It gets a 4 from me. Overall the game is pretty good. I enjoy playing it when it works, but there are some problems with the game that EA needs to figure out. Gameplay is the best part of the game. The CPU usually picks up on your gameplay near the 3rd quarter making it more difficult to score in the 4th.
Big problems come into affect when rosters come into play.
I couldnt change thier roster so this totally blew. Graphics are ok, except the players are too blocky. The tackles look real but the touchdown celebrations still need some work. Pat Summerall is just not that good as a commentator. The crowd never seems to get to loud even when the visiting team is in the red zone.