Deletion of List of ice hockey players considered the greatest of all time

Comment: for the exact same reasons as Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of association football players considered the greatest of all time. This is another  monstrosity
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:No original research (WP:SYNTH)

Comment: As it stands now, this is  and  and not much of a list anyway.  The sources are the particular ones that certain Wikipedia editors happened to find, but who is to say there isn't an expert somewhere who regards Maurice Richard as the greatest ever.  The number of experts in the list is particularly concerning as there is no objective basis for it - again, it just number of experts that certain Wikipedia editors happened to find.  There could be scope for an article about who has been considered the greatest of all time over time - and for right now I think the consensus as Clarityfiend states (and as the article actually supports) is that it would come from among Howe, Orr and Gretzky, but that is a sentence, not an article.  Tracing the emergence of the consensus greatest of all time over time could be a reasonable article - when did Howe gain consensus over the prior player or players considered, what happened before that, when did Orr join Howe on that pedestal, at least potentially, and then when did Gretzky.  But this isn't it
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:No original research (WP:SYNTH||WP:OR)

Comment: Lists of "something something something considered something something something" dont work on Wikipedia because they invariably apply undue weight by listing every minority opinion, because consensus never weeds out fringe opinions in these types of list.  However, per : {{tq|If a viewpoint is held by an extremely small minority, it does not belong on Wikipedia, regardless of whether it is true or you can prove it, except perhaps in some ancillary article.|q=y}} The list in theory could work. but just never will on Wikipedia
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Neutral point of view (WP:UNDUE)