Ifthis is what dispositionality means to you, fine. IF you think that dispositionality means that you can punt the CP mandates, think again. That's when it's no different from Conditionality. I have not voted negative on topicality much this year. Inmy world, topicality is first and foremost about meaning.
Meanings are indeterminate, constructed.
That having been said, in order to win a topicality debate the negative has got to provide an interpretation that has Is defensible in both gramatical and expert terms. Title VII - is hardly persujWve. Limits helps to choose between and among competing interpretations that meet the threshold tests of gramatical accuracy and qualified field support. For example, if legal change re-enforces the public private sphere, making life hell for women, then the fact that women live in a world defined by such a sphere now Is not necessarily damning for the critique. Ifthe case claims only that the legal protections oftheir plan better the plight ofwomen, then the aforementioned critique may well just function as a turn to the case.