Full coverage of the topic. Copy is publishable with minor editing and revisions. Good use of sources. Portions of copy probably need to be rewritten and closely edited before story can be published. Sources used but not sufficiently or effectively.
Copy contains major factual, structural, writing and usage flaws.
It is doubtful whether it could be published. Copy fails to meet even minimum standards for the assignment. The student should provide evidence in her responses indicating understanding of the content and context of reading assignments. The student is required to maintain a hard and disk copy of the assignments she has turned in. Once stories are published or assignments returned, the student should keep a tear sheet or retain the graded assignment to develop a portfolio of writing for future use.