Product does not include a concise information evaluation strategy. Paper does not use APA style for documenting sources. Self-evaluation is not consistent with rationale nor supported by the final product. Meets Expectations Product shows a clear definition of question to be answered. Includes reference to at least five secondary sources Product shows evidence of critical analysis of alternative methods of including critical thinking.
Product includes a concise information evaluation strategy.
Uses APA style for all documentation, including electronic sources. At end of paper includes a self-evaluation based on existing rubric, including a rationale for the evaluation. Deliberately looked for opposing views or different perspectives and have attended to this in the discussion. Product includes an original tool for students to use in evaluating sources. Product includes a script describing a cognitive apprenticeship in which students would follow a teacher through the process of critically evaluating information.