The means by which we make this choice is exactly the message of the Bible . I am going to propose something which seems to support that atheists' arguments regarding evil. I agree that there is a lot of evil in the world. In fact, I think that there is too much evil in the world to be explained by naturalistic processes. The fact is that there is too much evil in the world to be explained by chaos theory or the laws of physics.
Evolution provides no answers to explain the vast amount of evil done by mankind.
None of the other creatures on our planet have the capacity for evil that mankind does. No other mammals kill arbitrarily. They only kill to eat and survive - but not mankind. Just watch the nightly news or read your newspaper. The Bible says that the presence of evil is due to the spiritual component of our nature - something that animals do not possess.