We want this list to be a meaningful alternative to the plethora of shallow, superficial information on Wicca that is so prevalent both on the net and in popular books. That doesn't mean that newcomers are not allowed to subscribe, but those who already have a certain amount of experience with the Craft will probably get more out of it. If you are completely new to Wicca, it would be a good idea doing some reading first. In terms of Internet resources, StarFire Rising and the Covenant of Gaia site are good places to start. This list is definitely not a forum for trashing other people's traditions or beliefs.
Strong opinions are fine, but civility and respect for others are mandatory.
If you disagree with someone else's position, criticize that position, not the person holding it, or his or her coven, tradition or organization. Persistent disrespect for others will get you unsubscribed very quickly. Joining the list purely for the purpose of attacking Wicca or proselytizing for another religion will get you unsubscribed immediately. This list very strongly encourages thoughtful, well-informed criticism of current trends and problems, within the pagan community and elsewhere, and anyone who is likely to be offended by that should probably not join. I would like, however, to remind people that criticism should be expressed constructively to the greatest extent possible.