Assignments are due on the date they are described.
As a class, you agreed on two texts, one for the top half and one for the bottom half. Therefore, I m asking you to nominate three papers out of that group of twelve that you feel belong in the top half. Look at that group of twelve papers as a group. For each of the three papers that you nominate, prepare a two-column list of strengths and weaknesses. Your list should include not only the reason but the location of the places in the texts where that strength or weaknesses is evident.