Deletion of Glenn McGee

Comment: I think this barely passes cademics, but the media attention surrounding his departure of Albany makes that he passes . As to the publications, according to the Web of Science they have been cited less than 200 times (h-index of 8), which is less than stellar. There are some more citations if non-journal publications are taken into account and Web of Science may, in fact, be less appropriate for ethicists. Still, even Google Scholar, which casts a wider net, lists not that many citations (one with 63, one with 40, the rest less). What might tip the balance is the fact that he's the founding editor of the American Journal of Bioethics, which according to the Journal Citation Reports has an Impact factor of 3.9, which is more than twice the IF of number two in the category "HISTORY & PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE". (Strangely, there's an enormous amount of self-citations for 2007, but that does not enter into the above figures. Another strange thing with the journal: the Francis and Taylor website lists a pretty distinguished Editorial Board herehttp://www.tandf.co.uk/journals/journal.asp?issn=1526-5161&linktype=5, but the journal's own site lists no board at all and says that the "2008-2009 editorial board will be finalized shortly"http://www.bioethics.net/information.php?infoCat=faq&infoId=10). Whatever the verdict on the academic part, though,  carries the day
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Attribution (WP:A||WP:BIO||WP:BIO)

Comment: Looks likely to pass , but I think the media attention surrounding his departure from Albany Medical (and the irony of an ethics expert being caught up in possible ethical issues, as reported on in the second Scientific American article) lead to a pass of  as well. Care should be taken regarding our policy on |biographies of living persons but as long as anything we state can be sourced to reliable publishers (e.g. SciAm) we should be ok on that front. I don't think 1E applies because the articles about him are not just about his dismissal, but also about his life through the several years leading up to the dismissal and about the legal aftermath of the situation: BIO1E is for when we really only have one thing to say about a person (he was fired -- so what), but I think there is more here than that
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:PROF||WP:BIO||WP:BLP||WP:BIO1E)