Deletion of List of gay, lesbian or bisexual people (4th nomination)

Comment: I find yet another Afd for a list which has now had THREE parts of it featured exceedingly weird. It's like trying to delete an FA because you don't like the content. Once again:  contains three reasons for a list on Wikipedia
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Lists (WP:LIST)

Comment: I was the nominator for Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of LGBT characters in modern written fiction and one of my concerns were that it is difficult to maintain the accuracy of such a list and much easier to maintain the accuracy of a category because any time the category is inserted into an article, many people who are very familar with the subject and have the subject in their watchlist would see it and might disapprove. The response to this concern was that I shouldn't worry about it because there's no risk of a  violation. Well, in this case, there is a big risk of a  violation, this particular list that has been nominated now looks like a BLP violation just waiting to happen. Furthermore, this list will never be complete and diminishes the value of wikipedia as a whole by having incompete lists
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons (WP:BLP||WP:BLP)