Deletion of Alexis Cohen (2nd nomination)

Comment: Per the already discussed  and other policies.  Fact remains she has significant coverage for two events.  My only concern is that her death isn't notable and was only in the news because she was on American Idol.  That said, she does barely meet.--v/r
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:GNG)

Comment: per  and . The "after death" coverage is about the indictment relating to the crime/accident that caused her death. That is simply routine follow-up news coverage relating to a previously reported crime. The person doesn't pass ,  and the untimely death and resulting indictment do not pass .--Special:Contributions/74.57.5.235|74.57.5.235
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:ONEEVENT||WP:NOTNEWS||WP:NMUSIC||WP:GNG||WP:EFFECT)

Comment: full disclosure, I am the same person as the above IP:74.57.5.235, just on a different IP, I'd rather not register so just to explain this is not sockpuppetry or a separate vote). The point is that this person's 15 minutes of fame were related to some rant as a failed American Idol candidate. That is the , and thus a separate article is not needed as there is nothing to say about the person outside of that American Idol (season 7) (and possibly season 8 for the other failed audition). The accidental death also had some coverage but it is purely ''accidental''. Had this accident occured 10 years from now, there would have been no wide coverage outside from routine local accident news. There is nothing encyclopedic to say about this person (she ranted on AI, she died in a hit-and-run). She had wide coverage for 15 minutes. So did Christina Desforges (look at the AfD for that one). It's a clear case of .--Special:Contributions/70.80.234.196|70.80.234.196
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:ONEEVENT||WP:NOTNEWS)

Comment: WP:ONEEVENT, the reliable coverage is essentially about the fact that she was an American Idol contestant, thus, she should have mention in the appropriate American Idol season article (a '''redirect''' would be acceptable), but not her own article per  as, AFAIK, she was not a finalist. The accidental death is |routine news coverage of accidental deaths. The article as it stands is nothing more than a couple of lines about her and her death, and lots of |puffing of the death coverage to try to make her appear more notable.--Special:Contributions/74.57.5.235|74.57.5.235
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:NMUSIC||WP:ROUTINE||WP:PUFF)

Comment: The coverage of her death resulted from her appearance on American Idol which still puts this in the ambit of . Had she not been on AI she wouldn't have gotten the range of obits. Counting AI as one event and her death as a second event subverts the intent of ONEEVENT. A non-notable person suddenly becomes notable upon death? No
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:ONEEVENT)

Comment: Borderline N, but for me this is beyond  and there is enough coverage for a valid article
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons (WP:BLP1E)