Who Did It Problem Discussion Visualization or mathematics are very unlikely to help solving this problem. B and D contradict each other so only one of them can be true. Some people, like those who have a math block, may have a logic block, and resist solving such a problem, having set out that such a problem is to difficult to solve.
Many students experience the same problem solving word problems at school.
They many confuse the information statement with the problem statement, trying to figure out which statement is a true, rather than which person is guilty.