Deletion of List of cult video games

Comment: Citing the failed deletion discussions of List of cult films is absolutely not , they set an obvious precedentt. If List of cult films is sufficiently notable as proven in several discussions, then a list of cult video games is absolutely notable. Both should be nominated as a group if this is to be deleted
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions (WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS)

Comment: but support '''Delete''' too. On the article's talk page, concurrent to this AFD, we're discussing a set of criterion needed to limit what can be added to this list, which I personally expect would nix 75% of the games on it, which would require far better sourcing since as the above !votes have already noted, its far too easy to find a hit on "cult video game" for many titles but only in passing. This almost would be a  situation in that case, hence my support for deletion, but I'd rather see us better defined the inclusion metrics and cull down with impunity than delete outright
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over (WP:TNT)

Comment: these lists based on subjective qualities undermine the  of our encyclopedia. I'm sure that you can find a source or two that will say a game is any number of subjective qualities, including "cult". But |synthesizing them to together into a list is misleading. At best, it will represent the viewpoint of several individual journalists on several different articles, and that's assuming they use the word "cult" in the same sense". It ultimately becomes filtered through the point of view of the editor who noticed it and hopes to make it seem more objective than it actually is. If we're going to make lists of games, they should be based around qualities that journalists widely agree upon. Things like platform, year, or genre
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Neutral point of view (WP:NPOV||WP:SYNTH)

Comment: per the well-rationed nom and Masem's comments regarding 
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over (WP:TNT)