Later, after subduing Tingle and tying her wrists to the headboard, the students give their captive food and drink, treating her with a degree of respect. Leigh Ann has a bout of conscience, feeling badly for a decent woman who will be devastated if they hatch a particular scheme to blackmail Tingle. Leigh Ann creates a weathered journal based on the diary of a girl burned at the stake for witchcraft. Sadly, viewers know that this character's husband has been having an ongoing affair with Mrs. Tingle. Later, Leigh Ann heeds that advice and throws herself at Luke, tearing off her clothes as well as his.
Sex is implied as the two are shown the next morning wearing nothing but a blanket.
Luke volunteers to get naked and pose in bed beside Mrs. Tingle for photos to be used to blackmail her. Also, scattered references to sexual situations, including bondage. Cat-fights between Tingle and the girls involve clawing and choking. People are threatened with a crossbow. Luke suggests burning up the teacher in a house fire.