Folks fish here in the summer for scup and fluke as well. Menemsha is one of the best places to find bonito and false albacore in the late summer and fall. For false albacore try the same lures. The fly rod can be especially effective here when the fish are close. Be sure all your equipment is in good working order - rods and reels must be in tip top shape to land these speedsters from shore.
Incoming water brings bonito and 'albacore right between the jetties, especially at first light.
Outgoing water puts fish on the outside, but feeding well on the bait that gets swept out of the inlet. The boat ramp on the Lobsterville side is a good place to launch a boat out of Menemsha to go fishing at any time. Night fishermen should take a look around the docks in the harbor late in the evenings. Squid, mackerel, sand eels, silversides, feeding stripers, cunners, crabs, and a whole host of other critters make this harbor a virtual saltwater stew. Just watching the action is great fun, and clever flyrodders can pick up stripers by dead-drifting small clousers to feeding fish.