The researcher had discarded 68 percent of the deaths. Even if her selection was scientific and valid, the conclusion was not valid for over two thirds of her subjects. This study, as most studies published in refereed professional journals, shows higher mortality associated with losing weight. The food police have unconsciously encouraged dangerous anorexia and bulimia. They have actually increased obesity because dieting rarely lasts.
Most dieters gain back more than they lose.
The pressure on dieters has created an environment of prejudice and guilt. Shortcuts encouraged by the food manufacturers, weight loss groups, and bariatric physicians cost much time and wealth, yet end up also costing longevity. No doubt Mr. Fumento is well-meaning, but he will not improve our mortality by adding to the pressure. A lifetime of brussel sprouts and low-fat foods may not last longer, but it will seem longer. David Moshinsky I read and greatly enjoyed the review of the books on fat.