The featured celebrity panel then asks the three contestants questions, in hopes of trying to determine which one is telling the truth and which two are lying. Following the question session, each panelist has to vote for the contestant he thinks really is the person described in the affidavit.
Wrong guesses are worth money to all three contestants, who split the winnings equally.
As a new feature, the audience will also participate in the game by guessing which contestant is telling the truth. They will be polled electronically at the conclusion of each round. The program was also seen in daytime on CBS from June 1962 to September 1968. Regularly featured panelists included Polly Bergen, Kitty Carlisle, Ralph Bellamy, Tom Poston, Orson Bean and Peggy Cass. Other featured panelists included Johnny Carson, Bill Cullen and Don Ameche.