Deletion of Jasmine Murray (2nd nomination)

Comment: or '''Redirect''' to season article.  Irrespective of showing in X Idol Pop Superstar or similar, could only be considered a notable artist if subsequently met the usic|music notability requirements.  A couple of (other peoples') songs sung at local events does not qualify
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Mediation (WP:M)

Comment: I think most Wikipedians (and most Americans) would place ''American Idol'' in a different category than other reality-type TV shows.  This is the Big Kahuna, not low-level shows  like ''American's Top 40 Wannabe Fat Losers'' or such nonsense.  The runner-ups often tour nationally even before and after they get knocked off the show, as happened in this case.  Precedent has been to keep some of the articles of the "losers" on ''American Idol'' because they pass  and , see ''e.g.'', Melissa Sgambelluri.  In this case, Murray performed five times on National TV, in at least three states, and continued her career, albeit at a lower level. Now, I'll be honest, I didn't pay attention to her and can't recall her, but I'm Mommie Dearest|not one of her fans
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:GNG||WP:MUSICBIO)