The CDB claim that docking cannot be described as a mutilation. This emotive term is completely without foundation and is used by singularly ill-informed sources. When docking is carried out proficiently on whelps aged 2-7 days, there is a minimal amount of momentary discomfort and the puppies can immediately resume sucking on the dam with no sign of distress to either dam or whelp. Dr. R. Fritsch explains why tail docking in very young pups is not painful .
Docking is carried out to protect the future welfare of the whelp.
Balance and communication is not affected by docking as explained in a letter from Prof. Q. Latham Ph D . To stop the docking of whelps on this understanding, is a somewhat cynical view which does not address the phantom limb problem that can occur. Additionally there is a considerable risk in anaesthesia. The repair of chronic tail injuries are often protracted, difficult and traumatic for both dog and owner. The RCVS does not differentiate between working dogs, show dogs or companion pets.