Employs only the information provided. May include opinion as well as fact in developing a position. Employs the main points of information from the documents and at least one general idea from personal knowledge to build a position. Uses the main points of information from the documents and personal knowledge that is relevant and consistent in developing a position. Employs all information from the documents and extensive personal knowledge that is factually relevant, accurate and consistent in the development of a position.
Presentation is brief and includes unrelated general statements.
Overall view of problem is not clear. Only minimal organization in presentation. Emphasizes only one issue. Presents a somewhat organized argument. Uses general terms with limited evidence that may not be totally accurate.