This is by no means an attempt to call a stop to the debate that has arisen from the demand for reviews.
Unsolicited reviews can evolve into private vendettas.
I don't much like the talk of elitism. This is a very restricted number of people and perhaps as many as half of them are not on e-mail, but there is nothing elitist about it. Right from the start I was pleased to see how many others joined us and have participated. Discussion lists for ancient history, classics, late antiquity and so forth already exist. Those who have joined PAPY must already be aware of the importance of papyrology, so it would be preaching to the converted.