But our follow-up interviews with two of her key sources call her facts and conclusions into question. Whitehead's main source is social scientist Douglas Kirby. But Kirby, like Wilson, believes the Atlantic author misrepresented his work. However, her claim that sex education in general has failed is incorrect, and is based on a selective citing of the evidence. In fact, sex education programs can and do make a difference, as Whitehead knows from research of mine that she ignored in her Atlantic piece.
Some programs also help delay the onset of intercourse and reduce the number of sexual partners.
The programs that work are based upon established theories proven effective in other risk-taking areas, such as substance abuse. They provide accurate information in ways that allow students to personalize and retain it. For example, a class might examine lines people use to get someone to have sex, and then suggest responses to them. But they are a start. Inaccurate critiques such as Whitehead's only delay further progress.