Make sure your waitress understands what you are saying since some come from Eastern Europe and English is not their native language. End of note. This is my favorite. The food is excellent although the menu hardly ever changes. The wine selection is very good.
Service is always excellent and the place can be noisy as hell.
Don't sit at a table by the bar unless you love noise drumming on your ears and you enjoy shouting at your table mates. Still my favorite place and the best on the Island. The deserts are superb. It is interesting to me that the prices are more reasonable than most restaurants in Nantucket. If noise bothers you ask for a table in the back.