These traditions were passed down despite what the non-Indian community thought of them. We were prevented from participating in our traditions for many years, but the traditions were still passed along. They are an essential component of our culture not just an easy way to get fish. Participating in tradition, enhances ones awareness of their identity and pride. David W Oshkosh Menominee Nation, October, 1996.
Many indigenous people find catch and release fishing an illogical course of action.
To them, an animal or fish gives itself to the indigenous person so that the human can live. This action is considered a gift from one species to another. To play with an animal, by hunting it and then letting it go, is considered disrespectful to the animal.