Listeners gain insights. Speaker demonstrates good understanding of concepts and theories. Some helpful applications are included. Reference to theory is superficial. Little attempt is made to tie theory to practice.
Listeners gain little from the presentation.
No reference is made to literature or theory. Listeners gain no new insights. No significant errors are made. Listeners recognize any errors to be the result of nervousness or oversight. Enough errors are made to distract a knowledgeable listener, but some information is accurate.