The rule to argue a logical analysis proposal is to state the reason why the proposal does not make sense. For example the police detective has caught a left handed suspect of a murder case while the stab wound of the victim is from a right handed person. In our present case the way for one to argue would be pointing out that photons do not have such a strange behavior. Stating that photons do not have such a strange behavior in our present laws of physics is not an augement in logical analysis methodology. It is possible to train oneself with logical analysis skills and then apply these skills to one's own research environment.
Consultation is available.