The truth is that in the question of moral or ethical relationships it matters not. This is a side argument that is used to create shadows and divisions by both sides of the issue. The question is can a homosexual relationship be ethical not whether the individual is born or chooses to be gay. Even this statement is subject to the individual s acceptance of God, and that God is a singular being, as prescribed by either the Jewish, Christian or Islamic faith. Further if the individual believes in this prescribed God it is an act of faith.
Faith requires no logical or rational reasoning.
It allows for the illogical to become logical. It allows for a virgin birth, It allows for the resurrection of Christ. Faith is needed to allow these things to occur. If an individual doesn t have the faith then no amount of logical or rational thought will ever convert the individual resulting in not just part of the religious tenants but all the religious tenants become meaningless. For the religious individual when asking questions about homosexuality and whether it is ethically possible for a gay couple to live together they must search out the answers in their prescribed scriptures.