I think you're doing, but I'm not sure what it is exactly. You should have a case study detailed on the site, or at least an example that represents a wide range of the kinds of things you'd be able to source and some cost comparisons in very simple, one-sentence terms. It is very 1992, and especially these days, a business that doesn't feel very current, professional, doesn't feel solid. Font is too big and should have been proofread for typos and irregularities in size.
Drop shadows are also very outdated.
Too much wasted space and scolling. Feels like the navigation of a bad porn site. Almost nothing about yours instills any confidence. Sorry, you said be brutally honest. That can be done cheaply.