In general I prefer an answer that has depth rather than breadth. For example, if you have any criticisms of the research I would prefer that you NOT list all of the criticisms. Instead please state one or two criticisms and describe what you would do to fix the problem. If you choose to answer the second portion of the question I prefer responses which are very personal and concrete or specific. The more personal and specific you can make your response the more likely it is you will receive higher points.
Every student is assigned to a group that presents an article.
This is a group project, but most of the grade comes from your individual presentation. See the included page on how the presentations are graded. I will provide the article to the group. What problem was studied and why the experimenters did the research. How the researchers conducted the test of their hypothesis.