Your unclear thought comes from the difficulties of dealing with your personal religious background, your early religious training. Most people talk like fools, so you must cultivate to art of writing as you DON'T talk. This is basic. As a replacement for the above, write as you think the professor would like to hear you talk. Great ideas are the sure road to academic failure.
College is a battle.
The professor has the grade, you've got to get is away from him, and this can be done only by little ideas, things which will appeal to his kind of mind. When you write a paper, you are really writing the paper which is already imprinted in the professor mind. If it is a near match, you get an A, and so forth. College is a game which is played only by people who are still in the running . Your work may be uninspired, it may have little meaning to you as a person.