The audience is clear and the material seems to address audience needs or expectations. The site has design consistency throughout. The site makes clear choices and distinctions for the reader and does not merely link to information. It does not merely reproduce information on the web but at least begins to add to it and digest it, making a useful addition to knowledge or a helpful organization of knowledge on the web. It is a useful site and a worthwhile project.
Information seems well researched and authoritative.
The site links to very useful web resources in the field or the resources that the audience would appreciate. Significant resources are not overlooked. The material may repeat information already available on the web in some form, or else it quotes large passages from other sites without adding any useful information. The site is not considerate enough of audience concerns. Pages lack distinguishing titles.