The Witch of Blackbird Pond. A novel written for older children about the time of the Salem Witch Trials. An hour two or three times per week over two weeks. In cooperative groups, allow each group to choose which novel they will read. Each group can decide their reading schedule, finishing the book in two weeks.
Groups have discussions throughout the two weeks.
After finishing the books, groups have a longer discussion and work together to create a project to share with the class. While the transcript is read, A's should find evidence that supports a Guilty verdict and B's Not Guilty. Have them present their ideas convincingly to the opposite side. Then switch which group defends which decision. After, discuss which side was easier to uphold using logic and reasoning that we use today.