Daniel has very little personal experience in web design. Most people give general observations. Most people do not have a conclusion. I think it is split on people rephrasing someone's topic and advancing a topic. Most people include their personal experiences.
Most people react to the web sites that they found on the subject of web design.
Mr. Glover gives good tips on how what to use and what not to use. These tips are useful if you want a home page that is not sucky. See his suckometer. I have to agree and disagree with Mr. Glover on some of his items. While frames can be somewhat irritating, it depends on how they are used.