Click on the example to ftp a PostScript rendering of the example to your local disk. The image source book is called The Eclectic Organ Teacher, an Analytical and Synthetical Method for students desirous of becoming familiar with the Cabinet or Reed Organ, and music associated therewith, by James G. Barnett, published in 1883 by the Oliver Ditson Company, Boston. Also, half note and whole note noteheads are the same. Accents and tenutos are thicker, dots are much larger, and dynamics are smaller. The thick parts of time signature numbers are thicker, and the thin parts thinner.
Accidentals are smaller, and the double sharp is very odd, as is the dal segno sign.
The engraver frequently let accidentals run into leger lines, and allowed leger lines on consecutive notes to run together. It was red. If you wish, you can substitute the upper-case R to use this quarter rest. For more of a 19th century look, you can use Monotype Bulmer and Bulmer Italic for text and Adobe's Clarendon or Clarendon Light, or Monotype's Egyptian for titles. To use the Barnett font, switch Finale's Default Music Font to Barnett and load the supplied Barnett Settings Library, supplied with the font.