The plan of the whole composition should be such that each part contributes to an understanding of the writer's main idea or thesis, no part being misleading or unrelated to that thesis. The organization of each paragraph should be directed to the logical and full development of one idea. Correctness of style includes avoiding errors in sentence structure, punctuation, grammar, word usage, and spelling that hinder clear communication. Ranking the Compositions. The judges should discuss the papers contending for rank, and may alter decisions as a result of the discussion.
Judges are to reach a consensus on the rankings.
There can be no ties in this contest. Judges should prepare comments on the Ready Writing Judging Rubric for each entry. Comments should reflect the UIL philosophy on judging. First identify and comment on the positive aspects of the essay. Then offer constructive criticism aimed to help students overcome areas of weakness or error.