Trace the people in groups. Several families may have moved together. Check land records - many times they are more accurate. Everyone had to pay taxes after the age of 16. Check tax records.
Wills are a good source of information because they often list names of the family.
Check church and parish records. Sometimes they survived better. Check their indexes to see what has been done. The Census is quite complete. Then use tax, land, marriage, court, cemetery, and church records.