Detached chad can jam two cards together, increasing misfeeds. In some machines, detached chad can jam over the light or sensor, causing holes to not be read until the chad blows out of the way. Detached chad can migrate from one card to the next. People can not count cards as quickly as a card reader, but a card reader is much more limited than a person in how it can handle and read a card. Any damage a card has sustained can, as we've seen, confuse a card reader or cause it to malfunction.
People are better able to deal with such problems.
It is not possible to manually count the same cards as were voted, because those cards have now had one or more trips through a high-speed card reader. Now, finally, we must move beyond this temperamental antique.