Campbell texts out of storage. I also tell them to review their Chemistry with the chapters on basic chemistry, water and organic chem. For the most part, it's a good indicator. I have been very happy with the text. Although it often goes into more details than necessary, it is thorough and the diagrams are very helpful.
Most students seem to like it.
Also, I have students who separately purchased the Student Study Guide which goes along with the text and they feel it is very helpful. I agree that it goes into too much depth on certain topics but the majority of the students find it valuable. As a supplement I have had students order the Student Class Notes that are available for the text from Addison Wesley. I believe they were written for the 3rd edition. I supplement the information and have them take notes in the margins provided.