Well, upstate New York was once a part of Massachusetts. This was before the Phelps and Gorham Purchase of 1791 that preceded settlement in the Genesee Valley. By all indications, that was probably the game Weed and Adams played. The Massachusetts game was played in nearby Geneva, New York, well into the 1850's. By that time, Rochester was playing the New York game.
Historians disagree to which was the first organized club.
I know more supporting evidence is there somewhere and it will reveal that adult men regularly played organized club baseball on Mumford's lot. He plays for the Deep River Grinders. It just shows what lengths collectors will go to. Shemonsky, of Clarks Summit, Pa., said the false teeth, which were once owned by well-known baseball memorabilia collector Barry Halper, will be part of a new museum exhibition displaying 150 items from Halper's collection. While the dentures could not be part of the baseball museum's exhibit on Cobb because the teeth had nothing to do with baseball, Spencer said they were sure to be noticed by the thousands of visitors expected this summer.