An Argument Against AP 1. If an act is blameworthy, then it is free. John's act of staying in a locked room was blameworthy. Therefore, John's act was free. LIB is not identical with SD of any sort either.
Libertarians accept, while determinists reject, the idea of agent causation.
Our actions are always caused by desires, beliefs, habits, training, upbringing, etc. 2. The act is free only if it is avoidable. There can be a science of man and human behavior is completely predictable. If every human action has an event cause, then libertarianism is false. Therefore, Libertarianism is false.