The Vatican and episcopal critics of the earlier drafts wanted additions that would emphasize the role of the bishops as members of the magisterium. Anything that appeared to put the bishops and theologians on a equal plane was considered suspect. The document stressed that theologians and bishops have different but complimentary roles. In addition, critics wanted it clear that the bishops were not bound by the procedures outlined for resolving disputes. The committee always thought these points were clear, but it accepted numerous amendments which ultimately satisfied its critics.
Part one describes the rights and responsibilities of theologians and bishops in the church.
The Committee on Doctrine is also working on a more extensive statement on the teaching role of bishops. Part two calls for cooperation and informal dialogue between bishops and theologians. It notes that cooperation between theologians and bishops has in fact been good in this country and suggests areas of further collaboration. Part three describes possible procedures for formal dialogue to resolve disputes that might arise in a diocese between a theologian and his or her bishop. The procedures are optional and either the theologian or the bishops can refuse to use them.