This reviewer says 'neither'. This game is a competent one, but it is not at all great. TP just doesn't impress and despite the real player faces plastered on the 3d mugs of the team members' player models, I couldn't care less. At least the commentary isn't lame. A good game feels 'full'.
Graphics suck even when maxed.
This game brings nothing new or exciting and it doesn't heat up the competition with other baseball games in the least. Nice wandering eye buddy. I think Wells is fatter in real life too. I almost mistook this for a DOS game. If you saw these two polygonal, pot-belly wielding dudes in action, you'd understand how bad the model animation and movements are in this game.