Sadly the end result was, at best, a decent overall production. While there were some wonderful performances scattered throughout the cast, the production had one major obstacle that they could not be overcome, singing.
Musicals require superb vocals, no way around that.
That one key element is what separates a musical from a play. The Pegasus Cowboys is severely crippled with extremely weak singers, with the exception of maybe two performers. Finally, there was no solid diction in some of the numbers. I'm sure there were some laughable lyrics, but so many were lost in the muffled and swallowing of words and phrases. While some performers looked stiff and uncomfortable in their dancing techniques, others shined with energetic faces and charming disposition.