He went so far as to say that evidentialists, such as I, leave no room for the ministry of the Holy Spirit, deny the grace of God, and promote legalism. If this were just an isolated incident, I would not bother to mention it. My heart yearns to see people who emphasize either the propositions or the evidences appreciating the value of each approach and working together instead of against each other. Good presuppositional apologetics can be especially effective in telling us what is not true. Good evidential apologetics can be especially effective in telling us what is true.
Different people have different barriers to faith.
I believe we should be more concerned with guiding people around their barriers than with defending our favorite appeals. Perhaps the superiority struggle arises from differences in training and in personalities. At academic meetings I have noticed that lawyers and scientists communicate easily with one another, and so do philosophers and theologians. But I can see sharp tensions when scientists and theologians get together. More opportunities for dialogue, for working through differences and animosities, must be provided.