This is confusing to a child. Consequences may be adjusted to fit the individual. What works for most may not work for all. Kids need to know where the line is located. They want it black and white.
Children have difficulty understanding grey areas.
Not really, they have been informed that you are not pleased with their actions, and they now know exactly what will happen to them if it is repeated. This is a learning experience for both parent and child. Parents who treat their children in a fair and a consistent manner will be respected. Allow your child to suggest consequences. Kids believe it will be easy for them to behave in the future.