Deletion of George W. Bush substance abuse controversy (2nd nomination)

Comment: Some people seem to want to adopt a new version of BLP that would say: "When a politician or other controversial figure is criticized, and the criticism receives significant media coverage, Wikipedia is nevertheless not allowed to include any mention of the criticism, even a factual report of what is said and by whom, unless Wikipedia editors in their genius conclude that the criticism is well founded and backed by sources that would pass the  test."  That's not our policy and most definitely should not be.  Reliable sourcing here consists of documenting that the criticism has been made.  If this is deleted, let's delete John Kerry military service controversy, which reports on criticisms that were directly contradicted by official records and by some of the critics' own prior statements
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Reliable sources (WP:RS)

Comment: as this page runs contrary to the spirit of  and . Wikipedia is not a place for tabloid journalism and scandal mongering. Articles and content about living people are expected to meet higher standards, as they may be construed as libel|libelous. This page does not have encyclopedic value and it only contains speculations and allegations of alcohol abuse, the substance of which has been captured in the George W. Bush|biography page
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Biographies of living persons (WP:BLP||WP:NPOV)