The offer of Duffy to care for Mom in his home tended to swing the decision his way. To finish the case, a straw poll can be taken in the class as to which of several options is best. Follow-up essays can be assigned where the students must choose an option and defend it. Discussion of brothers' roles by each group. Group report out their views about Mom's condition and how she should be handled.
Groups retire to consider the other brothers' position.
General discussion where a compromise solution is sought. Mom is suddenly brought into the discussion. He thinks long term and is concerned not only about his mother's health but also about her fiscal well-being. He understands the ramifications of long-term care, its financial costs and health benefits. Duffy is aware that there are communities available for the aging and those in poor health that can be financially sound for the entire family.