Giovanni Cimabue, Madonna Enthroned with Angels and Prophets , c. 1285. Raphael, The Small Cowper Madonna , c.1505. These two paintings depict similar subjects. Explain your choice, comparing and contrasting the two images.
Students have two tasks.
They are NOT required to identify either work, nor are they required to give dates for either work . Students may discuss the possible influences of the works of Leonardo and Michelangelo on Raphael's composition versus the influence of Byzantine icons and mosaics on the Cimabue. The naturalism of the figures in the Raphael might be contrasted with the severity of design and expression in the Cimabue. The major task is to clearly differentiate between the Late Gothic and High Renaissance periods through a stylistic analysis of the works shown. Compares or contrasts at least 3 distinct elements that support the choice.