Good 'n' grapey. A first-class effort. Driven three times with consistent results. Best after 2004. I think the point of wine criticism is to give the critic an excuse to drink 12 different wines in a sitting.
Taste is inherently subjective.
May I also say that taste in critisism is inherently subjective. I found your critisism massive, unctuous, heady, with hints of asphalt and pencil lead. A first-class effort. The second - most wine critisism is formulaic. The third - I would like to be in a position where I am given 12 different wines to consume in a sitting.