This is completely wrong. On page 300 we give the references which show that 10 per cent was the programme for five years. This double mistake is no accidental slip. You cannot collectivize 20 per cent or 80 per cent at will. But you can try, with the results that we have seen.
Every fact is wrong.
On pages 271-272 we summarise the Platform on agriculture, with a long quotation. The Opposition made it quite clear that collectivization on the basis of industrialization was the only road towards Socialism. The Opposition explicitly condemned the idea of Bucharin and Stalin that voluntary co-operation could bring Socialism. We have quoted Stalin on page 211 laying it down in 1925 that re-equipment of factories and expansion of industrial capital had nothing to do with Socialism. We have shown at length that for four years the Opposition fought this costly Stupidity.