It's weird, you can catch one to 10 fish one day, I've heard of more even, then you can go to the same spot and you may go four or five trips without one. The key is covering water and casting, and casting, and casting until a fish in the mood is found. Minnow imitating plugs are best. Cast J13, J11 and J9 jointed Rapalas and Shad Raps in size 8 with perch patterns, black and silver, or fire tigers. Because water is low this year, it is possible to use lighter tackle because most line-snapping brush and logs are above waterline.
Water levels are low because a crack in the dam is being repaired.
Mornings and evenings are a little more productive, but not a lot. Normally the North Fork Bay holds bigger fish but fewer, this year south Fork Bay seems to be holding bigger fish. Tiger muskie fishing is dangerous, and not strictly because of the teeth. The infrequency of strikes and titanic size of these fish make hooking one electrifying, and it is difficult thereafter to get excited about probing streams for trout. When a tiger is tired at boatside, and opens that great toothy mouth, it's important to have a leather glove and long pointy needlenose pliers.