One-third failed the English component, and almost half failed math. Understandably, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts isn't thrilled at the prospect of denying diplomas to half the kids in the state. Predictably, the high failure rate has fueled criticism that the exams are too hard. Maybe they are. But rather than examine the test itself, Poor Elijah suggested that we review a few reactions and remedies officials are considering.
Critics point out correctly that even lawyers get more than one shot at the bar exam.
Actually, officials have proposed that they get five chances, which again isn't all that different from the bar exam. In other words, you have to pass the test in order to graduate. Unless, of course, you don't pass the test, in which case you get to pass an easier test. Not surprisingly, MCAS failure rates are even higher among special education students. That way a high school diploma could represent the attainment of a meaningful minimum standard, but the achievement of kids with special learning problems could still be recognized.