However, since not every good book receives such an honor, teachers also need to develop the expertise to evaluate books themselves. One strategy is to look at books through the eyes of the experts by applying the selection criteria they use. Along with their annual list of Outstanding Trade Books for Children, NSTA publishes information about the selection process used by their book review panel, which consists of NSTA and Children's Books Council experts. Although the summary supplied here is specific for science books, teachers can apply many of the points to books in other subject areas. The book has substantial science content.
Information is clear, accurate, and up to date.
Theories and facts are clearly distinguished. Facts are not simplified so much that the content is misleading. Generalizations are supported by facts, and significant facts are not omitted. The book is free of gender, ethnic, and socioeconomic bias. Presentation is logical, and sequence of ideas is clear.