In bringing this lawsuit, Beverly caused widespread concern, confusion, and outrage in the academic and labor communities. Within a space of five days over 500 people from all over the world joined in a statement attacking Beverly's actions. Those of us who lent our names to this statement did so because we believe lawsuits such as this threaten academic freedom and the role of scholarship in helping to formulate sound public policy. It is difficult, indeed almost impossible, to believe that Beverly brought this lawsuit to obtain monetary compensation from Dr. Bronfenbrenner for the pecuniary injury caused by her statement. We believe that Beverly's only reason for suing could have been to punish Dr. Bronfenbrenner and to serve as a warning to others who might consider scholarship or public statements critical of Beverly's approach to labor law.
Any lawsuit causes hardship for the defendant, even when the defendant ultimately prevails.
The impact of a lawsuit by a well-resourced corporation against an individual, as has occurred here, can be particularly damaging. Beverly has money, lawyers, and public relations staff. Dr. Bronfenbrenner does not. Beyond this, there are special issues that should concern congress. The Role Academics Play in the Legislative Process Congress cannot function properly without a steady supply of research and information.