They were using their expertise to analyze and criticize Tiger's swing changes. They called him too mechanical and said his swing was too short. I think the world of Player and respect his nine major championships and countless other victories. I admire Burke, his two majors, and the fact that he is one of the most interesting men in all of golf. But I can't imagine what they were thinking when they made those comments.
Tiger has the best swing in the game today, maybe the best of all time.
There is not a flaw that I can see. The reason he can hit it so high and far is that he has perfect fundamentals. He is in the position to swing hard when he needs to and not worry about whether the ball is going off-line. When his putter is working, he becomes almost impossible to beat. And, don't think Tiger doesn't read the things that are written about him.