If yes, then oxidation is still on the surface. Go back to step 1. Try using little or no water to make the product more aggressive. Be sure and use the scrub pad. The color of the gel coat will usually appear on the white pad when all oxidation is gone.
Oxidation is still present on the surface.
Do not dip applicator in pan because it can put too heavy a coating on applicator. Never milky in appearance. It has rained on the coating before it has adequately cured. Usually 2-4 coats are needed to achieve an even shine and 4 more additional coats for durability and protection. Pick a small area and apply more coats.