Voting is done by the league's six head baseball coaches.
Simply put, Lillash had a monstrous offensive year. Andrzejak won six games for Detroit and led the league with seven complete games and two shutouts, finishing second in the league with 67 strikeouts. Augustine and Dee were honored by their peers, after their squads tied for the 2000 regular-season championship. This is the second consecutive year Dee has received this honor. Total Sports and the Midwestern Collegiate Conference.