Deletion of Ashkenazi Jewish intelligence (2nd nomination)

Comment: This may be a bit of wikilawyering, but I feel it ought to be said that  is a guideline, whereas POV and / are policies
Stance: comment
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:N||WP:NPOV||WP:SYNTH||WP:OR)

Comment: per . The page creator appears to have taken a premise and cobbled together "facts" to support it. Some "key" points are dubious or unsourced. Not to mention that the whole topic smacks of racism
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:No original research (WP:SYNTH)

Comment: per  and 
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Fringe theories (WP:FRINGE||WP:SYNTH)

Comment: I agree with Grayfell, and also think that  and  applies. If we're going to have an article about this, it should follow the clear scientific consensus that race and intelligence are completely independent of each other, and that (pretty much without exception) arguments to the opposite are just racism wearing a pseudo-science mask. I'd also point out the last few Keep votes in rapid-fire succession look a bit suspicious and -y to me. Plus they have completely ignored the above points about it not being a delete for notability, but rather for FRINGE, SYNTH and NPOV
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Fringe theories (WP:FRINGE||WP:SYNTH||WP:SOCK)

Comment: Then createprotect it (and Ashkenazi intelligence) so only an extended confirmed user can remake the page. This is per the reasonings laid out by {{u|ජපස|jps}}. No editor should be expected to reformat such degrading  content in order to make this page at least passingly acceptable. This is one of those few and rare cases that starting from scratch () would be a lot easier than working with existing material. I struggle to find even a single ''sentence'' worth maintaining in its current form. It's all vague pseudoscience talking about average IQs as if they are the end-all-be-all of intelligence. It also focuses way too much on Ashkenazim who live in the United States despite half of the Ashkenazi Jewish population living elsewhere.It's time to toss this article in the bin. &#8211
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Neutral point of view (WP:POV||WP:TNT)

Comment: A lot of reasons for this. For one, it was mainly a coatrack for promoting a single very  theory by Henry Harpending (a eugenicist with ties to white supremacist groups) and Gregory Cochran (who's otherwise known for proposing that homosexuality is caused by an unknown virus).  We also have appearances by Richard Lynn, Charles Murray (political scientist), and J. Philippe Rushton which should ring a lot of alarm bells. My attempts at cleaning this up prompted some of the recent activity. The ''topic'' may or may not be notable, but the article isn't doing the topic any justice. If the article only exists to explain why a debunked study is not even wrong, then is should be rewritten to serve that goal. Any explanation of this larger topic would also have to start fresh, and would have to be based on high quality sources, similar to restrictions placed on race and intelligence
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Fringe theories (WP:FRINGE)

Comment: The extensive number of previous nominations indicates that a further nomination will not be productive – see  which states that "''It can be disruptive to repeatedly nominate a page in the hope of getting a different outcome.''"  The topic is clearly notable.  For example, see ''https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=rvaFyvcARUAC Smart Jews: The Construction of the Image of Jewish Superior Intelligence'' which was written by a Sander Gilman|distinguished professor and published by a university press.  The rest is then a matter of ordinary editing and so our |editing policy applies, especially the bits about |imperfection and the need to |preserve the content
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Deletion policy (WP:DELAFD||WP:EDIT||WP:IMPERFECT||WP:PRESERVE)

Comment: per , having no article would be better than having this crap
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Blow it up and start over (WP:TNT)