Council High Educated laypeople Low Simple, obvious precedent set by other council-appointed boards. Elections High Self-selected educated lay people High.
Big picture includes both costs of holding the election and money going to campaigns.
Appearance of public approval for winners. Would require separate charter amendment which could not occur until May 2002. Also, APA would control elections over time. Expert staff ensures consistency. Model's success relies heavily on the competence of the Auditor's staff.