Yes you would. You stated today that the world was designless and purposeless, the product of chances unrelated to guidance by any supernatural personality. Thus beyond what can be established by science there is no meaning. Indeed it's more scientifically significant that the fridge obeyed the laws of physics when it fell and squished Mr. Heinzfergen, than whether his squishing was just or not. The court requires a recess to consider this new evidence.
Defendant gets up to leave .
It's only by chance that I get up and leave this court room. Deliberately bumps into prosecutor . Oh sorry, it was an accident.