Deletion of After 12,000 Years

Comment: Mercurywoodrose's link to a work that "says the novel is important" is to Coblentz's autobiography; it's probably not surprising that he himself thought it important. In addition, the Google Books search suggested by MWR actually garners only 74 hits, among which I don't see anything that looks like significant coverage (the relevant page of Ashley's ''The Gernsback Days'' is not included in the preview I get, so I'm going by the search-result snippet). In the absence of evidence that the book meets any of the criteria of , "delete" is the only recommendation I can make, but I'm willing to consider any other evidence that may be offered
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:BK)

Comment: per 
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:NB)

Comment: Of the references already cited, ''333'' by Crawford et al contains descriptions of novels which are "generally considered the best efforts in Science-Fantasy up to and including 1950" which would indicate some notability.  Lloyd Eshbach in his book ''Over My Shoulder'' lists it as one of the stronger titles issued by FPCI.  ISFDB has references to three reviews, two of which are signed.  While I don't have access to these reviews, their existence as well as the the inclusion in ''333'' would satisfy criteria 1 of .  I will add the Eshbach quote and cite the reviews in the article
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:BK)