Simplifying a design template might not only be better, it might be faster for the designer. Think like readers. The newspaper is designed for them. Readers want surprises but in the form of investigative stories or breaking news or sharp graphics. Not in where standard features are going to be day to day.
Readers are creatures of habit.
When using type in a photo, place it in an appropriate space where it does not obscure meaningful content. Editors need to be catalysts for good design. They should serve as advocates. But they should also empower designers to get involved in the planning process. Implement as many layers of information as possible.