We are consciously or unconsciously teaching a child when you whip him that the way to get your way is through violence, and I don't think that is the message we want to send out. There are several alternatives to use of corporal punishment. The evidence against corporal punishment is overwhelming. Studies have proven that corporal punishment, and the fear of corporal punishment, are barriers to learning. Good classroom discipline is necessary for students' learning.
Good discipline is maintained through a climate of order and respect.
Corporal punishment is not necessary to maintain order in schools. Many good alternatives exist, such as the positive school discipline program at Gwinnett County's Knight Elementary School. I was a teacher years ago and paddled one child. It stands out as a vivid memory and to this day I feel guilty about it because I realize that paddling him satisfied my own anger and was not designed to modify his behavior. National PTA has taken a stand opposing corporal punishment and state PTA voted not to abolish corporal punishment.