Content is the most critical criterion.
Attractive presentation - Pretty, clever, colorful or surprising pages. Although content is most important, winning Web sites must be presented in such an appealing way that Web surfers will be attracted to the excellent content. While anyone can make a typo, there certainly must be content accuracy. Useful links to relevant resources - Helping us find other good resources. Winning pages are likely to be bookmarked by Web utilizing genealogists as good starting points in research projects.