Deletion of James Kinsella (journalist and tech entrepreneur) (2nd nomination)

Comment: The previous AfD was closed with a very clear consensus of Keep.  Even if you discard Lapin's votes, you still had several other Keep votes, and good solid arguments for notability, wothout a single Delete vote.  This is a clear, deliberate, bad-faith violation of , you cannot claim that there is no evidence for notability when the prior AfD cited multiple reasons for notability.  As I pointed out in the previous AfD {{tq|If the article itself is factually correct, then the subject must be notable. Former Vice President at Microsoft, President of MSNBC.com, Chairman and CEO of World Online, Chairman and CEO of Interoute Communications, etc. Look, even if he was a figurehead (and I see no reason to assume this), simply holding those roles should have generated significant reliable sources about the subject. And I see that at least one of those companies, World Online, appears to have been involved in some sort of controversy around the time of the dot-com bust, which ought to have generated even more coverage and thus more RS. In addition to the sources already cited, it may be worth looking through the relevant articles on those other companies to see if they contain further good sources that mention Mr. Kinsella
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion (WP:BEFORE)

Comment: Clearly fails  as a strong  exercise
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:GNG||WP:PROMO)

Comment: Saying that somebody is notable because they were VP or CEO of a company is not a policy-based argument. Plenty of high up corporate executives are not notable. This article appears to be built upon a  to make the subject appear at a glance to be notable, but these sources do not cover the subject of this Wiki article in the level of depth that is required for GNG. I wonder if the people who said keep in the first nom looked closely at the sources or were fooled by the sheer number of them. &ndash;&nbsp
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Citation overkill (WP:CITEBOMB)

Comment: for reasons cited last month at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Kinsella (journalist and tech entrepreneur).  Notability is not transitory.  See #Notability is not temporary|Notability is not temporary
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:GNG)