Attendance at other students' seminars. A student missing more than two seminars may have their final grade lowered by one letter grade. For an A 1. Good seminar presentation. For a C 1.
Paper reads well in most places but has some problems.
Seminar presentation may have some problems. References section contains few primary sources, is formatted incorrectly in some places, and contains few references. For a B Somewhere between an A and a C. For a D 1. Poorly written paper with many errors. However, a student can miss one class without penalty.