My reasons are strong and are supported with details. My reasons are in a clear order of importance. The conclusion sums up the important points. There are almost no mistakes in capitalization, punctuation, or spelling. The introduction could be more interesting.
Some reasons are vague or unclear.
Some need more details. In places, the writing doesn't sound like me. My reasons are not in a clear order of importance. The conclusion doesn't sum up the important points. Mistakes make the story confusing in some places.