Deletion of Outside Bozeman

Comment: This is pretty much the same article as from a year and a half ago, obviously written as part of the magazine's publicity effort and carefully tailored to squeeze every last droplet of "notability" from the relative stones which are the sources here.  And what are those sources?  An "alums done good" writeup in a college paper, a blog post on the website of a local radio station advertising the magazine's $250 contest, a half sentence in the Washington Post, and a three-minute "local interest" interview on a Montana TV station's morning show (which, again, is not really about the magazine but about its contest).  There's really nothing here that can possibly add up to "significant coverage."  If every throwaway interview, day after day, on local TV stations created notability, my grandmother's quilting club would be notable by now.  The keep !votes above run the range from blatant sockery to  to an irrelevant remark about its circulation -- last time I checked, didn't they give this thing away for free
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions (WP:WAX)

Comment: The magazine has not achieved notability per Wikipedia's standards. Please note, Mr. "Implicit keep", that  is against Wikipedia rules and can get you banned from Wikipedia altogether
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Sockpuppetry (WP:SOCKPUPPETRY)

Comment: since it does have multiple coverage in other media outlets (actually somewhat unusual for a paper like this one) and so passes  (barely), and it does seem to be a legitmately significant publication in its market. I don't think "local" is a valid objection; we do (and should) have articles for local papers.  Although I do favor keeping this article, I have to note that an article about this publication was deleted in April 2010; as I (vaguely) recall, that article was written (at least initially) in a more blatantly promotional style than this one, which did not help its case any.  See Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Outside Bozeman Magazine
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:GNG)

Comment: This AfD was not correctly transcluded to the log (|step 3).  I have transcluded it to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2011 November 17
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion (WP:AFDHOWTO)