On a good note, firefighters were able to save the fellowship hall adjacent to the church. Many records belonging to the church were destroyed from the fire. An effort is currently being made to try to recreate as much of the church's history as possible. The Middletown Christian Church, established in 1872 in the rural community of Middletown, is holding services in conjunction with Engelhard Christian Church. Pastor Scott Sukeforth currently serves both the Middletown and Engelhard Christian Churches.
Plans are already underway to rebuild.