Deletion of Ishkur's Guide to Electronic Music (4th nomination)

Comment: Cited and discussed, albeit briefly, in some of the book sourced linked above, plus coverage from ''The Guardian'', is enough to meet 
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:GNG)

Comment: for a web reference source, I think that it is doing rather well in terms of being paid attention to.  In addition to the mentions above, "Ishkur's Guide to Electronic Music" was suggested as a reference source at {{Cite journal|title=Web resources|journal=Keyboard (magazine)|Keyboard|date=September 2004}} and its accuracy, good, and ecletic classification system was discussed at {{Cite journal|author=Dr. Dawg|title=Ishkur Excursion|journal=Keyboard (magazine)|Keyboard|date=November 2004|page= 6}}. It was also covered in an article at {{Cite news|author=Hurley, Oliver|title=Friday Review: Little Things we like: ''Ishkur's Guide to Electronic Music''|date=11 June 2004|newspaper=The Guardian|location=London, England|page=31 (Arts and Entertainment)}} which discussed its scope and organization, and praised its detail. Since the nominator's deletion just prior to this nomination, I don't see any |OR problems in the article
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:No original research (:WP:OR)

Comment: The sources satisfy 
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:SIGCOV)

Comment: Did not find significant coverage in multiple reliable sources to meet . Previous AfD "keep" votes seem to rely on either "it's popular" or "you can't prove it's not notable" as arguments; the latter I think is irrelevent, and the former does not establish notability. In particular,  (the web-specific notability guidelines, which can be considered in addition to general guideline criteria in ) requires a website to have attracted notice (which I agree the has, in both reliable sources and in blogs and forums), but also requires either ''significant'' coverage in reliable sources, or winning a well-known award (see CRIT), which the subject fails to meet
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:GNG||WP:WEB||WP:GNG||WP:WEBCRIT)