At Dr. Alt's meeting, most hunters supported targeting specific areas for thinning or tag limits. The chief was elected to run that department. As such he should be obeyed, and his decisions respected. Although they are volunteers, firefighters do a job that puts their lives on the line, and a habit of ignoring lawful orders when they do not suit can be dangerous. The culprits should take their licks.
Nothing is forever.
I'll bet that if they were contrite and bided their time they could be reinstated later on. If they continue to make an issue of it the chief will just dig in his heels, unless he is overruled somehow, which would be unfortunate for everyone, not just the few at fault. Also, the cavalier disregard of his authority seems to demean the department, making it look as if these people were playing at being firemen instead of having the discipline that is required of people who must act as a unit in dangerous situations. If my house catches fire I would welcome men like the chief to come put it out. The crew he brings with him should be of the same caliber.