With the proper accouterments, they'd probably even taste like the real thing. Never mind the fact that Monkees albums routinely featured session work by the likes of Neil Young, Hendrix drummer Buddy Miles, and Elvis Presley guitarist James Burton. Of course not. IN FACT, it's not even a fatal flaw to be a fabricated studio boy band. That latter band shared vocalist Joey Levine with the 1910 Fruitgum Co., which disbanded in 1970.
Resistance is futile.