Even though the serious plot has tragic consequences, the story line is light, clear, and simple - as in a comic book. Similarly, the background is uncluttered. Bob Crowley's costumes and scenic designs use bold lines and monochromatic bright colors to correlate the story visually. In a visually stunning scene blending old themes with new technology, lighting designer Natasha Katz has the three principals locked in by a giant laser triangle. Third, musical theater pieces with upbeat finales do better at the box office.
Musicals require memorable music and delightful lyrics.
Elton John's tunes and rhythms are low key within the rock genre, far from the melodious arias that most people associate with the original opera this musical is based on. Tim Rice's lyrics seldom call attention to themselves, avoiding clever or complex rhymes. By contrast, all of the voices are strong and interesting. Nearly every one of the featured actors has at least one major song. Casting kept an eye on potential album sales.