Deletion of Stargate Atlantis DVD (second nomination)

Comment: Fancruft as a word should be banned from every Wikipedian's vocabulary.  There is no rule anywhere in Wikipedia about "fancruft", and moreover, people simply use it as a term for things they don't like.  I've seen it used to describe everything from Naruto articles to information about the Salvation Army.  An article shouldn't exist if it violates guidelines such as  or , not if a few Wikipedians declare it "cruft," especially as "cruft" is an entirely subjective term.  At least if you're going to call something cruft, back it up with actual guidelines to justify your decision. &mdash
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not (WP:NOT||WP:V)

Comment: or '''Merge''' It provides for good |Summary Style from the main articles.  A merge could be considered between the SG-1 DVD and Atlantis DVD which might satisfy
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Summary style (WP:SS)

Comment: or '''merge'''.  Precedent is that this article should be kept.  So far, there is no community consensus that articles like this should not exist.  If such a guideline is proposed, or perhaps as an addition to , such a change could be discussed. &mdash
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not (WP:NOT)