Their sparring is believable. The other jurors form a balanced ensemble, each having a say. Kara-Beth Oliver is the forewoman of the jury, trying to maintain order as tempers flair. As the evening wears on, tensions mount and the attacks become personal. Grudges and prejudices surface.
Personal agendas become obvious and eventually, against incredible odds, a decision is made.
The cast members did not miss a beat, continuing on as if all were well.