Deletion of List of academic computer science departments

Comment: This qualifies under . It's not indiscriminate given the content so #INDISCRIMINATE does not apply, nor does  or  as the links are reliable
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Lists (WP:LIST||WP:NOT||WP:NOR||WP:SYNTHESIS)

Comment: however, I wouldn't object to keeping it for now if a more general discussion is started as suggested by DGG.) If this is not a perfect example of the type of directory specifically excluded by #DIR, I don't know what is. If kept, I suggest renaming it to something like List of computer science departments in the United States offering doctoral degrees, in order to be describe the contents more precisely. The list is already huge and I don't think it can be expanded to become truly international as it is, because several of the columns only make sense in the U.S
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not (WP:NOT)

Comment: The reason for proposing the deletion is weak.  First, |not may be applicable, but the proposer of the deletion has not made a case. Merely stating it is applicable is not a justification. Before I could agree, I would have to know why he thinks this particular list is not appropriate. In other words, he has not made his case.  Second, I don't think the case for deletion under  has been made. The information is from reliable sources (though the sources could be better documented), it doesn't promote a point of view, etc. So, on either grounds, the proposer has failed his obligation to make his case
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not (WP:NOT||WP:OR)