The evaluating is an important part of the process of building a collection, but we needed to talk more about strategies. She seemed willing to show us a wide range of books far beyond her own personal tastes, which is so important. She has a great sense of humor. Atmosphere created by JD that encouraged discussion. Opportunity to see and examine a large gathering of books in the flesh.
More time is needed for reviewing the books.
The instructor and of course the material she presented. The discussion of theoretical context. Leader's ability to engage class members to participate and to do it gracefully. The instructor's lectures and insights. Also her willingness and openness to discuss, consider and reconsider various books.