The bishops looked at the current system and how it reflects the Church's teaching. We know that this is not an easy matter. Catholic teaching has developed over time and there have been diverse views on the application of these principles. People are asking whether we can be sure that those who are executed are truly guilty, given the evidence of wrongful convictions and poor representation in death penalty cases. Forgiveness is no longer seen as an option.
Revenge is valued over life.
Lawyers seek closure for their clients. The New York State Catholic Bishops feel differently. In their pastoral statement Restoring All To The Fullness Of Life, the New York State Catholic Bishops looked at restorative justice. Thus, when we assault the dignity or destroy the life of even the most hardened criminal, we assault Christ. Cuddy said that justice can be done while respecting human dignity.