If you're officially discouraging something it's hypocritical to then put your money into it. But Maureen Child, the council's finance convener, said the situation was complex, particularly because of the clear legal requirement to maximise returns on investment. On cigarette firms, she claimed it was better to have an investment which allowed influence to be brought to bear on the company. The council points out that it makes rigorous checks before committing itself to any investment. One of its stated principles is a commitment to socially responsible companies.
Pressure groups believe the council is fudging the issue, however.
It has recognised that smoking is a serious health issue and is helping its staff to give up through its smoking policy. But, simultaneously, it is investing in an industry that is marketing and promoting an addictive product.