Deletion of List of winners of the Lenore Marshall Poetry Prize

Comment: just like the other sub-articles of Academy of American Poets. I really don't see how the nominator could say this award is "unnotable" when Academy of American Poets#Lenore Marshall Poetry Prize has 11 citations, and there's plenty of http://news.google.com/archivesearch?um=1&ned=us&hl=en&q=%22Lenore+Marshall+Poetry+Prize%22&cf=all coverage available on Google News. Explain to me how this article "fails" WP:N, in light of , , , and . If there's an official list, this information is surely verifiable. Nobody said Wikipedia ''was'' a mirror for the Academy of American Poets, and describing information available in a reliable source as a "mirror" is just strange. Along with that DGG said, when |any persion recieves this award, it could be considered evidence of notability
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Lists (WP:LIST||WP:CLN||WP:SS||WP:SIZE||WP:ANYBIO)

Comment: this is deletion for the sake of it, rather than for any real reason.  It's not delete because this is flawed information, or delete, because this is a terrible article, it's deletion of the worst kind.  It's, and with all due respect, it's deletion based on rules, and that's not what we do, and that's not the point of Wikipedia. This is a content dispute masquerading as a deletion debate. Please lern to find some blinkers which allow you to filter really bad articles from the not so great but pfah, who cares, it doesn't do any haem, it informs, and by gooly, that's the point of WIkipedia.  Show how deleting improves Wikipedia. Keeping it |improves Wikipedia because it informs people, and that's what we are here for
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Ignore all rules (WP:IAR)

Comment: reviewers are encouraged to examine any sources found in the article, as several continue to be added which are Wikipedia mirrors, non-, and press releases, none of which establish notability for the award nor contain any info on the award beyond what is in the lead (copied from Academy of American Poets) and the winner list which is already on the official website
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Reliable sources (WP:RS)