The proposed expansion will most likely have a detrimental impact on the habitat. Ocean resources are vital for a healthy environment. These resources also play a significant role in Hawaiian culture, traditions and customs. Take suggests the possibility that what has been taken may be returned. Conversely, when considering negative impacts on threatened and endangered species, any loss, whether intentional or not, represents a significant decline in the population.
Area is classified as ag and conservation land.
The document provides a sustainable yield for Mana Shaft, but fails to indicate the expected amount of increased water consumption. What is the current and expected uses of water. According to the Preparation Notice, water on Ni'ihau is stored in ponds. Potable water is also a scarce resource on Ni'ihau. The impact from the proposed expansion on Ni'ihau's scarce water sources, highly susceptible to contamination, must be given serious consideration.