Deletion of Joel Scherban

Comment: per 
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:NCOLLATH)

Comment: I have mixed feelings. He doesn't meet  or the GNG. However, winning the annual award for being the best college hockey player in Canada seems to meet . I'd like to see what others think
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:NHOCKEY||WP:NCOLLATH)

Comment: CIS's Sullivan Trophy could clear COLLATH #1 if it were |reliably sourced, but it is not a notability freebie that exempts him from having to have any acceptable sources just because you can technically source the fact to a list of the award winners on CIS's own self-published website. "Notability because award" attaches to awards that ''get media coverage'', and not to awards that do not, especially given that even the CIS list just mentions his ''name'', and fails to say anything of substance ''about'' him. We do still have to be able to |verify everything ''else'' the article says about him too, so people are not exempted from having to clear GNG just because the article text has the ''word'' "award" in it
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Reliable sources (WP:RS||WP:V)

Comment: I believe that being the Canadian college hockey player of the year meets  criteria #1.  I might feel differently if it was a different sport, but hockey is a big deal in Canada (duh
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:NCOLLATH)

Comment: per .  As Djsasso says, this is the type of case that the specific notability guideline is supposed to simplify by avoiding the needs identify specific instances of coverage meeting GNG where there is consensus that the subject meets criteria that would cause it to meet GNG.  There is also an argument above to ignore the primary source that he meets NCOLLATH.  This is a misreading - all we need in this case is a reliable source and primary sources can be reliable.  But regardless I did find a reliable secondary source from the https://www.newspapers.com/clip/36105766/edm_journal_scherban/ Edmonton Journal
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:NCOLLATH)

Comment: Meets . Winning this would undoubtedly been covered in newspapers and not just primary sources, the most minor of hockey awards even at the college level in Canada end up with news blurbs. Unfortunately it was 15 years ago so finding internet based sources will be harder so going to newspaper archives may be required. This is precisely the type of article that is supposed to benefit from the help of NSPORTS
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:NCOLLATH)