From what you describe, the products you are currently using aren't effective. When you wash excessively with soap, your skin will dehydrate after each wash. You will find your skin getting coarser. As such, the manufacturer should never claim that they are non-comedogenic. To claim that a product is non-comedogenic is to say that the product contains ingredients that will not contribute to the building up of comedones.
Comedones is a medical term for blackheads.
And all the pigments, oxides and talc are powdery grains which do contribute to pore-cloggs. Unless you have a good and effective cleanser and a good skincare routine, I'd advise that you stop using makeup for one to two weeks. If you are willing to accept my advice, I would prefer that you stop all others and use the samples I will send you. It will comprise 4 to 5 items. I am confident you will see quick positive results, like many others have testified to us.