Modesty standards and nudity taboos are a well established part of the exercise of Islam, and many other religions. However, evidence of previous problems with contraband entering the prison through visits supports, and indeed requires, the finding that there is a rational connection between the regulation and the government's legitimate justification, security and integrity of the prison environment. Constrained resources make it necessary to have many inmates present in the room at one time, and no less costly alternative has been proposed. Accordingly, I find that the strip searches do not violate the First Amendment. Equal Protection Lastly, plaintiffs argue that the prison rule, requiring outside religious leaders to conduct services, discriminates against religious groups because civic organizations may continue to pick their leaders from within the prison population.
Defendants here argue that the issue has become moot.
Since October 1995, inmate civic groups are no longer permitted to hold meetings at SCI-Graterford. In the event that meetings are permitted again, they will be held only under the direct leadership of prison staff. Plaintiffs have not come forward with any evidence to dispute that the groups are now treated equally. Thus, summary judgment for defendants is granted. An order follows.