Deletion of Phone Call to Putin (2nd nomination)

Comment: without prejudice as a |neologism.  This needs more time to become notable. Wikipedia isn't the newspaper
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary (WP:NEOLOGISM)

Comment: Currently it's a  article, not about the method as such, but about the specific case where it was documented. If there's nothing more to be said about the method than that it happened in that case (see lead sentence: ''... is a Russian neologism for a torture method allegedly used by Russian police to extract a confession out of Alexey Mikheye''), it can easily be integrated in an article either about that person (if he's notable), or about the court case (which definitely is), or a wider "human rights in Russia"-style overview article. Notability and coverage of the term as such has not been demonstrated
Stance: merge
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Coatrack articles (WP:COATRACK)

Comment: Phone Call to Putin is a |non-notable EO|neologism used to describe electric shock#Torture|electric shocks given to a single person. It appears some editors in this AfD have misunderstood what the topic is about.  states: "If a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject, it is presumed to satisfy the inclusion criteria for a stand-alone article." The sources used in this article do not give significant coverage of ''Phone Call to Putin'', but rather to Alexey Mikheyev, and mention ''Phone Call to Putin'' in passing; there is nothing more that can be said about this term past it being electric shock given by attaching electrodes to the ears, and that this is only recorded as being applied to a single person, Mikheyev. The term does not meet the basic notability guidelines, and would be best placed in an article on Alexey Mikheyev, and |done so in passing as per the sources which discuss http://www.google.com/search?q=Alexey+Mikheyev&le=en&btnG=Google+Search&sourceid=Mozilla-search&start=0 this notable individual. As this is an article on a neologism, it absolutely lacks the substantial details on the term itself, '''every single one''' the sources used in the article relate to Mikheyev's case, which the more I look at it, it isn't the person who is notable, but the case, '''''Mikheyev v. Russia
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:N||WP:NEO||WP:N||WP:UNDUE)

Comment: into Human rights in Russia. Per . Or/and other ''Police torture in modern Russia'' like articles. The article is fully referenced and this is an important subject. ''Phone Call to Putin'' can be made a sub chapter of a lager scoped article
Stance: merge
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary (WP:NEO)

Comment: into Human rights in Russia. Per  it is a non-notable neologism so it is not notable for an article. We do not have an article for Palestinian hanging as that article is also a not notable neologism and it is redirected to Strappado. Phone Call to Putin is even less notable than Palestinian hanging as the term "Palestinian hanging" has been used to a great degree by human rights organizations such as http://www.hrw.org/reports/1997/turkey/Turkey-04.htm#P176_36663 HRW and the http://sim.law.uu.nl/SIM/CaseLaw/Hof.nsf/233813e697620022c1256864005232b7/d6ff575974b1f791c1256640004c3277?OpenDocument Netherlands institute for Human Rights
Stance: merge
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary (WP:NEO)

Comment: as well sourced and a likely search term; move (leaving a redirect) if people think that a different title is more appropriate.  This concept has been subject of non-trivial independent coverage; it appears to be a shoo-in per  unless I am completely misreading the sources
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:N)

Comment: but would like to point out that whatever this article is, it is certainly ''not'' about a neologism. I'm open to good arguments for deletion but quoting  to death is not going to do it and in fact I almost wonder if people quoting it realize how irrelevant that guideline is in the present case. "Phone call to Putin" is not fighting for a place into the next edition of Webster's. In any case, how about moving and redirecting to "zvonok Putinu
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Wikipedia is not a dictionary (WP:NEO)