It gives them what they need. Selection boards can operate with narrative alone, we don t need to have any restrictions on the box checks. We know conclusively that without box checks the system inflates almost immediately. The inflation also affects the narrative. We know from survey evidence from two inflated periods in our recent history that boards cannot select with confidence on narrative alone.
Serious inflation randomizes the selection process as well.
This is disastrous when making the tough cuts, especially command and school selections. There is also conclusive evidence from sister services that restrictions are necessary. The current OER inhibits counseling in the field. Evidence from history shows that the greatest motivator for counseling is leadership setting the example and demanding that subordinates counsel. In the past when the leadership pressured, counseling increased.