Christian Bookstores have great bookmarks and pencils just to name a few items you could hand out IF you choose to leave your lights on. You can have a family meeting and make the plans for the special evening. Maybe even have a Board Game Marathon. Give each member of the family a special responsibility. Each one of you can do something to plan, prepare and take part in, for your special evening.
Family times are too often rare or non existent.
Bake some cookies and make some popcorn the old fashioned way. Next year you can have the 2nd Annual Family Fun Night. Have a celebration with a theme. How about a Bible Quiz or charades game. Or bring out the Bible Board games like a Bible Trivia game.