Deletion of Shamsher Singh (journalist)

Comment: We do not cite images (they cannot go in depth) and we won't cite official emails (|Not formally published). As mentioned, sources need to discuss the subject ''themselves'' in some depth, not tangentially-related entities
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Verifiability (WP:SELFPUB)

Comment: with alternate of |USERFY. {{ping|SinghPurnima72}}. I am going to go the simple route. I have not looked at the history but I would suggest this article be moved to your user page. Edits can then be made to ready an article for review to be published. Submit via |AFC when you feel the concerns of editors weighing in above have been addressed. Editing a published article, as a defense to save, is ''NOT'' a good defense for COI editing. The AFC process can be slow and a good recommendation would be to edit other areas so as not to be deemed a |single purpose account
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Userfication (WP:USERFY||WP:AFC||WP:SPA)

Comment: Just reading this article as presented I don't see the subject meeting any of the four criteria for .  It reads more like a professional resume.  While the ''Ramnath Goenka'' award is a major journalistic award in India the subject's body of work does not have significant attention or coverage in reliable sources. The page creating editor also appears to be a  created solely to create this biography. This suggests major  of paid editing or promotion of a colleague or friend
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:JOURNALIST||WP:SPA||WP:COI)

Comment: The article makes bold claims, few if any of which are supported by strong secondary sources that are independent of the subject. I see , I see PR, I see those which are effectively self-published; above all, I see an article in |breach of policy from beginning to end. Special:contributions/Serial Number 54129
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Run-of-the-mill (WP:MILL||WP:NOTLINKEDIN)

Comment: A Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Awards|Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Award is not, in my evaluation, a "well-known and significant award" for the purposes of the first point of . It is some indication that he is "regarded as an important figure" for the purposes of the first point of , although the category in which he won, On-the-spot-Reporting (Broadcast), is one of almost 30, and not a marquee one. The only other reliable independent coverage of him is trivial, mentions of his hiring for ''Republic Bharat
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:ANYBIO||WP:JOURNALIST)