Deletion of List of floating islands in fiction

Comment: Poorly sourced without any defining criteria, pretty much WP:OR. Fails criteria for standalone article per . Also, we already have an article on this as a literary device (or trope) entitled "Floating cities and islands in fiction". That article already cites generalized examples followed by sections with specific examples. That makes this article is essentially a ontent fork
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:N||WP:C)

Comment: Just reading the title of this article set me off laughing for a couple of minutes, as much as I'll go into explaining why this article should be deleted, it's perfectly summed up with this word, '''nonsense'''. Some articles are oddly obscure but aren't bad, in this case though, the article is pure unorganized cruft and I feel like it was made just for the heck of it. Definitely not meeting , and 
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:GNG||WP:OR)

Comment: Looking at the above scholar references, it's clear that fictional floating islands are a notable concept.  The above deletion arguments are critiques of the content, which can be fixed by regular editing, rather than the concept.  While I agree with the critiques (floating in air != floating in water, too unreferenced, too much pop culture trivia), none of those, individually or together, justify deleting a notable topic.  Cutting it back to the Odyssey reference, or just redirecting to Floating island (fiction) per -R would be strongly preferable to deletion
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Deletion policy (WP:ATD)