In complex cases, etc, there can always be differing views of right and wrong. The RRCA does not make rules, but operates with guidelines that the clubs can take as their rules. We have found that this works well for the RRCA and its member clubs. The local club board should be the body discussing the appeal. That's the way the administrative process should work.
Controversial calls happen and that's part of all sports, and they survive.
The RRCA executive board will take an extensive long-term look at this issue and others from a national perspective.