Deletion of Jeremy Tolleson

Comment: Passes  and 
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:NFOOTBALL||WP:GNG)

Comment: subject is notable per  because he made 30+ professional appearances in the USL First Division with Carolina RailHawks, confirmed by https://www.oursportscentral.com/services/releases/railhawks-defender-tolleson-retires/n-3961541 this
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:NFOOTBALL)

Comment: I don't think the source GS posted https://www.oursportscentral.com/services/releases/railhawks-defender-tolleson-retires/n-3961541 is an RS; no evidence of any editorial oversight, and it looks very blog-ish to me. Of the 8 sources Smartyllama posted, six are from Indy Week (which covers the local Raleigh, North Carolina market). The other two https://www.wralsportsfan.com/soccer/story/5605183/?comment_order=forward https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2005/jul/17/surge-eliminate-shadow/ are game reports that have one mention of the player each, so definitely not GNG. Of the six Indy Week sources, I agree with Jogurney that https://indyweek.com/culture/archives/railhawks-tolleson-walks-away-schedule-revealed-10-first-15-games-road/ the first and https://indyweek.com/culture/archives/muscle-signed-cary/ the eighth are the two best (the others are brief mentions). However, they're both written by the same author and published by the same publisher–I don't believe they satisfy the "multiple sources" criteria–this is one source writing about the player twice. And, the eighth source is derivative of a team announcement and quotes the announcement verbatim–almost all of the content about the player comes from the announcement. This is not independent per  and ; it's derivative of the team announcement, and so the eighth source doesn't satisfy GNG. What's left is the first IndyWeek source, which is basically one author writing one piece for a local weekly online magazine about a player's retirement, and even then, it's not very in-depth. I'm not finding anything searching online, either. I don't see a GNG pass here, or other evidence of notability
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:SPORTSBASIC||WP:BASIC)

Comment: Glad for the relist. Concerning the "net sum" of sources, six Indy Week sources, along with 3 on the article, count as one towards notability as do the two by the same editor, so the statement ''"...there are 2 Indy Week articles that have enough coverage between them that I think we can conclude the GNG could be met"'' does not take this into account. I am having some possible browser issues as I couldn't get the cciw.org source to load and the sportsengine.com source came back with "Error: Page Not Found". The three Indy Week loaded fine but the triangledowntowner.com returned "That page seems to be missing or the link was mistyped. Please try again.", and I don't think anyone else mentioned having these issues. Of the eight sources provided above (aside from the 6 Indy Week), wralsportsfan.com has two passing mentions, "...because the backline of Jeremy Tolleson, Devon McKenney, Brad Rusin and John Gilkerson hadn’t played together yet this season.", and the subjects name mentioned under "LINEUPS" and "CAUTIONS". The spokesman.com source simply states "Rigby opened the scoring in the 29th minute on a pass from Jeremy Tolleson.", which may be great for content but "WP:Grasping at straws" to advance notability. I need to check to make sure I am not having site loading issues but also to see where these "other sources" are because a presumption of notability must still be supported by sources. "30+ professional appearances" |does not advance notability automatically or inherently but I do |think there should be sources out there. As a BLP the sourcing is supposedly held to a higher standard and that is currently severely lacking
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:NRV||WP:NPOSSIBLE)