Trace elements in Human and Animal Nutrition. Academic Press, 1977. If you had ever done research or written it up, you would know that almost every set of data leaves possible several, and often contradictory, interpretations. At the time Colgan wrote that book, his employer did not sell VS, and he had a decidedly negative view toward this. Whether this has changed since they began to sell VS, I am uncertain.
Creatine is the best thing since sliced bread.
The effects of the reviewer's biases must be considered. You, as a reporter, reading only his reviews and not the articles themselves, then lack credibility. But, either way, you will have done the work expected of a reporter doing a literature review. The manner is which you did it previously, in an academic sense, would have bordered on unethical. I would fail a student in one of my classes for writing a paper citing references that he had not read, but was pulling from another source and accepting that source's interpretation.