Dolly Varden char, kokanee, cutthroat and rainbow trout are resident in Muchalat Lake. Prospect Lake is regularily stocked with rainbow and cutthroat trout and provides good smallmouth bass fishery. Cutthroat are reported to sizes of up to 5 lbs. This small lake was recently stocked with 1000 cutthroat trout and provides an excellent fishery for both the cutthroat and Dolly Varden char. Rainbow trout are the game fish in Silver Lake.
Spectacle Lake holds the islands only eastern brook trout population.
This species is a member of the char family. During spawning the brook trout turns a brilliant colour and is easily caught. Large rainbow trout and cutthroat trout can be found here. Trolling with baitfish imitations will produce positive results. The best time of year to visit the lake is in the spring and fall.