The effort involved is large, but the promotion and tenure decisions have a critical impact on the future of the department. Candidates are encouraged to show evidence in addition to the computer-processed student assessments. However, the value of this evidence is compromised unless it is obtained in a method which demonstrates impartiality. Extensive documentation should be included in a separately bound appendix. However, it should be recognized that there are certain indicators that point to good teaching.
Good teachers receive public recognition in a variety of ways.
Students, both individually and through organizations, seek them out more often. They make more innovative contributions in courses, sometimes whole curricula. Their students demonstrate achievement in learning. They often serve on more student committees and carry heavier advising loads. In short they are known for their enthusiasm and involvement in the educational process of students.