The amendment as written fails to answer many questions. One certain consequence, opponents say, will be to inject uncertainty into the criminal justice system. An amendment will undermine the traditional distinction between criminal and civil law. The people are served by criminal law. If adjustments for victims are needed, legislation is more appropriate than tinkering with the nation's fundamental charter, opponents say.
States are very responsive to victims.
In a rare expression of public opinion, Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist also voiced his concerns about the proposed amendment. According to Sen. Kyl, the Victims' Rights Amendment will be presented to the full Senate floor in the next session, before the election. Most proposed amendments fail. Some pass quickly. Others take time.