This is more like it. Unlike the album cut, this one has that line repeated deep in the mix throughout almost the entire track. Ends with the line repeated several times accompanied by some wierd quitar screech sounds. Sounds like a run down of the parts that contain lyrics and omitted just about everything else. The integrity of the outtakes is definately debatable but I would tend to believe that they are real.
Echoes is a fake.
It's the Meddel version but a bit faster. Shine on You Crazy Diamond is a fake. Here Comes Santa. The 2nd is more like the album version, but a lot rougher sounding. The version of 'Echoes' is very similar to the 'Meddle' version, but perhaps a liitle bit faster.