Deletion of Kris Harvey (2nd nomination)

Comment: Clearly fails . I also don't think that the usual reporting of transactions for minor league players shows the GNG is met. While I see nothing to convince me he should have his own article. However, a redirect to his father's article would be OK with me
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:NBASEBALL)

Comment: It's true that GNG trumps SNG, but it's not clear to me that GNG is met. Rlendog's articles are local coverage.  For example, the first one mentioned is on the first day of the ACC tournament and is right next to a similar article on the starting pitcher for South Carolina.  Not a minor league transaction but typical coverage for local sports teams. The second article mentioned is coverage about him having a choice now that he's graduating from high school (college or pro ball) and that he has the guidance of his father, a former major leaguer.  The third article is another North Carolina paper article about him being part of the family business of playing pro ball.  I don't think this coverage is enough to meet GNG.  Much of it projects him on the same career track as his father and thus is .  The fact that he never went higher than AA in 8 season is why we actually need accomplishments not local paper routine coverage, puffery, and expectations.  I'd be inclined to redirect this article to the one on his father since I think the GNG argument is weak and much of the coverage is linked to his father
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not (WP:CRYSTALBALL)

Comment: Satisfies  as per the first AFD. Here is a relevant Quote: Wikipedia:Village_pump_(idea_lab)#Idea:_Before_saving_changes,_Wikipedia_software_checks_for_basic_fixes.|this comment from Dodger67 about subject-specific notability guidelines: {{tq|an SNG can never be used to ''exclude'' a subject that meets GNG. An SNG is by definition meant to (temporarily) lower the bar for subjects for which proving GNG compliance is difficult
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:GNG)