I do pornography. State senator Dale Shugars, the resolution's sponsor, is preparing legislation that would establish mandatory concert ratings based on both performance and lyrical content. Shugars is considering providing for civil liability as well so individuals could bring suit to enforce the law. In Virginia, the Richmond City Council was asked to research the legality of rating concerts following a failed effort there to prevent a Marilyn Manson concert. Critics of a ratings system point out that ratings present practical problems as well.
Live performances are to some extent spontaneous.
No two concerts in a tour are likely to be the same. Audience reaction, local issues, and current events often shape what happens during a particular concert. Ratings may discourage spontaneity and creativity, thus chilling artistic freedom. Some major concert attractions, such as Pearl Jam, have indicated that they won't play venues where concerts are rated or minors are not permitted to attend without their parents.