No, I don't want to debate it. I'm just refocusing my site on what I want it to be about, and who it's for. I'm doing this because I feel I need to. Because that's what I plan to do. Finally, I'd like to leave you with something to think about.
Any answer is the right answer, of course.
It's up to every site creator to decide for themselves. But if you've never thought about it, you should. The answer may surprise you. That means I've had the domain for four years now. This, by necessity, involves limiting access to content before payment is delivered.