Deletion of Samuel Mehr (2nd nomination)

Comment: re:Dylanfromthenorth, at , the guidelines specifically state that '''one''' of the criteria must be met -- that one criterion is that the musician is a member of two or more ensembles (item #6).  This seems to be at odds with your definition of notability as 'not every member of a notable group is inherently notable.'  That is a different discussion, though - as far as I can tell, this fits within Wiki guidelines
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:MUSICBIO)

Comment: Not every member of an ensemble/concert group is inherently notable - as with any other article's subject they have to have ''significant, non-trivial, third party coverage'' as per . This coverage has to be about Samuel Mehr, not about any groups he was in. If he was notable enough, this coverage, whether on the web, in newspapers, or whatever, would exist. Thats abpout all there is to it - the guy's not notable enough, the article should be deleted
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:MUSICBIO)

Comment: Musicbio criteria 6 is the only thing resembling a claim to notability, and the claim that he is a member of these orchestras is not |verified by any 3rd party sources.  Even if it was, I don't think the guideline should apply to members of orchestras as being part of a 4 person band and a 20 person orchestra aren't really the same thing.  (Although I do agree that Beantown Swing Orchestra is notable despite the lack of page
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Verifiability (WP:V)