The Commission recognizes the need for public support of the arts and understands the responsibilities that accompany the allocation of public funds. Members of the Commission and the staff may not use their positions to influence decisions or actions that will financially benefit themselves or an organization with which they have a monetary or policy-making interest. Commission members and review panelists must disclose any organizational affiliations and refrain from participating in discussion and voting on proposals related to individuals or organizations with which they have an affiliation. The Commission convenes independent professional peer review panels to review applications. Panel composition varies according to the disciplines being reviewed.
Slight variations exist in the evaluation criteria depending on the grant program.
A panel evaluates each application based on artistic quality, integrity, and community involvement. For organizations, management is an additional criterion. Individuals and organizations are encouraged to attend these public meetings to gain a better understanding of how the panel process works. All promotional materials must acknowledge that This project is funded, in part, by the Idaho Commission on the Arts and the National Endowment for the Arts. The Commission features the work of recipients in its publications, displays, and Web site.