Question: Who said that Where Have You Been was rave-tastic?
About the article "Where Have You Been", section "Critical reception".

Candidate passages:
"Where Have You Been" garnered positive reviews from music critics.
Andy Kellman for Allmusic wrote that "Where Have You Been", along with the album's lead single "We Found Love", serve as "Talk That Talk"s "place-holding" dance tracks.
Greg Kot for the "Chicago Tribune" compared "Where Have You Been" and "We Found Love" for being "rave-tastic."
Aside from noting the similarities between the two songs, Randell Roberts for "Los Angeles Times" wrote that neither song would sound out of place at an Electric Daisy Carnival.
Julianne Escobedo Shepherd for "Spin" also wrote that the song was a perfect play for a festival, writing Where Have You Been' is tailor-made for a Coachella pool rave."
Jon Caramanica for "The New York Times" was complimentary of both songs, but wrote that "Where Have You Been" "is even better."
Mark Graham for VH1 compared the song to one of Rihanna's previous singles from her 2007 album "Good Girl Gone Bad", "Don't Stop the Music", writing Where Have You Been will almost certainly be Rihanna's biggest club smash since 'Don't Stop the Music'.
"Robert Copsey for Digital Spy shared the same opinion as Graham, writing "We labelled 'Where Have You Been' the record's 'Don't Stop The Music'."
He continued to give an explanation as to why the songs are similar writing "On the surface, similarities between the two are almost non-existent, but on closer inspection, not only are they the danciest cuts on their respective LPs, they're both favourites that fans have been eager to see get an official release."
Copsey concluded his review praising the song and Rihanna, writing "Like Rihanna herself, it's hectic, confident and unashamedly sexual."
Meghan Brownfield for the "Columbia Missourian" praised the song as a track which people will want to dance to as well as writing that the lyrics ensure that the listener pays attention to the lyrics, saying "It is a song you would hear in a club that everyone would want to dance to.
This song makes you want to move, and it also has some strong lyrics that make you focus on what she is saying."
Matthew Cole for Slant Magazine, however, was critical of the song, writing that the song is a "boring dubstep-normalizing dance number reminiscent of LMFAO," as well as Rihanna's own "We Found Love".
"Put Your Hands Up (If You Feel Love)" was performed as last song on the set list before the encores in all the legs of Minogue's Aphrodite World Tour.
A live version of this song recorded at the The London O2 Arena was released in the single's first digital bundle.
There is no official music video for the song, although a video of the song's lyrics was uploaded to Minogue's website on 22 March 2011.
It uses the Pete Hammond remix of the song, and was accompanied by the following message: "Thank you all for making 'Aphrodite: Les Folies' such an amazing experience for me.
Those of you who have been to a show will know that 'Put Your Hands Up' goes "off"!
So as a tour thank you I wanted to share this 80′s-tastic remix by the legendary Pete Hammond.
Enjoy!!".
The song was further promoted by inclusion on various compilation albums including "Now: The Hits Of Spring 2011". 
Rave debuted in Ring of Honor in 2003.
He later became a member of The Embassy, a stable led by Prince Nana, and was nicknamed "The Crown Jewel of the Embassy".
Rave has gained notoriety for having received excessive heel heat from ROH fans.
In ROH it was common for fans to throw streamers over the wrestlers they support.
Rave, however, had become a sort of cult recipient as fans threw rolls of toilet paper at him instead.
ROH announced on November 6, 2006, that the throwing of toilet paper had been banned from all ROH shows after Jimmy Rave tried to attack a fan who threw a roll at him after his match.
Rave developed a habit of stealing other wrestlers finishers and claiming them as his own.
An example would be when he began to use the "Rave Clash" (a copy of Styles' own "Styles Clash"), and said he invented it and A.J.
Styles stole it from him.
After losing a match to Styles in ROH where the stipulation was the loser could no longer use the Rave/Styles Clash, Rave began to use the Greetings From Ghana (a copy of Triple H's "Pedigree") as a finisher and would again claim that he had in fact invented that move too.
On January 14, 2006 in Philadelphia, Rave and Alex Shelley of The Embassy attacked ROH World Champion Bryan Danielson after a successful title defense.
At "Tag Wars 2006", Rave, along with Shelley and Abyss, won the 2006 Trios Tournament.
Rave used his title shot earned at the Tag Wars 2006, but came up short in his match with Danielson at the "Fourth Anniversary Show".
In 2006, Rave had sporadically been tagging with Alex Shelley in search of the ROH Tag Team Titles, but after Shelley left the company in mid-year, Rave returned to singles action briefly.
He found himself on the losing side of several encounters with Davey Richards.
Soon Nana brought in a new tag partner, Sal Rinauro, and the two began working through the tag ranks.
In September 2006, Prince Nana announced his departure from Ring of Honor, ending The Embassy.
Jimmy Rave would then go on a losing streak, until he scored a major upset by pinning ROH World Championship number one contender Homicide.
The rest of the year and the early part of 2008, Rave feuded with Nigel McGuinness, culminating in a match on March 4, 2008, in Liverpool, England, where McGuinness finally managed to pin Rave in a "Fight Without Honor" to end the rivalry.
Following the match, Rave was temporarily sidelined from in-ring action due to a broken jaw.
In storyline the injury was credited with McGuinness hitting him with a lariat, but in reality Rave had broken his jaw a month earlier in a match against Samoa Joe.
During his recuperation Rave was prescribed with pain medication, which later led to an addiction.
On May 22, 2007 it was announced that Rave had signed a contract with Ring of Honor.
On August 2, 2007, however, it was announced that Rave had left both Ring of Honor and Full Impact Pro. 
All of the seventeen songs were recorded during the sessions for "I'm with You".
"Long Progression", the b-side to "Strange Man" which was the first single released, almost made the album's final cut but was left off in favor of "Goodbye Hooray".
One of the songs, "In Love, Dying" is an eight-minute rocker captured in a single studio take that occupies both sides of a single, as Klinghoffer told Rolling Stone from a recent tour stop in Berne, Switzerland.
“We’re going to have to do that old trick where it fades out and fades back in on the B-side.” Another cut, “Victorian Machinery” “sounds like a big three-headed monster playing drums,” Klinghoffer said, adding that the band captured “absolute magic” with “Never Is a Long Time,” a “pop-tastic” number featuring Greg Kurstin on piano.
“It’s really one of those cases where they had too many good songs to fit on an album.
They have this cohesive thing in the studio – when they get that take, that’s the take that they keep.”“It’s always difficult, but we use a democratic process and the songs with the most votes are usually the backbone of the album,” producer Rick Rubin wrote in an email.
“I can just say as is always the case, some of my personal favorites don’t make the cut.
I’m sure everyone in the band can tell you the same.”Klinghoffer said that they recorded 48 songs during the album's sessions and some could eventually see the light of day.
“It’s possible,” Klinghoffer said.
“We just had so much material back then that certain things just straight-up didn’t get enough attention.
There’s a couple that will probably just remain in our iPods.” 
Lance Hoyt and Jimmy Rave made their debut as a team at No Surrender in the tag team gauntlet.
On the following episode of iMPACT!
Hoyt and Rave, accompanied by Christy Hemme (Hoyt's on screen girlfriend at the time), made their impact debut as a team.
They wrestled regularly but continued losing.
Hemme quickly grew tired of the losses and began complaining.
The rift within the team continued to develop until Hemme claimed during an interview segment that she heard Rave call her a "red snapper".
Rave insisted he was talking about fishing but Hemme thought otherwise telling Hoyt to "make him get lost", to which Hoyt said "Jimmy's my boy, and you're gonna have to deal with it."
Hemme replied by saying "Your getting nothing tonight, NOTHING!".
It was during this interview that Rave first referred to the team of himself and Hoyt as "The Rock 'n' Rave Infection", which initially provoked an annoyed response from Hemme.
There have been no problems with the trio since Rave and Rock accompanied Hemme to a match against Awesome Kong.
On the November 15, 2007 episode of iMPACT!
the team scored their first major victory by upsetting LAX with help from Hemme, who was attacked after the match by a member of the "Latino Nation".
Hoyt and Rave began feuding with LAX and Hemme continued to be harassed or attacked by the masked member of LAX.
Hemme threatened to sue (kayfabe) TNA Management for male on female harassment.