The more attractive, more spacious window seats tend to be perpetually reserved for more upscale-appearing clientele, should they chance to appear. Two restaurants in one, both family-oriented, both popular, both good, particularly at dinner time. For breakfast, brunch or lunch, it is Estia, the best spot in town for above average breakfast fare. Calling itself Amagansett Fresh Pasta at dinner time, almost everybody knows it only as Estia. If you rely on anyone helping you locate where Amagansett Fresh Pasta is, and you will probably end up eating at home.
Service is friendly and unassuming.
An excellent choice for everyday dining, and for large parties, it is a treat to the pocketbook. The only down side, admittedly a minor one, is that at dinner time it still looks like a coffee shop. Small family-style Italian restaurant located on the north side of Montauk Highway, just east of Amagansett Square. If you like spicy, try their fra diavolo sauce. Astro's Pizza is now located inside the restaurant, which effectively downgrades both the decor and the food quality considerably.