Manuscripts prepared in accord with these considerations have a greater likelihood of eventual publication. The quality of the writing, from the standpoints of usage, grammar and spelling, is acceptable. The motivation and purpose of the paper are clearly developed. Antecedent work is appropriately reviewed and integrated. The originality and significance of the work is clearly stated.
Superfluous content is minimal.
Apparatus and procedures employed are clearly and completely described. Data and results are completely and objectively presented, i.e., sufficient for interpretation by the reader. Significant results are appropriately emphasized. Limitations of the results are shown. Discussion of the results clearly relates to the problem, as stated earlier in the paper.