Your picture appears much more finished than when I've seen it for first time. I'm Glad to read that you admit it is an old project, but also that you worked it specially for this round. The reason is, in my opinion, b'cos there is too many contrast between the realistic parts and the photo-textures, which detracts a bit on the artistic impression. The feel of a building is good, but the stonework has obvious repetitions. Much credibility in the whole scene.
Sharp shadows are incompatible with a fire.
Shadows could be softer. I do like it, except the fire. It doesn't exactly look natural, but hey, I wouldn't have known how to do it in POV, so I'll give you some credit. Hallam Oaks Pty.