It further should not simply repeat those arguments presented by Tolkein or myself, but engage with them and present your own critical view. If anyone tells you there is a magic formula for English papers, don't believe them. The tips outlined above contain implicit criteria for strong papers, but here's a more explicit set of criteria we use in our grading. We look for clear, concise prose. We look for clear and concise introductions and conclusions.
Excellent papers contain few, if any, errors in spelling, grammar and punctuation.
In the case of English 209, the papers will demonstrate mastery of relevant points covered in lecture, but will not simply repeat lecture or class discussion. If you wait until the last minute there may be no time left to conference. And don't forget the resources available at The Writer's Workshop as well. If you plan ahead you can get free tutoring on your paper from a graduate student. Call 333-8796 for information and appts.