However to only look at these areas, does an injustice to each team members resourcefulness, determination, and commitment to the rescue task. As the scenario is dynamic and in constant motion, a judge is required to monitor a million items at once. I feel the scenario plus the critique makes up the total exercise for the team. As for the Captains being more experienced than the judges, and are in most competitions, I strongly disagree with these. You as competitiors are the final say on judges.
Good ones become known.
All of us are valuable to the goal and that goal is serving the patient. We as judges have 13 categories in which we are asked to evaluate from 1 to 10 in value, for a total of 130 points. Here's my method. I make notes though out the scenario as to benchmarks. I use these to look at say, efficiency, such as speed in relation to task.