We want the description of all photos to be as accurate as possible in the Historic Photo Collection. While we certainly do not want incorrect information to be perpetuated, we cannot change information without some sort of research to support the change. Some may have an inclination toward one view or another, but we must avoid letting preconceived ideas cloud our judgment. It is important to keep an open mind when investigating such issues and to let the research guide us to the answers. My hope is that someone with historical curiosity and some time to spend in the courthouse records would try to solve this puzzle.
History is a little like science in that supporting evidence is sought to answer questions.
Just because the proof cannot be found in a historical search does not mean that the hypothesis is false. Sometimes the supporting evidence eludes the searcher, or simply has not survived the years. I hope this particular quest is one in which a definitive answer can be found. If you can shed any light on this subject, please contact Jamie Murray in the Museum Library.