A number of Indians were killed. Daniel Boone estimated the number between thirty and forty. This is given as the number by practically all other historians. Joseph Ficklin states that few were left unburied by the retreating enemy. Bryan Station suffered very little in comparison with the enemy.
Several historians give the number of killed as two but give no names.
Durrett give the names of Robert Mitchell and David Adkinson as killed during the fighting. Joseph Ficklin in his letter states that two men were killed in the early part of the siege, and he gives their names as Mr. Mitchell and J. Adkinson. Ranck's History of Lexington, page 109, states that two men were killed in the attack of the foot-men, but gives no names.