Deletion of Shona Holmes (3rd nomination)

Comment: per 
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons (WP:BLP1E)

Comment: There are a few issues that complicate here.  First, as I understand it, "Shona Holmes" is not the name that this woman uses in her day-to-day life, but her maiden name.  This, for me, alleviates some of the  concerns.  Second, this has been a big enough controversy that the public deserves a balanced one-stop account -- something that wikipedia should aim to provide.  One way or the other, however, the article should be renamed, because it is not and never will be a biography of this woman, but rather a description of an episode that brought her 15 minutes.  So at the very least something like '''Shona Holmes health insurance controversy
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons (WP: BLP)

Comment: per BLP1E.  There are plenty of sources, some of which do cover the subject.  But she is notable for one event and one event only (apologies for mixing the commonly understood meaning of notability, rather than  in there) and the article content reflects that.  There is copious coverage of the salient event and then the sources mostly discuss the health care debate.  I would prefer a merger over deletion, but I don't think deletion is out of bounds
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:N)

Comment: e.g. to Shona Holmes health insurance controversy as suggested by Bucketsofg. It shouldn't be set up as a BLP (per  and Wikipedia:BIO1E#People_notable_only_for_one_event) but should explicitly refer in the title to the particular issue relating to the media attention Ms. Holmes has received
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons (WP:BLP)

Comment: Still the  that I thought it was in the first AfD
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:ONEVENT)

Comment: to Health care reform in the United States per . The article and sources do not deal with the person but rather her case and the use and misuse of it. If any information is useful in other articles, that can be merged there as well
Stance: merge
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons (WP:BLP1E)