Deletion of Diana Gonzalez-Whyte

Comment: Firstly, judges at this level are not inherently notable — higher level judges, such as a state or federal Supreme Court or a federal District Court, count under our subject-specific inclusion rules for judges, but judges at the ''county'' level live or die on . Secondly, her ethnic background doesn't make her more notable than she would be otherwise — if she were the first judge from any Latina background at all, I'd accept that for notability, but not just "the first Colombian-American" (as if whether she were Colombian or Venezuelan or Peruvian or Nicaraguan made an appreciable difference to her career prospects). Thirdly, this article as written is hardly more than a blurb which asserts her existence but offers no real substance to demonstrate why she should be considered worthy of inclusion in an encyclopedia. And finally, the volume of sourcing here ''isn't'' sufficient to claim a  pass
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:GNG||WP:GNG)

Comment: wondering where there is some rule saying ''county judges are not notable''? That doesn't make sense -- some counties are highly populous, such as Miami-Dade, while others are rural, and will get less media coverage; still, it depends on what happens within the county, and whether the subject is notable. The  applies, with sufficient sources, since she's a big deal in the Columbian-American community, although she does not get as much attention in the American press. The previous version of her article was too long and unsourced, but hopefully improved as per . There is a http://dailybusinessreview.typepad.com/insidetrack/2013/03/miami-dades-first-colombian-american-judge-praised-at-investiture.html substantive article about her here after her investiture, http://www.nbcmiami.com/news/Man-Who-Grabbed-Teen-Girl-Thwarted-By-Rock-Throwing-Good-Samaritan-Miami-Police-209541991.html mention here, http://premioscolombiaexterior.com/por-votacion-popular/diana-gonzalez-whyte-juez-colombiana-en-el-condado-de-miami-dade/ major article here, http://recorriendoamericanews.com/diana-gonzalez-aspira-a-juez-para-hacer-justicia-en-miami-dade/ major article here, http://www.local10.com/news/miamidade-firefighter-arrested-on-child-porn-charges/25550534 mention here, http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/florida-firefighter-shared-child-porn-twitter-work-computer-cops-article-1.1762242 mention here, http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.redescolombia.org/destacado/DianaGonz%25C3%25A1lez&prev=/search%3Fq%3D%2522Diana%2BGonzalez%2522%2B(whyte%2BOR%2B%2522public%2Bdefender%2522%2BOR%2Bjudge%2BOR%2B%2522miami-dade%2522%2BOR%2Blawyer%2BOR%2Bcolumbia%2BOR%2Bcolumbian%2BOR%2Bjudicial)%26start%3D40%26sa%3DN%26espv%3D2%26biw%3D1093%26bih%3D605 article here. Another thing: a public defender handling 4,000 cases -- that is substantial. Big reason to keep: she'll throw out parking tickets for Wikipedians who get ticketed in the Miami-Dade county area, so I've been told
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:GNG||WP:HEYMANN)