Reality is simply ignored as irrelevant. In order to untangle this intellectual maze, a full analysis and application of Metaphysics, Epistemology, and Logic must be done. Since there is an unlimited series of such arguments, a thousand lifetimes will be insufficient to untangle all of them. It is not even necessary to untangle one of them. Such arguments are Arbitrary and can be dismissed immediately upon the identification that they are Arbitrary.
Evidence is a fact of reality.
Evidence must be an existent. Evidence must be demonstrable. Evidence must be presentable. If it is not all of these, it is NOT Evidence. True means non-contradictory correspondence to that which exists.