The following should be considered in dealing with writing, whether in preparing critical reviews of required texts or seminar discussion. It is important to state succinctly, in several sentences, the author's thesis. Always use succinct direct quotation to demonstrate your point.
Good writing involves argument and evidence.
Describe the structure and show how the organization relates to the argument. Relate your evaluation to the thesis, purpose, and objectives and make clear what standards or criteria you are using to analyze the argument. Formulate one or two questions that need to be addressed.