Deletion of Daniel Glen Timms

Comment: While there are many footnotes, on closer examination the sources don't hold up as  and various claims made appear to be unsupported by the sources cited. For example, the article says: "Daniel's first independently released demo received the highest-rated "rock" review of the year in 1998 by Music Connection Magazine". The footnote given points to the main website of  the Music Connection magazine, http://musicconnection.com. However, no specifics in the reference are given (such as a direct link to the article or the date of publication, name of the article, etc). A search of the http://musicconnection.com website for "Daniel Glen Timms" returns 0 hitshttp://musicconnection.com/?s=%22Daniel+Glen+Timms%22. The article then says about "The Highway Home" album:"The album garnered strong support among many commercial, public and community radio stations". Two footnotes are given, one to the webpage of the artist and the other is this linkhttp://www.ktep.org/program_detail.sstg?id=34 to KTEP radio site. The only mention of the name of the subject there is a listing of his song in the playlist column. No discussion of the song or the artist here and not something that can be characterized as "garnered strong support". We then proceed further in the article to the following statement: "His album, "La La Land," received his highest critical acclaim" with a reference to this Belgian site:http://www.rootstime.be/ The site is not searchable, but after looking around it a bit I could not find a mention of the name of Daniel Glen Timms there. The article then says, in relation to the same album:"with airplay worldwide and on over 130 radio stations". The reference given for this 130 stations claim is this linkhttp://www.wets.org/?BISKIT=4077585893&CONTEXT=cat&cat=10149 to the website of a radio station WETS. The page link does not mention either the name of the artist or the name of the album. Moreover, searching the entire website for the name "Timms" produces a single hithttp://www.wets.org/index.cgi?cat=10110&BISKIT=4077585893&CONTEXT=cat, to a long photogaller containing one photograph from a performace by Timms. Nothing about 130 stations here. And so on. Too many basic  problems here. Also, a googlenews search gives 0 hits http://news.google.com/archivesearch?hl=en&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tab=wn&q=%22Daniel+Glen+Timms%22
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Reliable sources (WP:RS||WP:V)

Comment: Comment''' - Hi, Jimbellizzi.  I think this is the first time you've had experience with the AfD, or Articles for Deletion process.  This is one of the constructs of Wikipedia, where editors make a determination whether articles meet the requirements for being kept on Wikipedia.  There's documentation for how this procedure works here: fD.  Typically, this page is used for editors to add their comments regarding '''keep'''ing or '''delete'''ing the article.  While lots of editors think that it's a matter of votes, it really isn't, as the process documentation will clarify.  So anyway, I know that you're working hard on the article.  I would recommend that you add your desired resolution outcome to this page (by adding  - followed by the reason you think the article should be kept.  I'll continue to work with you on the talk page of the article in order to suggest what might be needed to achieve notability. &mdash
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Attribution (WP:A)