I haven't had much luck with salads. I had to send one back because much of the lettuce was brown. But homemade gelato is pretty good. Technically, gelato should be smooth, and Brooklyn's hazelnut is full of little pieces of nuts. It tastes good, if chocolaty.
Ices are lower in fat and are great in the summer months.
There's a small selection of beer behind the cash register. For my money, Brooklyn Pizza Company is the best pizzeria in town.