Deletion of The TY Revolution

Comment: First of all, I reverted the redirect back to the article, including the AfD tag. Not just should the article be deleted, but it should not be a redirect. The site is not nearly popular enough for it to have any presence on WP. It completely fails . In addition, it should not be a redirect, as that 1) implies that the site is somehow significant, and 2) implies that anyone would search that term (which is highly doubtful
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:WEB)

Comment: Please see , specifically WP:not#Wikipedia_is_not_a_crystal_ball|Wikipedia is not a crystal ball. You (and I mean the general "you", not "you", ToyoWolf, in particular) cannot attempt to assert notability by saying "This could be popular one day," or "She could get famous if...," or, in your case, "We fully expect to have over 1,000 members" and "We intend to buy a server within a year." Also, please look at  for criteria for inclusion in Wikipedia concerning web sites
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not (WP:NOT||WP:WEB)

Comment: fails ,  a crystal ball, and not worth a merge/redirect
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:WEB||WP:NOT)

Comment: I'm simply going to respond in order of what you stated. 1) I couldn't care less about the "disk space"- I doubt Wikipedia could hold an ''infinite'' number of articles, but it could certainly hold ''a lot''. The concern is notability; in building an encyclopedia, we (meaning you, me, and everyone on WP) must have some standards. If every web site had its own Wikipedia article, then, obviously, WP would be larger than the entirety of the rest of the Web. 2) I'm not sure how |WP's rules on not making personal attacks applies to quoting other people, but I still don't appreciate it. I'm not attacking you for your views, and I should not be attacked for mine; our views are equally valid. For the record, I do adore ''Halo'' and ''GTA''; I also love the ''Ratchet & Clank'' games, the ''Tony Hawk'' games, the ''NBA Street'' games, the ''Dance Dance Revolution'' games, and games in pretty much every genre (besides RPGs and strategy games). I have absolutely nothing against the ''Ty'' series's games; as I have never played them, I cannot judge their quality. However, you can be sure that if a ''GTA'' fansite's article was up for deletion, I would argue for its deletion unless it could be proven that the site was particularly significant. 3) In addition, ''size'' of a web forum matters, and I'm sure the largest ''Halo'' or ''Half-Life'' forum is many dozens (if not hundreds) times larger than this ''Ty'' forum. I understand that staff members on the ''Ty'' team posts on your forums, but I know of (for example) more than a few ''GTA'' fansites that have direct correspondence with Rockstar (in fact, the pamphlet/booklet/whatever you want to call it for all of the PS2 ''GTA'' games have "Thank yous" for half a dozen or so sites), and none of them have articles
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:No personal attacks (WP:NPA)