Damnation awaits them. Even this is under the absolute control of God according to Peter. You must worship Him sincerely or be destroyed. There is no neutral ground. At the heart of Christianity is the call to cease worshiping and serving the creation, and to ascribe all of the glory of the creation to the Creator.
Fans cheer for two reasons.
They cheer for what might be, and for what has just happened. Or cheer as the pitcher gets ready to deliver what they hope will be strike three. They cheer again if it is strike three. We celebrate both in salvation. This is why the Word and the Sacrament are so important to worship.