If there is no navigation bar to the left, please click here to go to the main page.
Judgment can be extremely skilled and extremely reliable.
Skilled judgment is something you bet your life on at the hospital, or when you drive within a foot of a car coming the other way at a closing speed of 130mph. You can test someone to see if they have skilled judgment. One reason is that they switch between the three senses of 'subjective'. Suppose someone says that they value loyalty over length of service when promoting staff. If the answer is yes, the person needs to produce evidence for this claim then it can be tested as an objective evaluative claim.