The teller rarely can see both sides and repeats the story to those who will encourage one-sidedness. That's just human nature. Secondly, the targets often seem to be professionals whose code of ethics prevents revealing information about the accuser's stability, reliability, etc. The facts and standards in many professions are not clearly understood by laymen, so their decisions can easily be misunderstood. I know of no teachers, doctors, veterinarians, plumbers, etc.
Some decisions are wrong, and some are right.
Many cannot be totally explained in this venue. Rarely is each side fairly and honestly treated. Finally, a person's reputation is of inestimable value and can be ruined by public hearings of things that should be private. I hope you will decide it's not just controversial, but may result in meanness and hurt. It is not beneficial to the individuals or to a sense of community.