Deletion of Alan Baker (philosopher)

Comment: I don't think I actually did vote in the previous AfD, but thanks for the ping. I did point out that he has a Google scholar profile https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=jfTV1PgAAAAJ here which is helpful for getting an impression of how significant his philosophy work is; I think this may be a field with low-enough citations to make his numbers (h-index of 10, top citation count 127) meet the threshold for #C1, barely; I prefer Margin1522's argument from strength rather than numbers of citations, but that takes more subject-specific expertise than I have. I agree that there is no case for keeping on the basis of his shogi activity, so I think  is the only possibility
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:PROF||WP:PROF)

Comment: I first posted about this on Drmies' talk page, but since I've been pinged I guess it's OK for me to comment here too. I am the editor who proposed this article for deletion the first time, but that was based solely on Baker's notability as shogi player and {{diff|Alan Baker (philosopher)|next|598700800 this version}} of the article. As stated above, the result of first Afd was "no consensus". The article was improved, renamed and the focus shifted to Baker's academic activities which, in my opinion, made it much better than the version I first saw. That is why I just accepted the "no consensus" keep for what it was and moved on to other things. Is Baker notable enough to satisfy any of the criterion in WP:NACADEMICS? I cannot say for sure, but since he needs to satisfy only one of the nine and No.1 seems to be his best chance, I think it depends on how broadly you wish to define "significant impact". No. 1 of #Specific criteria notes says "the academic has been an author of highly cited academic work". Being cited 127 times sounds highly cited to me, but #Citation metrics seems to imply that using Google Scholar, citation counts, h-index, etc. as determining factors may not always be as clear cut as it seems
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:PROF||WP:PROF)