There is a total of 36 tombstones, and four field stones used as grave markers. There are two more pieces of the same type of field stones piled against a tree. There are at least fourteen graves with no markers, and possibly more. The stone with the earliest death date is Joseph Fireline's stone, who died in 1871. The last death date is on Amelia Mackey's stone, with 1946.
Quotation marks is around what is carved on the stone, and parenthesis is around added information.
Everyone buried here is related, either by blood, or through marriage, so they were more than just neighbors and friends. There are two field stones in the row behind Bina Sandefur Wells. Bina's daughter, Lula Sandefur, said that these were the graves of James Coleman and Mary Bottom Sandefur. Their death certificates verifies that they were buried in Mackey Cemetery. They died as they lived Trusting in God.