. Does fails Deletion of Joseph Borg (scientist) WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16129 386 [[Thomas Dietrich]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Magiers NONE keep Kasten|1= nach Ausbau. Inzwischen sind ausreichende Quellen vorhanden, die genügend Inszenierungen an relevanten Bühnen nachweisen. Damit sind die #Darstellende Künstler, Moderatoren, Filmstab erfüllt. Gruß Löschung von Thomas Dietrich Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
16130 15130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Su madre User:Yomangani 11:33, 17 September 2006 (UTC) delete """Wikipedia is |not a how to argue in other languages guide. Might merge to a more general article on translation of slang, if there was one. (It does translate as """"your mother"""" by the way, """"tu mama"""" would be closer to """"yo' mama""" Deletion of Su madre WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16131 2184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brandon Gentile User:Djsasso 18:49, 7 February 2012 (UTC) keep passes criteria #3 as also pointed out by Deletion of Brandon Gentile WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16132 13863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dreadnoks User:BOZ 02:56, 16 May 2020 (UTC) keep or '''merge''' to Cobra (G.I. Joe)#Factions per above comments since there are to retain, per and Deletion of Dreadnoks WP:RS||WP:PRESERVE||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16133 8483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Total Drama World Tour Cycle 1 User:Jj98 01:49, 28 August 2010 (UTC) delete as |hoax. The article fails Deletion of Total Drama World Tour Cycle 1 WP:HOAX||WP:N Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
16134 11703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B.Sc Emergency and Trauma Care Technology User:Daa89563 04:03, 23 January 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of B.Sc Emergency and Trauma Care Technology WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16135 19570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Anstruther-Thomson of Charleton and Carntyne User:PWilkinson 23:24, 18 July 2015 (UTC) comment I am not finding much except passing mentions, but I would be rather surprised to find that someone caricatured by Leslie Ward|Spy in Vanity Fair (UK)|Vanity Fair was not |notable at the time. I suspect I am missing something Deletion of John Anstruther-Thomson of Charleton and Carntyne WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16136 10989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Super Mario video game remakes User:Blake 18:09, 23 March 2011 (UTC) merge to something general like List of Mario media. While it is really a |content fork, as they should be discussed in the original game's article, I don't think the article deserves deletion because of its age and history Deletion of Super Mario video game remakes WP:FORK Wikipedia:Mirrors and forks 46
16137 9585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Septimus Heap (character) User:Sgeureka 18:14, 10 September 2008 (UTC) delete in its current form (#PLOT|pure plot summary at best, pure |original research at worst), '''or upmerge''' into List of characters in the Septimus Heap series (along with Snorri Snorrelssen and the redlinked characters from the template) to allow the addition of analysis/reception by reliable sources. The mentioned sources above do not convince me that this ''character'' can stand on its own as an article (yet), although these sources would be excellent for the main Septimus Heap ''series'' article. &ndash Deletion of Septimus Heap (character) WP:NOT||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16138 2572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Dungeons & Dragons halfling deities User:Rorshacma 19:26, 2 December 2019 (UTC) delete The individual gods listed here are not individually notable. Searching for sources discussing the concept of Halfling Deities as a group turns up nothing in-depth in any kind of reliable, secondary sources, thus causing the list to fail Deletion of List of Dungeons & Dragons halfling deities WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16139 17584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thottbot (2nd nomination) User:Pixelface 09:28, 8 March 2008 (UTC) delete as there are no |reliable secondary sources to demonstrate |notability. Ghits cannot be accepted as evidence of notability; nor can trivial mentions of the websites in press releases, fansites or brief mentions of the site's content. The content of the article does not have any citations which |verify its origins; this leads me to conclude that the article is |original research. Since Deletion of Thottbot (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:WEB||WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16140 11215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pete Holly (3rd nomination) User:Malber 13:31, 11 September 2006 (UTC) keep Artist has released three albums on The Orchard (music label).http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=sr_nr_seeall_1/102-7677520-5456915?ie=UTF8&keywords=Pete%20Holly&rh=i%3Aaps%2Ck%3APete%20Holly%2Ci%3Apopular Meets notability criteria of #Musicians and ensembles|#4 Deletion of Pete Holly (3rd nomination) WP:NMG||WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16141 17177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ectopusses User:Bearian 02:31, 12 July 2008 (UTC) delete per above. No real world notability, no evidence it's likely to be so per Deletion of Ectopusses WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16142 21250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Whitehouse User:Bearian 17:10, 23 June 2015 (UTC) delete not a single |reliable source exists. We don't build |biographies based solely on Good Reads, YouTube, and fan fiction. Perhaps a redirect might work Deletion of Michael Whitehouse WP:RS||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16143 3366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Rabbi's Wife User:RL0919 13:58, 19 March 2010 (UTC) keep I note that many articles about books by David Benedictus that were nominated recently had been prodded back in December. I did some basic research on them then. I only objected to the prods if I found evidence of multiple reliable sources. There seems to be a failure of on all these nominations Deletion of The Rabbi's Wife WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16144 1137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Imperial Garden User:Jerem43 20:17, 17 December 2010 (UTC) comment the Best of Madison is a readers poll and does not establish Notability per otability Deletion of Imperial Garden WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16145 17395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Leonard-Morgan User:Ponyo 18:39, 18 November 2016 (UTC) keep Leonard-Morgan has been nominated for two BAFTAS and won one. He meets points 1 and 4 of . There are plenty of reliable sources available, I'll start adding them to the article Deletion of Paul Leonard-Morgan WP:COMPOSER Wikipedia:Notability 77
16146 1942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Number Four in the Apocalypse User:Loriendrew 03:40, 10 October 2014 (UTC) delete WP:OR and Deletion of The Number Four in the Apocalypse WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16147 19031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Care2 User:Black 09:44, 10 March 2007 (UTC) keep A number of http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&q=%22Care2%22%20-wikipedia&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&um=1&sa=N&tab=wn Google News references for the group. Also, despite , which I agree with in principle, 7 million is a large enough number to confer notability. If all else fails (although I don't think this is the case here), should cover this: the inclusion of an organisation with a membership of 7 million is certainly beneficial to the building of an encyclopedia. I will try to improve the article with independent references by the close of the AFD, but can make no promises (as the close-date is in 14 hours). If closed as keep, I will still try to improve it with sources Deletion of Care2 WP:BIGNUMBER||WP:IAR Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16148 11088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yoshiki Nakajima User:K 00:44, 4 January 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet just yet. per review of available sources Deletion of Yoshiki Nakajima WP:NACTOR||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
16149 10019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Velizar Dimov User:GiantSnowman 21:12, 20 November 2013 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Velizar Dimov WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16150 20280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonnie Penn User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:42, 31 July 2012 (UTC) keep """and allow continued improvements to this stuub. WP:AUTHOR does not refer to only authors of books, but is set to address creative individuals in general. As the MTV show ''The Buried Life '', """"major"""" or not, has established notability enough to merit a Wikipedia article, it can be argued that this person, as creator, executive producer and cast member of the show, meets . And the book ''What Do You Want to Do Before You Die?'' '''IS''' a book, '''DID''' make the New York Times Bestseller list,http://newsroom.mtv.com/2012/04/05/buried-life-book-makes-best-seller-list-19-crossed-off-bucket-list/ and '''WAS''' in fact co-authored by Penn,http://books.google.com/books?id=qzhdZDhTMY4C&printsec=frontcover&dq=%22What+Do+You+Want+to+Do+Before+You+Die?%22&source=bl&ots=MmfLsX87gU&sig=oaUA_0ankhFTURkIfcXQYFUZ7wI&hl=en&sa=X&ei=U18XUJHeBYSjrQHR1oDYDw&ved=0CDAQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=%22What%20Do%20You%20Want%20to%20Do%20Before%20You%20Die%3F%22&f=false so a claim that it is not a book or that Penn had no part in its creation is patently incorrect. As a book itself receiving coverage in multiple reliable sources,http://www.google.com/search?q=New+York+Times+bestseller+list%2C+http%3A%2F%2Fbooks.google.com%2Fbooks%3Fid%3DqzhdZDhTMY4C%26printsec%3Dfrontcover%26dq%3D%2522What%2BDo%2BYou%2BWant%2Bto%2BDo%2BBefore%2BYou%2BDie%3F%2522%26source%3Dbl%26ots%3DMmfLsX87gU%26sig%3DoaUA_0ankhFTURkIfcXQYFUZ7wI%26hl%3Den%26sa%3DX%26ei%3DU18XUJHeBYSjrQHR1oDYDw%26ved%3D0CDAQ6AEwAA%23v%3Do&rls=com.microsoft:en-us&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&startIndex=&startPage=1#q=%22What+Do+You+Want+to+Do+Before+You+Die%3F%22&hl=en&rls=com.microsoft:en-us&tbm=nws&prmd=imvns&source=lnt&tbs=ar:1&sa=X&ei=2GAXUPXbCMi4rQG5_ICoBQ&ved=0CCUQpwUoBQ&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.&fp=d02239687ac47524&biw=1024&bih=616 the book meets the standards set at per and the """"author"""" portion of |guideline and is met. And oh... we have the individual himeself being the recipient of coverage in |multiple reliable sources... another point in his favor.http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Jonnie+Penn%22&tbm=nws&tbs=ar:1 I see an improvable stub on a notable topic. I do not see anything that requires deletion""" Deletion of Jonnie Penn WP:CREATIVE||WP:NBOOK||WP:BKCRIT||WP:CREATIVE||WP:NBOOK||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16151 15500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AS-PL User:Monrobang2017 13:26, 28 September 2018 (UTC) comment OK, using the . I would like to ask for your tips on how I should improve this article to remain him on Wikipedia Deletion of AS-PL WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
16152 7191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bellevue Massacre User:BabbaQ 21:27, 20 December 2014 (UTC) keep has been the subject of media, passes in large Deletion of Bellevue Massacre WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16153 18410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cardo (record producer) User:Meatsgains 22:46, 19 July 2016 (UTC) delete Subject lacks significant coverage in reliable sources. Deletion of Cardo (record producer) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16154 11192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albert Muema User:Taewangkorea 19:48, 17 October 2019 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Albert Muema WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16155 19332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rabia Salihu Sa'id User:David 21:43, 11 December 2016 (UTC) keep I'm pretty sure she does not pass (the Elsevier thing is an early-career award, not enough for that criterion of ). But getting both the Elsevier award and the BBC 100 listing gives enough in-depth and reliable coverage of her for . As for the publications in bad journals: this seems to be pretty common for third-world academics, and if the case were based on it would be a major problem, but I think the GNG case is independent of that. That said, any parts of the article based on material in bad journals (in particular the sentence cited to her own paper in IJETAE, for which see https://scholarlyoa.com/2016/10/25/journal-offers-authors-research-paper-royalty-scheme-for-getting-citations/ this post) should be trimmed from our article. It's not a reliable source both because of the journal quality issue and because it's by the subject rather than about her Deletion of Rabia Salihu Sa'id WP:PROF||WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16156 8489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iranian moderates User:Pburka 22:22, 18 March 2017 (UTC) merge to Politics of Iran. This stub of an article attempts to define the term, but admits in the first sentence that the term is not well defined. This is essentially a , so not encyclopedic Deletion of Iranian moderates WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
16157 7786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KidsClick Schedule Changes User:Wcquidditch 19:10, 5 January 2018 (UTC) delete """I'm not entirely sure if this actually meets the |criteria for speedy deletion… but as with virtually everyone else in this discussion, I cannot see how we can have this article when |we are not a program guide. While NOTTVGUIDE does say {{Talk quotation|historically significant program lists and schedules may be acceptable}}, I don't really think this really qualifies as """"historically significant"""". Take away the airtimes (which, even when not within the context of an actual schedule, have in other articles been deemed to violate NOTTVGUIDE) and you just have a list of programs aired on the block… which is already in the main KidsClick article and does not need its own page""" Deletion of KidsClick Schedule Changes WP:SPEEDY||WP:NOTTVGUIDE Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
16158 15814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shuhag Yahya User:PJM 03:57, 25 November 2005 (UTC) delete """per . The last sentence claims the subject holds a """"world record"""", so the article evades A7, in my view""" Deletion of Shuhag Yahya WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16159 11904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leanne Dunic User:Kudpung 13:32, 18 October 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and . A plethora of sources alone, whether primary or otherwise, does not necessarily add up to notability Deletion of Leanne Dunic WP:CREATIVE||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16160 18448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 Auckland Open (darts) User:Ajpolino 02:44, 9 January 2017 (UTC) comment It looks like there are identical articles for 2006 Auckland Open (darts)|2006 through the upcoming 2017 Auckland Open (darts)|2017 tournaments. I can't find much evidence these meet (which I think are the relevant notability criteria), unless these count as a final match determining champion of a top league? Perhaps someone with more familiarity with the topic could find sources indicating the tournaments are notable. If not, I'd support merging all the annual tournament pages to Auckland Open (darts). I'll notify Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Darts|WP:Darts of the AfD Deletion of 2016 Auckland Open (darts) WP:SPORTSEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16161 8759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burgerspace User:Sephiroth 00:29, 24 April 2008 (UTC) delete fails to assert any notability via |reliable sources independent of the topic Deletion of Burgerspace WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16162 6587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simtropolis (3rd nomination) User:Fredrick 16:23, 13 August 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Simtropolis (3rd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16163 14502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unbelievable (TV series) User:Hintswen 12:39, 18 September 2019 (UTC) delete This has been a hard one for me to make a decision on, while this may be a notable Japanese show (based on the fact that it has been running from 1997 to now as I could not find viewership numbers) the English article is likely so short due to the fact that it is not very popular (if at all) with international audiences. As far as I can tell it was never released with subtitles in anything other than Japanese making it inaccessible to people that do not speak Japanese. I see little point in keeping an article that gives almost no information about something inaccessible and of little interest to someone that does not know Japanese. While an article being short may not be a valid reason for deletion I do believe this fails in regards to the English Wikipedia Deletion of Unbelievable (TV series) WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16164 8682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alfie Meadows User:Joshua 18:11, 9 January 2011 (UTC) keep per . Notability is asserted by sources. There are multiple sources, both in the References section and in the External links section Deletion of Alfie Meadows WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16165 17153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Ciccone User:Jclemens 21:16, 16 July 2008 (UTC) keep He's put himself into the media spotlight in a big way. Had this been nominated two months ago, this might have been appropriate. If he vanishes off the face of the earth after the book furor dies down, take it back to AfD then, when we can take a longer view of his Deletion of Christopher Ciccone WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16166 20899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 American Northeast heat wave User:The 17:42, 13 July 2018 (UTC) delete on account of subject lacking |verifiable |notability. Where are the |sources? At some point we should be able to distinguish serious reporting from the summer silly season Deletion of 2016 American Northeast heat wave WP:V||WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16167 20737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alice Stevenson User:David 19:18, 8 December 2010 (UTC) delete per nom and Neptune. The footnotes to GRG web pages and the external link to the OHB page are now-familiar hallmarks of longevity-cruftstubs. Neither is a reliable source. Charitably, they are primary sources, prohibited as the sole source for any information in an article, per and . Less charitably, they are not reliable sources because they are the self-published work of a cadre of niche enthusiasts. The pages display few, if any, of the attributes defined in . The World's Oldest People wikiproject talk page is now host to an effort to prune back the worst of what's become a dreadfully dense . Please review the Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_World%27s_Oldest_People#Deletion_recommendations|table of proposed and resolved afds there for recent similar discussions to this one. There's a reassuring sameness to the results. The gears grind slowly, but the system works Deletion of Alice Stevenson WP:NOR||WP:SYN||WP:RS||WP:WALLEDGARDEN Wikipedia:No original research 65
16168 17608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pon And Zi User:Bill 01:31, 5 June 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Pon And Zi WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16169 12332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Filip Zekavičić User:Rikster2 13:25, 19 September 2016 (UTC) comment The PBL doesn't specifically meet the guideline and I don't think it is accurate to say that every player who has ever played even one game in the league should be presumed notable, as is generally true of the leagues specifically named. If he played in Euroleague games that would be a different matter. Best bet would be to prove that this subject meets , as this supersedes any sport guideline anyway. If it can't be proven he meets GNG then the article should be deleted Deletion of Filip Zekavičić WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16170 21426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 Wikipedia blackout User:The 18:01, 17 January 2012 (UTC) merge to article on SOPA. Eventually we may have an article on the general blackout, but focusing specifically on Wikipedia seems a bit too #NEWS|newsy to me Deletion of 2012 Wikipedia blackout WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16171 1235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grant Blackwood User:Cerebellum 15:54, 24 February 2010 (UTC) comment """I found http://thecelebritycafe.com/books/full_review/156.html this, which contains the sentence """"Grant Blackwood wrote with such visual excitement and the details of his characters' surroundings are sharp, clean, and chillingly alive with frightening realism that I found myself to be there in the middle of it all,"""" (significant critical attention per ? You decide.) and my google news search turned up http://moreresults.factiva.com/results/index/index.aspx?ref=EVEEXP0020051110e1b90000c another story as well, but the link is dead. I'll see if I can turn up anything else""" Deletion of Grant Blackwood WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16172 21651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taler (cryptocurrency) User:Bearian 18:18, 16 December 2020 (UTC) delete per . Even if it's notable, the propaganda-filled citations make this article untenable Deletion of Taler (cryptocurrency) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
16173 5850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sootie User:Quarl NONE delete as |unverifiable protologism. &mdash Deletion of Sootie WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16174 20355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Untouchable music group User:Truthsort 16:36, 9 March 2012 (UTC) delete per Deletion of The Untouchable music group WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16175 18667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dizzy Pong User:Hersfold 04:45, 28 October 2007 (UTC) delete haven't we deleted this before? Wait, that was some variation of beer pong. Not much difference, |clearly made up in school/in the author's basement/five minutes before this was written, or some variation thereof Deletion of Dizzy Pong WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
16176 6187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allegra Passugger User:Sam 09:42, 4 August 2016 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Allegra Passugger WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16177 1017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shuttlecraft (Star Trek) User:Edison 02:26, 22 November 2011 (UTC) keep """Too much in-universe detail?"""" Then use the '''edit''' button. Google book search shows the following books which are not franchise novels, with coverage of shuttlecraft on Star Trek: http://books.google.com/books?id=po7406HGXQYC&pg=SA13-PA8&dq=shuttlecraft+%22star+trek%22&hl=en&ei=zgTLTouWB8fY0QHW5IEI&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=2&ved=0CEEQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=shuttlecraft%20%22star%20trek%22&f=false, http://books.google.com/books?id=1DlgE6MS49AC&pg=PA136&dq=shuttlecraft+%22star+trek%22&hl=en&ei=zgTLTouWB8fY0QHW5IEI&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=3&ved=0CEcQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q&f=false, http://books.google.com/books?id=Ah1k_EsaOHsC&pg=PA51&dq=shuttlecraft+%22star+trek%22&hl=en&ei=zgTLTouWB8fY0QHW5IEI&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=7&ved=0CF8Q6AEwBg#v=onepage&q=shuttlecraft%20%22star%20trek%22&f=false, http://books.google.com/books?id=gmS3Lwm2MqIC&pg=PT180&dq=shuttlecraft+%22star+trek%22&hl=en&ei=cAXLTqeNDoL50gHM2fQN&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=2&ved=0CEEQ6AEwATgK#v=onepage&q=shuttlecraft%20%22star%20trek%22&f=false a real world simulation, http://books.google.com/books?id=R9G_F28VWXcC&q=shuttlecraft+%22star+trek%22&dq=shuttlecraft+%22star+trek%22&hl=en&ei=cAXLTqeNDoL50gHM2fQN&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=9&ved=0CGkQ6AEwCDgK, http://books.google.com/books?id=MiJTlrdSkpAC&pg=PA67&dq=shuttlecraft+%22star+trek%22&hl=en&ei=xQXLTsChGcH30gHn8JAo&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=7&ved=0CE8Q6AEwBjgU#v=onepage&q=shuttlecraft%20%22star%20trek%22&f=false, http://books.google.com/books?id=riW0RgaMN9sC&q=shuttlecraft+%22star+trek%22&dq=shuttlecraft+%22star+trek%22&hl=en&ei=xQXLTsChGcH30gHn8JAo&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=8&ved=0CFQQ6AEwBzgU, http://books.google.com/books?id=QYOFAAAAIAAJ&q=shuttlecraft+%22star+trek%22&dq=shuttlecraft+%22star+trek%22&hl=en&ei=xQXLTsChGcH30gHn8JAo&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=9&ved=0CFkQ6AEwCDgU, http://books.google.com/books?id=K3X9wMlmTjcC&pg=PA47&dq=shuttlecraft+%22star+trek%22&hl=en&ei=lAbLTtz7CKPj0QHLmMUv&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=8&ved=0CFIQ6AEwBzgy#v=onepage&q&f=false. Appears to satisfy """ Deletion of Shuttlecraft (Star Trek) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16178 8286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of physical therapy schools in the United States User:Triptothecottage 01:50, 8 July 2017 (UTC) delete Nothing here suggests and the structure looks like Deletion of List of physical therapy schools in the United States WP:LISTN||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16179 8740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ntelabi User:Bonadea 19:54, 1 May 2017 (UTC) delete does not meet nor Deletion of Ntelabi WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16180 19418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S. F. Kapoor User:David 07:05, 6 February 2010 (UTC) delete I tried some searches for evidence that he might pass and came up empty-handed Deletion of S. F. Kapoor WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16181 19704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Labour Party of America User:MuZemike 21:37, 23 November 2008 (UTC) delete http://brennan574.vox.com/library/post/the-labour-party-what-we-need.html?_c=feed-atom Not a hoax, I cannot find any |verifiable secondary sources establishing the needed |notability for inclusion. Also note a clear |conflict of interest with the article's creator; I also suspect possible |spamming as a result (i.e. Wikipedia is not the place to ''primarily'' let people know about a new party that you created yourself; that must be established outside of Wikipedia first Deletion of Labour Party of America WP:V||WP:N||WP:COI||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16182 18063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twilight: The Musical User:Accurizer 01:17, 29 June 2009 (UTC) comment I see a press release, two blog entries, and superficial coverage at www.yourmovies.com.au. Unless I am missing something, how does this satisty Deletion of Twilight: The Musical WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16183 17015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jasper A. Vrugt User:PWilkinson 13:39, 4 October 2014 (UTC) keep GScholar shows an h-index of 38, which would be well over what would be expected for #1 in most disciplines and (even though this is probably a relatively highly-cited discipline) probably adequate here - particularly when six of his papers (on all of which he seems to be the first-named author) have over 200 citations each. His fellowships of the American Geophysical Union and the Geological Society of America also both seem quite likely to meet #3, though I am willing to be corrected on this Deletion of Jasper A. Vrugt WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16184 8443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aleksandr Dulichenko User:Jpbowen 10:56, 18 January 2010 (UTC) keep He passes as a professor with a festschrift, which demonstrates significant peer esteem. Personally I think the existence of a festschrift should be mentioned explicitly in . This on its own makes him worthy of inclusion in my view. Of course non-English speaking and non-scientific academics will have lower Google rankings in general and I do not believe Wikipedia should be Anglo-centric in this regard Deletion of Aleksandr Dulichenko WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16185 1335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Collegiate Statesmen Foundation User:HitroMilanese 21:26, 6 September 2015 (UTC) delete Fails on . Not enough coverage in reliable sources, hence failing Deletion of The Collegiate Statesmen Foundation WP:NONPROFIT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16186 8769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carol Zara User:Vodello 01:48, 19 October 2010 (UTC) delete Although the nomination rationale is completely |weak and may ultimately lead to failure in this attempt because of it, I couldn't find any significant coverage from |reliable sources other than a mention on G4's Women of the Web. Google news and books turned up nil for her name and/or website, and the references in the article itself are unreliable blogs, blogs, and more blogs Deletion of Carol Zara WP:JNN||WP:RS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16187 2605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 Burgwedel stabbing [[User talk:92.11.149.25|talk]]) 23:10, 16 April 2018 (UTC) keep something'' meets here. It could be this article should be merged into and redirected towards 2018 German stabbings or even knife crime in Germany. Or, per , maybe it'll be alright as a standalone piece. But the information here should be retained in one form or another and once the dust settles merging can be discussed without heading to AfD. -- BobTheIP editing as Special:Contributions/92.11.149.25|92.11.149.25 Deletion of 2018 Burgwedel stabbing WP:GNG||WP:RAPID Wikipedia:Notability 77
16188 17549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New South Wales derby (A-League) User:Macktheknifeau 10:51, 20 August 2013 (UTC) delete No rivalry here at all, not a local derby. It would have been nice to go through however Deletion of New South Wales derby (A-League) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16189 16202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Is Otakudom (2nd nomination) User:Doctorfluffy 05:39, 2 November 2007 (UTC) delete per others. Fails Deletion of This Is Otakudom (2nd nomination) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16190 21399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/No Entry Mein Entry User:Anupmehra 22:18, 2 November 2016 (UTC) delete WP:CRYSTAL. Even the cast of film has not been finalised yet. Redirecting it to parent article is an |option but we would need to semi-protect the title Deletion of No Entry Mein Entry WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
16191 21654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brick&Bolt User:Pharaoh 00:12, 19 November 2020 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Brick&Bolt WP:NCORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16192 21317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plot of Les Misérables User:Noroton 00:52, 6 July 2007 (UTC) comment """Based on comments from Otto and Jay 32183, among others, my thinking on this is (I hope) becoming a bit more refined. Here's my concise, slightly retooled argument: ''Les Mis'' is not only without question notable itself, but it is so notable that Wikipedia should give it the same extended coverage that other subjects get in which we have multiple articles, some taking on aspects of those subjects. To adequately cover ''Les Mis'', with its enormous length and convoluted plot (something it is known for) you need an extensive plot summary, one which would overwhelm the main article if included there. The fact that Wikipedia has a rule on plots should not prevent us from adjusting, violating or making an exception to that rule (describe it however you will) in a way that protects Wikipedia from becoming damaged. And make no mistake, for Wikipedia to cover ''Les Mis'' inadequately because of some bureaucratic rule, damages Wikipedia. And gives us a mandate to ignore rules which, in a particular case, hurt Wikipedia. (Full text: """"If the rules prevent you from improving or maintaining Wikipedia, ignore them."""") We damage Wikipedia if we don't cover big subjects adequately, we improve Wikipedia when we do""" Deletion of Plot of Les Misérables WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
16193 15470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karaj Payam Noor University User:SailingInABathTub 15:15, 22 April 2021 (UTC) merge to Payame_Noor_University#Locations. I could not find sufficient English language sources to show that this campus is independently notable. The redirect (or merge) could have been boldly done without bringing it to AfD, per Deletion of Karaj Payam Noor University WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16194 3093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quest Atlantis User:Cymsdale 12:35, 25 February 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Quest Atlantis WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
16195 14183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amelia Kinkade User:AleatoryPonderings 16:07, 13 September 2020 (UTC) comment Relevant SNGs include both and as she began her career as an actor and then transitioned to an (apparently rather successful) career as an occult writer Deletion of Amelia Kinkade WP:NACTOR||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16196 15356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Artists' Studio User:Shirahadasha 02:36, 25 February 2007 (UTC) delete No |sources. Need sources with evidence of |notability per to survive deletion scrutiny Deletion of The Artists' Studio WP:RS||WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16197 21450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antoine Dodson (2nd nomination) User:John 01:51, 29 August 2010 (UTC) comment """Does'' criteria 2 apply here? I'm not entirely certain given the inadvertent nature of his artistic contribution. If it applies, then """"Keep."""" If not,"""" Delete"""" and redirect to Bed Intruder Song""" Deletion of Antoine Dodson (2nd nomination) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16198 18185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bunkunmi Oluwasina User:Celestina007 00:06, 14 July 2020 (UTC) comment It should be noted that subject of article is supposed to be an actress & singer but doesn’t fulfill any single criterion from & Deletion of Bunkunmi Oluwasina WP:NACTOR||WP:SINGER Wikipedia:Notability 77
16199 9944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karen Danczuk User:Lightburst 20:20, 3 July 2019 (UTC) keep once a subject is notable it is always notable. and Deletion of Karen Danczuk WP:BEFORE||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16200 6548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eboostr User:Blanchardb 00:11, 16 February 2008 (UTC) delete The sources in the article are either primary sources or passing mentions, and don't establish |notability. A quick gsearch shows lots of very short reviews of the software exist -- I am not familiar enough with the sites involved to determine if they are Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable sources that are independent of the subject. (And a note to Deletion of Eboostr WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16201 10667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 state visit of the United States to the United Kingdom User:Exemplo347 19:11, 22 June 2017 (UTC) delete Even if it had happened, it would probably have fallen foul of unless something special had happened during the visit Deletion of 2017 state visit of the United States to the United Kingdom WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16202 15454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sportscast Stars Training User:Sherwood10 15:55, 25 June 2013 (UTC) delete Spam and not notable per Deletion of Sportscast Stars Training WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16203 2538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary Watton User:Qrsdogg 21:38, 24 May 2011 (UTC) delete Looks to me like he fails Deletion of Gary Watton WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16204 6312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alfred Hitchcock Masterpiece Collection User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:55, 30 November 2008 (UTC) keep per as the article can be cleaned up and sourced. Have added several RS sources that might be used Deletion of Alfred Hitchcock Masterpiece Collection WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
16205 1986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Internet Watch Foundation and Wikipedia User:Ros0709 NONE comment Time to close per yet Deletion of Internet Watch Foundation and Wikipedia WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
16206 7349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IBasic User:Seraphimblade 23:00, 28 November 2006 (UTC) delete as advertisement, else '''delete''' as notability is established but is not |sourced Deletion of IBasic WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16207 2726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noogenesis User:Xxanthippe 23:46, 4 March 2021 (UTC) delete Lacks RS Deletion of Noogenesis WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
16208 10996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sex abuse cases in American public schools (Iowa) NONE NONE delete I am changing my vote to delete after reading wikipolicies on Deletion of Sex abuse cases in American public schools (Iowa) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16209 18806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bird Bird User:Nescio 09:46, 5 June 2007 (UTC) delete A quick glance at http://www.google.com/search?sourceid=navclient-ff&ie=UTF-8&rls=GGGL,GGGL:2006-17,GGGL:en&q=%22Bird+Bird%22 Google makes me think of Deletion of Bird Bird WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
16210 334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mythology of Lost User:I 20:52, 17 January 2013 (UTC) delete in agreement with the nominator. This doesn't really seem like appropriate content for Wikipedia (as it is mostly unsourced or interpretative speculation from primary/non-independent sources) and represents a |content fork where none is needed Deletion of Mythology of Lost WP:CONTENTFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
16211 5192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agniputra (Nepali film) User:SL93 01:04, 31 December 2018 (UTC) delete I couldn't find any significant coverage per Deletion of Agniputra (Nepali film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16212 711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pegasus Airlines Flight 8622 User:Sandstein 21:53, 20 January 2018 (UTC) delete WP:MILL transportation incident, got extensive reporting likely because of the dramatic imagery, but still a case of . Expensive things break all the time Deletion of Pegasus Airlines Flight 8622 WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16213 1301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesse Bushyhead User:Dsmdgold 20:50, 18 February 2008 (UTC) keep """meets the general |notability criteria, 2 sources already referenced in article, '''Bláthnaid''' found an additional two. Note that notability comes as from being one of the leaders of the Cherokees during the Trail of Tears not from being a """"religious leader"""". (Full disclosure, I created the intial version of this article""" Deletion of Jesse Bushyhead WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16214 9649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dick Cheney's health User:Ohnoitsjamie 23:52, 14 July 2010 (UTC) delete Fork from Dick Cheney with nothing more than an excess amount of detail. Just because all of this was reported in the news doesn't mean it merit's an article (i.e., . Cheney's health should be summarized in the main article, and nothing more Deletion of Dick Cheney's health WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16215 14125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Wachtler User:Dunkleosteus77 15:12, 28 August 2020 (UTC) delete per above, and most every sentence wholly fails Deletion of Michael Wachtler WP:EDITORIAL Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
16216 17286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William D. Carmichael User:David 17:59, 24 May 2013 (UTC) delete His positions have not been high enough level to be inherently notable and there doesn't seem to be enough nontrivial press coverage to make a good case for Deletion of William D. Carmichael WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16217 20432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hiram Lewis User:Koffieyahoo 02:38, 28 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails and the article is unsourced Deletion of Hiram Lewis WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16218 19596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/No Regrets (Band) User:NawlinWiki 19:38, 6 March 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of No Regrets (Band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16219 10840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/West Virginia University Alma Mater User:MelanieN 00:30, 11 August 2010 (UTC) merge """to West Virginia University. Nothing at the article or on a Google search indicates that this song is notable enough for a separate article. The explanation for why """"this type of article goes against Wikipedia recommendations,"""" and why no one attempted to """"improve the article before nominating"""", can be found at """ Deletion of West Virginia University Alma Mater WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16220 1709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Dungeons & Dragons dragon deities User:Rorshacma 16:48, 13 December 2019 (UTC) delete As with the rest of the species-specific deity lists, there are no reliable sources talking about the grouping as a whole that goes beyond basic plot or passing mentions - basically only Tiamat and Bahamut are potentially notable among the group, and are the only ones that really get any kind of coverage that could argued to be from reliable, secondary sources, and they already have their own articles. So, the grouping fails , and as only two of these entries are blue-linked, it does not really serve much of a purpose as a navigational tool. The only deities here that would warrant being merged into the main Dragon (Dungeons & Dragons) would be Tiamat & Bahamut, but since they already have separate articles, that isn't really necessary at this point Deletion of List of Dungeons & Dragons dragon deities WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16221 14269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isaiah Richardson Jr. User:4meter4 16:17, 10 March 2016 (UTC) delete I think enough non-trivial coverage is there to satisfy and a reasonable keep argument could be made. However, should be considered and for that reason we should delete this article. Best Deletion of Isaiah Richardson Jr. WP:GNG||WP:BLPREQUESTDELETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16222 1007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Psychology Wiki User:Dpbsmith 15:24, 3 August 2006 (UTC) delete """per above and also per #Wikipedia is not a crystal ball|Wikipedia is not a crystal ball. """"This site aims to..."""" """"This site is intended to slowly develop..."""" """"is is envisaged that..."""" """"as the intended users are..."""" """"much greater potential for... """" """"is intended to eventually have links to every..."""" """"will have extensive indexing..."""" The article can be re-created without prejudice when the site has '''achieved''' some of its """"aims,"""" has develop'''ed''' as """"intended"""", has '''realized''' some of what now is only """"envisaged,"""" has '''achieved''' some of what is now only """"potential"""", and actually ''has'' extensive indexing""" Deletion of The Psychology Wiki WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16223 10789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Mathewson User:SportingFlyer 11:33, 18 October 2020 (UTC) delete I agree with the nominator on the issue, and he's not otherwise notable per Deletion of Kevin Mathewson WP:BLP1E||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16224 16560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diaper bag User:Hobit 15:17, 16 March 2008 (UTC) keep per . Nice job Deletion of Diaper bag WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
16225 3862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NCircle User:Gavin 09:48, 28 July 2009 (UTC) delete as this |linkfarm is pure |spam. In any case, there is no evidence that this company, its products (or should I refer to them as nProducts?), employees or directors are notable Deletion of NCircle WP:LINKFARM||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16226 3331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Depledge User:4meter4 01:37, 6 October 2019 (UTC) keep Passes and Deletion of Alex Depledge WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16227 5874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frederick L. Schmersahl [[User talk:24.151.10.165|talk]]) 16:58, 19 February 2015 (UTC) keep per . Whether or not mayors of Hoboken are presumed notable as mayors of regionally significant cities, the multiple New York Times articles constitute significant coverage appropriate to the time period. Special:Contributions/24.151.10.165|24.151.10.165 Deletion of Frederick L. Schmersahl WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16228 10640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Imtech (band) User:Czar 01:31, 7 October 2014 (UTC) delete """Searched for the band name and """"Joaquim Sabaté"""". I'm not as well versed with music sources, but the closest I came to finding something on the artist was with ''ProQuest'': 'BRIDGE TO PEACE' CONCERT BRINGS THEODORE BIKEL, RENOWNED MUSICAL FRIENDS TOGETHER FOR EVENING OF GLOBAL MUSIC. (2007, Apr 03). US Fed News Service, Including US State News Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.ezproxy.library.wisc.edu/docview/472118030 (a press release). Otherwise, I couldn't confirm that other mentions were of the musician. Not nearly enough |significant coverage in multiple |reliable, |independent sources to constitute an article. No useful redirect targets. czar """ Deletion of Imtech (band) WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16229 8002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Momeraths User:Tucoxn 03:53, 2 December 2014 (UTC) delete since the subject of this article fails : it has not been the subject of multiple, non-trivial, published works appearing in sources that are reliable, not self-published, and are independent from the group itself. Also, Jabberwocky#cite_ref-AAW96_15-5|the mome raths' Jabberwocky#cite_ref-AAW96_15-6|outgrabe at an unfortunate level of quality because the band has not fulfilled most of the other criteria at , including having a single or album on a country's national music chart, having a record certified gold, or winning or being nominated a major music award Deletion of The Momeraths WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16230 1727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crystal Clark User:Corpx 06:17, 11 August 2007 (UTC) delete per #NEWS - An appearance on a reality show != historic notability Deletion of Crystal Clark WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16231 5130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minim football teams of the University of Notre Dame User:Paulmcdonald 14:35, 18 February 2021 (UTC) keep """There's nothing that discounts coverage for being """"local"""" only that the coverage must be """"significant"""" -- this topic seems to be a worthy inclusion for its historical value and coverage details. That we don't have a lot of online sources available for this time frame is no shock to me, and I believe that including this article does make Wikipedia better. It appears to be a worthy exception to the practice of not having articles for sports at this level""" Deletion of Minim football teams of the University of Notre Dame WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16232 1494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Roseberry [[User talk:Ravenswing|''' '' Ravenswing '' ''']] 07:33, 10 April 2015 (UTC) delete """Let's examine, for example, the links CrazyAces have posted. The first and fifth sources (from the same source) are fluff blog pieces of the sort debarred by WP:ROUTINE. The second is a mere mention of the subject's name in a list, and therefore can't be used to sustain the notability of the subject. The third reports, credulously, false claims that open grave doubts about it meeting the fact-checking requirement of the GNG and . The fourth is a casual one-sentence mention of the sort the GNG explicitly debars. The sixth is a casual mention. The seventh is the exact same citation as the third; err?As far as being an aikido practitioner goes, that in of itself isn't notable, and anyone connected with martial arts should know that. As far as """"creating a style"""" goes, there are hundreds of guys around the world who claim to have """"created a style,"""" at least for the purposes of declaring themselves 10th dan rainbow belt grandmasters and peddling videos ... my old teacher, a simple black belt in a legit style, sold out and repackaged himself as a similar bullshido peddler. Perhaps Roseberry isn't in that camp: in which case, there are multiple reliable sources saying so. Where are they, please""" Deletion of John Roseberry WP:IRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16233 13349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Extreme Dodgeball User:Alzarian16 20:24, 10 October 2011 (UTC) keep """Although the article is poor, sources definitely exist. """"Extreme Dodgeball"""" gets 310 http://www.google.co.uk/#q=%22Extreme+Dodgeball%22&hl=en&tbm=nws&source=lnt&tbs=ar:1&sa=X&ei=d1OTTtaPMsKw8gPM18QX&ved=0CBMQpwUoBw&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.,cf.osb&fp=48e3a202022e72cd&biw=1366&bih=562 GNews results, including significant coverage from the http://www.nytimes.com/2004/06/20/weekinreview/ouch-dodgeball-gets-another-shot.html New York Times, http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/chicagotribune/access/869473451.html?dids=869473451:869473451&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Jul+19%2C+2005&author=Associated+Press&pub=Chicago+Tribune&desc=Going+to+extremes+%3B+GSN+overhauls+'Extreme+Dodgeball'+into+high-action+sport&pqatl=google Chicago Tribune and http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=9lQyAAAAIBAJ&sjid=ZLUFAAAAIBAJ&pg=3300,4596602&dq=extreme-dodgeball&hl=en Beaver County Times - and that's just from the first page! Definitely meets """ Deletion of Extreme Dodgeball WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16234 4668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/County (China) User:Snotbot 19:12, 17 November 2011 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2011 November 17 Deletion of County (China) WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16235 21723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Shamrock (fighter) User:Mdtemp 14:59, 4 November 2011 (UTC) keep None of these fighters currently meet the notability criteria at , but Dollar is mentioned in TUF article and De Fries is scheduled to start fighting in the UFC Deletion of Ryan Shamrock (fighter) WP:MMANOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16236 7933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Climate change alarmism (2nd nomination) User:IRWolfie 16:03, 17 November 2011 (UTC) delete Edit: most of the arguments for the keep appear to be based around quoting search engine hits which flies in the face of .) It doesn't appear to be notable as a term. Do any of the sources in the article even use the term Deletion of Climate change alarmism (2nd nomination) WP:GOOGLEHITS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16237 6128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phir Subha Hogi User:MichaelQSchmidt 03:18, 1 May 2012 (UTC) merge """to Phir Subah Hogi. '''|Speedy Delete'''. While this is the ''older'' article, it is in far poorer shape than the ''newer'' one which was created under the correct title.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Phir_Subah_Hogi.jpg As it is the older, an |A10 speedy does not quite apply, however the |G6 techincal deletion does apply, IE: """"...also includes pages unambiguously created in error and/or in the incorrect namespace"""". Had the author of the ''new'' been aware of the ''old'', he might have expanded it and then done a |move to the correct name. As I noted above, both slightly different name spellings for this one film are sourcable, so I opt for setting a redirect to prevent unneccessary recreations of an existing article. As I have opined at this AFD, I really should not be the one to perform the close""" Deletion of Phir Subha Hogi WP:G6||WP:A10||WP:G6||WP:MOVE Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
16238 13856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hassanain Rajabali (2nd nomination) User:Xxanthippe 00:28, 27 July 2012 (UTC) delete Not enough sources for Deletion of Hassanain Rajabali (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16239 7600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisandro Aloi User:Pmedema NONE delete Fails and is not |notable Deletion of Lisandro Aloi WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16240 3453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atmospheric Jellyfish User:Terraxos 02:38, 9 January 2009 (UTC) delete this article is essentially |original research, and has a severe lack of reliable sources Deletion of Atmospheric Jellyfish WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16241 4751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chad Lee (politician) User:Cullen328 22:06, 24 May 2014 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Chad Lee (politician) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16242 1448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Atlantic Sun Men's Basketball Tournament Finals broadcasters User:Cbl62 17:13, 5 November 2015 (UTC) delete per nom. (Merge per X96lee15 would be fine too.) I've never grasped the notability of these stand-alone lists of tournament and bowl game broadcasters. The subject fails Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists and Deletion of List of Atlantic Sun Men's Basketball Tournament Finals broadcasters WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16243 3653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Predictions for human evolution User:Bearian 20:17, 13 October 2010 (UTC) delete per . It is weird, disjointed, and random Deletion of Predictions for human evolution WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
16244 16844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SnoutBusters User:JohnCD 16:33, 8 July 2008 (UTC) delete per and . Wikipedia is not for rumours Deletion of SnoutBusters WP:V||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16245 8583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Knapik User:Bearian 16:04, 22 August 2018 (UTC) delete per above. The organizations he led are |not so large or significant enough as to create automatic notability, and there's |too little about him to fill in even a stub Deletion of Daniel Knapik WP:MILL||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
16246 18144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Field Precision User:Blanchardb 23:24, 30 December 2007 (UTC) delete Fails . --Blanchardb Deletion of Field Precision WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16247 4627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Salvaggione User:Bettia 12:39, 31 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails as he has not played at a fully professional level yet, and there's no indication that he's notable in any other way Deletion of Chris Salvaggione WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16248 19447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indian fish names User:Yintan 11:31, 25 April 2009 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not an English-Indian dictionary Deletion of Indian fish names WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16249 14986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Clique (novel) User:KittyRainbow 09:25, 4 September 2008 (UTC) keep """It's incredibly difficult to find articles specifically about this book as it shares the name of the series and so you have to wade through pages and pages of stuff to find anything relevant. That said, according to http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/product-description/0316701297/ Amazon's product description page, this particular book in the series was reviewed by both ''School Library Journal'' and ''Booklist''. A ''Publishers Weekly'' article about the second book in the series http://www.publishersweekly.com/article/CA478269.html quotes from their own review of the first one, the original copy of which I can't find (I suspect it's too old to appear in the archives), but it clearly exists. Also, this book was http://www.schoollibraryjournal.com/article/CA508022.html selected as a """"Quick Pick For Reluctant Young Adult Readers"""" by the American Library Association. So I think it passes """ Deletion of The Clique (novel) WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
16250 6278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natalia Toreeva (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 13:58, 7 November 2019 (UTC) delete and . The page ''seems'' to be well-sourced, but the |quality of the sources is wanting; the references are local, self-written, or non-neutral. |Zero evidence that any major (Internationally reknown) museum, art show, or gallery has ever held her art. Totally |spam. We are a charity, not a webhost Deletion of Natalia Toreeva (2nd nomination) WP:SALT||WP:SIGCOV||WP:NARTIST||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
16251 9686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ai Oba Thaniwela User:Dan 06:55, 8 July 2021 (UTC) delete fails , lacks significant coverage in reliable independent sources. The Films.lk is just a listing/credits for the film nothing else. I have searched through most Sinhalese sources and can't really find much more on the film Deletion of Ai Oba Thaniwela WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
16252 11507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Franke (philosopher) User:Wikimandia 12:10, 27 November 2016 (UTC) keep I believe he meets based on Google Scholar citations; however, article needs massive cleanup Deletion of William Franke (philosopher) WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16253 20478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bray Ketchum [[User talk:Ravenswing|''' '' Ravenswing '' ''']] 21:35, 14 May 2018 (UTC) delete Fails NHOCKEY, no evidence the subject passes the GNG. Only coverage routine sports coverage explicitly debarred by as contributing towards notability Deletion of Bray Ketchum WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16254 5347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Clayton (footballer) User:Backslash 17:01, 3 July 2009 (UTC) delete per above, fails for not playing a professional match Deletion of Adam Clayton (footballer) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16255 11434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008 Conviasa Boeing 737 crash User:Thryduulf 20:18, 7 July 2009 (UTC) delete """fails and fails the spirit of - the only criteria it meets is """"It is an accident which involves a scheduled or charter air carrier."""" which considering the rest of the criteria seems unduly weak""" Deletion of 2008 Conviasa Boeing 737 crash WP:NOTNEWS||WP:AIRCRASH Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16256 2954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Killing of Ma'Khia Bryant User:ThadeusOfNazereth 19:11, 23 April 2021 (UTC) keep clearly meets notability guidelines per and probably per as well. I'd also asks whoever closes this to disregard the delete votes that speculate as to whether the shooting was justified, which are clearly not grounded in policy Deletion of Killing of Ma'Khia Bryant WP:GNG||WP:EVENTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16257 15270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Muller User:FOARP 12:51, 14 October 2019 (UTC) keep """The subject of this article appears to have been https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=RIpFAQAAIAAJ&q=%22The+True+Story+of+Jack+Muller%22&dq=%22The+True+Story+of+Jack+Muller%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwju5Nzo45vlAhXRUlAKHaF-DKUQ6AEINzAD the subject of a book, https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=0wy1DwAAQBAJ&pg=PA238&lpg=PA238&dq=%22The+real+Jack+Muller%22&source=bl&ots=TND38WIMyw&sig=ACfU3U2DppFJTcD5KdXrAXTro4Q7eSj9hw&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwidw7O15JvlAhWSfFAKHRCADWQQ6AEwAHoECAAQAQ#v=onepage&q=Jack%20Muller&f=false and a number of articles in reliable sources. Wikipedia:Offline sources|Having """"trouble"""" finding the references does not mean that these references do not exist. as such this is an easy pass for . Finally, AFD is not cleanup, so the lack of in-line citations does not mean we should delete""" Deletion of Jack Muller WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16258 19772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nasher Alagondar User:Doctorfluffy 05:29, 2 November 2007 (UTC) delete fails . No secondary sources as required to establish notability Deletion of Nasher Alagondar WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16259 4113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shine Horovits User:Sam 08:04, 16 October 2018 (UTC) delete Sources to meet or / have not been found Deletion of Shine Horovits WP:NARTIST||WP:BASIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16260 12818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Mallahan User:TonyTheTiger 14:37, 13 October 2016 (UTC) delete fails . Although there is significant biographical detail in the ''Seattle Times'', I think he fails because he has nothing but coverage. I think this should be pruned back and mentioned in regional elections articles, if anywhere Deletion of Joe Mallahan WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG||WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16261 15453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick West User:Hydronium NONE keep but revdel https://tools.wmflabs.org/copyvios/?lang=en&project=wikipedia&title=&oldid=878057228&use_engine=0&use_links=0&turnitin=0&action=compare&url=http%3A%2F%2Fpatrickwest1974.blogspot.com%2F copyvio). At minimum, ''Conspicuous Compassion'' appears to meet (and possibly ) with sigcovhttps://www.theage.com.au/opinion/just-what-is-so-wrong-with-all-this-compassion-20050104-gdzatq.htmlhttps://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1455117/Britain-wallowing-in-mourning-sickness.htmlhttps://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/opinion/poms-passports-tell-truth/news-story/19ee6e1f432f40858f0939035e74807chttps://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/selfish-britain-blamed-for-new-grief-lite-qptnt9gxncb, being used in at least one university coursehttp://academics.wellesley.edu/Sociology/syllabi/SOC202%20F08.pdf and https://scholar.google.com.au/scholar?cites=13813130688449138732&as_sdt=2005&sciodt=0,5&hl=en having a bunch of cites. That means that at least one article and a redirect would reasonable. Prefer redirection from book to author over the converse. ''The Poverty of Multiculturalism'' has https://scholar.google.com.au/scholar?cites=11224813577654600958&as_sdt=2005&sciodt=0,5&hl=en also been cited a number of times, and there's also at least one small review of ''Beating them at their own game''https://www.irishtimes.com/news/paperbacks-1.1197067 Deletion of Patrick West WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
16262 14630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Holly Grainger User:Thunderwing 19:44, 7 May 2007 (UTC) keep per above, clearly meets Deletion of Holly Grainger WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16263 3934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Make limstone in your own kitchen! User:Persian 03:09, 2 February 2007 (UTC) delete unencyclopedic, sections are short and lack content, article violates #INDISCRIMINATE Deletion of Make limstone in your own kitchen! WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16264 13702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Andrew Dunckelman User:Edison 17:45, 6 July 2010 (UTC) delete """If he has received significant coverage in multiple reliable and independent sources, then he satisfies |notability, unless he is known for only one thing (per ). He started a program """"Project Fine Arts Motivating the Elderly"""" when he was about 12 which provided arts materials worth at least $30,000 to nursing home residents in 10 states. He received national recognition for this, such as USA Today in 2002 http://goliath.ecnext.com/coms2/gi_0199-1972597/The-spirit-of-giving-is.html and http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=BN&p_theme=bn&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=108C6266D9D253C4&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM Buffalo News and other out of state papers in 2005. Other local press results show he received other local awards for this work, or in a baking contest and suchlike. He seems a young person with promise, but so far does not appear to satisfy """ Deletion of William Andrew Dunckelman WP:N||WP:BLP1E||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16265 8513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richie Gudgeon User:Mredidiongekong 19:25, 5 June 2018 (UTC) delete Claim of notability from a Movie (Home and Away) that doesn't cite him, Fails and Deletion of Richie Gudgeon WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16266 17089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Britton User:XOR 18:17, 16 January 2019 (UTC) comment Thank you again for your comments. I, for one, welcome our new altmetric overlords would be happy to have a discussion about whether #C1 needs updating, and if so, how to do it. (I can certainly see a case for making changes.) That is a bigger topic than what to do with an individual article, and perhaps Wikipedia talk:Notability (academics) would be a more suitable venue for that discussion Deletion of Ben Britton WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16267 12225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luka nervo User:Shadowjams 00:40, 28 November 2009 (UTC) keep The language is Croatian, and it ''is important'' that you be able to at least passingly understand what's being said before you point to an article as a . Translation engines are your friend, however, and searching http://www.google.hr Google for the name plus translation gives a lot of motorsports articles talking about the rider at high level competitions Deletion of Luka nervo WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16268 9939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adnan Kovačević User:Sionk 17:04, 10 September 2013 (UTC) delete looking at Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues there still seems to be some question about whether Bosnia's top league is fully professional. On that basis these two footballers fail and Deletion of Adnan Kovačević WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16269 17233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islamic Green user:Shrike 19:20, 7 April 2013 (UTC) merge Seems like some kind of Deletion of Islamic Green WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
16270 122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cordelia Naismith User:Rockphed 15:05, 16 October 2019 (UTC) delete and delete the whole slew too). This one at least pretends to have sources (most of the other Vorkosigan articles nominated for deletion didn't even have a reference section), but they are all either the books she appears in or things written by the author of said books. Alas, much as I love me some manic-dwarf-trainwreck-chess science fiction, I don't think society has noticed this awesomeness. I will happily change my mind if somebody finds some sources, but the only keep vote on any of them is, essentially an appeal to Deletion of Cordelia Naismith WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16271 6635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maki Kirioka User:Last_Malthusian 10:45, 27 January 2006 (UTC) delete """Macki Kirioka is a bemani composer, having only two songs produced as of yet"""" - self-admittedly fails """ Deletion of Maki Kirioka WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16272 8578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mallard, California User:A 02:46, 16 October 2020 (UTC) keep """Even abandoned places can be notable"""". The place was an old city. There are sources attesting to the existence of this settlement. Meets """ Deletion of Mallard, California WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16273 20903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Things in Atlas Shrugged User:BWD 22:37, 22 March 2006 (UTC) delete """because """"''list of general items''"""" doesn't jibe well with , even if it is from a specific piece of work""" Deletion of Things in Atlas Shrugged WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16274 5592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuljeet Singh User:Nomoskedasticity 13:25, 10 April 2009 (UTC) delete clearly does not meet , and I don't see enough coverage elsewhere to satisfy -- e.g. a news search http://news.google.co.uk/archivesearch?um=1&ned=uk&hl=en&num=50&q=Khalsa-college+OR+theatre+%22kuljeet+singh+%22&cf=all here. Some of those hits are not to the Kuljeet Singh in question, and none of them covers him, rather they contain brief remarks by him about something else Deletion of Kuljeet Singh WP:PROF||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16275 5154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Collin O'Mara User:scope_creep 10:40, 9 February 2019 (UTC) delete Fail . Barely any mention of him outside social media or the places he works at, hence the reason the article has no references Deletion of Collin O'Mara WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
16276 16766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warren Wald User:MONGO 06:04, 23 December 2005 (UTC) delete wannabe nobody... Deletion of Warren Wald WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
16277 5197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maygas User:AllyD 06:50, 14 June 2017 (UTC) delete An unsourced article making no claim to notability, even self-deprecating in tone. Nothing here to meet or , not even enough in my opinion to exceed a CSD A7 Deletion of Maygas :WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16278 7829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Menina Fortunato User:Bearcat 19:10, 30 January 2018 (UTC) delete """Actors do not get an automatic free pass over just because roles are listed — if that were all it took, we'd have to keep an article about every single actor who exists at all, because having acting roles is the job description. Rather, to get a Wikipedia article just for having had roles an actor needs to have |reliable source coverage ''about'' her, but there's none of that being shown here and I can't locate any evidence of it elsewhere. And for added bonus, even on her IMDb profile most of her listed credits are for unnamed bit parts such as """"Courtroom Dancer"""", """"Ballroom Dancer"""", """"Dancer"""" and """"Ta Da Show Choir Dancer"""", not as major characters""" Deletion of Menina Fortunato WP:NACTOR||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16279 19454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jess C Scott (2nd nomination) [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 00:56, 17 August 2013 (UTC) delete """plenty of stuff ''by'' her, not a lot ''about'' her. The ''""""Wikipedians are evil""""'' conspiracy refrain does nothing to suggest to others that you are |assuming good faith. There are plenty of """"getting started"""" guides that would have pointed you to and all other relevant policies had you looked before creating your article""" Deletion of Jess C Scott (2nd nomination) WP:AGF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
16280 4429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crescent Electric Supply Co. User:Patar 21:36, 17 September 2018 (UTC) delete per my comments at the Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2018 September 11|DRV. All or or almost all of Cunard's sources except for the BusinessWeek article either fail to meet the depth requirements at for only containing directory-like, routine information about the company or the independence requirements at , which specifically warns against using trade magazines. What is left is insufficient to meet to meet Deletion of Crescent Electric Supply Co. WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:COPRIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16281 17300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jazmín Chebar User:Randykitty 22:21, 1 February 2014 (UTC) keep It'sd a bit silly to take an article created by an experienced editor like Rosiestep to AFD within minutes of it being created, without first doing such revolutionary things as, say, ''talking''? Or PROD, if you have to. Clearly notable per the sources given above. Nom is reminded of and I for one would appreciate it I didn't need to waste my time on things like this Deletion of Jazmín Chebar WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16282 11209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ancient romes population User:Samir_ 00:12, 17 March 2006 (UTC) delete admitted Deletion of Ancient romes population WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16283 14666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs about tequila (2nd nomination) User:Plm209 12:14, 19 June 2007 (UTC) delete trivia sections/lists have no place in Wikipedia see |this for more info Deletion of List of songs about tequila (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16284 19649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamid Naderi Yeganeh User:Spectral 17:05, 21 July 2013 (UTC) delete no |significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject Deletion of Hamid Naderi Yeganeh WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16285 2900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vera Baker User:David 02:32, 2 May 2010 (UTC) delete Per , badly sourced scandal-mongering needs to stay off this article, but without that what do we have? An article in Politico with a paragraph about her consulting firm (not actually about her personally), another reliably published article that mentions her only trivially, and a purported screenshot of uncertain provenance showing her bio from her consulting web site. That's not good enough, and the present situation makes it very difficult to make any improvements Deletion of Vera Baker WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16286 13555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FP6 Grid Computing Projects User:Stuartyeates 02:16, 10 August 2011 (UTC) delete Few of the projects have WP pages and the first two I clicked on were of dubious notability (I tagged both). The page itself has no independent references. Fails Deletion of FP6 Grid Computing Projects WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16287 6363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2nd Address User:MER 12:52, 26 January 2018 (UTC) delete per , see also Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations/Barbequeue Deletion of 2nd Address WP:NOTSPAM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16288 2387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hand Hug User:SoSaysChappy 04:57, 17 December 2009 (UTC) delete """per nom. Although there is a Facebook """"following"""", the gesture doesn't seem notable enough to break beyond status. With time, if it becomes more common and significant, it might warrant an article. For now, at the most, merge the GBooks info about establishing this gesture with children into the Hug article""" Deletion of Hand Hug WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
16289 21576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mount Pearl Hindu Temple (St.Johns, Newfoundland) User:R 16:16, 7 April 2008 (UTC) keep It sounds to me like it is notable within the local community, at least, and the references provided have |verified some wider notability. (But '''rename''' to Mount Pearl Hindu Temple, unless there's some reason to believe there's more than one organization by that name Deletion of Mount Pearl Hindu Temple (St.Johns, Newfoundland) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16290 10703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melissa Flentzeris User:Exemplo347 21:01, 15 April 2017 (UTC) delete per (and by the sound of things, Deletion of Melissa Flentzeris WP:NOT||WP:PAID Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16291 5297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nidal Malik Hasan User:Falcorian 20:19, 13 November 2009 (UTC) keep Huge amount of coverage in reliable sources so he clearly passes . The length and density of citations in the article attest to this fact Deletion of Nidal Malik Hasan WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16292 13934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apathy (Swe) User:Blackmetalbaz 13:59, 27 August 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Apathy (Swe) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16293 2195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saudi Arabia and state sponsored terrorism User:BDD 14:36, 25 September 2012 (UTC) keep Calling this POV misunderstands . We can neutrally report on accusations made in , and there have certainly been allegations of Saudi-sponsored terrorism in reliable sources. I encourage editors with POV or synthesis concerns to tag the sections that concern them and discuss the issue on the talk page Deletion of Saudi Arabia and state sponsored terrorism WP:NPOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
16294 4451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sing sing slammer User:Niteshift36 03:14, 11 June 2009 (UTC) delete if possible, if not, fails miserably Deletion of Sing sing slammer WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16295 20134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shangwen Fang User:Kinu 05:44, 14 August 2006 (UTC) keep due to the lack of any cited violation of inclusion policy or guideline here. The information is |verifiable, is |not original research, and |is written in a neutral point of view; even if it wasn't, that's grounds for cleanup, not deletion. Further, the article is not |making slanderous or defamatory comments about this individual, and it seems to adhere to |biography standards for living people. If you feel there's a bigger legal issue involved, contact the Wikimedia foundation directly; AfD is NOT the place for it, as Wikipedia editors are not bound, ''per se'', to enforce either Taiwanese or American law in this regard, except where indirectly noted (i.e., in the case of copyright violations). NOTE: no prejudice to renomination based on a real guideline/policy, i.e., Deletion of Shangwen Fang WP:V||WP:NOR||WP:NPOV||WP:LEGAL||WP:LIVING||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16296 7906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Zanidean User:Niteshift36 13:34, 9 July 2009 (UTC) delete I'm going to have to look at as the category and he fails that. Could almost argue that he falls under Deletion of Mike Zanidean WP:ATHLETE||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16297 21044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victor Darley-Usmar User:David 03:33, 15 May 2013 (UTC) keep as passing both #C1 (highly cited researcher) and #C5 (he holds an endowed chair at UAB). I can go along with subject requests in marginal cases but this one is pretty clear Deletion of Victor Darley-Usmar WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16298 8946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pankaj Munjal User:Dane 01:35, 10 December 2016 (UTC) delete Promotional content. Fails Deletion of Pankaj Munjal WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16299 14228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacob Neusner bibliography (2nd nomination) User:Madcoverboy 08:04, 3 March 2010 (UTC) delete with prejudice towards other bibliography articles per Deletion of Jacob Neusner bibliography (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16300 8633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chamberlain Group User:TonyTheTiger 05:34, 29 March 2013 (UTC) keep The google news results show that several acquisitions are considered notable. Based on and considering the legal case, I guess this is sort of notable Deletion of Chamberlain Group WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16301 3131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Hegarty (Northern Irish footballer) (2nd nomination) User:GiantSnowman 12:17, 4 November 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Chris Hegarty (Northern Irish footballer) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16302 8883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Falsafatuna User:Hornplease 07:49, 27 May 2006 (UTC) keep per CJLLLW and . Also I continue to be amazed by nominations that seem to have come from people who have ''not followed the links in the article''. How can ''anyone'' read the al-Sadr article linked to from this one and determine this is a ''vanity'' page, let alone think its nn enough to do all the work for an AFD? Extraordinary puzzlement here Deletion of Falsafatuna WP:BITE Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
16303 4320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Groasis Waterboxx NONE NONE keep Content is referenced and contains little or no claims beyond what can be |reliably referenced Deletion of Groasis Waterboxx WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16304 16745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Attleborough Potters User:SL93 21:41, 6 December 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Attleborough Potters WP:CLUB||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16305 1019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of animated series with LGBT characters: 2010s User:Toughpigs 16:14, 10 March 2020 (UTC) keep I know we're not supposed to use to support a topic's notability, but I think the nomination is essentially based on . I think the article needs at least a good paragraph of text about the subject, but that can be resolved with normal editing Deletion of List of animated series with LGBT characters: 2010s WP:INTERESTING||WP:NOTINTERESTING Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16306 405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scientology discography User:Cirt 05:40, 24 January 2008 (UTC) comment At the moment, the ''entire'' article/list and everything in it is unsourced at any rate, and has been for quite some time. As such, even if it is not deleted, any unsourced/ information in the article that is not cited should be removed. That would leave the article with - nothing Deletion of Scientology discography WP:OR||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16307 1181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/US Airways Flights User:Stuartyeates 01:19, 15 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of US Airways Flights WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16308 12194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2020 Ghent stabbing User:Knowledgekid87 14:44, 4 February 2020 (UTC) delete """I wish editors would keep in mind for these things. Within an hour of the article being created false information was presented that included a """"terrorist incident"""" and a comment """"reported by eye witnesses to be of """"a dark skin colour"""". https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=2020_Ghent_stabbing&diff=938859670&oldid=938859155 This is concerning and should be concerning to editors out there who want to maintain Wikipedia's quality standards. The article was rushed to be made with the assumption that this was going to be some huge terrorist incident which it was clearly not""" Deletion of 2020 Ghent stabbing WP:NORUSH Wikipedia:There is no deadline 35
16309 43 [[Katrin Puth]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Drahreg01/American Academy of Arts and Sciences 23:08, 9. Jun. 2016 (CEST) delete Kasten|1=Kein Wunder, dass diese Löschdiskussion so lange nicht entschieden wurde, da hier ein grenzwertiger Fall vorliegt. Ich entscheide auf , weil ich keines der Relevanzkriterien unter #Sportler als erfüllt ansehe. Duathlon ist offenbar keine von Sportaccord anerkannte Sportart. Somit ist die Teilnahme an einer Weltmeisterschaft im Duathlon nicht automatisch relevanzstiftend, zumal Puth dort offenbar nicht in der höchsten Klasse angetreten ist (Vergleiche :en:2010 ITU Duathlon World Championships und http://www.triathlon.org/results/result/2010_edinburgh_itu_duathlon_world_championships/5808/http://www.triathlon.org/results/result/2010_edinburgh_itu_duathlon_world_championships/5832). Auch die weiteren Angaben im Artikel – z. B. 2. Liga der Triathlon Bundesliga – sehe ich nicht als relevanzstiftend an Löschung von Katrin Puth Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
16310 9181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Johnson (footballer) User:ChrisTheDude 21:04, 21 November 2010 (UTC) delete clearly fails both and (someone above claimed that he was the subject of coverage in The Guardian, but the only mention of him I could find on their website was one throw-away sentence in a match report about how he'd been on the sub's bench but never entered play Deletion of Daniel Johnson (footballer) WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16311 18840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/25 Frames [[User talk:Erpert|(let's talk about it)]] 07:53, 26 December 2010 (UTC) delete per . I cannot find any reliable sources about this show. '''Erpert Deletion of 25 Frames WP:TVSERIES Wikipedia:Notability 77
16312 15891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mehraj Ahmed User:Rugbyfan22 18:59, 10 April 2021 (UTC) merge A few games, but I'm struggling to see anything significant. There may be some coverage in Wisden of his appearances. Redirect a suitable Deletion of Mehraj Ahmed WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
16313 13975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruje Yasmin User:AllyD 15:12, 17 October 2018 (UTC) delete My searches are not finding better than the given references in relation to an employment training programme, which is not inherently notable, and more recently an appearance in an event photo caption https://rts.org.uk/article/event-report-working-television-journalism. These verify the subject as a working journalist but nothing indicates achievements to meet the criteria Deletion of Ruje Yasmin :WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
16314 21495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Assassin's Creed Virtues User:P199 13:41, 19 September 2011 (UTC) delete as per nom, also fails Deletion of Assassin's Creed Virtues WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16315 6368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/André Savetier User:Edison 17:18, 17 April 2017 (UTC) delete There are not enough independent and reliable sources with significant coverage to satisfy |notability. Facebook and Youtube should not even be included as references, since they are not |reliable sources Deletion of André Savetier WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16316 79 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Sedat Kapanoğlu (2. aday gösterme) Kullanıcı:hedda gablerhedda gabler 17:39, 30 Ağustos 2009 (UTC) delete """Tamam kendisi ünlü ''ssg'' ama ansiklopedik olarak kayda değerliği yok. Mesela içerik nasıl geliştirilebilir? """"Ekşi Sözlük'ü kurdu""""dan başka ansiklopedik ifadesi olur mu? (bkz: |vikipedi'de kayda değer olmayan kişilerin silinmesi""" Sedat Kapanoğlu (2. aday gösterme) yazısının silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda değerlik (kişi) Wikipedia:Notability 77
16317 116 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Serhat Durmuş """Kullanıcı:can'''can'''""" 16.33, 25 Temmuz 2020 (UTC) delete Öncelikle emeklerinize sağlık. Fakat bir yanlış anlaşılmayı düzeltmek lazım. Kuzgun (dizi)|Kuzgun dizisinin müziklerini Toygar Işıklı üstlenmiştir. Dizileri takip edenler bilir bazen konuk sanatçılar diziler için bir tane şarkı bestelerler ve ara ara bu şarkı da çalar. Örnekleri çok vardır bu sebeple yanlış yorumu düzelteyim dedim. Spotify, deezer vs.. Buraya herkes kayıt olup şarkılarını ekleyebiliyorlar, bunu geçelim. Kaynaklara gelelim: Kendisiyle ilgili arama yaptığım zaman da sadece wordpress'ten yapılmış 2019 yani 1 senedir yayında olan internet dergisi sitesinde röportajı var. Bu da bana pek güvenilir gelmedi. Elimizde akşam ve televizyon gazetesi mevcut bu iki haberde kuzgun dizisi için yaptığı şarkıyla alakalı tanıtım/reklam yapılmış. Şarkının sözleri var vs.. Bunlar da kayda değerliğini ispat edecek haberler değil ileride daha fazla çalışma yapar ve Kayda değer haberler olur hakkında o zaman tekrar maddesi açılabilir, |kahin değiliz sonuç olarak Serhat Durmuş'un silinmesi Vikipedi:KAHİN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16318 17103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muir Skate Longboard Shop (2nd nomination) [[User_talk:Black Kite|Black Kite (t)]] [[Special:Contributions/Black_Kite|(c)]] 10:24, 23 May 2010 (UTC) delete """I think the problem is basically this. If I was to open my town's first Widget Shop next week, I'm pretty sure I could guarantee some coverage in the two local papers, and probably even the one that covers the city near my town. I'm also pretty sure I could get some coverage in the online presence of Widget Buyers Monthly, and perhaps even in a few business-oriented sources - let's face it, mine is the first Widget Shop in the area. Is that coverage in reliable sources? Certainly is. But is it ''significant'' coverage. No, it's just another few space-filling stories about another Widget Shop which is no different from all the others in the country. The important part of is this - """"''Neither do the publication of routine communiqués (count as substantial coverage) announcing such matters as ... facility openings or closings, unless these events themselves are the subject of sustained, independent interest""" Deletion of Muir Skate Longboard Shop (2nd nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16319 9849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave Bizzigotti (2nd nomination) [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] 02:10, 29 January 2015 (UTC) delete I can't find anything other than trivial mentions of this person on a few fan sites and self published sources. Fails Deletion of Dave Bizzigotti (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16320 10529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Henle User:Niteshift36 13:50, 21 May 2010 (UTC) keep Even one pro fight qualifies him under as it currently reads. Having a crappy record isn't a reason to delete Deletion of Joseph Henle WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16321 2040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allegra Versace User:Cavarrone 07:01, 1 August 2012 (UTC) keep as she is the major shareholder in the Gianni Versace S.p.A. company, a point that overcome any concern. Furthermore, she appears to pass WP:BASIC and WP:GNG being subject of multiple published reliable, independent, secondary sources Deletion of Allegra Versace WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16322 6777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon Enciso User:Atlantic306 15:37, 19 January 2018 (UTC) keep has enough reliable sources coverage such as Phillipene Star to pass Deletion of Simon Enciso WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16323 17903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ron Manners User:Chris 16:20, 24 June 2014 (UTC) keep The IP nominator clearly hadn't read or . The subject is notable, therefore keep Deletion of Ron Manners WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16324 12564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackson South Coast League team User:Stifle 12:37, 26 September 2008 (UTC) delete team never existed and any speculation about its future existence would violate Deletion of Jackson South Coast League team WP:CBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16325 18955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/101st Academy Awards User:Metropolitan90 06:47, 12 January 2009 (UTC) delete all per . Just knowing what year an award ceremony will take place in is not enough to justify the creation of an encyclopedia article Deletion of 101st Academy Awards WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16326 371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mal logic User:Heimstern 00:18, 4 October 2006 (UTC) comment I seriously debated tagging this for speedy under #G1, but wasn't quite sure it was in fact patent nonsense Deletion of Mal logic WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
16327 13910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alpha Tau Omega (Philippines) (2nd nomination) User:I 07:52, 18 July 2011 (UTC) delete Each of these fraternities / Honors Societies are not covered by the kind of sources |required by organizations. I agree with the above editors' sentiments that these pages represent |using Wikipedia as a webhost and are inappropriate content. The amount of work and the clarity of a page also doesn't have any bearing on its notability, as noted by Moray An Par Deletion of Alpha Tau Omega (Philippines) (2nd nomination) WP:CLUB||WP:NOTWEBHOST Wikipedia:Notability 77
16328 14097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omise (Company) User:Jake 06:57, 8 May 2019 (UTC) comment not sure I follow the logic of the nomination. This appears to be the wrong venue. AfD is not a place to argue improvement of an article or request moves. There are specific venues for that (article talk page, RM). In fact, as the nominator agrees the article needs work, draft would have been the correct venue for that. Fix it, submit as AfC, get it reviewed or as experienced user |be bold and RM under new name. The nominator appears to be nominating for deletion to achieve a keep and RM. pseudonym Deletion of Omise (Company) WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
16329 9982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/130s BC User:Ivanvector 02:47, 28 January 2010 (UTC) delete per #G2|G2 or #A3|A3, take your pick Deletion of 130s BC WP:CSD||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
16330 13979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Mitchell (guitarist) User:Ritchie333 16:44, 15 January 2013 (UTC) merge with Ten (band). Doesn't appear to have achieved individual notability, so per , this is the thing to do Deletion of Dan Mitchell (guitarist) WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16331 439 [[If a Song Could Get Me You]] (Weiterleitung) Benutzer:Darth Stassen NONE keep Wie du schon sagst: Relevant. Daher und ab zur Löschung von If a Song Could Get Me You Wikipedia:QS Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
16332 4743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burnt City (Band) User:Dane 11:22, 4 January 2017 (UTC) delete Definitely fails Deletion of Burnt City (Band) WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16333 11686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qatar–Saudi Arabia proxy conflict User:Otr500 00:56, 20 May 2018 (UTC) delete """Does appear to be a |fork. I don't see how |synthesis is not a factor. There are 86 references and I did not run across anything to do with any """"proxy"""" that would be what, a Proxy war? . Even the use of the word, apparently just taken at face value, is confusing and I don't see a """"proxy conflict"""" either. Equally confusing is the above statement, """"this topic is specifically about Qatar and Saudi Arabia"""". The article does not indicate this nor the sources provided that include a multitude of countries""" Deletion of Qatar–Saudi Arabia proxy conflict WP:FORK||WP:SYNTHESIS Wikipedia:Mirrors and forks 46
16334 8691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vasundhara Metro Mall (2nd nomination) User:Krishna 12:44, 9 July 2016 (UTC) delete As per the nominator, the article completely fails Deletion of Vasundhara Metro Mall (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16335 2804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Playster User:scope_creep 12:24, 13 March 2019 (UTC) delete Fails and . Of the 16 references, 5 or 6 are dead and the rest discuss the launch. Very poor referencing. Also fails . No real coverage Deletion of Playster WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
16336 9108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wayland Smith in popular culture User:Otto4711 21:24, 2 August 2007 (UTC) delete """WP:NOT#DIR|directory of loosely associated items combined with |original research. """"The character Waylon Smithers from the TV show The Simpsons may be named after the mythical figure."""" OR. """"Weyland Smith is mentioned in Neil Gaiman's novel Stardust."""" Who cares? Get rid of it""" Deletion of Wayland Smith in popular culture WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16337 11416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angelo Bertolini User:Devokewater 10:49, 22 March 2021 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Angelo Bertolini WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16338 5897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Bohemian F.C. players User:Alzarian16 19:06, 29 August 2011 (UTC) delete When I first saw this list I was relatively supportive of the concept as a way of removing loads of unreferenced biographies. I even merged an article here. Trouble is, sourcing it seems to be almost impossible. The only source at present is a Wiki mirror, and the only results I could find by searching for the two players on the list at the moment were some random news reports with no real information and http://www.footballdatabase.eu/football.joueurs.tommy.byrne.110727.en.html this, which is demonstrably inaccurate by at least eight years. So apparently a list like this is going to fail , unless someone knows better, in which case I'll reconsider Deletion of List of Bohemian F.C. players WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16339 13494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poland–Uruguay relations User:WilyD 14:40, 2 April 2009 (UTC) keep notability established |the usual way. Sources unearthed by Cool3 are more than sufficient. No argument for deletion exists Deletion of Poland–Uruguay relations WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16340 13005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SurveyEngine User:ClanCC 08:33, 21 February 2008 (UTC) delete No references, no |Notability Deletion of SurveyEngine WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16341 8301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Divy (name) :User:Finemann|Fιηεmαηη]] [[:en 09:11, 23 August 2011 (UTC) comment In it is clearly mentioned that Wikipedia can have articles about names. The difference between a dictionary entry and Wikipedia entry is given at #Minor differences. — ''':en Deletion of Divy (name) WP:NOTDICT||WP:NOTDICT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
16342 14193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Novelguide User:Cunard 09:00, 31 October 2010 (UTC) delete per the http://news.google.com/archivesearch?&as_src=-newswire+-wire+-presswire+-PR+-release+-wikipedia&q=%22Novelguide%22 lack of |reliable sources. The coverage in the reference to which DGG refers is a directory. I have searched http://books.google.com/books?as_brr=0&as_pub=-icon&q=%22Novelguide%22 Google Books and have only able to find directory listings or passing mentions. This topic fails Wikipedia:Notability and Wikipedia:Notability (web Deletion of Novelguide WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16343 8935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naziphobia (2nd nomination) User:Good 01:03, 11 July 2008 (UTC) delete probably , but even if it is not, WP is Wikipedia:What_Wikipedia_is_not#Wikipedia_is_not_a_dictionary|not a dictionary, and this article is little more than a definition Deletion of Naziphobia (2nd nomination) WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
16344 9534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Bateson User:Rasadam 08:09, 5 July 2008 (UTC) delete I don't particularly agree with the rules, but he fails them. If we want to be consistent (not OTHERCRAP, just consistent), he fails to pass despite having a professional contract Deletion of Jonathan Bateson WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16345 6641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adaptive Compliant Trailing Edge (2nd nomination) User:Squeamish 05:48, 29 January 2015 (UTC) keep The ''Times of India'' bio is admittedly not great. The Fox News article that the nominator dismissed out of hand needed no such dismissal (regardless of one's political alignment, Fox News is generally a reliable source). The NASA press release is arguably not independent, and the university pages most certainly are not. Were that all there was to go on, I'd be more inclined to side with deletion. But they are not. There's discussion of the topic by ''Scientific American'' http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/elastic-design-the-fluid-future-of-shape-shifting-technology-video/ here and in one of their senior editor's s http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/2014/12/12/first-flexible-airplane-wing-takes-flight/ here, http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/articles/2014-11-20/flexsyss-wing-flaps-promise-to-save-fuel Bloomberg Business (which even drew an illustration with a hilariously out-of-context ''Twilight Zone'' tribute), and ''http://www.popsci.com/article/technology/shape-shifting-wing-design-prepares-testing Popular Science''. There's room for editorial quibbling, I'm certain, about ''where'' we should have this information (at the current title, under the company name, under the company's product name, or in BLP format titled after the inventor responsible), but none of that is an issue for AFD to consider Deletion of Adaptive Compliant Trailing Edge (2nd nomination) WP:NEWSBLOG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16346 2158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oproiescu Sorin User:Hobbes 20:21, 1 October 2011 (UTC) delete Zero Google news hits. No RS hits. About the best I could find is this blog notice http://soccertactician.wordpress.com/2011/08/02/oproiescu_sorin/ which may be an out-and-out advert; he's apparently out of football altogether at the moment. He's listed in the article as playing for Politehnica Timişoara, but cannot seem to find him on their WP entry or official website. Fails and Deletion of Oproiescu Sorin WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16347 10762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HIV/AIDS prophylaxis in British Columbia NONE NONE keep per my own essay at Wikipedia:Removal of Wikipedia articles on notable topics. The subject of this article passes , which is the criteria for inclusion into Wikipedia. If we merged this article in entirety then the next step would be deletion of 90% of this content. This content would be for HIV/AIDS in Canada and a merge is not a pathway to keeping well-cited content in this article which is specific to BC Deletion of HIV/AIDS prophylaxis in British Columbia WP:GNG||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16348 21288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lyle Zapato (2nd nomination) User:David 05:28, 28 September 2008 (UTC) delete Agree with the nominator that there does not seem to be enough reliable sourcing to pass . The article seems to serve mainly as a promotional vehicle for the subject's book and website Deletion of Lyle Zapato (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16349 15428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Strategic Public Relations User:SWik78 16:59, 15 July 2008 (UTC) delete The article is a |synthesis of material (possibly previously published but unsourced and unverified) used by the author to advance a position thereby violating Deletion of Strategic Public Relations WP:SYNTH||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16350 21619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diamond Pet Foods User:Jenova20 15:29, 22 April 2013 (UTC) delete since candidate and lack of notability from other sources. Thanks Deletion of Diamond Pet Foods WP:oneevent Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16351 7787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of women investors NONE NONE keep """Meets as a topic that """"has been discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources"""". Women investors are a topic of special interest and research. They are often considered as a subset of the investing class and gobs of reliable sources document how gender impacts investor decisions. Here are a few from this year""" Deletion of List of women investors WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16352 19386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beyond the Silence of the Sea User:Rpclod 02:17, 18 July 2015 (UTC) delete this article suggests |self-promotion Deletion of Beyond the Silence of the Sea WP:SELFPROMOTION Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
16353 5876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Australian Ambassadors to Norway (2nd nomination) User:Lankiveil 10:04, 19 November 2017 (UTC) merge to Australia–Norway relations. As non-resident representatives, this particular office is clearly not important enough for its own article, and the articles cited are simply stuff that doesn't indicate that the office has much significance. A merge will preserve the useful information and give some depth to the resulting article Deletion of List of Australian Ambassadors to Norway (2nd nomination) WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16354 375 [[Liste von Projekten und Reportagen der Plattform Addendum]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Jürgen Oetting NONE keep Laut dienen Listen dazu, ''dem Leser einen Überblick über ein detailreiches Thema zu bieten und ihm weiterführende Links zur Vertiefung der Informationen zu einem Themengebiet zu liefern. Meist gibt es einen Artikel, der ein Thema ausführlich darstellt. Listen können dann dazu ein umfassender Überblick oder eine beispielhafte Ergänzung sein. So kann zum Beispiel die Beschreibung der Geschichte und Vergabekriterien eines Literaturpreises mit einer Liste aller Preisträger vervollständigt werden.'' Das ist hier der Fall, die Liste ist eine Ergänzung des Artikels Addendum (Rechercheplattform). Man könnte die Listeninformationen auch im Artikel unterbringen, kann aber auch diesen Weg wählen Löschung von Liste von Projekten und Reportagen der Plattform Addendum Wikipedia:Listen Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
16355 1697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The musical parody User:Beeblbrox 05:51, 24 July 2008 (UTC) delete Unsourced Deletion of The musical parody WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
16356 1734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ÆON Bandaraya Melaka Shopping Centre User:Ad 15:36, 29 May 2014 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability. Subject appears to fail . Sources mostly are about other topics with the mall being incidental, often the location of a specific event, none of which are especially historic. A Google failed to yield anything that rings the notability bell Deletion of ÆON Bandaraya Melaka Shopping Centre WP:NGEOG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16357 11006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nitin Kumar Gupta User:Hobbes 02:40, 28 October 2011 (UTC) delete Not as absolutely non-notable as some AfD subjects, but references are mainly passing notes in articles focused elsewhere and credits. There's a http://www.timeoutmumbai.net/music/music_details.asp?code=102&source=1 decent album review in ''Time Out Mumbai'', but it's hardly enough, and source is not --this edition of the Time Out is not even put it out by Time Out--the trademark http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_Out_%28company%29#Publications is rented to a local publisher. Could become notable in the future, and happy to have another look then or if anyone can come up with substantial coverage from RS sources. I've also had a look at some of the bigger films where subject has credits, and my initial impression is that they are '''all''' non-notable and should be deleted from WP Deletion of Nitin Kumar Gupta WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16358 4930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William L. Wilson (Rice University) User:Ciar 19:13, 12 April 2009 (UTC) delete Although a touching memorial, it doesn't meet notability criteria , Deletion of William L. Wilson (Rice University) WP:ACADEMIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16359 1740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Load III User:E2eamon 15:57, 24 February 2011 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Load III WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16360 20004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crucible Red [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 01:38, 23 October 2006 (UTC) delete as insufficiently notable high school band. No assertions of notability that meet any of the twelve criteria listed in . No credible, third-party sources as required by . -- Deletion of Crucible Red WP:BAND||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
16361 15564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uk airport parking User:MER 12:27, 28 December 2006 (UTC) delete unsourced |original research essay Deletion of Uk airport parking WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16362 2979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Red and Anarchist black metal User:Bearian 16:36, 3 May 2016 (UTC) delete our |precedents show that most new genres of music are deleted, and I don't see why this would not be as well. Ping me if you need the pile of precedents Deletion of Red and Anarchist black metal WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
16363 18142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Success Hill railway station, Perth User:Shinjiman 03:59, 26 January 2008 (UTC) keep this as the article meets the . And the sources can be found in verifiable sources, as listed on the article Deletion of Success Hill railway station, Perth WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16364 17948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nardo Zalko User:Extraordinary 16:51, 17 February 2021 (UTC) keep per and Vaticidalprophet Deletion of Nardo Zalko WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16365 5973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James W. LaBelle User:K 05:06, 7 February 2018 (UTC) keep meets ; an acceptable stub at this point. Does not violate guidelines Deletion of James W. LaBelle WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16366 10206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plastic Nancy User:Gongshow 03:10, 9 May 2017 (UTC) delete lack of coverage found to suggest this band meets at this time Deletion of Plastic Nancy WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16367 6559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Use of chemical weapons in Sri Lankan civil war User:Obi2canibe 18:01, 25 October 2014 (UTC) keep Both reasons given for deletion are invalid - the article has several and therefore passes and Deletion of Use of chemical weapons in Sri Lankan civil war WP:RS||WP:V||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16368 14989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Westology User:Royboycrashfan 04:32, 26 February 2006 (UTC) delete as nn term and |original research Deletion of Westology WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16369 6150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emerson Spartz User:MacGyverMagic 10:55, 8 December 2005 (UTC) keep Anyone who was '''personally''' invited by J.K. Rowling to interview her for the release of book 6 is quite notable in my opinion. The images are likely a copyright issue. All but one or two should be axed. If not kept, it should at the very least be merged. Link to the interview in question is at the Pottercast entry on |deletion review Deletion of Emerson Spartz WP:DRV Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
16370 7123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giga Innovations User:Rosguill 22:54, 14 December 2019 (UTC) delete the subject does not appear to be anywhere near meeting . signed Deletion of Giga Innovations WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16371 3504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lightning Network User:Jtbobwaysf 03:58, 12 December 2019 (UTC) keep Frivolous nomination. Meets with sources from Bloomberg, Fortune (magazine), FT Alphaville, Daily Express, Ars Technica, Wired (magazine), Andreas Antonopoulos's books, etc. A lot of hits in google books as well https://www.google.com/search?tbm=bks&sxsrf=ACYBGNTdtghwKgCqM0rWJQk3D6Wnj0JWaA%3A1576122642181&ei=ErnxXZbhCoTi-Abuqof4Bg&q=%22lightning+network%22&oq=%22lightning+network%22&gs_l=psy-ab.3...327926.329765.0.329950.2.2.0.0.0.0.208.291.1j0j1.2.0....0...1c.1.64.psy-ab..0.0.0....0.QRdnfI5Lr4Y. Silly nomination really, probably should be withdrawn Deletion of Lightning Network WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16372 13438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Secular Homeschooling User:Jeff5102 07:50, 22 July 2015 (UTC) delete since 60% of the references lead to secularhomeschool.com, it feels safe to say it is |an advertisement. Regards Deletion of Secular Homeschooling WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
16373 21907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saranghaeyo algorithm User:Michael 10:46, 15 September 2006 (UTC) delete per comments above. Incidentally, the Alan Hshieh in question is likely to be the same one (a high school student) referenced in Hshieh-Hammond algorithm and Cysths. Frankly, all three articles smell like |OR to me Deletion of Saranghaeyo algorithm WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16374 10519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Panamerican Draughts Championship User:Coolabahapple 01:21, 9 August 2017 (UTC) comment """when is an international sports competition deemed notable enough to warrant a wikiarticle? is the """"trump card"""", or is it a case of lack of interest (this being the 3rd relist with not much contribution) from wikieditors (myself included) about this subject? Also, has this afd changed now that the article is a """"list"""", although a paragraph explaining what countries are involved, how many games are played might be useful""" Deletion of Panamerican Draughts Championship WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16375 10945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inste Bible College User:PohranicniStraze 15:54, 3 August 2018 (UTC) delete WP:PROMO|Promotional puff piece for an unaccredited school. Lack of |significant coverage in |reliable sources to demonstrate either or Deletion of Inste Bible College WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16376 2964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sports timeline User:Armbrust 11:49, 30 September 2010 (UTC) delete """as |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information. It is not cleat what """"significant event"""" means and thus has no clear inclusion criteria. There is too many space for |POV and article has no sources. I would say the 1985 World Snooker Championship final is very significant, why was this not selected for 1985? Why is the first Ryder Cup more significant than the first World Snooker Championship? (1927""" Deletion of Sports timeline WP:IINFO||WP:POV Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16377 14825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darmi Khan User:TimothyBlue 14:08, 24 July 2020 (UTC) delete Article does not meet or . I think it will just die a slow death in drafts. // Deletion of Darmi Khan WP:GNG||WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16378 21368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ground rules [[User Talk:JzG|Guy]] 19:16, 5 October 2006 (UTC) delete That which is not |original research is |a dictionary definition Deletion of Ground rules WP:OR||WP:WINAD Wikipedia:No original research 65
16379 7592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brosix (2nd nomination) User:Ifnord 04:20, 21 January 2012 (UTC) delete as failing notability under . No demonstration that this product has had significant or demonstrable effects on culture, society, entertainment, athletics, economies, history, literature, science, or education Deletion of Brosix (2nd nomination) WP:ORGIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16380 6092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Physistical User:Ugncreative 20:21, 12 January 2012 (UTC) delete Non-notable, no sources, and #DICTIONARY|Wikipedia isn't for dictionary entries anyway Deletion of Physistical WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16381 16276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pedals the Bear User:Meatsgains 23:05, 14 October 2016 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Pedals the Bear WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16382 9240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keith Beukelaer User:ERcheck 00:01, 26 February 2006 (UTC) delete Not notable, does not meet . Also, per Postdlf on Mary Roach precedent. &mdash Deletion of Keith Beukelaer WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16383 13564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nailya Alexander Gallery User:ThatMontrealIP 04:12, 21 January 2020 (UTC) keep It clearly does not meet the notability guidelines for NCORP, as there is not much coverage about the gallery itself out there. There are one or two decent sources in the article; maybe it just barely meets . I searched for the gallery, the gallery +collection, the gallery + founded+2004, Nailya Alexander alone and so on. All I found were trival mentions. Their collection might be important, but all I found were photo credits for the gallery (for example in https://fristartmuseum.org/calendar/detail/the-power-of-pictures-early-soviet-photography-and-film this blurb for the Jewish Museum show of Russian photographers). Perhaps that is enough, if they have been distributing important photographs.. even if no one has written much abotu that contribution? Anyway, this AfD seems like it is going to slip through the guidelines, so I am happy to jump on board and IAR. Keeping it would be the proper non-policy based decision to make, and I encourage all others to get on the keep train Deletion of Nailya Alexander Gallery WP:BARE||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
16384 307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wings of Fire (novel series) User:Rorshacma 16:25, 7 January 2021 (UTC) keep The current article is definitely in terrible shape and needs some major cleanup, but the series itself passes the . The one source currently in the article regarding the upcoming TV adaptation is a decent one, as are the ones listed by DiamondRemley39 above. And I'm finding plenty of other, smaller, sources as well, either regarding the comic or TV adaptations or mini-reviews on some of the products. So, again, terrible current article, but a subject that passes the and Deletion of Wings of Fire (novel series) WP:GNG||WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
16385 15971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syrym User:Moonriddengirl 13:48, 17 February 2008 (UTC) keep """though if independent sourcing cannot be found to verify stand-alone notability redirect to the parent article may be appropriate until such a time as this band is notable on its own. indicates that a band is notable if it """"Contains at least one member who was once a part of or later joined a band that is otherwise notable; note that it is often most appropriate to use Wikipedia:Redirect|redirects in place of articles on side projects, early bands and such""" Deletion of Syrym WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16386 16536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Palki Sharma Upadhyay (2nd nomination) User:RationalPuff 13:19, 10 January 2021 (UTC) delete The article is wholly promotional and mostly rely on primary sources. Fails . Just carrying out day-job as journalist does not in itself establishes nobility Deletion of Palki Sharma Upadhyay (2nd nomination) WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
16387 20786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard James Holland User:onel5969 13:51, 6 January 2019 (UTC) delete Cannot find enough in-depth sourcing to show they meet Deletion of Richard James Holland WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16388 14447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elevator photography User:Mandsford 14:55, 14 September 2010 (UTC) delete First article by a new contributor, welcome to Wikipedia. Safer and more sensible than elevator surfing, but until sources are found to show that this phenomenon has been noticed by the news media, it won't be able to meet even the |general notability guidelines. A Wikipedia article doesn't create notability, it only reports it Deletion of Elevator photography WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16389 6958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sukuma calendar User:JohnCD 19:04, 21 November 2016 (UTC) delete """All that I can find, from the references and by a search, is that the Sukuma, like many agricultural communities, have an annual cycle for their activities based on the movement of the stars, with associated ceremonies. That might be worth a mention in Sukuma people but is not |notable enough for an article. All the stuff about """"5776 solar years"""" and the """"ancient Sukuma"""" is on an unsourced """"''it is believed''"""" basis, failing """ Deletion of Sukuma calendar WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
16390 6438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Stephen User:I 15:08, 24 May 2011 (UTC) comment I continue to have reservations about the validity of assessing Stephen, or other clergy, in the category . and has no category for clergy. What would the process for adding a section on asessing the notability of clergy to look like Deletion of Jonathan Stephen WP:ACADEMIC||WP:BIO||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16391 19777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DataSynapse (2nd nomination) User:Wmahan 15:55, 2 August 2006 (UTC) delete all three articles, per above and since the company fails Deletion of DataSynapse (2nd nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16392 20904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pet recovery service User:Mike 15:58, 4 June 2010 (UTC) keep Clearly notable service with ample sources to meet Deletion of Pet recovery service WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16393 10982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cardiodontics User:MastCell 17:39, 10 May 2010 (UTC) delete Lack of independent, reliable sources, and thus fails |notability guidelines Deletion of Cardiodontics WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16394 4515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cassius Marcellus Clay Sr. (2nd nomination) User:Jacona 20:07, 27 June 2020 (UTC) keep """Easily passes . states """"Also, notability not being inherited is not by itself grounds for deletion"""". It should be noted this is one of a pair of articles nominated, along with Clay's wife Odessa Grady Clay""" Deletion of Cassius Marcellus Clay Sr. (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:INHERIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16395 11136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/F.2.D. User:Blathnaid 19:31, 10 June 2008 (UTC) delete There is nothing in the article that makes the band pass , and I can't find anything via Google that would pass . Article can be recreated in the future if the group becomes notable Deletion of F.2.D. WP:MUSIC||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16396 8900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SonFire Ministries User:Bearian 17:52, 23 July 2007 (UTC) delete per above. Also, violates Deletion of SonFire Ministries WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16397 15851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sven Voelpel User:Joe 23:12, 13 December 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |person Deletion of Sven Voelpel WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16398 10271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RubberNut Bob User:A 15:20, 13 March 2010 (UTC) delete """per and . I tried to at least http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=RubberNut_Bob&action=historysubmit&diff=349621968&oldid=349604584 fix the format of the article, but once I got to """"When the nut is busted open a condom pops out,"""" the believability of this story all but vanished. So, I checked online and not only does it not get Google News, J-Stor, etc. results, the only three http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&source=hp&q=%22RubberNut+Bob%22&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq= regular Google results even are all related to this article. Thus, it is almost assuredly a hoax and even if not is not something of any importance as we have nothing to verify it beyond the article creator. While we , we do not do so at the point of being naive and even so we need at least one non-Wikipedic source. As there are no other uses I could find of this name in fiction or otherwise, we can safely redlink this article for no merge or redirect locations exist. Sincerely""" Deletion of RubberNut Bob WP:V||WP:HOAX||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16399 14939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrienne Murphy User:Bearian 17:25, 11 September 2014 (UTC) keep based on |past outcomes and |growing consensus that Miss Universe contestants are almost always notable Deletion of Adrienne Murphy WP:OUTCOMES||WP:CCC Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
16400 7312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tarek Moore User:Prolog 10:42, 26 September 2006 (UTC) delete per a crystal ball as Google doesn't confirm the release of either the single or the upcoming album Deletion of Tarek Moore WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16401 18544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C. J. Germany User:Paulmcdonald 18:55, 5 July 2019 (UTC) delete I agree, subject does not pass or any other notability guideline Deletion of C. J. Germany WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16402 4308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2006 Colorado's 7th congressional district election User:Love 04:02, 7 February 2021 (UTC) merge """per {{U|Reywas92}}. Also, . These elections are held every two years, as required by law. And as ROUTINE says, """"Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill|Run-of-the-mill events—common, everyday, ordinary items that do not stand out—are probably not notable."""" Of course, these elections do not happen every day, but the fact that they are held every two years without fail also points to a common, ordinary occurrence. It's why we automatically have articles on special elections, because they do NOT fall into a ROUTINE sort of standard when it comes to the regular election cycle""" Deletion of 2006 Colorado's 7th congressional district election WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16403 1915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TriPoint Global Equities User:HighKing 14:27, 19 September 2018 (UTC) delete I can't find any references that meet the criteria for establishing notability, fails GNG and Deletion of TriPoint Global Equities WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16404 16674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Racism in the Palestinian territories User:Tarc 14:36, 22 August 2010 (UTC) delete """IMO a healthy dose of needs to be dropped onto this article so we can try to begin again fresh. A lot of shit has been stirred up lately with the mediation results from Israeli apartheid, resulting in a lot (moreso than usual in the I-P topic area) of """"Well if we're gonna have THIS on the Wikipedia then I'm gonna go create THAT"""" tit-for-tat editing. In its current form, this article has been crafted largely out of spite and is far too reliant on jpost, ynet, harretz, and (mind-boggle) worldnetdaily for sourcing. There may be a notable topic here, but building on the current foundation is not the way to go""" Deletion of Racism in the Palestinian territories WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
16405 20920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stomp! Shout! Scream! User:Cewbot 00:02, 6 February 2021 (UTC) comment While this discussion appears to have |no quorum, it is '''NOT eligible for |soft deletion''' because it has been Special:Diff/160159094|previously PROD'd (via summary Deletion of Stomp! Shout! Scream! WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
16406 256 [[BFS finance]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Joe-Tomato NONE keep Die Bafin-Zulassung als Factoring-Unternehmen ist in der Bafin-Datenbank zu finden. Angesichts der Strukturdatenhttp://www.bfs-finance.de/unternehmen/zahlen-fakten von 3 Mrd. EUR abgewickeltes Forderungsvolumen, 35 Mio. Transaktionen, 1.800 Geschäftskunden, Management von mehr als 20 Mio. B2B- und B2C-Debitoren scheint mir z.B. die Firma GE Corporate Financial Services vergleichbar. Das für Finanzdienstleister geltende #Banken_und_andere_Finanzdienstleister|Relevanzkriterium von mindestens 10 Mio. Transaktionen wird locker (um den Faktor 3,5) überschritten. Diese Werte habe ich nun auch in den Artikel geschrieben. Viele Grüße Löschung von BFS finance Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
16407 12112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Evil Empire: 101 Ways That England Ruined the World User:Nyttend 17:55, 15 April 2009 (UTC) keep """saying """"|I don't like it"""" is an invalid reason for deletion""" Deletion of The Evil Empire: 101 Ways That England Ruined the World WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16408 18304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cicero (Automobiles) User:Ukexpat 20:12, 9 September 2008 (UTC) delete in the strongest possible terms and speedy close per . Clearly a hoax - images are of other manufacturer's vehicles. User blocked for creating hoaxes Deletion of Cicero (Automobiles) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
16409 6637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Born Again (Newsboys album) User:Walter 22:17, 12 December 2015 (UTC) keep Meets . It actually does not need any of that, but it could be expanded Deletion of Born Again (Newsboys album) :WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16410 467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Bytheway User:EBY3221 01:59, 28 October 2014 (UTC) delete """The subject has many YouTube videos and much LDS promotional material but it strikes me as - there are no reliable sources from people independent of the topic himself (as another editor called it """"the LDS silo"""") that regard Bytheway as notable""" Deletion of John Bytheway WP:SPIP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16411 13890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternate versions of Nick Fury User:Shooterwalker 22:14, 1 October 2020 (UTC) merge as compromise if the AFD is going that way. Subject fails and and shouldn't be spunout into its own article. Would be justified in deleting Deletion of Alternate versions of Nick Fury WP:GNG||WP:NOTPLOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16412 16751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harney and Sons User:SL93 20:49, 13 April 2012 (UTC) keep Passes per Yunshui Deletion of Harney and Sons WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16413 12801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blockparty User:Yuckfoo 01:33, 23 November 2007 (UTC) keep please it is a important subject and erasing does not help our encyclopedia see also why deletion of this articles is wrong Deletion of Blockparty WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
16414 13906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Thomson (politician) user:xeno 21:17, 8 May 2010 (UTC) comment """I don't think anyone is saying she meets , but I believe she meets . Furthermore, POLITICIAN states that ''""""In the case of candidates for political office who do not meet this guideline, the general rule is to redirect to an appropriate page covering the election or political office sought in lieu of deletion. Relevant material from the biographical article can be merged into the election or political office page if appropriate.""""''. So redirect, rather than outright deletion, would be the appropriate course of action if the result here is not """"keep""" Deletion of Sarah Thomson (politician) WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16415 416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of independent bookstores in the United States (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 23:11, 4 July 2013 (UTC) keep """Per , """"It is neither improper nor uncommon to simultaneously have a category, a list, and a navigation template which all cover the same topic. These redundant systems of organizing information are considered to be complementary, not inappropriately duplicative."""" See also: :Category:Independent bookstores of the United States""" Deletion of List of independent bookstores in the United States (2nd nomination) WP:NOTDUP Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
16416 8116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Secularization of Christmas (2) User:AYArktos 10:20, 25 August 2006 (UTC) keep why is an article on Christian beliefs not deserving a place on Wikipedia. Last I heard Wikipedia was #Wikipedia_is_not_censored|not censored. No grounds given for deletion of a referenced article. Note related nomination at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spring Holiday Deletion of Secularization of Christmas (2) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16417 7554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chicken noodle KD User:Eauhomme 05:46, 19 May 2009 (UTC) delete per |WP:INEDIBLE. Also, if you need a valid rationale, Deletion of Chicken noodle KD WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP: MADEUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16418 18516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SerenityOS (2nd nomination) User:SK2242 12:01, 23 December 2020 (UTC) delete Only coverage is from https://hackaday.com/tag/serenityos/ Hackaday - fails Deletion of SerenityOS (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16419 9505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mathew Beard (2nd nomination) User:Newshunter12 00:10, 4 November 2018 (UTC) delete """Per and . There is essentially no article, it's just a claimed record and a list of years he moved or got a new job etc. Of the three sources in the article, one is a GRG list which does nothing to prove notability, and two are mere local feature articles. There is no policy that """"the oldest x"""" is notable or entitled to an article. His age, life dates, nationality and record are already variously recorded on five different lists, where they are easier to view, so this permanent is not needed""" Deletion of Mathew Beard (2nd nomination) WP:NOPAGE||WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE||WP:PERMASTUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16420 10098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Wilson, Jr. User:The 07:03, 13 June 2012 (UTC) delete has yet to compete in a professional series. Textbook case of . When he makes a start in a NASCAR national touring series (Cup/N'wide/Truck), wins in ARCA, or finishes top-5 or so in points in a NASCAR regional series (or otherwise meets the , of course!), we'll see him here again. Until then, hasta la vista, baby Deletion of Brian Wilson, Jr. WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16421 15546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gippsland phantom cat User:Permstrump 04:42, 29 July 2016 (UTC) comment I'm not totally opposed to merging, but since this seems to be a descriptive title, I don't quite see the purpose as it's rarely the term actually used to describe the thing. Keeping in mind that I was almost exclusively looking at self-published websites and tabloids, I did see Australian big cats come up enough that I'm open to the ''small'' possibility that Australian big cats are notable enough for a section in the main Phantom cat article (which I'm not even convinced merits its own article). Most of these things probably should get redirects to List of cryptids with a 1-2 sentence description and no main article. Because the thing I'm seeing with these regional phantom cats (e.g., see also Blue Mountains panther) is that, if they're even covered in independent reliable sources at all, which most aren't, it's never anything close to in depth coverage, so the only thing to say about them is that there's been speculation about sightings, which isn't encyclopedic per . That's how we end up with a Phantom cat article that is literally a list of sightings of non-existent cats that doesn't give the reader any information about the myth, its origin, where it's popular, etc., and basically treats it like it might be a real thing, because that's the only coverage that exists...people claiming to have seen them and sources repeating people's claims to have seen them Deletion of Gippsland phantom cat WP:SPECULATION Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16422 8808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Crow (2011 film) (2nd nomination) User:GorillaWarfare 15:14, 2 August 2010 (UTC) delete per above, and per . Maybe when more information becomes available the film will warrant its own article Deletion of The Crow (2011 film) (2nd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16423 21874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Punta Gorda Middle School User:TerriersFan 17:52, 27 December 2007 (UTC) keep thanks to DoubleBlue this page now contains the necessary independent, verifiable sources to meet and contains several specific claims of notability Deletion of Punta Gorda Middle School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16424 7475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Too Cool for School User:Ansh666 04:54, 28 November 2016 (UTC) delete or '''Redirect''' to List_of_Class_of_3000_episodes_and_songs#Season_2, which is hatted from the current article. Not ideal, but as it stands, this seems to fail Deletion of Too Cool for School WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
16425 9114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Digimon (2nd nomination) User:Sandstein 17:07, 31 August 2015 (UTC) delete Per policy, , our articles must be more than mere summaries of the contents of fiction. This here is nothing more than a list of monster names and fails that policy ''so'' hard Deletion of List of Digimon (2nd nomination) WP:NOTPLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16426 20575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gramble User:K 02:29, 17 July 2020 (UTC) delete does not meet ; sources are in passing and / or Deletion of Gramble WP:NORG||WP:SPIP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16427 15088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Honky Tonk Confidential User:Michig 15:09, 20 June 2010 (UTC) keep per apparent failure to follow . When I removed the PROD tag I indicated that coverage exists. See http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&searchlink=HONKY|TONK|CONFIDENTIAL&sql=11:abfyxq9jldhe~T1 Allmusic bio and http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&sql=10:3nfpxq90ld0e review, and http://news.google.co.uk/archivesearch?pz=1&cf=all&ned=uk&hl=en&q=%22honky+tonk+confidential%22&cf=all Google News - coverage from the ''Washington Post'', http://www.popmatters.com/music/reviews/h/honkytonkconfidential-your.shtml PopMatters, ''http://www.nytimes.com/2007/06/27/arts/28schieffer.html?_r=1&ref=music New York Times'', etc. The article needs improvement, not deletion, and we don't need to waste the time of several editors on this discussion Deletion of Honky Tonk Confidential WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16428 3783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Bergstein User:Gaijin42 15:00, 25 October 2013 (UTC) keep Per busterD way below with 3 RS. he meets GNG, but barely. Will have to keep vigilant to avoid the gossip rags from being used and bring in violations Deletion of David Bergstein WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16429 11857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noureddine Maamria User:Qwghlm 16:40, 27 January 2007 (UTC) delete as there's no evidence he satisifes , although he comes close Deletion of Noureddine Maamria WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16430 16967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prince Alexander, Duke of Södermanland User:Metropolitan90 02:22, 12 August 2020 (UTC) merge to his father, Prince Carl Philip, Duke of Värmland. There is not enough to say about this person yet to warrant having a separate article. If, later in life, he does things that bring him more |significant coverage, even if just for being a socialite, the article can be re-created at that time Deletion of Prince Alexander, Duke of Södermanland WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
16431 20119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry de la Mesa Allen, Jr. User:Dhartung 20:36, 6 January 2007 (UTC) merge with Terry de la Mesa Allen. Although he is mentioned in the book and was the highest-ranking officer killed in the battle, no other particular notability is established (e.g. posthumous medals). |Wikipedia is not a memorial, and over 400 officers of his rank were KIA in Vietnam.http://thewall-usa.com/index.asp Search on O-5 Chris 73, glad you changed the nom. The first version was |unduly incivil Deletion of Terry de la Mesa Allen, Jr. WP:NOT||WP:CIVIL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16432 8644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greenhill Primary School User:Colonel 22:59, 26 August 2009 (UTC) keep Seems to have been nominated in a deletion spree made without |due diligence. Improvement of the article to cite sources which assert notability proves easy when one makes the effort Deletion of Greenhill Primary School WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16433 11823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Scientology centers User:Chalst 19:52, 8 December 2005 (UTC) comment I found the justification for Scott Burley's sppedy deletion http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/List_of_Scientology_centers&diff=prev&oldid=30441792. He appears to be claiming the article falls under A3, a judgement I disagree with at least for the article in the form I first saw: there is too much structure for that Deletion of List of Scientology centers WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
16434 4221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of currently running Broadway shows User:danntm 15:02, 18 October 2006 (UTC) delete per |Wikipedia is not a playbill, and this list provides not added value (cf. Deletion of List of currently running Broadway shows WP:NOT||WP:LIST Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16435 17135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernard Lewinsky User:Bearian 21:43, 6 July 2011 (UTC) keep he easily passes |the Prof test as a top 15 % doctor, owner of a major clinic, ''h''-index over 10, etc., based on |literally hundreds of precedents. Neither does prevent inclusion of notable relatives. As noted above, |significant coverage in numerous sources creates a |presumption of notability, which must be rebutted by the preponderence of the evidence. This has not been done Deletion of Bernard Lewinsky WP:PROF||WP:OUTCOMES||WP:INHERITED||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16436 5658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaahin Filizadeh User:David 15:06, 19 June 2009 (UTC) delete """no evidence of passing . Assistant professor with a record that does not stand out among other assistant professors; few citations in Google scholar. Actually holding an NSERC chair might be grounds for keeping, but being """"associated with"""" one is not""" Deletion of Shaahin Filizadeh WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16437 1557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ricky Shivers User:LlamaAl 23:40, 19 December 2012 (UTC) delete Subject fails and Deletion of Ricky Shivers WP:MMANOT||WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
16438 14763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Ricci User:AllyD 07:49, 20 August 2014 (UTC) delete Multiple searches including Allmusic and Allaboutjazz are not turning up |evidence that the subject meets the |notability criteria. (Note: there is a Bob Ricci who does comedy music, but I think not the same person Deletion of Robert Ricci :WP:RS||:WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16439 11163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Talmud User:TheTito 23:29, 27 October 2009 (UTC) delete I'm unable to find neither any other roles he has taken nor even a fan page, large or other, as mentioned on Deletion of Steve Talmud WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16440 1272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/War (Swedish band) User:4meter4 01:57, 28 September 2019 (UTC) delete Fails and therefore . The sources cited are not reliable per wikipedia's standards for verifiability and therefore, the subject does not meet the criteria at . Sources independent of the subject are needed to verify that content in order for the article to be kept Deletion of War (Swedish band) WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16441 14750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of video games developed in Belgium User:Satellizer 12:07, 16 May 2016 (UTC) delete including List of video games developed in the Netherlands as well, as redundant to their categories. Sure, NOTDUP exists, but the existence of such a content fork still has to be justifiable. I just don't see the extra information being given here to be actually useful to readers, and they have the potential to get hideously long (:Category:Video games developed in the United States for example has 1700+ entries). Considering the fact that the articles are terribly written, completely unsourced, potentially (as no sources actually talk about or list games this way), and don't even follow the MOS (the Hong Kong one, for example, blatantly violates ) a healthy dosage of may work as well Deletion of List of video games developed in Belgium WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:ENGLISH||WP:TNT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16442 1475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ClipboardMultiSharer User:Joe 15:41, 22 June 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of ClipboardMultiSharer WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16443 20769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jon Kauffman User:Joe 20:18, 3 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |director Deletion of Jon Kauffman WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16444 8616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jehovah's Witnesses in popular culture User:Otto4711 18:33, 31 July 2007 (UTC) delete """per #DIR. This doesn't even pretend to be about actual appearances of JWs. Simply using the words """"Jehovah's Witness"""" is sufficient to make the list. Hey, in high school I wrote a poem in the style of Ogden Nash about the JWs, maybe I can add that to the list""" Deletion of Jehovah's Witnesses in popular culture WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16445 3162 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sako Chivitchian User:Sepulwiki 12:54, 22 December 2012 (UTC) keep Meets Deletion of Sako Chivitchian WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
16446 4564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Robinson (surfer) [[User Talk:JzG|Just zis Guy you know?]] 21:34, 19 June 2006 (UTC) delete noting but also - and , for that matter Deletion of James Robinson (surfer) WP:VAIN||WP:BIO||WP:HOLE Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
16447 8213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Space Penguins of Tuscumbia User:LuckyLouie 03:31, 4 March 2014 (UTC) delete No reliable sources found for this obscure UFO story. Americanmonsters.com, ufoupdateslist.com, theblackvault.com are |fringe sites and don't meet our criteria for |reliable sources Deletion of Space Penguins of Tuscumbia WP:FRINGE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
16448 19060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cleveland Bucs User:Smartyllama 18:46, 4 February 2021 (UTC) keep The league should not have been bundled into the AfD with the Teams, it's a suitable redirect target and there's no reason to delete it that has been provided. It seems to have been thrown in hastily after someone suggested retargeting there. There is ample coverage of the league to justify keeping. Not so much the teams, yet. Maybe later, not yet. Simply . No objection to recreating team articles once further notability is established Deletion of Cleveland Bucs WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16449 12620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Connect Bus and Coach User:Northamerica1000 06:27, 17 April 2016 (UTC) delete Not finding source coverage online to qualify an article; does not meet Deletion of Connect Bus and Coach WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
16450 8804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aerosmith's fifteenth studio album (3rd nomination) User:Tezero 18:36, 23 December 2009 (UTC) merge per Deletion of Aerosmith's fifteenth studio album (3rd nomination) WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
16451 12255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jugular Street Luge Racing User:Zxcvbnm 19:48, 16 September 2017 (UTC) keep You are confusing adhering to with properly sourcing your article. It was notable, but not properly sourced. Unsourced non biographical articles that are notable can still remain on Wikipedia. Therefore there is no real reason to delete, it can stay on as a stub Deletion of Jugular Street Luge Racing WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16452 19561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GayNZ.com User:Otto4711 04:55, 17 February 2007 (UTC) keep """taking a look at the Ghits, it may meet point 3 of : """"The content is distributed via a medium which is both well known and independent of the creators, either through an online newspaper or magazine, an online publisher, or an online broadcaster."""" The distribution of GayNZ.com stories by multiple other sites is enough to tip me to a keep !vote although it's hardly cast in stone""" Deletion of GayNZ.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16453 7259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DigiTech Bad Monkey User:A 05:20, 9 December 2009 (UTC) merge to DigiTech. I appreciate Mgm's concern, which is certainly very valid. But we do have a notability guideline for products, , and so far as I can tell this subject fails that guideline. No third-party reliable sources are cited in the article, nor can I find any significant coverage; it's a shame, because this is a fairly well-written stub. Per , if the product is not notable on its own, information about it belongs in the company's article Deletion of DigiTech Bad Monkey WP:PRODUCT||WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16454 9724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karibi Dede User:Paulmcdonald 20:55, 25 April 2018 (UTC) keep looks like he had playing time in the Canadian Football League, which passes Deletion of Karibi Dede WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
16455 5391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rich Zubaty User:Cunard 02:02, 13 May 2010 (UTC) delete per the http://news.google.com/archivesearch?&as_src=-newswire+-wire+-presswire+-PR+-press+-release+-wikipedia&q=%22Rich+Zubaty%22 lack of sufficient coverage in |reliable sources. This article fails Wikipedia:Notability (biographies), Wikipedia:Verifiability, and Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons Deletion of Rich Zubaty WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16456 16325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Third day in the Bible User:Fayenatic 00:04, 25 December 2012 (UTC) delete as . I have merged 2 lines into Chronology of Jesus#Day of death, as I considered them worthwhile and non-contentious.http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Chronology_of_Jesus&diff=529659428&oldid=529605783 The prophetic link between Jonah and Christ's burial is already covered appropriately in other articles. As for the specific thesis of the book, a few lines could be added to Kermit Zarley; but the page should be deleted rather than redirected Deletion of Third day in the Bible WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16457 165 [[RP-Eisenbahn]] (erl.) Benutzer:Kailas98 21:05, 23. Jun. 2009 (CEST) delete """da #U nicht auf Eisenbahninfrastrukturunternehmen (EIU) zutrifft. Diese sind in der Regel keine Wirtschaftsunternehmen, deren Hauptzweck die Erzielung eines Gewinns ist. Der Hauptzweck von EIU ist es, Bahnstrecken im Sinne der öffentlichen Daseinsvorsorge für die Allgemeinheit vorzuhalten. Als Relevanzkriterium kommt eigentlich nur unter #Schienenverkehr der Vermerk """"Bahnstrecken werden in der Regel mit ihrer Fertigstellung relevant."""" in Frage. Da EIU Bahnstrecken betreiben, sind sie genauso relevant wie die Bahnstrecke selbst. Ohne das EIU gibt es die Bahnstrecke nicht. Die #Schienenverkehr|Relevanzkriterien Schienenverkehr sind deshalb lückenhaft und sollten um Eisenbahninfrastrukturunternehmen und Eisenbahnverkehrsunternehmen (hier ggf. ab einer bestimmten Mindestgröße) erweitert werden""" Löschung von RP-Eisenbahn Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
16458 328 [[St.Johann-Batista]] (Gelöscht) Benutzer:Historiograf NONE keep Ist sicher ein eingetragenes Kulturdenkmal und als solches gemäß relevant Löschung von St.Johann-Batista Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
16459 3797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spuddles User:Quarl NONE delete as |Complete bollocks. &mdash Deletion of Spuddles WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
16460 16260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Police officers charged criminally in Canada User:Life 02:39, 29 February 2012 (UTC) delete This is not even a proper article—it is nothing but a collection of links, both internal and external. See Deletion of Police officers charged criminally in Canada WP:LINKFARM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16461 18852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mexican Crime Rates User:Jersey 23:14, 18 May 2006 (UTC) delete per , also a fork article where any relevant info presented could easily be placed in the Mexico article Deletion of Mexican Crime Rates WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16462 5359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ralph de Warenne (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep Do we really have to do this again? A historical figure does not have to do something noteworthy to be ''|notable''. There doesn't have to be a lot known for ''significant coverage'' to exist. Case in point, the rather undistinguished Ralph de Warenne has received significant coverage in the multiple reliable sources cited in the article, mainly because of his potential connection to the Whitchurch Warennes. There is no . The main secondary sources cited (Farrer 1923; Farrer & Clay 1949; Eyton 1859) are specifically about Ralph de Warenne and the article summarises what they say about him. The more tangential mentions in other secondary sources, and the few primary sources, are used appropriately, to clarify points of fact and make what is, as you say, an obscure and convoluted historical topic a little easier to parse Deletion of Ralph de Warenne (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
16463 4539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Db4o User:Pohta 15:13, 26 January 2010 (UTC) keep http://books.google.com/books?id=SXG19zl8qF4C&printsec=frontcover&dq=%22Db4o%22+-inpublisher:icon&as_brr=0&cd=1#v=onepage&q=&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=0zkEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA27&dq=%22Db4o%22+-inpublisher:icon&as_brr=0&cd=2#v=onepage&q=%22Db4o%22%20-inpublisher%3Aicon&f=false http://www.ddj.com/database/187203597?pgno=2 http://www.ddj.com/database/199901523?pgno=2 http://www.linuxjournal.com/article/8645 etc. Even covered in college textbooks http://books.google.com/books?id=fSMmr6ptb9oC&pg=RA2-PA269&dq=%22Db4o%22+-inpublisher:icon&lr=&as_brr=0&cd=21#v=onepage&q=%22Db4o%22%20-inpublisher%3Aicon&f=false. The article could use some work, but it's definitely nowhere near the advertorial level required for deletion. Also a http://www.ibm.com/developerworks/views/java/libraryview.jsp?search_by=db4o 7-part tutorial in IBM developerWorks, which was already linked in the article. Big for the guys trying to CSD this Deletion of Db4o WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Whacking with a wet trout 74
16464 11402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grillionaire User:Leebo86 03:14, 25 February 2007 (UTC) delete Lacks |reliable sources to support how this neologism is |notable Deletion of Grillionaire WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16465 8303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Douglas Herbert User:Resolute 19:14, 25 October 2010 (UTC) delete at this point, just another nn candidate running for office. As per repeated precedent, being a candidate does not pass , and I see nothing else here that argues notability at this time Deletion of Douglas Herbert WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16466 15228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Sun (Star Wars) User:Doc 21:09, 28 April 2008 (UTC) delete NN, lacks |reliable sources and is mostly plot. Anything noteworthy can be included in either the article for Prince Xizor or Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire Deletion of Black Sun (Star Wars) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16467 1489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Tourister User:Gene 07:49, 2 November 2008 (UTC) keep Easily meets and Deletion of American Tourister WP:V||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16468 14909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Echeverri User:Smartyllama 13:07, 27 September 2016 (UTC) keep Played on the Colombian national team and thus satisfies regardless of the magnitude of the tournament Deletion of Daniel Echeverri WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16469 17573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/School wiki User:Mgbo120 19:33, 11 January 2019 (UTC) delete Lacks notable refs. Appears to fail Deletion of School wiki WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16470 11079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Regional Theatre: the Revolutionary Stage User:Boneymau 01:54, 29 August 2020 (UTC) keep """Look at Google Books, there's at least a few journal articles that review it, loads of references to it as a significant contribution, and the 2019 book ''America in the Round: Capital, Race, and Nation at Washington D.C.'s Arena Stage'' calls it """"the central text of the field"""" of scholarship on US regional theatre. Looking at context it's enough to pass """ Deletion of Regional Theatre: the Revolutionary Stage WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
16471 11032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victor Győry User:DustFormsWords 05:53, 7 January 2011 (UTC) delete per . Wikipedia is not a news source and does not provide an article on every newsworthy event. In order to overcome this policy, the event would need to have wide demographic or geographic impact, be the precursor to or result of another notable event, and/or demonstrate sustained discussion sufficient to found a claim of historic importance Deletion of Victor Győry WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16472 12060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Revue des Juristes de Sciences Po User:Talk2chun 16:41, 8 January 2017 (UTC) delete I just did a quick Google search for RJSP. Aside from all the blog posts (which do not meet |Wikipedia's reliable sources guidelines), I've found one mention in a French handbook for students of legal sciences (Bonnard, Jérôme (2013-08-21), ''Méthodes de travail de l'étudiant en droit'', Paris:Hachette Livres) on https://books.google.be/books?id=jSfYAAAAQBAJ&lpg=PT67&ots=YG8U_OgYuD&dq=%22Revue%20des%20Juristes%20de%20Sciences%20Po%22%20-wikipedia&pg=PT67#v=onepage&q=%22Revue%20des%20Juristes%20de%20Sciences%20Po%22%20-wikipedia&f=false Google Books. Not sure if it would be enough to corroborate |notability, though definitely not enough to support notability on its own, and I could not determine the source's reliability Deletion of Revue des Juristes de Sciences Po WP:IRS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16473 6442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ardrums Little and Great Ardrums [[User talk:O'Dea|talk]]) 22:38, 4 March 2013 (UTC) keep """According to ikipedia is an encyclopedia, """"An encyclopedia...incorporates elements of general and specialized encyclopedias, almanacs, ''and gazetteers''"""" (my italics). A gazetteer is """"a geographical dictionary or directory"""", so the inclusion is justified. Also, |Wikipedia is not limited by paper. The article could use cleanup and references, however. :File:Usher statue - closeup.jpg|'''— O'Dea""" Deletion of Ardrums Little and Great Ardrums WP:W||WP:PAPER Help:Watchlist 110
16474 12823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virtuozzo (company) User:Jppcap 22:45, 26 April 2017 (UTC) comment """Pinged back and did a broader search rn and this looks like a case of . Alas, a number of primary refs / some overt advert cut out. Above refs added to a temp """"External links"""" header to work through & Russian/Chinese added. Needs more eyes on the current text, as plenty of advert still to revise""" Deletion of Virtuozzo (company) WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
16475 10728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spanish Briton User:Bearian 17:25, 14 December 2007 (UTC) keep One section needs work, but the rest of the article is |well-sourced and well-written. The article as a whole is |Notable and |is the sort of article that should be in English Wikipedia Deletion of Spanish Briton WP:RS||WP:N||WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16476 1057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Dean (magician) User:Paulmcdonald 14:06, 11 January 2018 (UTC) delete reads like an advertisement, so violates Deletion of Jason Dean (magician) WP:ADV Wikipedia:External links 76
16477 264 [[Wolfgang Priklopil]] (erl, redirect) Benutzer:Helge.at NONE delete Gemäß , Fall 1 (und auch 3), habe ich die Löschung von Wolfgang Priklopil Wikipedia:Entfernen von Löschwarnungen Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
16478 20415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015–16 F.C. Halifax Town season NONE NONE delete WP:NSEASONS is pretty strict about this – only teams playing in fully professional leagues should have a season article unless the season itself meets . As the English fifth tier is not fully professional, and GNG is not satisfied by pure coverage alone, no other choice but to delete the article Deletion of 2015–16 F.C. Halifax Town season WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16479 12417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of words having different meanings in British and American English User:Carlossuarez46 00:40, 28 June 2007 (UTC) comment fundamentally, the nominator doesn't like the current state of the article and intends to write another to replace it. Such a deletion is against policy. There seems to be no dispute as to whether the subject is encyclopedic (|reliable sources are available for the subject -- whether those sources bear out every detail of the current content is no reason to delete -- one editor's view is to the contrary, notwithstanding the cited books, which I will |assume that editor has read to be sure). If the pages are in such a need of a re-write the proper procedure is to propose the alternate on the talk page or create it in userspace and reference it on the talk page, rather than make the community take it on faith that this article will indeed be written, will be better than the current one, and will properly attribute any prior versions as per the GFDL. We all have come across an article in our humble opinions we'd prefer to delete and start from scratch. Fortunately, you can propose your own version for community review and consensus. Unfortunately, we cannot just delete something because we would rather re-start from scratch Deletion of List of words having different meanings in British and American English WP:RS||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16480 10923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KSP Sound Player User:Cunard 08:25, 21 November 2009 (UTC) delete per the http://news.google.com/archivesearch?&as_src=-newswire+-wire+-presswire+-PR+-press+-release+-wikipedia&q=%22KSP+Sound+Player%22 lack of |reliable sources. A http://books.google.com/books?as_brr=0&as_pub=-icon&q=%22KSP+Sound+Player%22 Google Books search returns only a passing mention. This topic fails Deletion of KSP Sound Player WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16481 16033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sylvester Renner User:Hobbes 19:05, 24 February 2019 (UTC) delete No independent, reliable sourcing to substantiate notability, offered or to be found. Deletion of Sylvester Renner WP:NOTPROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16482 2734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Urban Bank [[User talk:61.10.165.33|talk]]) 14:56, 13 January 2014 (UTC) keep """due to the amount of coverage which demonstrates notability. I am going through and adding some citations as I am able. That said, I understand the temptation to this. Sky Harbor deserves a very large for creating multiple articles with dozens of kilobytes of text and '''zero''' citations in them https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Urban_Bank&oldid=53491295https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Banco_Filipino&oldid=53540102 (not to mention those """"Comparisons"""" sections that may very well be unsourceable ) and then leaving them to gather dust for eight years. Even in 2006, that was not an acceptable practice, and it would be nice if this AfD motivated him to finally step up and add at least some sources to these giant uncited walls of text, notwithstanding that . Regards, Special:Contributions/61.10.165.33|61.10.165.33""" Deletion of Urban Bank WP:RS||WP:TNT||WP:TROUT||WP:SYNTHESIS||WP:AFDISNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16483 4690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ARDOR User:GermanJoe 13:54, 24 March 2018 (UTC) delete or draftify and AfC) - mentions and coverage in non-reliable sources are not sufficient to establish notability. It seems simply for this topic (and repeated arguments are invalid for such discussions). I would support Thomas' alternative suggestion to draftify the article to improve it, when better sources become available with in-depth coverage. The entire article needs an almost complete rewrite though to remove all the trivia, irrelevant tangents, low-quality sources and non-neutral language - most of the current content is not suitable for a dispassionate non-promotional article. It should also go through AfC then to allow reviewing by an unbiased editor Deletion of ARDOR WP:TOOSOON||WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16484 5580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henry Makow User:Nsk92 02:53, 20 May 2008 (UTC) keep """I agree with the nom that the references listed in the article do not pass . However, there is some reasonably significant newscoverage by reliable sources. GoogleNews gives 46 hitshttp://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&lr=&tab=pn&q=%22Henry+Makow%22&ie=UTF-8, a decent number of which pass . E.g. New York Daily Newshttp://www.nydailynews.com/archives/lifestyle/2005/03/31/2005-03-31_mail_order_matchmaking___new.html, Washington Posthttp://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-1317828.html, CBC CanadaNewshttp://www.cbc.ca/news/story/2000/05/15/women.html, as well as these ones http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-24761571_ITMhttp://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2000/may/00053002.htmlhttp://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-30538339.html and others. There is also a reasonable amount of coverage in this GoogleNews search of his childhood """"AskHenry"""" column, although I don't know how much that counts now. GoogleBooks gives 45 hits http://books.google.com/books?um=1&lr=&q=%22Henry%20Makow%22&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=np (I am not sure how many are actually related to him). GoogleScholar produces 26 hits totalhttp://scholar.google.com/scholar?um=1&lr=&q=%22Henry%20Makow%22&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=ps, a few of which appear relevant, such as thishttp://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/497347. Granted, this is not much, but for a conspiracy theorist it is not that bad. |Reliable sources usually avoid them. So I think one could stretch here a bit""" Deletion of Henry Makow WP:RS||WP:RS||WP:RS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16485 16180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/H.I.M. (History In Making) User:Blood 21:23, 19 May 2008 (UTC) delete Will make a come-back in 2010? What a load of |balls Deletion of H.I.M. (History In Making) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16486 15173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Cambridgeshire User:Mkdw 03:25, 30 March 2013 (UTC) delete I disagree with transwiki. Making our problem Wikivoyage's problem is not a good idea. Bus routes are continuously updated and changed, but not continuously maintained on wiki's. They've been having a large problem with this. Furthermore, all the relevant information is all under Deletion of List of bus routes in Cambridgeshire WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16487 7762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chandini Sreedharan User:Jupitus 09:16, 21 September 2017 (UTC) keep Actress who was the main heroine in at least 4 major films - easy and pass. Content disputes should not be solved by starting a deletion discussion, but must be discussed in the talk page Deletion of Chandini Sreedharan WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16488 19898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anirban Bhattacharya User:TheAafi 18:28, 8 November 2020 (UTC) keep TOOSOON has no place in this article. The subject worked in Arshinagar (2015), Khawto (2015), Eagoler Chokh (2016), Colkatay Columbus (2016), Durga Sohay (2017), Dhananjay (film)|Dhananjay (2017) - all these clarify that this subject is not a |TOO SOON case. He has a lead role in multiple notable films and thus passes the criteria Deletion of Anirban Bhattacharya WP:TOOSOON||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16489 15169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Björn Akstinat User:LaMona 22:01, 26 August 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and just about everything else. The one reference is a virtually empty page, and the publications are self-published. Get rid of this, ASAP. And thanks for the info from @de wikipedia Deletion of Björn Akstinat WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16490 2314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Football at the 2020 Summer Olympics – Men's tournament User:Jkudlick 03:21, 22 March 2016 (UTC) delete There isn't even a stand-alone article for the 2016 Men's and Women's tournaments, and the only thing known about 2020 is that the Games will be in Japan. This is far , so much so that the hasn't been made yet. — Deletion of Football at the 2020 Summer Olympics – Men's tournament WP:TOOSOON||WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16491 9358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Halo Business Intelligence User:SmileBlueJay97 09:47, 22 August 2014 (UTC) delete Fails | organization notability. No |significant coverage found in |independent |reliable sources. Deletion of Halo Business Intelligence WP:CORP||WP:SIGCOV||WP:THIRDPARTY||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16492 14264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helixo CMS User:Msnicki 13:58, 1 June 2011 (UTC) delete No independent secondary sources to establish notability as required by or . Searches (using the links above) fail to turn up anything useful Deletion of Helixo CMS WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
16493 15633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Blair, Minister User:Ihcoyc 13:59, 6 October 2006 (UTC) keep and move per DeLarge. Being a part of the team that translated the Bible into Scottish Gaelic strikes me as a significant enough achievement, and per translating the Bible into a small minority language is no less significant than translating it into English or French. '''Weak delete''' on the other two unless a further case for their notability is made out Deletion of Robert Blair, Minister WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
16494 18809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keith Shepherd User:Scientizzle 23:25, 29 June 2007 (UTC) delete until I see any evidence of |reliably sourced notability to meet . &mdash Deletion of Keith Shepherd WP:RS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16495 17645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shikha Khanduja Kaul User:E 18:25, 24 July 2019 (UTC) delete Fails , fails Deletion of Shikha Khanduja Kaul WP:AUTHOR||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
16496 15716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samuel Gamboa Potter User:Roswell 03:46, 22 March 2007 (UTC) delete as it does not assert notablity per Deletion of Samuel Gamboa Potter WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16497 21755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nordie Tullion a.k.a. Nordie4u User:Coredesat 07:04, 30 August 2006 (UTC) delete as |unverifiable and possibly a hoax Deletion of Nordie Tullion a.k.a. Nordie4u WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16498 434 [[FastForest]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Johannes Maximilian/Artikel NONE delete Um die Relevanz des Artikels adäquat darstellen zu können, müsste man ihn konsequent in deutscher Sprache verfassen… Aber zum Inhaltlichen: Der Artikel behandelt, sofern ich es ihm entnehmen kann, ein Rennteam der Forumla Student. Es gab in der Saison 2020 insgesamt 45 registrierte Teams (https://www.formulastudent.de/teams/registered/2020/ sofern ich das korrekt sehe), die überwiegend eingetragene Vereine sind. Zu keinem dieser Teams haben wir Artikel. Ich würde argumentieren, dass wir die #Sportvereine|Relevanzkriterien für Sportvereine hier anwenden können. Meines Erachtens nimmt Fast Forest nicht an einer der geforderten Ligen teil, wäre also gemäß Relevanzkriterien nicht relevant. Aber ganz davon abgesehen zweifle ich an, dass es erforderliche relevanzstiftende Sekundärquellen zum Thema gibt (gedruckte Fachliteratur oder überregionale Zeitungen zum Beispiel), die als Belege für den Artikel taugen. Das zeigt sich auch gut an der aktuellen Ausgestaltung des Artikels, die mehr wie Eigendarstellung als ein Wikipediaartikel wirkt, die wie eingangs erwähnt, überwiegend in einer projektfremden Sprache verfasst ist. Daher begrüße ich eine des Artikels Löschung von FastForest Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
16499 19979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Purifoy User:Bearian 02:33, 22 January 2010 (UTC) delete there are no |reliable sources in the article, or that I can find |to verify any information in this |biography of a living person. Zero http://news.google.com/news?sourceid=navclient&rlz=1T4GWYE_enUS241US241&q=%22Chris%20Purifoy%22&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&hl=en&tab=wn News Ghits Deletion of Chris Purifoy WP:RS||WP:V||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16500 6025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HELLZ BELLZ User:Dbtfz 00:40, 9 April 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of HELLZ BELLZ WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16501 4042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geoffrey Palmer (real estate developer) User:Pharaoh 03:29, 16 August 2016 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Geoffrey Palmer (real estate developer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16502 4525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World War II.5 User:Gosox5555 13:29, 6 September 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of World War II.5 WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
16503 18847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syla User:Froth 00:39, 8 February 2007 (UTC) delete both Syla and Sylvie Cachay, self-promotional and fails respectively Deletion of Syla WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16504 10426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Foyle User:GiantSnowman 09:06, 14 August 2009 (UTC) delete some kid who (maybe) played in a friendly for a lower league side. Fails and Deletion of Lee Foyle WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16505 6208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Batbayar Khash-Erdene User:GiantSnowman 10:01, 10 May 2019 (UTC) keep per N57, meets , and likely meets GNG due to his stature as international player (anybody speak Mongolian?!). Has nominator done BEFORE given sources already present in the article confirming his senior appearance Deletion of Batbayar Khash-Erdene WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16506 13057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellucian User:HighKing 14:13, 1 October 2019 (UTC) delete I agree with nom above, none of the references meet the criteria for establishing notability, fails GNG and Deletion of Ellucian WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16507 21296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Commissioner Service (Boy Scouts of America) User:Enos733 16:43, 11 July 2021 (UTC) merge to Leadership in the Boy Scouts of America#Commissioner Service and selectively merge content. The sourcing provided is not independent or significant about the position. says that each article must meet independently of whether the main topic is notable, so questions about independence of sourcing are appropriate here Deletion of Commissioner Service (Boy Scouts of America) WP:AVOIDSPLIT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Summary style 34
16508 4449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natasha Dalal User:Pharaoh 01:26, 5 September 2021 (UTC) delete fails a non notable fashion designer Deletion of Natasha Dalal WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16509 9779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evaluative diversity User:MelanieN 23:53, 1 February 2015 (UTC) delete This is not an encyclopedia article; it is an extended essay, riginal research. Setting aside the arguments above about explanation and sourcing, there is a much more basic question that needs to be answered for inclusion here: Is this a notable subject, an established concept? I went to Google Scholar to evaluate (no pun intended) this question and my conclusion is: no, it isn't. I found only a single paper that uses this term. Until this becomes an established scholarly concept, we cannot have an article here. Wikipedia is not a thought leader; it is an encyclopedia, a compiler of what is already known. To User:Langchri, I hope you have kept a copy of this because it shows an enormous amount of work. I would suggest putting it on a blog or webpage, or possibly submitting it for publication somewhere. But Wikipedia is not the place for it Deletion of Evaluative diversity WP:O Wikipedia:Orphan 47
16510 2027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of software companies in Mumbai User:Starblind 17:02, 4 June 2010 (UTC) delete classic , redlink farm, excessive external links and if it sticks around will attract spammers. We wouldn't want a List of pawn shops in New York either. Bottom line, Wikipedia is not your local yellow pages Deletion of List of software companies in Mumbai WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16511 21586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Research and Analysis Wing activities in Pakistan User:Lorstaking 13:12, 25 February 2018 (UTC) delete clear of Research and Analysis Wing that was created by an SPAhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Jockeyy13 to promote a POV Deletion of Research and Analysis Wing activities in Pakistan WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
16512 8071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M. A. Benjaminson [[User talk:Gwern |Gwern]] [[Special:Contributions/Gwern | (contribs)]] 16:25 [[7 November]] [[2007]] (GMT) NONE keep Insufficient nomination; he looks plenty notable to me even by the old standards. What d'you want, a Fields Medal or Nobel Prize Deletion of M. A. Benjaminson WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16513 12337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luan Bexheti User:Masterpiece2000 02:19, 17 June 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Luan Bexheti WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16514 18778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AboutUs.org User:162 18:26, 6 December 2006 (UTC) keep Some of this article meets , it has 2 veriable source (itself and business journal). The Portland business journal is the most reliable source, the other references range from blogs to specialized news sites. They are grey if they meet expectations but the article is on the road to meet it. If it does pass through an aggregation of the sites linking to it and the Portland article it does indeed meet criteria 1 of . Also arguments by Deletion of AboutUs.org WP:V||WP:RS||WP:RS||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16515 21826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Homochitto, Issaquena County, Mississippi User:SportingFlyer 04:28, 7 May 2020 (UTC) keep """I'm not sure is really the right thing here, but https://www.newspapers.com/image/213677211/ supports a """"populated place"""" finding, and it does receive local coverage such as https://www.newspapers.com/image/263803093/ https://www.newspapers.com/image/240522333/ https://www.newspapers.com/image/259811232/. This https://www.newspapers.com/image/183781488/ https://www.newspapers.com/image/236161925/ is a modern obituary which shows the plantation was relevant at least into the early 20th century. A Google book search brings up several results as well, though it's clear there are multiple plantations with this name. On the whole, a weak keep""" Deletion of Homochitto, Issaquena County, Mississippi WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16516 13634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eladio Ribeiro Neto :User:Algébrico|Algébrico]] ([[:pt 18:47, 15 September 2010 (UTC) delete not a significant international carreer. Non-notable per . :pt Deletion of Eladio Ribeiro Neto WP:NTENNIS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16517 2744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhys Williams, sociologist User:AlexTiefling 09:38, 26 September 2008 (UTC) delete Essentially a case of |a person notable for one thing only Deletion of Rhys Williams, sociologist WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16518 12819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dead Red (2nd nomination) User:Tokyogirl79 04:50, 24 February 2012 (UTC) comment The only reason it squeaked by last time was because one of their songs was used as a theme song to the National Geographic show Philly Undercover. Other than that, I agree that it's too soon. I did hold some reservations over the theme since there weren't any non-primary sources to back it up, though Deletion of Dead Red (2nd nomination) WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16519 90 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Cardi B live performances User:Animalparty 03:56, 28 April 2018 (UTC) delete per and . We should not encourage more WP:fancruft|Fancruft. Several lists in :Category:Lists of concerts and performances might also be examined Deletion of List of Cardi B live performances WP:LISTN||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16520 4846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuttiyani St George Orthodox Church, Ranny User:Whiteguru 12:58, 11 July 2011 (UTC) delete article lacks substance and fails Deletion of Kuttiyani St George Orthodox Church, Ranny WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16521 15225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ghat Pratighat User:Kolma8 08:10, 26 June 2021 (UTC) delete fails . Another poorly sourced without evidences of notability Deletion of Ghat Pratighat WP:NFILM||WP:2S Wikipedia:Notability 77
16522 14982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C.J. Rickard User:W 20:40, 31 May 2007 (UTC) delete """as once again i have to use the horrible phrase """"|non-notable murder victim"""". rest in peace|r.i.p""" Deletion of C.J. Rickard WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16523 3147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hilltop festival User:Coredesat 05:41, 3 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Hilltop festival WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16524 18262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ankit Love (2nd nomination) NONE NONE comment I'm going to assume that you agree Love is not notable as per the first three bullet points of my nomination (, , ) and assume that you're arguing for his notability based entirely on his claim as Emperor of Jammu and Kashmir. If that's the case, I'll put aside his involvement in the elections as that's not relevant to his claimed notability. With Zylinksi, you have entirely missed my point - he may qualify for an article but that notability would be independent from his electoral campaign - but again I'll |assume good faith and set aside the political line in favour of the royal line of enquiry that appears to be your argument here Deletion of Ankit Love (2nd nomination) WP:MUSICBIO||WP:DIRECTOR||WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GOODFAITH Wikipedia:Notability 77
16525 17026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Selby Whittingham [[User: Phoenix B 1of3|Phoenix B 1of3]] [[User talk: Phoenix B 1of3|(talk)]] 18:47, 28 October 2011 (UTC) keep """Heavily citated, descriptive, and long enough, I am ''""""pretty sure""""'' is met""" Deletion of Selby Whittingham WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16526 17961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marc Berris User:JayJasper 21:40, 24 August 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails . No evidence of significant coverage in |reliable independent sources Deletion of Marc Berris WP:BIO||WP:IRS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16527 12082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruurd Woltring User:SW3 16:35, 14 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Ruurd Woltring WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16528 17032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Super Strong Warner Siblings User:Sarilox 05:55, 10 January 2010 (UTC) delete Not |notable. No |reliable sources Deletion of Super Strong Warner Siblings WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16529 20524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IndiQube User:The 15:18, 31 July 2018 (UTC) delete per nomination. All that office space and yet no space in Wikipedia - that's a shame but subject fails . Who knows? Let's wish them Deletion of IndiQube WP:NCORP||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
16530 3023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tamko User:Otr500 14:20, 24 February 2019 (UTC) keep There is always the old |other stuff argument when that is not only generally a bad argument but not supported by any policies or guidelines. The company has been around a long time and even though likely rated outside the top ten (was #11) I can see some notability although a search seems to be more about the class action lawsuit. That is not abnormal as GAF, Owen Corning, Atlas, CertainTeed, IKO, and Globe Building Materials (probably others) along with Tamko, had these suits over roof failures (and fading), deceptive warranties, substandard roofing shingle manufacturing, false advertising, etc..., for fiberglass, organic, and asphalt shingles. My issue is that because a company has good advertising, as shown by mostly |primary sources, does not equate to notability regardless of how much we like it. Adding more primary sources to support notability does not make the case Deletion of Tamko WP:OTHER||WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16531 18345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ponder Stibbons User:McWomble 07:03, 19 November 2008 (UTC) comment """Ponder Stibbons and Harry Potter have similarities"""" and """"The creation of this device borrows heavily from the real world splitting of the atom"""" is original research. In any case the article is full of #PLOT|unnecessary plot details and there is no evidence of notability independent of the books""" Deletion of Ponder Stibbons WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16532 11858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gambo (carcass) User:Eggishorn 05:20, 9 December 2019 (UTC) delete None of the sources that have been removed are even remotely and no source suggested in the earlier AfD or this one have any hope of reversing that. There is no way this satisfies and the chances of it doing so in the future are remote Deletion of Gambo (carcass) WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16533 12089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norwegian C-130 Hercules accident User:Mentoz86 11:39, 17 March 2012 (UTC) keep clearly passes WP:GNG, and doesn't fails WP:NOTNEWS in my opinion. Major event in Scandinavia. Also think that this deletion-discussion should have been delayed a little, per , as the article already have evolved a lot since nomination, and when the deletion discussion ends in 6 days there will probably be a completely different article. The best thing would be to nominate this article in 14 days or a month, when the article have evolved even more and evolved away from a news story to a encyclopedic article Deletion of Norwegian C-130 Hercules accident WP:RAPID Wikipedia:Notability 77
16534 10720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C. R. Kesavan [[User talk:Sir Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington|Nearly Headless Nick]] [[Special:Contributions/Sir Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington|{c}]] 11:04, 17 March 2019 (UTC) delete fails and as there is no substantive coverage on the subject in multiple independent and reliable sources. |चाचा विधायक हैं हमारे is not a valid claim to notability Deletion of C. R. Kesavan WP:NPOL||WP:GNG||WP:INVALIDBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16535 9932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ASL Airlines Hungary Flight 7332 User:RoySmith 18:03, 13 August 2016 (UTC) delete both as , and because such events are neither particularly unusual, nor particularly interesting Deletion of ASL Airlines Hungary Flight 7332 WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16536 15364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deportation of Azerbaijanis from Armenia User:Peterkingiron 14:44, 23 July 2013 (UTC) keep This is far from an ideal article, in that it is written from the Azeri point of view. There have been similar expulsions in other directions. includinmg Armenians from Azerbaijan. I understood tha tthe ethnicity was Azeri and the nationality Azerbaijani. This suggests amending the ethnic description of non-Azerbaijani Azeris in the article. I would have preferred to have a general article on ethnic segregation in ther Caucasus, with articles on individual incidents on each of the periods of deportation, cvoering what all sides did. With the wealthy of sources, this cannot be called Deletion of Deportation of Azerbaijanis from Armenia WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16537 14466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mountain Biking on Mount Tamalpais User:John 16:08, 22 February 2007 (UTC) delete per , we're not a how-to guide. There is a section in the article on Mount Tamalpais about hiking and biking, and it's appropriate there (I'd argue) to provide a link to www.bicyclingwiki.com. (And if it's not appropriate as a footnote, it certainly should be okay as an external link.) —The preceding Wikipedia:Sign your posts on talk pages|unsigned comment was added by Deletion of Mountain Biking on Mount Tamalpais WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16538 13708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monday Night Football all-time team standings User:Lepricavark 05:28, 5 October 2016 (UTC) delete This is the very image of . I'm unpersuaded by Deletion of Monday Night Football all-time team standings WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16539 16337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Washington Metropolitan Association of Chinese Schools User:MacGyverMagic 09:43, 5 January 2009 (UTC) comment Notability shouldn't be questioned here. The nominator is questioning the article's |verifiability Deletion of Washington Metropolitan Association of Chinese Schools WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16540 9718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blackjack Parsons User:Icewedge 01:24, 23 December 2008 (UTC) delete insufficient reliable sources to demonstrate notability per the . None of the wrestling leagues he has worked with (Mississippi Valley Wrestling Alliance,International Pro Wrestling,IPW Home Video,Michiana Championship Wrestling,NWA Underground) have articles which suggests that they are relative minor and so he does not meet Deletion of Blackjack Parsons WP:GNG||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16541 12134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of corporations by market capitalization on 30th March 2007 User:GlassCobra 20:51, 8 July 2008 (UTC) delete per #LIST, as mentioned by WillOakland Deletion of List of corporations by market capitalization on 30th March 2007 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16542 14580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Powerglove (band) User:Wyatt 19:01, 22 May 2010 (UTC) keep Meets . Covered by Game Informerhttp://gameinformer.com/b/news/archive/2010/05/04/chatting-with-video-game-metal-band-powerglove.aspxhttp://gameinformer.com/blogs/editors/b/gitim_blog/archive/2009/09/30/now-you-re-playing-with-power-metal.aspx and G4http://g4tv.com/thefeed/blog/post/686773/Powerglove__Metal_Kombat_for_the_Mortal_Man_Review.html, both of which are on Wikipedia:WikiProject Video games/Sources|WikiProject Video games list of reliable sources. Toured the US and Canada 2 or 3 times. As the first VG music band signed to a real label, you could even make the claim that they're prominent representatives of the genre Deletion of Powerglove (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16543 3135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How Many Times (Can We Say Goodbye?) User:Esradekan 11:36, 3 April 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of How Many Times (Can We Say Goodbye?) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16544 11794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Ice User:Kerobaros 13:30, 20 January 2006 (UTC) keep He's a published author, as per Deletion of Thomas Ice WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16545 11310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of file verification software User:Mz7 19:01, 2 June 2020 (UTC) delete """This article is problematic for a few reasons. Firstly, as Praxidicae mentions, the overwhelming majority of the software listed in the article are not notable and |improperly include external links to places where you can purchase or download said software. As a result, this has made the page a very attractive target for |people who wish to promote a particular product. This, of course, is not a reason to delete the article in itself, since we could simply just clean up the article to remove any non-notable software. This leads me to the second issue. After reviewing the few entries on this list that ''are'' bluelinks to Wikipedia articles, I discovered that for several of the programs, """"file verification"""" is not their primary purpose: e.g. 7-Zip (file compression), TeraCopy (copying files between drives), Total Commander (file manager). As a result, it seems much of this list is a conglomeration of divergent pieces of software that just happen to have file verification as a side-feature, which makes this toe close to the line of . What's left are programs that are able to calculate cryptographic hashes or checksums as their primary purpose, e.g. md5deep, sha3sum, and cksum. However, I am skeptical that these relatively esoteric pieces of software are sufficient to sustain the notability of this kind of comparison article per """ Deletion of Comparison of file verification software WP:ELLIST||WP:SPAM||WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:LISTN Wikipedia:External links 76
16546 2494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Powers and abilities of Sabretooth and Wolverine (detailed) User:Anetode 14:49, 25 October 2005 (UTC) delete This edit war seems like an issue for rbCom Deletion of Powers and abilities of Sabretooth and Wolverine (detailed) WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
16547 12575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Margaret Stock User:Cullen328 04:18, 24 October 2016 (UTC) keep """Stock is notable as a recipient of a MacArthur Fellows Program|MacArthur Fellowship, a major award that includes a $625,000 prize. We already have biographies of a large majority of MacArthur Fellows. Accordingly, she meets which says that a person is notable if """"The person has received a well-known and significant award or honor, or has been nominated for one several times""" Deletion of Margaret Stock WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16548 2205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MSB FTW User:Irongargoyle 23:22, 5 September 2006 (UTC) delete Others may disagree, but I feel as though NN online forms fall under the ''groups'' section of |CSD A7 Deletion of MSB FTW WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
16549 2819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kwame Larry Tay User:AllyD 07:05, 15 October 2019 (UTC) delete Awards to graduating students are not inherently notable. Neither the reporting of these awards nor the subject's subsequent job demonstrate |notability Deletion of Kwame Larry Tay :WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16550 2909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Choi Kyu-Hwan User:GiantSnowman 14:35, 8 September 2009 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Choi Kyu-Hwan WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16551 8810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kish Family User:Dhartung 06:29, 25 January 2007 (UTC) delete NN family, written by a |single-purpose account thus likely Deletion of Kish Family WP:SPA||WP:COI Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
16552 12319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rimini Street (2nd nomination) User:Tony 18:01, 23 January 2006 (UTC) keep obviously. I wrote it myself so I know it isn't an ad. Even though this is an extremely new startup, it has already attracted enough ''independent'' media attention (including Forbes and eWeek) to satisfy , and numbers among its customers such heavy hitters as Toyota|Toyota Financial Services, the Blue Cross and Blue Shield Association, and Peregrine Systems. I'm shocked to see this renominated for no good reason Deletion of Rimini Street (2nd nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16553 120 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hüseyin İleri Kullanıcı:filancafilanca 11:44, 6 Aralık 2008 (UTC) delete Bunca tartışmaya rağmen kayda değerlikle ilgili kaynak bulunamadığına göre silinsin. Bu tür yeterli, yani 'de açıklanan şekilde, en az iki, tarafsız, muteber ve doğrudan bu kişiyi konu alan kaynak gösterilirse oyumu değiştirmeye hazırım. Yukarıdaki yoruma gelince: Silinmesi gereken çok sayıda madde olması, onlardan birinin silinmemesi için nasıl neden olabilir, bu nasıl bir mantıktır? Saygılar Hüseyin İleri'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
16554 10620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Freddy's Four Fingers User:Kafziel 19:00, 31 August 2006 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Freddy's Four Fingers WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16555 8225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dennis Steele (2nd nomination) User:Kuyabribri 16:11, 1 July 2011 (UTC) delete """Very little of what {{user|TR05401}} has said is valid rationale for deletion under the |deletion policy (full disclosure: in addition to opening this AfD on his behalf, I have responded to his requests for help that are directly related to this AfD). However, Steele ''does'' fail as an unelected candidate who received a whopping 0.80% of the vote (http://vermont-elections.org/elections1/2010GEOfficialFedStateResults11.09.pdf). As for the """"more than a dozen"""" news articles mentioning Steele, I skimmed all of the hits on that GNews search: the majority mention him only in passing in the context of discussing the two major party contenders in that governor's race, some sources do not mention him at all or are about the Vermont secession movement in general and not about Steele, one is about his fashion sense, and the one that is actually ''about'' Steele is an op-ed and therefore fails the |reliable source criterion. I do not believe that these sources are enough to get him over the |basic criteria of . If consensus is to delete, I would not be opposed to recreation as a redirect to Vermont gubernatorial election, 2010. &mdash""" Deletion of Dennis Steele (2nd nomination) WP:DP||WP:POLITICIAN||WP:RS||WP:BASIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
16556 7360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grupo Desportivo Águias de Camarate User:Serial 15:37, 4 September 2018 (UTC) delete """Since doesn't apply to teams (it's to individual players that playing at the national level equates to notability), applies, which relies upon in-depth and |persistent coverage in |reliable sources which is simply not available. This is not really a surprise: it is a local club with a stadium capacity of 1500. Yes, it makes claims as to various achievements, but they are not backed up with sources, and this is very much a case that """"|Any exceptional claim requires multiple high-quality sources""" Deletion of Grupo Desportivo Águias de Camarate WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG||WP:PERSISTENT||WP:RS||WP:EXTRAORDINARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16557 649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boguslaw Wozniak User:Bearcat 22:55, 14 March 2018 (UTC) delete """The """"inherent"""" notability of deputy heads of state attaches to the deputy heads of state of real established countries with real diplomatic recognition, not to the self-appointed governments of virtually unrecognized micronations whose ''only'' established diplomatic relationship is with one other unrecognized polity, and no |reliable source coverage has been shown to get him over as an individual in lieu""" Deletion of Boguslaw Wozniak WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16558 6509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bektour Iskender User:Sc 04:15, 29 September 2007 (UTC) delete Fails for Creative professionals Deletion of Bektour Iskender WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16559 20319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Deedler User:MelanieN 21:06, 2 September 2012 (UTC) delete """A long and distinguished career, but unfortunately, not meeting Wikipedia guidelines under ; I even considered without result. He gets a ton of hits at http://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=william+deedler&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8#q=william+deedler&hl=en&client=safari&rls=en&tbm=nws&prmd=imvnso&source=lnt&tbs=ar:1&sa=X&ei=JclDULGMOerKyQGaj4CwDA&ved=0CCAQpwUoBQ&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.&fp=9e12cb5ef80bf93f&biw=1079&bih=595 Google News Archive, but none of them are ABOUT him, they are QUOTING him (""""...according to Bill Deedler, meteorologist with the National Weather Service...""""). I was unable to think of a suitable redirect target""" Deletion of William Deedler WP:GNG||WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16560 819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/For Badgeholders Only User:Artyline 00:25, 27 June 2009 (UTC) delete Fails , non notable bootleg Deletion of For Badgeholders Only WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16561 11810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anime World Network User:PaintedCarpet 14:46, 20 June 2014 (UTC) delete I haven't been able to find any sources that would satisfy Deletion of Anime World Network WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16562 9376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rew User:Encephalon 09:35, 15 November 2005 (UTC) delete This qualifies under |G3. See also silly or joke vandalism under Deletion of Rew WP:CSD||WP:VAND Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
16563 9237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Carl User:Rorshacma 17:14, 2 May 2012 (UTC) delete """a thus far unnotable actor, as his credits would indicate that he's pretty much only appeared in bit parts and as an extra. His one """"lead"""" role in a PSA still doesn't let him pass """ Deletion of Nick Carl WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16564 19346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blame Israel first User:Gatoclass 05:33, 27 January 2011 (UTC) delete classic , additionally much of the content appears barely relevant to the purported topic Deletion of Blame Israel first WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
16565 12087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Romney User:Dhartung 08:18, 28 February 2008 (UTC) merge Being a candidate for office is not enough for , and being a son of a presidential candidate is somewhat less notable than being a son of a President, which itself is not inherently notable. At this point there is little coverage of him that is independent of his father Deletion of Josh Romney WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16566 21605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jake Goodman (footballer) User:ArsenalFan700 20:20, 12 January 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Jake Goodman (footballer) WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16567 6156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robin des Champs User:PohranicniStraze 18:56, 4 December 2018 (UTC) delete per nom; notability is |not inherited from the horse's progeny, and it doesn't appear to meet notability criteria on its own merits Deletion of Robin des Champs WP:NOTINHERIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16568 3293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Goldtec User:Northamerica1000 00:37, 21 July 2013 (UTC) delete I've nominated this article for speedy deletion (which is allowed even when an article is at AfD), because the text on the page (except for the infobox, section titles, refs and external links sections) is entirely a |copyright violation of http://mysterglas.wix.com/goldtec-technologies Deletion of Goldtec WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
16569 19288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cleo (film) (2nd nomination) User:Ryan 18:08, 11 December 2011 (UTC) delete This fails due to . There are no sources for this article. I don't know what the last article looked like but this might be able to be speedy deleted under CSD G4 Deletion of Cleo (film) (2nd nomination) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16570 3522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willowbrook Mall (Wayne, New Jersey) User:Alansohn 22:24, 23 July 2006 (UTC) keep at 1.5 million sq. ft. of selling area, it's the second largest mall in the state (not minor) and one of the earliest fully-enclosed large scale malls (notable). Article meets , without any explanation of what criteria are not being met Deletion of Willowbrook Mall (Wayne, New Jersey) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16571 21955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanjeevan Gurung User:StAnselm 20:46, 7 July 2016 (UTC) delete clearly fails Deletion of Sanjeevan Gurung WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16572 16893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mar Kuriakose Dayara User:Rjd0060 05:47, 22 October 2007 (UTC) comment It seems to be better now that it is rewritten, but I am not aware if WP has any guidelines for churches, etc. or if it would just fall under Deletion of Mar Kuriakose Dayara WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16573 1912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keyur Parikh User:JJL 00:36, 6 August 2009 (UTC) keep borderline notability (based principally on )--err on the side of retaining info Deletion of Keyur Parikh WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16574 102 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ali Haydar Kaytan Kullanıcı:ahmet turhanahmet turhan 09:22, 29 Eylül 2016 (UTC) comment """Sizce terörist, bence değil, başkasına göre kararsız. Başka bir kullanıcı için, başka bir şahıs terörist değil, bence terörist, diğer kişiler değil vb. Bu söylemler bu sayfadaki tartışmaya ne katacak? Bir kişiyi terörist olarak görmek vicdan rahatlatmak dışında buradaki konuya ne katacak? Hiçbir şey. Vikipedi bunlarla ilgilenmiyor çünkü. Bu tür bir üsluba birisi """"hayır bence terörist değil"""" yanıtı verse, hemen konu """"aa nasıl değil, bak şöyle şöyle.."""" diye konu hemen kişi yargılamaya gidecek. Belki de amaç budur bilinmez ama, konu KD ve SAS olduğundan bu tartışma son derece anlamsız. ''Not: Ayrıca Cemil Bayık maddesinde terörist yazmıyor, """"T.C İçişleri bakanlığının yayınladığı en çok aranan listesinde bulunuyor."""" yazıyor. Terörist sıfatını herhangi bir kişiye Vipikedi verseydi derhal kaldırılırdı. """"-e göre"""" ifadesi geçerli. Vikipedi buna taraf değil, ya da T.C. de yaşayan veya yaşamayan kişiler de buna taraf olmayabilir, bunu bilemeyiz. Bakınız: """ Ali Haydar Kaytan'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:MİLLİ Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16575 21796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of Maryland Route 200 User:Rschen7754 06:05, 17 March 2011 (UTC) keep """This article was created when applying on July 23, 2009. Recently, I attempted to improve the article by added a proper lead, adding a construction history section and conformed to by repeating the lead as the """"History"""" section of Maryland Route 200. I then nominated the article for GA, which drew the wrath of""" Deletion of History of Maryland Route 200 WP:SPLIT||WP:SS Wikipedia:Splitting 57
16576 1997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nickelodeon Original Movies User:Jayron32 05:26, 1 November 2007 (UTC) keep meets requirements of guideline. I see no reason to delete beyond , which isn't really a valid, guideline-based or policy-based reason Deletion of Nickelodeon Original Movies WP:LIST||WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Lists 97
16577 11981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CreativeTrack User:Stifle 12:38, 7 January 2006 (UTC) delete advert and proper capitalization thing mentioned by Deletion of CreativeTrack WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
16578 19238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephanie sarkis User:Eric 01:58, 7 January 2009 (UTC) delete Could not find enough to establish notability under . Does not seem to pass either. The claim that her views on ADHD caused controversy lacks , unless we are talking about http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Stephanie+Sarkis%22+ADHD&btnG=Search+Archives&hl=en&ned=us&ie=UTF-8 very minor controversy. The book ''10 simple solutions to adult ADD'' is in 265 libraries worldwide; I would expect more holdings for a keep recommendation Deletion of Stephanie sarkis WP:PROF||WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
16579 10344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leo (mobile suit) User:Mythsearcher 07:51, 18 February 2008 (UTC) comment a game that features units from multiple anime, games and manga with a mecha encyclopedia that states the origin of each unit is secondary. The secondary part comes from the fact that it states the origin of the unit from an out of game perspective, like in this case, the entry of the this Leo unit states that its appearance is from ''Mobile Suit Gundam Wing''. Also, it is by Banpresto, not Sunrise. They need to get copyright permissions from other companies to add units into the game. MAHQ is always quoted as not being a |reliable source since it is a fan site, although the same info could be sourced from primary sources like the official web site and MS encyclopedia, somehow people still don't take MAHQ as a Deletion of Leo (mobile suit) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16580 21918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rationale to impeach George W. Bush User:Merecat 02:12, 31 March 2006 (UTC) delete """Look at this link http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Kevin_Baas&diff=43280531&oldid=39252196 for a snapshot of an anti-Bush editor's user page. Note this quote on that page '''""""Based on these arguments Rationale to impeach George W. Bush was made. Feel free to improve that article with the following suggestions""""'''. This article is an aggregate of the personal opinions of a small group of anti-Bush editors who spend too much time reading the Democratic Underground. What makes this an |Original Research violation is that the logical flow of the article, as laid out, is a dynamic bullet list of every complaint by make by whomever anywhere, yet organized here by a few zealots so as to appear that there is some cohesive movement against Bush '''for these particular reasons - as they appear here'''. I suggest that there is '''not one''' anti-Bush group in the USA to which we can point, that is citing these reasons - as presented here - as their basis of attack on Bush. This article is a speculative POV rant and an anti-Bush screed. People who want to write articles like this, ought to start their own newspaper, because this is not an encyclopedia article, it's yellow journalism. And it's a boring, offensive and inaccurate read to boot""" Deletion of Rationale to impeach George W. Bush WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16581 11897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebecca Spelman NONE NONE delete per . The fact that the subject appeared on a show does not overcome the lack of independent sources that discuss the subject directly and in detail. If the article is purged from the content, there won't be much left. Sample Deletion of Rebecca Spelman WP:TOOSOON||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16582 5121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dilip Sapkota User:GPL93 17:31, 24 March 2020 (UTC) delete clear fail. Best Deletion of Dilip Sapkota WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16583 4867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Waqar Ali Khan User:FreeRangeFrog 18:59, 16 January 2013 (UTC) delete Seems to fail and a redirect is impossible since the show's article does not exist. I am seeing a lot of social media cruft but no substantive coverage, although as usual this might be a language issue Deletion of Waqar Ali Khan WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16584 4210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unpowered aircraft User:Atmoz 21:56, 15 January 2009 (UTC) keep The Unpowered aircraft article is older than the Glider article. If anything, the Glider article is the . The two should probably be merged, but that's not an AfD issue Deletion of Unpowered aircraft WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
16585 10120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NukeWatch User:Niteshift36 05:10, 4 July 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of NukeWatch WP:CLUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16586 1341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wakefield High School (Raleigh, North Carolina) User:TerriersFan 19:26, 10 October 2008 (UTC) keep high school for which sources are available to meet Deletion of Wakefield High School (Raleigh, North Carolina) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16587 7708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Beatnigs User:Realkyhick 20:45, 5 March 2008 (UTC) delete fails . Could make a redirect to existing section in Franti's article Deletion of The Beatnigs WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16588 7881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of NFL on Fox commentator pairings User:Paulmcdonald 14:34, 1 November 2019 (UTC) delete """There's a possibility that the list might actually pass somewhat as different parings are discussed but I doubt that """"all"""" pairings are discussed. I'm going to the """"common sense"""" argument here and going with |ignore all rules and state that deletion of this list makes Wikipedia better""" Deletion of List of NFL on Fox commentator pairings WP:GNG||WP:IAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16589 2203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Love Hina plot summaries User:Jay32183 00:34, 30 June 2007 (UTC) delete Article is just plot summaries, fails #PLOT Deletion of Love Hina plot summaries WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16590 5913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Miller (actor) User:Ad 20:34, 15 April 2014 (UTC) keep Subject meets . The article is in bad need of RS references though and I have tagged it accordingly Deletion of Nick Miller (actor) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16591 12701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VF2509 User:Bejnar 01:46, 8 July 2017 (UTC) delete one primary source and a directory listing do not grant notability. Fails Deletion of VF2509 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16592 7516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pune Institute of Business Management User:Adamant1 06:56, 9 May 2021 (UTC) delete Sure, there's a few articles out there about extremely trivial topics that mention the place in passing. There's nothing from what I can tell that addresses it directly and in-depth or isn't about other things that are only slightly related though. So, I'm not seeing the necessary sourcing needed to keep the article. Notability isn't just the number of Google News hits. I'm more then willing to change my vote to keep if someone can provide good sources though Deletion of Pune Institute of Business Management WP:THREE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16593 7130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hansen Gress Corporation User:Coredesat 13:34, 26 June 2006 (UTC) delete ad, fails Deletion of Hansen Gress Corporation WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16594 3178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mercedes Benz SA codes User:Gnfnrf 18:04, 30 September 2008 (UTC) delete as only useful in the context of a how-to guide, and therefore per #HOWTO Deletion of Mercedes Benz SA codes WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16595 11709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hellmouth (band) User:Gongshow NONE keep This band meets criterion 1 of , with non-trivial coverage in the Metro Timeshttp://metrotimes.com/archives/review.asp?rid=24985, Alternative Press (music magazine)|Alternative Presshttp://www.altpress.net/lowprofiles/hellmouth.htm, and Sputnikmusichttp://www.sputnikmusic.com/album.php?albumid=34851 Deletion of Hellmouth (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16596 9037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick D. Kim [[user talk:Altenmann|>t]] 16:12, 7 July 2009 (UTC) keep """how about the the most basic rule of wikipedia: |verifiablity? """"I saw it somewhere"""" is not an argument. Where is the scholarly/critical discussion that he is a notable cartoonist? - Altenmann""" Deletion of Nick D. Kim WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16597 13070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pour over User:BigDT 01:50, 31 May 2006 (UTC) delete non-notable |neologism Deletion of Pour over WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
16598 393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corey Boudreaux User:Seasider91 18:41, 19 July 2012 (UTC) delete Not notable and fails Deletion of Corey Boudreaux WP:ATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
16599 1921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nothing's How It Used To Be User:DESiegel 17:17, 12 February 2010 (UTC) delete as per my own nomination above '''unless''' sources are presented that establish the notability of this single, in accord with or the . If sources that I failed to find are presented, and they clearly establish notability, i would withdraw this nomination, as notability is the only issue here in my view Deletion of Nothing's How It Used To Be WP:MUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16600 445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coptic Soldier [[user talk:Javert|'''stargaze''']] 22:08, 2 August 2009 (UTC) delete Fails . Non-notable band. →'''javért Deletion of Coptic Soldier WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16601 3168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boyd Crowder User:Shooterwalker 14:54, 25 July 2010 (UTC) merge could not of this topic but I am ok with a merge as a compromise. Would a non-admin closure be fine in this case since the nominator is also ready to merge Deletion of Boyd Crowder WP:VERIFYNOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16602 11474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aisha Chaudhary User:DiamondRemley39 15:25, 5 July 2020 (UTC) keep """as it clearly meets . """"The person has created or played a major role in co-creating a significant or well-known work or collective body of work. In addition, such work must have been the primary subject of an independent and notable work (for example, a book, film..."""". She wrote the book. She is depicted in the film based on her book. Easy keep. The (IP) nominator may not be familiar with the notability standard and creative professions, so I won't chew 'em out, but they may want to spend a bit more time watching other AfDs before nominating other articles""" Deletion of Aisha Chaudhary WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16603 17106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Younessi User:BrownHairedGirl 20:52, 24 October 2006 (UTC) delete per above, as copvio; also fails Deletion of James Younessi WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16604 9113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave Wride User:Hello32020 13:13, 10 December 2006 (UTC) delete due to failing and Deletion of Dave Wride WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16605 7476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cooper (company) User:SoWhy 09:27, 6 July 2017 (UTC) merge to Alan Cooper. If he is notable and the company isn't, merging is the right way to go per . Regards Deletion of Cooper (company) WP:FAILCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16606 478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krabi International School User:Atlantic306 23:59, 4 October 2016 (UTC) keep minimal article and cites needed but degree issuing schools are usually kept as per Deletion of Krabi International School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
16607 14225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ty Brenneman User:onel5969 13:48, 22 November 2015 (UTC) delete clearly does not meet , and searches did not turn up enough to show they meet Deletion of Ty Brenneman WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16608 6821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khakan Sajid User:Bearian 02:34, 15 April 2018 (UTC) delete The |sourcing is horrifically bad: Facebook, commcerial imprints, and a single listing in a single minor library website Deletion of Khakan Sajid WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16609 2230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yoni Sherbatov User:24 NONE keep In reference to other previous comments, I have reviewed the page from a professional standpoint. The page for Yoni Sherbatov is very well written and the facts being presented within it are well referenced also. I do read and understand that he does not meet these certain requirements. He is a well known within the MMA and boxing community as a well respected fighter. I think that there should be a mid-level category for fighters that arent at the top elite status. As to appreciate all fighters at different points within their fighting status. I think many other people would benefit from these changes being made too. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Yoni Sherbatov WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
16610 16954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WebAPP User:Flakeloaf 15:57, 19 January 2007 (UTC) comment Now would be a good time to consult as well Deletion of WebAPP WP:SOCK||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
16611 5357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of programs broadcast by Cartoonito User:TimothyBlue 13:57, 6 November 2020 (UTC) merge per above and nom as an // Deletion of List of programs broadcast by Cartoonito WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
16612 1884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/McMillan Fire User:Coolabahapple 12:06, 28 June 2019 (UTC) delete does not meet , also, Deletion of McMillan Fire WP:EVENT||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16613 8741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S. Indika User:J947 22:42, 6 October 2017 (UTC) delete Per Wikipedia:Village_pump_(policy)/Archive_135#The_criteria_of_SPORT_here_are_too_inclusive|this discussion, subject-specific |notability guidelines do not supersede the |general notability guideline, except in clear cases where |GNG does not apply to. ''As it is the single most recent consensus on the notability of sport bios'', I feel obliged to go with the result of the discussion: '''NSPORTS does not supersede GNG'''. This really does need to be reflected on sport guideline pages, though, as this can seriously mislead people. The 'weak' is rather because that closure has not been linked or obeyed much, and is not in common use. Also, I will note that less coverage has to be applied for this article to be considered notable Deletion of S. Indika WP:N||WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16614 7960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juliusz Brzezinski User:Xxanthippe 11:12, 31 December 2019 (UTC) delete Fails rof Deletion of Juliusz Brzezinski WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
16615 20279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heart in Hand (band) User:Gongshow 05:07, 18 September 2012 (UTC) delete this along with the album ''Only Memories'' (which had been redirected to the band's page). I'm unable to find sufficient coverage to demonstrate that the group satisfies or at this time Deletion of Heart in Hand (band) WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16616 5170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hum Hai Teen Khurafaati User:Mr 00:20, 26 March 2018 (UTC) delete I could only find passing by mentions, nothing that indicates significance or meets Deletion of Hum Hai Teen Khurafaati WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
16617 18977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Pennsylvania locations by per capita income User:Ajf773 19:00, 3 March 2020 (UTC) delete Completely unsourced and Deletion of List of Pennsylvania locations by per capita income WP:RAWDATA Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16618 12372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mama grizzly User:Patsw 01:51, 6 October 2010 (UTC) comment If there's a political significance to Angry hornet (politics)|Angry hornet or Busy beaver (politics)|Busy beaver that can be defined, summarized and cited, |go for it! Obscure political expressions like Locofocos and the more recent Blue Dog Coalition|Blue dog have articles. (Is this my fifth example Deletion of Mama grizzly WP:SOFIXIT Wikipedia:Be bold 9
16619 15411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sava Dumitrescu User:Nihola 21:10, 8 March 2011 (UTC) keep per . I added the above refs as well as three others Deletion of Sava Dumitrescu WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16620 15337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mars Initiative User:PianoDan 15:55, 14 April 2015 (UTC) delete Does not appear to get past Deletion of Mars Initiative WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16621 9096 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jnan Pujari User:Path 08:28, 13 September 2019 (UTC) keep Definitely pass (criteria 1:-'''The person has received a well-known and significant award or honor, or has been nominated for such an award several times.'''), since the person achieved a Sahithya Akademy award (one of the prominent award on literature in India Deletion of Jnan Pujari WP:ANYBIO||WP:NWRITER Wikipedia:Notability 77
16622 232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James W. Sperman User:Pan 14:09, 12 June 2007 (UTC) comment No one recommending deletion has addressed the central question of whether Sperman's restaurant is |notable Deletion of James W. Sperman WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16623 5157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vinod Jose [[User talk:210.7.71.114|talk]]) 09:47, 21 May 2013 (UTC) delete """Seems at present the claim to notability rests on awards. Which aren't really that. Since one is a single """"honourable mention"""" among many and one is a scholarship. The only remaining thing, therefore, is one award from the Asia Society of New york. In any case, and most importantly, a random award is explicitly not part of . There are dozens of journalism prizes out there, and that's why it isn't considered notable if you win one unless the prize itself is notable, like the Pulitzer. The """"secondary"""" sources mentioned discuss individual stories and consist mainly of blog roundups of notable stories of that period. So that isn't useful either. Essentially, it is difficult to find any journalist of any experience who has written one or two stories about which an analogous article could not be written. Which is why this needs to be deleted. Special:Contributions/210.7.71.114|210.7.71.114""" Deletion of Vinod Jose WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16624 8504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hello Internet (2nd nomination) User:Cerebral726 14:56, 3 November 2020 (UTC) keep """I see some of your arguments, but I believe there is enough coverage in the listed sources. As a note, thought it doesn't establish notability by itself, Hello Internet is constantly mentioned in lists of notable podcasts worth listening to like https://www.techtimes.com/articles/72271/20150728/internet-stars-podcasts.htm these. There is also a (admittedly somewhat weak) argument to made with 's second criteria: the podcast was named to iTunes """"Best New Podcasts of 2014"""" list""" Deletion of Hello Internet (2nd nomination) WP:WEBCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16625 7355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexis Gharibian User:Fenix 13:08, 8 September 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Alexis Gharibian WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16626 10727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Roccato User:AnmaFinotera 05:28, 2 June 2010 (UTC) delete Unnotable local figure - if the only coverage is local, that isn't significant press coverage for meeting , in general, nor Deletion of Daniel Roccato WP:POLITICIAN||WP:BIO||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16627 609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Page (MCC cricketer) (2nd nomination) User:Joseph2302 17:09, 18 December 2018 (UTC) delete as per nom, not played in a FC match. And fails as well Deletion of Page (MCC cricketer) (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16628 17591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guantánamo: America's War on Human Rights User:Padenton 06:35, 15 May 2015 (UTC) delete """If someone wants to dig up more sources, go for it, because I can't find any. As of now, this is a clear failure of . The only source that actually covers the book is the New Zealand Herald article. Even if we ignore the problems stated by {{u|VMS Mosaic}}, that's only one source, while BKCRIT says """"The book has been the subject1 of two or more non-trivial2 published works appearing in sources that are independent of the book itself"""". The Guardian article is written by the author and the WNYC link is a radio show where the author was a guest. I can't find any mention of it at the Amnesty USA page. ― """ Deletion of Guantánamo: America's War on Human Rights WP:BKCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16629 14343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rosalie Cadron-Jetté User:Raaggio 05:29, 8 April 2010 (UTC) delete as nominator. Per , I searched on Bing and the topic came up with a little more than 100 hits. (http://www.bing.com/search?q=%22Rosalie+Cadron-Jetté%22&go=&form=QBLH&qs=n&sk=). Therefore, I assumed the topic was not that noteworthy. But in reality, I nominated the article for AfD because the article has absolutely not one reference to source the prose nor to prove notability. After further research, she has a certain popularity, but I still believe she isn't notable enough for an article (however, her organization might be notable enough). However, because of the few links on the internet, I doubt reliable sources would be easy to obtain Deletion of Rosalie Cadron-Jetté WP:SET Wikipedia:Search engine test 38
16630 9772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sonny Milano [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 16:12, 30 April 2014 (UTC) delete Fails NHOCKEY and GNG. May become notable but right now it's . Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Sonny Milano WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16631 13648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss Elite Cosmopolitan World User:TheSandDoctor 22:14, 15 March 2018 (UTC) delete as it does appear to be a |hoax per the nominator (and my own) assessment Deletion of Miss Elite Cosmopolitan World WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
16632 20550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barbara Mamabolo User:Pburka 15:24, 14 July 2012 (UTC) keep per persistent news coverage in multiple languages. Also notable per as her eponymous band has toured nationally with Men Without Hats and performed at major festivals (NXNE, Montreal Jazz Festival Deletion of Barbara Mamabolo WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16633 21345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Introduction to the metric system [[User talk:Lambiam|Lambiam]] 22:04, 11 October 2011 (UTC) keep """This is not a """"simple case"""". The metric system is a subject that is known to have stymied generations of students in non-metric countries. This article is an honest attempt to present an accessible, non-technical introduction to the subject. In that sense it is not essentially different from Introduction to M-theory, Introduction to entropy, Introduction to evolution, Introduction to viruses, and many other """"Introduction to ..."""" articles. Yes, in a sense they are |article forks, but not all forks are evil. fork|POV forks should be deleted; they are an attempt to get around our WP:neutral point of view|neutral point of view policy, but that is not the case here. And forks that (usually unintentionally) simply duplicate existing articles should be merged and redirected. But this is obviously not a simple duplication. """ Deletion of Introduction to the metric system WP:POV||WP:article fork Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
16634 18581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Rupp Award User:GauchoDude 20:38, 23 January 2017 (UTC) delete While logically it seems like it should have an article, I cannot find any sourcing to justify my own opinion and therefore must choose to delete per Deletion of Scott Rupp Award WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16635 11986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Tubiolo User:Bearian 19:45, 23 October 2020 (UTC) keep per . Local politicians are not normally notable, but this is a rare exception. He's gotten considerable coverage |not for a single event but for two: his registration change and his Covid-19 diagnosis. |FWIW, he's the local legislator for an older brother of mine and they're acquainted, although I don't know the subject Deletion of David Tubiolo WP:SIGCOV||WP:BLP1E||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
16636 3740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abigail Spanberger User:Bearcat 18:17, 21 July 2018 (UTC) merge """This is not showing the depth of coverage it takes to make a candidate notable just for being a candidate — that requires coverage that explodes to Christine O'Donnell proportions, and is not instantly passed by every candidate the moment one extralocal media outlet ''mentions'' her name — every single candidate who runs ''at all'' is ''always'' going to have her name ''mentioned'' in national media at least once or twice. Appearing on TV as an interview guest is not support for notability either, as that makes her the ''speaker'' and not the ''subject''. Wikipedia's notability test is not """"has she been in the news lately"""", it is """"has she been in the news for reasons that would pass the |ten-year test for enduring significance"""" — the notability test is showing evidence that people will ''still'' be looking for this article in ''2028'' because she accomplished something, like ''winning'' the election and thereby ''holding'' office, that makes her ''permanently'' notable. Having an article about every single person whose name happens to get into the news cycle is ''not'' what we're here for, and the volume of coverage actually being shown here is ''not'' enough to make her a special case over and above most other candidates in most other districts who are also getting their names into the news cycle right now""" Deletion of Abigail Spanberger WP:10YT Wikipedia:Recentism 10
16637 6270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015–16 Gretna 2008 F.C. season User:Jmorrison230582 09:07, 26 August 2015 (UTC) delete WP:NOTSTATS, - I can't see how you could create a season article about a Scottish club outside the Scottish Professional Football League that would satisfy . Non-league clubs only normally get coverage from the local paper (if that), with some (Scottish) national coverage if they progress in the Scottish Cup to play league teams Deletion of 2015–16 Gretna 2008 F.C. season WP:NSEASONS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16638 5115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KBIT FM User:Avraham 04:50, 9 July 2006 (UTC) delete Unfortunately, Hoax is NOT a speedy criterion, neither is . Please see #Non-criteria, but as it doesn't exist here http://www.officialusa.com/stateguides/media/radiostations/california.html it should be tossed with extreme prejiduce Deletion of KBIT FM WP:OR||WP:CSD Wikipedia:No original research 65
16639 140 [[German Goo Girls]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Andy king50 NONE keep """Nach /29._M%C3%A4rz_2006#German_Goo_Girls_.28Bleibt.29 unzulässiger Wiederhol-LA, bei >1 Mio. Googletreffer liegt Relevanz zudem nahe. """"Pfui"""" ist kein Grund für Irrelevanz""" Löschung von German Goo Girls Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16640 21478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/We are the 99% User:Sergecross73 13:44, 13 October 2011 (UTC) keep Plenty of third party coverage from |reliable sources. Seems to be similar, yet separate, from OWS Deletion of We are the 99% WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16641 21864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jake Felton (author) User:DUBJAY04 17:17, 8 February 2007 (UTC) delete per | Everyone Deletion of Jake Felton (author) WP:CON Wikipedia:Consensus 78
16642 6894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marion Foster Welch User:Unscintillating 02:53, 8 January 2017 (UTC) keep """nbsp; Wikipedia's notability is defined as being that the topic is """"worthy of notice"""". That's it. The WP:N nutshell explains that notability is understood as that the topic attracts attention from the world at large over a period of time. https://books.google.com/books?id=qfnkcWmDdDQC&lpg=PA100&ots=0FwBdFML0g&dq=%22stephen%20foster%20memorial%22%20welch&pg=PA100#v=onepage&q=%22stephen%20foster%20memorial%22%20welch&f=false This source shows the topic receiving attention in an event with 50,000 people.I had the occasion to read a 2007 version of eletion policy, and it says, """"The deletion processes all focus on whether an article meets the criteria for existence on Wikipedia; that is, they are to determine whether it is not original research, its central information is verifiable, and it is capable of achieving a neutral point of view with good editorship."""" It should be quickly apparent from this 2007 concept as applied to the discussion here to focus on the idea of original research. Is """"Marion Foster Welch"""" the construction of multiple small pieces of evidence that don't quite fit together? I'm not buying it.As for verifiability, does anyone doubt that the scholarship here is sound? I think we are comfortable that this is not a controversial topic that will require attention to keeping a neutral view. """ Deletion of Marion Foster Welch WP:D Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
16643 12566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled Second Album User:TenPoundHammer 01:56, 2 October 2008 (UTC) delete No sources at all, Deletion of Untitled Second Album WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
16644 12496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ihsan Khan (2nd nomination) User:PohranicniStraze 15:01, 10 July 2017 (UTC) delete As it stands, the article is pretty weak. The references are pretty lousy, the office held is not enough to pass , and the allegations of vote-buying need to be very reliably sourced or removed to meet . That said, it sounds like there '''could''' be a decent article to be had, since the story overall (Pakistani expat cabbie wins millions, returns to start political career, helps out in the aftermath of horrible disaster, etc.) is unique enough to be worth documenting Deletion of Ihsan Khan (2nd nomination) WP:NPOL||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16645 284 [[Alexander Klenke]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Bujo NONE delete Der Artikel verletzt Alexander K.s Persönlichkeitsrecht. Alle relevanten Quellen beziehen sich lediglich auf den Tatverdacht Alexander K.s als Totschläger. Als Hobby-Rapmusiker ohne Plattenlabel und gelegentlicher Laiendarsteller im Fernsehen ist er keine Person des öffentlichen Lebens. Wäre er nicht verhaftet worden, hätten auch keine zuverlässigen Quellen über seine Aktivität als Rapper, Rechtsextremist und Fernsehdarsteller berichtet. Diese schreiben zudem nicht seinen Nachnamen aus. Übrig wären nur sein youtube-Kanal, seine private Website und sein Gästebucheintrag, die keine zuverlässigen Belege im Sinne der Wikipedia-Richtlinien sind. Relevant ist er nur als Totschlag-Verdächtiger. Und #Straftaten legt uns da strenge Grenzen auf, umso mehr, da Alexander K. bloß ''Tatverdächtiger'' und nicht rechtskräftig verurteilt ist. Selbst im Falle einer Verurteilung wäre es im Sinne der Resozialisierung abzulehnen, einen Artikel über den Täter mit Klarnamen zu veröffentlichen Löschung von Alexander Klenke Wikipedia:Artikel über lebende Personen Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16646 14920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anal Cunt User:Ac 08:42, 17 May 2006 (UTC) keep per above - dreadful band but a clear pass Deletion of Anal Cunt WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16647 18618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Carmichael (politician) User:209 14:56, 18 December 2005 (UTC) delete Candidates do not merit articles unless notable for other reasons. I also disagree with the notion that major party candidates for national office satisfy by being of interest to the voters of that riding Deletion of John Carmichael (politician) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16648 12999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rick Worman User:Lepricavark 11:17, 3 August 2016 (UTC) keep article passes . Furthermore, I found several sources quite easily: http://montrealgazette.com/sports/football/alouettes-fire-offensive-coordinator-rick-worman, http://www.milb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20150914&content_id=149313644&fext=.jsp&vkey=news_t545, http://www.cfl.ca/2014/06/09/quick-exit-alouettes-part-ways-with-worman/, http://lametropolesports.com/2014/06/10/montreal-alouettes-fire-offensive-coordinator-first-pre-season-game/, and http://www.torontosun.com/2012/04/30/former-qb-joins-ottawa-cfl-teams-staff Deletion of Rick Worman WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
16649 20349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people who have been pied (2nd nomination) User:Cirt 19:21, 1 May 2008 (UTC) keep An interesting list, populated with notable individuals and with information sourced to / secondary sources. Most useful on Wikipedia Deletion of List of people who have been pied (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16650 16793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007 French coach crash User:Arkyan 19:16, 21 March 2007 (UTC) delete This is a prime example of why is an often disputed guideline - for while it may technically satisfy N, only a few months later and people are scratching their heads trying to figure out what it is Deletion of 2007 French coach crash WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16651 16454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Guerra User:Rlendog 16:18, 23 January 2012 (UTC) delete Per nom and prod reason. Federal Hockey League doesn't qualify for presumed notability and don't see any other reason why he would meet Deletion of Michael Guerra WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16652 19306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Tesco Extra Stores User:Jayden54 14:29, 4 January 2007 (UTC) delete per #DIRECTORY|Wikipedia is not a directory, and the above comments Deletion of List of Tesco Extra Stores WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16653 15813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sales Graphics User:Yeeno 20:43, 7 July 2021 (UTC) delete per above. No notability is demonstrated in both articles, and both subjects lack from what I could find. Awards don't seem significant either Deletion of Sales Graphics WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
16654 12233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Financial Coach User:Ammarpad 11:39, 28 October 2017 (UTC) keep actually there is good references in the article and it carries meaningful content, concerns like can be addressed by tag and cleanup since the subject passess notability Deletion of Financial Coach WP:NOTADVOCACY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16655 3741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suvra Mukherjee User:Chris 10:21, 19 October 2015 (UTC) delete Questionable notability. Without more sources I don't think this passes Deletion of Suvra Mukherjee WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16656 17421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shere Khan A Cappella User:ErikTheBikeMan 18:58, 22 March 2009 (UTC) delete Fails . Non-notable, however, I would reconsider if more sources were added Deletion of Shere Khan A Cappella WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16657 8210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Opinions That DL Had User:James500 07:06, 28 July 2018 (UTC) keep per Mortee. Satisfies criteria 5 of the guideline . The author, José Saramago, won a nobel prize for literature (and other important awards Deletion of Opinions That DL Had WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
16658 18527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrian Davis (rugby league) User:Doctorhawkes 21:44, 10 February 2016 (UTC) keep Clearly fails , but a surprising amount of coverage meets GNG Deletion of Adrian Davis (rugby league) WP:RLN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16659 7957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alison Tan User:Kudpung 05:01, 12 July 2017 (UTC) delete The only thing Tan is known for is being the wife of a New York State Assemblyman. Notability is not inherited and a plethora of sources sill does not endorse notability where no genuine claims to significance or importance exits. Fails and IMO is clearly promotional in a run up to a forthcoming election Deletion of Alison Tan WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16660 12597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wil Emling User:Pharaoh 11:28, 18 September 2014 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Wil Emling WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16661 4083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Mario characters in other media User:Jakew 16:22, 17 May 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and , as it entirely lacks secondary sources (and sometimes even primary sources). Also, although the list may have defined inclusion criteria, there are a potentially infinite number of lists with defined inclusion criteria, and we have to consider whether the inclusion criteria are in fact meaningful and notable. In my view, this is merely a compilation of trivia. Hence, in my view, the page as a whole fails Deletion of List of Mario characters in other media WP:V||WP:PSTS||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16662 16965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liam Kerrigan User:Jimbo 07:22, 8 September 2008 (UTC) comment you do realise players actually have to play to pass the criteria of Deletion of Liam Kerrigan WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16663 1563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Black Water Society User:EditorE 00:06, 26 March 2016 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a or advertising. I couldn't find a single source even mentioning this book, either that or its WP:TOOSOON, as mentioned above Deletion of The Black Water Society WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16664 11117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robin J. Elliott User:AllyD 08:50, 15 February 2018 (UTC) delete An article with a history of accounts alternately adding and removing material about particular financial ventures which the subject may have promoted. But I am not seeing a substantial claim to notability, not evidence. The ''Canadian Business'' article may be the most substantial but doesn't demonstrate encyclopaedic notability of any individual discussed there. Fails , Deletion of Robin J. Elliott :WP:SPA||:WP:RS||:WP:BASIC||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
16665 9021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Rose (podcaster) User:Alex 12:37, 4 February 2021 (UTC) keep Clear relevance and coverage Deletion of Brian Rose (podcaster) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16666 9561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of footballers from Bosnia and Herzegovina User:WilyD 22:13, 23 November 2006 (UTC) keep per Deletion of List of footballers from Bosnia and Herzegovina WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
16667 20568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/For Enforcing Peace User:Phil 23:33, 22 November 2009 (UTC) delete per #NEWS. I have a reading knowledge of Russian, and the sources offered don't seem to me to go beyond a brief flurry of coverage in minor partisan publications Deletion of For Enforcing Peace WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16668 3959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007 San Francisco International Airport runway incursion User:Dhaluza 09:34, 13 July 2007 (UTC) keep """From the second reference as quoted in the article: """"Federal Aviation Administration officials are calling a near-collision at San Francisco International Airport the most serious incident of its kind at the airport in at least a decade."""" That is prima facia claim of notability. We have two independent sources, the FAA and NTSB (which are completely independent), commenting on the severity of the incident, quoted in reliable published sources, so this meets the standard for . Also the controller was forced to recertify for their job, which would count as a severe reprimand, as outlined in the draft notability standards previously posted at Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Aviation/Aviation_accident_task_force#Notability guidelines""" Deletion of 2007 San Francisco International Airport runway incursion WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16669 5517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ex-girlfriend fist User:Tnxman307 15:07, 10 June 2009 (UTC) delete It's a non-notable |neologism that appears to have been |made up one day Deletion of Ex-girlfriend fist WP:NEO||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
16670 1970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave's Picks Volume 17 User:Mudwater 11:54, 18 January 2016 (UTC) keep """Although the album won't be released for another two weeks, it meets the |General Notability Guideline -- that is, it """"has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject"""". When this AFD was submitted the article didn't have any references, but I've added some now""" Deletion of Dave's Picks Volume 17 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16671 17937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Molecular hydrogen therapy User:Exemplo347 18:59, 23 January 2017 (UTC) delete Not notable per and unencyclopaedic per . As a side note, creating new accounts just to post walls of text isn't going to achieve anything positive Deletion of Molecular hydrogen therapy WP:GNG||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16672 11733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Resurrection Catholic Cemetery (Dubuque, Iowa) User:SL93 03:47, 15 July 2013 (UTC) delete Don Ameche is buried in the cemetery, but that doesn't show notability and I couldn't find any significant coverage. Fails Deletion of Resurrection Catholic Cemetery (Dubuque, Iowa) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16673 17538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oaktree International School, Kolkata User:Bigdelboy 23:02, 8 January 2020 (UTC) keep WP:VAGUEWAVE nomination. ''per the new guidelines'' … please specify specific guidelines.''Following the nominations of several other schools'' … what other schools? All vague and not specific. And has been read ? I see no sign of an attempt to tag the article as having problems of otherwise resolve per c#3 … ''If an article has issues try first raising your concerns on the article's talk page, with the main contributors, or an associated WikiProject, and/or adding a cleanup tag, such as Deletion of Oaktree International School, Kolkata WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16674 13513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eternity: Our Next Billion Years User:E 14:37, 4 June 2015 (UTC) keep as Tokyogirl79says, it now passes Deletion of Eternity: Our Next Billion Years WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
16675 16736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernd Dittrich User:Spongefrog 17:55, 5 December 2009 (UTC) delete Really? Almost a month? I thought there was a bot assigned to stop redlinks being added to these pages. Anyway, he still fails . His death seemed to get some coverage, however, (http://www.timescolonist.com/news/quarterback+Bernd+Dittrich+dies+university+swimming+pool+accident/2211081/story.html, http://www.vancouversun.com/news/quarterback+dies+after+drowning+university+pool/2211387/story.html) though I'm not sure if this is enough to assert his notability Deletion of Bernd Dittrich WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16676 5412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ha Sha User:Discospinster 23:48, 3 May 2006 (UTC) delete The very definition of Deletion of Ha Sha WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
16677 8910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sohee Park User:Bearian 01:46, 12 January 2020 (UTC) delete per . Classic |run of the mill character actor who lays a lot of Redshirt (stock character)|red shirt types Deletion of Sohee Park WP:NACTOR||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16678 3680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Popponesset Peninsula User:SportingFlyer 16:40, 16 May 2021 (UTC) keep The article is now well sourced per and passes as the spit. Recommend keeping and going through with the move, which isn't explicitly against the rules at AfD, could also be merged in the worst case scenario Deletion of Popponesset Peninsula WP:HEY||WP:GEOFEAT Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
16679 11158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comp (rapper) User:Gosox5555 21:23, 2 January 2010 (UTC) keep here. The local stuff plus the IGN stuff makes him notable more or less, as per and Deletion of Comp (rapper) WP:NOTE||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16680 17927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ayush mittal User:EricEnfermero 11:35, 17 March 2018 (UTC) delete Non-notable assistant professor / Ph.D. student. No GS profile, but a search turns up only a few hits that are likely to be him and they are not highly cited. Can't see any other path to meeting Deletion of Ayush mittal WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16681 4800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Puss (Swedish music duo) User:Walter 18:59, 30 April 2018 (UTC) delete WP:MUSICBIO states that they have won or been nominated for a '''major music award''', such as a Grammy, Juno, Mercury, Choice or '''Grammis''' award, but the the Grammis award for which they were nominated—club/dance—is not a major category. The nomination and their music has not garnered enough interest to make they notable yet. Hopefully a case of Deletion of Puss (Swedish music duo) :WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16682 9415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rachel Carson Elementary School User:Usedtobecool 13:59, 30 September 2020 (UTC) merge to Montgomery County Public Schools (Maryland) which does seem to have lists of schools in it, per , one I happen to agree with, and Deletion of Rachel Carson Elementary School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES||WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
16683 68 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hristiyanların İslamından Müslümanların İslamına (kitap) Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 15:24, 15 Nisan 2013 (UTC) delete Kitap varmış; ancak |İlgili kayda değerlik kriterlerine göre KD olmadığını düşünüyorum Hristiyanların İslamından Müslümanların İslamına (kitap) silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
16684 576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doomsday Prophecy User:IJBall 14:44, 30 June 2021 (UTC) delete Outside of ''Sharknado'', almost no Syfy Saturday night TV movie is going to pass //. The article's current two sources don't get it there Deletion of Doomsday Prophecy WP:GNG||WP:NFILM||WP:TVSHOW Wikipedia:Notability 77
16685 17722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lazzaro (producer) User:SamHolt6 20:05, 12 January 2018 (UTC) keep Won an award at the 2015 Armenian Pulse Music Awards, so passes Deletion of Lazzaro (producer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16686 20227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World Government (Mormonism) User:VQuakr 07:21, 10 August 2015 (UTC) keep WP:NOTCLEANUP; . Wrong forum to propose a merge Deletion of World Government (Mormonism) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16687 75 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/İbadet ve Hayat Kullanıcı:jumpeaxjumpeax 00:00, 2 Şubat 2016 (UTC) delete kayda değer olmayan yazarın kitabı, maddede de kayda değerliğini kanıtlayacak bir kaynak görünmüyor. eklenen referanslardan biri kitap satış sitesi diğeri de yazarın çalıştığı üniversitedeki biyografisi. göründüğü kadarıyla yüzlerce benzeri olan bir rehber kitap. 'daki kriterlerden herhangi birini karşılamıyor. --Kullanıcı mesaj:Kibele|'''kibele İbadet ve Hayat'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
16688 7575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucinda Rhodes-Flaherty User:MichaelQSchmidt 02:52, 16 August 2009 (UTC) keep and expand. Notabilty per easily presumable through appearing in 18 episodes of ''Harry and Cosh'', 35 episodes of ''Cavegirl'', and 12 episodes of ''Dream Team (TV series)|Dream Team'', as well as numerous positive reviews of her work on stage. http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Lucinda+Rhodes-Flaherty%22&cf=all. She passes , and . I'll be doing some work on it myself shortly Deletion of Lucinda Rhodes-Flaherty WP:ENT||WP:BIO||WP:GNG||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16689 15950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Proposed United States purchase of Greenland User:Chetsford 17:06, 16 August 2019 (UTC) keep """The article details internal proposals of 1868 and 2019, and an external proposal of 1946. A series of events spanning a time period of 150 years and covered by sources dated over a period of 30 years (the earliest direct source in the article is a 1991 report by the Associated Press https://www.apnews.com/9d4a8021c3650800fdf6dd5903f68972, the most recent is a 2019 report by BBC News https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-49367792) are not, by any logical reading, covered by .{{xt|""""THere is no proposal per reporting. Just Donald Trump asking his aides into looking for some.""""}} The most recent proposal, by Trump, is three sentences of a six paragraph article. This is like deleting Royal Family of the United Kingdom because Archie Mountbatten-Windsor happens to be mentioned in it""" Deletion of Proposed United States purchase of Greenland WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16690 4446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Ghost (Faroese band) User:AJHingston 09:32, 30 May 2011 (UTC) keep I think otability (local interests) comes into play here. For those who don't understand why see Faroe Islands. Being a large fish in a small pond (I'm sorry if that English expression confuses) can, and should, confer the notability Wikipeida demands, and they have established some interest internationally Deletion of The Ghost (Faroese band) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16691 5815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kai Frobel User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:04, 19 April 2009 (UTC) keep per asserted and found notability. Was this brought to AfD only to seek improvement? Even the nom agrees he seems notable. Per |WP:AFTER - In English: http://www.naturschutzbund.at/aktivitaeten/Projekte/gruenes_band/allg_info_gb_engl.html, http://sofiaecho.com/2009/03/04/684247_documentary-film-by-bbc-two-features-wildlife-in-bulgaria, http://www.europeangreenbelt.org/download/projects/Pan%20European%20Projects/Workshops%20for%20GB/Documents/Participants.pdf, http://tv.sky.com/natural-world-iron-curtain-ribbon-of-life, http://www.celotajs.lv/cont/prof/proj/GreenBelt/kickoff_programme.pdf, and in German: http://www.dradio.de/dlr/sendungen/gespraech/318933/, http://www.frankenpost.de/nachrichten/regional/laenderspiegel/art2388,850759, http://www.dradio.de/dlr/sendungen/gespraech/318933/?drucken, http://www.np-coburg.de/nachrichten/lokal/kronach/art2396,681433, http://www.n-tv.de/768186.html, http://www.focus.de/wissen/wissenschaft/artenschutz-ein-herz-fuer-biber_aid_176334.html, http://www.n-tv.de/672936.html, http://www.nrc.nl/buitenland/article1704746.ece/Een_groen_lint_waar_ooit_het_IJzeren_Gordijn_liep, et al Deletion of Kai Frobel WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16692 69 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Algeria–Cyprus relations User:WilyD 12:36, 1 May 2009 (UTC) keep meets and exceeds the standard of . I see no argument why this is a highly unusual article that merits a highly irregular treatment. http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=NewsLibrary&p_multi=BBAB&d_place=BBAB&p_theme=newslibrary2&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F99F9EF435A915A&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM + http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=NewsLibrary&p_multi=BBAB&d_place=BBAB&p_theme=newslibrary2&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F97DCD6DE9A0CAB&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM + http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=NewsLibrary&p_multi=BBAB&d_place=BBAB&p_theme=newslibrary2&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F97A7757B15EBDB&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM + http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-10602024_ITM + http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=NewsLibrary&p_multi=BBAB&d_place=BBAB&p_theme=newslibrary2&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F979EE5409EB125&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM + http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-53246517.html + http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-10318738_ITM + http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-18301140.html + http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/summary_0286-24505662_ITM + http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=NewsLibrary&p_multi=BBAB&d_place=BBAB&p_theme=newslibrary2&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=1096EB4679DDD3E7&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM + http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=NewsLibrary&p_multi=BBAB&d_place=BBAB&p_theme=newslibrary2&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F979EE3B9196990&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM + http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-78733874.html + http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=NewsLibrary&p_multi=BBAB&d_place=BBAB&p_theme=newslibrary2&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F99F6695D3542E0&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM + http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=NewsLibrary&p_multi=BBAB&d_place=BBAB&p_theme=newslibrary2&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F98E73199F7CC28&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM + http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=NewsLibrary&p_multi=BBAB&d_place=BBAB&p_theme=newslibrary2&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F98E72D270A92AA&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM - one can of course dig up more, but this pretty clearly demonstrates that the article exceeds the standards of by an enormous margin Deletion of Algeria–Cyprus relations WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16693 10286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trey Scott Atwater User:Horologium 16:30, 17 January 2012 (UTC) delete per and . The essay is relevant here as well; not everything which is widely covered is appropriate material for an encyclopedia Deletion of Trey Scott Atwater WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:109PAPERS Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16694 18937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Milo Yiannopoulos (2nd nomination) User:WilliamH 16:24, 24 July 2012 (UTC) keep Disclosure: I am the author of the article, and am aquainted with the subject.) The subject http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2012/jul/08/milo-yiannopoulos-kernel-technology-interview was covered in depth by ''The Guardian''. A feature in a national mainstream publication completely satisfies the |general notability guideline Deletion of Milo Yiannopoulos (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16695 3652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chloe Cammeniti User:Matthewedwards 19:23, 12 July 2009 (UTC) delete A long and detailed |plot S|summary / character biography that only a |dedicated fan would be interested in. It cannot be re-written to meet Wikipedia:SOAPS#Character articles|WikiProject Soap Opera's notability standards for characters or otability as the subject has not received Wikipedia:WAF#Real-world_perspective|real-world coverage in |reliable Wikipedia:V#Sources|independent sources, so cannot satisfy the :CAT:CONTENT|inclusion criteria Deletion of Chloe Cammeniti WP:PLOT||WP:PLOTS||WP:FANCRUFT||WP:N||WP:PSTS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16696 20611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zenburn User:Kieff 23:56, 23 April 2008 (UTC) comment It already does have some independent coverage on several blogshttp://www.google.com/search?q=%2Bblog+%2Bzenburn. It is extremely unlikely that a mere color scheme will get coverage that will count as a |RS. Blogs are pretty much all we can expect, and I don't know of any particular color scheme that has attracted such level of attention. I agree that by Wikipedia's standards the article should be deleted, but just wanted to point out that the color scheme does have some level of notability. &mdash Deletion of Zenburn WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16697 11541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twelve Men of Christmas User:J04n 18:10, 11 December 2009 (UTC) keep Some of the references found by Joe Chill have been incorporated into the article, meets Deletion of Twelve Men of Christmas WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16698 11545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anne Rimoin NONE NONE keep """Manually counting an h-index of 13 from GS. She is primary author on papers with citation counts of 115, 60, 48. I don't have the benchmarks in epidemiology, but I would not say that is particularly """"highly cited"""" in itself and I see no other lasting impact on the field. However, she appears to meet the |general notability guideline with |significant coverage in multiple |reliable, |independent sources that cite her work and expertise such as: {{Refbegin""" Deletion of Anne Rimoin WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS||WP:IS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16699 13933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KZYY-LP User:onel5969 13:06, 29 November 2019 (UTC) comment the snark was yours, my friend, being thrown back at you. Read the refs, not impressed, the newspaper article is a brief mention of the station. Half the article is about a food pantry opening. In-depth is part of , which is part of Deletion of KZYY-LP WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16700 17663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dovico (company) User:Cunard 22:41, 11 February 2011 (UTC) delete per the lack of significant coverage in |reliable sources. The coverage in the http://www.hoovers.com/company/Enterprise_Dovico_Enterprises_Inc_Les/thxxchfty-1-1njgbe.html Hoovers source is basically a directory listing. The coverage in the http://sbinfocanada.about.com/od/software/tp/timetracking.htm about.com source, while nontrivial, has dubious reliability and is not by itself sufficient to allow Dovico to pass . The http://gupea.ub.gu.se/bitstream/2077/10464/1/gupea_2077_10464_1.pdf Sidenko paper is a passing mention and as a master's thesis, not a source that establishes notability. The other references in the article are either passing mentions or primary sources.A http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Dovico%22+software+source%3A%22-newswire%22+source%3A%22-wire%22+source%3A%22-presswire%22+source%3A%22-PR%22+source%3A%22-release%22+source%3A%22-wikipedia%22&btnG=Search+Archives&scoring=a Google News Archive search returns http://timestranscript.canadaeast.com/news/article/494133 tangential coverage and press releases.I agree with the analyses of {{user|Thparkth}} and {{user|Pnm}} and concur that Dovico does not pass Wikipedia:Notability and Wikipedia:Notability (companies Deletion of Dovico (company) WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16701 6793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of animals in Zoo Tycoon 2 User:Alksub 22:34, 5 September 2007 (UTC) delete per #GUIDE Deletion of List of animals in Zoo Tycoon 2 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16702 20237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Most Beautiful Christmas Songs of the World User:HĐ 16:00, 13 January 2021 (UTC) delete fails . I do not recommend redirect as not much information can be incorporated Deletion of The Most Beautiful Christmas Songs of the World WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
16703 558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Homeworkgate User:Colapeninsula 11:22, 8 April 2014 (UTC) merge to Australian cricket team in India in 2012–13. No evidence that this meets notability requirements for events (): events need to have lasting impact and more than a few days' press coverage. Some content could be merged but not sure it's necessary Deletion of Homeworkgate WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16704 1338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Georges Khabbaz User:Elie 17:19, 4 February 2011 (UTC) keep Subject meets criteria Deletion of Georges Khabbaz WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
16705 18982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ZEDO User:Ranma9617 00:41, 6 July 2007 (UTC) keep One of many adware companies to be aware of and well with bounds of and Deletion of ZEDO WP:CORP||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16706 1496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackson Williams (3rd nomination) User:Jakejr 06:40, 27 May 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and doesn't appear to be notable for his running. I couldn't access any independent sources to show he meets Deletion of Jackson Williams (3rd nomination) WP:NBOX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16707 19376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rocky Dzidzornu User:78 05:42, 20 May 2011 (UTC) keep Undoubtedly the article is poorly written, and un-sourced; it needs a complete overhaul. However, he may qualify under notability depending on your interpretation of #6, as he has appeared on several important albums. Likewise he may qualify under Other #2. This article is no orphan. He has the briefest of mentions under Allmusic. If you check Google news there are several valid references, and a check of Google books gives even more information. (search under Rocky Dijon Deletion of Rocky Dzidzornu WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16708 16921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Business innovation consulting group User:Taroaldo 04:28, 30 March 2008 (UTC) delete Non-notable as per nom. Significance not asserted; promotional; possible Deletion of Business innovation consulting group WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
16709 10366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ray E. Bornert II User:Starblind 22:04, 20 January 2011 (UTC) delete not even close to passing the Deletion of Ray E. Bornert II WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16710 15592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Becket Chimney Corners YMCA User:Daniel5127 06:45, 3 May 2007 (UTC) delete Non-notable. As Cornellrockey said on above, there are many YMCA in US. I also believe that this fails |ORG Deletion of Becket Chimney Corners YMCA WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16711 19475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative versions of Lex Luthor User:Jontesta 20:15, 8 November 2020 (UTC) delete as a non-notable that does not meet the . We have three articles about the same thing, with an article about Lex Luthor in other media along with the main Lex Luthor article. If an article becomes too long we should summarize and clean-up the main article. This spinout article doesn't meet our standards Deletion of Alternative versions of Lex Luthor WP:CONTENTFORK||WP:GNG||WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Content forking 33
16712 13832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1st Seiyu Awards User:Atlantic306 23:59, 1 November 2020 (UTC) keep as the awards are notable as being covered by reliable sources, and as per remerging all these into the parent article would oversize the page making loading difficult over low speed connections, imv Deletion of 1st Seiyu Awards WP:PAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16713 7474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave Norris (Louisiana politician) User:FOARP 14:13, 29 April 2019 (UTC) keep Unsurprisingly for someone who was the mayor of a town for 40 years and is Louisiana's longest serving mayor, this guy has received significant coverage in reliable sources, including those cited on the page. See here https://eu.thenewsstar.com/story/news/local/2018/06/29/dave-norris-ill-make-myself-useful/740809002/ 1 http://www.hannapub.com/ouachitacitizen/news/local_state_headlines/west-monroe-mayor-norris-i-ve-really-enjoyed-it/article_1133838e-7a18-11e8-b64f-737df884f8e2.html 2 https://eu.thenewsstar.com/story/news/2018/03/26/west-monroe-mayor-dave-norris-hospitalized/459319002/ 3 https://www.myarklamiss.com/news/local-news/mayor-dave-norris-prepares-to-exit-office-after-40-years/1269353139 4 https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=CZi-yfHRBhEC&pg=PA44&dq=%22Dave+Norris%22+%22West+Monroe%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjmiaKgvvXhAhUDSRUIHVtCBDIQ6AEIKDAA#v=onepage&q=%22Dave%20Norris%22%20%22West%20Monroe%22&f=false 5 https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=p5nZAAAAIAAJ&q=%22Dave+Norris%22+%22West+Monroe%22&dq=%22Dave+Norris%22+%22West+Monroe%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiZ2Mn_vvXhAhUlt3EKHZwuA5k4ChDoAQhHMAg 6 https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=FC0HAQAAIAAJ&q=%22Dave+Norris%22+%22West+Monroe%22&dq=%22Dave+Norris%22+%22West+Monroe%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiQ_Oq-v_XhAhV8QhUIHZV3DSQ4HhDoAQgrMAE 7 https://www.knoe.com/content/news/Dave-Norris-reveals-plans-if-re-elected-as-mayor-477345273.html 8 https://www.nola.com/opinions/2017/03/a_tribute_to_a_mentor_and_frie.html 9. Meets . Nb., has no geographic scope/audience requirements, but even if it did one of the references is a USA Today reference, another appears to be state-wide media, whilst another is a published book. The 6th reference is a public relations journal to which I don't have access and can only see the snippet, but it appears it might be significant coverage Deletion of Dave Norris (Louisiana politician) WP:BASIC||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16714 20650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Motormark User:Atlantic306 17:06, 27 March 2018 (UTC) keep as enough coverage has been identified above for to be passed Deletion of Motormark WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16715 5476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Creature breeder User:Stifle 14:51, 8 July 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Creature breeder WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16716 45 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Derviş Baba Kullanıcı:kafkasmurat'''''kafkasmurat''''' 10:12, 3 Ağustos 2016 (UTC) delete Burası bir işletme. politikasına uygun bir yeri olmadığı için silinmesi taraftarıyım. Ayrıca ansiklopedik niteliğini belirten herhangi bir kaynağa da rastlamadım. Üstelik isimlendirmesi çok yanlış, Derviş Baba Kahvehanesi olması gerekir Derviş Baba'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:ŞİRKET Wikipedia:Notability 77
16717 21374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tobias Bech User:Pharaoh 19:39, 18 September 2019 (UTC) keep passes as per sources by R96Skinner Deletion of Tobias Bech WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16718 19624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mansukh Ranwa User:MelanieN 02:01, 30 August 2012 (UTC) delete """Doesn't appear to pass if that is the appropriate criterion here; certainly doesn't pass . Google search found only Wikipedia mirrors and social media; Google News found only http://www.jatland.com/forums/showthread.php?32831-Young-author-Mansukh-Ranwa-died-in-accident this; Google Books found only passing mentions, as in """"list of Hindi authors""" Deletion of Mansukh Ranwa WP:AUTHOR||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16719 12666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Kay User:YechielMan 18:32, 26 April 2007 (UTC) delete Here's the obligatory link to . I have a RL friend named Stephen Kaye, and he's not any less notable than the subject of this article Deletion of Steven Kay WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16720 2717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peg Norman User:ErikTheBikeMan 04:34, 11 September 2011 (UTC) keep per having filmed a notable film. Does not meet by itself, but still notable because of the film. Should not be penalized for not meeting one type of notability Deletion of Peg Norman WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16721 9030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ronald Collé (3rd nomination) User:Dacium 05:23, 2 May 2007 (UTC) delete No indepedant non trivial sources so can't pass or Deletion of Ronald Collé (3rd nomination) WP:BIO||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16722 1370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liverpool Pirate Radio User:Edison 18:11, 8 September 2009 (UTC) delete A magistrate's court record is a primary source and certainly in no way satisfies |notability requirements of substantial coverage in multiple reliable and independent sources. We look for coverage in reliable and independent secondary sources. There is a newspaper article, but it shows nothing more significant than a hobby operation. The newspaper article just says he broadcast for 3 weeks before he was busted and fined Deletion of Liverpool Pirate Radio WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16723 9135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Truth or Legends: In Your Hometown User:Rorshacma 17:00, 27 November 2019 (UTC) delete It is far for this show to be considered notable. The handful of extremely local coverage is pretty much all that there is as far as secondary coverage goes. No prejudice for recreation if it does become notable in the future, but for now, it completely fails the Deletion of Truth or Legends: In Your Hometown WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16724 10394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chemistry (2013 film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 21:30, 7 June 2013 (UTC) keep Since my comment above, I have had a chance to look somewhat further per hints within the article, and review the Telugu language sources through Google translate. The article's current source tells us that filming has been completed (also confirmed here: http://movies.sulekha.com/telugu/chemistry/news/chemistry-manasuki-manasuki-madhya-completes-shooting.htm), and as it is finally released http://entertainment.oneindia.in/movie_listings/Hyderabad+Chemistry+Manasuki+Manasuki+Madhya+3.html and has received coverage, even if most is |non-English, it passes . It needs the attention of Telugu-reading Wikipedians, but does not merit deletion. And to the nominator, I can only offer that there are MANY released Indian productions who do not get themselves listed at the non-RS IMDB Deletion of Chemistry (2013 film) WP:CSB||WP:NF Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
16725 7579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Death Valley Days guest stars User:Ajf773 21:40, 29 August 2020 (UTC) delete per . This is just a collection of bare mentions at IMDb Deletion of List of Death Valley Days guest stars WP:NOTIINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16726 6716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebeca Martínez User:Burntsauce 22:08, 30 May 2007 (UTC) merge as per the others, reads like a to me Deletion of Rebeca Martínez WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
16727 9684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Marston (character) User:Lordtobi 20:27, 28 December 2018 (UTC) delete per nom. Easily identifiable as and in-universe-only topic Deletion of John Marston (character) WP:GAMECRUFT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
16728 4497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dartmouth Friary User:Smalljim 17:42, 17 August 2013 (UTC) keep now meets following great work by Deletion of Dartmouth Friary WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16729 195 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Tolon Tosun (2. aday gösterme) Kullanıcı:i̇ncelemeelemanii.е. 23:11, 19 Mayıs 2012 (UTC) keep """Özellikle yaşadığı yıllarda gösterdiği başarılar açısından KD olduğunu düşünüyorum. Yani bazen aileler bizi ilgilendirmiyor olabilir. Bu durum büyük önem taşımamalı. Ben sadece |Jimmy Wales'ın dediği gibi """"Kendiniz hakkında yazmanız toplumsal bir gaftır."""" sözü doğrultusunda kişilerin kendi otobiyografilerini baştan sona buraya yazmalarına karşıyım. Belki çok hatalı olan bir yerde düzeltme yapmaları gerekiyorsa yapmalılar. Aksi takdirde Vikipedistler, toplumun bireyleri olarak o kişinin otobiyografisini zaten yeri ve zamanı gelip müsait olduklarında ekliyorlar. Biyografiler konusunda ise bazı düşüncelerim bende kalsın""" Tolon Tosun (2. aday gösterme) yazısının silinmesi Vikipedi:Otobiyografi Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
16730 15788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chef Irie User:Northamerica1000 04:03, 20 December 2015 (UTC) comment Here are some sources http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/caribbeat-taste-islands-coming-american-tv-article-1.2174081, http://www.sfltimes.com/news/local/taste-the-islands-with-chef-irie-to-premiere-on-south-floridas-wpbt2-in-2015, http://www.southflorida.com/restaurants-and-bars/sf-chef-irie-pbs-taste-islands-20150420-story.html, https://atlantablackstar.com/2015/04/06/popular-jamaican-produced-cooking-show-tastes-islands-premiere-pbs-stations-across-us/ which are about the subject's television show debut on PBS. Most of the coverage is about the show debut, so this may be a matter at this time. http://jamaica-gleaner.com/article/food/20150730/chef-irie-grace-jerk-festival This source provides some information about the subject's appearance at a Jamaican food festival, but it is too short to qualify for significant coverage Deletion of Chef Irie WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16731 13868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Archery at the 2016 Sukma Games User:Ajf773 07:02, 18 January 2017 (UTC) delete Non-notable sporting event and Deletion of Archery at the 2016 Sukma Games WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16732 17707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atheism and obesity User:WikiDan61 16:43, 20 June 2012 (UTC) delete as a |attack page as it serves no purpose but to promote the author's point of view that atheism is inherently immoral Deletion of Atheism and obesity WP:ATTACK Wikipedia:Attack page 100
16733 16024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frederick Arthur Sefton Cottom User:Lightburst 17:15, 10 September 2020 (UTC) keep """using other search terms such as: """"Frederick Arthur Sefton Cottom organ"""" yields many results, and books. The person passes. The organist meets the criteria for """ Deletion of Frederick Arthur Sefton Cottom WP:COMPOSER Wikipedia:Notability 77
16734 14449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KTRN User:ArcAngel 01:02, 31 December 2009 (UTC) delete per failing and Deletion of KTRN WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16735 6879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Euler's Day Off User:Lugnuts 07:43, 12 September 2018 (UTC) delete per . And for some reason, I have an urge to re-watch ''Ferris Bueller's Day Off''. Oh yeaaahhh Deletion of Euler's Day Off WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
16736 14353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of flags by number of colors User:Ritchie333 15:23, 23 March 2017 (UTC) delete This is a close call, but the strongest argument advanced upthread is that the article fails and has |original research concerns. Neither of these substantial issues in the article can be resolved easily, even if you threw 500 sources at it Deletion of List of flags by number of colors WP:LISTN||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16737 3000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Olga Prokopova User:Cllgbksr 06:12, 13 April 2017 (UTC) delete The career section reads like an infomercial, subject fails to meet the simplest of standards for notability Deletion of Olga Prokopova WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16738 6853 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Denise """"Dee Dee"""" Walker case""" User:Artw 22:52, 12 September 2017 (UTC) merge per above arguments, though possibly the resulting article should be named to reflect a focus on the case and not the people, per """Deletion of The Denise """"Dee Dee"""" Walker case""" WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
16739 9687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whitefield College User:JYolkowski 01:15, 11 October 2006 (UTC) keep if references added before end of AfD to satisfy . It's a good idea to have articles on places like this to help people thinking about going to these schools make better decisions Deletion of Whitefield College WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16740 21891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Belaire Manor, Arizona User:SportingFlyer 06:30, 8 December 2019 (UTC) delete mobile home parks do not pass GEOLAND #1 on their own if they're part of a larger community like this one is, and this mobile home park does not pass Deletion of Belaire Manor, Arizona WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16741 18363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of places in South Park User:Subdolous 21:51, 9 November 2007 (UTC) delete also fails Deletion of List of places in South Park WP:PLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16742 16968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Château Bel Air (Le Haillan) User:Sam 22:44, 17 May 2016 (UTC) keep per . A building is presumed to be notable if it has received significant coverage in Wikipedia:Identifying reliable sources|reliable sources that are |independent of the bodies which have a vested interest in them. Here the significant coverage by reliable, third-party sources required to establish notability is present. A surprising nomination Deletion of Château Bel Air (Le Haillan) WP:GEOFEAT||WP:SECONDARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16743 6198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess Saskia of Hanover User:Eggishorn 15:42, 9 December 2013 (UTC) delete All sources I can find in both English and German spellings of her name only support minimal information in the article: name, relatives, titles claimed, etc. |Not notable in her own right but simply for her family Deletion of Princess Saskia of Hanover WP:ITSA Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16744 3861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bihar Startup Policy User:Steve NONE delete sources are a mish-mash of coverage about various subjects such as the Bihar sector, an entrepreneurs' organization, routine financial and investment information, an argument and police action at some sort of Bihar conference, one article that is passing mention of Bihar Startup Policy and so on. There is no significant coverage of this topic in any of the available sources. Fails CORPDEPTH and GNG. Also this seems to be an attempt to cobble together unrelated subjects under the heading of this article title. This could be construed as Deletion of Bihar Startup Policy WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
16745 408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011 UCLA racism controversy User:ResidentAnthropologist 23:50, 29 March 2011 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of 2011 UCLA racism controversy WP:BLP||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16746 19739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of High School DxD terminology User:Knowledgekid87 23:57, 22 February 2013 (UTC) delete """This was deprodded with the reason: """"The reason why that page was created, was because that information was occupying too much place on on the main page and to make extra space for other information. And deleting that page would put all the efforts of the users who made that information, which was moved to another page, to go to waste. An that is unforgivable"""" The """"efforts of the users who made that information"""" is what's called . I see no reason why this article should stay as it is unsourced and full of , if someone wants to merge this info into the plot (as a brief mention to avoid )) it could be helpful and feel free to do so""" Deletion of List of High School DxD terminology WP:OR||WP:FANCRUFT||WP:ALLPLOT Wikipedia:No original research 65
16747 2235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melia Kreiling User:INeedSupport 20:39, 11 May 2019 (UTC) keep """I think it barely pass , as she has been in numerous films and been part of television shows for quite a while now. A quick Google search in the """"news"""" section shows lots of news about her and the show she's in""" Deletion of Melia Kreiling WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16748 17102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ganesh Prasad Tiwari User:scope_creep 00:33, 9 August 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Ganesh Prasad Tiwari WP:BIO||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16749 2072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people with coronavirus disease 2019 User:Muboshgu 14:37, 13 March 2020 (UTC) delete per and . Almost half of the world's population is expected to contract COVID-19. This is not at all a defining characteristic that would make for a notable topic for a list. – Deletion of List of people with coronavirus disease 2019 WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16750 18461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Korben (band) User:Cunard 23:56, 24 October 2009 (UTC) delete """per the lack of |reliable sources. The article contains no reliable sources. The Blogcritics article mentioned above is not a sufficient source. An editor at the reliable sources noticeboard (see Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 9#blogcritic.org) wrote that this website will """"let just about anyone with a blog write for them, so of course they can't be considered reliable."""" A http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=Korben+band+Los+Angeles&btnG=Search&um=1&scoring=a Google News Archive search returns no results. This band fails """ Deletion of Korben (band) WP:RS||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16751 15234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Okpella User:Everymorning 04:11, 25 August 2016 (UTC) keep Is not a hoax and passes per the following reliable sources, among others: http://www.vanguardngr.com/2016/06/shuaibu-amodu-buried-okpella/ http://www.thisdaylive.com/index.php/2016/04/11/dangote-turns-59-begins-1bn-okpella-cement-plant-construction/ https://www.naij.com/794947-read-happened-dangotes-59th-birthday-edo-state-photo.html Nominator is reminded to follow before starting an AFD Deletion of Okpella WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16752 259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jan Finney NONE NONE keep Passes criteria #2 Deletion of Jan Finney WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
16753 5199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jessica May User:Dihydrogen 02:32, 13 March 2008 (UTC) keep """per - """"''Has won or been a serious nominee for a well-known award''"""" - Ninfa Prize per article (sourced, too""" Deletion of Jessica May WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16754 15832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kinetic degradation fluxion media (2nd nomination) User:Toddst1 14:25, 28 June 2016 (UTC) keep """With 8 reliable sources including the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry and coverage in several scientific texts, the assertion that this article fails seems absurd. The topic has clearly received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject. The subject's coverage in McGraw-Hill's """"'''''Materials Handbook:''' An encyclopedia for Managers, Technical Professionals, Purchasing and Production Managers, Technicians and Supervisors''"""" alone should have prevented this AFD""" Deletion of Kinetic degradation fluxion media (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16755 14524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kip Smith (2nd nomination) User:Masumrezarock100 00:38, 27 June 2019 (UTC) keep the subject meets . Just because the article is a stub doesn't mean that it is not notable Deletion of Kip Smith (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16756 6876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad Yasin Chowdhury User:GPL93 16:36, 29 January 2020 (UTC) delete Fails , likely a article. Best Deletion of Mohammad Yasin Chowdhury WP:GNG||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16757 3089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of App Store applications (Science) User:B 04:14, 26 February 2010 (UTC) delete as prodder. |Wikipedia is neither a price list nor a catalog. I found this as I was checking out the deletion discussion for its redirect List of App Store applications - do I see a #G8|speedy deletion of dependent page coming Deletion of List of App Store applications (Science) WP:NOT||WP:CSD Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16758 19728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bellator 55 User:WR NONE keep per and . These articles include championship fights from televised events covered in mainstream media sources. There is no actual reason why we should not cover sourced information that is relevant to a segment of a readership. Like seriously, what's it to ya? Gosh Deletion of Bellator 55 WP:EVENT||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
16759 19191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earth in science fiction (2nd nomination) user:Andrew 08:31, 13 July 2021 (UTC) keep """The page is now a promising work-in-progress and so our policy applies, """"''If editing can improve the page, this should be done rather than deleting the page.''"""" Further work should not be disrupted by the chilling effect of impending deletion. See also """ Deletion of Earth in science fiction (2nd nomination) WP:ATD||WP:HEY Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
16760 11234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kozma Dushi User:SK2242 16:57, 13 February 2021 (UTC) delete Fails and MUSICBIO Deletion of Kozma Dushi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16761 21475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamran Jawaid User:Jeremiah 23:40, 24 October 2008 (UTC) delete No significant coverage. Fails Deletion of Kamran Jawaid WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16762 3894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WFCA Plc User:Mikeman67 09:20, 7 February 2014 (UTC) delete Per , while the company is mentioned in online trade publications, the mentions are all incidental. Other references are simply press releases or announcements of awards. I couldn't find any mention in regional or national news at all. I don't think it meets the criteria for Deletion of WFCA Plc WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16763 16462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Burns (medical inventor and picture framer) User:Edison 21:00, 31 May 2011 (UTC) delete He had some interesting life experiences, and it would not be surprising if he had some coverage in reliable sources, but all that is presented in an obituary, and it is just not enough to satisfy Deletion of Terry Burns (medical inventor and picture framer) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16764 5921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carrot Cake Murder: A Hannah Swensen Mystery User:Northamerica1000 15:42, 27 February 2015 (UTC) keep Meets criteria #1 per the reviews above Deletion of Carrot Cake Murder: A Hannah Swensen Mystery WP:BKCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16765 14966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finished With My Ex's Untitled Forthcoming Album User:Sue 01:07, 8 December 2012 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Finished With My Ex's Untitled Forthcoming Album WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
16766 10479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Smitty (film) User:Donaldd23 16:06, 1 July 2020 (UTC) keep """per ; Your reasoning included reasons to keep the article. says, """"Publication of at least two non-trivial articles, at least five years after the film's initial release."""" and your reasoning says """"Has only one or two in-depth reviews."""" If there are 2, which there are (see Hitcher vs. Candyman's """"Keep"""" vote), then the article should not be deleted""" Deletion of Smitty (film) WP:NFO||WP:NFO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16767 2438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lennox Farrell User:SyndicaterUI78 20:24, 13 May 2019 (UTC) delete Has no references and fails Deletion of Lennox Farrell WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16768 63 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rammstein (album) User:B 05:43, 6 May 2008 (UTC) merge as non-charting demo albums don't reach the bar of Deletion of Rammstein (album) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16769 4820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NewStar Financial User:Adamant1 20:02, 25 July 2020 (UTC) delete The company lacks the in-depth coverage in multiple reliable sources need to pass . There was one source provided above, but it's a local outlet to the Boston area where this company is located. So, it doesn't count for notability on it's own. Merging might be an option, but the merge targets sourcing is also extremely suspect and I'm not a fan of merging one badly sourced article into another one Deletion of NewStar Financial WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16770 7618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radio Askew User:Sandstein 13:18, 5 March 2006 (UTC) delete per , ''sigh Deletion of Radio Askew WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16771 13670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Porch sitting User:Colonel 12:05, 9 February 2011 (UTC) keep The topic is, in fact, completly notable being covered in books such as ''http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=iwCUAAAACAAJ The Art of Porch Sitting: A Societal Barometer''. The current title is not a neologism and this would not be a reason to delete even if it were. The claim of OR is unsupported by any details or evidence. The article just seems to need more work per our |editing policy. Kudos to the creator for suggesting it Deletion of Porch sitting WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
16772 6280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of numbers in Vedas User:Shooterwalker 23:28, 2 September 2010 (UTC) keep on the basis that numerology is significant in the Vedic religions similar to list of animals in the Bible. No prejudice against renominating later, but I'm pretty sure there are sources to of this topic Deletion of List of numbers in Vedas WP:verify notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
16773 1179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pepperfry User:Lemongirl942 02:53, 10 October 2016 (UTC) delete The sources are pretty bad. All the stuff in Economic Times is blatant redressed PR. Every single other source that I managed to look was using quotes by the company employees as story sources (which doesn't satisfy ). More importantly this is and should be deleted. Saying that promotional content can be fixed and putting the burden on volunteer editors is counterproductive. It is essentially encouraging the on Wikipedia. We don't want a situation. Once Wikipedia becomes a medium for promotion it loses its relevance as an encyclopaedia Deletion of Pepperfry WP:ORGIND||WP:PROMO||WP:SYSTEMICBIAS||WP:BOGOF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16774 18193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Futuristic Sex Robotz User:Karmafist 13:59, 23 February 2006 (UTC) delete definately doesn't meet Deletion of Futuristic Sex Robotz WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16775 5608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/± Junkie User:AnmaFinotera 19:23, 19 March 2009 (UTC) delete completely unnotable series. Fails and Deletion of ± Junkie WP:BK||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16776 277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Autocunnilingus (2 nomination) User:Dhartung 08:47, 3 November 2006 (UTC) delete """as . http://www.selfellatio.com/interview.htm According to this guy, who ought to know, ''I have been searching for a long time for proof of that. I belong to a couple of groups on the internet who are also searching for it. We as a collective have yet to find any proof. I am positive that it can be done because if I were a woman I could reach. But yet there aren't any photographs out there other than some altered ones.'' I performed life-saving surgery on donkey punch but this has less cultural currency even though it's probably more """"popular"""" in pornographic terms""" Deletion of Autocunnilingus (2 nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16777 17913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grace Pacifica Chen User:ProcrasinatingReader 14:40, 11 June 2020 (UTC) delete does not meet or Deletion of Grace Pacifica Chen WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16778 13576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Estée Lauder pleasures User:Russavia 20:03, 20 January 2008 (UTC) comment Having looked thru Google News (before putting this up for Afd), I noticed that many of the results are press releases, so they can't be used as a basis for . Many other sources don't write extensively on the product in an encyclopaedic fashion, and many others mention Pleasures but in the context of the overall Estee Lauder product line/profits/etc. And then there are some which are about Pleasures, but other products such as Pleasures Delight, Pleasures Exotic, etc. And then some are about Gwyneth Paltrow being the face of the product; this may be suitable for a mention in her article but as notability isn't inherited, it can't be used to give this product notability Deletion of Estée Lauder pleasures WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16779 3370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eliska Sursova [[User talk:Florrie| florrie ]]''' 02:44, 15 May 2009 (UTC) delete """sources confusing and do not appear to be |reliable. See also Elissa Sursara which brings more doubt to the Eliska Sursova article. Which is the """"real"""" person? Listed at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Biographies_of_living_persons/Noticeboard#Elissa_Sursara_.2F_Eliska_Sursova WP:BLPN yesterday for comment""" Deletion of Eliska Sursova WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16780 5970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alone-ishness User:Aeon1006 06:19, 11 July 2006 (UTC) delete Fail Deletion of Alone-ishness WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16781 17612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anabond Limited User:Stifle 19:03, 14 May 2008 (UTC) delete As there are no |reliable sources |cited, I am persuaded that the article does not comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Anabond Limited WP:RS||WP:CITE||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16782 3070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Odoo User:Odony 09:29, 6 February 2015 (UTC) keep Odoo is the new name of OpenERP (it is a redirection). A Google search gives more than 600k results for either Odoo or OpenERP, from thousands of sources (keep in mind). A search for https://www.google.be/search?tbs=bks:1&q=OpenERP&qscrl=1 books gives hundreds of books about OpenERP/Odoo. http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=odoo%2C%20openerp%2C%20tinyerp&cmpt=q&tz= Google Trends shows the history of the project's name and popularity. More random examples: Odoo was recently selected in the http://opensource.com/business/15/1/top-project-management-tools-2015 top 5 project management tools for 2015 on opensource.com, in the http://www.linux.com/news/software/applications/800827-best-linux-and-open-source-apps-for-the-enterprise-in-2015 Best Linux and Open Source Apps for the Enterprise in 2015 of linux.com, nominated for the http://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/be/Documents/technology/DeloitteTechnologyFast50/Rankings/Fast50-ListNominees2014_Belgium.pdf Deloitte Technology Fast 50 2014. The product also won a BOSSIE Award two years in a row, under its former name, OpenERP, in http://www.infoworld.com/slideshow/65165 2012 and http://www.infoworld.com/slideshow/119652 2013. According to and , the above should be sufficient to establish notability, even if the article contents itself should certainly be improved. As a comparison, here is what http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=openerp%2Bodoo%2Btinyerp%2C%20openbravo&cmpt=q&tz= Google Trends says about popularity of OpenERP vs Openbravo. By that measure, the Openbravo article and a great many other ones would have to face deletion as well Deletion of Odoo WP:NTEMP||WP:NNC||WP:ARTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16783 5318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shuoji Zhou User:Ifnord 00:56, 24 August 2018 (UTC) delete per nom as . I was sure I was going to vote keep after reading the Forbes article, it really is a solid reference. But, searching for another reference proved fruitless. A speaker at several Chinese conventions, mentions in some blogs, but really nothing else. Surprising Deletion of Shuoji Zhou WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16784 14214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riana Rouge user:H3llkn0wz 15:57, 24 April 2010 (UTC) keep Passes but needs refs badly. — Deletion of Riana Rouge WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16785 732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeoke (Lučani) User:Hog 18:33, 23 February 2021 (UTC) keep a village reporting a population in a national census meets for me Deletion of Zeoke (Lučani) WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16786 11741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dennis Keyes User:Ejgreen77 03:06, 22 November 2019 (UTC) keep Meets and , per Cbl62's sources Deletion of Dennis Keyes WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16787 3427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Johan Lange (football coach) User:Tgeairn 17:24, 7 June 2012 (UTC) delete As above, the subject does not meet . In that case, the subject would need to meet in general, which I can find no evidence of Deletion of Johan Lange (football coach) WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16788 3090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arsalan Anwar (2nd nomination) User:DevaCat1 23:23, 17 March 2021 (UTC) keep He played in both first class cricket (which passes for ) and U19 international cricket (which improves general notability). Plus, articles shouldn't be up for AfD every month in the hope that there is a different result. This looks like bad faith gaming of the system Deletion of Arsalan Anwar (2nd nomination) WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16789 13871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Griffiths User:Phil 20:41, 1 June 2010 (UTC) delete """This is precisely the sort of article that the |policy on biographies of living people should be concerned about, as it repeats unproven allegations about a living person which are obviously potentially harmful to that person. We've been sidetracked this year by a handful of disruptive editors (included some admins and at least one steward) into a moral panic about poorly sourced articles saying """"Joe Bloggs is a footballer playing for Anytown United"""" rather than concentrating on the cases, such as this one, that have the potential to cause real, serious, harm""" Deletion of Stephen Griffiths WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16790 7526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of professional athletes who have been convicted of crimes User:JulesH 09:51, 24 July 2007 (UTC) merge Please do not rename like this. Felony is a US-specific word with no official meaning in most other jurisdictions, and therefore would be a clear case of . No opinion on whether or not the article should be deleted Deletion of List of professional athletes who have been convicted of crimes WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
16791 19640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amber Ellan User:Ozgod 14:07, 25 May 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails to meet otability Deletion of Amber Ellan WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16792 14210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Africa Unite Party User:TH1980 02:07, 21 May 2018 (UTC) delete As per , and due to poor sourcing Deletion of Africa Unite Party WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16793 14819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rachel White (Actress) User:Piotrus 03:11, 11 December 2016 (UTC) delete TOOSOON, two supporting roles (one with a character that is not even named) fail . No objection to userfying, since if she keeps it up she may become notable in few years Deletion of Rachel White (Actress) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16794 12264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Palestinian ax attacks on Israelis User:Bigger 22:03, 5 September 2010 (UTC) delete Palestinians attack Israelis, fine, but this seems more like a collection of individually news-based items than anything else. Furthermore, as per Claritas, there is not significant coverage of axe attacks as a phenomenon to suggest notability for collating them all, which is the opposite case for the rocket attack articles, which generally have historical context and political impact to support their inclusion. That is what is missing for this article/list. is also applicable here Deletion of List of Palestinian ax attacks on Israelis WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16795 8693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siege Perilous (comics) User:Folken 12:30, 4 October 2013 (UTC) merge """into Features of the Marvel Universe or '''Delete''', the article only has primary sourcing and thus fails which requires """"significant coverage from multiple reliable sources"""". Trivial mentions and fansites are not enough to meet the requirements""" Deletion of Siege Perilous (comics) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16796 12602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twenty Wan (Card Game) User:COMPFUNK2 21:16, 13 September 2009 (UTC) delete I don't think it should be merged because I can't find any sources of its existence (othen than a game-related wiki), so I have to conclude it was |made up Deletion of Twenty Wan (Card Game) WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
16797 12377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maximillion (fictional dog) User:Claritas 18:46, 13 July 2010 (UTC) delete fails - no significant out-of-universe coverage Deletion of Maximillion (fictional dog) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16798 13527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael L. Benton User:Bearian 20:51, 11 January 2010 (UTC) delete Besides being a violation, his position is not notable Deletion of Michael L. Benton WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16799 19577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Breaking Back User:Pdcook 16:09, 4 March 2010 (UTC) comment If you think the topic is notable, then AfD is not the place for it (see ). I personally don't think the topic is notable, and if additional references aren't added, I'd suggest delete, but I'm withholding my !vote for now Deletion of Breaking Back WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16800 11548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Descendants of Major Nazis User:Metropolitan90 06:45, 22 June 2011 (UTC) delete """We deleted a similar article a couple of months ago at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of descendants of Nazi officials. Among the reasons cited for doing so was that such a list violated by calling """"particular attention to a group of people solely by a feature that is both (i) highly negative & (ii) beyond their control""" Deletion of Descendants of Major Nazis WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16801 14053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Behave: The Biology of Humans at Our Best and Worst User:TheSandDoctor 20:23, 6 April 2017 (UTC) merge Redirect for the time being as per the above, simply considering the book has yet to be released. In the future (assuming it is indeed released etc and does become notable), then by all means, it should be made into its own article. It is simply too soon in my opinion at the moment Deletion of Behave: The Biology of Humans at Our Best and Worst WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
16802 20504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UK Alfa Romeo Owners Club User:JohnBlackburne 01:10, 13 October 2011 (UTC) delete per , with the refs being non-reliable and saying nothing about the topic respectively Deletion of UK Alfa Romeo Owners Club WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16803 1401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robin Spielberg User:Colapeninsula 15:42, 29 November 2013 (UTC) keep """as notable. A lot of the sources are routine local press coverage (although there's certainly a grey area between """"X is playing Y"""" which doesn't count and publications using an event as a peg for a larger article which does count), but there is a sizeable article from the New York Timeshttp://www.nytimes.com/2000/06/04/nyregion/music-an-infant-s-struggle-a-mother-s-gift-of-life.html and she's also been reviewed in the Washington Posthttp://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/WPcap/2000-06/16/102r-061600-idx.html as well as multiple reviews on AllMusic, and her self-published book was reviewed in Kirkushttps://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/robin-spielberg/naked-on-the-bench/. Plus there's the 1995 Billboard article, which she's not the primary subject of, but it still provides significant coverage, so that counts too for . And local press coverage, which counts for less, but cumulatively it all adds up to meeting . And the article does need editing""" Deletion of Robin Spielberg WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16804 8412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Komala Pata User:MichaelQSchmidt 06:31, 16 July 2016 (UTC) delete """for failing . It is incorrect for the nominator to state a film is a {{tq|""""notable subject if sources are provided""""}} because, even if unsourced, a topic '''''might''''' be notable |'''if''' sources are available, used or not. That clarified, I was unable to find decent sources in my |own search and so believe a delete is the proper outcome. If or when proper sources become available, bring them forth and the topic could then be |resurrected without prejudice""" Deletion of Komala Pata WP:NF||WP:NEXIST||WP:BEFORE||WP:REFUND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16805 19962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kylie's eleventh studio album User:Bearcat 20:59, 7 March 2008 (UTC) delete per . Albums should never have articles until, at minimum, the artist or the label has provided a firm title and track listing Deletion of Kylie's eleventh studio album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16806 20799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Key Themes in Media Theory User:bojo1498 17:47, 23 March 2017 (UTC) delete Doesn't seem to meet Deletion of Key Themes in Media Theory WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
16807 3688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess Zein bint Hussein NONE NONE keep This is the English Wikipedia and there's people who flock to keep articles on rticles for deletion/Child of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge|royal rticles for deletion/Second child of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge|fetuses of the United Kingdom. Having this helps balance things out. This article can be improved with Arabic sources. Here is one I found Deletion of Princess Zein bint Hussein WP:A||WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
16808 17964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tino Georgiou User:FisherQueen 11:55, 15 September 2007 (UTC) delete A self-published novel that doesn't seem to have achieved any particular |notability; all these sockpuppets indicate a probable |conflict of interest as well Deletion of Tino Georgiou WP:N||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
16809 1230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FIFA 09 User:TenPoundHammer 18:37, 20 May 2007 (UTC) delete as with no content whatsoever Deletion of FIFA 09 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16810 14001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald L. Trump User:Xxanthippe 03:52, 30 April 2018 (UTC) keep Clear pass of rof#C1 Deletion of Donald L. Trump WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
16811 13233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laura Marie Howard User:Clarityfiend 02:55, 9 April 2016 (UTC) delete per and . ''Pandorica'' has a teeny tiny budget and few IMDb votes. Her other two films haven't even been released yet Deletion of Laura Marie Howard WP:NACTOR||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
16812 6652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Computer Concepts (USA) User:Walton_monarchist89 18:55, 3 March 2007 (UTC) delete no evidence of multiple non-trivial coverage in independent sources to establish notability per . Delete unless sourced by the end of this AfD Deletion of Computer Concepts (USA) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16813 2977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flandal Steelskin User:Satellizer 06:54, 2 May 2016 (UTC) merge no reliable sources from what I can tell. , Flandal Steelskin needs to demonstrate notability independent of the ''D&D'' franchise Deletion of Flandal Steelskin WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16814 9902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Pete User:Mduvekot 13:54, 20 July 2016 (UTC) delete The external link to Genussmittel in Soller (http://web.archive.org/web/20110719082606/http://www.schoene-nachrichten.de/?p=12585 archive) gives something like a review, but that appears to be the extent of the critical reception of his work. The link to his homepage is dead. The German and French wikipedia both have an article about him, the French with even fewer sources than the English version. The German article has a long listing of exhibitions, none of which have taken place in notable galleries. Fails Deletion of Adam Pete WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
16815 2164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dream Car Racing 3D [[User talk:Czar|czar]] 19:36, 16 November 2016 (UTC) delete A little more listening might be in order. Try these links: This article topic lacks |significant coverage from |reliable, |independent sources. (|?) It had few meaningful hits (more than listings) in a /RS|video game reliable sources https://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=003516479746865699832:leawcwkqifq custom Google search. It doesn't have enough depth of coverage in reliable sources to write meaningfully on the topic, and there is no indication that the game is somehow notable despite this lack of coverage. There are no worthwhile redirect targets Deletion of Dream Car Racing 3D WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:42||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16816 17959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orcadian User:Angusmclellan 10:11, 13 July 2006 (UTC) comment nomination is an attempt to resolve a content dispute via AFD, so I'm minded to keep the article. POV issues, unless irremediable, are not grounds for deletion in most cases. The same is true of Deletion of Orcadian WP:OWN Wikipedia:Ownership of content 86
16817 14883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Commey User:HitroMilanese 11:00, 23 September 2017 (UTC) delete Not meeting currently Deletion of Aaron Commey WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16818 2051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Parker User:Kittybrewster 08:59, 27 February 2011 (UTC) delete Unsuccessful political candidate who fails and Deletion of Star Parker WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16819 927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of renewable energy manufacturers User:Americasroof 18:33, 23 December 2010 (UTC) keep This notable information was prodded and then thrown up for afd one day after work began on it – all in violation of efore. Is the information notable? Yes. Can the article be saved with editing? Yes. The rationale for deletion based irectory is not met. The topic is clearly defined as manufacturers of the categories. The rationale for is also not met since it clearly defines its boundaries. All that said, the article is definitely overly broad. It would be much better and probably would not have triggered the deletion reaction if it had been broken up in smaller more focused articles on what areas where it was fully developed (e.g., wind, solar, wave). I am willing to work with the original author to implement a more focused bite sized approach for a well researched article. I appreciate the argument that it is a link farm however it should be noted that since this is a new industry these companies tend to be small start ups (I wandered in while backlinking an article I started on a one of the companies). Therefore I am asking that the nominator withdraw the afd while this is implemented. Thanks Deletion of List of renewable energy manufacturers WP:B||WP:D||WP:SALAT Wikipedia:Bots 21
16820 3281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faisal Rahman (2nd nomination) User:MrClog 12:11, 23 May 2019 (UTC) keep Passes . This has also been established in the Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faisal Rahman|nomination a week ago Deletion of Faisal Rahman (2nd nomination) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16821 15921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Le Kevin Smith User:Stormie 10:17, 2 May 2006 (UTC) keep """meets notability criteria set out in - """"..or at the highest level in mainly amateur sports, including college sports in the United States"""" - even if he doesn't play for the Patriots he looks to have qualified through his play for the University of Nebraska, where he apparently performed great defensive feats in 2005: """"led the nation with 50 quarterback sacks and 124 tackles behind the line of scrimmage.""""http://www.patriots.com/team/index.cfm?ac=playerbio&bio=32017 ''oops that quote was not about Smith personally'' &mdash""" Deletion of Le Kevin Smith WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16822 10414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Stewart (politician) (2nd nomination) User:Ctmadsen 02:27, 15 November 2011 (UTC) keep per Bearian. I wrote the article, and agree that this fails - but is on the margin as an author. I recommend removing notes regarding political candidacy. Subject is not notable - by any stretch - as a politician Deletion of Chris Stewart (politician) (2nd nomination) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
16823 16160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earthshatter User:Gwernol 22:09, 4 January 2007 (UTC) delete WP:NFT|Wikipedia is not for |stuff you made up Deletion of Earthshatter WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
16824 6056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zach Steinberger User:Sir 19:54, 28 October 2014 (UTC) delete he has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Zach Steinberger WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16825 2350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chivalry-Now User:MelanieN 23:13, 14 October 2012 (UTC) delete This is not a notable organization as defined by Wikipedia, see . The organization has not received the required |significant coverage by multiple independent reliable sources. In fact it has received close to zero coverage; all I found was http://www.shorelinetimes.com/articles/2010/06/10/life/doc4c11071327e42661439767.txt this, from a small local paper and not written by the paper's staff so it might not be independent. Aside from the lack of notability this article suffers from a lot of unsourced |original research and a frankly promotional tone Deletion of Chivalry-Now WP:ORG||WP:42||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16826 15445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of The Closer broadcasters User:Otto4711 12:39, 25 July 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. per and per extensive precedents including the one linked in the nom and similar deletions for shows like Desperate Housewives, Smallville and others Deletion of List of The Closer broadcasters WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16827 5707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evil Factory Network User:UkPaolo 10:43, 5 March 2006 (UTC) delete fails to establish notability per as far as I'm concerned Deletion of Evil Factory Network WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16828 15995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Osceola County School For The Arts User:Camaron1 17:14, 16 November 2007 (UTC) keep """Article has been improved thanks to the efforts of Victuallers. It is a /AG|high school and the article on it can pass if it doesn't now, article includes some independent and reliable sources, and a search reveals more such as http://209.190.242.72/lbd/2005/projects/osceola-county.pdf. Things like ''It has been an """"A"""" school in the grading system that uses the Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test as its standard, and is also a """"5 Star"""" school'' would help enhance notability further if they were sourced, I am working on that""" Deletion of Osceola County School For The Arts WP:SCH||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16829 4911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mobovivo User:Kavadi 08:38, 4 November 2006 (UTC) delete Reads like an advertisement. YouTube this isn't. Above press mentions are of the company talking about itself, hence still does not satisfy Deletion of Mobovivo WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16830 18441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mockelberg User:Bearian 18:39, 29 January 2021 (UTC) delete per and . Not every name used in a fictional universe is notable Deletion of Mockelberg WP:GNG||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16831 16396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krustylu studios User:Arkyan 15:16, 19 April 2007 (UTC) delete no notability per Deletion of Krustylu studios WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16832 7959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Toby User:JMHamo 02:43, 31 January 2014 (UTC) delete fails and . The article can be restored at the click of a button when subject becomes notable, but at the moment he is not Deletion of Joseph Toby WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16833 18597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paris Hilton energy plan User:Deamon138 15:32, 26 August 2008 (UTC) comment """Per , notability doesn't have to be lasting. Notaility has to be established just once so, ''""""there is no need to show continual coverage or interest in the topic""" Deletion of Paris Hilton energy plan WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16834 19646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HP Enterprise Business User:K 22:38, 30 September 2017 (UTC) delete a corporate brochure masquerading as an encyclopedia article, and doing a rather poor job at that. That aside, sourcing does not meet . Almost no valid incoming links, so deletion is a best option here Deletion of HP Enterprise Business WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
16835 15013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ACAZ T.2 User:The 00:49, 22 April 2013 (UTC) keep """Per long-standing and results at AfD, all individual make-and-model aircraft types are |notable, much as all make-and-model vehicle types are. In addition, sources have been added clearly demonstrating that this """"unremarkable"""" type passes comfortably. Note that sources need only exist, not be in the article, and OEFFORT is a |argument to avoid. Also """"only one was ever made"""" is not a valid argument; only one Spruce Goose was ever made, for instance""" Deletion of ACAZ T.2 WP:CONSENSUS||WP:N||WP:GNG||WP:NOEFFORT||WP:ATA Wikipedia:Consensus 78
16836 15017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Goatse.cx (5th nomination) User:SlamDiego 19:12, 26 July 2008 (UTC) comment For purposes of an AfD, I also wouldn't ''bother'' producing a specific |“reliable source” to show that Karl Rove was |“notable”. I'd instead wonder ''how in the world'' someone could actually believe or hope to persuade others that Karl Rove or Goatse.cx weren't |“notable”, and move on as I do when encountering problematic people on city street corners Deletion of Goatse.cx (5th nomination) WP:RS||WP:NOTE||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16837 19020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 Australian network television schedule (weekday) User:Edison 16:57, 14 August 2009 (UTC) keep """Keeping such articles about the schedule (as opposed to daily programming) is consistent with #Wikipedia is not a directory which says """"..historically significant programme lists and schedules (such as the annual United States network television schedules) may be acceptable."""" This is not """"TV Guide,"""" which says what the program's episode will be on a particular day. In a given country, the network TV schedules have typically been discussed in more depth in books, magazines, and newspaper media columns, than mere listings of the days programming. The schedule is a strategic choice of what program leads into a given program, and what the competition is in a time slot""" Deletion of 2009 Australian network television schedule (weekday) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16838 12387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonny Staub User:Schuym1 21:06, 13 December 2008 (UTC) delete Doesn't show notability per Deletion of Jonny Staub WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16839 3826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gods of Demential User:RGTraynor 15:57, 13 June 2007 (UTC) delete fails , , . Only 22 hits on the Italian Wikipedia, and many of them are Wiki mirrors http://www.google.it/search?q=+%22Gods+of+Demential%22+-Myspace+-Wikipedia&hl=it&lr=&as_qdr=all&start=30&sa=N. This seems well under the radar even in Bologna Deletion of Gods of Demential WP:V||WP:MUSIC||WP:NN Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16840 3204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of centenarians User:Stifle 08:27, 16 October 2008 (UTC) delete arbitrary list. See items 1, 7, and 10 Deletion of List of centenarians WP:LC Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
16841 4070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suicide attacks in popular culture (2nd nomination) User:SlamDiego 10:19, 18 June 2007 (UTC) delete It's hard to judge the potential for such an article in the face of such a dreadfully poor realization, but it seems that it will always be awash in |“original research” and cannot transcend being a mere ''catalogue'' without even ''more'' |“original research Deletion of Suicide attacks in popular culture (2nd nomination) WP:OR||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16842 2961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avinaash V. Rai User:Comatmebro 16:43, 31 May 2017 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Avinaash V. Rai WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16843 35 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Monster Legends """Kullanıcı:vincent vegavincent vega """ 14.04, 14 Aralık 2021 (UTC) comment Lütfen Bakınız , Vikipedi:Doğrulanabilirlik Monster Legends'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Bağımsız kaynaklar Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16844 10402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Pilgrim User:Allisonmontgomery69 22:28, 20 July 2006 (UTC) delete because I don't think that this person is notable under the rules. It doesn't matter what the subject thinks. But my two cents is that this is unsourced and non-notable. Delete Deletion of Mark Pilgrim WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16845 1856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mel Gibson DUI incident (2nd nomination) User:DS1953 23:48, 31 May 2007 (UTC) delete While this event can and should be covered in the Mel Gibson article, it does not merit an article of its own. If it is kept, I hope that someone eventually will be |bold enough to merge Deletion of Mel Gibson DUI incident (2nd nomination) WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
16846 573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephano Barberis User:FisherQueen 22:41, 18 June 2010 (UTC) delete unless better sources become available. Many of the claimed awards are awards for videos he worked on- not awards that he himself was awarded. Most of the awards are purely regional in scope; this person's sole claim to notability is the Video Director of the Year awards in 2007 and 2008 from the Canadian Country Music Association, but as far as I can determine, those awards weren't reported on by any |independent sources. ''None'' of the biographical information in the article is verified in any independent sources Deletion of Stephano Barberis WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16847 10429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Old man's car User:Bearian 14:53, 29 June 2018 (UTC) keep """as a notable idiom rather than merely as an """"industry term"""", which it isn't anyway. Plenty of |good sources show it's |notable""" Deletion of Old man's car WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16848 7700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pearson in Practice User:HighKing 11:42, 10 October 2019 (UTC) merge as above and then '''Delete''' this link. This topic was never notable and fails GNG and Deletion of Pearson in Practice WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
16849 10965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/N-Sider (2nd nomination) [[User talk:Czar|czar]] 04:15, 14 December 2015 (UTC) delete Article topic lacks |significant coverage from |reliable, |independent sources. (|?) Its coverage was cited a few times in a /RS|video game reliable sources https://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=003516479746865699832:leawcwkqifq custom Google search, but in nothing more than passing mentions and in no depth about the publication itself. There are no worthwhile redirect targets. If someone finds more (non-English and offline) sources, please {{tl|ping}} me Deletion of N-Sider (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:42||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16850 9877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mamoudou Gassama (2nd nomination) User:pythoncoder 00:35, 3 November 2018 (UTC) keep Received substantial worldwide news coverage = |GNG Deletion of Mamoudou Gassama (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16851 2967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kate Elizabeth Hallam User:onel5969 13:57, 3 November 2015 (UTC) delete per nom and above editors. Searches do not show her meeting Deletion of Kate Elizabeth Hallam WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16852 3830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zorin OS (2nd nomination) User:Aoidh 23:05, 7 September 2013 (UTC) delete Fails . The only third-party sources are reviews from Katherine Noyes, who routinely reviews Linux distros; that doesn't seem to show notability and even if it did, that's the only third-party author who seems to have given Zorin OS any attention at all, which is not enough to establish notability on Wikipedia. DistroWatch does not contribute towards establishing notability as http://distrowatch.com/dwres.php?resource=submit you can simply buy an entry in DistroWatch. The subject also comes nowhere close to meeting in any way Deletion of Zorin OS (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16853 21438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khayal Dzhaniev User:Mdtemp 15:57, 14 August 2015 (UTC) delete Non-notable kickboxer and routine sports coverage doesn't meet Deletion of Khayal Dzhaniev WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16854 15206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All India Majlis Sada-e-Haq User:D4iNa4 13:04, 26 May 2020 (UTC) delete Fails . I don't think draftification will help Deletion of All India Majlis Sada-e-Haq WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16855 13027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Winter Storm Brutus User:gwickwire 03:00, 19 November 2012 (UTC) keep """Just my opinion, don't want to rehash this issue here. Also, the article has enough sourcing to meet RS, and in my opinion can be expanded upon. The storm is notable in that it dumped a 'ton' persay of snow over the northwest. Also, what support do you have for these """"unconstructive"""" edits? Also, USM, I'd strongly reccommend you read ollback|the rollback policy as you have used it incorrectly a few times now""" Deletion of Winter Storm Brutus WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
16856 16473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Los Baby's User:Chubbles 11:33, 7 October 2008 (UTC) keep """for procedural reasons. This is a bad-faith """"tit for tat"""" nomination made in response to my comment at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DJ Smallz. I contested the prod for Los Baby's, tagged the page {{tl|underconstruction}} and asked on the talk page for the community's patience as I translate the Spanish article on this phenomenally popular group with a decades-long career. I expect the community will give it to me, though I know from experience that the nominator will not, because he does not |assume good faith""" Deletion of Los Baby's WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
16857 766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Manning (2nd nomination) User:Billbowery 02:08, 20 August 2009 (UTC) delete as it does not pass Deletion of Mike Manning (2nd nomination) WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16858 14075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WNG560 User:Mrschimpf 06:20, 5 June 2018 (UTC) keep """They meet easily, but...I think a better mode of organization and article use would be to instead merge all these articles into one article serving a state or region, such as for this one List of NOAA Weather Radio stations in Oregon rather than individual articles about each station, which as-is has a skeleton of """"station is based in city and serves these counties"""". There are obviously exceptions to large-market stations such as the much-better organized National Weather Service Chicago, Illinois article and New York's KWO35 (which has a long, long history), but for the most part NOAA stations are operated by a state authority for the NOAA, and that's a better mode of organization than having an article like this one about a station that literally serves a middle-of-nowhere national forest whose only listeners are campers on weather watch""" Deletion of WNG560 WP:BROADCAST Wikipedia:Notability 77
16859 12635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cartoon Network schedule User:JayJay 06:30, 14 February 2021 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Cartoon Network schedule WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
16860 1863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlos Castillo (Colombian footballer) User:Pharaoh 21:51, 13 May 2018 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Carlos Castillo (Colombian footballer) WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16861 20372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of civil engineering schools User:Stifle 20:49, 20 September 2008 (UTC) delete for one thing this violates points 3 and 8, and additionally, the list only includes North American schools Deletion of List of civil engineering schools WP:LC Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
16862 13842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sherburn White Rose F.C. User:ItsZippy 21:23, 6 November 2011 (UTC) delete Does not meet the and, as a non-professional team, is not notable as a football club Deletion of Sherburn White Rose F.C. WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16863 3608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bhagwanji User:Deshnayak 15:37, 13 November 2020 (UTC) keep This article is about a person called Bhagwanji, who is still revered by many. The article doesn't try to prove that he was in fact Subhash Chandra Bose, but discusses from a neutral point of view about claims from certain sections who link him with Subhash Chandra Bose. It highlights the life of Bhagwanji and also delves into the intriguing legal procedure gaining lot of attention in . Merging this with {{slink|Death of Subhas Chandra Bose#Legends of Bose's survival}}, will drop lot of content and make the rest irrelevant. Please read the full article and help me improve it Deletion of Bhagwanji WP:NPOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
16864 10833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vasant Joglekar User:Υπογράφω 03:35, 20 February 2018 (UTC) keep I'm not surprised that Hindi director active in the 1960s does not have a ton of sources available readily available online. That doesn't mean he's non-notable, it just means there's bias to the available online sources. There are enough hits in the English Google book results to suggest that he's likely notable -- the best sources are likely offline, and in Hindi. This needs attention from a native speaker Deletion of Vasant Joglekar WP:SYSTEMIC Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
16865 11400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gimme What I Don't Know (I Want) User:Walter 03:10, 4 January 2020 (UTC) keep Has enough coverage to meet Deletion of Gimme What I Don't Know (I Want) :WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16866 21238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dean Shostak User:Whpq 17:18, 6 December 2010 (UTC) keep This musician meets the |general notability guidelines with significant coverage in indpendent reliable sources. The http://hamptonroads.com/node/198181 HamptonRoads peice cited in the article is a signficant profile where Shostak is the primary subject. A Google News search has a lot of results spanning multiple years. Most are behind pay walls, and many are concert annoucnements, but the abstracts chow fairly clearly that some of it is coverage about Shostak rather than concert listings. Beyond that we also have http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=aTMzAAAAIBAJ&sjid=rQgGAAAAIBAJ&pg=6939,4334213&dq=dean-shostak&hl=en Sunday Free Lance-Star, http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=4I4NAAAAIBAJ&sjid=NHADAAAAIBAJ&pg=5303,344214&dq=dean-shostak&hl=en Pittsburgh Post Gazette, and http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=76MpAAAAIBAJ&sjid=TewDAAAAIBAJ&pg=3800,4512124&dq=dean-shostak&hl=en Gainesville Sun - the latter two are not local to Williamsburg so coverage extends outside of the immediate locality Deletion of Dean Shostak WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16867 2384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Masseratti 2lts User:Armbrust 15:37, 23 September 2010 (UTC) delete as article fails |notability criteria for bands Deletion of Masseratti 2lts WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16868 11208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1993 Australian network television schedule (weekday) User:Niteshift36 08:25, 4 September 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of 1993 Australian network television schedule (weekday) WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16869 21494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel J. Edwards User:AmericanAir88 05:33, 27 August 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and per nom Deletion of Daniel J. Edwards WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16870 15112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willie Thornton (Canadian football) User:Paulmcdonald 20:09, 30 October 2020 (UTC) keep playing in the CFL does meet , good catch Deletion of Willie Thornton (Canadian football) WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
16871 9395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1843 Jarmila User:Padenton 17:28, 10 May 2015 (UTC) merge per () No significant coverage found on this object itself. Everything on google scholar is a paper listing several asteroids (explicitly mentioned in NASTCRIT #3 as not meeting notability) ― Deletion of 1843 Jarmila WP:NASTRO||WP:NASTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16872 8044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cthulhu Amulet User:Ihcoyc 14:29, 11 June 2007 (UTC) delete So there's a bit of Lovecraftiana, and apparently some kind of legend or theory about it has sprung up among Lovecraft fans, who blogged about it or wrote Usenet posts. The item remains a not particularly notable commercial product, and this article fails to make a case for notability and lacks |reliable sources Deletion of Cthulhu Amulet WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16873 21882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Games with ray tracing User:Zero 17:10, 28 August 2019 (UTC) delete I find this would |bloat out of control very quickly Deletion of Games with ray tracing WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
16874 4738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Belobogism User:JohnCD 15:28, 4 August 2012 (UTC) delete no |reliable |independent sources to indicate that this is |notable, or indeed more than something FT|made up one day. If not a hoax, it is at best OR|original research Deletion of Belobogism WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:N||WP:NFT||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16875 21299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Future of mathematics User:Colonel 12:40, 28 April 2010 (UTC) keep The recent work ''http://books.google.com/books?id=qjVaD1OQbxEC Mathematics: frontiers and perspectives'', produced under the auspices of the International Mathematical Union and written by several winners of the Fields Medal, demonstrates the continuing notability and merit of this topic. Bringing our article to a high standard is doubtless challenging but it is our |editing policy to persevere. Deletion would not assist this Deletion of Future of mathematics WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
16876 3160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Jahnke User:Punkmorten 12:59, 10 February 2009 (UTC) delete many news hits, but fails Deletion of Martin Jahnke WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16877 18945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Trump User:MB298 23:24, 23 March 2017 (UTC) keep for his activities and believe he meets Deletion of Robert Trump WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16878 6087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Dauterive (3rd nomination) user:Andrew 14:19, 4 October 2014 (UTC) keep """The result of the Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Dauterive (2nd nomination)|prior discussion was to keep the page as there was no consensus to delete it. No reason is provided to change this and so it's just a case of contrary to , """"'' It can be disruptive to repeatedly nominate a page in the hope of getting a different outcome""" Deletion of Bill Dauterive (3rd nomination) WP:KEEPLISTING||WP:DELAFD Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16879 11098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hoseynabad-e Khani, Arzuiyeh User:فرهنگ2016 13:53, 28 October 2019 (UTC) keep per .https://mapper.acme.com/?ll=28.675833,56.625&z=12&t=M&marker0=28.675833,56.625,Hoseynabad-e%20Khani%2C%20Arzuiyeh Deletion of Hoseynabad-e Khani, Arzuiyeh WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
16880 12537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of hotels in Port Harcourt User:Charlesdrakew 10:42, 19 November 2016 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of hotels in Port Harcourt WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16881 15436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/P. K. Krishna Das User:Lefcentreright 20:52, 17 February 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of P. K. Krishna Das WP:GNG||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16882 3237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Torre Futura User:Oakshade 03:37, 3 May 2010 (UTC) keep """Sure the article needs expansion and improvement, but that's what expansion and improvement tags are for. This topic in fact has received very significant coverage from reliable sources like La Prensa Gráfica and El Diario de Hoy http://www.laprensagrafica.com/economia/nacional/76814-agrisal-tiene-mas-proyectos-en-torno-a-torre-futura.htmlhttp://www.elsalvador.com/mwedh/nota/nota_completa.asp?idCat=6374&idArt=4298472http://www.laprensagrafica.com/el-salvador/lodeldia/76660-hoy-inauguran-torre-futura.htmlhttp://www.laprensagrafica.com/economia/nacional/73151-torre-futura-ya-tiene-ocupado-un-75-de-su-area-corporativa.html (these are just a few of the many I found), thus easily satisfying . And the nom simply stating """"Failure to meet """" with absolutely no argument as to why they feel that way gives the impression they want the article deleted for unknown reasons""" Deletion of Torre Futura WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16883 14609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monovia User:Paul 21:42, 2 November 2012 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability. Fails and may even be a candidate for speedy deletion Deletion of Monovia WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16884 20935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vance Syphers User:Hammersoft 15:31, 8 September 2019 (UTC) delete Nothing present to suggest meeting . Sure, this person has a web footprint, but that's not sufficient. Being an executive producer of two minor films isn't sufficient notability either Deletion of Vance Syphers WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16885 1129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lynn Coulter (2nd nomination) User:Rhododendrites 14:11, 27 June 2016 (UTC) delete Fails . Not seeing enough. &mdash Deletion of Lynn Coulter (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16886 8403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Legal drugs User:danntm 14:08, 27 September 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Legal drugs WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16887 13258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marrua User:Parsecboy 21:02, 26 May 2010 (UTC) keep an article being unintelligible is |not a reason to delete it. This vehicle is clearly worthy of an article Deletion of Marrua WP:RUBBISH Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16888 141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mannoorkavu temple User:Stifle 14:09, 18 August 2008 (UTC) delete due to the lack of |citations from |reliable sources, which are required by the |verifiability policy Deletion of Mannoorkavu temple WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16889 5920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antisemitic boycotts User:Joe 08:16, 31 August 2020 (UTC) delete """I agree that this is , plus a |POV fork of several existing articles on individual boycotts. The keeps above miss the point: yes, some sources make links between various boycotts and antisemitism, but that doesn't mean that """"antisemitic boycotts"""" is in itself a notable topic. For that we would need to see significant coverage that treats these boycotts together as a coherent topic, distinct from other forms of antisemitism, and under the |common name of """"antisemitic boycotts"""". Apart from the one JVL sourcehttps://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/anti-jewish-boycotts the nominator mentions, that coverage doesn't appear to exist. The historic boycotts are either discussed as independent events or as manifestations of antisemitism more broadly. The disputed position that links historic antisemitic boycotts to contemporary boycotts of Israel is already covered in a more balanced way at Boycotts of Israel. – """ Deletion of Antisemitic boycotts WP:SYNTH||WP:POVFORK||WP:COMMONNAME Wikipedia:No original research 65
16890 3651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gaby Hernandez (2nd nomination) [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 15:56, 30 April 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and . Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Gaby Hernandez (2nd nomination) WP:NBASEBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16891 2340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riley Shy User:Cerebellum 01:06, 14 September 2013 (UTC) delete Seems to fail Deletion of Riley Shy WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16892 16732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arshi Khan User:Britishfinance 13:02, 5 July 2020 (UTC) keep Suspect a bad faith nomination as this BLP actress has gotten involved in politics. Fail of per https://www.google.com/search?rlz=1C1CHZL_enIE785IE785&tbm=nws&ei=Kc8BX5eJAYeN1fAPxO6a6Ag&q=%22arshi+khan%22&oq=%22arshi+khan%22&gs_l=psy-ab.3...2549.4683.0.4896.2.2.0.0.0.0.70.126.2.2.0....0...1c.1.64.psy-ab..0.0.0....0.IYbL3dqApjI here Deletion of Arshi Khan WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16893 19493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walking With my Soul User:GPL93 16:10, 30 September 2019 (UTC) delete likely a for the book, which fails . Best Deletion of Walking With my Soul WP:PROMO||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16894 11238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rony (musical artist) User:JavaHurricane 09:33, 24 August 2021 (UTC) delete Delete both articles: attempts at promotion, failure of Deletion of Rony (musical artist) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16895 18913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sexuality of Abraham Lincoln (4th nomination) User:Dharmadhyaksha 07:39, 8 December 2015 (UTC) keep as the nomination is actually asking for merging/redirecting and AfDs are not for that. Also, no reason as such is provided in rationale; Deletion of Sexuality of Abraham Lincoln (4th nomination) WP:OSE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16896 3505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Napoleon Blownaparts User:Michig 11:37, 23 September 2017 (UTC) delete The vast majority of the content fails and the band doesn't appear to satisfy any of the criteria of . No significant coverage found in reliable sources Deletion of The Napoleon Blownaparts WP:V||WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16897 6027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flea Market Montgomery User:Mendaliv 09:32, 13 August 2008 (UTC) comment Specifically, I was referring to , ; the content of the article is little more than a biased towards discussing the meme, which I still suggest is of questionable notability. &mdash Deletion of Flea Market Montgomery WP:IINFO||WP:NOTADVOCATE||WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16898 19691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trumalia User:Col_tom 13:49, 6 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails . Will possibly pass the notability test in the future, but does not now Deletion of Trumalia WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16899 13818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kalyan Silks (2nd nomination) [[User talk:2409:4073:2012:E927:9DCB:43D3:32BA:78BC|talk]]) 14:41, 24 December 2019 (UTC) keep Notable company and satisfy and . But, the article definitely needs a rewrite and references need to be added which are available on the web. Should be tagged instead. Special:Contributions/2409:4073:2012:E927:9DCB:43D3:32BA:78BC|2409:4073:2012:E927:9DCB:43D3:32BA:78BC Deletion of Kalyan Silks (2nd nomination) WP:CORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16900 11782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liban Soleman User:Namiba 02:48, 26 June 2017 (UTC) keep sources available indicate article passes Deletion of Liban Soleman WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16901 21208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cocoa Mountain User:Atlantic306 20:19, 19 June 2020 (UTC) keep well it's definitely not a G11, it has no extensive use of peacock terms unless you count small, gourmet, or exotic truffles. It also has significant coverage in Scottish reliable sources such as Daily Herald and Northern Times as well as featuring in a Channel 4 programme, passes imv Deletion of Cocoa Mountain WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
16902 2656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chiyo Miyako (2nd nomination) User:CommanderLinx 11:32, 26 November 2018 (UTC) delete to appropriate list. and should almost certainly apply here. There is absolutely nothing to say about her other than she was born, got married to a husband who traveled a lot, she liked eel, became the oldest in the world and then died. Majority of the article restates table info easily seen and better handled in Oldest people Deletion of Chiyo Miyako (2nd nomination) WP:NOPAGE||WP:PERMASTUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16903 15045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Similarities between Jesus and Horus User:Moreschi 15:11, 10 January 2007 (UTC) delete large-scale |original research, essays of this nature neither needed nor wanted Deletion of Similarities between Jesus and Horus WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16904 9309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khumalo Derivative User:Bearian 20:27, 3 August 2009 (UTC) delete WP:FRINGE|fringe theory, |original work, or a |hoax Deletion of Khumalo Derivative WP:OR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
16905 7983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pavel Novotný (actor) User:L293D 00:57, 10 March 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Pavel Novotný (actor) WP:PORNBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16906 16338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Monster-of-the-Week characters in The X-Files User:Bearian 13:33, 25 May 2017 (UTC) delete personally, I liked these episodes, but |we are not a web host Deletion of List of Monster-of-the-Week characters in The X-Files WP:NOTWEBHOST Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16907 8031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Margunn Bjørnholt User:Kaldari 20:25, 7 October 2014 (UTC) keep Seems to pass per Eric Deletion of Margunn Bjørnholt WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16908 4710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leathes Prior User:Bearian 20:36, 30 January 2014 (UTC) keep WP:AGF|assuming that everything can be |verified by |reliable sources, this passes Deletion of Leathes Prior WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16909 7159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Diamond User:Isotope23 15:28, 26 April 2006 (UTC) delete doesn't meet criteria Deletion of Richard Diamond WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16910 14159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hafiz al Millat Mufti Abdul Aziz Ashrafi Muhaddith Mubarakpuri User:Rpclod 03:06, 14 August 2015 (UTC) delete The article provides no references, let alone any |reliable sources Deletion of Hafiz al Millat Mufti Abdul Aziz Ashrafi Muhaddith Mubarakpuri WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16911 20902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Celebrity Cafe User:Bob 18:51, 18 March 2011 (UTC) delete whilst the site appears to be used as a source for showbiz gossip with moderate frequency but does not appear to have obtained notability independently per quick googling. The tone of the nom isn't very helpful though, if you object to some uncited facts remove them (incidently they seem to have been taken from the website itself http://thecelebritycafe.com/about-us), if you think this is or spam then you could put that in the nomination Deletion of The Celebrity Cafe WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16912 7784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013 Mother's Day Parade shooting User:Tarc 13:56, 13 May 2013 (UTC) delete This IMO was what was envisioned to defend the project against; routine newswire stories. It wasn't a terrorist attack, it was spillover from gang violence, which it not all that uncommon in urban America. Sad, but true. If you look at an event and all you can say about it is a recitation of where-it-happened, who-did-it, etc... then what you have is a news article, not an encyclopedia entry Deletion of 2013 Mother's Day Parade shooting WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16913 20632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kolawole Sunday User:K 03:49, 20 August 2018 (UTC) delete a promotional page on a nn music manager. Does not meet Deletion of Kolawole Sunday WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16914 12538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Analytical Graphics (2nd nomination) User:Kingofaces43 04:26, 31 July 2016 (UTC) delete Not notable per . I found no secondary coverage aside from a boilerplate description of what the company does http://www.bloomberg.com/research/stocks/private/snapshot.asp?privcapId=24852 here, but that's a largely indiscriminate source Deletion of Analytical Graphics (2nd nomination) WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
16915 16799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Historical development of Ganesha User:Nyttend 19:53, 30 January 2011 (UTC) delete a great example of why speedy criterion |A10 was introduced. This is too old for A10, but it should be deleted for the same reasons Deletion of Historical development of Ganesha WP:A10 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
16916 3829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Kaplowitz User:Sugarpine 23:01, 20 September 2006 (UTC) delete WP:BIO and maybe a sentence of Deletion of Josh Kaplowitz WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
16917 4479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohamed Adel User:Sir 17:58, 27 July 2015 (UTC) keep The article clearly meets as he has played in a fully professional league Deletion of Mohamed Adel WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16918 9422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raleigh Muns User:Matthew 10:30, 13 May 2007 (UTC) keep The article contains multiple sources establishing notability, inline with Wikipedia:Notability (people) (sources given are also |verifiable and |reliable). I do believe, however, that this article could be sourced better—preferably with inline citations. It could also be copy edited to a higher quality. Remember, #PAPER|Wikipedia is not paper, so... while the Encyclopaedia Britannica may not have an article on this person, Wikipedia can Deletion of Raleigh Muns WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16919 21950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tales From The Pit User:Dragonfiend 23:17, 24 April 2006 (UTC) delete article does not meet Deletion of Tales From The Pit WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
16920 7085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islam and civil rights User:Lilac 18:44, 19 March 2009 (UTC) delete could potentially be a valid article but would require starting from scratch and not working from this |biased article Deletion of Islam and civil rights WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
16921 11299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Süleyman Luş User:Spiderone 15:59, 3 August 2021 (UTC) delete I agree that the sources presented are not significant enough. I did also find https://www.sportifcumleler.com/2019/04/suleyman-lusda-ulkenin-en-iyi-yerli-sol.html this, but it looks like a Galatasaray fan site so probably doesn't meet our requirements at . https://duckduckgo.com/?q=%22S%C3%BCleyman+Lu%C5%9F%22&t=h_&ia=web Turkish source search didn't yield anything better Deletion of Süleyman Luş WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16922 1685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of video games rated E10+ User:Randomran 20:39, 21 December 2008 (UTC) delete as and #DIRECTORY Deletion of List of video games rated E10+ WP:SALAT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
16923 2842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adeel pk User:AllyD 09:15, 27 February 2017 (UTC) delete """Notability is and the available coverage is of the offspring-of-famous-parent-getting-started-in-the-trade tendency. As to the article text, it is encrusted with |promotion. Whether or not the subject is """"all set to engage audiences with his tricky cinematography and modern-day filmmaking techniques"""" that is text; as things stand, the subject meets none of the criteria, nor broader notability""" Deletion of Adeel pk :WP:NOTINHERITED||:WP:POV||:WP:CRYSTAL||:WP:FILMMAKER||:WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16924 10021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/StarMUD User:Marasmusine 14:00, 10 December 2007 (UTC) delete I would love to have an article on this, one of my favouriate MUDs (from back when I used to play them) but we've been waiting for independent references for some time now. Delete and rewrite from scratch using when reliable coverage materializes Deletion of StarMUD WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
16925 7479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joel Hayward User:FisherQueen 18:04, 14 May 2007 (UTC) comment I can't decide until I get home, because many of the sources are blocked from work; he apparently is most |notable as the author of a work in defense of Holocaust deniers, which he has since tried to distance himself, but someone with unfiltered internet access will be better able to fill in details to determine notability Deletion of Joel Hayward WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16926 10952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geneva Conventions controversy User:Hrafn 04:05, 28 November 2010 (UTC) delete as , under a poorly thought out title. An article on the legal status of war on terror suspects (under both international, and relevant national, law) would probably be appropriate (if sourced to solid legal scholarship) -- but this isn't the seed for such an article Deletion of Geneva Conventions controversy WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16927 11490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kovas Boguta User:Janejellyroll 08:47, 1 February 2007 (UTC) delete for failing Deletion of Kovas Boguta WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16928 9597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mario Herrera User:Edwardx 23:21, 10 February 2017 (UTC) delete Fails . Not much coverage, and his job titles are not significant enough to merit articles on holders of such posts Deletion of Mario Herrera WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16929 6613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monochrome BBS (2nd nomination) User:WngLdr34 19:15, 18 November 2009 (UTC) delete Not notable, Deletion of Monochrome BBS (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
16930 3475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pin Young User:Shruti14 03:41, 21 March 2008 (UTC) delete can add later when she does something more notable, currently non-notable per Deletion of Pin Young WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16931 17998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Doe (3rd nomination) User:Mattythewhite 10:48, 4 August 2009 (UTC) keep I think Jmorrison has hit the nail on the head here. While the article presently fails , I think the sources included help establish notability as per . Cheers Deletion of Scott Doe (3rd nomination) WP:BIO||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16932 12270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herbert B. Mayo User:Eric 00:46, 28 October 2009 (UTC) keep With an h-index of 4 and a top WorldCat holding of 148, I do not think he meets criterion #1. However, based on http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&source=hp&q=%22Herbert+B.+Mayo%22+syllabus&btnG=Google+Search&aq=f&oq=&aqi= a search for syllabi listing his books, I think he meets criterion #4 (significant impact in the area of higher education, affecting a substantial number of academic institutions Deletion of Herbert B. Mayo WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16933 100 [[AXIe AdvancedTCA Extensions for Instrumentation and Test]] (SLA) Benutzer:Okmijnuhb NONE delete """Ein zwei Wochen alter Standard, der von 3 Unternehmen getragen wird und der """"dazu führen kann, daß AXIe am Markt als Ergänzung zu anderen Standards gesehen wird"""", weil er den Vorteil hat, dass viele einen Teil ihrer Systeme behalten können. Für wenig verständlich und wohl noch nicht relevant. , falls nichts umwerfendes kommt""" Löschung von AXIe AdvancedTCA Extensions for Instrumentation and Test Wikipedia:OMA Wikipedia:Allgemeinverständlichkeit 79
16934 3949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skilgannon the Damned User:MacGyverMagic 23:50, 16 November 2008 (UTC) merge to Drenai Series (per Deletion of Skilgannon the Damned WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16935 3446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avalon Roberts User:Powerful 15:08, 22 May 2021 (UTC) delete as per nom. Subject fails Deletion of Avalon Roberts WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16936 4483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Belsey (educator) User:1292simon 01:46, 15 December 2012 (UTC) delete Current article is and a community service medal is not enough to establish notability in my opinion Deletion of Bill Belsey (educator) WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
16937 13272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pink Floyd trivia (2nd nomination) User:Whstchy 17:28, 4 June 2007 (UTC) delete and do John's suggestion. Fails Deletion of Pink Floyd trivia (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16938 16326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marissa Tait User:onel5969 13:23, 6 January 2016 (UTC) delete While I love to figure out a way to keep articles about folks like this, she simply doesn't pass either (not enough in-depth coverage from reliable sources) or (not enough significant roles in notable projects). The soap is a good gig, but the short-lived Baby-Bob bit doesn't quite make it. She had a major role in ''The Last Resort'', but I question the notability of the film (appears to be a low-budget slasher film Deletion of Marissa Tait WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16939 20717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disappearance of Brandi Wells User:Cullen328 06:53, 27 January 2018 (UTC) keep """per , which states """"The disappearance of a person would fall under this guideline if law enforcement agencies deemed it likely to have been caused by criminal conduct, regardless of whether a perpetrator is identified or charged."""" An event of 12 years ago is hardly """"news""" Deletion of Disappearance of Brandi Wells WP:CRIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
16940 19329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pabulo Henrique Rampelotto User:Nsk92 23:21, 23 September 2011 (UTC) delete Almost zero citability in GoogleScholar and WebOfScience, nothing else to indicate passing . Plus appears to be a case Deletion of Pabulo Henrique Rampelotto WP:PROF||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16941 15607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacob L. Mey User:Bearian 22:13, 9 November 2010 (UTC) keep per . He was Professor Emeritus or professor at several major academic institutions Deletion of Jacob L. Mey WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16942 9247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Austin Regional Clinic User:Sam 01:28, 24 August 2019 (UTC) delete as there are no non-local sources, per — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Austin Regional Clinic WP:AUD Wikipedia:Notability 77
16943 10556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hilda Lamas User:Belovedfreak 17:40, 26 August 2008 (UTC) delete will probably be notable at some point, but not yet. Début CD (album?) set for release in late 2008 so doesn't meet criterion 5 of . I can't see any significant coverage in |reliable sources either, and doesn't seem to be mentioned on AllMusic. I would say delete, allowing for recreation after début release, if there is significant coverage then Deletion of Hilda Lamas WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16944 6240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antonio Cárdenas Rodriguez User:Location 05:45, 11 January 2012 (UTC) keep per Wikipedia:Speedy keep #1. Head of Mexican Air Force should pass Deletion of Antonio Cárdenas Rodriguez WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16945 13921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suparatana Bencharongkul User:MA 17:17, 6 July 2019 (UTC) keep Meets the . I think should be kept if unaffected by the sockpuppetry issue Deletion of Suparatana Bencharongkul WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16946 21696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Kent User:WilliamJE 11:26, 14 January 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Anthony Kent WP:NBASKETBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16947 11517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Out of the Blue (Oxford University) User:SkierRMH 21:24, 23 December 2006 (UTC) delete Here we go again... fails Deletion of Out of the Blue (Oxford University) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16948 10852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Junior's unofficial mascot owl User:Argyle 04:31, 16 March 2011 (UTC) delete Non-notable owl which fails and . The subject receives sufficient coverage at Luis Moreno (footballer Deletion of Junior's unofficial mascot owl WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
16949 18385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Illmanic User:Dgf32 16:38, 17 April 2008 (UTC) delete Fails to meet notability requirements per otability and otability (films Deletion of Illmanic WP:N||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
16950 3110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaali Khuhi User:Atlantic306 23:05, 1 November 2020 (UTC) keep as the film has now been released and has received significant coverage in multiple reliable sources such as reviews by eight professional critics for publications such as First Post and Hindustan Times linked at Rotten Tomatoes so that is passed and deletion is unnecessary in my view Deletion of Kaali Khuhi WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
16951 6040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Georg H.B. Luck User:David 08:44, 24 February 2013 (UTC) keep This is not the sort of field where I would expect Google scholar to be helpful in judging his impact (especially since he did much of his work pre-internet) but his ''Arcana mundi'' is held in nearly 1000 libraries and has nearly 200 citations on Google scholar, his 1997 German-language collection of texts of the cynics has recently been translated into Dutch with a nice review http://www.vn.nl/boeken/literaire-kroniek/waarin-het-cynisme-concurrentie-krijgt-van-het-kynisme/, his ''The Latin love elegy'' was translated into 5 languages, the ''New York Times'' in the late 1990s recalled him as ten years earlier being a leader of a group of anti-postmodern reactionaries, etc. I think he passes both #C1 and Deletion of Georg H.B. Luck WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16952 12326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aditya Akella User:David 05:42, 29 June 2017 (UTC) keep per #C1 as above, although I think having a publication with over 1000 cites and 19 with over 100 https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=d_rxnzAAAAAJ&hl=en is more relevant than the h-index here Deletion of Aditya Akella WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16953 10259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Nathaniel Henry Peters (2nd nomination) User:Jeffro77 01:24, 8 August 2010 (UTC) comment """If the article survives the AfD, I wouldn't have any problem with Cindamuse's suggestion to rename (per ) if he is better known as """"George N. H. Peters"""" (with the proper spacing""" Deletion of George Nathaniel Henry Peters (2nd nomination) WP:COMMON "Wikipedia:What ""Ignore all rules"" means" 62
16954 18212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SSSniperwolf User:The 22:43, 9 May 2020 (UTC) delete """A case of a gallant attempt at fame, initiated by an editor with a declared interest in putting up in Wikipedia articles about """"YouTubers, influencers,"""" etc. However, there are no adequate sources, either in number or in quality, to support the case for our subject's |notaibility. |Google hits and |YouTube views are unimportant in the context of sourcing""" Deletion of SSSniperwolf WP:NPERSON||WP:GOONOTE||WP:YT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16955 18698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Representative of Montserrat, London (2nd nomination) [[User talk:180.172.239.231|talk]]) 10:22, 3 September 2014 (UTC) delete Neither the |organization nor the |building is notable.--Special:Contributions/180.172.239.231|180.172.239.231 Deletion of Representative of Montserrat, London (2nd nomination) WP:ORG||WP:GEOFEAT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16956 11708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Designer baby User:Runningonbrains 15:16, 19 June 2009 (UTC) comment It is neither logical nor helpful to have information on the same topic at two different locations. That is why we have edirect|redirects Deletion of Designer baby WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
16957 4088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yannis's Law User:Mediavalia 10:35, 18 November 2014 (UTC) comment I've worked in the IT industry for 16 years and I've never heard of the so-called law or its author. It does smack a bit of |inherited notability by association to Moore's Law that everyone knows about. It is not a law, it's a hypothesis and one which the originator did not even test, so it's irrelevant. I still say delete Deletion of Yannis's Law WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
16958 18419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PSP (Firmware) User:NeoChaosX 19:20, 27 October 2006 (UTC) delete as Wikipedia |is not a web directory ''or'' a how-to guide Deletion of PSP (Firmware) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16959 4569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Part Two of the Fundamental Statute of the Kingdom of Albania User:Tillerh11 00:39, 12 July 2018 (UTC) delete per nominator, fails . Nothing else on the page Deletion of Part Two of the Fundamental Statute of the Kingdom of Albania WP:NOTREPOSITORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16960 6556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Forced orgasm User:Claritas 13:54, 2 June 2010 (UTC) delete no significant coverage in reliable sources, fails Deletion of Forced orgasm WP:NRVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16961 19052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Sandifer User:Thivierr 20:02, 26 May 2006 (UTC) delete """failes . The only test relevent is """"''The person has been the primary subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the person. (Multiple similar stories describing a single day's news event only count as one coverage.)''"""". One event with little coverage doesn't measure up""" Deletion of Philip Sandifer WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16962 6734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamandag User:Dvyost 05:31, 10 October 2005 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet criteria Deletion of Kamandag WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16963 1789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gilliver User:Blue520 20:50, 4 April 2006 (UTC) delete is a neologism , with out verification of its use the page is just an attack page Deletion of Gilliver WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
16964 5648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Metropolitan Jewish Hospice User:AdventurousSquirrel 07:14, 28 April 2014 (UTC) delete I've added a few external links, but none/all of them don't represent significant coverage. I'm sure the organization does good work, but Wikipedia is Deletion of Metropolitan Jewish Hospice WP:NOTADIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16965 9852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farooq Bakshi User:Eric 02:24, 18 April 2009 (UTC) delete Passes neither nor in a verifiable way. A grand total of ZERO hits on Google Scholar, Google News, Google Books, and WorldCat. The English WP is the main/global WP, so notability should be verifiable through international sources, ideally sources that are widely available to the participants in AfD discussions. Otherwise we may fall into the trap of having to lower the standards of notability for lack of verifiable sources of notability for certain subjects. In my opinion, it is not good practice to justify a keep recommendation based on the assumption that sources of notability MAY or PROBABLY exist, for this or that subject, but are not currently available. As for their language, it certainly does not have to be English Deletion of Farooq Bakshi WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
16966 6327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss Universe 2011 User:Mmyers1976 18:44, 7 April 2010 (UTC) delete per . —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Miss Universe 2011 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16967 18972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noel Burnet User:Kb 19:39, 20 December 2017 (UTC) keep but wouldn't be opposed to a merge. Might be just enough significant independent coverage to pass the , but as others have queried, is he actually notable or is the coverage of the Koala Park only sufficient to give notability to the Park? Remember that notability is not inherited Deletion of Noel Burnet WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16968 8200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hersham FC User:Sir 17:25, 27 January 2012 (UTC) delete per #A7 Deletion of Hersham FC WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
16969 4522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islamic University Laboratory School & College User:TimothyBlue 08:27, 17 December 2020 (UTC) merge """and trim to Islamic University, Bangladesh: Per , """"Faculties, departments or degree programs within a university, college, or school are generally not considered notable unless they have made significant contributions to their field."""". The content will fit well into the target article and improve it. As a stand alone article, the subject does not have from addressing the subject directly and in depth. // """ Deletion of Islamic University Laboratory School & College WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES||WP:SIGCOV||WP:IS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
16970 17481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Standard (warez) (2nd nomination) User:Equendil 10:48, 22 September 2008 (UTC) delete Informal standards set by unnamed committees with dubious authority to do so. Essentially |original research, no reliable third party sources, ie it fails and I can't see it improving seeing as the article is several years old already Deletion of Standard (warez) (2nd nomination) WP:OR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
16971 234 [[Karl Fees (Politiker, 1889)]] (gelöscht) Benutzerin:CaroFraTyskland NONE delete da enzyklopädische Relevanz gemäß unserer nicht dargestellt Löschung von Karl Fees (Politiker, 1889) Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
16972 10401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shermco Industries User:VMS 03:12, 16 October 2015 (UTC) keep as meeting Deletion of Shermco Industries WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16973 19124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francisco Rico Castro User:Sir 16:05, 22 March 2010 (UTC) delete As stated above, since he doesn't play in a fully pro league, he fails , and I can't find any significant coverage to merit keeping this article under Deletion of Francisco Rico Castro WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16974 14142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raymond A. Watson (2nd nomination) User:Alzarian16 19:10, 2 October 2011 (UTC) keep Coverage is not exclusively local, nor is it exclusively routine and/or trivial, so I don't think either of those arguments holds water. With the depth and range of news reporting that he seems to have accumulated, I can't see how Watson fails /. Maybe this means that the guideline is too broad and accepts articles that it shouldn't, but that would be much better discussed elsewhere and certainly isn't a reason for deleting in this specific case. Nor would retaining this article create a precedent of any kind, since the decision should (and hopefully will) be based on the article in question rather than any general principle Deletion of Raymond A. Watson (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
16975 4801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Great Spider User:Auric 21:35, 4 January 2020 (UTC) keep Article could use more work, but seems balanced. has already been applied Deletion of Great Spider WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
16976 188 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Mavi Şeker Kullanıcı:manco capac'''m'''an•'''c'''a 13.22, 19 Şubat 2020 (UTC) comment Arkadaşlar bu tip maddeleri Madde 1 e gore bir hizmetli hemen silebilir. Buraya getirmeden HS etiketi ref M1 koyarak gonderin gitsin. Teşekkürler Mavi Şeker'in silinmesi Vikipedi:HS Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
16977 1679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dorothy of Oz (film) User:Ginsengbomb 01:51, 22 June 2010 (UTC) delete """After some thought and searching, I really can't find evidence in ''reliable'' sources that the animation equivalent of """"principal photography"""" (which I would consider actual animation work plus voice work with actors -- any work that brings some relative finality to the cast and crew) has actually commenced. All we have is a primary source indicating that it is """"in production,"""" with suspiciously recent (within the last few days) release of """"character sketches."""" This, in the absence of reliable sourcing that says otherwise, strongly suggests that the level of certainty looked for in with its principal photography guideline does not ''yet'' exist. That said, this topic is almost entirely certain to pass NFF with flying colors at some point in the future, possibly in the relatively near future. But, until then, my opinion is that it's a delete""" Deletion of Dorothy of Oz (film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
16978 5099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ross Mark User:Resolute 05:39, 1 December 2008 (UTC) delete Drumheller Falcons, eh? Wow... He played for perhaps the worst team in AJHL history. That would be tier II junior, not even the highest level of ''junior hockey'', nevermind anything that would pass Deletion of Ross Mark WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
16979 189 [[Departament für Europarecht am Justizministerium der Republik Litauen]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Sanandros 09:14, 22. Apr. 2015 (CEST) keep Gemäss #Beh.C3.B6rden_und_.C3.84mter_auf_nationaler_Ebene|RKs Relevant da es eine eigene Behörde darstellt (siehe ref) und nicht eine Abteilung des Innenministeriums ist Löschung von Departament für Europarecht am Justizministerium der Republik Litauen Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
16980 17899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of victims of the Virginia Tech massacre (3rd nomination) User:Spawn 11:39, 25 September 2007 (UTC) merge Into whichever page is appropriate. #MEMORIAL|WP:IS NOT A MEMORIAL; the individuals are not notable on their own. There's a lot of emotion going around, but just because you delete an article about them, doesn't mean you're deleting the victims. Let's be rational, they're NN for wikipedia (Apart from the ones the nom mentioned), and should be merged Deletion of List of victims of the Virginia Tech massacre (3rd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
16981 1620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DWFJ User:Superastig 15:30, 8 June 2021 (UTC) keep The station is licensed by the NTC as it indicates an operator having a station. It was initially issued a PA per http://storage.googleapis.com/request-attachments/AV4y9qh3QvqYRdiDILKyN9nVIEnGnFovM9uuKB8iRaRW7PRrO633PGaXjSEULkqvEmjorBtVejJ00OBQf6uq5cH0nMZNFTt12UrY/FM%20STATIONS_2019.pdf 2019 NTC Listing. It was only http://storage.googleapis.com/request-attachments/krwjuYylHVSLLIneBnTI5jc9Tbe8fFM96hdHaRzlgo7uawnkM2AZ1usAzYkN26EeDvlaV0yL56GpT830ccMGHZyTnhk31ReKna5l/FM%20Listing.pdf last year's listing when it was given a callsign. That said, the article is good enough to pass /OUTCOMES Deletion of DWFJ WP:BCAST||WP:BCASTOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Notability 77
16982 155 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/1990 Sonrası Türk Sineması """Kullanıcı:pragdon'''pragdon'''""" 22:08, 17 Ocak 2018 (UTC) delete Güzel bir kaynak kitap ama vikipedide maddesi olacak kadar da KD değil maalesef. kriterlerini karşılamıyor 1990 Sonrası Türk Sineması'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
16983 18594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stereotypes of Canadians User:Bearcat 17:53, 22 May 2019 (UTC) delete per . I grant that it's possible that a genuinely ''good'' article could possibly be written about this topic, so no prejudice against recreation in the future if somebody can do a much better job than this — but as written, this is neither a good article about the topic nor even the seed from which a good article about the topic could sprout Deletion of Stereotypes of Canadians WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
16984 9456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guest Keen Williams User:Wildhorse3 19:04, 3 June 2021 (UTC) delete Badly fails . Non-notable Deletion of Guest Keen Williams WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16985 18471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellen Adarna User:Armbrust 19:42, 31 August 2010 (UTC) delete as article fails |notability criteria for entertainers Deletion of Ellen Adarna WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
16986 12221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indonesians in the Philippines User:Waitak 13:29, 2 June 2006 (UTC) merge provided that it's cleaned up first, to comply with and erifiability Deletion of Indonesians in the Philippines WP:NPOV||WP:V Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
16987 20385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meltan and Melmetal User:Juxlos 00:17, 29 November 2018 (UTC) keep Passes per Deletion of Meltan and Melmetal WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16988 17971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natsuki Okamoto User:Bakazaka 18:41, 18 July 2018 (UTC) keep Probably fails but Oricon profile ({{url|https://www.oricon.co.jp/prof/330395/}}) shows enough activity in TV, movies, and advertising to (barely) pass . Only needs to pass one of those notability guidelines, so keep Deletion of Natsuki Okamoto WP:GNG||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
16989 997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Chapman (Canadian) User:Ohconfucius 15:11, 28 October 2010 (UTC) delete do not pass |go, do not collect $200. All of the sources cited either fail 'trivial mentions' or Deletion of Jim Chapman (Canadian) WP:BIO||WP:SPS Wikipedia:Notability 77
16990 1554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Body Transfer [[User talk:159.182.1.4|talk]]) 19:25, 10 April 2009 (UTC) keep 1) Has been licensed in France. 2) In what way is it not enough? I've seen this argument used before, but I see nothing under that seems to indicate, like, a number. To my reading, what's there IS enough, once you add the mania review. Special:Contributions/159.182.1.4|159.182.1.4 Deletion of Body Transfer WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
16991 7110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chad Nance User:Onorem 12:04, 28 September 2007 (UTC) delete """http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&safe=off&q=%22Chad+Nance%22+gonzo&btnG=Search """"Chad Nance"""" gonzo returns 7 ghits. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&safe=off&q=%22Chad+Nance%22+skunk&btnG=Search """"Chad Nance"""" skunk returns 7 ghits. http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Chad+Nance%22+journalist&hl=en&safe=off&start=10&sa=N """"Chad Nance"""" journalist jumps to 16 ghits. All either this page, blogs, messageboards, or myspace. No |reliable sources provided that |verify any type of |notability""" Deletion of Chad Nance WP:RS||WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16992 5424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Debórah Dwork User:David 21:56, 13 July 2017 (UTC) keep Along with the clear pass of already demonstrated above, she passes for her heavily reviewed and adapted books. I just added ten book reviews as sources to the article, and that was only for her first two books Deletion of Debórah Dwork WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
16993 19757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guest and employee advocacy at casinos User:Ohconfucius 10:02, 3 May 2007 (UTC) delete WP:WALL|walled-garden of |nn |spam. There's really nothing to distinguish these notions from the less sector-specific concepts of advocacy and Turnover (employment)|Staff turnover except it being shrouded in buzz Deletion of Guest and employee advocacy at casinos WP:N||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
16994 6133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Wanjala [[User talk:Williamborg|Williamborg]] ([[User talk:Williamborg|Bill]]) 00:54, 17 September 2006 (UTC) delete """mdash;Does not meet Wikipedia:Notability. is probably too harsh. Vanity articles that make no plausible claim of notability may be speedied. Those that offer some claim of notability, however remote, are usually sent to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion. This one has enough notability, however remote, to warrant this thoughtful review. That said, in my judgement it does fail Wikipedia:Notability (people); specifically the requirement that """"The person made a widely recognized contribution that is part of the enduring historical record in their specific field,"""" since none of the other criteria come close to being satisified""" Deletion of John Wanjala WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
16995 9136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leader-1 User:Knowledgekid87 15:58, 11 October 2019 (UTC) keep for now. I feel this article just needs a bit of cleanup, it has sources which include TIME magazine among others. Was there a check done for sources Deletion of Leader-1 WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
16996 11367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keith Barber User:Xxanthippe 10:20, 17 October 2009 (UTC) keep As shown above, clearly satisfies rof #1 according to usual criteria with a solid record of scholarship. Article needs expansion Deletion of Keith Barber WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
16997 17728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Huang De-hui User:Vycl1994 23:52, 21 October 2019 (UTC) delete A connected with the 2018 Yilan train derailment, where Huang is not mentioned. Based on the number of sources Special:Permalink/922307136|currently in the article, his influence on the event is not very large Deletion of Huang De-hui WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
16998 5606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Txgarage User:Metropolitan90 13:15, 12 July 2011 (UTC) delete No |independent reliable sources have been provided, and I haven't found any myself Deletion of Txgarage WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
16999 12782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor Prober User:CAPTAIN 19:35, 25 April 2017 (UTC) delete non-notable Deletion of Doctor Prober WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17000 21879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of artists who have covered The Beatles User:Sephiroth 06:48, 8 May 2009 (UTC) delete This could basically encompass 95% of all musical artists. Per Stifle, fails Deletion of List of artists who have covered The Beatles WP:LC Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
17001 11155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of As the World Turns User:Kww 12:25, 28 October 2011 (UTC) delete per #PLOT.&mdash Deletion of History of As the World Turns WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17002 19745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pacifica Online User:Hobbes 13:46, 30 October 2011 (UTC) delete Article's four refs are all primary. Nothing in Metacritic or GameRankings. All the Gnews and general search hits I see are primary, sales sites, directory listings, and press release mirrors. Happy to look again if anyone can find something substantial from an site Deletion of Pacifica Online WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17003 18987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dexter Danger User:Rorshacma 16:53, 4 May 2021 (UTC) delete As far as I can see, there is not a single reference from a reliable, secondary source in the article. The multitude of references listed are just things like user reviews, track listings, sales pages, etc. Not a single one of them is actual coverage that would pass the or . Searching for any additional references that includes actual coverage from a reliable source turns up nothing Deletion of Dexter Danger WP:GNG||WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17004 9571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/6-7 September exhibition assault User:Dr 22:06, 23 February 2013 (UTC) keep Per Proudbolsahye and per significant, |well-covered historic event Deletion of 6-7 September exhibition assault WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17005 1888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mutha's Day Out User:wknight94 16:47, 28 January 2006 (UTC) comment Maybe I need an education here. Being an opening act on a tour is still considered a tour in regards to ? If so, then I agree - close this one up Deletion of Mutha's Day Out WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17006 14670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in East Sussex User:Beagel 14:28, 26 March 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of bus routes in East Sussex WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17007 17419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeremiah Red User:Runawaytonight 10:11, 19 December 2019 (UTC) comment Yes, {{u|Maile66}}, I blocked the editor for the combination of promotional editing with a promotional username implying shared use – which includes several years of |undisclosed paid contributions (the editor claims to be Deletion of Jeremiah Red WP:UPE Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
17008 14531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ravi Arvind Palat User:David 15:58, 1 June 2009 (UTC) delete Does not seem to be making the impact required to pass #1, and no evidence of passing the other criteria either. One edited volume, one book, and a bunch of papers, none of which appears to be particularly highly cited, adds up to an academic record that does not appear to be one of any great prominence. As Hairhorn and Xxanthippe aptly describe, chairing a department is also not unusual and explicitly not part of the criteria Deletion of Ravi Arvind Palat WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17009 8564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Testing reading User:Mr 14:59, 31 October 2008 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not a term paper repository Deletion of Testing reading WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17010 5010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Calzavara User:Bearian 14:41, 3 March 2020 (UTC) delete per . , and . It makes covers for cell towers to make you think you're looking at a tree or something else other than a cell tower Deletion of Calzavara WP:SPAM||WP:MILL||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Spam 112
17011 4988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul R. Gregory User:Lightburst 15:59, 14 June 2020 (UTC) keep WP:CREATIVE#1 non-trivial coverage of this subject also exists. The artist is clearly a leader in his field of work. Some of these sources are passing mention, some are interviews, however collectively they show that the subject passes https://heavymusicartwork.com/paul-r-gregory-studio54/ Heavy Music Artwork, http://www.tolkienlibrary.com/press/1082-Art-of-Paul-Raymond-Gregory.php Tolkien Library, https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/features/bloodstock-open-air-festival-art-metal-paul-gregory-a7880701.html Independent, https://books.google.com/books?id=duLYBgAAQBAJ&pg=PT138&lpg=PT138&dq=Paul+R.+Gregory+artist&source=bl&ots=P6CzZFNQt7&sig=ACfU3U02jIVF2Zdqk9FH2Rbjipx3aa-c4g&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwi1rOTz04HqAhVxQjABHQiVASc4ChDoATAFegQIChAB#v=onepage&q=Paul%20R.%20Gregory%20artist&f=false Master of the Moon: Ronnie James Dio, https://www.trebuchet-magazine.com/tolkien-art-metal-paul-r-gregory-interview/ Trebuchet Magazine Interview, https://greatalbumcovers.com/paul-raymond-gregory-heavy-metals-lord-of-the-rings/ Great album Covers Deletion of Paul R. Gregory WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17012 5342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Munk One User:Kinu 17:06, 28 November 2006 (UTC) delete no evidence from of meeting . Also a suspected article Deletion of Munk One WP:RS||WP:BIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17013 12867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noah D. Taylor User:Mendaliv 05:20, 8 September 2008 (UTC) delete failing and . Three of his compositions were linked to places where you can buy them too... wonderful. Blatantly an |autiobiography considering the article creator, {{user|Ndtaylor40}}. There's also copyvio on this page from the subject's homepage. &mdash Deletion of Noah D. Taylor WP:NOTADVERTISING||WP:NOTDIRECTORY||WP:AB Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17014 16810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Georgia Breweries, Wineries, and Distilleries User:Rusf10 22:48, 6 April 2019 (UTC) delete as per , we don't need to have a list of non-notable things Deletion of List of Georgia Breweries, Wineries, and Distilleries WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17015 21306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Hershey User:Evb 20:48, 2 June 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Not quite noteable for purposes. No real Deletion of Terry Hershey WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17016 9435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oriya Wikipedia User:Bearian 22:28, 19 June 2012 (UTC) keep not all Wikipedias are notable, but this one has potential. Oriya_language#Literature|Oriya Literature is fairly significant in India, so I'm surprised there are not |more sources that could not be added Deletion of Oriya Wikipedia WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
17017 11963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Gordeziani User:David 08:26, 2 February 2018 (UTC) delete """It was a case but XOR'easter fixed that. And I was about to !vote a weak delete (on the basis that borderline citation counts and no sources with in-depth detail about the subject don't provide us enough content for an actual article) but then I found his curriculum vitae http://www.viam.science.tsu.ge/cv/Gordeziani.pdf where it says that he was president of the """"Georgian Academy of Natural Sciences"""". Then I was about to !vote keep on the basis of #C3 until with a little more digging I realized that this was not a proper major national academy, but what appears to be a made-up title for a made-up organization http://worldcat.org/identities/lccn-no2005001747/. All the other impressive looking titles on the cv led to similarly sketchy results when I ran searches for them. So I think that this casts enough doubt on the cv that it cannot be taken a a factual and reliable source. And without even that, what content do we have""" Deletion of David Gordeziani WP:TNT||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
17018 14351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Petite Prince User:Knowledgekid87 02:54, 6 May 2013 (UTC) delete I don't see this passing Deletion of Petite Prince WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17019 14045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/King Products user:czarkoff 00:48, 21 July 2014 (UTC) delete my search did not reveal significant coverage in independent secondary reliable sources, while the article contains just press releases. 4 attempts of re-creation of this article warrants |'''salt'''ing King Products as was done for LMS King Deletion of King Products WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
17020 7835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Misses Glass User:Dravecky 05:55, 30 March 2008 (UTC) delete Easily recreated when (or if) the single is released should it meet at that time Deletion of Misses Glass WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17021 12918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Note Records User:Joshuaism 14:58, 9 June 2012 (UTC) delete Only independent source I can find is http://www.colorradio.com/Ronnie_Haig.htm some personal webpage. Only citations that have existed was a telephone interview removed per (see history). Hasn't produced any musicians of usic|notability. Fails Deletion of Note Records WP:NOR||WP:M||WP:GNG Wikipedia:No original research 65
17022 17757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wavestone User:onel5969 12:05, 31 October 2018 (UTC) delete as per nom and HighKing. The issue is independent sourcing. Right now, there isn't enough to meet either or Deletion of Wavestone WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
17023 4639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Weihrauch User:GiantSnowman 09:19, 14 February 2013 (UTC) delete fail and Deletion of Patrick Weihrauch WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17024 7746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Varieties of capitalism User:BigHaz 10:27, 24 July 2006 (UTC) delete for being an essay (thus applies) and probably crossing the POV barrier too Deletion of Varieties of capitalism WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
17025 10080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albanians in France User:Ceosad 18:05, 18 October 2015 (UTC) delete for failing Deletion of Albanians in France WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17026 2142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lil Eazy-E User:Burntsauce 17:20, 23 August 2007 (UTC) delete """especially the non-notable singles and albums, all of which fail miserably. The remainder of these """"unsigned comments"""" are nothing more than ball gazing. If Lil Eazy-E does ever become notable, we can write about him then""" Deletion of Lil Eazy-E WP:MUSIC||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17027 11740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Do You Want the Truth or Something Beautiful? (song) User:TenPoundHammer 20:21, 3 December 2009 (UTC) delete No verifiable info, , some slobbering fanboy wetting his pants over being the firstfirstfirstFIRST to post it. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Special:Contributions/TenPoundHammer|Many otters • :User talk:TenPoundHammer|One bat Deletion of Do You Want the Truth or Something Beautiful? (song) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17028 10346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Biofrequency Chip user:Bakerstmd 00:25, 7 April 2015 (UTC) delete Even if there exist enough RS to have this page, in its current iteration it needs to be |blown up because so many of citations don't back up statements made in the article Deletion of Biofrequency Chip WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
17029 698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albert Mariner User:Belovedfreak 21:51, 23 May 2011 (UTC) delete apparently no significant coverage in reliable, secondary sources. I can't see anything in the article that would meet |notability guidelines Deletion of Albert Mariner WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17030 15152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Age of Time (2nd nomination) User:Jonathan 22:06, 24 December 2007 (UTC) delete per #G4|criterion G4 Deletion of Age of Time (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17031 16375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pierre Cassignard User:Atlantic306 21:00, 7 July 2019 (UTC) keep passes with a very notable award, also passes with prominent roles as confirmed by The Figaro and other sources, thanks Deletion of Pierre Cassignard WP:ANYBIO||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17032 13873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vugar Ismailov User:Vugaris 04:29, 13 September 2016 (UTC) keep """The first criteria for reads as follows. """"''The person's research has made significant impact in their scholarly discipline''"""". Ismailov's research area is approximation by ''ridge functions''. The only book on this subject is """"Allan Pinkus, Ridge functions"""" which was published by Cambridge University Press in 2015. A quick glance at the '''Author Index''' of this book shows that he cited more times than many other researchers (see http://assets.cambridge.org/97811071/24394/index/9781107124394_index.pdf). A close examination can show in addition that several sections of this monograph are based on his results. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of Vugar Ismailov WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17033 3768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seventh Studio Project (Britney Spears Album) User:Narutolovehinata5 10:48, 19 April 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Seventh Studio Project (Britney Spears Album) WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
17034 3984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danny Sillada User:JL 12:44, 2 September 2009 (UTC) comment """According to rtist, he must least developed new concept in the field where he excelled, in this case, he is a surrealist painter and he doesn't developed that idea. Yes, he have """"Menstrual Period in Political History"""", supposed to be an important media in history especially during Hello Garci scandal, but what about other painters that did the same and has the same ideas with him? The inline citations rarely distinguish him, or at least, the links never mentioned him, I do not know why this happened. Most links came from Multiply or privately-owned blog sites. ( According to Wikipedia:BLP#Self-published_sources|this rule, it is unwise to use blogs as external links ''or'' as citation. To paraphrase, blogs are solely interpretation of the concern and are subjected to bias; i.e., I can say on my blog that """"Sillada is the greatest born Filipino painter, greater than Amorsolo and others"""". That is extreme bias, especially that majority of blogs (esp. Multiply) tend to give opinions rather than the truth. ) To continue, it was also said that the artist's work(s) must """"...(a) has become a significant monument, (b) has been a substantial part of a significant exhibition, (c) has won significant critical attention,..."""" In this case, the """"Menstrual Period"""" was the only mentioned work that gained critical analysis: and it was referenced to a website where it is very very difficult to confirm whether it was really said on that site. Furthermore, the article fails . Finally, Google search of his names will give us blog sites, Amazon/Twitter/Facebook and other links to social networking sites and there are no reliable news sources to confirm that Gloria Arroyo conferred him such an award. Sure that it is cited, but do we have any ways to confirm that? If that was published in a coffee table, sure that there is, at least, a news article from an online local newspaper saying that""" Deletion of Danny Sillada WP:A||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Attribution 108
17035 15686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of locations in the Superman film series User:N2e 23:09, 13 March 2010 (UTC) delete this is merely a rehash of other material |synthesized in a new article. Violates policy Deletion of List of locations in the Superman film series WP:SYN||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
17036 8589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Violence against men (3rd nomination) User:AutisticCatnip 07:07, 3 March 2013 (UTC) keep This is a notable subject. Deletion would violate Deletion of Violence against men (3rd nomination) WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
17037 11639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcus Mayo User:Quarl NONE delete """as |hoax. No google results for '""""marcus mayo"""" seamonkey '. &mdash""" Deletion of Marcus Mayo WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
17038 10478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Firefighting apparatus [[User talk:2A03:F80:32:194:71:227:81:1|talk]]) 22:10, 3 April 2021 (UTC) comment Strictly speaking #1 applies here. With no prior attempts at editing or discussion, I'm not sure why this wasn't just done old|boldly. Indeed in the absence of opposition it could probably still be done boldly and this discussion speedily closed. Special:Contributions/2A03:F80:32:194:71:227:81:1|2A03:F80:32:194:71:227:81:1 Deletion of Firefighting apparatus WP:SKCRIT||WP:B Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
17039 15460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur Kemp (3rd nomination) User:Night 11:02, 19 May 2012 (UTC) keep Although a scary guy, he meets as a journalist and writer Deletion of Arthur Kemp (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17040 12884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Palayathu Vayal Govt. UP School User:Tinucherian 14:07, 5 February 2014 (UTC) keep IMHO, Individual schools are inherently encyclopedic. , Wikipedia:Schools/Arguments#Keep Deletion of Palayathu Vayal Govt. UP School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
17041 13011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Dead in Dixon Indie Horror Film Festival User:Lugnuts 10:12, 1 December 2012 (UTC) delete maybe speedy, as an Deletion of The Dead in Dixon Indie Horror Film Festival WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Advertising 107
17042 11954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Serbia–Venezuela relations (2nd nomination) User:In 02:49, 4 March 2013 (UTC) keep """clearly is notable per common sense, and LibStar your :wikt:ultimatum """"You have 6 days to find sources"""" comment is inappropriate. Did you search in Spanish and Serbian sources"""" """"Serbia. Venezuela. relaciones diplomáticas"""" or Србија. Венецуела. """"дипломатски односи"""" before making this AfD? I could be wrong but based on those that I have seen I hope this series of AfDs to delete diplomatic relations stubs does in fact have community support and is not """ Deletion of Serbia–Venezuela relations (2nd nomination) WP:POINTY Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
17043 16555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dianetics: The Original Thesis User:Stifle 19:12, 13 May 2008 (UTC) delete Because the article does not include |citations from |reliable sources, it does not appear to be in compliance with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Dianetics: The Original Thesis WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17044 15759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Insatanity User:Reconsider_the_static 12:00, 26 September 2010 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Insatanity WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17045 11755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Container Man Project User:Jeepday 16:11, 3 March 2007 (UTC) delete agree with BlastoButter42, but the AfD trumps the #A7 so it probably has to wait the 5 days. I did not find the first paragraph in the self site or else I would have placed a '''copyvio''' on the article Deletion of Container Man Project WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17046 4415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jessica Yaniv genital waxing case User:Simonm223 12:16, 5 August 2019 (UTC) delete per and as this is not a notable event - and is one involving a BLP. Furthermore, it's a to circumvent the consensus at British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal and /N that the subject ''should not be named'' which makes this whole article a violation of Deletion of Jessica Yaniv genital waxing case WP:BLP||WP:EVENTCRIT||WP:POVFORK||WP:BLP||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17047 18714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liis Viira User:Northamerica1000 06:23, 4 April 2016 (UTC) keep Meets , albeit on a weak level, upon a review of available sources Deletion of Liis Viira WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17048 909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Myer stores User:Mr 13:06, 23 February 2009 (UTC) keep Actually reading #DIR, this is a good list. In the nomination, #DIR is cited but unread, and mentioned emptily and flagrantly. Please also check . List is perfectly good article. List of current stores would also be a perfectly good article Deletion of List of Myer stores WP:NOT||WP:LISTS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17049 19139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Dungeons & Dragons monsters (1974–76) User:Taewangkorea 23:39, 2 October 2019 (UTC) delete Just a game guide, and no reliable sources that discuss this group (1974-76) should be put together, failing and NFICTION Deletion of List of Dungeons & Dragons monsters (1974–76) WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
17050 3535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Windswept House: A Vatican Novel User:Bbb23 15:12, 26 December 2011 (UTC) comment """The NYT article is repeated by two editors. The Forbes quote is unsupported by Anthony, although it may indeed be verifiable. Publishers Weekly and Kirkus Reviews review almost every book that's published. Anthony, Martin ''does'' have his own article. This is the book we're talking about, not the author. Despite your statement, Anthony, about """"motive"""", you just recently tried to restore the offensive and policy non-compliant material about who each character equates to in real life (according to the author and whatever sources support the """"key""""). Unfortunately, the |notability guideline for having a book article at Wikipedia is very low. The only criterion this particular book could fit into is the reviews, and it's a close call. I would exclude Kirkus and PW for the reason stated above, and we are left with the Times and the Spartunburg papers (can't address the Forbes reference because I haven't seen the review, if indeed it's a review). I don't think the coverage is pervasive enough or of significant depth to include the book. I remind everyone that it is only a guideline and can be overridden by consensus: """"meeting these criteria is not an absolute guarantee that Wikipedia should have a separate, stand-alone article entirely dedicated to the book"""" and """"It is a generally accepted standard that editors should attempt to follow, though it is best treated with common sense, and occasional exceptions may apply""" Deletion of Windswept House: A Vatican Novel WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
17051 13188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward McSweegan User:Edokter 16:28, 21 July 2007 (UTC) delete per #A7|CSD A7 and Deletion of Edward McSweegan WP:CSD||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17052 17109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The New Defenders of Earth User:dcclark 04:51, 19 July 2006 (UTC) delete speculation, can't even find a reference to the book. Wikipedia |is not for unverifiable speculation Deletion of The New Defenders of Earth WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17053 1728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Little Mermaid III (2nd nomination) User:Liquidfinale 12:53, 25 October 2007 (UTC) comment I've only just noticed the previous AfD's for this title; each of which was clear as to the recommendation to delete. I should really have taken this to |speedy, but no matter Deletion of The Little Mermaid III (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17054 9844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Musa Abdul-Aleem User:JaconaFrere 15:44, 1 March 2017 (UTC) keep as the Greek Basket League meet Deletion of Musa Abdul-Aleem WP:NBASKETBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17055 8414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Light User:Ifnord 21:55, 17 October 2018 (UTC) delete """per nom for failing . There's a ton of those """"eggs"""" out there, most do not hatch""" Deletion of Alex Light WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
17056 9600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The End of the World (animation) User:Arkyan 19:03, 26 March 2007 (UTC) delete nothing more than another internet meme that lacks notability per , fails , could be called OR, yadda yadda Deletion of The End of the World (animation) WP:WEB||WP:ATT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17057 1878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ozone (festival) User:Ceradon 04:21, 2 March 2015 (UTC) delete I can't seen to determine an assertion of notability in the context of or Deletion of Ozone (festival) WP:GNG||WP:NEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17058 12994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barbie as the Sleeping Beauty User:Guest9999 20:47, 29 September 2008 (UTC) delete assuming it's not a |hoax, there don't appear to be any |reliable sources on which to base a |verifiable article Deletion of Barbie as the Sleeping Beauty WP:HOAX||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
17059 13996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wikipediocracy User:Alison 19:39, 19 May 2013 (UTC) keep clearly meets at this stage Deletion of Wikipediocracy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17060 18009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mateo arias User:Movingboxes 09:33, 23 August 2008 (UTC) delete Total failure of Deletion of Mateo arias WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17061 17556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aleksandra Ola Kozłowska User:4meter4 16:37, 22 October 2019 (UTC) keep per and . I did find some more coverage where she was the main subject under her new married name: https://ro.com.pl/396472-2/01396472, http://gazetaolsztynska.pl/486496,Aleksandra-Stanco-z-Olsztyna-Zeby-dac-rade-w-Caribbean-Dance-trzeba-miec-w-sobie-moc-jak-pocisk-WYWIAD.html, https://ro.com.pl/aleksandra-stanco-kozlowska-mistrzynia-warmii-i-mazur-w-kategorii-open-latin-freestyle-2017/01332496. The article should probably be moved to Aleksandra Stańco-Kozłowska Deletion of Aleksandra Ola Kozłowska WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
17062 17854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UH Racing User:TerriersFan 01:02, 7 January 2009 (UTC) delete no objection to a subsequent redirect being created. Insufficient independent sources to meet which is a policy requirement Deletion of UH Racing WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17063 14253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Shankland (2nd nomination) User:A 13:51, 18 January 2021 (UTC) keep He may not meet the thematic criteria, but meets , given the existence of multiple sources with extensive coverage Deletion of Mark Shankland (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17064 10232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oleg Sokolovskiy User:Tyrenius 21:08, 27 April 2010 (UTC) delete fails for lack of secondary coverage Deletion of Oleg Sokolovskiy WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17065 4272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 United Arab Emirates Under-19 Tri-Nation tournament User:Smartyllama 18:38, 19 May 2017 (UTC) keep per the sources provided above, which show that is met Deletion of 2016 United Arab Emirates Under-19 Tri-Nation tournament WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17066 3941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pearse dynasty User:Chzz 22:43, 15 April 2011 (UTC) delete No evidence of |notability. References given are not |reliable sources, and I have seen no evidence of any Deletion of Pearse dynasty WP:VRS||WP:RS Wikipedia:The answer to life, the universe, and everything 7
17067 20680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of eponymous streets in Hudson County User:Themfromspace 02:33, 8 December 2009 (UTC) delete WP:IINFO|Indiscriminate list about a |non-notable subject. Why is a list of eponymous streets in Hudson County relevant to an encyclopedic understanding of Hudson County, streets, or eponyms Deletion of List of eponymous streets in Hudson County WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17068 21792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/School wiki User:FOARP 12:25, 11 January 2019 (UTC) keep Sourcing in reliable sources is plentiful for this http://www.uniindia.com/kerala-govt-to-award-rs-1-lakh-for-best-school-in-school-wiki/states/news/1305542.html 1 https://keralaitnews.com/6456/ghss-areekode-bags-the-first-ever-kite-school-wiki-award 2 https://www.hindustantimes.com/education/it-school-connects-15-000-kerala-schools-on-wiki-platform/story-XA7NLacEU1PrSMyXOa73zK.html 3 https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/kerala/School-wiki-getting-ready-for-launch/article16889238.ece 4. Clear failure to do Deletion of School wiki WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
17069 8296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Turing, Kenneth Alan User:Rjd0060 04:26, 27 November 2007 (UTC) delete """Putting aside the huge amounts of |MOS work that needs to be done, including moving the page to correct the title, I say delete per the nom's reason. Long, rambling """"article"""", which doesn't provide any real encyclopedic context""" Deletion of Turing, Kenneth Alan WP:MOS Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
17070 14315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deb Crowfoot User:MelanieN 02:34, 7 March 2016 (UTC) delete His ancestor was notable, but he is not - based on Wikipedia's |criterion of needing |significant coverage from independent reliable sources. The article contains four references. Two of them are reliable sources but are about Chief Crowfoot and don't mention this subject at all. The third appears to be his own webpage. The fourth mentions him in passing in an article about Edmonton sports. I'm sure he is a good dentist and a good citizen, but this international encyclopedia requires significant coverage and he hasn't gotten it Deletion of Deb Crowfoot WP:BIO||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
17071 7037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/US Democratic Party-Iranian fundraising controversy User:Coelacan 00:17, 12 January 2007 (UTC) delete per Citicat, Settler, Bobblehead. The reliable sources in this article do not mention any controversy, nor any related allegations. Their use here represents a synthesis and thus a violation of . With the removal of those sources as a NOR violation, we are left only with far-right websites which cannot be considered reliable sources for these claims, per #Extremist sources. So this article fails as well. — Deletion of US Democratic Party-Iranian fundraising controversy WP:NOR||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
17072 646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Journal of Young Investigators User:David 00:01, 25 April 2015 (UTC) delete In contrast to the related AfD of ''Journal of Emerging Investigators'', which had two major sources directly about the journal, the coverage of this one looks shallow and incidental to stories about other subjects. I don't think it passes and I don't see any relevant criterion of ournals Deletion of Journal of Young Investigators WP:GNG||WP:NJ Wikipedia:Notability 77
17073 11839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raul Escribano User:Necrothesp 15:32, 3 January 2017 (UTC) keep General officer. Passes , which, essay or not, has been the accepted standard for military biographical notability for many years Deletion of Raul Escribano WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
17074 18446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stop Bild Sexism User:GermanJoe 22:39, 24 August 2015 (UTC) delete sources are mostly interviews, self-published information and brief re-reports of the same campaign summary. requires ''enduring'' notability of a topic, but criticism of BILD journalism is as old as the BILD itself - this is just one campaign with temporary publicity among many. It should not be ignored, but it is already covered with all relevant details in the main article Deletion of Stop Bild Sexism WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17075 1329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Vanity Label User:78 23:32, 3 February 2018 (UTC) delete unless it can be the label actually issued material by The Format. If so, then '''Merge''' and redirect. In any case this has no notability outside the band that made the label for their own purposes Deletion of The Vanity Label WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17076 15606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Bald Faced Truth Foundation User:Aboutmovies 07:24, 8 February 2010 (UTC) delete Gnews search comes up empty. Searching OregonLive comes up with a few things, but it's trivial coverage, and most of it is via John Canzano's posts (i.e. not independent). Ergo, fails / Deletion of The Bald Faced Truth Foundation WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17077 14849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mixcrate User:Acousmana 16:31, 9 March 2021 (UTC) delete clearly , not seeing quality sourcing, notability not evident, passing mention in Forbes does not suffice, it's an advertisement Deletion of Mixcrate WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17078 21416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiger By the Tail User:Ad 12:11, 15 November 2020 (UTC) keep """Undoubtedly a low-quality article. But that should be addressed through editing, not deletion. """"Perfection is not required: Wikipedia is a work in progress. Collaborative editing means that incomplete or poorly written first drafts can evolve over time into excellent articles. Even poor articles, if they can be improved, are welcome. For instance, one person may start an article with an overview of a subject or a few random facts."""" - . """"If editing can improve the page, this should be done rather than deleting the page."""" - . Regarding notability, please see: https://www.jstor.org/stable/44019068?Search=yes&resultItemClick=true&searchText=%22Tiger+By+the+Tail%22+James+Hadley+Chase&searchUri=%2Faction%2FdoBasicSearch%3FQuery%3D%2522Tiger%2BBy%2Bthe%2BTail%2522%2BJames%2BHadley%2BChase&ab_segments=0%2Fbasic_SYC-5187_SYC-5188%2F5187&refreqid=fastly-default%3Ac4f9d8493d30ad3a4f5010b4918d21a8&seq=1#metadata_info_tab_contents 1 https://books.google.dk/books?id=pNmMDwAAQBAJ&pg=PA52&dq=%22Tiger+By+the+Tail%22+-wikipedia+%22James+Hadley+Chase%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwj77qqZwYTtAhUI-yoKHQiKDZkQ6AEwAnoECAYQAg#v=onepage&q=%22Tiger%20By%20the%20Tail%22%20-wikipedia%20%22James%20Hadley%20Chase%22&f=false 2 https://books.google.dk/books?id=DZ44AAAAIAAJ&pg=PA254&dq=%22Tiger+By+the+Tail%22+-wikipedia+%22James+Hadley+Chase%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwj77qqZwYTtAhUI-yoKHQiKDZkQ6AEwBXoECAMQAg#v=onepage&q=%22Tiger%20By%20the%20Tail%22%20-wikipedia%20%22James%20Hadley%20Chase%22&f=false 3 https://books.google.dk/books?id=lP0dAQAAIAAJ&q=%22Tiger+By+the+Tail%22+-wikipedia+%22James+Hadley+Chase%22&dq=%22Tiger+By+the+Tail%22+-wikipedia+%22James+Hadley+Chase%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjEycG6wYTtAhWqtIsKHdbmAok4KBDoATAAegQIARAC 4""" Deletion of Tiger By the Tail WP:IMPERFECT||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
17079 20533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Dolls (band) User:Dwayne 03:15, 8 April 2010 (UTC) delete It fails |notability, i cant seem to find any sources on this band Deletion of The Dolls (band) WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
17080 7203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alna Group (2nd nomination) User:Pharaoh 23:46, 27 August 2019 (UTC) delete per nom and above fails and Deletion of Alna Group (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17081 7069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lance Petty User:Coredesat 08:17, 27 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Lance Petty WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
17082 13746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irish national team results User:Jnestorius 22:25, 2 January 2008 (UTC) keep """Punkmorten says: """"As established before, this is unsuitable"""": Could you point me to where this was established before? #STATS says """"Long and sprawling lists of statistics may be confusing to readers and reduce the readability and neatness of our articles. In addition, articles should contain sufficient explanatory text to put statistics within the article in their proper context for a general reader."""" As Abc183 says, that's not a strong argument for deleting this instance. Really what's needed is a discussion at involving the various sports wikiprojects about the notability and inclusivity criteria for sports results. Until that time, these pages are among the better examples of that genre currently included, and deserve a stay of execution""" Deletion of Irish national team results WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17083 1743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shubham Gupta User:Hobbes 14:13, 22 February 2015 (UTC) delete Not notable. Existing coverage is far too slender. Bad behavior by WP editors notwithstanding, if substantial coverage from independent |reliable sources can be found, am willing to reconsider Deletion of Shubham Gupta WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17084 19057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jan Moedwil User:AleatoryPonderings 14:57, 7 August 2020 (UTC) comment I've had trouble finding and would note that the corresponding articles in frwiki and nlwiki are unreferenced. https://archive.org/details/hetkoninkrijkder0000jong/page/396/mode/2up?q=%22jan+moedwil%22 This is the closest to sigcov I've been able to find, but I can't read Dutch Deletion of Jan Moedwil WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
17085 11973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Schommer User:Patar 22:33, 3 May 2009 (UTC) delete Fails , but more importantly . No significant coverage is available Deletion of Nick Schommer WP:ATHLETE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17086 13016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of WABC-TV personalities User:Richard 21:39, 11 June 2007 (UTC) keep Excellent navigation devices to blue linked articles. Paring it down would serve no purpose, it needs to be comprehensive to be useful. Anyway, is a personal essay. Can you imagine a legal proceeding where you weren't allowed to discuss other court cases that were decided. The basis of our judicial system is precedence Deletion of List of WABC-TV personalities :WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17087 3291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bhakti Arora Manekar User:onel5969 13:15, 28 November 2015 (UTC) delete as per nom and above editor. Not every game show contestant is notable. Searches turned up virtually nothing about this individual. Fails Deletion of Bhakti Arora Manekar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17088 5165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Envy of the State User:Lankiveil 12:04, 15 June 2014 (UTC) delete if the bit about headlining international tours was true, then they'd meet #4. However, the reference provided doesn't support the claim, and I have not been able to find anything online whatsoever to indicate they've played outside of the UK, which leads me to believe the claim is bollocks. I think there may be some puffery, exaggeration, and outright lies going into this article Deletion of Envy of the State WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17089 5242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lesser realm User:TonyBallioni 14:35, 16 October 2007 (UTC) delete If any reliable sources can be found (unlikely as that may be) Transwiki to Wiktionary. If no sources can be provided delete per Deletion of Lesser realm WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17090 21898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orlando Brooke User:Gongshow 22:03, 28 December 2012 (UTC) delete No significant coverage found (); roles to date to not satisfy Deletion of Orlando Brooke WP:GNG||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17091 12592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orion 17 User:Nfitz 04:18, 16 July 2009 (UTC) comment I can see that redirect may be appropiate. I don't see any material to merge; it's all the generic mission plan of a typical moon mission. Though I'm still not sure even a redirect meets Deletion of Orion 17 WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17092 10481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Starmin User:AnmaFinotera 14:10, 13 July 2010 (UTC) delete """Fan project"""" is no better than a , and clearly unnotable self-advertisement and spam. Rapid delete""" Deletion of Starmin WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
17093 7381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Heppell User:Porqin 14:11, 13 July 2006 (UTC) delete """This is surely a anity entry, and he cites his own personal website in which he quoted ''""""To be honest, I've completely lost track of where much of my stuff is on the Internet - conference slides, videos, transcripts, podcasts, debates...""""''. However, he appears to have won some sort of (notable?) award""" Deletion of Stephen Heppell WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17094 21127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/First Nations Bank of Canada User:Piotrus 05:26, 25 October 2019 (UTC) delete Cunard shows the bank got decent coverage for its launch, but in the end it's all a variation of . And said launch coverage doesn't rise much above the level or rewritten press releases Deletion of First Nations Bank of Canada WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17095 7690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1899 Crommelin User:Praemonitus 02:55, 2 May 2015 (UTC) merge per ; unable to satisfy notability requirements Deletion of 1899 Crommelin WP:DWMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17096 12325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Supreme Court of Pakistan Building User:Mrschimpf 02:10, 30 July 2017 (UTC) keep per ; the seat of a nation's highest court doesn't usually need much more than a basic description of the building to earn a keep. GEOFEAT additionally seals it Deletion of Supreme Court of Pakistan Building WP:COMMONSENSE "Wikipedia:What ""Ignore all rules"" means" 62
17097 18968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jfdd User:Calgary 05:09, 19 August 2007 (UTC) delete The article is an #OR|original first-person |opinionated |essay about a |novel, E|non-notable subject, which is an |invention of the author, with the possible intention to |advance a position or idea. Deletion seems utterly obvious, too bad it's not speedy criteria Deletion of Jfdd WP:NOT||WP:NPOV||WP:OR||WP:MADEUP||WP:NOTE||WP:AUTO||WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17098 15229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reverie User:Anetode 08:05, 28 October 2005 (UTC) delete garage band, not even close to meeting Deletion of Reverie WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17099 3982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Return of the Killer Klowns from Outer Space in 3D User:NinjaRobotPirate 01:22, 2 November 2013 (UTC) delete """Like the nom says, there have been rumors and fevered hopes of a sequel for years now. They can be recounted in the main article under a """"Potential sequel"""" section. requires reliable sources to state the film has begun principle photography. Until then, it's just more rumors and speculation""" Deletion of Return of the Killer Klowns from Outer Space in 3D WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17100 17727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gaetan Augsburger User:Rlendog 20:18, 3 March 2017 (UTC) keep meets #3 Deletion of Gaetan Augsburger WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
17101 19752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacek Yerka User:Jayvdb 01:40, 17 February 2007 (UTC) keep Meets due to exhibitions and plenty of reliable internet sources are available Deletion of Jacek Yerka WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17102 93 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Halkların Demokratik Partisinin kapatılma davası Kullanıcı:nanahuatlnanahuatl 22.49, 18 Mart 2021 (UTC) merge """Yukarıda {{ping|Kadıköylü}}'nün sunduğu gerekçelerin yönergelerde karşılığı bulunmamakta, kendi sübjektif düşünceleri. Görebildiğim kadarıyla temizlenmesi lazım. Temizlendikten sonra da ortada """"ana maddede yer alamayacak kadar uzayan bir başlık"""" kalmıyor. Dolayısıyla ayrı bir madde olma şartını karşılamıyor gereğince. Temizlenerek parti maddesine aktarılmasında fayda var""" Halkların Demokratik Partisinin Silinme Davası Kapatılma Davası Vikipedi:MB Wikipedia:Article size 51
17103 18029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farmmi User:Heartmusic678 17:55, 12 August 2021 (UTC) keep Although it was difficult to find anything that wasn't PR or a stock price discussion, {{u|Itemirus}} provided enough for this to pass . The page just needs to be extended to incorporate the 4 sources Deletion of Farmmi WP:ORGIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
17104 16812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Snurbs IM user:czarkoff 13:26, 26 September 2012 (UTC) delete my search brought nothing to demonstrate |notability. Given that this is a custom incompatible IM client with little to no user base, this article seems to serve promotional purposes, so may also apply Deletion of Snurbs IM WP:NOTPROMO||WP:notability Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17105 7232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lake High School (Millbury, Ohio) User:Seraphimblade 17:09, 25 February 2007 (UTC) delete or merge to parent community if appropriate to that article, no substantial secondary sources are cited (or that I can find are out there) to assert |notability Deletion of Lake High School (Millbury, Ohio) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17106 105 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Jaba (şarkıcı) Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 05.30, 19 Ekim 2018 (UTC) delete Albümler kendisinin değil, grubun albümleri. sayfasında belirtilen kriterleri karşılamıyor, hakkında yeteri kadar bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynak da bulunmuyor Jaba (şarkıcı) silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
17107 5303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/California gubernatorial election, 2022 User:StartTerminal 04:13, 20 April 2018 (UTC) delete Seems more fit for |PROD than AfD, but whatever Deletion of California gubernatorial election, 2022 WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
17108 11335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeremy Kosbob User:Sting 12:52, 9 February 2008 (UTC) keep """yes premier league player so passes . Although these Rugby League teams are described as """"semi"""" professional, even if part amateur these guys are still top level and probably notable for the fact that they play a non traditional U.S. game? This might become a test case""" Deletion of Jeremy Kosbob WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17109 4967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan McGuire User:MacGyverMagic 11:01, 7 May 2007 (UTC) keep subject http://www.google.com/search?q=%22wrestling%22+%22Dan+McGuire%22&rls=com.microsoft:*:IE-SearchBox&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&sourceid=ie7&rlz=1I7GGLJ to multiple independant sources. Current lack of sources in the article is something that can be remedied by cleanup rather than deletion. There's only an urgent need for deletion when unreferenced material is negative in such a way it violated Deletion of Dan McGuire WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17110 17928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Idle RPG [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 06:05, 8 February 2009 (UTC) delete nothing I could find, nor the abovementioned sources provide any verifiability of the article. Also remember that is not a good indicator of notability; it's what is found among those hits that do Deletion of Idle RPG WP:GOOGLEHITS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17111 21956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This WEEK in FUN User:Joe 20:56, 8 January 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this podcast Deletion of This WEEK in FUN WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17112 21932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seth kaplan User:Mike 03:49, 19 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Seth kaplan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17113 21508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Red Arrow International User:Ceradon 01:56, 1 March 2015 (UTC) delete WP:ADMASQ|Advertisements masquerading as articles. Additionally, quite possibly created with a |conflict of interest, but that is not a reason for deletion Deletion of Red Arrow International WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
17114 294 [[ATS Buntentor Knights]] (erledigt, gelöscht) Benutzer:Tom_md NONE delete Dann müssen für diese Behauptungen unabhängige Quellen her. Ach ja: Regionale Präsenz reicht nicht, überregionale Medienresonanz ist gefordert. Ansonsten , vorher lesen: Artikel werden nicht gegeneinander verglichen. Zudem generiert bei Randsportarten nur die Bundesliga Relevanz. Also: Wichtiges in ATS Buntentor einarbeiten, Artikel löschen Löschung von ATS Buntentor Knights Wikipedia:BNS Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
17115 5550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jill K. McNulty [[User talk:Albiet|Albiet]]'s claims) that McNulty was an exceptionally important one (academics, by their job description, write academic books and papers and this doesn't make them notable per se). NONE delete vote' as nominator (the author has expended thousands of words explaining their 'keep' vote so I think I need to make my position quite clear). Article fails the current Wikipedia |notability guidelines for judges and the news coverage about McNulty is fleeting, only brief mentions therefore failing criteria. Since http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Jill_K._McNulty&diff=567033835&oldid=556098025 the AfD nomination, the article has been expanded greatly, unfortunately without any reliable proof of the increasingly exaggerated claims. Though McNulty worked as an acadmeic, I still fail to see any reliable secondary proof (other than Deletion of Jill K. McNulty WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17116 12285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pavel Hlava User:Asnac 07:22, 30 April 2011 (UTC) delete the key points into other 9/11 articles - provides the specific example of the man who videotaped the Rodney King beating who doesn't have his own page. While 9/11 was of course of more significance, I think the principle of the event not the person still holds here. Moreover this particular recording was not produced until well after the event so had no impact on the public consciousness at the time Deletion of Pavel Hlava WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17117 2391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tech Compiler Data Systems User:Harsh_2580 22:31, 26 November 2014 (UTC) delete Not notable and unsourced Deletion of Tech Compiler Data Systems WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17118 6407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black River Beach Neighborhood Center User:GauchoDude 13:22, 12 January 2017 (UTC) delete Per nom. Cannot find reliable sourcing to satisfy Deletion of Black River Beach Neighborhood Center WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17119 8879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Australia-Indonesia Prisoner Exchange Agreement (2nd nomination) User:WWGB 09:59, 10 March 2009 (UTC) delete Any negotiations are completely stalled, progress is Deletion of Australia-Indonesia Prisoner Exchange Agreement (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17120 18295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peer39 (2nd nomination) User:Shoy 19:18, 19 August 2016 (UTC) delete Not enough to pass Deletion of Peer39 (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17121 21524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergio Sinistri User:Lugnuts 18:28, 19 June 2020 (UTC) keep """The nom's rationale of """"lack of sources"""" is not a valid reason for deletion. The individual has competed at the Olympics, so passes . The nom has been on WP about 1 month, so |I assume they are not versed in the notability requirements or """ Deletion of Sergio Sinistri WP:NOLY||WP:AGF||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17122 20350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Linwood Boulevard User:The 23:54, 3 September 2012 (UTC) delete does not meet |notability standards; coverage of a local street. |Notability is not inherited from celebrity parades or the LaMar's Donuts|famous doughnut store, which the article currently uses to |try to appear notable Deletion of Linwood Boulevard WP:GNG||WP:RUNOFTHEMILL||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:MASK Wikipedia:Notability 77
17123 7790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor Who Live User:Someone 20:02, 11 October 2010 (UTC) keep Please refer to before nominating something else for deletion. The first thing that google spat out was the show's website, it took all of a minute to see that it opened 3 nights ago in the Wembley Arena and to see that the show has garnered http://www.doctorwholive.com/pressquotes/ numerous pieces in the UK press, notability is blatantly obvious to those who'd care to look Deletion of Doctor Who Live WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
17124 9579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Math of Quran User:Stifle 14:34, 27 February 2006 (UTC) comment I feel that most if not all of the references are to primary sources, such as the Koran/Quran, and as such it appears to violate . However, I have revised to a weak delete after some consideration Deletion of Math of Quran WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
17125 7811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard L. Cevoli User:Kolma8 21:30, 7 January 2021 (UTC) keep probably enough coverage to meet Deletion of Richard L. Cevoli WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17126 11114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Railpage Australia (3rd nomination) User:The 07:38, 23 July 2007 (UTC) keep I concur with the previous comment.The article doesn't contain reliable sources, but they do exist. This is not a reason to delete the article. This was also discussed in the previous AfD. The decision of that AfD, even with the anon IP contributions, was '''keep''' and the article has since been cleaned up. The article remained protected until recently then the vandalism started again. Is it even legitimate that this AfD was sponsored by a newly created account, apparently created purely for the purpose of starting the AfD? Check the article history. An anon IP AfD was added a few days ago but this was removed as being incomplete. Then today a new account is created to do just that. is a major factor here. That is not a reason to delete the article, but it does need to be edited Deletion of Railpage Australia (3rd nomination) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
17127 16775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yannick Helbling User:GiantSnowman 11:34, 30 April 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Yannick Helbling WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17128 15266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/University of Dreams User:JJL 03:32, 3 November 2007 (UTC) keep suspect and some advertising issues, but there does seem to be something there nonetheless. Borderline at best Deletion of University of Dreams WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
17129 7433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of scientists opposing the mainstream scientific assessment of global warming (3rd nomination) User:Johnuniq 02:57, 25 October 2009 (UTC) delete The good-faith intentions of the article are not achievable without extreme and . First, a Wikipedian editor has selected a quote that they think justifies inclusion in this list; no |secondary source may be known with an analysis of the scientist's beliefs and with a conclusion justifying inclusion in this list. Second, there is no |verification that the scientist has not later repudiated the statement (people change their mind, particularly scientists upon viewing new data). Third, the lead claims that the list shows scientists who have opposed one of three principle conclusions; however, many of the quotations appear to have no connection with the particular IPCC conclusion (the scientist may very well oppose the conclusion, but it is up to the reader to infer that without verification Deletion of List of scientists opposing the mainstream scientific assessment of global warming (3rd nomination) WP:SYNTH||WP:OR||WP:SECONDARY||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
17130 6806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellie Chidzey User:Pharaoh 07:46, 17 January 2016 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Ellie Chidzey WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17131 13755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Colquhoun User:Störm 20:18, 2 June 2018 (UTC) delete no coverage, fails Deletion of Dan Colquhoun WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17132 12886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dream (YouTuber) (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep noting that I was the '''procedural nominator''') - Occasionally an article has very large responses, both for keeping and for deleting, on an |AFD. There may be at least two explanations Deletion of Dream (YouTuber) (2nd nomination) WP:AFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
17133 20828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guillaume Hubert User:Nfitz 18:35, 23 March 2014 (UTC) keep he's been the back-up keeper on the bench in the last 9 matches for Standard Liège. As such, he will make an appearance sooner or later, meeting ; as this is almost-certain, is not applicable. The danger of simply deleting, is that it will likely be recreated rather than restored, wasting editing time, and leading to a missing history, that is seldom restored in a timely fashion. In lieu of deletion, perhaps moving to draft space would be a better option Deletion of Guillaume Hubert WP:GNG||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17134 18566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Desh Premik User:Rpclod 14:19, 6 January 2018 (UTC) delete no authoritative references are provided to support Deletion of Desh Premik WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
17135 553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global Challenges Foundation User:GrapefruitSculpin 01:19, 22 October 2017 (UTC) keep """Additional sources showing clearance of found from the https://www.hhs.se/en/outreach/sse-initiatives/global-challenges/ Stockholm School of Economics, an additional http://news.trust.org/item/20170523230148-a90de Reuters article, https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/feb/18/artificial-intelligence-nanotechnology-risks-human-civilisation The Guardian and the http://carnegieeurope.eu/2017/06/27/global-challenges-when-corruption-is-operating-system-event-5633 Carnegie Endowment. The company they hired for their brand identity describes what they've done rather clearly: """"Our work with the Global Challenges Foundation has centred around their complex report; 12 Risks that threaten human civilisation."""" - http://bwa.design/clients/global-challenges-foundation?page=1 here. I'll edit the article to include these and soften the modest tone""" Deletion of Global Challenges Foundation WP:GNG||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17136 18617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mission Vision User:Joe 22:44, 28 April 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |organization. I guess that all the good noble causes were taken Deletion of Mission Vision WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17137 20991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elm Guest House claims and controversy User:LM2000 14:18, 22 January 2019 (UTC) keep No rationale for deletion, the bottom line is that this passes . The allegations were indeed bogus and the article reflects this Deletion of Elm Guest House claims and controversy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17138 7477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katherine Kenyon User:Corvus 05:23, 21 October 2005 (UTC) delete """After she becomes """"one of Britain's leading actresses"""" she will get a page. Wikipedia is #Wikipedia_is_not_a_crystal_ball|not a crystal ball""" Deletion of Katherine Kenyon WP:ISNOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17139 14369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Themes and motifs in Harry Potter User:Shalom 13:54, 1 July 2007 (UTC) delete This is an excellent example to illustrate my opinion that an |attributed article can contain |original research. At best, this article falls under the |synthesis clause. There is no way to write a neutral encyclopedic article under this title Deletion of Themes and motifs in Harry Potter WP:ATT||WP:OR||WP:SYN Wikipedia:Attribution 108
17140 11840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Badunk User:Kinu 08:11, 26 March 2006 (UTC) delete at the least, |unverifiable; likely |protologism Deletion of Badunk WP:V||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17141 183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thoughts in reverse User:Gongshow 18:06, 20 February 2010 (UTC) delete I'm finding zero significant coverage for this band in |reliable sources; does not meet or Deletion of Thoughts in reverse WP:RS||WP:N||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17142 17555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparing Temprature of Planets in Solar System User:Huon 21:34, 30 May 2008 (UTC) delete is almost #A3|empty, maybe a #G2|test page. The title has spelling errors and doesn't follow standard capitalization for Wikipedia articles. An overview of planetary information is already contained in the planet article, so even at its best this would be an unnecessary fork Deletion of Comparing Temprature of Planets in Solar System WP:CSD||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17143 13441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Boykin User:Alsee 16:45, 21 January 2020 (UTC) keep Failed political candidates are not notable. Almost all of the (search result)sources look rather dubious as Reliable Sources. Almost all of the sources that clearly are Reliable are pretty worthless for establishing Notability because they are trivial passing mentions. His notability basically amounts to being commonly cited in passing mention as a token freak, or (metaphorically) for persistently juggling dead babies in clown suit. However https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/amid-anti-trump-protests-one-lgbtq-group-celebrated-n711261 this NBC News piece plus a rather large pile of ''mostly'' crap other sources does add up to passing the |Notability Guideline. It looks like the article is likely to be a time sink, requiring cleanup work to clear out youtube videos and other crap that doesn't belong in any article. It would be a net plus if we did delete it. C'est la vie Deletion of Peter Boykin WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17144 21313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pro-abortion rights violence User:Neutrality 01:08, 5 June 2017 (UTC) delete Among the worst examples of that I have encountered Deletion of Pro-abortion rights violence WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
17145 19399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hisham Kelati User:sumnjim 15:58, 7 August 2007 (UTC) delete It tries to assert notability, so A7 does not apply, however he still isn't notable as there are no |reliable sources, and cannot establish |verifiability. Does not pass Deletion of Hisham Kelati WP:RS||WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17146 20170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joyce el rayess User:Ghostwheel 04:06, 22 July 2015 (UTC) delete Unfortunately, I'm not finding anything in reliable sources which would meet . I agree with Liz on userfy-ing the article, give the author/subject a chance to get some sources and write up a good article Deletion of Joyce el rayess WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17147 14689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Half-Life series storyline User:Isotope23 16:26, 2 October 2006 (UTC) delete per . Groundbreaking or not (and I happen to love the game), storylines for games are not suitable article material. No strong opposition to a transwiki, but Wikipedia is not the place for this article Deletion of Half-Life series storyline WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17148 16705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clayton Hotel, Limerick User:Guliolopez 10:33, 10 November 2020 (UTC) keep """Or '''redirect'''). There does, per {{u|Spiderone}} above, seem to be at least a moderate amount of coverage of a type which falls within the bounds of the criteria. (IE: """"notable as a result of .. architectural importance"""". Where there are otherwise several reliable sources confirming the subject's status as https://www.irishtimes.com/business/media-and-marketing/seen-heard-aib-takes-court-action-against-harcourt-1.2517235 Ireland's tallest hotel. And among the tallest buildings in the state overall.) If there is consensus that we don't need a standalone title to cover the few paras that might convey this information, then a merge/redirect to Dalata Hotel Group#Hotels might be more appropriate. Over outright deletion. (I otherwise don't see that this is as a cut and dried as the nomination suggests. The sources are perhaps not overwhelming. But they're not underwhelming or nonexistent either""" Deletion of Clayton Hotel, Limerick WP:NBUILDING Wikipedia:Notability 77
17149 8752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twisted mods User:Dennisthe2 16:51, 8 April 2007 (UTC) delete Even overlooking the COI or spam problem, the article seems to still fail , and needs attribution anyway Deletion of Twisted mods WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17150 3066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce McArthur User:E 14:15, 14 February 2018 (UTC) keep """Undoubtedly this series of murders is sufficiently notorious to support an article (and one ought to be created). Regarding the BLP concerns, in this case McArthur's name has been so widely disseminated by that he can support an article, and McArthur's """"fame"""" as a suspect means that privacy concerns are trumped by as per """ Deletion of Bruce McArthur WP:RS||WP:BLPNAME Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17151 18343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Revolution prep User:Mr 01:17, 10 November 2008 (UTC) keep since it has |substantial coverage. |POV and tone of the article need attention though Deletion of Revolution prep WP:RS||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17152 8525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/First Trust Portfolios User:MastCell 18:09, 21 August 2007 (UTC) delete as advertising. In any case, fails and is essentially promotional in nature Deletion of First Trust Portfolios WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17153 6241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dennis Roady User:Waggie 05:03, 15 May 2017 (UTC) comment I've been |canvassed to give my opinion here by {{u|Mjbmr}} and as such, I will |pointedly not do so. I do not approve of canvassing Deletion of Dennis Roady WP:CANVASS||WP:POINTY Wikipedia:Canvassing 93
17154 19715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warstic User:K 18:30, 9 October 2016 (UTC) delete """a article on an unremarkable company. Sources above are unconvincing, mostly routine """"local company does well"""" type of coverage. also applies; the company is not yet notable per available sources. Article create by user with one contribution Special:Contributions/JohnnyBattle so paid editing is about 100% certain, which is against policy. Keeping this article on a non-notable entity would only encourage the spammers, which is not in the best interest of the project""" Deletion of Warstic WP:PROMO||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17155 85 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/İl Han Özay Kullanıcı:ravagesravages 12.09, 31 Mayıs 2019 (UTC) keep """İdare hukuku alanında bilinen/tanınan ve kitaplarına başka akademisyenlerin eserlerinde de atıfta bulunulan bir isim. Kitap ve akademik aramalarından bu sonuca ulaşılabilir. |Akademisyenler için kayda değerlik kriterlerinden biri olan """"''4. Kişinin akademik çalışmaları, çok sayıda akademik kuruluştaki yükseköğretim süreçlerinde önemli etkilere sahiptir.''"""" kriterini karşıladığını düşünüyorum. Bu nedenle kalması yönünde oy kullanıyorum""" İl Han Özay'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17156 14951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wild scotsman User:Just 18:46, 27 November 2005 (UTC) delete apparent vanity. Might reconsider if they want to send me a case to |verify Deletion of Wild scotsman WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17157 16204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Digital gift User:Qwertyus 21:02, 5 November 2014 (UTC) comment """I wrote this article to replace an earlier one that was a straight-out DICDEF, focusing on the concept of a """"digital gift economy"""" that has some currency in social studies/media theory. I'm not an expert in those fields, and I had a hard time finding good sources, hence the poor state of the article. I think the current article is a stub, rather than a dicdef, but I won't mind deletion per """ Deletion of Digital gift WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
17158 9696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Good Gayme User:SkierRMH 19:16, 29 January 2007 (UTC) delete """as |utter nonsense, using my """"innate jurisprudence""" Deletion of Good Gayme WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
17159 19804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people with ADHD User:Stifle 23:06, 31 March 2006 (UTC) delete as POV and permanently unverifiable |listcruft Deletion of List of people with ADHD WP:LC Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
17160 11519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fictional history of Spider-Man (2nd nomination) User:Protonk 18:55, 16 October 2008 (UTC) comment This article '''can''' be sourced to third party sources (heck, even Stan Lee's 1974 Origins of Marvel Comics--not the new one--was published by Simon & Schuster). there is a non-trivial amount of coverage about Spiderman's origins and what those origins say about our fears as a society (how the origin story changes over time). Try the ''Journal of Popular Culture'' for a set of peer reviewed articles. Or http://books.google.com/books?id=4m1IM8L0hr0C The Creation of Spider-Man. That said, the article as written fails , and practically serves as a gallery of fair use images. So I'm neutral. My suspicion is that like Phoenix in popular culture, this article will be kept and remain in its current condition indefinitely Deletion of Fictional history of Spider-Man (2nd nomination) WP:PLOT||WP:NOR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17161 12845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rosa Rein User:Taketa 19:00, 16 December 2015 (UTC) keep WP:BIO, - She has received significant coverage in multiple reliable independant sources. I added a mention in a book to the article,a and two articles specifically about her from notable news agencies Deletion of Rosa Rein WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17162 20955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ralph Tarrant User:Newshunter12 10:12, 29 November 2018 (UTC) delete """This article fails , , and . There is no policy that the """"oldest x"""" is notable and this article is packed with longevity fancruft like his marriage date in relation to his birthday, his secret to longevity, and a dubious marriage length record. There is nothing to preserve about this man, including this """ Deletion of Ralph Tarrant WP:GNG||WP:BIO1E||WP:NOPAGE||WP:PERMASTUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
17163 9655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Whitfield (inventor) User:Edison 03:39, 3 August 2010 (UTC) delete Article does not clearly satisfy Deletion of Thomas Whitfield (inventor) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17164 14090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shiply (2nd nomination) User:Whpq 17:43, 11 March 2011 (UTC) keep While there has been an issue of conflict of interest with the company editting this article, the content is not in such a shape as to be irredeemable spam. With respect to citations not meeting verifiability, I am unclear on why the nominator believes this to be the case. There are primary sources (company's own web site) and press releases being used. However, the references also include an article in the http://www.nytimes.com/external/venturebeat/2010/08/20/20venturebeat-shipping-goes-green-as-shiply-expands-across-76729.html?partner=rss&emc=rss New York Times which features the company as the primary subject. Ditto for http://www.businessgreen.com/bg/news/1869770/shiply-aims-build-european-green-logistics-network BusinessGreen, http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/standard-business/article-23762098-amid-all-the-gloom-heres-one-man-on-the-road-to-success.do The Evening Standard, and http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sponsored/business/businesstruth/5314494/Plan-to-cut-transport-waste-moving-forward-with-Shiply.com.html The Telegraph, as well as significant coverage in http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/entrepreneur/article5438701.ece The Times, and http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/personalfinance/consumertips/4697744/Confessions-of-a-saveaholic-How-I-saved-more-than-1000-by-shopping-around.html The Telegraph. Aside from BusienssGreen, all of these are well-respected major newspapers and certainly represent the |reliable sources we would expect for an article Deletion of Shiply (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17165 4307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pradip Somasundaran User:202 05:35, 1 August 2006 (UTC) keep Pradip has been on the music scene since 1996 since he won Meri Awaz Suno. This music show was the forerunner of the many later music shows such as Sa Re Ga Ma and Indian Idol. Also note that he is a major celebrity in his home state of Kerala. Also according to not many people outside South India will know him. Hence, he is culturaaly significant for him to merit an article over here Deletion of Pradip Somasundaran WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
17166 21480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Asiedu (2nd nomination) NONE NONE delete Sorry, this fails . Simply having a bunch of questionable sources covering a subject doesn't make them notable. Let's have a look at the sources Deletion of Alexander Asiedu (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17167 18403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kingdom of Uantir User:Blanchardb 14:14, 5 November 2007 (UTC) comment Then the deletion rationale is one of |notability, something that will take a lot more than an active population of 6 to achieve. And I have a good reason to doubt the notability of the concept itself Deletion of Kingdom of Uantir WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17168 12298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Dunkley User:Datheisen 08:02, 18 October 2009 (UTC) delete Almost want to keep. If film work is completed and there are publication references of a professional level, bring it back. As it is, and as said above Deletion of Richard Dunkley WP:BLP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17169 7313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Vincenzo Castellano User:MelanieN 17:59, 13 August 2013 (UTC) delete I'm sure he is a fine physician, but he does not meet Wikipedia's rather demanding criteria for an article at this time. Google News finds nothing so he does not pass . He is an assistant professor at Cornell and director of a division of a reasonably notable hospital; http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=Vincenzo+Castellano&btnG=&as_sdt=1%2C5&as_sdtp= Google Scholar shows him as a co-author on some modestly cited papers; that's not enough to meet . He is young and he might become more notable in the future, but not yet Deletion of Dr. Vincenzo Castellano WP:GNG||WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17170 8146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elicia Hughes User:Pete 18:42, 25 March 2008 (UTC) comment """I am somewhat, but not totally, swayed by the argument for deletion of this Biography per and #NEWS. As I see it, the argument for notability is that the court cases are notable. I'd be open to """"keep"""" (and move to an article on '''the case''', rather than a Bio) if someone can argue that case is notable, e.g. by setting a notable precedent, for the ruling that he first trial was won by improper jury stacking. (I see no guideline like /CA for determining the notability of court cases, but think there ought to be one). Failing such demonstration of notabiloty for the court cases, I recommend '''delete''' per nominator's reasoning""" Deletion of Elicia Hughes WP:BIO1E||WP:NOT||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17171 6937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eisenman Synagogue User:Oakshade 20:35, 9 February 2011 (UTC) keep """Even by the """"sources provided"""" an http://books.google.com/books?id=lJowAQAAIAAJ&q=%22The+Synagogue+Within%22&dq=%22The+Synagogue+Within%22&hl=en&ei=GPlSTfPbKomWsgOO9a3dBg&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CCcQ6AEwAA entire book about this synagogue clearly indicates passing . Unless the publisher of that book is the synagogue, there are no independence issues""" Deletion of Eisenman Synagogue WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17172 14495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Railpage Australia (2) User:Nuttah68 10:54, 1 March 2007 (UTC) delete lots of claims to notability, but so far despite much asking and claims of proof, no |reliable sources backing up any of the claims Deletion of Railpage Australia (2) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17173 9333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deji (YouTuber) User:Sekyaw 08:08, 26 April 2020 (UTC) delete Even if the info in the draft is merged into this article, I would still consider it for deletion per . Much of the coverage on Deji consists of negative YouTube drama, and even though he is popular on YouTube, it doesn't take away the fact that he really isn't notable for doing anything else Deletion of Deji (YouTuber) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17174 18359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of national capitals in alphabetical order User:Acnetj 18:54, 16 June 2018 (UTC) delete Lists can now be sorted so this is redundant. Deletion of List of national capitals in alphabetical order WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
17175 7501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/In Honour of Icon E - A Tribute to Emperor User:4meter4 02:54, 27 March 2021 (UTC) keep Passes per ASTIG's references. Nominator should consider withdrawing nomination Deletion of In Honour of Icon E - A Tribute to Emperor WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
17176 3604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gavin Keohane User:Placeholder 03:32, 7 May 2007 (UTC) delete per CSD A7. Even without the problem, he's not notable Deletion of Gavin Keohane WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17177 5578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of video game websites (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 11:57, 2 January 2016 (UTC) keep """Qualifies for an article per relative to :Category:Video game websites, """"It is neither improper nor uncommon to simultaneously have a category, a list, and a navigation template which all cover the same topic. These redundant systems of organizing information are considered to be complementary, not inappropriately duplicative. Furthermore, arguing that a category duplicates a list (or vice versa) at a deletion discussion is not a valid reason for deletion and should be avoided."""" Also keep per , as having useful navigational functionality. Lastly, keep per , per the significant improvements the article has realized in being converted to a table format that has been expanded with more content by {{u|SharkD""" Deletion of List of video game websites (2nd nomination) WP:NOTDUP||WP:LISTPURP||WP:HEY Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
17178 19774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/42 (Song) User:Madchester 22:21, 20 February 2010 (UTC) delete Fails . No indication of individual notability outside of inclusion on the album Deletion of 42 (Song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17179 12507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Colombo User:Mdtemp 08:27, 25 March 2016 (UTC) delete Lacks the significant independent coverage needed to meet and fails to meet the notability standards for kickboxers at Deletion of Jim Colombo WP:GNG||WP:NKICK Wikipedia:Notability 77
17180 8766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ragnarok Wisdom User:Slf67 22:33, 31 October 2006 (UTC) delete fails , and hopefully we'll get around to deleting even less notable articles in due course Deletion of Ragnarok Wisdom WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
17181 8381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Godwulf User:Seraphim 01:53, 15 April 2017 (UTC) keep """per I found several articles in JSTOR and from what I can understand he seems to play a significant enough role in scholarly analysis of those genealogies to merit his own page. That would be like saying, we should not have a page for Philippa Plantagenet because we already have a page for House of Plantagenet. Unwraveling these genealogies can be both rewarding and challenging for scholars, and I think we should have more pages, not fewer - to make the relationships and significance clearer to researchers. Reader attention span and information saturation are legitimate concerns here - There are a lot of pages like this for members of notable families where we know little more then their role in a genealogy, like Margaret, Countess of Pembroke so I see no reason to delete. The """"father of, son of"""" is what makes them notable in this area of study, isn't it""" Deletion of Godwulf WP:GNG||WP:AS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17182 10974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zinho Gano User:Sir 04:35, 12 June 2011 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not played in a fully pro league, meaning he fails , and there is insufficient coverage for him to meet Deletion of Zinho Gano WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17183 5201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/London Buses route 331 User:Satori 12:38, 31 March 2010 (UTC) delete as insufficiently notable per the . There is no evidence this specific bus route has been the subject of non-trivial coverage by multiple, independent, reliable sources. As such, it is not possible to write an article which meets the non-negotiable requirements of and Deletion of London Buses route 331 WP:GNG||WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17184 13510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wynn Creasy User:E 18:01, 30 March 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Wynn Creasy WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
17185 588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Starmax User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:22, 21 February 2015 (UTC) keep per having sourcable notability, |even if in Korean. I would suggest the new editor who chose to nominate this perhaps gain a bit more experience and work on his |reserach skills before sending topics to AFD Deletion of Starmax WP:NONENG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17186 9112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julie Frith User:Steve 14:55, 5 July 2009 (UTC) delete for now. If she is really as well-known as it says a new article could be started with eliable sources Deletion of Julie Frith WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
17187 13115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unprecedented: A Simple Guide to the Crimes of the Trump Campaign and Presidency User:Swordman97 21:35, 12 March 2021 (UTC) comment most of the references in the article should be moved to footnotes or another section as they are not real references to another publication. In addition, I feel that this article may violate Deletion of Unprecedented: A Simple Guide to the Crimes of the Trump Campaign and Presidency WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
17188 2816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Esk User:Gilliam 06:02, 25 June 2014 (UTC) delete per Bearcat. A clear case and this guy just had his 15 minutes of fame Deletion of Scott Esk WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17189 5652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bottlecap shooting User:Alexius08 08:33, 7 October 2008 (UTC) delete it as a |how-to guide Deletion of Bottlecap shooting WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17190 15104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Independent Green Voice User:Wikicology 16:29, 30 November 2014 (UTC) keep subject of the article obviously meet Deletion of Independent Green Voice WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17191 11994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 Fox News – White House controversy User:RayAYang 16:43, 25 October 2009 (UTC) keep Significant event of lasting historical note concerning the media relations of this Administration. #NEWS must be placed into perspective - it is designed to ensure that events with no lasting historical notability do not appear in an encyclopedia. For a sitting administration to orchestrate a deliberate effort against a news organization in a free society is a major event, even if it's just run of the mill in other countries with less respect for freedom of speech. Coatrackish and NPOV concerns should be handled via the usual content dispute resolution procedures Deletion of 2009 Fox News – White House controversy WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17192 13298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Batman villain bibliographies User:GentlemanGhost 03:50, 18 June 2006 (UTC) keep I don't agree that the information within these articles is #Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information|indiscriminate. None of the examples listed are pertinent and I don't think that these bibliographies violate the spirit of the policy. Morever, as stated in meta:Wiki is not paper|Wiki is not paper, there is no reason why there shouldn't be an article for every Simpsons character and a table listing every episode. As such, I see no reason why there shouldn't be a complete bibliography for these prominent members of Batman's rogues gallery. As for the argument that upkeep would be a problem, I don't agree. With the exception of Catwoman, none of these characters is featured in a monthly series. While I would agree that trying to maintain a catalog of every appearance by Superman, Batman, or Spider-Man is a fool's errand, those are special cases (and if some fool volunteers, I won't stop him). However, on average, I don't anticipate that there will be more than one or two new issues to add to these lists each month. This is easily managable. Also, as far as whether the publisher chooses to create a similar bibliography, I don't think that's relevant. Either this information does belong on Wikipedia or it doesn't. This is my vote to say that it does Deletion of Batman villain bibliographies WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17193 6863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chintu TV User:Dane2007 05:30, 8 November 2016 (UTC) delete Per nom, this is not a notable channel and fails Deletion of Chintu TV WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17194 2741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trans Student Equality Resources User:Dricherby 11:11, 12 May 2013 (UTC) delete My best wishes to the organisation and its work but I couldn't find the sources needed to meet the |General Notability Guidelines Deletion of Trans Student Equality Resources WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17195 21068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lyrical Wanzam User:Huon 20:10, 2 July 2016 (UTC) delete not enough reliable sources to establish |notability Deletion of Lyrical Wanzam WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17196 8022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pharos Systems International User:Ihcoyc 14:49, 22 September 2010 (UTC) delete This is a ''company that provides print management software and services,'', |one of many, and yet another tech business advertising on Wikipedia. Their claims to notability are minor trade awards: ''Best of Show and Best Software Solution at the Print & Imaging Summit, an event attended by Information Technology executives'' and ''Software Company of the Year Award by the New Zealand Hi-Tech Trust''. These awards don't establish that this business or its products have |historical, technical, or cultural significance. Neither do routine announcements of profit lines, acquisitions, or mergers Deletion of Pharos Systems International WP:MILL||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
17197 3119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Surf's Up! At Banzai Pipeline User:Hzh 13:21, 3 February 2019 (UTC) keep I can see the album discussed in https://books.google.com/books?id=MSFaAAAAYAAJ&dq=%22Surf%27s+Up%21+At+Banzai+Pipeline%22&focus=searchwithinvolume&q=%22Banzai+Pipeline%22https://books.google.com/books?id=Qq1AAQAAIAAJ&dq=%22Surf%27s+Up%21+At+Banzai+Pipeline%22&focus=searchwithinvolume&q=%22Surf%27s+Up%21+At+Banzai+Pipeline%22+, reviews in the http://www.pipelinemag.co.uk/ Pipeline magazine (issue 29 page 45) and http://www.reverbcentral.com/reviews/comp/surfs0881.html Reverb central. Not a great haul of sources, but it's worth noting that the album was released in 1963 (therefore archived sources on the internet are harder to find), but it was still discussed in the sources which include the 1973 Listener magazine (BBC, UK) and the 2008 book, multiple sources that suggest sustained interest in the album in the wider world, therefore passing and Deletion of Surf's Up! At Banzai Pipeline WP:NALBUM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17198 9045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Weeds Characters: Hodes, James, and Wilson Families User:Stuartyeates 08:25, 15 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails , articles need . If this there's a related article to merge to that has to support this content then merge (but none of the ones I'm seeing do Deletion of Weeds Characters: Hodes, James, and Wilson Families WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17199 5943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of the alleged Qur'an scientific miracles User:Matt57 05:53, 14 January 2008 (UTC) delete As I mentioned on the article's talk page, this page doesnt need to exist. Imad should stop all this Islam/science stuff. Imad, please read . We really dont need more problems in Islam related articles than we already have Deletion of List of the alleged Qur'an scientific miracles WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17200 54 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grand Duke George Mikhailovich of Russia User:Plutonium27 17:30, 15 September 2020 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Grand Duke George Mikhailovich of Russia WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
17201 20838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cockeysville Middle School (Cockeysville, Maryland) User:John 02:57, 4 December 2015 (UTC) merge to school district per /AG|guidelines and OOLOUTCOMES|SCHOOLOUTCOMES. {{u|CatcherStorm}}, it would take a whole lot more to show notability for a middle school than having a handful of notable grads and being named as an exceptional school by the school district. Generally, there has to be some claim of notability beyond the school's existence as a school (something like being on the NRHP). Numerous inclusions on the national Blue Ribbon Schools list will sometimes do it. Having a very large (>50) number of notable grads in one field might point to having a notable program in the school, but that would have to be verified by solid reliable sources independent of the school and geographically disperse. Example: If there were 70 notable actors from this school and you could find newspaper or magazine articles about the drama program, some from outside the Baltimore-DC metroplex, then maybe you might have notability. In short, there is no way this article gets kept, and I hate to see you wasting time on it. Almost all the Baltimore area high schools need reference work in their athletic sections. Hint, hint Deletion of Cockeysville Middle School (Cockeysville, Maryland) WP:SCH||WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Notability 77
17202 3777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Lynx bus routes (Orlando) User:Ajf773 09:18, 27 April 2021 (UTC) delete per , nothing notable about any of these routes Deletion of List of Lynx bus routes (Orlando) WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17203 20165 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rahul Ravi (Malayalam Actor) User:Fitindia 17:05, 13 July 2017 (UTC) delete The subject in question fail , and can't see any chance of this article having any encyclopedic value Deletion of Rahul Ravi (Malayalam Actor) WP:BIO||WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17204 11564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Intrigue FX User:HighKing 17:59, 21 October 2020 (UTC) delete I am unable to locate any |significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, references to date fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic therefore fails GNG/ Deletion of Intrigue FX WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17205 16387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Federation of BodyBuilding & Fitness User:VMS 04:15, 10 February 2015 (UTC) keep per . Somebody deleted all the third party GNG cites I added last April. I have no idea why, but I'm not going to waste time adding them again if they are just going to be deleted without explanation again Deletion of International Federation of BodyBuilding & Fitness WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17206 6318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kristina Lenko User:Ymblanter 06:40, 28 December 2012 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Kristina Lenko WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17207 12088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quetzal: match three, let the prizes come to me User:Videogameplayer99 21:27, 27 September 2017 (UTC) delete per Sergecross73, fails Deletion of Quetzal: match three, let the prizes come to me WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17208 7062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gordon Caplan User:Kyykaarme 22:38, 3 February 2020 (UTC) delete per , the article is about as as one can get Deletion of Gordon Caplan WP:BLP1E||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17209 6758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eksman User:Whpq 11:19, 20 March 2010 (UTC) comment """None of the sourcing in the article is what could be deemed |reliable. The interview listed is from a site which tells ouy """"Anyone can add an article to DontStayIn - click here to add your own!"""". Discogs is a """"user-built database containing information on artists, labels, and their recordings"""". Rolldabeats is a one man show which is really again a directory/database. Myspace and Facebook being his own sites aren't useful for establishing notability. Nor is that fact that his music is available for sale via download breakbeat notable. Winning the Drum and Bass Awards might be bnotable if it is a be a notable award, but from what I can see, it isn't""" Deletion of Eksman WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17210 5421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Fenton (ice hockey) User:Ravenswing 04:29, 23 December 2010 (UTC) delete """I would say that """"we generally take the same stance here"""" is a little on the mild side; the NHL is the sole arbiter of who counts as playing in an NHL game or not, and the NHL rule is that you have to take the ice to be counted as having played. Goalies on emergency fill-in ATOs happen every year or so, in similar circumstances; heck, having been a season-ticket holder in Springfield for years, I can recall at least three instances where an AIC goalie sat on the bench. Absolutely a """ Deletion of Tom Fenton (ice hockey) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17211 8057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Horn Africans in the United States User:Goldsztajn 16:21, 10 October 2019 (UTC) delete """Horn African"""" as a term seems colloquial. Article looks to be and . No results for """"Horn African"""" from an https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=Horn+Africans&year_start=1800&year_end=2019&corpus=15&smoothing=3&share=&direct_url= Ngram search. No results from a https://www.jstor.org/action/doBasicSearch?Query=""""Horn+Africans"""" Jstor search""" Deletion of Horn Africans in the United States WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
17212 10321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicole Pérez User:Jogurney 23:23, 3 April 2020 (UTC) keep Article about semi-pro footballer and top performer for the Mexico youth national teams. I've expanded the article a bit since the PROD, and there is plenty of online coverage in Spanish-language media, which I've started to summarize in the table below. I think there's more than enough to satisfy Deletion of Nicole Pérez WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17213 11081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Kya Mast Hai Life characters User:Reyk 22:28, 8 May 2012 (UTC) delete There are no sources whatsoever and the content is entirely in-universe plot summary. Per the , we would need independent secondary sources to justify a stand-alone article and there aren't any. And the existence of the show does not |justify an unlimited proliferation of crufty articles related to it. So there should not be a stand-alone article. The next question to consider is a merge. For a merge to work, we would need to be alble to identify usable content that would benefit the proposed merge target. Since all that's in this article is unsourced in-universe plot summary, I don't think any of it is any good Deletion of List of Kya Mast Hai Life characters WP:GNG||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
17214 9950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The desert highlife User:Holderca1 20:42, 24 October 2005 (UTC) delete doesn't appear to meet criteria (as pointed out by Deletion of The desert highlife WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17215 19983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David R. Hekman User:Bearian 19:22, 29 October 2009 (UTC) delete I H-index#Criticism|dislike the ''h''-index, but prefer Google scholar, which shows only 8 Ghits, so in any case, I see little evidence of notability under , at least as of now. Also: not a full professor yet; not a department chairperson yet; no major awards yet, etc. FWIW, even I have citations in the popular press Deletion of David R. Hekman WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17216 20407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hassan Al Haidos User:Bettia 09:56, 10 December 2008 (UTC) keep The Qatari first division is fully professional, and therefore he passes . Along with the sources provided in the article, there seems to be a few mentions in the international press (http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&safe=off&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-GB:official&hs=uC1&sa=X&oi=spell&resnum=0&ct=result&cd=1&q=%22Hassan+Al+Haidous%22&spell=1 under http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=%22Hassan+Al+Haidos%22&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=org.mozilla:en-GB:official&client=firefox-a all http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&safe=off&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla%3Aen-GB%3Aofficial&hs=uC1&q=%22Hassan+Al+Haydos%22&btnG=Search&meta= three suggested spellings of his name!) which could also be enough for his to pass the usual |notability standards Deletion of Hassan Al Haidos WP:ATHLETE||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17217 9163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Grand Lodges recognized by the Regular Grand Lodge of England (RGLE) User:Stifle 00:22, 9 May 2006 (UTC) delete per the RGLE's website Deletion of List of Grand Lodges recognized by the Regular Grand Lodge of England (RGLE) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17218 17955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amy Wechsler User:GauchoDude 17:19, 6 January 2017 (UTC) delete Per nom and above rationale. Fails Deletion of Amy Wechsler WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17219 8637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julie Homi NONE NONE delete """unless more in-depth coverage is found. I found no significant coverage of the subject in published reliable sources. I do consider the subject's performance on a successful album as suggestive of Wikipedia notability, but it is mitigated by being one of eight musicians on the album, and more importantly, without any coverage found about the subject's performance in particular. One of the underlying reasons behind the coverage requirements is described at , """"We require 'significant coverage' in reliable sources so that we can actually write a whole article, rather than half a paragraph or a definition of that topic."""" While some allowances are made for certain fields (e.g., nationally elected politicians get articles regardless of coverage; academics get articles based on their work even if there is no coverage about ''them''), I'm not sure how far that should be extended to a musician. To some extent, with a lack of good references, it's a choice between providing terribly deficient coverage of the subject, or no coverage""" Deletion of Julie Homi WP:WHYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
17220 5516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dinosaur Adventure User:Marasmusine 14:38, 27 December 2009 (UTC) merge to Phoenix Games, per Deletion of Dinosaur Adventure WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17221 41 [[Jennifer Wanderer]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Kriddl NONE delete Delahoyarecords ist ja noch nicht sooo lange dabei, daher ein paar Worte zu dem Fall. Die von Eingangskontrolle zitierten |Relevanzkriterien sind nicht seine privaten, sondern diejenigen, auf die man sich -z.T. in diskussionstechnischen Grabenkämpfen- geeinigt hat. Von den Kriterien käme hier allenfalls eine gewisse Wahrhehmung durch die Medien in Betracht, wobei diese darauf hindeuten muss, dass ein zeitübergreifendes Interesse besteht. Wie bereits von Kollegen geschrieben ist das bei nachrangig platzierten Personen einer Casting-Show nicht der Fall. Konzept dieser Shows ist schlicht eine mehr oder weniger große Zahl von Personen durchzusieben, bis eine Person übrigbleibt. In der Zwischenzeit wird in den Medien über die Show zwar berichtet, die Kanidaten werden aber nur im Rahmen dessen abgehandelt. Eine gewisse Ausnahme ist der Gewinner und solche Teilnehmer, bei denen noch danach etwas kommt (z.B. Chartplatzierungen). Mit anmdeen Worten: Solange es nur die Teilnahme ist, ist von einer Berichterstattung und öffentlichen Wahrnehmung in der Regel nicht auszugehen. Eine beliebige Online-Publikation danach hilft da auch nicht. Für die müsste nachgewiesen werden, dass diese auf breiterer Basis eine gewisse Wahrnehmung besteht. Wie oben auch schon geschrieben ist Wikipedia in gewisser Hinsicht sehr konservativ, sie will nicht möglicherweise mal bedeutsames sammeln, sondern bereits Bedeutsames. Ich drücke Frau Wanderer daher gerne die Daumen, dass sie mal wichtig wird, zur Zeit plädiere ich aber für die des Artikels. Löschung von Jennifer Wanderer Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
17222 10814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Prysner User:RayAYang 20:16, 9 May 2011 (UTC) delete Fails . Purely trivial coverage of his positions, no coverage of him per se, as required by notability criteria Deletion of Michael Prysner WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17223 11523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC 142 User:Pat 16:59, 24 April 2012 (UTC) keep There's not much more to be said about this article. For me it falls completely under . If, for some reason, this doesn't meet all of Wikipedia guidelines perfectly, I think it demonstrates a clear weakness in Wikipedia's guidelines when it comes to mixed martial arts events. I would very much like to see a discussion in about possibly altering these notability guidelines. I follow a lot of sports and I find it very hard to fathom that certain events, such as tennis challenger series (please don't go on a crusade against them), are more notable than major MMA events Deletion of UFC 142 WP:COMMON||WP:MMANOT "Wikipedia:What ""Ignore all rules"" means" 62
17224 16742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Planet Dog Records User:Sparklism 13:31, 22 June 2015 (UTC) keep The sources added since the start of this AfD are enough to meet our |guideline for inclusion Deletion of Planet Dog Records WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17225 5042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Easy Records User:Tychocat 14:54, 30 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails , , and . Is an advertisement, article text is lifted verbatim from a http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendid=58918276 MySpace page Deletion of Easy Records WP:WEB||WP:MUSIC||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17226 212 [[Krio de Morto]] (bleibt erstmal) Benutzer:Gestumblindi 22:09, 28. Aug. 2007 (CEST) keep """LA ist obwohl Nr. 3 wahrscheinlich gültig, da die Begründung zur Abwechslung nicht angeblich fehlende Relevanz sondern unbefriedigende Artikelqualität ist. Nur darüber kann man jetzt ''hier'' diskutieren (es gibt keine neuen Argumente gegen ihre Relevanz; wollte man also """"sie sind doch irrelevant!"""" sagen, obwohl in den beiden letzten Löschdiskussionen auf Relevanz befunden wurde, wäre hier der falsche Ort und zu bemühen). Die Qualität des Artikels geht jedoch völlig in Ordnung. Kurz, aber korrekt, wie es scheint. Es besteht also kein Löschgrund und damit""" Löschung von Krio de Morto Wikipedia:LP Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
17227 18940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Halima Begum User:E 18:40, 17 October 2018 (UTC) delete """there are a ''lot'' of women named Halima Begum in the world (searching in Latin alphabet). This is the one with a piddling 886 twitter followers (not a valid metric, but when I see 60,000 followers for a policy wonk I've never heard of, I take it as a hint that I should be able to find sources.) Problem is, scanning the hits, even using keywords, I'm not finding anything to support notability. She appears to be what the page indicates that she is, a non-notable British ecpert on economic development. There are only 3 sources on the page, a potted speaker's bio; a website celebrating British Bangladeshis; and a dead link to something called, """"British Bangladeshi Power & Inspiration."""" Fails """ Deletion of Halima Begum WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17228 17150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Dan Kokoro Hikareteku User:Xymmax 21:18, 5 June 2008 (UTC) merge to Field of View. A redirect to the group or other appropriate target is the normal dispostion for songs under , and it seems likely to me that a reasonable number of those searching for this song will be doing so after discovering the anime, so mention of it is appropriate in the band's article. Actually, if this weren't at AfD I'd do a merge/redirect now Deletion of Dan Dan Kokoro Hikareteku WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17229 19046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Imperial Botanical Beach Hotel User:SamHolt6 04:31, 17 September 2017 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a directory per . A single establishment in a chain of hotels is not notable Deletion of Imperial Botanical Beach Hotel WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17230 20034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sabrina Schloss User:Chris 21:15, 25 March 2018 (UTC) delete Subject fails , , and Deletion of Sabrina Schloss WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17231 17403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unique Party (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 16:54, 20 April 2020 (UTC) delete To be fair, a political party's notability isn't a factor of its vote totals per se — even small fringe parties can be notable enough for inclusion here if they receive sufficient |reliable source coverage to clear . Rather, the core problem here is the article's complete and total lack of any reliable sources to support its notability at all. And even on the Swedish Wikipedia, the party actually just has a redirect to Linda Thelenius Rosing's BLP, rather than a standalone article about the political party itself — and if the Swedish Wikipedia, where the editor base literally by definition are going to have much better access to archived 15-year-old Swedish media coverage than the rest of us do, still can't find enough sources about a Swedish political party to get it over their notability standards, it can hardly be ''more'' notable in English than it is in its own native language Deletion of Unique Party (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17232 19652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammed al-Darbi User:Anotherclown 21:55, 27 July 2012 (UTC) delete """the subjects of the articles are not notable as they lack """"sigificant coverage"""" in reliable sources per . As such, invididual articles for each of them cannot be justified and aren't necessary. What little information that does exist is included elsewhere and is sufficient""" Deletion of Muhammed al-Darbi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17233 13524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nipple sucking User:HisSpaceResearch 14:31, 16 June 2007 (UTC) comment gonna remove it per on second thoughts. Back to the nipple sucking debate please Deletion of Nipple sucking WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17234 99 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Emin Seçkin Kullanıcı:mecnun112mecnun 20:21, 11 Şubat 2016 (UTC) delete Yargıtay üye olması kriterlerini taşıması için yeterli değil Emin Seçkin'in silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
17235 15691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Why Wait User:Esradekan 01:44, 13 August 2008 (UTC) merge back to main article until such time as it is released, and more references are supplied. Go |The Hammer Deletion of Why Wait WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
17236 2612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boity Thulo User:onel5969 13:47, 4 December 2015 (UTC) keep while I agree with the assessment of the current source, there is quite a bit out there on this actress. I also think this is a case of why is she notable, but she does at least pass , if not , as shown by articles http://www.bellanaija.com/2015/11/19/8-times-cassper-nyovest-boity-gave-us-couplegoals-while-on-a-romantic-vacation/ here, http://www.sundayworld.co.za/shwashwi/2015/11/06/cassper-nyovest-and-boity-on-baecation-photos here, http://www.channel24.co.za/The-Juice/Boity-Thulo-I-also-had-to-drop-out-of-university-20151022 here, http://mg.co.za/article/2015-07-16-boity-thulo-dispels-reports-of-her-engagement-to-cassper-nyovest here, http://www.channel24.co.za/The-Juice/Boity-Thulo-I-choose-Refiloe-every-day-20151030 here, http://www.channel24.co.za/The-Juice/Nandi-and-Boity-rubbish-feud-claims-20151012 here, http://www.iol.co.za/tonight/music/childish-boity-stirs-trouble-at-mamas-1.1887513#.VmGYZ_-FPIU here, http://connect.citizen.co.za/28107/boity-leaves-unpaid-bill-for-somizi/ here, and http://www.timeslive.co.za/entertainment/celebrity/2015/03/08/boity-thulo-pulls-an-emma-watson-with-speech-on-womens-rights here. And that's just on the first two pages at News Deletion of Boity Thulo WP:BASIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17237 18020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Gabb User:Ralbegen 20:25, 14 March 2018 (UTC) delete per nominator's reasoning. I can't find substantial coverage in reliable sources to justify existence by Deletion of Sean Gabb WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17238 4616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of current Major League Soccer players with national team caps User:Ajf773 08:56, 22 December 2016 (UTC) delete Definitely Deletion of List of current Major League Soccer players with national team caps WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
17239 18874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shroomin' At Moles (Single) User:Rlendog 13:41, 28 August 2009 (UTC) merge to B.l.o.w. given lack of notability per Deletion of Shroomin' At Moles (Single) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17240 8911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandra Rujević User:DrStrauss 12:02, 3 August 2017 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Sandra Rujević WP:NBADMINTON Wikipedia:Notability 77
17241 8887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Speed racer pass User:MuZemike 07:01, 10 October 2008 (UTC) delete per and . Arguably #A1|Steak sauce material, as well Deletion of Speed racer pass WP:NEO||WP:NFT||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17242 10006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ivan Antonov (Professional Gamer) User:Odie5533 15:48, 19 October 2011 (UTC) keep """Per , """"have participated in a major international amateur or professional competition at the highest level such as the Olympics."""" As a member of team Natus Vincere|Na'vi, Antonov participated in (and subsequently won) """"The International"""", a major international professional competition for Dota 2 that was held at Gamescom 2011. See http://www.shacknews.com/article/69831/dota-2-tournament-1-million-prize-won-by-navi ShackNews""" Deletion of Ivan Antonov (Professional Gamer) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17243 16829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harshita Tiwary User:Bearian 00:51, 15 October 2020 (UTC) delete per and - up and coming model and actress with a very short resume Deletion of Harshita Tiwary WP:GNG||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17244 1847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christine Caine User:pd_THOR 14:54, 20 July 2006 (UTC) keep First ten of http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Christine+Caine%22+-wikipedia 10200 google results all seem appropos, http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&q=%22Christine%20Caine%22%20-wikipedia&sa=N&tab=wn google news also serves a relevant result: coordinator for 40000 Hillsong volunteers at July conference in Sydney. Fulfills afaict Deletion of Christine Caine WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17245 2708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 Summer Tour User:Newslinger 18:08, 30 July 2018 (UTC) delete Not notable. Doesn't meet or . No significant coverage from reliable sources, just routine coverage. Reviews of the artists' concerts during this tour focus on the artists, and make no mention of the tour's name. Since it's a co-headlining tour, there's no suitable redirect target. — Deletion of 2012 Summer Tour WP:GNG||WP:NTOUR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17246 11005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lizette Parker (2nd nomination) User:Gidonb 06:17, 8 May 2018 (UTC) keep as she meets the . I am open to all options with relisting so was curious as to the reason for the relist after 6 months. This is short. Was disappointed that nominator did not provide a good reason and instead claimed it isn't short Deletion of Lizette Parker (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17247 72 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hideki Shiohira User:Papaursa 17:18, 1 August 2010 (UTC) delete This is an unreferenced BLP and there is no indication that he meets any of the notability criteria at . His instuctors may be notable, but notability is not inherited. I found no independent sources that show notability Deletion of Hideki Shiohira WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17248 8627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/X Ray: The Inner Image User:Atlantic306 00:58, 23 March 2020 (UTC) keep as since its release it has received full, independent reviews in national newspapers such as Times of India https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/hindi/movie-reviews/x-ray-the-inner-image/movie-review/72291872.cms here and Deccan Herald https://www.deccanherald.com/brandspot/pr-spot/x-ray-the-inner-image-a-technically-and-aesthetically-sound-psychological-thriller-movie-review-3-star-780665.html here, and MidDay https://m.mid-day.com/articles/x-ray-the-inner-image-a-true-hollywood-style-blood-and-gore-psychological-thriller/22166175 here, therefore passing criteria 1 which indicates a pass of , imv Deletion of X Ray: The Inner Image WP:NFILM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17249 3518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticism of info-gap decision theory User:JJL 01:12, 20 March 2009 (UTC) delete essay based on one (?) theory that argues a specific POV Deletion of Criticism of info-gap decision theory WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
17250 15913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Organic Narratives (2nd nomination) User:Exemplo347 14:17, 15 August 2018 (UTC) delete The lack of evidence that this entered any national charts is a huge problem. The fact that this article, if created today, would probably fall foul of is another concern. Wikipedia isn't meant to be a list of trivialities and non-notable things Deletion of Organic Narratives (2nd nomination) WP:A9 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17251 6177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moshe Abutbul User:NYC2TLV 00:04, 5 June 2009 (UTC) comment Player is proffesional and he has played on a fully professional level per Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues and he meets thlete. Article does shows that it passes and as such this discussion should be closed Deletion of Moshe Abutbul WP:A||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Attribution 108
17252 9892 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergeant Troy """"Told"""" 'Ya'""" User:Metropolitan90 05:21, 7 January 2009 (UTC) delete This is the same person whose article was deleted a few weeks ago at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergeant Troy. However, there are still no real independent sources to confirm his claim to be a signed recording artist. If he is for real, he will get coverage in |reliable sources soon enough, and ''then'' we can have an article about him in Wikipedia """Deletion of Sergeant Troy """"Told"""" 'Ya'""" WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17253 13033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Treasure in the Jungle: Journey to the Death User:dchall1 16:42, 24 October 2008 (UTC) delete per , plus obvious self-promotion Deletion of Treasure in the Jungle: Journey to the Death WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17254 2636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michaelwood services User:Ajf773 23:03, 14 July 2018 (UTC) delete per , and . This is hardly a major shopping complex, it's a service station with a few shops attached Deletion of Michaelwood services WP:NOTGUIDE||WP:NOTDIR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17255 1268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isabella Cramp User:Bearian 17:50, 5 May 2014 (UTC) delete per , we often delete BLPs of child actors who have only had minor roles Deletion of Isabella Cramp WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17256 15314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles McLaren, 4th Baron Aberconway (2nd nomination) user:Andrew 18:11, 11 April 2020 (UTC) keep """The topic has already been discussed and kept at AfD. As the nomination is mostly personal bias per , applies, """"It can be disruptive to repeatedly nominate a page in the hope of getting a different outcome""" Deletion of Charles McLaren, 4th Baron Aberconway (2nd nomination) WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:DELAFD Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17257 16250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional guidebooks User:JJL 02:32, 17 March 2008 (UTC) delete it's but hardly seems encyclopedic. Is a Pokedex truly a ''guide''book Deletion of List of fictional guidebooks WP:INTERESTING Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17258 1832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BM Nekutāru User:Goodraise 21:58, 15 April 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of BM Nekutāru WP:NOTPLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17259 19246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew J Newman User:CronopioFlotante 21:35, 1 September 2009 (UTC) comment If we are going to decide that #1 is satisfied based on non-english sources, do we have any evidence of Persian or Arabic citations of his work? I'm asking because I think that Wikipedia policy is that someone is non-notable unless shown otherwise, not the other way around Deletion of Andrew J Newman WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17260 14623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of organizations in the Honorverse (2nd nomination) User:RetiredDuke 10:34, 2 June 2019 (UTC) delete as there is no coverage of this content to be found in independent reliable sources. I'm also confused by the calls for a merge. The article is virtually unsourced, spreading unsourced content across the encyclopedia goes against Deletion of List of organizations in the Honorverse (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17261 8149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quidco (3rd nomination) User:Asterion 16:31, 13 October 2010 (UTC) keep """The website meets , it has """"multiple non-trivial independent sources"""". Regards""" Deletion of Quidco (3rd nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17262 1279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St Christopher Iba Mar Diop College of Medicine NONE NONE comment I have looked at all the references for SCIMD-COM, and some statements made in the article based on those references. The majority of references are either (a) self published, (b) lists giving no significant coverage of the subject, (c) criteria from which inferences are being drawn . One reference mentions the subject superficially whilst discussing another medical school, one I can not check (requires subscription) and one appears to be a valid in-depth coverage of the college. Here's the breakdown by reference number in the current article Deletion of St Christopher Iba Mar Diop College of Medicine WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
17263 12042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cruel Hand User:Chubbles 12:31, 8 April 2011 (UTC) keep Two releases on Bridge Nine Records satisfies ; I added a reference from Allmusic, Google turns up more Deletion of Cruel Hand WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17264 234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Texas Spinning Hound User:Metropolitan90 13:57, 17 June 2008 (UTC) delete as |original research. Wikipedia is not the place to debut the description of a new dog breed. We are only supposed to include in this encyclopedia topics that have already been noted previously elsewhere. If this breed is formally recognized, or even if not formally recognized becomes discussed in the media, we may be able to include an article about it at that time Deletion of Texas Spinning Hound WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
17265 18768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Manikfan [[User talk:202.124.73.162|talk]]) 12:53, 3 August 2011 (UTC) merge Islamic calendar. I am prepared to accept that this individual might notable, but the present article relies almost entirely on unreliable sources, leading to problems, and other sources in English are very thin. The material on the calendar is certainly notable, but logically belongs in Islamic calendar. -- Special:Contributions/202.124.73.162|202.124.73.162 Deletion of Ali Manikfan WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17266 14478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of celebrities with natural breasts implants User:Metropolitan90 13:34, 11 May 2006 (UTC) delete per A1; the article makes no attempt to explain its self-contradictory title Deletion of List of celebrities with natural breasts implants WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17267 8960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Face Lift User:Truco 19:32, 30 January 2009 (UTC) delete does not meet Deletion of The Face Lift WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17268 1106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colin Nell NONE NONE delete Sources used to establish notability under need to be independent, reliable, and in-depth; of the current sources, almost all are passing mentions (a sentence or two of barebones biography in the context of Mo Farah or the train safety program) or publicist bios from his own or his agents' websites. The closest to a satisfactory source is http://www.emel.com/article?id=80&a_id=2255 a three-paragraph bio in emel (magazine), which is pretty good for establishing notability but not very detailed or specific, and anyway GNG requires multiple such sources. Google finds no better ones Deletion of Colin Nell WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17269 7243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keith Miller (voice actor) User:A 21:54, 22 February 2012 (UTC) delete I looked into this once before but didn't comment; I still haven't found any significant coverage of Miller in secondary sources, so I don't believes he meets Deletion of Keith Miller (voice actor) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17270 9081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lancaster County Drive User:Joe 21:43, 6 September 2009 (UTC) delete Like most streets, |non-notable Deletion of Lancaster County Drive WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17271 2212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2021 International Friendlies User:Joseph2302 10:01, 30 March 2021 (UTC) delete per , we don't need a separate article for this. The relevant information is (or at least could be) in the team pages for the countries. As they're friendlies and not a tournament like World Cup, Euros/Copa America, there is no link between friendlies, and so as per {{U|Spiderone}}, I cannot see how it would ever be able to satisfy Deletion of 2021 International Friendlies WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:NLIST Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17272 14395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Honey Creek Middle School User:Joseph2302 12:27, 2 June 2015 (UTC) delete Non-notable middle school, fails and , doesn't pass as it's not a secondary school (high school to use the US term Deletion of Honey Creek Middle School WP:GNG||WP:CORP||WP:NSCHOOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17273 20236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/V-Focus User:Northamerica1000 00:23, 4 November 2016 (UTC) comment It's a new program that has received no significant coverage in reliable sources; filming began on September 21, 2016. This is a nomination for deletion, not a cleanup request. Lastly, is an essay page, not a notability guideline Deletion of V-Focus WP:BROADCAST Wikipedia:Notability 77
17274 11869 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jai Boo User:Yeanold 09:26, 14 October 2007 (UTC) keep Article satisfies otability, specifically sections 11. ''Has been placed in rotation nationally by any major radio network'' and 12. ''Has been the subject of a half hour or longer broadcast across a national radio or TV network''. Subject needs only satisfy one of these criteria in order to be kept. Google hits are only to be used as a rough indicator in lieu of other notability criteria, and the fact that subject hails from Wolverhampton is irrelevant Deletion of Jai Boo WP:N||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17275 2761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kris Slater User:ArcAngel 19:56, 12 March 2008 (UTC) delete for failing Deletion of Kris Slater WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17276 10413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Association of Business Communicators User:Bearian 20:23, 12 July 2007 (UTC) keep as per above. Originally, a |conflicted mess, I'll work more on it, too, right now Deletion of International Association of Business Communicators WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
17277 14583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of programmes broadcast by Milkshake! User:Mrschimpf 18:52, 28 August 2017 (UTC) comment ping|Logosncompanies}} has claimed on the talk page of this nom (wrong place to post that) there are sources now. There are not; the 'sources' are just the Milkshake home page and their program page about Pingu. As s they are wholly disqualified. Please address this, LNC Deletion of List of programmes broadcast by Milkshake! WP:PRIMARYSOURCE Wikipedia:No original research 65
17278 17159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inlight User:Pdcook 20:19, 28 February 2010 (UTC) delete I found http://bandweblogs.com/blog/2009/03/25/inlight-live-review-interview-with-charlie-cooke/ this blog article, which probably falls short of a reliable source. Otherwise I can find no sources that demonstrate notability per Deletion of Inlight WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17279 6886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Equix NONE NONE delete unless the ''Thoroughbred Times'' articles and 1 google news hit are sufficient to make it meet . ''No assertion of significance in the artcle Deletion of Equix WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17280 3254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaun T User:Rms125a 23:20, 6 June 2014 (UTC) delete fails |notability, fails |GNG Deletion of Shaun T WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17281 6911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Answer from the Stars User:Reference 11:19, 23 April 2011 (UTC) delete Fails http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=Chilbolton+%22Answer+from+the+Stars%22&num=100&hl=en&lr=&tbm=nws&source=lnt&tbs=ar:1&sa=X&ei=nLWyTbPwCsTWrQei2azIDQ&ved=0CBIQpwUoBQ&biw=1366&bih=627 Deletion of Answer from the Stars WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17282 4280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of endangered animal species User:JimMillerJr 17:00, 20 February 2010 (UTC) keep to IUCN Red List endangered anamalia species and continue to break up a list that is currently over 1100 kB, far beyond the size for a . If this one is not kept, some kind of breakdown should be found to get this into multiple lists of reasonable page lengths. The anamalia list is over 600kB by itself, so there may be a better method than splitting by kingdom. IUCN Red List endangered species is far too large to remain a single list Deletion of List of endangered animal species WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Splitting 57
17283 14416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of political magazines User:Northamerica1000 18:42, 28 April 2016 (UTC) keep Qualifies for an article per relative to :Category:Political magazines. Also qualifies as a functional navigational aid per Deletion of List of political magazines WP:NOTDUP||WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
17284 17347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MyAnimeList (4th nomination) User:Tarc 17:57, 19 March 2012 (UTC) delete Failure of . This should have been deleted long ago, but past AfDs on this were plagued with flawed keep rationales that cited term papers and press releases Deletion of MyAnimeList (4th nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
17285 7071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rolv Hauge User:Sionk 10:03, 15 April 2014 (UTC) delete I tend to agree, it seems he served as a captain in World War II so didn't command a large body of men or perform a major role. His medal was received much later for non-combat duties. Though he's of enough interest to an edition of ''Hvem er Hvem?'', I don't think that means he meets or . 'Weak' delete because Rolv Hauge is not an uncommon name, so someone with a better understanding of the Norwegian language may be able to turn up other information to prove me wrong Deletion of Rolv Hauge WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17286 228 [[Saarländische Sagen und Legenden]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Thüringer NONE keep Ich finde den Artikel okay, wenn auch ungewöhnlich. Der Löschantrag enthält keine |Begründung Löschung von Saarländische Sagen und Legenden Wikipedia:Löschregeln Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
17287 20956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clover Records User:Joe 01:38, 15 June 2010 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Clover Records WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17288 15014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ad Astra Films User:MichaelQSchmidt 00:56, 10 June 2010 (UTC) delete Produced 1 film in 2008 and distributed 5 since 2007. Not very productive. Not much in distribution. Lack of coverage of this company fails and Deletion of Ad Astra Films WP:GNG||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17289 12064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United Nations in popular culture User:Bearian 01:51, 7 August 2020 (UTC) keep per - plenty of sources to show it's influenced TV, film, and novels. Some of the cruft needs to be removed, but nothing that ordinary editing can't find and fix Deletion of United Nations in popular culture WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17290 18748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Techtronica User:Dhartung 00:34, 4 February 2007 (UTC) delete as yes, in fact, we are constnatly deleting bands that do not meet notability criteria, such as this one. Sorry Deletion of Techtronica WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17291 7540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nidal Malik Hasan User:Irn 17:14, 14 November 2009 (UTC) keep The strongest argument I can see for deleting runs like this: ''in order to keep the article, the argument has to be made that this is an exception to . For this to be an exception to , Hasan had to have had a “substantial” role in the Fort Hood killings. And when we say that he had a substantial role, we are necessarily jumping to the conclusion that he is guilty. And by doing that we are violating .'' However, I disagree that we are effectively concluding about Hasan’s guilt. Indeed, if he were innocent, his role is still substantial enough to warrant its own page simply due to the fact that all major media are treating him as guilty and devoting so much time and space to him as a person such that, were he to be exonerated, he would still warrant his own article as a result Deletion of Nidal Malik Hasan WP:BLP1E||WP:BLP1E||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17292 4343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mario Party 10 User:Sergecross73 15:07, 7 August 2012 (UTC) delete Per / G3. The game hasn't been announced, and this isn't even one of those titles where there have been well circulated rumors or leaks or anything. It's all completely made up Deletion of Mario Party 10 WP:HOAX||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
17293 19773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meredith Jung-En Woo User:Coredesat 22:39, 27 August 2006 (UTC) keep meets , potential bad faith nomination Deletion of Meredith Jung-En Woo WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17294 21959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Precocious User:Goh 16:13, 19 December 2006 (UTC) delete per . ''Precociousness'' would be a better article title, and the article could talk about the prevalence of precociousness, its effects and causes, etc. And once you conjure what the article could contain, it seems intuitive from the term's relative broadness that this does not belong to an encyclopaedia. &mdash Deletion of Precocious WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17295 17724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Optical Express Challenge Cup (2nd nomination) User:Kosm1fent 17:39, 14 October 2012 (UTC) delete an article about a pre-season friendly which fails . &ndash Deletion of Optical Express Challenge Cup (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17296 9272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary Holian User:Calton 14:49, 26 July 2019 (UTC) delete """I don't see the slightest sign he qualifies under specifically or generally, nor has anyone seen fit to provide evidence otherwise. """"Hope"""" is not a substitute for ACTUAL reliable sources""" Deletion of Gary Holian WP:NAUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17297 15836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vídeo Brinquedo (2nd nomination) User:WilyD 12:44, 7 January 2009 (UTC) keep Passes at 20 000 feet. Deletion arguments seem disconnected from facts, not sure what to say about that. Odd Deletion of Vídeo Brinquedo (2nd nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17298 20957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/7th Cross User:Henning 08:52, 19 March 2006 (UTC) delete per #A7 Deletion of 7th Cross WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17299 17558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss Earth country rankings User:The 23:28, 2 January 2016 (UTC) delete unsourced, and plain fancruft Deletion of Miss Earth country rankings WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
17300 5905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Englishman in L.A. User:Northamerica1000 10:37, 31 January 2017 (UTC) delete After searching around, unless I'm missing something, not finding any coverage in reliable sources. Fails Deletion of Englishman in L.A. WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17301 7500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SMH Records (2nd nomination) NONE NONE delete WP:5P - Wikipedia is not an |advertising platform. The return of the incessant attempt to abuse Wikipedia to promote Jonathan Hay (publicist) and associated subjects (Jonathan Hay Publicity, Hoopla Worldwide, Sabrina (pop singer), Audio Stepchild, Birdgang clothing, A Different Kind Of Christmas, Michael Barber (musician)) Wikipedia:Conflict of interest/Noticeboard/Archive 62#Jonathan Hay (publicist). Stop rewarding bad faithed editing. Help stop the rot, |delete spam to help preserve the integrity of Wikipedia Deletion of SMH Records (2nd nomination) WP:SPAM||WP:IAR Wikipedia:Spam 112
17302 964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Opinion polling for the United States presidential election, 2008 User:Guest9999 21:35, 25 December 2007 (UTC) comment """As mentioned above (thank you) I did not say that there was a consensus that lists should not be included in Wikipedia. This is clearly not the case (see , , , :Category:Lists); I said that there is a consensus that long """"lists of statistics"""" should not be included and linked to the policy that says as much #STATS. I do not agree that a list of poll results is an effective way of communicating information, I feel that an article based on commentry of analysis of the polls and trends shown by the polls would be far more informative than a long list of numbers""" Deletion of Opinion polling for the United States presidential election, 2008 WP:LIST||WP:SAL||WP:WIAFL||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Lists 97
17303 4514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khaled El-Khweldi El-Hamedi User:Antipastor 12:02, 13 October 2009 (UTC) comment This was previously A7 speedy deleted, but not sure if same version exactly. I am putting it here because of many recreations just to avoid repeated independent deletions. I think it can be deleted per Deletion of Khaled El-Khweldi El-Hamedi WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17304 18881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010–11 Newport County A.F.C. season User:Spiderone 14:39, 30 August 2020 (UTC) delete per nom; also fails Deletion of 2010–11 Newport County A.F.C. season WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17305 2682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of notable Star Wars substances User:Lugnuts 18:16, 9 September 2015 (UTC) delete This is |cruft at its best. Or worst Deletion of List of notable Star Wars substances WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
17306 19237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Narayanganj Club Ltd User:RationalPuff 18:19, 10 February 2021 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Narayanganj Club Ltd WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17307 8913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerda and Kai (book) User:Stuartyeates 18:41, 7 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails and appears to have issues Deletion of Gerda and Kai (book) WP:GNG||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
17308 4433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/In the Mix (Pink album) User:Bearian 21:11, 24 November 2009 (UTC) delete both per , this is not notable even as remixes and bootlegs go Deletion of In the Mix (Pink album) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17309 8398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Gift for Zooter User:Piotrus 13:11, 13 March 2020 (UTC) delete or '''Redirect''' to Jungle Junction. Does not seem to warrant a stand-alone article in light of and related Deletion of A Gift for Zooter WP:NMEDIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
17310 6329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephanie Pace Marshall User:TJMSmith 14:32, 8 May 2020 (UTC) keep per and . She is a Fellow of the Royal Society of Arts. Additionally, at least two of her works (books) are the subject of multiple reviews (this should be added into the article). A thorough would turn up these reviews Deletion of Stephanie Pace Marshall WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17311 2451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 Chinese memes war on Facebook User:Power 02:00, 9 July 2017 (UTC) delete per . Egregiously promotional in nature as-written, and likely not notable as a stand-alone event Deletion of 2016 Chinese memes war on Facebook WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
17312 11251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Diplomacy User:SportingFlyer 04:09, 19 December 2018 (UTC) delete WP:NJOURNALS is just an essay, but it fails it, and I couldn't find anything on either in terms of non-primary sources Deletion of American Diplomacy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17313 18672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of TV networks that air The Amazing Race( 2nd nomination) User:Otto4711 22:19, 3 April 2007 (UTC) delete Per the Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of TV networks that air The Amazing Race|first AFD the reason many or most wanted this article kept was because of the size of the main TAR article. I agree that this does not belong in the main article and it also doesn't belong in a separate list article. #DIR|Wikipedia is not a directory of program syndication or a TV Guide. The originating network, CBS, is already noted in the article and for the rest, viewers should check their local listings Deletion of List of TV networks that air The Amazing Race( 2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17314 15435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brooke Gilbertsen [[User talk:Sandahl|'''Sandahl''']] 03:35, 1 November 2007 (UTC) delete Reposted A7, she fails , didn't win the 2007 Diva Search, being a contestant does not confer notability Deletion of Brooke Gilbertsen WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17315 18408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sshguard User:Walter 00:21, 13 November 2012 (UTC) delete The sources supplied here are not reliable. One blog and two how-to. The fourth is a forum discussion about it. I suspect that it could be a notable product, but I can't find any es that have written feature articles about it Deletion of Sshguard :WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17316 6207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parnia Porsche User:Papaursa 01:42, 13 August 2016 (UTC) comment It's quite clear is not met. I also don't believe , which covers models and celebrities, is met--although some might argue that appearing in Maxim shows/generates notability. My apathy, and hence lack of knowledge, about the entertainment business and pop culture means I don't feel real comfortable voting at this time. If I had to vote, and I don't, I'd be leaning towards delete Deletion of Parnia Porsche WP:NBOX||WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
17317 20011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marygiri Public School NONE 00:38, 25 January 2007 (UTC) merge to Koothattukulam per and proposed school guidelines. http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Yamaguchi%E5%85%88%E7%94%9F&action=edit§ion=new Yamaguchi先生 Deletion of Marygiri Public School WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
17318 4184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Turkic ideograms User:Voceditenore 09:05, 2 July 2011 (UTC) delete per BabelStone. This article was essentially created http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Turkic_ideograms&oldid=437033555 here as a |coatrack for the slew of other articles by the same editor relating to his dubious fringe research (and movement). Of the original 9 created, 5 have already been deleted via AfD. In addition to this one, http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:WikiProject_Deletion_sorting/Hungary&oldid=437366194#Hungary 3 others are currently at AfD Deletion of Turkic ideograms WP:COAT Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
17319 12308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madame Hooligan User:Valereee 17:11, 11 May 2015 (UTC) delete I can't judge the Romanian sources, but the fact there is ZERO about them in ANY reliable English-language source makes me think that they aren't notable. Maybe it's just but since they only had one album six years ago I'm not sure they're every going to become notable Deletion of Madame Hooligan WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
17320 7319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Molly Kingsbury User:The 09:49, 4 May 2018 (UTC) delete """for explicitly failing . The rule is as follows: {{tq|Must have finished top 8 in a competition at the highest level outside of the Olympic games and world championships. Individual events in these championships must contain either several heats or extended fields in Commonwealth Games, etc.}} Yet, the subject of the article, as the article itself informs us, """"was selected for the England team for the 2018 Commonwealth Games,"""" and that """"was ''her first appearance'' at a senior event."""" Emphasis added. Try as we might (or even desire, since her courage is admirable), the subject does not meet the notability criteria""" Deletion of Molly Kingsbury WP:NTRACK Wikipedia:Notability 77
17321 8965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marionettes in pop-culture User:Eliz81 17:03, 26 July 2007 (UTC) delete WP:NOT#TRIVIA, , unreferenced Deletion of Marionettes in pop-culture WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
17322 11126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Music People (2nd nomination) User:Rhododendrites 22:20, 13 April 2019 (UTC) delete We have a company profile based, seemingly, just on its own website. That's a problem. Considering ALpha3031's review of the sources, it sounds like there's a notability issue, too, but I'm content postponing judgment on that if someone wants to recreate this with a bunch of reliable independent sources later. &mdash Deletion of The Music People (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17323 17200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Association of Churches User:Softlavender 10:55, 5 June 2016 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Association of Churches WP:NOTDIC Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17324 18442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maldon mud race User:Northamerica1000 12:31, 24 January 2016 (UTC) keep The subject meets . Source examples include, but are not limited to: {{cite web|url=http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-essex-14417819|title=Maldon Mud Race set for permanent switch to spring date|publisher=BBC News}}, {{cite web|url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/2613351.stm|title=River race gets down and dirty|publisher=BBC News}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2009/jan/05/mud-race-essex-uk|title=Our man in the ... Annual mud race in Essex|author=|work=the Guardian}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.essexchronicle.co.uk/Super-fit-mud-race-wally-champ/story-26409948-detail/story.html|title=Meet super-fit Bill Suggitt - the Maldon Mud Race champion|work=Essex Chronicle}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2319906/Maldon-Mud-Race-2013-Thats-way-spend-bank-holiday.html|title=Maldon Mud Race 2013: That's one way to spend the bank holiday!|date=5 May 2013|work=Mail Online}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-essex-13194712|title=Maldon Mud Race organisers eye permanent Easter date|work=BBC News}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/maldon-mud-race-sees-300-5589543|title=Maldon Mud Race sees 300 runners brave the muck of the River Blackwater in fancy dress|date=|work=Daily Mirror Deletion of Maldon mud race WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17325 3778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Back To Square One (Band) User:Kudpung 20:52, 31 August 2017 (UTC) delete clear case of failing to meet . Wikipedia is not for promoting new music groups or their recordings Deletion of Back To Square One (Band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17326 15767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Adventures of Captain Underpants User:Bonkers 06:53, 24 November 2012 (UTC) comment Also be wary for all those votes that might appear later on... Like it did during this afd. http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia%3AArticles_for_deletion%2FCaptain_Underpants_and_the_Preposterous_Plight_of_the_Purple_Potty_People&diff=515275128&oldid=515274912 Deletion of The Adventures of Captain Underpants WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17327 11578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scientology In Australia User:Gorkymalorki 04:17, 31 July 2007 (UTC) keep I think parts of this article are salvageable, it just needs a very thorough cleanup, especially from a more neutral sounding POV. That does not warrant a deletion. And I disagree about it being a Deletion of Scientology In Australia WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
17328 14690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wings.io User:The1337gamer 16:31, 15 September 2017 (UTC) delete both. Fails . Unable to find any significant coverage on either topic from a /RS|reliable video game source search Deletion of Wings.io WP:GNG||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17329 6512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aja (pornographic actress) User:Dylanfromthenorth 14:13, 31 July 2009 (UTC) keep Sails through at the first attempt due to winning AVN Award Deletion of Aja (pornographic actress) WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17330 58 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryn Davies (musician) User:JamesBurns 00:53, 11 December 2008 (UTC) delete notability not established, as per Deletion of Bryn Davies (musician) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17331 14634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ESports in Thailand User:Sergecross73 12:46, 3 November 2016 (UTC) merge verifiable content to eSports. Its for spinouts like this. This sort of thing may be more appropriate when the esports article is so large we start splitting it out according to various countries/regions...but we don't seem to be there yet, and it doesn't seem like Thailand shouldn't particularly be that first step yet Deletion of ESports in Thailand WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
17332 1577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Summer 2019 (Kylie Minogue) User:Mgbo120 19:12, 16 January 2019 (UTC) delete A case of , yet rich info Deletion of Summer 2019 (Kylie Minogue) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
17333 3241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Owen Webb User:power 02:53, 20 June 2018 (UTC) delete and procedurally blocking a speedy-keep withdrawal) Simply being a chair of a university department is not an automatic pass of . I don't see sufficient coverage to meet GNG, and the existing article doesn't demonstrate to me that NPROF is met; I also don't see enough in a Google Scholar search Deletion of Mark Owen Webb WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17334 10339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maksim Maksimov User:GiantSnowman 06:59, 7 July 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Maksim Maksimov WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17335 17459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minnesota State Highway 127 User:Alansohn 23:51, 10 February 2007 (UTC) keep """notability of secondary highways is clear, in a well-sourced and referenced article. This is yet another case where #DIR is being abused to mean """"anything that I think doesn't deserve an article for which I cannot or will not provide an actual reason""" Deletion of Minnesota State Highway 127 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17336 11689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stacey Scowley User:DarjeelingTea 18:16, 28 December 2016 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Stacey Scowley WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17337 10899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Engenius Europe User:Dlohcierekim 10:22, 10 December 2013 (UTC) delete I thought it looked like a case of #G11, but long as we're here Deletion of Engenius Europe WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17338 18133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FxMarketSpace User:DarkAudit 14:22, 31 March 2008 (UTC) delete """claim of being """"first"""" probably precludes a speedy, but there's no indication of notability to satisfy """ Deletion of FxMarketSpace WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17339 7175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gee-O-Jatta User:Ventric 20:02, 16 December 2017 (UTC) delete Does not meet , or , as noted, per nom Deletion of Gee-O-Jatta WP:GNG||WP:FILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
17340 13722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prince Chunk User:AmeIiorate 09:38, 8 August 2008 (UTC) keep """This cat greatly exceeds the |General notability guidelines with worldwide, reliable and third-party media reports (ie. not just in the US, but New Zealand and Australia as well). The fallacy that seems to be being repeated here is that this cat is only notable for the news coverage; this cat is notable because it is the second largest known cat, the heaviest known cat alive, the extensive media coverage ''and'' because of its """"TV stardom"""". Notability is not temporary and if this cat is notable enough for inclusion in multiple national newspaper and television news reports, for being a large cat, there is no reason why it is not notable enough for inclusion into Wikipedia. We may not be news, but when news reports reveal a notable subject, we should revel in the reliable sources that offers, not dismiss the subject by citing acronyms. '''~ AmeIiorate""" Deletion of Prince Chunk WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17341 12721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Sublimed User:Colapeninsula 13:11, 31 August 2012 (UTC) merge with The Culture. Banks's novels are among the most important of recent science fiction novels, and are discussed in academic contexts, but this article is purely concerned with recounting material in the novels, rather than providing the sort of deeper analysis you would expect from academic study. Wikipedia is supposed to summarise critical analyses and interpretations of literary works, and information on their creation and reception, not just recount their plots (). Therefore treating his whole universe in a single article is probably better unless significant 3rd-party sources analysing this topic can be found Deletion of The Sublimed WP:NOTPLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17342 14802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people working outside the arts who are also musicians User:Whose 21:11, 16 August 2010 (UTC) delete In my view, this would fall under also, and possibly Deletion of List of people working outside the arts who are also musicians WP:TRIVIA||WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
17343 318 [[Oliver Heinze]] (gelöscht) Benutzerin:CaroFraTyskland NONE delete Ohne Belege ist hier keine enzyklopädische Relevanz im Sinne unserer |Relevanzkriterien dargestellt. Auch wenn der Artikelinhalt belegt wäre, wäre das wohl kaum ausreichend Löschung von Oliver Heinze Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
17344 5250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grassman User:FOARP 20:15, 19 December 2018 (UTC) keep per . See references here: https://books.google.pl/books?id=XAgmDwAAQBAJ&pg=PA116&dq=ohio+grassman&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi4rdjY2azfAhVmsosKHT5lB1MQ6AEINTAC#v=onepage&q=ohio%20grassman&f=false 1 https://books.google.pl/books?id=awRgLQi_R5sC&pg=PA127&dq=ohio+grassman&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi4rdjY2azfAhVmsosKHT5lB1MQ6AEIVjAI#v=onepage&q=ohio%20grassman&f=false 2 Deletion of Grassman WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17345 14500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parent rogic theorem User:Squeamish 21:52, 15 May 2018 (UTC) delete Hoax created by ontent fork|forking our article on Holevo's theorem, filing off the serial numbers, and attaching spurious new names. Needless to say, the third listed source does not exist in any form Deletion of Parent rogic theorem WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
17346 2736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bhoot Police User:Serial 17:46, 13 April 2019 (UTC) delete per nom and . Etc Deletion of Bhoot Police WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
17347 4825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James William Middleton User:Patitomr 20:07, 4 May 2011 (UTC) merge to Middleton family as proposed above (is that really the best title though?). This is textbook |inheritance and |cruft. My bet is that in one year there will be as little if not less to write about him (and reasons to do so), and I would personally choose to get his and other relatives' data into a section at Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge, but I don't think an article on her family is inappropriate, and it is a fair compromise between the participants of this AfD Deletion of James William Middleton WP:INHERIT||WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17348 20868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Proctor User:Spongefrog 10:34, 30 December 2009 (UTC) keep The subject has quite a few claims to notability, and it's pretty well referenced. I can't find any reason to delete. It's a slightly promotional article, but that can be fixed. I'm slightly concerned about the...uh...majority(?) of the references, but I don't think it's ''too'' major an issue, not quite enough to delete. He may not be a public figure any more, but |notability is not temporary Deletion of Aaron Proctor WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17349 17838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heisenberg's Scientific Method (2nd nomination) User:Tikiwont 20:15, 7 June 2008 (UTC) delete as |personal synthesis. I unblocked the creator and tried to point out the synthetic character or guide him to other articles such as the Copenhagen interpretation that has a section on criticisms, Bohr-Einstein debates and Interpretation of quantum mechanics. While there is literature about Heisenbergs approach to physics, this is neither a common term a nor it right approach for an encyclopedia article and all material still exists in user space, if something fits in anywhere else Deletion of Heisenberg's Scientific Method (2nd nomination) WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
17350 3452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Multigarchy User:Clarityfiend 05:46, 21 April 2013 (UTC) delete per nom as an unnoticed, unsuccessful Deletion of Multigarchy WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17351 14789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaul Nurm User:Bearian 00:51, 7 November 2019 (UTC) delete fringe party candidate who once got a bit over 1,300 votes. |Really Deletion of Kaul Nurm WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
17352 239 [[Peters Operncafé Hartauer]] (LAZ) Benutzer:Serialismen 17:00, 17. Okt. 2011 (CEST) delete Auch wenn mich manche dafür hassen werden (vielleicht ist es Brodkeys Lieblingslokal), aber Operncafés hier einzutragen, halte ich für wenig sinnvoll. Hartauer ist weder besonders alt (Tradition als Cafehaus oder historische Immobilie), noch anderweitig relevanzstiftend. (vgl. #Bauwerke, Denkmäler und Naturdenkmäler) Bitte , sonst sieht das nach Werbung für einen kommerziellen Anbieter aus Löschung von Peters Operncafé Hartauer Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
17353 20879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wu Han (volleyball) User:Undead 03:28, 23 August 2015 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet requirements for . Not enough coverage to be notable on the player level Deletion of Wu Han (volleyball) WP:NHSPHSATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
17354 21187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ireland – Saudi Arabia relations User:Jayron32 04:04, 4 June 2009 (UTC) delete without commenting on the entire class of articles, THIS specific relationship does not appear to meet the specifications set out at for inclusion into Wikipedia Deletion of Ireland – Saudi Arabia relations WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17355 1459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mind Mastery NONE NONE delete Seems to be |original research taken directly from a blog http://thavamalargovindasamy.blogspot.com Deletion of Mind Mastery WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
17356 10992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Leonie Wasson User:ryanpostlethwaite 12:52, 5 March 2007 (UTC) delete No sources in a http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&q=%22Leonie+Wasson%22&meta= google search to show it meets Deletion of Dr. Leonie Wasson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17357 11099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jashodaben Modi (3rd nomination) User:Furius 01:16, 17 May 2021 (UTC) keep Absurd to claim that this doesn't meet Deletion of Jashodaben Modi (3rd nomination) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17358 10661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Barty User:GiantSnowman 08:03, 17 September 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Chris Barty WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17359 19276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I15 User:Orangemike 20:46, 17 June 2008 (UTC) delete """fails to meet . Yet another of those annoying """"They're gonna be famous someday, and then you'll be sorry"""" """"up-and-coming"""" """"next big thing"""" """"world-famous all over Napierville"""" non-notable music articles""" Deletion of I15 :WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17360 3072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colin Basran User:Bearcat 18:15, 11 October 2019 (UTC) keep """I'll grant that this is one of the last articles about a mayor that I created ''before'' our notability standard for mayors was tightened up from """"a certain arbitrary population figure confers automatic inclusion rights, so all you have to do is show verification that they've been elected as a mayor"""" to """"you need to write a substantive and well-sourced article that actually delves into detail about his political impact"""" — so it certainly does need significant improvement, and is not an accurate reflection of the amount of effort I would have put into the article if I were creating it today (Doug Craig (politician) is a more representative sample of that). But notability is ultimately based much more on the |existence of suitable sources, not on the current quality of the article, and Basran most certainly does have the kind of sourcing needed to improve the article with. Nominator is incorrect that statewide/provincewide office is always a base requirement for passing — while that is the lowest level of political office at which we ''automatically'' accept ''all'' MLAs as being permanently notable without having to achieve anything more than serving in the legislature, mayors of significant cities most certainly are also considered notable if we have the sources with which to write a substantive article. Nominator is also incorrect that mayoral notability always requires book-length works about his life — book-length biographies certainly count as ''bolsterers'' of notability if they do exist, but the existence of book-length biographies is not a mandatory condition that a mayor always has to have before he can ever be deemed notable. If there are enough other kinds of sources (like newspaper journalism) to establish a pass of NPOL #2, then NPOL #2 is still passed""" Deletion of Colin Basran WP:NEXIST||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17361 21693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thai Ngo (2nd nomination) User:RightCowLeftCoast 06:10, 16 October 2014 (UTC) delete subject has received |arguably significant coverage in some ethnic media (http://www.hyphenmagazine.com/blog/archive/2011/06/hyphen-film-review-byron-qs-bang-bang here, and http://www.asiansonfilm.com/2011/05/musicianrapperactor-thai-ngo-interview-bang-bang/ here) but nothing outside of that that I have been able to find. Therefore, not finding more reliable sources I can't support keeping this article. Furthermore, this article might be subject to speedy delete per Deletion of Thai Ngo (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV||WP:G4 Wikipedia:Notability 77
17362 11824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Duncan's paradox User:MaoGo 13:19, 31 July 2018 (UTC) delete aside from the peak in Quora questions about it I cannot find anything else. It is not as per JzG Deletion of Duncan's paradox WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17363 7193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stiffener User:Satori 20:32, 21 July 2006 (UTC) delete Protologism that fails and . |Wikipedia is not for things made up in school one day Deletion of Stiffener WP:NEO||WP:NOR||WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17364 3939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WikIran (2nd nomination) User:Halo 07:11, 6 January 2007 (UTC) delete Small wikis that don't meet aren't notable. I worry that a simple Google search isn't valid to establish notability due to alledged spam on Wikipedia (according to ). I also think that due to the notablity of the Wikimedia Foundation, any contrast to something like Wikispecies is unfair - I believe a less-notable product by a bigger company is worthy of an article over a small product by a small company (if that makes sense Deletion of WikIran (2nd nomination) WP:WEB||WP:AN Wikipedia:Notability 77
17365 9351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MySammy [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 09:08, 23 July 2013 (UTC) delete hang on, so there are actually two editors with a COI here - the editor above and the other editor who has contributed significantly to the article Wikipedia:COIN#User:Edyang|who declares his COI here? And one of the articles being relied on for the purposes of notability was written by that other editor - the company's PR agent? As for blogs, see and with regard to the interviews, see into which category those clearly fall. The simple fact is that the product doesn't |inherit notability from its creator anyway. Two of the sources are from the same author and are considered one source for the purpose of notability but are those primary source interviews anyway. Another is clearly a press release from the company itself. We need significant coverage in independent reliable sources about the company itself per . I'm not seeing that at this stage Deletion of MySammy WP:BLOGS||WP:PRIMARY||WP:INHERIT||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17366 258 [[Die Ausbilder-Eignung]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers 19:58, 25. Apr. 2012 (CEST) delete """Kasten|1=. Wir haben keine konkreten Relevanzkriterien für Sach- und Lehrbücher. Man kann sich nur grob an den Kriterien für literarische Einzelwerke sowie den allgemeinen Relevanzkriterien orientieren. 17 Auflagen sprechen sicher für eine gewisse Verbreitung, aber es ist im Artikel keine Rezeption dargestellt und ich habe auch im Internet keine solche auffinden können. Zu dem behaupteten """"Standardwerk"""" würde eine solche aber m.E. zwingend gehören. Aus der nicht vorhandenen Außensicht auf das Buch ergibt sich auch, dass der Artikel nichts anderes als eine werbende Verlagssicht dargstellt hat, von der so ohnehin nur eine zusammengestrichen Inhaltsangabe hätte bleiben können. Schließlich sind von beiden Autoren in der dnb keine weiteren Publikationen auffindbar als frühere Auflagen des Buches. Damit wären auch die Autoren nicht relevant gemäß #Autoren, und das ist für die #Bücher bei literarischen Werken eine zwingende Voraussetzung. Gruß""" Löschung von Die Ausbilder-Eignung Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
17367 2669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of legislators who support SOPA or PIPA User:Pharaoh 14:30, 19 January 2012 (UTC) delete As per nom ,LtNOWIS, shadowjams and .Even Former Co-Sponsors have shifted there position a supporter may change his support and opponent may support or abstain.It is current issue positions may change several times before the actual vote.Actual positions will only be known when they vote Deletion of List of legislators who support SOPA or PIPA WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17368 19515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles McAlister User:Guliolopez 20:54, 22 August 2018 (UTC) delete Dispassionately have to agree with nom. In terms of , the subject doesn't seem to meet the expected criteria. The independent coverage that is available (pretty much all of which seems to be included in the article itself) is not significant, and represents (for the most part) passing mentions in witness statements from the Bureau of Military History archives. The subject is not the primary topic in any of these references (or indeed in any other texts that I can find). Hence GNG is not met. In terms of , the subject doesn't seem to have held a particularly high-rank, or have played a significant role in the events described. Or otherwise meet any of the related criteria. (The text of the article itself notes that he didn't actually take part in the Easter Rising, was hospitalised through a significant portion of the War of Independence, and held a somewhat administrative role in the Civil War). In general terms I would note that 50,000 officers and men served alongside him in the Civil War, and 15,000 alongside him in the War of Independence. I see nothing to suggest that he was any more notable than the tens of thousands of others involved. Hence NMILPERSON also isn't met. In terms of , the subject and text seems better suited to a family history archive than to this project. In short: delete. (Or maybe |userfy. So the author can move it to Ancestry.com or similar. Which would seem to be more suited to this type of content Deletion of Charles McAlister WP:GNG||WP:MILPERSON||WP:NOTMEMORIAL||WP:USERFY Wikipedia:Notability 77
17369 14101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abar Basanta Bilap [[User talk:192.160.216.52|talk]]) 16:58, 17 April 2018 (UTC) keep Nom gives no valid reason for deletion. Furthermore, this film clearly satisfies the GNG. See https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/bengali/movies/news/paran-bandyopadhyay-and-kharaj-mukherjee-to-romance-moonmoon-sen-in-abar-basanta-bilap/articleshow/62929292.cms Times of India article already cited, and a bunch more articles from RS, including more from Times of India: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/bengali/movies/news/kharaj-mukherjees-son-bihu-mukherjee-to-debut-in-abar-basanta-bilap/articleshow/63489433.cms, http://www.millenniumpost.in/kolkata/sobhandeb-to-lend-voice-in-abar-basanta-bilap-271710, https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/bengali/movies/news/nana-patekar-to-play-lead-in-hindi-remake-of-bengali-hit-film-bela-seshe/articleshow/62929943.cms, https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/bengali/movies/news/soumitra-chatterjee-and-aparna-sen-to-share-screen-space-once-again-after-18-long-years/articleshow/62848812.cms. Another failure of . Special:Contributions/192.160.216.52|192.160.216.52 Deletion of Abar Basanta Bilap WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
17370 10573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keep Young and Beautiful (song) User:Colonel 15:53, 18 May 2011 (UTC) keep Speedy deletion has been declined. Prod has been overturned. And now The Hunting of the Snark|what I tell you three times is true: the topic is notable, being documented in detail in sources such as ''http://books.google.com/books?id=xRYCrmRngeQC&pg=PA145 Designing women: cinema, art deco, and the female form''. It is our |editing policy to keep such promising material Deletion of Keep Young and Beautiful (song) WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
17371 20508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Davies (footballer, born 1993) User:FreeRangeFrog 23:28, 25 May 2015 (UTC) delete Fails and in my opinion fails GNG as well. Best to just |nuke it given very obvious COI and let some time pass, allow someone unconnected to create the article. It's not like there's a shortage of established editors who create footballer bios anyway Deletion of Tom Davies (footballer, born 1993) WP:NFOOTY||WP:NUKE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17372 19828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Street Fighter in popular culture User:TheDeviantPro 09:36, 10 September 2017 (UTC) delete This article is purely Deletion of Street Fighter in popular culture WP:GAMECRUFT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
17373 13874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sonic Temple art & music festival User:RazorJackal 10:34, 8 July 2020 (EST) comment Per Walter Görlitz, No, Deletion of Sonic Temple art & music festival WP:DNB Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
17374 3822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Next Internet Millionaire (2nd nomination) User:Widefox 23:48, 12 September 2015 (UTC) delete Yes it's borderline N. Patience has run out for this self-promotion. It also isn't a) a film b) television or c) been broadcast. I've removed those three claims. Yes, I agree 100% with DGG. This is part of deciding where our boundaries are. It's basically to see if this was something important in the evolution of video. Looking at the timescale, maybe it wasn't. Else it's NOTNEWS. Reading the sources - Wired wasn't sure to take this seriously. What standard do we want to be? Less than NEWS? Promotion is dilution of our only worth Deletion of The Next Internet Millionaire (2nd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
17375 10824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cougartown User:Savidan 05:12, 24 February 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Cougartown WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
17376 11697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EB animated User:A 04:03, 4 January 2010 (UTC) delete per . Note to closing admin: The creator of this article also created articles for three episodes of this video series, all of which I redirected to the main article. If the consensus here is to delete, please #G8|G8 those while you're at it. Thanks Deletion of EB animated WP:MADEUP||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
17377 15332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zangezur corridor User:MrsSnoozyTurtle 00:50, 5 June 2021 (UTC) delete """The leap from """"transport links... to connect the Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic"""" to claiming notability for the subject """"Zangezur corridor"""" is a case of """ Deletion of Zangezur corridor WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
17378 20458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nahir Besara User:Fenix 10:14, 5 January 2015 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG. Unsure why this has been relisted, the first Keep comment is fundamentally incorrect, only the top level in Sweden is deemed FPL for notability purposes and the second comment claiming the league is notable is irrelevant, nobody is questioning the notability of the league, merely the notability of players who play in it who have neither full international caps or who have played in an FPL either before or after the Superettan Deletion of Nahir Besara WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17379 2573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pierre Picault User:Amalthea 11:50, 17 August 2008 (UTC) delete fails at the moment, per nomination. Even if he is officially one of the last WWI survivors and gets news coverage he might still fail due to Deletion of Pierre Picault WP:BIO||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17380 12671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joccin On Yo Bitch Ass User:Izzy007 00:28, 31 May 2008 (UTC) delete non notable, fails Deletion of Joccin On Yo Bitch Ass WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17381 21643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New School Center for Media User:AngusWOOF 20:22, 30 May 2018 (UTC) delete as a vocational school, I would apply instead of and right now there aren't any sources that would meet that Deletion of New School Center for Media WP:ORGCRIT||WP:NSCHOOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17382 15800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert J. O'Neill (Navy SEAL) User:James 14:36, 7 November 2019 (UTC) keep Killing one of the most wanted terrorists out there definitely will get you known, but this is a debatable subject. Barely clears for me Deletion of Robert J. O'Neill (Navy SEAL) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17383 12313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/4imprint plc User:HighKing 17:12, 9 May 2019 (UTC) keep There are more than two analyst companies providing research on this company (e.g. Edison Investment Research, Peel Hunt, Liberum, finnCap, Berenberg) and therefore meets the criteria for establishing notability. Topic meets and GNG Deletion of 4imprint plc WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17384 9008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryan Pisano (2nd nomination) User:Dhartung 20:20, 5 May 2008 (UTC) comment First of all, this is a discussion meant to achieve , not a vote per se. Second, nobody's opinion should be counted more than the strength of their argument from |policies and guidelines Deletion of Bryan Pisano (2nd nomination) WP:CONSENSUS||WP:PG Wikipedia:Consensus 78
17385 6673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhinelander High School User:Arxiloxos 23:32, 12 May 2012 (UTC) keep Leaving aside the overwhelming precedent that we keep articles about high schools like this one, did the nominator make even |a slight effort to check for sources? http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Rhinelander+High+School%22&hl=en&tbs=ar:1&tbm=nws&ei=FPKuT_HULsSXiQKP7bytBA&start=0&sa=N&biw=1680&bih=892 Deletion of Rhinelander High School WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
17386 15856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TREDIC Corporation User:MoonLichen 15:36, 27 August 2012 (UTC) delete Not notable. Google News gives no results, and Google only returns directories, LinkedIn pages, company websites, and other non-independent/non-|RS sources. Regarding Deletion of TREDIC Corporation WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17387 11793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark A. Moore User:Wiki 16:28, 12 March 2008 (UTC) delete per io Deletion of Mark A. Moore WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
17388 10008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trevor Anning User:Mdcollins1984 00:54, 15 August 2008 (UTC) keep has played in a competition that satisfies thlete, and satisfies the notability requirements (and precedence) set by |WikiProject Cricket. I've tidied it up, and will expand a little more. It is a valid stub however.&ndash Deletion of Trevor Anning WP:A||WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Attribution 108
17389 6976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Code of the Samurai User:Videogameplayer99 21:02, 1 April 2018 (UTC) delete per nom, seems to fail Deletion of Code of the Samurai WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17390 2214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of haunted locations User:The 00:50, 28 January 2007 (UTC) keep Essentially all this is is a dismabiguation page that links to existing articles that claim paranormal activity occurs at a certain place. is actually followed in the individual articles, as they themselves provide the links to reputable sources to back up the claims. As for the article itself failing , that's a bogus claim. Look at the bottom. References. A lot of the article IS supported by links to existing articles on the internet. That's satisfied too. Just because you haven't heard of something in the article isn't legitimate reason to delete the entire thing Deletion of List of haunted locations WP:V||WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17391 18027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guilherme Schröter User:Sting 07:42, 1 February 2008 (UTC) delete as nn. Article as is fails . Major contributor of this may have COI issues? Claims of notability via family associations doesn't work. Looks like trying to make a Linkfarm with all those family member red links Deletion of Guilherme Schröter WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17392 10722 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Em Lodge User:scope_creep 15:39, 6 December 2019 (UTC) delete No effective references. Fails Deletion of Em Lodge WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17393 21125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saveng Samnang User:GiantSnowman 13:18, 25 March 2019 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Saveng Samnang WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17394 10443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Michael Woods, Jr. User:Ravenswing 18:12, 7 September 2011 (UTC) keep """A common fallacy is that the various notability criteria for people somehow supercede the GNG. '''This curious notion is not supported by any policy or criterion.''' The GNG, in fact, supercedes the """"Additional Criteria"""" - WP:PERP included - and meeting the GNG's provisions is sufficient to sustain notability. I could see a issue were these articles clustered around a narrow date range, but in fact they stretch over the better part of a decade""" Deletion of Steven Michael Woods, Jr. WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17395 106 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Alper Tan Kullanıcı:dr. coaldr. coal 10:20, 5 Mayıs 2016 (UTC) comment Arama motorlarına yazdığımızda bile hakkında binlerce sayfa bilginin bulunduğu kişinin Wikipedia'da olmaması eksiklik değil mi? Sayfanın burada kalacağını umut ediyorum {{imzasız|Reggi12}} ( gereği yorum olarak değiştirildi Alper Tan'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:OY Wikipedia:Administrators 89
17396 18390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mac Yasuda User:Aguyintobooks 14:15, 7 September 2017 (UTC) delete Cant find any indication of subject meeting Deletion of Mac Yasuda WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17397 13043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Left-wing insurgency in Greece User:Icewhiz 07:07, 2 September 2018 (UTC) comment I'm of two minds here. On the one hand, there is an on-going string of connected radical left-wing acts of violence in Greece (ranging from very violent and widespread street rioting, to the occasional attack) - sourcing for these incidents and their relatedness is available. On the other hand, I'm not sure insurgency is the correct term (though I'm not sure what is - so that's really a move discussion issue) and the present article really just describes the 2008 Greek riots (notable riots, followed by other notable riots throughout the Greek debt crisis) - so I can see the case for . The topic itself could be developed into a proper article Deletion of Left-wing insurgency in Greece WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
17398 5141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jerome C. Glenn User:David 23:01, 3 May 2014 (UTC) delete The ''State of the Future'' reports have reasonably high citation counts on Google scholar, but I think any notability there goes to the Millenium Project rather than him personally. And there seems to be nothing else of note; in particular I don't see the evidence for nor Deletion of Jerome C. Glenn WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17399 3515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yves Chaudron [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 06:25, 6 June 2013 (UTC) keep per . I've just added a bunch of sources and information. The guy has been the subject of a large number of books and news articles and probably passes points 1 and 3, simply of the basis of his significant works of art - 6 carbon copies of the Mona Lisa impressive enough to fool a bunch of people and sell for $300k a piece (in 1911; millions in today's money Deletion of Yves Chaudron WP:BEFORE||WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
17400 3047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Circle justice User:Nosebagbear 19:47, 24 July 2018 (UTC) merge seems like a good faith . Give that the content has already been moved over I'd be happy for this to be a redirect rather a merge Deletion of Circle justice WP:REDUNDANTFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
17401 16108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alvin Smith (American football) User:SportingFlyer 03:37, 7 January 2020 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Alvin Smith (American football) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17402 10246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faanya Rose User:RickinBaltimore 13:06, 1 June 2016 (UTC) keep Reading through the article and sources provided in the article it would appear that the subject does pass Deletion of Faanya Rose WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17403 11826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kixeye User:Ihcoyc 14:57, 8 August 2011 (UTC) delete Business page press releases announcing that financing has been sought and granted are |routine coverage that does not constitute significant coverage to support a claim of notability Deletion of Kixeye WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17404 7977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Moran User:BrownHairedGirl 03:31, 4 March 2009 (UTC) delete """Barry Johnson (hurler), Aidan Ryan (hurler), Darren Crowley, Ger O'Driscoll, Cian McCarthy, Chris Murphy (hurler), Alan Kennedy (hurler) and Craig Leahy. These articles are wholly unreferenced, so their claims to notability are not supported by any reference, and wikipedia has no business publishing wholly unreferenced biographies of living people (see ). No prejudice to recreating these articles at a future date if they are referenced to establish notability. As Jimmy Wales wrote, """"''There seems to be a terrible bias among some editors that some sort of random speculative 'I heard it somewhere' pseudo information is to be tagged with a 'needs a cite' tag. Wrong. It should be removed, aggressively, unless it can be sourced.''"""""""" It's time to stop pussyfooting around this one and simply delete BLP articles which mock wikipedia's core policies by failing to even provide a reference for the subject's existence, let alone evidence to support the assertion of notability""" Deletion of Joe Moran WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17405 243 [[Freitonale Musik]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Hendrike 15:20, 22. Jun. 2007 (CEST) delete """vom Umfang her keine wirkliche Relevanz, eher ein """"freier Etablierungsversuch"""" eines Begriffs. Kann u.a. auch in Atonalität integriert werden. Siehe bitte auch ƒƒ zum Thema Begriffsfindung""" Löschung von Freitonale Musik Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
17406 4973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wut U Talkin Bout User:Esradekan 04:53, 23 October 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Albums.2C_singles_and_songs|#Songs Deletion of Wut U Talkin Bout WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17407 19881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rachel Corrie [[User talk:24.61.10.180|talk]]) 03:08, 8 May 2009 (UTC) delete I am the nominating IP. I nominated this page as it is utterly clear Ms Corrie only has a page on this wikipedia for one reason- her death. The circumstances and issues of her death generated a considerable amount of news. This I agree. However her life was entirely lacking in any notability. Thus she does not overcome the guideline. There have been many people who have been killed and their deaths generated a tremendous amount of media attention. I remember back to the PhD student at the University of Chicago who was killed on campus. His article on this wikipedia was deleted for the simple reason that his life was not notable. Only his death was. Thus, he did not survive the test. See: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amadou Cisse (student). In addition, Wikipedia is not a memorial, thus Ms Corrie's article must be deleted pursuant to . Thus, Ms Corrie's aricle must be deleted or merged into other articles- such as one about IDF home demolitions as an accidental casuality. Special:Contributions/24.61.10.180|24.61.10.180 Deletion of Rachel Corrie WP:ONEEVENT||WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17408 11421 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cultural references to """"All your base are belong to us""""""" User:Arakunem 17:24, 30 January 2007 (UTC) keep As annoying as the AYB phenomenon is/was, the content listed is verifiable, and follows guidelines for encyclopedic content. Some may question the usefulness of the article, or like me may just not care for the subject, but these are not valid reasons to delete, as per . Some pruning and consolidation could be done to keep the size manageable though """Deletion of List of cultural references to """"All your base are belong to us""""""" WP:AFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
17409 1688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doomcraft User:Celarnor 05:54, 23 May 2008 (UTC) delete Insufficient coverage in reliable sources. Fails both |FICT and |general notability Deletion of Doomcraft WP:FICT||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17410 10948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stan Owens User:PWilkinson 17:08, 30 August 2015 (UTC) comment Commander of the Order of the British Empire (CBE) is the lowest rank of that order where it is generally safe to assume notability. However, the article as it stands is just a CV which leaves the reader guessing why he should have received a CBE and why he might be notable. The most likely item on the list is as the first Executive Chairman of Hill Samuel Australia, which became Macquarie Bank two years after his death. Hill Samuel was one of the world's major investment banks during the 1970s and early 1980s, and I would fully expect that documentation (including but not only news articles) from that time would establish his notability. However, I can not find the documentation online, and an article which is nothing more than a CV is not really encyclopedic. Under the circumstances, unless someone improves the article with additional information from |reliable sources, the best course of action seems to be to '''redirect to Macquarie Group''', where he is already mentioned Deletion of Stan Owens WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17411 10333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Threat Remains User:Esradekan 04:11, 20 March 2009 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability per Deletion of The Threat Remains WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17412 1009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brent Pousson User:CASSIOPEIA 07:53, 29 December 2019 (UTC) delete no notable gridiron footballer - fails notability guidelines Deletion of Brent Pousson WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
17413 19858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Singapore MRT disruptions User:Mangoe 15:16, 25 January 2018 (UTC) delete per , , WP:NOTOBSESSINGOVERMINUTEDETAILS, you name it Deletion of List of Singapore MRT disruptions WP:NOTNEWS||WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17414 16328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aditya elite User:Deepak 06:58, 30 April 2009 (UTC) delete As per |Wikipedia is not Facebook Deletion of Aditya elite WP:NOTMYSPACE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17415 19830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Progressive Liberty Party Australia User:Cabrils 02:13, 10 February 2020 (UTC) delete I could not find a single reference in a ProQuest database search of Aust and NZ newspapers. Fails Deletion of Progressive Liberty Party Australia WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17416 13265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trump resistance User:Trackinfo 17:21, 15 June 2017 (UTC) keep per E.M.Gregory. In its current state it is a lousy article but there is a lot of content that should be developed into this subject. We have a case of poor execution, not an issue with notability or coverage Deletion of Trump resistance WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17417 15289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kristine Balanas User:Expertwikiguy 02:22, 23 March 2021 (UTC) keep meets criteria with the awards Deletion of Kristine Balanas WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17418 10944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Niko De Vera User:Jellyman 13:09, 22 January 2018 (UTC) delete Fails , and despite claims that the subject meets , nobody has added any sources to the article that are not or to demonstrate this is the case. I'm not convinced his success in being drafted is enough to meet either Deletion of Niko De Vera WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE||WP:PRIMARY||WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
17419 10181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saori Hayami User:Quasirandom 14:33, 31 March 2009 (UTC) keep Subject has had a sufficient number of lead roles to pass Deletion of Saori Hayami WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
17420 5281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khalil Duhoki User:Mscuthbert 18:24, 14 December 2015 (UTC) comment note that nominator has few edits besides listing numerous Kurdish academics for deletion; it looks like a or nationalist dispute. See Special:Contributions/Hassan_Rebell Deletion of Khalil Duhoki WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
17421 2150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kapoutland Pro Wrestling User:Kinu 21:08, 31 July 2006 (UTC) delete per all deletes above, looks like a worthy candidate. Can we go one day without a backyard wrestling article Deletion of Kapoutland Pro Wrestling WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
17422 4200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional Romans User:Postdlf 15:53, 11 July 2010 (UTC) keep """at least for now, but discuss serious cleanup and pruning concerns. I don't understand at all the claim that this is an """"unencyclopedic cross-categorization""""; those are just words—naked assertion of opinion—until someone substantively explains why the very concept of the list is somehow invalid. I see nothing in any of the acronyms invoked (, , ) that would compel or counsel the deletion of this list. The topic seems straightforward and simple enough, and there certainly is no shortage of notable examples. So the only real concern I can identify here is a meaningful threshold for what fictional Romans should be included. The list at present includes, for example, unseen """"characters"""" from ''Monty Python's Life of Brian'' who exist only for the purpose of joke names. There's also an issue of how to deal with ''fictionalized'' characters, where perhaps nothing more than a name or basic historical role is kept but the rest is pure invention (cf. Titus Pullo & Lucius Vorenus in the HBO ''Rome'' TV series). Maybe the only practical way to organize this content is indirectly, through Fiction set in the Roman empire, if this list cannot exist without blowing up to every name mentioned in any work of fiction set in Ancient Rome. But I'd like to see that discussion before coming to that conclusion rather than just a diarrhea of acronyms""" Deletion of List of fictional Romans WP:SALAT||WP:NOTDIR||WP:IINFO Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
17423 527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Microsoft Surface User:Michaelzeng7 23:44, 20 June 2012 (UTC) delete and Move Microsoft Surface (tablet) to here. Obviously the . There is even a hatnote at (tablet) for the PixelSense. Completely redundant disambiguation page Deletion of Microsoft Surface WP:PRIMARYTOPIC Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
17424 979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Papal Chase User:Cavarrone 04:37, 6 August 2012 (UTC) keep per , in accordance with my comment above. Schmidt's excellent work http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=The_Papal_Chase&diff=505700246&oldid=505560449 have already improved the article enough to proof it passes #3 (''the film has received a major award for excellence in some aspect of filmmaking''), as this film was awarded as best documentary/best film in three notable film festivals, and this is verifible through reliable sources. Yes, the page still needs additional work, but the notability of the subject appears now proven Deletion of The Papal Chase WP:HEY||WP:NFILMS Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
17425 9246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juan Rhyme Brothers User:Mr 04:51, 1 September 2012 (UTC) delete per failure to meet Deletion of Juan Rhyme Brothers WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17426 7751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kangleipak Historical And Cultural Research Centre User:Yoonadue 13:03, 24 October 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Kangleipak Historical And Cultural Research Centre WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17427 106 [[COVID-19-Pandemie im Landkreis Tirschenreuth]] (LAZ) Benutzer:Triplec85 22:20, 6. Apr. 2020 (CEST) keep """Es ist hier ein besonders betroffenes Gebiet von zeitüberdauernder historischer Bedeutung. Du hast wohl leider die bisherigen Löschdiskussionen in dem Themenbereich nicht verfolgt, es wurde immer auf ''Ereignisse oder Themen mit aktuell breiter Öffentlichkeitswirkung nach sinnvollem Ermessen auch zeitüberdauernd von Bedeutung sein werden"""".'' abgezielt, auch bei kleinsten Territorien. Artikel gibt es in allen Bereichen des föderalen Staats auch auf Kreisebene, selbst bei völlig unbedeutenden Themen. Hier ist es ein Gebiet mit ''vielen Todesfällen'', ''hohen Fallzahlen'' usw., usw., usw. ... Und viele Leser interessieren sich dafür. also klar""" Löschung von COVID-19-Pandemie im Landkreis Tirschenreuth Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
17428 8021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard 'the Lionheart' Morris User:Sjakkalle 06:10, 3 April 2006 (UTC) delete I sat on the student council in 10th grade. I would be a nn-bio candidate. Don't take it too hard, but this does not come near guidelines Deletion of Richard 'the Lionheart' Morris WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17429 19039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric R. Mayes Jr User:Narky 05:20, 7 August 2018 (UTC) delete Two citations. (1) A Better Business Bureau entry. (2) An advertisement for an upcoming Fox 2 (St. Louis) program (that's right, we don't have an article about that channel). Neither citation supports what is said in the bulk of the article; they merely show that he exists and is a photographer. No independent coverage, fails Deletion of Eric R. Mayes Jr WP:RS||WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17430 12711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Kenneth K. Kim User:Nsk92 10:55, 8 July 2010 (UTC) delete """The article appears to make a claim for his notability as a researcher, so this entry is probably best judged by standards. With a common name like that, searching various databases (GoogleScholar and the like) is difficult, but, to the extent I have been able to check, his work has not been significantly cited. His own websitehttp://www.drkennethkim.com/press/press.html does not list any particularly significant academic awards or honors. The most interesting one listed there is being a """"a Rhodes Scholar nominee"""", but being a nominee, whatever that means, does not really cut it. Not much else here to indicate passing either or """ Deletion of Dr. Kenneth K. Kim WP:ACADEMIC||WP:ACADEMIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17431 17451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New London Fire User:Mallanox 03:20, 7 January 2007 (UTC) delete just falls short of requirements. Can't really see why comes into it, you can buy their record on Amazon, it's unverified rather than unverifiable Deletion of New London Fire WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17432 4561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/6th hour heroes User:Lankiveil 05:17, 21 January 2007 (UTC) delete don't see how this passes Deletion of 6th hour heroes WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17433 14028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ananda Marga Elementary Philosophy User:Guy 03:06, 28 January 2013 (UTC) delete Not even close to meeting Deletion of Ananda Marga Elementary Philosophy WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
17434 9439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Itaici User:The 23:05, 12 August 2007 (UTC) delete Certainly fails Deletion of Itaici WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17435 9921 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tucson Pride User:Wildthing61476 17:30, 6 November 2015 (UTC) keep """The event does seem to meet the standards for inclusion, as there have been multiple |reliable sources reporting on the event. Robert, I will advise you that calling people """"homophobes"""" as you did for opposing an article and believing it is worthy of deletion is considered a personal attack. Please be sure you read up on , s this kind of behavior is highly frowned upon here. While you feel very passionate about this article, be sure to keep a level head, and do not immediately throw out accusations of harassment or homophobia""" Deletion of Tucson Pride WP:RS||WP:NPA Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17436 7263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Republic of Pontus User:Takabeg 14:19, 25 September 2012 (UTC) keep Although this article involves inaccurate information, we can find reliable sources even in Turkish language. See: http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Pontus+Cumhuriyeti%22+-Llc&btnG=Search+Books&tbm=bks&tbo=1 (Pontus Cumhuriyeti). I think this case is a kind of . Thank you Deletion of Republic of Pontus WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17437 14642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Misa Kobayashi User:T 18:26, 20 March 2009 (UTC) keep """referenced roles in 14 works notable enough to have Wikipedia articles. So the article must meet the notability guideline for entertainers, which reads """"''Has had significant roles in multiple notable films, television, stage performances, or other productions""" Deletion of Misa Kobayashi WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
17438 17425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laverne & Shirley User:Lord 03:28, 29 September 2005 (UTC) keep and give the anony a smack in the head with a y stick Deletion of Laverne & Shirley WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
17439 4975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Maire User:Jj137 16:54, 23 November 2007 (UTC) delete fails . Deletion of Charles Maire WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17440 10934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanya Granic Allen User:RoyalObserver 17:44, 24 February 2018 (UTC) merge to Progressive Conservative Party of Ontario leadership election, 2018 - does not meet - She is an activist who has never held public office. If she wins the leadership or a seat in the 2018 election, then she can qualify for a page. Until then, she should not have one Deletion of Tanya Granic Allen WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
17441 10118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luka Perić User:IJA 15:07, 22 September 2014 (UTC) delete He hasn't played in a Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|Fully professional league and he doesn't have any international caps either therefore he fails Deletion of Luka Perić WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17442 20597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Merete Lien (2nd nomination) User:The NONE delete subject's notability utterly lacks |verification. The Norwegian-language Wikipedia offers nothing, either Deletion of Merete Lien (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17443 17696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of native x86-64 Windows software User:Rankiri 14:18, 1 March 2010 (UTC) delete WP:NOT#DIR, . The list is too large in scope to be useful, maintainable and suitable for an encyclopedia Deletion of List of native x86-64 Windows software WP:SALAT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
17444 10845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monitory Democracy User:JayJasper 20:54, 2 March 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. & Deletion of Monitory Democracy WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17445 835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Dear Hunter (2nd nomination) User:Hyperbole 00:24, 3 January 2007 (UTC) delete The band contains one barely notable member, who was briefly a part of the barely notable band The Receiving End of Sirens, whose main accomplishment seems to be touring with the Warped Tour in 2005. Does this get The Dear Hunter past ? I don't really think so Deletion of The Dear Hunter (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17446 169 [[Tim Sauerwein]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Matthiasb 16:25, 21. Sep. 2009 (CEST) delete Die Homepage vom Tim Sauerwein wird pro Tag im Durchschnitt etwa 400 Mal aufgerufen (...)'' - also mit der Aufrufzahl ist das Alexa-mäßig http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/timsauerwein.de unter ferner liefen (Rang 9.632.509). Per http://www.alexa.com/siteinfo/chiara-ohoven.de Lex Ohoven (Rang 4.513.484) eindeutig irrelevante Website. Deswegen und per Löschung von Tim Sauerwein Wikipedia:SD Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
17447 5740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Shefman (third nomination) User:Obina 10:48, 25 February 2006 (UTC) delete Non notable. Per and precidents, this is not a notable nor national office. Local officials are not inherently notable, and this person not notable for other reasons. Can anyone guess how many similar people there are in just English speaking countries Deletion of Alan Shefman (third nomination) WP:BIO||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17448 3266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Holy Rosary parish, Warispura (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 18:23, 7 April 2021 (UTC) keep To be honest, I was ready to go along with deletion, but then saw |it's been covered in the media over the years for both religious and secular reasons. It's Deletion of Holy Rosary parish, Warispura (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
17449 15425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Thompson (footballer) User:TheSpecialUser 06:50, 19 June 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Dan Thompson (footballer) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17450 9417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One: The Movie User:2pou 21:27, 14 June 2021 (UTC) keep The RT link in external links was bad, but I have fixed it thanks to the Wayback Machine. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/10006322-one_the_movie/reviews?intcmp=rt-scorecard_tomatometer-reviews The correct RT page lists three reviews that should meet #1. It's not the best article, but enough sources to meet notability requirements. For some reason RT doesn't link the ''Seattle Times'' piece, but if interested, it can be found https://www.seattletimes.com/entertainment/movies/seeking-to-remind-filmgoers-of-our-shared-humanity/ here Deletion of One: The Movie WP:NFO||WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
17451 16809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unreal technology User:Graymornings NONE merge to Unreal engine per .Unsigned comment by Deletion of Unreal technology WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17452 1721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cheryl Rubenberg User:Xxanthippe 09:38, 13 August 2009 (UTC) comment """There appears to be a discrepancy between rof #1 which on these pages in the past has required hundreds of citations, and the interpretation of the editor above who finds that seven reviews satisfy uthor. It seems that it depends on how one interprets """"multiple""" Deletion of Cheryl Rubenberg WP:P||WP:A Wikipedia:Portal 85
17453 9838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sir Leonard Hatred User:Bigdaddy1981 06:15, 20 July 2007 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Sir Leonard Hatred WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17454 2827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mukesh Sharma (businessman) User:Coderzombie 22:04, 15 February 2017 (UTC) delete Clearly fails Deletion of Mukesh Sharma (businessman) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17455 8171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oracle Enterprise Service Bus User:Ihcoyc 21:59, 1 October 2010 (UTC) keep and perhaps revisit this in a year or ten. Searching for sources, I was able to uncover http://books.google.com/books?id=-CU4HMH0Te0C&dq=%22Oracle+Enterprise+Service+Bus%22+-inpublisher:icon&as_brr=0&source=gbs_navlinks_s one book about this product. There does seem to be some confusion about which product of several this actually is. But Oracle's fame does not confer |inherited notability on each of its products. This is deep, deep back office stuff that nobody outside the IT department is going to interact with directly. Products like this are unlikely to get much |disinterested notice from Deletion of Oracle Enterprise Service Bus WP:INHERIT||WP:N Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17456 9106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barry Purchase User:SportingFlyer 16:33, 25 March 2021 (UTC) delete The article definitively fails , and he barely passes the overly permissive cricket SNG Deletion of Barry Purchase WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17457 9636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of LGBT community and student centres in the United Kingdom User:Bearian 18:33, 5 June 2012 (UTC) delete per . It appears that this list is not ready; certainly when sources could be found, then it would be notable. I can't see how any reasonable person would say this list is random Deletion of List of LGBT community and student centres in the United Kingdom WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17458 11772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miloud Ennakhli User:GiantSnowman 18:06, 14 December 2014 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Miloud Ennakhli WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17459 14577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pokémon Moon User:Amorymeltzer 04:28, 7 June 2009 (UTC) delete Fails pretty much every test at and, as stated, vandalism is evidence of vandalism, not notability Deletion of Pokémon Moon WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17460 4716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dubrovnik Annals User:onel5969 13:29, 8 January 2016 (UTC) delete Searches did not turn up enough in-depth coverage from independent reliable sources to show it passes Deletion of Dubrovnik Annals WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17461 19832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mel Krajden User:Xxanthippe 03:05, 15 November 2010 (UTC) comment Incorrect. Notability for BLPs/BDPs of academics/researchers is determined by rof. Closing admin should give careful attention to this matter Deletion of Mel Krajden WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
17462 1540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deep Knowledge Ventures User:Northamerica1000 04:37, 17 January 2016 (UTC) keep Meets : http://www.cnn.com/2014/09/30/business/computers-ceo-boardroom-robot-boss/, http://www.theregister.co.uk/2014/05/18/software_appointed_to_board_of_venture_capital_firm/, http://motherboard.vice.com/read/the-robot-turned-venture-capitalist-exec-isnt-giving-interviews, http://www.businessinsider.com/vital-named-to-board-2014-5, http://observer.com/2014/05/v-c-firm-names-robot-to-board-of-directors/, http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2014/05/15/artificial-intelligence-board-directors_n_5329370.html, http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-27426942 Deletion of Deep Knowledge Ventures WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
17463 20329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khalid Malik User:UserDude 07:00, 11 July 2021 (UTC) keep as per . As explained by Deletion of Khalid Malik WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17464 17307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Popcorn Politics User:Ubiquity 20:01, 11 February 2016 (UTC) delete Since Scrappers Film Group and The A.V. Club are the sponsors, the only references are self-published, leaving an article that does not meet the Deletion of Popcorn Politics WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17465 17542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luke Hannant User:Atlantic306 14:11, 23 January 2018 (UTC) keep now passes Deletion of Luke Hannant WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
17466 7455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Algani User:Otr500 11:19, 10 June 2019 (UTC) delete """Per Nom. As presented there are 4 references from """"The Financial"""", a primary source, and an interview. This gives the appearance of an |promotional article""" Deletion of Algani WP:NOTADVERTISING Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17467 4503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virtual record User:William 22:33, 10 September 2006 (UTC) delete as not meeting Deletion of Virtual record WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17468 12648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sargeras User:Ridernyc 23:06, 1 November 2007 (UTC) delete violates lot and , while the game Warcraft is notable. The fiction and characters within it are not Deletion of Sargeras WP:P||WP:OR Wikipedia:Portal 85
17469 20801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SM Cyberzone User:Ihcoyc 15:41, 22 September 2011 (UTC) delete and '''salt'''. Similar articles have been deleted twice already as #G11|unambiguous advertising Deletion of SM Cyberzone WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17470 13304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sustainable energy vehicle User:BenTels 18:55, 29 July 2012 (UTC) delete seems to fail . Also and . This seems more like a category than an article Deletion of Sustainable energy vehicle WP:GNG||WP:NOTDICT||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17471 129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willie York (2nd nomination) User:Mztourist 04:20, 25 January 2021 (UTC) keep meets notability is based in SIGCOV in multiple RS, unless a specific guideline applies we don't assess the merits of the actions that led to that SIGCOV Deletion of Willie York (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17472 16878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loh Tick Boon User:NawlinWiki 14:31, 3 January 2012 (UTC) delete award doesn't seem significant, not otherwise notable per Deletion of Loh Tick Boon WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17473 6321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Sons of Eilaboun User:Jaakobou 17:08, 13 June 2008 (UTC) delete Seriously fails and the http://www.imdb.com/find?s=all&q=The+Sons+of+Eilaboun&x=17&y=8 lack of an IMDB entry is a clear problem. More reason to delete is that the article was written by the movie's creator with a clear conflict of interest - if proven notable later, it can be re-created Deletion of The Sons of Eilaboun WP:MOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17474 20677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al Lutz User:Toddclark 05:50, 20 October 2006 (UTC) keep as notable . Al Lutz is probably the most noteworthy internet blog writers on the theme park business. His blog is often referenced in Los Angeles Times stories concerning Disney for the past six years. I believe it is important that his entry in Wikipedia remain as it allows readers to understand why he is a credible source Deletion of Al Lutz WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17475 2344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karina Kay User:Tatarian 17:17, 16 October 2008 (UTC) keep Passes Deletion of Karina Kay WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17476 6059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Keever (2nd nomination) User:Bakazaka 00:04, 25 April 2019 (UTC) delete Exactly ten edits, then a promotional article for someone whose article was previously deleted at AfD as the eleventh edit? That's a bingo. Delete under , which is policy Deletion of Jason Keever (2nd nomination) WP:NOTPROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17477 19178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clash of Streamers User:Anarchyte 05:45, 1 February 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Clash of Streamers WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17478 6604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Foxfeather User:Tim 21:52, 8 January 2009 (UTC) delete Clearly fails Deletion of Foxfeather WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17479 10616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 Joué-lès-Tours attack User:EuroCarGT 20:15, 5 April 2015 (UTC) comment I agree with The Almightey Drill with having all 3 events be merged into a centralized article, certainly these events are not important and all fall into Deletion of 2014 Joué-lès-Tours attack WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17480 4389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black coin User:Starblind 22:19, 27 July 2013 (UTC) delete either a hoax or something at the bar one day Deletion of Black coin WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
17481 19576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelly Ritz User:Valfontis 18:56, 4 April 2012 (UTC) delete """Typical businessperson, fails Ms. Ritz or her promoters should wait until she becomes notable enough that a completely independent person writes about her or her business using multiple, substantive, independent, reliable sources. The ''Oregonian'' citation is by a http://www.linkedin.com/pub/phil-favorite/11/182/a89|""""special writer"""" for the paper's special advertising publications. Usually the ''Oregonian'' would be a fine citation, but this citation would only work to establish notability if the article also had a set of multiple independent write-ups about the person. {{ec}} Also ditto what Ted said""" Deletion of Kelly Ritz WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17482 20681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siren Visual User:ConcernedVancouverite 17:33, 20 November 2009 (UTC) comment I agree with Knowledgekid87. Before starting this AfD I attempted to find |reliable sources to establish |notability. I could only find social media mentions, or really passing references in traditional reliable sources - nothing that establishes notability. If such coverage can be found in legitimate reliable sources I'm fine with keeping the article. But as it stands right now it sounds as if this is a non-notable company that is associated with some potentially notable films that may be good subjects for articles on their own. But I just don't see anything currently to justify an article about the company itself. If someone thinks there are such sources, please go ahead and add them to the article. It will make things much clearer then Deletion of Siren Visual WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17483 344 [[Istapp]] (LAE) Benutzer:Siechfred 15:04, 6. Jun. 2016 (CEST) keep Ping|Ulz}} Das ist ein glasklarer Fall von , weil ein kommerzieller Tonträger gemäß #Musiker reicht. Da dieser mit Beleg im Artikel steht, trifft die Antragsbegründung nicht (mehr) zu. Gruß Löschung von Istapp Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
17484 1818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Bowes User:Papaursa 17:54, 6 July 2014 (UTC) delete Autobiography about a boxer who doesn't come close to meeting Deletion of Philip Bowes WP:NBOX Wikipedia:Notability 77
17485 9027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Run in Red (band) User:Sparklism 20:00, 13 June 2018 (UTC) delete I don't think these guys meet the guidelines for inclusion set out at . Sure, the band sound great, have played many shows and have an album about to be released (https://www.eventbrite.ie/e/run-in-red-debut-headline-show-the-sound-house-dublin-tickets-46115577935), but I couldn't find any non-trivial coverage from |reliable sources that shows how the band meets the Wikipedia |general notability guideline. No reviews, no band profiles, nothing. Maybe this is just a simple case of Deletion of Run in Red (band) WP:BAND||WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
17486 20932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mirage (novel) User:Jclemens 04:23, 13 February 2012 (UTC) keep Examining the history of the article shows that the nominator first attempted to redirect the stub to the author, and then nominated it for deletion less then one hour after its creation. The article now has four separate independent, non-trivial RS'es, clearly meeting both GNG and . This is what is specifically designed to prevent, and our overzealous NPP has done a disservice to the stub and the author who created it Deletion of The Mirage (novel) WP:BK||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17487 8402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Convision User:Borkificator 09:59, 7 February 2011 (UTC) delete Unreferenced, non-notable contest. Part of a alled garden with Anton Rothenberg and Larin Alexsandr, the latter of whom appears to the creator of the articles.{{Infobox Eurovision}} from various :Eurovision Song Contest articles have been copied in asserting television broadcasts, but I can find no evidence online in English that the contest even exists. I'll add deletion sorting for Russia: maybe online sources exist in Russian Deletion of Convision WP:W Help:Watchlist 110
17488 11480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aya (kitchens) User:Ihcoyc 15:19, 23 February 2009 (UTC) keep weakly, and '''stub'''. Minor industry awards, listings of new corporations, and the circulation of press releases by wire services aren't enough to confer |notability on a business, in my opinion. Nor do offhand mentions in relation to their charitable sponsorships make much of a case. So the http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=aya+kitchens&hl=en&ned=us&sa=N&start=0 Google news search doesn't provide a whole lot to go on. Still, this is a consumer related firm that may some day generate real independent reviews of its products and work in disinterested third party sources. I'd edit out all of the hornblowing, but keep a stub here Deletion of Aya (kitchens) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17489 16405 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emilio Villegas User:Phil 10:40, 20 June 2021 (UTC) keep per #4 Deletion of Emilio Villegas WP:SK Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
17490 18335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hit FM (Beijing) User:onel5969 14:53, 9 December 2017 (UTC) delete as per nom, while this might be a case of , can't find any sourcing to show it meets notability criteria Deletion of Hit FM (Beijing) WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
17491 11955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russia–Turkey proxy conflict User:TimothyBlue 05:50, 16 November 2020 (UTC) keep and clean up. There are plenty of sources in the article and found in . The article does need a lot of work, but it is a notable subject. // Deletion of Russia–Turkey proxy conflict WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
17492 6022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dinclix GroundWorks User:DMacks 20:23, 5 November 2016 (UTC) delete """As it stands, it's in #A7 grounds...doesn't even make a claim of """"notability"""", neither by nor standards. I'd already speedied it as such, but now it's been recreated by the same editor and I guess here we are. Notability is not sufficiently met by inheritance from its projects or affiliated organizations even if they were notable themselves (and note that even this lesser idea does not seem to be met""" Deletion of Dinclix GroundWorks WP:CSD||WP:CORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17493 12331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nagarro User:Adamant1 21:03, 5 November 2020 (UTC) delete Due to lacking multiple in-depth reliable sources and therefore failing . Along with not meeting Deletion of Nagarro WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17494 8986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joed User:Coredesat 10:09, 25 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Joed WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17495 487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin M. Connolly User:Malevious 19:17, 29 April 2007 (UTC) keep He's had many credits including that of a main character. That should be enough to satisfy . Just because you don't think doing dubbing of anime isn't notable doesn't mean it isn't. Please read up on the person before you nominate them for notability. --Malevious Deletion of Kevin M. Connolly WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17496 19568 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/How the American society is reflected at """"the Simpson"""" TV Series""" User:GreatOrangePumpkin 19:03, 2 May 2011 (UTC) delete per """Deletion of How the American society is reflected at """"the Simpson"""" TV Series""" WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17497 14620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Voltas House User:DoubleGrazing 07:11, 10 December 2020 (UTC) delete No indication of notability or importance, fails and . Effectively unreferenced, as the two alleged sources don't mention 'Voltas House' at all, and the rest of the article doesn't even pretend to have sources Deletion of Voltas House WP:GNG||WP:NBUILD Wikipedia:Notability 77
17498 3843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Williams (comedian) User:NZFC 05:20, 3 August 2021 (UTC) keep my feeling is he meets now, with performances at Edinburgh and Melbourne and around New Zealand for comedy. On TV with Taskmasker and put out music. I did find some more sources as well with https://www.pressreader.com/new-zealand/the-southland-times/20210702/281479279396733 Southland Times, https://www.rnz.co.nz/national/programmes/afternoons/audio/2018800016/bookmarks-with-paul-williams Radio NZ, https://thespinoff.co.nz/partner/barkers-1972/11-05-2019/my-obsession-guy-and-paul-williams-on-their-love-of-basketball/ The Spinoff, https://www.nzonscreen.com/interviews/funny-as/paul-williams NZ OnScreen, https://www.stuff.co.nz/entertainment/stage-and-theatre/85310163/finalists-for-the-2017-billy-t-award-have-been-announced two Stuff https://www.stuff.co.nz/nelson-mail/news/85468547/nelson-comedian-paul-williams-up-for-billy-t-award articles and https://www.nzherald.co.nz/entertainment/spy-meet-newsboys-new-newsboy-on-new-show-taskmaster/A7KREFI6Y6G3ESLVA5GH7IT364/ The New Zealand Herald. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Paul Williams (comedian) WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17499 18147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hawaii Free Press User:Yoninah 19:50, 29 June 2009 (UTC) delete The paper itself fails , but to use this information for an article about the publisher also fails . I suggest moving the paragraph about the editorial attack on Obama to Barack Obama presidential primary campaign, 2008#Controversies, allegations, and scandals during the primary campaign, and the paragraph about Walden's book to Ron Paul presidential campaign, 2008#Campaign developments, and delete the rest Deletion of Hawaii Free Press WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17500 20546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mission Viejo High School User:KillerChihuahua 21:21, 5 December 2006 (UTC) merge any ''significant'' information to Mission Viejo, California per ). Otherwise, '''delete'''. Argument per ptk, puff piece != notable. Blue Ribbon Schools Program and California Distinguished School notwithstanding - these are hardly highly notable achievements Deletion of Mission Viejo High School WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
17501 12146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Breathless Mahoney User:Hunter 23:57, 28 February 2020 (UTC) comment I felt some of the sources that have been cited in this AFD discuss the character in greater depth than some of the votes indicate. So to try to illustrate this, I https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Breathless_Mahoney&diff=943121837&oldid=943106777 expanded the article slightly, particularly trying to show that there is more to say about this character than simply plot summary, but there is also some historical context and thematic analysis to be had here. Please note this is NOT meant to be the full extent to which this article can be improved, but only a bit of expansion from the handful of sources found so far. I am confident there are other sources that could be found with further searching, but I don't have time to go full and expand this one anymore right now because I have other wiki-priorities I need to focus on. Still though, I think the expansion that has occurred so far more than shows the article meets notability requirements and should be kept. (Note: {{U|Toughpigs}}, my edits may have conflicted a bit with your own, so if so, I apologize, and feel free to add back anything Deletion of Breathless Mahoney WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
17502 1628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herbert midgley User:MastCell 20:42, 27 June 2007 (UTC) delete Fails - no reliable secondary sources establishing notability Deletion of Herbert midgley WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17503 2926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled eighth-generation Codemasters Formula One project [[User talk:69.166.78.85|talk]]) 17:31, 1 October 2014 (UTC) delete as per Special:Contributions/69.166.78.85|69.166.78.85 Deletion of Untitled eighth-generation Codemasters Formula One project WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
17504 6796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ossai Ovie Success (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 18:27, 25 November 2017 (UTC) delete Being a personal aide on a politician's staff is not an automatic Wikipedia inclusion criterion, but the referencing here isn't even close to good enough to get him over for it. Also, I suspect |conflict of interest editing, as the creator is an whose edit history consists ''exclusively'' of repeated attempts to make this article happen — in addition to the first AFD discussion, it's also been speedied twice at this title ''and'' twice more at the improperly-capitalized variant title Ossai ovie success, ''and'' attempted at least once in draftspace too, so a dose of may be needed as well. And on top of ''that'', the creator's response to the AFD nomination this time was to try to push the article into ''talkspace'', where it doesn't belong. We're an encyclopedia on which articles are ''earned'' by having |reliable source coverage for the passage of a |notability criterion, not a free alternative to LinkedIn on which people are ''entitled'' to have articles just because they ''exist Deletion of Ossai Ovie Success (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:COI||WP:SPA||WP:SALT||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17505 5374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Purple diet User:MastCell 22:36, 7 July 2007 (UTC) comment Is it a |notable aspect of Mariah Carey's biography, though Deletion of Purple diet WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17506 7487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Schwartz (2nd nomination) User:In 07:42, 21 February 2013 (UTC) keep would not even have been questioned without nonsense above. Deletion of Aaron Schwartz (2nd nomination) WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Whacking with a wet trout 74
17507 11752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Israel Vargas User:GiantSnowman 11:37, 22 December 2020 (UTC) keep easily meets NFOOTBALL, and there are sources out there - nearly 40,000 in Google News for 'Israel Vargas futbol'. Has nominator complied with Deletion of Israel Vargas WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
17508 11920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ovilus User:Bobrayner 20:14, 25 February 2014 (UTC) delete the weak notability and fringey sources make it impossible to write a |neutral article Deletion of Ovilus WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
17509 15978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bibliography of Catwoman (2nd nomination) User:Dhartung 22:42, 2 May 2008 (UTC) delete per TenPoundHammer. These are simply #DIR|directories Deletion of Bibliography of Catwoman (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17510 18703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Zatch Bell! Spells User:A 04:35, 7 November 2005 (UTC) delete as an image gallery with the images, and as exceedingly overspecific fancruft without the images Deletion of List of Zatch Bell! Spells WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17511 3756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diane Fleming User:Tgeairn 19:14, 3 February 2012 (UTC) delete WP:PERP makes this one clear. The victim was not and the motivation is not spelled out in the article at all (and therefore not a |well-documented historic event Deletion of Diane Fleming WP:WELLKNOWN||WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17512 1565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dinesh Nair User:Radagast3 09:30, 1 August 2010 (UTC) delete Fails , , Deletion of Dinesh Nair WP:PROF||WP:N||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17513 17490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/No Shows [[User talk:Jim Carter - Public|Jim Carter (''from public cyber'')]]''' 09:58, 11 September 2014 (UTC) keep multiple third party reliable sources were posted by Jinkinson. Passes Deletion of No Shows WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
17514 5631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of islands of Syria User:SportingFlyer 10:47, 4 November 2018 (UTC) keep Valid albeit short article Deletion of List of islands of Syria WP:NLIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
17515 18486 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""Carl Dundas""""""" User:Doc 17:46, 6 September 2008 (UTC) delete WP:COI|auto|biography |of a non-notable |person """Deletion of """"Carl Dundas""""""" WP:AB||WP:NN||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
17516 187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shane Balkowitsch User:Finngall 17:08, 9 June 2016 (UTC) keep Coverage is mostly local but I think it's just enough to pass Deletion of Shane Balkowitsch WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17517 15797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star wars empire at war tips User:Masaruemoto 02:15, 1 May 2007 (UTC) delete WP:SNOW - Wikipedia is #IINFO|not a game guide Deletion of Star wars empire at war tips WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17518 33 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Çiyni Kullanıcı:seksen iki yüz kırk beşseksen iki yüz kırk beş / ggt 09.24, 25 Nisan 2021 (UTC) keep Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Pelitözü, Bilecik sayfasında belirttiğim üzere #Kayda_değerlik_genellikle_kalıcıdır|kayda değerlik kalıcıdır. Köylerin otomatik olarak KD olduğunu varsayıyoruz, dolayısıyla köy niteliğindeki bir yerleşim yerinin sırf statüsü değişti diye kayda değerliğinin ortadan kalkması söz konusu olamaz Çiyni'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
17519 14740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sang Kyu Moon User:A 17:40, 24 January 2010 (UTC) delete per , , , and . This is very clearly a hoax article; the creator of the article ought to be sternly warned Deletion of Sang Kyu Moon WP:V||WP:A||WP:NOHOAXES||WP:BLPDEL Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17520 12955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy Dannatt User:Mattinbgn 21:06, 22 May 2007 (UTC) keep Easily meets for athletes, having both played in a fully professional league and achieved representative honours at the highest level Deletion of Andy Dannatt WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17521 16105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teen Kelly User:Cynical 19:56, 23 December 2005 (UTC) delete as spam, NOT due to POV notability standard (see for good reasons to ignore notability standards Deletion of Teen Kelly WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
17522 1597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stripe (company) User:Amitbanerji26 15:26, 8 February 2016 (UTC) keep One of the bigger Paypal competitor and meets . I will suggest rewrite than considering for delete. http://www.forbes.com/sites/miguelhelft/2016/01/04/cashiers-of-the-internet/#24abe55a6afc Forbes, http://www.wsj.com/articles/online-payments-startup-stripe-raises-new-funds-at-5-billion-valuation-1438060715 Wall Street Journal and many more. I request to research in detail, before AFD Deletion of Stripe (company) WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
17523 16039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oksana Kalashnikova User:Jared 07:46, 26 October 2015 (UTC) keep Kalashnikova meets the criteria set out by . She has played in the main draw at multiple Grand Slams and has represented her country in over 20 rubbers for the Georgia Fed Cup team (http://www.fedcup.com/en/players/player/profile.aspx?playerid=100063577 see profile Deletion of Oksana Kalashnikova WP:NTENNIS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17524 4576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Anal Cunt band members User:Cannibaloki 02:29, 26 June 2009 (UTC) merge to Anal Cunt per Deletion of List of Anal Cunt band members WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
17525 10754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tammo Tachtig User:Blair 00:27, 15 September 2007 (UTC) comment From what I can read, the Flying Spaghetti Monster is a lot more widespread and notable than Tammo Tachtig. Besides which, the fact that another article exists is not a sufficient argument for keeping this article - see Deletion of Tammo Tachtig WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17526 21342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Polish collaboration with Nazi Germany [[User talk:24.151.116.12|talk]]) 16:30, 16 March 2018 (UTC) keep as a proper from a long parent article. Some of this information is also at History of Poland (1939–1945)#Collaboration with the occupiers as noted just above, so a further hatnote should probably be added there and both entries at the general articles may need to be trimmed some per . This is a complex and contentious topic, but treating it in its own article is the best way to provide all the context and viewpoints presented in reliable sources. Special:Contributions/24.151.116.12|24.151.116.12 Deletion of Polish collaboration with Nazi Germany WP:SPINOUT||WP:SUMMARY Wikipedia:Article size 51
17527 10211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dream (YouTuber) (2nd nomination) User:MJL 20:42, 2 January 2021 (UTC) keep """To be honest, I wasn't going to make a comment here one way or the other. However, there are some really poor !votes both for an against keeping this article, and I figured I should probably weigh in with something at least a little substantive. Two hours ago, https://gamerant.com/dream-face-reveal-youtube-dox/ this was published. Some amount of hours before that, HITC wrote https://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2021/01/02/dream-doxxed/ this article. A day before that, we had https://gamerant.com/minecraft-youtuber-dream-video-not-cartoon/ this news story, and a week before that there was https://meaww.com/who-is-minecraft-youtuber-dream-days-after-cheating-scandal-records-for-mr-beast-youtube-rewind this.That's some obvious coverage right there. Mind you; all this guy did was basically go outside and record a video of himself that was less than ten seconds long, but that was enough to get ''four'' different articles written about it.Is there enough content about Dream to make a proper here? No, and I don't think there ever will be. Dream has stated several times that he wants to keep his IRL identity as private for as long as he can, so even ''if'' a posted information about where he grew up, his birthday, what his last name is, etc. It would not be responsible for us to publish it per PRIVACY.Secondaly, there is some arguement that coverage of Minecraft Manhunt or his speedruns should not be counted as coverage ''about Dream''. I am sorry, but I just do not buy into that contention. That is all coverage of Dream's Minecraft/YouTube career, and therefore it can be incredibly helpful in filling out this article. The personal life section will probably only end up covering (1) his first name and possibly his family (ie. """"Drista"""" if that gets mentioned in eventually which it probably will), and (2) the fact Dream keeps most of his personally identifiable information rather private (which has a lot of details to it imo). –""" Deletion of Dream (YouTuber) (2nd nomination) WP:SUSTAINING||WP:BLP||WP:RS||WP:BLPPRIVACY Wikipedia:Notability 77
17528 8615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mort Levine User:RMHED 03:13, 10 December 2007 (UTC) delete falls well short of Deletion of Mort Levine WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17529 10590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Ott User:GiantSnowman 14:12, 18 April 2014 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Mike Ott WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17530 8304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zahkila Magazine User:Whpq 22:54, 7 December 2006 (UTC) delete Incredibly, it really is only 4 Google hits. For a digital magazine, that misses by a long mile Deletion of Zahkila Magazine WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
17531 3449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jayachandran P R User:Bakazaka 01:03, 25 July 2018 (UTC) delete Fails . Named in list of team members finding one new species, and cited coverage is not significant coverage of subject, so no individual notability. Fails with low impact and no qualifying posts or awards Deletion of Jayachandran P R WP:GNG||WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17532 18331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adh Dharbaniyah User:Lugnuts 16:49, 12 September 2018 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Adh Dharbaniyah WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17533 10549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blackguard User:JamesBurns 01:02, 25 February 2009 (UTC) delete insufficient independent 3rd party sources Deletion of Blackguard WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17534 5188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of international cricket centuries by Upul Tharanga User:Ajf773 23:11, 18 November 2018 (UTC) delete per /. Content is easily sourced on ESPNCricinfo. Also the 25 requirement isn't a policy, it's a seemingly invented guideline created by Wikiproject Cricket Deletion of List of international cricket centuries by Upul Tharanga WP:NOTSTATS||WP:NOTMIRROR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17535 8373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Porto Claro User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable micronation, and see previous AFD. &mdash Deletion of Porto Claro WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17536 13229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conquest of Manila (1405) User:Bearian 15:39, 23 August 2019 (UTC) delete this is |totally made up propaganda. It never, ever happened. There was a tiny (starting with less than 100 households) Binondo#History|Chinatown in Manila starting about 1594. That's not an invasion, much less a conquest. I've personally been there with my Filipino partner Deletion of Conquest of Manila (1405) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17537 3858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Privacy in facebook User:Scientizzle 21:08, 7 June 2010 (UTC) delete """given that this appears to be a copy of a written product by multiple individuals (initial edit summary by article creator: """"i and my class mates create this as our academic assignment at Orebro university , Sweden""""), I think is a valid concern. As a group project, it would require '''everyone's''' approval to license this work appropriately, a task I'm not sure is particualrly feasible or worth doing. Thus, deletion seems the most reasonable route. I agree that it's a plausible search term, however, and a redirect to Criticism of Facebook should definitely be left in its place; a future sub-article on this topic isn't unreasonable. As for the sources, I don't see much that seems too obviously useful, but I'd be willing, on request, post-deletion, to move citations & links to Talk:Criticism of Facebook that might be relevant. &mdash""" Deletion of Privacy in facebook WP:COPYRIGHT Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
17538 10222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kimberly Hampton User:Eusebeus 00:20, 19 December 2006 (UTC) delete clearly and should be removed by closing admin by if necessary since it is bad bad precedent! This is not a |memorial and conflating brief press coverage with larger notability is erroneous and wrong-headed Deletion of Kimberly Hampton WP:IAR||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
17539 15611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omglolwtfbbq User:Rossami 20:29, 14 February 2008 (UTC) keep Soft-redirects using the {{tl|wi}} template are a fairly effective deterrent which prevent new users from endlessly recreating these mere dictionary definitions. Our history has taught us that if you delete it, we will be having deletion discussions on the page about monthly. And everytime that you have to delete the page, you inevitably |bite the newbie who created the page in good faith but who didn't know about Deletion of Omglolwtfbbq WP:BITE||WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
17540 13210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Commitment (EP) User:TwinTurbo 16:33, 25 April 2019 (UTC) keep The songs on this album definitely meet 1. 6. 7. of . Another reliable source http://thebeat1036.com/cadet-talks-commitment-dj-dubl-11-01-2017 here by a major radio station which I will add to the page Deletion of The Commitment (EP) WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
17541 2542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Debbie Dorsey User:Location 23:01, 25 August 2009 (UTC) delete Fails . Doesn't really even meet Deletion of Debbie Dorsey WP:GNG||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17542 19616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Americus Abesamis User:Astudent0 20:47, 24 January 2012 (UTC) delete Fails , , , plus the article lacks good sources Deletion of Americus Abesamis WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR||WP:NSPORTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17543 17071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bijpur A B High School User:Topcipher 17:10, 17 April 2017 (UTC) keep rationale being as they reasonably pass |verifiability; obviously, the articles need to be improved extensively to contribute for encyclopedic usage Deletion of Bijpur A B High School WP:NHS||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
17544 18016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Víctimas del Pecado User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:39, 4 February 2013 (UTC) comment Since nomination, the plot section has been improved, a few sources have been added, and the reception section has been tagged for additional cleanup and sourcing. It would be helpful if editors able to read Spanish add sources. Will need input from the Wikipedia:WikiProject Film/Spanish cinema task force|Spanish cinema task force. Per , see http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22V%C3%ADctimas+del+Pecado%22 Google scholar and https://www.google.com/search?tbs=bks:1&q=%22V%C3%ADctimas+del+Pecado%22 Google book results. Simply being |unknown here, does not make a topic somehow unnotable Deletion of Víctimas del Pecado WP:NRVE||WP:UNKNOWNHERE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17545 11239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lilli Xene User:Malik 23:14, 13 March 2008 (UTC) keep per #Pornographic actors. According to her article, Xene has made multiple appearances on talk shows, including ''The Jenny Jones Show Deletion of Lilli Xene WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17546 66 [[Yvo Antoni]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Masturbius NONE comment Obwohl ich mich nur sehr selten in Löschdisks einmische, möchte ich den Löschgegnern doch einen kleinen Tip geben. Zusätzlich zur Relevanzproblematik der beschriebenen Person ist der Text inhaltlich als auch stilistisch grottenschlecht. Was soll die Sache mit Bohlens Hund? Am Schluß wird Yvo Antoni auf einmal als ''Schauspieler'' bezeichnet, Geburtsdaten sind widersprüchlich und über die Bild-Zeitung als Quelle sage ich mal lieber gar nichts. Ich habe vor Tagen sehr wohlwollend versucht, diesen Müll etwas zu entwirren. Ich sehe grenzwertige Relevanz, was aber nur meine persönliche Meinung ist. Wer den Artikel behalten will, sollte hauptsächlich dort verbessern, denn die Person ist möglicherweise irrelevant aber im momentanen Zustand ist der Text definitiv peinlicher Müll. In einem Punkt muss ich aber dem Löschantragsteller widersprechen: Im Gegensatz zu diversen adligen Fatzkes, die die Relevanz offensichtlich ererbt haben und nicht wenigen C- und D-Promis hat der Dresseur sehr wohl etwas ''geleistet''. Ich weiß, dass man |nicht stören soll. Aber wenn ein Ernie Wasson|Gärtner die Relevanzhürde überspringt, kann's vielleicht auch ein Hunde-Dresseur schaffen Löschung von Yvo Antoni Wikipedia:Bitte nicht stören Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
17547 16330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy Beard User:Tulkolahten 08:10, 15 January 2008 (UTC) delete completely fails and Deletion of Andy Beard WP:BIO||WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17548 10968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ridwan Roslan User:One 04:34, 6 February 2007 (UTC) delete Fails most importantly. I'd have expected to find more than http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=%22Ridwan+Roslan%22&hl=en&safe=off&lr=lang_en&sa=X&oi=lrtip&ct=restrict&cad=9 4 Ghits in English for someone on an Australian TV show Deletion of Ridwan Roslan WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17549 16651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wala Mirza User:Smmurphy 19:35, 2 July 2017 (UTC) delete """fails . Jahangir was made governor of Ajmer in about 1595,https://books.google.com/books?id=AlagAAAAMAAJ&dq=""""governor+of+ajmer"""" so it isn't clear who this other son was who held a similar position. Akbar's sons (who survived to adulthood) are well discussed, so sources shouldn't be hard to find""" Deletion of Wala Mirza WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17550 20095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rudy Reyes (activist) User:Bearian 01:58, 10 July 2020 (UTC) delete per and . Until he gets on the ballot somewhere, he's not notable, and as we all have seen from Kanye West, it is already too late to get on the ballot in the vast majority of states. If this was |not a purple haze of a mess, I would advocate for its userfication Deletion of Rudy Reyes (activist) WP:TOOSOON||WP:NPOL||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Too soon 40
17551 918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Love (La Toya Jackson single) User:JamesBurns 08:14, 7 April 2009 (UTC) delete notability yet to be established Deletion of Love (La Toya Jackson single) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17552 18930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earl M. Monson User:The 14:18, 24 November 2018 (UTC) delete per nomination. Subject fails and Deletion of Earl M. Monson WP:BASIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17553 1735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indigo Agriculture User:Originalmess 20:53, 1 August 2018 (UTC) keep sources: CNBC https://www.cnbc.com/video/2018/05/24/indigo-agriculture-ceo-seeks-revolution-in-agriculture.html interview with CEO, http://www.bostonherald.com/business/business_markets/2018/06/charlestown_lab_mining_microbes_to_help_feed_the_world (local news?) Boston Herald article, https://www.bizjournals.com/memphis/news/2017/12/06/agtech-firm-with-memphis-office-closes-203m.html local news (possible press release but I'm not sure), https://www.bostonglobe.com/business/2017/09/26/indigo-agriculture-boston-newest-unicorn-startup/AhrZBNePKsEJkmPd47exlN/story.html Boston Globe article, http://www.wbur.org/bostonomix/2017/08/16/indigo-agriculture-drought-resistant-seeds local radio article, Digital Trends https://www.digitaltrends.com/cool-tech/plant-probiotics-could-accelerate-agriculture/ article, Forbes https://www.forbes.com/sites/maggiemcgrath/2018/06/27/the-25-most-innovative-agtech-startups-in-2018/#1c8062f42302 25 most innovative agtech startups, more http://charlestownbridge.com/2018/06/12/indigo-ag-in-hood-park-gets-major-state-job-creation-grant/ local news, 2016 Forbes http://fortune.com/2016/07/21/indigo-raised-100-million-funding-round/ article. (Only 1 or 2 of the sources I've listed are used in the article). None of these were marked as press releases by Google news/don't seem to be from blog contributors, but it seems to pass Deletion of Indigo Agriculture WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17554 9150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phantom Mobile Device Vibration Syndrome User:TheronJ 13:53, 27 October 2006 (UTC) delete I don't agree that it's or a hoax. The two links show that it's a real neologism, but I don't think it meets Wikipedia's |guidelines for neologisms because there are no reliable sources establishing the origin of the term or its notability. Also, this subject has been repeatedly deleted under the title Talk: Phantom mobile device vibration|Phantom mobile device vibration Deletion of Phantom Mobile Device Vibration Syndrome WP:OR||WP:NEO Wikipedia:No original research 65
17555 4089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Louisiana Baptist University people (second nomination) User:Sycthos 03:15, 18 January 2006 (UTC) merge """into Louisiana Baptist University. This article is vanity on its own, but the main article has an incomplete section on alumini. However, many sections, such as """"General alumni,"""" will be removed, as Wikipedia is a directory (""""indiscriminate collection of information""" Deletion of List of Louisiana Baptist University people (second nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17556 11812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jash NONE NONE merge Merge the two examples to articles on Kurds or, as mentioned above, Kurdish history. The |dictionary definition can then be deleted Deletion of Jash WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17557 19204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dougie Grant user:dugggy 12:16, 2 April 2009 (UTC) delete for failing to |assert |notability. As this is the sole article work of Deletion of Dougie Grant WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17558 10743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gender-neutral Bible User:Bearian 01:25, 24 July 2015 (UTC) merge per Deletion of Gender-neutral Bible WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
17559 17775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hatashe Channel [[User talk:72.75.78.75|talk]])}}''' 15:51, 5 August 2008 (UTC) delete lacks any to its ... Happy Editing! — '''{{#if:72.75.78.75|{{User|72.75.78.75}}|Special:Contributions/72.75.78.75|72.75.78.75 Deletion of Hatashe Channel WP:RS||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17560 16582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baggage Airline Guest Services User:Vegaswikian 09:08, 1 January 2007 (UTC) delete or '''Rewrite and Merge''' into a generic article. Existence of links is in and of itself not a reason to keep. Company fails Deletion of Baggage Airline Guest Services WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17561 1646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Sawchuk User:Kraxler 15:12, 13 April 2015 (UTC) keep """She seems to be notable, among other things, under # 8 """"''The person is or has been the head or chief editor of a major well-established academic journal in their subject area.''"""" In http://coms.concordia.ca/faculty/sawchuk.html this source she is presented as """"the editor"""" of the ''Canadian Journal of Communications''. """"The editor"""" would mean there is only one editor, and that is the """"head"""" of the journal as required under this criterion. The journal is described as a """"''nationally and internationally renowned journal in the field publishing work in communications, media studies, cultural studies and journalism""" Deletion of Kim Sawchuk WP:NACADEMICS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17562 5326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sex, Drugs & Superheroes User:Ohnoitsjamie 20:17, 16 July 2014 (UTC) delete No in-depth coverage in third-party sources Deletion of Sex, Drugs & Superheroes WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17563 16949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pârâul Varului User:Epinoia 20:51, 14 September 2019 (UTC) delete WP:GEOLAND says a stream '''may''' be notable provided there is enough information beyond statistics and coordinates - the article does not even provide the basic statistics and coordinates, nothing to show that the stream itself is notable - it's a run of the mill stream - we need something to show that the stream is unique to distinguish it from millions of other streams - no references to establish notability, no significant coverage in multiple reliable secondary sources - also Wikipedia:One sentence does not an article make Deletion of Pârâul Varului WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
17564 14842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Docurated User:AllyD 06:59, 28 April 2015 (UTC) delete A Highbeam search turns up various press release based items, plus an indication that the firm was one of 28 finalists in ''TechCrunch Disrupt NY 2013 Reports Startup Battlefield'' but nothing indicating notability Deletion of Docurated :WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
17565 2784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edwin Markham Elementary School User:RightCowLeftCoast 23:26, 2 February 2011 (UTC) merge Since it doesn't meet on its own, in the pasts the general consensus has been to take useful information and place it into the parent article of the school district and redirect it to that parent article until which time sufficient information is found to establish notability and thus the article can be recreated as a . Although it is not currently active, I don't believe that should have any bearing as to whether it can meet notability guidelines or that it shouldn't be mentioned in the parent article. If that were the case, there are many articles about relatively non-notable ships that have long since meet the scrappers torches that shouldn't have articles. The fact that several hundred (if not thousand) individuals have passed through those institutions should be enough to meet Deletion of Edwin Markham Elementary School WP:GNG||WP:SPINOUT||WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17566 7912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coffee High School User:Seicer 16:19, 27 February 2008 (UTC) delete Does not assert |notability (per proposed guidelines Deletion of Coffee High School WP:SCL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17567 13157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiki bar User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable podcast. &mdash Deletion of Tiki bar WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17568 17705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Ahmadi Martyrs User:Mandsford 18:31, 13 January 2011 (UTC) delete per nominator. New author was probably not aware of , a rule that may seem harsh at first, but is a necessity in an encyclopedia that anyone can edit. It's been applied more equally than any other policy. Hence, we have no articles attempting to list all of the persons who died in the 9/11 attacks, nor in the bombing of Hiroshima Deletion of 2010 Ahmadi Martyrs WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17569 16658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nadigan Kural User:MichaelQSchmidt 03:23, 16 April 2016 (UTC) delete for failing . Understanding that even an unreleased film might meet inclusion criteria of F|F (paragraph 3), I gave the thing a https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Nadigan_Kural&type=revision&diff=715485823&oldid=715372842 face-lift per MOS:FILM. Sadly, pre-internet Indian films are difficult to source, and it never being released makes it more difficult. While the cast and crew are sourcable (even with some now deceased), I could not find suitable coverage for this 1981 project. If someone comes forward with Tamil-language sources, ping me. Thanks Deletion of Nadigan Kural WP:NF||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17570 3625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sona the Voice User:Graeme 12:23, 6 July 2013 (UTC) comment I have declined the speedy delete, so please discuss this properly with a consensus outcome. There is not much promotion and some kind of claim of importance, but I don't think this meets Deletion of Sona the Voice WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17571 8604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sorboni Banerjee User:Jayden54 16:19, 26 December 2006 (UTC) delete non notable per and the article doesn't even really assert notability so might even be speedy deleted under CSD A7 Deletion of Sorboni Banerjee WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17572 5752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AFI World 9s User:Pichpich 02:34, 19 August 2019 (UTC) delete I too can't find anything beyond the ministryofsport article which discusses the tournament but is more focused on the efforts of the AFI to generate worldwide interest in the sport. I think that's a bit too thin for meeting Deletion of AFI World 9s WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17573 7593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radhika Nagrath User:Tayi 22:55, 26 June 2021 (UTC) delete does not meet , only has a couple passing mentions in reliable independent sources Deletion of Radhika Nagrath WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17574 2607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/End of roman republic User:Nick 02:24, 18 May 2014 (UTC) delete per nom and per Deletion of End of roman republic WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
17575 15463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slipknot (original band) User:Isotope23 16:30, 15 February 2006 (UTC) delete not and doesn't meet to boot. I'm not sure how to couple up an AfD, but I'd carry that delete over to the EP article as well Deletion of Slipknot (original band) WP:V||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17576 14328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mormon Expression User:VQuakr 01:53, 8 January 2011 (UTC) delete sources from a quick Google search appear similar to the two that are already in the article - blogs and similar non-|reliable sources. If some of them turned out to actually be well regarded within their niche, I could be convinced that this should be a weak keep instead. We really need a few editors with a better feel for what can be considered good sources for what effectively amounts to LDS pop culture. I am posting a link to this AfD at Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Latter Day Saint movement Deletion of Mormon Expression WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17577 14558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antisemitic incidents during the 2008–2009 Israel–Gaza conflict (2nd nomination) User:Mhking 17:08, 15 February 2009 (UTC) delete """per nominator; who's to define the attacks as """"antisemetic""""? violates """ Deletion of Antisemitic incidents during the 2008–2009 Israel–Gaza conflict (2nd nomination) WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
17578 5382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nayaki NONE NONE keep per filming having begun and topic of film's MOS:FILM#Production|production meeting | (paragraph 3), IE Deletion of Nayaki WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17579 4499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norman Ralph Bowen User:Dhartung 20:24, 15 May 2008 (UTC) comment It is not just that you need to use reliable sources or inline citations. Those are matters of style. But material that is not adequately supported by sources is not |notable and subject to deletion Deletion of Norman Ralph Bowen WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17580 8151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Human Exposure to Thimerosal from Vaccines Labeled for Use in Dogs User:MelanieN 17:38, 28 November 2011 (UTC) delete This is not an encyclopedia entry; it is a research paper. Wikipedia is for original research/synthesis like this Deletion of Human Exposure to Thimerosal from Vaccines Labeled for Use in Dogs WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17581 3969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Romanian Secular-Humanist Association User:Kraxler 16:00, 19 May 2015 (UTC) comment The article was moved back from draft space to main space but had the AfD tag removed, which is not correct, since this discussion is not closed yet. I restored the tag. The sources are all either the organization's own website, or trivial mentions in directories and news about loosely related things. It fails , especially , so far. And talking of Icelandic Ethical Humanist Association: First, please check out , and second, that article should be nominated for deletion too, since there are no independent sources at all, that could establish notability Deletion of Romanian Secular-Humanist Association WP:NORG||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17582 10214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Mack (catcher) User:Kbabej 16:01, 6 April 2021 (UTC) delete Definitely a case of . The article is so short that if he makes it pro it can be recreated easily Deletion of Joe Mack (catcher) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
17583 4375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Great Falls Police Department User:Jayron32 04:45, 19 February 2008 (UTC) delete The information can easily be incorporated into an article on the town. I see nothing to indicate this is a notable police department per all the relevent guidlines etc Deletion of Great Falls Police Department WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17584 9927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artemis (Marvel Comics) User:Gavin 08:55, 25 March 2008 (UTC) comment I am not saying the topic is non-notable. Wikipedia guidelines on |notability requires that evidence of notability in the form of |reliable sources should be cited in the article. Can you provide |reliable sources Deletion of Artemis (Marvel Comics) WP:FICT||WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17585 8073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bhopal Pride March User:AusLondonder 00:58, 4 October 2017 (UTC) keep ec}} My searches show significant coverage from independent, secondary reliable sources such as the ''http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/bhopal/bhopal-gets-drenched-in-rainbow-colours/articleshow/58746571.cms Times of India'', ''http://www.newindianexpress.com/nation/2017/may/17/lgbtq-community-parade-with-pride-in-first-for-bhopal-demand-welfare-board-for-transgendersexual-m-1605921.html The New Indian Express'', ''http://www.hindustantimes.com/bhopal/lgbtqia-parade-in-bhopal-for-demand-of-equal-rights/story-zuQRdX1wFFb4y0VtY7gXNO.html Hindustan Times'' and ''http://www.freepressjournal.in/bhopal/bhopal-madhya-pradeshs-first-lgbt-pride-parade-in-city-on-may-17/1063460 The Free Press Journal''; to name a few. The coverage goes beyond the coverage you may expect. Purely having not recieved coverage in the ''New York Times'' does not remove notability Deletion of Bhopal Pride March WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17586 21870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Spivak User:Cocytus 14:00, 2 January 2010 (UTC) keep if he played at the highest level of the sport, even internationally, he passes , and therefore merits inclusion Deletion of Daniel Spivak WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17587 15613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Volt (Transformers) User:Shooterwalker 14:00, 19 March 2011 (UTC) delete due to lack of sources to . Would not object to userfying it, so maybe a quality list could be created at a later date Deletion of Volt (Transformers) WP:verify notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
17588 17904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sedition Caucus User:KidAd 03:17, 22 June 2021 (UTC) delete Poor and Deletion of Sedition Caucus WP:ATTACKPAGE||WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Attack page 100
17589 14999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Team conflict user:Andrew 09:35, 10 July 2020 (UTC) keep """Team conflict? Like when some members of the team build something and then others members of the team try to destroy it? This is obviously notable as the page already has plenty of sources and there are lots more out there about this common phenomenon. If the article is not |perfect yet this is not a problem per our policy which states clearly that """"If editing can improve the page, this should be done rather than deleting the page""" Deletion of Team conflict WP:IMPERFECT||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
17590 1491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Area code 856 User:Edison 23:10, 4 July 2007 (UTC) delete per Kesh. Wikipedia is not a directory. This article also fails to show the area code in notable, since only one reference is presented. The fact that there are other articles about area codes only invites adding them to the AFD or nominating them separate, in keeping with Deletion of Area code 856 WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17591 18776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WBCQ (SW) User:Forest90 08:06, 1 July 2019 (UTC) keep the Article. It's passes guideline but the weak coverage in reliable and independent sources is a real weakness for the Article Deletion of WBCQ (SW) WP:BROADCAST Wikipedia:Notability 77
17592 17282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hotel Massachusetts User:JamesBurns 06:07, 19 February 2009 (UTC) delete insufficient 3rd party sources Deletion of Hotel Massachusetts WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17593 19138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brimsdown F.C. User:Lukeno94 10:38, 18 September 2013 (UTC) delete clearly fails , , and they have never been in a professional league (or even close to being Deletion of Brimsdown F.C. WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17594 5772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruby Granger User:Bearian 19:37, 28 January 2021 (UTC) delete per past outcomes (we tend to be strict on YouTubers), and ( she hasn't really ''done anything notable'', other than to be another teenager Deletion of Ruby Granger WP:GNG||WP:UPANDCOMING Wikipedia:Notability 77
17595 12930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Buffyverse objects User:Bearian 19:11, 13 April 2009 (UTC) keep per , split from overly long article Deletion of List of Buffyverse objects WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
17596 6243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akihiko Hoshide User:Neier 04:18, 24 April 2007 (UTC) keep per Nick Mallory, and close with Deletion of Akihiko Hoshide WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
17597 7139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Childstar band User:Theseeker4 19:46, 30 July 2009 (UTC) delete Trivial coverage, meets none of the or criteria, not signed with any label, let alone a notable one, single album release, no evidence of notable tours or singles, etc. Special:Contributions/Theseeker4|'''The''' Deletion of Childstar band WP:N||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17598 16008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiffany Teen User:Valrith 21:45, 9 October 2006 (UTC) delete as |unverifiable person failing to meet Deletion of Tiffany Teen WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17599 17580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David A. Bray User:Monty845 19:24, 29 December 2015 (UTC) delete Close enough to the borderline that we should respect the Subject's wishes, which have now been confirmed via OTRS https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia%3AAdministrators%27_noticeboard%2FIncidents&type=revision&diff=697322275&oldid=697320618. While arguably a public figure, I think we should still treat it as a situation Deletion of David A. Bray WP:BLPREQUESTDELETE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17600 2752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Idriss Aberkane User:David 03:43, 16 November 2015 (UTC) keep I only found two of what look like reliable in-depth independent sources on the subject http://www.lanouvellerepublique.fr/Vienne/Actualite/Dossiers-actualite/n/Contenus/Dossiers/Actualite/Jeunes-Express/Initiatives/Idriss-Aberkane-l-accoucheur-des-geeks-de-Gatine-1772253 http://mg.co.za/article/2015-09-23-the-geeks-shall-inherit-the-earth (one in French but that makes no dfference for notability). But two may be enough for . On the other hand, the article needs a lot of cleanup Deletion of Idriss Aberkane WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17601 15471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrian Justinussen User:GiantSnowman 07:38, 5 June 2019 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Adrian Justinussen WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17602 2661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heidi Behrens-Benedict User:MichaelQSchmidt 03:01, 20 October 2008 (UTC) keep """and tag for improvement and sourcing. There is a lot of coverage even for an """"also-ran"""" in reliable sources that pass : http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Heidi+Behrens-Benedict%22&btnG=Search Google Search, http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tab=wn&q=%22Heidi+Behrens-Benedict%22 Google News""" Deletion of Heidi Behrens-Benedict WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17603 213 [[Liste von Ausflugszielen und Sehenswürdigkeiten am Niederrhein]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Sir Gawain 13:47, 27. Apr. 2011 (CEST) keep und Verschieben auf Liste von Ausflugszielen und Sehenswürdigkeiten am Niederrhein. Diese Liste hat seit Jahr und Tag eine Definition (siehe 1. Satz des Texts), mehr ist für eine solche Liste, die ja kein Artikel sein will, nicht nötig. Weblinks sind mit Sicherheit kein Muss, das Fehlen derselben ist also auch kein Löschgrund. Literaturangaben kann man in einer solchen Liste gem. nicht angeben, da dies allesamt Reiseführer sein müssten, die aber den Kriterien für Literaturangaben nicht entsprächen. Und wieso ausgerechnet diese eine Liste gelöscht werden soll, wo es doch sogar eine eigene und gut gefüllte Kategorie :Kategorie:Liste (Sehenswürdigkeiten) gibt, will mir nicht einleuchten. Löschung von Liste von Ausflugszielen und Sehenswürdigkeiten am Niederrhein Wikipedia:LIT Wikipedia:Literatur 73
17604 17712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FOX animated universe User:Nymf 16:29, 7 October 2014 (UTC) delete and salt. Previously created (and deleted) as FOX Animated Universe by the now blocked {{User|TreCoolGuy}}. It is all original research/a made up term, and at best Deletion of FOX animated universe WP:NEOLOGISM Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17605 10356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nirman Dave User:Rsrikanth05 08:35, 12 August 2014 (UTC) delete Fails , , , , and . What 'great work' has he done? Well known? Seriously Deletion of Nirman Dave WP:N||WP:BIO||WP:V||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17606 4828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whompa User:MER 04:27, 8 December 2006 (UTC) delete as and/or failure to assert notability. So tagged Deletion of Whompa WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
17607 7234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Debra W. Soh User:Redditaddict69 14:03, 9 November 2018 (UTC) keep Seems to pass Deletion of Debra W. Soh WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
17608 6239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ananeuzumab User:Bearian 00:50, 29 November 2007 (UTC) delete After reviewing the template, the user page, and his talk page, I can only conclude two things: (1) these might be |hoaxes, or (2) these might be |his own research. He appears to be on a long Wikibreak Deletion of Ananeuzumab WP:HOAX||WP:OR Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
17609 20087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of living Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross recipients (2nd nomination) User:Kusma 16:30, 13 July 2021 (UTC) delete While says that we can certainly have things that are more up-to-date than printed encyclopaedias, like the things in :Category:Lists of living people (List of living cardinals is something we clearly should have and keep updated), a list with a single entry is utterly pointless. Wherever you would link to this list, just mention the one member instead Deletion of List of living Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross recipients (2nd nomination) WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17610 17364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Whip (band) User:Seraphim 23:54, 19 May 2008 (UTC) keep The band clearly meet criteria #4 with a http://www.nme.com/news/the-whip/31291 UK tour. You only need to meet one criteria to pass Deletion of The Whip (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17611 2323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/What Obama Really Meant User:23skidoo 14:46, 13 April 2008 (UTC) delete There's no indication the term has entered into general use, and at least some of the sources cited probably wouldn't pass muster with . If the term gets picked up by more mainstream media, then let's revisit it. Otherwise I agree, this comes off as an anti-Obama attack disguised as an article. Otherwise let's wait and see if it gains the same sort of equity as Bushism, for example Deletion of What Obama Really Meant WP:SOURCES Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17612 443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PokéBattlers User:Randomran 19:25, 3 November 2008 (UTC) delete Creator states that there is only one site to do with it at the moment. That's no other sources, let alone reliable third-party sources. Thus, this article fails the current and policy at this time Deletion of PokéBattlers WP:NOTABILITY||WP:VERIFIABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
17613 16604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Washington (1545 - 1620 User:Bearian 20:22, 11 July 2018 (UTC) delete he's one of |many remote ancestors of |a famous descendant Deletion of Robert Washington (1545 - 1620 WP:MILL||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
17614 9191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lunatic Gods User:Matt 07:45, 21 February 2009 (UTC) delete fails |notability guidelines for |bands Deletion of Lunatic Gods WP:N||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17615 17366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syrian government requests for peace talks User:Bedivere 22:19, 16 October 2007 (UTC) delete as violation Deletion of Syrian government requests for peace talks WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
17616 6342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ross Newell User:LeaveSleaves 13:33, 9 December 2008 (UTC) delete For failing . Part of the information is either hoax or unverifiable. e.g. there are no indications that he actually co-wrote songs in Read My Lips (album) (which incidentally released in 2002 and not 1991 as the article suggests). Plus director/producer of films with no third party coverage. ''Special:Contributions/LeaveSleaves|Leave Deletion of Ross Newell WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17617 20446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael James Lowrey User:FreeRangeFrog 20:31, 21 February 2013 (UTC) delete Regardless of my appreciation for all the hard work Orange Mike (and all other admins) do, I can't see that this would get past and . And as a courtesy since the subject has requested the deletion as well. Maybe |too soon? Maybe if more politicians were like Wikipedia admins things would be better... although sometimes they'd lock the door to the state capitol with Wikipedia:WRONGVERSION|the wrong padlock... and then |burn it down... um, well maybe not <g> Deletion of Michael James Lowrey WP:GNG||WP:POLITICIAN||WP:TOOSOON||WP:DDMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17618 12242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dean Bouzanis (2nd nomination) User:Mattythewhite 12:13, 17 April 2009 (UTC) keep While this article fails by the subject having not participated in a fully professional league, it passes with ease. Having been kept in the last AfD, I think it's fair to keep with the status quo Deletion of Dean Bouzanis (2nd nomination) WP:BIO||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17619 21574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Fronts of War User:ManicSpider 05:44, 7 January 2011 (UTC) delete WP:SPAM or ? There is nothing in reliable sources about this almost single-man project that doesn't have an air date yet Deletion of The Fronts of War WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17620 5904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Stick Cricket versions [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 00:22, 6 April 2009 (UTC) delete """I would be tempted to say """"merge"""", but after looking at some contribs and article history, I don't think there is anything verifiable here to merge; it's almost completely |original research""" Deletion of List of Stick Cricket versions WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
17621 5119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhythm Activism User:Bearcat 18:20, 3 November 2013 (UTC) keep per sourcing improvements. What happened here is that this article was created a long time ago, when Wikipedia's sourcing requirements weren't nearly as strict as they are now, and it just never got added to as the rules tightened up. Although ''some'' of the newly added references are actually |primary sources and should still be upgraded to the better kind, enough of them (''Voir'', Library and Archives Canada, etc.) are valid to demonstrate that they do indeed meet criteria Deletion of Rhythm Activism WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:BAND Wikipedia:No original research 65
17622 3003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Pham User:Blueboy96 18:22, 10 May 2008 (UTC) delete as blatant |vanispamcruftisement. Note that nearly all of the principal contributors are socks of {{user|Azurik}}, whom I have blocked for abusive sockpuppetry Deletion of John Pham WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
17623 10076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denmark–Mexico relations User:Hans_Adler 03:33, 4 June 2009 (UTC) delete The article lists 12 unrelated facts (but Wikipedia is |not a directory). All arguments to keep this article apply doubly to Deletion of Denmark–Mexico relations WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17624 3479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emerging market business User:Abu 19:55, 6 June 2007 (UTC) delete my apologies to Vital Wave Consulting, but this really looks like a spam |fork of emerging markets, which the author {{fullurl:emerging markets|diff=102915212}} previously tried to spam Deletion of Emerging market business WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
17625 3886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kitty (porn star) User:Obina 22:35, 11 January 2006 (UTC) delete Not notable enough for ,, per Obli, adult entertainer can be notable, but we can't use same movie or google counts as other potentially notable people Deletion of Kitty (porn star) WP:BIO||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17626 18012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caroline Worsley, Lady Worsley User:Bearian 14:33, 7 August 2020 (UTC) merge per {{U|Bogger}}, , and Deletion of Caroline Worsley, Lady Worsley WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
17627 16721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cathedral (US band) User:Darth 04:51, 22 May 2009 (UTC) delete Article gives no indication that this band passes Deletion of Cathedral (US band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17628 15764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Domination Through Impurity User:Dalbury 02:29, 1 December 2005 (UTC) comment """You forgot to quote the rest of the line from , """"note that it is often most appropriate to use redirects in place of articles on side projects, early bands and such."""" Right now it looks like Joe Payne's notability comes from recently joining a notable band, and I don't see that notability rubbing off on Domination Through Impurity. When Joe Payne gets his own article, then there can be a Redirect from Domination Through Impurity to his article""" Deletion of Domination Through Impurity WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17629 20825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti-homosexualism User:Bikeable 14:32, 1 September 2006 (UTC) delete """as POV fork. I have never heard the term, and I get about 120 google hits for """"anti-homosexualism"""" and less than half that for the unhyphenated version. (Weirdly, when I accidently clicked """"maps"""" when googling ''anti-homosexualism'', it found the Academy Awards.) The fact that the author cites the demonstrably false definition of homophobia as """"fear"""" (''Anti-homosexualism is a calculated political philosophy ... It is not associated with a fear of homosexuals''), as well as his characterization of the UU church above, leads me to believe that this is an attempt to discredit the very common and well-understood word """"homophobia"""" by introducing a near-|neologism. I agree that the Nazi and KKK anti-gay activities deserve mention, which is why we have Violence against gays, lesbians, bisexuals, and the transgendered. Some detail could be added there""" Deletion of Anti-homosexualism WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17630 6492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maryse Selit User:SudoGhost 17:33, 17 May 2012 (UTC) delete Article's subject does not meet the criteria of , and |notability is not inherited Deletion of Maryse Selit WP:BIO||WP:ITSA Wikipedia:Notability 77
17631 19263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrian Alfonso User:Bearian 17:00, 5 October 2007 (UTC) delete but ''not salted'', per nom, and as violating , , , and Deletion of Adrian Alfonso WP:AUTO||WP:NPOV||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
17632 20234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wang Yichen User:CAPTAIN 18:37, 23 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Wang Yichen WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17633 560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamen Rider Femme User:Active 21:30, 7 September 2010 (UTC) delete or merge, but there being no sourced, third party content, there is nothing to merge) fails no non-trivial third party content. Special:Contributions/Active_Banana|''Active Deletion of Kamen Rider Femme WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17634 7292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giant Space Shark User:discospinster 02:41, 10 August 2008 (UTC) delete does not meet Wikipedia standards of |notability Deletion of Giant Space Shark WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17635 6495 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alternative explanations of the """"grandmother"""" cell""" User:Kingofaces43 17:24, 7 November 2019 (UTC) delete Just piling on at this point, but I couldn't find anything in my read through either that would be worth even merging, and it does indeed look like a attempt """Deletion of Alternative explanations of the """"grandmother"""" cell""" WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
17636 16583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frederico Morais User:Arruda81 19:31, 27 October 2015 (UTC) delete per . I'm sorry to disagree {{lu|Carlrobinsonuk}} but an interview with a newspaper is not enough to make someone notable. With or without the interview, the article still looks like a professional resumé. Monaco U17 isn't professional football, and even if it was he's not even listed on AS Monaco official website as part of the technical staff of the U17 team, so I can only assume he's an assistant coach. And thank you {{lu|davidwr Deletion of Frederico Morais WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
17637 17436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Serwan Baban User:Phil 00:52, 31 July 2010 (UTC) keep Clearly passes criterion 6 as a vice chancellor of a university Deletion of Serwan Baban WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17638 16683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vulcan To The Sky Trust User:RightCowLeftCoast 19:58, 18 October 2014 (UTC) merge to Avro Vulcan XH558, subject is about a specific non-notable (|yet) surviving aircraft of the subject of the article Avro Vulcan XH558. Therefore, until the specific aircraft receives |significant coverage sufficient to pass , summarize verified content, and merge into parent article. No prejudice against recreating article about the specific aircraft if it can meet GNG in the future Deletion of Vulcan To The Sky Trust WP:TOOSOON||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
17639 2373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Racial Contract [[User talk:Czar|czar]] 19:34, 24 October 2017 (UTC) keep Added six academic reviews from JSTOR, which should be sufficient for |significant coverage. If anyone wants more book reviews, let me know and I can dig deeper Deletion of The Racial Contract WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
17640 785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allegations of apartheid (third nomination) User:Armon 02:02, 13 April 2007 (UTC) keep and '''merge''' the various sub-article POV forks/polemics into this one. WilyD point about which uses to list via makes sense. Anything more detailed regarding the human rights situation in various countries should be dealt with in the appropriate human rights articles. As for the claim, does this mean that the people arguing SYNTH therefore object to all lists? To my mind, this seems to be what the article essentially is -a list Deletion of Allegations of apartheid (third nomination) WP:RS||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17641 5325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Healthpoint Ltd User:Bobherry 16:15, 31 March 2015 (UTC) delete Not notable. Deletion of Healthpoint Ltd WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17642 20624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kyle Butler (footballer) User:SportingFlyer 00:22, 13 December 2020 (UTC) keep barely scrapes by , but there's enough coverage where this isn't a straight up delete - however, if his football career doesn't continue might be worth taking a second look in a couple years Deletion of Kyle Butler (footballer) WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
17643 14697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucien van der Walt User:ThePlatypusofDoom 19:30, 8 April 2016 (UTC) keep For me, we need to figure out where the promotion ends and the fact begins. If he meets he should be kept Deletion of Lucien van der Walt WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17644 2382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tsubee U User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:30, 11 August 2012 (UTC) delete No reliable sources offering |verifiability. Fails Deletion of Tsubee U WP:V||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17645 14997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip K. Dick in popular culture User:Otto4711 14:56, 13 May 2007 (UTC) delete it is somewhat notable that the author has appeared as a character in the works of other authors. That one paragraph, if |verified, should be placed in Dick's article. All the rest of it, composed as it is of |original research and triviality, needs to be deleted Deletion of Philip K. Dick in popular culture WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17646 9314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Courtney Crutcher User:Yobmod 13:58, 12 February 2009 (UTC) delete I wouldn't say they are not notewothy achievments, but they certainly don't provide notability per Deletion of Courtney Crutcher WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17647 5697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ktjames User:Alex43223 08:30, 8 December 2008 (UTC) delete per and . Also delete other articles created by this user on the same topic. &ndash Deletion of Ktjames WP:BIO||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17648 2090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trackle User:Septrillion 05:25, 9 May 2018 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Trackle WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17649 15746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Send My Love (To Your New Lover) User:Jonesey95 04:10, 25 January 2016 (UTC) keep per {{U|Softlavender}}. Clearly passes Deletion of Send My Love (To Your New Lover) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17650 17719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J. Caleb Boggs III User:MelanieN 00:40, 9 January 2011 (UTC) delete """Please provide us with some of those references you found. Because I searched and found http://news.google.com/archivesearch?&as_src=-newswire+-wire+-presswire+-PR+-release+-wikipedia&q=%22J.+Caleb+Boggs+III%22 zilch. The achievements boasted of in the article - being president of an organization, being appointed to a commission - do not amount to notability. This has nothing to do with """"savouriness or otherwise"""", and in fact there is nothing in the article to suggest he is anything but a model citizen. The problem is that he doesn't meet Wikipedia's |notability criteria""" Deletion of J. Caleb Boggs III WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17651 18059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Bauer (radio host) User:S 23:45, 9 August 2008 (UTC) delete on grounds. NB: The potential COI is ''not'' in itself grounds for deletion Deletion of Kim Bauer (radio host) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17652 1368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Serene Branson User:Kevin 22:05, 15 February 2011 (UTC) delete I pretty much agree with Tarc. If it wasn't for the recent event she would not be notable. The earlier coverage is neither substantial nor widespread, being typical local coverage of TV reporters. This would not have passed before, which makes this recent incident fit squarely into Deletion of Serene Branson WP:GNG||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
17653 166 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Mara wittz """Kullanıcı:muratsahanmuratsahin""" 08:45, 9 Ağustos 2010 (UTC) delete Arama motoru ile arandığında kişi hakkında birçok kaynak var fakat hiçbiri |güvenilir kaynakları sağlamıyor, bence. Kişi hakkında doğrulanabilir bir bilgi veren tarafları yok. Bu dış bağlantılar kayda değer de değil. Yani gerekçeye katılıyorum Mara wittz'in silinmesi Vikipedi:Güvenilir kaynaklar Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17654 9388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony John Bailey User:One 19:09, 16 February 2007 (UTC) delete Too many unverifiable vanity claims, fails Deletion of Anthony John Bailey WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17655 67 [[Ökobilanz und ökologischer Fußabdruck des Hundes]] (SLA, gelöscht) Benutzer:Vierteltakt 23:47, 25. Sep. 2015 (CEST) delete Benutzer Raoul65, der den Artikel angelegt hat, wurde inzwischen gesperrt wegen Umgehung einer Sperre unter anderem Namen. Anscheinend hat er einige Nonsens-Artikel, die nur der Provokation dienen sollten, verfasst. Bitte Vergleiche hierzu auch /25. September 2015#Koscheres Bier (SLA Löschung von Ökobilanz und ökologischer Fußabdruck des Hundes Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
17656 16650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Iron Man supporting characters User:BOZ 19:40, 3 September 2020 (UTC) keep per above comments, and per and Deletion of List of Iron Man supporting characters WP:PRESERVE||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
17657 18998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Get Out (song) User:JamesBurns 23:27, 7 December 2008 (UTC) delete notability not established, as per Deletion of Get Out (song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17658 18800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Near Infinity Corporation User:Stifle 14:07, 3 September 2008 (UTC) delete does not appear to meet , and while there's a load of references, the sources don't seem |reliable Deletion of Near Infinity Corporation WP:CORP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17659 13092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Good looking User:DustFormsWords 07:11, 7 April 2010 (UTC) delete None of the entries on this page are appropriate disambiguations per (and particularly Deletion of Good looking WP:DISAMBIG||WP:DABNOT Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
17660 4002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of obligatory nude recreation sites User:Tarc 17:17, 15 July 2014 (UTC) delete Fails , as noted above. Also shades of Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of gay bathhouse regulars|List of gay bathhouse regulars here, in that the Wikipedia is being used as a nudist recreation guidebook Deletion of List of obligatory nude recreation sites WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
17661 7510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canadian Libraries User:Northamerica1000 06:52, 28 January 2015 (UTC) keep Upon further consideration, per {{U|DGG}}'s rationale, vis-à-vis . The article technically also qualifies as a reasonable of the Internet Archive article per . Also of note is that the Internet Archive article presently has a merge tag to merge this article into it. Struck my previous !vote above Deletion of Canadian Libraries WP:IAR||WP:SPINOUT||WP:SIZERULE Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
17662 19614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timeless Time & Expense User:ThePlatypusofDoom 15:07, 26 April 2016 (UTC) delete Not enough good sources, doesn't meet requirements ( Deletion of Timeless Time & Expense WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17663 20643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nadia Bello User:Tree 07:10, 17 September 2006 (UTC) delete per and . Candidates for elections are usually not considered notable until they've won (unless of course it was an election for a very high political position, such as president, or if the candidate has done something else notable in his/her life). Also, only 183 Google results http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=%22Nadia+Bello%22&btnG=Search Deletion of Nadia Bello WP:BIO||WP:ADS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17664 11933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marlene Griggs-Knope User:Hunter 13:26, 29 July 2020 (UTC) keep """The nominator cites without explaining why he believes this article doesn't pass that guideline. The benchmark for GNG is that the subject of an article has significant coverage in reliable secondary sources independent of the subject, and this article checks all those boxes. It is well-sourced by reliable secondary sources, with coverage that goes beyond plot summary into a Development section as well. I imagine this article could be expanded further, but that's not a reason for deletion. The nominator doesn't seem to be making a policy-based argument for deletions but rather stating his own opinion that she's a """"minor character"""" who he, in his subjective opinion, feels isn't notable""" Deletion of Marlene Griggs-Knope WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17665 8817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmad Raza Khan Kasuri User:Pharaoh 22:19, 20 June 2019 (UTC) keep passes was a member of the National Assembly of Pakistan Deletion of Ahmad Raza Khan Kasuri WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17666 2858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Statutory Instruments of Scotland, 2012 User:Cynical 00:47, 20 October 2013 (UTC) delete It's merely a reproduction of a list available in primary sources - there's no value in duplicating it on Wikipedia when the vast, vast majority of the entries on the list are redlinks or nonlinks with no prospect of ever having enough secondary sources avaiable to become viable articles Deletion of List of Statutory Instruments of Scotland, 2012 WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17667 12231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liam Tulley (actor) [[User talk:71.166.147.78|talk]])}}''' 16:32, 21 April 2010 (UTC) delete Subect does not even have an Imdb entry ... utterly fails . Happy Editing! — '''{{#if:71.166.147.78|{{User|71.166.147.78}}|Special:Contributions/71.166.147.78|71.166.147.78 Deletion of Liam Tulley (actor) WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17668 9362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Open Source Routing Machine User:SL93 20:32, 15 May 2012 (UTC) delete No sign of notability per Deletion of Open Source Routing Machine WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17669 16607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Social polling User:Mark 04:51, 21 June 2016 (UTC) keep Using a simple style search, I have added 6 sources since the initial prod. There is a Time piece, 2 academic papers, and a piece by the pollster Pew Research that look secondary and reliable. The entrepreneur.com piece is secondary and in depth, but is a lightweight source. The Variety piece may or may not be reliable, but is secondary. Overall, there are multiple in-depth reliable sources needed for notability per and upon which to build a modest article Deletion of Social polling WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
17670 16556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Argentine Americans User:Badagnani 01:21, 13 September 2007 (UTC) keep """Important aid for researchers. We only include notable individuals in these lists and they are well sourced. As with previous ethnic group nominations, this nomination, apparently done along with dozens if not hundreds of others all in a single day, is disruptive, , and does not enhance our encyclopedia. Editor apparently presumes that all Americans ''should'' simply be """"American,"""" and their national origin should be ignored. This attempt to inject political POV into the Wiki should be eschewed in the strongest terms. '''Improve, don't delete""" Deletion of List of Argentine Americans WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
17671 16283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apartionalism User:Black 17:48, 8 March 2007 (UTC) delete per without prejudice to proper recreation in the future (somewhat doubtful). The term was invented 2-3 days ago in an op-ed piece by an individual who has published previous op-ed pieces in ''The Stanford Daily'' (see http://daily.stanford.edu/author/Eugene+Gu). It may be appropriately recreated if the term catches on or becomes the subject of controversy. Until it does Deletion of Apartionalism WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17672 6852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xilisoft Corporation User:Gavin 17:05, 21 December 2007 (UTC) delete as company fails . The lack of |reliable secondary sources makes this article look like a Ghit farm for its products Deletion of Xilisoft Corporation WP:CORP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17673 15260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jared Hyatt (baseball) User:BRMo 23:57, 13 April 2009 (UTC) delete """Statistics or brief mentions in articles about minor league teams do not constitute """"significant coverage in reliable sources,"""" as required by """ Deletion of Jared Hyatt (baseball) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17674 12915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Serious Truth User:Orangemike 16:34, 7 July 2018 (UTC) delete """fails notability. Most of the """"coverage"""" is of his arrest, which falls under """"one event""""; or about other people, thus falling under . The fact that almost everything has been done by his publicist/manager, who has been canvassing off-Wiki, is secondary to the failure to meet our standards of musician notability""" Deletion of Serious Truth :WP:NOTCONTAGIOUS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17675 10079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Starf*ck (party) User:Jersey 03:24, 3 April 2006 (UTC) delete nn annual party thrown at Brown University. Does not meet with no sources either Deletion of Starf*ck (party) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17676 15097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Stuart Lloyd User:Eddie891 21:49, 25 June 2020 (UTC) delete 1) doesn't seem to meet with little clearly reliable coverage, and 2) in not clearly notable private individual cases where |the blp requests deletion the article should be deleted Deletion of Anthony Stuart Lloyd WP:NPERSON||WP:BLPREQUESTDELETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17677 21143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eduwonkette User:Mayalld 15:25, 7 July 2008 (UTC) comment You have been neither threatened nor bullied. You have been warned for making |personal attacks following your comments in the AFD about my motivation, and the accusations that you placed on my talk page Deletion of Eduwonkette WP:NPA Wikipedia:No personal attacks 58
17678 19446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Embargoed [[User_Talk:SiobhanHansa|SiobhanHansa]] 14:52, 6 October 2007 (UTC) keep I've edited the article to include the references SolDrury put on another users talk page and to add in some press coverage I found of the organization's activities. I think this makes for a minor but notable organization and provided the article can be kept |neutral, its presence will benefit the encyclopedia. I encourage others to look at the rewritten article to see if it now meets their own standards Deletion of Embargoed WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
17679 4235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Israel–Kenya relations User:Johnuniq 09:04, 13 July 2009 (UTC) delete """No one here has shown any particular knowledge of relations between Israel and Kenya (I don't have any either). So all we have is some editors saying the news stories and government announcements that mention Israel and Kenya show the relations are notable, while other editors say those same articles do ''not'' establish notability. That's precisely why we have which requires some independent analysis that concludes the topic has general significance. If this were an article about some recent musical fashion, I wouldn't care. However, the """"relations"""" articles are core encyclopedic content and articles such as this (even if expanded with the information mentioned above) will only ever be a |synthesis of factoids with no """"so what"""" exposition. There are some significant issues in some of the articles mentioned above; those issues should be part of articles about the ''events''. None of the sources mentioned claim that Kenya is important to Israel, or that Israel is important to Kenya""" Deletion of Israel–Kenya relations WP:GNG||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
17680 8268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of current ACC basketball announcers User:WikiVirusC 19:05, 18 February 2018 (UTC) delete list that doesn't meet requirements of , won't find this list in any kind of signficant coverage, coverage will be mentions that are specific to relevant broadcasters for that game or team only Deletion of List of current ACC basketball announcers WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
17681 9861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cryptoskank User:Meshach 23:00, 6 March 2007 (UTC) delete per and . Also (if this is removed) remove the entry from the category Deletion of Cryptoskank WP:NOR||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:No original research 65
17682 13562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emily J. Hilscher User:StuffOfInterest 13:28, 18 April 2007 (UTC) comment Please see in addition to Deletion of Emily J. Hilscher WP:CRYSTAL||WP:MEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17683 13308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SyntheticPages user:BlindEagle 16:37, 18 September 2007 (UTC) delete This appears to fail to me Deletion of SyntheticPages WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
17684 13351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angie Paccione User:David 21:41, 5 October 2006 (UTC) keep """Not just a candidate, but a leader (""""Majority Caucus Chair"""") in the Colorado State House, thus satisfying the second notability category given in , """"Political figures holding international, national or statewide/provincewide office '''or members of a national, state or provincial legislature'''"""" (emphasis added""" Deletion of Angie Paccione WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17685 10451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sobrietol User:Accounting4Taste 05:00, 23 January 2009 (UTC) delete """The three citations purporting to be for """"peer-reviewed science"""" are either broken or irrelevant; a random sampling of the other citations indicates |original research and shows all the signs of junk science. seems to apply here""" Deletion of Sobrietol WP:OR||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:No original research 65
17686 3784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Racial disappearance User:Baileypalblue 23:50, 19 March 2009 (UTC) delete The nominator's rationale sums the situation pretty well. It may be possible to write an encyclopedic article on the subject of the dimunition and disappearance of races due to immigration and miscegenation, but this article is a |FRINGE #ESSAY|ESSAY. Ordinarily I would argue for keeping the article and re-writing it, but when you remove the non-encylopedic content from this article (as I have done), you are left with nothing but a |NEOLOGISM. To make a truly clean start you'd have to rename the article, come up with a different definition of its topic, and re-write and source it from the ground up. There's no foundation to build on; better to delete the article and start from scratch Deletion of Racial disappearance WP:FRINGE||WP:NOT||WP:NEOLOGISM Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
17687 14376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gale Thomson User:Inother 11:42, 14 April 2015 (UTC) delete Non-notable wife of a local politician who does not meet the |general notability guideline Deletion of Gale Thomson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17688 624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Johnny Hanson User:Edison 12:01, 24 June 2007 (UTC) delete as failing , as per Deletion of Johnny Hanson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17689 882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lamar Atkins User:SportingFlyer 01:48, 25 December 2019 (UTC) delete nothing but a couple routine transactional reports and some routine college blogs on him. Fails Deletion of Lamar Atkins WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17690 11419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruben Loftus-Cheek User:Egghead06 05:40, 28 June 2013 (UTC) delete Fails and . Way too soon and as an Englishman with Chelsea who knows when he will get his chance Deletion of Ruben Loftus-Cheek WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17691 5881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryan Wagner User:W 14:28, 28 March 2007 (UTC) keep apparently got a lot of media coverage in the 1980s, including by the New York Times http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&ned=us&ie=UTF-8&q=%22Bryan+Wagner%22+New+Orleans so that satisfies / Deletion of Bryan Wagner WP:A||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Attribution 108
17692 13399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Homosexualist User:Dhartung 18:33, 5 February 2007 (UTC) comment This fails the |speedy keep criteria. The nomination was valid -- the present state of the article is terrible. Though new sources have been brought up in debate, the article hasn't been revised. It definitely needs a thorough cleanup (removing the OR and urbandictionary stuff) and rewrite to sources Deletion of Homosexualist WP:SK Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
17693 19896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Yonga User:Hobbes 22:11, 14 December 2011 (UTC) delete College soccer player, also plays on a (presumably amateur) 4th-division US team. Web searches find just a faint amount of local coverage, in addition to social media. Fails Deletion of Paul Yonga WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17694 11802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Computational and Structural Biotechnology Journal NONE NONE comment Per Deletion of Computational and Structural Biotechnology Journal WP:NJOURNAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17695 1257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kotick Marketing Group (2nd nomination) User:Ihcoyc 16:42, 13 October 2009 (UTC) delete would say '''speedy delete''' as #G11|blatant advertising, but for a 2d AfD it may be best to set a firm precedent here. This is a ''full-service, multi-dimensional marketing firm''. Oonh, it's '''''multi-dimensional''''' we are, is it? What dimensions do you practice in besides this one? ''The agency’s focus lies in the strategic development of numerous industry brands and the creation of integrated marketing campaigns and promotions for Business-to-Business (B2B) and Business-to-Consumer (B2C) clients.'' In other words, empty Deletion of Kotick Marketing Group (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17696 2939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of properties of Hilton Worldwide User:Aausterm 18:34, 1 April 2021 (UTC) comment This violates the simple listings part of the as it just provides a listing of locations. Most of them are non notable and the notable ones are already covered by the :Category:Hilton Hotels & Resorts hotels. If this page is to be kept, it will need to be changed Deletion of List of properties of Hilton Worldwide WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17697 21177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zycus (2nd nomination) User:AleatoryPonderings 04:03, 12 August 2020 (UTC) delete """There's mentions, but nothing in reputable press—just press releases and clickbait. The link above appears to be copy-pasted from a press release (author is listed as """"BusinessWire""""). I cannot find SIGCOV in reliable, independent sources, so I believe this company fails """ Deletion of Zycus (2nd nomination) WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17698 15882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Corsaletti [[User: Phoenix B 1of3|Phoenix B 1of3]] [[User talk: Phoenix B 1of3|(talk)]] 02:54, 22 October 2011 (UTC) keep It passes , well known and notable to have an article, well written enough to keep Deletion of Jeff Corsaletti WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
17699 2315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Behm User:Yoninah 17:50, 25 February 2017 (UTC) delete per . I tried to add additional sources to beef up this article, but she just sounds like a local personality who's running a restaurant and appearing in some shows. Winning Master Chef does not confer notability Deletion of Jennifer Behm WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17700 3801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PEN15 User:Useight 04:22, 16 July 2007 (UTC) delete non-notable prank. Wikipedia is |not for things made up on day Deletion of PEN15 WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
17701 3674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fabio moro User:MER 07:44, 26 December 2006 (UTC) delete unsourced |autobiography of a |non-notable person Deletion of Fabio moro WP:AUTO||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
17702 17585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WWF Mayhem in Manchester User:Galatz 18:21, 14 February 2018 (UTC) keep The previous article which was a redirected is completely different than the article in its current form. The event meets as it is still talked about today due to its controversy over originally being a PPV to becoming a poorly shot home video release. There is enough sourcing in the article to pass Deletion of WWF Mayhem in Manchester WP:LASTING||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17703 11765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lewis Nixon (United States Army officer) User:GretLomborg 20:23, 30 June 2017 (UTC) keep """he is notable enough to have had his https://www.amazon.com/Beyond-Band-Brothers-Memoirs-Winters/dp/0425208133/ memoirs published, and he was also covered in the Band of Brothers book and TV series. says: """"it is important to note that a person who does not meet the criteria mention above is not necessarily non-notable,"""" and I think the coverage of him is sufficient to meet the """ Deletion of Lewis Nixon (United States Army officer) WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17704 2148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Floyd User:Bagumba 09:19, 31 May 2020 (UTC) comment """No issue if the primary topic for George Floyd is a redirect to Death of George Floyd. However, there are a few title matches handled by the dab's """"see also"""". {{u|Anon0098}} commented on partial titles at Talk:George_Floyd#Recent_Protests, and {{u|Paintspot}} attempted to add another partial title before.https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=George_Floyd&diff=959611387&oldid=959526033 No opinion currently if that is sufficient reason to keep but move the dab""" Deletion of George Floyd WP:PARTIAL Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
17705 2484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naim (chat program) User:Joe 20:55, 30 September 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of Naim (chat program) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17706 16148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khel Prashal Stadium User:Spiderone 16:30, 18 December 2015 (UTC) delete lack of reliable sources to pass Deletion of Khel Prashal Stadium WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17707 9555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Road User:Chase 01:44, 22 October 2007 (UTC) comment Still smacks of advertising! Have a look at Deletion of American Road WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17708 4573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kyle Schlesinger User:LinguistAtLarge 21:13, 30 March 2009 (UTC) comment There are a few http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Kyle+Schlesinger%22&cf=all Gnews hits, so he might have notability, but I can't access the pay-per-view articles to tell. The issue isn't too relevant, since COI editing is only a problem when it affects Wikipedia's goal of producing a neutral, reliably sourced encyclopedia — Deletion of Kyle Schlesinger WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
17709 3436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad Zubair (cricketer, born 1987) User:Wjemather 16:10, 13 March 2021 (UTC) delete No significant coverage, only wide-ranging databases built on scorecard data, so fails and . This trumps the trivial pass of NCRIC (playing for the weakest team in the competition) which by consensus is a very poor indicator of worthiness for a standalone article in cases such as these. Lack of any performances of note suggests no coverage will be found. Redirect would be an accepted ATD, but a suitable target does not exist Deletion of Mohammad Zubair (cricketer, born 1987) WP:GNG||WP:SPORTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17710 19845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dean Andrew Kantis User:WikiDan61 16:37, 4 October 2013 (UTC) comment I believe Gibco has improperly summarized the gist of this discussion. If the article were salvageable, then it would be salvaged. I believe the problem is that there are not sufficient independent unbiased sources on which to build the article in the first place. Mr Kantis is simply not a |notable person according to the standards of Wikipedia, and does not merit an article, no matter how well or poorly written Deletion of Dean Andrew Kantis WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17711 7545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joey Concepcion User:The 10:25, 23 July 2018 (UTC) delete since subject fails . If there's any material to be salvaged, '''Merge''' it into the band article and place a '''Redirect''' on this one. There seems to be some problem with the notion of independent notability in this discussion. Let's just hope , then Deletion of Joey Concepcion WP:NMUSICIAN||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
17712 3965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Nina Concerts and Gigs User:JamesBurns 04:17, 28 December 2008 (UTC) delete listcruft, Deletion of List of Nina Concerts and Gigs WP:DIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17713 20791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Munni Saha User:Ibrahim 10:43, 27 September 2016 (UTC) delete does not qualify Deletion of Munni Saha WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
17714 4717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AustinFromNEW User:Narthring 05:12, 31 October 2009 (UTC) delete The article's references do not establish notability per any of the points in , nor was I able to find anything after searching online. There are many examples of the subject's work but I couldn't find anything that seemed to indicate notability. A third-party reference treating the subject or something similar would help, if such a reference exists Deletion of AustinFromNEW WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
17715 581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Long Sight User:Pburka 01:26, 12 July 2013 (UTC) delete per , Deletion of Long Sight WP:NFILM||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17716 15189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rock noir User:Sabrebd 09:14, 30 July 2012 (UTC) delete The lack of reliable third party sources (music stores and forums are not reliable sources) indicates that this fails . The argument that there is a long term link between rock and theatre only undermines the case for this being a recognisable genre Deletion of Rock noir WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17717 8288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thurs statistical function [[User talk:101.119.29.206|talk]]) 13:27, 13 January 2014 (UTC) delete as non-notable . -- Special:Contributions/101.119.29.206|101.119.29.206 Deletion of Thurs statistical function WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
17718 20086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nia Sioux User:Yamaguchi先生 23:20, 30 March 2015 (UTC) delete due to a lack of non-trivial coverage of this subject by reliable third party publications. Extra care should be taken as this is a about a minor child. Regards Deletion of Nia Sioux WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17719 20366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pet ownership among the homeless User:Dumyes 22:42, 25 October 2018 (UTC) comment Ok i now see the page meets i thought it was unneeded. But i see that it should stay now Deletion of Pet ownership among the homeless WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17720 861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lists of people by cause of death User:Evb 03:17, 13 June 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of items of information Deletion of Lists of people by cause of death WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17721 15618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rosemarie Allen User:Russ 10:39, 29 January 2021 (UTC) keep There is absolutely no sign of whatsoever. But I take the Essence profile quite seriously as significant independent coverage. The in-depth Chalkbeat interview (a regional magazine), supported by local coverage, brings me to a weak keep. The article needs quite a bit of work for style and issues, but as usual, Deletion of Rosemarie Allen WP:NPROF||WP:PROMO||WP:DINC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17722 5633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Art+Feminism User:Clpo13 16:37, 13 March 2016 (UTC) keep There are plenty of reliable, independent sources reporting on this, enough to satisfy . The article is distinct from Wikipedia:Meetup/ArtAndFeminism in that it's a report on the event without the meta aspects of coordinating. Compare The Signpost (Wikipedia)|''The Signpost'' (Wikipedia) and Knowledge Engine (Wikimedia Foundation) for other articles on Wikipedia/WMF aspects or initiatives Deletion of Art+Feminism WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17723 20784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Smip User:Joe 00:29, 19 November 2009 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Smip WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
17724 19528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Velma Kelly Online user:Some 21:34, 20 September 2006 (UTC) delete see and Deletion of Velma Kelly Online WP:NFT||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
17725 4348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Herring (businessman) User:RightCowLeftCoast 05:46, 12 March 2013 (UTC) delete multiple mentions in non-primary |reliable sources, however added together I do not believe they add up to |significant coverage of the subject. Furthermore, although Wealth TV is notable, |that doesn't mean the subject of this AfD is notable. Therefore, failing or , the proper course of action is deletion. As a compromise, I can agree to changing the article to a redirect to Wealth TV Deletion of Robert Herring (businessman) WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17726 20433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shawn Eckardt User:Bongomatic 06:55, 7 October 2008 (UTC) merge This could be the poster child for Deletion of Shawn Eckardt WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
17727 20972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs about rain NONE NONE keep Passes , the list topic itself has been discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources Deletion of List of songs about rain WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
17728 2099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/McDonald's rap User:JBsupreme 09:13, 18 December 2009 (UTC) delete Interesting arguments put forth by the nominator, but I'm endorsing deletion for a different reason: Deletion of McDonald's rap WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17729 6834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/India Walton User:NickCT 19:30, 23 June 2021 (UTC) keep """Does seem like and a bit, but the proposed language at Wikipedia:Notability_(politics)#Local_politicians seems cogent; """"Mayors of cities of at least regional prominence have usually survived AfD""" Deletion of India Walton WP:RECENTISM||WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:Recentism 10
17730 18730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B52 User:doomsdayer520 13:33, 21 April 2020 (UTC) delete This article is operating as one of many self-promotional announcements that were created around that time. No |significant and reliable coverage on the rapper can be found Deletion of B52 WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
17731 15962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hesse state election, 2013 User:Lugnuts 13:07, 3 June 2012 (UTC) keep """Per , which states """"Individual scheduled or expected future events should only be included if the event is notable and almost certain to take place""" Deletion of Hesse state election, 2013 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17732 11451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Kennedy (chemistry spokesperson) User:Aoziwe 12:31, 7 October 2018 (UTC) delete """with a '''redirect'''. The campaign the subject runs for """"natural chemicals"""" would I suggest have more than enough to easily support . It has multiple references from independent reliable sources over a number of years. I suggest that the """"natural chemicals"""" subject will have reasonable interest, but not the current subject person per se at this time. Notability is not inherited. I suggest that the article be ed and '''redone about """"natural chemicals""""''' with the current subject strongly mentioned with due weight and with a redirect from the current title to the new article""" Deletion of James Kennedy (chemistry spokesperson) WP:NEXIST||WP:GNG||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17733 4079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Kostric User:Lithorien 19:11, 21 August 2009 (UTC) delete The article itself fails and really, the only notability that's offered up goes towards proving the '''event's''' notability, not the person's. Regardless of if more information will come out or not, this single person isn't likely to ever have signifigant notability. Just the event Deletion of William Kostric WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17734 14858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Thing About Jane Spring User:EconomistBR 03:28, 25 May 2008 (UTC) delete The article fails to establish the subjects' notability () by not citing sources Deletion of The Thing About Jane Spring WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17735 10984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fairfield (producer) User:Nyttend 18:02, 12 January 2010 (UTC) delete blatantly fails Deletion of Fairfield (producer) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17736 4284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albert M. Wolters (second nomination) User:Unfocused 16:50, 17 October 2005 (UTC) keep This is clear and convincing evidence that AfD '''''AND''''' VFU occasionally make mistakes. |Ignore all rules has been successfully applied to improve the encyclopedia. Wikilawyers who value process over the end product should try not to take this personally, and then if they're still upset over this, reconsider whether they're actually helping create an encyclopedia or not Deletion of Albert M. Wolters (second nomination) WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
17737 16227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spencer Clark User:Paddles 10:57, 27 May 2006 (UTC) delete Clearly fails . Condolences to the page creator, but he is not notable enough to include Deletion of Spencer Clark WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17738 5360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Red Shoes Unno User:LM2000 07:15, 2 June 2017 (UTC) delete I've heard of this referee, which is more than I can say for most. Unfortunately that's not enough to satisfy Deletion of Red Shoes Unno WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17739 604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atta ur Rehman Khan [[User talk:86.17.222.157|talk]]) 17:13, 20 October 2016 (UTC) delete Nobody has come up with, and I can't find, any evidence that the subject might pass or the WP:general notability guideline|general notability guideline. Special:Contributions/86.17.222.157|86.17.222.157 Deletion of Atta ur Rehman Khan WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17740 14288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francesco Rossi User:GiantSnowman 15:04, 30 September 2010 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Francesco Rossi WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17741 11412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ann Ariel Wilson User:OliverTwisted 11:24, 18 December 2008 (UTC) delete Fail Deletion of Ann Ariel Wilson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17742 3980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hal Parrish User:Bearcat 19:24, 3 April 2017 (UTC) delete """without prejudice against recreation if somebody can put the emphasis where it belongs. A person does not get a Wikipedia article just for being a ''candidate'' in an election — either you show and properly source that he was ''already'' eligible for a Wikipedia article for some other reason ''independent'' of his candidacy, or he has to ''win'' the election, not just run in it, to clear the bar because of the election itself. Campaign coverage, further, does ''not'' assist a candidate for office in clearing GNG just for the candidacy — ''all'' candidates for office ''always'' garner campaign coverage, so such coverage is , not notability-building. If campaign coverage built notability in and of itself, we would always have to keep an article about every single candidate for any office at all. But we ''don't'' do that.Accordingly, in order for Parrish to get an article ''today'', the substance and the sourceability would have to be shifted onto his role as mayor of Manassas — and even then, Manassas is ''not'' large enough that he would get an automatic ''presumption'' of notability for that in the ''absence'' of a demonstrated pass, so there aren't grounds for an automatic """"keep because mayor"""" either. I'm willing to withdraw this ''if'' the substance and the weight sourcing are transferred onto his mayoralty — but until that actually happens, nothing present in ''this'' version of the article qualifies him to keep it ''now""" Deletion of Hal Parrish WP:ROUTINE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17743 10145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spygate User:Cube 02:01, 6 February 2008 (UTC) comment The last two sentances make me question, is this a nomination? ''This article is not necessary if we wish to bury truth and justice.'' seems like someone has another motive. Forgive me if i'm mistaken. (Full disclosure I voted delete on the first AFD, but I understand conensus went the other way and I respect the community's choice Deletion of Spygate WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
17744 17669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dire Wolf Digital User:Zxcvbnm 02:02, 14 October 2017 (UTC) delete The vast majority of coverage on the studio was when they opened, but it fails . Most of the other articles mentioning them are predominantly about Elder Scrolls Legends, not the studio itself. applies here Deletion of Dire Wolf Digital WP:SUSTAINED||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
17745 1817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kermit Roosevelt III (2nd nomination) User:Russ 23:14, 16 August 2020 (UTC) comment Some more reviews towards a likely case. Popular books: https://www.publishersweekly.com/978-1-941393-30-7https://aux.avclub.com/kermit-roosevelt-in-the-shadow-of-the-law-1798200803https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/kermit-roosevelt/allegiance-roosevelt/https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/kermit-roosevelt/in-the-shadow-of-the-law/?page=76https://www.jstor.org/stable/40041505https://www.jstor.org/stable/40042023. Legal books: https://www.jstor.org/stable/27558027 Deletion of Kermit Roosevelt III (2nd nomination) WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17746 3576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013 Atlantic Sun Conference men's soccer season User:GiantSnowman 15:13, 4 March 2018 (UTC) delete unsourced, no evidence of notability ( failure Deletion of 2013 Atlantic Sun Conference men's soccer season WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17747 3169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myra Greene User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:01, 26 November 2008 (UTC) keep per meeting the |general notability guidelines Deletion of Myra Greene WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17748 13041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valeri Lilov (2nd nomination) User:Glenfarclas 15:11, 19 July 2010 (UTC) delete """again. """"Tiger"""" Lilov ''really'' seems to want a Wikipedia page to help sell his chess tutoring (oh, you thought his """"lectures"""" and """"broadcast"""" were free?). As the nom points out, the references are mostly spurious, self-published, and primary sources like rankings which don't show anything. A 2007 Bulgarian web article about a chess tournament doesn't exactly cut it to meet """ Deletion of Valeri Lilov (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17749 8471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen William Boyd User:David 21:35, 15 September 2012 (UTC) comment """The current detail-free state of the article would seem to invite speedy deletion under A7. But among his publications, """"Heritage tourism"""" has 283 citations in Google scholar, """"Managing ecotourism: an opportunity spectrum approach"""" has 168, etc. To me this indicates that he may pass #C1. I'm only holding off on a keep !vote because I don't think we can have an article without some sort of reliable sources that allow us to say something nontrivial about the subject, and those aren't present in the article as it stands""" Deletion of Stephen William Boyd WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17750 13954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Epic Western User:MichaelQSchmidt 23:09, 20 December 2012 (UTC) merge """for now to Western (genre)#Film... but as the topic of |""""Epic Western"""" is emminently sourcable and IS covered in multiple sources,https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Epic+Western%22&tbm=nws&tbs=ar:1https://www.google.com/search?tbs=bks:1&q=%22Epic+Western%22http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22Epic+Western%22 let the redirect be without prejudice toward a recreation of a far better and more comprehensive article which could/would cover the subject in literature and film""" Deletion of Epic Western WP:NRVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17751 12115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people by name (2nd nomination) User:Eluchil404 10:22, 5 January 2007 (UTC) delete per JzG way up above. The comment by Wikikiwi is also perceptive in the comparison to a telephone directory. But that is something |Wikipedia is not Deletion of List of people by name (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17752 4660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shahroz Education System Saroke User:Spiderone 12:18, 10 November 2018 (UTC) delete clear failure of Deletion of Shahroz Education System Saroke WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17753 7987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cognitive closure (psychology) User:Edison 04:07, 17 June 2008 (UTC) delete This is not a dictionary. The term fails Deletion of Cognitive closure (psychology) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17754 18182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebecca Wallace-Segall User:RayAYang 18:12, 3 May 2013 (UTC) merge to Writopia. It does seem to fail at the moment, but I see no need to delete the article and its history, since this is probably a case of NOTYET and a handy redirect target is available Deletion of Rebecca Wallace-Segall WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
17755 2491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Frangou User:Binksternet 12:58, 6 July 2015 (UTC) delete This article has been deleted five times as Chris Frangou. See the previous discussion at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Frangou. Fails Deletion of Christopher Frangou WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17756 8503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inez Palange [[User talk:24.151.116.12|talk]]) 18:48, 23 January 2018 (UTC) keep as satisfying per the references now at the article. Special:Contributions/24.151.116.12|24.151.116.12 Deletion of Inez Palange WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17757 5687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kate Addo User:HeyitsRay 14:50, 7 July 2021 (UTC) keep the subject of the article has been quoted in multiple independent, reliable and newsworthy publications ''https://www.ghanaiantimes.com.gh/parliament-sensitive-to-public-concern-over-new-parliament-chamber-kate-addo Ghanian Times'',''https://starrfm.com.gh/2021/04/orphanage-homes-should-be-safe-haven-for-children-duo-concept-appeals Star Fm'',''https://www.modernghana.com/news/808121/gij-alumna-returns-to-mentor-current-students.html Modern Ghana'' because of her role as the Director of Public Affairs of the Parliament of Ghana. Addo is an individual of public interest and as such should not fail and Deletion of Kate Addo WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17758 385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Northeast District Student Council User:Littleteddy 11:52, 6 March 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Northeast District Student Council WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17759 19068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Genesis of a nemesis User:Doc 12:36, 2 January 2008 (UTC) delete """only Google hits I get for """"Kwest"""" are for Kanye West, another (solo) rappe (named """"Kwest tha Madd Lad"""") and for the sign on the cover of David Bowie's The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust, otherwise they're NN and don't meet , article is orphaned""" Deletion of Genesis of a nemesis WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17760 10522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lacine Cherif User:GiantSnowman 13:52, 4 June 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Lacine Cherif WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17761 336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethem User:Anupam 06:44, 21 April 2010 (UTC) keep per . Thanks Deletion of Ethem WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17762 12510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Landover Baptist Church (2) User:Allefant 19:03, 18 October 2007 (UTC) keep http://www.theforce.net/jedicouncil/editorials/070999.asp One other article I found on google news and which can be read for free is from TheForce.Net. So together with the pay-per-view articles and the book, should pass Deletion of Landover Baptist Church (2) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
17763 18458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tori index User:Mark 19:42, 22 November 2013 (UTC) delete The main claim to notability for this bibliometric is usage by the major database Astrophysics Data System. This database is undoubtedly a reliable secondary source, but at present, it is the only one. I've been unable to find a second source; an APS blog doesn't count as reliable for me. This may fall under ; not enough time has elapsed for notability to develop. This doesn't preclude the development of a bibliometrics section in the Astrophysics Data System article to discuss this and https://github.com/adsabs/adsabs-pages/blob/master/help/metricsdefs.md other metrics used at ADS. No prejudice to recreation when multiple in depth reliable sources become available Deletion of Tori index WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
17764 3552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Comics Journal interview subjects User:Otto4711 12:48, 27 March 2007 (UTC) comment First, to the person who's accusing me of colluding with Harlan Ellison, rest assured that I have no knowledge of said suit. The lawsuit or lack of same has nothing to do with this nomination and the notion that a lawsuit could somehow be influenced by the existence or non-existence of a list of interview subjects is ludicrous. Second, I have explained the reason for the nomination, which is that #DIR|Wikipedia is not a directory. That a number of people were interviewed by the same publication does not create the sort of association that would warrant an article. Compliance with , which is a guideline and not policy, is irrelevant if the list itself fails , which is policy. Third, |It's useful is an incredibly poor reason for keeping an article. All sorts of things that all sorts of people find useful get deleted off Wikipedia every day. Finally, is also a horrible reason for keeping an article. If other articles which don't meet Wikipedia policy and guidelines exist, then the proper response to them is to deleted them, not to point to them in an attempt to save other non-compliant articles Deletion of List of Comics Journal interview subjects WP:NOT||WP:LIST||WP:NOT||WP:USEFUL||WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17765 18792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tristan Pollock User:AuthorAuthor 18:13, 8 December 2019 (UTC) delete per nom. This has the look and feel of a paid promo. No significant coverage of the subject can be found. Sorely fails Deletion of Tristan Pollock WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17766 6992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Optomechatronics User:XOR 21:05, 26 August 2018 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Optomechatronics WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
17767 5789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Gill, M.D. user:jfrank1 NONE comment """I created this page because David asked me to and someone not affiliated with the campaign or David continues to edit it. David certainly does meet the second bullet point on which by the way states """"This is not intended to be an exclusionary list. Just because someone doesn't fall into one of these categories doesn't mean an article on the person should automatically be deleted."""" You can't make it more clear than that. Whoever you are, I'd appreciate it if you'd stop this witch hunt. If you have problems with David, he'd be happy to discuss them with you- davidgill@gill2006.com As for the name of the article, there already was an article titled David Gill, so I needed something to distinguish the two and MD is what came to mind. Any particulare reason it should be changed? As for verifing that Doc donates blood, I didn't even know that until he told me himself. If you really want me to, I can have him contact the blood bank and post the record on the website or something""" Deletion of David Gill, M.D. WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17768 17781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joomdle User:Gongshow 20:45, 27 May 2013 (UTC) delete I'm unable to find evidence that the subject meets , , , etc Deletion of Joomdle WP:GNG||WP:NSOFT||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
17769 14587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/India and state sponsored terrorism user:Surajt88 03:52, 8 August 2012 (UTC) delete Agree with DS here. I have been trying to improve the article for a few days now and in my opinion, has very little to no scope for improvement other than removal of 90% of the content which is either |original research or |misrepresented content woven to allege India of supporting terrorism. The remaining content would be a bunch of unfounded allegations by Pakistan supported by |self published sources. A further websearch has revealed nothing but further allegations by Pakistan from unreliable sources Deletion of India and state sponsored terrorism WP:OR||WP:SYNTH||WP:SPS Wikipedia:No original research 65
17770 12773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of the founders of religious traditions User:E 18:23, 26 August 2018 (UTC) delete """per . The """"facts"""" in the table are things like: Death; Moses: ''""""Natural death (age c. 120)""""''that we cover on other more appropriate pages. I do not doubt the significance of Bahá'u'lláh's """"Vision of the Maid of Heaven"""", or of Joseph Smith's """"First Vision, where God the Father and the Son appeared to Smith as a young boy."""" But comparing cherry-picked items from disparate scriptural traditions and arranging them in a table is a work of pure that is NOT ENCYCLOPEDIC""" Deletion of Comparison of the founders of religious traditions WP:OR||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
17771 12518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Smegma (band) User:Cyrus 17:50, 20 April 2007 (UTC) comment They may have been mainstream, but without any sources, that remains |unverified. I'll abstain for now, but I want to see sources before I vote to keep. I'm too young to know if this band was legitimate or not Deletion of Smegma (band) WP:VERIFIABILITY Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17772 17379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nurzaidi Bunari User:Hhhhhkohhhhh 10:56, 2 January 2018 (UTC) delete Fail Deletion of Nurzaidi Bunari WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17773 18078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Justin Bieber's hair User:NellieBly 19:40, 10 April 2011 (UTC) keep and God help us. His haircut is the subject of articles published in numerous reliable sources. The Hollywood Reporter, a trade magazine for the entertainment industry: http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/justin-biebers-haircut-was-calculated-160153. The London Evening Standard: http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/showbiz/article-23926438-justin-biebers-haircut-costs-him-80000-fans.do. The Toronto Star, for heaven's sake http://www.thestar.com/entertainment/article/922888--justin-bieber-has-a-new-haircut. I'm afraid the hair actually passes Deletion of Justin Bieber's hair WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17774 9914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kingdom of Elleore User:Horologium 03:20, 7 January 2012 (UTC) comment """The article has been expanded and additional """"sources"""" (and I use the term loosely) have been added. The problem is that almost every source is based on a single book—''Micro Nations: The Lonely Planet Guide to Home-Made Nations''. There is the book itself, a review of the book in ''The Australian'', and a page on the personal website of one of the authors of the book. The review of the book only has a single sentence relating to Elleore, which is nowhere near enough to qualify as """"significant coverage"""". (Another review of the same book, cited above but not in the article, is equally vague as it relates to Elleore, and it's a review from a self-described """"citizen-journalist and social media"""" site.) That leaves one other source, which is a one paragraph mention in a list of European micronations. requires """"significant coverage"""", and we only have a single source with in-depth coverage of the article, the book. Multiple sources are expected (as per ), and Wikipedia:N#cite_note-2|footnote 3 from the notability guideline is particularly relevant here: ''""""Lack of multiple sources suggests that the topic may be more suitable for inclusion in an article on a broader topic. It is common for multiple newspapers or journals to publish the same story, sometimes with minor alterations or different headlines, but one story does not constitute multiple works. Several journals simultaneously publishing different articles does not always constitute multiple works, especially when the authors are relying on the same sources, and merely restating the same information. Similarly, a series of publications by the same author or in the same periodical is normally counted as one source.""""'' Heavy reliance on a single book does not make for a strong argument to retain this article""" Deletion of Kingdom of Elleore WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17775 20375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saša Lozar User:Ron 00:04, 18 May 2010 (UTC) merge The article is a |BLP Deletion of Saša Lozar WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17776 18589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swings-N-Things User:Jayron32 03:41, 28 June 2009 (UTC) delete per nominator. I can't find any sign of the depth-of-coverage as required at guidelines for inclusion Deletion of Swings-N-Things WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17777 926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig B. Johnson User:TonyTheTiger 19:46, 19 April 2017 (UTC) delete fails , and Deletion of Craig B. Johnson WP:GNG||WP:N||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
17778 14378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Metaledge Records User:Esradekan 12:25, 13 August 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per . Searching finds no significant coverage in |reliable, third-party, sources Deletion of Metaledge Records WP:CORP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17779 10309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skankin' Pickle (album) User:Satori 15:00, 31 March 2010 (UTC) delete """as insufficiently notable per #Songs. No evidence this demo tape has received """"''significant independent coverage in reliable sources""" Deletion of Skankin' Pickle (album) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17780 4979 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manuel Jalón Corominas NONE NONE keep There are multiple, reliable sources presented in the article. These sources include the state-owned, public broadcaster RTVE and the 125-years old newspaper Heraldo de Aragón. Besides passing , the subject also meets , receiving honors in the city of Zaragoza, and in the town of Trasmoz Deletion of Manuel Jalón Corominas WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17781 16741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayo School of Astrology User:SynergeticMaggot 04:50, 10 July 2006 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Mayo School of Astrology WP:NN||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
17782 18273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PennSix (band) User:ShadowHalo 00:25, 9 February 2007 (UTC) delete Lack of third-party coverage, fails Deletion of PennSix (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17783 3725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TOMS SHOES (2nd nomination) User:MichaelQSchmidt 18:23, 7 April 2009 (UTC) keep as meeting per provided sources and then send to to remove sense of advert Deletion of TOMS SHOES (2nd nomination) WP:CORP||WP:CLEANUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17784 128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Van (band) User:Champion 06:58, 8 August 2018 (UTC) keep Meets as a band that has charted. Note that is 1) not policy; and 2) not a reason for deletion Deletion of Van (band) WP:NMUSIC||WP:PERMASTUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
17785 2978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Life As A Teenage Robot: The Movie User:Joe 04:13, 15 August 2009 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of My Life As A Teenage Robot: The Movie WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17786 7163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cool Apocalypse User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:38, 2 June 2015 (UTC) delete for a return when this gets analysis and commentary in multiple reliable sources. It has screened and received peer recognition through awards, but still needs a bit more coverage. Okay with it being returned to its author as a user draft. It's simply a bit |TOO SOON. But {{ping|Michaelgsmith}} as it appears from username that you might be its writer/director Michael Glover Smith, I wish to advise that while does not absolutely forbid you writing about your own project here, because of a personal connection with the project it is strongly discouraged Deletion of Cool Apocalypse WP:NYF||WP:COI Wikipedia:Too soon 40
17787 20706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vilayna Lasalle User:Optimale 11:16, 21 October 2009 (UTC) keep """In my opinion she passes the """"Significant coverage"""" part of (see links given in the previous comment by MichaelQSchmidt""" Deletion of Vilayna Lasalle WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17788 18042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chikkajala User:PratyushSinha101 17:46, 13 December 2017 (UTC) keep as a recognized populated place, the subject passes Deletion of Chikkajala WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17789 13807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bigamy (canon law) user:Andrew 12:00, 15 January 2021 (UTC) keep """I do not see the point of this nomination. All our content is expected to be found elsewhere. By bringing topics into Wikipedia, there are mechanical advantages as the topics are then easier to access index and cross-link. And we are then able to update the topics to improve them by incorporating later changes and findings. This topic is no different and so our policy applies: """"''If editing can improve the page, this should be done rather than deleting the page""" Deletion of Bigamy (canon law) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
17790 68 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Absition User:Petr 23:07, 7 January 2016 (UTC) delete Absition at least describes an application and according to the table below we have 3 articles on absement fulfilling criteria (although not many more such sources exist). The others (absity...) are just definitions without suggesting why such quantity should be considered Deletion of Absition WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17791 8907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alireza Haghighi (physician) User:Xxanthippe 01:44, 24 February 2010 (UTC) delete Does not pass rof and political activities do not seem sufficient Deletion of Alireza Haghighi (physician) WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
17792 11748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Special Purpose User:Bcasterline 18:55, 22 February 2006 (UTC) delete per . Some Google hits http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&safe=off&q=%22The+Special+Purpose%22+Seattle: it looks like they've had a few shows and have scheduled a few more in the Seattle area, but nothing notable Deletion of The Special Purpose WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17793 21016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ProjectInsight NONE NONE comment I am a contributor to the article. The following references have been added to better illustrate the |notability of ProjectInsight|Project Insight Deletion of ProjectInsight WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17794 6160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Christian User:Metropolitan90 03:30, 5 June 2007 (UTC) keep Pitcairn Island is not an independent country, but it is a dependency of its own -- one of about 70 that has its own entry in the CIA World Factbook. It's also the subject of international public attention due to its connection to the Mutiny on the Bounty and its status as (I think) the least populous dependency with a permanent resident population. So Steve Christian, as Pitcairn's head of government, would arguably have qualified for an article under even before he became the subject of a criminal investigation. But the Pitcairn sexual assault trial of 2004 made the news ''worldwide''; I was able to find articles about him through a Google search from every continent except Antarctica. See http://news.independent.co.uk/world/australasia/article30472.ece, http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/6323696/ for example. To delete the article about Steve Christian -- a head of government who was convicted of rape and sentenced to three years in prison -- in hopes of maintaining his privacy would be a misapplication of Deletion of Steve Christian WP:BIO||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17795 18113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Easter Tekafa User:Mentoz86 17:53, 20 October 2012 (UTC) delete as a footballer he fails as he hasn't played in a |fully pro league or represented his country at senior level. As a futsal-player he fails as he hasn't participated in a major international amateur or professional competition at the highest level such as the Olympics. Also fails due to lack of coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Easter Tekafa WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:FPL||WP:NSPORTS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17796 11843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stock trading terms [[User talk:Triplestop|'''Triplestop''']] [[Special:Contributions/Triplestop|x3]] 02:05, 11 August 2009 (UTC) delete This article appears to be Deletion of Stock trading terms WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17797 13883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Connor Cruise User:Gene93k 20:01, 4 November 2008 (UTC) delete per . Fails WP:ENTERTAINER and relations don't confer notability. All coverage falls back on the People Magazine story about a bit part in a movie Deletion of Connor Cruise WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17798 13572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Great White Brotherhood User:Fireplace 18:14, 14 December 2007 (UTC) comment The question is whether the subject meets the standard of significant coverage from reliable sources that are independent of the subject. It's possible such coverage exists, but the current sources provided in the article do not meet that standard Deletion of Great White Brotherhood WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17799 18996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miscellaneous technology of Command & Conquer User:Gamer007 09:29, 25 April 2007 (UTC) keep I feel this complies with point #2. While it is relatively minor overall, it is has an important part in the series (much like the pages on GDI and Nod technology Deletion of Miscellaneous technology of Command & Conquer WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17800 8945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Kingsley User:MartinDK 22:26, 13 November 2006 (UTC) delete per . Looks like an autobiography Deletion of Daniel Kingsley WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17801 15821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Grierson [[User talk:180.172.239.231|talk]]) 15:16, 24 August 2014 (UTC) keep Meets .(Has had significant roles in multiple notable films, ''television shows'', stage performances, or other productions.)--Special:Contributions/180.172.239.231|180.172.239.231 Deletion of David Grierson WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17802 8456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Spiess Company User:TonyTheTiger 12:02, 26 July 2016 (UTC) delete all the coverage seems to be local. If there are any articles about this company from out of state, then I might support a Deletion of Joseph Spiess Company WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17803 19063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murders of Margaret and Seana Tapp NONE NONE comment """As noted above, these links are not WP:SIGCOV of the crime. states """"media coverage can confer notability on a high-profile criminal act, provided such coverage meets the above guidelines"""" (referring to ). The links in this discussion do not meet criteria in """ Deletion of Murders of Margaret and Seana Tapp WP:NCRIME||WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17804 5000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhythm Method (a cappella group) User:Moswento 07:30, 20 April 2010 (UTC) comment That is not a valid argument, as articles are judged on individual merit, and a capella groups must currently be judged under Wikipedia notability guidelines per . You could always nominate the other groups' articles for deletion, if you feel they fail notability guidelines, although Emocapella seem to have some claim to notability in terms of press coverage Deletion of Rhythm Method (a cappella group) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17805 12668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danger Angel User:TenPoundHammer 18:00, 4 August 2010 (UTC) delete """all the sources are unreliable or primary. And the next person who uses another Wikipedia article as a """"reference"""" will be promptly ed. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Special:Contributions/TenPoundHammer|Many otters • :User talk:TenPoundHammer|One bat""" Deletion of Danger Angel WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Whacking with a wet trout 74
17806 1662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giovanni Battista Armenini User:FreeRangeFrog 00:17, 28 December 2012 (UTC) keep Author of a notable historical book about painting. Meets and . The book is important enough to be included in the virtual library of the Istituto Nazionale di Studi sul Rinascimento (the Italian National Institute for the study of the Renaissance) http://bivio.filosofia.sns.it/bvWorkTOC.php?authorSign=ArmeniniGiovanBattista&titleSign=DeVeriPrecettiDellaPittura, and 23 editions of its English translation are held by more than 350 libraries http://www.worldcat.org/title/on-the-true-precepts-of-the-art-of-painting/oclc/003169161 worldwide. A case of perhaps the book being more notable than the author, so no prejudice to a move to On the true precepts of the art of painting, leaving a redirect behind and incorporating the author's bio. However, even with the primary sources (and heck, this is the 15th century after all) I think a standalone bio is merited Deletion of Giovanni Battista Armenini WP:AUTHOR||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17807 17348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryon Cook User:Cbl62 12:40, 4 May 2021 (UTC) delete Does not qualify under . Moreover, his Division III collegiate career (summarized https://www.bwyellowjackets.com/sports/fball/2015-16/bios/cook_bryon_sb79 here - 27 catches for 400 yards in his best season) doesn't include the types of accomplishments that qualify under . Finally, my searches did not turn up of the type needed to pass Deletion of Bryon Cook WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:NCOLLATH||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17808 28 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RockON.me User:Rhododendrites 08:00, 14 January 2015 (UTC) delete Possible just but, for now, there are insufficient sources to meet . --&mdash Deletion of RockON.me WP:TOOSOON||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Too soon 40
17809 17333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aputheatre User:Phil 12:41, 16 November 2007 (UTC) comment I think this article may be redeemable. Notability is certainly ''asserted''. I don't know if there are any particular notability guidelines for theatre companies, but by analogy with the #Criteria for musicians and ensembles|guidelines for bands the fact that this company has toured nationally and internationally should be enough to make them notable, if it is verifiable. There seems to be an attempt to provide a reference: ''“A significant shift in Aids Theatre” - (Plays and Players May 1990)'', although it is not wikified. It's unclear whether this is supposed to apply to the preceding or the succeding text. If the reference does confirm that this company toured as stated then the article should be kept Deletion of Aputheatre WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17810 2526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geneva Manifesto User:Kusma 01:17, 21 November 2015 (UTC) keep or '''merge to Infante Juan, Count of Barcelona'''. The nominator deserves a for assuming that references linking back into an article are evidence of a hoax - particularly when the links go to an entry in the article's Bibliography section which gives full bibliographical details of the referenced work, complete with a working ISBN link. As Deletion of Geneva Manifesto WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Whacking with a wet trout 74
17811 113 [[Sechsundfünfzig]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Micha L. Rieser 20:35, 27. Apr. 2008 (CEST) keep denn exisiteren tut es -> http://www.pagat.com/jass/56.html. Und relevant ist es gemäss Zitat: „in einem Kulturkreis besonders herausragend vorkommen oder dies historisch einmal waren“. Und reine Spielanleitung ist kein Löschgrund, sonst müsste man fast die lesenwerten Artikel Königrufen oder Schere, Stein, Papier ja schnelllöschen :-) - Ps. Und man darf anstelle eines LAs auch ein einfaches {{QS-Spiele}} rein tun. Ihr dürft mir glauben, wir kümmern uns gerne darum ;-) und es versumpft dort auch nicht, wie bei der normalen QS Löschung von Sechsundfünfzig Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
17812 4766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of scientists opposing the mainstream scientific assessment of global warming (3rd nomination) User:John 09:33, 26 October 2009 (UTC) delete """It is quite a stretch to apply a single stereotypical """"List of scientists opposing the mainstream scientific assessment of global warming"""" to a group who holds a wide variety of opinions on a wide spectrum of """"opposition"""" (as opposed to disagreement--a quite different issue even the title is blatantly ) with ''certain'' scientific assessments. Many of the scientists support """"other"""" mainstream and peer-reviewed scientific assessments. Claiming it's a ''majority-held'' scientific viewpoint might be debated (and is in separate WP articles, but that's not the phrase the title uses. It is useless to try to stuff a cadre of scientists into a one-size-fits-all title like this one. What I think the current discussion will illustrate is how it is impossible to delete articles once inserted regardless of how tenuous the proposition it purports to try to address. Might as well call it """"List of scientists supporting different scientific assessments of global warming""""--at least that one doesn't require an OR/POV personal definition of terms""" Deletion of List of scientists opposing the mainstream scientific assessment of global warming (3rd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
17813 19281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scream Four User:Useight 15:49, 13 August 2007 (UTC) delete Violation of . Create article when more information becomes available Deletion of Scream Four WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17814 14140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thunder Collins User:Location 00:39, 23 November 2009 (UTC) delete Judging the spirit of , I think he fails. He wasn't notable as a football player and he isn't notable as a criminal. (Criminal charges prior to the murder here: http://www.usatoday.com/sports/college/football/big12/2003-07-02-collins-arrested_x.htm). The two together give him a fair amount of uninteresting news coverage Deletion of Thunder Collins WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17815 8917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sector7seven User:Lemongirl942 06:06, 29 July 2016 (UTC) delete As our notability standards have got stricter over the years, this no longer satisfied GNG or Deletion of Sector7seven WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17816 14799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bell Tower Falls User:GB 19:48, 3 October 2009 (UTC) delete no significant coverage in |reliable sources that I could find. If reliable sources cover this band in the future recreate the article then Deletion of Bell Tower Falls WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17817 18313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zodiac (computer game) User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable. &mdash Deletion of Zodiac (computer game) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17818 204 [[Markus Voeth]] (erl.) Benutzer:Uwe Gille NONE keep Ordentlicher Artikel, erfüllt Löschung von Markus Voeth Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
17819 10580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UCIP (2nd nomination) [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 21:32, 18 June 2007 (UTC) delete both under as likely hoaxes. Also see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United Confederation of Interstellar Planets. -- Deletion of UCIP (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17820 15803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stereotypes of Arabs and Muslims User:Shirahadasha 01:44, 6 February 2007 (UTC) comment """While the general decision to split up stereotyping content into various """"Stereotypes of..."""" articles may or may not have been a good one, once the general decision was made, lots of individual """"Stereotypes of..."""" articles follow, and it makes no sense to try to rehash the general decision by picking a few off individually and leaving the rest. The article could stand improvement, but the existence of stereotypes is |notable from common knowledge. That said, it's questionable whether """"Arabs and Muslims"""" should be combined, since the latter is a much larger group than the former""" Deletion of Stereotypes of Arabs and Muslims WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17821 21928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Wassong (2nd nomination) User:Forest90 14:16, 21 July 2019 (UTC) delete the Article because it is not notable and also fail Deletion of Kevin Wassong (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17822 198 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ismet Saz Kullanıcı:ravagesravages 15.03, 9 Şubat 2020 (UTC) delete """Kayda değer olduğunu gösterir tarafsız, bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynaklar bulunmuyor. Var olan kaynaklar genellikle birincil kaynaklardan elde edilmiş biyografi, sahibi olduğu mekânlar, yaptığı yemekler, verdiği hizmetin kalitesi gibi """"blog"""" niteliğinde kaynaklar ve haber sitelerinden oluşuyor. Şu aşamada KD olduğunu düşünmüyorum. Katılmış olduğu TV programları (MasterChef Türkiye'ye konuk olmuş ve geçen sene Show TV'de Lezzet Akademisi adında bir programda jürilik yapmış), |kişiler için kayda değerlik kriterlerinden biri olan """"Kişinin adının kanıtlanabilir şekilde yaygınca tanınmış olması"""" kriterini karşılıyor denebilir. Fakat gerek güvenilir kaynak bulunmaması, gerekse bahsettiğim kriterin tek başına kayda değerliği sağlayamayabileceği gerçeği nedeniyle KD olmadığını düşünüyor, silinmesi yönünde oy kullanıyorum""" İsmet Saz'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
17823 5120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ted Frank User:MCB 21:16, 26 August 2007 (UTC) keep """I am somewhat puzzled by the existence of this AfD, and some of the """"delete"""" votes and comments. I tend to have a resaonably high bar for notability, but this person clearly meets without much serious argument, both from the article and its sources, and from a cursory examination of media mentions and authorship of widely-read material. While I assume good faith in the nomination, I suspect that a lot of the deletion arguments are based on Wikipedia politics, and that has no place here at all""" Deletion of Ted Frank WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17824 17942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/L.A. Percussion Rentals User:Besieged 18:37, 14 November 2012 (UTC) merge into Emil Richards Fails , a company is not notable because it is owned by someone notable or because notable people have worked/performed or simply been there:(CORP#Decisions_based_on_verifiable_evidence|notability is neither inherent nor inherited Deletion of L.A. Percussion Rentals WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17825 16687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mobicure User:Justlettersandnumbers 17:51, 16 July 2019 (UTC) delete per above. Despite the claims of solving the world's health problems with technology, it seems that this company actually has two apps for health-related social chat. According to https://www.aaas.org/tech-i/mobicure the American Association for the Advancement of Science, one of them has been downloaded 2000 times and is used by 500 people. Those are not high numbers. I see no indication that could be met Deletion of Mobicure WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17826 21881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marina Osman User:Les 10:53, 26 November 2017 (UTC) keep Please kindly indicate the informations to be sourced. I believe this is unfounded as 'To place a BLPPROD tag, the process requires that the article contain no sources in any form (as references, external links, etc.) which support any statements made about the person in the biography. (see )' This decision seems arbitrary and has no apparent motivations. This action is against the policy for the deletion of biographical articles (see ). I request an immediate remediation to this problem Deletion of Marina Osman WP:BLPPROD||WP:BLPPROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion of biographies of living people 66
17827 18333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Calamba Medical Center User:Koridas 07:59, 14 November 2020 (UTC) delete There is nothing significant about it. It kinda fails because it's just like any other hospital in the Phillipines, or in this case, the world Deletion of Calamba Medical Center WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
17828 18779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silent Hill influences and trivia (2nd nomination) User:DarkSaber2k 15:14, 29 June 2007 (UTC) comment I hope that isn't meant as the |other stuff exists argument Deletion of Silent Hill influences and trivia (2nd nomination) WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17829 21736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Chip 'n' Dale merchandise User:Ajf773 19:28, 21 February 2018 (UTC) delete per . Wikipedia is not a product database Deletion of List of Chip 'n' Dale merchandise WP:NOTCATALOGUE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17830 15521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/First Battle of Beruna User:TTN 13:59, 30 January 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of First Battle of Beruna WP:GNG||WP:NOTPLOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17831 19398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Razorback Records User:JamesBurns 23:59, 15 December 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability, as per Deletion of Razorback Records WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17832 1484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reynold Xin (2nd nomination) User:David 20:42, 11 September 2016 (UTC) delete He's not really an academic, but looking at his citation record https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=X22nUYgAAAAJ he has some highly cited papers, but a relatively low h-index. I think this is an indication more that this is an especially high-citation area within CS, and less something that could be used to pass #C1. His current position in industry makes a more appropriate notability criterion but the case there is also weak Deletion of Reynold Xin (2nd nomination) WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17833 21519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Namiq Yusifov User:Sir 16:25, 8 October 2014 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Namiq Yusifov WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17834 255 [[Schulische Disziplin]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Logograph 18:28, 15. Jul. 2015 (CEST) delete """Unrettbarer Laber-Essay, Verstoß gg , Punkt 4. Zu fast jeder Aussage ließe sich das Gegenteil behaupten. Ob die Stichworte Schwarze Pädagogik und Antiautoritäre Erziehung nicht vorkommen, weil mans eben vergessen hat oder weil dann der Artikel von 20.000 auf 40.000 Bytes anschwellen würde, steht dahin. Notgedrungen höchst-willkürliche 10 Literaturangaben aus rund 200.000 möglichen zu diesem Thema. Unfreiwillige Komik ist ebenfalls vorprogrammiert: """"allgegenwärtige Lehrer haben auch hinten Augen"""", glaubte man 1976. Und das neueste Zitat: """"Es ist gut, dass Sie ein bisschen streng sind. Viele liebe Grüsse Melanie."""" Findet Ihr das nicht ein bisschen ''schlüpfrig''? - Kurioses Brainstorming""" Löschung von Schulische Disziplin Wikipedia:Was Wikipedia nicht ist Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17835 13024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LOLCODE (2nd nomination) User:Umbralcorax 13:48, 9 September 2009 (UTC) keep Article's sources show it easily meets the Deletion of LOLCODE (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17836 17388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Jason Dominus (4th nomination) User:Dominus 14:13, 7 October 2016 (UTC) comment I am the subject of the article, which has survived three previous deletion discussions with strong consensus for “keep”. The proposal to delete claims that I wrote the article and edited it heavily; both of these claims are easily seen to be false. Wikipedia's |policy on notability of authors says “The person has created … a significant or well-known work. Such work must have been the primary subject … of multiple independent periodical articles or reviews.” Higher-Order Perl meets this standard Deletion of Mark Jason Dominus (4th nomination) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17837 18751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/House Full (film) User:LeaveSleaves 17:06, 19 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails . Filming is expected to start in http://www.starboxoffice.com/newsDetails.aspx?xfile=2009/January/News_20090116_136 May or http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/3991823.cms June '09. By the way, there's another Telugu B-grade film with the same title possibly http://entertainment.oneindia.in/telugu/top-stories/2009/housefull-film-industry-190109.html under production. ''Special:Contributions/LeaveSleaves|Leave Deletion of House Full (film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17838 21331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/East Magazine User:Otolemur 16:57, 31 March 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of East Magazine WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17839 18712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thamaraiyin Sondhangal User:Karthikndr 13:08, 14 September 2011 (UTC) keep The film has been confirmed by http://www.behindwoods.com/tamil-movie-news-1/sep-11-02/vijay-praksh-thamarai-13-09-11.html reliable source and is currently under production stage, hence must be kept again as per . If single source is a problem, please wait for few more days. If still it doesn't work, i will blank the page and you can '''delete it Deletion of Thamaraiyin Sondhangal WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17840 1568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Serbophobia (fourth nomination) User:Aldux 23:31, 28 December 2006 (UTC) delete this article is nothing more than and its deletion was almost unanimously supported by the board when the question was brought to the /I Deletion of Serbophobia (fourth nomination) WP:OR||WP:AN Wikipedia:No original research 65
17841 13840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Osama bin Laden conspiracy theories [[User talk:143.105.11.99|talk]]) — [[Special:Contributions/143.105.11.99|143.105.11.99]] ([[User talk:143.105.11.99|talk]]) has made [[Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|few or no other edits]] outside this topic. 14:42, 4 May 2011 (UTC) keep per . --Special:Contributions/143.105.11.99|143.105.11.99 Deletion of Death of Osama bin Laden conspiracy theories WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17842 4595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katherine Monbiot User:Wee 12:11, 11 August 2018 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet , nothing more than anecdotal coverage in sources Deletion of Katherine Monbiot WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17843 17080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alpha Omega (game) User:NeoChaosX 17:08, 22 September 2007 (UTC) delete """as Wikipedia's not a tool to promote your upcoming game. """"Little to no media attention"""" likely means no coverage in |reliable sources, meaning it doesn't meet the guidelines for |notability""" Deletion of Alpha Omega (game) WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17844 21936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saoirse McHugh User:Lefcentreright 09:20, 8 April 2020 (UTC) delete Fails as she is an unelected candidate Deletion of Saoirse McHugh WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
17845 18489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harpy (Puyo Puyo) User:Ningauble 15:15, 10 September 2008 (UTC) delete Article does not indicate any real-world |significance of this #Summary style approach|fictional element Deletion of Harpy (Puyo Puyo) WP:GNG||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17846 3341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rusty trombone (2nd nomination) User:Mallanox 03:28, 7 January 2007 (UTC) keep article doesn't need to have improved since last time as it was a keep result. Surely this is a case? —The preceding Wikipedia:Sign your posts on talk pages|unsigned comment was added by Deletion of Rusty trombone (2nd nomination) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
17847 21510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyler Summitt User:Doctree 02:01, 5 May 2012 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of Tyler Summitt WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
17848 453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bostyn Olivia Smith User:Non 01:07, 3 June 2015 (UTC) delete The subject is probably not notable but even if they were, this page is written in such egregiously promotional language, there's nothing to salvage. This page is absolutely Deletion of Bostyn Olivia Smith WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17849 5310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Datawasp User:Stifle 19:58, 30 April 2008 (UTC) delete unless |citations from |reliable sources are added to comply with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Datawasp WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17850 19093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mikk Reintam User:GiantSnowman 13:28, 26 February 2011 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Mikk Reintam WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17851 4430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wayan Blue User:PJM 19:29, 25 January 2006 (UTC) delete per , based on what I findhttp://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=Wayan+Blue&btnG=Google+Search. The article does make an assertion (co-managing Spun Records & a CD released with 'other artists'), so I don't see it as being eligible for a speedy Deletion of Wayan Blue WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17852 15704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of shortest-lived sovereign states NONE NONE delete I get the votes, but I find it interesting only insofar as it is accurate, and in the absence of reliable sources per , we have no reason to assume that it is accurate Deletion of List of shortest-lived sovereign states WP:INTERESTING||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17853 19173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter James Madden User:Philosopher 19:40, 10 July 2015 (UTC) delete I suspect that he is generally notable, even if he doesn't meet the politician qualification. Unfortunately, notability doesn't matter in this case, as the quality of the article is such that applies. The closer should note that includes no prejudice against recreation. – Deletion of Peter James Madden WP:TNT||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
17854 13331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dorothy Kostrzewa User:SportingFlyer 11:51, 5 November 2018 (UTC) keep it's not a since she has passed, it's not since she has passed, she's been covered in a couple different independent sources about the Chinese community in B.C., and she did get a couple local long form obituaries. This is one of the most marginal !votes I've ever made since she's only a local politician, but I think the diversity of the sources documenting her unique life and career is enough to get her over the line Deletion of Dorothy Kostrzewa WP:BLP1E||WP:PROMO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17855 12237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disney-Pixar Cars Die-Cast Line User:RaptorWiki 21:59, 29 December 2008 (UTC) delete I concur that the article does not meet . There are simply not enough third party sources out there presently. Perhaps in the future. However I do disagree with the reasoning of failure to meet OTCATALOG. I also believe that it fails , '''but''' only as a result of failing , which is a criterion for Deletion of Disney-Pixar Cars Die-Cast Line WP:N||WP:NOTCATALOG||WP:PRODUCT||WP:N||WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17856 12482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gretchen User:Morbidthoughts 21:51, 27 August 2008 (UTC) keep Using babelfish, those portuguese sources seem like reliable sources to verify the general criteria of Deletion of Gretchen WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17857 21273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prabhakar Srinet User:Fitindia 09:34, 27 June 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and has acted in one non-notable movie in a supporting role, strong case for speedy deletion Deletion of Prabhakar Srinet WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17858 13683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oporadhi User:Eggishorn 20:39, 24 June 2020 (UTC) delete """With one exception, all the sources cited are only demonstrating it was highly-ranked in a non-reliable chart that fails . The exception is a source demonstrating the singer was nominated for an award that debatably qualifies as """"significant awards or honors"""", which the singer does not appear to have won. None of this complies with as that standard is written. No obvious merge or redirect target appears to exist""" Deletion of Oporadhi WP:CHARTS||WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Record charts 13
17859 1873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Windows Insider User:Samee 23:43, 24 March 2015 (UTC) keep per . The subject is of public interest Deletion of Windows Insider WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17860 3318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greenbury Ridgely Henry User:Cunard 23:39, 11 February 2011 (UTC) merge The article cites several sources about Greenbury Ridgely Henry that verify the information in the article. Per , a merge/redirect to the society he co-founded is not unreasonable. {{user|John Milito}} has spent much of his time working on these articles. It would be a shame to delete wholesale his hard work. I concur that most of these subjects do not pass Wikipedia:Notability; however, there is no reason not to place several sentences from each of these articles into Phi Alpha Literary Society#Founders Deletion of Greenbury Ridgely Henry WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
17861 1252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Puffy AmiYumi tours User:onel5969 23:14, 28 April 2017 (UTC) delete as per . Any citable info can be merged Deletion of List of Puffy AmiYumi tours WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17862 7421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Knäbel User:Sir 22:56, 18 May 2014 (UTC) keep Clearly passes Deletion of Peter Knäbel WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17863 16805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indonesia top 3 disease burden NONE NONE delete """Thought about this a while; the presentation is so different from anything else in WP that I had a kneejerk reaction to delete. Then I thought about it. I have concerns about copyvio from UptoDate (I don't have access to the subscription so cannot tell). Figures are unsourced, a problem in itself, and are maybe (?) copyvio from the university of washington copyrighted https://vizhub.healthdata.org/gbd-compare/ vizhub site. There appears to pure like """" Despite stroke being the leading cause of death (and increasing with time), there are few references specific to stroke prevention or treatment efforts. Generally speaking, focus on non-communicable disease does not appear at the top of priority lists. One reason for this may be the quality of health services"""".... Not to mention stuff like """"Indonesia 1 is the largest economy in Southeast Asia with nearly 260 million people, but like so many other countries, it has passed into the third stage of the Epidemiological TransitionTransition: The Age of Man-made Diseases. Indonesians must recognize non-communicable diseases as their largest health burden and ensure their health infrastructure can meet the unique and increasing demands resulting from these types of diseases."""" which is """ Deletion of Indonesia top 3 disease burden WP:OR||WP:SOAPBOX Wikipedia:No original research 65
17864 9904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/They Are Billions User:Otr500 06:49, 22 December 2017 (UTC) delete """or alt. '''user draft'''. Definiantly |way too early with only one reference. One of the extra https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2017/12/18/they-are-billions-steampunk-zombie-rts/ sources from above states the game is in an ''initial early access state'' with further developement due in the Spring of 2018. '''Please note''': So there is no confusion; the article is not ready for coverage yet and my alternative to delete, of placing in draft-space, can in no way be construed as to mean """"keep"""" as an article""" Deletion of They Are Billions WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
17865 5940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cradle of Faith User:JNW 21:40, 16 June 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. Whether hoax or non-notable, this is a candidate for . Or feel free to use the rationale I created, Deletion of Cradle of Faith WP:SNOW||WP:LOAP Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
17866 6672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Name Is Khan User:Steve 16:09, 29 January 2008 (UTC) delete The |notability guidelines for future films stipulate that a stand-alone article for a film should not be created until a project enters production. This is because many factors such as budget issues, scripting issues, and casting issues can interfere with the project. Any verifiable information should be placed at the director's article. The film article can be recreated when principal photography is confirmed to have begun Deletion of My Name Is Khan WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17867 8063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Town Needs Guns User:TenPoundHammer 16:48, 29 September 2009 (UTC) keep per Paul Erik, nice save. Sources aren't great, but they're enough to meet . Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Special:Contributions/TenPoundHammer|Many otters • :User talk:TenPoundHammer|One bat Deletion of This Town Needs Guns WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17868 3560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of most-retweeted tweets (2nd nomination) User:Ahiijny 03:40, 17 February 2019 (UTC) keep """Just stumbled across this AfD from googling """"what is the most liked tweet of all time"""". The concept of most retweeted tweets meets . I don't see why the list of most-liked Tweets was deleted either; I'd think that these two would easily meet NLIST, especially for a social media site as popular as Twitter e.g. https://www.euronews.com/2019/01/07/what-are-the-most-retweeted-tweets-of-all-time https://www.theweek.co.uk/98782/the-five-most-popular-tweets-of-all-time https://mashable.com/article/most-retweeted-tweet-billionaire/#7Kf29vErUmqd https://www.businessinsider.com/10-most-liked-tweets-of-all-time-2017-8 https://techacute.com/list-most-liked-tweets/ http://time.com/4263227/most-popular-tweets/). Compare List of most-viewed YouTube videos, List of most-liked YouTube videos (currently also up for AfD), List of most-disliked YouTube videos""" Deletion of List of most-retweeted tweets (2nd nomination) WP:NLIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
17869 20819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willamette Valley Vineyards User:K 06:59, 16 August 2016 (UTC) keep per . A publicly traded company will almost always have sufficient coverage to meet NCOPR. Sources presented at this AfD are compelling Deletion of Willamette Valley Vineyards WP:LISTED Wikipedia:Notability 77
17870 21947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inevitability thesis User:הסרפד 02:28, 9 June 2014 (UTC) comment Perhaps an administrator can tell us whether this qualifies for speedy deletion as |G4—two articles with the same name //en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&page=Inevitability+thesis have previously been deleted Deletion of Inevitability thesis WP:G4 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17871 16464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Young kros User:Joe 00:55, 5 January 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |band Deletion of Young kros WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17872 17314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hohak Band User:Kinu 01:52, 5 February 2006 (UTC) delete Does not satisfy Deletion of Hohak Band WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17873 18689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Feathers User:Just 11:34, 5 November 2005 (UTC) delete per , there appears to be a possibly-notable band called The Feathers, but this isn't it Deletion of The Feathers WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17874 4559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diamond Standard User:SportingFlyer 10:19, 25 November 2019 (UTC) delete this was recently deleted on grounds and I would probably have kept it that way. The sourcing is pretty terrible, fails and Deletion of Diamond Standard WP:G11||WP:PROMO||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17875 874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Galla Aruna Kumari User:Gene93k 17:45, 13 July 2009 (UTC) keep As an MLA, she clearly passes . Other issues are for cleanup, not deletion Deletion of Galla Aruna Kumari WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
17876 15070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of teenage parents User:Flyer22 22:13, 9 July 2013 (UTC) delete """Teenage pregnancy is notable, but the list was a trivial, -violation mess that has also been removed from the Teenage pregnancy article twice (including once by me; see http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Flyer22&diff=563337375&oldid=563337193#Teenage_pregnancy here and/or http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:List_of_teenage_parents&diff=563583132&oldid=563582524 here for backstory with regard to my removal). And titling it """"List of teenage parents,"""" without the word ''famous'' that was included in the title before, leaves the door open for this article to include any non-notable teenage parent that was reported in the news. Sure, the lead currently specifies that the list is """"a partial list of historical figures and modern celebrities who became parents before the age of 20,"""" but that can be easily reworded or removed to widen the scope of the list. Also, the talk page should be kept this time if the article is deleted; it assists the record of the article having been deleted and serves as a record for past discussion about that article""" Deletion of List of teenage parents WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17877 7049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Breadline Cafe User:MB 17:57, 8 December 2019 (UTC) delete """per above. Newspapers.com search only finds minor mentions in ''The Spokesman-Review''. Searching on the long-term tenant of the building, Omak Beverages finds almost nothing (except the Cafe saying they are in the former Omak Beverages building). With coverage of the restaurant and no coverage of the """"historic"""" building, nothing left but delete""" Deletion of Breadline Cafe WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
17878 5474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greece–Venezuela relations User:BlueSquadronRaven 22:57, 6 May 2009 (UTC) delete No secondary sources, no assertion of why this is a notable topic, nothing to back it up with. Fails miserably Deletion of Greece–Venezuela relations WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17879 11991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mandana Seyfeddinipur User:RebeccaGreen 00:46, 20 August 2019 (UTC) keep """I agree that there is evidence that she meets #C7. That says """"the person is frequently quoted in conventional media as an academic expert in a particular area. A small number of quotations, especially in local news media, is not unexpected for academics and so falls short of this mark."""" Seyfeddinipur has been quoted and interviewed in the US, Germany (as already mentioned) and here https://www.sueddeutsche.de/bayern/linguistik-warum-sprachen-sterben-1.3246181, India https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/losing-our-languages/story-IFNYB3xyzYMI1JHtyz5E9K.html, and in the ''Guardian'', ''Aljazeera'', ''The Times'' and other major media. I would say that this meets #C7""" Deletion of Mandana Seyfeddinipur WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17880 3361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Premeditated User:Porqin 18:17, 10 August 2006 (UTC) delete This isn't , it is a random film that can't be |verified Deletion of Premeditated WP:NN||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
17881 11414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abby Martin (2nd nomination) User:Shalom11111 03:40, 7 December 2013 (UTC) delete the page has been successfully nominated for deletion in the past and was then redirected to RT (TV network)#Programming, but later it was created again for some reason. Indeed, the subject does not meet and doesn't have sufficient independent RS. Serioudly, is every American journalist going to have an article on Wikipedia Deletion of Abby Martin (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17882 12534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 Clovis library shooting User:Bryan 19:23, 7 September 2017 (UTC) keep The way this article reads now is not conducive to what I'd say is a wiki-worthy article, but I believe with the right editors and right information, this article can stay, therefore I am sticking with keep, so long as information within the next 1 week that comes out as the grand jury convenes reads less like a news article. Definitely meets otability standards Deletion of 2017 Clovis library shooting WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17883 12141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NK Trogir 1912 User:GiantSnowman 10:08, 15 February 2013 (UTC) delete fails , no evidence of notability Deletion of NK Trogir 1912 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17884 20379 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cheat Code Central User:Masem 21:25, 15 June 2008 (UTC) keep but cleanup, on the presumption that the references listed are good for showing the notability, but they need to be inline citations to match with the content (see and T Deletion of Cheat Code Central WP:CITE||WP:CITET Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17885 5459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nikos Stylos NONE NONE keep this is a AfD, mainly because the person is a Cham Albanian, a minority group of Greece. He has been interviewed by Shekulli, a newspaper widely circulated newspaper of Albania and one of the 3 largest Albanian newspapershttp://www.peshkupauje.com/2009/12/profesor-niko-stillo-ne-greqi-ka-70-mije. In Albanian national television TVSH there has been a program about him http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LL1rKn5Kxd4http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vWBvG5OfeFkhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yfbqBug_Qnw. Members of the Albanian Academy of Sciences have examined, peer-reviewed and written about him and his works Deletion of Nikos Stylos WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
17886 18707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Tomczyk - 3rd nomination NONE NONE delete Multiple AFD's, many speeedies, etc and repeating the same notability issues makes it that the ground needs to the |salted Deletion of Thomas Tomczyk - 3rd nomination WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
17887 18256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sara Goldrick-Rab (2nd nomination) User:Mendaliv 11:58, 4 July 2008 (UTC) delete I don't see her as passing . This looks just a tad better than a ''curriculum vitae Deletion of Sara Goldrick-Rab (2nd nomination) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17888 10601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Columbia University College Democrats User:TerriersFan 05:07, 24 February 2008 (UTC) delete student chapters are rarely notable and there is nothing here that would meet Deletion of Columbia University College Democrats WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17889 15194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kiwi! User:SunStar 19:20, 16 November 2006 (UTC) delete Nice little animation, I have to say. Sadly it's not notable as an Internet meme, but if it becomes one we can take it to . Notability would count as a newspaper/magazine article about the item, or a TV report etc. It hasn't reached those standards, ''yet Deletion of Kiwi! WP:DRV Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
17890 12451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Math Field Day User:D 08:19, 8 May 2019 (UTC) delete """per : """"Notable events usually have significant impact over a wide region, domain, or widespread societal group"""". Here the region is at most two counties""" Deletion of Math Field Day WP:GEOSCOPE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17891 395 [[ReviseF65]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Leithian NONE keep """Die ordnungsgemäße Begründung für ein hat Ivy eigentlich schon geliefert, die Artikelqualität ist - wie Benutzer Amberg bereits sagte - überdurchschnittlich und die #Vereine_und_B.C3.BCrgerinitiativen|einschlägigen RK scheinen mir bereits aufgrund """"Als relevant gelten Vereine und Bürgerinitiativen die eine überregionale Bedeutung haben"""" erfüllt""" Löschung von ReviseF65 Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
17892 19882 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trukkin User:Jcc 20:13, 27 October 2017 (UTC) delete provided sources are nothing better than |regurgitated press releases and |run of the mill coverage; additionally there appears to be some COI on the part of the creator Deletion of Trukkin WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17893 5180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry hoknes User:Excirial 10:44, 23 October 2009 (UTC) delete """I agree with the assessment. A search on both the article name, as well as on the related band """"Orange Lucy"""" returns nothing but myspace, youtube and similar websites which do not count as |reliable sources. Furthermore the article is full of claims they inspired other bands (), includes a lot of red links to apparently not notable artists, and the few names that do yield a link are either wrongly linked, or not related to the notability of the subject""" Deletion of Terry hoknes WP:RS||WP:OPINION Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17894 17987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Roadex Project User:Frayae 15:24, 22 July 2018 (UTC) merge The article clearly needs some secondary sources added, I suggest sending it the draft area for work and republishing via |AfC at a later time if and when it meets the various notability and writing standards. &mdash Deletion of The Roadex Project WP:AFC Wikipedia:Articles for creation 55
17895 20345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Stanton-Reid User:PJM 12:43, 8 February 2006 (UTC) delete per , http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=Sam+Stanton-Reid&btnG=Search, probably a hoax. The article does not qualify for speedy deletion because it contains claims of notability (mixed in with stupidity Deletion of Sam Stanton-Reid WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17896 5634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OurStage (2nd nomination) User:Pharaoh 18:58, 6 November 2020 (UTC) delete per nom and above fails Deletion of OurStage (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17897 18263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teenage Dog Orgy User:AmeIiorate 03:11, 2 June 2008 (UTC) delete per Qworty and etc. '''~ Ameliorate Deletion of Teenage Dog Orgy WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17898 5006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elián User:Northamerica1000 04:20, 13 December 2017 (UTC) keep per a review of available sources, passes / Deletion of Elián WP:NFP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17899 11934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swami Atmapriyananda User:Mscuthbert 17:43, 12 February 2016 (UTC) keep """per DGG's invocation of #C6 -- I think that a government-established university almost anywhere has come to have the status of """"major institution"""" for C6""" Deletion of Swami Atmapriyananda WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17900 6954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tag Bertuzzi User:Papaursa 23:37, 9 August 2017 (UTC) delete Another in a long list of articles on 16 year old hockey players that don't come close to meeting either or Deletion of Tag Bertuzzi WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
17901 7327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devante Davis User:Paulmcdonald 03:15, 21 June 2019 (UTC) keep I wasn't impressed until I saw CBL's research. Passes Deletion of Devante Davis WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17902 16800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chika Nwobi User:K 03:45, 8 September 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet per review of available sources, which are mostly advertorial in nature Deletion of Chika Nwobi WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17903 12378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zac Poonen (2nd nomination) User:Fiftytwo 03:09, 13 August 2010 (UTC) delete non-notable person, fails Deletion of Zac Poonen (2nd nomination) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17904 20007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mahmoud Hassan Al-Halwani User:Reddragon7 04:07, 6 March 2019 (UTC) delete failure of and Deletion of Mahmoud Hassan Al-Halwani WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17905 5100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luxiole User:Knowledgekid87 00:39, 14 October 2013 (UTC) delete per but mostly because of lack of reliable sources Deletion of Luxiole WP:NOTPLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17906 6874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Olivia Safe User:Tcr25 NONE comment """Searching around, I don't see much about her in . That said, not included in the article is her winning an """"X-Factor-style"""" ITV1 contest in 2008https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/whats-on/music/duo-go-for-op-stardom-69225https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1080100/Im-getting-Murrayed-says-Craig.html, one of the few things I could find. There's also mention of her performing on a Jeff Beck albumhttps://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=127774069https://jambands.com/reviews/cds/2010/04/05/jeff-beck-emotion-commotion/, but it's just mentions ... and not in the article""" Deletion of Olivia Safe WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17907 15848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kilcar GAA User:Blue 21:08, 30 April 2009 (UTC) delete at present. Club plays in Donegal Div 1 but has no record of national success in club championship that I can find. Would seem to fail on lack of national scope. Similar notability in football (soccer) project would also require this I think Deletion of Kilcar GAA WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17908 21404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wilhelmina Kott User:Canadian 20:37, 9 December 2007 (UTC) delete No substantial independent, reliable sources to establish meeting or . Nothing here that couldn't be summarized in the many supercentenarian lists. Cheers Deletion of Wilhelmina Kott WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17909 5016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kittenpants User:JFHJr 05:58, 12 November 2011 (UTC) delete This isn't the subject of substantial reliable coverage, nor is it award-winning, non-trivial, or anything else at . It's apparently defunct, so it doesn't seem likely to gain notability in the future. ...Ex-staff members? Really? No better coattails Deletion of Kittenpants WP:NMEDIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
17910 21719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prince Sani Gee User:CASSIOPEIA 13:15, 17 September 2019 (UTC) delete No notable musician. Fails Deletion of Prince Sani Gee WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17911 5259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xiaoze Xie User:B 02:29, 1 December 2011 (UTC) keep Per SarahStierch - clearly passes Deletion of Xiaoze Xie WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
17912 15770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Embraer MFT-LF User:Ahunt 12:29, 17 November 2016 (UTC) delete without sources it doesn't meet . If sources can be found it might be better to just mention it in the manufacturer article since nothing ever came of the project Deletion of Embraer MFT-LF WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17913 16818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Portuguese Pandur User:MarkH21 05:09, 13 April 2021 (UTC) merge to Pandur II#Portuguese variants: there is significant as this is essentially a slight variant of the base. Only the essential details need to be merged (e.g. not the lengthy and only partially-referenced timeline Deletion of Portuguese Pandur WP:OVERLAP Wikipedia:Merging 54
17914 6104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Border imperialism User:Telescopegenius 20:10, 16 November 2019 (UTC) delete I agree with the other votes to delete. I do not think the article passes . I also think the article reads too much like an essay Deletion of Border imperialism WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17915 11877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gasoline (Skillet song) User:Squeamish 19:49, 13 April 2018 (UTC) merge """I'll not go through all these nominations to post the same response, but states """"Songs that do not rise to notability for an independent article should redirect to another relevant article, such as for the songwriter, a prominent album or for the artist who prominently performed the song."""" I see no reason why the individual songs cannot or should not be redirected to their album articles""" Deletion of Gasoline (Skillet song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17916 10841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Metcalf User:DustFormsWords 03:18, 2 October 2009 (UTC) delete I'm pretty sure I've met this person, and with all due respect to him he's not (yet) notable. (Certainly not per ). And while we're at it, with regrets to the fine people at the ACT Writer's Centre, who I definitely HAVE met, the ACT Writing and Publishing Awards aren't notable either (they're a short step above vanity press), although at least one of the recipients is Deletion of Tim Metcalf WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17917 7581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fred Reid User:The 02:17, 30 December 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Fred Reid WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17918 7275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nícolas Andrade User:Pharaoh 09:12, 16 August 2016 (UTC) keep Passes ooty has played in Serie B a PL|fully professional league as per http://int.soccerway.com/players/nicolas-andrade-david/74343/ this Deletion of Nícolas Andrade WP:F||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Non-free content 99
17919 20410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Barney Dallenbach User:Isotope23 20:34, 29 August 2006 (UTC) comment the organization itself may be notable; but the individuals listed here don't meet ; I'm having a hard time finding any reliable sources about any of these people that would establish that they meet . Everything I'm seeing is Wikipedia or mirrors Deletion of Robert Barney Dallenbach WP:BIO||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17920 10572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dujuan Thomas User:Topoint22 16:13, 24 September 2019 (UTC) delete The article does have credibility of notability from my research. is covered with his work in Film, and his social following. After reviewing his television appearances which are a credible source of his celebrity status. It seems that some users are putting personal opinions above Wikipedia norms. However I think more research can be done and sources added to better this article. But at this time it does meet a basic minimum requirement to be included in the encyclopedia Deletion of Dujuan Thomas WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17921 11884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pínéis wainc User:ChrisO 11:52, 12 November 2005 (UTC) delete but definitely move to |BJAODN Deletion of Pínéis wainc WP:BJAODN Wikipedia:Silly Things 72
17922 3115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Typewriter Tape User:Esradekan 12:43, 26 August 2009 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability per #Albums Deletion of The Typewriter Tape WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
17923 14365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transformers: Alternators (2nd nomination) User:onel5969 00:38, 7 November 2019 (UTC) delete one of the most blatant examples of fancruft. Zero sourcing. Fails Deletion of Transformers: Alternators (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17924 5998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Multiple oscillation mechanism User:Mark 03:16, 30 September 2013 (UTC) delete I was unable to find any reliable sources for this topic in Google news, books, or scholar. The animation comes from http://www.anandmi.com/NEW_INVENTION_1.html this page, which indicated that the mechanism is the subject of a patent, but patents are not considered reliable sources. Thus the topic seems to fail general notability guidelines, per . The author of the article also looks like the inventor, raising conflict of interest problems, per , and rendering this article promotional in nature. A non-notable topic and serious article problems suggest deletion Deletion of Multiple oscillation mechanism WP:GNG||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
17925 11814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sally J. Clark User:Bearian 23:44, 21 July 2007 (UTC) delete as ''some'' city councillors can be notable, but |I am not sure that she is notable Deletion of Sally J. Clark WP:HOLE Wikipedia:I wouldn't know him from a hole in the ground 12
17926 10396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Rina Shnerb User:Huldra 22:43, 2 June 2020 (UTC) delete pr . (Btw: If we look at Wikipedia, there are at least 10 times as many articles about Israeli civilians killed, as there are articles about Palestinian civilians killed. The reality is opposite: at least 10 Palestinian civilians are killed for each civilian Israelis killed. Palestinian lives definitely don't matter Deletion of Murder of Rina Shnerb WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17927 17852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Chung (artist) User:AuthorAuthor 04:23, 26 November 2019 (UTC) keep Wide coverage of the subject is easily found and is now in the article. I worked on the article and cleaned up POV and puffery, tightened writing and added reliable sources. Media coverage goes beyond the controversial painting. It includes feature newspaper and magazine articles and a public radio feature about the subject's art. Coverage is ample and meets . Multiple awards and gallery showings also contribute to notability. Passes and Deletion of Thomas Chung (artist) WP:GNG||WP:NARTIST||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17928 1672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashley Morgan (musician) User:Raaggio 17:03, 9 April 2010 (UTC) delete After using |the Bing search engine to verify notability, I noticed that there are very few sources, let alone |reliable ones. Due to , , and, in my opinion, , the article should be deleted Deletion of Ashley Morgan (musician) WP:SET||WP:RL||WP:RL||WP:SET||WP:N Wikipedia:Search engine test 38
17929 2936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanner Price User:Paulmcdonald 06:16, 15 January 2019 (UTC) keep several of the sources provided by Yankees10 are feature articles from major news outlets, which is more than enough to pass . Not every college football athlete attains notability, but this one does Deletion of Tanner Price WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17930 4513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suzan Woodruff User:Yash 22:53, 2 January 2017 (UTC) keep seems to pass by a thin margin and per the coverage received. Although I completely agree to what {{u|TheLongTone}} said at the end Deletion of Suzan Woodruff WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
17931 19496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Salda User:Jayron32 16:07, 25 June 2009 (UTC) delete per nom, who has done his homework. The lack of coverage in web sources, coupled with no evidence of non-web sources, would seem to clearly indicate this person does not pass or inclusion criteria Deletion of Michael Salda WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17932 2370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC 143 User:TreyGeek 01:32, 23 April 2012 (UTC) delete """The article contains mostly statistics (fight results, payouts and awards) and generally lacks """"well sourced prose"""" as requested by for notable events""" Deletion of UFC 143 WP:SPORTSEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17933 5423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Safari Ltd User:Johnuniq 10:45, 13 June 2009 (UTC) delete No way to make an article out of this advert. Fails Deletion of Safari Ltd WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17934 5378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Michael Lacey (2nd nomination) User:Whpq 14:18, 7 April 2008 (UTC) comment shouldn't this really have been submitted to |Deletion Review Deletion of Aaron Michael Lacey (2nd nomination) WP:DRV Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
17935 10935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Cabal (2nd nomination) User:Jmundo 22:36, 12 January 2009 (UTC) keep The article has good sources and just the fact that he has been published by national magazines should be enough to meet . Notability is not temporary Deletion of Alan Cabal (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17936 12806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of algal culture collections (2nd nomination) User:Deor 12:38, 17 April 2009 (UTC) keep I see where the concerns are coming from, but I think that the basic existence of an article at this title is justified. It would be nice if someone who knows about such collections would format it more like List of herbaria, where the significance of the entries is established by the scope of the collections' holdings Deletion of List of algal culture collections (2nd nomination) WP:NOTLINK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17937 19392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bagrunov Vladimir User:Targeman 15:01, 23 July 2007 (UTC) delete My Russian sucks even more than the author's English, but it's enough to see this is obvious |spam. The Bagrunov guy in question opened a school where people allegedly learn to sing without using their vocal cords, which this man claims is against nature (!). The website says the school is famous and has been covered by major Russian media, but a quick Google makes it clear |it has not Deletion of Bagrunov Vladimir WP:SPAM||WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Spam 112
17938 5753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trinity Lutheran School (Kaukauna, WI) User:Mandsford 22:41, 6 March 2011 (UTC) comment OK, we have a new contributor--- welcome to Wikipedia-- who might not be familiar with the general result concerning schools #Education. Basically, it's that high schools, like Fox Valley Lutheran, usually get their own article, while middle schools and elementary schools are referred to in the article about the school district it's located in (for a public school) or the school network or the town if it's a private school. In this case, it's part of the Fox Valley Lutheran School System, which may not have its own article; it could be redirected to Fox Valley High or to Kaukana, Wisconsin, or an article could be written about the school system Deletion of Trinity Lutheran School (Kaukauna, WI) WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
17939 19151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Europe Racer User:Aguyintobooks 12:20, 16 September 2017 (UTC) delete per failing , after search can't find anything, I am not assuming there are offline sources either Deletion of Europe Racer WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17940 159 [[Tim Schrick]] (bleibt) Benutzer:AndyNE NONE delete Welcher Grund soll zutreffen? , da „vollkommen unbekannte Person“ bei einer die Sendungen moderiert, in bekannten Rennklassen fährt etc nicht gegeben ist Löschung von Tim Schrick Wikipedia:Schnelllöschantrag Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17941 5457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vatula User:Sitush 12:16, 20 June 2016 (UTC) delete as fails and is a . I have removed one source (Rediff) because it is a mirror of Wikipedia. The others do not discuss it in depth and are basically definitions Deletion of Vatula WP:GNG||WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17942 16231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Na astaraichean User:Charlene 18:59, 9 July 2007 (UTC) delete Fails - unattributable per Google search and possibly Deletion of Na astaraichean WP:ATT||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Attribution 108
17943 2200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Agnes Sina-Inakoju User:TheGracefulSlick 20:33, 26 January 2018 (UTC) delete WP:NOTNEWS|Wikipedia is not a newspaper; crimes, even tragic ones, are not automatically exonerated from this fact. The same story is being |routinely covered but there is a clear lack of |lasting significance Deletion of Murder of Agnes Sina-Inakoju WP:ROUTINE||WP:LASTING Wikipedia:Notability 77
17944 1088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hula Popper User:Wavy 19:01, 11 November 2006 (UTC) delete per . Sounds more like something you'd find on the appetizer menu at T.G.I. Friday's than a sexual term Deletion of Hula Popper WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
17945 2267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Shaw (Encana) User:Bearcat 12:48, 16 July 2021 (UTC) delete """Article is advertorialized (""""Brian Shaw, CFA, is a Canadian financial industry executive with particular expertise in capital market and investing activities""""), has been edited by the subject himself (see ), is referenced overwhelmingly to directory entries and other |primary sources rather than journalist-written third party |reliable source coverage ''about'' him, and states absolutely nothing about his career that would be """"inherently"""" notable enough to exempt it from any of those problems having to be taken seriously""" Deletion of Brian Shaw (Encana) WP:COI||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:RS Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
17946 15333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyber-Duck (2nd nomination) User:Ihcoyc 04:02, 31 January 2011 (UTC) delete """They're a """"digital agency"""", and I gather that they've made websites, but I still have no idea what they make or do here. This kind of evasive description is typical of spam. At any rate, there's no indication that any of the petty trade awards they've listed equate to the sort of |historical, technical, or cultural significance of the kind that gets you remembered in encyclopedias. (""""When evaluating the notability of organizations, please consider whether it has had any significant or demonstrable effects on culture, society, entertainment, athletics, economies, history, literature, science, or education."""") So no, it doesn't even meet the current notability guideline""" Deletion of Cyber-Duck (2nd nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
17947 13253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kick Natural Energy Bar User:Glane23 18:06, 11 September 2017 (UTC) delete Purely promotional. And, to be sure, the article also fails |general notability as the subject lacks significant coverage in reliable sources. I could find no mention of the product in the usual gSearches Deletion of Kick Natural Energy Bar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17948 7508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Dolman User:XLerate 00:21, 26 February 2009 (UTC) delete see nothing on NZ Herald, Stuff, Google, fails Deletion of Matt Dolman WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17949 12559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/In da Streetsz Musik User:SkierRMH 04:12, 10 January 2007 (UTC) delete Only sources outside of Wiki&mirrors appear to be Myspace related, w/ no 3rd parties, fails , in addition to the aforementioned Deletion of In da Streetsz Musik WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17950 16237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Embry Hills church of Christ User:Edison2 21:49, 29 August 2008 (UTC) delete I see nothing here to satisfy or . There is also nothing to satisf which was created as an attempt to have a notability guideline for chiurches and religious congregations, but which did not gain consensus Deletion of Embry Hills church of Christ WP:ORG||WP:N||WP:CONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17951 24 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pirates at Ocean’s Edge User:Scottie_theNerd 08:13, 4 April 2007 (UTC) comment Articles on Wikipedia do not belong to a single author. It is not up to the creator of the article to provide all the sources and complete the entire article; that is the domain of the entire Wikipedia community. However, I would like to see sources that assert the series' |notability Deletion of Pirates at Ocean’s Edge WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17952 11049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lolcat User:Ptkfgs 06:35, 25 April 2007 (UTC) merge to List of internet phenomena, unless |I can has reliable sources?. &mdash Deletion of Lolcat WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17953 10881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Strategic Leadership Consultation User:Ihcoyc 14:03, 23 June 2009 (UTC) delete per nomination. This is apparently some kind of conference for church leaders, a fact that its name |(that smells like a cow pasture) fails to convey clearly. A http://www.google.com/search?q=%22strategic+leadership+consultation%22&hl=en&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&hs=2Em&start=10&sa=N general Google search yields only 317 hits, some of which are just the usual malarkey you'd expect from a name like that, and none of them that I found look like independent reliable sources Deletion of Strategic Leadership Consultation WP:CB Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
17954 8827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ska Punk And Other Junk User:WilyD 16:05, 9 August 2006 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Ska Punk And Other Junk WP:VAIN||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
17955 4069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billy Quinncroft User:Fenix 11:26, 10 July 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Billy Quinncroft WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17956 7019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phillip King (tennis) User:Wolbo 11:06, 24 July 2017 (UTC) keep player passes and played at the highest level of professional tennis (Grand Slam tournament Deletion of Phillip King (tennis) WP:NTENNIS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17957 9966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vega Colony User:Garycompugeek 20:55, 22 June 2009 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Vega Colony WP:VER||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17958 21799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamza Idris NONE NONE keep My sense is that this fellow's work and activities and extra curricular activity meets in print and electronic media, and that for Nigeria, this meets notability for a national audience, i.e., his country Deletion of Hamza Idris WP:NMEDIA||WP:AUD Wikipedia:Notability 77
17959 5830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Newfoundland and Labrador First Party User:Edivorce 19:10, 14 March 2007 (UTC) keep notable, sufficiently sources, meets WP:ORG. is an essay- not a policy- not even a guideline. It is internally riddled with cautions and self limiting language. It should not be used to delete the work of other editors Deletion of Newfoundland and Labrador First Party WP:GOOGLE Wikipedia:Search engine test 38
17960 9315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WWII A Comedy User:Armbrust 08:35, 24 September 2010 (UTC) delete as article fails |notability criteria for books Deletion of WWII A Comedy WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
17961 4462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gabriel Murphy (3rd nomination) User:HelloAnnyong 00:55, 6 July 2008 (UTC) delete """Come on - three nominations and five deletions? Article is most certainly written from someone's who's , if not by Murphy himself. :Image:Gabriel_Murphy_Signature.jpg|His signature marks the source as """"Own work by uploader"""" - it stands to reason that Murphy was the uploader. Either way, I don't think that |notability has been reached here. &mdash""" Deletion of Gabriel Murphy (3rd nomination) WP:COI||WP:N Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
17962 17690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emma Tillman User:Rhododendrites 02:43, 16 November 2015 (UTC) keep I can see why this is such a hard one to determine consensus for. I'm sympathetic to the idea of in this sort of scenario. There can be sufficient sources to justify a claim to notability but not a stand-alone article. Ultimately, however, though there is a salient fact of her age which serves as the basis for this coverage, the coverage in very high-profile sources extends past that. Her age and death may be driven the stories, but if many high-profile sources are going into some depth about other aspects of her life such that what is due weight to include goes beyond the fact of her age and basic biographical data, I have to lean keep. What is encyclopedic is what aspects of a subject receive coverage in reliable sources, and there looks to be just enough here to merit a stand-alone article. &mdash Deletion of Emma Tillman WP:NOPAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
17963 16230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magic: The Gathering deck types (3rd nomination) User:Sangrolu 15:35, 29 August 2016 (UTC) keep I actually don't like this article, but (as I mentioned in the last nomination), is about video games. This in not a how-to guide, and it does meet . But the way it is written coming across as a laundry list of decks that might have been competitive at one point quickly gets dated. If you strip it down to its essence, you end up with something that might better fit into a larger MTG strategy article. I would support some sort of merge Deletion of Magic: The Gathering deck types (3rd nomination) WP:GAMEGUIDE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17964 2312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard T. Snodgrass User:Agricola44 14:48, 28 April 2010 (UTC) keep """This is a slam dunk. The enormous citation base to his work is sufficient (GS h-index seems to be around 25): it is independent, verifiable, as well as being conclusive proof of impact. This indeed is the long-established standard test of #1, which the subject conspicuously satisfies. ACM Fellow would also be a pass (as would """"Fellow""""-level election in any of the main scientific societies). Respectfully""" Deletion of Richard T. Snodgrass WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17965 9232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Run Rincewind Run! User:TenPoundHammer 13:10, 9 January 2008 (UTC) delete Even if Pratchett was in it, it still fails . No reliable sources could be found pertaining to the film, and furthermore, it was only a minor film shown at a convention Deletion of Run Rincewind Run! WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
17966 15392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Daniels (journalist) User:TheSandDoctor 15:49, 1 September 2019 (UTC) delete own work does not count towards your own notability ( at best). David does not appear to satisfy Deletion of David Daniels (journalist) WP:PRIMARY||WP:NJOURNALIST Wikipedia:No original research 65
17967 15793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gianna Giavelli User:Whpq 14:56, 21 August 2012 (UTC) delete I don't see the significant coverage about the individual to meet |Wikipedia's inclusion guidelines Deletion of Gianna Giavelli WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
17968 19311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brandon Ormonde-Ottewill User:Fenix 07:33, 14 July 2015 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Brandon Ormonde-Ottewill WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17969 8528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zaka Public School User:Bearian 22:27, 14 November 2011 (UTC) delete per past precedent and ; see also Deletion of Zaka Public School WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17970 21464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gökhan Töre User:JonBroxton 01:11, 1 February 2009 (UTC) delete player fails and /N. Recreate if and when he makes his professional debut Deletion of Gökhan Töre WP:ATHLETE||WP:FOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
17971 3216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/D. L. Hall User:Lizard 04:34, 27 May 2017 (UTC) keep No valid rationale given. Article appears to pass http://www.macon.com/sports/article89216707.htmlhttp://highschoolsports.blog.ajc.com/2017/03/28/valdosta-lefty-hall-heads-list-of-georgias-top-10-baseball-prospects/http://www.baseballamerica.com/draft/dl-hall-shines-east-coast-pro/#UTLH4oy9w37t7tiq.97 and there are plenty of articles on high school baseball players; see 2017 Major League Baseball draft#Prospects Deletion of D. L. Hall WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17972 4212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corrina Broz User:TheGracefulSlick 18:47, 29 July 2017 (UTC) keep I should have considered editors wouldn't read the disclaimer in where it notes teams/team members are discounted Deletion of Corrina Broz WP:NOLYMPICS Wikipedia:Notability 77
17973 10976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conner, California User:Spiderone 11:03, 15 December 2020 (UTC) delete fails and likely fails Deletion of Conner, California WP:GNG||WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17974 4941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craic User:NeilN 00:36, 17 April 2010 (UTC) keep """Despite Wolfkeeper's attempt to portray otherwise, states that """"in some cases, a word or phrase itself may be an encyclopedic subject."""" Quite hilariously, his assertion that """"we don't have articles on neologisms"""" is refuted by looking at the article Neologism, itself a """"word"""" article. It is clear that the community accepts that articles like Yankee and Thou belong on Wikipedia and that it is capable of distinguishing between articles which are dictionary definitions and those which have encyclopedic merit""" Deletion of Craic WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17975 16417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GameJournoPros User:Ryulong 06:50, 28 October 2014 (UTC) delete Definitely not notable and issues up the wazoo. This was expressly excluded from the Gamergate controversy article for these reasons Deletion of GameJournoPros WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
17976 16214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jones in the Fast Lane User:MLauba 16:16, 17 March 2009 (UTC) keep """the ad hominems notwithstanding, I trust more |reliable sources can still be recovered which would definitely move this from """"barely passes |the GNG"""" to solidly referenced. |Considering potential, and both the age and the producer (despite the fact that |notability isn't inherited) should warrant this one the benefit of the doubt, also per """ Deletion of Jones in the Fast Lane WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:POTENTIAL||WP:N||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17977 4009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emre Anuk User:Argyle 19:05, 30 November 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Emre Anuk WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17978 3726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Soares User:Satori 20:57, 30 August 2006 (UTC) merge to WFHN. Does not meet Deletion of Larry Soares WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17979 18774 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William G. """"Bill"""" Bailey""" User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable vanity biography. Recommend the article author see http://www.wikime.org/ WikiMe for writing biographies and/or http://www.wikitree.org WikiTree for writing genealogies. &mdash """Deletion of William G. """"Bill"""" Bailey""" WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17980 7674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AHOY User:Bearian 21:01, 23 October 2007 (UTC) delete fails . |We are not a catalog for Bootleg discs Deletion of AHOY WP:MUSIC||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17981 3364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/POV Pervert User:Atlantic306 20:03, 24 June 2018 (UTC) delete as it does not pass or and the awards are in niche categories, thanks Deletion of POV Pervert WP:NFILM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17982 6950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Satanic ritual abuse and The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints User:Bearian 20:15, 8 November 2007 (UTC) keep as notable and well-referenced (16 footnotes, mostly ), as well as different from other churches' scandals, and NPOV - the summary says it all. Problems with specific footnotes, content, etc., belongs on the talk page, not at AfD. Admins: There is no consensus here per ; allow this AfD nom to continue Deletion of Satanic ritual abuse and The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints WP:RS||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
17983 20052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abhijeet shwetchandra User:Jeepday 18:09, 4 June 2021 (UTC) delete Possibly an up and coming actor, but currently I agree with nom, does not look to meet Deletion of Abhijeet shwetchandra WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17984 20625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Masada (Honorverse) (2nd nomination) [[User_talk:Bradv15|BradV]] 15:41, 25 March 2008 (UTC) delete per policy (). If the policy needs to be changed that can be discussed at the policy talk page or at the village pump. There are more than enough precedents for this to be deleted Deletion of Masada (Honorverse) (2nd nomination) WP:PLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17985 70 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Mustafa Gözel Kullanıcı:emreosm95emreos 19.29, 4 Haziran 2021 (UTC) comment """Muadillerinin sayfaları mevcut"""" yeterli bir neden değil, aksine hatalı akıl yürütme. Hakkında zamana yayılmış bir şekilde bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynaklar olması gerekiyor. Ayrıca kitap yazmış olmak, dernek kurmak, akademik yayın yapmak da tek başına kayda değerlik kriterlerini sağlamıyor. Hakkında çıkmış ciddi bir haber yok. Televizyona da çıkmış olması yeterli değil. Lütfen ve Vikipedi:Kayda değerlik (kişiler) maddelerini okuyun""" Mustafa Gözel'in silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
17986 3321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Garius User:MuZemike 22:35, 30 November 2008 (UTC) merge to Zoids as a plausible search term. Otherwise, this is nothing but |unverifiable |original research (note: I will be copy-and-pasting this on the related AFDs as well, as the exact same rationale applies Deletion of Garius WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
17987 8630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shauna Sylvester User:Rusf10 00:22, 5 May 2018 (UTC) delete Fails , if she actually goes on to win the race, this can be revisited Deletion of Shauna Sylvester WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
17988 7902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Elite (futsal team) User:Mattinbgn 11:00, 22 May 2007 (UTC) delete per |CSD A7 An under-12 futsal team! Nowhere near notable Deletion of The Elite (futsal team) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
17989 17972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammed sanduk User:Agricola44 17:09, 1 April 2010 (UTC) delete """The subject is a physicist and the article makes at least 2 claims to notability that, if true, would represent remarkable advances in this science: (1) an extension of the theory of Bohm diffusion, and (2) an extension of the Wave–particle duality|wave model of a particle. The source provided for the first claim is an obscure journal and this paper appears in none of the usual mainstream indexing services, e.g. WoS and GS. (Long parenthetical remark: this paper was also added as reference for Bohm diffusion in that article by an anonymous editor Special:Contributions/86.2.247.35|IP 82.2.247.35 in Guildford, the subject's hometown, and an apparently account, Special:Contributions/86.2.254.132|IP 86.2.254.132 also from Guildford, has also edited only this article and the Bohm diffusion article. If the Sanduk article is eventually deleted, the reference should be removed from the Bohm diffusion article, as it is apparently not recognized by mainstream physicists.) There are 2 sources for the second claim: and article in Apeiron (physics journal)|Apeiron and an uploaded paper in arXiv. Apeiron is a well-known """"alternative science"""" journal and is not regarded as part of the mainstream science world, for example it is not indexed by WoS. The arXiv:0904.0790|arxiv source, though more credible, is still not a peer-reviewed contribution. It's been uploaded there for about a year and there's no indication in the article that this paper has been submitted to a mainstream physics journal. On balance, there's no indication whatsoever that the physics community has embraced either of these two ideas. In terms of a more routine check, WoS shows 1 paper with 9 citations from 1992 (h-index = 1). This appears to be something related to what the article says was his PhD topic 20 years ago. It does not appear that he is a notable physicist in the least. Respectfully""" Deletion of Mohammed sanduk WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
17990 10770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nina Cassady User:Shooterwalker 16:56, 8 October 2020 (UTC) delete due to exclusive sourced material, with no significant reception from reliable sources Deletion of Nina Cassady WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
17991 157 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hakan Dalokay Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 07:01, 8 Ekim 2013 (UTC) comment Ulusal Mimarlık Ödülleri kapsamında bir ödülü var, Türkiye'deki en prestijli mimarlık ödüllerinden. |İlgili kriterlerimizde yer alan ''eleştirmenlerin önemli derecede dikkatini çekmiş'' şartını sağlayabilir belki Hakan Dalokay'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
17992 17001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Nathaniel Henry Peters (3rd nomination) NONE NONE keep Has not created entirely new theories? That's funny, considering he's been dead for a hundred years. That said, a hundred years after death, he remains one of the most highly notable religious eschatologists known throughout history. Although, the article should probably be renamed George N. H. Peters, as this was the name he wrote under, and most people with interest wouldn't know to look under his full name. The research and works he completed are classics in the study of premillennialism. Per , the subject of this article meets the first three criteria for inclusion Deletion of George Nathaniel Henry Peters (3rd nomination) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
17993 17821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suzette Davenport User:YorkshireLad 17:39, 28 March 2020 (UTC) keep I've added sources to the article that hopefully show that it meets , as well as a claim to notability (the first woman to be head of Gloucestershire Constabulary). Seems to be plenty of coverage of her on the internet, I'll keep trying to add stuff. (I feel like receiving an honorary doctorate might qualify her under part 1 as well Deletion of Suzette Davenport WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
17994 16463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Rules (dating) User:DMacks 18:10, 12 January 2007 (UTC) delete if fabricated refs. I was the PRODer, and stand by my original concern Deletion of The Rules (dating) WP:OR||WP:NFT Wikipedia:No original research 65
17995 10792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Planet Express Ship (2nd nomination) User:RMHED 21:32, 27 November 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Planet Express Ship (2nd nomination) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
17996 6222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angalaamman User:SportingFlyer 06:54, 13 March 2018 (UTC) merge with Ankalamma. Feel like the Temples section at least can be saved and sourced. Honestly do not understand the component of the AfD Deletion of Angalaamman WP:BALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
17997 4370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hello Beautiful User:Michig 21:23, 24 September 2008 (UTC) keep Hello Beautiful and merge the other 2 into it. Just passes based on coverage already identified in the article and these: http://www.punktv.ca/?c=105&a=3567, http://www.indiesolo.com/artists/HelloBeautiful/interview.htm, http://www.soundproofmagazine.com/Canada/Albums/index.html?show=full, and current national tour appears to be verifiable Deletion of Hello Beautiful WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
17998 3304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Huriye Yeliz Yüksel User:Djsasso 12:47, 30 August 2017 (UTC) delete Summed up pretty well already. I can find nothing anywhere that indicates they meet the Deletion of Huriye Yeliz Yüksel WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
17999 18159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Didley squat User:Thivierr 11:22, 15 September 2005 (UTC) delete I have to agree it doesn't meet . From what I see, they've gotten out of the garage, but not out of the city, so they're not quite there yet, but have more potential than most of the nn-bands Deletion of Didley squat WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18000 2001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Renuka David User:Anupmehra 02:05, 22 November 2016 (UTC) delete It is a pure advertisement. However, that is not only problem. The bigger issue is that she has not received '|significant' coverage in |reliable sources. I'm seeing only http://searchindiannews.in/search.html?query=%22Renuka%20David%22#&gsc.q=%22Renuka%20David%22&gsc.page=1 trivial coverage of her in reliable sources Deletion of Renuka David WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18001 1753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dare To Love Me User:Ward3001 23:57, 13 February 2009 (UTC) comment Sources have been added, but there still aren't any sources that filming has begun. Still fails Deletion of Dare To Love Me WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18002 13361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anomaly (band) User:B 00:10, 28 November 2006 (UTC) delete I'd tend to give the benefit of the doubt to Maltese bands, but if the article doesn't give a lineup, the band ''can't'' be sufficiently notable for Deletion of Anomaly (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18003 4319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Snapple Real Facts User:Gobonobo 21:55, 12 January 2014 (UTC) delete per . This is an unsourced list of trivia that is printed inside of Snapple bottle caps Deletion of List of Snapple Real Facts WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18004 18477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phobos (computer game) User:Someone 16:51, 15 December 2008 (UTC) delete """The game's site describes it as ''""""a Massively Multiplayer Online Role-playing Game (MMORPG) created by a team of volunteers from all around the world. Phobos is the first product of “Myth Entertainment” and though it's still in development, it already has a strong community.""""'' IE it's a low-fi indie effort, the likes of which almost never gain |notability, the lack of sources coming up in a search illustrates this, articles can't be built with """"ever heard of this..?"""" message board posts. Though I don't like the idea that someone's first contributions are up for deletion so quickly, nobody likes their contributions being deleted regardless of how long they've been on WP. Dismissing this process due to that alone is not a kindness in the long run, much as I would like the article's creator to feel welcome""" Deletion of Phobos (computer game) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18005 14335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harry Whittington (2nd nomination) User:Miniapolis 17:57, 22 May 2013 (UTC) merge to Dick Cheney hunting incident, per ; article's subject is |low-profile, and all refs concern the shooting Deletion of Harry Whittington (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:LOWPROFILE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18006 5012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wonky (music) (2nd nomination) User:Esradekan 23:26, 28 December 2008 (UTC) keep well written and wp:rs|referenced. Smells like |socks around here though Deletion of Wonky (music) (2nd nomination) WP:SOCK Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
18007 11240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryan Versteeg User:FreeRangeFrog 22:27, 20 November 2012 (UTC) delete Fails . Involvement in a notable project does not automatically afford notability Deletion of Bryan Versteeg WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18008 2946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flow-through test User:FourViolas 06:36, 7 July 2016 (UTC) keep """Bravo to M. A. Bruhn. There may be some ambiguity remaining in that non-clinical """"flow-through assays"""" also exist (I added a MEDRS-compliant source discussing some), but that's a minor concern. Article as it stands approximately meets , with clinically relevant information cited to respected recent reviews""" Deletion of Flow-through test WP:MEDRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18009 4034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of enclosed roller coasters User:RoySmith 17:28, 24 August 2018 (UTC) delete Unsourced for nine years. No evidence that this is a real term. Don't merge; since this is unsourced, it fails , so can't be merged. In fact, the proposed target fails as well, for the same reason Deletion of List of enclosed roller coasters WP:V||WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18010 2512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moros Eros User:Chubbles 19:02, 6 December 2007 (UTC) keep two albums on Victory Records passes . A little digging would turn up scads of album reviews, an Allmusic profile, and plenty of touring Deletion of Moros Eros WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18011 20365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matti Jutila User:David 09:04, 15 August 2020 (UTC) keep 3 pubs with 100 cites each is a solid record in a low citation field like mathematics, likely a pass of C1, and as Deletion of Matti Jutila WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18012 21097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chaotic hardcore [[User talk:TenPoundHammer|What did I screw up now?]]) 07:09, 11 March 2012 (UTC) delete per . '''Ten Pound Hammer Deletion of Chaotic hardcore WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18013 11837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guido Martino [[User talk:24.151.10.165|talk]]) 17:14, 18 November 2016 (UTC) delete Having spent some time looking for any reference for this individual, I have found none. Fails . Special:Contributions/24.151.10.165|24.151.10.165 Deletion of Guido Martino WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18014 5896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phonon renormalization in the single-mode spin-boson Hamiltonian User:Colonel 06:30, 13 May 2010 (UTC) delete per PAPER Deletion of Phonon renormalization in the single-mode spin-boson Hamiltonian WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18015 4715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brent Britton User:Uncle 02:59, 5 February 2014 (UTC) comment The reasons the nominator listed for deletion |can be fixed without deleting the article. --| Deletion of Brent Britton WP:DELETIONISNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18016 15969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leon Fresco User:Endofskull 04:08, 19 November 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Leon Fresco WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18017 7293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthems in Animal Farm User:Carrite 13:53, 15 June 2013 (UTC) delete as an unsourced original essay. Yeah, . If there is scholarship out there on such things, source it up and try again Deletion of Anthems in Animal Farm WP:ITSINTERESTING Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18018 7773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greenacres, Kentucky User:Suonii180 12:29, 19 October 2020 (UTC) delete Couldn't find reliable sources to prove Deletion of Greenacres, Kentucky WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18019 1602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Travel & Tourism Academy User:AllyD 06:50, 27 May 2015 (UTC) delete Searches are not turning up any |evidence of |notability for this training centre Deletion of International Travel & Tourism Academy :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18020 264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Schuyler Hayden User:SportingFlyer 02:05, 20 March 2018 (UTC) comment """I'd still like to see a keep argument that's based on notability and not an extension of , as none of the keep votes have provided sources. Rat Fink does not have an article on this site. A Google Search shows the film is registered on imdb and a number of film directory sites. A book search shows his name appears in some books which talk primarily about Riot on the Sunset Strip, and a couple others talked about Rat Fink as well, saying it could """"do the art theater rounds well if handled correctly,"""" not exactly a good endorsement. Hayden's name appears in similar directories. I don't see significant coverage at all""" Deletion of Schuyler Hayden WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18021 13288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/An Hobbes User:Truth 15:17, 2 June 2013 (UTC) delete Insufficient track record for . A look at past venues suggests a tavern, a bar, a theater... No substantive online review either. Fails in terms of overall visibility too Deletion of An Hobbes WP:ARTIST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18022 3683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Bell (Australian actor) User:Jenks24 06:27, 5 October 2011 (UTC) delete One minor role in a fairly small TV series means he does not pass and I can't find anything that shows him even coming close to the significant coverage that is required to pass Deletion of James Bell (Australian actor) WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18023 93 [[Axel Buch]] (Glöscht) Benutzer:Zaphiro NONE delete mit 9.054 Einwohnern seiner Stadt erfüllt der Bürgermeister nicht die |Relevanzkriterien, deshalb Löschung von Axel Buch Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
18024 15781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dors Feline User:Snottywong 17:26, 27 May 2010 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Dors Feline WP:PORNSTAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
18025 18783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Memorycoin User:Dwpaul 00:46, 28 July 2014 (UTC) delete nbsp; Also nothing in HighBeam. Though not particularly useful in determining |notability, it is interesting to note that Memorycoin is not mentioned at ''cryptocurrency'' (though other cryptocurrency projects of similarly questionable notability are Deletion of Memorycoin WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18026 18705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Images of castles User:TheCoffee 05:48, 6 October 2005 (UTC) delete """Indeed, I think there's little doubt that these article are clearly contradictory to the guidelines in . If anyone wants these to serve as a """"visual index"""", they could include pictures in List of castles""" Deletion of Images of castles WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18027 17673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Watchtower Movement User:S 08:14, 3 May 2009 (UTC) delete this complete Deletion of Watchtower Movement WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
18028 3373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Binahian User:JohnCD 21:06, 28 October 2010 (UTC) keep rescued version. I thought originally that this was a case of , but based on the excellent rescue work I am happy to keep it. Main problem now is lack of sources. I am pleased to see that the original author's work is not lost - she has posted it at a more suitable place: http://nyleve02.wordpress.com/2010/10/24/binahian Deletion of Binahian WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
18029 9413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Napoleon Dynamite (character) User:Carlossuarez46 16:11, 12 June 2007 (UTC) delete per nom & per Deletion of Napoleon Dynamite (character) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18030 19684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BlueVine User:Bungstnk 12:18, 27 June 2021 (UTC) delete Doesn’t meet Deletion of BlueVine WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18031 29 [[Gerätewagen Gefahrgut 3]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Brandpatsche NONE comment Aus der /24. Januar 2006|QS vom 24.1.06: Kaum mehr als eine Artikelvorlage - bisher keine Verbesserung eingetreten. und dann löschen Löschung von Gerätewagen Gefahrgut 3 Wikipedia:Qualitätssicherung Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
18032 15864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fieldwire User:HighKing 14:13, 5 November 2017 (UTC) delete Fails GNG and Deletion of Fieldwire WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18033 18508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bufus Dei User:Stuartyeates 07:41, 9 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Bufus Dei WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18034 6544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Movement to impeach George W. Bush (4th nomination) User:Metropolitan90 03:35, 21 January 2009 (UTC) keep I don't understand the objections to nominating this article today. After all, before today, impeachment of George W. Bush was still a theoretical possibility, whereas now it isn't. Thus, today was a logical day to nominate the article for deletion, since it is now certain that the movement will not succeed. That said, it may be possible to improve this article by normal editing to bring it closer to a |neutral point of view. The movement may be notable even though it was unsuccessful Deletion of Movement to impeach George W. Bush (4th nomination) WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18035 6857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/InuYasha: First Season Box Set User:Undead 04:13, 29 February 2008 (UTC) delete as |listcruft. Non notable section already covered in the main article Deletion of InuYasha: First Season Box Set WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
18036 10936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Berlin Wine Tastings User:Pete 17:31, 9 March 2008 (UTC) delete el |spammo Deletion of Berlin Wine Tastings WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
18037 14716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Cassell (2nd nomination) User:Green 21:13, 2 October 2013 (UTC) keep """5 million is significant supported by """"Has a large fan base"""". per two sources Daily Mirror and The Sunday Times""" Deletion of Tom Cassell (2nd nomination) WP:ENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18038 15820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Idris Tawfiq (3rd nomination) User:Nsk92 14:08, 29 March 2021 (UTC) delete Appears to be a combination of /. There are a few more mentions of the subject by other sources in relation to his conversion, but not enough for demonstrating / notability. Nothing appears to indicate notability on any other grounds such as or Deletion of Idris Tawfiq (3rd nomination) WP:BIO1E||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:GNG||WP:BIO||WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
18039 1737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sree Andalurkavu User:Allventon 17:12, 15 February 2009 (UTC) comment """http://tripatlas.com/Dharmadam is a mirror of a Wikipedia article, as noted by the disclaimer on the website: """"This article provided by Wikipedia."""" As a result, I do not believe the assertion on the website that the temple is """"a famous temple in Dharmadam ,during the festival of this Temple thousands of people used to make their devotions from different parts of Kannur and Calicut District"""" can be considered reliable. Thank you for showing that """"Sree"""" was not needed in a Google search; I didn't realize that. I could only find 5 other Ghits beside this website using the word """"Andalurkavu"""", 4 of which are restricted photos for me, and 1 a PDF document I am having trouble accessing for some reason. With regards to churches surviving AFD, I am afraid I wasn't aware of that precedent, so I am willing to dismiss my argument that the article should be deleted per WP:N. However, I believe that the lack of reliable sources to verify the subject of the article means that the article could be deleted per """ Deletion of Sree Andalurkavu WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18040 11734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Mattock User:Wesley 06:22, 12 May 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and the article seems to be a personal ego boost for the subject Deletion of Andrew Mattock WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
18041 20729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gaucho theory User:Neurolysis 21:56, 21 November 2008 (UTC) delete Per just about every delete vote so far. This meme is not widely followed, and fails . &mdash Deletion of Gaucho theory WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18042 10696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dental care of Guantanamo Bay detainees User:Bearian 20:52, 12 October 2010 (UTC) keep per , , and . It has three |good sources (since when is the US Government ''not'' a reliable source?) and is about what had been a controversial topic. An orphan article can be fixed with wikilinks. Many arcane an odd articles exist here at Wikipedia; we don't delete them but rather celebrate them Deletion of Dental care of Guantanamo Bay detainees WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE||WP:ODD||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18043 5112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dominik Bartmanski User:Bakazaka 18:00, 5 November 2018 (UTC) delete as the scholarly impact is relatively normal, no significantly influential idea or theory, no post as named chair or journal editor, no significant award, does not seem to be a widely-cited expert in the media, etc, so does not pass . Note also that higher number of citations is in work with multiple authors (which is not uncommon, but also weighs against individual impact). Perfectly adequate academic, maybe a more influential career ahead, but not notable enough for Wikipedia now Deletion of Dominik Bartmanski WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18044 19960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sittisak Tarapan [[User_talk:ClubOranje|T]] 22:42, 13 March 2011 (UTC) keep passes . Thai Premier league is listed as a fully professional league at Wikipedia:WikiProject_Football/Fully_professional_leagues and ref provided to show he has played there. Article needs improving not deleting.--ClubOranje Deletion of Sittisak Tarapan WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18045 7403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Controversy among United States mobile phone companies User:Harlowraman 02:58, 20 August 2007 (UTC) delete as per nom clearly fails Deletion of Controversy among United States mobile phone companies WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18046 1142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Hairy Monster User:Captain 09:33, 16 July 2006 (UTC) delete per |CSD:A7. Tagged it accordingly Deletion of Big Hairy Monster WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18047 3771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Benedict User:StAnselm 11:49, 9 March 2015 (UTC) keep the current state of the article is of little relevance in determining this; the relevant guideline is . I don't quite know what ''profeseur honoraire'' means in terms of criterion 5, but the Google Scholar results, headlined by works of 187 and 120 citations respectively, suggests that the subject passes criterion 1 Deletion of Philip Benedict WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18048 16461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Shiver User:Ad 13:59, 30 May 2014 (UTC) delete Subject fails and . Sources fail . Article is just another by a Deletion of Mike Shiver WP:BASIC||WP:CREATIVE||WP:RS||WP:PROMO||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Notability 77
18049 1966 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamas and the Taliban analogy User:JFlav 03:49, 8 November 2010 (UTC) delete as |original research, specifically for overuse of |primary sources. I agree with Deletion of Hamas and the Taliban analogy WP:OR||WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
18050 4174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AryoGen NONE NONE keep spaced ndash}} Meets per Deletion of AryoGen WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
18051 14840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Lord of the Rings: Gollum User:RoySmith 12:45, 31 August 2020 (UTC) delete per Deletion of The Lord of the Rings: Gollum WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18052 6043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donner Pass Derby User:Govvy 15:58, 8 May 2021 (UTC) delete article fails , Deletion of Donner Pass Derby WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18053 17968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rival Sons User:Michig 08:18, 25 October 2018 (UTC) keep The nomination appears to be judging the subject based solely on the article, and with flawed logic - several of the sources cited are not 'crappy blogs'. Four albums on Earache Records gives the band an easy pass of criterion 5. They have had three albums on the UK Albums Chart (https://www.officialcharts.com/artist/7634/rival-sons/), and two on the Billboard 200 (https://www.billboard.com/music/rival-sons) and well as placings on other Billboard charts (e.g. https://www.billboard.com/music/rival-sons/chart-history/independent-albums), easily satisfying criterion 2. Whatever sources are cited in the article, plenty of coverage exists in reliable sources, e.g. ''NME'': https://www.nme.com/news/music/rival-sons-1255203, ''MOJO'': https://www.mojo4music.com/articles/11762/rival-sons-new-album-behind-scenes-video, ''Rolling Stone'': https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/watch-rival-sons-bash-out-new-anthem-do-your-worst-723690/, Allmusic: https://www.allmusic.com/artist/rival-sons-mn0002672136/biography, https://www.allmusic.com/album/pressure-time-mw0002130234, https://www.allmusic.com/album/head-down-mw0002400742, https://www.allmusic.com/album/great-western-valkyrie-mw0002640729, https://www.allmusic.com/album/hollow-bones-mw0002927423, ''The Independent'': https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/features/rival-sons-interview-how-the-blues-rockers-have-forged-their-own-path-to-fame-10123483.html, https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/reviews/album-reviews-allen-toussaint-augustines-garbage-rival-sons-weird-dreams-the-invisible-a7072066.html, The Quietus: http://thequietus.com/articles/10762-rival-sons-interview, ''The Guardian'': https://www.theguardian.com/music/2012/sep/13/rival-sons-head-down-review, the BBC: http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/3v28/, http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/reviews/mbcg/, ''American Songwriter'': http://americansongwriter.com/2013/03/rival-sons-head-down-2/, ''Classic Rock'': https://www.loudersound.com/reviews/rival-sons-hollow-bones, ''Guitar Player'': https://www.guitarplayer.com/players/rival-sons-scott-holiday-preaches-the-classic-rock-gospel, ''GQ'': https://www.gq-magazine.co.uk/article/rival-sons-tour-uk-tour-tickets, ''Phoenix New Times'': https://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/music/rival-sons-jay-buchanan-never-wanted-to-be-a-rock-n-roll-frontman-6592530, ''The Northern Echo'': https://www.thenorthernecho.co.uk/news/13587011.Review__Rival_Sons__The_Point__Sunderland/, as well as further coverage unavailable online in publications such as ''Kerrang!'', easily satisfying criterion 1 of and Deletion of Rival Sons WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18054 5275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Small Town Murder User:Royboycrashfan 02:38, 9 February 2006 (UTC) delete doesn't meet Deletion of Small Town Murder WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18055 11607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Casino hotel NONE NONE keep The nomination completely misunderstands the essential nature of , for which the size of the article is quite irrelevant as the policy explains. As this is a major type of business, the topic is actually quite notable and it is easy to find substantial sources including Deletion of Casino hotel WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18056 10849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sidd Chaudhuri (basketball) User:Sandals1 16:05, 9 August 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and the GNG Deletion of Sidd Chaudhuri (basketball) WP:NHOOPS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18057 4121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kylyn User:Devonian 05:29, 2 May 2020 (UTC) merge to Kazumi Watanabe per Doomsdayer. As there is no significant coverage of this album, just passing mentions, it fails Deletion of Kylyn WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
18058 9570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allegations of Bias in the ABC User:Lankiveil 01:59, 24 March 2013 (UTC) delete """a classic article, clearly intended to promote the author's view that the ABC is a hotbed of lefty bolshie brainwashing. The """"source"""" of this is a whole bunch of inane bleating by right-wing commentators on the payroll of the ABC's commercial rivals. It is potentially a valid topic for an article, but if so the article would have to be junked and rewritten anyway to remove the bias""" Deletion of Allegations of Bias in the ABC WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
18059 3880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Bixby User:Bonadea 11:47, 17 March 2018 (UTC) delete I can't find any sources showing that the artist meets or . I have removed some of the art jargon/promotion from the article - some of that was copyright violating text as well Deletion of Brian Bixby WP:NARTIST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18060 9537 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of works with the subtitle """"Constancy Rewarded""""""" User:John 16:55, 23 May 2019 (UTC) merge """into the """"Virtue Rewarded"""" page. While this isn't as -y as it initially appears per Spinningspark, it still seems to be a subsidiary topic to the Virtue Rewarded page. &ndash""" """Deletion of List of works with the subtitle """"Constancy Rewarded""""""" WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
18061 5036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dear Sherlock User:KaisaL 23:56, 23 March 2017 (UTC) delete The television segment they were in doesn't meet because it doesn't appear to be a major national television network in Portugal, nor do we have sourcing that it was for broadcast or substantial. A band around for seven years in the 2010s ought to have lots of coverage by now, and they do not, one local BBC article isn't enough Deletion of Dear Sherlock WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
18062 6494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amanbek Esen Uulu User:David 13:42, 20 February 2017 (UTC) comment ping|L3X1}} {{ping|GuzzyG}} One of you says says it meets thlete, the other says no. I looked into that standard, and that got me to the Hockey requirements for notability: and /LA. I asked https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_Ice_Hockey/League_assessment#Notability this question on the talk page of /LA. If either of you can quote the standard that clearly says yes or no--I don't know much about hockey, but interested in learning the standards we use for sports players, since there are so many articles on them Deletion of Amanbek Esen Uulu WP:A||WP:NHOCKEY||WP:NHOCKEY||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Attribution 108
18063 7651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa McGregor User:Stalwart111 05:09, 21 July 2014 (UTC) delete I couldn't find anything beyond what seems to be listed in the article and what is listed in the article doesn't seem like enough for the subject to pass Deletion of Lisa McGregor WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18064 6786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Whyte User:E 15:22, 24 February 2009 (UTC) delete also. Fails both in basic criteria and athletes section in Deletion of Ben Whyte WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
18065 12283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandoz (Youtuber) User:Graywalls 06:55, 1 December 2019 (UTC) delete fails the guideline for talent/authors Deletion of Sandoz (Youtuber) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18066 863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Rajab Amin User:Anotherclown 05:43, 18 August 2012 (UTC) delete """individual subject lacks """"significant coverage"""" in reliable sources and is therefore not notable per """ Deletion of Omar Rajab Amin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18067 1416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/P. S. Srijith User:Akhiljaxxn 14:49, 30 July 2020 (UTC) delete per nom, subject fails and Deletion of P. S. Srijith WP:SIGCOV||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
18068 5482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naraka: Bladepoint User:Haleth 12:15, 22 August 2021 (UTC) keep per . A convenient litmus test to determine whether a game is subject to enough significant coverage to meet is whether they have a Metacritic score, which requires a minimum of four reviews for each relevant platform. https://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/naraka-bladepoint/critic-reviews At the time of writing, it has ten reviews, five of which are from undisputedly reliable sources according to /RS. |Article content does not determine the notability of the subject Deletion of Naraka: Bladepoint WP:NEXIST||WP:GNG||WP:VG||WP:ARTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
18069 11627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roger Crowley User:E 15:07, 27 October 2017 (UTC) keep Nom appears to misunderstand notability for authors, which derives form writing notable books. Many more reviews in exist than are on the page. Certainly article needs expansion. But Deletion of Roger Crowley WP:RS||WP:DELETIONISNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18070 17479 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Little Clive River User:Bearian 18:37, 29 January 2021 (UTC) delete per and . No, not every fork and creek is notable. It has to be shown by at least two reliable sources Deletion of Little Clive River WP:SIGCOV||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18071 11257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donna Upson (3rd nomination) User:Abd 20:37, 21 June 2008 (UTC) keep per the significant coverage in reliable sources already in the article spread over both the election and her earlier arrest. (so not ). Also per the lots of additional coverage in reliable sources found by Abd here Deletion of Donna Upson (3rd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18072 13447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alacra User:Coredesat 06:44, 24 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Alacra WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
18073 142 [[Extraterrestrisch]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Frado NONE delete Nach |NK falsche Form (Substantiv), dem Text nach eine WP:BKL|BKL, umwandeln oder Löschung von Extraterrestrisch Wikipedia:NK Wikipedia:Article titles 75
18074 8546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luke Fair User:Richard3120 23:56, 23 September 2018 (UTC) delete """fails and . He is responsible for one of my favourite progressive house remixes of all time (his remix of Max Graham's """"Tell You""""), but apart from a brief period in the mid-2000s when he was popular in progressive house circles, he hasn't ever been a big name, even in dance music. The two mix albums mentioned in the article and a handful of singles are the only things he's produced, and none of them have got anywhere near charting. Mr. Fair has scaled back his DJ career to concentrate on web development, and rarely plays outside Toronto these days, so scope for improving this article in future is going to be very limited""" Deletion of Luke Fair WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18075 15697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Locked Door (2012 film) User:Celestina007 20:59, 31 October 2017 (UTC) delete Non-notable film which falls short of Deletion of The Locked Door (2012 film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
18076 12809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Israel FC: Genesis [[User talk:131.118.229.18|talk]]) 15:14, 1 July 2011 (UTC) delete """The unknown user who voted Keep is correct when he says this event is as notable as the two Australian events he mentions--they should all be deleted as routine sports coverage. As for """"potentially more encyclopedic"""" I refer you to . Special:Contributions/131.118.229.18|131.118.229.18""" Deletion of Israel FC: Genesis WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18077 5623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Cambridge Working Group user:Andrew 11:49, 16 January 2021 (UTC) keep """This group was effective in getting a moratorium on dangerous virus experimentation in 2014. But then the experiments were resumed in 2017. And now we have a novel virus causing a global pandemic. The matter has naturally attracted attention such as https://www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3099(18)30006-9/fulltext this at each stage and this large group of scientists seems to be a significant part of the story. I'm not finding another article on Wikipedia which covers the history of this controversy in a more general way. If there is one, the worst case would be that we merge into it. Otherwise this will have to do as a start and we should be considering expansion. applies: """"''If editing can improve the page, this should be done rather than deleting the page""" Deletion of The Cambridge Working Group WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18078 13474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ralph Pucci [[User talk:104.163.153.162|talk]]) 00:05, 9 January 2018 (UTC) keep """the nominator should try some next time. I added significant review/profile articles from the Wall Street Journal, New York Times and Architecture Digest. I agree that """"having sources is not the same as have good sources."""", however this article has good sources. I've added a lot of good references, and I might add that he has made a significant contribution to the field of mannequin design, thereby satisfying Special:Contributions/104.163.153.162|104.163.153.162""" Deletion of Ralph Pucci WP:BEFORE||WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
18079 16156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alor Incident User:Maashatra11 12:04, 28 June 2010 (UTC) delete not notable, doesn't pass Deletion of Alor Incident WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18080 360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sokol Çikalleshi User:GiantSnowman 12:18, 24 June 2009 (UTC) delete per nom; non-notable player who fails Deletion of Sokol Çikalleshi WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18081 4732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jenny Quinn User:Nikki311 20:58, 1 November 2009 (UTC) delete fails , as she has not worked at the top level of her sport. Also seems to fail , as I couldn't find anything on her modeling career Deletion of Jenny Quinn WP:ATHLETE||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18082 8931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicholas Nip User:K 05:29, 19 June 2017 (UTC) delete then, per . The event (becoming the youngest master) is not significant enough to warrant an article in the absence of any other accomplishments Deletion of Nicholas Nip WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
18083 19831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donna Smith (journalist) User:Meters 01:19, 17 July 2021 (UTC) delete Can't find anything to show that this person passes or . Zero independent refs. The 13-year-old archived page (the only ref in the article) claims she is an award-winning journalist but does not specify what award or when. The three lines of content in this article were created in one edit in 2007, and have not changed since, so it appears that there is nothing more to say about her Deletion of Donna Smith (journalist) WP:JOURNALIST||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18084 4124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spanish Galleon, Greenwich User:MarkZusab 13:44, 11 May 2020 (UTC) keep per Philafrenzy. The place meets Deletion of Spanish Galleon, Greenwich WP:GEOFEAT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18085 4580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Red Pepper Chinese Cuisine User:S 23:28, 7 August 2008 (UTC) keep with edits for . I see three serious reviews in sources I find acceptably reliable. The nominator could have read those reviews and added an assertion of notability based on them, rather than invoking the afd process Deletion of Red Pepper Chinese Cuisine WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18086 20621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Italians User:Fountains 00:56, 7 March 2016 (UTC) delete """per - """"Lists that are too general or too broad in scope have little value"""". There are probably over 30,000 potential entries for this list, even if someone tried to limit to a subjective """"more notable"""". No way this short list is anything but OR or POV. arguments of """"there are similar lists"""" do not hold water. Now if someone wants to do the donkey work of organizing 30,000 articles into a """"list of lists"""" I'll change my vote""" Deletion of List of Italians WP:SALAT||WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
18087 9745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sapana gardens User:Trevj 11:16, 10 April 2012 (UTC) delete Appears to fail Deletion of Sapana gardens WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18088 5420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kissmetrics User:Safehaven86 17:44, 26 September 2016 (UTC) keep per sourcing listed above by NorthAmerica, this company meets Deletion of Kissmetrics WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18089 142 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ferec Kullanıcı:cemyildizcem yıldız NONE keep Ferec grubu |kayda değerlik 1 ve 6'ya net bir şekilde uyuyor. 4'üncü maddeye de uyması için bir kaç ay var Ferec'in silinmesi Vikipedi:MÜZİK Wikipedia:Notability 77
18090 135 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Auto Show Kullanıcı:nanahuatlnanahuatl 09.08, 31 Mart 2021 (UTC) comment """bu şekilde """"şu şu şu şu kaynaklar var"""" gibi gerekçeler https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Arguments_to_avoid_in_deletion_discussions#Lots_of_sources şurada anlatıldığı üzere kabul edilmiyor, öncelikle onu belirterek başlayayım. Kaynakları incelersek, ilk verdiğin tezde, benim görebildiğim kadarıyla yalnızca derginin haftalık olduğu bilgisi var, dergiyle alakalı başka bir bilgi sunmamakta. İkinci tez, ayrıntılı bir bilgi sunsa da hiçbir kaynak gösterilmemiş ilgili kısımda (böyle yüksek lisans tezi olur mu?). """"Anılar"""" diye verdiğin bağlantıdaki kişi, dergide çalıştığını ifade etmiş zaten ve sayfasındaki """"örnekler"""" kısmındaki tablonun ilk satırının ikinci sütununda, bu tip kaynakların bağımsız sayılmayacağı belirtiliyor. ''Milliyet'' gazetesine gelirsek, aynı firmanın bir yayını (Doğan Grubu) olduğundan yine sayfasının aynı yerine göre bağımsız olmayan kaynak. Toparlarsam, verdiğin kaynaklardan doğru düzgün tek bilgi sunanı bir yüksek lisans tezi, ancak ilgili kısımda da hiçbir kaynak sunulmamış ve zaten tezi, en sonra kullanılan kaynakları, bunların kullanım biçimlerini incelersek güvenilir kaynak olmadığı kanaatindeyim""" Otomatik Gösterinin silinmesi Vikipedi:BK Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18091 1604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angela Zhang (scientist) User:King 19:36, 12 July 2020 (UTC) keep Clearly meets with significant coverage in a combination of national (U.S. News, Atlantic) and local (Mercury) sources Deletion of Angela Zhang (scientist) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18092 9635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of terms of endearment (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 20:47, 14 January 2009 (UTC) delete per as an indiscriminate list of many NN ideas, per above. Or '''merge''' back into Terms of endearment, a valid scholarly topic for a comprehensive encyclopedia Deletion of List of terms of endearment (2nd nomination) WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
18093 4913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Human flu User:Bearian 22:43, 22 October 2007 (UTC) keep as a good article - notable per Ghits, fixed per , and well-sourced Deletion of Human flu WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
18094 15085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zak Elbouzedi (2nd nomination) User:Govvy 12:51, 14 March 2018 (UTC) keep There are no citations or external links, but he clearly passes according to this, http://www.soccerbase.com/players/player.sd?player_id=96130 Deletion of Zak Elbouzedi (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18095 2883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Panda Candies User:MER 07:36, 1 December 2006 (UTC) delete http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=%22The+Panda+Candies%22+-myspace&btnG=Search 11 ghits outside of myspace. Fails Deletion of The Panda Candies WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18096 1644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silvan Elves User:Zxcvbnm 07:24, 13 March 2020 (UTC) delete Fails . Entirely original research, and therefore, nothing to merge. No obvious target, and therefore it is better if users utilize the search function Deletion of Silvan Elves WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18097 10328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shivang Vaishnav [[User talk:174.254.194.88|talk]]) 07:54, 18 December 2020 (UTC) delete article's author removed speedy A7 template. References added don't come close to |ANYBIO or |NMUSIC. Only source speaking even possibly to notability, TOI, is a reprint from a much less reliable source and authored by a person with the same last name as the article's subject. No real claim made to notability and IMO A7 still applies. |BEFORE showed no better sources. Minimally, |TOOSOON. Special:Contributions/174.254.194.88|174.254.194.88 Deletion of Shivang Vaishnav WP:ANYBIO||WP:NMUSIC||WP:BEFORE||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
18098 19933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Duberrys User:Alphachimp 22:58, 17 July 2006 (UTC) delete for failure of per nom Deletion of The Duberrys WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
18099 16642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jezchat User:JzG 23:59, 19 January 2006 (UTC) delete """Is this a joke? Or does someone seriously think this is a real article? No, GoldenTie, web communities don't need to be """"tidied up"""", they need to be measured against , and if (like this one) they have ''no'' Alexa ranking at all, ''no'' Google News hits, ''no'' significant inbound links - in short ''no'' evidence of any significance whatsoever - then they need to be """"tidied up"""" into the bitbucket! This is an ''|encyclopaedia'', |not a directory of trivial websites. Seriously""" Deletion of Jezchat WP:WEB||WP:ENC||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18100 5729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad Gulzar Saifi User:Robofish 12:14, 31 January 2010 (UTC) merge to The Final Inch. There are plenty of references here - enough to verify the article - but not enough to establish notability independent from the film. I think this is basically a case, and he would be best covered by being merged into the article on the film Deletion of Mohammad Gulzar Saifi WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18101 3488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anozie Ugochukwu Calistus User:Fenix 08:31, 27 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Anozie Ugochukwu Calistus WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18102 17241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nate Costa User:Monty845 18:32, 1 October 2011 (UTC) keep Subject meets the , independent reliable sources wrote articles about him as an individual Deletion of Nate Costa WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18103 20872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rattikorn Kunsom User:Ad 20:38, 20 May 2015 (UTC) delete Unable to find any in depth coverage from reliable sources. Subject fails and Deletion of Rattikorn Kunsom WP:BASIC||WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
18104 10874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kingdom Hearts Showdown User:TheFarix 19:06, 2 September 2006 (UTC) delete self-admitted #Wikipedia is not a soapbox|advertisement. I'll also add that the advert is entirely |original research without using |verifiable and |reliable sources and has a clear |POV. It also has elements of a #Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information|game guide Deletion of Kingdom Hearts Showdown WP:NOT||WP:NOR||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NPOV||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18105 3942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kreuz Oranienburg User:The 02:13, 31 December 2015 (UTC) delete Autobahn interchanges are all named; there is no significant inference of notability from the mere fact that it is a named interchange. There is no apparent evidence that this meets . These should probably be part of a list - there would be no objection to redirects to the individual Autobahns' pages Deletion of Kreuz Oranienburg WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18106 21301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lindsey Haley User:Kncny11 17:08, 11 June 2021 (UTC) delete fails and . https://www.kcet.org/shows/departures/lindsey-haley-chicano-poet-and-activist This is pretty much all I could find about her Deletion of Lindsey Haley WP:SIGCOV||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18107 15485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noctuam Society User:Ashram321 14:37, 13 April 2016 (UTC) comment """There is more than enough Precedent|precedence for the continued existence of this page and I believe the argument for the group's |""""notability"""" has been very well established by myself and others above. This page has already been shown to be of great interest regarding a notable and seclusive organization""" Deletion of Noctuam Society WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18108 20938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarai Sierra User:MelanieN 03:03, 10 June 2015 (UTC) delete This case doesn't seem to have achieved the required impact or lasting notability for an article here. Wikipedia is not the news. BTW we don't have articles about murder victims, because they are not notable in themselves. We have an article about the crime, if it meets the criteria of . So this article should be retitled Murder of Sarai Sierra if it is kept - which I don't think it should be Deletion of Sarai Sierra WP:CRIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
18109 709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdul Traya User:Chiswick 18:52, 21 January 2012 (UTC) delete an open-and-shut case. No notability whatsoever. Even if the single event were of interest, it would fall foul of . But it isn't even that Deletion of Abdul Traya WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18110 12933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corey schafer User:1292simon 13:47, 25 May 2013 (UTC) delete Does not pass Deletion of Corey schafer WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18111 6850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Democratic Party (United States) presidential primaries, 2012 User:JulesH 20:16, 2 December 2008 (UTC) delete unless somebody finds something |veriable to say about the subject. The article currently says, essentially, nothing, and history revisions that have said something have all been unsourced speculation Deletion of Democratic Party (United States) presidential primaries, 2012 WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18112 7894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Duncan Ronald Gordon Mackay User:Mztourist 09:28, 31 December 2020 (UTC) delete fails and , nothing notable Deletion of Duncan Ronald Gordon Mackay WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18113 14529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian Spectre User:AllyD 10:00, 31 July 2017 (UTC) delete No |evidence found to suggest that this cartoon character is of |encyclopaedic notability Deletion of Ian Spectre :WP:RS||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18114 17469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Dalton User:Hongkongresident 06:46, 30 October 2010 (UTC) delete http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Chris+Dalton%22+Acquity&hl=en&safe=off&rlz=1T4TSNA_enUS385US385&tbs=nws:1,ar:1&source=lnt&sa=X&ei=mr7LTPuRAYOglAfIh-3kCA&ved=0CBMQpwU There are seach results, but they're mainly PR releases or trivial mentions. The article does not meet the criteria at Deletion of Chris Dalton WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18115 17263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paraduin User:Eggishorn 17:30, 19 June 2017 (UTC) delete The are not actually about this micronation, and the sources about this micronation are not reliable. It is not impossible for micronations to qualify under (See Principality of Sealand|Sealand and Principality of Hutt River for the most prominent examples). This one, however, doesn't show anything available in sources that would qualify Deletion of Paraduin WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18116 3542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess Elisabeth Maria of Bavaria User:Bearian 20:42, 30 July 2020 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Princess Elisabeth Maria of Bavaria WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
18117 21782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammad Arshad Khan User:Freshacconci 23:48, 30 August 2012 (UTC) delete There are a great deal of words on the page but they add up to very little that supports notability per . The sources provided are for the most part promotional in nature and are either press release copy, fluff pieces of little value (for our purposes) or passing mentions. If we were to edit out the POV wording and aggrandizing prose, we'd be left with very little. Simply does not pass Deletion of Muhammad Arshad Khan WP:ARTIST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18118 16660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandalwood Talkies User:K 03:07, 21 January 2018 (UTC) delete fails , , . A directory-like listing on an nn distribution company. These are rarely notable and this one misses the mark Deletion of Sandalwood Talkies WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:NOTCATALOG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18119 20743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Owu Kingdom User:Oluwa2Chainz 22:09, 27 August 2016 (UTC) keep topic beats and as it stretches to Kwara State|Kwara, Osun State|Osun and Ogun States per ''http://thenationonlineng.net/obasanjo-aregbesola-meet-on-orile-owu-chieftaincy-tussle/ The Nation''. Reputable people including Ibikunle Amosun, Samuel Adegboyega and Olusegun Obasanjo per ''http://citypeopleng.com/meet-30-prominent-owu-sons-daughters/ City People Magazine Deletion of Owu Kingdom WP:GNG||WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
18120 12904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agrizoophobia NONE NONE delete per nom and per Deletion of Agrizoophobia WP:NOTDICTIONARY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18121 5090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunnyhillselementary User:Cullen328 03:02, 26 March 2014 (UTC) merge to Issaquah School District per long established precedent described in Deletion of Sunnyhillselementary WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18122 791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stavros Damianides User:Bbb23 21:53, 24 January 2014 (UTC) comment I believe the article infringes the copyright of Australian Walkabout Magazine based on a supposed copy of the article online. I tried to tag it per #G12, but the online site is blacklisted. Assuming the blacklisted site is correct, much of the Wikipedia article is copied word for word Deletion of Stavros Damianides WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18123 1136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Dunn (businessman) User:Bearian 18:18, 9 January 2014 (UTC) delete unless soembody finds and adds more information. There is a ''WSJ'' article about his work, but we need more |significant coverage. His name is common enough that |online searches are prolematic Deletion of Tim Dunn (businessman) WP:SIGCOV||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18124 9268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riskay User:Simon 22:25, 30 January 2009 (UTC) delete """Non-notable; criterion 1 is the only colorable theory for inclusion, and even that fails, requiring a musician (purported or actual) to have """"been the ''subject'' of ''multiple'' and ''non-trivial'' published works."""" Her mentions in the New York Times and the New Yorker are trivial, amounting to a couple of sentences buried in articles about multiple subjects.- Simon Dodd""" Deletion of Riskay WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18125 21035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Openad User:Breno 17:30, 4 January 2008 (UTC) delete Unsure why #G11 was declined. Obvious advertising. Similar article OpenAd was speedied yesterday under G11 Deletion of Openad WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18126 18933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Tash [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 03:31, 26 November 2012 (UTC) keep per re-worked article (nice work!) and sources provided therein. I'm satisfied they are enough to meet Deletion of Maria Tash WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18127 19484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oleg Czougeda User:Northamerica1000 22:48, 13 October 2012 (UTC) keep This person appears to pass Deletion of Oleg Czougeda WP:NCYCLING Wikipedia:Notability 77
18128 6475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chaotic Desimator User:Gatoclass 05:59, 6 September 2007 (UTC) delete completely unsourced and violates Deletion of Chaotic Desimator WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18129 13437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanmaya Bhatnagar user:Mamushir 14:29, 20 December 2020 (UTC) delete per discussion. May be Deletion of Tanmaya Bhatnagar WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
18130 16640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yousef Al-Saraff User:IJA 18:26, 14 August 2014 (UTC) delete He hasn't played in a Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|Fully professional league & he doesn't have any international caps therefore he fails Deletion of Yousef Al-Saraff WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18131 2771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tracey Curtis-Taylor User:Aircorn 06:19, 30 October 2016 (UTC) keep This is a tricky one. I read the article, the above and most of the talk page and am in two minds still. Most of the good sources mention the flight and then the resulting controversy. It does lead into territory. Many other sources that mention other aspects are weak, but there are probably enough in between to justify keeping it. Maybe a merge would be the best solution, although I can't think of a suitable target Deletion of Tracey Curtis-Taylor WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
18132 8365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cooks the Bakery User:Arxiloxos 04:43, 3 February 2014 (UTC) keep per {{u|Northamerica1000}}. A major UK chain with 100+ outlets at one time and plenty of sources. Passes and Deletion of Cooks the Bakery WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
18133 11494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Go! (programming language) (2nd nomination) User:Lsmll 10:16, 28 June 2013 (UTC) keep There are references from different sources,and the language is notable enough,which doesn't fail Deletion of Go! (programming language) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18134 13215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MobileRobots inc User:Stifle 23:53, 3 April 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of MobileRobots inc WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18135 10473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erez Aviram User:Handoto 00:34, 24 October 2018 (UTC) keep certainly has some independent sources, just enough to cover to my knowledge Deletion of Erez Aviram WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18136 8035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phinditt User:Frank 19:29, 16 July 2009 (UTC) delete A http://news.google.com/archivesearch?pz=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Phinditt%22&cf=all google ''news'' search shows zero hits. That the site exists is not in question. That it is not currently notable is also not, in my view, in question, and it's still regardless. (Disclosure: I speedied this article yesterday as a G11, which it still is; it was also then (and remains) an A7 Deletion of Phinditt WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
18137 17938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Hogg User:Hunterm267 18:13, 27 February 2018 (UTC) keep Without the notability of all of the articles and media attention, I would certainly argue this would be part of , but due to the media attention and vast number of references, I think the article is sufficiently notable Deletion of David Hogg WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18138 6574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Regresa (Chantal Andere album) User:CAPTAIN 19:20, 28 February 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Regresa (Chantal Andere album) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18139 6117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NED Foundation Higher Secondary School User:4meter4 02:33, 25 October 2019 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of NED Foundation Higher Secondary School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18140 14281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle of Yonkers User:RPIRED 12:51, 11 July 2007 (UTC) merge """whatever can be merged into World War Z (which has major cleanup issues, perhaps should include """"Wikipedia is not a novel"""") and then '''redirect'''. The book itself doesn't seem to be notable enough to require branches like these no matter how important the fictional events are to the progression of the story""" Deletion of Battle of Yonkers WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18141 17562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Web Analytics in India User:Ihcoyc 14:05, 6 August 2009 (UTC) delete an essay of |original research. Reads like an |advertising brochure promoting the wonderful things that outsourcing your IT department to India can do: ''Online marketing managers and business heads of companies need to often make strategic marketing decisions. For this they require informative data in the form of dashboards Deletion of Web Analytics in India WP:OR||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:No original research 65
18142 10436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Visual Effects Companies In India User:Mailer 17:24, 21 April 2015 (UTC) delete Firstly, |Wikipedia is not a directory: the article is too specialized and it itself is an orphan. Otherwise Singapore can have its own article too. Secondly and more importantly, this list lacks |reliable sources. Finally, categories are a perfect substitute and a more appropriate method in contrast to this list Deletion of List of Visual Effects Companies In India WP:NOTDIR||WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18143 19740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Team Go User:Pan 22:29, 9 May 2007 (UTC) merge to Minor allies in Kim Possible. #IINFO|In-universe and supported by zero external sources. Appears to have been copied from Minor allies in Kim Possible, which itself is in-universe and supported by zero external sources and should probably be redirected to Kim Possible Deletion of Team Go WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18144 11438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S. V. Divvaakar User:Kj 12:07, 19 June 2021 (UTC) delete Insufficient independant coverage to warrant a pass of or Deletion of S. V. Divvaakar WP:NAUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18145 1403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naomi Hunter User:Lefcentreright 17:38, 8 September 2020 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet . Hunter is the leader of a small provincial political party Deletion of Naomi Hunter WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18146 9591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kacey Khaliel (3rd nomination) User:Eggishorn 22:04, 20 August 2017 (UTC) delete Does not pass or . Significant coverage is in sources that are either not independent or not reliable Deletion of Kacey Khaliel (3rd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18147 1954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph M. Still Burn Center User:Dhartung 04:25, 30 March 2008 (UTC) keep """largest privately-owned burn center in the US is a strong claim to notability. (Note that New York Presbyterian's Hearst Burn Center is probably the largest overallhttp://www.nyp.org/services/burn-center.html, despite some stories about Still dropping the """"private"""".) Certainly there are numerous sources demonstrating an ability to pass """ Deletion of Joseph M. Still Burn Center WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18148 5711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Westphal User:Sir 15:22, 9 October 2016 (UTC) delete Since the international matches he played were not Tier 1, the article does not meet Deletion of Daniel Westphal WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18149 9449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isolde Fair User:doomsdayer520 14:51, 4 June 2020 (UTC) delete The article's sloppy state and support from a (nearly) |single-purpose account show that it could be an attempted |promotion by a volunteer who may not understand what Wikipedia is for. In response to a commenter above, in this particular discussion, what matters is |notability rather than neutrality. is relevant because Ms. Fair received some momentary coverage for one story that was noticed by some media sources, but this does not bestow notability on any of her other work as a musician, professionally or otherwise Deletion of Isolde Fair WP:SPA||WP:PROMOTION||WP:GNG||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
18150 17431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John S. Weinberg User:Ohnoitsjamie 14:31, 24 April 2018 (UTC) delete No evidence of or notability Deletion of John S. Weinberg WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18151 10056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amika Shail User:David 14:45, 21 July 2016 (UTC) delete Only refs cited are the subject's web page and something called Awesong.in, which is absolutely not a |reliable source. I've looked for better sources. I cannot find any, let alone |significant, coverage in reliable sources. The subject is not |notable, or at least |not yet notable Deletion of Amika Shail WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV||WP:N||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18152 21054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Symbols of Scientology User:Zahakiel 21:19, 1 March 2008 (UTC) keep Religious symbolism is a notable topic, of which we have many articles on Wikipedia. Lest I be ed, I say this only to point out that there seems to be a general consensus that the symbols of various religious organizations (and Scientology is certainly a notable religious organization) is suitable for inclusion. The nominator's point that we can't even show the symbols is unfortunately true, but there is enough to be gained by discussing them in text to provide some understanding of the symbols utilized Deletion of Symbols of Scientology WP:WAX Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18153 9576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Muller User:SmartGuy 14:06, 5 April 2007 (UTC) delete nowhere even close to noteworthy subject. I put a speedy tag on it. Anytime you see a new article about a high school student, it's a fair assumption that the article qualifies for Deletion of Alex Muller WP:SPEEDY Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18154 21470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abubakar Sani Bello User:Bearcat 22:10, 22 February 2018 (UTC) keep Some cleanup and referencing improvement is definitely needed here, but the topic |verifiably holds a political role that constitutes a must-keep under . By comparison, the only way a state governor in the United States, a state or provincial premier in Canada or Australia, a state ''Ministerpräsident'' in Germany, etc., would ''ever'' be deleted is if they were actually an unverifiable hoax Deletion of Abubakar Sani Bello WP:V||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18155 9866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of J-pop artists (2nd nomination) User:Quasirandom 19:42, 2 August 2008 (UTC) keep The nomination rationale seems be, essentially, that the list isn't well-developed yet and doesn't yet provide enough information for context. As we all knw, Bob, it is official policy that |being a stub is not a wikicrime. I'd be happier with the article if it clarified that it's a list of ''notable'' J-pop artists and had the redlinks culled Deletion of List of J-pop artists (2nd nomination) WP:EP Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
18156 13463 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Dark Tower series film adaptation User:DustFormsWords 05:38, 25 November 2011 (UTC) delete """per . Last I heard this was off again anyway, so as of right now it's more likely than not that no movie will ever be made. The small amount of encyclopaedically relevant information can be adequately summarised on one of the existing Dark Tower articles under a """"film adaptations"""" section, in the style of upcoming or failed adaptation attempts in other franchises""" Deletion of The Dark Tower series film adaptation WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18157 14411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francesca List User:Metropolitan90 01:06, 25 December 2006 (UTC) delete Nobody could have become notable under by virtue of being a contestant on Studio 7 due to the low viewership and lack of significant media attention to the program Deletion of Francesca List WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18158 2947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/China Attacks User:SlamDiego 14:04, 19 November 2009 (UTC) delete No indication of |“notability Deletion of China Attacks WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18159 4931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AFL Central Queensland Highlands User:Tirin NONE delete Could not find any secondary sources using Google News All Dates. The only primary sources found are derivatives of the wikipedia article. Article does not meet and is unlikely to do so Deletion of AFL Central Queensland Highlands WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18160 1068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tourneys in A Song of Ice and Fire (2nd nomination) User:Reyk 07:00, 24 July 2010 (UTC) delete excessive fan trivia. Wikipedia is not an |indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of Tourneys in A Song of Ice and Fire (2nd nomination) WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18161 19091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Booton (actor) User:Theodore 02:10, 18 August 2013 (UTC) delete Doesn't seem to meet . He may have played a significant role in mildly-notable films, but |no reliable sources substantiate this, and he fails the other two criteria Deletion of Joseph Booton (actor) WP:ENT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18162 19544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethnic English User:RGTraynor 14:13, 29 May 2007 (UTC) comment Can Wikipedia cope with a new term? If there are |reliable, published, independent, third-party sources. |Wikipedia is not a publisher of first instance Deletion of Ethnic English WP:RS||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18163 20931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Eatock User:B 17:32, 15 April 2010 (UTC) delete being the creator of a logo used in a televised game show is insufficient for (and it's not even worth the redirect to the article on the show). Much more needs to be demonstrated to meet Deletion of Daniel Eatock WP:CREATIVE||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18164 20982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Salama (2nd nomination) User:Mcmatter 00:47, 27 September 2010 (UTC) delete Does not meet , none, but one, of the references is about the subject. The one that is, is only his status with the California Bar. There is not even a claim of significance or notability in the article Deletion of Joseph Salama (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18165 18377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of out-of-town shopping centres in the United Kingdom User:Hrafn 15:14, 27 November 2010 (UTC) delete unmaintainable , best handled as categories Deletion of List of out-of-town shopping centres in the United Kingdom WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18166 19811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bradford murders User:Necrothesp 15:28, 6 May 2012 (UTC) keep Very heavily covered in the media and therefore clearly notable. A quick read of will establish that this article does not fall within its scope Deletion of Bradford murders WP:NOTNEWSPAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18167 1435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah D. Goode User:Cdjp1 23:11, 23 April 2020 (UTC) keep per . She's not a pop psychologist; she's a sociologist who's been recognized for her work in her field. There are multiple reviews of her books, other academics reference her work, and she's treated by the press as an expert in understanding pedophiles Deletion of Sarah D. Goode WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
18168 19957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Red Gambit User:Marchjuly 07:44, 20 November 2015 (UTC) delete """I tired looking for better sourcing for the series as a whole and for the individual books, but could not find anything at all which provides the significant coverage required by or . Google Books does have https://www.google.co.jp/search?hl=ja&tbo=p&tbm=bks&q=bibliogroup:%22Red+Gambit+Series%22&source=gbs_metadata_r&cad=2 some pages about the individual books, but not sure if that is really enough in and of itself to show notability, especially for something which seems to be self-published. I also couldn't find anything on the author other than social media pages and some mentions on Amazon or Goodreads pages, so it doesn't seem as if they would satisfy making a possible merge of the series article into an author's article unlikely. Will be happy to change !vote if others are able to find better sourcing, but I don't believe such sources appear to exist per item """"D"""" of """ Deletion of Red Gambit :WP:GNG||:WP:NBOOK||:WP:BASIC||:WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18169 13355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meri Jung Ka Elaan User:Aervanath 16:56, 2 November 2020 (UTC) delete """Fails or as it does not have """"significant coverage"""". Most of the references are the very definition of """"insignificant coverage"""": they mention the name of the film and almost nothing more. The Box Office India page is merely a recitation of basic box office data and doesn't include any reviews or other proof that the film has independent notability""" Deletion of Meri Jung Ka Elaan WP:GNG||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
18170 7580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iqbal Ahmed Khan User:wintonian 02:34, 17 May 2013 (UTC) delete Not much to add to the above comments really, just that the article certainly does assert notability per , but there seem to be no sources (in English at least) that support this and whilst the name seems to be fairly common I think we would need a good source that makes clear that the subject is this same person and not just their namesake with similar characteristics. I think this is going to be one of those articles that would be primarily supported by foreign language sources if it is retained and any can be found, until then I don't think it should remain Deletion of Iqbal Ahmed Khan WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
18171 6615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Galuh Noor Hendrayana User:IJA 09:26, 2 December 2014 (UTC) delete He hasn't played in a Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|Fully professional league and he doesn't have any senior international caps either therefore he fails Deletion of Galuh Noor Hendrayana WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18172 7607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William J. Marks, Sr. User:SudoGhost 21:24, 29 August 2012 (UTC) delete The subject's only notability is a single crime plea, which falls squarely into Deletion of William J. Marks, Sr. WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18173 21267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergey Pershin user:Hannes 11:43, 31 August 2021 (UTC) delete """I dont see a reason to treat scientists within a purely local context, a scientific contribution is equally important no matter who and where in the world it is made. Also looking at his https://academic.microsoft.com/author/2717311145 MA profile I do see many publications but few with a strong impact as per analysis above (already the 5th paper has 28 citations only and a total of 220 papers are listed for the subject but an h-index of 17 speaks to a lower number of quality papers). I cannot see the argument here for #1. Even the most cited paper Colao et al on double pulse LIBS is included as a listing in a review of LIBS as a key paper but not singled out, so probably not truly a landmark paper: """"Fortunately, several very informative reviews and key papers have been written by leading groups in this field double pulse LIBS, in addition to a few modeling papers (see, for example, Babushok et al., 22 Noll et al., 307 Scaffidi et al., 325 Mao et al., 317 Colao et al., 301 Corsi et al., 306 Piñon and Anglos, 335 De Giacomo et al., 26,333 Bogaerts et al., 165 and Rai et al. 167""" Deletion of Sergey Pershin WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18174 6949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sound devastation records User:Esradekan 08:34, 27 July 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per . Searching finds no significant coverage in |reliable, third-party, sources. While some of the bands on the label may be notable, there is nothing to show why this company has stand alone notability Deletion of Sound devastation records WP:CORP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18175 12645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Career Toppers User:AllyD 06:43, 23 May 2017 (UTC) delete A promotional-tone article on a business, sourced only to a case-search page. Searches, including the tailored Wikiproject India search, are locating no |evidence of |notability Deletion of Career Toppers :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18176 1428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicholas McAnulty User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:08, 17 December 2009 (UTC) delete without prejudice toward recreation. If is not met, becomes the determinant. That he is written of in numerous reliable sources is to be considered toward his possible meeting of . However, since that coverage is '''for''' that one role, this seems to be 1E. Let him get another role and receive coverage for that as well, and he may then better meet Deletion of Nicholas McAnulty WP:ENT||WP:GNG||WP:BLP||WP:BLP1E||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18177 193 [[TSVE_Bielefeld]] (schnellgelöscht) Benutzer:Frank Murmann NONE delete Und genau deswegen hat sich der Artikel MTV Itzehoe Eagles auch gerade nen Löschantrag eingefangen ... Laut |WP:RK sind beide irrelevant Löschung von TSVE_Bielefeld Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
18178 13972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Darkest Night User:Erik 02:09, 21 June 2011 (UTC) delete as a topic not |verifiable, much less |notable. It almost seems like a hoax article that has been under the radar for so long Deletion of The Darkest Night WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18179 4364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1692 Subbotina (2nd nomination) User:Praemonitus 20:21, 26 April 2015 (UTC) merge per . All I found are data entries with no substantial coverage Deletion of 1692 Subbotina (2nd nomination) WP:DWMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18180 18952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comprehensive study of aging and free radicals User:MastCell 19:20, 9 September 2008 (UTC) delete the comprehensive assessment article as impossibly |original research (essentially an essay) and a |unecessary content fork. The platinum nanoparticles article, I would lean toward '''deletion''', but '''keep and rewrite from scratch''' would also be an option. It will require a near-complete rewrite to comply with Wikipedia's policies on |verifiability, |appropriate sourcing, |original research, and |undue weight Deletion of Comprehensive study of aging and free radicals WP:NOR||WP:POVFORK||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NOR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
18181 14052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Chalmers User:Bidgee NONE delete May not be a hoax but someone who has only played Australian Rules on a local level but it fails and and has no reliable sources Deletion of Bruce Chalmers WP:NOTABILITY||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18182 9963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Butterfly tent User:Deor 14:31, 28 February 2009 (UTC) delete """Fails . (And """"the word for tent in Latin is Pavillion, while the word for butterfly in Latin is Patillion"""" is Wikipedia:Complete bollocks|complete bollocks""" Deletion of Butterfly tent WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18183 20013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daud Arsala User:Piotrus 08:23, 10 September 2019 (UTC) delete Seems to fail Deletion of Daud Arsala WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18184 2294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Premiership of Stephen Harper User:Torchiest 19:32, 8 April 2011 (UTC) keep How can this even be up for debate? I know, I know, , but this is analogous to Premiership of Gordon Brown and Presidency of Barack Obama. Clearly a notable subject, and yeah maybe it needs work, but deletion shouldn't even be on the list of options for this type of article. It's been around for four and a half years without problems. I don't think this falls under the purview of Canadian law either, unless they burn books before elections. If it's |spammy or |POV, fix it, simple as that Deletion of Premiership of Stephen Harper WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS||WP:SPAM||WP:POV Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18185 19280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Snakes in Suits User:Penbat 09:36, 2 March 2017 (UTC) comment Almost certainly also meets no. 5 of as well as one of the authors, Robert D. Hare, has guru status in the psychopathy field Deletion of Snakes in Suits WP:BOOKCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18186 9022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I am ghost User:Cdcon 18:42, 28 February 2006 (UTC) keep Jcbarr gives a correct argument in stating this article does not satisfy WP:MUSIC. The one verifiable source of notability is the Metal Hammer magazine. Metal Hammer is a somewhat widely circulated UK rock music magazine, awarding the band with a sliver of notability. I have seen much less notable articles kept (especially via ), so I hesitate to delete an article that is borderline failing the relatively stringent music criterion Deletion of I am ghost WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18187 16317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of screen capture software User:ColourBurst 15:33, 27 February 2007 (UTC) comment List of Star Trek races are an aspect of fiction in a notable work of fiction; they have their |own guidelines. This isn't comparable. I'm not sure how you can keep an article with eternal redlinks without having it become a linkfarm Deletion of List of screen capture software WP:WAF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
18188 18805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scene (2010s subculture) User:Kuyabribri 22:21, 26 February 2010 (UTC) comment """Per the proposed deletion process is for articles where an article is """"''uncontestably'' deletable"""" (original emphasis). The article creator is quite opposed to the deletion. Whether his/her reasoning behind that is in good faith or within policy is irrelevant; the mere fact that someone has objected to the deletion means this article fails the primary criteria for deletion via prod. &mdash""" Deletion of Scene (2010s subculture) WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
18189 9403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brain in a Jar (Dungeons & Dragons) User:Gavin 14:27, 6 March 2008 (UTC) delete Non-notable http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=dnd/lists/monsters stock character with no |reliable secondary sources to demonstrate real world |notability outside D&D. This article fails #GUIDE, #PLOT, and as well, so none of its content is worth keeping or merging Deletion of Brain in a Jar (Dungeons & Dragons) WP:RS||WP:FICT||WP:NOT||WP:NOT||WP:WEASEL||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18190 17341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Creed User:David 15:25, 5 May 2008 (UTC) comment Yes there is. #G3 may be used for blatant hoaxes Deletion of Sean Creed WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18191 16646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lightfoot (Transformers) User:The 14:09, 14 October 2013 (UTC) merge to List of Transformers: Super-God Masterforce characters. There is no |out-of-universe notability, however as part of the group he is worth mentioning, so coverage in the list is appropriate Deletion of Lightfoot (Transformers) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18192 7343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/General Technics User:Shoessss 21:00, 16 December 2008 (UTC) keep I was really up in the air about this one. However, after reviewing the guidelines under otability|Notability and the way it applies to organizations like this one, as listed under '''Wikipedia:Notability (organizations and companies)|3.1 Non-commercial organizations''', I came down on the keep side for two reasons. The first is that the requirement for inclusion states that “…The scope of their activities is national or international in scale. “ This can be judged easily by looking at their membership list and can be verified by the coverage in the book Science Fiction Culture, as shown here http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=oCvIZpCSRA0C&oi=fnd&pg=PA11&dq=%22General+Technics%22+science+fiction&ots=5-EqcfpSrM&sig=DRcFuB8Q-_yilC04SNmu2EinjGM The second reason is that: “…Information about the organization and its activities can be verified by third-party, independent, reliable sources.” This again can be easily proved by this reference. www.absoluteastronomy.com/topics/Hard_science_fiction. Tough call, but have to go with Keep. Thanks Deletion of General Technics WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18193 1902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prof K E Viswanathan User:Utcursch 05:18, 24 October 2006 (UTC) delete Fails . Also Deletion of Prof K E Viswanathan WP:PROF||WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18194 4191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephanie Poole User:PMDrive1061 17:07, 27 June 2009 (UTC) delete and invoking both and as a hoax both here and on that phony blog. Blocking the user as well. This individual has already wasted enough valuable volunteer time with this nonsense Deletion of Stephanie Poole WP:BOLD||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Be bold 9
18195 6195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daily Sham User:Malcolmxl5 18:21, 23 October 2017 (UTC) delete I can’t find any |significance coverage about this newspaper with which to write an article or to show it meets Deletion of Daily Sham WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18196 2199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LinuxDC++ NONE NONE comment """Most criticisms of that I've seen involve it being too inclusive (especially the free-software clause). Yet you seem to be using its still-tentative status as a justification for being even ''more'' inclusive. In the absence of more specific guidelines, the general guideline that prevails in AfDs is non-trivial coverage by multiple |reliable sources. If you're going to ignore (which, while somewhat controversial in parts, is usually well-received in AfD discussions), you should be providing more standard evidence of notability, not just saying, effectively, """"keep 'cause I think it should be kept""" Deletion of LinuxDC++ WP:RS||WP:SOFTWARE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18197 15380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/California State Route 37 User:Daniel 04:28, 8 February 2007 (UTC) keep Well written, well sourced. Easily meets . It doesn't need to be the deadliest highway in the world to get an article Deletion of California State Route 37 WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18198 7517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cal Marshall User:Sam 19:28, 16 May 2018 (UTC) delete Fails the subject-specific notability guideline and Deletion of Cal Marshall WP:BASIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18199 11987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Park Joy User:Karst 11:15, 10 August 2014 (UTC) delete Fails on all fronts - redirect to the group until she launches a career of her own or becomes the primary focus of the group Deletion of Park Joy WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18200 2672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tagaru User:DrStrauss 13:22, 11 February 2017 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Tagaru WP:MOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18201 10090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of left communist organizations by country User:Redditaddict69 01:44, 20 January 2019 (UTC) merge to List of communist parties. This content has almost no sourcing at all and may not be |verifiable Deletion of List of left communist organizations by country WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18202 21401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Suprun User:Bearcat 21:15, 3 April 2017 (UTC) delete While he did get a bit of media coverage for his electoral college action, that just makes him a . He doesn't need a standalone biography for this; a brief mention in the ''concept'' article on faithless electors is all that's actually warranted Deletion of Christopher Suprun WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18203 21476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One World - Many Cultures User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable. &mdash Deletion of One World - Many Cultures WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18204 19902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of recluses User:Rhododendrites 21:29, 25 January 2020 (UTC) keep there are sufficient sources linked above (and which I'm seeing in my own search) to show that this passes . All of the other issues raised here can be hashed out on the talk page (if there are BLP issues, limit it to dead people, for example). &mdash Deletion of List of recluses WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
18205 20239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thumbs Up! User:Starblind 17:21, 28 December 2005 (UTC) delete per . After deletion, I suggest a redirect to Thums Up Deletion of Thumbs Up! WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18206 21210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Wars Episode VII (2nd nomination) User:Coppaar 23:15, 31 October 2012 (UTC) comment """My thoughts are these: The first and best policy to look at here is Wikipedia:Notability (films)|WP:NFF. '''This film has not started principle photography''', and it is clearly outlined that in this scenario, a film should not yet have its own page. But wait, we're not done yet, because there are a few Wikipedia:Planned films|WP:FFEXCEPTIONS. Has the film's pre-production or planning generated """"multiple non-trivial news stories""""? No it has not, '''the only news story as yet is the announcement in and of itself'''. Is the coverage of the topic of the film's production """"enduring and persistent in multiple reliable sources and over an extended period?"""" No, unless you consider a couple days to be an extended period. Is there not a suitable redirect target? Of course there is, as we've been saying, '''Star Wars sequel trilogy is an entirely appropriate redirect'''. And, is there too much information to redirect the article? I think not, considering that '''the sequel trilogy page already contains almost all the relevant information we know''' about Episode VII. So pretty clearly, this is no exception to NFF. The only recourse you have if you want it kept is , so let's address that. Why is keeping Episode VII in Wikipedia's best interest? Say we redirect it: people wanting to know about the film may search for Episode VII under that name, and find themselves at the sequel trilogy page. What's the big deal? They were announced jointly, because they are in a sense one and the same. The information about Episode VII is the same information we have about the rest of the trilogy, because it all came from a single statement by Disney. So people won't miss Episode VII for quite a while. And yes, there will very likely be at some point in the future a notable page for this, that's irrelevant because it isn't actually certain (), and we don't even need the article yet (). Lastly, the amount of fans Star Wars has does not have any bearing whatsoever on the notability of the article in review (see ). So I ask you: If no policy supports this article, how is it in Wikipedia's best interest""" Deletion of Star Wars Episode VII (2nd nomination) WP:IAR||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:NORUSH||WP:FAVORITE Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
18207 18535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Trouble with Mr. Bean User:CAPTAIN 12:43, 16 February 2017 (UTC) keep Notable Deletion of The Trouble with Mr. Bean WP:TVSERIES Wikipedia:Notability 77
18208 3288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Buell User:ජපස 14:03, 10 January 2018 (UTC) delete per and . Those are two excellent guidelines that let us evaluate whether a person (note this is a living, breathing person we're talking about having an article focused solely on) should be subject to biographical scrutiny. In this case, neither of these criteria are fulfilled. Arguments that the person fulfills hinge mostly on the television show in which he was featured meeting the requirements for inclusion. A redirect to the television show may be appropriate, but keeping a separate biography with the notability lacking as it is in this case is something that we should not be doing and I would hate for precedent to be kept in keeping a biography solely on the basis of entanglements with the law and incidents indicating a failure to launch Deletion of Ryan Buell WP:FRINGEBLP||WP:CELEBRITY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
18209 10013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coast to coast (Canadian mobile network) User:Me 06:04, 22 May 2011 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not |for things made up Deletion of Coast to coast (Canadian mobile network) WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
18210 5368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/East Coast Avengers User:Subwayatrain 15:51, 26 August 2008 (UTC) delete The song may be notable for its controversy at the present, but the group itself fails to meet . The content related to the controversial song could be merged into another article such as Bill_O'Reilly_(commentator), but only if the controversy of the song persists, which is doubtful Deletion of East Coast Avengers WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18211 15495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Georgia Brown (child prodigy) User:Talmage 18:44, 27 June 2007 (UTC) delete I read the sourced articles and quite frankly I'm surprised she even aroused local interest. If she had done something more profound than know her colors, identify shapes, and count to 10 by age 2 then there might be some notability. However she hasn't done anything millions of other toddlers haven't already demonstrated. This is probably an example of the ''#NEWS|because there's a news blurb there should be a Wikipedia article'' phenomenon Deletion of Georgia Brown (child prodigy) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18212 9025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unverified longevity claims User:Ricky81682 23:32, 15 August 2015 (UTC) delete """See my reasoning from Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Incomplete longevity claims. As a stand-alone topic, what this split is based upon (when it was called """"incomplete"""" claims) is either parroting the GRG's verified/unverified claims (while allowing their unverified claims to persist), or pure with about what constitutes verified/not verified/complete/incomplete claims. This is purely |crystal balling that these claims could or will have reliable sources. This was merged before and split under the basis that these are the claims based on non-reliable sources (that certain people still want to list here under as their cruft-de-jur). For example, http://newsrescue.com/nigeria-claims-world-oldest-man-170-year-old-oluwaro-iloro-ekiti/#axzz3NM0eEteO this for James Olofintuyi is not a reliable source and rather than actually deleting and removing it, it's been moved to this page if/until the GRG has verified it. At best, the place for these speculative nonsense claims is the project's (Wikipedia:WikiProject World's Oldest People/Future supercentenarians|complete or the Wikipedia:WikiProject World's Oldest People/Future supercentenarians/Incomplete cases|incomplete cases list) rather than as an separate article from the actual """"verified"""" claims but frankly we shouldn't be webhosting a storehouse of all nonsense claims so that people who are interested in this cruft can keep track of it using our resources""" Deletion of Unverified longevity claims WP:OR||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:No original research 65
18213 884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Port Blue - The Airship (Album) User:Gongshow 03:49, 2 June 2011 (UTC) delete My understanding is that staff reviews on sputnikmusic are considered |reliable, so the http://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/15506/Port-Blue-The-Airship/ EL from the article seems to be an acceptable source. However, I'm not finding any more significant coverage that would get this album to pass or . If that holds up, then I'd just add any pertinent info on the album to Adam Young's article Deletion of Port Blue - The Airship (Album) WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18214 5680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/María Martha Fernández User:BrownHairedGirl 15:08, 17 May 2006 (UTC) delete as per Gadig. I can understand why IgnatiusReilly is disappointed, but this article does not make the grade for notability as per Deletion of María Martha Fernández WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
18215 20071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Suprise User:Sir 18:24, 10 March 2015 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league, meaning the article fails , which does not cover futsal, and in the absence of significant coverage, fails as well Deletion of Philip Suprise WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18216 3348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michigan State Miracle User:Cbl62 14:55, 18 October 2015 (UTC) delete for now or '''redirect''' to 2015 Michigan State Spartans football team#Michigan. This article was created about 6 hours after the game ended. College football games are dealt with appropriately in season articles on the teams involved. Individual college games only warrant stand-alone articles if they are shown, through the test of time, to be historically significant to the sport. It is simply |TOOSOON to determine whether this game will achieve that level of significance Deletion of Michigan State Miracle WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
18217 11305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blippar User:Alexius08 09:51, 9 October 2017 (UTC) delete It's on the verge of being qualified for a #G11|G11 Deletion of Blippar WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18218 6358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiffany Adler User:Coelacan 22:49, 20 April 2007 (UTC) keep per Bierherr, who notes that there are ''four'' non-trivial published works that are reliable and independent of the subject, so this unquestionably meets . The article is free of BLP concerns, it does not pass judgment, it merely attributes what the media reported. There's a lot of here, but there's no question that the article meets our notability guidelines Deletion of Tiffany Adler WP:N||WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18219 591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monday Night Football all-time team standings (2nd nomination) User:Ajf773 15:28, 23 December 2016 (UTC) delete as and . Non encyclopedic list Deletion of Monday Night Football all-time team standings (2nd nomination) WP:LISTCRUFT||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
18220 16301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Swadlincote User:Beagel 14:48, 26 March 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of bus routes in Swadlincote WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18221 3875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Dark One User:Thunderwing 21:28, 8 May 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of The Dark One WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18222 18388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Leaders in Panzer General II (2nd nomination) User:MuZemike 22:12, 27 July 2008 (UTC) delete This article is not encyclopedic in the slightest. It fails . The policy clearly states that ''Wikipedia is an encyclopedic reference, not an instruction manual, guidebook or textbook Deletion of List of Leaders in Panzer General II (2nd nomination) WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18223 8055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chicago Stockyard Kilty Band User:BDD 19:05, 30 September 2013 (UTC) delete No references, no notability demonstrated. If I came across it tagged with |A7, I'd give it the axe Deletion of Chicago Stockyard Kilty Band WP:A7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18224 15538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PIMBY User:Hut 12:25, 15 September 2007 (UTC) delete not made up, but not notable either. #DICT Deletion of PIMBY WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18225 4566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fuji Food User:HighKing 17:33, 30 June 2017 (UTC) comment """Note to closing admin. It appears that many editors do not understand the policies and guidelines on sources that meet the criteria to establish notability and many make the mistake of stating a source is """"notable"""" (which it might well be) which is a completely different criteria for establishing notability for the """"topic"""" in question. For example, {{u|Cunard}} above has stated that the article in the Los Angeles Business Journal is an """"independent source"""" (correct, the """"publisher"""" is independent) and substantial (OK, lets go along with that). What he fails to point out is that the article fails the criteria for establishing notability because the article almost completely relies on direct quotations from the president of Fuji Food or their owners or """"anonymous"""" company employees and therefore fails both and . Similarly, the Chicago Business article (sure, reliable, independent source) is a regurgitated Press Release from Fuji Foods and also contains quotes the company CEO - in fact the entire article relies exclusively on the company for facts and info and therefore that reference also fails both and . In fact, *all* of the references provided fall foul of either one or the other policy or guideline for establishing notability. Not one is """"intellectually independent"""" and meets the criteria""" Deletion of Fuji Food WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
18226 14530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesuit Centre for Faith and Justice, Dublin User:Bakazaka 21:20, 14 February 2019 (UTC) delete Making sentences out of routine and trivial mentions does not transubstantiate the source material into significant coverage. The article subject lacks significant coverage in multiple independent sources, and does not meet or Deletion of Jesuit Centre for Faith and Justice, Dublin WP:GNG||WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
18227 3466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vulcan High Command User:Doctorfluffy 15:25, 5 January 2008 (UTC) delete It's doubtful secondary sources exist to establish |notability and it's mostly just OT#PLOT|plot summary Deletion of Vulcan High Command WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18228 21439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shehzad Ghias Shaikh User:Coolabahapple 22:53, 7 March 2017 (UTC) comment """as a comedian Shaikh's 'works' are his jokes, if these have been discussed/analysed by the newspaper articles then he is notable under ie. """"3.The person has created or played a major role in co-creating a significant or well-known work or collective body of work. In addition, such work must have been the primary subject of an independent and notable work (for example, a book, film, or television series, but usually not a single episode of a television series) or of multiple independent periodical articles or reviews""" Deletion of Shehzad Ghias Shaikh WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18229 17171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roger La Plante User:MelanieN 14:55, 21 January 2016 (UTC) delete """Promotional article for a non-notable candidate for office - or per the comment above, for a non-notable person. The article is basically a summary of the guy's campaign platform. The three citations include significant profiles/interviews from two obscure publications (''Veterans Today'', """"a journal for the clandestine community"""", and the ''Brazil Times'') and a passing mention in a local newspaper, the ''Victorville Daily Press''. My own Google search turns up many other people by the same name (a hockey player, a Florida felon), but the only thing I found about this person is a YouTube campaign video. Good luck to User:MBUSHistory; you have a week to find some |significant coverage from reliable sources; but without that the person fails and as well as """ Deletion of Roger La Plante WP:SIGCOV||WP:BIO||WP:GNG||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
18230 89 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The L. Ron Hubbard Series User:Asukite 02:29, 7 October 2013 (UTC) merge I was going to suggest a merge with the article for L. Ron Hubbard, but it appears Colliric suggested it, and decided to be |bold and just do it. I believe the page should be redirected now, unless anybody disagrees with the merge. {Special:Contributions/Asukite|C Deletion of The L. Ron Hubbard Series WP:bold Wikipedia:Be bold 9
18231 12985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Environics Communications User:Bearcat 19:35, 1 December 2016 (UTC) merge to Environics. While the company does have a valid notability claim and |reliable source coverage, I have to agree with Shawn in that we do ''not'' need ''three'' separate articles about Environics, Environics Communications and Environics Analytics as three separate ''standalone'' topics — at this level of substance, we only need ''one'' article about the ''whole'' company, with ''subsections'' for its communications and analytics divisions Deletion of Environics Communications WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18232 3579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KidsClick Schedule Changes User:Mrschimpf 21:17, 5 January 2018 (UTC) delete Oh hell no, . Definitely a reaction to KidsClick editors trying to keep that article from becoming an unfiltered . Also a to {{user|Philblue7}} who still hasn't gotten the point of why we keep this cruft out of articles (https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Philblue7&diff=808611642&oldid=808227918 my warning to them from November 3rd, for instance). In addition it's all unsourced, and as I have re-iterated to the user several times, stations can air the programming whenever they want, so the times are '''not''' universal Deletion of KidsClick Schedule Changes WP:NOTTVGUIDE||WP:ADVERT||WP:TROUT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18233 18056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nanae Katō (2nd nomination) User:Knowledgekid87 17:33, 14 November 2016 (UTC) keep My argument stands from last time around, in addition this passes Deletion of Nanae Katō (2nd nomination) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
18234 8893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jhazmyne's Lullaby User:Wikicology 01:04, 19 October 2014 (UTC) comment All articles on albums, singles or other recordings must meet the basic criteria at the |notability guidelines, with significant coverage in Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable sources that are Wikipedia:Verifiability#Sources|independent of the subject. However, an album requires its own notability, and that notability is OTINHERITED|not inherited and RVE|requires independent evidence. That an album is an officially released recording by a notable musician or ensemble is not by itself reason for a standalone article Deletion of Jhazmyne's Lullaby WP:N||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:NRVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18235 13663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheldon Riley User:Mccapra 15:21, 10 May 2021 (UTC) comment thanks for finding those. One is an interview with him and the other repurposes the same jnformation in non interview format. I agree they carry some weight but I still don’t think this passes Deletion of Sheldon Riley WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18236 7030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laure louise User:Verdatum 19:01, 2 July 2009 (UTC) delete I edited the page to remove unverified content per . Article admits to be about an unpublished poet. No other establishment of notability Deletion of Laure louise WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18237 2401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bloody Stupid Johnson User:MacGyverMagic 23:51, 16 November 2008 (UTC) merge to List of Discworld characters (per Deletion of Bloody Stupid Johnson WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18238 3495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sangeeth Kollam User:VeryCrocker 10:07, 13 April 2015 (UTC) delete as failing the |general notability guideline. It doesn't seem possible to even |verify the claimed screenwriting credits Deletion of Sangeeth Kollam WP:GNG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
18239 12547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Carrigan User:MichaelQSchmidt 01:21, 1 February 2010 (UTC) keep per body of work that meets and . Send to cleanup Deletion of Paul Carrigan WP:ENT||WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18240 9832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agonia (2006 film) User:Donaldd23 12:30, 12 July 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Agonia (2006 film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
18241 6620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Top Gear races User:Guest9999 21:20, 14 January 2008 (UTC) comment I think another problem is that as the show somewhat straddles the line between fact and fiction it is debateable how much any of it can be presumed |to be verifiable by primary sources Deletion of Top Gear races WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18242 15616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samantha Strong (2nd nomination) User:K 18:05, 18 January 2020 (UTC) delete does not meet / Deletion of Samantha Strong (2nd nomination) WP:ENT||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18243 1775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DVD single User:Northamerica1000 12:27, 10 June 2016 (UTC) keep or '''Merge''' to Music single, which presently has no content about this |verified aspect of music singles. The Recording Industry Association of America has certified some DVD singles as platinum and gold. Some coverage exists, but it will take time to sort out content about the format itself and sources about artist releases on DVD singles. Some sources about the former are listed below Deletion of DVD single WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18244 21029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Prince User:Burntsauce 16:11, 9 May 2007 (UTC) delete per One Night In Hackney 303, the subject fails as it does not meet our low standards for inclusion Deletion of Matt Prince WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18245 21715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SMT Software User:Piotrus 04:38, 3 March 2014 (UTC) comment The company was listed on Warsaw Stock Exchange at some point; it shouldn't matter that it isn't now (notability is not temporary). On pl wiki as a rule all companies listed on WSE are notable. Wikipedia:Notability (organizations) () suggests that our criteria are more strict, and GNG should be respected - still, it may be possible more sources can be found. My quick search did not find any more reliable sources besides what I've added to the article, and to be honest I am not that interested in rescuing what is indeed a promotional entry Deletion of SMT Software WP:LISTED Wikipedia:Notability 77
18246 1073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of blue-eyed soul artists [[User_talk:Neon white|talk]] 12:37, 30 October 2008 (UTC) keep Valid topic for a list. Seems like a |snowball to me seen as the original reasons for nominated have proven to be mistaken. --neon white Deletion of List of blue-eyed soul artists WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
18247 3884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elide [[User talk:Kaustuv|Kaustuv Chaudhuri]] 16:03, 15 July 2006 (UTC) comment advertising is not a |CSD. Here's what says on this topic: '''''Advertisements or spam''': These may be subject to deletion, but not speedy deletion. There is often a chance to replace them with an NPOV version instead Deletion of Elide WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18248 7229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rahil Gupta User:Robert 18:51, 7 June 2014 (UTC) delete as per previous posts, the sources do not qualify as |reliable sources Deletion of Rahil Gupta WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18249 10347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Children's immigration crisis User:Solarra 05:11, 10 July 2014 (UTC) keep this not only meets it http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2014/jul/8/obama-requests-37-billion-fight-surge-illegals/ very http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/08/us/immigrant-surge-rooted-in-law-to-curb-child-trafficking.html?_r=0 easily http://dallasmorningviewsblog.dallasnews.com/2014/07/obamas-immigration-problem-is-also-perrys-and-cornyns-and-mccains.html/ exceeds it. This event is being as widely covered in the US as the 2014 Crimean crisis was, in some aspects even more so. does not apply as this will have significant impact on US immigration policy and political ramifications for the upcoming 2014 US Election cycle. If there are issues, those can be dealt with on the talk page and with future edits Deletion of Children's immigration crisis WP:GNG||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
18250 3570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Elliot Orr User:MA 20:49, 16 July 2019 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Matthew Elliot Orr WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18251 689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Hidden Messages in Water User:Eggishorn 18:07, 15 April 2020 (UTC) merge and Redirect to Masaru Emoto The sources given for notability of the article do not establish notability independent of the author so merging to the parent topic per , as {{u|Crossroads}} points out, is appropriate Deletion of The Hidden Messages in Water WP:NOPAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18252 20570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kicks Online User:Someone 18:28, 29 March 2010 (UTC) delete there is no non-trivial independent coverage in |reliable sources that I can find, meaning the subject hasn't been shown to be |notable. This is no reflection on the game, the infrastructure for reviewing MMOs to the relevant standard simply isn't there Deletion of Kicks Online WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18253 70 [[Erkan Dinar]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Schmelzle 18:02, 21. Okt. 2009 (CEST) delete nach #7.2; der Artikel listet keine Besonderheiten, sondern nur einen 08/15-Lebenslauf. — User:3247|3247 (User talk:3247|D Löschung von Erkan Dinar Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18254 20180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Piggate User:Johnuniq 10:57, 28 September 2015 (UTC) delete """Naturally there is a lot of excitement about such a titillating (''prickillating''?) topic, but says that current twitterings should be ignored until something of enduring significance happens. If a political figure were to resign, or even if they took a hit in the polls which reliable sources attributed to the """"scandal"""", the topic may have encyclopedic significance. Meanwhile, it is just prattle. Recreate the article in three months if reliable sources still refer to the issue""" Deletion of Piggate WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18255 5054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harry Broudy User:Piotrus 02:01, 23 April 2020 (UTC) keep I can only assume BEFORE was not done, since it's not hard to find refs like the ones I just reformatted (https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Harry_Broudy&type=revision&diff=952593099&oldid=952592851&diffmode=source) which clearly suggest he is notable, having had other scholars write articles about him. He clearly meets Deletion of Harry Broudy WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18256 3899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1776 (company) User:AmericanAir88 00:31, 12 September 2018 (UTC) delete Spam and an advertisement. Fails Deletion of 1776 (company) WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18257 4270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ogonek and Cooh User:Alexwcovington 08:46, 22 April 2006 (UTC) keep it's rough but it's fixable. The group seems to have a following in major nightclubs. Eastern European culture, keep it to fight Deletion of Ogonek and Cooh WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
18258 9071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Niana Guerrero User:SBKSPP 03:15, 6 March 2021 (UTC) merge with Ranz Kyle under '''Ranz and Niana'''. She and Ranz meet with sources presented by Astig as a duo. They're rather notable as a duo than as individuals as per Deletion of Niana Guerrero WP:ENT||WP:INHERIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18259 828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wonut User:Cyclopia 21:08, 30 October 2016 (UTC) keep Plenty of sources seem to indicate is met, plus remember -that it was mostly discussed between April and May 2014 does not mean it stops being notable in 2016. Also, that a source discusses it, albeit briefly, in 2016, indicates some evidence of ongoing notability Deletion of Wonut WP:GNG||WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18260 8457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Estrella Falls (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 20:23, 20 October 2020 (UTC) delete not a single allegation of notability much less |any evidence it exists. |Many malls are proposed, start construction, and go under. Their own website is 404 Deletion of Estrella Falls (2nd nomination) WP:V||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18261 3696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thaindian News (2nd nomination) User:Czarkoff 19:59, 18 March 2012 (UTC) delete per {{section link|WP:CSD|A7}}: the article doesn't even claim the notability of this site. Meanwhile (the guideline on web content notability) gives two notability criteria: (1) the content (that is this site, not its wires) has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself and (2) it received a recognized award from independant body. Neither of this condition is demonstrated to be met Deletion of Thaindian News (2nd nomination) WP:NWEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18262 6014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunstroke (song) User:PamD 14:31, 25 November 2009 (UTC) keep """Songs that have been ranked on national or significant music charts, that have won significant awards or honors or that have been performed independently by several notable artists, bands or groups are probably notable."""" from , so it's notable""" Deletion of Sunstroke (song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18263 780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inam Kharel User:GiantSnowman 15:40, 13 July 2017 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Inam Kharel WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18264 2783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blood Out (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 02:16, 19 June 2010 (UTC) comment """SW: |Article topics must be notable, or """"worthy of notice."""" Determining notability does not necessarily depend on things like fame, importance, or popularity—'''although those may enhance''' the acceptability of a subject that meets the guidelines. A topic is presumed to merit an article if it meets the '''general notability guidelines''' and is not excluded by OT. A topic '''can also''' be considered notable if it meets the criteria outlined in any of the subject-specific guidelines listed on the right...."""" The subsections of do not overrule the |main notability guideline page... they support it and allow further considerations toward notability, and guideline are not set to be mutually exclusionary. Someone may fail GNG but pass ANYBIO. Someone might fail ANYBIO but pass GNG. So sorry... the topic does pass both and FF... through the notability of its production, as NFF is set in place to acknowledge that unreleased films might be found |notable through production receiving coverage in reliable sources... as this one is.... and there is absolutely no hint of it being in """"production hell"""".... quite the opposite. Further, it has distribution in place and a tentative release set for the end of the year. Lionsgate has locked distribution in the US, UK, and Canada... and Cinema Management Group of Los Angeles has locked sales in (so far) Australia, New Zealand, Thailand, Vietnam, Indonesia, Latin America, Poland, Turkey, Hungary, the Czech and Slovak Republics, Scandinavia, and the Middle East... seems folks want to show this film. Now had this film been something merely """"rumored"""", or something still in still in """"pre-production"""", I might tend to agree... but that's not the case. Considering who is involved, coverage has been continuing... and it is a bit of a strech to think that coverage |might somehow decrease as release draws near... and heck, even total failures that were never released can and have occasionally been found notable enough for Wikipedia... but hey... this ain't been claimed or shown a failure here by anyone""" Deletion of Blood Out (film) WP:N||WP:N||WP:GNG||WP:NFF||WP:GNG||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18265 16239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cecilia Harvey User:PamD 11:28, 27 October 2019 (UTC) comment """Undisclosed paid editor""""? On what basis? No-one has suggested it on the editor's talk page, or asked whether they have a . It's not a phrase to be thrown around lightly. Yes, it's this editor's only contribution, they worked on it in their sandbox and then copied that into a new article, but that doesn't prove they are paid editor. Ask them about COI first? And leave them a welcoming template: """ Deletion of Cecilia Harvey WP:COI||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
18266 18233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reunited Kingdom User:Clarityfiend 20:16, 27 December 2019 (UTC) delete All plot, except for the occasional sprinkling of Deletion of Reunited Kingdom WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18267 4382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rose Kabuye User:Julius 16:07, 12 November 2008 (UTC) keep Her arrest has been widely covered by the international press. does not apply, when she is notable for two events: 1. Assassination of Habyarimana and Ntaryamira in 1994, 2. The arrest of Rose Kabuye in 2008. While the latter is related to the former, given the new diplomatic row between Rwanda and and Germany, the latter is by certainty a major event of its own. The article already has acceptable amount of content and is expandable. I would also point out that the article was nominated for deletion four minutes after it was created! It is impossible to figure out non-notability in such a short timespan, particularly given the huge number of ghits for a Rwandan person Deletion of Rose Kabuye WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18268 14301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fairinvestment.co.uk User:RGTraynor 18:16, 8 April 2008 (UTC) comment """This from , one of the official Wikipedia guidelines: """"If ... you are receiving monetary or other benefits or considerations to edit Wikipedia as a representative of an organization (whether directly as an employee or contractor of that organization, or indirectly as an employee or contractor of a firm hired by that organization for public relations purposes) ... then we '''very strongly''' encourage you to avoid editing Wikipedia in areas where there is a conflict of interest that would make your edits non-neutral (biased)."""" (emphasis in the original""" Deletion of Fairinvestment.co.uk WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
18269 8666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hauke Harder User:MichaelQSchmidt 01:10, 3 May 2009 (UTC) keep Its now referenced. Its a pity that classical composers to not get the press hype that follows rock musicians or fast food franchises, but his erified body of work seems to tickle at and rings a bell on Deletion of Hauke Harder WP:V||WP:CREATIVE||WP:COMPOSER Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18270 4500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Committee room User:PWilkinson 00:19, 17 December 2018 (UTC) comment """I can tell that none of the participants so far have ever been directly involved with a UK election campaign (at least at local level), because this is definitely UK political terminology and has been for over 200 years, from the days when British political parties had no formal local organisation, and parliamentary candidates depended on committees of influential local people to help organise their election campaigns. And since at least the Corrupt and Illegal Practices Prevention Act 1883, it has been the officially-used term for almost any premises used for organising their election campaigns by candidates for parliament or local councils, which are subject to a number of legal requirements about what must and must not be done in committee rooms. These days, British political parties tend to refer to their main premises in an area as """"campaign headquarters"""" or similar, and use the term """"committee room"""" just for smaller premises (often rooms in members' homes) used on election day itself - but legally, they are all committee rooms. Reliable sources will certainly exist (mostly, admittedly, probably legal textbooks or books about how to organise an election campaign without breaking the law - and sometimes several decades old) and should enable the article to be expanded well beyond a , but mostly either don't seem to be online at all or only in snippet form. A couple of sources which are good practical guides (if probably not Wikipedia reliable) are https://www.aldc.org/2012/04/committee-rooms/ this and http://www.broxtowelabour.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/Polling_day_committee_room_organisers_briefing1.pdf this. And https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=I2GoBAAAQBAJ&pg=PT135&lpg=PT135 this more reliable source should put things a little more into context""" Deletion of Committee room WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18271 12286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francisco José da Silva Couto User:Kierzek 14:08, 13 October 2016 (UTC) delete not notable, trivia and emorial applies Deletion of Francisco José da Silva Couto WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
18272 5219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stratified multi criteria decision making User:Coolabahapple 12:52, 27 July 2018 (UTC) delete """a case of (with ), in addition to , what is telling is """"not the first proposal of my method, namely stratified multi criteria decision making method."""" from the article creator 1st response above""" Deletion of Stratified multi criteria decision making WP:OR||WP:COI||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:No original research 65
18273 5189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bidyut Khan (2nd nomination) User:Katarighe 01:08, 28 November 2011 (UTC) delete Huge concerns Deletion of Bidyut Khan (2nd nomination) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18274 366 [[Johann und Helene Ihnen Stiftung]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Evolutionärer Humanist NONE delete Relevanz nicht dargestellt und wohl auch nicht vorhanden. Wikipedia ist gemäß keine Werbeplattform Löschung von Johann und Helene Ihnen Stiftung Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18275 14314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/London Chessboxing User:Mdtemp 16:56, 2 July 2015 (UTC) delete Lacks the significant coverage needed to meet for a standalone article. Having a lot of Facebook followers does not make it notable Deletion of London Chessboxing WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18276 10110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raymond Ablack User:Ron 00:11, 12 August 2010 (UTC) merge The article is a |BLP Deletion of Raymond Ablack WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18277 9483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KansasCali User:Nuttah68 15:48, 21 January 2007 (UTC) keep more than meet with the number of soundtracks they have appeared on Deletion of KansasCali WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18278 12828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ricky Sinz User:TonyTheTiger 04:22, 3 May 2020 (UTC) delete fails , , , Deletion of Ricky Sinz WP:BASIC||WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18279 1333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swargakunnile Kuriyakose user:IVORK 01:22, 26 March 2018 (UTC) delete Had tagged for CSD and PROD for failing to meet , I believe the article creator {{u|Jinuthomson}} has been removing the XfD/AfD notices Deletion of Swargakunnile Kuriyakose WP:NMOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18280 2360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prince Nikolaos of Greece and Denmark User:Bearian 17:50, 10 August 2011 (UTC) delete most royals of all stripes are, in fact kept with their own articles, as noted by Postdlf, and all were kept until c. June 2010, when the prior |Wikipedia precedent was that all royals were presumed notable. While |the consensus seems to have changed, at least for ''not-sitting'' royals, I ''don't'' want this (or his brother's case) to be bad precedent. Sitting royals still enjoy the presumption of notability, like First Ladies, |members of the British House of Lords, and other acknowledged and proven nobility Deletion of Prince Nikolaos of Greece and Denmark WP:OUTCOMES||WP:CCC||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18281 13736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naturoid User:Rankiri 15:59, 10 February 2010 (UTC) comment """The article definitely has some major issues. A Google Web search for """"Theory of Naturoids"""" returns seven results. Six of them are Wikipedia mirrors and the last one is Negrotti's biography page maintained by the book's publisher""" Deletion of Naturoid WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18282 6298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ren-raw chen User:Mallanox 02:41, 2 January 2007 (UTC) delete appears to be |vanity, certainly doesn't read very encyclopaedically Deletion of Ren-raw chen WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
18283 1375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rallye rim User:RichardOSmith 20:23, 25 February 2011 (UTC) comment """I don't think the proposer has put forward a valid reason for deletion so I cannot support the nomination. Google clearly shows the term ''Rallye Rim'' in use to at least indicate that the term is indeed an alternative for """"Rally wheel"""", and if establishing this more formally cannot be achieved then the article could still be renamed """"Rally wheel"""", for which there is much information. WP:PRODUCT clearly doesn't apply because this is not a particular manufacturers product. However, it does seem this article is no more than a |dictionary entry and as it has not become more that than in the 18 months it has existed, it probably isn't going to""" Deletion of Rallye rim WP:DICTDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18284 15081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faison Firehouse Theater User:Pburka 00:44, 2 October 2014 (UTC) keep The tone was a bit promotional, but that was easily fixed through editing. Both the building (a 1909 firehouse) and the theater it currently houses are notable per , as demonstrated by the references in the article Deletion of Faison Firehouse Theater WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18285 17678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Robinson (footballer) User:Angelo 07:38, 11 September 2008 (UTC) delete per - unless evidence of the contrary can be found Deletion of Anthony Robinson (footballer) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18286 543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Live Armageddon User:Esradekan 01:43, 8 April 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Albums. No significant coverage in |reliable, third-party, sources Deletion of Live Armageddon WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18287 19486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moths of Whitley County Indiana User:Animalparty 23:22, 14 January 2017 (UTC) delete The question of weather this list might be ''useful'' to some is of no relevance. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, |not a field guide, database of statistics, scientific journal, etc. Wikipedia cannot and should not serve as a repository of all data in existence. County level searches can be performed on existing sources such as BugGuide, BAMONA, and other Wikipedia:Alternative outlets|alternative outlets Deletion of Moths of Whitley County Indiana WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18288 12630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Spring Press User:Gavin 22:29, 14 December 2008 (UTC) delete as there are no reliable secondary sources cited as evidence of |notability, which |cannot be inherited from a list a publications. Notability to come, perhaps Deletion of Black Spring Press WP:CORP||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
18289 13619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faculty of Economics, Rangsit University User:Pharaoh 16:04, 21 September 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and . There is already an article about Rangsit University Deletion of Faculty of Economics, Rangsit University WP:GNG||WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18290 10228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nico Muñiz User:Keskkonnakaitse 17:06, 22 October 2020 (UTC) delete he actually fails as well, as that one appearance came for the New York Red Bulls Reserves in the MLS Reserve League Deletion of Nico Muñiz WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
18291 18816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rishte Ke Deewar User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:58, 19 April 2015 (UTC) delete as an unfinished film that does not have the coverage to meet . Yes, searches are hampered by it being an Indian film and waaaay pre-internet. If Hindi sources come forward, ping me Deletion of Rishte Ke Deewar WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18292 15178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Malarkey User:Calton 02:06, 10 February 2018 (UTC) keep Rank and awards are irrelevant, since that's not what his notability is based on: is not the only notability standard, it's subservient to . Going solely by what's in the article, he's part of a best-selling history book, a major character in a TV dramatization of his experiences, the subject of a nationally broadcast obituary, AND had his memoirs published by St. Martin's Press. So yeah, definitely passes Deletion of Donald Malarkey WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18293 2050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nedaphadrimeru User:Shooterwalker 23:17, 17 September 2012 (UTC) delete same here. Couldn't find any third party sources to , as required by the general notability guideline Deletion of Nedaphadrimeru WP:verify notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
18294 17752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grayson Alexander User:Drm310 15:21, 8 March 2016 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet |notability guidelines for actors. Clearly a case of Deletion of Grayson Alexander WP:NACTOR||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
18295 10614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Andersen User:ISPman 04:42, 26 January 2010 (UTC) keep As the author of this page I strongly disagree that this person is not notable. If your concern is that this is a CEO résumé, I'm more than happy to remove the mention of his current position and the company in which he founded. (note this edit has already been completed) This person is obviously notable enough. They are named in at least 3 other Wikipedia pages and perhaps more, Canadian_Internet_Registration_Authority|CIRA, TORIX|TORIX, and ARIN|ARIN. As the author I have read |CONFLICT OF INTEREST and can declare that I have no conflict of interest Deletion of Paul Andersen WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
18296 6079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Besnik Sulaj. User:Crystallizedcarbon 16:09, 1 November 2019 (UTC) delete Could not find in-depth coverage by reliable sources to meet Deletion of Besnik Sulaj. WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18297 6471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pubology User:Mikm 20:05, 16 January 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Pubology WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
18298 7374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 conspiracy theories User:Group29 12:26, 26 March 2014 (UTC) keep example precedent : John F. Kennedy assassination conspiracy theories. However, an article with a topic such as this is quite ripe for Deletion of Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 conspiracy theories WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18299 1633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ska Punk And Other Junk User:Scorpiondollprincess 15:58, 9 August 2006 (UTC) keep Site has been around almost a decade -- that's a lifetime by web standards. I'm borderline on this one, but I think this is a attempt at a legitimate article Deletion of Ska Punk And Other Junk WP:GF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
18300 10155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Glenn Middle School User:JaconaFrere 13:57, 23 December 2015 (UTC) merge to Desert Sands Unified School District per our customary practice for all but the most unusually notable elementary and middle schools as expressed at Deletion of John Glenn Middle School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18301 12838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Shipley (writer) User:Chiswick 13:05, 9 October 2012 (UTC) delete found some other Shipleys, but hardly anything usable on this one. It certainly looks like publicity, whoever wrote it. is nowhere in sight Deletion of Jonathan Shipley (writer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18302 3198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Joseph Harrington User:Iridescenti 17:04, 11 April 2007 (UTC) delete if the best argument even the ''subject of the article'' can make for keeping this is this is unsalvageable Deletion of Matthew Joseph Harrington WP:WAX Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18303 7988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of sailors at the Summer Olympics User:Claritas 19:22, 8 July 2010 (UTC) delete per , which prohibits the listing of non-notable people. See, as a parallel case, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of organ scholars at British cathedrals and parish churches Deletion of List of sailors at the Summer Olympics WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18304 15338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Besim Šerbečić User:Sir 00:31, 27 May 2015 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Besim Šerbečić WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18305 14069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Duck! The Carbine High Massacre User:MichaelQSchmidt 21:50, 23 July 2013 (UTC) keep Despite the |article needing work (an addressable issue), this film meets and . A little |looking shows it reviewed in ''Film Threat'' http://www.filmthreat.com/reviews/1383/ and production spoken of in more than a trivial fashion in such as ''The Gazette (Colorado Springs)|The Gazette'' http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=NewsLibrary&p_multi=CSGB&d_place=CSGB&p_theme=newslibrary2&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=0F34B7FB702D0986&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM and ''MinnPost'' http://www.minnpost.com/max-about-town/2011/08/history-popular-art-and-taste-30-minutes-or-less-and-devils-double ''The New York Times'' http://movies.nytimes.com/movie/313302/Duck-The-Carbine-High-Massacre/overview (via AllRovi) ''B-Independent'' review http://www.b-independent.com/reviews/duck.htm and others.http://books.google.com/books?id=VKhqh3HFH8AC&pg=PA265&dq=%22Duck!+The+Carbine+High+Massacre%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=FvruUbaGLIadiALp54GwCw&ved=0CDMQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q=%22Duck!%20The%20Carbine%20High%20Massacre%22&f=false It's not a big budget blockbuster like ''Star Wars'', but is is notable enough to allow this to remain and be improved through regular editing Deletion of Duck! The Carbine High Massacre WP:UGLY||WP:NF||WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18306 1693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Holiday World & Splashin' Safari User:McDoobAU93 05:12, 5 May 2012 (UTC) keep Park is very notable, and article can easily be edited to remove any promotional jargon and |peacock words. I agree there are too many sources coming from the park's own website (although a number of those come from ''Amusement Today'', which is a |reliable source), but again those can be removed and replaced with independent sources. Is it in need of some TLC? Yes. Is it a candidate for deletion? Absolutely not Deletion of Holiday World & Splashin' Safari WP:PEACOCK||WP:RS Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
18307 11891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adapt Technologies, Inc. User:Pureblade 17:59, 9 January 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Adapt Technologies, Inc. WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18308 13112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Gifty Opoku-Agyeman User:Jesswade88 05:52, 7 June 2020 (UTC) keep this fits . Just because anonymous Twitter uses can take to Wikipedia to nominate the pages of people of colour for deletion, doesn't mean they should. As mentioned above, Black Birders Week has been covered on several news sites, as well as by National Geographic and various other societies. There are easily enough references to do with both AGOA herself, the Sadie Collective and BBW. The fact that it was nominated and 'seconded' by Wikipedia 'users' whose only ever contributions are nominating this article for deletion speaks volumes Deletion of Anna Gifty Opoku-Agyeman WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18309 14488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/José Pou User:LACaliNYC 21:13, 29 July 2018 (UTC) delete Clearly fails the and the Deletion of José Pou WP:GNG||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18310 2403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reality-based community (3rd nomination) User:XavierItzm 10:22, 13 September 2017 (UTC) keep Agree that the contemporaneous sources more than guarantee the entry should be kept on grounds of ; plus the cite from September 2017 from The Atlantic right there holds that the term was historic for over a decade, remains current, and that it must be kept forever. It is true that some of its adherents may finally have come to realize how embarrassing their self-given motto always was, but that should be no grounds for its expunging from the Wikipedia Deletion of Reality-based community (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18311 14034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uysyn User:Zyma 08:04, 31 May 2015 (UTC) delete per , and . If it has any reliable content, those content should be used on the main article Wusun Deletion of Uysyn WP:POVFORK||WP:FRINGE||WP:SOAP Wikipedia:Content forking 33
18312 21926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Pretty User:ERcheck 01:51, 16 February 2009 (UTC) delete mdash; Does not meet notability guidelines for |entertainers. Article appears largely promotional for a person trying to break into the field. &mdash Deletion of Jordan Pretty WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
18313 18767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/College football lineal championship User:NeoChaosX 01:07, 24 December 2007 (UTC) delete Looks like an |original research #PUBLISHER|essay to me Deletion of College football lineal championship WP:OR||WP:NOT Wikipedia:No original research 65
18314 44 [[Abdurrahim Vural]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Kmhkmh NONE delete Es ist wie Telford schon ausführt – ich habe nämlich dasselbe versucht – augenscheinlich schlicht nicht möglich, diesen Artikel mit entsprechenden Quellen im Sinne von aufzubauen. Er ist schon jetzt vollkommen unbelegt: Der Abschnitt „Jugend und Ausbildung“ hat keinerlei Quelle (das ist eben das, was der Dargestellte selbst in seinem Lebenslauf behauptet), nicht anders Verhält es sich mit dem zweiten und letzten Abschnitt „Politisches Leben und Verbandstätigkeit“. Der Einzelnachweis (woher auch immer der stammt, war heute früh noch nicht da) belegt nicht einmal den Satz, hinter dem er steht. Ich finde auch erst gar keine vertrauenswürdige Quelle für die Frage, seit wann er überhaupt Mitglied/Präsident der Islamischen Religionsgemeinschaft ist oder gar schon für sein Geburtsdatum. Wer hier auf „Berichterstattung“ zu ihm verweist, den möchte ich doch bitten, entsprechende Quellen zu finden, ich finde sie trotz wirklich langer Suche in LexisNexis u.a. nicht. Der Artikel ist in dieser Form nicht haltbar und ich kann nicht ansatzweise erkennen, dass inhaltlich Besserung in Sicht wäre. Daher – und das schon ohne Berücksichtigung des Relevanzaspekts, das ist noch eine ganz andere Frage. Wikipedia neigt ein Wenig zum boulevardesken Overkill, aber ich möchte wirklich darum bitten, hier mal objektiv auf den Artikel und die desaströse Quellenlage zu schauen. —User:Pill|Pill (User talk:Pill|Kontakt) 00:37, 27. Mai 2012 (CEST Löschung von Abdurrahim Vural Wikipedia:Belege Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18315 3498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dean Bouzanis User:Davewild 08:53, 7 March 2008 (UTC) keep """The main criteria at is """"A person is presumed to be notable if he or she has been the subject of published secondary source material which is reliable, intellectually independent, and independent of the subject"""". There appears to no dispute here that this article meets this criteria. The athlete additional criteria on BIO does not supersede this as BIO states that ref the additional criteria """"Failure to meet these criteria is not conclusive proof that a subject should not be included""" Deletion of Dean Bouzanis WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18316 14413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ronald Armbrust User:Alex 09:37, 26 June 2019 (UTC) delete Does not meet . Even if he was notable the article is only a line and not telling us anything Deletion of Ronald Armbrust WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18317 21509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cat training User:Themfromspace 05:44, 26 March 2009 (UTC) keep as |notability of the subject is established from reliable sources like http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi%3Ff=/g/a/2008/09/30/petscol.DTL this that cover the subject in a non-trivial manner Deletion of Cat training WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18318 17415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All Media Network User:SamHolt6 18:32, 19 July 2017 (UTC) delete in violation of Deletion of All Media Network WP:NOTYELLOW Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18319 4507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Protests of 2019 (2nd nomination) User:ProcrasinatingReader 11:09, 9 June 2020 (UTC) comment """I'm really on the fence here. Many of the sources there and here in the AfD are opinions and columnists, which I regard as being near useless. There are some actual news sources too, though, like the BBC and WaPo, where they've made some speculative comments on the protests, but these aren't opinion articles so we should consider them. These sources paint a picture of common themes as the reason for the protests, and define an explicit phenomenon as """"the protestors' year"""". So I disagree with the comment that previous comments made absolutely no reference to - there are some arguments in this discussion (eg by {{u|Keepcalmandchill}}. I'm personally on the fence because the premise of the article still feels icky, but I think it may have potential to be cleaned up further""" Deletion of Protests of 2019 (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18320 271 [[Bundesverband der Frau in Business und Management]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Wishlist NONE delete Wenn man die #Vereine beachtet, kann bei gutem Willen aus den 17 Regionalgruppen eine ''überregionale Bedeutung'' erkannt werden. Die ''besondere mediale Aufmerksamkeit'' und die ''besondere Tradition oder signifikante Mitgliederzahl'' sind aber nicht vorhanden. Damit kann man wenn man fordert, das mind. 2 der drei Kriterien erfüllt sind, bei einem erfüllten Kriterium keine Relevanz feststellen Löschung von Bundesverband der Frau in Business und Management Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
18321 4475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martín Deiros (3rd nomination) User:Sam 21:15, 5 August 2018 (UTC) delete """It actually looks like a hoax. :es:Especial:PermaLink/107461448 gives http://web.archive.org/web/20160919120157/http://buscardatos.com/personas.php?nombre=Deiros%20Diego%20Martin&cuit=20-22922937-1 this primary source with a birth year of 1973 and the full name {{mxtn|Deiros Diego Martin}} (or {{mxtn|Diego Martin Deiros}}). I find as little when searching for the alleged full name as just {{mxtn|Martin Deiros}} or {{mxtn|Deiros Martin}}. A birth year of 1973 would make him ~2 years at the time ''La Hora de María y el pájaro de oro'' was released. So he was ... 18 month during production? Not impossible, but the only source we have is http://www.cinenacional.com/persona/martin-deiros and it is http://www.cinenacional.com/acerca-de not reliable. I can find {{bxtn|no}} other source that is not a mirror of Wikipedia that mentions him. It is claimed that ''Un diccionario de films argentinos (1930-1995)'' mentions Deiros on page 291. I do not have the book, but a relative of mine reports that Deiros is not mentioned on page 291, and is not listed in the index. ''Un diccionario de films argentinos (1930-1995)'' is not available for preview via Google Books. Deiros should have won the award """"Premio Pampa"""" as best actor for his television work in 1979, age ~6. I can't find {{em|any}} """"Premio Pampa"""" related to TV/cinema, let alone any mention of Deiros and """"Premio Pampa"""". The rest of the claims are unverifiable as well, and the Youtube videos appear to be false fillers, I don't see a young kid that could possibly be Deiros. All in all this stinks, and is at best a case""" Deletion of Martín Deiros (3rd nomination) WP:DEL7 Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18322 15374 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Curse, the Life, the Blood User:Gongshow 15:48, 8 July 2012 (UTC) delete I'm unable to find significant coverage for this release; does not appear to meet or Deletion of The Curse, the Life, the Blood WP:GNG||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18323 17002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mao Kobayashi (second nomination) User:Valrith 20:14, 30 July 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails to satisfy any criteria for inclusion, including , etc Deletion of Mao Kobayashi (second nomination) WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18324 14071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simran Budharup User:Skr15081997 04:53, 11 March 2016 (UTC) delete She has played a supporting role in just 1 series. Doesn't meet . No significant coverage found in reliable sources. Fails Deletion of Simran Budharup WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18325 5996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of second generation National Football League players User:Shoessss 15:06, 7 May 2009 (UTC) keep First, I would not use the word “Arbitrary”, in that a requirement for the list is that their father played. That makes the list just the opposite. Second, in that the players listed on the page will have qualified for inclusion here at Wikipedia under |athlete their inclusion on this page does not contradicted any policies or procedures. Finally, I believe the list could be both informative and helpful. Thanks Deletion of List of second generation National Football League players WP:ATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
18326 15893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Baker (basketball) (2nd nomination) User:Rikster2 15:18, 8 April 2018 (UTC) delete again) - doesn’t meet Deletion of Jordan Baker (basketball) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18327 20282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chiropractic care: Research and Criticism User:Dematt 03:27, 12 February 2008 (UTC) delete """This is by definition a . I agree with QG and Hyperbole that the idea to break off a section of chiropractic and expand it in another article would be great (and therefore shorten the chiropractic article), but it too has to be NPOV. This article appears to be an attempt to avoid NPOV. How many different ways can we say """"there is research, some people think it is great, others think it is crap, blah, blah, blah..."""" Unless you have something more important to add, a POV FORK is not the way to make your point. It just makes for a bigger battlefield. What next, add chiropractic to all the articles that concern symptoms? Let's not go there""" Deletion of Chiropractic care: Research and Criticism WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
18328 8257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Living dinosaurs User:Prosfilaes 16:10, 5 April 2008 (UTC) keep redirecting this to Bird would be and actively annoying to just about everyone who would enter the term. As it is, this is an entirely suitable Wikipedia page Deletion of Living dinosaurs WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18329 19770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zaidan S.A.L. User:RileyBugz 01:50, 25 July 2017 (UTC) delete Does not pass our |general notability guidelines Deletion of Zaidan S.A.L. WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18330 6630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Morgan Berry User:Joseph2302 17:56, 1 March 2016 (UTC) delete WP:AUTO|Autobiography (or large |COI) of a |non-notable |person Deletion of Morgan Berry WP:COI||WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
18331 10369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bubble Up [[User_talk:Rudget|Rudget]] [[Special:Contributions/Rudget|contributions]] 17:59, 27 November 2007 (UTC) keep as per Starblind. I've searched Bubble Up, and it doesn't come up with much, but that doesn't mean it should based on that relevance. It supposedly |notable per some literary sources I have, at least I think so. &mdash Deletion of Bubble Up WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18332 4725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Collins User:Location 18:38, 9 June 2012 (UTC) delete Fails . There appears to be a lack of significant coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Matt Collins WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
18333 2470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Obama Administration Miranda-warning proposal User:Ultraexactzz 18:18, 11 May 2011 (UTC) delete per , strange though that may be for a legal article. If this becomes a cogent policy proposal, an article would absolutely be appropriate -but we're not there yet. Anything about this proposal that doesn't yet exist would be speculation at best Deletion of Obama Administration Miranda-warning proposal WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18334 8418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Worst in history User:TenPoundHammer 02:21, 9 August 2007 (UTC) delete """per #DIRand #IINFO. The existing """"worst"""" lists are enough""" Deletion of Worst in history WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18335 20009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 AFC U-14 Girls Regional Championship User:Cloudz679 15:17, 21 March 2014 (UTC) delete no indication this topic has been the subject of non-trivial independent coverage from |reliable sources Deletion of 2014 AFC U-14 Girls Regional Championship WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18336 14699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dustin's Bar Mitzvah (2nd nomination) User:Chubbles 15:56, 12 June 2020 (UTC) comment The article states that the group hit the Japanese (ORICON) singles chart, which if true would meet . I'm not good enough with my Japanese to be able to explore sourcing for this, but it suggests caution in deletion, and certainly no prejudice toward re-creation Deletion of Dustin's Bar Mitzvah (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18337 6887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MacMahon family User:Epinoia 21:41, 18 September 2019 (UTC) delete members of a family cannot inherit notability from other members per and - this article also lacks significant coverage in multiple reliable secondary sources and so does not meet or - while individual members of the family might be notable, that does not mean that the whole family is notable Deletion of MacMahon family WP:BIOFAMILY||WP:INVALIDBIO||WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18338 21452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raffaele Cretaro User:Sparklism 10:25, 5 May 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and . --'''sparkl Deletion of Raffaele Cretaro WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18339 16104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wowk Elementary School NONE 04:07, 20 June 2007 (UTC) merge and redirect to School District 38 Richmond per guidelines. http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Yamaguchi%E5%85%88%E7%94%9F&action=edit§ion=new Yamaguchi先生 Deletion of Wowk Elementary School WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
18340 3624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mina Pam Dick User:JFHJr NONE delete No substantial coverage that I could find indicating this subject satisfies . I also found no substantial citations or critical review to pass under .— Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Mina Pam Dick WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
18341 19993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shipyourenemiesglitter.com User:SamHolt6 04:10, 17 September 2017 (UTC) delete Coverage seems sensationalist, and more importantly the subject company fails and Deletion of Shipyourenemiesglitter.com WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18342 1336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs in English labeled the worst ever (3rd nomination) User:Resolute 16:20, 2 July 2006 (UTC) comment """The problem here is that the author has simply picked and chosen whatever entries he dislikes from these lists and included them in this article. That is both |OR and |POV. The only possible way this article can avoid violating both these policies is if the article was rewritten to show the top five or top ten of various """"worst song lists"""" from reputable sources, ie VH1, BBC, Rolling Stone, etc. However, in that case, it is merely listcruft, and violates as it would be an indiscriminate collection of information""" Deletion of List of songs in English labeled the worst ever (3rd nomination) WP:NOR||WP:NPOV||WP:NOT Wikipedia:No original research 65
18343 11956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Host Virtual User:K 05:07, 26 September 2016 (UTC) delete per ; company's product brochure in the form of a wikipedia article. I don't see a reason to redirect to Virtual private cloud since this is a technology article; I don't think it would be intuitive to redirect a company name to it Deletion of Host Virtual WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18344 9307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alameda Muslim League User:RightCowLeftCoast 17:07, 27 January 2013 (UTC) delete subject has not received sufficient |significant coverage to be considered |notable as defined by or Deletion of Alameda Muslim League WP:INDEPTH||WP:NN||WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18345 2984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pinball Fish User:Schuym1 00:16, 29 December 2008 (UTC) delete Doesn't show notability per Deletion of Pinball Fish WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
18346 166 [[Vorlage:RSIGN/US]] (LAE) Benutzer:Daniel749 NONE keep Diese Vorlage ist für Neulinge und auch für normale Benutzer aufgrund der Doku und auch der Vereinheitlichung zu den anderen Vorlagen der Vorlage:RSIGN für andere Länder einfacher zu bedienen. Niemand, der die Infoboxen der Straßen z.B. in Kanada und Mexiko bearbeitet, sollte zusätzliche Zeit darauf aufbringen, um erstmal die einzelnen unterschiedlichen US-Vorlagen zu suchen, dann um diese benutzen zu können und um schließlich zwei US-Straßen an der Staatsgrenze zur USA zu verlinken. Die Untervorlagen der Vorlage:RSIGN erleichtern die Bedienung aufgrund der gleichen Parameter und der mit übersichtlichen Tabellen versehenen einzelnen Dokus. Zusätzlich ist die Wartung der gemeinsamen Vorlage einfacher, wenn die Neulinge die Parameter falsch ausfüllen, etc.. Das Entfernen der Vorlage aus den nicht im Zusammenhang zu der Umstellung der USA-Vorlagen stehenden Straßenartikel stellt für mich das Beharren auf den eigenen Standpunkt und dessen Durchsetzung ohne Rücksicht auf andere Mitarbeiter dar und trägt nicht zur Verbesserung der Wikipedia im Rahmen der Benutzerfreundlichkeit bei. Dies verstößt meiner Einsicht gegen die |Grundprinzipien der Wikipedia (Gemeinschaftsprojekt) und stellt eine Art von WP:VAND|Vandalismus dar. Natürlich sollte die Untervorlage wie die anderen Untervorlagen (z.B. Vorlage:RSIGN/CA|Kanada) aus den oben genannten Gründen für die Verwendung in Artikeln zur Verfügung stehen, daher Löschung von Vorlage:RSIGN/US Wikipedia:Grundprinzipien Wikipedia:Five pillars 17
18347 6939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Harbinger (2nd nomination) User:The 20:46, 6 June 2018 (UTC) keep """The text may be indeed highly |promotional but this is why we have tags about that issue. The subject is notable according to the sources cited in the article: ''Forbes'', ''Inc. (magazine)|Inc.'', ''Time (magazine)|Time'', ''Business Insider'', and so on, and they're all about the person and what he does. No matter what one thinks about the article's subject or about """"dating lessons,"""" we assess worthiness by specific criteria""" Deletion of Jordan Harbinger (2nd nomination) WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18348 8987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of civilisations in the Culture series User:Shritwod 22:04, 30 July 2019 (UTC) keep there are some fairly detailed articles on The Culture in the encyclopaedia, and this is an extension of those. As it stands, the information is too detailed to fit easily into another Culture article. What bothers me is that it seems overly detailed and somewhat light on references. Possibly more of a problem: it smacks of the dreaded |original research - it's an impressive collection of information about these civilizations and it is certainly of value, yet Wikipedia's own policies discourage this sort of article. On balance though I think it should stay Deletion of List of civilisations in the Culture series WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18349 19156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Milk & Honey, Pt. 1 User:Aoba47 22:41, 20 May 2016 (UTC) delete Subject fails as stated by the nominator Deletion of Milk & Honey, Pt. 1 WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18350 18216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flashblock User:Widefox 14:29, 17 September 2018 (UTC) keep it only took minutes to find and add several RS reviews describing it as one of the most popular extensions. Was actually done Deletion of Flashblock WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
18351 21731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Perry (mixed martial artist) User:Papaursa 18:05, 3 May 2015 (UTC) delete None of them meet and all of the sources for the 3 fighters are merely links to their fight records. Those records are also unimpressive, showing that the 3 of them combined won a total of 3 matches Deletion of Joe Perry (mixed martial artist) WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
18352 9263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Endless Night Vampire Ball User:Stuartyeates 09:25, 7 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Endless Night Vampire Ball WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18353 21940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Graffiti (album) User:Cliff 23:22, 11 August 2008 (UTC) delete per and thus . Title, track list, and release date must all be confirmed by artist or label Deletion of Graffiti (album) WP:MUSIC||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18354 2868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Castle Adventure User:Someone 13:05, 28 June 2008 (UTC) delete Lacks significant coverage in the multiple reliable sources needed to demonstrate |notability and provide the materials to write an encyclopedia article. Home of the Underdogs is a ''very'' weak source, being an abandonware site, yet is the best of all the mentions I can find. None of the above sources are appropriate for referencing or providing reliable material. The only GameSpy reference I've found so far is http://ascii.classicgaming.gamespy.com/featgame_files/castle/castle.html this, which is not GameSpy, it's a personal website hosted on the classic gaming network. Games of historical importance are covered in the multitude of books published about videogames, meaning they'd never be permastubs and notability would be demonstrable. I'd be happy to switch to keep if some of these abundant reliable sources which supposedly exist are demonstrated Deletion of Castle Adventure WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18355 2104 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Port Kaituma airstrip shootings User:Somno 10:21, 13 March 2009 (UTC) delete content is already covered in Jonestown. Article was not |spun out correctly (no attribution under GFDL and the section in Jonestown was not summarised). Jonestown is a big article and summarising might be appropriate for certain sections, but there should be discussion on the talk page about which sections to spin out and the content should be split properly Deletion of Port Kaituma airstrip shootings WP:SPINOUT Wikipedia:Article size 51
18356 20512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Veracity of statements by Donald Trump (2nd nomination) User:Nnadigoodluck 02:18, 19 December 2019 (UTC) keep Article clearly passes . I don't see a need re-creating this delete discussion after the way the first one ended Deletion of Veracity of statements by Donald Trump (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18357 12877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rahimafrooz User:Joe 00:12, 29 October 2009 (UTC) keep Passes Deletion of Rahimafrooz WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18358 1227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tamerlan Tsarnaev and Dzhokar Tsarnaev User:Coffeepusher 19:01, 20 April 2013 (UTC) delete and redirect. this is definitely a |Content fork of which the notable information is already in the main article Deletion of Tamerlan Tsarnaev and Dzhokar Tsarnaev WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
18359 898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The L. Ron Hubbard Series User:Jinkinson 02:20, 7 October 2013 (UTC) delete While there are other references not included in this article that give the book non-trivial treatment, http://blogs.villagevoice.com/runninscared/2012/03/scientology_sun_18.php http://www.prweb.com/releases/2013/1/prweb10291324.htm and http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/01/23/scientologists-claim-errors-in-lawrence-wright-book.html, this does not, in fact, meet , in my view Deletion of The L. Ron Hubbard Series WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
18360 18501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammad Hussein Ali Hassan User:Anotherclown 10:29, 10 August 2012 (UTC) delete """subject lacks """"significant coverage"""" in reliable source therefore is unlikely to be notable under """ Deletion of Muhammad Hussein Ali Hassan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18361 4211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Total Drama Reloaded User:David 15:22, 16 April 2010 (UTC) merge with the series. Total Drama, right? If it's not out yet, isn't this a violation of Deletion of Total Drama Reloaded WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18362 19482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Take the Time (2nd nomination) User:Tokyogirl79 06:15, 15 June 2016 (UTC) comment The general rule of thumb is that redirects are on Wikipedia and there's really not much lost to keeping them as long as they make sense and they seem like a reasonable redirect. Since the article was created there appears to have been two attempts to un-redirect the article, so that suggests that there are likely people looking for this so it'd be a valid search term. However that said, it looks like a Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Take the Time|2009 AfD closed as redirect and there's nothing in the article that suggests that anything has changed since then. I'm going to close this, delete the article history, turn it into a redirect, and protect it against recreation until sourcing can be provided to establish independent notability Deletion of Take the Time (2nd nomination) WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
18363 1071 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Morgan State University Athletic Hall of Fame User:L 06:41, 22 July 2008 (UTC) delete consists solely of a list/directory of individually non-notable people. It's a well compiled list and the sourcing could be worse, but I just don't think it has a place here. For the record, I hold essentially the same opinion about the other articles listed by Marylandstater, remember- |the existence of other examples of something does not justify that something's existence. Furthermore, I rather resent the subtle implications of racism in Marylandstater's post. Frankly, I think most people haven't even ''heard'' of Morgan State University (I hadn't) and thus would not know that it is or isn't an African American college (I didn't). Let's try to keep that sort of misplaced sentiment out of this discussion, as I've found it tends to ''dis''courage honest dialogue and ''en''courage needless |drama Deletion of List of Morgan State University Athletic Hall of Fame WP:OSE||WP:DRAMA Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18364 5726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Figge User:LinguistAtLarge 18:58, 12 February 2009 (UTC) keep She's only notable for this hoax/controversy, so we should cover the event not the person . — Deletion of Jennifer Figge WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18365 17278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Firelake User:GeoffreyT2000 17:55, 25 February 2017 (UTC) delete Fails . Searching finds no reliable sources Deletion of Firelake WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
18366 2725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vermontcentric User:Eliz81 19:21, 13 August 2007 (UTC) delete """per nom, notability, and . """"The Great State of Vermont will not apologize for its cheese""" Deletion of Vermontcentric WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18367 196 [[Offene Schulbücher]] (erledigt, gelöscht) Benutzer:Idler NONE delete Was soll die Eile? IMO ist kein /Schnelllöschung|Schnellöschgrund ersichtlich. Reine Projektbeschreibung, nach Ablauf der ordentlichen Löschfrist Löschung von Offene Schulbücher Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
18368 3490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/24 Hours City Florist User:Ishdarian 06:29, 29 July 2014 (UTC) delete Fails . Trivial mentions, business directories, and a PR blurb won't cut it Deletion of 24 Hours City Florist WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18369 13322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 Newcastle sharks attack User:Nick 00:59, 18 January 2015 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of 2015 Newcastle sharks attack WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18370 4699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/5 Star Grave User:Adjkasi 13:09, 30 June 2012 (UTC) delete because it meets one or more of the criteria for speedy deletion: |CSD A9 Deletion of 5 Star Grave WP:A9 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18371 10116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mongol alliances in the Middle-East User:Elonka 20:22, 18 January 2008 (UTC) delete Though the article appears well-sourced, it is just more copy/paste information attempting to push a bias that the Mongols had a series of alliances. The article includes a long list of sources pasted from Franco-Mongol alliance, some of which have little or no information related to the new topic. It is disappointing that after several articles were AfDed yesterday, that {{user|PHG}} went and created ''another'' fork today, as this is very disruptive. We are requesting that all such |POV forks be deleted, so that we can centralize discussions at Talk:Franco-Mongol alliance and figure out what to do Deletion of Mongol alliances in the Middle-East WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
18372 13939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucy Barzun Donnelly User:RebeccaGreen 01:48, 22 February 2019 (UTC) keep """She has been producer of several notable films (ie, they have Wikipedia articles), so surely she meets #3, """"has created or played a major role in co-creating a significant or well-known work or collective body of work."""" She has also been executive producer of other films and a TV show. The article needs improving, but I believe she meets notability guidelines""" Deletion of Lucy Barzun Donnelly WP:FILMMAKER Wikipedia:Notability 77
18373 4840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erik J. Berg User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:35, 20 May 2009 (UTC) keep """In looking toward : Alonso Duralde of ''MSNBC'': """"I was particularly taken with Berg, who has almost no dialogue, but who expresses volumes through his eyes and facial expressions; he could have been huge in silent cinema, but hopefully there’s a place for him in talkies as well. (It’s Berg, incidentally, who you see on the posters with the weird driftwood-like blob thing coming out of his mouth.)""""http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/29916733 seems a bit more-than-trivial and would tend to nudge the bar of the a bit more""" Deletion of Erik J. Berg WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18374 5023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Golconda Express User:Colonel 01:43, 1 January 2010 (UTC) keep Fairly obviously notable as one can see from inspection of the sources per . These include lots of news coverage of a major derailment; coverage in books, including a complete book dedicated exclusively to this topic; and details of speed records and other facts about the service. And that's just in English; no doubt there is much more in the local languages of Urdu and Telegu, which will not appear in ordinary searches Deletion of Golconda Express WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
18375 19468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lights In Atlantis User:Esradekan 11:49, 7 March 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per . Searching pulls up no |reliable, third-party, sources Deletion of Lights In Atlantis WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18376 21075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The War That Ended the World User:Pious7 18:28, 5 March 2007 (UTC) delete due to #G10 against Stargate school if it's fake or #A7 if it's just some amateur movie Deletion of The War That Ended the World WP:CSD||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18377 11336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gabriela Borges User:Gtwfan52 02:29, 20 May 2012 (UTC) comment """My concern about Ms. Borges's age is not that young performers are any more or less noteworthy due to their age; it is that ANY minor is more in need of the protection of """"WP"""" than an adult. Still haven't seen any arguement for keep that rises much above . It seems kinda creepy to me that a Google image search turns up hundreds of results, but a Google web search turns up next to nothing""" Deletion of Gabriela Borges WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18378 1404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Klarisse de Guzman (2nd nomination) User:onel5969 19:04, 14 March 2021 (UTC) delete not nearly enough to pass , nothing significant since last AfD Deletion of Klarisse de Guzman (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18379 180 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Sello alışveriş merkezi Kullanıcı:takabegtakabeg 17:26, 23 Aralık 2009 (UTC) comment Sello bayağı büyük (Finlandiya'nın ikinci büyükhttp://www.rakli.fi/kky/attachements/2009-03-30T18-29-3965.pdf Finnish Shopping Center (PDF)) bir alışveriş merkezidir. 'nin M1 maddesine göre Vikipedi:Taslak madde|taslak kriterlerini sağlamazsa hızlı silinir. Bu madde hızlı silinebilecek kadar kısa değildir. Vikipedi:Silme politikası'na bakın. Orda ''çok kısa'' diye gerekçe yer alıyor mu ? :Kategori:Alışveriş merkezleri'ye bakalım. Mesela :Kategori:İstanbul'daki alışveriş merkezleri'ne bakalım. Bunlardan Carousel Alışveriş ve Yaşam Merkezi ise çok kısa diye M1 etiketini ekleyebilirsiniz. Bu madde ise kaynaklandırılması yeterlidir Sello alışveriş merkezinin silinmesi Vikipedi:Hızlı silme Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18380 5698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SitNGo Wizard User:Pohta 22:05, 22 January 2010 (UTC) keep I don't know much about the reliability of these sites, but three of the reviews http://www.parttimepoker.com/sitngo-wizard-sngwiz-review http://www.ontherail.co.uk/poker-software/sitngo-wizard-review/ http://www.pokersoftware.com/sitngo-wizard/# appear to engage in enough critical thinking, and only http://www.learn2holdem.com/poker-software-reviews/sit-and-go-wizard-review.htm appears a mere advertorial. So, despite the obvious #Financial issues with the creator of this article, a NPOV version can be written. TonyTheTiger, who appears to be only financially motivated to edit this (in that he didn't seem to even understand the main market for this software at the beginning of the AfD) should definitely '''''' from editing the article though. The fact that we don't have articles on more notable Poker software is an argument to create those articles, not to delete this one Deletion of SitNGo Wizard WP:COI||WP:DISENGAGE Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
18381 2453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nora O'Murchú User:David 23:05, 6 April 2015 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON. Her https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=NkE8p7IAAAAJ Google scholar profile shows a grand total of three citations to her work, far below #C1, and what else is there Deletion of Nora O'Murchú WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18382 4181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Pierce User:Catchpole 07:57, 6 November 2006 (UTC) keep Spiritualized clearly meet , Ladies And Gentlemen We Are Floating In Space makes frequent appearances in greatest albums lists Deletion of Jason Pierce WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18383 17767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fast Web Media (2nd nomination) User:Ihcoyc 15:08, 19 December 2008 (UTC) delete """After reading the article fairly carefully to check if I missed something, I still have no idea what this business actually '''''does''''', other than claiming to be a ''full service digital agency'', whatever that means. The """"references"""" given are to an internal site and to a list of regulatory filings: they do not obviously support the assertions made in the article. This is a non-notable, non-consumer tech business, and as such it |fits the profile""" Deletion of Fast Web Media (2nd nomination) WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
18384 16127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Knowledge & Innocence User:Widefox 10:26, 15 November 2014 (UTC) merge userify, or redirect in that order. Sources borderline , so . The BLP has sourcing issues, so this will aid that too Deletion of Knowledge & Innocence WP:GNG||WP:SPINOUT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18385 3402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robi Botos User:Whpq 20:43, 19 May 2010 (UTC) keep Meets as a winner of a major music competition Deletion of Robi Botos WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18386 11917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syed Arslan Ali User:Snthdiueoa 20:51, 17 March 2008 (UTC) delete WP:CSD#A7|A7) -- #WEBSPACE Deletion of Syed Arslan Ali WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18387 2943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Final Destination 6: The Final Stand User:SL93 19:50, 18 September 2011 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Final Destination 6: The Final Stand WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18388 9884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Configuration Workgroup User:Msnicki 20:50, 26 July 2011 (UTC) delete Lacks even one reliable independent secondary source as required by and . Google searching suggests they probably don't exist. The sources provided are all (published by the subject organization) and are not useful in establishing notability. Wikipedia is not for Deletion of Configuration Workgroup WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:PRIMARY||WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18389 99 [[Rory Hills]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers 16:18, 7. Okt. 2012 (CEST) delete Kasten|1=. Eine Erfüllung unserer Kriterien nach #Pop ist nicht ersichtlich, keine Rezeption auffindbar. Als Folge war natürlich auch der Artikel völlig unbelegt. Gruß Löschung von Rory Hills Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
18390 7732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephanie Pace Marshall User:XOR 21:13, 10 May 2020 (UTC) keep """per . Only having one book probably wouldn't be enough to count as a """"body of work"""", but the book reviews and everything else together suffice""" Deletion of Stephanie Pace Marshall WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
18391 19038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/XCritic User:Lankiveil 12:39, 28 December 2007 (UTC) delete promotional material for a site that does not meet Deletion of XCritic WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18392 11033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ibrahim Shahid User:Joe 16:29, 21 August 2011 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Ibrahim Shahid WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18393 9522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comedy Tumbleweed Awards User:Kinu 07:51, 22 December 2006 (UTC) delete no |reliable sources found that indicate notability Deletion of Comedy Tumbleweed Awards WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18394 11382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Electronics circuit mini project on front door bell User:Osarius 15:43, 2 February 2012 (UTC) delete As per and Deletion of Electronics circuit mini project on front door bell WP:NOT||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18395 14572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phil Hine User:Hanuman 01:35, 1 December 2006 (UTC) keep as others have said, Phil's work is seminal in chaos magic, which apparently the nominator doesn't believe in. I don't believe in Chrsitianity, but I don't go nominating Christian articles for deletion. Looking at the noms contribs, this is a clear violation of as has already been suggested. &mdash Deletion of Phil Hine WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
18396 11725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Adventures of Dr. McNinja (fourth nomination) User:Dragonfiend 17:55, 10 June 2006 (UTC) delete article has no Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable sources, runs counter to the Wikipedia:Verifiability policy, and is full of Wikipedia:No original research|original research. There is also no claim of any sort of encyclopedic Wikipedia:Notability|notability for the topic of this article -- it is simply a webcomic that, like all webcomics, has a creator, characters and a story. It does not meet the guideline for webcomics, and probably runs counter to another half dozen policies and guidelines Deletion of The Adventures of Dr. McNinja (fourth nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18397 13858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Breanne McGhee User:Xxanthippe 22:29, 10 June 2021 (UTC) delete PR flim-flam. No pass of rof or Deletion of Breanne McGhee WP:P||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Portal 85
18398 3549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radial balance User:Freshacconci 20:07, 25 March 2017 (UTC) delete Definitely falls under . A google search indicates that the word is being used out there in the design world, and there are blogs and Prezis discussing it. However, per , there are no actual sources that I can find beyond the blogs. Since there's not much there and no sources, best to delete and someone can create this in a few years if it begins to appear in reliable sources Deletion of Radial balance WP:NOTDIC||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18399 6801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geje Eustaquio (2nd nomination) User:Sandals1 19:17, 8 January 2019 (UTC) delete Fails to meet . Most of the coverage is typical sports reporting or not independent. The coverage that isn't one of those two does not rise to the level of showing that the GNG is met--interviews, passing mentions, etc Deletion of Geje Eustaquio (2nd nomination) WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
18400 2524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Satyodaya Centre [[User talk:96.127.243.251|talk]]) 04:28, 11 August 2018 (UTC) delete half of sources are from the org itself. As demonstrated in the discussion above, the article creator does not understand or , thus, this article on another non-notable org.Special:Contributions/96.127.243.251|96.127.243.251 Deletion of Satyodaya Centre WP:ORG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18401 2666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Hall (lawyer) User:David 06:37, 29 August 2012 (UTC) delete Friends of Animals is notable but I don't think that being their legal director is enough on its own. I found some press stories quoting her in that role, but they said nothing nontrivial about her, so there is no sign of notability. Academic impact seems low, or maybe this is just an area that the tools I usually use to test that are bad at, but it doesn't matter, either way it means there's no evidence of notability there. And I can't find enough mainstream attention to her books for her to be notable that way Deletion of Lee Hall (lawyer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18402 199 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Halil Türkmen Kullanıcı:yzkocyzkoc 08.02, 28 Nisan 2021 (UTC) keep Milletvekilliği yapması kapsamında KD olduğunu gösteriyor. User:Baran Ahmet| Baran Ahmet User Talk:Baran Ahmet|''Talk Halil Türkmen'in silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
18403 11681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Garrison User:Jbhunley 13:41, 4 September 2015 (UTC) delete Not enough coverage in |independent, |reliable sources to |verify or |sustian article. Fails |general notability guidelines, . Article has been recreated after being deleted as an Attack page and serious BLP violations are continuing per //en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special%3ALog&type=delete&user=&page=Ben+Garrison&year=&month=-1&tagfilter=&hide_patrol_log=1&hide_tag_log=1&hide_review_log=1&hide_thanks_log=1 Deletion of Ben Garrison WP:IS||WP:RS||WP:V||WP:NRV||WP:GNG||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18404 19106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camp Ozark User:Fæ 16:25, 21 August 2010 (UTC) comment """Noted, and agreed, thank you for your feedback. As I've done more research, I've become very aware of the truth of your point. That is why my ''core'' argument in favor of deletion is that Camp Ozark simply does not meet WP standards of notability (other problems with the article have been noted previously, see article). That said, my question then becomes whether it is best to just accept that there are many, many organizations (in this case, summer camps) that don't appear to meet WP standards of notability () yet still exist as entries in WP, and not worry about it, or should I, as a novice editor, try to improve content? I guess I'm looking at this particular effort as a sort of """"test case"""" as to whether or not WP standards, like , actually have """"weight"""" or not, and if so, if I truly understand them. So far, I have yet to hear anyone suggest Camp Ozark actually MEETS the standards of notability for an organization as defined by WP; in fact, what appear to be three very experienced editors (i.e""" Deletion of Camp Ozark WP:ORG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18405 16849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cherita NONE NONE keep The form was part of a series of different genres developed out of Tanka and Haiku over several years and is now accepted by major Tanka journals with many different writers. If I follow your argument then all forms developed out of the haiku and tanka roots such as Haibun should be removed as applies to Matsuo Bashō when he invented the form in a letter to his disciple Kyorai. That appears to be the logical conclusion of your analysis of a form now written by many different authors around the global Deletion of Cherita WP:NOTMADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
18406 7689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herbert C. Kodilinye (2nd nomination) User:Ammarpad 10:23, 2 January 2018 (UTC) keep Yet another |JNN deletion spree. It was just -closed 7 days ago and you're here again mistaking article content as the basis of notability. He passes two solid notability criteria by having been vice chancellor of renown public university (in fact, one of the top in Africa). And equally passes another by being foundation Fellow of Nigerian Academy of Science. I will advise you to speedy withdraw this, it is not going anywhere Deletion of Herbert C. Kodilinye (2nd nomination) WP:JNN||WP:SNOW||WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18407 14576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Urn (band) User:Mattg82 20:50, 25 January 2020 (UTC) delete per and . No indication of importance or notability Deletion of Urn (band) WP:BAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18408 17432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Be Careful (album) User:Trevj 09:39, 19 March 2012 (UTC) merge to Destorm - appears to fail Deletion of Be Careful (album) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18409 20738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian D Foy User:Msnicki 19:27, 23 August 2011 (UTC) keep """The relevant guideline is , and foy clearly qualifies under item #3: """"The person has played a major role in co-creating a significant or well-known work that has been the subject of multiple independent periodical articles or reviews""" Deletion of Brian D Foy WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
18410 2875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Cass User:Kierzek 15:10, 19 November 2019 (UTC) delete per nom. Does not meet and not notable for stand alone article Deletion of Jonathan Cass WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
18411 5401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Da Governor User:NeemNarduni2 06:16, 22 January 2016 (UTC) delete """fails . This article was speedied A7 yesterday: it was a hoax pastiche of Samini and Stonebwoy. This time he's gathered some references that actually mention him, but per nomination, nothing from secondary . Infobox currently states ''""""Associated acts: Samini, Stonebwoy, Kaakie, Busy Signal, Chronixx, Bob Marley.""""'' Born in 1988, and associated with Bob Marley,? How""" Deletion of Da Governor WP:MUSICBIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18412 8045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter John User:Oakshade 01:12, 1 January 2010 (UTC) keep Elected council person in major city. Easily passes both and . Has significant coverage from reliable independent sources.http://www.london-se1.co.uk/news/view/2122http://www.london-se1.co.uk/news/view/2316 Is even Southwark Labour Party leader Deletion of Peter John WP:NOTABILITY||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
18413 7617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amita Chapra (2nd nomination) User:Fitindia 20:22, 1 July 2018 (UTC) delete Fails , has never been elected and there is no inherent notability being the Chairperson of the State Women's Commission Deletion of Amita Chapra (2nd nomination) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18414 3772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J.C. Gregson User:onel5969 19:46, 12 April 2016 (UTC) delete not enough coverage in independent, reliable sources to show they pass Deletion of J.C. Gregson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18415 2488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Ferry User:Bearian 16:30, 12 August 2019 (UTC) keep the bestselling book checks out. I'm not sure if that's |enough coverage Deletion of Tom Ferry WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
18416 11651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Leak Detection (2nd nomination) [[User talk:Eustress|Eustress]]''''' 23:24, 10 January 2014 (UTC) delete I'm a significant contributor to the article and no longer believe it meets , not because it isn't supported by reliable independent sources (like Inc. and WSJ) but because its coverage in these sources lacks any real depth (see Deletion of American Leak Detection (2nd nomination) WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
18417 15216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shona Gilbert User:MelanieN 19:02, 18 November 2012 (UTC) delete Agree with FreeRangeFrog, this is a case of . Google News Archive http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws&q=%22Tarina+Tarantino%22&oq=%22Tarina+Tarantino%22&gs_l=news-cc.3..43j43i400.1693.2972.0.3771.3.2.0.1.0.0.945.1057.0j1j6-1.2.0...0.0...1ac.1j2.hCYgGd_A_R0#hl=en&tbo=d&gl=us&tbs=ar:1&tbm=nws&sclient=psy-ab&q=%22Shona+Gilbert%22&oq=%22Shona+Gilbert%22&gs_l=serp.3...1507326.1511959.0.1512324.29.27.0.0.0.13.212.3878.0j26j1.27.0.ernk_timediscountb..0.0...1c.1.-KoUte9QhCM&pbx=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.&fp=e87726a3c3fe4bce&bpcl=38625945&biw=1003&bih=617 finds almost nothing Deletion of Shona Gilbert WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
18418 855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Raymond Evelyn Stansfeld (2nd nomination) User:Mztourist 03:06, 11 August 2021 (UTC) delete """fails , which reads """"People are presumed notable if they have received significant coverage in multiple published secondary sources that are reliable, intellectually independent of each other, and independent of the subject."""", the few sources provided do not satisfy those criteria. Nor is any part of satisfied. The closer in the previous AFD specifically stated that """"I am unaware of any convention that the mere existence of an obituary grants notability, and in the absence of written guidelines saying as much, that argument contributes nothing to consensus in either direction""" Deletion of John Raymond Evelyn Stansfeld (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18419 12655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enytially User:Gpkp 07:49, 16 May 2021 (UTC) delete No reliable sources available in a Google search. Doesn't meet . --Gpkp Deletion of Enytially WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18420 5806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Deacon User:Isotope23 12:44, 6 June 2006 (UTC) comment """It has nothing to do with, how cool or ugly his MySpace is. It has to do with meeting criteria and the evidence of meeting said criteria coming from verifiable, reliable sources. So far no evidence has been presented to show that Deacon meets (though Angus McLellan has advanced an arguable point). Appearing on a local NBC affiliate in any given city does not meet any criteria at either or , do that is irrelevant. Touring meets , but as you've said it has to be ''""""reported in notable and verifiable sources""""''. So, you would mind posting a link to the verifiable sources for Dan Deacon touring the United States""" Deletion of Dan Deacon WP:MUSIC||WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO||WP:MUSIC||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18421 6472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Common room cricket User:0L1 NONE delete fails Deletion of Common room cricket WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
18422 15792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baldwin family User:Sulfurboy 04:07, 15 April 2020 (UTC) keep And seconded on the make it a blizzard, close it out, etc Deletion of Baldwin family WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
18423 19363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Woman's Liberation User:Safehaven86 16:56, 6 July 2015 (UTC) keep Coverage in reliable secondary sources meets . Thanks Deletion of A Woman's Liberation WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18424 12396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J. Wesley Thompson User:MelanieN 16:23, 21 February 2013 (UTC) delete """It's clear that Mr. Thompson is a fine person and doing important work. But unfortunately that's not enough for inclusion in Wikipedia. The requirements for an article here can be found at for people in general, or for people based on their professional qualifications. Neither seems to apply to him. The award he got, while admirable, is not a """" well-known and significant award or honor"""" (we're talking Nobel Prize type awards), and he has not made """"a widely recognized contribution that is part of the enduring historical record in his or her specific field"""". I know, the criteria are awfully high and they leave out a lot of people whose friends and colleagues might consider them notable - but this is an international encyclopedia and it has to have standards""" Deletion of J. Wesley Thompson WP:BIO||WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18425 17785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Are you afraid of the dark? (2019 miniserie) User:Jovanmilic97 19:41, 17 October 2019 (UTC) comment This is going to be a clear case of a no-consensus AfD, so no vote from me. The sources posted by Desmay are hardly sufficient for (only USA Today one is barely OK). But, there are of the miniseries at Paste (magazine) https://www.pastemagazine.com/articles/2019/10/are-you-afraid-of-the-dark-review.html, Consequence of Sound https://consequenceofsound.net/2019/10/tv-review-are-you-afraid-of-the-dark/, Mashable https://sea.mashable.com/entertainment/6786/how-are-you-afraid-of-the-dark-taps-into-the-power-of-telling-scary-stories-as-kids (a different article than that was posted), Decider (website) https://decider.com/2019/10/11/are-you-afraid-of-the-dark-nickelodeon-stream-it-or-skip-it/, TV Guide https://www.tvguide.com/news/are-you-afraid-of-the-dark-reboot-midnight-society-nycc-interviews/, Den of Geek https://www.denofgeek.com/us/tv/horror/283588/inside-the-return-of-are-you-afraid-of-the-dark. The rest seems to be . Enough for a standalone article even if not that much notable Deletion of Are you afraid of the dark? (2019 miniserie) WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18426 15984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guardians of Ga'Hoole Book 13: The River of Wind User:Wknight94 13:49, 23 February 2008 (UTC) merge Per TenPoundHammer and . {{user|Autocracy}} is referring to an AFD that is over 10 months old when was not an accepted guideline. Now the notability is pretty clearly not there Deletion of Guardians of Ga'Hoole Book 13: The River of Wind WP:BK||WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
18427 6454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Hornor Jacobs User:Lightburst 01:36, 7 July 2019 (UTC) keep The subject passes The article should be developed Deletion of John Hornor Jacobs WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18428 6378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Savol [[User talk:Jennavecia|Lara]] 19:18, 29 July 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. Despite the support of the Idol Wikiproject, subject fails and Deletion of Scott Savol WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18429 156 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Nalet Bebe NONE 13.46, 8 Haziran 2020 (UTC) delete """Kayda değer olduğunu gösterir bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynak bulunmuyor. Oyuncu bir film çekmiş (Şahane Hayaller, Vikipedi maddesi yok), bir de Tutunamayanlar dizisinde konuk oyuncu olarak yer alıyor. Film görebildiğim kadarıyla kriterlerini karşılamıyor, dizideki rolü için de """"önemli"""" denemez diye düşünüyorum. Bu nedenlerle silinmesi bence daha uygun. --Kullanıcı mesaj:Justinianus|'''justinianus""" Nalet Bebe'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:FİLM Wikipedia:Notability 77
18430 10700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/15 Minutes (novel) User:THF 15:53, 30 January 2010 (UTC) delete """A tiny handful of minor """"reviews"""" that do no more than indicate that the book exists and has a summarizable plot do not add up to notability under . A LOC mention is necessary, but far from sufficient, for notability for an English-language book""" Deletion of 15 Minutes (novel) WP:PERSISTENCE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18431 3717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alhassan Nuhu User:Smartyllama 18:35, 11 December 2018 (UTC) keep Passes per sources Deletion of Alhassan Nuhu WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
18432 4822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MetaMask User:Expertwikiguy 10:30, 7 December 2020 (UTC) keep Meets based on sources such as Newsweek, Mashable, NY Tines, ZDNet, etc. What else is needed to justify significant coverage? I know that Crypto is looked as spam by many Wiki admins, but it is time it gets to be an acceptable topic, specially when they have significant coverage Deletion of MetaMask WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18433 14641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arctic MUD (2nd nomination) User:Teancum 20:32, 28 July 2010 (UTC) delete but check to see if it's listed in List of MUDs. Couldn't find any reliable, significant coverage to satisfy Deletion of Arctic MUD (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18434 16089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magic item (Dungeons & Dragons) User:Drilnoth 19:07, 24 December 2008 (UTC) comment """I think that if the article was merged, Game Mechanics wouldn't be the right place. Additionally, says that """"a Wikipedia |article should not read like a how-to style manual of instructions, advice (Wikipedia:Legal disclaimer|legal, Wikipedia:Medical disclaimer|medical or otherwise) or suggestions, or contain how-tos."""" Although the article does contain some things which should probably be removed because they fail this, I think that the vast majority of the article just needs a bit of a rewrite""" Deletion of Magic item (Dungeons & Dragons) WP:GAMEGUIDE||WP:WIAA Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18435 20582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul M. Strickler User:Joe 03:27, 13 June 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |author Deletion of Paul M. Strickler WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18436 11236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GunBeat User:Eduemoni 12:01, 3 February 2016 (UTC) delete Notability is not a comprehensive reason for deletion, but it lacks reference and as a cancelled game for a niche video game console/arcade system it fails Deletion of GunBeat WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18437 6042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guy Stephens Celin User:Opencooper 04:12, 29 March 2016 (UTC) delete I can't find any coverage of the subject to meet the |general notability guidelines nor do they meet considering they only recently released a film and it is a short. The page is also eligible for speedy deletion via Deletion of Guy Stephens Celin WP:GNG||WP:FILMMAKER||WP:A7 Wikipedia:Notability 77
18438 20101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 Golden Gate Bridge deer crossing User:Spirit 02:04, 3 October 2014 (UTC) delete The article is a violation of . All of the sources were released on or the day after this event, and there has not been any lasting impact. I am hesitate to merge this, as animal caused traffic jams are really common and including it in an article would likely be giving undue weight to this event Deletion of 2014 Golden Gate Bridge deer crossing WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18439 7549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Lewis (philosopher) (3rd nomination) User:RJC 17:42, 24 July 2010 (UTC) delete """The last time this was up for deletion, was not yet a guideline and some keep votes were based on its not yet being a guideline (e.g., that the """"average professor test"""" has no standing). Others argued that they found his work interesting, which not not currently a criterion for inclusion. Based on the information reported in the article, I'd say he fails the notability criteria as currently phrased. The nominator seems to understate the h-index, though. The Scholar h-Index Calculator extension for Firefox returns an h-index of 122 for http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=%22Peter+Lewis%22+philosophy&btnG=Search&as_sdt=400000&as_ylo=&as_vis=0&as_sauthors=&as_publication=&query_as=word a Google Scholar search of ''""""Peter Lewis"""" philosophy''. Still, none of the publications that come up has been cited more than 31 times. The previous AfD said that a Google search of ''""""Peter Lewis"""" quantum'' turned up a lot of hits, but I don't get an impressive result from http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Peter+Lewis%22+quantum&hl=en&prmd=o&ei=cSRLTNnaIs-HnQe3nvziDQ&start=0&sa=N&cts=1279992952896 that search. Unless I'm missing something, he looks like a run-of-the-mill associate professor""" Deletion of Peter Lewis (philosopher) (3rd nomination) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18440 253 [[Monta (Band)]] (erl.) Benutzer:Quedel NONE keep Nach #Pop- und Rockmusik Relevanz gegeben durch (1) Veröffentlichungen und (2) Erwähnung auf http://www.laut.de/wortlaut/artists/m/monta/biographie/index.htm dieser und http://www.poplist.de/poplist.php?p=541 dieser als Entscheidungsgrundlage geltenden Seiten. Daher Löschung von Monta (Band) Wikipedia:Relevanz Wikipedia:Notability 77
18441 598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1352 Wawel User:Praemonitus 18:47, 11 May 2015 (UTC) merge per : only one photometry study found; there's insufficient references to build a decent article Deletion of 1352 Wawel WP:DWMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18442 6714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pakistani Web portals User:Maralia 04:04, 22 December 2008 (UTC) delete per ; this is just a collection of external links Deletion of Pakistani Web portals WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18443 11101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gallery of sovereign-state flags (2nd nomination) User:Colonel 20:13, 7 October 2011 (UTC) keep """The nominator has nominated this before and the result was a resounding Keep. Per , """"''It can be disruptive to repeatedly nominate a page in the hopes of getting a different outcome.''"""". The claim that this is contrary to Wikipedia:NOTGALLERY is false because the images here have accompanying text which provide a coherent theme and explanation of them. If we should feel the need for more text then this will be done by further editing not by deletion. Presenting the flags of all nations in this way is standard material for an encyclopedia and it is vexatiously false to suggest otherwise""" Deletion of Gallery of sovereign-state flags (2nd nomination) WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18444 9305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of gay porn stars (second nomination) User:Fbb 01:20, 20 August 2006 (UTC) keep For some reason, it seems to be a common misconception that categories and lists are interchangeable. They are not - please see Deletion of List of gay porn stars (second nomination) WP:CLS Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
18445 2284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vishal Saxena User:Mduvekot 02:49, 20 June 2017 (UTC) delete I cringed when I read that the subject seems to think that the Hasselblad he professes to love so much is a Full-frame digital SLR|full-frame camera when it's a Medium format (film)|Medium format camera. The article is promotional garbage. The subject is an amateur. On a more serious note: The subject has not received substantial coverage in |independent, |reliable sources and fails every criterion of : 1) He is not regarded as an important figure or is widely cited by peers or successors. 2) He is not known for originating a significant new concept, theory, or technique. 3) He has not created or played a major role in co-creating a significant or well-known work or collective body of work. 4a) His work has not become a significant monument 4b) His work has not been a substantial part of a significant exhibition 4c) His work has not won significant critical attention 4d) His work is not represented within the permanent collections of several notable galleries or museums Deletion of Vishal Saxena WP:IS||WP:RS||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18446 11074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/City Center Plaza User:Shruti14 18:24, 21 August 2007 (UTC) delete as it fails and has been orphaned and is a microstub Deletion of City Center Plaza WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18447 9746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Silke User:Eduemoni 01:59, 30 March 2011 (UTC) keep He is notable in the gaming scenario (voice scripting, design and acting), a preliminary research got me the two sources needed and also a reference that makes him passes . http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0403324/ 1 http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0307501/fullcredits#cast 2 http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0403324/fullcredits#cast 3 With the correct sourcing and a good writing skill this article can be improved Deletion of John Silke WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18448 17997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dance for Me (Empire Mates Entertainment song) User:CoffeeWithMarkets 16:59, 26 May 2016 (UTC) delete As much as I do see a mentioning of this song in pop culture related http://www.okayafrica.com/video/wizkid-dance-for-me-video/ article https://www.bellanaija.com/2012/07/bn-video-premiere-wizkid-dance-for-me/ after http://allafrica.com/stories/201604180008.html article, there doesn't appear to be evidence that this significantly charted anywhere, or that it became a particularly viral sensation, or that it formed a turning point in Wizkid's discography, or anything of the sort. A happy, bubbly guy made a happy, bubbly tune, and I've got tons of support for the notion of crossing international barriers with music, but I don't think this passes the bar of notability. In particular, the references to the song appear to constantly come from sources where the reliability isn't clear, and it all seems like |run of the mill coverage in the bigger picture of his career Deletion of Dance for Me (Empire Mates Entertainment song) WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
18449 4944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radio ITU User:SBKSPP 01:20, 17 August 2021 (UTC) merge to Istanbul Technical University. Fails per nom Deletion of Radio ITU WP:STUDENTMEDIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
18450 5454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kill the Commie Bastards! User:Chetsford 20:38, 7 March 2020 (UTC) delete insufficient RS to demonstrate Deletion of Kill the Commie Bastards! WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
18451 18415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Smartphone Films User:MarnetteD 01:39, 10 August 2017 (UTC) delete per nom's reasoning as well as the fact that it fails Deletion of List of Smartphone Films WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18452 21419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan C. Clark User:StuffOfInterest 14:59, 17 April 2007 (UTC) comment Is it time to call this one Deletion of Ryan C. Clark WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
18453 4901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cross of the UnderTaker User:IslaySolomon 09:31, 15 October 2006 (UTC) delete symbol of wrestling character, utterly undeserving of its own article. #Wikipedia_is_not_an_indiscriminate_collection_of_information|Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information. Pointless fancruft Deletion of Cross of the UnderTaker WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18454 4333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norman Wielsch User:DBigXray 20:43, 2 September 2018 (UTC) delete per Fails Significant coverage over the years. only mentioned for his arrest Deletion of Norman Wielsch WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18455 10209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kuran no Yami User:Whpq 16:54, 9 July 2007 (UTC) delete fails to provide |reliable sources and fails Deletion of Kuran no Yami WP:RS||WP:FICT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18456 21257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Neyor User:Ceradon 01:53, 1 March 2015 (UTC) keep Passes and easily. A senatorial candidate and the former president of the National Oil Company in Liberia is surely notable enough for inclusion, I think Deletion of Christopher Neyor WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18457 12196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Osuolale Farouq User:ThatMontrealIP 04:59, 5 September 2020 (UTC) delete A first-year university student who redesigned a logo. Although they got some coverage, applies Deletion of Osuolale Farouq WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18458 15011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Chief Commissioners of Panth-Piploda User:RockManQ 01:20, 9 October 2008 (UTC) delete a one entry list...is not a list. A |PROD could of/should of been used instead Deletion of List of Chief Commissioners of Panth-Piploda WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
18459 3919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saskatchewan Highway 703 User:Alansohn 05:38, 21 October 2007 (UTC) keep Per , consensus is clear that state/provincial roads are notable Deletion of Saskatchewan Highway 703 WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18460 1288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Abhijeet Nath and Nilotpal Das User:FR30799386 14:08, 16 June 2018 (UTC) delete Six months later the subject will not even warrant a footnote in the main article... applies here. — Deletion of Death of Abhijeet Nath and Nilotpal Das WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18461 428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Good-Ass Job User:Stormie 10:39, 24 July 2008 (UTC) delete """unreleased albums are in general not notable; however, they may be notable if they have significant independent coverage in reliable sources"""" () - this doesn't. It has a passing mention""" Deletion of Good-Ass Job WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18462 6684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamrul Hasan Nasim User:NahalAhmed 12:21, 13 October 2019 (UTC) delete I check all of reference but i couldn't find which source pass on . and he isn't notable Journalist because ''The Daily Amader'' isn't a notable newspaper. an also fail becouse i don't find his any biography related news all of source are not with him Deletion of Kamrul Hasan Nasim WP:POLITICIAN||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18463 20826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VF/religious stations User:Wcquidditch 21:22, 15 August 2016 (UTC) delete I was considering a bulk nomination of these low-power religious stations myself, but didn't get around to it. It has been suggested that |VF stations are not inherently notable, and I can't imagine these church stations that exist solely to broadcast religious celebrations will ever attain the significant coverage in |reliable sources to meet the |general notability guideline. In addition the VF8020 article claims that the station is defunct, and notes that http://www.crtc.gc.ca/eng/archive/2015/2015-7.htm the CRTC revoked the license at the request of the church that owned it — but the CRTC decision specifically notes that the revocation was requested specifically ''because'' these stations are now exempt from CRTC licensing, and that the station would remain in operation as an exempt undertaking, meaning that the station was ''not'' defunct and at the time had no plans on actually shutting down. While these VF stations still require Industry Canada authorization on a technical level from what I can tell, that simply indicates that they exist on paper; other that that, they are practically non-notable unlicensed low-power stations whose operations are effectively |unverifiable at this point Deletion of VF/religious stations WP:BCASTOUTCOMES||WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:V Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18464 4001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Serenism User:Peterkingiron 21:35, 21 September 2013 (UTC) delete I note that it is categorised as a Neologism: it obviously fails . With no sources, my guess is that it is also WO:OR Deletion of Serenism WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18465 8916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lynn Marinelli User:GPL93 13:47, 5 August 2019 (UTC) delete Fails as a county legislator and being the regional executive of a state agency doesn't pass either. Best Deletion of Lynn Marinelli WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18466 4260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deuce (singer) (2nd nomination) User:DMacks 22:19, 24 January 2012 (UTC) delete and salt per nom and previous AfDs. Some previous claims of notability were based on produced works, which (per their previous AfDs) were found to be non-notable, and for a person isn't just being prolific or being an individual in a notable or prolific group Deletion of Deuce (singer) (2nd nomination) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
18467 15488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avery Watts User:Qwyrxian 22:36, 21 December 2011 (UTC) delete The references in the article are not sufficient to meet or . Other references raised above are trivial (like the last 2 by AlphaSur: the first is about only 1 local concert, the second is less than that--it's just a concert schedule), or aren't reliable. Finally, just as a note, the IP above is wrong on multiple accounts: Wikipedia is ''not'' a catalogue of everything that exists, and just because a few people here happen to be fans and are devoting hours and hours of their time to keeping the article is not sufficient to keep the article--the subject must meet our notability guideline. Now, all of that being said, it looks entirely possible that, in a little more time (maybe another major album, maybe a song breaking into some national charts), Avery could become notable, just not yet Deletion of Avery Watts WP:MUSICBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18468 9380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grant Harrison User:Winhunter 08:40, 29 June 2006 (UTC) delete state tournaments aren't notable enough, fails Deletion of Grant Harrison WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18469 20065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Straw polls for the Democratic Party 2008 presidential nomination User:JohnCD 22:24, 10 November 2008 (UTC) delete """per the arguments at the AfD for the parent article. Also, per , these are not """"''verifiably of significant lasting and historical interest and impact""" Deletion of Straw polls for the Democratic Party 2008 presidential nomination WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18470 1325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tasha Williamson User:4meter4 21:53, 29 September 2019 (UTC) keep """Passes for her work as an activist but not as a politician. Her Peace Prize win was significant enough that she was the main subject of several articles acknowledging her work as an activist/ founder of the active non-profit San Diego Compassion Project, including the national news article """"TCWF Honors Unsung Heroes With 21st Annual California Peace Prize"""", ''PR Newswire'', 10 September 2013 (the text of which mainly is about Tasha Williamson and her work as an activist) . That in conjunction with all of the news articles already cited in the article are enough to just barely pass . On a side note, it would be helpful to create a notability guideline specifically for activists""" Deletion of Tasha Williamson WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18471 236 [[Ursula Winkelsett]] (bleibt) Benutzer:AF666 15:24, 28. Aug. 2007 (CEST) delete Da bei dieser Dame die Erfüllung der zweifelhaft erscheint (nie Abgeordnete oberhalb der kommunalen Ebene, nie Bundesvorsitzende) plädiere ich für Löschung von Ursula Winkelsett Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
18472 14857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hedayatollah Behboudi User:Bearian 18:18, 20 December 2019 (UTC) keep the English sources check out. Is this an nom Deletion of Hedayatollah Behboudi WP:IDONTLIKE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18473 15557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HAL 9000 in popular culture (3rd nomination) User:Cirt 17:08, 14 January 2011 (UTC) keep There is most definitely a wealth of secondary sourced information from whence to easily improve the quality of referencing for this page and its subject matter Deletion of HAL 9000 in popular culture (3rd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18474 7387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ann Darrow User:A 05:48, 1 May 2011 (UTC) delete A 100% comparison between how the character in question was portrayed in the original ''King Kong'' and how she was portrayed in the remake. No objection to redirection to King Kong (1933 film Deletion of Ann Darrow WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18475 9734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wikipedia Ambassador Program User:Penwhale 08:02, 30 July 2015 (UTC) keep or at the very least '''move''' to WP namespace. Note that in theory this at the very least also should be '''procedurally kept''' because this is in actuality an interwiki redirect and probably needs to be at Deletion of Wikipedia Ambassador Program WP:RFD Wikipedia:Redirect 56
18476 21571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Game events User:Haipa 01:43, 13 June 2009 (UTC) delete Entirely |original research, not |notable Deletion of Game events WP:OR||WP:N Wikipedia:No original research 65
18477 5413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gateway Center (Wenatchee) User:Oakshade 21:25, 16 December 2010 (UTC) delete I'm just not finding anything even close to significant in terms of coverage or passing even the most liberal interpretation of Deletion of Gateway Center (Wenatchee) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18478 973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Skilbeck User:Bearian 23:54, 10 March 2009 (UTC) delete notably lacks any evidence of notability. Any one of the acts attributed to him - writing two books, founding a (smallish) club, being a photographer - does not prove notability. It needs |much better sources to show |general notability Deletion of Paul Skilbeck WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18479 8628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Just Like That (song) User:LinguistAtLarge 04:07, 9 February 2009 (UTC) keep The article asserts individual notability for this song (''It is considered by many to be the 'Holy Grail' of unreleased ABBA recordings''), which is a valid reason for keeping it per if that can be verified with reliable sources. Additionally, the article already contains enough material for a full article-- it shouldn't be merged just for being a stub. So, in conclusion, I think the problem is finding references to verify the material and notability of the song. Remember there's no . Where can we list this article so that interested parties can look for |sources? Deletion of Just Like That (song) WP:NSONGS||WP:DEADLINE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18480 11293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elaine Macmann Willoughby User:E 13:25, 1 May 2015 (UTC) keep What perhaps misled the Nom is the fact that an author who was well-reviewed and widely read in the 50s, but whose work was perhaps not timeless, will not show well in a simple search. Even if she had only published under one, consistent name. You need to use news archive searches to find authors form other eras; I added a couple of sources after looking up only the first (maiden) name she wrote under and her first book. There are more. . An author who was notable (as per reviews, inclusion in best books lists) n the 1950s through 1980s continues to be . The article continues to need expansion, sourcing Deletion of Elaine Macmann Willoughby WP:NOTTEMPORARY||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18481 18786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dahir Insaat User:K 00:34, 2 May 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet / . Sourcing is in passing and / or . Just a directory listing, which Wikipedia is Deletion of Dahir Insaat WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:SPIP||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18482 16439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Samuel Decosta Higgins User:David 19:04, 7 November 2017 (UTC) keep According to http://asts.org/about-asts/chimera-chronicles/profiles/robert-s-d-higgins-md this source he's the William Stewart Halsted Professor at Johns Hopkins, so he passes #C5. He also has highly cited publications in Google scholar, enough for #C1. The article does say he is the first African-American director, but (contrary to what the nomination says) does not claim that he is notable for that Deletion of Robert Samuel Decosta Higgins WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18483 8067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mimi Macpherson (2nd nomination) User:WWGB 14:32, 19 April 2012 (UTC) keep Sufficient independent references, from various sources and over extended time, to satisfy Deletion of Mimi Macpherson (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18484 18264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/East Islip Middle School (2nd nomination) User:Twenty 16:08, 4 November 2007 (UTC) delete Fails notability. Given the lack of an agreement at WP:SCH, it fails WP:N, WP:ORG, WP:CORP. It asserts no notability. It has no that are . Thank you Deletion of East Islip Middle School (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18485 2469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/INTP Central User:Alias 03:05, 8 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of INTP Central WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18486 12158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Macedonophobia User:Curb 11:00, 21 October 2011 (UTC) delete searching revealed no hitsactually there are hits;;;no references Deletion of Macedonophobia WP:OR||WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
18487 7738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Planes of Fame User:JingleJim 22:30, 4 March 2011 (UTC) delete """While the ''subject'' of the article may be noteworthy, the article itself is a loser, even with the worst of the grandstanding language removed. It has only two sources; one of them is used once, and is the only source for its section (which is even written in the first person!), so it's essentially a one-source article. More disturbing, the one source is the website of the subject of the article (and the other source is from its section's subject's website), a violation of the self-published source rule (). An article based on its subject's own (self-published) website falls far short of the |verifiability standards. Until and unless a collection of proper outside sources is developed, I'd drop this article. It can be re-instituted when good sources turn up. Google-citing guys: here's your chance to go get those """"significant hits"""" and use them to establish facts, while dropping the remaining rah-rah language""" Deletion of Planes of Fame WP:SPS||WP:verify Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18488 3118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Midfield quartet User:Govvy 11:59, 25 June 2021 (UTC) delete The whole article seems pointless and trivial, ? I agree with the main AfD assessment by Fram for deletion Deletion of Midfield quartet WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18489 9848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spectral Power User:Cullen328 01:38, 10 November 2010 (UTC) delete This is a |neologism. The Christian Science Monitor reference is |original research since it is an opinion piece written by the gentlemen who coined the term, and therefore lacks independence Deletion of Spectral Power WP:NEO||WP:OR Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18490 15359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tilt-a-whirl gutbuster User:Bearian 03:40, 20 November 2016 (UTC) delete per - the first real I've seen in months. This is a waste of time even to comment on deleting it Deletion of Tilt-a-whirl gutbuster WP:TNT||WP:VANITYSPAMCRUFT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
18491 6435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faizan Khan (Indian actor) User:Pharaoh 11:04, 6 August 2019 (UTC) delete Fails and upcoming not ntoable at this point Deletion of Faizan Khan (Indian actor) WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18492 12587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Minala User:Nfitz 01:52, 15 February 2014 (UTC) keep Given the coverage he was getting in the international media before the whole age thing blew up, the issue isn't applicable. http://www.svenskafans.com/italien/aquilotti-joseph-minala-499560.aspx Deletion of Joseph Minala WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18493 353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lauren Birgenheier User:David 17:16, 13 June 2020 (UTC) keep The article is puffed up with minor awards, self-sourced descriptions of her research, and other non-accomplishments, but (even if we ignore the Baksi reference that appears not to be hers) the Google Scholar record https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=c1qrHrQAAAAJ shows enough well-cited papers to convince me of a pass of #C1 Deletion of Lauren Birgenheier WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18494 8661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toofer Spurlock User:Shooterwalker 17:04, 16 July 2011 (UTC) delete due to lack of sources to or provide any information that's Deletion of Toofer Spurlock WP:NOTPLOT||WP:verify notability Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18495 17111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manor Woods, Fort Wayne User:Unscintillating 00:27, 12 September 2014 (UTC) keep nbsp; Unquestionable disruption, #2. Deletion of Manor Woods, Fort Wayne WP:SK Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
18496 137 [[Main-Sieg-Express]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Global Fish NONE delete Das sind im wesentlichen abgetippte Fahrplantabellen (sogar noch mit konkreten Abfahrzeiten) und so etwas gehört auf keinen Fall in die Wikipedia! (@Quedel, nein, so etwas muss man auch nicht woanders einarbeiten. Lies doch bitte Mal ). Wurde so ein $%%§$§§§ behalten werden und das Schule machen würde, hätten wir hunderte von Linienartikeln, von denen die Hälfte beim nächsten oder spätestens übernächsten Fahrplanwechsel veraltet wäre. Nein, danke. Klares Löschung von Main-Sieg-Express Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18497 16318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/City National Arena [[User talk:194.28.127.53|talk]]) 02:08, 6 August 2017 (UTC) delete A non-notable arena that doesn't need a mention in the VGK article, let alone it's own article. Also some serious wn going on on the article. Special:Contributions/194.28.127.53|194.28.127.53 Deletion of City National Arena WP:O Wikipedia:Orphan 47
18498 848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Farid Khan (tennis) User:BonkHindrance 22:59, 25 February 2020 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Farid Khan (tennis) WP:BLPBALANCE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18499 13309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Awel Mara User:Ojorojo 15:56, 29 September 2017 (UTC) delete """Besides confirming the its existence, there is no significant discussion of the album in RS. Doesn't meet : there is no """"significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject"""" and therefore there isn't """"enough material to warrant a reasonably detailed article; articles unlikely ever to grow beyond stubs should be merged into the artist's article or discography""" Deletion of Awel Mara WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
18500 9737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 Newcastle sharks attack User:WilliamJE 16:32, 18 January 2015 (UTC) delete A clear case of Deletion of 2015 Newcastle sharks attack WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18501 7839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruthellen Josselson User:Xxanthippe 21:38, 23 January 2014 (UTC) keep Fullbright is not sufficient to pass rof but 15 publications with over 100 cites on GS is Deletion of Ruthellen Josselson WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
18502 17901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rage comic [[User talk:Η-θ|Eta]][[Special:Random|-]][[Special:Contributions/Η-θ|theta]] 02:16, 20 November 2011 (UTC) delete WP:42 Deletion of Rage comic WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
18503 160 [[WePad]] (LAE) Benutzer:Norro/RC NONE keep Was geht denn hier ab? Koennt ihr bitte bei sachlicher Argumentation bleiben? Ausser den Verschwoerungstheorien, Wikipedia wuerde hier als Marketingsplattform missbraucht, ist hier in der Diskussion vornehmlich zu lesen (''„Die nach aussen beteiligten Unternehmen verfügen nicht annähernd über die finanziellen und logistischen Möglichkeiten solch ein Projekt zu stemmen“'', ''„ Ist vaporware.“''). Ich dachte erst, diese Diskussion ist Satire. Wenn ihr konkrete Kritikuntke habt, dann nennt sie. Dem urspruenglichen Grund fuer den Loeschantrag (''keine Resonanz'') wurde durch sachliche Nennung von Quellen begegnet. Dementsprechend muss nun ein neuer Loeschgrund her, oder der Artikel wird . Wenn die Sprache im Artikel jmd. zu werbend/wertend ist, dann sollten die entsprechenden Abschnitte auf der Diskussionsseite des Artikels genannt werden und koennen anschliessend belegt werden. Das ist aber in der Loeschdiskussion nicht relevant. Also bitte ... sachlich bleiben und die Loeschung des Artikels diskutieren. Mehr nicht. Gruss Löschung von WePad Wikipedia:Theoriefindung Wikipedia:No original research 65
18504 7566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erno S. Daniel User:Woerich 03:17, 24 April 2020 (UTC) delete Doesn’t meet . I did my own search and like {{u|WhatamIdoing}}, found nothing that would satisfy independent sourcing requirements Deletion of Erno S. Daniel WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18505 125 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Şablon:Kullanıcı Antikomünist """Kullanıcı:melihsenms""" 20.36, 20 Ocak 2020 (UTC) delete """Bu tür ideolojik yanlılık belirten şablonların tamamı silinmeli.?#Vikipedi özgür kürsü değildir|Vikipedi özgür kürsü değildir. """"Vikipedi özgür kürsü veya blog olmadığından; sohbet, tartışma, propaganda veya reklam yapma yeri değildir""" Şablon:Kullanıcı Antikomünist'in silinmesi Vikipedi:Vikipedi ne değildir Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18506 20557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tehreek-e-Tahaffuz-e-Pakistan User:DrStrauss 17:21, 28 September 2017 (UTC) delete wow, I would have thought a discussion like this would have elicited a bigger furore! But yeah, |notability isn't inherited - just because its founder is notable doesn't mean that it is notable. As nom says, any coverage independent from its creator is mostly passing, failing |coverage depth guidelines Deletion of Tehreek-e-Tahaffuz-e-Pakistan WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18507 1264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pataki full User:Northamerica1000 05:47, 12 January 2017 (UTC) delete Per source searches, does not meet and finding no evidence of being met. Source searches are only providing passing mentions (e.g. https://books.google.com/books?id=eJ5tBAAAQBAJ&pg=PT378&lpg=PT378&dq=%22Pataki+full%22+-wikipedia&source=bl&ots=mPw4O9Lite&sig=rTXL5FX98LGWKSLW00tHfOAqaik&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjGjaTT87vRAhUIw1QKHT7hBoIQ6AEInwEwGQ#v=onepage&q=%22Pataki%20full%22%20-wikipedia&f=false, https://books.google.com/books?id=Zxmuu7MrJT8C&pg=PA266&lpg=PA266&dq=%22Pataki+full%22+-wikipedia&source=bl&ots=_yDSh3pVjb&sig=ZA-L3rIOe4ddctfLdQc2rSQDPk8&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjGjaTT87vRAhUIw1QKHT7hBoIQ6AEIsAEwHQ#v=onepage&q=%22Pataki%20full%22%20-wikipedia&f=false Deletion of Pataki full WP:GNG||WP:BOOKCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18508 13400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian Ridpath (Canadian artist) User:Freshacconci 01:00, 13 May 2010 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability per or Deletion of Ian Ridpath (Canadian artist) WP:BIO||WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
18509 17230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MACS M3 User:K 02:56, 13 August 2018 (UTC) comment I'm not satisfied by the Jane snippet view: https://books.google.co.il/books?id=kC5EAQAAIAAJ&q=%22MACS+M3%22&dq=%22MACS+M3%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjYuZ_D5tzcAhVlLcAKHXTZC6EQ6AEINDAC; it may very well be passing mentions. Jane probably mentions many firearms routinely; the confirmation of existance does not mean . None have been offered at this AfD so far Deletion of MACS M3 WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
18510 146 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ertan Saruhan Kullanıcı:göktürk97göktürk97 16.23, 18 Aralık 2020 (UTC) merge """madde biraz da olsa gelişmiş. Emek veren arkadaşların eline emeğine sağlık fakat madde hâlâ kayda değer değil. Gazete haberleri denmiş gerekçelerde, şu an maddede bulunan hiçbir gazete haberi bu kişiyi kayda değer yapmıyor. https://www.evrensel.net/haber/109163/onlar-her-yerde-aniliyor Mesela şu kaynakta sadece ismi var, başka hiçbir şey yok. Adı da """"Erhan"""" olarak yazılmış, yanlış yazılmış. Bu gazete haberine göre """"kayda değer"""" dersek bu kişiye, emsal olduğunu düşünelim her ismi geçeni alıp Vikipediye ekleyecek miyiz? Yine OdaTv haberinde de Kızıldere Olayı'nda öldürülen kişilerle birlikte ismi geçiyor sadece. Turhan Feyizoğlu kaynağı incelenirse kişi direkt olarak konu alınmıyor, hep birileriyle bir yere gitmesi, bir yerden dönmesi konu alınmış. Bazen de diyaloglarda ismi geçiyor. Kitapta başka bir özelliği bulunmamakta. Hatta soyadı Saruhan olan başka kişilerin de ismi geçiyor. Onları da herhangi bir kitapta ismi geçiyor diye kayda değer mi görmeliyiz bu mantıkla? Tuncay Çelen'in kitabındaysa farklı bir durum mevcut. Kişiden 127. 128. ve 129. sayfalarda bahsedilmiş fakat kaynak okunursa yine kendisi Mahir Çayan'a bağlanıyor. Yani çok kısıtlı bir tanıtma var, başka hiçbir şey yok. Onun dışında eklenen sayfalara dikkat edilirse yine tek başına değil, bir grubun hareketi anlatılıyor. Yine bir yere hareket etme, bir yerden dönme var. Kendisiyle birlikte birçok isim var. Bedri Baykam'ın eserinde de 453-460 arasında 6 kez Ertuğrul Kürkçü'nün yorumlarında geçiyor ve kaynağa bakılırsa yine kayda değer bir hareketi yok. Yani direkt olarak kişiyi anlatmıyor. Daha çok bölgeye odaklanıyor. Şu an maddede bulunan kaynaklardan sadece bir tanesinde hayatı kısıtlı şekilde tanıtılmış, o da yine Mahir Çayan'a bağlanmış. Onun dışında tamamen isim olarak bulunuyor kaynaklarda. Kişi konu bile edilmiyor. Kişiden, aynı kaynaklarda olduğu gibi, Kızıldere Olayı maddesinde veyahut diğer devrimcilerin, örneğin Mahir Çayan, maddelerinde kısıtlı olarak bahsetmek yeterli olacaktır. Kaynaklar incelenirse ve buradan yola çıkarak |kayda değerlik yönergesine bakılırsa kişi kayda değer değildir. Kaynakların fazla olması, gazete haberlerinde isminin geçmesi, maddeye bibliyografya bölümünün eklenmesi kişiyi kayda değer yapmıyor, kendisini direkt olarak konu olan bir kaynak lazım. En azından şu an için kayda değer olmadığı kesin""" Ertan Saruhan'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
18511 3246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fatjon Tafaj User:GiantSnowman 10:08, 15 August 2012 (UTC) delete fail and Deletion of Fatjon Tafaj WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18512 19292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Team Unicorn User:Starblind 14:53, 30 September 2010 (UTC) delete per . I would have speedied this if I'd found it first, honestly Deletion of Team Unicorn WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
18513 18197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Zeigler User:Jodi 22:21, 19 April 2014 (UTC) comment I think vandalism/COI is a major problem here (as I've suggested at Wikipedia:Biographies_of_living_persons/Noticeboard#Jim Zeigler). I did some cleanup, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Jim_Zeigler&diff=604930740&oldid=604690037 deleting a bunch of the cruft. I agree that he passes #1 of olitician. Also his lawsuit got a 1-page mention in a book. So, for me, he just passes the bar for notability. Further editing/improvement is needed, for sure (to start, please can somebody fix my naming/grouping errors?). (For more references, the online version of the newspaper would be a start http://search.al.com/Jim+Zeigler/1/all/?date_range=y5 Al.com) Semi-protection until November would be advisable (since I assume this is mostly election-related vandalism Deletion of Jim Zeigler WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
18514 5011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Killer (card game) User:Edison 21:09, 17 April 2011 (UTC) delete unless sources are found to satisfy |notability Deletion of Killer (card game) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18515 6044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erdős–Bacon–Sabbath number User:Bilorv 00:35, 12 April 2017 (UTC) delete other than the Times Higher Education source, there are no reliable sources on this topic. The article is basically just and |synthesis of Erdos/Bacon/Sabbath numbers. I came across Erdős–Bacon number the other day and thought ''that'' was pushing it (and that article probably does need to be trimmed of a lot of OR), but Erdős–Bacon–Sabbath is definitely too far Deletion of Erdős–Bacon–Sabbath number WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
18516 169 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ayşegül Coşkun Kullanıcı:nedim gayet birnedim gâyet bir 15.52, 19 Şubat 2022 (UTC) delete """Vikipedi:Kayda değerlik (kişiler)|Vikipedi:Kayda değerlik (Kişiler)e göre kişinin kayda değerliği ispat edilemiyor. Çünkü, kayda değer filmlerde, televizyon ve sahne gösterilerinde """"önemli"""" rol oynamış değil. Yani, hasbelkader bir rol almış olması yetmiyor, önemli bir yapımda rolün """"önemli"""" de olması gerekiyor. Geniş veya önemli bir hayran kitlesi yok. Alanında çığır açmış değil. Aynı şekilde, e göre de kayda değerliği ispat edilemiyor. Gazete ve dergi mülakatlarının niceliğinden ziyade niteliklerine dikkat edilmesi gerekiyor. Daha çok """"röportaj"""", daha kayda değer anlamına gelmiyor. Konser verdi, sahneye çıktı, tekli çıkardı gibi basit ve cılız haberler, zâten """"güvenilir kaynak"""" sınıfına girmiyor. Uzun lafın kıssâsı; kayda değerliği tespit edilemediği için silinsin. Hamiş: """"İngilizce yazan arkadaş"""" bize sunduğu kaynakları okuyup, anlayabiliyor da, bize neden İngilizce yazıyor, bu da ayrı bir muammâ""" Ayşegül Coşkun'un silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
18517 160 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Evrensel Basım Yayın Kullanıcı:mecnun112mecnun 17:10, 14 Kasım 2016 (UTC) delete Kalsın diyen sevgili katılımcıların ekseninde fikirlerinizi gözden geçirmelerinde fayda var. Evrensel Gazetesi'nin (ki maddesi mevcut) bir girişimidir bu ve Evrensel Gazetesi'nin maddesi altında pek tabii yer alabilir. Vikipedi bir dizin veye PR alanı olmayıp, tecimsel yapıların her girişime ayrı ayrı yer vermesi düşünülümemez. Kaldı ki zaten VP:KD kriterlerini de taşımadığını düşünüyorum. Öte yandan Vikipedi basının https://www.evrensel.net/haber/295517/evrensel-basim-yayini-vikipediden-silme-girisimi muhtıra türü haberlerle dizayn edebileceği prangalı bir platform değildir Evrensel Basım Yayın'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:TBA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18518 11949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael H. Riordan User:Joe 17:55, 4 September 2016 (UTC) keep Clearly meets #C1 (>1000 citations and a h-index of 16 on https://www.scopus.com/authid/detail.uri?authorId=7006865777 Scopus), #C3, #C5 and #C7 Deletion of Michael H. Riordan WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18519 11059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bullshit User:Colonel 19:28, 26 April 2009 (UTC) delete It's etymology, usage and synonyms - nothing but dictionary/thesaurus material. is a policy and this article blatantly fails it Deletion of Bullshit WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18520 12804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pan Pantziarka User:Green 16:25, 28 October 2013 (UTC) delete """The reason for the delete vote is because the rules for Notability can be found at . It says sources must be ''secondary'' ie. newspapers, magazines, books, etc.. ''about'' the topic, not ''by'' the topic (summarized at ). Of course material by the subject of the article is available, but anyone can show their accomplishments. That is why we need independent evidence from sources unassociated with the subject that this is a person of """"note"""" ie. discussed in a significant manner by other people. There is a single source that does this, ''The Independent'', from 1999. I'm actually impressed with the wide ranging career of Pantziarka and couldn't imagine this was all the same person, yet couldn't imagine two people with the same name either. So I searched many sources both online and off and had no luck, other than the ''Independent''. If there are other sources like it, they should be added since it establishes notability, but I could not find them""" Deletion of Pan Pantziarka WP:GNG||WP:42 Wikipedia:Notability 77
18521 16256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lena Hyena User:Cirt 01:10, 17 December 2007 (UTC) delete agree with {{user|Malleus Fatuarum}}, any relevant info can be moved to the movie article, but as it is this is unsourced Deletion of Lena Hyena WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18522 11652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whealk User:Blanchardb 20:24, 15 December 2007 (UTC) delete per . The fact the article is unsourced makes this term a potential as well. --Blanchardb Deletion of Whealk WP:NEO||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18523 10632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dead map User:Edison 18:55, 18 January 2011 (UTC) delete """as failing |verifiability as well as |notability, and because WP is OT|not a dictionary. Every nation, and many organizations undoubtedly have """"secret maps,"""" but for present ones it would be quite difficult to get reliable sources which say much about them. Historic secret maps might be a topic for an article. This is not it""" Deletion of Dead map WP:V||WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18524 10538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disco Singh User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:52, 2 December 2013 (UTC) keep As filming has begun, |looking finds this topic IS being covered in |multiple sources,http://tito-dutta.my3gb.com/IndianEnglishNewspapersSearch.html#gsc.tab=0&gsc.q=Diljit-Dosanjh&gsc.sort=http://tito-dutta.my3gb.com/IndianEnglishNewspapersSearch.html#gsc.tab=0&gsc.q=Diljit-Dosanjh-Disco-Singh&gsc.sort= I think we do the project a service by allowing the topic to be improved over time and through regular editing. Let's enlist the aid of Project India and let it be done Deletion of Disco Singh WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
18525 11569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murders of Jourdan Bobbish and Jacob Kudla User:Hobit 07:31, 21 November 2016 (UTC) keep Clearly meets , so the question is of meeting and the associated OTNEWS. Given that we've got sustained coverage on an international level, I've got to say yes it does Deletion of Murders of Jourdan Bobbish and Jacob Kudla WP:N||WP:EVENT||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18526 14370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/You're the One (The Black Keys song) User:SBKSPP 01:33, 10 April 2021 (UTC) keep Meets with sources presented by MarioSoulTruthFan and nom. They're reliable enough IMV Deletion of You're the One (The Black Keys song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18527 13391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Douglas User:Edgars2007 11:06, 15 June 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Steven Douglas WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
18528 762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/101 West Ohio User:Batard0 15:05, 22 October 2012 (UTC) delete """The sourcing that can be found is thin, although I'm open to changing my vote if convincingly significant coverage can be uncovered. The page on the EPA website does not amount to significant independent coverage, in my view, because it was largely provided by the owners of the building in question. The EPA may be a reliable source, but it must also be independent of the subject, which is not wholly the case here. The award the building won is not significant coverage; it's merely a listing of an award it won. It fails on these bases. The spirit of notability is that reliable sources have independently decided to take note of something because they think it's worth noting. The award may indicate this to a degree, but the EPA coverage certainly does not, in my view. It is on a website that catalogs all buildings meeting its certifications, and thus the EPA was effectively required to """"take note"""" of it instead of deciding on its own that it was notable""" Deletion of 101 West Ohio WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18529 11391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Modern Art Records User:Doc 17:17, 26 January 2008 (UTC) delete doesn't assert notability, no notable bands, no secondary sources, yup it fails Deletion of Modern Art Records WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18530 813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tukur Adam User:Versace1608 17:11, 10 April 2020 (UTC) delete The subject fails and . I wasn't able to find any reliable independent coverage of him in the article or through a Google search. The first and second references cited in the article are not independent of the subject. The third reference is about the subject winning a non-notable award Deletion of Tukur Adam WP:GNG||WP:NMODEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18531 16944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Batman Beyond characters User:DustFormsWords 02:35, 21 October 2009 (UTC) merge all nominated entries) to appropriate character list. Per and proposal at Wikipedia:Notability (fiction) individual characters must have individual notability, with the standard generally being that the character is titular, historically significant, or a major character of a multimedia franchise. I'm a Batman nut and I can't remotely make the claim that these are major characters Deletion of Batman Beyond characters WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18532 6829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Famous Litvaks of Lithuanian origin User:Kraxler 16:55, 16 July 2015 (UTC) delete """It's , only """"source"""" is a blog""" Deletion of Famous Litvaks of Lithuanian origin WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
18533 931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boris Palatnik User:Bearian 19:53, 3 February 2020 (UTC) delete per - there are a couple of possible sources, but really, is a designer of walking canes |notable? Or is this just |spam for a luxury accessory Deletion of Boris Palatnik WP:MILL||WP:GNG||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
18534 10391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Renaldo Fischer User:Lesion 11:35, 4 July 2013 (UTC) delete doesn't appear to meet or criteria Deletion of Renaldo Fischer WP:AUTHOR||WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18535 18736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas McNutt User:Bearcat 22:25, 3 August 2017 (UTC) delete """People do not get Wikipedia articles just for being ''candidates'' in future elections — if you cannot show and properly source that he was ''already'' notable enough for an article for some other reason ''besides'' the fact of being a candidate, then he has to ''win'' the election and become an actual ''holder'' of political office, not just have his name on the ballot, to get an article for his political activities. But nothing here demonstrates that: all of the sources here are either |primary source references to his own campaign literature, or local election coverage of the type that's |routinely ''expected'' to exist for ''all'' elections, so nothing here demonstrates that his candidacy would somehow qualify as that exceedingly rare """"notable because his candidacy exploded to garner a lot more coverage than normal"""" special case either""" Deletion of Thomas McNutt WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:No original research 65
18536 11781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henessy User:Snowsuit 18:14, 29 July 2015 (UTC) delete """fails since the AVN """"Best Sex Scene in a Foreign-Shot Production"""" which she won meets the criterium """"Awards in scene-related and ensemble categories are excluded from consideration""" Deletion of Henessy WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18537 11535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Hellevator episodes User:Jax 03:02, 20 November 2016 (UTC) comment I am willing to consider a redirect per Deletion of List of Hellevator episodes WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
18538 15363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myles Eden User:Bagumba 22:55, 11 May 2012 (UTC) delete """As a former college football quarterback, he did meet nor did he become a professional that meets . He does not meet with multiple sources of significant coverage from independent sources. There is lots of Google hits, but the sources are mostly just his name mentioned as part of normal game coverage, or a few lines of pre-game coverage about practices or trivial quotes about upcoming opponents. Most of the major sources are from the Bay Area News Group local papers of ''San Jose Mercury News'' or ''Oakland Tribune''. Per GNG, """"Multiple publications from the same author or organization are usually regarded as a single source for the purposes of establishing notability."""" If major coverage can be uncovered and his can be explained as more than a un-of-the-mill college QB, I can reconsider. Starting college quarterbacks as a group are not automatically notable, let alone one that only started a few games. I ask that the discussion not be ed with any and all coverage""" Deletion of Myles Eden WP:NCOLLATH||WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE||WP:IMPACT||WP:R||WP:BOMBARD Wikipedia:Notability 77
18539 12554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob cuba User:CheNuevara 18:47, 1 October 2007 (UTC) delete Clear case of and . See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Gavfox77 contribs Deletion of Bob cuba WP:SPAM||WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Spam 112
18540 15994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of historical drama films User:MichaelQSchmidt 09:23, 8 May 2013 (UTC) keep """as a list article with clearly defined inclusion criteria. To disagree with the nominator's |feeling it """"indescriminate"""", it nicely meets and serves Wikipeidia readers as a functional navigational aid. To agree with NA1K's analysis, as a list of |notable historical drama films, a notable genre of film, it's not particularly indiscriminate""" Deletion of List of historical drama films WP:POV||WP:LISTPURP||WP:NF Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18541 7511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gupta Straddle User:Moreschi 11:25, 17 February 2007 (UTC) delete quite apart from the wikilinks, |Wikipedia is really not for stuff thought up in the bedroom one day. Pardon the pun, but this one really is |complete bollocks. Indeed, I might go so far as to say that this article matches the Deletion of Gupta Straddle WP:NFT||WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
18542 12615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rama Akkiraju User:Jooojay 08:52, 22 October 2019 (UTC) keep I see significant coverage of reliable sources already here in the article, passes Deletion of Rama Akkiraju WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18543 965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islam and censorship User:Anonymous209 17:04, 19 September 2012 (UTC) keep Due to change in title. Let me stipulate that I agree with almost all points Roscelese and NarSakSasLee have made. It is a terrible article. It has within it, there are multiple editors adding criticisms of Muslims or the actions of some Muslims as censorship, when they clearly aren't, plus there is a confusion between the actions of autocratic regimes (which, whether secular or religious, always censor free speech) with their religious character. The question I now ask myself is not whether it is a good article (it isn't) nor whether the article as written violates WP principles (it does), but whether an article CAN be written on the subject. I also agree that to get there, it has to be mercilessly slashed, but falls short of WP:TNT Deletion of Islam and censorship WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
18544 16343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diwali sweets [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 05:58, 30 October 2013 (UTC) comment Shouldn't this be the subject of a discussion (on relevant article talk pages) rather than a deletion discussion Deletion of Diwali sweets WP:MERGE Wikipedia:Merging 54
18545 6367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grand Duchy of Machias User:Cosmic 05:52, 17 November 2008 (UTC) delete per . Looks like Special:Contributions/TheGrandDuke|someone has been having delusions of grandeur Deletion of Grand Duchy of Machias WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18546 1141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul McDonald (musician) User:Northamerica1000 22:04, 8 April 2014 (UTC) keep The subject passes and has received post-American Idol coverage in reliable sources, thus not failing WP:BLP1E Deletion of Paul McDonald (musician) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18547 6614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Savannah State University College of Liberal Arts and Social Sciences User:Noeticsage 20:28, 23 March 2008 (UTC) comment In fact, |notability is not inherited from a parent article. Just because Savannah State University is notable does not mean that all of its constituent colleges are notable. Each subarticle still has to satisfy |general notability guidelines on its own Deletion of Savannah State University College of Liberal Arts and Social Sciences WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:N Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18548 17840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Week in League User:Stuartyeates 10:30, 19 August 2015 (UTC) delete as failing to meet the Deletion of This Week in League WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18549 12488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Le Mur (urban art) User:Pburka 16:58, 22 September 2012 (UTC) keep per and the references in the article Deletion of Le Mur (urban art) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18550 5807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Earle Sullivan User:KidAd 23:59, 18 January 2021 (UTC) delete Non-notable activist is a glaring case of Deletion of John Earle Sullivan WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18551 9230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elf Only Inn (5th nomination) User:T3h 19:40, 13 June 2010 (UTC) delete because the WCCA is from the same company as EOI. That means that even if it is |notable, you have to make sure it's not |self-promotional. —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Elf Only Inn (5th nomination) WP:PROMO||WP:notable Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18552 269 [[Cidad]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Saluk 14:01, 13. Aug. 2008 (CEST) delete Mir kam das Projekt gleich so bekannt vor, das wurde im gelöschten Artikel /26. Juni 2008#I-sense (gelöscht)|I-sense als Referenz angegeben. Jedenfalls ist es hier in der WP fehl am Platz, wir sind doch kein Verzeichnis von Entwicklerportalen. Dafür sind Hauptseiten der Universitäten und solche Web-2.0-Geschichten wie Xing zuständig. Hier Löschung von Cidad Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
18553 20676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K. Surendran (politician) (3rd nomination) User:Padavalamkuttanpilla 09:06, 13 March 2021 (UTC) keep """What's going on here I don't understand... How can the notability of a person who sees more than a hundred different types of reliable sources be repeatedly questioned? You should clarify why he failed the WP:GNG.. According to GNG {{tq|A topic is presumed'' to be suitable for a stand-alone article or list when'' it has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject}}. So Not satisfying criteria does not per se indicate a lack of notability.The """""""" standard is the only component needed to pass the WP:GNG. Are you saying that and can't be used because he didn't pass ? Btw ,I can't proceed without mentioning your double standard ,why it isn't applicable here the same criteria you defined in the https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/T._Geenakumari This discussion.? Please elaborate and It amazes me that you could not find more sources about him that are not already used in the article""" Deletion of K. Surendran (politician) (3rd nomination) WP:NPOL||WP:NPOL||WP:ANYBIO||WP:BASIC||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18554 14303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cooneyites User:Shoessss 02:10, 27 January 2008 (UTC) keep Google Scholar shows several hits as noted here http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22Cooneyites%22&hl=en&lr=&btnG=Search. Google News has additional information, as shown here http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Cooneyites%22&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&btnG=Search+Archives. With at least two of the articles being from the New York Times and lastly good old Google with at least one additional mention from the New York Times, as shown here http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Cooneyites%22&btnG=Google+Search. Regarding the article is referenced, as noted on the page. Are more cites needed, yes, but not a reason to delete Deletion of Cooneyites WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18555 114 [[Theater Performance Kunst RAMPIG]] (bleibt) NONE NONE keep """In Ermangelung ausgearbeiteter Relevanzkriterien für Theaterensembles, insb. für Gruppierungen der freien Szene oder gar interdisziplinärer Kollektive wie im Fall der behandelten Gruppe, habe ich mich an den #Darstellende_K.C3.BCnstler.2C_Moderatoren.2C_Filmstab|Relevanzkriterien für Darstellende Künstler orientiert, die auch """"andere Mitwirkende an Bühnenaufführungen"""" mit einschließen. Das Kollektiv hatte u.a. drei Inszenierungen am Theater der Stadt Heidelberg und eine Inszenierung als Preiträger eines Bundeswettbewerbs Berliner Festspiele im Haus der Berliner Festspiele. Die Gruppe und deren Inszenierungen hatten äußerst positive Aufmerksamkeit in einem bedeutendem überregionalem Medium, der Zeitschrift http://theaterderzeit.de/2014/02/ Theater der Zeit sowie einen anerkannten und bedeutenden Preis erhalten: Preisträger http://www.berlinerfestspiele.de/de/aktuell/festivals/bundeswettbewerbe/theatertreffen_der_jugend/archiv_ttj/archiv_ttj13/ttj13_buehne/ttj13_veranstaltungsdetail_65766.php Berliner Festspiele Theatertreffen der Jugend 2013 (sowie 2 weitere Nominierungen eben dort). Jeder einzelne der drei Umstände begründet laut Kriterienkatalog Relevanz, insb. natürlich in der kombinierten Gesamtheit der drei Kriterien, daher""" Löschung von Theater Performance Kunst RAMPIG Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
18556 16840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Korean drama television series in Pakistan User:Narky 14:34, 14 August 2018 (UTC) delete A list of this sort needs to be supported by coverage ''of the subject-matter of the list as such''. All that I could find was https://hnow.tv/blog/korean-dramas-pakistan/ this blog (which clearly isn't ). Fails and Deletion of Korean drama television series in Pakistan WP:RS||WP:LISTN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18557 2836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uneven User:Hzh 14:37, 3 August 2018 (UTC) delete """Apart from trivial listings, I can only find one brief mention in a book https://books.google.com/books?id=8ZwZcZ2X5ToC&pg=PA78, not enough to satisfy . A redirect is also possible, but the title is a common word and people searching for something """"uneven"""" is unlikely to be looking for the album, and it would only cause confusion when redirected to Sieges Even""" Deletion of Uneven WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18558 21126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sultan Mansor Shah Secondary School User:Rubbish 18:46, 17 January 2016 (UTC) keep per which states that articles on secondary schools ahould be kept as long as their existence can be http://www.flipkart.com/education-melaka-including-st-francis-institution-smk-tinggi-sultan-mansor-shah-secondary-school-smss-henry-gurney-prisoners-school-english/p/itmd3kqmaseme5az verified Deletion of Sultan Mansor Shah Secondary School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18559 3125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trump resistance User:Sławomir 12:04, 12 June 2017 (UTC) delete The present article exists solely as a POV-fork of Protests against Donald Trump. For context, see https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Trump_resistance&oldid=784103458 this revision of the article, which spectacularly fails . The current revision has had the gross policy failures mostly removed, but there is now no reasonable scope for a separate article Deletion of Trump resistance WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18560 7735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sweeney Young User:Siva1979 05:42, 24 July 2007 (UTC) delete A http://www.google.com.sg/search?as_q=&hl=en&num=100&btnG=Google+Search&as_epq=Sweeney+Young&as_oq=&as_eq=wikipedia&lr=&as_ft=i&as_filetype=&as_qdr=all&as_occt=any&as_dt=i&as_sitesearch=&as_rights=&safe=images google search shows up no |reliable hits for this actor. Moreover, the subject in question fails |notability guidelines as well. Finally, according to the article, he has not won any noteworthy awards for his acting. --|S Deletion of Sweeney Young WP:RS||WP:BIO||WP:EA Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18561 4943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Talking Snowman User:Nsk92 01:54, 15 August 2008 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability under given in the article and none that I could find after quite a bit of googling. Could not find any libraries holding this book in WorldCathttp://www.worldcat.org/search?q=ti%3ATalking+Snowman&qt=advanced (although there is another book there with the same name but by a different writer, Lois Gladys Leppard, that might actually be notable Deletion of The Talking Snowman WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
18562 3013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Culbann C.P.C (2nd nomination) User:Joe 18:52, 17 June 2010 (UTC) comment Hosting a notable event does not show automatic notability per . In Schmidt's searches, I didn't see any significant coverage Deletion of Culbann C.P.C (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18563 4755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mount Star Secondary School (2nd nomination) User:Lemongirl942 03:47, 24 July 2016 (UTC) comment vote Updated with stronger reasoning below) Fails . While I generally support , this is only if the school is a verified accredited school. I have not found a single reliable source which indicates that the school exists and is accredited. Till such sources are found, this is a delete Deletion of Mount Star Secondary School (2nd nomination) WP:V||WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18564 8091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of ultra high-net-worth individuals User:Clarityfiend 08:11, 15 August 2018 (UTC) delete """per , specifically """"too general or too broad in scope"""". Ultra high-net-worth individual claims 226,450 people qualify! Billionaires make manageable lists by wealth. $30 million is chump change, comparatively speaking""" Deletion of List of ultra high-net-worth individuals WP:SALAT Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
18565 7269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wenatchee-Eastmont Basketball Rivalry User:Metropolitan90 06:32, 13 December 2010 (UTC) delete High school sports rivalries are not inherently notable; they need to have independent |reliable sources to establish their notability. Furthermore, this rivalry has only been played three times, and it looks like Wikipedia doesn't even have an article about either of the high schools involved Deletion of Wenatchee-Eastmont Basketball Rivalry WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18566 13135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Interstellar Marines (2nd nomination) User:Someone 19:01, 9 February 2011 (UTC) keep Whether the game is released or not is irrelevant, the bottom line is whether enough sources exist for an article (per , , etc.). In addition to the couple of sources pointed out above, Ars Technica (owned by Condé Nast Publications) has two pieces by the same author, Michael Thompson. The http://arstechnica.com/gaming/news/2010/01/interstellar-marines-trite-name-crowd-sourced-budget.ars first is an extremely useful source chock-ful of info. The http://arstechnica.com/gaming/news/2010/02/interstellar-marines-crowd-sourced-funding-not-what-it-seems.ars second actually looks at what the developers' history and is very pertinent. The sources allow an article to be crafted on what it is, an unfinished project which may never see the light of day, rather than a pre-emptive article on a non-existent video game Deletion of Interstellar Marines (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
18567 2322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naomi Hunter User:Bearian 16:48, 14 September 2020 (UTC) delete per . We've been over this many times. State/provincial leaders of minor parties are almost never notable Deletion of Naomi Hunter WP:POLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18568 19628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The peace movement User:Dhartung 03:49, 27 September 2007 (UTC) delete creator admits there is no |notability above. Should be named Day of Silence for Peace if kept; current name is simply asking for confusion Deletion of The peace movement WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18569 8550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rojda Aykoç User:Boleyn 07:42, 6 September 2014 (UTC) comment ping|Vekoler}} and {{ping|Tiptoethrutheminefield}} Does she meet any of the criteria at or ? Having a long career or lots of Youtube videos can't count. Of her seven albums, have any of them charted in a national chart, or met any other part of Deletion of Rojda Aykoç WP:MUSICBIO||WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18570 17992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gunther Holtorf user:Andrew 19:52, 25 April 2015 (UTC) keep Barbara Toy was doing this sort of journey 50 years ago so this chap is not that remarkable but, even so, it's quite clearly not a |BLP1E case as there isn't an event and there's no separate article for this non-existent event Deletion of Gunther Holtorf WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18571 10813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coffee Comic User:Just 18:15, 19 November 2005 (UTC) delete as no evidence of passing Deletion of Coffee Comic WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18572 18362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Kernell User:Yworo 21:36, 14 July 2010 (UTC) merge per Deletion of David Kernell WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18573 13026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ass Hunter User:Ferret 21:44, 18 March 2017 (UTC) comment Besides the reliable sources already in the article, there's also http://www.slate.com/blogs/business_insider/2014/11/24/google_removes_ass_hunter_game_app_about_killing_gay_people_from_google.html Slate, http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2472666,00.asp PCMag, http://money.cnn.com/2014/11/24/news/companies/ass-hunter-gay-google-game/ CNN. http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/homophobic-ass-hunter-gay-killing-game-pulled-google-play-amid-controversy-1476366 IBTimes (Questionable reliably if I recall though), https://www.dailydot.com/debug/google-removes-homophobic-android-game/ Daily Dot (Questionable reliably), http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/google-play-deletes-homophobic-game-10-000-downloads-article-1.2021819 NY Daily News... There's a lot of sourcing available from secondary reliable sources, however, it feels a little bit like a situation (Which normally only applies to people). The coverage is entirely about the game's removal, and appears to be covered only by typical daily news. Other than PCMag, there appears to be no coverage from any typical VG reliable sources and no direct coverage of the game itself separate from it's removal Deletion of Ass Hunter WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18574 2186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MV Island Sky User:Parsecboy 13:40, 16 May 2008 (UTC) keep per MBK004's comments. It's not a violation of Deletion of MV Island Sky WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18575 15227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keisha Buchanan's debut album User:My76Strat 04:00, 17 June 2012 (UTC) delete per under CSD A7 without redirect. '''Merge and redirect'''; while it may be proper to include the subject within Keisha Buchanan's BLP, it is not possible to predict notability for stand alone status unless there were significant pre-production sales Deletion of Keisha Buchanan's debut album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18576 12502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gage, Randy Paul User:The 12:49, 27 January 2013 (UTC) delete this has the distict whiff of anispamcruftisement to it. (Also, if kept, it needs to be moved to Randy Gage Deletion of Gage, Randy Paul WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18577 21587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stan Neeleman User:MCB 07:59, 18 June 2008 (UTC) delete does not meet and seems like an average academic to me. I don't think an endowed chair necessarily indicates encylopedic notability (certain chairs in certain fields at certain universities, because of traditions associated with them and notable previous holders; that's more the case in the sciences). And third-party coverage is very thin indeed, along the lines of passing mentions Deletion of Stan Neeleman WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18578 13283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suicide of Katelyn Nicole Davis User:Tamsier 17:01, 26 January 2019 (UTC) delete thousands of people commit suicide every day and many are reported in the press. However we can't create articles for every dead person especially someone who video taped their own suicide. Delete as per and year test Deletion of Suicide of Katelyn Nicole Davis WP:NOTNEWS||WP:10 Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18579 15324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Weitz user:Hannes 16:01, 22 June 2021 (UTC) comment """while I could not find any reviews on JSTOR, there are https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22Richard+Weitz%22 high citation rates on GS including a paper that has 328 citations and a single author article with >100 citations. For the humanities that seems a lot to me and his books seem to be cited 50-100 times even though I did not find reviews, so clearly there is a documented influence on the field, but maybe this is a high citation field within the humanities. Overall, I am not sure if it amounts to what would be needed in #1 but when I doubt I would lean to keep. Also in the article he is mentioned as a """"Director"""" at the Hudson_Institute but that title does not seem to mean much, in the article of the institute he is listed as """"fellow"""" which is also what the institutes https://www.hudson.org/experts website seems to indicate""" Deletion of Richard Weitz WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18580 18893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thein Myint User:Phil 17:59, 23 November 2010 (UTC) keep The source linked in the article confirms participation in three Olympics, passing , and http://www.myanmar.gov.mm/myanmartimes/no228/MyanmarTimes12-228/olp02.htm this confirms the Asian Games gold medal Deletion of Thein Myint WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18581 2227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oliver Skipp User:GiantSnowman 12:54, 1 August 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Oliver Skipp WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18582 16606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ZoomCare User:DannyS712 20:50, 13 February 2019 (UTC) keep clearly passes Deletion of ZoomCare WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18583 16402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sigma 60mm f/2.8 DN Art User:Graeme 22:52, 5 July 2017 (UTC) keep This should be kept on Wikipedia as it easily can achieve . There are numerous references available online including independent reviews and magazine appearances Deletion of Sigma 60mm f/2.8 DN Art WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18584 8387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 UK Open Qualifier 1 User:Adamant1 07:31, 6 November 2020 (UTC) delete Only primary and trivial coverage=does not pass or =delete all Deletion of 2010 UK Open Qualifier 1 WP:GNG||WP:NSPORTWHATEVER Wikipedia:Notability 77
18585 11225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pi-nella User:MER 03:16, 3 February 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Pi-nella WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18586 19871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uplinkearth User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable corporation. &mdash Deletion of Uplinkearth WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18587 11330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathan Apodaca User:Benmite 08:35, 21 October 2020 (UTC) merge as per and above votes Deletion of Nathan Apodaca WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18588 9543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Built to Serve User:Russavia 17:30, 6 October 2007 (UTC) delete per , and failing that, Deletion of Built to Serve WP:SPAM||WP:V Wikipedia:Spam 112
18589 17084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vacs (musician) User:Kofiowia 19:03, 7 April 2017 (UTC) keep WP:GNG or requirement met BIO well sourced and referenced. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Vacs (musician) WP:MUSIC||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18590 10045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Behrooz Astaneh User:Icewhiz 14:04, 16 July 2018 (UTC) delete Clearly does not pass GNG. I don't see how he passes . h-index of 9 per google scholar. Academic position (and journal editor) doesn't seem to qualify Deletion of Behrooz Astaneh WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18591 2299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phantom fungus User:Gavin 11:31, 7 November 2007 (UTC) delete as ghits show that no |reliable secondary sources exist to demonstrate |notability outside of the game. Shame it can't speak or sing, otherwise this could be merged with ''Little Shop of Horrors (musical Deletion of Phantom fungus WP:RS||WP:FICT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18592 3633 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barry Atwater User:DiamondRemley39 01:14, 23 July 2020 (UTC) keep as meets . I've been going through sources and I've added some to the article. More reviews to read, his other name to search for, info on his father/early life/UCLA to seek out, and scifi sources to investigate and add Deletion of Barry Atwater WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18593 13525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Major League Baseball attendance figures User:GiantSnowman 11:35, 14 September 2013 (UTC) delete clear case of Deletion of List of Major League Baseball attendance figures WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18594 7442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Single File User:Chubbles1212 20:32, 20 November 2006 (UTC) comment I think at this point, it's clear that the band is notable under ; the only problem is whether it passes . Again, I need more time than AfD permits, but I think this band is notable and this article can eventually pass muster Deletion of Single File WP:MUSIC||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
18595 8565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Truman (musician) User:Themfromspace 02:08, 26 January 2012 (UTC) delete per and . I can't find significant coverage of him in reliable sources, nor has he impacted his field in a notable way or won any important awards Deletion of Tim Truman (musician) WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18596 6537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greatest Hits (Lost) User:Rockstar915 05:21, 6 April 2007 (UTC) comment Depressed Marvin, |be civil Deletion of Greatest Hits (Lost) WP:CIVIL Wikipedia:Civility 37
18597 4476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephanie Cmar User:Samsmachado 23:21, 3 May 2021 (UTC) keep Plenty of in-depth coverage to demonstrate meeting . As outlined by Pburka, is not a problem. Coverage demonstrates Cmar's notability extends beyond Top Chef and exceeds that of your average reality show contestant Deletion of Stephanie Cmar WP:GNG||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
18598 21579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melvin Burris User:Inks 22:37, 16 October 2011 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Melvin Burris WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18599 20453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lawrence E. Corbridge User:Bakazaka 04:10, 3 November 2018 (UTC) delete """Community consensus has not supported treating LDS leaders as exempt from GNG, despite repeated efforts to propose such an exemption (see examples in Wikipedia_talk:Notability_(people)/Archive_2014#Religious_leaders|2014, Wikipedia_talk:Notability_(people)/Archive_2016#Leaders in The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and other religious organizations|2016, Wikipedia_talk:Notability_(people)/Archive_2017#Exception Proposal for General Authority Seventies of the LDS_Church|2017, and Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2018 August 3|2018). So applies to LDS leaders. This is not a problem for LDS leaders who actually get significant coverage in multiple independent reliable sources. But that's not the case for this article's subject. Sources currently in article are not independent under (''Liahona'', ''Almanac'', lds.org) or not reliable (""""Grampa Bill"""") and do not count toward establishing notability. Note that the ''Almanac'' is assembled by ''Church News'' staff, which is why it is not independent. Search does not find in independent reliable sources, only the usual passing mentions, event announcements, and ''Church News'' items reproduced in ''Deseret News'', along with a single name check in a 1996 local business article in his role as an attorney (under """"Larry Corbridge""""). The subject does not seem to pass . Open to reconsideration if in-depth coverage emerges""" Deletion of Lawrence E. Corbridge WP:GNG||WP:IIS||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18600 17976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radisson Blu Edwardian Heathrow Hotel user:Andrew 12:58, 17 July 2021 (UTC) keep """WP:MILL is an |essay and so has """"''no official status, and does not speak for the Wikipedia community''"""". See |A;|B;|C and |D""" Deletion of Radisson Blu Edwardian Heathrow Hotel WP:ESSAY||WP:ATD||WP:BEFORE||WP:CENSOR||WP:DINC Wikipedia:Essays 31
18601 15163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/.рф User:Wrs1864 13:22, 13 May 2008 (UTC) delete The references appear to mostly be from the organization proposing this new TLD, which would violate and it is about a hypothetical, which violates . I could see it (and many similar TLD articles) being created when the Internationalized domain name process for TLDs is closer to being finalized Deletion of .рф WP:RS||WP:NOTCRYSTAL Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18602 133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raise the Death User:Scientizzle 03:13, 25 June 2007 (UTC) delete or redirect to the band. There's no sources here, which fails . Just because the band is (ostensibly) notable, doesn't mean unsourced articles about individual albums with no secondary coverage. &mdash Deletion of Raise the Death WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18603 1180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Wasow User:Fæ 19:21, 31 July 2010 (UTC) keep As he holds a named chair (according to the linked Stanford bio page), the article meets criteria 5 of . The article requires expansion and improvement so maintenance tags rather than deletion is the way to go Deletion of Tom Wasow WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18604 6985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dreams of Stabbing and/or Being Stabbed (2nd nomination) User:Duffbeerforme 00:54, 23 April 2011 (UTC) delete """Lacks coverage in independent reliable sources. , """"Unreleased material (including demos, mixtapes, bootlegs, promo-only recordings) are in general not notable"""", this is one such case that is not notable""" Deletion of Dreams of Stabbing and/or Being Stabbed (2nd nomination) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18605 7098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roman Matovsky User:IceWelder 10:24, 25 April 2021 (UTC) delete per nom. This falls under . The author appears to be article subject.https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Microsoft_OneDrive&diff=prev&oldid=916301580 Deletion of Roman Matovsky WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
18606 17455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chrissy Houlahan User:Mr 14:56, 15 September 2018 (UTC) keep passes |GNG and |ANYBIO ''' —''' Deletion of Chrissy Houlahan WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18607 2461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roger Maloney User:HumbleGod 19:50, 15 July 2006 (UTC) delete as non-notable bureaucrat failing Deletion of Roger Maloney WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18608 2167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Universal rotation curve [[User talk:120.23.241.114|talk]]) 13:19, 16 October 2014 (UTC) comment Somebody should perhaps read and . -- Special:Contributions/120.23.241.114|120.23.241.114 Deletion of Universal rotation curve WP:COI||WP:YOURSELF Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
18609 5684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phousseyne Diaby User:Path 08:06, 6 April 2019 (UTC) keep Definitely satisfies , , , (this player is a member of a team participating in tournaments conducted by FIFA), links= https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/phousseyne-diaby/profil/spieler/182815, https://www.whoscored.com/Players/116578/Show/Phousseyne-Diaby, etc Deletion of Phousseyne Diaby WP:BIO||WP:SPORTSPERSON||WP:NSPORT||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18610 13012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JKO EZ User:Archiegoel 09:23, 4 July 2012 (UTC) delete not enough to meet - and Deletion of JKO EZ WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18611 658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Black (cricketer) User:Lugnuts 13:16, 18 January 2021 (UTC) keep Meets N:CRIC. After a failed RfC, Fram is now trying to make his with wide-scale across the project Deletion of James Black (cricketer) WP:POINT||WP:DE Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
18612 3855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roland Agambire User:DJAMP4444 09:02, 5 June 2014 (UTC) delete It clearly meets . If it was PRODed before and no change happened, get an administrator to delete it ASAP Deletion of Roland Agambire WP:BLPPROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion of biographies of living people 66
18613 3700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matrix scheme User:Krimpet 06:43, 6 April 2007 (UTC) keep deletion is not the way to resolve an edit war. Plenty of |reliable sources are cited; |notability is firmly established. An edit war, no matter how prolonged, #Discussion|is not a valid reason to delete a perfectly valid article Deletion of Matrix scheme WP:ATT||WP:N||WP:DP Wikipedia:Attribution 108
18614 11711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jovan Krneta User:GiantSnowman 09:22, 13 December 2011 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Jovan Krneta WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18615 5902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Table of divisors NONE NONE comment First of all, this all needs to be referenced presumably, or at least the source code used to generate the page needs to be posted in order to conduct an audit of it. Otherwise, as a '''reference about numbers''', it's unverifiable. Secondly, I find it a bit of a stretch to say that this is any kind of useful reference at all. But be that as it may, the policy specifically states Deletion of Table of divisors WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18616 2486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 Shuvat Rachel shooting User:E 19:35, 24 July 2015 (UTC) keep """As per the most important of the several policies that distinguish notable events from routine news and events. reads: """"If a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to be suitable for a stand-alone article."""" I point you to in-depth articles on this terror murder in linked in the article. I remind editors raising that WP is and , and that is not a policy based argument. An event with this breadth and depth of coverage does not have to demonstrate ongoing impact to be WP notable. Under an event has to meet , which this event objectively does. Nevertheless, this shooting has had demonstrable impact (in article since the creation) on the Israeli conversation about whether to agree to a prisoner exchange that Hamas is requesting this summer (for the bodies of soldiers, or for the return of a mentally ill Israelis who crossed the border into Gaza). It is argued that since this was one of 6 recent terror murders carried out by convicted terrorists released in the Gilad Shalit prisoner exchange, a fresh exchange endangers the lives of Israelis and is, therefore, bad policy. Independent of that, it is making waves in diplomatic relations between Turkey and Israel (because Saleh al-Arouri) and between Israel and Jordan (because the operative directly in charge of this Hamas terror cell resides in Jordan""" Deletion of 2015 Shuvat Rachel shooting WP:GNG||WP:GNG||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:NOTCENSORED||WP:BATTLEGROUND||WP:JUSTDONTLIKEIT||WP:EVENTCRIT||WP:INDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
18617 13281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Constitarian Party User:Bobanny 18:50, 23 March 2007 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of The Constitarian Party WP:NFT||WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
18618 12247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paymentwall User:Northamerica1000 21:33, 1 August 2017 (UTC) keep Meets per a source review Deletion of Paymentwall WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
18619 10960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark McNulty (footballer) (3rd nomination) User:Sir 20:42, 20 February 2015 (UTC) delete He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Mark McNulty (footballer) (3rd nomination) WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18620 8280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Show Cats: The Standard of Perfection User:Armbrust 10:41, 30 September 2010 (UTC) keep Agree with MichaelQSchmidt, it is now a decent Start-class article with |reliable sources Deletion of Show Cats: The Standard of Perfection WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18621 3327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter Dorn User:Lesnail 16:04, 11 December 2007 (UTC) delete fails and is copyright violation Deletion of Walter Dorn WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18622 18601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bluetab Solutions Holding User:Coredesat 04:10, 14 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Bluetab Solutions Holding WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
18623 3059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MiJournal User:Trevj 01:48, 13 November 2013 (UTC) delete per . I found links to downloads and |BLOGS but no |reliable sources except the one already contained within the article. Perhaps it's |TOOSOON, in which case perhaps this could be considered a |SOFTDELETE for de-PRODing again in the future if/when notability is clearly established Deletion of MiJournal WP:NSOFT||WP:BLOGS||WP:TOOSOON||WP:SOFTDELETE||WP:reliable sources Wikipedia:Notability 77
18624 15213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anatoly Moskvin User:Ad 22:37, 13 November 2014 (UTC) delete I could not find anything that rings the notability bell in a Google. With respect to his morbid hobby that would seem to fall under Deletion of Anatoly Moskvin WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18625 12533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alien and Predator timeline (2nd nomination) User:Deor 12:41, 8 June 2008 (UTC) delete as |original research. That the synthesis may have been made http://time.absoluteavp.com/index.html off-wiki is irrelevant unless the source making it can be shown to meet , which I don't think this one can Deletion of Alien and Predator timeline (2nd nomination) WP:OR||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
18626 7756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackie Chiles Law Society Banquet [[User_talk:Bradv15|BradV]] 17:22, 1 April 2008 (UTC) delete Possible |hoax. Jackie Chiles is a character on Seinfeld. This article is based on someone's http://www.jackiechiles.org/ blog Deletion of Jackie Chiles Law Society Banquet WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
18627 10035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/State Patty's Day (3rd nomination) User:Lukeno94 18:29, 20 February 2013 (UTC) comment Speedy keep is inappropriate here, this isn't a nom, please for starters. I don't have an opinion on this, but I'm not 100% sure is met - I don't see much out-of-state coverage from , although there is a reasonable amount of state-wide coverage Deletion of State Patty's Day (3rd nomination) WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:AGF||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18628 1579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of email marketing service providers User:Bearian 18:01, 10 December 2009 (UTC) delete while there may be many such providers, and many of them may be notable, an encyclopedia |should not be a marketing guide Deletion of Comparison of email marketing service providers WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18629 10202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Z Corp. User:PCock 21:10, 30 October 2008 (UTC) delete Does not appear to meet criteria in Deletion of Z Corp. WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18630 6231 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sony Ericsson V800 User:Edison 03:44, 16 December 2007 (UTC) delete About the only thing with inline references is that it is a clamshell in form. The article is full of apparent original research about its shortcomings and nature. The references do not satisfy . Wikipedia is not a celphone catalog or a celphone blog Deletion of Sony Ericsson V800 WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18631 21101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bresketball User:Ravenswing 16:13, 28 September 2011 (UTC) delete Aside from the other failed criteria cited above, this butts heads with Deletion of Bresketball WP:BULLSHIT Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
18632 16897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abhay Vidhya Mandir Senior Secondary School, Hindaun City User:TransporterMan 14:29, 30 March 2015 (UTC) delete """both speedily and regularly '''and/or merge''' into Hindaun. If there are multiple ''reliable'' sources for anything other than this school's mere existence, I cannot find them. Mere passing mentions in directories or news articles is not sufficient to keep this. The administrator or closer who adjudges this discussion must ''weigh'' the arguments to keep this particular article, not just act on what ''usually'' happens here and those arguments must be enough ''in quality'' to either satisfy the ''guideline'' or to set it aside as a local exception under |IAR. Arguments from """"precedent"""" or prior consensuses here at AfD in prior cases are meaningless whereas , as a guideline, is the ''""""established consensus""""'' of the community per . Regards""" Deletion of Abhay Vidhya Mandir Senior Secondary School, Hindaun City WP:NHSCHOOL||WP:IAR||WP:NHSCHOOL||WP:CONLIMITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
18633 4628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaleb Eulls User:Jujutacular 22:43, 3 September 2009 (UTC) delete Subject has not yet received notability in football per , and per nomination, subject is not notable for one news event either Deletion of Kaleb Eulls WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18634 1221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sathiala User:Oakshade 03:22, 5 January 2008 (UTC) keep Towns/villages are inherently notable regardless of size. Passes Deletion of Sathiala WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18635 20556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Legacy Movement User:First 21:56, 6 May 2012 (UTC) delete A search in |Reliable Sources found absolutely nothing, so this fails to meet Wikipedia's |General Notability Guideline Deletion of The Legacy Movement WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18636 4354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francesca Hogi (2nd nomination) User:Jclemens 22:20, 19 April 2013 (UTC) merge """and merge if anything worthwhile is appropriately sourced. The """"delete"""" !votes above run afoul of because they fail to detail ''why'' her article should be deleted when a reasonable and appropriate merge target exists""" Deletion of Francesca Hogi (2nd nomination) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18637 1724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of international goals scored by Islam Slimani User:Spiderone 15:37, 15 February 2016 (UTC) delete for failure to meet Deletion of List of international goals scored by Islam Slimani WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18638 8299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Keller court martial User:Anthony 22:38, 8 January 2007 (UTC) delete Yes, clearly applies to this article Deletion of Adam Keller court martial WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18639 2239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernoulli stochastics User:Ammarpad 02:26, 25 November 2017 (UTC) delete blatant and promotion of primary source. I am in support of deleting all these wp:OR|OR articles by this user because they are all similar Deletion of Bernoulli stochastics WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18640 7157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Schechter User:Eric 17:59, 1 January 2009 (UTC) keep While I do not disagree with the points made by Nsk92, I think he possibly meets criterion #4 (significant impact in the area of higher education, affecting a substantial number of academic institutions). Take a look at http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Eric+Schechter%22+syllabus this search, which suggests that his impact as an educator makes him notable (even after discounting false positives - e.g., his own comments on discussion boards etc Deletion of Eric Schechter WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18641 12536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skyway Enterprises flight SKZ 7101 User:Wikimandia 15:53, 9 May 2015 (UTC) keep per Shelbystripes. This meets Deletion of Skyway Enterprises flight SKZ 7101 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18642 19133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tad Hill User:Rpclod 01:34, 6 May 2015 (UTC) delete press releases do not qualify as | reliable sources Deletion of Tad Hill WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18643 10203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lego Marvel Super Heroes: Avengers Reassembled User:Some 00:10, 24 December 2020 (UTC) merge to List of films based on Marvel Comics publications as the article fails Deletion of Lego Marvel Super Heroes: Avengers Reassembled WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18644 1659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fallout: The Health Impact of 9/11 (2nd nomination) User:Wadester16 07:25, 11 February 2009 (UTC) delete I agree with the past consensus and have little faith in the easy Google hits. and need more than what is offered Deletion of Fallout: The Health Impact of 9/11 (2nd nomination) WP:NF||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
18645 18926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kobi Arad (2nd nomination) User:Absconded 07:40, 29 May 2020 (UTC) delete """per . At first glance this looks like a well-sourced, if rather poorly written, article but closer inspection reveals most sources to be nothing more than personal blogs, which certainly fail . The only two that look more serious are the Independent Music Awards and Global Music Awards links, but those appear to be awards-for-cash: the latter currently has a COVID statement including """"We will fully refund all payments for unjudged entries. We are not accepting medallion orders. We will ship all medallion orders currently in hand."""" I'd say that means the article currently has no reliable sources. I'm not able to find anything more substantial so deletion is the way to go""" Deletion of Kobi Arad (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18646 18560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liz Meyer User:Mcmatter 16:43, 11 September 2010 (UTC) delete This article does not meet usic Deletion of Liz Meyer WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
18647 17898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Paull (actor) User:Magnolia677 19:31, 14 August 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Andrew Paull (actor) WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18648 14133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammad Sheeraz User:Saqib 11:59, 26 January 2018 (UTC) keep """The subject is a current member of a provincial legislature and thus pass speciality notability guideline . What made you say """"Article does not cite reliable sources."""" Its amusing that the websites of KP Assembly and the Express Tribune does not deem reliable to you. Government websites are primary but are not prohibited and can be safely used for verification purpose""" Deletion of Muhammad Sheeraz WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
18649 4461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raul Cătinaș (2nd nomination) [[User:.karellian-24|.karellian-24]] ([[User talk:.karellian-24|talk]]) 16:37, 27 August 2020 (UTC) keep """2 reasons. At that point we had no rankings, and he would pass being top 10 heavyweight. He was qualified for the Final 16 of heavyweight, it is called the Seoul Final 16 final and is part of the finals event (Seoul and Tokyo). TWICE was qualified then we can presume he could have been top 10 at some point. SECONDLY, actually he meets , Thom Harinck described him as """"perhaps the hardest white hitter in heavyweight history"""".{{cite web|url=https://www.sport.ro/k1/antrenorul-lui-badr-hari-socat-de-un-roman-in-45-de-ani-nu-am-vazut-un-alb-sa-dea-cu-pumnul-atat-de-tare.html|title=Antrenorul lui Badr Hari, SOCAT de un roman: """"In 45 de ani nu am vazut un alb sa dea cu pumnul atat de tare!"""" VIDEO cu ultimul KO |publisher=Pro X|date=13 July 2012|language=Romanian}} In several articles. So he is good for the kickboxing. Good enough to have a page. Not just a gesture of goodwill, but he also meets """ Deletion of Raul Cătinaș (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18650 18546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Serbian war crimes User:Location 22:01, 21 October 2010 (UTC) keep The subject obviously meets the criteria set forth at and there is a precedent for this type of subject at :Category:War crimes committed by country. The talk page does not show any strong effort to resolve POV concerns, so I'm left with the impression that any problems in the article are fixable Deletion of Serbian war crimes WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18651 16155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gail Brewer-Giorgio User:Uzma 07:57, 26 December 2010 (UTC) keep She's nutty. Got mixed in with Elvis's death. Everyone wants to write about her (e.g., who is this nut?). That means plenty of reliable source material for a biography on her. Thus, meets and keep. Here's another reference (This one has her name in the article title): {{cite news |title= Elvis Lives, Author Brewer-Giorgio Says, and Here's Proof|page=6C|department=Daybreak|author= Larry McShane|newspaper=The Wichita Eagle |date= October 23, 1990|accessdate=26 December 2010|url= http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=WE&p_theme=we&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&s_dispstring=ELVIS%20LIVES,%20AUTHOR%20BREWER-GIORGIO%20SAYS,%20AND%20HERE'S%20PROOF%20AND%20date(all)&p_field_advanced-0=&p_text_advanced-0=(ELVIS%20LIVES,%20AUTHOR%20BREWER-GIORGIO%20SAYS,%20AND%20HERE'S%20PROOF)&xcal_numdocs=20&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&xcal_useweights=no Deletion of Gail Brewer-Giorgio WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18652 4629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional doppelgängers User:Reyk 21:55, 2 February 2010 (UTC) delete Terrible, just terrible. Seems to consist of nothing but |synthesis and |original research Deletion of List of fictional doppelgängers WP:SYNTH||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18653 12743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iskin User:Wtfunkymonkey 05:48, 27 December 2006 (UTC) delete nn-company fails , does not sources, and the product itself is not notable either. It's only saving grace is that it won an award which distinguishes one of it's products from the thousands of other non notable ipod accessories. Article has been tagged with template Deletion of Iskin WP:CORP||WP:CITE||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
18654 12634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackie Barnes User:A1octopus 16:25, 4 March 2007 (UTC) delete Very much borderline on the usic criteria. I say delete however on the basis of wikipedia not being any the poorer were this article not there. Perhaps a re-direct to Jimmy Barnes and a couple of lines about his son on that page would be preferable Deletion of Jackie Barnes WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
18655 16928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rusty Ryan User:Magioladitis 20:00, 10 May 2008 (UTC) delete and create redirects. Articles consist only of |plot summaries of the remakes. The films are notable but that doesn't imply that each individual character is as well. It is exactly like episodes an Tv series. The notability of the Tv series is not transferes to each episode Deletion of Rusty Ryan WP:PLOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18656 19626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of legislators who support SOPA or PIPA User:BnBH 01:16, 20 January 2012 (UTC) delete """Per . Inappropriate and POV list with the likely effect of applying political pressure to those with the """"wrong"""" position. This is supposed to be an encyclopedia, not a political action committee which implicitly says """"WRITE YOUR CONGRESSMAN!"""". It fails |verifiability, since most of the entries lack any source at all, much less a reliable one. Further, the support or opposition is subject to change, as shown by numerous entries saying """"no longer supports""" Deletion of List of legislators who support SOPA or PIPA WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:V Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18657 3389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akiko Hatsu [[User talk:208.245.87.2|talk]]) 12:14, 18 September 2008 (UTC) comment I wasn't aware we had a , but even so I'm ambivalent on this one. I just find it odd that if this artist does indeed have 30+ works under their belt, why do we (and ANN) only have two listed? If I saw just, say, 3-4 more I'd say '''keep'''. Special:Contributions/208.245.87.2|208.245.87.2 Deletion of Akiko Hatsu WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:There is no deadline 35
18658 1505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oliver Curry (2nd nomination) User:Xxanthippe 00:15, 29 September 2011 (UTC) delete With GS cites all under 10 fails rof#C1 by a large margin Deletion of Oliver Curry (2nd nomination) WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
18659 21434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Amor Torres User:MichaelQSchmidt 12:31, 19 August 2015 (UTC) keep or, at the minimum '''merge''' and expand at a section in the article of the organization she founded. Sources do not have to be solely about this woman, just so long as they provide more-than-trivial coverage. is met through http://newsfirst.lk/english/2015/03/princess-maria-amor-says-human-rights-still-key-concern-international-community/82174 ''Newsfirst'' (1), http://nation.lk/edition/fine/people-and-events/item/39230-the-comeback-of-princess-maria-amor-in-sri-lanka.html ''The Nation'', http://www.news.lk/news/business/item/6597-princess-maria-calls-on-state-minister-for-child-development ''News Sri Lanka'', http://vancouver.24hrs.ca/ur/story/985614 ''24 Hours''(1), http://www.thestar.com.my/Metro/Focus/2015/02/06/For-humanitys-sake-Former-beauty-queen-visits-Malaysia-in-search-of-humanitarians-to-feature-in-her/ ''The Star'', http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/companies/award-for-srei-foundation-chairman/article7553844.ece ''The Hindu'', http://www.theborneopost.com/2015/01/29/we-care-for-humanity-to-set-up-new-chapter-in-malaysia/ ''Bornoe Post'', http://thehollywoodtimes.net/2014/08/12/princess-amor-is-crowned-as-the-traveling-princess/ ''The Hollywood Times'', http://newsfirst.lk/english/2015/03/princess-maria-amor-says-human-rights-still-key-concern-international-community/82174 ''Newsfirst'' (2), http://www.ft.lk/article/395075/Princess-Maria-Amor-visits ''Daily FT'', http://ellennation.com/11330/princess-maria-amor-expresses-her-support-to-morocco ''Elle Nation'', and others. Enough sources have taken note of this individual, that it is sensible that we do too, and the article can grow and expand over time and through regular editing. Deletion does not serve the project Deletion of Maria Amor Torres WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18660 522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Auburn Avenue (publication) User:juliarulia NONE keep """I believe the articles referenced do suggest notability (to whatever subjective degree) and the stub should not be deleted. Stubs have room to grow and expand. Furthermore, I've come across dozens of stubs that don't have any references cited and they have not been recommended for deletion. To keep citing when only selected articles are being held to that standard is unfair. There's no required quantifiable amount of sources or coverage that constitutes """"significant coverage."""" To nit pit whether two cited independent sources actually mention the publication, when the sources are clearly recognizing and featuring its exclusive content, is also unfair. I still contend that there are no concrete identifiable grounds on which this stub should be deleted""" Deletion of Auburn Avenue (publication) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18661 19427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of artists with a title track User:Superastig 06:18, 7 July 2020 (UTC) delete Per and Deletion of List of artists with a title track WP:TRIVIA||WP:OR Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
18662 5263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Upcoming nintendo products User:Firebug 21:44, 3 December 2005 (UTC) delete possible copyvio, advertising, a crystal ball Deletion of Upcoming nintendo products WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18663 9346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deda (ethnic slur) User:Kmzayeem 11:26, 3 March 2015 (UTC) delete per . Only passing mentions I could see Deletion of Deda (ethnic slur) WP:NOTDICT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18664 6411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zip Codes 01000 - 01499 User:Suonii180 14:03, 29 April 2021 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of Zip Codes 01000 - 01499 WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18665 6978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/6523 Clube User:Praemonitus 18:37, 10 May 2015 (UTC) merge per : Insufficient sources found Deletion of 6523 Clube WP:DWMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18666 8785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of association football players diagnosed with COVID-19 User:Govvy 12:25, 23 March 2020 (UTC) delete Not only is this article a breach of , this article is also a breach of law in several countries, publishing lists of medical prognosis without consent can allow action be taken against wikipedia, seriously, these lists and anything else like this should be exterminated by admins ASAP Deletion of List of association football players diagnosed with COVID-19 WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18667 13931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Harmer User:Bearcat 14:22, 29 November 2016 (UTC) delete There's no strong claim of notability for anything more than being a non-winning candidate for political office, and no strong sourcing to pass : of the nine sources here, five are primary sources such as his own website, raw tables of election results and a Google Books copy of a book he wrote, while the four that are reliable sources are local coverage of the election campaign itself. This is not the kind of sourcing it takes to get a non-winning candidate for political office into Wikipedia Deletion of David Harmer WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18668 14958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aasimar User:Rorshacma 16:34, 24 January 2020 (UTC) delete Minor fictional race, no non-trivial coverage in reliable, secondary sources, fails the , etc. is not some sort of catch-all argument that means that content cannot be deleted. It describes steps to take to actually fix the issues that may result in an article or content being deleted. In cases like this, where the subject matter fails the and reliable, secondary sources are non-existent, those issues are ''not'' going to be fixed by merging the problematic content into another article, and so is not a valid argument for doing so Deletion of Aasimar WP:GNG||WP:PRESERVE||WP:GNG||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18669 162 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Mustafa Kemal Anadolu Lisesi Kullanıcı:cobijacobija 11:17, 13 Eylül 2016 (UTC) keep Neye göre KD değil, neye göre silinsin? |Madde içeriğinde sınavlarda derece, yarışmalarda birincilik kazandığı yazıyor Mustafa Kemal Anadolu Lisesinin silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
18670 13947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Credorax User:HighKing 17:15, 3 October 2017 (UTC) delete No indications of notability, fails GNG and , references fail the criteria for establishing notability, and/or Deletion of Credorax WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
18671 8549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reestablishmentariansim User:DARTH 14:31, 28 September 2010 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Reestablishmentariansim WP:DICTIONARY Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18672 14209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Kings of Appletown User:MichaelQSchmidt 20:28, 27 December 2008 (UTC) keep WP:CRYSTAL|Crystal does not apply as filming has begun and it seems to be getting http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tab=wn&q=%22The+Kings+of+Appletown%22 enough coverage in |reliable sources to satisfy |notability for future films. Article should be nurtured, not deleted Deletion of The Kings of Appletown WP:RS||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18673 10863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comedy hip hop User:JavaTenor 18:08, 20 October 2007 (UTC) delete It's my opinion that a reasonable article could be written about this subject, but this mess of |original research isn't it, and it might be better to just start over. No prejudice against recreation of this article with different contents, and improvements to the existing one could convince me to change my !vote Deletion of Comedy hip hop WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18674 8573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ballard Nuggets User:Ww2censor 18:44, 22 February 2009 (UTC) delete per nom - non-notable fantasy team with not one should go Deletion of Ballard Nuggets WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18675 19364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Powerboot PCs User:Imminent77 19:57, 13 April 2017 (UTC) delete My source searching for coverage did not find sufficient secondary source coverage and therefore fails Deletion of Powerboot PCs WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18676 620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti-Zionist proposals for alternative Jewish homelands User:IZAK 08:01, 6 February 2014 (UTC) merge to Proposals for a Jewish state by removing all duplicate and non-NPOV material and retaining whatever is worthwhile in this clear violation of Deletion of Anti-Zionist proposals for alternative Jewish homelands WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
18677 1670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mahnoor Baloch User:Master 11:52, 8 December 2011 (UTC) delete mdash; There is some credibility to the article's assertions of notability, being that she ''is'' in fact a moderately well known model and actress in Pakistan. A http://www.google.ca/search?sourceid=navclient&aq=hts&oq=&ie=UTF-8&rlz=1T4RNWN_enCA217CA221&q=Mahnoor+Baloch Google search yields several relevant results, and she has a starring role in a Pakistani television series that has Chaandni Raatain|its own article on Wikipedia, but even that one Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chaandni Raatain|barely survived AfD back in 2008. This is a borderline case, and I prefer to err on the side of caution when it comes to barely notable |living people Deletion of Mahnoor Baloch WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18678 14726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thefederalist.com User:Bonewah 14:11, 29 September 2014 (UTC) keep """Pretty easily passes """"The content itself has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself."""" Just from the Neil deGrasse Tyson stuff, not to mention a lot of the sources provided here. The case for inclusion would be way easier if the article were unlocked so we could improve it based on what has been brought up here. Also, the timing of this AfD is horrible""" Deletion of Thefederalist.com WP:WEBCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18679 17811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Fistful of Nothing User:Ceradon 04:00, 24 February 2015 (UTC) delete notability not asserted in the context of or Deletion of A Fistful of Nothing WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
18680 19397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LimeLife (2nd nomination) User:FreeRangeFrog 20:37, 17 November 2012 (UTC) keep """Unfortunately there's no criteria for """"website that generated hype at one point and has since become irrelevant"""". The given references certainly meet """ Deletion of LimeLife (2nd nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18681 8024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/You Better Believe It User:Auger 08:08, 17 June 2006 (UTC) delete Pure vanity articlle. Fails to meet sufficient guidelines for as well Deletion of You Better Believe It WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18682 9761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LinkNZ User:Bejnar 05:39, 3 October 2015 (UTC) delete for lack of coverage. From a notability standpoint it is really rather irrelevant what is on their own webpages, unless it points to indepdent reliable sources with substantial content. Fails Deletion of LinkNZ WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18683 146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arifs (gang) User:C 03:03, 26 January 2008 (UTC) delete The passing mention in a single article does not meet the requirement of |notability Deletion of Arifs (gang) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18684 8117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cricket 09 (video game) User:MacGyverMagic 11:37, 3 February 2009 (UTC) delete per . Not enough information available to support an article. Too speculative to even mention in the article on the predecessors Deletion of Cricket 09 (video game) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18685 9190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cast members in Casino Royale (1967) User:XDanielx 06:25, 4 September 2007 (UTC) keep Normally such a list would be inappropriate, but Casino Royale is a very high-profile movie known for having many high-profile actors. Appropriate fork per Deletion of List of cast members in Casino Royale (1967) WP:SS Wikipedia:Summary style 34
18686 9277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DNA Model Management User:SamHolt6 22:25, 4 October 2018 (UTC) delete fails and ; a search for source turns up only trivial mentions or mentions in passing, I.E nothing in depth that is actually concerned with the company. The nom is absolutely correct to point out , as in the case DNA Model Management does not inherit notability from notable people it has worked with in the past Deletion of DNA Model Management WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
18687 302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wake Self User:Smile 17:27, 4 March 2015 (UTC) keep """meets |GNG, article creator. The articles by Local iQ, ABQ-Live, and Santa Fe Reporter are not trivial, and they are independent. Some of them are interviews, which are primary in nature, but they do not amount to original research or self-published sourcing, meaning they are acceptable in |BLP. Performing nationally with a well-known hip-hop group, being recognized by a notable member of that group, and performing internationally all indicate some level of importance. From Santa Fe Reporter,""""he might be one of the few New Mexican rappers to have toured Europe"""". From Fuse Weekly, """"integral part of Albuquerque’s hip-hop scene for the better part of a decade""" Deletion of Wake Self WP:GNG||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18688 21364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Astropy User:Fountains 15:23, 5 November 2013 (UTC) comment """The number of accounts that popped back to life (or were created the day of the AFD) to vote in this AFD shows a sockpuppetry/meatpuppetry campaign going on. I just https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Astrofrog notified another """"suddenly alive"""" account for spamming Astropy (fixed for format and Astropy left pending AFD). Re: astropy-related listserv, that's still |Meatpuppetry. As to AFD, no comment at this time""" Deletion of Astropy WP:MEAT Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
18689 21118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael McDonald (fighter) User:Papaursa 17:16, 11 July 2010 (UTC) delete Article has no independent sources and subject fails and . The article describes him as fighting in local promotions. Non-notable at this time Deletion of Michael McDonald (fighter) WP:GNG||WP:MMANOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18690 13570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Defective Epitaph User:SorryGuy 02:04, 14 November 2007 (UTC) keep Look at , it is my feeling that these albums do qualify as notable. While I would not be totally opposed to a merge of them to the band's article, because there are six of them I think it is best to keep them as separate articles Deletion of Defective Epitaph WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18691 14010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billy Alaimo User:Kris 01:14, 5 May 2007 (UTC) delete He only wrestled for a few years, and did absolutely nothing notable during that time. He has made a few very small appearances on a few shows, nothing major. He most definetly fails Deletion of Billy Alaimo WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18692 1386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michigan digitization project User:Dhartung 03:37, 20 August 2007 (UTC) delete I #DIR|don't believe we are a directory of all digitization projects undertaken by library and records agencies, as that would be quite extensive Deletion of Michigan digitization project WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18693 8964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicholas Claxton User:Chrisw80 06:12, 29 March 2016 (UTC) delete There just isn't enough solid coverage about '''him''' to meet , or any of the other notability criteria. Article would also likely need serious rewriting in order to not qualify for CSD G11, IMHO. This article also suffers from far too much for my tastes on top of the aspects Deletion of Nicholas Claxton WP:GNG||WP:OR||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18694 7797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taruni Sachdev User:Vejvančický 08:02, 15 May 2012 (UTC) keep per the evidence posted by User:Karthikndr. I don't think applies here. She was noted by Indian media as a child actor long before the tragic event happened Deletion of Taruni Sachdev WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18695 17460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Biblical Prophecy Fulfilled User:Cyrus 13:19, 1 May 2007 (UTC) delete This is definitely a textbook example of |POV pushing and |original research. The entire article is open to interpretation, which is clearly what the editor has done. He has taken passages from the Bible that supposedly foreshadow present day events and shown, in his opinion, how those prophecies have been fulfilled. How can any of the information in this article be |atrributed to any reliable secondary sources? It can't. I wholeheartedly disagree with everything in the article and believe it should be deleted and protected so that it will never be recreated Deletion of Biblical Prophecy Fulfilled WP:NPOV||WP:OR||WP:ATTRIBUTION Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18696 21544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Vasiliev User:Splash 20:39, 15 October 2005 (UTC) delete Merely finding some Google hits isn't meaningful unless you check that the Google hits actually apply to the topic of the article, which they largely do not in this case: the first hit is this article. On the other hand, the absence of Google success that Capitalistroadster finds renders the article with serious |verifiability problems. The article is also largely written in the absurd which makes taking its topic seriously the more difficult Deletion of Michael Vasiliev WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18697 18533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Tiju Abraham User:timtempleton 23:29, 20 January 2018 (UTC) delete insufficient media coverqe to demonstrate notability - fails Deletion of Philip Tiju Abraham WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18698 14703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chimurito User:MER 08:14, 24 December 2006 (UTC) delete completely nn, fails with http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=Chimurito+-wikipedia&btnG=Search 21 non-wiki ghits, crufty Deletion of Chimurito WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18699 17919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nosocomephobia User:Zetawoof 00:02, 29 November 2009 (UTC) delete """http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/ PubMed finds no mention of """"nosocomephobia"""" in the medical literature. Per our very own article List of phobias, """"a large number of -phobia lists circulate on the Internet, with words collected from indiscriminate sources, often copying each other"""". While the fear of hospitals is no doubt real for some people, the condition does not appear to be documented in any """ Deletion of Nosocomephobia WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18700 11147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orwell Bridge (Dublin) User:The 01:36, 16 February 2012 (UTC) merge to River Dodder, possibly creating River Dodder#Crossings. A list of crossings as part of the river article is fully appropriate; the bridge itself, however, is a |run-of-the-mill concrete bridge Deletion of Orwell Bridge (Dublin) WP:RUNOFTHEMILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
18701 1201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Ferry User:AuthorWiki99 10:48, 5 July 2019 (UTC) delete Not notable enough as per Deletion of Christopher Ferry WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18702 21513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cornelius Williams User:Qworty 08:02, 22 April 2011 (UTC) delete this utterly non-notable piece of self-hyping Deletion of Cornelius Williams WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
18703 11086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Champlain Centre North User:Edison 14:11, 29 August 2007 (UTC) delete I could not find a statement of the gross leasable are of the Champlain Centre North mall, but just adding up the retail space of the present anchors would equal at least a regional mall. Could not find articles with more than run of the mill coverage of routine events (Santa arrives, etc). Needs better sourcing to show satisfaction of or . The Souith mall should be separately listed Deletion of Champlain Centre North WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18704 9391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gar Oo Noon Ko User:No 08:51, 9 December 2016 (UTC) delete Unless sources exist in another language, does not seem to satisfy Deletion of Gar Oo Noon Ko WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18705 14677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/T-Bone (rapper) User:Hello 16:28, 22 November 2008 (UTC) keep One of his albums was nominated for a Grammy Award (I replaced the ref with a more reliable one)—meets criterion #8. Article needs a hearty re-write, though Deletion of T-Bone (rapper) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18706 21481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Recife FC 3 User:Papaursa 00:39, 14 December 2010 (UTC) delete This was an event run by a non-notable organization. The article lacks independent sources and articles on individual events fail when they're merely sports reports Deletion of Recife FC 3 WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18707 21283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Combatic User:Ravenswing 14:34, 13 March 2007 (UTC) delete NN, fails , and probably into the bargain. What in the heck is this, anyway Deletion of Combatic WP:ATT||WP:COI||WP:BULLSHIT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
18708 6233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael W. Dean User:Burpelson 02:15, 17 August 2010 (UTC) delete Fails WP:BIO and Deletion of Michael W. Dean WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
18709 15846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jenny Nicholson User:PearlSt82 14:36, 8 July 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Jenny Nicholson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18710 16197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Child's Play (2009 film) User:Redfarmer 09:55, 4 February 2008 (UTC) merge any relevant information to David Kirschner and '''delete''' as fails . Not in production yet Deletion of Child's Play (2009 film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18711 20202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shahram Jahansooz User:Bearian 18:32, 16 September 2019 (UTC) delete fails . Specifically, the subject has had no solo exhibits in art gallery capitals, except a single 8-day show in Tokyo Deletion of Shahram Jahansooz WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18712 7450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UTS Buddhist Meditation Society User:That NONE delete as |non-notable. &mdash Deletion of UTS Buddhist Meditation Society WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18713 16009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TBA (Third M.I.A album) User:TenPoundHammer 21:17, 22 October 2009 (UTC) delete per , way too soon, no sources, etc. Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Special:Contributions/TenPoundHammer|Many otters • :User talk:TenPoundHammer|One bat Deletion of TBA (Third M.I.A album) WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
18714 15370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel episodes User:Tarc 16:10, 25 November 2011 (UTC) delete This is the sort of /fancruft that needs to be avoided in an encyclopedia project, it it just |synthesis of fictional material rearranged in perceived chronological order. Note Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chronology of River Song, deleted for similar reasons Deletion of List of Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel episodes WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
18715 9783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Courtney Corey User:Jasynnash2 14:03, 8 October 2008 (UTC) delete """as an """"actor, singer, and dancer"""" she has not contributed significant works to meet the criteria in , nor has she met any of the criteria of or been covered sufficiently in reliable 3rd party sources to cover | the general notability criteria. Additionally, OT| Wikipedia is not for hosting CV's""" Deletion of Courtney Corey WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:MUSIC||WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18716 10257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swing Dance Hall of Fame User:Joseph2302 15:20, 18 May 2016 (UTC) delete All sources are |primary, and so fails Deletion of Swing Dance Hall of Fame WP:PRIMARY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:No original research 65
18717 935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Louise Lidströmer User:Demiurge 11:37, 25 November 2006 (UTC) delete as above and there also seems to be some involved from http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:RichMac&diff=90005668&oldid=90005196 this comment. The potential is there for verifiability/notability so I'll change my vote to keep if the required two non-trivial external sources can be found Deletion of Louise Lidströmer WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
18718 12172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flush (Head song) User:Masterpiece2000 02:45, 20 June 2008 (UTC) delete Fails #SONGS Deletion of Flush (Head song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18719 1175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lust on the Prairie User:Anonymous 16:18, 27 June 2021 (UTC) delete """fails . I found two reviews http://pvvonline.com/pvv/pvvreview-–-examples-of-romance-porn-3-wicked-pictures-heart-strings-2011/#.YNiggy94W-o http://www.adultdvdtalk.com/reviews/read_review.dlt/sku=25079/heart-strings-%28wicked%29.htm but those do not seem like """"… nationally known critics"""" as NFILM requires""" Deletion of Lust on the Prairie WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
18720 19357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/András Gregorik User:Toon05 21:59, 14 September 2008 (UTC) delete """as failing , which requires ''The person has received a notable award or honor, or has been often nominated for them or the person has made a widely recognized contribution that is part of the enduring historical record in his or her specific field.'' - there is no evidence of this within the article, and the tag of """"unknown"""" suggests that he has not made a widely recognized contribution""" Deletion of András Gregorik WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18721 15982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Griswold (Singer-Songwriter) User:Gongshow 23:26, 9 December 2009 (UTC) delete I'm not finding in-depth coverage for this singer-songwriter; does not appear to satisfy Deletion of Matthew Griswold (Singer-Songwriter) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18722 21491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Wilkinson (U.S. politician) User:Bearian 16:31, 11 December 2009 (UTC) keep He's held several positions of influence in the US government, thus is |notable. The stub needs semi-protection and a clean-up, but he's forfeited ''total'' privacy Deletion of Jim Wilkinson (U.S. politician) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18723 10425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph R. Carvalko User:David 20:29, 27 October 2012 (UTC) delete There's too much here for an A7 speedy deletion, but nothing in the article rises to any real significance, and there isn't any evidence of passing or Deletion of Joseph R. Carvalko WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18724 305 [[Wolfgang Nieburg]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:S.Didam 10:19, 19. Sep. 2009 (CEST) delete Ich kann ebenfalls absolut keine |Relevanz feststellen Löschung von Wolfgang Nieburg Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
18725 2348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reactive mind User:Riffic 15:23, 19 June 2009 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not for things made up one day Deletion of Reactive mind WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
18726 12940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leak Proof Mission (2018 short film) User:Kirbanzo 17:49, 28 September 2018 (UTC) delete per nom - and definitely not met. No notable Ghits Deletion of Leak Proof Mission (2018 short film) WP:GNG||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
18727 21327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kanpur over-bridge User:Nsk92 17:21, 8 July 2010 (UTC) delete pure essay, plus no verifiable evidence of notability provided. Even a plain vanilla google searchhttp://www.google.com/search?hl=en&safe=off&q=%22Kanpur+over-bridge%22+&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai= returns only the hits to Wikipedia and nothing else. So fails, as well Deletion of Kanpur over-bridge WP:OR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
18728 2493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Superluminal graviton User:Cosmic 09:54, 11 July 2008 (UTC) delete """per . We already have a Superluminal article. As an aside, the ''seven'' Google hits (apart from the WP article, and including at least one blog, which references Superluminal anyway!) for """"superluminal graviton"""" do not exactly look promising""" Deletion of Superluminal graviton WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18729 11552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Joseph Watson (second nomination) User:Ergot 17:28, 29 September 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails , , . Sometimes articles go through half a dozen AfDs before they get deleted Deletion of Paul Joseph Watson (second nomination) WP:BIO||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18730 18189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Veracity User:Eddie 05:51, 17 December 2005 (UTC) delete for failure to meet Deletion of Veracity WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18731 9959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toontown User:power 03:40, 11 July 2018 (UTC) comment """the question in my mind is: is the area from Who Framed Roger Rabbit notable enough for a stand-alone article separate from the movie? As there are no references, I don't feel that is necessary. The other content here is best handled as part of the DAB page (which can be moved to this location); the content is something of . I don't feel like having this article as a pseudo-DAB of """"any place where cartoon characters live"""" is of any value above the existing DAB page at all""" Deletion of Toontown WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
18732 5417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Live from London (iTunes) User:Esradekan 21:22, 1 April 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Albums. No significant coverage in |reliable, third-party, sources. A passing mention on each of the artists parent article is all that is required, if that. No notability for a stand alone article Deletion of Live from London (iTunes) WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18733 16983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bose headphones User:Jayvdb 05:07, 10 January 2007 (UTC) keep """add maintenance tags and improve. As far as I can see, this is an abuse of Afd, as an article for this topic is clearly warranted, and the current article goes a long way to filling that need. The previous outcome stated """"Those issues can and should be addressed by editing."""" I'm not a fan of direct links to BestBuy, and I'm sure I can find other faults, but those can be fixed by editing. Stop whining that certain people haven't done this within the time-frames you expect: be |bold and help""" Deletion of Bose headphones WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
18734 8568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fung Shoe User:Peridon 10:59, 12 July 2011 (UTC) delete My compliments to the author. This has inspired me to invent 'Flung Shoe', where the arrangement of one's environment and life is determined by the path and resting place (and collateral damage) of a randomly hurled trainer. Neither are encyclopaedic, however, being Original Research Deletion of Fung Shoe WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18735 8331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myungbaksanseong User:Gtstricky 19:25, 23 June 2008 (UTC) delete per . Word has only been around less then one month Deletion of Myungbaksanseong WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18736 5555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dre McFly User:Cocytus 05:13, 11 January 2010 (UTC) delete fails and is almost certainly a on some level Deletion of Dre McFly WP:MUSICBIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
18737 13362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 Herat shooting User:Faizan 14:21, 25 July 2014 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of 2014 Herat shooting WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18738 19419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St Albans Bach Choir User:Pleriche 16:26, 11 November 2018 (UTC) comment """By its nature, not many of the criteria in can be easily satisfied by a provincial amateur choir but that doesn't necessarily mean it doesn't deserve a Wikipedia page. There are a number of other amateur choirs with uncontested Wikipedia pages. In the last few days I've made a number of edits to try and improve the case for the choir's notability, in particular, subsections brought together under """"Concerts and other appearances"""" and a citation through JSTOR of a report of a first performance""" Deletion of St Albans Bach Choir WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
18739 20179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of professional sports owners considered the worst User:Justin 20:22, 1 May 2010 (UTC) delete """This is an obvious violation of and . Since it also relates to |living people and is solely intended to disparage its subjects, it certainly should qualify (per D. Eppstein) for G10 """"speedy delete""" Deletion of List of professional sports owners considered the worst WP:NPOV||WP:UNDUE||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18740 1547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anup Ghoshal User:MacGyverMagic 13:57, 10 December 2008 (UTC) keep Hi, Article was improved by creator by including good references after its nomination. The article was nominated because only single reference was pointing to http://www.anupghoshal.com offical website of Anup Ghoshal, which is not fair according to guidelines. as noted by Deletion of Anup Ghoshal WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18741 18593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Types of crude oil in Nigeria user:Radman1 06:50, 2 September 2005 (UTC) keep as per . &mdash Deletion of Types of crude oil in Nigeria WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18742 2846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seth Adkins User:Cwmhiraeth 11:57, 10 February 2017 (UTC) keep Meets having appeared in a number of films and television series including as a main character in the film Pirates of the Plain and the title role in When Andrew Came Home Deletion of Seth Adkins WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
18743 13366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna Phoebe User:Mystache 16:08, 3 July 2006 (UTC) keep Meets as a part of The Trans-Siberian Orchestra -- their album ''Christmas Eve and Other Stories'' has gone 2xPlatinum Deletion of Anna Phoebe WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18744 12245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salvatore Cusato User:IceCreamAntisocial 11:03, 18 December 2008 (UTC) delete there don't seem to be any |reliable secondary sources out there which would provide |verifiability and indicate notability Deletion of Salvatore Cusato WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18745 5050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nigger Hills User:Northamerica1000 06:17, 21 September 2011 (UTC) keep Passes . Move the data to article titled, Ernie Hills, as he was referred to Deletion of Nigger Hills WP:NRU Wikipedia:Notability 77
18746 10838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harry Shapiro (author) User:Spatulli 21:16, 9 September 2010 (UTC) delete doesn't pass Deletion of Harry Shapiro (author) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
18747 19247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Wreck: In the Pirkinning User:Kusma 00:48, 10 June 2006 (UTC) keep one of the examples for notable fan created content, also for meeting Deletion of Star Wreck: In the Pirkinning WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18748 7697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annihilation Earth User:Ad 17:01, 20 October 2020 (UTC) delete Couldn't find any significant coverage in /. Doesn't pass or Deletion of Annihilation Earth WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:GNG||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18749 1363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All Worlds Resorts User:Cunard 05:41, 22 October 2009 (UTC) delete per the lack of |reliable sources. The article is unreferenced and promotional. The content could be useful for a merge if there were sources, but I have been unable to find any. Having searched through Google News Archive and Google, I was not able to find reliable sources.Only useful, marginally-notable content that can be sourced should be merged. However, since there are no sources, merging this content to LGBT tourism would not improve that article but detract from its quality Deletion of All Worlds Resorts WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18750 2400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edmund Keli’i Silva Jr. (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 16:23, 30 September 2015 (UTC) delete per . Too long, I could not finish reading this |soapboxing essay Deletion of Edmund Keli’i Silva Jr. (2nd nomination) WP:TNT||WP:SOAP Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
18751 14971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Video games notable for negative reception (2nd nomination) User:Matt 12:48, 6 May 2008 (UTC) keep """and possible move to """"Video games ''noted'' for negative reception"""". But I understand the nominator's concerns. The bar has to be very clear for this kind of article. There should not be just verifiable sources blasting the games, but verifiable sources noting that ''other'' sources have blasted the game (some Worst Ever lists), or that the game was a prominent commercial failure (E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (Atari 2600)|E.T.), or that the game sparked outrage (Super Columbine Massacre RPG!|Columbine). Otherwise we just get """"Video games somebody sometime somewhere didn't like"""" loaded with all kinds of |original research""" Deletion of Video games notable for negative reception (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18752 1783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Mues User:Hawkeye7 07:11, 2 August 2019 (UTC) delete but no objection to redirecting to 2020 United States Senate election in Montana. How many times do we have to go through this? says a politician has to ''get elected'' before they qualify for an article Deletion of John Mues WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18753 1583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Garfi (cat) User:Nosebagbear 17:45, 19 July 2018 (UTC) delete fails to meet . There are a couple of later sources but they fail to either be reliable or fail Sig Cov. I'm also inclined a similar way towards DGG's case - as it is, it may well fail A7 Deletion of Garfi (cat) WP:CONTINUEDCOVERAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18754 19971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 Summer Olympics national flag bearers User:Ukexpat 22:37, 8 November 2010 (UTC) delete clear and obvious per Deletion of 2012 Summer Olympics national flag bearers WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18755 1906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William W. McCorkle Jr. User:Nuttah 08:56, 8 March 2009 (UTC) delete as no evidence from reliable sources of how the subject meets or is provided or apparently available Deletion of William W. McCorkle Jr. WP:PROF||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18756 14088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camilla Tyldum User:Geschichte 10:41, 29 September 2020 (UTC) delete """amateur sportsperson. The """"weight incident"""" was not extensively covered and would be, you guessed it, |undue weight""" Deletion of Camilla Tyldum WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18757 8651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AVN Award for All-Girl Performer of the Year User:Cullen328 06:53, 4 September 2016 (UTC) delete """Our core content policy |Verifiability requires that we """"base articles on reliable, third-party, published sources with a reputation for fact-checking and accuracy."""" A third-party source is """"one that is entirely independent of the subject being covered"""". This article about an Adult Video News pornography award has six references, all of which are published by the AVN. These sources do not meet the policy requirements for verifiability. I made a good faith search for reliable, independent sources covering this award and found nothing. Therefore, the article fails the |General notability guideline as well""" Deletion of AVN Award for All-Girl Performer of the Year WP:V||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18758 8731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barry Aycock User:Go4thProsper 16:36, 21 February 2021 (UTC) delete This page fails the oteworthy test. Posting a profile photo with a noteworthy person does not make one noteworthy himself. Nor does partnering on a small business venture or running unsuccessfully for political office Deletion of Barry Aycock WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18759 16236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelan Luker [[User talk:180.172.239.231|talk]]) 08:26, 31 July 2014 (UTC) comment While the depth of coverage is enough, the sources are too local. Not sure if the subject passes .--Special:Contributions/180.172.239.231|180.172.239.231 Deletion of Kelan Luker WP:SPORTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18760 12509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VistaDB User:Nonstopdrivel 18:55, 24 June 2007 (UTC) delete as blatant and shameless and advertising. The text is copied verbatim from the company's own website.http://www.vistadb.net/history.asp Listing prices in a Wiki article? Come on, people Deletion of VistaDB WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
18761 8410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Music Is the Weapon NONE NONE keep Enough high profile music reliable sources have dedicated entire articles around the album to meet the Deletion of Music Is the Weapon WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18762 13774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ogden Professor of Fundamental Physics User:Modest 19:49, 31 July 2013 (UTC) delete No evidence for notability beyond its current occupant (who is indeed notable). Of the two references in the article, one is a link to the university itself (so not independent) and the other is a dead link. applies to individuals, not the posts they hold. Simply no good arguments for keeping this Deletion of Ogden Professor of Fundamental Physics WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18763 10977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Non-natural death User:Teratix 01:59, 25 April 2019 (UTC) delete an excessive listing of unexplained statistics failing the third point at . The creator's constant argument and walls of text are not helpful in advancing their case Deletion of Non-natural death WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18764 9517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lists of people with specific surnames User:Clarityfiend 21:49, 6 May 2013 (UTC) delete The list would have to be over 40K entries long, just a tad Deletion of Lists of people with specific surnames WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18765 1631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GREENSOLE (2nd nomination) User:Kinu 18:30, 6 April 2020 (UTC) delete per the nominator's thorough rationale. While masquerading as an article, it is thinly-veiled advertising with nothing substantive to show is met Deletion of GREENSOLE (2nd nomination) WP:NCOMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
18766 17221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Puerto Rican Football Federation Preparatory Tournament User:Joseph2302 07:19, 13 August 2021 (UTC) delete fails , pre-season tournament don't tend to be notable (with a few specific exceptions Deletion of Puerto Rican Football Federation Preparatory Tournament WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18767 3334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harold Jensen Christopher user:Andrew 17:59, 24 January 2021 (UTC) keep """A warship was named after him which is a """"''significant award or honor''"""" and so passes """ Deletion of Harold Jensen Christopher WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18768 1950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aussieschoolmates User:SM247 01:03, 6 July 2006 (UTC) delete per above, fails Deletion of Aussieschoolmates WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18769 803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Shane Neal User:JoshuaZ 00:36, 21 February 2008 (UTC) keep The sockpuppeting is unfortunate because this is someone who would be kept anyways and I hope that the closing admin will keep a good track of the arguments from normal users. There are a variety of non-trivial sources about Michael Shane Neal including the the Artist's Magazine and Art News. That together with his work makes him pass Deletion of Michael Shane Neal WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18770 11512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scopical User:Lankiveil 04:55, 10 June 2007 (UTC) delete WP:CRYSTAL, , vapourware... take your pick Deletion of Scopical WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18771 2507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chaundon User:Victor 14:39, 13 April 2008 (UTC) delete per . Artist must have released ''two'' albuns through a major label to become notable Deletion of Chaundon WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18772 17560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lions Gold Awards User:Newshunter12 05:51, 30 July 2020 (UTC) delete Fails . I found no evidence of notability in a search I did Deletion of Lions Gold Awards WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18773 10308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bearsden Chess Club User:Cool 16:08, 19 May 2007 (UTC) delete No evidence that has been met Deletion of Bearsden Chess Club WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18774 6294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AUCS Linux User:Ahunt 01:33, 9 April 2015 (UTC) comment """Just a note here, """"keep votes"""" are not counted and will just result in a block for the sock-master""" Deletion of AUCS Linux WP:SOCKPUPPET Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
18775 17482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kilbrogan House user:Andrew 13:32, 8 July 2021 (UTC) keep """The https://www.buildingsofireland.ie/buildings-search/building/20844023/kilbrogan-house-kilbrogan-hill-coolfadda-bandon-cork NIAH source is excellent for our purpose. The place is also documented in other good sources such as ''https://www.google.co.uk/books/edition/Fodor_s_Western_Ireland/MrY1StosN5kC?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=Kilbrogan+House+bandon&pg=PT141&printsec=frontcover Fodor''. The place therefore passes and we're good. The nomination's complaint that we might have lots of similar articles is not a problem or reason to delete per policy , """"''there is no practical limit to the number of topics Wikipedia can cover""" Deletion of Kilbrogan House WP:GNG||WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:Notability 77
18776 9938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Texas Alliance for Life User:Carrite 15:17, 5 June 2012 (UTC) comment It goes without saying that there is an enormous IDONTLIKEIT and ILIKEIT potential for articles dealing with the hot topic abortion issue. I hope everyone here is able to put that aside. If you can't do that, don't say a word, just move along... As for the nominator — I am unclear, was followed? What leads you to believe that this is ''not'' a notable organization Deletion of Texas Alliance for Life WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
18777 2988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RepliGo User:Elonka 21:57, 22 September 2007 (UTC) delete no indication that it passes . Concerns were raised a year ago, and no expansion has taken place Deletion of RepliGo WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18778 1269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/G. Bull User:Stevie 09:08, 26 March 2021 (UTC) delete Fails which supersedes any presumed notability. |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information. Including *every* cricketer who played in two matches and did *nothing* else is not for Wikipedia. NCRIC is only a soft rule which presumes there will be other sources to establish a cricketer's notability over and above the standard statistical sites but not every one/two/three appearance wonder does generate significant coverage. Most of them don't Deletion of G. Bull WP:GNG||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18779 424 [[Akatsuki]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Hendrik J. NONE delete Gerne auch '''SOFORT'''. Der Artikel spottet Hohn. Völlig redundant zu Naruto und sollte auch da behandelt werden Löschung von Akatsuki Wikipedia:AüF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
18780 14552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cuts Plus Two User:LenyTee55 06:25, 5 April 2019 (UTC) delete Album of no significance. Does not meet Deletion of Cuts Plus Two WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
18781 300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AeronautX Luftfahrtschule User:D4iNa4 18:30, 10 January 2019 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails Deletion of AeronautX Luftfahrtschule WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18782 12680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gigi Ben Artzi User:StonyBrook 16:05, 4 December 2019 (UTC) delete per since even the best sources provided only mention the subject in passing. Does not seem to meet the requirements of since none of his films are blue-linked Deletion of Gigi Ben Artzi WP:SIGCOV||WP:DIRECTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
18783 20178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danny Walters (actor) User:Mcewan 02:07, 12 April 2013 (UTC) delete No available evidence of |notability, specifically |as an actor Deletion of Danny Walters (actor) WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
18784 21175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Israeli violations of Lebanese airspace User:Galatz 14:27, 27 November 2017 (UTC) merge There could be a section on Israel–Lebanon relations on both sides violations until such a time it is big enough for guidelines to apply Deletion of Israeli violations of Lebanese airspace WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Splitting 57
18785 4783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bani 'Udayd User:Sam 11:59, 31 October 2018 (UTC) delete Poorly sourced, mass-generated one-liner stubs, fails . No prejudice against recreation of properly sourced articles Deletion of Bani 'Udayd WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18786 6275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ISpy(2010 series) User:EEMIV 22:53, 28 December 2009 (UTC) delete unreferenced, -- frankly, not sure this isn't a hoax Deletion of ISpy(2010 series) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18787 16881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Afeez Olawale Oladipo (2nd nomination) User:Nnadigoodluck 18:29, 29 March 2020 (UTC) delete Non-notable article of a footballer who still fails and after the last AfD. Article should also be salted with no prejudice of recreation if subject becomes inherently notable in the future Deletion of Afeez Olawale Oladipo (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
18788 15344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of games with DirectX 9 support User:Ajf773 08:38, 20 June 2018 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of List of games with DirectX 9 support WP:NOTCATALOGUE||WP:NOTINDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18789 13582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Leaman User:Dolphin51 04:00, 15 August 2008 (UTC) delete This is a general biographical article that could be written about any career academic or PhD recipient. The article fails to identify adequate notability in accordance with or . A plethora of interesting biographical minutiae is not a substitute for identifying why the subject is truly notable for Wikipedia's purposes Deletion of David Leaman WP:BIO||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18790 1116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loose Logic (2nd nomination) [[User talk:08OceanBeach SD|08OceanBeachS.D.]] 22:40, 20 June 2011 (UTC) keep Mentioned in various local newspapers, though not cited. As of now fails criterion Deletion of Loose Logic (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18791 19415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Endal (dog) User:Richard 22:07, 4 May 2007 (UTC) keep Plenty of good sourced reference material from the BBC and the Guardian. Meets all criteria for io. If someone thinks its a Copyright Violation, then reword that section. Remember, you can't copyright facts. The outside press determines notability, not Wikipedians Deletion of Endal (dog) :WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
18792 6813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Austin Rigsbee User:Rtphokie 00:00, 25 May 2008 (UTC) delete lacks notability. FUTON bias is very important to consider but it's just a consideration, not a free pass for unsourced articles. Those sources still need to be produced at some point according to . If this DJ contributed to the industry the way and instructs, there would be some significant mention of her on the net somewhere. Many major newspapers have their full text archives available on Google News or their own websites going back to the 80's and images going back even further. Major awards and hall of fame inductions going back to the beginnings of these awards are easily sourced online. If a AFD doesn't flush out these references will additional time Deletion of Austin Rigsbee WP:BURDEN||WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18793 515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Biman Bangladesh Airlines Flight 60 User:Icewhiz 14:25, 13 May 2019 (UTC) keep per . The crash meets the essay (size, hull loss, injuries). An international passenger flight breaking up into 3 pieces on landing is far from routine. We had international coverage of this recent event, and at this point it is too soon to evaluate SUSTAINED Deletion of Biman Bangladesh Airlines Flight 60 WP:RAPID||WP:AIRCRASH Wikipedia:Notability 77
18794 20371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diana Schaub User:JJL 01:25, 31 January 2008 (UTC) keep clearly notable via http://www.bioethics.gov/about/schaub.html, http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0034-6705(199622)58%3A3%3C629%3AFAPL%3E2.0.CO%3B2-0, http://www.reason.com/news/show/33428.html, http://newcriterion.com/archives/author/dschaub/, http://www.firstthings.com/article.php3?id_article=414, http://www.thenewatlantis.com/archive/4/schaub.htm, http://iggy.loyola.edu/catalogues/current/undergraduate/artsandsci/polysci.html#Faculty Deletion of Diana Schaub WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18795 9768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kate Whitman User:Fordmadoxfraud 15:11, 14 June 2008 (UTC) keep """Amply satisfies and , which explicitly states that losing a race is no more a guarantor of non-notability than winning one is a guarantor of the opposite. To wit: """"Just being an elected local official, or an unelected candidate for political office, does not guarantee notability, ''although such people can still be notable if they meet the primary notability criterion of """"significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject.""""'' Done and done""" Deletion of Kate Whitman WP:RS||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18796 702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Wimbledon Championships - Girls' Singles Qualifying User:TerriersFan 21:17, 7 May 2011 (UTC) delete fail . If anything notable happens in the qualifying events then that can be mentioned in the pages on the main tournies Deletion of 2010 Wimbledon Championships - Girls' Singles Qualifying WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18797 5933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TO THE NEW User:Masumrezarock100 06:36, 26 June 2019 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails and and what's up with that page title Deletion of TO THE NEW WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18798 19756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of The Simpsons couch gags User:Jclemens 20:38, 29 October 2009 (UTC) keep And to the nominator for failing to articulate a deletion reason. 'nuff said Deletion of List of The Simpsons couch gags WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Whacking with a wet trout 74
18799 18817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chooka Parker User:Bridgeplayer NONE merge to Australia's Got Talent (season 5)#Auditions as a valid search term. Failing that '''delete'''. This is a situation - after such reality/talent show appearances there is always a transient burst of publicity but something more lasting is needed for notability Deletion of Chooka Parker WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18800 8708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Disappearance of David Guerrero User:TheGracefulSlick 22:23, 24 September 2017 (UTC) delete WP:ITSNOTABLE is an argument we recommend to avoid because it is weak. Nothing suggests that this disappearance had a |historical importance, nor does anything reach outside the |regular news cycle Deletion of Disappearance of David Guerrero WP:LASTING||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18801 4169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chuba Akpom User:Sir 23:02, 4 April 2013 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Chuba Akpom WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18802 21458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Engineering with Management User:Bearian 13:54, 30 July 2007 (UTC) keep as it appears to be a unique program, which ought to be notable, but cites are desperately needed per Deletion of Engineering with Management WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18803 11385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Weavers' cottage (Kleinschwarzenbach, Zum Weberhaus 10) User:Toughpigs 15:28, 10 August 2020 (UTC) keep as a listed building, per . I edited the article to remove the promotional language and personal reflections, as per the deletion review discussion Deletion of Weavers' cottage (Kleinschwarzenbach, Zum Weberhaus 10) WP:NBUILD Wikipedia:Notability 77
18804 14285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southern Basque Country User:Smartyllama 15:18, 22 July 2016 (UTC) keep Per , it's not up to us what is or is not a real place, and it has been covered by reliable sources. The politics of the situation shouldn't play a role - it's not our place to decide. It might need to be rewritten, but |AFD is not cleanup Deletion of Southern Basque Country WP:NPOV||WP:AFDISNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18805 6330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew McIntosh (professor) User:QTxVi4bEMRbrNqOorWBV 01:31, 27 April 2014 (UTC) delete He certainly isn't famous for standards that I can see. The argument that he is notable for his peculiar religious claims may be stronger, but I don't think such an argument is particularly compelling per Deletion of Andrew McIntosh (professor) WP:PROF||WP:BLPFRINGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18806 5484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raymond Heard Stadium User:Livitup 18:14, 30 August 2013 (UTC) delete Constructed in 1976, so non-routine coverage predates Google, but searching revealed nothing except coverage of events being held there Deletion of Raymond Heard Stadium WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18807 3721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Computrols Incorporated (2nd nomination) User:Kagundu 17:31, 17 May 2016 (UTC) delete this does not pass from searching materials online. The article also had and nothing has happened to gather reliable sources to support it Deletion of Computrols Incorporated (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:CHANCE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18808 3864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tata Technologies User:Yash 21:40, 5 May 2015 (UTC) keep Tata is one of the prominent groups in India. Despite of the poor quality of it, this article is very notable. A quick search shows some significant coverage: http://m.timesofindia.com/business/india-business/PEs-vie-for-520-million-Tata-Tech-stake/articleshow/47006986.cms http://www.siliconindia.com/magazine-articles-in/TATA_Technologies_Building_Competitive_Advantage_with_Effective_Implementation__Use_of_Product_Lifecycle_Management-SJGH484314419.html http://m.economictimes.com/industry/auto/news/industry/tata-motors-and-tata-capital-are-looking-to-sell-their-90-stake-in-tata-technologies/articleshow/46830423.cms http://m.timesofindia.com/business/india-business/Tata-Tech-eyes-250m-buys-to-hit-1bn-sales/articleshow/46337156.cms. Easily passes and . — Deletion of Tata Technologies WP:GNG||WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
18809 18235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chic Medley User:EliminatorJR 11:43, 11 April 2007 (UTC) comment I've been and done as the above user suggested. The relevant information from Kevin Patterson is now in Fiction Factory, which I've tidied up a bit, and the band members except for Ogletree now redirect there. I've also closed the AfDs Deletion of Chic Medley WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
18810 8586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elena Rumyantseva User:Nsk92 21:52, 30 December 2009 (UTC) comment """Wow, this one is really quite something. I do not have a definitive opinion yet but at the moment I am leaning towards delete, based on and concerns. The article is clearly relentlessly self-promotional and looks to be a or case. I looked through the talk page of the ru-wiki version of the article and people there are also complaining about not being able to verify various things, about issues with sources cited etc. Various googlenews, googlescholar and googlebooks searches for the name of the author (both in English and in Russian) also produce fairly little, which is hard to reconcile with the grand claims made in the article (here is a sample search in Russianhttp://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22Е.Е.%20Румянцева%22&lr=&hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=ps). I tried to do some worldcat searches for various versions of transliteration of the subject's name but did not find anything that looks like her books (maybe someone else should give it another try, though). This is all pretty strange given the grandiose claims made in the article. One thing that does check out is the """"best economist"""" prize but the people at the talk page of the ru-wiki version of the article claim that the organization that made the award is not really notable itself. Basically, I have no idea how we here can untangle this mess and decide what is and what is not verifiable from the information in the article and the current text does not look salvageable to me... If someone with some economics background and some knowledge of Russian can comment here, that'd be good""" Deletion of Elena Rumyantseva WP:V||WP:BLP||WP:AUTO||WP:COI||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18811 5101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Pokémon Ranger: Shadows of Almia quests User:Cabe6403 15:11, 7 April 2009 (UTC) delete blatant |game guide. Also delete per Deletion of List of Pokémon Ranger: Shadows of Almia quests WP:GAMEGUIDE||WP:SNOWBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18812 4584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gelheads User:Aspects 03:19, 29 July 2010 (UTC) delete both band and album. The band has no reliable sources and fails Deletion of Gelheads WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18813 4982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sky Sanctuary Zone User:ColourBurst 22:18, 29 September 2006 (UTC) delete It's not |neutral (it has weasel words in it), there aren't any sources (and there aren't many third-party sources who would write about a single level in a game), and anything else written would be |game guidish Deletion of Sky Sanctuary Zone WP:NPOV||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18814 16608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Ranns User:Graham11 05:51, 23 November 2015 (UTC) delete Small town mayor. Doesn't seem to be enough coverage of him to meet Deletion of John Ranns WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18815 12830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tara Hunt User:danntm 05:24, 5 January 2007 (UTC) delete no enough sources to satisfy Deletion of Tara Hunt WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18816 3627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benik Afobe User:GiantSnowman 17:36, 9 July 2010 (UTC) delete fails and , recreate if/when player becomes notable Deletion of Benik Afobe WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18817 1932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sohail Asif Qureshi User:Joe 09:49, 30 December 2017 (UTC) comment The subject of the article https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Sohail_Asif_Qureshi&diff=520605723&oldid=prev apparently wants it to be deleted, so even if there is marginal notability editors may want to bear in mind . – Deletion of Sohail Asif Qureshi WP:BLPREQUESTDELETE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18818 14312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Evangelical Old Catholic Communion User:Edison 17:01, 1 October 2010 (UTC) delete """Any small group of True Believers can split off from some other splinter group and give themselves an impressive name. That in no way satisfies . There has never been a guideline that every purported religious denomination is inherently notable. References are apparently lacking which are needed to satisfy |verifiablity and |notability. Their """"official site"""" has no content and does not show up at Wayback Machine as ever having had any content. Nothing at Google Books to support notability except one line in a listing of Catholic offshoots in a book of unknown reliability""" Deletion of The Evangelical Old Catholic Communion WP:ORG||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18819 19827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Veljko Batrović User:GiantSnowman 16:35, 28 January 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Veljko Batrović WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18820 12 [[Isabelle d'Orléans (1878-1961)]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Ehrhardt NONE keep Die Diskussion zu /23._Juli_2006#Isabelle_d'Orléans-Bragance lief bisher ziemlich eindeutig auf hinaus. Vor diesem Hintergrund erscheint mir das hier klar als Trollantrag. Über eine Verschiebung des Lemmas zur Umbenennung kann man sicher sprechen. Das gehört dann aber auf die Diskussionsseite des Artikels Löschung von Isabelle d'Orléans (1878-1961) Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
18821 13611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hawks' Club User:Caknuck 16:32, 7 July 2007 (UTC) keep I found two references documenting the club's charity work with The Prostate Cancer Charity: http://www.admin.cam.ac.uk/news/dp/2007022803 Press release from Cambridge & http://www.prostate-cancer.org.uk/news/features/hawks_club.asp the Charity's coverage of a fundraiser hosted by the club. Both of those should satisfy Deletion of Hawks' Club WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18822 14545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Stajcer User:Dane 20:59, 17 April 2018 (UTC) delete After reviewing and the comments below, I have been swayed to move this to delete as it does seem to be typical local mentions Deletion of Scott Stajcer WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
18823 8873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Bonaccio User:AllyD 19:06, 25 November 2015 (UTC) delete An unsourced whose subject does not meet . criteria Deletion of Nick Bonaccio :WP:BLP||:WP:MUSICBIO||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18824 14836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerald Sagoe User:Fenix 12:24, 24 October 2014 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Gerald Sagoe WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18825 97 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cindy Chandler (Lost) User:Isotope23 19:45, 1 May 2006 (UTC) delete I'd say redirect, but as far as I can tell the surname isn't Deletion of Cindy Chandler (Lost) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18826 8816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007 De Anza baseball players rape case User:Edison 16:28, 12 December 2007 (UTC) keep This alleged rape has received widespread coverage over an extended period. It has implications beyond the average alleged rape in that it has occasioned widespread comment about the handling of the case by the prosecutor, and because of the notoreity before the incident on the part of the college baseball team which is alleged to have had involvement. The 90 plus dozens of references appear to offer the basis for satisfying the requirements for compliance with policy, in that there are enough reliable sources to back up statements in a coherent account of the event and its aftermath. That said, there is clearly room for improvement in the tone and exposition of the article, which is not in itself a basis for deletion. Also, such a contentious case requires ongoing editorial supervision. Those two facts are not a basis for deletion. {{WP:N is satisfied Deletion of 2007 De Anza baseball players rape case WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18827 18785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Retch (rapper) User:Snowycats 03:47, 15 July 2018 (UTC) delete Lacks reliable sources and fails Deletion of Retch (rapper) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18828 13720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Man card User:Freakofnurture NONE comment I went ahead and |BJAODN'd it. &mdash Deletion of Man card WP:BJAODN Wikipedia:Silly Things 72
18829 173 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Cumhuriyet - Türk Mucizesi """Kullanıcı:nushirevan11'''''nushirevan11'''''""" 18:51, 20 Şubat 2017 (UTC) merge """ping|Pragdon}} Bağımsız kaynaklandırma mevcut değil. Söz konusu kaynaklar yazarla yapılan söyleşi ve röportajlar. Ayrıca maddesinin 1. kriterinde """"'''Kitap birkaç önemli çalışmaya konu olmuş ve bu önemli ve yayımlanmış çalışmaların kaynakları kitabın kendisinden bağımsızdır'''"""" denilmektedir. Bu kıstasları sağlamamaktadır""" Cumhuriyet'in silinmesi - Türk Mucizesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
18830 12046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Little Pony: The Wonderbolts User:Rangoondispenser 13:36, 11 August 2011 (UTC) merge into List of My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic characters#Minor Characters. Also, the newcomers Deletion of My Little Pony: The Wonderbolts WP:DONTBITE Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
18831 12175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Priscilla Yeung User:Capmango 14:41, 7 June 2007 (UTC) comment I think that any time that is the only reason an article is being sent to afd, and the article appears to be written in good faith by someone who is just not clear that notability needs to be asserted, we should start with a notability tag, not go straight to afd Deletion of Priscilla Yeung WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18832 13926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heterophobia (4th nomination) User:Dawn 13:39, 12 February 2013 (UTC) delete """POV, soapboxing, also it's a violation of , since it was cobbled together using a bunch or sources that don't even use the word """"heterophobia."""" Cheers""" Deletion of Heterophobia (4th nomination) WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
18833 804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Linda Weber User:Bearcat 18:27, 12 February 2018 (UTC) delete A non-winning candidate for office who fails does not get an automatic free pass over in lieu just because some coverage of her campaign for office exists — ''every'' candidate for office ''always'' gets some coverage of their campaign, so every candidate would always clear GNG if that were enough in and of itself. Rather, a candidate gets an article in one of three ways: (a) she ''wins'' the election and thereby becomes a ''holder'' of a notable political office, (b) she ''already'' had a credible and properly sourced notability claim ''independently'' of her candidacy, such as already having held another notable office or passing our notability standards for her primary career ''apart'' from politics, or (c) she received ''so'' much coverage for her campaign, expanding ''significantly'' out of scope to what every other candidate also got, that her candidacy itself can be credibly claimed as significantly ''more'' notable than everybody else's candidacy (the Christine O'Donnell test.) But A isn't true, and this article as written is demonstrating neither B nor C. Tomwsulcer isn't a user whose assessment of sources I put much stock in, considering that he once tried to argue that a television reporter had cleared our notability standards for journalists because her existence could be referenced to a letter she had written to her local newspaper's food columnist asking for a kale recipe Deletion of Linda Weber WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18834 12024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ron Boyd User:Ukexpat 19:41, 27 May 2010 (UTC) merge per Whpq; in fact it should be snowball done now as this guy is clearly not notable per Deletion of Ron Boyd WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18835 3595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Wilkie User:Darryl 18:33, 21 September 2020 (UTC) keep I am not sure this articles' topic has obtained , but I will say our hypocrisy in these discussions is deafening. It is clear that there is one set of rules for Green leaders and another for Liberal and NDP leaders (who also lack representation in a provincial legislature). If those articles are a '''Keep''', removing this one is simple hypocrisy. For examples, see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naveed Anwar, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mackenzie Thomason, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darrin Lamoureux and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naomi Hunter Deletion of Jordan Wilkie WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18836 11618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFO sightings in outer space User:Bearian 23:02, 11 February 2014 (UTC) keep per , and as a fairly well-known urban legend. We are not Truthpedia: we publish ''stuff'' - see Deletion of UFO sightings in outer space WP:FRINGE||WP:ODD Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
18837 6221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AppleAddict Forums User:JiFish 19:55, 21 December 2005 (UTC) delete fails , meatpuppets Deletion of AppleAddict Forums WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18838 7183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammad Akram (blind cricketer) [[User_talk:ClubOranje|Oranje]][[User_talk:ClubOranje|T]] 11:46, 9 October 2017 (UTC) merge to Blind cricket, with maybe a mention in Pakistan national blind cricket team per . He is currently the world record holder, but one day he won't be. And to pre-empt the NOTTEMP comments, if it is such a permanent noteworthy thing, who was the previous holder? And the one before that? talks about the highest level for cricket. This is not the highest level for cricket, otherwise we'd be meeting notability criteria for every player at that tournament. If you want to argue that blind cricket is different, get consensus at Club Deletion of Muhammad Akram (blind cricketer) WP:BIO1E||WP:NCRIC||WP:NBLINDCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18839 13705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hail Satan (book) User:Ian 13:07, 29 June 2010 (UTC) comment """I like it"""" is not a standard of |notability""" Deletion of Hail Satan (book) WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
18840 9907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ioquake3 User:Teancum 12:25, 11 January 2010 (UTC) comment While most here would not deny that your average PC gamer sees the value and notability in IoQuake3, we have to remember that Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, and like any good encyclopedia its sources have to be |reliable and published and provide |siginificant coverage to ensure factual information. Nobody is questioning whether its popular, or even whether its a good program. The issue comes down to those two things, no matter how popular the engine may be. Should those things ever be satisfied, or if sources are found now that fit that criteria then it's always welcome as an article Deletion of Ioquake3 WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18841 5329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Robert Fuller (2nd nomination) User:Aseleste 11:40, 2 April 2021 (UTC) keep The subject of the article is the event, not the person, so and should not apply here.{{Paragraph break}}As for notability as an event, the previous consensus was that it meets (and is not the main policy contested in this AfD Deletion of Death of Robert Fuller (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:BIO1E||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18842 9015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doron Nof User:Iridescenti 17:46, 3 May 2007 (UTC) keep easily satisfies cat 6 of - the Fridtjof_Nansen#Posthumous_honors|Fridtjof Nansen Medal is the European Geophysical Society's highest award for oceanography & this guy's won it Deletion of Doron Nof WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
18843 9632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Voafose User:DrStrauss 08:07, 4 August 2017 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Voafose WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18844 15348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PhpPgAdmin User:Mark 00:17, 2 February 2017 (UTC) merge to PostgreSQL#Database administration where it is already mentioned. I don't see enough reliable sourcing for notability, but there is verifiability of basic facts, enough for a mention at the target article. 5-20 page views a day suggests that this is a plausible search term. Per our Wikipedia policy for alternatives to deletion , preservation of verifiable material is preferable to deletion. Hence, redirect Deletion of PhpPgAdmin WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18845 6266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JStar User:Pharaoh 08:58, 28 December 2015 (UTC) delete per nom lacks Deletion of JStar WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
18846 10305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juan Manuel Abras (second nomination) User:AbsolutDan 00:54, 21 April 2006 (UTC) delete as NN and protect from recreation. Membership in organizations and admission to programs/educational institutions, prestigious though they may be, does not necessarily confer notability. For all the hyperbole above I see no mention of ''which'' orchestras he led (ite). The extensive ockpuppet|sock puppetry above and on the article's Talk:Juan Manuel Abras|talk page indicate that this article will be quickly recreated if not protected Deletion of Juan Manuel Abras (second nomination) WP:C||WP:S Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
18847 16495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Henderson (teacher) User:Ddcm8991 03:23, 5 August 2015 (UTC) delete Per nomination and David Eppstein. Not notable by the criteria of or Deletion of Matt Henderson (teacher) WP:GNG||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
18848 3470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Wayne Sinclair User:Sceptre 21:52, 19 June 2008 (UTC) delete per #G4, Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Badlydrawnjeff#Summary deletion of BLPs, and standard message given on create-protected pages Deletion of Larry Wayne Sinclair WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18849 242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iron fist fighting User:Mtking 20:37, 21 October 2012 (UTC) delete No indication that this meets I cant find the significant coverage in RS's Deletion of Iron fist fighting WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18850 5735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Draeden User:Aoidh 09:24, 20 September 2013 (UTC) delete Subject fails as it has zero third-party reliable sources. A merge might be appropriate, but even that's pushing it Deletion of Draeden WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18851 12126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untranslatability User:Cnilep 02:36, 18 December 2017 (UTC) keep ish? |There is no deadline; deletion is not for clean up; et cetera. In principle the problems are surmountable. Furthermore, the topic is discussed in literature on translation or linguistics. But, as Colapeninsula suggests, this might be better handled in an article on translation, perhaps via selective merging Deletion of Untranslatability WP:AADD Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18852 7458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fred Galoff User:Abraham 00:32, 30 December 2009 (UTC) delete per , and the precedent set by the aforementioned AFDs in the nomination. Admirable, but not quite notable by Wikipedia's standards. Cheers Deletion of Fred Galoff WP:GNG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
18853 8243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abhay Pandey User:AllyD 05:52, 9 May 2014 (UTC) delete Routine career biography suitable for his firm's website but |nothing to indicate |encyclopaedic notability Deletion of Abhay Pandey :WP:RS||:WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18854 441 [[Hallteiche]] (LAE 1) Benutzer:Mogadir NONE delete WP:ART|kein ausreichender Artikel und/oder |kein enzyklopädischer Inhalt Löschung von Hallteiche Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18855 623 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/U.S. intervention in Venezuela User:Lubbad85 02:07, 30 April 2019 (UTC) keep I agree with Dream Focus that reliable sources are covering this event so it passes . and come to mind Deletion of U.S. intervention in Venezuela WP:GNG||WP:ATD||WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18856 9510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lockport Mall User:Sjakkalle 13:55, 20 March 2007 (UTC) delete Regular shopping mall which does not appear to have any major or serious impact on the community. (Scratching my head a bit on why is being used as a rationale for deletion though Deletion of Lockport Mall WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18857 1087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transformers: Robot Masters User:Piotrus 09:37, 11 November 2019 (UTC) delete Fails / Deletion of Transformers: Robot Masters WP:NFICTION||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18858 7004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melinda Jacobs Grodnick User:VernoWhitney 19:47, 25 February 2010 (UTC) keep Maybe not notable as a reporter, but 100+ mentions in the Star Tribune over 20 years meets , the article does need more sourcing, but that's not the issue Deletion of Melinda Jacobs Grodnick WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18859 20757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor Who 2008 Christmas special User:Edokter 13:26, 6 July 2008 (UTC) delete """Fails and . Seriously people, I see so many """"keeps per WP:CRYSTAL"""" it is insane. The article contains no information partaining to the epiosde itself, is filled with non-information that the name has ''not been revealed yet'', and lacks any sort of reliable sources; most information is coming from tabloids. The information that is available only relates to the production, which is best suited in List of Doctor Who serials. There is just too little information and notability to sustain a seperate article for now. """"It exists"""" is not reason enough to have an article. Article creation should be suspended until we ''at least'' have a title, ''and'' we have enough sourceble information""" Deletion of Doctor Who 2008 Christmas special WP:FUTURE||WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18860 15422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas H. Haines User:CASSIOPEIA 09:52, 6 May 2019 (UTC) keep Subject born in the year of 1933, pre internet ear, thus digital RS is not easy to be found. Google scholar https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=Thomas+Henry+Haines&hl=en and Mendeley https://www.mendeley.com/research-papers/?query=Thomas%20Henry%20Haines&page=1 show many citation of subject's works passes |NACADEMIC#4 Deletion of Thomas H. Haines WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18861 9648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Countries Michael Jackson performed in User:Spiderone 09:47, 21 December 2016 (UTC) delete see ; it fails on almost every point Deletion of List of Countries Michael Jackson performed in WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
18862 12403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Myers Snagg Aceto User:Possibly 02:25, 5 June 2021 (UTC) delete this was only up for an hour before it was AfD'd. However, the nomination seems correct as I could not find any at all. She illustrated one book, which is not enough on its own. I looked for exhibitions, reviews and collections (the triad of art practice?) but saw nothing. GNG fail. The creator should not be discouraged, as it was a good attempt... but have a look at and as these are the key policies for determining what is kept and what is not Deletion of Elizabeth Myers Snagg Aceto WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG||WP:NARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
18863 2615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Visions of Violence (film) User:ReaderofthePack 09:42, 5 January 2021 (UTC) delete There's nothing out there for this film to establish how it's individually notable. Assuming the other film is notable, notability is |not inherited from the other film. IMDb is not usable as a source on Wikipedia because it's easy to submit false or incorrect information. It doesn't mean that the info here is incorrect, just that the abuse from others has been so bad that IMDb just isn't reliable. Even if it could be used, it would be a database listing at best and couldn't give notability. Since notability is an issue here, I'll investigate the other film to see if it also has notability issues Deletion of Visions of Violence (film) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18864 7783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teleport (website) User:AllyD 15:34, 8 May 2021 (UTC) delete """An article describing the initial phase of this proposition, supported by start-up announcement coverage which is insufficient for . No article on """"MOVE Guides"""" so no redirect alternative, and I am not seeing the |coverage needed to demonstrate / notability""" Deletion of Teleport (website) :WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:RS||:WP:NSOFT||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18865 11671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roheen Berry User:Ifnord 13:55, 20 June 2021 (UTC) delete for failing . Being a CEO of a company which may or may not return from bankruptcy does not confer notability Deletion of Roheen Berry WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18866 14408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Babak Radmanesh User:Alvestrand 11:17, 6 April 2009 (UTC) delete as unsourced. If any of the Google hits were to a newspaper or other , and the newspaper was added as a source (for what it corroborated), I would change to a 'keep' - but all my own checking of the google results have just turned up unverifiable claims Deletion of Babak Radmanesh WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18867 1641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Policide User:Amoruso 12:42, 24 October 2006 (UTC) keep Seems like a nomination without any reasoning. The article is well sourced and very encyclopedic. Speedy keep Deletion of Policide WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18868 12744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Barnes User:AJW7X 12:49, 18 May 2014 (UTC) keep Meets with Deletion of Tony Barnes WP:NAFL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18869 11717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of state Constitution Parties User:Smartyllama 19:00, 15 June 2016 (UTC) merge per Postdlf. Most of the state affiliates redirect to that section, and this is a plausible search term for someone looking for the information contained in that section. There's really no reason ''not'' to do it, and |Redirects are cheap Deletion of List of state Constitution Parties WP:REDIRECTSARECHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
18870 11449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NautiChem User:Leuko 04:11, 25 August 2006 (UTC) delete not notable for in google.de either Deletion of NautiChem WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18871 16901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Take Control (Dangerous Muse album) User:Nnadigoodluck 06:44, 20 November 2019 (UTC) delete Looks like Deletion of Take Control (Dangerous Muse album) WP:PROMOTION Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18872 2447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apple Oxidation User:Doc 17:51, 13 March 2008 (UTC) delete WP:OR|original research, seems to be a #PUBLISHER|personal essay or a school project Deletion of Apple Oxidation WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18873 1718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009–10 Gateshead F.C. season User:Number 10:32, 20 September 2020 (UTC) delete per failure Deletion of 2009–10 Gateshead F.C. season WP:NSEASON Wikipedia:Notability 77
18874 17268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Gregory Buttigieg User:Markdsgraham 02:13, 17 September 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Althought it's probably close, there are not any major sources providing coverage of any of the assertions of notability. While it isn't certain that is in play, the author's only contributions are in respect of this article and the article contains information that could not be assembled from the listed sources alone Deletion of George Gregory Buttigieg WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
18875 9654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dammit, Janet (Third Time)! User:Kww 21:18, 30 November 2007 (UTC) delete I probably wouldn't have reopened this one, because I have given up. The song just isn't notable as an independent entity. The closing admin on the last AFD admitted that he closed it for inappropriate reasons (all the 'keep' votes ignored multiple policies, but they were a clear majority, so he went with them to save the hassle of a DRV). Insufficient sourcing, insufficient notability. What passes for sources in the article are passing mentions, and there is not a single source that addresses the topic directly and in detail, which is required by otability. Redirecting to Rocky Horror Picture Show is the best that should happen to this thing Deletion of Dammit, Janet (Third Time)! WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18876 21676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loren Feldman [[User talk:64.120.158.21|talk]]) 03:34, 30 October 2009 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet |general notability guideline or . --Special:Contributions/64.120.158.21|64.120.158.21 Deletion of Loren Feldman WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18877 12691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MySupermarket (3rd nomination) NONE NONE delete just a shopping web site. Raised about $15M which strongly suggests it's for an encyclopedia article. The coverage is shallow and the reviews offered are routine, as in Deletion of MySupermarket (3rd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
18878 1171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/College Square Mall User:Orlady 03:32, 18 October 2008 (UTC) keep or '''merge/redirect'''. Merging to Morristown would be a good option, as this is a major commercial center for Morristown and the surrounding rural region. Other 3rd-party coverage I have found online (not all of it ) includes http://www.deadmalls.com/?/malls/college_square.html DeadMalls.com, http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0EIN/is_2007_Oct_9/ai_n27401129 a different version of the local newspaper story cited in the article, http://www.portfolio.com/resources/company-profiles/College-Square-Mall-298065 this short description of the mall, http://www.knoxnews.com/news/2005/nov/18/yeldell-speculation-on-turkey-creeks-new-tenants/ this Knoxville newspaper article about a planned store closure, and http://www.hamblencountygovernment.us/county_commission/county_clerk.cfm an item about the county clerk's branch office in the mall. Also, here's a http://74.125.45.104/search?q=cache:VgxpAz9jiBgJ:morristownnewspaper.com/news/view_sections.asp%3Fidcategory%3D3%26idarticle%3D9925+college+square+mall+morristown&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=125&gl=us&client=firefox-a Google cache link to another article in the local newspaper Deletion of College Square Mall WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18879 20779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shane O'Connor (soccer) User:GiantSnowman 13:12, 3 August 2009 (UTC) delete """fails both (as he hasn't """"competed at the fully professional level of a sport"""") and (as he hasn't """"received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject""""). Recreate if & when he meets either of these guidelines in the future""" Deletion of Shane O'Connor (soccer) WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18880 3461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Biblical christian belief User:Kim 15:31, 11 January 2008 (UTC) delete As written, there is no way the article's claims could be established by reference to any |source which could be cited. If re-written (entirely!) to say 'Some people claim that.....XYZ' with a good reference that establishes this fact is |notable, it could survive. But I suspect this is unlikely to happen, and atricles outlining these views in a POV|neutral manner probably already exist anyway Deletion of Biblical christian belief WP:V||WP:N||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18881 1750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Don Chilton User:Hello32020 02:06, 16 October 2006 (UTC) delete Right now, it doesn't satisfy |notability guidelines Deletion of Don Chilton WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18882 19984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Damir Kedžo User:GregorB 09:10, 5 May 2010 (UTC) merge """to Saša, Tin i Kedžo. The band itself arguably meets criterion #7 as """"the first Croatian boy band""" Deletion of Damir Kedžo WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18883 2998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Internet slang phrases (3rd nomination) User:DHowell 00:15, 26 October 2007 (UTC) keep """1) The part of prohibiting """"lists of defintions"""" is disputed, because there exist dozens of :Category:Glossaries|glossaries which are properly encyclopedic. 2) This is not a guide on how words, idioms, etc. ''should'' be used, but a document which describes how they ''are'' used; this is a difference which distinguishes a violation of from an encylopedic article. 3) The existence of anything similar on Wiktionary should not have any bearing on this article. Just like Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and series boxes|categories and lists can complement each other, so too can glossaries on Wikipedia and definitions on Wiktionary complement each other. Redundancy is not always bad. 4) """"''|There are some times when 'usefulness' can be the basis of a valid argument for inclusion. An encyclopedia should, by definition, be informative and useful to its readers. Try to exercise common sense, and consider how a non-trivial number of people will consider the information 'useful""" Deletion of List of Internet slang phrases (3rd nomination) WP:NOT||WP:NOT||WP:USEFUL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18884 8645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chaudhari Kumbharam Arya User:Umakant 15:58, 20 June 2021 (UTC) keep Article is not unsourced, it has a link to parliamentofindia which indicates he was an MP and MLA from Rajasthan hence passes Deletion of Chaudhari Kumbharam Arya WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18885 20160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guto (footballer, born 1991) User:Peter 16:52, 7 December 2020 (UTC) keep It's better to have a complete set of articles here for than maintain a complete set on another site and a separate incomplete set here. Subject-specific guidelines are more important than as a reason to delete an article, there's no reason to say they shouldn't be as a reason to keep an article Deletion of Guto (footballer, born 1991) WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18886 4741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loki installers for linux gamers User:Starblind 17:07, 25 November 2009 (UTC) delete Oh man, you know an article is in big trouble when the first reference is to a forum post. Anyway, delete per , , , etc Deletion of Loki installers for linux gamers WP:WEB||WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18887 15662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iksar User:IAmSasori 02:40, 7 November 2007 (UTC) delete There are no |sources on this article. It also lacks real world |notability, so creating more race articles would only go against those ideals. If more race articles were to be created, readers who do not play EverQuest will have little to no interest in this article, giving little reason to create them nor keep this one Deletion of Iksar WP:SOURCE||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18888 279 [[Johannes Bergsmann]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Wahldresdner 02:34, 23. Okt. 2010 (CEST) delete Nichts erkennbar, was ihn relevant für einen WP-Artikel macht. Inhaber einer nicht sonderlich großen Firma, bestellter Sachverständiger, Lehrbeauftragter an einer Hochschule, ein kleiner Vereinsposten, Vorträge auf irgendwelchen Branchentagungen und Fachartikel in Branchenmagazinen... das bleibt alles deutlich unter den Anforderungen von Löschung von Johannes Bergsmann Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
18889 15685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meiningen Court Orchestra User:antiuser 07:45, 25 June 2011 (UTC) keep Even a quick Google search brings up enough results that could be used as |sources to establish the history and notability of the orchestra. XXX Deletion of Meiningen Court Orchestra WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18890 8065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Company of Seven User:WWGB 13:50, 8 August 2010 (UTC) delete Non-notable theatre company, fails . References all allude to self-published history of the company. Total absence of any multiple, third-party, independent, reliable sources as required Deletion of The Company of Seven WP:GROUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18891 19261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayan Restaurant User:KojiDude 22:31, 16 October 2006 (UTC) delete May be a cool resturant, but as Jimbo said himself in his C-SPAN interview, you can't just waltz in and write about something in your local area you think is cool. It has to be |notable Deletion of Mayan Restaurant WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
18892 18924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy Grammer User:Waseabind 20:29, 24 March 2011 (UTC) keep meets has been the subject of multiple, non-trivial, published works appearing in sources that are reliable and are independent from the musician or ensemble itself, this includes, but not limited to: billboard.com, popeater.com, vevo.com, spinner.com, bmi.com, wsj.com, starpulse.com, and many, many others. He performed on The Rachael Ray Show live on November 17, 2010 Deletion of Andy Grammer WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18893 6955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marybeth Grant User:Suriel1981 17:18, 11 April 2007 (UTC) delete """Failing the """"General"""" points of """ Deletion of Marybeth Grant WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18894 1154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Integrated Conflict Management Systems User:Ihcoyc 18:34, 27 September 2006 (UTC) delete as OR, and for inappropriate vagueness and abstraction. ''An organization is a complex system of people, procedures, practices, policies, relationships, facilities, values, resources, cultures, services and products, production, activity and transformation.''. In Wikipedia:Plain English|plain English, wouldn't it be simpler to say ''An organization is an arbitrary string of abstract nouns''? I strongly suspect this is veiled |spam for a management consulting|consulting business Deletion of Integrated Conflict Management Systems WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
18895 3 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karachi Kings–Lahore Qalandars rivalry NONE NONE keep """Seems like a legitimate rivalry: I am not an expert in Cricket but this one has s per and passes - most of the references below describe this rivalry and """"biggest"""" and """"intense"""" etc. Finally per RIVALRY This passes the requirement of NRIVALRY because of the RS. {{tq|Sports rivalries are not inherently notable. Articles on sports rivalries, such as Yankees–Red Sox rivalry, should satisfy the general notability guideline""" Deletion of Karachi Kings–Lahore Qalandars rivalry WP:RS||WP:NEXIST||WP:N||WP:NRIVALRY Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18896 5704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New River, Nanjing User:Philg88 05:51, 13 May 2014 (UTC) delete The town doesn't appear as an official subdivision of the Jianye District according to the National Bureau of Statistics of the People's Republic of China. See http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjsj/tjbz/tjyqhdmhcxhfdm/2013/32/01/320105.html this link. Thereby fails |verifiability. No reliable source found to justify retention as a stub, probably an informal name for part of the Jianye District used by locals. The Baidu and Aibang references are not considered |reliable and I can find no others Deletion of New River, Nanjing WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18897 14357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ole Sheldon User:Reaper 17:17, 3 March 2011 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Ole Sheldon WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18898 8971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rose (goat) User:Darksun 12:22, 6 June 2007 (UTC) keep blatantly passes . One of the most read stories in the history of the BBC News website, that is certainly noteworthy. However, I think consensus is needed whether or not the article should be here or in Charles Tombe, the human involved in the incident, but we can leave that till after this AfD Deletion of Rose (goat) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18899 12346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yeganeh User:Hobbes 01:40, 2 October 2011 (UTC) delete This is a miniscule #DICDEF|dictionary definition, not an encyclopedia entry. Here is an Hassan_(given_name)|example of an encyclopedia entry for a name. The WP entry Persian_name|Persian name might be a place to put this, although it might need a new section for names that don't qualify as common, or for all names Deletion of Yeganeh WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18900 11560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/YIMBY User:Alan 20:13, 12 September 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of YIMBY WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18901 1674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Accusations against Israel of war crimes during the Al-Aqsa Intifada User:Jayjg 03:31, 14 January 2007 (UTC) delete """obvious article, and votes solicited at Wikipedia:WikiProject Deletion sorting/Islam should be discounted. '''Also, almost none (or is there even one?) of the """"sources"""" actually seems to refer to """"war-crimes""" Deletion of Accusations against Israel of war crimes during the Al-Aqsa Intifada WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18902 155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Philippine Presidents by longevity User:Charlene 08:50, 23 April 2007 (UTC) comment Yes, I know, , but it does seem a failure of to have an identical article about US presidents and not about any other world leaders Deletion of List of Philippine Presidents by longevity WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS||WP:CSB Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18903 12836 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanjeev Sharma (filmmaker) User:Anupmehra 22:53, 2 November 2016 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Sanjeev Sharma (filmmaker) WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18904 11464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henrietta Hughes User:Neurolysis 13:42, 14 February 2009 (UTC) delete Fails , . Not notable - her encounter with the president is irrelevant. &mdash Deletion of Henrietta Hughes WP:BIO||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
18905 14511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oxi Fresh Carpet Cleaning User:Jack 23:33, 15 April 2020 (UTC) delete Fails to meet any of the |notability guidelines, and not likely to do so in the foreseeable future Deletion of Oxi Fresh Carpet Cleaning WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18906 4092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Why is plastic surgery bad User:Mr 02:18, 19 April 2008 (UTC) delete A poorly written essay full of |original research and |POV. I think it might be |snowing Deletion of Why is plastic surgery bad WP:NOR||WP:NPOV||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:No original research 65
18907 21498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Competent man User:Parabolooidal 15:37, 20 August 2014 (UTC) delete agree that it seems like |original research. Completely unreferenced article. No citations for the long list of names in the article as well Deletion of Competent man WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18908 12226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phil Collins News User:Joe 22:28, 21 December 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Phil Collins News WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18909 708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of UK Admiralty Charts, 1967 User:Dr 20:42, 22 July 2021 (UTC) keep This is a very valuable source of information and is exactly what Wikipedia is for. Also per others Deletion of List of UK Admiralty Charts, 1967 WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18910 11308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicholas Lore User:Faustus37 02:03, 1 November 2012 (UTC) keep Fireside and Touchstone are both Simon & Schuster imprints. No vanity publishing here. The article does need work with respect to , but it otherwise passes muster Deletion of Nicholas Lore WP:AB Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
18911 9279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derby Tel Aviv User:Cloudz679 22:50, 19 December 2013 (UTC) keep a notable rivalry as demonstrated by links in the discussion here. Further, recommend nominator reads Deletion of Derby Tel Aviv WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
18912 17053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roopesh Peethambaran User:Cutest 12:13, 17 October 2014 (UTC) delete Appears to be |too soon as well as lacks significant coverage in |reliable sources. — Deletion of Roopesh Peethambaran WP:TOOSOON||WP:RS Wikipedia:Too soon 40
18913 12276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norman J. Wildberger User:Eric 02:05, 7 January 2009 (UTC) merge As suggested by Michael Hardy and Espresso Addict. Could not find enough to establish notability under . Does not seem to pass either Deletion of Norman J. Wildberger WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18914 6761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur Stewart (footballer) User:DustFormsWords 02:19, 2 October 2009 (UTC) keep """unless anyone's asserting that he is not, in fact, a professional footballer, then he meets (""""People who have competed at the fully professional level of a sport"""") and the article should be kept""" Deletion of Arthur Stewart (footballer) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
18915 20725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raleigh Lacrosse Club User:SkyGazer 14:35, 16 September 2018 (UTC) delete I've looked around a bit, and I can't find good, reliable sources that significantly cover the topic. Doesn't appear to or Deletion of Raleigh Lacrosse Club WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18916 14573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John W. Childs User:Pegnawl 18:23, 13 March 2020 (UTC) keep """Nicknamed the """"Republican ATM"""", the subject appears in several articles and listicles, despite being notoriously """"media-shy"""": https://www.huffpost.com/entry/club-for-growth-directors_n_3286332 (1)https://www.bostonmagazine.com/2006/05/15/the-50-wealthiest-bostonians/ (2)https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2011/09/koch-brothers-million-dollar-donor-club/ (3). A nice article on his conservation work through the Wild Salmon Center exists here: https://www.adn.com/politics/2018/10/01/why-a-boston-billionaire-and-global-resource-companies-are-fueling-alaskas-salmon-initiative-debate/ (4). While the more recent coverage is about , it is substantial and in-depth, and provides a ton of further detail on the man's life, e.g. https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/2019/02/22/billionaire-john-childs-charged-florida-human-trafficking-prostitution-ring/2956107002/ USA Today, https://www.bostonglobe.com/business/2019/02/25/john-childs-other-rich-mass-guy-charged-florida-day-spa-sweep/DYNMGfFUkp9JFKOgE0yohJ/story.html Boston Globe, https://www.cnbc.com/2019/08/21/republican-donor-john-childs-donated-330000-since-prostitution-sting.html CNBC. I respect the BLP concern, but I think the entry can remain balanced. Given the above references, GNG is satisfied, and the subject appears notable beyond the recent charges in Florida. """ Deletion of John W. Childs WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18917 10568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madura Kulatunga (2nd nomination) User:CactusWriter 18:51, 12 September 2015 (UTC) merge to Madura English-Sinhala Dictionary per and issues of notability. The sources and text are primarily relevant only to the dictionary. There also seems to be the continuing problems of |COI and self-promotion -- the same issues expressed at the previous AFD last March Deletion of Madura Kulatunga (2nd nomination) WP:BLP||WP:BIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18918 18091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Landmarks in the Sim City Series User:Marasmusine 15:03, 2 December 2008 (UTC) delete the issue isn't so much sources, as notability. Have the landmarks in the game, as a subject, received any coverage in reliable, third-party sources? Is the coverage significant enough to warrant a seperate article? In addition, our guidelines apply here - the article has nothing interesting to say Deletion of Landmarks in the Sim City Series WP:WAF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
18919 14244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Debate Klub User:Alias 01:36, 21 July 2006 (UTC) delete unless and is established Deletion of Debate Klub WP:NN||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
18920 16458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Project Monarch User:Just 01:15, 23 December 2006 (UTC) keep This afd is about the rumors of the project rather than the project it seems. The project probably wouldn't be able to meet due to its nature Deletion of Project Monarch WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18921 15702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dutch Acadie User:DoubleBlue 16:58, 4 May 2008 (UTC) delete """Dutch Acadie never existed and appears to be a |coined phrase. A Dutch ship captured two barely defended French forts and were re-taken a month later. The Netherlands never had any rule over the area. No reliable sources for term """"Dutch Acadie"""" as per Ghits and GoogleBooks cited by The Red Hat of Pat Ferrick""" Deletion of Dutch Acadie WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18922 16365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Parisian locations User:TenPoundHammer 20:44, 20 April 2007 (UTC) keep or '''Merge'''. I created the Former Mervyn's list because I was going to add current Mervyn's to the list too. However, the data for current locations are not readily available (Mervyn's store locator only lists the three nearest stores to any given point, and doesn't a full directory), so I haven't added the Mervyn's listings yet. As for the others, I feel that the listings could be merged into their respective store articles... but made into hidden lists, like found on Woolco and Dillard's. So many people have contributed to some of these lists; it would likely be upsetting for the listings to be deleted. To hell with what says -- I honestly think that such data are useful, especially in cases like Mervyn's, which has seen a slew of closings lately. (I just knew this vote would be edit conflicted, too Deletion of List of Parisian locations WP:USEFUL Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
18923 21370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plot of Les Misérables User:Mantanmoreland 19:10, 6 July 2007 (UTC) keep and fix #PLOT, with which it conflicts. Articles on plots should be discouraged, but not banned. Clearly warranted for this opus and a very few others Deletion of Plot of Les Misérables WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18924 6840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denialism User:Paul_Pigman 01:55, 1 March 2007 (UTC) delete This really does seem like . The sources seem less than directly supportive of the current existence and use of the term and more like, surprise! sources supporting an original synthesis. Unless there's more specific cites of it, I'm reluctant to let it stand as is Deletion of Denialism WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18925 12986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathalie Piquion User:Sandstein 19:58, 24 March 2012 (UTC) delete per , article contains no references of significant third party coverage Deletion of Nathalie Piquion WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18926 4186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Christie User:Osomec 08:33, 3 June 2006 (UTC) keep Easily and indisputably meets the criteria for sportspeople. Calvin Peete is one of just over a hundred red links out of over 900 names on list of golfers and at the current rate of progress they will all have articles in a month or two Deletion of Michael Christie WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18927 6404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GIBS Business School User:Epinoia 04:16, 9 May 2019 (UTC) delete """does not meet or - """"If the individual organization has received no or very little notice from independent sources, then it is not notable""" Deletion of GIBS Business School WP:NSCHOOL||WP:ORGSIG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18928 9452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Big Box Stores in Michigan User:Kagundu 18:15, 4 April 2016 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of List of Big Box Stores in Michigan WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18929 5653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robo.to User:South 23:33, 21 September 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Robo.to WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18930 4236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Harley Worthington User:Jahnx 08:10, 23 February 2008 (UTC) delete per nom, fails and Deletion of David Harley Worthington WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18931 9881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled Nicole Scherzinger Debut Album User:Juliancolton 18:54, 17 August 2008 (UTC) delete Fails . &ndash Deletion of Untitled Nicole Scherzinger Debut Album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18932 18279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enfield Monster User:McGeddon 09:43, 7 March 2014 (UTC) keep The cryptozoonews.com source given in the article is clearly headlined as being a reprint of an article from Fate (magazine)|Fate magazine. Combined with the Cohen book mentioned above, this seems enough to meet Deletion of Enfield Monster WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18933 11640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahn Tae-Yoon User:Sir 14:13, 14 July 2011 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not made his professional debut and there is no indication of significant coverage, meaning he fails both and Deletion of Ahn Tae-Yoon WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18934 4425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darryl Buchanan User:Bearian 17:40, 26 January 2021 (UTC) delete per above, and particularly failing and . Flint is not so large a city that its city council members are automatically notable, and |the coverage he's had is entirely local Deletion of Darryl Buchanan WP:NPOL||WP:POLOUTCOMES||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
18935 4388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hot Rod Girls Save The World User:Mr 00:05, 9 April 2009 (UTC) delete Non-notable indie film, no awards, no film festival screenings, no IMDB entry, and most importantly, no |non-trivial third party sources Deletion of Hot Rod Girls Save The World WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
18936 20006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earth-349 User:Sbrools 03:47, 27 December 2006 (UTC) delete Completely non-notable. And I agree, the close similarity of the creator to the name in the article is highly suspicious. This could possible fall under {{db-spam}} and definitely violates Deletion of Earth-349 WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
18937 4787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2000s in Young People's fashion User:Doc 18:29, 9 October 2009 (UTC) delete WEBHOST|violates |almost |every |rule |we |have Deletion of 2000s in Young People's fashion WP:NPOV||WP:RS||WP:OR||WP:V||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
18938 13802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Hayes (lawyer) User:Kirbanzo 09:49, 4 October 2018 (UTC) delete to sum up this long nomination, the subject fails due to their notability being from only one event. applies Deletion of Peter Hayes (lawyer) WP:NBIO||WP:TABLOID Wikipedia:Notability 77
18939 8345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pakelika Presents: Another Cult Classic User:Sharkface217 02:58, 21 March 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Pakelika Presents: Another Cult Classic WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18940 4171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Washiqur Rahman Babu User:Masem 23:57, 30 March 2015 (UTC) delete or consider an article about the attacks against progressives in Bangladesh which would include other related problems lke Avijit Roy. By itself, despite the wide coverage, this is a failure of and considering the event standalone, fails . But there is clearly a larger problem with stuff like this happening in that country, and so it fully makes sense to have an article about it that would also include this person's murder Deletion of Washiqur Rahman Babu WP:BLP1E||WP:NEVENT Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
18941 2649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tharindu Wijesekara User:ChamithN 05:36, 4 August 2015 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet . Youtube links to his videos cannot be considered as reliable sources as they are self published Deletion of Tharindu Wijesekara WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18942 8758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plant on a chip [[User talk:202.124.74.3|talk]]) 08:34, 22 September 2012 (UTC) delete """While the name occurs in the literature, it refers to something completely different (either """"power plant on a chip"""" or """"chemical plant on a chip""""). With just 5 citations for the paper, the topic of '''this''' article is not notable. I also note that the author of the article seems to be the """"Ali Yetisen"""" mentioned, and if so, applies. -- Special:Contributions/202.124.74.3|202.124.74.3""" Deletion of Plant on a chip WP:YOURSELF Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
18943 13186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bands named after gruesome events User:Cyrus 12:24, 11 April 2007 (UTC) delete indiscriminate list that is completely Deletion of Bands named after gruesome events WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18944 8030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013 Peru plane crash NONE NONE delete as a non-notable event. This accident fails the guideline for the following reasons Deletion of 2013 Peru plane crash WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18945 412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Internet celebrity User:MuZemike 16:29, 1 October 2008 (UTC) delete While a topic like this can possibly warrant a halfway-decent article, its current state is certainly a |spam magnet and would need a complete rewrite to become encyclopedic Deletion of Internet celebrity WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
18946 3120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of literary works with eponymous heroes User:Axem 05:35, 14 January 2007 (UTC) delete per GassyGuy. He summed up my argument better than I did. Oh, and #IINFO, too Deletion of List of literary works with eponymous heroes WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18947 15259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AfricaHacks User:Spicy 23:50, 7 September 2020 (UTC) delete all of the sources are affiliated with the company, or merely name-drop the company in passing, or do not even mention the company at all. Nothing better found through Deletion of AfricaHacks WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
18948 20792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maziar Zand User:FreeRangeFrog 00:38, 25 February 2009 (UTC) delete With some regrets, but fails . After going through all the references and doing some Google work, the man appears to have a presence online but no third-party sources that could possibly establish notability. He seems gifted, but then all of those links he has on there also showcase people who are as gifted as him who are not profiled by Wikipedia. Maybe later Deletion of Maziar Zand WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18949 19396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magnus Børmark User:William 19:15, 8 November 2005 (UTC) merge """useful info with Gåte or delete. Per 5, band must be """"extremely notable"""" for musician to qualify independently""" Deletion of Magnus Børmark WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18950 227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jared Blake User:GlenerationX 06:40, 24 June 2012 (UTC) keep """Criterion 9 states clearly """"Has won or placed in a major music competition."""" In Ten Pound Hammer's first statement he agrees that the artist """"Placed"""" in a TV show. Being one of the highest ranking shows on NBC would certainly classify The Voice as a major music competition. Has won or placed in a major music competition""" Deletion of Jared Blake WP:MUS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18951 16673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jade Marcela (2nd nomination) User:Suastiastu 13:53, 24 July 2015 (UTC) keep Does meet unless Indonesian media does not count Deletion of Jade Marcela (2nd nomination) WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18952 7788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Autocoitus User:Ohconfucius 09:42, 1 February 2007 (UTC) delete """per . It'll never replace the popularity of """"go screw yourself"""", so let's delete it here and now""" Deletion of Autocoitus WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18953 11571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of celebrity hairdressers User:Colonel 22:56, 3 October 2012 (UTC) keep See the ''http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=9Z6vCGbf66YC&pg=PA164 Encyclopedia of Hair: A Cultural History'' for an example of encyclopedic coverage of famous hairdressers, from Antoine de Paris to Vidal Sassoon. The topic therefore passes Deletion of List of celebrity hairdressers WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
18954 4482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muse fans' boycott User:Ben 12:52, 10 April 2011 (UTC) comment Please, could you cite from the article where it is about ''... social consciousness...'' and ''... representatives from various countries...'' and ''... may eventually develop...''? and Thanks Deletion of Muse fans' boycott WP:INDEPTH||WP:EFFECT Wikipedia:Notability 77
18955 10724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Screaming Banshee Aircrew User:Scottywong 21:19, 9 April 2013 (UTC) merge Hoping for more input from non- editors Deletion of Screaming Banshee Aircrew WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
18956 5431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barack Obama's first 100 days User:Grsz11 19:37, 19 January 2009 (UTC) delete a major violation Deletion of Barack Obama's first 100 days WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18957 437 [[Eugen Pierer]] (LA entfernt) Benutzer:Wo st 01 NONE delete Die |Relevanz des Lexikons färbt nicht auf diesen Herren ab, der lediglich seine Arbeit gemacht hat Löschung von Eugen Pierer Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
18958 4952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cycles per byte user:Andrew 19:01, 4 September 2019 (UTC) keep """Per , this is the """"''perennial source of confusion is that a stub encyclopedia article looks very much like a dictionary entry, and stubs are often poorly written; another is that some paper dictionaries, such as """"pocket"""" dictionaries, lead users to the mistaken belief that dictionary entries are short, and that short article and dictionary entry are therefore equivalent.''"""" The stub can quite readily be expanded from sources such as https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=VaiYIZHduXQC&pg=PA240 Cryptography for Developers""" Deletion of Cycles per byte WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
18959 2510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sleepy's User:Bearian 01:22, 17 November 2009 (UTC) keep possibly one of the two or three |best known bedding stores in the United States, with hundreds of locations Deletion of Sleepy's WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
18960 421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Elconin User:Studerby 08:15, 19 March 2010 (UTC) delete concur. Clearly for deleted content. On the outside chance that |reliable sources establishing |notability have appeared since that AFD 5 months ago (just before publication), I'd suggest letting it run the full 5 days though Deletion of Dan Elconin WP:COATRACK||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
18961 14713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manchester United F.C. 7–1 Blackburn Rovers F.C. User:Giants2008 23:18, 3 December 2010 (UTC) delete For to not apply, individual sports games/matches should have some evidence that they themselves are notable. In soccer (upset American here), any kind of cup final would have notability, as would something like England v United States (1950)|this that has often been written about in reliable sources through the years. (not just in the aftermath of the game, or else every game would be notable). There appears to be nothing notable about this match by Wikipedia standards. It was a blowout, but that's all Deletion of Manchester United F.C. 7–1 Blackburn Rovers F.C. WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18962 5771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sharon Lebewohl User:K 05:12, 6 October 2018 (UTC) keep meets per review of available sources Deletion of Sharon Lebewohl WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
18963 370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam O'Hirsi User:Coredesat 09:14, 26 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails - only 4 unique Google hits Deletion of Adam O'Hirsi WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
18964 6274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hayling Musical Society User:SL93 17:05, 26 December 2011 (UTC) delete Despite it being around for a long time, it fails Deletion of Hayling Musical Society WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18965 19738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/T. Rafael Cimino [[User talk:SarekOfVulcan|SarekOfVulcan (talk)]] 16:18, 11 August 2011 (UTC) delete assertions are not supported by eliable sources Deletion of T. Rafael Cimino WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
18966 6388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oliver Farid User:Sam 13:18, 12 November 2015 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Oliver Farid WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
18967 319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of starships in Stargate User:Shooterwalker 20:53, 22 November 2012 (UTC) delete because #PLOT. Articles need sufficient context, not just a recap of various plot elements, no matter how novel or interesting it might be to extract those plot elements (in this case, ships). That context can only come from reliable sources that can . And even if we could, it's not to say we would need a list of every ship above and beyond a short description of the ships as a whole Deletion of List of starships in Stargate WP:NOT||WP:verify notability Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18968 7102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Affections (band) User:Hobbes 01:16, 16 January 2012 (UTC) delete I would recommend reading the http://www.bluepierecords.com/featured-artists.php?artist_id=328 linked record company bio. It paints a picture of an Aussie pub band from the early 80s that failed to become notable. No albums, one single released, with no evidence of sales or airplay. Other than the record company bio, no sources provided, and seemingly nothing substantial from a source from web search. Fails Deletion of The Affections (band) WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18969 838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Okey Uzoeshi User:Miniapolis 23:33, 30 September 2015 (UTC) delete per nom; although it's important to |AGF, SPAs often do have COIs with the subjects of their articles Deletion of Okey Uzoeshi WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
18970 7573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Damaris Lewis User:Ravenswing 19:00, 23 November 2010 (UTC) delete """By what definition is that, Tony? I don't see any guideline explicitly giving a presumption of notability for models in SI, and I'd sure be grateful if you could link to it. Beyond that, the whole underpinning of notability criteria beyond the GNG is that the criteria establish """"presumptive"""" notability, in so far that (for example) someone who plays in the National Hockey League almost certainly has had articles written about him in the mainstream press. Ms. Lewis certainly appears on a lot of modeling sites, Flickr, social media, blogs and the like, but that hasn't translated into any coverage of her in substantial detail on any source, in the year-plus since the issue in which she appeared. Fails , """ Deletion of Damaris Lewis WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18971 2092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation User:JimMillerJr 18:15, 4 November 2009 (UTC) keep I have found, and added, several news sources discussing this foundation. Clearly passes due to extensive news coverage over the past 16 years Deletion of Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18972 21326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The People's Cube User:Fortuna 15:40, 9 January 2017 (UTC) delete This appears to have been exciting! -but, unnecessarilly so. is perfecly clear: It has to be {{green|the subject of multiple non-trivial published works}}- and not {{green|trivial coverage, such as: a brief summary of the nature of the content}} in the sources. Unfortunately, that is all we have here- as they only give (at most) {{green|a brief summary of the nature of the content}}. No or of coverage, and no major awards, etc., won either, which is another relevant condition. Hence this article fails both generally and particularly. Cheers Deletion of The People's Cube WP:WEBCRIT||WP:DEPTH||WP:PERSISTENCE||WP:GNG||WP:NWEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18973 134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of towns in Central Province, Sri Lanka NONE NONE comment I was thinking starting an AfD, not just this list but also for other provincial lists. I believe List of towns in Sabaragamuwa, and List of towns in Western Province, Sri Lanka meet |CSD A3 criteria. I found several issues are there common to all 9 provincial articles Deletion of List of towns in Central Province, Sri Lanka WP:A3 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18974 2085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blane Covert User:Nilfanion 13:19, 1 October 2006 (UTC) delete both. An unpublished book might be notable if sufficiently important, but a collection of literature by a nn author? The author isn't yet notable and the book article is #Wikipedia is not a crystal ball|crystal balling even if it is verifiable, after all who knows what will happen in editing Deletion of Blane Covert WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18975 6798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Kucinich (3rd nomination) User:Umbralcorax 19:33, 22 March 2010 (UTC) keep Meets the |GNG, and has enough separate notability to justify an article separate from her husband Deletion of Elizabeth Kucinich (3rd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18976 3723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bud, Not Buddy (film) User:Chris 16:07, 28 December 2011 (UTC) delete I checked over the |criteria for speedy deletion, and I'm not sure which one this would fall under, but it is quite blatant violation of Deletion of Bud, Not Buddy (film) WP:CSD||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
18977 411 [[Blutelektrifikation]] (zum zweiten Mal nach SLA gelöscht) Benutzer:Gleiberg 09:41, 11. Okt. 2006 (CEST) delete Das Posten von meterlangen Texten aus den verlinkten Quellen ist kaum hilfreich bei einer LD. Die vorgeblichen Quellen belegen für mich nur die Auffassung eines ''Fakes'', daher sollte man diesen Artikel auch als solchen bezüglich der Löschkriterien behandeln. Das Vorgehen bei der von Universaldilettant angeführte /28._Juli_2006#GeoWave-Welle_.28gel.C3.B6scht.29|Löschdiskussion als Vorbild nehmend, ist wie dort nach einer solchen Diskussion ein zu stellen Löschung von Blutelektrifikation Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
18978 12880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/If You Could See Me Now (Oscar Peterson album) User:AllyD 16:30, 14 November 2018 (UTC) keep The sources and award identified above by {{u|Michig}} above are sufficient to demonstrate that criteria 1 and 4 are met Deletion of If You Could See Me Now (Oscar Peterson album) :WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
18979 20488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tytania User:Stifle 18:48, 8 February 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Tytania WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18980 415 [[Bahnhof Dortmund-Kirchderne]] (gelöscht) Benutzerin:CaroFraTyskland NONE delete Für beide : Per gilt: „Erfüllt ein Thema die nachfolgenden Kriterien nicht, so muss das nicht zwingend zum Ausschluss dieses Artikelgegenstands führen, es müssen dann aber andere stichhaltige Argumente für dessen Relevanz angeführt werden.“ Die RKs für den Schienenverkehr sind nicht erfüllt, als Belege gibt es nicht wirklich was Externes (z. T. auch Sachen, die auch gemäß WP:Belege eher wenig geeignet sind), was auf enzyklopädische Relevanz hinweisen würde. Wirklich stichhaltige Argumente für Behalten, die sich konkret auf die Artikel beziehen und über „gibt es auch in anderen Sprachversionen“ und „dann wäre Artikel xy auch nicht relevant“, finde ich hier eher keine Löschung von Bahnhof Dortmund-Kirchderne Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
18981 15805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Trek: Enterprise alleged continuity problems (third nomination) User:Sandstein 18:15, 14 June 2006 (UTC) delete pure fancruft, sorry Deletion of Star Trek: Enterprise alleged continuity problems (third nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
18982 15073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conrad Mieschke (2nd nomination) User:Rpclod 12:23, 19 April 2015 (UTC) delete No | reliable sources and no real | notability even if verifiable Deletion of Conrad Mieschke (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
18983 10445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Langit Ng Pag-ibig User:JamesBurns 08:26, 9 March 2009 (UTC) delete notability not established Deletion of Langit Ng Pag-ibig WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18984 815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hashim Lafond User:No 13:30, 13 April 2016 (UTC) delete Does not meet and does not meet . The roles in notable films have not been significant, and general coverage is non-existent Deletion of Hashim Lafond WP:BASIC||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
18985 2508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atop the Fourth Wall: The Movie User:MichaelQSchmidt 09:28, 11 May 2015 (UTC) delete for now as simply being |TOO SOON and failing . It mmight nerit a mention over at the Lewis Lovhaug article, but not a separate article. allow undeletion or recreation once filming begins and if it gets the requisite media coverage Deletion of Atop the Fourth Wall: The Movie WP:NYF||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
18986 14039 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theology of relational care User:Cindamuse 07:17, 18 June 2013 (UTC) keep """Article is supported by at least one source that uses the term """"theology of relational care"""" in the title, so I'm puzzled when TG says that the sources do not use the term. A https://www.google.com/search?num=20&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla%3Aen-US%3Aofficial&q=%22relational+care%22+theology+-wikipedia&oq=%22relational+care%22+theology+-wikipedia&gs_l=serp.3...36574.39191.0.39938.11.11.0.0.0.0.101.802.10j1.11.0.ernk_timediscountc..0.0...1.1.17.serp.O2bOBNjPov8 search for additional sources returns numerous possibilities with which to support notability, while expanding the article. With all sincere respect, it appears as though the article was not afforded a |thorough review prior to nomination""" Deletion of Theology of relational care WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
18987 5657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti Dogmatism User:Guy 05:06, 14 May 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Anti Dogmatism WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
18988 8178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anne Zetzsche User:Kraxler 13:41, 3 October 2015 (UTC) delete fails and , no sources in the article except ice-skating stats and dead links, web searches turn up http://www.salsa-und-tango.de/eiskunstlauf-ergebnis-grosser-berliner-baer-2014-und-bm-2015/55347/ this in December 2014, she was 3rd place (senior level) at the Open Berlin Figure Skating Championship (a national event Deletion of Anne Zetzsche WP:NSKATE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
18989 11258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammed Ibrahim (footballer) User:Feedintm 13:35, 25 March 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and ; no evidence of notability Deletion of Mohammed Ibrahim (footballer) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
18990 18819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arma Partners User:Callanecc 03:37, 6 September 2012 (UTC) delete As ECF said looks a little too much like an advert (which can be fixed), however after a good search I can't find anything which indicates it meets the WP|GNG or Deletion of Arma Partners WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
18991 14644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Ratzmann User:Dbtfz 04:12, 25 January 2006 (UTC) keep the guy is notable for the same reason Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold are. BTW, POV is not grounds for deletion; see Deletion of Terry Ratzmann WP:DP Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
18992 2548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TPG - Toilet Paper Gun User:Ahecht 18:42, 12 May 2014 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of TPG - Toilet Paper Gun WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
18993 17293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Open-E (company) User:Kostas20142 14:50, 14 April 2017 (UTC) delete as per nom and Deletion of Open-E (company) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18994 4460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Ibranyi [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 12:32, 16 June 2013 (UTC) delete fails , simple as that. Want to argue otherwise? Present |reliable sources that give the subject significant coverage, rather than bizarre conspiracy theories Deletion of Richard Ibranyi WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
18995 9103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Magic Camp User:ZimmerBarnes 22:38, 13 February 2007 (UTC) comment The blog isn't a blog, it's news footage, which should fix both and as it is supported by a major news agency, the Austin-American Statesman Deletion of The Magic Camp WP:N||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
18996 3906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hoes.com User:Satori 20:04, 7 August 2006 (UTC) delete As written, article does not provide info on subject that meets any of the three criteria in Deletion of Hoes.com WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
18997 7444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Town's Disaster User:Rwiggum 19:57, 11 July 2008 (UTC) keep The editor who nominated this page failed to create a discussion page, and I didn't want to just remove the warning from the page, so I went ahead and created the discussion page myself. Nonetheless, this article meets the criteria of usic. It is a notable release from a notable band that has gained substantial coverage from reliable, third-party publications, as is stated in the article. This nomination seems to be in bad faith Deletion of This Town's Disaster WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
18998 19673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Srbosjek (knife) (2nd nomination) User:Nsk92 18:59, 16 July 2008 (UTC) keep I have attempted to wade through the present AfD and the two previous ones. I am rather put off by the debate (POV pushing from delete proponents, socking from the keep proponents and a heavy dose of stuff). At the end of the day, my impression is that there are sufficient sources for the fairly wide use of the term Srbosjek. The English langiage sources mentioned in my comments above are OK and the pre-1990s yugoslavian sources mentioned by Terse appear to be OK (at least I am not willing to discount these sources without a lot more evidence of their unsuitability). Some of the content problems mentioned by the delete proponents can be rectified within the article itself (e.g. one can mention that some of the claims in the article are disputed Deletion of Srbosjek (knife) (2nd nomination) WP:BATTLE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
18999 823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheetster User:Stifle 23:52, 12 April 2006 (UTC) delete advert, refers Deletion of Sheetster WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
19000 88 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Kalamadım Kullanıcı:solidersolider 20.10, 1 Mayıs 2022 (UTC) comment ağırlıklı olarak halihazırda kalmasını düşünmekle birlikte yorumum şu şekilde; {{ping|Nedim Gayet Bir}}, içinde yer aldığı albümün bile müstakil maddesinin olmamasının nedeni albümün kayda değer olmaması değil maddenin açılmamış olmasıdır ki söz konusu albüm müzisyenin zamanında en çok sükse yapmış albümlerinden birisidir. Şablon:Yalın|Şablondaki 'Klipleri' alt bölmesinde aynı şekilde diğer video klipli şarkılara yönelik maddeler de var. Diğer müzisyenlerin de video klip çekilmiş şarkılarına ilişkin aynı durum mevcut. Bu şekilde birçok madde var. Bu maddeler özelinde KD durumunun yorumlanışı noktasında genel görüş birliği oluşmalı. Bu haliyle |KD: Müzik taşımıyor görünüyor ancak silinmesi yönünde görüş birliği oluştuğu takdirde şablondaki - diğer sanatçılara ait birçok şarkı da - diğer şarkıların da silinmesi durumu ortaya çıkabilecek. Eğer bu durum oluşacaksa, diğerleri maddeler de KD süzgecinden geçirilecekse ve genel görüş silinmesi yönünde oluşacaksa şayet silinsin Silme Kalamadım Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
19001 15494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deviance in modern film User:Doc 00:42, 9 May 2009 (UTC) delete WP:NOT#WEBSPACE|Wikipedia is not a place to post your homework. Also, its very |soapy and full of POV Deletion of Deviance in modern film WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19002 18277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keppel Gate, Isle of Man user:Andrew 19:27, 30 April 2017 (UTC) keep """Easily passes being a notable named feature. The page already has plenty of sourced detail and it's easy to find more such as the 1881 ''Tourist's picturesque guide to the Isle of Man'', """"The ascent from Douglas to the Keppel Gate is interesting in the extreme. It commands a magnificent view of Douglas and of the southern portions of the islands, and on the east of parts of the parish of Lonan; while from the Keppel Gate""" Deletion of Keppel Gate, Isle of Man WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19003 19999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zachary Laoutides (2nd nomination) User:Ambrosiawater 23:04, 20 July 2020 (UTC) keep Clearly meets and is definitely a notable filmmaker, director, and actor. Multiple awards such as Best Actor and Best Screenplay writer at the Bel Air Film Festival and a pretty good-sized filmography. Well sourced with ABC News references and more. This really looks like a keep to me Deletion of Zachary Laoutides (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19004 3561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesuit European Social Centre User:Newshunter12 10:02, 22 September 2018 (UTC) delete This article fails and for there is not enough to demonstrate the organization is notable, or much of any coverage for that matter. Wikipedia isn't the place to advertise non-notable charity groups either Deletion of Jesuit European Social Centre WP:NCORP||WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
19005 18846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1989 The Right Stuff User:Gongshow 17:13, 21 January 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find any in-depth coverage in |reliable sources for this compilation album; does not appear to meet Deletion of 1989 The Right Stuff WP:RS||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19006 20818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanha Jafrin User:Epinoia 01:14, 10 September 2019 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON - not enough of a notable career yet - hasn't had significant roles in multiple notable films per - I couldn't even find listings for her films (although language may have played a part there, but usually if foreign films are at all notable even a search in English will turn up something Deletion of Tanha Jafrin WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19007 2103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Monohull Open Classes Association User:Amisom 13:47, 19 January 2017 (UTC) keep per sources uncovered by {{user|Exemplo347}}. If they exist, then the subject meets the whether or not they are currently incorporated into the article: see eg. . Also a little perturbed by the sniping from {{ping|Tavix}}: we're all here to deliberate and discuss, let's cool it a bit Deletion of International Monohull Open Classes Association WP:GNG||WP:NOIMPROVEMENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19008 5168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Twingo snooker User:Batard0 12:13, 25 October 2012 (UTC) delete It's funny. But . Not a single reference on google books, google news or google. Indicates it may be . Misses all notability guidelines by a long way Deletion of Twingo snooker WP:ITSFUNNY||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
19009 19456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tamar Kintsurashvili User:Wikimandia 08:39, 15 May 2015 (UTC) keep more than sufficiently notable. http://www.civil.ge/geo/article.php?id=18018, http://reportiori.ge/index.php?menuid=3&id=20951, http://iliauni.edu.ge/ge/siaxleebi-8/gonisdziebebi-346/tamar-kinwurashvili-media-da-tolerantobis-sakitxebi.page, http://www.tabula.ge/ge/tv/religion/92056-saxelmtsifo-media-da-diskriminacia-tamar-kintsurashvili, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ZEzl00zdJw, http://www.mdfgeorgia.ge/geo/view_gallery/243, etc. I've added her name in Georgian to her page. Nominator is kindly reminded to check native language sources prior to AfD as per Deletion of Tamar Kintsurashvili WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19010 5092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Randall (serial killer) User:Edison 21:30, 16 September 2009 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not a directory of every ordinary criminal. See NEWS as well. A crime or criminal gets a slash of news coverage, but is not suitable for an encyclopedia unless it has wider consequences, like new laws (such as Megan's Law or the Amber Alert), or secondary coverage like books or movies (such as In Cold Blood Deletion of James Randall (serial killer) WP:NOT||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19011 928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Cleveland Drew User:Bearcat 16:48, 15 August 2019 (UTC) delete """State circuit court is not an automatic free pass over our notability standards for judges, but the article is not |reliably sourced for the purposes of getting him over the bar he would actually have to clear — as usual for Billy Hathorn content, it is """"referenced"""" to a mix of unreliable sources that are not support for notability at all, clarifying notes that aren't actually references of any sort, and purely tangential referencing of stray biographical facts about his family members, with no evidence whatsoever of ''reliable source'' coverage about ''him""" Deletion of Richard Cleveland Drew WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19012 18725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian Fox User:Bearian 01:32, 1 March 2020 (UTC) delete per . My understanding of organists is that they need to be lead/head organist at a major church, cathedral, or university chapel to be notable Deletion of Ian Fox WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19013 15037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeremy Adams User:Cindamuse 03:37, 3 February 2012 (UTC) keep I've done significant work on cleaning and formatting this article. I removed the hobby genealogist's family trees, reformatted gbook refs, and added an infobox. The number of references are significant for an individual that lived 400 years ago. He is the documented founder and proprietor of Hartford and Colchester. I recognize the asserted significance and notability supported through reliable and independent sources. Recommend retaining the article in accordance with the |general notability guidelines. Best regards Deletion of Jeremy Adams WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19014 9705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riecoin User:Citation 03:13, 28 February 2014 (UTC) delete this coin falls flat on it's ass faster than Bitcoin's own market value in terms of WP:GNG. Prime example of Deletion of Riecoin WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19015 2577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tomas Lasansky User:Northamerica1000 10:44, 13 August 2016 (UTC) keep Meets on a weak level. The subject has received in-depth, significant coverage in two sources (http://www.aspentimes.com/article/20080223/ASPENWEEKLY03/796843832 ''The Aspen Times'', http://www.southbendtribune.com/entertainment/inthebend/eventnews/lasansky-exhibit-highlights-father-s-influence/article_73e9f9a3-08c0-5af8-93ab-99d119656769.html ''South Bend Tribune''), and coverage beyond passing mentions in the University of Notre Dame's http://sniteartmuseum.nd.edu/exhibitions/past-exhibitions/2015-exhibitions/mauricio-and-tomas-lasansky-br-father-and-son/ Snite Museum of Art. For what it's worth, the subject is also mentioned at the Oxford Dictionary of American Art and Artists (https://books.google.com/books?id=VxsTDAAAQBAJ&pg=PA274&dq=%22Tomas+Lasansky%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiW7v6Sm77OAhVE2WMKHVP5Dz0Q6AEIHjAA#v=onepage&q=%22Tomas%20Lasansky%22&f=false link Deletion of Tomas Lasansky WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19016 19212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rapist User:Evb 12:10, 20 August 2007 (UTC) merge per nom. Completely , a bit , and provides no Deletion of Rapist WP:OR||WP:POV||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
19017 18244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeAndre Harris User:Icewhiz 05:28, 20 October 2017 (UTC) keep but '''Rename''' to Unite the Right Car Park Fight (or to ''beating of...'' - might be issues with taking a sides here prior to legal proceedings ending seeing there are charges on both sides). The '''incident''' is notable (and in light of later legal proceedings - makes sense to spin out from Unite the Right. Harris is not. Per - the appropriate course of action is to create an article on the incident. Some bio information on Harris should probably be redacted, and some information of the other people involved should be added Deletion of DeAndre Harris WP:NCRIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
19018 21381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Renee Hoagenson User:Bearcat 17:10, 25 November 2019 (UTC) delete People do not get Wikipedia articles just for being candidates in elections they did not win — the notability test per is ''holding'' a notable political office, not just running for one. To qualify for an article, rather, she would have to demonstrate one or the other of two things: either (a) she was ''already'' notable enough for other reasons ''besides'' the candidacy that she would ''already'' have gotten an article on those grounds ''anyway'' (i.e. Cynthia Nixon), or (b) she can be referenced to such an ''unusual'' degree of coverage, nationalizing and deepening ''far'' beyond what just ''every'' candidate in ''every'' election can ''always'' show, that her candidacy has a credible claim to being ''much more special'' than everybody else's candidacies (i.e. Christine O'Donnell). But this claims literally nothing that would fulfill the former, and is not sourced nearly well enough to pass the latter Deletion of Renee Hoagenson WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19019 10103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wheeler Ridge Interchange User:Charlesdrakew 10:24, 16 December 2015 (UTC) delete Having a name does not confer notability. Fails , Deletion of Wheeler Ridge Interchange WP:GNG||WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19020 7986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sharika Raina User:CAPTAIN 19:47, 5 April 2017 (UTC) delete doesn't meet Deletion of Sharika Raina WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19021 11599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coloring India Foundation User:NitinMlk 21:37, 31 May 2018 (UTC) delete fails & . Both of the previous !votes are based on the two cited sources – http://www.thehindu.com/features/metroplus/For-a-perfect-stroke/article14399295.ece & http://www.newindianexpress.com/cities/bengaluru/2016/jul/07/Sip-a-chai-pencil-a-portrait-878083.html. But both of these sources are advertisements of the organization's workshops & they are filled with promotional statements from the organization's founders. In short, they fail IND. We need independent & in-depth coverage for notability which is totally missing here. In fact, leaving behind these two adverts, I couldn't find any coverage of this organization in reliable sources Deletion of Coloring India Foundation WP:ORG||WP:GNG||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19022 9873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Se-jeong (singer) User:Tavix 14:40, 2 October 2016 (UTC) keep She's done a lot more than just present for a television show, and meets #6 by being a part of two notable groups Deletion of Kim Se-jeong (singer) WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19023 8090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xtreme Ice Skating (2nd nomination) [[User talk:Ravendrop|Ravendrop]] 01:03, 10 July 2013 (UTC) delete """The """"sport"""" (I use that term generously) is clearly not notable. Essentially all references calling it """"Xtreme Ice Skating"""" are self-published. The page is also clearly an advertisement for the """"creator's"""" business/webpage and their (not yet available?) skates, not to mention a serious issue. The claim of this """"sport"""" being invented in 2005 is also laughable, as these types of jumps, spins, etc. have been around for many years (i.e. figure skating, but also acrobatic skating/extreme skating, which is often seen in ice shows) and the only thing unique i the name/business which the author is trying to promote. Finally, as it has only 14 participants, according to http://www.xtremeiceskating.com/registrants.htm this page, it has hardly reached the level of participation to even start to remotely be considered notable""" Deletion of Xtreme Ice Skating (2nd nomination) WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
19024 615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Schuck User:JFHJr 03:41, 28 September 2011 (UTC) delete Having cleaned up the article for several blatant problems with basic guidelines for encyclopedic articles (, , , , to name a few) notability isn't met at this time. Even the subject's involvement in a startup company or a development team needs to be underpinned by notability. It looks like only Google has it, and that doesn't approach the guidelines: 1) not to be overly cynical, but we only have Google to cite, which is |problematic; and 2) we still don't have multiple, reliable, third party sources on the subject Deletion of Adam Schuck WP:NN||WP:BIO||WP:SOURCE||WP:BLP||WP:SOURCE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19025 2518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashli Babbitt User:Muboshgu 17:39, 7 January 2021 (UTC) delete as meeting the criteria of that says not to give her an article. – Deletion of Ashli Babbitt WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19026 9829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Biology Open (journal) NONE NONE delete no mentions YET. may be notable in the future; Deletion of Biology Open (journal) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
19027 2517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cold War II User:Hawkeye7 20:33, 5 November 2015 (UTC) keep Agree with {{u|Artw}} that the title is a terrible , and may well be renamed in due course, but that does not alter the fact that passes . It could be considered a subarticle of Foreign policy of Vladimir Putin but that article is bursting at the seams and has already quite rightly spawned a number of subarticles. Not a , so no grounds for deletion Deletion of Cold War II WP:NEO||WP:GNG||WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
19028 17453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trevor Mills (2nd nomination) User:Operator873 00:50, 25 November 2017 (UTC) delete Fails . Three indie albums made, but no independent coverage or other avenues to . Difficult to find any reference to this musician become graphic designer Deletion of Trevor Mills (2nd nomination) WP:BAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19029 13031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Other Side of the Game User:Gosox5555 22:09, 5 August 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. and Deletion of Other Side of the Game WP:NOTCRYSTAL||WP:NF Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19030 7204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teabag (billiards game) User:Shadowlynk 06:43, 5 September 2007 (UTC) delete per as original prod2er. Earlier revisions of the article state it was made up by New Zealand college students, which was removed when the prods were. No sources in the article, and Web searches have turned up nothing Deletion of Teabag (billiards game) WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
19031 15747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Traffic Ramasamy (film) User:The 15:10, 9 June 2018 (UTC) delete This is clearly part of the |promotional campaign of the subject film. No independent notability is established. Rid us of it Deletion of Traffic Ramasamy (film) WP:NOTADVERTISEMENT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19032 91 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Kaya Türkmen Kullanıcı:yzkocyzkoc 17.50, 25 Nisan 2021 (UTC) keep Milletvekilliği yapmış, büyükelçilik yapmış gereği kayda değer Kaya Türkmen'in silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
19033 7425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Rapid Development User:WikiDan61 20:29, 26 September 2013 (UTC) delete Relying only on the primary text itself, any summarization or extraction of meaning can only be considered |original research Deletion of The Rapid Development WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19034 18131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Rose User:Krash 01:41, 9 March 2006 (UTC) delete WP:VAIN|Vanity. |Not notable. Wikipedia:Importance|Unimportant. -- Deletion of Alexander Rose WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19035 3360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Equatorial Guinea at the 2009 Lusophony Games User:AbstractIllusions 13:39, 2 January 2017 (UTC) delete For new events like the Lusophony Games, the best use to the reader seems to be fewer, focused articles rather than sprawling linked-to articles that become more like a |directory than a coherent article. I did searches on four of these (Angola, Mozambique, Sao Tome, and Equatorial Guinea) in Lexis, Proquest, and Newsbank and can't make a case for any coverage transcending outine and couldn't find any. Delete is warranted in terms of 1. GNG coverage standard and 2. Best help to readers/editors Deletion of Equatorial Guinea at the 2009 Lusophony Games WP:NOTDIR||WP:R Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19036 21894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Petranker User:Wikipeterproject 23:37, 30 January 2010 (UTC) delete Clear case of |promotion Deletion of David Petranker WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19037 19434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fluff in Brooklyn User:Kinu 01:44, 2 October 2006 (UTC) delete """per all above and my original PROD (""""non-notable web comic. No third-party indicating notability. Fails ; Alexa rank 3,438,073""" Deletion of Fluff in Brooklyn WP:RS||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19038 21386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Constitution of the Free Republic of Liberland User:Coolabahapple 20:42, 13 July 2015 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet . search brings up lots of news about the micronation and some trivial mentions that there is a constitution but nothing else. Article's references are to the constitution itself and a press release. Also only edits of one month old article creator is this article (except for 1 edit linking from article about micronation) which should have gone through afc, and would not have made it onto mainspace Deletion of Constitution of the Free Republic of Liberland WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19039 14038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Woznica User:Capitalistroadster 04:45, 11 November 2005 (UTC) delete as silly Wikipedia:Vandalism|vandalism as outlined in category G3. Silly vandalism is a joke page. As this man is credited with responsibility for the Russian revolution, the Cuban revolution and the Stalinist purges as well as cures for the Spanish influenza it is clearly nonsense Deletion of Alex Woznica WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
19040 3418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yehuda Farkas User:Onebravemonkey 09:48, 2 November 2006 (UTC) delete per . I've had a good go at verifying this and haven't been able to find anything substantial Deletion of Yehuda Farkas WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19041 18290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yakub Abahanov User:Stifle 10:41, 10 April 2008 (UTC) delete Not notable by himself. Another article about an arbitrary GB detainee. See #SOAPBOX and Deletion of Yakub Abahanov WP:NOT||WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19042 12369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Upton User:Papaursa 20:48, 7 August 2017 (UTC) delete Still another hockey player who fails and because they've never played at the top level of their sport Deletion of David Upton WP:GNG||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
19043 14239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ekpyrotek User:WebHamster 18:56, 4 September 2007 (UTC) comment """How difficult is it to read and digest , and ? Then look at the criteria they set out that is needed for inclusion in Wikipedia. Then extrapolate the differences between those articles and the article under discussion. If it meets the criteria then it stays, if it doesn't then it goes. It's not subjective, the guidelines don't respond to """"please"""" or new-age rhetoric. If I can figure it out then I'm pretty sure most people can. Canvassing for sympathy won't elicit anything but lectures like this one. If the article's subject is notable (using the accepted criteria) then prove it; if he isn't then wait until he is and create another article. These are the guidelines we all have to follow, why do you feel this article and its creator should be different""" Deletion of Ekpyrotek WP:N||WP:BIO||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19044 1643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valley of Decapitated Horses User:Ihcoyc 15:32, 19 December 2007 (UTC) delete In case you're curious, this is about a band (got to point that out, folks! I thought for a minute that this might be a real estate development named by someone whose thoughts run free in the same fields as mine.) The instant article contains little outside information confirming notability per . If it ain't on any of the metal sites, it may well be a hoax Deletion of Valley of Decapitated Horses WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19045 4436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eveda User:Eveda 17:02, 16 March 2009 (UTC) delete WP:V|Verifiable |notability comes before Wikipedia article, not the other way around (particularly when there are POV and issues too Deletion of Eveda WP:N||WP:NPOV||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
19046 2495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Schoyen User:RoySmith 20:30, 29 September 2018 (UTC) delete Promotional puff-piece created by a . Amazing it lasted this long Deletion of Christian Schoyen WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
19047 11078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crush (Pendulum song) [[User talk:137.122.49.102|talk]]) 18:42, 15 October 2010 (UTC) delete per and .--Special:Contributions/137.122.49.102|137.122.49.102 Deletion of Crush (Pendulum song) WP:NSONGS||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19048 17576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Briscoe User:Smartyllama 14:45, 2 August 2017 (UTC) keep Per the excellent research showing he passes . |AFD is not cleanup. The current state is irrelevant Deletion of James Briscoe WP:NFOOTY||WP:AFDISNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19049 703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Growing Out (film) User:Blathnaid 20:05, 24 February 2008 (UTC) delete Fails , as there is no coverage in reliable sources Deletion of Growing Out (film) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19050 20692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sir John Wright (2nd nomination) User:GretLomborg 18:23, 13 May 2019 (UTC) delete per , and a failure to meet . Seems like a minor figure who's only claim to notability is a distant ancestor Deletion of Sir John Wright (2nd nomination) WP:NOTGENEOLOGY||WP:INVALIDBIO||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19051 6935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PepperTap (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 23:19, 29 June 2017 (UTC) keep or '''Merge to List of online grocers''' – Meets and . Also, whether or not a company is defunct is not associated with topic notability, as per . See also: . However, this content could also be merged to the List of online grocers article Deletion of PepperTap (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:NTEMP||WP:OUTOFBUSINESS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19052 13064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of watch manufacturers User:Meshach 21:08, 18 November 2006 (UTC) delete as #Wikipedia_is_not_an_indiscriminate_collection_of_information|pointless list. There is no encyclopedic value is providing a list of links Deletion of List of watch manufacturers WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19053 18502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saif Group User:HighKing 14:59, 3 October 2017 (UTC) delete """I've checked the 9 references added to the article. Normally Forbes is a poor source for references but in https://www.forbes.com/global/2009/0921/companies-pakistan-saif-group-drilling-amid-taliban.html this case there at first glance, appears to be a substantial independent article that meets the criteria for establishing notability. The first problem is that the article mostly concerns the activities of Saif Energy and not the holding company, Saif Group (the subject of this topic), although later on in the article the contributor switches to talk about Saif Group. The second problem is that halfway through the article, we start to see quotations from Javed Khan, an officer of the company. That would call into question the intellectual independence of the article and I would say it fails the criteria () on that basis. The http://nation.com.pk/lahore/03-Dec-2013/rs22-2m-for-balochistan-quake-survivors reference from nation.com.pk fails as it is a mere mention in passing and has no indepth details. http://pakistan-stocks.blogspot.ie/2012/11/saif-saif-textile-mills-limited.html the pakistan-stocks.blogspot.ie reference fails for many reasons - it is a blog and therefore not a reliable source, but it is also a normal business listing and fails too. Similarly, http://www.pagespak.com/company-textile_spinning_mills-saif_textile_mills_ltd_-islamabad-560304.html the pagespak.com reference fails as it is a mere listing. The http://fp.brecorder.com/2013/09/201309141230946/ brecorder.com reference fails and/or as it is based on a company announcement and is not intellectually independent. The following three references fail as they are from the saifgroup website and therefore are a PRIMARY source. The https://www.dawn.com/news/1159590 dawn.com reference is an obituary for the """"patron of Saif Group"""" and fails as it is a mere mention-in-passing. Finally, https://www.pakistantoday.com.pk/2012/02/08/saif-group-of-companies-chairman-joins-pti/ the pakistantoday.com reference fails as it is also a mention in passing. I'd be happy to reconsider my !vote if two references that meet the criteria for establishing notability can be found""" Deletion of Saif Group WP:ORGIND||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
19054 16169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atticus Mitchell User:Cntras 02:39, 24 July 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Atticus Mitchell WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19055 491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kristina Pimenova User:Deathlibrarian 11:19, 9 June 2016 (UTC) delete """Fails Not notable - references seem to relate to the one event where she was called """"the most beuatiful girl in the world""" Deletion of Kristina Pimenova WP:NMODEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19056 6721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Athena School of Management [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 03:29, 19 November 2012 (UTC) delete """all sources are either from the subject school, its commercial affiliates or from social networking sites. A long way from having enough """"significant coverage"""" to meet """ Deletion of Athena School of Management WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
19057 6785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexandros Dimgkiokas User:Fenix 17:31, 19 March 2018 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Alexandros Dimgkiokas WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19058 9901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Symbiont (company) User:HighKing 11:25, 14 October 2020 (UTC) delete """As per , references should contain |significant coverage with |in-depth information *on the company* and (this bit is important!) containing |""""Independent Content"""". """"Independent content"""", in order to count towards establishing notability, must include ''original and independent opinion, analysis, investigation, and fact checking that are clearly attributable to a source unaffiliated to the subject''. None of the references meets this criteria as the content is invariably sourced back to the company. There is no independent opinion with in-depth information on the company. Topic fails GNG/NCORP""" Deletion of Symbiont (company) WP:ORGIND||WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19059 6130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Papanasam (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 05:40, 27 August 2014 (UTC) keep per production of this filming-and-currently-unreleased film meeting notability guidelines. To {{u|NickCT}} with respects, take a look at | (paragraph 3 Deletion of Papanasam (film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19060 2198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FADVOCAT User:LittleOldMe 12:58, 20 March 2008 (UTC) delete It seems that the primary author also has a |conflict of interest Deletion of FADVOCAT WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
19061 16676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hikuta (2nd nomination) User:Umbralcorax 20:04, 4 February 2009 (UTC) comment Looks like its already up for a speedy delete (|G4), I can't find anything to argue with that Deletion of Hikuta (2nd nomination) WP:G4 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
19062 8782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alt-right User:EvergreenFir 21:06, 10 May 2016 (UTC) keep SYNTH and UNDUE are not -REASON|valid deletion criteria. If you intend to argue for , I strongly disagree. There seems to be enough sources and coverage to have an independent article. The nomination makes no valid argument (e.g., notability, verifyability, etc.) for deletion Deletion of Alt-right WP:DEL||WP:NUKEANDPAVE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19063 6608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C9orf3 User:Dpmuk 11:17, 4 September 2008 (UTC) comment """I have informed the editors who have already contributed to this page that I've added the above comment using the text """"I thought you might be interested to know that I have posted a longer reason as to why I think this gene should be deleted which I did not, through niavity, include in my original arguement"""". I have read and believe that this is allowable under that policy. I have not posted on Stormie's or John254's talk pages as it's clear that they've read the DRV and thus aware of my arguement""" Deletion of C9orf3 WP:CANVASS Wikipedia:Canvassing 93
19064 9976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Garia User:Northamerica1000 03:28, 26 July 2015 (UTC) keep Appears to meet the first point of Deletion of New Garia WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19065 4753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/La migra (game) User:TenPoundHammer 20:43, 5 August 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of La migra (game) WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
19066 9943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of female racing drivers User:Northamerica1000 19:42, 4 February 2016 (UTC) keep Qualifies for an article per relative to :Category:Female racing drivers. Also qualifies as a functional navigational aid per . Also, allow time for potential expansion; this was nominated for deletion less than an hour after it was created Deletion of List of female racing drivers WP:NOTDUP||WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
19067 8984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave Kilminster User:Yanksox 03:56, 10 July 2006 (UTC) keep meets notability by satisfying , salute to Messedrocker for being bold in removing the text Deletion of Dave Kilminster WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19068 16871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aziz tarak User:CAPTAIN 20:23, 13 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Aziz tarak WP:GNG||WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
19069 17850 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The """"Scramble & Gamble""""""" User:Terraxos 03:24, 6 February 2008 (UTC) delete see #NEWS, Wikipedia:Recentism. This doesn't seem to me yet notable enough for its own page; hence, it shouldn't have its own article unless there's some evidence of ''long-term'' notability. A merge into the main Superbowl article might be best, as that way it can always be moved out again if it becomes independently notable """Deletion of The """"Scramble & Gamble""""""" WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19070 17717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of former members of the United States House of Representatives User:Dhartung 20:11, 3 August 2007 (UTC) comment Valadius, given that the information has been separated into subarticles, what is your position on that? I think it's a reasonable article but I prefer it split up in some fashion. (Noting that we already have articles such as everything on {{tl|US Congress by state}}, although I have no idea of their completeness, so that option is already taken care of.) Although I'm in favor of keeping the information, though, realize that |effort isn't a keep rationale, unfortunately Deletion of List of former members of the United States House of Representatives WP:EFFORT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
19071 12358 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J. P. McMeekin User:Snottywong 01:04, 20 May 2010 (UTC) delete Appears to have local notability, but not much more than that. If anyone has any sources that prove otherwise (and can satisfy ), now would be the time to produce them Deletion of J. P. McMeekin WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
19072 15636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Sutherland (headmaster) User:David 06:52, 5 April 2020 (UTC) delete Nothing here shows that he was known outside of Wick. It's possible that there's some notability through his book ''War diary of the Fifth Seaforth Highlanders'' but if so I haven't been able to find it (and I would need multiple books with multiple published reviews each before being convinced of a pass of Deletion of David Sutherland (headmaster) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19073 11388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JRiver Media Center User:A 19:40, 24 October 2017 (UTC) keep Doing a turns up https://www.stereophile.com/search/node/jriver countless hits in ''Stereophile'' magazine, among https://www.computeraudiophile.com/ca/ca-academy/streaming-around-the-globe-or-around-the-home-with-jriver-media-center/ other sources. This seems like the media software of choice for hi-fi nerds, which would explain why the article has been here since 2005 Deletion of JRiver Media Center WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19074 19413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antonio Chiumiento User:Eric 14:51, 20 October 2013 (UTC) delete Could not find enough to establish notability under . Does not seem to pass either. News coverage http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws&authuser=0&q=Antonio+Chiumiento not particularly impressive Deletion of Antonio Chiumiento WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19075 3602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walid Phares User:Twp 17:13, 10 April 2009 (UTC) delete """Problematic article made thornier by the strong possibility of |conflict of interest edits: repeated edits by {{user|Futureofterrorismproject}} (note that """"Future Jihad"""" appears to be one of Walid Phares' pet projects""" Deletion of Walid Phares WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
19076 19041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ridha Gataa User:Yunshui 10:17, 6 January 2012 (UTC) delete After a cursory check, doesn't appear to pass |the professor test. Open to changing !vote if sources in other languages are shown to exist Deletion of Ridha Gataa WP:BEFORE||WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19077 8980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MauBank WithMe User:4meter4 00:41, 3 March 2020 (UTC) delete Fails . All of the sources are too closely connected to the subject (ie press releases or paid for PR). My search yielded nothing to support notability Deletion of MauBank WithMe WP:SIGCOV||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19078 9609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cesar Del Penes User:Tevildo 11:51, 15 November 2009 (UTC) delete per nom. Almost certainly a hoax - and probably a fail of , even if the person existed Deletion of Cesar Del Penes WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19079 15699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edwin's hometown(film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 18:33, 4 October 2008 (UTC) delete with haste, per rystal and . A http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=edwin%27s+hometown%2C+tom+cruise search combinging the name with its rumoured major star finds nothhing except this blurb on wiki. Period Deletion of Edwin's hometown(film) WP:C||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
19080 20751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zoner, Inc. User:Michal 09:42, 4 September 2005 (UTC) comment """Zoner, Inc. is not a small """"garage"""" company. See google hits: http://www.google.com/search?num=50&hl=en&lr=&c2coff=1&q=%22Zoner%2C+Inc.%22&btnG=Search 993 hits for """"Zoner, Inc."""" http://www.google.com/search?num=50&hl=en&lr=&c2coff=1&q=%22Zoner+software%22&btnG=Search 131,000 hists for """"Zoner software"""" , http://www.google.com/search?num=50&hl=en&lr=&c2coff=1&q=Zoner&btnG=Search 962,000 for Zoner and #Wikipedia is not a propaganda machine, part Advertising""" Deletion of Zoner, Inc. WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19081 9028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Patrych User:Wm335td 22:11, 9 December 2019 (UTC) delete this does not pass Just passing mentions Deletion of Joseph Patrych WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19082 6149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mr. Monk and the Astronaut User:Sgeureka 08:51, 13 December 2010 (UTC) delete to Monk (season 4), ''do not keep'' as a separate article. Article contains only plot (#PLOT) and (in-universe) trivia in prose form. The actor Emmy was for a different episode, but even if it was for this episode, a one sentence blurb still fits in the LoE. No evidence of ABILITY for this episode otherwise. &ndash Deletion of Mr. Monk and the Astronaut WP:NOT||WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19083 7122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of gay, lesbian or bisexual people/No longer identified User:RGTraynor 16:41, 21 March 2007 (UTC) delete """per , , : Yikes, this is a potential lawsuit just waiting to happen. Per the """"aggressive deletion"""" clause in , I've just deleted out those entries in the article that were unsourced. Quite aside from all of that, what is the attribution, never mind the criteria, for calling some of those people gay/bi, and what is the attribution, never mind the criteria, for declaring any such """"no longer identified?"""" I hear what Otto's saying, but frankly, barring an attribution '''in print''' from a '''reliable source''' of one of these people saying """"I used to be gay but now I'm not,"""" any such citation is garbage""" Deletion of List of gay, lesbian or bisexual people/No longer identified WP:ATT||WP:BLP||WP:NPOV||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Attribution 108
19084 1101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Alquilar User:Hmlarson 17:55, 2 September 2016 (UTC) keep Criteria noted by nominating editor is no longer valid. Additional references added to re-inforce notability. Article needs expansion, not deletion per Deletion of Maria Alquilar WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19085 25 [[Georg Thalmeier]] (bereits geklöscht) Benutzer:Wahrheitsministerium 14:01, 31. Mär. 2007 (CEST) delete Mit guten Gründen schließen die #Schriftsteller_und_Sachbuchautoren BoD-Bücher aus, wenn es um die Beurteilung der Relevanz geht Löschung von Georg Thalmeier Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
19086 15197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of important homeopaths User:Jim 22:01, 9 March 2007 (UTC) keep since some of those listed pass but prune the redlinked stuff Deletion of List of important homeopaths WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19087 8624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eugene Kontorovich User:Yash 15:55, 18 February 2017 (UTC) keep per Northamerica1000. Passes . — Deletion of Eugene Kontorovich WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19088 21794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Universiteitskrant User:Bearian 14:40, 15 January 2021 (UTC) merge per {{U|onel5969}} as sensible and Deletion of Universiteitskrant WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
19089 4579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Post-disco User:RockandDiscoFanCZ 18:41, 15 December 2009 (UTC) keep """per Special:Contributions/Power.corrupts|Power.corrupts. Post-disco IS a real genre (it's the same like post-punk, post-rock, post-country, post-post.. etc .. and meaning is all the same = after the punk, after the rock, etc), it's NOT only an era. We can also speculate that Disco is not a kind of music, because RollingStone defined it per the word """"discotheque"""" http://www.jahsonic.com/VinceAletti.html -> disco is all type of music that is playing on discotheques. So much gonna get ya on Disco article, I recommend to nominee a Disco article""" Deletion of Post-disco WP:SYNTHESIS Wikipedia:No original research 65
19090 2525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Nichols User:David 17:08, 12 March 2014 (UTC) delete for lack of independent, reliable (and mainstream) sources that cover the subject in-depth. No evidence of passing Deletion of Andrew Nichols WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19091 1928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saidy Janko User:GiantSnowman 17:26, 6 September 2013 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Saidy Janko WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19092 44 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Elvin Aghayev """Kullanıcı:chanseychansey""" 21:14, 19 Ekim 2017 (UTC) delete Gözüken o ki sağlamamakta. VP:KİŞİ kapsamında ise kişi hakkındaki kaynakların yetersiz olduğu kanaatindeyim Elvin Aghayev'in silinmesi Vikipedi:AKADEMİSYEN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19093 18033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indo-Aryan migration debate User:Ekvastra 10:43, 1 August 2016 (UTC) keep I see credible references used and the topic passes . It would be a loss to purge the article. Please persuade if it fails notability guidelines Deletion of Indo-Aryan migration debate WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19094 9301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iranian-American War User:Rackabello 23:38, 9 April 2007 (UTC) delete per and POV. If there is an article about the history of Iranian-American conflicts, merge any useful information there Deletion of Iranian-American War WP:CRYSTAL||WP:NOR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19095 16030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of worlds in the Kingdom Hearts series User:Masem 21:28, 9 May 2010 (UTC) delete but not before merging some of the developer bits into the appropriate game or series articles. A list of worlds in a game is generally , and most of the entries here are just talking about the worlds in-universe. There is some useful information that can be rescued, but not the full list; alternatively, because these reference certain Disney films, a table in the series articles to list the worlds and movies borrowed from would be appropriate Deletion of List of worlds in the Kingdom Hearts series WP:GAMEGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19096 12934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shane Conacher User:Ajraddatz 02:30, 1 April 2016 (UTC) delete Fails clearly, but the evaluation is more tricky. Ultimately I think deletion is the best option ''for now'', because the coverage in reliable sources is general and not about him for the most part Deletion of Shane Conacher WP:NHOCKEY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19097 7666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Capri Anderson (3rd nomination) User:Cavarrone 19:51, 14 February 2013 (UTC) keep """Outside of what the nominator """"''Wikipedia:POINT|personally feels''"""", the subject clearly passes our notability guidelines. She won an AVN Award for best supporting actress, she was nominated to a XBIZ Award for best actress and to several other AVN Awards for best actress, crossover star of the year, best web starlet and best tease performance (plus a bunch of scene awards that, per consensus, do not count towards notability). Even ignoring , that quite recently received widespread consensus on its actual version, how she fails ? Wikipedia is not |censored, and she is clearly notable in her field. I wonder if the nominator would have rised the same objections if Anderson was an award winning graphic designer, or a clay pigeon shooter""" Deletion of Capri Anderson (3rd nomination) WP:PORNBIO||WP:ANYBIO||WP:CENSOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19098 21304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/General and I User:Shawn 02:54, 31 December 2016 (UTC) keep per . Yes, NOTTVGUIDE does ''not'' mean we can't have articles on TV shows. Anyway, Google Translate makes it clear enough (barely) that the first ref alone is indeed a feature article about the new series, in what seems to be reliable source Deletion of General and I WP:TVSERIES Wikipedia:Notability 77
19099 617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Social verbs User:Greenrd 23:34, 29 December 2016 (UTC) delete this is more of a glossary entry than an article, so it fails Deletion of Social verbs WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19100 6671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sanapia User:Armbrust 10:44, 1 November 2010 (UTC) keep Article has enough |reliable sources to pass |GNG Deletion of Sanapia WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19101 14430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lemonade Mouth 2 User:LibStar 12:11, 15 June 2011 (UTC) delete clear cut case of Deletion of Lemonade Mouth 2 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19102 10997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bucks–Bulls rivalry User:Ejgreen77 05:57, 9 March 2014 (UTC) keep """I added 4 more new sources to the page today, from the ''Milwaukee Journal Sentinel'', ESPN, and USA Today. They are all from |reliable sources, and they all use the term """"rivalry"""" to refer to this series""" Deletion of Bucks–Bulls rivalry WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19103 8753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Landegg International University User:Britishfinance 10:45, 21 March 2019 (UTC) comment """Just seeing this article now and wondering why this university is a ghost in general searches for . I do see its name appearing in """"Degree Mills"""" (e.g. bogus private universities issuing degrees to make money), here http://www.consumerfraudreporting.org/Education_Degree_Scam_list.php Consumer Fraud Reporting, and in this book ''https://books.google.ie/books?id=DRgwAQAAQBAJ&pg=PT299&lpg=PT299&dq=Landegg+International+University+fake&source=bl&ots=YhuolCsa4D&sig=ACfU3U14x0QDSJT_XipVegxdIK_iWsgb5g&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwilwrO5hZPhAhUN-6QKHcyeAUgQ6AEwC3oECAgQAQ#v=onepage&q=Landegg%20International%20University%20fake&f=false Degree Mills: The Billion Dollar Industry that has sold over a Million Fake Degrees'', and even Quora (although it is a repeat of my first ref) ''https://www.quora.com/Which-online-schools-are-scams Quora: Which online schools are scams''. Is this the reason why Landegg is a ghost in general GNG terms""" Deletion of Landegg International University WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19104 11646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Patterson User:Kevin1243 10:27, 29 May 2006 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass any of the criteria Deletion of Andrew Patterson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19105 8500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siege of the Banu Qurayza User:Angusmclellan 22:54, 18 December 2006 (UTC) delete per nom; POV fork, Deletion of Siege of the Banu Qurayza WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19106 11320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teddy-Sumo's Disease User:Toon05 17:07, 28 December 2008 (UTC) delete """the links presented above: the latter two are both '''wikipedia mirrors''', presenting the same fictitious article as is being deleted here - as mentioned at the bottom of the articles. The first is also derived from wikipedia, as is noted: """"The original description for this topic was automatically generated from the Wikipedia article """"Teddy-Sumo's Disease"""""""" and a link to the """"full Wikipedia article"""". There are http://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?q=Teddy-Sumo%27s%20Disease&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&rls=org.mozilla:en-GB:official&client=firefox-a&um=1&sa=N&tab=ws no Google scholar hits, which is odd for a disease, and there are just 136 niormal hits; none of which are |reliable sources, the vast majority are from Wikipedia. This serves to demonstrate just how far misinformation in Wikipedia articles can penetrate""" Deletion of Teddy-Sumo's Disease WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19107 8552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Şemsişah Sultan User:Kvng 14:28, 25 February 2019 (UTC) delete without prejudice - Lack of coverage where it would be expected. Possible although there is no evidence of this Deletion of Şemsişah Sultan WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
19108 7842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Not Another Not Another Movie User:MichaelQSchmidt 02:37, 13 December 2010 (UTC) delete per . Had the nominator had a |little look around he might have realized that the project is not a hoax,http://news.google.com/archivesearch?as_user_ldate=2008&as_user_hdate=2010&q=%22Not+Another+Not+Another+Movie%22+source%3A%22-newswire%22+source%3A%22-wire%22+source%3A%22-presswire%22+source%3A%22-PR%22+source%3A%22-release%22+source%3A%22-wikipedia%22&scoring=a&q=%22Not+Another+Not+Another+Movie%22+source%3A%22-newswire%22+source%3A%22-wire%22+source%3A%22-presswire%22+source%3A%22-PR%22+source%3A%22-release%22+source%3A%22-wikipedia%22&lnav=od&btnG=Gohttp://www.imdb.com/title/tt1302019/combinedhttp://www.notanothermovie.com/ and indeed has such persons attached. However, it does seem to be caught in production hell and does not have the coverage to merit being an exception to . Let it be undeleted later Deletion of Not Another Not Another Movie WP:TOOSOON||WP:BEFORE||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
19109 5075 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naseer Mirza User:onel5969 17:00, 16 November 2016 (UTC) delete as said above, a promotional piece, does not pass Deletion of Naseer Mirza WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19110 5418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RuneScape armour User:Poorleno 23:05, 24 June 2006 (UTC) keep """Hardly gets mentioned in main article, as the purpose of this page was to shorten RuneScape and an article on a ''MAJOR'' section of the game hardly qualifies as as """"Game Guide"""", therefor, Doesn't apply. Really no problem with it whatsoever, and if you have a problem with this statement, rant on""" Deletion of RuneScape armour WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19111 16054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deathsaurus User:Eggishorn 04:02, 7 January 2017 (UTC) delete A single listicle in does not confer notability Deletion of Deathsaurus WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19112 18596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Hongkongers User:Iridescenti 16:20, 25 April 2007 (UTC) comment Wikipedia:List guideline isn't a notability criteria but a ''technical article on how to format lists''. #DIRECTORY and #INDISCRIMINATE ''are'' criteria, both of which this clearly breaches by a huge margin. We may as well have a List of people with brown hair or List of cars with a registered keeper in Rutland Deletion of List of Hongkongers WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19113 7914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trump Derangement Syndrome User:Dave 23:34, 22 May 2018 (UTC) delete This is |recentism bias and fails . The article has more about Bush than Trump. Also, Trump lies more than http://www.politifact.com/personalities/donald-trump/ two-thirds of the time he speaks(via PolitiFact), while telling the complete truth about 5% of the time. If there's a Trump derangement syndrome article, the many analysis done on Trump's derangement should be included Deletion of Trump Derangement Syndrome WP:RECENTISM||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Recentism 10
19114 16563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Airlines Flight 550 User:NinjaRobotPirate 20:17, 16 October 2015 (UTC) delete mostly per . A medical emergency happened, the plane was diverted, and everyone but the captain lived happily ever after. It's not an accident, so it can't be merged to a list of accidents. I don't think routine incidents like this should have their own article. Yes, the news media did report on it, but we are not beholden to create an article on every single topic that briefly bubbles to the top of Google News. This is more applicable to Wikinews Deletion of American Airlines Flight 550 WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19115 21262 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Platón (band) User:onel5969 00:42, 22 September 2020 (UTC) delete searches did not turn up enough in-depth coverage to pass , and definitely doesn't pass Deletion of Platón (band) WP:GNG||WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19116 5509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Better Place (David Campbell Album) User:Tavix 02:24, 3 April 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of A Better Place (David Campbell Album) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19117 16824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Casey Bisson User:Dhartung 20:49, 18 December 2006 (UTC) delete fails . Notability not significantly more than |average professor Deletion of Casey Bisson WP:BIO||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19118 12625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Koretz User:Charlene 12:09, 15 November 2006 (UTC) delete per , , , , and WP:GETALIFE. If that had been my kid I sure'd have noticed, and doubled up on my contraceptive in the future Deletion of David Koretz WP:COI||WP:BIO||WP:SPAM||WP:V Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
19119 2045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joaquin Garay User:Atlantic306 19:31, 18 February 2020 (UTC) keep as per the reliable sources identified above that show that asic is passed in my view, the museum reference is particularly convincing, imv Deletion of Joaquin Garay WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
19120 12669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nilam Parikh User:NewYorkActuary 21:34, 17 June 2016 (UTC) delete If the book had generated enough interest to have its own article here, I would have recommended a redirect to that article. But there is no such article. Either way, the subject doesn't come close to meeting Deletion of Nilam Parikh WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19121 2547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grenfell Tower (2nd nomination) User:Thincat 22:04, 5 June 2018 (UTC) keep """It may well not have been a notable building before the fire but since the fire there has been a mass of reporting about the building as it was before the fire. We do not ask ''why'' there is coverage (of the pre-fire building) we simply ask that there ''is'' such coverage. Even if the analogy with people is appropriate using , """"If the event is highly significant, and the individual's role within it is a large one, a separate article is generally appropriate"""" rather strongly advises we should have both articles""" Deletion of Grenfell Tower (2nd nomination) WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19122 3486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lynx Equity Ltd User:HighKing 17:38, 10 September 2017 (UTC) delete """It is clear that the """"Keep"""" !voters above are misinterpreting the guidelines for notability, especially and . References derived from company PR, company announcements and normal business announcements do not meet the criteria for establishing notability since they are not """"intellectually"""" independent. The quantity of sources only suggests a functional PR department. {{u|ViktoriaCerena}} suggests that """"independent in-depth references from reliable sources"""" have been added but looking at the sources added, it is clear that while the sources may be independent, the articles are not since they rely almost exclusively on company material with no independent opinion or commentary. For example, http://www.privateequitywire.co.uk/2017/04/21/250911/howard-kennedy-advises-lynx-equity-second-uk-acquisition this added references from privateequitywire is not independent as it is a joint announcement from the company and the law firm that advised them on an acquisition and fails ORGIND and/or CORPDEPTH. https://www.pehub.com/canada/2016/2/need-to-meet-brad-nathan-president-of-lynx-equity/# This reference from pehub.com is an interview with the company president, offers no independent commentary or opinion, and fails CORPDEPTH and/or ORGIND. I could go on but you get the point""" Deletion of Lynx Equity Ltd WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19123 5464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stable Isotope Foundation User:Ihcoyc 14:39, 24 July 2008 (UTC) delete agree with all above, and articles that contain text arguing their subject's notability seem to be |self-referential in a sense, as well as clutching at straws Deletion of Stable Isotope Foundation WP:SELF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
19124 3586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tommy Sowers User:GlassCobra 15:44, 14 October 2009 (UTC) delete per , running candidates not yet notable (, etc Deletion of Tommy Sowers WP:POLITICIAN||WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19125 16677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hendry Adii Magiic (actor) User:MRD2014 03:07, 14 September 2017 (UTC) delete Google search only turned up IMDb and some Japanese site. Fails and Deletion of Hendry Adii Magiic (actor) WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19126 18904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Pixel-Stained Technopeasant Day User:Hyperdoctor 18:28, 19 March 2011 (UTC) comment The references in the article and both the examples above appear to be blogs, not |reliable sources Deletion of International Pixel-Stained Technopeasant Day WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19127 5571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Pool Pros User:Akerans 18:43, 5 June 2010 (UTC) delete """per . 3 of 4 references used do not """"address the subject directly in detail."""" The 4th reference reads like a yellow pages ad, which does not make the subject notable""" Deletion of The Pool Pros WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19128 8240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007-08 Rogue Valley Wranglers hockey team User:JD554 08:25, 14 February 2008 (UTC) delete Insufficient |reliable secondary sources found to provide |notability Deletion of 2007-08 Rogue Valley Wranglers hockey team WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19129 4224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colares UFO flap User:LuckyLouie 03:26, 13 December 2013 (UTC) delete According to the article, UFOs supposedly attacked people with radiation beams on an island in Brazil. There are no objective sources available to show notability of these |extraordinary claims Deletion of Colares UFO flap WP:REDFLAG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19130 4474 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Water Cycle - new definition as """"Waterway Cycle""""""" User:Metropolitan90 15:09, 25 March 2012 (UTC) delete If this is a subject worth covering in Wikipedia, the article ought to be created by someone other than the person who created this concept and named it after himself. Otherwise, we will have problems with |original research and |conflict of interest """Deletion of Water Cycle - new definition as """"Waterway Cycle""""""" WP:NOR||WP:COI Wikipedia:No original research 65
19131 21618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TVAus User:Capitalistroadster 01:31, 13 June 2006 (UTC) delete no evidence that this forum meets Deletion of TVAus WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
19132 77 [[Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Zoologisch-botanischer Garten Wilhelma in Stuttgart]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Holmium NONE keep Kasten|1= Per vollständig abgrenzbar und gleichwertige Linkziele, daher zulässig Löschung von Vorlage:Navigationsleiste Zoologisch-botanischer Garten Wilhelma in Stuttgart Wikipedia:Themenring Wikipedia:Themenring 103
19133 14338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/On My Way (Billy Boy on Poison Song) User:Who 21:42, 3 August 2009 (UTC) delete I'd recommend deleting the song article, the album article, ''and'' the band article. There's a Grauniad article about them, but other than that, how do they qualify according to ? Their record company is a redlink, and other than the single article, the only thing notable about them is their connection to Kiefer Sutherland Deletion of On My Way (Billy Boy on Poison Song) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19134 7596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Environmental Impact on Human Health: An Annotated Bibliography User:Eastmain 00:08, 18 April 2008 (UTC) keep or merge to an existing article, and clean up. The topic is a notable one, and the material in the bibliography is what we normally consider |reliable sources. This is not originail thought in the sense of someone's new theory Deletion of Environmental Impact on Human Health: An Annotated Bibliography WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19135 5667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myra Wilson User:BlueValour 03:52, 6 September 2006 (UTC) delete Smith and Sharkey are both Professors and have, therefore, much more notability. Also no references to published works. At the moment I don't see Wilson meeting Deletion of Myra Wilson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19136 2307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juan Branco User:David 00:20, 24 February 2016 (UTC) delete Sources do not bear out the significance claimed in the article. He clearly does not pass , but it looks like he also does not pass , and in any case the article needs to remove all the self-promotion Deletion of Juan Branco WP:PROF||WP:GNG||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19137 11601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ken buck User:Armbrust 12:00, 1 July 2010 (UTC) delete per #G4|G4 as the recreation of the Ken Buck article Deletion of Ken buck WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
19138 15888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Too Far User:Esradekan 11:26, 7 March 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Songs Deletion of Too Far WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19139 14876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Homeschooling Day User:Ajf773 05:19, 4 November 2018 (UTC) delete """per nominator. Fails and . I also love this sentence in the content: """"Wikipedia is also among the sources families use to know more about a topic of their interest."""", further reinforces the uselessness of this article""" Deletion of International Homeschooling Day WP:GNG||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19140 16384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stunner (game) User:Tree 04:54, 17 September 2006 (UTC) delete per and ; non-notable, defunct freeware game Deletion of Stunner (game) WP:ADS||WP:SOFT Wikipedia:Spam 112
19141 16763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ravinder Jagdev User:Rrburke 20:58, 6 October 2010 (UTC) delete WP:SOAP|Self-promoting |autobiographical |spam Deletion of Ravinder Jagdev WP:AUTO||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
19142 13252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southern Fires Restaurant User:Arxiloxos 02:11, 17 November 2011 (UTC) comment """The current article is written in an unacceptably promotional style. On the other hand, references to this restaurant as a Detroit's culinary """"landmark""""http://www.detnews.com/article/20110203/OPINION03/102030301/1031/opinion03(and a favorite of various celebrities) show up in a variety of news articles, including some from outside Detroit, e.g. http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/travel/2002134731_detroit02.htmlhttp://books.google.com/books?id=wSYEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA104&dq=%22southern+fires%22+detroit&hl=en&ei=vWnETpO4GIrciALpwMjJBQ&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=4&ved=0CD8Q6AEwAw#v=onepage&q=%22southern%20fires%22%20detroit&f=false. So it's possible that this restaurant might be notable and that a satisfactorily article could be written here""" Deletion of Southern Fires Restaurant WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
19143 10107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leathermouth's first studio album User:SRX 12:47, 1 August 2008 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Leathermouth's first studio album WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19144 14362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stafford (band) User:Joe 18:35, 25 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |band Deletion of Stafford (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19145 15935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Annerson User:Number 09:24, 20 August 2007 (UTC) delete per : Has not played in a fully-professional league Deletion of Jamie Annerson WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19146 2686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Gerald Lorge User:MrScorch6200 22:44, 22 July 2015 (UTC) delete per all above and Deletion of Robert Gerald Lorge WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
19147 13018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Possible consequences of Kosovo independence User:EJF 19:10, 17 February 2008 (UTC) delete speculative POV fork. Violation of Deletion of Possible consequences of Kosovo independence WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19148 10810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leslie Lee Sanders User:Kim 20:00, 16 October 2007 (UTC) delete Failure to meet Deletion of Leslie Lee Sanders WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19149 4 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Murat Demiroğlu Kullanıcı:151.250.243.86151.250.243.86 22:26, 12 Ağustos 2013 (UTC) keep İnsan Kaynakları adına Türkiye'de kariyer yapmış isim Murat bey kalsın...--Özel:Katkılar/151.250.243.86|151.250.243.86 (#Oyların geçerliliği uyarınca geçersiz oy Murat Demiroğlu'nun silinmesi Vikipedi:OY Wikipedia:Administrators 89
19150 2578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Starving the Monkeys User:Vicenarian 22:10, 29 June 2009 (UTC) delete """You can buy lots of non-notable things on Amazon.com, being available for sale there doesn't otability (books)#Online bookstores|automatically confer notability. Note that Amazon lists the publisher as """"Starve Monkey Press (June 2, 2009)."""" Vanity press? This, and the fact that the only sources available seem to come from the author, concern me per otability (books)#Self-publication|the guidelines regarding self-publishing. The notability criteria for Wikipedia are well-defined and straight-forward, and the objections here have nothing to do with the topic of the book or content of the article. Also, we quickly and vigorously delete a LOT of non-notable content every single day""" Deletion of Starving the Monkeys WP:N||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19151 21761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rachel Mathson User:K 19:37, 5 September 2016 (UTC) delete per ; not otherwise notable. I don't believe a redirect is needed as the subject was unlikely to gain note for her name to become a valid search term Deletion of Rachel Mathson WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
19152 8996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of multiplayer gametypes in Halo 2 User:Proto 09:34, 25 July 2006 (UTC) delete and '''do not merge'''. Information is already present in the main article, and an in depth description makes this game guide information. Fails Deletion of List of multiplayer gametypes in Halo 2 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19153 10689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ajeesh Dasan User:Mccapra 10:32, 18 July 2019 (UTC) comment Does he not meet for having three reliable independent sources that cover his work Deletion of Ajeesh Dasan WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19154 19097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Acclaimed Indian Police Officers User:FunnyPika 15:10, 1 March 2013 (UTC) comment """Just to make things clearer, another synonym for """"acclaimed"""" is """"notable"""". There's no need to state this in the title so I've moved the page to List of Indian police officers. Like List of electricians or List of cyclists, if an Indian police officer meets then they would qualify for this list. The question is whether the list should stand as it is""" Deletion of List of Acclaimed Indian Police Officers WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19155 3548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ong Tze Ch'in User:Mztourist 05:06, 25 August 2021 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Ong Tze Ch'in WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19156 9180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Rellik User:TenPoundHammer 00:56, 8 July 2007 (UTC) delete Absolutely nothing notable here, not even the author is notable. Possibly |vanispami... Vanispuft... vanispammy... I can never pronounce that Deletion of The Rellik WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
19157 9412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chikkajala User:MB 21:00, 10 December 2017 (UTC) keep This places seems to be a whole village of 6000: https://villageinfo.in/karnataka/bangalore/bangalore-north/chikkajala.html, https://www.google.com/maps/place/Chikkajala,+Bengaluru,+Karnataka+562157,+India/@13.1711333,77.6276329,15z/data=!4m5!3m4!1s0x3bae1ebefd680589:0x158a5611c27b9408!8m2!3d13.1715223!4d77.6356486. Meets as a populated place. Article should be expanded to cover the whole village Deletion of Chikkajala WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19158 153 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hilal Altınbilek Kullanıcı:bulgudeniz 16:53, 11 Kasım 2016 (UTC) comment BS olur da, HS (M6) olmasa daha iyi olur. |Hızlı sil sayfasında itidalli kullanılması söylenen kriterler (M6, G8, G4) bence gereğinden çok fazla ve haşince kullanılıyor. Buradaki SAS tartışmaları genelde KD'lik etrafında dönüyor, burayı es geçiyor olmayalım. Reklam için G-11, taslak bile olamayacaklar için M1/M3/G1-3, telif sorunu için G9 var. Zannedersem maddeleri öldürdükten sonra diriltebiliyor olmamız olayı çok basitleştirmiş. Ölü olduğu dönemdeki katkı fırsatını kaçırıyoruz, en azından Hilal Altınbilek'in silinmesi Vikipedi:HS Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
19159 16302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zachary Quack Minimonster User:Lopifalko 09:42, 1 September 2019 (UTC) delete to Lynley Dodd. Does not satisfy Deletion of Zachary Quack Minimonster WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
19160 3962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Casa Guidi (album) User:Schazjmd 18:08, 19 September 2019 (UTC) keep Meets #4 Deletion of Casa Guidi (album) WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
19161 12107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Frimpong User:Bettia 15:52, 29 June 2010 (UTC) delete Sports-wise, he hasn't achieved anything of note or played at a professional level, so he fails . The only news coverage he has received is for the rape case, which means the subject also fails Deletion of Eric Frimpong WP:ATHLETE||WP:ONEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19162 3400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CD Gold 2 User:Joe 23:01, 27 May 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |album Deletion of CD Gold 2 WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19163 18151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiens Group User:Hzh 19:10, 15 August 2018 (UTC) keep A quick look in Google Books yields many hits - https://books.google.com/books?id=2AlcAgAAQBAJ&pg=PT49#v=onepage&q&f=falsehttps://books.google.com/books?id=DtUwDAAAQBAJ&pg=PA411#v=onepage&q&f=falsehttps://books.google.com/books?id=4ZCXRsgV_M0C&pg=PT39#v=onepage&q&f=falsehttps://books.google.com/books?id=2C1LDwAAQBAJ&pg=PT185#v=onepage&q&f=false, should qualify under . I don't know why such a large corporation with significant international presence should be submitted for AfD Deletion of Tiens Group WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19164 10393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Nehlen User:JerryRussell 23:47, 17 August 2016 (UTC) keep This article definitely meets , and he received ''significant'' national coverage, as Deletion of Paul Nehlen WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19165 14433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cognac diplomacy User:Colapeninsula 15:04, 28 July 2017 (UTC) delete The article is very biassed and not neutral point of view, and seems to use its ostensible topic as a |coatrack for attacks on various organisations, although it's not entirely clear what its precise aim is (although the nomination itself is equally propagandist and just as out of place on Wikipedia Deletion of Cognac diplomacy WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
19166 9575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Puppy-throwing marine video incident User:Edison 05:01, 20 June 2008 (UTC) keep """Viral videos can be notable, as evidenced by AFDs deciding to keep several of them, or at least no consensus to delete, such as the Obama Girl video I Got a Crush... on Obama (no consensus) or the video about an Asian girl whose dog pooped on a bus and she refused to clean it up, Dog poop girl ('''Keep''' in 3 afds). Star Wars kid, about a young man swing a golf ball retriever like a light saber ('''Keep''' in two AFDs). The video about a profane old Chinese man on a bus The Bus Uncle, appeared on Wikipedia's Main Page as Today's featured article on September 7, 2007. An old man cursing someone on a bus, a dog pooping on a bus, or a child swinging a golf ball retriever like a weapon is surely no more encyclopedic than a U.S. Marine killing a puppy, if the latter got enough news coverage. This one got substantial coverage in multiple independent and reliable sources. See List of Internet phenomena for more trivial things which became notable via the internet. This not """"media coverage"""" of a trivial event, as is addressed by since no reporter made the video. It is an internet phenomenon""" Deletion of Puppy-throwing marine video incident WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19167 14835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mototaka Nakamura User:XOR 00:05, 4 April 2020 (UTC) delete Citation profile too underwhelming to pass #C1 (an h-index of only 13, in a field where citation counts are actually informative). No other evidence of notability per , or any other applicable guideline Deletion of Mototaka Nakamura WP:PROF||WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19168 19873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Full Tilt Online Poker Series User:Sloane 03:42, 2 March 2009 (UTC) comment """I recommend you to read . """"Articles should rely on reliable, third-party, published sources with a reputation for fact-checking and accuracy."""" That means sources like the New York Times or CNN, I doubt commercial poker sites have much of a """"reputation for fact-checking and accuracy""" Deletion of Full Tilt Online Poker Series WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19169 62 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Mélisandre Meertens Kullanıcı:ravagesravages 18.02, 13 Şubat 2020 (UTC) keep """VP:KİŞİ, oyuncular için """"Kayda değer filmlerde, televizyon ve sahne gösterilerinde ve diğer prodüksiyonlarda önemli rol oynamış olanlar"""" hükmüne sahip. Buradan oyuncunun yer aldığı yapımların kayda değerliğini sorgulamamız gerektiği sonucuna varıyoruz. ve VP:TV de ana kayda değerlik kriterinin yanında bazı özel kriterler vermiş. İlgili kişinin içinde yer aldığı yapımların ödül alıp almadığını, ya da alanında çığır açan işlerden olup olmadığını bilmiyoruz. Fakat kişiyi ve yaptığı işleri baz alan, tarafsız, bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynaklar var (maddede aktarıldığı için tekrarlamaya gerek görmüyorum). O hâlde kayda değerdir demek mümkündür. Bu nedenle de kalması gerektiği kanaatindeyim""" Mélisandre Meertens'in silinmesi Vikipedi:FİLM Wikipedia:Notability 77
19170 12696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burning from the Inside (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 21:07, 2 March 2011 (UTC) delete all without prejdice, as this is a multiple article nomination, and addressing the issues of all within a short period of time may be difficult. I have found that ''Burning from the Inside (film)'' exists.http://www.britfilms.com/britishfilms/catalogue/browse/?id=D5D44D521aee027A86pGh4245A6C ''Speed of Light (film)'' exists.http://www.britfilms.com/britishfilms/catalogue/browse/?id=D5D44D521618918A9DNhW1FDE173 ''Writing on the Wall (film)'' exists.http://www.britfilms.com/britishfilms/catalogue/browse/?id=D5D44D521b200225B4oTs264B141 ''In and Out of Planet Earth'' exists.http://www.britfilms.com/britishfilms/catalogue/browse/?id=D5D44D521afa822EC2KmO186270F ''Est (TV series)'' exists.http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Est+%28TV+series%29+%22%2C+%22+Nick+Peterson%22&sourceid=ie7&rls=com.microsoft:en-US&ie=utf8&oe=utf8 And despite the appearances of a walled garden from an editor with an apparent COI (the films ARE releated through the director, after all), and while willing to grant good faith in the creation of articles about a few of this one director's http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1807599/filmotype many projects, there are not enough reliable sources (currently) offered in the articles to show any as meeting . '''HOWEVER''', if any can be shown to meet through , I would think a recreation of those that qualify could then be allowed. And a '''note''': I was not involved in the Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Nick_Peterson|deletion discussion of the article on the director Nick Peterson, so I do not know how poorly that article may itself have been written or sourced. I might have even suggested a userfication, but we do have a problematic COI in the author's username Deletion of Burning from the Inside (film) WP:NF||WP:NF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19171 191 [[Tiere der Harry-Potter-Romane]] (ungültig, da bereits alter LA abgelehnt) Benutzer:Iwoelbern NONE keep gibt genug Leute, die sich dazu informieren wollen, und sei es, um zu wissen, wovon ihre Kinder so begeistert sind. Der Artikel entspricht zudem ideal .{{Unsigniert|Wahldresdner Löschung von Tiere der Harry-Potter-Romane Wikipedia:AüF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
19172 21229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur Godfrey Peuchen User:CASSIOPEIA 11:23, 29 November 2018 (UTC) keep Passes Deletion of Arthur Godfrey Peuchen WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19173 9908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Temba Tsheri User:Grandmartin11 16:15, 12 May 2009 (UTC) comment What would we use for criteria on this? ? If so, it could be argued that climbing Everest is competing at the highest level of mountaineering Deletion of Temba Tsheri WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19174 17694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Takatak User:JohnCD 20:28, 7 February 2011 (UTC) delete """the only possible claim to notability is the assertion that the single which is their only release so far """"''topped all local charts in the first week of release''"""", but this is not confirmed by the sources cited. We would need to see evidence that this was true and that the ''local charts'' were significant enough to meet , which requires """"''any country's national music chart""" Deletion of Takatak WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19175 6017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khawar Qureshi User:ianmacm 07:49, 5 July 2020 (UTC) delete various problems including failing to meet and written like a résumé Deletion of Khawar Qureshi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19176 20857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Janet Emerson Bashen (2nd nomination) User:RebeccaGreen 12:24, 17 August 2019 (UTC) keep She meets with 3 long profiles of her, with lots of biographical info, one in the article already (''BlackPast.org'' https://www.blackpast.org/african-american-history/bashen-janet-emerson-1957/), and two others that I've found quite quickly: ''Face2Face Africa'' https://face2faceafrica.com/article/womens-history-month-meet-janet-emerson-bashen-first-black-woman-attain-patent-computer-software and ''Black Enterprise'' https://www.blackenterprise.com/how-janet-bashen-became-a-software-pioneer/, plus a short entry here https://rollingout.com/2017/02/14/14-black-inventors-inventions-love/. It's clear that the subject and others working for her have edited the article, and it does need work to remove unencyclopaedic descriptions, but she does meet Wikipedia's notability criteria Deletion of Janet Emerson Bashen (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19177 10962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Echoing the sound User:Proto 13:20, 3 February 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Echoing the sound WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
19178 13862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marc Tyler User:ZimZalaBim 17:30, 14 December 2008 (UTC) keep Meets general |notability guidelines, which generally take precedence over specific conditions listed under (which are meant to help establish notability if the general conditions aren't met Deletion of Marc Tyler WP:BIO||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19179 19942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bing Maniquiz User:Theroadislong 10:13, 30 May 2016 (UTC) delete Ridiculous puff piece, fails and |general notability guide Deletion of Bing Maniquiz WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19180 2781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James P. Morrison User:Tony 20:41, 8 October 2009 (UTC) delete the subject doesn't appear to meet guidelines for notable musicians at this point. Come back when he's signed to a notable label, touring and has a full-length album out, okay Deletion of James P. Morrison WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19181 10851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Suburbs (Arcade Fire album) User:JD554 06:55, 28 May 2010 (UTC) comment An album being confirmed as being released does not make it notable. Both and require that the album be discussed in detail by mulitple reliable sources. While this album has been discussed by multiple reliable sources, simply confirming the album's title, release date and co-producer doesn't meet with the detail required in my opinion. Do we have any early feedback from sources on the songs that have been released that can be added? Or anything that can be added beyond a release date and track listing? I've not seen anything. That level of detail may be forthcoming in the following weeks, but it isn't there yet. The article can always be re-created when the ablum is notable Deletion of The Suburbs (Arcade Fire album) WP:GNG||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19182 131 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ermeni Soykırımını Anma Günü Kullanıcı:takabegtakabeg 13:45, 12 Haziran 2009 (UTC) keep Anladığım kadarıyla Troll zararlısının kurbanı olduğu için gelişmemiştir. Aslında Azerbaycanlıların Soykırım Günü'nün kardeş maddesi olarak açtım. Yani bunları anma günleridir. Ermeni tarafı iddiaları diye birşey söz konusu değildir. Sadece anıyorlar. Zaten kriterleri sağlıyor Ermeni Soykırımını Anma Günü'nün silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
19183 17408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ready10 User:Nick 13:47, 17 November 2017 (UTC) delete All sources in article are to insider journals promoting stories about similar companies. No other (third party) found on a Google News or other searches. This PR company might well become notable in the future - but is right now, despite its own video stating it has attained 1,925 pieces of earned media in its lifetime. |Notability is OTINHERITED from the companies who employ them to do their PR. Regards from the UK Deletion of Ready10 WP:RS||WP:TOOSOON||WP:N||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19184 3514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert M. Bernstein User:Qworty 01:32, 29 January 2011 (UTC) comment With all due respect, I have to point out that none of the links you provide constitute for the purpose of establishing . First of all, not a single one of the links is ABOUT Bernstein. They are about hair transplantation, not Bernstein. They might indicate that hair transplantation is notable, not Bernstein. But I would argue that they don't even indicate that much, because four of these links do not constitute of any kind. They are primary, non-neutral sources, not secondary, neutral sources. They aren't news stories--they're nothing more than press releases about each TV network's own programming. They are, in effect, advertising rather than news reporting. Since they are neither secondary nor impartial, they cannot be used as Deletion of Robert M. Bernstein WP:RS||WP:N||WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19185 7368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amber Siegel User:HeartSWild 14:47, 1 September 2010 (UTC) delete While this individual may be notable, there's no evidence to support it in the article. Until |reliable sources are referenced, the policy is to delete. I would change my mind if someone would properly source the article Deletion of Amber Siegel WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19186 10070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monastic HSEB, Janakpur User:Usedtobecool 08:50, 12 August 2019 (UTC) delete Verified from HSEB link that it's a real higher secondary school. May deserve keeping, as an education institution that's big enough to substantially impact the lives of the community it services. However, being a for-profit institution, it needs to meet guidelines which it doesn't. No independent RS that I could find except for the HSEB member listing (which is enough to verify it's not a hoax, but doesn't aid notability in any way). Edusanjal lists it, but still am not clear what the status of Edusanjal is, on reliability/credibility Deletion of Monastic HSEB, Janakpur WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19187 13530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katsunori Furuya User:Pichpich 14:15, 6 April 2016 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet or . As noted above, the article would currently be eligible for a BLPPROD Deletion of Katsunori Furuya WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19188 2015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Graham Short User:Nasty 23:35, 15 October 2020 (UTC) keep and '''Edit''' The subject is notable in his field and the article does meet . The existing references from BBC are . It needs further improvement in terms of content and references per and . A few notable references that can be added include the following: https://qz.com/645382/inside-the-studio-of-the-micro-engraver-who-works-between-heartbeats-to-keep-his-hand-steady/ Quartz,https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/five-pound-note-plastic-worth-50-000-engrave-jane-austen-winston-churchill-a7459171.html The Indepdendent,https://www.birminghamlocal.tv/videos/graham-short-has-just-completed-his-most-difficult-project-x7vb258/ Birmingham TV, http://www.digitaljournal.com/pr/4762432 Digital Journal, https://www.arthousescotland.com/blog/graham-short-thh-gallery-collaborate/ Art House Scotland. Unsourced information can be removed and replaced with information from the above references Deletion of Graham Short WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:CCPOL||WP:MOS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19189 6884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apollos University User:And 21:13, 9 April 2018 (UTC) delete My own searching fails to find any . There's first-party pages. There's directory listings in various education sites. There's facebook, linkedin, twitter, glassdoor, yelp, etc. But so far, I haven't found a single article in a newspaper or anything that I could use to get past . I don't understand Deletion of Apollos University WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19190 6654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Archimedes Plutonium (2nd) User:PCock 11:48, 20 March 2007 (UTC) keep The attention he has received makes the subject meet . Some cleanup of unverified statements may be necessary Deletion of Archimedes Plutonium (2nd) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19191 15615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014–15 FC Halifax Town season User:Number 12:50, 6 August 2020 (UTC) delete Fails . Almost all previous AfDs on National League seasons have ended in delete. See recent examples like Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019–20 Notts County F.C. season|this or Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018–19 Hartlepool United F.C. season|this (and all the other previous AfDs referenced in that one Deletion of 2014–15 FC Halifax Town season WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19192 18288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Document User:Naufana 01:24, 7 July 2007 (UTC) comment First of all if it is a bootleg then it's a bootleg purporting to be an official release, which would only cause confusion. secondly if it is a bootleg then wouldn't the notability still fail per ? It hasn't even been released yet Deletion of The Document WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19193 6125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Archimonde User:Sakkura 16:35, 4 November 2007 (UTC) keep There's a link to a third-party database, so it definitely doesn't violate . Whether it is notable is another matter, and I'm not convinced either way at the moment, what with the game being the most famous computer game around, known among non-gamers and gamers alike. (yes, Archimonde is just a character inside the indisputably notable game; but he is a sufficiently major and recurring character that he might be considered notable in his own right Deletion of Archimonde WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19194 6469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jörmungandr in popular culture User:Haemo 01:27, 25 July 2007 (UTC) delete laundry list of |trivia loosely related to the subject Deletion of Jörmungandr in popular culture WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
19195 17842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Circumnavigate play area User:Mangoe 14:55, 6 January 2014 (UTC) delete as . The correct term is Wraparound (video games Deletion of Circumnavigate play area WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
19196 17988 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of theatres in Mumbai User:Shreshth91 03:36, 14 November 2005 (UTC) keep This is a non-promotional, informational, notable article and in no way meets . These are an important part of an important city, moreover the film city of India. Many of these cinemas are well known and deserve articles of their own, even if they don't have them.--May the Force be with you Deletion of List of theatres in Mumbai WP:DP Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19197 12572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BeForU User:Nihonjoe 00:55, 3 April 2010 (UTC) keep """as they more than meet (specifically, they meet #2 (charted single or album), #5 (2+ major label albums), and #10 (performed music for a work of media that is notable: DDR is clearly very notable)). Their single """"Shangri-La"""" reached 110 on the Oricon charts http://ranking.oricon.co.jp/free_contents/search/ranking_list.asp?itemcd=776153&samecd=1&chart_kbn=111&linkcd=40472703, the single """"Yohanabi"""" reached 102 http://ranking.oricon.co.jp/free_contents/search/ranking_list.asp?itemcd=710739&samecd=1&chart_kbn=111&linkcd=40427382, the single """"Strike Party!!!"""" reached 49 and was on the charts for three weeks http://ranking.oricon.co.jp/free_contents/search/ranking_list.asp?itemcd=687308&samecd=1&chart_kbn=111&linkcd=40411963, """"Red Rocket Rising"""" reached 68 and was on the charts for 3 weeks, the album ''Shangri-La'' (yes the same name as the single) reached 221 on the charts http://ranking.oricon.co.jp/free_contents/search/ranking_list.asp?itemcd=781802&samecd=1&chart_kbn=11A&linkcd=31415563, the album ''Be4U III'' reached 126 on the charts http://ranking.oricon.co.jp/free_contents/search/ranking_list.asp?itemcd=696539&samecd=1&chart_kbn=11A&linkcd=31364275. They have released albums and singles through two major labels (Konami and avex mode) and one label I haven't heard of (Gambit, it's probably a fairly new label). They clearly meet the notability requirements. This is just what I found after 5 minutes of quickie searching on Google""" Deletion of BeForU WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19198 13300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beer in Argentina User:Pburka 15:46, 11 April 2020 (UTC) keep The article can easily be improved, and it would take little more effort than has been spent trying to delete it. The PROD was clearly invalid, per Deletion of Beer in Argentina WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19199 14221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chloe Ayling User:CambodianSandwich 14:34, 11 August 2017 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Chloe Ayling WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19200 6213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenneth C. Waller User:Cullen328 04:23, 15 May 2011 (UTC) delete per as any notability he has, which is very limited, derives from a single event in the war in Afghanistan. This could also be considered an |attack page Deletion of Kenneth C. Waller WP:BLP1E||WP:ATTACK Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19201 9946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jain Farm Fresh Foods Ltd User:Anupmehra 05:04, 17 September 2016 (UTC) delete Definitely doesn't satisfy criteria. Not sure even if the parent organization ''Jain Irrigation'' does Deletion of Jain Farm Fresh Foods Ltd WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
19202 14657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meiobit User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable website. http://meiobit.com has http://www.alexa.com/data/details/?url=meiobit.com Alexa traffic rank of 300,000 (|rank of 10,000 needed for website to be considered notable). &mdash Deletion of Meiobit WP:WEB||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
19203 18642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Genesis 5 User:Scorpiondollprincess 18:27, 1 August 2006 (UTC) delete """as , per nom. First sentence of article is, """"This page is a commentary on..."""" #Wikipedia_is_not_a_soapbox|Wikipedia is not a soapboax; Wikipedia was not made for opinion, it was made for fact. Don't write commentaries; write |verifiably |sourced articles on |notable subjects. A page of commentary on one chapter of one book in order to express a particular point-of-view in an argument is ''not'' encyclopedic""" Deletion of Genesis 5 WP:OR||WP:CENSOR||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NN Wikipedia:No original research 65
19204 865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Beloya User:Ravenswing 10:18, 14 February 2012 (UTC) delete """On the contrary, Alpha's rationale leaves out a couple of important elements. First off, the GNG doesn't merely require that the subject be mentioned in reliable sources; it requires that the subject be discussed in """"significant detail."""" None of the sources presented in Alpha's Google list do so. Further, explicitly debars the type of routine sports coverage, such as match recaps, that comprise these hits""" Deletion of Joshua Beloya WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19205 1048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucky Office User:TreasuryTag 09:47, 1 March 2009 (UTC) delete no notability asserted, little |citing of sources Deletion of Lucky Office WP:CITE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19206 8375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rinat Akhmetshin User:Casprings 11:57, 15 July 2017 (UTC) keep """As WP:1E says, """"However, if media coverage of both the event and the individual's role grow larger, separate articles may become justified."""" This is the case here. A simple google search reveals article after article digging into who this person is. That is an indication that he is notable and not simple the event as the articles about the person clearly meet the standards of """ Deletion of Rinat Akhmetshin WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19207 15837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Violence of Gender User:Thincat 10:17, 17 March 2019 (UTC) keep I'm not persuaded that short exhibitions are inherently non-notable. seems to suggest the topic might or might not be notable but, since this guideline claims to be interpreting pre-existing guidelines I'll refer to where the guidance indicates the topic may be presumed to merit an article Deletion of The Violence of Gender WP:NEVENTS||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19208 294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yung Miraboi Mark (2nd nomination) User:Hyttgf975 00:01, 6 September 2019 (UTC) keep Almost all subject reference are from reliable source such as Vanguard (Nigeria), The Punch, The Sun (Nigeria), Daily Times (Nigeria), The Daily Independent (Lagos newspaper) many but few to mention from my point of view independent of the subject but not mere mentions which passes also considered in otability_(people)#Entertainers|WP:ENT much but might not know in other hands from my point stated article has to be keep thanks Deletion of Yung Miraboi Mark (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19209 6577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Myra Greene User:Shelly 19:04, 23 September 2008 (UTC) comment """Extensive Google and Yahoo searches turn up nothing notable. Some blogs, a few solo shows at minor venues. The MoCP """"review"""" cited is not a review, but rather a description of some pieces in it owns, more or less an advertisement for its collection - it has apparently not been published. And even if it were, a single review does not establish notability. While the subject may in fact be a very good artist, she has, to date, not met the criteria for notability. Please see . Author fails to establish notability per these guidelines. No evidence exists that she is """"widely cited"""" , has received """"significant critical attention"""" or represented in the permanent collections of """"several notable galleries or museums."""" —Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by""" Deletion of Myra Greene WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19210 14174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mario Super Sluggers Collectible Cards User:Someone 21:50, 10 September 2008 (UTC) delete places |undue weight on a glorified ad campaign, which can and should be covered in prose within Mario Super Sluggers. The article is a guide in every sense, being nothing more than a list of URL card locations and instructions on how to unlock other materials - |Wikipedia is not a guide Deletion of Mario Super Sluggers Collectible Cards WP:UNDUE||WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
19211 19061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solomon Walusimbi User:GiantSnowman 15:28, 15 February 2021 (UTC) keep he might fail but I think there is enough in-depth coverage about this person to satisfy . Article needs improving, not deleting Deletion of Solomon Walusimbi WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19212 4848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of minor Star Wars Jedi knights User:Ridernyc 21:19, 6 November 2007 (UTC) delete per lot and . No real world context at all. There is already a Star Wars Wiki for this type of content Deletion of List of minor Star Wars Jedi knights WP:P||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Portal 85
19213 9942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zak Ringelstein User:Luftfall 06:33, 21 July 2018 (UTC) keep Received recent substantial coverage for his arrest and endorsement by Democratic Socialists. I would expect coverage to only grow with time. Also, as per above, received coverage for his notability in business and advocacy. Definitely doesn't fail as notability isn't restricted to candidature Deletion of Zak Ringelstein WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19214 2204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/INC Research User:Theseeker4 15:28, 13 November 2008 (UTC) delete Could not find any hits that established notability of company, fails Deletion of INC Research WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19215 15 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Official Slasher Movies. User:Reyk 20:50, 9 June 2011 (UTC) delete """inherently |original research. The article seems to be advocating that there is such a thing as an """"official"""" slasher movie, and trying to convince people that certain movies ought to be included. Read the comments in parentheses sprinkled throughout the article and it'll be obvious that it's a lot of personal opinions""" Deletion of List of Official Slasher Movies. WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19216 13748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alain Paul Martin User:Xxanthippe 22:52, 28 May 2012 (UTC) delete Cites on Google scholar are 11, 4. Totally inadequate for rof#C1. Fails other rof categories as well Deletion of Alain Paul Martin WP:P||WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
19217 16977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Occupations of the future User:Hrafn 16:14, 4 February 2009 (UTC) delete Mostly and wikipedia's not a ball for such speculation Deletion of Occupations of the future WP:OR||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:No original research 65
19218 12182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joyous Celebration (2nd nomination) User:Mattg82 23:19, 23 January 2020 (UTC) delete There maybe some offline sources but there is nothing available atm to satisfy and and help fix this wikt:dog's breakfast|dog's breakfast Deletion of Joyous Celebration (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19219 19538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bidenism User:Celestina007 20:41, 18 November 2020 (UTC) delete I concur with both nom & {{u|Missvain}}. This is definitely a scenario Deletion of Bidenism WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
19220 10957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Persian Gulf Organization User:آرش 18:38, 28 September 2011 (UTC) keep As I checked the article now, it contains enough independent reliable sources to meet Deletion of Persian Gulf Organization WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19221 19729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yewande Sadiku User:Falcon 06:03, 18 December 2020 (UTC) delete No sustained coverage in . The beginning of the article is rearranged from the first paragraph of the promotional page the nominator linked, odd capitalization and all. She's very accomplished and has much to be proud of, but this does not make her notable, and it's faintly possible that this is a vanity page Deletion of Yewande Sadiku WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19222 19179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elliot Minor User:RFerreira 20:33, 7 October 2007 (UTC) keep Meets as mentioned more than once above Deletion of Elliot Minor WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19223 6870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annie George User:Bearian 20:49, 27 June 2012 (UTC) delete """I read over the same sources, but I don't see |how those sources cover her significantly. We only have bare-bones material about her. It depends on how one interprets """"sources address the subject directly in detail, so no original research is needed ... more than a trivial mention but it need not be the main topic of the source material."""" The sources cited do address her directly, but details about her life are missing. The articles address her work, with only passing or trivial information about her""" Deletion of Annie George WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
19224 1664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corruption in Cuba User:Luis 15:12, 5 April 2009 (UTC) comment Cosmic Latte, this is not for merging discussions. You can e bold|be bold and merge the content into Politics in Cuba if you want Deletion of Corruption in Cuba WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
19225 19317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thug-u-cation User:J04n 10:55, 5 January 2010 (UTC) delete agree with above, can find no reliable sources but must say that I was suprised to find this http://sciencestage.com/g/3095736/thug-u-cation.html. Does not meet or Deletion of Thug-u-cation WP:NALBUMS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19226 13153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transfer art User:AllyD 20:55, 2 May 2013 (UTC) delete """The article text is a strange combination of uncited high claims (""""finally leaving behind"""", """"advancement"""") and mundane |how to guide. No |evidence found to establish any notability""" Deletion of Transfer art :WP:NOTHOWTO||:WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19227 8216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Munchausen by Internet User:Lightburst 13:25, 21 July 2020 (UTC) keep I realize that we do not care about hits on an article. however I looked and this one sinceJanuary 1, 2020 has 18,581 page views which is 92 per day day. This appears to be a well researched and referenced article. I looked to see if it was synth or OR, and it smacks of it in places. So the article needs ambitious editing, to pare, and reference and remove any synth, however notable topics are not deleted based on needing work. . WP:ATD-M is a possibility of the paring gets down to a reasonable length as to fit it into the merge target mentioned above: Factitious disorder imposed on self Deletion of Munchausen by Internet WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
19228 14784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Invasion OS User:Ryan 20:50, 18 August 2010 (UTC) delete Just another Linux clone (openSuse) claiming to be for the average user (and most Linux clones claim to do this nowadays...). Dime a dozen. No sources, nothing on google, fails Deletion of Invasion OS WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19229 12460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Filmörnen (3rd nomination) User:Sam 23:59, 8 February 2017 (UTC) merge to Värmlands Filmförbund. Our |deletion policy encourages |alternatives to deletion, and when an article as {{History|Filmörnen}} receives ~2-3 edits per year it is safe to assume that a |bold merge would have been met with little opposition. I have added a few sources, removed a dead site from external links (nothing worth linking to archive.org), and updated another external link. Värmlands Filmförbund in itself needs secondary sources, so we could hope that a -M outcome of this discussion brings us closer to that goal Deletion of Filmörnen (3rd nomination) WP:DP||WP:ATD||WP:MERGEINIT||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19230 12738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bat World Sanctuary (3rd nomination) User:MisterUnit 16:01, 28 November 2012 (UTC) keep Per the above listed sources, the sources currently referenced in the article (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bat_World_Sanctuary&diff=525217536&oldid=525217480 current diff here in case it changes) AND the first AfD on this page. I don't understand why this has been nominated for deletion so many times, it is clearly notable. This article should be kept and future nominations for deletion should be Speedy Kept per Deletion of Bat World Sanctuary (3rd nomination) WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19231 18568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of writing systems by adoption User:Batard0 16:28, 22 October 2012 (UTC) merge per others. requires that the subject of the list be covered ''as a group'' in reliable sources, and I can't myself find anything that treats writing systems by adoption as a group of things Deletion of List of writing systems by adoption WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19232 21 [[Ulrich Grosse]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Dealerofsalvation NONE keep Kasten|. Hauptsächlich per Wahldresdners unwidersprochenem Beitrag vom 16. Februar, zusammen mit den im Artikel angegebenem Spiegel-Artikel und SWR-Beitrag, halte ich „… Person, dessen Werk oder Arbeitsleistung als herausragend anerkannt und dauerhaft Teil der Geschichte des Fachgebiets geworden ist“ gemäß #Lebende Personen (allgemein) für nicht zwangsläufig, aber erstmal hinreichend wahrscheinlich erfüllt. Gerne aber kürzen, was sich nicht belegen lässt und weitere Quellen einfügen Löschung von Ulrich Grosse Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
19233 1585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Macedonian Cross User:SWik78 14:10, 17 July 2008 (UTC) delete """None of the claims made by the article could be verified by any of the 200+ http://www.google.ca/search?hl=en&q=%22Macedonian+Cross%22&meta= Google hits for """"Macedonian Cross"""". This is nothing more than """ Deletion of Macedonian Cross WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
19234 13461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Operation Waverider User:Anotherclown 09:03, 22 March 2015 (UTC) delete non-notable per due to lack of coverage Deletion of Operation Waverider WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19235 6476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wild animal suffering user:Andrew 13:54, 24 April 2016 (UTC) keep The nomination's claims are clearly false. For example, the source ''https://global.oup.com/academic/product/nature-red-in-tooth-and-claw-9780199596324?cc=us&lang=en&# Nature Red in Tooth and Claw'' was written by a professor and published by a university press. The topic is quite notable and our |editing policy applies Deletion of Wild animal suffering WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
19236 7710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Rothenberg (activist) User:SanAnMan 14:03, 4 May 2016 (UTC) comment the article has been redirected and all links in this AfD page corrected to reflect the new article title David Rothenberg (activist). However, I still believe is rather questionable, as almost all sources cited are a book from the subject. See also article author's very similar article Fortune Society which has also been flagged for potential GNG issues Deletion of David Rothenberg (activist) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19237 10183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stanley McKessock User:Tsistunagiska 17:42, 26 January 2021 (UTC) delete Non-notable per basic notability criteria . search reveals nothing of consequence Deletion of Stanley McKessock WP:N||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19238 16627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carol Daniels User:JohnCD 08:20, 2 September 2009 (UTC) delete """fails and #NEWS. In fact the article was first created as """"The Murder of Carol Daniels"""", which avoids , and then moved (wrongly, in my view) to """"Carol Daniels""""; but it fails #NEWS either way""" Deletion of Carol Daniels WP:BIO1E||WP:NOT||WP:BIO1E||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19239 4779 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Koulik Bhattacharjee User:PCock 11:42, 1 April 2017 (UTC) delete He does seem to be a talented kid who may accomplish enough to meet our notability guidelines in the future, but I don't see the significant independent coverage to meet at this time Deletion of Koulik Bhattacharjee WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19240 18936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Beasley User:RoySmith 00:35, 18 June 2014 (UTC) keep For a modern subject, I would be inclined to say there are insufficient sources to pass , but for historical figure, sources are scarcer and harder to find, so the single item in ''The Sydney Mail'', especially considering it's an Australian newspaper writing about an Irish rider, strikes me as sufficient Deletion of William Beasley WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19241 2691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gavin Hoyte (2nd nomination) User:Jrphayes 11:19, 4 March 2008 (UTC) delete Fails , though I do think this could be one of the cases were we use common sense and keep it, as one of the highest profile -failing players Deletion of Gavin Hoyte (2nd nomination) WP:BIO||WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19242 17202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ram Shanker User:Shovon76 16:35, 19 June 2008 (UTC) keep As a professional player playing in a professional league, passes Deletion of Ram Shanker WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19243 6332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeffrey Vinokur User:Kinu 08:08, 27 August 2010 (UTC) delete does not appear to meet as a dancer or any other way Deletion of Jeffrey Vinokur WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19244 12539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neil Rhind User:CAPTAIN 19:50, 17 January 2017 (UTC) keep as nom.Notable uthor Deletion of Neil Rhind WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
19245 16352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norman F. Douty User:Cullen328 04:30, 23 April 2011 (UTC) keep He meets as a past president of Cornerstone University. He was also a prolific author Deletion of Norman F. Douty WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19246 20041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Ireland User:Fenix 17:29, 25 December 2009 (UTC) comment Several editors have stated that the references indicate notability. Clearly they indicate that the article subject has attracted attention, however no one who has made such statements has made any attempt to link them to . Disregarding the obvious socks / trolls here, the article appears to be leaning towards keep, no one has made any attempt to assert notability other than the arguement that a press article = notability. Aside from the other issues with this discussion is becoming very confusing. I am happy for the article to stay if notability is established, but no source quoted in the article asserts notability of the individual, they all focus on events he has organised, events that themselves do not appear notable temselves, making it hard to justify te article subject's notability Deletion of Tim Ireland WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19247 7683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex The Soccerbear Cast User:Alfadog 14:35, 24 December 2007 (UTC) delete Clearly fails and that is sufficient grounds for deletion Deletion of Alex The Soccerbear Cast WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19248 21692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Torture in china prisons User:Bfigura 04:10, 11 April 2008 (UTC) delete We already have Human rights in the People's Republic of China. No need for this |orginal researchy |NPOV essay Deletion of Torture in china prisons WP:OR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
19249 17963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Mary of Czestochowa Parish (Middletown, Connecticut) (2nd nomination) User:Orlady 15:36, 31 January 2011 (UTC) merge to Polish-American Roman Catholic parishes in New England, Roman Catholic Diocese of Norwich), ''and'' Middletown, Connecticut, and redirect to one of these. I can't find much of anything to suggest that this church is individually |notable. Based on the reference list in the article and the results of Google searching, I've concluded that whatever notability is possessed by this church/parish is largely historical and in connection with Polish immigration in the late 19th and early 20th century. The Polish-American parishes article is currently a list, but its text components could (and should) be expanded to include more information on the context and history of the establishment of these churches/parishes. http://www.middlesexhistory.org/exhibits/poles.htm This page about the history of Middletown (this is the one relevant page from a larger website that is listed on the articles reference list) indicates that the establishment of this church was a significant event in connection with the growth of Middletown's Polish population. There probably is a similar story to be told about Polish churches throughout the Diocese of Norwich, and the stub about the diocese could be expanded to include that history. Discussion of this church/parish in those three other articles would be an effective way to present the little information that exists about it -- and more valuable to the encyclopedia than attempting to make a stand-alone article about a topic that is not independently notable Deletion of St. Mary of Czestochowa Parish (Middletown, Connecticut) (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19250 19001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nerea Gabirondo User:Alvaldi 11:34, 27 April 2021 (UTC) delete No on the subject hence she fails Deletion of Nerea Gabirondo WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19251 4675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yuuka Akama User:श 18:51, 30 September 2018 (UTC) delete no evidence of qualifying the requirement of Deletion of Yuuka Akama WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19252 15468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pro Beach Hockey User:The 18:09, 22 January 2017 (UTC) delete as failing Deletion of Pro Beach Hockey WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19253 7270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Folkcracy User:Joe 13:48, 4 June 2010 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Folkcracy WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
19254 14632 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ray B. Oladapo-Johnson User:Binna 23:42, 20 October 2020 (UTC) comment """Please note that I was originally blocked for submitting this petition for article deletion. However I was unblocked as the """"paid editing"""" accusation was re-evaluated. I am not being paid in any direct or indirect way for this article petition. My unsponsored, objective, view that this article does not pass muster . One New York Daily News reference does not merit a person having their own article, namely one that blatantly fails . If anything, as previously stated, merge into a section on High Line of notable people, of which there are https://www.thehighline.org/leadership/ many others""" Deletion of Ray B. Oladapo-Johnson WP:SIGCOV||WP:NOTRESUME Wikipedia:Notability 77
19255 20245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/December 2017 Melbourne car attack User:power 06:18, 22 December 2017 (UTC) keep with no prejudice against renomination in a month's time. Per ; it's impossible to demonstrate that there won't be long-lasting coverage at this time Deletion of December 2017 Melbourne car attack WP:RAPID Wikipedia:Notability 77
19256 19895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Giorgia Simonato User:Sir 23:29, 8 November 2013 (UTC) delete She has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Giorgia Simonato WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19257 16333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Capri Everitt User:Z359q 23:48, 8 April 2018 (UTC) keep """There seems to be quite a few news stories with significant coverage about this subject including international coverage as well as Canada, US, India, Ireland and others available. I added a cross section of references to the article, including one titled, ''16 Girls Who Changed The World"""".'' She was #9. This article passes and should be kept and expanded""" Deletion of Capri Everitt WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19258 1991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Mitchell (2nd nomination) User:Delta13C 09:09, 6 January 2016 (UTC) keep The guy passes GNG and BLP given the good coverage. The article also appears to already be de-|fringed, but a bit more may be in order Deletion of Jonathan Mitchell (2nd nomination) WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
19259 16641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Denis (YouTuber) User:Rhododendrites 03:18, 19 April 2020 (UTC) delete Fails &mdash Deletion of Denis (YouTuber) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19260 12017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Citation needed User:Ritchie333 21:29, 10 October 2013 (UTC) merge """to Wikipedia:Citation needed. """"Citation needed"""" is a bona fide meme, according to http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/citation-needed Know Your Meme. It's a nice history, but I wouldn't consider the site a reliable source. The meme has lead to the phenomenon of ''Wikiffiti''--citation needed stickers being placed on dubious public assertions--as reported in http://makezine.com/2008/01/02/wikiffiti-citation-needed/ Make, http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-15037358.html The Boston Globe, http://reason.com/archives/2008/02/28/artifact-the-world-needs-citat reason.com, and http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/ideas/brainiac/2008/01/citation_needed.html boston.com. There is also a http://www.amazon.com/Citation-Needed-Wikipedias-Worst-Writing-ebook/dp/B005W55IVE book with this title. Together, these sources show that the Citation needed is verifiable in reliable sources, but not enough are both reliable and in-depth to pass notability per . But the topic warrants a merge into the main article on this topic, per and -M. I agree with""" Deletion of Citation needed WP:GNG||WP:PRESERVE||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Notability 77
19261 3804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elijah Daniel (2nd nomination) user:fourthords 14:59, 18 July 2017 (UTC) keep """because """"Declined prod"""" is not a #REASON|reason for deletion, and looking at the article currently at Elijah Daniel, I don't see any myself""" Deletion of Elijah Daniel (2nd nomination) WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19262 11493 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Give it a Name User:Northamerica1000 07:18, 28 January 2015 (UTC) keep Meets upon a review of sources posted above by {{U|Paul Erik Deletion of Give it a Name WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19263 20121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff King (consultant) User:Shearonink 22:58, 22 July 2017 (UTC) delete Fails , , & . Mr. King is the son of and is/was the campaign manager for his father Steve King, the Congressman from Iowa, but I have been unable to find any in-depth |reliable sources that cover Jeff King (apart from his job in his father's campaign) in depth Deletion of Jeff King (consultant) WP:ANYBIO||WP:NPOL||WP:GNG||WP:IRS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19264 2634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timeline of Batman User:Apostrophe 08:41, 10 February 2007 (UTC) delete WP:NOR and a plot summary. The idea of an absolute timeline for a DC character is ridiculous, as adherence to such a timeline, if it exists, is never a concern for writers. Also, where are the sources for exact years? Where is the source of Jason Todd becoming robin and dying in the same year Deletion of Timeline of Batman WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19265 16270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roy Geronemus User:David 18:57, 19 August 2020 (UTC) keep per #C1 and maybe #C6 as above Deletion of Roy Geronemus WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19266 7644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derivation of the Cartesian form for an ellipse User:Ozob 13:13, 17 July 2016 (UTC) delete It's not OR (I believe it dates back to Descartes), but it's not of encyclopedic interest. Deletion of Derivation of the Cartesian form for an ellipse WP:NOTTEXTBOOK Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19267 2411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Exodus Geohaghon User:Peanut4 13:48, 21 December 2008 (UTC) keep although he doesn't meet , he easily passes Deletion of Exodus Geohaghon WP:ATHLETE||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19268 15202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sky Tao User:Quartermaster 11:40, 7 September 2010 (UTC) delete Still a poster child for self-promoting spam by a non-notable person. Blatant abuse of . Removal of all the problem elements would result in a blank article Deletion of Sky Tao WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
19269 20910 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ball sport (Battlestar Galactica) User:Colonel 15:04, 1 January 2009 (UTC) keep Article is not a hopeless case, as indicated by Hobit, and deletion is therefore not appropriate. See |policy Deletion of Ball sport (Battlestar Galactica) WP:AFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19270 21241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Torrent finder User:Gay 23:26, 2 July 2006 (UTC) delete despite also thinking it may be a useful tool, the article does not meet nor Deletion of Torrent finder WP:WEB||WP:ADS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19271 9526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fileitup media User:Docether 15:08, 26 May 2006 (UTC) delete Subject of article does not meet the notability criteria |for companies and corporations. If the author of the article includes information to the contrary in the article (criterion 1 seems most likely), then I'll revise my vote. Best Deletion of Fileitup media WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19272 12063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gentlemen of the College, The User:W 10:31, 8 June 2007 (UTC) delete Non-notable by , , lack of multiple non-trivial sources Deletion of Gentlemen of the College, The WP:BAND||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19273 4815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeltaNeutralCalendarSpreading User:Tyrol5 00:40, 6 April 2011 (UTC) delete Hybrid of an editorial and spam (i.e. it doesn't belong here per Deletion of DeltaNeutralCalendarSpreading WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19274 4596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Folklore in Uzbekistan User:Bishonen 20:41, 7 April 2016 (UTC) delete per , indeed Deletion of Folklore in Uzbekistan WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
19275 14927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hillel Neuer User:TheGracefulSlick 10:19, 9 January 2018 (UTC) merge to the its original target article. Come on guys, be objective (like Joefromrandb) please. You cannot pass those interviews and the subject's own material off as passing GNG; we all know those are |primary sources. And whoever wrote this article may have mislead you: hardly any of the sources in the article actually describe the subject! The UN Watch is notable but |notability is not inherited hence a redirect is the only reasonable solution when we evaluate this puff piece objectively Deletion of Hillel Neuer WP:PRIMARYSOURCE||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:No original research 65
19276 20085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Georgie Bingham User:Bearian 21:00, 9 March 2010 (UTC) keep while I can't find anything at http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&source=hp&q=%22Georgie%20Bingham%22&aql=&oq=&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=wn Google News about her, newscasters are |usually kept if they are prominent, see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pete Williams (journalist). I found at least one source http://www.epltalk.com/epl-talk-podcast-georgie-bingham/11139 here, but there is http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Georgie+Bingham%22+-wiki+-pedia+-blog+-facebook+-twitter+-myspace&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq= not much else out there. |She's barely notable Deletion of Georgie Bingham WP:OUTCOMES||WP:BARE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19277 11695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thirteen Thirty-Six User:Casualtyken 01:32, 13 July 2006 (UTC) comment """Thirteen Thirty-Six meets the criteria for in that it """"has been featured in multiple non-trivial published works in reliable and reputable media"""" (ie. Bill Chapin. """"Play Offs"""" Port Huron Times Herald, January 13, 2006 and Bill Chapin. “CD REVIEW: Five Ways to Kill a Pirate by Thirteen Thirty-Six” Port Huron Times Herald, April 28 2006). These articles also serve to verify the existence of Thirteen Thirty-Six and all claims made in the article, excepting the death of Justin Hearn""" Deletion of Thirteen Thirty-Six WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19278 2554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ilyas Ahmed (East Pakistan cricketer) User:Lugnuts 13:54, 18 January 2021 (UTC) keep meets . Ten days ago Deletion of Ilyas Ahmed (East Pakistan cricketer) WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19279 8905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aristidh Ruci [[User talk:137.122.49.102|talk]]) 20:54, 29 January 2010 (UTC) merge though this person may technically pass , there is insufficient information to warrant an article as all the information is already contained in Albanian Declaration of Independence (where Assembly of Vlora also redirects). At the moment, the article is nothing more than a glorified redirect.--Special:Contributions/137.122.49.102|137.122.49.102 Deletion of Aristidh Ruci WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19280 3220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Millenia Malls User:Pmedema 17:30, 17 April 2008 (UTC) delete It may pass but fails . The article may be |looking into a crystal ball but that's inconclusive Deletion of Millenia Malls WP:N||WP:RS||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19281 2812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BP Logix User:Tucoxn 04:17, 25 January 2014 (UTC) delete This article does not pass the relevant guideline for articles about companies: Wikipedia:Notability (organizations and companies). The sources are not |reliable sources and all the ''KMWorld Magazine'' sources are not Wikipedia:Independent sources|independent of the subject. |Wikipedia is not a soapbox or means of promotion Deletion of BP Logix WP:RS||WP:SOAP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19282 5253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khrystyna Pereviznyk User:Number 17:52, 18 December 2019 (UTC) delete per failure. The fact that the league is top level is irrelevant Deletion of Khrystyna Pereviznyk WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
19283 6069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Superhero Hype! (2nd nomination) User:Carrite 14:47, 18 August 2011 (UTC) comment """I took a glance at the nearly information-free, unsourced stub of a piece and I thought this was an easy call for deletion. Then I ran a simple Google search for the exact phrase """"Superhero hype"""" and came up with 1.65 million hits and that made my head swim a little. How can there be so much out there relating to a site that ends up in an article this bad? It's a bit of a mystery... Does the lack of a swarm of comic book nerds here making an impassioned defense mean that the comic book nerds have given up on Wikipedia? And if so, what does that mean? Is it worth sifting through 1,649,854 blog posts to find a few kernels of substantial independent content that will save this wretched stub? It's all very puzzling. Ironically, and it will probably drive Mr. Hammer nuts for me to say this, the simple argument seems to me to be a reasonable one. Then again, that doesn't cut the mustard with most AfD closers, who want to see (a) content worth saving and/or (b) independent sourcing. This piece has neither. And I'm done blathering without an opinion either way""" Deletion of Superhero Hype! (2nd nomination) WP:ITSNOTABLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
19284 17440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Politics of Virtual Realities User:Toddst1 21:26, 24 April 2012 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Politics of Virtual Realities WP:NOTEVERYTHING Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19285 1323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Square root of 5 User:JPG 03:39, 12 August 2007 (UTC) keep inherently notable. Part of me wants to claim bad faith nomination as user clearly has a scientific background, but I'm going to and chalk it up to being outside his field Deletion of Square root of 5 WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
19286 17774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Howarth User:NinjaRobotPirate 13:53, 6 June 2014 (UTC) comment I tried checking Bloody Disgusting and ''Fangoria'', but I didn't see anything obvious. However, he's got coverage from the other usual genre sources, such as Dread Central: http://www.dreadcentral.com/reviews/seasoning-house-2012 ''Seasoning House'' review and http://www.dreadcentral.com/reviews/last-horror-movie-the-2003 ''Last Horror Film'' review. Both reviews specifically comment on his acting. His awards got coverage from Ain't It Cool News (http://www.aintitcool.com/node/18741) and Twitch Film (http://twitchfilm.com/2007/09/time-crimes-and-mirage-man-take-home-the-hardware-at-fantastic-fest.html). These are basically reprinted press releases, but they're still coverage. Maybe he passes ? The article can probably be cleaned up enough to make it presentable Deletion of Kevin Howarth WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19287 1855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scrollback User:JugniSQ 09:00, 19 October 2015 (UTC) delete No eliable source|reliable source Deletion of Scrollback WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
19288 18587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Rose Anarchist Federation User:Huon 21:06, 26 June 2017 (UTC) comment The specific standard this article falls short of is the notability guideline for organizations, . The sources originally in the article, and those subsequently added, generally fall into one of three categories: Some are by Black Rose members, some are published on anarchist sites of dubious |reliability, and those which were published by clearly reliable independent sources only mention the Black Rose Anarchist Federation in passing - those do not represent the depth of coverage we require (see DEPTH Deletion of Black Rose Anarchist Federation WP:ORG||WP:RS||WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
19289 14646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madison Ivy User:Morbidthoughts 01:51, 19 November 2010 (UTC) keep """I dislike porn on Wikipedia, as even minors may read such articles without any oversite or regulation. But as WP:PORNBIO is being dismantled and is under dispute, it is |reasonable to then look up the hill to the very basic and relevent , which grants a """"presumption"""" of notability for multiple nominations of notable awards (even if the awards are specific to one genre). Nothing is or is not """"automatically notable"""" and it is consensus that is seen as the final arbiter. I am not myself """"assuming"""" anything, but am rather acknowleging an allowable presumption based upon guideline. As that """"presumption"""" as clarified by""" Deletion of Madison Ivy WP:COMMONSENSE||WP:ANYBIO "Wikipedia:What ""Ignore all rules"" means" 62
19290 20888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Progressive Judaism (Israel) User:Solarra 21:32, 28 July 2014 (UTC) keep per {{u|AddMore}}. exists to establish reliable sources to pull content for articles from, that is clearly done here Deletion of Progressive Judaism (Israel) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19291 14720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aurobindo Pharma User:Snotbot 06:09, 13 December 2011 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2011 December 13 Deletion of Aurobindo Pharma WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19292 10758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/24601 (number) User:Pmanderson 17:28, 12 July 2007 (UTC) merge or ''rename''' per Jao. This is certainly a meme, even if there is a flavor of about it; but it has nothing to do with the number as such Deletion of 24601 (number) WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
19293 15760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy Dawson (podcaster) User:Eggishorn 14:45, 13 June 2020 (UTC) keep No valid grounds for nomination given. Article already demonstrates |significant coverage in independent, reliable sources Deletion of Andy Dawson (podcaster) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19294 7359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bernard Chiu User:Wikipedian2 16:13, 15 April 2011 (UTC) delete Does not meet |notability or reference guidelines for Biographies of living persons Deletion of Bernard Chiu WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19295 368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rohandeep Singh User:GermanKity 16:34, 19 July 2021 (UTC) delete The references to till date did not establish the notability of the subject. fails Deletion of Rohandeep Singh WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19296 17973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Al Somah User:Sir 15:58, 22 January 2016 (UTC) keep Al Somah has played for the Syrian national team, and in the fully pro Saudi Premier League, meaning the article meets Deletion of Omar Al Somah WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19297 6206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evelyn Young User:Gidonb 01:28, 10 October 2017 (UTC) keep """This is a notable actress per : """"Has had significant roles in multiple notable films"""". The article needs more info and more referencing""" Deletion of Evelyn Young WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19298 20268 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emaar South User:Pharaoh 00:10, 18 July 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Emaar South WP:NCORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19299 12746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sometimes The World Ain't Enough User:Sam 19:01, 14 May 2018 (UTC) merge to artist article The Night Flight Orchestra for now per , it's too soon. Can be rewritten if and when the |notability guideline for recordings is met Deletion of Sometimes The World Ain't Enough WP:MUSICOUTCOMES||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19300 11815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of high-end audio equipment manufacturers (2nd nomination) User:Klausness 21:03, 26 April 2008 (UTC) keep This list needs lots of cleanup, and it's not clear that anyone's interested in putting in that kind of work. Nevertheless, a cleaned-up verison of this list would clearly be worth keeping per , and since deletion is not a substitute for cleanup, I suppose that makes this worth keeping Deletion of List of high-end audio equipment manufacturers (2nd nomination) WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
19301 11010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OneCone User:Coredesat 02:30, 26 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails , , and Deletion of OneCone WP:ORG||WP:WEB||WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19302 16035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Broke & Broken [[User talk:157.235.66.80|talk]]) 20:22, 3 November 2016 (UTC) delete Borderline and certainly . Special:Contributions/157.235.66.80|157.235.66.80 Deletion of Broke & Broken WP:NONSENSE||WP:NOCONTEXT Wikipedia:Patent nonsense 105
19303 10564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GreenEvo (2nd nomination) User:Pmedema 16:24, 17 June 2016 (UTC) keep There seems to be |reliable sources and as a government initiative I feel that it passes |notability guidelines Deletion of GreenEvo (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19304 3306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helen Guthrie User:WilliamJE 16:55, 25 March 2018 (UTC) delete per . The article was almost certainly created by a family member Deletion of Helen Guthrie WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19305 16866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nigga know technology User:HumbleGod 07:32, 5 July 2006 (UTC) delete nn blog, fails , and is a repeat offender. No reason for us to have to keep doing this Deletion of Nigga know technology WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
19306 3406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Normal Bob Smith (2nd nomination) User:Quarl NONE comment """I would like to remind everyone to debate whether the article should be included from fundamentals such as notability, verifiability, media references; does the subject meet ? Arguments about """"recreation without DRV"""" don't apply because this article is very different from the previous version (which was 1 sentence during the previous AFD), most likely created by different users; the previous AFD was hardly a concensus at 2 delete """"votes"""" followed by 1 keep """"vote""" Deletion of Normal Bob Smith (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19307 3351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carl Cashman User:E 17:22, 26 April 2018 (UTC) delete despite the fact that even the quickest gNews search https://www.google.com/search?q=%22carl+cashman%22&safe=active&client=firefox-b&source=lnms&tbm=nws&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiRmbG2udjaAhXDneAKHbq-BmkQ_AUICigB&biw=1190&bih=686 shows an unusual amount of press interest in a LibDem city council member, it is too little, perhaps merely for an article Deletion of Carl Cashman WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
19308 20450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WISE J154459.27+584204.5 User:Xanchester 00:06, 20 November 2012 (UTC) merge to List of brown dwarfs. Plausible search term, and redirects are cheap. recommends redirecting Deletion of WISE J154459.27+584204.5 WP:NASTRO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19309 9652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gulam Mohammad Meer User:Lefcentreright 20:18, 22 February 2020 (UTC) delete Fails . Losing candidate in an election and also serving as the vice president of a state party is not enough to warrant notability Deletion of Gulam Mohammad Meer WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19310 12295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JS Kabylie 1 - 2 USM Alger match 2014 User:SportingFlyer 20:55, 24 April 2020 (UTC) keep didn't expect to !vote keep for this initially, but the game does pass as it's been discussed for years in Algerian press due to the death of a player and due to the fact it's a local rivalry, and it doesn't violate because it's not written as an obituary. Desperately needs a copy edit for wording and neutrality, though, and could see it being deleted on those grounds or potentially merged into the player's article, but I think the topic itself notable Deletion of JS Kabylie 1 - 2 USM Alger match 2014 WP:GNG||WP:MEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19311 6382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Te Daré Lo Mejor User:Snottywong 18:57, 9 August 2010 (UTC) keep per , although the current sources are not very convincingly establishing notability. Article is still very |promotional Deletion of Te Daré Lo Mejor WP:NALBUM||WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19312 14732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/4-year plan User:Nwlaw63 02:58, 5 December 2011 (UTC) delete Article is a ssay - all OR. I found one reliable source for this. If someone can find a bunch more, I might reconsider my opinion (though the article would still have to be rewritten Deletion of 4-year plan WP:E Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
19313 7752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flying Tigers (TV Documentary) User:Rpclod 03:28, 23 July 2015 (UTC) delete I found nothing online other than Wiki mirrors and pirated video. The article itself provides only youtube links and no |reliable sources Deletion of Flying Tigers (TV Documentary) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19314 18222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CannaTech User:Ifnord 21:19, 19 September 2017 (UTC) delete as non-notable. It may also be , once it gets more than cursory mention in reliable sources it may cross over into notability. But, not now Deletion of CannaTech WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
19315 8321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Piper Harron User:Pburka 16:23, 7 June 2021 (UTC) keep She doesn't meet , but she's notable per . She's received significant coverage in https://www.thehindu.com/thread/arts-culture-society/article9022211.ece ''The Hindu'' (Desikan; 2016), https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_Female_Artist_in_Academia/mp27DwAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&pg=PA21&printsec=frontcover ''The Female Artist in Academia'' (Kamanos; 2019), and https://www.google.com/books/edition/Mathematical_Outreach_Explorations_In_So/uu_CDwAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&pg=PR13&printsec=frontcover ''Mathematical Outreach'' (Rosario; 2019), and her book / thesis has been reviewed in http://digitaleditions.walsworthprintgroup.com/publication/?i=566588&article_id=3302591&view=articleBrowser&ver=html5 ''MAA Focus'' (Salerno; 2019). There's some additional significant coverage in right-wing sources like ''The Daily Caller'' and ''Breitbart News'', but I don't consider those particularly reliable Deletion of Piper Harron WP:NPROF||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19316 20286 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Put Your Money Where Your Mouth Is Act NONE NONE keep like the others, is the standard that should be applied. This one has received quite a bit of coverage Deletion of Put Your Money Where Your Mouth Is Act WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19317 18859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010-2011 Worldwide protests User:N5iln 19:56, 22 February 2011 (UTC) delete unless |reliable, |verifiable sources can be found to support. No logical reason at this point to lump all protests together as as single article, since different areas are experiencing different levels of protests and for different reasons. Otherwise, one could lump the demonstrations in Egypt and the (by comparison) violent uprising in Libya together with the demonstrations in Ohio and Wisconsin Deletion of 2010-2011 Worldwide protests WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19318 13548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roadender User:Danny 01:11, 13 April 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Roadender WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
19319 19157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Post-election pendulum for the Australian federal election, 2013 User:Lexein 07:23, 30 October 2013 (UTC) comment I have a concern about notability. It's sourced to two Australian government sources, which alone aren't enough for . There may be special election-coverage notability separate from GNG. I found only two news sources, but they're not exactly independent, because AFAIK they're government owned: http://www.abc.net.au/news/federal-election-2013/guide/pendulum/ and http://www.abc.net.au/news/federal-election-2013/results/pendulum/. Can we expect discussion of this particular topic in further independent RS over the next 3 years? Just my 2c Deletion of Post-election pendulum for the Australian federal election, 2013 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19320 17765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Discovering Gloria User:Shawn 17:39, 16 June 2014 (UTC) keep seems to meet now, based on current Deletion of Discovering Gloria WP:NF||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19321 11530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wade Jackson [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart111''']] [[User talk:Stalwart111|(talk)]] 03:12, 17 October 2012 (UTC) delete """obviously non-notable. Some of the """"sources"""" don't even mention the subject. One is a LinkedIn profile and another is a Facebook status update - not a Facebook page, a status update! Don't know how you could consider them """"sources"""" for anything at all, let alone """"|reliable sources""" Deletion of Wade Jackson WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19322 16648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allen Blakemore (political consultant) User:Roxy 16:40, 17 April 2019 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Allen Blakemore (political consultant) WP:NOTADVERTISING Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19323 13087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raynes Park High School User:TerriersFan 19:03, 4 February 2009 (UTC) keep not only a high school but a specialist school with Sports Mark status. This is a former grammar school which adds to its notability. It is also the only school I have come across with a Guinness World Records|Guinness World Record which is a clear claim to notability. sources available to meet Deletion of Raynes Park High School WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19324 3336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/It Takes Two (1982 TV series) User:Cavarrone 20:57, 22 May 2012 (UTC) keep """Wikipedia doesn't require the sources are immediately cited, just that they exist. require that we search for them before nominating an article for deletion (and for voting ''delete'', too), and in a case like this it's quite easy to find book and news sources about this TV-series, including some printed encyclopedias. If even we don't do a research, """"common sense"""" tells us that a TV-series broadcasted in prime time by ABC, starred by Richard Crenna and Patty Duke, created by Susan Harris, that '''already''' includes a reliable source, it is probably notable""" Deletion of It Takes Two (1982 TV series) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19325 13999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benjamin Foster (2nd nomination) User:Luchuslu 21:33, 4 March 2013 (UTC) delete No professional bouts, no significant media coverage. Fails and Deletion of Benjamin Foster (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
19326 18920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of retailers in the United Kingdom User:Ajf773 20:07, 4 June 2020 (UTC) delete per nom and per . We already have sublists for specific types of retailers. ''There are no List of retailers in'' articles for other countries as well Deletion of List of retailers in the United Kingdom WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19327 4761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of weightlifters at the 2007 World Weightlifting Championships User:Lugnuts 10:29, 17 September 2016 (UTC) keep A clearly defined list of notable individuals. This would tie in with , specifically . The nom's reason is also very poor, citing the essay on cruft Deletion of List of weightlifters at the 2007 World Weightlifting Championships WP:CLN||WP:NOTDUP Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
19328 19377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/El Salvadorian Thriller User:LedgendGamer 06:33, 1 July 2009 (UTC) delete """Absolutely no Ghits for """"El Salvadorian Thriller"""". No references. Violates . '''''&mdash""" Deletion of El Salvadorian Thriller WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
19329 76 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Zana Gümüş Kullanıcı:destemoradestemora 11.39, 25 Eylül 2020 (UTC) delete Güvenilir haber ve kaynak yok. {{seslen|Victor Trevor}} hızlı silinsin önerisini yerinde bulmakla beraber farklı görüşleri dinlemekte elbette fayda var. Maddede kaynak verilen siteler güvenilir ve bağımsız değildir. Gerek |VP:KİŞİ yönünden gerekse genel KD kriterlerini karşılayamamaktadır Zana Gümüş'ün silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
19330 11473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TinyIDS User:Snottywong 23:18, 21 May 2010 (UTC) delete While the program is interesting, interestingness is not a requirement for inclusion in WP. Someone (hopefully without a |conflict of interest and a fragile ego) can recreate this article when/if the software gains some degree of verifiable notoriety Deletion of TinyIDS WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
19331 13725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Invisible, Inc. User:Odie5533 23:26, 30 January 2014 (UTC) keep What notability guideline for video games are you referring to? I could not find one. Regarding I believe the article should be kept since it is not a mere product announcement, but an already playable product that is receiving attention from reliable sources. The article consists solely of verifiable encyclopedic information, and much more about the game could be added to the article, particularly by looking under its previous name since the game recently changed its name Deletion of Invisible, Inc. WP:FUTURE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19332 17393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lady Christina de Souza User:Umbralcorax 16:27, 21 June 2010 (UTC) keep Plenty of out of universe information in the article, so hardly your typical one-shot character. Meets the |GNG by light years, and there's simply too much verifiable out of universe information in the article that a merge isn't a viable option either Deletion of Lady Christina de Souza WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19333 11009 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Herewini User:Hawkeye7 02:04, 12 November 2015 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet I'm afraid Deletion of Kevin Herewini WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
19334 11214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ABC For Kids Video Hits 2 User:Trident13 00:52, 24 January 2008 (UTC) delete fails . Rgds Deletion of ABC For Kids Video Hits 2 Wikipedia:Notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
19335 16106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of video game designers User:Ajf773 00:42, 13 July 2017 (UTC) keep sorry not seeing any genuine concerns with the list which seems to pass is not indiscriminate and all list entries are notable and have articles. applies Deletion of List of video game designers WP:LISTN||WP:CLN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19336 16978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RightHook.org User:Pboyd04 23:05, 28 December 2005 (UTC) comment Liface can you post proof of notability (and which part of it meets) if so I will withdraw the nomination Deletion of RightHook.org WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
19337 18761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Sallah User:Fenix 11:19, 8 September 2014 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Omar Sallah WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19338 17203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The World's most northern NONE NONE comment Where do you draw the line with |stuff like this? We are missing the world's most northerly and southerly brothel, fish and chip shop, car exhaust centre, ceramic tile store, electrician, plumber (That's Joe, right?), bedding store, brickworks, coal mine, carpet manufacturer, sewage treatment works, iron works, canal, sex shop, wheelchair manufacturer. This is a load of indiscriminate information. Even if an item can be verfied it is only verified as ''existing''. What verifies that it is the most N or S? Schott's Miscellany, yes. Wikipedia, no Deletion of The World's most northern WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
19339 20803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher King (options trader) User:Jack 14:25, 6 March 2017 (UTC) delete Does not meet either or criteria. No other secondary sources available on search. Appears |promotional Deletion of Christopher King (options trader) WP:ANYBIO||WP:GNG||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19340 19941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barack Obama fly swatting incident [[User: Allen3|Allen3]]'' [[User talk:Allen3|talk]] 20:32, 24 June 2009 (UTC) delete as per #NEWS with a healthy serving of Wikipedia:Recentism on the side. Just because something make a news cycle does not mean it automatically becomes encyclopedic Deletion of Barack Obama fly swatting incident WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19341 7364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IMG Models User:Northamerica1000 23:22, 4 October 2018 (UTC) merge to IMG (company): -M that will improve the suggested merge target article Deletion of IMG Models WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19342 10585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bond girls User:Ridernyc 00:40, 3 November 2007 (UTC) delete fails lot and . Massively popular or not you still have to follow policy Deletion of Bond girls WP:P||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Portal 85
19343 19183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BlueTie (3rd nomination) User:JFHJr 20:48, 16 May 2013 (UTC) delete The Information Week review is insubstantial especially as to . The PC Magazine review is closer to substantial, but it alone isn't multiple. Defending patents and press release news isn't coverage of the company itself, nor is it reliable when fodder news is clearly based on press releases Deletion of BlueTie (3rd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
19344 7373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jay Nordenstrom User:Terence 01:32, 12 October 2006 (UTC) delete advertising, Deletion of Jay Nordenstrom WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19345 6030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phousseyne Diaby NONE NONE delete Subject fails . The criteria and subject's scoring on them are presented herebelow Deletion of Phousseyne Diaby WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
19346 8871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lil Cory User:Antonioatrylia 01:44, 3 April 2017 (UTC) delete As per CAPTAIN RAJU just does not meet . Fails to meet GNG with no significant coverage in Deletion of Lil Cory WP:MUSICBIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19347 18528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Limbo 41414 User:Carolfrog 00:02, 9 July 2007 (UTC) delete The references listed do not qualify as independent third-party |reliable sources. The article has no content that is not advertisement for the subject company Deletion of Limbo 41414 WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19348 3280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of postal codes in Portugal User:Lightburst 18:52, 2 April 2020 (UTC) delete a good example of Deletion of List of postal codes in Portugal WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19349 9990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mundial de tango NONE NONE keep spaced ndash}} The topic passes . Some sources Deletion of Mundial de tango WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19350 10351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anu Emmanuel User:Northamerica1000 21:13, 10 November 2015 (UTC) keep Meets , albeit on a weak level. Sources include: {{cite web|url=http://english.manoramaonline.com/entertainment/interview/anu-emmanuel-making-a-comeback-in-nivin-pauly-action-hero-biju.html|title=Meet Anu Emmanuel, the prettiest Nivin Pauly fan|work=ManoramaOnline}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.ibtimes.co.in/anu-emmanuel-heroine-nivin-paulys-action-hero-biju-photos-646868|title=Is Anu Emmanuel heroine of Nivin Pauly's 'Action Hero Biju'? |date=16 September 2015|work=International Business Times, India Edition}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.sify.com/movies/anu-emmanuel-is-nivin-s-heroine-in-action-hero-biju-news-malayalam-pjrgJhgijcfge.html|title=Anu Emmanuel is Nivin’s heroine in `Action Hero Biju`|work=Sify}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.deccanchronicle.com/150917/entertainment-mollywood/article/anu-emmanuel-back-after-study-break-be-nivin%E2%80%99s-pair|title=Anu Emmanuel back after study break, to be Nivin’s pair|work=Deccan Chronicle}}. These sources were all added to the article after all of the delete !votes above, except for the last one directly above (see https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Anu_Emmanuel&action=history Revision history Deletion of Anu Emmanuel WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19351 16466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OYO Rooms (2nd nomination) User:Oshwah 02:07, 14 July 2016 (UTC) keep Per the reasons I stated in the first |AFD discussion of this article Deletion of OYO Rooms (2nd nomination) WP:AFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19352 5778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Airwolf Themes User:Trevj 02:37, 13 November 2013 (UTC) merge to Airwolf, per Deletion of Airwolf Themes WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19353 15103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional radio stations User:Canley 13:24, 14 January 2007 (UTC) keep easily maintained, absolutely verifiable from both primary and secondary sources. #IINFO? I'm baffled, which part applies so rigourously to these fictional list articles, Axem Deletion of List of fictional radio stations WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19354 1938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of current professional wrestling champions User:Lugnuts 09:39, 11 June 2014 (UTC) keep """This is a list of notable champions held by notable people from notable promotions. The inclusion criteria would clearly be '''notable''' promotions - IE they have an article here. Looking at the List of professional wrestling promotions, there aren't really that many current promotions. Unsourced? . It can't be that hard to source. By looking down the list, may of them seem to have sub-lists of champions by belt, which as Featured Lists in their own right. """"Original search""""? Haha, no. Unmanageable list? Wrong again. And that's not a valid rationale for deletion either. Basically the two deletion nominations smack of """ Deletion of List of current professional wrestling champions WP:SOFIXIT||WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Be bold 9
19355 10205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Toland User:Kimchi 23:44, 21 March 2006 (UTC) delete article provides no assertion of notability, refer to . http://www.google.com/search?q=%22james%20toland%22 514 google hits, but for the (apparently unrelated) writer of an Ireland travel guide. &mdash Deletion of James Toland WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19356 21380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcel Heinig User:Jminthorne 04:51, 6 May 2010 (UTC) comment """I took a second look at this one and am less sure if it should be a delete. indicates that the subject should compete at the professional or Olympic level (paraphrase), but I do not think think that Ultra-triathlons can be classified in either category. In any case, the subject has won some races in """"IUTA"""" events, which apparently is a (the?) ultra triathlon association. The sport itself seems only borderline notable at first glance, with the WP article less than a month old and so far not a lot of third party references. If no one else has an opinion on this article, perhaps the best thing is to close the AfD as a weak keep and hope the references improve with time""" Deletion of Marcel Heinig WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19357 18773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of PlayStation Move games User:Ansh666 20:00, 12 December 2016 (UTC) keep as the nom kindly points out, there is already a category, so by , there is no real reason to delete. I don't see the conflict with other lists, either, and it's probably too big to merge into the main article Deletion of List of PlayStation Move games WP:CLT Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
19358 1976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gosnell: The Trial of America's Biggest Serial Killer User:AlessandroTiandelli333 14:07, 23 October 2018 (UTC) keep Passes , and FILM Deletion of Gosnell: The Trial of America's Biggest Serial Killer WP:GNG||WP:N||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
19359 21960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Moonies User:B 06:36, 1 June 2006 (UTC) keep media coverage and national tours cover , but this reads more like a tribute page than a encyclopedia article Deletion of The Moonies WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19360 16038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jon Hulburd User:MelanieN 01:21, 5 September 2010 (UTC) delete All he has won so far is an uncontested primary. The article is heavily footnoted so it looks impressive, but most of the refs are duplicative or self-referential. Most of the press he has gotten is routine political handicapping, with a few mentions in stories about his far more notable opponent. Per the consensus at that is not enough to qualify as notable Deletion of Jon Hulburd WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19361 5875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of video game soundtracks released on vinyl User:ONUnicorn 01:29, 19 January 2015 (UTC) keep Lots of |reliable sources, and the mere fact that stuff like this is being released on vinyl in this day and age is interesting and possibly notable in and of itself Deletion of List of video game soundtracks released on vinyl WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19362 16513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Africa Today User:Dylanfromthenorth NONE keep Seems like a notable journal under the criteria at , and looking at the info at http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/africa_today/ Project MUSE and http://www.scimagojr.com/journalsearch.php?q=15024&tip=sid&clean=0 SJR Deletion of Africa Today WP:NJOURNAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19363 20181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fuck Buttons User:Sparklism 14:46, 27 February 2008 (UTC) keep Aside from the Pitchfork Media|Pitchfork stuff http://www.pitchforkmedia.com/article/news/48016-fuck-buttons-start-ihorrrsingi-around-on-lp-tour here and their All Music Guide entry http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&searchlink=FUCK|BUTTONS&sql=11:difixzl5ldae~T1 here, they also have a http://www.drownedinsound.com/bands/8616 page at Drowned in Sound. For me, these are reliable sources, meaning these guys meet quite easily. '''sparkl Deletion of Fuck Buttons WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19364 5033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neehar Raina (2nd nomination) User:Less 20:43, 23 May 2020 (UTC) delete I failed to find any reliable sources apart from a couple mentioning the inclusion controversy. Seems like an , but the coverage wasn't widespread either. Fails Deletion of Neehar Raina (2nd nomination) WP:1E||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19365 1369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashley Toms User:Bearian 21:05, 25 November 2013 (UTC) delete There is an allegation of notability under - that he's toured extensively in the United States. However, all the https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Ashley+Toms%22&tbm=nws&tbs=ar:1 news articles indicate local stardom in the Sarasota area only Deletion of Ashley Toms WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19366 36 [[Michael Heumann]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:S.Didam 20:53, 19. Okt. 2008 (CEST) delete Kein Artikel. |Relevanz nicht erkennbar Löschung von Michael Heumann :Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
19367 18429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Jacoby User:GRBerry 01:54, 14 September 2006 (UTC) keep """Rudimentary google searching reveals that this stub is expandable. Here is evidence of why he meets the """"Widely recognized entertainment personalities and opinion makers"""" test of : an issue involving him and the globe that caused a good deal of controversy during the 2000 election cycle http://www.massnews.com/past_issues/2000/9_Sept/900jac.htm , http://www.slate.com/id/1005659/ (and plenty more of these in the top pages of my google search); has made public appearances internationally http://biurchametz.blogspot.com/2005/05/jeff-jacoby-on-us-media-bias.html (blog, so not a RS to quote, but helps us know the range of reach); domestically, his columns have been picked up in publications in Denver (http://www.archden.org/dcr/news.php?e=379&s=3&a=7995), Texas (http://www.initiativefortexas.org/jacoby.html), and Seattle (http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/opinion/280335_bostonglobe07ww.html), all of which are a fair bit outside the Boston Globe's publishing area""" Deletion of Jeff Jacoby WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19368 178 [[London Lesbian and Gay Film Festival]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Magiers NONE keep Kasten|1=, Relevanz nach #Filmfestivals inzwischen deutlich dargestellt. Danke an Fg68at für den Ausbau. Gruß Löschung von London Lesbian and Gay Film Festival Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
19369 21560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Benson Miller User:MichaelQSchmidt 21:16, 8 February 2010 (UTC) keep per career meeting http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0589077/ and http://news.google.com/archivesearch?as_user_ldate=1992&as_user_hdate=2010&q=%22Omar+Benson+Miller%22&scoring=a&hl=en&ned=us&um=1&q=%22Omar+Benson+Miller%22&lnav=od&btnG=Go coverage meeting . Its time to use the available sources to expand and improve the article. |Surmountable issues are a reason to |keep an article, not delete it Deletion of Omar Benson Miller WP:ENT||WP:GNG||WP:ATD||WP:IMPROVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19370 13140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of role-playing game software User:Mr 20:54, 3 May 2016 (UTC) comment """Searching for the term provided nothing of this sort. There were """"virtual tabletops"""" but no """"assist software"""" like in our article. At the very least it needs a rename, but I'd see a better fit for this being merged to some related article. The main one for tabletop doesn't quite fit. But that article needs a heavy redo in any case. At this point in time probably applies to our article""" Deletion of List of role-playing game software WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
19371 21666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Beall User:AllyD 20:10, 31 December 2013 (UTC) delete I can find sourced coverage of various people named Matthew Beall, but of this one the nearest to substantial is http://artbookguy.com/matthew-beall-austere-disciplined_568.html this blog interview. Fails Deletion of Matthew Beall :WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
19372 8008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shokolat User:JamesBurns 05:13, 17 December 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability, as per Deletion of Shokolat WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19373 5765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Denner User:Guest9999 00:16, 26 March 2010 (UTC) comment the article has been cut down significantly in the run up to this discussion (see http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=John_Denner&oldid=336201519) by a user who I assume is the subject. The prior version contained some |uncited |biographical information but did give some sources which might be useful if it is decided to keep the article Deletion of John Denner WP:CITE||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19374 18428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Luke Lutheran Church User:Aboutmovies 11:19, 7 June 2008 (UTC) delete Proposed policies/guidlines carry no weight. does, and this article fails that Deletion of St. Luke Lutheran Church WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19375 19202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robbie Farrell User:GiantSnowman 15:37, 15 October 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Robbie Farrell WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19376 17394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LoanMart User:HighKing 17:33, 20 October 2018 (UTC) delete Good analysis by Newslinger above, references fail the criteria for establishing notability, fails GNG and Deletion of LoanMart WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19377 15897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reverend and The Makers User:Kingboyk 10:58, 9 May 2006 (UTC) comment It all comes down to whether touring as ''support band'' is enough to satisfy . I'm not sure what the precedent is so no vote at the moment, but my personal feeling is that as this band are unsigned (or were when I last checked), they weren't the headliners on the tour, they are not yet sufficiently notable Deletion of Reverend and The Makers WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19378 20762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Worth Dying For user:h2g2bob 00:50, 5 May 2007 (UTC) delete """fails . The band do not appear to be signed to a major record label, and their only album """"Waiting For The Last Sacrifice"""" has only the official website as a google hit""" Deletion of Worth Dying For WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19379 382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Once Upon a Time in Bolivia (2nd nomination) User:MichaelQSchmidt 19:12, 16 December 2014 (UTC) keep per ''just'' meeting . I note that |sources are available, even if not being used as citations. No need to something per . And while not as earth-stopping as an Academy Award, winning Best International Feature at London Independent Film Festival is not exactly minor Deletion of Once Upon a Time in Bolivia (2nd nomination) WP:NF||WP:NRVE||WP:KEEPLISTING||WP:NOEFFORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19380 8784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/River Oaks Baptist School User:Yakushima 15:58, 3 February 2011 (UTC) comment """I can sympathize -- but seems, if anything, a bit looser than some notability guidelines for award-winning ''people'' (depending on what they might or might not be notable for). If so, that could be a problem with the guidelines. I'd prefer more consistency among them, but am also reminded that """"a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of small minds."""" In this case, we've got multiple awards for the school -- """"automatic notability"""" from a ''single'' award (the issue you seem to raise above) isn't really on the table. So what ''do'' we have to settle, and what do we have to go on for settling it? doesn't mention """"awards"""" per se, but it does say that ''""""organizations whose activities are local in scope (e.g., a school ....) may be notable if there is substantial verifiable evidence of coverage by reliable independent sources outside the organization's local area.""""'' The award notices certainly count as """"substantial verifiable evidence"""". But do these notices ''also'' count as """"coverage ... outside the organization's local area""""? """"Coverage"""", to me, implies coverage by news organizations of some kind, but is it really that narrow? Well, let's look at the policy that links at its phrasing ''""""substantial verifiable evidence of coverage""""'': . And it says ''""""'''significant''' independent coverage '''or recognition'''""""'' An award certainly counts as """"recognition""""; whether it's """"significant"""" might be subject-dependent. If the subject is middle schools, maybe national Blue Ribbon and/or Melba foreign-language program count as """"significant""" Deletion of River Oaks Baptist School WP:ORG||WP:ORG||WP:ORG||WP:NRVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19381 4614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Medical research related to low-carbohydrate diets User:Xasodfuih 23:23, 9 February 2009 (UTC) merge I have already merged the last section (the one about metaanalyses and systematic reviews which was so far down the page that nobody here seems to have noticed it) to Low-carbohydrate_diet#Meta-analytic_studies_and_systematic_reviews. That section is entirely appropriate per , and was not included in the main article. So, this needs to be a redirect to comply with GFDL Deletion of Medical research related to low-carbohydrate diets WP:MEDRS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19382 4760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mastan Malli User:WilyD 12:34, 12 November 2008 (UTC) keep notability established |the usual way. I see no reason to make an exception in this case; rather, we should apply the usual standards Deletion of Mastan Malli WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19383 3983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leroy W. Stutz User:Peacemaker67 00:59, 11 October 2015 (UTC) delete no doubt a brave man, but doesn't appear to meet , and as a colonel without a fighting command with his awards, doesn't get close to Deletion of Leroy W. Stutz WP:GNG||WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
19384 15064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Tart (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 17:58, 15 December 2008 (UTC) keep It seems like a perfectly good little stub. It has plenty of |good cites - including trade papers and ''The Times'' of London Deletion of The Tart (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19385 21639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HillJack User:Joe 13:55, 25 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |person Deletion of HillJack WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19386 14794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diary of a Supernatural User:Atsme 18:34, 10 September 2017 (UTC) delete fails the requirements for (music) - WP is not the marketing arm for launching new careers in the music industry Deletion of Diary of a Supernatural WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19387 8580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Integral yoga User:4meter4 03:26, 18 June 2021 (UTC) keep Per jps. Passes Deletion of Integral yoga WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
19388 6908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Italian geniuses User:No 16:27, 23 January 2014 (UTC) delete """with regrets. Per reasoning on rticles for deletion/List of people who have been called a polymath, it is based on highly subjective criteria – and even the authors who wrote quoted must have applied necessarily subjective criteria. There is no objective criterion for being a """"genius"""", sorry, and the category is way too open-ended to be encyclopedic""" Deletion of List of Italian geniuses WP:A||WP:RS Wikipedia:Attribution 108
19389 8203 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan L. Langer User:David 00:40, 20 December 2010 (UTC) delete """Some stuff that should have been easy to find (anything referring to the titles of his supposed publications, or the existence of the """"Association of American Historiographers"""") turned up nothing in Google, and I was unable to verify anything else. On that basis I am inclined to believe the nominator's supposition that this is all an elaborate hoax. But regardless, it fails |verifiability""" Deletion of Jonathan L. Langer WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19390 7868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pre-verbal insult User:Endomion 17:10, 27 January 2006 (UTC) delete unless the author can comply with Deletion of Pre-verbal insult WP:CITE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19391 34 [[Oliver Haag]] (erl., gelöscht) Benutzer:Kriddl NONE delete """da unrelevanter Eintrag, oder alle Professoren jeder Hochschule ohne Prüfung aufnehmen. Ein kurzer Blick auf die Darstellung der Person, sowie in die Versionsliste und den Ersteller """"Olli the law"""" und die Verlinkung auf meinprof.de lassen auch Verstöße gegen |Was Wikipedia nicht ist Punkte 3 und 4 suggerieren. - ClausMueller""" Löschung von Oliver Haag Wikipedia:Was Wikipedia nicht ist Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19392 19494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uma Kumaran User:Tomwsulcer 20:54, 18 February 2015 (UTC) keep Numerous references where this person is the subject of the article, suggesting she meets Deletion of Uma Kumaran WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19393 9542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Latitude and wealth User:danntm 22:29, 15 March 2007 (UTC) delete an essay Deletion of Latitude and wealth WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19394 17338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Astriaal User:wknight94 02:32, 25 January 2006 (UTC) comment Unfortunately, that's not the criteria for having an article. They seem to have gotten one of their lyric sheets mirrored a zillion times on Google but that doesn't help meet . Notice what doesn't come up on Google? An official web site! Even my Aunt Irene has her own web site Deletion of Astriaal WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19395 3889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leviton User:Durova 21:45, 9 April 2007 (UTC) comment This single purpose account was created yesterday and I have blocked it for 1 month for violations of , , , , and Deletion of Leviton WP:OWN||WP:NOT||WP:NPOV||WP:VANDAL||WP:COI Wikipedia:Ownership of content 86
19396 20370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Internet Explorer 11 User:Northamerica1000 08:47, 22 October 2013 (UTC) keep """Meets . The Internet Explorer article is already at 110 kilobytes and per , articles over 100 kb """"almost certainly should be divided"""". Also, the Internet Explorer 11 article has a significant amount of content that's not present in the Internet Explorer article; a merge is not the best option, in this case""" Deletion of Internet Explorer 11 WP:N||WP:SIZERULE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19397 10777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pendulum rocket fallacy User:Levivich 17:18, 30 September 2020 (UTC) delete """because there doesn't appear to be ''any'' RS we can use to cite this content on ''any'' page. The article begins {{tqq|The pendulum rocket fallacy is a common fundamental misunderstanding of the mechanics of rocket flight}} ... well, how common can it be if we can't even find a reliable source talking about it? Bowery and Manley are self-published sources and there doesn't appear to evidence of their expertise sufficient to satisfy . The other sources are unreliable for reasons explained above. If we had an RS, then I'd say '''merge''', but so long as we don't, it should just be deleted. Otherwise we risk that this is a type of hoax, or at least, there is no support for our stating that this is a """"common"""" fallacy, and we don't need to be covering obscure fallacies that are not covered in reliable secondary sources. Our job is to summarize reliable secondary sources, and here we have none to summarize""" Deletion of Pendulum rocket fallacy WP:SPS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19398 21601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AMR Research User:Hatchens 04:39, 5 August 2020 (UTC) delete Purely a promotional article ( Deletion of AMR Research WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19399 14820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bharatyug User:WilliamH 15:57, 15 May 2008 (UTC) delete WP:NEO|Non-notable neologism/|original thought Deletion of Bharatyug WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19400 17940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Araby, Arizona User:Smartyllama 15:29, 24 February 2020 (UTC) keep Inappropriate as Blaisdell and Araby are definitely notable and this demonstrates an insufficient to bundle everything together. Kim, Asher, and Blaisdell also had their own post offices according to the articles so they're definitely notable too. As for the remaining articles (Colfred, Growler, Horn, Kinter, and Tyson), given the apparent lack of BEFORE, I'm not comfortable bundling them like this Deletion of Araby, Arizona WP:MULTIAFD||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19401 3171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UK and US counting units User:Minimac 05:47, 26 December 2014 (UTC) delete these look like a list of #DICT|dictionary definitions collected onto the same article Deletion of UK and US counting units WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19402 13791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled seventh studio album User:23skidoo 21:28, 12 August 2008 (UTC) delete as . I'm also going to cite the unofficial as well - if there's no title available, 9 times out of 10 it's crystal balling. If this article is kept, it must be renamed something less generic, such as White Stripes seventh studio album or something Deletion of Untitled seventh studio album WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19403 5430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I sucked a lot of cock to get where I am User:Newsaholic 07:35, 21 October 2008 (UTC) merge per to Tu-Plang|the album containing the song as a plausible typo for the correct capitalization Deletion of I sucked a lot of cock to get where I am WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19404 13179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moratorium (law) User:Lord 16:34, 28 June 2020 (UTC) keep My search on JSTOR and Google Books turns up discussion of ''moratorium'' as a term, rather than just usages of the term.{{cite journal |author=Kathryn A. Watts |title=Regulatory Moratoria |journal=Duke Law Journal |volume=61 |issue=8 |date=May 2012 |pages=1883–1955 |jstor=23267963}}{{cite journal |author1=Matthew G. St. Amand |author2=Dwight H. Merriam |title=Defensible Moratoria: The Law Before and After the 'Tahoe-Sierra' Decision |journal=Natural Resources Journal |volume=43 |issue=3 |date=Summer 2003 |pages=703–752 |jstor=24888861}}{{cite journal |author=Martha W. Barnett |title=Moratorium: A Growing Movement |journal=Human Rights |volume=28 |issue=3 |date=Summer 2001 |pages=3, 23 |jstor=27880266}}{{cite journal |author=Diane Albert |title=Building Moratoria: Strategies and Tools for Governing Bodies |journal=Water Resources Impact |volume=7 |issue=6 |date=November 2005 |pages=16–18 |jstor=wateresoimpa.7.6.0016}}{{cite book |title=Constitutional Law |edition=4th |publisher=Aspen Publishers |year=2010 |page=43 |isbn=978-0-7355-8944-5 |url=https://www.google.com/books/edition/Constitutional_Law/9VnUB1Y44b0C?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=moratorium+definition&pg=PA43&printsec=frontcover}} I think this is enough to pass . I oppose a merger to Debt moratorium per the above Deletion of Moratorium (law) WP:WORDISSUBJECT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
19405 12601 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leroy Jethro Gibbs (3rd nomination) User:MrDolomite 13:40, 26 April 2010 (UTC) keep """While this AfD is about a very narrow family of articles, IMHO, it is really about the larger treatment of fictional items on WP. These articles are actively edited, improving, may contain some crufty details (like most things on WP), and very likely to be recreated based on the popularity (which may or may not be equal to notability) of this TV show. While none of these four items are specifically terms in a WP policy, in my view of common sense, I am being and stating they are all reasons to keep and improve the content. Otherwise this will be a whack-a-mole game for these articles going forward and you know that someone will use this AfD to start deleting fiction all over WP, even though one AfD is not """"supposed"""" to be used as a precedent for another. All the gets old very quickly and and while I agree that there is plenty of cruft throughout WP, this AfD is not the appropriate forum for its debate. Bump it up to an RFC or other larger audience and work towards changing the policy towards fiction. Are these decent articles in need of improving? Yes. So then keep them, improve them, and move along. — """ Deletion of Leroy Jethro Gibbs (3rd nomination) WP:BOLD||WP:WIKILAWYERING Wikipedia:Be bold 9
19406 14419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethan Jamieson (actor) User:Clarityfiend 00:29, 8 September 2016 (UTC) delete Playing the male Tribute from District 4 isn't going to satisfy . The odds are not in this actor's favor Deletion of Ethan Jamieson (actor) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19407 16647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katsap (2nd nomination) User:DustFormsWords 00:43, 6 January 2011 (UTC) delete per (Wikipedia is not a dictionary). Article does not extend beyond a dictionary definition Deletion of Katsap (2nd nomination) WP:DICTIONARY Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
19408 13313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terror Titans User:T 04:50, 10 July 2008 (UTC) delete this is the comic book version of Deletion of Terror Titans WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19409 11437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ken Gorin User:BlueSalix 14:01, 16 January 2015 (UTC) delete doesn't meet Deletion of Ken Gorin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19410 12002 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pendulum Films User:MichaelQSchmidt 01:46, 4 September 2015 (UTC) delete for failing . It exists, but has made no mark Deletion of Pendulum Films WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19411 16246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Jalowiczor User:Fountains 20:59, 15 May 2017 (UTC) delete """per . No significant coverage other than being covered as a http://deerval.com/daily/?tag=russian-proverb """"dancing bear"""" - noted in a single event as a non-scientist contributing to a scientific discovery. A notable person would have an actual biography somewhere: we do not have that here - biography is cobbled together OR from disparate sources (Czech news blurb, alumni news, football websites""" Deletion of Peter Jalowiczor WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19412 3923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TWBPSK Kevin Ray's Corner Blog User:Proto 10:32, 12 January 2006 (UTC) delete Speedy delete''' as advertising if possible. Fails Deletion of TWBPSK Kevin Ray's Corner Blog WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
19413 7133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oyewole Yemi Joseph User:GiantSnowman 18:34, 5 February 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Oyewole Yemi Joseph WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19414 10903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phoenixsong.net User:Kusma 23:25, 22 January 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Phoenixsong.net WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
19415 14400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Regal Views User:Pedro 11:20, 7 February 2008 (UTC) delete on the basis that the buildings claim to notability is apparently ''Regal Views is noted throughout the region for its visibility from the local train station platform''. How underwhelming is that?? I suspect a possible |attempt by the owners to up the buildings profile Deletion of Regal Views WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
19416 2378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/7th Son (Podiobook) User:SkierRMH 09:19, 8 January 2007 (UTC) delete Couldn't get any ghits for this, ergo amongst the aforementioned Deletion of 7th Son (Podiobook) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19417 17935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Finnic Cates User:TimothyBlue 06:29, 25 January 2021 (UTC) merge """to USS Cates per above. Doesn't pass for a stand alone article, but the content will improve the target article, be less fragmented, and give the content more readership. Per , ''""""Editors may use their discretion to merge or group two or more related topics into a single article.""""'' // """ Deletion of William Finnic Cates WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19418 5626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gabrielle David NONE NONE comment I'm finding some things here and there like https://www.bostonglobe.com/arts/books/2016/07/19/the-hole-story-sweet-tale/MDbo6lrUyKeFR1b0MHzPBM/story.html this that shows that she ''might'' be notable, but if there is enough out there I'd suggest that this get -d and started afresh by a non-COI editor. There's so much puffery and promotion in the article, along with unsourced claims, that this would pretty much need to be re-written from scratch. What makes the unsourced claims problematic is that other than it posing a BLP issue, I'm concerned about some of the vague claims in other articles, like the claims of the Phatitude magazine winning an award. Neither the magazine article or website specify what this award actually ''is'', which means that it could be anything from something that could give notability to an award given out by a non-notable self-published blog or a vanity award. In other words, in an attempt to promote all things IAAS, the editors have actually done more harm than good because they've just ended up casting far more doubt on the veracity of the claims. I don't doubt that this might have happened in some form or fashion, but now we have to question whether or not any of the claims are getting puffed up beyond what they actually are. This is why COI editing - specifically article creation and the addition of major chunks of text - needs to be done very, very carefully. From a personal standpoint this is why I've refused some requests from people or organizations I'm familiar with, where the COI and issues (tone, COI) pose too much of a problem Deletion of Gabrielle David WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
19419 14061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pedro Chirino User:Carolfrog 04:48, 17 March 2007 (UTC) keep Now passes Deletion of Pedro Chirino WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
19420 8941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Risstrom (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 16:05, 3 March 2019 (UTC) delete """The title """"City of Melbourne councillor"""" isn't what it sounds like — the City of Melbourne is the local government area (what readers in Canada, the United States or the UK would understand as a ''borough'' councillor ''below'' the level of the entire city) for ''downtown'' Melbourne, not the governing body of Melbourne as a whole. So he's not a """"city councillor in a global city"""" for the purposes of , he's a person who would have to pass the """"highly sourceable as much more notable than the norm for his level of significance"""" test. And being a non-winning candidate in a federal election is not a notability criterion either, so that's not in and of itself enough to get him over the special case bar. As for the argument in the AWNB thread that his candidacy was itself a special case of greater notability than most other candidates, even that condition isn't passed just because somebody asserts it — it's passed only if and when the ''sources'' properly support it by exploding significantly ''out'' of proportion to what every other non-winning candidate can also show. But with just two media sources and a raw table of election results, that's not nearly enough sourcing to get him there. No prejudice against recreation after election day 2019 if he wins his seat, but nothing present here is convincing evidence that he's already notable enough today""" Deletion of David Risstrom (2nd nomination) WP:POLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19421 13884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Saldan (2nd nomination) User:Ventric 23:16, 6 January 2018 (UTC) delete Does not meet , specifically ; subsequently . Looking at the ref regarding the publication of a book, it was http://self.gutenberg.org/article/WHEBN0018509241/Richard%20Saldan a self-published work requiring a hard look at , regardless of the reference. Additionally the reference at https://www.pr.com/company-profile/overview/6980 pr.com is hardly sourcing. As for the subject failing , he has not opened for Penn & Teller, he has not won any international award. I find no relevant mention to performances on stage with even notable magicians. I would regard this article's existence as a Deletion of Richard Saldan (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV||WP:ENT||WP:BLPSPS||WP:SELFCITE||WP:SECONDARY||WP:ENT||WP:SELFPROMOTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
19422 4731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glam Philippines User:Bearian 18:52, 9 December 2016 (UTC) delete """They lost me at """"fusion company"""". And by """"lost me"""", I mean this is |fairly blatant spam. I'll verify in the ground next week, but if's deleted by then, no worries. ''Maligayang Pasko""" Deletion of Glam Philippines WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
19423 29 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott D. White (computer scientist) User:Kinu 16:10, 18 August 2006 (UTC) delete per due to lack of Deletion of Scott D. White (computer scientist) WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19424 5714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aparajit Deb User:Folken 21:08, 16 September 2012 (UTC) delete fails no significant coverage in secondary sources Deletion of Aparajit Deb WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19425 734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carmine Miranda User:Nagle 01:13, 17 November 2014 (UTC) keep Yes, big COI problem. I've taken a lot of hype out of the article. I think the article subject does, just barely, pass , with two recordings on a major, or at least reasonably established, label. AllMusic verifies those recordings. He did place in a major music competition, again, just barely (score 7.00, cutoff 7.00). Close call. This is classical; everything is smaller and lower-key than in pop Deletion of Carmine Miranda WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19426 16492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peeved User:Artene50 05:19, 26 June 2012 (UTC) delete per lack of Surprising this has been here since http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Peeved&action=history 2005 Deletion of Peeved WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19427 17841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cat Porter User:Captain 00:19, 12 May 2006 (UTC) keep Are all of these really good faith nominations? I don't believe they are. At best, I think we're well in territory; at worst, this smacks of vandalism Deletion of Cat Porter WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
19428 8204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nurul Nuha Anwar User:Cullen328 20:34, 26 March 2013 (UTC) delete She fails and the article consists mostly of rumor and speculation, which makes it a violation of our policy on |biographies of living people Deletion of Nurul Nuha Anwar WP:POLITICIAN||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19429 16233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KRYPTON (Programming Language) User:Flylanguage 16:17, 26 July 2011 (UTC) delete fails entirely Preceding nomination was made by {{User|Flylanguage Deletion of KRYPTON (Programming Language) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19430 9157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The greatest goalkeepers ever User:Alexius08 12:36, 14 December 2008 (UTC) delete as useless unsourced |weasel-filled article Deletion of The greatest goalkeepers ever WP:WEASEL Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
19431 7408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dwayne Cameron User:J947 05:04, 28 March 2019 (UTC) keep 2 sources in the article, from NZ's leading two online sources, who are confirmed to be reliable in many AfDs before this. Couple that with the NACTOR pass and it's a keep. I found those two on thd first page of a gnews search too, before looking at the article. At least when nominating an article here look at the article and do a search. Would provide links but on mobile Deletion of Dwayne Cameron WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19432 14678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pretoria Muslim School User:Park3r 07:22, 9 April 2021 (UTC) keep """I de-prodded the article on the basis of , and to give it a fair chance of being saved, because there is a reasonable amount of coverage in over a number of years (either as """"Pretoria Muslim School"""" or """"Tshwane Muslim School"""") e.g. https://www.iol.co.za/pretoria-news/tshwane-learners-score-big-in-matric-exams-40243590 https://citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/107426/matrics-at-muslim-school-gladly-bear-double-load/ https://www.pressreader.com/south-africa/pretoria-news/20140108/281676842754729https://www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/gauteng/triplets-spurred-to-excel-by-sibling-competition-1967250. I suppose it could be notable as an example of a community-run religious school in a township being competitive with top-tier private schools. There was a lot of unsourced material that has been removed. It's also probably got a lot more coverage from RS than many other SA schools on Wikipedia. That said is a thing, and I don't feel strongly either way ( aside, there should probably be more deletions of SA schools than less""" Deletion of Pretoria Muslim School WP:CONTN||WP:RS||WP:OTHER||WP:GLOBAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19433 7896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of international goals scored by Abby Wambach User:The 19:40, 14 April 2013 (UTC) comment """for all those voting delete, I'd like to ask if they would also ensure that all lists of international goals are removed from all international footballers, male and female, across all of Wikipedia. Voting delete here isn't really a vote to delete a |standalone list which has become too large to easily be accommodated in the main article, it's clearly a vote to remove the existence of this kind of list of goals from Wikipedia altogether. What makes a """"milestone"""" international goal? What makes a """"notable"""" international goal? I don't know. What I '''do''' know is that having a factual list of international goals, sourced correctly does not do this |computer-based encyclopaedia any harm. Deleting it, and therefore setting a precedent to remove all international goals from all articles possibly '''does''' harm what we're doing here""" Deletion of List of international goals scored by Abby Wambach WP:SAL||WP:NOTPAPER Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
19434 9539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pol Goossen User:Phil 17:46, 8 October 2011 (UTC) keep """I don't understand why this was relisted. The """"delete"""" opinions are |just assertions, but the """"keeps"""" came with evidence""" Deletion of Pol Goossen WP:JNN Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
19435 6677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frédéric Dalsace User:Qwfp 14:29, 25 August 2009 (UTC) delete in agreement with above. No sign he meets or #General criteria at present. Also note that article created by {{user| Kbelltrium}}, who seems to work only on articles associated with TRIUM EMBA, so suspect onflict of interest Deletion of Frédéric Dalsace WP:PROF||WP:BIO||WP:C Wikipedia:Notability 77
19436 3157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HKFYG Lee Shau Kee College User:The 15:29, 17 August 2013 (UTC) keep Experience shows that, with enough research, sources can almost invariably be found for high schools that meet . We must avoid systemic bias and allow time for local and Chinese language sources to be investigated Deletion of HKFYG Lee Shau Kee College WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19437 7489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moon-eyed people User:Mike 22:18, 30 April 2013 (UTC) keep """The references presented thus far are sufficient to establish the notability () of this element of Cherokee folklore. However, I also agree with some previous comments that the article should (if possible) be supplemented with contemporary scholarly analyses of this folklore motif. Via a bit of Google searching, I came across a paper with the promising title """"Of Trembling Gods and Moon-Eyed People: Ruminations on the Limits of Ethnography"""" on http://muse.jhu.edu/books/9780826348753?auth=0 Project MUSE, but alas, it is behind a paywall, so I cannot say if it is relevant or not. For anyone searching for additional sources, I'll also note that academic papers on this subject may use the original designation in the Cherokee language to refer to the """"moon-eyed people"""" instead of the popularized English translation""" Deletion of Moon-eyed people WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19438 3895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Russell Fowler User:Location 22:05, 13 June 2010 (UTC) delete Fails and . There is a lack of significant coverage in independent reliable sources Deletion of Nick Russell Fowler WP:CREATIVE||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19439 6395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maze Clays(tm) User:Ziggurat 02:38, 20 March 2006 (UTC) delete Notability is a guideline, not a grounds for deletion. Whether this is an ad or not is debatable (although the TM everywhere doesn't help matters). But pending some kind of third party Wikipedia:Verifiability|verification this article should be deleted. Note also that |Wikipedia is not for self-promotion - the creators of such a sport should not be the ones writing an article about that sport Deletion of Maze Clays(tm) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19440 2490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Two Coats of Paint [[User talk:209.30.16.190|talk]]) 17:09, 19 January 2009 (UTC) delete Clearly fails . Not notable. Special:Contributions/209.30.16.190|209.30.16.190 Deletion of Two Coats of Paint WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
19441 7861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Group Sports Management User:Spiderone 12:10, 27 April 2021 (UTC) delete references provided in the article, as well as those found in a search for independent and reliable sources, fail to address the company in enough depth to satisfy . The company therefore does not pass . Passing mentions and interviews with people associated with the company are insufficient when it comes to meeting the necessary guideline Deletion of American Group Sports Management WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19442 10061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ajit Iqbal Singh User:Pharaoh 09:58, 4 May 2015 (UTC) comment Agree with Sławomir Biały that mere membership of INSA is not sufficient . states This guideline, sometimes referred to as the professor test, is meant to reflect consensus about the notability of academics as measured by their academic achievements. For the purposes of this guideline, an academic is someone engaged in scholarly research or higher education, and academic notability refers to being known for such engagement. #C3 is to be taken in conjugation with this not in isolation of mere membership of a scientific body Deletion of Ajit Iqbal Singh WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19443 4750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ikhfanul Alam User:R96Skinner 16:13, 5 September 2019 (UTC) keep NFOOTY pass, career ongoing - currently with Arema in Indonesia's Wikipedia:WikiProject Football/Fully professional leagues|FPL-listed Liga 1 (Indonesia)|Liga 1 - which is enough for keep, based on past cases: e.g. Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mats van Kins|AfD/Mats van Kins, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Karani|AfD/Sean Karani and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danish Irfan Azman|AfD/Danish Irfan Azman. Enough out there for GNG anyway: https://suryamalang.tribunnews.com/2019/01/15/ikhfanul-alam-terpilih-sebagai-gelandang-arema-fc-mimpi-yang-jadi-kenyataan, https://www.medcom.id/bola/liga-indonesia/lKY6DQWN-jalan-panjang-ikhfanul-alam-sebelum-gabung-arema, https://www.tribunnews.com/superskor/2019/01/16/ikhfanul-alam-anggota-polisi-yang-jadi-pemain-sepak-bola-hati-saya-ingin-bermain-di-arema-fc, https://www.malangpostonline.com/read/15428/usai-insiden-berdarah-ikhfanul-alam-siap-main-lagi. No Deletion of Ikhfanul Alam WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19444 21831 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of political organizations whose name include """"Marxist-Leninist""""""" User:Realkyhick 01:07, 1 January 2009 (UTC) delete listcruft, violates """Deletion of List of political organizations whose name include """"Marxist-Leninist""""""" WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19445 19195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cardem User:JohnCD 11:03, 8 March 2009 (UTC) delete """as feeble hoax. """"The most unseasonable snowfall was on May 3, 1989"""" - time for another |SNOWfall today""" Deletion of Cardem WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
19446 7153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Brother Australia 2009 User:Townlake 19:59, 20 July 2008 (UTC) delete per . The relevant aspects of the topic are amply covered at Big Brother Australia already. http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&tab=wn&ncl=1227452182&scoring=n Here's a link to recent Google News on the topic if anyone's interested Deletion of Big Brother Australia 2009 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19447 20392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lone Wolf Real Estate Technologies User:Satori 01:27, 7 September 2006 (UTC) delete This company doesn't quite meet the notability requirements of , and the sources provided are not up to the standards of and Deletion of Lone Wolf Real Estate Technologies WP:CORP||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19448 12775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big House Publishing User:SwisterTwister 05:55, 19 July 2015 (UTC) delete My searches found nothing even in the slightest good and third-party and it's not surprising it's all PR for a recently founded company. For a future article, I strongly suggest but only when it's come closer to notability and better sources Deletion of Big House Publishing WP:AFC Wikipedia:Articles for creation 55
19449 1956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dunn Consistency Model User:danntm 02:14, 19 October 2006 (UTC) delete as |hoax, per Uncle G Deletion of Dunn Consistency Model WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
19450 18602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dennis Steele User:Valenciano 18:22, 23 June 2010 (UTC) delete no substantial coverage in reliable third party sources, only a bit of local coverage such as every political candidate gets. The interruption of the debate can be filed under and . Can be redirected to the Vermont election page and any salvagable content included there Deletion of Dennis Steele WP:ONEEVENT||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19451 14423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hot Rod Girls Save The World User:Bali 12:45, 10 April 2009 (UTC) delete no awards, no wide-spread non-trivial coverage. Clear fail on Deletion of Hot Rod Girls Save The World WP:MOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19452 18101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WED2B User:HighKing 15:18, 10 June 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and GNG Deletion of WED2B WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
19453 741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madison Pro Soccer User:SportingFlyer 05:55, 25 September 2018 (UTC) keep passes from the references provided Deletion of Madison Pro Soccer WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19454 6723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/4155 Watanabe User:Praemonitus 02:51, 2 May 2015 (UTC) merge per ; unable to satisfy notability requirements Deletion of 4155 Watanabe WP:DWMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19455 10137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rashumon User:Cyclopia 08:00, 25 August 2013 (UTC) keep Messy AFD aside, the sources provided show that it clearly meets : reviewed/discussed in a lot of reliable printed magazines in many languages. Let us remember that |notability is not temporary Deletion of Rashumon WP:GNG||WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19456 191 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Bay Pipo Kullanıcı:assyrtikoassyrtiko 06.15, 16 Ağustos 2021 (UTC) keep Kaynak eklemesi yaptım). Bu kitabın çıktığı zamanı hatırlıyorum, şuanda heralde 100 baskısını felan yapmış. 2000 yılında en çok satanlar listesinde yer almış, 3-4 ayda 8 baskı yapmıştı. Kaynak taraması yapıldığında genel sağladığı görüşüyle kalmasının daha uygun olacağını değerlendiriyorum Bay Pipo'nun silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
19457 14744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Idara-e-Amn-o-Insaf User:Rpclod 03:31, 21 January 2018 (UTC) delete most of the references are dead links. None of them provided any reference to the subject. Nothing supports criteria for notability Deletion of Idara-e-Amn-o-Insaf WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19458 14571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bloody Hands User:onel5969 20:09, 22 October 2015 (UTC) delete Because of the commonality of the name, research is difficult. This is an upcoming film with no sources. I might have missed them because of the search difficulty, but based on what I could see, does not meet Deletion of Bloody Hands WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
19459 1464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madhogaria User:Stifle 12:36, 29 March 2009 (UTC) delete per . Possible hoax Deletion of Madhogaria WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19460 17602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seema Midha (2nd nomination) User:Samat 11:58, 2 October 2017 (UTC) delete FAIL Deletion of Seema Midha (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19461 5868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Detlev Lauscher User:Vejvančický 15:08, 27 October 2010 (UTC) keep """Subject clearly meets |""""Wikipedia standards"""" for football players. Check http://www.fussballdaten.de/spieler/lauscherdetlev/ this link for verification, please. As for the circumstances of his death, see http://www.sport1.de/de/fussball/newspage_194491.html this link (requires knowledge of German language""" Deletion of Detlev Lauscher WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19462 3808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isaac Nessim User:Shizane 12:11, 12 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Isaac Nessim WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19463 13515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Local Licks Live 1999 User:Mrschimpf 02:21, 16 November 2018 (UTC) comment A |bundled nomination would make much more sense for this group of albums Deletion of Local Licks Live 1999 WP:BUNDLE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19464 11758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Runway Magazine User:Johnuniq 04:39, 25 May 2010 (UTC) delete No claim of notability; fails Deletion of Runway Magazine WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19465 9365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laxman Kagne User:Pharaoh 17:13, 1 October 2017 (UTC) delete per nom Fails Deletion of Laxman Kagne WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19466 7356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Racing Dynamics User:CASSIOPEIA 11:11, 13 January 2018 (UTC) delete Fails , primary source and promotional content Deletion of Racing Dynamics WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19467 19787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pleasure Valley, Indiana User:Necrothesp 15:38, 24 May 2019 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Pleasure Valley, Indiana WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19468 9468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of action film clichés (2nd nomination) User:The 19:18, 25 July 2006 (UTC) delete The article is all original research and has no to be found. While funny, should be deleted Deletion of List of action film clichés (2nd nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19469 5001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/REVE Antivirus User:Tpdwkouaa 20:15, 16 June 2016 (UTC) comment Additionally, {{ping|Wrtamal.bd}}, if you have a potential with the subject of this article, you should https://bd.linkedin.com/in/waliur-rashid-tamal-a1a587114 really https://twitter.com/tamalmeghbalok declare it Deletion of REVE Antivirus WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
19470 11847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Johor User:Charlesdrakew 21:03, 27 September 2018 (UTC) delete per , Deletion of List of bus routes in Johor WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19471 13099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Macy's Day Parade (song) User:Nouse4aname 09:22, 12 June 2009 (UTC) delete and '''redirect''' to Warning (album). Fails Deletion of Macy's Day Parade (song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19472 14144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brains (web series) User:Joseph2302 22:38, 3 June 2016 (UTC) delete In my view, a clear #A7|A7 candidate. Nowhere near passing or Deletion of Brains (web series) WP:CSD||WP:WEB||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
19473 78 [[Liste der aktuellen Sportsaisons]] (gelöscht) Benutzerin:CaroFraTyskland NONE delete """Die Liste entspricht nicht unbedingt den Kriterien für Listen. Das behandelte Thema ist nicht konkret abgegrenzt („aktuell laufenden Spielzeiten in verschiedenen Sportarten“), was gewissermaßen die Anforderung an Listen gemäß widerspricht, wo gefordert wird, dass Listen „ in einer kurzen, übersichtlichen Form einen Überblick über ein Thema“ geben. Zudem trifft hier der Punkt „Wikipedia ist keine Linksammlung“ von WP:Was Wikipedia nicht ist zu, denn mehr als ein Link auf einen Artikel, der gemeinsam mit dem Lemma die Information """"= laufenden Saison"""" ergibt, ist nicht vorhanden. Eventuell auch noch der Punkt „Wikipedia ist kein Newsticker oder Veranstaltungskalender.“, je nach dem, wie man das so auslegt. In der Summe ist das enzyklopädische Konzept für die Liste nicht ausreichend, sollte die Liste als Unterseite für das Sportportal oder so gebraucht werden können, so kann ist eine Wiederherstellung und Verschiebung möglich""" Löschung von Liste der aktuellen Sportsaisons Wikipedia:Listen Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
19474 5890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Smart (author) User:Colapeninsula 15:18, 21 April 2015 (UTC) keep His book ''Clarity'' has coverage in the FThttp://www.ftadviser.com/2013/07/24/ifa-industry/your-business/book-review-clarity-by-jamie-smart-UbmRzKbrNgdm5jSb9Bru9J/article.html, London Timeshttp://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/life/food/article3732432.ece, a book from reputable publisher SAGEhttps://books.google.co.uk/books?id=Ol2mBgAAQBAJ&pg=PT117&lpg=PT117&dq=jamie+smart+clarity&source=bl&ots=lZe4SUMIS4&sig=RkW65JVG0GNC_kaG49UTCMk2zy8&hl=en&sa=X&ei=Dmk2VaTpFMyksgG6joCQBw&ved=0CCAQ6AEwADiWAQ#v=onepage&q=jamie%20smart%20clarity&f=false, and there's other sources listed (which may be briefer mentions). That puts either him or ''Clarity'' over the bar for or Deletion of Jamie Smart (author) WP:AUTHOR||WP:BKCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19475 4789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suicide of Nicola Raphael User:CactusWriter 23:02, 19 December 2010 (UTC) delete """Per and . Unlike the """"see other"""" articles about suicides listed on the page, I find no evidence of significant results in this case (i.e., legislation, etc.). Unfortunately, this is only another of the hundreds of teenage suicides which occur each year as listed http://www.bullyonline.org/schoolbully/cases.htm here""" Deletion of Suicide of Nicola Raphael WP:1E||WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19476 12320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/October 2006 in video gaming User:Bearian 14:16, 28 March 2017 (UTC) delete not even close to notable; nothing more than |a fork. We already have a 2016 list Deletion of October 2006 in video gaming WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
19477 17897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teo Olivares User:Missvain 00:05, 15 January 2020 (UTC) delete He was in ''Geography Club (film)'', and has one article about him in his local newspaper (about him being in the movie) and the rest if coverage about the film or mere mentions about him being a reaccuring character on television shows. Does not meet Deletion of Teo Olivares WP:ACTORBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19478 21958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Kennedy (scientist) User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:00, 4 October 2008 (UTC) delete The article is not about Kennedy... only about what he's done. Making it a Deletion of Adam Kennedy (scientist) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19479 13630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sir Shephard Dube User:Karl 14:31, 5 May 2011 (UTC) delete Article does not meet almost meets A7 speedy deletion Deletion of Sir Shephard Dube WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19480 3732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lesson XX User:Knowledgekid87 18:47, 16 December 2016 (UTC) delete Not enough independent sources to establish notability. Also I want to say that while google is nice you have to keep in mind as well Deletion of Lesson XX WP:GHITS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
19481 14295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wasi User:Moonriddengirl 16:53, 1 March 2008 (UTC) delete The threshold for inclusion on Wikipedia is |verifiability, and currently there are no |sources to verify that this individual is |notable Deletion of Wasi WP:V||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19482 16864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Celegaytions User:Nagle 21:21, 6 April 2006 (UTC) delete per and . Basically advertising Deletion of Celegaytions WP:WEB||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19483 6519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Double Circle (film) User:Daß 20:26, 27 July 2018 (UTC) keep satisfies #4 as its sole reference as well as http://arhinet.arhiv.hr/details.aspx?ItemId=1_66804 this shows it was preserved by the Croatian State Archives Deletion of Double Circle (film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
19484 5335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Burn a Koran Day User:EnabledDanger 20:52, 9 September 2010 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a crystal ball rystal. In a couple of months we may know whether this subject is notable or not, but not today Deletion of International Burn a Koran Day WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
19485 2677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Takuya Imahori User:Pharaoh 21:28, 30 September 2017 (UTC) delete per DGG fails Deletion of Takuya Imahori WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
19486 2309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bombilla & Gourd Mate Tea User:Bearian 02:01, 18 January 2008 (UTC) delete it's not ''too'' smammy, but |the sources are very weak. It tastes like a |local beverage company to me Deletion of Bombilla & Gourd Mate Tea WP:RS||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19487 6508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Profile Defenders (2nd nomination) User:Timtempleton 01:17, 24 November 2020 (UTC) delete I'm striking my keep vote and voting delete. I just spent some more time reading the material thinking I could fix this, but on second glance the sourcing is poor. For example, the WaPost piece is an opinion column, and the Inc piece is a guest writer. If you take out the court filings there's not much left. I think it would just be faster and easier to blow it up, and only rewrite it if enough decent sources can be found. So I'm going for Deletion of Profile Defenders (2nd nomination) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
19488 5976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randy Boyd (Tennessee public figure) User:South 14:55, 5 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails , . Some bits and pieces can be merged into other articles, but not too much Deletion of Randy Boyd (Tennessee public figure) WP:NPOLITICIAN||WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19489 16323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/God in everyday life user:teh 15:50, 17 February 2007 (UTC) delete fails , , , and is thus eligible, essentially, for Deletion of God in everyday life WP:OR||WP:NPOV||WP:SOAP||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:No original research 65
19490 12014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nina Ridge User:Ohconfucius 06:03, 21 August 2006 (UTC) delete Not notable for ''being'', no notability for ''doing'' either. Unless she's a sex-symbol with a cult following which I don't know about, there's nothing on her http://www.bbc.co.uk/weather/bbcweather/forecasters/ninaridge.shtml BBC bio which points to notability per Deletion of Nina Ridge WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19491 15506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hogg Robinson Group User:Bearian 14:57, 30 July 2007 (UTC) keep per above discussion re: . I will also work on it a bit Deletion of Hogg Robinson Group WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
19492 3994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yoshihiro Homma Hisa User:Trebor 15:53, 2 February 2007 (UTC) delete unless sourced, would be nice for a linguist to take a look. From the brief description, it doesn't seem likely he'll pass Deletion of Yoshihiro Homma Hisa WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19493 18655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sylvari User:David 21:03, 29 August 2007 (UTC) merge Individual race in an |unreleased computer game. I think not Deletion of Sylvari WP:CBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19494 11316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Simpson (politician) User:Chris 18:43, 13 May 2010 (UTC) delete """Oh dear, """"Northampton North is an important seat for the Liberal Democrats, needing only a 5.86% swing to win the seat,"""" is not very subtle. Definite fail of """ Deletion of Andrew Simpson (politician) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19495 808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Hosseinzadeh User:Bearian 14:39, 7 November 2019 (UTC) delete INHERITED|notability is not inherited from the other musicians with whom you perform. Musicians, especially singers, are supposed to collaborate. Most of his songs appear to be duets. If |he's not in the national media, as admitted by the proponents, that's not our problem. It's a crime that so many talented musicians are not known, and I've been publicly vocal IRL about that situation. However, |Wikipedia is not an alternate source |of original content. When there's evidence, in reliable sources in English translation, that shows he's toured nationally/internationally, then |he would be notable Deletion of Ali Hosseinzadeh WP:SIGCOV||WP:NOT||WP:OR||WP:NARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
19496 3512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave Smith (ice hockey, born 1951) User:Hirolovesswords 06:36, 12 January 2014 (UTC) delete """Not sure if the CHL is considered a """"top-level minor league"""", but either way the subject of the article played less than 200 and did not achieve any preeminent honors, so he fails . Has not received enough significant coverage to pass GNG either""" Deletion of Dave Smith (ice hockey, born 1951) WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
19497 16443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glacier Lake School user:czar 04:13, 16 December 2014 (UTC) merge """to an entry at List of democratic schools instead of the above. School is more notable as a Sudbury Valley-style school than as a Montana school. (Fun fact—this area is actually my academic specialty, but don't ask me why that list is still a mess.) Also I understand that it's theoretically nicer to get second opinions at AfD, but """"|before"""" says to redirect wherever possible, ostensibly to save our attention for other things. This is a noncontroversial redirect czar """ Deletion of Glacier Lake School WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19498 6970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alicia Rhodes User:Dekkappai 00:41, 24 December 2006 (UTC) keep """Passes on at least two counts-- #6: """"Performer has been notable or prolific within a specific genre niche. """" 178 appearances (including three on television) listed at http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1311151/ IMDB. #7 """"There is an original film (not a compilation) named after the performer."""" ''http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0386875/ When Layla Jade Met Alicia Rhodes'', and ''http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0449966/ Hand Job Heaven All Autumn & Alicia""" Deletion of Alicia Rhodes WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19499 17184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Modern Electric User:Joe 21:33, 1 November 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |band. If this is deleted, The Modern Electric (album) should be delete also Deletion of The Modern Electric WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19500 17518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gainesville powerlines User:Bfigura 04:10, 26 April 2009 (UTC) delete as Wikipedia is |not for directions on how to get to the local powerlines Deletion of Gainesville powerlines WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19501 7048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scintilla Iceland (2nd nomination) User:davidwr 15:48, 10 November 2020 (UTC) delete """otherwise have an admin copy-and-paste the references from the deleted version to the current version's talk page and ask editors familiar with Iceland to give their notability assessments. If they say it is non-notable, then delete. If they say it is notable, then improve-in-place or, failing that, DELETE with option to DRAFTIFY if editors not """"pushing an agenda"""" are willing to clean it up. If notability cannot be determined, DELETE with option to RESTORE AS DRAFT if editors not """"pushing an agenda"""" are willing to work on it and submit it through a formal review process such as """ Deletion of Scintilla Iceland (2nd nomination) WP:AFC Wikipedia:Articles for creation 55
19502 17229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jha Jha User:We66er 19:35, 13 September 2008 (UTC) delete no beside her website Deletion of Jha Jha WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19503 18283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison between written English and written Chinese User:Colonel 01:06, 19 November 2010 (UTC) keep The nomination seems to be arguing for a merger not a deletion. Deletion would be contrary to our |editing policy Deletion of Comparison between written English and written Chinese WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
19504 15368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JkDefrag User:Nuttah68 07:02, 16 September 2007 (UTC) delete unless |reliable sources are provided. The so called references so far provided links to: a) generic defrag articles, with no mention of this software. b) This softwares web site. c) Comaparable software to this Deletion of JkDefrag WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19505 12421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackie Brockington User:Carlossuarez46 22:09, 15 October 2007 (UTC) delete per & per nom Deletion of Jackie Brockington WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19506 17500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heather Kuzmich User:Brewcrewer 09:13, 4 December 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Heather Kuzmich WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19507 19808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Selçan Hatun User:Piotrus 05:28, 16 October 2020 (UTC) delete Fails as written and I don't see better sources in my search, through I am open to considering Turkish sources if anyone can find them, maybe there is something there Deletion of Selçan Hatun WP:NFICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
19508 19244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emad Rahim (2nd nomination) User:WikiDan61 14:00, 18 August 2014 (UTC) comment """The requirements of state that ''either'' a named chair or a """"Distinguished Professor"""" position are required, not both. I believe Rahim's position as a """"Distinguished Entrepreneur-in-Residence"""" is equivalent to a """"Distinguished Professor"""". However, I agree with JohnCD's assessment of this article creation as the likely output of a banned PR firm. I recommend a |sockpuppet investigation to ascertain whether these two SPAs can be added to the existing sock farm, and if so, all of their creations (if there are any others) can be deleted under #G5""" Deletion of Emad Rahim (2nd nomination) WP:PROF||WP:SPI||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Notability 77
19509 2408 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anjaan (1956 film) User:Spiderone 11:50, 16 July 2020 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Anjaan (1956 film) WP:NFILM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19510 7819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barrington Plaza (2nd nomination) User:Kuyabribri 16:48, 25 November 2009 (UTC) comment A little bit on the history of this article that isn't readily apparent: I nominated this article at AfD yesterday on the grounds of notability (see first AfD link above). It was deleted not because of notability, but because {{user|HkFnsNGA}}—the article author and at that time its only contributor of content—blanked the page ''and'' made what I interpreted to be an explicit request for deletion on my talk page, thereby qualifying it for #G7|G7 speedy deletion. I tagged it as such and it was deleted. Personally, I would have preferred that AfD run its course, but I saw no point in keeping an article if its author and only contributor of content requested deletion. About the same time, {{user|Sancho Mandoval}} chimed in that he had found some sources to indicate the subject's notability, and requested the deleting admin to restore the article, which he did. '''No opinion''' on deletion this time around, but I ask the nominator to clarify the rationale for deletion, as the one cited is not valid Deletion of Barrington Plaza (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
19511 16359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/El Cielito Café User:Devokewater 20:04, 26 October 2020 (UTC) delete not notable, fails Deletion of El Cielito Café WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19512 20459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TELL MAMA User:Several_Times 18:04, 17 November 2012 (UTC) keep It's clear that many of the sources are not reliable, independent sources. The remaining links, including press releases from sources not directly affiliated with the organization, should be enough to establish notability as per . I agree that it may be a case of Deletion of TELL MAMA WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
19513 19935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Linglewood Lodge User:Sallicio 16:15, 19 May 2009 (UTC) delete fails . References don't establish Deletion of Linglewood Lodge WP:ORG||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19514 21456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Padmalal Sandungahawatte User:onel5969 22:43, 7 July 2017 (UTC) delete Can't find any in-depth coverage to show that they pass Deletion of Padmalal Sandungahawatte WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19515 669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Leisure Coffee User:PJM 04:08, 19 February 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. A band that would pass would turn up in a Google search. It's bullocks Deletion of The Leisure Coffee WP:NMG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19516 9478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Todd Akin rape and pregnancy controversy User:Agnosticaphid 22:19, 22 August 2012 (UTC) keep for now in light of . This article and event are a moving target if I've ever seen one Deletion of Todd Akin rape and pregnancy controversy WP:RAPID Wikipedia:Notability 77
19517 11829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hurricane Katrina as divine retribution User:I9Q79oL78KiL0QTFHgyc 16:21, 21 March 2016 (UTC) comment No opinion as to whether this article should be kept. It is the result of trying to contain some of the nonsense surrounding conspiracy theories about Hurricane Katrina which were polluting main articles. Arguments that articles like this one are forks are certainly worthy of consideration. For more background see Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Alternative theories regarding Hurricane Katrina (3rd_nomination) and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Supernatural attributions of Hurricane Katrina Deletion of Hurricane Katrina as divine retribution WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
19518 18329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mysurfpad User:Misterdiscreet 21:50, 17 September 2008 (UTC) delete per http://news.google.com/news?q=mysurfpad. doesn't do anything to establish |notability Deletion of Mysurfpad WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19519 21749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashok Kundapur User:SonicChao 16:07, 24 November 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Ashok Kundapur WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19520 1111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/José Antonio Solano User:Amalthea 21:57, 8 August 2008 (UTC) delete agree with the nomination. The Segunda División B|third level league is neither fully professional nor a national leage, so topic falis and even Deletion of José Antonio Solano WP:ATHLETE||WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19521 10139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Holly Butcher User:SD0001 19:57, 14 March 2020 (UTC) delete per nomination and per (which applies to recently deceased individuals as well, in addition to just BLPs). All media coverage exclusively revolves around the letter she wrote Deletion of Holly Butcher WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19522 10613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helen Berg User:Bearcat 18:35, 17 December 2020 (UTC) delete unless somebody can improve the articles. Corvallis is certainly a significant enough city that a mayor ''could'' get in the door if his or her article were substantially well-sourced, but it isn't large enough to confer an automatic inclusion freebie on all of its mayors in the absence of a demonstrated pass — and while Helen does include a bit more content about specific aspects of her mayoralty than inadequate articles about mayors usually do, that means it's starting down the right path but doesn't mean it's reached the finish line. If all you've got for sourcing is two death announcements and her announcement of her retirement, all in the local media where coverage of mayors is simply ''expected'' to exist, then that's not enough in and of itself. And Alan's even worse, being cited ''only'' to a namecheck of his existence in his wife's death notice rather than any coverage ''about him'', and offering literally ''none'' of the substantive content about his mayoralty (specific projects he spearheaded, specific effects he had on the development of the city, etc.) that would required. The bar for mayoral notability is considerably higher than just being able to offer minimal verification that the person exists or existed as a mayor — it requires a lot more substance, and a lot more sourcing, than either of these articles is actually attempting to show Deletion of Helen Berg WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19523 8383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swetank gupta User:Lemongirl942 07:15, 26 June 2016 (UTC) delete There are literally no third party sources to even verify the facts in the article. The subject is the founder of a non-notable company. The few sources available http://i4d.eletsonline.com/sixth-annual-baramati-initiative-9-11-march-2006-maharashtra-india-2/, http://ehealth.eletsonline.com/2011/08/best-mhealth-project are from a questionable source and even then, doesn't cover the subject in detail. This fails by a wide margin Deletion of Swetank gupta WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19524 6285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peruvian region name etymologies User:LaundryPizza03 21:07, 29 May 2021 (UTC) delete Zero references, |dictionary material Deletion of Peruvian region name etymologies WP:NOTDICT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
19525 10320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin2Smoove User:Yunshui 09:39, 29 May 2020 (UTC) comment Please see my comments on Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kobi Arad (2nd nomination); the article creator is part of a persistent paid editing sockfarm and I would recommend early closure under |CSD G5 Deletion of Martin2Smoove WP:G5 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
19526 16224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Klook User:TonyBallioni 18:33, 30 December 2017 (UTC) delete the notability guideline is abundantly clear that passing the GNG is not a guarantee of inclusion. It must also must not fail our other policies and guidelines, such as , which is a policy. As such, it is excluded from Wikipedia as promotionalism. Notability doesn't matter Deletion of Klook WP:NOTSPAM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19527 1943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mad Hatter Studios User:JMHamo 11:42, 1 March 2014 (UTC) delete Fails comprehensively Deletion of Mad Hatter Studios WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19528 18799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amrapali Jewels NONE NONE comment """u|Cunard}} please stop posting these overly long posts. Your style of linking is great and appreciated but there's no need for you to include so much text. A one or two line summary is far better. Also, please take a read of - in particular what """"independent"""" means. You appear to not understand the meaning of """"intellectually independent"""" as most of your links (on AfDs related to organizations) fail this test - ''Too often a related party produces a narrative that is then copied, regurgitated, and published in whole or in part by independent parties (as exemplified by churnalism). Independent content, in order to count towards establishing notability, must include original and independent opinion, analysis, investigation, and fact checking that are clearly attributable to a source unaffiliated to the subject.'' Also, you appear to deliberately ignore parts of articles that categorically state they are based on sources affiliated with the subject and omit quotations/interviews from your selections in an attempt to make the article appear intellectually independent""" Deletion of Amrapali Jewels WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19529 1454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chukka boot User:Belovedfreak 18:21, 22 April 2008 (UTC) keep plenty of coverage in |reliable sources demonstrates notability Deletion of Chukka boot WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19530 2311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blacksteel and Badger User:Quarl NONE delete per The Anome - |non-notable band, |vanity. &mdash Deletion of Blacksteel and Badger WP:MUSIC||WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19531 20773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/You Can Dance - Single Edits of Album Remixes User:Euryalus 10:39, 13 November 2008 (UTC) delete the |notability criteria for albums makes clear promo-only versions are generally not notable, and articles that are litle more than a track listing may be appropriately merged if possible. This promo version scored an arguably notable chart hit in February 1988, but all other references to it are in the context of the main ''You Can Dance'' album which was released on the same day. All of the information in this article already appears in the page relating to the mainstream album of the same name Deletion of You Can Dance - Single Edits of Album Remixes WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19532 10018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ravi murdianto User:IJA 13:46, 13 January 2015 (UTC) delete Fails as he hasn't played in a |fully professional league and he doesn't have any senior international caps Deletion of Ravi murdianto WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19533 9003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Japanese people User:Badagnani 04:39, 24 October 2007 (UTC) keep """Our users are in need of sourced, annotated information about notable Japanese individuals as contained in this article. Improve, don't delete, if you have our users in mind. There is no reason in WP's guidelines that calls for us to hamper our users' research by entirely blanking this article. As seen by the many similar deletions over the past months, this delete proposal seems to have been made solely to prove a , and the case that our users should not be permitted to have a well sourced, annotated list of individuals of this notable group has not been convincingly made. Neither has the case been made that a category """"does the same job,"""" as a category is clearly not sourced and properly annotated, organized by occupation and date of birth and death, etc. If editors within the community of editors active in Japan-related article (who work together at Wikipedia:WikiProject Japan decide that they wish to split this article into sub-articles, then we should let them make this decision, via consensus of editors knowledgeable in this subject""" Deletion of List of Japanese people WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
19534 10482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wing Ding User:Bearian 20:32, 7 January 2021 (UTC) delete per |poor coverage; however, Nickleback|everyone's most hated band performed, so it could be re-created if good sources were found Deletion of Wing Ding WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
19535 14994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ad feminam User:Bearian 15:31, 6 August 2011 (UTC) merge to Ad hominem per Malik Shabazz and as a sensible closure Deletion of Ad feminam WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
19536 4054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lyndal Eckersley User:Jayvdb 00:41, 5 June 2007 (UTC) delete http://www.faess.jcu.edu.au/soe/alumni.html real person however the article is full of wikt:claptrap|claptrap. Fails Deletion of Lyndal Eckersley WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19537 12811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seamus Coleman User:Parslad 00:21, 25 February 2009 (UTC) comment I'm new to AfD discussions and am a little confused by an (apparent) lack of consistency. In this recent discussion Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Gardner (curler) the consensus was overwhelming that this curler meets both and despite the fact that he '''may''' only have played in tournaments where prize money was on offer, with no evidence he had actually won any. Seamus Coleman has played competitive football in a top level national league of an important footballing nation and now has a professional contract with one of the largest teams in Europe AND has Under-21 caps AND has significant coverage in Irish newspapers and some from the UK and that's less noteworthy than Chris Gardner?? Many of the players in the LOI are on full time, professional contracts. I understand that it is not a '''fully''' professional league but the fact that it is a top level league of a significant country and not the fifth or sixth level of e.g. England or a larger country surely allows a degree of flexibility over the precise definition of thlete? As for the comments that he fails I wonder if the reports had been in the largest circulation newspapers of the USA or England would there be doubt over ? Sorry if I'm well wide of the mark here, but it is a little confusing Deletion of Seamus Coleman WP:N||WP:A||WP:N||WP:N||WP:athlete Wikipedia:Notability 77
19538 425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Church of the tragical Christ User:Fan 22:25, 28 August 2006 (UTC) delete for now until more evidence can be found through intensive investigation. Those are |the rules here Deletion of Church of the tragical Christ WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19539 16451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Histeria! characters User:DHowell 20:00, 18 July 2007 (UTC) merge """to Histeria! or '''keep''' if it would make the article too long. says """"'''''Minor characters''' and minor treatments of such matters as places and concepts in a work of fiction are '''Wikipedia:Merge|merged''' with short descriptions into a ''""""List of characters.""""'' This list resides in the article relating to the work itself, unless it |becomes long, in which case a separate article for the list is created.''"""". This seems to be an explicit exception to the |stand-alone list guideline which says that """"''Ideally each entry on the list should have a Wikipedia article''""""; which makes sense as seems to only apply to mere lists of links (with some annotation), not to heavily annotated lists such as these. As for real-world context, there was a http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-53693276.html promotion with Subway restaurants featuring toys of various characters, and reliable sources do exist (e.g. http://home.comcast.net/~reidlee1/anim/histeria.html this syndicated column) for more information, in addition to web sources such as http://www.angelfire.com/tv/enhist/ Encyclopedia Histeria""" Deletion of List of Histeria! characters WP:FICT||WP:SIZE||WP:SAL||WP:SAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19540 8617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JZ Moyo High School User:Tovian 15:56, 8 August 2008 (UTC) keep per Deletion of JZ Moyo High School WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19541 21137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A8 expressway (Shanghai) User:STSC 22:05, 28 July 2013 (UTC) merge As per -R Deletion of A8 expressway (Shanghai) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19542 15442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eboni Boykin User:David 19:00, 28 February 2020 (UTC) keep In-depth reliably-published news stories from multiple sources, over multiple years, that are primarily about her give her a clear pass of . It doesn't matter whether we think she's not the sort of person who should be worthy of becoming notable Deletion of Eboni Boykin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19543 6856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emir Dautović User:Fenix 12:57, 8 January 2014 (UTC) delete per above, a case of by the looks of things as has not played in |fully professional league or senior international team. Agree with GS regarding routine coverage, but happy to change if in depth interviews / discussions with / of the player can be sourced, not just transfer speculation Deletion of Emir Dautović WP:TOOSOON||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Too soon 40
19544 7483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slovetzian User:Kinu 06:31, 18 May 2007 (UTC) merge to The Beautician and the Beast. Also, if possible, merge any useful content there, as that article could benefit from expansion, such as some properly sourced information from here. However, the amount of |secondary information out there (i.e., excluding |original research based on viewing the movie itself) probably does not lend to a standalone article that would pass Deletion of Slovetzian WP:RS||WP:OR||WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19545 4311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rajeev Janardan User:ThaddeusB 22:36, 16 May 2009 (UTC) keep per diligent |WP:AFTER performed by Deletion of Rajeev Janardan WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19546 16896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dog-gone Sauce User:OGBranniff 06:54, 9 March 2013 (UTC) keep From the sources it looks like multiple non-trivial coverage in reliable media sources. Therefore passes . Thank you Deletion of Dog-gone Sauce WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19547 20855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CAOS Linux User:Ahunt 22:19, 2 April 2021 (UTC) delete the article does not even come close to . The Computer World ref cited does not even mention it, the Infiscale ref is just a passing mention and the readyspace ref is about the founder, not the OS. The remaining ref is . Just a discontinued, non-notable Linux distro. Sure, it is an ancestor of CentOS, which is notable, but notability is Deletion of CAOS Linux WP:GNG||WP:PRIMARY||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
19548 18939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam James William Mckay User:Kinu 23:19, 6 February 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Adam James William Mckay WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
19549 10972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jefferson Stein User:EverybodyEdits 06:05, 26 September 2020 (UTC) delete Look: There's just not enough. Deletion of Jefferson Stein WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
19550 15622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ali Mohamed Essa Eshaqi User:Spiderone 12:05, 12 December 2015 (UTC) delete I can't find any reliable sources on this person; the article therefore fails Deletion of Ali Mohamed Essa Eshaqi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19551 8300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kolachi (film) User:KGirlTrucker81 23:31, 18 September 2016 (UTC) delete It's just and I think Deletion of Kolachi (film) WP:TOOSOON||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Too soon 40
19552 5179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amin Affane User:Mattythewhite 16:10, 14 March 2012 (UTC) delete Fail and Deletion of Amin Affane WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19553 18267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jerry Balmuth User:XOR 00:56, 27 August 2019 (UTC) keep Passes #C5 for holding an endowed professorship Deletion of Jerry Balmuth WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19554 15240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AC-DC (song) User:Rollidan 17:07, 7 June 2019 (UTC) delete could not find any independent sources (or any more sources for that matter), fails Deletion of AC-DC (song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19555 19708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eastside Sun User:Barek 21:16, 24 November 2010 (UTC) delete per |notability criteria and nom criteria. No significant coverage by |reliable sources Deletion of Eastside Sun WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19556 21361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tracksuit Rock User:Ohconfucius 15:28, 22 June 2009 (UTC) delete not notable and notability not asserted (and so tagged); - also fails Deletion of Tracksuit Rock WP:YOUTUBE||WP:RS Wikipedia:External links 76
19557 9758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohd Zaidi Napiah User:Alzarian16 01:25, 8 July 2010 (UTC) delete as failing . Unless someone can find a source that actually states that he played for a professional team, rather than just being registered for them, possibly meeting is meaningless Deletion of Mohd Zaidi Napiah WP:V||WP:ATH Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19558 4916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Temples of Taichung User:Prisencolin 01:46, 12 March 2021 (UTC) keep WP:AFDNOTCLEANUP, needs to some especially with sourcing but this a very valid topic about rich architectural and cultural history. Passed as many of the entries has their own article, as can be more clearly seen in :Category:Temples in Taichung Deletion of Temples of Taichung WP:NLIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
19559 4402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of women with very long hair User:Crystallina 03:11, 18 December 2006 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not |an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of List of women with very long hair WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19560 283 [[Nobelkarossentod]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:MittlererWeg 20:38, 12. Okt. 2009 (CEST) delete Versuch einer |Begriffsetablierung. ! Löschung von Nobelkarossentod Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
19561 14746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cory Gunz (2nd nomination) User:Ron 00:08, 9 May 2010 (UTC) comment Since this article is a |BLP, a little more participation would be helpful before closing Deletion of Cory Gunz (2nd nomination) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19562 12783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fictional Dartmouth College alumni NONE 17:36, 28 April 2007 (UTC) delete """indiscriminate collection of fictional characters with nothing in common except when they were being thought up the author picked """"Dartmouth"""" instead of some other school. The existence of a Medal of Honor winners or a cryogenically frozen characters list |has no bearing on whether this article should exist. '''''Under no circumstances''''' should this list be merged to any article on Dartmouth or its alumni""" Deletion of Fictional Dartmouth College alumni WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
19563 9044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Ionics User:Coredesat 08:17, 27 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails . Not a speedy candidate since the article's been around for a while Deletion of The Ionics WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19564 12646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boytjie points User:Monty845 19:26, 3 October 2011 (UTC) delete Per and . Sorting out whether a neologism is notable enough for inclusion is not really something a CSD should do, unless the article includes hoax level statements Deletion of Boytjie points WP:NOT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19565 4723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avijit Arya User:Melcous 21:56, 18 December 2017 (UTC) delete per nomination. A source shows up a bunch of |self promotion, much like this seems to be Deletion of Avijit Arya WP:BEFORE||WP:UGC Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19566 7233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Edward's College, Gosford User:Recurring 12:07, 21 June 2007 (UTC) keep Notable enough, and the Central Coast Express should cover Deletion of St. Edward's College, Gosford WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19567 9791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clone Manga User:Tokyogirl79 03:35, 4 September 2012 (UTC) comment I'm doing a bit of a search on the Joe Shuster Award and I'm not seeing where this is so tremendously notable that winning one would keep the article on that merit alone. It does somewhat extend notability but I'm not seeing where it's tremendously notable. As far as webcomic creators go, Fred Gallagher is pretty notable in the webcomic world and is one of the very, very few people I'd consider to be notable enough to have a blog count towards notability. I'll see what I can do for the article, but offhand this needs pretty much an almost complete rewrite in many sections. It reads like a fan page rather than an encyclopedic entry. It's pretty |puffy in places Deletion of Clone Manga WP:PUFFERY Wikipedia:Wikipuffery 0
19568 3530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheki Arzaga User:Hzh 15:57, 23 January 2019 (UTC) merge to MNL48. Same rationale as with Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sela Guia|Sela Guia - per , {{tquote|members of notable bands are redirected to the band's article, not given individual articles, unless they have demonstrated individual notability for activity independent of the band, such as solo releases.}} The article can be recreated when she has achieved notability as an individual Deletion of Sheki Arzaga WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19569 19539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Group urban User:Shawn 16:20, 2 December 2016 (UTC) delete per nom and . I've looked at the three references we can access and they all seem to be talking about urban groups in different senses (and one is a tertiary source, an encyclopedia, which may not be considered a reliable source.) I'll keep a watch on this, but I don't know that we have a distinct concept here Deletion of Group urban WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
19570 18990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Symbol support vote.svg User:Javit 13:39, 9 June 2007 (UTC) delete Tagged #G6 Deletion of Symbol support vote.svg WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
19571 16743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amy Cohen-Corwin User:RayAYang 17:55, 28 October 2010 (UTC) keep A search on MathSciNet suggests that her research days are behind her (last reviewed publication was in 1992); however, I think she would pass criterion 4, judging from the numerous service awards and the effort she's put into mathematical teaching, with a possible pass of criterion 8 based on her role as managing editor of Selecta Mathematica. FYI: Her research cites from MathSciNet go 12,11,6,4,etc. She has also published as Amy Cohen, Amy Cohen Murray, or Amy C. Murray Deletion of Amy Cohen-Corwin WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19572 7653 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quarentine User:Carlosguitar 18:33, 14 September 2007 (UTC) delete per Zetawoof. Also fails and Deletion of Quarentine WP:ATT||WP:N Wikipedia:Attribution 108
19573 17569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Etihad Liberal Press User:Edwardx 13:46, 13 April 2016 (UTC) delete Fails . No 3rd part reliable sources Deletion of Etihad Liberal Press WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19574 2534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drogbaism User:Richmeister 06:58, 29 August 2007 (UTC) delete per PC78 below - #G10 Deletion of Drogbaism WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
19575 6436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thameside Radio User:NASCAR 21:27, 6 October 2007 (UTC) delete NN radio station and mostly |OR Deletion of Thameside Radio WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19576 8077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kiernan Majerus-Collins User:Beemer69 17:02, 3 February 2016 (UTC) delete """Not notable in the slightest, and I'll echo everyone else saying . """"He gained attention by attending a Trump rally"""" - seriously""" Deletion of Kiernan Majerus-Collins WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
19577 5975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas McNutt User:Boleyn 15:18, 2 August 2017 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet or . My first idea was a redirect to Collin Street Bakery, which mentions McNutt. However, I think there's a high chance that would misdirect people who are actually looking for Thomas MacNutt. I appreciate the efforts {{u|Flatoncsi}} has gone to in an attempt to rescue this, but although there's a possibility the election itself meets our notability criteria, McNutt himself just does not Deletion of Thomas McNutt WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19578 5989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RAS syndrome (2nd nomination) User:LinguistAtLarge 17:53, 23 June 2009 (UTC) keep """We should improve sourcing and expand notable subjects, not delete them. For proof of |notability, see Uncle G's comments above. If the article's title """"RAS Syndrome"""" is not the most widespread term used to describe this phenomenon, then that should be discussed on the talk page, and the article moved, not deleted. — """ Deletion of RAS syndrome (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19579 11135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruby Jacenko User:HMSSolent 04:45, 22 February 2013 (UTC) delete per LibStar, no assertion of notability, fails Deletion of Ruby Jacenko WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19580 7598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aloy (rapper) User:Z0 08:18, 26 May 2018 (UTC) delete No notability, fails and . » Deletion of Aloy (rapper) WP:GNG||WP:MBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19581 53 [[K.D.St.V. Staufia Bonn]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Liberaler Humanist 18:52, 2. Apr. 2013 (CEST) delete Es ist nicht wirklich zu erkennen, in welchem Punkt die RK erfült werden, ist auch nicht wirklich umgesetzt Löschung von K.D.St.V. Staufia Bonn Wikipedia:BLG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19582 16755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frederic Arthur Martens User:Green 20:15, 13 November 2013 (UTC) delete Fails the pilot is not a renowned figure (ie. someone famous before the incident). The event itself lacks persistence so does not appear to have had lasting social impact. on the national news headlines. This could become notable if he is written about in books in the future, or movie made about him, or the case is overturned causing a corrupt judge to be disgraced or sent to jail, etc.. out of the ordinary that impacts wider culture Deletion of Frederic Arthur Martens WP:CRIMINAL||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19583 14526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark McNulty (footballer) User:Loitid 09:10, 5 April 2011 (UTC) keep They satisfy , they have received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject Deletion of Mark McNulty (footballer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19584 7080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Systems Distributors User:Joe 21:41, 13 November 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |company Deletion of Systems Distributors WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19585 17537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fauxtography User:WilyD 12:41, 10 August 2006 (UTC) delete WP:OR, |Not for things you pull out of your butt, |WP:So many policies Deletion of Fauxtography WP:NOT||WP:NEO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19586 14694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon Curtis (actor) User:Joe 03:17, 2 August 2009 (UTC) delete All that I can find is trivial mentions. Simon Curtis has only had one major role and one minor role. Fails Deletion of Simon Curtis (actor) WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19587 11344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tokio Uchida User:Logan 02:24, 9 January 2011 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Tokio Uchida WP:INHERIT||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
19588 7680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Cabinda User:Dainomite 20:19, 11 January 2016 (UTC) keep It's just a article and that's perfectly acceptable. It meets GNG as others have mentioned. Just because no one has fleshed out the article isn't a reason for deletion, there's . — Deletion of Jason Cabinda WP:STUB||WP:NORUSH Wikipedia:Stub 114
19589 14588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theologian of Christianity [[User_talk:Bradv|Brad]][[Special:Contributions/Bradv|v]] 22:16, 3 September 2018 (UTC) delete We already have Theology and Christian theology. This article is redundant. As a personal essay, it also fails Deletion of Theologian of Christianity WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19590 8631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randall Hicks User:Ret 14:52, 5 February 2017 (UTC) keep It clearly meets and . Randall Hicks is skilled person who is an expert in his field. Therefore, I agree that the article is notable Deletion of Randall Hicks WP:NAUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19591 5246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anna M. Cienciala User:Xxanthippe 01:40, 2 January 2011 (UTC) delete GS cites are 25, 11, 8, 4 .... Inadequate to meet rof#C1. Emeritus does not help; by that time achievement should be apparent Deletion of Anna M. Cienciala WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
19592 19110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Archimedes, Inc. User:Ohconfucius 04:50, 16 November 2010 (UTC) delete per , and per the nom's very well laid-out arguments. Although the article does not appear to have Peacock terms, it still does come across as slightly |promotional for a company that is under the bar as far as our notability criteria are concerned Deletion of Archimedes, Inc. WP:SOAP||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19593 10678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pizza delivery in popular culture (second nomination) [[User: Allen3|Allen3]]'' [[User talk:Allen3|talk]] 18:44, 17 June 2008 (UTC) delete """as per |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information. While the """"improvements"""" have addressed some of the verifiability and original research problems that lead to this articles initial AfD deletion, no amount of sourcing will be able to overcome the problem that a list of every mention of pizza delivery made in a book, television show, or movie is an unbounded list of Wikipedia:Handling trivia#Connective trivia|unimportant connective trivia. All useful information, such as the use of pizza delivery as a stag film MacGuffin, has already been merged back into the Pizza delivery|appropriate parent article""" Deletion of Pizza delivery in popular culture (second nomination) WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19594 19749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of PNAC Members associated with the Administration of George W. Bush User:Collect 14:55, 14 March 2015 (UTC) delete """SYNTH in making a claim that anyone who signs anything at all ''related'' to an organization is therefore a """"member"""" of that organization. Uses such ''wonderful sources'' as Lewrockwell.com for conspiracy articles making such assertions. Violates by making implications that living persons engaged in a conspiracy. Violates by failing to include a whit of balancing material about any person. Violates by using sources which are clearly not usable for contentious claims about living persons. Uses the classic """"guilt by association"""" fallacy through use of a table """"connecting"""" individuals who are not otherwise """"connected."""" And so on. I believe the proper term here is """"POV pushing list making a POINT"""". To the extent that it intrinsically and deliberately violates multiple policies, it should not be """"merged"""" but should be salted thoroughly. A neighbor of my aunt was caught up in McCarthyism, I see no reason to endorse that same logic today. It is noted that personal anecdotes have no relationship to policy, and at least one editor interprets this as attacking him personally, even though it was given only to show my personal state of mind about such SYNTH usage""" Deletion of List of PNAC Members associated with the Administration of George W. Bush WP:BLP||WP:NPOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19595 13930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Open source CRM software [[User talk:137.122.49.102|talk]]) 20:50, 1 June 2010 (UTC) delete it's a list but most of the entries are not notable, thus it's an unnecessary list article. Just went through and prodded most of them for lack of |notability and independent |sources (and speedied one which had been deleted via discussion and recreated with no improvement).--Special:Contributions/137.122.49.102|137.122.49.102 Deletion of Open source CRM software WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19596 17667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Balda User:Fenix 13:51, 19 September 2014 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of David Balda WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19597 19550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ghani Automobile Industries User:Mfarazbaig 08:53, 26 May 2017 (UTC) keep The company is . Therefore, keep and improve. See: https://tribune.com.pk/story/931740/tricky-business-manipulators-spread-rumours-to-raise-stock-prices/ Express Tribune, https://tribune.com.pk/story/1389495/ghani-autos-loss-comes-rs6-6-million/ Express Tribune & http://nation.com.pk/business/10-May-2017/no-financial-criminal-can-hide-from-secp The Nation Deletion of Ghani Automobile Industries WP:LISTED Wikipedia:Notability 77
19598 15361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mrs. Fun User:Bakazaka 20:39, 23 February 2019 (UTC) keep """Obvious failure, as group easily passes . Quick newspaper database search finds hundreds of hits, including profiles like """"Mrs. Fun likes to take liberties."""" Mackie, John. The Vancouver Sun, 19 Jan 1989: E5, or """"Fun musical collaboration had roots in grade school."""" Luhrssen, Dave. Milwaukee Journal, 06 July 1990: d2, or """"Funky fun duo continues club hop."""" Point, Michael. Austin American Statesman, 02 Dec 1993: 14""" Deletion of Mrs. Fun WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19599 2166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Taemin User:SoWhy 12:20, 3 July 2017 (UTC) merge to List of Produce 101 Season 2 contestants per -R. Really people, why do we need to delete everything that can easily be handled differently? Regards Deletion of Kim Taemin WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19600 14019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Brandon Brown User:Paulmcdonald 03:52, 5 February 2013 (UTC) keep """Clearly passes with multiple third party reliable sources on the subject. ESPN, USA Today, Fox Sports for example. #NEWS clearly does not apply as this is not (1) a first-hand report, (2) routine reporting, (3) a Who's Who, nor (4) a diary. For a so-called """"local affair"""" it sure is getting a lot of national coverage""" Deletion of Murder of Brandon Brown WP:GNG||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19601 12038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert J. Vezina User:onel5969 16:15, 19 May 2021 (UTC) delete clearly not enough in-depth coverage from independent, reliable sources to meet Deletion of Robert J. Vezina WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19602 7678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timea Nagy (activist) User:Mkdw 19:19, 15 November 2015 (UTC) keep Dirtlawyer1 essentially outlined everything. |AFD is not cleanup nor should it be used to promote nuking the article. If the topic is notable and its contents are supported by reliable sources, then we start to tread into POV when discussing removing wholesale sections of it Deletion of Timea Nagy (activist) WP:SURMOUNTABLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
19603 2641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sheep Tag (Warcraft III) User:Protonk 05:35, 5 May 2008 (UTC) delete Boy, the socks are out tonight. It doesn't MATTER if you think it is fun. I think the Myth II WWII mod was fun. that doesn't mean it gets an article in wikipedia. It gets an article in wikipedia if it is |notable, contains |verifiable information from |reliable sources and can allow the article to be written in a POV|neutral point of view. Otherwise, it should be deleted Deletion of Sheep Tag (Warcraft III) WP:N||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
19604 12309 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big hair User:Colonel 23:26, 23 March 2010 (UTC) keep This is basically a pseudo-nomination - a case of without any basis in policy Deletion of Big hair WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
19605 12758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/High Spirits (short story collection) User:Tchaliburton 21:24, 12 August 2014 (UTC) keep """I would think that this meets #5: """"The book's author is so historically significant that any of his or her written works may be considered notable. This does not simply mean that the book's author is him/herself notable by Wikipedia's standards; rather, the book's author is of exceptional significance and the author's life and body of written work would be a common subject of academic study."""" Robertson Davies is among the most studied Canadian authors""" Deletion of High Spirits (short story collection) WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
19606 19368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Josephs User:NuclearWarfare 21:31, 23 October 2010 (UTC) delete """clearly fits : """"If reliable sources cover the person only in the context of a single event, and if that person otherwise remains, or is likely to remain, a low-profile individual, we should generally avoid having an article on them""" Deletion of Adam Josephs WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19607 5227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammadreza Khalilighazi User:RadioFan 19:27, 30 March 2010 (UTC) delete """autobiography, fails lacks coverage in 3rd party sources. This same editor has created another article on a computer science """"method"""" he """"created""" Deletion of Mohammadreza Khalilighazi WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19608 16688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jag Mag User:Caknuck 22:45, 3 May 2017 (UTC) delete No assertion of notability, no |reliable sources. And judging by the edit history, it looks like one of the principal article authors is one of the publication's contributing staff members Deletion of Jag Mag WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19609 3550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ghulam Kibria Khaki User:Maashatra11 12:08, 9 June 2010 (UTC) delete Fails wp:N and wp:V. No sources provided, doesn't meet the notability criteria for authors ( Deletion of Ghulam Kibria Khaki WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19610 6000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/November 9th, 2010 Southern California Missile Launch User:Anotherclown 20:20, 11 November 2010 (UTC) delete fails and is unlikley to be notable in the future (given the now obvious outcome of the investigation Deletion of November 9th, 2010 Southern California Missile Launch WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19611 21078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of plants of Collin County, Texas User:Bearian 16:16, 27 December 2010 (UTC) delete basically |original research for it is based on a single primary source Deletion of List of plants of Collin County, Texas WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19612 4136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Randles User:Whpq 17:01, 23 July 2013 (UTC) delete Game Inventor's Guidebook'' is a good source, but Boardgamegeeks is not a |reliable source. I don;t see any other significant coverage that would indicate that Wikipedia's inclusion criteria are met Deletion of Paul Randles WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19613 8640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Southern Ohio Patriots User:Dhartung 22:28, 18 February 2007 (UTC) delete fails / notability standards. I haven't found anything that indicates a link to the NFL team Deletion of Southern Ohio Patriots WP:CORP||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19614 21709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erin Hanson (2nd nomination) [[User talk:104.163.148.25|talk]]) 04:29, 25 February 2018 (UTC) delete """the museum show mentioned is a very low level show. In fact https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/st-george-art-museum-st-george?select=On8aaDMwDlbQOK6NlSYl6A Yelp has a picture of the actual show in question. One might also note that a """"museum show"""" is not the same as being in the permanent collections of several notable museums, per . A search turns up nothing in terms of RS. I cannot see what the page had as it has been blanked. If you know anything about the history of art and contemporary art, you can also see that her paintings are extremely run of the mill and do not constitute anything innovative or particularly original that would meet rtist. If her work was in fact original and innovative, we'd see her in permanent collections, reviews and books. We see her work not in those notability-causing things but rather the few run of the mill local news items mentioned above. Ergo, she is not notable in any way. Special:Contributions/104.163.148.25|104.163.148.25""" Deletion of Erin Hanson (2nd nomination) WP:ARTIST||WP:A Wikipedia:Notability 77
19615 13798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elijah Daniel (2nd nomination) User:Sagecandor 14:45, 18 July 2017 (UTC) delete This guys fails to be notable enough to have an article. The article is full of unreliable sources (social media, random blogs), manipulated sources, subjetivity (, and remember . I also see a clear case of by user Deletion of Elijah Daniel (2nd nomination) WP:NEUTRAL||WP:NOTPAPER||WP:OWNERSHIP Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
19616 10435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2015 Jhelum attacks User:Mfarazbaig 15:33, 11 October 2017 (UTC) keep Satisfies and . See: http://tns.thenews.com.pk/manufacturing-intolerance/#.Wd44I4-Cy1s The News, https://www.dawn.com/news/1221446 DAWN, https://tribune.com.pk/story/995808/after-factory-mob-torches-ahmadi-place-of-worship-in-jhelum-over-blasphemy-allegations/ Express Tribune, http://nation.com.pk/national/22-Nov-2015/jhelum-arson-attacks-will-be-comprehensively-probed-sanaullah The Nation, https://www.pakistantoday.com.pk/2015/11/21/jhelum-under-army-control-after-ahmadi-place-of-worship-burnt-riots-erupt/ Pakistan Today Deletion of 2015 Jhelum attacks WP:GNG||WP:DIVERSE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19617 4115 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Tylman (5th nomination) User:Orlady 14:36, 12 September 2012 (UTC) delete An interesting little bit of long-ago genealogical research, but in the absence of published |Wikipedia-reliable sources to establish |notability and |verifiability, it doesn't belong in this encyclopedia Deletion of Richard Tylman (5th nomination) WP:RS||WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19618 6569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Streicker User:Whpq 15:59, 18 May 2011 (UTC) delete No coverage in reliable sources to establish notability. As he was not elected, he dos not meet . Hi notability as an enviromentalist needs to be established with significant coverage in reliable sources, which I cannot find Deletion of John Streicker WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19619 7830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Kurtagić (2nd nomination) User:Wikieditindia 12:48, 20 February 2012 (UTC) delete Fails to meet #Basic Criteria. No significant coverage in reliable secondary sources. Primary sources can not be used to prove notability Deletion of Alex Kurtagić (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19620 20045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Modestas Mankus (2nd nomination) User:Pontificalibus 07:33, 16 November 2018 (UTC) delete """Those two """"interviews"""" do not represent in-depth coverage and are clearly |promotional. The Huffington Post one even contains a link to his crowdfunding campaign! Fails """ Deletion of Modestas Mankus (2nd nomination) WP:PRSOURCE||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19621 6665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deeper and Deeper (film) User:Ginsengbomb 06:13, 12 September 2010 (UTC) delete or possibly '''Incubate'''. There is no compelling evidence in the article, in GNews et al., or in the arguments above that this film is currently notable. There is compelling evidence that it ''might'' be notable at ''some point in the future,'' but notability is, in my view, concerned with current, actual notability, not potential, speculative notability. |Wikipedia's not having a deadline is not a particularly compelling defense of the article. It's an essay, not a guideline or policy, that expresses multiple semi-conflicting views. One view supports this article (sorta), one doesn't, etc. View one says delete, view two might say keep. Either way, existing coverage is trivial, at best. Trivial coverage is insufficient to establish notability. I support incubation on the basis of the film's potential notability Deletion of Deeper and Deeper (film) WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:There is no deadline 35
19622 20813 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khalid Jehangir User:DBigXray 13:30, 18 February 2020 (UTC) delete fails due to lack of state or national election victories. The post of spokesperson of the state wing of the party is not a notable post and has been discussed in earlier AfDs as non notable Deletion of Khalid Jehangir WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19623 15667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Opeyemi Enoch User:Slawekb 23:37, 21 December 2015 (UTC) delete No reliable secondary sources on the subject (as required by ), and no evidence of passing Deletion of Opeyemi Enoch WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19624 11181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khalid Hossain User:David 17:07, 5 July 2011 (UTC) delete for lack of evidence of passing Deletion of Khalid Hossain WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19625 11175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anatoliy Andreyev User:K 08:29, 4 October 2016 (UTC) comment I added content and references to the article. Now meets #1 (has credit for writing or co-writing either lyrics or music for a notable composition) and #2 (has written musical theatre of some sort (includes musicals, operas, etc.) that was performed in a notable theatre Deletion of Anatoliy Andreyev WP:COMPOSER Wikipedia:Notability 77
19626 19794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of vehicles simulated by iRacing.com User:Sergecross73 20:17, 5 October 2016 (UTC) delete all. discourages these sorts of massive in-game lists without any context or further information provided, being in articles. Exhaustive lists of participants and winners of tournaments is discouraged as well. If we don't even want them ''in'' articles, surely we don't want articles ''dedicated to them entirely''. Wikipedia is |not the place to track all this stuff Deletion of List of vehicles simulated by iRacing.com WP:GAMECRUFT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
19627 11808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nokia 8600 Luna User:Collectonian 08:29, 15 December 2007 (UTC) delete Wikipedia |is not a directory nor is it a cell phone catalog. That's what the Nokia website is for Deletion of Nokia 8600 Luna WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19628 19666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wizard (fantasy) User:FrozenPurpleCube 21:11, 23 November 2006 (UTC) comment I'm confused. Wizard (fantasy) is currently a redirect to Wizard. That's a disambig page (and there's no question of deleting it Too many valid references). What exactly do you have a problem with? Are you sure you don't want to take this to Deletion of Wizard (fantasy) WP:RFD Wikipedia:Redirect 56
19629 14050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Official User:P199 18:28, 1 April 2006 (UTC) merge Good dictionary entry but not for wp ( Deletion of Official WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
19630 418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dominique Strauss-Kahn Tristane Banon alleged sexual assault User:AndyTheGrump 16:28, 6 July 2011 (UTC) delete as a content fork, and with due regard to policy Deletion of Dominique Strauss-Kahn Tristane Banon alleged sexual assault WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19631 18001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adolph Behrman User:Mr 22:23, 13 August 2012 (UTC) comment Can you cite some sources that are more than just a passion mention of his name, e.g. that meet the guidelines in Deletion of Adolph Behrman WP:SOURCES Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19632 18225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kel'Thuzad User:Ridernyc 22:50, 1 November 2007 (UTC) delete violates lot and , while the game Warcraft is notable. The fiction and characters within it are not Deletion of Kel'Thuzad WP:P||WP:OR Wikipedia:Portal 85
19633 8502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Macedonian constitutional referendum, 2018 [[User talk:NukeThePukes|Allons!]] 17:44, 17 July 2018 (UTC) delete """Yeah, that was a |bad rationale to remove a prod; I'm never going to stop shaking my head at the people who think that they get gold stars on their foreheads for """"scooping"""" Wikipedia on a new article. Obvious violations of CRYSTAL and TOO SOON are obvious. ''' ''Nha Trang""" Deletion of Macedonian constitutional referendum, 2018 WP:BULLSHIT Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
19634 12176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Microvitum in a Nutshell User:Ihcoyc 16:59, 25 January 2013 (UTC) delete """This is a recent book about """"microvita theory"""", apparently a twentieth century New Age vitalism|vitalist philosophy: ''microvita are tiny little creative catalysing agents. They build atoms of matter, biology and mind, while cooperating with the characteristics of subatomic particles and pure energy''. The topic of the book seems somewhat |fringe, and neither the book nor its subject really have the kind of long term depth to support an article at this stage""" Deletion of Microvitum in a Nutshell WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
19635 10341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jon Garcia (baseball) User:Dirtlawyer1 13:44, 27 May 2015 (UTC) delete per : article creator Spanneraol supports deletion of article he created; there is no opposition to deletion of article about non-notable minor leaguer who does not satisfy the specific notabilit guideline for baseball players per or the general notability guidelines per Deletion of Jon Garcia (baseball) WP:G7||WP:NBASEBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
19636 14575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liberal Fascism (graphic novel) User:HisSpaceResearch 20:59, 3 February 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Liberal Fascism (graphic novel) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19637 13721 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jurong Point Shopping Centre User:TheronJ 15:03, 13 October 2006 (UTC) comment was delete, see below)'' If the page defenders want to make a run at establishing notability, I would give them a day or two to do it.) Page fans, per |Wikipedia's notability guidelines for businesses, you need to come up with at least a few non-trivial articles about the mall in |reliable sources. The easiest way is to go to your local library and ask a librarian to help you search newspaper records, or just call the mall and see if they have a press clipping file you can review Deletion of Jurong Point Shopping Centre WP:CORP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19638 11233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rugged Maniac Kansas City User:RhinosF1 12:24, 2 March 2019 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Rugged Maniac Kansas City WP:NEVENT||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19639 5503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nico F. Declercq User:Mwelch 21:38, 12 April 2007 (UTC) keep The two papers mentioned in the article, on Chichen Itza and on Epidaurus, seem to be pretty widely reported and cited.http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%28%22nico+F.+declercq%22+OR+%22nico+declercq%22%29+%28pyramid+OR+Greek%29&btnG=Search Seems to meet #3 Deletion of Nico F. Declercq WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19640 5824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC 143 User:Hasteur 20:11, 25 April 2012 (UTC) delete There is a definition of what a notable MMA event is. It's called . Prose at Omnibus 2012 in UFC events for this is superior, well cited and communicates the points necessary. No need for a spin off Deletion of UFC 143 WP:MMANOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19641 2780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boston Luxe Real Estate LLC User:AllyD 07:43, 13 January 2015 (UTC) delete Multiple searches turn up no |evidence that this firm is |notable Deletion of Boston Luxe Real Estate LLC :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19642 14969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saul Adelman User:David 21:15, 5 April 2009 (UTC) delete 300 publications and the best he can muster is one with 35 citations in Google scholar? It is not difficult to find papers on similar subjects with ten times that (e.g. DOI:10.1086/305126). To me this seems a clear sign that he has not been making an impact, and there is no evidence of passing the other criteria Deletion of Saul Adelman WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19643 15714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Merkle User:Cyrus 18:47, 10 April 2007 (UTC) delete His most notable performance was in Booker High School's acclaimed ''Seussical''. I believe that in itself says it all. High school / college actors are not notable. This could even be speedied under #A7|this as a non notable bio Deletion of Bruce Merkle WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
19644 17637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monument Beach (Bourne, Massachusetts) User:Coolabahapple 23:16, 7 December 2019 (UTC) delete as not meeting due to lack of significant sources, no need to have an article separate from Monument Beach, Massachusetts Deletion of Monument Beach (Bourne, Massachusetts) WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19645 313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Horseheads High School User:Thivierr 05:06, 19 January 2006 (UTC) keep per . Some work on references may be needed though. Also, can somebody familiar with this tell, if this school is related to the one of the same name/place with a graduating class in 1888? http://www.rootsweb.com/~srgp/souvenir/1919ww1h.htm http://www.rootsweb.com/~srgp/articles/horschro.htm. Perhaps one school was built, torn down, and entirely new largely unrelated one built later. Or maybe it was a a continuation of the same institution, but a different building (as is often the case with some schools, for which we discuss all buildings in one article). Since this is speculation on my part (aka unverified) I obviously didn't mention it in the article. As for merge suggestions, I suggest, that since the district has exactly one high school, and we merge to districts (if possible), any merger be done to *this* article. That is if any elem substubs are made, they be merged/redirected here, rather then merging/redirecting this elsewhere Deletion of Horseheads High School WP:SCH Wikipedia:Notability 77
19646 2800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gregory A. Sandfort User:Brianhe 22:40, 9 June 2015 (UTC) delete as NN; the sources in the article are not just , but appear to be mirroring one another. Current news sources are just more routine PR stuff, and a rather expensive house sale Deletion of Gregory A. Sandfort WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19647 8319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Line of succession to the former throne of Jammu and Kashmir User:TimothyBlue 07:15, 29 July 2020 (UTC) delete per nom and TompaDompa. The article does not cite RS and I don't believe this could be verifiably sourced and not contain substantial | . // Deletion of Line of succession to the former throne of Jammu and Kashmir WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
19648 12992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yewri Guillen User:Overdrawn 14:21, 22 April 2011 (UTC) delete With condolences and sympathy to his family, he doesn't pass and he is not notable by Wikipedia standards Deletion of Yewri Guillen WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19649 5035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Indira Priyadarshini Ravindran User:Joe 18:54, 9 September 2016 (UTC) delete I've just speedied this as a copyright violation, but in case that's declined for some reason:) no indication that Ravindran meets . She is an Assistant Prof. and completed her PhD less than ten years ago, so I'd say it's clearly for her to have made a significant impact Deletion of Dr. Indira Priyadarshini Ravindran WP:PROF||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
19650 15010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karrigan (2nd nomination) User:Yellow 10:33, 19 July 2016 (UTC) keep per Prisencolin; meets with a multitude of reliable, independent and in-depth coverage Deletion of Karrigan (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19651 12812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Captain (inline hockey) User:Ajf773 NONE delete as of Inline hockey — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Captain (inline hockey) WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
19652 20835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cougar Valley, Washington User:Surachit 04:01, 18 January 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Cougar Valley, Washington WP:GEOLAND||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19653 393 [[SCHAU HIN!]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Knoerz NONE delete relevanz nach klarstellen oder Löschung von SCHAU HIN! Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
19654 4548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar 'OJ' Koroma User:Vickser 08:54, 8 August 2008 (UTC) delete """The BBC claim that he's going to Norwich to gain first team play isn't enough for me. Notability isn't temporary, and as of now he's not notable. If tomorrow he got injured and couldn't play football anymore, and had no chance of ever playing, he wouldn't be notable. That's different than the High School Musical 3 case, where, if tomorrow Disney announced that they weren't releasing the film, or something else similar happened, the film would still be notable. If he ever does make a professional debut, which, football being football is far from certain, the article is easy to recreate. Ask on the Footy project with """"this person now has a professional debut, could you recreate the article?"""" and I'm sure you'll get a friendly admin to recreate it. Heck, if you're afraid, ask me and I'll ask an admin. We're not a |crysal ball, and as of now, he's not notable""" Deletion of Omar 'OJ' Koroma WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19655 10927 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Bottle Flipping Game User:Pdcook 16:28, 4 March 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of The Bottle Flipping Game WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
19656 6735 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sharyn Booth (Comedian) User:C 17:02, 1 September 2009 (UTC) delete While Stormbay might be right about niche popularity, the problem is that it isn't clearly |verifiable. The review in ''The Age'' was too short to stand on its own in support of her. There certainly aren't enough sources to meet , and the panning in ''The Age'' doesn't get her over the WP:ENT hurdle. If additional sources are discovered, I am willing to reconsider this recommendation Deletion of Sharyn Booth (Comedian) WP:V||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19657 16218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taylor Lindsey User:Barkeep49 15:03, 2 June 2018 (UTC) merge to List of Los Angeles Angels first-round draft picks. The coverage cited for GNG is and thus actually doesn't go towards establishing GNG. Best Deletion of Taylor Lindsey WP:RUNOFTHEMILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
19658 7614 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stack Bundles User:Fordmadoxfraud 20:04, 12 June 2007 (UTC) comment this is preposterous, but gee, thanks for getting racism involved. The dispute here is a simple one of and no Wikipedia:No original research#Primary, secondary, and tertiary sources|secondary sources. ''Almost'' becoming a notable person doesn't count Deletion of Stack Bundles WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19659 266 [[Quisa CRM]] (erl.) Benutzer:Wangen 20:23, 25. Jun. 2007 (CEST) delete Relevanz wird nicht dargestellt (Lesetipps für den Autor: |Was Wikipedia nicht ist, WP:WSIGA|Wie schreibe ich gute Artikel und besonders WP:RK|die Relevanzkriterien, am Rande vielleicht auch Hilfe:Signatur|Richtiges Unterschreiben Löschung von Quisa CRM Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19660 5247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seapunk User:Tokyogirl79 07:11, 21 November 2011 (UTC) delete This is a very, very recently coined term and as such, doesn't have anything that would be considered a reliable source. In response to '''Dinospartan117''', a term, person, place, or item might be considered notable within a group of people, but that doesn't automatically mean it's notable enough to go onto Wikipedia. What's needed to prove notability are reliable sources. (See for what's considered a reliable source.) Unfortunately I didn't find that when I did a search on this term. I found some blogs, youtube videos, and sources that would be considered trivial at best, but I didn't find anything reliable. A reliable source would be if Rolling Stone did an article on seapunk or if it was covered in a news article. That said, I think that it might be worth userfying () until Dinospartan117 can find enough reliable sources to flesh the term out Deletion of Seapunk WP:RS||WP:USERFY Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19661 9264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crime against peace User:EricSerge 18:30, 19 November 2011 (UTC) keep This one looks like a good candidate for . Why not just zap the OR and SYNTH sections Deletion of Crime against peace WP:SOFIXIT Wikipedia:Be bold 9
19662 16507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ProElite 1 (event) User:Temporary 16:24, 23 January 2012 (UTC) comment """It is flat out not true to say the non-routine coverage only contains fight results. Previews of the cards for example as what appeared in the print version of USA Today is by its nature as a preview not """"results"""". Something covered across multiple paragraphs that discuss the ramifications of the fights and the history of the fighters involved is not mere """"stats"""" either. The condition of the articles is a reason to improve them, not to delete them. Looking over the first draft of many articles, including ones on famous historical subjects do not always look good, but we improve them instead of delete them. As the commenter above me notes, quote, """"the first and second event articles...contain...reference offering coverage of the event itself beyond fight results"""" and that is just in the articles, let alone the numerous sources that we can and should also add to the articles as well and also acknowledges that the third article's references added since the discussion started do indeed show signs of improvement. The call for additional sources has been answered and is in the process of being addressed to improve the articles as well, which undeniably and objectively pass the , because these are not just televised events, but notable televised events and yes a first event of a mainstream televised promotion featuring UFC champion level fighters and that is written about in not just blogs, but newspaper articles by non-MMA specific publishers is inherently notable by any reasonable interpretation of the concept. And if we are talking personal levels, I am far more disappointed by the number of delete votes we see in this and other discussions by accounts and IPs that never improve or add anything to these or other articles for that matter. TreyGeek, you may help add articles, but seriously, how many deletes from this and other discussions do we see that ever do anything more than just lazily dismiss everything as non-notable without actually doing search sourcing. And for the record, after I make this post, I will indeed add at least one source to an article under discussion here to show by example and not just words""" Deletion of ProElite 1 (event) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19663 5673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrea Parhamovich User:MacGyverMagic 17:22, 17 December 2008 (UTC) delete While there may have been lots of reports, most of those weren't independent and none of them went beyond reporting her death. Also applies. She's known only for her death which had no lasting impact on US perception of the war in Iraq, nor any procedures or laws inside Iraq itself. Basically a memorial, like the book her husband wrote Deletion of Andrea Parhamovich WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19664 5558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eliteanswers.com User:Fasach 10:02, 5 September 2008 (UTC) keep It seems to meet , I have tagged it as advert and for cleanup Deletion of Eliteanswers.com WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19665 15451 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of notable Ebola patients User:SW3 16:53, 24 October 2014 (UTC) comment I'm happy to withdraw the nom if other editors feel that's best. But first, I'd like to know if in their view, this article satisfies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style/Lists#Navigation navigation in the WP:MOS. Also, the talk page and the article edit summaries suggested to me that there was concern about the content. Specifically one editor noted that the focus on 'notable' Ebola patients, would mean that the list is out of proportion to all others with Ebola. So |undue weight would apply. And finally another editor pointed out that the list is essentially covered in Template:Ebola. My concern firstly is the ‘notable’ cases are really the health care workers who’ve fallen ill. Granted, they've done God's work there, but their misfortune in contracting the virus is no greater than that of any of the thousands who've fallen ill. Perhaps what is needed is a rename, or repurpose Deletion of List of notable Ebola patients WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
19666 7152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slashdot subculture (3rd nomination) User:Mitaphane 10:12, 8 October 2006 (UTC) delete without a secondary source, there is only one way to |verify this; go to Slashdot. Which, in turn, would be |OR. If someone has a secondary source about this info, it should stay, but I find it unlikely that someone out there has documented the themes of slashdot forum posts Deletion of Slashdot subculture (3rd nomination) WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19667 14022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vikki Blows (2nd nomination) User:Dennisthe2 23:03, 3 December 2011 (UTC) delete This one I'm going to echo Hullaballoo above, and go with a as well Deletion of Vikki Blows (2nd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
19668 18615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colonel Ashfaq Hussain User:DBigXray 21:51, 27 September 2018 (UTC) keep """passes and due to significant critical attention. This Colonel is notable for his book '''Witness to Blunder: Kargil Story Unfolds''' Colonel has got significant coverage in Pakistani and Indian mainstream media both print and television. NDTV,https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/commend-musharraf-for-crossing-loc-to-be-with-troops-general-vk-singh-512077 ABP News, Geo TV (talk shows and news channels), Newspaper Dawnhttps://www.dawn.com/news/826860, India todayhttps://www.indiatoday.in/world/pakistan/story/kargil-operation-pervez-musharraf-pakistan-army-loc-col-ashfaq-hussain-153092-2013-02-01, Rediff news,http://www.rediff.com/news/slide-show/slide-show-1-musharraf-lied-he-crossed-loc-in-march-1999/20130201.htm Tribune India,https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/nation/saved-siachen-by-winning-kargil/442935.html Tribune Pakistanhttps://tribune.com.pk/story/501602/controversy-musharraf-crossed-loc-before-kargil-war/ to pass GNG. There are only a few books written on Kargil wars by """"Pakistani military officers"""". This author being one of them""" Deletion of Colonel Ashfaq Hussain WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19669 6618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Trump's hair User:Kierzek 14:05, 27 October 2016 (UTC) delete per ; Wikipedia is not a newspaper, nor a soapbox. This is unencyclopedic speculation and tabloid news, at best Deletion of Donald Trump's hair WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19670 139 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Öğretim Elemanları Sendikası Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 21:36, 2 Aralık 2014 (UTC) delete Aslında maddeler açılırken kayda değer olduğu ispatlanmış bir biçimde açılmalı, sorunun kaynağı bu bizdeki. Şu an maddede kullanılan kaynakların tamamı bu kurumla alakalı organlar tarafından oluşturulan kaynaklar. Bu tip |bağımsız olmayan kaynaklar kayda değer olduğunun ispatında kullanılamıyor. Kayda değer olmadığını düşünüyorum Öğretim Elemanları Sendikasının silinmesi Vikipedi:BK Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19671 6295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neurot Recordings discography User:FisherQueen 13:37, 14 April 2007 (UTC) delete use a category to organize those recordings that meet the |notability standard Deletion of Neurot Recordings discography WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19672 15418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Downsizing masculinity User:Esradekan 18:17, 21 June 2008 (UTC) comment """And the top of the page you've quoted states """"''This is an essay. It is '''not''' a policy or guideline""" Deletion of Downsizing masculinity WP:VAGUEWAVE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
19673 21812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nullset User:Gongshow 06:25, 12 August 2013 (UTC) delete and '''redirect''' per above. I'm unable to find evidence that this group meets or Deletion of Nullset WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19674 14317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hal Stalmaster NONE NONE keep Passes . His work in ''Johnny Trumain'' has been covered in numerous publications, including scholarly articles. He has been covered for his work as a talent agent as well. In addition to the sources provided above, here are some more high quality sources Deletion of Hal Stalmaster WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
19675 11229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M. Sarngadharan User:David 07:43, 30 May 2021 (UTC) delete """There's a different researcher M. G. Sarngadharan with heavy citations on AIDS and leukemia, but the only significant scholarly work I could find by the one here (a researcher in commerce, not medicine) was a book """"Financial Analysis for Management Decisions"""" with 19 citations in Google Scholar. That's not enough for or , and even if the book were itself notable (say because it had multiple in-depth published reviews) the best we might do would be to redirect to an article on it""" Deletion of M. Sarngadharan WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19676 5835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/bopo User:Kinu 14:03, 31 August 2006 (UTC) delete blatant Deletion of bopo WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
19677 18579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Percy Nobby Norton User:Kinu 21:31, 31 July 2006 (UTC) delete as , no since that would be Deletion of Percy Nobby Norton WP:HOAX||WP:BJAODN||WP:BEANS Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
19678 4233 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jewdar (2nd nomination) User:Weirdoactor 13:25, 4 January 2007 (UTC) keep """Satisfies in triplicate (which is policy, not a guideline, as is ). The Delete votes here (as in the original AfD) seem to be either jokes (""""crap sense""""?), """"per"""" votes (which is laziness/bad faith, as this is a debate, NOT a vote) or they don't quote actual policy. Using bureaucracy to commit article murder is bad faith. Shame! You hug your mother with the hands on the same fingers you type these delete votes with? Oy! You should BE so lucky""" Deletion of Jewdar (2nd nomination) WP:V||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19679 13786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenneth Andam User:Clarityfiend 01:02, 22 August 2012 (UTC) keep Everyone who competes in the Olympics is automatically notable (just as baseball players who have had one single at-bat in the Major Leagues are). See #1. (Here's his https://web.archive.org/web/20200418052021/https://www.sports-reference.com/olympics/athletes/an/kenneth-andam-1.html sports-reference.com entry confirming he was in the 2000 Olympics.) Andam it, he also satisfies #3 by finishing third in the 2000 African Championships.http://www.gbrathletics.com/ic/afc.htm Deletion of Kenneth Andam WP:NTRACK Wikipedia:Notability 77
19680 7329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Pope (2nd nomination) User:Papaursa 04:01, 5 January 2019 (UTC) delete Not seeing or finding evidence to show he meets , , or Deletion of Robert Pope (2nd nomination) WP:NAUTHOR||WP:NPROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19681 2245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alp Akar User:Kemalcan 08:52, 21 January 2021 (UTC) delete delete per YET (actors) he does not meet , , . The awards mentioned in the comments above is just a nomination. He did not actually win it. Not yet notable Deletion of Alp Akar WP:NOT||WP:GNG||WP:BASIC||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19682 5021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Levan Kirakosyan User:Mdtemp 19:02, 18 March 2014 (UTC) keep His EBU title is enough to meet Deletion of Levan Kirakosyan WP:NBOX Wikipedia:Notability 77
19683 9620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RB Collection User:ProClasher97 05:12, 1 August 2021 (UTC) comment I certainly don’t believe that either of these two new articles by this user meet (hence why I moved them to draft space after they were submitted the first time), and I would have done the same if there wasn’t already a deletion discussion on the subject. But now that there is, I would certainly say to delete both articles Deletion of RB Collection WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19684 5005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Uppal User:Skeezix1000 15:21, 4 July 2007 (UTC) delete """Failed candidates are not inherently notable, and do not meet . His stint as a radio host has the potential to make him noteworthy, but there is nothing in the article that suggests that is the case. As for the assertions on this page that """"anyone who knows anything about Canadian politics will understand that he will win in his seat"""" and so forth, since when do the speculation, hunches, predictions, guesses and offers-to-eat-socks of a small group of Wikipedia editors trump and """ Deletion of Tim Uppal WP:BIO||WP:OR||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19685 12971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doctor Who Reference Guide User:Themindset 20:38, 4 August 2006 (UTC) delete Probably too Deletion of Doctor Who Reference Guide WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
19686 6305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenneth O'Keefe (2nd nomination) User:Ginsengbomb 06:58, 3 January 2011 (UTC) delete The sources presented in the article and in the conversation above appear, to me at least, to fail one or both of two criteria: |reliability, or |demonstrative of non-trivial coverage ''of the topic at hand.'' This is a significant distinction. Coverage of actions which Mr. O'Keefe may have been involved with does not necessarily equate to coverage of Mr. O'Keefe himself and, as such, doesn't necessarily confer notability. That said, this is a bit of a close call for me Deletion of Kenneth O'Keefe (2nd nomination) WP:RELIABLE||WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19687 13801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019 The Hague stabbing User:Clovermoss 02:14, 1 December 2019 (UTC) keep passes with signifigant news coverage. See https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-50617525, https://www.cnn.com/2019/11/29/europe/hague-netherlands-intl/index.html Deletion of 2019 The Hague stabbing WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19688 12960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Metafore, LLC User:KrakatoaKatie 12:23, 3 September 2007 (UTC) delete I was going to A7 speedy it too, but let's give it the full run. It fails Deletion of Metafore, LLC WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19689 10398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bangkok City F.C. User:Paul 04:09, 13 January 2019 (UTC) comment Hmm. Looking again at the sources, they all seem to be covering the press event announcing the club's establishment. Could probably be considered Deletion of Bangkok City F.C. WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19690 359 [[Debütalbum]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Zaphiro 17:46, 27. Sep. 2008 (CEST) delete """die belegten Statistiken kann man in entsprechenden Absatz von Musikalbum einbringen, der Rest ist trivial und selbsterklärend, garniert mit z.B. """"''Das erste Album erscheint oft ohne Titel, also einfach unter dem Namen des Künstlers oder der Band.''"""" oder """"''Einige Debütalben machten ihren Schöpfer über Nacht bekannt ... Andere liegen zunächst unbeachtet in den Regalen''""""...soso, der rest ist beliebig""" Löschung von Debütalbum Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
19691 8282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bioscrypt Inc. User:onel5969 15:34, 13 August 2015 (UTC) merge A news search returned only press releases; Newspapers returned zero results; Books returned quite a few results, but all of a tangential or listing nature, which does not rise to fulfilling ; Highbeam returned results which are either non-substantial, or of press release nature; and JStor returned zero results. That said, I think there is enough independent citation to include the non-promotional aspects of this article in the L-1 Identity Solutions article Deletion of Bioscrypt Inc. WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19692 20652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vedanta Resources [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 13:24, 21 September 2006 (UTC) keep """per . Meets first criteria, ''""""The company or corporation is listed on ranking indices of important companies produced by well-known and independent publications.""""'' Company is listed on London Stock Exchange and FTSE 100 Index""" Deletion of Vedanta Resources WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19693 1648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Flytrap User:segv11 06:27, 9 January 2006 (UTC) delete WP:NOT a crystal |ball Deletion of Flytrap WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
19694 12206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Symbian Horizon User:Fences 04:18, 19 December 2009 (UTC) keep or '''Merge''' to Symbian. Do remember to look for sources before nominating or !voting.http://www.informationweek.com/news/mobility/business/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=218500918http://www.businessweek.com/the_thread/techbeat/archives/2009/07/symbian_horizon.htmlhttp://www.zdnetasia.com/news/communications/0,39044192,62058928,00.htmhttp://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/09/09/symbian_china/http://news.cnet.com/8301-1035_3-10289087-94.htmlhttp://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/07/16/symbian_horizon/http://news.bbc.co.uk/nol/ukfs_news/mobile/newsid_8150000/newsid_8152400/8152443.stmhttp://www.itpro.co.uk/616906/symbian-unveils-horizon-app-storehttp://www.informationweek.com/news/telecom/business/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=220900802. So there's definitely significant coverage in multiple reliable sources, thus it meets the . I think a merge is best as it is integral to Symbian and both articles are short Deletion of Symbian Horizon WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19695 19337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David dejonge User:NawlinWiki 18:49, 24 July 2008 (UTC) comment Original article speedied; author reposted at David DeJonge. There are now some sources, but I'd still like to see the problem discussed Deletion of David dejonge WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
19696 14570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gabriel Weinberg User:Student7 00:29, 6 February 2011 (UTC) comment Mentioned? Not in article anyplace. The only article quoted there is a website constructed by the subject. This is not considered for this purpose Deletion of Gabriel Weinberg WP:RELY Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19697 8433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2013–14 Holywell Town F.C. season User:Nfitz 17:38, 26 July 2014 (UTC) keep meets with media coverage of recent season and recent Welsh Cup semi-finals. Article needs to be improved, not deleted, adding sources from other than the team itself. Media coverage examples of various seasons are http://www.dailypost.co.uk/sport/sport-opinion/north-wales-football-holywell-town-7502363 http://www.dailypost.co.uk/sport/football/amateur-football/football-holywell-town-boss-john-5675624 http://www.uefa.com/memberassociations/association=wal/news/newsid=2070800.html http://www.bbc.com/sport/0/football/26420692 Deletion of 2013–14 Holywell Town F.C. season WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19698 12862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corporate Affiliations User:Bluerasberry 14:45, 18 May 2015 (UTC) delete No attempt made to be in compliance with Wikipedia's inclusion criteria. Fails Deletion of Corporate Affiliations WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19699 13563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of British words not widely used in the United States (3rd nomination) User:Asenine 07:54, 13 May 2008 (UTC) delete Massive |OR Deletion of List of British words not widely used in the United States (3rd nomination) WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19700 4355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Los Baby's [[User_talk:Travellingcari|TravellingCari]] 02:30, 8 October 2008 (UTC) keep I read Spanish and the article there establishes notability. It needs translation which I could do, but have no time at this moment. Also keep on the grounds that Chubbles does good work with music/band related articles - s/he has a good track record with these articles and I |don't believe s/he'd go to trouble of creating an article on a n-n band Deletion of Los Baby's WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
19701 11729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Benden Weyr User:Colonel 07:28, 31 May 2009 (UTC) keep Evidently notable. There are obviously good alternatives to deletion in such cases and so these cookie cutter nominations fail Deletion of Benden Weyr WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19702 20970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M. Zachary Sherman User:Stifle 00:10, 18 April 2006 (UTC) keep seems to pass quite easily. He's been involved in multiple notable films Deletion of M. Zachary Sherman WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19703 67 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hatice Karahan """Kullanıcı:maurice flesiermaurice flesier""" 17:31, 19 Ağustos 2017 (UTC) keep """SETA'dan alındığı anlaşılıyor"""".. Kişisel düşünce ve çıkarımlar 'ya girer ve hiçbir geçerliliği yoktur. Ben yorumlardan politikaların halen daha tam kavranmadığını, güvenilir kaynakların tam olarak ne olduğunun bilinmediğini gördüm. VP:KD'nin temel kriteri çok bariz. '''Bir konu kendisinden bağımsız, önemli, güvenilir, birden çok ikincil kaynaklarca içerik edilmiş veya kapsanmışsa kayda değerdir.''' Kaynak analizi yapmak ve bir takım seneryolar üretmek yerine ikincil kaynağın tanımının ne olduğunun okunmasını tavsiye ediyorum""" Hatice Karahan'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:ÖA Wikipedia:No original research 65
19704 17430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Franchezca Valentina User:Stuartyeates 06:35, 9 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Franchezca Valentina WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19705 3194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Koo-Koo and Luke User:Adrian 03:48, 11 February 2006 (UTC) delete as |non-notable web comic Deletion of Koo-Koo and Luke WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19706 211 [[Elisabeth Fürstin von Urach Gräfin von Württemberg]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Andy king50 NONE delete """Leider wieder ein Eintrag, der verkennt, dass """"Adel am sich"""" in der durchaus """"bürgerlichen"""" Wikipedia keinerlei Relevanz-Bonus bringt. Die Relevanzkriterien gelten ganz egalitär für Jedermann. Es lässt sich im Artikel keine persönliche Leistung der Person oder ein anderes Relevanzmerkmal gem. #P erkennen, folglich zu""" Löschung von Elisabeth Fürstin von Urach Gräfin von Württemberg Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
19707 16795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian David Mitchell User:Cindamuse 04:45, 15 December 2010 (UTC) comment """Meets criteria #3 of . """"The motivation for the crime or the execution of the crime is unusual or has otherwise been considered noteworthy such that it is a well-documented historic event. Generally the historic significance is indicated by persistent coverage of the event in reliable secondary sources that devote significant attention to the individual's role""" Deletion of Brian David Mitchell WP:PERP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19708 6101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kozo the Hippo User:Pharaoh 17:52, 15 September 2017 (UTC) delete Does appear non notable lacks and fails Deletion of Kozo the Hippo WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19709 19339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solomon (unit) User:Johnuniq 10:13, 23 December 2014 (UTC) delete The source is not sufficiently reliable to be used for novel claims that cannot be verified in other sources. The source appears to have no more than a single row in a table to justify the statements in this article, and there is no encyclopedic information available to make an article beyond a |dictionary definition. This is part of a big issue; see my comment at ispute resolution noticeboard#Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Calibre(unit)|DRN. All the pages should be considered together, rather than having fragmented discussions Deletion of Solomon (unit) WP:NOTDICT||WP:D Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
19710 1151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hans Tuppy User:Metropolitan90 05:06, 18 June 2006 (UTC) keep While the article is poorly translated, this person appears to be |well more notable than the average professor, having been president of the Austrian Academy for Science, and Federal Minister for Science and Research in the Austrian government. Maybe these positions are less notable than they sound, but it is verifiable that he held them. http://www.wien2004.ica.org/fo/speakers.php?ctNv1=48&ctNv2=&IdSpk=509&AlphSpk=@&p= He also turns up at least 46 times in a Google scholar search in contexts consistent with the article Deletion of Hans Tuppy WP:PROFTEST Wikipedia:Notability 77
19711 8152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beat Up a White Kid Day (second nomination) User:Ocatecir 17:03, 7 May 2007 (UTC) keep Per the evidence found by Ianmanka in closing the first AFD. Event clearly happened and was notable for its racial controversy. While the title might seem to imply some sort of holiday, the article shows that it is the name the participants gave the event, not a version of . &mdash Deletion of Beat Up a White Kid Day (second nomination) WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
19712 11629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indianapolis Capitols User:Jacona 15:16, 29 April 2019 (UTC) keep Plenty of coverage to satisfy gng. I grabbed two quick clips at newspaperarchive.com that show, non-local , one about them trying to sign O.J. Simpson, and another that discusses their winning the league. https://newspaperarchive.com/sports-clipping-aug-20-1970-1159409, https://newspaperarchive.com/sports-clipping-mar-22-1969-1159405. There are a plethora of sources, literally thousands, if you are willing to look at sources that are before the internet age. Once you go to either newspapers.com or newspaperarchive.com, it should be instantly clear that this article meets gng Deletion of Indianapolis Capitols WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
19713 20381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Governors Towne Club User:Ultraexactzz 18:24, 30 September 2009 (UTC) delete This is close to a Speedy, as the article really doesn't assert notability. But, for all that, look at the coverage - it's all from 2005 and before, when the development was under construction. So, there was very little notable about it then, and nothing since. I'm not finding additional |sources, either - so, we should probably delete Deletion of Governors Towne Club WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19714 20936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/World Martial Arts Games (2nd nomination) User:Papaursa 20:43, 18 September 2019 (UTC) delete I did a web search for sources, again. What I found wasn't really different from the first discussion. Sources either weren't independent or were local stories of athletes (overwhelmingly kids) competing at one of the events. I don't believe these are the type of references that suffice to meet . Combining those with routine sports coverage doesn't make these events WP notable. The splitting of the original organization, having multiple events, and titles that overlap with other organizations makes this even harder to follow--especially with no documentation Deletion of World Martial Arts Games (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19715 1920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lorna Bourg User:Pburka 15:41, 21 May 2021 (UTC) keep In my opinion, a MacArthur Fellowship is sufficient for Deletion of Lorna Bourg WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19716 14749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Weng's Cold Storage Industrial Company ammonia leak User:LGA 20:56, 6 September 2013 (UTC) delete per as the article makes no claim to any lasting significance; it can be recreated later if it proves a catalyst for a change in law Deletion of Weng's Cold Storage Industrial Company ammonia leak WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19717 16518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tallest buildings in Amarillo (2nd nomination) User:Dralwik 02:52, 14 November 2020 (UTC) merge to Amarillo, Texas. I've |taken the liberty of copying the first five entries in the table to the main article. '''''D Deletion of List of tallest buildings in Amarillo (2nd nomination) WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
19718 11428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Marsden User:Papaursa 15:54, 8 August 2015 (UTC) delete Article gives no references and the external links are to blogs, podcasts, IMDB, etc. Currently I don't see the significant reliable coverage needed to show he meets Deletion of Matt Marsden WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19719 10686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Betty baba User:Gene93k 13:58, 12 November 2008 (UTC) delete per . This is a book review/personal essay Deletion of Betty baba WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19720 1539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Petro photoglyph User:Catfish 16:10, 27 July 2010 (UTC) delete Clearly against and Deletion of Petro photoglyph WP:FRINGE||WP:SPS Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
19721 3302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B'Robby User:Peridon 22:12, 15 July 2011 (UTC) comment It's not much help adding references for 'Terry tha rapman' - this would be of use if we were discussing an article on him. We're not. Whatever notability he has is not relevant here. We need references for this subject that are not mere mentions or offers of downloading something. Coverage. This means an article somewhere reliable that is written independently and actually discusses B'Robby. As to disability, there are and have been other blind artists. 'Not many' does not necessarily equal notable. Notably there have been Ray Charles and Stevie Wonder, to name two. Neither of them would have merited an article in their early days. If this artiste is so notable in Nigeria, how about proving it? Even so, you must look at for the standards needed. That's the easy way. To show that someone who fails them really is notable can be done. But you've got a hack of a job on your hands to do it, and references like the current ones are not the way Deletion of B'Robby WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19722 21843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Dodd User:SingCal 01:19, 11 February 2008 (UTC) merge To Section Quartet. TV appearances are unsourced, and if they're cameos they're non-notable at anyway. Doesn't seem to be mentioned in the articles about his other serious projects. Resume as a guest artist is impressive, but not justification for his own article. No solo projects, no international tours, no competitions mentioned. The only notable project he seems to have is the Section Quartet Deletion of Richard Dodd WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19723 4051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Rime of the Ancient Mariner in popular culture User:TenPoundHammer 18:11, 26 October 2009 (UTC) delete per nom, don't even bother restarting from scratch, it's unsalvageable. No secondary sources, nothing more than . Ten Pound Hammer, his otters and a clue-bat • (Special:Contributions/TenPoundHammer|Many otters • :User talk:TenPoundHammer|One bat Deletion of The Rime of the Ancient Mariner in popular culture WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
19724 17550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Attina Marie Cannaday User:Samsmachado 04:21, 22 June 2020 (UTC) keep Per (perpetrators, bullet two), the crime was historically noteworthy in that Cannaday was a minor sentenced to the death penalty. Also Cannaday's story inspired a film. Her legacy (see the section I added to the article titled ''Legacy'') seems to make this not really 'one event'. (Note: Per , if Cannaday is deemed insignificant herself, the information from this page should be merged into a page about the crime itself (ie. the event Deletion of Attina Marie Cannaday WP:CRIME||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
19725 8113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jaxon Rose Moore User:Theroadislong 09:49, 18 November 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and , IMDb appears to be the only source available, apart from this one https://bckonline.com/2016/11/09/jaxon-rose-moore-makes-her-big-screen-debut-in-almost-christmas/ but applies I think Deletion of Jaxon Rose Moore WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
19726 1548 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stop Biden Agenda User:Hulatam 13:42, 26 February 2021 (UTC) delete Current sources doesn't show Deletion of Stop Biden Agenda WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19727 15961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pupi Poisson User:Bapinghosh 13:00, 22 July 2021 (UTC) keep Subject is meeting , as per GNG keep Deletion of Pupi Poisson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19728 12660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Network as a service User:Ihcoyc 14:35, 30 March 2010 (UTC) delete non-notable neologism and |promotional: ''With the NaaS model, operators treat their key assets - network communications, billing and intelligence - as marketable resources that can be offered to third parties on a commercial basis.... The IGT has established a working group to investigate the NaaS concept. The NaaS concept continues to gain traction within telecommunications as industry analysts try to predict what impact it will have on the market Deletion of Network as a service WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
19729 7334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/APECO (disambiguation) User:RightCowLeftCoast 21:06, 29 March 2011 (UTC) keep Subject of article appears to pass , see http://www.google.com/search?aq=f&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8&q=Aurora+Pacific+Economic+Zone+and+Freeport+Authority#q=%22Aurora+Pacific+Economic+Zone+and+Freeport+Authority%22&hl=en&tbs=nws:1,ar:1&source=lnt&sa=X&ei=H0mSTdOgLc_PiAL44YH-AQ&ved=0CA8QpwUoBQ&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.&fp=7e1fbe3f23c23f49 significant coverage in reliable sources Deletion of APECO (disambiguation) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19730 7267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Avatars(God) born as Rajput User:Rabbabodrool 20:10, 22 November 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of Avatars(God) born as Rajput WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19731 9316 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natural History of South Asia mailing list (2nd nomination) [[User talk:Lethaniol|Lethaniol]] 14:42, 19 March 2007 (UTC) delete I do not think this meets as said above the content and persons involved in of course notable, but the mailing list in itself is not. In fact I find it hard to imagine any mailing list being encyclopaedic (though there likely is). Cheers Deletion of Natural History of South Asia mailing list (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
19732 1828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jun Fukuyama User:KrebMarkt 10:16, 18 August 2009 (UTC) keep Jun Fukuyama has won the first http://www.seiyuawards.jp/200812/11182724.php Seiyu Awards in Best Actor in leading role. I'm aware that wikipedia has |bias issue and will discount that prize as an outlander non notable non reliable prize for Japanese seiyu but still i tried. I agree that this article would be way better with some sources thought like that one to the Seiyu Awards Deletion of Jun Fukuyama WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
19733 14381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/QAliber User:AllyD 08:54, 16 March 2014 (UTC) delete """The Test and Try """"first look"""" review linked in the article is the most substantial coverage that I can see, and is not enough to demonstrate that the product ever attained |notability""" Deletion of QAliber :WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19734 16669 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Austerman User:Monterey 02:18, 28 October 2011 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Jim Austerman WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19735 3148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RJ Dheena User:TheCrazedBeast 14:31, 23 December 2016 (UTC) delete Does not meet Deletion of RJ Dheena WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19736 9292 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Central 1 Credit Union User:Bearcat 15:13, 9 October 2019 (UTC) delete Companies are not automatically entitled to have Wikipedia articles just because they exist — they need to be the ''subject'' of enough |reliable source coverage in ''media'' to satisfy , and are not entitled to keep articles sourced entirely to their own self-published content about themselves Deletion of Central 1 Credit Union WP:RS||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19737 13654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of windmills in Guernsey user:Andrew 00:27, 4 March 2021 (UTC) keep """Being on hiatus from AfD does not grant immunity to PRODs which are supposed to be uncontroversial. The page is reasonably well-sourced and the topic seems quite reasonable and respectable. As for , it's an |essay and so has """"''no official status, and do not speak for the Wikipedia community''"""". See also the Mills of God""" Deletion of List of windmills in Guernsey WP:MILL||WP:ESSAY Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
19738 4137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gumb user:WarthogDemon 15:36, 10 October 2009 (UTC) delete Fails |being anything remotely interesting Deletion of Gumb WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19739 10595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tejatat Tejasen User:Resurgent NONE delete fails as written; claims of notability are |unsourced and laced with weasel words. &mdash Deletion of Tejatat Tejasen WP:BIO||WP:CITE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19740 15481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miranda Brown NONE NONE delete Said singer Isn’t notable as stated above. No single evidence of notability on web search as there is little or no independent news coverage of her, hence she fails Deletion of Miranda Brown WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19741 15942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zazz User:Feedyourfeet 21:45, 17 July 2006 (UTC) comment """It does meet & i quote """"The company or corporation has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the company itself""" Deletion of Zazz WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19742 16245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taylor Behl User:Black 23:04, 10 February 2007 (UTC) keep """she has been the subject of multiple (several dozen at least), non-trivial, reliable news (national) publications, which alone qualifies her for otability. ''In addition'', she's the subject of a book--what more could one want for notability? I agree with the nom that """"being the victim of a murder does not automatically indicate |encyclopedic notability"""", but being the subject of so much attention and published coverage (news, books, TV, etc.) certainly does""" Deletion of Taylor Behl WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19743 13706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slovenian under-17 League User:JMHamo 21:55, 13 May 2015 (UTC) delete Youth football fails and is non-notable Deletion of Slovenian under-17 League WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19744 8484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Zilincik User:Agricola44 05:40, 22 January 2011 (UTC) delete Woefully insufficient . Almost every reference is web flotsam (university listings, pdf files, etc). While there is one mention in his local newspaper, that is very obviously trivial. It now seems clear that there are no real sources to demonstrate notability. Article is -created, so this may be little more than a vanity page. Uncontroversial policy-based delete. Respectfully Deletion of Tony Zilincik WP:RS||WP:SPA Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19745 17630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teairra Mari's Forthcoming Studio Album User:SRX 12:49, 1 August 2008 (UTC) delete per and and nom Deletion of Teairra Mari's Forthcoming Studio Album WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19746 7594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MAN-03 Braw Bro User:Pak21 14:25, 10 January 2007 (UTC) delete no assertion of notability even within the fictional universe. While minor characters/places/things can be merged, trivial things should just be deleted as #IINFO|Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of MAN-03 Braw Bro WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19747 296 [[Träume]] (zurückgezogen, ist jetzt eine echte BKL) Benutzer:Gestumblindi NONE keep """Ich halte eine BKL für sinnvoll. Redirects und BKLs sind ja nicht nur für die ''Schreiber'' da, die vielleicht mal einen falschen Link setzen, sondern in erster Linie für die ''Leser'', und von denen kann man nicht verlangen, unsere Singularregel zu kennen. Wenn es das Hörspiel """"Träume"""" nicht gäbe, wäre also ein Redirect von Träume auf Traum weiterhin sinnvoll. Solche Redirects sind ja bei vielen Pluralformen vorhanden, nach denen mutmasslich oft gesucht wird (z.B. von Götter auf Gott, von Hände auf Hand etc.). Da das Hörspiel existiert und einen Artikel hat, aber davon auszugehen ist, dass jemand, der """"Träume"""" in die Suchbox eingibt, in den meisten Fällen nicht das Hörspiel meint, sollte man die BKL - oder vielleicht noch besser in eine #Modell_3:_Stichwort_f.C3.BChrt_auf_eine_Weiterleitung_.28BKL_III.29|BKL Modell 3 umwandeln. D.h.: Träume redirectet auf Traum, dort wird oben wie in Andorra eine BKL für die andere Bedeutung gesetzt - bzw. wie in Otto von Bismarck auf eine Seite Träume (Begriffsklärung) verwiesen, sobald wir mehrere Artikel haben""" Löschung von Träume Wikipedia:BKL Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
19748 12505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cecilie Broch Knudsen User:Hmlarson 23:37, 19 February 2017 (UTC) keep per and Deletion of Cecilie Broch Knudsen WP:GNG||WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19749 154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Wissot (2nd nomination) User:Nsk92 23:14, 7 December 2014 (UTC) delete A few brief mentions in the news, but certainly not enough to pass Deletion of Michael Wissot (2nd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19750 3874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jaafar Aksikas User:Eric 16:43, 11 January 2009 (UTC) delete Does not seem to pass notability requirements under or . As pointed out by Hqb and Crusio, not just any journal can be used to satisfy criterion #8 (editor-in-chief of established journal Deletion of Jaafar Aksikas WP:PROF||WP:BIO||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19751 12532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Koyakatsi (2nd nomination) User:Piotrus 02:09, 16 April 2021 (UTC) delete or '''drafity'''. Not ready for mainspace - very poor sourcing and missing key information - like when was it released? Also nom's criticism of insufficient reception are reasonable and suggest this may fail / Deletion of Koyakatsi (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
19752 1676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ed, Edd n Eddy's Big Picture Show [[User talk:Treelo|treelo]] [[Special:Contributions/Treelo|radda]] 03:02, 13 August 2009 (UTC) delete I'm yet to see a decent reason as to why this article should be kept, so far the reasons for are that it should be kept through inherited notability and to wait a year before requesting again, the last one striking me as the least reasoned !vote here as it doesn't say why a year's wait should be enough. I guess it could be some kind of bizzaro-|recentism logic but I'll await further clarification. Even with the many AfDs proceeding this, they were for crystal-balling so a bit moot here. The lack of sourcing for this overlong synopsis along with no establishment of individual notability separate from the series doesn't give me much confidence in this article's future though I expect it to be recreated several times before being protected Deletion of Ed, Edd n Eddy's Big Picture Show WP:RECENT Wikipedia:Recentism 10
19753 13498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mattador User:Armbrust 21:48, 20 September 2010 (UTC) delete as article fails |notability criteria for band Deletion of Mattador WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19754 18228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salvatore Di Vittorio User:Cricket02 15:41, 12 January 2010 (UTC) keep Actually better sourced than others. Two third-party reliable refs were added on the 3rd (http://www.danbury.org/musicctr/DMCReviews2004.htm#DSO032005, http://www.nytimes.com/2008/05/26/arts/music/26cham.html), and I briefly looked around and added http://en.epochtimes.com/news/7-9-26/60119.html this one today. Passes notability requirements per usic. I tried to clean up for neutrality Deletion of Salvatore Di Vittorio WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
19755 11566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Italian language in Albania NONE NONE delete A clear ; the absence of references is not a surprise. Albania was an independent republic in 1930 and has never been a colony of Italy; who invaded it in 1939. Italian is not an official language of Albania Deletion of Italian language in Albania WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
19756 18473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Take Me Home (Alexandra Stan song) User:MarioSoulTruthFan 13:09, 11 July 2020 (UTC) delete With only one source, Celebmix, which I have some doubts regading its reability, it fails as it doesn't provide significant coverage in third-party, reliable sources (one isn't enough Deletion of Take Me Home (Alexandra Stan song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19757 78 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eternity (game) User:Hbdragon88 05:51, 7 December 2006 (UTC) delete Megaburn, you are ignoring the parts about and . No media coverage, no third-party sources, only the site itself listed as a source. This does not meet any standard of notability. WP is not for crystal ballery Deletion of Eternity (game) WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19758 4491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Kushiel's Legacy characters User:Reyk 12:21, 18 September 2011 (UTC) delete I agree with Jfgslo. This article cites no sources whatsoever. Per , there would have to be sources discussing these fictional characters ''as a group''- this list simply does ''not'' inherit notability from the work of fiction. The Wikipedia:V#Notability|verifiability states that if there are no reliable third-party sources that discuss a subject, we shouldn't have an article on it; and an article is not exempt from this just because it is written in a list format. Since there are no independent sources for this topic, it is impossible for it to be anything more than |pure plot summary. A merge has been suggested, but the obvious merge target already contains a character list of appropriate length. Since this article is unsuitable for a stand-alone article and a merge would accomplish nothing, deletion is the only option Deletion of List of Kushiel's Legacy characters WP:LISTN||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19759 7870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Georgy User:TonyTheTiger 18:48, 27 April 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Mark Georgy WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19760 18164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam C. Johnson User:KidAd 00:50, 9 January 2021 (UTC) delete Case study of . Not even worth mentioning at 2021 storming of the United States Capitol Deletion of Adam C. Johnson WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19761 19492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Westbrook Waldron (Canada) User:Bearcat 12:55, 29 October 2016 (UTC) delete per nom. This is indeed a genealogical profile of a person whose only claim of encyclopedic |notability is that he's an ancestor of other people, and which is sourced almost entirely to genealogical sources like Ancestry.com and census records and LDS microfilms. WikiTree exists for what this user seems to want to do, but this is OT|not what Wikipedia is for Deletion of Thomas Westbrook Waldron (Canada) WP:N||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19762 11997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Thomson (politician) User:Mkativerata 21:35, 14 May 2010 (UTC) keep There is no hierarchy of notability guidelines. Each guideline is just a guideline. They only create presumptions of notability. When guidelines create conflicting presumptions in a single case they should be balanced together with common sense, as follows: in this case, on balance, the extent to which the subject passes the general notability guideline outweighs the extent to which she fails Deletion of Sarah Thomson (politician) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19763 19382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zhang Yu (voice actress) User:IJBall 13:43, 7 December 2018 (UTC) delete Agree: unsourced BLP article, so no evidence of notability demonstrated. And based on what's presented there, the subject almost certainly does not meet Deletion of Zhang Yu (voice actress) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19764 9805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mitch McCarthy User:Bearian 20:50, 6 October 2016 (UTC) delete arguably, based on the large number of credits, there ought to be more and |deeper coverage of this mixer/engineer. However, other than the AllMusic link, I don't see a lot of |releiable sources on this subject. I'd give the editors a week to work on it, or possibly userfy it Deletion of Mitch McCarthy WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19765 11467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abraham Lincoln II User:RebeccaGreen 03:02, 3 February 2019 (UTC) merge relevant details about his infection and death to Robert Todd Lincoln. There is not enough significant, independent, reliable coverage to meet - most of the sources are genealogical, not reliable (a Tumblr blog), or primarily about his father or grandfather Deletion of Abraham Lincoln II WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19766 6276 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S.m.o.g. User:Lankiveil 10:01, 12 May 2008 (UTC) delete falls afoul of our |neologism notability guideline Deletion of S.m.o.g. WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
19767 20777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enrique Felpi User:Mdtemp 18:27, 23 September 2014 (UTC) delete Fails . Fighting at Madison Square Garden does not make you notable Deletion of Enrique Felpi WP:NBOX Wikipedia:Notability 77
19768 1265 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The band Element 115 User:Pete 05:47, 21 January 2008 (UTC) delete """fails . No charted hit, record certified gold or higher, international tours or major music award, not even close. Plus: not """"two or more albums on a major label"""", or """"subject of a half hour or longer broadcast across a national ... network"""" not close, just not close, to the standard of """"extensive coverage by reliable secondary sources"""" required by """ Deletion of The band Element 115 WP:BAND||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19769 5974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tornado supreme User:Wstaffor 23:01, 18 April 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Tornado supreme WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19770 15342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Douglas Whitehead User:Magnolia677 10:53, 27 September 2018 (UTC) delete Fails , , and . Two sources listed in the article, http://hiphopsince1987.com/2017/music/dougie-shows-how-he-made-1942-flows-off-meek-mills-wins-losses-album-hhs1987-exclusive/ and http://hiphopsince1987.com/2017/music/lihtz-kamraz-feat-kur-proud-prod-by-dougie/, offer some biographical detail, as does http://www.philadelphiaweekly.com/music/out-of-the-box-beats-dougie-on-the-beat-crafting/article_00fb6c28-e73f-11e7-81a4-f31729264693.html this source, which was not included in the article. The rest of the sources listed in the article either do not mention this person, mention only his name, or are links to other Wikipedia articles. This article does not appear to cross the threshold of notability yet Deletion of Douglas Whitehead WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19771 1569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Western International Hockey League User:Resolute 01:09, 4 May 2010 (UTC) keep the League article, no opinion, leaning delete, on the season articles at present (should they ever formally be added to this nom). The essay does not have guidelines regarding ice hockey leagues, so I'm not certain why you are using it as a basis to argue for deletion. Regardless, this was one of the top senior leagues in Canada at a time when senior hockey held considerably greater prestige as compared to today. Teams from this league competed for the Allan Cup at a time when it was second only to the Stanley Cup in prestige. Easily a notable league Deletion of Western International Hockey League WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19772 3044 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deviance in modern film User:Eddie 00:49, 10 May 2009 (UTC) delete for being Deletion of Deviance in modern film WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19773 12001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coxs Corner, Monmouth County, New Jersey User:Alansohn 18:29, 16 March 2015 (UTC) keep """As this is not an incorporated place, it would help to actually look at , which {{u|Magnolia677}} references to justify deletion - '''""""Populated places without legal recognition are considered on a case-by-case basis in accordance with the GNG. Examples may include subdivisions, business parks, housing developments, informal regions of a state, unofficial neighborhoods, etc. – any of which could be considered notable on a case-by-case basis, given non-trivial coverage in multiple, independent reliable sources. If a Wikipedia article cannot be developed using known sources, information on the informal place should be included in the more general article on the legally-recognized populated place or administrative subdivision that contains it.""""''' GNIS is a reliable and verifiable source, but it is not sufficient in and of itself to establish notability. http://www.state.nj.us/infobank/localnames.txt New Jersey Locality Search is also a reliable and verifiable source, but it too is not sufficient in and of itself to establish notability. The article for Fair Play, New Jersey created by Magnolia677 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Fair_Play,_New_Jersey&oldid=634909350 here with only a GNIS source does not meet the notability standard. The article for Coxs Corner under discussion here did not meet this standard as created. I concur with those who specify a minimum two-source standard, and this is what the definition of """"multiple, independent reliable sources"""" would appear to require. Under this clear definition of , the original versions of the Fair Play and Coxs Corner articles should each have been turned into redirects to the parent municipality article (as Magnolia677 would seem to agree here, though he offers no acceptable rationale for deletion rather than turning it into a redirect). Data from GNIS is duplicated in other sources -- such as Google Maps, Mapquest and Zillow, among many other such mapping and location-based search sites -- and the use of a GNIS source combined with one of these GNIS mirrors does not constitute a second independent source. The book source added to the Coxs Corner article by RAN is a second independent source here and that meets this bare minimum multiple source standard, which is why the article as it currently exists should be retained per """ Deletion of Coxs Corner, Monmouth County, New Jersey WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19774 12905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Porcerelli User:Coredesat 04:14, 14 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of John Porcerelli WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19775 406 [[Notdienst für Suchtmittelgefährdete und -abhängige Berlin e.V.]] (LAE) Benutzer:Schnatzel NONE delete """Die Autorin stellt die ''guten Absichten'' heraus. Zudem betont sie, dass es darum geht, ''auf sich aufmerksam zu machen'', damit Leute wissen ''wohin sie sich wenden sollten''. , Absatz 3 (Wikipedia ist keine Werbe- oder Propagandaplattform) und Absatz 9 (Wikipedia ist weder Anleitung noch Ratgeber). Irrelevante Artikel wegen ihrer """"guten Absichten"""" zu behalten ist enzyklopädisch genauso daneben wie relevante Artikel zu löschen, weil sie """"Pfui"""" oder politisch inkorrekt sind""" Löschung von Notdienst für Suchtmittelgefährdete und -abhängige Berlin e.V. Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19776 11944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roboticizer (2nd nomination) User:Artene50 04:15, 12 June 2008 (UTC) delete Nonsensical article with zero sources which suggests it is not It may also be Deletion of Roboticizer (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19777 2610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Berandal User:Narutolovehinata5 22:27, 26 October 2013 (UTC) keep Has received significant coverage in reliable sources, thus passing Deletion of Berandal WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
19778 20771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamino User:Gelmax 19:29, 13 August 2008 (UTC) keep """How much coverage by independent secondary sources must be shown before the nom and his buddy give in and stop saying """"nuh-uh!"""" to everyone who disagrees with them? While I'm no fan of simply pointing to policies, I think that everyone here could use a look at , , and the discussion articles linked from them such as proof by assertion, which seems to have been used quite often by Judgesurreal and several others in recent deletion discussions. While I'm glad that it's at least remaining civil, this really needs to stop. How many AfDs have I looked at today that degenerated into Hobit and Citrouilles posting source after source while Judgesurreal and EEMIV or Doctorfluffy call every single one non-notable? How many massive discussion trees do you have to fill with long-winded versions of the playground arguement strategy """"Nuh-uh!"""", """"uh-huh!"""" before you guys recognize that there is a ''problem'' and it needs to be solved? I'm new here, but Wikipedia is community-driven enough that I'm sure there IS a way to solve this, whether it be arbitration or something else""" Deletion of Kamino WP:UNENCYCLOPEDIC||WP:ITSNOTABLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
19779 3401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Leakey User:Whiteguru 11:49, 28 September 2020 (UTC) delete although an interesting narrative, it is self-referential, and half the article is about the family. Fails Deletion of Jonathan Leakey WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19780 12590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Garth Westbrook User:JavaTenor 18:59, 9 April 2007 (UTC) delete as probable |hoax Deletion of Garth Westbrook WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
19781 21537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devaki Marks User:Bearcat 17:20, 4 October 2015 (UTC) delete Radio personality of exclusively local-to-a-single-city notability, with nowhere near enough sourcing or substance to make her ''more'' notable under than the thousands upon thousands of other radio personalities of exclusively local notability who exist in the world Deletion of Devaki Marks WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19782 19889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gavin Lowe User:Corpx 06:15, 11 August 2007 (UTC) delete unless sources are found to get this past Deletion of Gavin Lowe WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19783 21166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Brumberg (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 06:10, 20 August 2014 (UTC) delete per nom (redirect would also be acceptable). does not confer notability on unelected ''candidates'' for office, and while this ''looks'' better-sourced on the surface than most campaign brochures for unelected candidates, closer examination reveals that a lot of the sources are |primary ones — so he can't claim the loophole either Deletion of Ryan Brumberg (2nd nomination) WP:NPOL||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19784 6204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gordon Manche User:Bearian 17:38, 7 August 2015 (UTC) delete per |past outcomes, whereby we almost always delete attack BLPs of marginally notable people Deletion of Gordon Manche WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19785 18558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Sayers User:TheBlackandSilver 02:36, 22 June 2016 (UTC) keep This politician does meet the , , and criteria to not warrant deletion in a variety of ways. The page is created using impartial and factual sources, which are accurately referenced. He is a major political figure who meets the primary notability criterion from many sources. Auckland Council is unique in that its wards are larger in area and population than electorates for central government. This politician holds dual office over an area much larger than an electorate. His regular news coverage is of public interest and the existence of this page achieves the aims of Wikipedia. It is not a . I have also noted that some contributors to the Auckland Council page have added material, including controversies associated with this politician. This businessman is also notable for his previous achievements and family background. Zorbing is as significant to New Zealand culture as Bungee jumping|bungee jumping. Greg has continued the legacy of his famous father, Alan Sayers, whose achievements are also noteworthy Deletion of Greg Sayers WP:POLITICIAN||WP:NBIO||WP:GNG||WP:SOAPBOX Wikipedia:Notability 77
19786 11849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John C. Clemens User:RGTraynor 19:56, 8 June 2007 (UTC) delete Just a guy who started a modestly successful business. Folks like him are in the hundreds of thousands. Fails , Deletion of John C. Clemens WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
19787 12353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Brook Road bridge over the Connecticut River User:Coolabahapple 07:22, 30 September 2016 (UTC) merge as Scott Brook Road Bridge to List of crossings of the Connecticut River in line with as not enough |sources to warrant a standalone article Deletion of Scott Brook Road bridge over the Connecticut River WP:GEOFEAT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19788 2933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of British Jewish entertainers [[User talk:Bulldog123|Bulldog123]] 09:09, 5 December 2010 (UTC) delete """Pretty much for the same exact reasons stated in the AfD for List of Jewish American entertainers ...with one thing to add. The """"British Jewish"""" connection seems much more synthesized than the """"Jewish American"""" one. Jewish American is well-defined -- a distinct ethnic & cultural group that many consider themselves part of. British Jews appears to be drafted on a minimal amount of sources and a lot of |OR - making the """"entertainer"""" intersection even worse""" Deletion of List of British Jewish entertainers WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19789 16767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Lighthill House User:Jpbowen 14:39, 21 March 2011 (UTC) keep there is historical information online and associations with Sir Michael James Lighthill, FRS, a significant applied mathematician. I have added historical information and updated the references. There is a lack of evidence that , especially points 4 & 6, was followed before proposing this article for deletion Deletion of James Lighthill House WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19790 17098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antipodean Pharmaceuticals User:scope_creep 11:14, 26 September 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Antipodean Pharmaceuticals WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
19791 1595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seymore Butts User:Malik 02:43, 18 February 2019 (UTC) keep """Easily passes , probably passes and as well. Those who are recommending deletion: Have you actually ''read'' the article? Glasser (""""Seymore Butts"""") was one of the originators of Gonzo pornography, his film series ''Seymore Butts'' won Best Gonzo Series AVN Awards in 1999 and 2000, he was the subject of a series on Showtime. How much more notable can a director of pornography be? — """ Deletion of Seymore Butts WP:NPORN||WP:ANYBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19792 17101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seton Hall University Alma Mater User:Kane5187 08:53, 8 January 2008 (UTC) delete not notable and unsupported by |reliable |citations Deletion of Seton Hall University Alma Mater WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19793 14148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Betoota Advocate User:Mkativerata 19:41, 7 December 2014 (UTC) delete The only reliable source coverage I could find was the ABC Mediawatch transcript of the story that Channel 9's Today Show fell for. That's not enough for the |GNG which, for good reason, requires in-depth coverage in multiple reliable sources Deletion of The Betoota Advocate WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19794 10891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Net Authority User:TenPoundHammer 20:12, 18 May 2008 (UTC) keep Weak assertations of notability, but they're there. And a |trout to the nom as well Deletion of Net Authority WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Whacking with a wet trout 74
19795 14051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bishop Road Primary School User:Ritchie333 10:46, 13 August 2012 (UTC) merge as per current policy of redirecting primary schools to the main education topic in that area, in the absence of any other sources to satisfy by other means (see Deletion of Bishop Road Primary School WP:GNG||WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Notability 77
19796 5030 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cache Olson User:E 20:54, 26 January 2017 (UTC) delete as Deletion of Cache Olson WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
19797 2496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cory Wade Hindorff User:Melia97 21:32, 23 November 2016 (UTC) delete Has not gained any sort of significant notability after losing a reality TV show. Fails Deletion of Cory Wade Hindorff WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19798 1765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fenrir (Dungeons & Dragons) User:Hello32020 20:41, 14 September 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Fenrir (Dungeons & Dragons) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19799 9564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Louis Mills User:A 10:32, 23 October 2005 (UTC) delete This is a completely interchangable, forgettable mall (I've been there many times), and right now this is a address directory entry. There's nothing encyclopedic to say about this particular mall, and this article right now runs afoul of Deletion of St. Louis Mills WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19800 19880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trust It (album) User:Rlendog 01:38, 5 December 2009 (UTC) keep Meets as an officially released album by a notable artist. And at least one review is linked in the article Deletion of Trust It (album) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19801 11619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Palmquist User:Born2cycle 02:53, 1 August 2011 (UTC) keep """He is a published author and there are http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=%22Stephen+Palmquist%22&btnG=Search&as_sdt=0%2C5&as_ylo=&as_vis=0 150 ghits at Scholar for """"Stephen Palmquist"""". The first result is a book he co-authored, """"Kant and the new philosophy of religion"""", which is http://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=4029321488913259173&as_sdt=2005&sciodt=0,5&hl=en cited 11 times. The first citation is in the book, """"Transcending boundaries in philosophy and theology: reason, meaning and ... """", which is at google bookshttp://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=xjdaX9C5QQsC&oi=fnd&pg=PR7&ots=1Y6bNXeG5q&sig=PGPAns1yFNs3EvrUqVsWuqoLs4Y#v=onepage&q&f=false, and can be searched for Palmquist. The reference is on p.79. Unless someone shows that all these references and citations are somehow bogus, I think that makes him notable per . But, then, I'm :Category:Inclusionist_Wikipedians|biased""" Deletion of Stephen Palmquist WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19802 13838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jay Sher User:Jfdwolff 20:54, 10 September 2011 (UTC) delete And so what if he's an expert in a rare hormone-secreting tumour? fail Deletion of Jay Sher WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19803 15347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shawn Carter (actor) User:Joe 02:04, 1 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |actor with only one major role Deletion of Shawn Carter (actor) WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
19804 16499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Fitzgerald User:HJ 17:29, 20 April 2009 (UTC) delete should have been tagged for speedy on grounds of , , etc etc. The article is merely speculation masquerading as fact and has no place in an encyclopaedia Deletion of Jennifer Fitzgerald WP:BLP||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19805 13295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Portfolio.hu User:Redditaddict69 03:18, 8 October 2018 (UTC) keep Unsure about but seems to be widely known in Hungary. There are a few sources that are independent but personally I think they are sufficient Deletion of Portfolio.hu WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19806 13902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Schnoebelen User:BreathingMeat 03:53, 4 May 2008 (UTC) comment To be honest, I thought that the {{fact}} tags made a fair enough point -- perhaps a little overzealous but |not in bad faith. Remember that we do have to adhere to as a matter of legal responsibility. Having said that, my vote is to '''Keep''' the article, as the guy is clearly a notable figure (as a published author and controversial religious commentator) despite the difficulty we seem to be having in finding appropriate references. I think the references and links we have are enough to establish his notability, even if they are perhaps not formal enough to establish much else Deletion of William Schnoebelen WP:AGF||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
19807 13511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Les Lancaster User:Kingofaces43 16:25, 28 December 2015 (UTC) delete Nothing particularly notable under . I'd expect a bit more for a professor to have enough material for an article. Article was also written by a blocked SPA account that was having issues with Deletion of Brian Les Lancaster WP:ACADEMIC||WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19808 7629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edwin E. Smith User:E 16:44, 29 January 2019 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Edwin E. Smith WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19809 4255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Firdous Shamim Naqvi User:Saqib 06:37, 28 July 2017 (UTC) delete doesn't pass Deletion of Firdous Shamim Naqvi WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19810 16696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick F. Leonard User:SGGH 10:37, 1 February 2008 (UTC) delete per CSD and Deletion of Patrick F. Leonard WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
19811 7660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kreator's 12th Studio album User:Edison 17:02, 1 August 2008 (UTC) delete per and . Also fails to show |notability and to satisfy |verifiability due to absence of |reliable sources Deletion of Kreator's 12th Studio album WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER||WP:N||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19812 12561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011 D.C. United Women season User:Number 14:21, 17 June 2018 (UTC) delete per failure Deletion of 2011 D.C. United Women season WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19813 14260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Serwaa Kesse Girls' Senior High School (SEKESS) User:Winged 16:56, 18 October 2019 (UTC) delete per nom and Rockphed. The circular argument per was rejected from being considered as a valid argument, after a site-wide RfC Deletion of Serwaa Kesse Girls' Senior High School (SEKESS) WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19814 18149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whopperbuzz User:Radiant 18:27, 29 November 2005 (UTC) delete nn. Deletion of Whopperbuzz WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
19815 13719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wes Cummins User:Gaff NONE delete Interesting, yet non-notable per io.— Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Wes Cummins WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
19816 6023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesusry User:IslaySolomon 03:21, 30 November 2006 (UTC) delete per noms http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=Jesusry&btnG=Google+Search ghits. |Neologism |dict def. |Wikipedia is not a dictionary Deletion of Jesusry WP:NEO||WP:DICDEF||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
19817 15059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Homosocratic User:JohnCD 16:54, 16 March 2009 (UTC) delete """unsourced neologism. Note to article author: it's not that """"Wikipedia has decided that it is not a word"""" - it's undoubtedly a word, but it's a ''new'' word and there is no evidence but your assertion that it is in widespread use. http://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_q=homosocratic&num=10&btnG=Search+Scholar&as_epq=&as_oq=&as_eq=&as_occt=any&as_sauthors=&as_publication=&as_ylo=&as_yhi=&as_allsubj=all&hl=en&lr= Google scholar does not find it. Wikipedia isn't a place for first publication of anything - see |No original research and #Articles on neologisms|Articles on neologisms and |Wikipedia is not for things made up one day""" Deletion of Homosocratic WP:OR||WP:NEO||WP:NFT Wikipedia:No original research 65
19818 4453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deji Falope (Television Host) User:Persian 21:51, 22 November 2006 (UTC) delete a promo article that lacks the requirements Deletion of Deji Falope (Television Host) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19819 4259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rspoprockband User:Edison 04:28, 10 December 2008 (UTC) delete No independent and reliable sources to establish notability. Myspace and Youtube and the like. Fails and Deletion of Rspoprockband WP:N||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19820 14507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011–12 Eastleigh F.C. season (2nd nomination) User:Mentoz86 23:03, 28 August 2013 (UTC) keep """my opinion has not changed since the previous AfD one year ago - this subject passes , even if the clubs plays in the """"wrong"""" league""" Deletion of 2011–12 Eastleigh F.C. season (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19821 1541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Cavilla User:Valenciano 13:13, 14 May 2012 (UTC) delete """coverage simply isn't there so the subject fails both and . Arguments along the lines of """"I reckon this should be in Wikipedia"""" have no basis in policy and are specifically discouraged per """ Deletion of Charles Cavilla WP:GNG||WP:POLITICIAN||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19822 4163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rantahryu User:Accounting4Taste 18:59, 25 September 2007 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet otability and I can't find much in the way of third-party coverage, except of the methods of which this is an offshoot of an offshoot. I can't see a way to shoehorn this in as a sentence in Tang Soo Do, for instance; best left uncovered, I suggest Deletion of Rantahryu WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19823 9723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frederica Jansz [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart111''']] [[User talk:Stalwart111|(talk)]] 05:31, 29 September 2012 (UTC) comment while we should assume good faith, this nom was made by a brand new who joined WP to ANGRILY nominate a BLP which has been controversial, and subject to IP vandalism and edit-warring. Suggest there is at least some going on, if not . The article has a number of sources that appear to provide coverage of the subject. So in what way are you suggesting the subject does not meet ? Are the sources not reliable? Otherwise I would suggest this is a Y nomination and perhaps should be withdrawn Deletion of Frederica Jansz WP:SPA||WP:COI||WP:SOC||WP:GNG||WP:POINT Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
19824 21600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lynn Hershman Leeson User:Williamborg 04:50, 4 September 2006 (UTC) keep When one has to revert to Wikipedia:Search engine test|Google testing for something written, you suspect it is a slim topic; I began this originally with a delete. But Goggle shows 39,000 hits, many of which show some merit. Someone needs to beeef this article up. But she passes . Keep it Deletion of Lynn Hershman Leeson WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19825 19911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Regnart Elementary School User:Mh29255 20:58, 17 December 2007 (UTC) delete per nom: article is completely non-notable per Deletion of Regnart Elementary School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19826 15963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Butterfly warrior User:Amatulic 01:10, 8 January 2009 (UTC) delete I don't know that it's a neologism, but it's certainly a non-notable non-encyclopedic term. The article also has clear problems, and lacks citations other than referring to what seem to be primary sources for this term Deletion of Butterfly warrior WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
19827 7834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kübra Dadaşoğlu User:Yosemiter 21:31, 14 August 2017 (UTC) delete """I am not seeing '''significant coverage''' per GNG, specifically: ''""""Significant coverage"""" addresses the topic directly and in detail, so that no original research is needed to extract the content. Significant coverage is more than a trivial mention, but it does not need to be the main topic of the source material.'' Anything that is just a passing mention or game coverage is typically considered . Number 1 is a team roster. Number 2 is coverage of the Championship team going into details on the backgrounds the players who participated. Her only mention there is """"Kubra Dadaşoğlu, who is the best goalkeeper in the Turkish Ice Hockey Federation Women's League, and Betul Toygar, who is the best forward player, stated that women in the first place in the East are not warmly interested in sports but they are appreciated by the success stories that extend to the championship"""" (more or less based on translation) and really only confirms that she was named Best Goaltender. Number 3 is a interview with what appears to be her entire team, she is quoted three times (two of which are one sentence responses) and lacks the depth of coverage needed for a GNG-worthy source as she is not the subject. Number 4 is the same article as Number 2. Number 5 mentions her as the best goaltender from the previous season. Number 6 is a brief article stating the team won the championship and the subject won best goaltender. Number 7, she is listed among other athletes invited to a training camp. Number 8, she is listed as a member if the team. Number 9 is a stats page. For a Turkish player, this coverage is better than most get. However, I am just not seeing significant depth needed for GNG""" Deletion of Kübra Dadaşoğlu WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19828 14124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Gadfly (Philosophy Magazine) User:Amalthea 11:55, 8 August 2008 (UTC) delete I usually like to give articles that are {{tl2|underconstruction}} a chance, but after reading the authors assertion of notability on Talk:The Gadfly (Philosophy Magazine) I'm afraid that this topic will never pass , barring some new significant coverage. Campus magazines and blogs just aren't enough, leaving only http://www.columbiaspectator.com/eye/index.php/site/article/philosophy-on-the-fly/ this Deletion of The Gadfly (Philosophy Magazine) WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19829 6725 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Sikh members of the United States Congress User:Sandstein 13:33, 17 July 2020 (UTC) delete as a of Dalip Singh Saund. By definition, a list of one is not a list Deletion of List of Sikh members of the United States Congress WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
19830 7909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mutant Pop Records NONE NONE keep based on the impropriety of the nomination. ''Cf.'' point 2. In my estimation, the article's notability is debatable—not clearly lacking, not obviously established—but I do not believe it's appropriate to reach that question under the circumstances Deletion of Mutant Pop Records WP:SKCRIT Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
19831 2971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Edward's College, East Gosford User:Twenty 14:56, 17 August 2007 (UTC) keep Found some |reliable sources on a quick google search Deletion of St. Edward's College, East Gosford WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19832 1951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sebastian Cruz Couture (2nd nomination) User:HighKing 21:39, 5 March 2021 (UTC) delete """The criteria for establishing notability for companies/organizations is and applies a stricter interpretation of requirements than for other topics. In short, requires multiple sources (at least two) of deep or significant coverage with |in-depth information *on the company* and (this bit is important!) containing |""""Independent Content"""". """"Independent content"""", in order to count towards establishing notability, must include ''original and independent opinion, analysis, investigation, and fact checking that are clearly attributable to a source unaffiliated to the subject''. That means, nothing that relies on company information or announcements or interviews, etc. None of the references in the article meet the criteria and having searched I am unable to locate any references that meet the criteria. Topic fails """ Deletion of Sebastian Cruz Couture (2nd nomination) WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19833 18068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sonny Bama User:STATicVapor 19:41, 17 May 2014 (UTC) delete Fails , lacks significant independent coverage in |reliable sources Deletion of Sonny Bama WP:MUSICBIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19834 3885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SkillSlate User:Ihcoyc 20:37, 13 November 2010 (UTC) delete vehemently. This is yet another search engine manipulation business (''According to a website description, SkillSlate helps the pages of service providers surface more prominently in search engine queries'') using Wikipedia to manipulate search engines. References given are entirely routine announcements of funding or local events that do not come close to meeting |the business notability guideline. Article is |advertising from beginning to end Deletion of SkillSlate WP:CORP||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
19835 15534 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Movie jamUP [[User talk:Erpert|(let's talk about it)]] 16:30, 5 June 2010 (UTC) delete as |hoax. ''Three'' Google hits, all of them Wikipedia. '''Erpert Deletion of Movie jamUP WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
19836 6248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of time and places in cases of Sherlock Holmes User:Ajf773 09:36, 6 October 2020 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of time and places in cases of Sherlock Holmes WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
19837 11322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Roger Currie (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep per . I went through the existing references and evaluated each for . The yes/no is if I saw that reference as qualifying under Deletion of Alan Roger Currie (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19838 11526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rhys Williams, sociologist User:Nomoskedasticity 19:07, 28 September 2008 (UTC) keep Editorship of JSSR is sufficient to meet Deletion of Rhys Williams, sociologist WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
19839 6215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dragon Ball FO User:UzEE 21:18, 2 January 2008 (UTC) delete Per , as it fails to cite any sources at all. Although it would be exciting if it turns to be true Deletion of Dragon Ball FO WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19840 237 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saturday Night Fever (musical cast) User:Ryan 10:47, 6 August 2010 (UTC) delete per - this seems more appropriate for IMDB or similar Deletion of Saturday Night Fever (musical cast) WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19841 16981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sayonala User:Northamerica1000 15:15, 5 November 2016 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Sayonala WP:NOTDIC Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
19842 18622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kembra Pfahler NONE NONE keep In what way does it fail ? To me, it appears to meet several of the criteria Deletion of Kembra Pfahler WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19843 8531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ShoMiz User:Isarra 19:38, 30 March 2013 (UTC) keep well-covered, won an apparently somewhat important thingy, and while doesn't entirely apply to this sort of thing there's probably enough here to merit keeping especially on account of the winningness. If anyone searches for 'showmiz' they'll probably be wanting this instead of an article on one or the other of the guys regardless Deletion of ShoMiz WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19844 8205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fistful User:Lightburst 22:34, 11 January 2020 (UTC) delete we are not a search index and the article titles are all different . I fail to see how this would help our readers per Deletion of Fistful WP:PTM||WP:D Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
19845 1140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Merton College (London) User:Arxiloxos 23:09, 21 March 2014 (UTC) keep A merger (retaining the sourced historical content about this school) can be considered separately from the AfD but deletion would not be appropriate here, as {{U|Eastmain}} correctly states; |notability is not temporary Deletion of Merton College (London) WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19846 16955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Brown (Texas politician) User:E 10:30, 12 March 2019 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Bob Brown (Texas politician) WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19847 2755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Count Reginald Alford Promquery User:RHaworth 14:17, 26 March 2007 (UTC) comment So if you like it, copy it to . And curses I missed the initials Deletion of Count Reginald Alford Promquery WP:BJAODN Wikipedia:Silly Things 72
19848 291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Video DownloadHelper User:Philg88 09:16, 23 May 2014 (UTC) keep Easily passes the |notability threshold with widespread coverage in |reliable sources Deletion of Video DownloadHelper WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19849 6007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PRstore User:AllyD 08:54, 12 July 2015 (UTC) delete As per the nominator, I am seeing nothing beyond routine announcements in the period to 2009 and then the given references to the legal action, but nothing that would meet Deletion of PRstore :WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
19850 12305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Lebed User:Wikicology 08:05, 31 October 2014 (UTC) keep Subject of the article meets . There are enough coverages to |reliable sources that establish the subject |notability Deletion of Jonathan Lebed WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19851 8409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Cooters User:Chubbles 15:41, 27 January 2009 (UTC) keep None of the reasons cited above are valid reasons for deletion. The article's already tagged for cleanup. Artist meets Deletion of The Cooters WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19852 18040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniele Catanzaro User:Xxanthippe 22:40, 10 July 2020 (UTC) delete Citations not enough for rof Deletion of Daniele Catanzaro WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
19853 16395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julio Santa Cruz User:Sunderland06 23:22, 6 August 2008 (UTC) delete Fails as he didn't play a game for Cerro Porteno as far as I can see, can be re-created if/when he makes an appearances for Blackburn Deletion of Julio Santa Cruz WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19854 7672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nuclear Fatwa under International Law User:HyperGaruda 07:57, 15 April 2017 (UTC) delete half of the article is a about the fatwa itself instead of the book reviewing it; the other half is poorly sourced. To that, add a dash of and sprinkle with Deletion of Nuclear Fatwa under International Law WP:COATRACK||WP:SYNTH||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
19855 2861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesus the True Vine Christian Fellowship User:RadioFan 20:20, 18 March 2010 (UTC) delete Fails , no indication of how it might be notable Deletion of Jesus the True Vine Christian Fellowship WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19856 3916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Before I Weigh User:Whpq 17:04, 2 November 2011 (UTC) merge """to Cellulite Soul. There is a guideline for |""""just another single"""". I don't see the coverage that would justify a separate article for the song""" Deletion of Before I Weigh WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19857 18339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roger DiLuigi III User:DrStrauss 16:28, 31 July 2017 (UTC) delete no in Deletion of Roger DiLuigi III WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19858 12694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RJ Amuthan User:Bonadea 09:57, 18 September 2014 (UTC) delete fails the |General notability guideline and the |notability guideline for entertainers. This seems like an |up and coming person - once he has gained real notability there can be a Wikipedia article about him, but not before Deletion of RJ Amuthan WP:GNG||WP:ENT||WP:UPANDCOMING Wikipedia:Notability 77
19859 10353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of minor characters in Xenosaga (2nd nomination) User:MuZemike 22:18, 22 August 2008 (UTC) comment before I pass judgment, I'd like to say that the first AfD was improperly closed (non-admin) as a keep. When there is no ''clear'' consensus (there was 4 '''keep'''s and 1 '''delete''') the discussion should not be non-admin closed; instead, let it run its course and let admin decide, even if they decide to keep. Not doing that leaves the door wide open for |DRVs and/or subsequent AfD nominations Deletion of List of minor characters in Xenosaga (2nd nomination) WP:DRV Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19860 7010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khokababu (TV series) User:Shawn 12:25, 21 June 2016 (UTC) keep agreed, Star Jalsha seems to expressly ''meet'' Deletion of Khokababu (TV series) WP:TVSHOW Wikipedia:Notability 77
19861 9704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryan Pisano (2nd nomination) User:Captain 19:55, 9 May 2008 (UTC) delete no |reliable sources to establish |notability means that it fails , one imdb entry does not IMHO make the grade Deletion of Bryan Pisano (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19862 16785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of German Americans User:Badagnani 03:09, 28 August 2007 (UTC) keep encyclopedic, well sourced (279 footnotes) and needed for our users. Contribute constructively, not destructively, to our project, and do not disruptively propose this article for deletion again, thanks Deletion of List of German Americans WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
19863 16040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rob Cornilles User:Bearcat 14:27, 29 November 2016 (UTC) delete Non-winning candidates for political office do not get Wikipedia articles just for being candidates; if you cannot credibly claim and |reliably source that he was ''already'' eligible for a Wikipedia article for some other reason ''independent'' of his candidacy, then he has to ''win'' the seat, not just run for it, to become eligible because of his political activity itself. But this does not demonstrate any reason at all why he would be eligible for an article Deletion of Rob Cornilles WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19864 11749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randox Laboratories User:VMS 05:36, 5 November 2014 (UTC) keep Needs a lot of work, but is Deletion of Randox Laboratories WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19865 20293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Microsoft Windows Tiger User:Whpq 17:49, 29 January 2013 (UTC) delete Article actually fails |verifiability. Micrsoft did ahve a project by the codename of Tiger but it was video streaming technology and eventually became part of NetShow; all of which predates this supposed OS version Deletion of Microsoft Windows Tiger WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19866 18060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Circuit (film) User:Otto4711 20:51, 10 December 2008 (UTC) comment given the improvements to the article since this AFD was opened and given that it appears to be ing a bit, can this be closed Deletion of Circuit (film) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
19867 736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 Richmond High School gang rape User:Xymmax 16:52, 6 November 2009 (UTC) keep """although I won't shed a tear if it is deleted. The split between NOTNEWS !votes and N/CA !votes is stark, but in reality people are talking across each other rather than engaging the issue. The NOTNEWS camp holds that this article, irrespective of verifiability, NPOV, and notability of the material, is not appropriate, and cannot be made appropriate. The N/CA folk are essentially saying that there is plenty of coverage from which an article can be written. In other words, one group asks """"could we"""" while the other asks """"should we"""". I come down moderately as saying """"we should"""". There all ready is coverage that addresses the larger context of this event, see http://www.statesman.com/opinion/content/editorial/stories/2009/11/04/1104swan_edit.html here for example, or listen to the audio coverage http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=114287592&ps=rs here (notice both of the opining professors are blue links). Since notability, in the sense of independant coverage in wp:reliable sources|reliable sources cannot reasonably be challenged, I think that an article treating the event is appropriate. I will confess to reservations about BLP issues, which I encountered http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=2009_Richmond_High_School_gang_rape&action=historysubmit&diff=323476997&oldid=323475774 early on with this article, and eventually prompted me to list it on the /N|BLP noticeboard, but I think that there are enough sets of eyes to keep things under control""" Deletion of 2009 Richmond High School gang rape WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19868 19608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russophobia User:Balcer 05:36, 16 July 2007 (UTC) keep of course. At to everyone making a connection between this article and Estophobia, I suggest a careful re-read of oint Deletion of Russophobia WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
19869 1440 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Technochrist User:JamesBurns 08:47, 17 February 2009 (UTC) delete insufficient independent 3rd party coverage Deletion of Technochrist WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19870 12363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iranian moderates User:Pahlevun 17:57, 26 February 2017 (UTC) merge Politics of Iran. Wikipedia:Notability: There is no solid literature around the term, which is apparently a neologism. Most of the article is Deletion of Iranian moderates WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19871 18704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesus isn't a dick keep him out of my vagina User:Darkness 20:02, 4 August 2013 (UTC) delete per (E) Single event with to lasting notability Deletion of Jesus isn't a dick keep him out of my vagina WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19872 17260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Milena Szymczyk User:Kraxler 00:37, 3 October 2015 (UTC) delete fails and , no sources in the article except ice-skating stats, web searches turn up social media and youtube videos Deletion of Milena Szymczyk WP:NSKATE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19873 1400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edith Grove User:Eastmain 07:32, 12 June 2007 (UTC) keep """New Mexico media coverage passes the """"reliable sources"""" test, and hence the band passes . There is an allmusic.com listing at http://www.allmusic.com/cg/amg.dll?p=amg&searchlink=EDITH|GROVE&sql=11:wxfwxqqgldde~T2 The article doesn't menbtion which label the albums are on, though, suggesting that they may be self-released""" Deletion of Edith Grove WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
19874 10135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OtterBox User:Supernerd11 17:57, 7 March 2014 (UTC) keep Definitely and has a wide variety of reliable sources. Might've been a promo at one time, but it's certainly not now Deletion of OtterBox WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19875 6085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alina Foley (2nd nomination) User:Ron 00:19, 14 May 2010 (UTC) comment Being a |BLP, a few more comments would be helpful before this is closed Deletion of Alina Foley (2nd nomination) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19876 13561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uju Obuekwe User:Timtrent 18:20, 11 April 2021 (UTC) delete This has been to mainspace and back to Draft already. Draftifying is not recommended as an outcome. This is simple advertising cruft for a businessperson. It fails .Referencing is unremitting poor, despite attempts by reviewer(s) to encourage enhancement. The suspicion of UPE has been denied by the creating editor, which AGF demands I honour, yet the style of the article still carries the scent of it Deletion of Uju Obuekwe WP:ROTM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
19877 15401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jared Remy User:ReverendWayne 18:36, 22 August 2013 (UTC) keep The article's subject, as the son of a notable baseball broadcaster and player, gets more media attention than might be given to another criminal defendant. Coverage of the steroids story along with the murder charge takes this out of single-event territory. Agree with Hirolovesswords on Deletion of Jared Remy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19878 13821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Smooth Island (Ontario) User:Bearcat 18:44, 22 December 2014 (UTC) delete The provided references are not substantive coverage of the island in |reliable sources, but rather serve only as |verification that the island ''exists''. Islands can be notable enough for inclusion in Wikipedia, absolutely — but small and unpopulated islands are not ''entitled'' to Wikipedia articles which demonstrate little more than the fact that they ''exist''. No prejudice against recreation in the future if ''real'' sources supporting ''substantive'' content about the island can be located — but being able to locate it on Google Maps is not, in and of itself, enough to qualify a place for a Wikipedia article if that's ''all'' you can do for referencing Deletion of Smooth Island (Ontario) WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19879 21114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Timetales User:Gary 19:23, 24 April 2008 (UTC) delete Per above; needs some Deletion of Timetales WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19880 21512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gassama Alfusainey (2nd nomination) User:Spiderone 17:22, 8 January 2021 (UTC) comment I definitely would agree with being used Deletion of Gassama Alfusainey (2nd nomination) WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
19881 1829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Rovics User:MCB 22:55, 22 January 2006 (UTC) keep bad faith nom, . After 10 or more of these it is time to block nominator for disruption of Wikipedia Deletion of David Rovics WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
19882 12497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nadine Burke Harris [[User talk:75.108.94.227|talk]]) 21:44, 1 September 2015 (UTC) keep per . Also, provideth: Mar'11.http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2011/03/21/the-poverty-clinic Jul'11.http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/10/fashion/weddings/nadine-burke-arno-harris-weddings.html?_r=0 Nov'13.https://www.dmu.edu/dose/2013/11/newly-released-data-on-adverse-childhood-experiences-analyzed-at-iowa-aces-lunch-and-learn/https://www.dmu.edu/dose/2014/02/toll-aces/ Jan'14.http://www.c-span.org/person/?nadineharris Aug'14.http://www.boston.com/health/2014/08/17/nadine-burke-harris-founder-ceo-center-for-youth-wellness/DDBfipvq3681Hij2Ggq9tK/video.html Nov'14.http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Google-gives-3-million-to-Nadine-Burke-Harris-5865372.phphttp://www.sfgate.com/visionaryoftheyear/article/Dr-Nadine-Burke-Harris-gets-to-the-heart-of-6082828.php Lastly, means legit papers, via wiki-reliable co-authors/editors/journals, do help show , there is no that I'm aware of. Special:Contributions/75.108.94.227|75.108.94.227 Deletion of Nadine Burke Harris WP:IAR||WP:GOOG||WP:SCHOLARSHIP||WP:N||WP:ONLYIFSHEHASTENTHOUSANDCITES Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
19883 8890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/August 2017 Brussels attack User:Greenbörg 10:56, 2 September 2017 (UTC) keep as clearly passes with widespread coverage for this event Deletion of August 2017 Brussels attack WP:NEVENTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
19884 13175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Statue of Thomas Cass User:Gleeanon409 03:52, 10 October 2019 (UTC) keep per above. does not seemed to have been followed Deletion of Statue of Thomas Cass WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19885 19975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terra Incognita (Juliette Lewis album) User:Michig 07:27, 31 July 2016 (UTC) keep due to complete failure and obvious notability. The first few pages of Google results also threw up coverage from http://www.allmusic.com/album/terra-incognita-mw0000820195 Allmusic, http://www.avclub.com/review/juliette-lewis-emterra-incognitaem-32310 A.V. Club, http://www.spin.com/2009/03/juliette-lewis-explains-her-dark-new-album/ SPIN, https://www.theguardian.com/music/2009/aug/30/juliette-lewis-terra-incognita ''The Guardian'', http://www.rocksound.tv/reviews/read/juliette-lewis-terra-incognita ''Rock Sound'', and http://www.uncut.co.uk/reviews/album/juliette-lewis-the-new-romantiques-terra-incognita ''Uncut Deletion of Terra Incognita (Juliette Lewis album) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19886 10291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Buchtmann User:Argyle 16:48, 2 September 2010 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Christopher Buchtmann WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19887 7283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rice rocket User:Niteshift36 04:26, 16 July 2009 (UTC) delete WP is for 's Deletion of Rice rocket WP:NOTDICT||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
19888 422 [[Eurofestival]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Tom_md 16:13, 26. Apr. 2010 (CEST) delete """Geheimtipp der Region"""". Na dann lassen wir es mal geheim bleiben und wegen meilenweiter Unterschreitung der """ Löschung von Eurofestival Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
19889 12515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kim Se-jeong (singer) User:Finnusertop 22:22, 20 September 2016 (UTC) delete fails – Deletion of Kim Se-jeong (singer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19890 17346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Jones views User:AllGloryToTheHypnotoad 17:19, 6 August 2007 (UTC) comment """I think that it might have been a better idea to have kept the """"views"""" section in the main article, and then deleted those things that you consider to be unsourced. I can understand that Wikipedia can't have an article saying """"these are the views of Alex Jones"""" without full attribution, since we need to abide by . However, forking off and AfDing seems like the wrong way to deal with it - and 1 week was a bit short for a notification period, as the complaints in the talk page suggest. I suspect that the """"best option"""" would probably end in a revert war, but at least then the problems would stay with the main article. So I'd say '''withdraw AfD, revert back into the main article,''' and then delete unattributed/dangerous stuff from there. Unfortunately, that might mean keeping the article on a watchlist to ensure that troublesome unattributed statements don't come back: what can you do, though, eh""" Deletion of Alex Jones views WP:LIVING Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19891 14769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zulekha Daud User:Aust331 09:36, 8 August 2016 (UTC) keep Agree with Northamerica1000 about article passing via available sources Deletion of Zulekha Daud WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19892 3878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ekramuddin Ahmad User:Nosebagbear 11:50, 11 August 2018 (UTC) keep both and seem satisfied by Worldbruce's sources Deletion of Ekramuddin Ahmad WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19893 21377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/House of Love (Mumbai) NONE NONE keep per but the topic does meet notability guidelines, although not on a grand level just scrapes through. There is coverage in major Indian newspapers .It is a 52 year old organisation.Note it is mentioned as Sneha Sadan and I have not gone through the coverage in the local Marathi and Hindi languages Deletion of House of Love (Mumbai) WP:AUD Wikipedia:Notability 77
19894 19123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DrEd User:Tiggerjay 05:49, 27 February 2013 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of DrEd WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19895 6667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katarina Lilja (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 19:39, 5 August 2020 (UTC) delete per , , and . Backup singers are almost never notable Deletion of Katarina Lilja (2nd nomination) WP:SNOW||WP:MILL||WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
19896 14217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of number-one albums in Australia during the 1970s User:ScottDavis 13:43, 2 September 2008 (UTC) keep does not satisfy any of the reasons for deletion in #REASON Deletion of List of number-one albums in Australia during the 1970s WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
19897 15604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of TEDx conferences User:Roller26 20:50, 2 September 2020 (UTC) delete Concur with nom and above comments. The list is pretty arbitrary in nature covering only a tiny fraction of events based on no observable criteria. Also it has lot of intent by the use of good number of external links within the main space. The official TED website is far better for this purpose covering not only all the future events but also all the past events as well Deletion of List of TEDx conferences WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19898 18620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gilbert Aldana User:LiberatorLX 22:54, 2 December 2013 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass Deletion of Gilbert Aldana WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
19899 7068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hernando Ruiz-Jimenez User:Dlohcierekim 05:22, 30 April 2017 (UTC) delete coverage not sufficient to meet . Position not sufficient to have notability on its own Deletion of Hernando Ruiz-Jimenez WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19900 12083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chaos Theory (essay) User:Tempodivalse 14:34, 26 March 2009 (UTC) delete per above and Deletion of Chaos Theory (essay) WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19901 21061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephanie Banister User:Nick 08:46, 10 August 2013 (UTC) delete this is a textbook example of Deletion of Stephanie Banister WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19902 8476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harry Fraud User:STATicVerseatide 02:34, 15 April 2013 (UTC) keep Easily passes and . Coverage including http://www.xxlmag.com/rap-music/2013/03/harry-fraud-talks-sampling-adrift-mixtape-download/ XXL http://www.factmag.com/2013/03/07/producer-of-the-moment-harry-fraud-recruits-action-bronson-french-montana-and-more-for-adrift-mixtape/ Fact Magazine, http://www.hiphopdx.com/index/interviews/id.1979/title.sean-price-interviews-harry-fraud-they-discuss-hamburgers-surfing-producer-tags HipHop DX, http://www.thefader.com/2012/06/29/beat-construction-harry-fraud-2/ The Fader, and http://www.complex.com/music/2012/10/25-new-producers-to-watch-out-for/harry-fraud Complex Magazine. Not to mention the MTV articles sourced in the article Deletion of Harry Fraud WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19903 2059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teamlorio.net User:AmitDeshwar 01:11, 26 September 2006 (UTC) keep It meets so lets keep it. I agree that simply hosting your webpage on Newsgrounds is not signifigant but thate fact that it has been on the front page and given awards suggests that it is in fact notable. Evidence of those things should be presented though Deletion of Teamlorio.net WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
19904 20100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Casey and dew User:Capitalistroadster 02:58, 15 June 2006 (UTC) delete Can't see how this meets Deletion of Casey and dew WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
19905 19527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deletionist versus Inclusionist Controversy User:Edison 22:41, 23 January 2008 (UTC) comment The very day that USA Today, BusinessWeek, National Public Radio, Der Spiegel and Harvard Business School all write substantial coverage of any of us gazing at navels, it will become a notable subject for a Wikipedia article. See Deletion of Deletionist versus Inclusionist Controversy WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19906 2604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Footballdatabase.eu User:Spiderone 16:05, 4 December 2020 (UTC) delete a very useful website for me as a fan of football stats but, unfortunately, fails and Deletion of Footballdatabase.eu WP:NWEB||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19907 5267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VEMA High Angle Rescue User:VQuakr 05:48, 12 February 2011 (UTC) delete There are many articles about rescue organizations on Wikipedia, but Wikipedia:Org#No_inherent_notability|notability is not inherent. The existing references in the article do not establish notability because one is the group's home page, one is a blog, and the last is not about the organization. This at a ''weak'' delete for me due to the mild inherent bias of the guideline: I think an identical organization from North America would meet the but local media in KwaZulu-Natal might have less of an online presence. I agree with the author that the similarity to other works does not justify deletion on copyright grounds here Deletion of VEMA High Angle Rescue WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19908 8778 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Epsom Normal Primary School User:GRBerry 01:13, 13 August 2006 (UTC) delete Age is not an adequate assertion of notability. Being first in some significant way (not in a sub-national geographic unit) might make the cut. With no adeqaute assertion of notability, keeping it violates the policy against being an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of Epsom Normal Primary School WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19909 14937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michele Bowie User:Freshacconci 03:30, 2 November 2010 (UTC) delete per nom. This does not pass and firmly falls under Deletion of Michele Bowie WP:BIO||WP:ONEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19910 18733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reader's Circle User:Cunard 10:31, 10 April 2011 (UTC) delete """per the lack of |reliable sources. The sources do not cover Reader's Circle in sufficient depth to establish notability. Analysis of the sources in the article:1. At 1,500 local book groups, MeetUp.com has a larger network but is a commercial site. – this is a footnote, not a source.2. Handcock, Nancy. ''Spirit of Service: Your Daily Stimulus for Making a Difference'', (HarperCollins: New York, 2008), p. 10. – http://books.google.com/books?id=kq-5RQbONFIC&pg=PA10#v=onepage&q&f=false The source states: """"Go to www.readerscircle.org, an Internet resource that helps people organize and sustain reader's circles. The site has a wealth of information; you can also post a listing on the site to attract potential members and connect with authors who will speak with your group by phone."""" As {{user|Kinu}} notes above, this is a directory entry. Directory entries do not establish notability because they are not as calculated and selective as sources that purposefully delve into a specific topic.3. http://www.postgazette.com/pg/05066/466991-44.stm Exclusive book clubs writing a new chapter in social status,"""" ''Wall Street Journal'', March 4, 2005. – Reader's Circle receives a tangential coverage in this source: """"In New York, legal assistant Sarah Milks has a boldfaced posting on a Web site called readerscircle.org that starts off: NOT ACCEPTING NEW MEMBERS AT THIS TIME. Despite that warning, 200 new applications have poured in over the past year, all but one of which were rejected."""" While a ''Wall Street Journal'' source generally establishes notability for a subject, Reader's Circle receives merely a one sentence mention. The remainder of the paragraph is about the group founded by Sarah Milks. In my opinion, the commentary about both Reader's Circle and Sarah Milk's group is of insufficient depth to establish notability for either of the topics.4. Carter, Chelsea J. """"Book clubs evolve as page-turners,"""" ''Los Angeles Times'', Jan. 6, 2007. – The source states: Norman Hicks founded Reader's Circle, a website aimed at promoting an alternative to the traditional book club, as a way to meet people after graduating college. Rather than have a group read one book and follow a structured format, Reader's Circle promotes bringing people together in public settings, such as coffeehouses, to discuss a variety of books at once.""""I think a lot of people were drawn to it because they could read what they want, talk about it and get suggestions for other books,"""" said Hicks, 29. The coverage here, as {{user|Cindamuse}} notes above, is trivial. Reader's Circle is mentioned as an example to the proposition by the article's author that book clubs are evolving as page-turners. The paragraph after the trivial discussion about Reader's Circle is: It's that same idea behind PaperBackSwap.com, an online book club that allows members to trade their books with others. The site also makes a book-of-the-month selection and offers live online chats for its members to discuss books, said founder Richard Pickering of Atlanta. Because Book's Circle is only mentioned in two sentences (excluding the founder's quote), along with similar website PaperBackSwap.com which is mentioned in a few more, there is not enough here to pass the bar of Wikipedia:Notability#General notability guideline, which requires ''significant'' coverage.5. http://www.cityofrc.us/cityhall/lib/adults/circle.asp Archibald Library, Rancho Cucamonga, CA – this is a link to a library that hosts Reader's Circle. It contains no coverage about Reader's Circle the website and would be discounted as a source even if it did because only secondary sources, not primary ones, count toward establishing notability.6. http://plinkit-michigan.hosting.enfoldsystems.com/MichiganLibraries/niles/news-events/lib-cal/adult-services-department-events/reader.ics Niles District Library, Niles, MI – this is also a library source; see #5.7. http://stanlycountypubliclibrary.blogspot.com/2009/12/readers-circle-book-club-2010.html Stanly County Public Library, Albemarle, NC – this is also a library source; see #5.8. http://www.americantowns.com/nj/rahway/events/reader-s-circle-book-club-2011-06-15 Rahway Public Library, Rahway, NJ – this is also a library source; see #5.9. http://www.clarington-library.on.ca/node/577 Clarington Public Library, Bomanville, Ontario, Canada – this is also a library source; see #5.10. http://virl.bibliocommons.com/list/show/71807141_bplpicks/71875512_st_paul_readers_circle_20092010 Brantford Public Library, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada – this is also a library source; see #5.11. http://www.northyorks.gov.uk/index.aspx?articleid=5624 Richmond Library, North Yorkshire County, United Kingdom – this is also a library source; see #5.12. http://www.eagleharborbooks.com/event/eagle-harbor-readers-circle-newcomers-drop-ins-welcome-14 Eagle Harbor Book Co. Reader's Circle, Bainbridge Island, WA – this is a source from an independent bookstore; see #5.13. http://www.gcnews.com/news/2008-04-04/Community/071.html Socially Speaking, Garden City News April 4, 2008 – The source states: Joan Kuster and Edith Trestik will be hostesses for the Tuesday, April 8 th Reader's Circle at the Garden City Community Church. The book will be """"Broken"""" by William Coper Moyers , a former resident of this Village. They will meet at 12 noon and it sounds very interesting. Tangential coverage in the """"Notices"""" section of a community newspaper is not enough to pass the notability guidelines. Second, it is |original research to use this source and the next two to verify that """"The term has passed into common usage, appearing in press announcements as a taken-for-granted expression.""""14. http://www.salisburypost.com/Entertainment/041110-book-lib-week-RCCC Literary Week, Salisbury Post, April 11, 2010 – The source states: Book Club discussion of """"Twilight."""" Tuesday, 12:15 p.m., Room 2234, RCCC South Campus. The Reader's Circle Book Club will read """"Twilight,"""" by Stephenie Meyer. This book was selected with RCCC students in mind, but everyone's invited. Discussion will emphasize characterization, heroism and the contrast of the film version. Contact Amelia Likin at likina@rowancabarrus.edu.- """"Faculty Writes"""" panel discussion. Wednesday at 3 p.m., Room 106, South Campus. This is a community listing like the previous source.15. http://thebokenonline.com/books/the-readers-circle-2011-in-hoboken-james-joyce-march-17-at-7pm/ TheBokenOnline.com, March 16, 2011 – The source states: The Reader’s Circle, a Hoboken book club has their next event for this Thursday March 17th at 7PM to discuss the book A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man by James Joyce.The Reader’s Circle book group meets at 7:00PM in All Saints Church at 701 Washington Street in Hoboken, NJ. The Reader’s Circle is a community event. All book lovers are welcome. Free coffee and cake is offered at each monthly event. For more information email: readerscircle123@aol.com. This source is also a community listing like the previous two sources.The references are either primary sources or passing mentions, neither of which enable Reader's Circle to pass Wikipedia:Notability. A http://news.google.com/archivesearch?&as_src=-newswire+-wire+-presswire+-PR+-release+-wikipedia&q=%22Reader%27s+Circle%22 Google News Archive search returns mostly directory-type mentions or unrelated results. Likewise, a http://www.google.com/search?tbs=bks:1&q=%22readerscircle.org%22 Google Books search also returns trivial mentions.I appreciate the work {{user|Normanrobert}} has spent crafting this article and responding to the arguments for deletion here. However, because the sources lack the depth and reliability mandated by Wikipedia:Notability, this article must be deleted. Should Normanrobert find secondary reliable sources that provide ''significant'' coverage about Reader's Circle, the article may be recreated""" Deletion of Reader's Circle WP:RS||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19911 5781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles R. Borchers User:Bellhalla 23:44, 6 February 2008 (UTC) comment """Members of state legislature are considered notable as are holders of ''statewide'' offices. Mr. Borchers would be considered a local political figure under , and the threshold for inclusion in WP for local political figures is """"significant press coverage"""", which is not apparent from this article""" Deletion of Charles R. Borchers WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19912 94 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ulusalcılık """Kullanıcı:dsmurat'''ds''''''murat'''""" 16:34, 21 Eylül 2008 (UTC) comment """Eskiden Mantık konusunda yapılan bir espri vardı: ''""""Gerçekler acıdır. Baklava tatlıdır. O hâlde baklava gerçek değildir.""""'' Bu SAM'ın gerekçesi de bana bunu hatırlattı {{*:D}}.Ulusçuluk, Ulusalcılık, Milliyetçilik vb. hakkında bir tartışma yürütmüştük pek çok farklı yerde. Bunlardan bazılarını """"Tartışma:Milliyetçilik#Milliyetçilik ve Ulusçuluk|Milliyetçilik ve Ulusçuluk"""" ve """"Tartışma:Ulusalcılık#Kavram kargaşası|Kavram kargaşası"""" başlıklarında görebilirsiniz.Yalnız bir noktaya da değinmeden geçemeyeceğim: Partilerin ideolojik sınıflandırmasının kişisel kriterleri olamaz. Vikipedi için birincil olan; partilerin tüzük, program gibi resmî belgelerinde yer alan ibareler ve parti siyasetine yön verenlerin açıklamalarıdır. Yani ''""""Bu parti X'tir, şu parti Y'dir, o parti Z'dir""""'' dememiz Vikipedi için geçerli değildir. Ayrıca konuya ilişkin bazı ayrıntılar için bkz. .Uzun lafın kısası, ilkin, kavram karmaşasına son vererek, olayı netliğe kavuşturmamız gerekir. Saygılarımla""" Ulusalcılığın silinmesi Vikipedi:ÖAYV Wikipedia:No original research 65
19913 10331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yu-Gi-Oh! GX minor characters User:TheFarix 14:22, 17 July 2006 (UTC) keep """list passes requirements on the listing of minor characters. This article also does not meet any of the 11 classifications for """"indiscriminate information"""" listed in and there is also no redundancy with :Category:Yu-Gi-Oh! GX characters as none of these characters have, and probably should not have, standalone articles. The only thing that is significant problem with this article is that it needs better sourcing""" Deletion of Yu-Gi-Oh! GX minor characters WP:FICT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
19914 1372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fygnificm User:RC 15:32, 15 April 2008 (UTC) delete per |G1 and possibly G3 Deletion of Fygnificm WP:SPEEDY Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
19915 6385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/High Treason Pictures [[User talk:Lourdes|Lourdes]]''' 10:14, 10 December 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and . Couldn't find any reliable source that covers the subject Deletion of High Treason Pictures WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19916 1690 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oobi at Work User:Bearian 18:30, 26 February 2011 (UTC) delete per - no regular editor has read this article and could state that it |meets the notability guidelines Deletion of Oobi at Work WP:SNOW||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
19917 61 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of highest-grossing Indian films worldwide User:Hometech 13:48, 22 December 2012 (UTC) keep Waste of time. there are other cleanup tags in case u have douts on what is an Indian film exactly. All sources available otherwise. The lister mostly thought its but its not Deletion of List of highest-grossing Indian films worldwide WP:SYNTHESIS Wikipedia:No original research 65
19918 6562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mercury Award User:Realkyhick 17:55, 24 July 2007 (UTC) keep Passes , barely Deletion of The Mercury Award WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19919 338 [[Hermann Bartels]] (erledigt, LA zurueckgezogen) Benutzer:Docmo NONE keep Was soll das denn jetzt wieder ? Trollantrag ? Begründung ?; selbstverständlich , siehe Löschung von Hermann Bartels Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
19920 3834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Needar the Fearless User:Priyanjali 10:23, 10 September 2020 (UTC) delete lack of reliable resources. Fails Deletion of Needar the Fearless WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19921 17343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amirite User:FreeRangeFrog 01:08, 3 January 2013 (UTC) delete Another attempt at desperately trying to manufacture notability for an unknown company, and the socks are not helping. In fact, the coverage that's there at the moment is, at best, |routine for the tech rags that cover startups. Fails and Deletion of Amirite WP:ROUTINE||WP:GNG||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
19922 10746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Priyanka Arul Mohan User:onel5969 13:50, 6 April 2021 (UTC) keep I think there was an issue with notability in the past, but with the recently released ''Sreekaram'', it does appear that they now pass Deletion of Priyanka Arul Mohan WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19923 5867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesus Christ as myth NONE NONE keep """Jesus-myth hypothesis is largely the original Jesus as Myth article, and deals with a fringe hypothesis. Jesus Christ as Myth deals - quite badly at present - with a much broader question of how far ancient mythology correlates to Christianity, in a much more mainstream way. Most scholars would hold that Christian traditions about Jesus were influenced to some extent by mythology - e.g. in terms of language like """"Son of God"""", etc - but wouldn't see it as undermining the knowability of history so much as the mythicists. There's also the """"Jesus as true myth"""" types . If the article were to try to deal with all these kinds of people, the Jesus-myth theory would (or, at least, should) be barely mentioned, per our #Undue Weight|Undue Weight policies. An article devoted to those kind of ideas can enable people to find this material much more easily""" Deletion of Jesus Christ as myth WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
19924 15626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Bridegroom User:Whpq 18:26, 15 May 2012 (UTC) delete I see no coverage in independent reliable sources about the subject that establishes |notability Deletion of Thomas Bridegroom WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19925 175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dipankar Home User:Qwfp 16:19, 1 June 2010 (UTC) keep """Meets criterion 3: he has """"created, or played a major role in co-creating, a significant or well-known work, or collective body of work, that has been the subject of … multiple independent periodical articles or reviews"""" as evidenced by http://www.dipankarhome.com/About%20me%20Details.html the press cuttings on his website that include full-length, positive reviews of his books in ''The Times Higher Education Supplement'', ''Physics Today'' and ''Foundations of Physics''. In addition, http://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?hl=en&client=firefox-a&hs=Bf9&rls=org.mozilla:en-GB:official&q=%22dipankar%20home%22%20%22riddles%20in%20your%20teacup%22%20review&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=ws Google finds reviews of both the hardback and paperback editions of his book ''Riddles in your Teacup - Fun with Everyday Scientific Puzzles'' in ''New Scientist'', although these aren't mentioned on his webpage (possibly they weren't so positive, but that's not relevant to the criterion). The fact that Forewards to his books have been written by Anthony Leggett, Roger Penrose and Paul Davies should surely count for something too. I did also check citations counts for his journal articles in Web of Science: it reckons his h-index is 13, with top 5 articles cited 95, 50, 43, 38, 33 times, which doesn't seem all that impressive in absolute terms, but I'm not sure how that compares to others working on theoretical foundations of physics. Should take into account that his papers only have two or three authors, fewer than typical in many areas of science and medicine""" Deletion of Dipankar Home WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19926 2257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Collins User:Angelatc 17:24, 10 June 2012 (UTC) delete """definitely non-notable per . This is a vanity entry. Note that the page was created by """"Intact Molls"""" which is an anagram of Matt Collins. He's trolling ya'll""" Deletion of Matt Collins WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19927 4816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Memory Alpha (4th nomination) User:Skomorokh 16:01, 5 December 2008 (UTC) keep http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Memory_Alpha&diff=255814227&oldid=255787640 This was not at all difficult, nor comprehensive. Wikipedia would without question be a poorer encyclopaedia with the removal of this article. This discussion shows a typical failure to consider an article's |potential, rather than current state Deletion of Memory Alpha (4th nomination) WP:POTENTIAL Wikipedia:Potential, not just current state 11
19928 7688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Category 4 Atlantic hurricanes (2nd nomination) User:Eluchil404 23:17, 12 November 2011 (UTC) keep I prefer to delete lists that are truly redundant to categories, despite the wording of , but in this case the list provides information and formatting that no category could. In such cases lists are in fact complementary not redundant and should not be deleted Deletion of List of Category 4 Atlantic hurricanes (2nd nomination) WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
19929 15027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Midsummer Night's Dream (Seiji Ozawa recording) User:Coolabahapple 03:01, 22 September 2019 (UTC) keep meets with 3 reviews, 2 listed in the article, and 1 from the ''NYT'' listed above (thanks to {{u|4meter4}}:)).ps. material that has caused copyvio concerns has been removed from the article Deletion of A Midsummer Night's Dream (Seiji Ozawa recording) WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
19930 9948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Hayden User:Cabrils 23:18, 24 February 2021 (UTC) keep Clearly meets . Have also added https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adam_Hayden#cite_ref-5| another IRS Deletion of Adam Hayden WP:RLN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19931 8010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brainbrench (3rd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 08:39, 30 July 2016 (UTC) keep Meets per a review of |available sources. See source examples listed below Deletion of Brainbrench (3rd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
19932 6351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arick Wierson User:Pontificalibus 06:42, 9 May 2009 (UTC) keep clearly meets Deletion of Arick Wierson WP:PEOPLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
19933 13937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William S. Gannaway User:Dhartung 05:55, 17 March 2007 (UTC) delete per nomination; fails . Billy Hathorn, it's unfortunate that you seem to have the chops to create well-formatted biographical articles, but you use this skill on articles that are bound to eventually be deleted. Please, please, please familiarize yourself with and before creating any new articles. Your local perception of notability is really not valid Deletion of William S. Gannaway WP:BIO||WP:ATT||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19934 6699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yakub Abahanov User:Stifle 18:25, 4 April 2008 (UTC) delete does not meet . Articles on arbitrary Gitmo detainees don't belong. Sorry Deletion of Yakub Abahanov WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19935 16015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Firoz Kunnamparambil User:Bearian 01:39, 19 April 2021 (UTC) delete per . He's gone through bad times and succeeded in spite of it all. That sounds like |a million other people Deletion of Firoz Kunnamparambil WP:SIGCOV||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19936 19934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Healthcare Leadership Academy User:Rogermx 01:37, 18 January 2017 (UTC) delete cannot find any proof online that this group actually exists. Article is written like a screed and is blatantly biased. Delete based on and Deletion of The Healthcare Leadership Academy WP:GNG||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19937 2108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antonio Núñez López User:onel5969 12:00, 3 August 2018 (UTC) delete As nom pointed out, searching is difficult due to the prominence of the notable Marco Antonio Núñez López, who interestingly doesn't have an article. He doesn't quite pass the threshold of notability. His one book, ''Storytelling in a Week'' might be notable, but I don't think any of his other works are. Fails and Deletion of Antonio Núñez López WP:GNG||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
19938 15457 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Azad Ali User:E 14:45, 2 March 2018 (UTC) keep Nom's assertion that Azad Ali is NOTPUBLICFIGURE is frankly surreal in light of the fact that Ali has been a well-known and very public advocate for various causes in Britain for many years; he has even been Chair of the quasi-official Muslim Safety Forum. This is what a PUBLICFIGURE looks like. Article could use improvement (what else is new), and contains a number of unreliable and primary sources, but it also has many , and many more are available in searches. Keep as per Deletion of Azad Ali WP:RS||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19939 10794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Master Colony User:OlYeller21 21:11, 9 August 2011 (UTC) keep Fulfills with http://www.gazettelive.co.uk/entertainment-leisure/music-gigs/2010/08/20/preview-the-master-colony-84229-27097624/ this, http://www.gazettelive.co.uk/news/teesside-news/2010/07/13/the-master-colony-celebrate-new-record-deal-84229-26837804/ this and http://www.whitbygazette.co.uk/news/local/record_label_signs_up_whitby_man_s_band_1_1888697 this (significant coverage from reliable sources). Even though they have bad haircuts, they seem to be notable Deletion of The Master Colony WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19940 16708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Cantor Wultz User:Crusio 22:12, 7 September 2008 (UTC) delete As the original prodder, I obviously feel that this should be deleted. Wikipedia cannot make an article for every victim of every crime. This is very much a case of and therefore does not meet the requirements of Deletion of Daniel Cantor Wultz WP:ONEEVENT||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19941 10817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Involuntary celibacy (4th nomination) User:Flyer22 20:48, 29 December 2015 (UTC) comment How many times must we discuss this topic? Should I copy and paste my previous reply (or replies) each time? I mean, most of our feelings have not changed on this topic. This constant debate is doing nothing but draining the community, and is a clear ''' violation.''' Consensus is usually to '''merge this article to the Celibacy article, to the Sexual abstinence article, which already addresses involuntarily sexual abstinence in the lead, to the Sexual frustration article, or to delete.''' Given how small the Sexual frustration article currently is, and that there is enough to state about involuntary celibacy, I disagree that this should be merged to the Sexual frustration article or otherwise significantly covered there. Cover it in the Sexual abstinence article and call it a day. I wouldn't even mind if it was covered in the Celibacy article, or if it exists as its own article; '''I don't see a huge problem with this article existing as its own article.''' And again, this topic is not a medical topic. Just stop all this repeat debating. Sighs Deletion of Involuntary celibacy (4th nomination) WP:FORUMSHOP Wikipedia:Consensus 78
19942 4214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007/08 Premier League Results User:Rackabello 17:49, 21 July 2007 (UTC) delete Very |crufty and |Wikipedia is not a sports almanac Deletion of 2007/08 Premier League Results WP:LISTCRUFT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
19943 15390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dmitry Green User:K 00:48, 20 March 2019 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Dmitry Green WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
19944 10058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jelen pivo [[User talk:Melmann|Melmann]] 11:25, 10 April 2021 (UTC) delete as it appears to fail . All the sources I was able to identify are likely to be promotional in nature Deletion of Jelen pivo WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19945 7082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of guidebooks about the Sierra Nevada User:Delicious 18:29, 3 June 2008 (UTC) delete Nice list, but not encyclopaedic. Fails Deletion of List of guidebooks about the Sierra Nevada WP:NOTCATALOG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19946 6713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kathy Evers User:Bearcat 15:54, 18 December 2019 (UTC) delete """without prejudice against recreation of a redirect to Tony. """"First lady"""" at the state level is not an inherently notable role that guarantees an article to every spouse of a state governor — the ''national'' first lady gets that, but state first ladies are only notable if they get over a regular notability criterion on their own activities independently of who they happen to be married to. But this features entirely too much |primary and unreliable sourcing (Twitter tweets are a no-no), and not nearly enough of the |reliable kind: even the real media sources mostly aren't ''about her'', but merely mention her name in the process of being about Tony. Accordingly, a bit of content about her in Tony's article would be perfectly appropriate, but the substance and sourcing here don't rise to the level of earning her a standalone BLP separately from him""" Deletion of Kathy Evers WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
19947 21615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ProjectSim User:Empty 12:58, 9 June 2010 (UTC) delete zero coverage online (not even a project website), article doesn't assert notability, editor's username indicates . Possible Deletion of ProjectSim WP:COI||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
19948 16616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Not Profane [[User talk:Dcshank| :- ) Don]] 19:40, 5 August 2012 (UTC) keep """per cite 1 & 2 put together, as a song writer per : """"Has credit for writing or co-writing either lyrics or music for a notable composition."""" Notable composition according to : """"Songs that have been ranked on national or significant music charts, or ...."""" The song written made the German charts, so I believe he meets the notability requirement as a composer. I don't see any thing else significant. As of this time, I do not believe notability for YouTube work has ben established. Take your trout home and fry him up for dinner, Ritchie333""" Deletion of Not Profane WP:COMPOSER||WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19949 20911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional brands User:Otto4711 06:40, 13 May 2007 (UTC) delete indiscriminate list and a directory of loosely-assoicated topics, in violation of . Tries to gather every reference to any fictional brand with no regard to whether there is any actual importance to its existence or not. See similar AFDs for Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional foods and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional beverages for two similar indiscriminate, unmaintainable lists that were deleted Deletion of List of fictional brands WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19950 4213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wired (Hugh Cornwell album) User:BlueThird 00:04, 1 June 2011 (UTC) comment It might not be strictly appropriate to |bundle this with other Cornwell albums that are being considered for deletion, but they should surely be considered together and within the wider context of Cornwell's notability. There's an earlier AfD for Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Beyond_Elysian_Fields_(2nd_nomination)|Beyond Elysian Fields Deletion of Wired (Hugh Cornwell album) WP:BUNDLE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19951 13495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/3:36 (Music to Sleep To) User:SBKSPP 02:12, 7 August 2021 (UTC) merge to Poppy discography. Fails per nom Deletion of 3:36 (Music to Sleep To) WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
19952 1502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Annie Morton User:Willthacheerleader18 20:30, 12 November 2018 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Annie Morton WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19953 6249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/At One with the Shadows User:Expertwikiguy 18:07, 15 May 2020 (UTC) delete Fails , Sources not that many or reliable. Album has no Top 100 ranking or awards Deletion of At One with the Shadows WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
19954 10885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Heliosynchronous orbit User:N2e 17:21, 3 November 2011 (UTC) delete """the main idea, to get rid of Heliosynchronous orbit. But would prefer a """"no-content"""" merge to Synchronous orbit (via a '''Redirect'''), which will effectively delete the article, but will retain the comment history on the redir page. Rationale: ''Heliosynchronous'' is a meaningless term, and no sources are provided for any of the existing claims. Since all claims appear to be unsourced |orginal research, I don't believe any of the content ought to be moved to ''Synchronous orbit""" Deletion of Heliosynchronous orbit WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19955 18031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Bowie User:Epinoia 03:21, 9 May 2019 (UTC) delete does not meet - no significant achievements to establish notability - essentially the article just says the guy has a job Deletion of George Bowie WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19956 8378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1300 René-Lévesque Ouest User:Dhartung 01:35, 5 February 2007 (UTC) delete per . Once construction has started it's a different storey Deletion of 1300 René-Lévesque Ouest WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19957 5912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avi Tuschman User:Joseph2302 11:26, 30 May 2015 (UTC) keep as Our Political Nature- the book seems to pass , although I believe that the person themself isn't notable enough Deletion of Avi Tuschman WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
19958 9101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Content Partners User:onel5969 02:42, 20 December 2020 (UTC) delete not enough sourcing to satisfy or Deletion of Content Partners WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
19959 371 [[Kometa (Kamera)]] (LAZ) Benutzerin Diskussion:Weissbier|WB! 06:40, 13. Nov. 2015 (CET NONE delete Vor allem ist das völlig belegfrei und warum dieses Konsumgut nun relevant sei ist auch nicht ersichtlich. , da . Je suis Tiger! Löschung von Kometa (Kamera) Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
19960 21090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omniarchy [[User talk:Skomorokh|the skomorokh]] 16:31, 12 October 2008 (UTC) delete for my part, as I cannot find enough significant coverage of the topic in reliable sources to |verify a basic introduction to the topic. I am happy to retract this !vote if acceptable sources are forthcoming Deletion of Omniarchy WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19961 21081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Croatia national American football team User:Dirtlawyer1 07:51, 27 September 2014 (UTC) delete """Non-notable """"American football"""" national team of Croatia, which has never played a game, and it's unclear whether it will ever play a game. Putting aside issues of notability per , this is a clear case of : Wikipedia does not speculate about things which have not yet come to pass""" Deletion of Croatia national American football team WP:ORG||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
19962 2273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sightread User:Red 13:17, 28 September 2008 (UTC) delete Already on Wiktionary, not for Wikipedia (). Also some oririgal research mentioned in the nom Deletion of Sightread WP:DICT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
19963 12202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergey Dmitriev (born 1966) User:Cabayi 17:36, 16 December 2016 (UTC) delete Previously speedied at President of JetBrains, fails to show any |notability Deletion of Sergey Dmitriev (born 1966) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19964 205 [[Wikipedia:Artikel über Schulen]] (erl., LAE) Benutzer:Suricata 20:33, 20. Okt. 2010 (CEST) keep beispielsweise wegen des Absatzes #Begriffsklärungen bei gleichnamigen Schulen auf den ich mich berufen muss, um Schul-BKLs aufzuräumen Löschung von Wikipedia:Artikel über Schulen Wikipedia:Artikel über Schulen Wikipedia:Artikel über Schulen 4
19965 11747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elevations Residential Treatment Center User:The 08:45, 20 June 2018 (UTC) keep with Island View Residential Treatment Center. This article is a of the latter, created in apparent good faith in 2015: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Elevations_Residential_Treatment_Center&oldid=683916470. Both articles have contentious edit histories, but that's not a reason for deletion. Article creator has been removing material about the centre under its former ownership and name, e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Elevations_Residential_Treatment_Center&type=revision&diff=684873407&oldid=684872780,https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Elevations_Residential_Treatment_Center&type=revision&diff=685020474&oldid=685010495, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Elevations_Residential_Treatment_Center&type=revision&diff=684873407&oldid=684872780, when in fact there should be a single article about the centre. Definitely notable per and , with significant coverage online in Deletion of Elevations Residential Treatment Center WP:CFORK||WP:GNG||WP:CORP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Content forking 33
19966 5277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jessica Falkholt User:TheGracefulSlick 14:45, 17 January 2018 (UTC) comment """Really goes to show where the """"notability"""" lies when almost half of the entire article is devoted to a |few moments in the final three weeks of her life: car crash, surgery and death. But, then again, these are |the subjects enough editors feel are important in the moment. A few people here believe it was """"disrespectful"""" to nominate this for deletion but do you really believe Jessica (or anyone) would want a piece primarily devoted to the pitiful state she was left in as a result of the crash to remember her by? Sometimes, if you want to build an ''encyclopedia'', you can't let stories that pull at your heartstrings influence you""" Deletion of Jessica Falkholt WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19967 20942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Low Priced Asian Edition User:Obina 16:57, 18 November 2007 (UTC) delete Low priced editions exist. But is the topic notable? We need non trivial reliable sources. Trivial in this case means someone mentioning that a book is less expensive in Asia. Non trivial is an article about the topic. Without other articles, this is almost . Could be merged into a general article about cheaper goods in Asia Deletion of Low Priced Asian Edition WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
19968 4929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Association for Research on Ethnicity and Nationalism in the Americas User:RayAYang 19:48, 3 August 2008 (UTC) delete None of the preceding discussion helps to meet the primary criterion for , which is significant coverage by secondary sources. I do not feel that an academic association for a small subfield is of such earth-shaking importance that we can justify breaching Wikipedia's customary guidelines Deletion of Association for Research on Ethnicity and Nationalism in the Americas WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19969 4590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Lord (One Life to Live) User:Shooterwalker 21:37, 28 January 2012 (UTC) delete no significant information from third-party sources can be found to . Listing the actors portraying the character is not enough to explain this character's reception or significance Deletion of Tony Lord (One Life to Live) WP:verify notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
19970 16887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter Mosley (US lawyer) [[User: Northern Escapee|Northern Escapee]] ([[user talk: Northern Escapee|talk]]) 12:46, 28 September 2020 (UTC) keep Found a source that gives to the subject and I think that if a more advanced search was conducted more sources may be found Deletion of Walter Mosley (US lawyer) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
19971 17485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clogher Cricket Club User:Ravenswing 17:17, 17 June 2011 (UTC) delete """I'm concerned in seeing some of the same discredited arguments to Keep as in the recent Cork County Cricket Club AfD, with people stoutly arguing that a FOURTH tier club is really a """"top-level"""" club, that there is some bias against Irish cricket or nonsense. The bottom line is that this team doesn't pass the GNG, and the only explanation for the Keep proponents failing to come up with the |reliable, third-party sources that would save these articles is that they know there aren't any""" Deletion of Clogher Cricket Club WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS||WP:IRS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
19972 656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick M. Novack User:Dawn 19:39, 25 May 2009 (UTC) delete """I don't see how the the burden of """"significant coverage in reliable secondary sources that are independent of the subject"""" has been met here. Reference 2 http://www.ichiban1.org/html/history_E.htm doesn't mention Novack, and the melissadata.com and gravelocator.com refences http://www.melissadata.com/lookups/np.asp?ein=410956667http://www.melissadata.com/lookups/np.asp?ein=203761716 http://gravelocator.cem.va.gov/j2ee/servlet/NGL_v1 are just directory listings which do nothing to establish notability (the first of these doesn't mention Novack's name, either). The zoominfo reference confirms that he ran in a local election, but that doesn't meet criteria for inclusion. I agree with '''DGG''' that the we don't normally accept 3rd level military awards as establishing notability. Novack sounds like a genuinely good and honourable person who died way too soon, but that doesn't make him notable enough to meet Wikipedia's criteria""" Deletion of Patrick M. Novack WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
19973 10643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cara Saunders User:Mr 14:20, 4 July 2012 (UTC) delete I agree with Colapeninsula that the mismatches in the article are deeply worrying; in addition to this, I can't find any coverage about her online, so it looks like she doesn't pass . I'm not too convinced about the sources in the article either: I couldn't find any mention of the Nassau Guardian piece online, a search of Craton & Saunders (2007) turned up no results, and I could not find any mentions of the Freeport News piece other than on Wikipedia and its mirrors. And finally, even if we were able to verify the sporting achievements in the article, they wouldn't satisfy , as they were junior events Deletion of Cara Saunders WP:BIO||WP:NTRACK Wikipedia:Notability 77
19974 13893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Louis Joseph Posner User:JohnInDC 17:58, 27 December 2013 (UTC) comment CRIME and are red herrings. Posner’s arrest, plea, conviction and disbarment were not only covered by the NY tabloid media (NY Post, Daily News) but by more sedate outlets such as the New York Times and the ABA Journal. Posner pleaded guilty and is a convicted felon. The events are well-sourced, and the article here does not sensationalize them. It should also be noted that What88, who now argues so strenuously for the deletion, had previously contended that this subject was in fact notable, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Louis_Joseph_Posner&diff=587414488&oldid=587413328 here Deletion of Louis Joseph Posner WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19975 15205 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethical living User:Stifle 16:45, 14 July 2006 (UTC) delete or redirect, unless |reliable sources |cited Deletion of Ethical living WP:RS||WP:CITE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19976 2905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spanish profanity (3rd nomination) User:Mike 01:39, 13 November 2011 (UTC) comment Nom provides no valid el#Reason|rationale for deletion. Why should this article be deleted Deletion of Spanish profanity (3rd nomination) WP:D Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
19977 3987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fiona Stewart (event director) User:EmyRussell 13:18, 26 February 2018 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Fiona Stewart (event director) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19978 12317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Couzens (2nd nomination) User:Edwardx 11:10, 31 August 2017 (UTC) delete Insufficient independent in-depth coverage in reliable sources, lack of . Fails Deletion of Bill Couzens (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
19979 660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Costello (actor) User:Kinu 02:40, 7 April 2020 (UTC) delete Many bit parts, but no substantive coverage to support a Deletion of Michael Costello (actor) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
19980 6741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Fredinburg User:Karthikndr 05:49, 3 May 2015 (UTC) delete Agree with most of proposing for Delete as per (E). Notability caused by single event, previously, I couldn't sense any notability. Also, if death is the notable concept, I'm afraid things will look more memorial. '''Comment:''' If notability could be established, then we can keep this article. But for now, Delete Deletion of Dan Fredinburg WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
19981 2337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seydibesir POW Camp User:Ddcm8991 17:40, 21 September 2015 (UTC) delete Fails , and Deletion of Seydibesir POW Camp WP:V||WP:EVENT||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
19982 9566 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 North American heat wave User:ConCompS 19:31, 10 July 2018 (UTC) merge into two articles, leave the continental US wave in this article (and rename it accordingly), and merge the Quebec wave into 2018 Eastern Canada heat wave. If no fatalities occur with the continental US wave, re-try a deletion discussion on this article at a later time. There's not much reason that separate heat waves in separate areas should be in one article unless phrased as such. There are numerous articles in Canadian press reporting on the Quebec deaths, so there should be no question that it passes Deletion of 2018 North American heat wave WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
19983 3482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Buckley (artist) User:BuickCenturyDriver 03:12, 11 February 2007 (UTC) keep He wrote a couple of legitamate books. Perhaps you nominated per Deletion of Tim Buckley (artist) WP:HOLE Wikipedia:I wouldn't know him from a hole in the ground 12
19984 21802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Angry Alien User:Monkeyman 23:24, 21 February 2006 (UTC) delete as nn . Image:Monkeyman.png Deletion of Angry Alien WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
19985 6299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Attack! Attack! User:Esradekan NONE keep """and here's some more, http://www.thrashhits.com/2009/02/future-hits-013-attack-attack/, http://www2.kerrang.com/2009/03/attack_attack_tour_and_news.html. To the Nom, """"may be regionally famous only"""", did you actually do a search for any sources at all |before you nominated the article""" Deletion of Attack! Attack! WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19986 4768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Probit model for panel data with heterogeneity and endogenous explanatory variables (2nd nomination) User:Nsk92 21:43, 17 October 2019 (UTC) delete """Written so increadibly badly that the article is incomprehensible even to the experts, so much so that the page is a borderline case. I am a professional mathematician myself and I have no idea what the page is talking about. There are no definitions of any kind, the topic of the article is not coherently described, the various quantities/notations/variables used are not defined or explained, and there are no clearly idetifiable and properly formulated mathematical statements. Basically just a bunch of incoherent semi-mathematical verbiage. In mathematics we refer to this kind of text as """"not even wrong""" Deletion of Probit model for panel data with heterogeneity and endogenous explanatory variables (2nd nomination) WP:A1 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
19987 7953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarthak Sinha (2nd nomination) User:Vanamonde93 04:28, 21 January 2016 (UTC) delete essentially per Opabinia Regalis; this is most likely a case of , although it might never end up being notable Deletion of Sarthak Sinha (2nd nomination) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
19988 14385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rolo Tomassi (2nd nomination) User:Koavf 20:32, 23 June 2009 (UTC) delete Several of the sources provided do not establish notability (e.g. http://www.sheffieldtelegraph.co.uk/music/Rolo-Tomassi-Corporation.3782990.jp a performance review from a local paper) and the ones that do are pretty sparse (http://www.nme.com/reviews/rolotomassi/9979 this is a start, but it's not possible to create an article based on this write-up in NME.) Without better documentation of their notability (not just their existence), there is not justification for keeping these articles. As pointed out above, there definitely are sources to prove that they exist, but interviews and podcasts exist for all kinds of musical acts that fail Deletion of Rolo Tomassi (2nd nomination) WP:NM Wikipedia:Notability 77
19989 11714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Place names considered unusual (2nd nomination) User:Themfromspace 09:52, 8 November 2008 (UTC) delete per above, plus a clear violation of . Any place name can be considered unusual by some person or another, and just because an article is written on it in a newspaper doesn't mean a compilation of all these NPOV assertations merits an article Deletion of Place names considered unusual (2nd nomination) WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
19990 5972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Socialism in One Country User:AllyD 22:06, 12 November 2011 (UTC) keep A one-word nomination that really needs a prior application of . Try Google Books for a start. Articles in need of improved referencing but on subjects of clear notability do not belong at AfD Deletion of Socialism in One Country :WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19991 9482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bishop Challoner Catholic Secondary School User:Bearian 21:22, 11 July 2013 (UTC) keep AfD is not for cleanup; please read Deletion of Bishop Challoner Catholic Secondary School WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
19992 5833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theodis Bowe User:Thomas 17:47, 21 September 2009 (UTC) keep """per |Wikipedia's notability guidelines, which state that anyone who has """"competed at the fully professional level of a sport"""" is notable. Since he has played professional minor league baseball, he meets this guideline""" Deletion of Theodis Bowe WP:ATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
19993 21641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judy Fentress-Williams User:Crunch 13:06, 11 February 2009 (UTC) delete Fails otability_(academics) and other criteria of Deletion of Judy Fentress-Williams WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
19994 12168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Repent Sinner [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 02:55, 26 November 2012 (UTC) delete """suffers from many of the same problems as other street art articles. Often they are fads or short-term campaigns by particular groups or a particular """"style"""" adopted by several artists. There are plenty of blog posts and social media references to """"Repent Sinner"""" graffiti but they certainly wouldn't be considered |reliable sources here. Interestingly, some of the social media commentary refers to its importance because it has a WP article. In reality, it must be important (|notable) before it gets a WP article""" Deletion of Repent Sinner WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
19995 12321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maulik baxi User:Coredesat 10:22, 13 June 2006 (UTC) delete per |Wikipedia is not a free webhost. Also NN vanity Deletion of Maulik baxi WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
19996 7640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictitious Academy Award winners and nominees User:LaundryPizza03 16:14, 22 May 2018 (UTC) delete It looks like the arguments of notability in the prior AfD ran afoul of and asserted the existence of sources without proof. Almost all ghits under this title appear to be |mirrors and forks of this article, with no reliable sources in existence Deletion of List of fictitious Academy Award winners and nominees WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:MIRROR Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
19997 1434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terrian (singer) User:Versace1608 14:05, 26 April 2020 (UTC) delete Apart from her low charting singles, I was not able to find critical reviews of her music. I believe it is for her to have a separate article at this time. I'm confident she will become notable once she continues releasing quality music. I am going to give her music a listen; hopefully it is great Deletion of Terrian (singer) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
19998 19731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of For Better or For Worse User:Pixelface 01:17, 15 March 2008 (UTC) keep storylines are not unencyclopedic and this could actually be merged into the For Better or For Worse article per the |editing policy. I think this is a fine sub-article of For Better or For Worse Deletion of History of For Better or For Worse WP:EP Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
19999 20218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Illness among Jews User:Shuki 22:34, 15 November 2009 (UTC) delete per IZAK and I42 and violating Wikipedia:Scientific standards. While the Jewish Encyclopedia printed 100 years ago might be a good source for 'timeless' material about people or places, it is not an RS for this subject and it is utterly ridiculous to use superstitious and primitive medical information as a base for an article in WP. The information is utterly out of date and not relevant anymore. Giving a platform about studies on mental disease or anything else over a hundred years ago is very misleading and making a farce out of Wikipedia. This is and Deletion of Illness among Jews WP:COATRACK||WP:SYN Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
20000 159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miller v. Campbell User:Philosopher 16:21, 11 November 2010 (UTC) merge Wikipedia is not a |crystal ball. We don't know if the court will make a significant decision or simply find some existing law to apply here. We don't know if this will become a Supreme Court case. We don't even know if any truly novel arguments will be advanced in the argument. Until one of these things (or something akin to them) happens, this is a and should be merged into the article about the election Deletion of Miller v. Campbell WP:CRYSTAL||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20001 20598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lock On (street art) [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart111''']] [[User talk:Stalwart111|(talk)]] 02:56, 18 September 2012 (UTC) delete """agreed. There are """"sources"""" for the information like the http://www.brooklynstreetart.com/theblog/2012/03/24/copenhagen-street-art-on-lock-down/ brooklynstreetart blog and the http://classiccopenhagen.blogspot.com.au/2012/03/lock-on-tejn.html Classic Copenhagen blog and these are probably what inspired the article. But these are not |""""reliable sources"""" as per WP, so the subject fails as far as I am concerned""" Deletion of Lock On (street art) WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20002 9663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammad Hassan Khan User:Spicy 14:33, 4 October 2020 (UTC) delete and oppose draftification. The subject does not meet or , and there is no indication that giving the author more time to work on the article will fix the fundamental problem which is that he is not notable Deletion of Muhammad Hassan Khan WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20003 17438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billy Cote User:Beeblbrox 21:15, 11 August 2008 (UTC) comment If the nominator has no objections, we could just do the redirect and close the AfD, I think is pretty clear on this type of thing Deletion of Billy Cote WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20004 6456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Gaunt's Ghosts characters User:Devonian 22:33, 7 June 2020 (UTC) delete an impressive amount of fancruft for a series that is skirting on notability itself. This page fails , since the only reference is one of the books in the series itself, a primary source. It also fails , since it is written from an entirely in-universe perspective. Gaunt's Ghosts already has more than enough fancruft as it is, enough to create a sensible list of characters, there is no need to Merge more. This level of extreme fancruft should not exist anywhere on Wikipedia Deletion of List of Gaunt's Ghosts characters WP:LISTN||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20005 5642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Taylor (boxer) User:Papaursa 19:23, 8 November 2015 (UTC) delete I don't believe he's achieved notability as a boxer or has the significant coverage required to meet Deletion of Anthony Taylor (boxer) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20006 20173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vanguards Die-cast User:Expertwikiguy 01:13, 13 December 2020 (UTC) delete and redirect to Corgi Toys. Not enough sources and violation of lose_paraphrasing. Most content seems to be https://www.5wiki.club/wiki/Vanguards-0660060426 copied from here Deletion of Vanguards Die-cast WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
20007 4510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gabriela Hersham User:Truthsort 16:30, 25 December 2011 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Gabriela Hersham WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20008 17519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Historymon User:Danski14 17:34, 3 March 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Historymon WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
20009 914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Fetzer Bates User:Rollidan 05:03, 29 July 2019 (UTC) keep concur with above keep !votes. Sources added during the AfD carry this article past Deletion of Elizabeth Fetzer Bates WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20010 2222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taiga.io User:Rhododendrites 13:56, 28 December 2014 (UTC) delete The refs above appear decent, perhaps falling just short of in my view, though their use of the same images with much of the same information makes me suspicious that they may be working off PR materials. It may also be that it's just -- it's still in beta and some of the article's language is even in future tense. There's also the issue of the article containing information, some of it presented as though for an advertisement, company website, etc. --&mdash Deletion of Taiga.io WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:TOOSOON||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20011 13717 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Stevens (presenter) User:DanielZimmerman 23:30, 11 May 2006 (UTC) keep as per above, but cleanup. Another reason why | notability is subjective, POV, and should not be used as a criteria for inclusion in or deletion from Wikipedia Deletion of Craig Stevens (presenter) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20012 360 [[Ulrich Fricke]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers NONE delete Kasten|1= gemäß Andreas König. Die #Journalisten werden nicht erfüllt. Gruß Löschung von Ulrich Fricke Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
20013 8482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Damn Vulnerable Linux User:Stuartyeates 01:37, 27 October 2012 (UTC) delete """this is a teaching and research tool. That I can see it has one http://www.networkworld.com/community/node/66224 independent ref that doesn't cover it in all that much depth and in a niche outlet at that. This is not the """"significant coverage"""" which the requires""" Deletion of Damn Vulnerable Linux WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20014 7828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ps Samuel Khawas User:ConcernedVancouverite 16:21, 25 April 2011 (UTC) delete Unable to find any |reliable sources to establish notability Deletion of Ps Samuel Khawas WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20015 6399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Kelly (Scottish footballer) User:Mentoz86 19:29, 30 December 2011 (UTC) delete per nom. fails and Deletion of Sean Kelly (Scottish footballer) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20016 10240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Premiere Global Services User:Bad 05:49, 10 February 2006 (UTC) keep and cleanup, is listed on NYSE on does meet Deletion of Premiere Global Services WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20017 1023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Child Bite User:Doktorbuk 14:02, 30 June 2006 (UTC) delete if they can't make it in the real world, they can't make it here. Fails , and vanity policy Deletion of Child Bite WP:BAND||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20018 122 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Nevnihal Erdoğan Kullanıcı:ravagesravages 15.23, 6 Mart 2020 (UTC) delete """Kayda değer olduğunu gösterir tarafsız, bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynaklar bulunmuyor. Kişi sayfasında yer alan ölçütleri karşılıyor olsa bile bunu gösterebilecek kaynaklar maalesef yok. Bütün kaynaklar, içinde bulunduğu çeşitli etkinlikleri anlatırken ilgili kişiye de değinen alelâde haberler. Bununla birlikte, {{ping|Nedim Gayet Bir}}'in gösterdiği şartların da sağlandığı görüşünde değilim. http://mtf.kocaeli.edu.tr/mimarlik-akademik.php Burada da görülebileceği üzere, kendisi mimarlık bölümünün başkanlığını yapan bir profesör. """"Önemli bir yükseköğretim kurumunda özel unvanlı akademik rütbe ya da tanınmış profesör ve ya buna denk bir konum"""" kıstasının sağlandığını düşünmüyorum. Kocaeli Üniversitesinin (ya da bu bölümün) ülkedeki diğer üniversitelerle kıyaslandığında önemli sayılmasını gerektiren bir sebep var mı? Ya da ilgili kişinin profesörlük dışında (ki profesörlük de özel bir unvan değildir, şartları sağlandığı takdirde her akademisyen profesör olabilmektedir) kriterde vurgulanan nitelikte bir unvanı bulunuyor mu? Diğer kıstas olan """"önemli ve büyük bir akademik kurumun veya büyük bir akademik topluluğun en üst düzeydeki temsilcisi olarak seçilmiş ya da bu kurumlarda akademik görevler yürütmektedir"""" kıstasının da sağlandığını düşünmüyorum. Bunun sağlandığını kabul edebilmek için yine Kocaeli Üniversitesinin önemli ve büyük bir akademik kurum olması gerekiyor. Ayrıca şunu da belirtmek isterim ki ilgili kişi yalnızca üniversitede bir fakültenin bölümlerinden birinin başkanlığını yapıyor. Yani o kurumun en tepesindeki (rektör) değil. Bu nedenlerle, hem VP:AKADEMİSYEN hem de genel kayda değerlik şartları sağlanmadığı için silinmesi gerektiği düşünüyorum""" Nevnihal Erdoğan'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:AKADEMİSYEN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20019 16314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ty Simpkins User:MichaelQSchmidt 06:15, 20 April 2010 (UTC) keep Sourcing has begun. Allow continued |improvements through the course of regular editing. Actor meets both and Deletion of Ty Simpkins WP:ATD||WP:ENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20020 14329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ENZO (Singer) User:Skr15081997 13:24, 28 May 2017 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet the or standard. The only external links used presently in the article are his songs and related info coming from the producers Deletion of ENZO (Singer) WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20021 3244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Legion of Doom (Batman: The Brave and the Bold) User:AdamBMorgan 17:59, 26 January 2010 (UTC) delete as , even if there is a formal grouping (which I don't think has been established) they could easily use any number of original or established names (Injustice League, Crime Syndicate etc). It could serve as a list of villains on the show but that is already covered by List of characters in Batman: The Brave and the Bold#Villains Deletion of Legion of Doom (Batman: The Brave and the Bold) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
20022 15715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hell'z Movie User:Theleekycauldron 20:19, 27 January 2021 (UTC) delete no sources, couldn't find any. Never released, fails worse than I do. I don't matter but at least I exist Deletion of Hell'z Movie WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20023 568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Kautz User:TenPoundHammer 02:18, 7 December 2008 (UTC) delete Utterly fails Deletion of Adam Kautz WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20024 20965 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keegan Coulter User:TheSandDoctor 03:20, 15 March 2018 (UTC) delete Is a (potential) case of and, as others have stated, fails to meet the relevant notability guidelines Deletion of Keegan Coulter WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20025 4074 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samraat Joshua Grewal User:Find 02:16, 9 January 2019 (UTC) delete per , no significant coverage in reliable independent sources. A position in an organisation does not make a person notable, especially when the organisation itself is not notable per . See Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Youth (Australia)|Articles for deletion/Christian Youth (Australia Deletion of Samraat Joshua Grewal WP:NPOL||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20026 17761 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cleveland steamer (9th nomination) User:Lugnuts 17:17, 26 June 2008 (UTC) keep Per the nominators statement of ''consider the fact that notability and factuality have been established beyond usual doubt.'' He then goes onto say: ''However, whether the topic is notable or not, it has remained without any serious content for far too long to believe anyone will improve it''. '''|So what? - There is no deadline'''. Notability has already been established, referenced and cleaned up since nomination #1 and nomination #9. I would even push for the irony of it being notable ONLY via the fact it's been up for deletion so many times and survived. Same time, next year Deletion of Cleveland steamer (9th nomination) WP:DEADLINE Wikipedia:There is no deadline 35
20027 64 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beep Beep (band) User:Daniel 06:21, 18 August 2006 (UTC) delete It seems they don't quite meet the standards Deletion of Beep Beep (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20028 14232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Eriksson (supercentenarian) User:Canadian 16:57, 26 August 2015 (UTC) delete for failing 's requirement of non-trivial coverage in multiple, reliable third-party sources Deletion of Maria Eriksson (supercentenarian) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20029 497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sakis Gouzonis User:Kosm1fent 07:12, 28 November 2011 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails and Deletion of Sakis Gouzonis WP:COMPOSER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20030 21314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Birmingham City councillors User:Valenciano 05:31, 12 May 2010 (UTC) keep reading this seems to be a valid exception to that under section 1 of the criteria there. However no objection to merging into a related article, say Birmingham City Council election results, should such an article ever be created Deletion of List of Birmingham City councillors WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20031 16098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Following the Voice of Blood User:Starblueheather 04:59, 5 May 2010 (UTC) keep """full length studio album"""" meets . Thanks""" Deletion of Following the Voice of Blood WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20032 16675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yaroslav Kislyakov User:Lilac 12:20, 11 March 2009 (UTC) keep normally, I'd argue for deletion, but the article states that much interest has been ongoing in Russian media, so I'll not call that here. As for the article being poorly sourced, well, I don't speak Russian, so I can't make that call - there is a source and if, indeed, that one source backs up everything in the article, then there are no problems. So I will try and find someone from the Russian WikiProject and have them look at the source and comment here Deletion of Yaroslav Kislyakov WP:ONEEVENT||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20033 18032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshus moloney User:Valenciano 17:29, 23 March 2014 (UTC) delete nothing to suggest that this person meets , the only ref is a |self published source apparently created by his classmates Deletion of Joshus moloney WP:GNG||WP:SPS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20034 6918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hanukkah Harry User:IZAK 16:09, 3 May 2007 (UTC) delete offensive Deletion of Hanukkah Harry WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
20035 18513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leslie Carol Roberts User:Xxanthippe 01:02, 15 May 2018 (UTC) delete fails rof. GS cites negligible. Just publishing stuff does not give notability. It has to be noted by others. WP:too soon Deletion of Leslie Carol Roberts WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
20036 4621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hacoupian User:AllyD 12:36, 4 September 2016 (UTC) delete """There is a page on fa.wikipedia.org but, judging by a Google Translate, it is fully promotional in tone and lacking in better sources. The firm does seem to be included in a list of Iran's 100 valuable brands (translating as """"Hakobyan"""": http://www.khabaronline.ir/detail/394761/Economy/industry) but I am not seeing |evidence that this is more than a run-of-the-mill retailer without |encyclopaedic notability""" Deletion of Hacoupian :WP:RS||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20037 2973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Piotr Musial User:Stuartyeates 01:10, 23 July 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Piotr Musial WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20038 15818 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cricketers by number of international five-wicket hauls User:Störm 21:05, 10 January 2021 (UTC) comment """I am still not convinced that how this list meets , the guidline says """"a list topic is considered notable is if it has been discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources."""" The above comments don't reflect the current WP policy on such lists. Closing admin, please close this AfD in the light of """ Deletion of List of cricketers by number of international five-wicket hauls WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20039 5745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PowerPoint party User:The 10:46, 13 March 2018 (UTC) delete """as lacking notability. Wikipedia's criteria for notability do no rest on potential """"future notability""""; hence, """ Deletion of PowerPoint party WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20040 10199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mishu Sabbir (actor) User:Northamerica1000 02:38, 26 August 2015 (UTC) keep Meets (albeit weekly), based upon a source review, some of which involved using Google translate Deletion of Mishu Sabbir (actor) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20041 6585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Guinness R.F.C. User:Stuartyeates 02:07, 15 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Guinness R.F.C. WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20042 1453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artemij Sitenkov User:Sue 23:57, 9 December 2012 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Artemij Sitenkov WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20043 1250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liam Rawrd User:FreeRangeFrog 00:18, 3 March 2009 (UTC) delete Vanity page and general failure to meet . Unless the subject or someone else can point to something that proves he is a ''noted'' human rights activist (as claimed) or notable for something ''other'' than the usual MySpace fame Deletion of Liam Rawrd WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20044 20154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Damone Morris User:Dirtlawyer1 22:39, 19 July 2014 (UTC) delete Subject is not entitled to a presumption of notability per the specific sports guideline of , and fails to satisfy the requirements of significant coverage in multiple, independent, reliable sources per the general notability guidelines of Deletion of Damone Morris WP:NBASKETBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20045 3485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reign Supreme (2nd nomination) User:SummerPhD 03:36, 12 April 2012 (UTC) comment """Metal Injection is a |SPS, not a |reliable source. What someone else calls """"reliable"""" is not likely to be what Wikipedia considers """"|reliable""" Deletion of Reign Supreme (2nd nomination) WP:SPS||WP:RS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20046 19864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/It's Me, Eloise User:Sgeureka 06:00, 3 July 2008 (UTC) delete to Eloise: The Animated Series. These articles are over two years old, and even their parent article is really stubby, so any information (which may exist, I didn't check) should go there first per . &ndash Deletion of It's Me, Eloise WP:AVOIDSPLIT Wikipedia:Summary style 34
20047 3692 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LinkStation User:Moeron 03:08, 27 June 2006 (UTC) delete does not meet |notability criteria of . Looks more like an advert Deletion of LinkStation WP:N||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20048 20609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BMB Group User:Ihcoyc 02:37, 9 November 2010 (UTC) delete weakly. The cited coverage is all announcements of investments or acquisitions. These routine deals don't really establish historical, technical, or cultural |significance, and I am not seeing anything more substantial Deletion of BMB Group WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20049 4247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Osei Kwasi Boamah Brown User:TonyStarks 16:37, 12 March 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and . No significant media coverage other than routine coverage of football matches he was part of Deletion of Mark Osei Kwasi Boamah Brown WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20050 3052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silas Hathaway (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 14:38, 19 March 2020 (UTC) delete """No matter how notable something may sound in theory, a person still has to have |reliable source coverage ''supporting'' their notability claim before they get a Wikipedia article for it. Having had an acting role as a baby is not """"inherently"""" notable enough to exempt a person from having to clear """ Deletion of Silas Hathaway (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20051 6803 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jovan Ivanovic User:Hobbes 12:15, 24 May 2012 (UTC) delete and do not redirect. The WP entry for Voltera is for an older, unrelated Aussie band. For this person, I found no independent coverage at all, just this WP page and its mirrors, a couple of Youtube videos with 200+ listens each, and a couple of other user-contributed entries elsewhere. Hardly shocking for a 15-year-old drummer. Fails Deletion of Jovan Ivanovic WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20052 17141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The New American Empire User:Vizjim 09:44, 30 May 2006 (UTC) keep I've been |bold and changed the article to only be about the book, which seems significant enough to be worth a keep Deletion of The New American Empire WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
20053 397 [[Wikipedia:Umfragen/Verbot von Sockenpuppen]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Rauenstein NONE delete die Krönung aller Meinungsbilder. Besser noch als neuen Unterpunkt in aufnehmen - für das Humorarchiv ist es zu langweilig Löschung von Wikipedia:Umfragen/Verbot von Sockenpuppen Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20054 21194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unfair Science Fair and Unfair Science Fair Redux (Another Story) User:Jclemens 07:10, 30 March 2011 (UTC) keep Has production and reception info, already referenced at time of nom. Besides that, per it should be merged into a series or show article rather than being deleted outright, if it is determined to be insufficiently independently notable Deletion of Unfair Science Fair and Unfair Science Fair Redux (Another Story) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20055 14439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Hodgkiss User:AssociateAffiliate 19:48, 20 April 2020 (UTC) delete Per nom, beyond routine coverage I can't find any in-depth coverage. Certainly fails too Deletion of David Hodgkiss WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20056 6651 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Special Needs Learning User:DoriSmith 01:43, 4 January 2010 (UTC) delete per #ESSAY and #OR, just like Special:Contributions/Snowite19|every other article this editor has created to date Deletion of Special Needs Learning WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20057 9122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Massacre at Ywahoo Falls User:MichaelQSchmidt 03:27, 23 August 2010 (UTC) comment """Okay, we can disregard the Lulu book (now removed as a ref). However, http://books.google.com/books?id=8AIms2agOHEC&pg=PA176&dq=Ywahoo+Falls,+Cherokee&hl=en&ei=eXtxTKb_JIuisAOAoMSIBw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CCwQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q&f=false ''Hiking the Big South Fork'', University of Tennessee Press ({{ISBN|1572330317}}) is not self-published... and per guideline offers """"|significant coverage in that it is more than trivial mention, and need not be the main topic of the source material. And are you suggesting that http://books.google.com/books?id=9ejbAAAAMAAJ&q=Ywahoo+Falls,+Cherokee&dq=Ywahoo+Falls,+Cherokee&hl=en&ei=eXtxTKb_JIuisAOAoMSIBw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=4&ved=0CEEQ6AEwAw ''Women and war: a historical encyclopedia from antiquity to the present, Volume 1'', ABC-CLIO ({{ISBN|1851097708}}) is a work of fiction? Or are you suggesting that both ABC-CLIO and University of Tennessee Press have no editorial staff or reputation for fact checking or accuracy? While I suppose that's vaguely possible, and that they have been publishing hoax material for years... but somehow I think that conclusion highly unlikley... specially as both institutions have been long-accepted by consensus and guideline as decent and responsible publishers. If you want to learn how the ABC-CLIO and University of Tennessee Press vet their information, I suggest you write them. And again, I am not myself claiming that the massacre happened... only that its allegedly happening is covered in books acceptable for sourcing such. And respected as it is, JSTOR is not the sole repository or archive of all human knowledge. So when a G-search """"Princess Cornblossom""""+""""Cherokee"""" brings up book sources... JSTOR must have simply missed them, I suppose.http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rls=com.microsoft%3Aen-US&tbs=bks%3A1&q=%22Princess+Cornblossom%22%2C+Cherokee&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai= and even ABC News' Diane Sawyer speaks toward the legend of Princess Cornblossom in speaking of her own Kentucky family history.http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/story?id=2626364&page=1 Or is Diane Sawyer herself a Troxell shill""" Deletion of Massacre at Ywahoo Falls WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20058 20367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adorama User:HighKing 11:55, 5 March 2018 (UTC) delete References fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic fails and GNG Deletion of Adorama WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20059 8033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samantha Lewis User:Burroughs 12:26, 6 December 2016 (UTC) delete as according to IMDb, roles apart from ''Grange Hill'' are uncredited. Does not meet for multiple, '''significant''' roles Deletion of Samantha Lewis WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
20060 9425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paulo Sitanggang User:Fenix 15:41, 29 January 2015 (UTC) delete Player fails as has not played in a |fully professional league, nor senior international football. No indication of any other achievements that have garnered sufficient, significant coverage to satisfy Deletion of Paulo Sitanggang WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20061 210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayor of Vinita Park, Missouri User:JayJasper 20:38, 24 January 2013 (UTC) merge to Vinita Park, Missouri per Nyttend. While the subject itself does not meet , it has obvious relevance to the target article Deletion of Mayor of Vinita Park, Missouri WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20062 244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IT New York User:Blue 04:31, 20 December 2013 (UTC) delete for failing and lack of independent sources Deletion of IT New York WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
20063 4139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of supporters of same-sex marriage in the United States User:Blanchardb 01:08, 3 June 2009 (UTC) delete Any list that can potentially contain easily over 1 million entries is ''definitely'' not wanted in Wikipedia. Also, --''' Blanchardb''' Deletion of List of supporters of same-sex marriage in the United States WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20064 16248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John A. Palmer (Lawyer) User:MelbourneStar 11:59, 21 August 2019 (UTC) delete per . Barring that, I'm not seeing the demonstrated within the article (or from performing my own quick search outside Wikipedia Deletion of John A. Palmer (Lawyer) WP:NPOL||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
20065 10014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jean Evrard Kouassi User:Bald 16:14, 25 January 2013 (UTC) delete the figures in the infobox are false, as he joined Hajduk on the 17th January but the league season doesn't resume until next month. The only game Hajduk have played in January was a friendly which they won 1-0 - this game was played the day before he joined the club. This player fails both as he yet to play in a fully-professional league, and the |general notability guideline due to a lack of third-party coverage Deletion of Jean Evrard Kouassi WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20066 1059 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bogosort [[User talk:24.36.199.169|talk]]) 21:32, 22 June 2011 (UTC) comment The first two are just dictionaries, which Wikepedia is not a dictionary . While the conference lecture published in LNCS does have merit, there are millions of professional lectures and articles published every year. 24.716 articles where published in LNCS in 2007. http://www.scimagojr.com/journalsearch.php?q=25674&tip=sid. A single publish reference is not sufficient to establish noteworthiness, unless the algorithm itself is actually somehow noteworthy.Special:Contributions/24.36.199.169|24.36.199.169 Deletion of Bogosort WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20067 4098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MikS User:onel5969 21:32, 25 December 2020 (UTC) delete not enough in-depth coverage to pass , and doesn't pass Deletion of MikS WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20068 2587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arianna Afsar User:Lonehexagon 23:26, 28 February 2018 (UTC) keep Easily passes with significant coverage in reliable sources. The article appears to be well-referenced Deletion of Arianna Afsar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20069 14976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mai Mari da Ashtan User:Atlantic306 19:37, 27 July 2019 (UTC) keep as a number of the sources added to the article such as the Asia Times and books devoted to the subject seem to pass , thanks Deletion of Mai Mari da Ashtan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20070 7765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aasan R. Rajendran NONE NONE delete Fails and Deletion of Aasan R. Rajendran WP:ANYBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20071 5235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Feminist imperative User:ReyBrujo 05:23, 6 May 2006 (UTC) delete I would go with the definition here, unless a good resource is provided Deletion of Feminist imperative WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
20072 11068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warm-Bodies User:WWGB 02:16, 2 October 2011 (UTC) delete Non-notable book, fails , no reliable independent references, contested prod Deletion of Warm-Bodies WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
20073 8940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Princess Maria Adelgunde of Hohenzollern-Sigmaringen User:RGTraynor 13:02, 17 August 2009 (UTC) delete WP:NOT|Notability is not inherited, even for a ''soi-disant'' scion of the aristocracy. specifically requires significant, substantial, multiple sources discussing the subject in detail, and a mere geneaological listing doesn't qualify. One of her sons is demonstrably notable, but that doesn't make her notable. Being a stub doesn't disqualify an article; an article that has no chance of growing beyond a stub is what doesn't qualify. There's no evidence that this can Deletion of Princess Maria Adelgunde of Hohenzollern-Sigmaringen WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20074 11426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jewdar (2nd nomination) User:Psychonaut 12:18, 4 January 2007 (UTC) delete The article now provides a lot of references, but these are all to mere ''use'' of the term. Notability would be established only if the term were the actual ''subject'' of multiple, independent published works. If such citations can be provided, then the article can be kept, or recreated in the future, but as-is it doesn't meet Deletion of Jewdar (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20075 14481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simone Sheffield User:MichaelQSchmidt 21:29, 24 March 2009 (UTC) keep and remove the fluff. A search on http://books.google.com/books?um=1&q=%22Simone+Sheffield%22&btnG=Search+Books google books (some of which I have added to the article) shows sources that can been used to cite the article. Further, a seacrh including the names of her Bollywood clients shows her being quoted in many reliable sources (again, some of which I have added). I agree that it has many problems, but feel that with work, it can be made a suitable and encyclopdeic entry for Wikipedia per ... mostly, the hyperbole inserted by the original author has got to go... unless properly sourced Deletion of Simone Sheffield WP:CLEANUP Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
20076 7099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madalina Bellariu Ion User:Rpclod 16:56, 4 February 2017 (UTC) delete """Her """"most notable television appearance"""" is two episodes in a minor role. at best""" Deletion of Madalina Bellariu Ion WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20077 17422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Knight Protectors of the Great Kingdom User:Piotrus 13:29, 9 December 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Knight Protectors of the Great Kingdom WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20078 6015 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hollywood Undead (2nd nomination) User:Doktorbuk 07:58, 22 April 2006 (UTC) comment Uh-oh, be careful with that. This particular band are, strictly speaking, non-notable by the rules of . Attempting to stretch the boundaries of those rules for one specific case will only make subsequent debates even harder to undertake. I thought the non-notable band argument had been sorted, but obviously not Deletion of Hollywood Undead (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20079 15670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hindu Taliban User:Shovon76 10:28, 11 November 2008 (UTC) keep """The term is often used and certainly a notable political term. Strictly speaking, it cannot even be termed as """"neologism"""" as it definitely is accepeted by the mainstream media. The article is well sourced and does not, in any way, represents |OR or |NPOV. Thanks""" Deletion of Hindu Taliban WP:OR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
20080 3412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zin-carla User:Percy 13:29, 1 February 2008 (UTC) delete no independent coverage; fails , , /N Deletion of Zin-carla WP:N||WP:FICT||WP:RPG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20081 11502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sudarshan Kriya User:Moorsmur 19:16, 28 May 2010 (UTC) keep The article is well referenced and meets the standards established by the Deletion of Sudarshan Kriya WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20082 1259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Masroor International Cricket Tournament User:Mtking 07:51, 1 July 2011 (UTC) delete Lacks coverage in |reliable sources so fails Deletion of Masroor International Cricket Tournament WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20083 67 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asia Book of Records User:Bearian 15:31, 21 April 2020 (UTC) delete WP:MADEUP, or in the alternative, and Deletion of Asia Book of Records WP:MILL||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
20084 2586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1974 Boston University Terriers football team User:Chetsford 19:02, 25 February 2018 (UTC) keep Notability is not temporary, the mere fact that the BU FB program has become defunct is not a valid deletion criteria. Article is extensively sourced to Deletion of 1974 Boston University Terriers football team WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20085 4426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brogan Hay User:BabbaQ 17:05, 8 April 2016 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Brogan Hay WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20086 9443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battlefield 3 (2nd nomination) User:Fritzpoll 20:27, 29 March 2008 (UTC) delete """both sources quoted use the same single primary source. In a sense, this means that they are basically based on a single source, so that in essence the citations are the same. That the source they use is not officially confirmed (""""EA remains tight-lipped"""" from the primary source http://gamestrafe.com/wiki/images/0/0c/Battlefield3-PCGamer-2007.jpg here) means that the primary source was not reliable, so the secondary sources are also not reliable. Thus the sources fail and the article as a whole fails per """ Deletion of Battlefield 3 (2nd nomination) WP:V||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20087 4855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional law firms [[User talk:137.122.49.102|talk]]) 14:57, 20 September 2010 (UTC) delete unencyclopedic cross-categorization, loosely associated topics, .--Special:Contributions/137.122.49.102|137.122.49.102 Deletion of List of fictional law firms WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20088 18795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mononlogue (Brand) User:AllyD 14:47, 3 December 2017 (UTC) delete """An indigestible lump of advertising: ''""""MONOLOGUE is all about the infallible integrity of style, in which austere silhouettes and exquisite décor mutually complement each other ...Our exacting approach""""'', blah blah. Product placement to serve the company, not the encyclopaedia""" Deletion of Mononlogue (Brand) :WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
20089 6444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergey V. Arzhanukhin User:Joe 23:33, 7 September 2016 (UTC) keep The Russian sources (which are not an argument for deletion, see ) include entries in two reliable encyclopaedias, which meets the GNG in my book. The article itself obviously needs work Deletion of Sergey V. Arzhanukhin WP:RSUE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20090 9411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diego Maquieira User:Cewbot 00:02, 16 November 2020 (UTC) comment This nomination has had limited participation and falls within the standards set for |lack of quorum. There are no previous AfD discussions, undeletions, or current redirects and no previous PRODs have been located. This nomination may be '''eligible for |soft deletion''' at the end of its 7-day listing Deletion of Diego Maquieira WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
20091 6001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ardashir Vakil User:Whpq 16:12, 28 February 2011 (UTC) keep He has been profiled in the http://thestar.com.my/lifestyle/story.asp?file=/2010/2/26/lifebookshelf/5549884&sec=lifebookshelf Malaysia Star, and interviewed by http://cities.expressindia.com/fullstory.php?newsid=49645 Express India which represent coverage about the subject meeting he |general notability criteria. Aside from that, his works have received critical reviews in multiple reliable sources such as http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/books/reviews/one-day-by-ardashir-vakil-596952.html The Independent, http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/latimes/access/32706473.html?dids=32706473:32706473&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Aug+09%2C+1998&author=PAULA+FRIEDMAN&pub=Los+Angeles+Times&desc=Only+the+Lonely%3B+BEACH+BOY.+By+Ardashir+Vakil+%28Scribner%3A+240+pp.%2C+%2422%29&pqatl=google LA Times, http://www.newstatesman.com/200302030042 New Statesman, http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/washingtonpost/access/34592889.html?dids=34592889:34592889&FMT=ABS&FMTS=ABS:FT&type=current&date=Sep+27%2C+1998&author=Sudip+Bose&pub=The+Washington+Post&desc=Bombay+Spice&pqatl=google Washington Post meeting |notoability for authors being multiple reviews from reliable sources Deletion of Ardashir Vakil WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
20092 17224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Carpenter (1752-1847) User:Northamerica1000 12:02, 1 August 2012 (UTC) keep Appears to meet per the sources in the article. Links to the sources, if any are available on the internet, would be an improvement Deletion of Thomas Carpenter (1752-1847) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20093 7144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noodles! (band) User:Toddst1 11:06, 27 October 2010 (UTC) delete as non-notable, failing . Gold status in India requires selling only 7,500 copies internationally so it may be true, but who cares? We're talking about an EP here that sold 7,500 copies Deletion of Noodles! (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20094 111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Presidents of the United States with facial hair (4th nomination) User:Gameinfirmary 03:40, 5 August 2018 (UTC) delete I don't see how this belongs on Wikipedia. It makes for good trivia but not really informative and doesn't appear to have much cultural impact on whether or not a president has a beard. Also as mentioned before |Consensus can change and it has been a few years since it was last reviewed Deletion of List of Presidents of the United States with facial hair (4th nomination) WP:CCC Wikipedia:Consensus 78
20095 7376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Berliner Tageszeitung [[User talk:2A03:4A80:0:44A:44A:795C:18B9:AB9#top|talk]]) 21:06, 27 October 2016 (UTC) delete because any sources of the article is proved, to use and is absolute strange and not applicable! — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/2A03:4A80:0:44A:44A:795C:18B9:AB9|2A03:4A80:0:44A:44A:795C:18B9:AB9 Deletion of Berliner Tageszeitung WP:WEBCRIT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20096 7563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucy Becker User:South 04:10, 25 March 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Lucy Becker WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20097 1492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Furrh User:RebeccaGreen 07:26, 11 November 2018 (UTC) keep """There was enough coverage in newspapers of the time to meet : ''Philadelphia Daily News'', 16 March 1990, (Jack (Chris Furrh), leader of the primitives, is the only character effectively sketched in this movie. He convincingly intimidates and charms the other boys in the group ...)https://www.newspapers.com/image/186290835/?terms=%22Chris%2BFurrh%22; ''The Baltimore Sun'', two page spread on ''Lord of the Flies'' with an interview with the two lead boys, Getty and Furrh, and the comment """"the boys are all good actors, particularly the leads ...""""https://www.newspapers.com/image/376840460/?terms=%22Chris%2BFurrh%22; the ''Tampa Bay Times'' said Getty's performance was """"no match for Chris Furrh, the intense, though too-puny, Jack"""" https://www.newspapers.com/image/322363746/?terms=%22Chris%2BFurrh%22; though not all coverage was positive - the ''Calgary Herald'' had """"echoing his pale performance is Chris Furrh .... both actors are devoid of emotion"""" https://www.newspapers.com/image/484929014/?terms=%22Chris%2BFurrh%22, and ''The Pittsburgh Press'' said of him in ''A Family for Joe'', """"the self-conscious, amateurish affectations of Chris Furrh as Nick""""https://www.newspapers.com/image/141482139/?terms=%22Chris%2BFurrh%22. The local (to Furrh) ''Austin American-Statesman'' had a profile of him before the premiere of ''Lord of the Flies''.https://www.newspapers.com/image/358757457/?terms=%22Chris%2BFurrh%22%2Bexile""" Deletion of Chris Furrh WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20098 8789 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andreas Teuber (Second Nomination) User:HagenUK 21:02, 11 March 2007 (UTC) delete this article looks like a no-brainer for deletion. Don't think it passess io in any shape or form Deletion of Andreas Teuber (Second Nomination) WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
20099 8475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Affiliatecommission User:Yomangani 01:03, 8 September 2006 (UTC) delete classic and copyvio from http://www.affiliatecommission.co.uk/how_it_works.php. Author has no other edits Deletion of Affiliatecommission WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
20100 4298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prison cell pony party User:TheSpecialUser 17:17, 27 May 2012 (UTC) delete no proper refs and no coverage under thus fails . Also notability of the term as well as concept is at question Deletion of Prison cell pony party WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20101 11296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barack Obama's visit to India User:Wikireader41 06:18, 7 November 2010 (UTC) keep """this is not just another routine visit. a classic misapplication of which states ''routine news reporting on things like announcements, sports, or celebrities is not a sufficient basis for inclusion in the encyclopedia'' This visit is an event of enduring significance with US reversing its long standing policy & lending support to India's bid for NSG, MTCR etc for 1st time, several large Indian firms being taken off """"entities list"""" by US thereby paving trade between US and these companies. it clearly meets with multiple independent RS from across the world covering it so I will not spend more time discussing that. as far as meeting is concerned the is already evident and I would point to Barack Obama's visit to India#Impact. creating 50,000 jobs in the middle of a recession and concluding $10 billion in business deals is no small feat IMO (even for POTUS). Approx 80 countries have GDP lower than that. Wall street journal even has an editorial on this event http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304155604575581721120234484.html. what percentage of events covered by WP are considered notable enough for an opinion piece by WSJ ?? states and I quote ''Articles about breaking news events —particularly biographies of participants— are often rapidly nominated for deletion. As there is no deadline, it is recommended to delay the nomination for a few days to avoid the deletion debate dealing with a moving target and to allow time for a clearer picture of the notability of the event to emerge, which may make a deletion nomination unnecessary.'' It seems to me that the deletionists want a separate (much higher) threshold for notability for Obama's actions and another threshold for the average notable person. I agree not everything obama does is notable but this visit is one of the notable things he has done recently""" Deletion of Barack Obama's visit to India WP:NOTNEWS||WP:N||WP:EVENT||WP:EFFECT||WP:BREAKING Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20102 7299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Advances in Group Theory and Applications User:Headbomb 22:25, 5 September 2015 (UTC) delete per / and . This is a non-notable journal, and the article was created by the EiC of the journal. If it becomes notable, then we can have it, but not before Deletion of Advances in Group Theory and Applications WP:CRYSTAL||WP:TOOSOON||WP:NJOURNALS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20103 9993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Names and titles of God in the New Testament (3rd nomination) User:Jeffro77 11:47, 17 May 2019 (UTC) delete originally called Jehovah in the New Testament, but for more of its existence as Tetragrammaton in the New Testament, this article began as a POV |coatrack originally to 'defend' Jehovah's Witnesses' use of 'Jehovah' in their version of the New Testament. After previous AfDs, and with some degree of support from proponents of Sacred Name Bibles, there has been some attempt to add a few more 'respectable layers' to the coatrack. Despite the extra layers, the core intent of the article still seems to boil down to 'the tetragrammaton isn't in the New Testament at all, but maybe you can kind of see it if you squint'. Suitable material is already at articles such as Tetragrammaton, Jehovah and Names of God in Christianity, and relevant articles can be expanded if necessary Deletion of Names and titles of God in the New Testament (3rd nomination) WP:COAT Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
20104 14441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mahad Kazi User:E 17:23, 29 January 2017 (UTC) delete mere Deletion of Mahad Kazi WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20105 2701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Regan bauman User:Edison 20:24, 8 September 2010 (UTC) delete per nomination for failure to satisfy , even if claims were true. Found nothing at IMDB Deletion of Regan bauman WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20106 16016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Lowe User:Closeapple 02:22, 5 January 2010 (UTC) delete Minor horse owner in regional shows; does not seem to meet . Also apparently Wikipedia:Autobiography which makes article and citations self-sourced anyway Deletion of Christopher Lowe WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20107 1444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avelyn Desbris User:Quasirandom 18:18, 26 January 2008 (UTC) comment I'm not finding much in the way of sources to support the notability of this character either. Contra nom, per not all in-universe material need be removed, and primary sources are acceptable for in-universe information. Per , the next thing to try is merge, but I'm not seeing an obvious merge target. Possibly selectively to a new Main Characters section in The DemonWars Saga. Will wait to !vote till I think some more Deletion of Avelyn Desbris WP:WAF||WP:FICT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
20108 3844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leigh Remedios User:1292simon 12:46, 2 May 2013 (UTC) delete fails for starters Deletion of Leigh Remedios WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
20109 12578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Professor Victor Hugo User:OfficeGirl 18:07, 16 November 2006 (UTC) delete If he has really done ''pioneering'' work in synthetic antimicrobial whatsie-thingies, lets have the proof now-- something that shows ''the scientific community has recognized him as a standout'', per . But this isn't even an attempt to create a stub here. If there aren't some very big changes to the article during the course of this discussion, there's no reason to keep it. Someone can write a better article later if this professor is the real deal if there's no one here ready, willing and able to work on the article and bring it up to standards Deletion of Professor Victor Hugo WP:PROFTEST Wikipedia:Notability 77
20110 1796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebeca Omordia User:Laurenlinn 15:49, 12 January 2013 (UTC) delete I agree that this page appears to be . The references listed for the artist's achievements are weak and are not high quality secondary sources per WP policy, but rather event and programme listings. I might even venture to say Deletion of Rebeca Omordia WP:TOOSOON||WP:NPF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20111 11508 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Wicca (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 18:44, 12 March 2009 (UTC) keep it links to dozens of Wikipedia articles, including Grieg's music in popular culture, and has ''some'' |good sources, so it needs clean up, not deletion Deletion of Christian Wicca (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20112 13559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All Alright (Sigur Rós song) User:Esradekan 06:28, 1 February 2009 (UTC) delete as a non-plausible search term, fails notability per #Songs Deletion of All Alright (Sigur Rós song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20113 10219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/These Colours Don't Run User:J 19:18, 22 September 2007 (UTC) delete unless reliable sources are provided. Yes, adding this information to the album article would swell it to an unmanagable size, but is the information completely relevent? Are these songs independently notable? Have there been reliable sources written about them? Adding information about every shop in Barrow in Furness (an article I am working on passively at the moment) would swell it- does that mean that every shop should have an article? No, not unless the shops have notability of their own. And, as ever, |the fact other songs have articles is irrelevent. You don't like it? Nominate them Deletion of These Colours Don't Run WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20114 7711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Slow Readers Club User:Sparklism 09:44, 23 April 2012 (UTC) delete There has been ''some'' coverage (http://www.subba-cultcha.com/news/article.php?contentID=26675 here and http://www.spinner.com/2012/02/14/the-slow-readers-club-feet-on-fire-playmobil-video/ here), but not enough to satisfy at the present time. --'''sparkl Deletion of The Slow Readers Club WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20115 2987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teen Assassin User:Hobbes 05:00, 24 November 2011 (UTC) delete """Gbooks shows zero reviews. Puny, mostly primary or sales sites from a general search. The author did get a http://www.couriermail.com.au/ipad/sean-comes-up-with-novel-diy-approach/story-fn6ck620-1226123989330 cute little piece in a Brisbane paper, but I think it actually provides the most damning evidence: """"Now 17, Sean worked part-time at a local supermarket to raise $4000 to have Teen Assassin edited and self-published earlier this year after several unsuccessful approaches to publishers. The original print run sold out, and Sean last week printed another 100 copies of the action-thriller..."""" Fails """ Deletion of Teen Assassin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20116 15383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Ice Bucket Challenge participants User:Azurfrog 19:06, 24 August 2014 (UTC) delete No lasting value of any kind except that of ''Most Ridiculous Article Ever on Wikipedia'': regrouping here |the indiscriminate and potentially limitless list of those famous people who had rather a bucket of cold water poured on their heads than pay 100 bucks to a charity is... both ludicrous and indecent Deletion of List of Ice Bucket Challenge participants WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20117 4808 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List Of KISS Songs User:HisSpaceResearch 08:25, 17 June 2007 (UTC) delete per . Not necessary, and not wikified, issues, etc Deletion of List Of KISS Songs WP:IINFO||WP:MOS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20118 15556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashley Underwood User:Otr500 06:52, 5 June 2017 (UTC) merge """The otability (people)|subjects are just not otability|notable. ''Ashley Underwood'' was a top ten all time scorer for the Black Bears, """"won"""" Miss Maine USA 2009, and was a participant on the Survivor. Any obvious redirect would be to Miss Maine USA. Angelia Layton was a participant on Survivor and won Miss Utah USA 2014. Redirect to that article. Janu Tornell participated on Survivor and """"won"""" Miss Nevada USA 1989. Redirect to that article""" Deletion of Ashley Underwood WP:N||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20119 2747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Doyle (actor) User:Spy 20:23, 6 November 2019 (UTC) delete Article's subject neither meets nor Deletion of Peter Doyle (actor) WP:GNG||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20120 17858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Strange User:Bbatsell 23:14, 19 January 2007 (UTC) keep Meets and this is going to become a pretty big issue, if my reading of the landscape is correct Deletion of Jennifer Strange WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20121 13565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yejun Feng User:Sam 12:22, 7 April 2019 (UTC) delete Associate professor, appears to fail . I'm unsure what sources Deletion of Yejun Feng WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20122 235 [[René Schneider (Politiker)]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Neumeier NONE keep Es gab für diesen Artikel schon zwei Löschdiskussion, die hier nachgelesen werden können: /14._Juni_2004#Ren.C3.A9_Schneider_.28Politiker.29| LD vom 14. Juni 2004 und http://de.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:L%C3%B6schkandidaten/6._Juli_2004&oldid=1970027#Ren.C3.A9_Schneider_.28Politiker.29_und_Heinz-J.C3.BCrgen_Milse LD vom 6. Juli 2004. Der Artikel ist stark umstritten und wurde in der Vergangheit wiederholt vandalisiert und geleert. Zum heutigen Thema jetzt: Der Mann hatte bei Wahlen vielleicht keinen besonderen Erfolg, aber durch seine Aktivitäten betreffend den Studierendenschaften hat er sicher mehr Einfluss gehabt als manche Landestagsabgeordnete Löschung von René Schneider (Politiker) Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20123 10026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elvis Kabashi User:Cloudz679 20:20, 25 February 2013 (UTC) delete per nom as he has not played in a fully professional league, at senior international level, or been the subject of non-trivial coverage from multiple independent sources, failing and Deletion of Elvis Kabashi WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20124 12611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eleanor Iselin User:Sgeureka 08:09, 12 August 2010 (UTC) delete Just plot and/or original research (#PLOT and ). &ndash Deletion of Eleanor Iselin WP:NOT||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20125 20108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NUFN User:Accounting4Taste 17:01, 3 October 2007 (UTC) delete Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion|No assertion of importance/significance. I find this article very peculiar and possibly a hoax -- Canada still uses the penny, so why is this small group of people focusing on the nickel? Also, nearly zero in the way of Google hits for the acronym; no one has found this group to be otable|notable, it seems. So I recommend deletion unless someone can back this up with third-party citations that I couldn't find Deletion of NUFN WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20126 18624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fates Forever User:Ceosad 16:19, 15 October 2016 (UTC) delete """Notability is not inherited, and reliable sources are lacking in depth. The release or existence of this game did not get acclaim for being """"the first MOBA designed exclusively for tablets"""" either. It looks like this was just another generic app game without lasting impact on the video game culture. , """ Deletion of Fates Forever WP:GNG||WP:INDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
20127 2963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of films considered the worst (9th nomination) User:MichaelQSchmidt 03:13, 12 July 2017 (UTC) keep Sheesh.... Even in not looking at the previous 8 failed deletion attempts, this meets inclusion standards for . I'm feeling that |chill Deletion of List of films considered the worst (9th nomination) WP:NOTAGAIN||WP:SALAT||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20128 15417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashkona User:Pharaoh 20:31, 3 March 2015 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Ashkona WP:NPLACE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20129 14718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2020 Regents Park stabbing User:Mrschimpf 21:35, 20 February 2020 (UTC) delete """Failed murder attempt (thankfully), will be within a week. We're not """"London Action News This Morning"""", so please stop creating articles about everyday crimes that we have to waste time trying to remove from here""" Deletion of 2020 Regents Park stabbing WP:ROUTINE||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20130 6219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liam Tulley (actor) [[User talk:147.70.242.54|talk]]) 14:52, 21 April 2010 (UTC) delete """I couldn't find much when I removed the self-link from the article; I see nothing supporting , either... which basically means that that I must've had the same breakfast as nom. One would think that a recurring character in a televised series would attract some notice in reliable sources, but a Google search of """"Daniel Dingle"""" turns up no such mention (mainly real life people, one of whom who claimed the invention of a car that runs on water).Special:Contributions/147.70.242.54|147.70.242.54""" Deletion of Liam Tulley (actor) WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20131 3677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jossed User:James086 02:49, 11 February 2007 (UTC) delete WP:NOT#DICTIONARY|Wikipedia is not a dictionary, I think the nominator is right that there aren't any |''reliable'' sources Deletion of Jossed WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20132 2131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 Time 100 User:Guillaume2303 16:11, 4 May 2012 (UTC) merge """I agree completely with Enric Naval. The 2012 list in itself is not notable, there are no sources ''about'' this list, just scattered mentions that """"John Doe was on the 2012 list"""". As such, this list does not meet """ Deletion of 2012 Time 100 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20133 12767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Five Star Prison Cell (2nd nomination) User:Sparklism 12:59, 24 May 2012 (UTC) keep Three albums on a major label, meets Deletion of Five Star Prison Cell (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20134 9467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Alderson (3rd nomination) User:TonyBallioni 20:11, 22 August 2016 (UTC) keep reviewing the 2nd nomination and the article itself, I'm convinced of his notability by the arguments that led to it being kept the second time. |Notability is not temporary and I think the arguments lade out seven years ago still hold today Deletion of Tim Alderson (3rd nomination) WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20135 5269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Survival food User:Tree 03:52, 27 June 2006 (UTC) merge to Survival kit, don't merge since the article seems to be as mentioned by nom Deletion of Survival food WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
20136 3063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alta Mira (2nd nomination) User:Jujutacular 18:00, 3 May 2010 (UTC) delete Unable to find evidence that this facility passes or Deletion of Alta Mira (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20137 652 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chukwuma Onwuchekwa User:ImperatorExercitus 22:31, 5 April 2009 (UTC) delete fails , , and . No references, http://www.google.com/search?ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&sourceid=navclient&gfns=1&q=Chukwuma+Onwuchekwa only returns a few relevant hits...none of which give notability. Article in question doesn't even supply proper guidelines for writing an article. Cheers Deletion of Chukwuma Onwuchekwa WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20138 90 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Ömer Halisdemir """Kullanıcı:pragdon'''pragdon'''""" 09:33, 7 Ağustos 2016 (UTC) keep Kişinin darbe girişimine karşı aksiyon aldığı kamera görüntüleri ile de net olarak doğrulanmış bir olay. Bu ismin vikipedia dan kaldırılmasının tartışılması çok anlamsız ve itibar zedeleyici.{{imzasız|5.46.243.177}} kriterlerini sağlamayan kullanıcı Ömer Halisdemir'in silinmesi Vikipedi:OY Wikipedia:Administrators 89
20139 11844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of WindClan Cats User:Redl 14:58, 16 December 2007 (UTC) delete Violates a number of policies, primarily and Deletion of List of WindClan Cats WP:N||WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20140 16125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aclame ao Senhor User:Ugog 19:10, 9 April 2014 (UTC) delete per nom. Couldn't find any coverage, fails and Deletion of Aclame ao Senhor WP:GNG||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20141 20626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agilebuddy User:Joe 21:17, 14 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of Agilebuddy WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20142 607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Windows Odyssey (2nd nomination) User:MichaelQSchmidt 05:19, 6 January 2010 (UTC) keep """Puppets are dealt with by blocking. Article issues are dealt with through editing. Having giving thought to the comments here, the |potential this article has for |improvement, and in consideration of a brief serach http://www.google.com/search?q=Windows+Odyssey&sourceid=ie7&rls=com.microsoft:en-US&ie=utf8&oe=utf8, http://books.google.com/books?um=1&cf=all&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Windows%20Odyssey%22&sa=N&tab=np, http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Windows+Odyssey%22&sa=X&oi=print_back, I have struck my """"merge"""" up above. Now the the article belongs to Wikipedia, I believe it can be improved through |regular editing. With respects, the GNG is a guideline, used by default when it seems applicable, but it will not and does not apply to all subjects. The notability of an idea or concept is not judged by the same criteria as notability for an person or a film. Further research in archives and technical journals not available online would be reasonable and prudent. Surmountable issues are never proper cause for deletion""" Deletion of Windows Odyssey (2nd nomination) WP:POTENTIAL||WP:IMPROVE||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Potential, not just current state 11
20143 16077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My bad User:Michig 09:26, 7 November 2015 (UTC) delete per #DICDEF. Unlikely to expand beyond a dictionary definition Deletion of My bad WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20144 611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nipple-Touch Mini User:Youremyjuliet 01:42, 19 October 2005 (UTC) comment Ah ha! Thank you, Llywrch. Even if we get over-ruled, you're really right about everything else. I hope this gets to at least have a chance... Or maybe keeping it afloat on a |BJAODN page would help it last long enough to be undeleted Deletion of Nipple-Touch Mini WP:BJAODN Wikipedia:Silly Things 72
20145 6317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United Noachide Council, Inc. User:Butseriouslyfolks 17:41, 27 May 2007 (UTC) delete per and . Even author concedes article may be deleted on notability grounds Deletion of United Noachide Council, Inc. WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
20146 21216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur oakeshott User:Quarl NONE delete as |unverifiable. &mdash Deletion of Arthur oakeshott WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20147 3137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sony PictureStation DPP-EX50 (2nd nomination) User:Mattg82 23:38, 7 December 2011 (UTC) delete Not a notable . Not possible to merge as no suitable article exists for it to merge to. This is one many hundreds or thousands of products that Sony make, I don't see how it can be merged into Sony Deletion of Sony PictureStation DPP-EX50 (2nd nomination) WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20148 1389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eamon McDonnell User:Nappa90 08:02, 31 May 2007 (UTC) delete As . If you want to keep the content, then move it into something like Deletion of Eamon McDonnell WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
20149 2406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Teeters User:Trackinfo 07:28, 22 February 2017 (UTC) keep """Nom has misspoken. As Jrheller notes, the 60 metres is an IAAF World Indoor Championships event. So being ranked in the top 6 in the world on the annual list clearly passes #8. The current champion is Trayvon Bromell, who Teeters ran against in the same collegiate conference many times. I believe (based on so far, unreliable blog sources, so I haven't added it to the article) Teeters holds victories over the world champion Bromell and over triple Olympic medalist Andre De Grasse. As you know NTRACK is based on the presumption of meeting . Google his name and you will find pages of coverage, a lot of it related to his being """"the fastest white American of all time."""" Because of the racial component, I added that to the article as a quote. So even beyond the specific of NTRACK, he clearly also meets GNG""" Deletion of John Teeters WP:NTRACK||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20150 3018 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bottle toss User:Blueboy96 22:57, 3 February 2011 (UTC) delete Either a hoax, or completely |made up Deletion of Bottle toss WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
20151 2404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kulaxingu Kambamjiji User:Anakin101 13:44, 4 January 2008 (UTC) delete per , as well. The single reference in that book is too fleeting and obscure. Maybe they simply transcribed his name in a non-standard way and that's why we can't find anything more about him. But it's not a good idea to have an article for that one reference (other people could copy Wikipedia and confuse the situation even more Deletion of Kulaxingu Kambamjiji WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20152 7976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/F@NB0Y$ User:Selmo 05:39, 17 January 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of F@NB0Y$ WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20153 14256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Falinski User:Enos733 18:13, 8 May 2016 (UTC) comment Elections fall under as a topic not usually appropriate for Wikipedia. The real concern, at this point, is whether the subject meets . I challenge editors who have access to more substantive sourcing to edit and improve the article Deletion of Jason Falinski WP:CRYSTAL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20154 9822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russell Brand prank calls row User:Mr 15:15, 29 October 2008 (UTC) keep Significant coverage satisfies source and notability policies. Hey, it's '''snowing''' here in Ithaca, NY|Ithaca I think it's '''|snowing''' on this AfD as well Deletion of Russell Brand prank calls row WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
20155 16580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/No.1 Middle School of Xuyi County User:Yunshui 09:12, 6 January 2012 (UTC) merge to Huai'an, per Deletion of No.1 Middle School of Xuyi County WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20156 6590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baron Leighinmohr User:Peterkingiron 16:43, 10 December 2017 (UTC) delete If the title had been created, that would be recorded in London Gazettee. Accordingly, this is a case of Deletion of Baron Leighinmohr WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
20157 14444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peniel Revival Ministries Inc User:ApFaq NONE comment Well This is a new organization and it is mostly based in India. So in India, they do not have the best of online information systems especially for a charity organization working in wilderness and remote village areas. So i would expect the internet references to this organization to be few. But i think since it is a '''501c organization''' registered in the US, it does have the right to classify as ''''''. The references cannot be changed in the URL form because it is a flash site so you cannot go to specific articles. Anyway, i think this is a great organization and it should be kept around Deletion of Peniel Revival Ministries Inc WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20158 12944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Felicilandia User:KidAd 00:03, 23 September 2020 (UTC) delete Amusement park fails guidelines established by ({{tq|Buildings, including private residences and commercial developments, may be notable as a result of their historic, social, economic, or architectural importance, but they require significant in-depth coverage by reliable, third-party sources to establish notability}}). No such sources support the notability of this park Deletion of Felicilandia WP:NBUILD Wikipedia:Notability 77
20159 16111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mounir Darbaki User:D 21:21, 4 January 2008 (UTC) delete no where near |notable Deletion of Mounir Darbaki WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20160 164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of found art User:Vcessayist 00:48, 7 October 2012 (UTC) delete """as . Appreciate what the nominator is getting at. """"Found art"""" is something that appears in reliable sources, as per our article on Found object. But trying to determine what constitutes """"found"""", let alone what constitutes """"art"""", is very difficult and subjective in this particular area. We shouldn't put inclusion in this list to the whims of one or two reliable sources. There are literally hundreds and thousands of things that might fit here, or merely dozens, because the inclusion criteria is so impossibly vague""" Deletion of List of found art WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20161 12996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New York City FC User:Presidentman 22:14, 2 May 2013 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of New York City FC WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20162 19130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herbert Road, Dublin User:Trusilver 09:07, 28 December 2008 (UTC) delete WP:V|VERIFIABILITY is not the same thing as |NOTABILITY. Just because this street exists and there are sources to back that fact up, does not mean it is worth an article Deletion of Herbert Road, Dublin WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20163 14693 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diego Sebastian Schwartzman User:Kante4 10:55, 16 April 2011 (UTC) delete He is not notable, PL Alvarez explained why he fails Deletion of Diego Sebastian Schwartzman WP:NTENNIS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20164 8201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Berg Party User:Bonadea 11:04, 14 July 2021 (UTC) keep Surely it doesn't fail ''every'' guideline? ;-) Joking aside, a local party in a small Swedish municipality is unlikely to meet , but I think that the criteria are met here. The current sourcing is abysmal, but the sv.wiki article includes several sources: https://web.archive.org/web/20070927220419/http://www.ltz.se/artikel_standard.php?id=413222 this is a regional newspaper, so wouldn't work on its own, https://www.dn.se/nyheter/politik/valjarna-foljde-pampen-till-nytt-parti/ this however is an in-depth article in ''Dagens Nyheter'' and https://sverigesradio.se/artikel/5840486 this is is from Sveriges Radio. Looking for other sources, I find https://www.svt.se/nyheter/lokalt/jamtland/spricka-i-bergspartiet this from (a local division of) Sveriges Television and https://www.op.se/artikel/framgangssagan-over-for-bergspartiet this which is fairly in-depth, from ''Östersunds-Posten'', also a regional newspaper but slightly weightier than the first source I linked. Taken together, I think these sources show that is met, especially since they were published at different times, the earliest in 2006 and the last in 2014, so it is not a case of brief and ephemeral interest. I will undertake to add these sources and develop the article based on them, provided it survives the AfD Deletion of Berg Party WP:ORGCRIT||WP:ORGCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20165 12345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crissi Cochrane User:Pikks 18:25, 21 March 2012 (UTC) keep According to please refrain to check the number of hits from google. Of course you can use google to add other relevant sources to the article, but not as a tool to see whether an article can be kept or not because of its number of hits. In the current state in my opinion the article should be kept according to as it satisfies the point 1,2, 4, 7, and from what I see in the refs also 11 Deletion of Crissi Cochrane WP:GOOGLEHITS||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20166 793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hongwei Li User:ThatMontrealIP 07:09, 27 June 2019 (UTC) keep this is a pretty clear keep as, for starters, he is in multiple museum collections. For example the https://www.artic.edu/artists/114915/hongwei-li Art Institute of Chicago has some of his work. When I see collection(s), I generally figure they are notable as it is hard to get into collections. Also, we have a policy to the same effect ( 4)d). After the collections, I look around for sources. I see a profile interview in Scultpure magazine. So he meets . The fact that he might have edited the article himself can be corrected through the use of the delete key on any non-encylopedic text Deletion of Hongwei Li WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
20167 21454 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Marks User:Curbon7 07:51, 19 August 2021 (UTC) keep You seem to have misread . This subject easily passes that criterion as he was a state senator Deletion of Bruce Marks WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20168 18409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shadowrun timeline (3rd nomination) User:Shooterwalker 17:27, 1 December 2010 (UTC) delete another where we have two articles trying to spin the same sources in two different ways. This one is solely a plot summary. Keep the main article which has some coverage of the plot but also could cover other aspects of the series Deletion of Shadowrun timeline (3rd nomination) WP:CONTENTFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
20169 11738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Civil courage NONE NONE keep """I can read German. I don't have access to the printed German sources, but I read the online citations under """"Weblinks"""" in :de:Zivilcourage. These two are , and are specifically about the subject: http://www.psychologie.uzh.ch/de/bereiche/sob/motivation/zivilcourage.html """"Willkommen auf dem Zivilcourage-Portal!"""" (University of Zurich); and http://www.sueddeutsche.de/leben/uebergriffe-in-der-oeffentlichkeit-sieben-tipps-fuer-mehr-zivilcourage-1.2213360 """"Sieben Tipps für mehr Zivilcourage """" (''Süddeutsche Zeitung''). I googled, and found: http://www.spiegel.de/thema/zivilcourage/ """"Zivilcourage - Alle Artikel und Hintergründe"""" (''Der Spiegel''); https://www.bundespolizei.de/Web/DE/02Sicher-im-Alltag/02Zivilcourage-zeigen/Zivilcourage-zeigen_node.html """"Zivilcourage zeigen"""" (Bundespolizei (Germany)|Bundespolizei); https://econtent.hogrefe.com/doi/abs/10.1024/0044-3514.35.4.185 """"Zivilcourage"""" ('':de:Zeitschrift für Psychologie''); https://www.br.de/radio/bayern2/sendungen/radiowissen/ethik-und-philosophie/zivilcourage-mut-104.html """"Der Mut des Bürgers"""" (Bayerischer Rundfunk); and https://www.amazon.de/Zivilcourage-Staat-seine-B%C3%BCrger-Stich/dp/3423348852 ''Zivilcourage: Wie der Staat seine Bürger im Stich lässt'' (Michael Wolffsohn, a 2016 book). My 5 finds were among the top 13 hits""" Deletion of Civil courage WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20170 382 [[GemDat Informatik]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Tom_md 11:49, 9. Sep. 2010 (CEST) delete Marktführerschaft unbelegt, deshalb erstmal raus. Ansonsten ohne Relevanz nach #U Löschung von GemDat Informatik Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
20171 9284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mediashout User:Thesquire 07:38, 8 January 2006 (UTC) delete not notable, made by a company that probably fails horribly Deletion of Mediashout WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20172 9446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SAVE Bandra Crosses User:Gene93k 19:35, 3 April 2011 (UTC) delete This article violates . While an encyclopedic article about the crosses themselves might be written, this isn't it. Notability for the campaign to save the crosses is not established Deletion of SAVE Bandra Crosses WP:NOTSOAPBOX Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20173 3253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evil reptilian kitten-eater from another planet (2nd nomination) User:Reference 10:38, 18 April 2011 (UTC) keep """Editing Wikipedia with a constructive motive should have led any editor to do some research before nominating this article for AfD. ''The Chatham Daily News'' provides a clear definition for the term: """"evil reptilian kitten-eater from another planet, a term that surfaced in a press release from the PC campaign of Ernie Eves to describe McGuinty in the 2003 election."""" http://www.chathamdailynews.ca/ArticleDisplay.aspx?e=3073879 There are enough coverage and discussion of this phrase in the media http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=%22Evil+reptilian+kitten-eater+from+another+planet%22&num=100&hl=en&lr=&tbm=nws&source=lnt&tbs=ar:1&sa=X&ei=WRCsTYnqMYjorQeChPinCA&ved=0CBIQpwUoBQ and in GBooks http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=%22Evil%20reptilian%20kitten-eater%20from%20another%20planet%22&num=100&hl=en&lr=&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tbo=u&tbs=ar:1,bks:1&source=og&sa=N&tab=np The phrase has also received coverage in scholarly journals http://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?q=%22Evil%20reptilian%20kitten-eater%20from%20another%20planet%22&num=100&hl=en&lr=&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=ps does not apply for political phrases. Yes it is a newly developed political phrase, but it passes and """ Deletion of Evil reptilian kitten-eater from another planet (2nd nomination) WP:IINFO||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20174 924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Australian Football International User:Melcous 01:37, 2 November 2019 (UTC) keep While there has been COI and promotional editing, I have added some sources that I think demonstrate the organisation does meet and the article can hopefully be further improved from here. Possibly some of the multiple articles created by this editor should be merged/re-directed Deletion of Australian Football International WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20175 17235 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/""""Canadian Space Opera Company""""""" User:Cool3 21:48, 23 September 2006 (UTC) delete """under as A7 (""""Unremarkable people or groups/vanity pages. An article about a real person, group of people, band, or club that does not assert the importance or significance of its subject."""") as an unremarkable group of people""" """Deletion of """"Canadian Space Opera Company""""""" WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
20176 21363 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sinking ship statement User:Blue 20:36, 22 December 2012 (UTC) delete per #DICDEF Deletion of Sinking ship statement WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20177 6997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Notarize (company) User:HighKing 21:30, 26 November 2020 (UTC) delete """There's currently a discussion ongoing on the Talk page where the clear consensus is that the NCORP/NORG SNG is the guideline to follow and that this guideline adopts a stricter interpretation on sources that establish notability for companies/organizations. With that in mind, much of Timtempleton's arguments fall away. For example, Timtempleton lists four references above which are claimed to meet the criteria for notability for the reasons that they are ''independent, third party sources''. https://www.bizjournals.com/washington/blog/techflash/2016/02/need-something-notarized-virginia-startup-says-its.html This reference from BizJournals opens with ''An Arlington tech startup says'' and relies entirely on an interview/quotation with the CEO. Even by GNG standards, this in not """"independent"""" and experienced editors who spend time at AfD are expected to know that an """"independent source"""" doesn't just mean that the publisher is functionally and corporately separate from the topic company, but that the content is also Independent. within CORP provides clarity on """"Independent Content"""" to mean ''original and independent opinion, analysis, investigation, and fact checking that are clearly attributable to a source unaffiliated to the subject''. This reference therefore fails ORGIND and GNG. https://techcrunch.com/2020/03/27/notarize-to-add-1000-online-notaries-to-address-demand-for-remote-transactions/ The TechCrunch reference suffers the same faults, the article starts with ''Notarize, the platform that enables digital notarizations, announced'' and the reference is clearly based on a company announcement and interview/quotations attributed to the CEO. This reference fails for the same reasons as the previous. https://news.crunchbase.com/news/e-doc-verifier-notarize-launches-competitor-to-docusign/ This Crunchbase reference is off the back of https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20190611005742/en/Notarize-Announces-Free-eSignature-Product-Debuts-Comprehensive this announcement and fails for the exact same reasons as the previous two references. It contains no Independent Content. Finally, https://fortune.com/2016/06/13/notarize-iphone-notary-app/ this Fortune article is a classic churnalism profile piece, based on an interview with the CEO and also contain absolutely zero Independent Content. All four reference fail GNG (an """"independent"""" reference doesn't just refer to no corporate links between the publisher and the topic company) and . I am unable to locate any reference that meets the criteria for establishing notability. (adding my sig late""" Deletion of Notarize (company) WP:N||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP||WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20178 20506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wikitistics User:Wmahan 03:00, 28 August 2006 (UTC) delete per , non-notable, etc Deletion of Wikitistics WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20179 6223 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Disability Justice and State Violence User:Septrillion 20:48, 6 July 2018 (UTC) delete as and . \\\Septrillion Deletion of Black Disability Justice and State Violence WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
20180 10275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Proton pack (2nd nomination) User:Folken 21:21, 20 February 2012 (UTC) comment """1) """"fascinating"""" is your own personal judgment. is not a valid argument because wikipedia is not your personal blog. Your personal opinion has nothing to do here, articles are not kept because one merely """"likes"""" them, but because they pass the |general notability guideline, and it is not the case here.2) """"well sourced"""": completely wrong> With only primary sources and message boards, this artiucle is not sourced at all and fails .3) """"dullards"""": a |personal attack. If you think this is how you will keep this article, you're seriously mistaken""" Deletion of Proton pack (2nd nomination) WP:ILIKEIT||WP:GNG||WP:GNG||WP:NPA Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20181 13636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Universe Today (4th nomination) User:Johnuniq 11:30, 13 July 2012 (UTC) keep """Above is the claim that http://searchenginewatch.com/article/2187666/From-0-to-3-Million-Monthly-Visitors-Learn-One-Mans-Proven-Strategy this interview with Fraser Cain can be ignored as a primary source, but the key point from that interview is valid: the Universe Today website """"{{xt|is currently one of the most popular astronomy blogs on the net}}"""" (the opinion of the interviewer—and much more than puffery as the interviewer is clearly impressed). Such a conclusion is grounds for establishing notability, particularly when combined with the refs in the article. Each item is only a weak indication of notability, but this is |not a bureaucracy with a precise formula for determining notability—the spirit of is satisfied by the links given that the article is not a promotion or puff piece, and that the subject is of encyclopedic value""" Deletion of Universe Today (4th nomination) WP:BURO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20182 20952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nguyễn Công Phượng User:SuperJew 12:00, 14 September 2014 (UTC) delete """hasn't played in pro league, no significant coverage, failing and . Morever, the """"article"""" is a stub of one single sentence, and the infobox doesn't even have caps and goals in the Hoang Anh Gia Lai – Arsenal JMG Academy|non-pro team he did play in or his national (u20) caps and goals""" Deletion of Nguyễn Công Phượng WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20183 8153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solace.fm User:Chzz 11:33, 20 January 2011 (UTC) delete I can't see evidence of |notability; it's unreferenced (really) and a bit of an advert, too Deletion of Solace.fm WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20184 7792 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Loud: Around the Time User:Presidentman 22:07, 9 July 2012 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of The Loud: Around the Time WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
20185 13147 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pennbrook Middle School User:Burntsauce 17:33, 27 September 2007 (UTC) merge Well what do you know, we have an article about North Penn School District, so redirect it there per our well established and widely accepted guidelines Deletion of Pennbrook Middle School WP:REDIRECT Wikipedia:Redirect 56
20186 3008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lindsay Soto User:Tarheel95 19:35, 15 April 2009 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of Lindsay Soto WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20187 7492 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Alford Jr. User:Eagles247 16:54, 19 October 2019 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Bruce Alford Jr. WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
20188 20517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nakia and his Southern Cousins User:Guest9999 12:13, 5 October 2008 (UTC) delete not |speedy - listed sixth in best new band category - claim of importance) I do not think that the level of |reliable sourcing exists on which a |verifiable article could be based, of the sources that appear in the article, one is an interview in a blog, one is a list on which they are placed sixth in the Austin music awards best new band category (with no additional information) and the other is a review on a site called Twangville, which even if it did count as a reliable source - with a reputation for fact checking and accuracy - I'm not sure if it could be the basis of an article Deletion of Nakia and his Southern Cousins WP:SPEEDY||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
20189 12563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Free Republic of Verdis User:CASSIOPEIA 13:26, 30 July 2019 (UTC) comment For a hoax subject, no merge should be performance - see link above I provide. A micro nation declaration should be recieved with |independent, |reliable sources. This subject has has been created in draft many times and all of the creator are sock and they are all banned Deletion of Free Republic of Verdis WP:SIGCOV||WP:IS||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20190 4145 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Straight Community User:Last 10:07, 22 December 2005 (UTC) comment Chooserr created it, so it's fairer to say that it's a propaganda vehicle hijacked and turned into a dicdef. Half the reason to delete (apart from a dictionary) is that there's no point in people watching this page to make sure it's maintained as a dicdef and Chooserr doesn't revert it back to being a POV vehicle Deletion of Straight Community WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20191 12155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DJ Tilt User:FreeRangeFrog 02:52, 18 February 2009 (UTC) delete I don't think it meets any of the guidelines. Even the interview by CNBC doesn't quite make it up to #1 Deletion of DJ Tilt WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20192 6434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aire Libre Mobile Home Park User:onel5969 21:03, 14 August 2016 (UTC) keep """Per : """"Populated, legally recognized places are typically presumed to be notable, even if their population is very low."""" By definition, the USGS designation is legal recognition of the place. And the USGS listing gives the location the definition of a """"populated place"""". There is nothing, as the nominator claims, in Geoland which says that a populated place which meets the main requirement of Geoland must also show independent notability if it is located within a city/town""" Deletion of Aire Libre Mobile Home Park WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20193 7782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mnawi Basha Hotel User:Grim23 18:12, 15 December 2009 (UTC) delete """Per |Wikipedia is not a Travel guide, """"Wikipedia is not the place to recreate content more suited to entries in hotel or culinary guides""" Deletion of Mnawi Basha Hotel WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20194 16143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lesley Ugochukwu User:HawkAussie 01:09, 5 April 2021 (UTC) delete Fails under for now but if he makes an appearance in the league that isn't just a small substitution than I would re-consider Deletion of Lesley Ugochukwu WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20195 12705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelsely Abaza User:Rhododendrites 14:41, 12 October 2015 (UTC) delete Does not look to be notable (), but at best this is a scenario, with too much questionable or promotional content and almost all of it contributed by sock puppets. &mdash Deletion of Kelsely Abaza WP:GNG||WP:TNT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20196 17289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United States presidential election, 2024 (3rd nomination) User:power 20:21, 28 October 2018 (UTC) merge to United States elections, 2024. The speculation about candidates is and ; I don't think credible sources are willing to make definitive statements about 2024 candidacies until they know who wins the 2020 election. However, there seems to be enough other coverage to have something. After the elections next week, the initial 2024 Senate map will be set, and there will be enough for at least one article on the 2024 US elections; that first article should be United States elections, 2024 Deletion of United States presidential election, 2024 (3rd nomination) WP:CRYSTAL||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20197 18518 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hilal Ahmed Rather User:Necrothesp 13:34, 13 August 2020 (UTC) comment """To quote from , re personnel of his rank: {{tq| If, for instance, there is enough information in reliable sources to include details about a person's birth, personal life, education and military career, then they most likely warrant a stand-alone article.}} Certainly applies here. I would also note that, despite """"only"""" being an essay, is listed on Wikipedia:Notability (people) under the header note: {{tq|People are likely to be notable if they meet any of the following standards.}} It is therefore clear that, despite the comments above that he does not, Rather rather easily meets our criteria for inclusion. I would also reiterate that two of the """"delete"""" !votes completely ignore the fact that he is an air commodore and only focus on the non-notable fact that he may have been the first IAF pilot to fly a particular aircraft""" Deletion of Hilal Ahmed Rather WP:SOLDIER||WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
20198 7134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ines Crnokrak User:Whpq 21:40, 20 April 2009 (UTC) delete she is verifiably working as a model, but there is no coverage about her aside from the one from NY News network which is rather insubstantial. Some quotes in http://women.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/women/beauty/article732198.ece, and http://moda.gazeta.pl/moda/1,77803,4940676.html but taken altogether, it does not add up to enough to meet notability. The sad state of other articles on models has |no relevance to this AFD Deletion of Ines Crnokrak WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20199 4600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Event symmetry User:XOR 18:45, 5 April 2021 (UTC) delete My PROD rationale was {{tq|With the original publication getting only 11 citations in 25 years, even by the permissive standards of Google Scholar (counting unpublished items and self-citations), this is not a notable physics idea. throughout.}} I thought at the time that that was an understatement; the nomination goes into more detail Deletion of Event symmetry WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
20200 6547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bagdasarian Productions User:HighKing 15:04, 28 January 2017 (UTC) delete Article is essentially a duplicate of Alvin and the Chipmunks. This topic fails and as notability is not inherited so a redirect is not appropriate Deletion of Bagdasarian Productions WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20201 13218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Kayatta User:Robofish 01:54, 2 February 2010 (UTC) delete the coverage of him appears to be fairly trivial. Significant coverage in reliable sources is required for , and I don't think he has it Deletion of George Kayatta WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20202 6394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of films featuring home invasions User:IllaZilla 16:57, 25 November 2012 (UTC) delete per nom & above comment. Seems to be |listcruft Deletion of List of films featuring home invasions WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
20203 8650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deputy High Commission of Sri Lanka, Chennai User:Anupmehra 11:48, 6 January 2015 (UTC) keep It may not have the highest authority and high commission situation at Delhi may be the final decision-making body, but it is not a |valid criteria for deletion. It appears to have been written in detail in multiple |secondary, |independent and |reliable sources (sources provided above by User:NorthAmerica1000, see also -http://searchindiannews.in/#gsc.tab=0&gsc.q=%22Deputy%20High%20Commission%20of%20Sri%20Lanka%22&gsc.sort=), therefore it does meet the |required standard and merits a Wikipedia article Deletion of Deputy High Commission of Sri Lanka, Chennai WP:BEFORE||WP:SECONDARY||WP:3PARTY||WP:RS||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20204 21414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American-led intervention in Iraq User:Kudzu1 03:17, 30 September 2014 (UTC) keep """Article was proposed https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:2014_military_intervention_against_ISIS&diff=627322201&oldid=627321734 before temporary semi-protection was https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=2014_military_intervention_against_ISIS&diff=627373409&oldid=627367180 instated on 2014 military intervention against ISIS. Article does not meet definition, but is rather clearly a . Consensus clearly existed for an article focusing on the Iraqi theater of this notable, significant, and complex conflict, as evidenced on Talk:2014 military intervention against ISIS in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:2014_military_intervention_against_ISIS#An_article_for_intervention_in_Iraq.3F this thread and Talk:American-led intervention in Syria in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:American-led_intervention_in_Syria#Remove_the_word_.22coalition.22_from_the_title.3F this thread. Nominator's objections are rooted in a discussion that has little to nothing to do with the manner of the article's creation and is being addressed through more appropriate channels already, via Talk:American-led intervention in Iraq#Systemic_Bias. Nominator has hereto failed to raise objections, whether policy-based or entirely subjective, to the content that exists on American-led intervention in Iraq and https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:American-led_intervention_in_Iraq&diff=627624703&oldid=627624689 made clear his belief that a new article title would be a """"good compromise"""" in his eyes. In conclusion, the evidence does not support nominator's contention that this article was created improperly, and other avenues exist to resolve nominator's objections to the article title and scope""" Deletion of American-led intervention in Iraq WP:POVFORK||WP:SPINOFF Wikipedia:Content forking 33
20205 8155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Johnstone (darts player) User:Walwal20 18:38, 7 October 2020 (UTC) delete fails way too much. Playing an international competition indeed leads to a Rebuttable presumption|presumption of notability, but this presumption is clearly rebutted once you search for coverage on the subject Deletion of Peter Johnstone (darts player) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20206 21888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/City of Shoulders and Noses User:Accounting4Taste 22:27, 24 October 2007 (UTC) delete Films that are not even in production yet don't come close to meeting , but I'm delighted to know that Sybil Danning is still getting work, even though shoulders and noses are not the body parts for which she's best known Deletion of City of Shoulders and Noses WP:MOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20207 11025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Perfect Murder (R.I.A.M) User:Doomsdayer520 22:08, 25 January 2018 (UTC) delete or '''Redirect''' to Sutter Kain. Album appears to be local and self-released with no evidence of being noticed enough to achieve |notability Deletion of A Perfect Murder (R.I.A.M) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20208 502 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Proposed United States purchase of Greenland User:TJRC 23:24, 16 August 2019 (UTC) keep At first blush, this looks like , as WilliamJE says. But really, even ignoring the current claim, the 1867 and 1946 proposals are sufficient to make this notable. They are interesting, worthy of historical study, well-documented, and covered in multiple reliable sources. In short, it's a great candidate for an article. We'll need to be careful that it isn't used to coat-rack in Trump ridicule, but that's an entirely different question. The fact that it's only coming to light as a ''result'' of the Trump thing does not disqualify it from being as a notable and article-worthy subject Deletion of Proposed United States purchase of Greenland WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
20209 15091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antigua honeymoon murders User:Brewcrewer 01:15, 13 August 2008 (UTC) comment This afd epitomizes that is all about. These murders has a major effect on the Antiguan society. Because of ''this'' murder, there have been legislative attempts to overhaul and revamp police powers. In addition, it has renewed the always controversial death penalty debate. These ''facts'' are well-sourced in the article. Nonetheless, since it doesn't have a great societal effect on English society, editors consider it of no importance Deletion of Antigua honeymoon murders WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
20210 17372 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Wright (music producer) User:Cunard 01:17, 3 August 2010 (UTC) delete per {{user|J04n}}. Because this |biography of a living person has not received the nontrivial coverage required to satisfy Wikipedia:Notability (people) and Wikipedia:Verifiability, this article should be deleted Deletion of James Wright (music producer) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20211 8014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparisons between the Women's United Soccer Association, Women's Professional Soccer, and National Women's Soccer League User:Joseph2302 12:11, 5 July 2020 (UTC) delete """anything starting """"Comparison of"""" is inevitably going to be |original research. None of the sources so far as I can see are actually comparing the two""" Deletion of Comparisons between the Women's United Soccer Association, Women's Professional Soccer, and National Women's Soccer League WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
20212 21349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Logic of Half a Moustache User:Rankiri 13:45, 8 April 2010 (UTC) delete Both the book and its author don't seem to meet the respective notability guidelines (, ). The above review by :Mahmud Khan's hometown newspaper is insufficient. Where exactly is the other review Deletion of The Logic of Half a Moustache WP:BK||WP:AUTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
20213 16146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Veda Shook User:Kuyabribri 21:00, 13 February 2013 (UTC) delete Actually one of the sources currently on the article ''does'' mention her, but only to quote her, and only one sentence. There is plenty of coverage on her and I managed to find http://nwlaborpress.org/2011/01/afa/ one decent source, but the overwhelming majority of sources I found are: 1) published by her, 2) business directory and/or social media sites, 3) published by the Association of Flight Attendants or its parent organization, the Communications Workers of America and therefore not truly independent of the subject, or 4) only mention her in passing or quote her, which is expected given her position. She does not |inherit notability from the union or her position in it, and based on what I said above I don't see |significant coverage in reliable, independent sources. &mdash Deletion of Veda Shook WP:INHERITED||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20214 15678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Red Dwarf DVD Easter Eggs User:Tx17777 15:52, 20 October 2007 (UTC) delete wikipedia is not an #INFO|indiscriminate collection of trivial information Deletion of Red Dwarf DVD Easter Eggs WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20215 16707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muse fans' boycott User:Whpq 16:34, 8 April 2011 (UTC) delete This is Wikipedia |not Wikinews Deletion of Muse fans' boycott WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20216 4657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Safdar Hussain User:Edison 15:30, 27 May 2011 (UTC) delete """The references do not satisfy the need tor significant coverage in multiple reliable and independent sources needed to satisfy and , the standards for notability for bio articles in Wikipedia.There are two citations to a broken link (article not found) from the local police department, which might not be considered """"independent"""" and a link to some webpage related to some mall, which not only does not mention him, but which would not be considered a """"reliable source"""" for biographical information about historical figures. There is mention of a book, but no bibliographical information which would allow one to decide if it is a reliable and independent source. Lots of laudatory assertions made here by Wikipedia editors are not at all effective in establishing notability. Were there other books, newspapers and magazine articles from independent and reliable sources""" Deletion of Safdar Hussain WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20217 16821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven O'Brien User:Evb 02:38, 15 June 2007 (UTC) delete """per nom. Also, these and '''Motron Software|the """"company"""" page''' are |PR vanispam masquerading as articles""" Deletion of Steven O'Brien WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
20218 5478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Antone Belt User:Kolma8 18:17, 4 December 2020 (UTC) delete lacks and little media coverage Deletion of Antone Belt WP:NTRACK Wikipedia:Notability 77
20219 21681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Joseph Phillips User:Fuhghettaboutit 16:06, 11 March 2007 (UTC) delete No relevant Google hits for the author http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&safe=off&q=%22Mark+Joseph+Phillips%22&btnG=Search, and none at Worldcat for a few of the 10 novels he has purportedly written (but never states are published) that I checked (Robot World=0http://www.worldcat.org/search?qt=worldcat_org&q=Robot+World+&submit=Search; Terminal Writer=0http://www.worldcat.org/search?qt=worldcat_org&q=Terminal+Writer+&submit=Search) and his geocities page listed in the article is just as vague in asserting authorship but not listing anything which substantiates actual publication. Thus, nothing here showing he meets Deletion of Mark Joseph Phillips WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20220 16435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chandre Dharma-wardana User:Deiz 02:20, 17 March 2006 (UTC) delete current article does not assert compliance with or professor test Deletion of Chandre Dharma-wardana WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20221 627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harry P. Gamble User:Ejgreen77 03:35, 4 February 2015 (UTC) comment First of all, I am not an expert on this era of college football, at all. But, the inbox for this guy states that he was an College Football All-Southern Team|All-Southern selection in 1926. Based on Wikipedia talk:WikiProject College football/Archive 14#Category:All-Southern_college_football_players|this prior discussion, it appears that during the era this guy played, being an All-Southern selection was the historical equivalent of being named an All-American. If that's true, wouldn't that then qualify to meet Deletion of Harry P. Gamble WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
20222 8919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aliakbar Campwala User:Ab207 13:19, 10 June 2021 (UTC) delete Does not meet NACTOR or NCREATIVE. Sources lacks Deletion of Aliakbar Campwala WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
20223 6099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amanda Carpenter (second nomination) User:Deiz 02:10, 23 December 2006 (UTC) delete fails / . Would reassess if worked on Deletion of Amanda Carpenter (second nomination) WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20224 14691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shea McKeen User:Ejgreen77 07:05, 24 January 2020 (UTC) delete Fails , , , and Deletion of Shea McKeen WP:GNG||WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:NCOLLATH||WP:CRIMINAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20225 19509 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Universal Soul (3rd nomination) User:Hunterm267 16:18, 17 July 2018 (UTC) delete mostly per nom. Little-to-no references found in a google search; article has 5 citations, 4 of which are YouTube videos, 1 of which is an expired/archived link. Subject fails Deletion of Universal Soul (3rd nomination) WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20226 426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adenike Fajemirokun User:Lonehexagon 08:45, 28 February 2018 (UTC) comment """This article doesn't need to pass because it already satisfies . The topic """"has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject""" Deletion of Adenike Fajemirokun WP:NBUSINESSPEOPLE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20227 7597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Massimo Carello [[User talk:Serial Number 54129|'''S'''erial]] 16:26, 28 August 2020 (UTC) delete Effectively |a resumé; we are |not LinkedIn. Special:contributions/Serial Number 54129 Deletion of Massimo Carello WP:NOTCV||WP:NOTLINKEDIN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20228 8135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Intersex rights in India User:D4iNa4 21:38, 20 December 2017 (UTC) delete already described on LGBT rights in India, not just on Hijra (South Asia)|Hijra. LGBTQI|LGBT itself covers concepts of Lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer and intersex. We should really don't expect creation of |POV forks like Eunuchs rights in India, Transgender rights in India, Lesbian rights in India, Bisexual rights in India, Queer rights in India. This article is factually incorrect and made in violation of Deletion of Intersex rights in India WP:POVFORKS||WP:CONTENTFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
20229 19800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neon Knights (band) User:Michig 20:41, 6 May 2011 (UTC) delete No criterion of is met. No significant coverage found in reliable sources Deletion of Neon Knights (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20230 14520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Troy Garrod User:Kinu 06:23, 27 September 2010 (UTC) delete no significant coverage in , does not come close to meeting . Pretty apparent article based on the creator Deletion of Troy Garrod WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:COI Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20231 13743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Traditional Indian cricket bat User:Arxiloxos 15:16, 29 September 2011 (UTC) comment I don't claim to be an expert on , but I'm not sure that deletion is appropriate here, because it appears that material from this article has been re-used in cricket bat and thus the edit history of this article needs to be preserved. Assuming that others conclude the present article is no longer needed, redirect may be a better way to go Deletion of Traditional Indian cricket bat WP:ATTRIBUTION Wikipedia:Attribution 108
20232 20971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The immigrant magician User:Robert 22:55, 19 May 2017 (UTC) comment This article was already deleted, on my nomination, once as |advertising, and was promptly re-created. This version differs slightly from the deleted version in that it does not include the link to order the book Deletion of The immigrant magician WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
20233 7954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maia Krall Fry User:Bearian 19:46, 19 July 2010 (UTC) delete This article is |too soon, and has |too many unknowns, and although |she's up and coming, she is not yet |there Deletion of Maia Krall Fry WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER||WP:UPANDCOMING||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20234 15986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greece–Jamaica relations User:Atmoz 20:27, 4 March 2009 (UTC) delete The threshold for inclusion in Wikipedia is verifiability, not truth. No third-party sources, fails Deletion of Greece–Jamaica relations WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20235 17271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kathy Keller User:Qasaur 22:29, 14 June 2015 (UTC) delete After searching Google for the author, I can't seem to find any proper sources that indicate that the author is notable in any way, especially when looking at the criteria. I cannot find any reviews either, professional or amateur ones (Goodreads, Amazon, etc.). I don't think that this article meets the standards laid out in the notability criteria Deletion of Kathy Keller WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20236 14349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aturaparijnana User:Deacon 02:42, 29 July 2017 (UTC) delete I'm reaffirming my delete !vote after the updates to the article by Anoptimistix. Even after the updates, I {{em|still}} can't tell what the article is actually about. But more importantly, the article still doesn't demonstrate the topic's notability as the only two mentions are from extremely unrealiable sources. There isn't even enough information or notability to merge as was also suggested above. This is a fringe idea within a topic, but the article doesn't treat it as such. There's simply nothing here to salvage; the article should just be deleted Deletion of Aturaparijnana WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
20237 19043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dress Like a Woman User:Bearian 14:45, 3 March 2017 (UTC) merge to Implicit stereotype for now, per |the standard result. It exists as a meme, and might continue, but this is an unsourced essay Deletion of Dress Like a Woman WP:CHEAP Wikipedia:Redirects are cheap 69
20238 17832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baris Ince User:HisSpaceResearch 14:38, 1 February 2008 (UTC) delete per nom and , , Deletion of Baris Ince WP:BIO||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
20239 9521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kathie-Ann Joseph (2nd nomination) User:Horse 08:24, 7 May 2019 (UTC) keep because it passes |NACADEMIC, also it seems all the reasons for nomination have been fixed in the interim Deletion of Kathie-Ann Joseph (2nd nomination) WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20240 19700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Jarman User:Alex 10:13, 9 October 2019 (UTC) keep Meets for the roles he has had in some major productions Deletion of Chris Jarman WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
20241 15247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Philip Gale User:Jayen466 02:09, 9 January 2011 (UTC) delete To actually make the article NPOV would require adding further material which, although reported at the time (see Talk:Death_of_Philip_Gale#Major_coatrack_and_NPOV_issues), I don't have the heart to add. Basically the article was written under the premise that Scientology was to blame; given that all those who were closest to Gale said that was nonsense, what is left is no more notable than other college suicides for which coverage could be found, but which haven't made it into our pages. Deletion of Death of Philip Gale WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20242 13841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Secret Archives of the Vatican User:Mattg82 19:59, 27 January 2020 (UTC) delete No |indication of importance, even https://www.allmusic.com/artist/secret-archives-of-the-vatican-mn0000319474 their Allmusic page is rather empty. The BBC Asian radio ref looks interesting until it shows they only played one song. There may have been interviewed in the program as well but I don't think this classes as anything much and it appears there is no other |significant coverage Deletion of Secret Archives of the Vatican WP:BAND||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
20243 5455 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Pamphile User:Ejgreen77 21:25, 22 June 2014 (UTC) keep All of the nominations by this particular nominator appear to be based on a misunderstanding of how and work together. trumps all other WikiProject-specific notability guidelines Deletion of Kevin Pamphile WP:GNG||WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20244 7637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Durham Flames User:Bettia 10:57, 3 July 2012 (UTC) keep the additional sources means that article probably meets the |general notability guideline Deletion of Durham Flames WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20245 14940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rugby AM User:onel5969 13:52, 13 September 2015 (UTC) delete searches showed nothing to meet Deletion of Rugby AM WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20246 8635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Penkyampji User:Piotrus 06:46, 22 March 2017 (UTC) delete Seems like a hoax/OR, and fails . No mentions of the term in Google Books/Scholar. It is remotely possible it is based on some Chinese scholarly works that could lend it notability, but they are certainly not cited Deletion of Penkyampji WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20247 7981 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grover Furr User:Bastique 01:43, 5 September 2014 (UTC) delete per the nom. Given and the lack of meeting the criteria of , I see no reason Furr's article should remain Deletion of Grover Furr WP:BLP||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20248 20304 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Researchers questioning the official account of 9/11 User:Stifle 11:52, 26 April 2006 (UTC) keep but please make sure to keep it |verifiable and avoid |original research Deletion of Researchers questioning the official account of 9/11 WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20249 9242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minhaj al-karamah User:Sam 22:21, 20 November 2015 (UTC) keep Snow}}. I have added a couple of {{tl|cite book}}s, there are hundreds in English and G*d knows how many in Arabic. {{Ping|Lfstevens}} is mandatory, nominating an article on a ~700 year-old manuscript without looking at the article history or doing a book search is a waste of time Deletion of Minhaj al-karamah WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20250 8263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maximilian Rothenbücher User:GiantSnowman 17:50, 24 July 2016 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Maximilian Rothenbücher WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20251 15638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ingrid Kerma User:LizardJr8 05:03, 31 May 2021 (UTC) delete I am not finding any sources to satisfy or Deletion of Ingrid Kerma WP:ARTIST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20252 15319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qi (programming language) (2nd nomination) User:David 20:14, 6 January 2012 (UTC) delete """The main source for this language, """"Functional Programming in Qi"""" by Tarver, has only been cited once according to Google scholar, by Tarver himself (http://lac.linuxaudio.org/2011/download/Kjetil_Matheussen_PoingImperatif.pdf the other cite listed by GS appears to be a false positive). I also found a trivial mention in the preface of ECOOP'08. That is enough to convince me that this language has not yet had a chance to make a significant impact in theory or in practice, and that the multiple third-party sources with nontrivial coverage required by do not exist. No prejudice against recreation in some future date when this language becomes significantly more popular""" Deletion of Qi (programming language) (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20253 8136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julian Smith (saxophonist) User:I42 13:41, 31 May 2009 (UTC) keep Whilst I disagree with User:Sulfis above (), the X Factor series established a precedent that the top three finalists are sufficiently notable for their own articles Deletion of Julian Smith (saxophonist) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20254 953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Columbia Mall (Missouri) User:VMS 04:42, 4 March 2014 (UTC) keep per . I de|PRODed it because needs to be considered. See a recent mall AfD: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Findlay Village Mall (2nd nomination). Added cites. Needs expanded with infobox, etc Deletion of Columbia Mall (Missouri) WP:OUTCOMES||WP:PROD||WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20255 9975 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Order of Cosmic Engineers User:Stifle 13:25, 12 January 2009 (UTC) delete Doesn't seem to meet now, and saying that it will meet it in the future fails Deletion of The Order of Cosmic Engineers WP:ORG||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20256 3957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juliet Simms User:Oakshade 06:36, 8 January 2012 (UTC) keep The nom's sole argument for deletion is moot as it's no longer an un-sourced BLP violation. The coverage of this person in the sources provided by Northamerica1000 demonstrate easily passing and . Redirecting would be incorrect as the existing content about this person outside of Automatic Loveletter would be off-topic in that article Deletion of Juliet Simms WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20257 11662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Game Drive (company) User:AKS 04:37, 23 November 2016 (UTC) delete Pure Deletion of Game Drive (company) WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
20258 3876 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Masonic Lodges of North Carolina User:Jclemens 19:28, 10 February 2012 (UTC) keep """The nomination statement fundamentally misunderstands ; all """"X in one (geographical location)"""" is not indiscriminate, nor is an exhaustive listing a """"directory"""" in the sense used by #DIR. Sources present seem adequate and authoritative""" Deletion of Masonic Lodges of North Carolina WP:IINFO||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20259 9433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyler Hill (baseball) User:MA 20:26, 30 June 2019 (UTC) delete has succeed so far but thus he has not at least one game in any one of the following active major leagues: Major League Baseball, Nippon Professional Baseball, KBO League, or have participated in a major international competition (such as the World Baseball Classic, Baseball World Cup or Olympics) as a member of a national team Deletion of Tyler Hill (baseball) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20260 12760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Man of the Year (album) (2nd nomination) User:Horizonlove 02:58, 4 March 2019 (UTC) delete """First off, it looks unfinished. If that's the case, this page should not have been started until there was more information available. Whoever the creator of the page was, should have did a rough draft. A lot of mandatory contents are missing from this article including track listing, cover art, a release date (not a release year), chart information, etc. One line from the article reads """"Man of the Year consists of two tracks, Twerk it and Give it to me"""". If that's the case, this is ''not an album'' but a single, an ''extended play'' at best considering that the project title is different from any song in the track list. Unless this is quickly rectified in the article, it fails and it would also fail . Also the Rhapsody link is a dead page""" Deletion of Man of the Year (album) (2nd nomination) WP:NALBUM||WP:NSINGLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20261 20216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miss Exotic World Pageant User:onel5969 12:59, 23 April 2018 (UTC) keep Not only the references currently in the article, but coverage in the ''San Bernadino Sun'', ''New York Daily News'', ''The Daily Telegraph'', ''Slate'', ''CBS News'' would indicate it clearly passes . Not to mention discussion in quite a few books, such as ''Burlesque In a Nutshell - Girls, Gimmicks & Gags'', ''The League of Exotic Dancers: Legends from American Burlesque'', ''Burlesque and the New Bump-n-grind'', and ''Strip City: A Stripper's Farewell Journey Across America'', to name a few Deletion of Miss Exotic World Pageant WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20262 9287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Helmes AS User:Jauerback 15:24, 21 August 2017 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Helmes AS WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20263 781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Undone by Blood User:KylieTastic 17:10, 28 November 2020 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON fails Deletion of Undone by Blood WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20264 17028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fatal dog attacks in the United States User:Jacobm 03:55, 15 September 2020 (UTC) comment I was asked to chime in (vote) on this AFD discussion but I will abstain since I'm not an expert on the policies or rules that govern deletions. However, I'll point out that per : {{tq|Consensus is not based on a tally of votes, but on reasonable, logical, policy-based arguments.}}. So as I understand this one part of the Wiki deletion policy, the outcome of this AFD nomination should be based on Wiki policy and less on total votes. Thanks Deletion of List of fatal dog attacks in the United States WP:AFD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20265 82 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hayri Baraçlı Kullanıcı:sarvsarv 17.10, 31 Temmuz 2022 (UTC) keep hem Akademisyen olarak 138 atıfta bulunulmuştur. Ödülleri vardır ayrıca başlığındaki 1. 2. ve 4. kriterini karşılamaktadır. Zaten 2019 İstanbul yerel seçimlerinin yenilenmesi süreci bile tek başına sırf İstanbul'da değil Türkiye'de tanınırlığına vesile olmuştur Hayri Baraçlı'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
20266 17596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of English medium Primary schools in Ireland User:Mh29255 00:50, 27 December 2007 (UTC) delete non-notable list per . Primary schools are not generally regarded as being notable Deletion of List of English medium Primary schools in Ireland WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20267 9897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellex Medical Lasers User:Bearian 02:34, 23 July 2020 (UTC) delete per above; also , , , and . It is written as a resume, not an article. The unusual history of SPA editing indicates it might be spam; |I can't assume good faith when it's so in your face. Even if we were to overlook that, it just seems not to pass as a notable business. It would need a total laser-focused (pardon the pun) re-do in order to be an article Deletion of Ellex Medical Lasers WP:NOTRESUME||WP:SPAM||WP:NCORP||WP:TNT||WP:AGF Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20268 9530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Shankbone User:Cyclopia 01:47, 25 October 2009 (UTC) keep Seems absolutely notable under every interpretation of Deletion of David Shankbone WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20269 316 [[Oberreichenbach (Großhabersdorf)]] (LAE nach Ausbau) Benutzer:Triebtäter (MMX) 19:47, 1. Jun. 2010 (CEST) delete Nachdem eine Benutzer:Septembermorgen initiierte Wikipedia_Diskussion:WikiProjekt_Kommunen_und_Landkreise_in_Deutschland#Wie_umgehen_mit_Weiterleitungen_f.C3.BCr_Ortsteile_auf_Gemeindeartikel|Diskussion zum Thema Weiterleitungen keinen Konsens brachte, löschte er vor einigen Tagen im Alleingang eine ganze Reihe dieser Weiterleitungen ohne Grundlage. Nach Wiederherstellung per Löschprüfung sind . Zudem ist allgemeine Wikipedia-Politik (diese Weiterleitungen waren vor einigen Jahren durchaus erwünscht und wurden systematisch angelegt) per #Nicht akzeptierte Löschbegründungen #1 ausdrücklich von der Klärung per Löschdiskussion ausgeschlossen Löschung von Oberreichenbach (Großhabersdorf) Wikipedia:LR Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20270 9127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cubone User:onel5969 16:50, 24 June 2021 (UTC) merge restore as previous. Coverage is all not significant enough to pass Deletion of Cubone WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20271 15025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2004 Summer Olympics medals count by International Organization (second nomination) User:Aagtbdfoua 20:04, 15 January 2007 (UTC) delete per nom, unless shown to not be |original research Deletion of 2004 Summer Olympics medals count by International Organization (second nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
20272 1212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AnaSpec User:A 05:04, 16 December 2008 (UTC) comment Please note that the company is covered substantially and not trivially or incidentally in multiple independent sources that are cited in the article's References section. I don't know about you, but in my book that passes Deletion of AnaSpec WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20273 5978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Controversies related to prevalence of Jews in leadership roles in Hollywood User:Frmatt 18:19, 20 October 2009 (UTC) comment As the nominator of this article, I feel some need to speak up a bit about the reasons why it was nominated. As I said in the original nomination, it appeared to have some significant sourcing issues as the article at that time mainly consisted of excerpts from other WP articles, and had the appearance of making significant claims of anti-semitism without properly sourcing or criticizing them. Of the sources listed, both the Haaertz and the Joel Stein columns appear to be somewhat satirical, and not as factual as other sources might be. Nowhere did I ever list as a reason for this AfD, and I don't believe that it applies here. As for Noleander's second question, I don't know. It should be noted that this AfD stemmed from an Wikipedia:Administrators%27_noticeboard/Incidents#user:Noleander_and_antisemitism-related_articles|ANI entry where an accusation of anti-semitism was brought against a user and I brought the conversation over here so that the conversation would focus on the article instead of the user Deletion of Controversies related to prevalence of Jews in leadership roles in Hollywood WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
20274 11196 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tarquine Iquar User:Themfromspace 07:55, 25 July 2009 (UTC) delete Not sure where the editors above are suggesting we should merge this to, as the series' article redirects to the author. A merge/redirect to a character list would be acceptable, if one existed. Anyway, this article fails our notability guidelines as the character hasn't been the subject of significant coverage in reliable, third-party sources. The content within this article fails two of our core content policies as it contains no sources for |verification and reads like |original research Deletion of Tarquine Iquar WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20275 12516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B. Alan Bourgeois User:Mrmewe 04:45, 10 May 2011 (UTC) delete Does not demonstrate |notability Deletion of B. Alan Bourgeois WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20276 5386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pamela Pendley Biggers User:Ironholds 05:55, 25 September 2009 (UTC) delete fails #NEWS and Deletion of Pamela Pendley Biggers WP:NOT||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20277 18928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eladio Ramirez User:Joe 14:00, 27 November 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Eladio Ramirez WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20278 17010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IQcuties User:Tree 03:58, 30 June 2006 (UTC) delete per . No Alexa ranking http://www.alexa.com/data/details/main?q=http%3A%2F%2Fiqcuties.com%2F&url=iqcuties.com Deletion of IQcuties WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20279 16475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aapne Toh Chhie Bindaas User:Spiderone 22:31, 22 July 2020 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Aapne Toh Chhie Bindaas WP:NFILM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20280 5452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mobispine User:Ifnord 05:14, 22 November 2018 (UTC) delete per nom for failing . There's no claim to notability in the article Deletion of Mobispine WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20281 12962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Global Online Gaming User:Starblind 15:55, 2 July 2007 (UTC) delete per . It's on a free web host, come on. Not even remotely notable Deletion of Global Online Gaming WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20282 15220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roy St. Clair (3rd nomination) User:Isotope23 18:09, 5 June 2006 (UTC) keep in this case I agree with RGTraynor, CCG major competative players are as notable as any other competitive game players. Particularly in this case, you have a player who was fairly highly ranked but was banned for cheating. Within the realm of CCG I imagine this is probably the equivalent to a baseball player getting caught using steroids (OK, maybe not... the baseball player wouldn't get banned from the game). Regardless, could be construed to include notable competative game players under notable sportspeople (hey, if Golf|walking around swiping at a little white ball with metal stick is a sport, then cards are too Deletion of Roy St. Clair (3rd nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20283 9031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Curse of Mike Hart User:Strikehold 22:59, 10 October 2010 (UTC) merge with a redirect) to Mike Hart and/or Paul Bunyan Trophy. There are quite a few Google hits, but virtually all of the ones in |reliable sources are only excerpts of the http://thequad.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/10/09/the-curse-of-mike-hart/ New York Times blog post. The only other source I found that makes prominent use of the term is from http://theoaklandpress.com/articles/2010/10/09/sports/columns/doc4cb1167072e92473029364.txt The Oakland (Michigan) Press, and even then, it's only mentioned in the title and once in the text. Unless other sources can be found, I think notability has yet to be established Deletion of Curse of Mike Hart WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20284 7875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JioMeet user:DMySon 13:21, 1 July 2020 (UTC) delete do not show significant coverage (not just passing mentions) about the subject in published, reliable, secondary sources that are independent of the subject. Fails Deletion of JioMeet WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20285 12049 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aline Cumming User:Margin1522 18:20, 10 January 2015 (UTC) delete """Keep Delete Keep – http://archive.cra.org/CRN/articles/may02/cumming.html This cite shows that she was Executive Officer in 2002. I added it and edited the article to make clear that she is one of 15 co-editors. That doesn't quite qualify under #C8, which wants a """"head or chief editor"""". So that leaves #C6, for Executive Officer, which would depend on whether the CPHC is a """"major academic institution or major academic society"""". I don't know, but the earlier cite as of 2002 said that """"There are 106 departments in the UK that are eligible to join CPHC, and 103 of them belong."""" so maybe it qualifies. – """ Deletion of Aline Cumming WP:NACADEMICS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20286 797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bert Hatten User:SportingFlyer 04:51, 1 May 2018 (UTC) delete there was a lot there to sort through. Does not pass and . Possibly also fails Deletion of Bert Hatten WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
20287 20636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cody Bollinger User:CaSJer 22:42, 28 March 2013 (UTC) delete only one top tier fight, so he fails , and I'm not seeing enough coverage to pass Deletion of Cody Bollinger WP:NMMA||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20288 21053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 Olympics curse User:Irn 17:52, 30 April 2016 (UTC) comment I think it needs to be noted that presents more stringent criteria than for events precisely because so many events easily meet the GNG. An argument to keep the article must, therefore, explain how the article meets the criteria of and not merely Deletion of 2012 Olympics curse WP:EVENT||WP:GNG||WP:EVENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20289 14796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Planet Bowl User:1292simon 11:10, 7 January 2013 (UTC) delete I believe applies re the 2015 games. As for the fundraising reference, the coverage is a local media article, which is not enough to establish notability Deletion of Planet Bowl WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20290 12047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bristol Arena User:Gene93k 07:03, 10 December 2008 (UTC) delete A local building project that never materialized. Sustained multiple RS interest is not apparent. If the project hadn't been canceled, it would have also failed Deletion of Bristol Arena WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20291 8748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Target Travel (2nd nomination) User:HighKing 21:00, 2 March 2021 (UTC) delete """The criteria for establishing notability for companies/organizations as per is for multiple sources (at least two) of deep or significant coverage with |in-depth information *on the company* and (this bit is important!) containing |""""Independent Content"""". """"Independent content"""", in order to count towards establishing notability, must include ''original and independent opinion, analysis, investigation, and fact checking that are clearly attributable to a source unaffiliated to the subject''. None of the references in the article meet the criteria and having searched I am unable to locate any references that meet the criteria. Topic fails """ Deletion of Target Travel (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20292 4131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Article (company) User:HighKing 15:00, 22 December 2017 (UTC) delete References fail the criteria for establishing notability, fails GNG and Deletion of Article (company) WP:ORGIND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20293 16354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joyce Kozloff User:Gobonobo 01:26, 16 January 2014 (UTC) keep The sources provided in the article are sufficient to establish notability. Kozloff is featured prominently in ''The Female Gaze'', a book that I will add to the references. She meets as her body of work has been the subject of multiple independent periodical articles and reviews. The concerns laid out in the nomination are surmountable. Any close paraphrasing can be corrected without resorting to deletion of the article Deletion of Joyce Kozloff WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
20294 20862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Public weal User:Cybercobra 21:04, 24 August 2009 (UTC) keep This DAB seems perfectly reasonable; disams get to skirt |DICDEF a bit and this doesn't seem like a particularly bad or unreasonable case Deletion of Public weal WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
20295 12873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saoud al-Daweesh User:JzG 09:13, 21 November 2017 (UTC) delete """per . The so-called """"crackdown"""" looks very much like an attempt to silence potential dissent or opposition, this may receive more coverage later but for now there's nothing on which to build a stand-alone biography""" Deletion of Saoud al-Daweesh WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20296 9865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryan Berghoef User:Edge3 17:55, 29 August 2021 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Bryan Berghoef WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20297 7615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syed Ali Miran Al Naqvi User:CNMall41 21:11, 9 September 2019 (UTC) delete Absolutely delete as there are no references that meet Deletion of Syed Ali Miran Al Naqvi WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20298 18637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haelyn Shastri [[User talk:Usernamekiran|'''(talk)''']] 18:41, 22 September 2019 (UTC) delete the subject fails , and , as I could not find wp:sigcov|significant coverage in reliable sources. —usernamekiran Deletion of Haelyn Shastri WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20299 10517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gil Student (2nd nomination) User:TenPoundHammer 06:56, 22 November 2007 (UTC) delete per previous AfD's, no notability asserted. Only hits fail Deletion of Gil Student (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20300 10087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Say Ahh: A Film About Fighting The World’s Largest Cavity (the one in our healthcare system) User:MichaelQSchmidt NONE delete for failing to meet . This film premiered on http://www.sayahhthemovie.com/ June 13, 2013 but has not received coverage, analysis, or coverage in any reliable sources. IF IT EVER DOES, then issues with tone ''might'' be addressable. Until then, this fails inclusion criteria Deletion of Say Ahh: A Film About Fighting The World’s Largest Cavity (the one in our healthcare system) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20301 12282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anything and Whatever User:Glane23 21:18, 29 September 2016 (UTC) keep The drinks may be notable more for the marketing/advertising concept than the products themselves. Few good sources, but a lot of blog mentions. However, they earned a page in a book on the marketing technique of not identifying which flavours were in which cans of soda. ''Pow! Right Between the Eyes: Profiting from the Power of Surprise'' (2009); Andy Nulman; John Wiley & Sons; {{ISBN|9780470443842}}; Page 38 - https://books.google.com/books?id=iepRGryywNwC&pg=PA36&dq=%22Anything+and+Whatever%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj68K76u7XPAhVIQiYKHWmTBAMQ6AEIKTAC#v=onepage&q=%22Anything%20and%20Whatever%22&f=false here. But I did not find more mentions beyond blogs, so I am torn as to whether the mentions are enough for and/or . Thus the weak keep !vote Deletion of Anything and Whatever WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20302 17434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Cherniak User:NeoJustin NONE delete """per above. Also, the use of the word """"vanity"""" in AFD discussions is now discouraged. Please instead use """"conflict of interest"""" per """ Deletion of Jason Cherniak WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
20303 6791 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Something to Remember (song) User:Esradekan 20:48, 6 December 2008 (UTC) delete as a non-plausible search term, article fails to establish notability as per #Songs Deletion of Something to Remember (song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20304 18443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Lee Thompson Ska Orchestra User:Colapeninsula 16:24, 1 July 2014 (UTC) comment A keep might be justified on the basis of notable members ( #6), but a merge to Lee Thompson (saxophonist) would also be quite sensible Deletion of The Lee Thompson Ska Orchestra WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20305 4636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Treason laws in the United States User:Bearian 02:30, 16 June 2017 (UTC) keep per and Deletion of Treason laws in the United States WP:HEY||WP:ODD Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
20306 5944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big White Tiger LLC User:ResidentAnthropologist 18:17, 14 November 2010 (UTC) delete unable to find multiple RS providing Significant coverage. Thus Failing Deletion of Big White Tiger LLC WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20307 8011 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of most expensive video games to develop User:Mike 22:28, 22 April 2013 (UTC) keep """After a bit more reflection, I'm going to cast a """"Keep"""" vote. The MSN Games article to which I linked above and (probably) at least one or two others among the five sources I listed earlier qualify as reliable. These sources demonstrate that the construction of this type of list is an established, and notable, concept. Added to these sources are others which describe specific games as having one of the most expensive development budgets in the gaming industry (a few of which DoctorKubla already added to the article). Both types of sources permit a well-documented list to be constructed that involves no and satisfies """ Deletion of List of most expensive video games to develop WP:OR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:No original research 65
20308 13470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Person, woman, man, camera, TV User:GenQuest 12:38, 26 July 2020 (UTC) delete More Flotsam and Jetsam|dreck in our pages, per Wikipedia:Fart|Fart, |Not the News, and |Trivia. Can't people tell trivia from whats encyclopedic anymore? Just because some nonsense is covered in news cycles does not mean it's encyclopedic. wp:Notable|Not notable and passing, too Deletion of Person, woman, man, camera, TV WP:NOTNEWS||WP:NOTTRIVIA Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20309 21280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Brewer's Art User:ScottishFinnishRadish 14:36, 3 March 2021 (UTC) keep Looks to pass per Cunard Deletion of The Brewer's Art WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20310 225 [[Liste von Alpenvereinen]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Herzi Pinki 20:33, 19. Jun. 2008 (CEST) keep Damit sollte ein brauchbares Abgrenzungskriterium definiert sein (sowohl inhaltlich, als auch der Relevanz nach). Die Liste wurde inzwischen mehrfach überarbeitet, Flachlandvereine, die nicht nachgewiesenermaßen an den Bergen interessiert sind oder Gegenrecht genießen, wurden aus der Liste entfernt, ebenso nicht eigenständige Sektion (Alpenverein)|Sektionen. Fehler in der Auswahl sprechen wegen der nun definierten Aufnahmekriterien dafür den Verein zu entfernen, oder bei kleinen Vereinen den Link zu entfernen, nicht aber den Artikel zu löschen. Dass Inhalte von Diskussionsseiten als Löschbegründung angeführt werden, halte ich für eine offene und freie Diskussionskultur nicht förderlich und hier auch für irrelevant. Ob http://de.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Alpenverein&redirect=no Alpenverein irgendetwas hergibt, beschreibbar oder sonst was ist, halte ich auch für irrelevant. Ich denke nicht, dass ein REDIRECT über Wohl und Wehe eines verlinkten Artikels entscheiden soll und kann. In diesem Sinne nochmals . ME liegt hier , Fall 1 vor Löschung von Liste von Alpenvereinen Wikipedia:LAE Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
20311 2073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abdullah Sallum Abdullah User:ARoseWolf 13:19, 3 June 2021 (UTC) comment Why is a search coming back with Abdullah Sallu''o''m Abdullah? Perhaps a mispelling? Like with the other AfD, I can't find much on the individual and nothing in-depth. If allows us to keep subjects that you can't find reliable biographical information on beyond two sentences then maybe there is an issue with the way NPOL is written. I digress, that's another issue for another time. Fails , , and pretty much every other guideline surrounding notability but passes so I guess the subject gets a golden ticket Deletion of Abdullah Sallum Abdullah WP:NPOL||WP:GNG||WP:N||WP:V||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20312 15751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stone pelting in India User:Tayi 20:39, 5 May 2020 (UTC) delete per nominator. Does not pass on its own merit as a phenomenon Deletion of Stone pelting in India WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20313 21501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CRC for Spatial Information User:Deus 04:29, 4 January 2021 (UTC) merge to Cooperative Research Centre. This is an obvious |alternative to deletion, I'm not sure why this had to come to AfD Deletion of CRC for Spatial Information WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20314 292 [[Hammer & Michel]] (LAE) Benutzer:Havelbaude 11:26, 28. Apr. 2014 (CEST) delete Albumartikel, der nur aus einer Trackliste besteht. 7 Tage zum Ausbau i.S.v. #Musikalben oder Löschung von Hammer & Michel Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
20315 12848 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of games using Steam authentication User:Sergecross73 20:18, 3 May 2017 (UTC) delete per nomination. I also feel there'd be a issue - as I don't think this is something frequently covered in third party reliable sources. (And if all verification is coming from first party accounts, then we're right back at - why even document this? Just check Steam itself Deletion of List of games using Steam authentication WP:V||WP:NOTCATALOGUE Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20316 14366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Capell, 11th Earl of Essex User:Necrothesp 10:44, 18 March 2014 (UTC) keep I think I'm coming down on the side of keeping articles on peers or their heirs, whether or not they sit in the House of Lords, as all their predecessors did (and therefore all meet ) and it would be slightly odd and not of value to the project to break the chain of Wikipedia articles Deletion of Paul Capell, 11th Earl of Essex WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20317 1530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OEKC User:WikiDan61 16:50, 15 September 2015 (UTC) delete I'm not finding any |reliable sources about this organization Deletion of OEKC WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20318 8998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brandon Magee User:rmosler2100 22:10, 27 June 2009 (UTC) delete Appears non-notable per and Deletion of Brandon Magee WP:N||WP:ATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
20319 599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ivan Musardo User:Joaquin008 20:40, 3 May 2013 (UTC) delete as fails Deletion of Ivan Musardo WP:NMMA Wikipedia:Notability 77
20320 14242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Preditas Inc User:Bearian 20:33, 18 December 2013 (UTC) delete very new start-up; the coverage is |not significant Deletion of Preditas Inc WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
20321 20783 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barack Obama condolences User:Phantomsteve 22:01, 20 January 2010 (UTC) delete This article serves no purpose in an encyclopedia. Can we expect to see Barack Obama dances with his wife and Barack Obama shakes hands with a world leader soon? I would suggest a closure for this one Deletion of Barack Obama condolences WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
20322 10295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephanie Holmes Didwania User:David 20:56, 6 December 2020 (UTC) delete """WP:TOOSOON. To the analysis above, I would add that her position as """"Harry A. Bigelow Fellow"""" appears to be a postdoctoral research position, neither the kind of fellow that passes #C3 nor the kind of named position that passes #C5""" Deletion of Stephanie Holmes Didwania WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20323 12583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gwen Media User:Billbowery 22:53, 26 September 2009 (UTC) delete As per Deletion of Gwen Media WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20324 17313 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cristian Vogel User:Atlantic306 18:45, 29 July 2016 (UTC) keep passes for notable label releases, also passes . with the reliable sources identified above as well as the allmusic bio which is rs.It would be best if the author can add these sources to the article and any other rs available Deletion of Cristian Vogel WP:MUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20325 21620 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Johnathan Seitler QC User:WikiDan61 17:18, 4 February 2014 (UTC) comment Added duplicate articles Johnathan seitler QC and Jonathan Seitler QC. (Apparently it took the author a few tries to get the spelling of his name correct.) Note that Jonathan Seitler QC is already the subject of rticles for deletion/Johnathan seitler QC|its own AFD. The closing admin is urged to check the status of that AFD upon closure of this one Deletion of Johnathan Seitler QC WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
20326 16596 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 Balkans terrorism plot User:IsaacSt 23:47, 22 March 2017 (UTC) keep Though the article itself looks like a poor stub to me (I'll tag it), this was an ultra-high-profile terrorism plot that received coverage in most major international newspapers, and in particular plenty in Israel, Albania, and Kosovo. BTW, according to reliable news reports, a total of 26 (not 18) people were eventually arrested. What makes it even more notable per is the lingering effect on these countries. It included a Jerusalem stadium public screening of the Albania-Israel match, since the travel of Israeli fans to Albania was prohibited after this terrorism plot was discovered Deletion of 2016 Balkans terrorism plot WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20327 17814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doug Lewis (Royal Navy officer) (2nd nomination) User:Necrothesp 16:06, 25 November 2020 (UTC) keep Despite the nominator's spurious claims, he clearly passes both #2 as a commodore Deletion of Doug Lewis (Royal Navy officer) (2nd nomination) WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
20328 15710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Who the F**k Is Justin Bieber User:4meter4 17:55, 14 November 2019 (UTC) keep per . Normally I would say redirect this to a page on the artist due to lack of sourcing, but in the absence of a viable redirect keep is the best option. The song charted so it's notable. Any content not reliably cited should be removed. If it's a stub, it is a stub Deletion of Who the F**k Is Justin Bieber WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20329 3698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avaya Unified Communications Management User:Geek2003 04:02, 17 August 2011 (UTC) keep 15 valid citations with separate authors are cited from within the article establishes and this software has 15 years of history. I found thousands of additional citations within google searches and will add if needed Deletion of Avaya Unified Communications Management WP:NOTABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20330 192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/So Happy I Could Die [[User talk:180.172.239.231|talk]]) 14:53, 2 August 2014 (UTC) comment """The logic of seems rather strange to me. says that a person who is """"part of the enduring historical record"""" will have been written about, in depth, independently in multiple history books on that field, by historians. If the same logic applies to , we will say that person who has been written about, in depth, independently in multiple history books is '''not notable at all''', since '''the only coverage of this person occurs in the context of history of that field'''. Clearly this is not what suggests. states significant coverage '''need not''' be the main topic of the source material. In my own view, whether the '''main topic is the album''' is not important, while the '''volume''' of sourcing is.--Special:Contributions/180.172.239.231|180.172.239.231""" Deletion of So Happy I Could Die WP:NSONG||WP:ANYBIO||WP:ANYBIO||WP:GNG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20331 14109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Petscop (2nd nomination) User:AlessandroTiandelli333 14:55, 25 November 2017 (UTC) keep Has received enough coverage and speculation on its own, passes Deletion of Petscop (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20332 10446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Goatgyan User:AllyD 09:11, 14 May 2017 (UTC) delete An article whose text is setting out the firm's wares, but without a sustainable claim to encyclopaedic notability. Searches are turning up nothing beyond routine listings. Fails , Deletion of Goatgyan :WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20333 21160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Axe manufacturing in Pennsylvania User:Fiachra10003 10:53, 4 November 2017 (UTC) keep While the nominator fairly states that many of the sources are self-published, many others are regional newspapers with a cumulative weight sufficient to meet , assuming that all the sources are fairly cited. More generally, the article subject itself is perfectly encyclopedic Deletion of Axe manufacturing in Pennsylvania WP:SECONDARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
20334 1681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deputy Chairman of the NATO Military Committee User:SemiHypercube 21:28, 3 September 2018 (UTC) merge and protect the redirect to stop it from being recreated. Fails Deletion of Deputy Chairman of the NATO Military Committee WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20335 17862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philanthroteer User:Olaf 18:33, 23 February 2010 (UTC) comment I notice the article's now been tagged for CSD as |G11. I considered that but thought it borderline enough to go for AfD instead: although it is somewhat promotional in tone, I don't think a total rewrite would be required to turn it into a neutral piece. I'll leave it up to the discretion of whichever admin/user wants to deal with it, though Deletion of Philanthroteer WP:G11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
20336 17480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gerry Stahl User:Ajshul 22:04, 17 March 2021 (UTC) keep per David Eppstein. Article needs sourcing, but subject does merit an article based on #C1 Deletion of Gerry Stahl WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20337 17450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Add my work User:JohnCD 17:56, 11 May 2008 (UTC) delete WP:OR|original research, no |references Deletion of Add my work WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20338 21580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammad Hanif Khan User:Rahmatgee 16:49, 3 July 2016 (UTC) keep Page is in accordance to of its sources, It is not problematic as satisfying recommendations. Additionally there are nothing to be considered as objectionable in view of . Write up is also satisfactory to . Page under review has no issues related to . Contribution is covered under URATOR and is part of OIU. Person satisfies and is in accordance to in Urdu language being a saint. Authors refer him as the major source of innovating thought of ''Vision of absolute self of God''. Spiritual chain such Tauheediyah is following his ideology and has its followers around the globe Deletion of Muhammad Hanif Khan WP:V||WP:NOR||WP:C||WP:NPOV||WP:SELFPROMOTE||WP:CURATOR||WP:COIU||WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20339 16128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CJAX Framework User:MountainMan11 20:33, 10 August 2012 (UTC) delete sources do not meet . The article is all over the place structurally Deletion of CJAX Framework WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20340 259 [[Liste deutschsprachiger Science-Fiction-Autorinnen]] (erl.) Benutzer:Superbass NONE keep """Listen """"sollen dazu dienen, in einer kurzen, übersichtlichen Form einen Überblick über ein Thema zu geben."""" () Ich halte Science-Fiction-Autorinnen für ein gut eingrenzbares Thema, kann jedenfalls nicht erkennen, warum sie weniger Thema sind als Liste der badischen Lokomotiven und Triebwagen|badische Lokomotiven oder Liste der Fußball-Pflichtspiele zwischen dem Hamburger SV und Werder Bremen|Fußball-Pflichtspiele zwischen dem Hamburger SV und Werder Bremen. Demnach""" Löschung von Liste deutschsprachiger Science-Fiction-Autorinnen Wikipedia:Listen Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
20341 6833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PRIZ-ONE User:Erechtheus 14:45, 22 September 2006 (UTC) delete When doing the suggested search, I get http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=+%22graffiti+PRIZ%22 one result. This article fails Deletion of PRIZ-ONE WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20342 15920 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kurj Skolia User:Savidan 17:43, 20 July 2009 (UTC) delete not notable in real world, only to plot. and #PLOT. These articles about minor characters from the same series could have been combined Deletion of Kurj Skolia WP:WAF||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
20343 155 [[Bündnis für Ehe und Familie]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Fossa/Bewertung 14:02, 30. Jun. 2008 (CEST) delete """per . Offenbar ist es nichtmal moeglich http://de.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=B%C3%BCndnis_Ehe_und_Familie&diff=next&oldid=47834158 mit einem Quellenbaustein darauf hinweisen, dass dies ein auf Christen-Aktivisten-Quellen aufbauender Reklameartikel ist (siehe auch """"Dr. von der Leyen"""" etc""" Löschung von Bündnis für Ehe und Familie Wikipedia:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
20344 11674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cagayan Heritage Conservation Society User:Superastig 04:33, 5 April 2020 (UTC) keep I found a few articles about the NGO: https://renz15.wordpress.com/2019/09/27/10-interesting-places-visit-stay-tuguegarao/, http://www.cagayan.gov.ph/news/heritage-walk-itinampok-ng-cagayan-museum-at-heritage-conservation-society/ and http://northernforum.net/who-said-cagayano-millennials-cant-revitalize-ibanag-itawes/. I believe those, along with Doncram's link, are reliable enough to make the article close to passing . My vote stands Deletion of Cagayan Heritage Conservation Society WP:NGO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20345 6 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hakan Ergün (3. aday gösterme) """Kullanıcı:evrifaessaevrifaessa""" 12.08, 18 Ağustos 2020 (UTC) comment siz demin Telegram'da direkt olarak maddeye konu kişinin kendisiyle iletişim hâlinde olduğunu söyleyen kişiydiniz sanırım. Siz de hoş geldiniz Vikipedi'ye. Ama yorum yapmadan önce ve VP:MÜZİK sayfalarını okumanızı, ve yorum yaparken kişiyle olan direkt ilişkilerinizden çok kişinin az önce verdiğim iki sayfadaki yönergelere uygun olup olmadığını dikkate alarak yorum yapmanızı rica edeceğim Hakan Ergün (3. aday gösterme) yazısının silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
20346 13558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neg (seduction) User:Movingboxes 05:32, 8 August 2008 (UTC) delete """per . """"To support the use of (or an article about) a particular term we must cite reliable secondary sources such as books and papers about the term—not books and papers that use the term."""" I don't see any of that in the article, and honestly--I'd be pretty astonished if there was anything about it""" Deletion of Neg (seduction) WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
20347 2948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lom Harsh (2nd nomination) User:Nanophosis 17:38, 14 June 2018 (UTC) delete per #G4. The article was recreated by the original creator of the deleted page, and appears to be nearly identical to the deleted version Deletion of Lom Harsh (2nd nomination) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
20348 9955 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of economics topics User:Bearian 01:14, 14 November 2007 (UTC) keep as |a useful and non-duplicative list, per DGG and Mandsford Deletion of List of economics topics WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
20349 20832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tykwani Dublin User:TheSpecialUser 11:16, 4 July 2012 (UTC) delete Again, a article which fails and Deletion of Tykwani Dublin WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20350 18696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Hewson User:Stuartyeates 07:18, 9 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails , we need indepth content about her personally, which I'm not seeing Deletion of Sarah Hewson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20351 3799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pivot Legal Society User:Rhododendrites 01:09, 10 November 2015 (UTC) comment While complaining about Neelix creating a bunch of clean-up work for others in the community, your rapid fire deletion nominations (dozens made within a few minutes of each other that clearly did not follow ) likewise puts a burden on others (it takes time to look for sources). &mdash Deletion of Pivot Legal Society WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20352 9048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russia and Weapons of Mass Destruction in Iraq controversy (2nd nomination) User:Risker 06:19, 10 June 2008 (UTC) delete per Orderinchaos and Irpen. A classic case of and and a few other acronyms that come to mind, but I am too polite to write. Is glad that she will not be penalised for wanting to delete this...ummm...article Deletion of Russia and Weapons of Mass Destruction in Iraq controversy (2nd nomination) WP:SYN||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:No original research 65
20353 12844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Susie Wall User:onel5969 02:59, 25 July 2021 (UTC) delete not enough in-depth coverage to show how they pass Deletion of Susie Wall WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20354 6432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eclectika (festival) User:Sovereign 13:24, 5 September 2015 (UTC) delete the TOI mention is insufficient for this article to meet Deletion of Eclectika (festival) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20355 11306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/V-COM Records User:Lankiveil 13:16, 25 January 2008 (UTC) delete fails both and fairly comprehensively Deletion of V-COM Records WP:MUSIC||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20356 7382 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allegations of Israeli apartheid (6th nomination) User:Shalom 05:41, 26 June 2007 (UTC) keep Pretty much a dictionary violation of . If you don't like the way things are going at the Islam deletion, bring it up over there (that includes Deletion Review if you ever cross that bridge). I'd say you could nominate this article per precedent ''after'' the other one gets deleted, if it does Deletion of Allegations of Israeli apartheid (6th nomination) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
20357 17043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ravindra Venshi User:Pharaoh 18:56, 1 April 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and at best upcoming Deletion of Ravindra Venshi WP:GNG||WP:DIRECTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
20358 17888 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordann Yéyé User:Inter 16:09, 23 October 2018 (UTC) delete clearly fails , and as his champions league match was not between two professional clubs he unfortunately fails as well. Article can always be recreated if and when subject meets said requirements Deletion of Jordann Yéyé WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20359 21373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radha Stirling User:Namkongville 15:15, 16 August 2021 (UTC) keep Per above. Have enough significant coverage to meet Deletion of Radha Stirling WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20360 8812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willie Wilson (businessman) User:Tdl1060 19:58, 3 June 2015 (UTC) keep """Wilson received substantial press coverage in his campaign for Mayor of Chicago and is receiving substantial press coverage in his run for President. Therefore it was not just one single event or """"brief bursts of news coverage"""" as is stated in that illustrate Wilson's notability. Furthermore, Wilson was a serious contender in the race for Mayor of Chicago, and received over 10% of the vote in a 5 way race. Wilson is also notable for his gospel music program on WGN-TV, so his political activities are not his only claim to notability""" Deletion of Willie Wilson (businessman) WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20361 17741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Journal of Healthcare Management User:Alexbrn 17:52, 2 November 2020 (UTC) keep Meets and is a respectable and weighty enough serial to merit an article Deletion of Journal of Healthcare Management WP:NJOURNALS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20362 6175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Witold Gustaw Pawel Maria Czartoryski User:Computerjoe 16:39, 20 March 2006 (UTC) delete next time use Deletion of Witold Gustaw Pawel Maria Czartoryski WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
20363 17885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/22 Cats User:Esradekan 07:00, 7 November 2008 (UTC) delete fails notability per Deletion of 22 Cats WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20364 10158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qualified Zone Academy Bonds User:Dhartung 21:10, 21 February 2008 (UTC) keep these only affect a small number of school districts (due to intentional limitations) but they are notable. Could use a rewrite, and needs to be moved to Qualified Zone Academy Bond per Deletion of Qualified Zone Academy Bonds WP:MOS Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
20365 20679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coláiste na bhFiann User:scope_creep 22:23, 16 April 2013 (UTC) keep Well established, over 40 years, summer school for a slowly dying language. Google books has several entries, 3-6 books and several citations in Google scholar. Satisfies and . The article needs worth, it's really shabby looking. Needs references added for somebody who can speak the language, or perhaps spend time to translate the citations etc Deletion of Coláiste na bhFiann WP:GNG||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20366 12251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert S. Kwok User:Isotope23 20:05, 12 October 2006 (UTC) delete subject does not meet Deletion of Robert S. Kwok WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20367 18599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United Express Flight 3411 User:NickCT 13:32, 12 April 2017 (UTC) keep Some obvious and legitimate concerns here, but at this point, this story has met pretty much any notability guideline we have Deletion of United Express Flight 3411 WP:RECENTISM Wikipedia:Recentism 10
20368 6634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Landon Pigg User:RGTraynor 19:31, 30 July 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. What part of do any of you claim this fellow fulfills? Maybe two weeks from now he might ... and maybe he won't at that. In any event, he does not now fulfill any, and Wikipedia still isn't a crystal ball Deletion of Landon Pigg WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20369 14853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Idato User:Duffbeerforme 07:55, 4 April 2016 (UTC) delete Not |notable. Lacks coverage about him in independent reliable sources Deletion of Michael Idato WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20370 14064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A2z(Interactive); Ltd User:Izno 14:29, 29 November 2017 (UTC) delete per and |notability. Only a single redlinked title is not a good indication this studio will be around at a later date Deletion of A2z(Interactive); Ltd WP:TOOSOON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20371 4686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donnie Hogan User:Edwardx 22:11, 13 December 2016 (UTC) delete Fails . There are insufficient in-depth secondary sources Deletion of Donnie Hogan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20372 1183 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steak Escape (2nd nomination) User:Wm335td 19:45, 4 September 2019 (UTC) keep per AmericanAir88's rationale. This is a notable franchise with multiple locations the article has . https://www.bizjournals.com/columbus/stories/2000/02/07/story4.html Business Journal, and (international) opening http://www.tradearabia.com/news/MISC_230263.html ten outlets in the United Arab Emirates Deletion of Steak Escape (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20373 7301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Save My Soul – Music to Prevent Malaria User:onel5969 02:58, 25 September 2015 (UTC) delete Cannot find anything on the search engines. Fails Deletion of Save My Soul – Music to Prevent Malaria WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20374 2306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arthur J. Williams User:Finnegas 14:44, 1 September 2013 (UTC) keep Agree with views expressed above. Satisfies as a member of the North Carolina General Assembly Deletion of Arthur J. Williams WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20375 5878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paris Hilton energy plan User:Deamon138 15:27, 26 August 2008 (UTC) merge verifiable enough event, but there's no need for a |spinout from the mother article, Paris Hilton, when it's only 42kB Deletion of Paris Hilton energy plan WP:SPINOUT Wikipedia:Article size 51
20376 4416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artificial General Intelligence Research Institute User:Cewbot 00:02, 9 September 2020 (UTC) comment This nomination has had limited participation and falls within the standards set for |lack of quorum. There are no previous AfD discussions, undeletions, or current redirects and no previous PRODs have been located. This nomination may be '''eligible for |soft deletion''' at the end of its 7-day listing Deletion of Artificial General Intelligence Research Institute WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
20377 9208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sand Castles: A Story of Family and Tragedy User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:45, 5 January 2013 (UTC) delete without prejudice as being somewhat |WP:TOOSOON. Article tells us this film is slated for release in Novemner 2013, and while there is some available about this film's production and filming,http://goshennews.com/breakingnews/x1040819803/Writer-actor-returns-to-Goshen-for-film-projecthttp://www.midamericafilmmakers.org/goshen-native-to-film-sand-castles-locally-in-october/http://www.wsbt.com/news/wsbt-film-crew-shoots-movie-in-goshen-20121012,0,222002.storyhttp://www.the-papers.com/OnlineIssue.aspx?pub=thepaper&ed=elkhttp://www.etruth.com/article/20121018/LIFESTYLE/710189983 there is really not enough to qualify this as an exception to . When closer to release, there may likely be enough... but for now, nope. Definitely enough for its current mention in the Jordon Hodges article (where we learn it might be out in early 2014), but not for a separate article Deletion of Sand Castles: A Story of Family and Tragedy WP:NYF||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20378 500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gaël Kakuta (2nd nomination) User:MotorsportPete93 16:38, 7 September 2009 (UTC) keep While he may not be notable yet under , he is still a notable person, even if it is only for one event, the media coverage is significant enough to warrant an article. He is not just another Chelsea youth player. He is more notable than Paul Pogba because the Pogba incident is just an allegation at the moment. Besides, Kakuta's was really the first of its kind - it sets a precedent for punishments and treatment of youngsters in the future. It has lead to discussions of banning transfers of Under-18s. It doesn't really matter what he is notable for, so long as he is notable Deletion of Gaël Kakuta (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20379 50 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PDFescape [[User talk:Feminist|(talk)]] 07:47, 1 May 2021 (UTC) keep Having reviewed three of Cunard's sources, they do not link to the PDFescape website via affiliate links, hence meeting . feminist Deletion of PDFescape WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20380 147 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Akpınar, Bozüyük Kullanıcı:seksen iki yüz kırk beşseksen iki yüz kırk beş / ggt 09.25, 25 Nisan 2021 (UTC) keep Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Pelitözü, Bilecik sayfasında belirttiğim üzere #Kayda_değerlik_genellikle_kalıcıdır|kayda değerlik kalıcıdır. Köylerin otomatik olarak KD olduğunu varsayıyoruz, dolayısıyla köy niteliğindeki bir yerleşim yerinin sırf statüsü değişti diye kayda değerliğinin ortadan kalkması söz konusu olamaz Akpınar, Bozüyük'ün silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
20381 2499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Honours School System, Lahore (2nd nomination) User:4meter4 02:48, 25 October 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Honours School System, Lahore (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
20382 17859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mezzo Secolo Di Ritornelli User:Jack 09:50, 2 July 2020 (UTC) delete Nothing I can find to indicate this book meets or the . Despite the determined efforts to get articles on this subject and his works onto Wikipedia, the fact remains that |Wikipedia is not for promotion Deletion of Mezzo Secolo Di Ritornelli WP:NBOOK||WP:GNG||WP:NOTPROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20383 377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rafal Zielinski User:Piotrus 07:49, 16 June 2021 (UTC) delete Created 10 years ago, and still looks quite bad, failing . Likely a case of or self-promo anyway Deletion of Rafal Zielinski WP:GNG||WP:VANITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20384 15277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kris brunken User:Fan 05:37, 11 December 2006 (UTC) delete Professional information doesn't look notable. Most of the article is personal bio, totally unverifiable, and reads suspiciously like |COI Deletion of Kris brunken WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
20385 14375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Work record of Bhaktivinoda Thakur User:SpacemanSpiff 06:31, 17 June 2014 (UTC) delete Clear lack of notability for this part of his life, merging it to the main article does a disservice to that article with a |weight problem. All that's really required from this particular list in the main article is a one-two sentence extract about his work life and that needs to be fresh prose, so nothing really salvageable here. &mdash Deletion of Work record of Bhaktivinoda Thakur WP:DUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
20386 15305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pierce Bush User:JJL 22:13, 24 November 2007 (UTC) keep Today Show, Larry King Live (thence CNN.com http://edition.cnn.com/2004/ALLPOLITICS/09/02/gop.bushs.lkl.access/), Rolling Stone, Wonkette (notable blog, http://wonkette.com/politics/pierce-bush/douchebag-of-the-day-pierce-bush-160204.php)...what more do people want for ? Here's someone a person might need to look up in an encyclopedia Deletion of Pierce Bush WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20387 20429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank Arrigo User:Delicategenius 08:52, 25 May 2007 (UTC) keep I found Frank on the front page of the AFR last week. I saw him keynote several high profile events in the Tech industry over the past few years. To me, it seems he is quite |notable. Not to mention that he's been an advisor to both Bill Gates and Steve Ballmer Deletion of Frank Arrigo Wikipedia:Notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
20388 16948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanawat Wattanaputi User:DAJF 23:03, 20 January 2014 (UTC) delete Unsourced violation Deletion of Tanawat Wattanaputi WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20389 8526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mr. Lee (cat) User:Sandstein 20:25, 29 July 2007 (UTC) delete News reports are often a necessary, but never a sufficient criterion for notability. Per , mention the cat in an article on webcams or something instead Deletion of Mr. Lee (cat) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20390 8713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gabriel Basso User:NortyNort 06:52, 3 August 2010 (UTC) delete The actors http://www.imdb.com/name/nm2773059/resume resume doesn't meet . I think Alabama Moon is the only notable gig he starred in Deletion of Gabriel Basso WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20391 1702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2024 Republican Party presidential primaries User:Schetm 08:38, 12 November 2020 (UTC) keep the nom failed to provide a -REASON|reason for the article to be deleted. It's well sourced and quite useful for the reader Deletion of 2024 Republican Party presidential primaries WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20392 16334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Louis Rivas User:LAmusic3 01:06, 23 December 2008 (UTC) delete per notability policy: Article about a |nonnotable actor with barely any sources Deletion of Daniel Louis Rivas WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20393 20264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Green Calx (EP) User:RayAYang 05:57, 16 March 2010 (UTC) delete per , but really, you could've saved us an AFD nom if you'd just boldly redirected to the band Deletion of Green Calx (EP) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20394 6924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Long (director) User:Artw 15:46, 10 January 2015 (UTC) keep was able to add some refs, but for the most part I am only finding reviews where a nice solid interview or profile would be better for establishing notability. Probably scrapes by on Deletion of Christopher Long (director) WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20395 6763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Progressive Dog Breeders' Alliance (2nd nomination) User:Sagaciousphil 16:08, 19 January 2015 (UTC) delete does not meet |notability guide Deletion of International Progressive Dog Breeders' Alliance (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20396 10740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Cooke User:Gargleafg 23:09, 30 April 2018 (UTC) delete Maybe the most salient claim to notability Cooke has is that his book was adapted into a The Principles of Lust|2003 film. Even the film references just list him as the author of the source material (i.e. no depth). In fact, most sources about his work don't mention him much. Mentions of Cooke in almost any other source are passing at best. Doesn't meet Deletion of Tim Cooke WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20397 20291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Free and open-source ATS User:Ifnord 04:29, 31 December 2018 (UTC) delete for failing . suggests we could merge or redirect to the organization or company that first created it but that's not entirely clear from the article Deletion of Free and open-source ATS WP:GNG||WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20398 12641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/31st Kentucky Infantry Regiment User:Hog 03:45, 27 June 2020 (UTC) delete As one who writes a number of ACW unit histories, I can state with confidence this is a clear failure Deletion of 31st Kentucky Infantry Regiment WP:MILUNIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20399 10924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Der König verneigt sich und tötet User:Roscelese 15:16, 25 April 2011 (UTC) keep Passes criterion #5 of as the author has won a Nobel in literature Deletion of Der König verneigt sich und tötet WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
20400 1994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Logan Grove User:Eggishorn 19:31, 5 January 2014 (UTC) delete """U|JamesBWatson}} has ably summarized the lack of |general notability, so I agree that is the only hope for this article. As far as I can tall, however, the subject has not had """"''significant'' roles in ''multiple''...productions"""". The only significant role he has had was as the voice of the protagonist in ''The Amazing World of Gumball'', a role he no longer has. His other roles were all quite minor""" Deletion of Logan Grove WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
20401 7190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The London Eye in popular culture User:Otto4711 16:46, 2 January 2008 (UTC) delete """#IINFO|indiscriminate list and #DIR|directory of unassociated items with no relationship to each other than happening to have this wheel in them in some way. The things on this list have nothing in common with each other and the presence of the wheel does not create an encyclopedic relationship. """"The London Eye is in it"""" is not a theme. Regarding the comments from the article's creator, I am sorry that you put |effort into creating this unencyclopedic article, but your effort is not relevant to the list's unsuitability. Neither does the |existence of other """"dorky"""" lists (and I note that this characterization of the work of others is surprisingly |uncivil given your strong feelings about your |own work) does not serve to justify the existence of this list""" Deletion of The London Eye in popular culture WP:NOT||WP:EFFORT||WP:WAX||WP:CIVIL||WP:OWN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20402 20190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Plummer (politician) User:Bearian 19:46, 22 December 2010 (UTC) keep losing major party candidates for statewide offices may be kept, when they have ''some'' |bare claim to outside notability. The subject raised over a Million $USD, came fairly close to winning, and is not a gadly. ''Compare'' Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gail Goode and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruce Blakeman with Harry Wilson (businessman) and Sharron Angle. For disclosure, I am a Democrat Deletion of Jason Plummer (politician) WP:BARE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20403 9419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brooklyn Girls [[user talk:badmachine|badmachine]]'' 16:39, 16 August 2011 (UTC) merge """this artist seems to be mainly known for being featured on the cover of the Freshmen 09' XXL magazine and being """"the cousin of famous rapper MC Lyte."""" i dont know the policies as well as herostratus, but his points seem valid. the main article reads like a puff piece on Hamilton. i think i |proded the main article once upon a time and found out swiftly that he is notable, but this seems like overcoverage for an artist who probably hasnt released a studio album yet""" Deletion of Brooklyn Girls WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
20404 20759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marlon Patersson User:Angelo 21:10, 29 July 2009 (UTC) delete even if the subject meets (which is debatable), he does not meet , which has to be met by all subjects covered into the Wikipedia project. Hence, he is simply not notable. I wouldn't consider all of these Non-League papers, since they cover solely subjects from amateur and semi-pro tiers. Also, a website that asks for direct feedback from its usershttp://www.nonleaguedaily.com/feedback/index.php does not look particularly |reliable Deletion of Marlon Patersson WP:ATHLETE||WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20405 424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abraham Reuel NONE NONE delete per . If this person ever existed, he's known only for his conversion to Judaism, and that only in a single newspaper article. This policy reads, in part Deletion of Abraham Reuel WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20406 972 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IRIS (Annual Management and Cultural Fest) User:JMWt 09:12, 9 May 2016 (UTC) delete no evidence of notability which meets the . I can't find any secondary independent at all. And it also reads as a cut-and-paste from publicity materials Deletion of IRIS (Annual Management and Cultural Fest) WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20407 17008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Afghan Jalebi (Ya Baba) (2nd nomination) User:Faizan 07:19, 13 October 2015 (UTC) delete Fails per the reference analyses table Deletion of Afghan Jalebi (Ya Baba) (2nd nomination) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20408 12302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kikuo Harigaya User:J 23:24, 11 September 2008 (UTC) delete I did some work on this subject last night, but I didn't get the chance to post. Basically, the Science Citation Index lists nothing for Kikuo Harigaya. At first I wasn't surprised by that result considering the index looks for mostly English-language publications and their citations. However, I also checked Google Scholar. I found a few citations here and there and verification of his English-language publications. For me, it becomes a tough call because I don't want to be unfair to Dr. Harigaya's work and impact. lists several notability criteria that don't seem to apply to Hiragaya. That leaves us with #1 and #4 -- ''The person's research has made significant impact in their scholarly discipline, broadly construed, as demonstrated by independent reliable sources'' and ''The person's academic work has made a significant impact in the area of higher education, affecting a substantial number of academic institutions''. Based on what we have, I'm leaning towards delete. I speak and read Japanese, but I'm not aware of a Japanese-language search engine similar to the Science Citation Index. For me, that index is probably what we should be consulting. If new information arises that he's significantly cited in the Japanese-language community, I'll change my opinion for sure Deletion of Kikuo Harigaya WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20409 6757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omega zeta chi User:Anthony_cfc 19:21, 31 December 2006 (UTC) delete per #SOAP Deletion of Omega zeta chi WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20410 357 [[Gertrude Baines]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Govannon 23:18, 11. Sep. 2009 (CEST) keep Der Artikel über die Ältester Mensch|ältesten Menschen legt eine Relevanz nahe, wenn jemand ein Alter über 110 Jahre erreicht. Sollte sicherheitshalber am besten in die |RK aufgenommen werden, diesen Artikel natürlich Löschung von Gertrude Baines Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
20411 2498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elephants Are Not Birds User:Isabelle 20:41, 5 August 2021 (UTC) delete Having an ISBN doesn't mean it's notable. The article in its current state reads as an advertisement. I wouldn't say it meets , as it's only being covered by a few and only for the fact it's not being sold on the Amazon store due to its transphobic content because it's chosen not to sell via Amazon and due to its anti-trans content Deletion of Elephants Are Not Birds WP:NBOOK||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20412 8089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Temi Olajide User:scope_creep 09:47, 15 June 2020 (UTC) delete I'm not convinced with arguments so far, for keep.I don't see much in the comprehensive secondary source that establish notability beyond all doubt. Really not a lot here, a simple small para that mentions her as a sleep consultant. I'm curious as to why so many editors are pushing to get the article kept when there is such tenuous notability. There is effectively no secondary sources that are in in-depth and that are independent of the subject. There is no other coverage, so it fails and Deletion of Temi Olajide WP:SIGCOV||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20413 4613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ronald Barnes (Alaskan politician) User:Beeblebrox 18:42, 11 February 2015 (UTC) delete """I came to this expecting this would be a member of the state senate or something, but he doesn't actually appear to be a politician at all in the normally understood sense of the word. He may need policitial skills to be the """"diplomatic representative"""" of a small NGO but that's not the same thing. Attending a notable event event as a representative of an obscure organization does not confer notability on the attendee. Overall looks like a case of . An article on the organization he represents would be a better place to start, if there are any |sources to construct that from""" Deletion of Ronald Barnes (Alaskan politician) WP:VSCA||WP:RS Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
20414 17600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Treasure Data NONE NONE delete An IT company with less than 100 employees and circa 100 customers that has been trading for less than four years. For this to be notable, it would require a significant and substantial amount of coverage beyond a couple of PR driven articles/interviews in industry publications. This is not the case. In fact, it pretty comprehensively fails . Analysis of references Deletion of Treasure Data WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20415 19982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doughboy Beatz User:Richard3120 17:20, 29 October 2016 (UTC) comment this AfD probably needs to be considered alongside Doughboy Beatz production discography. The subject has clearly worked with notable artists, but per that doesn't make Doughboy Beatz notable, and in addition his work appears to be on non-notable mixtapes by those artists, not charting releases Deletion of Doughboy Beatz WP:INHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20416 449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Main Stage Wrestling User:Paviliolive 16:55, 2 February 2014 (UTC) delete As not meeting Deletion of Main Stage Wrestling WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20417 11579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cover (album) User:Tassedethe 14:06, 10 July 2011 (UTC) keep well-reviewed album by notable artist; passes Deletion of Cover (album) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20418 16629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clackamas Town Center Shooting User:David1217 20:25, 13 December 2012 (UTC) merge to Clackamas Town Center, unless there are lasting effects (gun law changes, for example). applies Deletion of Clackamas Town Center Shooting WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20419 7429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Common Dreams NewsCenter User:Hipocrite 13:43, 5 February 2007 (UTC) delete Ignoring the bad faith in the nomination, fails Deletion of Common Dreams NewsCenter WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20420 10560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manoj Dey User:Ab207 05:16, 8 August 2021 (UTC) delete due to lack of in independent reliable sources. Sponsored content/press releases do not contribute to notability Deletion of Manoj Dey WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
20421 17999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carl Freer (3rd nomination) User:Jackmcbarn 20:22, 25 August 2014 (UTC) keep Not an attack page, as all of the negativity is well-sourced, and even if you think he doesn't fall under the exception in , he's notable per Deletion of Carl Freer (3rd nomination) WP:CRIME||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20422 17281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Menace of Maninsuit / K-9 Quarry User:Stuartyeates 02:16, 23 October 2011 (UTC) delete as completely failing due to lack of references Deletion of The Menace of Maninsuit / K-9 Quarry WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20423 12610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ilandi.co.uk User:DAJF 15:12, 26 November 2007 (UTC) delete Does not establish notability, and has |spam/|COI issues Deletion of Ilandi.co.uk WP:SPAM||WP:COI Wikipedia:Spam 112
20424 9299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of dog cop episodes [[User talk:Orderinchaos|Orderinchaos]] 23:11, 7 June 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of dog cop episodes WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20425 15907 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Gregory Buttigieg User:Inkwina 21:21, 19 September 2007 (UTC) delete I know the person concerned personally and confirm the person's relative local notability within Malta. Yet the |Criteria for Notability for Wikipedia are not met in my opinion. Maybe the author should consider translating the article and moving it to mt:George Gregory Buttigieg on the Maltese wikipedia. But please check the policy there before. Unfortunately there are several Bios on Maltese People which suffer from the same problem as this. I guess the ratio of ''Maltese people with entries on wikipedia'' to ''the population of 400,000 on Malta'' is on the high side. That is no justification. A cleanup is rather needed Deletion of George Gregory Buttigieg WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20426 7730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adria Airways destinations User:Billhpike 02:44, 1 February 2018 (UTC) keep This is a valid list and I don't see how applies as this is not travel advice. And as Deletion of Adria Airways destinations WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20427 20997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billy Williams (Coronation Street) User:Sgeureka 08:55, 14 September 2008 (UTC) delete per , OT#PLOT, etc. I reason that the other bad CS articles should also be deleted (or be merged where appropriate) instead of this one kept. Cleanup needs to start somewhere. &ndash Deletion of Billy Williams (Coronation Street) WP:N||WP:NOT||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20428 151 [[Bahnhof Toyoda]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Matthiasb 12:16, 1. Jul. 2008 (CEST) keep Nachdem diverse Löschsocken gesperrt sind, kommen also nun die Reihen-LAe auf Bahnhöfe durch Ralf Scholze. Abweichend zu den vom Bahnportal im Januar geänderten RKen, zu denen es (siehe Diskussions-Archiv zu ) keinen Konsenz gibt, erachte ich Bahnhöfe grundsätzlich für relevant Löschung von Bahnhof Toyoda Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
20429 18438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Association of Scientists, Developers and Faculties User:Qworty 14:54, 24 November 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. The sole keep argument appears to be purely , and the user has changed his mind Deletion of Association of Scientists, Developers and Faculties WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
20430 8364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conspiracies II User:Corpx 08:14, 6 July 2007 (UTC) delete """per . There is """"not much known"""" about the game except the speculation on that page""" Deletion of Conspiracies II WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20431 13943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Satish Sugars User:DrStrauss 09:03, 13 September 2017 (UTC) delete few |independent, reliable sources have covered the company |in any depth. https://www.justdial.com/Belgaum/Satish-Sugars-Ltd-Gokak/9999PMULBLRSTD1006716_BZDET This is a review aggregator site with no editorial oversight and http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/topic/Satish-Sugars this, while from the Times of India, is merely an auto-generated sorting list. The only source which gives any sort of valuable media attention is https://allaboutbelgaum.com/news/satish-sugars-organises-various-competitions-school-college-students/ this but still fails |depth of coverage standards Deletion of Satish Sugars WP:42||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:The answer to life, the universe, and everything 7
20432 4734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Redneck monday User:Evb 16:53, 17 October 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. #MADEUP Deletion of Redneck monday WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20433 20290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/French telemarketing User:BenLinus1214 21:28, 25 May 2015 (UTC) delete fails , no |reliable sources cited in the article or can be found otherwise Deletion of French telemarketing WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20434 16086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Religious identity User:Black 00:11, 9 February 2007 (UTC) delete per and . The topic ''is'' notable, but even if anyone wants to start an article on it, they could/should not use the text that is there now. And yes, one of the WP policies I've cited is fictional Deletion of Religious identity WP:NOR||WP:OVERCOMPLICATED Wikipedia:No original research 65
20435 9890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Be Jenna User:Quarl NONE delete as |unverifiable/|non-notable. &mdash Deletion of Be Jenna WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20436 9751 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of phone prefixes in Omaha, Nebraska User:Edison 19:23, 26 March 2011 (UTC) delete """per |not a directory and per failure of |verifiability, since no source is provided for the claims. I could add """"402-202 Dingledoofer Phone Co."""" to the list and it would be as reliably sourced as the other listings as is """"402-294 TELEPORT COMMUNICATIONS GROUP - OMAHA""" Deletion of List of phone prefixes in Omaha, Nebraska WP:NOT||WP:V Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20437 20647 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Oarhe User:Jamzy4 14:11, 4 October 2016 (UTC) delete Article failed , References are not reliable, I think the article was not properly constructed to meet wikipedia criteria before moving to main space. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Chris Oarhe WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20438 14135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Center, New Mexico NONE NONE keep This topic passes Deletion of The Center, New Mexico WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20439 5590 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luis Vázquez Martínez User:David 05:19, 4 March 2016 (UTC) keep I have completely rewritten and stubbed-down the article, so that it no longer looks like a cv. Regardless of the messed-up scholar page, and whatever his actual citations are, I think the corresponding membership in the Spanish Royal Academy gives him a pass of #C3 Deletion of Luis Vázquez Martínez WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20440 19186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cooperative Earth Time User:MuZemike 22:17, 4 November 2008 (UTC) delete lack of |verifiable sources establishing |notability; that is, I could not find any Deletion of Cooperative Earth Time WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20441 6320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BaySand User:Sunmist 15:55, 15 August 2016 (UTC) delete per nom. At first glance the sources appear to be news articles, but they're all press releases or links to BaySand's website, which don't fulfill . Searching for BaySand yielded the same result; just press releases and Deletion of BaySand WP:CORP||WP:SELFPUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20442 14093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Pay-TV Company in Nigeria User:SW3 06:31, 26 September 2014 (UTC) delete per , and fails Deletion of List of Pay-TV Company in Nigeria WP:NOTDIR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20443 6034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyer Allen User:Spatulli 11:30, 27 September 2010 (UTC) delete per otability (sports), playing for the US national team is not notable in rugby league Deletion of Tyer Allen WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20444 4073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camp david GCC User:Esquivalience 00:31, 31 May 2015 (UTC) keep The summit meets and , has a wide geographical scope, and will probably lead to '''international''' agreements Deletion of Camp david GCC WP:GNG||WP:EVENTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20445 8670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of United States presidential firsts User:Shearonink 19:49, 13 January 2020 (UTC) comment If this list is Kept I think it should be placed under permanent |semi-protection. There is always a low-level murmur of oh-so-clever vandal-edits. Putting the List under permanent semi-protection would remove some of that vandalistic-hubbub Deletion of List of United States presidential firsts WP:SEMI Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
20446 8914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transhumanist Party User:The 11:58, 15 November 2014 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Transhumanist Party WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20447 3897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Libido Airbag User:Nuttah68 12:15, 11 February 2007 (UTC) delete unless some reliable sources showing how they meet are provided. The fact that it is a side project of GUT (band) doesn't help because that article offers no more than this Deletion of Libido Airbag WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20448 1156 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hui martial arts User:Dane2007 21:23, 2 September 2016 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Hui martial arts WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20449 15301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bearcat Sports Complex User:Redphoenix526 15:37, 29 March 2008 (UTC) delete This article horribly fails and I doubt it ever will be notable by any standard Deletion of Bearcat Sports Complex WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20450 10464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Norton Rose Fulbright User:Shawn 17:56, 1 June 2016 (UTC) keep the 3 links provided by Arxiloxos above (the ''WSJ'' link is actually the ''NYT''s link, repeated) and what one finds via the news links atop this Afd show more than enough to meet Deletion of Norton Rose Fulbright WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20451 4110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Lonelygirl15 Episodes User:Wenli 03:21, 2 February 2008 (UTC) delete per . — Deletion of List of Lonelygirl15 Episodes WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20452 4310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J. D. Westmoreland User:SL93 23:52, 15 December 2011 (UTC) delete Appears to fail Deletion of J. D. Westmoreland WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20453 17195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rashid Khan (Nepali cricketer) NONE NONE delete per nominator. Fails Deletion of Rashid Khan (Nepali cricketer) WP:NCRIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20454 14758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Songs about sex User:Rimmers 17:42, 19 August 2006 (UTC) delete Agreed that its completely unmanageable. And the majority of songs in popular culture today reference sex - imo, this is just a random collection of information that doesn't serve any real purpose. See: #Wikipedia_is_not_an_indiscriminate_collection_of_information Deletion of Songs about sex WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20455 1934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C. Anandharamakrishnan (2nd nomination) User:Xxanthippe 22:52, 18 November 2017 (UTC) keep as in August AfD. Passes rof#C1 and rof#C3 Deletion of C. Anandharamakrishnan (2nd nomination) WP:P||WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
20456 387 [[Hofbräukeller]] (bleibt) Benutzer:08-15 01:54, 14. Aug. 2007 (CEST) keep Der Artikel wurde grundlegend überarbeitet und behandelt jetzt primär das historische Gebäude. Damit , Relevanz gemäß #Bauwerke und Denkmäler ist gegeben Löschung von Hofbräukeller Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
20457 12311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Littler User:Qworty 06:43, 17 April 2013 (UTC) delete for failing Deletion of John Littler WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20458 16782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Who-is-famous.com User:JohnBlackburne 23:42, 21 July 2014 (UTC) delete I note that several attempts have been made to get this into mainspace already, via the draft process. Draft:How to become famous, Draft:Who-is-famous.com, Draft:Who is famous, Draft:Who is famous ( website ). I am unsure a rule covers this precisely, but in the spirit of this to me would be grounds for speedily deleting this and warning the editor for wasting everyone's time attempting to get around the repeated rejections/bypass the draft process Deletion of Who-is-famous.com WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
20459 4805 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/José Echenique User:SportsOlympic 21:16, 14 July 2020 (UTC) keep Meets “A sportsperson is presumed to be notable if the person has actively participated in a major amateur or professional competition Deletion of José Echenique WP:SPORTSPERSON Wikipedia:Notability 77
20460 17650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prashanth Nair (IAS) User:onel5969 15:35, 24 March 2021 (UTC) delete not enough in-depth coverage from independent reliable sources to pass Deletion of Prashanth Nair (IAS) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20461 5755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Humayun Khan (soldier) User:Rhododendrites 12:45, 3 August 2016 (UTC) keep My thinking when creating the article on the parents was largely along the lines of what {{u|Cullen328}} says above, and how I described it on Talk:Khizr and Ghazala Khan|that talk page. There's no question that there's enough significant coverage of them to satisfy notability. I think there's more than enough to justify an article independent of the convention, too, given there have been new developments that have kept them among the top national headlines every day since the speech (e.g. just a few hours ago http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/03/us/politics/donald-trump-gop.html from the NY Times -- not the best source, because it's more about Trump than the Khans, but not all of the sources have to have them as the primary subject). There's a valid question of whether, per , it would make sense to move the article about the parents to an article about the speech (not the campaign/convention), but I think a biography is justified and that discussion can always happen down the road. &mdash Deletion of Humayun Khan (soldier) WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
20462 19724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mountaineers 5 Peak Pin User:Balle010 18:20, 4 August 2020 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Mountaineers 5 Peak Pin WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20463 9796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Miniatures Page User:Thomas 18:17, 4 September 2014 (UTC) delete as non-notable. Fails as there is no independent coverage Deletion of The Miniatures Page WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20464 16952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David W. Force (politician) NONE NONE keep Nine articles regarding Howard County Executives/Commissioners/Councilmen have been recommended for deletion based on not meeting only one of the three polices in olitician by User:MilaPedia with an account created 9 August 2013 Deletion of David W. Force (politician) WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
20465 13977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dylan's Couch User:Townlake 14:43, 4 July 2008 (UTC) delete """Zero reliable sources discuss Dylan's Couch (unless someone found some?), and zero bullets of are satisfied as an alternative. """"Official Honoree"""" is a type of recognition that young Dylan should be proud of, but it simply isn't a well-known award, and the fundamental criteria for inclusion in Wikipedia aren't otherwise satisfied""" Deletion of Dylan's Couch WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20466 6880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dai Ling Ping User:TBrandley 02:57, 14 November 2012 (UTC) delete Non-notable topic fails . Google search doesn't prove notability at all. Sorry Deletion of Dai Ling Ping WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20467 1696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ende International Airport User:Ringbark 21:56, 4 December 2007 (UTC) delete Extensive collection of airlines were edited, many of which do not/could not offer service to Erde, even if it existed. Suggest that the appropriate action is deletion under Deletion of Ende International Airport WP:SNOWBALL Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
20468 430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tristar and Red Sector Incorporated (3rd nomination) User:Vertigo 18:51, 23 June 2011 (UTC) comment How do those links meet Deletion of Tristar and Red Sector Incorporated (3rd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20469 3035 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of file sharing software User:TheM62Manchester 09:00, 10 August 2006 (UTC) delete move to as example of redundant article Deletion of List of file sharing software WP:BJAODN Wikipedia:Silly Things 72
20470 13102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lilium (song) User:Captain 18:04, 2 June 2008 (UTC) delete """article fails #Songs, which says that a song should be """"ranked on national or significant music charts, that have won significant awards or honors or that have been performed independently by several notable artists, bands or groups"""" to have its own article""" Deletion of Lilium (song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20471 2445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paracoccidioidomicosisproctitissarcomucosis (2nd nomination) User:Lankiveil 01:58, 23 March 2008 (UTC) delete while the band name is certainly amusing, they don't appear to meet . Many of the arguments from the previous AfD discussion still seem to apply here Deletion of Paracoccidioidomicosisproctitissarcomucosis (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20472 3112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mobil Directo User:Bearian 20:32, 23 October 2020 (UTC) delete per nom and . There were a few passing mentions in 1960s ''Mechanical Engineering''-type magazines, but zero coverage in text books or newspapers Deletion of Mobil Directo WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
20473 11860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Philip Gale User:Fences 01:37, 11 January 2011 (UTC) comment I'm not going to !vote, I'm neutral on whether this event has sufficient notability - my only reason for commenting here is to remind everyone of the existence of the ''' guideline'''. and clash, and aims to square that circle - ''please'' make use of its guidance Deletion of Death of Philip Gale WP:EVENT||WP:GNG||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20474 19000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hayes Barnard User:AntonNexa 21:37, 16 March 2020 (UTC) keep Added a few more sources to the article. Many meet including https://www.businessinsider.com/reinventing-the-solar-business-according-to-solarcity-exec-2019-7 1, https://www.icastusa.org/solar-powered-desalination/ 2, https://thesiliconreview.com/magazine/profile/financing-the-clean-energy-future-loanpal 3, https://www.inverse.com/article/55481-the-3-huge-trends-driving-the-imminent-solar-energy-revolution 4, https://www.bizjournals.com/sacramento/news/2013/12/26/hayes-barnard-exec-of-year.html 5, https://www.inverse.com/article/57475-ex-solarcity-exec-is-using-tesla-powerwall-to-bring-clean-water-worldwide 6 Deletion of Hayes Barnard WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
20475 7939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Palace Productions User:ST47 18:16, 23 August 2006 (UTC) delete as per and Deletion of Palace Productions WP:SPAM||WP:VANITY Wikipedia:Spam 112
20476 10296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lina Ashar User:Walwal20 22:53, 19 September 2020 (UTC) delete While the awards are promising, they do not seem to have the level of significance required for . The award-givers are not independent from the subject, I'd say, and they all have a local scope. Maybe a case of Deletion of Lina Ashar WP:ANYBIO||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
20477 339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Force FM User:Joe 02:41, 8 January 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this radio station Deletion of Force FM WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20478 6306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs with personal names: A User:Masaruemoto 02:50, 27 June 2007 (UTC) delete Violates #IINFO and #DIR of loosely associated topics. The only thing these songs have in common is that they happen to include the name of a person in the title. That's ''any'' name, out of thousands of possible names, from tens of thousands of possible song titles Deletion of List of songs with personal names: A WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20479 17069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Porscia Yeganeh User:NebY 18:42, 20 May 2012 (UTC) delete """The article itself demonstrates the subject does not meet the notability tests (above) when it resorts to attempts to inflate the subject's significance by the loosest of associations (for example, """"The store carried a number of signature designer labels including Calvin Klein, Kenneth Cole & Tommy Hilfiger"""", """"This relationship was the beginning of the startup journey where many of the signature fashion designers are based, including Prada, Gucci, Dolce & Gabbana""""). The sources cited are poor evidence of notability; certainly the Afro News article reads as promotional rather than reporting. Of course the subject has a duty to her company to promote herself, and it has been suggested that some recent development of this article was commissioned by her or her company (see halfway through dministrators%27_noticeboard/IncidentArchive746#possible_paid_editing_for_Jill_Kenton). This would put the threat to sue a book's publisher in an odd light, as that book is nothing but a print-on-demand collation of Wikipedia articles (see Books_LLC) that if it ever was printed would contain this very article. Is there a suggestion that this article needs her """"authorisation""" Deletion of Porscia Yeganeh WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
20480 9192 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AFC Wimbledon league record by opponent User:Pharaoh 08:16, 25 July 2015 (UTC) keep per Mattythewhite and Lugnuts articles are generally only deleted for problems with content only | if they are unsalvageable .But this list can be improved as Mattythewhite rightly points out Deletion of AFC Wimbledon league record by opponent WP:SURMOUNTABLE Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20481 94 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of media markets and college football User:Wcquidditch 03:22, 7 July 2012 (UTC) delete we can't even use DMAs to begin with, and college team fanbases don't exactly correlate with market definitions anyhow. To say nothing of those schools with no football teams… and the lone reference is a DMA list that obviously has nothing to do with college football, which may as well put this list dangerously close to (if not outright in) |original research territory anyhow. Outside of the DMAs, little effort is made to connect this to college football on television… and even if you took all of ''those'' issues away, we're not |an indiscriminate collection of information. There seems to be more wrong with this list than not Deletion of List of media markets and college football WP:OR||WP:IINFO Wikipedia:No original research 65
20482 743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virender Dahiya User:Rugbyfan22 09:35, 5 April 2021 (UTC) merge Has played 1 FC, 2 List-A and 2 T20 games, but I couldn't find any significant coverage. Seems to have gone into governmental work so cricket career seems to be over. Sources may exist in Indian sources though. Redirect is a suitable and maybe could have been BOLDly done instead of AfD Deletion of Virender Dahiya WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20483 16939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Presidents of the United States with facial hair (4th nomination) User:Accesscrawl 06:39, 3 August 2018 (UTC) delete Fails . List of trivia, not telling us anything important or valuable Deletion of List of Presidents of the United States with facial hair (4th nomination) WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20484 9755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Popaditch User:Bearian 23:35, 3 November 2010 (UTC) delete """per all of the above and to be discussed. I note the discussion at Wikipedia_talk:Notability_(people)#Proposed_objective_definition_of_a_fringe_candidate_for_WP:POLITICIAN. I thought there was a |strong consensus that failed candidates for national (or state or povincial) office are not ''per se'' notable, absent """"more than routine coverage"""" of their candidcy. There are also several other AfDs going on about this very topic. Reasonable people can disagree whether a 60-40 victory is a landslide. At 40 %, he's certainly ''not'' a fringe candidate. The only possible measure of notability is his Silver Star, a fairly high honor""" Deletion of Nick Popaditch WP:CCC Wikipedia:Consensus 78
20485 9857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Govasool User:AllyD 09:26, 17 November 2016 (UTC) delete The references in the article are predominantly start-up coverage of this firm among others, to which could be added http://theviewspaper.net/an-interview-with-aditya-bhamidipaty-ceo-of-govasool/ this 2009 interview with the founder. Later references in the article relate to the eMart Solutions parent, possibly due to focus shifting to white-labelling services http://www.businesstoday.in/magazine/cover-story/indias-coolest-start-ups-emart-solutions-india/story/191499.html, also reflected in recent coverage of the parent http://www.financialexpress.com/companies/emart-solutions-strengthens-its-leadership-to-accelerate-growth-2/152711/. I don't think that is sufficient for notability of the eMart Solutions parent and certainly doesn't inherit back to their retail service, which I think fails to demonstrate |encyclopaedic notability Deletion of Govasool :WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
20486 17804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Giallombardo User:GiantSnowman 23:17, 21 June 2010 (UTC) delete fails and ; was not eligible for a speedy as some degree of notability is implied Deletion of Andrew Giallombardo WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20487 21344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ExAmour User:Shaundakulbara 08:21, 25 January 2007 (UTC) keep This article provides |verifiable sources, is not spam, is Wikified, and presents information that might be useful or interesting to someone (certainly not me though). Based on that, and the fact that this is an esoteric subject, I suggest we give some benefit of the doubt regarding |notability Deletion of ExAmour WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20488 4010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blue Cruise User:Trilliumz 23:17, 19 May 2011 (UTC) keep """Added citations to books, |, and copyedited for clarity, changing to the indefinite article """"a blue cruise,"""" to match the Dutch version. Discovered in the process of adding citations that this term appears to have literary origins which predate its use in the tourist industry. We could use |help from some Turkish speakers to |expand on its significance in literature""" Deletion of Blue Cruise WP:RS||WP:WORLDVIEW||WP:HASPOT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20489 18641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zack Friedman User:Bearian 15:54, 15 December 2020 (UTC) delete per and . In theory, giving a TEDx talk can ''count towards'' notability, |but is not automatic Deletion of Zack Friedman WP:TNT||WP:NOTRESUME||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
20490 21938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islamophobiaphobia User:Ikkyu2 00:24, 14 February 2006 (UTC) delete neologism. |not a dictionary, |not for things made up in school one day.. Also, article was originated explicitly as a |POV fork, which is absolutely prohibited. If there's any useful content in the current version, merge to Islamophobia Deletion of Islamophobiaphobia WP:WWIN||WP:NFT||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20491 21827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magic: The Gathering deck types (4rd nomination) User:Clarityfiend 00:09, 12 August 2017 (UTC) delete """per , which specifically includes """"game guides"""" without qualifiers""" Deletion of Magic: The Gathering deck types (4rd nomination) WP:NOTMANUAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20492 3516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vegoia and Egeria NONE NONE delete It should be noted that this is the work of a new editor who may need some help becoming familiar with WP policies and guidelines. The essay seems to be a content fork from the new article Vegoia; both show many many |Manual of Style issues, which also need to be addressed. I see the following grounds for deletion Deletion of Vegoia and Egeria WP:MOS Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
20493 1128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/After Hours (British TV series) User:Toughpigs 00:52, 20 January 2020 (UTC) keep National TV show as per . There's the usual coverage of a new show before broadcast (https://www.radiotimes.com/news/2014-06-23/jaime-winstone-and-ardal-ohanlon-to-star-in-new-sky-comedy-set-around-an-internet-radio-station/ Radio Times) and after (https://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/tvandradio/tv-and-radio-reviews/11970577/After-Hours-review-charming.html The Telegraph). Also coverage on https://www.comedy.co.uk/tv/news/1523/after_hours_sky_comedy_series/ British Comedy Guide. It's not a very good article and it doesn't have references, but they and there's no reason to say this is worse than any other run of the mill article on a one-season national TV show Deletion of After Hours (British TV series) WP:TVSERIES||WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
20494 18175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katie Gold User:Natalie 23:06, 8 April 2007 (UTC) comment Actually, if you read , you will see that the number of films any one person has been in is explicitly noted as ''not'' a measure of notability. However, awards are, so I withdrawing this nomination. Thank you Epbr123 for finding the cite Deletion of Katie Gold WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20495 16423 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Cole User:Firelement85 23:10, 7 January 2007 (UTC) delete """Google turns up very few results for """"Craig Cole""""+wrestler, I get more results encouraging me to fight pit bull|pit bulls, completely fails , can't find any reliable sources. (Side note - the fun fact is just gross""" Deletion of Craig Cole WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20496 1016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Tischman User:Thincat 18:34, 21 June 2018 (UTC) keep """Regarding #3, a couple of hundred strikes me as """"multiple""" Deletion of David Tischman WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
20497 16835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dungeon Inquisitor User:Wyatt 18:00, 11 July 2012 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Dungeon Inquisitor WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20498 13491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diandra Newlin User:Bearian 20:25, 14 December 2020 (UTC) delete per . How is a model like this notable Deletion of Diandra Newlin WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
20499 3240 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Maryott User:Bearcat 11:28, 20 June 2020 (UTC) delete """without prejudice against recreation on or after election day if he wins. People do not get articles just for being candidates in elections they have not yet won — requires ''holding'' a notable office, not just running for one — but being mayor of a small town in the 33K population range is not """"inherently"""" notable either, so that doesn't get him over the """"preexisting notability for other reasons independent of the candidacy"""" test, and the depth of media coverage shown here is nowhere near enough to get him over the """"his candidacy is more special than everybody else's candidacies"""" test either. But we also don't keep articles about candidates in draftspace ''pending'' the election results, either, because that just turns ''draftspace'' into the repository of campaign brochures for unelected candidates that our rules were intentionally designed to prevent mainspace from becoming. If he wins in November, administrators have the ability to undelete the article at that time with one punch on one button, so """"don't lose the work because he might win"""" is not a compelling reason to waive our rules""" Deletion of Brian Maryott WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20500 14919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/YouTube statistics User:Status 23:27, 22 November 2012 (UTC) delete """per . The """"Traffic"""", """"Mobile and Devices"""" and """"Social"""" sections can be merged to YouTube""" Deletion of YouTube statistics WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20501 10571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Every Girl (film) User:Aeon1006 05:05, 22 July 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Every Girl (film) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20502 8639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wheelers User:Eddie 22:37, 9 December 2005 (UTC) delete fails to meet Deletion of Wheelers WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20503 3028 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mindmistress User:Dragonfiend 17:55, 19 April 2006 (UTC) delete article does not meet Deletion of Mindmistress WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20504 21169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aleen N. Johnson User:Whisperjanes 01:13, 25 June 2020 (UTC) delete The playboy magazine might have been notable attention, but the content is just interviews - it seems all of the sources I can find on her are tabloids and/or non-indpendent/non-secondary interviews, so she doesn't seem to meet . She has international coverage too, so it's possible some of those sources could be |reliable, but I doubt it from all of the English sources I've seen Deletion of Aleen N. Johnson WP:GNG||WP:RELIABLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20505 13449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicholas Lore NONE NONE keep A published author that passes per Deletion of Nicholas Lore WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20506 1762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ahmed Yusuf (2nd nomination) User:onel5969 17:40, 13 December 2020 (UTC) delete """does not meet , and as pointed out by HandsomeBoy, """"unelected statewide apointees are not automatically deemed notable""" Deletion of Ahmed Yusuf (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20507 1699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Puerto Rican Shits [[User talk:MuZemike|MuZemike]] 17:20, 4 March 2009 (UTC) delete per lack of |verifiability. For a second there, I thought this was what happens after eating a bunch of Puerto Rican cuisine|Puerto Rican food Deletion of Puerto Rican Shits WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20508 4986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conor and Jay User:Cocytus 05:27, 11 January 2010 (UTC) delete doesn't appear to satisfy , and I don't think the GTA appearances merit inclusion as it's really rather trivial significance, I feel Deletion of Conor and Jay WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20509 16299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The murder of Yehuda Shoham User:HighKing 16:55, 13 August 2012 (UTC) delete """as per and . As per , there is nothing in the article that indicates any lasting significance. The event does not appear to be a precedent or catalyst for something else of lasting significance that is notable. I'm also concerned at the title - using the term """"Murder"""" in the title is not NPOV, and is not supported by references""" Deletion of The murder of Yehuda Shoham WP:EVENT||WP:BLP1E||WP:EFFECT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20510 14865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Future Leaders Academy, Kenya User:Adamant1 23:16, 24 January 2021 (UTC) delete The article lacks any references and I couldn't find anything to substantiate notability when I looked. Not even the usual trivial news sources. Not that they would cut it on their own if they did exist though. So, this school clearly fails both and Deletion of Future Leaders Academy, Kenya WP:GNG||WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20511 14177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seanna Leath User:David 19:49, 7 December 2019 (UTC) delete per . New assistant professors almost always have not had enough time for their publications to achieve the impact needed for notability, this article provides no evidence of being an exception, and with low citations on Google Scholar and no published books the two most-likely pathways for academics to become notable are both not yet open Deletion of Seanna Leath WP:TOOSOON||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20512 16819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Suderman User:Papaursa 03:07, 17 April 2017 (UTC) delete Coverage appears to be routine sports reporting and I couldn't find anything to show he meets Deletion of Matt Suderman WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20513 14091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cherwell Convention User:Doctorfluffy 04:56, 2 November 2007 (UTC) delete per . Secondary sources to establish notability do not exist Deletion of Cherwell Convention WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20514 1173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Ed, Edd n Eddy movie [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 05:28, 1 October 2006 (UTC) delete Not yet enough for a stand-alone article. Most importantly, no credible sources as required by Deletion of The Ed, Edd n Eddy movie WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20515 13389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Film.fm User:Lankiveil 10:36, 27 February 2012 (UTC) delete does not appear to be notable per , with the proviso that I can't read Hebrew and I'm not able to validate whether the coverage in those articles is substantial Deletion of Film.fm WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20516 11137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Motorola Tough Talker User:Darth 14:25, 6 December 2019 (UTC) delete Cannot find any |significant coverage to demonstrate |notability Deletion of Motorola Tough Talker WP:SIGCOV||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20517 21585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcus Stanley (pianist) User:GermanJoe 11:29, 28 June 2015 (UTC) comment voted above) - another copy of this article has been created at Marcus Stanley (musician) with https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Marcus_Stanley_%28musician%29&oldid=667717647, just minutes after the speedy tag was removed without explanation. But it's redirected now. Anyway, the topic clearly fails all criteria in ; the coverage in news almost entirely consists of interviews and self-published statements, repeated by the press - fails (and for that aspect Deletion of Marcus Stanley (pianist) WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20518 12912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/In the Moment User:Gongshow 10:03, 30 November 2009 (UTC) keep per Michig and Doomsdayer520. Notable artist and notable album. Passes , The article could use work, but not deletion. There's already one source of coverage linked to within the article Deletion of In the Moment WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20519 18266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeopardy! broadcast history (3rd nomination) User:Ginsengbomb 14:21, 14 January 2013 (UTC) keep per valid sourcing in article; suggest that nominator open a |merge discussion instead Deletion of Jeopardy! broadcast history (3rd nomination) WP:MERGE Wikipedia:Merging 54
20520 3181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Journey (film series) User:Betty 00:09, 9 May 2013 (UTC) delete """It seems to me we really wouldn't be losing much. I don't think anyone would dispute that two films constitute a """"series"""", the question is what unique perspective can such an article offer by comparing just two films? As Erik points out articles about sequels compare them to the predecessor anyway, and elaborate on which actors reprised their roles etc, so the sequel article as rule covers the same ground as the series article. It's difficult to envisage what would go into this article that shouldn't go into Journey 2: The Mysterious Island. Series with three films have an inherent complexity that series with two films don't have: for a start each film can be compared to two other films, as opposed to just two films compared with each other; rather than just having some actors returning and others not like with a single sequel, you often have recurring actors throughout a series, so a series article is the best way of tracking who has appeared in what. The third film does complicate this to an extent, but if we abide strictly by then the third film isn't eligible for an article yet; speculation about the sequel can simply go in the ''Journey 2'' article as well""" Deletion of Journey (film series) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20521 10392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Thai people User:Exit2DOS2000 02:11, 6 August 2011 (UTC) keep Really does need some work, before it get too big to be an easy job, but its allowed via Exit2DOS Deletion of List of Thai people WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
20522 18337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebound tockey ball User:Anomie 12:40, 24 September 2008 (UTC) delete per , and a lack of any indication of |notability. It would be #A7-able if it were in one of the allowed categories Deletion of Rebound tockey ball WP:NFT||WP:N||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
20523 420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Awaken (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 18:12, 30 April 2012 (UTC) comment """It's premiering tonight, April 30. The Wikipedia:Article Incubator|incubator was set up specifically for cases such as this, where there is """"an intention that the article can and will be improved"""". Sadly, outright deletion, however temporary, takes the topic out of these pages and eliminates any opportunity for collaborative editing to address issues. If it is not sent to the incubator as #Incubation|deletion policy encourages, I request a relist so we might '''A)''' await expected coverage of the film, and '''B)''' not have to go through possible in a few days""" Deletion of Awaken (film) WP:DEL||WP:REFUND Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20524 19923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony E. Meyer User:Joaquin008 10:28, 5 September 2010 (UTC) delete as seems to fail Deletion of Anthony E. Meyer WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20525 2016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael David Crawford User:Dreadstar 02:09, 12 October 2007 (UTC) delete non-notable per , no non-trivial coverage by reliable secondary sources. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Michael+David+Crawford%22 Google search returns few secondary independent sources Deletion of Michael David Crawford WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20526 4889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OMICS Group Inc User:January 17:19, 7 November 2015 (UTC) comment the creator of this article is a likely sock of Scholarscentral, who has a long history of copyright violations and is the subject of a ontributor copyright investigations/Scholarscentral|CCI. If any content is retained from this article it should be checked for copyright violations Deletion of OMICS Group Inc WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
20527 19078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Webe Kadima NONE NONE keep I've thought a bunch about this one because honestly I don't think the entry outrightly meets any of the notability guidelines. But at the end of the day, the reason for those guidelines----is to make sure we're providing readers with a reliable account. And I have vanishingly little concern that we might lead readers astray with this entry--much less so, in fact, than any number of entries that do meet our notability guidelines, but do so through popular press sources that in many cases are much less credible than the Dictionary of African Biography. Now, if the DAB were literally the only source, we might have a different issue, along the lines of : we can't create a Wikipedia entry by, essentially, copying the entry from another encyclopedia, especially not one that's not in the public domain! But that doesn't seem to be the issue here; the DAB provides some information for this entry, and confirms information from other sources we have Deletion of Webe Kadima WP:WHYN||WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20528 5793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marcus Foligno User:Resolute 15:26, 29 May 2011 (UTC) keep per Dolovis. Foligno easily meets , though it would be nice if he would integrate the articles he found into an expanded article Deletion of Marcus Foligno WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20529 12152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roadworthiness User:Davey2010 06:35, 9 April 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Roadworthiness WP:NOTDICTIONARY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20530 18661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dalton Gomez User:Aoi 19:57, 20 May 2021 (UTC) merge """WP:NOTINHERITED|notability is not inherited; subject does not meet on his own. All but three independent references listed on the page all reference Dalton Gomez according to his relationship with Grande, and the fact that one of the sources is literally titled """"Dalton Gomez: Who is Ariana Grande's husband? Mystery surrounds real estate agent who stayed out of spotlight"""" says quite a lot about his independent notability. (The other three independent sources are not """ Deletion of Dalton Gomez WP:NBIO||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
20531 15123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syboard User:Ohnoitsjamie 04:58, 26 April 2006 (UTC) delete Despite the article's claim that it is ''one of the most complete websites/companies on the net,'' does not meet . (Though maybe if we had a WP:Completeness criteria Deletion of Syboard WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20532 6674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allister Adel User:ErieSwiftByrd 02:58, 16 January 2020 (UTC) comment Upon reflection, her interim status does make her less notable than I otherwise might argue. Perhaps after the 2020 Arizona elections|election she can pass , but that's highly Wikipedia:CRYSTAL|speculative Deletion of Allister Adel WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20533 6812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Free From Conceptual Thoughts (LOUD Studio Album) User:ONUnicorn 17:10, 7 July 2015 (UTC) delete under due to the unambiguous copyright violation in the article's history. The only non-infringing content is the track list, and the earliest history contains the copyvio. I've been combing through the user's contributions speedying many other copyvios Deletion of Free From Conceptual Thoughts (LOUD Studio Album) WP:G12 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
20534 10034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eniaptycha User:Dekisugi 07:50, 12 November 2008 (UTC) delete of course. No references given. It falls to Deletion of Eniaptycha WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
20535 20820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amirhossein Jeddi User:Fenix 08:02, 11 April 2018 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Amirhossein Jeddi WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20536 14528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Freddyjrjr User:Tree 04:36, 17 September 2006 (UTC) delete fails and criterias. Alexa ranking of 2,939,924 http://www.alexa.com/data/details/main?q=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.freddyjrjr.com%2F&url=freddyjrjr.com Deletion of Freddyjrjr WP:ADS||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Spam 112
20537 17361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Britney Spears Seventh Studio Album User:Joe 14:06, 22 December 2009 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Britney Spears Seventh Studio Album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20538 8662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philip Jeays User:Alexandermcnabb 09:44, 1 June 2021 (UTC) delete Tagged for notability for a decade? Mr J's website cites some reviews from pretty mainstream media, but all unlinked from the '90s, before the modern era and all that. There's nothing much beyond the local papers quoted above, (''very'' local coverage) to meet out there now. Best Deletion of Philip Jeays WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20539 19678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Géa User:Teapotgeorge 16:25, 17 June 2011 (UTC) delete per and BOOK with no independent |reliable sources Deletion of Géa WP:N||WP:NBOOK||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20540 1635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amir Abdur Rehman Cheema (2nd nomination) User:Celestina007 08:34, 01 November 2017 (UTC) keep As per and . This article merits a space on the encylopedia Deletion of Amir Abdur Rehman Cheema (2nd nomination) WP:PERSISTENCE||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GOLDENRULE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20541 8557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dragonfly Productions NONE NONE comment The only problem is that client testimonials cannot be seen as anything that would give notability. The first reason would be that since they are associated with your company, their testimonials would be seen as sources at best. Primary sources are anything that is put out by you, your company, friends/family, or anyone that has used you to help make/produce something. The second reason is that even if the people involved were notable, notability is by the company having been associated with notable persons or even really notable films. Now if your company was given a notable award for creating something, then that could help show notability. The problem with awards is that the vast majority of them aren't notable, not per Wikipedia's rules. Only about 2% of any award for anything ever given in any scope give some sort of notability to the subject. Of that 2%, I'd say that most of them aren't the type that would give notability on that basis alone. As far as keeping the article because you do nice things for good purposes, we can't and don't keep articles because it would be nice to do so or because it'd be |useful. Your company would have to pass notability guidelines. Now as far as why it's not really a good idea to edit an article about a subject you're personally involved in is because it's so incredibly easy to not see things impartially. You'll see notability where there is none, write a sentence that you think is impartial but comes across as promotional in nature, as well as other things- all without ever really realizing that you're not being neutral. I'd somewhat recommend against telling someone to do direct editing to the article, because if they're not really familiar with how Wikipedia works then they might actually do more harm to the article than good. I'm not saying that they shouldn't contribute, just that it'd be a better idea for them to use the talk page to suggest additions and edits until they gain more familiarity with Wikipedia in general. Now as far as being well known goes, popularity and notoriety do not automatically mean notability here on Wikipedia. It's fairly common to have people, things, and companies that are well known and popular that do not pass notability guidelines. () It's actually more common for someone to be well known but not notable than it is to have someone that is well known '''and''' notable per Wikipedia guidelines. Notability is shown through reliable sources. Now as far as that goes, just because you can't directly edit or influence a source does not mean that it is reliable. I'm giving a rundown of the sources and why they might be usable or unusable Deletion of Dragonfly Productions WP:PRIMARY||WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:ITSUSEFUL||WP:VALINFO Wikipedia:No original research 65
20542 7532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scientific Software Database User:Alexius08 03:22, 25 July 2009 (UTC) delete as un|sourced |crystalballing Deletion of Scientific Software Database WP:RS||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20543 2436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charity Reuben User:Pharaoh 02:22, 2 August 2019 (UTC) keep Fails but scrapes thorugh Deletion of Charity Reuben WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20544 10938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Synthetic Removal Technology User:Redrose64 20:57, 29 February 2012 (UTC) comment Background: I saw that this article had been given a {{tlx|db-g7}}, and reverted that because I didn't agree that it met #G7 (tagger was creator and primary author, but some content was added by others). I suggested that it go to in order to gain wider notice Deletion of Synthetic Removal Technology WP:CSD||WP:AFD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
20545 5215 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joaquín Carbonell User:GiantSnowman 17:19, 27 May 2013 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Joaquín Carbonell WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20546 19815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kieran Murtagh User:Masterpiece2000 08:03, 16 June 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Kieran Murtagh WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20547 11499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OGOGO User:Mazca 10:26, 31 May 2008 (UTC) keep I've cleaned the article up a little - it seems from a quick look around that this artist might just about fulfil #5 as Lugnuts says, but I'm having trouble finding much meaningful coverage of them anywhere to reference the article Deletion of OGOGO WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20548 1537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Holy Kiss User:TenPoundHammer 20:54, 19 November 2007 (UTC) delete fails all criteria of Deletion of The Holy Kiss WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20549 18916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zionist hunter User:Zoporific 20:40, 7 February 2008 (UTC) delete Probably a case of . Author has preformed quite a few POV pro-Palestinaian/anti-Israeli edits in the past Deletion of Zionist hunter WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
20550 7673 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Jersey Route 64 User:RichsLaw 09:02, 8 September 2009 (UTC) delete simply doesn't pass , and not surprising, because it's just a tiny road Deletion of New Jersey Route 64 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20551 12217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of last games released on video game consoles user:Hellknowz 17:32, 11 November 2015 (UTC) delete """as a non-notable topic. This is fairly arbitrary criteria where many factors affect a """"release date"""". While """"useful"""" is not a deletion criteria, I don't see how this list is helpful in encyclopedic manner. Not to mention verifying the individual items would be and . Truly """"final"""" game by some criteria can be mentioned in game's and console's articles. — """ Deletion of List of last games released on video game consoles WP:OR||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
20552 20505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of SDFL football clubs User:Armbrust 13:38, 4 November 2010 (UTC) delete as |Wikipedia is not a directory. Article contains mostly non-notable entries Deletion of List of SDFL football clubs WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20553 10352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faye McMillan User:Xxanthippe 07:30, 18 July 2019 (UTC) delete Not remotely a pass of rof#C1 on basis of citations in GS. I don't see enough yet for Deletion of Faye McMillan WP:P||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Portal 85
20554 303 [[Ingrid Elisabeth Krummacher]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers 00:34, 15. Jul. 2012 (CEST) delete Kasten|1= gemäß Diskussion. Kein Nachweis für die Veröffentlichungen, damit die Relevanz als Autorin nach unseren #Autoren|Kriterien nicht dargestellt, ebenso wenig wie eine sonstige öffentliche Wahrnehmung. Gruß Löschung von Ingrid Elisabeth Krummacher Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
20555 19241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tan-Hauser Gate User:MER 10:50, 31 January 2007 (UTC) delete fails . Added Template:Tan-Hauser Gate to the nomination, don't forget to get rid of those vanity/fair use pics too Deletion of Tan-Hauser Gate WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20556 8349 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of tallest buildings in 2020 User:Astronaut 00:46, 20 July 2009 (UTC) delete the construction business is way too volatile for this list to be maintainable in any sensible manner. (for example: just Nakheel Tower|one of the proposed buildings has had its planned height changed five times, its location changed three times, and its name changed three times as well). This is a maintenance nightmare waiting to happen which also fails Deletion of List of tallest buildings in 2020 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20557 16754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Outrage porn User:Bacondrum 01:03, 2 June 2019 (UTC) comment Indeed , I think the article is a lot better now Deletion of Outrage porn WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
20558 4324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trick arrows User:Zxcvbnm 18:00, 16 January 2020 (UTC) delete Maybe potential for a List of arrow types that could go alongside :Category:Arrow types, but this particular article is just fancruft and should be deleted per Deletion of Trick arrows WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
20559 5773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Honor Oak Christian Fellowship Centre [[User talk:180.172.239.231|talk]]) 12:40, 1 September 2014 (UTC) comment ping|Peterkingiron}} The article contains only one source, and I can't verify it. Hardly will this source |be considered '''neutral''', '''credible''' and '''sufficiently detailed''' for a comprehensive article. --Special:Contributions/180.172.239.231|180.172.239.231 Deletion of Honor Oak Christian Fellowship Centre WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20560 9520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Craig Carless User:Fenix 10:29, 29 September 2014 (UTC) delete Fail as have not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subjects have garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Craig Carless WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20561 16593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vincent Gray (consultant) User:Oren0 18:18, 30 December 2007 (UTC) comment """I've added two more sources that establish notability. One is a feature piece in the New Zealand Herald (with a picture, no less) that refers to him as a """"prominent"""" climate skeptic. The other is a radio interview on ABC's Counterpoint (Radio National)|Counterpoint. Does this help put the notability concerns to bed, or should we add more sources? He's mentioned very non-trivially by more than enough |reliable sources to qualify as notable. Additionally, both of these sources refer to him as a scientist and I intend to propose a move back to Vincent Gray (scientist) should this article result in a keep""" Deletion of Vincent Gray (consultant) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20562 18143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Primitive Race User:Ritchie333 10:02, 17 September 2013 (UTC) keep """per http://louderthanwar.com/primitive-race-industrial-super-group-launch-crowd-funding-you-get-a-paper-bag/ this, http://regenmag.com/news/mysterious-industrial-super-group-on-the-rise/ this and http://www.mxdwn.com/2013/05/28/news/industrial-heavyweights-chris-vrenna-luc-van-acker-raymond-watts-dave-ogilvie-and-chris-kniker-unite-to-form-new-band-primitive-race/ this which confirms the band pass criteria #6 ''""""Is an ensemble which contains two or more independently notable musicians""""''. Transceration, we have kept the article on Tapeworm (band) because it cites Kerrang!, Rolling Stone and MTV, and if you can find articles in these three publications that talk '''directly''' about Primitive Race, it will help enormously with improving the article. The problem with Soundcloud it that''anybody'' can create music and host it there, and claiming you should keep a band article based on presence there is akin to voting """"keep"""" because they have a phone number and email address. It's nothing special""" Deletion of Primitive Race WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20563 7393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unit (art collective) User:AllyD 14:48, 22 December 2014 (UTC) delete I added a couple of basic links that at least confirm that events occurred but am not finding anything substantial that would indicate critical attention or evaluation of Unit as such. The principals of the group don't appear to have the established notability in their own right which might confer retrospective notability on this group, as suggested above, nor does notability |inherit from putting on exhibitions by say John Latham (artist)|John Latham, much of whose career probably preceded the lifespan of the Unit members. Unless someone can identify actual |coverage of the group itself, this fails Deletion of Unit (art collective) :WP:NOTINHERITED||:WP:RS||:WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20564 989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noncommutative polynomial User:David 02:22, 20 December 2009 (UTC) delete Given the content fork issues, the Wikipedia:Contributor copyright investigations/Henry Delforn|copyright problems involving its main contributor, and issues with its too-narrow focus, it doesn't seem that this is a helpful contribution. No prejudice against someone later creating a proper article on the subject Deletion of Noncommutative polynomial WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
20565 422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cage (enclosure) (2nd nomination) User:SMcCandlish 02:10, 3 October 2017 (UTC) keep as a basic topic we must have an article on, though the page clearly needs some work. This should be closed Deletion of Cage (enclosure) (2nd nomination) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
20566 18822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bertha (song) User:Esradekan 02:13, 24 April 2009 (UTC) delete as a non-plausible search term, fails notability per #Songs. No awards, no chart, no covers, no Deletion of Bertha (song) WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20567 8144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arghoslent User:Grandmasterka 22:26, 30 September 2006 (UTC) delete Gosh, if 1000 last.fm plays and some interviews is all you're looking for, my band could ''easily'' have an article! Fails utterly Deletion of Arghoslent WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20568 11771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Ford (cricketer) User:Reywas92 05:23, 27 March 2021 (UTC) delete Lacks significant coverage. Fails , which says sports database entries are not satisfactory to establish notability. Performance on a youth team does not contribute to notability, especially without any substantive sources about him in particular Deletion of John Ford (cricketer) WP:SPORTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20569 17299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New York Liberal (beer cocktail) User:King 22:37, 8 October 2013 (UTC) delete Would tag for A7 were cocktails |created by some bored guy one day eligible for that criterion Deletion of New York Liberal (beer cocktail) WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
20570 16404 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeeshan Khan (actor) User:Sunshine1191 14:51, 24 November 2020 (UTC) delete Doesn't fulfill |NACTOR as of now Deletion of Zeeshan Khan (actor) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
20571 5594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gurglin Gutz user:Andrew 10:12, 4 February 2021 (UTC) keep """It's easy to find coverage in the ''https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1995-11-21-9511210328-story.html Chicago Tribune'', ''https://www.nytimes.com/1999/09/05/nyregion/new-yorkers-co-toys-and-items-that-began-as-found-objects.html New York Times'', ''https://www.google.co.uk/books/edition/Encyclopedia_of_Major_Marketing_Campaign/MWUPAQAAMAAJ?hl=en Encyclopedia of Major Marketing Campaigns'', &c. Our policy applies, """"''If editing can improve the page, this should be done rather than deleting the page""" Deletion of Gurglin Gutz WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20572 20448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Personal relationship skills User:Mkdw 05:44, 30 December 2013 (UTC) delete This 'article' falls into so many categories that it is too many to list. What I find the most problematic is the amount of loosely based |synthesis of information and sources that as a topic it seems that this subtopic does exist but this article is too broad. While I understand the authors attempt to create a helpful article, Wikipedia is not a self-help relationship advice giving website. Also, to VisitingPhilosopher, I do not believe you have correctly applied some of the policies, guidelines, and essays you have linked as saying the article meets Deletion of Personal relationship skills WP:NOT||WP:SYNTHESIS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20573 1853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AFerry User:Themfromspace 19:47, 24 December 2013 (UTC) delete This is a great example of |wikipuffery, where a page is built up to appear like a decent article in an attempt to fool editors into thinking the subject is notable. The bar for getting a website mentioned in passing by reliable sources is small. Add PR pieces to the mix and you can build an encyclopedic-''looking'' but still promotional article about a website pretty easily. And this doesn't help the encyclopedia at all as the website need have no significant impact on the world. Thankfully we have that provision in our notability guidelines requiring in-depth analysis of the subject by multiple reliable sources. This insures that we don't become a database of every website out there, or one that sets itself up for exploitation by PR types Deletion of AFerry WP:PUFF Wikipedia:Wikipuffery 0
20574 21269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Creation (Exalted) User:Sandstein 22:14, 27 September 2007 (UTC) delete WP:FAN|Vanity of |vanities, saith Ecclesiastes|the Preacher, |vanity of |vanities; all is |vanity Deletion of Creation (Exalted) WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NOR||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20575 6288 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Template Band User:Xtifr 11:57, 20 November 2006 (UTC) delete but wouldn't this be more appropriately discussed under TfD? :) Just kidding, clearly fails to meet Deletion of Template Band WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20576 13101 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/G-Unit feuds User:Resolute 05:46, 30 June 2007 (UTC) delete aside from the fact that there are zero ''reliable'' sources on this article, most of these feuds are trivial, and the few that aren't are better documented (and sourced) on the articles about the artists themselves. A lot of concerns as well Deletion of G-Unit feuds WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20577 21772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Investment Corporation of Dubai User:HighKing 12:21, 6 October 2020 (UTC) delete I am unable to locate any |significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, references to date fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic therefore fails GNG/ Deletion of Investment Corporation of Dubai WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20578 17865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tajikistan at the 2013 Asian Youth Games User:Malcolmxl5 11:13, 3 June 2016 (UTC) merge to the main games article. This could have been done |boldly without bringing this and others here Deletion of Tajikistan at the 2013 Asian Youth Games WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
20579 9016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Limoz Dizdari User:PWilkinson 15:26, 21 June 2015 (UTC) comment From the Google results, I rather suspect someone able to read Albanian could fairly quickly establish and probably for the subject - the real problem here is that the subject seems to have established his reputation as a composer during the Communist period, when Albania almost totally isolated itself from the outside world, and, while still well-known in Albania, to have made relatively little attempt to develop an international reputation since then. Also, it looks likely that he meets - his Polish Wikipedia article claims (admittedly without references) that he was elected to the Albanian Parliament in 1997, and page 62 of http://www.parlament.al/graphics/foto/Legjislatura.pdf this publication of the Albanian Parliament does confirm that a Limoz Dizdari, the Google translation of whose biographical details do seem to match the information we otherwise have on the subject, was a member at least between 2001 and 2005. Can anyone with some knowledge of Albanian help Deletion of Limoz Dizdari WP:GNG||WP:COMPOSER||WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20580 7179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeri-KO User:WarMachineWildThing 04:59, 23 August 2016 (UTC) delete Fails and is Deletion of Jeri-KO WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
20581 17384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Applied Science (video game) User:Czar 16:57, 3 November 2012 (UTC) delete WP:GNG|GNG is how WP determines which topics/ideas get article space (encyclopedia, |not directory). This game does not yet meet this criteria Deletion of Applied Science (video game) WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20582 2474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sumon (Aurthohin) User:Kmzayeem 08:53, 15 April 2014 (UTC) keep per , sources - http://archive.thedailystar.net/magazine/2007/04/01/music.htm, http://www.banglamusic.com/artists/sumon/, http://www.banglanews24.com/detailsnews.php?nssl=987d824465b7718c4aa3cc8a9e8530db&nttl=71077 Deletion of Sumon (Aurthohin) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20583 5923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solar ventilation User:Empty 11:10, 1 July 2010 (UTC) merge to one of the above or Solar air heat. Editor has also created Solar air collector and SUN ECO AIR today, all three with a highly tone and all solely referenced with links to a single company that sells this technology. SUN ECO AIR has just been speedied as spam Deletion of Solar ventilation WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20584 12235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Curto User:David 17:47, 28 February 2008 (UTC) delete Community-college instructor and freelance photographer. I see neither the academic achievements that would pass nor the artistic achievements (major awards, reviews, exhibits in important museums and galleries) that would pass Deletion of Jeff Curto WP:PROF||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20585 19160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Widow * Second Wife: Real Sucking Engulfing a Rare Utensil User:Testales 12:58, 3 August 2010 (UTC) keep What right do we have to declare a place 8 award in a notable Japanese award ceremony as unimportant? There are over 20 Oscar_nominations|Oscar category awards and even getting nominated for just one estabilishes a certain notabililty. So how would we as non experts tell that a place 8 award in Japan lacks relevance? At least I have not seen any prove for this here. I am also impressed of the deep knowledge that Dekkappai and Cherryblossom1982 have in that field, so there is nothing to add to their comphrehensive explanations which even for an (open) western eye should make the inclusion of this article plausible. Both main editors are hardworking experts and would be loss for Wikipedia when stopping their contributions. Furthermore the nominator lacks obviously and without any doubt in this area which even goes to name-calling of involved editorshttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Administrators%27_noticeboard/Incidents&diff=prev&oldid=375897186http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Administrators%27_noticeboard/Incidents&diff=prev&oldid=375915608http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Administrators%27_noticeboard/Incidents&diff=prev&oldid=376082318 Deletion of Widow * Second Wife: Real Sucking Engulfing a Rare Utensil WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
20586 2760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesusry User:RockMFR 03:51, 30 November 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Jesusry WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
20587 13612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Twigger User:Dustimagic 03:41, 12 February 2006 (UTC) delete as per nom, Deletion of Paul Twigger WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20588 754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Young Mahasi User:SamHolt6 03:08, 27 November 2017 (UTC) comment I have been watching the changes made to this article by the article creator. Despite more content being added, it is my view that these changes only add more press-release style information. Additional, the adding of links to notable people with Wikipedia articles is superfluous as |notability is not inherited. I'm sticking with delete Deletion of Young Mahasi WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20589 893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shawn P. Wilbur User:Starblind 00:02, 22 March 2009 (UTC) delete as above and per , , . Appears to be (surprise!) a issue as well Deletion of Shawn P. Wilbur WP:N||WP:V||WP:BIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
20590 21204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deborah Mayer User:Badgerpatrol 02:05, 4 October 2007 (UTC) keep Notable enough but in an ideal world would be renamed and rewritten to conform to BLP- no prejudice against the nomination, which is technically correct, but per the much-abused it's better to have an article that doesn't quite conform to policy but doesn't otherwise do any harm than no article at all. Kudos to whomever removed Mightyms' steaming pile of insulting ill-informed sh... erm, comment Deletion of Deborah Mayer WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
20591 15749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Knight class User:Haipa 22:47, 12 June 2009 (UTC) delete Fails , , etc Deletion of Knight class WP:GAMEGUIDE||WP:OR||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20592 21334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Australian Muslim Party User:E 14:26, 15 February 2016 (UTC) delete this new political party got a flurry of publicity the day after it was founded last November, so it is sort of like , it was founded, people noticed. But until it wins elections, or gains ongoing attention of some sort, it lacks notability Deletion of Australian Muslim Party WP:1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
20593 9549 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unniyarcha (film) User:Donaldd23 16:27, 27 December 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Unniyarcha (film) WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
20594 17088 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anjub Botawala User:Whiteguru 09:34, 18 February 2021 (UTC) delete Does not meet requirements of Deletion of Anjub Botawala WP:NCRICKET Wikipedia:Notability 77
20595 20229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greenie Bus (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep nbsp; #1, #2|#2b, #2|#2c, with prejudice against speedy renomination Deletion of Greenie Bus (2nd nomination) WP:SK||WP:SK||WP:SK Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
20596 5085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All Natural Food Zone User:Ignatzmice 22:45, 25 April 2013 (UTC) delete """ec}} reads like ery (just as one example, 5 50M page hits ≠ 5 50M users), and the name """"Coolboygcp"""" implies a COI (site is created by George Poulos), though the account's been in use for a year and a half. Not sure if I'm using Topsy right, but I can't find the supposed tweets by @barackobama http://topsy.com/s?q=food+zone+from%3Abarackobama http://topsy.com/s/naturalfoodblog+from%3ABarackObama http://topsy.com/allnaturalfoodzone.blogspot.com/?contains=from%3Abarackobama or @whitehouse http://topsy.com/s?q=naturalfoodzone+from%3Awhitehouse http://topsy.com/s?q=naturalfoodblog+from%3Awhitehouse http://topsy.com/allnaturalfoodzone.blogspot.com/?contains=from%3Awhitehouse. No indication of real notability; fails """ Deletion of All Natural Food Zone WP:PUFF||WP:WEBCRIT Wikipedia:Wikipuffery 0
20597 3305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pascal Plisson User:Comte0 14:02, 7 April 2019 (UTC) keep The :fr:Pascal Plisson|French article has sources from Le Figaro, Le Monde and Canal+, which make it pass . Regards Deletion of Pascal Plisson WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20598 13983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karen Hall Stewart User:scope_creep 20:11, 18 June 2020 (UTC) delete No real coverage outwith the above puff articles. Couldn't find a single notable ref. Fails and Deletion of Karen Hall Stewart WP:BIO||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
20599 2762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of UK Admiralty Charts, 1967 User:Reywas92 14:18, 15 July 2021 (UTC) delete This is basically a copy-paste of the https://archive.org/details/catalogue-admiralty-charts-hydrographic-publications-1967-images/page/24/mode/2up ''Catalogue of Admiralty Charts 1967 Complete Edition'' and I fail to see why this directory of maps available in that year is a notable encyclopedic topic, sourced only to this primary source which it replicates. This link – which can certainly be useful – should be highlighed in the Admiralty chart but it's not clear what makes this catalogue an article Deletion of List of UK Admiralty Charts, 1967 WP:CATALOG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20600 4726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terrence Keith Ashwin User:Piotrus 21:21, 26 June 2014 (UTC) delete No significant coverage to satisfy per nom Deletion of Terrence Keith Ashwin WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20601 8279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ARC Weekly Top 40 User:Gavin 11:24, 24 February 2010 (UTC) delete as this list fails #MIRROR as it is a reguritation of the ARC website and lacks any evidence of notability Deletion of ARC Weekly Top 40 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20602 18701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of occupations of secret identity personas of fictional characters User:Philg88 07:00, 17 June 2014 (UTC) merge Delete''' to Secret identity. Please see comment below. Wp:GNG|Non-notable topic per |stand-alone list criteria. No |reliable sources available. The topic could be dealt with in a section in Secret identity, but that article is precipitously close to its own AfD Deletion of List of occupations of secret identity personas of fictional characters WP:NOTESAL||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20603 8337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dog poop girl (3rd nomination) User:Wildthing61476 20:20, 6 May 2008 (UTC) keep The event was well covered, and has been used as an example of how the internet has been used to harass people. Perhaps the name of the article should be changed, but even this is , it's still notable enough for an article Deletion of Dog poop girl (3rd nomination) WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20604 21141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adis Husidić User:Jmundo 02:52, 21 January 2009 (UTC) keep Meets per the sources found by Nfitz and Panyd Deletion of Adis Husidić WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20605 19225 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward Kotlyanskiy User:Chzz 07:07, 8 May 2010 (UTC) delete I have to agree with the nominator. This article was made via |articles for creation. I reviewed it, and after much hunting for more sources, I declined it as not meeting . The user then asked for further help and, after discussion, I got two other experienced Wikipedians to independently double-check my assessment. They, also, did not locate any |reliable sources other than chess clubs, and were similarly not able to accept the submission and make the article live. After these discussions, the user themself decided to move it to the live area. Per all assessments, and particularly with |BLP caution, I do not feel this person meets the requirements of |notability Deletion of Edward Kotlyanskiy WP:AFC||WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:BLP||WP:N Wikipedia:Articles for creation 55
20606 4445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nattasha Nauljam User:Northamerica1000 06:35, 9 April 2014 (UTC) delete Not finding significant coverage in reliable sources for the subject. Appears to not meet for a Wikipedia article Deletion of Nattasha Nauljam WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20607 14179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Zenon User:Paulmcdonald 17:02, 14 September 2020 (UTC) keep passes just from sources in the article Deletion of Jonathan Zenon WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20608 17875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sylvia Scott User:Glenfarclas 02:48, 18 January 2010 (UTC) delete fails . Reliable-source mentions like http://books.google.com/books?id=L-oCAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA54&lpg=PA54&dq=%22Sylvia+Patterson-Scott%22&source=bl&ots=7Jv9XqsDLO&sig=qI-6ZD-MjO19r5vRYE3cwpFaiKo&hl=en&ei=nMtTS5jyHoP8Nc7R0OYI&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=24&ved=0CEEQ6AEwFw#v=onepage&q=%22Sylvia%20Patterson-Scott%22&f=false this don't quite cut it Deletion of Sylvia Scott WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20609 20889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/XS Energy Drink (2nd nomination) User:Tgeairn 03:01, 17 February 2012 (UTC) delete per roduct or '''Redirect''' to Amway_Global#Products by same rationale. There is no established |notability that singles out this individual product Deletion of XS Energy Drink (2nd nomination) WP:P||WP:N Wikipedia:Portal 85
20610 6067 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephen Mulcahy User:TCN7JM 01:56, 28 September 2013 (UTC) delete Yeah, it doesn't look like he's played in a league that would make him famous per Deletion of Stephen Mulcahy WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20611 13335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ed Welch User:RebeccaGreen 15:27, 20 May 2019 (UTC) keep per sourcing by Deletion of Ed Welch WP:HEYMANN Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
20612 6658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David L. Richards User:Yngvadottir 19:02, 24 September 2019 (UTC) delete The strongest argument for notability seems to me to be that he cofounded the CIRI Human Rights Data Project, which is mentioned in the infobox but not in the article text; see https://today.uconn.edu/2015/03/violence-against-women-the-scope-and-strength-of-the-law/ this ''UConn Today'' article about the book he co-wrote (not cited in the article). I'm not sure that's enough. What tips me toward recommending deletion is that {{U|Richardsdl!!}}, saying he was the article subject, tried to have it deleted in 2016: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=David_L._Richards&diff=755729652&oldid=755677533 blanking, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=David_L._Richards&diff=755772626&oldid=755747269 speedy templating. (There were also photo substitutions by {{U|Sophia1778}}, who apparently said on Commons that she was Richards' wife.) In cases of marginal notability, we usually respect the subject's wishes. Things are complicated by suggestions that the article creator, {{U|Daver68}}, was Richards ... but I'm going to |assume that if that was so, the subject had a change of heart about the article, and come down on the side of honoring the request. Since Daver68 has been notified of this discussion, I'll also drop notifications on the other two account talk pages in addition to my pings here Deletion of David L. Richards WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
20613 19571 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neferti Tadiar User:Superastig 03:00, 13 June 2020 (UTC) keep Article easily passes Deletion of Neferti Tadiar WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
20614 4152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1988–89 Newport County A.F.C. season User:Brichcja 06:39, 8 September 2020 (UTC) keep multiple coverage from national sources, so meets Deletion of 1988–89 Newport County A.F.C. season WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20615 6807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of emo artists User:Neon 23:12, 18 April 2008 (UTC) keep Article is a fork of the obviously notable Emo article, has clearly defined criteria (see other similar lists List of pop punk bands, List of J-pop artists) and is based entirely on verfiable sources including MTV, AOL music, Rolling Stone, BBC, NY Times to name a few. It is not OR under any definition. ''Contention'' is a content issue which effects many articles on wikipedia and is not a valid reason for deletion. Categories and lists are not exclusive as defined in guidelines (Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigational templates). I suggest the nominee withdraws the afd as a mistaken nomination as there is no valid #REASON|criteria for deletion given in the nomination and most experienced editors can see the article is obviously notable. --neonwhite Deletion of List of emo artists WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20616 3021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luka Magnotta (4th nomination) [[User talk:66.102.83.61|talk]]) 06:14, 17 June 2012 (UTC) keep The murder of Lin Jun is notable but . The fabricated nonsense about an affair with Karla Homolka is not, nor is most of the other attention whoring that's found its way onto this page. If notability exists for one event only, the article should be named for the event, not for a suspect who has neither been charged nor tried for the . Special:Contributions/66.102.83.61|66.102.83.61 Deletion of Luka Magnotta (4th nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:BLPCRIME Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20617 529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kids Next Door Sector V [[User talk:Yngvarr|Yng]][[Special:Contributions/Yngvarr|varr]] 19:11, 2 January 2008 (UTC) delete If you were to address the |guesses and suppositions of this article, you'd end up with pretty much nothing which isn't already contained in Codename: Kids Next Door Deletion of Kids Next Door Sector V WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
20618 6333 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Geier User:Lacypaperclip 00:22, 20 September 2017 (UTC) comment An editor said here that I did not perfom . https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Mike_Geier&diff=next&oldid=801472931, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Lacypaperclip&oldid=801436655. He is incorrect. I always do a before first, before undertaking a decision to place an article at AFD Deletion of Mike Geier WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20619 18128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gumbercules User:Reyk 01:19, 4 August 2008 (UTC) delete per #G7|author blanking. So tagged Deletion of Gumbercules WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
20620 14054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grey's Anatomy in popular culture User:Omghgomg 22:10, 30 September 2007 (UTC) comment The reason I created this article was due to . Now that I think about it, it was really pointless as this article contains trivial information. So, I'm not going vote to keep or delete, rather, merge would be preferable Deletion of Grey's Anatomy in popular culture WP:SIZE Wikipedia:Article size 51
20621 8190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dennis Yan User:Rlendog 01:36, 19 April 2016 (UTC) delete """I can't agree that this article, at over 200 words with multiple references is a """"substub"""" or even close to one. But the references present do not add up to notability, and the accomplishments do not meet """ Deletion of Dennis Yan WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20622 20896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krishnology (2nd nomination) User:Snottywong 16:36, 30 August 2010 (UTC) delete Pretty clearly a non-notable eologism|neologism with little or no use outside of WP. Good nomination Deletion of Krishnology (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20623 21851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sauerländer Heimatbund User:JD554 17:22, 23 August 2008 (UTC) delete article only has three references, none of which appear to be |reliable sources. Fails and Deletion of Sauerländer Heimatbund WP:RS||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20624 1283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/American Graphics Institute NONE 05:53, 19 November 2009 (UTC) keep per and meets . Their conference attracts speakers like Michael Eisner, Al Gore, and Marissa Mayer which should be enough to meet and it is much larger than MIX_(Microsoft). Their large number of current books published by Wiley_Publishing also meets . Edward Dewey Deletion of American Graphics Institute WP:HEY||WP:V||WP:N||WP:N Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
20625 1755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hillary Bus User:Bearian 16:41, 17 May 2016 (UTC) delete Yes, I endorsed the proposed deletion as non-controversial. It is |only vaguely related to the campaign, and |gives undue weight to one type of event. Four of |the sources are decent, but the others are social media. If truly needed, ''merge'' as suggested Deletion of Hillary Bus WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:UNDUE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20626 20847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unhexseptium User:Yilloslime 02:14, 16 January 2009 (UTC) delete """Contrary to many !keep votes, this element is most definitely '''not''' covered by the exception in noted in , as it has '''not''' been documented by IUPAC. This is more analogous to the hurricane example cited in item of CRYSTAL: """"Individual items from a predetermined list or a systematic pattern of names, pre-assigned to future events or discoveries, are not suitable article topics, if only generic information is known about the item. Lists of tropical cyclone names is encyclopedic; """"Tropical Storm Alberto (2012)"""" is not, even though it is virtually certain that a storm of that name will occur in the North Atlantic and will turn counterclockwise."""" We know what this element will likely be provisionally named ''if it's ever observed'', but so far it hasn't been observed, and, as there are only 8 googlehits for the termhttp://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=Unhexseptium&btnG=Google+Search&aq=f&oq= it seems no one is even doing theoretical on """"unhexseptium."""" (This would also suggest this article is mostly |original research). List of hypothesized transuranic elements might be encyclopedic, but individual articles such as this one are not""" Deletion of Unhexseptium WP:CRYSTAL||WP:OR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20627 5819 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Boston Rockers User:Pepsidrinka 19:11, 29 May 2007 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of The Boston Rockers WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20628 21748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toenut User:J 21:54, 16 June 2006 (UTC) keep It seems that this article might have been copied from somewhere. Then again, it might be someone's essay. In either case is needs serious work. However, the band seems to meet . (3 albums, 2 national tours (US & UK)...) But there is a serious lack of Deletion of Toenut WP:BAND||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
20629 18821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional films User:Erik 18:52, 17 August 2013 (UTC) keep because the topic appears to meet notability guidelines per as seen by a reference like http://entertainment.ca.msn.com/movies/galleries/fictional-films-that-should-be-made this. However, I would suggest starting over with the list and require |selection criteria, in this case requiring a secondary source to add an item. This list reminds me of List of teen films, which was http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=List_of_teen_films&oldid=415465262 this before I argued to keep it and revised it Deletion of List of fictional films WP:NOTESAL||WP:LSC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20630 10867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bhavin Turakhia User:Vinay089 14:54, 19 June 2016 (UTC) delete No grounds asserted for notability meeting . Turakhia's article looks like an advertisement & promotion page of the person and his brands, who has done lots of PR done online and not received any significant awards/recognition - otability. Seems a good business person from India but not notable Deletion of Bhavin Turakhia WP:BIO||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20631 19121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robin Holm [[User_talk:ClubOranje|Oranje]][[User_talk:ClubOranje|T]] 09:11, 9 October 2017 (UTC) delete Fails , and subject specific guideline which specifically says youth footballers do not have inherent notability. Coverage is for footballers with potential and does not indicate this person is any different from the many thousands of youth players which the above guidelines tell us shouldn't have stand alone articles. Club Deletion of Robin Holm WP:ANYBIO||WP:TOOSOON||WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20632 2710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 North American heat wave User:Bearcat 18:32, 9 July 2018 (UTC) delete """In the age of climate change, it's very likely that almost ''every'' year will ''always'' be able to claim that ''some'' part of the world set new summer heat records at some point during the northern and/or southern summers — and it's certainly true that ''every'' summer ''always'' has a stretch of days that are hot enough that even if they're not quite ''record'' heat, are still hot enough ''somewhere'' that ''somebody'' deems it a """"heat wave"""". But it takes much more than that to turn a hot summer into a noteworthy heat wave — namely, it takes significant ''effects'' referenced to |reliable source coverage that ''supports'' the significance of the effects, and ''not'' just the ability to single-source the fact that ''somebody'' declared that a heat wave was ''happening''. But this is referenced to just one |routine weather report stating that a heat wave was on its way but had not yet hit at the time of the source's publication, which is not enough to make a """"heat wave"""" ''notable'' in and of itself""" Deletion of 2016 North American heat wave WP:RS||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20633 1936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vincent Yatz User:Rorshacma 15:54, 17 December 2020 (UTC) merge to Creeper (DC Comics) - Unlike the other two Creeper-related AFDs today, this character does get a few brief mentions here or there under his various names, largely due to the fact that he is explicitly tied to the origin of the notable character, The Creeper. Not enough to actually pass the or support an independent article, but enough that it would make sense to redirect this page to the main page on the Creeper, where he is actually already discussed quite a bit Deletion of Vincent Yatz WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20634 1371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jacksonville Ninja User:RFerreira 02:18, 19 February 2010 (UTC) delete as this fails and the more general guidelines Deletion of Jacksonville Ninja WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20635 7961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeNique Ford User:Paulmcdonald 04:03, 13 September 2014 (UTC) delete hey I haven't played professional football either, can I have a free Wikipedia page? Clearly fails Deletion of DeNique Ford WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20636 20565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Lorenzen User:Metropolitan90 07:04, 10 July 2006 (UTC) delete Considering the subject as an academic, he does not appear to be more notable than the average professor. See Deletion of Michael Lorenzen WP:PROFTEST Wikipedia:Notability 77
20637 11047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pongthep Pumsiri User:Fenix 17:39, 10 February 2015 (UTC) delete Player fails as has not played in a |fully professional league, nor senior international football. No indication of any other achievements that have garnered sufficient, significant coverage to satisfy Deletion of Pongthep Pumsiri WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20638 15322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bradley Nelson User:David 05:51, 3 February 2016 (UTC) keep He is both an IEEE Fellow and an ASME Fellow. That's two passes of . His https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=lFI6TqAAAAAJ Google scholar profile shows an h-index of 54 and over 30 papers with over 100 citations each, well over the threshold for #C1. And though I can't find clear evidence of it, I strongly suspect that his professorship at ETHZ is a lot closer to a distinguished professorship at a US university than to a regular full professorship; if so that would be another pass Deletion of Bradley Nelson WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20639 7410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skeem (2011 film) User:Atlantic306 21:18, 19 January 2019 (UTC) keep as per as the article has been substantially improved since nomination including content referenced to multiple reliable sources coverage such as National newspapers including a secondary review in the South African Mail and Guardian, thanks Deletion of Skeem (2011 film) WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
20640 16682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al Falah College (2nd nomination) User:4meter4 00:26, 3 March 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Al Falah College (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
20641 645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Allison Stanger User:David 18:22, 3 October 2011 (UTC) keep """At first I thought the nominator's scattershot approach to academic AfDs had hit a good target, because there was nothing in the article as nominated that would suggest a pass of . But I think she does pass, by virtue of her named chair, and that she also passes for the continuing media attention to her book """"One Nation Under Contract""" Deletion of Allison Stanger WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20642 5475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Athena School of Management User:Richigi 13:25, 2 December 2012 (UTC) delete Fails every measure of Deletion of Athena School of Management WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20643 19254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conducive Isocracy User:Bearian 18:31, 15 August 2014 (UTC) delete this is |spam masquerading as |original research about |a phrase made up just |last year Deletion of Conducive Isocracy WP:SPAM||WP:OR||WP:MADEUPONEDAY||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Spam 112
20644 11961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boss Ross User:Mallocks 12:36, 3 October 2005 (UTC) delete unsigned band, fails Deletion of Boss Ross WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20645 10287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/When You're Young (film) User:Donaldd23 16:58, 17 April 2021 (UTC) delete Fails and reeks of self promotion Deletion of When You're Young (film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20646 15118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devann Yao User:Angryapathy 16:29, 3 February 2010 (UTC) delete Fails as he has not played in the professional level Deletion of Devann Yao WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20647 4252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Star Wars Episode VII (2nd nomination) User:Robsinden 10:34, 31 October 2012 (UTC) comment """Have any of the editors voting for """"keep"""" read ? I hope the closing admin takes this into account too""" Deletion of Star Wars Episode VII (2nd nomination) WP:ATA Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20648 7743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aluma Shield User:MB 03:30, 2 January 2017 (UTC) delete Concur with nom. Insufficient coverage to meet Deletion of Aluma Shield WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20649 13134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Art of Charm User:Ihcoyc 14:44, 3 August 2010 (UTC) delete weakly. Note that this is about ''a New York and Los Angeles based service company specializing in dating coaching for men and women''. It does have some coverage in reliable sources, but those would appear to be mostly human interest stories that do not establish that this business has enough |historical, technical, or cultural significance to achieve Notability in Wikipedia|long term historical notability. The sources seem rather inflated, and many are local access TV shows and commercial sites of various sorts, suggesting puffery Deletion of The Art of Charm WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20650 9930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Mykles User:Soetermans 08:40, 14 May 2016 (UTC) delete Does not meet . Only mentioned in passing Deletion of Christopher Mykles WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20651 13567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theresa Fairbanks Harris User:Hammersoft 21:02, 25 October 2018 (UTC) delete As ThatMontrealIP notes, failure of . I too looked around for references, and found precious little. Yes, she exists, yes she's as the article states, but there's almost nothing out there about her but passing references. Also fails Wikipedia:Notability (academics). Of note; while searching I found the article to be a copy of https://www.biographies.net/bio/m/0bwl4l5. https://tools.wmflabs.org/copyvios/?lang=en&project=wikipedia&title=Theresa+Fairbanks+Harris&oldid=&use_engine=0&use_links=0&turnitin=0&action=compare&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.biographies.net%2Fbio%2Fm%2F0bwl4l5 See Earwig report. I can't tell whether that resource copied from here or us from them. This article's been around for 8 years, so who knows. Also of note; the article is a failure of . It appears Ms. Harris created the article about herself. She's not edited in 8 years, nor has she edited anything else but her article Deletion of Theresa Fairbanks Harris WP:GNG||WP:AUTOBIOGRAPHY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20652 8439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Secret Maryo Chronicles (3 nomination) User:Tim 02:23, 20 December 2009 (UTC) keep Per http://www.stern.de/digital/computer/shareware/secret-maryo-chronicles-maryo-macht-auch-spass-620308.html and http://apcmag.com/top_5_best_free_open_source_games.htm. Seems to pass Deletion of Secret Maryo Chronicles (3 nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20653 12084 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of biographies of musicians in Rees's Cyclopaedia User:Canyouhearmenow 12:07, 18 July 2014 (UTC) delete While I agree that the subject matter is notable in aspects, I also agree that this is nor do I feel it is worthy of having its own page. I think I would support merging it into another article that could better benefit from its content. Not sure there would be a way to build this page and still make it viable to stand on its own Deletion of List of biographies of musicians in Rees's Cyclopaedia WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20654 2531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FK Budućnost Arilje User:Fenix 09:04, 21 July 2017 (UTC) delete fails , no indication the club has played in a national competition, no indication of any other achievements garnering sufficient significant, independent coverage to satisfy GNG Deletion of FK Budućnost Arilje WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20655 8772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackson Emmett Shaw User:Phil 11:24, 28 February 2008 (UTC) delete per #A7. My understanding is that a removed speedy tag (unlike a prod) can be reinstated if the article clearly qualifies for speedy deletion Deletion of Jackson Emmett Shaw WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
20656 17736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Gifted High User:Extraordinary 03:58, 1 July 2021 (UTC) delete appears to have been |made up by the author, and in any event would fail |any applicable notability guideline due to the dearth of reliable sources Deletion of The Gifted High WP:MADEUP||WP:N Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
20657 7036 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ndriqim Halili User:Sir 21:14, 1 September 2012 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not received significant coverage or played in a fully pro league. This article fails and Deletion of Ndriqim Halili WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20658 1419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orchards of the world User:Clarityfiend 20:08, 16 February 2019 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails Deletion of Orchards of the world WP:NEOLOGISM Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
20659 66 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Naleski User:Ad 20:12, 28 October 2020 (UTC) delete A couple of / have been cited. The subject misses . As with most living, young people, I prefer draftification to deletion Deletion of James Naleski WP:RS||WP:IS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20660 13759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thinkin' Lincoln User:Dragonfiend 04:36, 16 June 2006 (UTC) delete no eliable sources, does not meet Deletion of Thinkin' Lincoln WP:R||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Redirect 56
20661 10567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/José David Name Cardoso User:Valenciano 19:57, 14 December 2008 (UTC) keep I've just done a short translation. As Gene93k points out, he passes WP:POLITICIAN and we need more of such articles not less to counter Deletion of José David Name Cardoso WP:BIAS Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
20662 21860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neighbours 2011 Ratings [[User talk:Frickative|Frickative]] 22:56, 1 March 2011 (UTC) comment Is there any possibility that the scope of the list could be expanded, turning it into a full-fledged list of 2011 episodes? I know that episode lists for year-round series aren't common, but List of The Bill episodes was Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of The Bill episodes|kept at AfD. 2011 isn't an ideal starting point for a series that's been on air for so long, but it's just a suggestion. Of course, if that's not possible - I don't know whether there are |reliable sources to |verify the writers/directors etc. for ''Neighbours'' episodes (I just did a search and only turned up fansites) - then '''delete''' per - a list of ratings alone is too narrow a scope to be of encyclopaedic value Deletion of Neighbours 2011 Ratings WP:RS||WP:V||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20663 16950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wild Cherries User:Coredesat 19:24, 19 June 2006 (UTC) keep meets , well-known in Australia Deletion of Wild Cherries WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20664 20683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Painface (2nd nomination) User:Alzarian16 11:32, 19 August 2010 (UTC) keep Meets #6. The issue of verifiability has been addressed too, as the ELs at the bottom of the article tell us that all the notable people were definitely in the band Deletion of Painface (2nd nomination) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20665 20125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Spells in Slayers User:Sephiroth 22:01, 3 August 2008 (UTC) delete huge mass of #PLOT|excessive plot summary. Zero notability asserted Deletion of List of Spells in Slayers WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20666 14527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ake Lianga User:Black 17:10, 24 May 2008 (UTC) keep """Lianga has been the subject of non-trivial coverage in independent, reliable sources (and this is only what we've been able to find via Google; there is likely to be quite a bit of local coverage of him that does not show up in Google). Thus, he meets the basic notability criterion, irrespective of whether he meets one or more of the specific """"Additional criteria"""" specified in """ Deletion of Ake Lianga WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20667 6567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Simpsons (season 30) User:SemiHypercube 20:18, 4 October 2018 (UTC) keep might not be , as there is one episode aired. Now, if it was The Simpsons (season 35) or something like that, then I'd say delete, but I think this is not too far into the future (actually present Deletion of The Simpsons (season 30) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20668 1261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K. Johnston User:David 22:23, 13 May 2016 (UTC) delete """I had noticed the same thing as DGG and held off commenting until now because of it. Her top-cited paper in Google scholar (""""Strange-quark contributions"""") has a citation-to-author ratio of less than three, and she appears in a middling position, so it is difficult to find a convincing case for notability via #C1. Directing a center is not an indication of notability (huge numbers of academics do this, basically because it sounds more impressive to call your group of grad students a center than to call them your group of grad students). And the Sigma Xi award appears to be very local, something that they give on a per-chapter (that is, per-university) basis rather than a national-level award, and has no sources independent of Johnston herself. So I don't see a basis for notability""" Deletion of K. Johnston WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20669 17247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hero (2011 film) User:American 19:20, 8 October 2013 (UTC) keep The article is a notch above the requirements of and has some potential Deletion of Hero (2011 film) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20670 14347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Team KNOx User:Hobbes 01:00, 3 October 2011 (UTC) delete The competition itself gets a few GNews hits, but not this particular team. Like the references provided in the article, hits on general Google search are limited to their university or team websites. No evidence of |notability Deletion of Team KNOx WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20671 13040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blood Dragonns User:gwernol 18:15, 4 May 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Blood Dragonns WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
20672 20480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of San Diego Padres no-hitters (2nd nomination) User:Bagumba 15:19, 10 April 2021 (UTC) merge """Appreciate attempt to , but merging to List of San Diego Padres team records is awkward. What is the record? A convoluted """"Fewest hits allowed, complete game""""? Even if the record is listed, it's trivial to merge in the current table, when only the record holder, Musgrove, is relevant. No similar precedent with List of Tampa Bay Rays no-hitters or any of the other similar page deleted in the last RfD""" Deletion of List of San Diego Padres no-hitters (2nd nomination) WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
20673 5586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yu Bo User:Atlantic306 21:42, 6 March 2019 (UTC) keep the article needs improvement with additional references but the actor has plenty of leading roles so easily passes Deletion of Yu Bo WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
20674 17592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wikipediism User:Otolemur 20:24, 4 April 2008 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Wikipediism WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20675 11048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vera Shpak User:RebeccaGreen 04:15, 12 July 2019 (UTC) delete I don't see multiple significant roles in notable productions, unfortunately. I have to admit that, rather than searching in Russian or Belorussian sources, I am going on the Russian and Belorussian pages, which have only a couple of blue-linked productions in the list of her screen roles, and she did not have significant roles in those productions. For some of the films/series named, the list states that she had a major role - but as there are no articles about those films/series, we can't know if they are notable. Most of the stage roles listed were while she was at theatre school, so are unlikely to be notable productions. Of the sources in the articles, most are primary, and one is an interview, so not independent. I think this may be a case of , although someone with knowledge of Russian may be able to find evidence of reviews, or that the productions were notable and her roles in them significant Deletion of Vera Shpak WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20676 13338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Runa Akasaka User:Quasirandom 23:27, 29 December 2008 (UTC) comment WP:PORNBIO seems to be hopelessly |biased towards how the AV industry works in the West, to the point that attempting to apply it to Asian actors seems to be not a good idea. Avoiding that notability shortcut and resorting to the |general notability requirements would be in order Deletion of Runa Akasaka WP:BIAS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
20677 4238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wyatt Strahan User:Whiteguru 10:55, 16 May 2021 (UTC) delete Too many ERA's ... Minor league player, no signs of passing Deletion of Wyatt Strahan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20678 12385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pradeep Thapliyal User:Curbon7 22:14, 1 August 2021 (UTC) delete Thapliyal is not the assemblyman for Rudraprayang, that is Bharat Singh. This subject merely lost the election for that constituency. Fails Deletion of Pradeep Thapliyal WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20679 20637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Claira Hollingsworth (2nd nomination) User:The 12:31, 20 December 2015 (UTC) merge """to Miss Idaho USA#Winners, as suggested by the nom and for the usual reasons of plausibility, cheapness, and the like. My musings at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucy Fleck are also """"per"""" here (and boil down to """ Deletion of Claira Hollingsworth (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20680 5394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Dave Jones Interval Averages (DJIA) User:Dhartung 06:14, 6 March 2008 (UTC) delete we have a word for what Canterbury Tail is trying to say -- |vanispamcruftisement -- and I haven't seen such an illustrative example in some time. It's not notable, so it's vanity. It's pumping a business, so it's spam. It goes into great unencyclopedic detail about whatever it is, so it's cruft. And it's soapboxing, hence advertisement Deletion of The Dave Jones Interval Averages (DJIA) WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
20681 349 [[Saufen]] (erledigt, redir) Benutzer:Peterlustig NONE delete Wurde schon unter /17._April_2005#Saufen_erledigt.2C_redirect_auf_Alkoholkrankheit diskutiert. Hab vorerst mal einen redir, der damals auch vorgeschlagen wurde, draus gemacht, auch wenn ich persönlich eher für erneutes bin (aus den damals von mir genannten Gründen, wenn es interessiert kann es dort nachlesen Löschung von Saufen Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20682 2714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Poor Moon User:Sparklism 07:52, 28 March 2012 (UTC) keep While it is cleary |early days for this band, the success of their 'parent' band almost guarantees that Poor Moon will receive some serious coverage. I have added some sources to the article, and I believe this already shows that is met. --'''sparkl Deletion of Poor Moon WP:CRYSTAL||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20683 2281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Schniedewind User:Dhartung 06:21, 18 July 2007 (UTC) keep but '''cleanup'''. The subject is the occupant of a named and endowed professorial chair at a major university, and while is only a proposed guideline, such individuals have been kept in the past Deletion of William Schniedewind WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20684 14934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lesley Smith User:Evb 14:46, 9 August 2007 (UTC) keep per my clean up. Subject satisfies Deletion of Lesley Smith WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20685 8069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lazlow Jones User:Handoto 04:13, 18 February 2020 (UTC) keep While I agree this article needs to be re-worded to remove promotional material, Lazlow's work with Rockstar has given him a lot of independent and significant coverage. There is a lot of coverage available, and states that notability is based on the existence of sources, not on the sourcing in an article Deletion of Lazlow Jones WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
20686 16790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Urdu web sites User:Notecardforfree 22:24, 18 December 2015 (UTC) delete per because this list is too broad in scope to be of any value. Additionally, an indiscriminate list of Urdu websites likely violates Deletion of List of Urdu web sites WP:SALAT||WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
20687 2093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Football at the 2018 CJSOI Games User:CeltJungleSnake 15:38, 9 May 2021 (UTC) delete no evidence of notability, fails Deletion of Football at the 2018 CJSOI Games WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20688 1469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Australian Muslim Party User:Coolabahapple 12:45, 19 February 2016 (UTC) delete a case of Deletion of Australian Muslim Party WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20689 221 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/H.R. 3325 (117th Congress) NONE NONE keep Sourcing is not an issue; it had four non-primary sources at the time of nomination, and has six now. It's sufficiently distinct from 2021 United States Capitol attack that it deserves separate coverage; and in fact, merging it could likely lead to sacrificing worthy information on the alter of Deletion of H.R. 3325 (117th Congress) WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
20690 21410 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shea McKeen User:Cbl62 16:03, 22 January 2020 (UTC) delete Most of the coverage turned up by my searches relate to a 2006 arrest and suspension from the Sourth Carolina team. E.g., https://www.goupstate.com/article/NC/20060325/News/605191289/SJ here. Predicating an article on such coverage is inconsistent with . I did also find https://www.wralsportsfan.com/colleges/blogpost/3979675/ this relating to a 2008 injury after transferring to NC State, but not enough to pass the bar. Also fails and Deletion of Shea McKeen WP:BLP1E||WP:GNG||WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20691 3705 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tammy Horton User:CosmicNotes 22:41, 8 August 2021 (UTC) delete """Agree with nominator does not meet which requires significant roles in multiple notable films, television shows, stage performances, or other productions; or unique, prolific or innovative contributions to a field of entertainment. Here """"claim to fame"""" appears to be marrying a hockey player and a few trivial mentions in modeling articles. Does not meet """ Deletion of Tammy Horton WP:NMODEL||WP:NMODEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20692 18004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Byrne (centenarian) User:Canadian 16:55, 4 January 2013 (UTC) delete for failing as mentioned above and, to a lesser extent, in regards to the level of sourcing Deletion of Mary Byrne (centenarian) WP:ONEEVENT||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20693 1729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Maw User:Obina 09:15, 29 September 2007 (UTC) delete per . This is trivia about trivia. I did like the part about the parsec mistake - though that is not about the Maw. That mistake is notable since people do learn about science from popular media and people can belive parsec is a speed or light-year a time when popular cinema gets it wrong. That part should be merged somewhere - if it's not already in 10 star wars pages Deletion of The Maw WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
20694 19829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wade Mitchells User:Coredesat 07:33, 22 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Wade Mitchells WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
20695 4362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/5 Days: How I Survived Hurricane Katrina User:Armbrust 00:35, 2 February 2010 (UTC) delete as of Deletion of 5 Days: How I Survived Hurricane Katrina WP:SELFPUBLISH Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20696 4209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Praça TV User:Sander 20:40, 18 December 2016 (UTC) comment When starting a AfD with guessing, you should have started a discussion (on the talk page) first. Please read Deletion of Praça TV WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20697 7402 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Sayers [[User talk:118.93.48.173|talk]]) — [[Special:Contributions/118.93.48.173|118.93.48.173]] ([[User talk:118.93.48.173|talk]]) has made [[Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|few or no other edits]] outside this topic. 08:13, 23 June 2016 (UTC) keep I have Edited in references 11 and 12 about Mr Sayers as this string seems to missing his political sphere of influance. This politician does meet the protocols because the largest newspaper in New Zealand reports on him and he negotiates with the country's Prime Minister which also gets reported. See the tags ( currently 11 &12 ) to Penlink Bridge. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Special:Contributions/118.93.48.173|118.93.48.173 Deletion of Greg Sayers WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20698 8093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francis Leo Marcos User:Superastig 09:00, 12 August 2020 (UTC) delete A controversial YouTuber who claims to be a nephew of the late Pres. Marcos, which was later on https://www.mindanaodailynews.com/news/front-page/todays-top-stories/imelda-marcos-clarifies-she-is-not-in-anyway-related-to-francis-leo-marcos dismissed by Imelda as false. That said, does not apply. Search results return mostly news about his arrest for violating a couple of laws, an indication of . Barely found anything about him aside from those. He may have done some good deeds during the pandemic, but that doesn't escape him from his controversies Deletion of Francis Leo Marcos WP:INHERIT||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20699 7859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blue Cross Sale User:Spinningspark 14:59, 1 April 2009 (UTC) delete """I don't agree that the article is unencyclopedic, it defines a marketing term and gives some of its origin and history which is certainly a suitable subject and correctly treated. Its main problem is the lack of referencing. I found a couple of passing mentions in books http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=uSbcZDHe2C8C&pg=PA194&dq=%22blue+cross+sale%22&lr=&ei=hHPTSZeBAoHANtHenPcI,http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=NjYQ4P8oniUC&pg=PP1&dq=%22blue+cross+sale%22&lr=&ei=hHPTSZeBAoHANtHenPcI#PPP1,M1 but nothing that could be used to build the article. Everything else online is either even more tangential or not . In short I cannot ever see this being expanded into a substantial article, especially as its use seems to be limited to a handful of large UK stores only. The material has a place on Wikipedia, but imo it is as part of a broader article. If there were a general article on """"sale"""" that would be where it should be, but quite to my astonishment no such article exists. January sales redirects (not entirely appropriately imo) to Christmas and holiday season and the sale dab page points (for this meaning) to Discounts and allowances, again, not exactly the same thing. My suggestion to the author, if they are willing, is to work on the article in user space, expanding it to a more general article on """"sale (retail)"""" or some such title""" Deletion of Blue Cross Sale WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20700 15560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Mark Duggan User:Trevj 12:09, 11 August 2011 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Death of Mark Duggan WP:EFFECT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20701 17923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glendon Swift User:Z10987 01:31, 10 June 2014 (UTC) delete Fits perfectly into guidelines Deletion of Glendon Swift WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20702 1723 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jake Presutti User:Kubigula 15:13, 26 July 2007 (UTC) delete """per the """"tier two"""" option. This seems about the right balance - keep the starters and delete the prospects, benchwarmers and assistant coaches (unless, of course, they can be shown to meet """ Deletion of Jake Presutti WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20703 17447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2008 double album User:Blathnaid 19:57, 4 February 2008 (UTC) delete per . If there is sourced information about an upcoming album out there, it can be mentioned in the Paul Weller (singer)|Paul Weller article Deletion of 2008 double album WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20704 6337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Venhuizen User:Arthistorian1977 20:29, 2 March 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Tony Venhuizen WP:POLITICIAN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20705 12951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Setia Alam LRT station User:The 10:06, 4 May 2019 (UTC) delete since the subject is a non-notable construction project set |for the future. The creator of the article was |banned the other day for Deletion of Setia Alam LRT station WP:CRYSTAL||WP:G5 Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20706 14202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Orchard Theory User:Doc 22:52, 3 December 2006 (UTC) delete """the term """"Orchard Theory"""" only gets 33 ghits (33!) and most of those relate to arboreal agriculture, not Evolution. This is clearly |original research, and not even in common usage enough to be a |neologism""" Deletion of Orchard Theory WP:OR||WP:NEO Wikipedia:No original research 65
20707 14944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Save Our Strays Vermont User:DustFormsWords 11:08, 9 December 2010 (UTC) delete """Personally, I'd argue this should be a '''Speedy Delete A7''' candidate as an article about an organisation with no credible assertion of notability, but were I an admin I'd be reluctant to make that call. In any case the article does not provide significant discussion in reliable independent sources capable of sastifying the general notability guidelines and I have been unable to identify any. (Please note that there is no agreement on whether or not local sources do or do not count towards notability. is an essay which says """"no"""", while INT is a proposed guideline that says """"yes"""", with the talk page discussion leaning towards a view that Wikipedia should be more inclusive yet in regards to local interests. In the absence of community consensus, wins, which makes no mention of local notability not being notability generally""" Deletion of Save Our Strays Vermont WP:LOCAL||WP:LOCALINT||WP:N Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
20708 3140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 Swedish heat wave User:TheGracefulSlick 18:20, 22 July 2018 (UTC) delete Sourcing is great”...no, no it is not. The weather was reported on by the usual agencies at the time of its existence. That is not “great”, that is |routine. By the same logic, we must offer a daily weather report because, hey, the |some news agency reported it too Deletion of 2014 Swedish heat wave WP:ROUTINE||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20709 2773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/We Break the Dawn User:Hello 00:05, 1 April 2008 (UTC) comment I don't see how a single promotional blurb on a magazine's website equals notability. There's nothing like that in #Songs Deletion of We Break the Dawn WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20710 14399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patriotic Alternative User:Modern 11:22, 3 February 2021 (UTC) keep Has been covered by Hope not Hate, and has been mentioned on the BBC. Thus, passes |notability Deletion of Patriotic Alternative WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20711 20046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/U.S. National Video Game Team User:Satellizer 00:15, 17 October 2015 (UTC) delete """per nom and Sergecross73. Coverage in reliable sources is minimal and insignificant. Most of the """"keep"""" arguments are not policy-based and amount to little more than and """ Deletion of U.S. National Video Game Team WP:ILIKEIT||WP:ITEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20712 10646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Ewing User:MartinDK 04:22, 8 July 2007 (UTC) keep We do accept articles on fictional characters based on the argument but I will admit that almost all of these appear to be of very poor quality (who really cares what car Lucy drove?). I say keep for now to let someone improve the articles but if that doesn't happen they will likely end up here again. Also, thanks for not mass nominating these as most such nominations turn out to be trainwrecks Deletion of Jack Ewing WP:PAPER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20713 17042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jake Henning User:Stormtracker94 20:54, 12 October 2007 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Jake Henning WP:COI||WP:N Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
20714 9306 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/That Vegan Teacher User:Theleekycauldron 17:35, 3 March 2021 (UTC) keep Full disclosure: I wrote the article and moved it into the article space.'' hat BLP1E is not|this essay pretty clearly spells out that if there's more than one event worth mentioning, no matter the size, than the article is worth keeping. We have multiple reliable sources, at different times, showing that the things she says and does were notable before she was banned. I do realize one of the citations was an incorrect duplicate, that otherwise would have shown this, so my apologies. Going back to what BLP1E is not, since we have reliable sources (a few of which are listed eliable sources/Perennial sources|here) for multiple different events, even if the most notable part of her career was the ban, this conclusively ''does not'' disqualify her page. As precedent for this, i'd like to point out Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CallMeCarson (2nd nomination) (another article that i wrote), where the consensus was that is not meant to delete articles for content creators who have one event that's more notable than most others. This article passes Deletion of That Vegan Teacher WP:W||WP:R||WP:BLP1E||WP:GNG Help:Watchlist 110
20715 19990 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gordon the Big Engine User:TTN 18:09, 6 October 2020 (UTC) delete """Fails and . Not sure on the reliability of opinion pieces, but the above article hardly seems worthy of inclusion in the article regardless. It say very little about the actual character, and I doubt """"Random Journalist compared the character to a British Prime Minister"""" is anything anyone would ever deem worthy of connecting to this character""" Deletion of Gordon the Big Engine WP:GNG||WP:NOTPLOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20716 11732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lillian Müller User:Carrite 13:41, 4 May 2011 (UTC) keep """The use of automated tools for mass deletions should not be allowed against large blocks of articles which have already been patrolled at New Pages. It is, simply put, a violation of — due diligence is not being done when these tools are being used in this way. """"Shoot them all and let the saps at AfD sort them out,"""" is apparently the line of thinking. While I am personally sympathetic to the idea of a very high bar for so-called """"Porn Bios,"""" this blasting of 100 articles at the rate of 1 per minute, judging from the time logs, is not conducive to the spirit or practice of AfD. It is putting DON'T LIKE IT ahead of the established article deletion process and is disrespectful both to the work of article creators and those of us who volunteer our time at AfD. We have seen similar automated mass annihilation efforts recently against modern Trotskyist political organizations and against fraternities and sororities. The net result of these efforts was a lot of lost time by article creators and AfD participants and a lot of lost information from those articles annihilated as part of these campaigns. Meanwhile, the backlog of crap at New Pages festers. Something needs to be done about this problem. Mine is not a unique view — see Wikipedia:ANI#Massive_number_of_Playboy-related_AFD_nominations_by_a_single_user at ANI. We need to keep them all as a matter of principle and ban the future use of automated tools in this way. ''This argument will be copied-and-pasted in the debate sections for all automated AfDs of this campaign""" Deletion of Lillian Müller WP:BEFORE||WP:I Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20717 10512 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Colin (mathematician) User:Nsk92 17:09, 17 May 2008 (UTC) delete Not enough evidence presented to satisfy the notability requirements under either or . For one would have to see some substantial evidence of citability of his research in scholarly articles. I dod a bit of google and WoS searching but did not find much; with a common name like that it is hard to do filtering so perhaps something was inadvertently missed. Still, the keep proponents would have to present some positive and verifiable evidence of high citability here. The case for is even more problematic. I did not see any evidence of substantial coverage of him by independent third-party reliable sources (per ) as required to satisfy Deletion of Andrew Colin (mathematician) WP:PROF||WP:BIO||WP:PROF||WP:BIO||WP:RS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20718 14195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Durbans very own records User:Richard3120 14:00, 13 June 2016 (UTC) delete it's not a hoax, but it is a non-notable record label and fails . Article creator has been blocked, no coverage found anywhere on the internet apart from the company's own Facebook page, and even their blogspot contains no posts at all Deletion of Durbans very own records WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20719 185 [[Amelia Earhart Fellowship]] (gelöscht) Benutzerin:CaroFraTyskland NONE delete Enzyklopädische Relevanz gemäß unserer |Relevanzkriterien nicht dargestellt. Weiterleitung geht momentan nicht, da kein geeignetes Ziel Löschung von Amelia Earhart Fellowship Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
20720 6825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Loretta Kelsey User:Baileypalblue 07:12, 12 February 2009 (UTC) keep """added sources satisfy #General notability guideline|the general notability guideline, and I agree that the last remaining repository for a non-written language is notable, particularly when the individual in question is spearheading a campaign to keep the language alive. Satisfies : """"is regarded as an important figure"""" among her peers. does not apply -- her campaign to save the language is not just a one-time event, and there's also an article about how she got kicked out of her own tribe -- that's two different context points. There's room for separate articles on the language and on the individual""" Deletion of Loretta Kelsey WP:N||WP:CREATIVE||WP:ONEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20721 1263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pietra Wexstun User:Missvain 18:32, 21 May 2021 (UTC) delete I could not find anything to establish nor . I suppose another option could be to '''redirect''' Pietra Wexstun to Stan Ridgeway as an lternative to deletion Deletion of Pietra Wexstun WP:GNG||WP:BAND||WP:A Wikipedia:Notability 77
20722 4543 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JSHint (2nd nomination) NONE NONE keep spaced ndash}} Topic appears to just meet , per Deletion of JSHint (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20723 14650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gladys Swetland (2nd nomination) User:Kraxler 18:53, 5 August 2015 (UTC) delete was never the oldest person anywhere, just a run-of-the-mill supercentenarian. Wikipedia is and subject fails and Deletion of Gladys Swetland (2nd nomination) WP:NOTNEWS||WP:1E||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20724 9661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gbadebo Rhodes Vivour User:Celestina007 18:16, 24 May 2020 (UTC) delete Basically echoing what {{u|GPL93}} “said” I can’t seem to find any evidence of true notability, fails & Deletion of Gbadebo Rhodes Vivour WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20725 20605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ChucK User:Ruud 15:36, 27 May 2011 (UTC) keep Peer reviewed and cited reliable sources available. ''The Oxford Handbook of Computer Music'' and ''The Cambridge companion to electronic music'' establish independent notability. Seems to pass and Deletion of ChucK WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20726 18573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maruthamunai User:Ultraexactzz 23:14, 9 February 2008 (UTC) keep per - The article has been sufficiently rewritten to satisfy me Deletion of Maruthamunai WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
20727 1461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Silas McGuffers User:Resolute 04:23, 5 October 2006 (UTC) delete per nom and as a failure of Deletion of Silas McGuffers WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
20728 3442 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Titans (Crash of the Titans) User:Sephiroth 04:38, 12 June 2008 (UTC) delete fails #GUIDE, nothing more than a list of enemies with excessive detail Deletion of Titans (Crash of the Titans) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20729 6466 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/North British, Arbroath and Montrose Railway User:AllyD 23:48, 30 March 2013 (UTC) keep """References are available via Google and I have begun adding these into the article. See also the """"Special:WhatLinksHere/North_British,_Arbroath_and_Montrose_Railway|What links here"""", which is another useful check. A historical railway company, established by Act of Parliament, is part of the record and worthy of noting in an encyclopaedia. It is a stub, but one for improvement, not deletion""" Deletion of North British, Arbroath and Montrose Railway :WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20730 10264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reb Moshe of Tzfat User:MPerel 18:29, 29 August 2008 (UTC) comment This article probably should be deleted based on our notability criteria. However, I'm concerned that the coldness of this process has been a bit unwelcoming and has unnecessarily chased off a new editor with unintentional |newbie biting. I see the new editor has blanked his user page and not returned Deletion of Reb Moshe of Tzfat WP:DBTN Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
20731 10928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prakash Chand (2nd nomination) User:Velella 00:04, 25 February 2018 (UTC) delete any notability is soley predicated on his position as CEO of a notable copnay. clearly indicates that notability is not inherited in this way. Only one ref gets close and that is a rather bare paragraph. Fails ''''' Deletion of Prakash Chand (2nd nomination) WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20732 1993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nightlife in Canberra User:Mattinbgn 12:01, 15 June 2007 (UTC) delete Not sure how this article can be written without breaching and/or with the selection of venues etc. It is not a topic that lends itself to inclusion in Wikipedia, given Wikipedia policies and guidelines Deletion of Nightlife in Canberra WP:NPOV||WP:OR Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
20733 11244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrea Baptiste (2nd nomination) User:Location 18:59, 5 November 2010 (UTC) merge per guideline at . Plausible search term. I agree with the above that there is nothing to merge Deletion of Andrea Baptiste (2nd nomination) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20734 16603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Aigner (Media entrepreneur) User:Fly 18:05, 21 April 2013 (UTC) keep Subject to rewrite) – I agree that the article contains a great deal of seemingly promotional content which needs to be removed. However, the subject clearly meets . He has presented four mainstream shows on national television Deletion of Thomas Aigner (Media entrepreneur) WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20735 21337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Rider User:NinjaRobotPirate 04:12, 30 March 2016 (UTC) delete He got some local coverage (http://www.mlive.com/business/west-michigan/index.ssf/2011/10/educators_say_more_michigan_co.html and http://www.mlive.com/grpress/business/index.ssf/2008/12/founders_of_digital_wingman_tw.html), but I don't think there's enough here to satisfy . The awards don't look like they would confer notability Deletion of Brian Rider WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20736 17958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zoran Dragelj User:NickCT 02:09, 30 December 2014 (UTC) delete Not seeing significant coverage. Article created by a . This is likely or Deletion of Zoran Dragelj WP:SPA||WP:COI||WP:AUTOBIO Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
20737 11396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Breedlove User:Ritchie333 NONE keep """There is coverage in reliable sources, albeit for a single event. I suggest we let this one pass for the time being, and suggest opening a further AfD in, say, six months time. This debate reminds me of rticles for deletion/Rhys Morgan a few weeks back, where I went for """"Keep"""" mainly because I believed notable events of his were likely to increase in the future. That probably isn't the case here unless some well known person or organisation picks up this guy's story and runs with it. PS: Claiming Wikipedia is pro censorship is a great way to poison a debate quickly into bickering, distracting from the issues of whether or not an article meets the well known WP quality rules""" Deletion of Ben Breedlove WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
20738 11795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashington JW RFC (2nd nomination) User:Rugbyfan22 09:34, 2 April 2021 (UTC) delete Fails and while there is some coverage, it is merely trivial coverage and not enough to pass Deletion of Ashington JW RFC (2nd nomination) WP:NRU||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20739 5982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Lewis (singer-songwriter) User:Bearian 21:10, 16 March 2010 (UTC) delete """or ''userfy''. There is a claim of notability per - """"Has performed in 40 states across the U.S."""" But this statement needs to be |verified""" Deletion of Michael Lewis (singer-songwriter) WP:MUSIC||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
20740 6688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph Trem User:Zingarese 17:05, 7 April 2019 (UTC) delete It's just |too soon. I couldn't find any coverage about this young musician in independent reliable sources, and he doesn't satisfy any of the criteria at Deletion of Joseph Trem WP:TOOSOON||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20741 18487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Batey User:Viewmaster17 23:49, 24 August 2007 (UTC) keep """First, is Wikipedia merely a repository of information easily located with ghits? If so, what is the point? Please judge the article on its own merits. If references from Entertainment Weekly, Salon.com, and the Museum of Modern Art don't establish notability, I don't know what does. Second, her status as an innovator in the lifestreaming arena is not in dispute. She was the first cam girl to go 24/7 with streaming video. Please consult |notability guidelines - """"Has made unique, prolific or '''innovative contributions''' to a field of entertainment."""" On this basis alone, the entry is appropriate""" Deletion of Lisa Batey WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20742 6152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Morrison (filmmaker) User:Mkdw 05:01, 3 March 2013 (UTC) delete It bemoans me to delete a Canadian director article, but nothing suggests this person meets or that his films meet Deletion of Scott Morrison (filmmaker) WP:FILMMAKER||WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
20743 681 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Pelosi User:Bkissin 22:03, 4 January 2019 (UTC) delete I don't know if minor-league sports ownership is enough to prove notability for me personally, and as others mentioned |notability is not inherited Deletion of Paul Pelosi WP:INHERIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20744 16371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baroness of Douglas User:BrownHairedGirl 15:43, 27 May 2012 (UTC) merge """I nominated this article for deletion, because I found no evidence to support its existence. Some references have now been produced (though not all in |reliable sources), but I not persuaded that they solve the original problem. On the contrary they point to a much more complex picture, which still leads me to think that there should not be a standalone article ''under the current title''. Please bear with me while I explain.AFAICS, the situation here is the Isle of Man had a structure similar to that pertaining in much of the rest of Europe, where religious orders owned a lot of land and other property, and had extensive civil powers. It seems that there were several such religious houses in the Isle of Man, in which the head of the abbey/priory/monastery had significant civil powers, which led to them being described ''in some sources'' as """"barons"""" or """"baronesses"""". However, that terminology is not as straightforward as it appears. In contemporary usage in England, a Baron is the junior rank of hereditary peerage, a person whose title entitled them until the House of Lords Act 1999|1999 Act to a seat in the House of Lords ... but as set out at Baron#Barons_in_the_United_Kingdom_and_the_Commonwealth, the term had a much wider usage in the middle ages, when it extended far beyond those who would now be considered """"nobility"""".So, a lot of caution is needed when looking looking at the usage in medieval societies ... particularly when the term is linked to religious office.In the contemporary United Kingdom, the Lords Spiritual (i.e. CoE Bishops) continue to hold ''ex officio'' seats in the House of Lords, but there is disagreement as to whether they are members of the peerage (see Lords Spiritual#Peers) ... and they are certainly not Barons.In this case, the situation appears to be that there were a number of religious houses, whose leaders held some civil power. However, evidence presented here for the use of the titles """"Baron"""" and """"Baroness"""" is very weak; AFAICS amidst the shoal of red herrings, it consists solely of a mention in a travelogue and a http://www.manxmanorialroll.com/quests/baronies.html unattributed website. The quality of debate has been undermined by one editor postings 4 refs (http://www.isle-of-man.com/manxnotebook/manxsoc/msvol05/index.htm; http://www.isle-of-man.com/manxnotebook/fulltext/dh1893/ch04.htm, http://www.isle-of-man.com/manxnotebook/jmmuseum/d231.htm, http://books.google.com/books?id=pc8DAAAAQAAJ&pg=PA20&lpg=PA20&dq=%22prior+of+Douglas%22&source=bl&ots=5Xm4NtNSrZ&sig=eX2MWS3FKviH3ITyI1gCEg3g9Cg&hl=en&sa=X&ei=4_DAT5_5EuSm6gGqtsShCg&ved=0CEYQ6AEwBg#v=onepage&q=%22prior%20of%20Douglas%22&f=false) as """"evidence"""" of the notability of tithe title, but ''none of them even mentions the word """"baroness""""''.I do not yet see any clear evidence about the nature of this title of baroness: was it an ''ex officio'' role of the Prioress? Was either position hereditary (whether through primogeniture or otherwise)? Was it a Courtesy title#Courtesy_title_as_principal_title|courtesy title? Even the very specific but non-RS http://www.manxmanorialroll.com/quests/baronies.html is not clear about this.Most of the references that I can see clearly support the existence of a notable """"Prioress of Douglas""""; but they make far fewer refs to the title """"Baroness of Douglas"""", and are unclear about the nature of that title.So, I suggest that ''if'' there is to be a standalone article on this office, it should be titled per as """"Prioress of Douglas"""". However, the material collected so far in relation to the prioress is patchy and brief, so I suggest that a better solution is DoctorKubla's suggestion of a merger to The Nunnery, Douglas. That way, the material on the priory and its leaders can be kept together on one page, while will still be quite short""" Deletion of Baroness of Douglas WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:COMMONNAME Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20745 7630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mud Connector User:Izno 14:09, 7 March 2016 (UTC) keep per the provided references satisfying the . I am cognizant that this may be a |permastub, but I am also skeptical that there is a good merge target (else that would be my !vote); if that's a desired outcome, perhaps {{u|Czar}} can provide his preferred target Deletion of The Mud Connector WP:GNG||WP:permastub Wikipedia:Notability 77
20746 10666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Too Much of Heaven User:Graeme 11:16, 12 July 2013 (UTC) keep this meets the usic with appearances on several charts in different countries Deletion of Too Much of Heaven WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
20747 1686 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Glimmer Twins User:Masterpiece2000 13:21, 21 June 2008 (UTC) delete Fails . Unencyclopedic article Deletion of The Glimmer Twins WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20748 8042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mountain Gap Middle School User:RFerreira 06:06, 6 May 2007 (UTC) merge and redirect to Huntsville, Alabama per and various proposed school guidelines Deletion of Mountain Gap Middle School WP:LOCAL Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
20749 18275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Babajide Ogunbiyi User:Malcolmxl5 23:14, 7 April 2009 (UTC) delete It's rather obvious that this is not a notable sportsperson since he has yet to play at the highest level, which is in a fully professional league. Not notable and fails thlete Deletion of Babajide Ogunbiyi WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
20750 4095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gigaset Communications User:Usrnme 13:28, 9 January 2009 (UTC) delete """per Wikipedia:NOTADVERTISING#ADVERTISING|WikiNot:Advertising and . The previous IP contributor to this discussion mentions """"Company was established recently, so not enough time to be on major new sources."""" which is exactly the point of and """ Deletion of Gigaset Communications WP:N||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20751 18043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Bongino User:Cullen328 06:12, 13 September 2011 (UTC) merge to United States Senate election in Maryland, 2012 where all candidates for this office can receive balanced coverage written from the |neutral point of view. Bongino fails but his candidacy ought to be covered fairly in the article about the race. If he wins, of course an article about him will then be entirely appropriate Deletion of Dan Bongino WP:NPOV||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
20752 16385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spanish Caravan User:onel5969 17:47, 3 November 2019 (UTC) merge restore to the Doors' album, as per Deletion of Spanish Caravan WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20753 21305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pēteris Kampenuss User:Sionk 17:04, 15 January 2012 (UTC) delete he has not participated in a 'major international amateur or professional competition at the highest level' so doesn't meet Deletion of Pēteris Kampenuss WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20754 2327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FreeFileSync User:StayAwhileAndListen 22:34, 24 May 2018 (UTC) keep per ; as mentioned by Deletion of FreeFileSync WP:NSOFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20755 9255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephan Kinsella (4th Nomination) User:Lawrencekhoo 06:36, 23 April 2013 (UTC) delete The applicable guideline appears to be . From what is on the page, I don't see any evidence that he passes any of the criteria in . DCM's comment above points to publications that are the strongest claim to notability: Editorship of legal texts published by Oxford University Press (http://ukcatalogue.oup.com/product/9780379215229.do#.UW6p56LqnHQ 1, http://web.archive.org/web/20050205234822/http://www.oceanalaw.com/main_product_details.asp?ID=293 2, http://web.archive.org/web/20121023232305/http://www.oup.com/us/catalog/general/subject/Law/ContractandGeneralCommercialLaw/ElectronicCommerce/?view=usa&ci=9780379215199 3, http://web.archive.org/web/20070219083421/http://www.oup.com/us/catalog/general/subject/Law/IntellectualProperty/IntellectualProperty/?view=usa&ci=9780379012699 4, http://web.archive.org/web/20070219081545/http://www.oup.com/us/catalog/general/subject/Law/ContractandGeneralCommercialLaw/?view=usa&ci=9780379010008 5). However, these are not enough to establish notability under Deletion of Stephan Kinsella (4th Nomination) WP:ACADEMIC||WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20756 6766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CSI Church Kaliakkavilai (2nd nomination) User:Anupmehra 20:57, 11 September 2016 (UTC) delete Fails . Photos of chruch and few lines however could be added into Kaliyakkavilai article Deletion of CSI Church Kaliakkavilai (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20757 12184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willie Thornton (Canadian football) User:KartikeyaS343 18:08, 5 November 2020 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Willie Thornton (Canadian football) WP:NGRIDIRON Wikipedia:Notability 77
20758 14428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lucius Nereparampil User:Radagast3 04:24, 2 May 2010 (UTC) delete GS cites are thin: 4, 2, 1, 1. GB finds several citations of his ''Destroy This Temple'', but Google finds no discussion of his other work. Seems to fail unless additional sources can be found Deletion of Lucius Nereparampil WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20759 6952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Illinois Club Baseball User:Kudpung 08:58, 25 July 2011 (UTC) delete vanity page for a non notable school/college sports team (not a major league per Deletion of Illinois Club Baseball WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20760 9211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/And One User:Torchiest 17:14, 17 April 2011 (UTC) keep """This band absolutely passes and . They have had plenty of coverage in secondary sources, but it's difficult to find the sources in Google because the words in the band's name are so common. ''Billboard'' called their first single, """"Metal Hammer"""", a http://www.billboard.com/#/artist/and-one/bio/352901 """"significant club hit"""". They have released albums on two notable labels, Metropolis Records (''Bodypop'') and Virgin Records (''Virgin Superstar''). According to the book http://books.google.com/books?id=IE3yERse7MUC&pg=PA108&dq=%22and+one%22+%22bodypop%22&hl=en&ei=ah2rTfSbDaW60QHd89H5CA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CC8Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q&f=false ''Synthiepop - Die gefühlvolle Kälte'' (in German) by Dirk Horst, they were honored as the Best New Artist in Germany in 1991. I would be okay with merging the two album articles into the main band article, but '''keep''' the discography page as well""" Deletion of And One WP:GNG||WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20761 18657 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scorpio (Blake's 7) User:Jclemens 02:33, 21 September 2016 (UTC) keep a cursory review of the sources found above shows multiple RS mentions, demonstrating that was clearly not followed. An improved deletion rationale should deal with the obvious references available and explain why they cannot simply be incorporated into the article. I'm not doing so myself, as I'm unfamiliar with this fictional franchise Deletion of Scorpio (Blake's 7) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20762 12896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashfield Mall User:Ajf773 09:09, 19 April 2017 (UTC) delete per and . Small shopping centre with a lack of significant independent sources Deletion of Ashfield Mall WP:MILL||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
20763 15822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Nackman User:Feezo 13:47, 21 March 2006 (UTC) keep Needs some cleanup, but appears to meet usic Deletion of Alex Nackman WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
20764 6046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Invisible system User:Joe 00:29, 9 June 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |band Deletion of Invisible system WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20765 10307 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Barancik User:Masaruemoto 05:15, 25 September 2007 (UTC) keep """It says he wrote ''The Last Seduction'' and co-wrote the story for ''Domino''. ''The Last Seduction'' is widely regarded as one of the best thrillers of the 90s and it won several awards, even Roger Ebert noted it """"got some of the best reviews of the year"""". Passes for writers; ''The person's work... has won significant critical attention'', many highly respected sources (such as Variety) commented on Barancik's writing skills. I'll add more sources later""" Deletion of Steve Barancik WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20766 10462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people with coronavirus disease 2019 User:JeanPassepartout 03:34, 13 March 2020 (UTC) comment The list won't get out of hand. It's not listing every person on the planet who has been diagnosed, only notable people (those who meet and have an article on at least one Wikipedia Deletion of List of people with coronavirus disease 2019 WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20767 13666 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ed Reilly (karting) User:Ukexpat 16:36, 18 November 2010 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Ed Reilly (karting) WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20768 10362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nowheristan User:75 21:44, 2 November 2007 (UTC) delete currently non-notable as there doesn't appear to be verifiable sources at the moment so it fails . Further, it is written in so severe a non-npov style that it simply isn't salvagable Deletion of Nowheristan WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20769 12122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Merced User:AusLondonder 08:57, 28 February 2017 (UTC) delete Not a notable person per . No other claim to notability Deletion of Alex Merced WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20770 5449 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Herr beach User:Guliolopez 16:01, 22 May 2017 (UTC) delete """per nom. doesn't seem to be met. also a significant concern. (A Google search for https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Herr+beach%22+louth """"herr beach"""" louth or https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Herr+beach%22+blackrock """"herr beach"""" blackrock returns zero results""" Deletion of Herr beach WP:NGEO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20771 8788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finis Valorum User:Gavin 14:33, 4 January 2008 (UTC) delete as the articles all fail #PLOT and there are no |reliable secondary sources to demonstrate |notability outside the ''Star Wars'' canon Deletion of Finis Valorum WP:NOT||WP:RS||WP:FICT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20772 9424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Age of Empires II: Definitive Edition User:Videogameplayer99 21:25, 1 September 2019 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Age of Empires II: Definitive Edition WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20773 11065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Corporate social media NONE NONE keep spaced ndash}} Per and . The topic passes Wikipedia's General notability guideline with ease Deletion of Corporate social media WP:GNG||WP:NRVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20774 16346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Armenian footballers User:Lugnuts 09:17, 27 March 2010 (UTC) keep Lists and categories go hand-in-hand, per . Also part of a bigger scheme of :Category:Lists of footballers by country Deletion of List of Armenian footballers WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
20775 9053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sonia Ahmed User:Mendaliv 19:37, 18 June 2008 (UTC) delete Delete''' per nom and Deletion of Sonia Ahmed WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20776 2118 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One people under one God User:Seraphimblade 18:27, 12 October 2018 (UTC) delete """or if appropriate '''merge and redirect'''. Apologies in advance for the length, there's a lot of sources here to analyze. Analysis of sources is as of this revision: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=One_people_under_one_God&oldid=863735389. #1 is the Huffington Post, which is a relatively partisan source. Especially in the area of politics itself, partisan sources aren't generally reliable. #2 is a brief mention in passing. #3 is just a Bible passage, only very tangentially related. #4 covers it a bit, in context of analysis of Trump's speech in general, but I'm not sure of the reliability of the reference and it's regardless a pretty brief blurb. #5 only mentions in passing. #6 is the American Humanist Association, not particularly reliable and of course will have a clear position on the matter. #7 looks like an internal periodical for a specific organization, unknown reliability and certainly doing nothing for notability. #8 is NPR, certainly highly reliable, but is about the role of religion in his campaign in general and only mentions the specific phrase in passing. #9 is a blog, nothing more to be said there. #10 is RedState, another partisan source, and again those should be treated extremely carefully in terms of reliability on political topics. #11 is again about Trump's campaign and religion in general, with only a passing mention of the particular phrase. #12 is a partisan source (""""liberal bias"""" right in their """"About Us"""" page), so same caveat as before. #13 is the Inquisitr, which an RSN discussion found to be an unreliable source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Noticeboard/Archive_240#Inquisitr. #14 is again a brief mention in passing. #15 is a brief mention in passing and only of a passingly ''similar'' phrase, not even the one in question. #16 is just a quotation of the statement as part of a larger quote and isn't even about that portion of his speech. #17 is, again, just quoting it a part of a larger quote, and the article isn't at all addressing that portion of it. This is |reference bombing of every single thing that can be found that mentions the thing in passing, but no number of unreliable sources and passing mentions add up to |notability. This subject isn't notable for a standalone article, and at most should possibly be briefly mentioned in a parent or sibling article""" Deletion of One people under one God WP:REFBOMB||WP:N Wikipedia:Citation overkill 60
20777 18048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Damian Wills User:Mdtemp 18:13, 30 September 2014 (UTC) delete Fails both and . Sources are routine sports coverage and he fought for no significant titles. Interesting that the guy he fought for the California title had 3 wins in 22 fights--clearly a very prestigious title Deletion of Damian Wills WP:NBOX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20778 15083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indian Institute of Ecology and Environment User:SuperGoose007 02:55, 27 June 2020 (UTC) delete """Falls under |CSD G3. If there is any significant coverage about how this """"institute"""" is a hoax, then recreate the article and rewrite so it talks about the hoax""" Deletion of Indian Institute of Ecology and Environment WP:G3 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
20779 16434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neo-Tech (philosophy) (3rd nomination) User:JoeMystical 18:29, 31 August 2006 (UTC) comment This article is not about the meaning of a word. does not apply whatseover Deletion of Neo-Tech (philosophy) (3rd nomination) WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
20780 13177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Burning Tears User:Esradekan 09:45, 2 April 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability as per Deletion of Burning Tears WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20781 15486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frequent stops User:Pburka 09:01, 1 December 2013 (UTC) keep per lack of and per |numerous sources https://www.google.com/search?tbs=ar%3A1&tbm=nws&q=Paradas-contínuas&oq=Paradas-contínuas&gs_l=serp.12...2390.7176.0.8342.4.4.0.0.0.0.416.579.3j4-1.4.0....0...1c.1.32.serp..4.0.0.MVCi3106HTI available for improvement (thanks Deletion of Frequent stops WP:BEFORE||WP:NRVE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20782 3685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jocelyne Couture-Nowak (second nomination) User:Jpbowen 01:23, 30 April 2007 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Jocelyne Couture-Nowak (second nomination) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20783 6767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carson Rowland User:YoungForever 19:35, 10 December 2020 (UTC) delete per nominator, fails and it is way |too soon Deletion of Carson Rowland WP:BASIC||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
20784 15419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/10 Greatest Norwegian Sporting Moments User:Arsenikk 09:46, 1 May 2008 (UTC) delete An attempt by me to find reliable sources independent of the subject (i.e. Norsk Rikskringkasting|NRK), fails. Since the article lacks independent sources at assertain notability, both for the show and the list, it fails otability. Uless it can be established, Topp 10 may also fail notability unless sufficient independent sources can be found. Also, it seems rather non-encyclopedic list, since the list is created based on a non-random sampled collection of people, on a highly subjective matter Deletion of 10 Greatest Norwegian Sporting Moments WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20785 9100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti-Americanism in various countries User:Sandstein 21:29, 7 September 2006 (UTC) delete per complete lack of on-point , therefore by default, encyclopedic or not. You can't just edit out the OR if there are no sources, i.e. ''nothing but'' OR Deletion of Anti-Americanism in various countries WP:RS||WP:OR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20786 13855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010s in music User:Nymf 03:42, 6 January 2010 (UTC) delete Not only does it fail , but in the context (and looking at the previous decade articles) the article is full of content. It is ''way'' too early to define a decade. How notable is X tour/album release by X band in 5 years? That belongs in 2010 in music Deletion of 2010s in music WP:CRYSTAL||WP:RECENT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20787 4625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephanie Peacock User:Bearcat 20:44, 29 September 2014 (UTC) delete per nom. Under , a person does not qualify for a Wikipedia article just for being an as-yet-unelected ''candidate'' in a future election — if you cannot credibly source that they were ''already'' notable enough for a Wikipedia article under a ''different'' inclusion criterion ''before'' they were named a candidate, then they do not ''become'' notable enough for a Wikipedia article until they ''win'' the election. And needless to say, no strong evidence of preexisting notability has been demonstrated here — virtually all of the coverage is about either her candidacy (failing ) or her relationship with somebody else (failing Deletion of Stephanie Peacock WP:NPOL||WP:ROUTINE||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Notability 77
20788 107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William W. McCorkle Jr. NONE NONE comment and Thank you, Nappystar! Just trying to comply with the |Wikipedia guidelines, not feelings or delusions of power as implied. Will gladly change my vote, if you can prove that this individual meets the following criteria Deletion of William W. McCorkle Jr. WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
20789 18608 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ghost Train (2011 film) User:11coolguy12 07:37, 15 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Ghost Train (2011 film) WP:NFILMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20790 712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Siobhan Benita User:Timrollpickering 09:42, 6 May 2012 (UTC) merge to London mayoral election, 2012 per and long standing convention that simply being an unsuccessful candidate is not sufficient for notability Deletion of Siobhan Benita WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20791 16613 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mrs. Sri Lanka 2021 controversy User:Jacknstock 21:50, 27 April 2021 (UTC) keep I'm only on WP today because I read about this incident on the other side of the world. World-wide reporting by major media outlets passes Deletion of Mrs. Sri Lanka 2021 controversy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20792 9224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bollarum Golf Course User:Nomader NONE delete It exists (I found it in a list on a Yellow Pages website), but it still definitely fails . — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Bollarum Golf Course WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20793 8206 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cédric Boussoughou User:GiantSnowman 21:56, 19 June 2012 (UTC) delete previous consensus at two AfDs - Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aboubacar Camara (Guinean goalkeeper)|1, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Titima|2 - established that being a squad member at the ACN was not enough. This player fails and - non-notable Deletion of Cédric Boussoughou WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20794 5962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Space Marine Scouts User:Edison 15:19, 2 July 2008 (UTC) delete In-universe article about subject that fails Deletion of Space Marine Scouts WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20795 10940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruhu User:Dharmadhyaksha 09:14, 11 February 2014 (UTC) comment Irrespective of their seemingly small sizes and seemingly templated prose formats, we keep articles of villages where a |reliable source is present to prove the village/settlement exists. I and others would add a # opposite all the articles listed above for the ones where reference of its existence is noted in the article. Nominator's mass-AfD is non-constructive and not the creator's creation of articles Deletion of Ruhu WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20796 5255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Defeating Jihad User:RayAYang 23:42, 20 December 2008 (UTC) merge Keep''' Multiple reviews in secondary sources independent of the subject. These are notable, well-known magazines with serious editorial processes (within the bounds of ), and their reviews more than suffice for , whatever their political slants Deletion of Defeating Jihad WP:RS||WP:BK Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20797 4588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticisms of Harry Reid (3rd nomination) User:Eustress 19:41, 17 May 2011 (UTC) keep """Too much valid info here to simply delete. As mentioned in the previous AfD, the article conforms with : """"Sections of long articles should be spun off into their own articles leaving a summary in its place."""" According to http://www.javascriptkit.com/script/script2/charcount.shtml this tool, the character count of Harry_Reid#Criticism is 4,020, while the character count for Criticisms of Harry Reid is 15,355—more than three times as large. (In fact, the entire Harry Reid article has only 11,992 characters.) If a merge is desired with Political positions of Harry Reid, then a |merge request should instead be initiated""" Deletion of Criticisms of Harry Reid (3rd nomination) WP:SS||WP:MERGE Wikipedia:Summary style 34
20798 14581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Genetic Native Americans User:WngLdr34 13:41, 22 October 2009 (UTC) delete Clear oint Violation, Original Research, and Deletion of Genetic Native Americans WP:P||WP:SYN Wikipedia:Portal 85
20799 16523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Simon Whyman [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 03:46, 10 April 2007 (UTC) delete as insufficiently notable per . No evidence of non-trivial coverage of subject by reliable, third-party published sources. -- Deletion of Simon Whyman WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20800 17433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pwnboxer User:Jayron32 04:55, 8 July 2009 (UTC) delete I can only find sporadic, trivial or unreliable mentions at http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=Pwnboxer&btnG=Google+Search&aq=f&oq=&aqi= google search. The software clearly exists, but since we can make noting reliable and/or independent exists beyond that fact, this does not appear to pass inclusion criteria Deletion of Pwnboxer WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20801 10420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Mossberg User:Shawn 19:26, 30 April 2016 (UTC) keep first of all, this is an unreferenced BLP, so I would not have objected to a speedy or PROD on that basis. But since it's here, I see that the Swedish language Wikipedia article does have a one or two working references to reliable sources (easily readable via Google Translation). Moreover, while the sport of bandy hasn't mentioned on the policy page, it's close enough ice hockey that I feel like offers some guidance, and this person's participation at the World Cup level would help establish notability. Finally, articles like http://www.expressen.se/sport/mossberg-stangs-av-resten-av-sasongen/ this or http://www.aftonbladet.se/sportbladet/bandy/article12851331.ab this took all of a split-second to find via Gnews, so I can only wonder at the ''utter'' laziness of those offering cookie cutter rationales such as 'nothing yet suggesting the necessary notability improvements,' when it takes virtually ''no effort at all'' to find them Deletion of Daniel Mossberg WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20802 16388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Adan User:doomsdayer520 15:20, 31 January 2021 (UTC) delete Wrote one hit song and manages one non-notable singer. The nominator is correct on how the one hit song fails the requirements at , and her other ventures have not generated the coverage for the notability guidelines Deletion of Jennifer Adan WP:COMPOSER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20803 21025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battle of Dargo (1842) User:RightCowLeftCoast 22:49, 14 March 2015 (UTC) merge to which ever name is the . These appear to both be the same event, but apparently there is a disagreement as to what the proper name is Deletion of Battle of Dargo (1842) WP:COMMONNAME Wikipedia:Article titles 75
20804 12731 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/On Genetic Interests User:XOR 18:19, 16 August 2020 (UTC) delete The notability case is dubious at best (for an analogy: Michael Behe works at a university, but if he wrote a glowing review of a creationist book, it would still be support from within the creationist bubble). Even if there were an argument for notability, would apply Deletion of On Genetic Interests WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
20805 7079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crimson Falls User:Esradekan 11:39, 28 December 2008 (UTC) delete article fails to establish notability per Deletion of Crimson Falls WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20806 4676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelley Gulledge User:Brewcrewer 23:22, 28 July 2008 (UTC) delete Bios in encyclopedia are intended for people that are widely accepted as the elite in their profession. This person is not a notable baseball player. There are thousands upon thousands of baseball players that have accomplished as much as him. If he is equal to thousands upon thousands of other players it doesn't make any sense for there to be an article about him in an encyclopedia. For those editors that won't accept an argument at an afd discussion that doesn't include wikilinked abbreviations here goes: '''Delete'''. No coverage in , thus not meeting . is a Wikiproject, thus any notability standard they come up with doesn't trump Deletion of Kelley Gulledge WP:RS||WP:BIO||WP:BB||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20807 1552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CSANF User:Phil 17:45, 27 March 2009 (UTC) delete """per . No evidence that anyone other than the founders has noticed these """"federations"""" apart from one silly season press article. Part of the fantasy football |walled garden around NF-Board""" Deletion of CSANF WP:NFT||WP:walled garden Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
20808 11481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The lost boys 2 the tribe User:Zouavman 19:39, 28 July 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of The lost boys 2 the tribe WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20809 3914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruelle (group) User:Lowellian 05:25, 9 April 2017 (UTC) keep """The article (''not'' created by me) was https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Ruelle_%28singer%29&oldid=774385563 very much a stub when initially nominated, but the proper action for a notable subject is cleanup and expansion, not deletion. The article needs to be renamed to """"Ruelle (singer)"""" and expanded, but she is definitely notable from her widespread presence in television and film: she is the singer of not just incidental music, but the ''main/opening'' theme songs for both ''Shadowhunters'' (""""This Is the Hunt"""") and ''The Shannara Chronicles'' (""""Until We Go Down""""). Beyond those main opening titles, her songs have also been featured in ''numerous'' primetime television series http://www.tunefind.com/artist/ruelle on multiple television network|networks, including ''Dancing with the Stars (U.S. TV series)|Dancing with the Stars'', ''How to Get Away with Murder'', ''Pretty Little Liars'', ''Quantico (TV series)|Quantico'', ''Revenge (TV series)|Revenge'', ''Scream (TV series)|Scream'', ''Teen Wolf (2011 TV series)|Teen Wolf'', ''The Vampire Diaries'', ''The Walking Dead (TV series)|The Walking Dead'', and ''many'' more. On film, she is featured on both the trailer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=08JRDC4-kug and the soundtrack http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1850397/soundtrack for ''The Loft (film)|The Loft''. That widespread use of her music more than satisfies criteria #10 on . Furthermore, she has collaborated with other notable musical groups, for instance, providing the vocals on the Ki Theory|Ki:Theory song """"Bringing Me Down"""" http://kitheory.spinshop.com/Home/details/250420 http://www.purevolume.com/news/PREMIERE-KiTheory-Bringing-Me-Down-ft-Ruelle http://www.soundfiction.net/2017/03/29/kitheory-releases-new-single-bringing-announces-silence-album-pre-orders. She has been a Wikipedia:Requested articles/music/Performers, bands and songwriters|requested article for over a year, since March 2016 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Requested_articles/music/Performers,_bands_and_songwriters&diff=708112359&oldid=707770304. As for independent, third-party coverage, she has been interviewed by ''Culture Collide'' http://www.culturecollide.com/reviews/detail/ruelle_reps_electro_pop_in_nashville, the ''Society Cynic'' http://thesocietycynic.com/the-literary-review-blog/exclusive-interview-with-maggie-eckford-ruelle, and ''Young Entertainment'' magazine https://youngentertainmentmag.com/ye-talks-to-haunting-songstress-ruelle/. She is the subject of an ''AllMusic'' profile http://www.allmusic.com/artist/ruelle-mn0003439471/biography and of articles by ''Bookstacked'' http://bookstacked.com/features/ruelle-songs-shadowhunters/, ''Beyond the Stage'' magazine http://www.beyondthestagemagazine.com/new-music-monday-ruelle/, Freeform (TV channel)|Freeform http://freeform.go.com/shows/shadowhunters/news/ruelle-the-woman-behind-the-music-from-that-clace-kiss, and MTV http://www.mtv.com/news/2548733/shannara-chronicles-opening-credits/. Finally, her song """"I Get to Love You"""" reached #15 on the Billboard charts|''Billboard'' Spotify Viral 50 chart http://www.billboard.com/artist/6889562/ruelle/chart?f=2206""" Deletion of Ruelle (group) WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20810 10197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Rankin (actor) User:Magnolia677 23:29, 29 August 2018 (UTC) delete Fails , and . No coverage in reliable secondary sources Deletion of James Rankin (actor) WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO||WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20811 18555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Grimshaw User:Bearian 15:25, 10 February 2009 (UTC) delete attack bio of non-notable living person; |see the rules Deletion of Paul Grimshaw WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20812 2270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erlend Krauser User:Wikicology 00:28, 19 October 2014 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability. Subject of the article fails . Subject of the article is not covered in multiple independent |reliable sources. Although it has an article in Romanian Wikipedia but no single reference was present to validate its notability, just like the one we have here (on the english wikipedia Deletion of Erlend Krauser WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20813 11667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Livonia High School (New York) User:Arg342 13:21, 9 February 2021 (UTC) merge From the original author. Back in 2013 when I created this article, I was trying to flesh out articles about Secondary Schools in New York State. Back then, articles about Secondary Schools had an automatic right to exist. This was before the 2017 decision that went the other way. See bullet point 3 under . So anyhow, I got an Excel Spreadsheet of all the Secondary Schools in New York State and went through the list, county by county, and started improving or creating them as stubs. Now, eight years later, no one has found anything notable about this school and the standards have changed. So if it no longer belongs as a stand-alone article, maybe it should go away. On the other hand, rather than throwing out the baby with the bathwater, perhaps this article can become a section within the article about the Town where it is located, Livonia, New York Deletion of Livonia High School (New York) WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20814 14952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of crimes committed in the United States by illegal aliens User:DreamLinker 18:52, 1 March 2019 (UTC) delete """as this is a synthesised list for a cross category (List of X belonging to Y). At the moment, there is no definite guideline on notability of such lists. The closest I found was {{tq|There is no present consensus for how to assess the notability of more complex and cross-categorization lists (such as """"Lists of X of Y"""") or what other criteria may justify the notability of stand-alone lists, although non-encyclopedic cross-categorizations are touched upon in Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not}}, available in . Interestingly, :Category:Crimes committed by illegal immigrants was https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2019_January_24&oldid=885334849#Category:Crimes_committed_by_illegal_immigrants deleted, which makes me lean towards deletion. Unless multiple reliable sources have documented such a list and it has been shown to be notable, I think it is pure to create one. For example, List of crimes in USA by NRA members could plausibly exist, but there is no need to have one unless it has actually been published in reliable sources. This list violates and it is particularly POV, given that a list documenting crimes by people other than illegal immigrants, does not exist. I am also concerned about BLP/NPOV issues and I think Wikipedia should avoid keeping anything which denigrates an individual without legal proof (a few articles for a short while in some sensationalist media do not count""" Deletion of List of crimes committed in the United States by illegal aliens WP:NOTESAL||WP:SYNTH||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
20815 1396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cheese (cheesy music) User:Andrew 01:11, 20 April 2007 (UTC) delete we don't need an article for the use of an adjective that some people associate with some types of music. Therefore, I believe the content isn't suited for an encyclopedia, nor does it meet the spirit of . Plus there are OR/sourcing issues Deletion of Cheese (cheesy music) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20816 7685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tracie D. Hall User:Pburka 22:36, 2 May 2021 (UTC) keep The nominator's rationale is vague, but Hall satisfies . For example, she's the subject (and title!) of chapter 9 in https://www.google.com/books/edition/Real_Role_Models/QAI7ydZVaW8C?hl=en&gbpv=1&pg=PA43&printsec=frontcover ''Real Role Models: Successful African Americans Beyond Pop Culture '' (University of Texas Press; 2013). Her predecessor, Mary Ghikas, is probably notable, too, but nobody's started a page for her, yet Deletion of Tracie D. Hall WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20817 7151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Gooderham and Maxine Arnold User:Kylohk 00:58, 26 July 2007 (UTC) delete Wikipedia |isn't some place for reporting news, particularly if there is nothing significant about the murder other than someone's been killed Deletion of Terry Gooderham and Maxine Arnold WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20818 21939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of streets and roads in Hong Kong NONE NONE comment Well, I know this more of what mentions as 'bad' to say in arguments, but to avoid some parochialism simply because it is Hong Kong, please compare to New York City. In that area there are a web of interlinked articles and categories - here are 'some' of them Deletion of List of streets and roads in Hong Kong WP:ATA Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20819 8555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unfinished Confessions User:Wisdom89 05:32, 25 March 2008 (UTC) delete Complete failure of . I can't find any sources which can confirm the purported recognition. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Unfinished+Confessions%22+metalcore&btnG=Search and http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Unfinished+Confessions%22+band&btnG=Search, http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&um=1&tab=wn&q=%22Unfinished+Confessions%22+&btnG=Search+News. No Deletion of Unfinished Confessions WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20820 13998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jon Young User:B 03:08, 11 May 2008 (UTC) delete Not to be confused with John Young. Locally well-known, but mixtapes do not get him close to the notability bar under Deletion of Jon Young WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20821 7890 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maria Said User:Tikiwont 14:22, 16 November 2009 (UTC) delete as not meeting otability (people)#Politicians Deletion of Maria Said WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20822 12070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anak (society) User:Disavian 06:16, 14 June 2006 (UTC) keep Unfortunately, the nature of secret societies makes it hard for them to pass . However, there IS public information that I feel gives them enough verifiability and notability for the article to remain on wikipedia. ''Especially'' since they (could have) started all of the important organizations on campus. If they did, then they're just as notable as G. Wayne Clough|Funk masta G-Wayne Deletion of Anak (society) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20823 15796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ledri Vula User:Hughesdarren 08:30, 25 August 2019 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Ledri Vula WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20824 12661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lightshow (rapper) User:Erpert 18:21, 13 July 2013 (UTC) delete """His having been shot garnered ''some'' attention, but not enough to pass , imo (one of the links in the article even says """"a local rapper from..."""", which suggests ). '''Erpert""" Deletion of Lightshow (rapper) WP:MUSICBIO||WP:ITSLOCAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20825 528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rafael Leão User:Argyle 15:29, 29 August 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Rafael Leão WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20826 11485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roman Heart User:Gene93k 14:06, 14 January 2008 (UTC) keep and cleanup. He passes per Grabby and GayVN award wins. Sources easily found and added Deletion of Roman Heart WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20827 5838 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raffaele Di Gennaro User:GiantSnowman 09:36, 15 May 2012 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Raffaele Di Gennaro WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20828 5823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raynes Park High School User:Atmoz 17:27, 4 February 2009 (UTC) delete High schools are not inherently notable. http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Raynes+Park+High+School%22 Google shows WP as its first hit, and no other sources which provide independent third-party reliable sources with enough material for this ever to be more than a stub. http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Raynes+Park+High+School%22 GNews has a few links to articles such as http://news.bbc.co.uk/cbbcnews/hi/uk/newsid_3211000/3211835.stm this and http://www.watfordobserver.co.uk/news/1430338.print/ this. Fails Deletion of Raynes Park High School WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20829 3711 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daphne Plessner User:J04n 13:23, 9 March 2011 (UTC) delete unable to find significant coverage in reliable sources independent of the subject of this unsourced |BLP. I did find http://www.timeshighereducation.co.uk/story.asp?storyCode=192547§ioncode=26 this but it falls short of significant coverage by quite a bit Deletion of Daphne Plessner WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20830 21043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sreebala K Menon User:WordSeventeen 08:26, 10 April 2015 (UTC) keep """This article subject meets by having significant coverage in multiple independent . I would hope that in the future the nominator would more completely follow . I do not really get the meaning of this sentence nominator. """"(I didn't feel like going through every history update either)"""" What did you mean by that statement, and how does the meaning of said statement coincide with ? Cheers""" Deletion of Sreebala K Menon WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:BEFORE||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20831 18393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Linda Cohen User:AusLondonder 23:18, 14 April 2016 (UTC) delete Fails , no in-depth coverage Deletion of Linda Cohen WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20832 14505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ameer Abro User:Capmango 21:34, 7 June 2007 (UTC) keep Probably doesn't meet the threshold, and has problems. But the article was tagged with autobiography, notability, and verify on June 5th and then nominated for deletion June 7th. An author ought to be given at least a week to rewrite in response to the tags before being sent to afd Deletion of Ameer Abro WP:BIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
20833 19844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colin Montgomery Lewis User:PJM 21:50, 22 November 2005 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Colin Montgomery Lewis WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20834 6905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Floyd User:Paulmcdonald 15:36, 26 May 2020 (UTC) keep we typically find that head coaches of college football programs pass and I see no reason to make an exception here. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Jeff Floyd WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20835 16546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Instrument maker User:Non 18:38, 1 October 2015 (UTC) keep """Per : """"Disambiguation in Wikipedia is the process of resolving the conflicts that arise when a single term is ambiguous...even it does not presently result in a titling conflict between two or more articles""" Deletion of Instrument maker WP:D Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
20836 151 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/La-Tar Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 10:11, 16 Aralık 2015 (UTC) delete Tam aktarılsın diyecektim ki gerekçede belirttiğin gibi müzik aletinin varlığını |doğrulayabilen kaynağa rastlamadım. Silinmesi daha uygun La-Tar'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:D Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20837 19606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melrose Bickerstaff (second nomination) User:Bschott 21:48, 8 December 2006 (UTC) comment But she is Not Notable. We don't have nor need pages for every contestant for every game/talent/reality show on television. IF she wins or has other claims to fame other than this, then she passes but for now...she doesn't and that means in wikipedia that her article should be removed. |Wikipedia is NOT a crystal ball for what could be Deletion of Melrose Bickerstaff (second nomination) WP:BIO||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20838 6885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karolcia User:Coolabahapple 10:49, 6 October 2016 (UTC) keep """meets , ie. """"4.The book is, or has been, the subject of instruction at two or more schools,6 colleges, universities or post-graduate programs in any particular country."""" as it is required reading in Poland classes I to III, see http://redmine.nowoczesnapolska.org.pl/projects/wl-publikacje/wiki/Lista_lektur_wed%C5%82ug_spisu_MEN here, tks to Piotrus above and Polish wikipedia, their article on the book is https://pl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karolcia_(powie%C5%9B%C4%87) here""" Deletion of Karolcia WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
20839 4748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Command & Conquer: Red Alert 3 (second) User:FreelanceWizard 10:32, 6 December 2005 (UTC) delete as it appears to violate #General|Criteria for Speedy Deletion G4 (no recreation of deleted material). I am getting terribly tired of people doing that. It shows very bad faith on their part Deletion of Command & Conquer: Red Alert 3 (second) WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
20840 13409 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gino ninja User:Grafikm_fr 13:53, 6 May 2006 (UTC) delete as I can get no google hits on this one. Fails quite prolly Deletion of Gino ninja WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
20841 4487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Spieth User:Bagumba 10:18, 2 January 2019 (UTC) delete to Jordan Spieth#Personal life at his brother's article. Fails with lack of significant coverage in multiple, independent sources. Does not meet . Any current independent significant coverage is spawned from his famous brother Deletion of Steven Spieth WP:GNG||WP:NBASKETBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20842 11042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seth Garin User:Shooterwalker 03:13, 3 August 2012 (UTC) delete per doniago. No sources to or say anything that isn't in the plot of the regulators in some way shape or form Deletion of Seth Garin WP:verify notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
20843 6504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WNEP Anchors User:Howcheng 06:52, 1 January 2006 (UTC) merge per nom. |Be bold and just do it. There's no need to bring this to AfD Deletion of WNEP Anchors WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
20844 15599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Antinori (Attorney, Author) User:Whpq 13:50, 27 September 2011 (UTC) comment Being a state attorney, all by itself, probably does not meet with respect to holding a state level office as the jurisdiction is at the county level (I think). However, as an elected official, in his capacity as state attorney, he did gain press coverage as shown in the links above. Note that this term as a state attorney comes well before the advent of the Internet, so there's likely very many more sources offline that cover him. So I believe that any issue of intrinsic notability is really irrelevant due to newspaper coverage. I (and I believe Bearian) agree that his books are not notable. However, the coatrack aspect of the biography can be dealt with through normal editting to trim that back Deletion of Paul Antinori (Attorney, Author) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20845 5344 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Information Clearing House (second nomination) User:Tewfik 19:35, 16 May 2007 (UTC) delete failure of criteria. There has been more than enough time for adding sourcing Deletion of Information Clearing House (second nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20846 19726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Cottle NONE NONE keep hat|Inappropriate discussion of off-Wiki activity; borderline |NPA/|OUTING; please discuss the merits of the content, not the editors who created it.}}I discovered that the user who initiated this Articles for deletion (Afd) action, samrolken -- is actually a close personal friend of the subject of the article, Steve Cottle Deletion of Steve Cottle WP:NPA||WP:OUTING Wikipedia:No personal attacks 58
20847 5480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Re:sound User:Charlene 20:35, 9 March 2007 (UTC) delete There are no references given outside those associated with the program. If reliable third party sources are discussing this local radio program, and if those sources were identified and attributed, the article would be fine. As is it fails Deletion of Re:sound WP:ATT Wikipedia:Attribution 108
20848 18089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jilletta Jarvis User:SportingFlyer 01:43, 18 October 2018 (UTC) delete fails , Deletion of Jilletta Jarvis WP:NPOL||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20849 1131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frances M. Vega User:Nsk92 23:55, 17 February 2021 (UTC) keep Admittedly there's not a lot here in terms of coverage, but I think there's just enough to satisfy . I have added an extra source, https://www.tdtnews.com/archive/article_e9bab327-4c76-5f25-893e-8dcc49ce3c49.html, a newspaper article regarding the dedication of the Post Office named after her; the article contains some info about Vega's family background that could be added to the page Deletion of Frances M. Vega WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20850 10 [[Computereinsatz in der Grundschule]] (erl.) Benutzer:Omphalos 01:51, 3. Jul. 2007 (CEST) delete """ack'' mit dem Bischof: Da wird nix draus, hier ist meiner Meinung nach kaum etwas von enzyklopädischem Wert herausdestillierbar. Der größte Teil des Artikels ist entweder oder Glaskugelei (Zitat: """"..''Immer noch ist keine allgemein gültige Theorie des Computereinsatzes im Grundschulunterricht vorhanden''.."""") und verschwurbelt""" Löschung von Computereinsatz in der Grundschule Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
20851 14879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Faded Spades User:A1octopus 23:08, 5 April 2007 (UTC) delete No, no, no, no, no, no, no, NO! The Wikipedia Wikipedia:No one cares about your garage band|does not care about non notable bands. Fails usic and anity Deletion of The Faded Spades WP:M||WP:V Wikipedia:Mediation 96
20852 11159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NewtonX, Inc. (2nd nomination) User:Rhododendrites 22:31, 12 October 2019 (UTC) delete Yeah, all of the sources I've clicked so far are pretty terrible (including those linked above). Definite issues. Furthermore some funny business going on here. I see in this AfD several relatively inactive accounts that I'm used to seeing pop up together, but always in one completely unrelated topic area, which makes this quite strange. More so that so many people are getting WP:ORG so wrong, pointing to brief mentions, press releases, routine coverage, trade publications, etc. &mdash Deletion of NewtonX, Inc. (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
20853 19578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Willie Macc User:FisherQueen 16:42, 7 November 2007 (UTC) delete I couldn't find much in the way of |reliable sources, and IMDB indicates that he's mainly played minor roles. No prejudice against recreation if he becomes famous some day Deletion of Willie Macc WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20854 7862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Příběh kriminálního rady User:James500 18:42, 22 July 2018 (UTC) keep """Satisfies by virtue of having been adapted for film: https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=nW5FAAAAQBAJ&pg=PA177#v=onepage. (The film is """"In the Silence of the Night"""", 1978). Appears to satisfy GNG due to coverage in GBooks and elsewhere (assuming I am reading the czech language sources correctly""" Deletion of Příběh kriminálního rady WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
20855 21598 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bulbul Maina User:MichaelQSchmidt 06:45, 18 January 2017 (UTC) delete as being far |TOO SOON, not for being hoaxy (sorry). Allow a |return ONLY if or when is met Deletion of Bulbul Maina WP:NYF||WP:REFUND||WP:NF Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20856 2113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fictional portrayals of the Japan Self-Defense Forces User:Mangojuice 13:21, 23 February 2007 (UTC) delete as |trivia Deletion of Fictional portrayals of the Japan Self-Defense Forces WP:TRIV Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
20857 10198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Live At Parc Des Princes DVD User:TenPoundHammer 16:27, 9 August 2008 (UTC) delete per . No reliable sources yet Deletion of Live At Parc Des Princes DVD WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20858 13380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mahdi Yahya User:Lapablo 00:27, 18 February 2019 (UTC) delete Not enough from GNEWS to establish notability. Fails Deletion of Mahdi Yahya WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20859 15871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Accelerated Evolution Forum User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable website forum. &mdash Deletion of Accelerated Evolution Forum WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20860 19199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bahasa Rojak User:CASSIOPEIA 12:26, 26 August 2019 (UTC) keep WP:CENSOR|Wikipedia is not censored and the article is well-sourced with |independent, |reliable sources, thus pass Deletion of Bahasa Rojak WP:IS||WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20861 7595 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frenetic (programming language) User:Peridon 22:34, 14 February 2011 (UTC) delete per nom. I'm not privy to the business of the harassment, but I can see some distinctly odd editing, and an article that's about something with no indication of notability shown. And indeed stated so in its creation, which lends credence to the allegation of , unless I'm missing something. As to the language, I couldn't say. I could write in BASIC, but could make COBOL sit up and beg. (The good old days when silica chunks were set upright in the ground...) I can't even work out what this is supposed to be for. I can see that it's not referenced and from (and possibly including) its creation it's been a problem. I could be wrong (which proves I don't program any more Deletion of Frenetic (programming language) WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
20862 1082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dreams of Deception User:Edtropolis 19:54, 16 June 2007 (UTC) delete As per nom. Basically #MYSPACE|Wikipedia is not MySpace Deletion of Dreams of Deception WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20863 18863 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moulton-Udell High School User:Sue 20:06, 21 December 2012 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Moulton-Udell High School WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20864 15249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of layout engines (CSS) User:GreyWanderer 22:14, 24 February 2007 (UTC) comment """If there are """"plenty of third-party sites doing a much better job ..."""", why don't you list them so they provide as ? I dispute this argument as being contradictory. For the other part of the quote, see below""" Deletion of Comparison of layout engines (CSS) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20865 2646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yana Buchina User:Tomwsulcer 21:23, 1 November 2014 (UTC) keep International contender, competes worldwide, plays in the http://voiceofrussia.com/2009/10/19/2087392/ Kremlin Cup International and against top players such as http://voiceofrussia.com/tag_49398127/2011/04/25/ Martina Sirotkina and http://www1.skysports.com/tennis/news/12110/5543600/heartbreak-for-cornish Stephanie Cornish. Included http://www.cbssports.com/tennis/players/playerpage/1716482/2013/yana-buchina here in CBS Sports roster of tennis contenders, plus http://sportsnetwork.msnbc.com/merge/tsnform.aspx?c=sportsnetwork&page=tennis-w/stat/player.aspx?playerid=1632,season=2014 included here too and in a http://www.gotennis.ru/players/WTA/Yana%20Buchina.html Russian tennis database. A http://www.tennisrecruiting.net/article.asp?id=879&sessionid=08A42C391F13D1A4 write-up here and http://www.tennisrecruiting.net/article.asp?id=834&sessionid=08A42C391F13D1A4 here and a http://tenniskalamazoo.blogspot.com/2007/09/chasing-dream-russian-style-anaheim.html mention here and her http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/tennis/australianopen/4372955/Australian-Open-Day-10.html?image=1 photo here. She has numerous mentions in major international newspapers such as the ''Guardian'' http://www.theguardian.com/sport/2009/sep/13/us-open-order-of-play here and http://www.theguardian.com/sport/2009/sep/13/heather-watson-us-open here and http://www.theguardian.com/sport/2009/sep/07/us-open-order-of-play-day-eight here and has her photo http://www.theguardian.com/sport/gallery/2009/sep/14/heather-watson-us-open-girls-title here. While she is not one of the top women's singles players -- she is ranked 765 according to http://www.wtatennis.com/players/player/14158/title/yana-buchina this source -- still she's won almost $50K in prize money during her career. Still, I did not find a few in-depth reports on her, but if we combine the (numerous) reports about her, in important well-covered matches, in databases, using the rule |If the depth of coverage in any given source is not substantial, then multiple independent sources may be combined to demonstrate notability then she passes notability Deletion of Yana Buchina WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20866 21211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mirage (Aladdin) User:T 23:55, 20 May 2009 (UTC) keep at least two of them, which are more notable than the others (the two that have toys, for example), but all of these are at least redirectable if not mergeable per and . Remember, deletion is considered a last resort for hoaxes, copy vios, and libel, i.e. things that cannot be redirected anywhere or that contains damaging information that we don't want public. We don't delete based on or . Nominator has said, “http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:A_Nobody&diff=291156170&oldid=291127700 I am not really opposed to merging/redirecting the articles.” Please note that if I merge anything we cannot delete per Wikipedia:Merge and delete|the GFDL. Otherwise, subjects can't really fail , which lacks community consensus as evidence by the dispute that resulted in its protection to resolve the dispute as well as a recent RfC in which more editors (over sixty!) opposed it. Anyway, due to the overwhelming notability of the characters as confirmed through reliable independent sourcing, we should either keep and continue to improve or merge and redirect per Deletion of Mirage (Aladdin) WP:BEFORE||WP:PRESERVE||WP:JNN||WP:ITSCRUFT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20867 10091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zane B. Stein User:Softlavender 07:07, 22 July 2013 (UTC) keep Although the article as it now stands may not reflect it, Stein definitely meets , in that in his field he is (1) regarded as an important figure or is widely cited by peers or successors, and (2) known for originating a significant new concept, theory or technique. He is THE pioneer and world astrological expert on Centaurs in astrology#Chiron|Chiron, now regarded as an extremely significant part of an astrological chart and listed on all birthcharts. All subsequent authors or commentators on this astrological body have given deference to Stein and used and quoted his data and findings, including some of the authors seen https://www.google.com/search?q=%22zane+stein%22&num=100&newwindow=1&hl=en&tbm=bks&ei=ONXsUeSGDe3qigLLh4CYAw&start=0&sa=N&biw=1163&bih=718 here, and also Debbi Kempton-Smith's very influential and internationally revered (including in ''The New Yorker'' magazine, etc.) ''Secrets from a Stargazer's Notebook'', and many other books which do not show up on Google's currently rather clunky and inadequate book search. Here are a few other views of mentions: https://www.google.com/search?num=100&newwindow=1&q=%22stein%2C%20zane%22&um=1&ie=UTF-8&hl=en&tbo=u&tbm=bks&source=og&sa=N&tab=wp&ei=nNbsUc6xGYisiALNhYGIDA, http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias%3Dstripbooks&field-keywords=%22zane+stein%22, http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=sr_pg_2?rh=n%3A283155%2Ck%3A%22stein%5Cc+zane%22&page=2&keywords=%22stein%2C+zane%22&ie=UTF8&qid=1374475889 Deletion of Zane B. Stein WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
20868 8786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iranianism User:Taprobanus 14:35, 12 July 2007 (UTC) comment If this page is renamed as Pan Iranianism and properly cited with sources then, i will vote to '''Keep Deletion of Iranianism WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20869 13533 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamaica mann User:Twsx 12:33, 8 November 2007 (UTC) delete per #A7 Deletion of Jamaica mann WP:SD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
20870 3222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emmanuel Morin User:Stifle 01:11, 6 May 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Emmanuel Morin WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20871 58 [[Vorlage:InfoboxSee]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Matthiasb NONE delete Eine Breiteneinstellbarkeit ist unnötig. Damit kein Mehrwert vorhanden, damit redundant, bitte . Das ganze ist sowieso ein eklatanter Verstoß gegen Löschung von Vorlage:InfoboxSee Wikipedia:BNS Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
20872 13537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rodney Pocceschi User:Zunaid 08:58, 20 December 2006 (UTC) delete Being killed in the line of duty does not automatically confer notability, and nothing in the article suggests that this individual did anything notable (in the Wikipedia sense) during his lifetime. News coverage seems mostly local (correct me if I'm wrong?). Article fails . Note: around the world there are literally 1000s of officers who are killed in the line of duty every year. Does this make them non-notable? IMHO yes, although others may disagree Deletion of Rodney Pocceschi WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20873 12713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1785 Wurm User:Praemonitus 20:34, 13 May 2015 (UTC) merge per : unable to satisfy notability requirements based on existing sources Deletion of 1785 Wurm WP:DWMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20874 6760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mandviwalla Entertainment User:K 07:04, 18 September 2016 (UTC) delete per and no indications of notability Deletion of Mandviwalla Entertainment WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20875 19275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Swearing-in ceremony of Narendra Modi User:Prateekmalviya20 11:34, 4 June 2014 (UTC) keep This article meets criteria. It's not ecentism Deletion of Swearing-in ceremony of Narendra Modi WP:EVENTCRIT||WP:R Wikipedia:Notability 77
20876 9033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1521 in India User:Colonel 21:24, 25 May 2013 (UTC) keep per . The claims of the nomination seem too speculative and merger would be more in accordance with our |editing policy Deletion of 1521 in India WP:ATD||WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20877 18139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SpotJobs User:Nick 04:57, 8 January 2017 (UTC) delete The sources appear to mainly be advertorials or lightweight stories that aren't much better, and this is not a large company. As such is not met Deletion of SpotJobs WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20878 7140 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finnimore User:Shalom 22:56, 11 March 2008 (UTC) delete per etc Deletion of Finnimore WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
20879 7116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miserabilis User:Lenticel 05:24, 28 May 2008 (UTC) delete as violation of #Partial title matches. Binomial nomeclature says that the species name is a two-part name. As Deor says, species names are meaningless on their own Deletion of Miserabilis WP:DAB Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
20880 3352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eon8 (2nd nomination) User:Motor 10:54, 1 July 2006 (UTC) delete Internet experiment which appears to fail . The article seems to be entirely original research. Plus, I rather agree with some of Deletion of Eon8 (2nd nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20881 21000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiny Travel Tracker User:Dialectric 12:25, 21 September 2015 (UTC) delete Software article of unclear notability, lacking independent references. A search turned up no significant coverage. Article was created by an Wikipedia:Single-purpose account|SPA as possibly promotional Deletion of Tiny Travel Tracker WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20882 6605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steam Forums User:Last_Malthusian 09:27, 11 January 2006 (UTC) comment """from the original article it seemed as if it might pass . However, as long as there don't seem to be sufficient editors interested to keep it unvandalized without resorting to protection, and as long as there's nothing more to be protected than a stub, I don't think it's worth keeping. I think I looked at all the edits that might not have been vandalism, and couldn't find any versions of the article longer than a stub (""""it exists, it has x users and y posts as of z"""") that weren't vandalism. Maybe add a note about the forum in wherever is relevant, presumably Steam (content delivery""" Deletion of Steam Forums WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20883 6045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vidyananda User:K 05:43, 24 June 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet ; significant RS coverage not found. Just a page, lacking reliable sources Deletion of Vidyananda WP:ANYBIO||WP:ADVOCACY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20884 5524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buttock Batu User:Dlthewave 12:42, 5 July 2021 (UTC) delete """Sourcing is insufficient to establish notability. I would challenge the assertion that this meets , since that guideline {{tq|""""specifically excludes maps, tables, lists, databases, etc., from consideration when establishing topic notability""""}} and the only current references are a list and a database""" Deletion of Buttock Batu WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20885 20513 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin's Super Markets User:Epinoia 01:24, 14 May 2019 (UTC) merge """to SpartanNash - not notable enough for a stand-alone article - no """"significant or demonstrable effects on culture, society, entertainment, athletics, economies, history, literature, science, or education"""" per - citations are about the take-over by SpartanNash and a crime (one-event notability), not specifically about Martin's Super Markets - therefore, redirect""" Deletion of Martin's Super Markets WP:ORGSIG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20886 18034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shafique Katumba User:The 09:30, 13 August 2020 (UTC) delete """since our subject (""""https://www.sqoop.co.ug/201908/four-one-one/socialite-katsha-debank-launches-education-foundation.html founder of a money spending group, based in South Africa but comes to Uganda every end of the year to throw parties"""") abjectly fails . Description of subject and his major claim to notability is that he's a """"socialite,"""" with, however, an extremely lite support for the claim. Even the references that are invoked to prop up the subject's worthiness admit as much, i.e. """"Katsha is not known much on the socialite list,"""" in https://www.newvision.co.ug/news/1511530/katsha-bank-replace-rich-gang here. All the invoked sources, in any case, or those that can be scared up through |online searches, are thinner than an summer suit's fabric: A bunch of advertorials (such https://www.newvision.co.ug/news/1511530/katsha-bank-replace-rich-gang this where we're questioned in the prose """"Will Katumba satisfy the hungry money hunters who will storm the club expecting to pick free money in a night?"""" or https://www.showbizuganda.com/katsha-debank-to-expand-college-branches/ this, with no quote necessary, or https://www.routineblast.com/katsha-debank-follows-the-late-don-ivan-footsteps-to-expand-colleges-to-new-towns-in-south-africa/ this); some |interviews in gossip magazines, such as https://www.sqoop.co.ug/201501/features/katsha-de-banks-story-of-the-south-african-hustle.html this one; then a flock of dead links on which we better tread carefully, e.g. https://www.xclusive.co.ug/2020/05/08/katsha-de-bank-auctions-shs1-5-billion-car-for-covid-19-relief/ here, http://news.ugo.co.ug/furious-mc-kats-spills-secrets-behind-ivan-semwanga-rich-gangs-fame/ here, etc. This is but another |vain attempt at |social promotion, |unworthy of an article""" Deletion of Shafique Katumba WP:NPERSON||WP:BEFORE||WP:PRIMARY||WP:COI||WP:PROMO||WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20887 8037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Fissel User:Evb 04:09, 24 August 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. , fails to meet , and provides no Deletion of William Fissel WP:NN||WP:BIO||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20888 4325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trail Bologna User:Arxiloxos 02:44, 18 January 2011 (UTC) keep In addition to the above, more than 50 hits at Google Books and nearly 200 at Google News archives back up what's offered so far. (Many of them are from local papers, e.g. http://news.google.com/newspapers?id=0CZcAAAAIBAJ&sjid=XFUNAAAAIBAJ&pg=3204,5809055&dq=trail-bologna+troyer&hl=enhttp://news.google.com/newspapers?id=yDBPAAAAIBAJ&sjid=kwIEAAAAIBAJ&pg=6942,1988907&dq=trail-bologna+troyer&hl=en, but here's a mention in the ''Los Angeles Times''http://articles.latimes.com/print/1987-08-09/travel/tr-60_1_plain-people.) Article badly needs a clean-up and wikilinking, but this seems to be a legitimately notable bit of local folkway cuisine. Let's |bite the bologna and not the newbie creators of this article Deletion of Trail Bologna WP:BITE Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
20889 3264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russian legal history User:Bearian 02:37, 9 February 2008 (UTC) keep It's a perfectly good legal stub, with two Deletion of Russian legal history WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20890 21849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Romanian words of possible Dacian origin User:Borsoka 15:00, 15 November 2013 (UTC) delete """1) The article is mainly based on the work of a late 19th-century scholar (Bogdan Petriceicu Hasdeu) whose views have not been universally accepted. (2) That there are words in the Romanian language which are of Dacian origin is only a POV, which cannot be substantiated: there are less than a 100 documented Dacian words and none of them is attested among the Romanian words of """"possible Dacian origin"""". Therefore these words can be of """"possible Thracian origin"""" or of """"possible Illyrian origin"""", as well. (3) There are many words in all languages the origin of which is uncertain, but there are no separate articles/lists for them. I think there is no need to create such lists. (4) ikipedia is not a dictionary""" Deletion of List of Romanian words of possible Dacian origin WP:W Help:Watchlist 110
20891 6977 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Art Nalls User:Anotherclown 03:30, 19 August 2015 (UTC) keep there does appear to be sufficient coverage in RS to write a complete biography (no major details missing that I could see) so it meets (in my opinion anyway Deletion of Art Nalls WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20892 15900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Live, Vol. Four User:The 07:11, 5 January 2016 (UTC) keep It passes |general notability guidelines, where it has been reviewed at http://www.allmusic.com/album/live-vol-4-mw0002900058 AllMusic and http://www.jsonline.com/entertainment/musicandnightlife/album-reviews-coldplay-tom-jones-and-the-avett-brothers-b99625663z1-360586631.html ''Milwaukee Journal Sentinel'', and two Billboard (magazine)|''Billboard'' magazine chartings are sufficient to pass |notability for albums and also by |band criteria, for albums are based off the same exact same standards Deletion of Live, Vol. Four WP:GNG||WP:NALBUMS||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
20893 19420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rick Skene User:MichaelQSchmidt 12:07, 5 November 2015 (UTC) delete for failing , and . Sadly, while he is prolific and the many projects which have used him are themselves notable, he makes no spash. As an actor or stunt person his work might be exemplary, but his role choices (even with named support roles) pretty much guarantees he makes no spalsh Deletion of Rick Skene WP:ENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20894 8688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Murray (politician) (4th nomination) User:Cullen328 15:55, 16 June 2012 (UTC) merge to a neutral article about the current race he's a candidate in, that describes all the candidates. At this time, he fails in terms of a biographical article devoted to him Deletion of Patrick Murray (politician) (4th nomination) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20895 6061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kathryn Smith User:Peterkingiron 12:17, 26 January 2011 (UTC) delete see - Councillor = NN; failed Parliamentary candidate - NN; drunk driver = NN; Nothing notable Deletion of Kathryn Smith WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20896 11584 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Civilian Combat Veteran User:Clarityfiend 02:40, 23 April 2015 (UTC) delete per . Nobody's paid much attention Deletion of Civilian Combat Veteran WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
20897 2514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wardheernews Somalia User:JohnmgKing 20:34, 29 May 2020 (UTC) delete article looks promotional or simply created because . Some coverage can be found but not sufficiently reliable sources Deletion of Wardheernews Somalia WP:ITEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20898 14898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Accusations against Israel of war crimes during the Al-Aqsa Intifada NONE NONE comment I had a look at , and I'm still convinced that this isn't a POV fork. If anything, it's an article spinout due to size. There are two quotes in that I think are relevant Deletion of Accusations against Israel of war crimes during the Al-Aqsa Intifada WP:POVFORK||WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
20899 10954 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicole Uysiuseng User:AbsolutDan 14:52, 11 October 2009 (UTC) delete """as having zero reliable sources (fails ). In response to Starczamora, requires sources to be verifiable. Articles that """"go poof"""" with no way of locating them should be disregarded - readers must be ''able'' to """"check that material added to Wikipedia has already been published by a reliable source"""". If articles are found in sources that are expected to disappear, there are archiving services that could be utilized. No prejudice against recreation if (but only if) reliable sources are included""" Deletion of Nicole Uysiuseng WP:V||WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20900 17710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of words to denote religious opponents User:Husond 02:24, 20 October 2006 (UTC) delete """Can hardly be any useful. Furthermore, looks like an inaccurate |original research (""""infidel"""" isn't used just for those who aren't Christians""" Deletion of List of words to denote religious opponents WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
20901 20337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Querix User:Ihcoyc 15:50, 26 September 2011 (UTC) delete per nomination. No showing of |significant effects on history, technology, or culture outside the IT department Deletion of Querix WP:ORGIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20902 1691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pension Volkmann User:Lankiveil 06:19, 22 April 2016 (UTC) keep """I believe a lot of the """"did a search, found nothing"""" results here are based upon looking for sources in English, rather than German, which one would expect the majority of the coverage to be in. While I don't think that Amiga (record label)|Amiga records released during the DDR era are really what #5 has in mind, I think there's enough coverage available in the German language (including on http://www.pensionvolkmann.de/presse.htm their website's press section) to think that there is something notable here""" Deletion of Pension Volkmann WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20903 2983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Karmi User:Mailer 10:40, 6 July 2012 (UTC) delete article is |original research - does not tally with the claimed sources provided Deletion of David Karmi WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
20904 3095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amy Sue Cooper (2nd nomination) User:Morbidthoughts 19:20, 6 April 2010 (UTC) keep Cybergirl of the Year award reported by multiple reliable source passes . She also has enough coverage for me to pass the general notability guidelines Deletion of Amy Sue Cooper (2nd nomination) WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20905 8322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kit Jarrell User:Wistless 20:45, 1 October 2006 (UTC) delete Fails . Not one of the assertions by Deletion of Kit Jarrell WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20906 3963 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vic Joseph User:Cwmhiraeth 13:33, 8 January 2019 (UTC) delete fails to meet and Deletion of Vic Joseph WP:NBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20907 7308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LACMTA citizen proposals User:HisSpaceResearch 16:55, 22 June 2007 (UTC) delete Seems like a newbie's first article without really being aware of the core policies of and Deletion of LACMTA citizen proposals WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20908 110 [[Jack Ryan]] (zurückgezogen) Benutzer:Kriddl NONE comment """Sein"""" Universumm hat er nicht verlassen, der Artikel liest sich auch eher wie eine Darstellung des Gesamtwerkes des Autoren. Abgesehen davon bin ich inzwischen der Ansicht, dass ein Schritt in die falsche Richtung war. Daher""" Löschung von Jack Ryan Wikipedia:AüF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
20909 15092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rude Boy: The Jamaican Don User:Stuartyeates 05:48, 23 July 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Rude Boy: The Jamaican Don WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20910 14092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of current Arena Football League team rosters User:Paulmcdonald 23:24, 4 December 2019 (UTC) delete per |ignore all rules. Yeah, notability is not temporary and such but this is a case where we should just do what's right even if we don't have a rule for it. Maybe an enthusiastic editor can incorporate the data into other pages, no objection to that Deletion of List of current Arena Football League team rosters WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
20911 10285 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Interhistorical User:Spinningspark 10:15, 30 March 2019 (UTC) delete or '''delete and redirect'''. and Deletion of Interhistorical WP:PROMO||WP:NOTESSAY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20912 4130 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naomi Ginsberg User:PWilkinson 12:10, 8 March 2015 (UTC) comment The subject's h-index, according to GScholar, is indeed only 9, but GScholar also shows her as first-named author of two papers with citation counts of over 100 and (so far as I can judge) a g-index of at least 25 (a person's g-index is usually more than their h-index, but rarely by this kind of ratio). The main problem here seems to be that she has published a few papers with high citations but not much else. In some fields, these achievements would be quite enough to clearly meet #1 despite the low h-index - here, it might still be |TOOSOON but I would like to see further opinions Deletion of Naomi Ginsberg WP:PROF||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
20913 16649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelly Chapman User:Finngall 18:39, 28 February 2021 (UTC) delete Completing nomination on behalf of the editor who AfD-tagged the article, who claims to be the subject and the article creator under a different account name. Above text is copied from their edit summary. Normal procedure tends to be to respect the wishes of article subjects of borderline notability in these matters, but regardless of whether they are who they say they are, provided sources fall short of meeting and I found nothing better at a first pass. (Courtesy ping to {{u|Izzysmumkelly Deletion of Kelly Chapman WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20914 5043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boddole Zer User:Shooterwalker 15:35, 10 August 2010 (UTC) merge due to lack of third party sources to . Would be enough for deletion but will support merge for the sake of consensus Deletion of Boddole Zer WP:verify notability Wikipedia:Notability 77
20915 4617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KeyedBits User:Alpha 02:52, 1 October 2011 (UTC) delete Article lacks |reliable third party sources and is almost entirely comprised of |origional research Deletion of KeyedBits WP:IRS||WP:OR Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20916 1446 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Burchert User:Bearian 00:06, 15 September 2007 (UTC) delete per nom - improper no-freeuse images, |auto-hagiography, non-notable, improper sourcing for a , and spam Deletion of John Burchert WP:AUTO||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
20917 1777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hänsel und Gretel (John Pritchard recording) User:4meter4 01:22, 20 September 2019 (UTC) comment The criteria in ikiProject Classical music/Guidelines#Notability of recordings is from an essay by a WikiProject and does not carry the broad support of wikipedia policy. Further, this guideline section is currently being considered for removal for concerns, as well as its conflict with the policy at Deletion of Hänsel und Gretel (John Pritchard recording) WP:W||WP:NPOV||WP:NALBUM Help:Watchlist 110
20918 186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Cooke (cyclist) (2nd nomination) User:Lugnuts 10:05, 7 December 2014 (UTC) keep One ref does not equate to non-notable. Suggest the nominator withdraws this and reads Deletion of Matt Cooke (cyclist) (2nd nomination) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
20919 336 [[Wikipedia:Richtlinien Musikalische Werke]] (gelöscht, Weiterleitung auf WP:RK) Benutzer:Gripweed NONE keep Gähn. und '''ungültiger Löschantrag'''. Ersatzloses Streichen ist kontraproduktiv. Artikel-Qualität ist weiterhin im Umgang mit Alben und Songs notwendig. Zum wiederholten Mal der Hinweis, das es sowohl der |Literatur- als auch der Filmbereich genauso handhaben Löschung von Wikipedia:Richtlinien Musikalische Werke Wikipedia:Richtlinien Literarische Werke Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
20920 21056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SLT Human Capital Solutions User:scope_creep 09:07, 6 November 2020 (UTC) delete No effective sources. Fails Deletion of SLT Human Capital Solutions WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20921 14521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hippopotomonstrosesquippedaliophobia User:ColourBurst 18:14, 16 September 2006 (UTC) comment has nothing to do with the merit of the article, good or bad. It's because |Wikipedia isn't a dictionary Deletion of Hippopotomonstrosesquippedaliophobia WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20922 19713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Study of Tamoxifen and Raloxifene (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 12:57, 11 January 2012 (UTC) keep Per sourcing added to the article, topic passes . See references section in the article; the ABC News, USA Today and Business Week articles cover this topic directly Deletion of Study of Tamoxifen and Raloxifene (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20923 2366 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Au Revoir User:Esradekan 02:33, 8 April 2009 (UTC) delete fails notability per #Songs. No awards, no chart, no covers, no Deletion of Au Revoir WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20924 14556 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of minor Ranma ½ characters (anime) User:Collectonian 19:25, 10 January 2009 (UTC) delete on-episode/ characters are of little consequence to plot and already covered adequately in their mentions in the the summaries of List of Ranma ½ episodes|the episodes. Fails and . Absolutely no third party sourcing mentioning this minor characters at all. Also extremely redundant, with List of minor Ranma ½ characters (manga) and List of Ranma ½ minor characters lists as well...how many minor character lists did this series get Deletion of List of minor Ranma ½ characters (anime) WP:WAF||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
20925 7055 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Ross Hinton User:Jersey92 14:16, 14 July 2014 (UTC) delete Fails . Seems . If he wins it is still right now. Also poorly written: does not even have a political party listed. Delete Deletion of James Ross Hinton WP:POLITICIAN||WP:PROMOTION||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
20926 2897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/One Financial (2nd nomination) User:Cocytus 01:48, 3 January 2010 (UTC) delete fails . The fact that a spam campaign seems to be involved doesn't help; the fact that this same article (more or less) has not survived past AfDs doesn't help. I suggest salting this for now, as it appears as though those involved in the spam campaign are recreating these types of articles repeatedly Deletion of One Financial (2nd nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20927 21642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pokejungle.net User:Haeleth 11:32, 7 September 2006 (UTC) delete per . Note that I have no prejudice against the site as such; but claims to notability like ~3000 visitors a day or references on international blogs and image boards are simply inadequate in the absence of awards or published references. My own homepage gets more visitors than that and has also been referred to on a number of international blogs and forums, but if anyone created an article on it, I would nominate it for deletion myself. &mdash Deletion of Pokejungle.net WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
20928 19850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caroline Scott (2nd nomination) User:ThaddeusB NONE merge to Miss Wyoming USA - The correct sourcing is rather weak and the article has minimal content. In other words, notability is possible, but unproven. However, that doesn't mean the subject can't be covered at a broader article and the current article content (4 sentences) would not be undue weight at Miss Wyoming USA. I note also, that the two recent delete arguments are exceptionally weak (and the others preceded the current version of the article). One is flat out wrong (she won the adult version of the pageant this year, not the teen version, and no one is arguing that is automatic notability anyway) and the other is Deletion of Caroline Scott (2nd nomination) WP:JNN Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20929 19119 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hellmut Schnackenburg User:Atlantic306 00:08, 15 November 2020 (UTC) keep as has reliable sources have been added to the article so that is passed and deletion is unnecessary in my view Deletion of Hellmut Schnackenburg WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20930 16238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/^v^w^v^ (Car Bomb album) User:Armbrust 13:21, 30 September 2010 (UTC) delete as there are no |reliable sources about this album and it is a very unlikely search term. |TenPoundHammer's Law can be aplied too, as there is no information on tracklist and release date and no source confirms the title of the album Deletion of ^v^w^v^ (Car Bomb album) WP:RS||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20931 9799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Surendar Shanmugam User:GeoffreyT2000 00:49, 20 March 2017 (UTC) delete Search found nothing but LinkedIn and other unreliable sources. The non-IMDb source in the article is not sufficient for notability as notability is |not inherited Deletion of Surendar Shanmugam WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20932 16510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sirens (U2 album) User:Lugnuts 18:09, 22 August 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and borderline hoax too Deletion of Sirens (U2 album) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20933 9341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Two Days in April User:Erik 19:06, 8 June 2011 (UTC) comment I agree that coverage is sparse, at least when doing a |search engine test. http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2007/writers/the_bonus/12/20/documentary/ Here is one article available online. http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=HT&p_theme=ht&p_action=search&p_maxdocs=200&p_topdoc=1&p_text_direct-0=11FE6D18E2F40B38&p_field_direct-0=document_id&p_perpage=10&p_sort=YMD_date:D&s_trackval=GooglePM Here is another that isn't. It may help to ask someone to do a search in subscription-only news databases to see if additional coverage exists. In addition, film and sports periodicals will not always put their articles online, so there may be something more Deletion of Two Days in April WP:SET Wikipedia:Search engine test 38
20934 3706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hash BioTech Labs User:AllyD 16:37, 25 October 2018 (UTC) delete I don't see the 2013 ''Indian Express'' article describing their farm as sufficient to demonstrate attained notability, and searches are not finding better Deletion of Hash BioTech Labs :WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20935 5931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jokers' Masquerade (2nd nomination) User:Money 02:48, 25 January 2020 (UTC) keep The sources for the article are quite shoddy now (2 primary, other 2 are for a unimpressive world record), but a search revealed that this company has continually caused controversy in Britain over the last few years, such as when they sold an https://metro.co.uk/2018/10/09/blade-gunner-costume-lets-you-dress-up-as-killer-oscar-pistorius-for-halloween-8020484/ Oscar Pistorius costume (complete with toy gun!), a https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-berkshire-29718923 psych ward costume that was https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2014/oct/31/halloween-costume-mental-illness-prime-minister-norman-lamb condemned as rienforcing stereotypes, https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-33451674 and were forced to surrender one of their star wars domain names to disney. I couldn't find anything supporting the unimpressive hitwise awards and will remove their mention, along with the primary sources, but I think this just barely passes Deletion of Jokers' Masquerade (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20936 14282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shiyas Kareem (2nd nomination) User:GSS 14:46, 1 March 2021 (UTC) delete fails and a case of . As mentioned by the nominator the creator appear to have a conflict of interested and socking using IP addresses Deletion of Shiyas Kareem (2nd nomination) WP:NACTOR||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
20937 15857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brandon Newton User:Paulmcdonald 22:45, 22 December 2015 (UTC) delete fails and does not seem to pass any other notability measure such as . Generally, college offensive linemen are not found to be notable because they just don't get the coverage, so it is not surprising. Unable to find any news articles on this particular Brandon Newton in my cursory review. If they are found and presented, I will happily review Deletion of Brandon Newton WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20938 4414 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Culver User:Niteshift36 09:15, 12 June 2009 (UTC) delete Not notable at all. Fails Deletion of Jonathan Culver WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20939 1756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DMS Derivatives Market Specialist User:Johnuniq 10:44, 13 June 2009 (UTC) delete We have articles for certification programs like Microsoft Certified Professional, because it is an extremely widely-discussed course. I don't know of anything other than to gauge whether this course is notable, and I believe it fails that test. The references establish that there is a course, and that there are sites that want to sell the course to you. However, it has be |notable for an encyclopedic article. A similiar article is Macquarie Global Leadership Program which is also up for AFD Deletion of DMS Derivatives Market Specialist WP:GNG||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20940 4875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/London Underground trivia (4th nomination) User:Gavin 09:49, 18 September 2007 (UTC) delete as the rump of an article is comprised of otability|non-notable |original research Deletion of London Underground trivia (4th nomination) WP:N||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
20941 15315 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Archangel class assault ship (2nd nomination) User:Knowledgekid87 20:53, 20 December 2012 (UTC) delete Fails per and OTPLOT Deletion of Archangel class assault ship (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:NOTPLOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20942 605 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TIME Fibre Broadband User:Lemongirl942 09:23, 19 October 2016 (UTC) delete Sourced or not, this is simply advertising. No claim of significance here and doesn't satisfy Deletion of TIME Fibre Broadband WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20943 6170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MPD in fiction User:Jay32183 07:00, 18 November 2007 (UTC) delete This list doesn't contain any sourced analysis. Making a list that associates all the fictional works that have MPD is unpublished synthesis from published works, violating . It this is not original research then it is a directory of loosely associated topics, violation #DIR Deletion of MPD in fiction WP:OR||WP:NOT Wikipedia:No original research 65
20944 12557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Microsoft office 2012 User:Lulu 08:53, 14 January 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Microsoft office 2012 WP:CHRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20945 4135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skippy List [[User talk:Skomorokh|Skomorokh]] 23:40, 19 June 2008 (UTC) comment Could you please elaborate on how you see applying to this case? Thank you Deletion of Skippy List WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20946 19793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of electricians User:Fayenatic 20:47, 9 January 2013 (UTC) keep This list was created following Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2012 March 15#Category:Electricians by nationality. This was subsequently discussed at and Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2012 April 1#Category:Electricians, at which there was no consensus about the list. IMHO the list should be kept as it presents more information than the category, namely the grounds for the notability achieved by each electrician with an article Deletion of List of electricians WP:DRV Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
20947 10485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Electoral history of Nabih Berri User:TimothyBlue 15:38, 10 November 2020 (UTC) merge This is an unnecessary split . Article Nabih Berri already discusses his political career and there is no reason to split off these details into their own article. There are sources that show the notability of their political career, but none that address their electoral history as a seperate topic. If sources do not separate their political career and electoral history, but treats them as one topic, the article shouldn't be split either unless there is a very good reason to. // Deletion of Electoral history of Nabih Berri WP:CFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
20948 6331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Northwest Post-Grunge (2nd nomination) User:SportingFlyer 12:18, 2 April 2021 (UTC) delete Per my discussion at the DRV, this article fails . While additional sources have been added since my comments, including a several-sentence review in Gavin Rocks, none of the other sources are close. I'd prefer a salt - if this is recreated, it can be done in draft space Deletion of Northwest Post-Grunge (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20949 15127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bart B More User:Bearian 17:25, 22 September 2018 (UTC) delete producers are |dime a dozen. I tried to click on a few possibly good sources (BBC) and found nothing |indicating significant coverage, other than a stray interview Deletion of Bart B More WP:MILL||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
20950 5314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary C. Ross User:Anotherclown 00:22, 5 July 2015 (UTC) delete """per nomination. Obviously there is some useful information which can be included elsewhere - if it hasn't already (like at Don't ask, don't tell per the suggestions above). Otherwise the subject doesn't appear to be notable per (lacks """"significant"""" coverage in independent |reliable sources). Likewise fails and as far as I can see. I'm also concerned about the |COI and advocacy aspects the article seems to present (is Wikipedia being used here as a forum to question the validity of an administrative decision, i.e. his non-promotion and discharge for instance?) Overall, a fairly junior officer with a relatively average / normal / undistinguished career that seems little different from all the others who have trodden the same path (setting aside the LGBT issues which as I said should be addressed elsewhere - but even then only briefly so as not to breach """ Deletion of Gary C. Ross WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:SOLDIER||WP:AUTHOR||WP:COI||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20951 6412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Enyart User:Kafziel 01:42, 16 September 2008 (UTC) delete I can't find any significant coverage in reliable third-party sources. Mostly just blogs and watchdog groups (either for or against him), and no sources for the many opinions and accusations. I tried to improve the refs but wasn't able to do so, and instead had to remove a lot of statements that were in violation of . Without those, he doesn't seem to add up to much Deletion of Bob Enyart WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
20952 21659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erich Reimer (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 17:24, 29 November 2018 (UTC) delete Nothing stated here is an article-clinching notability claim in the absence of a -passing volume of media coverage ''for'' it — but the sources aren't getting him over GNG. Almost all of the references are unreliable sources, |primary sources, pieces where he's the bylined ''author'' of content about himself or other things rather than the ''subject'' of coverage written by other ''people'', or glancing namechecks of his existence as a giver of soundbite in coverage about other things — none of which supports notability at all. Literally the ''only'' source here that represents coverage ''about him'' in a ''reliable'' source is a piece of ''local'' coverage in his own hometown media, which is ''not'' enough coverage to clinch nationalized notability Deletion of Erich Reimer (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES Wikipedia:Notability 77
20953 14935 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of United States tornadoes from November to December 2012 User:Spinningspark 10:31, 31 October 2012 (UTC) keep """per UltraExactZZ. This would be a pointless bureaucratic deletion as the article would definitely be recreated in a day or two. Please be sensible and apply . The claim that item 2 applies is incorrect, this article is not an """"Individual items from a predetermined list or a systematic pattern of names"""" but rather an overview of a group of individual items""" Deletion of List of United States tornadoes from November to December 2012 WP:IAR||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
20954 8649 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Rain Tapes User:Edgarde 01:19, 9 February 2009 (UTC) keep Not covered in this form in the ''Unreleased'' article. It would be nice if the Goldmine article were more extensively quoted, because it seems to be the main source of the detail in this article, and ''Goldmine (magazine)'' is a reasonably good source per :unreleased albums are in general not notable; however, they may be notable if they have significant independent coverage in reliable sources.Subject exists, and more information will probably become available in time Deletion of The Rain Tapes WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20955 14925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of internet marketing gurus User:Kinu 00:06, 23 November 2009 (UTC) delete """per my original {{tl|prod}} endorsement. The list is based on dubious criteria. The """"cart before the horse"""" argument mentioned on the talk page applies: ''if'' relevant articles can be created with reliable sources (note that Armand Morin has been deleted for lack of ), ''and'' the term """"guru"""" can be defined in such a way that isn't purely subjective, then such a list ''may'' be legitimate""" Deletion of List of internet marketing gurus WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20956 6517 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Disobedients User:Adrian 21:44, 31 January 2006 (UTC) delete as |non-notable Deletion of The Disobedients WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20957 11957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raúl González (Mexican boxer) User:Papaursa 00:06, 5 May 2014 (UTC) delete He doesn't meet and none of the references are sufficient to meet Deletion of Raúl González (Mexican boxer) WP:NBOX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20958 412 [[Gustav und Erich]] (LAZ) NONE 21:00, 11. Apr. 2014 (CEST) delete WP:ART|kein ausreichender Artikel und/oder |kein enzyklopädischer Inhalt'' —|| Löschung von Gustav und Erich Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20959 12314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jimmy Nakayama User:Bearian 16:31, 13 June 2013 (UTC) keep per LeftCoast and ChrisGualtieri. While he doesn't pass WP:SOLDIER, he easily passes . I also think the article has been fixed up enough for . In the alternative, a '''merge''' ''a la'' Roderick_Wetherill#Roderick_Wetherill.2C_Jr. would work, too Deletion of Jimmy Nakayama WP:GNG||WP:HEY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20960 15930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/4077 Asuka User:Boleyn 16:35, 7 December 2014 (UTC) comment u|Deadbeef}}, of course, , but that isn't a suitable argument in an AfD discussion. Have you read and think it meets the guidelines? Best wishes Deletion of 4077 Asuka WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS||WP:NASTRO Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
20961 7437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of former employees of McKinsey & Company User:Postdlf 16:00, 28 October 2018 (UTC) keep per and as an index of notable people by connection to a notable company, and per as an encyclopedic subsection of a parent article on the notable company too large to be contained therein. This is just a list of notable people who worked for a notable company, which is compliant with NOTDIR as a standard, consensus-supported method of indexing articles (see extensive contents of :Category:People by company). The nominator's rationale seems to rest entirely upon the incorrect assumption that this would (or should) eventually contain everyone whoever worked for the company, when it is actually standard practice to limit such lists only to those individuals with articles, just as we would with a list of people from a town, alumni of a school, etc. The parent article, McKinsey & Company, at present contains no list of notable employees, instead only pointing to the list's corresponding category, so we would at most merge this list there rather than deleting it outright, and with 158 articles in :Category:McKinsey & Company people there are undoubtedly enough to merit a standalone list as a split from the parent. Whether each particular individual's connection is substantive enough to merit inclusion in the list or the category is a matter for ordinary editing, and the list can also annotate just what the relationship is Deletion of List of former employees of McKinsey & Company WP:LISTPURP||WP:CLN||WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
20962 2991 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Florida State University shooting (2nd nomination) User:Location 00:50, 21 September 2015 (UTC) delete Fails various criteria in Deletion of Florida State University shooting (2nd nomination) WP:EVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20963 2353 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katharina Leiding User:Grailcombs 17:50, 13 March 2021 (UTC) delete Current sources and his sports achievements doesn't qualify for and Deletion of Katharina Leiding WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
20964 3891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Catia Ojeda User:Aoba47 20:17, 28 November 2016 (UTC) delete per and AngusWOOF's comment above. A promising start and this could be appropriate in the future, but just not right now Deletion of Catia Ojeda WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20965 2949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pari Passu Realty Corp. User:Gavin 07:43, 17 May 2009 (UTC) delete as there is no |verifiable evidence of |notability, and the lack of sourcing shows in its |promotional tone and |undue reliance on the views expressed in the company's own website Deletion of Pari Passu Realty Corp. WP:NRVE||WP:CORP||WP:SPAM||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Notability 77
20966 20612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Kanzius User:Iain99 14:09, 11 July 2007 (UTC) delete on reflection and on further reading and searching. His sporadic local news coverage and even more sporadic national news coverage puts him on the fringes of notability at best (), and the lack of non-credulous, reliable sources makes balanced coverage of his more outlandish ideas impossible Deletion of John Kanzius WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20967 4254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UTRGV Soccer and Track & Field Complex User:Tristan 10:52, 5 February 2021 (UTC) merge to Texas–Rio Grande Valley Vaqueros. There is nothing special about this complex (not historic, important or very large) and it does not pass . All keep votes are based on the assertion that stadia of teams in such a league are presumed to be notable. However, they fail to show a policy/guideline/essay that suggests such a consensus Deletion of UTRGV Soccer and Track & Field Complex WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20968 4488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Chinedu User:HawkAussie 01:57, 21 April 2020 (UTC) delete Fails both and Deletion of Matthew Chinedu WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
20969 20523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JC I User:Qwertyus 19:22, 25 December 2013 (UTC) delete per . Even if the references to Rock On magazine and the French edition of Rolling Stone can be substantiated, these pages are hopeless fancruft and should be completely rewritten Deletion of JC I WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
20970 1182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthony Peake User:S 20:30, 18 July 2012 (UTC) delete This is a biography of a living person and I can't find any evidence of any independent sources that pass Deletion of Anthony Peake WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20971 20728 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ShapeShift (company) NONE NONE keep Article meets , which is explicitly stated in the edit comments as this article was created. Multiple independent sources show notability Deletion of ShapeShift (company) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20972 18166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SyFy Genre Awards User:SamJohnston 16:28, 21 March 2009 (UTC) delete per , /, OT#WEBHOST, etc Deletion of SyFy Genre Awards WP:N||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
20973 10234 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniela E Schreier User:Location 22:00, 25 August 2009 (UTC) delete Fails and . No significant, independent sources thus fails Deletion of Daniela E Schreier WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20974 10272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruth Swissa User:Netrogeractor 02:02, 21 January 2016 (UTC) delete the two news appearances were not stories about her, so it was not significant coverage per . Other sources are not reliable - ex: CTW (Connection to Wellbeing) is just a local advertising sheet that profiles its advertisers. She does not meet as she does not seem to have any achievement, contribution or award different than anyone else in her field Deletion of Ruth Swissa WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20975 3798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Phoenix User:Mattythewhite 17:04, 3 September 2010 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Jamie Phoenix WP:ATHLETE||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20976 1348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jews and Communism User:IZAK 17:44, 5 March 2014 (UTC) merge """to History of communism because as this title stands now it is basically a crude attempt to smear the Jews and not much else. There is a subtle very fine line between presenting facts objectively in NPOV fashion versus using facts in a tendentious manner to paint an obviously derogatory picture of an ''ethnic'' group that has had many characteristics attached to it by its enemies, thus violating in the process with unwanted tones of a favorite slander thrown at """"Jews"""" when, note, the truth about Jews (look up the term) is that they are an ''ethnicity'' but overlooks the fact that when connected to Judaism it ''opposes'' secular atheist ideologies which is what Communism is. Thus those Jews who were part of it were more accurately RENEGADE Jews, which this title does nothing to make clear. No normal person would post about Germans and Nazism since objectively no fair person would want to slander the German people as a whole to associate ''all'' of them with the implication of being Nazis, unlike this article which implicates all Jews willy-nilly, by not having any qualifiers of any kind at any point! Likewise no normal person would write up an article of Italians and Fascism or Italians and the Mafia because that would obviously DEFAME ''all'' Italians by association implying that Italians have a predilection for Fascism or the Mafia. While many Jews were part of Communism's early history and founding, it should be part of the history of communism and not mis-represented as being a """"by-product"""" of Jews (always worrisome when articles like this pop up), no more or less than no normal person would write a blanket article implying that Germans are somehow or other the only prime motivators for the rise of Nazism, or implicating Italians as having some kind of monopoly over the causes promoting the rise of Fascism or the birth of the Mafia. Take heed, this is a slippery slope""" Deletion of Jews and Communism WP:NOTSOAPBOX Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20977 11913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glossary of Christian, Jewish, and Messianic terms user:mikkalai 19:40, 10 December 2007 (UTC) delete This is not a glossary, this is a full-blown exegesis. And its long descriptions combine into one long multi-|fork, with all its problems: difficulty of maintenance of several texts, problems with synchronization and POV subtleties. Each term must be treated in a carefully referenced way in a single place, which is its own article Deletion of Glossary of Christian, Jewish, and Messianic terms WP:FORK Wikipedia:Mirrors and forks 46
20978 17168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/In The Loop (radio program) User:DustFormsWords 05:02, 22 February 2010 (UTC) delete Plenty of sources confirming it exists, but no sources that are either independent, significant, or reliable, let alone all three at once. Without such sources it fails . (Note also that there's a much MORE notable http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/intheloop/ Radio Australia program with the same name Deletion of In The Loop (radio program) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20979 15980 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rene """"brewedsosweet"""" Reyes""" User:Wenli 00:58, 22 September 2007 (UTC) delete Fails . — """Deletion of Rene """"brewedsosweet"""" Reyes""" WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
20980 16407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miami–Nebraska football rivalry User:Northamerica1000 03:42, 4 October 2016 (UTC) keep The sources provided above by {{u|Lizard the Wizard}} show that is met. Note that the article is sourced at this time Deletion of Miami–Nebraska football rivalry WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
20981 12010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dreieck Walsrode User:Imzadi1979 21:59, 7 January 2016 (UTC) delete """fails to meet the burden of . One two sources are cited, one is a and the other is a compilation of statistics, neither of which demonstrate """"significant coverage in reliable sources independent of the subject"""" as we require for stand-alone articles""" Deletion of Dreieck Walsrode WP:GNG||WP:SPS Wikipedia:Notability 77
20982 978 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019–20 Bayamón FC season User:Joseph2302 07:18, 13 August 2021 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of 2019–20 Bayamón FC season WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20983 4105 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valentine Ligny [[User talk:45.144.113.202|talk]]) 22:20, 28 August 2021 (UTC) keep Meets . Special:Contributions/45.144.113.202|45.144.113.202 Deletion of Valentine Ligny WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
20984 13373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terri Summers User:Agricola44 17:17, 9 April 2010 (UTC) delete I don't think a myspace page counts as . Concur with above observations on failing notability guidelines. Respectfully Deletion of Terri Summers WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20985 9378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andre Comeau [[User_talk:Bradv|BradV]] 01:29, 4 April 2008 (UTC) delete Article was largely written by a |single-purpose account (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Hedlo here). Completely unsourced biographies of living people should be deleted. Whether or not the subject is notable is secondary Deletion of Andre Comeau WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
20986 7227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GOTO++ User:MCB 06:38, 22 September 2006 (UTC) delete very hard to find any |reliable sources for this. Appears not to be a hoax, but more of a very minor in-joke Deletion of GOTO++ WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
20987 4903 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apps4Brands User:Ihcoyc 14:57, 21 April 2010 (UTC) delete WP:CSD#G11|unambiguous advertising and |patent nonsense: ''Engaging their customers, prospects, employees and other influencers on social networks, attaining attention of influencers through Earned Media, automating the process to lower the cost of investment in new employees and custom solutions and maintaining consistent branding and voice on multiple earned media platforms Deletion of Apps4Brands WP:NONSENSE Wikipedia:Patent nonsense 105
20988 10872 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kigo (Kim Possible) User:Yuser31415 03:08, 3 January 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. Please note that is not a reason to '''keep''' (aka '''retain'''), and I would recommend those who have !voted such to read Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions. Thanks Deletion of Kigo (Kim Possible) WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
20989 15116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ealing Broadway Platform 9 User:Exit2DOS2000 23:50, 1 April 2008 (UTC) keep http://maps.google.com/maps?q=%22Ealing+Broadway+Platform+9%22+-Wikipedia&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=wl just as |Verifiable as a host of other geographic stubs. The Article does ''assert'' Notability. Deletes are based upon the fact that it has no WP:RS, just like a whole host of Alacska|hungarian Füzérradvány|town Teresztenye|stubs. This will change once the relevant Wikipedia:WikiProject Trains|WikiProject gets to it, is there a rush? WP will always be a work in progress. (Please be careful that your !Vote is not based upon , which seems to be the tone that this AfD is taking Deletion of Ealing Broadway Platform 9 WP:V||WP:IDONTLIKEHIM Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20990 17749 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/YTS solutions User:Alpha 05:28, 29 September 2015 (UTC) delete Fails . ♔ Deletion of YTS solutions WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
20991 2959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of web application frameworks User:Tellyaddict 15:44, 6 February 2007 (UTC) delete not relevant per Deletion of Comparison of web application frameworks WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20992 4665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Decibel Devils User:Vegaswikian 06:45, 6 January 2006 (UTC) delete unless it is clear that they meet . Right now it does not appear that they do Deletion of Decibel Devils WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20993 1132 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashley Tang User:TedE 18:25, 28 June 2006 (UTC) delete as non-notable (). Not even close. There are dozens (if not hundreds) of such stories in the US every year (hard beginnings, pick-themselves-up-by-the-bootstraps character, reward). None of them are notable Deletion of Ashley Tang WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
20994 16182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Game (game) (fifth nomination) User:Visviva 05:26, 1 August 2006 (UTC) keep per above and previous arguments. Meets the letter of |Wikipedia policy, and these recurrent debates are a drain on the community Deletion of The Game (game) (fifth nomination) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
20995 4103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Degausser (song) User:Esradekan 00:31, 31 August 2008 (UTC) delete as a non-plausible search term. Fails notability per #Songs. No chart, no awards, no cover versions Deletion of Degausser (song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
20996 150 [[Verschwörungstheorien zum 11. September 2001]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Provi-neu 00:30, 10. Jul. 2007 (CEST) delete 11. September 2001#Verschwörungstheorien sollte zur kurzen Beschreibung der Thematik vollkommen ausreichen. Die -Anteile passen da vermutlich gut rein Löschung von Verschwörungstheorien zum 11. September 2001 Wikipedia:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
20997 8347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Air Force One in popular culture (2nd nomination) User:Crazysuit 01:16, 1 August 2007 (UTC) delete the only notable references are the two films mentioned, the rest of the appearances are trivia. #DIR loosely associated trivial appearances/mentions of an airlplane Deletion of Air Force One in popular culture (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
20998 2706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yenitza Muñoz User:Jmertel23 16:46, 2 December 2019 (UTC) delete I haven't found any independent, in-depth, reliable sources either. I think it's for an article Deletion of Yenitza Muñoz WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
20999 5918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magellan Guides User:Davidpdx 12:19, 1 January 2007 (UTC) delete as also fails Deletion of Magellan Guides WP:SPAM||WP:V Wikipedia:Spam 112
21000 2860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2004 United States presidential election controversy and irregularities User:Protonk 17:49, 21 April 2008 (UTC) comment """Part of the problem here is that the subject is really, REALLY personal for people. This is akin to editing the Abortion article. People believe very strongly that the 2004 election was hijacked by Bush et. al. Consequently they try very hard to find sourced that agree with that feeling. That is a problem, because it (obviously) violates POV, but it also leads to a shortage of sources in these articles. Most academics aren't going to stick their necks out and suggest that Diebold delivered the 2004 elections to the republicans because that's not the kind of people they are. They didn't get to be academics by making bold claims when the evidence didn't support it. they got to be academics by amounting masses of evidence for tentative claims on limited subject areas. Consequently, the academic research is going to be mixed. However, that doesn't mean that there aren't other sources--reliable publications, films, and other non-academic sources--to be mined. We are kind of stuck between people who didn't think that bush stole the election (and who consequently will label people who do as ) and people for whom the theft is glaringly obvious. I don't think Phil is nominating these articles in bad faith. there isn't any evidence to suggest that and no real motive--for that matter he has behaved exceedingly well in the face of accusations. However, I don't share his view of the articles themselves and I think his words on the subject are instructive. Consider the Estate_tax_in_the_United_States|Estate Tax. Editors who add the """"arguments against"""" section without the same demand for rigor as the rest of the article are ''shocked'' that the section is tagged for being unverified. surely it is common knowledge that the estate tax is morally wrong, impacts farmers, etc. One needs to only provide a hint out sources for these claims, just like the population of a town is sourced. for them, the proposition is uncontroversial. for people who think the debate over the estate tax is a republican canard, just the opposite is true. None of this means that either side is wrong. It means that we are going to have a rough time coming to consensus, but it isn't hopeless""" Deletion of 2004 United States presidential election controversy and irregularities WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
21001 21360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Outer Lands [[User talk:Ravenswing|''' '' Ravenswing '' ''']] 08:55, 3 July 2018 (UTC) delete As neologism at best, per . Like the nom, I agree that there's no sign that this is a widespread term used ''in reliable sources'', and I want more than a single author's neologism for it. Two or three blogsites don't cut it; show me strong cites from the likes of the ''Boston Globe, Hartford Courant, New York Times'' and the like. The same applies to the notion that this is a notable geographical topic, as Pharos believes: if that's the case, then where are the sources discussing it, and do they do so using this name Deletion of Outer Lands WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21002 16625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warren E. Dixon User:Lesser 03:50, 29 August 2014 (UTC) keep mdash;h-index is http://scholar.google.com/citations?user=ORU4Ja4AAAAJ&hl=en&oi=sra north of 35, which is more than sufficient to satisfy criteria #1 Deletion of Warren E. Dixon WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21003 20078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wanker (2nd nomination) User:Silensor 02:06, 5 January 2007 (UTC) keep one of the few instances where I believe that actually applies Deletion of Wanker (2nd nomination) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
21004 2138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe castillo User:Orangemike 17:04, 11 February 2008 (UTC) delete for all the reasons cited, but especially the blatant violations of |verifiability Deletion of Joe castillo :WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21005 2643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amirhossein Ipakchi User:GiantSnowman 17:55, 14 March 2014 (UTC) delete fail and Deletion of Amirhossein Ipakchi WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21006 167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of places in South Park User:BeanoJosh 20:25, 9 November 2007 (UTC) delete per above. Fails Deletion of List of places in South Park WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21007 19754 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Talk to Me (NYC) (2nd nomination) [[User_talk:Travellingcari|TravellingCari]][[Special:Contributions/Travellingcari|the Busy Bee]] 18:02, 10 June 2008 (UTC) keep """I see a http://news.google.com/archivesearch?ie=UTF-8&oe=utf-8&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a&um=1&tab=wn&q=%22Talk+to+me%22+%22Liz+Barry%22 good amount of RS coverage and last time I checked, the New York POst and Times were not """"student newspapers, blogs"""". was not a valid delete reason last time I noticed""" Deletion of Talk to Me (NYC) (2nd nomination) WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21008 11855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Reuven Shmerling user:Shrike 05:19, 19 October 2017 (UTC) keep """Per as article was already created. doesn't apply """"its not routine news reporting on things like announcements, sports, or celebrities"""" .Also WashPO is not Jewish source https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/middle_east/israel-arrests-2-palestinians-after-israeli-man-found-dead/2017/10/08/d3afea00-ac38-11e7-9b93-b97043e57a22_story.html?utm_term=.4d6f16fc6945 so its meets too""" Deletion of Murder of Reuven Shmerling WP:RAPID||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:DIVERSE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21009 296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Commander Kyle User:danntm 14:22, 26 January 2007 (UTC) delete or '''Merge''' per Deletion of Commander Kyle WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21010 21447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bari baba sarkar User:Deor 20:23, 4 June 2009 (UTC) delete Given the names Mehda and Raun in the article, this would appear to be a temple in Bhind District; but I can find no sources for the existence of a Hanuman temple with this or a similar name at the specified location (though there seem to be several elsewhere in the area). As it stands, this article fails . No prejudice to recreation if reliable sources can be found Deletion of Bari baba sarkar WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21011 8538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patchy the Pirate User:MastCell 19:55, 30 January 2007 (UTC) merge into list of minor characters per . Failing that, delete Deletion of Patchy the Pirate WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21012 2922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reactions to the 2016 Orlando nightclub shooting User:Smartyllama 17:38, 15 June 2016 (UTC) keep Merge isn't feasible due to the large amount of content, and there is significant precedent for having articles of this nature. It's an event of significant magnitude. And stop with the editing SI mentioned above. If the article needs improving, improve it. Don't willfully stop improvement so it can fulfill your goal of deletion. In any event, |AFD is not cleanup so if the article has potential, which it does, it should stay Deletion of Reactions to the 2016 Orlando nightclub shooting WP:POINT||WP:AFDISNOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
21013 19495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cynthia Lett User:David 00:38, 26 August 2016 (UTC) delete I did a ref check: very few RSes, most sources primary or user-generated, many unreliable sources, almost all biographical details completely unsourced - by , this should be culled to a stub ASAP. I wonder if we could get her to write some civility or etiquette guidance on promotional editing of Wikipedia Deletion of Cynthia Lett WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21014 18879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Alexander Hernandez User:SlideAndSlip 22:33, 13 February 2007 (UTC) delete no sources so it is not Deletion of John Alexander Hernandez WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21015 10486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Business Recorder Group User:TopGun 16:56, 20 April 2015 (UTC) merge with Business Recorder as obviously that's their notable flagship service and notability is not inherited to the org. Info such as ownership of AAJ TV by the same corp and a minimal list of other ventures (if verifiable per ) needs to be preserved into the Business Recorder article Deletion of Business Recorder Group WP:ABOUTSELF Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21016 8537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trinity Catholic School User:Pan 20:09, 27 January 2007 (UTC) delete because there is no sign of non-trivial external |coverage which we could use to write a Wikipedia article. Checked http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22trinity+catholic+school%22+lewiston&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8 Google news archives and even ''local'' papers in Lexis-Nexis. This is not a surprise though, because most schools wouldn't pass Deletion of Trinity Catholic School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21017 3340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chelsea F.C. vs FC Barcelona, 2009 UEFA Champions League semi-final, second leg User:Angelo 21:00, 7 May 2009 (UTC) delete per #NEWS and . About other comments: bad performances from referees happen everyday, even in the top flight, and it's nothing new; speaking foul language to a camera is not that original, actually. Of course, feel free to mention the controversy into the UEFA Champions League 2008–09 article, but a stand-alone article makes no sense Deletion of Chelsea F.C. vs FC Barcelona, 2009 UEFA Champions League semi-final, second leg WP:NOT||WP:RECENTISM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21018 9785 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International Association of Facilitators User:Cewbot 00:02, 19 March 2021 (UTC) comment This nomination has had limited participation and falls within the standards set for |lack of quorum. There are no previous AfD discussions, undeletions, or current redirects and no previous PRODs have been located. This nomination may be '''eligible for |soft deletion''' at the end of its 7-day listing Deletion of International Association of Facilitators WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
21019 15510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Muncy User:Dhartung 19:27, 3 July 2007 (UTC) delete """teacher of the year"""" (unless it's some national award) is not a claim to notability any more than """"employee of the month"""" is. Possibly meets for his writing but we would want to see |independent sources for the claims such as """"widely distributed among peers""" Deletion of Jim Muncy WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21020 15743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reba Monica John User:JackTracker 20:59, 13 April 2016 (UTC) delete """The article fails , also Reba Monica John played a role of having 3-5 min.s within her debut movie. As on the reviews of her debut movie, their is not even any mentions about her name. http://movies.ndtv.com/movie-reviews/jacobinte-swargarajyam-movie-review-1253, http://indianexpress.com/article/entertainment/movie-review/jacobinte-swargarajyam-movie-review-ratings-three-and-half-stars/, http://www.hindustantimes.com/movie-reviews/jacobinte-swargarajyam-review-a-tragic-tale-told-without-tears/story-euRpI794pGHA00d1N27DZJ.html also the Manorama Online clearly mentions on their review that """"Reba Monica John as Chippy has very little to contribute to the whole"""" See: http://english.manoramaonline.com/entertainment/movie-reviews/nivin-pauly-jacobinte-swargarajyam-vineeth-sreenivasan.html""" Deletion of Reba Monica John WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21021 20788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Margaux Avedisian User:Superastig 16:03, 26 October 2020 (UTC) delete """Barely found anything about her. Search results return mostly articles where she's mentioned as the """"Queen of Bitcoin"""". Perhaps a """ Deletion of Margaux Avedisian WP:RUNOFTHEMILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
21022 3641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hogg Robinson Group User:Dhartung 17:27, 27 July 2007 (UTC) keep after |excellent rewrite work. Hogg Robinson is indeed a recognizable name Deletion of Hogg Robinson Group WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
21023 9828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julien Mayfair User:Scapler 12:24, 27 February 2009 (UTC) comment """It does not matter how notable she is within the work of fiction, rather it matters what '''real-world content''' such as creation, reception, influence, etc. from '''reliable third-party sources''' the article contains. : """"When an article is created, the subject's real-world notability should be established according to the general notability guideline by including independent reliable secondary sources"""". I do not see any of these. Cheers""" Deletion of Julien Mayfair WP:WAF Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
21024 12224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inflationomics User:JohnCD 19:01, 26 November 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. and Deletion of Inflationomics WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21025 8844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quahog 5 User:Reyk 19:49, 21 September 2010 (UTC) delete Cow is correct in saying that an element of a fictional series does not |inherit notability from the series itself. It is required to |demonstrate its own through |reliable, independent sources. Furthermore, the article is not about the TV station at all, it's just about the various characters that work there. We already have an List_of_characters_in_Family_Guy|article on that, which covers these characters in appropriate depth, but there's nothing to really be said about the TV station itself Deletion of Quahog 5 WP:INHERIT||WP:N||WP:BURDEN Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21026 10946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mustafa Tunahan Bodur User:Spiderone 18:02, 9 June 2021 (UTC) delete fails NACTOR due to no notable roles and fails due to a complete lack of reliable sources covering him Deletion of Mustafa Tunahan Bodur WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21027 816 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jay Baron Nicorvo User:E 18:28, 10 April 2018 (UTC) keep 2 newspaper profiles; first novel that has attracted attention. I expanded, sourced the article a little. I think he scrapes past the bar at . I do see that he probably created his own page, enormous numbers of actors, writers, wanna-be self-help gurus, etc. do that. And, if they pass the bar, we keep the articles Deletion of Jay Baron Nicorvo WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21028 16569 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alien and Predator timeline (2nd nomination) User:Sgeureka 13:00, 8 June 2008 (UTC) delete for violating #PLOT and possibly , '''or merge''' with Alien vs. Predator as a complement for interested readers. &ndash Deletion of Alien and Predator timeline (2nd nomination) WP:NOT||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21029 982 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Salangaiattam User:Belovedfreak 15:34, 3 September 2011 (UTC) delete at least under this name, it appears to be |unverifiable and doesn't meet the |notability guideline. Using google I could find one trivial mention of a folk dance under this name, from a source of questionable reliability. There also appears to be a group called Salangai Attam, but that would be a different article Deletion of Salangaiattam WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21030 9887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wings.io User:ZettaComposer 16:37, 12 September 2017 (UTC) delete both for failing Deletion of Wings.io WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21031 9664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Winnie the Pooh (1953 film) User:Erik 19:52, 14 November 2007 (UTC) delete per -- clearly a hoax Deletion of Winnie the Pooh (1953 film) WP:SNOWBALL Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
21032 7341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel and Flavia Gernatt Family Foundation User:Solarra 23:59, 10 July 2014 (UTC) keep per major published journals and newspapers are reliable sources. The point of and is so that enough secondary sources exist to cover a subject from a neutral point of view, which in this article, is clearly the case Deletion of Daniel and Flavia Gernatt Family Foundation WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21033 1097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alex Kehr (2nd nomination) User:Voceditenore 11:21, 18 March 2016 (UTC) delete """this advertorial. The subject comprehensively fails both the |general notability criteria for biographies and the alternative criteria at uthor. The book is self-published. It has not been reviewed in any independent publications as far as I can see. Amazon sales rankings are notoriously unreliable, as are the """"customer reviews"""". Required reading: http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/oct/18/amazon-sues-1000-fake-reviewers """"Amazon sues 1,000 'fake reviewers' """", ''The Guardian'' and http://www.thesundaytimes.co.uk/sto/news/uk_news/National/article1618237.ece """"How to fake a bestseller"""", ''The Times''. It would need to be on something like the New York Times Bestseller List and/or to have been the subject of multiple reviews in real publications to even have a remote chance of being considered notable. I can find no coverage of the subject himself, apart from brief mentions (10 years ago, when he was presumably 14) in a couple of articles on the use of websites to find people missing in Hurricane Katrina, of which his was one of many. His company is 4 months old and has zero coverage. Incidentally, I have removed the article's external link to the book's page on Amazon""" Deletion of Alex Kehr (2nd nomination) WP:BIO||WP:A Wikipedia:Notability 77
21034 20149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phobomania User:Agha 01:56, 19 April 2007 (UTC) delete """This article is in violation of . Furthermore this article may have been made in bad faith. User Limboot may have made this page as a response to Islamophobia. Obviously Wikipedia does not allow counter articles which have the sole purpose of responding to other articles. Limboot said """"Wiki has an abusive article about 'islamophobia""""' even brought as """"discrimination"""". So wiki has to tolorate other opinions, imho"""" in the talk. Also see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Islamophobia#Linked_to_fobomania""" Deletion of Phobomania WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21035 18497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Shaima Alawadi User:Sandstein 08:03, 7 April 2012 (UTC) delete per , all cited sources are from within two days of each other (), and it's unclear what the |wide geographical scope of this could be. Can be recreated if this is still in the news a few months from now Deletion of Murder of Shaima Alawadi WP:EVENT||WP:PERSISTENCE||WP:GEOSCOPE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21036 4168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rayshaun Deese User:Rms125a 07:09, 14 March 2016 (UTC) delete as non-notable |actor Deletion of Rayshaun Deese WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21037 21282 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chinese Consulate-General, Houston User:LibStar 06:27, 31 October 2011 (UTC) delete fails . consulates are not inherently notable Deletion of Chinese Consulate-General, Houston WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21038 17489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beth Chalmers User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:02, 7 June 2010 (UTC) delete While ''Angry Kid'' is not listed on IMDB, the Atom Films series does exist,http://www.angrykid.com/http://www.atom.com/channel/channel_angry_kid/ and Chalmers CAN be sourced as being the voice of 'Litle Sister' http://www.bcdb.com/cartoon_characters/79189-Angry_Kid_Who_Do_You_Think_You_Are.html just as she was for the UNited Kingdom|UK TV special for that series... titled ''Who Do You Think You Are''... which IS on IMDB.http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0477134/ However, as she is barely creeping up on , lack of coverage fails and . This perosn already has an article on the Harry Potter Wikia,http://harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Beth_Chalmers where they care less for actual coverage Deletion of Beth Chalmers WP:ENT||WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21039 20973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nordan Shat User:Bearcat 00:54, 17 April 2016 (UTC) delete """No matter how popular a YouTuber might be, the notability standards for YouTubers require |reliable source coverage ''about'' them — no YouTuber ''ever'' gets an automatic """"because they have X number of subscribers"""" freebie, if RS coverage in ''media'' is ''not'' present to support an article. But there's exactly ''zero'' RS coverage shown here""" Deletion of Nordan Shat WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21040 4424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Surch User:Wafulz 07:12, 26 August 2006 (UTC) delete per and , and from the link the nom gave, there's a fair amount of |crystal balling too. Additionally, there is only one http://www.google.ca/search?hl=en&q=link%3AfuZzxybEowwJ%3Awww.surch.com%2F&btnG=Google+Search&meta= external link to the site Deletion of Surch WP:WEB||WP:V||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21041 1293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fixing America User:MichaelQSchmidt 06:27, 5 September 2015 (UTC) keep per it already https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fixing_America#References having sources speaking about the production and thus showing the project as specifically meeting . I do not have to watch it or care one little bit about what it purports to document, as |film notability is found through ''just enough'' coverage Deletion of Fixing America WP:NF||WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21042 13788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/False clock User:Colonel 11:58, 19 October 2010 (UTC) keep This is a stub not a dictionary definition as there is no lexical content and the the title is a phrase not a word. If the content seems too small then it should be merged into a larger article such as clock signal. This is our |editing and |deletion policy Deletion of False clock WP:PRESERVE||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
21043 13656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frank Smith (fireman) (2nd nomination) User:Whpq 17:21, 29 January 2009 (UTC) comment Would it be appropriate to leave a note at ikiproject Trains to ask for their opinions? The intent is not to , but rather bring in editors who may be more familiar with the subject matter Deletion of Frank Smith (fireman) (2nd nomination) WP:W||WP:CANVASS Help:Watchlist 110
21044 383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Egypt national ice hockey team User:Flibirigit 18:47, 9 February 2018 (UTC) delete fails without reliable sources Deletion of Egypt national ice hockey team WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21045 5870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teamlorio.net User:Vic 09:19, 28 September 2006 (UTC) delete Having a tiny fan club does not meet Deletion of Teamlorio.net WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
21046 14599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aegean Macedonians User:JeremyMcCracken 22:03, 12 May 2008 (UTC) keep The term appears to be used based on a google test. This appears to be an |IDONTLIKEIT nomination (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Aegean_Macedonians&diff=211687098&oldid=211669793), and I think that's what most of the keep and delete votes seem to be quickly stacking up to. The article is also brand new and hasn't had any time to evolve Deletion of Aegean Macedonians WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21047 18671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of programs broadcast by Indosiar User:JamesBurns 03:28, 29 January 2009 (UTC) delete WP:NOTDIRECTORY, , listcruft Deletion of List of programs broadcast by Indosiar WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21048 3388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011–12 Los Angeles arson attacks (3rd nomination) User:Mkdw 22:19, 9 January 2013 (UTC) keep """WP:NOTNEWS says in the first sentence: """" ''editors are encouraged to include current and up-to-date information within its coverage, and to develop stand-alone articles on significant current events'' """". Essentially it's very difficult to prove this event isn't significant with the length of coverage its received. Your argument must rely mostly on your |personal opinion as the basis of it not being a significant current event""" Deletion of 2011–12 Los Angeles arson attacks (3rd nomination) WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21049 18526 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Black Women in Europe Blog User:E 17:34, 3 October 2017 (UTC) delete """There's a list of awards, none are bluelinked, and most appear to be given to blogs by groups of bloggers; I can't see that these give much support to notability; they may not even be independent of subject. Worse, is the utter lack of evidence of in . a gNews search comes up blank: https://www.google.com/search?q=%22black+women+in+Europe+blog%22&safe=active&source=lnms&tbm=nws&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiOqMOq_dTWAhUE3IMKHUjnBToQ_AUICigB&biw=1386&bih=862. Sources on page include two books, one ''Don't Bring Home a White Boy: And Other Notions that Keep Black '' is written by one of the bloggers who write this blog https://books.google.com/books?id=4xBRucoPhD0C&pg=PA219&dq=black+women+in+Europe+blog&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjp3uzE_dTWAhXlz4MKHT9LC5MQ6AEINDAC#v=onepage&q=black%20women%20in%20Europe%20blog&f=false """"“I started the Black Women in Europe (BWIE) blog after moving to Sweden because I wanted to connect with other black women in Europe."""" , the other book is a mere inclusion on a list https://books.google.com/books?id=I4iDDAAAQBAJ&pg=PA172&dq=black+women+in+Europe+blog&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjp3uzE_dTWAhXlz4MKHT9LC5MQ6AEILzAB#v=onepage&q=black%20women%20in%20Europe%20blog&f=false """"The women envisiaged utilising various social websites and blogs such as Facebook, BEWC, Black Women in Europe Blog, Afro European ..."""". In sum, this is mere PROMO by a fan or a blogger. Mere PROMO overstuffed with worthless sources""" Deletion of Black Women in Europe Blog WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21050 6227 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radiator Springs User:Protonk 22:31, 26 July 2008 (UTC) delete Fails , OT and . Doesn't cite a single source (primary or otherwise). Delete and rediect to cars or just redirect to cars. It doesn't matter to me Deletion of Radiator Springs WP:N||WP:NOT||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21051 6960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inner Tay Estuary User:AllyD 20:16, 3 January 2013 (UTC) keep The sources already in the article indicate that subject of the article is designated as a Local nature reserve and Site of Special Scientific Interest; passes . I recommend for the nominator Deletion of Inner Tay Estuary :WP:GNG||:WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21052 343 [[DXCC]] (erl., redirect) Benutzer:84.175.125.181 NONE delete Das muss ich Mozart widersprechen: Allgemeininteresse, Sekundärquelle und Zielgruppe sind gegeben. Such mal mit Google nach DXCC - da finden sich eine Menge Treffe - es ist also nicht auf eine kleine Gruppe Interessenten beschränkt. Und auch der Eintrag unter :en:DXCC zeigt, dass noch Potential im Artikel steckt Löschung von DXCC Wikipedia:Artikel Wikipedia:Artikel 90
21053 19345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Costigan (youth speaker) User:Bearian 23:00, 12 November 2014 (UTC) delete per . Columnists, even for notable publications, are not automatically notable themselves Deletion of Michael Costigan (youth speaker) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
21054 17564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enverus User:HighKing 13:27, 23 December 2019 (UTC) delete I am unable to locate any |significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, fails GNG/ Deletion of Enverus WP:SIGCOV||WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21055 42 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Tîroj (3. aday gösterme) Kullanıcı:tuğkantuğkan 21.20, 11 Eylül 2019 (UTC) delete Kaynaklar çok zorlama. Kalabalık gözüksün diye ne kadar bağımsız ve güvenilirliği şüpheli link varsa tıkıştırılmış maddeye. a uygun bir şeyler olursa pingleyin beni. O zamana kadar silinmesi gerektiğini savunuyor olacağım Tîroj (3. aday gösterme) yazısının silinmesi Vikipedi:Güvenilir kaynaklar Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21056 4277 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Rock-afire Explosion (2nd nomination) User:FoCuSandLeArN 17:28, 31 August 2014 (UTC) delete Clearly non-notable and written by someone with a |COI. Sources provided are severely deficient in that they are only 4, and absolutely non-reliable. The language is unencyclopaedic. Perhaps a small mention in the Showbiz Pizza Place article is merited, but not more than that in my opinion Deletion of The Rock-afire Explosion (2nd nomination) WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
21057 4691 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ollie Stanbridge User:Malcolmxl5 11:48, 27 April 2008 (UTC) delete Not notable per thlete Deletion of Ollie Stanbridge WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
21058 12391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of female Egyptologists User:Joe 16:27, 25 December 2016 (UTC) keep u|David Eppstein}} has made a strong case that this topic is notable per . Contrary to {{u|Fram}}'s assertion, some people do care about whether archaeologists (including Egyptologists) ''today'' are women, e.g. https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=csshE845UsQC&dq=women+in+archaeology&lr=&source=gbs_navlinks_shttp://trowelblazers.com/https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=DKAj27myGQUC&dq=women+in+archaeology&lr=&source=gbs_navlinks_shttps://books.google.co.uk/books?id=brj2o4EF_EMC&dq=women+in+archaeology&lr=&source=gbs_navlinks_shttps://www.australianarchaeologicalassociation.com.au/journal/review-of-women-in-archaeology-a-feminist-critique-edited-by-hilary-du-cros-and-laurajane-smith/https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/antiquity/article/div-classtitlewomenandaposs-archaeology-political-feminism-gender-theory-and-historical-revisiondiv/2314183E0C9404DEA3FD4205180C774Fhttp://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED402263http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00438240050131162?journalCode=rwar20http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00293652.1992.9965541http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/345322?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents. The Wikidata argument is irrelevant as far as I'm concerned; the list is referenced, albeit in a roundabout way, through the Wikidata entries (perhaps this could be made more explicit). If the nominator is seeking to ban bot-maintained lists from Wikidata, that should be a much wider community discussion. Personally I think it's an extremely promising solution to the problem of lists get created and then never properly maintained. – Deletion of List of female Egyptologists WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
21059 19248 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yuuki Tanaka User:Wolbo 13:41, 12 March 2016 (UTC) delete or '''Userfy''' - does not meet WP Tennis or sport guidelines for notability. See insufficient evidence that she meets general notability requirements per Deletion of Yuuki Tanaka WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21060 19980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zanta User:BigrTex 19:34, 6 December 2006 (UTC) keep It's a better referenced article than a lot of cruft articles I've seen. I think he qualifies under and meets and Deletion of Zanta WP:LOCAL||WP:NPOV||WP:V Wikipedia:Places of local interest 14
21061 19967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Your Demise User:Colapeninsula 10:33, 11 April 2013 (UTC) keep """There is a good amount of online coverage, though much of it is not very in depth. But i think together it meets . Coverage in well-established UK metal magazineshttp://www.kerrang.com/blog/2009/07/your_demise_part_ways_with_voc.htmlhttp://www.kerrang.com/blog/2013/01/your_demise_line_up_cold_chill.htmlhttp://www.kerrang.com/blog/2012/11/your_demise_launch_push_me_und.htmlhttp://www.kerrang.com/blog/2012/03/your_demise_post_new_video.htmlhttp://www.kerrang.com/blog/2012/02/check_out_the_new_your_demise.htmlhttp://www.metalhammer.co.uk/news/your-demise-to-release-cold-chillin-ep/http://www.metalhammer.co.uk/news/your-demise-february-uk-tour-revealed/http://www.metalhammer.co.uk/news/your-demise-frontman-is-not-on-the-new-a-day-to-remember-album/http://www.metalhammer.co.uk/news/your-demise-announce-intimate-100-club-show/http://www.metalhammer.co.uk/news/your-demise-video-shoot-to-take-place-in-london/ AllMusic profilehttp://www.allmusic.com/artist/your-demise-mn0001971959. Punknews.comhttp://www.punknews.org/article/49529/your-demise-post-brownface-photo-apologise-delete-apologyhttp://www.punknews.org/article/47277/interviews-your-demise Articles on other websiteshttp://www.rockindustry.co.uk/2013/02/21/your-demise-gig-stopped-and-police-called-video/6698http://brightonsource.co.uk/reviews/your-demise-review/. There's a shortage of reviews but I did find: AllMusichttp://www.allmusic.com/album/ignorance-never-dies-mw0001339087, Bring The Noisehttp://www.bringthenoiseuk.com/201301/music/reviews/ep-review-your-demise-cold-chillin%E2%80%99http://www.bringthenoiseuk.com/201203/music/reviews/review-your-demise-the-golden-age, Sputnik have a """"contributor"""" reviewhttp://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/54951/Your-Demise-Cold-Chillin""" Deletion of Your Demise WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21062 16916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lukas Miklos User:Joe 00:23, 30 October 2009 (UTC) merge to Left Behind (series). Fails Deletion of Lukas Miklos WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21063 7806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ages of Myst V: End of Ages [[User talk:Bullzeye| (Ring for Service)]] 05:28, 2 December 2007 (UTC) delete per nom and Rjf0060. An unnecessary, redundant, non-notable, |gameguide. Need I say more? Bullzeye Deletion of Ages of Myst V: End of Ages WP:WWIN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21064 12676 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Van Voorhis User:Bearcat 17:43, 12 April 2016 (UTC) delete Being a ''delegate'' to a political party's convention is not a claim of notability that gets a person into Wikipedia in and of itself, and this article claims and |reliably sources ''nothing'' else about him that would get him included for any other reason Deletion of Peter Van Voorhis WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21065 8064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom St Denis User:Mus 13:28, 14 December 2006 (UTC) delete """One of the criterion of is """"Published authors, editors and photographers who received multiple independent reviews of or awards for their work"""". The article establishes that he is published, but at least two of the books are public domain projects and I cannot find any evidence that any of his works meet the requirement of being subject to multiple independent reviews""" Deletion of Tom St Denis WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21066 14729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Finda User:GarrieIrons 01:43, 13 December 2006 (UTC) keep Meets in its current form, I have heard of it in Australia as a NZ competitor to similar Australian based sites Deletion of Finda WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
21067 11527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Spectrobes User:YechielMan 07:48, 8 April 2007 (UTC) delete per #INFO. Who needs this silly list? It's useful only for people who play the game, not for people who might want to know ''about'' the game from an encyclopedic point of view Deletion of List of Spectrobes WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21068 1177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Initiation (Kung Fu: The Legend Continues) User:Jfire 20:19, 16 February 2009 (UTC) merge """to series article unless and until significant reliable-source coverage of this individual episode is located and cited. Several editors have looked for such sources and failed. The burden of proof is on those asserting that this episode received significant critical commentary to |prove it, not on those who have tried and failed to find sources to prove that none exist. |""""Merely asserting that such sources exist is seldom persuasive, especially as time passes and actual proof does not surface""" Deletion of Initiation (Kung Fu: The Legend Continues) WP:PROVEIT||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21069 15462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Women's Rights in Religion User:IZAK 08:05, 9 May 2007 (UTC) delete this violation of and . (For Judaism there already is a long article Role of women in Judaism and more in :Category:Judaism and women Deletion of Women's Rights in Religion WP:OR||WP:CITE Wikipedia:No original research 65
21070 8054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George E. Stephens User:Mztourist 03:09, 16 June 2020 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of George E. Stephens WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21071 4672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/STQ-3 (band) User:mr 04:48, 12 June 2008 (UTC) delete per , when you can't find them on Amazon.com or some other online music store I think it's a pretty safe bet |N hasn't been achieved yet Deletion of STQ-3 (band) WP:MUSIC||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21072 5399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Reformation (band) (2nd nomination) User:Wikitam331 19:21, 22 February 2015 (UTC) keep Artist pages have at least five non-trivial, published works that provide substantial coverage that appears in sources that are reliable, not-self-published, and are independent from the musician or ensemble itself. Article was unsalted because deleting admin agreed that the additional four new sources are sufficient to establish notability per Deletion of The Reformation (band) (2nd nomination) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
21073 14682 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Older (2nd nomination) [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 01:38, 12 July 2013 (UTC) NONE delete there is a |long standing consensus that individuals who might pass but comprehensively fail will often be considered to not meet inclusion criteria and there are a |string of recent examples of AFDs that have |overwhelmingly concluded as much. Beyond that, I don't think I've ever seen a |dead horse so comprehensively flogged Deletion of Jordan Older (2nd nomination) WP:CONSENSUS||WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG||WP:OUTCOMES||WP:SNOW||WP:STICK Wikipedia:Consensus 78
21074 8040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mubarkah Al-Abdulla User:Papaursa 21:32, 25 November 2018 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet any of the notability criteria for curling. Lacks the significant coverage required by . The only reference is for winning a medal at a 3 team competition in Turkey Deletion of Mubarkah Al-Abdulla WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21075 10082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Patrick Burke User:Bakazaka 23:49, 6 November 2018 (UTC) delete after having similar search results to E.M.Gregory. There is no question that the subject wrote and edited things. But notability on Wikipedia is not based on output. Notability here is based on significant coverage in multiple reliable independent sources (see ), which this subject does not have, or on passing a more specific notability guideline like , which this subject most assuredly does not Deletion of Thomas Patrick Burke WP:GNG||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21076 16327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Child of Prince William, Duke of Cambridge User:Safiel 23:22, 6 March 2013 (UTC) delete per . At least wait for the fetus to be born/named Deletion of Child of Prince William, Duke of Cambridge WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21077 20083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2018 Grand Rapids FC season (2nd nomination) User:Taxman1913 10:48, 11 September 2018 (UTC) comment I do not agree that every well sourced, well written article about an association football team merits inclusion on Wikipedia. For example, my cousin plays on a U-9 girls team. If her enthusiastic mother were to write a well sourced article that follows the MoS guidelines of WikiProject Football and has an absolutely beautiful flow to it, I would still expect to conclude that it meets neither nor . Based on that, such an article does not belong here. Despite the fact that I contributed to this article—in an effort to get the subject evaluated more fairly—I don't think it is well sourced or well written. There are gaps in the sourcing of things written by the primary editor. There are sources that do not support what the article says. There are synthesis/original research issues, and there are neutrality issues. As I said above, it appears there is not enough independent coverage from reliable sources to conclude that there has been |significant coverage of the subject Deletion of 2018 Grand Rapids FC season (2nd nomination) WP:NSEASONS||WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
21078 5384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fort not Portland NONE NONE keep I am the original author of this article. I am new to wikipedia, but trying to catch up. As I understand it, my page has been marked for deletion under Deletion of Fort not Portland WP:VAIN Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
21079 18973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MelodyVision User:Joe 01:00, 11 October 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |online music contest Deletion of MelodyVision WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
21080 15087 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emanuela Rei User:Dflaw4 12:31, 4 April 2020 (UTC) keep WP:ENT is definitely made out, in my opinion. Aside from her role in ''Maggie & Bianca: Fashion Friends'', the subject has had significant recurring roles in a number of other Italian shows. (Claiming that was not made out would have been a better reason for nomination, I think—but sources have been identified above Deletion of Emanuela Rei WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21081 866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Nicholas Gomes User:PhilKnight 09:00, 1 October 2009 (UTC) delete based on the above search links, and references included in the article, there seems to be only trivial coverage, consequently doesn't appear to comply with the |general notability guideline. Also, concur with Ukexpat that articles written by the subject don't establish notability Deletion of William Nicholas Gomes WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21082 12987 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/LetsGoBlues.com User:Barno 22:20, 25 April 2006 (UTC) delete just another fan forum even if it's a busy one, lacking evidence of meeting . http://www.alexa.com/data/details/main?q=&url=letsgoblues.com Alexa search shows a ranking of 206,026. a Web directory Deletion of LetsGoBlues.com WP:WEB||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21083 20157 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Careem User:Northamerica1000 06:32, 28 January 2017 (UTC) comment More sources are available in addition to the samples listed above. See below for more. Yet more are available in addition to those listed below. Clearly meets . The sources provided herein are news articles written by staff writers that have been published in independent, reliable sources. Every source is not automatically PR or advertising as some sort of peculiar default Deletion of Careem WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
21084 7070 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bryan Ciesiulka User:GiantSnowman 12:43, 27 February 2015 (UTC) delete fail and Deletion of Bryan Ciesiulka WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21085 20430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Two-man baseball User:Joe 21:16, 1 November 2009 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Two-man baseball WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
21086 10121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Wilson (actor) User:Bakazaka 17:35, 20 February 2019 (UTC) delete While there is a marginal case for a pass of #1 (The Bronx Zoo + It's a Bird... It's a Plane... It's Superman TV adaptation + Eddie and the Cruisers + Dallas: The Early Years), this article is a BLP mess, with promotional language inherited from earlier versions, and unsourced accusations tacked on later. Except that this isn't a BLP, is it? Didn't the subject die several years ago? So, maybe not a BLP, but this is a mess of bad/promotional information, and in my opinion our readers are better served with a redlink so someone can recreate the article later with reliable sources Deletion of David Wilson (actor) WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21087 14710 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ZineWiki User:Metropolitan90 04:37, 14 November 2006 (UTC) delete per . Merely being a wiki is not a sign of notability, and I have opposed the inclusion of articles here about other wikis (see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lostpedia (second nomination)). ZineWiki has an external link from Zine; I don't think it needs to have a full article of its own on Wikipedia Deletion of ZineWiki WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
21088 3043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiffany Anastasia Lowe User:Daniel 22:03, 16 August 2006 (UTC) keep Article neads substantial cleanup to comply with , but doesn't deserve to be completely killed Deletion of Tiffany Anastasia Lowe WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
21089 21905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Conway (academic) User:David 23:59, 22 April 2016 (UTC) keep Four of his books are by major academic publishers (Penguin, Palgrave Macmillan, Ashgate) and I found five reliably-published academic reviews of them. That may be more relevant than citation counts for this sort of academic subject, and likely is also enough to pass . It also saves the article from being unsourced, although sources for the biographical detail of the article and not just for his publication activities are still needed Deletion of David Conway (academic) WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21090 74 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zach Varga User:Number 08:52, 18 April 2019 (UTC) delete Fails (the keep !votes made on this basis need to be discounted as the league has been removed from the list at following a discussion Deletion of Zach Varga WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21091 14687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New England Cavalry User:Kudpung 17:54, 4 May 2018 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of New England Cavalry WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21092 10170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Weston G. Wetzel User:JohnCD 16:00, 25 May 2009 (UTC) delete no indication of notability (and it seems to be |autobiography). Sorry, Weston, but have a look at and to get an idea of the notability standards in your field Deletion of Weston G. Wetzel WP:AUTO||WP:CREATIVE||WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
21093 15293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2005 Finta International Cup User:Whiteguru 10:38, 16 May 2021 (UTC) delete local competition that does not meet Deletion of 2005 Finta International Cup WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21094 7061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solstice (film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:24, 25 April 2009 (UTC) keep for goodness sake. That it existed without being properly sourced is a shame... but absolutely no reason to delete if it can easily be addressed by . Reviews by experts in their field, qualified to voice an opinion: http://www.bloody-disgusting.com/film/1148/review ''Bloody Disgusting'', http://www.best-horror-movies.com/solstice.html ''Best Horror Movies'', http://www.dreadcentral.com/reviews/solstice-dvd ''Dread Central'', http://www.esplatter.com/reviews.php?id=762 ''E SPlatter'', http://www.shocktillyoudrop.com/news/reviewsnews.php?id=4116 ''Shock Till You Drop'', et al. And no, these reviewes are not from the ''New York Times'' (which does not review every film ever made), but still from respected experts in the horror genre... themselves reliable sources with editorial oversite Deletion of Solstice (film) WP:CLEANUP Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
21095 6511 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Just Mo User:Caknuck 21:03, 24 October 2006 (UTC) delete """Fails . No references, Google search for """"Just Mo"""" didn't reveal anything relevant in the top 50 hits""" Deletion of Just Mo WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21096 15807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alvi Awan (Birote) User:Michaelzeng7 19:51, 3 January 2013 (UTC) delete Agreed on the nonsense part. I can't gather what this is even talking about. Could be a joke or hoax. Make sure that you don't simply go by the number of hits on Google to judge notability. See Deletion of Alvi Awan (Birote) WP:GOOGLETEST Wikipedia:Search engine test 38
21097 18929 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/E. M. Washington (2nd nomination) User:Gene93k 19:57, 21 March 2008 (UTC) delete per nom and . At best, calling subject a forger/counterfeiter goes beyond provided. We have one RS with the accusations, but charges are not proven yet. I don't see sustained or deep RS coverage to establish notability. Shedding whatever deserved light on Washington is a job for journalists, not Wikipedia Deletion of E. M. Washington (2nd nomination) WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21098 15394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stand Alone Complex User:Jesboat 06:40, 20 November 2006 (UTC) keep The topic is crucially important to GitS:SAC, and certainly more important than some concepts in other articles. The content wouldn't flow correctly if inserted into any other article. Most of the points in the article are supported by sources. I've read , and I'm unconvinced (shall we say) that most of content in this page is original research Deletion of Stand Alone Complex WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21099 6703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Like Suicide User:NinjaRobotPirate 22:08, 16 April 2014 (UTC) merge to Superunknown. I reluctantly agree with Lugnuts. It could also be selectively merged to the album without issue. Hard to believe this was 20 years ago. Some of the classic rock articles do seem a bit crufty as well, but that's an argument. For those of us suffering from nostalgia, there's always Wikia Deletion of Like Suicide WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21100 16437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darren Bartsch User:WWGB 08:30, 4 October 2009 (UTC) delete all. Draftees who do not make the first team fail Deletion of Darren Bartsch WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21101 14254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Henry Mortensen (actor) (2nd nomination) User:Dennisthe2 20:33, 24 September 2009 (UTC) comment I'm torn. Probably the best we have are the albums, so he'd possibly be a keeper under as a session musician. Thoughts Deletion of Henry Mortensen (actor) (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21102 18917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rockville Stone Chapel User:Coolabahapple 00:32, 5 October 2019 (UTC) keep and might i say |snowy, although it would probably quickly melt outside of the chapel:)), meets , and a big congratulations to {{u|Olef641}} for their first article Deletion of Rockville Stone Chapel WP:SNOW||WP:NBUILDING Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
21103 21209 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mugairyu Iaido Association India User:Niteshift36 21:53, 12 March 2010 (UTC) delete Good faith effort was made to find notability, but it seems to fail and Deletion of Mugairyu Iaido Association India WP:ORG||WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21104 20585 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Druyen User:David 05:58, 29 December 2009 (UTC) keep The small number of cites in Google scholar for his work fails to convince me that he passes #1, and the small number of papers that even mention his supposed main research topic Vermögenskultur leads me to think that it is not a notable enough topic to make his expertise in it stand out as important. Of course, citation counts in Google scholar are a poor stand-in for academic impact, but we need evidence of impact to keep the article and we have none. So I don't think we can use #1 as a basis for keeping the article. But he may pass #5; the language in the article is unclear and I'm not sufficiently familiar with the Austrian university system to tell whether his appointment is comparable to a personal chair. And, as Phil Bridger observes, the articles about him in Die Zeit, Die Welt, Südwestrundfunk|SWR Nachrichten, Wiener Zeitung etc make a persuasive case for Deletion of Thomas Druyen WP:PROF||WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21105 14586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Citizens for Social Reform User:Cirt 05:43, 1 March 2008 (UTC) keep Mentioned in multiple secondary sources that satisfy and . I told {{user|Steve Dufour}} on the talk page that I was going to use those sources to expand the article further, but he started this AfD before I had a chance to do so Deletion of Citizens for Social Reform WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21106 8524 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Friends of cathy User:Metropolitan90 14:35, 13 September 2006 (UTC) delete per nom, except that I thought an article could only be subjected to |PROD once Deletion of Friends of cathy WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
21107 13745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anders Lundkvist User:Bonadea 08:18, 5 November 2008 (UTC) delete If this is the most skilled person in the world in whatever it is he does, he could be notable, but the sources provided in the article fail and I'm unable to find anything that is verifiable Deletion of Anders Lundkvist WP:SOURCES Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21108 8253 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chew (film) User:Alpha3031 02:29, 5 March 2019 (UTC) merge to Chew (comics)#Animated feature, where it is currently covered minimally. Any content from the article history can be merged if it complies with , and the article spun out again when it is ready Deletion of Chew (film) WP:DUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
21109 436 [[ICon-L]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Tom_md NONE delete """Wer sich über den heutigen Stand der grafischen Programmierung informieren möchte, sollte wenigstens die Möglichkeit haben, einen umfassendes Bild zu erhalten und nicht nur die wenigen """"Großen"""" sehen.'' Mag sein, aber nicht in dieser Enzyklopädie. Hie geht es um |Relevanz, nicht um Vollständigkeit. Da diese nicht vorhanden ist""" Löschung von ICon-L Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
21110 12079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gamerstrike User:Agnte 11:35, 19 December 2005 (UTC) delete Per nom. Also fails Deletion of Gamerstrike WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
21111 2241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stefan Fischer User:Papaursa 04:20, 27 February 2013 (UTC) delete I couldn't find the sources necessary to support the claims of notability and don't believe the article's sources show that he meets or Deletion of Stefan Fischer WP:MANOTE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21112 11052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MGC Pharmaceuticals User:UnitedStatesian 06:36, 19 September 2019 (UTC) keep As indicates, there are many references that meet and thus demonstrate the notability of the publicly traded company Deletion of MGC Pharmaceuticals WP:LISTED||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
21113 3915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2 Girls 1 Cup User:HisSpaceResearch 21:14, 20 February 2008 (UTC) keep passes enough to have a decent-sized article on with twelve sources, and Wikipedia is not censored Deletion of 2 Girls 1 Cup WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21114 16857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tommy Car Wash Systems User:Hazarasp 12:04, 18 July 2017 (UTC) delete While there do appear to be reliable, independent sources available with in-depth coverage per and ; these sources lack a broad audience; they are either specialist car wash industry publications or local news Deletion of Tommy Car Wash Systems WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
21115 8572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Has globalisation been a benefit to everyone world wide User:Mh29255 01:10, 4 January 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Has globalisation been a benefit to everyone world wide WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21116 5843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of police stations in Karachi User:Noroton 21:42, 8 March 2008 (UTC) delete """Fails #DIRECTORY (""""Wikipedia is not a directory of everything that exists or has existed"""") in the most fundamental way. The whole spirit of that section of policy (and of the policy itself) is violated here. What is the purpose of this list? Lists are supposed to be useful to readers in understanding an encyclopedic subject or in finding their way around the encyclopedia (or both). This list isn't so long that it couldn't be included in an article about law enforcement in Karachi, a subject that would be welcome as an article if it can be written. But even in such an article, there should be some reason why the list would help the reader understand the subject or navigate""" Deletion of List of police stations in Karachi WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21117 5564 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victoria Leigh Soto User:David 00:43, 1 January 2013 (UTC) merge per and (which applies regardless of BLP status Deletion of Victoria Leigh Soto WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21118 17615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brad Booker User:Aarktica 22:09, 1 August 2007 (UTC) delete per criteria for entertainers Deletion of Brad Booker WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21119 8499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earl Watson (film editor) User:Whpq 18:05, 7 November 2012 (UTC) delete I can find credits which verify he works a s a film editor, but I cannot find the signficant coverage needed to meet Wikipedia's |inclusion criteria, nor is there significant awards that would indicate recognition of his work Deletion of Earl Watson (film editor) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21120 10864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Billy Batson and the Legend of Shazam User:FisherQueen 00:17, 30 September 2008 (UTC) delete for now, and no prejudice against recreation when there's something |verifiable to say about it Deletion of Billy Batson and the Legend of Shazam WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21121 542 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Srdjan Rajsic User:PJM 17:40, 12 November 2005 (UTC) delete per nom. Nice resume, but NN per Deletion of Srdjan Rajsic WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21122 14168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Hoffman User:Kollision 03:18, 20 July 2009 (UTC) delete """Non-notable. The |Notability guideline for Entertainers requires """"significant roles in multiple notable films, television, stage performances, or other productions."""", which he does not have""" Deletion of Thomas Hoffman WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21123 14970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Active Lancer User:Someone 17:31, 17 November 2008 (UTC) keep I don't see any rationale for deletion. No assertion of importance might work for speedy, but for an AFD some indication that sources were looked for first would be helpful, since |notability is the issue. Though I'd agree that what is in effect a single source does not cut the mustard in relation to reception, there's an in-depth review on http://www.insidemacgames.com/reviews/view.php?ID=433 Inside Mac Games which google spat out as the first result when I searched for the game's name along with 'game' and 'review Deletion of Active Lancer WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21124 18746 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The three wise monkeys in popular culture User:Pupster21 11:51, 6 September 2007 (UTC) delete This clearly is not noteable as per but it also doesn't meet the criteria for Deletion of The three wise monkeys in popular culture WP:NOTE||WP:LIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
21125 12467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of snipe hunts User:Niteshift36 NONE delete Yes, amusing (although some of them I saw were wrong/incomplete), but still an indiscriminate list of never ending . — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of List of snipe hunts WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21126 4158 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shataramarie User:Piotrus 03:36, 10 November 2016 (UTC) comment The problem with this is that it may meet . Or may not. Checking whether the albums are on the rankings or such is time consuming, and I don't know how to do it quickly, which is why I don't usually even comment on MUSIC and SPORT related deletion requests. Ít would be much easier if the nom has explained that they had considered NMUSIC criteria and confirm that the subject is failing them. As the nom is written, it is just complaining about , and that does not mean that the subject is not notable. Unreliable sources do not merit deletion. Ping me if there are new arguments Deletion of Shataramarie WP:NMUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21127 10386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JobsBroadway.com User:Fritzpoll 13:55, 4 March 2008 (UTC) comment I was the speedy nominator: I saw this as an article on a non-notable company being written by one of its founders, and failing . I don't know why speedy deletion is inferior to AfD in this respect meaning I may have misinterpreted a CSD guideline, and so will await comments before !voting Deletion of JobsBroadway.com WP:COMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
21128 6050 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tasha Scott User:Atlantic306 21:10, 18 September 2019 (UTC) keep in view of the evidence above, she does seem to pass with prominent roles on tv and theatre as theatre is included in the criteria, thanks Deletion of Tasha Scott WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21129 17582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of One Piece episodes (US TV broadcast edition) User:Peregrine 04:43, 30 May 2008 (UTC) comment Do what you gotta do. I created (split off) this article because two lists, one with over 300 eps and the other around 100 weren't fitting nicely on one page. If there's a MOS that says get rid of it, that's fine with me. Do whatever the current consensus supports but keep in mind the ridiculous number of episodes and how best to format the information. The current rules may not work well with lists this long. May need some sort of here, although what I don't know. Collectionian: what do the relevant MOS's specify Deletion of List of One Piece episodes (US TV broadcast edition) WP:IAR Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
21130 11016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gateway LT3103U User:Tijfo098 21:22, 7 September 2012 (UTC) keep """Passes per http://www.cnet.com/laptops/gateway-lt3103u/4505-3121_7-33721171.html http://www.laptopmag.com/review/laptops/gateway-lt3103u.aspx http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2352492,00.asp http://www.pcworld.in/product/review/gateway-lt31, http://computershopper.com/laptops/reviews/gateway-lt3103u--five long reviews in reliable sources CNET, Laptopmag, PC Magazine, PC World and Computer Shopper. I agree that it would perhaps be better for our readers if this were a section of an article on Gateway laptops or even Acer laptopts, (Gateway being an Acer brand nowadays), but those overview articles don't seem to exist and not for lack of sources. There is one for the Acer Aspire line of notebooks, but this one isn't suitable for merger there unless the focus of that article is enlarged first. As I said on the talk page before this AfD was started, the name of the article is also bad, because “LT3103u” refers to the Nightsky Black model, (“LT3114u” is Cherry Red for instance); the more appropriate name would have been Gateway LT31 or perhaps Gateway LT3100 series. (By the way, did anyone notice that ''some'' Asian brands have figured out that they need to use catchy names for their products? We even have an article on the Asus Eee Keyboard or Lenovo IdeaPad Yoga ...) Searching for """"Gateway LT3100 series"""" finds some more tech news coverage http://techcrunch.com/2009/06/23/gateway-lt3100-netbook-features-116-inch-screen-amd-processor/ TechCrunch, http://news.cnet.com/8301-17938_105-10270722-1.html CNET News, http://www.engadget.com/2009/06/23/gateways-amd-packing-lt3100-netbook-unleashed/ Engadget, http://www.eweek.com/c/a/Desktops-and-Notebooks/Gateway-Taps-AMD-Athlon-Processor-for-LT3100-Netbook-570257/ eWeek, etc. I don't see how these references are any different from those used in similar Wikipedia articles""" Deletion of Gateway LT3103U WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21131 9986 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kylian Hazard User:Fenix 07:07, 15 July 2014 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Kylian Hazard WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21132 7184 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thirst and Goal podcast User:Ejgreen77 14:19, 15 January 2019 (UTC) delete as shameless self-promotion in an attempt to manipulate search engines. Deletion of Thirst and Goal podcast WP:NOTWEBHOST Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21133 18782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Children of the Corn: Runaway User:Cardei012597 04:36, 27 August 2019 (UTC) comment If you still don't believe this film passes , even though this article clearly does, maybe actually contribute, add more to this page rather than go the easy route by deleting. Clearly, I've proven there are plenty of citations that describe filming, cast, and release of this film. If you believe ''Hellraiser: Judgment'' has more info on this article, maybe find more extra citations that describe similar info from Hellraiser's page. Its obvious this page, at least, passes . This fact alone is good enough to allow this page to stay. I can gladly copyedit the info on Hellraiser's page, reword the info to satisfy our Wikipedia rules, and add it to ''Runaway''. There is no basis or real reason, execept for the fact that it's easier, to delete this page. If I must, I can gather other editors who will follow rules Deletion of Children of the Corn: Runaway WP:NFF||WP:NFF||WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21134 15198 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Gools User:The 19:35, 8 July 2018 (UTC) delete per nomination; subject lacks notability. |Is this above or below the line? I forget Deletion of The Gools WP:PROMO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21135 18230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cameron Byrnes User:A 20:43, 10 April 2010 (UTC) delete The subject fails , plain and simple. He's notable for one thing alone, and there isn't enough coverage for him to merit an article Deletion of Cameron Byrnes WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21136 6541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lali Watt User:MichaelBillington 08:45, 14 October 2006 (UTC) delete Fails , not enough press coverage to pass Deletion of Lali Watt WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21137 9678 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of airports in the United States by passengers boarded User:Snotbot 10:26, 15 January 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 January 15 Deletion of List of airports in the United States by passengers boarded WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21138 7747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PRIZ-ONE [[User talk:Satori Son|Satori Son]] 16:54, 23 September 2006 (UTC) delete While there are some assertions of notability here that might satisfy , they are not supported by any sources whatsoever, much less reliable third-party ones. Since no one here has been able to find sources either, despite some due diligence research, the article does not meet the non-negotiable requirements of Deletion of PRIZ-ONE WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
21139 16858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1660 Safed massacre User:Jonathanwallace 07:56, 31 March 2011 (UTC) comment I have not reverted any more of your edits. You are adding sources such as Christian inspirational publishers and Zionist advocates that fail 's requirement of high quality sources for exceptional claims. You also re-added the lede which says, in Wikipedia's voice, that a massacre occurred. Again, there is not a single professional historian quoted saying a massacre happened in Safed in 1660. Also, please remember . All edits I made were to remove patently unreliable sources, synthesis and unsourced assertions, consistent with my understanding of our verifiability and sourcing rules Deletion of 1660 Safed massacre WP:REDFLAG||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21140 1776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sylloc Server User:Gary 20:13, 27 April 2008 (UTC) delete Does not appear notable enough to deserve its own article, per . I could not find any |reliable sources that covers the subject Deletion of Sylloc Server WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21141 17201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Burgess User:Ste4k 03:50, 30 June 2006 (UTC) delete WP:VER|This page is unverifiable and possibly |autobiographical, no |reputible resources are listed resulting in pure |original research. Read the history Deletion of Steve Burgess WP:AUTO||WP:RS||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
21142 11102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mirametrix Research User:Qworty 01:09, 31 October 2012 (UTC) delete Another paid sock'n'schlock article on a company that is long on promotional cash but very short on notability, assembled with a jumble of sketchy cites, mostly primary sludge mixed with bloggy onanism mixed with dishonest paraphrase of other sources--in other words, a typical paid hack job. In technical terms, fails per lack of Deletion of Mirametrix Research WP:CORP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21143 11581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Everett Berry User:Thine 18:18, 10 October 2012 (UTC) delete non-notable. Doesn't meet , especially #C1 Deletion of Everett Berry WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21144 12857 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mitchel P. Goldman User:Randykitty 10:33, 21 March 2015 (UTC) delete per . Horrific article with vastly inadequate and promotional sourcing (an Amazon author profile? Really?) Goldman meets and we should have an article on him, but this is irredeemable Deletion of Mitchel P. Goldman WP:TNT||WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
21145 883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patricia King (evangelist) User:Bearcat 23:10, 23 August 2016 (UTC) delete """What we have here is basically a PR résumé for a person who exists, rather than an encyclopedia article about a person who satisfies any specific notability rule. Prior to being tackled by the clean 'n scrub union, this was based ''entirely'' on her own |primary source content about herself with the ''sole'' exception of the SPLC citation — and the problem with the SPLC reference isn't that the SPLC are """"hatemongers"""" (which is not a claim that would pass even the most cursory test for ), but that it didn't even properly |verify the content being cited to it. Nothing left here now is a strong claim of notability, none of it is |properly sourced at all, and Wikipedia is ''not'' a free publicity platform on which a person is ''entitled'' to keep an unsourced or primary sourced article just because she ''exists""" Deletion of Patricia King (evangelist) WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:NPOV||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:No original research 65
21146 1095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noob tube User:Department 14:03, 12 January 2010 (UTC) delete per all of the above, particularly Deletion of Noob tube WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21147 16421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Noah's Ark, A Journey Through Faith Board Game User:Echuck215 23:41, 19 May 2007 (UTC) delete """If """"legit"""" means """"existent,"""" then yes, the game and company probably do ''exist.'' But if the only mention of them that can be found is the company's website, or similarly unreliable source, then the game is hardly |verifiable, and certainly not |notable""" Deletion of Noah's Ark, A Journey Through Faith Board Game WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21148 20894 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Shore User:EverybodyEdits 22:19, 22 August 2020 (UTC) delete Not enough coverage to warrant an article. Fails or Deletion of Tony Shore WP:NACTOR||WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
21149 6238 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Hirschhorn User:Northamerica1000 05:48, 3 November 2017 (UTC) merge to Dogvacay as a reasonable search term, per -R Deletion of Aaron Hirschhorn WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21150 19023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/T.L. Young User:MelanieN 01:02, 11 October 2013 (UTC) delete Does not pass the notability standards of (freelance writing and one self-published book) or (involvement with a few non-notable films). Nothing significant found at Google News Archive Deletion of T.L. Young WP:AUTHOR||WP:PERFORMER Wikipedia:Notability 77
21151 12708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bluestockings (bookstore) User:Marquardtika 18:46, 10 September 2020 (UTC) keep The current article is not very good, but there is definitely sufficient and in-depth coverage in independent sources to meet . A Google search yielded articles in https://www.timeout.com/newyork/news/les-radical-bookstore-and-cafe-bluestockings-is-closing-072120 TimeOut, https://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/29/nyregion/at-bluestockings-a-manhattan-bookshop-and-activist-center-radical-is-sensible.html New York Times, https://www.boweryboogie.com/2019/05/bluestockings-celebrates-20-years-on-the-lower-east-side/ Bowery Boogie, https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/bluestockings-bookstore Atlas Obscura, https://www.amny.com/things-to-do/bluestockings-bookstore-1-28657119/ AMYNY, https://lithub.com/iconic-lower-east-side-bookstore-bluestockings-has-found-a-new-home/ Literary Hub, https://bookstr.com/article/bookspot-of-the-week-bluestockings-bookstore/ Bookstr, and https://observer.com/2014/12/bluestockings-the-lower-east-sides-last-radical-bookstore/ The Observer Deletion of Bluestockings (bookstore) WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21152 7709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Battelle User:Qworty 19:51, 30 May 2011 (UTC) delete """He fails and . Also fails , since he is little more than an adjunct, despite the impressive-sounding title of """"visiting professor."""" That adds up to little more than a parking sticker on his car for the part-time temporary faculty lot. Also, if he really was such a web-tech heavyweight, he wouldn't be wasting his time here on Wikipedia in violation of and """ Deletion of John Battelle WP:AUTHOR||WP:BK||WP:PROF||WP:AUTO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
21153 14345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Foord User:CASSIOPEIA 10:24, 25 November 2019 (UTC) delete Non notable office to pass nor the sourcing is good enough to pass Deletion of James Foord WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21154 6467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ming Freeman User:Lilac 17:08, 8 March 2009 (UTC) keep it is difficult to determine whether the mentions are non-trivial, as required by and specifically . However, in a leap of |good faith, I'm assuming that what you dug out actually is non-trivial, and if so, I'll vote to keep the article. It would be great, however, if you could link to free online versions of these reviews and articles, if such exist, so the rest of us can easily verify notability Deletion of Ming Freeman WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21155 21756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shida Night Market User:Skyfiler 17:32, 30 March 2017 (UTC) keep already meets per Cunard Deletion of Shida Night Market WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21156 18510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Connell Fort User:Rusf10 07:03, 28 January 2018 (UTC) delete Doesn't pass - only coverage is from the local paper Deletion of Connell Fort WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
21157 13181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Lane (television personality) (2nd nomination) User:Jersey92 03:33, 7 September 2014 (UTC) delete Not sure that applies, but fails Deletion of Sarah Lane (television personality) (2nd nomination) WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21158 4026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticism of the 2019 Hong Kong anti-extradition bill protests User:Boud 02:02, 1 September 2019 (UTC) delete """but '''merge''' any notably new material. Following John M Wolfson's comments above, the original title """"Aggressive and abusive tactics used by the protesters in the 2019 Hong Kong anti-extradition bill protests"""" very much sounds like a of Tactics and methods surrounding the 2019 Hong Kong anti-extradition bill protests and ; whether the actions are """"aggressive"""" or """"abusive"""" forms of civil disobedience techniques used against unresponsive governments and police, in HK or elsewhere around the world, or whether they are really """"tactics"""" or not, or whether they are proportionate to the threat and urgency, are questions that go more into (at present) the """"Reactions"""" article - PRC policy aims to discredit 30% of HK's population as """"violent rioters"""". The tactics themselves (if they are tactics) make sense in the """"Tactics"""" article. ''(As mentioned at Talk:Tactics and methods surrounding the 2019 Hong Kong anti-extradition bill protests#Government tactics and methods, it might be worth it to off the PRC part of """"Reactions"""" into a """"PRC/HK governmental tactics ..."""" article, after choosing a reasonable name. The tactics of the PRC/HK governments in this context are a notable topic, no matter whether they are respectful of human rights and the international legal principle of self-determination or not""" Deletion of Criticism of the 2019 Hong Kong anti-extradition bill protests WP:POVFORK||WP:UNDUE||WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Content forking 33
21159 4161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Smith (health spa expert) User:AmericanAgent 09:56, 12 March 2019 (UTC) delete People are presumed |notable if they have received significant coverage in multiple published secondary sources that are reliable which clearly fails in this case . Hence delete this article Deletion of Mark Smith (health spa expert) WP:BASIC||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21160 167 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Murad Mirzayev Kullanıcı:nanahuatlnanahuatl 15.21, 29 Mayıs 2021 (UTC) comment en:WP:SNG|şuranın ilk paragrafı aslında tam dediğin konuya işaret eder: bu özel kriterlerin herhangi birini ya da birkaçını karşılamak kayda değer olduğu anlamına gelmediği gibi karşılamadığı da tersi anlamına gelmez. Keza sayfası da açıkça '''Ancak, bu kriterlerin sağlanamaması bu kişinin ansiklopedide yer almaması gerektiğinin kesin delili sayılmamalıdır ve bu kriterlerin bir veya birkaçının sağlanması da kişinin yer almasını garantilemez''' der. Senin görüşün ise bunun tersi yönde tam olarak Murad Mirzayev'in silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
21161 8930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joseph McMoneagle (2nd nomination) User:Sophos 18:39, 9 May 2009 (UTC) delete For the same reason invoked by LuckyLouie ( Deletion of Joseph McMoneagle (2nd nomination) WP:SELFPUB Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21162 8908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darrill Schoonover User:LiberatorLX 11:39, 29 October 2013 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet , maybe meets with his feuds with Rampage Jackson Deletion of Darrill Schoonover WP:NMMA||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21163 10004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mario Ostojić User:Uzma 12:01, 7 September 2012 (UTC) delete The level at which Mario Ostojić played football merely is one indication of whether reliable sources will have written biographical information about him. Believe it or not, Wikipedia has articles on people who didn't even play football! That's because Wikipedia merely is a writing based publisher of information and uses significant coverage in Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable sources that are Wikipedia:Independent sources|independent of the subject from which to draw that information. If Wikipedia were a reward based publisher of information, then it would directly matter whether Ostojić played professional football. What it comes down to is that, without enough reliable source material from which to draw material and write the Mario Ostojić Wikipedia article, there won't be enought text in the the Mario Ostojić Wikipedia article to justify a stand alone article. The topic does not meet Deletion of Mario Ostojić WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21164 10180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Walter Peirce User:XOR 18:24, 3 April 2019 (UTC) delete At least three of the four books mentioned in the article were self-published (see AuthorHouse). Plenty of worthwhile material on niche topics can show up that way, and his ''Guide to Patapsco Valley Mill Sites'' actually got a https://www.jstor.org/stable/40968665 favorable review in a IA (journal)|scholarly journal. But that only gets him a little ways up a steep hill. I'm just not finding a case for passing , or Deletion of James Walter Peirce WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21165 5500 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Explosive Pro Wrestling User:AllynJ 05:00, 12 October 2007 (UTC) delete per & . http://www.abc.net.au/perth/stories/s1202102.htm This was the only |reliable source I could find on the topic, and it doesn't do anything to verify the contents of the article other than saying it exists. Considering the lack of ''multiple'' independent sources, fails on the notability front too Deletion of Explosive Pro Wrestling WP:V||WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21166 7173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/StylishandTrendy User:Yunshui 20:46, 16 January 2012 (UTC) delete per nom, insufficient sources for Deletion of StylishandTrendy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21167 6830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Critical data studies User:Atlantic306 17:32, 12 December 2017 (UTC) keep as has coverage in reliable sources as shown by Piotrus, passes Deletion of Critical data studies WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21168 9583 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Junaidu Gambo Gurbin Bore User:JohnCD 10:41, 5 November 2015 (UTC) delete """A worthy person, but no indication of |''notability'' in Wikipedia's sense. This is one of series about people from Gurbin Bore, characterised by lack of notability and deadlink """"references"""". See ockpuppet investigations/Abbakahr""" Deletion of Junaidu Gambo Gurbin Bore WP:N||WP:S Wikipedia:Notability 77
21169 3122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grace Su [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 12:27, 6 February 2013 (UTC) delete it would seem most (if not all) of the sources are from sites like IMBD (not RS) and the subject's own website. I can't see significant coverage in reliable sources enough to meet Deletion of Grace Su WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21170 15594 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roy Sebag (2nd nomination) User:scope_creep 22:03, 4 June 2020 (UTC) comment The previous editor is another . Not a single reference has been added to the article, that can be used to verify , nevermind . This reference added by the SPA is an affiliate, interview style, primary ref and can't be used to establish notability Deletion of Roy Sebag (2nd nomination) WP:SPA||WP:SECONDARY||WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
21171 4080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sally the Sunflower User:Gongshow 05:29, 24 August 2017 (UTC) delete The game exists but I could find no coverage in reliable sources; appears to fail Deletion of Sally the Sunflower WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21172 13575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kasia Wrobel User:Piotrus 08:49, 9 December 2014 (UTC) delete So far the sources in the article offer only a paragraph at best, little more. Deletion of Kasia Wrobel WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
21173 809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2017 Interstate 75 rock-throwing deaths User:MB 18:30, 7 February 2019 (UTC) delete per /. We certainly don't cover all crimes. As far as the lasting effect, highway overpasses have been routinely fenced in many places for a very long time. I don't find the fact that Ohio passed a regulation about this to be significant Deletion of 2017 Interstate 75 rock-throwing deaths WP:NOTNEWS||WP:NCRIME Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21174 5 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leejay Abucayan User:Leesome 16:45, 20 March 2008 (UTC) comment """I agree with the editor above who pointed out that none of the """"sources"""" provided by Leejay Abucayan are reliable for establishing his """"notability."""" Most of the material in the sources is self-generated. What little third-party material he has provided fails the standard. Look at the """"article"""" about him in Sacramento Magazine--it's not an article at all, it's just a short blurb, and it shares the page with short blurbs about a hair salon and a car-repair shop!! Obviously, we're not going to have articles here about hair salons and car-repair places. That's '''''NOT''''' what personal notability is about, and that's not what an encyclopedia is about. Mr. Abucayan, please read so that you will understand what kind of sources you need to provide to us""" Deletion of Leejay Abucayan WP:RELIABLE Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21175 10073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Girls Just Wanna Have Fun (Miley Cyrus song) User:MacGyverMagic 08:52, 4 December 2008 (UTC) keep The Bubbling Under Hot 100 Singles is not a reliable chart, but the others are. And according to charted songs are notable, regardless of their actual ranking Deletion of Girls Just Wanna Have Fun (Miley Cyrus song) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21176 17368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fatima al-Sughra bint al-Husayn User:OccultZone 08:26, 3 February 2015 (UTC) delete Fails , there are no mentions outside this en.wiki page and some other social networking sites Deletion of Fatima al-Sughra bint al-Husayn WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21177 11538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2021 Island Games User:Buggie111 22:44, 2 December 2012 (UTC) delete per Deletion of 2021 Island Games WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21178 13486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Higher Earth User:Ginsengbomb 17:06, 29 May 2012 (UTC) delete Lackluster, somewhat |routine coverage in sources of borderline-at-best reliability = not ''yet'' notable. More issues and continuing coverage? Absolutely. Boilerplate preview coverage in at-best-questionable sources and the like? No Deletion of Higher Earth WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21179 5403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Management Information Systems Association User:Chaser 06:08, 15 July 2006 (UTC) delete Student clubs and organizations are not notable. FYI: is a proposed guideline Deletion of Management Information Systems Association WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21180 16973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gnostic Movement User:HumbleGod 06:36, 18 July 2006 (UTC) keep """An ideal outcome in my eyes would be to have this page point to Gnosticism (since Google indicates that far more people searching for the term are looking for thathttp://www.google.com/search?hs=2M3&hl=en&lr=&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla%3Aen-US%3Aofficial&q=%22Gnostic+Movement%22+-weor&btnG=Search than for thishttp://www.google.com/search?hs=O3N&hl=en&lr=&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla%3Aen-US%3Aofficial&q=%22Gnostic+Movement%22+weor&btnG=Search), move this current article to something like Gnostic Movement (Weor), and have a disamb sentence on Gnosticism pointing to the new page. I'm convinced that this is significant enough in some circles to be worth keeping, but not significant enough to hog the term """"Gnostic movement."""" And while this article is certainly POV right now and might be |OR, this can hopefully be fixed""" Deletion of Gnostic Movement WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21181 18900 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ARDOR User:Widefox 20:44, 9 March 2018 (UTC) comment we should probably look at per my comment at Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Qtum Deletion of ARDOR WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
21182 5573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Squirms User:Dacium 21:53, 15 February 2007 (UTC) delete Fails , not shown notibility Deletion of Squirms WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
21183 7297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Reverend Peyton's Big Damn Band User:Dennisthe2 22:18, 12 April 2007 (UTC) keep I'm going to assume that K8 fan there can get the references, so I'd like to |assume good faith and figure that s/he will do exactly this Deletion of The Reverend Peyton's Big Damn Band WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
21184 21045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Pennington User:Innisfree987 02:43, 5 May 2017 (UTC) keep with a gentle reminder. Here's the http://www.ajc.com/news/richard-pennington-former-atlanta-police-chief-has-died/ndtd1XLJu3OPbqvnIQqg2J/ Atlanta Journal Constitution, http://www.theadvocate.com/new_orleans/news/crime_police/article_cef20682-3114-11e7-bdf8-731f2c26e5a2.html The Advocate and http://www.nola.com/crime/index.ssf/2017/05/former_new_orleans_police_chie_1.html The Times-Picayune all devoting full articles to him, and then there's a great deal more press that includes descriptions of his work over many years. Sustained, significant coverage, passes GNG Deletion of Richard Pennington WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21185 1197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1933–34 EAHL season User:Yosemiter 20:48, 14 April 2020 (UTC) delete """I have no access to read the full content of the articles I see on the archives, however, the titles of the articles do seem on the routine side. Without significant coverage outside of |simple records and stats, I have to lean on the """"Fails to meet GNG"""" side of this discussion. I would prefer if some the more generic records are added with sources to the EHL/EAHL page, like a simple list of champions by season, before we have a bunch of unsourced, and possibly unreliable, stats pages for each season""" Deletion of 1933–34 EAHL season WP:NOTSTATS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21186 4207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayor of South Campus User:Bad 06:41, 1 February 2006 (UTC) delete cute, but Deletion of Mayor of South Campus WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
21187 6609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Table dance User:Ig8887 10:26, 25 February 2008 (UTC) keep lack of references is a surmountable problem as notability of the term is not in doubt. This nomination borders on Deletion of Table dance WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21188 16827 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/West And East Collide User:TheFeds 04:54, 3 May 2010 (UTC) delete no evidence of notability via references. I wish that |crystalballing of an album was a valid reason to speedy delete under A9 Deletion of West And East Collide WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21189 4823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Kamen Rider: Dragon Knight characters User:Rorshacma 16:50, 22 January 2021 (UTC) delete """While character lists ''can'' be valid spinouts of articles, they actually need to be comprised of sourced information and be able to pass and/or the . This list is only using a single source, which appears to not only be a dead link, but was just the program scheduling for a single episode. I've done some searches, and I am really not finding any coverage of the characters from the show in reliable sources that could support this spinout article. There is already basic coverage of the major characters in the """"Plot"""" section of the main Kamen Rider: Dragon Knight article, and there is really no content in this article that is actually salvageable for merging, as there is no sourced information""" Deletion of List of Kamen Rider: Dragon Knight characters WP:LISTN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21190 19383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Organized crime in popular culture User:Erik 16:47, 2 July 2007 (UTC) delete because like the nominator said, this is a #DIR|directory. Categories already exist for these items, and there's no encyclopedic value in putting these loosely-associated entries together into a list of indiscriminate trivia to convey the so-called topic of organized crime in popular culture. Seriously, someone needs to write a prose article of some entity in popular culture based on significant coverage from independent, secondary sources, to put this listcruft and all the rest to shame Deletion of Organized crime in popular culture WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21191 4589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicolai Lomov User:Stormtracker94 12:22, 30 September 2007 (UTC) delete per , , and . {{User:Stormtracker94/sig Deletion of Nicolai Lomov WP:N||WP:RS||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21192 11591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matheus Thiago de Carvalho User:Argyle 14:40, 23 April 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Matheus Thiago de Carvalho WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21193 15732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Eyton-Jones User:Melcous 21:43, 11 October 2018 (UTC) delete I've been through the sources and removed those that blatantly did not verify the claims they were being used for. The only claim to notability in the sources is that he is CEO of CERN's Pension Fund. A search does not find more. Fails to meet or Deletion of Matthew Eyton-Jones WP:BEFORE||WP:ANYBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21194 16161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Freechild Project User:Mangojuice 15:43, 4 April 2007 (UTC) delete """The sourcing of this article is beyond merely suspect, it is clearly stretched to inflate claims of significance. As an example, ''The Freechild Project has also been cited for making theoretical contributions to the field of youth service5 and youth participation.6'' is backed up by 5: an undergraduate term paper that cites the Freechild project to help determine a framework for the rest of the paper: it's not an important point in the paper, it's certainly not a paper about the Freechild project, and ''it's just a term paper'' anyway: not at all a reliable published source. And 6 is not much better: it is a reliable source but it doesn't attribute any such thing as """"theoretical contributions"""" to the Freechild project, rather, it's a source about how to foster youth participation in social activities in Halifax and mentions the Freechild Project. This problem is endemic in the article. Normally, I might say that the article should be edited to reflect the sources more accurately, but after examining the sources I am still unconvinced that the Freechild Project is really notable, and more importantly, the article has been written to promote it, in violation of and (soapbox""" Deletion of The Freechild Project WP:NPOV||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
21195 7486 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beatrice Farve (2nd nomination) User:Dirtlawyer1 05:01, 20 November 2015 (UTC) delete """to List of supercentenarians from the United States. In the absence of ''significant'' coverage in multiple, independent, reliable sources about the subject per , the default position should be to redirect these """"oldest person"""" articles to an appropriate list, where a description of a sentence or two may be added in addition to the subject's name, date of birth, place of birth, date of death and place of death -- assuming those datapoints can be reliably verified and sourced per and """ Deletion of Beatrice Farve (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21196 16655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valērijs Šabala User:Arsenalkid700 12:55, 30 December 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Valērijs Šabala WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21197 21757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Relationship between Tyranny and Arms Control User:KGirlTrucker81 22:03, 23 August 2016 (UTC) delete Pure and not wirtten |neutrally Deletion of The Relationship between Tyranny and Arms Control WP:OR||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:No original research 65
21198 7213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Douglas D. Taylor (2nd nomination) User:Stevietheman 16:52, 18 January 2016 (UTC) keep per previous recent AfD's outcome (speedy keep) that the individual is notable. If there are any errors in the article, they should be corrected using |reliable sources, of course, but I'm getting the notion that this person is throwing up a lot of things to see if anything sticks to avoid potential professional embarrassment. No individual has a right to request a removal of an article about themselves at any rate. However, he can certainly point us to reliable sources for fixing any errors Deletion of Douglas D. Taylor (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21199 19976 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of United States Supreme Court cases, volume 113 User:Davewild 07:43, 11 October 2007 (UTC) keep Is a sensible structured list (by date) meeting . Most if not all Supreme Court cases are notable in their impact as can be seen from the most recent of these lists List of United States Supreme Court cases, volume 546 where many of the cases have their own articles. As notability is permament I see no reason why the same cannot be done for many of the cases on this list Deletion of List of United States Supreme Court cases, volume 113 WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
21200 6687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Biltmore Square Mall User:TJ 22:35, 31 December 2007 (UTC) delete Fail (primary sources only help for ) due to no third party sources. It could be speedy deleted for no claims of notability, the entire article is just the location of the mall and some of the stores in it. Nothing to seperate this from any other mall (there are 4 malls within 15 minutes of my house, not counting strip malls or plazas Deletion of Biltmore Square Mall WP:N||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
21201 3744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rudolph van Richten (2nd nomination) User:Rorshacma 16:40, 11 December 2019 (UTC) delete As the article has undergone no major revisions, and there ''still'' are no reliable secondary sources discussing the character in any meaningful way to allow it to pass the , there is no reason for the previous AFD's consensus to have been ignored and reverted. Deletion and restoration of the redirect is the best solution to keep this from happening again Deletion of Rudolph van Richten (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21202 11252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Fleming User:Metropolitan90 08:04, 6 August 2006 (UTC) delete per . These articles are one-sentence stubs about characters in a book series, but Wikipedia doesn't even have an article about the series Deletion of Jack Fleming WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21203 4956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Izzo User:Jenks24 18:20, 18 April 2012 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet and doesn't have significant coverage in independent sources (only passing mentions) so doesn't meet . Can be recreated when he makes his debut for Adelaide United Deletion of Paul Izzo WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21204 11645 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maharishi Group User:AndyTheGrump 21:11, 8 October 2012 (UTC) delete """for reasons of apparent non-existence of the entity described by the article - the 'subject' is and conjecture. Having looked into this matter in some depth, it is apparent that there almost certainly is (or at least was) a commercial concern of some type entitled 'The Maharishi Group', as referred to in India's ''Financial Express''. However, much of the article seems instead to be referring to entities of some kind for which no source can be found linking it to that particular commercial concern - or indeed to anything beyond occasional vague references to Maharishi Mahesh Yogi or to Transcendental Meditation movement at best, and nothing more than a name with 'Maharishi' in it at worst - and this is even after removing nonsensical claims that the entire 'Group' was a """"Non-profit conglomerate"""" based on a source that mentioned a 'Maharishi Group Venture... non-profit benevolent society' of some kind in passing - with no indication whatsoever of any connection to any other entity. The crux of the problem becomes clear in the article lede, which states that """"Maharishi Group is also called Maharishi group, Maharishi Group Venture, Maharishi Group of Companies and TM organization"""", but fails entirely to source this statement. The connection between the various entities seems to be based on pure , almost certainly larded with a generous layer of POV-pushing by followers of the late Maharishi. There is nothing cited to demonstrate that the entity described in the article ''exists'' as an entity, rather than as something cobbled together for Wikipedia by Google miners. As for the ''actual'' Indian commercial concern entitled 'The Maharishi Group', there seems to be little to indicate that it would meet guidelines, and there certainly aren't sufficient either in the article, or easily locatable on the web, to construct an article on it at present""" Deletion of Maharishi Group WP:OR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:No original research 65
21205 20201 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/François Asselineau (4th nomination) User:French 20:47, 12 March 2012 (UTC) comment """There is something seriously unhealthy in the arguments of seren above (and only his, I understand very well and respect the position of other editors here, like S Marshall or Ravenswing who underline they have had a look at the sources and find them """"significant"""" enough). Seren, as concerns his position, seems to make the straw man fallacy that French wikipedia users are here in quest of power on english speaking Wikipedia, a kind of colonial war. This is obviously wrong and does not help to keep a good working atmosphere here ; we are not here to speak of cross-wiki power but to open and discuss sources to judge if is met or not. I have decided to make this observation when seeing his last absurd comment (""""''do you think it would be appropriate for us to delete an article here and then go to French Wikipedia and try to get it deleted there?''"""" - of course yes it would be appropriate, we sometimes receive warnings by foreign wikipedia users about multiwiki spam and we appreciate them). Arguments for deleting based on the possible bad behaviour of Asselineau's friends on some wiki are obviously poor, symmetric arguments for keeping based on the supposed bad behaviour of French wikipedia's users here are as poor : """"oppose French Wikipedia control"""" is a void motive for keeping""" Deletion of François Asselineau (4th nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21206 10959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tepperman's User:Steel1943 22:29, 2 February 2015 (UTC) delete Looking at this article and its history, all I can see are and issues Deletion of Tepperman's WP:COI||WP:POV Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
21207 1886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Estadio Argelio Sabillón User:Junior5a 21:08, 12 July 2020 (UTC) keep Meets . There's no need to delete it Deletion of Estadio Argelio Sabillón :WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21208 8465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Westphal User:Scope 12:27, 25 November 2018 (UTC) delete There are no real substantive sources, but potentially Chris Westphal could be notable. I cant find anything on a . The article reads like he should notable, but nothing there Deletion of Chris Westphal WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21209 11700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Source Credibility User:Rd232 16:33, 5 April 2009 (UTC) merge Seems like a valid topic, and some useful material, but it seems to me better covered as a section elsewhere, to give more context and prevent it becoming overly scientific ( an academic journal). So merge to communication or possibly persuasion Deletion of Source Credibility WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21210 799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reor User:LinguistAtLarge 16:23, 18 April 2009 (UTC) delete Speedy and PROD were both attempted, but were removed. Wikipedia is not for things |made up in one day in 2005/6 or for |non-notable EO|neologisms. — Deletion of Reor WP:MADEUP||WP:N||WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
21211 7769 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Page boy User:Satori 13:57, 25 October 2006 (UTC) comment You're right, I forgot about that. And I also missed the medieval term at Page (servant). How about a |disambig instead? I've created a sample at Deletion of Page boy WP:DISAMBIG Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
21212 2945 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julian Ruck User:Ukexpat 19:40, 5 April 2013 (UTC) delete spectacularly fails Deletion of Julian Ruck WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21213 20435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fookit Ball User:Edison 14:38, 10 August 2010 (UTC) delete Game made up one day, which fails |notability due to lack of significant coverage in multiple reliable and independent sources Deletion of Fookit Ball WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21214 18321 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pamela Pendley Biggers User:Kevin 03:50, 27 September 2009 (UTC) delete clearly fails Deletion of Pamela Pendley Biggers WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21215 17870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solipeta Ramalinga Reddy User:Ab207 05:15, 11 January 2021 (UTC) keep Passes as Reddy served as a member of the State legislative assemblies of India|state legislative assembly Deletion of Solipeta Ramalinga Reddy WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21216 6625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amy L. Lansky User:PaleoNeonate 06:32, 9 February 2020 (UTC) delete """I cannot access the ''Psychology Today'' article, but the other two independent (although still in-universe in their field) books ''Integrative Psychiatry and Brain Health'' (that only uncritically cites her own book) and ''Fundamental Research in Artificial Intelligence at NASA'' only have short mentions of Lansky, not significant coverage. The other sources are authored or co-authored by Lansky. This does not meet (quote: """"A person is presumed to be notable if he or she has received significant coverage in reliable secondary sources that are independent of the subject."""") and the lack of an article on Wikipedia may be better than one that is critical (in case notability, if any, was only derived from the controversial views she promoted; but if that was the case, wouldn't there also be more coverage in independent sources""" Deletion of Amy L. Lansky WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21217 13738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Detroit Tigers minor league players (2nd nomination) User:Kinston 14:17, 24 March 2009 (UTC) delete These should be deleted and indivdual pages made for the players. They are obviously notable per since they are all professional and are all discussed in third party sources Deletion of Detroit Tigers minor league players (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21218 10273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dead escape User:JohnCD 20:44, 23 May 2008 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not for |promoting your new product Deletion of Dead escape WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
21219 13960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/E-Sword (2nd nomination) [[User_talk:Travellingcari|TravellingCari]][[Special:Contributions/Travellingcari|the Busy Bee]] 13:57, 21 June 2008 (UTC) comment """Re: ''In addition, the deletion has been turned down or reversed however many times it is, and that in itself is an argument for notability ~ if it weren't notable, the previous deletions would have succeeded or stuck.'' WHere has it been reversed or overturned? I don't see any evidence for anything other than its been re-created a number of times? Being deleted three times says a lot. And while it's an essay, I suggest you have a look at , including ''A commonly seen argument at AfD is """"Subject has X number of Y, that's notable/non-notable"""". Notability isn't determined by something's quantity of members, but rather by the quality of the subject's verifiable, reliable sources.'' It's something to keep in mind, the latter are still lacking in terms of non-trivial coverage. Also while it's software and not wholly a website, this portion of is worth keeping in mind, ''Wikipedia articles should not exist only to describe the nature, appearance or services a website offers, but should describe the site in an encyclopedic manner, offering detail on a website's achievements, impact or historical significance""" Deletion of E-Sword (2nd nomination) WP:BIG||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21220 13166 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SQL Maestro User:Budgiekiller 19:41, 10 January 2007 (UTC) delete no sources provided, no notability asserted, can this meet ? Not at the moment Deletion of SQL Maestro WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21221 5026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danny Denholm User:Walls 16:17, 26 June 2013 (UTC) delete Fail and Deletion of Danny Denholm WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21222 6381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toast Nightclub User:Sandstein 11:10, 10 February 2007 (UTC) delete Also per ; only one independent source is cited and its link is dead Deletion of Toast Nightclub WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21223 6484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stacy Blackman User:Someone 22:58, 7 February 2014 (UTC) delete """Misleading article. She was not profiled in those publications as the wiki article claims. http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive/2000/05/29/280644/index.htm This doesn't even mention her. Having one piece published (as a kind of interview) on CNN Money's website http://money.cnn.com/2006/09/20/pf/mba_admissions/index.htm doesn't make her notable, as DGG correctly noted. There is one introductory paragraph about her http://www.entrepreneur.com/article/83610-2 here, but the rest of that is she talking about Charles Schwab (as a former employee). Not imparting her much notability as explained in """"quotations from an organization's personnel as story sources""" Deletion of Stacy Blackman WP:VANISPAM||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
21224 3357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elvin Aghayev User:Le 14:51, 29 March 2015 (UTC) delete Someone who's either just completed their PhD or is still writing up their dissertation, asserting this meets is fantastically overoptimistic, and presumably is because the author has the usual reason for writing about a nobody Deletion of Elvin Aghayev WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21225 3278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pear Cable Audio Cables User:MER 10:07, 1 December 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Pear Cable Audio Cables WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21226 13505 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Village School Charlottesville Virginia User:Michaelas10 17:00, 23 January 2007 (UTC) delete Even if the school http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Village+School+Charlottesville+Virginia%22 does exist, it absolutely fails any notability criteria and is filled with |original research Deletion of Village School Charlottesville Virginia WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21227 12917 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Essjay controversy (5th nomination) User:Tasoskessaris 00:11, 24 September 2008 (UTC) keep as per J Readings and also Deletion of Essjay controversy (5th nomination) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
21228 3587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Line of succession to the former Chinese throne User:Coolabahapple 04:08, 5 July 2017 (UTC) keep meets , well referenced article Deletion of Line of succession to the former Chinese throne WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21229 16280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dhiyavasu Bhadauria User:Vejvančický 11:54, 25 July 2014 (UTC) delete eligible for speedy deletion under , no evidence of notability. Possible and issue Deletion of Dhiyavasu Bhadauria WP:A7||WP:COI||WP:AUTOBIO Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
21230 10655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rubén Serrano User:Moonriddengirl 20:17, 2 June 2008 (UTC) comment I also had concerns about notability, as I indicated at the talk page, but the creator convinced me to remove my notability tag with the following:http://www.laquincena.es/20080326/presentada-la-nueva-edicion-de-los-duendes-de-navalcarnero-destinada-a-recabar-fondos-para-cruz-roja la quincena (machine translated http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.laquincena.es/20080326/presentada-la-nueva-edicion-de-los-duendes-de-navalcarnero-destinada-a-recabar-fondos-para-cruz-roja&sa=X&oi=translate&resnum=1&ct=result&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522Presentada%2Bla%2Bnueva%2Bedici%25C3%25B3n%2Bde%2B%25E2%2580%2598Los%2Bduendes%2Bde%2BNavalcarnero%25E2%2580%2599,%2Bdestinada%2Ba%2Brecabar%2Bfondos%2Bpara%2BCruz%2BRoja%2BLa%2Bnueva%2Bedici%25C3%25B3n%2Bcuenta%2Bcon%2Bel%2Bpatrocinio%2Bde%2Bdiferentes%2Bempresas%2By%2Bcomercios,y%2Bla%2Bdel%2BAyuntamiento%2Bde%2BNavalcarnero.%2BRedacci%25C3%25B3n%2BMi%25C3%25A9,%2B26/03/2008%2B-%2B14:18%2BVota%2B1%2Bvoto%2BEnviar%2Bnoticia%2BDestinatario:%2BRemitente:%2BComentarios%2522%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26hs%3Dlza here), http://www.aquiyahora.es/noticia.asp?ref=1445 aquiyahora.es, http://www.prensaquatro.es/noticia.asp?idnoticia=9435 prensaquatro.es (machine translated http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.prensaquatro.es/noticia.asp%3Fidnoticia%3D9435&sa=X&oi=translate&resnum=1&ct=result&prev=/search%3Fq%3DBajo%2Bel%2Bt%25C3%25ADtulo%2B%25E2%2580%2598Miradas%2Bimposibles%25E2%2580%2599,%2Bel%2Bperiodista,%2Bescritor%2By%2Bfot%25C3%25B3grafo%2BRub%25C3%25A9n%2BSerrano%2Brealiza%2Buna%2Bexposici%25C3%25B3n%2Bsolidaria%2Bde%2Bfotograf%25C3%25ADas%2Bin%25C3%25A9ditas,%2Bcuyo%2B%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26hs%3Dhmv here), http://www.diariodirecto.com/hem/20040808/SOC/soc_desarrollo_gral3.html diariodirecto.com (http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.diariodirecto.com/hem/20040808/SOC/soc_desarrollo_gral3.html&sa=X&oi=translate&resnum=1&ct=result&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522El%2Bperiodista%2By%2Bescritor%2BRub%25C3%25A9n%2BSerrano%2Bacaba%2Bde%2Bpublicar%2522%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-US:official%26hs%3DaUG%26sa%3DG machine translation) and http://www.quedicen.es/noticia.asp?ref=372413 quedicen.es. These all seem to be |reliable sources, though as I am not familiar I cannot be sure. Each of these seems to lead to notability, although if this is all that there is it may not be sufficient to meet . Are there problems with these sources Deletion of Rubén Serrano WP:RS||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21231 14885 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rachel Antoniadou User:Bagumba 09:38, 18 February 2017 (UTC) delete Fails . I'm not seeing multiple sources of significant coverage, particularly from independent sources. Nothing in presumes notability from playing in the WNBL or being a member of a national team. Incidentally, she's only played on an under-18 team, not even a senior team. But again, notability not presumed by being on a national basketball teams. not met Deletion of Rachel Antoniadou WP:GNG||WP:NBASKETBALL||WP:NOLYMPICS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21232 4072 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Lloyd Smith (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 04:21, 21 February 2010 (UTC) delete absolutely zero |reliable sources, which are needed for |basic notability Deletion of Greg Lloyd Smith (2nd nomination) WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21233 19799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ramsay Hall [[User: Yaksar|Yaksar]] [[User talk: Yaksar|(let's chat)]] 07:21, 14 March 2011 (UTC) delete definitely should not have an individual article on a dorm (famous people having lived there does not make it notable). I think a merge may lead to issues of , and a redirect seems weird for what's likely a common name Deletion of Ramsay Hall WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
21234 18317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kerri Bennett Williamson User:AllyD 12:03, 11 November 2016 (UTC) delete Searches are turning up very little. I am seeing no |evidence that the subject meets or broader criteria Deletion of Kerri Bennett Williamson :WP:RS||:WP:AUTHOR||:WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21235 18737 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Michelin three starred restaurants User:Clarityfiend 07:57, 16 March 2012 (UTC) merge """to List of Michelin starred restaurants, less the """"notably absent"""" countries and cities and captions with trivial stats. No need for two lists""" Deletion of List of Michelin three starred restaurants WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21236 12948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earth Fare User:Bakazaka 01:02, 18 October 2018 (UTC) keep """as sources in article and available in newspaper databases meet requirements for significant, in-depth coverage. """"Number of locations"""" is not part of policy or guidelines, except when discussing whether individual stores should have articles, which is not applicable here. Pre-internet coverage matters just as much as Google-able coverage, and this company has it, primarily because of their unusual and early pursuit of organic food as a niche market. Several sources are local, but is clear: """"the significance is not determined by the reputation of the source"""" but by reliability and independence, both of which are met by available sources""" Deletion of Earth Fare WP:NCORP||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21237 3626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Active NHL players by nationality User:Stifle 19:45, 29 December 2008 (UTC) delete fails items 6 and 8-11 Deletion of Active NHL players by nationality WP:LC Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
21238 14918 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fernando A. Rios User:Tychocat 16:18, 17 July 2006 (UTC) delete """for failing on three key points: No evidence of inter/national tours, no charted hits, no substantive third-party articles. I get ''five'' Ghits for """"Fernando A. Rios"""", and two of those are this article. Granted, Google should not necessarily be the final arbiter of notability, but at this level I think the Ghits are entirely symptomatic. I also can't find any listings for the albums beyond this article, suggesting they're self-published, which is why just having albums out isn't necessarily notable""" Deletion of Fernando A. Rios WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21239 1522 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Graph-tool User:Ihcoyc 16:05, 21 February 2013 (UTC) delete Adding 'python' to the several searches generates very little relevant hits; relevant books are all Wikipedia reprints. Google News search draws a complete blank. Scholar results are mostly irrelevant with the possible exception of http://cdn.intechopen.com/pdfs/30511/InTech-Guisurfer_a_reverse_engineering_framework_for_user_interface_software.pdf this paper, which contains text identical to the Wikipedia article, and notes that this software was used in some unrelated project. Bottom line is that nothing shows that this product has had |significant effects on technology, history, or culture, or that it has any fame or notoriety |beyond the community of Python programmers Deletion of Graph-tool WP:SIGCOV||WP:B2B Wikipedia:Notability 77
21240 9551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derro (Dungeons & Dragons) User:TTN 19:47, 15 December 2019 (UTC) delete Fails and no need to retain the information elsewhere Deletion of Derro (Dungeons & Dragons) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21241 14497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Lee (musician) (2nd nomination) User:NSR77 16:43, 13 September 2008 (UTC) delete Fails to meet Deletion of Matt Lee (musician) (2nd nomination) WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21242 26 [[Keiner ist kleiner]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:M-J NONE delete Demotape im Selbstverlag, zudem ist der Artikel größtenteils , damit Löschung von Keiner ist kleiner Wikipedia:TF Wikipedia:No original research 65
21243 9207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of deaths in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows User:Jreferee 17:24, 27 July 2007 (UTC) delete WP:OR|Original research for which there are not enough |reliable sources |independent of the book ''Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows'' to |verify the List of deaths in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows material Deletion of List of deaths in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows WP:RS||WP:V||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21244 10364 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of colleges in Ratnagiri User:Spiderone 19:21, 19 December 2016 (UTC) delete fails , etc. It is also not a plausible search term so no need for a redirect Deletion of List of colleges in Ratnagiri WP:LISTN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21245 6113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Justin Wells User:Gtstricky 19:43, 26 February 2008 (UTC) delete does not meet and seems like it is probably a |conflict of interest issue also Deletion of Justin Wells WP:BIO||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
21246 13685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/W.I.T. (3rd nomination) User:Versace1608 01:06, 5 April 2020 (UTC) delete The group fails and . I can't seem to find a coverage in reliable sources Deletion of W.I.T. (3rd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21247 17108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Smith (DJ) User:Funky 14:18, 24 August 2020 (UTC) comment Wow! I wish I'd never put this up as an AfD if I knew it would have caused so much upset. Let me explain my reasoning as to why I nominated this page for deletion. Although Tim is on the radio, this doesn't automatically mean he warrants an article. Even a Redirect to Steve Wright In The Afternoon would suffice. As far as I'm concerned (along with other editors) the subject doesn't meet or . As I've said before, someone just because someone is on a national radio station, doesn't make them notable. My nomination still stands Deletion of Tim Smith (DJ) WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21248 11529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chandler Hoffman User:Argyle 05:22, 5 January 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Chandler Hoffman WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21249 8274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aspen Graphics User:Stifle 20:14, 20 October 2008 (UTC) delete doesn't seem to meet Deletion of Aspen Graphics WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21250 11559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lee Ann Brown NONE NONE comment The subject married Rip Torn's son so the wedding announcement is in NY Times. The poetry of the subject is a vanity project, as is her entirely self published pseudo publishing company Tender Buttons Press|Tender Button Press. Any awards received are not mainstream awards. There is very little editorial oversight on any publication by this subject or about this subject. Reviews I have found are blogs or sites like Boston Review that ask for donations. To pass or we would need to see more. For instance which criteria does the author pass Deletion of Lee Ann Brown WP:NAUTHOR||WP:NPOET Wikipedia:Notability 77
21251 12148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter R. Nord User:RayAYang 17:35, 17 December 2012 (UTC) keep Google scholar gives him an h-index above 25 (good possibility of satisfying #C1). The very first source on the article (http://amle.aom.org/content/2/4/378.short) is an interview for the professor following his receipt of a an award for being a distinguished educator. He was an editor on the Handbook of Organization Studies, a frequently used text in courses on the subject (see, for example, http://wagner.nyu.edu/syllabus/200709/P11.2906.pdf). These two point towards satisfying rof#C4). His bio http://business.usf.edu/_docs/faculty/nordvita.pdf lists him as a Distinguished University Professor at the University of South Florida, possibly satisfying #C5 Deletion of Walter R. Nord WP:PROF||WP:P||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21252 13668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2.2.1 User:SyndicaterUI78 20:58, 13 May 2019 (UTC) delete Who would need this disambiguation? Fails Deletion of 2.2.1 WP:PTM Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
21253 12102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lakshya Digital User:The9Man 08:32, 6 May 2020 (UTC) delete Fails |notability to have a separate article Deletion of Lakshya Digital WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21254 4173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raymond A. Watson (2nd nomination) user:Lionelt 00:12, 2 October 2011 (UTC) keep The time this article was in ikiProject Conservatism/Incubator was time well spent. Thanks to George's patience and diligence the article is fully referenced with independent reliable sources and flies past WP:BASIC. &ndash Deletion of Raymond A. Watson (2nd nomination) WP:W Help:Watchlist 110
21255 17121 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grant Mahoney User:Whpq 17:57, 30 November 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Grant Mahoney WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21256 17017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Security theater User:Valrith 12:11, 26 August 2006 (UTC) delete as per , . Looks like neologism to me Deletion of Security theater WP:V||WP:OR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21257 13891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of gangs in Grand Theft Auto series User:96T 12:10, 27 February 2007 (UTC) keep per Deletion of List of gangs in Grand Theft Auto series WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21258 20128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2022 MotoGP season User:SSSB 09:59, 7 February 2020 (UTC) delete article constitutes only a list of contracts which is insufficent per , article therefore fails Deletion of 2022 MotoGP season WP:NSEASONS||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
21259 15947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Michael Brooks Show User:Kirbanzo 17:21, 22 January 2018 (UTC) delete although the podcast has a somewhat substantial following, it fails Deletion of The Michael Brooks Show WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21260 1064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irish Secret Service User:Quarl NONE delete as |unverifiable. Not even very notable as a conspiracy theory. An article on Irish Secret Service Fund could be created if someone wants. &mdash Deletion of Irish Secret Service WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21261 5107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of public houses in Bracknell User:Carlossuarez46 05:01, 6 December 2007 (UTC) delete as per #DIRECTORY as above by Deletion of List of public houses in Bracknell WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21262 9095 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Liw User:Hawkeye7 06:04, 17 January 2018 (UTC) keep Seems to be enough sources to sustain Deletion of Daniel Liw WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21263 18112 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brittany Anne Pirtle User:SL93 22:12, 14 September 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Brittany Anne Pirtle WP:ENT||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21264 1840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krishna Nagar, Delhi User:The 23:54, 4 April 2012 (UTC) merge although I'm not 100% sure of the target; East Delhi would be valid, but is there a lower-level subregion with a valid page? While, as Lugnuts points out, towns, communities, and so-on are universially kept per Wikipedia's remit as a gazeteer and , Krishna Nagar isn't one of those; it a neighborhood. http://maps.google.com/maps?q=Krishna+Nagar,+Delhi&oe=utf-8&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&client=firefox-a&um=1&ie=UTF-8&hl=en&sa=N&tab=wl Google Map - this is not an indpendent community, and as such, IMHO, should be merged and redirected to the actual community that it is a part of, as it does not meet Deletion of Krishna Nagar, Delhi WP:OUTCOMES||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21265 7974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juicy girl User:Tarinth 10:10, 6 January 2007 (UTC) keep as another of this nominator's attempts to bowdlerize Wikipedia. Please see Deletion of Juicy girl WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
21266 1083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DJ Flare User:Hoppingalong 04:18, 12 March 2012 (UTC) keep Though I have much more experience in geography, not music, the MTV and Shure book sources strike me as compelling. They note he invented a particular technique. That seems to support his passing No. 3, if only by a hair. http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_product=SMCB&p_theme=smcb&p_action=search&p_text_direct-0=11BA964E93343E98&p_field_direct-0=document_id This news article Michig cited also gives his real name and age and discusses an incident where he was shot. All together, I think he passes Deletion of DJ Flare WP:ENT||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21267 10417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liberty Clipper user:Andrew 08:50, 9 January 2017 (UTC) keep """per our |editing policy, """"Even poor articles, if they can be improved, are welcome."""" The nomination fails as sources are easy to find, for example ''https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=QgMRudqoLGQC&pg=PA369 Chapman Great Sailing Ships of the World''. The PROD was disruptive as the article is newly created by a new editor and so proposing deletion is obviously controversial and contrary to """ Deletion of Liberty Clipper WP:IMPERFECT||WP:BEFORE||WP:BITE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
21268 9445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Fulford User:Bencherlite 23:09, 20 January 2010 (UTC) keep as he passes by virtue of his FBA, if nothing else Deletion of Michael Fulford WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21269 289 [[TuRa 88 Duisburg]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Hullu poro NONE delete Der Verein steht nicht auf der /Fußballvereine in Deutschland|Positivliste und ist daher zu Löschung von TuRa 88 Duisburg Wikipedia:Positivlisten Wikipedia:Positivlisten 25
21270 13641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dechronication/Hypotheticals User:DustFormsWords 06:15, 9 November 2009 (UTC) delete as fundamentally unverifiable |original research and speculation. Also, I wasn't aware that articles forked off other articles like this (ie Article/Subarticle) were allowable - am I wrong Deletion of Dechronication/Hypotheticals WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21271 4250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erich Reimer (2nd nomination) User:TheGracefulSlick 19:09, 7 December 2018 (UTC) delete I see a lot of itation overkill|cite overkill, especially in the section regarding his political career, but little in adequate, in-depth sources to pass |GNG Deletion of Erich Reimer (2nd nomination) WP:C||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
21272 9137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juan Jesús Martínez Espinoza User:Gene93k 00:27, 14 June 2017 (UTC) comment At least one reliable source confirms that the subject has been convicted and sentenced to 14 years.https://www.clarin.com/policiales/Confirman-condena-Rey-Efedrina_0_rJQMFZmI.html BLPCRIME does not apply, but that that does not establish ongoing non-trivial interest to satisfy . Looks like a secondary player in a larger conspiracy Deletion of Juan Jesús Martínez Espinoza WP:PERP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21273 21412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caste-based prostitution User:Orientls 02:29, 4 June 2020 (UTC) delete per above and . The article is misrepresenting sources to spread false notion that prostitution is allowed for certain castes in certain regions, or all members of certain castes are required to become prostitutes Deletion of Caste-based prostitution WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21274 20537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Katzenjammer Records User:78 13:29, 13 September 2017 (UTC) delete superior analysis by Richard3120 and 331dot. Non-notable label. No length of history, no roster of notable artists, no indication the label made any impact on musical culture. Aside from what makes record labels notable, fails Deletion of Katzenjammer Records WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21275 10043 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The New Federal State of China User:Prosperosity 02:08, 27 June 2020 (UTC) merge to be a subsection of an article discussing 爆料革命 (with the article title being Baoliao geming / Whistleblower Movement / Exposé Revolution / whatever translation is the most common in the press), or put the article back into draft space. As per the equivalent Chinese wiki article, this is a small part of a larger movement. There seems to be significant media coverage for The New Federal State of China, but describing it as a government in exile or a micronation is misrepresenting what the group actually is/how it functions. In an article Steve Bannon calls it a government, but describes it as https://asiatimes.com/2020/06/bannon-tells-at-us-election-is-all-about-china/ an advocacy group, and the WSJ calls it https://www.wsj.com/articles/chinese-sporting-power-couple-issues-rare-rebuke-of-ruling-communist-party-11591797324 a campaign. Based on the sources, this group doesn't seem to function anything like a government/govt in exile/micronation at all (yet - it might do in the future but that's Deletion of The New Federal State of China WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21276 20660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Recycling and Waste Management Exhibition User:Shoy 18:47, 29 June 2017 (UTC) delete Sources fail and I can't find anything additional Deletion of Recycling and Waste Management Exhibition WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
21277 21226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sreyash Sarkar User:Otr500 14:19, 20 December 2018 (UTC) keep but a note to the article editors (some appearing new and even |thus far single purpose accounts) to provide against future AFD's notability needs to be clearly established by sources and not just by the number of sources on the article Deletion of Sreyash Sarkar WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
21278 14057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Armoured One User:4meter4 19:54, 30 October 2019 (UTC) keep Not sure why this was nominated for deletion under this rationale as the article contains plenty of sources to meet Deletion of Armoured One WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
21279 1047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamdi Zurqani User:David 21:57, 23 November 2020 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON, citations not yet strong enough for #C1 and no other case for notability is apparent Deletion of Hamdi Zurqani WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21280 16257 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colorado balloon incident User:Binarybits 13:08, 16 October 2009 (UTC) keep """The people citing need to work on their reading comprehension skills. I guess they're thinking of the sentence """"Routine news coverage of such things as announcements, sports, and tabloid journalism are not sufficient basis for an article,"""" but there was nothing routine about this—it was the front-page story on every major news outlet for the better part of the day, and there will likely be additional developments and follow-up coverage for several days. The point of the notability requirement is to ensure that WP doesn't cover topics that are so obscure or trivial that they won't be properly sourced or reviewed. The huge number of people participating in this AfD suggests this isn't an issue in this case""" Deletion of Colorado balloon incident WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21281 17264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Qlink [[User talk:NukeThePukes|Nha Trang]] 22:04, 23 October 2014 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Qlink WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
21282 20485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Forward Degree College User:MirkoS18 23:55, 4 January 2013 (UTC) keep per ''' Deletion of Forward Degree College WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21283 21496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Stambolziev (2nd nomination) User:Mkativerata 06:17, 29 June 2010 (UTC) delete """In my view, Luxic is absolutely right. We have to remember that both and are ''guidelines'' that give rise to ''presumptions'', not guarantees of notability. With that in mind, neither """"trumps"""" the other. This person clearly fails , which is the community's most generous inclusion criterion. On the other hand, his case on GNG is marginal at best - the sources appear provide isolated sports news coverage of events in his career rather than in depth biographical material. So in my view any presumption caused by the subject meeting the GNG - which is weak - is outweighed by his clear failure to meet the objective criteria of . Only with this approach can we mitigate the randomness and unpredictability of the GNG with sensible objective standards of notability. At the end of the day, notability is about being """"worthy of note"""", and it is only in special cases that a non-professional footballer in England is likely to be worthy of note""" Deletion of Robert Stambolziev (2nd nomination) WP:ATH||WP:GNG||WP:ATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
21284 184 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Seferihisar Anadolu Lisesi """Kullanıcı:mızrak'''mızrak'''""" 01:03, 11 Mayıs 2008 (UTC) delete Önce maddenin kalmasından yana oy kullandım fakat Noumenon'un bağlantı verdiği sayfasını inceledikten sonra silinmesi yönünde oy kullanıyorum. Kriterleri okuduktan sonra, başlattığım Kars Alpaslan Lisesi|şu maddeyi geliştirdim. Maddeyi kriterlere uygun hale getirmeye çalıştım. Sizce nasıl olmuş Seferihisar Anadolu Lisesinin silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda değerlik (okul) Wikipedia:Notability 77
21285 5078 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ufc-pride User:Metros232 15:58, 12 November 2006 (UTC) delete Notability not established through |reliable or |verifiable sources Deletion of Ufc-pride WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21286 8083 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gus Giesebrecht User:Kuyabribri 14:48, 15 July 2011 (UTC) keep The article states, and |reliable sources clearly verify, that he played for the Detroit Red Wings from 1938–1942, thereby passing . &mdash Deletion of Gus Giesebrecht WP:RS||WP:NHOCKEY Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21287 4246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Torment (2008 film) User:Brewcrewer 06:01, 1 February 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Torment (2008 film) WP:MOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21288 3525 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mancala networks user:czarkoff 17:28, 16 August 2012 (UTC) delete WP:B2B|B2B company with no |slightest difference from the generic company of a kind. |Awards don't help if there is nothing to write about. — Deletion of Mancala networks WP:MILL||WP:NBIZ Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
21289 16153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shabbos App (2nd nomination) User:Bus 01:53, 22 October 2014 (UTC) keep """This topic does not escape Wikipedia's radar. The argument to delete is an argument saying that this topic escapes Wikipedia's radar. The multitude of good quality |reliable sources discussing this topic are not concerned that this product does not exist or may not ever exist. Many sources are discussing the theory of such a phone. No, this is not a ''scientific theory''. The sources are discussing whether theoretically a few tweaks to a smartphone can render it compliant with the halacha governing Shabbos permissibility. It is a topic widely covered by good quality sources. That makes this topic compliant with Wikipedia policy which might be brought to bear on whether or not to """"keep"""" this article. In the final analysis the sources are supporting this article""" Deletion of Shabbos App (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21290 16213 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chelsea F.C. vs FC Barcelona, 2009 UEFA Champions League semi-final, second leg User:Jimbo 13:01, 13 May 2009 (UTC) delete as , despite a few penalty appeals and dodgy refereeing decisions this game is just another Champions League game. Maybe worth noting the controversy on the Tom Henning Ovrebo's page, as long as it's referenced otherwise it'd be subjective Deletion of Chelsea F.C. vs FC Barcelona, 2009 UEFA Champions League semi-final, second leg WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21291 12393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Jaames User:Joe 23:48, 29 January 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |author Deletion of Joshua Jaames WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21292 6804 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UBC International Law Journal User:Guillaume2303 20:09, 18 June 2012 (UTC) delete At this point, this even fails , as the journal's homepage is down. Does not meet or ournals Deletion of UBC International Law Journal WP:V||WP:GNG||WP:NJ Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21293 109 [[Martin Zitzmann]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Zubi NONE delete Gleiche Gründe wie /17. März 2005#Quartett (Schweizer Rock-/Popband). Person ziemlich unbekannt. Falls der Artikel nicht ausgebaut wird Löschung von Martin Zitzmann Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21294 14226 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beauty and Warrior User:JJL 00:18, 23 May 2009 (UTC) delete for lack of evidence of Deletion of Beauty and Warrior WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21295 14905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Roll-Pickering User:Timrollpickering 05:29, 1 June 2006 (UTC) delete """Minor UK student/blogger who fails notability test. Article claims the blog http://timrollpickering.blogspot.com is one of the most popular political blogs in the UK without any supporting evidence (external reference link is just to the blog itself). Large majority of the http://www.google.com/search?q=%22tim+roll-pickering%22 14,900 google hits for """"Tim Roll-Pickering"""" are blog/bulletin board/newspaper forum comment posts by subject himself or student union websites or amateur political blogs connecting to his amateur political blog. Just 116 hits including 43 hits from his own blog for the http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&safe=off&q=%22timrollpickering%22+blogspot&btnG=Search google search term """"timrollpickering"""" +blogspot. Cannot find material to support passing . FYI, the article subject is a Wikipedian - see""" Deletion of Tim Roll-Pickering WP:WEB||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
21296 16644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Graham Parsnip User:That NONE delete as |hoax. &mdash Deletion of Graham Parsnip WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
21297 11384 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hussain Industries (2nd nomination) User:HighKing 12:12, 21 February 2018 (UTC) delete a run-of-the-mill company with zero indications of notability. I have no idea why this company is deemed notable - certainly, participating in the Frankfurt trade show isn't it. The references are run-of-the-mill business directory listings and normal financial reporting, failing and/or . Is it normal or odd that http://www.tdap.gov.pk/pakistan-directory-inner.php?eid=3447&cid=13&pid=23 this reference appears to indicate that the company doesn't have their own domain name? Topic fails GNG and Deletion of Hussain Industries (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21298 5465 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doris Egbring-Kahn (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 04:40, 3 January 2017 (UTC) comment """Actually, the Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doris Egbring-Kahn|previous AfD discussion had two participants other than from the nominator, but after two relistings, the overall input was inadequate for a consensus to be determined. This counters the notion of """"Complete lack of community interest confirms non-notability"""" stated in the nomination herein. Furthermore, lack of input at AfD discussions has no bearing whatsoever upon whether or not a topic is |notable""" Deletion of Doris Egbring-Kahn (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21299 10832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EUROFUTURES User:Paolo 16:00, 21 December 2005 (UTC) delete as |unverifiable: the only reference to this project I could find is http://www.emeraldinsight.com/Insight/ViewContentServlet?Filename=Published/NonArticle/Articles/27307fac.002.html, which is however an article in what appears to be a non-refereed journal. Article also violates (section crystal ball Deletion of EUROFUTURES WP:V||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21300 2258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Faculty of Management of the University of Warsaw User:Dps04 13:09, 26 August 2020 (UTC) delete or '''redirect''' to University of Warsaw per the nomination. Also of interest is , which provides that {{tq|Faculties, departments or degree programs within a university, college, or school are generally not considered notable unless they have made significant contributions to their field}}. Given the fact that only routine coverage and https://www.polityka.pl/tygodnikpolityka/nauka/1942626,1,jaka-jest-przyszlosc-uczelni-wyzszych.read interviews on the subject was found (which are unlikely to be independent on the subject), it seems unlikely this faculty is one of the rare exceptions with significant contributions in the field of management, or is otherwise notable enough to warrant its own article Deletion of Faculty of Management of the University of Warsaw WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21301 18675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shot Tower Capital User:K 01:11, 23 June 2017 (UTC) delete notability is not inherited from notable clients, and there's nothing else there. Sources fail Deletion of Shot Tower Capital WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
21302 13773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pukaar News User:Sam 23:05, 31 July 2016 (UTC) delete Granted, it's like some articles about journalists, it's hard to find sources ''about'' subject among the many ''by'' subject, but with significant coverage about Pukaar News in secondary sources found missing, it looks like they fail Deletion of Pukaar News WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21303 868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stanley Burroughs User:MelanieN 21:03, 18 June 2013 (UTC) merge to Master Cleanse. There is little or no verified biographical information to support a biographical article. The current article consists almost entirely of verbatim quotation from a judge's ruling in the subject's criminal trial, massively Deletion of Stanley Burroughs WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
21304 12926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Piwo Fellowship User:Metropolitan90 14:22, 23 July 2008 (UTC) delete """as organization with no claim to notability, and '''block article creator''' whose name resembles the article title. The cited sources do not even mention this organization. This is one of those articles about """"secret"""" organizations we used to see a lot of at AfD, but less so in recent times. If the organization is so secret that the article has to cite rumors, the organization is probably not |verifiable. Article creators shouldn't try to have it both ways -- if you want to promote an organization, you can't write an article saying that little is known about it""" Deletion of Piwo Fellowship WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21305 20766 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Furmanism User:Mh29255 04:14, 19 December 2007 (UTC) delete per nomination; probable |hoax Deletion of Furmanism WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
21306 2581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Answerconnect User:Aboutmovies 08:40, 5 March 2008 (UTC) delete all but one of the references is a press release or blog entry, neither of which are RS and thus fails . The other ref (for customer service) no longer works and the WayBack machine has no record of it. Also, the ''Portland Business Journal'' shows zero hits for the company, and any notable company based in Portland would have at least one hit there Deletion of Answerconnect WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21307 1654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Battlefield: Apocalypse User:Royboycrashfan 04:18, 29 March 2006 (UTC) delete I'm pretty sure this is Deletion of Battlefield: Apocalypse WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
21308 12833 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Center for Computer Games Research User:Thibbs 14:07, 1 July 2009 (UTC) keep and |Stubbify - This is a major figure in Games studies and Ludology research. A quick Google search reveals hundreds of citations to it in RSes in this topic area, so I think it survives under #Faculties and academic colleges|UNIGUIDE. Clearly it needs to be expanded, however in this case per Jimmy Wales, http://lists.wikimedia.org/pipermail/wikien-l/2003-November/008266.html I think people should relax and accomodate Deletion of Center for Computer Games Research WP:STUB||WP:UNIGUIDE Wikipedia:Stub 114
21309 20462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jimmy H. Woo User:Mdtemp 15:11, 17 January 2012 (UTC) merge The articles mentioned focus on San Soo or simply say he's been in the same location for 25 years and taught lots of students. That's not sufficient to pass (in my opinion Deletion of Jimmy H. Woo WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21310 4329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Chappell User:Clarityfiend 08:45, 29 December 2019 (UTC) keep """but not because of an honorary degree from Colby College. That's not """"a well-known and significant award or honor"""". He has, however, received a significant amount of media coverage: https://www.nytimes.com/1996/12/22/magazine/god-and-toothpaste.html an article in ''The New York Times Magazine'', https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/1991-09-01/tom-chappell-sweet-success-from-unsweetened-toothpaste a Bloomberg article, https://www.npr.org/2018/01/22/569432668/toms-of-maine-tom-chappell an interview on NPR with Guy Raz, https://www.forbes.com/forbes/2009/0316/090_river_runs_through_it.html#6b93d37af78a a ''Forbes'' article, etc., so is satisfied""" Deletion of Tom Chappell WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21311 5019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Imee Marcos' Misuse of Tobacco Excise Tax Funds User:FenixFeather 00:03, 20 September 2018 (UTC) keep I think Alternatvity has done a great job of changing the article to something more encyclopedic. It's a close one but the article now passes , imo. &ndash Deletion of Imee Marcos' Misuse of Tobacco Excise Tax Funds WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21312 1065 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Werner G. Scharff User:Lightburst 19:41, 7 December 2019 (UTC) keep notable per RS. The article has reliable sources and others also exist per Deletion of Werner G. Scharff WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
21313 971 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/British Rail Class 37, 37427 User:JulesN 09:35, 26 April 2008 (UTC) delete I don't see anything notable about it, and also fails Deletion of British Rail Class 37, 37427 WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21314 16090 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The College of Wooster Greeks (3rd nomination) User:Titoxd 04:32, 8 November 2005 (UTC) delete Dragonfriend is quite correct on saying that several aspects of the article are in violation of , but there are snippets in this article that do merit inclusion in the encyclopedia. That said, they belong at College of Wooster, not here. If a merge is not accepted, then my vote should be read as a delete Deletion of The College of Wooster Greeks (3rd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21315 3450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ayesha Khalid User:Patar 08:26, 1 December 2015 (UTC) delete does not meet , and related show he's famous for was recently deleted via Deletion of Ayesha Khalid WP:GNG||WP:PROD Wikipedia:Notability 77
21316 18506 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zhang Haijie User:MichaelQSchmidt 02:10, 24 March 2010 (UTC) keep As individual is not a hoax and the award and award nominations appear to meet http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=Zhang+Haijie&btnG=Search&um=1&ned=us&hl=en&scoring=ahttp://www.asiaone.com/Just+Woman/News/Celebrities/Story/A1Story20080305-52835.html. Translating http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22%E5%BC%A0%E6%B5%B7%E6%B4%81;%22&btnG=Search&um=1&ned=us&hl=en&scoring=a these from Chinese language could be further helpful Deletion of Zhang Haijie WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21317 16561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apostolic Johannite Church User:Themfromspace 21:42, 21 March 2009 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Apostolic Johannite Church WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21318 2450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Free market fascism User:JayJasper 06:20, 15 August 2012 (UTC) delete Unencyclopedic essay. Clearly fails and runs afoul of , , & Deletion of Free market fascism WP:GNG||WP:NOR||WP:NPOV||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
21319 10153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Organic Narratives (2nd nomination) User:doomsdayer520 14:37, 13 August 2018 (UTC) comment Since the rapper has no article of his own (see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lostkeyz|AfD:Lostkeyz) , this album should be speedy deleted () unless there is evidence that anybody else notable was involved Deletion of Organic Narratives (2nd nomination) WP:A9 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
21320 6416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glossary of wine terms NONE NONE keep """You must be joking. The saying you quote: """"Wikipedia is not a dictionary"""" #DICT refers to policy about short articles which define a single word or indiscriminate collections of information, this clearly is neither. This is an excellent example of a list which can be used for navigation and information. Please see , below is an excerpt from the guideline""" Deletion of Glossary of wine terms WP:NOT||WP:LIST||WP:SAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21321 18638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dodo/Lurker User:JamesBurns 06:38, 17 February 2009 (UTC) delete non-charting song that fails to demonstrate notability Deletion of Dodo/Lurker WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21322 5636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mia Ikumi User:Allen4names 04:45, 25 September 2016 (UTC) keep As her one-shot ''Only One Wish'' may meet #1 (see /REQUEST#O) thereby just meeting #3 Deletion of Mia Ikumi WP:BK||WP:ANIME||WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21323 14461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2004 Vaughan Shooters season User:Mothman 22:22, 31 May 2019 (UTC) delete Fails . On the topic of 'regular coverage', specifies that routine coverage of a sports team is not a sufficient basis for an article. As an aside, NSEASONS also specifies that if there is a seasonal page, i.e for a major team, then it should not be a collection of stats, which this page is so there is a content issue in addition to the notability one Deletion of 2004 Vaughan Shooters season WP:NSEASONS||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21324 3300 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aya (kitchens) User:Jollygreeng 01:30, 18 February 2009 (UTC) delete This company seems to pass the grade of being notable , especially in the area of green building where very few cabinet companies have a third party certified LEED compliant program. Looks like the comment posted above recommending 'delete' because the 2008 NKBA reference could not be found is not valid as the reference is http://www.nkba.ca/gallery/v/NKBA+ONTARIO+CHAPETR+DESIGN+AWARDS+2008/?g2_page=3 here Deletion of Aya (kitchens) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21325 8899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Atheocracy (2nd nomination) User:Roscelese 18:41, 30 March 2012 (UTC) delete WP:NEO|Non-notable neologism for something that doesn't exist, sourced largely to |fringe websites with a few real sources about a different topic thrown in to make it seem legitimate Deletion of Atheocracy (2nd nomination) WP:FRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
21326 1821 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seph Lawless (2nd nomination) User:Jacobssteph 01:22, 21 November 2017 (UTC) delete """Based on the criteria set out in he does not meet any of the 4 requirements of notability for a Creative Person, or the criteria generally. There is no evidence that in the professional photography community he has significant recognition or reputation. He has not won minor or major awards (let alone multiple awards). He has not developed a new technique, style or subject matter (what he does, urban_exploration photography is very commonplace and he does not do it particularly well or uniquely). He has not generated a body of work that has generated an INDEPENDENT and notable work (i.e. he has not been the subject of a tv series, no books have been written about him that he did not write himself, or the like). His work is not part of any gallery permanent collections (minor or major galleries), reached the level of """"significant monument"""", or been the subject or part of a significant exhibition. Simply being in the news does not make one notable for the purposes of a wikipedia entry. To be notable, they must be significant and noteworthy. An example of a photographer who is significant and is included in wikipedia would be Edward_Burtynsky (major international exhibitions, groundbreaking body of work, deemed significant by his peers, series of movies made about him, etc""" Deletion of Seph Lawless (2nd nomination) WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21327 16 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Turkcell Süper Lig 2007-2008 Sezonu 1.Hafta-Turkcell Süper Lig 2007-2008 Sezonu 34.Hafta """Kullanıcı:mach'''mach'''iavelli'""" 12:05, 15 Haziran 2008 (UTC) delete Hızlı silinsin #Maddeler 3 -içeriksiz Turkcell Süper Lig 2007-2008 Sezonu 1.Hafta-Turkcell Süper Lig 2007-2008 Sezonu 34.Hafta Vikipedi:HS Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
21328 15236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Rosenthal User:Dschslava 17:56, 22 March 2016 (UTC) keep per , but does need cleanup Deletion of Michael Rosenthal WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21329 7073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Controlisable User:Guoguo12 00:59, 20 November 2010 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of Controlisable WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21330 3704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laxpower User:Piotrus 03:44, 20 February 2019 (UTC) delete Fails , Deletion of Laxpower WP:NCORP||WP:NOTYELLOWPAGES Wikipedia:Notability 77
21331 4793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/10 cent trek User:Bigdaddy1981 17:50, 3 July 2007 (UTC) delete sounds made up - 10 pence trek - the term that purports to describe the practice's UK analogue - is certainly |utter bollocks Deletion of 10 cent trek WP:BOLLOCKS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
21332 12116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rule 34 (Internet meme) User:Doc 22:21, 31 May 2009 (UTC) delete Actually, it's more than just XKCD and it didn't even originate there. It actually started at 4chan and/or Uncyclopedia. But that doesn't mean its notable whatsoever. This is a with little information Deletion of Rule 34 (Internet meme) WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21333 11477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dreadful User:Dhartung 08:09, 26 June 2007 (UTC) delete as utterly NN |neologism specific to a small group of enthusiasts Deletion of Dreadful WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21334 17960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blue (duo) User:Colapeninsula 10:10, 14 June 2012 (UTC) delete Band with no hits, no famous/notable songs, no wider cultural importance, and no references on the article. They may have received some press coverage in the 1980s in music magazines, or they may not. Unless someone is prepared to go to the British Library and crawl through their back issues of Smash Hits, I don't think notability will be established via press coverage. The two members may theoretically meet music notability guidelines for writing Sonia's hit Better The Devil You Know, but would articles on them meet ? For that reason I don't think their possible notability is enough to save the article Deletion of Blue (duo) WP:GNG||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21335 5068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Phillips (author, composer) User:Walwal20 13:27, 4 October 2020 (UTC) delete Fails as his books did not cause sufficient impact; also fails as there is no coverage of him Deletion of Thomas Phillips (author, composer) WP:AUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21336 14318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Moorlands of Halifax User:Deor 15:25, 15 May 2013 (UTC) delete per the opinion I expressed at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Séan Walsh (poet). Fails insofar as no sources are discoverable Deletion of The Moorlands of Halifax WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21337 8163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liam Quinn (Councillor) User:Snappy 12:32, 23 January 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and fails olitician (only elected to local office). P.S. Traditionally the nominator does not explicitly vote, as their nomination of the article is seen as a delete vote Deletion of Liam Quinn (Councillor) WP:GNG||WP:P Wikipedia:Notability 77
21338 1712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Ferguson (photographer) User:SPat 04:25, 31 January 2010 (UTC) comment wasn't aware of when I made the page (and the article doesn't seem to satisfy the criteria). Still, I thought the Time (magazine)|Time article made it noteworthy enough Deletion of Adam Ferguson (photographer) WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21339 11143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaw Academy User:Murry1975 19:56, 25 February 2016 (UTC) keep it passes Deletion of Shaw Academy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21340 20939 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canadian Gay & Lesbian Chamber of Commerce User:Lemongirl942 13:01, 18 October 2016 (UTC) delete Doesn't satisfy at this time. There are quite a few passing mentions, but nothing much about the organisation itself. This is something which might have a claim of significance but at the moment, not enough secondary coverage to write an article Deletion of Canadian Gay & Lesbian Chamber of Commerce WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
21341 2395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Firdaus Kharas User:LeQuattroStagioni 18:28, 20 December 2019 (UTC) delete """First I sensed a Conflict of interest as per - The creator's name is the same (refer history), later """"he"""" change to """"User:Vinlev"""" - refer to WikiCommons, you will see '''Vinlev''' is '''Firdaus Kharas''' (the author and the source of all the photos uploaded). Secondly, the article has been rewritten and revised again and again; and the final outcome is like what it is now (a """"stub"""" resume). If this person is really notable, it should have been easy to write about him but from how I see it, he is not. Moving to draft may or may not help unless if there is someone who are committed to rewrite it again - this article was created 13 years ago but yet no one was willing to improve it (except User:Vinlev). For now, I would say """"Delete"""" is the best vote""" Deletion of Firdaus Kharas WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
21342 20964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Advocates for Awareness of Watchtower Abuses : AAWA User:FreeRangeFrog 23:05, 3 November 2013 (UTC) delete A well-intentioned attempt to document the existence of the organization, however there is no significant coverage whatsoever other than self-generated content and some videos. Certainly no news hits at all. Which makes sense given that it was founded only this year. A case of perhaps, but fails for now Deletion of Advocates for Awareness of Watchtower Abuses : AAWA WP:TOOSOON||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Too soon 40
21343 13696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beyond Treason User:MichaelQSchmidt 20:53, 4 August 2014 (UTC) delete While this film exists and might stir up anxieties, it has not received coverage in reliable sources. Fails Deletion of Beyond Treason WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21344 8020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RPython User:Cunard 06:45, 15 May 2009 (UTC) merge per Deletion of RPython WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
21345 1113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/.sport User:SGGH 06:33, 10 June 2008 (UTC) delete article about an unofficial proposal suspected to perhaps be made sometime in 2009, |Wikipedia does not predict the future and notability can't be inherited from the future either, particularly based on such unofficial, predicted proposals that may or may not happen Deletion of .sport WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21346 12969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aldo Grippaldi [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 10:19, 4 January 2013 (UTC) delete """having noted the sock-puppetry above and given the ongoing trouble, it seems obvious to me that this article is by stealth, created by someone close to the subject who has failed in his campaign to insert the subject's company (''Gravitis'') into various articles. The editor was blocked for trying to legal-threat that company back into Wikipedia and now again for sock-puppetry. I can't help but query the honesty/legitimacy of the claimed sources - added by an editor with a history of system-gaming and bad faith. I can't find much online (by way of ) to verify notability or the claimed plethora of sources. The one that does have a link includes one mention of the subject - hardly """"significant coverage""" Deletion of Aldo Grippaldi WP:PROMO||WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21347 20437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cal dining User:Trialsanderrors 06:49, 16 June 2006 (UTC) delete Calcruft. a travel guide, not a how-to manual Deletion of Cal dining WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21348 18241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sherine Wells User:Ramaksoud2000 01:01, 14 December 2016 (UTC) keep Meets . Covered in at least https://www.thestar.com/sports/2007/05/25/wells_speeds_to_another_gold.html http://www.big12sports.com/ViewArticle.dbml?ATCLID=3728885 http://www.pressreader.com/canada/toronto-star/20080523/282720517704763, not including other trivial mentions Deletion of Sherine Wells WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21349 3622 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Total Dhamaal User:Umair 18:40, 17 September 2017 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Total Dhamaal WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21350 14278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Dublin Bus Routes User:TotalSilence 21:31, 2 May 2019 (UTC) delete This doesn't belong here under . Maybe put this in Wikivoyage Deletion of List of Dublin Bus Routes WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21351 5369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James T. White User:Qworty 09:55, 28 November 2012 (UTC) delete per Deletion of James T. White WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
21352 5784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Over Ashes User:Springnuts 17:44, 14 December 2008 (UTC) keep just meets the requirement for criterion 1 of . The key for me is that the reviews are not simply gushing praise; ie they are independent Deletion of Over Ashes WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21353 11969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dig Safe System User:RC 19:58, 14 March 2008 (UTC) delete Hmm, fails and . '''''Special:Contributions/RC-0722|K Deletion of Dig Safe System WP:N||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21354 21019 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eduard Einstein (2nd nomination) User:FactualCollector7d1 04:43, 21 July 2016 (UTC) merge This article appears to be a genealogical entry, somthing against guidelines. However, it appears to meet the requirement of Wikipedia:Notability#General_notability_guideline|significant coverage. There should also be coverage of Eduard Einstein on some page due to the Wikipedia:Notability#Notability_guidelines_do_not_apply_to_content_within_an_article|affect he would have had on his father. As mentioned in the previous deletion argument, the Albert Einstein page is quite long, so merging the page there would not be ideal; combined with the convention of placing biographies of relatives of Albert Einstein on the Einstein Family page this makes me believe the best option is to merge the Eduard Einstein article into that article. A similar arrangement can be found on the :wikt:fr:Descendance d'Albert Einstein#Eduard|French Wikipedia, creating precedent for this action (however it should be noted that several other Wikipedia's have separate articles about Eduard Einstein). — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Eduard Einstein (2nd nomination) WP:DIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21355 21312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Insider Pages User:FortyHertz 15:15, 11 October 2006 (UTC) keep by even the strictest interpretation of orp (see criterion #1). A cursory search of the web turns up multiple articles from CNet News, Business Journal, and the New York Times, of which this company is the direct subject Deletion of Insider Pages WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
21356 2412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AnimeB User:Mkdw 08:03, 8 March 2007 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of AnimeB WP:NEO||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21357 3811 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cellophane (band) User:FingersOnRoids 22:05, 23 April 2009 (UTC) keep The new sources warrant the article inclusion under Deletion of Cellophane (band) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21358 20858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nature Care College User:NewYorkActuary 11:10, 3 October 2015 (UTC) delete the claim of accreditation is (I think) based on this college being a http://www.asqa.gov.au/about-vet/about-rtos/about-rtos.html registered training organisation, according to http://www.naturecare.com.au/about/?id=40 this page on their website. That said, I'm not sure that simply being one of thousands of RTOs is sufficient grounds for notability, and I'm not finding other coverage that would push them past the . As an aside, I'd caution Deletion of Nature Care College WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21359 10815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Yale User:EricSerge 01:41, 6 October 2015 (UTC) delete While Yale and Haerter did display extraordinary heroism warranting the award of the Navy Cross, they are one of nearly 6900 estimated recipients of the Navy Cross. The bill to upgrade their awards died in congressional committee in 2014. The consensus has been that being awarded a nations highest award would confer sufficient notability, but the second highest award does not. This would seem to be . Their deaths are tragic but |Wikipedia is not a memorial Deletion of Jonathan Yale WP:BIO1E||WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21360 13892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jake Angeli User:Discott 10:00, 12 January 2021 (UTC) keep whilst I sympathise with those of us calling for deletion and agree with the assertion that Angeli's actions prior to the storming event are not notable (), it is apparent that his role in the storming is notable and that he has become something of a figurehead for that event. In this regard he has clearly become something of a public figure and therefore I feel it is in the public interest to keep the article. The number of reliable articles written about him since the event along with high public interest in him is a testament to this. If it is not kept then at the very least he should have his own section in another article related to the storming event Deletion of Jake Angeli WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21361 4764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Troll in popular culture NONE NONE delete """oh come now. Calling the deletion of articles like this """"vandalism"""" shows a serious lack of |good faith here. I mean, this is just a list of trivia related to trolls. It isn't even an article; it's a list -- and the only inclusions criterion is """"vaguely related to trolls, or things that look like trolls, or things associated with trolls"""". I mean""" Deletion of Troll in popular culture WP:AGF Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
21362 6628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Postal Dude (Postal) User:Coren 03:38, 30 November 2007 (UTC) delete no |reliable sources to establish |real-world notability. — Deletion of The Postal Dude (Postal) WP:RS||WP:FICT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21363 5956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Money as Debt (4th nomination) User:Yworo 16:48, 26 August 2013 (UTC) keep clearly meets Deletion of Money as Debt (4th nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21364 16488 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Array Networks User:Joseph2302 12:51, 30 April 2015 (UTC) delete No independent sources, fails and Deletion of Array Networks WP:GNG||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21365 6284 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yulia Putintseva User:Armbrust 15:59, 23 January 2011 (UTC) delete Fails |notability criteria for tennis players. Junior player, who hasn't won a Grand Slam and wasn't in the top 3 of the rankings Deletion of Yulia Putintseva WP:NTENNIS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21366 8195 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wayne C. Doty User:BabbaQ 11:32, 12 July 2020 (UTC) keep Per WP:GNG. Per 2. Also per sources Deletion of Wayne C. Doty WP:CRIMINAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21367 12164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan James (filmer) User:Selket 23:47, 12 February 2007 (UTC) delete fails as all external references are associated with the subject of the article. Also, autobiography problems Deletion of Jordan James (filmer) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21368 11984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bristol Classic Boat Company User:Jezhotwells 22:52, 3 December 2011 (UTC) keep I have added some cites from the Evening Post which support the statements in the article. I feel it meets the Deletion of Bristol Classic Boat Company WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21369 7555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Punch-Out!! characters User:Zxcvbnm 09:40, 6 February 2020 (UTC) keep Definitely notable. Large amount of refs, such as http://www.hardcoregaming101.net/punch-out-introduction-characters/ Hardcore Gaming 101, https://kotaku.com/every-punch-out-opponent-ranked-1750664537 Kotaku, and https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/pg5jyy/what-mike-tysons-punch-out-taught-us-about-fighting Vice that gives opinions about the characters. Not to mention how both Little Mac and Glass Joe have their own articles. Deletion of List of Punch-Out!! characters WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21370 18190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iran Paak Party User:Pharaoh 14:27, 3 May 2020 (UTC) delete per nom fails Deletion of Iran Paak Party WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21371 8131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TeamBglobal User:A 15:54, 25 March 2010 (UTC) delete I also failed to find any |significant coverage in reliable sources for this cycling team Deletion of TeamBglobal WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21372 12798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blizzhackers User:Mystache 13:24, 27 April 2006 (UTC) keep meets , I suppose Deletion of Blizzhackers WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
21373 13828 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Who See? [[User talk:EliminatorJR|ELIMINATORJR]] 18:08, 11 November 2007 (UTC) delete Taking into account ; sources on Eastern European bands are notoriously difficult to come by, but given that the article admits they've only released one album, they almost certainly don't pass the notability guidelines on bands anyway Deletion of Who See? WP:CSB Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
21374 175 [[Klaus Brandner (Künstler)]] (gelöscht) 178.191.215.84|178.191.215.84]] ([[Benutzer Diskussion:178.191.215.84|Diskussion]]) 18:13, 8. Mär. 2012 (CET NONE keep Nach den Wikipedia-Kriterien sollte die Erscheinung eines monographischen Artikels in einer Fachzeitschrift relevant genug sein! Die Vernissage (Zeitschrift) steht unter den Wikipediakategorien bei den Kunstzeitschriften (Österreich). Also nach den Regeln bzw. Kriterien Wikipedias, ist die Relevanz des Artikels nach nachgewiesen! '' (''nicht Hilfe:Signatur|signierter Beitrag von'' Löschung von Klaus Brandner (Künstler) Wikipedia:RBK Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
21375 1061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NetLink Trust User:HighKing 18:18, 15 October 2020 (UTC) keep It is listed and https://www.netlinknbn.com/analyst_coverage.html covered by many analysts. I can't access the analyst reports but https://sginvestors.io/sgx/stock/cjlu-netlink-nbn-tr/analyst-report there are many of them. Analyst reports meet the criteria for establishing notability as per and I am satisfied to assume that at least two of these reports provide Independent Content and in-depth analysis. Topic meets GNG/NCORP Deletion of NetLink Trust WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21376 19433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Esther Petrack (2nd nomination) User:Atlantic306 19:28, 23 July 2018 (UTC) merge as at present, thanks Deletion of Esther Petrack (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21377 8744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abhinav.net User:Stubblyhead 16:37, 23 May 2006 (UTC) delete nn web portal. Hard to get a number of google hits as Abhinav seems to be not uncommon as an Indian name. Appears to be an ed Article, and the main contributor has done little more than edit that page and vandalize users' pages when they prod it Deletion of Abhinav.net WP:OWN Wikipedia:Ownership of content 86
21378 20311 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neave Barker User:Becksguy 04:55, 1 March 2015 (UTC) delete per nom, , , and . There are only a few trivial mentions about the subject, nothing that shows notability. Not even borderline Deletion of Neave Barker WP:GNG||WP:BIO||WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
21379 14425 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Particle User:IvoryMeerkat 16:25, 25 February 2011 (UTC) merge """to particle (disambiguation). The article is only likely to ever be of this sort. The term """"particle"""" just means """"small thing"""" and in different contests has wildly different applications be they theoretical, phenomenological, or ontological. The best thing to do is to shunt off readers to the type of particle they're most interested in rather than having them wade through a |synthesis of disparate ideas""" Deletion of Particle WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
21380 21697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prompong Kansumrong User:GiantSnowman 17:17, 19 August 2009 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Prompong Kansumrong WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21381 19146 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rushing Woman's Syndrome User:Logical 02:43, 3 July 2014 (UTC) delete fails (and Deletion of Rushing Woman's Syndrome WP:BK||WP:MEDRS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21382 5456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Main Political Council User:Spinningspark 17:13, 24 August 2018 (UTC) keep """There is a fair amount of coverage in multiple books, https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=w4dsCQAAQBAJ&pg=PA49&dq=Główna+Rada+Polityczna ''The Polish Underground and the Jews, 1939–1945'' for instance. I would not oppose a merge given the current undeveloped state of both articles, but either way, the information should be kept per . By the way, a more common English translation in sources of ''Główna Rada Polityczna'' is """"Chief Political Council"""" which may help in searches. Also, the council is also known as ''Rada Główna Obrony Narodowej'' (""""Main National Defense Council""" Deletion of Main Political Council WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
21383 18474 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Possamai User:Sandstein 06:51, 15 November 2006 (UTC) delete per Xtifr, may also suffer from issues Deletion of Adam Possamai WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
21384 473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of performances on Top of the Pops User:MacGyverMagic 09:19, 1 May 2009 (UTC) keep """Colonel Warden showed the sources exist. The need to provide the sources has been met; after that applies. That said, the list isn't actually complete. http://news.bbc.co.uk/cbbcnews/hi/music/newsid_1957000/1957665.stm When a TOTP producer said he hated S Club Juniors and didn't want to put them on the show, it was regarding their first single """"One Step Closer"""" which isn't listed. I have no idea if they actually performed Puppy Love on the show""" Deletion of List of performances on Top of the Pops WP:NODEADLINE Wikipedia:There is no deadline 35
21385 4790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ek Khiladi Ek Haseena (film) User:Accesscrawl 11:00, 30 July 2018 (UTC) keep Passes . Source mentioned in RS is reliable Deletion of Ek Khiladi Ek Haseena (film) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21386 10553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brightpearl User:K 00:20, 5 June 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet / . Yet another private company that is using Wikipedia as an extension of a corporate website Deletion of Brightpearl WP:NCORP||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
21387 102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A. J. C. Jooste High School (2nd nomination) User:onel5969 23:20, 14 December 2020 (UTC) delete non-notable school, fails Deletion of A. J. C. Jooste High School (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21388 20020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Treno (micronation) User:KingAlex 10:31, 8 April 2009 (UTC) delete per |spam, |notability, |verifiability and |advertising. The main contributor is Deletion of Treno (micronation) WP:SPAM||WP:N||WP:V||WP:SOAPBOX Wikipedia:Spam 112
21389 16069 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/King Apparatus User:Ipsign 11:40, 20 September 2011 (UTC) keep per Bearcat. Also need to second Bearcat's note about difference between being ''unrefereced'' and being ''unreferenceable'', and to remind that per , it is nom's responsibility to do basic source search ''before'' starting AfD Deletion of King Apparatus WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21390 6538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Goldsmiths College alumni User:Northamerica1000 00:05, 5 May 2015 (UTC) keep Qualifies as per and Deletion of List of Goldsmiths College alumni WP:NOTDUP||WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
21391 16120 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nithichai Chamchoi User:Paul 11:32, 15 February 2018 (UTC) comment Couldn't identify any in-depth coverage online (Google results are only reports of team and/or match line-ups). This seems to suggest that the subject fails the GNG, which overrules , but his career was a decade ago so I'm not exactly sure Deletion of Nithichai Chamchoi WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
21392 18079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GTTC User:Kraxler 23:41, 17 August 2015 (UTC) delete advert for some new service created by a company which chose this acronym, seems to be some in-house Deletion of GTTC WP:NEOLOGISM Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21393 4776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deepak Jaikishan (2nd nomination) User:FreeRangeFrog 21:58, 22 February 2013 (UTC) delete Coatrack or not, this seems to be a , since as far as I can tell he's not notable for anything else, and he would fail since he's not an elected official (as far as I can see?). The bio seems to have been created specifically to regurgitate rumors and scandals. Whatever has happened since the last AFD seems to be more of the same Deletion of Deepak Jaikishan (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21394 7521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Gibson (footballer) User:Jimbo 08:30, 1 September 2008 (UTC) delete fails . Recreate if and when he plays in a fully pro league/competition Deletion of John Gibson (footballer) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21395 20324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Franklin Rees Associates User:Fan 16:46, 28 September 2006 (UTC) delete Based on the http://www.google.com/search?num=100&hl=en&lr=&safe=off&q=%22Franklin+Rees+Associates%22+-wikipedia six google hits, not in the same galaxy with Deletion of Franklin Rees Associates WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21396 6968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Ashton Vick User:A412 02:12, 13 November 2012 (UTC) merge to List of sole survivors of airline accidents or incidents. . All of the relevant information is already there. The event isn't even notable enough to have an article, for that matter Deletion of Paul Ashton Vick WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21397 287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prince Bobby User:Bettia 09:52, 2 June 2011 (UTC) delete as unverifiable. He was certainly in Bechem Chelsea's squad for 2008-09http://www.worldfootball.net/teams/bechem-chelsea/2009/2/ but like everyone else here I can't find evidence he's actually played at a fully professional level. The others leagues he's played in aren't fully professional, and there's no evidence he passes the |general notability guideline Deletion of Prince Bobby WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21398 20081 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/My Name is on the Bills User:Bkid 12:07, 29 September 2011 (UTC) delete per Deletion of My Name is on the Bills WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21399 8562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brett Younker User:4meter4 03:28, 27 June 2021 (UTC) keep This one is borderline. He did win a Dove Award for ''Passion: Let the Future Begin'' which qualifies him for passing notability under criteria 1. That album also charted in the Billboard 200 and the Top Christian Albums which passes criteria 2 of . However, he only contributed one song to that album, and the sourcing here is pretty thin. I'm leaning towards keep but not strongly Deletion of Brett Younker WP:ANYBIO||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21400 20852 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of professional wrestling promotions in Mexico User:Mal 22:41, 11 June 2010 (UTC) delete I'm leaning towards the nom, but the IP brings up a fair point re mainstream coverage in Mexico. However one needs to provide a limitation in the lead paragraph to avoid as Mexico has a very blurred line between proper feds and backyard (it's not as distinct as it is in other countries like the US). Placing a limitation on would validate MPJ's currently invalid comparison with NWA territories. As the IP created the article he should be the one to fix that. There is also the issue of a List of professional wrestling promotions#Mexico|list already existing. A quick comment to the IP; Punk said it was not a ''core'' issue. He didn't say it wasn't an issue at all. Aren't you nit picking his argument Deletion of List of professional wrestling promotions in Mexico WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21401 19412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chandpur Chandipur Riyajul Ulm User:Rebbing 14:07, 20 August 2016 (UTC) delete """The longstanding consensus of the community as reflected in (|a guideline, not an essay) is that schools are held to the same notability requirements as other organizations, namely, that they have received significant coverage in multiple independent reliable sources. ''Cf.'' {{slink|WP:Notability|Notability requires verifiable evidence}} (""""The common theme in the notability guidelines is that there must be verifiable, objective evidence that the subject has received significant attention from independent sources to support a claim of notability.""""); {{slink |WP:OUTCOMES |Citing this page in AfD}} (""""Notability is demonstrated by the mustering of evidence that an article topic is the subject of multiple instances of non-trivial coverage in trustworthy independent sources.""""). Topics that do not meet the notability requirement """"are not retained as separate articles."""" . See and for an explanation of why we have this requirement.In this case, there is virtually no qualifying coverage of the subject, so the article must be deleted""" Deletion of Chandpur Chandipur Riyajul Ulm WP:NSCHOOL||WP:GUIDES||WP:FAILN||WP:WHYN||WP:NOTDIRECTORY Wikipedia:Notability 77
21402 16336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Sim Wrestling League User:Seidenstud 20:12, 8 July 2006 (UTC) comment While it's very nice that you got new members from the page, using that as part of the argument for keeping it here, effectively means that it is an effective adverstisement. Unfortunately, Wikipedia already has a policy against that. See for more info Deletion of The Sim Wrestling League WP:ADS Wikipedia:Spam 112
21403 892 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Bubble (2013 film) User:I 19:02, 5 August 2013 (UTC) delete http://www.nytimes.com/best-sellers-books/2009-03-29/hardcover-nonfiction/list.html This NYTimes piece is solely about the book, and regardless of its fame, |the film does not get to reap the benefits. The others are |primaries. I can find no news sources providing any coverage of this film Deletion of The Bubble (2013 film) WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21404 3865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cockpuppet User:Danny 22:49, 22 June 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Cockpuppet WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21405 1331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Woohoo (song) user:BGTopDon 02:06, 2 June 2010 (UTC) keep WP:NSONG and Deletion of Woohoo (song) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21406 11141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mirasoft User:The9Man 08:58, 28 February 2020 (UTC) delete No significant coverage in multiple reliable secondary sources that are independent of the subject to pass . Not supporting Wikipedia:GNG|general notability guideline as well Deletion of Mirasoft WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21407 5984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Villa Park Little League User:TKE 04:13, 31 May 2006 (UTC) comment This belongs at |Copyright Problems, as the text is lifted from the website Deletion of Villa Park Little League WP:CV Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
21408 2424 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Spinnin' Records sublabels User:Ifnord 21:14, 18 July 2020 (UTC) merge what little non- information there is to Spinnin' Records Deletion of List of Spinnin' Records sublabels WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21409 16873 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Putinisms (2nd nomination) User:TheFEARgod 11:20, 4 October 2008 (UTC) delete Per and . Per Pocopoco Deletion of Putinisms (2nd nomination) WP:NEO||WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21410 69 [[Wire (Messenger)]] (bleibt) Benutzer:CaZeRillo NONE keep Durch Rezeption eindeutig erfüllt Löschung von Wire (Messenger) Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
21411 365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meat Light User:Mudwater 22:22, 9 April 2017 (UTC) keep I have added three references to the article, which I believe are sufficient to establish that the album in question meets the notability criteria at and . I would request other editors to review this and reassess what they have posted here. Thanks. {{Ping|Aoba47|Exemplo347 Deletion of Meat Light WP:GNG||WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
21412 381 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unstoppable (2010 film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 18:52, 16 August 2009 (UTC) keep and further source. Yes, though tells us a film that has not entered production should not have an article, it also allows/expects consideration of the occasional exception and the use of common sense. As ThaddeusB points out, this one qualifies as one of the exceptions to that rule, as it has enough coverage to qualify for inclusion even were it to be never made. I will myself be adding sourcing in a few hours if others have not beaten me to it Deletion of Unstoppable (2010 film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21413 12375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of people with coronavirus disease 2019 User:ianmacm 17:06, 16 March 2020 (UTC) delete Saw this on Jimbo's talk page and it can be deleted per various issues Deletion of List of people with coronavirus disease 2019 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21414 11539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Temple Emanuel (Cherry Hill, New Jersey) User:Basket 08:37, 19 June 2011 (UTC) delete IZAK's reasoning is a |personal attack against the nominator and also a textbook example of . The congregation is unnotable and the article is ripe for deletion Deletion of Temple Emanuel (Cherry Hill, New Jersey) WP:NPA||WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:No personal attacks 58
21415 8949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walter O'Brien User:Green 14:40, 30 January 2015 (UTC) keep Multiple reliable sources. Passes Deletion of Walter O'Brien WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21416 20137 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lowell Mick White User:Ron 00:05, 11 July 2010 (UTC) merge The article is a |BLP Deletion of Lowell Mick White WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21417 11 [[Shiloh Nouvel Jolie-Pitt]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:82.82.83.98 NONE keep Ich weiß, viele wollen eine Wikipedia der Dichter, Denker und Täter. Aber für viele sind auch Prominente wichtig (siehe einmal mehr ), daher sollten wir Shiloh Nouvel Jolie-Pitt in einer ausreichend knappen Form Löschung von Shiloh Nouvel Jolie-Pitt Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
21418 80 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hibya Haber Ajansı Kullanıcı:erdemsahin25erdemsahin25 11.07, 2 Nisan 2020 (UTC) delete Kayda değer olduğunu gösterir tarafsız, bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynak tespit edemedim. Görebildiğim kadarıyla kriterlerini de sağlamamakta. --Kullanıcı mesaj:Ravages|'''ravages Hibya Haber Ajansının silinmesi Vikipedi:ŞİRKET Wikipedia:Notability 77
21419 8159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emma Gonzalez user:MrX 19:37, 20 February 2018 (UTC) comment FYI to those citing . This subject does not meet criteria 2 and 3 of the guideline. Each of the criteria have to be met for the policy to apply Deletion of Emma Gonzalez WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21420 18695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/COVID-19 lab leak hypothesis User:Scorpions13256 22:44, 18 July 2021 (UTC) keep The lab leak hypothesis likely has received the most attention from reliable sources. The Zoonotic hypothesis, on the other hand, has received relatively little attention. concerns are valid, but there is enough coverage for the lab leak hypothesis to warrant a stand-alone article. So much about the lab leak hypothesis is missing from the main article. Improvement is needed though, because the current article is not good Deletion of COVID-19 lab leak hypothesis WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
21421 5599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Hernandez User:Youngamerican 13:22, 28 July 2009 (UTC) delete Fails and . Also move David Hernandez (baseball), the notable baseball player, to David Hernandez after deletion Deletion of David Hernandez WP:MUSIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21422 3189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Black Eyed Peas forthcoming album User:Esradekan 18:59, 31 July 2008 (UTC) delete per , and all those other ones we quote from in times like these. Good on ya TPH Deletion of The Black Eyed Peas forthcoming album WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
21423 4521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Theoretical Conceptual Vacuum User:Kinu 23:27, 29 June 2011 (UTC) delete appears to violate and , and is possibly a |hoax. If the article actually says anything that is sourceable, I'm not seeing it Deletion of Theoretical Conceptual Vacuum WP:V||WP:OR||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21424 14962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Parente (2nd nomination) User:Niteshift36 04:45, 9 July 2009 (UTC) delete Regardless of the amount of news coverage (the media loves tragedy), this is still a non-notable person who committed a horrific crime. Nothing beyond Deletion of William Parente (2nd nomination) WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21425 21798 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Janet Klatt User:Nolamgm 23:39, 30 September 2009 (UTC) delete Individual and event does not pass or /CA as she has not “received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject.” Nom is correct is that coverage was only in local press. does not apply as the event itself is not notable. Therefore, discussion of article name does not need to be addressed Deletion of Janet Klatt WP:GNG||WP:N||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
21426 19919 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boroka (2nd nomination) User:BabbaQ 16:53, 26 March 2011 (UTC) keep Meets |PORNBIO. I said keep last time and I say keep now too. ''was a nominee for the 2008 AVN Award for Female Foreign Performer of the Year'' is quite telling. Has made an impact in the world of adult entertainment,you can say whatever you like about the pron industry but its not up for us to judge a womans choice of career Deletion of Boroka (2nd nomination) WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21427 11532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Mortensen User:GPL93 13:19, 3 March 2020 (UTC) delete Fails as a failed primary candidate. Best Deletion of Scott Mortensen WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21428 20870 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Turner (Middlesex cricketer) User:BryanG 05:00, 8 April 2011 (UTC) keep Unless I'm reading #Cricket and wrong, players appearing in at least one major cricket match, as Turner did, are presumed notable Deletion of Robert Turner (Middlesex cricketer) WP:ATHLETE||WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
21429 21318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jonathan Bertman User:David 21:50, 27 December 2010 (UTC) keep Articles primarily about the subject in the AMA Newsletter, Modern Physician, and Providence Journal are enough to convince me of a pass of Deletion of Jonathan Bertman WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21430 9643 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled 2011 AMC television series User:Armbrust 12:41, 28 September 2010 (UTC) delete as it is pure |speculation and because it does not have a title it fails HAMMER|TenPoundHammer's Law also Deletion of Untitled 2011 AMC television series WP:CRYSTAL||WP:CRYSTALHAMMER Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21431 7135 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Konstantinos Rostantis User:Padavalamkuttanpilla 18:07, 23 September 2020 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet GNG, Deletion of Konstantinos Rostantis WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
21432 2847 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ibraah (2nd nomination) User:JPxG 03:34, 13 May 2021 (UTC) delete """Ibraah Biography, Age, Education, Album, Songs, Girlfriend, Net Worth"""" and """"Ibraah Biography, Age, Education, Album, Songs, Girlfriend, Net Worth"""" (yes, two refs with that same title) are not usable sources. The majority of these are download pages for the album. The https://www.cyclonetimes.com/harmonize-signs-first-artist-under-his-label-konde-music-worldwide/ Cyclone Times article is a passing mention of him quoted in an Instagram post. The only thing that seems like it even comes close to is https://www.capitalfm.co.ke/thesauce/harmonize-gives-diamond-platnumz-a-run-for-his-money-with-a-new-artist/ this one, but it seems fairly questionable in terms of being an independent RS""" Deletion of Ibraah (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
21433 10535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suicidal courage User:Colonel 18:02, 21 April 2011 (UTC) merge to Suicide mission which is the same topic. This is the essential point of - that we should cover topics which are known by different words together rather than separately. The DICDEF policy does not provide any support for the idea that we should delete short articles and goes to some length to explain the opposite. Editors should please read policies to understand their meaning Deletion of Suicidal courage WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21434 15264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chris Barnes (actor) (2nd nomination) User:Peter303x 09:23, 12 June 2021 (UTC) keep Tony Awards|Tony Award winner. Meets . I have significantly updated his page with his Broadway plays, etc Deletion of Chris Barnes (actor) (2nd nomination) WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21435 3057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aditya Kohli User:Cutest 15:03, 3 October 2014 (UTC) delete Seems to be |too soon and the contributor's username and the license used for the image of infbox indicated the |conflict of interest. — Deletion of Aditya Kohli WP:TOOSOON||WP:COI Wikipedia:Too soon 40
21436 4365 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Presidents of the United States with facial hair (2nd nomination) User:SSTflyer 09:54, 26 September 2016 (UTC) keep Meets as a group that has been discussed in-depth by reliable sources Deletion of List of Presidents of the United States with facial hair (2nd nomination) WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
21437 1290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Brazell User:4meter4 14:13, 27 September 2019 (UTC) delete What's disturbing here is that some of the cited online references do not contain the information they are supposed to be supporting. (such as the second source cited which doesn't even mention the subject). This makes me question whether the veracity of the offline source can be assumed in good faith, if some of the sources online have nothing at all to do with the content they are supposed to verifying. The other online sources, other than the one spanish langauge source, are all tangential. Fails and Deletion of Robert Brazell WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21438 15108 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beyond Protocol (video game) User:MLauba 07:55, 23 April 2009 (UTC) delete """Not enough independent |reliable sources to support a |verifiable and |neutral article. The IGN reference is only a landing page which doesn't count as independent coverage. Beckett.com has no indication of their editorial policies, they do however explicitely disclaim any editorial oversight: ''""""Content is not necessarily reviewed by Beckett prior to posting and does not necessarily reflect the opinions or policies of Beckett. Beckett makes no warranties, express or implied, as to the Content or as to the accuracy and reliability of the Content or any material or information that a Member transmits to other Members. If at any time Beckett chooses, in its sole discretion, to monitor the Services, Beckett assumes no responsibility for the Content, no obligation to modify or remove any inappropriate Content, and no responsibility for the conduct of the Member submitting any such Content.""""'' (from their http://beta.beckett.com/Content/Corporate/TOS.aspx Terms of Service). Other sources cited, including Ten Ton Hammer, are not considered as valid sources under the scope of G/S|Wikiproject VideoGames's source list. I'm also extremely shocked by the pattern of abusive behaviour and the multiple violations of and across several talk pages by some of the keep voters""" Deletion of Beyond Protocol (video game) WP:RS||WP:V||WP:NPOV||WP:VG||WP:AGF||WP:NPA Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21439 2089 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/R. Nicholson User:Hawkeye7 08:02, 20 July 2013 (UTC) keep Lieutenant generals are presumed notable per Deletion of R. Nicholson WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
21440 52 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Mısır bayrağı Kullanıcı:seksen iki yüz kırk beşseksen iki yüz kırk beş / ggt 14.54, 3 Nisan 2020 (UTC) comment Hızlı kalsın'''. , lütfen kriterlerini okuyunuz. Maddenin kısalığıyla kayda değerlik karıştırılmamalı. Diğer dillerdeki maddeleri ve şüpheniz varsa Beyaz Rusya bayrağı, Hong Kong bayrağı gibi maddeleri inceleyebilirsiniz. Ortada tartışılacak bir durum yok, {{ping|Sakhalinio}} etkin gözüküyor, seslenelim Mısır bayrağının silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
21441 12127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Budley User:Mike 08:38, 30 July 2006 (UTC) delete failure of Deletion of Budley WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21442 7026 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roch Hanmore User:BrownHairedGirl 12:32, 6 February 2012 (UTC) keep """Meets Generally acceptable standards """"participated in a major international amateur or professional competition at the highest level such as the Olympics"""". In this case, he played for the Ireland national Australian rules football team, which is the highest level of competition for Australian rules football.The article is currently very weak, with a lack of sourcing to independent reliable sources, so I see a case for merging it to a list until more sources are found. But the subject is notable, so the page and its history should not be deleted""" Deletion of Roch Hanmore WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21443 9683 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ken Chansopheak User:GiantSnowman 13:19, 25 March 2019 (UTC) keep international player, meets , needs improving Deletion of Ken Chansopheak WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21444 21228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Classic Rock Club User:Coredesat 23:32, 22 June 2006 (UTC) delete fails |CSD:A7 Deletion of Classic Rock Club WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
21445 19325 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beekman Fire District User:FrankTobia 13:36, 3 April 2008 (UTC) keep Okay, so I tried to find reliable sourcing for this article, and I admit it's been difficult. I did add one or two, and I think it's likely that it was the first district in Dutchess County, New York even though it hasn't been covered in any secondary sources accessible via internet. So even though it's weak, http://www.firedepartments.net/NewYork/Poughquag/BeekmanFireDistrict.html sources http://www.beekmanhistory.com/id46.html like http://www.beekmanfireco.com/documents/rfsi2003.htm these are good enough for me (for now). I imagine there are sources in the Beekman library / town hall that will support my premise of |notability Deletion of Beekman Fire District WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21446 6180 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sputnik (web browser) User:Mr 01:12, 31 August 2012 (UTC) delete I couldn't find any sources about this online, which leaves the sources in the article. MorphZone and AmigaWeb don't look like they qualify under , leaving the Total Amiga Magazine source, and I don't think that this is enough to prove Sputnik's notability Deletion of Sputnik (web browser) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21447 2435 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elysian Coffee NONE NONE keep This article is modeled on the some of local coffee shops in the region (Pacific North West), as a part of the third wave coffee movement. While this is not an AfD for those specific local coffee shops, none of them have had issues proving for the same reason as this one. The key local coffee shops and roasters on whom this article has been modeled on are as below Deletion of Elysian Coffee WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21448 7255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Milk Junkies User:Calathan 04:35, 30 May 2010 (UTC) delete First, I want to say that Mania.com is definitely a reliable source. Besides Anime News Network (which no longer reviews hentai), it is basically the gold standard for critical reviews of anime in English. It has been accepted as a reliable source in featured articles (such as Madlax and Tokyo Mew Mew), and reviews from Mania.com are regularly cited in articles on anime and manga that have been released in English. Furthermore, reviews from Mania.com are frequently given as reliable sources in AfD discussions for anime and manga articles, and have been used as a major reason for keeping many articles. The article clearly now contains references to a reliable source with significant coverage of the topic, contrary to what MelainieN and Nuujinn claim. All that being said, the coverage is only from a single source, and I feel that coverage from a single source is not sufficient to show that a topic is notable. Though Mania.com chose to review two volumes of the series, says that multiple sources are generally expected and multiple sources by the same author or organization are generally treated as a single source. So unless significant coverage from at least one additional reliable source besides Mania.com is found, I still think the article should be deleted. I would support redirecting the article as a valid search term if there was any appropriate target for a redirect, but I couldn't find one myself Deletion of Milk Junkies WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21449 1093 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Branigan: Boy Genius User:Splash 18:12, 8 September 2005 (UTC) delete either invention or deep |crystal ball gazing. IMDb hasn't heard of it either which they surely would have done if there was this much known about it. I reckon that text has been hacked around from some other movie synopsis and dumped here Deletion of Andrew Branigan: Boy Genius WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21450 5289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bitweaver (3rd nomination) User:Kappa 20:03, 19 September 2006 (UTC) delete for the fourth time and salt the earth. There are still no assertions of notability whatsoever in this article, much less any that would satisfy one of the three criteria listed in . Even the limited information that ''is'' there is not sourced by any references whatsoever, so fails . The two refs that Deletion of Bitweaver (3rd nomination) WP:CORP||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
21451 19111 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bollygraph User:Karthikndr 18:24, 10 April 2012 (UTC) delete Not so |notable. No significant coverage about the article could be found Deletion of Bollygraph WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21452 10185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elevator episode User:Ohconfucius 07:01, 6 October 2009 (UTC) delete the lack of sources would tend to suggest this is like a |neologism or |original research Deletion of Elevator episode WP:NEO||WP:OR Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21453 1558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B.o.B. User:Michig 12:40, 27 October 2008 (UTC) delete As I see it, the article doesn't even assert notability per , let alone demonstrate it Deletion of B.o.B. WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21454 6740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Cabinda NONE NONE delete Really going against the grain here, but in reviewing articles https://www.google.com/search?q=Jason+Cabinda&oq=Jason+Cabinda&aqs=chrome..69i57j69i60l3&sourceid=chrome&es_sm=122&ie=UTF-8#q=Jason+Cabinda&tbm=nws online and that {{u|Go Phightins!}} has provided, it seems like the college athlete in question has only received |routine coverage through media sources either associated with the Big Ten Conference or in different metro areas in Pennsylvania. Many college football athletes will receive mentions and some coverage in articles as the person in question has, but the question is whether or not the coverage makes him/her notable Deletion of Jason Cabinda WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21455 8453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Combat Marine Outdoors User:Armbrust 16:30, 26 October 2010 (UTC) delete There is no coverage in |reliable sources about this |organisation Deletion of Combat Marine Outdoors WP:RS||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21456 21354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Redondo Sycamore, Los Angeles User:GeorgeLouis 02:39, 27 May 2013 (UTC) delete It exists, but it's not notable. No eliable sources attest to its notability Deletion of Redondo Sycamore, Los Angeles WP: R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
21457 15469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ciplex User:KVIKountry 00:44, 10 January 2011 (UTC) keep found enough coverage in Businessweek Magazine, Techcrunch, Washington Post, Inc. Magazine, Designflavr and multiple industry award websites for Deletion of Ciplex WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21458 8355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brett DiBiase User:Shoessss 19:48, 27 August 2009 (UTC) keep As stated in |notability for athelets “…People who have competed at the fully professional level of a sport, or a competition of equivalent standing in a non-league sport such as swimming, golf or tennis” meet our standards for inclusion here at Wikipedia. Since Brett DiBiase|Mr. DiBiase has met that standard, he should be included. Thanks Deletion of Brett DiBiase WP:ATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
21459 19375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sabrina (American singer) User:EdJohnston 19:34, 26 May 2009 (UTC) delete She does not conventionally meet the criteria at . For example, she's just about to release her first CD, while wants multiple CDs on a major label. No national tours or awards Deletion of Sabrina (American singer) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21460 15295 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ennodius User:T8612 19:07, 18 December 2020 (UTC) delete per and . {{ping|Avilich}} Please add the ref to Prosopography of the Later Roman Empire Africa (Roman province)#Later Empire (Dominate)|here Deletion of Ennodius WP:NOTABILITY||WP:NOTGENEALOGY Wikipedia:Notability 77
21461 12957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matt Englett User:onel5969 13:41, 28 April 2016 (UTC) delete Searches did not turn up in-depth coverage to show they pass Deletion of Matt Englett WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21462 16877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/India bashing User:Chaser 03:29, 19 May 2006 (UTC) delete Per , that an article is POV or needs a lot of improvement is not reason enough to delete it. That being said, this article doesn't seem to contain any salvageable content Deletion of India bashing WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21463 21550 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BBC Sport Team User:Eggishorn 05:59, 22 March 2020 (UTC) delete """Fails all of , this is just a collection of poorly-sourced people who have been part of a BBC broadcast for a sporting event at some point. There is not a """"team"""" in any sense of the word in evidence""" Deletion of BBC Sport Team WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
21464 6994 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aidan Burke User:Fiachra10003 18:47, 3 August 2021 (UTC) delete """I looked quite hard for sources of information about the man, but could find nothing other than the Irish Times obituary cited above. On its own, this does not meet a standard of |notability. If he was a senior member of the Irish Civil Service, I could find no record of it, though the expression """"civil servant"""" could have other meanings""" Deletion of Aidan Burke WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
21465 7495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fazaldad User:Yachtsman1 18:50, 1 December 2010 (UTC) delete per nom - fails Deletion of Fazaldad WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21466 7998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Maryland National Guard Recruiting Medal User:SunDawn 09:00, 19 May 2021 (UTC) delete as it is unsourced and not notable. The fact that it is unsourced and can't be verifiable should be grounds for deletion. Use of is inapplicable as we can't have articles that can't adhere to Deletion of Maryland National Guard Recruiting Medal WP:IAR||WP:V Wikipedia:Ignore all rules 59
21467 19 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Pilkington User:Mattythewhite 11:26, 30 January 2012 (UTC) keep Easily passes and . Appears to be a nomination Deletion of Kevin Pilkington WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:POINTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
21468 13865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Graeme Nicholls User:Jeremiah 22:03, 27 October 2008 (UTC) delete We Be the Echo ''might'' be notable, but | notability is not inherited. Fails Deletion of Graeme Nicholls WP:ITSA||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21469 20327 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jnan Pujari User:DBigXray 07:04, 13 September 2019 (UTC) keep passes , #4. Unlike what the nominator thinks, Sahitya Akademi Award is a''' ''major award'' ''' for excellence in Indian language. Sahitya Akademi, India's National Academy of Letters, annually confers on writers of the {{gi|most outstanding books of literary merit}}. In the Assamese language category, the subject won the award for his literary works.https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/guwahati/sahitya-akademi-award-for-four-north-east-writers/articleshow/56112095.cms It is expected that people will be looking for his article. Hence I dont agree that this be deleted Deletion of Jnan Pujari WP:GNG||WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21470 9817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of military disasters (4th nomination) NONE NONE keep There are plenty of sources available for this and so the topic passes . Here's a selection Deletion of List of military disasters (4th nomination) WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
21471 141 [[Ergänzungsfrage]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Proofreader NONE comment Na, selbsterklärend würde ich nicht unbedingt sagen, aber Wörterbuch stimmt schon. , vielleicht wird ja noch was Vernünftiges draus. Was ein Stub ist, steht übrigens hier: #Umfang (Stubs Löschung von Ergänzungsfrage Wikipedia:Artikel Wikipedia:Artikel 90
21472 5244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/XConsortium User:Epinoia 02:14, 6 September 2019 (UTC) delete """does not meet : has not """"received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject"""" - also, Wikipedia:One sentence does not an article make""" Deletion of XConsortium WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21473 20630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francis Baraan IV User:JWilz12345 10:52, 29 August 2020 (UTC) delete per nom. The so-called improvements according to 120.29.66.62 are just cosmetic improvements — https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Francis_Baraan_IV&diff=975486977&oldid=975475047 for one wording fixes in the lead but not providing additional secondary sources: sources that are independent of the subject. Barely heard him on either ABS-CBN or GMA. It seems that warning tag is right: the editors seem to be connected to him. Additionally, the file used — :File:Filipino activist Francis Baraan IV car selfie.jpg, is :Commons:File:Filipino activist Francis Baraan IV car selfie.jpg|to be deleted sooner as it seems an obvious copyright violation: copyright vests in the person who pressed the shutter, not the person who owns or maintains the photo. Ownership and copyright are two different things. Multiple issues mean this article |doesn't warrant its standing in the mainspace Deletion of Francis Baraan IV WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
21474 10695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apple pie shooter User:Vinodbasker 12:55, 6 November 2018 (UTC) delete The article clearly fails as there is no reliable source to suggest the history and preparation of the drink and thus fails notability Deletion of Apple pie shooter WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21475 9996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam C. Winfield User:Geo 18:34, 15 September 2010 (UTC) keep The most important thing missing from is ''wikipedia should not be a hagiography''. Of course Winn is innocent until proven guilty. And, after drafting articles on more than a million individuals I think we should be pretty experienced how to draft a neutrally written article about individuals who face charges, without implying their guilt is a proven fact. Actually, I think the effect of suppressing our neutrally written, properly referenced, non-sensational articles, is directly counter the spirit of BLP, because it leaves our reader to rely on press coverage that is often not neutral, and is written from a sensational point of view Deletion of Adam C. Winfield WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21476 19780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fuck the Facts (album) User:Doomsdayer520 02:31, 25 May 2010 (UTC) comment """we've been through this before. Just because an article is (inaccurately) in the """"Demo Albums"""" category does not mean it is nothing but a demo and should be shot down without the proper |good faith research. This is an '''album''' and should be judged accordingly. I am not voting because the nomination is based on an inapplicable argument, and therefore this AfD is illegitimate""" Deletion of Fuck the Facts (album) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21477 4964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparisons between Superman and Batman User:Markeer 21:56, 12 February 2007 (UTC) delete nearly the definition of original research. I'm certain one could find individual comic books that have a situation where these two characters behaved toward each other in a certain way...but unless one could find an interview with the writer and artist of that comic book, any interpretation of the MEANING of that encounter only exists in the mind of the individual, not in any objective and verifiable state. An article about a psychology textbook that uses Superman and Batman as examples might be excyclopaedic (something like The Simpsons and Philosophy: The D'oh! of Homer) but a straight up article that attempts to determine meaning, psychology and interpretation to these characters is exactly what is intended to avoid Deletion of Comparisons between Superman and Batman WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21478 14218 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 Northern Fury FC season User:Spiderone 11:23, 17 September 2016 (UTC) delete per Deletion of 2014 Northern Fury FC season WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21479 3397 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cypress Creek, Florida User:Hog 23:36, 4 November 2020 (UTC) delete I turned up a road in Ft. Lauderdale, a corporate park in Ft. Lauderdale, some sort of feature in Boynton Beach, Florida, and a park near Lutz, Florida. This article appears to be an attempt to the two Ft. Lauderdale ones into a community Deletion of Cypress Creek, Florida WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21480 5462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Number One (Babylon 5) User:Sgeureka 08:42, 11 November 2019 (UTC) merge """to List of Babylon 5 characters, which didn't follow . This recurring character should be covered ''somewhere''. There is even some real-world info (""""Getting the role"""" section), but it's not expansive enough to justify a separate article. &ndash""" Deletion of Number One (Babylon 5) WP:SUMMARY Wikipedia:Summary style 34
21481 20310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dyertrini User:Lankiveil 11:37, 11 January 2008 (UTC) delete fails . A perfectly fine candidate for CSD A7, if you ask me Deletion of Dyertrini WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21482 16415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Pines, Butte County, California User:Reywas92 05:41, 6 July 2020 (UTC) delete """Part of the Yankee Hill, Butte County, California CDP, near the border of Concow, California. """"A community"""" includes neighborhoods and any cluster of homes, falling under #2, and this lacks significant coverage or legal recognition. ''Butte County Place Names'' is not a unique source of substance, rather here merely listing a name on Topo maps like the GNIS: It just says The Pines is """"NE corner of sect 33"""", section 33 so numbered on https://ngmdb.usgs.gov/ht-bin/tv_browse.pl?id=008a3b711a0e7ec5465381c7cdc45307 this map. https://www.gfusd.org/ Concow Elementary School serves/-d a wide area of Concow and does not belong to just this neighborhood""" Deletion of The Pines, Butte County, California WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
21483 4624 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Isaac Astill NONE NONE delete This page about me was set up years ago by friends and has become a source of embarrassment. I agree that I am not adequately notable as according to . I would like this page to be deleted Deletion of Isaac Astill WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21484 4418 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Halloweentown: She's the Witch User:FisherQueen 20:19, 17 July 2007 (UTC) delete It doesn't seem to have been through AfD before, so db-repost doesn't apply, but delete nevertheless per , with no prejudice against recreation when and if there is something to say on the subject Deletion of Halloweentown: She's the Witch WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21485 21027 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kickin' 14 User:Joe 22:48, 4 June 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |compilation album Deletion of Kickin' 14 WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21486 18320 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jasmine Murray NONE NONE keep """Passes multiple criteria in usic, most importantly #9: """"Has won or placed in a major music competition."""" American Idol is one of the biggest music competitions""" Deletion of Jasmine Murray WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
21487 14450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Himalayan Welfare Organization, Pahalgam (2nd nomination) User:Cewbot 00:03, 13 November 2020 (UTC) comment While this discussion appears to have |no quorum, it is '''NOT eligible for |soft deletion''' because it was Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Himalayan Welfare Organization, Pahalgam|previously discussed at AfD and the result was no consensus Deletion of Himalayan Welfare Organization, Pahalgam (2nd nomination) WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
21488 2161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robin Speziale User:Qworty 07:05, 11 January 2011 (UTC) delete Fails , , and Deletion of Robin Speziale WP:AUTHOR||WP:BK||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21489 1091 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Squidbillies characters User:J947 22:31, 31 December 2019 (UTC) delete just a whole bunch of unsourced unencyclopedic information which does not seem to pass |GNG or |LISTN. Could merge to a new section at Squidbillies but none of this content is actually appropriate for merging given that it is |original research. '''Happy New Year Deletion of List of Squidbillies characters WP:GNG||WP:LISTN||WP:OR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21490 2386 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/StarFighter: Quadrant Wars User:RGTraynor 15:26, 6 July 2007 (UTC) delete I just went through each and every unique Google hit on this game (given that there are only 44, it didn't take ''that'' long). Not a single one of them is from a reliable source. For all the SPA partisans claim that they can source this article to reliable sources -- and for the record, we're talking major gaming magazines, mass media, and the like -- they've yet to do so. The game's website isn't even on the Alexa chart. I'm quite willing to believe that there are a dozen fanatics who demonstrably really love this game, but I'm waiting for anyone to state the criteria at or this obscure game meets Deletion of StarFighter: Quadrant Wars WP:V||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21491 17280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melinda Hill User:Tomwsulcer 02:24, 30 November 2015 (UTC) keep Notable performer, talented, she https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jYYQcCLtK1M appeared on the Craig Ferguson show. My unofficial test of pageviews is averaging about 30/40 per day, sometimes spiking, http://stats.grok.se/en/latest90/Melinda_Hill here, and while of course it is unofficial, for me it usually is an indication of notability. Some coverage http://www.nj.com/entertainment/tv/index.ssf/2012/08/americas_got_talent_2012_youtu.html here, but sources in article now, such as http://www.laweekly.com/calendar/make-us-laugh-funny-girl-melinda-hill-2164568 this ind-depth one, and http://www.sandiego.com/articles/2011-03-08/interview-melinda-hill this one suggest she meets the although admittedly there is a much extra junk in the article Deletion of Melinda Hill WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21492 16469 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doc Halo User:davidwr 21:58, 27 December 2013 (UTC) delete without prejudice to a well-sourced version being written if sources can be found that demonstrate notability. I've commented on the existing references on the article talk page. There is a hint that we ''should'' be able to find enough references to demonstrate notability, but even the original author, who used presumably due to a , didn't put them in Deletion of Doc Halo WP:AFC||WP:COI Wikipedia:Articles for creation 55
21493 20189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Liebrecht User:SynergeticMaggot 00:09, 3 August 2006 (UTC) delete Fails . Will change to keep if article gets sourced properly (contact me via talk page Deletion of Jason Liebrecht WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21494 14172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/C9 Entertainment User:Sjakkalle 17:36, 28 August 2017 (UTC) delete due to lack of independent coverage. The content is directory type content, and is relevant Deletion of C9 Entertainment WP:YELLOWPAGES Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21495 338 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Holmen High School User:Alansohn 11:31, 21 March 2007 (UTC) comment Just like filing a lawsuit, anybody can start an AfD for any reason valid or invalid, and they usually do. The reality is that many of the articles listed at Wikipedia:WikiProject_Deletion_sorting/Schools were perfect examples of articles that had already demonstrated notability, or could be (and were) improved to further demonstrate notability. The fact that you and others have decided to nominate schools for deletion is no indication of the merit of these AfDs. I have expanded this article and other similar articles because they deserve to be retained. I never attended Holmen High School, I'm not even quite sure where it's located. But I do know that the article has multiple, non-trivial |reliable and |verifiable sources to demonstrate notability Deletion of Holmen High School WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21496 17634 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Symbolic Manipulation Program User:XOR 22:02, 17 March 2021 (UTC) keep and rename to SMP (computer algebra system), as suggested below. Seems to be a example now Deletion of Symbolic Manipulation Program WP:HEYMANN Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
21497 15256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nerissa Bowes-Lyon User:Edison 02:41, 7 June 2011 (UTC) delete Fails . Notability is |not inherited. Utterly nonnotable, though unfortunate, person Deletion of Nerissa Bowes-Lyon WP:BIO||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21498 11022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Criticism of Sunni Islam User:Markeer 16:15, 21 September 2010 (UTC) delete per . In style and tone, this article demonstrates that it exists solely to express a point of view, at least in it's current form. While I would certainly think issues of divergence and/or disagreement between the two sects are of encyclopaedic importance, they appear to already be sufficiently addressed in the main article on Islam and more specifically in the very well researched article on Shi'a–Sunni relations Deletion of Criticism of Sunni Islam WP:NOTSOAPBOX Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21499 13178 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brian Rose (podcaster) User:Joseph2302 11:58, 2 February 2021 (UTC) keep passes , as rightly or wrongly, he's the most talked about London mayoral candidate right now Deletion of Brian Rose (podcaster) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21500 5169 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Onses User:Bearcat 14:01, 7 February 2021 (UTC) delete """Nothing stated in the article is """"inherently"""" notable enough to exempt him from actually having to clear on his sources: businesspeople are not automatically notable just because they exist, writers are not automatically notable just because their writing technically metaverifies its own existence, unsuccessful political candidates are not automatically notable just because it's possible to verify their vote totals, and on and so forth. The article is not well-sourced, and nothing stated in the article body hands him an automatic notability freebie in the absence of much better sourcing than this""" Deletion of Richard Onses WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21501 147 [[Luger (Fußballspieler)]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Sänger NONE delete Aktuell komplett informationsfreier Nichtikel, der mit |unbrauchbare Fanseiten als Quelle aus einer einmaligen Erwähnung hingepfuscht wurde. Sobald tatsächlich reputable Quellen auftauchen, in denen mehr als der nichtssagende Listeneintrag steht, kann gerne eine LP angestoßen werden. So wäre das selbst eines Fanwiki unwürdig. Grüße vom Löschung von Luger (Fußballspieler) Wikipedia:Q Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21502 20901 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NLT (band) User:Nosleep 23:50, 14 May 2009 (UTC) keep The members are not on their own notable. Kevin Michael McHale wound up being deleted (though it could easily redirect to the band, which is what I suggested for Justin Joseph Thorne). Charting in the Top 40, though, definitely should satisfy Deletion of NLT (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
21503 17931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Slender Man (2nd nomination) User:RJHall 18:52, 20 July 2011 (UTC) comment mdash;I have to agree that this article lacks suitable citations needed to satisfy WP:GNG. Blogs are typically unsuitable, per . I was unable to find more reliable citations. Hence, I can't support a keep. Regards Deletion of Slender Man (2nd nomination) WP:USERGENERATED Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21504 1041 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeAndre Harris User:power 16:59, 20 October 2017 (UTC) comment I feel that having a >200K article on Unite the Right rally is excessive to the point of absurdity, but I'm clearly in the minority on that point. Having a sub-article based on this is reasonable if there's no consensus that the existing article is Deletion of DeAndre Harris WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
21505 6176 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Personal Trainers User:Joe 15:03, 1 May 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |film series Deletion of Personal Trainers WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21506 12279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xoy Ceremony User:I 00:06, 1 July 2011 (UTC) delete I found http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=D6PrqVKaZtgC&pg=PA1148&dq=xooy+ceremony&hl=en&ei=4Q4NTvKmMvDgsQKvtoW-Cg&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CDAQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=xooy%20ceremony&f=false this in Google Books. So, with one of the various spellings provided, we (might) assume it is real. However, this ceremony does not meet Deletion of Xoy Ceremony WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21507 9010 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grace A. Dow Memorial Library User:Nick 10:11, 11 June 2008 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet and . The NYT story is about this town and briefly mentions a news conference which was held in the library, and isn't about the library itself. Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indian Valley Public Library is a relevant previous AfD Deletion of Grace A. Dow Memorial Library WP:N||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21508 19997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti-globalization and antisemitism (5th nomination) User:Simon 14:50, 29 January 2009 (UTC) comment """The issue of was raised and specifically addressed in the third nomination. A user there rejoined: """"It's definitely not a SYN violation as someone suggested. When I last checked, the sources specifically discussed anti-globalization and antisemitism"""" (SlimVirgin, 01:36, 11 March 2008). What has changed since then to make that response unsound? And could you give one or two ''specific'' examples of the article's supposed syns? - Simon Dodd""" Deletion of Anti-globalization and antisemitism (5th nomination) WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
21509 17674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ScrewAttack (2nd nomination) User:DrStrauss 13:50, 12 September 2017 (UTC) delete the keep !vote above is based on the fact that ScrewAttack is |part of something notable which doesn't confer notability because notability isn't inherited. A quick https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=%22ScrewAttack%22&rlz=1C1CHBD_en-GBGB755GB755&oq=%22ScrewAttack%22&aqs=chrome..69i57j0l5.1028j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 source search reveals nothing other than fancruft, self-published sources and affiliated media outlets. There are no independent, reliable reviews which give any indication of the article passing |web notability standards. I am opposed to a merge because after looking at the article of the parent company, there is little sourced, encyclopedic content that can be merged. Perhaps a redirect may be the way to go but it's definitely not up to notability or verifiability standards Deletion of ScrewAttack (2nd nomination) WP:NOTINHERITED||WP:NWEB Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21510 16703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Towel Depot User:Kinu 05:20, 21 August 2006 (UTC) delete due to lack of that company meets Deletion of The Towel Depot WP:V||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21511 21930 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hollywood undead User:Ohconfucius 09:19, 16 May 2007 (UTC) delete A band that's signed even by a major label but doesn't put anything out or don't tour still fails , so just because it's the first to be signed by myspace records, it's no big deal. |High on promise, but nothing since they signed. Agree with above: all the articles are about myspace records, and are trivial mentions of the band, so fails Deletion of Hollywood undead WP:MUSIC||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21512 6586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Carr (baseball) User:Dirtlawyer1 01:27, 24 November 2012 (UTC) delete Non-notable minor league baseball player. Subject never played in a MLB game and is therefore not entitled to a presumption of notability per , and I find no depth of coverage that satisfies the general notability guidelines per . I might also add that the article is completely lacking in any references whatsoever, and is a violation in its present condition Deletion of Adam Carr (baseball) WP:NBASEBALL||WP:GNG||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21513 16452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ramsay Wood User:Paulmcdonald 19:33, 23 September 2016 (UTC) delete although my google search did turn up a few reports in the news, they did not seem to be providing anything of note or even writing about the subject of this article but just that they were attending a different event. I do not see passing or any other notability measure. I would change my position if sources were shown or were more clear to me Deletion of Ramsay Wood WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21514 17212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ay bendito User:Cerejota 03:55, 2 August 2007 (UTC) delete """WP:NOT#DICT| This is not a dictionary and we must not engage in |original research, proposal to '''merge''' is enticing, but Puerto Rican Spanish has very serious OR and |verifiability issues itself, and merging would simply add more OR into it. I say """"Ay bendito"""" every day, but this doesn't mean anything, as I am not a reliable source: please see Oh my God (specifically here http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log/delete&page=Oh_my_God. Thanks""" Deletion of Ay bendito WP:OR||WP:V Wikipedia:No original research 65
21515 15806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Burton (footballer) User:Michaelzeng7 20:07, 3 January 2013 (UTC) delete per nom. It's a borderline |A7 too Deletion of Paul Burton (footballer) WP:A7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
21516 114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrew Pitt User:Cactus 20:10, 31 January 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Very low unique Google hits, and seems to fail for living persons: (''Painters .... whose work is recognized as exceptional and likely to become a part of the enduring historical record of that field.'') Also, two of the external links provided appear to be to his own site Deletion of Andrew Pitt WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21517 7464 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aron Wright User:Bait30 19:15, 24 February 2020 (UTC) comment Does Miami Valley College count as a major academic institution per #6 of ? The school existed from 1870 to 1883, and I don't know how accreditation worked back then Deletion of Aron Wright WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21518 10023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bo Sullivan (2nd nomination) User:Rusf10 18:39, 29 December 2017 (UTC) comment """Most of the coverage of Sullivan seems to be related to his failed campaign. The precedent for this is """"Losing candidates for office below the national level who are otherwise non-notable are generally deleted."""" see """ Deletion of Bo Sullivan (2nd nomination) WP:POLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21519 12898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lekhraj Bugaliya User:Curb 11:51, 30 July 2019 (UTC) delete Pure promo. Fails . COI editor Deletion of Lekhraj Bugaliya WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21520 19514 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xacrox User:That NONE delete as |non-notable band. &mdash Deletion of Xacrox WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21521 4985 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hangry User:The 17:47, 8 August 2010 (UTC) delete per |NOTDICT and total failure of ; a local website and Urbandictionary.com (although the latter is quite amusing) are not nearly enough notability Deletion of Hangry WP:NOTDICT||WP:V Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21522 121 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Tolga Salman Kullanıcı:tema tema 23:20, 14 Temmuz 2007 (UTC) keep """Mach'ın uyarısına ve Metal Militia'nın haklı görüşlerine rağmen çok daha büyük sorunlar içeren, örneğin taslak bile olmayan birçok maddeyi düşünerek """"Kalsın"""" diyorum""" Tolga Salman'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:Otobiyografi Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
21523 11116 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Music community User:Francis 05:41, 14 August 2015 (UTC) delete """see also my comments at Wikipedia:Neutral point of view/Noticeboard#Music community: '''''' while entirely based on |primary sources (thesises and the like), and putting the content of these primary sources together in an """"original"""" fashion. The only two ''secondary'' sources in the article don't use the expression """"music community"""", not even once""" Deletion of Music community WP:OR||WP:PRIMARY Wikipedia:No original research 65
21524 18368 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Actuarial Society of Turkey User:Sionk 21:29, 29 July 2012 (UTC) delete unsourced, no evidence it has received enough in-depth news coverage to pass . Though if someone knows enough Turkish to find sources in Turkish (I can't see any), I'll consider changing my recommendation. The article on http://tr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akt%C3%BCerya Turkish Wikipedia is equally unsourced Deletion of Actuarial Society of Turkey WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21525 20 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Critical Mass (band) User:Crunk 03:10, 24 November 2006 (UTC) delete fails usic, and ''clearly'' fails Deletion of Critical Mass (band) WP:M||WP:COI Wikipedia:Mediation 96
21526 16013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grace Evangelical Lutheran Church (Buffalo, New York) User:Bearian 19:06, 19 November 2020 (UTC) delete per nom, , and Deletion of Grace Evangelical Lutheran Church (Buffalo, New York) WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
21527 2759 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Financial democracy User:COMPFUNK2 00:56, 29 September 2009 (UTC) delete Interesting essay, but |Wikipedia is not a soapbox Deletion of Financial democracy WP:SOAP Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21528 298 [[Bohuslav Vlček]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Firefly's luciferase NONE delete Nach #Wissenschaftler bin ich momentan auch der Meinung, dass die dargestellte Relevanz nicht ausreicht. Es fehlt insbesondere ein Nachweis von Preisen und auch der übrigen wissenschaftlichen Rezeption durch Dritte. Aktuell ist es hauptsächlich ein Lebenslauf mit Publikationsliste (was gem. der RK-Liste ebenso nicht genügt). Sehr stossend ist der Link auf die externe Seite, was als Werbung betrachtet werden kann und den ganzen Artikel in ein schiefes Licht bezüglich NPOV stellt. Zumindest in der aktuellen Form . Den externen werbenden Link auch bei Behalten bitte löschen Löschung von Bohuslav Vlček Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
21529 8164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of monuments and memorials of Joseph Smith, Jr. User:Gavin 12:45, 30 April 2010 (UTC) delete as the creation entirely novel list topics without a verifiable definition contravenes the prohibition on #OR|original research as illustrated by . As far as I can see, this list, or anything like it, has not be been published anywhere except within Wikipedia, so there is no evidence that it is verifiable, let alone notable. To demonstrate that this topic was not created based on editor's own idea, a verifiable definition is needed to provide external validation that this list complies with |content policy Deletion of List of monuments and memorials of Joseph Smith, Jr. WP:NOT||WP:MADEUP||WP:CONPOL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21530 15133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SuccessTech Academy shooting (2nd nomination) User:Shoyrudude555 00:56, 12 October 2007 (UTC) keep It is our job as Wikipedians to report what the media thinks is |notable, whether or not we think it is notable Deletion of SuccessTech Academy shooting (2nd nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21531 14781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harold Jensen Christopher User:TimothyBlue 07:18, 25 January 2021 (UTC) merge """to USS Christopher per above. Doesn't pass for a stand alone article, but the content will improve the target article, be less fragmented, and give the content more readership. Per , ''""""Editors may use their discretion to merge or group two or more related topics into a single article.""""'' The article as a stand alone will receive minimal readership, but as part of the target will receive much more. There is no benefit to fragmenting the content. I ce'd the article to help with the merge. // """ Deletion of Harold Jensen Christopher WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21532 15161 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sackler Center for Arts Education User:Ad 19:54, 22 August 2014 (UTC) comment Fine. If it will satisfy our legalistic impulses I will not object to a procedural close to the AfD. I will however, immediately renominate the article based on my observations above. It appears that |common sense is out to lunch Deletion of Sackler Center for Arts Education WP:COMMONSENSE "Wikipedia:What ""Ignore all rules"" means" 62
21533 12149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The First Podcast User:Sergecross73 03:56, 18 December 2018 (UTC) delete I don’t see anything here or at the article that proves it meets the , and the sole “keep” !vote so far has a pretty obvious |conflict of interest Deletion of The First Podcast WP:GNG||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
21534 20659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Raphals User:XOR 16:20, 2 May 2019 (UTC) keep Passes by way of multiple reviews of multiple books. In the humanities (as in law and pure mathematics, to name a couple other fields), Google Scholar counts are typically unilluminating. Given Raphals' field, reviews are the first place I'd look for a pass of #C1. I think that she succeeds on that, as well. I suppose that the COI could be an issue in principle, but given the respectable academic-bio-stub nature of the current article, it doesn't seem to have mattered in practice Deletion of Lisa Raphals WP:AUTHOR||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21535 6980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Yeldell User:LinguistAtLarge 07:33, 15 December 2008 (UTC) delete unfortunately. I can't find anything to prove notability for an author, per . Deletion of Jason Yeldell WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21536 10663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Suelyn Medeiros (2nd nomination) User:KarasuGamma 08:28, 05 May 2019 (UTC) delete Fails , , and . — Deletion of Suelyn Medeiros (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:CREATIVE||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21537 4330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zeemon User:Malkinann 00:11, 10 October 2010 (UTC) merge to Challenge_of_the_GoBots#Characters per Deletion of Zeemon WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21538 15998 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Auerbach (2nd nomination) User:Ylevental 17:30, 14 April 2016 (UTC) delete Does not meet Deletion of David Auerbach (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21539 16114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Climate Action Plan NONE NONE keep or possibly '''Merge''' by incorporating List of climate change initiatives here and having it redirect here, rather than vice-versa for reasons explained in my second paragraph). The page started out as a disambiguation page, and I could see there should be no problem developing it into a full article. Based on the fact numerous cites have them and use the same name, I had no doubt there was to be found, and I found a couple of journal articles and added them, but did not have time to include the abundant material in just those two articles. As stated above others are aware of more RS on the subject, so this article will no doubt eventually grow and be fully fleshed out from its recent infancy of a disambiguation page Deletion of Climate Action Plan WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21540 15537 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pritam kashyap User:Ammarpad NONE delete doesn't meet as searches yielded nothing Independent. I intended to move it back to draft space, but I understand this is possible autobiography, big possibility. All references are link to his social media pages and same username as article and the tone of the article prove this even more '' —'' Deletion of Pritam kashyap WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21541 21734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sportlobster (2nd nomination) User:Piotrus 08:38, 11 December 2017 (UTC) delete The coverage is poor, outside press releases we have interviews and that's about it. The 'article' in The National is a de facto interview too. I don't think this suffices for this to pass / Deletion of Sportlobster (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21542 2421 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Tabone User:Angelo 15:42, 20 October 2008 (UTC) delete """Maltese League is ''not'' fully professional, and playing the UEFA Cup qualifiers is way different than taking part in the full competition - even San Marino and Andorra teams compete in the qualifiers, and their players easily fail . In short, none of the competitions above (Malta Premier League and UEFA Cup Qualifiers) confer notability. About the """"reliable sources"""" provided by another user, they are: a personal blog, an article taken from the club website (definitely not a independent source), a Playerhistory.com page (a website that covers also non-notable subjects from several minor league teams, such as San Marino and the English Conference). The other two sources, taken from two Maltese newspaper websites, do not cover the subject in detail, but instead refer to him in a somewhat marginal way. So, he does not meet """ Deletion of Alan Tabone WP:N||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21543 13293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chiara Passa User:Zackmann08 19:32, 21 October 2016 (UTC) comment For any admins, the only ''keep'' votes up to this point are the page creator and their /. User has been engaged in widespread to make sure the page is kept Deletion of Chiara Passa WP:SOCK||WP:MEAT||WP:CANVASSING Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
21544 13171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wolfe Perry User:Peter303x 02:04, 20 January 2021 (UTC) keep Meets Deletion of Wolfe Perry WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21545 4419 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Rubik's Cube software User:Sebwite 01:54, 23 September 2008 (UTC) delete per , but first move whatever is notable to Rubik's Cube Deletion of List of Rubik's Cube software WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21546 538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Thein User:MelanieN 01:04, 18 December 2011 (UTC) delete """Sounds like an up-and-coming young man, but it's a case of . Maybe he will go on to greater heights than representative on a small munipical council and officer in a youth organization. If so, we can have an article about him then. BTW I see that the author of the article, in removing the PROD, said he is on the council of """"one of the biggest municipalities in Luxembourg"""". That may be so, but it still took only 403 votes to elect him. Per he will have to achieve national office before he gets an article here""" Deletion of Joe Thein WP:TOOSOON||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Too soon 40
21547 16085 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adrienne deWolfe User:Tokyogirl79 04:46, 18 January 2014 (UTC) delete After a search, I couldn't really find anything that would show that deWolfe passes . I'd initially thought she had won a RT award, but she hasn't. (http://www.rtbookreviews.com/author/adrienne-de-wolfe) deWolfe was only nominated. The Calico Trails Magazine doesn't really seem to be the type of place where an award would mean anything on here, not even partial notability. Now a RWA award does help, but the problem is that this is a ''chapter'' award and not an award given from the larger organization, which does make a huge difference. That makes this the type of award that would give a little notability but isn't something that would give a huge amount of notability. In the end all we have are a handful of reviews from one location (RT) and a review from a local chapter of RWA. There's just not enough here to show a depth of coverage enough to where she'd pass. If anyone can dig anything up, that's great. I'll edit the article in the meantime to remove all of the puffery and clearly promotional intent in anticipation of someone finding something Deletion of Adrienne deWolfe WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21548 2923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AVN Award for All-Girl Performer of the Year User:SSTflyer 08:11, 11 September 2016 (UTC) merge to AVN Award, per Deletion of AVN Award for All-Girl Performer of the Year WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
21549 10875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steve Pavlina (4th nomination) User:Finngall 21:22, 6 October 2020 (UTC) comment Discussion page was created without the {{tl|afd2}} template and not transcluded to a daily log. Fixed now--I have not yet formed an opinion of my own at this time. {{ping|Danihan}} If you wish to nominate other articles for deletion in the future, please take care to more fully follow the instructions at . Thank you Deletion of Steve Pavlina (4th nomination) WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21550 3136 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Teo User:XOR 15:27, 20 April 2018 (UTC) comment Not working in psychology myself, I'm not the best positioned to judge, but I suspect that Teo's corner of academia is a comparatively low-cited field, so his https://scholar.google.ca/citations?user=vNKpI-EAAAAJ&hl=en/ GS h-index of 18 might count substantially towards passing #C1. In addition, he https://www.theoreticalpsychology.org/journal edited the ''Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology'' (and remains a https://www.apa.org/pubs/journals/teo/index.aspx?tab=2 consulting editor). Scopus ranks this journal in the https://www.scopus.com/sourceid/19500157012?origin=sbrowse#tabs=1 86th percentile of philosophy journals, citation-wise, so his editorship might count towards passing #C8. If kept, the article would definitely need de-promotionalization, but that's routine for academic biographies, and sources affiliated with the subject are considered acceptable for uncontroversial claims (e.g., where they attended school Deletion of Thomas Teo WP:PROF||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21551 19175 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Kelly (rugby league) User:Icalanise 02:22, 30 January 2011 (UTC) delete per and unsourced Deletion of Richard Kelly (rugby league) WP:V||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21552 16914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oxford University Light Entertainment Society User:MER 03:28, 16 November 2006 (UTC) delete http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=%22Oxford+University+Light+Entertainment+Society%22+-wikipedia&btnG=Search 55 non-wiki ghits, quite a lot of which are from Oxford websites. Nothing else of interest found, leading to |verifiability problems Deletion of Oxford University Light Entertainment Society WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21553 559 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cassey Ho (2nd nomination) User:The 07:35, 28 April 2014 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Cassey Ho (2nd nomination) WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21554 17189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rodrigo Hernando User:GiantSnowman 11:19, 26 October 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Rodrigo Hernando WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21555 6482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mbenznl User:Stifle 11:09, 26 September 2008 (UTC) delete Lots of links, very little of Deletion of Mbenznl WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21556 18395 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CAT1-X Hyperion Gundam series User:TheEmulatorGuy 01:18, 3 December 2006 (UTC) comment """You don't seem to understand what I am basing this on. """"Useless"""" is not my opinion, it is a gathered opinion based on the various policies and guidelines these articles violate. I have already given them many times, as have a few other users. Upon your claim of """"resource of information, regardless of spurious guidelines"""", I invite you to give me any policy showing this. I suggest you read , because it is a POLICY showing what Wikipedia is NOT - it just happens to include the Gundam articles that a few people wish to keep for their own personal reasons""" Deletion of CAT1-X Hyperion Gundam series WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21557 19959 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cash Suvidha User:Cwmhiraeth 09:31, 9 January 2017 (UTC) delete Start-up company that currently fails Deletion of Cash Suvidha WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21558 15459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wavedash Games User:K 05:15, 17 August 2017 (UTC) delete WP:PROMO with a good doze of . A company with a small round of funding; article likely created for promotional purposes Deletion of Wavedash Games WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
21559 21357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joel Weiner User:Pontificalibus 22:30, 20 April 2010 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet . Not everyone who appears on TV and has Facebook Fans needs an encyclopedia article Deletion of Joel Weiner WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21560 17540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GameTZ.com (2nd nom) User:Nihonjoe 06:24, 17 May 2007 (UTC) keep as bad faith nom by possible |SPA. Nominator has done little other than nominating this and one other article for deletion. The article clearly establishes notability as shown in the Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2007 February 14|DRV discussion Deletion of GameTZ.com (2nd nom) WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
21561 8736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iran's 2018 prisoner swap proposal to the United States User:ChrisWar666 06:37, 1 December 2019 (UTC) delete as I don't think there's enough to go into the relations article. At most one line if you insist on erge|merging (although this 'proposal' came after the Ayatollah banned direct talks Deletion of Iran's 2018 prisoner swap proposal to the United States WP:M Wikipedia:Mediation 96
21562 19670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Feldman (boxer) User:Papaursa 00:12, 14 July 2014 (UTC) delete Boxrec shows him with a total of 5 fights. He doesn't meet the notability requirements of or have the coverage required by Deletion of David Feldman (boxer) WP:NBOX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21563 21750 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Comparison of X Window System desktop environments User:Widefox 16:33, 16 September 2018 (UTC) keep Speedy Keep''', can be improved so . There's sources above for the comparison and I see no reason to take out of mainspace to improve, it's been there since 2006. ( disclaimer - this is only like Comparison of X window managers Deletion of Comparison of X Window System desktop environments WP:SURMOUNTABLE||WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21564 12484 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Immediate Family Records User:Whiteguru 20:30, 23 February 2021 (UTC) delete Does not meet notability Deletion of Immediate Family Records WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21565 5361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canadian Equal Parenting Council User:Martinogk 12:25, 1 March 2019 (UTC) keep Per (i) As a federation of local affiliates, the organization has national scope, with media mentions across both urban and rural Canada, including e.g. Montreal, Toronto, Ottawa, Winnipeg, Calgary, Windsor, Saint John, Yellowknife, Barrie, Oshawa, Alliston and Portage La Prairie. (ii) Coverage in multiple reliable media sources, many but not all by independent journalists, and significant in the sense that the organization is cited in articles about the topic on which it is active rather than passing mentions in articles about something else. (iii) Some international coverage. (iv) Additional newspaper, academic, book and web sources exist, but the article already has citation overkill Deletion of Canadian Equal Parenting Council WP:NONPROFIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21566 18302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Baba Zumbi (2nd nomination) User:Hobbes 04:30, 3 December 2011 (UTC) delete There is Zion I coverage out there, but cannot find much substantial and for Baba Zumbi himself. All of http://www.last.fm/music/Baba+Zumbi 99 total listeners on last.fm suggests I'm not overlooking sources, but if I am, please provide and I will look again Deletion of Baba Zumbi (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21567 969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pikmin 3: Invasion of the Pikmin Planet User:Doc 02:53, 30 March 2008 (UTC) delete It's either a |hoax or wishful thinking by a fan of the series (which makes it fanfiction and/or fancruft which is still unecyclopedic anyhow Deletion of Pikmin 3: Invasion of the Pikmin Planet WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
21568 6189 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United States presidential election, 2024 (2nd nomination) User:Iamozy 15:35, 24 May 2016 (UTC) keep """per , which clearly states: """"It is appropriate to report discussion and arguments about the prospects for success of future proposals and projects or whether some development will occur, if discussion is properly referenced... Predictions, speculation, forecasts and theories stated by reliable, expert sources or recognized entities in a field may be included."""" As long as reliable sources are used, this article should stay""" Deletion of United States presidential election, 2024 (2nd nomination) WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21569 21698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Destiney Sue Moore User:Quackslikeaduck 18:59, 21 January 2009 (UTC) keep Unlike Jes Rickleff, Destiney Sue Moore passes ntertainer because she has had significant roles in multiple notable television shows, namely Rock of Love with Bret Michaels (season 2)|Rock of Love, I Love Money (Season 1)|I Love Money, and Rock of Love: Charm School|Charm School. The article, however, needs serious work. It has no references to any |reliable sources and is filled with |POV Deletion of Destiney Sue Moore WP:E||WP:RS||WP:POV Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
21570 7258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/XXXO User:Decltype 19:25, 12 May 2010 (UTC) keep Has been released, and has enough |RS coverage to warrant a stand-alone article Deletion of XXXO WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21571 5871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shelley Breen User:Tapered 01:28, 14 March 2017 (UTC) merge to Point of Grace. Only dedicated article I found is about her house in a specialist journal There are mentions in articles about Points of Grace, but only isn't . Lacks , but since google search gets significant hits, redirect to band's article Deletion of Shelley Breen WP:TRIVIAL||WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21572 8461 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magical nonfiction User:jmason888 07:07, 19 December 2005 (UTC) delete as |complete bollocks, unless we want to send this to for translation from Bullshit into English Language|English Deletion of Magical nonfiction WP:BALLS||WP:PNT Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
21573 19695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dale Baumwoll User:Student7 00:58, 18 December 2010 (UTC) delete Person is not notable. Wrote two books, which do not appear to have received critical acclaim. She appears to support herself by teaching, where she has apparently won some awards. A fine person, I am sure, but just not particularly noteworthy or notable. Presence here seems for the books Deletion of Dale Baumwoll WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
21574 19619 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Co-Ed Confidential User:Arxiloxos 21:20, 23 October 2011 (UTC) keep """A long-running series on a national TV networkhttp://articles.latimes.com/2010/may/10/entertainment/la-et-cable-porn-20100510, and one of the hallmark shows of the """"Skinemax"""" programming slatehttp://www.foxnews.com/entertainment/2011/02/14/cinemax-looking-movie-away-skin-emax-tag/http://heraldnet.com/article/20100317/BLOG08/703179867/0/NEWS01, this show passes """ Deletion of Co-Ed Confidential WP:TVSERIES Wikipedia:Notability 77
21575 12357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional revolutions and coups [[User talk:192.76.8.81|talk]]) 01:48, 17 November 2020 (UTC) delete per nom. The single source used in this 60k article appears to be a blog, so basically all the content here appears to be . Even if sources can be found discussing this concept as a group to satisfy I think what is currently here is a good candidate for . Special:Contributions/192.76.8.81|192.76.8.81 Deletion of List of fictional revolutions and coups WP:OR||WP:LISTN||WP:TNT Wikipedia:No original research 65
21576 2886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Catholic leaders and politicians User:Useight 17:59, 24 July 2007 (UTC) delete as violation of #LINK and, I agree, this should be done via category, because it's kind of an intersection between two unrelated topics Deletion of List of Catholic leaders and politicians WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21577 8340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dawn Brancheau NONE NONE keep but per move over redirect to Death of Dawn Brancheau, trimming the biographical information that's unrelated to the event itself. I recognize that the event is covered in Tilikum (orca)#Third death, but enough has been written about this particular death to justify a separate article Deletion of Dawn Brancheau WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21578 21607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Hogg User:LM2000 07:59, 1 March 2018 (UTC) keep There's a degree of in arguing that coverage will go on into the future but I'm more inclined to believe that it well continue based on the CNN interview he did with Dan Rather. We can always revisit if that doesn't happen Deletion of David Hogg WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21579 12254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jodi Arias: Dirty Little Secret User:SL93 23:22, 16 June 2013 (UTC) keep Passes in its current state Deletion of Jodi Arias: Dirty Little Secret WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21580 523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nathan Parsons User:Bigdaddy1981 00:30, 28 May 2009 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Nathan Parsons WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21581 3375 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eugene Puryear NONE NONE keep """spaced ndash}}Per , (within Wikipedia:Notability (people)) """"...multiple independent sources may be combined to demonstrate notability""" Deletion of Eugene Puryear WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21582 2772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seth Fleetwood User:Bearcat 16:35, 4 April 2021 (UTC) delete Bellingham WA is not a large or significant enough city to extend its mayors an automatic presumption of notability in the absence of a properly demonstrated pass of #2, cities don't get special exemptions from NPOL just because their population cracks 50K or because of their geographical locations per se, and this relies mainly on |primary sources rather than any significant volume of |reliable source coverage for the purposes of getting him past NPOL #2 Deletion of Seth Fleetwood WP:NPOL||WP:PRIMARYSOURCES||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21583 6849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Surrey User:Beagel 14:48, 26 March 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of bus routes in Surrey WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21584 3540 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greg Laughery NONE NONE keep I admit that I was at first skeptical about this gentleman's notability; however I have managed to uncover some relevant source information, which if included in a revision of the Article, would lead me to support keeping it (per and Deletion of Greg Laughery WP:AUTHOR||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21585 18659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manchester Township Middle School User:Edison 18:41, 27 December 2011 (UTC) merge per #Schools. Does not appear to satisfy the applicable notability guideline, . Wikipedia is |not a directory of every thing that exists or which previously existed which fails to satisfy the notability guidelines Deletion of Manchester Township Middle School WP:OUTCOMES||WP:ORG||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21586 20720 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leslie Kanes Weisman User:Pharaoh 21:22, 3 December 2020 (UTC) keep per and Deletion of Leslie Kanes Weisman WP:AUTHOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21587 1413 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jocelyne Couture-Nowak (4th nomination) User:BRMo 22:27, 24 July 2007 (UTC) keep """This biography clearly meets Wikipedia's |notability guideline: """"A topic is presumed to be notable if it has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject."""" The article cites a number of reliable, national news sources. Notability is not a personal """"achievement""""; it is a recognition that enough information on the subject has been published in reliable secondary sources to support an encyclopedia article""" Deletion of Jocelyne Couture-Nowak (4th nomination) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21588 11280 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Land Far Away User:Avraham 03:43, 3 November 2006 (UTC) keep In the NWN world, ALFA is very notable, predating NWN, and having more than a little say in NWN's development as well as other Bioware titles. It is still the most selective and developed 24-7 NWN persistent universe in cyberspace. See it's talk page for more. I could add stuff from personal experience, but that would be Deletion of A Land Far Away WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21589 6360 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omise (Company) (2nd nomination) User:Paul 14:08, 18 May 2019 (UTC) comment """There's considerable amount of coverage by the ''Bangkok Post''https://www.bangkokpost.com/business/news/1591510/hitting-pay-dirt-with-paymentshttps://www.bangkokpost.com/business/news/1297839/omisegohttps://www.bangkokpost.com/tech/local-news/1282371/e-payment-deal-defies-tax-plan and tech news sites TechCrunchhttps://techcrunch.com/2016/07/20/omise-lands-17-5m-series-b-to-expand-its-stripe-like-service-in-southeast-asia/https://techcrunch.com/2017/09/27/omise-krungsri/https://techcrunch.com/2017/07/05/omise-paysbuy-dtac/https://techcrunch.com/2017/07/05/omise-go-ico-25-million-omg/https://techcrunch.com/2017/05/30/omise-to-raise-19m-in-first-cryptocurrency-sale-from-a-major-vc-backed-startup/https://techcrunch.com/2015/05/05/omise-2-6-million-series-a-southeast-asia/ and Tech in Asiahttps://www.techinasia.com/omise-funding-expansionhttps://www.techinasia.com/omise-krungsri-finnovate-investmenthttps://www.techinasia.com/payments-startup-omise-denies-acquired-thai-conglomerate-150m. While Jake Brockman describes some of these as """"business as usual"""" reporting, I believe they contain analysis that is significant enough to satisfy . Also, considering Thai sources, has been profiled in the cover story of the October 2016 issue of ''Forbes Thailand'' (excerpthttp://www.forbesthailand.com/people-detail.php?did=1332""" Deletion of Omise (Company) (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
21590 1086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pavani Gangireddy User:Ab207 07:35, 6 September 2020 (UTC) delete Lacks . Fails Deletion of Pavani Gangireddy WP:SIGCOV||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21591 15810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ultimate theory of reality User:Pjacobi 20:50, 24 September 2005 (UTC) delete per , obviously a misunderstanding of what Wikipedia is Deletion of Ultimate theory of reality WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21592 10350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of postcodes in Queensland User:Unus 20:28, 30 April 2013 (UTC) delete It flat out contravenes the policy, and I will add that the lists as construed are not very useful anyway in this format. If you look at the official postcode directory they print it's very large because there are thousands of localities and hamlets not included in these lists that nonetheless fall into a postcode, and not always that of the nearest town/suburb. I think any list Wikipedia generates of postcodes is going to be inferior to that maintained by the postal service - at best incomplete and at worst inaccurate or misleading Deletion of List of postcodes in Queensland WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21593 7482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Esmond James User:Reckless182 12:34, 20 January 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Esmond James WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21594 16289 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ZZ Top equipment (3rd nomination) User:Avilich 20:50, 26 August 2021 (UTC) delete The nominator does allude to a policy, wp:contentfork, which is a -REASON|reason for deletion. DanielRigal's argument is also convincing, this is not a band which needs a separate article dealing with its equipment solely Deletion of ZZ Top equipment (3rd nomination) WP:DEL Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21595 577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Haine User:Cinderella157 02:22, 12 May 2019 (UTC) comment """Probably meets but not wrt award and rank - the latter has arguably a higher threshold but does not preclude notability for other reasons. requires """"significant coverage in multiple published secondary sources"""". A full obituary in the Times carries weight, even if it is otherwise a little weak on sources. The subject is ''at'' the threshold I think. Therefore happy with a decision to '''keep'''. Regards""" Deletion of Richard Haine WP:ANYBIO||WP:SOLDIER||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21596 8124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AVRO F.C. User:Fenix 15:26, 13 February 2015 (UTC) delete per has never played in a national competition. No other achievements noted that have garnered sufficient, significant, reliable and e|non-routine coverage to satisfy |GNG Deletion of AVRO F.C. WP:FOOTYN||WP:ROUTIN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21597 4143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oliver Daemen User:Wehwalt 04:22, 1 August 2021 (UTC) keep Reasonably sure he satisfies Deletion of Oliver Daemen WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21598 11352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Keys User:Richard3120 13:37, 14 June 2016 (UTC) delete """leaving aside the terrible writing, I note the article creator is """"Iamicekid"""" – Ice Kid is an alias of Daniel Keys. Fails – this looks like a self-written promo piece, with unverified claims (lead states his most recent single reached number one on the Canadian ''Billboard'' Hot 100, which isn't true). All the blue links in the discography section link to disambiguation pages""" Deletion of Daniel Keys WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21599 6704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emma Mildon User:SpiritualPA 16:12, 19 June 2015 (UTC) delete Potential based on Deletion of Emma Mildon WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
21600 6996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B. H. Carroll Theological Institute User:Tychocat 11:11, 12 September 2006 (UTC) delete """I get 1,260 general hits with the WP mirrors, and those boil down to only 216 distinct Ghits. The article makes no attempt to show notability, and without sources appears to be original research. The article makes no statements about any struggles for Baptist leadership, nor historical context. I do note the """"Associated Baptist Press"""" claims in their http://www.baptiststandard.com/postnuke/pdf/ad_ratesheet.pdf ad rates they have 80,000 paid subscribers with an estimated readership of 200,000. Fine, but (the closest guidelines I can find) requires ''multiple'' non-trivial third-party articles to establish notability, and I'm only finding church newsletters and blogs for the rest of it. In any case, per the ad sheet the ABP is a church organ (sorry, couldn't resist the pun) and not a third-party""" Deletion of B. H. Carroll Theological Institute WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21601 18992 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2,548 best things anyone aever said User:Gay 20:24, 9 August 2006 (UTC) delete as non-notable, no |reliable sources provided; this is nothing more then an advertisement for the book Deletion of 2,548 best things anyone aever said WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21602 18005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC 16 User:Mtking 12:33, 31 May 2012 (UTC) delete or '''merge''' to year in type article as there is no claim to enduring notability (), no objection to on-mass move to area of so that merge can be performed Deletion of UFC 16 WP:NOT||WP:MMA Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21603 12628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Spin That Wheel Punk User:Gene93k 00:50, 27 August 2015 (UTC) delete Complete failure. No trace of this title found outside the Wikipedia article Deletion of Spin That Wheel Punk WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21604 19581 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rution User:Bearcat 19:27, 14 October 2009 (UTC) delete """No evidence of notability per ; article even says that his albums were hits """"among his friends""" Deletion of Rution WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21605 17546 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NSO Punishment 2008 User:Nerdluck34 09:12, 1 October 2008 (UTC) delete """probable hoax and at best grossly non-notable, PPV's e.g. """"Happy Brawlidays"""" seem |madeup. Related article NSO Punishment|NSO Punishment was speedily deleted a couple of days ago""" Deletion of NSO Punishment 2008 WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
21606 17587 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of guitarists (2nd nomination) User:WebHamster 19:08, 9 March 2009 (UTC) keep It serves its purpose as a quick access point for, err people interested in guitarists. It is useful, well moderated and has a place in WP. Whereas spurious list haters who use as a self-perpetuating argument does not. What happens after decimating all the List of... pages, a full onslaught of the lists of categories Deletion of List of guitarists (2nd nomination) WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21607 3242 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cyberconfidence User:Ihcoyc 14:29, 19 August 2011 (UTC) delete """Seems to be a vacuous |neologism for network security. Chief purpose of the page seems to be to drum up traffic for a """"csc.com"""" website, which is where most of the """"references"""" end up. The others are a snow job: you will look in vain for the word """"cyberconfidence"""" in the linked Forbes and New York Times articles. Obviously a |promotional insertion""" Deletion of Cyberconfidence WP:NEO||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21608 7322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stella Pennell User:TonyBallioni 04:09, 21 December 2016 (UTC) keep was originally leaning ''delete'' because the international sports argument didn't convince me as much since she didn't seem to have won a championship at that level, but she seems to have won regional and national level championships, which is similar to criteria 2/4 of (different, but looking at the existing sports level criteria for precedents.) The international combined with the national are enough for a keep !vote from me Deletion of Stella Pennell WP:NBOXING Wikipedia:Notability 77
21609 3807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devaraya (Telugu Film) User:MichaelQSchmidt 06:54, 14 September 2012 (UTC) delete this one-sentence stub. As with most Indian films, the audio music tracks are almost always released weeks or months before the film itself... and I did find THESE http://entertainment.oneindia.in/telugu/news/2012/pawan-kalyan-release-srikanth-devaraya-audio-099397.htmlhttp://entertainment.oneindia.in/telugu/news/2012/pawan-kalyan-release-srikanth-devaraya-audio-099397.htmlhttp://ibnlive.in.com/news/devarayas-music-to-be-released-by-pawan-kalyan/288617-71-216.htmlhttp://www.apgap.com/devaraya-audio-launch-promo/ which state that the audio will come out on September 28 2012, but that the project is currently filming. Fails . As this article is |premature, we can bring back a far more comprehensive article when the film is released and actually gets some film coverage Deletion of Devaraya (Telugu Film) WP:NFF||WP:NYF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21610 15483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liberation Tour User:Mythdon 11:58, 2 November 2018 (UTC) keep Google News shows plenty of sources https://www.metrotimes.com/city-slang/archives/2018/10/11/christina-aguilera-brings-liberation-tour-to-detroits-fox-theatre https://www.billboard.com/articles/columns/pop/8482783/christina-aguilera-teases-wonderland https://musicmayhemmagazine.com/christina-aguilera-receives-well-deserved-5-minute-standing-ovation-on-liberation-tour/ https://www.prevention.com/health/a23789673/christina-aguilera-laryngitis/. This is the same as with the Ariana Grande AFD's where the nomination is based on a literal interpretation or misinterpretation of Deletion of Liberation Tour WP:NTOUR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21611 1730 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas and Friends (series 18) User:Lugnuts 17:19, 3 March 2012 (UTC) delete No sources provided by the creator, who should read and understand and Deletion of Thomas and Friends (series 18) WP:CRYSTAL||WP:BURDEN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21612 14020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ALS Society of Ontario User:MelanieN 22:50, 6 March 2011 (UTC) merge as suggested by Robofish, per |usual practice for local affiliates of national/international organizations Deletion of ALS Society of Ontario WP:CLUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
21613 4898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cheats for WarCraft 3: Reign of Chaos and Frozen Throne User:Flygon 14:03, 15 June 2012 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of Cheats for WarCraft 3: Reign of Chaos and Frozen Throne WP:CHEATS Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
21614 16212 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Rovics User:JzG 13:40, 22 January 2006 (UTC) keep per and Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Jason Gastrich Deletion of David Rovics WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
21615 4560 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Cooper (voice-over artist) User:Avala 13:11, 2 February 2012 (UTC) keep fully meets the . Issues with sourcing are unfortunate but not enough to delete the article, on contrary it is an invitation to improve it. Deleting is easy, improving is not, so try doing that instead Deletion of Mike Cooper (voice-over artist) WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21616 411 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kalka–Barmer Express User:Jumpytoo 21:35, 11 September 2020 (UTC) delete """This is an unnamed train, where the """"name"""" is basically just """"Where train starts-Where train ends Express"""". Most of these types of articles were only made by a few editors, which isn't consensus. While named trains can be notable, this typically isn't true for unnamed ones. We don't create articles for the hourly service between London Waterloo and Poole or the daily Jinan to Kunming service, which are both also unnamed. If we do write about them, it's generally on their parent railway line or company, not in a new article. A search on Google News only gave https://www.hindustantimes.com/punjab/bid-to-derail-train-near-patiala-railway-station-narrow-escape-for-400/story-afbm1GGlHuPIxixxSuLP5M.html|one result about an attempt to derail the train, but the rest is coverage about train delays and cancellations""" Deletion of Kalka–Barmer Express WP:RUNOFTHEMILL||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
21617 3831 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Girl User:Alphachimp 03:00, 20 July 2006 (UTC) delete Not notable, per nom. Also |Wikipedia is not a crystal ball Deletion of This Girl WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21618 15434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Brizel User:Northamerica1000 01:13, 30 March 2012 (UTC) delete """The topic appears to fail at this time. After performing searches using various criteria, such as """"""""Robert Brizel"""", boxing"""", """"""""Robert Brizel"""" writer"""", """"Robert Brizel"""" boxing writer"""" and others, just not finding coverage in third-party reliable sources""" Deletion of Robert Brizel WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21619 19373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Panacea (band) [[User talk:SarekOfVulcan|uɐɔlnʌɟoʞǝɹɐs]] 17:55, 29 October 2007 (UTC) delete per no evidence of passing , despite being tagged for months Deletion of Panacea (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
21620 7443 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Belding User:BusterD 12:59, 22 July 2011 (UTC) delete per not meeting or GNG. One indy film Deletion of Tom Belding WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21621 19294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Open Source Track User:Richard3120 00:25, 17 January 2018 (UTC) delete totally fails . No longer exists, and even by 2013, its only contribution appears to have been a five-year-old track by one of the site's founders http://web.archive.org/web/20130721201206/http://www.opensourcetrack.com/recent_artists/index.php. Absolutely no mention of the organization found anywhere on the internet apart from Wikipedia mirrors Deletion of Open Source Track WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21622 3867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saudi Real Estate Companion User:E 19:17, 18 June 2019 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Saudi Real Estate Companion WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
21623 20768 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/German Goo Girls User:Valrith 21:23, 1 December 2006 (UTC) delete for lack of evidence of notability and not showing any that would allow Deletion of German Goo Girls WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21624 16351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vaidyanathan Ramaswami (3rd nomination) User:Xxanthippe 02:36, 31 March 2016 (UTC) keep GS h-index of 32 in computer science passes rof#C1 Deletion of Vaidyanathan Ramaswami (3rd nomination) WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
21625 15473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sir Thomas Osborne, 5th Baronet User:Bearian 16:24, 20 March 2014 (UTC) keep he was a high sheriff, knighted, and a baronet in Ireland when such things mattered (1715, not 1999). While the growing consensus is that baronets are ''not that'' notable, and we |often have merged them into one article, this guy appears to have been easily notable, and once notable, always notable Deletion of Sir Thomas Osborne, 5th Baronet WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21626 3539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Climb a Volcano User:Whpq 18:05, 24 November 2006 (UTC) delete I don't know whether this is a hoax or not, but then that's why articles need to be able to meet which this article fails to do Deletion of Climb a Volcano WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21627 7763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ucraft User:HighKing 10:19, 15 February 2018 (UTC) delete as per nom, sources fails the criteria for establishing notability, fails Deletion of Ucraft WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21628 13222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pride Bushido 4 User:BusterD 00:17, 2 August 2011 (UTC) merge to List of Pride Fighting events (which I'm glad to see was recently moved) as clearly failing by lacking diversity of sources. sports event results by reputable Sherdog and a link to the promoter's site doesn't constitute significant coverage in multiple independent sources. Adding the meager sources from this page would improve the target significantly. All five fail in every aspect. Sorry to invoke , but we've deleted dozens of like events this month which had better sourcing than these five. Any assertion about notability would better serve the pagespace by adding relevant citation to the page, instead of making sweeping statements NOT based on policy. There's nothing here to keep, even if closer made that assessment of consensus Deletion of Pride Bushido 4 WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE||WP:EVENT||WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21629 19319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ClickInsurance User:AllyD 06:11, 13 August 2014 (UTC) delete No |evidence of notability found for this comparison site. Fails , Deletion of ClickInsurance :WP:RS||:WP:NWEB||:WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21630 644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of female classical conductors User:Lugnuts 06:46, 7 October 2013 (UTC) keep and expand. At first glance, I'd say delete, as a list of two entries is not a list. However, the category :Category:Women conductors (music) has many entries and that can be used to expand this list (maybe into a table with other info, country, when they were active, etc). The inclusion criteria is clear - any female conductor who is notable. And the argurement for deletion because of the category existing fails Deletion of List of female classical conductors WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
21631 4138 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/365 Days User:Sgeureka 13:57, 16 July 2012 (UTC) merge which also silences the ''keep because you can't delete merged content'' votes. So, this article fails #PLOT and doesn't establish otability. Plus per , this means there is absolutely no basis for a stand-alone episode article. &ndash Deletion of 365 Days WP:NOT||WP:N||WP:AVOIDSPLIT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21632 9786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexa Goddard User:A 15:31, 4 April 2011 (UTC) keep The very fact that she has topped the UK charts twice means that she is notable, per criterion 2 of Deletion of Alexa Goddard WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21633 20468 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apokalupis User:Nuttah 19:33, 16 December 2007 (UTC) delete for failing Deletion of Apokalupis WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
21634 12031 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Townsend User:W 13:08, 13 April 2007 (UTC) keep hard name to search for but seems to meet . Any serious candidate (this guy lost narrowly) for US Congress is nearly always going to have enough sources if you dig them up. http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&ned=us&ie=UTF-8&q=%22Bill+Townsend%22+Pennsylvania, http://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Bill+Townsend%22+Deja+News&btnG=Search+Archives&hl=en&ned=us&ie=UTF-8, http://www.news8austin.com/content/your_news/?SecID=278&ArID=84453. We dont |like him because he spammed us, but the sources seem to exist for meeting Deletion of Bill Townsend WP:IHATEIT||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21635 1523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danny Parish user:Mamushir 16:48, 9 October 2020 (UTC) delete Fails for not being professional player Deletion of Danny Parish WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
21636 9359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Becca Mercedi User:Iowateen 22:28, 3 May 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Becca Mercedi WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21637 14110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Starships! User:MartinDK 06:50, 3 May 2007 (UTC) delete With a heavy heart I must say that is not and probably won't be satisfied. This applies to OGame as well despite the game having more users than World of Warcraft. The problem here is that this is a game that happens to run through a browser. Had the game been using a client that you download we wouldn't be having this AfD because wouldn't be relevant. Also not all sources are online, specifically gaming magazines that you can't just scan and upload. This isn't the place to debate the ridiculously wide scope of so like I said a very weak delete !vote from me Deletion of Starships! WP:WEB||WP:WEB||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
21638 20698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarjano Khalid User:Atlantic306 18:38, 7 March 2019 (UTC) delete needs at least one more significant role in a notable production with the extra coverage that will bring, it is unfortunately at this stage Deletion of Sarjano Khalid WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
21639 21200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of action film clichés User:Stifle 15:16, 16 May 2006 (UTC) delete or '''transwiki''' to Wikisource. Not encyclopaedic material, and currently a poorly-defined list with POV criteria for inclusion. Notability also questionable. See Deletion of List of action film clichés WP:LC Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
21640 13068 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neredesin Firuze (soundtrack) User:Rebbing 21:35, 22 April 2016 (UTC) delete as clearly failing |GNG and |NALBUM. I would say it should be merged to Where's Firuze?, but, as it's just an unreferenced track listing, I don't see the point Deletion of Neredesin Firuze (soundtrack) WP:GNG||WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
21641 7897 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Beating up User:VasileGaburici 18:21, 4 October 2008 (UTC) delete No salvageable content beyond the . The topic is covered in the article on violence Deletion of Beating up WP:DICTDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21642 15204 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Persona (2008 film) User:Michitaro 23:28, 18 February 2014 (UTC) keep The Eiga Geijutsu interview is an RS (it's one of the major film magazines), and it's likely their print edition had a review. A search of the Oya Soichi Bunko (good for mass market magazines) comes up with reviews or articles in Shukan Bunshun (2008/2/14), FLASH (2008/2/12), Scola (Feb 2008), Saizo (Feb 2008), CD Data (2008/11/20), etc. There are likely more. Kinenote does not mention a KineJun review, but it looks like it got sufficient, though not extensive coverage in the mass market press. There are also a few other pieces on the net, most focusing on the lead actress, but definitely selling the movie: http://www.scramble-egg.com/artist/event08/yamasaki_mami06.htm, http://www.dokant.com/backnumber/enta/64/, http://www.fjmovie.com/main/news/2008/0121_persona.html, http://www.oricon.co.jp/news/51318/full/, http://www.utsunomiya-u.ac.jp/news/2007/n_080124.html, http://ascii.jp/elem/000/000/147/147053/, etc. Several of these are major sites. Passes and Deletion of Persona (2008 film) WP:GNG||WP:MOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21643 8154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anjaam (2022 film) User:Nitesh003 13:27, 28 July 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Anjaam (2022 film) WP:NFILMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21644 1150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fibonacci numbers and Fractals User:QuidProQuo23 11:55, 11 September 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. Notability, , and it's just not encyclopedic Deletion of Fibonacci numbers and Fractals WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21645 18814 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gorokan High School User:Tellyaddict 17:41, 1 May 2007 (UTC) delete Would be suitable if it could get some refs, if not then delete per Deletion of Gorokan High School WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21646 10626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Euro-Industriepark User:K 22:05, 21 January 2018 (UTC) delete lacks notability per review of available sources. Coverage is in passing or incidental. Per , Wikipedia is not a directory of shopping centres Deletion of Euro-Industriepark WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21647 18949 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ambedkarite buddhists group [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 16:12, 17 April 2015 (UTC) delete Unsourced article that fails . Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Ambedkarite buddhists group WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21648 14760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hotel Flamingo Oasis User:MB 03:01, 6 July 2020 (UTC) delete Concur with nom. hotel, nothing notable stated. Sources have no in-depth independent coverage Deletion of Hotel Flamingo Oasis WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
21649 19490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Mothership EP User:Sue 23:08, 27 December 2012 (UTC) delete A complete lack of sourcing combined with Deletion of The Mothership EP WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
21650 9377 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan McGrotty User:Spiderone 14:45, 24 May 2021 (UTC) delete played 2 mins of professional football but failed to achieve sufficient coverage from reliable, independent sources so fails Deletion of Jordan McGrotty WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21651 18993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oscar (cat) User:Xorkl000 12:18, 27 July 2007 (UTC) delete keeping this would be ecentism|recentism, no way this passes the 10 year test Deletion of Oscar (cat) WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
21652 4385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grady W. White User:Bearcat 19:12, 20 June 2018 (UTC) delete Melbourne FL is not large enough to hand all of its mayors an automatic free pass over #2 just for existing, but this is sourced nowhere near well enough to actually get him over the bar Deletion of Grady W. White WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21653 7603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sumedh Mudgalkar User:Sam 14:18, 17 November 2015 (UTC) delete Appears to be a case of , searches for sources indicate that nothing is found to meet Deletion of Sumedh Mudgalkar WP:TOOSOON||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Too soon 40
21654 10883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1946 New Years Honours (Commander of the Order of the British Empire) [[User talk:86.17.222.157|talk]]) 17:54, 31 August 2017 (UTC) delete This article simply reproduces what is in the ''London Gazette'' without adding any context. This falls foul of and . I would support the inclusion of a list of CBEs and above somewhere, because they are likely to be notable, and also of the small minority of OBEs and MBEs who have or should have Wikipedia articles, but not this indiscrimate list. And, by the way, they are the New Year Honours, or possibly in some contexts the New Year's Honours, but certainly not the New Years Honours. Special:Contributions/86.17.222.157|86.17.222.157 Deletion of 1946 New Years Honours (Commander of the Order of the British Empire) WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:BADIDEA Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21655 20846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gaston Lagman User:Sir 15:18, 18 January 2013 (UTC) delete per nom. He has not played in a fully pro league or received significant coverage, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Gaston Lagman WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21656 4485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plastique Tiara User:Nikki311 01:16, 23 March 2019 (UTC) merge per above. Doesn't ''currently'' meet Deletion of Plastique Tiara WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21657 11664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lexi St. George User:SudoGhost 13:35, 30 July 2011 (UTC) delete """Does not meet the criteria of . """"''She is known for being picked...in the hopes of launching a brand new recording artist...''"""" is not a notable achievement by itself""" Deletion of Lexi St. George WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21658 7931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Appetizing User:1redrun 13:39, 10 September 2007 (UTC) delete Per #DICT Deletion of Appetizing WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21659 19698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of current Indian Super League players with national team caps User:GiantSnowman 09:17, 4 January 2017 (UTC) keep Not . Rename to List of Indian Super League players with national team caps as suggested or implied by Deletion of List of current Indian Super League players with national team caps WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
21660 17456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khalid Mahmood (academic) [[User talk:192.160.216.52|talk]]) 18:21, 13 April 2018 (UTC) keep """This guy's work is very highly cited. I did https://scholar.google.com/scholar?start=0&q=%22Khalid+Mahmood%22+information&hl=en&as_sdt=0,5 this GScholar search on his name in quotes plus the word """"information"""" outside the quotes and it seemed to filter out false positives. On a hand count it appears that his h-index is over 20. I'm not familiar with all of the journals involved, but at least some are published by Sage, which means they're selective. Some of his articles have over 100 citations. I'm going to say he passes . Special:Contributions/192.160.216.52|192.160.216.52""" Deletion of Khalid Mahmood (academic) WP:NPROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21661 16685 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Krave (Group) User:JamesBurns 05:05, 8 January 2009 (UTC) delete no 3rd party notability for this group Deletion of Krave (Group) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
21662 3329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blue Thunder (helicopter) User:Trevj 02:50, 13 November 2013 (UTC) merge to Blue Thunder#Blue Thunder helicopter per lack of evidence of . There's already |due weight content there, and nothing reliably sourced which would warrant even selective merging. The ''keep'' !votes are not presenting any sources or valid rationales to demonstrate notability, and the position on offline sources is not whether they are valid but whether we know them to exist Deletion of Blue Thunder (helicopter) WP:GNG||WP:due weight Wikipedia:Notability 77
21663 4444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hot dog club User:SpacemanSpiff 07:15, 20 July 2009 (UTC) delete per and hoping we get a snowfall, if not a new . -SpacemanSpiff Deletion of Hot dog club WP:NFT||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
21664 19859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nikki Laoye User:Onyeuwaoma2000 09:46, 21 November 2017 (UTC) comment let's be clear on the issue here, the subject of the matter is to determine if the subject of the article is notable enough and meets both and , there are numerous sources that indicate that the subject does meet these criteria. You should not nominate an article for deletion when you have not attempted to resolve them, simply because you have found some dead links? I am trying to ignore the claims that I am a sock puppet, but it is very hard to ignore. I joined Wikipedia 3 months ago, and I have a life outside Wikipedia, so I am sorry if I do not edit enough for someone's liking. The nominator should be trying to negate the issues raised and stop casting aspersions on people. the subject has numerous verifiable sources, dead links are not a reason for deletion Deletion of Nikki Laoye :WP:GNG||:WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21665 3387 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Fritz Theater User:RightCowLeftCoast 05:01, 7 March 2011 (UTC) delete Although there has been coverage of plays that occurred a said theater by the http://www.google.com/search?as_eq=wikipedia&q=%22The+Fritz+Theater%22&num=50#q=%22The+Fritz+Theater%22+-wikipedia&hl=en&tbs=nws:1,ar:1&prmd=ivns&source=lnt&sa=X&ei=-GV0Tay7F5H4swOqw-DKCw&ved=0CA8QpwUoBQ&bav=on.2,or.&fp=ac56f9c8492699d3 LA Times and SDUT there doesn't appear to be sufficient coverage of the subject of this article to warrant it passing . Subject of article may be sufficient to be covered under , however, it needs to pass first, and it doesn't look like there is sufficient secondary or tertiary |reliable sources that discuss the subject of the article as the primary focus of the writings Deletion of The Fritz Theater WP:GNG||WP:LOCAL||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21666 12983 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Thanga [[User talk:103.200.134.150|talk]]) 02:20, 17 December 2019 (UTC) delete no pass .Special:Contributions/103.200.134.150|103.200.134.150 Deletion of John Thanga WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21667 7757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naafia User:Bearian 19:27, 19 May 2016 (UTC) delete per established practice (see and ) for upcoming TV shows Deletion of Naafia WP:TOOSOON||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:Too soon 40
21668 14752 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Livingston Police Department User:Bearian 23:23, 23 February 2012 (UTC) merge per Alansohn and per -- we've probably merged 3/4 or 4/5 of local law enforcement agencies, unless they have a real claim for uniqueness Deletion of Livingston Police Department WP:OUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21669 849 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevinmap User:Odie5533 07:49, 24 November 2012 (UTC) delete fails . 0 hits on LexisNexis. If it was notable, someone would have written something about it somewhere Deletion of Kevinmap WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21670 16431 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rosalie Cadron-Jetté User:Raaggio 12:56, 8 April 2010 (UTC) comment I did not nominate the article for deletion because it was uncategorized or because it didn't belong to any project. I nominated it because it failed and . The comments above about not being in a category or project are because of Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion#A7. (I assumed the lack of category was because of non-importance). Also, I nominated the article for deletion before any sources were provided. However, viewing the sources, I see that there are very few of them and they peak very little about the subject and most of them pretty much supply the same information. Can anyone supply a reference that proves substantial notability Deletion of Rosalie Cadron-Jetté WP:N||WP:RL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21671 18716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trope (religion) User:Epinoia 16:51, 11 May 2019 (UTC) delete """the only reference here is OED, but OED does not mention trope in a religious or musical setting, only as """"a figurative or metaphorical use of a word or expression"""" - covered in the Cantillation article, not notable enough for a stand-alone article - with no references, this article does not meet , """"If a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to be suitable for a stand-alone article or list""" Deletion of Trope (religion) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21672 19520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toni Seawright User:MacGyverMagic 17:28, 5 May 2009 (UTC) comment Being the first in recognized competition is notable. Winning a significant competition, award or honor is even a criterion in the notability guidelines for people. OneEvent does not apply to events that the notability guidelines say make a person notable. Tone can be fixed with editing, so the real issue that should be focussed on is the lack of reliable sources. Did you try to find any per Deletion of Toni Seawright WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21673 16271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Advok8.in User:Cesdeva 16:25, 5 April 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and GNG. Also complete promo Deletion of Advok8.in WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21674 14252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chailie Ho User:Ron 00:08, 30 July 2010 (UTC) merge The article is a |BLP Deletion of Chailie Ho WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21675 14834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Children's Museum of Southeastern Connecticut User:Edison 15:14, 12 May 2009 (UTC) keep """The nominator did not comply with and the instructions for AFD, in that there are easily found reliable sources with substantial coverage, satisfying |notability. Google news archive search shows many sources which satisfy notability and can be used to improve the article. See THE VIEW FROM: NIANTIC; Ch""""THE VIEW FROM: NIANTIC; Children's Museum Born of Teamwork."""" See http://www.nytimes.com/1994/10/09/nyregion/where-children-are-supposed-to-be-heard-not-simply-seen.html The New York Times, Oct. 9, 1994 """"Where Children Are Supposed to Be Heard, Not Simply Seen."""" See http://www.nytimes.com/2001/12/30/nyregion/the-view-from-east-lyme-the-tale-of-a-children-s-museum-without-a-lease.html the New York Times Dec. 30, 2001 """"The View From/East Lyme; The Tale of a Children's Museum Without a Lease."""" These are all substantial articles about the museum, and not mere directory listings or news items about some event. Many more articles show up in the Google news search,some with subscription required""" Deletion of Children's Museum of Southeastern Connecticut WP:BEFORE||WP:N Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21676 19167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/253 (number) User:David 04:05, 20 February 2017 (UTC) keep As a figurate number, it is the ninth centered heptagonal number http://oeis.org/A069099, the eighth centered enneagonal number http://oeis.org/A060544, the seventh star number http://oeis.org/A003154, the first nontrivial triangular number that is also centered heptagonal http://oeis.org/A253880 and the first nontrivial triangular star number http://oeis.org/A006060. It is also very early on the list of numbers of 5-packed words, whatever those are http://oeis.org/A243666, early on the list of third differences of eighth powers http://oeis.org/A255182, and early on the list of numbers of 5-multiparking functions, whatever those are http://oeis.org/A243687. A 3x3x3 grid has exactly 253 lines through pairs of points http://oeis.org/A222267. I think that's enough somewhat-interesting and varied properties to pass otability (numbers). This is despite the fact that I disagree with the nominator in the other direction about moderate-sized primes being notable by themselves; there are lots of primes, so I don't think primality alone is enough for notability Deletion of 253 (number) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21677 3053 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DeviceAtlas User:Pawelpiejko 22:53, 11 September 2016 (UTC) keep clearly meets or the GNG. Loads of coverage from multiple independent sources including references to five books on web design. It definitely belongs on Wikipedia. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of DeviceAtlas WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21678 16617 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Voytek Kochanek (audio engineer) User:Gay 18:57, 13 October 2006 (UTC) delete as non-notable, failing . Working with notable people does not make you notable Deletion of Voytek Kochanek (audio engineer) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21679 15707 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kailaasa User:Jay 12:16, 6 December 2019 (UTC) delete Speedy Delete per (|G3) Hoax and per and should be deleted without a redirect since Ecuador clarified that this is fake news https://twitter.com/EmbajadaEcIndia/status/1202915067911499776 on twitter. courtesy ping Deletion of Kailaasa WP:G3||WP:NOPAGE Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
21680 10734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fellowship of United Methodists in Music and Worship Arts User:CesareAngelotti 20:33, 25 August 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Fellowship of United Methodists in Music and Worship Arts WP:CORP||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21681 1467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mundane astrology NONE NONE keep I suppose people haven't even bothered to look up sources? I would say shame on you, but AfD no longer surprises me. Voters just don't bother doing the due diligence needed. I should really start a proposal to make a policy. Anyways, sources Deletion of Mundane astrology WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21682 6781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of areas currently held by Syrian opposition User:Knowledgekid87 22:59, 9 July 2012 (UTC) delete Not only , in some ways this is as well, if you want a place to create maps and gather info there is always wikipedia commons and |Sandbox as well as making your own userpage for this Deletion of List of areas currently held by Syrian opposition WP:NOTNEWS||WP:OR||WP:SANDBOX Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21683 7103 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Viscardi (3rd nomination) User:Sławomir 18:29, 27 January 2015 (UTC) delete per nom. Not everybody who has been a darling of some media ephemera at one point is necessarily notable. Notability requires something of encyclopedic interest. Student competitions are explicitly ruled out from consideration at . That the subject continues to fail is evidence that the subject's ''presumed'' notability was indeed transient Deletion of Michael Viscardi (3rd nomination) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21684 19260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rent My Vacation Home USA User:I 20:57, 10 October 2013 (UTC) delete In addition to a news search, I also tried search for discussion of the company in books (perhaps vacation guides), but nothing turned up. I agree that the current sources do not constitute |independent or |significant coverage. This discussion doesn't need to run the full 7 days Deletion of Rent My Vacation Home USA WP:INDEPENDENT||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21685 13552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aki Tomosaki User:CAPTAIN 20:25, 23 February 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and the Deletion of Aki Tomosaki WP:PORNBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21686 18301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Razorback Records User:Schuym1 22:21, 13 December 2008 (UTC) delete Does not show notability per Deletion of Razorback Records WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21687 4241 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Independent Group User:Ralbegen 12:44, 28 February 2019 (UTC) keep This clearly passes the GNG. There is a lot of of in-depth coverage of this group, and there will continue to be even if it ceases to exist. If it ceases to grow, it still meets notability criteria. I don't see why is being invoked given the sheer volume of independent reliable source coverage Deletion of The Independent Group WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
21688 21271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/To, The Principal...yours sincerely [[User talk:Secret of success|talk]] 14:20, 9 November 2012 (UTC) delete as a violation of . No significant coverage produced. Special:Contributions/Secret of success|Secret of success Deletion of To, The Principal...yours sincerely WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21689 3042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Playboy Cyber Girl (2nd nomination) User:K 00:52, 9 January 2018 (UTC) delete Does not meet and significant RS coverage not found. and trivia Deletion of Playboy Cyber Girl (2nd nomination) WP:LISTN||WP:LISTCRUFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21690 12131 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Colin Wynter User:Premeditated 09:05, 2 February 2020 (UTC) delete a merge would constitute weight in Sivers' article. &spades Deletion of Colin Wynter WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
21691 5925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie West User:Richard3120 17:32, 8 June 2018 (UTC) delete fails and . Any independent coverage of Mr. West is related to him winning a busking competition nine years ago https://www.standard.co.uk/news/boriss-busk-off-23-year-old-wins-licence-to-play-on-underground-6722747.html, and there has been nothing since then. The rest of the article is self-promotional and citing only Mr. West's own social media Deletion of Jamie West WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO||WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21692 3650 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kristina Behr User:Dhartung 02:59, 30 December 2007 (UTC) delete seems like a just to mention the song. No notability apparent or demonstrated Deletion of Kristina Behr WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Coatrack articles 84
21693 196 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Yeni Ümit (dergi) Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 10:05, 9 Aralık 2014 (UTC) delete """Kayda değer olduğunu ortaya koyacak kaynak yok çünkü. https://tr.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Yeni_Ümit_(dergi)&diff=14902940&oldid=14888514 Burada çıkarttığım cümleler |özgün araştırmadır. Defalarca söyledim, özgün araştırmanı tanımı bazı kullanıcılarca yanlış biliniyor. Kaynakta yer almayan bir ifadeyi, kişisel çıkarım ve yorumlarla değiştirerek maddeye eklemek özgün araştırmadır. Verilen kaynakta """"Ayrıca, yurt içi ve yurt dışında düzenlediği organizasyon ve sempozyumlarla da dergi adından söz ettirmektedir"""" demezken, bu ifadeyi ekleyen kullanıcı bu kaynağı göstererek ilgili çıkarımı yapmıştır. Ek olarak belirteyim, dış bağlantı olarak eklediğim bu iki yazı aynı yazılar ve yalnızca derginin ne dergisi olduğu ve konferansı düzenleyenlerden biri olduğunu belirtmekte. Aksi ispatlanana kadar kayda değer değil""" Yeni Ümit (dergi) silinmesi Vikipedi:ÖA Wikipedia:No original research 65
21694 3577 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in North Yorkshire User:Beagel 14:37, 26 March 2013 (UTC) delete per Deletion of List of bus routes in North Yorkshire WP:NOTTRAVEL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21695 2697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Northern Link, Brisbane User:Nasica 04:11, 9 January 2009 (UTC) keep as per Oakshade. applies to things that will presumably happen in the future, but about which we don't know anything useful because it's so far away. The examples given include an election dozens of years in the future. This is clearly not the same category as a major motorway in the advanced planning stages (with multiple sources giving specific details) with construction scheduled to begin this year. In fact, the Northern Link falls under 'notable and almost certain to take place with preparation ... already in progress', which CRYSTAL specifically says is an allowable category of article Deletion of Northern Link, Brisbane WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21696 5529 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akash Ambani User:FlyingBlueDream 09:26, 10 May 2018 (UTC) keep """Hi All! I believe that merely basing the discussion on the content only present on the article right now is not fair. A quick Google search tells me that he passes and through substantial mentions in a lot of verifiable publications, https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/307754 Entrepreneur, for instance, and others already on the page. GQ, who also featured him in a cover story, called him """"India's most influential young Indians"""" in 2017 (https://www.gqindia.com/content/gqs-most-influential-young-indians-2017-digital-disruptors/#akash-ambani here) while he is also credited for M&As and new ventures at his organization. He has also received coverage where the company he is heading strategy for, Jio has been in the news such as acquiring a music streaming system to create the largest streaming company in the subcontinent (https://www.businesstoday.in/current/corporate/reliance-jio-saavn-to-combine-forces-to-create-usd-1-billion-digital-music-platform/story/273297.html here) and venturing into blockchain (bit speculative: http://www.business-standard.com/article/companies/jiocoin-reliance-planning-own-cryptocurrency-akash-ambani-to-lead-project-118011200346_1.html this and https://www.thequint.com/news/india/reliance-jio-to-venture-into-cryptocurrency-jiocoin-under-akash-ambani this). These are just some things that I found within a few minutes on Google search and as such he is definitely notable. Lastly, I also believe he satisfies through lines mentioned in the GQ and Entrepreneur articles. Some of these include - """"man behind Reliance’s open office culture and open collaboration framework"""" (Entrepreneur) and """"Ambani helped grow an initial 60-person team to a 17,000-strong workforce, achieving the goal of 100 million subscribers in just 170 days"""" (GQ). I strongly support keeping this page and do not agree with its deletion""" Deletion of Akash Ambani WP:BASIC||WP:GNG||WP:CCS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21697 7187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rigby (Regular Show) User:Green 19:09, 2 December 2012 (UTC) delete No reliable secondary sources per . This kind of fan material better off at the Regular Show wikihttp://regularshow.wikia.com/wiki/Rigby Deletion of Rigby (Regular Show) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21698 10302 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Moloko Plus User:Zxcvbnm 09:49, 20 June 2020 (UTC) merge to A Clockwork Orange (novel) per , where it is mentioned Deletion of Moloko Plus WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21699 9644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marco A. Diaz [[User Talk:Blaxthos|t]] / [[Special:Contributions/Blaxthos|c]] ) 05:39, 11 June 2008 (UTC) delete Seems to fail , as there are no reliable references beyond tivial listings at imdb. COI aside (cough), come back when career has been more sufficiently covered. / USER:Blaxthos|Blaxthos Deletion of Marco A. Diaz WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21700 1627 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Elizabeth Clarke Cunningham User:Mkdw 08:13, 8 March 2007 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Elizabeth Clarke Cunningham WP:N||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21701 2996 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Cool Day in August User:MichaelQSchmidt 16:21, 28 February 2009 (UTC) delete without prejudice in agreement with the nom. I have also done a diligent search and have found of the film but nothing that shows anything past its simple existance Deletion of A Cool Day in August WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21702 14884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lothar Haselberger User:Coolabahapple 00:16, 22 April 2020 (UTC) keep meets as holding a named chair Deletion of Lothar Haselberger WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21703 21173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rapture (film) (2nd nomination) User:Keb25 09:15, 9 September 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Rapture (film) (2nd nomination) WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21704 9188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/T. M. Yarbrough User:CASSIOPEIA 08:29, 10 May 2019 (UTC) delete Fails as a town mayor Deletion of T. M. Yarbrough WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21705 11441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steroid usage amongst Dominican Athletes (2nd nomination) User:Jersey 21:51, 4 November 2009 (UTC) delete this is this article's second nomination. I have no idea how it could have possibly survived the first. It is essentially an essay made up of some quotes from newspaper articles. Perhaps the most relevant policy is in particular #4 news reports section Deletion of Steroid usage amongst Dominican Athletes (2nd nomination) WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21706 18644 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Taylor Bradford User:B 12:49, 2 October 2007 (UTC) delete per - leaving aside the circumstances of his death, he does not meet the notability criteria Deletion of Taylor Bradford WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21707 719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Untitled (R. Kelly album) User:Cliff 02:04, 22 June 2009 (UTC) delete """WP:NALBUMS basically says that albums shouldn't have their own article until the title, release date and track list have all been |verified. It does note that """"in a few special cases an unreleased album ''may'' qualify for an advance article"""" if there's a sufficient amount of verifiable info about it. But since there's only about a paragraph here, I think that the verifiable info here can go to R. Kelly|the artist's article until we get the release date and track list""" Deletion of Untitled (R. Kelly album) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21708 15923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Georges Rey User:Xxanthippe 09:34, 24 December 2019 (UTC) keep Clear pass of rof#C1 on GS citations Deletion of Georges Rey WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
21709 5677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of common misconceptions (4th nomination) [[User talk:142.160.89.97|talk]]) 05:39, 30 September 2018 (UTC) delete per , Special:Contributions/86.149.219.138|86.149.219.138, and the nominator. Regarding those who argue that the list merely needs more stringent inclusion criteria, I cannot conceive of what any set of adequate criteria could look like that wouldn't pose a '''''huge''''' {{tl|globalize}} issue. Special:Contributions/142.160.89.97|142.160.89.97 Deletion of List of common misconceptions (4th nomination) WP:NOPAGE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21710 17718 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parental Consent Act User:tqbf 17:59, 31 December 2007 (UTC) delete no-brainer; this is proposed legislation that has obtained ''no press coverage'', or coverage in ''any reliable source''. Any conceivable argument for notability is . Delete w/o prejudice, and if something actually comes of it, re-add later. Note that by Paul advocates own admission, the WP would have something like 50 more RP articles if we covered every random bill he introduced. WP does this for no other politician Deletion of Parental Consent Act WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21711 19741 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Liu Ch'ing User:Fordmadoxfraud 00:58, 31 December 2007 (UTC) delete per , or redirect, if we can figure out who this is actually supposed to be Deletion of Liu Ch'ing WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21712 7781 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aryeh Nusbacher User:Nsk92 11:53, 24 November 2010 (UTC) delete basically per DGG. Too little to show to demonstrate notability per or - few publications, no citability, no significant published reviews of the subject's writings, rather small library holdings - nothing else to hang one's hat on. I do not find the claims of notability as a news-commentator/media personality on the topics of military history convincing. A Googlenews searchhttp://news.google.com/archivesearch?as_user_ldate=2000%2F01&as_user_hdate=2010%2F12&q=%22Aryeh+Nusbacher%22+&scoring=a&q=%22Aryeh+Nusbacher%22+&lnav=od&btnG=Go shows just a few hits. Fails too Deletion of Aryeh Nusbacher WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21713 16599 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cristina Nardozzi User:Presidentman 19:27, 9 August 2016 (UTC) keep """We appear to have articles on multiple other Miss USA contestants from the year Nardozzi participated in. Plus, per she """"received a well-known and significant award or honor, or has been nominated for one several times""" Deletion of Cristina Nardozzi WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21714 18576 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tekserve User:BusterD 14:23, 31 July 2009 (UTC) comment First, I'll confess a conflict of interest with this page and this process; I previously disclosed my http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:BusterD/Admin_coaching&diff=prev&oldid=73577700 professional association during admin coaching early in my wiki career. My edits on this page since that time have been limited to reversions of clear breaches of http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Tekserve&diff=232440142&oldid=232437554 here and Wikipedia:COI#Legal_antagonists|WP:COI http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Tekserve&diff=252468925&oldid=252213256 here. For this reason I'll not participate in this process other than to assert notability, and offer to demonstrate this through page cleanup and addition of sufficient and significant sourcing intended to demonstrate the assertion. I urge all involved with this process to look over my shoulder as I attempt rescue to minimize any inherent biases I may have on this subject. I'll use Wikipedia:WikiProject Companies guidelines Deletion of Tekserve WP:COS Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
21715 18662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Janet Jacme User:Sandals1 16:47, 1 January 2018 (UTC) keep My search found some coverage to boost the argument that is met plus being in the AVN hall of fame meets Deletion of Janet Jacme WP:GNG||WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21716 5854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamalika Chanda User:MSJapan 17:37, 27 August 2016 (UTC) delete What the nom is referring to is the editor moving her name from near the bottom of the cast list to near the top. This grossly exaggerates the size of the role the subject had in the films in question. I've reverted those edits. As for notability, the subject doesn't appear other than by name ''once'' in several of the references, and she isn't mentioned otherwise in others. She did have a starring role in a film, but it appears to be a NN film, as its not even mentioned in the article of the person it's about. Basically, she's an adult film actress who fails and Deletion of Kamalika Chanda WP:NACTOR||WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21717 7392 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Industrias Lácteas Asturianas User:AllyD 12:14, 18 March 2020 (UTC) comment """This firm appears to be known more under their brand-name ''""""Reny Picot""""'' and sometimes as ''""""ILAS""""''. I have added a couple of references, one of which is also available in English https://spainsnews.com/reny-picot-the-dairy-that-almost-does-not-sell-milk-economy/ here. I have not yet decided whether they are sufficient for but it is certainly close""" Deletion of Industrias Lácteas Asturianas :WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21718 5790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chirundu.com User:Ecoleetage 17:22, 11 July 2008 (UTC) delete I hate to knock this one, given the situation in Zimbabwe today, but it fails and too easily Deletion of Chirundu.com WP:RS||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21719 9854 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jai Reason (2nd nomination) User:Fenix 08:56, 20 August 2015 (UTC) comment I think this would more be deletion because he doesn't meet any notability guideline if that is the way this discussion goes. The other players at Eastleigh who have WP articles have them because they have previously played at a higher level and at least meet because of this. The fact that conference football is shown on television is not a rationale for keeping a specific player article from a conference team Deletion of Jai Reason (2nd nomination) WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
21720 2912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anthropedia Foundation User:WhatamIdoing 19:36, 5 January 2009 (UTC) comment """All of the """"keep votes"""" come from brand-new accounts and unregistered IP addresses, and since accounts are free on Wikipedia, this naturally will make some people wonder whether all of these comments might be |from the same person. It also suggests that the """"keep"""" supporters are probably unfamiliar with Wikipedia's process for deleting articles. Since this is '''not a majority vote''', I'd like to clarify for our new editors (welcome!) that what we need for an article on an organization is a ''bona fide'' independent, third-party publication (e.g., a story in a major newspaper or magazine) that is ''about'' the specific organization. Note that an article ''about'' the organization is different from an article that merely ''happens to mention'' the organization, or that is about a single person or member of the organization. One detailed profile in a major media outlet trumps all """"delete"""" comments""" Deletion of Anthropedia Foundation WP:SOCK Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
21721 2745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of pastries User:Northamerica1000 12:45, 4 May 2012 (UTC) keep """Per , """"It is neither improper nor uncommon to simultaneously have a category, a list, and a navigation template which all cover the same topic. These redundant systems of organizing information are considered to be complementary, not inappropriately duplicative. Furthermore, arguing that a category duplicates a list (or vice versa) at a deletion discussion is not a valid reason for deletion and should be avoided."""" This is a list of articles relevant to the notable topic of pastry""" Deletion of List of pastries WP:NOTDUP Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
21722 1957 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Palayathu Vayal Govt. UP School User:Lankiveil 01:55, 16 February 2014 (UTC) keep typically I'd argue that 99.9% of primary schools are not notable and should not have articles. However, this case seems unusual in that there appears to be feature articles and television documentaries on the subject, which would appear to indicate it meets the . I don't speak the language, so I don't know how substantial these are (hence the 'weak'), but I think we can give this one the benefit of the doubt Deletion of Palayathu Vayal Govt. UP School WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21723 14738 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unni Lalu User:Krishna 02:25, 5 November 2017 (UTC) delete Clearly fails , and per . Regards Deletion of Unni Lalu WP:GNG||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Notability 77
21724 20716 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vedran Brkic User:Rugbyfan22 09:24, 20 July 2021 (UTC) delete Per nom, fails as no professional appearances. May have played internationally but that would also be non-notable. Not seeing anything in a GNG search to suggest a pass there either Deletion of Vedran Brkic WP:NRU Wikipedia:Notability 77
21725 15928 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AUCS Linux User:Ahunt 20:05, 8 April 2015 (UTC) delete non-notable Linux distribution. A search for sources turned up nothing at all of significance, nothing on Distrowatch, nothing anywhere. Completely fails Deletion of AUCS Linux WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21726 11345 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Fitzgerald (Irish republican) User:SW3 23:43, 20 May 2014 (UTC) keep Passes and . Michael Fitzgerald was one of the Cork Ten arrested with Terence MacSwiney. I easily found two sources: New York Times, 13 November 1920, and Michael Collins, the Man Who Made Ireland, by Tim Coogan. I will rewrite the article and add these and other sources Deletion of Michael Fitzgerald (Irish republican) WP:GNG||WP:notable Wikipedia:Notability 77
21727 15174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crispin Struthers User:Lugnuts 10:27, 14 December 2014 (UTC) keep """per - """"The person has received a well-known and significant award or honor, or has been nominated for one several times"""". Has been nominate for several other awards. And per , too""" Deletion of Crispin Struthers WP:ANYBIO||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21728 12786 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Höck User:Sergecross73 14:35, 27 October 2011 (UTC) delete Lack of reliable, third party sources. |Notability not established Deletion of Christian Höck WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21729 16788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peterson Appiah User:Fenix 14:09, 3 October 2016 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Peterson Appiah WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21730 11641 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dominik Dziewanowski User:Necrothesp 13:36, 5 December 2018 (UTC) keep As a general, clearly does meet the criteria of and did when nominated Deletion of Dominik Dziewanowski WP:SOLDIER Wikipedia:Notability 77
21731 13475 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Infeeds User:Rhododendrites 15:30, 29 April 2014 (UTC) delete could probably be speedied under -- but regardless it does not pass . --&mdash Deletion of Infeeds WP:G11||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
21732 5635 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Catholic American entertainers User:Adrian_M 21:21, 21 May 2007 (UTC) delete per nom, and nominate similar lists while you're at it. That should appease the |WAXers Deletion of List of Catholic American entertainers WP:WAX Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21733 1013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ashton Kutcher on Twitter (2nd nomination) User:WilyD 08:21, 7 August 2012 (UTC) keep """that it meets |the usual inclusion guideline isn't really disputed (because it goes so far above the beyond the requirements, given the sources cited in the article. The primary argument for deletion is that the list is indiscriminate. lists three examples: plot summaries, song lyrics, and statistics dumps, which this is obviously none of. On the more general question of """"Is this indiscriminate?"""" - the answer is """"Reliable sources say no"""". http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/technology/2009/01/demi-moore-twit.html They http://adage.com/article/the-media-guy/real-meaning-ashton-kutcher-s-1m-twitter-followers/136049/ cover http://www.wired.com/underwire/2011/11/ashton-kutcher-twitter/ Kutcher's http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/02/23/twittering-celebrities-take-fans-backstage-in-their-lives/ use http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/30263363/ns/today-entertainment/t/kutchers-twitter-flock-first-hit-million/#.UCDL_VuXd_t of http://ac360.blogs.cnn.com/2009/04/16/ashton-kutcher-challenges-cnn-to-twitter-popularity-contest/ twitter http://edition.cnn.com/2009/TECH/04/17/ashton.cnn.twitter.battle/index.html specifically, not merely things Kutcher did that happened to use twitter. (Though his foot in mouth re:Paterno is of the latter persuation). Since it meets |the usual inclusion guideline, and isn't indiscriminate or trivia, it's a pretty clear keep. Merger and/or splitting could be done as makes sense per and . Kutcher + Kutcher on Twitter is about 50K, which SPLIT says is about where you should think about division, so it could go either way, and might need to change in the future. I don't know whether merger would be a problem for UNDUE or not, I could believe either position, I think""" Deletion of Ashton Kutcher on Twitter (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:INDISCRIMINATE||WP:GNG||WP:UNDUE||WP:SPLIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21734 12000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/3 shades of ignorance User:Aranda56 01:36, 12 December 2005 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of 3 shades of ignorance WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21735 2210 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Louis Rossmann User:Tutelary 02:21, 23 May 2020 (UTC) keep I am the creator of this article. I would not have created this article if I feel it did not pass |general notability guideline, which I truly and firmly believe that it does. Let me back up my statements. Louis Rossmann has received substantial secondary coverage in the following |reliable sources. https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/9kxzpy/apple-is-still-trying-to-sue-the-owner-of-an-independent-iphone-repair-shop-louis-rossmann-henrik-huseby Vice https://www.foxbusiness.com/technology/apple-right-to-repair Fox Business https://mspoweruser.com/apples-independent-repair-provider-program-eviscerated-in-profanity-laden-video/ MS Power user https://www.cbc.ca/news/thenational/complete-control-apple-accused-of-overpricing-restricting-device-repairs-1.4859099 CBC--which did an indepth review of Apple with Louis Rossmann, which delved in depth. https://9to5mac.com/2016/07/01/tekserve-closure-louis-rossman-videos/ 9to5mac https://appleinsider.com/articles/18/10/19/apple-repair-policy-critic-vows-to-fight-counterfeit-battery-seizure-by-us-customs Apple Insider https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/may/08/sidestepping-apple-the-third-party-tinkerers-fighting-for-your-right-to-repair The Guardian https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/how-digital-copyright-law-being-used-run-roughshod-over-repairs-n628606 NBC News https://www.iphoneincanada.ca/news/nyc-repair-tech-apple-customs-seize-batteries/ iPhone Canada https://9to5mac.com/2017/02/15/apple-nebraska-right-to-repair/ 9to5mac. https://boingboing.net/2017/04/17/right-to-repair.html Boing Boing https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2016/06/17/apple-wants-to-kill-a-bill-that-could-make-it-easier-for-you-to-fix-your-iphone/ Washington Post https://apps.derstandard.de/privacywall/story/2000109587848/ist-das-ein-placebo-reparaturexperte-entsetzt-ueber-kuehlung-von-macbook Foreign Newspapers even. Louis Rossmann has definitely met the |general notability guideline. In addition to the sources I cited above that mention him in depth, Louis Rossmann is also frequently mentioned in far more sources in passing, and is widely sought for input on matters pertaining to Apple and the repairability of their products. It's also established that once a subject is notable, they do not need to have consistent coverage to maintain said notability, per Deletion of Louis Rossmann WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21736 19801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hallel Yaffa Ariel User:E 21:43, 25 July 2016 (UTC) comment """the disruptive nature of deletions of articles on dramatic events in that dragging an article to AFD discourages editors from expanding articles in the very weeks when editors are most likely to be interested in expanding an article. Furthermore it leads to bad decisions since editors iVote while deeper coverage is continuing to be published, and before impact can possibly be clear. Note, for example, that Nom's assertion that """"The death of Halel on the other hand caused pretty much nothing,"""" is now demonstrably untrue, although it was relatively more plausible at the time he asserted it""" Deletion of Hallel Yaffa Ariel WP:RAPID Wikipedia:Notability 77
21737 2452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cut Up User:Michig 17:07, 7 January 2018 (UTC) comment I know isn't really your thing, but would you care to explain why you are ignoring the potential pass of via those two albums, and my comment when deproding suggest a potential merge to :Vomitory (band Deletion of Cut Up WP:ATD||:WP:NBAND Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21738 14245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wizard sticks User:Starblind 18:39, 7 May 2010 (UTC) delete classic case Deletion of Wizard sticks WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
21739 586 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Torto User:JohnCD 16:38, 26 February 2014 (UTC) delete per Lankiveil and Deletion of Robert Torto WP:PERP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21740 13609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Onward Muslim Soldiers User:Rumpelstiltskin223 09:54, 13 January 2007 (UTC) keep But, for the sake of , any notable criticism of the book should be listed, even if it comes from partisan scholars. It is important to have all significant viewpoints. One must distinguish between criticism of Spencer and criticism of the book, of course. Only the latter should be included in this article Deletion of Onward Muslim Soldiers WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
21741 5496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JoJo Ryder User:Trusilver 02:18, 28 September 2011 (UTC) delete fails . I found plenty of promotional material on him, but nothing that comes even close to establishing notability, and definitely no notable secondary sources Deletion of JoJo Ryder WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21742 17092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hessian (social group) User:Moreschi 13:36, 13 March 2007 (UTC) delete little to no assertion of notability, no |reliable sources cited to support notability Deletion of Hessian (social group) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21743 19388 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles R. Miller (general) User:Necrothesp 10:10, 21 July 2021 (UTC) keep Easily enough sourcing to meet . A non-independent source would be one produced by him, not by the US Government or Stanford University Deletion of Charles R. Miller (general) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21744 16168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cloward-Piven Strategy [[User talk:Misarxist|Misarxist]]''''' 14:27, 18 December 2008 (UTC) delete """per GoodDamon & JamesMLane. Note that the additional sources that aren't from right-wing/conspiracy sites do not discuss a 'strategy' to """"bring about the demise of the capitalist system"""", but a grass roots ''welfare reform campaign'' which Cloward & Priven were involved in. The relation between this campaign and the 'Cloward-Piven Strategy' exists only in the minds of the conspiracy theorists, so using these reliable sources to bolster the theory's notability/credibility is entirely & only makes sense if you buy into the theory. Also doesn't appear to scope for an article on the conspiracy theory itself, as we don't have sources discussing it as a conspiracy theory. """ Deletion of Cloward-Piven Strategy WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
21745 4893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Click referral cycle User:Ihcoyc 14:39, 31 October 2011 (UTC) delete Has to do with |advertising on the Internet: ''Life cycle of any click can be referred as Click referral cycle, Click referral cycle is mainly used in click measurement and filtration of invalid clicks in internet advertising Deletion of Click referral cycle WP:B2B Wikipedia:Notability 77
21746 20874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Leathermouth (2nd nomination) User:Neurolysis 00:59, 4 February 2009 (UTC) keep Meets , signed to notable label, notability established per third-party sources. &mdash Deletion of Leathermouth (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21747 516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/That's what she said (2nd nomination) User:Ryan 02:05, 28 July 2010 (UTC) comment """We have to come to some sort of consensus here - previously it was deleted unanimously (""""I don't believe usage in a TV show justifies having an article about this form of joke.""""); right now even with the mentioned sources (almost all of which don't actually directly discuss it, even the WP article mentioned above) it's barely going to be more then a dictionary defition; its already on en-wiktionary. If that's the case it needs to be merged or redirected into something more appropriate; if an actual SOURCED encyclopedia article (not with OR) can be made out of it that can get past a dictionary then it should be kept""" Deletion of That's what she said (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21748 1822 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/X-net (2nd nomination) User:Syrthiss 16:17, 9 December 2005 (UTC) delete Based on the comments on the previous one, I am agreeing this looks like different content. Wikipedia is |not a crystal ball, and while some pre-release software is notable (ie Windows Vista)...this doesn't appear to be Deletion of X-net (2nd nomination) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21749 16630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Les larmes de l’émigration User:MichaelQSchmidt 05:52, 11 March 2012 (UTC) keep Covered in multiple, |easily found sources.https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Les+larmes+de+l%E2%80%99%C3%A9migration%22&tbm=nws&tbs=ar:1#hl=en&gs_nf=1&tok=Sz2bUhNxWU9L6l5rFjsKpA&ds=n&pq=%22les+larmes+de+l%E2%80%99%C3%A9migration%22&cp=46&gs_id=l&xhr=t&q=%22Les+larmes+de+l%E2%80%99%C3%A9migration%22+%2B%22Alassane+Diago%22&pf=p&tbs=ar:1&tbm=nws&sclient=psy-ab&oq=%22Les+larmes+de+l%E2%80%99%C3%A9migration%22+%2B%22Alassane+Diago%22&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&gs_sm=&gs_upl=&gs_l=&pbx=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.,cf.osb&fp=3aa1957e4010708a&biw=819&bih=474 We do not punish an author by |mass nominations of |arguably notable film topics. We instead involve in discussions that seek improvements of such over time and through regular editing so as to improve Wikipedia's coverage of these non-English films. What is this... the 12th such nomination? We do not disrupt Wikipedia to make a point, specially when we have so many other ways to improve the project Deletion of Les larmes de l’émigration WP:BEFORE||WP:POINT||WP:NRVE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21750 19255 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wendell Fairley User:Montco 04:00, 21 June 2007 (UTC) delete as failing Deletion of Wendell Fairley WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21751 7348 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inside My Notebook User:Hello 20:53, 16 September 2008 (UTC) delete Fails #Albums Deletion of Inside My Notebook WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21752 3787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ganool User:Jmertel23 13:46, 7 March 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Ganool WP:WEBCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21753 17662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clay Duke User:Minimac 04:44, 18 December 2010 (UTC) delete Are criminals honoured for their job? Not in my perspective. There's a published news source, but it does fail , and Deletion of Clay Duke WP:NOTNEWS||WP:BIO1E||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21754 17539 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The sims 2 cheats ps2 User:Matthewrbowker 03:38, 16 January 2011 (UTC) delete This content doesn't belong in an encyclopedia per Deletion of The sims 2 cheats ps2 WP:GAMEGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21755 9438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yannick Ossok User:GiantSnowman 14:49, 26 December 2010 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Yannick Ossok WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21756 8906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Devin Lockett User:Snotbot 01:59, 11 April 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 April 11 Deletion of Devin Lockett WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21757 765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lauren Cohen (painter) User:Tckma 13:06, 19 August 2009 (UTC) delete Non-notable person (per #A7|A7), blatant advertising (per #G11|G11 Deletion of Lauren Cohen (painter) WP:CSD||WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
21758 11712 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rasa Levickaitė User:Xxanthippe 21:50, 29 March 2013 (UTC) delete Notability not found for rof, Deletion of Rasa Levickaitė WP:P||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Portal 85
21759 17616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minicraft User:Stvfetterly 15:03, 4 January 2012 (UTC) keep Articles aren't deleted because of lack of longevity. Once notability is established, it's considered permanently notable (). BBC news, Wired news, PC Gamer, PC World are all major publications and have established notability. There seems to be enough content to validate a separate article from Markus Persson Deletion of Minicraft WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21760 11654 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Márcio Alexandre User:Papaursa 21:20, 16 August 2014 (UTC) delete I agree this article was created too soon. His eventual meeting of falls under , but I have no objections if the article is userfied Deletion of Márcio Alexandre WP:NMMA||WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21761 19188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Natural Born Kittens User:JuJube 10:21, 12 January 2007 (UTC) delete smells like a |duck Deletion of Natural Born Kittens WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
21762 925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Recurring character User:FreeKresge 16:30, 23 April 2008 (UTC) delete preferred option) or '''stubify''' as |original research. I agree with everyone, including the nominator, that it is possible to create an article on the topic. However, the current material, even with the list removed, is so bad that it would be better to re-create an article from scratch than to try to salvage this mess. As Staeiou noted, recurring characters are not limited to television series, so not even the first sentence can be preserved as is Deletion of Recurring character WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21763 12252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BC13 (brokeNCYDE album) User:OlYeller21 07:40, 19 February 2009 (UTC) delete per . The album isn't notable and neither is the band as Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/BrokeNCYDE|was decided in Dec 2008 Deletion of BC13 (brokeNCYDE album) WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21764 7932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fictional landship (2nd nomination) User:Ceosad 18:58, 12 December 2017 (UTC) delete By reading the past discussions I can see why the content was originally split from the Landship article. However, most (all? I could not find anything that is related with the topic from the two given references) of the content here is unsourced original research. Perhaps is the solution here... Deletion is not cleanup, but any cleanup would make the article pointless as stated above Deletion of Fictional landship (2nd nomination) WP:TNT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
21765 12932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/African Americans in the United States Congress User:Jake 08:14, 18 November 2005 (UTC) keep useful, Deletion of African Americans in the United States Congress WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
21766 13187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Higher Heights User:Sky 21:55, 19 June 2009 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a |Crystal Ball Deletion of Higher Heights WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21767 1923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaize Kazmi User:4meter4 18:57, 29 February 2020 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Shaize Kazmi WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
21768 5232 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Ryan Ruiz User:Kostas20142 10:36, 20 April 2017 (UTC) delete as it fails both and Deletion of Michael Ryan Ruiz WP:GNG||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21769 10190 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/To Inflict User:NatGertler 22:01, 21 February 2018 (UTC) delete """no sign of meeting , per nominator. The """"two added sources"""" are a one-sentence mention in an article, which does not convey significant notability, and a database listing, also not indicative of notability. Digging up https://web.archive.org/web/20130703030139/http://indiefestusa.com:80/ the IndieFest page that was linked to via archives, I am not seeing mention of this film, much less in-depth coverage. There's no there there""" Deletion of To Inflict WP:NOTFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
21770 2602 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dysfunctional Family Circus User:Verdatum 16:41, 24 June 2008 (UTC) delete """While I regret to say |I've heard of it, it's only worth a footnote in an encyclopedic sense. Don't confuse articles mentioning the phrase """"Dysfunctional Family Circus"""" with articles actually related to the parody comic""" Deletion of Dysfunctional Family Circus WP:IKNOWIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21771 17967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rajesh Lakhan User:RickinBaltimore 21:12, 7 April 2016 (UTC) delete The author appears to be a |single-purpose account. Per Deletion of Rajesh Lakhan WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
21772 4097 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Falen Bonsett User:Bearcat 16:20, 6 February 2017 (UTC) delete """Single-market radio personalities do not get an automatic inclusion freebie just because they exist; they get articles only if and when they can be sourced over for something of ''more'' than purely local significance. But of the four sources here, two are her own |self-published social networking profiles, one is a deadlink of an article about her being named one of the """"hottest"""" women in radio — as if physical appearance had ''anything'' to do with success in an ''audio-only'' medium! — in a non-notable other radio host's self-created and unscientific poll, and the last is a non-substantive blurb about her getting married. A person does not get an article the moment one or two reliable sources nominally verify that she ''exists''; she gets an article when reliable sources are ''substantively'' covering her in a ''context'' that constitutes a ''notability'' claim""" Deletion of Falen Bonsett WP:GNG||WP:SELFPUB Wikipedia:Notability 77
21773 230 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RightsLogic User:WilyD 14:00, 15 August 2006 (UTC) delete with fire, . Add some Ketchup and you've got a sandwich Deletion of RightsLogic WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
21774 3812 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DW Three Kingdoms User:Orangemike 17:15, 30 January 2008 (UTC) comment my call for deletion applies to both the book and the publisher. |Notability is not contagious; a retelling of a notable story is not therefore in any way itself notable, and this is a classic example of non-notable: a company set up by an obscure author, to publish his own fanfiction (with cover illustration by himself). It fails in the strongest terms, and should have been speedied long since Deletion of DW Three Kingdoms :WP:NOTCONTAGIOUS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21775 17154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hassan Noor Ahmed Choudhary User:Fenix 11:51, 27 June 2017 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Hassan Noor Ahmed Choudhary WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21776 21923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phoebe Hearst Elementary School - Del Cerro, San Diego [[User talk:-Midorihana-|Midorihana]][[User:-Midorihana-|~いいです]][[Special:Contributions/-Midorihana-|ね？]] 20:21, 16 January 2008 (UTC) keep Well cited, meets Deletion of Phoebe Hearst Elementary School - Del Cerro, San Diego WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21777 6228 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haluskein User:HisSpaceResearch 15:29, 13 April 2007 (UTC) delete Doesn't have a |snowball's chance in hell of passing . It's amazing that so many people do not understand what Wikipedia is not on a daily basis and that they're wasting their own time working on articles like this one, because if they're anything like this, they will be deleted Deletion of Haluskein WP:SNOW||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
21778 21436 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Gannon User:J 08:58, 4 March 2017 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Josh Gannon WP:RLN||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21779 12835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blizzhackers User:129 02:19, 19 April 2006 (UTC) delete unless shown to meet Deletion of Blizzhackers WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
21780 16058 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nusrit Shaheen User:Bearian 17:23, 1 February 2020 (UTC) delete per . While I admire anyone with her kind of spirit, we are |not a directory |nor a web-host for every such person. Perhaps the OP/nominator intended a redirect as a solution Deletion of Nusrit Shaheen WP:SIGCOV||WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOTWEBHOST Wikipedia:Notability 77
21781 1362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 UCLA throat slashing User:Mandsford 03:12, 12 March 2011 (UTC) delete Not a historical , didn't go beyond . Definitely no merge to the UCLA article Deletion of 2009 UCLA throat slashing WP:EVENT||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21782 6940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Monetary Approach to The Balance of Payments User:Snotbot 09:57, 10 December 2011 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2011 December 10 Deletion of Monetary Approach to The Balance of Payments WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21783 14555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bruk Asres User:Sir 16:22, 26 December 2011 (UTC) delete per nom. Having never played in a fully pro league, or a recognised international match, this article fails , and there is insufficient coverage for it pass Deletion of Bruk Asres WP:NSPORT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21784 12574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zego (insurance) User:RoySmith 22:59, 23 July 2020 (UTC) delete There's a bunch of sources, but most of them don't meet . For example, the fist two, https://www.insurancetimes.co.uk and https://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/, published one day apart, are clearly warmed over press releases, which even have the same quotes from the CEO. Most of the other sources are routine announcements of closing funding rounds and the like. Obvious Deletion of Zego (insurance) WP:NCORP||WP:UPE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21785 3403 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Creepy Line User:Jmertel23 15:24, 17 November 2018 (UTC) delete fails notability guidelines Deletion of The Creepy Line WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
21786 9740 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicke Kabamba User:Kosack 19:50, 17 February 2017 (UTC) delete fails having never played in a fully professional league and does not have enough significant coverage to pass Deletion of Nicke Kabamba WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21787 7967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarasota News Leader User:Alf 22:28, 25 August 2012 (UTC) keep mdash;Because . And because there is one (actually 1.2 if you count the Q & A with the dude separately; they're on separate pages of the print edition) reliable source that discusses it. In some cases this is enough to meet the GNG, and I think this is one of them. And I like it.Yes, I know that is an argument to avoid. I habitually seek out things that are to be avoided.&mdash Deletion of Sarasota News Leader WP:ILIKEIT||WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21788 17016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Godolphin River City User:Sandstein 07:51, 11 September 2011 (UTC) delete per , the article does not contain references to substantial coverage in independent sources Deletion of Godolphin River City WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21789 9383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Snowmen hunters (2nd nomination) User:CosmicPenguin 00:43, 1 September 2007 (UTC) delete Previous discussion was dominated by votes and several editors who argued extensively that due to their nature, viral videos should be excluded from and . That bit of wikilawyering aside, all the same concerns are still there. These videos are on the edge of |notability, no |reliable sources (and two of the references in the article point to the same trivial mention). Most of my comments in the previous AfD have been taken care of (the article is a damn sight better then it was when the first AfD started), but I still think that 700k all time views is just a blip in the YouTube world, where even the most 100 most popular comedy clips have over 3 million views. I don't have anything against truly notable and widespread viral videos, but Wikipedia just isn't for whatever happens to tickle the fancy of folks trolling the front page of YouTube Deletion of Snowmen hunters (2nd nomination) WP:ILIKEIT||WP:V||WP:N||WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21790 18008 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arya (tribe) User:Bearian 16:08, 23 July 2013 (UTC) delete per Chaipau, , Deletion of Arya (tribe) WP:OR||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:No original research 65
21791 20867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Foo Conner User:FIFAukr 14:22, 12 April 2019 (UTC) keep He passes . Could be reread by an independent wikipedian for COI control Deletion of Foo Conner WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21792 2177 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conspiracy theories of the United States presidential election, 2016 User:Rhododendrites 18:24, 3 September 2016 (UTC) delete """I'm still not convinced there's an intelligible encyclopedic subject here. There are sources using the term """"conspiracy theory"""" to talk about specific claims and there are sources which talk about the use of conspiracy theories being a trend in one campaign or another -- or in the election in general. Given the latter, I get why there are people arguing to keep. My problem is that it's analogous to """"List of lies of the United States presidential election, 2016"""" based on sources like http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/explaining-scandals-lies-incivility-2016-election-teens/ this, http://www.alternet.org/election-2016/debunking-biggest-lies-trumps-speech this, or http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/ben-carson-donald-trump-are-the-least-truthful-candidates-20151215 this. Or a """"List of crazy claims of the United States presidential election, 2016"""" because of sources like http://www.usmagazine.com/celebrity-news/news/donald-trumps-craziest-quotes-the-2016-presidential-hopeful-speaks-201568 this or http://www.politico.com/story/2015/11/crazy-quotes-2016-campaign-trail-216157 this. There are indeed plenty of sources for both -- talking about individual crazy claims and a pattern of crazy claims. The problem is, """"conspiracy theory"""", like """"crazy claim"""" does not in this usage have any clear meaning such that they can be brought together without ''either'' (a) , or (b) sourcing that simply uses the term (in which case a list of """"crazy"""" claims also fits the bill). As others have pointed out, many of the things called """"conspiracy theories"""" do not include a conspiracy, but are rather just baseless/fringe/outrageous claims. There's plenty of room in the various campaign/election articles for mention of particular claims that attracted significant attention, though. &mdash""" Deletion of Conspiracy theories of the United States presidential election, 2016 WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
21793 575 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/24 season 6 episodes User:Ned 23:49, 30 January 2007 (UTC) delete maybe merge'', per Chuq and other concerns. While I'm usually not a fan of individual episode articles anyways, Chuq is right in that the unique nature of 24 makes these types of articles just stupid (even if you love episode articles, why organize the plot summary like this?). This same logic can be applied to the reason I normally (but certainly not always) discourage individual episode articles, the individual episodes are not independently notable nor do they need to be split for page size concerns. It's this kind of preemptive article creation that leads to the massive misconception about episode articles. #IINFO #7, we are not plot summaries, and other uses of plot summary don't need this kind of formatting. It's being done just because that's what someone did for other episode articles. These episodes, aired or not, shouldn't be formatted this way, even if you like episode articles Deletion of 24 season 6 episodes WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21794 8114 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/British Isles naming dispute User:Thryduulf 07:21, 3 July 2009 (UTC) keep This is a stable, well-referenced article (although admittedly not perfect, if we deleted every article in this state we'd lose most of our content) that would overload any potential merge target. Even if it were smaller enough to merge, I just don't see that that would be benefit to either this topic or that of the destination, wherever that might be. Additionally, I couldn't see the NPOV problem with this article, nor has the tagger elucidated on the talk page beyond Deletion of British Isles naming dispute WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21795 6422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oluwatomiwa Akinola User:Celestina007 11:05, 8 April 2020 (UTC) delete subject of article does not qualify as per , , & . Wikipedia is not a platform to “launch or re-launch yourself to the world Deletion of Oluwatomiwa Akinola WP:BASIC||WP:ANYBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21796 5859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/InfoRegistry User:ArcAngel 14:14, 14 March 2008 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of InfoRegistry WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21797 21004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Our Road To Kosovo User:IJA 23:31, 11 March 2014 (UTC) delete I've had second thoughts after realising this James Saldana aka Film Blog 101 has created an article on his own piece of work, probably for the purpose of self promotion. Wikipedia isn't a place for advertisement. My initial keep argument wasn't very strong in the first place. Perhaps a violation of too Deletion of Our Road To Kosovo WP:SOCK Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
21798 17391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/London Buses route 74 User:Mkativerata 04:11, 30 March 2010 (UTC) delete Oops, missed this one. Essentially per BrownHairedGirl. |GNG is an important guideline and shouldn't discarded lightly. It is important for good reason. Without significant coverage in reliable sources, it is usually impossible to have an encyclopaedic article about a subject that is properly verified. These bus route articles are a case in point: they are littered with original research and for all we know could be totally inaccurate. The reason they are littered with original research is because the reliable sources aren't there. For that reason, the original research is fatal and unsalvageable Deletion of London Buses route 74 WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21799 10060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Level of support for evolution User:Avb 23:57, 16 February 2007 (UTC) keep """The nomination asserts that """"this has proven to be an impossible task"""" without specifying exactly what's wrong with the article in this respect. Much of the nomination consists of Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions#What_about_article_x.3F. For the rest it's just an ''ex cathedra'' assertion in need of a clarification. (Somewhat tongue-in-cheek: I'm awaiting SA's AfD for the Controversy article.) I also have a positive argument: this article reports on the acceptance of evolution amongst lay people whereas the Controversy article deals with acceptance amongst scientists vs. rejection amongst lay people (creationists...). As such this new article Fillls a very real niche that was empty until this article was started. Obviously its scientific counterpart, the Evolution article, has been there since time immemorial. (Some of the information relating to acceptance among the scientific community could be deleted from the article since it duplicates information also available in the Controversy article""" Deletion of Level of support for evolution WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21800 2247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GK Elite Sportswear User:Snotbot 00:48, 10 January 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 January 10 Deletion of GK Elite Sportswear WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21801 3191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/COEBA User:Stifle 11:38, 1 March 2006 (UTC) delete """as """"Wikipedia is the only """"reference info."""" source fortunate enough to provide info on this shift/change as it happens."""" Wikipedia is not a primary source, therefore this is |unverifiable""" Deletion of COEBA WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21802 5544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Pakistani Nobel laureates User:Amorymeltzer 16:16, 1 February 2018 (UTC) keep This is — and the others are — eminently notable and definitively established by . There are a very limited number of potential lists like these (limited, albeit growing, number of countries and winners) and are absolutely bringing readers. ~ Amory Deletion of List of Pakistani Nobel laureates WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21803 9252 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Fazio User:Inks 04:30, 29 August 2015 (UTC) delete fails , as there is not significant non-trivial coverage of the subject Deletion of Michael Fazio WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21804 6744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pier Solar and the Great Architects User:MuZemike 16:31, 15 October 2008 (UTC) delete per lack of |verifiable, third-party sources establishing |notability Deletion of Pier Solar and the Great Architects WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21805 17287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ceasefire (M*A*S*H) User:AnmaFinotera 04:42, 15 May 2009 (UTC) delete Unnotable episode of the series with nothing but a very brief episode summary that seems an appropriate length. Fails and . Per Wp:MOS-TV, numerous other episode AfDs, and general consensus regarding individual episode articles. Unlikely search term, so redirect unnecessary Deletion of Ceasefire (M*A*S*H) WP:N||WP:WAF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21806 11219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tax Deductible Theatre Company User:Walton_monarchist89 15:03, 7 April 2007 (UTC) delete external links are to their site and MySpace, so no evidence of multiple non-trivial coverage in independent sources to meet . Delete unless multiple reliable sources are added to the article by the end of this AfD Deletion of Tax Deductible Theatre Company WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21807 15267 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/K. Johanna (Joana) Altmann User:Ryk72 13:19, 26 July 2019 (UTC) delete Not notable. Was actually going through the process of for this article when the nomination was made. Unable to find any independent reliable sources which cover the article subject Deletion of K. Johanna (Joana) Altmann :WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21808 20845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Neil Paterson (politician) User:Lexlex 17:39, 21 May 2013 (UTC) delete Notability isn't there. The most notable claim, regarding his involvement in the founding of a minor political party, doesn't have a reference and the rest of the article's claims don't satisfy otability Deletion of Neil Paterson (politician) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21809 14412 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016 Albuquerque riot User:KidAd 01:46, 2 November 2020 (UTC) delete per . If there is no consensus to delete, the article definitely needs a name change Deletion of 2016 Albuquerque riot WP:EVENTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21810 19164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2014 AdvoCare Texas Kickoff User:Paulmcdonald 04:19, 9 October 2014 (UTC) keep """Really? Wisconsin vs LSU got """"routine"""" coverage? Clearly passes with flaming colors""" Deletion of 2014 AdvoCare Texas Kickoff WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21811 18866 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sensei's Library User:Daniel 23:38, 22 February 2007 (UTC) delete Unless some sources are provided. Does not meet Deletion of Sensei's Library WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21812 15914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bal-e Bala User:Atlantic306 18:03, 17 September 2016 (UTC) keep as villages are normally considered notable as per Deletion of Bal-e Bala WP:NPLACE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21813 7473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paulys sub User:Isotope23 14:39, 16 August 2006 (UTC) delete at regular speed as business fails Deletion of Paulys sub WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21814 10834 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vanessa Lane [[User talk:SummerPhDv2.0|v2.0]] 01:38, 14 August 2015 (UTC) delete Lacks substantial coverage in independent reliable sources. Yes, {{u|PiercingGreen10}}, we are pointing to our policies and guidelines. These represent the community's consensus. The community agrees that no subject is notable without substantial coverage in independent reliable sources. Otherwise, Wikipedia would end up with articles on my 11th grade French teacher (a total hottie, BTW), the horrible garage band the 14 year old next door is starting up and your grandmother's jello salad recipe. If you believe those things should be included, along with this poorly sourced , feel free to start your own wiki project or work to change this one. - SummerPhD Deletion of Vanessa Lane WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21815 8860 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death Rap (Music) User:A 03:39, 6 July 2009 (UTC) delete Easily just - Best Deletion of Death Rap (Music) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21816 7254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Capezzone User:Ohconfucius 04:02, 6 November 2006 (UTC) delete """per """"|A year of gigging in the northeast without a CD and only limited support left the five piece frustrated and eventually led to an indefinite hiatus""" Deletion of Tim Capezzone WP:MUS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21817 12032 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meshel, Ash and Kip with Luttsy User:Thewinchester 22:44, 7 June 2007 (UTC) delete Per nom and ors as Deletion of Meshel, Ash and Kip with Luttsy WP:VSCA Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
21818 20592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ed Alleyne-Johnson (2nd nomination) User:Lankiveil 02:46, 31 May 2014 (UTC) merge to New Model Army (band). He meets , but only in a purely technical capacity which I think does not meet the spirit of that guideline Deletion of Ed Alleyne-Johnson (2nd nomination) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21819 8437 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Graffiti (Chris Brown album) User:Brianga 18:41, 27 July 2008 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Graffiti (Chris Brown album) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21820 10745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paula Leggett Chase User:Gidonb 14:04, 27 September 2018 (UTC) keep Further to , the actress passes the for significant coverage in her lead role in Queen of Hearts. Chase played Diana in that show. She is covered also in other roles. I've added some references to the article. Will format these soon Deletion of Paula Leggett Chase WP:NEXIST||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21821 18407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dry and Thirsty User:Atlantic306 20:53, 23 February 2020 (UTC) keep most silent films are notable and this one has reviews in reliable sources. A film does not have to pass it can just pass and this one does imv Deletion of Dry and Thirsty WP:NFILM||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21822 23 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Öğrenci Sendikası """Kullanıcı:evrifaessaevrifaessa""" 16.02, 6 Eylül 2020 (UTC) comment ve diğerleri, görüş bildirmeden önce sizi ve VP:CK sayfalarımızı okumaya davet ediyorum Öğrenci Sendikasının silinmesi Vikipedi:KUKLA Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
21823 5589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AdPushup (2nd nomination) [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] 15:24, 30 September 2015 (UTC) delete The only thing notable about the company is that it received a small capital injection. Most of the coverage in reliable souces is trivial. Fails Deletion of AdPushup (2nd nomination) WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
21824 192 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Yaprak sarması Kullanıcı:superyetkinsuperyetkin 20:44, 14 Ocak 2015 (UTC) comment kalsın}} Bence sayfa geliştirilmeli.Kalmasında bir sakınca göremiyorum. Ne Mutlu Türküm Diyene! bkz. Oylamanın başlangıç tarihi itibariyle kullanıcı 150 değişikliğe sahip değil Yaprak sarmasının silinmesi Vikipedi:OY Wikipedia:Administrators 89
21825 895 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Propofol for Narco-analysis; A novel and better alternative. Preliminary report of three cases. User:Cyclonenim 12:20, 11 February 2009 (UTC) delete for plagarism concerns, or if not, |original research concerns. It looks almost copied from another article, but I can't find it on PubMed Deletion of Propofol for Narco-analysis; A novel and better alternative. Preliminary report of three cases. WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21826 322 [[Mainzer Weinsenat]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Kandschwar NONE keep da Löschantrag ungültig. Artikel war /30._April_2007#Mainzer_Weinsenat_.28bleibt.29|bereits Löschkandidat mit dem Votum behalten! Und da keine neuen Argumente die für das Löschen sprechen gekommen sind, ist dieser Abzulehnen Löschung von Mainzer Weinsenat Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21827 15886 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kathryn Borel Jr. User:Northwestgnome 05:42, 4 October 2009 (UTC) delete in accordance with otable, then rewrite when her book comes out and is reviewed and profiles are written about the author Deletion of Kathryn Borel Jr. WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21828 2274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vol'jin User:Doctorfluffy 05:27, 3 November 2007 (UTC) delete Fails , unlikely reliable secondary sources can be found to establish notability, and violates #PLOT Deletion of Vol'jin WP:FICT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21829 20266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 Portland nightclub shooting User:Secret 02:05, 30 July 2013 (UTC) delete no evidence of everlasting significance since the shooting, fails #NEWS Deletion of 2009 Portland nightclub shooting WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21830 12491 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Randal Haworth User:Aarktica 21:54, 26 August 2007 (UTC) delete Borderline material; should only be kept if article is overhauled Deletion of Randal Haworth WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21831 15516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boudreau Road User:117Avenue 00:08, 12 April 2017 (UTC) delete as very few sources are out there to prove they meet . I have also https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk%3A117Avenue&type=revision&diff=774997460&oldid=773533142 notified Deletion of Boudreau Road WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21832 16422 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nick Whitaker User:MichaelQSchmidt 06:54, 15 July 2010 (UTC) keep Lead role in ''Benji: Off the Leash!''.http://www.haro-online.com/movies/benji_off_the_leash.html His other verifiable roles push at . Stub can grow with this actor's career Deletion of Nick Whitaker WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21833 63 [[Herbert Scherer]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Hsingh 00:33, 9. Sep. 2015 (CEST) keep """Als Schriftleiter (=#Journalisten|Chefredakteur) der #Zeitungen_und_Zeitschriften|WP-relevanten Zeitschrift """"http://www.worldcat.org/title/wachenburg-verbandsorgan-d-weinheimer-corpsstudenten-nachrichten-d-weinheimer-senioren-convents/oclc/310973686&referer=brief_results Die Wachenburg"""" klar relevant, daher""" Löschung von Herbert Scherer Wikipedia:Relevanzkriterien Wikipedia:Notability 77
21834 15756 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kelley Day User:onel5969 15:59, 6 June 2018 (UTC) delete as per nom and MT Train. Can't find in-depth coverage from independent, reliable sources which shows she meets , and fails Deletion of Kelley Day WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21835 10167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Moment (Framing Hanley album) User:Esradekan 23:49, 20 May 2008 (UTC) delete non-notable album by a red link singer. Fails Deletion of The Moment (Framing Hanley album) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21836 19308 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Business systems development User:Ihcoyc 14:36, 16 June 2008 (UTC) delete """per G1 as |patent nonsense. ''Are you a business owner who has spent years trying to work out the secret of business?'' As far as I am concerned, any article so full of vague generalities is """"(c)ontent that, while apparently meaningful after a fashion, is so completely and irredeemably confused that no reasonable person can be expected to make any sense of it whatsoever."""" To the extent that any meaning can be extracted from this bit of logorrhea, it's yet another suggestion that you can Make Money Fast in ''any'' business by adding to your administrative overhead. There seem to be a lot of people |selling plans that amount to this, and as such there is a likely commercial agenda at work here too""" Deletion of Business systems development WP:CSD||WP:NONSENSE||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
21837 5708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Sweetest Day Hoax User:Isotope23 20:04, 6 September 2006 (UTC) comment """well, by all means... if you have """"primary source information"""" that has not been posted here or in the article yet, that specifically proves this day was a hoax created by the 12 individuals you feel are responsible for it ''and'' refers to them as """"founders"""" of Sweetest Day, then what are you waiting for? I for one welcome you to produce this evidence if it exists so I can stop wasting my time here... As for the census data, I'd already seen all that during the original AfD of Sweetest Day and I'm at a loss to see what you think that proves. It shows that he exists, that he resided in Cleveland, that he worked in advertising, and at some point he apparently owned a confectionery shop. How is that at odds with the popular mythology of """"Herbert Birch Kingston, a philanthropist and candy company employee..."""" Candy companies employ advertisers. Anyone can be a philanthropist. The census data ''proves nothing either way''... other than his exsitence, residence, and employment. As for sourcing, the current article is sourced by primary and secondary sources. I'm tired of explaining this... so I'll leave it at that. If you have problems with sourcing of information on other websites, I suggest you contact them. The original Sweetest Day page has stopped because it is finally to a point where it contains only information that is |verified. You may think it pathetic, but IMO this is probably the best version of this page that has ever existed at this namespace... though it would be improved by Leigh Eric Schmidt's version of Sweetest Day from his book""" Deletion of The Sweetest Day Hoax WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21838 10973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevan Ohtsji User:Niteshift36 04:30, 18 July 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Kevan Ohtsji WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21839 12329 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Chmykhalov User:AllyD 18:36, 4 April 2013 (UTC) comment So is the preferance to take this particular nomination to a speedy procedural close - after which I will re-nominate on the grounds that the subject does not meet Deletion of Alexander Chmykhalov :WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21840 14926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shannon F. Reeves User:Dawn 03:24, 25 May 2011 (UTC) delete No evidence that or have been met at this time. Of course it can be re-created when and if Reeves achieves notability Deletion of Shannon F. Reeves WP:GNG||WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
21841 18298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Russell (The West Wing) User:Namiba 00:22, 8 March 2021 (UTC) delete Redirect''' fails Deletion of Bob Russell (The West Wing) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21842 8520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eli Barkai User:Kj 10:02, 27 March 2021 (UTC) keep under . Article needs better referencing, but Deletion of Eli Barkai WP:NPROF||WP:DINC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21843 11875 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Where's the Party? User:Gongshow 04:49, 13 October 2011 (UTC) keep Subject is sufficiently covered in multiple |reliable sources; meets and Deletion of Where's the Party? WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21844 1658 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/All wet User:Metropolitan90 14:33, 29 September 2011 (UTC) delete Just a |dictionary definition of a phrase, which is already :wikt:all_wet|listed in Wiktionary anyway Deletion of All wet WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
21845 4428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr Nadadur Janardhan User:Aymatth2 20:04, 5 August 2009 (UTC) delete I took the time to work through all the references. They show that he worked for the UN for some years as a regional advisor on e-commerce. In this capacity, he sat on various committees and working groups, and spoke at several conferences. He contributed to a UN publication on e-commerce. He has founded a company that provides software and consulting on e-commerce, and continues to speak at conferences. None of this seems enough to establish notability according to guidelines. There is no strong evidence of significant work, honors or even wide respect by his peers Deletion of Dr Nadadur Janardhan WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21846 12562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian Andrew (author) User:Bearian 19:48, 28 December 2016 (UTC) delete not all writers are notable; this one seems especially |run of the mill. There are no major reviews nor awards; the one award is particularly minor. We are |not a web host for writers Deletion of Ian Andrew (author) WP:MILL||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
21847 21609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Occultists United User:DanMS 04:03, 19 December 2005 (UTC) delete Per : “Wikipedia is not a free host or webspace provider.” &bull Deletion of Occultists United WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21848 3045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carl Heldmann User:E 14:25, 10 July 2019 (UTC) keep as Nom states, page needs improvement. However, I ran a and in a proquest news archive search I can see book reviews and coverage going back to the publication of his first book in the 1990s. Added two book reviews and a NYTimes article stating that one of his books sold 300,000 copied. This page just needs an editor to put the work in, but it may require access to news archive searches Deletion of Carl Heldmann WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21849 12023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KOI-5806.01 User:Astro4686 19:27, 7 April 2016 (UTC) delete I concur with the nominator's formulation of the issues. This exoplanet candidate should be subject to and , and it does not fulfill either. Regarding NASTCRIT #3 (as pointed out by Tigraan), there were no results when I did a full-text search for this candidate exoplanet in NASA's ADS search engine. More broadly, I agree that the KOIs shouldn't have their own articles unless they fulfill either or . Otherwise, there would be a flood of articles which needlessly duplicate basic catalog information Deletion of KOI-5806.01 WP:GNG||WP:NASTCRIT||WP:GNG||WP:NASTCRIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21850 418 [[René Zeyer]] (LAE) Benutzer:Wangen 00:58, 9. Jun. 2010 (CEST) delete Womit oder durch was wird bitte R nach #Journalisten oder #Schriftsteller_und_Sachbuchautoren erfüllt? Löschung von René Zeyer Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
21851 2637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/J Gramm User:Richard3120 17:32, 15 August 2016 (UTC) delete """fails and . The YoRapper and ''Complex'' references don't even mention J Gramm, and they are just about the two best sources in the article. As far as I can tell, the """"Grammy nomination"""" is for Wiz Khalifa's ''Blacc Hollywood'' album... but the link is tenuous – J Gramm was one of many producers who contributed to the album, and his contribution consists of co-writing and co-producing a bonus track on a limited edition of the album that was exclusively released through Target Corporation|Target stores. I don't believe this confers enough notability to be considered a """"Grammy nominee"""", particularly as the nomination is for the album and the performer. As has been stated above, the other mentions in the sources amount to little more than """"produced by J Gramm"""", and are not RS""" Deletion of J Gramm WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21852 21726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rohanpreet Singh [[User talk:2409:4061:90:D357:C141:C5DC:E1C9:50AC|talk]]) 17:54, 31 October 2020 (UTC) delete per . The creator seems to be and most refs are PR stuff/ for promotion only. Special:Contributions/2409:4061:90:D357:C141:C5DC:E1C9:50AC|2409:4061:90:D357:C141:C5DC:E1C9:50AC Deletion of Rohanpreet Singh WP:BLP1E||WP:UPE Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21853 3557 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wonders in civilization IV User:Masem 15:56, 30 November 2008 (UTC) delete Clearly material. Brief mention of a few examples should be placed in the game's article Deletion of Wonders in civilization IV WP:GAMEGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21854 6450 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harry Potter film/book differences User:Seraphimblade 00:32, 3 August 2007 (UTC) merge the ''sourced'' items to the parent article. a fansite. (That might technically not be in there, but it should be Deletion of Harry Potter film/book differences WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21855 2134 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Journey of a Thousand Miles User:Matthew 22:27, 11 April 2007 (UTC) keep The consensus is to improve, not delete (see ). I see no reasoning as to why they can't be improved Deletion of The Journey of a Thousand Miles WP:EPISODE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
21856 5671 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Max (ripping software) User:Stuartyeates 10:39, 7 September 2011 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Max (ripping software) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21857 20123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fitri Department User:Phil 10:11, 7 July 2020 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Fitri Department WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
21858 21880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Internet Game Database User:Sergecross73 12:57, 10 June 2016 (UTC) delete I couldn't find the sources to make it meet the . Would be glad to reconsider if others provide sources though - I could have missed them, as the subject's name is a combination of three rather common/generic words, so there could be good sources in a see of false positives out there Deletion of Internet Game Database WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21859 7865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Coyle (rugby league) User:Jimbo 18:06, 22 November 2009 (UTC) keep easily passes as he has played at a fully-professional level of sport. Has also http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_league/8334615.stm played international rugby league for Ireland Deletion of James Coyle (rugby league) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21860 15496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Personal Financial Organizer User:Corpx 01:34, 24 August 2007 (UTC) delete unless somebody cares to cite everything said in there. As of now, it looks to be completely Deletion of Personal Financial Organizer WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21861 13989 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Baxter (Last Man Standing) User:Jclemens 21:36, 30 May 2017 (UTC) merge to Last Man Standing (U.S. TV series) per -M. Neither the nom nor the above !voter articulate why a merge is inappropriate, and are thus non-policy-based rationales Deletion of Mike Baxter (Last Man Standing) WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21862 7793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Wainer (MIKE 13) User:Kudpung 02:22, 23 November 2010 (UTC) delete Notability is not asserted, fails under . As per nom, not one of the sources linked in the article is reliable according to . Not one of the sources linked in the article treats the subject in depth, (} and certainly YouTube, whether it supports the article's claims or not, is not admissible evidence Deletion of Michael Wainer (MIKE 13) WP:BAND||WP:RS||WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
21863 16787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rolandas Baravykas User:Fenix 16:52, 21 July 2015 (UTC) delete Fails as has not played senior international football nor played in a |fully professional league. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Rolandas Baravykas WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21864 19771 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shamkant Navathe User:Sodabottle 05:06, 14 August 2010 (UTC) keep meets . I have cleaned up the article. (removed the weasel bits and the resume like stuff Deletion of Shamkant Navathe WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
21865 5160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CodebaseHQ User:Joe 22:36, 21 August 2009 (UTC) delete I can't find |significant coverage for this software Deletion of CodebaseHQ WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21866 1398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ZoomInfo (2nd nomination) User:K 03:00, 12 September 2018 (UTC) delete Does not meet ; the sourcing is routine and / or . Just a company going about its business; this is insufficient for encyclopedia notability Deletion of ZoomInfo (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:SPIP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21867 20775 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tammie Jo Bonnell User:Kierzek 15:00, 19 April 2018 (UTC) delete per and the fact that Wikipedia is not a newspaper, see ; further, fails oldier guidelines Deletion of Tammie Jo Bonnell WP:BLP1E||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:S Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21868 13191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Street Co-op User:HighKing 19:55, 21 January 2018 (UTC) keep """There are at least two references that (just about) meet the criteria for establishing notability. I have reservations about the references. For example, https://web.archive.org/web/20110610175624/http://www.dailytargum.com/2.4991/the-vegan-times-1.1513459 the Vegan Times is a college-produced newspaper and may be critisised based on but my opinion is that is meets the criteria as it is intellectually independent and in-depth. https://books.google.ie/books?id=tnBhhDQDTh0C&pg=PA118&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false I also believe that this inclusion in a book on """"Food Lovers' Guide to New Jersey"""" also meets the criteria, just about, since it is slightly more than inclusion in a list of similar businesses as there is also some information on the business. It's weak, I know, but I believe it just about creeps over the line""" Deletion of George Street Co-op WP:AUD Wikipedia:Notability 77
21869 14923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parkroyal (2nd nomination) User:Northamerica1000 09:39, 8 July 2015 (UTC) keep """Passes with ease. Simply selecting the News link atop provides plenty of sig cov in rs: {{cite web|url=http://www.news.com.au/travel/travel-ideas/hotel-review-high-tech-parkroyal-darling-harbour/story-e6frfqdi-1226598124095|title=Review: High-tech Parkroyal Darling Harbour|work=NewsComAu}}, http://www.theaustralian.com.au/life/travel/hotel-of-the-week-parkroyal-darling-harbour-sydney/story-e6frg8rf-1226853945063 """"Hotel of the Week - Parkroyal Darling Harbour, Sydney"""". ''The Australian''., {{cite web|url=http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-01-14/raffles-place-room-shortage-eases-with-parkroyal-southeast-asia|title=Raffles Place Room Shortage Eases With Parkroyal: Southeast Asia|author=Pooja Thakur Mahrotri|date=15 January 2013|work=Bloomberg.com}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.scmp.com/magazines/post-magazine/article/1734947/parkroyal-pickering-singapore-slice-jungle-paradise-city|title=Parkroyal on Pickering, Singapore - a slice of jungle paradise in the city|date=14 March 2015|work=South China Morning Post}}, {{cite web|url=http://www.spicenews.com.au/2015/01/parkroyal-parramattas-25-million-extension/|title=Parkroyal Parramatta's $25 million extension|work=Spice magazine}}, http://www.theaustralian.com.au/life/travel/a-breath-of-fresh-flair/story-e6frg8rf-1227024835154 """"A breath of fresh flair"""". ''The Australian''., {{cite web|url=http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2013/04/30/pan-pacific-introduce-parkroyal-brand-ri.html|title=Pan Pacific to introduce Parkroyal brand in RI|work=thejakartapost.com}}. See also, section D of """ Deletion of Parkroyal (2nd nomination) WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21870 1839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Supreme Grand Master Azrael User:Protonk 04:25, 21 September 2008 (UTC) delete as |original research and |plot recapitulation of a non-notable fictional subject. You can add a redirect or not. It doesn't seem to be a likely search term, but you might as well. If you '''do''' redirect, the target should be to Space Marines (Warhammer 40,000), not Warhammer 40,000 Deletion of Supreme Grand Master Azrael WP:OR||WP:PLOT Wikipedia:No original research 65
21871 1100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jay Jennings User:Cptnono 01:42, 12 August 2009 (UTC) comment I have already expressed concerns over the resume like style of the article. This is based off little things that can hopefully be fixed and would be appropriate in another discussion. In regards to deletion, I recommend that Timemachine1967 takes a look at to see if his work with Loanshark or anything else meet the criteria. If those are too restricting please also see if he meets the or Wikipedia:Notability (people)#Basic criteria|basic criteria. He looks close to me and I would be surprised if we could not find the coverage Deletion of Jay Jennings WP:CREATIVE||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21872 14793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camerina Arvizu User:Wiae 22:16, 7 February 2016 (UTC) delete Fails with only one film credit to her name, and there is no coverage from |reliable sources that would meet / Deletion of Camerina Arvizu WP:NACTOR||WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21873 420 [[Abspecken]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Holman NONE keep Zwar gibt es für die einzelnen Bedeutungen von Abspecken keine eigenen Lemmas, aber Abnehmen ist unter Diät erklärt, Abschälen von Papier ist im Lemma Druckersprache erklärt, Abflensen wird unter einem Walfang-Kapitel erklärt, die wirtschaftliche Bedeutung ist bei Verschlankung erklärt. Das sind genau die Punkte, auf die man mit dem Lemma Abspecken geführt wird. Damit ist es als nützlich. (Ich stimme also auch dem Punkt „formal ist es keine BKL“ nicht zu – mal ganz abgesehen davon, dass „formal“ ohnehin nie ein gutes Argument ist Löschung von Abspecken Wikipedia:BKL Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
21874 11054 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry A. Kaczala User:GPL93 22:07, 29 June 2020 (UTC) delete fails and is not notable outside of his campaign. Best Deletion of Larry A. Kaczala WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21875 184 [[Günther Angern]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Chianti NONE keep Bitte Punkt 2. beachten. Nur ein einziger Satz ist belegt, das Löschargument schwere inhaltliche Mängel besteht weiterhin Löschung von Günther Angern Wikipedia:LR Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21876 20113 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/East Hope Group User:DGG 22:07, 11 April 2017 (UTC) keep I cannot judge the depth of coverage in Chinese sources, but it seems a sufficiently large company that it is likely to be notable. Given the ultural bias is sourcing, I think we should accept it. — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of East Hope Group WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
21877 21660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fatemeh Naghavi User:MichaelQSchmidt 22:46, 3 December 2010 (UTC) keep The nominator's concern with it originally having no sources has now been addressed, and in considering how little coverage of Iranian film and TV makes it outside that media-controlled cointry, I am pleased to note that she has found western coverage in news and books.http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Fatemeh+Naghavi%22&tbo=u&tbs=bks:1&source=og&sa=N&hl=en&tab=nphttp://news.google.com/archivesearch?q=%22Fatemeh+Naghavi%22&btnG=Search+Archives&scoring=a I'm satisfied that she meets through application of both and . And as en.Wikipedia does not require that notability be world-wide, or even Western-wide, kudos to Milowent for |digging through the available sources Deletion of Fatemeh Naghavi WP:PEOPLE||WP:GNG||WP:ENT||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21878 16867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Lewis Dear User:Muboshgu 22:29, 4 December 2015 (UTC) merge to 2015 Colorado Springs shooting per and its usefulness as a search term. – Deletion of Robert Lewis Dear WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
21879 9909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Celebrity Cricket League (2nd nomination) User:AssociateAffiliate 21:55, 5 February 2012 (UTC) delete This is getting ridiculous now. This article and numerous other variations of it have been taken to AfD and have been deemed to be non-notable; rightly so in my opinion. A celebrity in India cannot sneeze without the media reporting on it. The tournament is a jolly for a bunch of cult worshipped celebrities. The league is not played to a professional standard, is not officially sanctioned (while one can argue the ICL wasn't, it was however a professional league and involved professional cricketers). This doesn't qualify as routine coverage of a sporting event, because the people taking part are notable, not the event. The event only gets coverage because of the people taking part. It's mickey mouse cricket which fails the inclusion guidelines of . One can find all the sources in the world reporting on it, I'd still refuse to acknowledge its notability on the sole merit of a sporting event. Media sensationalism is a poor basis for an article Deletion of Celebrity Cricket League (2nd nomination) WP:CRIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
21880 8842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Crowther (ecologist) User:Tomwill1 11:44, 1 November 2018 (UTC) comment Further citations have been added to the article to show that criterion 1 (significant impact within the scholarly discipline) is met under notability guidelines. A additional textbook featuring Dr. Crowther's soil carbon work https://www.amazon.com/Fungal-Community-Organization-Ecosystem-Mycology/dp/1498706657 as well as a review of the latest research in this field, published in Nature https://www.nature.com/articles/540047a. One of the key aspects to consider in meeting criterion 1 is citation rate. Crowther's major publications featured in the article clearly have an outstanding citation rate (as noted in the above comment. I have also considered Crowther's impact for his overall work. Whilst the limitation of using Google Scholar are referenced in the notability guidelines, this can be used as a supporting source in this instance. The major publications in the field of ecology (with the highest impact factor) are Nature, Science, PNAS, Nature Climate Change, Nature Ecology & Evolution - citations from all of these journals (and many others in the field) are cited by Google Scholar. Professor Crowther's research has been cited by his peers 737 times within the last 12 months https://scholar.google.ch/citations?user=EYjCeRIAAAAJ&hl=en&oi=ao. From a review of other leaders in the field Crowther stands out against those such as Tracey Rogers with 205 citations https://scholar.google.ch/citations?user=GDgxEnYAAAAJ&hl=en, Roberto Cazzolla Gatti with 211 citations https://scholar.google.ch/citations?user=0yBmy5YAAAAJ&hl=en and Jacqueline McGlade with 228 citations. He is driving the field in this area with three times more citations than other notable academics Deletion of Thomas Crowther (ecologist) WP:SCHOLAR||WP:SCHOLAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21881 115 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Karin Hanczewski """Kullanıcı:can'''can'''""" 16.51, 14 Eylül 2020 (UTC) delete Kayda değerliliğini ispat edecek bağımsız ve güvenilir herhangi bir kaynak mevcut değil. Oynadığı dizi kayda değer olabilir fakat 9 bölüm rol almış sadece. Dizinin en wiki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tatort#Table_of_broadcasters sayfasından oyuncunun rolünü bulabilirsiniz. Başrol karakterlerden biri değil. Zaten oyuncunun rol aldığı Tatort, 1970 yılından bu yana sürekli oyuncu kadrosu değişen bir dizidir. Kendisi de diziye başrol olarak girmemiş, ileride olabilir fakat bizde |kahin değiliz. Almanca ve İngilizce sayfasından da teyit edebilirsiniz. Çeviri icat edileli daha kolay oluyor:) İyi vikiler Karin Hanczewski'nin silinmesi Vikipedi:KAHİN Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21882 20554 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zakaria Hassan User:GiantSnowman 18:35, 23 September 2008 (UTC) delete per nom, fails Deletion of Zakaria Hassan WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21883 11773 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kostis Petrakis User:Mztourist 06:28, 5 June 2020 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Kostis Petrakis WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21884 21432 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sam Creery User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable biography, |unverifiable, attack page. &mdash Deletion of Sam Creery WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
21885 1914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MoreViews User:Ihcoyc 16:14, 6 February 2013 (UTC) delete A ''|social media marketing company that helps improve a company's online presence primarily through the use of social networks'' |advertising on Wikipedia, and |where have we heard that before Deletion of MoreViews WP:B2B||WP:SPAM||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21886 2485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Japanese American Evacuation of 1942 User:SarekOfVulcan 20:34, 18 July 2006 (UTC) delete per as nominated Deletion of Japanese American Evacuation of 1942 WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
21887 18478 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Massive Monster User:AdrianGamer 15:03, 28 June 2016 (UTC) delete Does not appear to be a notable company. |Too soon Deletion of Massive Monster WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
21888 15561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Demonic car concept User:Bryson109 02:18, 17 April 2007 (UTC) delete per nom, fails Deletion of Demonic car concept WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21889 20263 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bygdøfergene User:HighKing 17:48, 13 August 2018 (UTC) delete Agree as there are no references that meet the criteria for establishing notability. Topic fails GNG and Deletion of Bygdøfergene WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21890 21129 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Afore notation User:Hetar 17:35, 29 March 2006 (UTC) delete This is nowhere near Deletion of Afore notation WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
21891 8704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albin Ljungqvist User:K 22:18, 10 February 2018 (UTC) delete does not meet & significant RS coverage not found Deletion of Albin Ljungqvist WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21892 19655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asia-Pacific Innovation Network User:Alberto79 17:23, 5 January 2016 (UTC) delete This article has no citations and references to show the notability of the page ( and ). Bassically, this article is a simple advertisement () and a spam ( Deletion of Asia-Pacific Innovation Network WP:N||WP:REF||WP:ADV||WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Notability 77
21893 10001 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raffles Institution Military Band User:Tedder 17:47, 13 May 2010 (UTC) merge back to school. It's only worth a sentence or two, and no independent |reliable sources have been given to indicate it deserves more than that Deletion of Raffles Institution Military Band WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21894 5426 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joshua Gardner User:Thebainer 07:03, 19 January 2006 (UTC) delete """The only criteria that comes close is """"Persons achieving renown or notoriety for their involvement in newsworthy events"""", which is so nebulous as to be almost useless. Notoriety within the WP world yes, in teh real world? Methinks not""" Deletion of Joshua Gardner WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21895 17782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1974 Hunza earthquake User:RecycledPixels 04:58, 13 July 2021 (UTC) keep Easily meets when searching for sources on newspapers.com. Plenty of worldwide coverage on an ongoing basis, not only about the initial event but the ongoing relief and rescue efforts afterward Deletion of 1974 Hunza earthquake WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21896 12865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fernando Gonzalez JR User:Atlantic306 15:15, 10 August 2017 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON as only minor roles in feature films so far, a lack of coverage so does not pass at this time Deletion of Fernando Gonzalez JR WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21897 7604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dielectric wireless receiver User:Rackabello 05:12, 21 September 2007 (UTC) delete I understand that this has appeared in peer-reviewed journals, but I feel that including this still verges on |crystal ballery, and steering clear might not be a bad idea until it garners some more mainstream acceptance Deletion of Dielectric wireless receiver WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21898 10297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dag Creative Media User:onel5969 03:49, 2 November 2015 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Dag Creative Media WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
21899 14523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inspector Shimura User:Vizjim 09:34, 4 December 2019 (UTC) keep """OR '''fully merge'''. This is an odd nomination. """"Fictional character"""" is not a disqualifier. """"Analysis"""" is not the point of a Wikipedia article. does not apply as the article is not a plot summary, and is barely a guideline, beyond pointing to """ Deletion of Inspector Shimura WP:PLOT||WP:FICTION||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21900 12672 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Will That Vanished User:Sodabottle 06:37, 3 June 2010 (UTC) comment The Bengalis are known for literary consumption and have huge media coverage for books (much more than other language people). Coverage for such a book (reviews and discussions) almost certainly exists in the offline archives. But regrettably, gets in the way Deletion of The Will That Vanished WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21901 275 [[Bye Bye Lugo]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Theghaz/Bewertung 08:59, 22. Aug. 2013 (CEST) keep Es ist hier nicht unsere Aufgabe, die Qualität des Films zu beurteilen. Wir prüfen hier, ob die Relevanzkriterien erfüllt sind. Das ist hier offenbar der Fall, da der Film auf DVD veröffentlicht wurde und einen IMDb-Eintrag hat. Dass damit auch Machwerke einen Artikel erhalten können, die trotz fleißig gerührter Werbetrommel keinerlei öffentliche Wahrnehmung erfahren, ist ein Problem der RK, das auf oder WP:RFF zu beheben wäre Löschung von Bye Bye Lugo Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
21902 15167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Education Side of Minecraft User:Soetermans 09:35, 31 January 2020 (UTC) delete unnecessary spin-off from ''Minecraft'', no relevant and substantial information that would merit its own article. Maybe it's at this point and we can have a properly sourced (and correctly named) article solely on the educational uses of ''Minecraft'' at some point, but right now it's just retelling the Minecraft#Applications section in a somewhat strange way Deletion of Education Side of Minecraft WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
21903 5046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Hampshire County Historical Highway Markers User:FCYTravis 07:39, 18 December 2005 (UTC) keep """if |verified that these markers are erected by the state as part of a historical landmark signage system, a-la the roadside """"California State Historic Landmark"""" plaques installed by the California Department of Parks and Recreation""" Deletion of List of Hampshire County Historical Highway Markers WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21904 5191 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Skyline Marina User:Kalivd 14:38, 5 September 2008 (UTC) delete as per nom Deletion of Skyline Marina WP:NOTABILITY Wikipedia:Notability 77
21905 640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matthew Parker (teenager) User:Pdcook 16:03, 26 July 2019 (UTC) delete I can't find non-trivial coverage of this person in RS. I suggest is relevant here Deletion of Matthew Parker (teenager) WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21906 11796 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Worth It (song) User:Gongshow 05:50, 8 February 2010 (UTC) merge to I Look to You per Rlendog. I can find passing mentions of the song within reviews for the album, but not coverage to suggest the song is notable in its own right. That may change in the near future, if the single is released and it charts and/or receives significant coverage; however, for now it does not meet Deletion of Worth It (song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21907 4271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Agg User:Royboycrashfan 02:55, 9 March 2006 (UTC) delete WP:NEO|neologism|cruft Deletion of Agg WP:CRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
21908 10956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thomas Jackson (police officer) (2nd nomination) [[user: MrX|Mr]][[user talk:MrX|X]] 21:02, 14 September 2014 (UTC) keep There are thousands of news sources available that discuss the subject in various levels of detail. Easily meets . If the article has improper content, or is being used as a , then the appropriate course of action is to edit the article, not delete it outright Deletion of Thomas Jackson (police officer) (2nd nomination) WP:BASIC||WP:COATRACK Wikipedia:Notability 77
21909 10117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boylston Junction, Wisconsin User:Spinningspark 17:05, 19 April 2020 (UTC) merge any that have been shown to definitely exist, but cannot sustain a standalone page. '''Merge''' all information per , including the coodinates Deletion of Boylston Junction, Wisconsin WP:PRESERVE Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
21910 9563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rattanindia User:BU 08:35, 3 July 2015 (UTC) keep Meets . See sources such as http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2014-10-30/news/55595397_1_coal-blocks-indiabulls-power-jindal-power http://www.business-standard.com/article/companies/rajiv-rattan-takes-control-of-indiabulls-power-114090600798_1.html http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/india-business/Adani-eyes-Indiabulls-power-plant/articleshow/39254829.cms http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/nagpur/Train-to-RattanIndia-plant-soon/articleshow/46681949.cms http://www.business-standard.com/article/pti-stories/rattanindia-power-commissions-270-mw-unit-5-at-amravati-115032501016_1.html , which pass Deletion of Rattanindia WP:GNG||WP:ORGDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
21911 5898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The black and white tour User:Esradekan 12:38, 24 May 2009 (UTC) delete a non-notable tour that fails to satisfy the |general notability guideline and File:Crystalball.jpg|20px with significant coverage in |reliable, third-party, sources Deletion of The black and white tour WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21912 332 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1998 St. Cloud explosion User:Michaelzeng7 19:54, 24 May 2013 (UTC) keep Bushranger has found sources that range across years of time: evidence that this topic is notable and meeting . Further, |notability is not temporary Deletion of 1998 St. Cloud explosion WP:PERSISTENCE||WP:NOTTEMPORARY Wikipedia:Notability 77
21913 18648 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carolyn Ramo User:VocalIndia 05:53, 28 May 2020 (UTC) delete per nom. My search didn't find anything to show that and Deletion of Carolyn Ramo WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21914 8734 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alan Waddell User:Trident13 21:48, 1 April 2007 (UTC) keep certainly passes , but its a very, very poor article and yes, more like a press release at present. Somone with some knowledge and a little bit of time could make an interesting article with all the hits I got from a quick search on Google. Rgds Deletion of Alan Waddell WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21915 12906 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toy Meets Girl User:Shruti14 18:35, 21 August 2007 (UTC) merge to List of Robot Chicken episodes per Deletion of Toy Meets Girl WP:EPISODE Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
21916 4331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Naomi Andrews User:Muboshgu 16:26, 27 August 2018 (UTC) merge this is a clear case of a non notable political candidate with a campaign advertisement masquerading as a biographical article. Most if the article is non biographical political positions. Much for an article on this candidate. – Deletion of Naomi Andrews WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
21917 628 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MSTRKRFT User:Doc 13:33, 21 October 2008 (UTC) keep Meets the following criterion: 1 (several references provided at the bottom of article), 5 (signed to Last Gang Records), 6 (Jesse Keeler, a member of the notable dance-punk group Death from Above 1979 is a member) and 8 (won a Juno Award Deletion of MSTRKRFT WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21918 7736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Franklin User:Bearian 20:45, 11 June 2007 (UTC) delete as |non-notable hole in the ground -- even his band article the Funky Nixons -- was edited by him, and that should be tagged and '''deleted as well Deletion of George Franklin WP:HOLE Wikipedia:I wouldn't know him from a hole in the ground 12
21919 32 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Miray Daner Kullanıcı:e4024e4024 06:55, 9 Ekim 2014 (UTC) comment Kalacaksa usulüne uygun tartışma ile, politika, ilke, yönerge ve kurallarımız (unuttuğum bir şey var mı?) çerçevesinde kalacak, yoksa oyunculuk düzeyine ilişkin öznel |kukla yorumları doğrultusunda değil Miray Daner'in silinmesi Vikipedi:Kukla Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
21920 18600 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Health care in Pakistan User:Cyrus 18:57, 18 May 2007 (UTC) keep I don't know about everyone else, but I thought Wikipedia ''was'' a game, at least an MMORPG. If it isn't then why am I keeping score and leveling up? But seriously, this article is not written well. I agree with the nominator in that regard. Also, the article is not |sourced and provides no means of |verifying the information. That is definitely a problem. However, the topic is definitely notable as health care and level of coverage will vary in each country. If it were deleted, it would be recreated later. This article really only needs to be sourced and expanded to be acceptable Deletion of Health care in Pakistan WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21921 8249 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles R. Gallagher III NONE 17:52, 3 May 2010 (UTC) delete """per . This attorney has been practicing for ten years, and may become notable, but he is far from there. He's never taught at a college or law school; he's not a partner at a major law firm; he hasn't chaired any ABA or state bar committees or sections; his only awards are of the local """"best young lawyer"""" or """"up-and-coming"""" variety. Maybe he'll become notable, but until then, delete""" Deletion of Charles R. Gallagher III WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21922 1445 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kenzie (songwriter) User:Metropolitan90 01:34, 26 April 2012 (UTC) keep It looks like the subject at least has a claim to be notable per since a few of her songs already have Wikipedia articles. I recommend that this article be re-structured to indicate the ''chart performance'' of the hit songs she wrote, according to the authoritative music charts as indicated at Wikipedia:Record charts. This would be a lot more relevant than the albums that the songs appeared on, which is currently included in the article Deletion of Kenzie (songwriter) WP:COMPOSER Wikipedia:Notability 77
21923 7662 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joel Rudewicz User:Fabrictramp 14:29, 30 June 2008 (UTC) delete 0 non-wiki ghits + 0 gnews hits + 0 gscholar hits = unlikely to be a world famous historian. However, it's a bit soon for a close Deletion of Joel Rudewicz WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
21924 2893 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gurinder Seagal User:Pharaoh 02:22, 24 September 2014 (UTC) delete As per nom and fails Deletion of Gurinder Seagal WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21925 11960 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PMID 8474513 User:Jayvdb 06:20, 17 January 2007 (UTC) merge to Minnesota Colon Cancer Control Study. As a result of my discussion with Badgettrg I am convinced that the topic is notable, and DGG has done the leg work to confirm the details. The current article text forms a good foundation for the expanded topic and it already also meets , so I dont see that the article must be rewritten before it is acceptable. I have added a todo list on the talk page listing a few of the suggestions that have been made during this Afd Deletion of PMID 8474513 WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21926 7467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Art Nalls User:YSSYguy 23:38, 15 August 2015 (UTC) keep although many of the sources used do just contain passing mentions, it appears to me that there is sufficient in-depth coverage in reliable sources independent of the subject, including the ''Washington Post'', ''Popular Mechanics'' and the ''Flight International'' website Flightglobal. In my opinion these sources satisfy the requirements of the |general notability guidelines. Yes the article could do with some work, but that is not a reason for deletion Deletion of Art Nalls WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21927 19588 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Zobel (musician) User:Gongshow 16:39, 25 August 2012 (UTC) delete I found a couple blurbs like http://relevant.at/kultur/veranstaltungen/672363/martin-zobel-soulrise-band-donauinsel.story this which promote concert appearances, but I'm unable to find significant coverage; does not appear to meet or at this time Deletion of Martin Zobel (musician) WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21928 2830 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William J. Ecker User:Peacemaker67 05:29, 11 May 2014 (UTC) keep """Other than his rank (and which is a WikiProject Military History thing, not a WP-wide guideline), Ecker's """"notability"""" relates to appearing before a number of Congressional and Senate Committee hearings in relation to maritime safety, and he presented at least one paper on that subject at a major conference. He was Chief of the Office of Navigation Safety and Waterway Services for the USCG in the 1990's, not sure how important a role that is. This from the single page of Google Books hits. On that basis, his notability per is marginal at best IMO. His gongs don't help him, as his highest is apparently Officer of the Legion of Merit, which is pretty much passe for a US one-star. I consider the one-star bit of SOLDIER to be blurry at the bottom ranks, so a one-star without clear notability per GNG is questionable. I would AGF and think he's got newspaper coverage no-one's bothered to look for yet. Cheers""" Deletion of William J. Ecker WP:SOLDIER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21929 16667 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Killshot (Eminem song) User:Z0 15:34, 16 September 2018 (UTC) keep """I'm not sure why you think this ''song'' is a violation of . There is significant coverage of reliable sources that aren't just press releases and news reports.https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/eminem-responds-to-machine-gun-kelly-on-killshot-724704/https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/news/killshot-eminem-diss-track-machine-gun-kelly-rap-devil-response-a8538861.htmlhttps://www.billboard.com/articles/columns/hip-hop/8475302/eminem-machine-gun-kelly-decoding-killshothttps://people.com/music/eminem-diss-track-machine-gun-kelly-killshot/. It's not clearly related to Kamikaze either because this song and the album have nothing to do with each other since the song is a product of the feuding between Eminem and MGK, which is irrelevant to the album. It is debatable that the feuding might be a publicity stunt to boost sales, hence causing some to think the song is directly connected to the album, but there is no evidence of that. This article is about the song not its surrounding feud and reactions, it is not just news and is suitable for inclusion in the encyclopedia. The article does not look like it's written in news style and even so, it can be |expanded and improved further rather than deleted. Besides, it's only been two days since the song's release and it has already received sufficient coverage, passing - """"songs and singles are probably notable if they have been the subject of multiple, non-trivial published works whose sources are independent of the artist and label"""" which is just an iteration of """ Deletion of Killshot (Eminem song) WP:NOTNEWS||WP:PRESERVE||WP:NSONGS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21930 4334 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fairground Gaming User:2005 01:07, 5 March 2007 (UTC) keep """Easily met , now article needs to say """"was"""". If all the assets went somewhere else, it could be redirected there, but we have :Category:Defunct gambling companies for a reason""" Deletion of Fairground Gaming WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21931 20124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Foxy Production User:Artentries 11:53, 17 April 2019 (UTC) delete """does not meet our revised guideline (and probably didn't meet the old one either). The Australian """"Broadsheet"""" article does have some in-depth coverage, but – surprise, surprise! – is a """"dispatch"""" supplied by """"John Thomson of Foxy Production"""". As discussed in innumerable past deletion nominations, the notability of the product or merchandise (here, works by various artists) is not """"inherited"""" by the trader or merchant. As for the notability of the artists, several of those listed are blue-linked because""" Deletion of Foxy Production WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21932 7046 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Three Great Powers User:Ned 07:07, 23 December 2006 (UTC) comment normally I'd say delete, but holy crap look how many |freaking One Piece articles there are... I'm just going to pretend like I didn't see that... and go on my way Deletion of The Three Great Powers WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21933 8733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of football clubs in Germany by major honours won User:Fenix 13:06, 19 September 2014 (UTC) delete """Agree with implications of subjective term """"major"""". If no reliable sources are discussing this then I am not sure the OR issues can be resolved""" Deletion of List of football clubs in Germany by major honours won WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
21934 41 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Pir Muhammed Hüseyin Kullanıcı:derviş nazarıderviş nazarı NONE comment """seslen|Derviş Nazarı}} - Kimse """"bence KD değil"""" şeklinde görüş belirtmiyor. En azından kendi adıma söyleyeyim, ben silinsin şeklinde görüş belirtirken sebebini de yazdım. Derseniz ki """"tarafınızca görüşünüzü destekleyecek maddeleri kısa olarak belirtin"""", buyrun o zaman size politikamızdan bir alıntı""" Pir Muhammed Hüseyin'in silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
21935 4558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adele Uddo User:AuthorAuthor 06:25, 5 June 2019 (UTC) keep I improved the article by adding a bit more content with sources and by removing POV. Subject has had sustained wide coverage in the media as evidenced by the cited reliable sources. Easily passes and meets notability criteria as per Deletion of Adele Uddo WP:GNG||WP:NMODEL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21936 6346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Richard Phillips (captain) User:Torsodog 04:10, 13 April 2009 (UTC) merge to MV Maersk Alabama per Deletion of Richard Phillips (captain) WP:ONEEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21937 2080 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erik Gunnarsson User:Alvaldi 20:02, 16 April 2021 (UTC) delete Fails . Passing means the subject is likely to pass GNG but there still has to be on him to pass it. A Google search turned up nothing and his Swedish article only has links to trivial sources or database sites Deletion of Erik Gunnarsson WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
21938 18494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francis R. Whelton [[User: Stalwart111|'''Stalwart''']][[User talk:Stalwart111|'''111''']] 02:40, 17 December 2012 (UTC) keep there are a number of source extracts or summaries (provided above) that (combined) would likely be enough to meet were those sources replicated in a modern context with regard to a modern subject. |Notability is not temporary so those are enough for me. The article needs work, sure, but they are sorts of problems if we have |reliable sources Deletion of Francis R. Whelton WP:GNG||WP:NOTTEMP||WP:FIXTHEPROBLEM||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21939 9868 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sindhu Joy (2nd nomination) User:Bearian 15:45, 17 March 2021 (UTC) delete per . Short of being a party chairperson, treasurer, or executive director, we have almost never kept an article on a party functionary that I can recall. General secretaries, youth leaders, rapporteurs, and the like are |run of the mill. ''Zero'' evidence she passes or as alleged. I found ''no'' social media following, ''zero'' articles from newspapers of record, and only a new scholarly articles that mention her Deletion of Sindhu Joy (2nd nomination) WP:POLOUTCOMES||WP:MILL||WP:PROF||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
21940 6293 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ronin press User:Joe 02:21, 23 December 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Ronin press WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21941 7659 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of allergies (2nd nomination) User:Nageh 13:04, 17 December 2011 (UTC) comment This list is problematic for so many reasons. First, you can be allergic to just about anything and everything, including but not limited to just about any protein. Second, the potential reactions you may show are not limited in any way, and can be all through category I to IV, albeit one is usually much more common. Third, potential reactions are largely dependent on the category the allergy falls in, and not the allergen by itself. Of course, digesting an allergen results in different reactions than inhaling or skin contact, yet the principle is the same for all allergens. Last but not least, this list will ''never'' include the more rare allergies just ''because'' you can be allergic to just about anything and everything. This list ''is'' |indiscriminate Deletion of List of allergies (2nd nomination) WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21942 18909 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Kingdon [[User talk:50.24.119.73|talk]]) 15:31, 21 September 2020 (UTC) keep This page was completely reworked by a single-purpose editor just hours before the AfD. The page has been restored including all of the reliable sources and proper encyclopedic tone that was removed by that editor. The AfD was quick to be placed before checking the recent history of the page, (which raises some questions about the unusual timing) and its current state meets Special:Contributions/50.24.119.73|50.24.119.73 Deletion of Jason Kingdon WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21943 3944 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cat Beach User:Rjanag 04:38, 17 June 2009 (UTC) delete No evidence of notability, doesn't appear to satisfy the |notability criteria for musical artists. Quick google search turned up very few hits (most were unrelated hits), and none of them appeared to be |reliable sources with significant coverage; rather, they were just things like Myspace pages, etc Deletion of Cat Beach WP:BAND||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21944 12670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ján Andráš User:Argyle 15:59, 26 May 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Ján Andráš WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
21945 9477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lia (pornographic actress) User:GentlemanGhost 05:03, 29 March 2013 (UTC) delete Still fails and . The article is lacking in |reliable sources Deletion of Lia (pornographic actress) WP:PORNBIO||WP:GNG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21946 11133 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Jay Wienbarg User:TenPoundHammer 02:29, 1 August 2007 (UTC) keep seems to marginally pass . And to the above user -- please |sign your posts Deletion of George Jay Wienbarg WP:RS||WP:SIG Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21947 7905 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of films featuring United States Marines User:Black 18:01, 25 February 2007 (UTC) delete """This version is much better in terms of content, compliance with , and presentation. I would suggest renaming the """"Awards"""" section to """"Notes"""" to include a wide range of information on the movie such as awards received, financial success, breakthrough performance of an actor/actress, and so on. Many thanks for your improvements""" Deletion of List of films featuring United States Marines WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
21948 7684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Krischan User:Xxanthippe 23:49, 5 December 2016 (UTC) delete No pass of rof Deletion of Alexander Krischan WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
21949 2606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roger Craig (Jeopardy! contestant) User:Armbrust 18:02, 25 September 2010 (UTC) delete as he is |only notable for one event (winning many money on a game show) and |Wikipedia is not the news Deletion of Roger Craig (Jeopardy! contestant) WP:ONEVENT||WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21950 8765 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Capricorn (manga) NONE NONE keep it meets , per the above and a page at the ''New York Times'' (http://movies.nytimes.com/movie/206323/Capricorn-Anime-OVA-/overview -- taken from ''All Movie Guide'' however Deletion of Capricorn (manga) WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21951 5098 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional television shows (2nd nomination) User:Ohconfucius 02:04, 29 July 2008 (UTC) delete The previous close was faulty and completely out of order. My guess is that it would have been overturned at DRV. I'd say that, depending on the channel, up to 95% of the fare is fictional, so this list is really quite #IINFO|pointless. And a show-in-show? |Wow! It would impart no great |encyclopaedic value. I would strongly urge for its deletion, lest we be plagued with articles such as List of television documentaries, List of reality TV shows, List of news programs, ''etc'', instead of relying on categorisation Deletion of List of fictional television shows (2nd nomination) WP:NOT||WP:SARCASM||WP:ENC Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21952 11615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/ICA (4-Icaroldichloridesulphate aka Icarus) User:MuffledThud 22:09, 26 January 2010 (UTC) delete per Deletion of ICA (4-Icaroldichloridesulphate aka Icarus) WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
21953 4807 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jet Pack Adventure User:James086 10:04, 11 February 2007 (UTC) delete WP:N|not notable, no |sources and #IINFO|Wikipedia is not a game guide Deletion of Jet Pack Adventure WP:RS||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21954 18406 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nagambie Football Club User:GarrieIrons 22:23, 24 June 2007 (UTC) delete every article on {{tl|Kyabram & District Football League}}. None meet or individually. Most of the material is a list of premiership wins, which would be better at Kyabram & District Football League ''where it is already listed Deletion of Nagambie Football Club WP:CORP||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
21955 13246 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cody Strait (2nd nomination) User:NY 05:57, 7 October 2011 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Cody Strait (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21956 9139 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Libcom.org (3rd nomination) User:Bilorv 01:05, 6 April 2021 (UTC) keep """there is some coverage of the website, like Sky Croeser's chapter and ''The Brooklyn Rail'' article. However, I think it's more important to see how the website is treated as a publication by those in the relevant subject area—similar to —and in this area we can see with a search on Proquest in |The Wikipedia Library or JSTOR or with a Google News search (tag with """"-site:libcom.org"""") that there are dozens to hundreds of meaningful citations in respectable works to libcom.org as a source. I'm not really sure what sort of search yielded only a primary source and a Reddit post""" Deletion of Libcom.org (3rd nomination) WP:JOURNALCRIT||WP:TWL||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21957 2801 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Lucie West Centennial High School User:Antonio_Lopez 04:44, 17 February 2008 (UTC) delete Per above. The article is all |POV Deletion of St. Lucie West Centennial High School WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
21958 21630 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Whippoorwill, Kentucky User:Eggishorn NONE merge to Logan County, Kentucky There really isn't anything worth merging and there really aren't any sources that fit within . Mere inclusion on GNIS is not guarantee of notability and appears to have been one of thousands of GNIS-only stubs created ''en masse Deletion of Whippoorwill, Kentucky WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
21959 2787 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M. E. Hart User:AuthorAuthor 01:48, 4 February 2020 (UTC) delete per nom. This so-called article displays a total lack of Wikipedia notability guidelines. No coverage and no notability of the subject has been shown. An online search turned up nothing significant. Sorely fails and flunks Deletion of M. E. Hart WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21960 20631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SDSU Sports Deck User:onel5969 16:56, 31 January 2021 (UTC) merge to San Diego State Aztecs, as before. Not enough in-depth coverage to pass Deletion of SDSU Sports Deck WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21961 17896 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/George Ferguson (Irish dancer) User:Scorpiondollprincess 16:39, 18 July 2006 (UTC) delete as per . He is acclaimed by whom? I agree with Vengeful Cynic; the school seems to be notable. Ferguson himself is not Deletion of George Ferguson (Irish dancer) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21962 2 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Seniha (şarkıcı) Kullanıcı:rapsarrapsar 10:05, 9 Aralık 2015 (UTC) keep Maddede belirtilen albümlere ek olarak başka albümleri de var, basit bir Google aramasıyla gözüküyor. kriterlerini karşılamakta Seniha (şarkıcı) silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
21963 11871 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeannette Kizirian User:יום 20:27, 5 April 2011 (UTC) delete Article does not meet Deletion of Jeannette Kizirian WP:PORNBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21964 3247 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jennifer Akiniymika User:Papaursa 01:46, 10 December 2019 (UTC) delete She's not come close to meeting . According to a link in the aritcle, her current world ranking in the 200m is 320th. Coverage appears to be routine sports reporting and is insufficient to meet Deletion of Jennifer Akiniymika WP:NATH||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21965 10270 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zombie vs. humans User:Realkyhick 21:05, 14 September 2007 (UTC) delete as I originally tagged. It is simply |something someone made up in class one day. Not notable Deletion of Zombie vs. humans WP:NFT Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
21966 18439 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PlaneShift (video game) User:Marasmusine 16:13, 3 April 2010 (UTC) keep first of all, the references will need vetting for reliability. It's pretty indiscriminate and there are a lot of sites linked to that simply do not pass . However, trawling through them I see ''one'' piece of significant coverage I'm happy to accept (About.com). I'm not completely convinced by OMGN or Warcry, I'll have to investigate further later Deletion of PlaneShift (video game) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21967 9880 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TUS Project User:Hello32020 13:51, 17 September 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of TUS Project WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
21968 17357 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eastern Glow User:Iridescent 12:04, 5 May 2008 (UTC) delete Fails , completely unsourced other than a myspace page and (even if the band somehow ''did'' pass and) appears unsalvageable in its current form Deletion of Eastern Glow WP:N||WP:B Wikipedia:Notability 77
21969 1845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tai Lopez User:Narky 11:21, 11 January 2018 (UTC) delete Four of the five sources are self-published or minor mentions. Only the ''Vice'' one is independent, but it isn't enough to establish notability (which requires multiple sources). Fails Deletion of Tai Lopez WP:NBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21970 17163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wikijumping User:Doc 15:38, 24 April 2008 (UTC) delete WP:NFT|madeup |nonsense Deletion of Wikijumping WP:NONSENSE Wikipedia:Patent nonsense 105
21971 21037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/St. Jude Catholic Church, Allen, Texas User:Metropolitan90 01:33, 24 August 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. Most individual religious congregations are non-notable per . Also, this article has no |independent sources Deletion of St. Jude Catholic Church, Allen, Texas WP:ORG||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21972 3100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shawn Johnson User:MER 08:18, 26 November 2006 (UTC) delete http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=%22Shawn+Johnson%22&btnG=Search ghits seem to be unrelated. Possible |verifiability concerns Deletion of Shawn Johnson WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21973 10245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Sargent User:GiantSnowman 11:28, 30 May 2017 (UTC) delete fails and . Scoring at a youth tournament is Deletion of Josh Sargent WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
21974 7800 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/United Football Club Philippines (2nd nomination) User:The 14:26, 23 November 2013 (UTC) delete full of unsourced speculation and fails . The names in the list of prospective players and absence of any GHits are all the signs of a hoax. Interestingly there is some coverage of a similarly named club in England, Philippine United Football Club - http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/global-filipino/06/01/10/uks-first-pinoy-soccer-team-finishes-2ndhttp://www.watfordobserver.co.uk/sport/4710565.Watford_based_side_hoping_to_find_players_for_Philippines_national_side Deletion of United Football Club Philippines (2nd nomination) WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21975 19764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sharia patrols (London) User:Alfietucker 09:21, 2 May 2014 (UTC) keep As per reasons given by Northamerica1000 - above all Deletion of Sharia patrols (London) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21976 13753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terence Linatoc User:Fenix 17:08, 23 April 2018 (UTC) delete Fails |NFOOTY as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a |fully professional league. The Philippines leagues is not fully professional. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy |GNG Deletion of Terence Linatoc WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21977 17117 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haakonian Order User:Protonk 07:38, 7 August 2008 (UTC) delete I would normally be inclined to keep an article based on some significant coverage in the star trek encyclopedia, but snippets provided in google books indicate that even the coverage there is trivial. Apart from that bit of coverage, there is not significant coverage from independent, reliable sources in order to meet the . Even if sources, the aside about Haakonian being inspired by House Harkonnen is exceedingly trivial. It might merit a mention in the House Harkonnen article...maybe Deletion of Haakonian Order WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21978 12664 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scenera Research (2nd nomination) User:Snotbot 16:31, 16 June 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 June 16 Deletion of Scenera Research (2nd nomination) WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
21979 1999 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Magnus Blaze User:Scarian 17:06, 2 January 2008 (UTC) delete fails and until 's can be found to prove otherwise Deletion of Magnus Blaze WP:BAND||WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21980 1810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Data Control & Systems User:AllyD 06:22, 8 June 2013 (UTC) delete """The section on """"Ownership History"""" indicates the firm went through a number of names in a short period, between UUnet and a final merge into Econet Wireless, but nothing is found to indicate its individual notability per . A viewpoint on :Talk:Data Control & Systems is well worth reading: the convoluting history of early ISPs is interesting (and probably under-documented) especially in that country's socio-political context, but broadening or repurposing this article in that direction would be |original research""" Deletion of Data Control & Systems :WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:NOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
21981 6815 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stéphane obadia User:Dissolve 16:24, 22 August 2007 (UTC) delete Sources found don't meet so the article fails Deletion of Stéphane obadia WP:RS||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
21982 3359 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of delicacies User:Doc 19:32, 4 August 2008 (UTC) delete """Inclusion of what a """"delicacy"""" would be is |indiscriminate""" Deletion of List of delicacies WP:INDISCRIMINATE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
21983 18167 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alba and Eire (Kushiel's Legacy) User:Jfgslo 01:49, 17 September 2011 (UTC) delete Fictional countries that do not meet the |general notability guideline and which article can only be a |summary-only description of a fictional work. The article is a |content fork and an |unnecessary split of the several Kushiel's Legacy-related articles and it is also devoid of references to justify its content Deletion of Alba and Eire (Kushiel's Legacy) WP:GNG||WP:PLOT||WP:CFORK||WP:AVOIDSPLIT Wikipedia:Notability 77
21984 14579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tony Ciccone User:John537 10:51, 15 August 2020 (UTC) keep """|notable film editor/actor during his 30+ year career. Body of work; 32 films, 11 TV shows, 1 video game and 2 music videos. IMDb lists Ciccone's domestic Box Office for 16 films at $847,257,098. He is the only """"hyphenate"""" Picture Editor/Actor that I am aware of. Since the dominate basis for article deletion nomination is mis-understanding that Ciccone did not 'rise above role of """"assistant"""" film editor', I will start with that. Motion Pictures Editors Guild has Ciccone classified a Z1 Motion Picture Editor (highest classification) since 1999. Other """"final credit"""" titles that can be attributed to a Z1 Picture Editor include; """"Additional Editor"""" """"Associate Editor"""" """"Editorial Consultant"""" """"Co-Editor"""". Meets Wikipedia:Notability (films)|WP:FILM Sources/significant coverage on his career. Google search for ''Tony Ciccone'' ''editor'' resulted in 93 global websites that include his bio and/or his resume; 5 """"celebrity"""" websites include bio/net worth/personal details; 3 websites contained articles on his work. Google's ''People Also Searched For'' included; |notable collaborators; Hans Zimmer, Tom Cruise, Paula Wagner, Robert Towne, Thandie Newton, Ving Rhames. One can make a reasonable presumption early in his career, that Ciccone appeared in TV Guide """"Guest Star"""" listings. Regarding IMDb Pro Starmeter system, where filmmakers are given a rating, Ciccone's career span has a much lower (better) star-rating than most other picture/sound editors listed in Wikipedia. This tells me that he specifically is popular. I will add more sourcing shortly, bear with me, I am a novice. Article has been live since March 17, 2008. The material is out there, the subject just needs a little TLC as opposed to deletion""" Deletion of Tony Ciccone WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
21985 16347 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valley life User:Belinrahs 17:20, 6 October 2009 (UTC) delete Also fails and Deletion of Valley life WP:NPOV||WP:ADVERT Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
21986 14319 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mrs. Scabtree User:WLU 19:44, 25 April 2009 (UTC) delete only two shows, neither broadcast? At best merge into a footnote of Manson's page. Doesn't pass and the trivial and |self-published sources aren't enough in my mind to justify a keep Deletion of Mrs. Scabtree WP:MUSIC||WP:SPS Wikipedia:Notability 77
21987 9820 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kumro (artist) User:Cerebellum 05:12, 4 December 2014 (UTC) delete fails GNG and Deletion of Kumro (artist) WP:CREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21988 10714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trebek effect User:OntarioQuizzer 08:39, 3 January 2007 (UTC) delete I've followed Jeopardy! and Trebek for the better part of two decades, and I've never heard of this one. Certainly fails as well Deletion of Trebek effect WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
21989 17877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Dandelion Girl (Visual Novel) User:Joe 22:47, 30 September 2009 (UTC) delete """I can't find significant coverage for this |online """"novel""" Deletion of The Dandelion Girl (Visual Novel) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
21990 4107 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brandon School and Residential Treatment Center User:Adamant1 12:45, 26 June 2021 (UTC) delete As the nominator says, private schools (I have my questions as to if this place even counts as one) have to pass and this article clearly doesn't come anywhere close to meeting NORG. Receiving some awards definitely isn't enough to do it Deletion of Brandon School and Residential Treatment Center WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21991 19732 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mithaq Kazimi (2nd nomination) User:Newshunter12 05:45, 22 September 2018 (UTC) delete The article should not have been recreated because the underlying reasons for deletion have not been rectified. He lacks so he fails or any notability guidelines and many of the sources in the article are unreliable, such as Twitter or IMDB Deletion of Mithaq Kazimi (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21992 11568 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NǽnøĉÿbbŒrğ VbëřřĦōlökäävsŦ User:Satori 23:14, 15 July 2008 (UTC) delete both as insufficiently notable per Deletion of NǽnøĉÿbbŒrğ VbëřřĦōlökäävsŦ WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
21993 12902 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patsy Presley User:Tarc 17:07, 1 April 2015 (UTC) delete """as notability is not inherited. This person has not done a single noteworthy thing in her life, and is only discussed in sources because of who she answered fan mail for and for who she was """"shopping buddies"""" with. This is precisely what is intended to protect the project from""" Deletion of Patsy Presley WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21994 7 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Türkleşmek, İslamlaşmak, Muasırlaşmak Kullanıcı:kingbjelicakingbjelica 08:06, 21 Kasım 2016 (UTC) keep Kaynaklandırılması için kd etiketi konmaz, kaynaksız etiketi konur. Kayda değerliği kati bir eserdir. 'ın beşinci kriteri değişmedikçe silinsin demek yanlış olur. Onun dışında bu eserin/kitabın kayda değerliği sadece Türkiye'deki okullardaki atıflardan bile anlaşılabilir. Mustafa Celâleddin Paşa'nın Eski ve Modern Türkler ile Léon Cahun'un Asya Tarhine Giriş adlı eserinden sonra Üç Tarzı Siyaset ve Türkleşmek, İslamlaşmak, Muasırlaşmak gibi eserler sıralanır. Sanıyorum benden maddeyi geliştirmem bekleniyor, buna vaktim de yok mecburiyetim de.. Ayrıca VP:KİTAP'ın beşinci kriteri tıpkı VP:Müzik ve kayda değer filmlerde başrol oynama kriteri gibidir. Örn ikincil olarak (akademik) incelenmeyen Kırmızı Saçlı Kadın adlı eser silinmeye aday gösterilemeyecek kadar kayda değerdir, çünkü kimse Orhan Pamuk'un kdliğini tartışamaz. Bu eser maddelerinin zamanla ne duruma geleceği bilinemez Bkz. https://tr.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bir_Tereddüdün_Romanı&oldid=16751771 bu sürüm ve güncel durum.. Tekrar ediyorum kimsenin bu maddeleri geliştirme mecburiyeti yok, eğer bu SAS gerçekten sayfanın kaynaklandırılması için açıldıysa Pragdon'dan rica edelim yazsın. Kaynaklar YÖK Tez Arama motorundaki Ziya Gökalp aramasında Türkleşmek, İslamlaşmak, Muasırlaşmak Vikipedi:KİTAP Wikipedia:Notability 77
21995 9515 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fr Dominic Valanmanal User:RebeccaGreen 12:04, 15 May 2019 (UTC) delete I do not see, and can't find, any in independent sources. There is one independent source in the article, ''News24Live'', which as another editor has stated above has one sentence and a video (which I am unable to view, so I don't know whether it's an interview, video of him speaking, or what). ''Dagen'' is also an independent source, but the only reference to him is a caption on a photo. I am unable to search for sources in Malayalam, but none have been provided in the two weeks this AfD has been running. Nothing about what he does or has achieved gives him presumed notability under Wikipedia guidelines (that is, I see nothing that would meet ). However important he may be to the Catholic Church, or some part of it, he does not yet qualify for a Wikipedia article Deletion of Fr Dominic Valanmanal WP:SIGCOV||WP:RELPEOPLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
21996 6675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UniquePhones (2nd nomination) User:Adamant1 03:19, 11 November 2020 (UTC) delete They sound like a pretty run of the mill unlocking service. There isn't anything to indicate otherwise, especially in relation to the absence of sourcing, and therefore they lack the notability needed to pass either or Deletion of UniquePhones (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:NORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
21997 15467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/1992 Indy Lights season User:Drdisque 18:11, 2 November 2020 (UTC) keep There is no valid basis for deleting this article. Not to but seasons of virtually every other professional motorsports league has articles. Why were these four seasons singled out? Because the nom thought the body was a bit light - that can be fixed and is not a reason to delete Deletion of 1992 Indy Lights season WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
21998 369 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brizzly (2nd nomination) User:Lemongirl942 03:31, 15 August 2016 (UTC) merge This is one of the numerous Twitter apps released everyday but was noticed and taken over by AOL and then killed off. Technology companies tends to receive a lot more coverage than others precisely because sources like techcrunch, mashable, gizmodo and numerous others specifically focus on it(which probably contributes to the on Wikipedia). Which is why it is important to see stuff in perspective. If you look at the sources, the app received a lot of initial publicity in 2009 when it was launched and later in 2010 when it was acquired by AOL. The next bit of news coverage it received was when AOL killed it off. (Some of the coverage btw deals more with the company not with the app; this article btw is solely about the app not the company). If we do the , is this app really significant in the grand scheme of things? For an app with such a short lifespan and whose sole claim of significance is that it was an app for Twitter, I would like a sentence of two of this to remain in the encyclopaedia, but there isn't enough for a page solely for itself (See ). A mention at a it of Twitter services helps to improve that page. I would suggest a redirect and selective merge to List of Twitter services and applications Deletion of Brizzly (2nd nomination) WP:SYSTEMICBIAS||WP:10YT||WP:PAGEDECIDE Wikipedia:Systemic bias 26
21999 14275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Man Beast: The Night of Death (movie) User:Jersey 02:46, 15 May 2006 (UTC) delete and move to Deletion of Man Beast: The Night of Death (movie) WP:BJAODN Wikipedia:Silly Things 72
22000 20864 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Himanshu Goel User:Coolabahapple 05:55, 16 December 2020 (UTC) delete does not meet , prolific does not equate to wikinotability, Goel's works https://www.worldcat.org/search?q=%22Himanshu+Goel%22&qt=results_page do not appear to be held in any libraries(?) which does not bode well, |wikiuseable reviews not found Deletion of Himanshu Goel WP:AUTHOR||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22001 21528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/MyFrostzone User:Stifle 22:31, 21 February 2006 (UTC) delete as advert and . If it was anyway serious it would have its own domain name Deletion of MyFrostzone WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22002 7938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Crimson Delight User:009o9 05:40, 20 February 2016 (UTC) keep Compact little article nice read. Funny thing, the more you search about a topic, the more Google turns up. Can take a few weeks. The editor should declare his/her on the talk page so we can remove the maintenance tags Deletion of Crimson Delight WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
22003 15724 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uncle Albert's Auto Stop & Gunnery Shop 2035 Catalog User:BOZ 13:08, 16 January 2020 (UTC) keep based on sources found, otherwise '''merge''' to Car Wars per and Deletion of Uncle Albert's Auto Stop & Gunnery Shop 2035 Catalog WP:PRESERVE||WP:ATD Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
22004 8427 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Unknown Crane User:Vectro 04:23, 18 October 2006 (UTC) delete or '''Merge''' per Deletion of Unknown Crane WP:FICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
22005 5552 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Iranian football clubs in 2010–11 season User:P199 19:44, 30 December 2011 (UTC) delete as per istcruft. Redundant Deletion of List of Iranian football clubs in 2010–11 season WP:L Wikipedia:Lists 97
22006 4757 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deborah R Williams User:Xtifr 22:31, 25 October 2006 (UTC) delete per A7 or G11 (either could apply). Otherwise, '''Delete''' per nom Deletion of Deborah R Williams WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
22007 2799 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of ex-gay people User:Scheinwerfermann 15:27, 14 August 2011 (UTC) delete """I struggle to |AGF on the creation and maintenance of this list of names. It and its associated non-|RS-at-best sources appear to be little more than an attempt to manufacture the appearance of legitimacy for scientifically dubious/discredited ideas like Conversion therapy. That is on top of issues with |BLP and |N. The """"keep"""" arguments appear to boil down to a fatuous |""""I like it, so it should stay"""" and a ginned-up attempt at conjuring the spectre of some nebulous (but ooooh, so indubitably scary!) """"precedent"""" under which vast swaths of lists would have to be purged from Wikipedia. Fortunately for the clarity of this present discussion, the notion of this kind of """"precedent"""" is inapposite per OTLAW""" Deletion of List of ex-gay people WP:AGF||WP:RS||WP:BLP||WP:N||WP:LIKE||WP:NOTLAW Wikipedia:Assume good faith 83
22008 4788 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/FullMAC User:Batard0 11:22, 23 October 2012 (UTC) merge as above. I found a few books in which they're mentioned briefly http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=ZtBnZoijaDcC&pg=PA28&lpg=PA28&dq=%22fullmac%22&source=bl&ots=cKW0Fow3ca&sig=CC7keXDSgcvEXhgxw6WBjLFg6Fc&hl=en&sa=X&ei=ynOGUOTpFqq20QX0-ICIBA&ved=0CC8Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=%22fullmac%22&f=false here and http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=f5Vz08spzw8C&q=%22fullmac%22&dq=%22fullmac%22&source=bl&ots=b19H9azGRO&sig=lJdvwhuDn3dg9Y9jTwtO1rmnQ7Y&hl=en&sa=X&ei=ynOGUOTpFqq20QX0-ICIBA&ved=0CDQQ6AEwAQ here and http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=JCf9jCPSfa8C&pg=PA128&lpg=PA128&dq=%22fullmac%22&source=bl&ots=u-Q-esoAEn&sig=LA5QVW-FwKs8JdOAwRuFpDXlv4Y&hl=en&sa=X&ei=ynOGUOTpFqq20QX0-ICIBA&ved=0CDgQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=%22fullmac%22&f=false here, but this doesn't rise to the level of significant coverage under , I would argue. These limited sources are better placed in another article where they can be treated with a couple of sentences Deletion of FullMAC WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22009 15269 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Convention Hall (disambiguation) User:Boleyn 09:49, 9 February 2015 (UTC) comment Is it clear that the one with the name Convention Hall is indeed the primary and is always/commonly known simply as 'Convention Hall' and the others are not commonly known as 'Convention Hall Deletion of Convention Hall (disambiguation) WP:PRIMARYTOPIC Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
22010 21612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/BackAndLay User:Kusma 11:08, 6 October 2006 (UTC) delete no |reliable sources given to |verifiably show the notability of this website Deletion of BackAndLay WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22011 6016 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trans-Siberian March Band User:Atlantic306 01:45, 27 October 2016 (UTC) keep as just passing , managed to fix some of the references including: https://web.archive.org/web/20111109020138/http://ukingeorgia.fco.gov.uk/en/about-us/our-embassy/social/brass-band British Embassy in Georgia, https://web.archive.org/web/20110927065432/http://www.musicomh.com/music/gigs/dj-yoda_0911.htm Music OMH, and https://web.archive.org/web/20120325215539/http://www.theartsdesk.com/new-music/mahala-rai-banda-and-trans-siberian-march-band-rich-mix the arts desk Deletion of Trans-Siberian March Band WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22012 5182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of scientists opposing the mainstream scientific assessment of global warming (3rd nomination) User:Oren0 00:48, 26 October 2009 (UTC) keep I do believe that this article has POV and OR issues, but I don't believe that those issues are inherent in the subject matter; they can be fixed. I don't see why this page is any more or than any number of lists of controversial subject matter, as noted above. Overall, I find the deletion arguments to be unconvincing and I don't see what has changed since the previous AfDs Deletion of List of scientists opposing the mainstream scientific assessment of global warming (3rd nomination) WP:POV||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
22013 6460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sharkboy and Lavagirl: Disaster on Drool User:MichaelBillington 02:13, 1 September 2006 (UTC) delete Per this page ( Deletion of Sharkboy and Lavagirl: Disaster on Drool WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
22014 15102 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canvas Infotech User:Logical 00:28, 4 January 2014 (UTC) delete poorly-sourced article that fails Deletion of Canvas Infotech WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
22015 3239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Davide Petrucci (2nd nomination) User:GiantSnowman 21:13, 3 March 2009 (UTC) delete per nom; player still fails . Recreate when/if becomes notable Deletion of Davide Petrucci (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22016 12294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frontside Promotions User:Ihcoyc 14:31, 7 July 2009 (UTC) delete WP:INHERITED|Notability is not inherited. I presume that a publicity firm will know the value of Wikipedia for search engine visibility, and as such lawyering over their notability is a side issue when the article in question also reads like #G11|obvious advertising: ''...an independent promotions company in Vancouver, BC, specializing in all areas of the music industry, including but not limited to Commercial/non-Commercial Radio Promotion, Publicity, Street/Lifestyle Marketing, Online Marketing, and Artist Management Deletion of Frontside Promotions WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
22017 25 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Now That's What I Call Music! 29 (U.S. series) 2nd nom User:Deor 03:38, 10 July 2008 (UTC) delete """All that I'm seeing on the """"official site"""" is """"'''NOW 29: November 4'''"""" with no further information. Can find no further substantive information. Fails at this time""" Deletion of Now That's What I Call Music! 29 (U.S. series) 2nd nom WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22018 4774 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sarah Ansari User:Montanabw 07:26, 1 October 2017 (UTC) keep Passes and . Adequate publications and accomplishments Deletion of Sarah Ansari WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22019 20352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Total Drama Wiki User:A 16:22, 28 November 2009 (UTC) delete as failing . Oppose userfying, as the article's creator has been indefinitely blocked Deletion of Total Drama Wiki WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22020 1045 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wes Carroll (radio & tv personality & publisher) User:23skidoo 12:28, 8 July 2008 (UTC) delete as per nom. ;) Seriously, though, there seems to be little to suggest notability outside his region. The magazine only has regional distribution and the Guiness record is unsourced. Nothing here really sets off the alarm, but there needs to be better sourcing to assert notability and right now I'm just not seeing any Deletion of Wes Carroll (radio & tv personality & publisher) WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
22021 4448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Islamic State of Iraq and Syria User:RJFF 20:19, 10 January 2014 (UTC) delete """This is premature. We do not know how long ISIL will be able to keep control over this territory and if they will be able to establish some degree of ''de facto'' state order. Wikipedia is not a news platform. It should be up to date, but creating an article about a purported """"state"""" that has only existed for a few days so far is an example of ecentism, which we should avoid. For now, it is completely sufficient if the article on the group mentions the declaration of independence and the current territorial control. The article about ISIL """"state"""" lacks (and will continue to lack) information on essential features that define a state, like geography and demographics, because it has no defined borders (not even ''de facto'' borders), because it will expand or shrink or otherwise change its shape depending on the moving frontlines between ISIL group and its enemies in the ongoing war. Conclusion: this """"state"""" lacks a defined territory, a definded people and we do not know yet if it has any kind of state order (unlike e.g. the aforementioned Somaliland, which has a defined territory, people and ''de facto'' state order""" Deletion of Islamic State of Iraq and Syria WP:R Wikipedia:Redirect 56
22022 7330 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prince Otto Heinrich of Hanover User:Bruddersohn 23:17, 2 December 2012 (UTC) delete Not up to the standards Deletion of Prince Otto Heinrich of Hanover WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22023 11013 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Death of Prince User:Richhoncho 21:15, 24 April 2016 (UTC) delete This is not a debate whether the death of Prince is notable, this a discussion whether the death of Prince should be in a separate article. Or in other words, just another meaningless debate on article namespace. The details regarding his death should be in the main article, if later, there is an argument based on , then a separate article might be appropriate. 3 days after his death is not enough, at least give it 40 days Deletion of Death of Prince WP:SIZE Wikipedia:Article size 51
22024 3489 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mary Pride User:Kicking222 12:54, 7 January 2007 (UTC) delete per nom. I also don't like persecuting CyberAnth, but in the same way, I don't like CyberAnth persecuting the nominator in this AfD. Throwing out these issues, there is still no evidence that Mary Pride meets Deletion of Mary Pride WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22025 10637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lime Media Marketing User:Alpha 02:56, 10 February 2012 (UTC) delete the subject of the article lack any coverage whatsoever in |reliable third party sources and fails to meet |notability guidelines for organizations Deletion of Lime Media Marketing WP:RS||WP:CORP Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22026 2908 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Griggs User:Ohnoitsjamie 13:55, 15 April 2016 (UTC) delete No games played in the majors, no evidence otherwise of notability Deletion of Scott Griggs WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22027 12471 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Duology (2nd nomination) User:Jontesta 15:28, 4 February 2021 (UTC) delete as a dictionary definition at best. Wikipedia explicitly says this is what articles are for. No to write a full article Deletion of Duology (2nd nomination) WP:NOT||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22028 16303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Charles Barwell User:Dhartung 03:58, 13 May 2007 (UTC) delete fails and contains no references establishing notability. The various offices seem like a ''claim'' of notability but none of them is really significant. Deputy regional chairman? You don't say Deletion of Charles Barwell WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22029 8934 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manheim Township Performing Arts User:Otolemur 19:48, 1 April 2008 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Manheim Township Performing Arts WP:N||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22030 3760 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dejan Bandović (2nd nomination) User:Pharaoh 02:35, 10 August 2017 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Dejan Bandović (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22031 6638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/NLT (band) User:Chubbles 00:27, 12 May 2009 (UTC) keep Charting singles pass . It would be harebrained to write articles for the singles and delete the band's page, rather than the other way around Deletion of NLT (band) WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22032 5947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fire department rehab User:Bejnar 07:41, 17 June 2013 (UTC) keep mostly because deletion is not cleanup. The nominator said: ''That there would be health services available to firefighters really goes without saying.'' But if one reads the introduction to the USFA Emergency Incident Rehab Manual, FA-114 one sees that that was not so obvious. That manual and the FireRehab.com site provide verifiability. I would urge the nominator to give up this Afd, and after it is over, to ruthlessly remove the |original research from the article, with appropriate comments on the talk page towards improving the article within Wikipedia guidelines Deletion of Fire department rehab :WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22033 2616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evan siemann User:Crusio 15:57, 10 February 2009 (UTC) keep Very strong citation record indicating that he is a major influence in his field. Web of Science lists several publications with hundreds of citations each (top 5: 598, 329, 207, 198, 126). Given that ecology is a field with rather low citation density makes this record even more impressive. Obviously meets #1 Deletion of Evan siemann WP:ACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22034 10128 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Valerie van der Graaf User:Ifnord 12:25, 24 December 2018 (UTC) keep Definitely meets criteria #1, as SI and Playboy are quite notable. is tougher but she's been in several papers, like when she turned down Jon Snow at a party. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-3467408/GIRL-TOWN-Oh-no-Jon-Snow-Game-Thrones-hunk-Kit-Harrington-fails-persuade-Dutch-models-share-vintage-wine-him.html Deletion of Valerie van der Graaf WP:NMODEL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22035 14891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Francisco Valero i Simó User:Theodore 02:38, 18 August 2013 (UTC) delete """The article appears to be a machine-translation of a Catalan Wikipedia page. While I'm not inclined to question the reliability of the given source, says that """"multiple sources are generally expected"""". There's no indication that Valero i Simó has received significant coverage anywhere else""" Deletion of Francisco Valero i Simó WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22036 172 [[Benutzer:Bibhistor/Überlieferungsgeschichte der antiken Literatur]] (erl.) Benutzer:Armin P. NONE keep Der Hinweis im Text ''Dieser Artikel ist im Entstehen und noch nicht Bestandteil der freien Enzyklopädie'' sagt eigentlich alles. Da es sich um keinen Artikel der wikipedia handelt, er sich also nicht im ANR befindet, greifen auch keine u.a. auch im Löschantrag formulierten Projektrichtlinien wie , WP:WSIGA oder WP:NOR. Ich sehe keinen Verstoß gegen Hilfe:Benutzernamensraum#Unterseite vorliegen. Auch das folgende trifft in diesem Fall nicht zu: Hilfe:Benutzernamensraum#Konventionen|Die Gestaltungsfreiheit der Benutzerseite hat Grenzen. Verletzungen der Wikiquette, persönliche Angriffe, Urheberrechtsverletzungen, Beleidigungen, den Ruf der Wikipedia schädigende oder strafbare Inhalte sind nicht zulässig. Daher Löschung von Benutzer:Bibhistor/Überlieferungsgeschichte der antiken Literatur Wikipedia:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
22037 15109 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/HongCouver User:Ds13 21:55, 19 October 2006 (UTC) delete The article's |citations give some notability and erifiability|verifiability to this nickname that not all nicknames have. (Its past, minor use is proven — verifiability is there. Its meaning is debated and too speculative and less important anyways.) Still, not enough for an article itself. But reference to the nickname need not be lost Deletion of HongCouver WP:CITE||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22038 2504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frances Griffiths User:Sjakkalle 07:47, 18 May 2006 (UTC) delete It is a G2 testpage. No need to bring this stuff to AFD, just let the speedy tag stay until someone deletes it or makes something resembling an article Deletion of Frances Griffiths WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
22039 17148 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of bus routes in Brighton & Hove User:Stuart 12:50, 23 March 2013 (UTC) delete """Transwiki to Wikivoyage or Wikia, or otherwise remove from Wikipedia. The policy |Wikipedia is not a travel guide does apply here, as does """"Wikipedia is not a directory"""" on the same policy page. Various routes have been to AfD but there's no real strategy as to which are taken to AfD and which we retain. Because of the pendulum swing from editors voting keep and delete there was an RFC at the village pump which equally could not draw a single consensus for keeping or deleting but advised that each list should be nominated individually. This article is only likely to ever be sourced to primary sources (either 1st party the bus company, or 3rd party the local authority) it's unlikely that any secondary sources will be found to establish either the individual routes or the list of routes as |notable and meeting the GNG. London is the rare alternative where there are reliable secondary sources but even it should be replaced by a prose article rather than a list with a list only to specifically notable routes, but the debate for that is probably some way off. Also broadly through nomination, there has been a clear consensus formed for deletion with multiple bus route list articles deleted in the very recent past (past 6 months) this compares to prior to that time when there was no consensus whatsoever with most AfDs tied and the occasional few closing either way""" Deletion of List of bus routes in Brighton & Hove WP:NOTTRAVEL||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22040 4923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muar Municipal Council FC User:Yk 03:08, 9 June 2011 (UTC) keep Passes per having played in a national cup Deletion of Muar Municipal Council FC WP:FOOTYN Wikipedia:Notability 77
22041 14660 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Craciun III User:Whiteguru 06:51, 13 July 2011 (UTC) keep article has notability in music and history of FM Radio. No obvious Deletion of Jack Craciun III WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
22042 11298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Laurentian Society User:Starblind 00:42, 13 February 2012 (UTC) delete per , student group at a single school. You know an article is in deep shit when the only references are to the school website and the school newspaper Deletion of Laurentian Society WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22043 10638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dmitry Erokhin (2nd nomination) [[User talk:166.239.110.60|talk]]) 07:16, 10 July 2020 (UTC) delete """fails (""""Trivial coverage of a subject by secondary sources may be used to support content in an article, but it is not sufficient to establish notability""""). Clearly (Unambiguous advertising or promotion) + undisclosed . '''Important:''' https://xtools.wmflabs.org/pages/en.wikipedia.org/Mark%20Ekimov 64% of pages deleted as promotion. Special:Contributions/166.239.110.60|166.239.110.60""" Deletion of Dmitry Erokhin (2nd nomination) WP:NSPORT||WP:G11||WP:PAID Wikipedia:Notability 77
22044 3603 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Da Bulldogs User:CheCheDaWaff 18:50, 23 October 2016 (UTC) delete """This article isn't notable as there isn't any """"significant coverage"""" () in the one reference present""" Deletion of Da Bulldogs WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22045 7 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Smokers Die Younger User:Arthurrh 00:43, 9 November 2007 (UTC) delete I don't see any notability established, and a quick web search mostly found sites created/managed by them. I didn't see anything from a third-party Deletion of Smokers Die Younger WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22046 17294 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Conspiracy journalism (2nd nomination) User:Jettparmer 18:46, 20 December 2010 (UTC) keep """Despite circumstantial claims of , this article meets WP standards as encyclopedic. The term or categorization is in use within both popular and scholarly circles. Stating that the article is simply """"essentially just OR"""" is highly subjective and unsupported in comparison to WP standards. Development of this article is warranted and suported by the simple presence of the term under a limited Google search""" Deletion of Conspiracy journalism (2nd nomination) WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22047 12887 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jessi Slaughter cyberbullying case User:Skinny87 08:30, 25 July 2010 (UTC) delete per Alison. This isn't worthy of anything past a tabloid newspaper mention, it's a BLP nightmare, and entirely Deletion of Jessi Slaughter cyberbullying case WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22048 5699 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Holly Harris User:Galerita 00:49, 28 January 2016 (UTC) delete I accept the criteria for deletion based on Wikipedia:WikiProject Figure Skating/Notability, but the article was sourced from the competition website, so I don't understand your objection on grounds Deletion of Holly Harris WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
22049 19416 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amir Butler User:Assize 07:58, 8 May 2007 (UTC) delete """No substantial secondary sources, therefore not notable according to Wikipedia policies. The only substantial source is an article in The Age written by Amir and is not about him. The article really needs more secondary sources to be considered notable. Otherwise, article needs to address """"The person is regarded as an important figure or is widely cited by their peers or successors"""" under . The article doesn't really address this""" Deletion of Amir Butler WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22050 3840 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Youness Lacchab User:Grailcombs 19:57, 18 March 2021 (UTC) delete Present sources doen't passes and his career has yet to show to meet Deletion of Youness Lacchab WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
22051 3033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scoil an Spioraid Naoimh User:Jackmcbarn 23:23, 2 July 2014 (UTC) merge to Bishopstown (and maybe mention it there) per Deletion of Scoil an Spioraid Naoimh WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
22052 825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of film series with two entries (3rd nomination) User:JimMillerJr 14:42, 18 February 2010 (UTC) keep Clearly meets the requirements for a stand-alone list and is part of a collection of lists that are clearly defined by number in a series. There are complimentary lists for List of film series with three entries|3, List of film series with four entries|4, List of film series with five entries|5 through the List of film series with more than ten entries|more than 10 list, that work together to classify film series by a clearly defined, discriminate set of criteria. I do not argue , but rather point out that merging all of these into List of film series would be far too large for our purposes, and would be the end result of deleting these seperate lists. None of the delete arguments specify policy-based grounds for deletion, and given the existence of a systematic classifaction among multiple lists, the inclusion criteria here are clearly not random in any way. Nothing has really changed since the last AfD that would provide a basis for a different result Deletion of List of film series with two entries (3rd nomination) WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
22053 10495 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canlubang User:SportingFlyer 12:42, 5 November 2018 (UTC) keep The article needs cleanup and references, but unless I'm mistaken? it seems to clearly pass both and Deletion of Canlubang WP:NGEO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22054 268 [[Kauf-Nix-Tag]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Mjh NONE keep ist genauso wichtig wie der Weltlachtag (Ebenfalls von Dir /30._April_2007#Weltlachtag (gelöscht)|zur Löschung vorgeschlagen!). Nur weil Dir diese Gedenktage nicht enzyklopädisch genug erscheinen sind sie nicht irrelevant. Es gibt genügend Leute die sich darüber Informationen erhoffen, warum soll sie diese denn dann nicht in der Wikipedia finden Löschung von Kauf-Nix-Tag Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
22055 5376 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brightpod User:Kvng 14:54, 11 August 2016 (UTC) keep """Significant coverage in cited reliable sources. The relevant definition for significant coverage is and this is clearly met. """"Insufficient coverage to sustain an encyclopedia entry"""" is a subjective assessment and not a valid -REASON. Other delete comments are also |not compelling""" Deletion of Brightpod WP:SIGCOV||WP:DEL||WP:JNN Wikipedia:Notability 77
22056 3580 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edith Espie User:RebeccaGreen 14:49, 3 December 2019 (UTC) keep I don't agree that having a street named after you gives presumed notability, but I believe that she meets . This article has been further improved with more sources. I have been meaning to go to the Northern Territory Library to check the books given as sources, and I will still try to do that Deletion of Edith Espie WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22057 18932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TalkShoe User:Tree 03:34, 12 June 2006 (UTC) delete per and . Alexa ranking of 1,052,188 http://www.alexa.com/data/details/main?q=TalkShoe&url=http://www.talkshoe.com Deletion of TalkShoe WP:SPAM||WP:WEB Wikipedia:Spam 112
22058 14637 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Philippe Coutinho User:Jimbo 15:58, 21 August 2008 (UTC) delete footballer fails notability at having never played in a fully professional league or competition. The transfer fee is not notworthy enough to keep the article. There is nothing of any value on the article at the moment to |ignore all rules Deletion of Philippe Coutinho WP:ATHLETE||WP:IAR Wikipedia:Notability 77
22059 3251 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mike Miller (wrestler) User:MER 06:54, 6 December 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Mike Miller (wrestler) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22060 1340 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joel Warady Group User:Ged 11:33, 25 February 2009 (UTC) delete as per . He might be notable, his company isn't Deletion of Joel Warady Group WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
22061 11498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sunpendulum User:W 11:00, 29 May 2007 (UTC) delete Sounds like an interesting artistic conceit but this here's conflict of interest, original research, non-verifiable and |crystal ball-ish. Should be on the artist's own webpage Deletion of Sunpendulum WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22062 16003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of country songs User:7triton7 04:09, 14 March 2009 (UTC) keep Let's not let the perfect be an enemy of the good Deletion of List of country songs WP:IMPERFECT Wikipedia:Editing policy 8
22063 4646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vincenzo Cox User:Atama 22:28, 12 August 2009 (UTC) delete I supported the proposed deletion, but I also understand why you started this AfD, I myself took some time before I decided to support the deletion, it wasn't obvious. He certainly has an interesting past, but in deciding whether or not to support deleting the article I considered both and . Under general notability guidelines there should be significant coverage of him, but the most I can find were when he was included in a list of players as the result of a sporting event, no actual coverage of him specifically. Under the guideline for athletes, he either had to have performed at the highest amateur level (which would be the Olympic Games or something equivalent) or performed professionally. As to the former, he only made it to the trials for the '96 Olympics but didn't qualify. In 1995 and 1997 he also was at the trials for the USA Track & Field World Championship, but again only the trials. As to the latter, he tried out for a professional soccer career but didn't make it. There might be a place to chronicle the efforts of an athlete who ''almost'' succeeds but fails each time, but Wikipedia isn't the place Deletion of Vincenzo Cox WP:N||WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22064 211 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deepak Singhal (banker) User:The 07:55, 20 August 2019 (UTC) delete per nomination on account of subject's lack of notability per criteria. All that one can find on the web, and indeed this is all that has been added since the AfD process started, were routine announcements of appointment and news about the banks rather than the person, who's at best name dropped (e.g. https://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/rbi-for-more-tier-i-capital-adequacy-than-basel-iii-norms-112030200035_1.html here; https://www.rbi.org.in/Scripts/NotificationUser.aspx?Id=7174&Mode=0 here; https://www.businesstoday.in/money/banking/rbi-reserve-bank-on-financial-inclusion-mission-kyc-jan-dhan/story/210886.html here; https://www.india.com/business/rbi-pushing-financial-inclusion-on-a-mission-mode-official-161101/ here; etc Deletion of Deepak Singhal (banker) WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22065 6582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Earth (2nd nomination) User:Mandsford 18:16, 1 April 2009 (UTC) delete per obvious ; sources cited are all written by persons living on that planet Deletion of Earth (2nd nomination) WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
22066 20501 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josetxo Grieta User:Bondegezou 11:42, 13 February 2008 (UTC) keep under criterion #6, that is the band includes Mattin, a notable musician in his own right (and there's too much material to merge Josetxo Grieta into Mattin Deletion of Josetxo Grieta WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22067 7810 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buildabazaar User:Fitindia 18:09, 7 May 2018 (UTC) delete Promotional article that fails Deletion of Buildabazaar WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
22068 4878 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Klaus Solberg Søilen User:Joseph2302 21:11, 18 June 2015 (UTC) delete As per FreeRangeFrog, doesn't quite pass or Deletion of Klaus Solberg Søilen WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22069 18051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Texts From Last Night User:Pokerdance 22:03, 6 August 2009 (UTC) keep """Are you serious? This clearly meets criterion #1 at as the site has """"been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself."""" See http://www.whas11.com/news/consumer/stories/WHAS11-090716-Top-Texting.4a0b263a.html here and http://www.herald.ie/lifestyle/the-best-way-to-land-a-book-deal--start-a-silly-blog-1845146.html here. And that's just from the ''references'', which not only means there might be more information about this site out there, but also suggests that you haven't even looked at the article. I wouldn't be surprised if you haven't; you've hardly bothered to give a decent nomination reason""" Deletion of Texts From Last Night WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22070 499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/N202LF User:Edtropolis 19:06, 13 June 2007 (UTC) keep Helicopters of that type meets criteria of otability. Needs improvement Deletion of N202LF WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22071 1823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/WHAV User:Mrschimpf 03:55, 11 July 2016 (UTC) keep Well meets easily Deletion of WHAV WP:BROADCAST Wikipedia:Notability 77
22072 261 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KDE Light User:Siva1979 04:02, 31 July 2007 (UTC) delete The lack of |reliable sources for this article is a major concern here. Moerover, it is quite difficult to |verify the contents of this article from third-party sources. --|S Deletion of KDE Light WP:RS||WP:V||WP:EA Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22073 16528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Camp Tel Noar (3rd nomination) User:Pontificalibus 08:48, 20 August 2019 (UTC) delete A search of books and newspaper archives reveals only passing mentions and event listings. The best I could find was https://www.newspapers.com/clip/35089394/tel_noar_reunion and https://www.newspapers.com/clip/35089435/laymens_tel_noar/, which isn't enough to satisfy Deletion of Camp Tel Noar (3rd nomination) WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22074 5490 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Future World Music User:James086 09:07, 13 February 2007 (UTC) delete I don't think it passes |company notability guideline so I'm also going to say delete. I also think there is a |conflict of interest due to the wording Deletion of Future World Music WP:CORP||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
22075 14914 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hans Ramzan User:Theroadislong 14:32, 8 June 2020 (UTC) delete Per nom, fails , primary sources, passing mentions and interviews with no Deletion of Hans Ramzan WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
22076 7527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dean hurley User:1292simon 11:36, 16 September 2014 (UTC) delete does not pass Deletion of Dean hurley WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22077 10453 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saint Johns Mission, Arizona User:onel5969 02:34, 5 December 2019 (UTC) keep Passes . There is no indication in the source that this officially recognized populated place is the same as the CDP, Komatke. Rather, the source shows that the populated place at one time was known as Komatke, long before CDP's even existed. But the personal attack is noted Deletion of Saint Johns Mission, Arizona WP:GEOLAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
22078 14266 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/21st Century Cyber Charter School User:Mommmyy 05:31, 8 August 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Written like an advertisement and lacks reliable source Deletion of 21st Century Cyber Charter School WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
22079 18291 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frankenshred User:Wisdom89 21:06, 2 March 2008 (UTC) delete per above, definitely fails - only references I can find are either blogs, myspace, youtube, or non-notable personal/fan websites Deletion of Frankenshred WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22080 12216 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dale Roberts (footballer) User:GiantSnowman 21:03, 6 October 2009 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Dale Roberts (footballer) WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22081 11679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oak Engage User:HighKing 17:16, 2 April 2021 (UTC) delete I am unable to locate any deep or significant coverage with |in-depth information on the company and containing |independent content, references to date fail the criteria for establishing notability, topic therefore fails Deletion of Oak Engage WP:CORPDEPTH||WP:ORGIND||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
22082 20153 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Great yarmouth high school User:Walton_monarchist89 14:58, 8 March 2007 (UTC) delete """for a variety of reasons. Could be db-tagged under G10 as an attack page - """"Great Yarmouth High School was established in 1886 as a Slave Labour Camp"""" - but probably better to let the AfD run its course. Only external link is to the school's own site, so no evidence of multiple non-trivial coverage in independent sources to establish notability per . Also semi-nonsensical in places, and uses wrong infobox (I realise these aren't reasons for deletion ''per se'', but they do detract from the article's credibility""" Deletion of Great yarmouth high school WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22083 17646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/San Trigo, Bastilion (fictional) User:Bejnar 21:27, 23 December 2014 (UTC) delete fails ''et al.'', no basis for notability claimed Deletion of San Trigo, Bastilion (fictional) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22084 9743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Day Sleeper User:FreeRangeFrog 18:46, 5 February 2009 (UTC) delete Fails , no reliable sources and I would have speedie'd it in a heartbeat if I had spotted it in new pages patrol Deletion of Day Sleeper WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22085 18523 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/X3 Generation User:HumbleGod 07:26, 8 July 2006 (UTC) delete """only 42 unique Ghits for site, 61 unique Ghits for """"x3gen"""" nickname. Appears to fail """ Deletion of X3 Generation WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22086 15458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2012 Roanoke Obama campaign speech User:CallawayRox 17:45, 14 August 2012 (UTC) keep """You didn't build that"""" passes easily. This AFD smacks of trying to Wikipedia:Speedy keep|""""end an editing dispute through deletion"""". AFD is """ Deletion of 2012 Roanoke Obama campaign speech WP:GNG||WP:NOTCLEANUP Wikipedia:Notability 77
22087 9793 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nokia 1600 (3rd nomination) User:Aervanath 19:14, 10 June 2008 (UTC) keep Merge and redirect''' to List of Nokia products.My initial instinct is to support Shoombooly, my |WikiProject Orphanage partner-in-crime. However, my friend, I think that your arguments for keeping this article speak more towards the fact that there are a lot of other articles which deserve deletion (see Edison's Caligula quote, above). Doing a cursory Google search for this phone only reveals the specs for this phone, and not any other reason it's notable. The Apple remote ''is'' notable, in my opinion, simply because it can be used for so much, and is pretty unique as far as remotes go, in that it is a remote for a PC, which is not a common thing. But cell phones are common as mud these days, and there doesn't seem to be anything unique about this phone that is not already covered by the cellular phone article. If you can find something specifically unique about it, then I would switch to keep. Until then, I would merge all the specs into the Nokia product article. Sorry, pardner Deletion of Nokia 1600 (3rd nomination) WP:O Wikipedia:Orphan 47
22088 6743 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carolyn Stafford Stein User:Bioforce12 19:44, 20 May 2020 (UTC) delete Not notable as per Deletion of Carolyn Stafford Stein WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22089 5151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Wells (politician) User:Cullen328 23:04, 5 April 2011 (UTC) delete As an unsuccessful candidate, he fails and no other claim to notability is made Deletion of Robert Wells (politician) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
22090 12941 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/KidCrusher User:W 02:57, 21 October 2007 (UTC) delete per failing 'n' the lack of reliable sources. and the albums too, obviously Deletion of KidCrusher WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
22091 14597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Singaporean presidential election, 2023 User:Number 13:53, 11 October 2017 (UTC) keep Needs rewriting in the correct tense (which I've now done), but not a crystal ball exercise; we have numerous articles on elections scheduled to happen in the next decade (United States presidential election, 2020, Norwegian parliamentary election, 2021, French presidential election, 2022, which are explicitly allowed under Deletion of Singaporean presidential election, 2023 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22092 10160 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jews of Rhode Island User:Hoopydink 01:38, 17 July 2006 (UTC) delete there could also be |copyvio issues here Deletion of Jews of Rhode Island WP:COPYVIO Wikipedia:Copyright violations 88
22093 679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asset management in Singapore User:Rusf10 04:50, 11 December 2017 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is not a directory Deletion of Asset management in Singapore WP:DIRECTORY Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22094 20640 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamaica–Serbia relations User:Pastor 23:02, 13 April 2009 (UTC) delete Does not meet standards Deletion of Jamaica–Serbia relations WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22095 4951 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roger Matas User:DoubleBlue 05:24, 27 September 2008 (UTC) delete fails and with only two passing mentions in Google News, no reliable sources to construct a , , article Deletion of Roger Matas WP:BIO||WP:V||WP:NPOV||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
22096 21656 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derek Chauvin User:Hut 17:42, 5 June 2020 (UTC) delete """this article is a fork of Killing of George Floyd, there is essentially no information in it which isn't in that article. The """"Background"""" and """"Involvement in the killing of George Floyd"""" sections, which make up most of it, were copied and pasted from Killing of George Floyd (without attribution, making this article a copyright violation). The remaining content doesn't offer anything which isn't covered in that article, aside from a few trivial details such as his marital status. Furthermore says that someone known in connection with a criminal event shouldn't have a standalone article if they can be adequately covered in some other article. That is clearly the case here as all the information in this article is also in Killing of George Floyd. also advises against having articles on alleged perpetrators of crimes who have not been convicted, here the subject hasn't""" Deletion of Derek Chauvin WP:CRIME||WP:CRIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
22097 1170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kiss and Tell (album) User:Talkingbirds 18:25, 9 August 2009 (UTC) merge to Selena Gomez until an official, sourced tracklist surfaces, or it otherwise passes . Right now, it's just speculation, other than the name. (No exercise for my |hammer today Deletion of Kiss and Tell (album) WP:NALBUMS||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:Notability 77
22098 1780 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Enrique's 10th Studio Album User:Ansh666 01:34, 31 August 2013 (UTC) delete classic case Deletion of Enrique's 10th Studio Album WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:TenPoundHammer's Law 1
22099 3272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark McCrindle User:Qworty 08:21, 22 April 2011 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Mark McCrindle WP:AUTHOR||WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
22100 639 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Von Ehrics User:Belasted 16:02, 1 March 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Von Ehrics WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
22101 10125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Franchise Hockey Manager User:FreeRangeFrog 01:15, 28 April 2013 (UTC) delete """All things aside, this won't be released (supposedly) until September, so let's not stretch that much. The """"coverage"""" seems limited to forums and whatnot, so I don't see how this gets past . Perhaps userify and then wait for it to actually be available and receive some substantial coverage""" Deletion of Franchise Hockey Manager WP:CRYSTAL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22102 352 [[OGame]] (erleidigt, LA bereits am 10. Juni abgelehnt) Benutzer:Kam Solusar NONE keep Das ist doch jetzt nur eine Racheaktion, weil die oben genannten Browserspiele SpaceVoyage, Herr der Sterne und Star Imperator hier gelöscht wurden. Das sie laut Impressum ihrer Webseite und der Spieleseite Geschäftsführer des Betreiberunternehmens dieser Spiele sind, läßt das ganze auch nicht unbedingt in einem besseren Licht erscheinen. Es wäre vielleicht angebracht, analog zu , als Hersteller/Betreiber lieber die Finger von Artikeln über eigene Produkte zu lassen. Wie man gesehen hat, ist die Enttäuschung danach meist groß Löschung von OGame Wikipedia:Selbstdarsteller Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
22103 9809 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Go hatchet User:JohnCD 14:50, 26 August 2009 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Go hatchet WP:NEO||WP:V Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
22104 13073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Ballinger User:Bkissin 16:24, 11 September 2018 (UTC) delete Per regarding candidates. My colleagues, esp. {{u|Bearcat}} have taken the words right out of my mouth on this one Deletion of Jamie Ballinger WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
22105 8430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/STAR: St Andrews Radio User:Samboy 04:10, 21 February 2020 (UTC) merge preserving history. This is part of the university, the university itself is obviously notable, so adding information about the radio station in the university’s page, even if it only comes from the university’s own sources, is OK as per Deletion of STAR: St Andrews Radio WP:ABOUTSELF Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
22106 21021 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dave Roland User:Sulfurboy 02:50, 21 April 2020 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Dave Roland WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
22107 3335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fred Meissner User:XOR 22:24, 8 January 2018 (UTC) keep The subject evidently meets . The article needs cleanup (I noticed some repeated text, for example), but that's not what AfD is for Deletion of Fred Meissner WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22108 18612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seventh studio album (Xzibit album) User:MattieTK 11:12, 4 December 2008 (UTC) delete All information would be speculation at the moment. Wikipedia is |not a crystal ball Deletion of Seventh studio album (Xzibit album) WP:CRYSTALBALL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22109 10898 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kull (Inheritance) User:Hemhem20X6 01:52, 19 September 2006 (UTC) comment What in justifies deleting that article Deletion of Kull (Inheritance) WP:FICT Wikipedia:Notability 77
22110 10498 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gary Young (businessman) User:Paulmcdonald 04:01, 7 August 2009 (UTC) delete violates and reads like a resume. Look Ma, I got a Wikipedia article Deletion of Gary Young (businessman) WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
22111 19149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vince Gotera User:Eric 00:57, 31 October 2009 (UTC) keep In addition to what has already been said above, he also probably meets criterion #1 (significant impact in scholarly discipline, broadly construed). One of this books, ''Radical Visions'', is held by 439 WorldCat libraries. COI issues aside, it is a well written and organized article Deletion of Vince Gotera WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22112 15355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ranjeet Jha User:MarkH21 01:55, 25 March 2021 (UTC) delete Roles fall short of and the only independent reliable source coverage (i.e. ) that I can find are passing mentions Deletion of Ranjeet Jha WP:NACTOR||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22113 16483 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pølsesita User:Colapeninsula 10:25, 3 August 2012 (UTC) delete Not even notable in the slightest way, as Google shows, and probably a hoax or thing Deletion of Pølsesita WP:ONEDAY Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
22114 1480 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teddi Gold User:Masumrezarock100 20:26, 24 July 2019 (UTC) delete Doesn't meet Deletion of Teddi Gold WP:SINGER Wikipedia:Notability 77
22115 17144 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bureau of Fire Protection Region VIII User:RioHondo 05:48, 11 August 2015 (UTC) keep The government agency is |notable given that it serves an Eastern Visayas|entire region of more than 4million residents. The fire bureau was most notably involved in the Typhoon Haiyan disaster response and retrieval operations, for which some of their firefighters lost their lives http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/nation/regions/11/21/13/bfp-recovers-1678-bodies-tacloban 1, http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/focus/12/04/13/dead-tacloban-firefighters-honored-heroes 2 http://www.rappler.com/move-ph/issues/disasters/typhoon-yolanda/43845-mass-burial-firemen-yolanda-rain-corpses 3, the Samar forest fire and even non-fire emergencies in the region. http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/580524/forest-fires-in-eastern-samar-put-out-report 4 http://www.coastguard.gov.ph/index.php/downloads/11-news/553-pcg-bfp-continues-search-for-missing-boy-in-tacloban-boat-sinking 5 Deletion of Bureau of Fire Protection Region VIII WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22116 15124 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Phoenix Game Engine User:RGTraynor 13:44, 22 April 2008 (UTC) delete """Sources are given for neither, they are both """"under development,"""" and in truth, a Speedy under A7 would be appropriate for both -- no assertion of notability is made. I'd almost suggest too, if either article asserted much in the way of future importance, which neither does""" Deletion of Phoenix Game Engine WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22117 8099 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meghan Trainor discography User:Joseph2302 16:24, 6 May 2015 (UTC) keep Seems perfectly fine to me, passes Deletion of Meghan Trainor discography WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22118 19709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jaijo Joseph User:Kthxbay 10:03, 20 April 2020 (UTC) delete as per Deletion of Jaijo Joseph WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22119 12891 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Is Blythe [[User talk:Czar|czar]] 04:02, 11 October 2017 (UTC) merge is reasonable |alternative to deletion, though its mention there should be sourced. Don't think this discussion warranted the relist Deletion of This Is Blythe WP:ATD Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
22120 19835 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thick Records User:Cupper52 11:24, 23 December 2020 (UTC) comment Was created in 2006, but wasn’t tagged for until October 2020 Deletion of Thick Records WP:NCOMPANY Wikipedia:Notability 77
22121 19697 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vinala language User:Firefly322 22:09, 13 May 2008 (UTC) comment It lacks notability (i.e., no references) which is not a good sign. But to call an aritcle a hoax when it clearly says itself to be an artificilially constructed language with 2 speakers suggests that all those saying something like are on a witch hunt, making the AfD process look really BAD Deletion of Vinala language WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
22122 5398 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of idioms in the English language (A) User:Recury 14:12, 21 November 2006 (UTC) delete obviously violates Deletion of List of idioms in the English language (A) WP:WINAD Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
22123 10933 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ontario United FC User:Kosm1fent 18:57, 11 September 2011 (UTC) delete ndash; The club (in its original format) hasn't played any higher than level 4 of the American league system. Clearly non-notable, and no significant media coverage about them to justify Deletion of Ontario United FC WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22124 2473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Federalist Party (Brazil) User:Coredesat 04:05, 29 June 2006 (UTC) delete nothing to assert notability (), |Wikipedia is not a soapbox Deletion of Federalist Party (Brazil) WP:ORG||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Notability 77
22125 17061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Legend (game publisher) User:Zxcvbnm 14:36, 28 December 2017 (UTC) delete Per Deletion of Legend (game publisher) WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
22126 8563 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Korean Mastiff User:Bearian 18:44, 7 February 2013 (UTC) delete no |reliable sources Deletion of Korean Mastiff WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22127 18470 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/An Instinct for Murder User:Phirazo 16:55, 29 August 2007 (UTC) delete TV episodes do not |inherit notability from the TV series, and this is simply a plot summary Deletion of An Instinct for Murder WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
22128 16589 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Quinn (Actor) User:Stifle 13:17, 23 February 2006 (UTC) comment Nobody |owns Wikipedia articles. If a user is persistently reverting to avoid consensus, raise an |RFC or use /I. You don't get the choice as to whether you have a Wikipedia article about you or not Deletion of David Quinn (Actor) WP:OWN||WP:RFC||WP:AN Wikipedia:Ownership of content 86
22129 17023 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wolfgang Digital User:AllyD 16:23, 4 May 2018 (UTC) delete """Various reports published by the firm have been quoted in media such as the Irish Times, but these fall under the """"Examples of trivial coverage"""" point of , as do the company's industry awards and appearance in local """"Fast 50"""" lists. The previous discussion mention in the """"keep"""" opinion above related to criterion which does not in itself establish a position of notability; nor is """"newsworthiness"""" a criterion here. All in all, a company going about its business, but I am not seeing |evidence of encyclopaedic notability""" Deletion of Wolfgang Digital :WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:A7||:WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22130 9974 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Danny Mastrogiorgio User:MichaelQSchmidt 06:30, 22 March 2012 (UTC) keep Initially, I see the fellow as meeting , and then in searches I see that he is sourcable for his work in theater as well.https://www.google.com/search?q=%22Daniel+Mastrogiorgio%22&tbm=nws&tbs=ar:1#q=%22Daniel+Mastrogiorgio%22&hl=en&tbm=bks&source=lnms&ei=P8pqT7_EH8HYiALwv9CBBQ&sa=X&oi=mode_link&ct=mode&cd=2&ved=0CCEQ_AUoATgU&prmdo=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.,cf.osb&fp=558bd53ac35959a0&biw=793&bih=459 While I see that it was poorly sourced only to IMDB when nominated, I see its potential. And THAT is something we can address Deletion of Danny Mastrogiorgio WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
22131 11946 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of breakfast foods User:The 17:00, 28 July 2018 (UTC) delete This is yet another attempt at a list with boundaries more open than Land Rush of 1889|1889 Oklahoma. If, at least, we had something along the lines of foods officially, commercially designated for breakfast, then we'd have something, ''perhaps''. Now, an expert writes an article about how your golf putting can improve by eating owl eyes over easy in the morning and, hey presto, it makes the list. |This is not what lists are here for, sorry Deletion of List of breakfast foods WP:LISTPURP Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
22132 16006 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Johnny Sudenberg User:Papaursa 03:05, 1 June 2014 (UTC) delete There's nothing to show he meets or Deletion of Johnny Sudenberg WP:NBOX||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22133 2516 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Albi the Squirrel User:Chris 16:48, 28 October 2010 (UTC) delete A lot more coverage than your average squirrel, but not enough to overcome Deletion of Albi the Squirrel WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22134 12020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lelo Sejean User:Alexius08 09:25, 9 January 2010 (UTC) delete obvious |bombing that occasionally linked to unreliable references. It cited various wikis, Yahoo! Answers, various blogs and other comparable resources Deletion of Lelo Sejean WP:BOMBARD Wikipedia:Citation overkill 60
22135 19064 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Buttprune [[User talk:Erpert|(let's talk about it)]] 18:19, 10 December 2010 (UTC) delete Less than ten Ghits, and only five are about the subject (four of which are Urban Dictionary). |Get on your winter coats, people. '''Erpert Deletion of Buttprune WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
22136 13214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Séamus Coleman User:Struway2 08:22, 26 June 2009 (UTC) delete per me on Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Seamus Coleman|his last AfD. Fails as never having played in a fully-professional league, and fails as sources never progress beyond the trivial level typical of media coverage of non-notable footballers. Recreate when and if he plays for Everton. cheers Deletion of Séamus Coleman WP:ATHLETE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22137 21684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Caged Angel User:Gene93k 00:14, 31 October 2008 (UTC) delete per and apparent . There is a Caged Angel on MySpace but little trace of them anywhere else. The claims in the article are ludicrous and completely unverifiable Deletion of Caged Angel WP:V||WP:HOAX Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
22138 10702 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VoicePulse (2nd nomination) User:TrulyBlue 17:04, 17 July 2008 (UTC) delete possibly speedily as it fails , no assertion of notability Deletion of VoicePulse (2nd nomination) WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
22139 1553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Watched By More Americans Than Any Other Network User:Springnuts 20:33, 2 February 2008 (UTC) delete not sure that applies, since some were existing phrases used by the networks, but I agree with the nomination - fails - and with the inclusion of the other articles Deletion of Watched By More Americans Than Any Other Network WP:NEO||WP:N Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
22140 14163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Action On Film International Film Festival User:NinjaRobotPirate 12:34, 18 February 2014 (UTC) keep Well, this festival is even lower profile than the previous one, but it's still got coverage in reliable sources: http://www.pasadenastarnews.com/general-news/20110729/action-on-film-festival-comes-to-a-close-in-pasadena Pasadena Star-News, http://www.pasadenaweekly.com/cms/story/detail/action_makes_a_comeback/7525/ Pasadena Weekly, http://www.ocregister.com/articles/festival-103606-film-aof.html OC Register, http://www.dreadcentral.com/news/45236/action-film-festival-heading-burbank-july Dread Central. discounts completely local coverage, but Dread Central is not local. ''The Orange County Register'' is also regional, I believe. It seems to satisfy , even if just barely Deletion of Action On Film International Film Festival WP:AUD||WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22141 3610 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ero Manga Sensei - My Little Sister and the Locked Room [[User talk:24.149.119.20|talk]]) 00:08, 27 November 2013 (UTC) merge to Tsukasa Fushimi. Only coverage is based off of an advertisement and/or press-releases, so the subject itself fails and for lacking ''independent'' coverage. Also, the success of a previous light novel series by the same author does not transfer notability on this light novel series. And the presumption that this light novel series ''will'' be successful and ''will'' establish its own notability falls under . Special:Contributions/24.149.119.20|24.149.119.20 Deletion of Ero Manga Sensei - My Little Sister and the Locked Room WP:NOTE||WP:BK||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
22142 11371 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Basanta Dhakal User:Bearian 20:34, 24 May 2017 (UTC) delete a with |no reliable sources: a whole bunch of blogs, social media, and a dead link to MTV redirecting to its main page Deletion of Basanta Dhakal WP:BLP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
22143 12025 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Olli Petra User:StrPby 13:47, 26 October 2010 (UTC) keep """per : """"Sports figures are ... presumed notable if they have participated in a major international amateur ... competition at the highest level"""". As Olympic medal winners - most individual NOCs refer to them as such - they are inherently notable""" Deletion of Olli Petra WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
22144 318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of world's most expensive transport infrastructure User:Ivanvector 18:02, 5 March 2015 (UTC) keep very good points made by nominator, but I think this list can be fixed rather than deleted. I don't think it is necessarily to have a superlative list based on a comparison of reliably-sourced information - comparing dollars to dollars is not |original research. I agree that it would be better divided into lists by type of infrastructure, but I think the key for longer-term projects is following the sources to determine which qualify as singular projects versus combinations of separate projects. For example, the Interstate Highway System is commonly referred to in reliable sources as a singular venture and there is a reliable source for its singular cost, although individual improvements are considered separate (e.g. Big Dig). Other large maintenance projects are considered separate infrastructure projects (e.g. Eastern span replacement of the San Francisco–Oakland Bay Bridge), and some projects are actually several smaller projects lumped together as one major project by reliable sources (e.g. Honshū–Shikoku Bridge Project). Probably the list should only include projects which are complete or substantially under construction; projects which are well-known but aren't approved can't have a reliable source for their cost and shouldn't be included (looking at you, Hurontario-Main LRT). Reliable sources should be available in the linked articles; it's a different problem if they're not Deletion of List of world's most expensive transport infrastructure WP:SYNTH||WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22145 12942 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pop Eyed User:Gongshow 16:38, 9 August 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find any significant coverage for this compilation in |reliable sources; appears to fail Deletion of Pop Eyed WP:RS||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22146 221 [[Walid_Nakschbandi]] (bleibt) Benutzer:'ElLo57 NONE keep Relevanz gegeben, Löschgrund nichtig. Jemand aus der im Thema? Aber auch ohne ''sofortige'' Überarbeitung jedenfalls Löschung von Walid_Nakschbandi Wikipedia:QS Wikipedia:Cleanup 82
22147 17520 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marlton Circle User:JimMillerJr 21:52, 13 January 2011 (UTC) keep Work done by Alansohn has shown that there are sufficient sources to support the article according to the . I would also note that even if the circle is scheduled to be eliminated, would provide for keeping the article as a stand alone, and not merge/redirect to something less. Since sources exist, the stub can be expanded through regular editing by ''any'' editor Deletion of Marlton Circle WP:GNG||WP:NTEMP Wikipedia:Notability 77
22148 19326 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rare Carat User:MER 14:42, 23 February 2018 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Rare Carat WP:NOTSPAM Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22149 17745 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adílio Varela User:Nfitz 19:58, 5 April 2020 (UTC) keep meets . If they possibly don't meet GNG, then should be applied, so that at least it's probable. Though entirely moot as either NFOOTBALL or GNG should be met, unless this a former footballer who has only made a very brief fully-professional appearance - which is not the case Deletion of Adílio Varela WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22150 16727 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cylon War User:A_Nobody 16:40, 21 July 2009 (UTC) keep as frivolous and disruptive mass nomination. No none with any actual knowledge on fictional subjects would say to delete these articles, which means the only so-called basis for deletion is . In any event, because these |notable subjects can be |verified in |reliable sources they constitute out of universe unoriginal research and even appear in published encylopedias. We may not be the Battlestar Wiki, but we are not Encyclopedia Britannica either and we cover articles that Britannica cover just as we include articles that appear in other encyclopedias as per our first pillar we are a combination of general and specialized encyclopedias. In any event, the above elements of fiction appear in a franchise that spans video games, books, three TV series (original, reimagined, and upcoming prequel series), multiple miniseries/TV films, etc. as seen at Deletion of Cylon War WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:N||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
22151 8825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Defeatschool User:Torinir 23:55, 15 September 2006 (UTC) delete NN site, fails Deletion of Defeatschool WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22152 367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IdeaSIP User:Jayvdb 20:41, 18 January 2007 (UTC) comment Special:Contributions/Eneref is a , and almost certainly a COI Deletion of IdeaSIP WP:SPA Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
22153 20704 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kraftwurx User:Andy 14:17, 29 November 2011 (UTC) keep I expect to see this deleted, and perhaps rightly so, for lack of 3rd party coverage. However this business sector, outsourced 3D print, is a growing and important one. I expect to see Kraftwurx as a very obviously notable player in this field before long, even if article is currently premature. Once again Wikipedia seems to be making itself ridiculous with repeated calls to delete Makerbot, Thingiverse, Shapeways et al and it would be a shame to act over-hastily on Kraftwurx too, just to satisfy Deletion of Kraftwurx WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
22154 14551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ray Du English User:Whjayg 17:24, 29 September 2018 (UTC) delete """I couldn't find substantial coverage of reliable sources for this, and I couldn't understand the purpose / contents of the article --> Sorry I dont understand what this article is all about. Is it a song? Or is it about brother and sister? Or is it a talk show or reality TV or education channel? Or is it a video on youtube? Not sure whether it was the """"English"""" or it simply not noted enough for it to be expanded. To me, this article fails """ Deletion of Ray Du English WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22155 8122 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lila Azam Zanganeh User:David 01:33, 4 March 2010 (UTC) delete """As far as I can tell from http://bokcenter.harvard.edu/icb/icb.do?keyword=k1985&pageid=icb.page29684&pageContentId=icb.pagecontent79570&view=view.do&viewParam_name=fall%2FCUEfall99.html this link, the """"has taught at Harvard"""" part of the article just means that she was a section leader there, not that Harvard hired her as faculty. Even if they had, that's not enough for . And I don't think enough notability accrues from having written a few pieces in notable newspapers, either""" Deletion of Lila Azam Zanganeh WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22156 4301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kadrolsha Ona Carole User:PaleoNeonate 21:36, 27 October 2017 (UTC) delete I have tried to find more references in reliable sources like newspapers but failed. Cameo appearences also don't count, even in the filmography of notable actors. The movie(s) also appear rather underground. I know of the Toxic Avenger, but never heard of Toxic Tutu before. It's possible that future events may increase notability and that it's simply Deletion of Kadrolsha Ona Carole WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
22157 18538 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2019 Boeing 737 MAX crisis User:AEMoreira042281 02:52, 12 March 2019 (UTC) keep since 1978, a mass grounding of an aircraft type has only happened 3 times...when the DC-10's type certificate was suspended by the FAA after American Airlines Flight 191 crashed less than a minute after takeoff (138 were grounded in the USA where the plane was a workhorse at the time), the Boeing 787 Dreamliner after Boeing 787 Dreamliner battery problems|battery issues cropped up (with 50 grounded and the most severe effect in Japan, and now this, with (as of this post) 135 MAX 8 aircraft grounded to date. A significant portion of an aircraft type being grounded is rare, with this being just the 3rd example in 40 years, and thus, in my opinion, this satisfies Deletion of 2019 Boeing 737 MAX crisis WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22158 4677 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Indiefeed User:Stifle 00:09, 26 December 2005 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Indiefeed WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22159 8012 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jock Tamson's Bairns User:Badgerpatrol 23:43, 7 May 2006 (UTC) keep Tempted to vote delete per but the notability and cultural significance of the phrase (and the OK quality of the stub) are such that I suggest we keep it. I would suggest that cultural significance IS a decent metric by which to judge such articles Deletion of Jock Tamson's Bairns WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22160 5611 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National Youth Party User:Slon02 04:52, 15 November 2011 (UTC) delete per nom and Deletion of National Youth Party WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22161 4747 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jason Shepherd User:Robin99 16:01, 14 February 2007 (UTC) delete per nom, essentially a vanity article and as above doesn't comply with Deletion of Jason Shepherd WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
22162 13899 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kulim Lake Garden (2nd nomination) User:Alpha 00:37, 15 March 2012 (UTC) delete The subject of the article lacks |significant coveage in |reliable third party sources and fails the |notability guidelines Deletion of Kulim Lake Garden (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22163 14739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dark Angel (BDSM) User:Edison 04:16, 8 October 2008 (UTC) delete No independent and reliable sources presented to satisfy |the notability standard for biography articles, and the article reads like an advertisement Deletion of Dark Angel (BDSM) WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22164 2318 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Professor A.L.I. User:Ohnoitsjamie 02:07, 8 December 2015 (UTC) delete None of the sources listed appear to meet guidelines Deletion of Professor A.L.I. WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22165 18236 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tyler Hayes Weinman User:Lord 19:46, 16 June 2009 (UTC) delete per . This is a person who is in the news for a single insignificant event and is not otherwise notable Deletion of Tyler Hayes Weinman WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
22166 2527 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aaron Herzberg NONE NONE delete Classic example of which excludes this type of article. Additionally, fails , and . Article and references do not establish anything notable about the subject - plenty of lawyers earn over $1 mil. a year, plenty of people own cannabis dispensaries, plenty of people are partners at non-notable companies. No amount of sourcing or editing is going to make the subject notable Deletion of Aaron Herzberg WP:NOT||WP:GNG||WP:BASIC||WP:BIO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22167 19296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jhoon Rhee User:SkierRMH 18:11, 23 December 2006 (UTC) delete per and in the sense that there are no 3rd party verifications of nontariety Deletion of Jhoon Rhee WP:BIO||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
22168 8385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeff Fox User:JzG 22:33, 27 April 2007 (UTC) delete unsourced, Deletion of Jeff Fox WP:COI Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
22169 12565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of car-free people User:Nagle 05:19, 9 June 2006 (UTC) delete as listcruft/trivia, per Deletion of List of car-free people WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22170 10621 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Virginia gubernatorial election, 2013 User:Blodance 06:23, 31 December 2009 (UTC) keep The exemption is clearly stated in for such articles, but this article is unrefed now. If this is OR, then delete it Deletion of Virginia gubernatorial election, 2013 WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22171 9063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S23 Wiki (second nomination) User:Agnte 13:06, 6 February 2006 (UTC) delete per nom, non-notable website, as defined in Deletion of S23 Wiki (second nomination) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22172 16037 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Madelyn Dunham User:Americasroof 03:34, 12 March 2008 (UTC) keep She raised Obama from age 10 on while his mother was running around the world and is discussed in Obama's best selling book. She is Obama's only living ancestor and thus subject of numerous articles (and thus subject of numerous articles -- particularly those delving into his white background including the claim that Obama facial appearance is similar to his maternal grandparents). says '''A person is presumed to be notable if he or she has received significant coverage in reliable secondary sources that are independent of the subject.''' At this writing I see at least six sources. A book and numerous sources is more than enough to meet the criteria Deletion of Madelyn Dunham WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22173 13243 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Use of Quotations within Your Dissertations User:AllyD 11:47, 8 August 2017 (UTC) delete Non-encyclopaedic content Deletion of The Use of Quotations within Your Dissertations :WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22174 11020 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethan Cooper User:Ejgreen77 00:53, 2 October 2018 (UTC) keep Meets and , per Cbl62's sources Deletion of Ethan Cooper WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22175 3845 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Brendan Munnerlyn [[User talk:204.126.132.231|talk]]) 18:38, 30 July 2014 (UTC) delete Fails and .Special:Contributions/204.126.132.231|204.126.132.231 Deletion of Brendan Munnerlyn WP:NGRIDIRON||WP:NCOLLATH Wikipedia:Notability 77
22176 10545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/YMS-15 Gyan User:Fordmadoxfraud 03:31, 23 May 2007 (UTC) delete In the ''distance''? Have you looked at the Gundam template/infobox at the bottom of that page? We're already there! I agree with deletion here only because this article is hopelessly in-universe. For better or worse (probably worse) articles about every single Gundam variant are here to stay I think. Their sheer profusion constitutes precedent (and not just in that sense Deletion of YMS-15 Gyan WP:OTHERCRAPEXISTS Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
22177 8865 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ann Grocott User:Deus 08:20, 12 March 2021 (UTC) comment are you able to point us to where your work has been covered (to a significant extent - ie. a feature article on you, etc., not just a one-off mention of an exhibition)? We're struggling to find sources to meet |Wikipedia's guidelines on notability Deletion of Ann Grocott WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22178 11497 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Volkers User:Bejnar 20:57, 8 July 2021 (UTC) merge """The only mentions of :Scott Volkers at :Swimming Australia are for allegations of child sexual abuse, so given the ''raison d'etre'' of the nominator that would not be a good choice. Apparently (although not mentioned in his current article), he was the head coach at the :Commercial Swimming Club in Brisbane, but he is not mentioned in that article. The allegations are discussed in a long paragraph (probably ) at the prosecutor's article :Margaret Cunneen#Notable cases. In the :Samantha Riley article it mentions without citation """"She had failed a drug test, and was only exonerated after her coach Scott Volkers admitted to giving her a headache tablet which contained the banned substance."""" In the :Australian Sport Awards article it mentions in a table, his 1995 """"Coach of the Year"""" award. There does not appear to be a viable target for any redirect. Overall, if he is not notable, ''aside from the allegations'', then the article should be '''deleted'''; it doesn't seem that such deletion would cause any loss of information, outside of the allegations. Also, per the nominator's ({{ping|DanCherek}}) rationale, the section :Margaret Cunneen#Notable cases|Notable cases in the :Margaret Cunneen article, and the mentions in the :Swimming Australia article should be cleaned up""" Deletion of Scott Volkers :WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
22179 10772 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ignacio Anaya User:Britishfinance 00:56, 16 August 2019 (UTC) keep There is clearly a lot of GNG from strong re this subject, not just from his being the subject of a Google Doodle (''The Independent'' https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/ignacio-anaya-garcia-google-doodle-nachos-who-profile-124-birthday-mexico-city-a9060801.html, ''USA Today'' https://eu.usatoday.com/story/tech/2019/08/15/google-doodle-nachos-inventor-ignacio-anaya-garcia-honored/2015881001/, ''Fortune (magazine)'' https://fortune.com/2019/08/15/ignacio-anaya-garcia-nachos-google-doodle/, ''Time (magazine)'' https://time.com/5652911/google-doodle-nachos-ignacio-anaya-garcia/; there are lots more), but even before that, he has been given a section in several notable books on food as the creator of the nachos (I added a reference from the ''Oxford Companion to American Food and Drink'' (he gets two pages), and another notable book on US food by a notable author, Josh Chetwynd; again, I could have added several more books), and other RS, such as ''Huffington Post'' from 2012 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/nachos-inventor_n_1515233, that pre-date his appearing on Google Doodle. does not ''exclude'' a subject from being a BLP; it sets the conditions under which a BIO1E can be a BLP, and says: {{tq|On the other hand, if an event is of sufficient importance, even relatively minor participants may require their own articles}}. Inventing Nachos is notable (even Google recognise it), and he is the recognised inventor Deletion of Ignacio Anaya WP:RS||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22180 21578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sad Bin Kader Chowdhury user:Jenyire2 07:04, 4 February 2021 (UTC) delete Fails in its field Deletion of Sad Bin Kader Chowdhury WP:SIGCOV Wikipedia:Notability 77
22181 5367 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Homeless women in the United States User:Snotbot 17:08, 2 April 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 April 2 Deletion of Homeless women in the United States WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
22182 19181 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Damezi Anderson User:Ejgreen77 11:48, 2 June 2018 (UTC) keep Meets and , per Smartyllama's sources above Deletion of Damezi Anderson WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22183 8922 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sri Rama Rao Gandikota User:Tsistunagiska 21:01, 8 January 2021 (UTC) delete After a search the subject has not received in a therefore does not meet the notability requirements and should not be included in the encyclopedia Deletion of Sri Rama Rao Gandikota WP:BEFORE||WP:SIGCOV||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
22184 19855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DhoomBros (2nd nomination) User:DaltonCastle 01:38, 15 April 2016 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of DhoomBros (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22185 20380 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stranded (Dave Kerzner song) User:Davey2010 15:42, 30 April 2015 (UTC) keep As someone who's witnessed the back and fourth arguments between these 2 it's clear to anyone this is simply a |POINTy nomination, Cant you both kiss and make up Deletion of Stranded (Dave Kerzner song) WP:POINTY Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
22186 14396 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boss (Life's Work) User:Mrschimpf 00:28, 23 February 2012 (UTC) delete Show was a very humdrum sitcom without any unique elements at all, and this episode was par for the course for a 1996 sitcom, with an article editor who is |overstating the impact of this show immensely. Also looking at the infobox titlecard for the show, isn't there a standard where we discourage animated GIF images (and it's not even the titlecard, it's a promo for the show.)? Also advising ''Banquet (Life's Work)'' be added to this nom; both sources are to editable content sites, leaving it questionably sourced Deletion of Boss (Life's Work) WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Fancruft 70
22187 3755 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jared Staal User:Nurmsook 17:09, 11 January 2011 (UTC) keep """WP:SNOW and per Ravendrop. Let's be honest, the Staal family and its individual members have probably established more notability in recent years than any other family in this country, including the Harpers or any other recent PM. Seriously, their ''parents'' could pass based on the coverage they have received. So to say that one of their sons doesn't is ludicrous. Step 9 in mentions that """"before nominating due to sourcing or notability concerns, make a good-faith attempt to confirm that such sources don't exist"""". I'm not sure these attempts were made for this article. If they were, this article would not be at AfD. At any rate, this article is an easy pass at GNG""" Deletion of Jared Staal WP:GNG||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22188 7143 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Safe Home User:Azealia911 18:47, 22 December 2015 (UTC) delete Fails , a non-notable single Deletion of Safe Home WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22189 8273 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trisha Woodward User:DrunkenSmurf 20:22, 8 August 2006 (UTC) delete No sources can be found that would help this subject meet Deletion of Trisha Woodward WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22190 20661 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bob Rupe NONE NONE keep """I can't agree with the stated basis for the nomination: Rupe clearly passes #6. The Silos and Cracker (band)|Cracker were not """"barely notable"""" bands, and he was a significant member of both, as well as being connected with a number of other notable bands, all as documented in the article and in plenty of potential sources viewable (but mostly paywalled) at GNews and HighBeam. In my view, the only substantial reason to consider deleting this is that an IP editor has come to the page, identifying himself as Bob Rupe, has repeatedly removed content from the article, and has repeatedly marked it for deletion. He objected to inclusion of Rupe's real name http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:24.125.180.232&diff=prev&oldid=554212066; a few hours later he posted the following at the Help Desk: """"Please delete this article http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bob_Rupe. I do not want to have a page of my personal life on your site. In fact, I insist it be removed."""" http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Help_desk&diff=prev&oldid=554235487""" Deletion of Bob Rupe WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22191 3155 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Epicureans User:Sjakkalle 08:20, 27 September 2005 (UTC) delete no evidence of having passed Deletion of The Epicureans WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22192 9936 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mayer Hawthorne User:DustFormsWords 23:12, 19 October 2009 (UTC) delete even if there are reliable sources, those sources need to attest to the notability of the subject. None of the claims in the article pass any of the criteria at Deletion of Mayer Hawthorne WP:NMUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22193 378 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Europeanization of the Scriptures User:DustFormsWords 03:59, 24 May 2010 (UTC) delete No sources provided establishing notability of topic. The nature of the topic makes independent searches for notability problematic at best. Much or all of the article appears to be |original research or at the very least unsourced. No clear rationale is provided for why this material can't be dealt with in existing Bible articles, making it an impermissible |content fork Deletion of Europeanization of the Scriptures WP:OR||WP:FORK Wikipedia:No original research 65
22194 11940 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cal Arnold O'Driscoll User:Guliolopez 10:02, 14 June 2019 (UTC) delete per nom and notes above. Doesn't meet . The single claim to notability (involvement in one young person's film-making competition) is not substantive enough to meet the criteria. The and policies should also be considered here. (Both in terms of the article and this discussion Deletion of Cal Arnold O'Driscoll WP:GNG||WP:MINORS||WP:CHILD Wikipedia:Notability 77
22195 9193 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haridas (director) User:Velella 07:53, 12 July 2017 (UTC) delete No evidence of any notability. Own web-site, his own quotes and peripheral mentions only in film reviews. Fails ''''' Deletion of Haridas (director) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22196 7706 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lilo Gloeden [[User talk:24.151.116.12|talk]]) 19:16, 24 February 2018 (UTC) keep """I added a couple references and others may be found (many in German) by searching books or scholar for """"Elisabeth Gloeden"""", satisfying . In editing the article, I've put the focus more on the family as a unit and a rename might be appropriate if kept in this form. Special:Contributions/24.151.116.12|24.151.116.12""" Deletion of Lilo Gloeden WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22197 21948 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kamal Benslama User:Dominus 19:04, 28 February 2012 (UTC) delete Most of the sources provided are not independent. Of the rest, one is a local news story, and one is a radio program where the subject was invited to explain research results from the Hadron collider. it doesn't focus on him specifically. Doesn't meet the requirements of . While the publication list is impressive, it probably does not accuraely refelct his personal output, as explained by Guillaume above. Being team leader of a project is not really notable. My own search turned up no good sources establishing notability. Sources provided by or proposed by Kamalbenslama above (apparently the subject of the article) are run-of-the-mill or not independent. In short, a hard-working, productive young professor, but not distinguished enough by substantial independent coverage to justify an independent article Deletion of Kamal Benslama WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22198 7767 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luke Whitehead User:Rikster2 14:28, 7 February 2018 (UTC) keep He actually meets having played in the Australian National Basketball League. But I would also argue he meets GNG (even if barely) with articles like https://theundefeated.com/features/luke-whitehead/ this and http://www.sfgate.com/sports/article/Shooting-for-the-NBA-Ex-city-star-Whitehead-2787319.php this and https://www.newsday.com/news/nation/former-louisville-star-arrested-1.1399995 this Deletion of Luke Whitehead WP:NBASKETBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
22199 19839 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Steven Suptic User:TonyBallioni 14:51, 8 August 2017 (UTC) delete non-notable internet personality. Sourcing does not meet the general guideline found as part of Deletion of Steven Suptic WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22200 9038 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tamara Bach User:Marc 04:50, 5 October 2009 (UTC) keep """per . The Deutscher Jugendliteraturpreis award win for ''Marsmädchen'' and subsequent nomination for ''Busfahrt mit Kuhn'' is notable. The :de:Luchs (Literaturpreis)|Luchs prize seems less notable or at least the German WP article is not citing/referencing it well. Nominator, has """"The person has received a ''notable'' award or honor..."""" and not """"major."""" I interpret ''notable'' in that case to be notable per WP rules and usually also look over the award article to see if it seem to be a bona fide """"notable"""" subject""" Deletion of Tamara Bach WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22201 9259 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trouble Ticket Express User:RoySmith 12:43, 1 June 2014 (UTC) delete Fails . But, thank you to new wikipedian {{U|Jasondaemon}} for your contribution. Please don't take it personally that your first attempt to write an article wasn't received well. Read up on Wikipedia:Article development and please come back with more contributions Deletion of Trouble Ticket Express WP:PRODUCT Wikipedia:Notability 77
22202 15499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bullseye (C.O.P.S.) User:Reyk 08:18, 23 February 2010 (UTC) delete """as yet another of these COPS articles that are """"sourced"""" (and I'm using the word in the sense that you'd nickname a fat guy 'slim' or a redhead 'bluey') by some dubious youtube videos, thus making them nothing but |original research. I'll also point out that the show itself only ran for about a year, making it fairly low on the notability scale so extensive articles on every character is |excessive and inappropriate""" Deletion of Bullseye (C.O.P.S.) WP:OR||WP:UNDUE Wikipedia:No original research 65
22203 21151 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fabform User:AllyD 15:47, 3 August 2017 (UTC) delete """A article on a new YouTube-based proposition. The most substantial coverage is http://www.indiantelevision.com/mam/marketing/mam/idea-shops-vishal-mull-starts-digital-venture-fabform-170710 the IndianTelevision.com item, but that is promotional start-up coverage (''""""Vishal Mull, former executive producer and creative director at Idea Shop, announces his first independent digital content network – ‘FabForm’ that will bring comic and quirky content on-the-go to the country's internet generation...""""'') rather than bylined in-depth analysis. Fails , """ Deletion of Fabform :WP:SPA||:WP:CORPDEPTH||:WP:GNG Wikipedia:Single-purpose account 23
22204 3531 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Inner family archetypes User:Pigman 04:20, 21 September 2007 (UTC) delete I feel strongly this amounts to |original research if it is not a more widely recognized descriptive paradigm Deletion of Inner family archetypes WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22205 11264 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Bruce User:Aleksa 09:38, 9 January 2014 (UTC) delete not notable as there's no claims of notability that would qualify him under any criteria, also lacks of |reliable sources, |verifiability and media coverage Deletion of Ben Bruce WP:RS||WP:VERIFY Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22206 7770 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nepal News Network International (2nd nomination) User:Malcolmxl5 12:13, 10 June 2019 (UTC) delete Does not meet or . What we are looking for is Wp:sigcov|significance coverage in reliable, independent secondary sources and I’m not seeing it Deletion of Nepal News Network International (2nd nomination) WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22207 4472 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nadeem Sarwar (Noha Khwan) User:Faizan 14:52, 28 December 2014 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Nadeem Sarwar (Noha Khwan) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22208 13797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TerryTheVoice User:4meter4 19:33, 5 October 2019 (UTC) delete Fails , , and Deletion of TerryTheVoice WP:NMUSIC||WP:SIGCOV||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22209 18141 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aviation Academy Halt Railway Station, Thailand User:NinjaRobotPirate 07:38, 25 January 2014 (UTC) merge to appropriate railway line or '''delete'''. These are unimpressive keep arguments. Notability is indeed a valid criteria for deletion; see eletion policy. Is there an actual policy that says all railway stations are notable? I don't see one Deletion of Aviation Academy Halt Railway Station, Thailand WP:D Wikipedia:Disambiguation 27
22210 2250 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joint Operation Computer Project Team User:Annette46 08:35, 19 August 2008 (UTC) keep the page creator seems sincere, the article seems notable if true, but he will have to really get the article upto all Wikipedia's policy including and . Alternatively '''Merge''', '''Redirect''' with Projects Wavell / Ptarmigan Deletion of Joint Operation Computer Project Team WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
22211 19846 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Luke Cutforth User:Whpq 16:59, 28 September 2011 (UTC) delete The article has a massive reference section populated exclusively with unreliable sources. I can find no reliable sources to meet |verifiability which is fundamental to Wikipedia Deletion of Luke Cutforth WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
22212 7339 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hakim Callender User:LACaliNYC 06:04, 8 July 2018 (UTC) delete Obviously fails the and the Deletion of Hakim Callender WP:GNG||WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
22213 7748 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Genesis Hearing Labs User:Schuym1 00:12, 6 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Genesis Hearing Labs WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
22214 6281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mort Fertel NONE NONE keep I have added following two |reliable source references to the article Deletion of Mort Fertel WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22215 14154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jake Von Neumann User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable vanity biography. Recommend the article author see http://www.wikime.org/ WikiMe for writing biographies and/or http://www.wikitree.org WikiTree for writing genealogies; article author may also want to consider moving the content to his Wikipedia:User page|user page. &mdash Deletion of Jake Von Neumann WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22216 20877 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gouge your eyes User:Glenfarclas 06:56, 7 February 2010 (UTC) delete """not a notable """"game"""" and, presumably, just """ Deletion of Gouge your eyes WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
22217 8224 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Epilepsy surgery and art User:WikiDan61 22:09, 20 August 2013 (UTC) delete """by virtue of low it up and start over. There ''may'' be an article with this topic to be be had at Wikipedia, but this is not it. The lead paragraph discusses the concept of medical procedures in general as a subject for various pieces of art, but not epilepsy surgery in any example. The section on Merino discusses a single piece of art that he has created, but that piece depicts the ravages of arthritis, not epilepsy surgery. Finally, there is a section that describes one piece titled """"Epilepsy, leaving the nightmare behind"""", with a detailed description of the painting, but neglecting to note who created the work. An online search finds that the painting was also created by Merino, an artist of no particular |notability. The article itself points out that """"Epilepsy surgery has been depicted in few artistic works"""", suggesting that this topic probably is not notable enough for an entire Wikipedia article""" Deletion of Epilepsy surgery and art WP:B||WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Bots 21
22218 20481 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jim Coughlan User:Pburka 20:18, 23 November 2013 (UTC) keep per Deletion of Jim Coughlan WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22219 21482 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Geometric Negative Value Theorem User:Michael 20:51, 27 January 2009 (UTC) delete The fact that this is childishly written is not a reason to delete; it would be a reason to re-write. However, the content, although unclear, is close enough to being clear to make it clear that it's nonsense, and near the end it comes close to confessing that it's |original research, clearly forbidden Deletion of Geometric Negative Value Theorem WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22220 11254 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of key MBTA bus routes User:Davey2010 13:47, 27 December 2017 (UTC) delete as per Charles and nom - Fails , , and - Back in 2014 the UK bus routes were ''all'' deleted due to a lack of notability and there's nothing different with these, Also if a passenger wants to know where a bus goes to and from then they should check the bus operators website - not an encyclopedia!, and last but not least a lot of these all become outdated anyway (One article a few years back was 5 years out of date!), In short this whole article fails GNG as well as the bus-related guidelines Deletion of List of key MBTA bus routes WP:NOTDIR||WP:NOTTRAVEL||WP:BUSCRUFT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22221 6106 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diary of a Teenage Girl NONE NONE keep Here are some reliable sources that provide |notability for this series, obtained via the EBSCO database using my local public libraries web site. Perhaps the author of this article could get a list of the books in the series into the article Deletion of Diary of a Teenage Girl WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22222 21853 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ronald Tisauke User:Pharaoh 22:39, 22 January 2016 (UTC) delete per nom Clearly fails Deletion of Ronald Tisauke WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22223 16229 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anne-Marie Baiynd User:RexxS 22:25, 1 May 2013 (UTC) keep """I can see non-trivial coverage of Baiynd herself, rather than her book, in multiple sources, for example: http://www.forbes.com/sites/kitconews/2012/03/14/webinar-sp-capital-iq-analyst-looks-for-higher-gold-price-by-year-end/ Forbes, http://www.moneyshow.com/marketdata/Annual_Online_Profile/300/5D83CD501E9946A9BF6B31216C461F67/Baiynd-Anne-Marie/ MoneyShow.com, http://www.traders.com/index.php/sac-magazine/current-contents/interviews/801-trade-smart-with-anne-marie-baiynd Traders.com - check the article references for more. The Forbes coverage is not much, but it's there, and most of the other sources may be marginal for """"reliability"""" - i.e. """"a reputation for fact-checking and accuracy"""", but there are quite a few sources on the web (Google for {{xt|""""Anne-Marie Baiynd"""" -wikipedia}} gives 107,000 ghits) including many seemingly serious online publications devoted to trading. This isn't conclusive evidence that is met, but there seems enough to me to suggest that she's notable for more than just the book (being notable for her job is still notability, of course""" Deletion of Anne-Marie Baiynd WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22224 335 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2016–17 Inverness Caledonian Thistle F.C. season User:Kosack 14:57, 11 February 2017 (UTC) keep season articles for sides in a fully professional league are notable under . Poor quality should not result in deletion, article needs improving not deleting Deletion of 2016–17 Inverness Caledonian Thistle F.C. season WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22225 3385 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mangos (band) User:ShadowHalo 05:06, 2 January 2007 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Mangos (band) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
22226 8444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ulteo (3rd nomination) User:Cewbot 00:02, 29 January 2021 (UTC) comment While this discussion appears to have |no quorum, it is '''NOT eligible for |soft deletion''' because it was Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ulteo (2nd nomination)|previously discussed at AfD and the result was delete Deletion of Ulteo (3rd nomination) WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
22227 10950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dance: Ten; Looks: Three User:Sergecross73 16:35, 25 January 2016 (UTC) merge per nom, Deletion of Dance: Ten; Looks: Three WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22228 11663 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terence H. Winkless User:Bearian 18:39, 15 August 2007 (UTC) keep per above. |Awful movies, truly bloody awful, but |notable as is the writer Deletion of Terence H. Winkless WP:IDONTLIKEIT||WP:N Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
22229 18219 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EgoZ User:Huon 21:09, 8 August 2007 (UTC) keep by now contains a most explicit reference to the TV interview, so passes Deletion of EgoZ WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22230 38 [[Zahltag – Das Buchprojekt]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Magiers 00:26, 14. Aug. 2012 (CEST) delete Kasten|1=, nachdem bereits in der Diskussion Einigkeit herrscht. Der Artikel hat keine |Belege und Relevanz nach WP:RK|unseren Kriterien ist nicht erkennbar, insbesondere nicht eine solche nach WP:RK#Literarische Einzelwerke. Gruß Löschung von Zahltag – Das Buchprojekt Wikipedia:Belege Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
22231 15004 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Majed Jaber Alhamoud Al-Sabah User:Northamerica1000 01:36, 3 April 2016 (UTC) keep """The subject actually comfortably passes . Source examples include, but are not limited to: http://content.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,419752,00.html """"The Sheik Of Chic"""". ''Time (magazine)|Time''., http://www.independent.co.uk/news/media/chic-sheikh-shows-arab-women-how-to-be-sexy-6106317.html """"'Chic sheikh' shows Arab women how to be sexy"""". ''The Independent''., http://nypost.com/2016/03/11/this-sheikh-is-making-perfume/ """"This Sheikh is making perfume"""". ''New York Post''., http://arabia.style.com/fashion/news/sheikh-majed-al-sabah-lauches-tfk-the-fragrance-kitchen-collections-at-bloomingdales-dubai-mall/ """"The Fragrance Kitchen (TFK) Hits Dubai"""". Style.com (published by Condé Nast)., https://next.ft.com/content/3a0bdcfa-3402-11e2-8270-00144feabdc0 """"Spice age"""". ''Financial Times''., https://www.lsnglobal.com/the-big-idea/article/145/sheikh-majed-al-sabah-redefining-retail-luxury-and-the-arts-for-the-middle-eastern-consumer """"Majed Al-Sabah : Redefining retail, luxury and the arts for the Middle Eastern consumer"""". LS:N., https://vimeo.com/77482534 """"Majed Al Sabah - CNN Interview"""". CNN., http://hauteliving.com/2014/01/sheikh-majeds-fragrance-kitchen-now-available-exclusively-bloomingdales-dubai/436849/ Sheikh Majed’s The Fragrance Kitchen. ''Haute Living''., http://www.ilgiornale.it/news/milano/sabah-apre-corner-profumialla-rinascente-944763.html """"Al Sabah apre un «corner» di profumiAlla Rinascente"""". ''Il Giornale''. {{In lang|it}} (https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=y&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.ilgiornale.it%2Fnews%2Fmilano%2Fsabah-apre-corner-profumialla-rinascente-944763.html&edit-text=&act=url English-translated article)., http://www.mbc.net/ar/programs/sabah-al-khair/articles/3-%D8%A3%D8%B4%D8%AE%D8%A7%D8%B5-%D9%85%D8%A4%D8%AB%D8%B1%D9%8A%D9%86-%D8%A8%D9%8A%D9%86%D9%87%D9%85-%D8%A7%D8%AB%D9%86%D9%8A%D9%86-%D8%B9%D8%B1%D8%A8---%D9%85%D8%A7-%D9%87%D9%8A-%D9%82%D8%B5%D8%AA%D9%87%D9%85%D8%9F.html """"3 influential people, including two arabs...what is their story?"""". Middle East Broadcasting Center. (https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=y&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.mbc.net%2Far%2Fprograms%2Fsabah-al-khair%2Farticles%2F3-%25D8%25A3%25D8%25B4%25D8%25AE%25D8%25A7%25D8%25B5-%25D9%2585%25D8%25A4%25D8%25AB%25D8%25B1%25D9%258A%25D9%2586-%25D8%25A8%25D9%258A%25D9%2586%25D9%2587%25D9%2585-%25D8%25A7%25D8%25AB%25D9%2586%25D9%258A%25D9%2586-%25D8%25B9%25D8%25B1%25D8%25A8---%25D9%2585%25D8%25A7-%25D9%2587%25D9%258A-%25D9%2582%25D8%25B5%25D8%25AA%25D9%2587%25D9%2585%25D8%259F.html&edit-text= English-translated article)., https://books.google.com/books?id=S1JWAAAAMAAJ&q=%22Majed+al-Sabah%22+villa+moda&dq=%22Majed+al-Sabah%22+villa+moda&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjpm6STq_HLAhXKtYMKHZfSDzkQ6AEINTAF ''FX: Design, Business and Society''. p. 38, p. 65. {{paywall}}, https://books.google.com/books?id=4ZQYAQAAMAAJ&q=%22Majed+al-Sabah%22&dq=%22Majed+al-Sabah%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwit1_7EqvHLAhVFg4MKHRuNAlIQ6AEIKTAC ''Travel & Leisure''. {{paywall}}, https://books.google.com/books?id=hvAeAQAAMAAJ&q=%22Majed+al-Sabah%22+villa+moda&dq=%22Majed+al-Sabah%22+villa+moda&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj0o4Plq_HLAhUhmoMKHXcKB2M4ChDoAQgbMAA ''Time''. Volume 164. 2004. """"Retail Renegade Sheik Majed al-Sabah Claim to fame: President and chairman of the Villa Moda empire, al-Sabah, 35, has brought luxury shopping to the Middle East and helped re-educate the West on the spending habits of the region ..."""" {{paywall}}. Perhaps users opining to delete only based their assessment of notability based upon sources that were in the article, rather than the ''availability'' of sources, as per """ Deletion of Majed Jaber Alhamoud Al-Sabah WP:BASIC||WP:NEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
22232 18186 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bethel Mission School User:Necrothesp 08:49, 31 July 2014 (UTC) keep """as a secondary school per longstanding precedent and consensus. See . No true reason given for deletion. """"advertising"""" is a ridiculous reason to delete a school article and it's easy enough to remove anything that's over-promotional. It's time that editors cleaned up articles as a first option instead of nominating them for deletion""" Deletion of Bethel Mission School WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
22233 17969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Soy boy user:Andrew 10:05, 23 September 2020 (UTC) merge """into Effeminacy#The_effects_of_chemicals which is much the same topic. The point of is that topics are """"grouped into articles based on what they are, not what they are called by"""". It's a matter of correct consolidation, not deletion""" Deletion of Soy boy WP:DICDEF Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
22234 400 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rebecca Cross User:Colapeninsula 16:46, 30 June 2015 (UTC) delete Doesn't quite meet notability requirements. A couple of reasonable-sized roles in B movies: ''Wet and Wild Summer!'' and ''The Last Patrol'' (aka ''The Last Warrior''). Plus some smaller parts. But I can't see in-depth coverage, and that doesn't quite meet . Note that New Zealand actor Rebecca Carlton was also sometimes billed as Rebecca Cross or Rebekah Cross in the 1990s, the same time as this Rebecca Cross was working Deletion of Rebecca Cross WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
22235 15579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Curve transformation User:Haemo 20:22, 8 April 2007 (UTC) delete as |original research, and as per Deletion of Curve transformation WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22236 12171 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Lost Symbol (film) User:Erik 14:27, 22 January 2013 (UTC) merge to The Lost Symbol#Film per the |notability guidelines for future films. The person who reverted was {{user|Elonka}} who referred to Talk:The Lost Symbol#Merger proposal|this discussion which does not consider the aforementioned guidelines. In addition, the claim at that discussion that the film is in production is incorrect. The start of filming is the proper threshold for the creation of a stand-alone article. From what I can tell, they are still writing it, which is no assurance that a film will ever be made. EDIT: To elaborate on the reason for the guidelines, the assumption is that once filming starts, a final product will result. Before then is no guarantee, so it would be misleading to have a film article Deletion of The Lost Symbol (film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22237 4925 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wizard staffing User:Wenli 01:17, 23 October 2007 (UTC) delete Definitely — Deletion of Wizard staffing WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not for things made up one day 32
22238 13777 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Godfather Of The Ghetto User:Niteshift36 15:09, 28 July 2009 (UTC) delete Fails , and Deletion of Godfather Of The Ghetto WP:NALBUM||WP:CRYSTAL||WP:HAMMER Wikipedia:Notability 77
22239 7665 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ceasar Mestre User:AusLondonder 20:08, 6 May 2016 (UTC) delete Fails both and Deletion of Ceasar Mestre WP:NPOL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22240 17126 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Daddy [[User talk:99.12.243.20|talk]]) 21:47, 9 January 2010 (UTC) delete The Daddy per nom and . Neutral to weak keep on the other two, where there are claims to television appearances for Kubb and major concert appearances for Moke, though both need sources to confirm claims. Conflict of interest is an issue on all three. Special:Contributions/99.12.243.20|99.12.243.20 Deletion of The Daddy WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
22241 7964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andy Beard User:Tevildo 19:19, 15 January 2008 (UTC) delete per nom. Borderline A7, very limited/no assertion of notability. Fails , , Deletion of Andy Beard WP:BIO||WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22242 188 [[Hans Steindl]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Wangen 19:11, 17. Sep. 2009 (CEST) delete also: gemeint ist wohl August Fischer (Bürgermeister)|dieser Fischer, der relevant ist wg. seiner Tätigkeit in Kempten. Dieser Kandidat hier erfüllt weder die |Relevanzkriterien noch sind im Artikel andere Anhaltspunkte für eine Relevanz für WP zu erkennen. Sollte da nicht deutlich mehr zu erwähnen sein was immer das auch sein könnte gilt für mich Löschung von Hans Steindl Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
22243 9625 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I.N.I. Streetwear User:MER 03:01, 7 January 2007 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of I.N.I. Streetwear WP:CORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
22244 8351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mental Potentials Create Many Realities or Many Worlds User:Chiswick 09:06, 17 November 2016 (UTC) delete is it |SNOWING?), the only thing the author doesn't suggest is a mind-driven perpetual motion machine, though I might have missed it after falling asleep on page 3 Deletion of Mental Potentials Create Many Realities or Many Worlds WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
22245 17429 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bermuda Shorts Day [[User talk:Ardenn|Ardenn]] 03:14, 21 April 2006 (UTC) delete per nom, no merge. |Wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of information Deletion of Bermuda Shorts Day WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22246 19714 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ryan Murdough User:Location 18:47, 24 September 2010 (UTC) delete per guideline at ikipedia is not a source for election candidate biographies. Fails Deletion of Ryan Murdough WP:W||WP:POLITICIAN Help:Watchlist 110
22247 18646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Race and intelligence 2 User:Wtfunkymonkey 02:17, 3 December 2006 (UTC) keep """you decided to allow Race_and_crime because """"''different ethnic groups find themselves in different circumstances'' - so you are of the opinion that men and women do not find themselves in different circumstances as well? Extremely important, controversial, and notable subjects. The articles are well sourced and any issues can be remedied with a POV-Check template. Please see Wikipedia:NPOV_dispute for the proper course of action""" Deletion of Race and intelligence 2 WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
22248 18154 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ken Dahl User:Bearian 18:23, 7 July 2016 (UTC) delete I've heard of him - he's more of a NYC socialite than a working musician. Perhaps |too soon Deletion of Ken Dahl WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
22249 19535 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pak Watan User:Sitush 14:43, 26 February 2012 (UTC) delete regardless of the procedural sideshow above, this seems clearly to be a situation and there has been no resolution of the proposer's concerns despite those being raised some time prior to the nomination Deletion of Pak Watan WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
22250 7022 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Martin Haase NONE NONE keep A quick look at the :de:Martin Haase|German version of this biography shows many additional sources and seem to clearly indicate |notability. I don't speak German but I'm under the impression that Die Zeit, Der Spiegel, and Cicero (magazine) are among the most reliable sources in the German language and are globally recognized. Based on my read of the automatic translations, it sure reads like all three have published profiles and/or interviews with the subject. I've added these references to the article. The English article was in a bad shape, but a simple look at the German version would have shown that it could be improved and kept. {{u|Ego Hunter}} is right that this probably does not meet #1 but clearly does meet the Deletion of Martin Haase WP:N||WP:PROF||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22251 1433 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/11277 Ballard User:RJHall 14:42, 22 July 2012 (UTC) merge to List of minor planets: 11001–12000#201 per . Regards Deletion of 11277 Ballard WP:NASTHELP Wikipedia:Notability 77
22252 3434 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Jackson (activist) User:Bearian 17:21, 12 August 2019 (UTC) delete it's not even wrong; he's neither |notable nor |an activist Deletion of Daniel Jackson (activist) WP:GNG||WP:SOAP Wikipedia:Notability 77
22253 1407 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prettyman, Missouri User:Bearian 18:53, 29 January 2021 (UTC) delete """per - according to reference # 2, it is """"A switch on the Missouri, Kansas and Texas Railroad""" Deletion of Prettyman, Missouri WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
22254 3173 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abraham & Straus User:Fuhghettaboutit 22:24, 19 March 2007 (UTC) keep """This is an {{tl|unreferenced}} maintenance tag issue, not a deletion issue. I haven't bothered to check yet because I happen to know they were a massive outlet akin to JC Penny, but will source in a few minutes. To cite : """"this policy should not be used to cause disruption by removing material for which reliable sources could easily or reasonably be found"""" or at : """"consider...adding a """"cleanup"""" template, instead of bringing the article to AfD""" Deletion of Abraham & Straus WP:ATT||WP:AFD Wikipedia:Attribution 108
22255 2558 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bread Givers User:Zagalejo 17:20, 24 October 2007 (UTC) keep I think every book summarized at http://www.sparknotes.com/lit/breadgivers/ Sparknotes has to pass with ease. It does need cleanup, but that's not what AFD is for Deletion of Bread Givers WP:BK Wikipedia:Notability 77
22256 4459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ctrl+Alt+Del (webcomic) (2nd nomination) [[User_talk:Radiant!|>Radiant<]] 15:42, 19 February 2011 (UTC) delete No reliable sources means no article; all sources that I've found are either trivial mentions, or self-promotion by the comic's author. That several people express |liking the comic is no grounds for it getting a free pass against sourcing policy Deletion of Ctrl+Alt+Del (webcomic) (2nd nomination) WP:ILIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
22257 15062 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Modified.ca User:Wsiegmund 03:04, 6 December 2005 (UTC) delete It was started on 16 October 2005 by 209.112.216.22 who spelled the name wrong. Perhaps I should have AfDed it then, rather than correcting the name and cleaning it up. But, I didn't want to . It has not been edited since I moved it Deletion of Modified.ca WP:BITE Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
22258 10314 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Estonia–India relations User:Drawn 02:01, 14 July 2009 (UTC) delete Not one of the independent sources actually addresses the topic of the article. The Indian government website lays bare the unimportance -- less than 600 Estonians even visited India in 2004. Note that they haven't bothered to update the website since July 2005. Must not be too important of a relationship even in the Indian government's eyes, much less anyone elses'. Fails and the effort at rescue that came up with exactly ZERO sources addressing the subject makes that VERY clear Deletion of Estonia–India relations WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22259 5670 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Circle of Death (beer) User:TBC 06:03, 3 April 2006 (UTC) delete interesting, but |not notable Deletion of Circle of Death (beer) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22260 6858 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/DROsoft User:FenixFeather 23:39, 14 July 2020 (UTC) delete I read the new sources, and none of them constitute significant coverage of the company. Brief, passing descriptions do not suffice for . &ndash Deletion of DROsoft WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22261 6063 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Partner 2 (2011 film) User:Eddie 19:54, 22 July 2010 (UTC) delete violates and Deletion of Partner 2 (2011 film) WP:CRYSTAL||WP:RS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22262 14060 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Samsung Galaxy S8 User:Pmedema 02:26, 1 March 2017 (UTC) delete """until the proper announcement comes out on March 29th, which is when Samsung has advised it will happen. All the sources I'm seeing are speculative, """"it might have"""", """"it may come with"""", etc based on an apparently """"leaked"""" video. definitely I have been corrected... is more appropriate""" Deletion of Samsung Galaxy S8 WP:TOOSOON||WP:CBALL Wikipedia:Too soon 40
22263 10217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dan Roodt User:Addionne 18:53, 3 March 2010 (UTC) delete In addition the above arguments about conflict of interest, and verfiability/reliability of sources - we also need to consider that Wiki policy is that in BLPs, |unsourced contentious material about living persons should be removed immediately.. Coupled with the fact that he is only questionably notable, this is probably grounds to scrap the whole article Deletion of Dan Roodt WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
22264 2086 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of items and artifacts in Negima User:TheFarix 02:20, 6 April 2009 (UTC) delete as excessive level of plot detail which falls under |indiscriminate information. Information about the Pactio Artifacts could be included in the character's descriptions. But beyond that, a list of chapters is a better way to summarize plot information Deletion of List of items and artifacts in Negima WP:IINFO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22265 15079 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Police Misconduct in Pasadena Texas User:EEng 21:14, 16 December 2010 (UTC) delete Article is just a collection of incident summaries sourced to news stories. I'd call it except nothing is synthesized. The entirety of the lead reads, ''There are several documented examples of police misconduct in Pasadena, Texas, United States.'' By that standard, there's be a corresponding article for every locality throughout the world Deletion of Police Misconduct in Pasadena Texas WP:SYNTH Wikipedia:No original research 65
22266 13541 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lorna Bennett (actress) User:Ravenswing NONE delete A career of barely-credited bit parts does not or the GNG pass. Nor, as does the anon IP above, do I presume that someone can only seek to apply Wikipedia rules and guidelines through Some Hidden Agenda. Some , please Deletion of Lorna Bennett (actress) WP:ENTERTAINER||WP:AGF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22267 8459 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Confederation of Planes and Planets User:MacGyverMagic 09:01, 6 January 2009 (UTC) keep Being 'bare bones' is not a valid reason for deletion and the nominator only discusses the sources already in the article without making any sort of attempt to find more per . I also agree with DGG that this is about the amount of detail you'd expect -- not too much not too little Deletion of Confederation of Planes and Planets WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
22268 21758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aleisha Allen (2nd nomination) NONE NONE delete the sources which have been added do not demonstrate that the subject meets the |general notability guideline Deletion of Aleisha Allen (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22269 10354 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RusHouR User:Persian 10:28, 27 November 2006 (UTC) delete non-notable, winning a college rock competition does not exactly meet the award requirement in Deletion of RusHouR WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22270 12477 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of repeated names User:Colonel 10:24, 27 November 2011 (UTC) keep It didn't take long to find http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=p8IUAQAAIAAJ an encyclopedia which contains a similar list - Pago Pago, Lulu, ack-ack, &c. The claim of the nomination that this material is unencyclopedic is thus shown to be false and is satisfied Deletion of List of repeated names WP:LISTN Wikipedia:Notability 77
22271 4545 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Folarin Balogun User:ArsenalFan700 15:34, 21 October 2020 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Folarin Balogun WP:NFOOTY||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22272 2341 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of official record charts User:Aquasplash 21:25, 9 March 2007 (UTC) delete If the external links are not removed and it is made into a proper list and not displayed like a category, then it would meet the |criteria but at the minute it fails #LINK|Wikipedia is not a place for external links Deletion of List of official record charts WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22273 21742 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anti-Hellenism (2nd nomination) User:Aramgar 14:12, 3 December 2008 (UTC) delete What do the Hasmonean|Hasmonean dynasty and Oscar Wilde have in common? perhaps only this article. Any attempt to knit such diverse temporal and geographical elements into a coherent article would inevitably fall afoul of Deletion of Anti-Hellenism (2nd nomination) WP:SYN Wikipedia:No original research 65
22274 16931 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cuttlefish Optimization Algorithm User:Bluerasberry 19:50, 20 July 2016 (UTC) keep for each of Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Intelligent Water Drops algorithm, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glowworm swarm optimization, and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cuttlefish Optimization Algorithm. For each of these there are multiple publications in academic journals over a period of years. That seems to establish . If these are to be deleted I would want a counterargument to the default assumption that the articles cited are not reliable. Peer reviewed academic research which addresses a topic by name is usually considered to meet and establish . Why demand a higher standard in this case Deletion of Cuttlefish Optimization Algorithm WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22275 20638 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sharad Patel User:Peter303x 00:01, 17 April 2021 (UTC) delete does not meet , very few citations Deletion of Sharad Patel WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
22276 2244 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yosef Babad (HTC) User:David 21:46, 31 December 2009 (UTC) delete I tried and failed to find sources on him — the article mentions two Chicago-area newspaper obituaries but I couldn't find them (so couldn't tell if they were the kind of obituary the family pays to publish or the kind that major newspapers write about famous people). The institution for which he was dean of students is tiny (around 300 students combined from high school and college levels) so his position there may be more analogous to a high school assistant principal than to a major academic position of the type that would meet #6. Regardless of whether he passes , he seems to fail Deletion of Yosef Babad (HTC) WP:PROF||WP:PROF||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
22277 14938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/UFC 27 User:Mtking 08:42, 29 April 2012 (UTC) delete This unsourced article makes no attempt to explain why this event is encyclopaedic, so fails Deletion of UFC 27 WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22278 6168 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aces of the Air user:Hellknowz 12:39, 12 March 2017 (UTC) delete as failing with insufficient reliable independent in-depth sources, such as /RS. http://www.gamerankings.com/ps/563026-aces-of-the-air/index.html GameRankings lists PSN magazine review https://web.archive.org/web/20040624151701/www.playstationmagazine.com/article2/0,2053,1492135,00.asp, but that's just one review. VG reliable source search, as well as aggregate listings don't bring anything else up. — Deletion of Aces of the Air WP:GNG||WP:VG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22279 18739 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexis Rodríguez Fernández User:Grsz11 15:51, 23 October 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Alexis Rodríguez Fernández WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
22280 390 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Barks Babes & Bros User:Jmertel23 02:19, 1 February 2019 (UTC) delete Sounds like a good cause, but that has no bearing on notability. Promotional, and lacking in reliable, independent sources. Fails Deletion of Barks Babes & Bros WP:EVENTCRITERIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
22281 3430 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chodankar User:Jd027 22:48, 11 February 2008 (UTC) delete It may work better as a disambiguation page, although no one as of now is named that on Wikipedia. For now, delete per Deletion of Chodankar WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22282 2197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Edward F. Group User:Drchriswilliams 09:56, 3 April 2016 (UTC) delete This person has provided a couple of quotes that appeared in the mainstream press in features articles that were covering celebrity colon cleansing, but this doesn't meet . A lack of coverage in reliable sources means that notability has not been established Deletion of Edward F. Group WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22283 17256 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hari Singh Mahua User:SpacemanSpiff 20:11, 30 June 2011 (UTC) keep Referenced, passes olitician. &mdash Deletion of Hari Singh Mahua WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
22284 19688 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pinkstart User:Rhododendrites 19:56, 10 January 2016 (UTC) delete The COI is concerning, but a secondary issue to the lack of sources. I couldn't find sufficient sources to satisfy . May be notable soon, but not now. &mdash Deletion of Pinkstart WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22285 6473 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/COPS in popular culture User:Storm 20:59, 1 August 2007 (UTC) delete this has the feel of Cruft|fancruft and it is |original research Deletion of COPS in popular culture WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22286 6499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Even Kern User:Artene50 09:07, 11 June 2008 (UTC) delete The article fails . The only footnoted reference leads to this promotion http://www.sharkmeatrecords.com/news/even-kerns-new-album-did-featured-on-european-itunes-stores/ site Deletion of Even Kern WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22287 7350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RankMF User:K 17:40, 9 February 2019 (UTC) delete Does not meet ; significant coverage not found. Typical launch publicity does not amount to notability Deletion of RankMF WP:NCORP||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22288 1519 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delphonse the Frowny Clown User:Fuhghettaboutit 13:49, 18 March 2007 (UTC) delete No |attribution in article; one Google web hit; no Google news or book hits; and critically, no results for a Worldcat search http://www.worldcat.org/search?qt=worldcat_org&q=Delphonse+the+Frowny+Clown&submit=Search and no listing or ISBN at the Library of Congress http://catalog.loc.gov/cgi-bin/Pwebrecon.cgi?Search_Arg=Delphonse+the+Frowny+Clown+&Search_Code=TALL&PID=24271&SEQ=20070318094640&CNT=25&HIST=1. Accordingly, nothing here satisfying any criteria at and not even meeting any threshold standards listed there Deletion of Delphonse the Frowny Clown WP:ATT||WP:BK Wikipedia:Attribution 108
22289 776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aleix Serra User:The 17:07, 31 January 2008 (UTC) delete until he meets WP:FOOTBALL's i.e. he plays in at least one professional match Deletion of Aleix Serra WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22290 21350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sasha Gabor User:Kraxler 18:50, 20 September 2015 (UTC) comment """changed from Delete) fails PORNBIO and there's no other claim of notability in the article, the refs shown here are of the """"tabloid journalism"""" variety, discouraged to be used by . Having an obit in a newspaper is not enough, Wikipedia is """ Deletion of Sasha Gabor WP:SENSATION||WP:NOTMEMORIAL Wikipedia:Notability 77
22291 14007 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juan Pardo User:Gtstricky 18:11, 10 July 2008 (UTC) comment I was |bold and redirected it Deletion of Juan Pardo WP:BOLD Wikipedia:Be bold 9
22292 17172 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 Udon Thani F.C. season User:Walter 14:36, 11 February 2015 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of 2009 Udon Thani F.C. season :WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22293 10521 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Luckett (businessman) User:Launchballer 09:07, 9 March 2013 (UTC) keep The article got through at the end of 2010, which means that it would have needed to have got past policy then Deletion of Bill Luckett (businessman) WP:AFC Wikipedia:Articles for creation 55
22294 206 [[§ 94 StGB]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Markus Schulenburg NONE keep So sehr ich einzelne Kollegen innerhalb der Diskussion schätze, läuft es hier gerade ein wenig aus dem Ruder. Wir sprechen hier nicht von einer Rohdatensammlung (wie UHT fälschlich annimmt), sondern Weiterleitungen, die auf Basis von |WL angelegt wurden. Wenn es zu einem Stichwort bzw. in diesem Falle zu einer Weiterleitung mehrere Begriffe unter dem gleichen Wortlaut gibt, gehört dort eine WP:BKL|BKL eingerichtet. Auch eine Vielzahl von solchen BKL sind nicht gegen WP:WWNI|wikipedianische Grundlagen. In der Summe sind die Weiterleitungen swert. Von kleineren Verfahrensfehlern (Nichteintragung des LA in die WLs, Sammellöschantrag etc.) mögen wir uns hier nicht weiter den Kopf zerbrechen, dies führt nur zur entsprechenden WP:LP|LP Löschung von § 94 StGB Wikipedia:WL Wikipedia:Redirect 56
22295 15824 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2020–21 United States network television schedule User:IJBall 14:59, 9 June 2020 (UTC) keep after multiple long-running discussions indicating that there is a strong consensus to keep these, and that they do not violate and provide encyclopedic content. That said, '''draftify 2021–22 United States network television schedule''' as per and Deletion of 2020–21 United States network television schedule WP:NOTTVGUIDE||WP:CRYSTALBALL||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22296 8924 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Break My Heart Again User:doomsdayer520 02:22, 8 July 2020 (UTC) delete """my preference) or '''Redirect''' to Finneas O'Connell - For about the seventh time it is necessary to state that a Finneas song is not |notable just because it was released as a single. Per the above discussion, whether or not CelebMix is reliable does not matter too much for ''this'' song because that publication only announced the single's release and said a few nice things about the video. The other magazine-like sources in the article, like Atwood Magazine and Our Culture Mag, ''could'' be reliable for this article if they did anything more than announce the song's existence, which they don't. A """"reliable"""" source is a good start, but it still must say something |significant about the item. All these Finneas song articles by DarklyShadows are passionately written but give us little more than |fan trivia""" Deletion of Break My Heart Again WP:NSONG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:FANCRUFT Wikipedia:Notability 77
22297 12879 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/This Is My Life (Fefe Dobson song) [[User talk:TenPoundHammer|Otters want attention]]) 01:50, 19 January 2011 (UTC) delete for failing notability per — no sources, very short articles and the (Fefe Dobson song) part precludes any usefulness as a redirect. Ten Pound Hammer, Special:Contributions/TenPoundHammer|his otters and a clue-bat Deletion of This Is My Life (Fefe Dobson song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22298 18125 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mr. President (title) (second nomination) [[User talk:74.137.108.115|74]] 16:19, 25 February 2009 (UTC) keep This article has improved significantly since the nomination, but even before those improvements there wasn't a valid reason to nominate it for deletion ( appears to have been disregarded). The article is valuable, its presence is not disruptive (unlike spurious AfDs), and no compelling reasons for removal have been presented. – Deletion of Mr. President (title) (second nomination) WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
22299 5499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quizzaciously User:Ubiquity 16:18, 16 September 2015 (UTC) delete WP:NOTDIC. The math stuff makes it look like a candidate for Deletion of Quizzaciously WP:A11 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
22300 458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marvel Movie Universe User:Jc37 22:31, 31 October 2006 (UTC) delete Marvel Movie Universe Timeline, as blatant , and a rather duplicative list of List of Marvel Comics films Deletion of Marvel Movie Universe WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22301 21258 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Journey of Souls User:Darth_Panda 21:33, 6 November 2008 (UTC) delete Fails because of a lack of third-party reviews. No mentions on a Google Book search aside from the books themselves Deletion of Journey of Souls WP:NB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22302 6328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of public statues of individuals linked to the Atlantic slave trade User:SportingFlyer 19:22, 14 June 2020 (UTC) comment """To be honest, I think the nominator's onto something with the AfD nom. We need to keep this article, but as it stands it's malformed - what this should reflect is not of statues of people """"linked"""" to the slave trade, but instead a reflection of the current event going on where society's looking at statues and removing problematic ones. For instance, at CfD, this would be deleted for being an overcategorisation. We need to rename this to something like """"List of statues removed during the Black Lives Matter protests, 2020"""" and reformat the table so it's one giant table with a bunch of prose. I don't support keeping the article as-is, but it's so easily fixable it's not even worth voting to delete""" Deletion of List of public statues of individuals linked to the Atlantic slave trade WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22303 19051 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abhinay Banker (2nd nomination) User:Coderzombie 16:46, 23 August 2016 (UTC) keep I originally nominated the article, but I think it has been much better since. Even includes a few , which are specifically about him, such as http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/gujarati/theatre/The-latest-promo-of-the-successful-game-show-Kaun-Banega-Crorepati-has-Gujarats-theatre-actor-and-director-Abhinay-Banker-in-it-/articleshow/38981262.cms this, http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/gujarati/theatre/Theatre-actor-and-director-Abhinay-Banker-talks-about-how-Ahmedabad-theatre-scene-is-getting-more-experimental-and-how-/articleshow/46723208.cms this, http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/entertainment/gujarati/theatre/Abhinay-Banker-Abhinay-Bankers-double-dhamaka-for-Amdavadis/articleshow/46537683.cms this, so I am inclined towards keep Deletion of Abhinay Banker (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22304 15758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam West (band) User:Atlantic306 23:56, 17 October 2020 (UTC) keep as per the multiple reliable sources coverage identified in this discussion that show a pass of so that deletion is unnecessary imv Deletion of Adam West (band) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22305 19040 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eric Sparrow (2nd nomination) User:Spy 16:39, 24 February 2020 (UTC) delete In order for an article to meet the |General notability guideline the topic has received '''significant coverage''' in '''reliable sources''' that are '''independent''' of the subject. Here on this occassion there is a lack of in-depth reliable coverage due to a lot of the sources being user submitted hence it does not meet the guideline. In response to some of {{u|DasallmächtigeJ}}'s if you think that Lucky Chloe and Arbiter (Halo) do not meet I suggest you discuss it on their respective talk pages but pointing that out here does not warrant this article to be kept (see Deletion of Eric Sparrow (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:GNG||WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22306 14782 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of sources about claims that Vojsava Kastrioti was Albanian User:WhiteWriter 11:40, 16 April 2011 (UTC) merge both articles into the article on the principal subject, per Deletion of List of sources about claims that Vojsava Kastrioti was Albanian WP:AVOIDSPLIT Wikipedia:Summary style 34
22307 17351 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Greater Cornerstone Community Center Development Project User:Tarheel95 14:10, 1 December 2011 (UTC) delete per section G11 of |CSD. It seems to be blatant advertising and contains copyvios as well Deletion of Greater Cornerstone Community Center Development Project WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
22308 21530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sherrie Miday User:Bearcat 15:49, 28 October 2017 (UTC) delete """County court judges do not get an automatic notability freebie just for existing, and being the first person of any particular ethnicity to hold the role does not automatically make her special in the absence of significantly nationalized |reliable source coverage ''about'' the historic importance of that distinction. That said, I also agree with Ritchie that CSD was not relevant here — to be non-speediable, all an article has to do is make any notability claim at all. It doesn't actually have to be one that would survive an AFD — ''any'' notability claim at all, even one that clearly ''fails'' our actual notability standards, still precludes speedy on those grounds and forces prod or AFD instead. CSD A7 is for articles on the order of """"John Smith lives at 128 Elm Street, the end"""" or """"Jane Mitchell is the best girlfriend in the world, the end"""", not articles like this""" Deletion of Sherrie Miday WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22309 11510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Austria–Moldova relations User:Smile 16:57, 10 May 2009 (UTC) keep important ongoing relationship and the sources added clearly meet Deletion of Austria–Moldova relations WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22310 14636 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victor Lazzarini User:Giso6150 03:14, 3 October 2016 (UTC) keep Even a cursory look at the sources more than demonstrates that this person fulfills |the notability criteria for academics Deletion of Victor Lazzarini WP:NACADEMIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22311 21655 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sergey Manukyan User:Bearian 01:34, 18 September 2019 (UTC) delete """per . He collaborated with other musicians, as |all musicians do. He won a """"''sympathy''"""" (''sic., emphasis added'') award. Really""" Deletion of Sergey Manukyan WP:TNT||WP:MILL Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
22312 510 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiger vs lion User:Cindamuse 13:54, 17 October 2010 (UTC) delete per . This one raised my eyebrows a tad bit. Honestly, my mama can take a tiger any day of the week. Word Deletion of Tiger vs lion WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22313 6943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/San Andreas Multiplayer (SA:MP) User:Sjones23 00:52, 24 August 2012 (UTC) delete A serious |advertising issue and the article never passed Deletion of San Andreas Multiplayer (SA:MP) WP:ADVERTISEMENT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Advertising 107
22314 11278 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of artists who have recorded """"Jingle Bells"""" (2nd nomination)""" User:Snotbot 16:25, 7 April 2012 (UTC) comment This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3). I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2012 April 7 """Deletion of List of artists who have recorded """"Jingle Bells"""" (2nd nomination)""" WP:AFDHOWTO Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
22315 4883 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/88-Keys User:Rackabello 21:35, 10 August 2007 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of 88-Keys WP:V||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
22316 6452 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James H. Chadbourn User:Xxanthippe 22:42, 9 June 2011 (UTC) keep Passes rof#C1 on GS cites and rof#C5 Deletion of James H. Chadbourn WP:P||WP:P Wikipedia:Portal 85
22317 6689 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fashion victim user:Alf_photoman 18:15, 11 March 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Fashion victim WP:A Wikipedia:Attribution 108
22318 18970 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fuji Food User:onel5969 01:25, 7 July 2017 (UTC) delete The sources existing, as well as the those provided in this discussion, do not provide the type of in-depth coverage to show , not to mention Deletion of Fuji Food WP:GNG||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
22319 5961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Irina Berezhna User:Unscintillating 05:29, 5 February 2012 (UTC) keep nbsp; As per #1, nomination is not an argument for deletion. AfD should be closed within 24 hours so that nominator can decide whether or not to do the work needed to prepare the community for a discussion. See and . Deletion of Irina Berezhna WP:SK||WP:NPASR||WP:ATD||WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Speedy keep 68
22320 9790 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Special Force - ParaCommando Division User:Britishfinance 17:07, 11 February 2019 (UTC) delete The Para-Commando Brigade (Bangladesh) article exists; which the most credilbe references in this article, per ''The Daily Star'' (and even the photo) are really referring to. The reference that a new Division is being formed in 2030 to absord the existing Brigade is junk. Could even be a hoax. Deletion of Special Force - ParaCommando Division WP:NUKEIT Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over 19
22321 11362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alison Davis User:Atama 19:52, 14 January 2010 (UTC) delete I've also tried to find significant coverage to satisfy , but haven't found enough for this person. I might also mention that the article was created and substantially edited by an editor whose username matches her husband's name Matthew Le Merle, and there was even one edit by an editor with a name identical to her. Seems self-promotional in nature Deletion of Alison Davis WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22322 1042 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Haifa International Conference for a WMD-Free Middle East user:Shrike 22:08, 11 March 2021 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Haifa International Conference for a WMD-Free Middle East WP:NEVENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
22323 14496 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexander Berghaus User:K 04:41, 20 October 2017 (UTC) keep a member of the Academy of Sciences Leopoldina helps to meet + other contributions. An article on de.wiki (https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Berghaus link) is also a good indicator of notability Deletion of Alexander Berghaus WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22324 298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Cooters User:Ijanderson977 22:38, 27 January 2009 (UTC) delete Fails because it only has albums and independent labels making the band not notable. Also lack of references. No-one has explained how it passes either, this is because it doesn't pass it Deletion of The Cooters WP:MUSIC||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22325 11947 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicola Scafetta User:Agricola44 19:09, 29 March 2010 (UTC) keep """With all due respect, the idea that """"an academic is notable if people want to read about him"""" is nonsense – we're all aware that this process is governed by well-established WP guidelines. That said, the subject clearly has quite a significant research record. WoS shows 45 publications with a citation list of 49, 47, 47, 34, .... (total cites approaching 500, h-index = 13), which I think is passable under #1. Respectfully""" Deletion of Nicola Scafetta WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22326 9536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Superman (film project) User:Chzz 13:59, 28 March 2011 (UTC) keep enough to overcome the concerns Deletion of Superman (film project) WP:RS||WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22327 423 [[Leatherheads]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Carlo Cravallo 11:58, 10. Okt. 2007 (CEST) delete Noch nicht veröffentlicht. Damit nach den |Relevanzkriterien für Filme eindeutig noch nicht relevant Löschung von Leatherheads Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
22328 4606 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lauren Razavi User:Colapeninsula 10:07, 27 November 2013 (UTC) delete Fails . No substantial reviews of her work, no indication of her importance/significance/innovation as a writer, no major prizes, and I can't find any in-depth -style coverage. Some of the claims to fame are very desperate (e.g. she was thanked in liner notes by a band, whose article she created). Nomination is accurate Deletion of Lauren Razavi WP:WRITER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22329 11142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Zulu Wikipedia User:Pharmboy 23:57, 30 October 2008 (UTC) keep as you are recommending deleting that article on the Zulu language version of Wikipedia. As for how many people participate, please give a read Deletion of Zulu Wikipedia WP:BIG Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
22330 12997 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Al-Zayni User:Pharaoh 11:48, 21 December 2020 (UTC) keep passes . Subject is 24 years and currently playing for a club in a |fully professional league an his last appreance in the current season was on https://int.soccerway.com/matches/2020/10/17/saudi-arabia/pro-league/al-wehda-mecca/al-quadisiya-khobar/3400386/ 17th October 2020 and is part of the current team Deletion of Omar Al-Zayni WP:NFOOTY||WP:FPL Wikipedia:Notability 77
22331 11753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Narada Film and Television Music Sampler User:MichaelQSchmidt 21:40, 18 July 2016 (UTC) delete for failing all applicable aspects of : fails ALBUMS, fails MUSIC and fails FILM... all per failing the overriding and Deletion of Narada Film and Television Music Sampler WP:N||WP:NALBUMS||WP:NMUSIC||WP:NFILM||WP:V||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22332 7646 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khayal Abbas AKhtar User:McGeddon 11:27, 17 September 2015 (UTC) delete having no reliable secondary sources, just quote sites and a / interview. Seems to have been speedied in the past as Khayal Abbas Akhtar (with a lowercase K Deletion of Khayal Abbas AKhtar WP:PRIMARY||WP:NEWSPRIMARY||WP:BLOGS Wikipedia:No original research 65
22333 1806 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michelle T. Hayes User:Richwales 04:58, 1 August 2011 (UTC) merge to Nine Eleven Finding Answers Foundation. No notability of this person per . Nothing useful found in a Google search Deletion of Michelle T. Hayes WP:PEOPLE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22334 10476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Italian American actors User:Badagnani 00:41, 24 October 2007 (UTC) keep Notable categorization, and editor proposing deletion is well known for his/her profusion of nominations without merit Deletion of List of Italian American actors WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
22335 5703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Prateek Parmar user:Hellknowz 15:08, 18 June 2020 (UTC) delete as failing and / with no reliable independent in-depth sources, in this case in-depth in particular. — Deletion of Prateek Parmar WP:GNG||WP:NBIO||WP:NCREATIVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22336 16744 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tomos Roberts User:NealeFamily 08:12, 26 January 2021 (UTC) delete I have reached the conclusion that Roberts is only known for a single poem at this stage, although I do applaud him for not allowing setbacks and dyslexia for standing in his way. I conclude that it is most likely a case of as he appears very talented. I look forward to seeing how he progresses in the future Deletion of Tomos Roberts WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
22337 12856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erma (webcomic) User:Steve 07:44, 28 December 2017 (UTC) delete not enough coverage in reliable sources, fails WP:N. Also, probably . Sources are supposed to be intellectually independent of the others. This means sources are supposed to be from various publishers. Not multiple sources from the same publisher. Create this article later, when more sources emerge Deletion of Erma (webcomic) WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
22338 11694 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Clyde Aufner User:Paulmcdonald 11:26, 17 August 2016 (UTC) delete offensive linemen get bruises, not news coverage. It's rare for an OL to get enough coverage to pass and I don't see it happening here Deletion of Clyde Aufner WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22339 21713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sadat Hossain (2nd nomination) User:Jubair 13:44, 4 May 2020 (UTC) keep The article meets the criteria of as & beacuse he is the director of Gohiner Gaan feature film, documentary, short films and third best selling writer 2019 in Bangladesh which is independent and notable work. Also has a several mainstream media covergae and review of his books and films. It also meets the criteria of as it is on press release, significant covergae and from relibale source. It also meets the criteria about well-known and significant award or honor such as Humayun Ahmed Literary Award Deletion of Sadat Hossain (2nd nomination) WP:CREATIVE||WP:AUTHOR||WP:DIRECTOR||WP:GNG||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22340 5077 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of American politicians convicted of crimes user:tmorton166 17:49, 29 November 2010 (UTC) keep concur with DGG. That a politician is convicted of a crime is always significant in relation to their public life (although, disclaimer; only those crimes committed whilst in office, or in relation to their office). |BLP policy for this issue is designed to ensure we are sensitive to the issues of using pejorative terms in relation to living persons - it does ''not'' mean we do not aply such terms Deletion of List of American politicians convicted of crimes WP:BLPCAT Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
22341 2679 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tolulope Arotile (2nd nomination) user:Andrew 21:38, 16 July 2020 (UTC) keep The subject is clearly notable as they pass and Deletion of Tolulope Arotile (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22342 4274 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/S.H.I.E.L.D. (Marvel animated universe) User:Andy14and16 03:56, 20 May 2010 (UTC) keep Lists, categories and navigation templates are synergistic—the benefits of their redundancy are covered in . This is a useful and informative list and meets the guidelines for inclusion per Deletion of S.H.I.E.L.D. (Marvel animated universe) WP:CLN||WP:LIST Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
22343 11034 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Asharfi Lal Mishra User:Skamecrazy123 13:31, 30 March 2015 (UTC) delete Per |A7. No indication of notability or importance Deletion of Asharfi Lal Mishra WP:A7 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
22344 15066 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Confusion (album) User:Eduemoni 13:47, 18 February 2013 (UTC) delete Fails , fails and fails Deletion of Confusion (album) WP:CREATIVE||WP:MUSIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22345 21290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RJ Preet User:Mz7 15:43, 3 May 2014 (UTC) delete This article could have been ed, since it is a BLP with no sources. The articles is written promotionally and is completely unsourced. Appears to be a case of , as her career is only a few years long, involved only in a few local radio shows. Fails Deletion of RJ Preet WP:STICKYPROD||WP:TOOSOON||WP:BIO Wikipedia:Proposed deletion of biographies of living people 66
22346 19696 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Victorian Serrated Tussock Working Party User:Joe 16:48, 13 June 2010 (UTC) delete I can't find significant coverage for this |organization Deletion of Victorian Serrated Tussock Working Party WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22347 20715 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/R&R Design User:Huon 12:24, 18 October 2009 (UTC) delete I found http://www.scribd.com/doc/20790258/R-R this link which seems to verify existence, but no reliable, independent sources seem to exist. Thus, fails Deletion of R&R Design WP:NOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22348 6279 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bollywood Breaks Vol. 1 User:Lankiveil 13:27, 19 January 2008 (UTC) delete per , not a notable album Deletion of Bollywood Breaks Vol. 1 WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22349 2462 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nurarihyon no Mago User:Collectonian 05:15, 19 January 2009 (UTC) delete fails and . Unnotable manga series with no significant coverage in reliable sources. Article is pure plot. Also delete List of Nurarihyon No Mago chapters with it, which appears to have been an unnecessary split with no sources Deletion of Nurarihyon no Mago WP:BK||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22350 21417 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of museums User:S 00:49, 21 June 2009 (UTC) keep There are good reasons why we have lists as well as categories. You can put a list on your watchlist, but not a category. Lists can be sortable, but categories are always alphabetical. See for other reasons, and the relevant guidelines Deletion of List of museums WP:CLN Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates 16
22351 11995 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/International rankings of Singapore User:James086 12:06, 8 December 2006 (UTC) delete per #IINFO|wikipedia is not an indiscriminate collection of info Deletion of International rankings of Singapore WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22352 19235 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Vallo User:Northamerica1000 02:49, 11 July 2012 (UTC) keep spaced ndash}} per the sources presented above by User:Snow Rise. This person appears to meet Deletion of James Vallo WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22353 4494 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jehovah's Witnesses and the United Nations (2nd nomination) User:Coolabahapple 08:34, 1 June 2017 (UTC) comment okay, this is one of the fundamental beliefs of jws (it just doesn't come up when they are preaching door-to door:)), being integral with their view/prophecies about the destruction of all religions and organisations (except them of course:)) that they believe are in opposition to Jehovah (God) and the setting up of God's kingdom on the Earth. Agree that the majority of sources are primary and there does appear to be an undue emphasis on the UN Department of Public Information issue, that really should only be a one or two sentence mention. The article should either be '''kept''' and improved with more |non-jw sources (difficult as there is a dearth (love that word, dearth, yeeaaahh...) of such sources) or '''merged/redirected''' to Eschatology of Jehovah's Witnesses with a 1, 2 line mention at Jehovah's Witnesses beliefs Deletion of Jehovah's Witnesses and the United Nations (2nd nomination) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22354 2675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Best Believe It User:Wisdom89 NONE delete I don't feel that it's a matter of , but complete lack of verifiability and notability. If this is the case, then it fails album. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Billy+Arnold%22+music+%22best+believe+it%22&btnG=Search and http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22Billy+Arnold%22+music+&btnG=Search — Preceding Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned comment added by Deletion of Best Believe It WP:HOAX||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Do not create hoaxes 111
22355 10961 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/OpsRamp (2nd nomination) User:Whispering 18:58, 19 October 2018 (UTC) delete I wasn't able to find anything remotely notable when I searched for sources. Fails Deletion of OpsRamp (2nd nomination) WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
22356 10855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ken Case User:Smmurphy 15:20, 14 August 2017 (UTC) delete I don't find enough on newspapers.com, genealogybank (a newspaper site like newspapers.com), etc. I see a few mentions in program notes to confirm his radio and television work. I also find a couple passing mentions as a host of other events (radio and television hosts frequently are invited to host other events, after all), and mention of his country club. To me, it isn't enough to write a |neutral, |verifiable, |NOR article. I am generally in favor of allowing obituaries as sources, and this is clearly a public figure, suggesting the obituary is not merely vanity (regardless of the obituaries author). However, if an obituary is a/the main source, I feel it would be important to see more detail to really feel that a NPOV, NOR article can be written. I also think flexibility should be given for especially interesting cases (as suggested by ), but I don't see it here Deletion of Ken Case WP:NPOV||WP:V||WP:NOR||WP:ANYBIO Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
22357 17000 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Wrecks (2nd nomination) User:JayJay 05:09, 28 December 2020 (UTC) keep This article needs some improvements but with the Billboard pieces and other sources found this article meets Deletion of The Wrecks (2nd nomination) WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
22358 10467 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TV-Fucked By Plastic Queens User:Schuym1 23:36, 15 December 2008 (UTC) delete Doesn't show notability per Deletion of TV-Fucked By Plastic Queens WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22359 11217 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lance Skiiiwalker User:CAPTAIN 19:39, 22 February 2017 (UTC) keep He does seem to meet the notability criteria for and Deletion of Lance Skiiiwalker WP:MUSICBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22360 20561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alfred Zakharyaev User:HawkAussie 00:52, 29 June 2020 (UTC) delete Look for any reference and I am struggling to find any which would hve this pass Deletion of Alfred Zakharyaev WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22361 8862 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eastern Glow User:I 04:21, 5 May 2008 (UTC) delete Fails notability as per and Deletion of Eastern Glow WP:B Wikipedia:Bots 21
22362 3297 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kieran edwards User:Sparklism 10:57, 8 January 2013 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Kieran edwards WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22363 11850 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cecil Newton, Sr. User:Eagles247 19:48, 28 September 2011 (UTC) comment Looking closer at the Cecil Newton, Sr. article and the Cam Newton article, it doesn't appear that the Cecil Newton, Sr. article expands upon the controversy any further than what is already at the Cam Newton article and could meet |CSD A10. It appears that the entire Cecil Newton, Sr.#Scandal details section is copied word-for-word from Cam Newton#Eligibility controversy, which is actually considered a |copyright violation per Wikipedia:Copying within Wikipedia without attribution (could also meet |CSD G12 Deletion of Cecil Newton, Sr. WP:A10||WP:COPYRIGHT||WP:G12 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
22364 20152 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Steinmetz User:Bearian 17:29, 20 August 2018 (UTC) delete as passing neither |general notability nor |the professor test. This is a completely unsourced BLP, and thus subject to speedy deletion. There's |nothing available other than a few news stories about a protest, ''not about'' the person. Having one well-cited paper goes nowhere near passing the threshold of notability for academics. We are a not-for-profit encyclopedia, |not a resume service Deletion of Peter Steinmetz WP:GNG||WP:PROF||WP:SIGCOV||WP:NOTRESUME Wikipedia:Notability 77
22365 9149 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr Eric Pearl User:Bradjamesbrown 18:15, 27 November 2009 (UTC) comment His book does appear to exist http://www.amazon.com/Reconnection-Heal-Others-Yourself/dp/1561708194. Also, Google has lots of coverage of the subject http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Dr+Eric+Pearl%22&num=50 Is the subject notable? I honestly don't know. But this article could be of a much higher quality than it is now. (Also, a strict application of that unsourced information should be removed would leave absolutely no content, letting an A3 speedy go through Deletion of Dr Eric Pearl WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
22366 13544 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fountain of Tears User:Gongshow 00:21, 30 August 2014 (UTC) delete This http://www.crossrhythms.co.uk/products/Fountain_Of_Tears/Fate/43502/ album review was the best coverage I could find; subject does not appear to meet or Deletion of Fountain of Tears WP:GNG||WP:BAND Wikipedia:Notability 77
22367 6565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ellen Rose Levy User:PhnomPencil 01:56, 4 December 2011 (UTC) delete Smells like . Edited by one user with no other contributions. The only thing that could be considered notable -- that she was the first female bowler on this men's bowling team -- really isn't. I don't think the team would even get an article Deletion of Ellen Rose Levy WP:AUTOBIO Wikipedia:Autobiography 30
22368 3956 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Emraanakbar Enamdar User:Jmertel23 13:08, 21 November 2019 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON; fails Deletion of Emraanakbar Enamdar WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22369 10932 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alexandra Bruce (filmmaker) User:PaleoNeonate 21:49, 18 August 2020 (UTC) delete I tried searching for sources in various major newspapers but failed to find any coverage, indicating is not met. The very first version of the article long ago clearly described her as a conspiracy theorist but also lacked any decent source to back it up Deletion of Alexandra Bruce (filmmaker) WP:NBLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
22370 15776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joan of Arc Academy (Ottawa) User:TBrandley 02:35, 26 February 2013 (UTC) delete WP:N|Non-notable school per . Not much |significant coverage to indicate notability, according to a number of Google searches. There is no school district article to redirect to, so this will need to be performed probably Deletion of Joan of Arc Academy (Ottawa) WP:SCHOOLOUTCOMES||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
22371 18322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Audrey Doering User:ThatMontrealIP 05:27, 28 December 2019 (UTC) delete This is literally . It's a heartwarming story that belongs on GMA and not here Deletion of Audrey Doering WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
22372 8626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Miquel Serra [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']] 22:45, 22 January 2006 (UTC) delete The article makes some sense if filtered through a Spanish-to-English translator, as written by a Spaniard who isn't too happy with English spelling or grammatical rules. This person is still non-notable, {{tl|nn-bio}} tag, probably, refers Deletion of Miquel Serra WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22373 1841 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jordan Andrew Wilson User:Icewhiz 12:39, 12 March 2019 (UTC) delete Whether 2nd-tier Danish 1st Division (beneath Danish Superliga) possibly meets NFOOTY (not in current list) is immaterial, as this subject does not meet and NFOOTY merely creates a presumption of GNG. Per my BEFORE all we have is a signing announcement (which is mainly PR flap from the club as well) as a few brief mentions in match reports in possibly non-reliable sources. As we are clearly lacking '''significant coverage''' in '''|reliable sources''' that are '''ndependent sources|independent of the subject''' - subject simply does not have SIGCOV Deletion of Jordan Andrew Wilson WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE||WP:I||WP:reliable sources Wikipedia:Notability 77
22374 11420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ken Scalir User:MER 08:46, 10 May 2007 (UTC) delete unsourced |BLP Deletion of Ken Scalir WP:BLP Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
22375 9532 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shadowed Realms User:Gavin 09:59, 17 September 2007 (UTC) delete as fails to demonstrate notability per Deletion of Shadowed Realms WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22376 143 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Kutlu Özmakinacı Kullanıcı:justinianusjustinianus 20.00, 22 Şubat 2021 (UTC) keep Kayda değer olduğunu gösterir bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynaklar bulunmuyor. Her ne kadar #Besteci ve güfte yazarı kriterleri|besteci ve söz yazarları için öngörülen kriterleri karşılıyor olsa da, bunun dışında kayda değerliği gösterir bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynakların bulunmaması nedeniyle daha yakınım. Maalesef ülkemizde müzik yapan grupların üyeleri bireysel anlamda (bence) görmeleri gereken ilgiyi görmüyorlar, bu da kayda değerliği gösterebilecek kaynakların oluşmasını engelliyor. Yüksek Sadakat gibi bir grubun üyelerinden biri olarak kayda değer olması gereken ama mevcut şartlarda maalesef sağlayamayan bir madde diyebiliyorum yalnızca Kutlu Özmakinacı'nın silinmesi Vikipedi:Kayda_değerlik Wikipedia:Notability 77
22377 21572 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dulhe Raja (1998 film) [[User talk:98.212.162.154|talk]]) 04:56, 28 February 2008 (UTC) keep as per . Widely released, immensely popular Bollywood movie starring grade one cast ... even shown in Indian film festival in Japan http://www.japantoday.com/jp/news/265918. As for sources: http://movies.nytimes.com/movie/354242/Dulhe-Raja/overview, http://books.google.com/books?id=glDZKHgyoAoC&, http://books.google.com/books?id=8Q8Z9Ukwn6EC, http://books.google.com/books?id=s1mVuJJPm3UC etc Special:Contributions/98.212.162.154|98.212.162.154 Deletion of Dulhe Raja (1998 film) WP:MOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22378 7582 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Juan Carlos Domingo User:Skirts89 17:17, 25 January 2019 (UTC) delete Non-notable subject, fails Deletion of Juan Carlos Domingo WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22379 11719 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Omar Al Somah User:Joseph2302 09:40, 23 January 2016 (UTC) keep Passes per above Deletion of Omar Al Somah WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22380 10701 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apex High School User:TerriersFan 19:19, 10 October 2008 (UTC) keep high school for which sources are available to meet Deletion of Apex High School WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22381 2057 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chen Guanrong User:David 18:16, 20 October 2012 (UTC) keep """He passes multiple criteria: #C1 for his highly cited papers (e.g. 1626 Google scholar cites for """"From Chaos to Order"""", 1297 for """"Yet another chaotic attractor"""", 964 for """"Kalman filtering""""), #C3 as an IEEE Fellow, plausibly #C5 as argued above, and #C8 as editor-in-chief of IEEE Circuits and Systems (a major journal; he is also EIC of the International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos but I'm not sure whether that is as significant""" Deletion of Chen Guanrong WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22382 7389 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dhadak (song) User:1l2l3k 18:02, 31 July 2018 (UTC) merge info and make it a '''redirect''' to Dhadak, as it fails by itself Deletion of Dhadak (song) WP:NSONG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22383 73 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Peşeng Kullanıcı:takabegtakabeg 12:44, 26 Şubat 2010 (UTC) comment Manco'nun eline sağlık. Ancak bu SAS'ın gerekçesi lik değil, VP:ÖAY'liktir. '''Peşeng''' başlıklı bir madde açılabilir. Yine de bir kullanıcının ÖAY kralını ihlal eden maddeleri seri bir halinde açmasına müsaade edilmemesidir. Eğer kalma yönünde karar verilirse Peşeng'in silinmesi Vikipedi:KD Wikipedia:Notability 77
22384 16618 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dead Men's Hollow User:Tychocat 10:17, 2 September 2006 (UTC) delete per nom. Amazon sales ranking of their CD is somewhere about 295,000th, no evidence of charting, no national tours. They've won a local award, but needs more for , in particular, multiple non-trivial articles by third parties. Only 790 Ghits, mainly music directories. Being mainstream has nothing to do with notability Deletion of Dead Men's Hollow WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22385 208 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amie Street (2nd) User:Howrealisreal 15:31, 16 November 2006 (UTC) keep Meets for press coverage. Site is sole focus of http://www.pe.com/entertainment/music/stories/PE_Fea_Ent_D_music.amiestreet.23f1f85.html article in ''The Press-Enterprise (California)|The Press-Enterprise'', and this http://online.wsj.com/google_login.html?url=http%3A%2F%2Fonline.wsj.com%2Farticle%2FSB116077466937892327.html%3Fmod%3Dgooglenews_wsj article in ''The Wall Street Journal Deletion of Amie Street (2nd) WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22386 16278 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Radu Sardescu User:Jogurney 03:49, 18 September 2008 (UTC) delete no evidence that he has played in the I Liga and playing for Rapid II should not be sufficient to pass Deletion of Radu Sardescu WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22387 14029 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa M. Hansen [[User talk:74.57.5.235|talk]]) 01:33, 5 September 2010 (UTC) delete no |reliable sources to establish |notability. Directory entries are not reliable sources and only confer evidence of existence.--Special:Contributions/74.57.5.235|74.57.5.235 Deletion of Lisa M. Hansen WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22388 20713 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/CIMR User:Bearcat 20:47, 6 March 2018 (UTC) delete """To be fair, a station in another country can still use an initialism that begins with the letter C as its name. Yes, this station's name looks like a Canadian call sign, but that doesn't inherently make it an impossible name for a station in Ireland — stations in Ireland can still ''brand'' themselves with a name that ''looks'' like another country's call sign format, so its name isn't in and of itself a deletion criterion. That said, """"temporary licensed"""" stations are not granted an automatic presumption of notability per , especially when there isn't even a |reliable source present to ''support'' that there was a temporary license at all. One of the biggest problems here, in fact, is that as written I'm hard pressed to identify whether this is an active station that operates today, or a defunct station whose article just never got converted to the past tense, again precisely because of the lack of any reliable sources. To be eligible for an article, a station like this would need to be referenced to reliable source coverage about it — even a ''permanent'' licensed station still requires some evidence of reliable source coverage before it actually passes NMEDIA's criteria for the notability of radio stations. So no prejudice against recreation in the future if somebody can reference it properly, but nothing here entitles it to keep a completely unreferenced article just because it exists or existed""" Deletion of CIMR WP:NMEDIA||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22389 826 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Derek Allen User:MichaelQSchmidt 07:49, 14 April 2010 (UTC) keep While certainly the article might benefit from a |re-write through regular editing, and as the age thing is really not so important (albeit an nice addition), the subject appears to pass thlete... and it seems that TH does not mandate also meeting ... else there would fewer athletes here in Wikipedia. I do not believe TH is only for football, baseball, and basketball players Deletion of Derek Allen WP:ATD||WP:A||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
22390 9503 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/AMCO Sports Personality Of The Year User:Robertbcole 20:36, 2 November 2006 (UTC) delete """Wikipedia is |not for things made up in school. The page is only notable to the individuals participating in the """"events"""". Rather than using up Wikipedia's webspace, the participants should investigate free web hosting alternatives""" Deletion of AMCO Sports Personality Of The Year WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22391 21593 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tormenta (2nd nomination) User:Cwmhiraeth 10:12, 28 January 2020 (UTC) keep It was deemed notable in the previous AfD and has a comprehensive, well-referenced article in the Portuguese Wikipedia. I do not speak Portuguese, but it appears to meet Deletion of Tormenta (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22392 19884 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stephanie Bews User:HisSpaceResearch 17:33, 8 March 2008 (UTC) delete appears to fail due to the apparent lack of non-trivial coverage in reliable sources, unless these are provided - and I did search for some Deletion of Stephanie Bews WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22393 119 [[Topcon]] (schnellgelöscht) Benutzer:Andy king50 07:38, 7. Jul. 2007 (CEST) delete Mann müsste zwischen der Mutter http://www.topcon.co.jp/eng/corporate/index.html Topcom Corporation unterscheiden, die relevant ist, und in deren künftigen Artikel auch ein Absatz über die hier behandelte (als Unternehmen für einen eigenen Artikel nach nicht relevante) europäische Tochter drin vorkommen könnte. Wegen der URV im 1. Drittel und des zu streichenden komletten letzten 2/3 (nur Produktinformationen mit PR-Mäßigem Zuschnitt), und des auch so stark werblichen Zuschnittes: Platz für Neuanfang mit der Firmenmutter als Hauptgegenstand schaffen Löschung von Topcon Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
22394 103 [[Liste der Spitznamen in der Fußball-Bundesliga]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Steindy NONE delete Stimme dem SLA zu! – Geht’s noch? Dass über solchen Nonsens noch diskutiert wird, ist schon schändlich genug. |„4. Wikipedia ist kein Ort für Essays und kein Ort für Fan-Seiten…“ Wer solchen Unsinn haben möchte, der möge sich sein eigenes Wiki schnitzen. Bevorzugt Löschung von Liste der Spitznamen in der Fußball-Bundesliga Wikipedia:WWNI Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22395 4578 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Defibtech User:MER 13:44, 21 December 2006 (UTC) delete as thinly disguised Deletion of Defibtech WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
22396 10530 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Waldorf Schools User:Alansohn 04:33, 27 March 2007 (UTC) keep """The primary purposes of a list are to allow organization and additional details and to allow for red links, all of which can not be done in a category. See Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and series boxes for a rather clear explanation of the synergistic interaction of lists and categories; they are not mutually exclusive. As usual, is being used as an excuse to mean """"anything I have arbitrarily decided does not belong on Wikipedia, but won't offer a valid reason"""". The concern that red links """"may encourage people to make non-notable school articles"""" is just as ludicrous as the fear that they might lead to mixed dancing""" Deletion of List of Waldorf Schools WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22397 16164 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Weapons and items from The Legend of Zelda series User:Yukichigai 20:00, 23 January 2007 (UTC) comment See also #What about article x?. -- |Y'''| Deletion of Weapons and items from The Legend of Zelda series WP:AADD||WP:IKNOWBEST Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
22398 12200 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fiction set in Geneva User:Alan 22:59, 9 March 2012 (UTC) delete per the ''spirit'' of and Deletion of List of fiction set in Geneva WP:NOT||WP:N Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22399 2005 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/IQ by race User:ScienceApologist 19:05, 22 January 2007 (UTC) delete This article is definitely assuming a POV straight off the bat (that race and intelligence comeasurement are reportable correlations). Since race is mostly sociological while intelligence is entirely psychometric, such an article is either entirely |original research or it is POV-pushing a conservative racial agenda ala ''The Bell Curve Deletion of IQ by race WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22400 18561 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Thompson (2nd nomination) User:Sir 18:21, 1 October 2010 (UTC) comment I'm still on the fence on this one. However, I do have one question. Why is playing a match in one national competition more noteworthy than playing the same match in another? While I'm well aware that Watford F.C. and Notts County F.C. do not play in the same league, but if Mr. Thompson had appeared in a league fixture between the two, even in the lower of the two leagues in which they currently play, there would be no question whatsoever of him meeting . Just some food for thought Deletion of Adam Thompson (2nd nomination) WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22401 17399 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Korean influence on Japanese culture User:De 19:16, 13 October 2014 (UTC) delete Violation of , , , , etc., as pointed out by the nominator, Nishidani and others. Overall, the opponents of the deletion have not provided effective counterarguments Deletion of Korean influence on Japanese culture WP:WEIGHT||WP:SYNTH||WP:OR||WP:RS Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
22402 8968 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Master of Badness User:Panyd 02:00, 15 November 2008 (UTC) delete WP is not Urban Dictionary and Deletion of Master of Badness WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22403 9842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Teeka Ram Meena User:Cewbot 00:02, 5 April 2021 (UTC) comment This nomination has had limited participation and falls within the standards set for |lack of quorum. There are no previous AfD discussions, undeletions, or current redirects and no previous PRODs have been located. This nomination may be '''eligible for |soft deletion''' at the end of its 7-day listing Deletion of Teeka Ram Meena WP:NOQUORUM||WP:SOFTDELETE Wikipedia:Deletion process 36
22404 17458 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2007 French coach crash User:Tellyaddict 15:39, 22 March 2007 (UTC) keep As the creator of this article, it is referenced and is written according to and does satisfy the |notability guideline Deletion of 2007 French coach crash WP:MOS||WP:NN Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
22405 9616 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Murder of Anthony Walker User:Edison 20:00, 6 June 2007 (UTC) keep """Even though we do not have to keep an article on every crime which gets a couple of newspaper stories, per , this crime is somewhat more than ordinary in its import, since it was racially motivated (per """"urban life Darcus Howe. New Statesman. London: Jan 9, 2006. Vol.19, Iss. 893; pg. 17, 1 pgs"""" the killers were angered to see a black student walking with his white girlfriend). This is not included in the article, and I'm not sure with all the BLP deletions if we are now allowed to mention it.), a killer was related to a prominent sports figure (not unlike Michael Skakel the Kennedy relative who was convicted of murdering a teenage girl Martha Moxley giving that crime enhanced notability), and they fled outside the country before being apprehended""" Deletion of Murder of Anthony Walker WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22406 4393 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shit sandwich User:Haemo 02:52, 15 May 2007 (UTC) delete Wikipedia is |not a slang usage guide, or a compendium of instances where slang has occurred in popular culture Deletion of Shit sandwich WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22407 13762 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Dark Reign User:Mdsummermsw 19:38, 15 May 2008 (UTC) comment """The discussion here is not whether or not the album exists. We are trying to decide if this album is """"notable"""". Per guidelines at , unreleased albums are not notable (that is, don't get an article) without substantial coverage in reliable, third-party sources. """"Substantial coverage"""" means it goes into some detail. Myspace is ''not'' a """"|reliable source"""". The band's myspace is not a third-party source""" Deletion of The Dark Reign WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22408 9310 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Sean Salazar U.S. Senate Candidate 2010, Washington State User:A 05:15, 16 December 2009 (UTC) delete Yikes, this should not have survived in the mainspace for three weeks. This is pure – that is, it is promotional in nature but disguised as a legitimate article. The article was created by someone with a |conflict of interest, seeking to promote their preferred candidate in a Senate race, and so fails , particularly Deletion of Dr. Sean Salazar U.S. Senate Candidate 2010, Washington State WP:ARTSPAM||WP:COI||WP:NOT||WP:SOAP Wikipedia:Spam 112
22409 6197 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gajanand Rajput User:Astudent0 13:49, 27 May 2010 (UTC) delete I found no evidence that shows this person passes Deletion of Gajanand Rajput WP:MANOTE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22410 18547 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daffodil Kingpin of Montana User:Eddie 04:20, 21 November 2005 (UTC) delete as the kind of hoax covered by omplete Bollocks Deletion of Daffodil Kingpin of Montana WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
22411 9736 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of covers of U2 songs User:A 03:24, 24 February 2010 (UTC) delete per . This stand-alone list is too broad in scope and indiscriminate in its nature; it therefore isn't a suitable list topic. For the purposes of comparison, consensus at rticles for deletion/List of covers of the smashing pumpkins songs|a similar AfD for a list of Smashing Pumpkins covers was to delete Deletion of List of covers of U2 songs WP:SALAT||WP:A Wikipedia:Stand-alone lists 48
22412 12441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Collins Press User:Mrschimpf 18:35, 5 January 2012 (UTC) delete as redirect is non-controversial and in error by above nominator. This can be closed, and in the future, redirects should be taken to if there is some issue with deletion Deletion of Collins Press WP:RFD Wikipedia:Redirect 56
22413 12832 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian Fang User:Qworty 19:20, 16 September 2012 (UTC) delete Woefully fails Deletion of Ian Fang WP:ENTERTAINER Wikipedia:Notability 77
22414 19214 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John C. Hench Division of Animation and Digital Arts User:TonyBallioni 22:30, 10 December 2017 (UTC) merge The current text is , even including a lengthy quote direct from the USC web site, and the argument won't fly, so I agree with Deletion of John C. Hench Division of Animation and Digital Arts WP:PROMO||WP:OTHERSTUFF Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22415 9837 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Iron Chef Thailand User:Spiderone 09:44, 27 November 2020 (UTC) delete I'm very surprised that this passed AfC. If people aren't happy with deleting this, then maybe '''redirect''' to Iron Chef where it is already mentioned in enough detail. There don't seem to be any to establish notability for this particular version of the show Deletion of Iron Chef Thailand WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22416 16258 """Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter and the Wolf (""""Weird Al"""" Yankovic & Wendy Carlos album)""" User:Gongshow 22:41, 7 March 2015 (UTC) keep In addition to the Grammy nomination mentioned above by Arxiloxos, there is a 2nd write-up in the ''Chicago Tribune'' (http://archives.chicagotribune.com/1988/10/16/page/350/article/arts-afield 1988), and further coverage in ''People'' magazine (http://www.people.com/people/archive/article/0,,20100507,00.html 1988), and ''Keyboard'' magazine (1988; snippet https://books.google.com/books?id=agw9AQAAIAAJ&q=peter+wolf+%22wendy+carlos%22+%22weird+al%22&dq=peter+wolf+%22wendy+carlos%22+%22weird+al%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=Anj7VPm3HMvboAT-goGIAQ&ved=0CDwQ6AEwBg 1, https://books.google.com/books?id=agw9AQAAIAAJ&q=%22carlos+and+yankovic%22&dq=%22carlos+and+yankovic%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=CHv7VKK5OY_xoASNp4KIDw&ved=0CB4Q6AEwAA 2). Subject meets and """Deletion of Peter and the Wolf (""""Weird Al"""" Yankovic & Wendy Carlos album)""" WP:GNG||WP:NALBUMS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22417 409 [[OVirt]] (gelöscht) Benutzer:Hephaion/Pong 20:47, 1. Okt. 2013 (CEST) delete Kasten|1= . Die sind da relativ eindeutig; eine nachgewiesene Verbreitung kann ich aufgrund mangelnder Testberichte/Literatur nicht erkennen. Löschung von OVirt Wikipedia:RKSW Wikipedia:Notability 77
22418 21861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rex Lease User:MichaelQSchmidt 04:59, 21 September 2011 (UTC) keep The AFD's ''Find sources'' show the error of the nom's statement. met. met. Time to early close per . No sense we all pile on to remind the nominator about |looking beyond current state Deletion of Rex Lease WP:ENT||WP:GNG||WP:OUTCOMES||WP:IMPROVE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22419 13312 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ian Jopling User:Devokewater 11:42, 23 February 2021 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Ian Jopling WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22420 19485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Balbina Steffenone User:Dhartung 07:50, 27 August 2007 (UTC) comment """Well, it was said, credible or not. JSTOR has an obituary online http://links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0958-8434(18970201)38%3A648%3C124%3AOBS%3E2.0.CO%3B2-N sub only that calls her """"an operatic star greatly admired in her time"""" (that's visible in the Google results for http://www.google.com/search?q=bina.steffenone bina.steffenone). And the http://oq.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/citation/21/1/68?ck=nck Opera Quarterly has an article where she is described as """"on this tour (Verdi) the brightest of the star sopranos"""" (in counterpoint to a critic's """"extravagant praise""""). In a bio of Walt Whitman he is described as hearing """"sixteen of the major singers who made their debut in the next eight years"""" including Steffanone (note that the """"a"""" spelling returns about the same number of results wherever). There is a mini-bio in a footnote in http://books.google.com/books?id=GgwbQC2KVzMC&pg=PA63&dq=Balbina+Steffanone&ei=BIHSRp3WBJPWoQKfv8HQBw&ie=ISO-8859-1&sig=h7ccrhmIw6vV08gd8XDpsO5fMh0 The Diaries of Giacomo Meyerbeer, noting her """"great success"""" (touring the whole of the Americas) and her """"big expressive voice"""". (Also search under just """"Bina"""".) Maybe not universally regarded as ''one of the greatest'' but certainly |notable""" Deletion of Balbina Steffenone WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22421 5352 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donyi Taga (Networker) User:WikiDan61 15:41, 1 October 2014 (UTC) delete No indications of anything notable. A |run of the mill student Deletion of Donyi Taga (Networker) WP:MILL Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill 115
22422 3859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kevin Vandenbroek User:Alias 20:08, 15 July 2006 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Kevin Vandenbroek WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22423 19607 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grey wolf protection argument User:Cool3 15:21, 7 April 2009 (UTC) delete It's either a |POV-fork on the one hand, or |original research/essay on the other. Either way, I'm afraid it doesn't mean the standards for inclusion Deletion of Grey wolf protection argument WP:POVFORK||WP:NOR Wikipedia:Content forking 33
22424 20567 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Digital amnesia [[User talk:74.137.108.115|74]] 23:44, 4 March 2009 (UTC) keep per sources added above. Was followed in this nomination? – Deletion of Digital amnesia WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
22425 11609 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Solar bowl User:Wikidemon 19:20, 8 August 2009 (UTC) comment """on the surface, seems to be a bad nomination. The subject is apparently notablehttp://scitation.aip.org/getabs/servlet/GetabsServlet?prog=normal&id=JSEEDO000114000004000272000001&idtype=cvips&gifs=yeshttp://solar.calfinder.com/blog/going/the-solar-bowl-solar-vs-electric-water-heaters/http://www.auroville.org/research/ren_energy/solar_bowl.htm and the article, such as exists at the momenthttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Solar_bowl&oldid=306826140 is sourceable and perhaps sourced. It was nominated for deletion in ''less than one minute'' after creation,http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Solar_bowl&diff=306822305&oldid=306822205 The article creator admits to a potential , being a newbie, and being unfamiliar with process. We all remember writing our first article, right? New editors deserve |a little extra slack. Hopefully they will review their """"welcome to Wikipedia"""" package and look to emulate the methods, style, and tone of some of the better articles they can find around here. There are """"templates"""" you can use to indicate that you are in the middle of an article and requesting a little time - I won't point you to them because it's useful to learn the ropes by climbing them. I suggest the nominator withdraw the nomination, watchlist it, correspond with the article creator about any concerns, and consider re-nominating it later if they still believe the subject to be non-notable""" Deletion of Solar bowl WP:COI||WP:BITE Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
22426 6447 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Riverside (Barrie-James O'Neill song) User:Ashleyyoursmile 08:15, 2 February 2021 (UTC) delete per nom. Fails . Google search turned up nothing, should be deleted per lack of coverage Deletion of Riverside (Barrie-James O'Neill song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22427 1346 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yannai Gonczarowski [[User talk:Becky Sayles|''' B E C K Y S A Y L E S ''']] 01:19, 11 January 2015 (UTC) delete Insufficient references to support Deletion of Yannai Gonczarowski WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22428 11222 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tumalip User:HisSpaceResearch 07:33, 5 January 2008 (UTC) comment I don't know about barangays, but it's been established that all stand-alone places are notable. But if barangays are just small sub-communities within settlements, then I'd agree that they're probably not notable as stand-alone entries, and they all have to pass as well Deletion of Tumalip WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
22429 15182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wajahat Hasan User:Anupmehra 13:09, 6 January 2015 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Wajahat Hasan WP:MUSICBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22430 8082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Raccoon City User:Verdatum 21:55, 2 January 2008 (UTC) keep As with the recently deleted article on S.T.A.R.S, this appears to be another issue of a split due to . As is currently under discussion Wikipedia_talk:Notability#Notability_and_size_splits|here, I find it distressing that a split for size reasons removes the concept of Deletion of Raccoon City WP:SIZE||WP:NNC Wikipedia:Article size 51
22431 16843 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Peter Hargitay User:Whpq 14:20, 13 February 2013 (UTC) comment Issues of details which are not directly related to the reason for notability per are things that can be taken care of through regular editting, and do not necessitate the deletion of the article. With respect to , that guideline does not preclude a standalone article on an individual related to an event. The newspaper sources noted above show coverage that spans a period time (notabiltiy is not temporary), and includes articles that cover him as the primary subject Deletion of Peter Hargitay WP:AVOIDVICTIM||WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
22432 9356 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vinay Deolalikar User:Adacore 16:40, 10 August 2010 (UTC) comment While I agree that this article is currently highly dubious for notability, mainstream press articles are beginning to appear. For example, a http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn19287-p--np-its-bad-news-for-the-power-of-computing.html New Scientist story was published today. I would be surprised if there was not enough coverage within the next couple of days to gain notability. Yes, this is a crystal ball argument, but is there really any harm waiting a few days Deletion of Vinay Deolalikar WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22433 7438 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Justus Goebel User:JaconaFrere 11:00, 15 August 2018 (UTC) keep There are plenty of sources to meet , although they may not come up in a casual search. It appears this is a case of recency bias, because the sources are not in-your-face on the internet. They are on paper, microfilm, and in old newspapers (including the NY Times), but often behind paywalls. He made page 2 of the NY Times in 2/09/1900. The article may not be in a perfect state now, but there is to make it better Deletion of Justus Goebel WP:GNG||WP:TIME Wikipedia:Notability 77
22434 15874 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Da Yellow Bus Rydah User:Hobbes 01:22, 14 January 2013 (UTC) merge to Ghost Ride It, the single that actually ''was'' released, to some notice. The article offers no cite to suggest that the album will actually materialize in 2013, or ever, and I couldn't readily find anything useful in searches, as to current release date or to make the case that this is one of those rare Chinese Democracy-type cases. Certainly, it's not up on Amazon for pre-order. Fails . And redirect, not merge, as what little here worth keeping is already incorporated in the song's article Deletion of Da Yellow Bus Rydah WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22435 7460 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sir Ralf of Bracebridge User:Edison 04:51, 17 October 2008 (UTC) delete Too much speculation, too few facts. Fails |verifiability due to lack of |reliable sources Deletion of Sir Ralf of Bracebridge WP:V||WP:RS Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
22436 17305 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meatitarians User:Gwernol 03:39, 4 July 2006 (UTC) delete WP:N|Non-notable |neologism Deletion of Meatitarians WP:NEO Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
22437 4950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dr. Suresh Kumar Mishra 'Uratrupta' User:Creffett 13:50, 17 November 2019 (UTC) delete looks like an autobiography, being a translator and having a couple textbooks published doesn't seem especially notable, doesn't look like it passes or Deletion of Dr. Suresh Kumar Mishra 'Uratrupta' WP:NACADEMIC||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22438 3185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I Killed My Lesbian Wife, Hung Her on a Meat Hook, and Now I Have a Three-Picture Deal at Disney User:MichaelQSchmidt 10:16, 12 September 2017 (UTC) keep this silly & bad short film per meeting inclusion criteria of . We'd love to have even more, but I believe coverage by http://ew.com/article/2013/02/21/ben-affleck-i-killed-my-lesbian-wife/ ''Entertainment Weekly'' http://www.slashfilm.com/watch-ben-afflecks-atrocious-directorial-debut-i-killed-my-lesbian-wife-hung-her-on-a-meat-hook-and-now-i-have-a-three-picture-deal-at-disney/ ''SlashFilm'',https://filmschoolrejects.com/watch-ben-afflecks-embarrassing-directorial-debut-from-1993-943909a1c74/ ''Film School Rejects'', http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/risky-business/ben-afflecks-i-killed-my-422734 ''Hollywood Reporter'', http://www.cinemablend.com/new/Watch-Ben-Affleck-Debut-Directorial-Short-I-Killed-My-Lesbian-Wife-35849.html ''Cinemablend'', http://news.avclub.com/ben-affleck-made-a-movie-called-i-killed-my-lesbian-wi-1798236481 ''AV Club'', https://www.pastemagazine.com/articles/2013/02/watch-early-ben-affleck-directed-short-film-i-kill.html ''Paste'', and http://www.eonline.com/news/819115/ben-affleck-has-come-a-long-way-since-i-killed-my-lesbian-wife ''E-Online'' are enough Deletion of I Killed My Lesbian Wife, Hung Her on a Meat Hook, and Now I Have a Three-Picture Deal at Disney WP:NF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22439 2017 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/M. Dale Newton User:Ozgod 17:00, 26 February 2008 (UTC) delete Article (lacking references) appears to be a non-|notable biography Deletion of M. Dale Newton WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22440 8889 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/New Brooklyn User:MichaelQSchmidt 17:37, 1 October 2008 (UTC) keep per improvements to article. rystal does not apply as principle filming has finished. Have cleaned up article per mos and set links back to notability on Spanish Wiki Deletion of New Brooklyn WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
22441 6784 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shinichi Kitaoka User:Firefly322 10:16, 17 August 2008 (UTC) keep find|Shinichi Kitaoka}} A major international figure who is mentioned in books, journals, and the general media. This article should never have been nominated. The nom deserves a Deletion of Shinichi Kitaoka WP:TROUT Wikipedia:Whacking with a wet trout 74
22442 14668 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Berg (Kabbalah Centre) User:JediLofty 16:10, 4 September 2008 (UTC) delete Article fails . Subject is not notable on his own, and |notability is not inherited Deletion of Michael Berg (Kabbalah Centre) WP:OR||WP:NOTINHERITED Wikipedia:No original research 65
22443 12179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mark Tucker (musician) User:Ikiroid 21:37, 28 September 2006 (UTC) delete Why didn't you this Deletion of Mark Tucker (musician) WP:PROD Wikipedia:Proposed deletion 43
22444 14401 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Akash Jain User:ChunnuBhai 05:52, 9 April 2017 (UTC) delete Apart from being , the author is likely to have , and is also likely canvassing and voting here as a neutral voter. The article clearly has self promotional purpose Deletion of Akash Jain WP:1E||WP:COI Wikipedia:Notability 77
22445 8687 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Reno Barons User:Dirtlawyer1 00:28, 12 June 2015 (UTC) delete Non-notable minor league football team that never played a regular season game. Fails the notability guidelines for sports teams and other organizations per and for lack of significant coverage in multiple, independent, reliable sources Deletion of Reno Barons WP:ORG||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22446 18708 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bani Mustafa User:Evanh2008 20:11, 12 June 2012 (UTC) delete per , and . What few RS's there are (Peake and Field) are improperly formatted so aren't even verifiable Deletion of Bani Mustafa WP:COI||WP:VERIFY Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
22447 4504 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Little (attorney) User:Boblittle 11:21, 17 June 2006 (UTC) delete advert, and given the author . The fact that Deletion of Robert Little (attorney) WP:VANITY Wikipedia:Conflict of interest 5
22448 2179 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/B-3 Long Range Strike Platform User:Ktr101 04:04, 8 January 2008 (UTC) delete per rystal. The requirements haven't even yet been settled on and the assignment of the designator B-3 is entirely speculative. I agree with Deletion of B-3 Long Range Strike Platform WP:C Wikipedia:Copyrights 67
22449 20420 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thanksmas User:Persian 04:38, 30 November 2006 (UTC) delete seems like |patent nonsense to me Deletion of Thanksmas WP:NONSENSE Wikipedia:Patent nonsense 105
22450 15170 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Sons of Eilaboun NONE NONE keep The film also meets the following principles of Deletion of The Sons of Eilaboun WP:MOVIE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22451 1881 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dragan Karanfilovski-Bojs User:Geschichte 21:51, 11 February 2020 (UTC) delete per unless it's sourced that he was a star in Macedonia. Had he been a performer at the ESC it might have been different, but he was just a songwriter. Could redirect to either the song or his family member Deletion of Dragan Karanfilovski-Bojs WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
22452 4912 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Los Angeles Dodgers Opening Day Starting Lineups User:Jaranda 23:02, 9 August 2007 (UTC) delete please read and , the notabilty case is moot here as we are talking about a list here, not the players of the list, with that reasoning, every list on pointless subjects gets articles, because they have related to notable people Deletion of List of Los Angeles Dodgers Opening Day Starting Lineups WP:LISTCRUFT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:Listcruft 109
22453 8950 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pass the pickle User:Gurch 08:30, 28 May 2006 (UTC) delete as patent nonsense under |CSD G1 Deletion of Pass the pickle WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
22454 12296 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2010 Honshu earthquake (2nd nomination) User:Umbralcorax 16:54, 21 May 2010 (UTC) keep For my reasoning see the previous AFD. The nominator may not feel it holds up, but I disagree. A 6.6 earthquake is past the threshold of being a simple |news story and puts it into the realm of encyclopedic event Deletion of 2010 Honshu earthquake (2nd nomination) WP:NOTNEWS Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22455 17362 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Jordan Steaks User:Alexius08 14:10, 11 November 2008 (UTC) delete smells like |spam Deletion of Michael Jordan Steaks WP:SPAM Wikipedia:Spam 112
22456 363 [[1000 Tage]] (bleibt) Benutzer:Hephaion NONE keep Kasten|1= . Gemäß den #Filme lief er auf einem relevanten Festival, daher RK erfüllt. Löschung von 1000 Tage Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
22457 16856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adhyapaknagar User:AusLondonder 01:50, 31 March 2016 (UTC) keep """Obviously needs drastic improvement but per all legally recognised, populated places are presumed to be notable. Google maps apparently lists this neighbourhood as """"Adhyapak Nagar"""" with a space""" Deletion of Adhyapaknagar WP:NGEO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22458 20629 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Minicraft User:Sergecross73 23:39, 4 January 2012 (UTC) keep Plenty of coverage in reliable, third party sources. It seems like this nomination was based more along the lines of , not actual notabilibilty concerns. (No bad faith intended on my part Deletion of Minicraft WP:IDONTLIKEIT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
22459 11680 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Julia Clancey User:Kneel17 01:57, 21 July 2007 (UTC) delete She's apparently up-and-coming, but |non-notable at the moment. Not only are there prices included, but some parts of the article are word for word copies from the Julia Clancey website http://www.juliaclancey.com/docs/about/index.html Deletion of Julia Clancey WP:NN Wikipedia:Notability 77
22460 15733 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of songs about homosexuality [[User:(aeropagitica)|''' (aeropagitica) ''']][[User talk:(aeropagitica)|''' (talk) ''']] 15:34, 15 May 2006 (UTC) keep Bad faith nomination, refers Deletion of List of songs about homosexuality WP:POINT Wikipedia:Do not disrupt Wikipedia to illustrate a point 24
22461 9202 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sandor Clegane User:Newimpartial 18:36, 11 July 2017 (UTC) keep I see dozens of scholarly references on even a cursory search using Google Scholar. What does mean, again Deletion of Sandor Clegane WP:BEFORE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
22462 18092 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Karmarama (advertising agency) User:Yappy2bhere 20:26, 17 January 2012 (UTC) keep The Google news search indicates sufficient coverage in even excluding articles that are probably press releases or rewrites of press releases Deletion of Karmarama (advertising agency) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22463 5159 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Warren Baker User:MichaelQSchmidt 09:27, 21 December 2009 (UTC) delete Wow. Here's an individual who appears to meet , but his name is so common that it is nigh on impossible to find sources Deletion of Warren Baker WP:ENT Wikipedia:Notability 77
22464 2487 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Arun Kumar Pallathadka (2nd nomination) User:Redtigerxyz 10:46, 2 September 2012 (UTC) delete """fails (""""Significant coverage"""") and """ Deletion of Arun Kumar Pallathadka (2nd nomination) WP:GNG||WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
22465 3615 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Black Golden Globe Award winners and nominees User:Feedback 16:42, 25 February 2011 (UTC) comment """If we allow this list to exist, then we should definitely open a """"List of Caucasian Golden Globe winners and nominees"""". There's no difference. By allowing this article to exist and not the latter, you're not being neutral. This list has absolutely no impact or cultural significance. """"'''African Americans in Cinema''' would be a very culturally important article, but that isn't what we're voting for here. We're voting to either keep or delete a very |TRIVIAL list that doesn't need placement in an encyclopedia. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia after all, not a Golden Globes trivia handbook""" Deletion of List of Black Golden Globe Award winners and nominees WP:TRIVIA Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
22466 6579 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shayea (rapper) User:Bearian 16:50, 14 September 2020 (UTC) delete per . Actually, already deleted Deletion of Shayea (rapper) WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Snowball clause 101
22467 17980 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Abeil User:4meter4 03:08, 29 September 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Abeil WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22468 1958 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Erika Andiola User:Bakazaka 21:55, 17 November 2018 (UTC) keep """as subject easily passes . Even under the non-policy, non-guideline """"name in headlines in articles that are supposed to be about her"""" criterion introduced into this discussion, the subject passes, see e.g. {{cite news|url=http://articles.latimes.com/2013/jan/11/nation/la-na-nn-erika-andiola-immigrant-activist-family-detained-by-immigration-officials-20130111|title=Relatives of Erika Andiola, immigrant activist, detained|work=Los Angeles Times|first=Cindy|last=Carcamo|date=January 11, 2013|access-date=November 17, 2018}} Thanks to {{u|Megalibrarygirl}} for putting in the work to improve the article""" Deletion of Erika Andiola WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22469 2952 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kahaani 2 User:Gongshow 18:01, 14 February 2013 (UTC) merge to Kahaani#Sequel for now. This article duplicates the content from that section; seems for a standalone article for the sequel at this time Deletion of Kahaani 2 WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
22470 11199 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaalaippani User:Spiderone 14:34, 9 July 2020 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Kaalaippani WP:NFILM Wikipedia:Notability 77
22471 20562 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National Council of Investigative and Security Services User:GreenJoe 05:28, 22 April 2007 (UTC) delete as it fails Deletion of National Council of Investigative and Security Services WP:ORG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22472 8003 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Séamus Coleman User:GiantSnowman 12:12, 25 June 2009 (UTC) delete as recreation of deleted material, #G4 Deletion of Séamus Coleman WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
22473 15967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Project Husker User:Blueboy96 20:04, 12 July 2007 (UTC) delete per . Comes pretty close to being an A3 as well Deletion of Project Husker WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22474 937 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Authbind User:Lilac 18:43, 8 March 2009 (UTC) comment neither is a valid argument for outright deletion. The lack of references could be handled with a {{tl|unreferenced}} tag for a month or two before trying deletion; and being poorly written just means that |you could fix it yourself. What matters is if it meets . It might not, but it isn't at all clear that it doesn't Deletion of Authbind WP:SOFIXIT||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Be bold 9
22475 6794 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mosh & Go User:Gongshow 05:03, 22 December 2015 (UTC) delete I am unable to find evidence that this compilation meets or Deletion of Mosh & Go WP:GNG||WP:NALBUM Wikipedia:Notability 77
22476 7764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mass civilian casualties of Israeli bombing, shelling and rocket attacks on the Gaza Strip user:Shrike 14:58, 22 November 2019 (UTC) delete As wikipedia:NOTESSAY|essay i.e there is no sources that discuss those events together as part of some pattern Deletion of Mass civilian casualties of Israeli bombing, shelling and rocket attacks on the Gaza Strip WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22477 3842 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/South Dublin Football League User:BigDom 23:08, 19 February 2010 (UTC) delete Unless we're going to set some absurd precedence that all schoolboy and junior leagues deserve an article on Wikipedia, this one has no place here. Nobody would argue that the Accrington and District Junior Football League should have an article and that league is 51 years old and the strongest junior league in Hyndburn(!). There's no sources to suggest that the league passes the |general notability guidelines and the clubs in the league are not eligible for any national senior competition Deletion of South Dublin Football League WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22478 10911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amelia Kinkade User:DESiegel 19:28, 13 September 2020 (UTC) keep I have added several sources to the article, and will be adding more. I believe the article as it stands passes both the GNG and . Nost of thsese sources could and should have been cited long ago. It is true that most of them do not show up on a basic google search Deletion of Amelia Kinkade WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
22479 4194 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Manspreading User:Bearian 00:33, 21 April 2015 (UTC) keep per - many reliable newspapers and magazines have had articles on the ''phenomenon'', not the word itself. Wikipedia has |many odd articles Deletion of Manspreading WP:BEFORE||WP:ODD Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
22480 8150 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sikkimonline User:Seed 12:13, 9 June 2007 (UTC) delete No assertion of notability. On top of that, it clearly fails . There are no sources, just links to multiple sections of the website. After filtering the site in question and discounting Wiki-mirrors, I got 268 Ghits (the first, incidentally, being a spammers-paradise.com link). I'm also concerned with the lack of content: the site's AUP, for example, is hardly something that should be mentioned in an encyclopedic article and aside from that and a general description, there just isn't much, I'm afraid. I'm sure a lot of work has gone into this websitehttp://www.theadminzone.com/forums/showthread.php?t=26361, but it's just not ready for inclusion here yet. Sorry. Tagged as A7 Deletion of Sikkimonline WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22481 11337 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tiffany Williamson (2nd nomination) User:Frank 03:35, 27 May 2008 (UTC) delete for lack of independent coverage. The few news hits from 2005 seem to solely mention the novelty of a female in the tournament, but do not seem to be profiles of her. | Notability does not seem to be established. | Reliable sources are not even referenced in the article. (I could be convinced with independent coverage, but...I couldn't find anything significant Deletion of Tiffany Williamson (2nd nomination) WP:NOTE||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22482 17328 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Le Pietre (yacht) User:Cullen328 21:34, 22 February 2011 (UTC) delete """This article is little more than a sales brochure for this yacht, and is packed full of |puffery. It is unreferenced and violates |the neutral point of view. Do we want some rich guy to be able to brag, """"My yacht is so spectacular that it has its own Wikipedia page!"""" I don't think so""" Deletion of Le Pietre (yacht) WP:PEACOCK||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Manual of Style 6
22483 1591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al Jalaa Highrise User:Dainomite 05:08, 21 May 2021 (UTC) keep but rename to something akin to Bombing of Al-Jalaa Tower as it meets due to it receiving significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject. If this is the direction the AfD goes (the page is renamed for the event) we can establish consensus on the name via a new poll. — Deletion of Al Jalaa Highrise WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22484 14861 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ice Poseidon User:Prevan 02:29, 24 May 2017 (UTC) delete fails Deletion of Ice Poseidon WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22485 16052 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Les Edgerton User:MarkH21 07:45, 24 September 2020 (UTC) keep In addition to the reviews found by {{u|Z1720}} (which includes the ''Stuttgarter Zeitung''), I also found https://tagesspiegel.de/kultur/roman-der-vergewaltiger-manifest-aus-der-todeszelle/19472966.html this review from ''Der Tagesspiegel'' and https://www.freitag.de/autoren/der-freitag/my-life-as-a-russian-novel another from ''Der Freitag'' with just enough coverage to probably be significant. The five reviews (why so many are from German daily newspapers, I don’t know) probably show that this barely passes #3 Deletion of Les Edgerton WP:NAUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
22486 19674 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Khowar Academy User:Sandstein 11:15, 22 January 2013 (UTC) delete per : No coverage in reliable independent sources is cited Deletion of Khowar Academy WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22487 4287 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rowan Hamilton User:Bearian 21:12, 10 June 2010 (UTC) delete fails , , and Deletion of Rowan Hamilton WP:RS||WP:BLP||WP:PROF Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22488 3709 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ethnic stereotypes in American media User:Hateless 05:44, 30 June 2006 (UTC) comment Stereotypes are subjective matters, true, and there will always be controversy over what is a stereotype. However, there is no rule that Wikipedia must shy away from controversies and that Wikipedia can only cover objective truths. The rule that applies, however, is that all sides of the controversy be given equal weight (). There has been plenty analyzed and written about stereotypes, the task WP places upon itself is to represent what is out there Deletion of Ethnic stereotypes in American media WP:NPOV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
22489 17753 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jeddah Hilton Hotel User:Eggishorn 03:57, 29 August 2017 (UTC) delete Despite concerns about the nomination. The page was created by {{u|Ammar shaker}} and {{u|Valgetova}}'s contributions seem limited to a requested move from Jeddah Hilton to Jeddah Hilton Hotel and and EL to the hotel's website, hardly significant contributions by a paid editor. That said, the page does not provide an evidence of complying with |the general notability guideline and I can find only |routine coverage about the hotel. The subject appears to lack significant coverage in independent, reliable sources Deletion of Jeddah Hilton Hotel WP:GNG||WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22490 8536 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Wilson (British politician) User:FOARP 18:18, 5 October 2019 (UTC) keep Is he VERY notable? No. But somehow he's managed to stay in the news for years: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-32038485 1 https://www.lancashiretelegraph.co.uk/news/national/11874891.farage-shrugs-off-ex-candidate-jibe/ 2 http://euromaidanpress.com/2019/07/09/how-russian-propaganda-outlets-manipulate-comments-dubbing-them-in-russian/ 3 https://inews.co.uk/culture/television/tim-wilson-circle-2019-contestants-line-up-professor-ukip-candidate-quit-637121 4. Easy pass for Deletion of Tim Wilson (British politician) WP:BASIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22491 6551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Frida Matsdotter User:Epinoia 16:03, 22 September 2019 (UTC) delete WP:TOOSOON - does not meet any of the 6 criteria of - no significant coverage in multiple reliable secondary sources per - article can be re-created if a career is established Deletion of Frida Matsdotter WP:COMPOSER||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22492 14322 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 attacks on Indian students in Australia User:Nick 09:43, 11 June 2009 (UTC) keep This meets WP:N and is out of scope of #NEWS given the extent and duration of international and domestic Australian coverage Deletion of 2009 attacks on Indian students in Australia WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22493 17698 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Plunderphonics User:Thine 18:37, 21 December 2012 (UTC) keep passes Deletion of Plunderphonics WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22494 7916 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Russian invasion of Ukraine (2014) User:Iryna 23:29, 2 September 2014 (UTC) delete or '''merge''' with 2014 Russian military intervention in Ukraine as blatant . No amount of shuffling around the content has concealed that fact Deletion of Russian invasion of Ukraine (2014) WP:POVFORK Wikipedia:Content forking 33
22495 21573 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Terry Dowdall User:Bkissin 20:48, 17 June 2019 (UTC) delete Non-notable mayor and future federal candidate do not meet . Use of Wikipedia as free election advertising would violate Deletion of Terry Dowdall WP:NPOL||WP:PROMO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22496 11323 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Don Wilson (footballer) User:Mattythewhite 11:39, 1 July 2015 (UTC) keep Subject played in the fully professional Football League and therefore pases Deletion of Don Wilson (footballer) WP:NFOOTY Wikipedia:Notability 77
22497 11642 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carry On (band) User:TedFrank 02:51, 18 May 2007 (UTC) delete Not notable by any stretch of the imagination. Only source is the band's website, and that flunks : a band doesn't create notability for itself by putting up a website Deletion of Carry On (band) WP:RS Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22498 12528 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avalara User:HighKing 13:40, 20 May 2018 (UTC) delete """Thinly veiled advert. For example, second line says """"Avalara helps businesses get tax compliance right."""" This is not balanced nor encyclopedic. The business tagline is """"Tax Compliance done right"""". Also none of the references meet the criteria for establishing notability. Fails and """ Deletion of Avalara WP:SPIP||WP:NCORP Wikipedia:Notability 77
22499 5370 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ben Cormack (2nd nomination) User:Alexandermcnabb 10:19, 1 June 2021 (UTC) delete No sources presented in article, none immediately found online. Fails . Best Deletion of Ben Cormack (2nd nomination) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22500 13923 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Javelin (agency) User:Edwardx 16:43, 23 February 2018 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Javelin (agency) WP:ORGIND||WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
22501 11597 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Identity control theory User:Location 11:19, 10 August 2009 (UTC) comment """for the time being, but I'm wondering what influence PAPER has here. Policy regarding scientific journals and research papers states: """"A Wikipedia article should not be presented on the assumption that the reader is well versed in the topic's field. Introductory language in the lead and initial sections of the article should be written in plain terms and concepts that can be understood by any literate reader of Wikipedia without any knowledge in the given field before advancing to more detailed explanations of the topic."""" It would be nice if the article started """"Identity control theory is..."""" because I cannot figure it out. Do any of the above references explicitly state what it is""" Deletion of Identity control theory WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22502 4048 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tanjib Ahsan Saad User:A 04:30, 4 May 2021 (UTC) delete Fails , and . Player has appeared in ICC Trophy but not in final. There are some passing mentions but not enough for him to pass GNG. The articles needs more reliable sources in significant coverage to pass GNG. &mdash Deletion of Tanjib Ahsan Saad WP:CRIN||WP:GNG||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
22503 7574 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Indonesian expatriate footballers User:Kosm1fent 10:08, 22 September 2011 (UTC) delete screams |original research by miles Deletion of List of Indonesian expatriate footballers WP:OR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22504 39 Vikipedi:Silinmeye aday sayfalar/Hafsanur Sancaktutan Kullanıcı:ravagesravages 19.47, 14 Mart 2020 (UTC) delete Kayda değer olduğunu gösterir tarafsız, bağımsız ve güvenilir kaynaklar bulunmuyor. Bununla birlikte kriterlerini de karşılamıyor Hafsanur Sancaktutan'ın silinmesi Vikipedi:KİŞİ Wikipedia:Notability 77
22505 9476 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Eco-brick User:Esquivalience 14:46, 15 March 2015 (UTC) keep """Because the """"spam"""" in the article can be removed through normal editing, """"spammy"""" is not a valid deletion rationale (see § c1). The subject meets (significant coverage), so it is notable""" Deletion of Eco-brick WP:BEFORE||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
22506 18350 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011–12 FK Željezničar season User:HawkAussie 18:34, 23 June 2019 (UTC) comment There are claims in the some of the delete comments that isn't met. However this is not true. This also came up in the previous 2014 AFD. NSEASONS says ''Articles can be created on individual seasons of teams in top professional leagues''. And these articles are (I think) all for the top level professional soccer - Premier League of Bosnia and Herzegovina. The claim in the nomination statement by Deletion of 2011–12 FK Željezničar season WP:NSEASONS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22507 2695 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Viswasara Tantra User:Jbhunley 21:01, 19 February 2018 (UTC) delete No evidence this passes or . See my comment above for my reasoning and concern Deletion of Viswasara Tantra WP:GNG||WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
22508 85 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christopher Irons User:MER 13:17, 14 November 2006 (UTC) delete fails , http://www.google.com/search?q=%22Christopher+Irons%22+-wikipedia&hl=en&lr=&start=0&sa=N check ghits Deletion of Christopher Irons WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22509 17275 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Do You Know (Jessica Simpson album) User:Eric444 05:36, 26 June 2008 (UTC) delete No sources; Deletion of Do You Know (Jessica Simpson album) WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22510 21383 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jrocknyc User:Savidan 05:54, 4 March 2006 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Jrocknyc WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22511 507 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Winchester bus route 5 User:LibStar 06:28, 9 June 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Winchester bus route 5 WP:NOTGUIDE Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22512 185 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/E.B. Hughes (2nd nomination) User:Erik 18:52, 20 July 2008 (UTC) delete per #G4; tagged accordingly Deletion of E.B. Hughes (2nd nomination) WP:SD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
22513 21298 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Thongkholal Haokip User:David 06:23, 3 November 2013 (UTC) delete for lack of evidence of passing . Most humanities academics publish at least one book so unless it has attracted an unusual level of attention that wouldn't be enough Deletion of Thongkholal Haokip WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22514 2033 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muhammad Yahya Waliullah User:Visviva 08:59, 7 December 2006 (UTC) delete per nom; does not appear to meet Deletion of Muhammad Yahya Waliullah WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22515 20829 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lincoln (film) User:Steve 13:49, 6 March 2008 (UTC) delete I was bordering on suggesting putting the redirect back in, but with production so far off, it's probably better to delete it now under . If there's no content to go back to in the history (even that one stubby paragraph), it ''might'' help to dissuade editors from recreating it at the drop of a hat Deletion of Lincoln (film) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22516 8967 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Electric Brain (2nd nomination) User:David 17:47, 31 July 2019 (UTC) delete """I don't agree the sourcing provided meets . To discuss the sources brought up above, the ''Nintendo Life'' article is talking about ''Super Play'', so the subject in question is ''Super Play'', not ''Electric Brain''; the article does not appear to mention Electric Brain at all, if I'm not mistaken. The claim {{xt|Electric Brain was the final name for the multi-platform magazine, and with it came a publisher and high street distribution}} is cited to the https://portal.issn.org/resource/ISSN/0968-8471 ISSN portal, which does not support the assertion made. I find the reference to ''Electric Brain'' in ''Super Play'' #23 pretty minor (it's mostly talking about Onn Lee and the new magazine). Weak references to assert its notability includes http://www.smspower.org/Scans/STheSegaMagazine-Magazine-Issue09?gallerypage=23 random """"wanted"""" ads from a user-submitted part of other magazines. is an essay and has no power to invoke here, and even then there's been no substantial demonstration of its legacy such an evidence-based keep would require. It's great all these people keep turning up to talk about how important it was, but at present the article doesn't |prove it""" Deletion of Electric Brain (2nd nomination) WP:SIGCOV||WP:DEFUNCTNEWS||WP:V Wikipedia:Notability 77
22517 10675 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Modern Gnosticism User:Barno 20:57, 20 April 2006 (UTC) delete per nomination, per RGTraynor, and per . I see nothing approaching a fact here, and I read the whole thing (ouch Deletion of Modern Gnosticism WP:BALLS Wikipedia:Complete bollocks 42
22518 18188 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trailer Trash (movie) User:Tanthalas39 22:31, 30 December 2007 (UTC) delete Clear deviation of . Merge with larger related article or toss altogether Deletion of Trailer Trash (movie) WP:NFF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22519 21825 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Why students may study abroad User:Hut 06:33, 29 April 2008 (UTC) delete violates Deletion of Why students may study abroad WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22520 16626 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fight Club in popular culture User:Krimpet 04:49, 4 February 2007 (UTC) delete per nom, #IINFO list of passing mentions of cliched lines from the movie Deletion of Fight Club in popular culture WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22521 20441 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Idaho PTV Kids Programming (Sundays) [[User talk:Becky Sayles|''' B E C K Y S A Y L E S ''']] 05:26, 23 January 2015 (UTC) delete No references to support notability. Also, Deletion of Idaho PTV Kids Programming (Sundays) WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22522 13758 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Paul Street (journalist) User:Wikimandia 03:57, 7 June 2015 (UTC) delete per nom; I don't see how he meets or Deletion of Paul Street (journalist) WP:AUTHOR||WP:JOURNALIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
22523 12591 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick O'Shea User:Ukexpat 01:58, 26 September 2010 (UTC) delete Obviously fails and a self indulgent spamfest to boot Deletion of Patrick O'Shea WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22524 17127 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Berik Ismail User:Kirbanzo 14:18, 8 May 2018 (UTC) delete fails GNG at this time, seems to be a case of Deletion of Berik Ismail WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Too soon 40
22525 17499 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Avaya Enterprise Switch Manager NONE NONE delete """and '''|Salt''' any new article starting with """"Avaya"""". Note""" Deletion of Avaya Enterprise Switch Manager WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
22526 13993 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/SkyscraperCity (5th nomination) User:Superastig 07:30, 21 July 2020 (UTC) keep Per reasons above. By this time, the article is good enough to pass Deletion of SkyscraperCity (5th nomination) WP:NWEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22527 19271 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jamie Steele User:Adolphus79 17:36, 13 December 2008 (UTC) delete Fails & ... The creating editor's username is {{User|JamieSteele}}, and creating this article is his/her/its one and only edit Deletion of Jamie Steele WP:MUSIC||WP:AUTO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22528 1592 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saniyya Sidney User:Balablitz 13:39, 16 December 2016 (UTC) keep Satisfies Deletion of Saniyya Sidney WP:NACTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
22529 17187 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joe Dispenza User:MelanieN 00:57, 2 August 2010 (UTC) comment """Further support for my """"delete"""" vote above: he has no presence at Google Scholar except his one book; he is """"not found"""" at PubMed; he is """"not found"""" at ChiroWeb or the major chiropractic journals. It appears he has never published anything in any peer-reviewed forum. So his claim to be some kind of scientist is unsupported. That leaves which he fails""" Deletion of Joe Dispenza WP:AUTHOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
22530 16342 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Í Mynd User:Nenyedi 23:16, 16 August 2007 (UTC) delete as per nom, and , , and Deletion of Í Mynd WP:MUSIC||WP:RS||WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22531 10943 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carlos canteri User:WWGB 07:17, 4 April 2010 (UTC) delete Fails , contested prod. Unable to find reliable, independent secondary sources to establish notability. Appears to be written by the subject of the article Deletion of Carlos canteri WP:MUSICBIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22532 14797 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/I'm Different (NC.A song) User:TerryAlex 05:55, 4 January 2015 (UTC) delete According to , song charting alone is no longer considered to be notable. There is no other notable information Deletion of I'm Different (NC.A song) WP:NSONGS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22533 8415 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of cooperatives User:Snottywong 17:52, 23 October 2010 (UTC) delete per , criterion #4. Were this list ever completed (assuming it is completable), it would be gargantuan and unmaintainable. The list is 100% redundant with :Category:Cooperatives by country, therefore no new information is introduced in this article, and it doesn't make Wikipedia easier to navigate Deletion of List of cooperatives WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22534 11817 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/TE Rijeka User:GregorB 22:15, 25 August 2013 (UTC) comment """Appears to be a major power station. Still, when considering the criteria, the article is on the thin side to say the least. Even the primary source (hep.hr, which does not count towards ) is fairly terse (i.e. arguably is not really """"significant coverage""" Deletion of TE Rijeka WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22535 3207 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mohammad Mahtab Alam User:TheAafi 14:45, 19 July 2021 (UTC) delete I cleaned up the article and there's nothing that helps in establishing notability, if we try for , because it fails GNG at the first instance. Weird advert piece Deletion of Mohammad Mahtab Alam WP:NPOL Wikipedia:Notability 77
22536 7855 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jesus (archangel) User:Smeat75 17:18, 6 May 2017 (UTC) delete """per , one might really say """"lunatic fringe"""", it is sourced to Richard Carrier, who does not hold an academic position, has zero academic credibility and is almost solely known for pushing the extreme fringe idea that Jesus never existed""" Deletion of Jesus (archangel) WP:NFRINGE Wikipedia:Fringe theories 113
22537 13076 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Muntadar al-Zaidi User:Jmundo 19:55, 15 December 2008 (UTC) keep This person doesn't fail . Sources are provided for his 2007 kidnapping incident Deletion of Muntadar al-Zaidi WP:BLP1E Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons 3
22538 16394 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of operas performed by the Santa Fe Opera User:Bearian 03:08, 24 October 2007 (UTC) delete as violating every precept of . Useless. Notable opera company/stage, certainly, but that is not inherited Deletion of List of operas performed by the Santa Fe Opera WP:LIST Wikipedia:Lists 97
22539 14290 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dark Riders (comics) User:Zxcvbnm 13:01, 3 September 2019 (UTC) delete no reason given for the Deprod, contrary to Wikipedia guidelines. There are no secondary sources and the article fails as complete fancruft Deletion of Dark Riders (comics) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22540 12073 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Richardson (Continental Army officer) User:Joe 05:01, 18 June 2010 (UTC) keep and rename as per Gwinva, particularly noting Deletion of William Richardson (Continental Army officer) WP:POLITICIAN Wikipedia:Notability 77
22541 11555 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A-1 Auto Transport User:Ihcoyc 15:13, 12 October 2011 (UTC) delete per nomination. Article is about a |trucking company that delivers cars. No evidence of |significant effects on history, technology, or culture Deletion of A-1 Auto Transport WP:B2B||WP:ORGIN Wikipedia:Notability 77
22542 10729 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Betty Kelen User:Striver 14:11, 12 March 2006 (UTC) keep She fullfils easly, having an audience of over 5000 Deletion of Betty Kelen WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22543 3795 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alice Sakitnak Akammak User:Beccaynr 04:22, 8 March 2021 (UTC) keep per 4(d Deletion of Alice Sakitnak Akammak WP:ARTIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
22544 19428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nora Young User:Alex 07:14, 6 July 2021 (UTC) keep Meets as the host of a notable program Deletion of Nora Young WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22545 1281 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gunwitch User:Dissolva 06:36, 20 March 2008 (UTC) comment Deletion discussions are not a vote, but a discussion to establish |concensus if an article deserves inclusion in Wikipedia. Mentions on web sites and unpublished claims of influence do not establish |notability or meet the need for reliable sources for a #Sources|biography of a living person Deletion of Gunwitch WP:CONCENSUS||WP:N||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Consensus 78
22546 17684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JMathLib User:Paloma 18:56, 6 April 2007 (UTC) delete per nom fails otability Deletion of JMathLib WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22547 5331 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mochila Inc. User:AllyD 12:31, 2 July 2018 (UTC) delete I can see a couple of brief items relating to the company's partnership with Belo in 2007 (https://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-169100774.html {{Highbeam}}) and being commissioned to develop an Emmy archive website (https://www.mediapost.com/publications/article/108813/and-the-emmys-go-to-mochila.html), but nothing that rises about routine announcements. Fails Deletion of Mochila Inc. :WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
22548 1024 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Toronto-Montreal rivalry (2nd nomination) User:Dawn 19:36, 21 May 2011 (UTC) delete This is more of a comparison between a few aspects of these cities than a description of inter-city rivalry. There is a notable professional hockey rivalry that is already addressed here: Maple Leafs – Canadiens rivalry, but the rest of it is , and it's synthesis of information that doesn't even add up to prove that there is a notable Montreal-Toronto rivalry Deletion of Toronto-Montreal rivalry (2nd nomination) WP:SYNTHESIS Wikipedia:No original research 65
22549 12163 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Drachentaube User:Pmanderson 16:34, 7 June 2007 (UTC) delete The College of Arms blazoned it, according to Dr. Clackson himself, as http://www.dragonlore.co.uk/magazines/issue53.pdf A dove argent beaked azure with a Dragon's wings displayed and a Dragon's legs and a Dragon's tail. The beast is an invention from the grantee's own Fake Middle English poetry. http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=drachentaube The Google results show that the word shows up in Wikipedia, and in two contributions by the grantee. The Scottish Heraldry Society seems to have taken down http://72.14.209.104/search?q=cache:O4XXtj4RA_gJ:heraldry-scotland.com/copgal/displayimage.php%3Falbum%3D7%26pos%3D135+drachentaube+-wikipedia&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=4&gl=us their page. Deletion of Drachentaube WP:NEOLOGISM Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
22550 2343 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fuukit User:Stuartyeates 07:40, 8 July 2012 (UTC) delete as lacking indepth coverage in independent third party sources, as required by Deletion of Fuukit WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22551 3317 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Hillmann User:Ivanvector 02:16, 21 November 2016 (UTC) keep """sources indicate the subject clearly meets , and we don't seem to have a more specific notability guideline for bullfighters. Whether his 300-or-so bullfights constitute a single event or not, his career has received |significant coverage in reliable sources, and that's good enough. Yes, some of the sources are less reliable than others, but that's not enough to question their validity here. Furthermore this should be closed per : {{ul|Piotrus}} called it """"borderline"""" (which I ''don't'' interpret as an argument to delete) and nominator {{ul|SwisterTwister}} said """"confident keep"""" above although I'm not entirely sure how to interpret that comment, but that leaves nobody calling for deletion here""" Deletion of Bill Hillmann WP:GNG||WP:SIGCOV||WP:SNOW Wikipedia:Notability 77
22552 6984 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Not Possible IRL User:Stifle 19:59, 13 May 2008 (UTC) delete Because the article does not include |citations from |reliable sources, it does not appear to be in compliance with the |verifiability policy Deletion of Not Possible IRL WP:CITE||WP:RS||WP:V Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22553 174 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ektron (3rd nomination) User:Ihcoyc 21:42, 13 February 2010 (UTC) delete """and '''salt'''. Gartner is an investment research business. Their editors are the customers who hire them to prepare reports. Being included in their """"magic quadrants"""" is insufficient for notability, that's just their version of a directory or """"top 100"""" style listing. This has been deleted several times before, and should have been |protected against re-creation. Book mentions all look trivial and incidental to me. The bottom line is that this is just another behind the scenes tech business that the general public does not interact with directly. A very persistent spammer""" Deletion of Ektron (3rd nomination) WP:SALT Wikipedia:Protection policy 61
22554 2913 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kaif Raza Khan Qadri User:Samee 14:50, 27 February 2018 (UTC) delete non-notable. Notability isn't |inherited, there is only one sentence about the subject, others are about his great-grandfather and uncle Deletion of Kaif Raza Khan Qadri WP:INHERITED Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18
22555 9962 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Newage Tactics User:Quarl NONE delete as |non-notable software. &mdash Deletion of Newage Tactics WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22556 21915 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Christian Engström User:Kubigula 02:15, 19 February 2007 (UTC) delete There are no independant articles regarding the subject cited in the article and I couldn't find any either. He does not appear to meet Deletion of Christian Engström WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22557 2856 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Apurva Chamaria User:Bearian 14:51, 12 August 2016 (UTC) delete per , , , and . The subject lacks |significant coverage in multiple sources, which is |required of all BLPs. All business VPs post on LinkedIn and try to get published in an ''economist''-type magazine, especially marketing mavens like the subject. We are not a place to post this person's resume, which is more of what this is than a real article. He's up-and-coming like lots of people in business; when he actually makes it big, we can re-create an article for him Deletion of Apurva Chamaria WP:GNG||WP:MILL||WP:NOTRESUME||WP:UPANDCOMING||WP:SIGCOV||WP:BLP Wikipedia:Notability 77
22558 8142 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The X Factor (Kazakhstan) User:Mh29255 05:03, 17 December 2007 (UTC) delete practically no content, completely non-notable and doesn't meet Deletion of The X Factor (Kazakhstan) WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
22559 15904 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cássio Ferreira User:Sir 12:42, 22 January 2013 (UTC) delete He has not received significant coverage or played in a fully pro league, meaning the article fails and Deletion of Cássio Ferreira WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT Wikipedia:Notability 77
22560 11867 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adam Fein User:Terence 10:10, 9 August 2006 (UTC) delete vanity, fails Deletion of Adam Fein WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22561 8802 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/John Donald Barton User:Bearcat 16:58, 12 May 2016 (UTC) delete """Neither the substance nor the sourcing here provides a reason why he warrants permanent coverage in an international encyclopedia. A broadcaster generally has to work for ''national'', rather than local, media before the mere fact that they worked as a broadcaster can confer an automatic presumption of notability — absent that, it's """"pass or bust"""", and a person does ''not'' get exempted from that just because they moved around to several different local media markets over the course of their career. But the closest thing to a |reliable source here is a community weekly newspaper blurbing his opinion on the death of Phyllis Diller, which is not the kind of coverage it takes — ''all'' of the other sourcing is to invalid sources like IMDb, |Blogspot blogs, a local radio history directory with thumbnail profiles of ''everybody'' who ''ever'' worked for ''any'' of that city's radio and television outlets ''at all'' (thus failing to ''distinguish'' him as ''more'' notable than the norm), and a glancing namecheck of his existence in a summary of the history of a television station he worked for (which is coverage of the ''television station'', not of ''him''.) I ran a ProQuest Canadian Newsstand Major Dailies search, and found ''no'' coverage of him with which this could be repaired. In addition, the creator's username suggests the possibility of by a direct relative of his. I'm having extreme trouble, in fact, figuring out how this ever got approved at , where the sources are normally evaluated much more carefully than this""" Deletion of John Donald Barton WP:GNG||WP:RS||WP:BLOGS||WP:COI||WP:AFC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22562 6938 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/EditPad User:Vacuum 08:26, 17 May 2007 (UTC) comment on '''my sock puppetry''') I hope I am not going to be lynched as far as I do not violate any . Is it not allowed to do so when you have a real reason to believe that you will be ''hated by some'' and ''pursused thereafter'' for what you are trying to do? And again, I fail to recognize what good would it bring to my own account Deletion of EditPad WP:SOCK Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry 52
22563 18239 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JQuarks User:Spinningspark 12:48, 6 November 2018 (UTC) delete which should have been done when it was first created. In my opinion, still applies to a recreation that contains no meaningful independent references when the previous article was deleted for failing notability, even if the text isn't precisely the same. The page as created was also eligible for speedy as a copyvio, so at the very least, the history needs revdeleting Deletion of JQuarks WP:G4||WP:G12 Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
22564 48 [[Aliens (Rollenspiel)]], nach [[Leading Edge Games]] verschoben Benutzer:ElRaki NONE keep Es wurde schon am /17._Dezember_2004#Aliens (Rollenspiel) (erweitert, bleibt)|17. Dezember zum Löschen vorgeschlagen und ist geblieben. Der Grund, zu löschen, weil das Spiel eingestellt wurde, finde ich unpassen, auch über nicht aktuelle kann man Artikel schreiben. Bin wie damals, auch heute für Löschung von Aliens (Leading Edge Games Wikipedia:Löschkandidaten Wikipedia:Articles for deletion 102
22565 20361 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/87.9 Pride FM User:Neutralhomer 14:03, 3 February 2016 (UTC) delete Part 15 stations, which this one is, do not enjoy the same notability under , as full power AM/FM/HD stations do Deletion of 87.9 Pride FM WP:NMEDIA Wikipedia:Notability 77
22566 291 [[Frank Leicht]] (LAZ) Benutzer:Wo st 01/Bewertung 17:02, 14. Sep. 2010 (CEST) delete Als Trainer #P{{!}}zweifelsfrei relevanzfrei Löschung von Frank Leicht Wikipedia:RK Wikipedia:Notability 77
22567 13456 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harry Braun, Democratic Presidential Candidate, 2016 NONE NONE keep for the Harry Braun BLP-article, but '''Redirect''' Harry Braun, Democratic Presidential Candidate, 2016 to Harry_Braun#Political_campaigns (1984/1986 in AZ CD#1 versus McCain, and 2004/2012/2016 for president). Also, create the wiki-traditional Harry Braun presidential campaign, 2004 + Harry Braun presidential campaign, 2012 + Harry Braun presidential campaign, 2016 redirects, pointing to the same location of Harry_Braun#Political_campaigns. Braun's 2012 campaign satisfies , with articles in specifically about his presidential campaign efforts. Braun's 2004 potus campaign was also covered, once by C-SPAN, and also got ~10 sentences of reasonably-detailed listicle-depth in WaPo, which again is for inclusion into the most-appropriate article, in this case Harry Braun the BLP article Deletion of Harry Braun, Democratic Presidential Candidate, 2016 WP:NOTEWORTHY||WP:SOURCES||WP:NOTEWORTHY Wikipedia:Notability 77
22568 8776 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ill Mitch User:Motor 10:08, 7 June 2006 (UTC) delete """another """"internet phenomenon"""" with a few blog mentions. Fails , and """ Deletion of Ill Mitch WP:BIO||WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22569 5336 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/William Andrew Dunckelman User:Robert 00:20, 13 July 2010 (UTC) keep The guy does seem to get around, and for somebody his age he certainly has made an impact in his community. Apparently he was even quoted extensively in a newspaper article about a recycling program in Louisiana (http://www.houmatoday.com/article/20090724/ARTICLES/907241004). For me this one is right on the line in terms of notability, where what he has accomplished certainly makes his contributions stand out in a crowd, but it is still rather modest. I don't know what to think about him showing up in the news for several issues above and beyond the initial claim to fame. Unfortunately, the real reason I'd like to keep this article isn't really valid as it is sort of a |crystal ball hope that this guy might make something more of his life and become notable in the future. He does meet the very hard nosed technical qualifications for notability (sort of stretching the imagination a bit), but is that enough Deletion of William Andrew Dunckelman WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22570 19283 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Learned pigs & fireproof women User:Andy 00:51, 1 October 2010 (UTC) keep 15 minutes'' before it was nom'ed? On a new editor's very first edits? How Y can we get! How about doing something ''positive'' to improve the article, rather than trying to stomp new editors Deletion of Learned pigs & fireproof women WP:BITE Wikipedia:Please do not bite the newcomers 92
22571 5553 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Walmart greeter User:Notecardforfree 23:05, 27 May 2016 (UTC) merge """to greeting per . If someone feels ambitious enough to create an article about greeters, go right ahead, but until then we should make a sub-section at greeting about professional """"greeters""" Deletion of Walmart greeter WP:PAGEDECIDE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22572 21182 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Coinfloor User:Jtbobwaysf 20:25, 1 August 2020 (UTC) keep Wired, Sunday Times, and Techcrunch all did indepth articles on this. Easily passes |coredepth, even though nothing seems to have happened on the article recently. Thanks Deletion of Coinfloor WP:CORPDEPTH Wikipedia:Notability 77
22573 7851 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sad Sam & Honey User:Ifnord 18:57, 28 September 2017 (UTC) delete for failing Deletion of Sad Sam & Honey WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22574 8220 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Trump orb (2nd nomination) User:Bearcat 15:11, 9 September 2017 (UTC) delete """LM2000 is right that at the depth of media coverage that Trump generates, we could eventually end up having to keep an article about every single object he so much as touches if the only standard we applied is """"did it get a blip of press coverage at the time"""". To actually warrant an article, however, this would need to pass the |ten-year test for enduring ''significance'', which I'm not seeing any evidence that it does. LM2000 is also correct that a small amount of content about this at the article on the Riyadh ''summit'' would be acceptable, but it doesn't need its own standalone article""" Deletion of Trump orb (2nd nomination) WP:10YT Wikipedia:Recentism 10
22575 6245 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Donald Isler User:Jeepday 17:41, 10 May 2021 (UTC) delete There are no claims in the article that make the subject likely to meet The references on the article do not clearly meet , my search for references found several promotion and/or trivial mentions. I do not see any evidence that the subject is Notable per English Wikipedia criteria Deletion of Donald Isler WP:MUSICBIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22576 6428 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Johannes Brahms in film and popular culture User:TenPoundHammer 12:47, 26 July 2007 (UTC) delete per {{fact}} as a #TRIVIA|trivial #DIR|list of... well... trivia Deletion of Johannes Brahms in film and popular culture WP:NOT||WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22577 2823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of entertainers by nickname User:Bearian 18:26, 6 August 2007 (UTC) keep per above, but remove the nicknames of couples. |This is not a gossip rag Deletion of List of entertainers by nickname WP:NOT Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22578 12570 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Uruguay–Philippines relations User:Biruitorul 18:13, 17 May 2012 (UTC) delete """we need actual sources describing relations between Uruguay and the Philippines, not a Wikipedia editor giving us his |point of view that because the two countries happen to be part of the same club, and because they were both controlled by the same colonial power, their relations are therefore notable. Unsurprisingly for two countries that are not global powers and are 11,000 miles apart, such sources are nowhere to be found. And as LibStar has noted, neither a newspaper article noting a national holiday nor an official record of a meeting between two foreign ministers come anywhere near establishing the notability of this """"topic"""" that no one had heard of until someone had the bright idea of inventing it yesterday""" Deletion of Uruguay–Philippines relations WP:POV Wikipedia:Neutral point of view 64
22579 19964 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Viscape User:davidwr 01:56, 9 December 2008 (UTC) delete """Other than """"routine"""" publications which one would expect of any business of this type, the site '''only seems to be known in connection with upcoming United States Presidential Inauguration.''' Topics which are known only in connection with one event are generally not considered notable in their own right. It ''nominally'' passes Wikipedia:Notability (web) criteria #1 but as I said, it's all in connection with the inauguration or is routine for a business of this type. This is more of an argument to refine Wikipedia:Notability (web) than it is to accept this article ''at this time''. When the company clearly meets criteria #1 in a non-routine way, or clearly meets criteria 2 or 3 or any of the |general notability criteria or Wikipedia:Notability (organizations and companies) criteria then it will be time for an article""" Deletion of Viscape WP:N Wikipedia:Notability 77
22580 16926 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Patrick Lane (footballer) User:Mattythewhite 23:48, 23 February 2012 (UTC) delete Fails and Deletion of Patrick Lane (footballer) WP:GNG||WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
22581 9303 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Milton William Cooper User:RadioFan 03:09, 5 January 2012 (UTC) keep There appears to be sufficient coverage outside of primary sources already in the article to meet . All sections refernced by this author's self published books does need to be removed and the article generally cleaned up though Deletion of Milton William Cooper WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22582 20391 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Illumina Methylation Assay User:Bfigura 04:25, 10 October 2009 (UTC) delete as advertising. All this does is describe the methodology (and usage) of a methylation assay produced by Illumina. There's nothing here to suggest that their product is any more notable than their competitors. It might also fall under , but I'd have to wait for a colleague in Molecular Biology to tell me how generalizable this procedure would be Deletion of Illumina Methylation Assay WP:NOTHOWTO Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22583 2301 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lloyd R. Woodson User:Contains 08:48, 2 February 2010 (UTC) keep """this is a topic of ongoing public interest. Woodson may be notable only for one event, but in the absence of any obvious target for a move or redirect, I think it's appropriate that his name should be the article title. This clearly goes way beyond an ordinary """"guy gets arrested for unlicensed gun collection"""" news story. Wikipedia is |not news but we do have many articles on notable events which have been reported in the news, and rightly so; and significantly, we also have a |neutral point of view policy which is enforced usually quite effectively through collective editing. Maintaining this article on a notable subject serves the public interest""" Deletion of Lloyd R. Woodson WP:NOTNEWS||WP:NPOV Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22584 17272 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tsuyoshi Shimamura User:Lankiveil 09:12, 23 August 2009 (UTC) delete unsourced BLP, seems to fail Deletion of Tsuyoshi Shimamura WP:ATHLETE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22585 3551 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shaping Your Child's Sexual Identity User:Softlavender 20:22, 10 May 2015 (UTC) delete Does not assert any notability and does not pass Deletion of Shaping Your Child's Sexual Identity WP:NBOOK Wikipedia:Notability 77
22586 12911 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Calvin C. Girvin User:PCock 20:01, 1 January 2009 (UTC) delete Does not appear to meet criteria at Deletion of Calvin C. Girvin WP:BIO Wikipedia:Notability 77
22587 11082 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Joy Duru User:Number 10:27, 27 November 2020 (UTC) delete per failure. Happy to restore the article if she makes an appearance for the senior national team Deletion of Joy Duru WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
22588 110 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Troll Country User:Piotrus 01:19, 30 September 2019 (UTC) delete Fails Deletion of Troll Country WP:NFICTION Wikipedia:Notability 77
22589 21703 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Pardon of Joe Arpaio (2nd nomination) User:Galobtter 02:39, 14 November 2017 (UTC) keep """obviously) Like I was saying in the link above, there's a lot of legal analyses, criticisms by senators and scholars, how """"issuing this pardon would be an impeachable offence"""" that is pretty irrelevant and undue for the Joe Arpaio article. Essentially most of the reaction section is way too much for an article on Joe Arpaio. But the pardon is still important, and still received a lot of coverage. So this is a simple """ Deletion of Pardon of Joe Arpaio (2nd nomination) WP:SPINOFF Wikipedia:Content forking 33
22590 21700 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Anthony Ryder User:WikiDan61 16:43, 15 October 2014 (UTC) delete """per #A7. There is nothing significant about achieving """"high distinction"""" in these national quizzes""" Deletion of James Anthony Ryder WP:CSD Wikipedia:Criteria for speedy deletion 104
22591 11631 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/True Christianity User:Tarinth 14:50, 7 January 2007 (UTC) delete per Deletion of True Christianity WP:NOR Wikipedia:No original research 65
22592 15056 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jan-Dirk Nijkamp User:Smartyllama 19:55, 16 December 2019 (UTC) keep Passes having competed in the 1992 Olympics, and also has at least some online sources and probably many more offline Deletion of Jan-Dirk Nijkamp WP:NOLYMPICS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22593 15100 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Amir Yusuf Pohan User:HawkAussie 02:45, 8 June 2019 (UTC) keep If it was in its original state, I would say delete but after the IP is gone, I do think that this passes Deletion of Amir Yusuf Pohan WP:NFOOTBALL Wikipedia:Notability 77
22594 4953 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Syed Ali Naqvi User:Paolo 17:10, 10 January 2006 (UTC) delete """As an example, I have tried a Google search for this persons' name + """"The Role of the Ombudsman and the concept of Administrative Justice""""; this search returns only the author's page in geocities (other than the wikipedia article) http://www.google.com/search?hl=it&q=%22Syed+Ali+Naqvi%22+%22The+Role+of+the+Ombudsman+and+the+concept+of+Administrative+Justice%22&btnG=Cerca&meta= and only got the wikipedia page and the author's page. If this were an """"eminent historian"""" he would have at least be cited somewhere. Anyway, is clear: """"Any edit lacking a source may be removed"""" (in this case, the whole article lacks sources); the new proposal says """"The obligation to provide a reputable source is on editors wishing to include information, not on those seeking to remove it""" Deletion of Syed Ali Naqvi WP:V Wikipedia:Verifiability 49
22595 9485 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Saiju Sreedharan User:SamHolt6 06:05, 27 July 2018 (UTC) delete fails and Deletion of Saiju Sreedharan WP:SIGCOV||WP:DIRECTOR Wikipedia:Notability 77
22596 1260 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Transracial identity User:Skyerise 01:23, 17 June 2015 (UTC) delete per and Deletion of Transracial identity WP:NEOLOGISM||WP:TOOSOON Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
22597 18684 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/VF2281 User:Wcquidditch 20:49, 23 August 2016 (UTC) delete WP:BROADCAST|the presumption of notability for broadcast stations doesn't necessarily extend to VF stations, and I'm not finding much in the way of |reliable sources to satisfy the |general notability guideline. (Plus, with so little out there in general about this station, it is unlikely to be anything more than a |permastub anyway Deletion of VF2281 WP:RS||WP:GNG||WP:PERMASTUB Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22598 20859 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hollow volcano base User:Carlosguitar 01:27, 28 August 2007 (UTC) delete WP:N|non-notable, |neologism, |unattributed and Deletion of Hollow volcano base WP:NEO||WP:ATT||WP:MADEUP Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary 28
22599 9969 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Keith Bodie User:Bagumba 02:23, 29 November 2011 (UTC) delete Fails with no significant coverage in multiple, independent, reliable sources Deletion of Keith Bodie WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22600 15612 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Quynh Nguyen (2nd nomination) User:CaliforniaAliBaba 06:31, 20 August 2010 (UTC) keep """WP:BIO standards have risen somewhat since the original nomination in 2007, but the article is adequately sourced to newspapers featuring coverage of her which is """"more than a trivial mention"""" even if not """"the main topic of the source material"""" (; in fact, she is the main topic of http://web.archive.org/web/20080609215228/http://nguoivienxu.vietnamnet.vn/vanngheviet/hoatdongvhnt/2006/09/612630/), and I find the nominator's """"this will open the floodgates to millions of articles""""/ style of argumentation unconvincing""" Deletion of Quynh Nguyen (2nd nomination) WP:N||WP:OTHERCRAPDOESNTEXIST Wikipedia:Notability 77
22601 15061 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Parker Pyne User:TTN 20:40, 23 October 2020 (UTC) delete Topic fails to establish notability per . Even should there be some older print-only sources discussing the character, I find it doubtful that it would need coverage outside of the context of the main article Deletion of Parker Pyne WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22602 5123 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bacolod Evangelical Church User:TimothyBlue 19:45, 2 August 2020 (UTC) delete WP:BEFORE shows only coverage, does not meet ''addresses the topic directly and in detail''. // Deletion of Bacolod Evangelical Church WP:ROUTINE Wikipedia:Notability 77
22603 1763 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruby Zoo User:B 10:09, 18 June 2007 (UTC) delete By , international tours only establish notability if they are reported in |reliable sources. None are given however. Albums seem to be self-released, at least I could not find any information to the contrary Deletion of Ruby Zoo WP:MUSIC||WP:RS Wikipedia:Notability 77
22604 10726 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Kaminski (computer scientist) [[User talk:Stringy Acid|talk]]) 16:04, 10 April 2017 (UTC) delete as the article doesn't pass (unfortunately). H-index Deletion of Michael Kaminski (computer scientist) WP:PROF Wikipedia:Notability 77
22605 5355 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hardy Bucks [[User talk:Rannpháirtí anaithnid|coṁrá]]) 02:10, 24 July 2009 (UTC) keep """Not hugely notable but sources """"|address the subject directly in detail, and no original research is needed to extract the content"""" (e.g. http://www.mayonews.ie/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=6931&Itemid=135 local newspaper 1, http://www.westernpeople.com/news/story/?trs=eycwgbkfql&cat=entertainment local newspaper 2, http://www.iftn.ie/?act1=record&only=1&aid=73&rid=4281916&tpl=archnews reliable website, http://www.rte.ie/arts/2009/0323/storyland.html RTÉ, etc.) As well as that, as noted on the talk page, it gets http://stats.grok.se/en/200906/Hardy%20Bucks quite a respectable number of hits per day. |Sources are an issue, and should be dealt with separately. But, as far notability, it reaches the target, albeit just barely. --rannṗáirtí anaiṫnid""" Deletion of Hardy Bucks WP:NOTABLE||WP:SOURCES Wikipedia:Notability 77
22606 19973 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mister Dave's User:Mayalld 16:13, 17 July 2008 (UTC) comment Who is to say what is notable... '' Well, Wikipedia is. We have policies defining notability, which you should read (try ), and also policies defining |verifiability and |reliable sources. If we didn't have such policies, then we would end up with articles on next-door-but-one's-ginger-tom etc. We also have a |civility policy, which requires editors to be civil to each other. Your tone in this discussion has tended towards the sarcastic, and snarky, and it would be better all round if you adopted a less confrontational approach Deletion of Mister Dave's WP:N||WP:V||WP:RS||WP:CIVIL Wikipedia:Notability 77
22607 6047 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Boraq Tower User:Sabiona 15:23, 3 December 2009 (UTC) delete per Deletion of Boraq Tower WP:CRYSTAL Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22608 9764 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Stickman arcade User:Dragonfiend 22:07, 31 January 2006 (UTC) delete per nom, fails Deletion of Stickman arcade WP:WEB Wikipedia:Notability 77
22609 19604 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Getting Through User:Lankiveil 11:21, 24 April 2008 (UTC) delete does not meet the notability criteria for songs as per Deletion of Getting Through WP:MUSIC Wikipedia:Notability 77
22610 17844 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Preston FM (2nd nomination) User:NemesisAT 19:49, 29 August 2021 (UTC) keep per thanks to the work put in by {{u|Eastmain Deletion of Preston FM (2nd nomination) WP:HEY Wikipedia:The Heymann Standard 81
22611 17448 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of fictional archenemies User:Reyk 23:58, 28 May 2010 (UTC) delete because this encyclopedia is |not a directory, because there's hardly any sources and significant original research is needed to bring this up to any sort of useful completeness, and because it's cruft Deletion of List of fictional archenemies WP:NOTDIR Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not 50
22612 5299 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of Cosmic Era mobile units User:Sephiroth 04:03, 23 August 2007 (UTC) delete no |reliable, |verifiable out-of-universe third party sources to establish its |notability Deletion of List of Cosmic Era mobile units WP:RS||WP:V||WP:N Wikipedia:Reliable sources 39
22613 20373 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Deal Angel (company) User:RightCowLeftCoast 18:50, 25 June 2013 (UTC) keep while the coverage from the SJBJ appears to be passing mention, and I am unsure as to the reliability of TechCrunch, I do recognize PCWorld as a reliable source as it is a widely distributed professionally published magazine. After reviewing the PCWorld article which is used as a source within the article, along with the San Jose Mercury News article, this makes two significant coverage sources, sufficient IMHO to pass ; therefore, I am supporting keeping this article Deletion of Deal Angel (company) WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22614 17565 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Furkan Doğan User:Pohick2 02:06, 20 June 2010 (UTC) comment you insouciant sophist, showing the to be WP:idontlikeit Deletion of Furkan Doğan WP:BIO1E Wikipedia:Notability 77
22615 15823 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Grouvellina hova User:Demiurge1000 05:07, 29 June 2014 (UTC) keep per . No argument has been advanced that the beetle in question is not a separate and documented species Deletion of Grouvellina hova WP:SPECIESOUTCOMES Wikipedia:Deletion policy 20
22616 21444 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Michael Dargaville User:Hrafn 15:34, 3 October 2009 (UTC) delete no evidence that topic meets or . Purported 'references' are vague to the point of being useless (generally lacking specific dates for periodicals, and authors to tell which are by him & which are about him Deletion of Michael Dargaville WP:BIO||WP:GNG Wikipedia:Notability 77
22617 12324 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jive Software User:Tedder 23:43, 12 January 2010 (UTC) keep http://news.google.com/news?q=jive%20software&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&hl=en&tab=wn reliable sources are easily found, and |deletion should not be used for articles simply needing cleanup. Further, this is likely a |pointy deletion in response to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Blogtronix (2nd nomination)|this. I http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Tedder&oldid=337310520#deletion_of_Jive gave the nominator some advice about deletion of this article recently Deletion of Jive Software WP:NOTCLEANUP||WP:POINT Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions 18