Please submit your reviews as email messages, identifying the paper by its title and ID number. If you wish to make annotations on the printed copy of the manuscript, turn in this copy to the teaching staff and we will pass it along to the author. There is no specific length requirement for the reviews. We expect most reviews will be about one page. The actual identity of authors and reviewers will remain unknown to one another.
Anonymity often makes it easier for people to give their candid opinions about a paper.
Of course, anonymity should not be used as a cover for hostile or personal comments. We ask everyone to strive for fair and objective review. A sentence or two should be sufficient. If the paper is murky and hard to follow, be sure to let the author know. Conclude with a brief summary of your overall reaction to the paper.