That's where I lived, Gardner 3rd West. And we had a bookcase, and a huge window, and better bathrooms, and two closets and two sets of drawers. Really, both dorms are great and everyone loves where they are, but Gardner does have nicer rooms. For the guys, there is Mabee dorm and McKenzie. Mabee is bigger, and I'd say probably the better dorm, but McKenzie is right in the middle of campus, and really cool if you plan on waking up 2 min. before class.
Sophomore year is all different.
For the girls, there's 4 dorms to choose between. The most popular is probably Sikes. McDonald is an option for girls wishing to live by themselves. And Smith-Adams is where I live. It's the closest thing on campus to a co-ed dorm.