Deletion of List of objects in Pirates of the Caribbean

Comment: per 
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Manual of Style (WP:TRIVIA)

Comment: Duplication of a licensed guide, spiced with personal observation.  is still significant coverage in multiple reliable, independent sources, and this strictly fails the "multiple" and "independent" parts. We already have all of this plot summary in the movie articles as well; we don't need it duplicated here
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:N)

Comment: The unusual juxtaposition of plot tidbits, focusing around objects, seems to be approaching |original research to me, even if we could pare down the article to the well-written and well-sourced material.  More imporatantly, it's not clear to me why anyone would be interested in the information on this page in the format it is in.  Plot summaries on the pages of the appropriate movies seem the way to go--and then, if there is enough page to justify splitting off one particular object or two, then split off those objects--but having different (unrelated) objects together on the same page seems kinda absurd to me.  I also agree with A Man in Black's comments that we need to consider the notability guideline here--and I don't know of any source that talks about the objects from these movies as some sort of coherent entity--and I think that would be necessary in order to justify having a page on this topic
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:No original research (WP:OR)

Comment: This is not |listcruft, and it is a very good addendum to the Pirates of the Caribbean article. --'''&nbsp;Blanchardb'''&nbsp
Stance: keep
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Listcruft (WP:LISTCRUFT)

Comment: I wish to move away from the non-encyclopedic argument (which I would argue it is)to the fact that it doesn't meet . Individual items/props from notable films do not inherit the notability of their film, if they did we would have Darth Vadar's Mask, List of objects in Star Wars, List of objects in the Wizard of Oz, etc., which would be impossible to maintain
Stance: delete
Cited policy: Wikipedia:Notability (WP:N)