The problem here may be with the attitude of reefkeepers on the net. You draw your own conclusions. Theil does not divulge the exact composition of his additives. Restaurants don't give out recipes, clothing stores don't give out patterns, and Theil doesn't divulge the composition of his products. Its called economics.
Research costs money which has to be recouped in product revenues.
I don't think we should blame Theil for not giving away his research but instead trying to capitalize on it. There is so little solid research being done in our hobby, the last thing we want to do is steal from the few people that are doing it and run them out of business. This one boils down to religious faith. I personally think actinic lit reefs look best when surrounded by black velvet Jimi Hendrix and Led Zeppelin posters, but again, that's just my personal opinion. That's my .02.