The problem is that the CME classes can be on any topic and some of the courses are pretty easy. Some doctors will fly to Hawaii, just sign in for classes and then just play on the beach, still getting full credit. Some credits can get obtained by taking tests online, by mailing in forms and attending lectures designed to give CME credit. Still, the AMA award is some guarantee that your doctor is actively trying to learn. Ask a doctor who he'd use .
Doctors often know who are the best-qualified colleagues in their field.
For instance, I asked a general surgeon friend who was not on my list of preferred providers who he would go to on the list of eligible general surgeons. Since my friend had daily, personal experience with some of the surgeons, he was well-qualified to make a recommendation. A potential pitfall- make sure the doctor is being objective and not just referring you to his friend. On the bright side, had this doctor not done such a poor job on me, I might not have written The Arthritis Cure . Often more important than training is if your doctor listens to you and connects with your personality.