The personal lives of Nicholas Earp's sons were extremely tangled and unconventional. Their marital complications were such as to lend credence even to malicious gossip about them. Some of the stories about Wyatt and his brothers reflect interfamily quarrels. Similarly, the local differences of opinion about Wyatt's authentic birthplace reflect, in part, disputes among relatives. The situation does not lend itself to dispassionate analysis.
Some local residents yearn for authentic national heroes.
They believe that Wyatt Earp is one who should be honored by his home town. Others believe that the reputation of the Earps should be exploited for tourist dollars. In short, there are valid reasons for individuals to be concerned about where Wyatt was born. This article should not discourage anyone from participating in activities or supporting institutions honoring Wyatt Earp. That is a matter of personal choice.