The criteria common to all of our awards. You may also pick up the award image here if you wish. One thing that I do NOT recommend is to inform your winners about any negatives or give them ay criticism. I know from personal experience that these kinds of comments detract from the thrill of winning an award. I prefer to just tell my winners the good news and leave it at that.
Some sites use a scoring system to figure out who has won the award.
In those instance, I would also recommend that this score NOT be shared with anyone - again, no need to take anything away from your winners victory. That, in a nutshell, is a method which is useful for handling your winners.