Very often, no matter which way we decide, some owners will be unhappy. Remember, these decisions are not personal - they are simply matters of opinion. The people who review trades include SportsZone experts who watch hundreds of Major League games a year, either on TV or in person. We also examine stats, both past and present. If we feel a team has a decent chance to improve, we'll OK the trade.
Many owners automatically protest when a 'big name' player is involved.
Don't be beguiled by name recognition. Fantasy value can differ from real value. Sometimes the decisions are very close, and occasionally we'll make a decision that a month later may look silly - we can't worry about that. Our responsibility is to make the most informed decision we can, based on the data available when we review the protest. We will never 're-create' a voided trade.