Deletion of List of 2012 murders in the United States

Comment: per 
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates (WP:NOTDUP)

Comment: per . This list contains notable entries on a notable topic. The list could be expanded into a table giving more details (body count, location, etc). Yes, there is a category, but this is an aid to navigation too. Note that the nominator hasn't cited any '''policy''' that this list violates, or indeed explained what "an odd one out" means and how it is relevant
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates (WP:CLN)

Comment: per . This is better served by a category
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Categories, lists, and navigation templates (WP:DOAL)

Comment: Article needs improvement, but it surely satisfies . &nbsp;—&nbsp
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Manual of Style (WP:LISTPURP)

Comment: satisfies  as a navigational list of article topics, as a complement to :Category:2012 murders in the United States per . I see no substantive deletion arguments here, and so nothing that would override any of that
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Manual of Style (WP:LISTPURP||WP:CLN)