Sports banners and framed drama production posters lining the gym walls and entry hallways are daily reminders of the traditions of Rutherford High School. Each spring inductees into the National Honor Society sign their names in a register dating back to 1922, when the school chapter was first started. One of the year's highlights is the presentation of the Distinguished Graduate Award. The honoree returns to the school to speak to students about his or her accomplishments. Career diplomat and ambassador Thomas H. Pickering and presidential speech writer Peggy Noonan have both been honored as part of this tradition.
Students also serve as guides for reunion classes.
A rigorous core curriculum provides students with the basis for success. SAT scores are above the state and national averages. These results far exceed state and district factor group results. Students in the Class of 1999 took 49 Advanced Placement examinations. Students must successfully complete 120 credits in order to graduate.