It was replaced in 1958 by the Feiger Memorial Parish House. It is simple, honest, rectangular rather than cruciform, with lancet windows and a corner tower. The material is native stone in a medium rough textured finish. An interesting feature is that no two corbels are alike. Tinsley's signature, usually found in stone or wood has never been found, perhaps because he was not present during the building.
Old pictures show that the church had two aisles and a curved altar rail.
Sometime after 1890, a central aisle was installed, the sanctuary was made smaller with a straight altar rail, choir stalls were added on each side of the chancel and a small organ was used. The font, hand carved, was given by the Charles R. Pomeroy family, and the carrara marble bowl in the font was brought back from Italy by S. Dana Horton. A large Victorian style home was built behind the church and given to the parish by Judge Philemon Beecher Stanbery in memory of his daughter Cecelia who had died at the Ashville, North Carolina Tubercular Sanatorium on July 31, 1893. The home still serves as the church's rectory. Grace Church during the Flood of 1903.