Well, one day I noticed that the man tending me had webbed toes and of course I remarked on it. But it wasn't until the night above in Main's Pub that I came by the whole story. Kelly then explains that his attendant had webbed toes because he had a selkie in his family line. Both Conneelly and Kelly go on to tell the same story. Each differs only in a few minor details.
Every story has two versions.