It seductively offers the silver bullet against dispensationalism, but it does this at the expense of disemboweling orthodox Christianity. Second, it appeals, I believe, to curious, creative minds for whom theological novelty is especially appealing. Any other theological and dogmatic development, whatever it may be, is not Christian. Others are merely arrogant, setting their own imagination against the entire testimony of the saints for 1700 years. I know of no devotee of this heresy, not one, who is deeply schooled in the history of the church or its theology.
Historians know better.
So, for that matter, do all orthodox Christians. P. Andrew Sandlin is executive vice president of Chalcedon and editor of the Chalcedon Report and other Chalcedon publications. He has written hundreds of scholarly and popular articles and several monographs.