Every claim must be substantiated through detailed arguments. In general, minor revisions are checked by the associate editor in charge of the paper whereas major revisions are re-reviewed by the original reviewers. In both cases the authors are asked to prepare a cover letter detailing how they addressed the various reviewers' concerns. An anonymous copy of your review will be emailed to the authors. Anonymous copies of all reviews will also be emailed to all reviewers together with information about the decision taken by the Editorial Board.
All manuscripts are to be treated confidentially.
Please do not distribute or reference a manuscript under consideration without an author's permission. Reviewers' names are not disclosed to authors, so contacting an author can only be done at your discretion. Publishing a high-quality research journal requires a tremendous commitment by the reviewers who give of their time and knowledge.