Public buildings of this sort, where the arts, commerce and architectural style are to be fused, invariably prompt rash judgments. But the polarisation that has accompanied the MCA proposals is lamentable. The dress-circle waterfront site is a vital part of Sydney. The retention of the MCA is integral to both proposals and while demolition is the most favoured course, the Premier, Mr Carr, is known to be against destruction of the 1950s building, built originally for the Maritime Services Board. The controversy surrounding the design has overshadowed the astounding cost blowout associated with redevelopment.
Government authorities seem to under-estimate the real cost of major projects almost routinely.
Cr Sartor has not explained the reasons behind the blowout and how much more the council will be required to pay. He must do both. However, debate on the design should now consider if the museum should remain beside the harbour. Over the years, proposed developments around Circular Quay have generated such fierce argument that politics, personal taste and powerplays have ruled the day. Mistakes have been many.