There is little skill in designing a tight 600-yard three shotter laced at all turns with hazards, and usually there is little joy in playing one. The real trick is to design a long hole that tests the player on every shot, a hole where boldness can directly lead either a four or a seven on the card. The par five in which the green may be reachable with two flawless strokes, and where the penalty for a miscue is severe, is one of the most exciting situations in golf.
Most knowledgeable players are willing to accept such risks if the reward is appreciable.
Most par fives don't place enough value on the second shot. On the average long hole, the second shot is typically an indifferent play for position, or a conservative play away from a hazard. Without temptation and opportunity there can be little excitement, and the best par fives challenge the player to make decisions and think strategically. While the island-green 17th at the Stadium Course, home of The Players Championship, is the most famous hole on North Florida's most famous course, the 11th might be its best. This is a classic example of the strategic hole, interpreted by Pete Dye.