I feel the fans are correct in that analysis. If constant criticism is not balanced with careful analysis and balance, is it so unreasonable for people begin to take the criticism's less seriously. I think that is what has happened in Lipper's case. Secondly, is the time and effort spent on the finished product. I think Doughty, you, and Molinaro spend some time on their columns and validly buttressing their opinions.
Ordinary journalists can toss out opinions, create discussion, and sell publications.
Balance, fairness, and effort mean a lot. By the way, I don't always agree with you. But I respect the you and enjoy what you write. I also feel you do a good job of supporting your opinions.