Deletion of Take Me Out to the Ballgame (SATC episode)

Comment: I think having individual episode pages for every episode of a notable series is appropriate, and is a case where keeping the fact that |Wikipedia is not paper in mind is vital.  The simplest way to have reasonable coverage of a show's plot is to have an article for each episode -- an attempt to consolidate all episodes for a series into a single article is likely to result in a large, unwieldy article that makes it difficult to find desired information.  Having a single article also opens the door for all sorts of arguments about what is sufficiently important to include in the article, and only having articles for "important" episodes will lead similarly to constant arguments as to what constitutes an important episode.  Separate articles for every episode ensure that there's a specific place for any information about the plot of the show, allow someone typing in an episode title to go directly to the information they're looking for, and provide a way to navigate through the history of a show.  Yes, this may result in the occasional permanently stub-sized article about an unexciting episode, but not having every article would leave a disconcerting gap for anyone trying to read through the story of a show, and undoubtedly result in repeated re-creation of the missing article.  We're certainly always going to have at least a redirect for any episode, so why not, since space is not a concern, improve the usability and informativeness of Wikipedia by having a short article to host basic episode-specific and navigation information (previous/next episodes, guest stars/writer/director) instead of a redirect that provides nothing
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not (WP:PAPER)

Comment: sound action stations. Consensus is to improve, not delete (). Article establishes notability to me, not to mention it was Emmy nominated
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Manual of Style (WP:EPISODE)

Comment: This AfD is about this episode, not the series -- I'm not sure why you're making remarks about the series. Assuming that the precedent is correct is fallacy. This article establishes no level of influence for this episode within any circle of influence -- even limited to the characters on the show. What would that "hole" leave? There's really zero information here, and apparently very little to say about this mundane episode. While high-ratings are nice for the producers and advertisers, |popularity does not confer notability
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:N)