The problem of where to draw the line is a recurrent one in moral decisions. Sometimes people argue that the only coherent position is an extreme one just so that this problem can be avoided. In the debate over the moral permissibility of abortion, Noonan and Tooley represent the extreme positions. Discuss whether or not their positions are coherent, and if they are the only coherent positions regarding the status of the fetus, drawing on other readings and lectures as needed. Be sure to articulate what you take to be the most coherent position and why.
Abortion is impermissible except where the fetus has a birth defect.
Maximum length should be 6 pp., double spaced. Feel free to consult with your TA or Professor Comisso in the course of working out your arguments. And you re welcome to discuss the questions on the Virtual Section as well as you can see, the debate is well under way there.