The first 37,917 half eagles struck in 1842 at the Dahlonega Mint were small date, small letters in design. The 1842-D small date, small letter design is by far the most common half eagle of that year. Most examples of this date have a below average strike and surfaces that have significant marks, and are usually found in Very Fine to Extremely Fine condition.
Few examples exist with good eye appeal and they bring a premium when offered.
One PCGS MS67 coin in perfect condition, sold last month 2. Three PCGS MS65's sold at auction in September 3. Coin photograph is from the Duke's Creek Collection.