Deletion of American Nihilist Underground Society (5th nomination)

Comment: In a previous AfD my opinion was to keep thinking that it met criterion 1 of . I'm no longer convinced in meets that criterion. In particular, none of the mentions are non-trivial and the summary of all the details is drawn by synthesizing disparate details from a variety of sources. While one could argue that it meets the second criterion of  but a glance shows that the relevant Houston award is not sufficiently notable for that purpose. I would strongly suggest that the page be userfied until someone can come up with better sourcing(not all the sources used meet ) and a demonstration of notability occurs. If nothing else, I won't mind having a version userfied to my userspace if no one else wants to take it
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:WEB||WP:WEB||WP:V)

Comment: ANUS seems to meet  (I realize it is a guideline not a policy) which is important since ANUS is more than just a website and a heavy metal FAQ
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:ORG)

Comment: mentioned by name numerous times in the media including MTV, Village Voice and YAHOO! News. The article as it stands is well referenced, completely verifiable, and probably the best sourced stub on wikipedia. It clearly passes , , , and . I would in fact deem this the PERFECT EXAMPLE of what a stub on wikipedia should be. Just because you dont like the subject matter is not a valid deletion grounds, many people hate George W. Bush but if we deleted on the grounds people dislike him where the hell would we be as an encyclopedia? A "vote" here for deletion is a "vote" for censorship and bowdlerism on wikipedia. &nbsp
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Verifiability (WP:V||WP:RS||WP:WEB||WP:NPOV)

Comment: Per redone article, redone sourcing. Articles can and do reach permanent notability standards. Arguments that no articles can/should be permanent are straw men. Notable troll organization covered by a stunning array of mainstream and independent media sources. This is and should be the final XfD on this. Keep/close per . Future noms should also close as hasty keeps. s
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Snowball clause (WP:SNOW||WP:BALL)

Comment: Why would we delete organization Y because organization X was deleted? We don't do that to bands or schools either.  This one seems to meet  criterion #2: ''The website or content has won a notable independent award from either a publication or organization.'' Houston Press http://www.houstonpress.com/bestof/award.php?oid=oid:198232
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:WEB)

Comment: I appreciate how you claim the article is not yet verified, because 1/13 references is the GNAA. Let's define ":wiktionary|trivial" per Wiktionary: ''Of little significance or value'', or per Trivial|Wikipedia: ''Trivia are unimportant (or "trivial") items, especially of information''. How is a http://www.metalcrypt.com/pages/interviewsframe.php?intid=143 long interview on a website with http://www.alexa.org/data/details/traffic_details?url=metalcrypt.com 0.8% reach "trivial"? How is a Houston Press http://www.houstonpress.com/bestof/award.php?oid=oid:198232 web page entirely dedicated to this organization "trivial"? This article meets ,  (#1) and  (#1
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Verifiability (WP:V||WP:WEB||WP:ORG)

Comment: so 2 AFDs go by and I as a major editor of this article receive no notifications on my talk about it? I know you don't have to tell people about your AFDs but it is courtesy. Regardless the ANUS article meets the notability and reliable sources requirements. For  it is verifiable as per  and  (multiple news sources) and it has won a non-trivial award. Thus ANUS passes criteria 1 & 3 of  (you only need to pass 1 of the 3). ANUS is not just a website and do in real life trolls like slayer day and various postering campaigns. They have multiple media mentions in magazines such as Wired, in Houston newspapers and on MTV news
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:WEB||WP:RS||WP:V||WP:WEB)