Deletion of Descendants of Adam and Eve

Comment: It seems that StAnselm's argument is .  That's not enough.  The article collects information from various books of the bible into a single list, and saying that someone can just look it up in the bible is like saying that anyone can just do their own research instead of reading a Wikipedia article. Why does Wikipedia exist then?  We cover notable topics in Wikipedia, whether or not a given editor finds the topic personally useful.  Many bible topics including this one are notable and this may include many "minor" or lesser known characters, but there are major ones on the list as well
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions (WP:USELESS)

Comment: I'll agree that this list is very useful for some people, but for me it is somewhat problematic as a WP article.  The format, while very creative, doesn't really suit WP--it doesn't conform to any existing template or style.   That may seem like a pointless complaint, but it would be very hard for other editors to contribute to this page as it is the project of a small team of users.  It just seems like the creators of this really should create their own website for this rather than store it on Wikipedia in their own format.  I'm sure the editors are acting in good faith (no pun intended) but I feel the page has potential  issues due to its 'pet project' feel
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Ownership of content (WP:OWN)