We divide them across the class. Each of you will read 4 papers. After reading them, you will fill out a review form for each paper assigned to you, and send them to me by email by Dec. 9, midnight. I'll rank the papers on their collective scores, tabulate the results and reports, and we discuss the top papers in class. The area for specific comments is the space where you can identify specific strenghts and weaknesses of the paper.
Some people write long reviews, some write short ones.
I therefore think we should reject this paper. Please, if you have any comments about the process and review forms, send me email or raise them in class. I strongly encourage everyone to submit their project paper, even if your project is not completely finished yet, or your paper is not as strong as you wish it would be. Second, you will not be the only one who has an unfinished project. Four, submitting is required if you want a passing grade for 6.853.