Deletion of Garrett Chisolm

Comment: I found a some coverage of him only because of the tragedy which affected him. He did not receive this coverage as a notable football player, and the only non-tragedy-related stories are not enough to pass . He also fails , as he has yet to play in an NFL game
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:GNG||WP:NSPORT)

Comment: per Eagles247, and I do find him to be un-of-the-mill vignette material with no lasting . Scholar athletes, perhaps unfortunately, are not notable in real-life and neither is a one-time second-team conference college player who was released from NFL practice squad. To (hopefully) save the standard rebuttals, I am knowingly overriding the "presumption" of notability in GNG, which itself allows a consensus to still determine a stand-alone article is not warranted in spite of the number of sources. I am referencing some essays and not guidelines which I find applicable, but don't persecute me as |Wikipedia does not have firm rules aside from improving Wikipedia.  I know deleting this article will be an uphill battle in that it is well-written and has citations
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Redirect (WP:R||WP:IMPACT||WP:IAR)

Comment: Per Cbl. He has convinced me that Chisholm is notable enough for an article. He's clearly not your un-of-the-mill player
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Redirect (WP:R)

Comment: I understand Eagles24/7's point, but I think there's enough enough to satisfy  and with the national coverage (e.g., http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/news?slug=jc-cole_chisolm_still_in_pain_after_parents_loss_042711 this story) he also passes  #3.  The story is not simply that the kid had both of his parents die from cancer in the months before his senior year.  If that were it, there would be no argument.  The real story that attracted national media coverage is how this kid (the son of janitors) overcame adversity to become a star football player.  He was a walk-on at South Carolina who refused to quit and continued to play in his senior year following his parents' death.  He excelled on the field, helping South Carolina win its first ever SEC East championship, and being selected as a second-team All-SEC player (bear in mind the SEC is the most competitive conference is American college football). He also excelled academically such that he was a semi-finalist for the William V. Campbell Trophy as the sport's top scholar-athlete.  His is a remarkable and notable story that deservedly attracted national media attention.  His accomplishments and news coverage are enough to pass  and  #3
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:GNG||WP:NCOLLATH||WP:GNG||WP:NCOLLATH)