That you and he may or may not have been looking at the same thing is possible, but that does not show that you are right and he is wrong. That is a presumption on your part. So that's where I'm coming from on this particular issue. See my point above. I am surprised you would make such an assertion.
People sense something's wrong.
It's a tough task. You cannot test the Copernican hypothesis that the Sun is the center of the system of planetary orbits without considering how things would look from that point of view. That is instead a misrepresentation of research. You go on to ask where my apology and errata are for this error. I saw what I thought were obvious errors in basic reporting.