As a rule, most of this mixed-bag action takes place within an hour of port, sometimes it can be within just a few minutes of Montauk harbor. Porgy and sea bass fishing is the backbone of this mixed-bag game, and it get's started as early as Independence Day. Expect to use eight to ten ounces of lead to hold bottom in and around Montauk, ten to 12 ounces if you head out to Block Island or further offshore. These hooks have a sharp point that penetrates well when porgies, sea bass, ling and blackfish are the primary targets. Better yet, while these hooks have pretty good holding power, they can be straightened out if caught on the bottom, allowing you to save a sinker or two during the course of each trip.
Most regulars use cut skimmer clam and small strips of squid on a year-round basis.
Green crabs are an option if trying to tempt the blacks, but I've always found the clam to score best from a mixed-bag perspective. Choose a long, thin strip of skimmer and hook it once or twice through the toughest section, allowing a trailing end of two inches or so to hang straight down from the hook's hooks bend. When it comes to hooking up, there are a couple of points to keep in mind. When your bait first hits the bottom smaller fish and bergalls will usually rush right over for a nibble. Most days, you'll need to wait out these pests before the bigger fish get a shot at your hook.