Hope this is enough of a comment. Well, we have been over this question many, many times. Unfortunately, we have not yet answered the question. I think so, because I have seen good writing in my lifetime. Good writing does not come in a package with directions.
Good writing involves creativity, ideas, thought and a whole lot more.
I cannot say exactly what, because I do not know. If I did know, believe me my grades would be higher. When a teacher says what they want, students generally dish out and think nothing more of the assignment. That is what the teacher is demanding. All he is looking for is the straight answer.