The author's response addresses the question, but leaves some loose ends. Explanations may require further development or additional backing from the literature. The author begs the question, omits key points, errs in fundamental ways, or demonstrates little familiarity with the literature. Argumentation Arguments supporting the author's assertions are logically sound. They are convincing.
Arguments supporting the author's assertions are erroneous or grossly insufficient.
A Look at its Students, Programs, and Prospects. Please check the unit web pages. I will of course keep you posted well in advance.